[,ai,U.AtB.S..-I±.i i—miBiT ie-:;KI'S & ie—78 -""..^ .^..^ri^ y {••' \ sn^r ^t R.I TT^iT 3FfT^T5tt^l<^ 7's^ •^ww-ii, •a-^w'i's,, [^ftwy, C^^-No- ":5-^t)05' tnwn- wrra? ......................^................................^ 200 an^TT TR9B (ipf^gtT) TOIIW ^if®tsii^r <j:i-3^ Kllhrami Somdu. age 49. S/o Sunaa Muriya. Vo viliaiis Janqa! para, Chiokai, P.5.- |ngpal, Oistt. &Gr.tewada (0$). Tl iCr'iminai Aooeol ijnd. f.iui Divjsion B® Hon'bie Shri L-C. *i»nws Sttf! t ,•-. Aharma. »i. 20-2-200s Voswani. iSovt. Advocate for th Orci iudqment dictoted a vi ff ~ ^J: This aoDeal is directed o'rder of sentence dated 31- Scheduled Castes A Schaduled AdditionGi Sassions. Ju< <*i^d41-t ^Tra^ff '^\'f^t3l- <F>|^.|< ^sTRiHsn^r -Versus- tate of ChhattisQarh. Throuah the tatwn Moiise Utticer, Koiice otstion inqosi, Distt. Dantewada (CS'i. •:r' Section 374(2) of the Cr.P.C.) ir-i Anant Bajpi^i." counsel for the appelicrit & Shci Q.d: ' Stats. n Qais. aqainst the ludqment of coriyiction ar.-d 110-2001 passed by the Speciai Judge, IV- ITfibes (Pi'evention of •Atr'ocities) Act and Bastar, in sessio'-is trial ^0.312/2001 sni^yi h-n* 'aSTT 3TK?T ^HTCh 'sssi ^w\^, •s-^w'w, R^i'yy •qroar **<icb ----•-•--^••--•--•-----^ 200 anSsr 'VSISR cipf^ga) '^giwofro sii^n whereby and whereunder- le ho!dmg the accused/Gppaiion^ 1<i». Sectlon 302 of the Inditirt.^ committina the mur'der of "AAI impfisonment for .'ife & to pav of fins to fu"Ther underqo ft.IJ 2) Ccse of the prose^rV 'i-fW 5.30 o.m. .M.adkatr.i Dosru was < naniely. -junqi can'e and infor" deceosedl hod aoi"e to Ji accused/aoDaiiant fKuhr'QW So the daughter of Somdu, aged dowr.. Accused oicked uo a dececsed twics. Hearina th (Ex.P/li was mvan bv &as"u which Fii'st Informsrt-ion fe registerinq the cr'ime under 5 Officer left for the scene of o \:. the Panchas, he oreDit''ed inau' in Poiice custodv accussd Sor' <*i<ilfi^-t ''mai tf Isst <fat$i< •^siRn 311^1 ir'ned Addit'ono! Sessions Judoe after quilty for co'nn'.ission of otfence under Penal Code ^fof shor'f "itie IPC'} for Ikomi Sannu sentenced hins to ui"de"qo pi fine of Rs.1,000/-, in defoiuit of payment ; for ons yea'". in b"ief. is that ort 2-5-2001. at about lit his "esidence at that time his dauahter ed tiiat brothar Madkami Scnnu (since knaai Para where he met with the bdu) and oushed him.as G r'ssuit of which obout cne year.who was in his iap, felt fetbne ond attccked on the. head of the news Dasru went to the scsr.e of (ccurrence and saw thot Sohnu wes ajr'eaa'v dead. AAerq intimation Poiice Statio"! Tongpai, on the basis sf bort (Ex.P/2'i was reqistered. Afte" sction 302 of *he IPC. the Invas-t-igating j:cu""ence. After WVWQ not'ce (Ex-P/4) to |st (Ex.P/B') on the bodv of Sonnu- Whiis jdu qave men'sorandun-. (Ex.P/65 "egardine ^sy's, .^•''^'^ 3^T "i<i<ii0<i, yTfly<i<o, Ri^iiyy Mwn\ *NI* "g^ 200 si^ff IR»I? (iy(-t«iiysi) 3)1^1 ?iTl^RT ^SU STT^T ^qi°h 'TOIIWHfCT 3D^T <fti*fT?i4hi TnTRff '^^'f^t <F4'^i< ^i'siRm aii^i the pioce where he kept,.t'he s" iri&'norondum the stons was si: cccused/appeilant. Biood stain^ ^ the oiacs cf occurrence und# 'oy the Investigatlrig Officer". '-lealth Centra. ChhindGarh und^ conducted oostwcrtem on the \; deoth wss due to shock. os o r| death is hon-iicidol in notui's. r4^ fone i.e. weaoon of offence. Sased on the ted urider Ex.P/7 <at the irsstonce of the |d soil and Glain soii was a!so seized ft'om IEx.P/8. Site cion fEx.P/Sl was BreDafea he bodv of Sonnu was sent To Coi'RftUnit',.' 3) After comoietten of inv< Court of Judicia! Magisti'cte, F the cass to the Court of 5ess;< Additional Sessions Judgs, So. -rial. 4'i In ordei* to estobiish t! the orcsecution sxamined 6 wi recor'ded'under Section 313 o1 he deniad the motei'ial csoear'i'l He stated that he is innoce?i1 cnms. ' •' • v- kf Ex.P/10 whe-e Dr. P.N. Sandilva (PW-&) body of Sannu ai"d opined that cause of ^suit of hesd injury ^ brain hemorrhoge, prepared postmo?'tem f'eport Sx.P-10/A. iStiqation. chs'rqe sheet wa.s filed in the |irst Ciass, Sukma, who 'm turn con'iiriitted tns Judge. JaGOGJDur. from whefe iearned ttar, received the sawe oh transfer for- |ie charqe cgoinst the accused/appeliant, lil'nessss. StQterp.ent of the accused wcs the Code of Criminal Procedur-e in which lo Gosinst him in the D'-osecution evidsnce. and has been fGJss!v iiTiclicated in the "'%> ^s^Sx^s^'. ^ ''S:<if»?ii^iBr'n^s^n?? ./ 3=5^ '^m^, fs-^wiic, Ri^K-iy Mlt^dl **11«b sn^rw K-u* fisn aii^r *t<i«t> ^f' W^ 200 an^T •<raq> ^ipf^^i) 'reiiwafeT a'li^t 5) Learned Additionai Sesd •esoective oarttes. corivicted ions Judoe o.fter hearino counsei for Itie and sentenced the sccused/aonsHant cs aforewsntioned. 6) We haye heard Sh-i aDoel'antand Shrt &D. Vsswanil 7) At the outset. -Shrt \1 cccused/cppeSbnt, hos not d| /y'iio»eove". &r. P.N. Sandilya (P| bodv of thz dececsed has stia- the r'ight'tampontj region of *emDG-"ai "sQ'on wcsa fractured L'acer'aTed wound on ths occiai' occiDJtal bone WQS frocti m.iu"5es wers snte mor-tem in rt Post'T'ortsm reDor.t is Ex.P/1 corrobor'o.ted bv the eysdence .s that the occused sttacked ths estabHshec thst the death of 3a Anw,t BaJDQs, iearned counsei for the i) As fo.'" as invoivement o quss+ion is concernec, PW-2 tbl^i<*11(flT1 'Riq^ft '^.'f^Sl' <raq'fr$t'( ^ sjfgiT ail^l toOVT. ts fo- the Statt BGjoai. leorned counsel for' the tSDuted the hon'iicidsl dsath of Sannu. -6). who conducted postiriC!"teir> on the ted thot there was a iacerated wound on the deceased. The bcns bensotft the and the size of injury wcs l" x 0.5" x l". tal reqlon. brcin wcteriai wcs comina ou't, the size of iniu.")' wos 4° x I" x 4". The fature a'nd deoth Vitas homicida! jn riQ+ure. abovs medico! avidence js if PW-2 Muchaki AAadda: who has steted deceaseo with ,o stone. Tner'efore, it is nnu was homicidai in naturs. J/. cccused/'GppelianT m ffie cnme in Muchaki Madda is the Derson who hos sf. >»;>K-!l..ia.K>l )e^e—~ ;: 3=5? "'<l-4l<?iA|, yiTTl^'ic, Ri^i'My ^WM **<1* WI, 200 sn^r ?n R-fi'* TTSff3TT^?T,Sti*licfr Iff'- 3IT^?r IR^ (4<<f-j,«l<tf) ^giw ;Hf?3 3)1^1 witnessed the incident and csitt the accused Gttacked the decet 'f.i Janqal Para at abcut 5.00 B;.tn. &asru about th& incident. In 1+ defence hss nct been sbie to the testifionv of this witness. to both the deceassd an3 tl excrninotion he hcs ststed thcf ths accused is his uncis. The;f deceased snd the cccused ther) accused in a false case ths- Ther'efo.-e. on the testimonv o' occused attacked the deceosed this witness is cor'roborated b| (PW-6), who hds ststsd that hi the dscsased and there were ?u, -egwn &. on occipitsi region tyoctur'ed. 9) SSii"! BaJDai. ieor'ned counfceS - ^r . ^ the o?'osecutiQn case itself it deceased oushed ffie sccused. '+lld'l'il'l ^IITCff if.fe'st <R|<SK '^arfin aii^i goricQiiy steted thiit on the fatefui dcy :sed Sannu with a stone o'n his head nea" n the eyeninQ. Thereaftsr. he informed a cross-eKowinotion of this witnass. 'me ;licit cnv circuiTiStance. which discredits AAQr'eover, this witness is closelv feiatsd ie accusefl. In oa.»a-6 of his cross- was his ma.teriisj uncls whereas ;foF'e. for such o c!ose r'elative to th< iss no reason tor him to imolicats the too in a heinous crime like murder. this witness. it is established that +be lAijth o. stone. .-Vsoreovef". thg testin'sor'v of 1' medical evidence cf &!". P.N. Sandilya t conducted Dostmortem o" the bodv of [wo lacersted wounds on riyht tewDOfo! the skui! bone of both the places was feeS for the oooeiia.rt. crqued that from t established that in the first instance i|is a result of which his daushter. aaed XI-HC—78? 'S^ei '<ii<<wq, axn^'is, Riwi^y tiropir **^i* 'V^ 200 3n^?r •q^ C^f^sRW) sn^r yi K.-u^i ^STT 3TT^¥T sti*llGb ?^nw ^ifei sii^i <^i*iW*ilt ^m^f 'if.l^t' <I<i^.i< ^T3lfOT3II^I about one veo.r. fel! down froni aiS of a sudden without any pr^ his lao. that infui'iated the accused cnd por'ation or premeditation he picked up o stone !yir;<j on the spot and att <!' deceased 'm o. heat of Das^toifl estabiishes that the sccuseci a\ cause h'lS cieath. The.Fs'fore. tr-Qyei bevond Section 304 Pa"-^ bcked with that stone on the heesd of the the"e is nothing on recor'd, which 31-tacked l+ie deceased with an in-ention to ifie! offence agciinst the accused does not •S-II of the IPC. 10) On Ine cther hand, J suoDorted the ludgiriant of ths 11) In order to ODDreciats iecrned counsel for the aeoeilc of FIR (Ex.P/2) shows that cn (dececsed) we.v* to Jongcl Pard that titris. Sannu was 'n drunkei of which the dcuahte" of Somd bp, therefore, tnat infur'icted stone 'yinq on the SDot and atta 12) From the cboye fGC+s. i't San'nu wias in drunkei" condition V; Somdu. os a resuit of whlch th6 ihri Voswcni. iearned 'Sovt. Advocate ti'ini Court. "he arqument edyanced bv Shr'i Baiooi. ht. we have oerused the recorci. Perusa. the fotefu! day at sbout 5-30 p.m. Sanr'u where he wet with Somdu fcccused). At ^ condition wid pushed Soirsdu, as a result \i, aqed abcut or.e yea;". felS down from his Somdu. Thss'eafte?', Sorpdu pici-ed up s fcked on the heod of Sonnu. is established that in the first instfance rhvme and reo.son he pushed 5 i?!uu i dauahte" of Somdu, Qoed cbout one vear. 30-HC—78' 3'E^ ^TFTRSq', yrfly'l<o,R|<?il'y^< n sn^[ w (c;.fich '^^ ¥TT^?T st)*11et) »- ^ Hl*1rtl *MI«b•-••---—•-••—•-----"•---^ 200 \. an^yr'qaw (1i?f^?w) 'S^ITWdiTO 3D^[ re!l down trom lis lop. whicn ir anv or'eDQpation or Dr'emeditatit up a stone lying on -frie spot srs(| a r'ssult of which he sustained accused/appellant is squorely <i of the IPC. 13) In the- "esuit, the Gppea iinpossd upon the accused/app set aside; instsad ther'eof he i' the IPC orsd sentenced to undej accused is in detention since i entit'ed for set off of the ab(] imposed upon him. Sd/. . • L.C. Bhadoo Judge <^i*i(?i<Hi tTn?ff '£f,fe^t'<P>R^f< ^; sifilH 311^1 ;furiated hiw and ali of a sudden. without >n, in o heat of passion the eccused picked j'attacked on the hecd or the deceosed,as stdl iniuries. Therefore. tha case of the overed unde?" exceotion 4 to Section 300 oaftlv succeeds. Conviction and sentence aiiant unde'r Section 302 of the IPC are ccnvicted under Section 304 Port-TI of 'oo ft.I. for 7 yecrs. It is stated that the i-5-2001 tiil todoy. Tne occused shc'l be iye detention perlod OQainst the sentence Sd/- T.P. Sharma Judge