R PETITIONER as Umesh Tirkey, S/o. Tirkey, aged about 53 Executive Engineering Mamahi, Distt. Bilaspur (C.G.J VERSUS / State of Qhhattisgarh, Through its Secretary, e? h \, {)9u x ESPONDENTS : l. Engineer, Service, Panchayat Development, D.K.S. Raipur (C.G.) Chief Engineer, Panehayat 85 Rural Development 2. / Department, Engineering Service, Vikas Bh Raipur (C.G.). Late Julious years, working Rural Division 85 Rural Bhawan, Rural aWan, ‘ ) PETIT§GNER H§G§é sSiER'f w: QEHATHSGARH : $1LA$PUR / WRH’ PETWEW‘é {$} Nil4$$5 G? 20$§ Umegh @‘iikey Vefsus $ta'ie cf $M;ai%isgaa'h & Ama€her ‘ iWa’R petition uracier i-‘.r%§cie 225 of ihe: CmsiEmfior. a? £m§ia§ ' i 5§ngge Eench : Hen“bie Shri $aiJsh K. Agraihotri J. 9fese'aat :- Shri Vimci 335%mukh, suunst‘ai fer i‘he jaeiiékmei’. Shri AV. sridhar, Panei Lawyi‘ar ‘Em ihe 3%&‘te. RESPGNDENTS su; GRDER gRg {Passed on this 3’ a'ay of Eécember, QWE; t 1' Wii§i ihe can$en% of §eame€£ cmmsel a§3pea€§ng fm’ "me gaemkma, the peiiwm is hEard fma§§yx The §et§tiene§g by thig peiééian; §m§agraS the 2ega§iéy mad? vaikjEfzy of ihe arder dated 2??-$-2i§i)§ mimaxwe - ?i‘§}’ whereby ihe pewmner has be&n‘fransferreii from Mamiahigé D§smci Bilaspus‘ to Eijapus'. “Hm pemimia E339 impagns ’ihe ordef da€ed $-3-2w$ §A:mexure — WE} where§3y t‘fga" represeniaimn submitted by him Ems beg-2n {e§&cied. Learned counsei appearing §or €he pe‘&§ticmes" $u§3méts %hatf eari§er by criier daied 3a-$-2!3&3 {Mmexwa - W3} t??? @et§€icne; was posted 3% we presem piece sf peeting Lei %§?arwah§, meme: 33%aspw. Tixerea§ien byrimpugneé ewe! datezi 2Y-5-259§ {Ai‘u’aexwre — FIT;- he was iramsfea'rea‘ fremt' ¥é3amah§,‘ Sisiriei 5§§ars§m §16 8&japur. The imeugned imne‘fer‘ order is centrary te me ‘zrar‘asa‘er peHcy} as if; ’éhe ‘trenefafi pc3§cy §€ was pwovided that in nerma! sewse an emweyeei shomd net be trans‘.‘ened, if he has :‘mt‘aempia‘ed 121/2 years: serwce m a pamcwar piaceef pasiihg whereas En the pfeeeME case 4che impugned transfer amer hae beea passeci wiéhin ai period of erie year. Shri Deshmukh, marries! ceunee} appearing fer ihe peéitienet rurther‘ subm%&s the? being aggréeveé by {he 'irarisfer 9rc§eri ated 2?-G-29€39, the petitkmer preferred a petjéiera befere tms; Caurt being WP. {S} Ne.3177 cf ZGGQ {Umesh T§rke3r v, $iate§ »\_//x«% \ d / k)t \ \ 1 It is wei§-settied that transfer is at; §nc§de§1ce cf sewice and i%‘. is for the emphyer to decide asio where a pamcuiar ‘ i eff’sceflempioyee be pcs‘éed, keepinv m View pabiic im€ewes% as ; wei? as adminisératéve exigency. Tms Cam“: ha$ i§m§€e§ i jua'isdiQiian to iniei'feie w§§h the tra sfer matter, except 3&1 the i cases of prcved maia fide, non-competemce 0f authm’ity passing the tyansfer orcka' arm! rmr being in confarm§w with I ihe ruies and ragwatmns. The peti {imweyiempiayee camwt be i c pefmii‘ied E's 'remam ai' Gne aaae fareveax Linda” the prévisions af service mks, empEei‘y‘er hae aéi ihe eewere i post an empiayee 51% a paf‘ticwm mace in View 0f mimic imeresi and adminisis‘aiWe exigemey. {See EREeyappe ii. Stare 0f Tamii iVadu and anotheig, Shiipi Bose {ihirsj and others v. Siege of Eifiar & anofiaers,‘ Siege af A‘iP. aeo‘ araazher J 8.3.Kourv and ethers" and Mahd. i‘yiasaed Ahmad v. Stese af UP. & cmersi §n Chief Gemmerciai £§anegeg Seam; Seefre! £aiiway, Secunderabad & 6t§wers v. G. ‘E’az‘aam é: Gmers5, the $upreme Cour€ Geserved a3 Linder : “29. it is weH sewed mat the Centrai Government Gr the Siete Government can awe administrat§ve inshuct§ons ‘te its servants how t6 act Sn certain circumsma’aces; bu? thai wé§§ net make such insiructions stemtary ruies which are iast§tiab§e in cer‘iaéa ckcumstaz‘uces‘ In order that such'execuiive instructicns heve Ehe farce 0? stetmory mie, §t mmsi be shawe mat they have been issued either undef the’euthe?§%y csnferred an :he Centrai Governmem or the Siate Gavemmem by same statute er andef some emvisicns ef me Caestwtise pmviding therefen $he¥e§o{e, even if there has been: any breech 9f sugh executive insimc%iens thei does nei H confei’ arty right an any member 9f the eubiic te ask fey a writ against the Government by a peiitmn under Areici 22$ Q the Cstitutien of inie. " A 1W4 (4) SCC 3 ‘ 3 (I . 991) Supp 2 SCC 65g *1 ('1 995} 3 SCC 270 3 (2007) 8 SCC 150‘ (2007) 8 3pc 212 ' '6 / /’”\x" i e f on d 4».. J ‘ ‘ Even oer§s ere s no caknge a e §mugra asr arer am air p ésaébEe §ag guiws a3 marfe c éih me m§3ugd ir me w §€m %§wwe! th § h t th pe& i aforesiate, arranting tran5fe arr. Fethe reasons as afreséam, ‘ petn d5missed. N mer asm casts. Qeu imeyim ardef med r od é e MG 3 3 e ta aasaemv. d ’W-8-2w3 i3 vaaa‘éad. Sd/~ a .ct ' Judge ' ” rnfe d an ; he e m a§ m d w r de J § l w Stish KAgmhfi I /