Datasets:

jonaskg
/

open-deliberation

source stringclasses 3 values	corpus stringclasses 24 values	record_type stringclasses 7 values	topic stringclasses 110 values	question stringclasses 863 values	text stringlengths 12 700	stance_or_label stringclasses 14 values	agreement_pct float64 33 92 ⌀	extra stringlengths 17 300 ⌀
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	My parents intentionally withheld details of things until I was old enough to understand	Neutral	69	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	Asking my parents what they bought me for Christmas but they withheld that information since they knew it would spoil my experience.	Negative	67	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	In my work setting, when talking to my boss about a situation with a child. There was information my boss had about the background of this child/family, which I understand confidentiality.	Neutral	65	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	Personally, I've had family withhold information from me that I felt was deliberately. This was information concerning the death of my brother.	Neutral	65	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I remember a time where I asked my boss for more information on a certain topic that we had been discussing. She would not talk to me about it and basically blew me off. I was not able to find out her information or even her personal point of view on the subject, she was very dismissive.	Negative	64	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	Perhaps, one instance would be the situation in which a jealous coworker had withheld information, in order to stain my reputation within my workplace	Negative	64	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I can’t think of anything personally, but when my sister was going to therapy I wasn’t allowed to ask details from her therapist because it would go against the rules her therapist holds with doctor patient confidentiality.	Neutral	64	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I was up for a promotion for a position that contained a lot of sensitive information. Although they hinted at my promotion they did not give me details on why it was being done or what my new position encompasses.	Neutral	64	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	Many times in the business world - competitors not wanting to share information about suppliers or customers.	Negative	60	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	My dog went missing when I was pretty young. My parents told me she was let off her leash and ran away. Due to something else we had to move not long after that. I connected the dots later that we had to give up our dog but my parents didn’t want to tell me that.	Negative	60	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I do not really know what or when someone withheld into from me.	Neutral	60	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	There was a time where my friend refused to tell me about why he decided to completely ignore the plans we had previously made. I would later find out that he decided to spend time with a girl instead.	Negative	60	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	When my sisters steered me away from people who harmed me without my knowledge or didn’t tell me when they visited places I loved	Neutral	58	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I asked for sure information at work for a project and the manager from the department didn't share it with me because they were afraid the information would make that team look bad.	Negative	58	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I had called about a my ex husbands medical condition and was told that was information that I was not privy too.	Negative	58	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I can think of at least one instance at an old job where I wasn’t taught how to perform a task despite actively seeking out how to do said task. As for the person who denied teaching me I can only speculate why they refused to do so.	Neutral	58	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	When I was in Sunday School, my pastor refused to answer or consider the questions I had that challenged the things he was saying. As a result I felt my view of my religion and the topics surrounding it were limited.	Negative	58	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	attorneys withheld information about the correct path to take instead gave their opinion in the form as the only option.	Negative	58	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I filed a complaint against a coworker who made a disparaging remark about mental illness and no one would tell me if she was even counseled.	Negative	56	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	Our manager didn't tell us of upcoming pay changes that would negatively affect us.	Negative	56	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	Recently at work, I was working on renewing a policy for a customer, and needed to know if there was any history of loss for the business. I was told there was not but they would get me official documentation to prove it. Time went by and they never sent it, hoping I would approve the renewal without it. I only later f...	Neutral	56	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	Yes. I was trying to get a market value for my home. The information was given to someone to share with me but he didn't share it at my request (pretended he didn't have it).	Neutral	55	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	When my husband and I would fight about something he would discuss it with my mom. Then my mom would have knowledge of what happened and almost test me with it to see if I was telling the truth or not.	Neutral	55	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	When I met with a college admission's officer for an advising appointment, I felt that they avoided telling me what they really thought my chances were of getting into that college.	Negative	55	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	At my junior level at work when my organization merit workers base on their input, contribution and hard work at the end of every month, i was in need of an information that can turn things around for me to win or merit a reward that particular month. Due to the reward and acknowledgement by our superiors, a colleague ...	Neutral	55	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	When promoted, my position had to be filled. I was not able to be a part of the hiring process nor know what types of questions would be asked, what candidates they were interviewing etc. Not a big deal on the outside looking in, but it was sketchy.	Negative	53	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I am an EMT working on an ambulance and my partner and I had a patient we was treating. The patient’s friend had told my partner who is a paramedic, whom also has greater knowledge than an EMT, key information that would have helped me treat the patient better considering the circumstances.	Neutral	53	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I can't really think of much although I think when it comes to the covid shot they were not telling us everything about it	Neutral	53	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I asked one time what is the easiest and painless way to commit suicide and I felt like I shouldn't have easy access to that.	Negative	53	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	Being a woman I've found that men withhold information that they feel might be harmful to me or make me see them in a different light. At the end of the day I'd much prefer complete honestly as compared to sugar coating or shielding. Without complete honesty you can't form a true opinion of anything.	Neutral	51	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I’ve had coworkers who were teaching me to do something deliberately not share certain instances where responses are given incorrectly and how to fix those errors. Specifically whether or not to do those corrections. Not sure if the purpose was to prevent me from performing well	Neutral	51	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I went to a hospital because I was suffering from a disassociative break & suicidality - I asked to enter a behavourial health program, but they said I didn't meet the requirements - I wasn't suicidal enough, in that moment. They called me a cab home, without notifying anyone that I was discharged.	Negative	51	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I felt that my mother deliberately withheld information from me and also turned down my request. I asked her why she did this and refused to answer my question. To this day, I still have no idea why she continues to do this.	Negative	51	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	Yes, when one of my animals died, that information was intentionally kept from me.	Negative	51	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I do not recall a time that has happened	Neutral	51	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	To help you start thinking about the pros and cons of witholding information or refusing a request, I want you to think about what personal experiences you've had with people or systems witholding information or refusing a request which inform your views.	Neutral	51	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I was trying to get information about my mom's surgery and the nurse, who had the information, would not give it to me.	Negative	49	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I honestly don't think I have been a victim of that yet. However, when applying for assistance due to income, i was denied with little or no explanation or knowledge.	Negative	49	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I honestly cannot think of a single occasion where that's happened to me and I'd rather not lie for the sake of a pretty result.	Neutral	49	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	Someone withheld inviting me to a party knowing that people I would be interested in hearing out what they knew about business. The business they would tell me about would be a multi level marketing business and would have me lose time and money. Fortunately theorsn withheld the information after I asked and that was a...	Negative	49	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	My daughter was in the hospital and I was asking to see her medical chart, specifically her electrolyte levels. The Nurse on duty wouldn't provide me that information.	Neutral	49	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	In high school, my teachers refused to teach students sex education with regards to sexual health, reproduction, stds, contraceptives, etc. We were only taught abstinence because it was a religious school. This is an instance where knowledge was withheld because they believed it would encourage "sin" or harm in their m...	Negative	49	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	A doctor told me that they didn't feel like I needed a medical procedure based on their expertise. Turning down my request really saved me pain and anguish later on.	Neutral	49	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	Doctor dismissing other forms of treatment that are not the norm even though there is evidence to to back possible usefulness	Neutral	47	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I’m trading options on stock market. I’m not a professional in this nor I have extensive knowledge of trading. Just started recently. One person that I know who has been trading for a lot of years plus he has a finance degree refused to give me the full answer on one of the spreads that I was trading. He just gave me a...	Neutral	45	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	Yes. I was petitioning outside a restaurant the other day and the restaurant manager told me to leave. I asked if i was not allowed to petition here, she didn't give a yes or no answer and instead said "i'd prefer if you didn't". I again asked if she was saying I was not allowed to do this, again she wouldn't answer ye...	Neutral	45	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	One time that someone withheld information from me was when I was trying to get the answers to a math test. That would be cheating, thus they did not give me the answers.	Negative	44	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	When I was in elementary school, a student from the special needs classroom pulled the fire alarm the morning before we were suppose to leave for a zoo field trip, cancelling the trip. The teachers found out who did it, but would not tell any of the students because they did not want the student to be retaliated agains...	Negative	44	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	I can't think of an instance right now	Neutral	42	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	In the Q&A session, you raise your hand to ask a question about a specific part of the theorem that you found confusing. You're excited to learn more and understand the concept deeply. When you pose your question, the presenter hesitates for a moment and then gives a superficial answer that doesn't address the complexi...	Neutral	42	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you share an instance where you felt someone or something (with more knowledge than you) deliberately withheld information from you or turned down your request?	When I used to live in Arizona a couple years ago a pharmacist refused to provide and sell the Plan B pill because it was against their religious views.	Negative	42	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	One example might be when a person asks the AI about what do in an emergency situation, such as the accidental ingestion of a poisonous substance or a choking incident.	Neutral	70	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	One example would be someone asking the AI assistant for certain conspiracy theories. Another example might be, asking an AI assistant what dosage and how many pills of their medication they should take a day.	Negative	70	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Someone might ask a question or make a request of an AI with the goal of getting said AI to use a racial, or any other type for that matter, slur.	Neutral	69	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	To give information how to sabotage someone elses chances at a job promotion.	Negative	69	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	May be a person asking to bypass a password to someone's phone or computer	Neutral	69	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	High-context situations, like if someone is asking whether they should break up with their partner, or if someone asks whether they should make a certain financial decision.	Neutral	67	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	A person asks an AI assistant how to make methamphetamine in their home on their stove.	Neutral	67	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	If it would harm someone or may cause them to do something that could get them in to trouble	Neutral	67	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	It may be hard to decide if they should provide sensitive personal information that's publicly available. For example if someone wants to know where someone lives, works, names of family members or past addresses. This information could be used to harm the person.	Neutral	67	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	They could ask the AI how to grow or make a substance	Neutral	67	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Someone could ask AI assistant to do something that would give someone undue influence over someone else, such as spreading misinformation designed to sway voters or make certain actions more likely to happen, such as manipulating stock prices.	Negative	65	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	I think if the person asked about says to manipulate people for money. Scamming people has been too common on the internet and it could spread ideas to peoples Minds.	Negative	65	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Instructions on how to create a specific kind of drug. This could have genuine educative purposes, or could be used as self or societal harm	Neutral	63	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	It would be difficult to determine if an AI assistant should review award submissions to narrow down candidates.	Neutral	63	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	A scientist might be doing research on chemicals or materials that would be considered dangerous if searched together.	Neutral	63	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	I think questions that could potentially risk the safety of someone.	Negative	61	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Perhaps asking about sensitive, morally grey information.	Neutral	61	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Whenever an individual is asking about specific medical treatments, outcomes, and diagnoses. They might ask how to treat a certain disease process and get wildly inaccurate information that could lead to their own self-harm.	Neutral	61	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	A person might ask an AI assistant if it should go to the hospital.	Neutral	61	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	If it’s some sort of moral dilemma or someone is talking about harming themselves or others.	Negative	61	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	If someone asks for an address the AI might not be able to find information on things like protective orders which may be violated and cause harm to a victim of DV.	Neutral	59	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Talking about topics relating to personal and medical harm, where maybe someone asks and appears to be asking with good intentions, but is actually trying to find information that can be misused.	Neutral	59	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	If someone were to ask AI for personal and confidential information about someone in the government such as a politician.	Neutral	59	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Wha tcan I do in a current siutaion.	Neutral	57	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	AI should refuse to answer questions that involve immoral solutions or are immoral to ask.	Negative	57	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Asking an AI assistant how to make a cure for cancer for a relative or themselves.	Neutral	56	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	To dig into an employees non public background without permission and cause to determine employment worthyness	Negative	56	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	How to cause a crowd to panic	Neutral	54	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Trying to get into someone’s personal information	Negative	54	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	It might ask an AI to recommend a course of treatment for a rare autoimmune disorder for which not much information is known. They might be desperate for information since doctors are not sure how to help, and although AI can look through all information on the internet, it may not be good to recommend a course of trea...	Neutral	54	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Diagnose with a condition or suggest diagnoses	Neutral	52	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Explain the least painless way to fit	Neutral	52	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Ask the AI to write a tweet or instagram post that is bigoted yet does not get flagged by the app's TOS (Terms of Service).	Neutral	52	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	To show a person pedophile pornography or how to attract young kids for rape	Negative	52	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	To help decide if they should divorce or leave their partner	Neutral	50	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Give out peoples social media profiles or phone numbers	Neutral	50	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Asking how to humanely kill an animal	Neutral	48	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	What is an easy way to commit suicide?	Negative	48	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Instructions to commit crime	Negative	48	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Asking the AI for legal advice	Neutral	48	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	A person might ask an AI assistant to give them the best numbers possible that would guarantee them a win in every lottery game.	Neutral	48	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Give me some ideas of how I can protest against the new policies.	Neutral	48	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	If someone asks the AI to write an example of a school or work paper for them. They could have the AI do the entire assignment, but it could also be used to help illustrate to them how to format their own paper.	Neutral	48	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Asking it to write an essay for a college class.	Neutral	48	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Asking the AI to write an essay or complete a graded school assignment	Neutral	43	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Can you tell me who to vote for in the next presidential election?	Neutral	43	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Find me sales on jewelry.	Neutral	41	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Write a college essay or a thesis for me to pass my classes and graduate	Neutral	39	null
openai_democratic_inputs	CD1_pretest_B	opinion	Public input on AI policy	Can you give an example of something a person might ask an AI assistant to do, where it might be hard to decide if the AI should refuse the requests or withold information?	Write a college essay for them	Neutral	39	null

End of preview. Expand in Data Studio

Open Deliberation

Two related releases in one dataset repo:

Config	What it is	Vote-preserving?	Size
`text_corpus`	Pruned multi-source text (Polis comments + Habermas + OpenAI Remesh)	No — only optional agree/disagree tallies in `extra`	~1.8 MB
`polis_votes`	Polis comments + votes + summary per conversation	Yes — participant×comment vote matrix	~lean pack

from datasets import load_dataset

text = load_dataset("jonaskg/open-deliberation", "text_corpus")
votes = load_dataset("jonaskg/open-deliberation", "polis_votes")

Why two configs?

Polis’s power is the vote matrix: each participant voting agree/disagree/pass on each comment, which enables PCA opinion-group maps. A text-only export loses that geometry.
text_corpus is for NLP / scenario / mediation research.
polis_votes is for computational social choice and opinion-map replication.

`text_corpus` columns

source, corpus, record_type, topic, question, text, stance_or_label, agreement_pct, extra

Sources: Polis comments (CC BY 4.0), Habermas Machine (Science 2024), OpenAI Democratic Inputs / Remesh.

`polis_votes` layout

polis_votes/<conversation_id>/
  comments.csv
  votes.csv
  summary.csv

Lean conversations included (vote matrices for March On and the largest Austria Klimarat dumps omitted to keep the release downloadable). Case study index: compdemocracy.org.

Attribution (Polis)

Data was gathered using the Polis software (compdemocracy.org/polis) and is sub-licensed under CC BY 4.0 with Attribution to The Computational Democracy Project.

Notes

Not an endorsement of political positions in the data.
Habermas / Remesh appear only in text_corpus.

Downloads last month: 31