Dataset Viewer
Auto-converted to Parquet Duplicate
provider
stringclasses
3 values
model
stringclasses
3 values
text
stringlengths
46
7.02k
gemini
gemini-flash-latest
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "contradiction" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "contradiction" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 5, "label": "consistent" } ] }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": true, "benefit": "शिक्षण शुल्काच्या प्रतिपूर्ती", "value1": "50 टक्के", "value2": "जशक्षि शुल्क व परीक्षा शुल्काच्या 50 टक्के" }
ollama
llama3.1
{"same_scheme": false, "benefit": "", "value1": "", "value2": ""}
ollama
llama3.1
The draft clause in the new Government Resolution (GR) conflicts with the existing GR dated 2024-05-09 (उच्च व तंत्र णशक्षि णवभाग GR मांच्या प्रवशे). Specifically, the conflict arises from the introduction of a new amendment (E-766368-HTED-14025/11/2024-MHT-TE-5) which is not present in the existing GR. This new amendm...
ollama
llama3.1
The conflict lies in the method of disbursing stipend through Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT). The draft clause specifies that the stipend shall be disbursed "directly through the MahaDBT portal to the Aadhaar-linked bank accounts" (emphasis on direct and Aadhaar-linked), whereas the existing GR dated 2024-03-27 (GR-2024...
ollama
llama3.1
Here's a breakdown of the conflict: **Specific contradiction:** The draft clause "The concerned Directorates shall give wide publicity to this decision through all media" conflicts with the existing GR clause "महामंडळाच्या अध्यक्षस्तरािर जनयजमतपणे आढािा घेण्यात यािा. तसचे याबाबतचा तपजशल जनयोिन ि जित्त जिभागास सादर करण...
ollama
llama3.1
The draft clause conflicts with the existing GR ( उच्च व तंत्रशशक्षण शवभाग GR तंशनशव-1522/प्र.क्र.68/22/तांशश-3 dated 2023-02-09) in that it specifies stipend disbursement directly to Aadhaar-linked bank accounts, whereas the existing GR states that the stipend will be credited into a bank account through the MahaDBT p...
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": 1, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 2, "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": 3, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 4, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 5, "label": "neutral"}]}
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": true, "benefit": "शिक्षण शुल्क प्रतिपूर्ती", "value1": "", "value2": "" }
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": "1", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "2", "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": "3", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "4", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "5", "label": "neutral"}]}
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "", "value1": "", "value2": "" }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "approval of revised syllabus", "value1": "", "value2": "" }
gemini
gemini-flash-latest
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 5, "label": "consistent" } ] }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "conflict", "reason": "Different numeric amounts/percentages/limits for the same benefit or fee" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "consistent", "reason": "Both clauses are about the same scheme and procedure, but one is more specific about t...
ollama
llama3.1
{ "results": [ {"pair": "1", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "2", "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": "3", "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": "4", "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": "5", "label": "neutral"} ] }
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "consistent" }, ...
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "", "value1": "Rs. 2,000", "value2": "" }
gemini
gemini-flash-latest
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 5, "label": "neutral" } ] }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "शिक्षण शुल्काची प्रातिपूर्ती", "value1": "50 टक्के", "value2": "100 टक्के" }
ollama
llama3.1
The draft clause conflicts with the existing Government Resolution dated 2024-07-19 (उच्च व तसत्र जशक्षि जवभाग GR जशष्ट्यव-ृ 2024/प्र.क्र.207/तासजश-4) in the following specific contradiction: * The draft clause states that students from all categories (EBC, EWS, SEBC, and OBC) must pay "संपूर्ण रक्कम" (the entire amou...
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "consistent" }, ...
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "education fee reimbursement", "value1": "50 टक्के", "value2": "100 टक्के" }
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": "1", "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": "2", "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": "3", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "4", "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": "5", "label": "neutral"}]}
gemini
gemini-flash-latest
The draft clause mandates stipend disbursement specifically to "Aadhaar-linked bank accounts" via the "MahaDBT portal," whereas the existing provision broadly specifies disbursement merely as "थेट लाभ हस्तांतरणाद्वारे (DBT) लाभार्थ्यांच्या बँक खात्यामध्ये" (Direct Benefit Transfer to beneficiaries' bank accounts) witho...
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "", "value1": "2025-26", "value2": "2022" }
gemini
gemini-flash-latest
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 5, "label": "consistent" } ] }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": true, "benefit": "शिक्षण शुल्क प्रतिपूर्ती", "value1": "", "value2": "50 टक्के" }
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "neutral" }, { ...
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ {"pair": 1, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 2, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 3, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 4, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 5, "label": "neutral"} ] }
ollama
llama3.1
The draft clause "The concerned Directorates shall give wide publicity to this decision through all media" conflicts with the existing GR clause "हा शासन टनणणय, उच्चाटधकार सटचि सटमतीने मान्यता टदल्यानुसार टनगणटमत करण्यात येत आहे" from GR टिमटि-2023/प्र.क्र.83/टिटश-2 dated 2024-02-27. The specific contradiction lies in...
gemini
gemini-flash-latest
{ "results": [ {"pair": 1, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 2, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 3, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 4, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 5, "label": "consistent"} ] }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "", "value1": "academic year 2025-26", "value2": "" }
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "neutral" }, { ...
ollama
llama3.1
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "conflict", "reason": "The DRAFT and EXISTING GRs both concern the same scheme (hostel stipend) for the same beneficiary group (eligible students of professional courses), and the contradiction is explicit in the text of both clauses." }, { "pai...
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "technical diploma admissions", "value1": "", "value2": "" }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "hostel stipend", "value1": "Rs. 2,000 per month", "value2": "Rs. 9,74,56,128" }
ollama
llama3.1
The draft clause states that "आर्थिकदृष्ट्या मागास (EBC), आर्थिकदृष्ट्या दुर्बल घटक (EWS), सामाजिक व शैक्षणिकदृष्ट्या मागास प्रवर्ग (SEBC) व इतर मागासवर्ग (OBC)" will receive education fee reimbursement. However, the existing GR dated 2024-07-09 specifically mentions that only "आर्थिकदृष्ट्या दुर्बल घटक (EWS), सामायिक ...
gemini
gemini-flash-latest
The draft clause creates a contradiction by mandating direct benefit transfer specifically to **"Aadhaar-linked bank accounts"** for a stipend, whereas the prior framework only broadly specifies direct deposit into **"बँक खात्यात"** (bank accounts) restricted to **"शैक्षणिक शुल्क शिष्यवृत्ती"** (tuition fee scholarship...
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "शिक्षण शुल्काची प्रतिपूर्ति", "value1": "संपूर्ण रक्कम", "value2": "एकवत्रतरीत्या" }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "शिक्षण शुल्क प्रतिपूर्ती", "value1": "50 टक्के", "value2": "100 टक्के" }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": true, "benefit": "शिक्षण शुल्क प्रतिपूर्ती", "value1": "", "value2": "" }
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": 1, "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": 2, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 3, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 4, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 5, "label": "consistent"}]}
ollama
llama3.1
The draft clause proposes an additional hostel stipend of Rs. 2,000 per month for eligible students, whereas the existing GR dated 2023-03-31 (उच्च व तंत्र शिक्षण शवभाग GR सेपप्र-2019/प्र.क्र.236/मशि-1) states that the Director and Joint Director of Higher Education are to screen the applications of eligible students, ...
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": true, "incompatible": false }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "", "value1": "", "value2": "" }
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "consistent" }, ...
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": "1", "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": "2", "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": "3", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "4", "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": "5", "label": "contradiction"}]}
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "publicity", "value1": "wide publicity", "value2": "" }
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": 1, "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": 2, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 3, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 4, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 5, "label": "neutral"}]}
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": 1, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 2, "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": 3, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 4, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 5, "label": "consistent"}]}
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": true, "benefit": "शिक्षण शुल्क प्रतिपूर्ती", "value1": "आर्थिकदृष्ट्या मागास (EBC), आर्थिकदृष्ट्या दुर्बल घटक (EWS), सामाजिक व शैक्षणिकदृष्ट्या मागास प्रवर्ग (SEBC) व इतर मागासवर्ग (OBC)", "value2": "रु.8.00 लाख" }
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "consistent" }, { ...
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": true, "benefit": "stipend", "value1": "paid through the Maha-DBT portal", "value2": "संबंधित संस्थेस केंद्रशासनहाय प्रिविदेण्यात अलेल्या" }
ollama
llama3.1
The draft clause conflicts with the existing Government Resolution dated 2024-07-09 (उच्च व तंत्र यशक्षण यवभाग GR मास प्रवशे घेणाऱ्या आर्थिकदृष्ट्या) in specifying a different percentage for the benefit of reduced fees. Specifically, the draft clause states "50 टक्के ऐवजी 100 टक्के" (50% instead of 100%) for शिक्षण शुल...
gemini
gemini-flash-latest
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "contradiction" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 5, "label": "contradiction" } ] }
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "neutral" }, { ...
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "contradiction" }, { ...
ollama
llama3.1
{ "results": [ {"pair": "1", "label": "conflict", "reason": "Different methods of disbursing stipend to eligible students."}, {"pair": "2", "label": "conflict", "reason": "Different methods of disbursing stipend to eligible students."}, {"pair": "3", "label": "consistent", "reason": "Both clauses describe...
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "neutral" }, { ...
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": "1", "label": "neutral"}]}
gemini
gemini-flash-latest
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "contradiction" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "contradiction" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "contradiction" }, { "pair": 5, "label": "contradiction" } ] }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": true, "explicit_contradiction": false }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "शिक्षण शुल्काची प्रतिपूर्ति", "value1": "संपूर्ण रक्कम", "value2": "व्याजाची रक्कम" }
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": 1, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 2, "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": 3, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 4, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 5, "label": "contradiction"}]}
ollama
llama3.1
Here's a breakdown of the conflict: **Specific contradiction:** The draft clause states that EWS students will be eligible for 50% reimbursement of education fees, whereas the existing GR (शालये नशक्षण व क्रीडा नवभाग GR dated 2024-03-15) specifies that private school teachers and staff are entitled to a 100% waiver of...
ollama
llama3.1
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "conflict", "reason": "Different numeric amounts for the same benefit (hostel stipend)" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "consistent", "reason": "Both clauses describe disbursal of stipend through MahaDBT portal" }, { "pair": 3...
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": 1, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 2, "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": 3, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 4, "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": 5, "label": "neutral"}]}
ollama
llama3.1
{ "results": [ {"pair": "1", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "2", "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": "3", "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": "4", "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": "5", "label": "neutral"} ] }
ollama
llama3.1
The draft clause proposes an additional hostel stipend for students of professional courses, but it does not specify a numeric amount. In contrast, the existing Government Resolution dated 2024-03-11 ( उच्च ि तुंत्र वशक्षण विभाग GR माकुं : सकुं ीणण-2023/प्र.क्र.30/विवश-2) specifies that the sanctioned amount for a part...
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "contradiction" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "contradiction" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "neutral" }, ...
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "", "value1": "2025-26", "value2": "30 जािेवारी, 2024" }
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "neutral" }, { ...
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "", "value1": "", "value2": "" }
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": "1", "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": "2", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "3", "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": "4", "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": "5", "label": "consistent"}]}
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ {"pair": 1, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 2, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 3, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 4, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 5, "label": "neutral"} ] }
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "contradiction" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "consistent" }, ...
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": 1, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 2, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 3, "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": 4, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 5, "label": "neutral"}]}
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "stipend disbursal", "value1": "directly through MahaDBT portal to Aadhaar-linked bank accounts", "value2": "टप्याटप्याने विद्यापीठास उपलब्ध करुन देण्यात येईल" }
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": 1, "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": 2, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 3, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 4, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 5, "label": "contradiction"}]}
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "consistent" }, { ...
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "same_scheme": true, "benefit": "shikshan shulka pratipurti", "value1": "50 टक्के", "value2": "100 टक्के" }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "incompatible": false }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "मुदतवाढ", "value1": "", "value2": "" }
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": "1", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "2", "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": "3", "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": "4", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "5", "label": "contradiction"}]
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": "1", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "2", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "3", "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": "4", "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": "5", "label": "consistent"}]
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": "1", "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": "2", "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": "3", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "4", "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": "5", "label": "contradiction"}]}
ollama
llama3.1
{"results": [{"pair": "1", "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": "2", "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": "3", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "4", "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": "5", "label": "consistent"}]}
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": false, "benefit": "", "value1": "academic year 2025-26", "value2": "" }
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "consistent" }, { ...
ollama
llama3.1
The draft clause states that this Government Resolution shall come into effect from the academic year 2025-26, whereas the existing Government Resolution (GR सावियो-2023/प्र. क्र. 491 /अजाक सामावजक न्याय ि विशेष सहाय्य विभाग dated 2024-07-09) specifies that the scheme for financial assistance to students shall be imple...
gemini
gemini-flash-latest
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "contradiction" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "contradiction" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 5, "label": "neutral" } ] }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": true, "explicit_contradiction": false }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "results": [ {"pair": 1, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 2, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 3, "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": 4, "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": 5, "label": "consistent"} ] }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "same_scheme": true, "benefit": "शिक्षण शुल्क प्रतिपूर्ती", "value1": "", "value2": "" }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "background": "The Government has been considering the need to provide financial assistance to meritorious students studying in Government Polytechnics. In order to encourage and reward academic excellence, it is proposed to sanction a merit scholarship to top-performing students.", "clauses": [ "A merit scho...
ollama
llama3.1
{ "results": [ {"pair": 1, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 2, "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": 3, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 4, "label": "contradiction"}, {"pair": 5, "label": "contradiction"} ] }
ollama
llama3.1
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "consistent", "reason": "Both draft and existing GRs have the same content" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "neutral", "reason": "The two documents are identical, indicating a possible error in the existing pair number" }, { "...
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ {"pair": 1, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 2, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 3, "label": "consistent"}, {"pair": 4, "label": "neutral"}, {"pair": 5, "label": "neutral"} ] }
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "consistent" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "neutral" }, { ...
groq
llama-3.3-70b-versatile
{ "results": [ { "pair": 1, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 2, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 3, "label": "neutral" }, { "pair": 4, "label": "consistent" }, { ...
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio

No dataset card yet

Downloads last month
60

Space using samay-rajput/clauseguard-index 1