^: ^mm^ il^^:'••'•• /» IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR WRIT PETITION N0.431^ QF 20Q5 PETITIONER PLAINTIFF /.<^v J^^':/ ^B^ ^''c^A>" ^,/^v Bahadur Singh, S/o. Jagmohan Singh Rajpoot, Aged about 54 years, Occupation - Police Constable, State of Chhattisgarh, Raigarh, Resident of village Chhoteatarmuda, Raigarh, Tahsil & District Raigarh (C.G.) ^ ^- ^" ^< '^ RESPONDENTS fcl<r' VERSUS ,1. State of Chhattisgarh, Through CoUector Raigarh (C.G.) (DEPENDANT) 2. Kelo Vihar Shaskiya Karmachari Grih Nirman Sahakari Sanstha Maryadit, Raigarh, Through its President, Kelo Vihar Shaskiya Karmachari Grih Nirman Sahakad Sanstha Maryadit, Raigarh (C.G.) ^' WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA ffPIWWIT^ %^»< W|®^W^^B?i?Rtel»11^j? c ii • •<r<r»••»»•••• «^yTl»r<*.»<• BY-OH-X ^i^p%i$(%a^^ sn^w^lftaf^i ?wr3i(^tawfr^l <; ^"?^^^jJWfi?r.3n^r :^T,:s^@Tfi?r ••""-—---i 14.9.2005 Shri A.N. Bhakt4, co^^^! f<?d Shri R.R. Sinha, J>.L for the ^ The pe+itioner hns preferrecl the order dated 25.7.2005 (Ani| Additional Civii Judge; p!ass-II, Rai| .aliowed the appiicatio^Of respond| Rule .10 of the Code ofCivil Procedul The case of th4 petitioner civit "sult' agairist^ re^pondsnt. Nc respondent:.NoJ: to ..Ihterfere : wi' petitioner in 'respect 'of the disputi favour of the petitioner herein am J, ;. fippllcotion under Ord^r 9 Rule l'. decree. disposed of, ^x-part'e yecree -has |rW^<ffeW^RT$f!T& ?!^8ri^wan^FTO%^ n%; the petitioner. tate. thjs writ petitiori being aggrieved by th exure"P-n]:) passed. 'b^ :: learned 4th |arh whereby learned <3vi! Judg.e 'has ^nt;.No2 herein fiiec! uhder Order 1 •e,,1908...: • - 1 ^. s thot the .petitioner |erein^ fiied' a .l-5tate.'"' questiontng':: 1|h'e right of 1 'h the.'possesslon A.ng-ht- of-the •I ^d !and. The' suit vms decreed In now' 'respondent No.l h^' moved an !:"of the CPC'f.or' settjng a'side the ^Coynsei for thejpetitioner o^gued thot the suit ha^ been finaily I- teen passed' against re^pondent No,l suit before th6 leQrndd.CJvil Judge and therefore/there IB no pending^ and as such, iearned C|vj! Judge h<^s committed materia! iiregularity by ajiowing the applicatiori fiied-by re| oftheCPC. . :| • . :-| The argument advanced ' by j pnma-facie appears to be correct pondent No2 under Orjder 1 ftule 10 iearned counsei' for t|ie petitioner tsnd therefore, issuancd of notice to 3f>/cs,'2005.20.000 ^mS*tNI'IC3>*<l,FWcIl^l^pRkl»:If^ qP(^|T^<TT^ •:9W^^'»^^mpiQt aniSCTsijR^i^^s^ w^r^^gtp! PCTW^ttjBCTfrBI <:' 'Wi 'v- ryr?- ?|T^TJfgji^^an^f ^(^n^^-irp' . ' ' • . 1 . —^ respondent No.2 hereii|i Is further suit, as such/notice isjnot being is^ respondent No*2 feeis|aggrievea b| t0 move this Court for recali of th.N It is'true thG|- an exmpar|'e. decree has a!ready| •been..pas^ed. agdnst respondent No|l in which. r^ t thereafl-er, respondent No.l has'i^ s thot ex-part'e dccree. The suit. ha^ .s the ex-parte decree i& set aside^ triai -court and .uniess the suit is .rc { No.2 cannot. be diowedl . . In the circum'stances, the or ^ and ^uffers from iiiegdiity & materi •quashed. AccorciingSy/the order im| 1) is hereby quashed* However, if tl ;•: triai Court in that case the tria! C the appjication fiied by .responde accordance with !aw, 1 With the aforesoid, the peti' Consequently, ^,(W*)P. No 7824/05 aiso stand of. Certified copy a^ per rules. ^ A?n— !n.^.r^-c-i.j, -?^^, -"% H!$i'fl'llfll<SPI?1;t1mwl ^'i^^1]W^^ ^pl ^S 3|R|*< 3ffi^fm^?riT€?IT&11 |oing to delay the proceedlng^ of civii ued .to respondent No*2. However, if this order then he wlii be at iiberty order. • ' '. • . |' . • ' • ,spondent No,2 was'notjthe party-and oved an appilcatton fon setting aside dready' been.-disposedjof .and unless the suit cannot'be restored for the stored, the application &f respondent der impugned is. prima-facie perv^rse , •( ai irreguJaritY.and SGmejis .Ilabie to be »ugned dctted 25.7.200S (Annsxure P" ie ex-parte'decree is ser .aside by the t )urt wili be within its r|ght to decide it No.2 herein -on its lown merit in fion stands disposed of. j 13509/05 and I.A. 7823/05 <& Sd/- L.C. Bhadoo Judge ;->i^:&'2005;. 20.000 ^ ^Sts^t-^^v^