IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT : THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.R.RAMAN & THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE T.R.RAMACHANDRAN NAIR TUESDAY, THE 18TH NOVEMBER 2008 / 27TH KARTHIKA 1930 AS.No. 309 of 1993(D) --------------------- OS.4/1985 OF THE SUB COURT, TIRUR .................... APPELLANTS/PLAINTIFFS: --------------------- 1. PUTHEN VALAPPIL AHAMMED'S CHILDREN BEERANKUTTY. 2. KUNHIMOHAMMED. 3. UMMACHAKUTTY. 4. PATHUMMAKUTTY. (ALL ARE RESIDING AT KANMANAM AMSOM AND DESOM IN TIRUR TALUK) BY ADV. SRI.P.N.KRISHNANKUTTY ACHAN(SR.) SRI.T.SETHUMADHAVAN RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS: --------------- 1. PARAKUNNATH KUNHU'S SON MOIDEENKUTTY. 2. PARAKUNNATH ISMAIL'S CHILDREN ENIKUTTY 3. MAMMIKUTTY. 4. PARAKUNNATH KUNHASSAN'S SON KUNHAMMAD. 5. PARAKUNNATH MYINKUTTY'S CHILDREN KUNHASSANKUTTY. 6. KUNHAMMAD. 7. HAMZA. 8. KUNHEEMA UMMA. 9. VEERAUMMA, W/O.PLAKKAL IBRAIN. 10. PATHUMMA UMMA, W/O.MELEPEEDIKAKKAL MUHAMMED. -2- A.S.NO.309/93 11. AYAMMA UMMA. 12. AMINA UMMA. 13. VETTIKKATU VALIYA ALASSANKUTTY'S CHILDREN AYAMMU. 14. ABUTTY. 15. KADEESA. 16. PATHUMMA. 17. PARAKUNNATH ENIKUTTY[S CHILDREN ISMAIL. 18. YAHU. 19. NABEESA. 20. MUHAMMED. 21. AYISHA. 22. SAIDALIKUTTY. 23. JAMEELA. 24. SAFIYA. 25. KUNHIKADIYA. 26. PARAKUNNATH MOIDEENKUTTY'S WIFE MAMMALI UMMA. 27. CHILDREN MUHAMMED. 28. KADEEJAKUTTY. 29. THITHACHU. 30. UMMACHU, W/O.VATTAMANNIL ISMAIL. 31. PATHUMMA, W/O.AYYATHAKANI. 32. VIRIYAKUTTY, W/O.KANJATHODI ALAVI. 33. BEEVIKUTTY, W/O.KAYALMADATHIL KARAVATH KUNJIPPA. 34. AYISAKUTTY, W/O.THAZHATHE AL-SUBAR. 35. ANJATH KANHIRANKATH MUHAMMED. 36. ANIYAMTHODI ABDUL MAJID, S/O.KUTTU. -3- A.S.NO.309/93 37. PARAKUNNATH MAMMIKUTTY'S CHILDREN SAFIYA, W/O.KOORIPARAMBIL HAMZA. 38. PARAKUNNATH ABU, S/O.ISMAIL. 39. VILAKKATH YAHU HAJI, S/O.KAMMUKUTTY. 40. THE SECRETARY, ATHAVANAD SERVICE CO-OP. BANK, P.O.ATHAVANAD. 41. A.K.MUHAMMED ALIAS BABBUTTY, PRESIDENT, NAJAMUTHAL HUDA MADRASSA. 42. KOTTARADHIKARATH VELAYUDHAN NAIR ALIAS UNNI, S/O.LAKSHMI AMMA. 43. PULIKKATHODI BAVA, S/O.ALIYAMMU. 44. POOLAKKAD MARAKKAR'S SON MOIDEEN. 45. KUNJIKADIYUMMA. 46. KAVUMPURATH AMINA, W/O.MANAKKATHODI SAIDALIKUTTY. 47. VATTAMANNIL MAMMUTTY, S/O.MOIDEEN. 48. VATTAMANNIL MAMMAD'S CHILDREN AIDRU. 49. SAIDALI. 50. IBRAYIN. 51. VALLIYAKATHODI IMBICHI BEEVI. 52. SON ATTAKOYATHANGAL. 53. VATTIKKATTI KAMMU, S/O.MOIDEENKUTTY HAJI. 54. KALATHIL THODI KUNHAPPAN, S/O.POCKER. 55. PARAKUNNATH ISMAIL'S WIFE AYISHAKUTTY. 56. CHILDREN IBRAHIM. 57. VEERAN. 58. AYAMU. 59. ABDULLA. 60. ABU. 61. KUNHASSANKUTTY. -4- A.S.NO.309/93. 62. KUNHEERIYA. Respondents 1 to 4, 6 to 8, 11 to 16, 26 to 28, 30 to 32, 35, 36, 38 to 62 are residing at Athavanad amsom, desom in Tirur Taluk, 5th respondent is residing in Muthoor amsom and desom, Ponnani Taluk, R9 in Vadakkumbram amsom, Mavandiyoom desom, Tirur Taluk, R10 and 34 in Vadakkumbram amsom and desom in Tirur Taluk, R17 to 25 at Athavanad amsom and desom in Tirur Taluk, R29 in Vengal amsom and desom in Perinthalmanna Taluk, R33 in Ananthavoor amsom and desom in Tirur Taluk, R37 in Kuttipuram amsom and desom in Tirur Taluk in Malappuram District. ADV. SRI.K.RAMACHANDRAN FOR R27 & 39 SRI M GOPIKRISHNAN FOR R40 SMT.T.K.SREEKALA FOR R5,6,8,9,11 &12 SRI.K.T.SANKARAN FOR R27 & 39 THIS APPEAL SUITS HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 18/11/2008, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: P.R.RAMAN & T.R.RAMACHANDRAN NAIR,JJ. ------------------------------- A.S.NO.309 OF 1993 -------------------------------- Dated this the 18th day of November, 2008 JUDGMENT Raman,J. Since some of the respondents were not served, the matter was posted in the defect list. This Court by order dated 1-4-2008 directed to take out notice by paper publication and to take steps in this regard within a week. Even thereafter a proper petition was not filed and defect cured. However, taking a lenient view we extended the time for filing a proper petition till the re-opening of this Court as per order dated 11/4/2008. Several months elapsed thereafter and even today the matter continues to be defective. Hence, we dismiss the appeal for non-prosecution. P.R.RAMAN, Judge. T.R.RAMACHANDRAN NAIR, Judge. kcv. -2- WP(C).No. P.R.RAMAN & T.R.RAMACHANDRAN NAIR,JJ. --------------------------- A.S.NO.309 OF 1993 --------------------------- JUDGMENT 18TH NOVEMBER, 2008