Datasets:

avihayamor
/

tripmatch-ai-plan-comparisons

alternative_id string	trip_id string	destination string	country_or_category string	source_description string	duration_days int64	companions string	budget string	pace string	route_type string	primary_theme string	secondary_theme string	difficulty string	recommended_season string	main_ideas string	daily_plan_original string	daily_plan_alternative string	daily_plan_alternative_rich string	created_by_model string	generator_model string	generator_family string	alternative_model string	model_family string	prompt_version string	prompt_techniques string	generation_seed int64	generation_parameters string	gpu_hardware string	generation_seconds_batch_share float64	repair_attempted bool	validation_passed bool	validation_errors string	original_word_count int64	alternative_word_count int64	richness_ratio float64	original_alternative_similarity float64	days_with_all_required_sections int64	source_dataset string	source_config string	source_revision string	postprocessing_version string	full_run_id string	source_partition string	model_data_label string	is_gemma_generated bool	is_qwen_generated bool	comparison_id string	judge_model string	judge_family string	comparison_json string	json_valid bool	overall_winner string	confidence float64	overall_explanation string	comparison_prompt_version string	comparison_engine string	comparison_generation_seconds_batch_share float64	comparison_gpu_hardware string	comparison_source_repo string	comparison_source_config string	comparison_source_revision string	comparison_run_id string	budget_alignment_original_score int64	budget_alignment_alternative_score int64	budget_alignment_winner string	budget_alignment_reason string	pace_alignment_original_score int64	pace_alignment_alternative_score int64	pace_alignment_winner string	pace_alignment_reason string	duration_feasibility_original_score int64	duration_feasibility_alternative_score int64	duration_feasibility_winner string	duration_feasibility_reason string	companion_suitability_original_score int64	companion_suitability_alternative_score int64	companion_suitability_winner string	companion_suitability_reason string	practical_organization_original_score int64	practical_organization_alternative_score int64	practical_organization_winner string	practical_organization_reason string	destination_specificity_original_score int64	destination_specificity_alternative_score int64	destination_specificity_winner string	destination_specificity_reason string
TRIP-00001::qwen	TRIP-00001	Poipet (Cambodia)	South/East Asia	Poipet, known for its vibrant border-crossing activities and dynamic markets, offers a unique glimpse into the day-to-day hustle and cultural melting pot at the Cambodian-Thai frontier.	10	family with children	premium	active	destination	food	culture	moderate	autumn	A active, premium 10-day food trip for family with children, supported by culture experiences at a moderate activity level.	Day 1: Arrive in Poipet (Cambodia), settle in, take an orientation walk and enjoy a local meal. Day 2: Visit a cultural district or museum. Day 3: Visit a market or take a self-guided food walk. Day 4: Visit a cultural district or museum. Day 5: Visit a market or take a self-guided food walk. Day 6: Visit a cultural di...	Day 1: Arrival and Border Orientation Morning: Arrive in Poipet via land crossing from Thailand; transfer to a centrally located, family-friendly hotel with child-accessible rooms and private balconies. Begin with a brief guided orientation walk near the Thai-Cambodian border checkpoint, focusing on cross-border trade ...	Day 1: Arrival and Border Orientation Morning: Arrive in Poipet via land crossing from Thailand; transfer to a centrally located, family-friendly hotel with child-accessible rooms and private balconies. Begin with a brief guided orientation walk near the Thai-Cambodian border checkpoint, focusing on cross-border trade ...	Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	full-alternative-daily-plan-v4.0-vllm-0.25.1	["role_prompting", "source_grounding", "constraint_table", "few_shot_structured_output", "quality_rubric", "explicit_improvement_baseline", "negative_constraints", "silent_self_critique", "controlled_sampling", "single_llm_repair_pass"]	20,269,114	{"engine": "vllm-0.25.1", "max_tokens": 1200, "repair_seed_offset": 100000, "repetition_penalty": 1.08, "temperature": 0.72, "top_p": 0.9}	NVIDIA A10G	1.035	false	true	[]	106	704	6.642	0.0536	10	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-dataset	trip_plans	bda5ce774fe16b127a743b592487689847d68f27	canonical-labels-v1	full-10k-v1	qwen	QWEN_GENERATED	false	true	TRIP-00001::gemma-3	Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	{"alternative_created_by_model": "Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507", "confidence": 0.95, "criteria": {"budget_alignment": {"alternative_score": 5, "original_score": 4, "reason": "Plan B incorporates more expensive activities like guided excursions, cooking classes, and private transportation, aligning better with a...	true	alternative	0.95	Plan B demonstrates a stronger alignment with the trip's premium budget, active pace, family-focused requirements, and practical organization. While Plan A is adequate, Plan B’s detailed itinerary and emphasis on immersive experiences create a more compelling and suitable trip for the specified criteria.	amit-cross-model-json-judge-v1.0	vllm-0.25.1-structured-outputs	0.5858	NVIDIA A10G	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-daily-plan-alternatives	full	3f0b612c8a44b57a787a406c03f54b982428459b	cross-model-judge-10k-v1	4	5	alternative	Plan B incorporates more expensive activities like guided excursions, cooking classes, and private transportation, aligning better with a premium budget.	3	5	alternative	Plan B offers a more structured and engaging pace with specific activities and excursions, catering to an active family.	4	4	tie	Both plans cover the 10-day duration adequately, though Plan B packs more activities into each day.	4	5	alternative	Plan B is specifically designed with family-friendly elements like child-accessible rooms, cooking workshops, and age-appropriate tasks, making it more suitable for children.	3	5	alternative	Plan B provides detailed logistical information (transportation arrangements, hotel requirements, timing considerations) demonstrating superior practical organization.	5	5	tie	Both plans are highly specific to Poipet, Cambodia, detailing local food, culture, and activities.
TRIP-00002::gemma	TRIP-00002	Thimphu (Bhutan)	South/East Asia	Thimphu, the capital of Bhutan, intrigues visitors with its unique blend of traditional Bhutanese culture and modern development, set against a backdrop of lush greenery and historic dzongs.	3	family with children	mid-range	balanced	destination	culture	food	easy	spring	A balanced, mid-range 3-day culture trip for family with children, supported by food experiences at a easy activity level.	Day 1: Arrive in Thimphu (Bhutan), settle in, take an orientation walk and enjoy a local meal. Day 2: Sample regional food in a local area. Day 3: Use the final morning for a nearby highlight and depart with buffer time.	Day 1: Settling into Thimphu’s Heart Morning: Arrive at Paro International Airport (PBH). Transfer to Thimphu via private vehicle – approximately 1.5 hours. Check into a comfortable hotel near the city center offering family suites, allowing for space and relaxation. Begin with a gentle stroll along K Dzong Road, obser...	Day 1: Settling into Thimphu’s Heart Morning: Arrive at Paro International Airport (PBH). Transfer to Thimphu via private vehicle – approximately 1.5 hours. Check into a comfortable hotel near the city center offering family suites, allowing for space and relaxation. Begin with a gentle stroll along K Dzong Road, obser...	Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it	google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	full-alternative-daily-plan-v4.0-vllm-0.25.1	["role_prompting", "source_grounding", "constraint_table", "few_shot_structured_output", "quality_rubric", "explicit_improvement_baseline", "negative_constraints", "silent_self_critique", "controlled_sampling", "single_llm_repair_pass"]	20,266,612	{"engine": "vllm-0.25.1", "max_tokens": 1200, "repair_seed_offset": 100000, "repetition_penalty": 1.08, "temperature": 0.72, "top_p": 0.9}	NVIDIA A10G	0.852	false	true	[]	41	426	10.39	0.034	3	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-dataset	trip_plans	bda5ce774fe16b127a743b592487689847d68f27	canonical-labels-v1	full-10k-v1	gemma	GEMMA_GENERATED	true	false	TRIP-00002::qwen-3	Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	{"alternative_created_by_model": "Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it", "confidence": 0.96, "criteria": {"budget_alignment": {"alternative_score": 4, "original_score": 3, "reason": "Plan B includes specific, affordable cultural and food experiences (e.g., textile workshop, museum visits) with clear cost-saving suggestions l...	true	alternative	0.96	Plan B outperforms Plan A across all criteria by offering a richer, more structured, and family-centered experience that respects the trip’s constraints—especially pace, companion suitability, and practicality—while maintaining a mid-range budget. Its detailed, context-aware structure and child-friendly elements make i...	amit-cross-model-json-judge-v1.0	vllm-0.25.1-structured-outputs	0.9197	NVIDIA A10G	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-daily-plan-alternatives	full	3f0b612c8a44b57a787a406c03f54b982428459b	cross-model-judge-10k-v1	3	4	alternative	Plan B includes specific, affordable cultural and food experiences (e.g., textile workshop, museum visits) with clear cost-saving suggestions like local snacks and pre-arranged transport, aligning better with mid-range budget constraints.	2	5	alternative	Plan B maintains a balanced, easy pace with clearly defined rest periods, family-friendly activities (e.g., textile workshop, museum), and avoids rushed transitions, matching the 'balanced' pace requirement for children and families.	3	5	alternative	Plan B fills all three days with structured, realistic activities and buffer times, including practical notes on transport and weather, making it fully feasible within 3 days without overloading the schedule.	2	5	alternative	Plan B explicitly includes child-friendly elements (e.g., hands-on textile workshop, rural homes museum, games) and avoids religious site fatigue, making it suitable for a family with children.	2	5	alternative	Plan B provides detailed practical notes on customs, dress codes, transportation, and timing, with clear warnings and logistics, offering better real-world usability for travelers.	3	5	alternative	Plan B deeply integrates Thimphu-specific landmarks (Tashichho Dzong, Buddha Dordenma, Changangkha Lhakhang) and local culture (textiles, food, masked dances), demonstrating strong alignment with Bhutan’s cultural and geographic context.
TRIP-00003::qwen	TRIP-00003	Hot Springs (Arkansas)	USA	Hot Springs, Arkansas is renowned for its rich history, therapeutic hot springs, and beautiful historic architecture, making it a unique destination steeped in wellness and cultural heritage.	5	family with children	mid-range	active	destination	culture	wellness	easy	winter	A active, mid-range 5-day culture trip for family with children, supported by wellness experiences at a easy activity level.	Day 1: Arrive in Hot Springs (Arkansas), settle in, take an orientation walk and enjoy a local meal. Day 2: Schedule a slow morning and restorative activity. Day 3: Schedule a slow morning and restorative activity. Day 4: Explore local traditions and architecture. Day 5: Use the final morning for a nearby highlight and...	Day 1: Arrival and Thermal Orientation Morning: Arrive in Hot Springs, check into a centrally located mid-range hotel near the historic district, and begin with a brief guided walking tour of the Main Street area focusing on 19th-century architecture and early wellness history. Afternoon: Visit the National Park Servic...	Day 1: Arrival and Thermal Orientation Morning: Arrive in Hot Springs, check into a centrally located mid-range hotel near the historic district, and begin with a brief guided walking tour of the Main Street area focusing on 19th-century architecture and early wellness history. Afternoon: Visit the National Park Servic...	Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	full-alternative-daily-plan-v4.0-vllm-0.25.1	["role_prompting", "source_grounding", "constraint_table", "few_shot_structured_output", "quality_rubric", "explicit_improvement_baseline", "negative_constraints", "silent_self_critique", "controlled_sampling", "single_llm_repair_pass"]	20,270,225	{"engine": "vllm-0.25.1", "max_tokens": 1200, "repair_seed_offset": 100000, "repetition_penalty": 1.08, "temperature": 0.72, "top_p": 0.9}	NVIDIA A10G	0.918	false	true	[]	58	421	7.259	0.0456	5	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-dataset	trip_plans	bda5ce774fe16b127a743b592487689847d68f27	canonical-labels-v1	full-10k-v1	qwen	QWEN_GENERATED	false	true	TRIP-00003::gemma-3	Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	{"alternative_created_by_model": "Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507", "confidence": 0.85, "criteria": {"budget_alignment": {"alternative_score": 4, "original_score": 4, "reason": "Both plans suggest mid-range options (local meals, modest activities) without specifying costs, aligning with the budget constraint.", "w...	true	alternative	0.85	Plan B demonstrates a more comprehensive and family-oriented approach to the trip, incorporating specific activities and practical considerations that align more closely with the stated constraints and desired experience. While Plan A is adequate, Plan B’s detailed scheduling and focus on cultural and wellness elements...	amit-cross-model-json-judge-v1.0	vllm-0.25.1-structured-outputs	0.5858	NVIDIA A10G	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-daily-plan-alternatives	full	3f0b612c8a44b57a787a406c03f54b982428459b	cross-model-judge-10k-v1	4	4	tie	Both plans suggest mid-range options (local meals, modest activities) without specifying costs, aligning with the budget constraint.	3	5	alternative	Plan B explicitly incorporates 'slow mornings' and 'leisurely' activities, aligning better with the 'active' and 'easy' pace requirements.	4	4	tie	Both plans cover the 5-day duration with a reasonable distribution of activities, allowing for buffer time.	4	5	alternative	Plan B includes specific activities geared towards families with children (thermal soak, craft workshop, storytelling) and emphasizes family-friendly dining.	3	5	alternative	Plan B provides more detailed practical notes (registration, layers, transportation) enhancing the trip's organization and preparedness.	5	5	tie	Both plans focus on Hot Springs and its specific attractions (National Park, Cultural Center, Botanical Garden) fulfilling the destination requirement.
TRIP-00004::qwen	TRIP-00004	Chicago (Illinois)	USA	Chicago, a vibrant metropolis celebrated for its world-class cultural attractions, stunning architecture, and rich musical heritage, epitomizes the pioneering American spirit with its dynamic energy and bold skyline.	14	couple	mid-range	relaxed	destination	culture	scenic	moderate	winter	A relaxed, mid-range 14-day culture trip for couple, supported by scenic experiences at a moderate activity level.	Day 1: Arrive in Chicago (Illinois), settle in, take an orientation walk and enjoy a local meal. Day 2: Seek out panoramic views and photo stops. Day 3: Visit a cultural district or museum. Day 4: Take a scenic route between the day's main areas. Day 5: Seek out panoramic views and photo stops. Day 6: Take a scenic rou...	Day 1: Arrival and Neighborhood Orientation Morning: Arrive at O’Hare International Airport, transfer to downtown via train or shared shuttle, check into a centrally located mid-range hotel near the Loop. Complete a light orientation walk along State Street, observing historic buildings and street art. Afternoon: Strol...	Day 1: Arrival and Neighborhood Orientation Morning: Arrive at O’Hare International Airport, transfer to downtown via train or shared shuttle, check into a centrally located mid-range hotel near the Loop. Complete a light orientation walk along State Street, observing historic buildings and street art. Afternoon: Strol...	Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	full-alternative-daily-plan-v4.0-vllm-0.25.1	["role_prompting", "source_grounding", "constraint_table", "few_shot_structured_output", "quality_rubric", "explicit_improvement_baseline", "negative_constraints", "silent_self_critique", "controlled_sampling", "single_llm_repair_pass"]	20,272,122	{"engine": "vllm-0.25.1", "max_tokens": 1200, "repair_seed_offset": 100000, "repetition_penalty": 1.08, "temperature": 0.72, "top_p": 0.9}	NVIDIA A10G	0.881	true	false	["incorrect_day_count_or_sequence", "day_13_missing_practical_note"]	142	845	5.951	0.022	12	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-dataset	trip_plans	bda5ce774fe16b127a743b592487689847d68f27	canonical-labels-v1	full-10k-v1	qwen	QWEN_GENERATED	false	true	TRIP-00004::gemma-3	Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	{"alternative_created_by_model": "Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507", "confidence": 0.95, "criteria": {"budget_alignment": {"alternative_score": 4, "original_score": 4, "reason": "Both plans suggest mid-range activities and dining, though Plan B provides more specific cost-saving suggestions (e.g., free museum exhib...	true	alternative	0.95	Plan B demonstrates a stronger alignment with the trip constraints, particularly regarding pace, practicality, and companion suitability. While Plan A is adequate, Plan B’s detailed itinerary and logistical considerations make it a more well-organized and enjoyable experience for the couple traveling to Chicago.	amit-cross-model-json-judge-v1.0	vllm-0.25.1-structured-outputs	0.5858	NVIDIA A10G	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-daily-plan-alternatives	full	3f0b612c8a44b57a787a406c03f54b982428459b	cross-model-judge-10k-v1	4	4	tie	Both plans suggest mid-range activities and dining, though Plan B provides more specific cost-saving suggestions (e.g., free museum exhibits, picnics). Neither is extravagant, aligning with the budget constraint.	3	5	alternative	Plan B offers a more structured and detailed pace with specific activities and timings, aligning better with the 'relaxed' pace requirement. Plan A is very open-ended.	5	5	tie	Both plans cover the 14-day duration with a reasonable number of activities per day, allowing for flexibility and buffer time as noted.	4	5	alternative	Plan B includes more couple-friendly activities like river cruises, jazz performances, and cozy dinners, catering to the companions' preferences more directly.	3	5	alternative	Plan B provides more practical details like booking museum tickets in advance, suggesting specific restaurants, and noting potential delays (airport transfers). Plan A is very general.	5	5	tie	Both plans focus entirely on Chicago and its attractions, fulfilling the destination requirement effectively. Plan B provides more specific locations and experiences within the city.
TRIP-00005::qwen	TRIP-00005	Visby (Sweden)	Europe	Visby, often referred to as 'the city of roses and ruins', is a unique historical gem on the limestone island of Gotland, Sweden, featuring a rich medieval history complemented by vibrant summer nightlife and tranquil natural settings.	4	seniors	budget	balanced	destination	nature	wellness	moderate	summer	A balanced, budget 4-day nature trip for seniors, supported by wellness experiences at a moderate activity level.	Day 1: Arrive in Visby (Sweden), settle in, take an orientation walk and enjoy a local meal. Day 2: Enjoy an unhurried scenic afternoon. Day 3: Enjoy viewpoints and a comfortable outdoor activity. Day 4: Use the final morning for a nearby highlight and depart with buffer time.	Day 1: Arrival and Coastal Orientation Morning: Arrive in Visby via public transport, transfer to a centrally located, affordable guesthouse near the harbor. Check in, rest, and take a gentle walk along the coastal path from the old town to the western shore—flat terrain, well-maintained, with views of the sea and hist...	Day 1: Arrival and Coastal Orientation Morning: Arrive in Visby via public transport, transfer to a centrally located, affordable guesthouse near the harbor. Check in, rest, and take a gentle walk along the coastal path from the old town to the western shore—flat terrain, well-maintained, with views of the sea and hist...	Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	full-alternative-daily-plan-v4.0-vllm-0.25.1	["role_prompting", "source_grounding", "constraint_table", "few_shot_structured_output", "quality_rubric", "explicit_improvement_baseline", "negative_constraints", "silent_self_critique", "controlled_sampling", "single_llm_repair_pass"]	20,268,092	{"engine": "vllm-0.25.1", "max_tokens": 1200, "repair_seed_offset": 100000, "repetition_penalty": 1.08, "temperature": 0.72, "top_p": 0.9}	NVIDIA A10G	0.826	false	true	[]	48	486	10.125	0.0372	4	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-dataset	trip_plans	bda5ce774fe16b127a743b592487689847d68f27	canonical-labels-v1	full-10k-v1	qwen	QWEN_GENERATED	false	true	TRIP-00005::gemma-3	Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	{"alternative_created_by_model": "Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507", "confidence": 0.85, "criteria": {"budget_alignment": {"alternative_score": 4, "original_score": 4, "reason": "Both plans suggest budget-friendly options (local meals, affordable guesthouse).", "winner": "tie"}, "companion_suitability": {"alternati...	true	alternative	0.85	Plan B offers a more detailed, paced, and practically organized itinerary specifically tailored to the needs and preferences of senior travelers, aligning better with the trip constraints and theme. While Plan A is adequate, Plan B demonstrates a stronger commitment to the wellness and nature aspects of the trip.	amit-cross-model-json-judge-v1.0	vllm-0.25.1-structured-outputs	0.5858	NVIDIA A10G	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-daily-plan-alternatives	full	3f0b612c8a44b57a787a406c03f54b982428459b	cross-model-judge-10k-v1	4	4	tie	Both plans suggest budget-friendly options (local meals, affordable guesthouse).	3	5	alternative	Plan B provides a more detailed and paced itinerary with specific activities and rest breaks.	5	4	original	Plan A's 'flexible' days allow for more buffer and spontaneity, fitting the 4-day duration better.	4	5	alternative	Plan B explicitly considers senior companions with gentle hikes, accessible routes, and frequent rest stops.	3	5	alternative	Plan B includes detailed practical notes regarding transportation, footwear, and potential challenges, enhancing preparedness.	5	5	tie	Both plans accurately incorporate Visby's key features – coastal walks, historical sites, and natural landscapes.
TRIP-00006::gemma	TRIP-00006	Lake Alfred (Florida)	USA	Lake Alfred is a quaint town in Florida with rich history and natural charm, perfect for those looking to explore the culturally vibrant small-town America and enjoy nature.	5	seniors	premium	balanced	destination	culture	scenic	easy	summer	A balanced, premium 5-day culture trip for seniors, supported by scenic experiences at a easy activity level.	Day 1: Arrive in Lake Alfred (Florida), settle in, take an orientation walk and enjoy a local meal. Day 2: Take a scenic route between the day's main areas. Day 3: Visit a cultural district or museum. Day 4: Visit a cultural district or museum. Day 5: Use the final morning for a nearby highlight and depart with buffer ...	Day 1: Settling into Historic Lake Alfred Morning: Arrive at Orlando International Airport (MCO). Pre-booked private transfer to the ‘The Pines,’ a boutique hotel known for its southern hospitality and proximity to downtown Lake Alfred. Settle in and enjoy a welcome refreshment – iced tea and light pastries. Afternoon:...	Day 1: Settling into Historic Lake Alfred Morning: Arrive at Orlando International Airport (MCO). Pre-booked private transfer to the ‘The Pines,’ a boutique hotel known for its southern hospitality and proximity to downtown Lake Alfred. Settle in and enjoy a welcome refreshment – iced tea and light pastries. Afternoon:...	Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it	google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	full-alternative-daily-plan-v4.0-vllm-0.25.1	["role_prompting", "source_grounding", "constraint_table", "few_shot_structured_output", "quality_rubric", "explicit_improvement_baseline", "negative_constraints", "silent_self_critique", "controlled_sampling", "single_llm_repair_pass"]	20,263,271	{"engine": "vllm-0.25.1", "max_tokens": 1200, "repair_seed_offset": 100000, "repetition_penalty": 1.08, "temperature": 0.72, "top_p": 0.9}	NVIDIA A10G	0.868	false	true	[]	60	516	8.6	0.039	5	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-dataset	trip_plans	bda5ce774fe16b127a743b592487689847d68f27	canonical-labels-v1	full-10k-v1	gemma	GEMMA_GENERATED	true	false	TRIP-00006::qwen-3	Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	{"alternative_created_by_model": "Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it", "confidence": 0.98, "criteria": {"budget_alignment": {"alternative_score": 5, "original_score": 3, "reason": "The alternative includes premium accommodations, curated dining, guided tours, and workshops, all aligned with a premium budget. The original l...	true	alternative	0.98	The alternative plan excels in all key criteria by providing premium, accessible, and well-organized experiences tailored to seniors. It aligns precisely with the trip constraints—premium budget, balanced pace, easy difficulty, cultural and scenic themes, and companion suitability—while offering practical, evidence-bas...	amit-cross-model-json-judge-v1.0	vllm-0.25.1-structured-outputs	0.9197	NVIDIA A10G	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-daily-plan-alternatives	full	3f0b612c8a44b57a787a406c03f54b982428459b	cross-model-judge-10k-v1	3	5	alternative	The alternative includes premium accommodations, curated dining, guided tours, and workshops, all aligned with a premium budget. The original lacks specific cost indicators and offers generic activities that may not reflect premium spending.	3	5	alternative	The alternative maintains a balanced, easy pace with structured, low-intensity activities and ample rest periods. The original lacks detail on activity duration or breaks, risking a rushed or monotonous flow.	5	5	tie	Both plans fit within 5 days with realistic daily distributions. The alternative adds more detail but does not extend or compress the timeline beyond feasibility.	3	5	alternative	The alternative emphasizes accessibility, includes mobility considerations, offers indoor backups, and features low-physical-demand activities ideal for seniors. The original lacks such accommodations or considerations.	2	5	alternative	The alternative provides detailed practical notes on logistics, weather contingencies, mobility, and advance bookings—critical for seniors. The original offers no such guidance or risk mitigation.	3	5	alternative	The alternative deeply integrates Lake Alfred’s cultural and scenic landmarks (e.g., Heritage Museum, Harmony Hall, Greenway Trail) with local context. The original is vague and generic in its references.
TRIP-00007::qwen	TRIP-00007	Százhalombatta (Hungary)	Europe	Százhalombatta is distinguished for its enlightening archaeological sites and tranquil river views, offering a unique glimpse into Hungary's ancient past.	14	friends	premium	relaxed	destination	scenic	city	moderate	autumn	A relaxed, premium 14-day scenic trip for friends, supported by city experiences at a moderate activity level.	Day 1: Arrive in Százhalombatta (Hungary), settle in, take an orientation walk and enjoy a local meal. Day 2: Walk through central neighborhoods and public spaces. Day 3: Take a scenic route between the day's main areas. Day 4: Take a scenic route between the day's main areas. Day 5: Combine a landmark area with local ...	Day 1: Arrival and Riverfront Orientation Morning: Arrive at Százhalombatta’s central train station, transfer to a centrally located boutique hotel near the Danube Riverbank, and check in. Begin with a brief guided orientation walk along the river promenade, focusing on the historic bridge and surrounding greenery. Aft...	Day 1: Arrival and Riverfront Orientation Morning: Arrive at Százhalombatta’s central train station, transfer to a centrally located boutique hotel near the Danube Riverbank, and check in. Begin with a brief guided orientation walk along the river promenade, focusing on the historic bridge and surrounding greenery. Aft...	Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	full-alternative-daily-plan-v4.0-vllm-0.25.1	["role_prompting", "source_grounding", "constraint_table", "few_shot_structured_output", "quality_rubric", "explicit_improvement_baseline", "negative_constraints", "silent_self_critique", "controlled_sampling", "single_llm_repair_pass"]	20,268,763	{"engine": "vllm-0.25.1", "max_tokens": 1200, "repair_seed_offset": 100000, "repetition_penalty": 1.08, "temperature": 0.72, "top_p": 0.9}	NVIDIA A10G	0.85	true	false	["incorrect_day_count_or_sequence", "day_13_missing_afternoon", "day_13_missing_evening", "day_13_missing_practical_note", "day_13_too_brief"]	158	835	5.285	0.0637	12	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-dataset	trip_plans	bda5ce774fe16b127a743b592487689847d68f27	canonical-labels-v1	full-10k-v1	qwen	QWEN_GENERATED	false	true	TRIP-00007::gemma-3	Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	{"alternative_created_by_model": "Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507", "confidence": 0.95, "criteria": {"budget_alignment": {"alternative_score": 4, "original_score": 4, "reason": "Both plans are suitable for a premium budget, focusing on local experiences and potentially higher-end dining. Neither explicitly details...	true	alternative	0.95	Plan B is the superior itinerary due to its greater level of detail, practical organization, and specific engagement with the destination's unique features and local culture. While Plan A is adequate, it lacks the depth and structure needed to fully realize a premium, scenic, and relaxed trip for friends.	amit-cross-model-json-judge-v1.0	vllm-0.25.1-structured-outputs	0.5858	NVIDIA A10G	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-daily-plan-alternatives	full	3f0b612c8a44b57a787a406c03f54b982428459b	cross-model-judge-10k-v1	4	4	tie	Both plans are suitable for a premium budget, focusing on local experiences and potentially higher-end dining. Neither explicitly details costs, but the activities align with a premium travel style.	3	5	alternative	Plan B offers a more detailed and structured pace with specific activities and timings, aligning better with a relaxed but engaging itinerary. Plan A is very open-ended.	5	5	tie	Both plans cover the 14-day duration with a reasonable number of activities per day, allowing for flexibility and buffer time. The detailed schedule in Plan B provides better structure.	4	4	tie	Both plans cater to a group of friends with a mix of activities – cultural, scenic, and social. The suggested meals and optional events are suitable for a group.	2	5	alternative	Plan B is significantly more organized, providing specific locations, reservation notes, and practical details (e.g., museum hours, market timing). Plan A is vague and lacks logistical information.	4	5	alternative	Plan B demonstrates a deeper understanding of Százhalombatta, incorporating local landmarks, traditions, and specific locations (e.g., Archaeological Museum, river trail). Plan A is very generic.
TRIP-00008::gemma	TRIP-00008	Homer (Alaska)	USA	Homer, Alaska, renowned as the 'Halibut Fishing Capital of the World' and the 'End of the Road,' offers stunning natural landscapes and is a paradise for fishing enthusiasts and nature lovers alike.	3	couple	premium	balanced	destination	nature	wellness	easy	winter	A balanced, premium 3-day nature trip for couple, supported by wellness experiences at a easy activity level.	Day 1: Arrive in Homer (Alaska), settle in, take an orientation walk and enjoy a local meal. Day 2: Enjoy viewpoints and a comfortable outdoor activity. Day 3: Use the final morning for a nearby highlight and depart with buffer time.	Day 1: Arrival & Coastal Charm Morning: Arrive at King Salmon Airport (KNG). Private transfer via a comfortable, climate-controlled SUV to a boutique hotel overlooking Beluga Point - "The Mariner’s Rest," known for its understated elegance and proximity to the harbor. Settle in and unpack, taking advantage of the hotel...	Day 1: Arrival & Coastal Charm Morning: Arrive at King Salmon Airport (KNG). Private transfer via a comfortable, climate-controlled SUV to a boutique hotel overlooking Beluga Point - "The Mariner’s Rest," known for its understated elegance and proximity to the harbor. Settle in and unpack, taking advantage of the hotel...	Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it	google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	full-alternative-daily-plan-v4.0-vllm-0.25.1	["role_prompting", "source_grounding", "constraint_table", "few_shot_structured_output", "quality_rubric", "explicit_improvement_baseline", "negative_constraints", "silent_self_critique", "controlled_sampling", "single_llm_repair_pass"]	20,264,930	{"engine": "vllm-0.25.1", "max_tokens": 1200, "repair_seed_offset": 100000, "repetition_penalty": 1.08, "temperature": 0.72, "top_p": 0.9}	NVIDIA A10G	1.012	true	true	[]	41	433	10.561	0.035	3	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-dataset	trip_plans	bda5ce774fe16b127a743b592487689847d68f27	canonical-labels-v1	full-10k-v1	gemma	GEMMA_GENERATED	true	false	TRIP-00008::qwen-3	Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	{"alternative_created_by_model": "Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it", "confidence": 0.96, "criteria": {"budget_alignment": {"alternative_score": 5, "original_score": 4, "reason": "The alternative includes premium accommodations, guided experiences, and specialty dining—all aligned with a premium budget. The original lacks...	true	alternative	0.96	While both plans meet the duration and theme requirements, the alternative significantly outperforms in budget alignment, pace, companion suitability, and practical organization. It provides rich, specific, and well-structured experiences that align with the premium, balanced, nature-and-wellness focus for a couple in ...	amit-cross-model-json-judge-v1.0	vllm-0.25.1-structured-outputs	0.9197	NVIDIA A10G	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-daily-plan-alternatives	full	3f0b612c8a44b57a787a406c03f54b982428459b	cross-model-judge-10k-v1	4	5	alternative	The alternative includes premium accommodations, guided experiences, and specialty dining—all aligned with a premium budget. The original lacks specific cost indicators, making it less transparent in budget alignment.	3	5	alternative	The alternative maintains a balanced pace with structured, moderate activities (fishing, spa, scenic drives) and wellness elements (massage, ranger talks), matching the 'balanced' pace requirement. The original is vague and lacks activity pacing detail.	5	5	tie	Both plans fit within 3 days with realistic daily distributions. The alternative adds more detail but does not extend beyond the duration; all activities are time-bound and feasible.	3	5	alternative	The alternative features shared experiences (dining, walks, fishing, spa) designed for couples, with social and romantic elements (acoustic music, shared views). The original lacks shared activities and is too passive for a couple-focused trip.	2	5	alternative	The alternative includes detailed practical notes (weather checks, gear, transfers, layout awareness), clear logistics, and activity-specific advice—critical for a premium, easy-paced trip. The original offers no such detail.	3	5	alternative	The alternative references specific locations (Beluga Point, Exit Glacier, Crowley Lake Store, North Star Charters) and local institutions, demonstrating deep alignment with Homer’s geography and culture. The original is generic and lacks destination-specific anchoring.
TRIP-00009::gemma	TRIP-00009	Arusha (Tanzania)	Africa/Middle East	Arusha, nestled at the foot of Mount Meru, is a vibrant gateway to Tanzania's wildlife and natural beauty, offering a blend of adventure, culture, and relaxation.	14	friends	budget	balanced	destination	culture	history	challenging	autumn	A balanced, budget 14-day culture trip for friends, supported by history experiences at a challenging activity level.	Day 1: Arrive in Arusha (Tanzania), settle in, take an orientation walk and enjoy a local meal. Day 2: Visit a cultural district or museum. Day 3: Learn about the destination's historical context. Day 4: Visit a cultural district or museum. Day 5: Explore local traditions and architecture. Day 6: Explore a historic qua...	Day 1: Arrival and Arusha Foundations Morning: Arrive at Kilimanjaro International Airport (JRO). Transfer via pre-booked shared shuttle service to accommodation in the Mzuri neighborhood – a developing area known for its mix of local residents and guesthouses catering to independent travelers. Settle in and unpack. Af...	Day 1: Arrival and Arusha Foundations Morning: Arrive at Kilimanjaro International Airport (JRO). Transfer via pre-booked shared shuttle service to accommodation in the Mzuri neighborhood – a developing area known for its mix of local residents and guesthouses catering to independent travelers. Settle in and unpack. Af...	Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it	google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	full-alternative-daily-plan-v4.0-vllm-0.25.1	["role_prompting", "source_grounding", "constraint_table", "few_shot_structured_output", "quality_rubric", "explicit_improvement_baseline", "negative_constraints", "silent_self_critique", "controlled_sampling", "single_llm_repair_pass"]	20,266,476	{"engine": "vllm-0.25.1", "max_tokens": 1200, "repair_seed_offset": 100000, "repetition_penalty": 1.08, "temperature": 0.72, "top_p": 0.9}	NVIDIA A10G	1.046	true	false	["incorrect_day_count_or_sequence", "day_9_missing_practical_note"]	126	859	6.817	0.0363	8	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-dataset	trip_plans	bda5ce774fe16b127a743b592487689847d68f27	canonical-labels-v1	full-10k-v1	gemma	GEMMA_GENERATED	true	false	TRIP-00009::qwen-3	Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	{"alternative_created_by_model": "Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it", "confidence": 0.96, "criteria": {"budget_alignment": {"alternative_score": 5, "original_score": 3, "reason": "Plan B includes specific, low-cost activities (e.g., shared shuttle, market visits, community volunteering) and avoids expensive excursions lik...	true	alternative	0.96	Plan B excels in budget alignment, pace, companion engagement, and practical realism by embedding culturally relevant, locally grounded activities with clear logistical support. While Plan A provides a structured framework, it lacks depth, interactivity, and contextual authenticity required for a challenging, culture-f...	amit-cross-model-json-judge-v1.0	vllm-0.25.1-structured-outputs	0.9197	NVIDIA A10G	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-daily-plan-alternatives	full	3f0b612c8a44b57a787a406c03f54b982428459b	cross-model-judge-10k-v1	3	5	alternative	Plan B includes specific, low-cost activities (e.g., shared shuttle, market visits, community volunteering) and avoids expensive excursions like full-day hikes or museums with admission fees, aligning better with a budget constraint.	2	5	alternative	Plan A follows a repetitive, passive pattern with no variation in activity intensity, while Plan B balances active, immersive experiences with rest days and cultural engagement, matching the 'challenging' pace requirement.	5	5	tie	Both plans fit within 14 days with realistic daily allocations; no activity exceeds typical daily capacity or requires impractical scheduling.	3	5	alternative	Plan B fosters group interaction through shared meals, language classes, and casual gatherings, enhancing social bonding among friends; Plan A lacks meaningful shared experiences or group activities.	2	5	alternative	Plan B includes detailed practical notes on transport, language, dress, safety, and local customs, making it more actionable and safer for travelers; Plan A offers no such guidance.	3	5	alternative	Plan B integrates authentic cultural and historical elements tied to Arusha’s geography and communities (e.g., Mzuri neighborhood, Meru, Maasai village, Chagga cuisine), offering deeper destination-specific immersion.
TRIP-00010::qwen	TRIP-00010	Phnom Penh (Cambodia)	South/East Asia	Phnom Penh, the heart of Cambodia, is a city rich in history and culture, laced with remnants of French colonial architecture, bustling markets, and a vibrant riverside promenade.	5	seniors	mid-range	relaxed	destination	city	culture	moderate	summer	A relaxed, mid-range 5-day city trip for seniors, supported by culture experiences at a moderate activity level.	Day 1: Arrive in Phnom Penh (Cambodia), settle in, take an orientation walk and enjoy a local meal. Day 2: Combine a landmark area with local street life. Day 3: Walk through central neighborhoods and public spaces. Day 4: Walk through central neighborhoods and public spaces. Day 5: Use the final morning for a nearby h...	Day 1: Arrival and Riverside Orientation Morning: Arrive at Phnom Penh International Airport, transfer to a centrally located mid-range hotel via shared shuttle or taxi. Check in, rest, and review the itinerary. Afternoon: Begin a slow-paced walk along the Tonlé Sap River promenade, passing local fishing boats and open...	Day 1: Arrival and Riverside Orientation Morning: Arrive at Phnom Penh International Airport, transfer to a centrally located mid-range hotel via shared shuttle or taxi. Check in, rest, and review the itinerary. Afternoon: Begin a slow-paced walk along the Tonlé Sap River promenade, passing local fishing boats and open...	Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	full-alternative-daily-plan-v4.0-vllm-0.25.1	["role_prompting", "source_grounding", "constraint_table", "few_shot_structured_output", "quality_rubric", "explicit_improvement_baseline", "negative_constraints", "silent_self_critique", "controlled_sampling", "single_llm_repair_pass"]	20,269,691	{"engine": "vllm-0.25.1", "max_tokens": 1200, "repair_seed_offset": 100000, "repetition_penalty": 1.08, "temperature": 0.72, "top_p": 0.9}	NVIDIA A10G	0.932	false	true	[]	61	477	7.82	0.0386	5	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-dataset	trip_plans	bda5ce774fe16b127a743b592487689847d68f27	canonical-labels-v1	full-10k-v1	qwen	QWEN_GENERATED	false	true	TRIP-00010::gemma-3	Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	{"alternative_created_by_model": "Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507", "confidence": 0.85, "criteria": {"budget_alignment": {"alternative_score": 4, "original_score": 4, "reason": "Both plans suggest mid-range options (local meals, family restaurants) without specifying exorbitant costs.", "winner": "tie"}, "companio...	true	alternative	0.85	Plan B demonstrates a stronger alignment with the trip constraints, particularly regarding the pace and practical considerations for senior companions. While both plans are reasonable, Plan B’s detailed notes and explicit accommodations for the group’s needs make it the superior option.	amit-cross-model-json-judge-v1.0	vllm-0.25.1-structured-outputs	0.5858	NVIDIA A10G	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-daily-plan-alternatives	full	3f0b612c8a44b57a787a406c03f54b982428459b	cross-model-judge-10k-v1	4	4	tie	Both plans suggest mid-range options (local meals, family restaurants) without specifying exorbitant costs.	3	5	alternative	Plan B explicitly incorporates 'slow-paced walks,' 'leisurely walks,' and 'rest breaks,' aligning better with the relaxed pace requirement for seniors.	4	4	tie	Both plans cover the 5-day duration with a final buffer day, offering sufficient time for activities.	3	5	alternative	Plan B includes more frequent and explicit consideration for senior companions, such as 'minimal walking,' 'seated breaks,' and 'emotional sensitivity' regarding the memorial visits.	3	5	alternative	Plan B provides more detailed practical notes, including booking museum tickets, managing crowded markets, and suggesting transportation options, enhancing its organization.	4	4	tie	Both plans focus on Phnom Penh and include relevant landmarks and cultural sites.
TRIP-00011::gemma	TRIP-00011	Rome (Italy)	Europe	Rome, the Eternal City, enchants with its rich history, opulent architecture, vibrant street life, and a timeless influence on art, culture, and religion.	14	seniors	budget	active	destination	culture	food	moderate	summer	A active, budget 14-day culture trip for seniors, supported by food experiences at a moderate activity level.	Day 1: Arrive in Rome (Italy), settle in, take an orientation walk and enjoy a local meal. Day 2: Visit a cultural district or museum. Day 3: Visit a cultural district or museum. Day 4: Visit a cultural district or museum. Day 5: Sample regional food in a local area. Day 6: Explore local traditions and architecture. Da...	Day 1: Arrival and Trastevere Welcome Morning: Arrive at Leonardo da Vinci–Fiumicino Airport (FCO). Utilize a pre-booked private transfer service to the charming Trastevere neighborhood – known for its narrow cobbled lanes and artisan workshops. Settle into your hotel, ideally located for easy access to key sites. Afte...	Day 1: Arrival and Trastevere Welcome Morning: Arrive at Leonardo da Vinci–Fiumicino Airport (FCO). Utilize a pre-booked private transfer service to the charming Trastevere neighborhood – known for its narrow cobbled lanes and artisan workshops. Settle into your hotel, ideally located for easy access to key sites. Afte...	Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it	google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	google/gemma-3-4b-it	Gemma 3	full-alternative-daily-plan-v4.0-vllm-0.25.1	["role_prompting", "source_grounding", "constraint_table", "few_shot_structured_output", "quality_rubric", "explicit_improvement_baseline", "negative_constraints", "silent_self_critique", "controlled_sampling", "single_llm_repair_pass"]	20,263,797	{"engine": "vllm-0.25.1", "max_tokens": 1200, "repair_seed_offset": 100000, "repetition_penalty": 1.08, "temperature": 0.72, "top_p": 0.9}	NVIDIA A10G	0.968	true	false	["incorrect_day_count_or_sequence"]	132	874	6.621	0.0272	9	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-dataset	trip_plans	bda5ce774fe16b127a743b592487689847d68f27	canonical-labels-v1	full-10k-v1	gemma	GEMMA_GENERATED	true	false	TRIP-00011::qwen-3	Qwen 3 \| Qwen/Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507	Qwen 3	{"alternative_created_by_model": "Gemma 3 \| google/gemma-3-4b-it", "confidence": 0.96, "criteria": {"budget_alignment": {"alternative_score": 4, "original_score": 3, "reason": "Plan B includes specific cost-saving measures like pre-booked transfers, Roma Pass, and timed entries, which reduce hidden expenses and optimiz...	true	alternative	0.96	Plan B outperforms Plan A across all criteria by providing a senior-friendly, well-structured, and practically grounded itinerary that respects pace, accessibility, and cultural authenticity. It aligns with the trip’s theme of culture and food while being budget-conscious and feasible for active seniors. The detailed p...	amit-cross-model-json-judge-v1.0	vllm-0.25.1-structured-outputs	0.9197	NVIDIA A10G	avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-daily-plan-alternatives	full	3f0b612c8a44b57a787a406c03f54b982428459b	cross-model-judge-10k-v1	3	4	alternative	Plan B includes specific cost-saving measures like pre-booked transfers, Roma Pass, and timed entries, which reduce hidden expenses and optimize spending; Plan A lacks such details and assumes generic budgeting.	2	5	alternative	Plan B consistently incorporates rest breaks, slow pacing, accessible routes, and relaxed transitions (e.g., aperitivo, picnics, guided stops), aligning with seniors' need for comfort and low physical strain; Plan A's repetitive museum visits suggest a rigid, high-intensity pace.	4	5	alternative	Plan B efficiently uses 14 days with balanced daily rhythms, including rest, cultural depth, and food integration; Plan A's daily repetition of museum visits risks over-scheduling and lacks buffer time for recovery or spontaneous exploration.	2	5	alternative	Plan B explicitly addresses senior needs with rest stops, accessible sites, modest dress, and low-impact activities (e.g., electric bikes, gardens, aperitivo); Plan A lacks accessibility notes and assumes general physical capability.	2	5	alternative	Plan B includes detailed practical notes on transfers, attire, accessibility, booking, and safety (e.g., pickpockets, sun protection), demonstrating clear logistical planning; Plan A offers no such guidance, making it less actionable for seniors.	3	5	alternative	Plan B deeply integrates Rome’s cultural and food landmarks with thematic coherence (e.g., Trastevere, Vatican, Borghese, Appian Way), offering authentic, location-specific experiences; Plan A is generic and lacks distinct regional or thematic anchoring.

End of preview. Expand in Data Studio

TripMatch AI — Original vs Alternative Plan Comparisons

This dataset is Amit's professor-assigned extension of TripMatch AI. It compares the original daily plan with the richer alternative plan using an LLM judge.

The decision is generated by the LLM as strict JSON. Python is used only for orchestration, persistence, and JSON-schema validation; it does not calculate scores, choose a winner, or write explanations.

The generation jobs use vLLM structured outputs with the published comparison_schema.json, so the JSON format is constrained while each LLM is answering. Invalid judgment content is sent back to the same LLM for a full regeneration. Python may canonicalize only the three copied identity metadata strings (trip_id, judge model, and generator model) from the source row; it never creates or changes a score, winner, reason, confidence, or explanation.

Cross-model judging

Alternatives created by Gemma 3 are judged by Qwen 3.
Alternatives created by Qwen 3 are judged by Gemma 3.

This prevents a model from judging its own generated plan.

Evaluation criteria

The judge evaluates budget alignment, pace alignment, duration feasibility, companion suitability, practical organization, and destination specificity.

Expected final configuration

The full configuration will contain 10,000 rows. Important fields include daily_plan_original, daily_plan_alternative, created_by_model, judge_model, comparison_json, overall_winner, confidence, and json_valid.

Reproducibility files

comparison_schema.json: strict professor-facing JSON contract.
jobs/tripmatch_cross_model_judge_vllm.py: GPU LLM judging and checkpoints.
jobs/tripmatch_merge_comparisons.py: validation, Dataset Viewer publishing, summary metrics, and charts.

Source dataset: https://huggingface.co/datasets/avihayamor/tripmatch-ai-daily-plan-alternatives

Complete 10,000-row comparison results

Every original trip is compared with its richer alternative. The LLM judge generated the scores, reasons, winner, confidence, and explanation as schema-valid JSON; Python did not make the decision.

Judge	Alternatives judged	Rows
Gemma 3	Qwen 3 alternatives	5,000
Qwen 3	Gemma 3 alternatives	5,000

Overall LLM decisions: 9,960 alternative, 36 original, and 4 ties.

Dataset Viewer configurations: full, gemma_judge, and qwen_judge.

Download every comparison as JSON

All 10,000 schema-valid LLM judgments are also published as standalone JSON files for direct inspection and submission:

exports/all_comparisons.json: one JSON array containing all 10,000 comparison objects.
exports/all_comparisons.jsonl: JSON Lines format with one complete comparison object per line.
exports/manifest.json: row count, validation rate, file sizes, and SHA-256 checksums.

Every object follows comparison_schema.json and contains the trip ID, generator model, judge model, six criterion-level score pairs and explanations, overall winner, confidence, and overall explanation.

Downloads last month: 356