;IN 'HIE mcH ccnnyr otSrefinc^'NiRE cHH^T'Nse^^ :.^^;:Jtin^^im:^r:::^^.'::..,?;:"':":^-^ W.P.NO.^ ^-tKK/ 2XSM .-^ ^^, :^'1: : Pramod Luaiya . . S/o t^fe SKri^ Luiiiya, ^Aged.about 40i'3;ears, Matiamaya ' • ;Ward:•£ .^ N6.4 KawarS^ tMt ^'Ka^Sasdn- (C.G.). '.: ':';.:.^ :••:'• Res.ppndents ^^^ SantQda Gupta S/o Jagaruiafh Gupta, Aged abozifc 3? years, Ward No4<3, Kawara&a, Di§t iS Kahinlhflin. T PET3TION U/A 226/227 QF THE CSONSTITUTION OF INDIA State^of Ghliattisgaite Throu^i DeEartmertt^ofIJrt)an AdminlstratiCai Marttralaya Ratpur, Disf : Raipur-(©.0^ Chhattisgarh State Eleetiori Commission ^^^^^^^^^ T^ Comnussioner, Raipur, Dist : Raipur-(e.G.) The Retuming OfBcer, MuniGipaH^y E3ecf^ Kabirdliaia XI-HC—78 siT^i^ei R-iji* ^SI 3H^?T ssi^l^ ^5f^i-I<ld-4;EsiT3-u'i(o,fsi<nwtiC ^.(^,^.N0.^^2/<=^ 3n^?(Tra^T (' TBTIW ^ft^ 311^? ShriftafuU SImSaiy^S. fer ic^KMBdemtNo.l.J iShilSi'^aoilE^Wsi'maj TespGadea.t^Nt^.2; SUri Malsy KumSr TespoilclMit N6.4. ,jc©Bna!eK -"the^pctitkHaeR';!' : ' ,i€»^u<yGtWfcamaaetitAdvocate 'Stato.'^', • , 1': ;• ./','- A*Ictiti@iat;AdwoCTte Geiteralfiw ^. ..•'^...^.i^.::<:':' ..: QIiiadun, cQiEmsel'for fhe adff Hcard on actinissiohl mterimreBef. Under GIt&attisgai^i coatesting elecstj'o® as a qiaaMcations faame more fhan two tMag ctuldren, 2001, is dfaqualMcd to conte^ Lunfya filed nomination said and all (rflBean Iiaye "(aiEtoi No.4, with vanous documents, baby ofpetitkuter, aad ia hfe and other docuiaents, he on 9-9-2002. Retiuaiag reganiiag birih of lliad baby, by Dr.Subir Shi-h^stw?a, dhe a Govenuneat HospitriwUcrda| B.e.G. •vaccmatxma and I objeetor/respondent No.4, aad sio|i apd M.(W.)I*.No.4g@5/3004 Sx Rjesatent nan'ated ^T1^^') ^tH<?tf^f1^T^ <Rsi^R ^TSlfipT 311^1 MuBiCtpayties Act, IS6I, "fiw or Counsdtor, i®rieus 1, and jf afly peisaa, wbp baa loae ef vdiOTa is Ixan aft %-1- K thc saine. PtetlttoneT Piaxaiod fhat he has tluce chfldrea, beforo 26-1-3001. Ra c|tiaBeaged liue date ofliu'ffiofthiid. otijectioa, du^su^iortBd "^r affldewtt dyctesai birtti Itoattte ttual Uaby td<rtEl>afh ia his sunMnaiy etognaBy, oaasidCTed theiORrtifiesrtielssiiKd of GOTntnwnity^Hea|(b Geatre, |tUe baly wws pnwMfid I}.P.T. aaid |&e andawt fflnxt t?y fte ialso^coiB^ercd eae dociMBdt ie. lids «e<xad F p: ;:-f-!' ^^i-n^-— ^sr -^ i<<M 4), yti|<H' i(o, fs(d hyi^l. ^-f^.^^rsy'^ sn^r 'q^' ('^f^sr^ET) 3l1^T ^T R-fi'* ?TS?l SFfT^T *^l^ ^BiWflfCTsn^t q'l«<lCT<iil^FRff 'if TS<S ff^t^t ^•3TfOTfl;31]t5r^ : " : ba-Bi eertiflesae, issued by<auef|Muaieip^ OfiBeer, Ratrardha,' ffled by fhe petittiaiCT, wfaereui fllfi d^^Nitt fias l>c®n'Wrtsred as"S- t-2001. Aftergiwta^'weightE^^d| ao^ilmiaitea^;It^^ the.pMties, Returnu^ QdB^ t^ c<Mne to tUe^^ flie petitioiter^ (Idd fcaby totAbir^ after ^-]L^@1^^ dedaicd the petitiBDerdisqiaalifl^fcwlIwetecti^^ ' e objecrti^resp0tj<leait'^.4 filledi^affiAawtt beferc Retiuiung Officeriasupp^ o ^c<mtiai(i(^,,'I^a^ not coiitroverteit ly (he petttionlsi'. Br-Subir SluuastawaDf'Waaal Surgk^ Nursii^ Home iSsued ^efertifieate GMti^a^ ^ baby offhe petlttenertook bir(h{cm 9-Q-! Q2 at 11;^ P.M. Undw D.P.T./Pdip Tlkalsanm Abttiyai^ tte tbad fcaty of tt^ peiUianer was got vaeciaated m Govenu^mt Mospital, wtoerMa ^ A birth oflltat baby was mcntK>nejd as 10-9-2002. 'Iliat date ofbnth is sSwaya given by the par«|i'ts who take (hieitieMdrea for vaccination. Ftom aU thc afore^ad documratts, tt te 8OTw*eBt fl*at the tiurd baby of the petiyone^ •ttxA buth aft 26-1-2001. In rebuttal, petitioaer faas flied on^r oiie doe'uiatait ie. feirtti eertffiGate issucd byN^arPalika,Kabirj©}i,aia<ai10-9-2004, whareja ttie date ofbirth is niealapnedas $-1-2001. -Tfais ei tlfi<»tewsa aot obtaiaajed soou a^a" fhe birtli orlaratttin reasoiMBtle fnae. 'IliiCTefiMe, leanwd Rctumu^ Qfifeer, uji pving nreightage to fbe o&er doeuaieiris, diify supported ^By af&lBOTt, did ^aefc'eotnndt aay K: 9 wssas 'S^: -41<tlyl •i),;®TllWt<c, fs]dWly uo.r't^.^^s^ *<I*IMI 9b*<rai ^Sn^TiTSRT (' p) SiT^I ^f R-li* d«IT3tl^Tgiiriq; G.SJzigEi ?'RIW( ^(T SD^I fllegaMly or enor ia wliieh ttus juaasdicticui. The petitfon, fited Court In (he l^it of above) l=fil<<M^*l 'lTW^ff ^* f^et tf^RgT^ ^'sifgHaii^r iBtei'fa"e-under ils wxit xmd»Anycles 236/227 of ttc Coastitution, isliabletobedteii^ssedaadffia^ saiBaimaty. <Mdea-s,Aa.{W,}P.N6.4995/M04fiM- iaBteraa rcUef aad I.A.No.Sa^/^Q^ fer la^jeat of. Sd/- I-.C. Bhadoo Judge Nr