t0;.l:.fc;-f. ^v^M ^.,:j|g|.::|g ^fi.'';^ iiBRsSKBB SBSigBBBnS WSSiHSia M^^^^^^B ft iK^ l:Eii IJlljl ^. 1 II g p SSSSK Bai'ii«K118SitSBSiK Q'sW S 5- a ;^. i§: w w-^ 1.s- :-Mi. €§iu ^ti r':ll MS!Balgg';B»:: waiesKs^ M T'1?'^^ BS": •ii:!i« lEEt asii iBlii- IBIIIll^ illiEB'l ;K W iiii siiir.; !i :111 Itlll '-i' 'iiUhaiii/^ lili 1 1 riiii^i cliemiG^ exmiHnati^ vide ^ "-" StateaBeBteB:<®f.!ttei; ^ratncsses "weae recofded undfera Swttoa Iftli ;oE 1;he~^G<xte;s«£s <2riiiuiialProcedute,lW3(Bisl rf&eCd<Ie).sasfl 4. ABcr coaiptetion of^u^sjii^atte^ bcforc the Chief .iudici^ Magstiate Ambiteaina^ ;wte>:rais''t«aai,i <x>auiutted"tfac ease^ •^^©cni^ whcre the leanied Additioaal^ssiotM ^udgc xec«wcdl^ :"'^',;:••;•:-.•"'.^-^•:;';'-.'1.;. ..•:-"-..:^',••;,.;• 'tiansftT^Ibr-trial..' ~" - ; .; .•.•:';:- • .••.:.. ,,^,:^; . : .••• :• • - 5; ; fa orter^ to^^ p^ proscCTitioa etainiaed ^ma^^ A3i^^ exaaaaed /undCT'SectiOn^lS ®^'fe:'0B^a^ fhe ciicuinslHD^es appesua%a^^ biaj^Ksa&^iB.ciSsw^fyiKstioa^^ SS. Afte affiMding oppCTtouu^ c^ Vesaxag^ •Qis .3eaEnedi Adaitt9iQsal; Sessloim t3 iia^ cbaw^^ ?a|[ipeHflntas afiaesaid tneatieUsffid.A^ " ^®5"WWiel3iliawesSieai8;!iSB3Ei :f-^3SiSHS^SS^^SSfiywiiB^i^^:,impiSasstt!^:'0wc'K ¥:slRJllN'HiMIM^IBB^Ii^lWI^'*E^FG^t^"' ^.;| ; 'iIieffiEHe ^uas^j^^ coayKstl^^itheappellairfis-substEi^^ extia jjud&aaKGoafessiqnfaa^eE^^^ Ram{FW^,IMSai{PW^a^Sa^atia^^R,^^(F^^ "CTailen<»Ofafiucsaid~fl^a^sefedoesaK)t;i^ ^zmS^^'SW^^V^^^^^ tnistsvortliy.^ ttlose witeesses does^aotijBaffi^suppoiE^^ asiS: ocKQar evideQce. As'^ier ewtdeaiee <^l|al.!?SaiifRW-@)^ jhas^Gaused- deafe.-of^fau'^wMe^;l^^^stffil^&ibut^^:^pe{E ie^eBce^I)i^.E. Relff^^ i~:-K BiE li!11 ilt M:!l ::1 S'i ^: h^( fecen noticed ia fhe autop^r rcporfc On the basia Qp;se]:R contradictDry medacal aiiid ocular twidsace, coiBiaKtioa 'of- ^he'? appeUaalt is aot safe •tfiat too ftu- Gomnussjon of^sueh hemsuss offeace of lauideK He furth^^^^^^a^ laboujrer ahd Gourt ^elt^ h^ im^ sciriieiK» Of^fiaeNiot ^:~';.'.^.';:A'.^:-.:''^1.1:.:..»..;S.':.'"^ Rs.SO,QOO/-, wluG& is flot^^^ heavy amount offirie, Courf;betow Iias not coiisidered fheiiiaeoaie and capacity of fhe aRpellaa^^^fc "thcreby coinmatted illegalily. 9, Oa the other Iiaad. lcaraed ccmii^l 'for tb& vefaemeutfy ppppsed Atese aigiHneBts^ -and^^ «^ evidence oFPfeahu Ram (tW-2)»Lal Sai (FWf-S) and Satyanai-ayaa Rajwar (PW^) is weD conoboratcd by fl^ Nhe cvideiice and^^^ ^ senfenced Ite appeilaat as afbresaM ifleutioned; 1Q». Ia;ot!dfirto:s^^c)a|^^®igi^i:HB)^^ l.tl ^p^iies,:a8?®|Bia3ire^^a^^?||^^|Bi^eNddu|j^^<^^ •;ttee;piosee'Ettiomte|^:^^K@::;^ ^s •'."1.:- ^,1 •' Ily;'"3a;^ie^preseia|ea!ses8SIiQa^^ jiyMi^^feu^<w^!£heBbd^ofs^^^^<^^ been substaBtial^ dasputed ^^^^^ Ite ofeer hand, ft is estayii^ied tiy the ;evidenee o^DaE'. iJ.B.Reh»aai (PW-8) aitd atitopsy report Ex. PP/T aad dsa&^waschoaiieide^'ffl! :xiature. :•••;.. :, ,^. s. ; ,; ••:',^ -, : ;: ,' 12. As re^nls Gomp&siy oftfaft ac«i^^ oAne^ questibais coaceaacd, eoDwjctKm^ Bimed oa the evideace uf" NanlWR^ if^^ ^afr (fiW-^» Ittcseramo'li (RW-7) antl; S^aitaTag^e'Rsgw^ ip^ ^aiiei^^Na^mJRani-^PW^^^Ben ^l^aiia iKuflo Rudo, hc Tasiied tow$rdte 4ftc?iplacB •fl»^ souad^w^ <»aiag aad fae saff S^ appeBaiit 'ISK ap^ ttem.thatlie&asldaed^fiswifeflaaai^^ wfasro fae Idlled lus^wjfe, ^ EEp^ where tiae deatl toody of Ns wife w®^lag m: fcjxired ctKadUioa^^ A^ and sticks-were^ato|yN^aeW'^I;^^ (PW-^liasaIsos^staayal^coteCTboiatecE^^ Ram (PW-% whQlias d^ioscd*tluat flw ^KpdlaEtt has mactoextea» judicial coBf S»C fhat te has laBed Ms w& 1^ stiritE." 3a» faetum of extra judicial CMifesaoaAEUs ^b^^ Satyaiiarayaa;R%war (P^9), wfaolias ferthcrdqiosedthatsoi^ personsweatlBthcpteceofiQca^^ himsetf has aot goae to sucb placc. As per ewfdea<» (rf' ^lyaxiarag^ Itegv^^ (^ fte soiaatff tOi^ ;TUsheA«ndcaughthc^ thje appeBant^^^^^^^ ^ ^A- i®cfeficehasc»osscxaxBme&& basinat®e®a,; a||dc ^^efiBitiM^fflBB^^aii^tai^. e^imiaBUaai te ::<3aSGi3ei^stM^i!3bBSS3Bf^^|®el^m|g||W^;|^^ ;.ccai:fesaofe||ffl |K^^||t^St|aBaffie®aas!taoc^ l1x):.S^;;^p&^u|Nye^||^^;de^|';fl»G>c^^^'de^^ AMuM^ I^iS^(I^^ ha^depos^ appeBaat I^ iitade exti^judKaal ^ has eaused fleafh ofI^ wife ^ stiek, wfaKA it dc^ sot^^ support fiBm Ibe mediE^^ tte grouad flf .aSoies^ diacsxfiaDey, es^ieac^ discarded. / The esctia judici^; csEia^ •weak ^qpe of evideiiee btit, biiiceitis prevedthcatKe^ jl4. White dcaling •Wifh tlte 'c'aidei^^ (rf extea?jodiEaid[^ ^£OESessmi^ws^\mS^Seeti0a.^<St^^ 'ss" BSStfi^Bitt 6 Court in fhe in.atter of BaMev tMiq^t w. State o( Bai^jad»l«|iBSi Iield tliat extta^udiGiaI coa^siEm is gKiME^ off-nae^^i evBlenGe. ^ ^xmvictiDa.tMdmai^CTUi^be^ased scd^ -ttnlcss saxite is cxaabborated m mateiial pattieulai^; » 15. Wfaj3edea!iag wiffi 1Iie,samt:^uestipa,^t^ .fhe:.inatter:<rf:M«>li&1Azad,'^:>8aiattt:~^ StaU».:.ot.:^^ has held fhM ife?Etia-jud»2MNaifession teitfti ia a fit state of imi^^^ t^ cotifessxni-will liawc to pBMre likc aay otti^ eviden<a. t:^ia 2%^ fhesaidjudgmfiaitleadsasuadcr;-' a22. Aa extra-judfc^ c<»»^sa^;;ff'»®te^ :1 ' l', truc^aad.ffliadcia^a,uBt|s| %iBS^ upcn lay fhe etma^ t@^ <XBifessuxffi wa^ lpn>veaiilre g% QiEBeT ^^JT^^va^ as to e0nlessioa,i ffl^ £,'upoa.ffief,veiraci^ :^^tie;;:::w^ 7 ; been inaBe. The^ :^^ eoa^ssi^ ^,:.,wli»^gj(i^''^;'iMg|a^xie|,;Iit^si^?ope^ .;^';;:.-ylg,,^:1.,^t6^'-star]k^ -l^rg;,ggj||!|i03S!i^sg|%y;^jlggw|ag||||^j|iS|«lgB^^ S^SMiisStiSSWSoEiSsi^sKswB^^mi^St^Siics^. •y[ 'SS^StWKSi^^^SKiWS^^R3tSE"^K ^SMcBM|B|ffil^|| |gK|p^g|^t;s|;mffio|;'speaM^..«^^ %g|^o@B|B^B|aSiSa<|Kag|^fflES^:ias::cmt;ilae^ielicd^ 'upBBp^ :^i',w.£tii:e?;%cMaBBeiffi3iL;;|caa®ii«Rt,^^ ; sfcSewiSeiice ateout^^^^^^ ; i"^Blo'uffi^-witoiessesrmho^ :. even teiuQte^' iiumicad jtiOt ;(he. laccu3se<I,'18nffEm respecttrfwhoiaaoflaiaglsbixm^it^^o^ fead 1i>;lndJGate^fiia|t^Bc^ ^ attnbuting an uE|TUiBbfut^ateaa^t te,^^ a^uiiseA, fhfi ^woais sjpokea ;to •^ ^ uaiainbjguousyand accased is fhe pra'@eti»|bEM"ofilIl.e^Gnme^aad aodumg- is daiitted ^ l^^.'mi^^ agaiast ifc Affer sabjec^ing?^^^^,^ I., ,witaess^lB.:a'-i^oTEn]ffi,^test^^i^jt^ eredtlMiyy, .'flie cxtea-judaaal CMifes^Htt ciaa t» il2iE^|aKS£W3730 ^SW^sew'Tsz:' ' ':^^ i ^-1 IJS;!iSii"'i:: 'llllt / 9 ]!H!: 'jij'i'J [ sitaita- i;i^ Km^ aceepted aad caa be tbe basis of conMGtioa tf ;U; . passes fhe testofcredibility" 16. EvideiiceofNaataM.Ram(PW-^,I^ (PW-'T') and SatyanaT^aa Rajwar (PW-9) te sufficienfc au infei»nce fbat the appeBaiit Ilas inade i®Eti», ooafessioa tieforc fhem ^tiat<the has ktUcd lus •wife aad atelEhB^ ift-, ; 'i ; . ' • instaiice of th®appeBant, de^ body <rf the dec^sed ;wa recovered, tyiag on the spot. This evideBce iB^SuffiKaeat-iBB'^ drawing au infeiience tfaatfhc appellajit has e<munteBd ctalpAte.i homacide ampuntu^ 1jb mnrder (rf'teiswife^PaBEtUHreu'. A ^ i 17. After agipjpeciatuig ^ie evid^ce wmBAte <)ffisacciarig^^ lieamed AxldiSoiial Sessiona tJiMl^flfi^-c»iwfertcd"ai^^s^^ ttu? appeBant •uiuter SedHaB; 302 ®f1te It^ Wlt^ c<>Hwicti.i%»aBi3E[ SettteDffiiDg ffae^E^peBaa^ tiie lescB^^^i^^ lias aofe'coaunitted aoy fllsgaUty or infimu^.Ooairactiaa <tf flite aBj@ieB,^t is ^bsused' oa: teggl aad^itafihil^ evidcaee si^^ i^aa®ef®i)e;/3aw.^;''- ^.•.'.':' -' :.'.::;;'^':'- l^-'sSlife8S^li^Ka^a'lilsiJBMB!mt^^t3^3®PBsecBria^^ca ^^ ?ail|B^a(^|^l|e||^'a|3^B>'usst @l:nirt'U^ i^^ ®|!^gmi8eri^BE;jBoa^ iBi2BiBaliDi3seHteHe&®wl^il^^ C^Misidjeraig th&^^t ti^ tfae^^ a^^ Rs.SQ,000/- is BOtju.staad pFQper^Wlucfa reguaes eoaasidHl^ioai Coasequentty; the -appeal is pasQy altowMt. <S<HaifctioaL ;etf tte' appeUaM ziader Sectfem 302 ^^{^^^I^ Instead of imprisoameat foFl^;^id'SQ t^i^ seiitieiK^^^I^ jmpasG®3ia8Bi ;asd^^^ •;tii6re;l:>y^set,^idfi;,''.':'1"]:":;; •• :• . ^ r^sd/-^ TJ'.Sfaarana Sd/- R.L. Jhanwar judge ••^;. '^'&^i '.^'•'"i' ^