IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE, ANDHRA PRADESH AT HYDERABAD MONDAY, THE TWENTY NINETH DAY OF DECEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND EIGHT PRESENT HON'BLE SRI ANIL R. DAVE, THE CHIEF JUSTICE And HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE R.SUBHASH REDDY WRIT APPEAL NO : 1764 of 2008 (Writ Appeal under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent against the Order dated 13/06/2008 in WP NO : 17403 OF 2003 on the file of the High Court.) Between: TTD Class-IV Employees Union (Retd.No.F/255/80), Tirumala-Tirupati, Rep. by its Additional General Secretary T. Madanmohan ..... APPELLANT AND 1 The Secretary to Government of A.P. Revenue (Endowments- III)Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad. 2 The Board of Trustees, Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams, Tirupathi 3 The Executive Officer, Tirumal Tirupati Devasthanam, Tirupati 4 V.R.Srinivasulu, S/o.V.R.Padmanabhan, Central Hospital, Tirupati 5 S.Nagesh Babu S/o.S.R.Krishnaiah, Sri Padmavathi Ammavari Temple Tiruchanur. 6 P.Venkata Krishnaiah S/o.P.Venkatasubbaiah, OA Section, Tirupati. 7 M.Radhakrishna S/o.Venkataswami, Accounts Section Tirupati. 8 D.Murali Krishna S/o.Muniratnam, Quality Control, Tirupati. 9 P.Srinivasulu S/o.Venkataseshaiah, Deaf and Dumb School, Tirupati. 10 P.Mohanaiah S/o.Munikrishnaiah, Parakamani Office, Tirumala. 11 P.Munikrishnaiah S/o.Munirathnam,Sri Padmavathi Ammavari Temple, Tiruchanur. 12 K.Balachandra Reddy S/o.Krishna Reddy, Law Section Tirupati. 13 P.Rukmangadha s/o.Dharmaiah, Law Section, Tirupati 14 Y.S.Padma W/o.Y.S.Rao, O/o.The Divisional Engineer(Electrical) Tirupati. 15 P.Sobhan Babu S/o.Subrahmanyam Reddy, Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 16 T.Srinivasulu S/o.late T.Mohan, Vaikuntam Que Complex's Office, Tirupati 17 K. Mangamma, W/o.Kuppa Swami, O/o.The Deputy Electrical Engineer(WH) Tirumala. 18 V.Bhagyalakshmi W/o.Balaji Singh, SVCC, Tirumala. 19 G.Changaiah S/o.Ramaiah, O/o.DRO (Revenue) Tirupati 20 K.Nageswara Rao S/o.Munirathnam, O/o.Senior Medical Officer, Tirupati. 21 G.Subramanyam S/o.Gangi Reddy, Education Section Tirupati. 22 P.Venkatramana S/o.Mangaiah, O/o.the Executive Engineer(SH) Tirupati 23 D.Pothaiah S/o.Siddappa, O/o.Senior Medical Officer Tirupati 24 K.Subramanyam S/o.Veera Raghavulu, DF Office, Tirupati. 25 M.Dhana S/o.Padmanaidu, Central Hospital, Tirupati. 26 V.Amruthavalli W/o.Anjaneyulu, O/o.Dy.EO(AT) Tirupati 27 A.Gangadevi W/o.Janakiram, SGS High School, Tirupati 28 B.Naganna S/o.Siddappa, Sri Govindaraja Temple Tirupati. 29 K.Ramamurthy S/o.Siddaiah, O/o.Dy.EE(Electrical-II) Tirupati. 30 S.Krishna Murthy S/o.Pullaiah, Sri Padmavathi Temple Tiruchanur 31 S.Surya Sekhar S/o.Muniswami, Sri Padmavathi Temple, Tiruchanur. 32 M.Padmavathi W/o.Venkat Reddy, O/o.the Dy.EE(West)Tirupati. 33 M.Vedavathi W/o.Ramachandra Reddy, Sri Padmavathi Temple, Tiruchanur. 34 P.Madhava Reddy S/o.late Lakshmana Reddy O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 35 K. Neelakanta Reddy S/o. Krishna Reddy, O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 36 M.Nageswara Rao S/o.Nagaiah, O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 37 Kola Srinivasulu S/o.Ramaiah, O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 38 A.Vijaya Reddy S/o.Tirumala Reddy, O/o.PP Complex, Tirumala. 39 K.Srinivasulu S/o.Ramanaiah, INC Dis, Tirupati 40 A.Umamaheswara Reddy S/o.Tirumala Reddy O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 41 M.Padmanabha Reddy S/o.Gopal Reddy, SV Museum Tirupati. 42 K.Gurava Reddy S/o.Venkatesam Reddy, Tirumala Temple, Tirumala. 43 Srinivasulu S/o.Munirathnam,KK Complex, Tirumala. 44 B.Thrimurthi S/o.Seshaiah, O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 45 S.Nagalakshmi D/o.Adinarayana, O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 46 P.Jayachandra S/o.Venkatamuni Chetty, O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 47 P.Munikrishna Reddy S/o.Muthyala Reddy, O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 48 P.Chandraiah S/o.P.Venkataramaiah, O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 49 K.Narasimhulu S/o.Gangulaiah, SV Recording Project, Tirupati 50 N.Lakshmi W/o.Yerram Reddy,O/o.the EE(III)Tirupati. 51 N.Guravappa Naidu S/o.Chanagaiah Naidu, PPC, Tirumala. 52 P.Rajeswari W/o.T.Naras, SV Museum, Tirumala 53 VT Balaji S/o.VL Tirumala Naidu, Tirumala Temple Parakamani Tirumala. 54 M.Subramanian S/o.Nagarajan, Pension Section, Tirupati. 55 R.Venkata Subbaiah S/o.Venkataratnam, O/o.DPP, Tirupati. 56 L.Namassivaya S/o.Lokanadha Naidu, Sales Wing Publications Tirupati. 57 M.Muna Swamy S/o Madhurai, SV Ayurvedic Hospital, Tirupati 58 B.Subadhra W/o.Muninagulu, Accounts Section, Tirupati. 59 O.Sulochana W/o.Tirumala Naidu,Sri Govindaraja Swamy Temple, Tirupati. 60 V.Savitramma W/o.Satyamurthy, Padmavathi Temple, Tiruchanur. 61 V.Narayana S/o.Venkatachalapathi, O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 62 K.Chandra Babu S/o.Siddaiah, Govindaraja Swamy Temple, Tirupati. 63 D.Nalini W/o.Chandram Naidu, SV Syu Hospital, Tirupati. 64 G.Dhakshavani W/o.Guruswamy, Govindrajaswamy Temple Tirupati. 65 S.Ayyappa Reddy S/o.Rathnam Reddy, KRT Temple, Tirupathi. 66 T.Illavarasi W/o.Ganesh Nadar, Unit Office, Tirupati. 67 T.Kuppa Singh S/o.Balaji Singh, Unit Office, Tirupati. 68 B.Munendra Babu S/o.Krishnaiah, SV Museum, Tirumala. 69 K.Krishna Murthy S/o.Subba Rao, O/o.EE II, Tirupati. 70 K.S.Balaram S/o.Singaramudaliyar, O/o.the DPP, Tirupati. 71 B.Govindaiah S/o.Dharmaaiah, O/o.Av&SO, Tirupati. 72 I.Munemma, W/o.Eswaraiah, O/o.Audit, Tirupati. 73 N.Satyanarayana S/o.Narayana Rao, O/o.AEO(Properties) Tirupati. 74 D.Anjaneyulu S/o.D.Venkatesh, TTD Central Hospital, Tirupathi 75 M.Chandramma W/o.Hema Reddy, TTD Central Hospital, Tirupati. 76 R.Rajamma W/o.Venkataswamy, TTD Central Hospital Tirupati. 77 D.Venkatesam S/o.Muna Swamy, Karunadamam. Tirupati. 78 B.Ellamma W/o.Desu Reddy, O/o.AFO Checking Squad, Tirupati. 79 D.Parvathamma W/o.Basava Reddy, O/o.the Inspection Section, Tirupati. 80 B.Minaswamy S/o.Ananthaiah, O/o.the Inspection Section, Tirupati. 81 B.S.Subramanya Reddy S/o.Munaswamy Reddy, O/o.DPP, Tirupati. 82 A.Mahalakshmi W/o.Munirathnam, SGs High School, Tirupathi. 83 S.Jasmuna W/o.G.Hari, Govindaraja Swamy Temple, Tirupati. 84 Y.Govindamma, W/o.Chinnababu, Govindarajaswamy Temple, Tirupati. 85 N.Madhavan, S/o.Narayana Swamy, O/o.Dy.EE(Elect.) Tirupati. 86 C.Munemma W/o.subrahmanyam, O/o.EE(SSH) Tirupathi 87 A.Guravaiah S/o.Thirumalaiah,Padmavathi Temple, Tiruchanoor. 88 G.Koteswara Rao S/o.Munaswamy, Padmavathy temple, Tiruchanoor. 89 A.Raju S/o.Chinnabba, Padmavathy Temple, Tiruchanoor. 90 C.Rajeswari W/o.Nagaraju, Padmavathy temple, Tiruchanoor 91 S.Neelamma W/o.Natesan, Govindaraja Swamy Temple, Tirupathi 92 A.Venkatalakshmi W/o.Ramachandraiah, SV High School, Tirumala. 93 D.Subbarathna W/o.Munirathnam Chetty, SV High School, Tirumala. 94 K.Sarada W/o.Arjun Reddy, SV High School, Tirumala. 95 P.Munirajeswari W/o.P.Guna, O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 96 P.S.Dhanalakshmi D/o.P.S.Subbaiah, Health Office, Tirumala. 97 KS.Varada Raju S/o.Seetharama Swamy,O/o.Vaikuntam QueComplex, Tirumala 98 D.Padmavathamma W/o.late Venkatarama Naidu O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 99 G.Annapurna W/o.Prabhakara Sarma,O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex,Tirumala 100 M.enkatalakshmi W/o.Gopal Reddy,O/o.Vaikuntam Que Complex, Tirumala 101 CN Padmavathamma W/o.CN Nagaraju, SV High School, Tirumala. 102 S.Latha W/o.DM Bhanudhar, P/o.the Dy.EE(East) Tirumala. 103 R.Kalappa W/o.Veeraswamy, SV Museum, Tirumala. 104 M.Munemma W/o.Raghavulu, Water Works, Tirumala. 105 G.Krishnamma W/o.Chinnaiah, Water Works, Tirumala. 106 P.V.Bhaskar S/o.Venkatarathnam, KKC Tirumala. 107 R.Vijaya W/o.late S.Babu, Health Office, Tirumala. 108 G.Chinna Swamy Mandadi S/o.Siddala Mandadi, KK Complex, Tirumala. 109 I.Parvathi W/o.I.V.Raju, SV Canteen complex, Tirumala. 110 M.Sankaraiah S/o.Venkataramana, KKC, Tirumala. 111 M.Venkata Subbaiah S/o.Rangaiah, Kalahasti Temple, Tirupati. 112 P.Subramanayam S/o.Srinivasulu, KK Complex, Tirumala. 113 P.Rani W/o.Venkatesam, SGS Arts College, Tirupati. 114 P.Murugesan S/o.Veeraswamy, SPW Jr.College, Tirupati. 115 M.Ramu S/o.Manikya Mudaliar, SV Recording Project, Tirupati. 116 A.Subramanyam S/o.Perumal Naidu, Central Library, Tirupati. 117 S.Anjali W/o.Bhaskar Reddy, Duty at G.T., Tirupathi. .....RESPONDENTS Counsel for the Appellant : MR.MEHERCHAND NOORI Counsel for the Respondents : GP FOR ENDOWMENTS The Court made the following : ORDER : (Per Hon’ble Sri Anil R.Dave, CJ) The learned counsel for appellant seeks permission to withdraw the appeal so as to enable the concerned aggrieved employees to take appropriate action for challenging the impugned order in accordance with law. Permission for withdrawal of the appeal is granted. Appeal stands disposed of as withdrawn with no order as to costs. _________________ ANIL R. DAVE, CJ 29th December 2008 ______________________ R. SUBHASH REDDY, J ajr