l WQéH €3€3L§RT Q? C§%E'§ATT§$GARE*E AT EILA$PHR EEVE$§GM EENSE‘E \ Qwam‘ : EIQN’gLE $§§R§ gf-EJEEV GQ’TWA P J & §3§SN5%§.E 3%Ri $W‘xi i. aL§i§W§k§§ $E §’€& «.5 §¥3§§€L @Qsew N3: ”m? a? 21mg £133 ELLEN?§ ”a. Saraswaié 831i Chandmkar, Wm Q. Laué‘NR? Haw Kumar Chamrakai agsd abam: 4O years. €‘éand Kumar Chandmkar, SXG Laie 6%1harahu La£ Cham‘rakar‘ aged abmzt 412 years. ' M resident; of vi3§age 8: RQ. Faffaud, PS. Aramg, ms‘it. Ram}? (0G) w RwfDUi’ \Cu} QvmEY {3f hum” gyCiC N!) C ..; 104/(‘DH 395. The New mdia énsumnce Company Limiied: By Dixii$mna§ Managez: The New %n€%%a insmanse Co. L‘Ed‘, RDA. Bmkiirag, Bairwg Mamet, GE. Raad. Raémur (CGA RwCELL§W§QUQ AF?:AL LNDER S33 mix iKi GF ‘EHE WGTGR VEHIGLE5 £1”? xag @resent. Sm t: C Vcrma Ieamed counse§ 19 we agapemms Shrz Aham’ Gupta earnei cemse; fvr gespaww “m2 @RagR gag?“ tsgawr gmg§ Tha fo§1ewin§ ordef of fne Caurt was passed by Verwg $€ES§€ER¥EENT§ i. rasharai" Kumar, Sio Budh $é€3N=£§PL§C§§§§ Cr‘hw ham? R/ VM. & Pcsi ranaud r” Maw 1 h & Disti b) Learngd counsei far ihe partias; are heard on M‘CP. NQ.Q27I2QQ6, a p€i§wn far com‘jwa‘tian G§ i‘ne de§ay in fi§§ng the EEESEL 0n due canSkjeration of tha submiéssiens of lea-med caunae! fer the pariies awd we gmundS tezken in the petétion, we are ( "tie‘féed that {he apgeilame have euceeecied in ehewing euniciem £.€ §‘ U) e f0? the deiey in fiéing ‘Ehe ameai. om (’)1 3. ?€E.C‘P. Ne. §2W2QQ§ themfore, i3 aiéewed and Ehe deiay of 42 days in féiing the ag3pee§ ie hereby canecned. 4. Sim SC. Verme, ieemed eeunsei fer the appeltante ie heard en admgeeion. 5‘ The epgeimme am seeking enhancement of i‘ne compensatien awarded by {he Ninth'Additionai Mater Accidents Ciaims Tribune; Reipur {m short, ‘the Tribunei’} wide award dated 21122065, paseed in Ciaim Gaee Ne.56/20{35 6‘ fee egamei qe compeneetion cf Re.6,42,f}{3i3f— cieimed ey the amaei§enief eieimame. unfer‘tuaate parente of deceaeed Mo‘nit Kumar Chaneraker by fiémg a ciaim peiition under Seciicn 1&3-A of i’he Mater Vehiciee Act for his death in ihe mam accident on 92.13.2GQ3, the Trihunet awarcied e {oiai sum of Refe ,Q0,00G,’- ee oompeneatien eieng wiih interesi @ 9% per ennum fmm me eeie ef fiémg cf éhe deim petiiion ti§& 'L'he date of acme; pavmeni. {e Shri 3C. Verme, Eeemed oeuneeé for i’ne eppeHents vehementéy argued met the ‘(ri‘eunei here erred in awareéng [aw cempenea‘iien e? Re? ,QQDEQL onéy. e )Ex FWM mmwwwq ' m '— 'W“ a . m n w a wwwmmw, Q9) 8. The Tribunal assessed {he incame 0f the decea$ed a? Rs.1,500!— ger month and Rs.18,DGOI— per amum. By deducting 11’3“ 9§ R$.’18,0€)Q/” towara‘és the parscna! expemes a? ihe dgcga$e¢ iha daimants’ dependency was asse$sed a? R$l12,0QQ!- per annum. By muétipiying ’xhe annuai dependency cf Rs.€2,QQG!- wi'ih me mul‘iipiier of i5, the comaénsa§on wa$ werked Gut m Rs.1,3Q,QOOf—. By awarding furiher 3mm of fQsJQEQG/n unner miner heads, the Tribuna} awarded n tom; sum of Rs.1,90,DDO/- as compensation tn the deimants for the death bf their son Mohi‘i Kumar Chandraka? in the meior accident, 9. .Even if the income e? “the éeceesed is assessec’i ei Rs‘35,0QQI— on Me basis oi the neiionai inceme in i'ne year 290:3; and 33% of RssaO-GQL is deducted tewarde the pereenei exeensee 9f the eeceeeed as ihe deceased was unmemed on the dais 0f the accident ensf after his marriage, his centribuftion te the eerents wouéd have been reduced etibstehtiaiiyi the eiaimants‘ depene’eney weeid be at Rs? a,QDQ/- per ennum; by muitieiying the sweet deeeneency 0f Rs.18,0GO/- with the meitieiier e"? t0 in View e? the dictum o? the Aeex Court in the case ef Meeicteei $ereeretien et Greeter &embey Vs. Lexmeri Eye? & enether, reperted iri é2§$3j§ g SQC ?3‘i, the compensation werks eui: t0 Rn. I) a..- .8 funerei expenses end Rs.5=QQG!- tewarcz‘s toss ef estate’the ciaiments become entitieci te receive e sum of Rsi ,9Q.QQOI’~ which is the acme emoent awaroed by the Tribunei vio‘e impugned? GOQQL; by awarding further eurn of Rs.5,£ii30[— tewareis t x x i 4% m. Far the foregoing reasons; we do mt find any scope far enhancement 0f the mmnensatien awarded by the T‘nbunai. 11. The anpea néed by the appenanw {:Eaimants fer enhancement cf ‘Ehe nompengaiinn; nwerefnre, is nabfe m be: dismissed ané is hereby digmissed summaniy‘ Sd/- Chief Justice \