//" tfc| THE HtGH COURT OF JUDICATURE CHHATTISQABI AT BILASPUR /' W.P.NO. 2kJ3 / 2005 PETITIONER y^ ;^%/ .•'^7 -ai^ ^ .* 0/ /^/ y^\ °7 ^'^ ^•^ KEBPQNDENTS S.K.Dwivedi, Aged about 38 yeara, l.l/ii Shri Kamla Prasad Dwlvedl, Piesiiiiillv working as - a Branch Mai)M||tii, Chhattisgarh State Ware I|OUH|II|J Corporation, Manendragarh, Dlsliliil - Korea(CG), R/o 217 Ward Nii<)0 Manendragarh, District - Korea (CG) Versus Chhattisgarh State Ware H(IIIM|II|:| Corporation - Through its Man(i||lii|| Director, Chhattisgarh 8tat6 V\/iirii Housing Corporation, 22 Anand Niiiidi, Mahasamund Road, Ralpur (CO) Manager (Personnel), ChhattlnjiMili State Ware Housing Corporatlon, 'i'). Anand Nagar, Mahasamund F<(III(I, Raipur (CG) Shri P.K.Garg, Junlor Techiiliirl Assistant, Chhattisgarh State Wiiiii Housing Corporation, Branch Kiii||i Road, District - Bilaspur (CG) .WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226/227 OF T±l£; CONSTITUTION OF INDIA XI-HC-22 an^rw feNisn^r st)tfi«nSfeT 3^ ^ii'!|icl'll, »Tf1wi<o, RKiwy IIHCTI inii^> 311^1^51c« —y...E;.?:cl;.^fclSH^ 200 '>'r l^<!«d sii^i ^snwafer Shri P. biwakar, 5r. petitioner. . shri Akhi! Agraival, <<ii.sif<-i41-f wicffif tecA (IWSK ^sif^rsn^r copy. Shri Awadh Tnport-hi M»> &a Thi's isan app!ication Ku. Sunita Jain, for the 'anel Lakvyer for the State on adyance courisel for respondent no.3. for urgent hearinq. Tite matter' is taken The petitioner who i^ agarn Brancn, up on Board. This interim atpiication stands disposed of. 1/2 working on the post of Branch Manager Ch.hattisgarh State Ware Housins Corporation has cheillen.ged ^he vaii'dit/ of his transfer ordar dated 18.7.2004 (Annexure P-2) t|y which he has been transferred from A^anendragarh to. Baramkejla. The submission of learned eounsel for the petitioner is that ti(e petitioner is posted in since 17.7.2002. He furthel on administrative exi'gencie^ been shown in the transferl from ManendFagaFii to Bard submits that the transfers are made , but no such administrative reason has order. Ths Detitioner has been sent [mkeia which is at a distance of about 400 K.AAs. He also submits •(hathis son namely Ashutosh Dwiyedi is studying in Class-irE in Cenljral Railway Schooi and hi's daughtei- Ku. XI-HC-22 3^? •^t'illd^, ®T?IWIS,['K'iiuy sn^r^r fewsn^r -^iWRdfiff Kiini inHKti 3ll^?l*<i|th .^;.?;..^.0...3.W.5V^ 200 <>' f^<)«d 311^1 SWIWflf^T -1-- eti is sTudyirl further submits that thel from 1 of Aprii 2005 and the studies of tl that immediciteiy after co the petitioner has made r^ as wej] as to Corporation yide Annexur^ date the representationsh The transfer is an tnansfer carinot be irsterfl same is vitidted b^ malafi against the statutory rule^ of an empioyee dre factor^ inteFference of the cour personai difficulties of fhe However, havinq con this case and a!so considei wi*it petition and after hec counse' for tne petitionei", wouid be served if a dir *i'iiT<'i''fl'f *<it)c-<)'tffcl<fl <Ri«i< ^;3lfWT3I1^T in the same schocl in Ciass-II. i- cacademic session has already star'is if the order is effected, it shali effs< of the petitioner. He further .subTii' 'ning to know about the transfe" oi'ds .presentations to the Managing Direct; t of Chhattisgarh State Wcre Housi? ;s P-4 and P-5. He a!so submits "hat -; we not been decided. exigency of servlce and the order c a Court of law uniess •il' des Qr extraneous considerations o" or the policy; The personal diffjcul-ii: to be considered by tiie employer. T'" is not pei'missibie on the grounds c sidered the facts and Circumstances ; 'ing the documents fiied aiong with 'rh ring the arguments adyanced by !;sai-n;i. t appears to me that the ends of justi-a sction'is given to the respondenta •;•: 1»» XI-HC-22 311^1 ^iT i?^N?3D^r , CTWdfer in< Rao/- T5? •<11<|1<'1'4, ®TilwiG,Rclltiy 3TT^?T^97 ^ 4-»».j%-?* *<**••'*••••*••'i**-mT 'ynn'' tllldl i*i*<l«»> ~ fire^ wifepfrrwisffffte^i^FRR ^iSlf^IT 311^1 dispose of the representc^-ions (Annexure P-4 & P-5) filed bythe petitione," within the stipui|ited period granted by this Court. It is hereby directeijl that if the representations referred to e noT iDO'd the respondent shai! disj^ preferabiy withln aperiod of certified copy of this ed of so far, the concerned authority' of ose of the same as early as possibie t?f 3 weeks frow the date of production oraer a!ongwith the copy of this writ petitiori. The trcuisfer of| •1+ie petjtioner shal! be subject to the finai decision of the repij&sentations. Meanwhiie the order of tronsfer of the petitioner ^haii not be qiven effect to for a period of 4 weeks fr'om today. 3|t is made clear that th'is order o.f not giving effect to the tranj arrer Tern the fact as to vshether the VVith the aforesaid ifer ordgr shall autonnatically iose its of 4 weeks from today irrespecti've of ^eppesentatjons are decided or not. ^bservations, this writ petjtion stands finaiiy disposed of. Consequentiy, AA.Vi/.P.i^]o.3033/2004 aiso stonds disposed of. C.C. as per rules. Sd/- Sunil Kumar Sinha Judge :ffi ^'s