IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BILASPUR W.P. AM 227 NO g3$ of 2009 C‘ggwkg 9ngh PETITIONERS 1. Bhagchand, aged 35 year‘s. (PlainTiffs) 2.Ashok Kumar, aged 32 years. WSW 3 Dlllp Kumar' aged 28 years ,J‘ . All sons of La‘re Roopchand Bajaj and residents of Sindhi Colony, Bilaspur' (CG). Vs n‘ a RESPONDENTS (Defendam‘s) H . Sm'r. Naanki Bai, aged 65 year's, wife of GirdharilaL residen’r of Sindhi Colony, Bilaspur (CG) . STaTe Through ' N’K of ChhaHisgar'h, fhe Collecfor', 1/ Biiaspur‘ (CG) WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA HQGH G$URT 6? 3HHfaTT§SGARHA¥ BiikSPUR siauié Bench: Haa’me Shri Justice Pfashaat Kumar Misha W¥§£ Petitiar: {Art 22?} Na 3333 i 266$ ?ETiTiGa'\éERS Bhagchand anti athera Versas RESPGNDEN?S Smt, Naanki Bai arid aneiher. Shri Ma§ay Shféva$tava, caun$ei far {he peWenem Shri Vineci Tekam, Pane! Lawyer for {he Statef'resgonden M02“ Nana for vegandem him . WRIT ?E'f§?§$i‘3 U§§ER éRTiaLE 22? GF Ti-iE €GESTITU?IGN $F mm}? QRAL QRBER $6.1 $.2m 6} The g3$aintiff3 if} the Sm have mefewed tag imam writ petitim under Ari§3te 227 m the C¢3n$t§aiia¥1 0f mwa Chaiienging the (we: ‘ pa$ae<j by the appaiate Sam’s ammmg tha appaa! preferred by are rasmncieat NM under Order 43 Ruie ${r} ef C.P.C. errd thereby eetting agree ihe ereer er iemperery‘ imurretien granted in fewer er ihe petitieeer by ihe trier Cum: 14, (2) The pieintifreipetitienere have fired the euit far eeeraretrerr ef titre and permeaeni injurmtien.. Aieng wéth the eiairrt en apprieetren meter Greer 39 Rete‘ i 8: 2 ef QRC. wee eiee meved fer reeireining the eefenderrt. rare, 1 freer airerrarirrg the sue ereperty eurérrg peeeerrcy ei ihe euit. \ 1 {3) Aceerdrng ta the pQerntrffe, re the meeetiee erder dated 23438— 4 2&34 eeme ef the pieintrffe were recerdee arer‘rg with the rreme er V*defendent Met theugh the eeid defeeeent Net hee he rtght, titte er t K \ GQ intar3$t ave! the wit magem. lt waa stated ihat if tha defendaat NM aiienate$ or GreateS third party intereat ii: tha Suit pmperty there shat! be maitipkigiy ef Eitigationi theremm the defendarxt NM $hauld be restrained in dqiag $Q wring parademy af the suit. (4) The défendani NM damea ihe wegatiam, hewever in mm Q $€ this \mmen statemeni ‘:t ha$ been 5€ate§ that $ha dee$ mat wigh tn alienaie the 3% pmgagty anti that Eahe i3 if: §GSS$$3§m 0n her awn . r§ght (5‘ The ma! $m$ by itg ardE§ éateii 25-10—20G8 (Amexura P52) aiiawed the prayer fer temperary iniuactien after freeing that the pteimifte have e prime feeie ease in their taveur and if the defehdant NM atiehetee the we erepert‘y er efeetee third eerty intereet, pteihttfte ehett stiffer trreperehte teee. \‘I (5) The appetiete ceeh hee eetvaeide the timing reeereed by the the! Ceurt wttheut remitting any timing ae te haw the exeretee ef dteeretieh by the that (hurt was; hot in eeeeteehee with iaw at the tinet@ teeeteed hy the the! Couxt eh the teeue et prime fecie eeee, betenee ef eehvehtehee ehd theeereete teee are emitter; and mehiteett‘; itteget: m tn the mettef cf h’ehee: Lie. am! Anethe! es. Aetex midie R Lien teperted th 1999 {Sweat SCC 72? the Heh'bte Supteme ester! has helé thee in paragraph 1e of the repert. “14, The ameals befme me Disiisian Beach were against the exemise 0f diygmtian by the SiiigéE .juiiga, in twat: aypaaEi the appe§iate cam Wm net imer€e¥e with tha exemiga 3f d§$me§ian Caf we cam 3f §r$t §rx$tame am sgmtitzita its; mm £§§$cra km exsept where ihe diiametian ha$ betan Shaw it; haw: b$en exemi$$d arbirarii‘y, ix capric§3§3$£y car gewergew at where iha Giana had ignered thE: Saretiiaé :arimipwsa crf iaw faguiatif‘xg grant a? {efu3ai af interioamovf inguncticna Fm appeai againgai exemise of diggfetiafz is saici ta ha an appea! an grinsip!e, AggeiEie 2mm, wiH mt rea$3§sg the materiaE and $eek ta mash a cunQSu$§§a digeferzi fmm me aria mashed by {Fag mud belaw §€ the we mashad by that mm wag reegmatziy mime cm tha maten‘aL The appe§£at3 cam woulé numia§§y mt be §a$tifxe§ §n inte¥feriag with the exemi$e 3f di$cre§ca amia appaa! $Q!e§y rm tha gimad th‘ai if é‘; haa' cumizidered the maaéf at the ma? siaga it waaid have came ta a mnkary camismSiDn if the ci§$x3ratim ha$ been exerci3&é $5; ihe in'ai mm reasana’éi‘; am: in a waiciai ' mama? the am that tha aigpeiiate smiri weak}. have iaken a ££EffEfeni viaw may mt §i33iify §aie§e¥eace with the triat matt’g exgmiiaé at titsctettan. Aftat tatén‘trtg ta tha$e pttnstgttais. Gaiettdtagatikar, J. it: P§§t2¥$ (Myswfe) Privatté Ltd v. Pastas; Jaseph‘t {?9§{2} 3 SCR 77‘3: (86R 7’21) Q? Thegze ptirmt§te3 ate weti eetebiiehed, but a3 he's Een abeeweé by Vieeaurtt Simian tr} Cheese Geeaten & Se; ta Jhanatoa 1942 AC 139 ‘mthe taw ae ta the tevereat by a mutt at aepeet Qt at: meter made by a iudge beiaw tn the exetetee Gt his disstetiim ie weii eetabiiehed, and emy " di :ietiity that eriees ts due enty ta the epptteetien ef wet: \‘ eettted erinctpiee ta ee indivtdttet eeeei" _41— The appei!ata §udgment 6:093 mt $eem t0 éefa ta Ws pfimigia.” (8} Agpty§rxg thé pfincipies in the masgnt saga it §$ fmmd that the appeiéta Cami has. appreciateti eniim materia! wheat recording any §n<1iiag 3% £3 haw emrcisa 6f discreiian by the tfiai Ccurt i3 mt m acnmrdansa with kw a? $uffer3 from inherent emit §n exemise 3f cié$c¥giéea Si hat; baen hetd by the Hm’bta Supfema 8mm in the mattax‘ at t‘t‘amief Lié. am? Ahathér {$upra) that ah appeat against éxersise cf éiwrgtian i3 an appea! an primipies; and that the appeiiate Cami; shauid net inte§€eye uniegs it fin€§$ that the hrda pa$sed by the Gcurt 0f hm: th$tance tn exerchte at tth dihcrhtianary jurisadiettah t3 amitrary amt that m} feahahahte {Ethan at Gtdthan; pmdenge wuutd am‘va at the hhrtthg remtdeci by the that geurt‘ (9) Even ethewxziee, the etatement made by the defendant Net in pare 9 ef the writteh Statement eheutd have weighed with the eepetiete Seed; in deciding the apeeet, hewe’ver that pelt at the pieedihg has etee been igner$ by the eeeeitete Qeett (t Q) Fer ett the abate teeeene, the instant petitien uneet Artiete 22? at the Cenetttetten at theta deeewee tn he and te hereby eiiewee: The impugned. enter ie eet—eetcie and the Greer gassed by the that Cetnt te reetered, (1 t) hte erder as. te mete. Sdk Prashant Kumar Mishra 7 - .Judge