1 D.B.Civil Special Appeal (Writ) No.DR(J) 4646/2008 The State of Raj. & ors. V/s Smt.Puro Devi 26.8.2008 Hon'ble the Chief Justice Mr.Narayan Roy Hon'ble Mr.Justice Sangeet Lodha Mr.N.K.Mehta for the appellants. Heard counsel for the appellants both in limitation matter and also in appeal. Delay in filing this appeal is condoned. This appeal is directed against order dated 11th July, 2006 passed by the learned Single Judge of this Court in its writ jurisdiction whereby and whereunder directions were issued to the State authorities to pay the pensionary benefits to the petitioner being widow of deceased Lakharam. Husband of the petitioner Lakharam is said to be employee of the work charged establishment. However, on his death, pensionary benefits were denied to the dependants saying that he had not attained the status of permanent employee. The learned Single Judge of this Court, on consideration of the pleadings of the parties and relying upon the judgment of this Court as rendered in the case of Sujan Singh V/s State of Rajasthan & ors. reported in WLR 1991 (S) Raj. 340, treated the deceased as permanent employee as he had completed ten years of services and thus, directed for payment of pensionary benefits to the widow. The findings recorded by the learned Single Judge of this Court are based on a judgment wherein it was rendered that an employee of work charged establishment having experience of ten years would be treated to be a permanent employee and he will be entitled for all the benefits to be given to the regular employees. In the light of the judgment as referred to above, the learned Single Judge was wholly justified in exercising his 2 discretion and passing necessary directions. The order impugned, in that view of the matter, cannot be faulted. This appeal accordingly is dismissed. (Sangeet Lodha)J. (Narayan Roy)CJ Parmar