tf li:il^^^ '^.^..^ "a"a*°XI-iK—78 ry) sn^r SBI ftFfw ^WT ^n^ff s(i*fi<») T *<i*<ni »*ira» :3^-Ml<ii<'i<<,®'31<yic;Pi<;iiyy. . LuP.CS>(Kt?. 13/0% ^......^......,...^....^....:..».........^,..^^Q sii^w Tpi^(xpf3qS*') ?%TWC ^lf^d ofl^^ PETITIONER 'I'iratn k'am aboiit. 63 ve^ ytate 01 Tribsl WBlft ur|nattisgam mrougn tlie yecretaiy, |re nei'^rtmsnr., n.K.R. Rhawan, ^. /I 5, FETITIi r'.cllpLtl , i./iisLi; 'l'iie; "DY. Hsn^n.mftnt, iTI-rv-\ "^,-YJJ 'l'ne Joint Pension. Rilal Uepaitment, The Princif L.-cAiiUiii^d, i--': 28-1-2000 yiin Uliaiiu'aiu ralel, nu! Ktui M.r^.M. Dtvatia, uy. Notices were issuea to orcler ot Ulis (^ourt uatecl 4- 1-y Leamea couasel lor me| iietu'ed on ^y-^-^UUb, wtuie ui Assistaut 'Jommissioner, 'l'nt] Uu'ector, 1'reasury, Accounts orcier datea ^Y-&-^uut> ot 44,7 II/- showin.g me same to dtiW^^I'l *<N<rfil ^f l^rct ^tf^K i? aifiCT sii^t siaai', y/o Late HaKna Kam Biclai', aged rs. R/ovi11aee Par^skol, Poftt. Navanara, r^^+.<- 'D^i^.^.^.T^. fr-l-r^\ , r/'loLL.. i\cuga.lii *^'^.^j D^-;".T!-' fr^/^-^ -i''\cLijJUl ^'^-^1 Commissioner, 'l'n'oal Wellare Division Rilaspur; Dist.t. Btlaspur Jirector, 'lTeasuiy, Accounts anct soiir, Distt. Bila-SDUr iCQI v^om-missionsr, Uistt. Kaigai-n (CU) ^-.1. Hisher Secondaj'y SchooL LL. iS.cilgi-diil. {^•'•J} CLB 226 Of TMB_COnsTITUTiON OF' INDIA t? y. lor luc pcuuouer. fJovt. Adv., tor Uie Ktate. |U^e responctents ui pursuance ot Uie pUS, Jiowpver, no reply tias been tUed. peuUoner subnuts uiat me petiuoner p was posted as miicipal, uncler Uie [al Developinent, RaigaTh. Tlie Joiat aaa rjension, riilaspur uivision vicle Aan^xure f-2, lias uu-ected recoven- ot Ks. pe extra paynieiit to tUe petitioner. F^ -i--^ .^""'-^^ ''^ T XI-HC—78 311^1'^fiFTO' WT ^)1<<<i !h*l ^ *fl*<Wl <hNl<h 3^'<(i<<i<iai,Ewiki<ie,Tq<'ii^i<, -, coPC;s).M5-/3^g_. ^..^..^...^....................-.........,..^^200 311^T'qsW('i°l(3«<yI) (NIW^rfCT W^y Leameu counsel tor Uie ot recovery nas been passea wj; wiUiout auomuig aiiy opportutiily aniount nienUoued. in ttie oit , 1,72,7/5/- nas also Deen rec4 su'osequent recovery Jias'also) orcler tor Uie sam.e ancl wit&oy to tlie petitioner. Leaniea counsel tor ttie b^34/ 2UUK ('I'opl UJiaaa -v-| mvolvmg idenncEa issue, orclef lo-l~^UUS$, in view 01 ttie SuDmjssiot peutiouer, ttiis peunon is auolved 2<JUt> (Aniiexurc I^-^j clu'ectuij account ot excess payinent m.a4 llie petiUoner is entitlecl to riiljl wimout aiiy cteaucUon. II tl? peunoner is euuuecl to Uie sa( b% per aiuauni. Mowever, it isj step, u so aclvised, in accord.aj|ice ot natural justice. <fit2J?it'Itft^ W^t ^ ^S^ <^lt$l< iTajfman^T tietiUouer subniits Uiat Uie above order ]imout any nonce to me pebnoner ana iip.tty ot iieanng to fiun. Apart troni me per ot Aiiaexure f-2, a suin ot Ks. ^vered towaras Htate scliolai-sliip. 'l'ne been maue wimout uiere being auy |t attomnig any oppprtiuuty ot ueaniis IpeUtioner suDnuts Uiat ui W.P. (HJ No. State ot ditiamsgarli as.cl oUiers) FS liave beeii passeu by uus Court on fi maue Dy me ieai-aeu counsel tor me L. 'I'lie unpugned order dateu '21-3- |recover}' ot a suni ot Ks. 44,Yll/- on jie to fhe petitioaer, is hereby quashed. pensionaiy benetits/gratuiy' ainount ^e ainount lias been recoverect, uie lcl ainount witt uiterest at t&e rate ol open to uie respouaents to taKe any wim law toUowBig Dasic pnncrples Sd/- Dhu'endra Mishra ^ Judge