IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.4687 of 2008 KRISHNA TIWARI & ORS Versus THE UNION OF INDIA & ORS ----------- CWJC No.5595 of 2008 KALYAN MARANDI &ORS Versus THE UNION OF INDIA & ORS For the Petitioners : Mr. Jagnnath Singh For the State of Jharkhand : Mr. Dhrub Mukherjee For the State of Bihar : Mr. Ray Saurabh Nath, JC to AAG 4 For the Union of India : Dr. Ratan Kumar, C.G.C. ----------- 4. 25.07.2008 The only submission made is for disposal of this writ application granting petitioners liberty to file a representation before the Home Secretary, State of Bihar that they are similarly situated as the petitioners in CWJC No. 5464 of 2007 and that their application for mutual transfer by allocation of cadres to the State of Bihar and Jharkhand respectively be considered in like manner as directed in the aforesaid writ application. The writ application is disposed with the observation that any such representation of the petitioners shall be required to be disposed off in accordance with law. The observation in the former writ application with regard to the State Advisory Committee shall not be relevant for consideration of such representation in view of the present counter affidavit of the committee that it has no role to play in application for mutual transfer. The objection of the Respondents whether the petitioners belong to the District Cadre or State level cadre is the aspect to be considered by the authority considering the representation. AKS/ (Navin Sinha, J.) - 2 -