y IN THE M.F.STATE ADMINISTRATIVE IRIBWAL BENCH AT - PAIPUR (C.G.) ^os^i1^u^- BETWEN \^y APPLICANTS ;\^ 1~-» 1. M.S.THAKUR:, AGE - 38 YRS. J S/o Sri KUMENDRA.SINGH POSTED AS - LECTMER (MATHS) . •AT GOVT. HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL, BHILAI - 3 R/o MIG-14 AViNSAROVAR COLONY ^ BHILAI—3, DURG (C.G.) 2. RAJESH KUMAR MISmA, AGE-40 ': S/oSri BRIJMOHAN PRASAD POSTED AS' - lECTtKER (ENG.) \ AT GOVT. HIGHER SEC. SCHOOL CHARODA, GURG (C.G.) is: R/o SUBHASH NAGAR DUSG (C.6.M 3. SMT. PURNIMA BHATTACHftRYA ...i AGE-42 YRS. W/o Sri T.K.BHATTACHARYA POSTED AS - LECTURER GCVT., HI6HER SECOiDARY SCHOW CHARCGA , DURG CC.p.) . R/o 3-349, NEW B(jiSI DURQ 4. SMT. SAVITft BENERJEE; AGE --40.YRS • V(/o Sri P.K.BENERJEE POSTED AS ! LECTURER AT — GOVT. HIG ffiR SE CO^DARY': SCHOOL, Ct-KRODA, R/o RAM NAGAR, BHILAI, DURG (C.G.) 5. SWESH KUriAR.AGE - 38 YRS S/o Sri RAMCH.WDRA POSTED AS—LECTURER. • AT GOVT. HIGHER SECCNDAHy. g SCHOOL VAISHALI NAGER,, • . ;?; BHIIAI, .DW.G |(C.G. ) . •1';.. 'W B./0 A-7, RADBiIKA'NAGEftf-BgJMK DUBG (C.G.) I " / :" ^llil 6. RAJESH CHftTAKJEE,;.SGE.t,<; S/o Sri R.t-i.eHABARJEEi; POSTED AS •LE&TtiREE: ••(ES©.iJi|i| ggH :^:ic^' Si9 ^s^^r^^^yL^A^1^' M ^ .AT GCWT. HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL RISALI, DIRG (C.G.) R/o LAXMI NIVAS,'C/75, SMRITI NA6AR| BHILAI ,.DURG. (C.G.5 -, 3 7,'SMT. SAVITA PfiNDEY, AGE ~- 40-YRSJ W/o SRI AJAY PANBEY • ' l^g POSTED AS - LECTURER '3 GO)'T. HffiHER SECCNDARY SGHCOL 3 RISALI, DUt6 (C.G.) 3 R/o BHILAINAQAR, DLRG (C.G.) .3 8. RAJESH OJHA , AGE - 35 YRS , .| S/o SRI !V.N.OJHA .i| POSTED AS - ^ U.D.T. . .3 R^sx AT - G.OVT..HIGHER SECajDARXl SCHOGL,KOHAKA , BHILAI R/o—C/3, RADHIKA NAGBR BHILAI , DURG (C.G.) 9. B.DASGUPTA , AGE.- 35 YRS' S/o Sri B.D.DASGUPTA POSTED AT—U.D.T. AT - GOVT. HIGHER SECONDARY - SCHQOL, RISALI (BHILAI) R/o' MITRI NAGAR BHILAI (EfiRG;) 10. SHI R.SARSAWTI NAIDU ,AGE-S41 ; W/o Sri R.L.NAIDU PGSTED AS - U.B.T. GOVT. MIDDLE SGHOOL RISALI •R/o - PRAGATI NAGAR BHILAI DIST - DURG (C.G.) 11 . StiST. TARA MADHAVI PILLE ^ AGE—35 YRS • W/o Sri RAJENBRA PILLE ': PGSTEI3 AS - U.D.T. : •; At ! 60VT. HIGHER SECCNDARY. ,' SGHOOL, RUAB»NDHA,.(D e) .: % R/o M OM SEG35CR: BKILAI :rg .•-. DIM: - DI.R6' (G.G'. }.i ' .. :' •'^S 12,'.eHmEaA.SE: AR.^;HANORAKm;'.'i:t® . :,:';.;ffiB::,^:Ni-1yRs''.^::'':'^ :'..-^^;g^jS3?^(£amii||^^|^R»||8^ .|||-^||gS?K:.^l^ :',.^^|g|J ®SiSSai8-JB» .ISS^ !^3K!a©L ^"'•.aaii c 3 :: R/o. VILL. - AOUTiDHI; (PATAN) DBST - DURG (C.G.) • 13. SMT. SEE; PARKAR , AGE - 35 YRS W/o Sri K.R.PARKAR POSTED AS - U.D.T. AT - GOVT. GIRLS HIGHER SECWDARY SBHOOL , VAISHALI NAGSR, BHILAI R/o BHILAI NAGAR, (DURG) 14. D.K.TEMBHARE ,, AGE - ^YRS. S/o Sri P • L- • TEMBHARE POSTED AS - U.D.T. AT - GOVT. HIfflER SECOi'DARY SCHOOL MARO, (DURG) - R/o RtSALI S&CTOR, BLOCK - 16/B BHILAI NAGAR DIST.- DURG (C.G.) : IS.MOHAIt LAL'DESHMUKH, AGE -46 YRS S/o Sri D.D.DESHMUKH POSTED AS -'U.D.T. •; AT - 60VT. KIGHER SECONDARY SCKOOL URLA , DIST -DLRG (C.G.) . R/o SUBHASH NAGBR ,(SURG) 16. CHANDRA KU/iAR DESHMUKH,AGE- 38YRS S/o Sri I- ^~. DESHMUKH POSTED AS - U.D.T. AT -.GOVT. HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL URLA, DURG (C.G.) . R/o BCRSI COLO'IY' (DUP.G) 17. D.P.CHANDRAKAR, AGE - 36 YRS S/o Sri SITARAM CHANDRAKAR POSTEDAS - ASTT. TEACHER -• AT - GOVT. PRIMARY SCHOOL,DEVBALCBA' R/o. VILL. LCHARSI, P.O.-TARRA; •^ TAH. - PATAN, DIST - DURG (C.G.) :!»i 18. HEfcLSN LAL H1RWANI, A3E - 3<g YRS.. S/o. Sri-R.S. HIRWANJ A POSTED AS - ASTT. TEACHER :%N AT - GOVT. PRIMARY SCHOOL MCRS,.;;® R/o. VILL. MCRID, DbKG (C.G.);::%i| •^aaas M an '^[^a • BHSM iii (9in.ia) "isra 'nnswna 'o/y ('3"o5 otfiai 'isia 'NViyd:—-'HVI IB®:'nnsNyHa 'TOOHSS 37001^ •IA.OO—iv y3H3V3J. •11SV - Sy 031SOd nuvs WVWATO T-cs o/s' 'saA ifr - 39^ ' OHVS HOMIS mwy 'ss (oyna) 'yvsvN iniHB o/y ivyvxvaor 'TOOHOS AW.Aiiyd • -IAOS asHovax 'iisy - sv aajsod HS39NV9 yVMHSaHSla T^S 'o/S S)(X sw. oi7—aoy. ' HSSSNVO yv»HS3H>iyi ras •frz (OUna)y33VN IV7IHS o/-y IVIIHS' ( I.) 'ON VaOBW; - NOI1V1S 'IOOHOS Ayvi'raad 'JLAOS - xv yaHovariisv - sy aaisod ' aVMHS3H>i'yi TJS o/M S'dA SS — 39V ' HaiNyO-^IHSnTOi 'XWS •£3 (syna) 'UVOVN lyiiHa 'o/y llMWi vcD-awi ^OOHOS Awmrad •IAOS - iy ygHoyai 'iisv - sy aaisod W!!'in>' AWiMVS T-CS o/M SyA 9£ - 3W ' VHIW>1U ¥W.L •IWS 'ZZ (oma) ' WWH I¥^IH9 O/H nvsiH 'IOOHOS 3^aaIN 'JAOO - iv 'H3H3VS1 •J.XSV - SV a31SOd >-y<I33a-ST T-rS "^^ o/S SHA 3S - 33V 'XW3.3Q CWSWd HSlaQVP ' tg Oyna) 'WOVN lyiina nvsiy -'o/y nvsiy'TOOH3S 3'Eiaiw -IAOS - xy ysHOvai •iisv -.sy aaisod nHwya tj:s O/M SaA Sfr - 39¥ ' niws yyiaNi •xws •os (oyna) zniHa 'WSVN yyHVAwr o/y I¥^IHa.WDVN nVHSIVA ^OOHOS AWahD03S U3H9IH STOI9 • iAOS - J,¥ y3Hov:3i 'iisv - sv aaisod 'NVONVMSa - T^S o/ffi SHA'Ofr - 33V ' NVO.WM'aa naNi •xws •6i IK, ^^y <,•*"> • • • * ^/ • • BERSUS RESPONDENTS A- 1. STATE OF CHATTISGARH. THROU3H THE SECRETAHY DEPARTNENT.OF EDUCATIQN D.K.S.BHAWAN, RAIPUR 2. THE DIRECTOR, PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS CmTTJSGARH, RAIPUR 3; DI'STRICT EDUCATIOM OFFZCER DL&G (C.G.) /^. ii£i!i"iia:i ISB'i'i^ £ t-II©HCOURT OF CHHATTTSeARH AT BILASPUR W. P.(S)No. 4641 of 2005 Petitioners M.5. Tliakur and others Versus Respondents State of Chhattisgarh & others ffi1' w,\ Single Bench; Hon'ble Mr. Justice Satish K. <4gnihotri. Shri R.K. ItesharMfani, Adyocate for the Petitioners. Shri V.V.S. Moorthy, t>y. Advocate Seneral with 5mt. Anju Ahuja, t>y. Sovt. Advocate for the respondents/S+ate. ORDEft ith (lfOctober.2006) 1. Leamed counse! appearing for the petitioners submits that while working os Lecturers/Assistant Teachers/Upper Division Teachers, the petitioners have gone on training to imphave their quatifications on their ovm expenses and acquired B.Ed./B.T.I Examination Certificate. 2. According to teamed counsel for the petitioners, the petitioners are entitted to twoadvance increments in view of the decision of this Court m the co^e of yashwant Kumar Bharadwaj Vs. Municipal Corporntion, Ourg ond onothep {2006 (II) MPJR-C6 96}. 'n'iis ,Court in the ease of Yashwant Kumar Bl'iaradwaj Vs. Municjpal 1- Corpordtion, Ourg ond another (Supra), came to the conclusion that the tedchers, who had obtained B. Ed./B.T.I. Examination lli.il- t^' lillii 111^1. 1?;^' Hiill IMii IIISi ISubhash Certificate on his own expenses, are covered by the circutar dated 24.12.98 issued by the State Sovemnient of Madhya Pradesh. 3. Leamed counset for the petitioners ."furriier aibmits thort- the facts and question of law involved in ttie present case is squarely covered by decision of this Court in the caseof Yashwont Kumar Bharacfwaj Vs. Municipat Corporation, Durg and another (5upra),to which leamed counsel appearing for the respondents fairty concedes dnd agrees with the averment made by teamed counsel appearing for the petitioners. 4. Accordingly, the writ petition is dllowed in terms of the order passed jn the case of yashwflnt Kumar Bharadwaj Vs. Municipal Corporation, Durg and another (Supra), subject to verification of the factas to whether the petitioners have acquired B. Ed./B.T-I. Exqmination Certificates on thei& own expenses or not. Noorder astocosts. SdA Satish l£Agiuhotri Judge