IN IEB EIGH GOUBT OF MffiHTA PE-ASBSH AT JABALPUK y'.p. No.u'B7y of 1995 Petitioner: K Bespondents! 1 ^slf Jogender Prasad Saa, S/o Late G. Sa®, Aged about 38 years, Proprietor of M/s. B.K. Brofctiers, Sontractor golony, Sirsa Boad, Supela, Btiilal, Oistrict Surg, M.P. Versus State of Madhya Pradesb, Tbrougti the Seore-fcary, Department; of S'ood and Givil Supplies, Vallabh Bhawan, Bhopal, M.P. 2. I'ae 30'amissioner (Bevenus) (Food and Givxl Supplies) Eaipur Division, Eaipur, M.P. 3. The Additional Sommissioner, CFeod and GiTil Supplies), Offlce of the Goimiiissioner (Bevenue), Baipur Diyxsion, aaxpur, M.P. '+. I'ne Dis-briat Magis-trate-cum- GaUector, Durg, (?ood Branch), Distria-i; Durg, M.P. ITPEII_TKN_XjIiDBB_ABIISLiSS 226 ^AND 227 OF TEB SOSSIITUTIONOF INDIA (/H XI-HC-78 *11*1c91 ^^TT^ vjuc) -^litlri^, u>-al'<-t<i<s, fsirtK-iy .^.f....'vo:...^n^. 3IT^9T IRcp (ijc|(jc|<g) an^sT'RT R-ii* aaiTan^?Td>*ii* swTSRTriinsii^sT <bl<<frt41'l *1WriT^'!^CS '(Rltci'f ^srf^qSR^CT '• A J.«< Shii P. Diwakai', Sr. Advocate for the peutioner, Shri Saiideep Diibey, By this writ petition Constitutioii of India the p< pi'oprieh' aiid coiTccttlcss of ( Advocate witll Shri P.R, PataiLkar, UOVt P-6) passed by tfae Appeuat^ 20.4.1995 (Aimexure P-4) v^ cum-CoBector, Durg whereiji holdiag the petitioner heref condition Nos-,3 (l), 4, 6 (1), $ Kerosene Licensuig uraer, Tirovlsions of Clause 3 i'2'1 of Ceiling Price Order, 1993 p 10 & 14 of the above Order, as forfeited thc securiff aiuoiii tSnet lacts relevant loil that fhe petitioner is propri^ name and sh'le of M/s R.K Bhilai, District Durg. The busiacss of salc and distribit uncier me ucense gi-antctl to 9.2.1994 tbe Additional Colt witli Food I.n.soectors Shri ovt. Advocate tor fhe State. under Articies 226 >*» 227 of €ne ititioner bas questioned tlie legalir;-, Iic ordc-r dated 15.1 1.1995 (Auncxui'c Authoritt' affirmuig tlie order dated bv leanieci DlsQ-lct Magistrate- 15^.33€d. »v lesi'D.ecl Disuict M>i"istra.te ^tter 'pa guilty for violatioii of licensiag Stf 'l \ Ct fr~^\ <?_ r^; /~l"i.-.; i.-t-_,.^ ;'^ -"- "! ^ ^. f ?';-T O <P(IJ, Q IA} c?u y. ^iauses y <% lu 01 ivi,r', 11979 aiid also tbr violation of tfle tjtie Registrauon on Use smd Fixation of pi[inished- the pentioner under Clan.ses .979 and caja.ceUed the Uceiise as well ii|iit dcpositcd by thc petitioncr hcreiii. ftie disposal of mis wiit peuaon is ttor of a IB-EU fLincnonuig luicier the proth.ers^ Contractor Colony; Supel£,. oetitioner's lii'in. is eagageti ui Uie [tion of kerosenc oil thiough hawkcrs (Iie petitioner by respoiident No.4. On tector, Diirg Shri G,S. Mishra aiong IB. S. SliajtTQia. RO.d Shri T- C. Thv^ji - ^^& _ XI-HC-78 ^ssf^WcW, yTfl'<-i''i<s, (s!rti'<-iy'< /;— / ^ :-ii-:: *1|ttriig?'TT^ sn^ST IRR! (Ljciijd^) 3ii^?iti>iR-ii<h aanan^ng^itiR <piiFn<i1i iMc'i'f^fe^ <[^|<<i|< ^Slf^TfSIT^ST Ku couducted a raid in. the pre] thereafter, on 1.3.10Q4 a s) petitioner. The petitioner si^ notice, Thci'cafte.r, thc Disb|ic 20.4.1995 canceUed fhe Ucetnse forfeiture of securitv7 acaoiutt aggrie'jed by the said ord.e| under Clause 16 cf the authority, which cainc 15.11.1995, The case of the T)etiti<t faises of petitioner's fera at Ehiiai aiid liovs' cause noti.ce V7as issued to the Ibnutted reolv to the ssid sbow cause )ict Magista'ate, Di.u-g vidc ordcr dated of fhe peritioner aivi dii'ected fbr deposited by Tlie petitioner. Eteuig ^' t!ie petitioner ps-eferred aii appeal Prder of 1979 bcfol-e the appellate bc disEiisscd vidc ordcr-datcd tb neanng was gn'en to "u" an' considercd at the back oj opportuiu.tv of hcaiiag, Tl( irregularities leveiled agains^ recorded by the District Mafe auttionT;/ are perverse anu il{ petition in the cnintinai c; lcamcd Spccial Judgc, Di^r acqultted tfae petition.er jiner is that no proper opportiuiirv of (1 th.e representation .uiade 'ov }u"i ".-as the petitioner without givnie aiiv ^c pctitioncr rlcnicd thc chai-ges of lum & his firm ancl that tfae fnidiiig feistratc and aiBnaed by uic appeilate |egal. Moreover, atter niuig ol' tn.is writ IBC arisiaa out cf fhe saine uiciclciit ~g vidc judgeincat datcd 31,1. 2000 froifa aU tfae cliarges ieyelled againsi rhe petitioner. i have heai'd Seamed c LrSS.mecL iSiAa TL^GUIISG. iiuisel for the parties. >r the petitioner subiaitted that the iiier s liccn-sc ha.s beeii caiiceUt':" aiid chargcs oa which thc pctitij securin' amount faas been fibrteited were betbre tiie crimtaa! Court XI-HC-78 ^T?q.^iiqirt«,y>-nl<<-i«i's,Rrtmy< sn^^TwR'ii* CTWSn^STiPWR sn^sTtRfEp (^ciijci^) anci the criminal Court af acquitted fhe petitioner vide P-8) holdiae that ail the c1 pctitioaer s pctition dcscives On me other ba-nd, State Shri Dubey supported Ha\"ag hear3 learaed the •writ petition and judgin< Spccial Judge, Durg, Penisal of judgment. q to prove the charges again^ liceiisuig conditions and fh.e bcen nientioned ia fhe judj Ordcr of 199.3 ai'c not attiacf so tar as Uie ylolation ot J14 8(1), 8 (2) & 9 is conceiiiecl tfa.e spme. Therefore, after the conclusioii that fhe chat not provcd, As such on t passed by t&e Dlstrict Magf passed b}' the appeUate auflji I:n tlie result, tlie pe| uapuencd orders dated 15, {Axiziexuz^ P~^l'i sre licretov Certiiied copv as per 3)1 <pl<l[n<Tll *l!*<rtTif)3'<SI 'iRl+dl'i! ^3if^T31T^?T ter recording ffae evideuce of.parties judgnieiit dated 31.1.2000 (Aa.nexure Israes are not Broved. Theicfore, Uie to be aUowed. leamed Govemnient Advocate Ibr me Ithe itap~dgned orders. •ounsel for the parties, i liave perused [nt lAnnexure P-85 rendered bv leamed jhows tfaat the respondent,/State failed |t the petitioner's firm for violation of provisions 01 tlie Or'-ifir of 1QQ3. It 'XRS fcnieat fhat on facts the tirovisions of Itcd. It has furthcr becu ineudoued tliat ;nslng conclitlons Nos. 3 (1), 4, 6 (1), the State has uot beeu able to prove rial ieanied Special .Judge reached to ^es leveUcd against the petitioner were cl^is grouiid, thc ordcr datcd 20,4.1995 itrate aad the order-dated 15.11.1995 .ufllLority are liable to be qiiaslied. ition of tbe peutioaer is allowed, the 111.1995 fAanejnu-e P-6) & 20.4.1995 laslicd. , uies. ^. Sd/- L.C.BHADOO Judge