1 mgj IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION Sales Tax Appeal No. 2 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.1 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.2 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.3 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.5 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.6 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.7 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld.)No. 8 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.9 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.10 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.11 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.12 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.13 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) no.14 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.15 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.16 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.17 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No. 18 of 2010 with Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.19 of 2010 2 and Sales Tax Appeal (Ld) No.20 of 2010 The Additional Commissioner of Sales Tax ..Appellant vs. M/s Jalaram Timber ..Respondent Mr.V.A.Sonpal A Panel Counsel for appellant. Mr.C.B.Thakkar for respondent. CORAM: V.C.DAGA AND K.K.TATED JJ 16th April ,2010 P.C. 1 After having heard these appeals for some time Mr. Thakkar brought to our notice that he is already before the Commissioner against the order of extension. In that view of the matter cause of action to proceed with these appeals does not survive. However, learned A Panel Counsel appearing for the appellant requests for withdrawal of these appeals keeping all rival contentions open. Leave granted. Appeals are dismissed as withdrawn. (K.K.TATED J.) (V.C.DAGA J.)