r^ iS^ ^' 'y^ 2-Z^ HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR '^^^?g^^w^-^' ;"""'"'"'^''''^^'^fS.S^z PETITIONER : Smt. Lata Singh W/o Deeb Singh, aged about 36 years, Sub Engineer, Public Heaith Engineering, Sub Division No. l,Bilaspur(CG). VERSUS RESPONDENTS : 1. State of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department of Public Health and Engineering Division, Raipur (CG). 2. The Under Secretary, fiepartment of Public Health, Dau Kalyan Singh Bhawan, Raipur (CG). 3. The Executive Engineer, Public Health Engineering, Deptt. Division Bilaspur, DisU. Bilaspur (CG). 4. Mr. Sunil Kumar Shukla, Asstt. Engineer, Public Health and Engineering Division, Sub Division No. 1. Bilaspur (CG). (WMT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTTnjHON OF INDU) (SB: Hon'ble Mr. Satteh K. Asnihotn, J.) Present : Shri Vinay Pandey, Advocate for the petitioner. Shri Y.S. Thakur, Deputy Advocate General for the State/respondent No. 1 to 3. ORALOROER (Passed on 21 day ofjuly, 2008) 1. With the consent of the parties, the matter is taken up for hearini finally. 2. The petitioner impugns the transfer order dated 30.06.2008 (Annexure P/l), whereby, the petitioner, working as Sub Engineer, has been transferred from Public Health Engineering Sub Division No. 1, Bilaspur, to Public Heath Engineering, Division Bilaspur, on the ground that this order is maiafide. 3. Shri Pandey, leamed counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that the petitioner has filed a complaint against the respondent No. 4 and a writ petition is also pending in this Court, on that account, the State Govemment has transferred the petitioner. The contention of the petitioner that this amounts to malafide is misplaced as the respondent No. 4 is an Assistant Engineer and the order has been passed by the Govt. of Chhattisgarh, Public Health Engineering Department, alongwith 41 more persons. Thus, the allegation made by the petitioner is not snflficient to hotd that there is a Rroved malafide: TKe ftefitioner 'l!liNHIil]!t i!lil lilt »![ NH IBii EJiili liiiiifIII ISilt IIUij; IHtli aiBiBittii' Itl'llilJH^H^: riiij :;E ..; <; t ! •e:: Sahu !N'iv l^,^^sncftiGfiaUjeaigi^^tiJMs.|)e^ifij^ 'non^oifflpeten(ie^|j£lffie|^ffi^||a^ua|g|t^s(:Bp3^;^^ ^.sEtatutoiyjiiiles;|and:,®egi2a^n^|@B|iK:(^^ ,^^placedj;:fi-om.c^^ofiice,1%atliei||w|ll^ aild'h .&uiul5||would.fbeja.|^®teffilis|lm^ •4..;Tiaasfer:is'an|iHeidient^seI^iisaKli|Sil|-^ tovyie^apau^ interest as 1^1 as ;adnMmsfeFative|exigen^^^^^^ junsdiction "tQ'iKtea-fei^ mB|tiG^|Eaffl mterfera <ml®tffi^th®^ '••;>'::ailrthonty%pa.^mg^^,ltii|ga^^ ^.'.Confot'mity,,^ji1}i;th.e'.Sri^ cannottiepermttted]1orefflainatone^^^^ 5. The pefitioner ^astnot niade cmt a caise^for shovHng iriterferanee witU j the transfer or4eF^ tUe^^a^^ ^:; petitiiMii^tde^eill^mei^ Sd/- Satish K. Agnihotri Judge IH^ M^i. •:;IIM ..:J)IIB ;' !. ] :.:.;..,^,,^!i^!tj^;i :i^i^.-}'^^ys s -::;::ii.'';:ii^Sl:^;;3.:;;iiS% 3ji'1^yll!s;!IMI"illBS