)^ W.P. (S )NO. 784/2 007 Coram: PSTiTSONSR Hon'sie Shri .Jagdfeh BhaHa, XctJng C«3 Hon'bSe Shri Satish H. Agnihofri, J M.VV. Ansari, A.Qed aboui 45 years, S/o. Late Haz' Ah.med AH, Presentjy posted as in-specmr Generai of Poiics {Training}, Po!ice Head Quarter, Raipur (CG) Vs. t^^^/TLt^ f^^ ^ i/%^-.i^^ F ^^ ff~^t^ J/*^ ^ ^'^^'^ '.^F ?*< ^ ^^ i It^ ^!.[ union OT fpoia. !"troLtQri in®.r^nnOtpsi Ssorgtsrv. M'n'stry of Hcms A'ffs'fs. Nsw Deihi-110001. State of Madhya Pradesh, Through the Secretan/, DspaFtmenf of Home Affairs; Valiabh Bhawan, Bhopai ?MP). State of Chhattisgarh. Through the Secretan/, Department of Home Affairs, DK.S. Bhawan, Manfraiaya, RaipurfCG). Shri S.P. Pandey, (1PS) C/o. Direcror Genera' of Po'ice, PoHce Head Quarter Bhopal, Mac'hya Praciesh ' S. ibrahim (IPS) Jolnt Director, intsiiigsnce Buf^su (M?nistn/ of Hom^ A^sirs Nortn Btock, New Dejhi). S. Shri A. K, Dhasmana (IPSi JoinS Qrector (RAV} Researoh & Anaiysis W'ng Through the Home Seoretanf', Govemment of 'no'ia, Ministrv or Home Afiairs, North Block New De"T. 7. Sri Vsjav Kumar Singh {IPS; C/o. Direotor Generai of Poi'oe, Po'ic.e Head Quarter, ihopai, Madhya Pradesh. 8. Sri Rajendra Kumar {IPS5 C/o. Diredor Generai of Po'toe, PoHce Head Qusrser. Bhooai, Madhva Pradesh. Sri D-. S. K.Shrh^stava (IPS) C/o. Director General of Poiice, Po'ioe 1-iead Quarter, Bhopaf, Madhya P'adesh. Sri Sanjiv Kumar Singh (iPS) C/o. Diraotor G'enera! of Pofice. Pol'oe Head Quarter, Bhopat, Madhya Pradesh. Sn Sesho'.van Banerjee (IPS) C/b. Director Generai of Police, Police Head Quartsr, Bhopa', Madhya Pradesh. K "!0, 17 .20. Ms. A. Shanker (!PS) Clo. Director Generai of Police, Po'ice Head Quarter, Bhopai, Madhya Pradesh. Srs P.K.Shrivastava (IPS} C/o. DireoSor Generai CB), Superintendent of Poitoe, (Anti Corruption), CB!, CB' Head Quorters, New Delhj. Sri Rajiv Kumar Gupta (IPS) C/o. Oirector Generai of Poi'roe, Po'ioe Head Quartsr, Bhopal, Macihya Pradesh. Sri Raja Bsbu Singh {sPS) C/o. Director Generai of Po!ics, Poi'ce Head Quarter, Shopal, Maa'hya Pradesh. 1 Sri K.Vaiphej (!PS) C/Q. DJrector Generai j o* Poli.se, Poli'ce Head Quarter, Shopal, Macihya Pracesh. ;ri n <^ .c;a^s?' I'.iO^'' F'ff\ Hir^ir-t-nr rSQr^)fCTi U L^'.'-i^. •i3i3y^St ^"'0) ;wiJV. •L«'°itSUKJ? ^SSt^£3i or Police, Police Head Quarter, Bhopai, Madhys Pradesh. Mc-hd. Shahid Absar (IPS) C/o. Director General of Poitee, Poitee Head Quarter, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh. Vishwaranja",, IPS C/o. Director General of Pdlice, Poiice Head Quarter; Raipur (CG'). O. P. Rathore, iPS C/o. Director GeneraS of Poiioe, Poitce Heas Quarter. RaiDur 21. Praveen Mahendru IPS C/o. Director General of Poiice, Poiioe Heac! Quarter, Re'pur (CG). 22. Anii M. Navaney, !PS C/o. Direcfof General of Foiice, Po!'cs Head Quarter, Raipur (CG), . 23. Ram Niwas, iPS C/o. Director Generai or Pojice, Poi'oe Head Quarter, Raipur (CO). 24. A. N. Uppaci'nya'/, IPS r-in nuirector Generai of Poi'ce, Polioe Head Quarfe'', ,;,n,,.. /r^^\ Ipui ss^LjL '-11 D.M. Awasthi, ',PS Cfo. Director Generai of Poiice, Poltee Head Quarter, Raipur (CG). B.'nay Kumar Singh, iPS C/o. Direotor Genera! of Pofice, Police Head Quarfer, Raipur (CG). ^^ Ashok Juneja. 1PS C/o, DirscSor Generai of Poiice, Poilce Head Quarter, Raipur (CG). 28. Rajesh Mishra, IPS C/o. Director Genera', of Police, Poi'oe Head Quarter, Raipur w ^- 29. Aruncieo Gautam, IPS C/o. Director Generai of Poltoe, Poiice Head Quarter. Raipur (CG). 30. Guninder Pai Singh, iPS G'o. Direotor Generai of Poiice. Poiloe Head Quarter. Raiour i'CG). d'l. '30 T.u. Longkumar, iPS C/o. Director General of Poi'ice, Police Head Quarter, Raipur (CG). Vivekanand, IPS C/o. Direotor GeneraS of Poiic.e, Poi'ce Head Quarter, Bhopal, Raipur (CG). (Writ Petition under Articie 226/227 of the Constitution of fndia) Sh'i Ananci Kumar Tiwari, counsel for tne petitioner. Shri S'umesh Bajaj, Goverr'ment Advocate for the State. Shri BhasKar Pvasi, counsel for the respandents No. 7 to 12 & 17. Ms. Ritu Mishra, counsel for the respondenf No.25. None for other respondents. (Passedon 10 0ctot»er, 2007) Lsarned counseS appearing for the petitioner submits thst ths petitioner was necessar/ party before the Centrai Acministrative Tribunai (for short, "the Tribunai") in ths isght of the order dated 16 September, 2005 psssed by the Trifcsunal, Jabaipur Bsnch, in Originai Appiications No. 525 and 528 of 2005. Some other mattsre regarding re-allocatton of the iPS officers are stiii pending before the same Benoh in whtoh petitioner is aiso a party. 2) interest of justice woufd be served if ths petSioner a>»roaches the Tribuna! by filing origlnai appiication or by making review appiioat'.on as advised. in cass review app!lcation is moved, whiie considering the detay, the Tribunai shsU consider the period beween Rt'ing of this petition snci its dsoision as expiained. Therefore, the rev'iew petition shafl not 'oe K J^ dlsmissed on the ground of deiay behveen 1-2-2007 to 10-10-2007. if review petit.'on is fifed by 22-10-2007 3) in view of the above, thls petltion is disposed of. raju Sd/- Acting Chief Justice Sd/- Satish K.Agnihotii Judge 't. ' i^^~?^^''^^^^t^?F