id stringlengths 21 21 | kind stringclasses 3
values | options listlengths 2 6 | target listlengths 2 6 | state stringlengths 171 246 | question stringclasses 7
values | domain stringclasses 1
value | family stringclasses 1
value | source stringclasses 1
value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
v3_921379c0e530be54_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.03,
0.03,
0.05,
0.27,
0.57,
0.05
] | A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_b3927949ca4e9c71_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.45,
0.55
] | An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue. | Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_8e5e44806cffbc0b_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.25,
0.74,
0,
0.01
] | An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_ccf40f8ad3cd4e0c_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.02,
0.4,
0.58,
0
] | A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_f49dcb68ae674c72_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.01,
0.08,
0.26,
0.36,
0.27,
0.02
] | A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_8b387e435a588e28_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.88,
0.12
] | A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_1c074a11b0185083_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.76,
0.23,
0.01,
0
] | An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_f4c8fbbda40ca67b_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.05,
0.05,
0.27,
0.5,
0.12,
0.01
] | A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_e47e7126a3eaa197_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.22,
0.78
] | An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_dabc9bbe9c19aeda_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.64,
0.36
] | A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor. | Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_e1d85e0de3af235a_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.24,
0.03,
0.55,
0.18
] | A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_823ce5508f4970db_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.02,
0.4,
0.56,
0.02
] | An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_45d2feb2c1001c42_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.14,
0.24,
0.31,
0.22,
0.08,
0.01
] | An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_3d37906e56f857b0_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.91,
0.09
] | A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue. | Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_f9db6260186531ad_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.04,
0.06,
0.84,
0.06
] | An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_454af686cfb8bdaf_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.79,
0.21
] | A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor. | Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_b6e471102ff8ead2_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.12,
0.23,
0.28,
0.26,
0.09,
0.02
] | An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_eb953ab3ef091e05_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.16,
0.84
] | A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator. | Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_80ab91df51694c85_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.59,
0.41
] | A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_17ca8ad52877a316_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.58,
0.42
] | A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_5dcde1ceb257eea0_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.08,
0.02,
0.71,
0.19
] | A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_f14e64f4bd6bae8d_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.1,
0.13,
0.11,
0.37,
0.24,
0.05
] | A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_9bcf0c1173e7f629_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.67,
0.33
] | A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_86890f39cc660dc8_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.38,
0.62
] | An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue. | Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_551b89dbfc52377f_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.84,
0.16
] | A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue. | Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_aaef30c1ff9bbd68_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.01,
0.01,
0.07,
0.45,
0.45,
0.01
] | A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_fdca00d869c82efa_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.07,
0.27,
0.28,
0.3,
0.07,
0.01
] | A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor. | Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_c24b2f86a1c336dd_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.02,
0.2,
0.36,
0.36,
0.05,
0.01
] | An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_b288b8b079cd0de0_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.02,
0.26,
0.7,
0.02
] | An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_91ec7023a086dd8a_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.12,
0.08,
0.11,
0.48,
0.2,
0.01
] | An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check. | Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_34bc65b940f184ae_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.86,
0.14
] | A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_4f00e7c5c7171462_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.1,
0.09,
0.17,
0.26,
0.34,
0.04
] | A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_668b7d184cd0aad3_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.88,
0.12
] | A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_0d379257433b00be_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.14,
0.71,
0.02,
0.13
] | An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_cbe8cb75e5359acc_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0,
0.48,
0.52,
0
] | A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_12e4e4b55c055ebe_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.07,
0.09,
0.08,
0.3,
0.42,
0.04
] | An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check. | Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_9bda57529422533b_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.49,
0.42,
0.08,
0.01
] | An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_391de218a986c03e_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.35,
0.12,
0.01,
0.52
] | An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_8b00cfeb687d329d_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.03,
0.86,
0.11,
0
] | An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_cffcc2ba66c060cb_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.03,
0.06,
0.13,
0.26,
0.46,
0.06
] | A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_ec724e4d0e10e0cb_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.02,
0.54,
0.44,
0
] | An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_874d779684283d80_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.04,
0.32,
0.58,
0.06
] | A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_8b78ea3ed947dbc4_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.5,
0.5
] | A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator. | Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_6837b018cb3f4c8c_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.04,
0.14,
0.12,
0.31,
0.38,
0.01
] | An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_0b37063d5f197ef0_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.04,
0.03,
0.7,
0.23
] | A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_3e10abef76b1c169_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.02,
0.31,
0.64,
0.03
] | A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_e524f32d0b2bd9f9_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.47,
0.53
] | A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system. | Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_93dabed265c122f1_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.73,
0.21,
0.06,
0
] | A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_8da0c9bd0322029c_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.23,
0.23,
0.11,
0.26,
0.14,
0.03
] | An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the operator. | Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_2eacae7898cc8471_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.38,
0.62
] | An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_727df6fcf2155dd4_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.37,
0.63
] | An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_188949afce8abc5f_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.13,
0.16,
0.24,
0.37,
0.09,
0.01
] | A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check. | Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_d2929e272de6497d_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.01,
0.35,
0.64,
0
] | A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_c394c055af579d6c_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.59,
0.41
] | An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_cf25cf58581a4da7_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.31,
0.68,
0.01,
0
] | A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_f221e7505dfd0d11_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.2,
0.35,
0.15,
0.25,
0.04,
0.01
] | An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_74cdcf04a4fda3ad_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.49,
0.5,
0.01,
0
] | An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_7e35d01c5cdd2463_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.01,
0.04,
0.25,
0.49,
0.2,
0.01
] | An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_933547979d8c63d7_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.77,
0.23
] | A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue. | Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_bbee4b07ce71cf50_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.09,
0.83,
0.08,
0
] | A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_2b35b62d6c8ec711_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.17,
0.25,
0.3,
0.2,
0.06,
0.02
] | A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue. | Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_3e5b1e8b399c29ec_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.58,
0.42
] | A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_80c1c6da5808923f_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.05,
0.07,
0.13,
0.35,
0.37,
0.03
] | A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system. | Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_50d5a926fd031c5a_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.81,
0.19
] | A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_8379018e170dbfa3_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.43,
0.57
] | An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system. | Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_f6185f252539612d_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.48,
0.31,
0.19,
0.02
] | A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_43a888ec41447ae5_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.43,
0.57
] | An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_fcd5a633bfc1c857_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.57,
0.31,
0.12,
0
] | A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_69c9f9c64368b6c5_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.71,
0.29
] | A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_e8761c8bc4b9a523_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.3,
0.47,
0.05,
0.18
] | A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_9dc5fa52c4efe6cb_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.9,
0.1
] | An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system. | Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_ead4e334d514c361_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.48,
0.33,
0.16,
0.03
] | A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_b06ed2be4ef6b1c5_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.02,
0.93,
0.05,
0
] | A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_1db87b833fed14e8_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.08,
0.07,
0.1,
0.52,
0.22,
0.01
] | A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check. | Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_f3c3c233971851de_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.14,
0.18,
0.29,
0.32,
0.06,
0.01
] | An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue. | Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_e8341fdbab1805a1_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.3333,
0.5455,
0.1111,
0.0101
] | A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_ecfae306bdef8d33_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.16,
0.11,
0.38,
0.31,
0.03,
0.01
] | A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system. | Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_6b21fd1a1558e7fe_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.13,
0.22,
0.22,
0.27,
0.13,
0.03
] | A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system. | Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_cc6058933795f5f9_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.15,
0.73,
0.11,
0.01
] | A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_1a6b105984c92e5d_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.13,
0.09,
0.21,
0.36,
0.2,
0.01
] | A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_4e7914f96b93f3bf_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.72,
0.14,
0.01,
0.13
] | A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_dc2e892acb163c5f_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.27,
0.73
] | An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer. | Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_a5d98e954df8dee6_c | choice | [
"replicate",
"design_falsification_test",
"abandon",
"fund_fully"
] | [
0.66,
0.29,
0.05,
0
] | A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check. | Next step for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_35923327e32c9527_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.65,
0.35
] | A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer. | Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_eab7303ea50c0db8_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.21,
0.53,
0.25,
0.01
] | An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_d78fbca79e7944bf_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.45,
0.55
] | A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_4f819b236e4738c4_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.69,
0.31
] | An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_0254ef73eaf0baaf_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.36,
0.64
] | An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator. | Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_d2929e272de6497d_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.09,
0.08,
0.1,
0.48,
0.23,
0.02
] | A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor. | Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_29820e5e24e1fbc7_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.23,
0.38,
0.19,
0.13,
0.05,
0.02
] | A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_bcaba9b3a072961e_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.21,
0.23,
0.13,
0.35,
0.06,
0.02
] | A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_44643d7118da6e5a_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.07,
0.4,
0.52,
0.01
] | A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_d20a5f7cc326010b_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.09,
0.84,
0.07,
0
] | A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_4abcef60be92938f_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.31,
0.69
] | A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_595e1e19ddeb36ae_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.28,
0.72
] | A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_2736514b6bdcf013_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.5,
0.5
] | A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor. | Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_cb5856c165d5bcb1_c | choice | [
"strongly_supported",
"tentatively_supported",
"unsupported",
"contradicted"
] | [
0.03,
0.18,
0.72,
0.07
] | A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor. | Verdict for this scenario. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_768c8fbb52c8f38c_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.01,
0.17,
0.49,
0.3,
0.03,
0
] | A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer. | Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_794ec1aa944f2239_s | score | [
"0",
"1",
"2",
"3",
"4",
"5"
] | [
0.09,
0.16,
0.28,
0.33,
0.12,
0.02
] | A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue. | Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale. | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
v3_5debf4498610dd5a_n | noul | [
"false",
"true"
] | [
0.24,
0.76
] | An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue. | Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable? | hypothesis_eval | science | yuri_v3 |
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio
JEV corpus - hypothesis_eval
7,884 typed calibrated decision rows from the jev-distill-corpus-v3 corpus (domain: hypothesis_eval).
Each row is one typed decision: kind (noul / choice / score), a state, a question, options, and a target probability distribution over the options.
Part of the per-domain split of SargeDev/jev-distill-corpus-v3 - the full corpus in one repo.
Domains:
- Downloads last month
- 27