sv sss IIS! ;,;l!: :1 "i; IN THE HI6H COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR ^fl^rfs Wri* Petition (S) No. PETITIOIS1ER5: ^^ ^....^- ^•"8^"'..-^" .^^M^ ^ '^'.••^0^'--"" .-•^O^fV'^''7'" ^^5" ^ t^ 2008 1-lori Ram Dewangan, S/o Late ShriSamrath Dewcingan, Aged about 58 years AccountsOfficer, Head Office of the Chhattisgarh State Cooperative Afarketin9 FederotibnLjmited, Raipur(C.©.) Awadhesh Kumar Singh, S/o Late SHri R. D. Singh, Aged abou1- 58 yettrs. ' t)is^l'ict;J%aj'l<e1'ing,;©f^icer, ^MItllis9SI|s1'e6tleNslp^'ffitil i:: |^|l^|j|gj^el|e^ji^i||||r|t|esl,i% |B|g®:||B|§||l||^|||||^j@^|^^;' UUrU^^maf'^SSrsas'rhOf.^ • K^. KS/o^ShrpJanakt.alShur'rna, AgeddbQUt54years, AAdnager, Kisoin Rice AAill, PdlaCi, &istt. Raipur(C.<S.) Suresh Rao Kadam, S/o Shri Laxman Rao Kdddm, Agedabout53y6ars, bistr'ict Marketing Qfficer, ChhattiS9arh State Coopera-l-ive AAarketing Federation l-imited; J<»w. .- '^,.,;:-.':^, E>istt. ,JanJ9Jr--'Champa (G.&^g &aulgt Ram Qiouclhary; S/oSltr'i Tikamlal Choudhdry, ,' Aged abou't'58 years, Senior Assiistant, P.F. Branch, l-1ead Office of the E a1tisgarh Stdtes Coogepatjve jlAaRketing Federa't'ioni-imitecl,^ 'Rdipur(C.6.)\,'1! .: ?':' ;; ;:i,: .:;:MW :<& :-;^1.;. "SR' Mahendra Sngh Thakur, S/o Shn ftaghunahdan 5ingh Thakur, Aged about 58 years, Mahager.Kisan Rice Mill, burg,. Distt.Durg(C^,) Manishankar Pandey, S/o Shri Basarit Lalji Pandey, Aged about62years, District Marketing Officer, ChhatTisgarh State Cooper'ative Marketing Federation Limited, Raigarh (C.6.) -Versus - RESPONDENTS: <^M^ '^^7% t's-^S^I<)S >\ <^^ 7.'^ ^TAH^: 1. <' State of Ghhal-l-isgarh, ,.,:^KlTHi^ugK|||^;:<Ssa"e^i^.:'''^;.^ sSSiSKWW^w'siss^^Q^^yi ||||B^||iig ||c|jtSg||gg|g8|an,:^if|1^ ||gj|||||iuJ||®B|i|i1~li|sgar|®||^l^',;:^;'f, %^ gistror/.:',.:,;'.::''':\\^^^ Cooperative Sdcieties; StciteofChhatttS9arh. Raipur, Chhattisgarh. Chhattisgarh State CoQperative Marketing Federation LimiTed, Through its Secretary, 880, Civill..Jnes,Raipur(C.6.) Monaiging Direcfor, Chhorrt'lsgarh STaTe Gooperative AAarketirig Federdtion l-imitey, Raipur^.).-',..,,:..;•... ';.'1':.:';..;.:;; Accourrfaht fieneral, A Madhya Pradesh; Swatior(M.P.) 6. Accoun-tant Gener<d, Chhaft'isgarh,Raipur :'9S9 wsssas '"' ^ WRFT PETITION UN&ER ARTICLE 226^2^ a-iE CONSTFTUTIQN C INC^ f'OR ISSUANCEGi i^^ WRrT/WRITS OIRECtTONS ETC. IN^^^ m M4NDAMV5. CERTIORARr WRrrOF LIKE NATUR& ANt>/OK AW at^Q^iUSW& ^. -«. HtGHCOURTOFGHHATTISGARHATBILASPUR WRJT PETITION fSV No. 4129 of2008 PETmONER : Hori Ram Dewangan & Others. .VERSUS .; ,• ,^. RESPONDENTS : State ofChhattisgarh & Others. WRITPETITION UNDERARTICLE 226/227 OFTHE CONSTITUTION OFINDIA SB: Hon'bleShrj Satish K. Aaaiihotri, J. Present: Shri Rajeev Shrivastava, Advocate fcu-tUe petitioners. ' ' , Shri N.N.Roy, Paiiel Eawyer fbr the.State/respbndent No 1 & 2. Dr. N.K.Shukla, Senior Adviocate withSBri Shailendra Shukla, Advocafe fortheresppndentNQ. 3 and4.. None •fbr the respondentNo. 5 and 6. ^ ; , • ORDERfORALy ;^^ 'C^^!^.,.(T^ssed<)n^^ T.i ^ f: Eeamed' .counsel ^appearing;lor "the/ petitioiiers submits that a repreSentation to settle the dispute as raised in this petition is not . being decided by respondents, which is evident from the ^ communication dated 05.06.2004 (Anhekure P/l) wherein the Managing Director, Chhattisgarh State eooperative Marketing Federation has Witfen to the Agriculture Productidn Commissioner, Govemment of Chhattisgarh, Raipur, Secretary, Agriculture and Cooperative Society ; and the Registrar, ;:, 'Gooperatrve Societies, to decide the.disp^^^ further submits that the State Govemment has infonned to .the petitioners that the dispute is to be decided by the respondent No. 3 and 4. Till date, no decision has been-taken pursuant to the direction made by this ;Gourt ofi 04.01.2005 m'W;P.No. 3186/2004. Uii 61H i sai ia j "l^ ii}HT'^^^;:^^^^^^'~'^^^;^^^^^j^^^?"^^^ Amit 2. Inviewoftheuncertaintyprevailingastowhoistodecide the representation dated 25.01.2008 (AnnexureP/9) which has been referred to the respondent No. 3 and 4 by the State GovemiTient for final decision, Dr. Shukla, leamed senior counsel appearing with Shri Shailendra SUukla, leamed counsel appearing for the respondent No. 3 aad 4 submits that in view of the letter dated 15.04.2006 ofthe State Govemment, the respondent No. 3 and 4 shall take final decision at the earliest within a period of four weeks. : . ' - ; ; : ' !. : . 3. In view ofthe foregoing, accordihg to leamed counsel appearing for the petitioners, notliing remains for adjudication in this petition. 4. Accordmgly,tUe'writpetitionisdisposedo£Noprderastocosts. Sd/- . . ; SatishK.AgniKotri _^__. Judge