i ktsudteli 'tt-:-L HIGH COURT OF CHH^TTISGARH AT BILASPUR WRTT PETmON No. 1422 of2001 PETITIONERS 's'Ba. r'"9s ^ 1. B.S.P. Kannehari SaUkari Upbhokta Bhandar Maryadit, Khursipar, Zone-2 (K.L.C.) & Zone - 3, Bhilai.Rsgn.No. 2143 Throu^i Its President Sht-i R.B.Sin^i, aged about 61 years, S/o Late Shri R.K.Singh R?'o Khursipar, Bhilai, Distt.Durg (ChlMttig^rh) „. 2. Jai Bajrang Prathmik Sahkari Upbhdcta Bhandar Maryadit, Balaji Nagai, Klnirsipar, Sector -11, Bhitai, Distt. Dure, Reai.No. 2/239& . : , Tlu-ou^i Shri Buddan Tliakur, aged 51 years, S/o Shri Dilochand Thakur, R/o Khursipar, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (Chhattisgarii).; > ^ ' „ 3. Jai Dursa Prathmik Upbhokta Sahkari Bhandar Maryadit, Paehari Para, Durg, Regi.No. 2/2385 Throu^i Anil gjunar Shau, aged 31 years, S/o Shri Kundanlal Sahu, R/o Pachri Eara, Diu-g, t. Durg (Chhattisgarii) r 4. Apna Prathmik Sahkari Upbhokta Bbgnte Maryadifc, Ward No. 10 Slwiiti Na^r,^ Supela, Bhilai,Distt.Durg(CBiattis8arii).,^ j Thraigh Manager Awadhbihari' Shali, aged 42 years, S/o Shri Moticfaaud; Sha^ RA> ,A{$roac Road, Camp-1, Bhilai, Kstt. Durg (ehhattisgarh) 5. Shakti Prathmik Upbhokta Sahfcari Bhandar, Sharda Para- Ward No 23, Hiilai, Regi.No. 2212, ,.,, • , -:: ".: : :• .;:::::, "' " ;'!! ;::: -" Throu^i Its president Jai Kumar Gupta, aged years, SA> Shn Juglal Guptc R/o SiiaidaPata, Camp-2,BhilatDigtt.Durg(e.G.) i 6. Adarsh Pratliamik, Upbho!flta SaUkaii Bhatidar, Bhilpara, DurgRsgi; No. 2404. p j a Through Manager R,ajjeiidr^Jau^,agea 4%,}Eears, S/o Motilal Jam, R/oGanjpara, Darg, ©istt.Dure (C.G.) ;;.::' :. :. :•:.' r ;,;;:<,, 7. Mamta Prathniik Upbhokta Sahkari Bhandar Maryaflit, WaniNo. 25, Durg.Distt. IVrg, Regi; No. 2/2396 .' -.• .. -..:i-. ..i:.:--.,- .- Through Shiv Kumar Tamrakar, aged 45 years, S/o Late Shri Ramswaroop 'Taiwaka^R^a SsSw Bazar Ward Dwg, Distt. Durg ^'.O.) •. , 8. Shri Santosh Pi-aftauk tyA<Ato SdAari Bhandar Maiyadit, Sheetal-Nagai, Wani No. 3, Durg, Distt. Dwg,'Regft.~No^2/'i414_^"jy:' Through Shatru^ian Patel, aged 33 years, S/o Sfari Kisl ilal Patel, R^ Baigipara^JNg, DStt. 'Dwg(C.G.) - . ,. :..' 1 ;'::., 9. Deepak Prathimk U{*hokta Sdkari phassdw, S^dcari Bhandar Maryadit, Deepak Naggr, Wanl No. 15, Durg. Reg. No. 2/2399 ; Through Vijay Jaikare, %ed 29 years, S/o Stari -2- i^? RE8PONDENTS : 1 Ramadhir Jaikare, R/o Deepak Na^r, Ehirg, Distt.Durg. , lO.Teen Darshan Mandir Pratfamik SaUori Upbhokta Bhandar Maiyadit, Camp-l,Bhiiai, Regn. Na 2/2394, ::, ;: 1:, ' ::.,::-:L \,,ii!"s^ Through Maimu Mishra, aged 48 years, S/o Late Shri RameshwMi Mi^lra, R/o Caaip-l,;JaleW Chowk, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (CUiattisgaAl , 11. The Consuniersl Co-op. Stoere IA1, KtoRipar, Zone-2,Bhilai, Rsgp. No. 1838. ,. Thtw^i Shri V.V.SSurtoman^m,' aged 51 years, S/o Shri B.Kainesbwati»Rao, R/a Khursipar, BhUai, Distt. Dufg (Chhaftisgarh^ " ; 12.0um Ghasidas Nagar Pratlmak Sahkai Upbhokta Bhandaf Maryadtt, Quru Bhasiflas Nagar, Bhilai, Distt. Durg, Regn. No.2/2593. Thraigh Bharat Bhushan Pandey^a^d ^S ypare, &/o Late Shri Setu BaB<lhuPandey,i;{yo<3hasidas Nagar, Housing Board, Bhilai,»j.Efett. Qurg (Chhattisgarh) < - • • IS.Prathmik Vpbhdktsi SaMcari ,BhandM» Supela, BhilM, Regn No. 2207. ? i Through Its pr^ident Mohd, Oliaus, .ag^l 43 yesas, S/o Mohd. lyakoob R/o SuMash ChwA, Supela, BUN, Distt. Durg(C.G,):",. ' 14.Laxnii Prathmik Upbhokta Satdari Bhaadar, Charoda, TTnpu^i QmprAaA Ayxw^, aj^d 'Sf years, SA> Matadeen AgrawaI,-RA) CSiaroda, Distt.Durg(C.G.) . , ' * ;° i 15.Prathmik Upbhokta Sahkari Hiandar (Model Town), WardNo. 1, Bhilai. , Throu^hi Ishwar Sao. aged 42 yesss, S/o Late Hari Sao, RA> Ea^ Ndiru Na^r>(8(09, JEhilai,' Distt.Durg(C.G.) » . VERSUS ,,' ; State ofCUhattisgarh Throu^i its &cretary, & Civil Supplies Departmetit,. GgPt. of Chhattisgarh, Raipur(ClA.)-.* ;« s < 2. Director, Food i^ CjyiB Supplies IRepartpie Govt.ofChhattisgarh.Rayur (GUi.) • ;. 3. Food CotitroUerCoUectQra^!t)urg,DiStHietE)uri (Chhattisprh) ^^^^^^^^ ^ 4. Viiiod Sin^i, Zone 1, Sector,ll,^Bhna, W^d No. 29 Bhaai,Du^(Chh.) , i: . ,;, 5. Ku. Kiran Tiwari, New Khursipacjyariset,, Ward No. 36, Bhilai, DistOut^; , * a 6. Shankar Lal Bachor, Polsapara^ W^! N% 23,;; Durg(Chh.) s 7. Baba Sin^i Ward No. 19, Vriada N^at, 0hilai, DisL Durg. ::,- -. ::,,„..,„ ,,„(;;( ,.,.;. 8. Kapil Dev and Ranwshadiw SundwNagpr W^-d No.22,Bhilai,DistDurg. . . ; t s fll1-;:-.:« -3. WMT PETmON UNDER ARTICLES 226/227 OFTHE CONSTrTUTION OF wm/e: •/- - -1; • '* -: --A — SB: Hon'Ue Shri Sattsh K. AenfhoW. J. Present: Shri Siashank Thakw, Advoeate Eq>pearingonbehaB'o£SIm, B.D.Guru.Advocatefifftitepetitibners.; 7; " Shri Rajendra Ag-awal, Panel Lawyer for'fiie KateA-espondent No. lto3. : ^ :- - ;;! .! .;!: ' ORALORDER (Passed on 02"' day of Septeni^er, 2008) . ' 1. Leamed eounsel appearing for tfae petitioneis subiaits tiiat flus petition has become mlructuous. Learned counsel appearing fin-i'the oftfir side does not cantrovertfhe said subniigsion. 2. Accordingly, the petition is disniissed as havicg bec<xne infiTictuoiB. No order asto costs. C—3 3. ItrterimreKefgrantedon 28.08.2001, standsdischarged. . Sd/- Satish K. AgBlhatri Anril Judge