'J ^^ ii8 BJ IN THE HIGH COURT OE JU0ICATBRE.jQEiafflftTTISGARff:M_BILASPH£ WRIT PETITON N0. S~TZ2> 2004, ^ PETITIONER: /iA^.^ ' M^ ./^T ^ ^ ^' ,?'..<? '"^/ '^ ,^4^ Deendayal Patel_ i'^(^f\><S/(^BansKaramPatel W<^J/r\ Aged about 41 years, Head Gonstable D.C.R.B. Beejapur Distt- Oantewada ( C. G.) VERSUS RESP9NDENTS:- 1) State of Ghhattisgarh ThrQugh: Seeretary, . .Bepart;ment of Home (Police) Raipur (G.G.). 2) -^Director Ggneral of Police, Policg Head Qiiarter Raipur B.'K.&Bhawm Raipur (e.G.) ,A\ \0 ^\° 3) SHpenrrfcendent of Police Dan'tewada s . Dlst-t-Da.ntewada (C. G.) ^ '{.^^^ ^^^ • Dalerod^ ...l^" WRIT PETITIQN \]mM MM£3^22&/2S^ M' CONSTITBTION^ INDIA. N-iiJ^ 1) PARTICIJLSRS OP THE i'ETn'IHNER:- As stated in cause title abiove. ~^t. . .'•••••••. . • . • • .. .••.-. --•••••••»- 2) PARIICULSRS^I^THE RE§P(M)@TFS As st.ated above in eaUse^'fci'tle. •nmBM.iS^gBSBKE l-HC—78 3^"41<41(TiAI,.^Tll*1'l$,Ia<rtl'M<j< Mw^sis............. ^ 2fiA?i wft-ii''* 's's sn^i sniw .:! ^gw^te an^i -s- for 4he M.JMSOOS ' ':, :/:. .\ : : , 1 1~'; ••': ;''' Shri Hemant Gupta, cpuiM^jfcr fhe petatiEfieT. ^in I'ank^ ^SUiwasrta^ PttaeT tawyer StatefsespoaQeixta. " I i ~ HeaTdfina^wi&lIie<x>as4^^ The pefititMierlias fited lllts^^^w^ icUewe hjia' in paxsaamsx a£'BBJ ttiaasfer oraer datat 02.8.2004 :(^u»exui»P/;l).A'-''••' ::; ' :::;''!""' " ' ''.' '.'' :' • I:'. 1': ' ItissutMiuttedbythetean^ (hoi^i tUe petttktncrwas tians^cicd^^ 02.&.3004^SK^Seeyi!gW[VoRsaspiJflSst^ &r. He aaalffisffi^ ^(Siteaiet ll(^1^ da^ 02.8.2004^iasi3Dttoe^esiucc31ed<tf^a^ Tbc same ;-lis:l in^;:eysfinice'-f^3i^^:11ie'^(peti )it^:'^^ isxtca£5ds8Sstfy\ . • ••:. /'.';": •r';:'.^'.^:t^;'..':-:':Y'':;"'7.-'''''' ^ ..^ .• ••' ; Tbc retuxn hsis beed file^ cn 22.01.2J005. It Uas bMn ^atejodol ®at;pxesarfty-^BIie^UEi3istiicA is fiteai^ ;Pdice''-LfiMX:«Sa^|;Uiigi?Su|[^iaBJlEoiia^^ Uad; earlier written a tettCT tp fhfi lasp^ctor Gtenexal ofPolice, Bastar for proviaing adcqua.te poUce fbias. ^| It has furftia' beeril cGMituuled that apart fiom llie abpve, due ^o operaition of code of coaiduct, firsfl^ dtuuig the Mwaieay^ttocti^^aaid.'QustestC^ib^Paxi^iayat elections, tfae petitioner cpuU no(| be a;elieved intiaae.tt has also bcen confimded that Baany pera^ns fpom Bolfcc Saivsc of Bastar ^iliti^^ 'RT?!^ ^ fe^ ^i'sifinsii^r % I-HC—78 sv^l 'SBI STO? W sii^tshii* \. ':i!. •'.:i- ^fflWIWtil'* ~3N"-*ll*lt«<4,'WdlwiS, .&^.i3^ 3n^!I'^H^<^^S^) wgTO ?!!% snts .~z'~ laagiB liave t>e»iaBOCTBbedto'fh^ Stete dfMaiIhyaPiaitesIi and-tlwy havc been nsBeyed for jomixig ^i<(^l<ft"i *itii<'" ^^^ T : . •^SffiTOSil^t. m MJP. Leanicd GOunsel fcr ftic icspondents si.dimits fhfft aU tl^is caascd lundiance ja iriicving <rf thepetitioner^itnne. ; I haveAfiaid ileaaaed cot^nsel fcr flui parties saSL have also perused fhe n>ra»rxteofthe n^t^^ Adnutted^ flle impiqpn^ order of^^ 02.8.2004, i.e., much after Chlhatti^Biii. •Nue ]sc>enano eacli dyteict of thfi iState was cnxter of transfa-. W was in aufhorilMs •thatIK»Winuxdi SM presum^ ftof afl^^ fhie fanitatiou of tt>e State of idmg awutediflity <rf tlie &roe in oa. titie date of pasaan^ (rf tbc knowle<4se of tBe tt'an^emng^ is avaflabte in wfaksh cUsteict Itw scenario at^ a g?an<« <M»^& xielewautxli^ofticaBBsf^^i&tij)^ Xfiamf:^:ffcpse'Saea£.^S&K'Slai^ ^^xeS^,'Q»eKat^9»w^BiMSlyo( adeqaal^iBSDce^mid^aMMi-iclievi^^^^ does not seeni to be reasoaa|de. WUea after lookiag ixrio fhe faetual postttoh so &r as avaadbility <rf (he foxce is concemed, an .!' ;'.1 .' ......, -, ../^. oider of teaasfer was passed, ((ierefore, at fhe tuae of tdievmg, a defence of scarcity offte fasce caxuiotbe tatea. Ifad^juate fbice was not available as oa 02.8.2C104 the oxder of tesm^r diould aot have been pas^ai. Tfaere is i|o nneiat ia fhis objectioa and the same is aegatival. r" •s'Si^'i^N;:^is^'N^.' ^ '^ ^'•1®^'^^''^i^K^" ^: ~' XI-HG—78 sii^n ^R RA (TqT aB^sh^i* '^^yw^,l-'a%wtB,'R<!ii«1^ 2,:2-.3 SPtCTO^Wi^ 3^H?^a^'.(^3g«»^)' ^^VT^-t)^^ ^ fe^^ §R '^'3ffilH3il^ '"..•' So fer as the other grou^ids litee Mvwacfpal^Sad PaiuSleyat electkaas axc coacertied, nowj (hosc pouads aaee aot awaalaUte because admifitedfy thosc eteiCti^as ane cwer. Gacisadcring the ovw aStf^fStaaod cucunastaac^ cftltis c6se, ^.deettt it;pioper to pass acondt|tion,nlonlaFai tfris wnt petitioa. S ^. ttteiM&eby llaected thatjif&c feaiMfer oftihe petitxater has not Iteen wained QT eaxiceBed •a^d Iic l»asaot beea relfeved so fer, IIien fae shaB be rdfewed &c^m: 'Begspur ia pursuance cf his ttansfer oniep daifed 03^8.200'1| Nocosts. ^AaaesauB F^l) withm a period of 15 days fixaa the datB of prodijctMMi ofcartifci copy oftlns Oiider before the conceraed autfapnty ^fthfi te^tQalents. Wi&;ftw^|rfciBes^ dfft^tira^ dispt^ed o£ Sd/- SunUKumarSinha - Judge ii: ,1-i^ ^.^i ^'i: