CWP-11803/2010 1 S.B.CIVIL WRIT PETITION NO.11803/2010. Anil Kumar Saravagi Vs. The State of Raj. & ors. DATE OF ORDER : 27/08/2010 HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY RASTOGI *** Mr.RP Saini, for petitioner Petitioner, who is working as Lower Division Clerk, was transferred from the office of Block Chief Medical Officer, Begu to Community Health Center, Mandfia which is within District Chittorgarh vide order dt. 16/02/2010 (Anx.8) in pursuance to which he was relieved for submitting his joining vide order dt. 16/07/2010 (Anx.9) which was challenged by filing Appeal before the Service Appellate Tribunal which came to be rejected vide order dt. 28/07/2010. It appears that the petitioner challenged the order by which he was relieved dt. 16/07/2010 (Anx.9) and not the original order in pursuance to which he was transferred under the orders of the Chief Medical and Health Officer, Chhitorgarh dt. 16/02/2010 (Anx.8) and taking note thereof, the learned Tribunal observed that the order impugned dt. 16/02/2010 cannot be considered to be an order of transfer which may affect the service conditions of the petitioner against which appeal is not maintainable Apart from it, the petitioner was CWP-11803/2010 2 transferred within District Chittorgarh under the orders of the Chief Medical and Health Officer, Chittorgarh vide order dt. 16/02/2010 (Anx.8) which did dot affect either of the service conditions of the petitioner and the petitioner has also not alleged any malice against the authority who has passed the order impugned or violation of statutory rules, if any. Even otherwise, he cannot claim any lien to continue at one place and if the authority has taken decision in the interest of administration, it cannot be said to be arbitrary which may call for interference. This Court does not find any manifest error in what has been observed by the learned Tribunal. Consequently, the writ petition, being devoid of merit, is hereby dismissed. [AJAY RASTOGI], J. Raghu/p.2/ 11803-CW-2010-final.doc