UUUKT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BIIABPUK CTiminal Appeal Wo. ^Tl/1»93 Kunwar yuigti, s/o yiin Kamlal, aged l^ Y£32'S . T/Q yill&GS RllandST. PolJCR !'>'^r' '^^•-^-^^i-^-*-'-*•'-•*-*• ^ -*- ^/A^.'^-V/ srauon, 'r'aian., UISTIICT, Kaipur MF Ktate 01 Ni.r. uirougti Hoiice ytatiou Pa1?tn- Histri^t Rainiir. MP PKESBnT: sru-i sameer oinga, Advocate, tor uie appeltaiit. STm Aiav DvK-iv^rl i _ Dv- G-ovt. A/1vor'?ite_ fnr tHe .^tat^ JUD SM B n-T ?20-3-20081 Dblrendra Misttra, J 'rnis cnmuial appeal is..du1ectect agam.st Uie juaginent ol conviction aD.et order ot sentence dated 30m Jaauary, 1993 passed ui o.i'. INO. i/ iyyu wliereDy leamea Additiouat Kessious Juclge Baloda Uajar fias convictetl tlie appeitant under Hectious 3'/b ancl 45U ot l.r.iJ. aiid sentencetl liun to unclergo K.l. tor / veai-s and 3 years respectively. 2. As per tlie report recelved Iroin tfae Ceutral Jail, Raipur, the appeliaat nas oeen reieasecl n-offl jail on l.ii-ll-iyyy atter co.mpletuig Uie seutence miposect Oii lina. o. Heai-cl 'fs'ail Kaineer Suigtl, Acivocate appearmg as Aiaiciis .?'•. Cui-iae on behalfol the appeUaut a^d Shri Ajay Dwivedi, Dy. Govt. Advocate lor tlie Htate. . ^-. • (Jase 01 tjie proseciition, ui Dnet, is Tliat on 4-8-89 at abput ,5.00, fs.to:., the -appellant was a'g.pnptuig 'to comniit rape wifh a gui agecl. aDout.q-.years. 'I'liis •was witaessecl by yiiafciuitala (F.W. 2) wlio urtoniiecl Uie:. motlier ot Uie prosecutrtx aDout the sam.e. Thei''eafter, tlie report was lodged on 6-8-89. T'he proseeutrbt was ^seiiftor nied-ical examimatiou wiiere iJr. Jaisliree Uabe [F.w. 7) 34 examuiecl ner ancl gave medico legal examuiation report ol Bx. f-S, ui wUicli slie noticed reclness over uie pnvate part ot ttte prosecutnx near labia ol tlie proseciiUTX ana sne was coiaplainuig paui also. iitie lui-Uier opuied Uiat atteiapt lias been iiiacte ot sexual uitercourse wittiout coniplete peneU-aUon. 's. 'l'tie tnal Uourt relymg upon Uie statement ot KtiaKuntala Bai (f. W. 'A'J WllO tias statect ttiat .sjie saw tlie prosecutnx lynig on Uie ground ancl weepuig aacl Uie appellant was sittmg nearby alter exposuig fiis pnvate pait aiia slie naiTated tiie inciclent to Kuman Hai, raottier ol t&e prosecutnx aiid 'ootti ol ttieni noticeu uijuiy over pnvate pai-t ot me prosecutnx aiict t&at t&eu' stateiiieiits are turtlier con-oDorated troni t&e inetlical eviclence ot Ur. Jaisnree tr'.W. i'], tias convictect uie appellaut nncter Kectiou oYO aiicl 45U ol I.P.C. and senteaced-as menfioned above. o. Alter gouig Uirougn tiie statenient ot yiiafcuntala [r.W.'2] as also Uie stateinent ot r'.W. 3 Ulielctas, f.V/. => Lolaiatli Mul as.ci r'.W. ti r'usKUu wlio liave corroDoratecl uie stateinent ot HliaKuiitala yai ui matei^al paruculars, aiid tteu- eviaence is turtfaer corroborated trom. the version of Dr. Jaishree Dabe (P.W. /), 1 aia ol ttie opniion tliafUie convictioii ot uie appeuaut is based ';K on Tlie eviclence available on recorcl ana Uie tnal Court tias not coiniaittect any lUegaiit^7 or uTtu-mit;' ui Uie mipugiied juclgruent. 7. 'l'&e appeal being clevoicl ot siibstances, cleserves to be '. / clisnussecl aiicl it is jtieretiv ctisinissea. •^.^t Sd/- Dhirendra Mishra Judge MSS