IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CIVIL REVIEW No.106 of 2009 HEMAN RAI, SON OF LATE PARAS NATH RAI, R/O VILLAGE – EAST BALUA, P.O. KANS DIYAR, P.S. DORIGANJ, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA ……… ………………..PETITIONER – APPELLANT - PETITIONER Versus 1. THE STATE ELECTION COMMISSION (PANCHAYAT), SONE BHAWAN, BIRCHAND PATEL PATH, PATNA THROUGH THE STATE ELECTION COMMISSIONER, 2. THE DISTRICT ELECTION OFFICER (PANCHAYAT), SARAN AT CHAPRA, 3. THE RETURNING OFFICER (PANCHAYAT), SADAR BLOCK, CHAPRA, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA, 4. THE ASSISTANT RETURNING OFFICER (PANCHAYAT), SADAR BLOCK, CHAPRA, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA, 5. MUNNA KUMAR, SON OF SRI GIRIJA PRASAD, R/O VILLAGE – WEST BALUAN, P.O. KANS DIYAR, P.S. DORIGANJ, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA, 6. ANIL SINGH, SON OF RAM BABU SINGH, R/O VILLAGE AND P.O. KANS DIYAR, P.S. DORIGNAJ, DISTRICT SARAN AT CHAPRA, 7. ASHOK KUMAR, SON OF JALESHWAR RAI, R/O VILLAGE AND P.O. KANS DIYAR, P.S. DORIGANJ, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA, 8. KALIKA AI, SON OF RAMUNA RAI, R/O VILLAGE – WEST BALUAN, P.O. KANS DIYAR, P.S. DORIGANJ, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA, 9. GAYA ARAI, SON OF LATE RAMDEWAN RAI, R/O VILLAGE – EAST BALUAN, P.O. KANS DIYAR, P.S. DORIGANJ, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA, 10. DINANATH RAI, SON OF LATE BHAW SAGAR RAI, R/O VILLAGE – WEST BALUAN, P.O. KANS DIYAR, P.S. DORIGANJ, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA, 11. PUNAM DEVI, WIFE OF MANOJ RAI, R/O VILLAGE – WEST BALUAN, P.O. KANS DIYAR, P.S. DORIGANJ, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA, 12. RAJ KISHORE RAI, SON OF LATE SURENDRA RAI, R/O VILLAGE – EAST BALUAN, P.O. KANS DIYAR, P.S. DORIGANJ, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA, 2 13. RAJ NARAIN SINGH, SON OF LATE RAM LAKHAN SINGH, R/O VILLAGE MUSEPUR, P.O. NARAON, P.S. DORIGANJ, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA, 14. RAM PUKAR RAI, SON OF LATE TRIVENI RAI, R/O VILLAGE – EAST BALUAN, P.O. KANS DIYAR, P.S. DORIGANJ, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA, 15. BIJAY KUMAR, SON OF BALESHWAR RAI, R/O VILLAGE – EAST BALUAN, P.O. KANS DIYAR, P.S. DORIGANJ, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA 16. SADANAND SINGH, SON OF SATYA NARAIN SINGH, R/O VILLAGE – MUSEPUR, P.O. NARAON, P.S. DORIGANJ, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA, 17. SHAILENDRA KUMAR RAI, SON OF BANWARI KISHORE RAI, R/O VILLAGE – WEST BALUAN, P.O. KANS DIYAR, P.S. DORIGANJ, DISTRICT – SARAN AT CHAPRA. …..……RESPONDENTS-RESPONDENTS-RESPONDENTS. ----------- 7. 07.04.2010. Heard Mr. S.B.K. Mangalam, learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr. Ashok Kumar Mishra No. 2, learned counsel for the respondent no. 5 and Mr. Sanjeev Nikesh, learned counsel for the State Election Commission. On concession of the learned counsel for the parties, the order dated 23.03.2009 passed in LPA No. 900 of 2008 is recalled. The review application is accordingly allowed. Dilip ( Dipak Misra, C.J. ) ( Dr. Ravi Ranjan, J. )