IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT : THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE K.T.SANKARAN MONDAY, THE 21ST FEBRUARY 2011 / 2ND PHALGUNA 1932 OP(C).No. 500 of 2011(O) ------------------------------ (O.S. NO.949/2008, SUB COURT, THRISSUR) ............. PETITIONER/PLAINTIFF ----------------------------- SANIL.K.MOHAN,S/O.MOHANAN PILLAI, NOW AT CHAITHANYA,CHANANGAD,OTTAPPALAM. BY ADVS. SRI.DINESH R.SHENOY SRI.G.HARIKRISHNAN RESPONDENT(S): DEFENDANTS ------------------------------------- 1. JANAKI AMMA,D/O.NANIKUTTY AMMA, KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519,AKKIKAVU, KUNNAMKULAM(DIED). 2. MEENAKSHIKUTTY AMMA.K,W/O.RAGHAVAN NAIR, CHAITHANYA,MANJAKKALMCHERUPPULASSERY PO, PALAKKAD,PIN 679 503. 3. LAKSHMIKUTTY AMMA,D/O.JANAKI AMMA, KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519, AKKIKAVU,KUNNAMKULAM. 4. ANANDAVALLI,D/O.JANAKI AMMA, KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519, AKKIKAVU,KUNNAMKULAM. 5. GOVINDANKUTTY,S/O.JANAKI AMMA, CHANGALATH HOUSE,ANNAKARA,ELAVATHOOR,THRISSUR, PIN 680 519. 6. RAJAGOPAL,S/O.JANAKI AMMA, KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519, AKKIKAVU,KUNNAMKULAM. 7. MURALEEDHARAN,S/O.JANAKI AMMA, KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519, AKKIKAVU,KUNNAMKULAM. svs .........2/-... ...2... OP(C).No. 500 of 2011(O) 8. AMBUJAKSHI.K,W/O.VENUGOPAL,KARTHIKA, MANJAKKAL,CHERUPPULASSERY,PALAKKAD,PIN 679 503. 9. KOMALAVALLI.K,W/O.MOHANAN PILLAI, KARUNALAYAM,KAPPRASSERY,NEDUMBASSERY PO, 683 585. 10. SIVSANKARAN.K,S/O.NARAYANA MENON, KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519, KUNNAMKULAM,THRISSUR. 11. PREMALATHA.K, W/O.VELAPPA MENON,SOUPARNIKA, CHAITHANYA COLONY,CHANKUVETTY,KOTTAKKAL, MALAPPURAM,PIN 676 503. 12. SHYAMALAVALLI.K,W/O.VENUGOPALAN,VYSHAK, CHERUPPULASSERY,PALAKKAD,PIN 679 503. 13. INDIRA,D/O.JANAKI AMMA,REP.BY HER SISTER AND POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER MEENAKSHIKUTTY AMMA, D/O.JANAKI AMMA,CHAITHANYA,MANJAKKAL, CHERUPPULASSERY PO,PALAKKAD. 14. ANIL,S/O.MEENAKSHIKUTTY AMMA, CHAITHANYA,MANJAKKAL, CHERUPPULASSERY PO,PALAKKAD,PIN 679 503. 15. SUNIL,S/O.MEENAKSHIKUTTY AMMA, CHAITHANYA,MANJAKKAL, CHERUPPULASSERY PO,PALAKKAD,PIN 679 503. 16. RAVEENDRANATHAN.K,S/O.LAKSHMIKUTTY AMMA, AVITTOM,SAWMILL ROAD, KOKKALA,THRISSUR,PIN 680001. 17. LAKSHMI,D/O.LAKSHMIKUTTY AMMA, KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519,AKKIKAVU, KUNNAMKULAM,REP.BY HER MOTHER AND P/A.H. LAKSHMIKUTTY AMMA,D/O.JANAKI AMMA,KOTTAYIL, KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519,AKKIKAVU, KUNNAMKULAM. 18. RAMKUMAR,S/O.LAKSHMIKUTTY AMMA, KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519,AKKIKAVU, KUNNAMKULAM,REP.BY HER MOTHER AND P/A.H. LAKSHMIKUTTY AMMA,D/O.JANAKI AMMA,KOTTAYIL, KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519,AKKIKAVU, KUNNAMKULAM. svs ..........3/-.... ...3... OP(C).No. 500 of 2011(O) 19. MOHAN,S/O.ANANDAVALLY, KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519,AKKIKAVU, KUNNAMKULAM. 20. NIRMALA,D/O.ANANDAVALLY,KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL, KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519,AKKIKAVU,KUNNAMKULAM, REP.BY HER MOTHER AND P/A.H.ANANDAVALLY, KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519,AKKIKAVU, KUNNAMKULAM. 21. SALEELA,D/O.ANANDAVALLI,KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL, KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519,AKKIKAVU,KUNNAMKULAM, REP.BY HER MOTHER AND P/A.H.ANANDAVALLY, KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519,AKKIKAVU, KUNNAMKULAM. 22. RENU,D/O.AMBUJAKSHI,KARTHIKA,MANJAKKAL, CHERUPPULASSERY PO,PALAKKAD,REP.BY HER P/A.H. AMBUJAKSHI,W/O.VENUGOPAL,KARTHIKA, MANJAKKAL,CHERUPPULASSERY PO,PALAKKAD, PIN 679 503. 23. ANU,D/O.AMBUJAKSHI,KARTHIKA,MANJAKKAL, CHERUPPULASSERY PO,PALAKKAD,REP.BY HER P/A.H. AMBUJAKSHI,W/O.VENUGOPAL,KARTHIKA, MANJAKKAL,CHERUPPULASSERY PO,PALAKKAD, PIN 679 503. 24. ANITHA,W/O.SUNNU,PULARI, THURUTHUSSERY,MEKKAD PO,ALUVA,PIN 683 589. 25. SINDHU RAJESH,D/O.PREMALATHA, SOUPARNIKA,CHAITHANYA COLONY,CHANKUVETTY, KOTTAKKAL,MALAPPURAM,REP.BY HER POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER & FATHER K.VELAPPA MENON R/AT DO. DO. PIN 676 503. 26. BHAGAVATHI NARAYANA PANICKER, W/O.LATE KUTTY NARAYANA PANICKER, KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519, AKKIKAVU,KUNNAMKULAM. 27. SREEDHAR NARAYANA PANICKER, S/O.LATE KUTTY NARAYANA PANICKER,KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL, KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519, AKKIKAVU,KUNNAMKULAM, REP.BY HIS P/A.H.BALAKRISHNA NARAYANA PANICKER, KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519, AKKIKAVU, KUNNAMKULAM. svs ...........4/-..... ...4... OP(C).No. 500 of 2011(O) 28. BALAKRISHNAN NARAYANA PANICKER, S/O.LATE KUTTY NARAYANA PANICKER,KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL, KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519, AKKIKAVU,KUNNAMKULAM. 29. SIVAKUMAR,S/O.KUTTY NARAYANA PANICKER , KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519, AKKIKAVU,KUNNAMKULAM. 30. JAYASANKAR,S/O.KUTTY NARAYANA PANICKER , KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519, AKKIKAVU,KUNNAMKULAM. 31. VENUGOPAL,S/O.KUTTY NARAYANA PANICKER , KOTTAYIL,KOTTOL,KARIKKAD PO,PIN 680 519, AKKIKAVU,KUNNAMKULAM. 32. K.VELAPPA MENON,S/O.KUNNATH NARAYAIKUTTY AMMA,SOUPARNIKA,CHAITHANYA COLONY, CHANKUVETTY,KOTTAKKAL,MALAPPURAM,PIN 676 503. R5 BY ADV. SMT.K.NANDINI THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 21/02/2011, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: svs K.T.SANKARAN, J. ------------------------------ O.P(C).No.500 OF 2011 ------------------------------ Dated this the 21st day of February, 2011 JUDGMENT The petitioner is the plaintiff in O.S.No.949 of 2008 Sub Court, Thrissur. The suit is for partition. The plaintiff applied for a temporary injunction restraining the defendants from alienating or encumbering the property and committing any acts of waste in the property. It is stated that the trial court initially granted an order against the alienation. It is alleged that the respondents unauthorizedly removed earth from the property, which is estimated at Rs.20 - 25 lakhs. The Sub Court granted injunction as prayed for, as per Ext.P3 order dated 2nd January, 2009. It is alleged that the respondent violated the order of injunction. I.A.No.491 of 2011 was filed by the plaintiff (Ext.P5) under Rule 2A of Order XXXIX of the Code of Civil Procedure. That application was filed on 14th January, 2011. The grievance of the petitioner is that the violation O.P(C).No.500 OF 2011 2 of the injunction continued and a padippura was demolished by the respondents. Some photographs are also produced to show that the padippura was demolished. The 5th respondent, in the counter affidavit filed in this Original Petition, contended that he did not commit violation of injunction. 2. When the Original Petition came up for admission on 4th February, 2011, the following order was passed: “It is submitted that though Ext.P5 application was filed against all the defendants in the suit, defendants 5 and 6 were mainly involved in the violation of the order. It is submitted that they continue to violate the order passed by the court below. The suit is posted for trial in the list on 14.2.2011. 2. In these circumstances, it is sufficient if notice is issued to respondents 5 and 6 in the Original Petition. 3. Urgent notice before admission to respondents 5 and 6, who are defendants 5 and 6. The petitioner is permitted to serve notice on respondents 5 and 6 by serving notice on their counsel in the trial court. Post on 16.2.2011. O.P(C).No.500 OF 2011 3 It is made clear that the trial of the suit may go on.” 3. The 6th respondent is not served with notice. The 5th respondent entered appearance. 4. It is not necessary to keep the Original Petition pending, since the suit is listed for trial. The prayer in the Original Petition is to issue a direction to the court below to dispose of I.A.No.491 of 2011 expeditiously, and also for a direction to the trial court to ensure that Ext.P3 injunction order is enforced. 5. The learned counsel appearing for the 5th respondent submitted that the 5th respondent undertakes not to commit any acts in derogation of the order of injunction granted by the trial court. 6. I am sure that the trial court will dispose of I.A.No.491 of 2011 at the appropriate time. The O.P(C).No.500 OF 2011 4 petitioner cannot insist that it should be disposed of on a particular date. Sometimes the court below may find it necessary to consider the evidence as well. Since the suit is at the final stage, I do not think any particular direction is required. If the petitioner is aggrieved by any violation of the injunction order, he would be free to approach the court below for appropriate reliefs. The Original Petition is disposed of as above. K.T.SANKARAN, JUDGE. cms