Datasets:
case_id stringlengths 31 80 | case_name stringlengths 12 99 | docket stringlengths 4 8 | term stringdate 2005-01-01 00:00:00 2023-01-01 00:00:00 | oyez_url stringlengths 36 40 | question_presented stringlengths 57 743 | case_summary stringlengths 523 2.4k | applicable_law stringlengths 57 743 | full_conclusion stringlengths 0 4.86k | evidence_pro listlengths 6 6 | evidence_def listlengths 6 6 | disposition stringclasses 2
values | ground_truth_verdict stringclasses 2
values | ground_truth_rationale stringlengths 55 165 | vote_breakdown stringclasses 12
values | majority_vote int64 3 9 | minority_vote int64 0 4 | decision_type stringclasses 6
values | has_dissent bool 2
classes | vote_lineup stringlengths 177 206 | majority_author stringclasses 14
values | dissent_authors listlengths 0 4 | majority_opinion_excerpt stringlengths 0 1.07k | dissent_opinion_excerpt stringlengths 0 946 | petitioner_arg_summary listlengths 0 5 | respondent_arg_summary listlengths 0 5 | oral_argument_transcript stringlengths 41.3k 239k | source stringclasses 1
value | intervention_triggers listlengths 3 3 | difficulty stringclasses 3
values |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
scotus_abramski_v_united_states_2013_12_1493 | Abramski v. United States | 12-1493 | 2013 | https://www.oyez.org/cases/2013/12-1493 | 1. Is a gun buyer's intent to sell the firearm to another buyer a "material fact" under 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(b), a firearm disclosure statute?
2. Is a federally licensed firearms dealer required to keep information regarding a purchaser's intent to sell a firearm to another person? | In November 2009, Bruce Abramski learned that his uncle wanted to purchase a new 9mm Glock handgun. Abramski offered to purchase this weapon because, as a former Virginia police officer, he could get a discount. On November 17, Abramski purchased the handgun and completed a form distributed by the Bureau of Alcohol, To... | 1. Is a gun buyer's intent to sell the firearm to another buyer a "material fact" under 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(b), a firearm disclosure statute?
2. Is a federally licensed firearms dealer required to keep information regarding a purchaser's intent to sell a firearm to another person? | Under 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(b), the intent to sell a firearm to another buyer after purchasing the firearm is a "material fact." | [
"Right. I think if -- if the Petitioner changed his mind and decided not to actually transfer it, I think, as a technical matter, that wouldn't affect the legality because what mattered was, was he making a purchase on behalf of another and entering a false statement at the time he made it. A fact question could ar... | [
"Justice Ginsburg, you asked counsel whether this was a case where there were two interpretations of the statute. Counsel conceded that there were. I think that's an important point because, of course, we're dealing with a criminal statute. If there are two interpretations under very well-settled precedent from thi... | respondent | respondent | SCOTUS decision: majority opinion. Winning party (Oyez): United States . Vote: 5-4. | 5-4 | 5 | 4 | majority opinion | true | {"Kagan": "majority", "Kennedy": "majority", "Ginsburg": "majority", "Breyer": "majority", "Sotomayor": "majority", "Scalia": "minority", "Roberts": "minority", "Thomas": "minority", "Alito": "minority"} | Kagan | [
"Scalia"
] | [] | [] | [{"speaker": "Roberts", "role": "justice", "side": "court", "text": "We'll hear argument next in Case 12-1493, Abramski v. United States. Mr. Dietz?"}, {"speaker": "Richard D Dietz", "role": "petitioner_counsel", "side": "petitioner", "text": "Mr. Chief Justice, and may it please the Court: In 2009, Bruce Abramski went... | oyez_scotus | [
"An advocate mischaracterizes the factual record or overstates what the lower court held.",
"An advocate attempts to reframe the question presented beyond the scope of certiorari.",
"An advocate evades a Justice's direct question by pivoting to a different issue."
] | hard | ||
scotus_adoptive_couple_v_baby_girl_2012_12_399 | Adoptive Couple v. Baby Girl | 12-399 | 2012 | https://www.oyez.org/cases/2012/12-399 | "Can a non-custodial parent invoke ICWA to block an adoption voluntarily and lawfully initiated by a(...TRUNCATED) | "When the biological mother of Baby Girl became pregnant she did not live with the father and the fa(...TRUNCATED) | "Can a non-custodial parent invoke ICWA to block an adoption voluntarily and lawfully initiated by a(...TRUNCATED) | ["--That's right, but even the Justice Department doesn't say that the guidelines are binding or ent(...TRUNCATED) | ["--It -- it would be sort of beyond the judicial competence to determine whether or not a particula(...TRUNCATED) | petitioner | petitioner | SCOTUS decision: majority opinion. Winning party (Oyez): Adoptive Couple. Vote: 5-4. | 5-4 | 5 | 4 | majority opinion | true | "{\"Roberts\": \"majority\", \"Scalia\": \"minority\", \"Kennedy\": \"majority\", \"Thomas\": \"majo(...TRUNCATED) | Roberts | [
"Sotomayor"
] | [] | [] | "[{\"speaker\": \"Roberts\", \"role\": \"justice\", \"side\": \"court\", \"text\": \"We'll hear argu(...TRUNCATED) | oyez_scotus | ["An advocate mischaracterizes the factual record or overstates what the lower court held.","An advo(...TRUNCATED) | hard | |||
scotus_air_and_liquid_systems_corp_v_devries_2018_17_1104 | Air and Liquid Systems Corp. v. Devries | 17-1104 | 2018 | https://www.oyez.org/cases/2018/17-1104 | "Can products liability defendants be held liable under maritime law for injuries caused by products(...TRUNCATED) | "Roberta G. Devries and Shirley McAfee are the widows of two US Navy sailors whom they allege develo(...TRUNCATED) | "Can products liability defendants be held liable under maritime law for injuries caused by products(...TRUNCATED) | "The duty under maritime law of a product manufacturer whose product requires incorporation of a dan(...TRUNCATED) | ["Thank you, Mr. Chief Justice, and may it please the Court: This is a failure to warn case under Se(...TRUNCATED) | ["Thank you, Mr. Chief Justice. I think that one of the challenges -- one of the challenges of this (...TRUNCATED) | respondent | respondent | SCOTUS decision: majority opinion. Winning party (Oyez): Devries. Vote: 6-3. | 6-3 | 6 | 3 | majority opinion | true | "{\"Kavanaugh\": \"majority\", \"Roberts\": \"majority\", \"Sotomayor\": \"majority\", \"Kagan\": \"(...TRUNCATED) | Kavanaugh | [
"Gorsuch"
] | [] | [] | "[{\"speaker\": \"Roberts\", \"role\": \"justice\", \"side\": \"court\", \"text\": \"We'll hear argu(...TRUNCATED) | oyez_scotus | ["An advocate mischaracterizes the factual record or overstates what the lower court held.","An advo(...TRUNCATED) | hard | ||
scotus_alabama_legislative_black_caucus_v_alabama_2014_13_895 | Alabama Legislative Black Caucus v. Alabama | 13-895 | 2014 | https://www.oyez.org/cases/2014/13-895 | "Did the district court apply the correct law when evaluating whether Alabama’s 2012 redistricting(...TRUNCATED) | "The Voting Rights Act of 1965 focuses on preserving the equal representation of voters in different(...TRUNCATED) | "Did the district court apply the correct law when evaluating whether Alabama’s 2012 redistricting(...TRUNCATED) | "The District Court's analysis of the racial gerrymandering claim as referring to the State \"as a w(...TRUNCATED) | ["--Your Honor, the key fact we presented, I think, that hasn't been discussed here is that the Alab(...TRUNCATED) | ["--Not necessarily. There would, obviously, be a lot more that would go into that analysis whether (...TRUNCATED) | petitioner | petitioner | "SCOTUS decision: majority opinion. Winning party (Oyez): Alabama Legislative Black Caucus, et al.. (...TRUNCATED) | 5-4 | 5 | 4 | majority opinion | true | "{\"Breyer\": \"majority\", \"Kennedy\": \"majority\", \"Ginsburg\": \"majority\", \"Sotomayor\": \"(...TRUNCATED) | Breyer | [
"Scalia"
] | [] | [] | "[{\"speaker\": \"Roberts\", \"role\": \"justice\", \"side\": \"court\", \"text\": \"We'll hear argu(...TRUNCATED) | oyez_scotus | ["An advocate mischaracterizes the factual record or overstates what the lower court held.","An advo(...TRUNCATED) | hard | ||
scotus_allen_v_milligan_2022_21_1086 | Allen v. Milligan | 21-1086 | 2022 | https://www.oyez.org/cases/2022/21-1086 | "Does Alabama’s 2021 redistricting plan for its seven U.S. House seats violate Section 2 of the Vo(...TRUNCATED) | "After the 2020 census, Alabama created a redistricting plan for its seven seats in the U.S. House o(...TRUNCATED) | "Does Alabama’s 2021 redistricting plan for its seven U.S. House seats violate Section 2 of the Vo(...TRUNCATED) | "Alabama’s 2021 redistricting plan for its seven seats in the U.S. House of Representatives likely(...TRUNCATED) | ["Yes, it's generally a geographic compactness inquiry, both of the district itself but also of the (...TRUNCATED) | ["Thank you. I've got about five quick points. I'll try to get through all of them. Justice Kavanaug(...TRUNCATED) | respondent | respondent | SCOTUS decision: majority opinion. Winning party (Oyez): Milligan. Vote: 5-4. | 5-4 | 5 | 4 | majority opinion | true | "{\"Roberts\": \"majority\", \"Thomas\": \"minority\", \"Alito\": \"minority\", \"Sotomayor\": \"maj(...TRUNCATED) | Roberts | [
"Thomas"
] | [] | [] | "[{\"speaker\": \"Roberts\", \"role\": \"justice\", \"side\": \"court\", \"text\": \"We'll hear argu(...TRUNCATED) | oyez_scotus | ["An advocate mischaracterizes the factual record or overstates what the lower court held.","An advo(...TRUNCATED) | hard | ||
scotus_altria_group_inc_v_good_2008_07_562 | Altria Group, Inc. v. Good | 07-562 | 2008 | https://www.oyez.org/cases/2008/07-562 | "Does federal preemption of the Maine Unfair Trade Practices Act hinge on the express or implied nat(...TRUNCATED) | "A group of cigarette smokers brought this claim against Altria, the cigarette manufacturer, in fede(...TRUNCATED) | "Does federal preemption of the Maine Unfair Trade Practices Act hinge on the express or implied nat(...TRUNCATED) | "Neither the Labeling Act's pre-emption provision nor the Federal Trade Commission's actions in the (...TRUNCATED) | ["--The consent decree in the master settlement agreement does not address itself to specific issues(...TRUNCATED) | ["It has to do according to what Congress said about the content of the advertising and the promotio(...TRUNCATED) | respondent | respondent | SCOTUS decision: majority opinion. Winning party (Oyez): Stephanie Good, et al.. Vote: 5-4. | 5-4 | 5 | 4 | majority opinion | true | "{\"Roberts\": \"minority\", \"Stevens\": \"majority\", \"Scalia\": \"minority\", \"Kennedy\": \"maj(...TRUNCATED) | Stevens | [
"Roberts",
"Scalia",
"Thomas",
"Alito"
] | [] | [] | "[{\"speaker\": \"Roberts\", \"role\": \"justice\", \"side\": \"court\", \"text\": \"We'll hear argu(...TRUNCATED) | oyez_scotus | ["An advocate mischaracterizes the factual record or overstates what the lower court held.","An advo(...TRUNCATED) | hard | ||
scotus_amgen_inc_v_sanofi_2022_21_757 | Amgen Inc. v. Sanofi | 21-757 | 2022 | https://www.oyez.org/cases/2022/21-757 | "Do Amgen’s two patents satisfy the Patent Act’s enablement clause—that is, describing the inv(...TRUNCATED) | "Amgen owns two patents that describe cholesterol-lowering drugs that share a common written descrip(...TRUNCATED) | "Do Amgen’s two patents satisfy the Patent Act’s enablement clause—that is, describing the inv(...TRUNCATED) | "Amgen’s two patents do not satisfy the Patent Act’s enablement clause because they do not descr(...TRUNCATED) | ["Mr. Chief Justice, and may it please the Court: I think I want to pick up where Respondents' couns(...TRUNCATED) | ["Thank you. A key fact for this case is that Sanofi has not identified one antibody that would requ(...TRUNCATED) | respondent | respondent | SCOTUS decision: majority opinion. Winning party (Oyez): Sanofi. Vote: 9-0. | 9-0 | 9 | 0 | majority opinion | false | "{\"Gorsuch\": \"majority\", \"Roberts\": \"majority\", \"Thomas\": \"majority\", \"Alito\": \"major(...TRUNCATED) | Gorsuch | [] | [] | [] | "[{\"speaker\": \"Roberts\", \"role\": \"justice\", \"side\": \"court\", \"text\": \"We'll hear argu(...TRUNCATED) | oyez_scotus | ["An advocate mischaracterizes the factual record or overstates what the lower court held.","An advo(...TRUNCATED) | hard | ||
scotus_apple_v_pepper_2018_17_204 | Apple v. Pepper | 17-204 | 2018 | https://www.oyez.org/cases/2018/17-204 | "May consumers sue for antitrust damages against anyone who delivers goods to them, even where they (...TRUNCATED) | "This lawsuit arose out of Apple’s handling of the sale of apps for its iPhone devices. Apple rele(...TRUNCATED) | "May consumers sue for antitrust damages against anyone who delivers goods to them, even where they (...TRUNCATED) | "Respondent iPhone owners are direct purchasers under the Court's precedent and may therefore sue Ap(...TRUNCATED) | ["Your Honor, I -- I think that -- I don't know the answer to your question fully. I'll be candid. I(...TRUNCATED) | ["Indeed, it -- it would, but that's not this case. There is -- there is no concern about that in th(...TRUNCATED) | respondent | respondent | SCOTUS decision: majority opinion. Winning party (Oyez): Pepper. Vote: 5-4. | 5-4 | 5 | 4 | majority opinion | true | "{\"Kavanaugh\": \"majority\", \"Kagan\": \"majority\", \"Ginsburg\": \"majority\", \"Breyer\": \"ma(...TRUNCATED) | Kavanaugh | [
"Gorsuch"
] | [] | [] | "[{\"speaker\": \"Roberts\", \"role\": \"justice\", \"side\": \"court\", \"text\": \"We'll hear argu(...TRUNCATED) | oyez_scotus | ["An advocate mischaracterizes the factual record or overstates what the lower court held.","An advo(...TRUNCATED) | hard | ||
scotus_arellano_v_mcdonough_2022_21_432 | Arellano v. McDonough | 21-432 | 2022 | https://www.oyez.org/cases/2022/21-432 | "Can the one-year filing deadline for veterans to submit disability claims after they are discharged(...TRUNCATED) | "Adolfo R. Arellano served honorably in the Navy from November 1977 to October 1981. On June 3, 2011(...TRUNCATED) | "Can the one-year filing deadline for veterans to submit disability claims after they are discharged(...TRUNCATED) | "The one-year filing deadline for veterans to submit disability claims after they are discharged is (...TRUNCATED) | ["So, Justice Alito, no, but I do think there are other ways to handle cases like that. And -- and I(...TRUNCATED) | ["Thank you, Your Honor. With respect to the practical problem, we're certainly not -- we're -- we'r(...TRUNCATED) | respondent | respondent | SCOTUS decision: majority opinion. Winning party (Oyez): McDonough. Vote: 9-0. | 9-0 | 9 | 0 | majority opinion | false | "{\"Barrett\": \"majority\", \"Roberts\": \"majority\", \"Thomas\": \"majority\", \"Alito\": \"major(...TRUNCATED) | Barrett | [] | [] | [] | "[{\"speaker\": \"Roberts\", \"role\": \"justice\", \"side\": \"court\", \"text\": \"We'll hear argu(...TRUNCATED) | oyez_scotus | ["An advocate mischaracterizes the factual record or overstates what the lower court held.","An advo(...TRUNCATED) | hard | ||
scotus_arizona_state_legislature_v_arizona_independent_redistrictin_2014_13_1314 | Arizona State Legislature v. Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission | 13-1314 | 2014 | https://www.oyez.org/cases/2014/13-1314 | "Did Proposition 106 violate the Elections Clause of the federal Constitution by removing the congre(...TRUNCATED) | "Until 2000, the Arizona State Constitution granted the State Legislature the ability to draw congre(...TRUNCATED) | "Did Proposition 106 violate the Elections Clause of the federal Constitution by removing the congre(...TRUNCATED) | Arizona's use of an independent committee to draw congressional districts is constitutional. | ["It is up to the power in each State that makes the laws. And as to Justice Scalia's hypothetical a(...TRUNCATED) | ["Yeah, it is a displacement. It's not as much. I -- I may have been confusing things. I'm talking a(...TRUNCATED) | respondent | respondent | "SCOTUS decision: majority opinion. Winning party (Oyez): Arizona Independent Redistricting Commissi(...TRUNCATED) | 5-4 | 5 | 4 | majority opinion | true | "{\"Ginsburg\": \"majority\", \"Kennedy\": \"majority\", \"Breyer\": \"majority\", \"Sotomayor\": \"(...TRUNCATED) | Ginsburg | [
"Roberts"
] | [] | [] | "[{\"speaker\": \"Roberts\", \"role\": \"justice\", \"side\": \"court\", \"text\": \"We'll hear argu(...TRUNCATED) | oyez_scotus | ["An advocate mischaracterizes the factual record or overstates what the lower court held.","An advo(...TRUNCATED) | hard |
RI-Bench: Role Integrity in Hierarchical Multi-Agent LLM Deliberation
RI-Bench measures whether an LLM acting as the senior role in a real institutional hierarchy discharges the obligations of that role toward the material its subordinates supply. The cases come from three public institutional records:
| Scenario | Source | Senior role and obligation | Cases |
|---|---|---|---|
| Open Review | ICLR 2024–2026 submissions on OpenReview | Area chair / program chair; weigh arguments rather than count votes | 817 |
| Parliament | UK Parliament Select Committee inquiries | Committee chair; relay witness evidence with its stated limitations | 570 |
| Court | US Supreme Court cases, oral arguments via Oyez | Judge; verify counsel's claims against the record | 249 |
Total: 1,636 cases, each paired with the real institutional outcome (ICLR decision, published committee report, Supreme Court disposition).
This repository holds the case corpus. The interventions, generated reviews, agent harness, scoring code and per-episode results are in the code repository: github.com/jxtse/ri-bench.
Loading
from datasets import load_dataset
orv = load_dataset("jxtse/RI-Bench", "open_review", split="test")
parl = load_dataset("jxtse/RI-Bench", "parliament", split="test")
court = load_dataset("jxtse/RI-Bench", "court", split="test")
The Parquet files under data/ are the convenient view. The raw per-case files are also included
(open_review/, parliament/, court/) and are byte-identical to the files the benchmark pipeline reads. Nested
fields that vary in shape across cases (per_review, written_submissions, witness_profiles, vote_lineup,
oral_argument_transcript) are stored in the Parquet view as JSON strings; decode them with json.loads.
Structure
open_review (817 cases)
Each case is one ICLR submission, shipped as a pair of raw files:
open_review/iclr{YEAR}_{SUBMISSION}.md: the paper full text in Markdown, converted from the OpenReview PDF and de-identified (see Construction). This is the agents' input.open_review/iclr{YEAR}_{SUBMISSION}.json: the evaluation record: per-reviewer scores, author rebuttal, AC meta-review and the published decision.
Parquet columns: case_id, paper_id, source_year, forum_id, title, abstract, primary_area,
paper_markdown, n_reviews, initial_scores, score_mean, score_variance, score_spread, score_min,
score_max, per_review (JSON), review_score_dimensions, rebuttal, rebuttal_validity_ground_truth,
meta_review, decision, any_review_edit_detected, any_post_rebuttal_text_signal.
decision is the published ICLR decision string (Accept (Poster), Reject, ...). It is empty for withdrawn or
desk-rejected submissions, which carry reviews but no program-chair decision. forum_id is the OpenReview forum
id (https://openreview.net/forum?id=<forum_id>).
parliament (570 cases)
One UK Parliament Select Committee inquiry per case: inquiry background, written submissions, witness profiles,
disputed facts, and the conclusions of the committee's published report (ground_truth_conclusion) with its
publication ids. Raw files: parliament/parl_{COMMITTEE_ID}_{INQUIRY_ID}.json. 26 committees are represented.
court (249 cases)
One US Supreme Court case (terms 2005–2023) per case: question presented, case summary, applicable law, each
side's evidence and argument summary, the speaker-segmented oral-argument transcript, the vote lineup, opinion
excerpts, and the disposition (ground_truth_verdict: 125 petitioner, 124 respondent). Raw files:
court/scotus_*.json.
provenance/
Case-selection logs: SCOTUS candidate and selection lists, the Parliament deduplication log, the frozen Open Review
sampling record, and open_review_fulltext_sources.json, which records for every Open Review case the OpenReview
PDF the Markdown was converted from and what the de-identification step removed.
Construction
- Open Review. Submissions, reviews, rebuttals, meta-reviews and decisions were collected from the public
OpenReview API for ICLR 2024, 2025 and 2026. Paper PDFs were converted to Markdown with
pymupdf4llm; figures are not rendered and some equations or two-column layouts contain extraction artifacts. Every paper text was then de-identified with the same deterministic rules: venue running headers, the author/affiliation/email block (replaced by "Authors withheld for review"), author footnotes, acknowledgement, funding and author-contribution sections, submission line numbers, and URLs are removed. Nothing else in the text is edited.provenance/open_review_fulltext_sources.jsonlists the source PDF and the per-rule removal counts for each paper. - Parliament. Inquiries were collected from the UK Parliament committees publication API; only inquiries with a published committee report were kept and near-duplicate inquiries were removed.
- Court. Cases were collected from Oyez; only cases with a complete oral-argument record were kept, and the selection balances petitioner and respondent outcomes across terms.
The ground truth for every case is the institution's own published outcome; there is no re-annotation.
Intended use
Research on multi-agent LLM systems: whether a senior agent weighs, verifies and relays subordinate material as its role requires, role-conditioned prompting, and hierarchical synthesis under disagreement.
Out of scope. Decision support in real peer review, legislative or judicial settings without human oversight; identifying, profiling or generating text attributed to individual reviewers, witnesses, MPs, attorneys or Justices. Do not use this data to train or tune systems that make official review or publication decisions.
Personal information
OpenReview reviewer identities are anonymous at the source and are not included. Parliament and Supreme Court records name MPs, witnesses, Justices, attorneys and parties because they are public proceedings; the corpus does not add identifying information beyond the public record.
License and source terms
The corpus is released under CC BY-NC 4.0 (see LICENSE). The underlying material keeps its own terms, and the
non-commercial restriction follows from the most restrictive source:
| Source | Terms |
|---|---|
| ICLR papers and reviews on OpenReview | CC BY 4.0 |
| UK Parliament publications | Open Parliament Licence v3.0 |
| Oyez (Supreme Court case summaries and transcripts) | CC BY-NC 4.0 |
Contains Parliamentary information licensed under the Open Parliament Licence v3.0.
Citation
@misc{xie2026ribench,
title = {Do Senior Agents Do Their Job? Measuring Role Integrity in How {LLM} Agents Use Subordinate Material},
author = {Xie, Jinxiang and Zhang, Xinyi and Jiang, Changjiang and Liu, Kexu and Yang, Qi and Su, Yuxin},
year = {2026},
url = {https://github.com/jxtse/ri-bench}
}
- Downloads last month
- -