“\\ )Q( ElgH €QLJkT QF JUEI5ATL1RE AT 3ELA§PUR (Q Wri‘i‘ $g‘i‘ifion No.3?6g 61": 2§G§ Ram Prasad, 5k) Chcmi , Aged abou‘i‘ 33 year's, Casua! Labour, R/o village K01“ Dam, Tehs’H: Baikun?hpUF l \ m L1 PEHTLONEE: D isTT. Koriya {C.Q,). - Versus — ' DESTMCT: Kor‘iya (Q6) §){;g 5% §§3§g egg: 1%“ s§wgagg wag L.C.BHADOO Judge ’ir I QESPONDENTS: The S.‘D.O., ubiic 5 -!!ea§??iEs'sgmearing, Qaikun‘rhpur, DEWEG: acriya. 2. 5hr‘i P5. Rm, §xe€u“§*iv2 E@i‘r1é2r‘, Hfaiic Haakh §§9Enge?§s§, D ‘gi3im - Baikuni‘hgur, Disfricf: @“qa 3. The €hief Eagi'neei“, Public Heah‘h Enginggrim §a§&%‘?msrr, Raipur Lugj. ‘ 4. Edgineérifxg-m—Chéef Public HeaH‘h Engineering Deparfmani Rmpur’ (€5.69. 5. The Coiiecfor‘, iiiéi—i €CJURT §F EUDEKfAafURE AT BELASPUR 6&6? w” Mir? g . emaw tmi. N§.3993 s g- ai" Ews naa a y I re Hm $ia 3hri Jus?aw ._ {J 3n£dev G§b§§ ’P§ss€a Z (Z# Qapfamba. , hOqa) i. We pe’rii’ioner‘ has preferr‘éd 'i'his pe‘fi‘i'ion under Jir‘i‘ides 226f22? of fhe Cons‘rifuficn of Endia and chal!enged the acfkm m; fhé raspandem‘s by which’ fhéy have PeT'used i’a pay +he saiary for fhe mom-h cf February 2062 and/ aiso for nojK, regumrmmg h§s servisas. / /" PEU ,LONER: Ram Pmsad S/Q Cho‘mi , " Amaa ubuu; Us year‘s, basuai Labour: R/o viHage i’ ‘ Darr‘x Tahsil: Bcikumhpur Dxs‘rT. Koriva (CG). — Versus — QESPONDcNT' F‘ i The 5.D.O., Public HeaH’h Enainearino, Baikunfhpur, Disfricf: Koriva: 2. Shri P5. Qua, Exaéa%i¥a Erxgii‘ieer, Pubk Hgalfh Enginaering, Divigian ~ Eaikunfhpur, Disfricf: Kariya. E: The Chief Enaineer. Pub1ic Heai‘r'h Engineer‘mg Qawrtmem, Raipur (C6,), 4. Engineerin§—%n—"hief PubHc Heal‘m Engineering Depam‘men‘r, Raipur (£16.). 5. The Coi!ec‘ror, DisTr‘icf: Koriva (6.6.). Pregam: - Mr. AK. Gup‘m, Advcca‘re: Far The nefh‘mner‘ Mr. P5. Kos'mi, &0v?. Advccwe : [:cr‘ "Me ‘Tarw espondew‘s Fggw ieading m fiiing mi this writ? pgij‘tian erg 1'ha‘t fhg :3§%d m We Pubiia Healfh DemWm£m cm 1“ $epfember 3‘88 as a casuai iabourer and his name appears in ‘iha iisf pregared byv fhe Dzparfmen‘l‘ cf Casual Labourer, Amexura-Pi’i. Thg pefi'rionar’s case, is fhat ihe Evovemmenf issued a sirguinr far reguiarizirag ifhe servicea‘ m“ ihése cawai iabam‘ers whc were working since 1988. Tire pefi‘i‘iener was reguiar‘iy war-king as a :asuai iabourer, bu? ai! cf a sudden he faii iii gn accoum' azf m¢iié uiEér’ in ihz sfamach ,éxs $12 was mi a'bie i'a pePfGF'm his dui'ias cm accaunf of illness, so he rgmainad absanf from fhz Gigi}; %mm 15‘ Gamber 2§QO fair gefiiig ‘ir—aai-mém‘ mid uiiimai‘eiy on gfh NovemBer 2001 fhe pei-i‘i‘ioner' repor'rad for- ?he du?y after Qbmiaing Tha maéisai aar?ifiaafe and requaggé f0 allaw him it; fake m1 dufy. 0n 9"“ Navambar Kim, {ha gafii’ionar steriad parfor‘ming his dufies regulariy. His saiary far sha masih sf Sséember 3'13}; am! Jamar“; EQCZ was paid, bui- fine salary for‘ the mom‘h oi No‘vember 2001 was nof paia and avan 'rhz saiary far 3'ha mcm'h cf Fgbruary EGOZ has m1“ beam paia‘ aver! ‘ihaug‘n he mms reguiariy serfcrming his du‘ries. His gaining repor‘i‘ is Annexure—P/Z, Medicai Cerfifice'ie is Amsxure—?;’3. The appiiéa‘x‘im submi?fed sy ‘i‘he pafi‘i‘icmr‘ c'n if? fifiar’ch 20(32 is Annexure—P/‘i’ The Assiswm Eagmear alsa recommended his ccsz far paymeri‘i' 0% saiar‘y viée imnexur'e-W5 Ul'i‘imafeiy, when i'hz salary was m’r paid the astifiangr served a nofica ia thg raspcndem's. I‘i is, ihésefai‘e; requesi‘eé i‘ha‘i' em apprawia‘ie wri‘i’ or direc‘i’ion ba issued “For reguiar‘izafion/paymenf of saiary ‘io ?ha satitianer far 'rhs mcm‘h sf Fabmar‘y 2902. Qe‘i'urn has been ‘Fiied on behaii‘ of respandenfs 1., 3,4 and 5 in which caunse! for The respcndsms submirmd ThaT The aeiiiiaaar was pureiy a casuai iabaurar cmd he abserri'ad himsalf from The dui'ies waf. 3Q-9-2QOO and he confinuausly ‘ remained absen? and fhara is m quasi-ion af rainsmfamem and regulariza‘i‘ion of ihe pefi‘iioner. Ti is fo‘raiiy faise i'ha'i 1"‘he gmi'i‘iiensr is working sings Navamber 2001. Since iha‘ N §€fi?i¢§er u ’i “z ()A Cg: dispufed ‘Fnc‘i's are invoived in fine pe‘i'ifion, fhe pe‘i’ifioner can approach me Labaur Ceur? far redressczl cf hi5 grieyahga5‘ If is admi‘i'fed firm? The pafii‘ioner had worked as casuui iabcurzr w.a.f, 1-9-85 m 30-9-2000, fhereaffer he remained (inseri? from ‘;‘%:e du'f‘y’. The metiica} cerfifiaa‘fe submi‘n‘%é§ by fhe pe‘i‘ifienar' i5 719+ from a campe+5n+ mgdical decfor. The mma of ma gafi‘iiarser hag {E233 wrengly sham in 3%: pamzm‘ sheaf +i1a+ ¥ie workeei for fha mo‘m’h of November, December 2001 and January 2002‘ When respondent No2 objeca‘ed an fhe grepcim‘i'ésn m£ The wages for fhé pe?h‘=ianer‘ ‘i‘ar ‘rhé mom‘h of Nevember ZQOI, i’hz Assisfanf Enginegr' namely, Shri 5K. Vewna %1§ruseh‘ arrested ‘rhs wages shee? and arapared We biiis and‘mad'e fhe wages’. Wom fhi's aione, i+ is evidzn‘Hy ciear' fha‘l‘ The Pafifionar had, in fact, nof war-ked in November 3901, Eva} fhéagh i‘ha pe€'i?ianer had m‘r wcrkeé far a singie day in fhe mon‘l‘h of December 2001 and January 2002. The pe?ih’aner m conmvame wéfh Ass§smrw E§gmear Shri 5K. Verma $0fnéhow managed fo 9e? fhé wage s‘me‘f‘ prepar‘éo‘ fcw fha mgnfh of Degember‘ 2001 and Jaguar}! 2QQ2 and dug ”m éver $igh% The wk} gaymenf $62“? was gmm’ed apprava§ and fhe paymen'i‘s have been shown 1‘0 ba made To fhe pe‘?i1’ioner‘ fzw ma momma 9f December 2091 and January 2003, Similarhg $0? *fhe mon‘i’h a1: February 2092 aisa when 'i'hza §é+if§oner somehow managed hi gef fhe wage sheaf grepared, i? wg5 objacfed by rmspw§enf Nee aw i'he biHs were sane?£med affer making necessary carrec‘riens inasmuch as disaiiowing ma slam! of waggs by the gaifianer far ?he mom‘h Gf Feh’r‘uar‘y 20§2. Eirice ‘i'hé pei'i‘i'ianar remaihed absén'i' {ram +hs dufy from 157 Camber 2000, being a ensue! labourer, his eervices eufama‘i‘icaily came #0 via end. The éiscipiinary ac‘rish has been recommended againsi $hri 5k ‘V‘erma, Iissisi‘am- Engineerx Rejoinder has been fiiec‘ on behaif of {he pe'i'i'i'ioner wherein if has been menfioned the? if is wrcng to say fhat The eefifiener remainea’ absenf cannnuousiy and fhereby‘his services have aufoma‘i‘icaiiy came +0 an end, as +he pe+i+ioner was eiek and he JN &ui‘ies an accoum‘ a1: sickness and whan he became perfecf, he made a regor? alang Mfh 111a m£d§gd car‘rifim‘m. He wag aiiéwzd i’a join €1u+y on W” Navzmbar 2333i a‘rw’ amamikgiy, His salary was gmkl far fhg men‘rh Q1? Dzcembar‘ ZQOI! +h¢raaf1'er é'n $§1a ;rma‘fh cf Jémary EQGE ha was pressur'ized by §unimé Engineer Shri VK. Misha, who happéns fa be madia‘for for- Shri Rfi. gag, :Jamandeé R3. 5,QOQ!~, whga thg gag?§*:§gner axpreggzé %is imbiHw, ‘?i—1e pmbiam has been criea‘?acx'. Tha 9gfi1‘iener has annexed fhz documenfg Annaxura-Fil & W2, A péra5§! x3“? %he said dccumer‘sfs ravaaéa‘ %%1::='§' %he §a?§?icmr~ had wen‘f 1"o his work yiace u‘p fa 20—8-2G02, ’how‘eVer respondem’ Na; was fransfer‘red frem Baikumh?ur and Sm! fhe §ai§$ianer is gi‘iing ‘m his wark piaca aw? he i$ m? aiiawing fine pairiiaazr 1-9 Perferm his du‘i‘ies dua +9 insfruc‘i‘igns Q‘F 5hri RS. Rag §e$pan$erif No.2 is reguizir‘iy misusiiig his powar‘s‘ i-‘ar’ exampie one Mr. RK. Kurmi worked oniy 'Fcr 1§ days in fi'ie monfh of Marah 2003 and wh% ‘2-‘hé; aiiwiii aiiwdama shag? wam ”w r‘ésponaen‘i‘ _. A -‘.a No.2, ne canceiieo ii ‘i‘he iamgzs 1,; srieef, ,‘ Annexurz—i ‘, Hr»;- -4( c) and inraparad g fra$h wgges shagti wharain he ha§ anhangad iiic- ai'iériéaruca fGr‘ 19 days :md prapare-d fha biii m1 his mam accoun‘i‘. There are reguiar‘ compiain'i's againsf raspondenf n Nag am cm. 4W WK. Mishra. I:1 ma .aewspapar dag The-is" iiiegai atiis’ris have bazi puElisi-iza. X havg hard The laarngd cognsgi far frhe gar‘ries ané gemsed fhé wewds. A perusal af fha Annexura~Pf5, iah‘ar wrif’ran by Assis‘mni Engiws? $haws ‘ihai' ‘i‘he pé‘i‘iiizmer‘ repar‘iéé aimig wiih medical ceri’ifica‘i’e on 9-11-2601 and he was aiiowed ‘i‘o faka 0n almy, In This ieffer" he has aiso mamimed mm cn accaun? 6f siama aiiéi‘wfian bei'weé'r‘i Junia?‘ Eiaginéar‘ Mr. Vii Mishré ar1& Tina paifiangr, fhe sniar‘y bill Qf lhe pgiilionar‘ was disallewed (31"?2r‘ wifiag m flag wa§é§ shag? lay l‘m‘. Vii. Mishm. When a show cause nofice was issued +a ‘rhe Assisi-an? Engineer. he repligd vida Annexuré—PK3 which shgws That fhe pg?i?ianer hail jcirié§ %is d‘uiies an 9-11-2901 and he alsa rnzn‘l‘ianati llia‘i’ affer 3vmon‘rl‘1s if has bean said thal‘ why ‘rhs salary has been paitl sc i‘hs pesii‘ismf mid if has bass furi‘ner mzmis'ned slur? h 9n gu ‘ in f'he ma‘i'i'ar of Ram Prasad fhe acfion is no? Jusfified. Annexura-P!5 algng with ma salary sm‘ramgn? fer- Thg menfh w? Navamsiaér‘ Hsél‘? $§1§w5 i'ha% +412 pay hm G‘F peiiiimiar‘ was: przparad which was ul'l'imafeiy disallowed on fhe order cf Rggpcnélan? NG.2. In fl’m circumsfanéas, #hé pa?if§m1 m‘ %he pa‘ri‘i‘ioner up f0 The ex'i'en‘r m?" paymem‘ of salary for fhz mom‘h o‘;‘ Febmary 2992 deserves m bg allowad‘ ii. 3s far as +l1e quesfion of ragulariza‘l’ion O‘l: ll’la pe+i+io7ler anu‘ “For allowing him ah: commug his work Es congerned, for Tho? purii’zosg $2 clispuwé focE are ”rher'é and ‘rhe pe‘%i%éoaer is a? liberl‘y fo move befora 'l'l'se appropria‘i‘e cour‘l' For radrgs$ol o1: Pas grievames. in ‘l'l'le resuif, "rhe gefiilon of "line pafi'fioner is parfly allowed and me. raggondenfs are dimcmd m make ‘lha pgymem' for we mom'h of Fabr-uary 2002 ‘m 'l‘ha pel‘ifioner. Res? o€ i‘he gefition is disallowad as menfionad above, A/ l ' . " » /’/// SN. Ju&ge /? V 2 'f"'” ‘ l 7 ‘