doc_id stringlengths 6 6 | text stringlengths 167 551 | date stringlengths 8 8 | author stringclasses 14
values | recipient stringclasses 15
values | cc stringclasses 2
values | type stringclasses 4
values | subject stringlengths 5 54 | label stringclasses 3
values | reason stringlengths 64 170 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
DOC001 | From: Alex Kim <akim@apextelecom.com>
To: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
Date: March 8, 2025
Subject: Expense report
Hey,
Can you send me the agenda for expense report? Want to make sure I'm prepared.
Thanks,
Alex
| 03/08/25 | Alex Kim | Michael Carter | Email | Expense report | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC002 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Alex Kim <akim@apextelecom.com>
Date: June 19, 2025
Subject: Meridian Corp check-in
Hi team,
Had a good call with Meridian Corp today. They're happy with service levels and we're on track for the standard renewal in Q3. Nothing unusual to report.
Michael
| 06/19/25 | Michael Carter | Alex Kim | Email | Meridian Corp check-in | Not Relevant | Routine, legitimate customer account update with no evidence of improper disclosure. | |
DOC003 | From: Linda Park <lpark@apextelecom.com>
To: Sarah Johnson <sjohnson@apextelecom.com>
Date: June 11, 2025
Subject: System maintenance window
Hi,
Sharing an update on system maintenance window. Nothing urgent, just keeping everyone informed.
Linda
| 06/11/25 | Linda Park | Sarah Johnson | Email | System maintenance window | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC004 | Chat Log: Priya Patel <-> Mark Delgado
Date: March 1, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Priya Patel: hey are we still on for the lunch?
Mark Delgado: yep works for me, see you then
| 03/01/25 | Priya Patel | Mark Delgado | Chat | lunch | Not Relevant | Casual, non-substantive workplace chat unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC005 | From: Karen Wilson <kwilson@apextelecom.com>
To: Nina Torres <ntorres@apextelecom.com>
Date: April 12, 2025
Subject: Office supply order
All,
Quick update on office supply order - everything is on track, no action needed from you.
Karen
| 04/12/25 | Karen Wilson | Nina Torres | Email | Office supply order | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC006 | Chat Log: Michael Carter <-> Robert Smith
Date: February 25, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Robert Smith: hey did you get a chance to pull that customer list?
Michael Carter: yeah, sending it from my personal email tonight so it doesn't show up on the apex server
Robert Smith: perfect, appreciate it
| 02/25/25 | Michael Carter | Robert Smith | Chat | customer list | Relevant | Michael discusses transmitting the Apex customer list to a Northstar employee and evading company monitoring. | |
DOC007 | From: Alex Kim <akim@apextelecom.com>
To: Priya Patel <ppatel@apextelecom.com>
Date: June 7, 2025
Subject: Sales training materials
Hi,
Sharing an update on sales training materials. Nothing urgent, just keeping everyone informed.
Alex
| 06/07/25 | Alex Kim | Priya Patel | Email | Sales training materials | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC008 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Karen Wilson <kwilson@apextelecom.com>
Date: April 9, 2025
Subject: Team lunch Friday
Hey,
Can you send me the agenda for team lunch friday? Want to make sure I'm prepared.
Thanks,
Michael
| 04/09/25 | Michael Carter | Karen Wilson | Email | Team lunch Friday | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC009 | ATTACHMENT
File Name: benefits_summary.pdf
Date: May 1, 2025
Standard internal reference document. No customer, pricing, or confidential information related to the investigation.
| 05/01/25 | Attachment | benefits_summary.pdf | Not Relevant | Generic internal reference material unrelated to the allegation. | |||
DOC010 | MEETING NOTES
Title: Sales Pipeline Review
Date: June 23, 2025
Attendees: Tom Reyes, Sarah Johnson, Michael Carter
Michael's numbers for the quarter were notably lower than peers. Tom asked whether there were any deals at risk; Michael mentioned 'a few things in motion' without elaborating.
| 06/23/25 | Tom Reyes | Meeting Notes | Sales Pipeline Review | Needs Human Review | Vague comment during a routine business meeting that could suggest undisclosed activity, but lacks specificity. | ||
DOC011 | ATTACHMENT
File Name: Q1_sales_deck.pptx
Date: March 7, 2025
Standard internal reference document. No customer, pricing, or confidential information related to the investigation.
| 03/07/25 | Attachment | Q1_sales_deck.pptx | Not Relevant | Generic internal reference material unrelated to the allegation. | |||
DOC012 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Robert Smith <robert.smith@northstarcomm.com>
Date: May 14, 2025
Subject: Falcon Industries pricing
Robert,
Attached is the current pricing sheet we discussed for Falcon Industries. Please don't forward this outside Northstar - I'd rather Apex not know we talked.
Mi... | 05/14/25 | Michael Carter | Robert Smith | Email | Falcon Industries pricing | Relevant | Direct evidence Michael sent Apex pricing information to a Northstar employee and asked for secrecy. | |
DOC013 | ATTACHMENT
File Name: Redstone Retail_pricing_sheet_CONFIDENTIAL.xlsx
Date: April 3, 2025
APEX TELECOMMUNICATIONS - INTERNAL USE ONLY
Customer: Redstone Retail
Negotiated Rate: $354/unit
Contract Term: 24 months
Internal Cost Basis: $37/unit
Sales Rep: Michael Carter
DO NOT DISTRIBUTE OUTSIDE APEX.
| 04/03/25 | Attachment | Redstone Retail_pricing_sheet_CONFIDENTIAL.xlsx | Relevant | Confidential internal Apex pricing document found in the population; corresponds to an email Michael sent externally. | |||
DOC014 | From: Sarah Johnson <sjohnson@apextelecom.com>
To: Karen Wilson <kwilson@apextelecom.com>
Date: May 7, 2025
Subject: Question about a former contact
Karen,
Michael mentioned in passing that he 'still talks to people' at Northstar from a prior role. Wanted to flag in case it's relevant, though it may be nothing.
Sara... | 05/07/25 | Sarah Johnson | Karen Wilson | Email | Question about a former contact | Needs Human Review | Manager flags a vague, secondhand comment about competitor contact that requires further investigation to interpret. | |
DOC015 | From: Karen Wilson <kwilson@apextelecom.com>
To: Emily Brown <ebrown@apextelecom.com>
Date: June 27, 2025
Subject: Litigation hold - Carter
Emily,
Please issue a litigation hold notice covering Michael Carter's email, chat, and file activity effective immediately. We have reason to believe confidential customer and p... | 06/27/25 | Karen Wilson | Emily Brown | Email | Litigation hold - Carter | Relevant | Legal hold notice directly referencing the suspected disclosure of confidential information - core investigation document. | |
DOC016 | Chat Log: Michael Carter <-> David Lee
Date: April 28, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Michael Carter: honestly kind of over it here, thinking about other options
David Lee: you should look around, no shame in that
| 04/28/25 | Michael Carter | David Lee | Chat | job search | Needs Human Review | Suggests Michael may have been considering leaving Apex, which is contextually relevant to motive but not direct evidence of disclosure. | |
DOC017 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Robert Smith <robert.smith@northstarcomm.com>
Date: February 17, 2025
Subject: Titan Manufacturing pricing
Robert,
Attached is the current pricing sheet we discussed for Titan Manufacturing. Please don't forward this outside Northstar - I'd rather Apex not know we ta... | 02/17/25 | Michael Carter | Robert Smith | Email | Titan Manufacturing pricing | Relevant | Direct evidence Michael sent Apex pricing information to a Northstar employee and asked for secrecy. | |
DOC018 | MEETING NOTES
Title: Q2 Planning
Date: March 20, 2025
Attendees: Sarah Johnson, Priya Patel, David Lee
Discussed pipeline status, upcoming renewals, and staffing. No issues raised. Next meeting scheduled for two weeks out.
| 03/20/25 | Sarah Johnson | Meeting Notes | Q2 Planning | Not Relevant | Standard internal meeting notes with no connection to the competitor or confidential disclosures. | ||
DOC019 | From: Nina Torres <ntorres@apextelecom.com>
To: Priya Patel <ppatel@apextelecom.com>
Date: March 6, 2025
Subject: Northgate Systems demo
Priya,
Northgate Systems (the software vendor, not a telecom competitor) wants to demo their new billing platform next week. Can you sit in?
Nina
| 03/06/25 | Nina Torres | Priya Patel | Email | Northgate Systems demo | Needs Human Review | Company name is similar to the competitor ('Northgate' vs 'Northstar') and could be mis-flagged by simple keyword matching. | |
DOC020 | Chat Log: Michael Carter <-> Robert Smith
Date: January 13, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Robert Smith: hey did you get a chance to pull that customer list?
Michael Carter: yeah, sending it from my personal email tonight so it doesn't show up on the apex server
Robert Smith: perfect, appreciate it
| 01/13/25 | Michael Carter | Robert Smith | Chat | customer list | Relevant | Michael discusses transmitting the Apex customer list to a Northstar employee and evading company monitoring. | |
DOC021 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Robert Smith <robert.smith@northstarcomm.com>
Date: June 4, 2025
Subject: BlueWave Networks pricing
Robert,
Attached is the current pricing sheet we discussed for BlueWave Networks. Please don't forward this outside Northstar - I'd rather Apex not know we talked.
Mi... | 06/04/25 | Michael Carter | Robert Smith | Email | BlueWave Networks pricing | Relevant | Direct evidence Michael sent Apex pricing information to a Northstar employee and asked for secrecy. | |
DOC022 | From: Alex Kim <akim@apextelecom.com>
To: Chris Evans <cevans@apextelecom.com>
Date: May 28, 2025
Subject: Weekly status update
Hey,
Can you send me the agenda for weekly status update? Want to make sure I'm prepared.
Thanks,
Alex
| 05/28/25 | Alex Kim | Chris Evans | Email | Weekly status update | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC023 | From: David Lee <dlee@apextelecom.com>
To: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
Date: May 24, 2025
Subject: Sunrise Health Systems check-in
Hi team,
Had a good call with Sunrise Health Systems today. They're happy with service levels and we're on track for the standard renewal in Q3. Nothing unusual to report.
D... | 05/24/25 | David Lee | Michael Carter | Email | Sunrise Health Systems check-in | Not Relevant | Routine, legitimate customer account update with no evidence of improper disclosure. | |
DOC024 | ATTACHMENT
File Name: team_org_chart.pdf
Date: May 2, 2025
Standard internal reference document. No customer, pricing, or confidential information related to the investigation.
| 05/02/25 | Attachment | team_org_chart.pdf | Not Relevant | Generic internal reference material unrelated to the allegation. | |||
DOC025 | ATTACHMENT
File Name: Falcon Industries_pricing_sheet_CONFIDENTIAL.xlsx
Date: February 25, 2025
APEX TELECOMMUNICATIONS - INTERNAL USE ONLY
Customer: Falcon Industries
Negotiated Rate: $103/unit
Contract Term: 24 months
Internal Cost Basis: $72/unit
Sales Rep: Michael Carter
DO NOT DISTRIBUTE OUTSIDE APEX.
| 02/25/25 | Attachment | Falcon Industries_pricing_sheet_CONFIDENTIAL.xlsx | Relevant | Confidential internal Apex pricing document found in the population; corresponds to an email Michael sent externally. | |||
DOC026 | Chat Log: Michael Carter <-> Robert Smith
Date: March 4, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Robert Smith: hey did you get a chance to pull that customer list?
Michael Carter: yeah, sending it from my personal email tonight so it doesn't show up on the apex server
Robert Smith: perfect, appreciate it
| 03/04/25 | Michael Carter | Robert Smith | Chat | customer list | Relevant | Michael discusses transmitting the Apex customer list to a Northstar employee and evading company monitoring. | |
DOC027 | Chat Log: David Lee <-> Mark Delgado
Date: May 8, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
David Lee: hey are we still on for the meeting time?
Mark Delgado: yep works for me, see you then
| 05/08/25 | David Lee | Mark Delgado | Chat | meeting time | Not Relevant | Casual, non-substantive workplace chat unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC028 | From: David Lee <dlee@apextelecom.com>
To: Priya Patel <ppatel@apextelecom.com>
Date: June 9, 2025
Subject: Q1 sales meeting
All,
Quick update on q1 sales meeting - everything is on track, no action needed from you.
David
| 06/09/25 | David Lee | Priya Patel | Email | Q1 sales meeting | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC029 | Chat Log: Priya Patel <-> Chris Evans
Date: February 28, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Priya Patel: hey are we still on for the weekend plans?
Chris Evans: yep works for me, see you then
| 02/28/25 | Priya Patel | Chris Evans | Chat | weekend plans | Not Relevant | Casual, non-substantive workplace chat unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC030 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Robert Smith <robert.smith@northstarcomm.com>
Date: January 3, 2025
Subject: Meridian Corp pricing
Robert,
Attached is the current pricing sheet we discussed for Meridian Corp. Please don't forward this outside Northstar - I'd rather Apex not know we talked.
Michael... | 01/03/25 | Michael Carter | Robert Smith | Email | Meridian Corp pricing | Relevant | Direct evidence Michael sent Apex pricing information to a Northstar employee and asked for secrecy. | |
DOC031 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Sarah Johnson <sjohnson@apextelecom.com>
Date: February 14, 2025
Subject: Sales meeting agenda
Hi,
Can you send me the agenda for tomorrow's sales meeting? Want to make sure I bring the right numbers.
Michael
| 02/14/25 | Michael Carter | Sarah Johnson | Email | Sales meeting agenda | Needs Human Review | Authored by the subject of the investigation, but content is routine - relevance should not be assumed from authorship alone. | |
DOC032 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: David Lee <dlee@apextelecom.com>
Date: May 7, 2025
Subject: Redstone Retail check-in
Hi team,
Had a good call with Redstone Retail today. They're happy with service levels and we're on track for the standard renewal in Q3. Nothing unusual to report.
Michael
| 05/07/25 | Michael Carter | David Lee | Email | Redstone Retail check-in | Not Relevant | Routine, legitimate customer account update with no evidence of improper disclosure. | |
DOC033 | ATTACHMENT
File Name: team_org_chart.pdf
Date: April 5, 2025
Standard internal reference document. No customer, pricing, or confidential information related to the investigation.
| 04/05/25 | Attachment | team_org_chart.pdf | Not Relevant | Generic internal reference material unrelated to the allegation. | |||
DOC034 | From: Karen Wilson <kwilson@apextelecom.com>
To: Mark Delgado <mdelgado@apextelecom.com>
Date: June 6, 2025
Subject: PTO request
All,
Quick update on pto request - everything is on track, no action needed from you.
Karen
| 06/06/25 | Karen Wilson | Mark Delgado | Email | PTO request | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC035 | Chat Log: Michael Carter <-> Robert Smith
Date: January 13, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Michael Carter: I can get you our full rate card for the healthcare vertical, just give me a day
Robert Smith: that would be huge for us, we're bidding against Apex on Sunrise Health next month
Michael Carter: on it
| 01/13/25 | Michael Carter | Robert Smith | Chat | pricing structure | Relevant | Michael offers to provide competitor with Apex's confidential rate card ahead of a competing bid. | |
DOC036 | From: Chris Evans <cevans@apextelecom.com>
To: Linda Park <lpark@apextelecom.com>
Date: June 23, 2025
Subject: IT ticket - laptop issue
All,
Quick update on it ticket - laptop issue - everything is on track, no action needed from you.
Chris
| 06/23/25 | Chris Evans | Linda Park | Email | IT ticket - laptop issue | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC037 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Alex Kim <akim@apextelecom.com>
Date: January 17, 2025
Subject: System maintenance window
Hi,
Sharing an update on system maintenance window. Nothing urgent, just keeping everyone informed.
Michael
| 01/17/25 | Michael Carter | Alex Kim | Email | System maintenance window | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC038 | From: Nina Torres <ntorres@apextelecom.com>
To: Priya Patel <ppatel@apextelecom.com>
Date: February 12, 2025
Subject: CRM login issue
Hi Priya,
Just a reminder about crm login issue. Let me know if you have questions.
Nina
| 02/12/25 | Nina Torres | Priya Patel | Email | CRM login issue | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC039 | From: Alex Kim <akim@apextelecom.com>
To: Emily Brown <ebrown@apextelecom.com>
Date: June 23, 2025
Subject: Coastal Logistics check-in
Hi team,
Had a good call with Coastal Logistics today. They're happy with service levels and we're on track for the standard renewal in Q3. Nothing unusual to report.
Alex
| 06/23/25 | Alex Kim | Emily Brown | Email | Coastal Logistics check-in | Not Relevant | Routine, legitimate customer account update with no evidence of improper disclosure. | |
DOC040 | MEETING NOTES
Title: Client Renewal Review
Date: May 23, 2025
Attendees: Tom Reyes, Karen Wilson, David Lee
Discussed pipeline status, upcoming renewals, and staffing. No issues raised. Next meeting scheduled for two weeks out.
| 05/23/25 | Tom Reyes | Meeting Notes | Client Renewal Review | Not Relevant | Standard internal meeting notes with no connection to the competitor or confidential disclosures. | ||
DOC041 | From: Sarah Johnson <sjohnson@apextelecom.com>
To: Tom Reyes <treyes@apextelecom.com>
Date: May 10, 2025
Subject: Facilities update
Hi,
Sharing an update on facilities update. Nothing urgent, just keeping everyone informed.
Sarah
| 05/10/25 | Sarah Johnson | Tom Reyes | Email | Facilities update | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC042 | Chat Log: Michael Carter <-> David Lee
Date: May 28, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
David Lee: did you see the new public pricing page?
Michael Carter: yeah looks fine to me, nothing new there
| 05/28/25 | Michael Carter | David Lee | Chat | pricing page | Needs Human Review | Michael discusses 'pricing' but the context suggests publicly available information rather than confidential data. | |
DOC043 | Chat Log: Michael Carter <-> Robert Smith
Date: January 12, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Robert Smith: hey did you get a chance to pull that customer list?
Michael Carter: yeah, sending it from my personal email tonight so it doesn't show up on the apex server
Robert Smith: perfect, appreciate it
| 01/12/25 | Michael Carter | Robert Smith | Chat | customer list | Relevant | Michael discusses transmitting the Apex customer list to a Northstar employee and evading company monitoring. | |
DOC044 | From: Karen Wilson <kwilson@apextelecom.com>
To: Mark Delgado <mdelgado@apextelecom.com>
Date: March 14, 2025
Subject: Parking garage closure
Hi Mark,
Just a reminder about parking garage closure. Let me know if you have questions.
Karen
| 03/14/25 | Karen Wilson | Mark Delgado | Email | Parking garage closure | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC045 | From: Mark Delgado <mdelgado@apextelecom.com>
To: David Lee <dlee@apextelecom.com>
Date: June 3, 2025
Subject: Client satisfaction survey results
Hi,
Sharing an update on client satisfaction survey results. Nothing urgent, just keeping everyone informed.
Mark
| 06/03/25 | Mark Delgado | David Lee | Email | Client satisfaction survey results | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC046 | MEETING NOTES
Title: Client Renewal Review
Date: March 2, 2025
Attendees: Karen Wilson, Michael Carter, Sarah Johnson
Discussed pipeline status, upcoming renewals, and staffing. No issues raised. Next meeting scheduled for two weeks out.
| 03/02/25 | Karen Wilson | Meeting Notes | Client Renewal Review | Not Relevant | Standard internal meeting notes with no connection to the competitor or confidential disclosures. | ||
DOC047 | Chat Log: Priya Patel <-> Nina Torres
Date: February 13, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Priya Patel: hey are we still on for the lunch?
Nina Torres: yep works for me, see you then
| 02/13/25 | Priya Patel | Nina Torres | Chat | lunch | Not Relevant | Casual, non-substantive workplace chat unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC048 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Robert Smith <robert.smith@northstarcomm.com>
Date: February 9, 2025
Subject: See attached
Robert,
See attached. Let me know if you need anything else formatted differently.
Michael
[Attachment: customer_master_list_Q1.xlsx (DOC058)]
| 02/09/25 | Michael Carter | Robert Smith | Email | See attached | Needs Human Review | The email body alone is generic ('see attached'); relevance depends entirely on the linked attachment, which a reviewer must consider as part of the same document family. | |
DOC049 | Chat Log: Mark Delgado <-> David Lee
Date: April 8, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Mark Delgado: hey are we still on for the sports?
David Lee: yep works for me, see you then
| 04/08/25 | Mark Delgado | David Lee | Chat | sports | Not Relevant | Casual, non-substantive workplace chat unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC050 | From: David Lee <dlee@apextelecom.com>
To: Tom Reyes <treyes@apextelecom.com>
Date: April 5, 2025
Subject: Coastal Logistics check-in
Hi team,
Had a good call with Coastal Logistics today. They're happy with service levels and we're on track for the standard renewal in Q3. Nothing unusual to report.
David
| 04/05/25 | David Lee | Tom Reyes | Email | Coastal Logistics check-in | Not Relevant | Routine, legitimate customer account update with no evidence of improper disclosure. | |
DOC051 | MEETING NOTES
Title: 1:1 - Michael / Sarah
Date: March 15, 2025
Attendees: Sarah Johnson, Michael Carter
Sarah raised concerns about Michael's declining pipeline activity and asked directly whether he has been in contact with Northstar. Michael denied any contact. Sarah noted increased personal phone use during client... | 03/15/25 | Sarah Johnson | Meeting Notes | 1:1 - Michael / Sarah | Relevant | Internal record documenting management's suspicion and a direct (denied) question about contact with the competitor. | ||
DOC052 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Robert Smith <robert.smith@northstarcomm.com>
Date: January 24, 2025
Subject: Falcon Industries pricing
Robert,
Attached is the current pricing sheet we discussed for Falcon Industries. Please don't forward this outside Northstar - I'd rather Apex not know we talked.... | 01/24/25 | Michael Carter | Robert Smith | Email | Falcon Industries pricing | Relevant | Direct evidence Michael sent Apex pricing information to a Northstar employee and asked for secrecy. | |
DOC053 | From: Robert Smith <robert.smith@northstarcomm.com>
To: Jessica Nguyen <jessica.nguyen@northstarcomm.com>
Date: March 24, 2025
Subject: Re: Apex intel
Jessica,
Michael came through again - got us Harbor Financial Group's renewal date and current rate. This puts us in a great spot to underbid when it comes up.
Robert... | 03/24/25 | Robert Smith | Jessica Nguyen | Email | Re: Apex intel | Relevant | Internal Northstar email confirming receipt and use of confidential Apex competitive information obtained from Michael. | |
DOC054 | From: Tom Reyes <treyes@apextelecom.com>
To: David Lee <dlee@apextelecom.com>
Date: February 22, 2025
Subject: Training session sign-up
Hey,
Can you send me the agenda for training session sign-up? Want to make sure I'm prepared.
Thanks,
Tom
| 02/22/25 | Tom Reyes | David Lee | Email | Training session sign-up | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC055 | ATTACHMENT
File Name: benefits_summary.pdf
Date: May 23, 2025
Standard internal reference document. No customer, pricing, or confidential information related to the investigation.
| 05/23/25 | Attachment | benefits_summary.pdf | Not Relevant | Generic internal reference material unrelated to the allegation. | |||
DOC056 | Chat Log: Priya Patel <-> Chris Evans
Date: June 21, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Priya Patel: hey are we still on for the weekend plans?
Chris Evans: yep works for me, see you then
| 06/21/25 | Priya Patel | Chris Evans | Chat | weekend plans | Not Relevant | Casual, non-substantive workplace chat unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC057 | ATTACHMENT
File Name: Q1_sales_deck.pptx
Date: January 23, 2025
Standard internal reference document. No customer, pricing, or confidential information related to the investigation.
| 01/23/25 | Attachment | Q1_sales_deck.pptx | Not Relevant | Generic internal reference material unrelated to the allegation. | |||
DOC058 | ATTACHMENT
File Name: customer_master_list_Q1.xlsx
Date: June 26, 2025
APEX TELECOMMUNICATIONS - CUSTOMER MASTER LIST
Contains all active customer accounts, contract values, and renewal dates. Confidential - internal use only.
| 06/26/25 | Attachment | customer_master_list_Q1.xlsx | Relevant | The attachment itself contains the confidential customer master list. | |||
DOC059 | From: Mark Delgado <mdelgado@apextelecom.com>
To: Emily Brown <ebrown@apextelecom.com>
Date: March 8, 2025
Subject: Unusual login activity
Emily,
Flagging that Michael Carter's account had two large file downloads from outside normal business hours last week. Not sure if this is worth escalating.
Mark
| 03/08/25 | Mark Delgado | Emily Brown | Email | Unusual login activity | Needs Human Review | IT security observation about unusual account activity - circumstantial but not direct evidence of disclosure. | |
DOC060 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Karen Wilson <kwilson@apextelecom.com>
Date: January 24, 2025
Subject: Travel reimbursement
Hi Karen,
Just a reminder about travel reimbursement. Let me know if you have questions.
Michael
| 01/24/25 | Michael Carter | Karen Wilson | Email | Travel reimbursement | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC061 | Chat Log: David Lee <-> Michael Carter
Date: January 2, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
David Lee: hey do you still have contacts at Northstar from before?
Michael Carter: a couple, why?
| 01/02/25 | David Lee | Michael Carter | Chat | quick question | Needs Human Review | Coworker asks Michael about competitor contacts; Michael's brief response doesn't confirm or deny improper conduct. | |
DOC062 | Chat Log: Mark Delgado <-> David Lee
Date: January 25, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Mark Delgado: hey are we still on for the lunch?
David Lee: yep works for me, see you then
| 01/25/25 | Mark Delgado | David Lee | Chat | lunch | Not Relevant | Casual, non-substantive workplace chat unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC063 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Sarah Johnson <sjohnson@apextelecom.com>
Date: February 28, 2025
Subject: Sales meeting agenda
Hi,
Can you send me the agenda for tomorrow's sales meeting? Want to make sure I bring the right numbers.
Michael
| 02/28/25 | Michael Carter | Sarah Johnson | Email | Sales meeting agenda | Needs Human Review | Authored by the subject of the investigation, but content is routine - relevance should not be assumed from authorship alone. | |
DOC064 | From: David Lee <dlee@apextelecom.com>
To: Alex Kim <akim@apextelecom.com>
Date: January 4, 2025
Subject: the numbers
Hey,
Can you send me the numbers we talked about? Want to have them ready before Friday.
Thanks
| 01/04/25 | David Lee | Alex Kim | Email | the numbers | Needs Human Review | Vague reference to 'the numbers' without enough context to determine whether this concerns confidential pricing/customer data. | |
DOC065 | From: Robert Smith <robert.smith@northstarcomm.com>
To: Jessica Nguyen <jessica.nguyen@northstarcomm.com>
Date: January 4, 2025
Subject: Re: Apex intel
Jessica,
Michael came through again - got us Sunrise Health Systems's renewal date and current rate. This puts us in a great spot to underbid when it comes up.
Rober... | 01/04/25 | Robert Smith | Jessica Nguyen | Email | Re: Apex intel | Relevant | Internal Northstar email confirming receipt and use of confidential Apex competitive information obtained from Michael. | |
DOC066 | From: Priya Patel <ppatel@apextelecom.com>
To: Emily Brown <ebrown@apextelecom.com>
Date: April 9, 2025
Subject: Weekly status update
Hey,
Can you send me the agenda for weekly status update? Want to make sure I'm prepared.
Thanks,
Priya
| 04/09/25 | Priya Patel | Emily Brown | Email | Weekly status update | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC067 | From: Robert Smith <robert.smith@northstarcomm.com>
To: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
Date: February 15, 2025
Subject: Following up
Michael,
Thanks for the Harbor Financial Group numbers last week. This is really helpful as we put our bid together. Can you also send the renewal dates for our other target a... | 02/15/25 | Robert Smith | Michael Carter | Email | Following up | Relevant | Competitor confirms receipt of Apex pricing/customer information and requests more. | |
DOC068 | From: Priya Patel <ppatel@apextelecom.com>
To: Sarah Johnson <sjohnson@apextelecom.com>
Date: May 8, 2025
Subject: Titan Manufacturing check-in
Hi team,
Had a good call with Titan Manufacturing today. They're happy with service levels and we're on track for the standard renewal in Q3. Nothing unusual to report.
Priy... | 05/08/25 | Priya Patel | Sarah Johnson | Email | Titan Manufacturing check-in | Not Relevant | Routine, legitimate customer account update with no evidence of improper disclosure. | |
DOC069 | From: Linda Park <lpark@apextelecom.com>
To: Karen Wilson <kwilson@apextelecom.com>
Date: May 5, 2025
Subject: System maintenance window
Hi,
Sharing an update on system maintenance window. Nothing urgent, just keeping everyone informed.
Linda
| 05/05/25 | Linda Park | Karen Wilson | Email | System maintenance window | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC070 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Sarah Johnson <sjohnson@apextelecom.com>
Date: February 24, 2025
Subject: Sales meeting agenda
Hi,
Can you send me the agenda for tomorrow's sales meeting? Want to make sure I bring the right numbers.
Michael
| 02/24/25 | Michael Carter | Sarah Johnson | Email | Sales meeting agenda | Needs Human Review | Authored by the subject of the investigation, but content is routine - relevance should not be assumed from authorship alone. | |
DOC071 | MEETING NOTES
Title: Q2 Planning
Date: May 16, 2025
Attendees: Emily Brown, Tom Reyes, Mark Delgado
Discussed pipeline status, upcoming renewals, and staffing. No issues raised. Next meeting scheduled for two weeks out.
| 05/16/25 | Emily Brown | Meeting Notes | Q2 Planning | Not Relevant | Standard internal meeting notes with no connection to the competitor or confidential disclosures. | ||
DOC072 | Chat Log: Alex Kim <-> Mark Delgado
Date: February 3, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Alex Kim: hey are we still on for the lunch?
Mark Delgado: yep works for me, see you then
| 02/03/25 | Alex Kim | Mark Delgado | Chat | lunch | Not Relevant | Casual, non-substantive workplace chat unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC073 | Chat Log: Alex Kim <-> Chris Evans
Date: May 8, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Alex Kim: hey are we still on for the lunch?
Chris Evans: yep works for me, see you then
| 05/08/25 | Alex Kim | Chris Evans | Chat | lunch | Not Relevant | Casual, non-substantive workplace chat unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC074 | From: Robert Smith <robert.smith@northstarcomm.com>
To: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
Date: January 25, 2025
Subject: Following up
Michael,
Thanks for the Sunrise Health Systems numbers last week. This is really helpful as we put our bid together. Can you also send the renewal dates for our other target ac... | 01/25/25 | Robert Smith | Michael Carter | Email | Following up | Relevant | Competitor confirms receipt of Apex pricing/customer information and requests more. | |
DOC075 | From: David Lee <dlee@apextelecom.com>
To: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
Date: February 22, 2025
Subject: Customer list access
Michael,
IT flagged that the customer master list was exported twice this month. Just confirming that was you for the renewal push?
David
| 02/22/25 | David Lee | Michael Carter | Email | Customer list access | Needs Human Review | References an export of the confidential customer list but frames it as a routine internal question - context needs verification. | |
DOC076 | Chat Log: Michael Carter <-> Alex Kim
Date: March 27, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Michael Carter: honestly kind of over it here, thinking about other options
Alex Kim: you should look around, no shame in that
| 03/27/25 | Michael Carter | Alex Kim | Chat | job search | Needs Human Review | Suggests Michael may have been considering leaving Apex, which is contextually relevant to motive but not direct evidence of disclosure. | |
DOC077 | Chat Log: Chris Evans <-> Nina Torres
Date: April 4, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Chris Evans: hey are we still on for the sports?
Nina Torres: yep works for me, see you then
| 04/04/25 | Chris Evans | Nina Torres | Chat | sports | Not Relevant | Casual, non-substantive workplace chat unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC078 | From: Sarah Johnson <sjohnson@apextelecom.com>
To: Karen Wilson <kwilson@apextelecom.com>
Date: March 7, 2025
Subject: Travel reimbursement
All,
Quick update on travel reimbursement - everything is on track, no action needed from you.
Sarah
| 03/07/25 | Sarah Johnson | Karen Wilson | Email | Travel reimbursement | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC079 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Jessica Nguyen <jessica.nguyen@northstarcomm.com>
Date: March 3, 2025
Subject: resume + intro
Jessica,
Great catching up. As promised, here's a summary of Apex's current top accounts and where I think Northstar could underbid us. Let's talk more once my offer is fina... | 03/03/25 | Michael Carter | Jessica Nguyen | Email | resume + intro | Relevant | Michael provides competitive intelligence about Apex's accounts to a Northstar employee while negotiating a job offer. | |
DOC080 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Robert Smith <robert.smith@northstarcomm.com>
Date: April 19, 2025
Subject: last batch
Robert,
This is the last batch I can get before my access is cut off - full account list with contract end dates. Good luck with the transition.
Michael
| 04/19/25 | Michael Carter | Robert Smith | Email | last batch | Relevant | Explicit statement that Michael is transmitting the full confidential account list before losing system access. | |
DOC081 | From: Robert Smith <robert.smith@northstarcomm.com>
To: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
Date: March 5, 2025
Subject: Following up
Michael,
Thanks for the Coastal Logistics numbers last week. This is really helpful as we put our bid together. Can you also send the renewal dates for our other target accounts?
... | 03/05/25 | Robert Smith | Michael Carter | Email | Following up | Relevant | Competitor confirms receipt of Apex pricing/customer information and requests more. | |
DOC082 | From: Alex Kim <akim@apextelecom.com>
To: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
Date: January 19, 2025
Subject: Meridian Corp check-in
Hi team,
Had a good call with Meridian Corp today. They're happy with service levels and we're on track for the standard renewal in Q3. Nothing unusual to report.
Alex
| 01/19/25 | Alex Kim | Michael Carter | Email | Meridian Corp check-in | Not Relevant | Routine, legitimate customer account update with no evidence of improper disclosure. | |
DOC083 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Alex Kim <akim@apextelecom.com>
Date: March 21, 2025
Subject: the numbers
Hey,
Can you send me the numbers we talked about? Want to have them ready before Friday.
Thanks
| 03/21/25 | Michael Carter | Alex Kim | Email | the numbers | Needs Human Review | Vague reference to 'the numbers' without enough context to determine whether this concerns confidential pricing/customer data. | |
DOC084 | From: David Lee <dlee@apextelecom.com>
To: Chris Evans <cevans@apextelecom.com>
Date: May 11, 2025
Subject: Company picnic
Hi Chris,
Just a reminder about company picnic. Let me know if you have questions.
David
| 05/11/25 | David Lee | Chris Evans | Email | Company picnic | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC085 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: David Lee <dlee@apextelecom.com>
Date: February 26, 2025
Subject: Conference room booking
All,
Quick update on conference room booking - everything is on track, no action needed from you.
Michael
| 02/26/25 | Michael Carter | David Lee | Email | Conference room booking | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC086 | ATTACHMENT
File Name: expense_policy.pdf
Date: May 18, 2025
Standard internal reference document. No customer, pricing, or confidential information related to the investigation.
| 05/18/25 | Attachment | expense_policy.pdf | Not Relevant | Generic internal reference material unrelated to the allegation. | |||
DOC087 | From: Chris Evans <cevans@apextelecom.com>
To: Alex Kim <akim@apextelecom.com>
Date: May 28, 2025
Subject: Company picnic
Hey,
Can you send me the agenda for company picnic? Want to make sure I'm prepared.
Thanks,
Chris
| 05/28/25 | Chris Evans | Alex Kim | Email | Company picnic | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC088 | From: Robert Smith <robert.smith@northstarcomm.com>
To: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
Date: June 14, 2025
Subject: Following up
Michael,
Thanks for the BlueWave Networks numbers last week. This is really helpful as we put our bid together. Can you also send the renewal dates for our other target accounts?
... | 06/14/25 | Robert Smith | Michael Carter | Email | Following up | Relevant | Competitor confirms receipt of Apex pricing/customer information and requests more. | |
DOC089 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Sarah Johnson <sjohnson@apextelecom.com>
Date: January 22, 2025
Subject: the numbers
Hey,
Can you send me the numbers we talked about? Want to have them ready before Friday.
Thanks
| 01/22/25 | Michael Carter | Sarah Johnson | Email | the numbers | Needs Human Review | Vague reference to 'the numbers' without enough context to determine whether this concerns confidential pricing/customer data. | |
DOC090 | From: David Lee <dlee@apextelecom.com>
To: Priya Patel <ppatel@apextelecom.com>
Date: June 8, 2025
Subject: Industry conference
Priya,
Saw that a rep from Northstar Communications was on the panel at the telecom conference last week. Nothing groundbreaking, mostly marketing talk.
David
| 06/08/25 | David Lee | Priya Patel | Email | Industry conference | Needs Human Review | Contains the competitor's name but appears to be innocuous industry commentary - context should be reviewed by a human. | |
DOC091 | From: Nina Torres <ntorres@apextelecom.com>
To: Alex Kim <akim@apextelecom.com>
Date: April 5, 2025
Subject: Sales contest results
All,
Quick update on sales contest results - everything is on track, no action needed from you.
Nina
| 04/05/25 | Nina Torres | Alex Kim | Email | Sales contest results | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC092 | MEETING NOTES
Title: Weekly Sales Standup
Date: June 27, 2025
Attendees: Karen Wilson, Chris Evans, Priya Patel
Discussed pipeline status, upcoming renewals, and staffing. No issues raised. Next meeting scheduled for two weeks out.
| 06/27/25 | Karen Wilson | Meeting Notes | Weekly Sales Standup | Not Relevant | Standard internal meeting notes with no connection to the competitor or confidential disclosures. | ||
DOC093 | Chat Log: David Lee <-> Michael Carter
Date: May 28, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Alex Kim: hey do you still have contacts at Northstar from before?
Michael Carter: a couple, why?
| 05/28/25 | David Lee | Michael Carter | Chat | quick question | Needs Human Review | Coworker asks Michael about competitor contacts; Michael's brief response doesn't confirm or deny improper conduct. | |
DOC094 | Chat Log: Alex Kim <-> Nina Torres
Date: April 10, 2025
Channel: Direct Message
Alex Kim: hey are we still on for the random question?
Nina Torres: yep works for me, see you then
| 04/10/25 | Alex Kim | Nina Torres | Chat | random question | Not Relevant | Casual, non-substantive workplace chat unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC095 | From: Nina Torres <ntorres@apextelecom.com>
To: Linda Park <lpark@apextelecom.com>
Date: April 13, 2025
Subject: CRM login issue
Hi Linda,
Just a reminder about crm login issue. Let me know if you have questions.
Nina
| 04/13/25 | Nina Torres | Linda Park | Email | CRM login issue | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC096 | MEETING NOTES
Title: Team Sync
Date: March 4, 2025
Attendees: Priya Patel, Karen Wilson, Sarah Johnson
Discussed pipeline status, upcoming renewals, and staffing. No issues raised. Next meeting scheduled for two weeks out.
| 03/04/25 | Priya Patel | Meeting Notes | Team Sync | Not Relevant | Standard internal meeting notes with no connection to the competitor or confidential disclosures. | ||
DOC097 | From: Nina Torres <ntorres@apextelecom.com>
To: Linda Park <lpark@apextelecom.com>
Date: June 24, 2025
Subject: Sales training materials
Hi,
Sharing an update on sales training materials. Nothing urgent, just keeping everyone informed.
Nina
| 06/24/25 | Nina Torres | Linda Park | Email | Sales training materials | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC098 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Alex Kim <akim@apextelecom.com>
Date: March 9, 2025
Subject: the numbers
Hey,
Can you send me the numbers we talked about? Want to have them ready before Friday.
Thanks
| 03/09/25 | Michael Carter | Alex Kim | Email | the numbers | Needs Human Review | Vague reference to 'the numbers' without enough context to determine whether this concerns confidential pricing/customer data. | |
DOC099 | From: Emily Brown <ebrown@apextelecom.com>
To: David Lee <dlee@apextelecom.com>
Date: January 25, 2025
Subject: Company picnic
Hey,
Can you send me the agenda for company picnic? Want to make sure I'm prepared.
Thanks,
Emily
| 01/25/25 | Emily Brown | David Lee | Email | Company picnic | Not Relevant | Routine internal administrative communication unrelated to the investigation. | |
DOC100 | From: Michael Carter <mcarter@apextelecom.com>
To: Sarah Johnson <sjohnson@apextelecom.com>
Date: April 26, 2025
Subject: Ran into an old contact
Sarah,
FYI I ran into an old industry contact at the conference last week - small talk, nothing more. Wanted to keep you in the loop since we know they're at a competitor n... | 04/26/25 | Michael Carter | Sarah Johnson | Email | Ran into an old contact | Needs Human Review | Michael proactively discloses contact with someone at a competitor but characterizes it as innocuous - requires human judgment on credibility. |
Apex Telecommunications Document Relevance Review (Synthetic)
A fully synthetic eDiscovery / internal-investigation dataset built to test whether an AI agent can perform first-pass relevance coding on a realistic, adversarial document population.
The scenario
Apex Telecommunications, Inc. suspects Senior Sales Manager Michael Carter of sharing confidential pricing and customer information with a competitor, Northstar Communications, before and during his departure from the company. The dataset contains 138 documents (emails, chat logs, meeting notes, and attachments) spanning the six-month investigation period (Jan 1 - Jun 30, 2025).
All people, companies, and events are fictional.
Why it's adversarial
The document set is deliberately constructed to defeat naive keyword-matching approaches:
- Keyword traps — the competitor's name appears in clearly irrelevant documents, and a similarly-named but unrelated company ("Northgate" vs. "Northstar") is designed to trigger false positives.
- Authorship bias — several benign documents are authored by the subject of the investigation.
- Document families — one relevant document's evidence lives entirely in an attachment referenced by a generic "see attached" email.
- Buried evidence — a genuinely relevant admission is nested inside a multi-level forwarded email chain.
- Genuine ambiguity — a set of documents are honestly unclear even to a human reviewer, testing whether a reviewer (human or AI) has the judgment to escalate rather than force a confident guess.
Labels
Each document is labeled with one of three classes:
| Label | Count | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
Relevant |
30 | Contains evidence of disclosure, competitor communication, intent, or concealment |
Not Relevant |
80 | Routine, unrelated business communication |
Needs Human Review |
28 | Genuinely ambiguous — should be escalated, not guessed |
Files
data.jsonl— one row per document:doc_id,text,date,author,recipient,cc,type,subject,label,reason. This is the file the Hugging Face Dataset Viewer will render and whatload_dataset()picks up automatically.documents/— the original raw documents as individual.txtfiles, in the format an agent would actually be handed (headers + body), for use in agentic/tool-use evaluations rather than plain classification.document_metadata.csv— the metadata table on its own.ground_truth.csv— the label/reason table on its own.review_protocol.docx— the relevance criteria reviewers (human or AI) were asked to apply.score_output.py— scores a model's predictions (ai_output.csv) againstground_truth.csv, reporting accuracy, precision, recall, and F1, withNeeds Human Reviewtreated as a correct escalation rather than a miss.
Loading
from datasets import load_dataset
ds = load_dataset("Vrishab80/apex-document-relevance-review")
print(ds["train"][0])
Intended use
Built as a course project testing whether a frontier AI agent can perform accurate, well-reasoned first-pass document relevance review. Useful as a small benchmark for agentic document review, legal-tech / eDiscovery tooling evaluation, or prompt-engineering experiments around grounded classification with an abstain option.
- Downloads last month
- 359