CW-15456/10 (1) In the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan Jaipur Bench, Jaipur O R D E R S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.15456/2010 Smt. Shakuntla Yadav Vs. State of Raj. & Ors. Date Of Order :: 22/11/2010 Hon'ble Mr. Justice Ajay Rastogi Mr. S.S. Sunda, for petitioner. Mr. Gurvinder Singh, for respondent. The petitioner who is working as Librarian on being transferred within District Alwar at a distance of 70 kms from Mani Ka Bad, Alwar to Tehla, Alwar vide order dt.26.09.2010 preferred appeal before the Service Appellate Tribunal. The learned Tribunal after hearing counsel for the petitioner and so also the affected respondent who appeared as a caveator did not find any merit in the submissions made and rejected the appeal vide order impugned dt.10.11.2010. The main thrust of submissions of counsel for the petitioner is that the petitioner is not having good health and suffiering with slip disc and came to present place of posting only a year before and in such circumstances her transfer which has been made under the order impugned by no strength of imagination can be said to be in CW-15456/10 (2) the interest of administration or in exigency of service. Taking note of the submissions made and the rival contentions advanced by the affected respondent as well and the fact that petitioner has been transferred at a distance of 70 kms within District Alwar, at the same time when there was no allegation levelled of malice against the authority or violation of statutory rules the learned Tribunal was not inclined to entertain the appeal which was dismissed vide order impugned. This Court has heard the counsel for the petitioner and the affected respondent as well and also gone through the material on record did not find any manifest error being committed by the Tribunal which may call for interference. Consequently, the petition fails and is hereby dismissed. (Ajay Rastogi),J VS Shekhawat /p.2/ 15456cw10Nov22FnlDsps.doc