i ill!fti; ?S ? S !!!UI]!.B?WTreBBBnBB'Ba'Wn :t ^••t ^•ls-?v'^--- 9^s^s^sys"""~. v^.y"~ ;. ' c^^^^ m THB atcffl eoOTer®r^mAa'msGARHAT BILASFOR ?s^^1 (^ 1. 4. wKrrvErmsKis^ao.. or2010 fS.«.Ki^fcft)»g5. BETWEEN Smt. Geeta NayakW/o Stu-i Gaiatana Nayak, aged about 30 irears, occaipatipn semce, Muiacipal Corporation Aaabikapur R/o Behuatt MISSMHI Hospital, Siqiff- Quarter Ambikapur,Distt.-SM^uja(C.G.t. Shrawan Kuanar Uikey, S/o Mooshan Rma Uikey, aged about 25 years, occupa<aon service, Mi.uucipal Corporatum Anal»lcajtur R/o BtShind Missicnt Hositftat, SupwQuarterAnilMkapur,Distt.-Sa(^i,ga<C.G.). ^ . : . .: .•• _:"i' „;'-• _.:! ;. _;•' . '•' . . Smt. Sumta Devi, W/o Diirakar Prasad, aged aliout'35 years, occupaBon sennce, Munidpal CkirporaHon Ambikapiur R/o Ward^ No. 16 SiAfiIt GaH, AaaN&Wur, •;Distt.-Sai'su)ai.(C^.).;''.::: '.:": ^ ' •;• •'••- ;':1 ^ :1 •-..: 1:' Smt. Oi&agra, W^w OTneshy&tdi, agsd ^out 33 years, occi^ation servic^ IbNnft^^^^^^ R/oShikariRoaa, B<n ^>tB^Amlrikiqn, , Distt.-Sai^a (C.G.). . :: • ';::' ^' •• . • • ••.-•:. . " ;/V ,.-'. Smt. todu, W/o Gaurav Naya^E, s^sd about 32 years, occupation sennce, Mtmkapal CtM^oration AmlrilEapur R/o ShikariR&ad, Bota^>ara, AmlMkapur, Distt.- Sai^t,t}a (C^F.). .—< .'-•; 1: l': ' ;': :.'<:;: : . ; 6.'" Md/ Asgar, S/o Md. lalam, aged tfaout 32 ^ occupayon servicc, Miaudpal CinpOTation Amtukapur R/o Mays^nu^ aiastn Wtod No. 27, Anibtkainu-, Distt.- Sargi.ya ^!.G.). 7.' W^l^QKS^^s^fo'f.^^x^Bax^^ years, oGcupstaon ser^«, ftRinic^al^^^^^^^^ ^ TT^ [^^ 8;^ 9. Ambikapiy R/o Mayapur, Shastri Ward No. 27, Ambikapiir, Distt.- Saiguja (C.G.). Ku. Jyoti, D/o Ashok Rawte, aged about 33 years, occupation service, Municipal Corporation Amb&apar R/o MsAamaya Mandir, Mahamaya Road, Ambikapiu", Distt.- Sarguja (C.G.). Dhaneshwar Rawte, S/o Adiok Rawte, aged about 31 years, occupation semce, Miaacipal Corporation Ambikapur R/o Mahamaya Mandir, Mahamaya Road, Ambikapur, Distt.- Sarguja (C.G.). 10. Dinedi, S/o RanEigopal, aged about 35 years, occupation serviGe, Mumcipal Gorporation Ambikapt.ir 8^0 Bhathupara, Ambikapiir, Distt.- Sarguja (C.G.). 11. Shrichand, S/o Babulal A^ar, aged about 33 years, occupation service, Minucipal Corporation Aabikapza- R/o Bhattpara, ^hind Kstrict Hospital, Ambifaapur, Distt.- Sai-guja (C.G.). 12. Smt.Goun, W/& Jagbandhu Nayak, aged about 33 yesirs, occupation service, Munidpal Corporation Ambikaptir R/o Shikari Road, Bozuipara, Ambikapiu-, Distt.- Sai^uja (C.G.). ^ 13. Kishan Lal S/o Mohan Lal ImRtia, aged abovit 33 yeara, occupation serrica, Mumcipal Corporation Ambikapur R/o Bhattpara, Ambikapiir, Kstt.- &aguja (C.G.). -^" . ' 14. Smt. Madhuri Devi, W/o Suredi Sagar, aged about 35 years, oceu(»tion srervice, Mumcipal Corpiration Ambikapur R/o Bhattpara, Ambikapur, Distt.- Sarguja (C.G.). ^ '' !' ' ' ' " . 15. Sanjay S/o Mangal, aged about 36 years, occupation serviia, Municapid Corporation Ambikapur R/o Sh&ari Road, Ambikapiar, Distt.- Sai-guja (C.G.). .:A^&.fc;Kii;l;.FSiS!-fei S^.^s^i's^^sy;:'Si!SS!W!i^^s~:^.5i r-^^"^ 3 16. Rakesh Katwal, S/o Ranveer Katwal, aged about 33 years, occupation service, Municapal Corporation Ambikapur R/o Bouripara, Axabikapur, Distt.- Sarguja (C.G.). ^ 17.'' Abhi Behra, S/o Ayodhya Behra, aged about 37 years, occupation service, Munkapa! Corporation Ambikapur R/o Bouripara, AinbftapiBr, Mstt.- Sarguja (C.G.). ^ 18. Sur Babu S/o Makradwaj, aged about 38 yeara, occupation scnace, Munkapal C<»poration AabScapiff R/o %ikari Road, Ambikapur, IMstt.- Sarguja ^C.G.). 19. Smt. BuUi W/o.Late Shri PanchaBand Behra, aged about 34 years, occupation service, Municipal Corporation Aaabilra.pur R/o Shikari Road, Bouripara, AnaMsapi , Distt.- Sargig'a (C.G.). 20. Smt. SUBU W/o Vasu, ^ed about 28 years, occupation SCTvice, Munidipal Corporation Ambikapur R/o Shikari Road, Bouripsffa, Anabikapur, I%stt.- Sai^uja (C.O.). Smt. Gayatn Devi W/o Jawahar Lal, aged about 36 years, occupation sCTTOee, Minadpal CorporatMm Ambfikapur R/o Mayapur, Bozuipara Talab, Ambikapi.ir, Distt.- Ssuguja (C.G.}. Hari S/o Basant Lal, aged about 27 years, occupation service, Mimicipal CtHptffation Ambikapur R/o Bhattpara Near Hospital Chowk, Ambikapur, Distt.- Sarguja (C.G.). PETITIONERS i S:l AND 1. The State of Chhattis^rh, through the principle Secretary, D^artaent of Urban Admuustration and Development, Mantralay at D.K.S. Etttawan, Ambikapur (CG). i;£SfflSFSK5Ly;,4^^ur^B=a* ^^-^"A^ 2./ Tfae Uader Secretary, Department of Urban AdaiinistTation aad Etevelopment, Mantralay at D.K.S. Bhawan, Ambikapiir (CG). 3. ^ "nie Director,l'Directorate of Urban Admuristration and Development Department, Chhattisgarh, Ambikapur (CG). 4.' The Municipal Corporation, AmNtopur, fhrough its Commissioner, Municipal Corporation Ambikapur, District - Sar^uja (C.G.l. 5. The Commissioner, Mumcipal Corporation AmbikapUr, District - Ssu%uja (C.Q.l. RESPONDENTS WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTIOir OPCTDIA H gl XI-HC—78 *1t*ICTI Sh^tTqR d-^-<]|<ll<?iq, B-g|<H<ie, 'fs)^f|^^< ^.y.(S}tw. £GS\>/tf1o•^200 31I^?T'tra^' (Ijclijajt^) 38: Hon'bleShri Manindra Mohan S(rivastava,J. 18-06-2011 Shri Sunil Sahu, counsel forthe Shri Y. S. Thakur, Deputy Advo| Smt. Hamida Siddiqui, counsel ] petitioners. ;ate General for the State. 'or respondents No.4 & 5. Heard. The petitioners, who are ijaily wagere, have filed this petition, apprehending adverse action/orders/i|ecovery in view of the impugned order dated 23-09-2010 (Annexure P-1). j Impugned order states that recfsvery shall be made frorri the Secretary of the concerned Commissioner/Chief E^ecutive Officer ofthe Local Bodies. The order does not per se direct any action|or recovery against the petitioners. Learned counsel for the respo|ident-Corporation eariier stated before the Court on 01-12-2010 that tili date, |the Corporation has not terminated the ' services of the petitioners and th^ Corporation needs their services. The aforesaid stand is reiteraisd by learnei)! counsel for the respondent-Corporation. In view of the aforesaid s(atement made by learned counset for respondent-Corporation and consictei)ing that the impugned order dated 23-09- 2010 (Annexure P-1) does not dir^ct any action to be taken against the petitioners either towards'their termihation or for any recovery, the petition is without any cause of action. Accordingly, the petition is jfinaily disposed off.However, liberty is reserved to the petitionsrs to take f^course to such legal remedy as may be avaiiable to them under the law, if ajiy adverse aclion is taken against them by any ofthe respondents. Sd-/ ManindraMohan Shrivastava —s-^^ Jud^e a^^i^iw ws'f3nt?isPTO ^raferah-qroff if fe^t tfw5n ^arfiw ar^i