IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.17435 of 2009 1. SANTOSH KUMAR S/O SRI RAMADHAR PRASAD R/O VILL- KARMAWAN, .S- SUGAULI, DISTT- EAST CHAMPARAN 2. AJAY KUMAR S/O SRI DHUKHAN SINGH R/O VILL- RAGHUNATHPUR BAZAR, P.S-SUGAULI, DISTT- EAST CHAMPARAN 3. SUNIL KUMAR GUPTA S/O DHARMANATH PRASAD GUPTA R/O VILL-KORAR, P.S-BASANTPUR, DISTT- SIWAN 4. SARBAJIT KUMAR SINGH S/O SRI KAPILDEO SINGH R/O VILL- BADPA, P.S- RIVILGANJ, DISTT-SARAN 5. RAVI KUMAR SINGH, S/O SRI RAM BINOD SINGH, R/O VILL- DHARAMPURA, P.S- DAUDPUR, DISTT- SARAN 6. RAJ KISHORE YADAV, S/O SRI CHANDRA DEO YADAV R/O VILL-BAREJA, P.S- DAUDPUR, DISTT- SARAN 7. AJAY KUMAR YADAV, S/O SRI CHANDESHWAR YADAV R/O VILL- BAREJA, P.S- DAUDPUR, DISTT- SARAN 8. NAVNIT KUMAR SINGH, S/O SRI KASHI NATH SINGH R/O VILL- DHARAMPUR, P.S- DAUDPUR, DISTT- SARAN 9. RAJIV KUMAR JHA S/O BABU SAHEB JHA R/O VILL- SATIGHAT, P.S- KUSHESHWAR ASTHAN, DISTT- DARBHANGA 10. BANTI KUMAR S/O SRI VIJAY KUMAR SINGH, R/O VILL- MAURYA VIHAR, TRANSPORT NAGAR KUMHRAR, PATNA, P.S- AGAMKUAN, DISTT- PATNA 11. UDAY SHANKAR CHAURASHIYA S/O SRI GANESH PRASAD CHAURASHIYA R/O VILL- NIMEZ, P.S- BRAHMPUR, DISTT- BUXAR 12. SANJAY KUMAR SINGH, S/O SUKHDEO YADAV, R/O VILL- UMEDPUR, P.S- DRAHMPUR, DISTT- BUXAR 13. BINOD PASWAN, S/O RAJENDRA PASWAN, R/O VILL- THAHAR, P.S- KHAJAULI, DISTT- MADHUBANI 14. SURENDRA PRASAD S/O GANGA PRASAD SINGH, R/O VILL- MADHA, P.S- KHAJAULI, DISTT- MADHUBANI 15. RAJIV RANJAN OJHA, S/O YADUNATH OJHA, R/O VILL NEMIZ, P.S- BRAHMPUR, DISTT- BUXAR 16. RITESH KUMAR BHAGAT, S/O LATE LALJI MALI R/O VILL- NIMEJ (MALITOLA), P.S- BRAHMPUR, DISTT- BUXAR 17. JIUT PRASAD S/O RAM NATH SAH R/O VILL-NEMEZ, P.S- BRAHMPUR, DISTT- BUXAR 18. AKHILESHWAR KUMAR BHARTI S/O PRABHU DAYAL BHARTI R/O VILL-GORHAT MATHIYA, P.S- MANJHI,DISTT- SARAN 19. DEEPAK KUMAR TIWARY, S/O BASHISTA NARAYAN TIWARY R/O MADANSATH, P.S- DAUDPUR, DISTT- SARAN 20. PANKAJ KUMAR S/O SRI RAM MISHRA, R/O VILL- BAREJA, P.S- DAUDPUR, DISTT- SARAN 21. SURENDRA SINGH S/O DEO NARAYAN SINGH R/O VILL- GAYGHAT, P.S-HARSIDHI, DISTT- EAST CHAMPARAN 22. MANINDRA KUMAR S/O BISHWANATH YADAV, R/O VILL- UJJAIN LOHIYAR, P.S-HARSIDHI, DISTT- EAST CHAMPARAN 23. BINOD KUMAR S/O BISHWANATH YADAV, R/O VILL- UJJAIN LOHIYAR, P.S- HARSIDDH, DISTT- EAST CHAMPARAN 2 24. RAJIV RANJAN KUMAR S/O SRI RAMPRAVESH SINGH R/O VILL- GAYGHAT, P.S- HARSIDHI, DISTT- EAST CHAMPARAN 25. MUKUL KUMAR S/O JYOT NARAYAN SINGH VILL- MANGALPUR, P.S- RAMGADHWA, DISTT- EAST CHAMPARAN 26. GAURAV KUMAR S/O JAGAT SINGH R/O VILL- PATNAI, P.S- RAMGADHWA, DISTT- EAST CHAMPARAN 27. VINIT SINGH S/O SHIV SARAN SINGH R/O VILL-MANGALPUR, P.S- RAMGADHWA,DISTT- EAST CHAMPARAN 28. KRISHNA MHAN PANDEY, S/O SRI LALLAN PANDEY, R/O VILL- PARSHIYA BUJURG, P.S- MAIRWA, DISTT- SIWAN 29. KAMESHWAR PASWAN S/O MUSHAHD PASWAN R/O VILL- SAHASHPURA, P.S- PASAUR, DISTT- BHOJPUR 30. BHOLA PASWAN S/O BIRBAL RAM R/O VILL-SAHASHPURA, P.S- CHARPOKHARI, DISTT- BHOJPUR 31. JITENDRA KUMAR S/O RAM ISHWAR DAS R/O VILL-KURTHA, DIH, P.S- MAKHDUMPUR, DISTT- JEHANABAD 32. SANTOSH KUMAR S/O LATE RAM BHAJJU YADAV, R/O VILL- NARSHUA, P.S-MAKHDUMPUR, DISTT- JEHANABAD 33. VIJAY KUMAR S/O RAM BILASH PASWAN, R/O VILL- KODARKAR,P.S- GHORASAHAN, DISTT- EAST CHAMPARAN 34. SURENDRA KUMAR S/O SRI MAHENDRAPRASAD YADAV, R/O VILL-SINGARPUR, P.S- MANANPUR, DISTT- LAKHISARAI 35. VIBHASH CHANDRA S/O SRI JAGDEMBA RAJAK, R/O VILL- KHAWA CHANDRA TOLA, P.S- MEDNICHOUKI, DISTT- LAKHISARAI 36. RAMNATH SINGH S/O NAKLESH KUMAR SINGH R/O VILL- KHARIKA,P.S- DIDDUPUR, DISTT- VAISHALI 37. JANARDAN RAI S/O SRI RAMRAI R/O VILL-LARAI, P.S- BAXUR, MUFFASIL, DISTT- BAXUR 38. RAJESHKUMAR RAI S/O LATE BRAHMESHWAR RAI R/O VILL- GOVINDPUR, P,S- BAXUR,MUFFASIL, DISTT- BAXUR 39. RANJIT SINGH S/O LATE RAMJIWAN SINGH, R/O VILL- BISHANPUR BERI, P.S- MOHADINAGAR, DISTT- SAMASTIPUR 40. LAKSHMAN PRASAD S/O RAJENDRA RAM R/O VILL- NEMIZ,P.S- BARHAMPUR, DISTT- BAXUR 41. SANTOSH KUMAR S/O RAM DAHU MISHRA, R/O VILL-PIPRA, P.S-GOVINDGANJ, DISTT- EAST CHAMPARAN 42. SANJIV KUMAR S/O SIVJEE PRASAD, R/O VILL- PIPRA, P.S- GOVINDGANJ, DISTT- EAST CHAMPARAN 43. BRIJ KISHORE PRASAD, S/O LATE RAJENDRA PRASAD R/O VILL-MAJHUPUR, P.S- JAGADISHPUR,DISTT- BHOJPUR Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH THE CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVT. OF BIHAR, PATNA 2. THE D.G. OF POLICE, BIHAR PATNA 3. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SLELECTION BAORD MUZAFFARPUR DISTRICT THROUGH S.P.MUZAFFARPUR 4. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD BETTIAH DISTRICT THROUGH S.P. BETTIAH 3 5. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD B.M.P.-6, MUZAFFARPUR THROUGH COMMANDANT B.M.P.6, MUZAFFAPUR 6. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD SARAN DISTRICT THROUGH S.P. SARAN 7. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD DARBHANGA DISTRICT THROUGH S.P. DARBHANGA 8. THE CHIARMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD PATNA DISTRICT THROUGH S.P. PATNA 9. THE CHAIRMAN, CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD, B.M.P-5, PATNA THROUGH COMMANDANT B.M.P-5, PATNA 10. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD, B.M.P-10 BODH GAYA THROUGH COMMANDANT B.M.P.-18 BODH GAYA, DISTT- GAYA 11. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD MADHUBANI DISTRICT THROUGH S..P. MADHUBANI 12. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD, B.M.P.-20 DUMRAO THROUGH COMMANDANT B.M.P.-20, DUMRAO, BUXAR 13. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BAORAD B.M.P.-14, PATNA THROUGH COMMANDANT B.M.P.-14, PATNA 14. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD MOTIHARI, DISTRICT THROUGH S.P. MOTIHARI, DISTT- EAST CHAMPARAN 15. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD BHOJPUR, DIST- THROUGH S.P.BHOJPUR 16. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD GAYA, DISTRICT THROUGH S.P. GAYA 17. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD BEGUSARAI DISTRICT THROUGH S.P,. BEGUSARAI 18. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD, B.M.P.-9, JAMALPUR THROUGH COMMANDANT B.M.P.-9, JAMALPUR, DISTT- MUNGER 19. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BOARD BAXUR, DISTRICT THROUGH S.P. BUXAR 20. THE CHAIRMAN CONSTABLE SELECTION BAORD, B.M.P.-12, NEW B.M.P.-11 JAMUI THROUGH COMMANDANT B.M.P-22 NEW B.M,P-11 JAMUI ----------- 2. 17.2.2010 Heard learned counsel for the petitioners and the State. The petitioners claim to be applicants for the post of Constables under Advertisement Nos. 1, 2 and 3 of 2004. The writ application is bereft of necessary 4 pleadings and materials. This Court is not persuaded to start a roving inquiry at the behest of the petitioners in an inconclusive writ petition. The writ application does not even disclose the marks obtained by each of the petitioners but mentions the marks of only some of them. Only in the event that the petitioners file a specific representation making full disclosures of the details of their application made in response to each advertisement, details with regard to name of another who allegedly had much less marks than the petitioners in the same category and came to be appointed causing hostile discrimination or a person lesser in the merit panel came to be appointed ignoring the successful placement of any of the petitioners higher in the panel position, only in that event and not otherwise, are the respondents required to consider such representation. The writ application stands disposed. P. Kumar (Navin Sinha, J.)