NorMistral-7b-scratch

NorMistral-7b-scratch is a large Norwegian language model pretrained from scratch on a total of 260 billion subword tokens (using six repetitions of open Norwegian texts).

This model is a part of the NORA.LLM family developed in collaboration between the Language Technology Group at the University of Oslo, the High Performance Language Technologies (HPLT) project, the National Library of Norway, and the University of Turku. All the models are pre-trained on the same dataset and with the same tokenizer. NorMistral-7b-scratch has over 7 billion parameters and is based on the Mistral architecture.

The NORA.LLM language model family includes (as of now):

NorMistral-7b-warm -- an LLM initialized from Mistral-7b-v0.1 and continuously pretrained on Norwegian data;
NorMistral-7b-scratch -- a Mistral-based LLM pretrained from scratch on Norwegian data;
NorBLOOM-7b-scratch -- a BLOOM-based LLM pretrained from scratch on Norwegian data.

Disclaimer: This model is pretrained on raw (mostly web-based) textual data. It is not finetuned to follow instructions, and it can generate harmful completions after inappropriate user prompts. It is primarily intended for research purposes.

Pretraining corpus

The model is pretrained exclusively on publicly available data. We combine the resources from the public part of the NCC corpus, from the cleaned HPLT corpus, and from CulturaX. This resulted in over 34B subword tokens of Norwegian (Bokmål or Nynorsk) in total, which amounts to about 26.7B whitespace-separated tokens. We also augment the corpus with Starcoder; 20% of the 260B tokens are sampled from this code corpus. The natural language data is repeated six times to get the pretraining budget of 260B tokens, in accordance with findings from Muennighoff et al. (2023).

Model details

Model Developers: Language Technology Group at the University of Oslo.

Variations: NorMistral is currently published as two 7B variants: one trained entirely from scratch and one warm-started from the Mistral model.

Input: Textual input.

Output: Generated text.

Model Architecture: NorMistral is an auto-regressive language model that uses an optimized transformer architecture based on the Mistral/Llama language models.

	Training Data	Params	Context Length	Tokens	LR
NorMistral-7b-warm	NCC+HPLT+CulturaX+Starcoder	7B	2k	260B	1.0 x 10^-4
NorMistral-7b-scratch	NCC+HPLT+CulturaX+Starcoder	7B	2k	260B	3.0 x 10^-4
NorBLOOM-7b-scratch	NCC+HPLT+CulturaX+Starcoder	7B	2k	260B	1.2 x 10^-4

Tokenizer: Byte-based BPE tokenizer trained on the same Norwegian corpus as this model. The vocabulary size is 32,768 tokens.

Training FLOPs The approximate amount is 1.22e+22 FLOPs; calculated as in Chowdhery et al. (2022).

Model Dates: The models were pretrained between December 2023 and January 2024.

Status: These are only pretrained language models; instruction-finetuned models will follow soon.

License: Apache-2.0

Research Paper: Forthcoming

Initial evaluation

Disclaimer: our model evaluation is an ongoing phase and is not claimed to be exhaustive. We provide our initial evaluation results on standard natural language understanding and generation tasks, and our evaluation design will be extended. The user should perform evaluation for their particular model application scenario, including safety and bias evaluations.

The perplexity on the heldout validation set from the Norwegian Colossal Corpus (NCC) is 7.43 and the final training perplexity is 4.76.

Our initial downstream evaluation is conducted on reading comprehension, sentiment analysis and machine translation tasks using open-source peer-reviewed datasets and benchmarks in native Norwegian. We release our codebase here. We compare against other pretrained generative language models that officially support Norwegian: NB-GPT-J, GPT-Sw3 6.7B, GPT-Sw3 6.7B v2, and Falcon-7B; we also include evaluation of Mistral-7b-v0.1.

Sentiment analysis

NoReC (Øvrelid et al., 2020) is a dataset for sentence-level sentiment analysis derived from the Norwegian Review Corpus (Velldal et al., 2018). We use the binary formulation of this task (positive vs. negative).

Method (click to expand)

Evaluation setting: zero-shot and few-shot perplexity-based evaluation.
Prompt: "Tekst: {text}\nSentiment:{label}", where the label is either "positiv" or "negativ".
Few-shot results show the average scores across 5 repetitions
Evaluation script: https://github.com/ltgoslo/norallm/blob/main/initial_evaluation/sentiment_analysis.py
Performance metric: macro-averaged F1-score.

Macro-averaged F1-scores on the sentence-level sentiment analysis task (NoReC)

Model	0-shot (macro F1)	1-shot (macro F1)	16-shot (macro F1)
NorMistral-7b-warm	60.6	77.8	87.3
NorMistral-7b-scratch	47.3	62.2	80.1
NorBLOOM-7b	75.7	73.8	65.5
NB-GPT-J	48.4	56.5	65.2
GPT-Sw3-6.7B	61.5	72.2	76.5
GPT-Sw3-6.7B-v2	42.4	69.1	83.4
Falcon-7B	53.3	61.6	74.9
Mistral-7B-v0.1	70.2	72.9	84.8

Reading comprehension

NorQuAD (Ivanova et al., 2023) is a dataset for extractive question answering in Norwegian designed similarly to SQuAD (Rajpurkar et al., 2016).

Method (click to expand)

Evaluation setting: zero-shot and few-shot settings via natural language generation using the greedy decoding strategy.
Prompt: "Tittel: {title}\n\nTekst: {text}\n\nSpørsmål: {question}\n\nSvar:{answer}" Based on Brown et al. (2020).
Few-shot results show the average scores across 5 repetitions
Evaluation script: https://github.com/ltgoslo/norallm/blob/main/initial_evaluation/norquad.py
Performance metrics: macro-averaged F1-score and exact match (EM).

Performance results on the extractive question answering task (NorQuAD)

Model	0-shot (F1/EM)	1-shot (F1/EM)	2-shot (F1/EM)
NorMistral-7b-warm	48.6/24.8	63.6/40.0	66.5/43.8
NorMistral-7b-scratch	34.0/15.7	46.5/25.8	48.5/27.8
NorBLOOM-7b	35.0/13.3	47.7/28.0	49.3/30.1
NB-GPT-J	24.4/6.8	32.8/11.6	35.0/12.3
GPT-Sw3-6.7B	46.5/22.0	55.9/32.0	58.1/34.3
GPT-Sw3-6.7B-v2	46.9/22.5	61.1/38.9	66.0/44.5
Falcon-7B	15.8/7.0	27.3/13.9	27.4/13.1
Mistral-7B-v0.1	46.4/22.4	64.9/41.1	71.7/49.4

Grammatical error correction

ASK-RAW is dataset for Norwegian grammatical error correction (GEC) created by Matias Jentoft (2023).

Method (click to expand)

Evaluation setting: zero-shot and few-shot settings via natural language generation using the greedy decoding strategy.
Prompt: "Her er eksempler på perfekt korrigering av grammatiske feil:\n\nTekst: {source_text}\nKorreksjon:{target_text}"
Few-shot results show the average scores across 5 repetitions
Evaluation script: https://github.com/ltgoslo/norallm/blob/main/initial_evaluation/gec.py
Performance metrics: the evaluation metric uses ERRANT, which identifies edit-spans and then calculates the F_{0.5} scores between the gold edits and predicted edits.

Results on [the ASK corpus](https://huggingface.co/datasets/ltg/ask-gec) (ERRANT F_{0.5})

Model	0-shot (F0.5)	1-shot (F0.5)	32-shot (F0.5)
NorMistral-7b-warm	40.8	41.8	48.5
NorMistral-7b-scratch	22.1	28.8	42.1
NorBLOOM-7b	8.7	24.5	32.0
NB-GPT-J	9.1	28.2	30.6
GPT-Sw3-6.7B	30.5	42.9	50.6
GPT-Sw3-6.7B-v2	40.6	43.4	49.8
Falcon-7B	10.8	12.4	15.5
Mistral-7B-v0.1	26.0	27.4	30.6

Machine translation

Tatoeba (Tiedemann, 2020) is a benchmark for machine translation, which includes hundreds of language pairs. We consider six language pairs (English <-> Bokmål, English <-> Nynorsk, and Bokmål <-> Nynorsk).

Method (click to expand)

Evaluation setting: zero-shot and few-shot settings via natural language generation using the greedy decoding strategy.
Prompt: "{source_language}: {source_text}\n{target_language}:{target_text}", where the source_language and target_language are Engelsk, Bokmål, or Nynorsk. Based on Garcia et al. (2023).
Few-shot results show the average scores across 5 repetitions
Evaluation script: https://github.com/ltgoslo/norallm/blob/main/initial_evaluation/machine_translation.py
Performance metrics: BLEU (Papineni et al., 2002) and chrF++ (Popović, 2015).

English → Norwegian Bokmål

Model	0-shot (BLEU/chrF++)	1-shot (BLEU/chrF++)	5-shot (BLEU/chrF++)
NorMistral-7b-warm	55.8/70.7	56.7/71.5	57.7/72.4
NorMistral-7b-scratch	46.4/62.9	50.4/66.3	52.1/67.6
NorBLOOM-7b	37.1/53.6	50.1/65.8	52.0/67.6
NB-GPT-J	8.6/39.1	35.9/64.5	47.2/68.7
GPT-Sw3-6.7B	21.8/55.2	54.5/69.6	58.6/73.2
GPT-Sw3-6.7B-v2	20.6/53.2	51.2/66.6	58.4/73.0
Falcon-7B	19.1/40.1	20.6/41.8	22.1/43.6
Mistral-7B-v0.1	32.5/51.9	35.4/55.1	36.3/56.0

English → Norwegian Nynorsk

Model	0-shot (BLEU/chrF++)	1-shot (BLEU/chrF++)	5-shot (BLEU/chrF++)
NorMistral-7b-warm	43.6/62.0	44.2/63.2	44.3/63.7
NorMistral-7b-scratch	38.0/56.9	39.2/57.9	40.7/59.3
NorBLOOM-7b	35.6/54.7	36.6/56.3	38.1/57.4
NB-GPT-J	1.7/14.7	6.3/34.1	35.2/60.4
GPT-Sw3-6.7B	13.4/44.3	43.6/62.5	44.5/63.5
GPT-Sw3-6.7B-v2	14.8/45.5	43.7/62.3	44.0/63.6
Falcon-7B	6.4/28.6	8.3/30.5	9.3/32.1
Mistral-7B-v0.1	11.6/35.7	13.5/38.7	15.0/40.0

Norwegian Bokmål → English

Model	0-shot (BLEU/chrF++)	1-shot (BLEU/chrF++)	5-shot (BLEU/chrF++)
NorMistral-7b-warm	56.7/70.6	57.7/71.7	58.5/72.2
NorMistral-7b-scratch	48.1/62.9	51.5/66.6	52.6/67.6
NorBLOOM-7b	46.0/61.5	51.3/66.7	51.7/66.9
NB-GPT-J	23.9/55.3	32.3/63.1	48.5/68.7
GPT-Sw3-6.7B	47.9/67.8	52.4/70.6	50.0/70.7
GPT-Sw3-6.7B-v2	38.8/59.6	49.0/68.6	50.7/70.6
Falcon-7B	42.4/58.5	47.3/62.3	48.6/63.3
Mistral-7B-v0.1	53.8/68.2	54.6/69.0	56.9/70.7

Norwegian Nynorsk → English

Model	0-shot (BLEU/chrF++)	1-shot (BLEU/chrF++)	5-shot (BLEU/chrF++)
NorMistral-7b-warm	55.1/68.4	55.5/69.5	56.0/69.8
NorMistral-7b-scratch	47.1/61.9	49.4/64.2	52.3/66.2
NorBLOOM-7b	45.0/59.3	48.3/64.0	49.0/64.7
NB-GPT-J	2.9/19.5	10.1/41.0	44.4/66.9
GPT-Sw3-6.7B	47.8/66.2	49.1/68.1	49.6/69.4
GPT-Sw3-6.7B-v2	46.3/67.5	48.9/69.3	58.2/72.8
Falcon-7B	21.6/40.6	31.7/47.4	36.6/57.1
Mistral-7B-v0.1	40.7/57.1	46.2/60.7	49.9/63.8

Norwegian Bokmål → Norwegian Nynorsk

Model	0-shot (BLEU/chrF++)	1-shot (BLEU/chrF++)	5-shot (BLEU/chrF++)
NorMistral-7b-warm	75.8/87.5	74.0/86.9	75.3/87.5
NorMistral-7b-scratch	38.0/56.9	39.2/57.9	40.7/59.3
NorBLOOM-7b	71.5/84.4	70.1/84.1	71.9/85.1
NB-GPT-J	6.6/35.5	9.6/41.0	26.0/64.7
GPT-Sw3-6.7B	63.6/82.8	74.7/86.0	75.8/86.9
GPT-Sw3-6.7B-v2	57.5/81.1	75.3/86.7	76.7/87.6
Falcon-7B	28.7/59.2	29.8/60.8	32.1/62.3
Mistral-7B-v0.1	32.0/62.2	32.9/62.6	35.2/63.9

Norwegian Nynorsk → Norwegian Bokmål

Model	0-shot (BLEU/chrF++)	1-shot (BLEU/chrF++)	5-shot (BLEU/chrF++)
NorMistral-7b-warm	88.1/93.6	89.2/94.3	89.3/94.6
NorMistral-7b-scratch	85.1/91.4	86.6/92.4	87.4/93.0
NorBLOOM-7b	78.7/88.5	84.2/90.7	87.4/93.0
NB-GPT-J	2.7/18.5	6.9/35.6	52.9/84.3
GPT-Sw3-6.7B	652.3/82.4	86.1/92.5	87.8/93.6
GPT-Sw3-6.7B-v2	72.0/88.6	86.1/92.5	88.2/93.9
Falcon-7B	36.7/61.6	38.3/63.5	45.8/68.1
Mistral-7B-v0.1	57.0/74.8	59.9/77.5	62.6/79.1

Hardware and Software

Training Factors: The models were pretrained using the Megatron-DeepSpeed library on the LUMI cluster in Finland.

Carbon Footprint: Pretraining one model took approximately 70k GPU hours of computation on AMD MI250X GPUs (assuming 2 GPUs per one AMD MI250X device), each of which draws 500W. LUMI is one of the most eco-efficient data centers in the world, and its energy consumption is covered 100% with renewable electricity.

Example usage

Let's try to use this model for English-to-Norwegian machine translation using simple zero-shot prompting:

from transformers import AutoTokenizer, AutoModelForCausalLM

# First, we will have to import the tokenizer and the language model
tokenizer = AutoTokenizer.from_pretrained("norallm/normistral-7b-scratch")
model = AutoModelForCausalLM.from_pretrained("norallm/normistral-7b-scratch").cuda().eval()

# Now we will define the zero-shot prompt template
prompt = """Engelsk: {0}
Bokmål:"""

# A function that will take care of generating the output
@torch.no_grad()
def generate(text):
    text = prompt.format(text)
    input_ids = tokenizer(text, return_tensors='pt').input_ids.cuda()
    prediction = model.generate(
        input_ids,
        max_new_tokens=64,
        do_sample=False,
        eos_token_id=tokenizer('\n').input_ids
    )
    return tokenizer.decode(prediction[0, input_ids.size(1):]).strip()

# Now you can simply call the generate function with an English text you want to translate:
generate("I'm super excited about this Norwegian NORA model! Can it translate these sentences?")
# > this should output: 'Jeg er super spent på denne norske NORA modellen! Kan den oversette disse setningene?'

Example usage on a GPU with ~16GB VRAM (try for yourself in Google Colab)

Install bitsandbytes if you want to load in 8bit

pip install bitsandbytes
pip install accelerate

import torch
from transformers import AutoTokenizer, AutoModelForCausalLM

tokenizer = AutoTokenizer.from_pretrained(
    "norallm/normistral-7b-scratch"
)

# This setup needs about 8gb VRAM
# Setting `load_in_8bit=False` -> 15gb VRAM
# Using `torch.float32` and `load_in_8bit=False` -> 21gb VRAM
model = AutoModelForCausalLM.from_pretrained(
    "norallm/normistral-7b-scratch",
    device_map='auto',
    load_in_8bit=True,
    torch_dtype=torch.bfloat16
)

norallm
/

normistral-7b-scratch

NorMistral-7b-scratch

Pretraining corpus

Model details

Initial evaluation

Sentiment analysis

Reading comprehension

Grammatical error correction

Machine translation

Hardware and Software

Example usage

Example usage on a GPU with ~16GB VRAM (try for yourself in Google Colab)

Datasets used to train norallm/normistral-7b-scratch