IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.4828 of 2004 LAXMI SINGH Versus THE STATE OF BIHAR & ORS 04/ 22.07.2010 The original petitioner Arjun Prasad Singh died during the pendency of the writ application. He was substituted by his wife who is pursuing the present matter. The reason for filing of the present writ application is that as per Annexure 1, husband of the petitioner was forcibly retired even without attaining so-called 58 years of age. As per pleadings in the writ application the employee still had couple of months in service since he had a right to superannuate on attaining 58 years of age and not on completion of 40 years of service. That was the reason given in annexure 1 (superannuation order). This court need not delve in this aspect of the matter raised in present writ application because question whether employee has a right to continue in service till he reaches the age of superannuation or 40 years of service was the issue which came to be decided by a Full Bench of this court in the case of Ragawa Narayan Mishra vs. The Chief Executive Officer, Bihar Rajya Khadi Gramoudyog Board & ors reported in 2006(1) PLJR 410. The ratio of that decision covers the present case. There is no merit in the writ application. It is accordingly, dismissed. shahid (Ajay Kumar Tripathi, J)