yesbut_cleaned

The yesbut__x family of the ElliotVL supervised-fine-tuning pool, after VLM cleaning.

images	1,077
QA turns	8,287
answers rewritten by the cleaning pass	1,244
QA created by the cleaning pass (new_qa)	3,997 (48.2%)
shards	2

How this was cleaned

A vision-language model read each image together with its QA and judged the item. The pass is not a filter that only removes rows — it rewrites answers it finds wrong but salvageable, drops what it cannot salvage, and adds QA where the image supports more than the source provided. Each row carries the judge's own record in clean_meta, including the cleaner identity, the policy it applied, and its per-item scores for legibility, richness and coverage.

A large share of the QA here was written by the cleaning pass, not by the original dataset. Across the pool that share runs from roughly half to over 80% of a family's turns, and it is reported in the table above. Those rows have an empty org_answer because no pre-clean original exists. Treat them as model-generated supervision: they were judged against the image, but they are not human annotation, and model-written QA is where formatting defects are most likely.

The effect on the answers that were carried over is substantive rather than cosmetic. In this pool the pass corrects values, not just wording — a curve's critical point restated from 4.00 to 2.00, a computed ratio from 1 to Approximately 1.33 — and for some families it removed the content entirely, which is why those families are absent here rather than published empty.

answer vs org_answer

• answer — the cleaned answer. Train on this.
• org_answer — the pre-cleaning answer from the same (image, question) in the uncleaned pool. It is empty for QA the cleaning pass added, which have no original.

Where the two differ, the difference is the correction. Keeping both makes every edit auditable instead of asking you to take the cleaning on trust.

This dataset supersedes an earlier upload of the same family that was built from the pre-clean pool. That version carried the uncorrected answers and has been deleted.

Schema

• image — HF Image(), renders directly in the dataset viewer
• image_sha256 — content hash of the image
• n_qa — number of turns attached to this image
• qa — list of {question, answer, org_answer}, in source order
• family / clean_meta — provenance and the judge's per-row record

A row with more than one entry in qa is a conversation over a single image, not a set of independent questions — the turns depend on each other and the image belongs to all of them. Keep them together and in order when training.

Parquet row groups are written at ~32 MB so the dataset viewer pages without stalling.

What is NOT claimed

No rejection sampling was run against this family: there is no accept/reject verdict per row, and answer is the cleaned reference rather than a model generation that a string verifier confirmed. For that, use the *_RS_think / *_rejected datasets in this org.

Examples

10 rows taken straight from this dataset. Images are the original files as stored here - no downscaling, no recompression - and every turn is shown in full.

Example 1 — 8 turns on one image

#	question	answer
1	Is this image satirical or non-satirical?	Yes, this image is satirical.
2	Explain why this image is satirical.	The images are funny since they show how the prettiest footwears like high heels, end up causing a lot of physical discomfort to the user, all in the name fashion
3	Compare the left and right sides of this image.	In the left part of the image: a pair of high heeled shoes In the right part of the image: A pair of feet, blistered and red, with bandages
4	What is shown in this image?	The images are funny since they show how the prettiest footwears like high heels, end up causing a lot of physical discomfort to the user, all in the name fashion
5	What text appears at the top of the left page?	YES,
6	What text appears at the top of the right page?	BUT
7	What color are the platform heels shown on the left page?	Pink
8	What physical object is the image depicting?	An open book

Example 2 — 8 turns on one image

#	question	answer (cleaned)	org_answer (pre-judge)
1	Is there satirical content in this image?	Yes, this image is satirical.	(unchanged)
2	What is the satirical meaning behind this image?	The image is funny because the person has a lot of furniture for his computer but none for himself.	(unchanged)
3	Describe what you see in the left and right parts of this image.	In the left part of the image: The image shows a computer desk with two monitors, two speakers on the side, a headphone hanging off the side of the table, a cpu on the floor with lights glowing on the front of the cpu and a very comfortable looking gaming chair. The whole setup looks high end and expensive. In the right part of the image: The image shows a man sleeping on a mattress on the floor, covered by a grey blanket.	In the left part of the image: The image shows a computer desk with two monitors, two speakers on the side, a headphone hanging off the side of the table, a cpu on the floor with lights glowing on the front of the cpu and a very comfortable looking gaming chair. The whole setup looks high end and expensive. In the right part of the image: The image shows a man sleeping on a mattress on the floor. There does not seem to be a bedsheet on the mattress.
4	Describe the content of this image.	The image is a two-panel comic. The left panel shows a high-end gaming setup with dual monitors, a gaming chair, and RGB lighting. The right panel shows a man sleeping on a mattress on the floor in a run-down room.	The image is funny because the person has a lot of furniture for his computer but none for himself.
5	What text appears above the left and right panels respectively?	The text 'YES,' is above the left panel and 'BUT' is above the right panel.	(unchanged)
6	What social media handle is visible in the bottom right corner?	@_yes_but	(unchanged)
7	What color is the keyboard on the desk?	Pink	(unchanged)
8	What color shirt is the man in the right panel wearing?	Blue	(unchanged)

Example 3 — 8 turns on one image

#	question	answer
1	Is this a satirical image?	Yes, this image is satirical.
2	What makes this image funny or satirical?	The image is satirical because while the man overfils his plate with differnt food items, he ends up wasting almost all of it by not eating them or by taking just one bite out of them leaving the rest.
3	What is shown in the left half versus the right half of this image?	In the left part of the image: The image shows a man overfilling his plate with different kinds of food from a self serving station with various items placed on it. In the right part of the image: The image shows a plate full of food items. Most of the items seems untouched and few have been taken a bite from.
4	Provide a description of this image.	The image is satirical because while the man overfils his plate with differnt food items, he ends up wasting almost all of it by not eating them or by taking just one bite out of them leaving the rest.
5	What text appears above the left and right panels respectively?	The text 'YES,' appears above the left panel and 'BUT' appears above the right panel.
6	What social media handle and logo are visible in the bottom right corner?	The handle is '@_yes_but' and there is a logo that says 'Gudim.'
7	What items are on the table next to the plate in the right panel?	There is a fork and a folded napkin on the table.
8	What specific food items can be identified on the plate in the right panel?	The plate contains croissants, a muffin, sausages, and stacked pancakes or flatbreads.

Example 4 — 9 turns on one image

#	question	answer (cleaned)	org_answer (pre-judge)
1	Is this image satirical or non-satirical?	Yes, this image is satirical.	(unchanged)
2	Why is this image considered satirical?	The image is ironic, because in the first image it seems that the woman is praying whole heartedly by bowing down in front of the statue but in the second image the same image is seen posted on the internet, so the woman was just posing for a photo to be posted on internet to gain followers or likes	(unchanged)
3	Describe what you see in the left and right parts of this image.	In the left part of the image: a woman is seen praying before the Buddha statue with closed hands. In the right part of the image: a zoomed-out view reveals the woman is actually holding a phone to take a photo, posted on social media with hashtags.	In the left part of the image: a woman is seen praying before the Buddha statue with closed hands In the right part of the image: a photo of a woman, praying before the Buddha statue with closed hands, posted on some social media with hashtags
4	Describe the content of this image.	The image is ironic, because in the first image it seems that the woman is praying whole heartedly by bowing down in front of the statue but in the second image the same image is seen posted on the internet, so the woman was just posing for a photo to be posted on internet to gain followers or likes	(unchanged)
5	What text appears above the left and right panels respectively?	The text 'YES,' appears above the left panel and 'BUT' appears above the right panel.	(unchanged)
6	What hashtag is displayed below the image in the right panel?	#praying	(unchanged)
7	What is the Instagram handle visible in the bottom right corner?	@_yes_but	(unchanged)
8	What specific action is the woman performing in the right panel that contradicts the left panel?	She is holding a phone up to take a selfie or photo.	(unchanged)
9	What color are the pants the woman is wearing in the right panel?	Purple	(unchanged)

Example 5 — 9 turns on one image

#	question	answer (cleaned)	org_answer (pre-judge)
1	Is this image satirical or non-satirical?	Yes, this image is satirical.	(unchanged)
2	Why is this image considered satirical?	The image is ironic, because it shows over modernization, earlier the size was printed on the label attached to the clothes but now for knowing even the basic details about the cloth like size there is some barcode or QR code attached which need to be scanned by some mobile phone or electronic device	(unchanged)
3	Compare the left and right sides of this image.	In the left part of the image, a single t-shirt hangs on a hanger with a tag inside the collar reading 'SIZE'. In the right part, the same t-shirt hangs with a tag attached to the outside featuring a barcode.	In the left part of the image: some t-shirts of the same type hanging together with size printed on the tag In the right part of the image: some t-shirts of the same type hanging together with some
4	What does this image depict?	The image is ironic, because it shows over modernization, earlier the size was printed on the label attached to the clothes but now for knowing even the basic details about the cloth like size there is some barcode or QR code attached which need to be scanned by some mobile phone or electronic device	(unchanged)
5	What text appears above the left and right panels respectively?	The text 'YES,' is above the left panel and 'BUT' is above the right panel.	(unchanged)
6	What is written on the white tag inside the collar of the shirt in the left panel?	The word 'SIZE'.	(unchanged)
7	What feature is visible on the hanging tag in the right panel?	A barcode.	(unchanged)
8	What Instagram handle is visible in the bottom right corner?	@_yes_but	(unchanged)
9	What logo appears in the very bottom right corner?	A speech bubble containing the text 'Gudim.'	(unchanged)

Example 6 — 7 turns on one image

#	question	answer
1	Is there satirical content in this image?	Yes, this image is satirical.
2	Why is this image considered satirical?	The images are funny since they show how pet owners cannot enjoy any tasty food like pizza without sharing with their pets. The look from the pets makes the owner too guilty if he does not share his food
3	Describe the contrast between the left and right parts of this image.	In the left part of the image: It is a man eating a pizza In the right part of the image: It is a pet dog with teary eyes
4	What is shown in this image?	The images are funny since they show how pet owners cannot enjoy any tasty food like pizza without sharing with their pets. The look from the pets makes the owner too guilty if he does not share his food
5	What text appears at the top of the left and right sections?	The text 'YES,' is above the left section and 'BUT' is above the right section.
6	What social media handle and logo are visible in the bottom right corner?	The Instagram handle '@_yes_but' and a 'Gudim' logo are visible.
7	What is the artistic style of the figure on the left?	It is a black and white low-poly or geometric silhouette.

Example 7 — 9 turns on one image

#	question	answer (cleaned)	org_answer (pre-judge)
1	Does this image contain satire or humor?	Yes, this image is satirical.	(unchanged)
2	Explain the humor or irony in this image.	The image is ironic, as the person is holding the game console to play a game during the flight. However, the person is unable to play the game, as the game requires internet (as is the case with many modern games), and internet is unavailable in many flights.	The image is ironic, as the person is holding the game console to play a game during the flight. However, the person is unable to play the game, as the game requires internet (as is the case with many modern games), and internet is unavailable in many lights.
3	Describe the contrast between the left and right parts of this image.	In the left part of the image: a person sitting in a flight seat, with a gaming console in the person's hands. In the right part of the image: a person sitting in a flight seat, with a gaming console in the person's hands, with a message which shows "No Internet, the game does not work without internet".	(unchanged)
4	Provide a description of this image.	The image is ironic, as the person is holding the game console to play a game during the flight. However, the person is unable to play the game, as the game requires internet (as is the case with many modern games), and internet is unavailable in many flights.	The image is ironic, as the person is holding the game console to play a game during the flight. However, the person is unable to play the game, as the game requires internet (as is the case with many modern games), and internet is unavailable in many lights.
5	What large text appears at the top of the left and right panels respectively?	The text 'YES,' is above the left panel and 'BUT' is above the right panel.	(unchanged)
6	What specific error message is displayed on the game console screen?	The screen displays 'No Internet the game does not work without internet' with a 'Close Game' button.	(unchanged)
7	What Instagram handle is visible in the bottom right corner?	_yes_but	(unchanged)
8	What logo is visible in the very bottom right corner?	A logo that says 'Gudim.'	(unchanged)
9	What object is sitting on the floor in front of the woman in the left panel?	A suitcase.	(unchanged)

Example 8 — 6 turns on one image

#	question	answer
1	Would you classify this image as satirical?	Yes, this image is satirical.
2	Why is this image considered satirical?	The image is ironic, because even after when the skateboard scooters are available for someone to ride but the road has many potholes that it is not suitable to ride the scooters on such roads
3	What do you see in each half of this image?	In the left part of the image: many skateboard scooters parked together In the right part of the image: a straight road with many potholes
4	Describe the content of this image.	The image is ironic, because even after when the skateboard scooters are available for someone to ride but the road has many potholes that it is not suitable to ride the scooters on such roads
5	What text is written at the top of the left and right panels?	The text 'YES,' is on the left and 'BUT' is on the right.
6	What is the color palette of the image?	The image is in black and white (grayscale).

Example 9 — 8 turns on one image

#	question	answer (cleaned)	org_answer (pre-judge)
1	Is this image satirical or non-satirical?	Yes, this image is satirical.	(unchanged)
2	Describe the satirical element in this image.	The image is ironic, because even after when the skateboard scooters are available for someone to ride but the road has many potholes that it is not suitable to ride the scooters on such roads	(unchanged)
3	Describe the contrast between the left and right parts of this image.	In the left part of the image: a collage of black silhouettes of people and scooters. In the right part of the image: a straight road with many potholes.	In the left part of the image: many skateboard scooters parked together In the right part of the image: a straight road with many potholes
4	What does this image depict?	The image is ironic, because even after when the skateboard scooters are available for someone to ride but the road has many potholes that it is not suitable to ride the scooters on such roads	(unchanged)
5	What text appears at the top of the left and right sections respectively?	The text 'YES,' appears on the left and 'BUT' appears on the right.	(unchanged)
6	What visual style is used for the figures and objects on the left side?	They are depicted as black silhouettes against a white background.	(unchanged)
7	What animals are visible in the upper part of the left section?	There are silhouettes of birds flying.	(unchanged)
8	What road marking is visible down the center of the damaged road?	A dashed white line.	(unchanged)

Example 10 — 6 turns on one image

#	question	answer
1	Is this a satirical image?	Yes, this image is satirical.
2	Why is this image considered satirical?	The image is funny, as there are two electrical sockets side-by-side, but the adapter is shaped in such a way, that if two adapters are inserted into the two sockets, they will butt into each other, leading to inconvenience.
3	What is shown in the left half versus the right half of this image?	In the left part of the image: two electrical sockets side by side In the right part of the image: an electrical adapter
4	Describe what you see in this image.	The image is funny, as there are two electrical sockets side-by-side, but the adapter is shaped in such a way, that if two adapters are inserted into the two sockets, they will butt into each other, leading to inconvenience.
5	What text appears at the top of the image?	The text 'YES,' appears above the left panel and 'BUT' appears above the right panel.
6	What specific type of electrical sockets are shown on the left?	They are Schuko sockets, characterized by the round holes and grounding clips on the sides.