CWP 764/2009 [1] IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT JAIPUR BENCH O R D E R (1) SB Civil Writ Petition No.764/2009 Madan Lal and others. Versus. Jaipur Development Authority & another (2) SB Civil Writ Petition No.765/2009 Smt. Raukmani Devi and others. Versus. Jaipur Development Authority & another (3) SB Civil Writ Petition No.766/2009 Kana and another. Versus. Jaipur Development Authority & another (4) SB Civil Writ Petition No.10420/2009 Jaipur Development Authority, Jaipur Versus. Madan Lal and others. (5) SB Civil Writ Petition No.15305/2009 Jaipur Development Authority Versus. Kana Ram and others. (6) SB Civil Writ Petition No.15306/2009 Jaipur Development Authority Versus. Smt. Rukmani Devi and others. DATE OF ORDER : 15/03/2010 HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY RASTOGI Mr. Ashok Gaur with Mr. Saransh Saini, for petitioners (CWP-764/09, 765/09 & 766/09) and for respondents in CWP-10420/2009, 15305/2009 and 15306/2009. Mr. AK Gupta with Mr. Rinesh Gupta for respondents in CWP-764/2009, 765/2009 & 766/2009 Since the controversy involved in the above writ petitions arises from common order, the same are being decided by the present order. The writ petitions No. 764/2009, 765/2009 and CWP 764/2009 [2] 766/2009 have been filed by the Ex-Khadetars with the grievance that they are entitled for 15% of the developed land in lieu of the land acquired and despite the JDA Tribunal having decided in their favour, still it has not been implemented by the JDA. AT the same time the JDA has also filed writ petitions No.10420/2009, 15305/2009 & 15306/2009 assailing the order of the Tribunal passed by favour of the Khatedars. Counsel for Khatedars-petitioners submits that the identical order passed by the Tribunal in Appeal No. 107/2005, Lal Ram and others Vs. JDA dt.18/10/2005, on the reference made by individual Khatedars, it was directed by the Tribunal for allotment of 15% of the developed land to the ex-Khatedars was challenged by the JDA by way of Civil Writ Petition No. 539/2009, JDA Vs. Lala Ram, which came to be dismissed on 11/01/2010. Counsel further submits that the order passed by the Tribunal in the cases of petitioners-Ex- Khatedars is also identical and since the issue has been decided by the Court in writ petition filed by the JDA assailing the order passed by the Tribunal vide judgment dated 11/01/2010, referred to supra, the writ petitions filed by the JDA bearing No.10420/2009, 15305/2009 and 15306/2009 deserves to be dismissed and at the CWP 764/2009 [3] same time the respondent-JDA may be directed to implement the order of the Tribunal. Counsel for JDA has not been able to controvert that the Writ Petition No. 539/2009 preferred by JDA against the order passed by the JDA Appellate Tribunal in the appeal of a similarly placed Ex-Khatedar Lala Ram, has been dismissed by this Court on 11/01/2010. Accordingly, Civil Writ Nos.10420/2009, 15305/2009 & 15306/2009 filed by the JDA are hereby dismissed and Civil Writ Nos.764/2009, 765/2009 and 766/2009 filed by the Ex-Khatedars petitioners are allowed and the JDA is directed to implment the order of the JDA Tribunal within four months from the date of communication of this order. No order as to costs. [AJAY RASTOGI], J. Raghu/p.3/ 764CW2009-finl.doc