IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA LPA No.110 of 2009 1. Surya Narayan Rai s/o late Dorik Rai, r/o village Samastipur, P.S. Bhagwanpur, P.O. Lakhanpur, District – Begusarai 2. Mithilesh Kumar Pathak s/o late Babu Saheb Pathak r/o village & P.O Bargun,, P.S. Ram Nagar, District – West Champaran 3. Ramdeo Singh, s/o late Lakshman Singh, r/o village & P.O. Harnaraina, P.S. Sjolargamk. East Champaran 4. Bhagya Narayan Thakaur, s/o late Surya Thakur, r/o village and P.O. Katharia, P.S. Kalyanpur, East Champaran 5. Nan Lal Sah s/o late Surya Prasad, r/o village Sekhauna Katharia, P.S. Kalyanpur, P.O. Katharia, East Champaran 6. Nand Rai s/o late Bhulli Rai, r/o village Semra Bazar, P.S. Kalyanpur,P.O. Katharia, East Champaran 7. Baldeo Baitha, s/o late Jangi Baitha, r/o village and P.O. Keola Belwa, P.S. Chakia, East Champaran 8. Radha Kant Singh, s/o late Bharat Singh r/o village and P.O. Singeshni, P.S. – Ramgarhwa, East Champaran 9. Bali Ram Singh s/o late Bilji Singh, r/o village and P.O. Rajepur Nawadah, P.S. – Pakrideyal , East Champaran 10. Jhapas Mahto s/o late Bujur Mahto r/o village and P.O. Parsauni Wazid, P.S. Kalyanpur, EastChamparan 11. Md. Nasim Ansari alias Nasim Ansari, s/o late Faud Ansari, r/o village Semra Bazar, P.O. – Katahria, P.S. Kalyanpur, East Champaran 12. Sidheshwar Singh s/o late Gujju Singh, r/o village Dumri, P.S. Barbigha, P.O. Kusarahi, District – Sheikhpura 13. Sri Jai Prakash Sharma, s/o late Gorey Lal Singh, r/o village Dehri, P.S. Kashichak, P.O. Bhatta, Nawadah 14. Jitendra Kr. Singh, s/o Sri Mishri Sing,. r/o village Dharpur, P.S. Kashichak, P.O. Bhatta, Nawadah 15. Sunil Kr. Singh, s/o Bharat Pd. Singh, r/o village Kurdal, P.O. Mahindwara, P.S. – Runni Saidpur, Sitamarhi 16. Ramesh Kumar s/o late Chandra Shekhar Kumar, r/o village Karamchand Balda, P.O. – Padmaul, P.S. Kurhni, Muzaffarpur 17. Anil Kumar Verma, s/o late Gaji Pd., r/o village and P.O. Agwanpur, P.S. Barh, Patna - 2 - 18. Chandeshwar Pd. Thakur, s/o late Ram Narayan Pd. Thakur, r/o village Gowan, P.O. Padnaul, P.S. Kurahani, Muzaffarpur 19. Rabindra Pd. Singh, s/o late Chandrika Pd. Singh, r/o village Madhopur, P.O. Dharphari, P.S. Paro, Muzaffarpur 20. Birendra Thakur, s/o lateDasai Thakur, r/o village and P.O. Kalyanpur, p.S. Paro, Muzaffarpur 21. Tej Narayan Choudhary, s/o late Madhukant Choudhary, r/o village Rampur, P.S. Sundarpur (Vira) P.S. Sadar, Darbhanga 22. Thakur Sah, s/o late Anmol Sah, r/o village Tenuwa, P.O. Katahria, P.S. Kalyanpur, District Motihari at West Champaran 23. Raghunath Ram, s/o late Mahabir Ram, r/o village Darkukha, P.O. Turki, P.S. Kurhani, Muzaffarpur 24. Nagendra Rai, s/o Sri Randi Rai, r/o village Parhian, P.O. and P.S. Saraiya, Muzaffarpur 25. Yogendra Rai s/o late Satya Narayan Rai, r/o village Parhean, P.O. & P.S. Saraiya, Muzaffarpur 26. Ashraf Ali s/o late Syed Md. Badre Alam r/o village Chak Abdul Ghani P.O. and P.S. Mehsi, East Champaran 27. Shyam Bihari Singh, s/o late Nawal Kishore Singh r/o village Rahua Sakha Ram P.O. Mushari Form, P.S. Mashari, Muzaffarpur 28. Syed Nasir Hussain s/o late Syed Sagir Hasan, r/o village Khemai Patti Dehuri, P.O. & P.S. Meenapur, Muzaffarpur 29. Shambhu Pd. Singh, s/o Chandirka Pd. Singh, r/o village and P.O. Kodai, P.S. Gai Ghat, Muzaffarpur 30. Sidheshwar Pd. Singh @ Bharat Singh, s/o late Bindeshwar Pd. Singh, r/o village Kharna, P.S. Atri, Gaya 31. Basant Pd. Singh, alias Basant Narayan, s/o Bindeshwar Pd. Singh, r/o village and P.O. Kharna, P.S Atri, Gaya 32. Sidheshwar Pd. s/o late Baijnath Mahto, r/o village & PO Mirnagar, P.S. Sermera, Nalanda 33. Athar Hussain s/o late Aedayal Hussain, r/o village Kunjhali, P.S. Nautan, P.O. Kheda, West Champaran 34. Rajdeo Das s/o late Mahesh Das, r/o village Mashawa Bishambra, P.S. Bhairoganj, West Champaran 35. Chandra Bhan Giri s/o late Mauleshwar Giri r/o village Domarua, P.S. Bagha, West Champaran - 3 - 36. Bhuwneshwar Gope s/o Sripati Gope, r/o village Pachmah, P.S. Gurwa, P.O. Chauni, Gaya 37. Sri Abadh Singh s/o late Lakhan Singh, r/o village Rabara, P.S. Keshichak, Nawadah 38. Akhilesh kumar s/o late Rajendra Pd. Sharma, r/o village & P.O. Mohammadpur Susta, Muzaffarpur 39. Madan Prasad, s/o Sri dasu Rai, r/o village Lanka Kachhuara, P.O. & P.S. Gaurichak, Patna 40. Sheo Ram s/o Sri Jahu Ram, r/o village Madhuryanmar P.O. Persapatti, P.S. – Sahebganj, Muzaffarpur 41. Suraj Das, s/o late Julhai Das, r/o village Kushi Kahari P.O. and P.S. Kauri, Muzaffarpur 42. Jaglal paswan s/o late Ram Surat Paswan, r/o village Kishu Nagar Keswa, P.O. & P.S. Kanti, Muzaffarpur 43. Yogendra Paswan, s/o late Ramautar Paswan, r/o village Kanti Harijan Tola, P.S. & P.O. Kanti, Muzaffarpur 44. Manager Ram s/o late Monu Ram r/o village & P.O. & P.S. Kanti, Muzaffarpur 45. Gopi Paswan s/o Bujhawan Paswan, V Kusli Kant Tola, P.O. & P.S. Kanti, Muzaffarpur ……….. Appellants Versus 1. The State Of Bihar 2. Registrar, Cooperative Development, New Secretariat, Patna 3. Bihar State Cooperative Marketing Union Ltd., through its Chairman, Biscomaun Bhawan, Patna 4. Managing Director, Bihar State Cooperative Marketing union, Ltd., Biscomaun Bhawan, Patna 5. Udit Narayan Singh s/o late Indradeo Singh, V Ramnubigha, P.S. Sheikhpura, Sheikhpura 6. Md. Nasim s/o late Md. Yusuf, r/o village Pakkigali, Munger 7. Tej Narayan Singh, s/o Sri Jagdhari Singh, r/o village Chaunpur, P.S. Sajau, Bhagalpur 8. Chandradeo Singh, s/o late Basudeo Pd. Singh, r/o village Khanpur English, P.O. Khanpur Marg, Bhagalpur 9. Mahesh Mandal s/o late Ashiklal Mandal, r/o village Karharia, P.O. & P.S. Bath, Bhagalpur 10. Umesh Kumar Roy, s/o late Bishun Deo Roy, r/o village Richyahi, P.S. Mathiam, Begusarai 11. Shashi Ranjan Singh, s/o late Upendra Nr. , r/o village & P.. Gangaria, Bhagalpur - 4 - 12. Sheo Shankar Prasad, s/o late Lakhan Singh, r/o village & P.O. Behrana, P.S. Barh, Patna 13. Shailendra Kumar, s/o Jagdish Chaudhary, r/o village JaiPrakash Nagar, Khagaria 14. Hari Krishna Chaudhary, s/o late Yugal Kishore Chaudhary, r/o village Survodya nagar, Begusarai 15. Subhash Mandal s/o Sri Bishundeo Mandal, , r/o village Survodya nagar, Begusarai 16. Mahendra Sharma s/o lateDashrath Sharma, P.S. & P.O. Goteharik, Bhagalpur 17. Nand Kishore Singh, s/o Jang Bahadur Singh, , r/o village Baltara, P.S. Gogri, Khagaria 18. Dhananjay Pd. Singh, s/o late Ganesh Singh, , r/o village and P.O. Bagauda, Siwan 19. Indradeo Prasad, s/o late Amrit Mahto, , r/o village & P.O. Oijaw, P.S. Asthama, Nalanda 20. Shatrudhan Singh, s/o late Yogendra Singh, , r/o village Takhat Jagatpur, P.O. Jagatpura, Siwan 21. Ramchjandra Pd., s/o late Shaukni Pd., , r/o village Krishnapuri, P.O. Korra, Hazaribagh 22. Manikant Yadav, s/o late Madhu Yadav, , r/o village Alakjara, P.S. Jhajha, Jamui 23. Awadhesh Kr. Srivastava, s/o late Chandrika Pd. Srivasta, r/o village Sheetalpur, P.O. Langerpura (Mairwa), Jamui 24. Suresh Giri s/o late Jagarnath Giri, , r/o village Kohiawan Khurd, P.S. Ram Nagar, West Champaran 25. Jaishankar Kumar s/o late Yaduvansh kumar, , r/o village and P.O. Harnaraina,East Champaran 26. md. Murtaza Hussain, s/o late Abdul Bari, , r/o village and P.O. Beoraha, Darbhanga 27. Dinesh Sharma s/o late Ramutar Sharma, , r/o village Kutri P.O. Naro Mura, P.S. Warsaliganj, Nawadah 28. Bishwanath Singh, s/o late Ramlal Singh, , r/o village P.O. & P.S. Suryapura, Rohtas 29. Lalan Singh, s/o Sri Surya Singh, , r/o village Hatia, P.O. Amarura, P.S. Godari, Rohtas 30. Awadh Kishore Pandit, s/o late Ram Badayut Pandit, , r/o village nadwan, P.O. Baraipur, Chapra 31. Ram Naresh Mahto, s/o Ram Waran Mahto, , r/o village Napoya, P.S. Bamapur, Chapra 32. Baleshwar Singh, s/o Mauzelal Singh , r/o village Karamchand Beldu, P.O. Padmaul, P.S. Kurhani, Muzaffarpur - 5 - 33. Heera Paswan, s/o late Nathuni Paswan, , r/o village Kushi Tola, P.O. & P.S. Kanti, Muzaffarpur 34. Hemant Kumar Dhir, s/o late Ram Krishna Dhir, , r/o village P.O. & P.S. Jalay, Darbhanga 35. Yogendra Tiwari, s/o late Rameshwar Tiwari, , r/o village and P.O. Kamrauli, P.S. Piprahi, Darbhanga 36. Rajendra Pd., s/o Ishwar Daya, , r/o village masarh, P.O. Jagdali, P.S. Godanganj (Ghosi), Jehanabad 37. Jainandan Singh, s/o Ramchandra Singh, , r/o village and P.O. Baurahi, P.S. Dhanarwa, Patna ………. Respondents ----------- 2 12-02-2009 We have heard the appeal on merit. The impugned order in the present appeal was also impugned in several appeals, i.e. L.P.A. No.1030 of 2008 and analogous appeals. In the said appeal, we have upheld the order of the learned Single Judge and dismissed the appeal. In that view of the matter, this appeal will have the same fate and, accordingly, it is also dismissed in limine. Neyaz/- C. K. Prasad, ACJ. S. K. Sharma, J.