Criminal Rev. No.2209 of 2009 1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH Criminal Rev. No.2209 of 2009 Date of Decision: 24.08.2011 Jasvir Singh ...Petitioner Vs. Ajaib Singh & Ors. ...Respondents BEFORE: HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE A.N.JINDAL Present: Mr.Sumit Jain, Advocate, for Mr.Sanjeev Manrai, Advocate, for the petitioner. Mr.APS Deol, Sr.Advocate, with Ms.Amandeep Kaur, Advocate. --- A.N.Jindal, J. This petition preferred by Jasvir Singh complainant (herein referred as the petitioner) is against the judgment of acquittal dated 27.03.2009 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Mansa reversing the judgment dated 14.03.2008 convicting and sentencing the accused/respondents (herein referred as the respondents) under sections 452, 427, 342, 323, 148 read with section 149 IPC. Five accused involved in the case hail from one family. Ajaib Singh, Harnek Singh and Naib Singh are the sons of Kartar Singh. Hardip Singh is son of Ajaib Singh. Criminal Rev. No.2209 of 2009 2 Heard. Occurrence in the present case took place on 13.12.2002 at 5.45 PM wherein two persons namely Jasvir Singh and Kulwant Kaur allegedly had suffered injuries, but they were admitted to hospital on 14.12.2002 at 9 AM. No explanation for late admission in the hospital for medico legal examination has come forth. Similarly, FIR was lodged after 3 days i.e. On 16.12.2002, but the delay for it is also not accompanied by any plausible explanation. Injuries suffered by Jasvir Singh and Kulwant Kaur appear to be superficial in nature as no depth of injuries has been given. PW 4 Dr.Sohan Lal has admitted during his cross-examination that the injuries on the person of Kulwant Kaur could be caused with a friendly hand or could be the result of fall. Similarly, two injuries on the persons of Jasvir Singh are in the shape of complaint of pain and remaining injury is on the vertical surface of the right thumb. Matrimonial dispute has been going on between Jasvir Singh and his wife Sukhjit Kaur. It may further be mentioned that Surinder Kaur another daughter of Ajaib Singh who is married to Balbir Singh is also living separately. Therefore, a doubt appears to have been created by the trial court. Evidence appears to have been appreciated in right perspective. The judgment sans any illegality much less irregularity warranting interference by this court at this revisional stage. No merit. Dismissed. (A.N.Jindal) 24.08.2011 Judge rp