i116h £C3uRT {)F C£HATT1$€3ARH AT 31LAS?UR Crim§mi Aimeai Na352 9f 1§§l {523: Han'ble AM" T.P.5HA§3§§A. 3} Mangd Siagh Vs, 5mm m: #adhya Pmdash {Naw Chhat?isgarh§ iii??? FOE PRQUNCEMENT QF THE JUD§MENT N $i O i?lzil$ Sd/- 'T.P. Sharma Judge Ta:‘ Valk‘ i’msem:- Miss Sharmib Sahiaghm, murmi far- ?hg. appa%§ant Aikr-Rakesh Kumar J‘ha‘ kpufy Gavzr'nman'r Advacafz for 'l'he $mm‘ Jyaéfa’IEMT {De§iv&reé an 3’“ SFaEy, 233$?) Chdiengg in Thés agmg§ §s m the gudgmtzn? 6f mnvé¢féan & timer af sanmme éaisd 19.3.1?9i $933M by ‘f‘rm i“ Adéi?§ana§ 5333mm: budga: Raigarh; in 5333mm: ‘Casg :‘~lc.124f$9, whar‘eby éL' whemunéer §eamzd 1’ ”i‘ Adzji?iena§ 5assE-3735 Juciga {iffer’ heiding Tha aggahaw gL‘EHy f5? ma affama gu§i§habia undgr Eactim 4 9f mg Expigsiva Qubsmnca$ Act 193?; {in slaw? “mg Arr”) «sgnmncm him Te undarga r§gamu$ ém§r§$9§1mgm fgr gym yam 2. CmvicTian is cka§iaryged m1 Thg gmmd iha’r wéfhw‘? {my evi§enca a? axclusive pmsassian af expigswa subsMncea 2mg 'fr-ia! Cam? has ”mnvictad £5m‘3‘amgd #ha appa§§anf as afaramaa?i9ned grid T’hemby ccmmmw magaiiw. m v . ’i Cgge: 0f mg gmsagwkm, m brégf, §s ‘rhca? an i7.4.3§, The: a§§§a§§anf was fraxtaHégg in 1mm Magi; dawn, ha ms m masgwém 9f 2§ K9, axpiwwg lég CGURT L HH&T?i$f§AEH A? $1LA$§5 H ? £ U§2 Crimina! Ari-“mi Na352 af 1993; Agpgésgm Mangm Smgh san a?’ Natmmm, agaé abeuf 37" year‘s, residem’ of viiiage Kui’akaia, Praiica S'irafion §gmdwan dis‘rrim B§§as§mr IAW} {Ntzw €36} Versus Ragggnéem Smw 9f :‘g‘ladhya ?m§!&sh (Maw ChhaWisgarh) fhmugh Gk}; Qaiga‘rh \ (13’s?) (Ncaw Ca?) {gMméaaE Apgmi undgr Sad-Em 3,74 {a} af (ii-$5,} 3B; Han‘bk: §$“T.?¢ $hwma$ *Zr_ subs‘rances (guapawéar‘) and 22 piggas of gunpawder $‘ricks w§Tham any iigensa. On The basis af mfar’mmwn maeh'zd fmm ma infurmant FER. was iadged Vida ExPIY. 5121? ingpacmr RRSing‘h (PW-3), Govammem Rmiwa‘y Fehce seJZsad fha afarasaki ar‘rkiw aleng wifh fmm irickéa? anti (me. chi? Exffi and paymen‘; maaipf Exf’ia vide ExPié. ,9cmchmmg fur sampk was gmpgmd yida ExWlZ {Eunpawdgr‘ and gunpawdar stigks wam 3$§zad fmm ge—amusad Sabbir Hassgin viéz Ema-’11. Lam? wri‘r'mn ft: Sabbir EhqE far supgéy af gurrpawdar aw gunpoyycjer sTiak$ Exv?fi4'and rmaip? Ex.?/13 were sgizm Vida EXP/’3 Reagan? bank wa$ saizgd fmm Qaawad $abhir Hamsain vitria ExPiw. Seizad ar‘richz-s mm sgn‘t far- examinm‘hn Ta axwr't am wma was found ammaaium Mirram. suifur and aiuminum mwdar 'tha axpiosiva mamrig! Vida Ex.P./1§, Smtemgn'rs 5f The whmssgs ware- remr'ded, under Sgctian 1&1’0‘? ‘rhe Cada a1? Crimina§ ?mcadure, i973 {in Shaw? "?hz~ Cada‘) and afvzr wmgia?im 0f iiwasz'riga?imn, ghargg shag? wa$ fEied hgfara the Ch§gf JudEciai Aaagis‘rmm, Raigerh, wha in mm wmmif‘md fha emag te we Caur? af Sessi-cng’ Raégarh, fmm wham §earn5d 1’” Aéditiana§ Sassiens Judgg‘ Raigarh mmhfgd ‘rha casa» cm fransfg-r far WM. In c-rdar' 'ro pmvg 'rhg guEET Lif The amusaai/Qgrpailant fha pmgaw'rign hag examined a5 many as 7 wimgssas? Thg aacusgdhppeiian? wa$ examine-d under S&c?ian 313 af Thz Sada whem hg denied the ckwmstgnms Qg‘gggring agg§rg5ir Mm and daimgd inncjcancg and faise img!§m¢ian in mg grimg §n ques'ma. g}! adducing dgfgnca witnass Déirsumm, The apge-iiam ha$ Taken dafgacg 141a? a? The Tim-3 0f maidan? he was refuming fmm vEQc-gg Kmgkah ‘m h§s viikxga by Wain am: he bcarded infmm at Raiiway S‘Rn‘icm Champa who, was iiia§a§ly armsmd by The: palim, . é. Af'fzr prcvidéng ¢p§oriunify zaf Pxecxring i’c i‘he par?i¢s, learnad lg Additiena! Saskms Judge, Raigm’h canvided s3: ' aemencad ?hg agpeaEiani 7. I hava mart! Lagmgd mumg? for Tina partiw, peru§e¢i The judgm‘ém impugnad cmd ramrti a“? :rha Mai Court 8. Lzamad mungai for ma cipgmimm whgmgn?iy arguad Tim? in ardar fa canvm? Thg upmliam unéar sawim 4 of 'kha Act The pmgacu?i0n is requinad t0 pmva Tha fag? frha? ma a§§a9ad axpbsiva mmeria! was in exciusive gt‘ssgsgmn of mg awzuanf, bu? in Th5 pmsam case, evidenca addugzd can bghatf m: irke- pmgsufien is my? suffidgn? f9? drawmg deafinim gendusian Thar 'fhg. appgimm wag 32'; axdusivg pessassim af gxpiaéiva mat§r§a§ (mfi in ‘tha absema 9f such pmve, canwcfkm af 7hr.- appaEicm? ész my? smsmimbie under #hg iawt 9, C’n fhg a'rhgr hand, tgamgd 5mm counée! sLigzpcrTed ‘rhe judgmm impughe-d érxd argggd TM? by £sdducing eviziema ?ha_pmaacu‘t§cn haa prove-d Thg exgigsivg gessessicn af exgaiwiva subsmnaes againg‘r i‘hg» accusadiappaim‘r and The ‘Mai Cam? has; r§9h?!y ccrrvm‘red & senfamad The appgilgm‘! as afar’e man‘riomd. 10in urdar +0 apymdafe ‘rha arguments advancgd 0n bahah‘ af this gar-rigs, 1 hava gmmingd “the matzricd avaiiahk en recard. 1L in the. prawn? msg, Invayigming Qfficar R.P.S§ngh (PW—3), whc- hag seizgd axpkasivg subwanceas, has camgarkallydaposed That he wa$ pos‘raé as Sub Engpe-cmr in 6avemmanT Ra§3way ,PaEca; Raigarh. Qn £71489 m aheu? 6.30 31m, Ahmdabaé-Hgwarh Expre§s Train No.133 dawn macheni a? Rgélway Smticra, Reiggrh‘ ma appaEkmf was in pQssasskjn- af axplgsivg sub$fan¢a$ §n Bcgi Ne. LEE 6299 E5. he mughf mid him and mgk him t9 Rmtway ?€>i§ce. 5m‘mm dang wi‘m wi‘mams grad seized the afar'e-aaid ar?i¢!a$ Wig ExPfé, Ha has aim aaizad passangzr tickaf ExP/i and paymgn? mcgip‘r ExP/2 Vida EXP/’6‘ He has ladged /hrl // war fhe FIR. EXP/'1 Ha has $aized latter ExP/13 fmm accused. Ha has furmer' dammed That he has sgizad ma igtfar Ex.P/14 from math-3r per-ma Sabbir Hussain v§dg ExP/g. Ha i’m dag-(ism #hm ha has eb'rained sanc‘tian far pmsacuTEm fmm ms‘rrié? §Mgis#rafa, Raigqrh Vida Ex’Pfié, Ha has further depasad Tha’r cm 2189 he has opamad szaied articies saizad fmm :Vhg accuagd affar praparing pamhmma bafare. ma wi?m3sgs andhcs mkevw samgk far examina?icn. 12,9. Chakmbart§ (PWd), Train Tickgi Chaakar’. has depa$gd in hE$ evidence That Ia? tha im'mnca of me mike, ha has cheaked #kkz'r 9f Tha accused, hg was heiding passengar ticket am was Trave!?ing §n gxprass Tram, Thgrzfar’a. he has gharggd a d§ff$mncg ef'iickaf and fine am! has issued recgip'r, a? ma? ?img—, Tha accusad wa$ in passwsian ef cartoon canmining wma paiy‘rhm pagkaw and aThar' arTiaigs. Ha haa further dapasad ma? an baing askad, The amused mic! him Thai“ he i5 kaeping #he afaresaéd articia far bigsfing hiiis and ha used m carry biasténg artichs, in his kiwi: cm3$—axaminmien, ha h9$ admitted fhm normaily hg dugs m? wrik Thg nama af 'tha passgnger in case 0f amass paymam, hm a? “rha immnsg of the; poke officer he has men‘riengd ‘the name of “ma amused. aavipmaai (PW—4) has dapesad in his evidence: ma? pdice. officiais and ‘rhe appeiiam were prgsem in we bagi, may gq‘r dawn from bog§, fhg appgHam waa §n passaggkm 9f car‘roen, pQ€§ca officiaig wek fha wpeikm? 1'0 the poHgg STm'ibn and cav‘mon “9:15 searchad. On haing saarch. 22 m 25 packaw axplesEve mamriais (gunpewdg-r) was fwnd m car‘mcn aEang with gmmwdar sticks wh§ch wart; sgizad vidg Ex.?/6 akmg wi'rh “tram T§ckef and (3m rzaipt Dafance has cmss-examinad ?h§$ wii'rxess at iengfh, bu? has. not been ablg m giich anything Vin his cresgaxamim‘tion 1’0 discmdi? Ms Tesfimuay, Sabbk HuSsain G’W—E‘}, busmassmgn 0f expimiva subsmnces, Champa, haa daposad; iri hisavidgnce fhat an 17.439 one» perwn. cam .aktng Mfrh EXPIM 3nd demandzd Z§ kg' axplasbxe a \ \2 sgbsmncgs den-g with 213i sTicks, aT4T§~§a§ Tim he was: not in passeasian ..__§'- 0f axgbsive subsmnces, thgrafwa, he gave him, 25 packg‘rs chack powder aiengwifh 25 main sT§§k5 and gavz (mg iaWar' Ex.Pl13. Ha. has fur‘Fhar depased That an fin: sacand day thg p9i§ca has saizad Ex.P!1.4 that heifer from him Wda Ex.?;’8 and cash mama back vida Ex.Pf1G. He’ has aisc admi‘rmé firm? fhg paiiae has seizad 23 kg. expkisive matariai and 45 piaces of gunpawdgr sfickss v§d£ Ex.?!11., Hg has dgpased mat ha has net given any‘rhing to ma pmxnf amuwd. in his crass- examimfian, ha; has! admi‘wed Tm? (m 114$? h§ was: no? having any :icense i m wig axpigsive summmas, Thamfgm, hg was m? iv, a pash‘im TO wits expbsiye subsmrmw m any pzr'scm. Distric? hiagisfmk J.P.Rai {PW—7) has acmrdad sqncfim fer pmsacu‘tian 9f fhe apgeiiam'. 13.143 par gvidame 9f Eabbir Huaaain (PW—5L we person came along wi‘m la??ar EXPXM. by which damand 0f Z5 kg. axpiosiva subsmnces md 25" ganpewdg-r s'ricks wm; made bu? a? We? fima ha was mt having any exgiasive substancas and aver: kg- was my? in a p-ashwn 1'0 saie. such expmive subsmrgcas whhou? {my i§can5,, fharefgra, ha gave 25 kg. chuck pewdar and E5 pigcg$ 0f pkzm aficksg To 3‘ha‘r parser: and alsa gave one chi? EicPfiS. Ex.?/13 shows Tha? my of 25 gmv and 25 baffi is Rs.332,59 which 5a§9bir Hussain was g§vga m Tina gay-stun cenmmaci who cenmcfeid him far guigpi‘y 9f explosive substancgs, aHhc-ugh Eabbhn Hmsain {PW—5) has spagtificany cEapasm‘ Thm‘ The pmsm‘r appallanf has m? ganmcwd with him bu? fha fact remain 1m? EXP/13 chi? wrH‘re-n by Sabbir Hussain has baa-e1 saize-d fmm ‘l'ha accusad along wi'rh gxpiesévg gubsmnces vitie $a§zum mam Exyla ». MeEViégncas tif D. Chgkmbar?§ (F’w-l‘), RRSingh {Pw-3) and Dexdpmsad (PW-4) gm sufficiem far drawing 'infgranm ma? thz afwzsaid arricigs ,,/ ware in pugsessicn 9f the appQMnt (dong wiTh ghif ExgP/m Essagd by 5ab§2ir Huasam, Ari.idgs sgizgd from mg apg§§am war-4:, no? chem pawdgr- and as ggr chemim! emmim‘riw rapar‘r ExPfla‘ arficies saized x fmm th'a: appzikm‘r ware exptesivg sgi’mmmgs. 5ubbir Hussain {PW-5) vé’K has smcifkaiiy ciepcuad in hig avédznce ‘rhaf (me Chaim??? Dawangan has demandgd expigsWe subsmmg-s thmugh ane- parson hm a? 1&5: Timg ha was nu? in pessiassicm gr? $x§EG$§vg subsmnaas, “themfam, ha gava chuck pgwdgr wad pigjn. sTicks m ma? persan wha mam with Eat-tar Ex.P{i-’§. There: wag m accagEan m pmva chmk pawdar La. nmv-axpécsiva matar'iai irx piace (3f axpbsiw mgnarmt. Thax dacxsmanw and avidz-nce— carmbummd tha evidanca ef R.P.S§ngh {PW-3} m ‘rhe- gffac’r ‘rha‘! ma gar-um? appgiEam was in passessizm of me afumsaid expkwive mafaria! aiang wi’rh lz?1'5? Ex.P!13 and he.- was frava!!ing in #min. 3a. 71$.Darsumm {EM/4} has Triad To expkxin ‘rhg wasance of tha appaihn? far cuThar gurggsg, Ha i5 ciasa mimiva ef Thg. appaiiam. His evidancz ravaaig Thar? he- hm Tried m haip the appgiiam 0n 'rhe gmumi of hi5 remianship. 16,1115 avidame adsiucad an bahalf 0f me pmsgcu?ian i$ sufficiam for drawing'infgr'encg that ‘rha appe?!am was i?! pesszssican exglegivg subwancw wifham any Egg-mg and Disfr'Ec? Magiwm‘fe», Raigarh have: avggardad sancticn far pmsecu‘rien in wrms of Secfian 7 9f The? Act. 1?. Afarer appracia’rivg ‘rha evidgrica avaiéabie an record, iha Via! Caur‘r has gmvigmd ma apggihm undgr §$afi0h 4 af The Ac? and sgnmngad him Ta undargc» rigemus impriwvimgn? for aver: year‘s‘ 13, As regards the qua5?ien of sgnfgnca, ‘rha Trig! Can‘t ha3 sanmnczd *ha aypaiiam riggmus imprisenman? fer sewn yamas... TM gmgem appeiignf is facmg fria§ smog. 38?. Tha gv§dan¢a 0f Thg gmsgcwien ravaakg ‘rha‘r ha wag carrying axgiasive subgmncas fer his master ané n0? for his avm use-t Qansétjeriag frag afareaaid fact 5anmnm awardzd ”m Thg appeEIan? a mquirgs mgansidamidm. 1.9.C9nsegggntw‘ ?hg apggg Es par'tb; gHqwady Cenviaim of fha aggpgHan‘r undgr Sgc‘rkm 4 g1? me;- Ac? i$ hemby mainmirge-d. Hawgvgr, sgmance 9f rigemgg imgr‘kanmen? far sgvan yams i5 aitarad t2:- rigmmus __.~7,_ impr§sm1ment far feur yaam Tag apmHan? 33 0n baié‘ he shali surren&ar farfhwifh befgm i’he 1“ Addi’ricna! Sassiarrg Judge; Raigarh for serving remaénérag par? af sgmenta imgmsad upon him in 5a5$iens Liasg Na,124!89. V T-P- Sharma Judge \K Sd/_ V\ ‘