6?"Jjk IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR WRIT PETITION s Nog193 2009 PETITIONER Jai Prakash Narayan Sharma S/o Shri V.D. Sharma, aged about 49 years working as officer class one/Branch Manager C.G. Gramin Bank Branch Tarseenwa Dist. Dharnatari (C.G.) VERSUS RESPONDENTS / 1. Chhattisgarh Gramin Bank Chairman through Head Office Choubey Colony Raipur (C.G.) General Manager Chhattisgarh Gramin Bank Khetriya Karyalya Shankar Nagar Raipur (C.G.) WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CUNTION OF IN OSTUTI DIA. HEQH CGURT 3: CHHATT§$€E£? H : E£LASFUR WRIT PiiTwm {S} NG§2 g C)? 233% (s3 {$§?é§ geiéé‘iw una‘e? Rmde 225 0f the Cwsii‘mtiw a?" Ema} ‘Mgse Sench : Plan‘bée $h¥i Saiish K. Agmhotr§, 3. m :- 3N R3 PaieL wwsa fag ihe gaiétwxer. Q?SER um ‘ w.”- u“~ (Passed 5m Wis 4i“ “'av ¥ Noygmber. 2999) W%i;1 %he caaseni 6f £eamed caunsei aweamg far ihe petii‘ianer, ‘zhé §ei§ticru is heard fina§§y. The pei%§§5ner, byvihi's peiitian, 3m§mgns the iegaiiiy and vaiidity cf the ewe? dated 2-9-2GW (Annexm‘e —- Pfe} whereby ‘me reiitieraer has been tramferred §mm the 'Ch%aait§sgarh K’Eiamin Bank gyaracin, Taiseenwa i0 Shhatiisgarh Giamm gank Bz’amc‘n, Am§§paéat The géeihiisnc—r chaEersges the iraraS§er {mar ma§m§y an i‘ne gmamds that Ehe :ransfer cfdar has beer: pa-ssaé com’aw is the §ygnsf$r goiisy and the peiifiaae! has seww m a mxaiiie infesied aréa mr a iang period. § have hearci ieameé mufisei appearing far the pe‘§§%§mer, pauaed fwe pieadmgs am’ ‘éi‘ze damamenw appem'ieii memw. f: as a éme éaw that ifawfef pc§icy is a mei’e guideiine am’ ii is mt e§femeab§e by way e? wm m axaraise cf writ jwisdiciwn a? the Hegh Cami. "i“‘nem is no :ilega’ii‘zy cf mf'aim‘aw m ihe ardei: “fhe sama is gust proper aad Gaes mt wafi’ani any imeyfefence‘ 6f ihis Court. Egg é‘naf. as é? may, if: §s we§i~semed that iran$'§er is 2m incidenase a? service and §i is fef ”me empéeyer ia decide as‘ze wheie a pari§cu§er efficeriemgiayee be meted, keeeing in View pubiic 'anierest es we§§ “e administrafwe exigemy. Th§s Quid has é§mited garisdiciim 'Tze interfere with the transfer matter, exeee‘t in the cases of preved meie Ikfe, non-campetence e?” authefm peeeing ihe trens§er aidef and net eema in cenform§ty with the miee em {eguietione The peiii%onerie‘meieyee cannaibe eeymmee ie :emain a‘i ene eiace p) gn TETE3‘3CA‘ER Vgws =?\EBENT§ ahhaitisgam $ram§n Ba'rak 3x Ano‘hef Gowri gr: ; 5199i) ~‘ (2004; “‘ (1995) 5 V ' gzw; ; t' J 1% & ycrevef. Linde? the pmwSions a? Serv'ace mies, empiey‘er has aéi ihe gmwers f0 msi an empiewe ai a mnicuiar place in View wf pub§§2 Mares? am? acéminés:ra:ive exigency. {See E.F.Ra3i&ppa v. $fafa 6f fi‘ami! Nada 53m” another“: $hiéai 595a (Wk-.5.) mid cfhetars 1/, Sfafe of $fhar (i amtherg, Unioa cf indie arid anca‘mr v, Jagardhan Deiganaz‘h & anot§yer3, $fa¥s 0f MP. ana’ anoffaer y. S.S.Kowv and ofhem4 and Mam Masoad Akmad v; 5w? a: up, & Gthers5‘. in Chief Qammerciai Maggy! Say??? $$nf$i Railway, Secursderabad & Others y, G, Ramam :3 aéhersi ihe Sayreme awrz abserved as uncier: “2Q. §€ és wei: seiiied é§2aé ihe Centraé Govemmeni £3? iiw ${ate Government aaii give aémin§stra£ive instmciioas ta iis $awan’ts haw m as? in cwam c§$cum$‘:ames; his? 'i'hat Wm mi make weir: in$émciicns staéutoary mies whéch are gwaidabie in certain circumstances. in arder mat such execuéive én$€ma€iem$ hava the farce cf statutwy Me? Ti? mus a; $hown ihat ”may have baen §ss§ied eithef under me auihwiiy canferred 9r: '&§1e I3enira§ Gcvemmem Gr ma $3933 Gavas’nment by game siaiaia a wade?" same pmvi3ions sf the Clamii‘mtmn gravidmg therefcr. Thaefcre‘ even. if Ebere has beat any breach 0f awh exec‘aféve mstmciicm thai does mt ccnfer any right an any member a”? ihE §u§3§§c in: ¢5¥ far a writ againsf éhe Governmeni by a petitéora made! Amcie 22S cf the Ccnstitution of §nc§ia ” Even othea'wise! mere §s m3 chas‘ienge $3 the impugned ifamsfer ordey on any o€her perm§s5§bie §egai QmundE as afaresiateé, warraming interference with the impugned E'ansfer em’er. For me feasons as eferesieted, the petiiwn is éismissed a2 me r,.,r.:vv,,~Sd/‘ Q-w ‘J‘ satish‘K. Agn‘ihatir; ‘9‘ ‘ V‘yJ'udger mcéien siege iieeif. Supp 2 SCC 559 4 SCC 245 3 $90270 8 SCC 15G § bbb,d'§é g 19m (4; scc 3