TE? '^i<<i«><<, ®Tfly'is,Rii?»iyy ^r ^te.....^.C<.l..'").,. W^ 2007 GRPRJ— FS;'246—2/20U7. »Bf WS9, an^r ira% ('pf^^a) SD^T.W R-li'ti TWT SV^S *4i<* TCirar^itasii^ •riilfi'fli 'qroif'? fei^ ^fSre^R ^i'sifOTan^r M.A- (Cl No JIOIO/2007 APPELLAKTS/ CLAIMANTS 1. Gencs Ulrruv .|h Ram Dhruv S/o Daya Raia j, Aged about 55 yeara /.' o-^. FekaB aged Baiw/o Gaaesh Raia Dhruv, tbout 50 years i.5 > j xU.ipci. Siagh Dhruv, s/o Gaiiesh Ram aged about 24 years —^" L '"1"" ,'^ci-ij'd. Ram r/o vi ] Palari ji Siagh Dliruv, s/o Gaaesh] fhruv, aKed about 21 yeara, ail )lage Kaaaliot, P.S. feTahsU District Raipiir(CG) VSStsirs RESPONDENTS 1. Haris] Kam 1. f \^ V Distri< Chaadra Kaslsyap s/p Paach LastiYap, aged about 26 years, lage Paijania, P.S. Lonai, :t Bilaspur(CU)- Driver ^.r- _L 2. 1 M/s Uirecl Deenii years, Bilasii _^wri)E| The A Lta.. Chow( Kaipi) Hondt CKS^ Yadav Bus Service, Through or Narendra Kumar Yadav s/o .sysl ys.d&v. o.££fi ofcout 50 r/o Kududaad Maagala Naka, nistrict RilasmiriCra- ! J — —- —.--^ =.. —-~. i.^^- —.- ^ -. •—/ T -^ [ew Iiid.la. Assuraiice CO£EIT)STIV hrough Branch Ofticer, Garden k> Baloda Bazar, District i\CG) - (Iusuit;r of Vehiclc Heiu RRaring registration No. CG 04 5Sj_ ! ,! ^ „,., J The Ltd., RaipTl Vclu^i No, a< few ladia Assurance Companv Througll Divisionai Office, -, District RaipurfCG) fiasurer of jE Mini Bus Bcarittg rcgistration. 3 15ZA 0717). i 1 . p sn^t.^i ft-fi't) wnaiK^I skll* \^ 3^T ^ll^l^, ^Ti1tijld, (S|<Y>l^y ^) ^Wvi\ *i41* i^-Atr^ lojo sa^r irag; Cpf^^T) w^ 2007 TOIRR ^ftcT SD^T Appeal under Sectioa 173 ofMotor Vehide Act, 1988 Appearance: Shri S.K.Giiha, coiinsel DB-: HO BLE SHRJ L,C. BltiADOO, J. fe KGH'SLB SKRI SUSIL 3 ORAIJ L.C. Bhadoo. J: (11 Heard on admission. This appeal bas appeflants/daimants for enli amount. TTiere is rielay of77 r| By thc inipngnerl awai)'l Trihiinal has assessed the n[ naindy- Kiinj Bihari as Rs.20C|0/- I^eamer! coiinsel for tN that the deceased was eamiTigl job ofgoldsmith and be wras a1 accoiintiTig and salesmanshin WR have nenised tlie Trilninal. 'tii'i)f<'f'!il'< 'qpraf tf is^S <Pflt<i^ i; affifir SII^T 'or the annellant. CUB5AR 3INKA, J. ORDER f-tnr^'-7\ ,^\f\ji ^ been pi-efen'ed by the ancemcnt of tTie. coTnpeTisation ays in filing fliis appeal. dated 28.2.3007, the leamed lonthlv incmnR of fhe decease.fi te appRllants/claiinanta suliTnits atteast Rs.3,000/- p.m. from the |so eaming aboiit Rs.5000/- from ^ifthe omaments. award passed bv the claiins GRPRJ— FS/246—2/2007— 50-000. 3wT ^wicfi^, •a-^ww, [^'ftw'y. , Cc3 /& lo tflKrtl *N|cb""""""""""""""""""""""""'""""^ 200 7 an^w 'VRK C'p^^y) <^ ai^T.'W lt(-li=k 'TOisn^r SCTW c» ^-{-^Z^jT^ i^iwdtersii^r A pemsal of para 13 of the deceased Kiinj Bihari wai sTion of the owner. T1ie ownei deceaseri nser! to eam Rs.2! doRiim('nfaiy pi-oofwas prodii the rleceaser) was working. Poi no documents have been siibifl we are of thf. considereri opin assesserl Rs.2000/- p.m. as t1 in oin-i opinion is jiist anrl assesserl hv the Tnbunal. We do not find anv impugnRr) awarrl and the trih^ 1 / 3r<^ of tb.e ia.coiEie aud ssse? as Rs.2,16,000/- anri Rs. 10,0(| overa11 loss and income assci i-easonahle. As siich this ani mcrits as we11 as on delay. Sd/- L.C. Bhadoo Judge ^)-4[^Titl'T ^W<lt*'^ f^^ ^•(^R i?3fRPT3Ilt5I fhe impiignefl ffwairl reveals that ijs working as a goldsmitb in the of the s1iop 1ias stateri that the liOO-3000/- n.m., for which, no ^ed T>v the ncTSOTi at whosp. shoo RBming from ntlicr sounces also, jiitted by the claiTnants; therffoi'e, ion that the Tribnnal bas riglitly ic income ofthe. deceased, whieh heasonabte incoTne as taas been i11ega1i1y anri infinnity in tTic inal has awarried after derlncting •sed. the total loss of deDeudeiicv 10/- in othcr heads, the.rRfore; the ssert hy tlie trihiinal is jnst anrl bea1 is 1iaMe to he dismisserl on Sd/- Sunil Kumar Sinha Judge GRPRJ— FS/246—2/2007— 50,000. iiiMBS Ij^^ „• ^^l^gl '• BBB6! ' 1JBB9!