F rmar ati MMM i O 2009:: V SanJay u' K; son of V an Lal Kada ae / 1. Shrl Moh gd abouT 45 years / 2. $mf. Ka ‘d f f w'ra Kaak, wie o na u uT 4,2‘ o ’ smma, Ramd‘shahkai ‘S h u:k about 40 yi, reid f ‘ ear's' s’e’hf o agar" , r ‘ ou i : r‘ ‘ Amm aid Bhawn q ,S dJ: . ec r'e’r‘ry w /'a, 'R‘aiur’ ’for‘, Rg S u b-R eg Ls ’r r‘ ah, PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226/27 OF TE“ CONsTITUTION OF INDIA . PARTICULARs OE P‘gTITIoNERs;_ As menioneVd in r’hé cause‘TiTle T ’ . . PARTIcuLARs oEiVRE's‘VPoNjb'ENTsu AsgmenTioned’ in TFE‘caus‘e TiHe ‘ . W P (c) NO PETITIONERS Shri aged 'abQ Iyke'~’ ‘ iBofh Hlder VSqj‘y Km " Thrgh“, 1 A $hr‘i 50“ 4 N, 1), Khama‘ndih, g fhe Through M‘anTrala"); p CG . TheCo‘‘Heo fp , . The Ralpur‘ 2 H ‘ / hallEnge In this petition Is to the endorsemént made by the Sub L Registrar (R) Ralpur on the back Side of the sale deed date r 08/07/2009 (Annexure P/1) whereby the Sub Registrar (R) declined - e > the‘eglstratron of the sale deed on the ground that pursuant to th ‘rorderi dated 29/06/2007 (Annexure P/2) passed by the Collector i :Ralpur true copy of the Khasra and Form B 1 has to be certified b I the Revenue Offtcer under Rule 19 (o) of the Madhy a "Pradesh/Chhattlsgarh Reglstr ules 193 orshort“the Rules “1939”), as modified b e Stat of Chhattls arh Vlde notlflcatl 3 LC -V d y? a ’ atl :R 9 f / y h ‘ onw , 7/06/2002 The, 'etltlonerslfurther challenge the order dae arpu a ,- . l ‘ ‘ ,.date ’ ‘9/06/2007 (Annex k :2 u acts In nutshell for properadjudrcatlon fthe case are tha oners are the own s of arrous ,propertres “ vrsr mamtamed under the pro L 2 td H Rr hs f t 3, l s V I; Officer The act of the respondent authorities Is Illegal and arbitrary Learned counsel fui‘ther submits that refusal on the part of the. ' ' ” Regrstenng authonty Is not only opposed to the public polrcy, but ' K ; - ‘ ' lso Invahd and constltutronally not sust ’Inable Thus this ‘ petrtron The sole ground raised by Shrl Sharma lear' ed counsel appearing - ‘ forlthe petltloners rs that Rule 19(0) of the R41les 1939 Inserted by ' ' notrflcatlon dated 27/06/2002 Co‘of form 31 and Khasra should f be certrfred by the Authorised Reve e Offlcej or concermng Halka Patwan The Registration Offrcer has declrn ‘d to reglster the sale; l eed of the petitioners on the ground that the same was not certified by the Authorised Revenue Officer The impdgned action taken by he rovrsrons respondent of law authorities is illegal arbitragry and agarnsttheu 1 / (n the other hand Shri Bhaduri learned Panelé Lawyer appearing for he State submits that the Collector by order dated 29/06/2007 Annexure R/1) directed all the District Registrar and Sub Registrar o the effect that the revenue records such as copy of B 1‘ and , Khasra should contained the endorsement by; the Revenue fficer ' . hat te entries made is the said documens ae duly certrfied In Rin t h t t Pustika Learned counsel revenue t ecords which were not duly certified by the Revenue Authority a ' ‘ presented he sale deed ong wrt the copi t p rregularity in returning thevdocuments to the’ petitioners a cc ‘d'ng the petrtioners are not entitled to any relie he Rules 1939 were the prowsmns of Sectlon 69 of ‘ ‘ g t o', l t or he egrstration Act 1908 (fo sh he Act 1908") The Inspect- " ‘ of Registration of the St erritories under the Sta ime to make rules con3is f S tion 69 of the Act 19 ‘, ‘ . i a , py i d .V t p O t t ( of reqUIred r nd ‘r nd _ a f ' ‘ r T fr l ” a 1 ‘ " general superintendenc‘ over all ‘ ', t t v t t o 08 a the registrtion offices and A a l - n i S ctlons 69 & 71 ofthe Act 1908 reads as lm’der “69 Power of Inspector General to supermtend regustratuon offices and make r Ies — (1) The Inspector-General : shall exercus a general supenntendence over all the regustrat on offuces m the terntones under the (State Govern ent) and shall have power from time to time to make rules consrstent wrth thrs Act (a) , prOVIdIng for the ste custody of books papers v and documents _ - ,hlch and the a safeguards ’ ’ whrc the books may be kept m computer flop o dls'kettes or In any other section electronic 16A] form under‘ L -sectlon (1) of (aa) provrdmg U declaring what language shall be deemed to be commonly used In each drstrlctl declarlng what territorial dlvrsrons shall be recognlzed under section 21 l; regulatmg the amou’ ’ ‘ ‘f fmesllmposed under sections 25 and 34 es ectlvely, regulatmg the, exe Ise of the drscretron regulatmg th form In whrch regrstenng officers are to make m or’anda'ofrdocuments regulatmg the ‘ thentrcatron by Registrars and rSub- Reglstrars of the books kept In therr 9 declaring the partrculars to be contamed In 'Indexes Nos i ii llland lVrespectIvely, _ declarmg the holidays that shall be observed In Z V .generally, regulatmg the proc dings of the Registrars and Sub Registrar The rules so made shall be submitted to the [State Government] for approva and after they have been approved they shall be published In the [OffICIal Gazette] and on publication shall have effect as If enacted In this Act 71. Reasons for refusal to reglster to be recorded —\ (1) Every Sub Registrar refusmg to register a document except on the ground that the property to which It relates Is not Sltuate Within his subdlstrlct shall make an order of refusal and record his reasons for such’order In his Book N02 and endorse the words-eg tratlon refused" on the document and on application made by any perso executing or claming under the document shall 1thout payment “nd unnecessary delay, give him opy of the reasons so recorded eturned for amen ment c supply of ' omISSIons - . xxx ”xxx , XXX xxx ~xxx rg'xxx R r ule 19 of the Rules 1939 p des for r_ Urn of documents fo orrectlon etc Clause (o) t ll the lands Involved In the Inst nt cas dmittedly, the documentgf he Patwarl H'owever,_‘orJI Annexure P/2) passed by h ‘l’e's; 1 939; the registr u at ‘i3w a c c mr orr‘ A: f1 ‘ I r xc o ~ » A e A r‘ " t t ( e t ‘ he ‘Collector has no unsuctuon o amend a art or entire rules b T Jd t p y th d ftt Th b pp tft s e orer as aoresaed ere has to e a roer noiicaion a rOVIde uner he rOVISIons o aw n erusa o te ue 9 o v of the Rues It cear aears at I e co o asra an orm l Is certiied e atwan the same us admISSIble for gtratlon of documents n e case on an e elsenng uthorl has wronl decllne l féc f Kh d f B 1 c ed b th Re hich Is not he rewrem (o) prov1es th opy of hasra and form B ma be cerlled either b the evenu e orer asse wdelme and not m accorance Wi te rovus as well as the Rules 1939 e earne IVISIon enc of e i our o aa r I . pd d t p f I O pl f h Rl 1 () l 1939 lly pp th ft py f Kh d "f B f by th P ” rels I th hd th Rgt At gy d’ h gt t y ther h gd tt “te reisration no on an o ,cept te roun ha opy o asra an orm wer not du y e evenu w t qe i d at c K 1 y tf y e Officer or Patwan Th d pd by thp Collector Is a mere g d th h pwns of the Act 1908 " Th ld D Bh th Hgh Ct f Mdhy Padesh lndre enc u Reistrar o Asuances ndoe and AnOther1, ,hlet'nid th idtil sr lr wicosering ie enca provsuons oserve as unde r bd r t ‘ “16 p N1 hl g : t h dh h tty s h oh e constrained to hol :‘ whlle refuslng to register baSIs of some mstructrons'fr m' the Collector was certalnly accordance With Iaw There coul 7 et t t to la ' (s rriding ffect n t ty pg a . o 5984) sho seek Justifcaton fr refsal t d u n 1 detion from the ddtiona ollector 7 d apln e wel ettl rncipes 'o e acs o te resent case Wiou om into te merit of e case as i reuireverificaion uner th rowsmns o aw orer o e eiseri J tori ecining eister e ocumens as well as e orer ae asse he Collector aiur are contrar t s an he same deserve o e uase l, ..... The resondent o wle purportin o act In te lscarge of is sautor dutle as to exclude such Instruc ns w hav xecuive instrucions conrary uch instructions have any ove o he satutor rowsmnsof l tht fct f h‘ C d he note a in a o t ourts irection t appelate order dated 25 2 1983 (in M P l N / ii o u o register the ment o irc Ai ,C F the easons mentioned herenabove or , r i 4 1 y 2 AIR 1985 Madha Pradesh 1 (o Bh) Sb g f n Kallash and Others , . n pyig th l sed pil f th law ‘ ft f h p tht gg h th t qst d e‘ p f l d f th Rgtng , uhty dl to rg th dt th d dtd 29/6/2007 pd ' by t Rp y o the statutory prOVISIon d t t b qhd ,. mEuS o: :6 amoxwam 9“Em mam ammaQw$a omaimooo . >23mxc6 3: man5w oaQ qw$am \oQNooNA>zzmxc$ 33 umwwma Ex3w Oo=mgor mEvE m6 ,gCTMgQ. _o:m,2_o_wcmmAoo 0* .H, am? awomsa 93$ arm mwggmq a‘ mgma8 mxm3§¢§m aoocBwEw 0*E ozwqw3 moooawanm 55 #:mt8 H . 1 Ema w i Em Ema: 5w mzgoqmmama 33m 3 :6 mcvxmmi q Axv Av m m $ _ wqosmmosm 2 5m> r$3 mag.Eoamma >ooo_d3m_<_ H3mw<<1&vm§_o: a m osma8 3 ~ 2o oaQ mmo 08$. _ xnmsa Sawomamg mco<m. max- wmmmmr N. >ml§a~1 m