Pefifioner HIEH CWRT OF‘CHHATTI56ARH AT BILASPUR Writ Petifion No; 6455 of 2005 J Versus Abrha'n Minj S/o Smuael Minj aged about 57 yrs, Head Masfer R/O Catholic Primwy School Bhelwm Td1. Kmkuri, Dim. ashpur, [ca] Sfafc of Chhcf‘tisga'h, Through fhe Secretary, Department of j 5chool Educa'rion, Mom-day, D.K.5. Bhawan Roipur [C.G.] 2. The Direc‘ror, Dir-comes of Public‘ Insfmci-ion, Pension Bodo Raipur [C5] V3. The Dish'icf Educoi‘ion Officer Piblic Instructions Joshpw,[€.6.] 4. The Chairman / Manager Co'l’holic Prima-y School Bhelwan, Kunkur'i Calholic Insfiiutions Jashpur Soulh Zone P.O. Kunkur'i, Dlsff. Joshpur [6.6.] ‘ Peiitio‘ner Respondenfs 4 Robot-i Minj S/o Joseph Minj Aged abouf 54 yrs, Assifonf Teacher R/O Catholic Primary School ’ Bhelwon Tdl. Kmklri, Disff. Joshpur, [C.6.] 1. Sfoi'e of hhol’fisga‘h, Through fh secretory, Deporlmenl . of School Educofion, Mann-clay, D.l<.5. Bhowon Roipur [6.6.] The Direc‘l'or, Direclcro‘l'es of Plblic Instruction, Pension Bodu Roipur [CG] Writ Petition No. 6456 of 2005 Versus C e . Wrif Pzfifimyo. Petitionér Jashpur [ca] Versus Respondents ' 3. The District Educafion Offiur PLbiic Insfrucfions Jashpw, [¢.6.] 4. The Chairman / Manager Cafholic Prima'y School Bhelwm, Kunkuri VCcrholic Institutions Jashpw South Zone P.O. Kmkuri Dis‘H. Jashpur [ca] 6482¢f2005 Bhinsem Tigga S/o Mia! Tlgga, Aged W 63 yrs, Rafired Lecfurer, RIO Vill. Ginabohw, Disf‘l’. Joshpur [6.6.], Posfal Add. Girl's Hr. Sec. School Ginabdw‘, 1. State of- Chhattisgwh, Throtgh the Secretory, Department of School Education, Mantraluy, D.l<.$. Bhawan Ralpw [C.6.] The Director, Directorates of Public Instruction, Pension Bada Raiptr [6.6] The District Education Officer Public Instructions JashpwJceJ 4. The Chairman /. Manager, Girl's Hr. Sec. School aim, kaigarh society of Frmsicon' Sisters of Marry H.o. a no. eiww, Dim. Jashpu» [ca] 6433 of2005 Carlus Xess S/o Late Joseph Xess', Aged m 65 yrs, Retired U.D. Teacher, RIO Vill. ,Kmktri, Distt. Ja§ipu~ [C.G.], Postal Add. Loyola Hr. Sec. School Kunkuri, Jashpur, [C.6.] Writ Petition No. Petitioner Versus , . . Respondents Wrif PgfifionNo. Pemioner- 1. sma of awhmwwh, Through the Secretary, Deparfmenf of School Educafion, Mmfralay, D.K.5. Bhwmn Raipw [C.6.] 2. The Direcfor, Direchmfes of Public Instr-udion, Pension Sada Raipur [6.6] 3. The Dish-id- Education Officer Pubiic In’siruciions Joshpw,[C.6.‘] 4. The Chairman / Manager Loyola Hr. Sec. School Kunkurl Jushpw, Loyola Jewi‘i sociew Kunkuri, P.o. Kunku-i, Dim. Joshpur [6.6.] 6485 of 2005 Jams Ekka 5/0 Lon Pefer Ekka, Aged m 68 yrs, ke‘rired U.D. Toochcr, k/O Vill. Kunkwi, DTS‘H'. Jad'ipur [C.6.], Postal Add. Loyola Hr. Sec. School Mari, Jadmpur, [6.6.] 1. Slate of Chhmisgmh, Through the secrei‘ory, Deoorfmen‘l of School Eduoofion, Manfroloy, D.l<.5. .Bhowan Roipur [C.$.] 2. The Director, Dired‘orales of Public Instruction, Pension. oada Rdpur [as] 3. The Dislricl Educo‘lian Officer Piblic Insiruc‘lions Jashpw, [co] The Chairman / Manager, Loyola Hr. Sec. School Kmkuri Joshpur, Loyola Jesui‘r Socie‘ly Kurkuri, P.O. Kunku-i, Disft. Joshpur [C.6.] Verws Respondents 4 . @ Pefifioner Vwsus kesponden’ts Petitioner Writ Pcfifion No. 6486 of 2005 Bhinsenf Toppo S/o Lat: Dhan Kunmr Toppo Aged abouf $3 yrs,‘ Retired U.D. Teacher R/O WI. Lokhanda Dim. Jashpur [cm Posh! Add. Mofilal Hr. Sac. School Lokhandi Jashpw.€.6.] ‘ 1. Sink of Chho‘rtisgm‘h, Through The Smtary, Doparfmem of School Education, Marmiay, bxs. Bhawon Roipur [C.6.] 2. The binder, Dired'ornfes of Public Insfr-uci-ion, Pension Roda Raipur [C5] 3. The District Education Officer PLbiic Insirucfions Jashpur. [C.6.] 4. The Choifmm / Manager Moii iui Hr. Sec. School Lokmdi Joshpur Regional Development Commi‘lfee Lokhmdi Disft Jashpur {6.6.} Wrif Pefifion No. 6487 of 2005 Benedicf Minj 5/0 Late Thomas Minj, Aged about 65 yrs, Rem-aw u.i>. Tmher, R/o mu. Kmku-i, Disit Ja’shpir [C.&.], Posial Add. Loyola Hr. sec. School Kmkwi,- Jashpu', [C.G.] Respondenis 1. Siale of Chharfisgwh, Through fhe Secretary, Depar‘imenf of School Educol'ion, Moniroloy, D.K.S. Bhowon Roipur [6.6.] 2. The Director, Directorafos of Public Insfrucfion, Parisian Bada Raipur {one} 3. The DiSl-rlcf Education Officor Piblic Insirucfians Joshpw, [cm Versus { 4. The Chairman / Manager Loyola Hr. Sec. bis”. Jashpur [C.6.] wm égmmuo. 6488 of 2005 Pe‘rifioner Tmtus Ekka s/o Lm Julius Ekka, Aged wt 64 yrs, Retired U.D. Teacher, R/O Vill. [6.6.] Versus Respondenfs 1. Sfd bf Thi'ough ‘I'he Deparh-nen‘l‘ Chhcfrisgw-h, 5ecre‘lary, of School Educafion, Mamralay, D.K.5. Bhawon Raipur- [C.6.] 2. The Director, Direcforci'es of Public Insfrucfion, Pension Bade Reipur [6.6] 3. The District Education Irish-whens Officer Public Joshpur, [6.6.] 4. The Chair-mm / Manager, Loyola Hr. Sec. School Kmkuri I Joshpur, ‘Loyold Jesuii Society Kunkuri, P.O. Kunkur'i, Dim. Jashpur [C.6.] ‘ Wri‘l’ Pefl‘l'lan No. 6491 of 2005 Pefifioner Miss Josphin Barwa D/o Carlus Barwa Aged about Holy Cross Sisters Asso. H.O. Gholengh, RIO Holy Cross 6irls Hr. Sec. School Gholeng, Distt. .Twpur, [6.6.] 45 yrs, U.D. Teacher, Working under Commif‘ree MJ’. Versus Respondems 1. Side of Through fhe Depar‘rmeni' Chhafiisgwh, Secretary, of School Educafion, Monfralay, VD.K.S. Bhawan Raipur [C.G.] Sch‘oal Kmkuri Jwhpur, Loyola Jewif Sociefy Kunkuri, P.O. Kunkuri, Kunkuri, Disit. Jashpur [6.6.], Postal Add. Loyola Hr. Sec. School Kunkwi, Jmhpur, e 9 6 2. The Direcfor, binder-«es of ' Public Instruction, Pcnsion Bade Raipur {cs} 3. The Dis'h'ict Education Officw Public Instrucfions Jashpur, {C.6.] Wri? Pe'mbn No. ‘ 6506 of 2005 Ku. Ap‘aiina Kujur D/o Piyus Kujur Agzd about 45 yrs, Assisfant Teacher, Working under Commiffee M.P. Holy Cross sister's Asso. H.O. Gholengh, RIO Holy Cross Girls Hr. Sec. School Gholeng, Dis‘H. Joshpur, [C.6.] PeTifioner' Versus Respondems 1. Side of Chhmisgarh, Through the Secretary, Depmem of School Eduoofion, Maw-clay, D.K.5. Bhawan Raipur- [6.6.] 2. The Director, Director-«cs of Public Insfruc‘rion, Pension Bade Roipur [c.G] , 3. The Districf Education Officer- Public structions Jmhpw, [cm 4 Wrif Pefifion No. 6507 of 2005 Sm'i‘. Nolini Bowie W/o Lucas Barwa Aged abouf 61 yrs, UD. Teacher, Working under Committee M.P. Holy Cross Sisfe'rs Assn. HO. Gholengh, k/O Holy Crm 6irls Hr. Sec. School Gholeng, Disff. Jmpur, [C.6.] M. Petitioner Versus Respondents 1. Side of. Chhoi’tisgwh, Through the ecretory, Deporimen'r of School Educofion, Manfralay, D.l<.S. Bhwon Roiptr- [6.6.] ' In S Writ Paifbn No. Petitioner 2. The Dir-Mar, Directorafcs of Public Instrucfion, Pznsion Bade Raipur [6.6] 3. The District Educafion Officzr Public Instrucfions Joshpur,[C.6.} 6508 «E2005 SIM. Moira Sunim Toppo‘ w/o Ajuv Tom» Asad m 36 m. U.D. Teachar, Working under Commi‘nee M.P. Holy Cross Sister's A590. H.O. Gholengh, R/O Haly Cross Girls Hr. Sec. 5¢hool Gholeng, Dim. Jashpur, [C.6.] Versus Respondenls 1. Side of Chha-Hisgwh, Through fhe Swefary, Deparimen‘i of School Education, Manfralay, D.K.$. Bhawan Raipur- [6.6.] 2. The Direcfor, Director-ales of Public Instruciion, Persian Boda Raipur [C5] The Dislricf Education Officer Public Insfruciions Jashpur.[€.6.] 6509 of 2005 Wrl‘l' Pe‘l'i‘l'lon No- Petitioner Versus Respondents Smt. Maximilia Xalxo W/o Bengul Xolxo Aged about 36 yrs. U.D. Teacher, Working under Committee M.P. Holy' Cross Sisters Asso. H.O. Gholengh, RIO Holy Crm Girls Hr. Sec. school Gholeng, Distt. Joshptir, [C.G.] 1. State of Chhottisgwh, Through the Secretory, Department of School Education, Monti-clay, D.K5. Bhowan Raipur [6.6.] . 2. The Direc‘for,rbimforatcs of Public Insfruction, Pulsion Bada kaipur [c6] 3. The District Education Officer Public Insfruciions Jashpur, [c.a} Wri‘i' P¢tifion Nu. 6510 of 2005 Pe‘ri’rioner Smf. Iéipriya Rqimi Ekka W/o Ronjif Ekka Aged abou? 35 yrs, Uppgr Div. Teacher, Working under Committee M.P.- Hoiy Crass Sisters Asso. H.O. Gholengh, R/O Holy Cross Girls Hr. Sac. Schnal Gholeng, Distt. Jashpur, [6.6.] Versus Respondents 1. State of Chhcttisga-h, Through the Secretory, Department of school Education, Montroloy, D.K.S. Bhmn Roipur [C.6.] 2. The Director, Directorates of " Public Instruction, Pension Bade Raipur [C5] 3. The District Eduootion , Officer Ptblic Instructions Joshpur, [C.G.] Writ Petition No. 6511 of 2005 Petitioner Miss Jenebibo Ekka D/o Johan Ekka Aged about 46 yrs, Upper Div. Teacher, Working under Committee M.P. Holy Cross Sisters Assn. H.O. 6holengh, RIO Holy Crm Girls Hr. Sec. School Gholeng, Distt. Jmhpur, [C.G.] Versus 1. state of Chhattisgm'h, Throtgh the Secretary, Department of School Education, Mantralay, D.l(.$. Bhwlan Raipur [C.6.] 2. The Director, Directorates of Public Instruction, Pension Bada Raipur [CG] Pe'ri'rioner 3. The Diswicf Educdion Officer Ptblic Instructions Jashpur,[c.6.] Ku. Jyo‘l'i Minj D/o Marcus Minj Aged abou‘r 33 yrs, Assistant Teacher R/O Catholic Prima-y Sahool Bhelwan Td'l. Kunktri, Distt. Joshpur, [C.6.] Resportdents Chhattisgwh, ' Through . th Secretary, Department of School Education, Mantratay, D.K.S. Bhawan Raipur [C.G.] ' 2. The Director, Direétoram of Public Instruction, Pension Bada Raipur [6.6] 3. The District Education Officer Pubiic Instructions Jashpur,[C.6.] The Chairman / Manager Catholic Primm‘y School Bhelwan, 'Kunkuri - Catholia Institutions Joshpu‘ South Zone P.O. Kunkuri, Distt.‘ Joshpw [CG] 4 1. State of Petitioner 6525 of zoos Writ Petition No. Respondents Ku. Sekunda Minj D/o Ageniyus Minj Aged w 36 yrs, Assistant Teacher RIO Catholic Primmy School Bhelwm Tdw. Kunkwi,‘ Distt. Jaiwpu‘, [C.6.] Versus 1. State of Chhottisgorh, Through the Secretory, Department of School Education, Mmtroloy, D.K.S. Bhawan Raipur [C.6.] Writ Petition No. 6524£L2005 Versus c . 10 2. The’Dirc'cfor, Directorates of Public Instruc'rion, Pension Bade Roipur [6.6] 3. The Disfr-icf Education Officer Public Insir‘ucfions Jashpur, [ca] The Chairman / Manager Cniholic' Primw-y School Bhelwm,‘ Kunkuri Catholic Insfii'ufions J’xhpur Souih Zone P.O. Kmkgri, Dim. Jashpur [cm Writ mm. No. 65a7 af zoos Pefi'l'ianen 53;. eulqb mu.» blo Thomas Ktuur Aged abou? 54 yrs, 'U.D. Teacher, Working under Commiffee M.P. Holy Cross Sisters Asso. H.O. Gholengh, R/O Holy Cross Girls Hr. Sec. School Gholeng, Disl‘l. Joshpur, [C.6.] ’1. sme of Chhanisgwh, Through the Secretory, Department of School Education, Mantrolay, D.K.S. Bhmon Roipur [C.6.] 2. The Director, Directormos of PLblic Instruction, Pension Bode Raipur [C5] he District Education Officer Ptblic Instructions Jashpur, [ca] Respondents Versus .. wm Penna. No. 6531 of zoos Petitioner 5m. Marry Pmisio Kujo- W/o Nirmol Kujw Aged M 45 yrs, Lab Assis'tmt, Working under Committee M.P. Holy Cross Sisters Asso. H.O. Gholengh, R/O Holy Cross Girls Hr. Sec. School Gholeng, Distt. Joshpur, [C.6.] Versus . T 11 Respondem's 6535 #2005 Wrif Petition No. Pei'itiomr Ku. Immakuiciu Ekkn .D/o Bhinseni Ekka Aged aboui 55 yrs. Assisia'ri Teacher, Working under Commiiiee M.P. Holy Cross 5mm Assn. H.o. ehoiengh, wo Holy Cross éirls Hr. Sec. School 6holeng, Dis‘l'l'. J¢hpnn [C.6.] Versus " 1. Sfafe of Respondenis 1. Sick ¢f Chhamsgwh, Through fhe ,Secrzfary, Dcpartmenf of School Educafion, Mmfralay, D.K.5. Bhowan kaipur [C.G.] 2. The Diredor, Directordcs of Public Instruction, Pension Roda Roipur [6.6] 3. The Disfrict Education Omar . Pubiic Instructions Jashpur, [C.G.] Chhoffisgwh, Through fhe Socrcfary, Department of School Educo'iion, Morriralay, D.K.$. Bhowon Roipur [C.G.] 2. The Director, Directorates of Public Instruction, Pemipn Bado Roipur [C5] The District Education Officer Public Instructions Joshpur, [6.6.] Petitioner Versus 6536 of 2005 Writ Petition No. Smt. Irine Lucy Ekka W/o Michael Ekku Aged about 60 yrs, Assistant Teacher, Working under Committee MP. Hoiy Cross Sisters Assn. HQ. Gholengh, RIO Holy Cross Sirls Hr. Sec. School Shaleng, Distt. Jwhpw, [6.6.] 12 Respondents wm Petition No. Pefifioner Nirdosh Toppo S/o Benedit Toppo Aged about 42 yrs, P.T. Instructor, Working under Committee M.P. Holy Cross Sisters Assn. H.O. Ghoiengh, R/O Holy Cross Girls Hr; Sec. School Gholeng, Distt. Jwhpur, [C.G.] Versus " 1. Respondents WrH' Pefifion No. Petitioner ' Versus 1. Sfafe of Chho'ttisghh, Through the Secretary, Department of School Education, Mantroloy, DJLS. Bhawan Roipur' [C.6.] The Director, Directorates of Public Instruction, Pension Bada Roipur [C5] 3. The District Education Officer ?ublic Instructions Jashpw,[C.6.] 6538 of 2005 State of Chhattisgarh, Through the Secretory, Department of School Education, Montralay, D.K.5. Bhawan Roipur [6.6.] 2. The Director, Directorates of Public Instruction, Pension Bode Roipur [C5] 3. The District Education Officer PLblic Instructions Joshpur, [C.6.] 6539 of 2005 Ku. Augustine Hembrome D/o Bernwd Aged ¢out 36 yrs, U.D. Teacher, . Working under Committee M.P. Holy Cross. Sisters Asso. H.O. Gholengh, R/O Holy Crm Girls Hr. Sec. school Gholeng, Distt. Joshpur, [§.6.] Respondenfs Peti'l'ioner Respondents Petifioner 13 1. Sfai'e of Chhmisgwh, Through the Sacrefary, Depamgm of school Education, Marm‘alay, D.K.S. Bhauan Raipur [C.G.] The Direcfor, Directorafa of Pubiic Insfmcrion, Pension Bada Raipur [C5] The District Education Officer Pubiic Instructions Jashpur, [ca] 65400f2005 Ku. Sabina Kerkofl’a D/o Anjulus Kerkeffa Agad abouf 33 yrs, U.D. Teacher, Working under M.P. Holy Cross Sisiers Asso. H.0, 6holengh, RIO Holy Cross Girls Hr. 5n. School Gholeng, Disfi. JoshPl-I‘. [6.6.] Writ Pgfii'ion No. Commiffee Versus 6570 of 2005 Writ Pefifion No. Versus 5fo‘le of Chha‘ffisgwh, Through lhe Secrelory, . Deporfmenf of School Education, Manfraluy, DKS, Bhmvon Roipur [6.6.] The Director, Direcforofes‘of Public Instruollon, Pension Bode Roipur [C5] The Dish-ici- Educolion Officer Public Insi‘rucfions Jashpur, ,[C.6'.] Joseph Kqjur S/o LoteB. Kujur, Aged m 66 yrs, Reiired U.D. Teacher, R/O Vill. Kunkuri, Dim. Joshpur [6.6.], Posiol Add. Loyola Hr. sec. school Kunkuri, Joshua», [co] . . 14 kespondents Pefifioners kesponden'rs @. 1. sme’ of Chhmisgwh, Through ‘l'he Sumter-y, Deparfmmf of School Education, Mantralay, D.K.5. shawan kaipur {cm The Direcfor, Direcfomra of Public Insiruction, Pension Bada Raipw [a6] 3. The District Educa'iion‘ Officer Public Instrucfions Jashpur'. [5.6-] 4. The Chairman / Manger Loyola Hr. 5ec. School Kmkuri Jashpur, Loyola Josuif Society Kunkuri, P.O. Kunkuri, Distt. Joshpw [C.6.] And Writ Pati‘i’ion No. 2212 of 2006 1. 5mt. Shanti Toppo 'W/o Silbonus Aged bout 5O yos, Assistant Teacher 2. Smt. Auleria Lakra S/o Jul Mashih Aged about 36 yrs, Assistant Teacher 3. Ku. Hiramoni Boi D/o Jogmohon ‘Aged about 32 yrs, Assistant Teacher 4. Snit. Silmmti Tirkey w/o Tejkumar Aged about 3b yrs. Assistant Teacher All are working at & Address are: - Dibya Bandana Girls Middle School Jokbahala Distt. Jashpur [co] o Versus 1. State of Chhattisgwh, Throtgh the Sewetary, Department of School Education, Mantralayh D.K.5. Bhawan Raipw [C.6.] . @ 15 _2. The Direc‘l'or, Directorates of Public Instruction, Pension Bada Raipur [c.G] 3. The Districf Educciion Officer Public Insiruc‘l'ions Jashpur, [c.eJ 4. The Chdirmon / Manager bibya smdam 6M: Middle School Jokbd'ialc, Chrisi'ian Peoples Commiffee Jokbd'iala, Dim. Jashpur' [C.G.] \ Single Bench: Hon’hle Mr. Justice 5aiisil K. Agnilioh‘i. Present Mr. Neelkant Molviya, Advocafe for me pefifioners. Mr. V.V.5. Moorihy, Depuiy Advocate General wifh Mrs. Anju Ahqia, Depuiy 60vernment Advocate for fhe Sink/respondents. oizoen . (Pasadous'h dayofmnh, 2007) Th: following order- of the am is passed by Salish x. Agnllmrl; J. 1. In ihis bdtch of wri? peritions, all the petitioners we teachers Working in Government aided schools. Thequestion of law involved herein asto whether the teochers working in Government aided schools we entitled to the benefit of recommendations of the Fifth Pay Commission under the provisions of the Madhya Praded'l Ashaskiya 5ikshan Sonstha " (AdhyQakon Tatha Anya Karmchoriyon Ke Vetmo Kn Sandoya) Adhiniyml, 197s (henceform 'lhe Adhlnlyam, 1973') and mantles made mammal read will. me Madhya Pradesh Revision of Pay miles, 1998 (henceforih who Pay Ruled, 1998 '). 16 The ideni'ical quesfion of law was considered by 1his Cour? in batch of maH‘ers i.e. 5min A. Lall vs. Stat: of Chha‘l'fisgwh md oiher connecfed ma‘H’ers (WP. No. 41m of 2005) and by judgment aid order dated 6.2.2007, this Court held fha+ fhe pe+i+ioners who are working In 1w% ‘ Govemmem aided privafe schools we enfiflcd To the revised pay-sodas wiih effect from 1-1-1996 as prescribed under 1he Pay Ruies, 1998. This Court furfher for 1he purpwe of paymenf of orrea's hod grmfed certain ‘ direction. Admittedly md jointly, it is submitted by the parties that this batch of matters we squwely covered by the judgment and order dated 6.2.2007 passed by this Court in the case of 5mt. A. Lall vs. State of Chhottisgarh and other connected matters (Supra). As a result, for the reasons stated in the judgment and order dated 6.2.2007 passed in W.P. No. 4103 of 2005 (Smt. A. Loll vs. State of Chhattisgarh and other connected matters) (Supra). These writ petitions a . are allowed in the some terms and conditions. A copy of this order be placed an the record of the connected writ petitions. Sd/- Satish K. Agnihotri Judge Subhash