^-^••o^^<.^~v-^^^-i^<,.o^.ig^.<^<^^^ ;>^:<^;^^^'^^^ V'^^^^^^^^^^^^'~^J^~^ i.'il: Mc^ lii lli'NlllKII1 '^ w •M...^.'-^,N6.t fim ,AII»EELANTS.. ^^^M^F^^ ^' <k : ^^ SmtNi^&C^ .^^::::..i^.^^..:;.;^^^'^ A@e3;6¥ea|s,^/aE>e^n^ Mmc^Ku.^ .^IQM6n^g,D/Ql.ate}I^^^^ 11irougli:^Nat^ Smt ^yGlibsh,BQllilp:Shyatn^ '-''^?;~s^·^ ••^.^^'^-^1 ^ '^^^^•?»^^ '^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^ ^^^^emei^^ater'Tas^, Bilaspur (C.Gr.) ^^..•^ ^••"" "7 ^ESIPCMSDMENTS ^^^fiN-AyFLlCAN'TS^. ^.v^^'^RSl^..-': •;'•:. ;1/'.' : 1. ^ A SMU.C.M6di;PraMslilI6diaiidCo. ':.l-:^..^^'^^:"''.::,:l;v::.^ I^:G^dluMaj[idir^^^ ./^Di^.-:Raipur.(E.G.^^.,l,i:;'',.\:;/^,;,'^ !', :.'. •\'.'\'. .'...". ;•.',.•' '." ' ;. k^ OrientaIIris^^ /Ilir6u^:D ^^Ma^aBmldmg,JailRoad,Raipiu-(C.G.) :;MlSClLl^m^US^^ffit^3t^^ •MOTQ]tt^HlGL^'^CT/l^^^^::'.':..'^ iliia,^•-1 m £-: HI^ICOLfflTOFCHHATTIS^RHATBILASPUR DIVISIONBfcNCH: HONiBLEMR. I.M.QUDi&USI& MR.MANINDR4 MOH^N SHRIV^ST4V^. JJ. .4Dpellant Respondents MA.rd No. 569/2007 Smt. Niyoti ^hosh © Dipika ^ho^h &ors Vs Abk Kumar Modi & othe^s A4r. B.K. Chakraborthy Advocate for the appeJlants. None for respondent No.l though served. Mr S. Agarv^il, Adv. for the respondent No,2, (OraD (2rid May, 20tl) I.M. Quddusl. J; I. Heard. 2. The oppeliants have filed this miscetlQneous^^^W^ dated 12.1.2007 passed jn Claim Case No.15/05 whereby the iearned Motor AcddentCIaJms Tribunai, Bhatapara, Distrjct Raipur (fo;r br^^ Tribunal'] has dismissed the ciairff appJicatJon &f the app@!lQnt hereln: 3. Facts of the case, in brjef, are 1tiat deceased bevendra &hosh was empioyed under the empbyment of non-applicdnt ISio.l's compQ^y M/s Prakash Modi A Co. On 13.4.05 sajdDevendra^hosh;hadgonetoNTPC, Seepat on the motorcycte beahng reqistrotion numberj €604-CL-23o6 and whiie returning to Bilaspur he met with an accid'ent and SListained g.rievous jnjurjes. He WGS taken to the NTPC HospitaL h^wever, iooking to the condition of said Devendra , he referred to CIMS, Bjtaspur where he WGS deaA fteport of the incident was in the Police Station City Kolwali/ BU^pur, The clajmants LC. wjdow & dau the deceased respectiveiy,,\fj{ed claim appjication seeking compensation of •\ Rs,5,80,UUO/<B dlong with ji^erest on tiie ground 1fiat the deceased soie cdmirig-member in the?amtJY and due to his death, the ciaiman^ suffered ioss of jncoms. ^. -I...." -2'm •f'^h •:... •^;-.. <?/ 4. The Claims Tribynaj, oifter hea^ the material brough^on reCord by the parties jn support of 1+ieir respective case, dismissed the cJaimapplicatJoh* 5. It is an admitted f|^t that fhe motor^ and the deceased had borrowed the Nr|^ its owner-respondent No.l herein. Further', respondent No.l-Alok^odj has also admitted jn written sfctBinent as well ds in his depositjon before the Court that the was employee of the company narriely Prakash Modi & Company, 6. At this stage iedmed counsei for the appellant has sybmitted that rt is not in dlsputes thatthe deceased had gone fqr We work of ttie company and met wJ1+i an accident and Jn these cJrcuwstCTices, the appellants want to approach -t+se Cotnmjssioner und'er the WorKmen's Compensation Act to claim 'compen^tionagaJnstM/s'PrakashModi&Compa^ ' ' ' ^ .7. Consjdering the':facts Sjtuationl'Qnd the^prayer~'rnad8^ by leamed .coun-sel appearing for the aDpeJiants, we AIIow Will^pea! jn pw^^ set aside the findings arrived at bv learned Claims Trtbunal in the impugned award< However, Jjbert^ is Qranted to the appeliants to approo^h the Commjssioner* under 1+ie Workmen's Compensatjort Act, if so adyised. On claim application filed, the Commissjoner under the Workmen's Compensation Act shai! the questjon of deloy, if any, in the light of^he fact that t|i@ cbim appiicatjon was fited before the Ciainis Tribunal on 07,10/2005, The same was decided by the Claims Tribunal vide award l2,L2007 and thereafter the instant.appeal was fjj'ed on 2.5.2007. 8. It is that the findlngs of the Glainis Trjbuna! shali not come in the way of the Commissioner for Worknien's Compensation in forming opinion.and decjdmgth^clajm petitjon on merits, \'l- .'• . '-. • ' • 9. copyQS;pert.i^}es. Roshan/- &d/- LM.Quddusi Judge Sd/- Manindra Mohan Shrivastava Judge