Datasets:
model_id string | display_name string | paper_group string | viewpoint_condition string | model_input string | source_group string | n_outputs string | D1_CamPrec string | D1_CamPrec_n string | D1_CamAlign_common_yaw string | D1_CamAlign_common_yaw_n string | D1_CamAlign_static_hold string | D1_CamAlign_static_hold_n string | D2 string | D2_n string | D3 string | D3_n string | D4 string | D4_n string | D5 string | D5_n string | D6 string | D6_n string | gate_applicable_rate string | low_n_flag string | metric_notes string | Avg string |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
gen3c | Gen3C | V2V | Geometry-cache | TV2V | local_deployed | 400 | 0.698673268222 | 400 | 0.763661 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.749128848955 | 400 | 0.7226223275 | 400 | 0.55832766 | 400 | 0.68128519863 | 292 | 0.640176664384 | 292 | 0.73 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6858669499115 |
hailuo_2_3 | Hailuo 2.3 | API prompt-camera | Prompt-only | TI2V | api_prompt_camera | 300 | NA | 0 | 0.074558 | 200 | 0.981497 | 100 | 0.828514992061 | 300 | 0.890903776667 | 300 | 0.758899813333 | 300 | 0.718581 | 19 | 0.641525789474 | 19 | 0.0633333333333 | true | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; D1-CamPrec not applicable to API prompt-camera rows; low re-observation support: D5/D6 n < 10 or gate_applicable_rate < 0.10; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6521638952558334 |
happyhorse_1_0_i2v | HappyHorse 1.0 I2V | API prompt-camera | Prompt-only | TI2V | api_prompt_camera | 300 | NA | 0 | 0.024535 | 200 | 0.922438 | 100 | 0.860335317714 | 300 | 0.87469286 | 300 | 0.71513801 | 300 | 0.779475774194 | 31 | 0.695482548387 | 31 | 0.103333333333 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; D1-CamPrec not applicable to API prompt-camera rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6582765850491666 |
hunyuan_game_craft | Hunyuan GameCraft | Interactive | Model-inferred | TI2V | local_deployed | 400 | 0.534075475538 | 400 | 0.360795 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.705359823713 | 400 | 0.671783215 | 400 | 0.4401988425 | 400 | 0.554439333333 | 24 | 0.490242458333 | 24 | 0.06 | true | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; low re-observation support: D5/D6 n < 10 or gate_applicable_rate < 0.10; Hunyuan GameCraft static-hold rows removed from the full benchmark set before aggregation; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-0... | 0.5371364454798334 |
hunyuan_worldplay | Hunyuan WorldPlay | Interactive | Model-inferred | TI2V | local_deployed | 500 | 0.708315962852 | 500 | 0.260852 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.869801497146 | 500 | 0.73659917 | 500 | 0.522926138 | 500 | 0.639683884615 | 104 | 0.602829153846 | 104 | 0.208 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6054486406011667 |
hydra | Hydra | V2V | Source-video | TV2V | local_deployed | 400 | 0.822318120077 | 400 | 0.854661 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.691303712003 | 400 | 0.6477865975 | 400 | 0.50005684 | 400 | 0.508819842105 | 133 | 0.445027180451 | 133 | 0.3325 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6079425286765 |
inspatio_world_14b | InSpatio World 14B | V2V | Source-video | TV2V | local_deployed | 400 | 0.693372270332 | 400 | 0.661046 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.824239589632 | 400 | 0.820893435 | 400 | 0.6682933025 | 400 | 0.733576232932 | 249 | 0.664453975904 | 249 | 0.6225 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.7287504226613333 |
kling_v2_6 | Kling v2.6 | API prompt-camera | Prompt-only | TI2V | api_prompt_camera | 300 | NA | 0 | 0.09363 | 200 | 0.985198 | 100 | 0.864106809528 | 300 | 0.854208363333 | 300 | 0.67445893 | 300 | 0.7105715 | 10 | 0.6169894 | 10 | 0.0333333333333 | true | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; D1-CamPrec not applicable to API prompt-camera rows; low re-observation support: D5/D6 n < 10 or gate_applicable_rate < 0.10; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6356608338101667 |
lingbot_world | Lingbot World | Camera | Model-inferred | TI2V | local_deployed | 500 | 0.513166219737 | 500 | 0.174531 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.870428621536 | 500 | 0.875510382 | 500 | 0.73469463 | 500 | 0.716896766667 | 30 | 0.662628866667 | 30 | 0.06 | true | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; low re-observation support: D5/D6 n < 10 or gate_applicable_rate < 0.10; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6724483778116666 |
lingbot_world_act | Lingbot Act | Camera | Model-inferred | TI2V | local_deployed | 500 | 0.468415889285 | 500 | 0.167776 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.855666152251 | 500 | 0.873558238 | 500 | 0.71915545 | 500 | 0.7708950625 | 32 | 0.7254394375 | 32 | 0.064 | true | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; low re-observation support: D5/D6 n < 10 or gate_applicable_rate < 0.10; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6854150567085 |
liveworld | LiveWorld | Camera | Model-inferred | TI2V | local_deployed | 500 | 0.8121368981 | 500 | 0.855566 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.775149112976 | 500 | 0.703464608 | 500 | 0.54072688 | 500 | 0.661172151515 | 198 | 0.599960616162 | 198 | 0.396 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6893398947755 |
magicworld | MagicWorld | Interactive | Model-inferred | TI2V | local_deployed | 500 | 0.763846235988 | 500 | 0.720109 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.542846623785 | 500 | 0.623476598 | 500 | 0.457725808 | 500 | 0.583945186667 | 75 | 0.573926986667 | 75 | 0.15 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.5836717005198334 |
recammaster | ReCamMaster | V2V | Source-video | TV2V | local_deployed | 400 | 0.716977662377 | 400 | 0.729189 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.7401647541 | 400 | 0.715309525 | 400 | 0.534607135 | 400 | 0.664939957265 | 234 | 0.616121816239 | 234 | 0.585 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6667220312673333 |
spatia | Spatia | V2V | Geometry-cache | TV2V | local_deployed | 500 | 0.704199145789 | 500 | 0.481764 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.763378869774 | 500 | 0.73106498 | 500 | 0.541310104 | 500 | 0.600367883721 | 129 | 0.586199550388 | 129 | 0.258 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6173475646471666 |
versecrafter | VerseCrafter | V2V | Geometry-cache | TI2V | local_deployed | 500 | 0.780724658379 | 500 | 0.667481 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.845725828024 | 500 | 0.706826178 | 500 | 0.507852736 | 500 | 0.60749035 | 140 | 0.584297085714 | 140 | 0.28 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6532788629563333 |
wan21_fun_14b_cam | Wan-Fun 2.1-14B | Camera | Model-inferred | TI2V | local_deployed | 500 | 0.756878968751 | 500 | 0.52611 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.845676887256 | 500 | 0.733425918 | 500 | 0.530165346 | 500 | 0.65872043956 | 91 | 0.62091689011 | 91 | 0.182 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6525025801543333 |
wan21_fun_1p3b_cam | Wan-Fun 2.1-1.3B | Camera | Model-inferred | TI2V | local_deployed | 500 | 0.770960473205 | 500 | 0.729311 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.842076226449 | 500 | 0.72511208 | 500 | 0.51258749 | 500 | 0.709351985507 | 69 | 0.657234246377 | 69 | 0.138 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6959455047221667 |
wan22_fun_5b_cam | Wan-Fun 2.2-5B | Camera | Model-inferred | TI2V | local_deployed | 500 | 0.723692813641 | 500 | 0.334865 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.811992971342 | 500 | 0.804725648 | 500 | 0.607042082 | 500 | 0.708930483333 | 60 | 0.66399395 | 60 | 0.12 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6552583557791666 |
wan22_fun_a14b_cam | Wan-Fun 2.2-A14B | Camera | Model-inferred | TI2V | local_deployed | 500 | 0.757783777558 | 500 | 0.553242 | 400 | NA | 0 | 0.848139955103 | 500 | 0.81033699 | 500 | 0.624871978 | 500 | 0.698005863636 | 88 | 0.648500590909 | 88 | 0.176 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6971828962746668 |
wan2_2_i2v_plus | Wan2.2 I2V Plus | API prompt-camera | Prompt-only | TI2V | api_prompt_camera | 300 | NA | 0 | 0.013104 | 200 | 0.89727 | 100 | 0.799875078936 | 300 | 0.829465053333 | 300 | 0.644361743333 | 300 | 0.7139465 | 6 | 0.610216833333 | 6 | 0.02 | true | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; D1-CamPrec not applicable to API prompt-camera rows; low re-observation support: D5/D6 n < 10 or gate_applicable_rate < 0.10; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6018282014891666 |
wan2_6_i2v | Wan2.6 I2V | API prompt-camera | Prompt-only | TI2V | api_prompt_camera | 300 | NA | 0 | 0.015884 | 200 | 0.952684 | 100 | 0.856449483645 | 300 | 0.85519144 | 300 | 0.68167217 | 300 | 0.658937052632 | 38 | 0.555804921053 | 38 | 0.126666666667 | false | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; D1-CamPrec not applicable to API prompt-camera rows; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6039898445549999 |
wan2_7_i2v | Wan2.7 I2V | API prompt-camera | Prompt-only | TI2V | api_prompt_camera | 300 | NA | 0 | 0.020148 | 200 | 0.989341 | 100 | 0.749693298475 | 300 | 0.84816837 | 300 | 0.675838 | 300 | 0.714835166667 | 18 | 0.637903777778 | 18 | 0.06 | true | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; D1-CamPrec not applicable to API prompt-camera rows; low re-observation support: D5/D6 n < 10 or gate_applicable_rate < 0.10; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6077644354866667 |
wanx2_1_i2v_turbo | WanX2.1 I2V Turbo | API prompt-camera | Prompt-only | TI2V | api_prompt_camera | 300 | NA | 0 | 0.029899 | 200 | 0.732483 | 100 | 0.71291740938 | 300 | 0.838559093333 | 300 | 0.651044936667 | 300 | 0.854777333333 | 3 | 0.777309333333 | 3 | 0.01 | true | D1-CamPrec and D1-CamAlign are separate metrics; D5/D6 are conditional over shared-E14 applicable rows; D1-CamPrec not applicable to API prompt-camera rows; low re-observation support: D5/D6 n < 10 or gate_applicable_rate < 0.10; CamAlign common-yaw uses d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10) | 0.6440845176743334 |
WRBench Evaluation Results
Model-level diagnostic profile for Current World Models Lack a Persistent State Core β the aggregate table behind the WRBench leaderboard. This release covers 23 models on the 9,600-video public benchmark surface, each scored on six evaluation dimensions (D1-D6) under controlled viewpoint changes.
π Explore it interactively in the WRBench Leaderboard.
Load
from datasets import load_dataset
scores = load_dataset("WRBench/wrbench-results", "model_scores", split="default")
df = scores.to_pandas().sort_values("Avg", ascending=False)
Metric definitions
All scores are in [0, 1]; higher is better.
| Column | Paper dimension | What it measures |
|---|---|---|
Cam Prec. (D1) |
requested-camera precision | Strict requested-camera precision on certified local requested-control rows with explicit target trajectories. A separate diagnostic from Cam Align.; not applicable to prompt-camera / API rows. |
Cam Align. (D1) |
prompt-camera alignment | Common-yaw / static prompt-camera alignment diagnostic (CamAlign v2-lite). Not strict trajectory precision. |
Integ. (D2) |
visual integrity | Full-FoV DINOv2 visual-evidence / readability proxy. |
Vis. spatial (D3) |
visible spatial consistency | Spatial consistency evaluated while the relevant spatial evidence is observable. |
Vis. state (D4) |
visible state consistency | Action / state consistency evaluated while the relevant evidence is observable. |
Reobs. Support |
re-observation support | Fraction of outputs with judgeable hidden-and-returned evidence (the E14 applicability gate). Diagnostic coverage only: it establishes applicability/judgeability, not correctness. |
Ret. spatial (D5) |
returned spatial consistency | Spatial consistency conditional on judgeable re-observation evidence. |
Ret. state (D6) |
returned state consistency | State consistency conditional on judgeable re-observation evidence. |
Avg |
(aggregate) | Mean of Cam Align., Integ., Vis. spatial, Vis. state, Ret. spatial, Ret. state (paper main-table average). |
Aggregation. Returned spatial/state metrics (D5/D6) are conditionally aggregated over the judgeable re-observation subset (the paper's shared-E14 pool of 2,073 rows); elsewhere they are null (NA). Outputs without identifiable returned evidence provide insufficient support for returned-state evaluation rather than counted failures. WRBench reports a diagnostic profile, not a single scalar ranking.
Viewpoint condition type. viewpoint_condition is the paper's viewpoint condition type (Table 2) β the form of input that supplies information about the requested viewpoint change:
- Source-video: a reference stream supplies appearance, layout, and partial event evidence.
- Geometry-cache: a point cloud / 3D / 4D record makes camera-target access computable.
- Model-inferred: no external view-state reference; the new view is synthesized under local camera/action/state controls.
- Prompt-only: natural-language camera intent only (uses CamAlign, not strict CamPrec).
Model input. model_input is the benchmark input interface delivered to each model (from the WRBenchLib inference contracts):
- TV2V (text + video): a source/reference video is the conditioning input (ReCamMaster, HyDRA, InSpatio World 14B, Gen3C, Spatia).
- TI2V (text + image): a text prompt plus a first-frame image is the conditioning input (all other models, including the prompt-only I2V APIs).
Schema
model_scores has one row per evaluated model:
| Field | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
model_id |
string | Internal model slug (matches wrbench-videos/videos/<model_id>/) |
display_name |
string | Public model name |
viewpoint_condition |
string | Paper viewpoint condition type: Source-video, Geometry-cache, Model-inferred, Prompt-only |
model_input |
string | Benchmark input interface: TV2V (text+video) or TI2V (text+image) |
paper_group |
string | Deprecated legacy grouping (V2V/Camera/Interactive/API prompt-camera); kept for backward compatibility β use viewpoint_condition |
source_group |
string | Provenance bucket (local_deployed, api_prompt_camera) |
n_outputs |
int | Evaluated outputs for this model |
D1_CamPrec, D1_CamPrec_n |
float, int | Requested-camera precision and its support count |
D1_CamAlign_common_yaw, _n |
float, int | Prompt-camera alignment (CamAlign v2-lite) and support |
D1_CamAlign_static_hold, _n |
float, int | Static-hold CamAlign component and support |
D2-D6, D2_n-D6_n |
float, int | Dimension scores and per-dimension support counts |
gate_applicable_rate |
float | Re-observation support rate (D5/D6 applicability gate) |
low_n_flag |
bool | True when a reported dimension has thin support |
metric_notes |
string | Per-row provenance / applicability caveats |
Avg |
float | Mean of CamAlign, D2, D3, D4, D5, D6 (paper main-table average) |
NA indicates a dimension that is not applicable to a model (e.g. D1_CamPrec
for API prompt-camera rows) rather than a zero score.
Provenance
- Benchmark date: 2026-06-08
- Commit: 73b804130
- CamAlign: d1_camalign_v2_lite (2026-06-10 common-yaw / static-hold intent)
- D5/D6: conditional over 2,073 shared-E14 re-observation-supported rows
- Raw exports kept under
original/(wrbench_23model_results.csv/.json)
Links
- π Leaderboard: https://huggingface.co/spaces/WRBench/wrbench-leaderboard
- ποΈ Videos + per-video scores: https://huggingface.co/datasets/WRBench/wrbench-videos
- πΌοΈ Natural-25 prompts: https://huggingface.co/datasets/WRBench/wrbench-natural25
- π§ββοΈ Human annotations: https://huggingface.co/datasets/WRBench/wrbench-human-annotations
- π§ Release collection: https://huggingface.co/collections/WRBench/wrbench-current-world-models-lack-a-persistent-state-core-6a365c717251293c9fc2cc26
- π» GitHub: https://github.com/JinPLu/WRBench
- π Project page: https://jinplu.github.io/WRBench/
- π Paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.20545
- π€ HF paper page: https://huggingface.co/papers/2606.20545
Citation
@article{wrbench2026,
title = {Current World Models Lack a Persistent State Core},
author = {WRBench Team},
journal = {arXiv preprint arXiv:2606.20545},
year = {2026},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.20545}
}
- Downloads last month
- -