KXMSEa' 0^1^^- IN THE HIGH COURT OF GHHATnSGARH AT BILASPUR WRITAPPEALNO. ^ OF 2008 APPELLANT Versus Respondehts ^-(Stot^g^.-,^ TZ,.7S;^^7X ' < Penr'o^w-c-) ^f/ sP^jV '1/' . ,°^w./ €S/ •y ;/y^ w ••litl'l' ^^ ^^ !^S ^^^ ^-•^" 1. 5. Pt. Ravishankar ShuKla University, Raipxir (C.G.) Through the Registrar, Raipur (C.G.) State of Chhattisgarh Thrpugh the Secretary, Ministiy ofSchool Education, Goyt. of Chhattisgarh, Mantralaya, Raipur State of Chhattisgarh Thrpugh the Secretary, Departmentof Higher Education, D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipur-fC.G.) Director, State Council for Education, Govt. of Chhattisgarh, Mantralaya, Raipur-(C.G,) National Education for Teacher Education-A statutory body of Government of India, Western Region Committee-through its Regional Director, Manas Bhayan, Shyarrila Hills Bhdpal ^M.P.) Chhattisgarh Professional Exammation Board - Through ifs Chairman, : Ghfaattisgarli Professional Exarninatioh Board, G/168, ' Tagore Nagar, Rarpur • (C;G.).'':,'. . ; -: •:•••,; .11 ] ilij(ii"'r ^6. 7. 8. ^- -10. 12. Soni Rakhi Bek, Aged about 23 years, D/o ShriAlaban Bek, R/o Vill-Lohafi, Lichibagan, P.0.- Namkum, Distt. Ranchi (Jharkhand) Sudhir Kumar^Yadav, Aged about 24 years, S/o Shri Rajendra PrasadYadav, R/o V.P.O.- Mandhan, The-Behror, Distt- Alwar (Rajasthan). Salim Mohammad, Aged about 23 years, S/o Shri Bhdnwaru Khan, R/o P.0. - Badayalt, Viya- Jasnagar, The-Bhedta City, Distt.-Nagai.u- (Rajasthan). Haren.dra, Aged about 24 years, S/o Shri Dhannaram Jat, R/o Kaletada, Post-Jhintiya, Via- Riyabadt, The-Bhedta City, Distt. Nagaur (Rajasthan) Pradeep Tete, Aged about 28 years, S/o Shri Lorentus Tete, R/o. Vill-Bharda Tetartoli, Post- Bharda, Thana-Palkot, Distt. - Gumla (Jharkhand) Budharam Lega,Aged about 22 ^ years, S/o Shri Sitaram, R/o Vill- Ucharda; The-Bhedta City, Distt- Nagur(Rajasthan) Annaram, Aged about 23 years, | &/o Shri Daui-am, R/o Main , I: Post-Manaj, The-Bilada, Distt- : Jodhpur(Rajasthan) !f '^rlT1E?'TT?!;l':T^S3:'"^Ga^''~'^ 'Brvra:BWJ.^.S' [,^s lll; IIB Kl!; ; (ire^sBfey) jndrep-nsTa 'nJB§?a . -er/\ 'snSaQ-^sod-A o/H '•BuuaA fdies ;nuB^[ ULIS °/S 's.,resyt^ sg l^noqB paSy '^ttusA Ba L[SBIrea OS^ (uB-q^sBfey) :jB3iig-^STa 'q.re§ireiuqs:5[Bq-BTA 'qsBj8g-i[iTYY o/s 'SJBS^ ^g ^rtpqe pagy '^iaqona: jetmTa ri.oq^ •6l (uBq^s^feg) .rsui-reg -^sip 'jBS^BMB^-^sod -A 0/H 'urey ^jop uqs 'o/S 'sjesX gg ^noq^ pagy 'AreqpnoT.tO urey BpaQ •8T (uBqisBfeg) -tnB§B^- '^sia '^AT(05i-'eiA 'T-wg oogBS-^sod A o/y '{B^I, JBMirGqg uqgo/s 'sjeaA gg ^noqB pagy 'JBiurv^ ireumg •/,T:^. (ureq^sBfeg) jndqpQp-^sia 'AipjedBd 'TjBg-uoq •o/s '^oiqBQ urey ^I^N IJLtS °/S 'sjBsX Tg ^noqa p3§v 4011.1^0 5[oqsv •^ (ueq^s^feg) nunqfunqp nsiQ 'jB5iHrej,-WA '^spiea •O'd'A 0/a 'TBMTuag UJBH jBqss^ uiis o/s 's-res^gg ^noqa ps§V 'l^Auuag qgutg dss^BQ •GT' (pCTBipi.reqf) A^IQ ^ss^S oJB^og',0, ix-Jo;o3g 'SST -n£) •o/~& 'vfSu.ls pBSBjd ^^TBttLre^ uqg o/s''8JB8/' oe WoqB ^^ pagy '5loi[svx[§UTSJBuin^ qpoqy •frl (rreq^s'Bfey) jriB&BN '•^10 ^psqa '^Jq^N ^ ? qS "o/H 'qSmg JBAireqg uvjs o/g 'sjea^ ^gli'ioqB pa8v 'qSuis LreuixBq -gT:' ^s^. l^^l '^^1 !WI ^-'21. Jagdish Prasad, Aged about 20 years, S/o Shri Bhikharam,. R/ p V. Post-Agurita, The-Didweana, Distt-Nagayr (Rajasthan) /22. Kishor Singh, Aged about 31 years, S/o Shri Sahwaldaii, R/o. Vill-Jalivadakhurd, PQst-Nanah, Vio-Pipar, Distt-Jodhpur (Rajasthan) /23. Pramod Alaria, Aged about 21 years, i S/a SUri Hemraj, R/o. V.P.Q.-Samaspur, f Distt- Jhunjlrt.inu (Rajasthan) ; ^^4. Maryeet, Aged about 20 years, S/o Shn Dharamchand, R/o V.P.Q.-Rajwara, The-Miindawa, Distt-Alwar (Rajasthan) 25. Yogendra yaday, Aged about 22 years, S/o Shtt Ram Singh, R/o. V.P.O.-Khatankhera,THe-Behror, Distt-Alwar (Rajasthan) 26. Ashok Kumar Meghwal, Aged about 22 years, S/p §hriHukma Ram, R/o. Dhadhasani, PQst- GantKiya, The-Merta City. Distt- Nagaur (Retjasthan) ^27. Sharwan Kumar Goyal, Aged abput 30 years, S/o Shri Babu Lal Goyal, R/o Napasar, The. SE Distt-Bikaiier (Rajasthan) ^28. Om ^Prakash Pal, Aged about 31 years, S/o' Shri Dudhnath Pal, 'R/o M.N.224, AGC ^Sesh Colony, Wl iiiii:i: .i.iU.t. ';!'iTI:'i; ;:s;i'«^l'' .i-^ssf I- ^6. Post-Jamul, Distt-Durg (Ghhattisgarh) ^29. Reema Kumari, Aged about 22 years, W/o Shri Rajesh Kumar Patel, R/Q Vill-tetariya, Post- Laheri, P.S.-K'OGhas; Distt-Rohtas (Bihar) . Suresh Chand, Aged about 24 years, S/o Shri Madandas Vaishnav, R/o. Main Post-Ladwa, Via-Ja.snagar, The-Bhedta City, Distt-Nagaur (Rajasthan) /31. - Rajnprakash, Aged about 22 years, S/o Shrt Ramkaran Jat, R/o Main Post-Falki, The-Bhedta City, Distt-Nagaur (Rajasthan) ^2. Rajkumar Sahu, Aged about 24 years, S/o.Shri Jayanta Salru, R/o At-Dholbandh, PO-Bisipali, Via-Jamala, Distt-Bargarh (Rajasthan) /83. Charu Charan Biswal, Aged about 34 years, S/o Shri Sagara Biswal, R/o At-Allpur, P.0.- Pathanta, Via-Bijepur (Orissa) J34. Dliaramveer Meel, Aged about 22 years, S/o Shri Padam Singh, R/o Gram Post-Dhandhan, The- Fatehpur, Distt-Sikar (Rajasthan) / 35. Poona Ram, Aged about 28 years,| S/o^SHi-i Puraram, R/o V.P.G).-: Khakharki; The-Bhedta City,i Distt-Nagaur (Raj.asthan) ' ; -li^ilH p^lai ,,ll .••! •<:lf );.(;..,( ^^ rf/M^A^ <s' '.ai .:y. •••'. yiT' ^ 36. 37. ,88, 39. ^40. ^ ^42. 43. / Amit Kumar Yadav, Aged aboyt 23 years, S/o Shri Puraram,R/o V.P.O.-Khakharki, The-Bhedta City, Distt-Nagaur (Rajasthan) Tejaram, Aged about 23 years, S/o Shri K^heya Lal, R/o. P.0.- Pipar City, Distt-Jodhpur (Rajasthan) Dhairendra Kumar Padhan, Aged about 36 years, S/o Shri Shankar Prasad PadKan, R/ o P.Q. - SharadhaF>ali, Via-Gaisilat, Distt-Bargarh (Orissa) Bira Swain, Aged about 31 years, S/o Shri Jageswar Swain, R/o Bariha Pali, Distt-Bargarh (Qrissa) Saudakar Bank, Aged aboyt 32 years, S/o Bhagadan Barik, R/o P.O.-Palsapali, Via-Jamla, Distt- Bargarh (Orissa) Subash Gadatia, Aged about 25 years, S/o Shri Baidehi Gadatia, R/o P.O.-Palsapali Via-Jamla, Distt-Bargarh (Orissa) PrafLilla Kumai- Mallick, Aged about 41 years, S/o shri Judhistir Mallick, R/o. P.O.-K- Hrkoad, Distt-Nayapada (Orissa) Krishna Chandra Sahu, Aged about 30 years, S/p Shri Bhajan Sahu, R/6 P.O.-Budala, Agatpur, Distt-Balangir (Onssa) ; i 34? ^) Aparna Patra, Aged about 33 years, D/o Shri Brajmohan Patra, R/o. At-Govind Tola, P.0.- Dhanupali, Distt-Sambalpur (Orissa) ^•5. Ashok Kumar Barupal, Aged about 22 years, S/o Shri Ramniwas Barupal, R/o V.P.O.- Dehari, The-Jayal, Dist-Nagaur (Rajasthan) ^46. ehandra Ram, Aged about 34 years, S/o Shri changa Ram,R/o V.P. O.-Galoki, Via-Kuchera, Dist- Nagaur (Rajasthan) ^•4'7. Gotam Lal Dayma, Aged about 31 years, S/o shri Thavra Dayma, R/o. Kajaliya, P.S.-Anandpuri, Distt-Baswari (Rajasthan) ^48. Govind Barik, Aged about 27 years, S/o shri Bharda Barik, R/o Negimunda, Via-Sohela, Distt-Bargarh (Orissa) ^.49. Gutha Ram, Aged about 29 years, S/o Shri Basti Ram R/o. V.P.O.- Diyakalla,. Via-Roll, The-Jayal, Distt-Nagaur (Rajasthan) /60. Jaiveer, Aged about 24 years, S/o Shri Gugan Ram, R/o ViU- Hansasar Baragaon, Distt- Jhunjhuni (Rajasthan) /"51. Jalli Sahu, Aged about 24 years, S/o Shri Purushottaffi Sahu, R/o At. P.O.-Uparbanhal, Distt- Barpangir (Rajasthan) .0 ^ - li ^3. /^4. ^S5. /56. ^57. /59, Jifu ^Bam, Aged about 27 years, S/o SUri Ridhkaran, R/o V.P.O.- Dehari, The-Jayal, Distt-Nagaur (Rajasthan) Kainal Kumar, Aged about 30 years, S^o Shri Chhabila Ram, R/o V.P.O.-Jogiwada, The- Bhodra, Distt-Hanumangarh Manju Goswami, Aged about 22 years, D/.p Shri Shravan Puri Goswami, R/o V.P.O.-Padukala, Bistt-Nagaur (Rajasthan) Pradeep Kumar Sahu, Aged about 29 years, S/o Shri Amrutlal Sahu, R/o KotabanHal, Yia-R.B.S.Badampur, Distt- Bargarh (Orissa) Puma. Ram Inaniya, Aged about 24 years, S/o Madanlal, R/Q Ardas Nagar, Merta Rbad, Distt- Nagaur (Rajasthan) Raju Devi, Aged about 23 years, D/o Shri Diyaram Jat, R/d Civil Line Near Post Office Merta City, Distt-Nagaur (Rajasthan) ' Ram Swarup, Aged aobitt 35 years, S/o Shri Badri prasad, R/o V.P.O.-Chudi Ajitgarh, Distt- Jhurijunu (Rajasthan) Ftinku Suri, Aged about 30 years, D/o Shri SidhewshwaF Sinha, R/6 Qr.No.2315, Sector-I^ 'D', Bokaro Steel City (.Jharkhand) •^ !:F M Niji*i' >0. Sitaram Kala, Aged about 21 years, S/p Shri Shimbhu Ram, R/o V.P.Q.-Sandila, The-Jayal, Distt-Nagaur (Rajasthan) ^ffl. Siyaram Jakhar, Aged about 23 years, S/o SJari Bhanuwara Ram Jakhar, R/o V.P.O.-Kheduli, The- Merta City, Distt-Nagaur (Rajasthan) >/62. Suriil Kymar, Aged abput 23 years, S/o Shri Bajarary Lal, R/o Shital, Via-Baragaon, Distt- Jhunjhunu (Rajasthan) ^.63. Surendra, Aged about 24 years, S/o Shri Rarn Jeevan, R/o V.P.O.-Ratanga, The-Jayal, Distt- Nagaur (Rajasthan) ^4. Snshma Tandi, Aged about 26 years, D/o Shri Taprieshwar Tandi, R/o Kuntapli, P.0.- Purena, Vill-Padampur, Distt- Bargarh (Orissa) ^. 65. Upendra Kumar, Aged about 29 years, S/o Shri Ramprasad Yadav, R/o Vill-Purhe, P.0.- Karvi, Manjhion, distt-Gharwa (Rajasfhan) Rungta College of Science and Technplogy-Through its authorized officer Gurprit Singh Dhilton, S/o Lafe Shri Gyan Singh DUillon, Aged about ; 33 years, Lecturer, Rungta Col!ege|of Science A and TecKnology^ 1.11 ft ~^6S. ^ G.E.Road, Ganjpara, Diirg (C.G.), R/o C/o Dhillon Nursing Home, Station Road, Durg (C.G.) yW. Bishwanath Pradhan, S/o Shri Sundanand Pradhan, Aged about 26 years, R/p Brarasan Post Talpali, Via-R.B.S. Rajboda - Sambal, District Bargarh(Qrissa) Pnncipal, Chhattisgarh Kalyan Samiti Aheri, District Durg (C.G.) Dhiraj Mohan, S/o Shri Krishna Mohan Prasad, Agfed about 24 years, R/o Mohalla Abadhganj, Mission School Road, Post Daltanganj, Distnct Palamu, (Jharkhand) ^70. Radhe Shyam Mandal, S/o Shri VasudeQ Mahto, Aged about 30 years, R/o Via 85 Post Sudna, Near Shambhy Gate Gayatri Mandir Road, Sudna, Districf Daltahganj, Palamu (Jharkhand) •^/'1\. Principal, Mahavir Jain Arts and Gommerce College, Distriet Durg (C.G.) . • , ^ T2, Lalu Ram Patel, S/o Shri NangaJL Patel, Aged about 28 years, R/ 6 Post Amarpur, Tahsil - Sarad, District Udaypur (Rajasthan) ^73. Prahlad Ram S/o Shri Sunda • Ram, Aged about 23 years, R/o Post Bahikhafu, Tahsil-Jayal,! Dtstrict Nagaur (Rajasthan). , ^ III t 1 '^r//75. ^" 76. Tanmaya Rana, S/o Shri Ganesh Ram Rana, Aged about 21 years, R/o Village 85 Post Kurumpuri, Nuwapada, District Nuwapada (Qrissa) Principal, Vignana College of Education, Daldal Siyni Marg, Mova, Raipur, District Raipur .(e.G.)::..:,.,,;. •:..••, ;: . Sashmita; Sahu, D/o Shri RIahesh^ Ram Sahu, Aged about 20 years, R/o Village 85 Post Kun-impuri, Nuwapada, District Nuwapada (Orissa) Principal, Mahant Laxmiriarayan Das Cbllege, Gandhi Chowk, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.) WRIT APPEAL UWDER SECTION 2(11 OF THE CHHATTISGARH mOH COURT (APPEAI, TO DIVISION BENCHt.AGT.2006. -T^,77; -y'' ^? ^'0 .f-^- Pt. Ravishankar Shukla' University, Respondents No.6 to 67,69,70,72,73,74 and 76 petitioners. State of Chhattisgarh and 76 others. Apoeai underSectjpn 2 dlofthe Chhattisgarh Hiqh Court Shri Vinay Pandey, counsel for the appetlant. Shri Kishore Bhaduri, Additional Advocate General for the State/ respondents No.1 to 3. Shri Pankaj Agrawal, counsel for respondent No.5. Shri Adii Minhaz, counsel for respondent No.66. Shri C.R. Sahu, counsel for respondent No.68. The foliowing order of the Court >ev Gupta, C.J. Shri Adil Minhaz, learned counsel for respondent No.66 Rungta College of Science and Technology, submits that as the students have already appeared in the examination on the strength of the interim order passed by the Apex Court and their results also have been declared by the University, the present writ appea! has become infructuous. 2) The writ appeal, therefore, is dismissed as infructuous. Sd/- Chief Justice SdV- SunU Kumar Sinha Judge