IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Civil Review No.234 of 2008 1. Smt.Sunaina Sinha wife of Sri Harinath Sinha. 2. Harinath Sinha @ Singh son of late Ganga Prasad Singh Both resident of Mohalla Gobarshahi, Police Station-Sadar in the town and District of Muzaffarpur.- Defendant-Judgment Debtor- Opposite parties- Petitioners. Versus 1. Jaleshwar Prasad Singh son of late Jayanti Prasad Singh @ Jayanti Pd. Singh. 2. Smt. Sunaina Devi wife of Sri Jaleshwar Prasad Singh. 3. Shashi @ Sashi Bhushan Singh son of Sri Jaleshwar Prasad Singh. 4. Prem Kumar Singh son of Sri Jaleshwar Prasad Singh All residents of Village Rampur Bakra, P.S. Lalganj, Distt. Vaishali, at present Mohalla Gobarsahi, P.S. Sadar, District-Muzaffarpur. -- Plaintiffs-Decree Holder-Petitioners- Opposite parties. ----------- 07. 11.02.2009 Heard Mr.S.K.Majumdar, Senior Advocate with Mr. A.B.Ojha, Advocate on behalf of the petitioners. This petition has been filed for review of order dated 09.09.2004 by which a Bench of this court allowed Civil Revision No.1733 of 2002 setting aside the order of the learned Subordinate Judge, V, Muzaffarpur dated 03.10.2002 by which he recalled his earlier order dated 12.09.2002 passed in Execution Case No.01 of 2002. From the said order, especially the penultimate paragraph of the said order, it appears that the Hon’ble Judge has considered the matter in detail and has passed a reasoned order. Furthermore, there appears to be neither error apparent on the face of record, nor there is any fresh material to take a different view. Accordingly, this civil review petition is dismissed. An interlocutory application for condoning the delay of about four years has been filed stating that the order under review was passed on 09.09.2004, but this civil review petition was filed on - 2 - 30.06.2008, although according to the stamp report, limitation had expired on 11.10.2004. Since, this court has not found any merit in the civil review petition itself, there is no occasion for going into the limitation matter. Sunil (S. N. Hussain, J.)