4- ;j:i?i?fSis|; j 1 "." J,l [^''•' 'J^^'"' "•" """ "•"•""••'.'-.;- y "''''"''SSf'wfwm^w^wm^ '^.'•v'- WHCTI fl»*ll«n 311^I'q3W ('iql^l'i'T) 311^1 W ft-fi'b W 311^1 iBlil' ?«tpa<^iicti <*ii<s<i N0. 11 'ETITIONBR V.S. Salwait, about 57 t' Service ia Goveraor S' fCGI Verstas ?ESPONDENTS 1. State of C'b^. Secretary, G|( Raipur Distrij: R;,K. Shriv^ Chliattisgart4 Raipur, Disti|ict Writ PetitioB under Artlcle 226y|227 ofthe Coastitutioa of India B Hou'ble SSui Dhlrendra Misy»a.J Mr. Suiul Sahu, leamed Mr, Rakesh Jha., leamed PL Dst Grieyaiice of fhe petitioner is |onsidered by fhe respondent NQ, ras dowu below in fhe. gradation iyoverainent Of&cers, was proniotep tjide order of Amiexure P/ 1 dated tjie petitioner has prayed for dir( [roiaote fhe petitioner on the post •*l<lfd<il"f ^roffif ftret Tfa^R iTsifiman^i 17 OF 2003 son of late Shri N.L. Salwar, aged ears, occupation Under Secretaiy, State Ministiy, Raipur posted at icretariat, Raipur, District Raipur attisgarh, through Secretary, Chief •neral Arlrmnistration Departinent, ;tRaipur(CG) . stava, Upper Sachiv State of Industrial and Miiiing Departinent, Raipur (CG) coui^el for the petitioner, fhe State. fd>r piat his case for proiuotion was not ./State and respondent No.2, who of Under Secretaries of 'A' Class to fhe post of Deputy Secretary 16.3.2002. In these circuiustances, iction to the respoudent No. 1 to [of Deputy Secretary, from fhe date ?iis^N^N ^suiicWf <ra:if?I)t^— FS/95—11/2008—1,00,000. T •^ V/ ...SS^ -^Y'^.-^^rA^,.^^ '3^''<ll<.l|(yl<^»flliH*l<o, R«11«lj,< dll^Sll^it Rti'B WII ail^ifl stiiro III*(CTI fl»*ti<n 3n^('T3a?('^f^S?) ^'WK<R ^ffea dii^<i 'hlllsl'fl'l *114<fl ^i ft^t <(a|<s;l< ' ^? siRpr oit^i when respondent No.2 was liromo.ted, along with consequential beuefits. I Leanied counsel for fhe Ipetitiouer subiuits th.at the petitiouer has ah-eady retu-ed from. service^ in. the year 2006 duruig peudency of J±uspetitiou.. | The icspondeut/State i^i its retum has subiuitted that proiiiotion on the post of Depu|ty Secretary fi-om. Uuder Secretary, is • ^iven on fhe .basis.;of inerit-cuii^-seiuonty on ftie reGoiumendations o.f fhe Departmental Rromotion Cotumttee. The DPC was held in. the year, 1997. There were fhree' posts aj reports offive years were requiijed for consideratLoa ofcan.didature of eaeh individual for th.e purpos^ conlidential reports of fh.e petil^orier for the year enduig 31Bt March, 1999 aud 2001 were not avail^ble with ftie DPC and therefore, the .petitionei s case for promotion complete record of respondent I^ averred that after receipt offhe <| the year eading 31st March, 199^ also be considered aad if he is i the post of Deputy Secretary, h| yailable for promotion aad confidential of.prom.otion by fhe DPC. However, was postponed, whereas, fhere was o.2 wifh fhe DPC and accordiugly, he was proiaoted to &e post of I^eputy Secretary. It has been farther ^onfideatial reports ofthe petttioner for ? aad 2001 by fhe DPC^.his case would fouiid fit and suitable for.proinotion to would be given benefit of promotion aud other ancillary benefits. Mr. Jha, leamed counse]| appearuig for fhe State/respondeuts submits fhat case of fhe petitlo]|ier for proiaotion would be considered ^tTft^k ^t^T %sl"(I^T W4-f1^1t^—FS/95-—11/2008—1,00,000. KSn n "'(.' >: 'l Sv' .4- '%. i /^^VS u-l"~1 '<i ^&s' ^. ^.: ^-^-i,^:. »^-^^^-^.^^J4y^^^.^i^A^'-^^*-^ •3-n»'<<i<.ii<i<i,'®nl'H<re,;(»«nw^' ii*«nia»*<i<t> SfI^CT'f^: (11(3*1'^) an^t vi \f.-n* WI Sltit^l aii t:,,; .^, <.<,... b <'(<fl<tl< <rf^t ^tt^H 3 after'Teceipt'.o'fhis confidential aad decision shaU be taken ia tfai ^,,g^.-,Ia..w^|^of above subm, t, the instaat to c.onsider fhe l.goanbnsnoiteimofril , tfae post of Deputy Secretaiy withiD.fe^period of eight weeks law. ' i^ports, within. a period of eight weeks ls regard, [ssions of leamed counsel for the is disposed ofwith a direction to iase offhe petitioner for proinotion to '~ af|er receipt of his coiifidential reports, decide the saine in accordauce with peption achl <t>I^<fi'') lfl4fl? ^f 1^'it <f^<$f< '^sifipi^n^ S(V- Dhu'endraMishra Juc^e ^Sff ^^i^^li'9-n'^ri^—fS/95-— 11 /2008—1 ^00,000. • i: > 1 '.;