ESA N038 0 2009 1 IN 111 IllGll COlJR OF PlJNJA13 I IARYANA A Cl IANDIGARI 1 IlSA No8 01 2009 Dccidcd onlia 2010 1 0 ChhotaSinghand olhers APlocllants C I C0 Vcrsus I Chand Kaur 8cothcrs Rcspondcn ts Z CORAMIONBIK MR JUSICK KC PURE I 08 CO Prescnt MrAKhlmgar Advocatc I79rthc appcllants Allslka Saril Advocate Ior No 1 7 Z KCPtJRI J 1 This is cxecution second appcalagainstthc judgmentdated 26 102009 passcdby IcarnedAdditional Dislricl Jiidgc61astTracl Court 13athindivide levhichtheappcalprclticclbytllc lo1cscnl Iatlls undcr order 21 Rulc 97 of thc Codc of Civil lccdliie ill shctl CJC2 againstthc judgmcnldatccl 3 2009 passcdbo ClilliI Judgc Scnici Divislronl13athindawas dismisscd he casc of thc plcadccli11tlle applicaliil Lllldcr ordcr 21 Rlilc 97 Cl rctd with Scctioil 15 1 021C2ls lllat llley Ilalic ll kanals of land vidc rcgistcrccIsalc dccd datcd 451989 r Parkash Om 2012.11.09 10: 02 True Scanned Copy Of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:30 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 83 ESA N038 ol 2009 2 63 1990 132 991 and 521 992 for a valuablc consideration It is lhat ciht kanals Iand was by Wailiata Singllalias 4e Wailiti Singh 179ra considcration of Rs25OO vidc sale decd lo11961 datcd 43 1989 Iand 1 kanal Ivas purchascd by Wailiata Singh alias WailitiSinghfor a considerationof RsA0001 vide salc decd No8487 r datcd 61 990 Iand l katlal I4Ias plirchascd by Waillata Singh 0 0 aliasWailitl Slneh I7orRs5001 vidc salc dccd No653 dalcd 132 1991 I C5 and landmeasuring1 kanal was by Chhota Sillgll t 1s7006Jl I vide sale dccd No984 datcd 521992 llc was dclivcred to Z the by vcndors and as such oblcctorsarC OIoVllCrS Ill o f lhcIandmeasuring I l kanals hc objcclorsplitchascd tllc abotc said land after verifyingthc rccord llotn thc Patwari 1lcte ivas 11 tlleiltiOtl I Oll regarding pcndcncyofanylltigationallegcdto bc inilialcd bySardaraSingh vcndor 1le obicetclrs arc b01121 Odc 17t i ialliablc ccllsidciatit11 em Z withoutnotice of any pcndinglitig2ili0nWailiata Sltlgllalias Wailitl SiIlgh dicd survivcd byRanjitKaur widcow I3utaSinghand RaghbiiSingllSOllS who 111CrCnCIleVthCOWllCrS Ill ol tllc sLiitIatld 1Ilcdcctcc a8811St lhc vcndors is a nullity as thc samc has bcen passcdwithout iinpleaditlg them as partl thc suit or appcalSo prayer hasbecn madefor acccptailce 01 objections utldcr Ordct 21 Rulc 97CPC and the decrcc holdcr be rcstrainedflom takingposscsslollofthc sut IailclLlildeltllc cxcculioll oltlle said decre hc su i t lev21srcsislcd It i s pleadcd thal CVCll according to the adlnlssioil b17thc objcctorsthclI 21rC IllCrCly lr2111sfcrccs lroill SardaraSingh JJ9 duringthc 01 thc ajopealancl 2111cldecisitoIlcf Clivil Parkash Om 2012.11.09 10: 02 True Scanned Copy Of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:30 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 84 13SAN038 01 2009 7 Thc objections arc hitbyprinciplcsofresjudicata 011lllcrlts lt is pleadcd lhat arc not the owners he SUlt was 61edon 121973 hc objcctors as well as whole ofthc village I1VS 111thc knowlcdgc of liligationgong on bctwecnlhc decreeholdersand 1 thej udgmenl dcbtors he objectors have purchascd tlle Iand tll ucll acl r and are nol protcctcdIll 211151 1T12111llCr SardaraSinghJlO WaS nol compctcnt 0 0 to trallsfcr thc propcrtynor hc was thc owlncr o tnhesanlc It JS Iurthcr I C5 contendedthat onlv 2 rtl partyand not thc froin lhe J I dcbtors can Illc thc application undcr Ordcr 21 Rule 97CPC Z hc Iearncdtrlal 020u1 allcl llcal118bctll ll1c sides disillissed the objcctionsundcr ordcr 21 rulc 97 CPC holdingthat objcctors al the r I most stepped lllto lhc shocs of SardaraSingh So they have 110 locllS a5 slandi 10 Illc objcctioils uloclcr 9rdcr 21 Rlilc 97 02102 Illc salc dccds 111 0 fallOllr ofthe decndants arc ht by 001tcsLtclicata 7 Z Fcclino dissatisOcd with thc abovc said ordcr the lm prefcrred the lrsl AjoIlcal lIlc same was hcard and dccidcd b1 Icamcd Ilddilional District Judgc vidc judomcntdatcd 26 02009 rhcrelorc thc prcscnl CXCCUllOll sccond appcalhas bccn prcfcrrcd carned counscl 01 lhc appeI Iallls has subtniltcd lllal aPlocl arc bona Ilde purchascrs179ra ilahlable considcratlon wlhotlt lloticc 01anypcndingaplocalIt is ccicilclcd tllat suit 01t11edcctcc holdcr 10 dcclaration W2lS dccrccd on 31181976 he judgmenldcblor SardaraSinghprclerrcd appcalwhlch was acceptedvidc judgnlcnldatcd 27 1 1979 Rc8lilarSccond aplocalIorcerrcclbI tllc dcctechclcict was Parkash Om 2012.11.09 10: 02 True Scanned Copy Of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:30 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 85 e4 ESA Illo38 of 2009 4 011 27006 rhcrc lvas no occasion lI tllc appcllatlts to InoIN aboul thc pcndcncy01 thc RcgularSecond AjopcaIpcndiilgin thc lIigll Court Thc factum of bolla lldc I7t a IlalLiablecoilsideraticI wilhout nolicc of any litigationCall onlybc by Iranling ISSUC lll lhis rcgard hc objcctlon undcr Otdcl 21 ILllc 97 Cll02 aillcuilts tc a civil r SLlilaild thc samc can bc dccidcd onor 21ftcrliamine lllc isslie lllc 0 0 bythc judgnlcnt dcblors or any pcrson undcr ordcr 21 Ordcr 97 I C5 CPC are lllallllalilablc lll VICIV oaulllorItv Iil Shreenath 2k Anre vse Raicsh I 82Ors 199821Civil Court Cascs 2112ISC1 lt is Iiirthcr conteildedlllat Z Scction 52 of thc ransler o1 ProperlyAcl docs not attract in rcspcctof 2 salc decd I7r consldcralion I4Iitholilllolicc O tlliScOnlclltioll Ilc I has rclled upoil aulhorityAvinash Chandcr and antItller vs Ifazura 08 Sinoh and othcrs 2002 Thc Pun iah Ialv Reporler383e So the pravcr CO has been nladc lhal foIlowngclLicstloils c1 Ialtl bc dccided iil fvcul 01 lhe 7 Z Ill VlClll 01argumenlsraiscd abovc Q Whclhcr thc arC llOt bonafldc Ior considcration bcciusc lhc pjocl Ianls havc purcllascd tllc laild fiom the oievncrs allcr vcying Ihctitlc sillcc Ic9tlg bacl 9 ii l Whcthcr thc appelIanls do not llil l within thc dcllnilion 01 third pcrSOll and can prccr objcctionsunclcrordcr 21 Rulc 97 ofCC2 iii l Whether thc trial coLirt is ncll bound to dccide lhc obIeclionsllled bythc undcr 091del2 1 11Ilc97 CllC2 altcr iSSLICSllrld aller giilg to Icad cvidcncc itl SLilopor101thclr 01jcclions Parkash Om 2012.11.09 10: 02 True Scanned Copy Of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:30 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 1 86 e IllSANo8 01 2009 0 ivl Whclhcr thc llndinos rccordcd by lhc courts below dlsmlssinolhc obicctionsofthc arc sustainablc ln thccvcsolIaw2 MsAlka Sarin Icarned counsel f79r thc has the udgmcntof bolh thc Courts belcJ11eIt is ccnteildcd tllal tlle righls01 lhc loiirlicshad to bc adudlcalcd Ill VlCW Order 21 Rulc 0 C 102CPC Iltsisa spccillcprovisionrclatlng to lis pcndens in rcspcctof I C5 undcr Ordcr 21 Rules 98 and 99 CPC It clcatIylaysdowtl I thatany propcrtyptirchascd dLlritlgthc pclldcilcItI tlle casc Iilill bc l1itby Z 0f lis pendcnsln aulhoritv Mitlalrslli S2Iini and inotller vse GurcharanSinoh Bharmra and othcrv 2002 21 Plel 78 6Punlab and 1IarvanaIeligh Courtlhas hcld that it s not ncccssary to rainc issue in cach I J 08 and cvcrv casc Whcre lhcrc is an altcnopltllc obJcclorlo prolongthc Cn alrc2idy litigatlollIll thal casc lhe lralningof Issuc would 7 Z upon thc facts and circumslanccs of cach casc and is not Il 111Cuinbcnt upon lhc cxccillllg Collrl lhat Il lllLlStIoiillo trial CVCryobjcction fllccl in thc CXCClllIOtl 1 tritil t is sublnittcd thal lor adjudication 0 clainl 01 thc parlicSit ls alwavs ilol neccssarv lo lrame lSSUC Iil llle prCSCIltC21SCthc IaClS 11rC llcll lll disputc hc lantshavc thc propcrtyduringthc pcndcncy of thc regtilar sccoild apjocal bcore thc l ligllCctitl Sr1 tllc lcaiiled ttial Cl011tIlas rightly hclcl that tllC S21111C lS hit by of rcs judicala le Honblc SuprcnleCourl in Usha Sinha vs Dina Ram and other20071 7 SupremcCourt Cases 144 Ivhilc dcalln Iovithorclcl 2 1 I7Lllcs97 98 1 10 and 102CPC hascalcuorically1111ih2il1i tlEinslice llotll tl jtidglllctltdcbl Parkash Om 2012.11.09 10: 02 True Scanned Copy Of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:30 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 87 ESA N038 of 2009 6 IS prcsunled 10 a117211 of thc be170rc Court 01 law It 1S thc doctrinc oflis pcndcns0tatlsllc11tcopctly Act IleldiI unlair or undescrvcd protcclionis aflorded to a lransfcree 1itc a dccrecloldcr will nevcrbe able to rcalzc thc fruits ofhis dccree his aulhorilyhas relied ulocotltlle aillllco1ty cf Silverlinc I1rtim Pl Ltd Ve Raiiv lrust 199813 SCC 723 So t ls Submlttedthal 110 0 C substantialqucstionof 1a14hasarisci 1le llilditlgc1 Ict tetutlledbybcth I C5 thc Courts bclolv docs not call 10r anv inlcrlcrcncc and praycr has bcen I madcfor dismissalofthc execution sccond appcal Z I havc carcfullyconsidcrcd the submissions madc by both the J r learncd counsel fr thc particsand havc gollc lllc lcc9ids c1 1Ile cas a5 The main coiltrovcrsyraisco bIolhc colillscl 1701 lllc appcll2ints lS that lhc obcctors appclIantsarc tlle bona Ildc of thc land Wllhout m Z anynotice he obicctionlindcr ordcr 21 Rulc 97CPC arc nlaintainableand Cle thosc objcctions cannol be dccidcd iIllhout JSSUC and affordltl8 opporlullity 0f Icadltlgevidcncc and it s Iitrlhci cc3lolendcdtllat llildllg cf both thc Courts bclow dismlssino thc objcclionsofthc are SUstaillablciil lew ofthc argUlllCtllS lllllde abovc hc ofi ISSUC IS rlol in order to adjudicalc the claim ofthe particsi11rcspccl 01 plca01 bona ildc 101laSC 1118Slllllch as the lacts are not in disIoutcAdmittcdlythe appcllanls purchasedthc propcrty froln thc judgrncnt dcbtors duritlOlhc o i regularsecond ajopcal So lll lhCSe ClrClllllSlatlCCS tllC 81111110 0 l SSUC was not rcquirec ln authotitl Minakshi Saini and anothcrs ClISC supral that aspeet of the Parkash Om 2012.11.09 10: 02 True Scanned Copy Of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:30 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 88 1 1 ESA N038 of 2009 7 e casc was dcalt in bv this Court Il has bccn hcld that it is not incutnbcnt Llponxecuting Gurl that it mast pLitlo trlal af012cct1cil Illed tllldcl 1del 1 V t 21Rulc 97 l0 108 0 thc CPO Iil casc l1olous vcxalious allcloIcCllClllS mcant lo cause dclaylllc cxcclitlon o Illc dccrcc lhal call bc suminarily dccidcd of oljccliondocs not mcan thal IralnltlgOf lsslic is Q allsIays neccssary lt has bccn ftirthcr laid dclwil iil tllc said luliIlglllat 0 C alietlal0111tlllrlllo c3 SUII IS hii hv principlcsoflis pcndcns lll I 9 VlCW 0 Scctions 52 and 41 oflhe ransfcr of PropcrlyAcl and plcaof bona fldc purchascr of propcrtyIvllhout noticc Ior valuablc considcratioll Z iStlol avalablc to thc hc l lonblc IjoexCtlllrl lll altlhorilv Usha Sin hav case supral whilc dcallngInllithorclcr 21 Rules 9798 100 a11d1 J2 ClIC Ilcld I 08 lhal objcctloiluilclcr Ordcr 21 Rulc l 02 Cl0 is Io2IscdliloIl justicccqttily m and goodconSClOUS A trailslcrcc Irolll a jiidgrllciltdebtor IS lO 7 Z be awail01 lhc jorocecdlllgs bcl7JrctI COllrt Ol 1v Il rccogtliesthc 11 0m doctrlnc of 1is pcndcnsas Cllvisaocd in Scclion 52 o f lhe ransfcr of PropcrlyAcl Il has bccn liirthcr hcltl that 11unflit or undcscrvcd prolcclionl s afl ordcd lo a lrallslcrcc IoCildcnle Iilc a clccrcc holdcr will nevcr be ablc to rcalize lhc l1uitsohs dcCrCC S lll VICW of thc aulh0ri12l1ivcprollolillcclncntof thc laIv Iaid d0ii7i1in aLilhorityIJsha Sinllas casc Slll Ill the Ilonble Apcx Court authorit 0f Ilvinlish Chander atld linotsrlfl lclicd bv thc Icarilcd couIlscl Ior thc c21nnOl hc 11117C11 lllUCll lIllIOOrlanCC Morcollcr lhat aLilhclrityis lc Illc lcts ol tlle IolCSCIllcase as 111lhat casc there18721 S tVlvalid conlpronllse in rcspcclof dccrecd land and Parkash Om 2012.11.09 10: 02 True Scanned Copy Of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:30 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 89 JS1 No38 01 2009 8 thc exccution Ivas hcld to bc not Illcd Ivithin linlitation Morcovcr lhe qucslion01 bona Ilde purchascr iovllhoutnotIcC IS 21qucslionof lact and not a Iaw aild in viclovof Secli011I00 CPC lh arc dcbarrcd fn challcnging thc CtlllCllrrctll ll ildi ne lhal lhcl arc ilol thc bona Odc 1 r So 17iriIs lllc sLiblllission01 Ic21n1cd coLinsellclr lhc appcllanls lo 0 C lllc elcct that lirc nlalnlainablclo 7 1tl 213 10811y lllVlCW ofauthoritv I C Silverlinc Vorum 01 Itds case supral IS conccrncd am ofthe I CotlSidercd vciov lhal thc obicclioolls lllcci bI tllc cectolS Ill VlCW Z 01thc sald aulhorltybLilobjectlons havc 110 171rCC itl vicw olthe cliscLiSSIOll 0 madcabovc So Ill tIlCSCCilClilllStaIlCCS100illl01 1211NcO2 stalldsllilsiollctcd I Ill Iavcllir 0 thc I loCVCl ltl 1I C11701 disClISSIOIlIlllldc abovc 08 t11Ialnilraiscd at SrlVo 1 3 11d4 slanl atlswcrcd agaiilsttllc appclla1115 7 Z Iil vicw clf lhc ilbovc dlsclission lhc is wilhout allv tl nlcrlt andthc simc slandsdisnlissed A copy 0 tllis jtitlollclllbc scnl t0 thc lrial Court Ior slrlct Ce 1 1 JlJDCIil Januarvllhl 2010 9 Sl OF9 9n9 u vJ e C Illb Parkash Om 2012.11.09 10: 02 True Scanned Copy Of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:30 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document