IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH ATBILASPUR WRIT PETITIONf227) No. L( S2^-2008 ^ r ,"«" \;'.a: PETITIONER A'PM.^CA.NT' ^\^ ^^ ^^""' . «*" ^.ss-' : : ::'^ .2 /^. ^.^' Sint. Samarin bai, aged about 53 years, W/o Late Shri Parasram Khare, R/o ^ •• • . •.". •' ' ".. .. village Adbhar, Tah.Malkaroda, Distt. Janjgir Champa (C.G) VERSUS The State of Chhattisgarh, through secretary Ministry of revenue, D.K.S. Bhavan, Raipur The Collector, Janjgir Champa The land Acquisition offieer, Bango Froject , Dabhara r TaMsil Sh.ali.ti, , Distt.Janjgii-;CBampa. ; ^ ij?v^f. ^. The ExecutivfiiEngineer, bango ' Projecf , Dafehara , Tahsil ShaKti, 0 5. o Distt. Janjgir CKampa . C.Qntracfor Prasad and coinpany (Project works) Limifed , Hydarabad Camp officer, Tulsi Bhawan Kharasiya Raigarh WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE227 OF THE CONSTITUTION Of INDIA K 1^ MI(3H(3mJRT©Rt:!@MH^^I^SRl€Sgl!li^ffiR ^? WRIT13ETI1~IG)tsl(22@N£)^822;ffi^CT(:)@ PETITlaNER RESPONDEN'TS Smt. 'Samarin BSi ' 'Versus'' ••::." .'..^.;,;1'' :': ;.::, ,'.:.'. :Trh:e;StEite;QfGt"1fR&W;isigat'h&0tl-ie!|'s ^rit,FtetitiortyndeF^iste22I^fihf©cj^s^ti®l^ •.•ySJn@]e.Bgnch.^H@r^BI®^|iffiS^ish;i.R.^gprBil^ri^ Present:-. 'Shn •Mhis j,'®t-m»iSla\(et^^^ ^AdvoG^es^^tlie^pi^iGiner.:.'1';.-:'^^,. •: '^Shn/RK.'Bl^yfi:t^n§ aiwiygff^p:tti:^^^^ '^..'.•^ffi'^I^BMSH^Ly^^'1'.')-^^^^ \ <Rassed;'0n%rsJ28J^^a|i^%uiiit,^:(:)5' 1. ' By'fhis p^ ion,.Ifte^tjtianerseel<S^i3irej^^to^^ StSte. to.coiTjpeft^ate.tlie ^ ;^ringfkhasra/N<:?;404/1/^4/aiaWj3|i%ie^^g|as2^:e!|gS§,g^ ;1 . yseiess •for^oultF^fijeS.^^T|ie|gaE||||%||S||S|ig||iM^^ .ynder:thie^RrovisiBEis|^;fa^h^f^»ei^i||Bt|^ We';flanel^|®^6^ti|;jfsclefHS®|e^jf%@Hffii\^W|piWF^ 2. :\:;'.Earljer:::a'wtit^Rgi||ttsgl3ijS^K ^I^?|s^ - same reltef.^s: Hl0d.,,.4:UJsa®|gi^^^ {Annexure' - R/6^jaireGtecl^^|^;?!(3Bi!6t%^.^ <det6Frn?nie;the .CQTripen&atiGfn JnfergsRs ^;^^^^ ! .early as ^Rossihle preferably^ wifHjffi;:aBp®ti^ ^RE|^W@raff!fS|fT®|jgi| • ^:the^<:la{e^i^6ipt:@fa.Go^^f^h®|Qrdet.^;':& 3^:: '''•ilfrappears.thatipui^^^tig^i^e^^ ':''\''..':':'.''::':::.:'g;:J^si'%^i'.^NS ?;^^ .'. . fhjs C0yFt^;in^W;P:l^):^ Jt^p •Gtiampa:,^^siJtnitia{ejd.^^,:;;aiti^ l':'; :,Rs.41,^84/--;was:determ|FfeG)iM8|^ SWSl ^'".8;H'!, ^M:^. iiilBa "iiii'Bi ^ss^ \6SS S^^'^i ai'B:i yjiS^i BS S§j|f| ai!» <% 7. aGcountgfyig@ing'Qfthaland,thoughthesarne;ha tothe petitioner. , . . . ; : ' ^ Shri Shrivastaya.and:Shn Kotecha.Jearned Goi.insel,appeat-in§Hf6r the pefitioner,:submitthatlhe^GpmpSnsafi6n ^ a&·d6terh^ihed wifh^^ regard to'lossof(^psonlyrtotfGr.loss;(3ftMe^^ useless for the puFpose 6f culfivation.,l-earned counsel^^^^^ submitonthe'basisbfFg|mttdated^1)8-8-2p©3(Annexure-P^ Sub Diyisioiral ©ffJG6F,.Min1Mata Bango;Pr^ EhgineeF'it haS^^n f6und,tliat,on;aGcount'Gfdig§ingo the land has beert filled^with wateF^andlfebecame^ petitioner;to. utitize the 'land forjhe purpose of^cultiyat crops; , •.•:•'': :::::;:': : :• :'... '.; : :' •'••••'r^;l:::.^'i. On theofher hand, Shri Bhaduri,'learnediRan®l;Uawy©ra fQrtheSfate^submitsthaKlhsi^ei'Kwas^u&m^ra^ August:wl%f6(n:;ffi^::^Qn^as||j|j|fl0f||ga^ ;filled'l:wrthf.watgr.,%:'^ut:6sstjueiti^^;^ fourid'tffiat thtlilaiml.lBe^rrie'un-ciultivataBlB.for'e^ Gibserved fhat?thE!^8riti^oWrespG>n^nf No.5 isliablefor payrfieHiJ" ofloss.causetflofhspefitiQner^^.^- ; - .. ' ; ^ 1 have heard learned counsel^aFpieanng^forthepartieSF.^rusedr' fhe p]eadings^an3thedoGumenfsappencledth&rpt6. • ; '^ ,^^ Be that as it may, the positibn ,is:not very elear,' if ths^ land •na's; beGorn®usel^s fQF;Gultivati6n ISr ever,; ifc'^ land should tre acquired and ^a; p per.$on'ipeFrsatian u provisionsoflawmaybeaetemiineelar^paidito^ •ownerciftheland^ndispufe.;'': , ;; • . . ;.': . ••;;i .^|K^i'| ii;!:^ •A'.^ "i^ 1;1:.;;;^ l''t ;•••£; 1:HH. ;;1U'i..^! ^J^!'^ '•f-^': MWfl !i:l!H; 8. "Oh papersTiledwiththe,pleacIingstnispositiQnisnot;cleaFason date. Ifthe loss is onlyon temporary basis,fh&cljgging;area^frtay be filled by^soiltomake it fully. cultivatalsle or ttie land- may Eie acqyfred underttie pi-ovisions oflaw. 9. Accordingly; Ihe Cpllectar, •Janjigir-eiiampa, is direoleiGl to' have inspecrtion.ol'-the'ISincl-.io.clisp Revenue'Aufttorities.iAfterrewrdihg.eviGlen^ , o^portunity'of hearifig to the petitipner,take'a^ in the inteFest of the land owngr arrcl pass appcoprrafe order&, 1n aceQrdanc^ wifh lawanctoh its ownimeritS. Ths^deteW compensatieri anti;paymer({lh^eof^hall;t^.'ff^®^w Qfthre6rnCirifKsftomthedateofreGeipt6factfpyof1Bi§^^@^ :10. . With the iaforesaid observati@ns ahff direcftjshs ^ stands:disF)osec|;oT.,;-, • :. .•.::.:'::..'^'1^. ::",.: : 1'.!:;,;':1' :.::;_^_ ^s Qowri ^Sd/-- .. SatishK.Agnihotri Judge \frV Stt J J;: