IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR WRIT PETITION Now OF 2006 s‘mmi 3E?§§§EI? Imam: m RESPONDENTS M.L. Ghritlahare, aged about 55 years, S/o Late Kartik Ram OA Ghritlahare, LecturefSociologr,‘ v" Posted at Government Higher Secondary School, ’I‘uman, District Korba (C.G.) VERSUS. . State of Chhattisgarh, Through: The Secretary, Schedule Caste and Schedule Tribe Development Department, D.K.S. Bhawan Raipur (C.G.) The Commissioner, , . Tribal Development Department, Raipur District Raipur (C.G.) The Collector, Korba District Korba (C.G.) The Assistant Commissioner, &. TribaLDevelopment Department, District Korba (C.G.) . The Principal, Government Higher Secondary School, 'I‘uman, District Korba I (C.G.) 6. Smt. Manjula Dubey, Lecturer Geography, Government Higher Secondary School Kanki,District Korba C.G. WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226/227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR ISSUANCE OF AN‘ APPROPRIATE WRIT IN THE NATURE OF MANDAMUS! CERTIORARI ETC. OR DIRECTIONIORDER IN THE LIKE NATURE ETC. XI-HC-78 mam wm mmm 1912§Gé W'P. N95. 3?:23/2006, 3 3527/2006, 3528/2066, 35$3/2$Gé, 3534/2006, 3542/2906) 3543/2G0é, ‘ 3547/2095. L Shri §ajash Pmdey, Advoca e for the pafifianers. ' 5hri ‘ Sumesh 3ajcj, responde'rifs/Si'dfe o‘n 2dva2acé co y. I Hedrd.‘ 7 2’ W 5 Tidal main grievance miSed by fhe‘ peTiT‘ionars is common and cammon issue is §nvb§ved in these pe§%fiens, 2herefere, ‘Fney are being disgaeszd of by fhis common crder 2 3y “these ge'i'ifbns, 2kg pe? Chha‘r?isggarh, have quzsi'bned ' mm§wm %a?%wan%¥T~ 352 524/2096, 3525/2006; 352é/200é, 2/2006, gasexzeoe, 3531/2006, ?/2Q06i 3549/200é, ‘3541/2906, 3/2006; 3§4§/2006, 3546IZQQ6, evernmenf Advaca‘re' far the new, who are wark'mg as Leanna?" in various Higher Secendar'y Sci'm [is ma ¥m Disfric? Korba of 5mm cf hagaiiw & correcmesé of Their §rcmsfer order dared 7.7.2QO’3 £Annaxure P—l} issuad under ’rhe Gevemment of Chhaf‘risgarh,‘ Devabpmen? Dapam‘mem, Raipur. The gréurids 01'" chaHenge of fhis order! as raised by the pefhie’n'ers, are i‘hai‘ ‘k’he Sacra? r‘y 0r 1‘iqe Undzr 5ecr'emry has m jurisd‘icfian‘ ‘l'o {in'sfs fhé"§m§u§ne fransfar orciar, as The Csmsaiiing ' PIC. signafure of Under Secre‘m m V Sghgdule‘d Cam & scheduiea E W , W , W mmoowoop..o$$o3o$ox.oo . - y 0(2: m 200 NWW(W) m k a , i XI—HC-78 H W , W , W o o‘o¢o‘..v..oo.oo¢.ooo 3mm (W) WWW' WWW ‘ WW§WW WHF%H3H%QT *”p?~ *Wm Ccmmifwe is empeweresi 1‘9 ssue Wansfer vardars‘ unéer The Qafionaiiza‘rien Scheme dafa& $2006; fherefore, fhe impggneti Transfer order §ssueci by raspamiem Na}. is wi‘r‘nouf jurisdisfian and ngEiify in ‘r’ne eyes of iaw. jm Sfaé'e Governmeni‘ §ms akeady ciaiagai'eé “rhe pawgrs of fransferring iriae feachars 'm wunse§§§ng csmmi‘h‘aa cari£?ifu‘raé a? ‘khe Sfa‘fe ieve§ uncéar we m%iom%iza?iw imwgnad fransfer wder has beam issued in flagram' vioia‘i'bn of fha‘ provisiuns conmined in Paras 5 :3;- 6 of '?%1§s r‘mioaa5i2afion scheme. $cheme éafeai M22006 and +992 Perusal ’ of impugned orcier Annexure P—1 whereby fhe pe‘ri‘rianers have been Transferrd as aéso T‘ne m?iomiiza‘§'is<n scheme dared 1.6.2£}06 shaws firm“ ?he paéfmns are mEscanceived, fer a‘he rzn$ens i‘ha‘: "‘rha impugned crdzr‘, undgr wiaich fhe peti‘l’ianers have bean Transferraai has been pase'eé on admm§ymfive groum’e The; ewe“ has no? been passed wider The mTionaiizafio'n scheme dated 2.6.ZGG§ and *i‘he same has been passeci by +§1e éavemmen? iv: exercige sf genera! powers w fmnsfer ifs mp!c‘yees. Perusai cf mfiam§izafion cheme aimed 1,6.2G06 shaws 1%a?* where on acccu’n? of Tmnsfers, p mafisns é: rairemems f‘ne num%)ers of teachers have become irra‘riie e3 in various schog§s baking w ‘r§'xe numbers of s‘mcienfe Le. where an aemum" 63" aémve memionee reasens m we schoo¥ numeers 01" feache have became iese 1 0r 2 er where P.T.O. XI-HC—78 mmmw x mmm‘ mwm ~?— ‘rhe mumbers of ‘a‘eachers have ¢ aumbers m? watchers, in ‘khm’ m arwismed §n ';"he scheme, wi¥§ com gf‘rer coi§ecf§ng infomda?ion fro schon§s or mid’dk sc‘nsals or cemmm‘ea s?1a§i m?iam!ize i‘éa-e m1 isqking #0 ‘rn‘a nambers of swdem ccmmitfee is 1‘9 ensure fha? in no g feachers, if: case of middie' schoc case 01‘ high schoai no? less fhan ' secondary schoo? no? iess Than six ‘ A-s has beeya meafiwssd ea ‘baarz passaaé Lmdar fha audminis‘r zdminis?m?%va grounijs and i—Ms m'fiamiiza'mrE schema dm'ed 1.6. ampcwar‘ed i'o ‘3‘mns‘?er h‘s em mficna§izafien schama dces he”? deparfmen? sf fhe Smfe Gavern lifs feachers in 'i’éne. adminisn‘mfive fxAsreovar, a bare parusai sf fhe mgnfienw in fhe pg‘réfiom *rhaf ’vzigaiqer secon&ary schooi numbers WW§WW ‘ ~$WW ' axceeded more ‘man 1%13 reauired 3e Té‘le 50nczme& deparfmam, as %§:?u1'e a caunseix‘érig csmmi‘H'ee am? m 1%}3 various higiqer sacsndary primary schaois, 1&3 ‘caracemed m’bgrs 9*? washers m each scfvmds s. 3:? has been envisaged 1%2? fine yrsmqry schooi remain less ‘?hcm fwe I m? Sass fhan fhree feachers, in :aur feachers and in case ef‘hiéher 'eachars. iigr €m? the impugneé Qrder has ve ppwers of “the §avemmam or: rder has nQ‘EJning ‘m ds WM? ‘E‘Zie 096. The (%evemmem is aiways éoyees ami ‘Eae infraégc‘i‘im cf eafa any bar 141a? the concamgd em‘ is naf emmwareci f0 fmnsfer exigency or in fhe pqbk inferest ?i:risns shows ‘i'ha? it has nei- been y “fnese frcmsfars m a parficukir sf feacham i’aas baccmg Sass ‘k‘mm P.T.O. H W , W , W . WW (W) =§ r .‘ p x , XI-HC~78 mwm‘ - WWW 4. l, ‘é'éne requirad number's of exaaeckd waking 1'9 a‘he num sf ?he paii'ieners are no? maxi Nr‘13 91" fhe §ovemmem ' ground and ii" ims n: rafiomHza‘rEen schemi m fh‘e pefi‘é'ions if ha: 1*mnsfers fhe princi; has been wowed i" WW§WW ‘ %aq%wan%w Roshcm/- {2} §amma%aa&w feachars or numbers a’f i’aaciqers imve bars of s?u:§en?s. Therefare, ‘rha pea’i'riorzs Waimbk for ?he reasans *Thai‘; ‘ms kueen passed under the generw pawers 'o i'mns‘far i%s empioyees on adminis?ra?§ve' ‘3? been pussad under- ‘rha said scheme Le. a da‘kd 1.6.ZQG&‘ ; no? been waged fha‘? on accoum’ of Tbese ie enunciafed in fhe rafibmliza‘fion scheme an accour? OT These 'i'ransfeFs 1+2 numbers or Teachers have bLcomz iess fhan fhe requweci nqmbers of #eac’ners under ”(ha any gar?§¢uiar sa‘hed Th2 areas mg open: 1.6.2906 wad of . Hawever, 3‘,“ any sud pe?i?§oners, f‘hen they wiii he awhori‘a‘y coracemed. ze pa?i?§ens smné dismissw; fer gram of smy aiso smnds dismissed ~af§ana§izm‘i0n saheme or‘ have exceeéed m ten‘rmry aha ?%ze mfiamikm‘ioa schema. “i'ian m‘ i'ha mfiomiiza'rion scheme dafed uwemmena are du i2 322mm! yowers of ‘7-‘mnsfer cf S‘m‘t‘e , insmnce crmaes To ‘rhe nefica of m‘ §ébzriy 1‘9 make a rapresem‘gfiar: f6 #hz rent * Sd/- L.C. Bhadoo Judge { v g y w mamm;®?hwg,W o _m..oo‘ooo.‘o¢o.o‘y§\_oa‘o E 200 WW(W> ' f’ne arder impugned In View Qf #‘rse abawa, f? Cansequzafiy, M.(W.}F. f