IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No 4262 of 2010 1. ASHOK KUMAR SINGH S/O LATE GUPTESHWAR PD. SINGH R/O VILLAGE + P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 2. AJAY KUMAR SINGH S/O LATE BINDHYACHAL SINGH R/O VILLAGE + P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 3. KRISHNA KUMAR SINGH S/O LATE RAM AYODHYA PD. SINGH R/O VILLAGE + P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 4. ANJANI SARAN S/O LATE RAGHUNANDAN SARAN R/O VILL.- MUNDICHAK N.C. CHATERJEE ROAD, P.O. + P.S.- DISTT.- BHAGALPUR 5. RAM CHANDRA MANDAL S/O LATE BHULAI MANDAL R/O VILL.- KALI BAZAR, ARARIA, P.O. + P.S. - DISTT.- ARARIYA 6. SURENDRA CHANDRA SINGH S/O LATE SURAJ SINGH R/O VILLAGE + P.O.- KAULODIHARI, P.S.- CHAURI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 7. ARUN KUMAR SINGH S/O LATE GUPTESWAR PD. SINGH R/O VILLAGE + P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S. CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 8. RADHA KRISHNA SINGH S/O RAM PRAVESH SINGH R/O VILLAGE + P.O.- SHIVPUR, P.S.- AGIAON, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 9. UDAY PRATAP SINGH S/O SRI RAJENDRA PRASAD SINGH R/O VILLAGE + P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 10. ...PENDRA PRASAD SINGH S/O SHIVJEE SINGH R/O VILLAGE + P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 11. SHAMSHER BAHADUR SINGH S/O SRI BRIJ BIHARI SINGH R/O VILLAGE + P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 12. RAJENDRA PD. SINGH S/O LATE RAMPRIAT SINGH R/O VILL.- KAHTHU, P.O.- KAHTHU, P.S.- JAGDISHPUR, DISTT.- BHOJPUR 13. RAM NARESH SINGH S/O LATE GANESH PD. SINGH R/O VILLAGE + P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR 2. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY HEALTH DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA 3. THE UNDER SECRETARY PERSONNEL AND ADMINISTRATIVE DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA 4. THE DIRECTOR-IN-CHIEF HEALTH SERVICES, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA 5. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR HEALTH SERVICES (TUBERCULOSIS), GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA WITH CWJC No 3339 of 2010 1. DINESH PRASAD S/O SHRI LALAN RAM R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 2. NIRMAL KUMAR SINGH S/O LATE BIGAN SINGH R/O VILL.- LABHUANI, P.O.- BANKAT, P.S.- SANDESH ( GADHANI ), DISTT.- BHOJPUR 3. JYOTI BHUSHAN SINGH S/O LATE GUPTESHWAR SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 4. MD. ISRAFIL ANSARI S/O LATE JAHUR ANSARI R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 5. ASHOK KUMAR SINGH S/O SRI TEJ NARAYAN SINGH R/O VILL.- GANGAPUR, P.O.- AYAR, P.S.- AGIYAON BAZAR, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 6. SHIVJEE SINGH S/O SRI RAM NARESH SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- MASADH, P.S.- UDWANTNAGAR, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 2 7. RAMAKANT SINGH S/O LATE PRAKASH SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- NAUAN, P.S.- BIKRAMGANJ, DISTT.- ROHTAS ( SASARAM ) 8. MAHARAJ PD. SINGH S/O SRI RAMASHISH SINGH R/O VILL.- BAHADURPUR, P.O.- MAKHDUMABAD, P.S.- PARASI, DISTT.- ARWAL 9. KAMLESH KUMAR @ KAMLESH KUMAR SINGH S/O SRI SHIVJEE SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 10. SANJAY KUMAR SINGH S/O BIRKUMAR SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- SHIVPUR, P.S.- AGIAON, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 11. UMESH KUMAR RAM S/O SRI LALAN RAM R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 12. NAWAL KISHORE DWEBEDY S/O BRINDAWAN DWEBEDY R/O VILL.+P.O.+P.S.- NAWADA, ARAH, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 13. SURESH SINGH S/O LATE RAM DAYAL SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 14. AGRENAND SHARMA S/O SRI KESHO SHARMA R/O VILL.- NAUAN, P.O.- DHANWANTI, P.S.- SIKARHATTA, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 15. MUKTI NATH SINGH S/O SRI RAM PRAVESH SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 16. SHEO KUMAR RAM S/O SRI RAM PRAVESH SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 17. KRISHNA KUMAR SHARMA S/O LATE KHADERAN SHARMA R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 18. SRIRAM PRASAD S/O LATE CHANDRAMA SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 19. ATAR BIHARI SINGH S/O LATE INDRA DEO SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 20. SURESH SINGH S/O LATE HIRA SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 21. BIKRAMA SINGH S/O SHAMHUT SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 22. PRABHUNATH SINGH S/O LATE INDRADEO SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 23. HARENDRA PRASAD SINGH S/O SHRI RAM PRIT SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 24. RAM DHANI PRASAD S/O SRI RAM KISHORE PD. R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 25. MD. GAFFAR ANSARI S/O LATE JAHUR ANSARI R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 26. JITENDRA PRASAD SINGH S/O SHRI RAMASHISH SINGH R/O VILL.+POST- NAWADA BEN, P.S.- UDAWANTNAGAR, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 27. LAL BABU PD. CHAURASIYA S/O SRI RAMRUP CHAURASIYA R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH 28. AJIT KUMAR SINGH S/O LATE NAGENDRA PD. SINGH R/O VILL.+P.O.- SEMRAO, P.S.- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARAH Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR 2. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY HEALTH DEPTT. GOVT. OF BIHAR, PATNA 3. THE UNDER SECRETARY PERSONNEL AND ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS DEPTT., GOVT. OF BIHAR, PATNA 4. THE DIRECTOR-IN-CHIEF HEALTH SERVICES, GOVT. OF BIHAR, PATNA 3 5. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR HEALTH SERVICES ( FALARIA ), GOVT. OF BIHAR, PATNA ----------- 2 21.07.2010 In these two cases, petitioners are dismissed employees of the Health Department, Government of Bihar. They had earlier come to this Court complaining upon their wrongful dismissal. Their writ petitions were dismissed. They did not proceed further in the matter. Subsequently, several other persons challenged similar dismissal order before this Court and the matter was ultimately taken up in Division Bench wherein the Division Bench appointed a Five Men Committee to look into each individual case and pass orders. Pursuant to the aforesaid, State Government issued a press communiqué calling upon similar employees to file representation for consideration by the Committee. Petitioners then filed representation which has been rejected on the ground that the petitioners having moved the High Court and had suffered dismissal order and petitioners were not parties to the Letters Patent Appeal, as such, their grievance cannot be considered. Having considered the matter, in my view, the petitioners having challenged the order of termination and lost before this Court, cannot resurrect the position any longer. Having suffered the order of this Court, they cannot come for the same relief again. Granting any indulgence would be contrary to the order already suffered by the petitioners. The writ petitions, thus, merit no consideration and are dismissed accordingly. So far as any other distinct relief that the petitioners would 4 seek, they would be at a liberty to file fresh separate writ petitions or take separate independent remedy in relation thereto. M.E.H./ (Navaniti Prasad Singh)