iN THE HIGH COURT OF OHHATTISGARH AT BILASFUR. W SENGLE 3mm S.N. Sahu, aged aboi1t 39 years, .a" é9“A f S/o Shn ‘ NR. Sahu, Lecturef rt, PETITIONER 24w Chemistry” Posted at Government (99V H.1gher Secondary School, kgv$k §c§\‘f{“ Sohagpur, District Korba (C.G.) $6” ®$°\\)\ @ «x‘ * $9 <z‘y? ' v E R s U s RESPONDENTS 1. State of Chhattisgarh, Through: The Secretary, Schedule Caste and Schedule Tribe Development Department, D.K.S. Bhawan Raipur (C.G.) 2. The Commissioner, Trfbal Development Department, Raipur District Raipur (C.G.) 3. The Collector, Korba District Korba (C.G.) 4. The Assi'stant Commissioner, /" ' “W ,1 TribdL Development Department. District Korba (C.G.) W 5. The Principal, Government Higher Secondary School, Sohagpur,‘ District Korba (C.G.) w“ WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 227 OF THE QONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR ISSUANCE QF AN APPROPRIATE WRIT IN THE NATURE OF MANDAMUS[CERTIORARI ETC. OR‘ DIRECTIONZORDER IN ' THE LIKE NATURE ETC. xxx Ni XI—HC—78 47 9/2065, WEOOé' re far ‘i'he pe‘ri?imers. ernmen't Advncafe ‘ for The _mu%aaniat 1§,?.29Gé W33, Nbs. 3523/20Q6, 3 3527/26Qé, 3§2S/ZOO6, 352 353332006? 3534l2006: 353 3542/2066, 3543/260é, 3§4 354772696. Shri Rajesh Pmdey, Advam ” $‘nri’ Sumesh rgajuj, respéride'n'fs/Sfdw er: advance co y. ‘ Hédri The Main gr‘ievma raised by The pe‘i’h‘ionerS is cemmon and cammen §ssue 3s §rw§ivéd Eta-these pef§fians, Therefsre, They are being disneszé of by #53 cemmon orde ; 8y These pe?i‘;‘isns! #he pafi iamrs, wha ara war-king as Lecfu-r‘er if} various Higher Seconéary Schc is of ‘r’ne Disfrid Korba sf 5mm of Chha??isgar?;, hcwe ques?§onzc§ '§' a §egaii+y & carrecmess 0f ?heir fransfar order da?a& 7.7.209é ‘ Signa'i'ure of Under Secre‘l’ ‘ Sch‘edukd £asfe 6g Schedulad Tr M The grounds of chaiieng 9e?§1‘i9n”ers, aré “rm? the Sacra? ry er *{he Under- 5ecremry has no jur§sd§cfism ‘to’ puss 5%; $mp‘ugnz transfer arciar, as 1‘hz C3unsei§ing {Annexure P-E) issued under- 'rhe Gavemmem of Chhcm’isgarh,‘ Deveiopmem Deyar‘rmem, Ra§purn ef fhis order, as raised by The 524/280é, 3525/2006, 352é/‘200é, 3530/2606] 3540/2006, V2006, 3545/2006, 3546/2006, 3531/2066, 3541/200é, P.T.O. e § .. v r, XI—HC-78 o V, mm (W) I mwm ' “9% WWW mmm ' WW wW éiwwéw v V Cammih‘ee is empawered 1‘0 issue ‘imnsfar arders‘ unéer The Rwionaiumion Schema dafed a.6.2006, fherefore, the impugned Transfer order issued by respemien? Mei is wi‘rhau? juriséicficn and numw §n fhe eyes Qf iaw. 7312 Sink €10vemmam" has a¥reac5y cieiegai'e& The powers 6f Tmns' erring “ma machers 1'0 c9unsei§ing commi‘m‘ee coas?ifu‘r2u’ a? ‘fhe S‘mfzz iavei Lim‘Eer ?§*§e haTiafia§5za1“isn scheme dated 1.:3‘2OG6 and 1‘he issued ir: ‘Hagr-cm' vioia‘rian of fhe, of ‘irhis mfienaiizafion scheme. Perusa§ cf impugned order Annexur'e P-l whereby $8 pa?§‘rioners have been fransferreci as aisa The mficmiiza‘fion scheme dafed 1.6.29Gé shgws €hm‘ ¥ae pe?§?i9ns are m§scen¢eived, fer “me rewons i'ha’? The impugned cm‘er‘ pnder which ‘fhe pefitioners have been ‘5'mnsferred has been passed an admimsfmfive greunds. This oréer has not? been passed Lieder The mfionaiizafio‘n scheme dated 1.6.2g06 end ‘?he same has been passee' by ‘rhe Gevemmen? in exercise of genemi powers 1'0 transfer HS e:mp%c‘yees. Perusai of mfianaizuiisn scheme dafed LéZGOé shows Tha‘r where en accoum“ a“? Transfers, gar of washers have become irm‘ricr number's 9f S‘mdenfe Le. weere on in one schad numbers of ‘reacher s have became less 1 or. 2 er where impugned transfer arde‘r has been provisians confuimed‘ in Paras 5 & 6 omoTions & re?iremenfs f‘ne numbers 43% in various schao§s baking Tr: a‘he aecaum of abcve men’doned reasms P.T.O. E W , W , W XI—HC—78 HW,W,W 4‘3 . .o~¢ooom.v~..oo‘m..‘. .V mm<m) WW§WW WWW r mwm ~37— ~‘%m%na~né21~ The number‘s of washers have exceeded mere 1%‘san The requirad numbers 6f washex, in a‘ha‘i’ csse :rha canczmed deparfment, as anvisagea‘ in fhé séheme, wiii consJ?i?ufe a ccunse3§ing comfniffee wad ?ha varioas higher sacmdary sch6oi$ or miédie sciwools or primary schcois, fha concerned semm§wee shag! mi'iomiize i’ke mu'rzbérs of feeichers in each schecis ieQking f9 fha numbers Of sfuden s. I“? has been anviéageé ?haf $2 cemmh‘fee is $0 ensure fhaf in no rimary schoai remain iess ?hcm We teachers, 3r: case cf midd§e scho i m? iess than fhrae washers, iw case of high schooi n01“ less fhan bur Teachers and in case ef higher secondary schooi nu? iess i'han six eachers. Ae has beea mem'ieeed ec: iier fémf fhe impugned oreer ms - hem passed under ‘ifhe adminis‘rve pewer‘s 9f fine igeyernmem :m admimssmi'ive gmunds and ?his der has m?h§ng so do wi‘sa she Jr‘a‘s‘ionalizafion scheme da‘hed 1.6 0G6. The Governmenfuis always efepower‘ed "m é‘mnsf‘er i?s em layees and“ fhe infraéuca‘ien 0f ‘ i afiem!iza?ian scheme does ne‘i‘ d’e any bet" fha? she csncemed eparfmenf m” she Sm'l'e éevem en? is no? empewered t9 fransfer * ?s Washers in 'Q’he admimsT‘m'i'ive exigency 9:” 'm The gubiic inieresf. oreover, a bare perusa§ of me pi‘i‘tiens smws trim? é‘r‘hcs no? been enfiened in fhe pe‘?§:*i0ns ism? fhese Wmsfers in c1 parficuiar 'ener w secensary school numbers e“? washers has became iess ‘i‘hen affer ceiiecfmg informmwn f RT.O. m m mxi r r . " § V m y XI—HC-78 3am,m, W . W W 200 WW(W) Waaiiw: WWEww‘ ammm xkl ‘ éqwm ' i’he required number's of %eac’ners 0r numbers G'f 'r“eachers have exceeded kmking fro ‘i’ha‘ numbers 9f s‘mdams. Therefsre, 141a pefi‘rions 9f fhe pzih'ianers are no? mai wuinabie for ‘i'ha reasons *‘i‘hm‘; {1) The crder impugned ms been passed under “fhe geaemi pswers of a‘he Govémmen? “o Transfer ifs empioyees on adminis‘?mi'§ve gmum’ and i? has n42? baen passed under ’fhe saki scheme 3.2. rationa§iz&i?ion scheme dafed 3&2906‘ (2) if} The pafi‘rions if has ne‘i‘ been aueged $51 on accoun'f of These fmnsfers fhe 'princi; i2 enuncia‘red in fhe mfihmiizcxfion scheme has been vi’oEa‘ired Le. m1 accsunf of These frans‘fers f§3e numbers 0'? Teacher's have become less fhan +he required numwrs of fgackers under The ~af§anaiiza"riah scheme or have excaeded is any par?§cu§ur schoai castra’ry fa ‘me m?§0miizc‘?§or3 schema. (3} The areas m5 wpercfiora 0f fhe mfiona§izafien scheme aimed 1A6‘2006 and m” genera? powers 0f ‘s‘mnsfer of Sia‘he gavemmen? are diffe rent Hawever, ifl my sud. ins‘mnce cames ’m ‘r‘ne rim-ice of fhe pe?ifioners, fhen f’sey wiii be a? Eberw "w make a regresenm?ien so she au?1‘1ori‘§y concerned. its View of fh'e shave, 1m pef§fions s‘meé dismissed. Csnsequen1§y, M.{W.)P. far gran? af smy aise skmds dismisses Sd/- ‘ L.C. Bhadoo RoshanF ‘ ‘ Judge t V s ,