'^^^^^1;^^^;^^^^^ 'HHI^B— area'iBa HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURECMHATTISGARH : BILASPUR SINGLEBENCH : HON'BI-eSHRI S.R.NAYAK, CJ. W,P.NQ.^9of2Q04 PETITIONERS •s- RESPONDENTS PETffit^ilEf^S 1. Mfe Syntex Packbigs Pvt. Ud. Rsgistereel Office at 97/C, tndustrtal Complex, Secfor-A Si^itB Bilaspur ffirough jte Director, Praveen Kumar Pafel Sfo Late C.J. Patel Rto 1.-2 Vinobha Nagar, Bitaspur (Ghhattisgarh) 2. Praveen Kumar Patel SitoLateCJ.Patel ^ged about 51 years Dirertor, Syntoc Packings Pnvate l.imited, ^R/o L-2 ^inobha Nagar, Bilaspur(eiilTattisgarh) /i Versus 4. Stateofehhattisgarh TI'irouglitie^Secretei'y ©eparbnientof eommereial Tax f(B«eis^ID.hi.S. BhaMSQii, Nantralaya^Saipur (ChhaUisgarh)! 2. Exeise ©bmmissioner State ofOfihattisgarh D.K.S. Bhawan, Maritralaya Raipur | (Chliattisgarh) 3. M/s. L^endDi;sUnariesPrh@te Limited 23,&ine 11, hteharana Pratap Nagar, BhopalpmrateGompany incarporateduiiderGompaniesAct tlirougli its ManagmgDirector, SKri JlagdisKftrora 4. E)r. Nirmal Shukla |^|ed^ab6ut.%years i iS/olMoilffuWm ^ jAdditi<^l|Advo(^ |eourtOtGhhaffisgarti; Bilaspur j | j(C(itiaffi!^aTh) 1 | W.P.aMo.3<S2,ot2004 l .1.:?,%jl^;::^j®yT^g?13a(^gs^^f:>vt.j!4!-tct. ,l^lljs|:S|gg^jg|l^|j||iM^ifiin|l^|il |V|||j^|^^|jg^|%||i^||||^| ^^W^iSii^ii^WSESBvyjprs^iaiS., :<;:'l :l-?t1 :H'& wx !'»; i 1»:: da j: 'r •| .;":••" •nl &^^^:SsgS5SS:Si^S^3^S^^i^SMiSS\ CTsBSSIM'KSSSsWBRti -5L~ RESPONDENTS Patel S/o Late G.J. Patel R/o L-2 Vinoba Nagar, Bilaspur. OhliattBgarii 2. Praveen Kumar Pafsl S/oLateCJ.E'atel ^edaboyt%yeare Dli'eG^F,Synt^1^1<mgsl^i-&, WQ L-2 Vlnoba Nagar, Bilaspur Chhattisgarh Vereus ^ . ' . ..'"••••.• • • •. : • 1. StateofGhhattisgarh TKroughtiie Seeretary Dep^ttme|rt|<>||Csdminereiat Tax <B«?isie)©.K.S.Bhawari, ' Msmtrailaya^ajpur iCMhattisgarh 2. ' ©ffiissCOrmnissioner Stat&WOMIiaftisgarh i D'.K.g.BI'iawaR.Maht^alayaRa^ur Chhaifisgarh ; 3. Mfe. Legend Distillaries Private ::l-imited. .: • : • • . • : -•: 23. Zone (I, Naharana Pratep Nagar, Bttoj3al PdvaMCompany i ilic<»FporatedupderComparrtesActi ttwough its Managing Directqr JagdjshArora i:!Til —li-U Present: ShnV.G.Tamaskafi.leainedjieounseljfttrtfieipetitj^iei^j ShSsl^rashant Misti^,i leam.il Ncll. JA.O. with S188i NtKalNti Vernte,leame(aDyyt3<^.Ad'^ :4:aBJ|t''I ^.r:':',''|,%|::i%:.,,.^';[^^ Shn|^Kit.aftf^^^|B|ei^S|i:i;iteS^ate^:i<^S|rjs •ShipaStasasli^ugisSBBII'BJ^BfllR^P^ ' :;:'';.i:^ 'H: Shiffi|!SK^i|e(Mi^!Sffi|l||g|^Ei|ejt^unsel forWe r^ ^illi.l.^ioiiiaiiiia^fi^1^.;.'' <f%iseS-<il2i'tS8SBit|><H>6): iTh^p^||§||j^n|^^|l||^li^i^tic»sj<;ouklHncrt'b^i|eg|^^ a^aggrieyect|^i||s|||i^|tai||^i^^lN|t|t:>^^ si;Ri 2004' is.dire<^^||j8^n^|tMe||!Bt|ia^jj)(rfi:^<|ie|:..prRC»ediR^:^ :M~K ^S^ a» m c<^missi®NeNMIM81SeSSM'fiWiral B(MBNI^^^^:1N!'%w!wsNii}W :fit^,by?fta^i..e|^|||B|Sftffi|UiB^NilliS§9ttt|iajr^poil8B^;li|^|iE lsi:/.'^NI; ll'il IISSI M kilfl^-.-^^^.f^Js^^^^.^^^^Sfi^! 3- for grant of licence and W.P. No. 1662 ofZCXM Is dirwted against the order made by the eommissiQnerfor Excise, GovemmentofChhattisgarh refusing to grant licence in favour oftheS respondent. When thiswas pointed out,leamed counsel forttie petitioners sought peimission ofthe Court to withdraw th^e writ petitions. Therefore.Uie W.P. No. 409 of 2004 andW.P. No. 1662 of2004 aredismissedasvirithdrawn. SdA Chief Justice Judge Kd>"°*t :1 i!i. I