title string | method string | models dict | headline string | unmeasured list | supersedes_note string | axes list | not_in_this_comparison dict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SOV-SIGNAL honest arena — base vs sovereign, measured 2026-08-09 from Cowork (CPU/llama.cpp) | labels pulled from each dataset; one-word answer; regex extraction; temp 0; unparsed reported not scored wrong; Wilson 95%; McNemar exact on discordant pairs. | {
"sovereign": "csoai/sov-gate-ft2 (Qwen2 494M)",
"base": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-1.5B-Instruct"
} | base Qwen wins or ties all 9 governance axes; separated (beats sovereign) on governance (n=237, p~0). Sovereigns win refusal/safety framing (xstest, AgentHarm) not shown here. | [] | Replaces sov-signal-leaderboard-v1, whose sov33-v11 'champion' art5=0.944 / gov=0.489 match BASE Qwen's measured scores, not any runnable sovereign. Re-run sov33-v11 independently before crediting it; do not assume. | [
{
"axis": "governance",
"gspc_id": "gspc-gov",
"sov_gate_ft2_494m": {
"acc": 0.249,
"wilson95": [
0.198,
0.308
],
"n": 237
},
"base_qwen2_5_1p5b": {
"acc": 0.54,
"wilson95": [
0.476,
0.602
],
"n": 237
},
"win... | {
"note": "gspc-care (n=201), gspc-swarm (n=41), gspc-det (n=34) are NOT unmeasured -- all clear usable_n>=30 and are measured on HF item banks. They were simply not run in THIS base-vs-sov-gate-ft2 comparison session. Correcting a stale claim inherited from an earlier draft that miscounted these as n=1/6/6.",
"axe... |
- Downloads last month
- 22