model stringclasses 81
values | image stringlengths 38 49 | image_url stringlengths 95 126 | prompt_key stringclasses 9
values | expected stringclasses 9
values | gemini_verdict stringclasses 2
values | gemini_response stringlengths 98 491 | count_point_verdict stringclasses 2
values | count_box_verdict stringclasses 2
values | count_prompt_counts stringlengths 36 106 | detection_verdict stringclasses 2
values | detection_counts stringclasses 137
values | mask_pipeline_verdict stringclasses 2
values | mask_pipeline_counts stringclasses 134
values | used_generic_mask bool 2
classes | human_label stringclasses 3
values | used_to_choose_methods bool 2
classes | raw_answers stringlengths 350 8.53k |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
bfl--flux-1-dev | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p1.b244b2d4.png | Easy__p1 | {"red apples": 3} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, there are four red apples resting on the wooden table. They are positioned with one on the left, one in the front center, one on the right, and one in the back. Since the criteria requires exactly three red apples, the image does not meet the requirement.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"red apples": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | FAIL | {"red apples": 4} | FAIL | {"red apples": 4} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><box><34><160><369><503>,<305><337><642><692>,<493><91><809><427>,<649><373><979><711></box>"}, "point": {"red apples": null}, "count_point": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><point><199><330>,<471><515>,<652><258>,<813><544></point>\nTotal number: 4."}, "count_box": ... | |
bfl--flux-1-dev | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p2.d24e8922.png | Easy__p2 | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | Based on the image, there is a row of yellow rubber ducks sitting on the shelf in front of the mirror. Counting them from left to right, there are exactly 5 ducks present. This matches the required count.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": {"point": 5, "box": 5}} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><box><57><437><251><674>,<249><432><435><671>,<424><434><609><668>,<589><432><764><659>,<733><434><907><651></box>"}, "point": {"yellow rubber ducks": null}, "count_point": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><point><154><556>,<342><55... | |
bfl--flux-1-dev | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p3.128b9b59.png | Easy__p3 | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly four white candles standing upright in a row on the dark surface. Each candle is lit with a visible flame.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"white candles": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><box><235><416><336><807>,<375><372><473><807>,<524><340><623><807>,<680><363><782><810></box>"}, "point": {"white candles": null}, "count_point": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><point><284><642>,<423><620>,<573><606>,<730><618></point>\nTotal number: 4.... | |
bfl--flux-1-dev | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p1.f1e4489e.png | Medium__p1 | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly 3 black dogs sitting in the background and exactly 2 orange tabby cats sitting in the foreground. The counts match the required criteria perfectly.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"orange cats": {"point": 2, "box": 2}, "black dogs": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | PASS | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><box><279><355><498><782>,<625><405><952><813></box>", "black dogs": "<ref>black dogs</ref><box><0><235><391><833>,<345><105><636><758>,<568><150><1000><824></box>"}, "point": {"orange cats": null, "black dogs": null}, "count_point": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</r... | |
bfl--flux-1-dev | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p2.eb5d1ad2.png | Medium__p2 | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are 3 red roses visible at the top of the arrangement and 2 white daisies positioned below them in the vase. Since the requirement is exactly 4 red roses and there are only 3, the criteria are not met.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"red roses": {"point": 3, "box": 3}, "white daisies": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"red roses": 3, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | {"red roses": 3, "white daisies": 2} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</ref><box><144><161><564><509>,<435><122><750><401>,<551><258><954><541></box>", "white daisies": "<ref>white daisies</ref><box><229><424><566><813>,<511><439><887><826></box>"}, "point": {"red roses": null, "white daisies": null}, "count_point": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</r... | |
bfl--flux-1-dev | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p3.65e5da9a.png | Medium__p3 | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there is exactly 1 large blue butterfly located on the left side. There are 3 yellow butterflies: one in the top left corner and two on the right side. The counts match the required criteria perfectly.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"blue butterflies": {"point": 1, "box": 1}, "yellow butterflies": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | PASS | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterflies</ref><box><10><143><565><737></box>", "yellow butterflies": "<ref>yellow butterflies</ref><box><23><32><324><348>,<610><232><996><584>,<657><538><902><918></box>"}, "point": {"blue butterflies": null, "yellow butterflies": null}, "count_point": {"blue butterflies":... | |
bfl--flux-1-dev | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p1.be868911.png | Hard__p1 | {"goldfish": 9} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, I can count 10 goldfish swimming inside the bowl. Since the requirement is exactly 9 goldfish, the image does not meet the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"goldfish": {"point": 10, "box": 10}} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 10} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 10} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><box><39><416><87><566>,<47><522><229><740>,<74><261><310><436>,<140><704><411><820>,<240><519><478><685>,<306><326><826><658>,<480><683><794><853>,<608><270><847><388>,<705><438><948><714>,<871><294><963><532></box>"}, "point": {"goldfish": null}, "count_point": {"goldfish":... | |
bfl--flux-1-dev | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p2.3c1a9109.png | Hard__p2 | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are exactly 3 bananas in the foreground and 2 apples near the top. However, there are significantly more than 4 oranges. I can clearly see at least 6 whole oranges and one orange half, with several more partially visible underneath. Since the orange count does not match the required number, th... | FAIL | FAIL | {"bananas": {"point": 2, "box": 3}, "oranges": {"point": 14, "box": 14}, "apples": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 16, "apples": 2} | FAIL | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 16, "apples": 2} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"bananas": "<ref>bananas</ref><box><117><407><509><909>,<176><401><756><906>,<244><434><884><785></box>", "oranges": "<ref>oranges</ref><box><23><342><210><546>,<143><174><375><394>,<206><383><331><463>,<268><447><348><541>,<297><159><348><224>,<329><299><523><436>,<333><358><572><596>,<450><541><623><654>,... | |
bfl--flux-1-dev | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p3.5354a527.png | Hard__p3 | {"balloons": 11} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, I can count 13 balloons in total. These include various sizes and colors scattered across the blue sky, from the small orange one on the far left to the tiny purple one on the far right. Since the requirement is exactly 11 balloons, the image does not meet the criteria.
VER... | FAIL | FAIL | {"balloons": {"point": 13, "box": 13}} | FAIL | {"balloons": 13} | FAIL | {"balloons": 13} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"balloons": "<ref>balloons</ref><box><116><601><149><642>,<138><229><263><384>,<204><399><345><576>,<202><662><360><873>,<308><147><461><338>,<370><359><611><660>,<514><243><552><284>,<580><731><657><834>,<619><535><735><684>,<630><300><716><404>,<656><171><760><284>,<751><387><906><577>,<932><694><961><729... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro-ultra | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p1.7a1f570a.png | Easy__p1 | {"red apples": 3} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, there are exactly two red apples resting on the wooden table. The evaluation criteria require exactly three red apples to pass. Since there are only two apples present, the image does not meet the requirement.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"red apples": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"red apples": 2} | FAIL | {"red apples": 2} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><box><376><399><644><662>,<649><417><930><682></box>"}, "point": {"red apples": null}, "count_point": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><point><509><530>,<789><550></point>\nTotal number: 2."}, "count_box": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><box><375><398><644><662>... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro-ultra | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p2.41de5a29.png | Easy__p2 | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are 7 yellow rubber ducks lined up in a row on the wooden shelf. Since the requirement is exactly 5 ducks, the image does not meet the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"yellow rubber ducks": {"point": 7, "box": 7}} | FAIL | {"yellow rubber ducks": 7} | FAIL | {"yellow rubber ducks": 7} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><box><67><758><183><898>,<196><758><310><898>,<333><758><446><898>,<456><758><571><898>,<582><758><697><898>,<711><760><829><899>,<840><758><961><898></box>"}, "point": {"yellow rubber ducks": null}, "count_point": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow ru... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro-ultra | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p3.d3c4bcaf.png | Easy__p3 | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly 4 white candles standing upright on the dark surface, each with a lit flame.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"white candles": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><box><229><177><306><863>,<359><145><427><852>,<545><157><607><854>,<677><172><750><860></box>"}, "point": {"white candles": null}, "count_point": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><point><265><550>,<391><544>,<578><544>,<715><555></point>\nTotal number: 4.... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro-ultra | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p1.de740763.png | Medium__p1 | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | PASS | The image shows three black dogs sitting in the background and two orange tabby cats sitting in the foreground. The count is exactly 2 orange cats and 3 black dogs, which matches the required criteria.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"orange cats": {"point": 2, "box": 2}, "black dogs": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | PASS | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><box><73><546><375><953>,<431><484><799><955></box>", "black dogs": "<ref>black dogs</ref><box><117><241><375><688>,<270><146><583><935>,<642><209><952><791></box>"}, "point": {"orange cats": null, "black dogs": null}, "count_point": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</r... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro-ultra | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p2.8c410015.png | Medium__p2 | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are exactly 4 red roses. However, counting the white daisies reveals there are 3 of them (one on the top left, one on the top right pointing upwards, and one on the middle right). Since the requirement is exactly 2 white daisies, the count is incorrect.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"red roses": {"point": 4, "box": 4}, "white daisies": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | FAIL | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 3} | FAIL | {"red roses": 1, "white daisies": 0} | true | FAIL | false | {"detect": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</ref><box><122><244><332><449>,<283><435><481><628>,<310><188><489><343>,<527><473><790><738></box>", "white daisies": "<ref>white daisies</ref><box><283><70><579><223>,<547><47><749><179>,<564><186><806><423></box>"}, "point": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</ref><point><228><342... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro-ultra | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p3.cd75b8a1.png | Medium__p3 | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | FAIL | Based on the image, there is exactly 1 large blue butterfly in the center. There are 2 small yellow butterflies: one positioned above the blue butterfly's left wing and another below its right wing. Since there are only 2 yellow butterflies instead of the required 3, the image does not meet the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": {"point": 1, "box": 1}, "yellow butterflies": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 2} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 2} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterflies</ref><box><23><41><987><862></box>", "yellow butterflies": "<ref>yellow butterflies</ref><box><351><53><541><226>,<493><634><753><818></box>"}, "point": {"blue butterflies": null, "yellow butterflies": null}, "count_point": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterfli... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro-ultra | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p1.e6840077.png | Hard__p1 | {"goldfish": 9} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, I count 18 goldfish swimming inside the bowl. Since the requirement is exactly 9 goldfish, the image does not meet the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"goldfish": {"point": 23, "box": 22}} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 22} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 19} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><box><85><498><195><654>,<139><404><282><547>,<152><184><287><323>,<184><566><313><690>,<236><678><321><768>,<282><443><447><577>,<299><236><471><371>,<310><160><393><207>,<329><695><435><768>,<368><396><464><483>,<505><174><523><204>,<507><681><660><784>,<515><505><671><637>... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro-ultra | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p2.d9932a0c.png | Hard__p2 | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are 4 oranges with textured peel and 3 apples, identifiable by their smooth skin and stem cavities (located on the bottom-left, right, and bottom-right). There is a bunch of at least 3 bananas at the top. Because there are 3 apples instead of the required 2, the count does not match the criter... | FAIL | FAIL | {"bananas": {"point": 4, "box": 5}, "oranges": {"point": 4, "box": 5}, "apples": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | FAIL | {"bananas": 5, "oranges": 5, "apples": 3} | FAIL | {"bananas": 5, "oranges": 5, "apples": 3} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"bananas": "<ref>bananas</ref><box><188><334><247><444>,<196><81><790><505>,<272><205><652><441>,<334><310><589><458>,<471><422><522><499></box>", "oranges": "<ref>oranges</ref><box><67><419><282><633>,<274><379><487><595>,<380><670><569><892>,<450><488><652><692>,<548><642><793><892></box>", "apples": "<re... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro-ultra | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p3.ace45615.png | Hard__p3 | {"balloons": 11} | FAIL | Based on the image, I can count 12 distinct balloons and a small sliver of a 13th on the bottom right edge. The visible balloons include large yellow, red, white/purple patterned, small pink, large blue, orange, checkered, green/yellow, large pink, yellow, yellow with a brown pattern, and blue/white patterned balloons.... | FAIL | FAIL | {"balloons": {"point": 14, "box": 13}} | FAIL | {"balloons": 14} | FAIL | {"balloons": 14} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"balloons": "<ref>balloons</ref><box><0><403><226><791>,<19><651><208><836>,<149><680><354><945>,<183><870><344><1000>,<238><452><528><827>,<275><887><445><1000>,<358><713><560><982>,<524><539><603><713>,<539><680><781><960>,<542><839><660><995>,<577><478><820><767>,<712><809><962><1000>,<926><652><1000><84... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p1.3e5cb1f4.png | Easy__p1 | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | The image shows a wooden surface with red apples placed on it. Counting the apples, there is one on the top left, one in the middle, and one on the right. Therefore, there are exactly three red apples present on the table.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"red apples": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><box><121><134><407><427>,<351><327><644><619>,<642><379><933><676></box>"}, "point": {"red apples": null}, "count_point": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><point><264><282>,<497><471>,<789><530></point>\nTotal number: 3."}, "count_box": {"red apples": "<ref>red apple... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p2.a7e10af4.png | Easy__p2 | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | Scanning the shelf from left to right, there are exactly five yellow rubber ducks present. There is one on the far left, a second one next to it, a cluster of two ducks (one positioned slightly behind the other), and a fifth, larger, out-of-focus duck on the far right.
VERDICT: PASS | FAIL | FAIL | {"yellow rubber ducks": {"point": 6, "box": 6}} | FAIL | {"yellow rubber ducks": 6} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | true | PASS | false | {"detect": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><box><349><425><471><549>,<466><429><588><569>,<580><488><718><631>,<588><437><724><567>,<710><421><978><686>,<859><390><903><426></box>"}, "point": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><point><406><496>,<524><506>,<644><574>,<654><498>... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p3.4aefcec0.png | Easy__p3 | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | Based on the image, there are four white candles standing on the surface. There is one tall unlit candle on the left, a shorter unlit candle in the front center, a thin lit candle behind it, and another tall unlit candle on the right.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"white candles": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><box><307><363><465><857>,<442><487><622><890>,<577><325><620><550>,<682><371><845><855></box>"}, "point": {"white candles": null}, "count_point": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><point><386><616>,<532><704>,<598><445>,<764><619></point>\nTotal number: 4.... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p1.0c84af1a.png | Medium__p1 | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are exactly 2 orange cats sitting in the foreground. However, there are only 2 black dogs visible behind them. Since the prompt requires exactly 3 black dogs, the count does not match the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"orange cats": {"point": 2, "box": 2}, "black dogs": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 2} | FAIL | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 2} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><box><206><349><524><842>,<669><402><932><833></box>", "black dogs": "<ref>black dogs</ref><box><0><135><470><855>,<469><137><996><832></box>"}, "point": {"orange cats": null, "black dogs": null}, "count_point": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><point><368><598>,<... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p2.6d0a200d.png | Medium__p2 | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are exactly 2 white daisies in the front. However, counting the red roses behind them reveals only 3 distinct blooms (one on the left, one in the top middle, and one on the right). Since there are not 4 red roses, the image fails the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"red roses": {"point": 3, "box": 3}, "white daisies": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"red roses": 3, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | {"red roses": 3, "white daisies": 2} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</ref><box><143><149><516><484>,<448><119><827><403>,<593><257><941><560></box>", "white daisies": "<ref>white daisies</ref><box><232><379><582><841>,<509><402><889><859></box>"}, "point": {"red roses": null, "white daisies": null}, "count_point": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</r... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p3.5d01a76f.png | Medium__p3 | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | FAIL | Based on the image, there is exactly one blue butterfly resting on the left side of the white fence. However, there are only two yellow butterflies: one located below the blue butterfly on the left, and another on the right side of the fence. Since the count of yellow butterflies is two instead of the required three, t... | FAIL | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": {"point": 1, "box": 2}, "yellow butterflies": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 2} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 2} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterflies</ref><box><95><401><424><698></box>", "yellow butterflies": "<ref>yellow butterflies</ref><box><174><668><406><871>,<746><313><991><581></box>"}, "point": {"blue butterflies": null, "yellow butterflies": null}, "count_point": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterf... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p1.67aec331.png | Hard__p1 | {"goldfish": 9} | PASS | Based on a careful examination of the image, I count exactly 9 goldfish swimming inside the fishbowl.
VERDICT: PASS | FAIL | FAIL | {"goldfish": {"point": 10, "box": 10}} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 10} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 10} | true | FAIL | false | {"detect": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><box><70><541><229><719>,<136><237><353><428>,<163><678><358><830>,<229><348><638><727>,<467><693><669><828>,<631><528><790><684>,<636><272><812><387>,<722><408><835><570>,<769><537><894><737>,<866><314><948><527></box>"}, "point": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><point><160... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p2.f23c797d.png | Hard__p2 | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, there is 1 banana, 4 round pinkish fruits (which appear to be oranges), and 1 lighter round fruit with a stem (which appears to be an apple). Because the counts are 1 banana, 4 oranges, and 1 apple, they do not match the required exactly 3 bananas, 4 oranges, and 2 apples.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"bananas": {"point": 1, "box": 1}, "oranges": {"point": 5, "box": 5}, "apples": {"point": 6, "box": 6}} | FAIL | {"bananas": 1, "oranges": 5, "apples": 6} | FAIL | {"bananas": 1, "oranges": 5, "apples": 6} | false | UNSURE | false | {"detect": {"bananas": "<ref>bananas</ref><box><206><248><522><561></box>", "oranges": "<ref>oranges</ref><box><346><413><463><478>,<363><532><498><571>,<398><365><542><459>,<495><408><654><509>,<500><491><666><571></box>", "apples": "<ref>apples</ref><box><347><413><463><479>,<363><532><498><571>,<398><365><542><460>,... | |
bfl--flux-1.1-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p3.ca6279b6.png | Hard__p3 | {"balloons": 11} | PASS | I have carefully examined the image and counted the balloons. There is a yellow one top left, a multi-colored one below it, a purple one top middle, a light blue one below that, a large pink one in the center, a yellow-green one bottom left, a multi-colored one right of center, a small pink/white one below that, a larg... | PASS | PASS | {"balloons": {"point": 11, "box": 11}} | PASS | {"balloons": 11} | PASS | {"balloons": 11} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"balloons": "<ref>balloons</ref><box><23><5><148><165>,<121><190><273><373>,<210><692><359><883>,<304><494><415><623>,<317><143><445><291>,<381><361><608><625>,<588><730><656><817>,<636><564><740><682>,<751><337><965><594>,<785><702><875><813>,<932><694><955><722></box>"}, "point": {"balloons": null}, "coun... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-4b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p1.png | Easy__p1 | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | The image displays exactly three red apples sitting in a row on a wooden table. No other apples are visible in the scene.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"red apples": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><box><47><322><348><672>,<349><323><654><680>,<652><319><958><661></box>"}, "point": {"red apples": null}, "count_point": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><point><196><498>,<501><500>,<805><492></point>\nTotal number: 3."}, "count_box": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-4b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p2.png | Easy__p2 | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | Based on the image, there is a clear row of yellow rubber ducks placed on the white surface. Counting them from left to right, there are exactly five ducks present.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": {"point": 5, "box": 5}} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><box><75><447><253><641>,<254><444><416><630>,<417><441><583><628>,<584><437><751><626>,<753><438><929><633></box>"}, "point": {"yellow rubber ducks": null}, "count_point": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><point><165><544>,<334><53... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-4b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p3.png | Easy__p3 | {"white candles": 4} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are exactly two white candles standing on the dark surface. The requirement is to have exactly four candles. Since the number of candles is two, not four, the condition is not met.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"white candles": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"white candles": 2} | FAIL | {"white candles": 2} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><box><212><146><473><863>,<543><142><794><861></box>"}, "point": {"white candles": null}, "count_point": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><point><343><503>,<668><501></point>\nTotal number: 2."}, "count_box": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><box... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-4b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p1.png | Medium__p1 | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | FAIL | Based on the image, there is exactly 1 orange cat sitting on the left and 2 black dogs sitting next to it on the right. Because the count is 1 orange cat and 2 black dogs, it does not meet the requirement of 2 orange cats and 3 black dogs.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"orange cats": {"point": 1, "box": 1}, "black dogs": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"orange cats": 1, "black dogs": 2} | FAIL | {"orange cats": 1, "black dogs": 2} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><box><18><244><388><765></box>", "black dogs": "<ref>black dogs</ref><box><377><205><635><760>,<608><225><959><793></box>"}, "point": {"orange cats": null, "black dogs": null}, "count_point": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><point><204><505></point>\nTotal number... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-4b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p2.png | Medium__p2 | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are 5 red roses visible in the bouquet (one front left, one front right, one far left, one back left, and one far right). There are exactly 2 white daisies visible. Since the number of red roses is 5 instead of the required 4, the image does not meet the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"red roses": {"point": 5, "box": 5}, "white daisies": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"red roses": 5, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | {"red roses": 1, "white daisies": 0} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</ref><box><128><167><312><342>,<159><181><529><481>,<270><84><492><209>,<457><90><742><340>,<700><146><900><356></box>", "white daisies": "<ref>white daisies</ref><box><456><309><804><587>,<650><263><816><425></box>"}, "point": {"red roses": null, "white daisies": null}, "count_... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-4b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p3.png | Medium__p3 | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | FAIL | Based on the image, there is exactly 1 blue butterfly resting on the left side of the railing. On the right side of the railing, there are 2 yellow butterflies. Since the count of yellow butterflies is 2 instead of the required 3, the criteria are not met.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": {"point": 1, "box": 1}, "yellow butterflies": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 2} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 2} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterflies</ref><box><60><369><369><649></box>", "yellow butterflies": "<ref>yellow butterflies</ref><box><572><346><763><572>,<734><338><917><593></box>"}, "point": {"blue butterflies": null, "yellow butterflies": null}, "count_point": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterf... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-4b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p1.png | Hard__p1 | {"goldfish": 9} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, there are exactly 10 goldfish visible swimming inside the fishbowl. Since the requirement is to have exactly 9 goldfish, the image does not meet the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"goldfish": {"point": 10, "box": 10}} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 10} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 10} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><box><177><550><395><718>,<200><348><397><473>,<252><470><355><578>,<375><415><593><548>,<388><264><560><375>,<409><676><592><789>,<444><521><615><650>,<561><331><767><452>,<663><538><768><693>,<708><429><829><535></box>"}, "point": {"goldfish": null}, "count_point": {"goldfi... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-4b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p2.png | Hard__p2 | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly 3 bananas (one pointing left, two curving right), 4 oranges (three clearly visible in the front/center, and one partially hidden behind the center orange), and 2 apples (both on the right side). The counts match the required criteria perfectly.
VERDICT: PASS | FAIL | FAIL | {"bananas": {"point": 2, "box": 3}, "oranges": {"point": 3, "box": 3}, "apples": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 3, "apples": 2} | FAIL | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 3, "apples": 2} | false | UNSURE | false | {"detect": {"bananas": "<ref>bananas</ref><box><119><331><321><501>,<193><45><432><482>,<300><197><679><383></box>", "oranges": "<ref>oranges</ref><box><129><467><386><726>,<333><581><590><796>,<362><372><617><608></box>", "apples": "<ref>apples</ref><box><577><271><820><512>,<585><506><872><779></box>"}, "point": {"ba... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-4b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p3.png | Hard__p3 | {"balloons": 11} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, there are 20 balloons visible against the blue sky. Since the requirement is exactly 11 balloons, the image does not meet the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"balloons": {"point": 20, "box": 20}} | FAIL | {"balloons": 20} | FAIL | {"balloons": 20} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"balloons": "<ref>balloons</ref><box><147><570><269><717>,<162><283><282><428>,<221><406><343><547>,<258><657><383><808>,<266><137><386><281>,<292><372><391><489>,<338><247><464><398>,<354><470><478><618>,<442><97><558><236>,<457><219><554><327>,<458><397><570><534>,<470><593><590><741>,<550><277><672><426>... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-9b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p1.png | Easy__p1 | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly three red apples arranged in a row on the wooden table. There are no other apples visible.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"red apples": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><box><67><338><348><639>,<350><371><639><682>,<646><334><930><641></box>"}, "point": {"red apples": null}, "count_point": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><point><207><489>,<494><523>,<789><490></point>\nTotal number: 3."}, "count_box": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-9b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p2.png | Easy__p2 | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | Based on the image provided, there is a row of yellow rubber ducks sitting on a white shelf. Counting them from left to right, there are exactly 5 yellow rubber ducks clearly visible.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": {"point": 5, "box": 5}} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><box><40><454><246><666>,<244><451><426><651>,<422><450><597><642>,<594><449><767><638>,<765><450><940><638></box>"}, "point": {"yellow rubber ducks": null}, "count_point": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><point><143><558>,<335><55... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-9b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p3.png | Easy__p3 | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly four white pillar candles standing upright in a row on the dark surface.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"white candles": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><box><106><314><291><736>,<300><316><488><743>,<502><309><692><744>,<700><315><886><737></box>"}, "point": {"white candles": null}, "count_point": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><point><198><525>,<394><525>,<598><525>,<792><525></point>\nTotal number: 4.... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-9b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p1.png | Medium__p1 | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | FAIL | Based on the image, there is exactly 1 orange cat and 2 black dogs sitting on the grass. This does not meet the required criteria of 2 orange cats and 3 black dogs.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"orange cats": {"point": 1, "box": 1}, "black dogs": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"orange cats": 1, "black dogs": 2} | FAIL | {"orange cats": 1, "black dogs": 2} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><box><100><351><377><852></box>", "black dogs": "<ref>black dogs</ref><box><369><298><614><818>,<620><210><894><832></box>"}, "point": {"orange cats": null, "black dogs": null}, "count_point": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><point><238><602></point>\nTotal numbe... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-9b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p2.png | Medium__p2 | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are 6 red roses and 4 white daisies in the vase. Since the requirement is exactly 4 red roses and 2 white daisies, the counts do not match.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"red roses": {"point": 6, "box": 6}, "white daisies": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | FAIL | {"red roses": 6, "white daisies": 4} | FAIL | {"red roses": 1, "white daisies": 0} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</ref><box><114><278><278><486>,<175><181><348><338>,<316><266><514><430>,<396><370><628><606>,<607><158><801><312>,<717><288><886><506></box>", "white daisies": "<ref>white daisies</ref><box><233><349><380><570>,<287><157><488><270>,<495><246><725><443>,<641><394><778><583></box... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-9b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p3.png | Medium__p3 | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | FAIL | Based on the image, there is exactly 1 blue butterfly and 1 yellow butterfly resting on the wooden fence. There are no other butterflies visible in the scene. This does not meet the requirement of having 3 yellow butterflies.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": {"point": 1, "box": 2}, "yellow butterflies": {"point": 1, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 1} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 1} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterflies</ref><box><308><385><566><599></box>", "yellow butterflies": "<ref>yellow butterflies</ref><box><610><316><803><583></box>"}, "point": {"blue butterflies": null, "yellow butterflies": null}, "count_point": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterflies</ref><point><43... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-9b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p1.png | Hard__p1 | {"goldfish": 9} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, there are exactly 7 goldfish visible inside the fishbowl (6 orange and 1 white). Since the requirement is to have exactly 9 goldfish, the image does not meet the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"goldfish": {"point": 7, "box": 7}} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 7} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 7} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><box><154><456><342><635>,<163><289><431><452>,<208><644><458><816>,<372><419><610><586>,<503><655><691><828>,<559><284><817><474>,<644><451><838><624></box>"}, "point": {"goldfish": null}, "count_point": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><point><247><544>,<299><372>,<335><729... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-9b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p2.png | Hard__p2 | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are 2 bananas visible on the left, 3 distinct oranges in the center (with a possible sliver of a fourth behind them), and 1 red apple on the right. This does not match the required count of exactly 3 bananas, 4 oranges, and 2 apples.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"bananas": {"point": 2, "box": 2}, "oranges": {"point": 4, "box": 4}, "apples": {"point": 1, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"bananas": 2, "oranges": 4, "apples": 1} | FAIL | {"bananas": 2, "oranges": 4, "apples": 1} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"bananas": "<ref>bananas</ref><box><79><214><702><530>,<142><314><393><604></box>", "oranges": "<ref>oranges</ref><box><229><446><462><667>,<374><256><626><506>,<434><489><519><547>,<445><498><685><673></box>", "apples": "<ref>apples</ref><box><610><328><893><629></box>"}, "point": {"bananas": null, "orange... | |
bfl--flux-2-klein-9b | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p3.png | Hard__p3 | {"balloons": 11} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, there are a total of 14 balloons. This includes two isolated balloons at the bottom (one red on the left, one light purple on the right) and a central cluster containing 12 balloons of various colors, some of which are partially hidden. Since the total is 14 and not exactly ... | FAIL | FAIL | {"balloons": {"point": 14, "box": 14}} | FAIL | {"balloons": 14} | FAIL | {"balloons": 14} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"balloons": "<ref>balloons</ref><box><182><323><318><491>,<182><579><314><750>,<291><235><429><407>,<303><469><439><634>,<362><381><479><507>,<379><545><498><685>,<434><422><568><600>,<434><203><568><382>,<438><621><557><764>,<524><314><653><479>,<554><488><694><661>,<569><442><692><527>,<662><277><804><449... | |
bfl--flux-2-max | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p1.png | Easy__p1 | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly three red apples resting on the wooden table. One is positioned in the front center, with two others slightly behind it to the left and right.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"red apples": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><box><82><226><478><668>,<280><339><721><823>,<533><223><919><675></box>"}, "point": {"red apples": null}, "count_point": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><point><281><448>,<500><578>,<727><450></point>\nTotal number: 3."}, "count_box": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples... | |
bfl--flux-2-max | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p2.png | Easy__p2 | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | FAIL | Based on the image, there is a row of yellow rubber ducks sitting on a white shelf. Counting them from left to right, there are exactly four ducks present. Since the requirement is to have exactly five ducks, the image does not meet the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"yellow rubber ducks": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | FAIL | {"yellow rubber ducks": 4} | FAIL | {"yellow rubber ducks": 4} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><box><69><388><293><643>,<293><388><512><643>,<513><388><733><642>,<733><386><957><642></box>"}, "point": {"yellow rubber ducks": null}, "count_point": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><point><182><515>,<402><515>,<623><514>,<843><5... | |
bfl--flux-2-max | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p3.png | Easy__p3 | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly four white candles standing upright in a row on a dark surface against a black background.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"white candles": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><box><202><206><328><779>,<361><216><486><779>,<520><204><644><778>,<677><217><804><778></box>"}, "point": {"white candles": null}, "count_point": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><point><264><490>,<424><491>,<583><489>,<740><495></point>\nTotal number: 4.... | |
bfl--flux-2-max | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p1.png | Medium__p1 | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly two orange cats sitting in the foreground and exactly three black dogs positioned around and behind them. The counts match the required criteria perfectly.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"orange cats": {"point": 2, "box": 2}, "black dogs": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | PASS | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><box><254><404><509><870>,<509><410><753><862></box>", "black dogs": "<ref>black dogs</ref><box><23><222><341><809>,<373><105><625><656>,<656><230><988><813></box>"}, "point": {"orange cats": null, "black dogs": null}, "count_point": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</r... | |
bfl--flux-2-max | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p2.png | Medium__p2 | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are 3 red roses and 2 white daisies in the vase. While the number of white daisies matches the requirement, the number of red roses falls short of the required 4.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"red roses": {"point": 3, "box": 3}, "white daisies": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"red roses": 3, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | {"red roses": 3, "white daisies": 2} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</ref><box><206><157><406><346>,<381><111><602><276>,<537><181><736><380></box>", "white daisies": "<ref>white daisies</ref><box><316><219><535><403>,<596><114><798><273></box>"}, "point": {"red roses": null, "white daisies": null}, "count_point": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</r... | |
bfl--flux-2-max | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p3.png | Medium__p3 | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | FAIL | Based on the image, there is exactly 1 blue butterfly resting in the center on the fence post. However, there are 4 yellow butterflies: one on the far left, two hovering just above the blue butterfly, and one on the far right. Because there are 4 yellow butterflies instead of the required 3, the image does not meet the... | FAIL | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": {"point": 1, "box": 2}, "yellow butterflies": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 4} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 4} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterflies</ref><box><310><384><676><606></box>", "yellow butterflies": "<ref>yellow butterflies</ref><box><84><345><273><522>,<261><276><414><452>,<576><263><747><431>,<767><299><936><483></box>"}, "point": {"blue butterflies": null, "yellow butterflies": null}, "count_point... | |
bfl--flux-2-max | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p1.png | Hard__p1 | {"goldfish": 9} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, there are 10 goldfish visible inside the fishbowl.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"goldfish": {"point": 10, "box": 10}} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 10} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 10} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><box><104><478><342><637>,<112><293><347><443>,<181><690><416><843>,<331><242><573><397>,<346><583><505><727>,<401><414><628><576>,<477><722><739><875>,<585><567><850><730>,<600><243><860><401>,<669><393><920><550></box>"}, "point": {"goldfish": null}, "count_point": {"goldfi... | |
bfl--flux-2-max | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p2.png | Hard__p2 | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are 2 bananas on the left, 2 apples (one red in the front, one green on the right), and at least 4 oranges (with a possible fifth partially visible in the center). Since there are only 2 bananas instead of the required 3, the count does not match the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"bananas": {"point": 2, "box": 2}, "oranges": {"point": 5, "box": 5}, "apples": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"bananas": 2, "oranges": 5, "apples": 2} | FAIL | {"bananas": 2, "oranges": 5, "apples": 2} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"bananas": "<ref>bananas</ref><box><31><191><415><742>,<189><225><462><750></box>", "oranges": "<ref>oranges</ref><box><340><288><530><458>,<351><370><612><604>,<519><241><770><482>,<608><480><668><536>,<757><358><896><436></box>", "apples": "<ref>apples</ref><box><442><517><732><752>,<659><411><952><720></... | |
bfl--flux-2-max | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p3.png | Hard__p3 | {"balloons": 11} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly 11 balloons. Counting from left to right, there are 7 fully visible balloons in the foreground (red, yellow, dark blue, light orange, green, pink, silver) and 4 partially hidden balloons behind them (blue, dark orange, light blue, gold). Each of the 11 balloons has a visible string... | PASS | PASS | {"balloons": {"point": 11, "box": 11}} | PASS | {"balloons": 11} | PASS | {"balloons": 11} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"balloons": "<ref>balloons</ref><box><46><299><186><479>,<168><369><301><535>,<168><458><290><554>,<287><341><410><497>,<371><410><486><562>,<434><310><572><486>,<538><420><648><562>,<576><332><704><503>,<674><368><783><523>,<764><415><877><566>,<816><321><952><495></box>"}, "point": {"balloons": null}, "co... | |
bfl--flux-2-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p1.png | Easy__p1 | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly three red apples sitting on the wooden table. One is positioned on the left, one in the middle, and one on the right.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"red apples": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><box><76><313><377><626>,<348><379><670><713>,<628><313><929><630></box>"}, "point": {"red apples": null}, "count_point": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><point><227><471>,<509><546>,<778><474></point>\nTotal number: 3."}, "count_box": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples... | |
bfl--flux-2-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p2.png | Easy__p2 | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are exactly four yellow rubber ducks lined up in a row on the edge of the bathtub. Since the requirement is to have exactly five ducks, the image does not meet the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"yellow rubber ducks": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | FAIL | {"yellow rubber ducks": 4} | FAIL | {"yellow rubber ducks": 4} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><box><63><359><285><576>,<287><356><502><570>,<503><356><718><570>,<717><364><940><582></box>"}, "point": {"yellow rubber ducks": null}, "count_point": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><point><174><467>,<393><463>,<610><463>,<828><4... | |
bfl--flux-2-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p3.png | Easy__p3 | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | Based on the image, there is a row of white, cylindrical candles standing upright on a dark surface. Counting them from left to right, there are exactly four candles visible.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"white candles": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><box><157><273><328><770>,<330><276><496><770>,<500><278><670><770>,<672><278><842><771></box>"}, "point": {"white candles": null}, "count_point": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><point><242><531>,<413><531>,<585><531>,<758><532></point>\nTotal number: 4.... | |
bfl--flux-2-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p1.png | Medium__p1 | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly two orange cats sitting in the foreground and three black dogs sitting in the background. The counts match the specified criteria perfectly.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"orange cats": {"point": 2, "box": 2}, "black dogs": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | PASS | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><box><88><391><509><870>,<503><327><801><864></box>", "black dogs": "<ref>black dogs</ref><box><43><96><377><706>,<372><34><626><522>,<654><90><922><735></box>"}, "point": {"orange cats": null, "black dogs": null}, "count_point": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><... | |
bfl--flux-2-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p2.png | Medium__p2 | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | PASS | Based on a careful examination of the image, there are exactly four red roses visible in the vase: one on the left, one in the front center, one in the upper back, and one on the right. There are also exactly two white daisies with yellow centers tucked between the roses. The counts match the required criteria perfectl... | PASS | PASS | {"red roses": {"point": 4, "box": 4}, "white daisies": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | PASS | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 0} | true | PASS | false | {"detect": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</ref><box><171><139><358><326>,<354><91><564><178>,<400><181><621><373>,<629><144><819><332></box>", "white daisies": "<ref>white daisies</ref><box><334><150><485><298>,<494><132><658><206></box>"}, "point": {"red roses": null, "white daisies": null}, "count_point": {"red roses"... | |
bfl--flux-2-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p3.png | Medium__p3 | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | FAIL | Based on the image, there is exactly one blue butterfly located in the center. However, there are only two yellow butterflies visible, one on the left and one on the right. Since the requirement is for three yellow butterflies, the count is incorrect.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": {"point": 1, "box": 2}, "yellow butterflies": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 2} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 2} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterflies</ref><box><284><334><692><568></box>", "yellow butterflies": "<ref>yellow butterflies</ref><box><161><435><379><689>,<650><421><873><654></box>"}, "point": {"blue butterflies": null, "yellow butterflies": null}, "count_point": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butter... | |
bfl--flux-2-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p1.png | Hard__p1 | {"goldfish": 9} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, I can see 8 goldfish swimming inside the glass bowl. There are three on the left side, two in the middle area, and three on the right side. Since the requirement is to have exactly 9 goldfish, the image does not meet the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"goldfish": {"point": 8, "box": 8}} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 8} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 8} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><box><139><489><351><638>,<140><337><377><471>,<200><639><458><780>,<373><431><613><575>,<446><566><666><704>,<534><666><764><822>,<616><318><832><469>,<692><508><866><644></box>"}, "point": {"goldfish": null}, "count_point": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><point><256><564>... | |
bfl--flux-2-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p2.png | Hard__p2 | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | PASS | Based on the image, there are 3 bananas (one on the left, two on the right), 4 oranges (two clearly visible in the front, one partially visible behind the left apple, and one partially visible behind the right apple), and 2 red apples. The counts match the required 3 bananas, 4 oranges, and 2 apples exactly.
VERDICT: ... | FAIL | FAIL | {"bananas": {"point": 3, "box": 3}, "oranges": {"point": 3, "box": 3}, "apples": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 3, "apples": 2} | FAIL | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 3, "apples": 2} | false | PASS | true | {"detect": {"bananas": "<ref>bananas</ref><box><106><367><394><582>,<567><323><920><458>,<640><424><924><556></box>", "oranges": "<ref>oranges</ref><box><212><432><427><625>,<354><487><594><636>,<357><385><431><488></box>", "apples": "<ref>apples</ref><box><423><320><642><544>,<588><437><826><634></box>"}, "point": {"b... | |
bfl--flux-2-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p3.png | Hard__p3 | {"balloons": 11} | FAIL | Based on a careful count, there are 13 balloons in the image: orange, dark blue, yellow (top), dark green, red (top right), light blue (left), red (center), light green, pink (center right), light blue (right), pink (bottom left), yellow (bottom center), and purple. Since there are 13 balloons instead of the required 1... | FAIL | FAIL | {"balloons": {"point": 13, "box": 13}} | FAIL | {"balloons": 13} | FAIL | {"balloons": 13} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"balloons": "<ref>balloons</ref><box><118><240><284><453>,<146><402><307><589>,<266><639><425><841>,<282><163><446><367>,<312><460><473><658>,<415><320><577><527>,<430><69><596><278>,<455><548><613><758>,<556><194><720><398>,<573><393><730><596>,<656><583><811><776>,<710><226><879><436>,<739><363><904><550>... | |
fal--bria--fast | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p1.png | Easy__p1 | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly three red apples resting on the wooden table. One is positioned in the front left, another in the back left, and the third on the right.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"red apples": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><box><180><382><521><730>,<227><224><540><458>,<502><310><829><651></box>"}, "point": {"red apples": null}, "count_point": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><point><352><558>,<385><340>,<665><482></point>\nTotal number: 3."}, "count_box": {"red apples": "<ref>red apple... | |
fal--bria--fast | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p2.png | Easy__p2 | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | Based on the image, there is a single row of yellow rubber ducks placed on a white shelf. Counting them from left to right, there are exactly 5 ducks present.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": {"point": 5, "box": 5}} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><box><7><463><220><668>,<204><465><404><673>,<404><463><601><674>,<600><465><797><672>,<783><463><994><668></box>"}, "point": {"yellow rubber ducks": null}, "count_point": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><point><114><564>,<304><568... | |
fal--bria--fast | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p3.png | Easy__p3 | {"white candles": 4} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are exactly five lit white candles standing on the dark, reflective surface. Since the criteria require exactly four candles, the image does not meet the requirement.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"white candles": {"point": 5, "box": 5}} | FAIL | {"white candles": 5} | FAIL | {"white candles": 5} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><box><155><342><333><834>,<332><207><482><769>,<391><455><577><855>,<530><280><681><778>,<658><389><850><844></box>"}, "point": {"white candles": null}, "count_point": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><point><244><622>,<406><511>,<483><685>,<606><536>,<754... | |
fal--bria--fast | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p1.png | Medium__p1 | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are exactly 2 orange cats and 2 black dogs. While the number of orange cats meets the requirement, there are only 2 black dogs instead of the requested 3.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"orange cats": {"point": 2, "box": 2}, "black dogs": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 2} | FAIL | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 2} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><box><202><321><369><787>,<440><313><577><775></box>", "black dogs": "<ref>black dogs</ref><box><284><438><516><863>,<552><402><885><811></box>"}, "point": {"orange cats": null, "black dogs": null}, "count_point": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><point><287><550>... | |
fal--bria--fast | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p2.png | Medium__p2 | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are exactly 4 red roses in the vase. However, there are 3 white daisies in the vase (one top left, one top right, one front left), plus an additional white daisy lying outside the vase. Since the number of white daisies in the vase is 3 instead of the required 2, the count differs.
VERDICT: F... | FAIL | FAIL | {"red roses": {"point": 4, "box": 4}, "white daisies": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | FAIL | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 4} | FAIL | {"red roses": 1, "white daisies": 1} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</ref><box><148><290><354><502>,<351><230><574><403>,<478><324><687><558>,<673><271><890><483></box>", "white daisies": "<ref>white daisies</ref><box><220><748><430><935>,<239><156><458><326>,<276><343><522><621>,<526><156><758><339></box>"}, "point": {"red roses": null, "white d... | |
fal--bria--fast | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p3.png | Medium__p3 | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there is exactly 1 blue butterfly resting on the wooden fence in the foreground. In the background, there are exactly 3 yellow butterflies flying above the flowers. The counts match the required criteria.
VERDICT: PASS | FAIL | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": {"point": 1, "box": 1}, "yellow butterflies": {"point": 10, "box": 7}} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 5} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 4} | true | UNSURE | false | {"detect": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterflies</ref><box><410><491><532><587></box>", "yellow butterflies": "<ref>yellow butterflies</ref><box><377><193><438><264>,<411><491><532><587>,<533><194><625><275>,<632><206><682><275>,<754><428><821><503></box>"}, "point": {"blue butterflies": null, "yellow butterflies... | |
fal--bria--fast | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p1.png | Hard__p1 | {"goldfish": 9} | PASS | Based on the image, I can identify the following goldfish:
1. Far left, facing right.
2. Bottom left, facing right.
3. Center, large, facing right.
4. Below center, facing right.
5. Bottom right, facing left.
6. Middle right, facing left.
7. Top right, facing left.
8. Background right, blurry.
9. Background top middle,... | PASS | FAIL | {"goldfish": {"point": 9, "box": 8}} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 8} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 8} | true | FAIL | false | {"detect": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><box><139><394><317><533>,<180><562><311><695>,<308><562><519><694>,<335><424><577><580>,<470><598><688><739>,<603><477><721><613>,<654><403><817><517>,<753><539><863><640></box>"}, "point": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><point><245><460>,<257><622>,<396><614>,<465><515>,<... | |
fal--bria--fast | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p2.png | Hard__p2 | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly 3 bananas visible on the left side of the bowl. In the center and upper right, there are 4 oranges. On the bottom right, there are 2 apples (one mostly green with a red blush, and one mostly red). The counts match the required criteria perfectly.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"bananas": {"point": 3, "box": 3}, "oranges": {"point": 4, "box": 4}, "apples": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | PASS | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | PASS | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"bananas": "<ref>bananas</ref><box><89><154><412><683>,<162><658><308><768>,<222><232><478><798></box>", "oranges": "<ref>oranges</ref><box><340><402><568><626>,<355><223><575><429>,<533><415><670><589>,<618><282><839><489></box>", "apples": "<ref>apples</ref><box><455><580><708><802>,<648><462><895><702></... | |
fal--bria--fast | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p3.png | Hard__p3 | {"balloons": 11} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, I count a total of 15 balloons scattered across the blue sky. This includes various sizes and colors, such as the prominent yellow, red, green, blue, and purple ones, as well as smaller and slightly blurred balloons. Since the count is 15 and not exactly 11, it does not meet... | FAIL | FAIL | {"balloons": {"point": 15, "box": 15}} | FAIL | {"balloons": 15} | FAIL | {"balloons": 15} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"balloons": "<ref>balloons</ref><box><68><681><137><773>,<84><86><162><184>,<89><472><120><511>,<156><426><248><551>,<297><255><369><343>,<352><565><388><612>,<367><70><454><183>,<446><323><530><430>,<474><685><526><756>,<594><512><652><593>,<691><211><767><310>,<767><575><818><645>,<774><431><820><492>,<82... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v4 | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p1.jpg | Easy__p1 | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly three red apples resting on the wooden table. One is positioned on the left, one in the front center, and one towards the back right.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"red apples": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><box><176><331><447><607>,<365><421><668><727>,<464><286><730><542></box>"}, "point": {"red apples": null}, "count_point": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><point><312><471>,<516><574>,<596><412></point>\nTotal number: 3."}, "count_box": {"red apples": "<ref>red apple... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v4 | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p2.jpg | Easy__p2 | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | Based on the image, there is a row of yellow rubber ducks lined up on the white shelf. Counting them from left to right, there are exactly five ducks present.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": {"point": 5, "box": 5}} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><box><68><475><305><716>,<270><480><468><699>,<436><485><612><685>,<582><488><737><673>,<709><491><849><663></box>"}, "point": {"yellow rubber ducks": null}, "count_point": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><point><188><598>,<370><59... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v4 | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p3.jpg | Easy__p3 | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | Based on the image, there is a row of tall, white candles standing upright on a dark, reflective surface against a black background. Counting them from left to right, there are exactly four distinct candles present.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"white candles": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><box><217><207><293><832>,<381><209><455><832>,<544><210><616><832>,<695><213><767><832></box>"}, "point": {"white candles": null}, "count_point": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><point><256><521>,<418><527>,<581><527>,<731><529></point>\nTotal number: 4.... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v4 | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p1.jpg | Medium__p1 | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly two orange cats sitting in the foreground. Behind them, there are exactly three black dogs sitting in a row. The counts match the required criteria perfectly.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"orange cats": {"point": 2, "box": 2}, "black dogs": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | PASS | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><box><147><444><505><844>,<546><437><904><822></box>", "black dogs": "<ref>black dogs</ref><box><0><202><360><774>,<382><173><624><790>,<626><190><993><713></box>"}, "point": {"orange cats": null, "black dogs": null}, "count_point": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</re... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v4 | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p2.jpg | Medium__p2 | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly four red roses (top left, top middle, top right, and bottom left) and exactly two white daisies (middle and bottom right) arranged in the clear glass vase. The counts perfectly match the required criteria.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"red roses": {"point": 4, "box": 4}, "white daisies": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | PASS | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | PASS | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</ref><box><98><140><369><377>,<215><331><521><634>,<373><50><660><243>,<658><158><895><397></box>", "white daisies": "<ref>white daisies</ref><box><433><204><682><407>,<550><335><798><593></box>"}, "point": {"red roses": null, "white daisies": null}, "count_point": {"red roses":... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v4 | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p3.jpg | Medium__p3 | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | FAIL | Based on the image, there is exactly 1 blue butterfly resting on top of a fence post. However, counting along the fence line from left to right, there are 4 yellow butterflies attached to the sides of the posts. Since there are 4 yellow butterflies instead of the required 3, the image does not meet the criteria.
VERDI... | FAIL | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": {"point": 1, "box": 1}, "yellow butterflies": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 4} | FAIL | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 4} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterflies</ref><box><185><260><438><487></box>", "yellow butterflies": "<ref>yellow butterflies</ref><box><288><588><509><813>,<426><496><620><693>,<567><471><743><603>,<709><373><860><492></box>"}, "point": {"blue butterflies": null, "yellow butterflies": null}, "count_poin... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v4 | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p1.jpg | Hard__p1 | {"goldfish": 9} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, there are exactly 8 goldfish visible inside the bowl. Since the requirement is to have exactly 9 goldfish, the image does not meet the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"goldfish": {"point": 8, "box": 8}} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 8} | FAIL | {"goldfish": 8} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><box><21><400><302><630>,<58><203><298><403>,<150><520><563><770>,<193><740><523><921>,<265><298><598><508>,<492><587><840><806>,<612><397><958><592>,<638><198><925><398></box>"}, "point": {"goldfish": null}, "count_point": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><point><161><511>,<... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v4 | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p2.jpg | Hard__p2 | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, I count the following fruit in the bowl:
- Bananas: There appear to be 4 bananas (visible by counting the distinct tips on the left side).
- Oranges: There are 3 oranges visible.
- Apples: There are 2 red apples.
Since the count is 4 bananas, 3 oranges, and 2 apples, it does not match the required ... | FAIL | FAIL | {"bananas": {"point": 3, "box": 4}, "oranges": {"point": 3, "box": 3}, "apples": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"bananas": 4, "oranges": 3, "apples": 2} | FAIL | {"bananas": 4, "oranges": 3, "apples": 2} | false | FAIL | false | {"detect": {"bananas": "<ref>bananas</ref><box><0><257><570><601>,<8><534><110><777>,<77><389><549><797>,<106><533><329><870></box>", "oranges": "<ref>oranges</ref><box><200><673><552><905>,<300><483><615><756>,<552><407><790><622></box>", "apples": "<ref>apples</ref><box><557><592><903><893>,<713><435><1000><739></box... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v4 | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p3.jpg | Hard__p3 | {"balloons": 11} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, there are 12 balloons present. Counting them from top to bottom, left to right: yellow, blue, light pink, orange, red, light pink, green, purple, teal, red, white, and yellow. Since the total is 12 and not exactly 11, the image does not meet the criteria.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"balloons": {"point": 12, "box": 12}} | FAIL | {"balloons": 12} | FAIL | {"balloons": 12} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"balloons": "<ref>balloons</ref><box><159><379><301><541>,<221><208><372><378>,<266><540><402><694>,<299><415><454><599>,<333><283><467><424>,<367><582><491><727>,<404><163><539><318>,<443><329><591><505>,<464><484><604><653>,<531><222><666><372>,<568><389><701><536>,<580><553><714><713></box>"}, "point": {... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-lite | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p1.adcdba83.png | Easy__p1 | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly three red apples arranged in a horizontal line on the wooden table.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"red apples": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><box><105><413><311><628>,<395><418><605><632>,<681><420><895><636></box>"}, "point": {"red apples": null}, "count_point": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><point><206><520>,<499><527>,<787><530></point>\nTotal number: 3."}, "count_box": {"red apples": "<ref>red apple... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-lite | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p2.2e6a991c.png | Easy__p2 | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | Based on the image, there is a glass shelf mounted on a white tiled wall. Lined up on this shelf are yellow rubber ducks. Counting them from left to right, there are exactly five yellow rubber ducks.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": {"point": 5, "box": 5}} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><box><96><431><248><555>,<266><431><411><556>,<437><431><580><557>,<602><432><750><559>,<764><431><913><560></box>"}, "point": {"yellow rubber ducks": null}, "count_point": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><point><171><495>,<339><49... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-lite | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p3.3ced68cc.png | Easy__p3 | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly four white candles standing upright in a row against a dark background.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"white candles": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><box><151><292><274><697>,<342><292><462><698>,<529><294><652><696>,<725><291><848><698></box>"}, "point": {"white candles": null}, "count_point": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><point><211><495>,<402><498>,<591><498>,<786><498></point>\nTotal number: 4.... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-lite | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p1.a2d17eca.png | Medium__p1 | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly two orange cats sitting on the left and three black dogs sitting on the right. The counts match the required criteria perfectly.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"orange cats": {"point": 2, "box": 2}, "black dogs": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | PASS | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><box><64><497><264><759>,<245><494><427><762></box>", "black dogs": "<ref>black dogs</ref><box><354><413><566><746>,<510><389><728><765>,<692><372><972><752></box>"}, "point": {"orange cats": null, "black dogs": null}, "count_point": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</r... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-lite | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p2.82ea23af.png | Medium__p2 | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly four red roses (positioned left, top center, bottom center, and right) and exactly two white daisies (one on the left and one on the right) in the vase. The counts match the required criteria perfectly.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"red roses": {"point": 4, "box": 4}, "white daisies": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | PASS | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | {"red roses": 3, "white daisies": 2} | true | PASS | false | {"detect": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</ref><box><198><326><370><479>,<361><276><561><445>,<383><183><570><293>,<650><254><839><429></box>", "white daisies": "<ref>white daisies</ref><box><213><212><351><368>,<552><184><694><308></box>"}, "point": {"red roses": null, "white daisies": null}, "count_point": {"red roses... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-lite | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p3.9ec3db18.png | Medium__p3 | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there is exactly 1 blue butterfly located on the left side of the fence. To its right, there are exactly 3 yellow butterflies resting on the fence pickets. The counts match the required criteria perfectly.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"blue butterflies": {"point": 1, "box": 1}, "yellow butterflies": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | PASS | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterflies</ref><box><231><456><406><586></box>", "yellow butterflies": "<ref>yellow butterflies</ref><box><440><498><562><589>,<542><436><669><546>,<706><447><828><558></box>"}, "point": {"blue butterflies": null, "yellow butterflies": null}, "count_point": {"blue butterflie... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-lite | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p1.069add78.png | Hard__p1 | {"goldfish": 9} | PASS | Based on a careful examination of the image, I count exactly 9 goldfish swimming inside the fishbowl. There are two in the upper section, four in the middle area, and three in the lower section above the pebbles. All nine fish are clearly visible and distinct.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"goldfish": {"point": 9, "box": 9}} | PASS | {"goldfish": 9} | PASS | {"goldfish": 9} | true | PASS | false | {"detect": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><box><88><395><299><579>,<196><580><382><744>,<220><204><464><362>,<300><724><517><884>,<358><459><604><623>,<395><338><633><481>,<594><219><813><381>,<617><649><841><821>,<634><443><865><600></box>"}, "point": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><point><195><468>,<290><660>,<34... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-lite | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p2.b0347281.png | Hard__p2 | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are 3 bananas, 2 red apples, and 5 oranges (one on the left, one in the back, and three clustered on the right). Since the orange count is 5 instead of the required 4, the criteria are not met.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"bananas": {"point": 3, "box": 3}, "oranges": {"point": 5, "box": 5}, "apples": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 5, "apples": 2} | FAIL | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 5, "apples": 2} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"bananas": "<ref>bananas</ref><box><241><225><460><537>,<335><221><554><543>,<418><222><554><471></box>", "oranges": "<ref>oranges</ref><box><198><480><359><643>,<524><560><697><687>,<571><343><709><443>,<651><506><805><651>,<673><375><838><528></box>", "apples": "<ref>apples</ref><box><321><515><527><689>,... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-lite | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p3.00e6f0b7.png | Hard__p3 | {"balloons": 11} | PASS | Based on a careful examination of the image, I can count the balloons arranged in three loose rows. The top row contains 5 balloons, the middle row contains 3 balloons, and the bottom row contains 3 balloons. This results in a total count of exactly 11 balloons against the blue sky background.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"balloons": {"point": 11, "box": 11}} | PASS | {"balloons": 11} | PASS | {"balloons": 11} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"balloons": "<ref>balloons</ref><box><92><239><168><342>,<176><462><252><559>,<265><668><344><762>,<275><250><352><346>,<470><459><544><551>,<473><191><548><281>,<483><681><560><775>,<668><245><746><341>,<672><654><751><750>,<754><459><827><551>,<836><250><913><346></box>"}, "point": {"balloons": null}, "co... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p1.09f7ae3b.png | Easy__p1 | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly three distinct red apples sitting on the wooden table in the foreground. There are no other apples visible in the scene.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"red apples": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | PASS | {"red apples": 3} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><box><165><381><418><658>,<355><444><644><751>,<594><393><849><678></box>"}, "point": {"red apples": null}, "count_point": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><point><291><521>,<500><597>,<723><536></point>\nTotal number: 3."}, "count_box": {"red apples": "<ref>red apple... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p2.72f61bc4.png | Easy__p2 | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | Based on the image, there is a row of yellow rubber ducks sitting on the top shelf of the wooden stand. Counting them from left to right, there are exactly five ducks. There are no other ducks visible elsewhere in the bathroom.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": {"point": 5, "box": 5}} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | PASS | {"yellow rubber ducks": 5} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><box><240><364><346><476>,<338><367><447><486>,<440><370><554><497>,<548><374><669><508>,<669><376><802><519></box>"}, "point": {"yellow rubber ducks": null}, "count_point": {"yellow rubber ducks": "<ref>yellow rubber ducks</ref><point><293><420>,<393><4... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p3.4ee65816.png | Easy__p3 | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly four white, lit candles standing in a row in the foreground on the dark surface. No other candles are visible.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"white candles": {"point": 4, "box": 4}} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | PASS | {"white candles": 4} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><box><224><481><289><804>,<378><516><458><811>,<535><556><615><812>,<699><542><771><810></box>"}, "point": {"white candles": null}, "count_point": {"white candles": "<ref>white candles</ref><point><257><640>,<417><672>,<576><695>,<735><690></point>\nTotal number: 4.... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p1.0086862e.png | Medium__p1 | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly two orange cats sitting in the foreground. Behind and beside them, there are exactly three black dogs. The counts match the required criteria perfectly.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"orange cats": {"point": 2, "box": 2}, "black dogs": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | PASS | {"orange cats": 2, "black dogs": 3} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</ref><box><45><523><292><844>,<399><535><589><811></box>", "black dogs": "<ref>black dogs</ref><box><191><396><481><831>,<550><448><704><797>,<663><352><974><827></box>"}, "point": {"orange cats": null, "black dogs": null}, "count_point": {"orange cats": "<ref>orange cats</r... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p2.29f9dc74.png | Medium__p2 | {"red roses": 4, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | Based on the image, there are 5 red roses (4 fully bloomed and 1 small red bud in the center) and 2 white daisies in the vase. Since the number of red roses is 5 instead of the requested 4, the count differs from the prompt's requirements.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"red roses": {"point": 5, "box": 5}, "white daisies": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"red roses": 5, "white daisies": 2} | FAIL | {"red roses": 5, "white daisies": 2} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red roses": "<ref>red roses</ref><box><237><257><386><405>,<351><167><502><271>,<426><334><485><401>,<523><344><690><496>,<666><249><795><370></box>", "white daisies": "<ref>white daisies</ref><box><498><247><617><340>,<581><163><699><245></box>"}, "point": {"red roses": null, "white daisies": null}, "coun... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Medium__p3.aa040465.png | Medium__p3 | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | PASS | Based on the image, there is exactly 1 blue butterfly resting on the top rail of the wooden fence. There are exactly 3 yellow butterflies: one on the top rail to the right of the blue butterfly, one on the middle rail, and one on the lower rail. The counts match the required criteria perfectly.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"blue butterflies": {"point": 1, "box": 1}, "yellow butterflies": {"point": 3, "box": 3}} | PASS | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | PASS | {"blue butterflies": 1, "yellow butterflies": 3} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"blue butterflies": "<ref>blue butterflies</ref><box><400><392><596><540></box>", "yellow butterflies": "<ref>yellow butterflies</ref><box><463><656><587><735>,<612><725><756><814>,<637><486><727><570></box>"}, "point": {"blue butterflies": null, "yellow butterflies": null}, "count_point": {"blue butterflie... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p1.76bac345.png | Hard__p1 | {"goldfish": 9} | PASS | Based on the image, I can count the following goldfish:
1. Top left (orange)
2. Middle left (red/white)
3. Bottom left (small orange)
4. Center (white/orange)
5. Upper center (mostly white)
6. Top right (large orange)
7. Middle right (orange/black)
8. Lower middle right (small red/white)
9. Bottom right (orange)
There... | PASS | PASS | {"goldfish": {"point": 9, "box": 9}} | PASS | {"goldfish": 9} | PASS | {"goldfish": 9} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</ref><box><190><467><330><536>,<231><356><388><452>,<245><655><348><710>,<352><514><498><593>,<516><392><627><455>,<636><350><791><435>,<733><566><882><663>,<740><431><869><501>,<759><504><828><554></box>"}, "point": {"goldfish": null}, "count_point": {"goldfish": "<ref>goldfish</... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p2.e4d37ef8.png | Hard__p2 | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | PASS | Based on the image, there are exactly 3 bananas in the center bunch. There are 4 oranges visible: two on the left side and two on the right side. Finally, there are 2 red apples positioned in the front. The counts perfectly match the required criteria.
VERDICT: PASS | PASS | PASS | {"bananas": {"point": 3, "box": 3}, "oranges": {"point": 4, "box": 4}, "apples": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | PASS | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | PASS | {"bananas": 3, "oranges": 4, "apples": 2} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"bananas": "<ref>bananas</ref><box><392><388><508><582>,<440><369><568><603>,<460><397><628><621></box>", "oranges": "<ref>oranges</ref><box><213><530><371><674>,<296><465><403><581>,<574><468><720><589>,<633><555><785><685></box>", "apples": "<ref>apples</ref><box><302><576><486><700>,<486><572><669><702><... | |
fal--bytedance--seedream-v5-pro | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Hard__p3.749fa254.png | Hard__p3 | {"balloons": 11} | FAIL | Based on a careful examination of the image, there are 13 balloons visible. They include red, orange (top), yellow, light green, pale green, light blue, a translucent green one in the center, pinkish-red, purple, dark blue, peach, dark purple, and another orange one on the bottom right. Since the count is 13 and not ex... | FAIL | FAIL | {"balloons": {"point": 13, "box": 13}} | FAIL | {"balloons": 13} | FAIL | {"balloons": 13} | false | null | false | {"detect": {"balloons": "<ref>balloons</ref><box><138><377><308><548>,<229><509><411><685>,<238><292><411><476>,<282><128><459><330>,<340><394><517><595>,<350><626><514><802>,<409><291><584><472>,<456><123><628><332>,<512><421><692><628>,<531><630><713><807>,<581><214><757><419>,<626><511><807><682>,<673><331><852><518... | |
fal--flux-1-schnell | SpatialReasoning_Counting_Easy__p1.db790680.png | Easy__p1 | {"red apples": 3} | FAIL | The image shows exactly two red apples resting on a wooden surface. Since the criteria requires exactly three red apples, the image fails to meet the condition.
VERDICT: FAIL | FAIL | FAIL | {"red apples": {"point": 2, "box": 2}} | FAIL | {"red apples": 2} | FAIL | {"red apples": 2} | true | null | false | {"detect": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><box><314><349><642><683>,<647><365><981><691></box>"}, "point": {"red apples": null}, "count_point": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><point><477><517>,<815><525></point>\nTotal number: 2."}, "count_box": {"red apples": "<ref>red apples</ref><box><313><349><643><685>... |
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio
ImageBench Judge Study
Can an open perception model replace a closed model as an image benchmark judge? This dataset holds the blind human labels, judge verdicts and raw answers from our test of Tencent's WeVisOne-VL-4B against the live ImageBench V1.2 judges.
Write-up: Can an Open Model Grade Our Benchmark?
Result: no switch. WeVisOne tied Gemini 3.1 Pro on Counting (detection 11 right to 13, p = 0.84) and on Negation Easy and Medium (9 to 13, p = 0.52). It lost on Writing accuracy and leaned clearly behind on Attributes Binding. It does not work as a general judge: asked benchmark questions directly, it said FAIL 16 times in 1,533 answers.
Files
| File | Rows | Contents |
|---|---|---|
counting.csv |
728 | Every Counting image from 81 models: Gemini verdict and text, four WeVisOne methods, human label where there is one, raw answers |
other_categories.csv |
4,204 | OCR, Negation, Attributes Binding and direct-question tests against the live verdict |
human_labels.csv |
203 | Every blind label with its round and selection reason |
methods_study.jsonl |
10 | 11 methods on 10 hand-picked hard images, with raw answers |
fingers.csv |
57 | Finger counts on hand crops from the 24-image hands set |
plans/ |
2 | The plans written before each test ran |
Key columns
human_label:PASS,FAILorUNSURE. Empty means the image was not labeled.used_to_choose_methods: true for the 10 images used to pick methods. They are excluded from the Counting score.live_judge,live_verdict: the V1.2 judge and its verdict. The judge is Gemini 3.1 Pro except on Hands (Qwen3.5-122B).raw_answers,wevisone_answer: the model's output. Coordinates are normalized to 0 to 1000.testinother_categories.csv:ocr_word_match,detection_zero_boxes,joint_detection_all_foundordirect_question.
In human_labels.csv, counting_1 covers images where Gemini and the count prompts disagreed, plus controls.
counting_2 covers new disagreements with detection or masks, and can relabel an earlier unsure image. In
counting.csv, human_label holds the latest label. For other_categories, the Writing Hard and Extreme and the
Attributes Binding groups are random samples of 20 disagreements.
Scoring
A verdict is PASS only if every class count equals the prompt's count. Winners were judged on images where the two judges disagreed, with an exact two-sided McNemar test, excluding unsure labels. A win needed p < 0.025 on Counting.
Limits
- All labels come from one reviewer, who saw verdicts only after answering.
- Labels cover disagreements and a few controls, so these numbers compare judges. They do not estimate absolute accuracy.
- The labeled set is enriched for hard images, and agreement on an image does not prove either judge is right.
- The methods study images were hand-picked for difficulty, so its scores are not a ranking.
- Masks and the methods study ran directly with Tencent's package. Full-board detection, OCR and direct questions ran through vLLM.
Images
Images are not included. image_url points to the WebP served by ImageBench. They were generated by third-party
models and remain subject to those models' terms. The CC-BY-4.0 license covers our labels, tables and write-up.
- Downloads last month
- 44