424 C YVPNoe3584OF 2008etc 1 t IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARHe 4 1 DATE OF DECISION 20 e5e2011 i 1 1eCWP N001197of2009 4 1 1 NiranjanSingh l eeePetitioner 1 0 0 VERSUS I StateofHaryanaand others t5 e e I 2CWP N003584of2008 Z Nha Yadav U eeePetitioner l I VERSUS C The State ofHaryanaand otherS Z t r1 3eCWPNoS738 of2009 Iv 1 Sandeep SinghSihagand others S7 Z OeePetitioners 1 0m VERSU StateofHilryana and others 4eCWP Noe271of2010 P4 0e 4 BaljinderSingh eeePetitioner VERSUS Stateof Hilryanaand others e e 40 1 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 425 CWP Noe3584OF 2008etc 2 1 5eCWPNoe16118of2009 v Pradeep Yadav eeePetitioner VERSUS State ofHaryanaand others 1 ee 6eCWP Noe15455of2009 It 1 0 SanjeevTinjan 0 eeePetitioner I Ca9 I VERSUS 4t State ofHaryanaand others Z ee 7eCWP No1822 of2009 C C Arvind Kumar I eeePetitioner Z VERSUS OO StateofHaryanaand others 2 e e Z 8eCWP Noe20315of2008 1 AbhishekGoyal and others 1 eeePetitioners VERSUS State of Haryanaand others 9eCWP Noe21821of20081 Mukesh Yadav eeePetitioner VERSUS sp Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 426 11 CWP N003584 OF 2008etce 3 r e e 100CWPNoe1236of2009 1 Nitin PratapSingh 1 eeePetitioner VERSUS 4 1m StateofHaryana etce e e 1 0 1 0 CORAM C9 HONBLE MRJUSTICE PERMlOD KOHU I c Z PRESENT Mrajiv Atina Ram SrAdvocatewith MrlVikhil ChopraAdvocate m MrIK Malik SrAdvocatewith MrlCohel Dev Advocate I CJ MrJK Sibal SrAdvocatewith Z Msanmeet Kaur Advocate OO MrPuneet GuptaAdvocate 4 3 MrPankajJain Advocate Z MrJatin Salwan Advocate ll 4 MrDheeraj Chawla Advocate MrPuneet GuptaAdvocate MrHakam ManuiaAdvocate Mranninder SinghAdvocate MrllKS Brar AddlAG Haryana with SinghAAG Haryana Permod Kohli Je Petitionersin all thesepetitions are Law GraduatesReliefs claimed ee Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 427 CWP No3584 OF 2008etce 4 4 being identical these petitions are being of by this common Factsrelevant for the purpose of thesepetitionsare being noticed HighCourt ofPunjabandHaryanaissuedbrochurein theyear 2007 1 invltlng for recruitmentto HaryanaCivil Service oudicial 4 This brochurecontainedall necessaryandrelevant detailsrelating 1 Q to eligibilitycriteria datefor modeand 1 0 methodof selection syllabus andothernecessaryconditionsThese details C I arenot beingrefened to the same beingnot germaneto the of 0 the issuesinvolvedin thesepetitionsApart8om detailsreferredto above I 4 numberof vacancies to befilled in through the processof Z selection are containedin the brochureSincethe numberof vacanciesls a r relevantfactor for the purposeof deciding thesepetitions the same are I being here under1 Z Availablenumberofvacantposts 34 4 10 details are as underl r a7 SO Category NoeofPosts Remwks Z 1 General 16 ll i 2 Scheduled Castes of 9 Out of these 2 vacancies are Haryana beingadvertisedfor the third time 3 Backward Classes of 5 lnclusiveof 2 carried forward Haryana vacancies which are being advertised for thesecondtime 4 ExeServicemen of 1 Haryana J 4 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 428 rJ 7 CWP Ne3584 OF 2008etc 5 1 r e Category iVoeosU Remarks 1 5 Physically 3 Including2 carried forwards vacancies which are being advertisedfor the third time In case of of suitable candidatesagainstany or both vacancies then these 1 1 vacancies will be filledup from amongst the suitablecandidates to thecategoryof Exe servicemanandfurtherin case ofl 4 of suitable 1 to the tr category of Hxeservicementhen thesevacancieswill be thrown 11 0 uponto the generalcategoryin 0 tenns of Govemment instructionscontained in letter I No4151913GSIII dated C5 2211199 I It is also providedin the brochure that in additionto 34 vacant Z posts 20 vacancies are beingadvertisedas per the 5 of the Honble Supreme Court in Malik Mazhar Sultan vse UePe Public t 4t ServiceCommission and others 200619 SupremeCourt Cases507 and I 2008 XVlll SCC 703e details of these vacancies are as Z under 00 46 a7 7 4r 1 Z e Category Noa OS8 1 General 12 Om t 2 ScheduledCastesof Haryana 4 3 BackwardClassesof Haryana 1 e 4 ExServicemenof Haryana 2 e e e e 5 Physically Ortholof 1 Haryana It was also stipulated that numberof vacanciesmay vary Selection was to be made on the basis of il examination 6iiIMain examination It is admittedcase ofthe r3 1 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 429 1 CWP N003584OF 2008etc 6 1Apartiesthat all the petitioners within stipulatedperiod ARer 1 qualifying the examination theywere permiued to appearin the rnain examination and vivaIoce vide noti6cation dated3022008 Final r result 6general inerit list1was issued on 1322008 exure Pe71 Thereaer on the basoisof the recommendationsmadeby the Selection 4 Committee were madebythe Govemment videMemo dated 1 C 1322008 Pm89The could not be 1 0 Names ofthe were accordingly enteredin the concemedregister 40 maintainedat HighCourt 9 The categorywise status ofthe is as underl I SreNOe Name ofthepetitioncr CWPNOe Categury Z 1 NehaYadav 3584of 2008 BackwardClass m onel 2 1197of2009 General onel I 3 Sandeep SinghSihagMohit 97380f2009 General t Sondhi GagandeepSingh onel Z Garg 4 Pradeep Yadav 161180f2009 General OO onel 5 SanjeevTinjan 15455of2009 General 7 Z onel 6 BaljinderSingh 271of2010 General l Clm one9 L 7 Arvind Kumar 1822of2009 General one9 8 Abhishek Goyal Neeraj203150f2008 General Goyal Nitin Mittal and fourl Surender 14 9 MukeshYadav 218210f2008 BackwardClass onel 10 Nitin PratapSingh 1236of2009 General onel Totall Generall 12 BC 2 In view of their nonmselectionsome of the claimedtheir selection and byfiling However receiving no ee 1 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 430 IV 19 CWP N03584 OF 2008etce 7 e response to such these wrlt petitionshave been filed 1 claimingfollowing relief XXX XXX Xxx 1 1 6iiiissuea writln thenature of mandamusdirecting the to consider and appointthe as 4 Civil Judge rDivision9in the HaryanaCivil Services a l OudicialBranchlin pursuanceto the selectionconducted 1 0 by it the result of which has been declared vide 0 I Annexure Pm6with effect Oom 1322008 when other C40 similarlysituatedselectedin the same processhavebeen I selectedand appointed and grantall reliefs Z that flow thereom includingsenioritypayfixation C arrearsofpayalongwith interest etc I The are claimingtheir on the t Z followinggroundsl 4 CO iIOut ofsix postsadvertisedfor Backward Class actual4ml e onlythreepostshavebeenfilled in theflrst instancevidenotiOcationsdated Z 1322008 and 14320081 i Qm iil 12 persons havebeen promoted on regular basisas AdditionalDistrict Judgeswhereas6ve personswere appointed as Additional District Judges on ad hoc basis for the Fast Track Courts in HaryanawhereasOve notiOed eVW vacanciesfrom ScheduledCaste remainunfllled 124e5422 iiilOn 211 12007 65 postsofCivil JudgesJrDivisionl were created by the which inter alia includessix postsfor Backward Classand 13for ScheduledCastecandidates iv9Asagainst13 advertised vacancies for ScheduledCaste onlyfive have 4 1 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 431 10 11 CWP Noa3584OF 2008etce 8 1 been filled and 9 vacancies could be utilised for 1 lfromthe Backward Class categoiycandidates in view of the govemment 1 lnstructions dated 1781976 which inter alia providesfor 1 of reserved categoty vacancies in the event of of candidatesfrom a particular reservedcategoryIn this case 9 Scheduled 4 Caste categoryvacancles were to be utilized for of Backward 0 Class candidatesdue to of ScheduledCastecandidates 1 0 of 6ve before 31 102008 and one candidate 0 I from Backward Class on 17A009 61 Resultantvacancles t5 on account of resignation are allsoto be filled in on thebasisof the same I selection Z It is contended on behalfof the that all theallailableposts m L are to be fllled in on thebasisofselect list dated1312008 in view I of the Honble SupremeCourt in the case of Malik Mazhar C Z Sultan supral The have giventhe details of the vacancies r fllled in and availtiblevacanciesundervarious as underl 1 2 3 4 7 Z Noof Postsadvertised PostsFilled by Balancevacant posts Selection aaaeaeememeeeam eeeeeawemeam meeeemnmaaaweemeeeeeeemm mamemam aaeeeeeaem mwemem General 1641228 Postsfilled up Balance vacant posts e iI Postsadvertisedfor ScheduledCaste P5 13 Posts filled upl 5 Balance remaining vacant 8 ii Postsadvertisedfor BackwardClasses P5 6511 6 90 1 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 432 11 CWP Noe3584OF 2008etc 9 r4 1 Postsfilled up 3 Balance vacant 3 iiil Membersof ScheduledCaste 1 P r in February 2008 5 Membersofthe BackwardClass proinoted in 2008 3 1 ivl Postscreatedon 211 12007 65 1 General 0 ScheduledCastePosts 13 Co I BackwardClassposts 6 0 I Thus total number of vacancies available for members of the 1 Z ScheduledCasteand BackwardClassesare as underl m General 6 ScheduledCaste Category 26 I t Backward Class Category 12 Z Petitioner namelyNeha Yadav in CWP N03584 of 2008 submits that she is at Srlllo10 in the list of BackwardClass candidates n Z and after of threecandidatesfrom this categoryshe figuresat l Om SrlVo next in theorder ofmerit It is stated that out of 54 advertisedposts 34 actual and 20 only 34 have been made 111 the following mannerl 1 a General 23 ScheduledCaste 5 Backward Class 6 Duringthe pendencyof these petitionsVMlOUS Were made lnview of events on the basisof the lnher W 1 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 1 433 CWP Noa3584OF 2008etce 10 d additionalaffldavitshave been filed on both the soidesOn the r basis of the additional information 6ve before 311 02008 and one Mroveleen on 17A2009 Their 8 1 havebeen as 1S evidentfrom the affidavitdated 29A2008 flled by Neha Yadav It is furtherallegedthatHighCourt decidedto 4 appointone Mona Singh candidatenext in the orderof merit vide decision r oftheCommitteedated 1432008 on thebasisofher meritin the selection 1p 0 from GeneralCategory On 5 2009 the High Court passedfollowing O I interimorder in CWP N03584 of2008 C5 Adjourned to 2622009 I In the meantimetwo postsof HCS 0udiciallshall be 1 Z keptvacant lt is furthermadeclear thatit would not be m 0 open to the to take thepleaofthe selectlist I having expired dueto efflux oftime 97 Z There are four in CWP No20315 of 2008 all from e QO General CategoryTheyareot SrlllosA2 to 45 in the merit list dated W2 1322008 It is statedthat GeneralCategorycandidatesuptomerit noAO Z stands and Mona Singhwho was next in the merit at 1 Qm SrNol also stands One candidatenamelyArvind Kumar in CWP No1822 of2009 to GeneralCategoryand figures at SrNo0 in the merit list It isalleged that candidates8om SrlllosA2 to 45 are writ in CWP No0315 of 2008 whereas candidateat SrllloA6 has pe not the Court Candidateat SroA7 hasjoinedPunjabCivil Services oudicialBranchlwhereas candidates at SrosA8 and 49 tlo Backward Class Categorystand vide notificationdated1432008 and this is next in the merit in ee 1 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document e 434 4 n CWP N003584OF 2008etc 11 General CategoryPetitioner Pradeep Yadav in CWP No6118 of 2009 1 whoalsobelongs to General Category falls at Srlllo63 in themeritlist In CWP No738 of 2009 there are three namely Singh ll Mohit Sondhi and Singh to General They standat SrNosA32 267 and 128 ln the final result not the merit list PetitionerNiranjanSinghin CWP No1197 of2009 1 C to General 1S at Srlllo9 in the merit list Petitioner Mukesh 1 0 Yadav in CWP No1821 of2008 to BC is at Srlllo1 l 0 PetitionerBaljinderSingh111CWP N0271 of 2010 to General 9 1Sat SrllloA7 in thefinal selectlist Petitioner TinjanlS GeneralCategory candidate His meritoposition is not reflected Z Recruitmentto the HCS JudicialServiceis govemed and by m C rules namelyPunjabCivil Services0udicialBranchlHwyana I Rules 1951 including the ainendmentsmade bythe Stateof HaryanaBy 1 t Z virtue ofan amendmentnotificationdated2332007 Punjab Civil Services ClO Judicial BranchlRules 1951 were amended34 posts of Civil Judges W2 JrDivision9lyingvacant were to be filled up throughspecial recruitment Z on the recominendationsof the SelectionCommittee constitutedfor the 1 Il purposeThe Selection Committee was constituted under the rules comprising of I threeJudgesof the HighCourt of Punjaband Haryana nominatedbythe Honble the Chief Justice of whom theseniormost has e be the chairman i9the Chief to to Govemment of Haryana and 6iii the Advocate General Haryanaand four legalremembrancersand Secretaries to Government of Haryanaand Legislative All other provisions in the existingrule eligibilityage educational conduct of examinationetc were to remain same Part B of 444 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 435 1 e CWP N03584 OF 2008etce 12 A the originalrulesdeal with the submissionof whereasPart C 1 dealswith the examinationof candidatesRule 80f Part D was amended to the of theHonble Supreme Court in Millik Mazhar 1 Sultan supra AmendedRule readsas underl 5n the saidsaid Rules in partDm 4 6ilforrule l the following rule shall be substituted m 0 The names of candidates selectedby Govemment for as 1 0 Civil Judgesunior Divisionlunder rule 10 and 11 ofthe Part C shallbe 0 I enteredin theHighCourt Register in the order of selectionto the extent of 4 30Iomore than the advettisedvacancies so as to meet any for I e theadvertisedpost unfilled for any reason Il Z 6iilrule 8 shall be omitted m replieshavebeenfiled bythe Stateand on behalfofthe High 4 I Court While the vacancies noti6ed through the brochure Z and creationof65 vacanciesduring the ofthe writ petitions CO theonlycontentionraisedbythe Stateisthatall unlled vacancieson Vm3 of the selectionprocess and aRer Z advertisementare to be advertisedagainto enable all eligible 1 tl candidatesto applyand seek theirconsiderationfor It is r lrther statedthat the grievance madeby the has no legal basis HighCourt also Oleda short afSdavit One ofthe pleasraisedis e that vacancies more than the adIertisednumbercannot be filled To support this contention leamed counsel for the Staterelies upon the in Virender SinghHooda and others vs State ofHaryana and another 200511RSJ 700Affidavit flled on behalf of the High 1 Court reveals that out of 54 advertised vacancies 53 stand i 1 1 1 J 19P 1 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 436 CWP N003584OF 2008etca 13 k flled up and one posthas been reserved which is subjectmatter of 1 CWP No15130 of 2007 Referring to the ofHonble Apex Court in Malik Mazhar Sultalsupral the standofthe HighCowt 4 1 1S that in with the orders of the SupremeCourt 20 vacancies were advertisedand havealso been filled up 4 Further standofthe HghCourt is that mere selectiondoesnot create a m f2 rightin favourofthe Il 0 Due to certain regarding the vacancy positionwhich inter C40 I alia also includes the new creations and esh C5 etc this Court passed an orderdated39009 seeking informationfrom the HighCourt in respectof the pointsindicated Z therein the same shall be referred to Pursuant to the aforesaid directions the HighCourt flled affidavitdated1882009 of I VirinderAggarwalRegistrar Punjab and Hatyana HighCoun 1 r Z pointwise replycontainedin theaffldavitis as followsle 7 00 Point General 42 7 vacancyposltionon the ScheduledCaste 394 Z date ofissuance offresh 24 1 tl 2341 advertisement dated Backward Class 02 149008 for HaryanaExeserviceman 06 PCS oludiciall Pllysically 04 1 44 Ortho9 Total 78 7444 1 4 1 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 437 r CWP N003584OF 2008etca 14 V iilwhether any unfilled No unfllled vacancy arisingout 1 vacancyfrom the earlier selectionadvertisement notiflcationdated23OoI was includedin the fresh advertisement arlSlng out of advertiselnent dated1492008 r 1 notification dated 2332007 was included in the fresh advertisement 4 1 if so the number of such vaCallCles C with categoryNise 1 0 0 I 1 Point Noiii9aner filling 54 One GeneralCategory vacancyaccruedon l 0 advertisedvacancies whether any account of joiningof Shri Sushant r Changotra lll the cadre of PCS 0B1 on 1 Z vacancy became available as 32008 8 more candidatesalso dropped out vacancy on accountof Ct fromthepostofCivil Juge0rDivn in the or if so I cadreofHCS OlBlwhich are as followslv number of such vacancies Z categorrwise break up ClO Cr emeo 7 SrJVoe Nameofthecandldmes Category bes to Date of Z SlShrVM resignation bythe HaryanaGovt i Qm 1 ParshantSharma Gencral 210008 2 JatindraSingh General 2402008 3 Monika Saroha General 24102008 1 4 ChetnaSingh General 24102008 5 Lovleen BC 28A2009 2 6 GomatiManocha General 282009 J 7 Ekta Gauba General 2002009 0e 1 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 438 CWP N03584 OF 2008etce 15 P 1 SVoe Nameofthecandites Category bclongs to Date of 1 SlShHIMs resignation bythe HtuyanaGovte 8 General 382009 L e e n 4 1 Point Nooivwhetherthe vacancies Pursuantto the decision of tlle selection 4 mentioned in 6iiil above and Committeeof the High 1 Ct Coutt dated2882008 Ms Mona Singh at were filled up the manner anddates 1 0 SrllloAl of the select list of HCS OJBI 0 of with details oofthe from the GeneralCategory was appointed candidatesand the categories to 0 bytheHaryana Govemmenton 17772009 whichtheybelong J Z W Point Novlwhether65 addilional65 Postsof Civil JudgcorDivisionl were tr Created during the createdby the HaryanaGovemmentvide Il vacancies I letterdated211 12007 Tllese postswere of the flrst selectioil Cl notifled in the freshadvertisement dated Z initiated in the year 2007 were 142008 00 notified for fresh selection vide 4t Va5 advertisement dated 142008 Z detailsthereof C t Categorywise break up ofthese vacancies Category Numberof Posls General 41 ScheduledCaste 20Yol 13 Ie BackwardClass 10Iol 06 Exnserviceman05Iol 03 Physically tho 030lol 02 ee Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document lll 439 CWP N003584OF 2008etc 16 n 7 A1 Category NumberofPosts a 1 Total 65 V 1 Point NolIl Retiree Promotions from PromotionsDeath Resignation ment 2312007 to ARer 1420081 142008 NIL G 6 One vacancy 9 4 accruingdue1 due to the m TotaU6 SC 4 G 8 C to death of Ajay Generale 9 BC 3 Kumar BC 1 retirement Aggarwal Ii SC 3 on 0 promotion 1452008 0 death BC 2 General resignatlOO Category I etc aRer the C9 completion I of the process of selection Z initiated vide Notification Q dated 2322007 I category t0 wise9 e L 1 Z In the affidavitof MrAggarwalthe numberof vacancies 0 available were not specifiedclearlythoughdetailsof promotions were a7 givenThus vide order dated 121 0201 0 a furtherdirectionwas issued to Z Qm the HighCourt to file fresh atYidavitgivingdetails of the vacancles 1 availableon account of promotionretirement and death of HCS 6JudicialBranch9betweenthe date of advenisementdated 232007 to 682009 date of ilssuance of next select list In responseto this direction an additionalaffidavithasbeen61edbyJointRegistrarlm OSD Punjaband HaryanaHighCourt with the followingdetailsof the vacanciesduring the aforesaidperiod as underl 7 Srllio Vacanciesbecameavailable Numberofvacancies J 1 1 On account of promotionof HCS OB 35 Officersl 1 e 41 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 440 4 CWP Noe3584OF 2008etc 17 W r SrlVo Vacanciesbecameavailable Numberof vacancies 2 Due to resignation ofHCS 6JBIOmcers 10 3 Due to deatllofHCS JBIofflcers Ol 4 Dueto retirement Ol 9 It has come on record in theaffidavit ofGovemmentofHaryanafiled 1 CC lll CWP No1197 of 2009 that a11the 54 vacancies noti8ed vide Il 0 advertisementissued in the year 2007have been Olledup in two phases ie 0 I 1322008 and 1432008 in thefollowing mannerl 0 Vacancy Actual vacancics Posts filled Postli fllled Total I showninthe that were availableupin thetlrst up in the advertiseme on reconciliationphase e second phase Z nts with the data made 1122008 ie 1432008 available by tllC Honble HighCourt Ien 629 631 51 61 6 I t n General 28 29 23 17 40 C Z Scheduled 13 11 5 5 Castes m e 1 Backward 6 9 3 9 t Classes mmo e Z Ex 3 2 1 servlcemen Om 1 1Physically4 3 d persons 1 Total 54 54 23 54 Result of2007 advertisement was declared on 132008 whereasthe result of selection for which advertisementwas issued on 1492008 was declared on 1 2009 and the select list notified on 682009 The entire arguinentof the petitioner is based uponjudgmentof esl Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 1 1 1 441 1 CWP N0e3584OF 2008etce 18 1 Malik Mazhar Sultan supral While the eligibilityof the 1 to Judicial servicein the Stateof UP Honble Supreme Court issuedcertaingeneraldirectioons to all the StateGovemmentsUTs andthe 1 1 HighCourts These directions are contained in 23 of the judgment which readsas underl 4 231t is absolutelynecessaryto evolve a mechanism to speedily r determineand Oll vacanciesof Judgesat all levels For this purpose 1 0 timelystepsare required to be takenfor detenninationofvacanciesissue 0 of examinationsinterviews declarationof lhe I t5 ilnal resultsandissueoforders For all theseand other I stepsif any it is necessaryto providefor Oxedtime scheduleso that systemworks and there ls no delayIll fillingup of Z W vacancies The datesfortakinglhese stepsCllll be provided for on tr 4t the pattemsimilar to fillingof vacancies in some other I services or fillingof seatsfor admissionlIl medicalcolleges 1 C Z The schedule to the Regulations governing medical 4t m adinissionssets out a tiine schedule for every stepto be 7 strictlyadheredto every year The exception can be provided Z for where sumcientnumber of vacanciesdo not occur in a 0m t givenyear The adherenceto strict timeschedulecan ensure timelyfillingof vacancies All State Govemments Union Territories andlor HighCourtsare directedto providc for tiine 4 schedule for the aforesaid purposes So that every year vacancies that may occur are timelyfilled All State Govemments Union Territoriesand HighCouits are directed to file within threemonthsdetailsof the time scheduleso fixed and date from which time schedule so fixed would be 40 1 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document V1 P 442 1 14 CWP Noe3584OF 2008etca 19 W operational 99 1 In response to the directionscontainedhere4llbove some of the State Courtsmade Takingnote 4 ofsuch the Honble Court in Malik Mazhar Sultane2 1 supral issued vanous directions by fixing time schedule for 4 holdingthe examinationsetc at differentlevels In the of subordinatejudicialservice m respectof the High 1 1 CourtsIUTs For the purpose of the presentwrit petitiondirections f lll respectof to the post of civil Judge rDivisionl only 0 C0 relevant Suchdirections containedin 14 and 15 which are I C5 as here under I 14The selectlist prepared for all ofofficials Z r shallbevalid till thenext selectlist is published m Cr 15We further direct that ten percent of unforeseen I 08 vacancies would be in respectof sanctionedpostsand oo not vacanciesoccuningin a particular year 7 Apartfrom above havealsorefenedto Z vanous 0 other to supporttheir contentionthat the merit Iistpreparedby 1 the SelectionCommitteeSUrvives till the next selection and thecandidates next in theinerit are required to be Som the select list In the case of GujaratStateDyeExecutiveEngineersAssociation e VeStateof Gujarat 199431SCT theHonble Supreme Court posedthree questionseil what is waitingliste iican it be treated as asource of recruitment from which candidatesmay be drawn as and when necessary and 6iiilhowlongcan it operate2 the first questionHonble Supreme Court observedas 41 Rawat Seema 2014.03.05 14:31 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 10:51 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 443 4 CWP Noe3584OF 2008etce 20 Y underl 1 8A waitinglist in service matters by the ts a list of eligibleand qualified f candidateswho order of merit are placedbelow the 1 lll lastselectedcandidate Il 4 In respectofquestionoiil it has beenobservedas underl 1 lr 9A waitinglist prepared 111 an examinatlon conductedbythe 1 0 Commissionerdoes not furnisha source ofrecnlitment It is 0 I onlyfor the that if anyof the selected 49 candidatesdoes not jointhen the person from the waitinglist inaybepushedup and be in the vacancy so causedor Z if there is some extreme exigeilcy the Govemmentmay as a 2