^:!~«c 'o' p fl :(!:.>-•' Tsr "^ww^, ^i^w'c, fsRrray ..W..(?..te;...M.?..7.2.£.2:1^7, 3TO?(^T'^!lN' ?!<n sn^i w»iHi' SV^V 'q^T («yf.l«^ET) W<roiT^fei3Dt?T •^'ailOTSR^i riesh Tagde. S/'o. Late Raaiii, T'agde, aaed a^out 35 yeax's, aged. about 33 yeai's, Resident of /|care of Git'har Ars.il Singh House No.329, New KfhursipaT, Jagir Chowk, Pitnjabi Molialla, Qpposite Pai'asnaui General Store, BIulai, ^istrict Durg (CG) 'lresenuy, R/o House <agai- Eluaspiir fCG) 913/7. Malianand Ihawl, OBI Kagai' Jarhabhatha, District lui-endra Kuinar Sonekunwar, S/o. Govtnd Rsia junkekunwar, aged about 34 years, Care ofTika. |ain Patil, Naharpara Nehru Nagar, BhUai r^^tnr-t H^-i.Tr (^C^ '^•'i\J±~^Jj L^^3L±1^>L i^ U.^ ^^/'i^Ti Rresent addiess: House No. 913/7, MaJ ^hal, Om. Nagar, Jai'Iiabhafha Bilaspur District luasour fCG'i 1. Sljate of Clitiattisgarb, through : Secreteiy, Dtpartaient of Labour, D.K.S. Bhawan, MpzitralaYa, Raipur, District Raipur iC.G.j 2. Tljie Drrector, Directorat.e Etaployees State T~^^-.-;~t-<'>—-/'=^> Q^T^c-.r's^s.r: F\._OOnJ^' /T/--!•/-.•"=; TV^,'v.- .- ii.|£3U.rHiice sciviccs u-^s^u/ Oj i H^c-rc ^THgfci-r, R|upur (CG) Writ Petition unde? Arfcicle 226 of tfae Constitution of India ur^adta Mishra, J. ShriY.K. Rao, Shri Arun Sao, HRarri coilnsel for fhe petitioners. G4vt. Advocate for flie State. ^•-,^f-k-^^^^-" -7 ^g-E-'g.,,. ,^''"^ '"%, rt;y""~"';' •(^ • "..--•"^A B I ^i^v ^y s.s'." -78 T^'^traRTtT, ^TitWS, fs|<r||yy ", ^ ati^i qn •^fRi' ti8n siri^r WWR a^tpRi'(ipf^Wt) WBiWHfNani'B z ^raferin *i!*mf <f fs^t 'a^re^ ^sffinsiAm The petitioners ha-^e ffled the itistaat petition for directi^..^ ..,_ respondents to consider t^ie candida.ture oftlie petitioners for the pos; of Wa.rd Bov and Dresser 1 as the •petitioners, who anpMed for the aaoye posts in response to th^ been issued iiiterview c; advei'ti.senient of Annexure P-1 1. liave n^.t ffi, fhough tb.cv have fiitSlled the eligibiliT't criteria for the aforesaid rfosts. The petitioners eajlier filed W.P. (S) No. 4021/08, which was disnosed of bv this Courll vide order d.ated 25th Julv 2008 on tne basis .^--.-..—„- .^. -. ---_^ .^_- —„^ ..-„-._-.- _-_^, of stateBa.e.nt on behalf o3 State couasel that in case the pet.lti.oBe?:? fll°_ .represeiitation agaiust tljeir grievaiices, tae saine shalt 'ue cdlisider"d and decided bv tlie concdmed authorits'. 'he representa.tioti. submitted bv the petitioners has heen rejected by fhe Direct4rate, Eoiployees State Insurance Seivices, RaiD'Tr vide. order ofAnrlexiire P-4 dated 3rd October 2008. Leamed counsel | for tbe petitioners subinitted that the rietitioners have not beAn issued iiiterview caDs on the a'round tlia.t j—---—- —.^-^^-—--—^-^- .,- they were not workuig l^nder fhe Eniployees State InsuraD.ce Servve's at the tiine of advertiseijient; they have secured 46% & 45% uiarlss ia the higher secondary ^ii.d class 5th ia the qualmdag exa3iiiiatiGQ, however, no inintmiiiq percentage was fixed to be eHgfefe ";br appointnient. Froni perusal of the advertiseinent of Annexure P-11; it 's 5 observed that whfle p^escriojji.g fhe eUgibiUty criteria, thsre is no aiention fhat the experi^nce of the candidate is to be give.u preferejice; on tlie coiitratv, c?ai<sej -7 of the condition enables the Directoi-ate to ^s!'°SSVs- •••<.A^' -s ^f .{: %. ^''•?t( ^aasssf1' s :.i(^i.^r'—" //. "3^'STRRTEl, ®T)l'M'Ko,fa<11'MI^< 3n^r^rf?;iffi' ^sffan^rai'inqi' l vV •W^V Ipf^ l WTwnfesn*^ ^rawfrT ^iiraf ?ft^ <P=f<^i< _1 •minose aiiv educational •j'ondition iii case large nuinber of applicatioiis are received froin tlie cajididates. While decidiiig the representation; it 1 has beeu specifically in^ntioned that looking to tlie large nuiaber of ca-ndidates, tlie caiididaKes, who secured niore uiarks ia tbe qua]ili'me: examiaation, only have t'jeen issued iuterview calls. Taking into consi4eration tli_e reasous assigned in the. order of Annexiire P-4, whei^bfe.' fhe representa.tion of tlie petitioners liave been decided, I ain of fhle opinion fhat ttiere is no gi-oiind available to the rietitioners to iiapuga the order ofAnnexiu'e P-4. Petition is accordMglv disinissed - — '~ Sd/- Dhirendra Mishra Judge [i 5 j^i i'-i >^.^