414 1f 4 CWP Noe18428of2009 1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH CWP No18428 of2009 Date ofdecisionlI4102011 MunicipalCouncil Ropar Petitioner Versus Karnail Singhsince deceasedl throughhis LR Sukhdev Singhand another CORAM HONBLE MR JUSTICE RAJIVE BHALLA 1m C Present MreRSlUlosla Advocate for the petitioner 0 Mr Vikas SinghAdvocate for respondent No2 0 88888 I RAJIVE BHALLA J 4ORALI C5 I This order shall dispose ofCWP Nos8428 18831to 18859 Z 18874to 18877 of 2009 as theyinvolve of common questions of fact and law For the sakeof convenience facts are being takenfrom CWP No8428 of2009 I L The Municipal Council Roparpraysfor issuanceof a writ 111 Z thenature of certiorarifor quashing theorder dated 10022009 passed a1 bytheLabour Court Patiala 7 Z Counsel for the petitionerstates on instructions that in the ll peculiarfacts and clrcumstances of the presentcase the Municipal Councils acceptthat the worklnen duties at octroi postsOll It is however submittedthat as the Labour Court has not recordedany flndingwith respectto the total numberof on which the workmen duties as octrOl Cl erks at octroi posts the matter may be remitted to the Labour Court to determine the actual Rawat Seema 2014.04.21 11: 50 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 1 415 1 1 CWP No18428 of2009 r e 0 numberof on whil theworkmen dutiesas octroi Clerks at octroi posts Counsel for the workmen accept the statement made by counsel for the petitioner and state thattheyhave no objectionif the matter lS remittedto the Labour Court for the limited purpose of the actual number of on which the workmen i dutiesas octroi Clerks at octroi post 0 ln view of the statements made bycounselfor thepartiesthe 0 orderpassedby the Labour Court Patiala is affinned with respectto t5 the entitlementof the workmanto receivewagesfor every Saturday on which theyperformed dutiesof octroi Clerks at octroi posts The matter Z 1S howeverremittedto the Labour Court Patiala to determine the total Q numberof on which the workmen duties as octroi I Clerks at octroi posts Z Each party shall be gantedthree each to lead C0 evidence to establish their pleas In case any amount 1S 7 Z founddue to any workman it shall be paidwithin three monthswilll Il interestc 6Io pa Parties are directedto appear before the Labour Courl Patiala on 08122011 The matter be decidedpreferably within six monthsfrom the said date 14102011 IRAJIVEBHALLAl sIlallISher JUDGE D9 Dl1731 i Rawat Seema 2014.04.21 11: 50 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document