1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY O. O. C. J. Chamber Summons No.1158 of 2006 In Suit No.4186 of 1999 Uniport Computers Limited. .. .. Plaintiffs v/s. 1.Wockhardt Limited & ors. .. .. Defendants And Karnataka State Industrial Investment & Development Corporation Ltd. .. Respondents Mr.B.V. Phadnis for Plaintiffs. Ms.Kranti Hiwrale i/by Harish Joshi for Deft.No.1. Mr.D.A.Shinde for Deft.No.4. Mr.Sachin Kudalkar i/by Madekar & Co. for Deft.No.2. ----- CORAM : SMT.ROSHAN DALVI, J. Dated : 11th February 2009 P.C. : 1.The Suit is filed for recovery of a sum of Rs.56,56,60,674/- which is the loss suffered by the Plaintiffs as occupant of the building which collapsed allegedly because of certain defaults on the part of the Defendants. 2.The Respondents desired to join in the Suit as Defendants. The Respondents advanced the loan to the Plaintiffs. The hypothecated property is stated to have been destroyed. The Respondents' cause of action is completely different from the 2 cause of action in this Suit. The Respondents would have to sue the Plaintiffs for recovery of the loan amount as required. The Respondents may claim from the Plaintiffs any amount recovered by the Plaintiffs upon execution of their decree as and when obtained. The Respondents are not a proper or necessary party in this Suit. Hence, the Chamber Summons is dismissed. (SMT.ROSHAN DALVI, J.)