1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION CHAMBER SUMMONS NO. 4 OF 2007 IN NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 1363 OF 2005 IN SUIT NO. 5101 OF 2000 Hasmukh B. Shah ... Plaintiff. Vs. Bharat M. Vakil & Ors. ... Defendants. Mr. Vipul Shukla advocate for the plaintiff. Mr. Bharat M. Vkil, defendantNo.1 in person. CORAM : A.A.Sayed, J. DATE : August 7, 2009. P.C. 1. Reply filed by the plaintiff to this Chamber Summons is taken on record. 2. This Chamber Summons is taken out by defendant No.1, who is appearing in person for the following reliefs :- 2 (a) that the plaintiff be directed and ordered to produce the Ration Card with all the pages relied upon by the plaintiff in the plaint of the above suit in this Hon'ble Court. (b) that the plaintiff be ordered to produce true copies of litigation being the Ejectment Suit filed by the Landlord of Radha Niwas in the Small Causes Court at Bombay against the plaintiff. 3. Insofar as prayer clause (b) is concerned, the plaintiff has not relied upon the Ejectment suit in the present proceedings and , therefore, the question of production thereof does not arise. 4. Insofar as prayer clause (a) is concerned, the learned Counsel for the plaintiff states that the inspection of new Ration Card has already been given to the defendant No.1, and so far as the old ration card is concerned, he states that he has copies of only the first page and the last page of the Ration Card and inspection of the same has also been given to the defendant No. 1. 5. Defendant No.1 relied upon the decision in case of M/S. BISHNU BALLAB PANDA VS. FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIA reported in AIR 1979 NOC 92 (ORISSA). 3 6. Since the proceedings in question are not relied upon by the plaintiff and in view of the fact that the inspection of theRation Card is already given, the authority cited by the defendant No. 1 will have no application for the purposes of the present Chamber Summons. 7. In the circumstances the prayers of the defendant No.1 cannot be granted in this Chamber Summons. 8. Chamber Summons to stand dismissed. [A.A.Sayed, J.]