@ w$H CQgR'i‘ OF 6%iiATTiSGARi-i AT BILAS§9i$R $inaie Eench: Haa’bie $mi éustiee Prashaat Kumar Mishm MA. NG.S&8 I 2992 é? PELLAN?$ MA. Chanciy and ansther. Versus gEiSPONDENw Santosh Kumar Yadav and others. 3hr: PS. Kashy and Shri Raj Kama! Gupta, ccunse£ fer the appeihnta Dim; mm Aiay Swiveut coumel fer respondents No. 1 & 2. 3m HP. Agrawak, counse! fer resgcndent NG.3. 4/ $WF€AL §JNQER SEGTI’JM $?$ QF THE MGTGR VEHI£LE ACT 1§8§ QFAL ORQER {2Q‘§8.291$} Heard. £2} Tm's appeai has been prefezrred ty the a!a%mants far e . gnhansement c2? the amount a? compensatien, The wa'ims T¥§buriaé has awarded a sum 0f Rs.1,05i069!- as compematien fm death ef Miss C.G.C. Mex aged abuut 19 yams. {3) Adminediy the deceased was not empmyed and them was n9 garaof ef hev imeme as ghe was a Student, therefafe the ciaims Tribuna ha$ taken the mtiena inceme 9f the deeeaeed at RefiimQQF per yeai We“ aeeuetmg a u‘.gm ameunt inwards her persunai expenses the amaze? depencéemy has been aseeseed at Re.1Q,GQG!— ane a er appiymg mutt§p§ier ef m the bee c§ aeeeedeecy meeme has beee aeeeesee at Re‘1P0Q,GQQa’—. !n adcetien a earn ef ReaGGGi— has been awarded tewards funera! expensee and Rs.3,909i— tewerds mente§ egany and sack. {4} Ceunse! for the appenants submits that én view 0f the rise tn \. emee the netieeet inceme eheuld have been assessed at Rs.3G,QQG!— / es has beer: hete by the Dieteten Bench ef this Ceurt tn the matter e? e A / am.‘ athem vs. Ashek Kamar am: amas regeréed m 2Q9$ {3} $§iJ ?$?. Ceumseg fm 211% respeadents vmuid submit that thg sta§m$ “wzmnai hag ceirrestsy assesgéé the amaant ef campgnsatfaa and the amwm awameé is fair am: reaaanabae and were is n0 ssape G! §¥2§1am$mem becauge ms deceagea was a student and there i3 n9 prwf a? her éncame. n the maaer of 33%;: am! trams {33pm} the Diwsmn Bemh ef rm: 83m mg mic; thw ‘m para a :— "The mtimm meame 0f Rs. ?5,3a9/- wr ennam was pyescww i2? {he Sesana’ $sfya§yie under Section ?63-A af fhe Mag! Vehisi‘gs Act in ihe yeaf a’994. me acsident if; re: case, wherem degeased Wendra @ J§eadra 3hrw Jest his 133‘s; took Mace in me year 200?, if ms? mwwse fn we m‘ces ef‘the essew‘ai cammedi§eg am? fh$ cw! affivmg betweer; the year 19% ared the year 2&m, tée year cf ascfdam‘ Eh the present case, mg takEn intt: cangéziérafiam me wér‘caai incums af R3. 15, 0%!1 yrexztrec‘ m {$3.9 Secam‘. Scwdme 2%; me year $94 wwfd caffairgiv cama: fa R33Q§GQA if? ms year $9M, Wé, mer$fara prepase {a re~campute tm campensatiafz taking me mcama cf she deceased at Rs.3£’,&0@/— per amum. "‘ m viaw ef tha my ¥aid~d<3’m in the matter of Quéaa am! miters gsgma} this Ceurt womd gancaude that the amsunt awardsé by the aiaims Trx‘‘mma} :s raquimd ta be reassessed i3y taking the nat§ana§ émgme cf me ciaceasea a: Rs.39x0£)@f~, as §n the preswt aase aisa me reak mace if} the year 26m . When the natimas gnwme of me céecaased is takgn at :EO‘GI— am $95 is déé'ucteci towamls her persona! SxgenSes, the easy weuéd came te 15,009 x 1Q = Rs.1,50,QGOf-. CZ} ag’ z§ep$m§ §\ Eaaductien ef 5$% tawards persenai incame af the decea$ed is mada Damage ihe maimams NM ‘ and 2 are the parents ami ciaimantg Na3 is; Ehe‘ brathey D? the deceased wha weuk! not b€ a dependgnt an his $§$§$¥. {m in additien is amount 9f Rs .,U0,QQ0*‘ $9ward3 39% 9f <$ admcy ‘mGMe t e apgaeilantg are am} armed ta aim af 2 QQG’ awardg fuaera§ expenses am} Rs.1D,GGG!— mwarda iava and $f?w‘i’trm E'hg c ww Triburai ha$ awaydgd eniy Rs 90% tawamg show. i *‘m Me??? ageny 3r: w hwtever kwkmg fa ma fact tha* We pa * wa mt rm mg; daughter wed amut w years, the sampengatian {m Wig heag gawk: EASG haVe been aS$e$¢av=d R$ ’§0QGI— Tim’s, ma tgzae amsuw w "emggmatmr: wamd be 3,5(m90 + 2,000 + mija§ + mJQQfw‘r ma? Rs.1e?2,%QOI—‘ The Wham! has akaady awamaeé P's ,G5i3G0f-I therefme tm appe!!ants wwm ba entEtied m an arsgi *3 n ‘3 "P 0f Rs o“? OGCI- awn” Wm the mtereet @ awardecé by the :% rm Tr§bunaL ”i £3} ‘Jhe §§$L¥ame Cempany Le. respmaem Ns.3 shaE alse be £iab!e {n “was? anhaacement ameunt befwe the dawns; T§buna¥ w§thin a gm ? hm mnvt’wg fmm tc ay a {‘a. 1,) The appee§ eiaede a?! wee m part /, i2} There ehea be he erder as ts casts. ”as W