IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.14277 of 2006 1. Premnath Paswan son of Sri Gaya Paswan R/o vill Gobarsahi, P.S.Sadar, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 2. Jitendra Kumar Choudhary son of Sri Sone Lal Choudhary R/o vill- Mornisaf, P.S. Maniari, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 3. Anil Kumar Choudhary son of Sri Mukhilal Choudhary R/o vill. And P.O.- Kerma, P.S. Kurhani, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 4. Shambhu Ram son of Sri Deep Lal Ram R/o vill and P.O. Ghoushaul, P.S. Shivapatti Dist. Muzaffarpur. 5. Sanjoy Kumar Paswan son of Late Chulhai Paswan, R/o vill-Sakra Mansurpur, P.S.Sakra, Dist-Muzaffarpur. 6. Sunil Kumar Rajak son of Late Gorakh Rajak, R/o of vill- Jogiamath Sariaganj, P.S. Nagar, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 7. Surendra Baitha son of Late Kuer Baitha Resident of village- Harpur, P.S.Sakra, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 8. Bishnudeyal Paswan son of Sri Basudeo Paswan, Resident of village- Bochaha, P.S. Bochaha, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 9. Deepak Kumar Rajak son of Sri Sitaram Rajak R/o Purani Bazar (Sayanarain Mandir) P.S.- Mithanpura, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 10. Kapildeo Paswan son of sri Yadunandan Paswan, R/o vill- Gobarsahi, P.S.Sadar, Dist-Muzaffarpur 11. Sanjit Kumar Choudhary son of sri Krishna Kumar Choudhary, R/o village and P.O. Susta Madhopur, P.S. Sadar, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 12. Bishwanath Ram son of Ramdeo Ram R/o vill-Patiasa Jalal, P.S. Ahiapur, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 13. Meghu Rajak son of sri Yogendra Rajak R/o vill-Naya Gaon, P.S. Misahri, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 14. Daulat Kumar son of Late Doman Ram R/o vill Salahpur, P.S. Karja, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 15. Kameshwar Ram son of Bhikhu Ram R/o vill-Srirampur, P.S. Kathaina, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 16. Rajesh Khanna son of Hira Rajak R/o village- Antraulia, P.S. Saraia, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 17. Mahendra Ram son of Jageshwar Ram R/o vill and P.O. Dumari, P.S. Musahri, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 18. Sumitra Kumari daughter of sri Ruplal Ram, R/o village-Maripur, P.S. Maniari, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 19. Shankar Paswan son of Muni Paswan, R/o vill-Bishunpur Sriram, P.S. Sakra Dist. Muzaffarpur. 20. Sushil Paswan son of Jaikishun Paswan, R/o vill- and P.O. Naropatti, P.S. Sakra, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 21. Bhagwan Lal Ram son of sri Bodhi Ram R/o village- Sakra Manshurpur, P.S. Sakra, Dist. Muzaffarpur 22. Jialal Choudhary son of Yogendra Choudhary R/o vill-Mornisaf, P.S. Maniari, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 23. Satrughan Paswan son of Sri Ramswaroop Paswan, R/o village and P.O. Kolhua Paigambarpur, P.S. Ahiapur, Dist Muzaffarpur. 24. Tripurari Nandan Ram son of sri Bhola Ram R/o of village Sundar Sarai, P.S. Motipur Dist. Muzaffarpur. 2 25. Raj Kishore Ram son of Ram Sundar Ram R/o of village Khalilpur, P.S. Karja, Dist-Muzaffarpur. 26. Umesh Kumar Rajak son of Gonaur Baitha, R/o village Sundar Sarai, P.S.Motipur, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 27. Dilip Kumar son of Gonaur Baitha, R/o village Sundar Sarai, P.S. Motipur, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 28. Mahendra Ram no.2, son of late Bisheshwar Ram R/o village and P.O. Pakohi, P.S. Karja, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 29. Arjun Kumar son of Sri Ram Ashish Ram R/o village and P.O. Chamrua, P.S. Karja, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 30. Asha Kumari wife of Shyamlal Paswan R/o village and P.O. Pakari, P.S.Karja, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 31. Radhe Paswan son of Gena Paswan R/o village Sudwara, P.S.Kurhni, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 32. Kishun Paswan son of Shyam Narayan Paswan R/o village and P.O. Kerma, P.S. Kurhni, Dist. Muzaffarpur. 33. Sanjoy Paswan son of Baleshwar Paswan R/o village and P.O. Kerma, P.S. Kurhni, Dist. Muzaffarpur. ---Petitioners. Versus 1. The State Of Bihar through the Chief Secretary Govt. of Bihar Old Secretariat, Patna. 2. The Commissioner and Secretary, Personnel and Administrative Reforms Department, Govt. of Bihar Old Secretariat, Patna. 3. The Board of Revenue, through the Secretary, Board of Revenue, Govt. of Bihar , Patna. 4. The Commissioner, Trihut Division, Muzaffarpur. 5. The District Magistrate, Muzaffarpur. 6. The Director, Science and Technology Department, Govt. of Bihar New Secretariat, Patna. 7. Principal, Institute of Technology, Muzaffarpur. 8. The Deputy Collector-in-charge, Nazarat, Muzaffarpur. ---Respondents. ----------- 03 19.07.2011 Mr. T.N. Matin, learned senior counsel for petitioners and Mr. Pramod Kumar Singh, learned Assistant Counsel to AAG-2 are present. Mr. Matin, learned counsel submits that identical issue was raised in CWJC no. 11168 of 2009 which was considered and disposed of by order dated 01.09.2009 (Annexure-16 to the Interlocutory application no. 4628 of 2011). For violation whereof, a contempt application being M.J.C. No. 3407 of 2010 was filed which is pending. It is submitted that the respondents are going to implement the order contained in Annexure- 3 16 to the Interlocutory application no. 4628 of 2011. Paragraph nos. 2 and 3 of said order dated 01.09.2009 whereof read as under:- “2. Petitioners have been engaged to serve as candidate peon in the Collectorate at Muzaffarpur. They were earlier included in the panel published for Class-IV appointment but before their turn for appointment could come, the life of panel expired and they could not be appointed. Now fresh panel is to be prepared in the light of the resolution of the Government bearing No. 19/09 dated 25.6.2009, which has been issued in the light of the earlier instruction of the State Government bearing No. 16441 dated 3.12.1980. 3. Let the case of the petitioners for empanelment be considered in accordance with law taking into account the entire length of engagement rendered by them as a candidate peon in the Collectorate at Muzaffarpur.” Learned counsel for the State on going through the pleadings made in the writ petition and the order dated 01.09.2009 does not dispute the stand of the petitioners that they are similarly placed. Having heard the parties, the application is disposed of by the following order:- The case of the petitioners shall also be considered by the respondents in the light of the order dated 01.09.2009, relevant part(s) whereof have already been quoted hereinabove. Sym ( Kishore K. Mandal, J. )