IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Miscellaneous Jurisdiction Case No.4540 of 2010 MASHESHWAR SINGH, SON OF LATE MAHABIR SINGH R/O MANJHAURA P.S. RIGA DISTT. SITAMARHI Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH COMMISSIONER CUM SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE, OLD SECRETARIAT, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA. 2. AFZAL IMAM, PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION THROUGH IT’S MAYOR, BUDH MARG PATNA. 3. CHIRI BOLU, MUNICIPAL COMMISSIONER CUM CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, PATNA. MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, BUDH MARG, PATNA. 4. ASHOK KUMAR SINGH, CHIEF ACCOUNT’S OFFICER, PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, BUDH MARG PATNA. 5. SHASHANK KUMAR SINGHA EXECUTIVE OFFICER NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL, PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, 10 HARDING ROAD, PATNA. ---------------------------------- With Miscellaneous Jurisdiction Case No.5213 of 2010 1. KEDAR RAM SON OF KHERU R/O SAIDPUR NAND NAGER COLONY P.S. KADAMKUAN DISTRICT PATNA PRESETLY POSTED BANKIPURE CIRCLE NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL/ KANKARBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.48. 2. RAMESH SON OF HARGU R/O SAIDPUR NAND NAGER COLONY P.S. BAHADURPUR DISTRICT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED AT KANKERBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.35. 3. RAJENDRA SON OF RAMKHELAMAN R/O CHHAJUBAGH P.S. GANDHI MAIDAN DISTRICT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED AT NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.07. 4. LAXHMAN DAS SON OF MAHABIR DAS R/O SANDPUR P.S. BAHADURPUR DISTRICT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED BANKIPUR CIRCLE/NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL/KANKARBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATIUON AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.48. 5. MUKESH SON OF NAGINA R/O RAJENDRA NAGER ROAD NO.5, P.S. KADAMKUAN DISTRICT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED AT KANKERBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.32. 6. AYHODHYA RAM SON OF JHARI RAM R/O NAND GAON P.S. MAHENDRU DISTRICT PATNA, PRESENTLY POSTED AT BANKIPURE CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.20. 7. SUSHILA D/O MUNNA R/O EXIBITION ROAD, MURGI BAGICHA, P.S. GANDHI MAIDAN, DISTRICT PATNA. PRESENTLY POSTED AT KANKERBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.24. 2 8. RANG LAL SON OF LATE BANGALIA R/O YARPUR AMBEDKAR COLONY P.S. GARDINABAGH DISTRICT PATNA, PRESENTLY POSTED NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.18 9. HEMANTI D/O LATE KEWALI R/O YARPUR AMBEDKAR COLONY P.S. GARDNIBAGH DISTRICT PATNA, PRESENTLY POSTED AT BANKIPURE CIRCLE/NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL/KANKERBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.12B 10. BALESHWAR DAS, SON OF LATE MAHABIR DAS, R/O SAIDPUR NAND NAGER COLONY P.S. BAHADURPUR DISTRICT PATNA, PRESENTLY POSTED AT BANKIPURE CIRCLE/NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL/KANKERBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.48. 11. SUNIL RAM, SON OF SAKHICHAN, R/O YARPUR AMBEDKAR COLONY P.S. GARDANIBAGH DISTRICT PATNA PRESETLY POSTED NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL PATNA, MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER WARD NO.11. 12. DUDHA NATH, SON OF CHOKAT R/O YARPUR AMBEDKAR COLONY, P.S. GARDNIBAGH DISTRICT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED AT KANKERBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.30. 13. MEENA D/O MATHURA R/O CHAJU BAGH P.S. GANDHI MAIDAN, DISTIRCT PATNA, PRESENTLY POSTED AT KANKERBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.30. 14. ASHOK SON OF RAMGATI R/O YARPUR AMBEDKAR COLONY P.S. GARDNIBAGH DISTRICT PATNA, PRESENTLY POSTED AS NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AT SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.19 15. JAGO DAS SON OF LATE MAHABIR DAS, R/O SAIDPUR NAND NAGER COLONY P.S. BAHADURPUR DISTRICT PATNA, PRESENTLY POSTED AT BANKIPURE CIRCLE/NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL/KANKERBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.48. 16. GIRISH SON OF LATE CHANDESHWAR R/O MACHUA TOLI, P.S. KADAMKUAN, DISTRICT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED AT BANKIPUR CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.49. 17. SARYUG DAS, SON OF LATE LILO DAS, R/O SAIDPUR NAND NAGER COLONY P.S. BAHADURPUR DISTRICT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED AT BANKIPURE CIRCLE/NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL/KANKERBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.42. Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH COMMISSIONER CUM SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE, OLD SECRETARIAT, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA. 3 2. PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION THROUGH ITS MAYOR AFZAL IMAM, BUDH MARG PATNA. 3. MANISH KUMAR, MUNICIPAL COMMISSIONER CUM CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, BUDH MARG PATNA. 4. ASHOK KUMAR SINGH, CHIEF ACCOUNT’S OFFICER, PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, BUDH MARG PATNA. 5. SHASHANK SHEKHAR SINHA EXECUTIVE OFFICER NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL, PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, 10 HARDING ROAD, PATNA. 6. CHANDRASEKHAR EXECUTIVE OFFICER BANKIPURE CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, LOHANIPUR PATNA. 7. GIRIJA SHANKER PRASAD EXECUTIVE OFFICER KANKERBAGH ANCHAL PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPPORAITON KANKERBAGH PATNA. ---------------------------------- With Miscellaneous Jurisdiction Case No.5167 of 2010 1. GIRIJA D/O LATE JAIRAM R/O MSALLAHPUR HATT HARIJAN COLONY P.S. SULTANGUNJ DISTRICT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED AT BANKIPURE CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.42 2. NANKHI SON OF LATE ANUJ R/O LOHANIPUR HARIJAN COLONY P.S. KADAMKUAN DISTIRCT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED AT BANKIPURE CIRCLE/NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL/KANKERBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.17. 3. SIKANDER SON OF BHATTU R/O ARYA KUMAR ROAD HARIJAN COLONY, P.S. KADAMKUAN DISTRICT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED AT BANKIPURE CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.17 4. MUKESH KUMAR SON OF KACHHARIYA R/O MUSALLAHPUR HATT HARIJAN COLONY P.S. SULTANGUNJ DISTRICT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED AT BANKIPURE CIRCLE/NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL/KANKERBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.49. 5. BARNAT @ BASANT SON OF LATE BIRISH RAM R/O ARYA KUMAR ROAD, ROAD NO.4 P.S. KADAMKUAN DISTRICT PANT PRESENTLY POSTED AT BANKIPURE CIRCLE/NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL/KANKERBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.32. 6. MALTI SON OF LATE NARAYAN R/O KAJIPUR MALIA TANKI P.S. KADAMKUAN DISTRICT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED AT BANKIPURE CIRCLE/NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL/KANKERBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.25. 7. SURESH SON OF LATE MOTI R/O KHOJAI IMALI KANHAIYA 4 NAGER P.S. PHULWARISARIF DISTRICT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED AT BANKIPURE CIRCLE/NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL/KANKERBAGH CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.17. 8. NANDWA D/O LATE JAIRAM R/O MUSALLAHPUR HATT HARIJAN COLONY P.S. SULTANGUNJ DISTRICT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED AT BANKI0PUR CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.48. 9. BINDIA D/O MAHENDRA R/O YARPUR AMBEDKAR COLONY P.S. GARDNIBAGH DISTRICT PATNA PRESENTLY POSTED AT NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AS SANITARY WORKER, WARD NO.19 Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH COMMISSIONER CUM SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE, OLD SECRETARIAT, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA. 2. PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION THROUGH ITS MAYOR AFZAL IMAM, BUDH MARG PATNA. 3. MANISH KUMAR, MUNICIPAL COMMISSIONER CUM CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, BUDH MARG PATNA. 4. ASHOK KUMAR SINGH, CHIEF ACCOUNT’S OFFICER, PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, BUDH MARG PATNA. 5. SHASHANK SHEKHAR SINHA EXECUTIVE OFFICER NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL, PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, 10 HARDING ROAD, PATNA. 6. CHANDRASEKHAR EXECUTIVE OFFICER BANKIPURE CIRCLE PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, LOHANIPUR PATNA. 7. GIRIJA SHANKER PRASAD EXECUTIVE OFFICER KANKERBAGH ANCHAL PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPPORAITON KANKERBAGH PATNA. ---------------------------------- With Miscellaneous Jurisdiction Case No.4543 of 2010 HARINANDAN SINGH, SON OF LATE BANBARI SINGH, R/O PATHAI P.S. EAST PATHAI, DISTT. EAST CHAMPARAN (MOTIHARI) Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH COMMISSIONER CUM SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE, OLD SECRETARIAT, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA. 2. AFZAL IMAM, THE MAYOR, PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION THROUGH IT’S MAYOR, BUDH MARG PATNA. 3. CHIRI BOLU, MUNICIPAL COMMISSIONER CUM CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, PATNA. MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, BUDH MARG, PATNA. 4. ASHOK KUMAR SINGH, CHIEF ACCOUNT’S OFFICER, 5 PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, BUDH MARG PATNA. 5. SHASHANK KUMAR SINGHA EXECUTIVE OFFICER NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL, PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, 10 HARDING ROAD, PATNA. ------------------ With Miscellaneous Jurisdiction Case No.4818 of 2010 1. LALITA D/O LATE MANGROO R/P PMCH CAMPUS P.S. PRIBAHOR DISTT PATNA. 2. SUMITRI D/O LATE RAMSWAROOP R/O ADALATGUNJ P.S. SACHIVALAYA DISTTT. PATNA. 3. BHAGWANTI D/O YUGESHWARI R/O OLD POLICE LINE P.S. GANDHI MAIDAN DISTT. PATNA. 4. CHINWA D/O RANGLAL R/O GANDHI MAIDAN, P.S. GANDHI MAIDAN DISTT. PATNA. 5. JIRVA D/O PARDESHI R/O OLD POLICE LINE P.S. GASANDHI MAIDAN DISTT. PATNA 6. RAMNARAYAN SON OF JUDAGI R/O ANISABAD, P.S. BEAUR, DISTT. PATNA. 7. BHOLA DAS SON OF SANICHAR DAS R/O GANDHI MAIDAN P.S. GANDHI MAIDAN, DISTT. PATNA 8. MOSAFIR SON OF BIGAN R/O YARPUR P.S. GARDANIBAGH DISTT. PATNA 9. MUNNA SON OF MUNSHI R/O R. BLOCK P.S. SACHIVALAYA DISTT. PATNA. 10. BRIJLAL SON OF BIDESHI R/O LOHANIPUR P.S. KADAMKUAN DISTT PATNA. 11. SHANTIYA D/O RANGLAL R/O YARPUR P.S. GARDNIBAGH DISTT. PATNA 12. DHANIYA D/O PARDESHI R/O MANDIRI P.S. BUDHA COLONY DISTT. PATNA. 13. JAGIYA D/O LATE MAHENDRA R/O OLD POLICE LINE P.S. GANDHI MAIDAN DISTT. PATNA. 14. SAHDEO SON OF SUKHAN R/O OLD POLICE LINE P.S. GANDHI MAIDAN DISTT. PATNA. 15. RAJENDRA SON OF BISHUNDHARI R/O BHAVAR POPKHAR P.S. PIRBAHOR DISTT PATNA. 16. SHIVSHANKER SON OF LATE BANSI R/O DAUDPUR P.S. MASAURHI DISTT PATNA. 17. LALPARIIYA D/O LATE BULKAN R/O OLD POLICE LINE P.S. GANDHI MAIDAN DISTT PATNA. 18. PINKU KUMAR SON OF LATE SURAJ R/O OLD POLICE LINE P.S. GANDHI MAIDAN DISTT. PATNA 19. BUDHAN DAS SON OF SUKHAD DAS R/O OLD POLICE LINE P.S. GANDHI MAIDAN DISTT. PATNA 20. YOSODA DEVI WOFE OF LATE AKLU DAS R/O R. BLOCK ROAD NO.8 P.S. SACHIVALAY DISTT. PATNA 21. LALIYA D/O LATE SAKHICHAND R/O R. BLOCK ROAD NO.8 P.S. PHULWARI DISTT PATNA. 22. SUNDRI D/O LATE GULAB R/OSISPARA NEAR IMDIAN OIL P.S. PHULWARI DISTT. PATNA. Versus 6 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH COMMISSIONER CUM SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE, OLD SECRETARIAT, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA. 2. AFZAL IMAM, PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION THROUGH IT’S MAYOR, BUDH MARG PATNA. 3. CHIRI BOLU, MUNICIPAL COMMISSIONER CUM CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, PATNA. MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, BUDH MARG, PATNA. 4. ASHOK KUMAR SINGH, CHIEF ACCOUNT’S OFFICER, PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, BUDH MARG PATNA. 5. SHASHANK KUMAR SINGHA EXECUTIVE OFFICER NUTAN RAJDHANI ANCHAL, PATNA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, 10 HARDING ROAD, PATNA. ---------------------------------- 19. 15.12.2011 In view of unqualified apology tendered by the two Ex-Municipal Commissioner, Patna Municipal Corporation without justifying their action, the contempt petitions are disposed of. Rajesh/ ( V. N. Sinha, J.)