irl.alr'r* ^;7?tnh ^ IN THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OFCHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR APPELLANT (>£TITier<F^ RESPONDENTS f ~^1 ^ a7 <x-1^ Writ Appeal No. lA^ /2010 /f VVomen's Self Help Group, Grani Panchayat, Dandkarwa, Pratappur, District Surguja (C.G.), through: its President Neera Devi, W/o. Keshavlal, aged about 39 years, R/o. village Dandkarwa, District Surguja (C.G.) VERSUS ^ 1] State of Chhattisgarh, through: Secretary, Department of'Food, Civil Supplies & Consumer Protection Department, D.K.S. f Bhawan, Raipur, District Raipi.tr Collector (Food), Ambikapur, District Surguja (C.G.) Sub-Divisional Officer (Revenue), Pratappur, District Surguja (C.G.) Assistant Food Officer, Pratappur, District Surguja (C.G.) ^5] Chitrabhan Singh Sidar, Assistant Food Officer, Pratappur, DistrictSurguja (C.G.) -2] ^3] ^4] WRIT APPEAL UNDER SECTION 2(1) OF THE CHHATTISGARH HIGH COURT (APPEAL TO DIVISION BENCH) ACT, 2006 RAV. RULE 157(10) OF CHHATTISGARH HIGH COURT RULES, 2005 Being aggrieved by the judgment dated 18.06.10 passed in W.P.(C) No. 2760/2010, passed by Hon'ble Single •Judge of the Hon ble High Court of Chhattisgarh, passed in case 6f "^omen's .Self^Help Group V/s State bf m HIGH GOURT OP CHHAmSGARH : BILASPUR W.^. No. 196 of 2010 AppeUaat Women's SeIfHelp Group Versus Respondents State of eiihattisgarh&bthers WRITAPPEALUNDEESEeTtQNZd.lOFTHECHHATTISGARH 1 HIGH COURTCA.PPEALTO DiyiSONBENCHlACT.2006 ?N DB: Hoi leMr.I.M.Quddusi, Ss HoiAleMr. N. K, Agarwal, JJ. SbriMan<>jParanjpe,Advocatefi3rtheappeUaut. SIlri G. D; Waswaiu, Govt. Advocate for the respQndeuts No.S to Ee." . • . : - : . •. :. .:;:, - ^ ORDBRtoran t Passed on this 30& day ofJune, 2010 ) Per I. M. Quddusi, J. Heard learned eouiiset ^Reaniag ^ tbfi^ ^a weU as leanied counSeI appeariiig for the Fespondents No. 1 to 4/State. This appeal has been filed agamst the unpugiied order dated l8<il June, 2010; passed by fhe leanled Single Judge in W. P. (C) No. 2760/2010, dismissingthe writ petitioa, as not mauitamable, da fhe ground ofavailability ofaltemative remedy. Brief facts of the case are fhat the appeUaat, which is a self help group of wonlen, was aUotted a&u-priceshppon 7.7.2006. The appeUaat made a complaint bn 22.4.2010 t6 the respondent No.a/Cbllector that fhe respondent No.S/Assistan.t Food QfBcer, Pratappur is deiuandiiig Rs. 20,QOO/- jrom them.A copy of the said com.plaint is ffled as Aunexure A/3. Thereafter, the fair priceshop of the petittoner was canceUedwde prder datefi I4.5.2Q10 On the ground'fhat the^leinaiid. draft was nof deposited witttiil tune aad olt fhe aUegatipn df misuse of the workuig capital aad coimnittiug irregularity iadistri.buttoiiGffoodgraius. agpnf isnppnt) 'Vl'l -/PS ^^^ ^w¥^ V ^---^^ s^soo o^ SB -ispid o(j •iCiS^ ^____—3--pssoasip-8T ]rB3d<fe ^UA aqj^ •ptts^xs SAQqB sip at pagippTa spTie(s 'aSpnp 3i8tcig paTUBs^ .atp ^q passwi 'OT QZ 'acmr io8T P3^P JSpio p3ii8ndiin aqj, •Vie^pddv 3i(i o^ 3iqB{t!BAB aq {[iMarpm: oit jspjo siq^jo ^gaTiaq aq-i 'psgtoads 3Tcn^ aq^ xiiqtTM. paig ysa si feaSdB wy. as^o wt '-t3A3MpH •o} 10353 aaAig aq ^oa Heqs OTOZ 'S'frl palBp -tapjo paaSndmi aq^ '£^uovsyxB sfByaddB wy. jtq pappap pire ps-iapTsuoo sijaiia.t UIUS^TII joj uoTteoT[d(fe atp. ^il ^Btn. apiAOjd 3M 'aiojajaqj, 'patKqSTLg aq pfnoM iBadd®aq'). Saiig joaeod.md aioqM aip 'SauBaq -toj dn Ti3i{B} ^oa st j3T[ai TOiuaiftt joj TiopB3i[ddB 3TR piiB pagioads aimi aqi. Tnip.ua. pai[g ST yeaddB aqi SSBO tti :&ft.ioTffl sfeQadSe svf^ aiojsq jat(3j: nxi.ia^tit -toj uoi^B3t[ddB TIB aAOta o^ ^tiB]jaddB aq^ o^ asdo aq OS[B HIA y"(rreijaddB aqi. ^ pgsjHM snCT^s^bo gq^ guu^^^^ 's%iaro no jo pasodsip sqiieqs aaree aq^ pire p3TXtE)Jayta aq Ueqs SUIBS 3tp '.ifepo^ mo-g s^CBp gt inqi.tA paig si {eaddB aip jl •.i^uoTOTffi alenaddB aq^ MOjaq iBaddB UB atg pinoqs liiB^adde aqj, •aSEtSSTCo IB aisj.is^ilt oi. paaiioai ^OTI SJB 3M '^OOZ '-t3P-[Q fto-40:oo) oiais^g Tiottiiqu^siEQ OTiqTij q.reSs^BqTio aq^ jo gt 3Tny japtm pspTAOjd ST ^addB OTOZ.'S't'T P3tBP -taiMEO paaSndiai sip isxireSB aottis •SiiuBaqjo AtTiiniJoddo SinpiACud ^noq(u& apBTii sq IOIKIBO ssgjBqo 3Tp jo STSBq aq^ ao doqe aoud JIBJ aqi jo uoTiB{[3oaBO •^ttB^addB aiR o^ Situeaq jo A^ianijoddo Sas ^vccpioffe ^noq^iM passed aaaq seq OtOZ'Q'i'f. V^fBp jap.io p^^ditEi sq^ •|Bq^ paHiroqns s^'tareipddB^^a^ •6 •8 •JL •11