19% W3 Islam HEW (:imm‘i‘ m trHgA'l‘T‘iwARH ‘xgggwwggyg WRI'E‘ ?i€’i‘i’§‘l(}iN (S) N0. 2km aflw§ P’‘E ETIEONERS : 1“ Sitaram Sahu 3/0 Shri 'Nanhuram Saba; aghad 3mm 38 years, presaimy 9osmd at Gwermmsm E’i‘immy Schsolg SonpurL mock Pandariag Dimict — Kahirtilmm Kym 2. Balmukund Maheshwari 3/0 Shri Lamiimmin: aged abuui 38 Vmua pmgmtw wstéd 33 Gavex‘mmeilt ?rimarv Sahaei imda Biock ii‘amiaria; District — Kabiriiham {C.G .) . T‘uiaram Kaghyap Sin Shri Pal-2111M}. Kashyap: atgedl eki‘mu‘t E9 yaai‘s, pmgemiy pwwii‘ ai, Gavammmxt Higher $ec0ndarv Schooir Ghograkaiap Block. — Paugdmia, Bimini iiaami‘ddzam {C(31) 4. Jsewaxq Laa. Ibewangan Sm Shri Rama Thwmgzm, aged abu‘u‘t 39 years, presentiy pasted at Gavannnemt Primary Sohsol; Thitixari" Biack _ Eaijpm, {Tiisirict — Iai‘gigirmCmmpa (mu. ) 3mt Vemdiana Mashi Wm Shri Ra'gies'h Mashi. agad amui 39 ywrg, prwem‘tiy pi‘;gteé 3L: 6Qvm'mi'xéilt Wimarv SGhooin Dhzma§i 13203}: Pamiaria. E)i5t1‘ict ‘ KEihil‘uii‘iMi} {66.) ' (i. Smt. Rekha Siagh Wit) $5hri Let: $ingh, agecl about 43 yaw, preswtly paswé ai Govargmwm Pmnwy Schcok Me§1aJL 'Eilock ~ Eindmm, Distrém; — Kabflrc’iham {CG} ’7‘ Ghaushyam Kumar ikwangan S/o Sht‘i Omjilai Dewaugzm, gal abwt 38 veam prewm‘dy pmwil at Gowmnmnt Primarv Sshmi Paheéda, Bleak. Nawagarha D§miat ~ Jamj gir-Ciw1wa {(1.6 .) . 38 S3111; wars, {Suiekha pre$eixtiy Singh W/o gjoswd Shw'i at Len GGvaa'mma-nt Sémh. aged Fii‘mai‘y 1mm: Sch601 Surajpura, Blxmk Pandariaw Disirict ‘— Kabiréham (C G.) 9, .‘fhzxiliram Rait‘ev S/e Shri Bisauia} Rcttrav agad abmlt 39 wars, pregcmfiy pvSxed at Gmwmmem Primary SghtE-QI Andhiyarkhor, mock — Pandaxim mmct Kabirdham (06.) 19.8wtosh Kumar Shrivas Sm Shri Panchram Sivivag pagad 37 yaam, pi’ewwdy 903w} at Gavm‘imieiit Higher Sacomiarv Schod E’a§mi, Bitwk Pandaria, Digwbt Kabmilmm {06;}: ' 11.Shaikhu Ayah S/o Shri Khaékh Kmu: wad 31mm, 37’ yeaw, presenily paged at Govm‘mmni Pi'm'im'y Schoni Mainpura, Block. E’andaria, {)is:£rict I(&bir€1.ham (C(32) 12.Makhania1 Senwani S/c Shri (Ehomlal Sommni: aged abwt 48 ygm’ga gi‘wamiy pé$t$d ai' G-ovea‘mlem ff‘f" b} {‘f‘N L’I ‘Dé 7E} ( } x ’ C7} Higher Secondary Schoai, Pandm‘ia, Digtrict Kabirdhma (C.G.) '£3.Shyam Bharose Sonwaxli S/o Slbri Samamram $0nwaxai, aged abwz 38 years, yewmiy paged at Gnvemment E’rémmy Sghocd Maugaom Bhck I’amiaréa, Diwict Kabirdl‘izml {CGJ 14rS1‘n‘egb Kumar Chelkar Sm Shari Chhadilal Chelkar. aged abam 41 years, girtzsaKly whim} ai Gavzimimnt M'iekiie Sahoe'i, Bibck He§hay 1hi$1yi<3t Bilaspur (CL?) §V5.Vija,yaial Farvi Slo Shari Ramsshwar Prasaé Fan/L aged about 43 wars; presemtly pogiw m Gavei‘m‘nma‘i Primary School, ROQSgkapzg Black Pan§ariag lbistric? Kabirdham {CG} 16.Smtn Sheeia Mishra W/o Shri Krishna MiShm: aged about 39 yeai‘s, pregemly pageéi at Gaveriimmt Primary School. Kunda, Biock. Paneiaria, District Kahirdham (C135) E7. Ayjun La} Soawani S/o Skid Chaitram Sonwani agad ébout 39 yam'g, {waied at Govex‘muem I‘Riighm‘ Seoondaw School Hammadi? Block —~ Pandaria, Dislrm Kabiretxmm (cm 1,8,Muksssh ”l‘haiwr Sic 53m Pmchmm 'i‘hakur. prewmiy po'smd a‘i Govmmicm Pl‘miary §cl100L Sai‘al 3&1}. l9.Niranian Kumar Pandey S/o Shrl Dinessh Kumar. pmwmly paisiecl at Goveymmani Primzary Sclmol,_ Parsiya, Distrlot ~ Bilawur (CK?) QRKaieslnwar E’rasad $ahuz aged about 39 years, mosently aog‘tm ai Govmmioixi Mioélc Scliool, Kanhaivzxm fllock ~ Nawagama llllistrm * .lanjgir—. Champa {C‘a} 2L$mt $heela. .Karshamrzml W/o Shri Am} Kesharwam. algal} about 47 yeaira, pregamly poated at Govmmlem Higher Sacomiary School. Padhi, Elook — Pandaria: Bimict Kabiréham (C11) State of Chhaitlsgarh Through :. Secretary, Dopamnem of gallool Edocaiioli, D.K.3LBhawatL Mammiay¢ Raipur (C.G.) 2“ Dismal, Education Qi’llceL District ’ Kabirciham CG.) 3. Dlmiot Education ()ffica‘r, District ~ .‘fanjgir — Champa (CGC) 4. District Eouoation {Kilicen bisslriot a Bila$p11r {C.G.} 5. Block Eéuoaiion Ollicer, Block Paridm‘iag Dismat ~ Kalbiré‘lhmn {6.6.} 6. Block Educaiion Oilloor‘ Block — Jaijpur, Maoist J&o§gir—Champ& {C.G.} VERSUS 'R'ESE’ON})ENT$ Present: ix; ’I /w£: A v»yf ’i’. Biook Eéucation .Qfficor, Eiock Nawagarh’ Distriot — Jaiijgir-Chaimm (C.G.) 8. Block Education Offioen Block Belhay District ~ Bilagpur (CG) ' RAREICLB226/ZZ7GFflHhQONmHTJHUNOP mmA E SB: &i0n’ble Shri $atish K. Aggiiy%l Smt. Anju Ahu§a Advecatg for the peiincmem Sim Ajay Ewiveuii, Deputy Gmiammmm Advaca‘te far {kw Staie/ respondenm gawaqgzmi (?asgsd on HE day cf April, 2008) Leamésd Comma! appgaring for the peti‘iieners as well a3 for me Stata/respondenm jeintEy submit that the fiaCtg am? quesiian of iaw invoived m fhe presem wrii patitior; are square£y caverefi by tha decisimn ofthis {hurt in the caw'a 0fA‘N,V.Satyanarayan £5 Othenm Vs“ S‘tata 0f Chhattisgarh 8:: Oihers {WW8} No. 69"f/2907} $ecéded on 07.02.20‘Q’7. Leanwd uounsei zlpysa‘ring for the. pe’zitignem hass painted eut {ha circukar dateci 13.9.1974 whex‘eunder awarding i0 Smii. Abuja, thg wiitiomrs: who had «>5tained B.Ed./B.T.I Examination Cemfica’tes befere appoimment, are aiso mtitied ‘to twa azivanw incmmems‘ The said Circuiar reads as unc‘ier: “gaékiem WWW wé‘ gm'fm §1w5f w? W511; Fm? $3 air {am I{E§Ia:ga,/ga?1f%a a‘daHr-Jf? Ii’ Q'EWkd mum? m? a? W zgg’wii HEW: 3% m? $11 aw ‘g‘a1fEm Wm? 2153‘ fmw %‘ wwwfwwi$ww$§¥i§f§afmwaam ur‘éax‘a? '&‘<W W1??? w-wim E? iari'q‘2% 95 ‘Q‘amii 'i‘ké? mr% Er? 9J3€$I s3! Hf%§m?‘ E5? 111a fanfém’ a? ?fT-¥ m m W: raw EW? a? my 1? Hg: Ufa @mrm § €5 2% mfmmma§mwq1$mqmm§$ w mw: "am gam‘i‘ mm awai é“ w? www- ‘éifa Rm} W#W€m1§1§§%$g§mm$m§ w§31Wf gm? §NH 33? a? am ii? Wg’fw 2i? Ema wm‘ mafm ézm 3? ari? Win ‘aa'rm W W W W mm; ‘Gféf mi? Wi’f‘tmi $im‘a3‘?’ as"? Wm 35%? ‘Eiaw ‘qikm' ma: 2W3! am W4 %. HE: m ‘fm mm § 1%? gW‘xW‘m ‘ $ §’r. g aw {q§é)&aWW%mmiw§§%W$wWf§ 3ri?m a i‘ $3 m “ maf? i T raspondents/State; whiie coiderg the casgs 0f the itionersn sham rant ti: miiaf; n cordance with the cimuiar 5yuprq}. For e aforemsntitma reasons, the wr§t mtititm w isgmsed f in iermS Gf‘e deciSian of tl's Court in 1&6 atter f A.N.‘V.atyanarayan $5 hes (imma), subject to erificaticn f e fact as whethw the petio‘s haw: acauired BJMJfi'ill. cercaie on thai own axpmsas per tbs circulars dated 24.‘21998 and €11,03‘99 and rthavr h hav ad he nsin m g nt i ac th tE (i o ih n m 0 S Otr v o th m tinm l iifi‘ r ag 3 E9 fa wether they e been paid two vanw inoremxams 0r not" V Sd/- I Satish K. Agnihe : tri Judge \... wH#gWw gféw $1 aw m a5? § . ..