1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICITON FIRST APPEAL NO. 646 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Shri Trimbak Joma Thakur, ] deceased, through his legal representatives:- ] 1) Dasharath Trimbak Thakur, age 39 ] 2) Kisan Trimbak Thakur, age 33 ] 3) Prabhakar Trimbak Thakur, age 31 ] 4) Bharati Bhaskar Patil, age 37 ] 5) Chandrabai Tukaram Patil, age 35 ] 6) Sulochana Mohan Patil, age 28 ] 7) Asha Vishwanath Patil, age 25 ] 8) Muktabai Trimbak Thakur, age 65 ] 9) Yeshwant Atmaram Thakur, age 25 ] 10) Ravindra Atmaram Thakur, age 23 ] 11) Vishwajeet Atmaram Thakur, age 21 ] 12) Santosh Atmaram Thakur, age 19 ] 13) Shirish Atmaram Thakur, age 17 ] 14) Sachin Atmaram Thakur, age 11 ] 15) Janabai Atmaram Thakur, age 42 ]... Respondents (Original Claimants) WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 27839 OF 1996 The State of Maharashtra ] through Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ...Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS 2 Shri Trimbak Joma Thakur, ] since deceased, through his legal representatives ] 1) Dasharath Trimbak Thakur, age 39 ] 2) Kisan Trimbak Thakur, age 33 ] 3) Prabhakar Trimbak Thakur, age 31 ] 4) Bharati Bhaskar Patil, age 37 ] 5) Chandrabai Tukaram Patil, age 35 ] 6) Sulochana Mohan Patil, age 28 ] 7) Asha Vishwanath Patil, age 25 ] 8) Muktabai Trimbak Thakur, age 65 ] 9) Yeshwant Atmaram Thakur, age 25 ] 10) Ravindra Atmaram Thakur, age 23 ] 11) Vishwajeet Atmaram Thakur, age 21 ] 12) Santosh Atmaram Thakur, age 19 ] 13) Shirish Atmaram Thakur, age 17 ] 14) Sachin Atmaram Thakur, age 11 ] ...Respondents WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 781 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Shri Trimbak Joma Thakur, ] deceased, through his legal representatives:- ] 1) Dasharath Trimbak Thakur, age 39 ] 2) Kisan Trimbak Thakur, age 33 ] 3) Prabhakar Trimbak Thakur, age 31 ] 4) Bharati Bhaskar Patil, age 37 ] 5) Chandrabai Tukaram Patil, age 35 ] 6) Sulochana Mohan Patil, age 28 ] 7) Asha Vishwanath Patil, age 25 ] 8) Muktabai Trimbak Thakur, age 65 ] 3 9) Yeshwant Atmaram Thakur, age 25 ] 10) Ravindra Atmaram Thakur, age 23 ] 11) Vishwajeet Atmaram Thakur, age 21 ] 12) Santosh Atmaram Thakur, age 19 ] 13) Shirish Atmaram Thakur, age 17 ] 14) Sachin Atmaram Thakur, age 22 ] 15) Janabai Atmaram Thakur, age 42 ]... Respondents (Original Claimants) WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 31303 OF 1996 The State of Maharashtra ] through Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ....Appellant VERSUS Shri Trimbak Joma Thakur, ] since deceased, through his legal representatives ] 1) Dasharath Trimbak Thakur, age 39 ] 2) Kisan Trimbak Thakur, age 33 ] 3) Prabhakar Trimbak Thakur, age 31 ] 4) Bharati Bhaskar Patil, age 37 ] 5) Chandrabai Tukaram Patil, age 35 ] 6) Sulochana Mohan Patil, age 28 ] 7) Asha Vishwanath Patil, age 25 ] 8) Muktabai Trimbak Thakur, age 65 ] 9) Yeshwant Atmaram Thakur, age 25 ] 10) Ravindra Atmaram Thakur, age 23 ] 11) Vishwajeet Atmaram Thakur, age 21 ] 12) Santosh Atmaram Thakur, age 19 ] 13)Shirish Atmaram Thakur, age 17 ] 14) Sachin Atmaram Thakur, age 11 ] 15) Janabai Atmaram Thakur, Age 42 ] ... Respondents WITH 4 FIRST APPEAL NO. 782 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Kundalik Tukaram Thakur, since deceased, ] through Legal Heirs: ] (1) Nirabai Kundalik @ Pundalik Thakur ] Resident of Roadpali, Taluka Panvel, ] District Raigad ] (2) Bebibai Ankush Bhoir ] Residing at Waklan, Taluka and Dist. Thane ] (3) Ratnabai Arun Keni ] Resident of Pethali, Taluka Panvel, ] Dist. Raigad ]...Respondents (Original Claimants) WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 27912 OF 1996 The State of Maharashtra ] through Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ....Appellant VERSUS Kandlik Tukaram Thakur, since deceased, ] through Legal Heirs: ] (1)Nirabai Kundalik @ Pundalik Thakur ] Resident of Roadpali, Taluka Panvel, ] District Raigad ] (2) Bebibai Ankush Bhoir ] Residing at Waklan, Taluka and Dist. Thane ] (3) Ratnabai Arun Keni ] Resident of Pethali, Taluka Panvel, ] Dist. Raigad ]...Respondents 5 (Original Claimants) WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 783 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Surendra Kumar Somany ] ...Respondent (Ori. Claimant) WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 32928 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] through Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ....Appellant VERSUS Surendra K. Somany ] C/o. A.K. Daruwala, 131, Bhusari Mohalla, ] Panvel 410 206 ] ...Respondent WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 785 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] 6 Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Ramchandra Balu Thakur, deceased through ] his legal representatives ] (1)Jeejabai Ramchandra Thakur, age 70 ] (2)Kesarinath Ramchandra Thakur, age 52 ] (3) Dhanubai Waman Madhavi, age 43 ] (4) Motibai Eknath Patil, age 36 ] (5) Bhagubai Krishna Tembhe, age 23 ] ...Respondents (Ori. Claimants) WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 27864 OF 1996 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Ramchandra Balu Thakur, deceased through ] his legal representatives ] (1) Jeejabai Ramchandra Thakur, age 70 ] (2) Kesarinath Ramchandra Thakur, age 52 ] (3) Dhanubai Waman Madhavi, age 43 ] (4) Motibai Eknath Patil, age 36 ] (5) Bhagubai Krishna Tembhe, age 23 ] ...Respondents WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 786 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] 7 Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Kundalik @ Pundalik Tukaram Thakur, ] since deceased, through Legal Heirs: ] (1)Nirabai Kundalik @ Pundalik Thakur ] Resident of Roadpali, Taluka Panvel, ] District Raigad ] (2) Bebibai Ankush Bhoir ] Residing at Waklan, Taluka and Dist. Thane ] (3) Ratnabai Arun Keni ] Resident of Pethali, Taluka Panvel, ] Dist. Raigad ]...Respondents (Original Claimants) WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 27918 OF 1996 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Kundalik @ Pundalik Tukaram Thakur, ] since deceased, through Legal Heirs: ] (1)Nirabai Kundalik @ Pundalik Thakur ] Resident of Roadpali, Taluka Panvel, ] District Raigad ] (2) Bebibai Ankush Bhoir ] Residing at Waklan, Taluka and Dist. Thane ] (3) Ratnabai Arun Keni ] Resident of Pethali, Taluka Panvel, ] Dist. Raigad ]...Respondents WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 787 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] 8 [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS 1. Dattatraya Kashinath Thakur ] (Deceased) through his legal representatives: ] 1/1. Baliram Dattatraya Thakur, age 20 ] 1/2. Ashok Dattatraya Thakur, age 27 ] 1/3. Bharat Dattatraya Thakur, age 23 ] 1/4. Mai Rajaram Patil, age 32 ] 2. Vithal Kashinath Thakur ] 3. Gopinath Kashinath Thakur ] 4. Maruti Kashinath Thakur, since deceased ] by his heir & L.R.: ] Jagdish Maruti Thakur ] Resident of Panvel, Taluka Panvel, ] Dist. Raigad ] 5. Kundalik @ Pundalik Tukaram Thakur, ] since deceased, through Legal Heirs: ] (1)Nirabai Kundalik @ Pundalik Thakur ] Resident of Roadpali, Taluka Panvel, ] District Raigad ] (2) Bebibai Ankush Bhoir ] Residing at Waklan, Taluka and Dist. Thane ] (3) Ratnabai Arun Keni ] Resident of Pethali, Taluka Panvel, ] Dist. Raigad ] 6. Bhagwan Tukaram Thakur ] 7. Balaram Tukaram Thakur ] 8. Tulsabai Balaram Kesai ] 9. Ramchandra Balu Thakur (Deceased) ] through legal representatives: ] 9/1. Jeejabai Ramchandra Thakur ] 9/2. Kesarinath Ramchandra Thakur ] 9/3. Dhanubai Waman Madhavi ] 9/4. Motibai Eknath Patil ] 9/5. Bhagubai Krishna Tembhe ] 10. Shukracharya Pandurang Thakur ] All of Rodpali, Tal. Panvel, Dist. Raigad ]...Respondents 9 (Original Claimants) WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 27840 OF 1996 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS 1. Dattatraya Kashinath Thakur ] (Deceased) through his legal representatives: ] 1/1. Baliram Dattatraya Thakur, age 20 ] 1/2. Ashok Dattatraya Thakur, age 27 ] 1/3. Bharat Dattatraya Thakur, age 23 ] 1/4. Mai Rajaram Patil, age 32 ] 2. Vithal Kashinath Thakur ] 3. Gopinath Kashinath Thakur ] 4. Maruti Kashinath Thakur, since deceased ] by his heir & L.R.: ] Jagdish Maruti Thakur ] Resident of Panvel, Taluka Panvel, ] Dist. Raigad ] 5. Kundalik @ Pundalik Tukaram Thakur, ] since deceased, through Legal Heirs: ] (A) Nirabai Kundalik @ Pundalik Thakur ] Resident of Rodpali, Taluka Panvel, ] District Raigad ] (B) Bebibai Ankush Bhoir ] Residing at Waklan, Taluka and Dist. Thane ] (C) Ratnabai Arun Keni ] Resident of Pethali, Taluka Panvel, ] Dist. Raigad ] 6. Bhagwan Tukaram Thakur ] 7. Balaram Tukaram Thakur ] 8. Tulsabai Balaram Kesai ] 9. Ramchandra Balu Thakur (Deceased) ] through legal representatives: ] 9/1. Jeejabai Ramchandra Thakur ] 10 9/2. Kesarinath Ramchandra Thakur ] 9/3. Dhanubai Waman Madhavi ] 9/4. Motibai Eknath Patil ] 9/5. Bhagubai Krishna Tembhe ] 10. Shukracharya Pandurang Thakur ] All of Rodpali, Tal. Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ...Respondents WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 788 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Shantaram Ambo Bhoir ] since deceased through his L.Rs.: ] (a) Devkubai Shantaram Bhoir, Age 65yrs., wife ] (b) Trimbak Shantaram Bhoir, age 42 yrs., son ] (c) Godabai Maya Joshi, Age 35 yrs., ] Married daughter ] (d) Muktabai Hiraman Patil, Age 40 yrs., ] Married daughter, ] All R/o. Padaghe, Post Navel, Tal. Panvel, ] Dist. Raigad. ] ...Respondents (Original Claimants) WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 27907 OF 1996 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Shantaram Ambo Bhoir ] 11 since deceased through his L.Rs.: ] (a) Devkubai Shantaram Bhoir, Age 65yrs., wife ] (b) Trimbak Shantaram Bhoir, age 42 yrs., son ] (c) Godabai Maya Joshi, Age 35 yrs., ] Married daughter ] (d) Muktabai Hiraman Patil, Age 40 yrs., ] Married daughter, ] All R/o. Padaghe, Post Navel, Tal. Panvel, ] Dist. Raigad. ] ... Respondents WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 789 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS 1. Atmaram Dhondu Mhatre, deceased, ] through his legal representatives: ] 1/1. Shewantibai Atmaram Mhatre, Age 70 ] 1/2. Pundlik Atmaram Mhatre, Age 42 ] 1/3. Krishnabai Budhaji Mendadkar, Age 50 ] 1/4. Yamunabai Ganpat Mhatre, Age 48 ] 1/5. Janabai Atmaram Thakur, Age 47, ] since deceased by her heirs & L.Rs.: ] 1/5(A) Yashwant Atmaram Thakur ] 1/5(B) Ravindra Atmaram Thakur ] 1/5(C) Vishwajeet Atmaram Thakur ] 1/5(D) Santosh Atmaram Thakur ] 1/5(E) Shirish Atmaram Thakur ] 1/5(F) Sachin Atmaram Thakur ] All residing at Roadpali,Taluka Panvel, ] Dist. Raigad ] 12 2. Kashinath Bama Bhoir, Age adult ] 3. Narayan Bama Bhoir, Age adult ] All of Road Pali, Taluka Panvel, Dist. Raigad ]...Respondents (Original Claimants) WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 27838 OF 1996 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS 1. Atmaram Dhondu Mhatre, deceased, ] through his legal representatives: ] 1/1. Shewantibai Atmaram Mhatre, Age 70 ] 1/2. Pundlik Atmaram Mhatre, Age 42 ] 1/3. Krishnabai Budhaji Mendadkar, Age 50 ] 1/4. Yamunabai Ganpat Mhatre, Age 48 ] 1/5. Janabai Atmaram Thakur, Age 47, ] since deceased by her heirs & L.Rs.: ] 1/5(A) Yashwant Atmaram Thakur ] 1/5(B) Ravindra Atmaram Thakur ] 1/5(C) Vishwajeet Atmaram Thakur ] 1/5(D) Santosh Atmaram Thakur ] 1/5(E) Shirish Atmaram Thakur ] 1/5(F) Sachin Atmaram Thakur ] All residing at Road Pali,Taluka Panvel, ] Dist. Raigad ] 2. Kashinath Bama Bhoir, Age adult ] 3. Narayan Bama Bhoir, Age adult ] All of Road Pali, Taluka Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ...Respondents WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 790 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] 13 Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS 1. Shri Trimbak Joma Thakur, ] deceased, through his legal representatives:- ] 1) Dasharath Trimbak Thakur, age 39 ] 2) Kisan Trimbak Thakur, age 33 ] 3) Prabhakar Trimbak Thakur, age 31 ] 4) Bharati Bhaskar Patil, age 37 ] 5) Chandrabai Tukaram Patil, age 35 ] 6) Sulochana Mohan Patil, age 28 ] 7) Asha Vishwanath Patil, age 25 ] 8) Muktabai Trimbak Thakur, age 65 ] 9) Yeshwant Atmaram Thakur, age 25 ] 10) Ravindra Atmaram Thakur, age 23 ] 11) Vishwajeet Atmaram Thakur, age 21 ] 12) Santosh Atmaram Thakur, age 19 ] 13) Shirish Atmaram Thakur, age 17 ] 14) Sachin Atmaram Thakur, age 11 ] 15) Janabai Atmaram Thakur, age 42 ] 2. Trimbak Namaji Bhoir ] All of Roadpali, Tal. Panvel, Dist. Raigad ]...Respondents (Original Claimants) WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 27910 OF 1996 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS 1. Shri Trimbak Joma Thakur, ] deceased, through his legal representatives:- ] 14 1) Dasharath Trimbak Thakur, age 39 ] 2) Kisan Trimbak Thakur, age 33 ] 3) Prabhakar Trimbak Thakur, age 31 ] 4) Bharati Bhaskar Patil, age 37 ] 5) Chandrabai Tukaram Patil, age 35 ] 6) Sulochana Mohan Patil, age 28 ] 7) Asha Vishwanath Patil, age 25 ] 8) Muktabai Trimbak Thakur, age 65 ] 9) Yeshwant Atmaram Thakur, age 25 ] 10) Ravindra Atmaram Thakur, age 23 ] 11)Vishwajeet Atmaram Thakur, age 21 ] 12) Santosh Atmaram Thakur, age 19 ] 13) Shirish Atmaram Thakur, age 17 ] 14) Sachin Atmaram Thakur, age 11 ] 15) Janabai Atmaram Thakur, age 42 ] 2. Trimbak Namaji Bhoir ] All of Roadpali, Tal. Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ... Respondents WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 808 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS 1. Kundalik @ Pundalik Tukaram Thakur, ] since deceased, through Legal Heirs: ] 1-A) Nirabai Kundalik @ Pundalik Thakur ] Resident of Rodpali, Taluka Panvel, ] District Raigad ] 1-B) Bebibai Ankush Bhoir ] Residing at Waklan, Taluka and Dist. Thane ] 1-C) Ratnabai Arun Keni ] Resident of Pethali, Taluka Panvel, ] 15 Dist. Raigad ] 2. Bhagwan Tukaram Thakur ] 3. Balaram Tukaram Thakur ] 4. Tulsabai Tukaram Thakur ] 5. Dattatraya Kashinath Thakur ] since deceased, through legal representatives: ] 5/1. Baliram Dattatraya Thakur ] 5/2. Ashok Dattatraya Thakur ] 5/3. Bharat Dattatraya Thakur ] 5/4. Mai Rajaram Thakur ] 6. Vithal Kashinath Thakur ] 7. Gopinath Kashinath Thakur ] 8. Maruti Kashinath Thakur, ] since deceased by his heir & L.R.: ] 8-A) Jagdish Maruti Thakur ] Resident of Panvel, Taluka Panvel ] Dist. Raigad ] 9. Ramchandra Balu Thakur ] since deceased, through legal representatives: ] 9/1. Jeejabi Ramchandra Thakur ] 9/2. Kesarinath Ramchandra Thakur ] 9/3. Dhanubai Waman Madhavi ] 9/4. Motibai Eknath Patil ] 9/5. Bhagubai Krishna Tembhe ] All are R/o. Roadpalli, Tal. Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ...Respondents (Ori. Claimants) WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 27859 OF 1996 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS 1. Kundalik @ Pundalik Tukaram Thakur, ] since deceased, through Legal Heirs: ] 16 1-A) Nirabai Kundalik @ Pundalik Thakur ] Resident of Rodpali, Taluka Panvel, ] District Raigad ] 1-B) Bebibai Ankush Bhoir ] Residing at Waklan, Taluka and Dist. Thane ] 1-C) Ratnabai Arun Keni ] Resident of Pethali, Taluka Panvel, ] Dist. Raigad ] 2. Bhagwan Tukaram Thakur ] 3. Balaram Tukaram Thakur ] 4. Tulsabai Tukaram Keni ] 5. Dattatraya Kashinath Thakur ] since deceased, through legal representatives: ] 5/1. Baliram Dattatraya Thakur ] 5/2. Ashok Dattatraya Thakur ] 5/3. Bharat Dattatraya Thakur ] 5/4. Mai Rajaram Thakur ] 6. Vithal Kashinath Thakur ] 7. Gopinath Kashinath Thakur ] 8. Maruti Kashinath Thakur, ] since deceased by his heir & L.R.: ] 8-A) Jagdish Maruti Thakur ] Resident of Panvel, Taluka Panvel ] Dist. Raigad ] 9. Ramchandra Balu Thakur ] since deceased, through legal representatives: ] 9/1. Jeejabi Ramchandra Thakur ] 9/2. Kesarinath Ramchandra Thakur ] 9/3. Dhanubai Waman Madhavi ] 9/4. Motibai Eknath Patil ] 9/5. Bhagubai Krishna Tembhe ] All are R/o. Roadpalli, Tal. Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ...Respondents WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 809 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] 17 Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS 1. Shri Trimbak Joma Thakur, ] deceased, through his legal representatives:- ] 1) Dasharath Trimbak Thakur, age 39 ] 2) Kisan Trimbak Thakur, age 33 ] 3) Prabhakar Trimbak Thakur, age 31 ] 4) Bharati Bhaskar Patil, age 37 ] 5) Chandrabai Tukaram Patil, age 35 ] 6) Sulochana Mohan Patil, age 28 ] 7) Asha Vishwanath Patil, age 25 ] 8) Muktabai Trimbak Thakur, age 65 ] 9) Yeshwant Atmaram Thakur, age 25 ] 10)Ravindra Atmaram Thakur, age 23 ] 11) Vishwajeet Atmaram Thakur, age 21 ] 12) Santosh Atmaram Thakur, age 19 ] 13) Shirish Atmaram Thakur, age 17 ] 14) Sachin Atmaram Thakur, age 11 ] 15) Janabai Atmaram Thakur, age 42 ] 2. Anant Narayan Thakur ] All of Roadpali, Tal. Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ... Respondents WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 27916 OF 1996 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS 1. Shri Trimbak Joma Thakur, ] deceased, through his legal representatives:- ] 1) Dasharath Trimbak Thakur, age 39 ] 18 2) Kisan Trimbak Thakur, age 33 ] 3) Prabhakar Trimbak Thakur, age 31 ] 4) Bharati Bhaskar Patil, age 37 ] 5) Chandrabai Tukaram Patil, age 35 ] 6) Sulochana Mohan Patil, age 28 ] 7) Asha Vishwanath Patil, age 25 ] 8) Muktabai Trimbak Thakur, age 65 ] 9) Yeshwant Atmaram Thakur, age 25 ] 10) Ravindra Atmaram Thakur, age 23 ] 11) Vishwajeet Atmaram Thakur, age 21 ] 12) Santosh Atmaram Thakur, age 19 ] 13) Shirish Atmaram Thakur, age 17 ] 14) Sachin Atmaram Thakur, age 11 ] 15) Janabai Atmaram Thakur, age 42 ] 2. Anant Narayan Thakur ] All of Roadpali, Tal. Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ... Respondents WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 810 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS 1. Ramchandra Balu Thakur, deceased through ] his legal representatives: ] (1) Jeejabai Ramchandra Thakur, age 70 ] (2) Kesarinath Ramchandra Thakur, age 52 ] (3) Dhanubai Waman Madhavi, age 43 ] (4) Motibai Eknath Patil, age 36 ] (5) Bhagubai Krishna Tembhe, age 23 ] 2. Shukrucharya Pandurang Thakur ] ...Respondents (Ori. Claimants) 19 WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 27842 OF 1996 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS 1. Ramchandra Balu Thakur, deceased through ] his legal representatives: ] (1) Jeejabai Ramchandra Thakur, age 70 ] (2) Kesarinath Ramchandra Thakur, age 52 ] (3) Dhanubai Waman Madhavi, age 43 ] (4) Motibai Eknath Patil, age 36 ] (5) Bhagubai Krishna Tembhe, age 23 ] 2. Shukrucharya Pandurang Thakur ] ...Respondents WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 811 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Gauraya Narayan Gharat, ] age 55, r/o. Roadpali, Tal. Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ...Respondent (Ori. Claimant) WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 27913 OF 1996 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] 20 Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Gauraya Narayan Gharat, ] age 55, r/o. Roadpali, Tal. Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ...Respondent 21 WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 812 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Prabhakar Bhiwa Patil ] age 44, r/o. Roadpali, Tal. Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ...Respondent (Ori. Claimant) WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 18882 OF 2002 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Prabhakar Bhiwa Patil ] age 44, r/o. Roadpali, Tal. Panvel, Dist. Raigad ] ...Respondent WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 813 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Shri Trimbak Joma Thakur, ] 22 deceased, through his legal representatives:- ] 1) Dasharath Trimbak Thakur, age 39 ] 2) Kisan Trimbak Thakur, age 33 ] 3) Prabhakar Trimbak Thakur, age 31 ] 4) Bharati Bhaskar Patil, age 37 ] 5) Chandrabai Tukaram Patil, age 35 ] 6) Sulochana Mohan Patil, age 28 ] 7) Asha Vishwanath Patil, age 25 ] 8) Muktabai Trimbak Thakur, age 65 ] 9) Yeshwant Atmaram Thakur, age 25 ] 10) Ravindra Atmaram Thakur, age 23 ] 11) Vishwajeet Atmaram Thakur, age 21 ] 12)Santosh Atmaram Thakur, age 19 ] 13) Shirish Atmaram Thakur, age 17 ] 14) Sachin Atmaram Thakur, age 11 ] 15) Janabai Atmaram Thakur, age 42 ]... Respondents (Original Claimants) WITH CROSS OBJECTION (STAMP) NO. 27854 OF 1996 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Shri Trimbak Joma Thakur, ] deceased, through his legal representatives:- ] 1) Dasharath Trimbak Thakur, age 39 ] 2) Kisan Trimbak Thakur, age 33 ] 3) Prabhakar Trimbak Thakur, age 31 ] 4) Bharati Bhaskar Patil, age 37 ] 5) Chandrabai Tukaram Patil, age 35 ] 6) Sulochana Mohan Patil, age 28 ] 7) Asha Vishwanath Patil, age 25 ] 8) Muktabai Trimbak Thakur, age 65 ] 23 9) Yeshwant Atmaram Thakur, age 25 ] 10) Ravindra Atmaram Thakur, age 23 ] 11) Vishwajeet Atmaram Thakur, age 21 ] 12) Santosh Atmaram Thakur, age 19 ] 13) Shirish Atmaram Thakur, age 17 ] 14) Sachin Atmaram Thakur, age 11 ] 15) Janabai Atmaram Thakur, age 42 ] ... Respondents WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 814 OF 1995 The State of Maharashtra ] [at the instance of ] Special Land Acquisition Officer, ] Metro Centre No. II, Panvel] ] ... Appellant (Original Opponent) VERSUS Kandalik Tukaram Thakur, since deceased, ] through Legal Heirs: ] (1) Nirabai Kundalik @ Pundalik Thakur ] Resident of Rodpali, Taluka Panvel, ] District Raigad ] (2) Bebibai