•ie.if'i ^ yfc ^a.'".- CM<OT IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR WRIT PETITION fS 1NO. -^\^'-^Z2Q06 PETITIQNER ^ ,.^'^ ^^ ' ^^ •'V& vi^ ^^: •~>-''"^?'>:\p'" S'VV .£%^' .^^•' RESPONDENTS 5-'v Suresh Kumar Pathak son of Late Shri M.L.Pathak, s^ ~ f-^- aged about ?o years, R/o SE 517 CSEB Colony, Korba (C.G.) VERSUS 1. State of C.G.- Through- The Secretary Department of Tribal Welfare, Mantralaya ^).K.S. Bhawan Raipur (C.G.) 2. Commissioner, Tribal Welfare Department, Ravi Shankar University Campus, Raipur (C.G.) 3. Asst Commissioner, Tribal Welfare Department Collectorate Campus, Korba (C.G) 4. Principal Government High School, Andhri Kachar, Korba (C.G.) WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE COMSTITUTION OF INDIA / XI-HC-78 ?5?^(Pn?pr, OTn^'16, |a|<1Wy lTTtT^TTsRlTt5B'y*i''y'^rTe"'";l""/"ip3" 200 l^ 3n^T^iTR^i+ (iwsn^T^iiNi L.' Bablu -^.^ \<-f ¥'- 3f1^T (Rra; (y)(^q^t)) WiTWBfersn^r 8.1.2007 Mr. Ajay Shrivastav^, Shri A.V. Shreedhar and Shri H.5. Ahluwalia, Adwcates for -tti^ petitioners. Mrs. Anju Ahuja, Djeputy Sovemment Advocate for the s. With the consent oi matt'er is heard finally ond d Order dictated m op^n Court in W.P. (s) No. 7426 of 2006, passed separately. A copy of 1+i is order writ petitions. 'nrafn'fl-i ^ii<nTffte3'<Rit<i< ^siRpTsn^TT lectmed counsel for the parties, the be ptaced on record in other connected Sd/. SW5^» P.T.O. r ¥- HI6H COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR SIN6LE BENCH : HON'BLE MR SATISH K. A6NIHOTRI. J. WRTT PFTmON (5.1 N0. 7426 OF 20Q6 Petitioner versus binbandhu Bharti The Sta+e of Chhatt'isgarh and wiother WRTT pETmoN es.i NO. 7427 OF 2005 oner : Ramnaroyan Pradhan State of Chhattisgarh and others WRFT pErmoN cs.i NO. 7423 OF 2006 versus R Smt. Mnnju Hiujur State of Chhatt-isgarh cmd others WRTT PETmON tS.) N0. 7429 OF 2006 versus Stnte of Chhatt-isgarh and other; WRIT PFm-tON (S.) N0.7430 OT 2006 versus ReSBondents Shivnand Rathore State of Chhattisqarh and otfier's WRFT PETTHON (S.'S N0.7431 OF 2006 versus Ram Chondra Namdeo State of Oihattisgarh and others t.: •<:-• WRTT PETTTION (S.'i N0.7432 OF 2006 versus Smt. Sharada Sahu State of Oihattisgarh wid other; wprr pErmoN (s.) N0.7433 OF 2006 Petitioner versus State of Chhattisyirh ond o-rtiers WRFT PETmON (5.) N0.7434 OF 20GS Petitiones' : Smt. Mary ©raceMinj versus State of Chhatt-isgarh and others Resoondents WRTT PETmON t5A N0.743S OF 2006 inon verajs Smt. Purnima Pandey State of Chhattisgar+i and o-Aers WRrr PETmON (S.) N0.7436 OF 2006 Petitjoner ; Likhonla! Jaiswa! versus State of Chhati'isgarh and others WRTT PETTTEON (S.) N0.7437 OF Petitioner : Hamarayon Patel versus 5+ate of Chhattisgarh and WRTT PETmON (S.) N0.7438 OF 2006 Respondents yersus Sta-te of Chhattisgar+i and others WRFT PETmON {SAN0.74390F 2006 Petitioner •3F. versus &dra Kumar Tiwari State of Oihattisgarh cmd others WRFT PFTmON fSANO,7440^)F 2006 Petitioner versus Respondents t&shri Kishore Dubey S'hate of Chhattisgarh cnd otiiers WRFT PFTTTrON (S.) N0.7441 _OF 2006 Petitjoner verais Laxmon Prosad Rathore State of Gihattisgarh and others WRIT pFrmoNCs.) N0.7442 OF 2006 Snnt. Gesta Sharma ve.-sus State of Chhattisgarh PETTnON (5.) N0.7443 OF Petitioner : Chemdra Kumar Shar-ma wrsys State of Chhatt'isgarh and others WRTT PETmON (5.1 N0.7444 ^2006 Petitioner ; Soaijeev Kumar Sharma wrsus State of Chhattisgarii dnd otiiers WRrr PETITION cs.) N0.7445 QF^ Phiratrom Nishad yersus (:.' WRFT PETITION (5.) N0.7446^^2006 Petitioner Jaggannatti Himdhar versus WRIT PETmON (S.} N0.7447 OF 2 Petitioner wrsus SureA Kumar Pathak State of Chhattisgarh and others WRTT PETITrON (5.5 N0.7448 OF 2006 Petitioner verajss Chandrashekhar Sharma Statie of Chhatt-isqorh and others WRIT PETmON (S.1NQ. 7449 _QF 2006 Petitioner versus 5tate of Chhattisgarh and others wprr pFrmoN is.) N0.7450 OF 2006 Smt. Rama foirmkar (Maiden name-Ku. Rama Mcndal) yersus State of Chhatt-isgarh ond others wprr PETTTION rs.i N0.7451 OF200& versis Rescondents 5.K. Rathore State of Chhattisgarh and o'tfiers WRTT PFTmON (S.) t40.74S2_W2Q^ Petitioner yerais •s Uttam Kumar TiwarE State of ChhotS-iqarh ond others WRIt PETmON (5.) N0.7453 OF 2006 Petitioner wrsus JTianak Ram Patei State of Chhattisgarh and others WRIT PETmON (5.1 N0.7454 QF 2006 Petjtioner versus ^SBondents Vijay Kumar Dwivedi State of ChhatS-isgarh and others wprr pFnnoN rs) N0.7455 OF 2006 Petitioner versus State of Chhattisgurh and others WRIT PFHTION (5.} N0.7456_0^2006 ,'««e; Petitioner Pandiram Sdiu versus of Oihati-isgarh and WRIT PFTTTION (S.) N0.7457 OF 2006 Petitioner Smt. Usha Oiatur versus •s WRTT PETTTrQN (5.1 y0^7458^)F_2006 Petitioner versus Puroshattam famar Kaushik State of Oihattisgarh cnd others 6 WRTT PETmON (6.) N0.7459 OF 2006 yersus P.N. Sharma State of Chhatt'isgurh ond others WRTT PETTnON (S.) N0.7460 OF 2006 Petitioner" versus Sitansm Kavar State of Chhattisgarh and others WRFT PETmON (S.l N0.7461 OF 2006 Petitioner versus Akhilesh Kumar Dubey State of Chhattisgarh ond oltiers WRFT PFTtTION (S.'i N0.7462 OF 2006 Respondents versus Balram Prasad Nayak State of Qihattisgarh ond o1+iers WRTT PETmON fS.I NO. 7463 OF 2006 ^ Petitioner Resoondents versus Umesh Praa>d 5ahu State of Chhattisgarh ond others WRFT PETmON (5.) N0.7464 OF 2006 Petitioner versus Osandra SheWiar Sarfiu State of Qihattisgarh ond others WRrr pmnoN (s.) N0.7455 OF 2006 Petitioner versus Smt. Rekha Bhatt State of Chhatt'isgarh and others lllWftS9W("llll»ll|iiii|i WRTT PETmON (5.) N0.7466 OF 2006 Petitioner versus Puron Chand Patei State of Chhati-isgarh and others WRFT PETTTEON CS.) N0.7467 OF 2006 r'- Petitioner Resoondents versus Smt. Ani State of Qihattisgarh and others WRH- PETTTrON (S.) NO. 7468 <y 2006 Petitioner versus Ram Hari Sharaff State of Chhatt-isgarh and others ySST PFTTTtON CS.) N0.7471 OF 2006 Petitioner vsrsus (Canhaiya Lal Yadav State of Chhattisgarh ond others y' Mr. Ajay Shrivastava, Shri A.V. Shreedhar and Shri H.5. Ahluwalia, Advocates for the petitioners. ttrs. Anju Ahuja, t)eputy ©ovemmenl' Advocnte for •the Ot&ER (passsd on 8n Dcy of Jcnuary, 2007} 1. Learned counsel cppearing for the petitioners as welt as for the State/respondents jointly submit -riiat the facts and question of iaw invoived in the present batch of writ % petitions are squarely covered by the decision of this Court in the case of yashwanf Kwnaf Bharwdwaj vs. Mwticipa! Corporafion, Owy easd eimrherr. 2. The petitioners in W.P. (s) No. 7440 of 2006, 7456 of 2006 and 7465 of 2006 hwe acquired M.Ed cert-ificates after In subsequent cases, i.e., Writ Petition (5.) No.4130 of 200' {,Gopesh Kumev Vermais. The State Savt. of Chhaftisgarh and a/wHm^ and other connected matters, decided by this Court on 15-12-2006, pursuant to the memo dated 28-1-1995, issued by the Secreta"y, Board of Secondary Education, BhopaS and the prospectus of Diploma in Education Examination, it was clarified that the nomenclature of the Basic Training Institute, i.e., B.T.I. has been changed and renaraed as Diploma in Education, i.e., D.Ed. Accordingly, the D.Ed. Certificate hoiders are a!so covered by the decision in Writ Pstition (5.) No.4130 of 2005 (jffope^f Kiimar yet'tiwvs. The State Govt. of Chhattisgarh andanothei1, (Supra). 4. For the aforementioned reasons, the writ petitions are disposed of in terms of the decision of this Court in the matter of Yashwanf Kumar Bharacfwaj (Supra), subject to verification of the fact as to whether the petitioners have acquired B.Ed./M.Ed./B.TJ./D.Ed. Cert-ificates at their own '! Bablu 9 expenas as per the circutars dated 24-12-1998 and 1-3-1999 end further whether they have been paid two advance increments or not. No order as to costs. 5. A copy of •riiis order be placed on -the record of connected writ petitions. Sd/- SatishKAgoibom Judge 1 20060:I)MPJR-C696 ¥-