70 1 a 0 n4 1 1 1 I 1 1 r 1 lN rHE llIGH COlJRT Ol7 PlJN Irlll iIND IIARYANA AT 1 CIIANDIARII IIAK 4117IlliSION 1 e t 1CWP NO116 0f2009 e 1 a 0 Rajindcr Kumar and others etitiotlers 0 41 I VKRSUS 0 A Stnteof Punjab S Otllers e e I r 2aCWPNo3772 of2008 1 Z 7 POIS18 and oIers Petilioners Q Ct VERSlJS I Slte of Punjab Olhcrs ResptIiIlIenls 08 3CWP Nrl7853 of 1999 r n6 4 Jaswinder Singhetce Petititnlers en Z VERSUS tl SliIleof Ptinjabetc 4eCWPNo12553of 1999 Daan Singli and others Petitioners j P Vl7lRSIIS Sfate of Punjab O Others 5CWP No19195 rll 211118 11 IVlatljillSingll 11i111111rs eeePetili41t1erS 1 0 VERSUS Stote ofPunjab S Others Respondeiits IPp 6eCWPNtl5461 of20119 Nllritltlcr Sitlgllatld otliers Pelitioiicrs Rawat Seema 2014.03.10 12:16 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 71 e 4 r 2 1 J VERSUS StllteofPuiljiib OtIers f 7eCVVPNo117 of2009 l JagjitSingh and othcrs Petitiolicrs 1 VERSUS Slate of Punjab SzOthers 0 8CWP N05472 01 2009 J CO Ilira Lal and others Petitioners C5 VERSUS StateofPunjab Others 4 a Z 9CWP No82 of2003 5 1 13holaSingh and others cti tioncrs e I VERSUS 08 StateofPunjab O Others Respondnts 10 Non152170f2008 P7 SubhashChand and others Petitioners Z 3 rl VERSUS Stoteof Punjab Others Ilespondcnls 11CWP No15204 of2008 Raj Kunlar lltld olliCS Pctitioners C VERSUS State of Punjab Others Rcspondeis J 2CWP No9726 of211118 Maldtan Singh nnd oters Petit ioners VERSUS StateofPunjab 0 Othcrs No07 of2003 4 Rawat Seema 2014.03.10 12:16 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 72 e 4 1 e 1 1 1 lIans RaJ and othcrs Petitioners 1 VKRSOS StaltofPunjab i Olllers 14CWP Noe16772of 2008 ShlcrPal andowrs Petitioiiers 1 VERSUS fr State of Punjab Others 0 C0 r CORAM 5 IION13LE MRJlJSTICIi PliRMOD K011L1 4 Z PRESENT Mrrora MrNlOStlillitli NliClSI3t11 Mi17SMIilllils MrRanlcsll Gocl MrM1llilltlli MrV8111111 0 Advocates for the peliliOllCl SI MsCharu Tuli SrDAG Ptinjllbfor 08 Pertnod Koilli Je ClO 4 Since coilltllOll qlICStIOllS Of IttWilild fElctsare involved in thcse lvrit wnn Z the salne are of by Illis COllllllOilOrclcr 1or thc sakc ol 0 brevityfacts are beingtakcn f0111CWP No 116of 2009 The in thesepelilioils tlrc oll dailywagcbasisIll diferent capacilics iil lhe Slatcof 1ltilI llle 01 WaterSuploly and Sanltatiotl The Ilrllyersill 1111 tllesc atc l7i giIlll C of Ivages at the Ill i il Illl ll Il l 0 Illc llIV SelIlCiIS lcvised l i0111 11111C 10 IllllC alongwitllalIowanccs tltlcl tIrrcrs 01 so l0 1or ii pcriodof thrcc VCls precedinglhc fllingoflhc Wrlt Thc haclctirlier fl IedCWI NI11211 1 2002 1illlicllCtlll lC Io bc of viclc tIrdcr 22 1 011711ilhtl dircctitlll tcl Engiilcer PlV Public Hcalthl RWS Circle Rawat Seema 2014.03.10 12:16 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 73 1 P1p r e eI 4 10 takc tl deeisitlil ilil Illc ISlIC IlllIolllcd Ill ViellI Ihe 1 decision rcnderedbythc Sulorcillc tlrl ill tllc COSC 01Secrelilry Sllllc Ilf Karnataka vse Umil Devi1111dotlIcrs 211116 131SLR l bypassing a wcll rCEISOIlCd Speaking orders witlll Il SiX Illtllllhs Iroill lllC dateof rcceipl01 tl ccrli fied copy of thc order On thc llasis 01 the ilforesaidcliIci tlle EngiilccrWater Stlpjlly1111ISotliloliotl Ciiclc ittdllitiilo 10 viclehis order dated252008 ltlncxiirc e I2I1lllcgccyrciccleIlllc cliiili 0 ofthe for iItthis stageIlhas bccn hcld that undcr 0 I thc GoveminentPolicy dated 15122006 the is to be 5 ordcredon coinplelionof 10 yCOrS Ol lllore scrvicc strictly to r thcir seniority in the coilceriled calcgoryagainstthe availableregular Z sanctioned vacant postswilh tIlc Il hos bccn illclll itIIlCtI er has been made in dl ffcrcilt ccgoriesagainstthe availalole I 08 vacancies For PumpOperators has beenmadcupto638 oo f6r Mali Cunl Chowkldarupto570 1111dIor Illtlci Coolic tijolo72 t11llie 1 7 Iist whereas the illilllberSare Inuch below and lhe Z case will bc coilslderedas aild whcil theii luril collles accoidiilg 0 10 theirseniority Il is Iiirlhcrstalccllltll 11011Cof llle jlIIliOr to lhc havebeen Learnedcounscl for thc pctilioncrs IltIvCvelleilletllly arglicdtllol lhe clainl of the peliliollerS Ill lhe aforcsaicl Ivril pclltlOllSWOS ilOl Ior 40 but for thc gttllll01 llle IlllilllllllllI Il llle 1Oilyscillc ltllcll Ilis becn cxtcndeclto situalccl Iocrsoilstllld IalgeIltlillbel Ol cngagedOil dailywage basis iatcr in litlle tlliIil lIlCIlclilIOtlCrSIli11CIlirll such benefltswhi Ie denyiilg lhc somc lreatnlenl tO the This fact is also cvideilt frOin Olle of thej datcd Rawat Seema 2014.03.10 12:16 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 74 1 8 7 17PNO116 of2009 ctc 5 e 4 passed in CWP No 1211ol 20112Illcd bythc llc 1 havc Illcd llis clliIlleiiilgIlle i11IicsIiol 1 trdCr Anncxure P 121 Il2lvcsotigllllllc icliel 1oi tlle grailtt11 IvllgcS411 the minimumofthe loay scalc In 11 Ilc olhet I7ctitiols illso lllc leliclis 171 grontofwages at thc illitlitnlttllOf Ihc 13111 Sctllll 1IlcIoctilitlilels Iltllc teliccl UpOllVOrIOUS ofthls Courtttld thc l011ble Coui1etitIici m 1 passccl 0 1Iowcvcr tllc claiill ol lllc llclllitlllcrs Is tIllposcd atld rcsislctl byllle C Oll lhe grouildlhal tllc clilioilcrSarc nol cntitledto the soInc 49 wtiges as arc granled lo the rcglilarIy cll tllc SllIte I MsCharu Tuli learnedcouilsel for 111c has subillittedtlllll Itl Z theIightofthe judgillelll ofthe Honble Sliprcllle COlirl lll tlle Casc of lJilln D t Devi supralthe petitioners are IlOt enttlcd to be Il has Z furlhcr beenargucd on bchalf of thc tllat by smiltIt 5 oo payscaIcSwould ainotlnt to treotiilgthe tiilcqliills witll eqllalsIilllicll itscll r em is 1Il COlltraveiltion to tlle of Arliclcs 14 and 16 of tllc z Conslitutionof India Il 1 haveheardlearlled counsel f0 the porticslt is not tllal thc arc working Ill VarIOUS as Ptlilllo MolieCUllle Chawkidar Fitter Coolie Filter HeljocrStorc Munshi and on such othcr C copociticsi t is admittcdpositiontllat tlle jlctilitlncrs i1171Workiilg Oll diIily wogebasis for lhc Iilsl nunlbcrtears iil S4IlllC CCS Illtly hC illilre lllll 1WO dectldcs Il is in thc Ilrll joclition t hIt there is groupofthclusatldsOfclllploycesworking oIl dlily 1471tgc Ioasis11tIlc SlilC t11 The dlities 111d t1 Illc ellljItlyccsIll lllCIr rcspeclivc ctitcgoriesarc sarnc hcy ideilliCtIlftIllCliOIlSillld SllllrC Rawat Seema 2014.03.10 12:16 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 75 10 7 0 1P NO116 of2009 etc 6 sinir lllc dlllics lllc iil lllciI 1 cotcgorleS are 1cv ore 0l lIlc Sillllc Sltllc SltllC WlSC senioritylists have becn or diffctetltcalegoiies ailcl 11l llle 11rCbornc on thc SCilltlrltY Iists A ItlrgeIllllllhcr of dlily Wagcrsevcn engagedIalet in tillle staild wllercas olhcis are gctting IlllllllllUill of poy scale under variOlIS judgtlleilts of tllIScourl and 1 lhe IIIonbleApexCourt The pctiioncrshilvc rcclicd lO a largcnunIbcrol 0 j passed by Honble Cotirtoildlllis Court Soine of stich 0 are noticedhcreuilder C5 In the case of State of Punjabi0 Otllcrs vse Devindcr Singh45 OllIers Civil AppealNoA492 of 1997 tlecidcd 011 2 17019971Illc Z 5 I IoilblcSuprcillc Courl IlilsmliclclIlltJwill tlhSCvatiotlSl 44ln oLir vew lllc of Et1i11liiy I7i I EqualWork can ellSllre tO the lo tllc 08 Oo Iiinitedexleill Wllell lllcy IVere founclIo hiive eCr W2 beengiviIlgsillliltlr work as laedger Z 20 Kecpersthcycould have bcenpaidthe mlnlmum 0m of lhc joaysctlle 01 iI lcdgcr Kccjocr 1V118 avaiIable to rCgtilY tlppoilltcd Lcdgcr CIcrlcs 1carnccl counsel for l he 4W S Ctlll ld Illll SlICCCSSIilliy ctltl lClld llltl Sllcll 1Ill tIrder Slltltlltl Iltll IlIc llCCIIIllscd Wc thercforc allow lhis appcalto tlle Iiinited CXlClll 1Ile tirc held Iiillitccl oil lllC princiIole of EqualPay lllt EquolWork to gcl 1110 stIlaryt11iiliblc lo tllc LcdgcrKccpcrsliedgcr Rawat Seema 2014.03.10 12:16 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 76 e 1 V e 7 CIcrks tl1C rccrliiled lllcywoulclhc 1 entltledlo lllc Illllllllllilll Of lIlC Ioayscale 01 ille LcclgerKccpcrswllich 111t1ybc 8vuilablc to tllc regulilrly t1 iltcd l CdgcrKeepCrStlnd lllcy l cannot be IlllidlllC rtllllllllg tinlc scale as theyWere nol rcgularlyappointed as Leclger m Q CIcrks Il 0 On thc basis oflhc CWP No10017 0 0 1995was decided clatcd20 1998 p8ssedby lhis Court C5 whereinfollowing observationshave bccn nladcl I e 46lccordingly I allow tllc writ and direct Ihc Z t to Ioay tlle illllllillllill pay Scalc to lhe elt pellllOIlersIilS IS avtlilitble lo lllc rcgularOclroi Clcrks 21 with allowanccs on the basis and thc 08 ao difTcrenccbctwccil thc cillolltllcllls illrclldyjliiitlltI cIcll W2 oftllc shallbepllidfor a peiiodoftle yctilS Z 10 to the filiilgof lhe wril ie 11oln122 1992 0 Thc arrearS So calctilalcd shall bc paidwilhin lotlr nlonthsThcrc willbc no orclcraslocosts Il A siinilarordcr callle to bc byl lotlble SliloicllleCollll Ill Illl 1 casc of NilgiIr Vse Ktilllir Siiiglt O Otlicrs Cjitjl AppealN00187911999decitIed llll 3113f9991Ivhcrcinil has hcenohscrvell as underl 44cspOlldCIlIS tlrc itilclcrlllc lllc ligll Court Ioi lllc rclicl Illill Ille arc cntiilcd lo thc scale of pay as Is availoblc ltl Rawat Seema 2014.03.10 12:16 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 77 1 e 2WP NOJ16 of2009 etc 8 vl ii2 sclllc hc 1 IearncdSitlgleJtidgcgrilillcd111csaid rclicf Otl tllopcallllc Divisioll 13cilcllIl3scoille lo CtlllClllSlOll tllal thcrc Is no jusliIlcotion t inlerlcrc Ivilll Ille orcler of Illc lctlrilcu SiriglcJudgc bui clariIlccl 1111Il So Illr 1IStllC OrlCtlrS 810 CllllCcrilCd t lhc woLild bc etltitlcd lo drllw ill lllc 0 Illilllllllltll of lhcscolcof pay for a period013 YCOrS 0 I2 priorlo datcoftllc fllingofthc writpclitlclil 19 5 A Divisloil Bcilch clf tllis Cclurl llltllvccl CMI Noe78071f 1999 Oll I 1422000relyingupon the abovetllcillioncd onclillade Iloliiilg Z t observationsl t 6 Ilc dtlclrlllC lll Ctlttolpay lor clllitll Ivork e I eilshrinccl iil Arliclc 39dl of tllc CIIlstltullllll CA5 r a dtllyOll 1lc ptiblic elllploycr O pilJ We smilir lO IllC doitlgsillliltir IlItlrlI Z 3 Elllcl ill 11IClv tll Ille Ilct llliit thc dLItics bciil le bv lllc pcliliollcrsarc similar Io tllose CIcrkslOctro Ierksiiild lOtICrS WIlt1211c locitle silliryill IIICrCgllltll 111110SCtlleInllcIind nlcrll CJ Ill thc cltlitll t11Illc llctilitltlcrslllill lhcyarc enlillel Io bc Ioilids11lry ill lIlCrellllr IOYSCalc IIleilcc tllc 1111t petitionIS tlllolvcd lc rcspondents 11rC dreclid to joayto the Illtllillllllll 0f lhc reglililrpay scales ftlr lhc posts 01 t IcrkslOctrcliClerks Ilrid l ri11Cr8 Rawat Seema 2014.03.10 12:16 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 78 1 1 0 r 9 1 hcy sllilll Ilstl Ilc IotlidDearilcssAllowOllCC11111 Olhcr aIIowIaIlCCS iIS IllaV bc adillissiblcto sticll tiilclerthe Riiles Tlle derent bctllleeil the emoltltllentsalreadypaidto the alld which may bcpayabie to themin terms ofthc ordcr shall bc collllilcd to a periodof threeycarspriorlo 1 C the date of Illiilll 01 tlle Wrll petilion Ilc ttrreiirs 0 shol bc paid l0 Illc Ioclitioncrs within a pericld o l C 0 fOllrIllOtllllslroln thc datc of recciptof a cer6cd C49 COjoy of lhis ordeiI 19 I hc haveplaccdoil rccord tl 01 Z 2 e this Court and Honble Coltrl wlleicitl tllc tllicsaid V Q f havebeenreliedupon wllicll ilre illlt Ilelilll re tl l 3 To l colllrary MsCIltirti 7ili Icllrllcd cllllllscl l1 Illc lesllIiltlcllls a5 00 has relicd upon StlIte of IlaryanaOtld nIher v Tak Raj and uthers er 47 AlR 2003 SupremeColtrl 2658 ln lhc ilIoresaid judglllclllwllilc Z the of of doctriilc of lqLt111ay l10t Clm EqualWork clua llle doilywaucrs in with thc regulIr and Sl0111lOtlblcSuprcillc Clltiil Illi101clIllolviilgobselIltlli9tls e 13 lqual Piiv lor Ctltiillwork Il 1S a conccplwhich rcqtlircsI7lr its IllIllicIilily tlllcl ilIlltllesIIle identily belweCIl il 8Otijl o f ellllol OyeCS Clil I lll iilg identicalpay SCiIICsiIild lllc tltller roup of cilljoloyccs who have alrcadycrtlcd sltcll py Scalcs Thc problcnl aboul equal pay cannot allvaysbe translatcdilllO 11 nlatllcnlaticalfornltllti 11 Rawat Seema 2014.03.10 12:16 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 79 0 4 9 a IO fcrcllCC IS 2IlSoIlltldCt lllCIlldIllCIll jltlssctlitl Ille cilSe tlfSl1ile Il Orissa and otliers VS Balllranl SalIu and otllers220031 1 Supretlle Courl Cnses 250 I0i1Ille SlillrCllle Illlrt illadc IolltlIlillll obscrvtllitlllSl l lee hotigll cqtial joav for equalWorl is considcrcdl bc i1 ctlctllllll21111Of Arlicle ILl tlS w Ct 1lllIC11 llS eqli11Wilrk ftlr WOrk IiIill lilso 0 0 bea ncgtltioli of lhat righlequalpajwould 10 f I llOt otllyllle lllre Or tlle VOlUlllCOf work t5 2C but also oil lhc qtitlliltIllvc differenceas 4t reliabiIityand as well atld t1lough 2Z thc IililCllOtlS llllly be tIlC Silillc blll tlle f2 44 Iitics do nliIkc ti rcol and J dIcrCllCC tA5 f10 XXX XX X XXX XXX 4 Wm IllTo clllim i rcliclllil thc IltlsisofetItttlliIl IS Z 10 for thc cla1t1111S 10 SllbSttltllllC l Clearlltl btlsis01 11 1lllclil Cslillanl llOStiIedlscrlllillati111 bcfore cligihlclo claim ri8h1s onapor HIllll Illc Illler 1tISIrVlS lll Ileced IisC Illllllllltlll Allotllcr Illdglllclltrclicd I NlsIlilru tili is in lllc ctse ll l S of Puiljllband olllers vs SuriiIder Sinuh and aiiotlier 211117 141 SCT 628 whereinfollowingobscrvationshavcbccn nlade 611lc priilcijolc of cqualpay Ior equalwork has gilc tI setl c1IllIle 11rIicr Illc vielv Il llliS 6Illlrl Rawat Seema 2014.03.10 12:16 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 80 1 1 r 4 l l J IVISIlllll if llvtl pcrstlnsOrC discl81118Illc SOlllC unclions tllcyIviII Ilc cnlillcd lo sollle IV tllls VICIV hashcen ond n011 1lc vielovo l lh is courl is that lllcre should bc CollOJClC 10111idciltitybctwccll lllc lllll pcrsonssiiniltIrly situitlcd SO tlS to grailt of elItial m l lly fol ctlllil ivtlrk RrcenllyIllis Ctltlrl llIs IlrlIl 0 lllltl Iclcnlily belwceil l140 IlaS ltl Ile 0 I COllJplclelnd lottil Iil CllSe of a regultlrOlOllOIlllee C5 he has ti selecliclll PrOCcsSOtld his I C scrvlccs orc rclllt11 l lcil il ll dallyMige Z IS llc somc fUtlCllOllSlS tI rCgtlllll m C 1e Illc tItillltlril ics irc Iltll 1NIuildItl illll eclualloay lO sllcll a pcrsoil 110is Oll 08 CO daily wagc basisi c for a shorl ternland C em has not Iaced lhc sclection process ThLts thc Z 3 prlnciple of cqualpay for equolwork has to be 0 8rIllledonly if tllcre is a tolal atld collljllelc 4 idenlitybcllvccn lIlCVo lll tlllS VICIV we arc loy tl tlccisitltl tl1 lll lS Cllllrl Ill Ille C4 case ol S e1111111Iil 4 Ililers S Stlltr Ilf I llIarkhand and olllrrs 211117l41Stl 76 211117 91 SCR 13ll el 211117IIll Se 272 wllicll Illls Ilccllre lirrctl l lI ciIrlicr iil dccisioils ol lllis tJllll xxx XXX XXX 8In vicw Jf lllc IcgolptlsiIillll 118IlIClIIItIilCtI Rawat Seema 2014.03.10 12:16 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 81 1 1 S a 12 above Ivc atC oflllc oloitlioil tllilt lllc viciv ltlkcll 1v fhe IIlonblc I llgh Courl payscalc 0 regllllir IO the claiIy wogc doesilol ololocarto be well louilded we allow tIlCSe alld set asiclelhc ordci 01 lhe I lighCOllrltIS tllstItllc al Court diSlllISS 1 0 thc sults Illcd hylhe hcrcln 94 0 The dictunlof tlle 1orestid tclictl iipoll byNlsCIliiili 1111 0 I ISlhat thc doclrincof cquol 1t11ClllllIllitIrk 114 IlCillVllltct1Illrrl I i Iltly C 1 I bccausesome cmployccstllC sinlilor kiJld of Ittties A l ul otherconsiderationsarcrcqrcd t0 hc SCCIl I7lrlevlliclltllc relcvllillIllolril Z n illust bc placedOll rccord Sllllilllr ISSlIC lVt18eonsidcrcdbythis Ctlllrl Ill lllc C casc of PlIrdeepKtitllar atld olllers vse St of Punjaband otllers CWP 12 Noe8671of 1987 dccided 11113 1eI020081In lhc aforesaid casc whiIc 08 OO the judgmentt1f I1011blc Suprcmc Colirl in thc casc 01 m3 Surindcr Singll supral followingobsetlations havebeeillllade Z t HowelICr Iil SllrlilclerKlltll2liS CllSC supral Ihe 11onI1IcIIpCXCourt IlIs ruled lllat lllc t cannot bc 1IllCd tinlcss lherc s totol llild cIillIlleteitkiltilyIlellvetIIltlIt IWll IlerSlltlsIil l C presenl casc Oll accounl of VOrIOllS Cllrlicr 0f lhis Cotirt cotlllrnlcd by tllc I loil11Ie SllprcllleCoui1 cloily Ivagers 111alnlosl oll thc orc gcllingthe bilslCslllaryIil IllCIllll scalc of ccltiivillcilljlost Occtipicdby Ihc retlliir Cillloloyecs 2111d tllis bcnellt Ilas llecil olloli cd ltl Rawat Seema 2014.03.10 12:16 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 82 1 CWPNO116 of2009 ctc 1 lllelll f01 lllc Iocriod 131cccdiilglllrcc ycorsild Illll monthsbelrIrethc Itlingo lhc wrlt pelition1llc are siluilled alld lIllISlllcre is conlpl ete andtola i idcntitybetweenthe alld the dailywagers who are Itl Othcr Ill tllCSlolc Tllc connolbc 1C2 denied the similar bcnelils as has been grunlcdto 0 other dailywagersworkillgin the same andothcr 0 ill thc Sltlteof Punjab 3 9 C5 I The sum andsubstonceof thc rclicd upIl botll tllc s2s IS e tllatlhe doctoriileof eqlii11 pily 171i IilIi1r s t0111IIllllctc tllc Z identitybctwecn IllC wilgcrs titld legUllU W C1 is cshlisl c sjlcclIlcovcrnlCIllS IlliideIlylIlt 2E are lhal thcyare lhocsalne dulics as the regliltlil 08 CO PPoinledeinployccs orc IlCrlIrlll l Il 1irgcillimbcr of cliiilyw2lgers I4 3 arc getol ingtlle ininiinulll of lhe joaysc11 byVirlliC of various ol Z lhc Honble Sulorcrnc Courl 1IlldlhiS Coull lls lllstl 11101 solnc llmc lhc posls Ll arc These EIVCr111Clllshavc 1101bccn denicd oncl disputccl I 1 the rcpJyflled bythe Ilc 011ly ilrglIillCillSi1lisedt111bellllll cJI the is that da IyWagershalletlIl bccil selcctedbyIllly C Of scleclioil wllcreas ilc regularlyljllllliiltctIClllllltlyccs WCrC dtilyselectccl In view of lhe cuteila ol ol lhis Collr1 afllllcd 1Ic l loll1lc Courto1cferredto llerceitlmiibOVCtltll 01 1lc cOtlsiderctlVICIVllll thepctitioners cannot beclenled a silli Ittr1calmclll as givento other dli loI wagersWorklllglrl varlOUS deoartmentsof thc Sac iil tlle same calegorics to which the belongEvcil tllc speciIlc averinenlsof lC Rawat Seema 2014.03.10 12:16 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 83 rbJMmIAWaMalmn e 4466 4 I4 Il 1 thiil pcrstlils wl90 lirc cIllIgcdli11crIll 11111CllllIil lllc IelitioIlCrS Il are gcttiilgilliililllUlll pElyscllles Iltlvc ilol bcell Il IS IlOl irrclcvanttosay thatthere is and I4IholesaleidenlilybelllL3Cll 1 the rcgularly employccsclaily Ivtlgcrstllrcadygetlitlgill itl iill lllll of pay scaleundcrthc courl ordersandthc In vicw of lhc tlbovc thescpclilillx SliCCecclhc peliliIllcrs sllll e Q bc cntitledto Illltliillulll of llle 10111 scalc 01 thc catcgorics tI Ivllicll tllc 0 belong with all allowallces tls reviscclIlll ilillC lo lilllc IIoloVelicitllc iclici 0 I shallbc confiilcd to tllrcc ycors jlrcccdiilg tllc IlIiilgnf tllc writ pctilionsIll 9 eachcase I 4 A copy hc plllccdon rccord on cach conccrIledOlc Z t 4 tV PlIlRMOD K0111ll a5 JUDGK 00 090702009 ve MFK Z 1a tl NOIEWhelhcr lo be relcrred ltl Rcptlrtci lll I119Y IISIN 1 2t91 8 fyl 4to4cl 53 r Rawat Seema 2014.03.10 12:16 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document