IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA C. REV. No.31 of 2004 with C.REV. No.33 of 2004 ------ 1. VIJAY BAHADUR SINGH, son of Late Babu Gaya Singh. 2. Manorama Devi, wife of Sri Jwala Prasad Singh. 3. Lakshimina Kuer, widow of late Sarjoo Prasad. 4. Suresh Prasad, son of late Sarjoo Prasad. 5. Awadesh Prasad, son of late Sarjoo Prasad. 6. Ramesh Prasad, son of late Sarjoo Prasad. 7. Kamlesh Prasad, son of late Sarjoo Prasad All residents of Village Nekara, P.O. Muradabad, P.S. Agrar Sasaram, District- Rohtas. .......Appellants...... Petitioners in both cases. Versus 1. RAMESHWAR SINGH. 2. Binod Kumar Singh. 3. Pramod Kumar Singh. 4. Manoj Kumar Singh. 5. Parsuram Singh. Sons of late Shivmuni Singh. 6. Sumato Devi, D/o late Shivmuni Singh. (Respondents 1 to 6 are heirs of original respondent no.1). All residents of Village- Nekara, P.O. Muradabad, P.S. Agrar, (Sasaram), District- Rohtas. 7. Rammat Mian. 8. Shaukat Ali (deceased) 8(a). Kharoon Khatoon, wife of Shaukat Ali. 8(b). Usuf Ansari 8(c). Yakuf Ansari. 8(d) Rafik Ansari. 8(e) Safik Ansari 8(f). Munna Ansari 8(g). Khurshid Ansari. 8(h) Tamizuddin Ansari All sons of Shaukat Ali. All R/o Village- Nekra, P.O. Muradabad, P.S. Sasaram, Distt- Rohtas. 9. Md. Khalil 10. Md. Ali. 11. Mukhtar Ali. 12. Tejam Ali. All son of late Bibi Modina. 13. Bibi Batulan, wife of late Kalam Ali, @ Kalam Ansari. 14. Jamal Ansari. 15. Ghoshan Ansari. Both sons of Late Kalam Ali @ Kalam Ansari. 16. Murali Khatoon, D/o late Kalam Ali. All resident of village- Nekara, P.S. Agrar (Sasaram), District- Rohtas (Respondent no.7 to 16 are heirs of original respondent no.2). 2 17. Baliram Prasad. 18. Loknath Prasad. Both sons of late Ram Lakhan Ram, resident of village- Nekara, P.S. Agrar, District- Rohtas. 19. Rajmuni Devi, D/o late Ram Lakhan Ram, wife of Tilak Prasad, resident of Mohalla- Kuhar Toli, P.O. and P.S. Dehrionson, District- Rohtas. 20. Lalmuni Devi, D/o late Ram Lakhan Ram, wife of Dhanesh Prasad, resident of Village- Koshdihara, P.O. & P.S. Indrapuri, District- Rohtas. (Respondent no.17 to 20 heirs of original respondent no.3). 21. Keshwar Prasad, son of late Ramlal Ram, resident of village- Nekara, P.S. Agrar, Sasaram, District- Rohtas. 22. Devo Muni Devi, D/o Late Ram lal Ram, wife of Brijraj Prasad, Resident of Mohalla- Idgaha, P.O. and P.S. Dehrionsone, District- Rohtas. (Respondent no.21 and 22 are heirs of original respondent no.4). 23. Sheikh Kadir, son of late Gulam Rasool, Village- Nekara, P.S. Agrar, (Sasaram), District- Rohtas. 24. Ali Hussain Mian (Deceased) 24(a). Ali Ahmad Miyan 24(b). Imam Miyan Both sons of late Ali Hussain Miyan, resident of Village- Sukhara Dihari, P.S. Nasariganj, District- Rohtas. 24(c). Usman Mian, s/o late Ali Hussain Miyan, at present Amber Hotel, Station Road, Dehri-on-Son, Rohtas at Sasaram. 25. Sunil Kumar. 26. Anil Kumar. 27. Kanil Kumar @ Sukhil Kumar. All sons of Satnarain Singh. 28. Satnarain Singh, son of Durga Pd. Singh. All respondent no.25 to 28 are resident of village- Nekara, P.O. Muradabad, P.S. Agrar (Sasaram), District- Rohtas. 29. Sabhuddin Mian, son of late Abbas Mian. 30. Anssari Mian, son of late Abbas Mian. Resident of village- Nekara, P.O. Murabad, P.S. Agrar (Sasaram), District- Rohtas. 31. Maharram Khatoon, wife of late Ahmad Mian. 32. Aftab Mian. 33. Suman Mian. 34. Kurban Mian. 35. Sultan Mian. 36. Sahat Jan Mian. All sons of late Ahmad Mian. 37. Hadshan Katoon, wife of Tauffique Ansarai, Resident of village- Hariharganj, P.S. & P.O. Nashiriganj, District- Rohtas. 38. Eidan Khatoon, D/o late Ahmad Mian. 39. Rashiden Khatoon, D/o late Ahmad Mian. Respondent no. 31 to 36 and 38 to 39 are resident of village Mekara, P.S. Agrar (Sasaram), District- Rohtas. 3 (Respondent no.29 to 39 are heirs of original respondent no.11). ..... Respondents... Opp. Parties in both cases. --------- 16- 11.8.2010 Mr. Ashutosh Ranjan Pandey for the petitioners is present. These two review applications are for recall of the orders dated 5.3.2002 and 11.7.2003, passed in First Appeal No. 111 of 1974. 2. A brief statement of facts essential for the disposal of the two review applications may be indicated. The substitution application filed by the appellants in First Appeal No.111 of 1974 was rejected by order dated 5.3.2002, whereby this Court did not allow substitution of the proposed heirs with respect to respondent nos.1, 2, 4, and 11. Consequently the appeal stood dismissed against these respondents. By order dated 11.7.2003, it was observed that the appeal stood dismissed against those four respondents as a result of which the judgment and decree became final in so far as they are concerned. Allowing the appeal to continue with respect to the remaining respondents may result in inconsistent judgment and decree. The appeal as a whole has, therefore, become incompetent and was accordingly dismissed. 3. The appellants filed two review applications for recall of the two orders passed in the appeal which were 4 rejected by this Court by separate orders both on 7.5.2008. Aggrieved by these orders, the appellants preferred Civil Appeal No.4755-4756 of 2009 (Vijay Bahadur Singh and others Vs. Rameshwar Singh and others), which were allowed by the Supreme Court by order dated 24.7.2009, whereby the two orders passed in the review applications were set aside and the substitution applications (I.A. No.836 of 2006 in Civil Review No.31 of 2004 and I.A. No.837 of 2006 in Civil Review No.33 of 2004) were allowed. In that view of the matter, the orders dated 5.3.2002 and 11.7.2003, stand set aside by the order of the Supreme Court. Substitution of the heirs of respondent nos.1, 2, 4, and 11 has also been ordered for. 4. In that view of the matter, the review applications automatically stand disposed of in view of the order of the Supreme Court. First Appeal No.111 of 1974 accordingly stands restored to its original file along with the order of substitution passed by the Supreme Court. Office is directed to make substitution in the cause title of this appeal and place it before the appropriate Bench expeditiously for further course of action. (S K Katriar, J.) S.K.Pathak/