glS{j(ja]isiiiijBaii)iS !ft!»(* »"^^ !i*w"'- 22 H!GH COURT OF JUDICATLIRE CHHffi3'T!SGARH : BILASPUR 'fe S!NGL.t= BRNCH : HON'BLE SHRI S.R.NAYAK, C.J. WPIT PRTITION N0 S496 OF 2008 ^ PFTJTIOMEP Mr S^i'f^bh' Bur'T^^H S/o Shri U.u. bu!)i')£d0, Ayeu at^out ^i vears, "ilpdical Student, CIMS r^:[.,.,..,,,. ":.- > '..-j: r-i ^c .'^ i.: C^^.-: r^ ^ t-/iict^.^/*ji , j'\U-iUv,;Ml^i ^?iJ OUi 1 L/.r', Rai. Kumharpara, Jarahabhata, R[!aspur (Chhattfegarh) M, RESPONDENTS o. The. State of Chhattisgarh, ihrough U'ie •'ie^ieiaiy, Departrnenl of Health A F'anTl" Welfare (includino t fl-.,..);/.. -,( ,„.'»;ijii/<.<i '~ ^. ./.^^.;.. ,.^\ b—^ii-iut.li.ii./ii^, throuah tho ^/i'icif"tC<3UOf7Li ic' ^OV&mOS t-inawan. iV!antra!ava, i^aicur ^C^f")at1:'90?rh) r t ie Ot;i-.E'6-'i.c2iy', U6pcii' 'ii'i'ieiTi. O' Hinhsr Fducation D.K.S Eihawan h r.-.,- ^...^.f..., ,,^ o,^.-^. ,,. i',"^^ >-..,;,^;-. ,.,^ i.i. \ i^lUJ ti.i<.iliC<y'i.,t ; i\Cij^>Ui ^ts^t J''fcii.Lt^l.jt^t f i^ Guru Ghasi uas Universin/. Pibspur Ci-i Chha-tisgsrh. Raj Fihawan, Raipur, //~l't^i-,.-4-!.;^.,/,-.^\ ^•<^i ll •i-tx.i.ayt.tl 1 i^ The Director Medical fcducation St?lt9 of Chh9.tt!SQ?irh, Rsiour ^\/n''!ciLtiS.yc'i f'i^ The Medical Counci! of tndia E'-'sn-a-Gs'ib M^ro. NGV/ De-lhi, f ft8 'uFiiitulu^Qcij'ri iuSLitUtiOri Ot Medica! Scienr.-;s (CIMS) through the Dsan, C!MS, Biiaspur (Cnhattisqarh) PET'T'OMER WRIT PFTJTION MO. $320 OF 2005 \./<; ^4ohd Shoeb Khan. S/o Shri i.n.Khaii, Ayed about 2G yeais, Meclica! Student CIMS. BilasDur J-102. Ashoka o^ - :^i ,-,^- ^ j\l-,3i'wjtii (t, .- |!J<-, Heiahis. Mova, RaiDUr. RESPONDENTS Ths State of ChhattisQarh. throtioh '''""'•^''''".^.^"^""^ £•iti oyCi ^(.isii y : U^pi^i'IPi'itsPil Oi' ^dntrwla**rrfh:aia .^nr^^';^.-.-. SiBS^ seiE SssK' •-2-- o. 23 Health;^, Famiiy Welfare (including MedicM' Education), D.K.S. Bhswan, Mantralaya, Rajpur (Chhaftisgarh) The Secretary, Depart.'nent of Higher Education, D.K.S. Bhawan, Mantralaya, Raipur (Chhattisgarhi Guru Ghasi Das Universrty. Bilaspur through the Chancellor/the Govemor Chhattisgarh, Raj Bhawan, Raipur, (Chhattisgarh) I The Dirsctor, IVIedical Education State of ChhatSisgarh, Raipur (Chhattisgar'h) The F.,'iedica! Councll of 'ndia, Evan-a-Gaiib Marg. New Delhi, Tiie Chhiattisgarh Institute of Medicg! Sciences (C!fyiS) through 4S, (Chhattisgarh) the Dean, CiMS, Bilaspur WRITPETiT'ON N0. 6321 OF 2001 PET'TIONER Mis? Manisha Ekka, D'o Shr! iJbup Ekka, . Aged about 21 years, Medicai :Student, CIMS, Resldent of Negr A^'yappamandir, Raip'.ir Road Jarabhata Bilasour CChhat.tisgsrr'i'! RESPQNDENTS Vs. 1. S. 6. The State of Chhattisgiarh, through the S.ecre'i.ary. DepartmenS :of Highsr' Edusation, O.K.S. Bhawan,, Mantraiaya, Raipu.-' (Chhat'iisgai-h) The Secretary,. Oepartment af Hea'th & Fami'y Weifare (including MedtCai Ediicatior;), D.K.S. Bhawan, ' ' Msntraiaya, Raipur (Chhattisgarh) , . . The Chancellor. (Syr'.i Gtiasldas Unh/ersity, Biiasprr. .Ra]! Bhawan, Raipi-ll, iChhaitiSgcifhi i s. Guru Ghasi Das Urt!''(ars'ty. BHaspur friroi.yh ^ »he .. ;ViCe Cha''.csilor, Districr Bitaspi-ir (Chhatisgarh) '; Thc; Oi^'sctOi' iVlfc-dic^J EuUCciti.Ot'i S*'3te of Chhattisaarh, Raipyr ff^^^.^.*^^.^^.^\ •••'• •• ,-. ; \i>wfi 'it(Ct.l.i.]^>^<A[ I i^ rhe Medica.t Counsei Q{ Inaia.. EV3n-n-Gaj!b Maro, Nev;' Deif'i. 24 -'"i. 7. 8 Th" Chhattisgarh tnstitute of ?v1euicai Sciences (CIMS) through the Doan, CIMS, Bitaspur /,^i.,I^^M.^^^-l^\ \\^l it i^i.lliaydi (•iy The 4"' University Grants Commission, Bahadur Shah Zafar iviaig, New Deihi-1 10002 WR!T DET!T!ON N0,53?6 OF 2005 PET!"r'ONEP. Vs. Miss Smriti Rathore, D/o Shri S.K. Rathore, Aged about 19 years, Medical Student, CIMS, Bilaspur, Residsnt of Chandaniya Para Janjgir Distt-Janjgir Champa (Chhatttegarh) (Sp<a '-1f'ir,!r~,Ch!T<*. ^ .' -^.-'" I I- ^ -u^ i A ^ LT^ o. The Stets of Chhatttegarh, through ihe Secretary, Department of Health S; Family VA/elfare (including Mcu^aS Education), D.K.S. Bhawsn. Mantralaya. Raipur (Chhgttisgarh) Thfc' Syeretary, Department of Hirjhor cd]iRation, D.K.S. Bhawa.n, '.ic.ntralsya, Ruipur (Chhattisgarh) Guru Ghasi Das Universitv. SHasp'T through ; the ClidriL.eiiOi/the Governor Chhattisgarh, Raj Bhawan, Raipyr, ^L/i istSli.iS^ The Dirsctor, Medical Education Stste of Chhattisgarh, Ra'pur vCiiliattiagarh) The Medical Councjl of India, Evsn-a-Galib Marg, New Delhi. Tiic Chhatti&garh institute of Medical Sciences (CIMS) throuoh thc Dean, CiMS, Biiaspur (Chhattisaarh) 'A'RIT PETITIOM MO, ?448 OF 2005 >3pT!"'!.">?i!CR Mr Mikash P. John, S/o Bsnny john, Aged about 24 years, iViedica! Sturient, C!MS, Bilaspur, Reaidei.t of MiG-40, R.P.Nagar, Hudco Phase /Chh2Hisaa'-h> li, Korba ^A •tac,^a^^i.i]i((frcaiit,^iii>imiiitsTTf+wwnv"wiwi- ^. 25 RESPONDENTS 4. &. The State of Chhattisgarh, through Lhe .Secretary, Department of l-fea|g-'& Family Welfare (including Medical Education), D.K.S. Bhawan, Mantralaya, Raipur (Chhattisgarh) The Secretary, Department of Higher Education, D.K.S. Bhawan, Mantraiaya, Raipur (Chhattisgarh) Guru Ghasi Das Universjty, Bilaspur through the Clianceilor/the Governor ChhattisgaFh, Raj Bhawan, Raipur, /^^t~,.~^\-^.^r\^\ \^t in.iji.t.ioyciii -!he Dirsctor, Medical Education State of Chhattisgarh, Raipur (Chhattisgarh) The Medical Council of India, E'.'an-a-Galib Marg, New Delhi. The Chhattisgarh tnstitute of Mertical Sciences (CIMS) through ths Dear,, CIMS, Bilaspur (Chhattisaarh) wpif PETIT'ON N0. S493 OF 2005 PETiT'ONER Mr Rupesh Agrawal,. S/o Shri Rambhaj Agrav^al, Aged about 21 years, Med'cal Student, CIMS, Biiaspur, Resident of Manokamna Vasrrataya Main Road Bishrampur Distt Sarguja. \^ RESPONDENTS 1. The State of Chhattisgarh, through the Secretary, Department of Health & Family Welfare (including Medical Education), D.K.S. Bhawan, Mantralaya, Raipur (Chhattisgarh) The Secretary, Department of Higher Education, D.K.S. Bhawan, Fvlanu-alaya, Raipur (Chhattisgarh) Guru Ghasi Das University, Bilaspur thriaugh the Chancellor/the Governor Chhattisgarh, Raj Bhawan, Raipur, (Chhattisgarh) The Director. Medicai Education State of Chhattisgarh, Raipur (Chhattisgai'h) -CT- 26 5. R The Medical Council of !ndia, Evan-a-Gali'o IViarg, New Delhi. The Chhattisgarh Institute of Medjea] Sciences (CIMS) through' the* Dean. CIMS, Bilaspur (Chhattisaarh) WR!T PETITiOM N0. 6497 QF 2005 PFTITin?!P!3 \fe M!-. Sudhanshu Patel, S/o Shri Jai Rarn Fatel, Aged about 23 years, Medical Student, CIMS, Bilaspur, ReSident of House No. 2/345, Near Dr. Das Clinic, Kota Raipur (Chhattisgarh) RESPONPEMTS -1.. EaB •< The State of Chhattisgarh, through tlie Secietary, Department of Health & Family Welfare (including ?w'ied;ca! Education), D.K.S. Bhawan, Mantralaya, Raipur (Chhattisgarh) Tlie Secretary, Department of Higher Education, D.K.S. Bhawan, ManSralaya, Raipur (Chhattisgarh) Guru Ghasi Das University, Bi'aspurthroughthe Chancellor/the Governor Chhattisgarh, Raj Bhawan, Raipur, (ChhaUisgarh) The Director, Medical Education State ofChhattisgarh, Raipur ; (Chhattissarh) ! •w...:^i. .The Medical Councit pflndiid Evan-a-Galjh:Mar!^iJ ne-ciihii^j^g Meclfcil^SBiSdi^lgl (Chhattiisp^ WR!T PETiTfON N0.165 OF 2006 PET'TIONER Vi'/ek Goyal, aged about 21 years, son of Shri Shyam Sundar Goyal, Student of Second year, M.B.B.S. C!MS, resldent of C/o Himadri Eiectricats, In front of Jain Mandir, Sadar Bazar, Raipur, Vs 6- .27 RpCps^'ynpiyTC; fi Sw" of Chhattlsgarh, through the ^ 3e.;.ie'.<ai v D'epartrnenS of L!eaSth & Fs^y Weifare inciuding Mssdicai Llu-ifiufion, \0au. Kaiyan. Singh Bhswan, RaipKF (C.G.) ••''• Th^.'?Acr^te?'\'<,';DAD3rtmen't of--" r!^i'ite;i -iIlditC(Stioi^''Osu .Kalya.ri'; •" Rii'rth Bh?wan, Raiour rc.G.) Tho Dirsctor, Msdica! Education State of Chhsttisgarh, Raipur •'f r~. \. GuiL'yi'iasidas Un.versiSy, Biiaspuf, th'-c'iigh -its.Registrar, Koni, Ofett. Gu^i&pur (Chhsttfsg'arh)' • r' The Medicai Councii of india. Evan C-~"iv "qra. New DB!h'. throuah its r'.egisu'ar/ authoiized signatoi'y, NAW rip^hi • - • f:' C''''"'-:'>t*!'^Ci^rh 'nstituto :or ivi^UTi/cit' 3cieftC^1 (Clifi^) thf'Oijyh 't? Ofsn Rilgsnur i'C'. G ) IA/RIT P>::T!T;01'-' "''n. "'°? OP 2006 P!-"-'T!'")MPP Pswsn Kumaf Sisod'ys-, &gs<! ,a[^\>LK 21 yeais. sen of Shn A.K. Sisodiva. Medica! •• Siudent, M,3.3.3. \\ y£3i', i'/o 56 NsurSu^^i Ra'npur, Distt. JabaSpur (Madhya P!l""^(3shi \lt •R'P-COi~ ?.j f) F ,\!T c; 5. Stai^ ot Chh'£(tttSG3th. throuoh th^ 3Qi:'iitai'Y Departf'nent 01 Heaith & F?>~iilv Weifgi'e includina Med'cal r-..'. .^^^,^,,-, r"'/~.i. [.!''/-..^ •-w o;i";n*-i L-,^js..s'^oi'-ii L^;5U r\£ti'y<An l^snc Bhawan, Raipur iC.G) T1'!'? Secretar;,', Depart'"]8n> of nigrKii' Educauon, Dau i^aiyan S'ngh Bhawan, Raipur(C.G,) 7he Cirector, Medical Education Staie of Chhattisgarh, Ra'pur (0 G.') Gui'uyhas.das Univei'sity, Bllaspur, ftrough - rts R'egjstrar, Koni, Distt. 1~'.;i^^.^. .,. .••/•-•'..'^ ..^^4:^/·l/.^^l^^ i.-><ii-i,.>y-''-j. ^i^i ., iAtli.<.^^a! i i* The Mec'^al Ciounei' of India, Evan C-i'ly Ma;3, Ne'" Deihi, through !ts Registrei' authorjzed s;3natory, MOV,, Dslh' -~+' 28 The Chhatt'sgarh Institute for ?»ifadicai Science (Ci?v1S) through it? Dean Bilasnur (C. G.) WR!T PETITiON M'"~l, 42'' OF 2006 p^vfTjn^f^p '"asi'- A!1, aged about 22 years, son of Siiii Ali Bakhsh, Student of SsFonf) Year M.B.B.S. C.I.M.S., B'!?5p;'r, resident of Civi! Lines, Wdid No. 20, Manendragarh, P'Rtrict Koriva (C.G.) \/< RccpnMnFr.n-i:; DCTIT.nMFR 1. S+ate of Chhattisgarh, through the Secreiary Department of Health & Fgmily Welfare including Medicat Cciucation, Dau Kalyan Singh Bhawan. Raiour (C.G.) ? Th^Secretan/, Department of niyiiei Euucalion, Dau Kaiy'an S'nrih Phawan, Raipur'C.G.) 3. T;-iu Di.uctor, Medica! Educatjon State of Chhattisgarh. Raipur (CG.) 4. Guiughasidas University, Bilaspur, throuoh - its Registrar, Koni, Distt. Ci;aapui (Chhattisgarh) 5. The Medical Council of India, Evan C?|iy ^4arg, New Delhi, through its Keyistiar; uuihorized signatory, Mew Dalhi. 5. Tho Chhatt'sgarh Institute for iVltidicai Science (CIMS) thi'ough its nean, Bilaspur(C. G.) WR!T PETIT'OM N0.422 OF 2006 Shahid Bakhsh, aged about 23 years, son of Shri Dr. Imam Bakhsh. Sti.ident of Second Year ^R.B? Cl.M.5., Bitaspur, •esiuerii of Ring Road, Radhsswami Nagar, Rawanbhata o/. ;^.,.. f^ r^ \ i'\<-iij^'k4> \^ .<.y.} Vc RESPONPENTS State of Chhattisgarh. through the Secretary Departtnent of Heaith & Fgm!!v Welfare includinc! Medical EduCotic.n, Dau Ka'yan Singh ^ \ • ^ ^s^l ~Fs3 tfea •-%- 23 :'< 4 6. Bha""an, Raipur (C.G.) The Secretary, Department of Higher Education, Dau Kalyan Singh;- Bhawan, Raipur (C.G.) The^birector, Medical Education State of Chhattisgarh, Raipur (C.G.) Gurughssidas University, Bitaspur, through ~ its Registrar, Koni, Distt. Bilaspyr (Chhattisgarh) The Medical Counci! of India, Evan Co!iy iVSarg, Hew Delhi, through its Regisfrar/ authorized signatory, New Delhi., - The Chhattisgarh Institute for Medica! Science (CIMS) through its Dean, Bilaspur (C. G.) WRIT PET!T!ON N0.220 OF 2006 PET'T'ONERS •i. o. 6. Pr:?gya Chandrakar, D/o Shri Rarn Kumar Chandrakar, Ageci sbout 20 years. Madhutika Chandrakar, D/o. Shri T.R. Chandrakar, Aged aboyt 20 years Sneha Singh Dhruw, D/oShnV.S. Dhruw, Aged about 20 years Ruch'ka Tamrakar, D/'o Shri S.K. Tamrakar, Aged about 20 years. Shefali Wadhwani, D/o Shri D.R. Wadhwani, Age.d, about 20 years Ujjawala Karade, D/o Shri R.G. Karade Aged about 20 years. Aii are students of il year, M.B.B.S. Course, Chhattisgarh Institute of fuledicai Science, Biiaspur, Oistrict - Bilaspur (C.G.) Vs. RESPONDENTS State of Chhattisgarh, Through Secreiary, [^epartment of Heglth, Mantsalaya, D.K.S. Bhawan, RaiDur(CG.) Chhattissarh institute cf Medical Science, through Dean, Chhattisaarh institufe of Medicat .'iJ:'.;' S?' '-^^-^ .^;'?^ 1 ^^ in^i^iuu; i FA*yWP''^WJ.'W 30 3 Science,' Biiaspur, District - Biiaspur (C.G.) Guru Ghasidas University, Thr.&ugh Registrar, Guru Ghasidas Uni&ersity, Koni, Bilaspur, District- Bi!aspur(C.G.) 'f-. 's "f PET'T'ONERS WRITPET'TiON N0,344 OF 2006 1. Neha Thawait D/o Dr, 3.N. Thawait Aged about 23 years. 2. Akanchha Sahu D/o Shri B.L. Sahu Aged about 22 years A!i students of II year, MBBS Course, Chhattisgarhlnstitute of Med'ral Science, Bilaspur, District Bilaspu,- (C.G.) RESPONDEMTS 1. State of Chhattisgarh, Through Secretary, Department of Health, ivi£iiiii3iSy3, Raipur (C.G.} Chhattisgarh bcience, Chhattisgarh D.K.S. Bhawan, Institute thiough Institute of of Medical Dean, Medical District Science, Bilaspur, Bilaspur(C.G.) Guru Ghasidas University, Through Registrar, Guru Ghasidas University, Koni, Bilaspur, District- Bilaspur (C.G.) WP.IT PETITION N0.347 OF_2006 PETIT!ONERS 5. Gourav Kumar Thawait S/o Dr. R.K. Thawait Aged about 20 years Aditi Gupta D/o Dr. Vinay Gupta Aged about 21 years Chandan Sahu S/o Shri S.R. Sahu Aged about 20 years Upasna Dewangan O/o Sri G.K.Oewangan • Aged about 21 yeafs Rrtu Rochwanf D'o Shri Ramesh l-a!'RQchw.sni ^i9, SsSS ^-^^:^:^ ^£^ ly-wiiwwiws^i^wsw^i^y VMMIMtH ^^:^ ?3!e?;?£i':7' -ij;^^'. B .;'s^^^:'i •^?' PJ4SIQ |B3ip8ift| p 'ueeQ Li6nojq) leoipsiAj jo &}r4i}su| 'UGMBlia (•00) jndseiig 'jndse]ig 'aousps ©tniBSU] yjeBsjueqyo 'eousiog ^eBsjueijLjo CQO) jndiey 'eAeiej}uei,'\i 'UiiesH io )usiutjedsa 'Ajeiejoss qBnojqj. •LjjBBsiiteqqo^oeiets •s'>i'au SA ('O'O) J"dse]!g PPISIQ 'jndseiig 'saueios iBsipeiftl p 8}n}!}SU| qjeBsjiieqqo 'eeinoo SQQM '-lesA || ^o siuspnis sje ijv sjeeA 1.2 }noqe psBy 'je'>|e.!u.iei pesejd )B<u\Be4a uqg o/s jeifBJiuei jBiun»ejpueiT sjee/ 02 inoqepsBv |s»ec)'N~d U4Siui4S o/a [8}ed luefey sjeeA QS inoqe peBy qBuis --TH uqs 0/0 4Bui9 i}dssa siNaaNOdsaa Sd3NOilll3d 9002 d0 OOt^'ON N0ilil3d J-ia/v\ ^Sff"?'' •^^?3' ;^1^^: •'^^^-^:; iSK ysssi :9SSe. ('S'O' Jndce;!a -PU.tSIQ 'jndSBIig 'IUO» 'AllSJSAIUfl sepiseqg njng '.leflsiBay uBnn.iqi 'AlisjeAiufi sepjseyo njriQ ('O'O) -inaseiig 'jndseijg 'soueps stn}!)su| L|je6siueL|L)0 q6noji)} ein)!»su| isiflsiQ |BOjpe|A| y> 'UBSQ jeojpei^ y> 'soueiog LjjeBsiueqijO (•30) ^ndiey •uemeqg 'S'>l'a 'eAe|ej}uey,i '4)|eet-j p .tueLu^edea '/Oejejosg q6nojqi 'LjjeBsiueqifo .(oe)e)S 'SA (£>-0)Jndsiiiig P!4sia 'jndseiig 'eouepg leoipeiftj io ein}j}SU| ijjeSsiueqijQ 'ssjnoQ SaSM -lesA || ^ostuspnts^je ||V sjesA 1.2 }no.q,& psSy ^wi 'x'v '^a o/s Ae>jjij, tisii.isw iiu.'v sjee/t (.z^noqe psB'g' TC ;SlNdaNud33a •Q -o ^i- •:<^ '^^^'^ ^;:'^^ . :K; vfs:^-'f^'^ fW -.11.- 32 3. Guru Ghasidas University, ThiuuQh Registrar, Guru Ghasidas Uniyersity, Koni, Bilaspur. District- EilaspiifeCC.G.) <, WR'T PETITION N0,414 OF 2006 "..ipR' Jv/sla Prasad Kaushik S/u Siiii S.P. Kaushik, Aged about 22 years AbhiSesh Keshwarni, S/o Shri Narendra Keshwarni, Ageda&out 21 yeare. Lavlesh Gupta, S/e Shn Ram Prasad Gupta, Aged about 20 years. Aii are students of il year, MBBS C&urse, Chhattisgarh Institute of Medic.i.J Seience, Bilaspur, District Bisaspur (C.G.) IBS SSt :',5SSs :"SB81 :i^s^^ ^s^& :^s!ss'- •^•.^h^i^^1'-^ -.•:^^^v: 3^i^^: ssw' ?®SN( vc ^ggp-iiMQCMfR PETiT'OMERS -> ^ State ofChhattisgarh. Tiii'ougn Secreiai'y, Deoartment of Health, »,•' D.K.S. Bhawan, (l.i <-ii(.4fU. Raipurrc.G.) Chhattisgarh institute of Medica! ocience, ihrough Dean, Chhsrtisqarh institute Science, BiSaspur, Bi'laspur iC.G.) Quru Ghas'das University. Thiough Registiar, Guru Ghasidas Univers'ty, Koni, Bilaspur, District ~ ra:?^-".- 'f '''/^- <^ L*'i)<at>fJl^i \\^.^?- of Medical District WR!T PETiTjOM N012 OF,2Q06 4. 'o. A!p' Gcyal, D/o Shri Janaklal Goyai, Aged about 22 years Prachj Jaiswal, D/o Shri M.K, Jaiswal, A.ged about 23 years Reeta, D/o Shri C.N. Mahte, Aged aboi.rt23 years Gitika Shankar Mishra, D/o Shri G.S. Mishra, Aged about 23 yeare Mana'ita Mandhani, D/o Shri Manohar Fviandhani, Aged about fff years Vandana Jaiswai, D/o Shri T.C. .Jaiswal. Aged about 20 years •SSft 39S ^sss- •i?;':?s^i •^^^ sU88 '•:s?!tSs^? ^Si^^ ^^^ .•Kiriia' 12-- 33 Vs Rishu Kejriwa!, D/o Shri Vijay Kurriai Kejiiwal, Aged about20 vears. All are sttreients of Second Year (Secondtemester), MBBS, Chhattisgarh Medical Institute of Sc'fnce, Bilaspur (CG) State of Chhattisgarh, Through its Secretai'y, Department of Health, Mantralaya, D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipur(C.G.1 Chhsi.tt'sgarh Institute of Medical Science, through Dean, Bilaspur (CG) Guru Ghasidas University, Througn Registrar. Koni, Bitaspur rc.G) fviedicai Council of India, Evan-a- Galib Marg, New Delhi (CG) vas. •^^^ a• :^^y::f ;SB! WRIT OPTITION N0.157 OF 2006 PET'TIONEP. Pupaii Bhure, D/o Shri Krishna Rao Bhuie, Aged about 23 years, Student of Second Year (Second Semester'), MBBS Course, Chhattisgarh Institute of Medical Science, Bilaspur, R/o 1 Municipa! Quarter, Near BDM Hospital, Champa, Distt Janjgir-Champa ff~^ r^\ yo.u; Vs. :8BS[ ;J^I RESPONDENTS State of Chhattisgarh, Through its Secretary, Oepartment of Health, Mantralaya, D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipur(C.G.) Chhattisgarh Institute of Medical Science, through Dean, Bilaspur rc.c.) Guru Ghasidas University, Through Registrar, Koni, Bilaspur (C.G.) Medical Council of India, Evan-a- Gaiib Marg, New Delhi (CG) "^^SSs[ .^^^ "sss :^^<:s? ^?^^ ^^ iar-*.' ••^^ 8B -13- 34 Present • Shri U N Awasthy, learned Sr. Advocate with Smt. Rateha Awasthy: Shri K.R. Nair, Shri Vinod Lalchandani and Shri V R. Tiwari. learned counsef foc^tie petitioners. -^..' Shri Prashant Mishra, iearned Add!. Advocate General with Shii Yashwant Singh, learned Govt. Advocate for the State ofChhattisaarh. Shri Arrifito Das, learnec' counsel for the Guru Ghasidas Univeisiry 'and C'MS. M? Samta ,)ain, leamed counsel for MCI. (ORAL ORDER) (PassedonlS February, 200S) l ;^? iSS IS ^%% ^'S :';:?^ ^s ?^ ;;;^^ S'nce the points invoived in a!! these writ petitions are substantially simitar, a." of theT' we'-e clubbed, heard together and they are being disposed of!'",' this comiron order, l;aa!a '^•^^- (2) The points that a'rise for decision-making in this bateh ofwrit petitions. it is stgf®''1 9* thp Bar, are seized by the Apex Court in Writ Petit'on Nn,63"<s of 2005 and coprected writ petitions filed under Artic'e 32 ef th" Con'?w'.!t!-'"-' in that view of the matter, 1 dispose of a!l these writ pstitions, ieaving open ai! the contentions raised by the parties in these >*'r:<: petitions in >:h'ei' respective plead'ngs. No costs. (3) Having cons'der°d the request of the learned counsel for the petitioners fc.r e'<ten?.'on of stay as "/e!! as the opposition raised by the University, 1 think 'rt ju.st and reasonabie to continue the stay for a further , period of one mon'h from today. Accorc'ingly, ! cfirect that interim order,;: u'here"er it '? ai-eady 3"ant"cl in this batch of writ pstltions, shall be in oper?t'on fcr a further period ofone month onlyfrom today. ^i9B '^^'^•k. ;"^^s- '•'^•SKS^: •'f.iS^^ "s '•^:"... ^s^^sl [ .••^^S& E6 Sd7- The ChiefJustice f S^Aii Bi-nj'