1 FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET NO. IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY APPELLATE SIDE NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR First Appeal No. 358/2007 Appeal District : Application No. of 200 Writ petition Office Notes, Office Memoranda of Coram, appearances, Court's orders or directions Court's or Judge's orders and Registrar's orders. CORAM : Smt. V. A. Naik, J. DATED : 6 th June, 2007. Heard Shri Pillai, learned counsel for the appellant. It appears from the perusal of the judgment that the Member, Industrial Court Chandrapur had rightly declared that the provisions of Employees State Insurance Act were not applicable to the respondent during the period from 15.07.1993 to 31.03.1996 and the recovery proceedings initiated by the appellant against the respondent were illegal and improper. It cannot be said by any stretch of imagination that the cartmen who had given carts on rent were paid the wages and were therefore employees of the respondent- Establishment. Findings of fact recorded by the Member, Industrial Court Chandrapur are based on a proper appreciation of the material evidence on record. Since no substantial question of law arises for 2 consideration in this appeal the same is dismissed with no order as to costs. JUDGE svk