78 t i 411 NO116 of2009 etc P 1 IN 11EI1IGHCOlll1 I7Pl 1 Ill ANII IIARYANA AT 1 1 IIAlll1110 1 1 1 IlA17117IllIISllIiV17201J9 lCWP NO116 of2009 5 1D 1 2 0 RajinderKunulr and otlIers Petitiollcrs 0 VKRSlIS 5 VAeW Stntcof Puiljab 8 Otllers IeslltJtllletlls 2C Ic 2CIVPNo13772 of 21108 1 21 Tej I Siilgll a1141Illlers clitioners e ea Cl VERSIJS I Stllte OlllcrS 08 3CWP No7853 tlf 1999 110 C Jaslvillder Singhet PelititJilerS WA Z VERSl1S fl Stateof Punjab Ctce 4CWP No12553 of 1999 1 Petitionersa DannSingh and others 1 VKRSlIS StateofPunjalI S tliers espondeiIts 5ClsVPN19195111 211118 I MailjitSitlllll ltntl t1Illers etili41i1C1Se Il llll5 l 4 StllteofPutljab tllerS lltSjllllltletlls 4 6eCWPN054610f2009 Narinder Sinoh and others etitioiicrs Rawat Seema 2014.02.21 14:05 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 79 7 tV Vl I Sl Is 1 Stlite ol lllerS 7CWPNo17 of2009 1 Pet itioners Jagjit Singh and otllcrs VERSUS 10 StateofPunjab 0 Others 8CWPN05472of2009 0 J Pet iti o ne rs 0 Hira Lal and otlIers I 0 VERSUS I e e StateofPunjab 8 Otllers Z 9CWPNoS2 of 2003 1 PetitiollCIS 1 m Bhola Singh and otllcrs 1 C r ViRSllS ResiolltlsIltS 1 08 State of Punjab Otllers 2 ClO of 2008 eee Pctitioners 7 m7 Chand anil otllers 1 Z 1 0m VERSUS il tS 4 Stote of Punjab8 Others 41 iO l CWP eee Petitioncrs l and othcrs 4 Rtj K u illlll Ya C 1 51 1 VERSlS StateofinjabS Otlle 11 2CWP No19726 of 2008 11 1etitiotlers 1n4 Makhan Singhand otIIers 11 Vl115l 5 11 State of Punjab OtlIer5 11 No107 f2003 13CWP 1 Rawat Seema 2014.02.21 14:05 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 44r 49ere k4 a4 80 4v 1 ClVl NO1 I6 f21111I ctce 1 7 1 1 11i iis llllJ 111111 0tlicrs elIlllllllrs V118l 1 Stlite tlf Punjall Ollters IlcSlllllldCllts 14CWP NtJ1677204211118 Slliilder P1ll 11111tItlters e4eletitIlilcrs 1 VKRSllS C Stilte of Punjab 0 Otllers Rcspotldetlts 0 0 f I CORAM C5 1 e a I IION13LIiMRJlIS10K PlllRMll 1illLl 1 Z 4 iii I7SlIVT 71rCI 51tll1 AtlIS111111 MrSItl 1lRti111 C7ocl Al141S aIllllli MrNl anlini 1tdVOCtltc 171r111C pclllIoilcsl 1 t i I AlsChdrli 1li11 SrDAC7 1linjabfOr respondcnts 08 Pernlod Koh ao 1 m7 SlllCCCtlllllllOll qucstions 01 1Ill 2IildlaclS 111101ccl 21rC 117 illcs Z petitiOIlS the sanle arc 01 Iovlllis COlllIllOIl Order For thc sake o 1 0 Ilrc11 I7lctsirc bciil ltkcll fCIlll0Wi Nt1 1 16 12009 11 4 it hc pctioncrsitllllcse 1 pcltlltIns tre IvorkillLlOll clailv Wtl11 IA 4 clillercilt calllcltics IlO lIlCSllltc 1 llttjaIo 17IrIlclllIythc 1 111 l 13 WaterSulOlol 1 and Sailiialion he 1117lVCrS I ll 111thcSejilililS c fOl Lo 1111 C 17 tll Il lIllC5 il 1Il c Il l 1l l li 111111 1 01 Ill1 1lt 117 rCVittl lttlill 1 111110Ili Illlll tliCillS f Ior 1 pcriocl of tllrc VCOrS Iorc c c diils llIc lllill I l l Il c i v r i l Ioc l i l u i l 5 r 4111 le810nersk04 f7lediCWP Wo I l 21 110f 20 90tlIlCt wluick jlllll ttI 1 I 4it91179e1 1 1 11 017Icrtlc1 1 21117 uilh Iieji jr 1 I7 rIIlllllIll illl ll14811llltA l llltllitloL1 I1 1ttiIlic 11 R11 5 Ccle 1 1 el Rawat Seema 2014.02.21 14:05 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 81 4 5urdasplIrto take a dccisltlll 4111ille iSSlICIllllllvcd kcepiilg 7 Iil VieW 1 decisionrenderedby tlle SuprclllCCt9llrl Ill lIlC COSC 01 ScerctliryStnte0I Karilataka VS Uttla DCVi 0tlitrS 21111631SLR 1 bypassiIlg a well reasoned orderswithttlSlX monthsIroln thedate of recelpl01 a certlIled copy of thc order C0illlle basis 01 lhe a Ioresaidordcr lhe 1 EngilIccrWatcl SlilPly 2111dSailitatioilCircle Ludhiana C vide hisorder dated2532008 Allilcrc P I 2 allegccllrcieclecl lllc cltllill 0 0 ofthe petitioners for il 4 SlEe I t Ilasbeen held tl01 undcr the GovernlnentPolv datecl 151 22006 llle regularization C5 IS to be E orderedon completion of 10 years Or 1110re Scrvice strictly to their seniority the concerned Z lll againstthe avaiIabJeregular sanctlonedvacant posts IoVilhthc Il bcCil Illclllltll led ll C1 has bcen illacle in clillcrelll Catcgoricsagainstthe available I 05 vacancies For Ptllllp Rcgtlllriz011hasbeennadeuplo 638 10 fOrMali Cum Chowkiclrllllltl 57 Illtl I7lrllllcr 000l ic llllltl 72 olc 1 e2 Z Senorilylist whereasthe petil ioners nliillbers are nluch below and lhe 3 Il petit loners case will bc consiclcrcdS Iiltl vllell Illcir lllrll colnes according 5 to their I t is turlhcr slalcd tl oflhe junior 11011C personsto tllc 1 petitlonershavebeen reglilarlzcol 1 1 Learnedcounsel for tllc jocliliollerS IliiVC lhe 4a claim of the joeti tioilers Ill lllt 1I7IrcsIldIlrIl Was not Ior but lor lllc grtllllI Illt Illllllllllllll tIllllt 1O1Iy scale 1111 1c111s becnexlcndcdlo slmiIarIy sjitil111 IcrStlllS Illtl IilrgCnumbcr of persolls engagedOll dallywagc basis Ialcr i il lilllc tllilil llle IoclitioilersIl2lvcl1Cll grantedsuch benellls levIlilc Illc sIlnC trCllllCill to the 1 This fact JS aJso cvIcnl Ii9111 f Cllle of the j udgnlenldated 1 4 Rawat Seema 2014.02.21 14:05 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 82 r 1 22 l 2007 passcdill CWlA112111212 Iilcd bylhc pelilltIilcrsIlt 1 rr 1 1 petitionershavc accorcliIlglyil lcd tlllS 11C1 ltlIil lhe o171rcsid Illc1ll7I lC Sl II 1 ll le re l ie l Ior lllerant of Ill118CS 11 theininimumofthe pay scale Iil 111llle 2i1s0the relicf is Iol grantof wagesat tlle Illlllillllllll Clf Ille IO sctlc The Ioelilioilers llillC relicd UPOilVriOUS judginents 0f this cc 2111d the Honble Suprenleourt 1 earlier passed 0 HOWCVCrthe claiill ol lle 0 pri j Iioners iS Jloposccl and reslslctl bv lJlC I respondcnts Oll lhC 4Ill ild tll tllC Ilcllollcrs C5 arc n01 cntitJedto lhe SIlllC I WageSas are granledlCI lhe of thc Slalc MsCharu Tuli learilccl Z COtt1Scllor l1112 has subinittedthal Ill 2 the llghtof the 110llc Collrl Ill lhe of llnlll case Devi supral the petiliollersIre nt Cillitlecl to be regularisedlt has I 08 furtherbeenarguedOll bclJ11f01 Ihe thal bygrantingsimilar r0 payscales would lIllOlllllO IIIC Illitll equalswhlch ilscl 1 t17 Z IS l n contraventioil tI lllc joro11 1s 1 1115 Il lrliclcs 14 and 16 of the Consliliition01Indiil 1 j haveheardlearileclCclllll 1tIlllle I11IICSIl Is ilcIl lllai llle t petitlonersare worklllOIll Vc1170llSC113ICilttIS llS PltillpOlerators MaliClllll Chawkidar Fitter Coolic 1 Illcr 1Iclller Slorc Munshi alld such othcr Oll C capaClties lt is adinittecl11tISIliOil lllll Ille iire working Oll dai IVOC hasis Ior lllc lIsl Ill lllllltr 11 11Il Sllt tlltS Illl Ilc Illlrc lllj tlovodccaclcs ll IS 1Ictidccl I l l 111C IlIrll llclilillil tlltll lIlcre is honltl Cll COll S P group of tholIsaildSOf CllllolOyccs ileorkiilo dciIlywlge basisin the Sltile Ill of Pun The dulieS lilcl r513tlilsillililes01 tlle ill tllcir respectlvc categories are same 11c111 IlClr111 IdctlticallnclionS and share Rawat Seema 2014.02.21 14:05 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 83 l5 similar responsibilllicsEveii lllc dLilles IlllOtlgSllllc iil tllcir 1 categones are lCY Cllljll0yccs 11lllc rc SIllle St11t SliIlC Wise seniOrityIists lave bceil 170rdi lereill and 1111 lhe pelitIonersllrC borIlCOll lllc oJIll Scll lort l v Ilsls A ItlrOeillilllbcr l dtIlllI wagerseven engagedlater lll liille sland rcgularized whereasolhers are gettlngmlnllllUtll of pay SCille unclcr vdrious Judgnlentsof this COurland 1 the Honble ApexCourt The pelionershtlverelerred lo a largenunlber01 O passedby Honblc Ctlllrl ttndtllis Court Sonle of such 0 I judgments are noticedlcre titlderl 9 I In the case ofStllte of Others VS Dcvinder Singhc0 01hers Civil AppealNoA492 of 1997 dccidcd Oll 21719971lhC Z 4 Hotlble Cotirl IlIs illtIc W Itl 0lir VICW tllc of lluitl IIay Iilr I EquolWork ca n cnsure to the to tlle r3 Qo iimilecl exlcilt Ivllcll lllcy Ivcrc Iound ltI lloVC t becil giviil siIllililr work as ledger 0 Kccperstheycould htlvebeen paidthe nlilllllllllll 1 of lhc joily scllc ol tt l edgcrKccperovhich uits 1 avililoble lO Lcdger Kcclocrslltlscr Ccis 1eilrIled colinsI for Ihe il ctniId Iltll sliccesI ltlly coiltctlcl tlii Sticll iil tIrtlci slltllild l tlIl IlIve hcell IltlssttlI4I thcrc17rc 1117llllS lO lhe 1inlitcd exlclll Illl Illtllt111 l llc 11rC held onthe IOriilcllolc cl cltii11 PY IClrEqlltllWork to gcl the 1 Sillilry 1111Illlc lo llle LedgcrKccl5rsllcdgci Rawat Seema 2014.02.21 14:05 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 84 7 1 rcgti I2lrlyrccrtliled theywould be Clc rks 1 110 11C n entitled lo the illlllllllUill of theay scale of the 1IgC illlIy hc avililtlblc ltl Illc il leol clgcr Keepersand lhey 1 Ctllllltlt1c Iolidlhc Llillllll tllllC SClle as lllCYIVerc not as Ledger 1 r lItlrkSoa 0 0 On the basisof thc aIoresaididgineiltCWP No10017 01 C0 r 1995was dccided vldc ltUlllclll llccl 2081 998 passedby thls Courl C5 whereinfollowingobservations hailchccninadel 6i I 11101lloc writ pctitionand dlrect the Z ts lO Iltly IllC lllltllllllltll pay scale to thc m C2 lvalltlbleto lllc rcgulilrOclroi Clerks r4 petitiOllersllS IS wlth allowailces 011 the basis and tlle c6 CO di11crctlcc1111 Ivetil tllC Cllltlllllllcills ctIcly ltl eIcll wa0 ofIhe pelilioner Ilall bc jol 179ra period01tlliee Ieilll Z prir to thc IllIilu tf 11112 Wril IoelillOll1O fronl 122 1992 t1 Thc arrcars so cllculIlcclshall be paidwithin loltl hcre inviIl bc ilo orcleras to costs Il A similarordercanle to be p9scdbyHonble SuprenleCourl ill lllc C0 case 01Nagtr IJllikIlill tiitl Is K11111ir SiiiIi O Jllieis 1Ci1Iil AppeINo187911999 tlecitled 1Ill Ivherciilil has bcenohscrlc as under cspondcilts re ltilder lllc iIllpcllillll Illc lighCouil lor lhc rclicl tllill 1 arc cillillcd lo lhc sclle of pay as is availableto Rawat Seema 2014.02.21 14:05 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 85 8 1 rCglllarcllllll0yees Il Illc sctIlc 11le 1 IelrIlcd SinglcJudgegrantcdhe said rellef Oll Y lhc DivIsioIl L3eiochhascoille tO COilCllisloll thal lhcrc IS IlO justiilcatloil lo iillerlerc wilh lllc order of the Ie2lrnedSingleJudge butrlher cllirIlletl l llIl stl l7Il IS tlle OrrCllrS are CoilCerJled n Q the rcspoiltlcllls 1v01 ld bc eiltitlcd lo draw ill lllC 0 tll i il 1Ill ll Ill O l thcscole 01 pay lor El peiod013 yellrs 0 I prior10clalcoflhe Olingofthe writ 90 C5 A Divisioii Bench of this Courl allowcd CWP No7807 of 1999 Oll 1422000 relyingupon the above mcntionedjudglnents and madefollowing Z observations 2 1t I1lc dtlclriilc ol cqtial for CtllltIlIvork 1Iy I eilsllrinccI iil Irlicle 39Il of llle Collsttllli4Ill 08 f illljOOSCSI dlllv 011 thc Ioubl ic eillploycr10 Io V similar wagesto the doingsilnllarwork Z and ill IilclntI l tlle lact lllat the dulics bciil Qm pcrIorillccllly Illc loclilloncrsorc simililr lo lllosc ClcrkslOclrtli Ierks and 10rIcrs who ar7 bciilc Ptlldstlt10in lhe rcgliItlrtinlc scalc we Ilnd nJeril C Ill lllc Illc llleyttrc enlillcd lo bc s11lryiil lhercgulilr joayscale 1cilCC tllC Iovril pctttioilis a llolnvedThe respondents arc clirectedto pay to Ioe ill l il l Ill ll Ill I l l tllc rcnlilar joay scales RrescrJbed loi nthc posls 0 1 CIcrkslOctrci Clerks antl 9rilcrS Rawat Seema 2014.02.21 14:05 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 86 9 1 hey shall also be IoaiclDearilessAllowance and other IlitlloIlilccs lIS illtlV bc adlllissiblc ltJ slIcll 1 ClllllllllCcs1111tler Illc Rtilcs 7hc cliffercilt thc eilloluillents alreadypaidto the and wllicll Ill2Iybcpiyllble 10 lllenl in terms ofthe order shall be coilllned to a periodof pnorto 1 C lhe dale 0 011i15 o the Writ petition 1ll e arrears 0 shiill bc 17idlo Illc joclilitlilcrse withiil a pcriod01 0 I IuLli Itlill Illc cIltlcof receipt0 a certilied 0 copyof this order 1 Thc pclilloilcrs l lc IllIcctl4111lCcllrtl il llliillloct tI olllel j 01 Z this Court and Honble Suprcnle00llrl lolIhcreillhc aforesaid Q have beenrelied upon WIlicharc nol bce adllcrcd ltI I To the colltraryMsCllarli 11 1 IcIrIleclclillscl lor llle resjlllldcill L QO has relied upon State of llaryaiill 11111 O il tIl e r V ilak Raj 1111d 2 AIR 2003 SuprenicCou rt 2658 lll tlle ilorcsaid udglllctllwhile Z the 01 pplicllliuil0 1 doclrinc of EqualPay 170r EqualWork qua the dally Ill Coillparison with the regularaJld PCrillanent staff Honble COtirl IllilcleIollowing obserVdtions 6 13Itilll P2Iy171rctlttillwoi is concepl Ievllich a rcquircS Ior ilS colllplcleaild Illltllcsale identilybelwccll 1 0 claiming idenlictll 1alI sctllcs lild lhe other group of cmployecs who havc alreadr corned such pay scales The problenl 1 1 about equal PllY CilllllOl il Illlaysbe translated liltO tl mathcnlatieaIlornllllll 1 Rawat Seema 2014.02.21 14:05 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 87 CWP NOJ 16 of2009 etc Ill Refercnce 1s tIso illtltlc lll 111llldglllclll9SCCIIll llle clse tll Stile 111 Orissa and others VSe Balarain 5ihu and others2200311 Suprcnle Court Cases 250 IvIlemill1lltlblc StiprcillcCourl Illadc observations I l 11ilIllgll Ctlll 1027Ior CqllillIiOrk J5 1 ciisidcrcd lo be a eoilconlilanl of lrtielc 4 il S 3 much as equalHlork for unequalwork Ivill also 0 CO bc tlcglIlltIil01 th2tlrighlequalpay wottld llPtlll 1101 lhC ilitlurc or the volunle o 1 work C5 I but also Oll lhc differele as regards Z reliabiIityand as well and thotlell 1C 2 lhc IllllCllllllS tllv be lIlC Sllnle bul tllc Q 4 IIics do lllokc il rcol tlild StillsltliltiIl I diIlcrcnce 08 OO XXX XXX XXX XXX 7 1 Z l 3 7l ClIllll i relicl 0Ill he hlsis Ofecltitllllll Il iS tl f71rillt CIIllllIlllS Itl SlllStlliltivc l clearctit llISISt11 CqllllIalcllceld tl reslillanl hostilediscriminatiotl bclorc hcclnoingcllgiblc lO claim rightson a par C Wltll Illc oIhcil Orollp VIS4IS 1111 illcgctl dISCrIIllilllllll Anolllcr udglllclll rrIictl Ill Ills ll1rl1 7111is i11lhc CaSeIl Stllte of Plliljllb and IlllIrS 1S StIriilllcr Sitloli 1111d71110111rr21111741 SCT 628 whereinfollowIngobscrllIllt1115 havebcen nlade Ilc lriiIcIc tl1 ct1l11IlOy Ior equalwork Ilas 0011e0 sco 0Ilil1 arlier lhc Vicw othis olIrl Rawat Seema 2014.02.21 14:05 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 88 1 1 S 1 l l IVIS i l 1117tlpClStlilsilrc thc SIlllC LlItctitliis 11111Ivill Ilc ctllIllcoI lll SOlllC IiIge5 Ilns VICIII hoshccn cllonoedoncl 011 1hc 110101 01 lllJS COllrl lS that there shoulcl bc coilllolctetIlcl tolal identlly betweeil lhe llnlill 1 IOSOllSSlllllllrlySllualccl so as to granl of ecluoI C 1lly lor Cllllll Ilitlrk Rccclltlytllis Cou rt Ilos 1111 0 0 Ill itl411 114tl pcrsons hS ltl h coinplcleand tolo in Case 0f a regularapIOOiIllec C5 mrm he has a selection process and his Z SCrVICCS lre Cglll IIleil ilti cltlilyWge CllllolIee n IS discllilinglhe siune IlillCllons as a regular L 4 lllc Ililllrilics 2Irc ilol bllulld Ill grIll I 06 eclLiEilIoay 10 stlcll a IoerSOll Who is appOillted Oll rio claily101121cbISISIC for a short tern ancl 4 m ilol 171ccdlhc sclccl10l1 Z processlllus lhc 1 tl o I CCllltllptly Ior equalwork hasto be 8l7liltedonly if thcrc is a lotal and ideilIllyIlelllleeilelhelWO Ioersoils n thisviei1 we lrC llI tt IccisItlil0l lllis COlirl Iil llle C 4 case Ol Otlers vs StlIte 1f Jlia rklili ntl 11t101lters 20117 SCI 76 211117 91 SCll 1311 JT 2111171Illl SC 272 IlIliell ll becil reerrecl to er 111dccisioilsoftllis Cotlrt XXX X XXX 8Ill 1ICII 111 Illc IcIil 1lISIlItIIl OS 111ClllllIilel Rawat Seema 2014.02.21 14:05 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 89 CWPNO16 of2009clc 12 aboVC IVC iIrc ofllle opiilioilllilt the victinltlkcil lll Illc lltlnble Iligh Clllrl granting SCalc t11 reglll lI r cill plcIyeCS10 the daiIy wage employccs 1 dc1es110 ljopclIilo be well founded p Il 4 we alloiv tllesc appealsand set aside the order 0 Ihc I lIllll COllrl tlS llle 1ri11Court tiIld diSllliSS 1 0 111C Slilts Illctl ly tllc rcspondcnts herciil 0 The dictunl o tllc rclictI 1110tilbyMsC1liiru ul Co I IS thatthc doclrincof cqtioi Itll ClllltllItlrk Il Illlllll IC Ill Vkell Illr11 C5 1 I becaiise sonle enlployces are ktld of duties tl Iot 01 othercons ideratio llS are 1I bc SCCIl 171rwhich lhc reIcvatllillalerl Z IllLISt be placedon rcclrd Siill i l1r 1SllC IViIS consiclcrcdbythis Ctllirt Iil tllc C2 case of PardeepKlilllllr tllllers vs Stllte ol Plttlj2tbllllcl othe CMl I c6 No8671 of 1987 decidcd tlil 11 120081 IIl lllc aloresaid case Ivllllc 00 considering the jliclgnlent01 11onble SupreilleColirt in tllc C21SC Ol 47 Surinder Singh supral follolvilgobservalionshavebeen lade Z Clm HOIVCIICr ill SllrinclerKllmars case supralIhe Iloilblc rlpcx Colirl has uled that lhe priilciIolc connol be iccl unlcss lherc ts lolal antl clIillpIeldt111iiy hclvretIIlr Iwo lr5111s Ill tlll C prcseni case on accounl of various earlicr j u dgillcllttll tIlISCollrt conllmled by lheHone Slipretllc0011 daily ivagersin almosl all the are getting the basic salaryin the pal SClIC 1 jOtlSl by lhe reelIlliI cinpIoIccs tlnd tlis bcneIlt hasnbccil 8110cd tll Rawat Seema 2014.02.21 14:05 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 90 r CIVPNO16 of2009 elc 13 IIlCIll Ilr lllc pcriIc1 tllrcc yciirS iltl Ill Illotltlls bcl0rc thc Illiilg lhc Writ pcljtion 11 17 petittoncrsilre simiIorIyslluole and lllus tllcre IS complele and lotal iclentllybetlveenthe Illtl lllc n1i111IlllClS lolIllotIrC Ivorkin iil olllCl dClltlrllllcillsitl Ille Sl2Ile Ile pelitillners cl1111101bl j Cl deiliecl thc simlllr bcnelIts as has beeil grttiltecl ltl 0 olllcr d2itl waeers wlorking iil the saine anclother 0 I Ill lIlCSltltccll Puillab 11 C5 The suill and sllbslallcc 31tIlC rclied Lilooilbothtlle siclcsis I V lhat the doclrine of cquiil1121yIor ctllltll lrork ts icable onlywherelhe Z 4 idcntity IllC ICllllllrllrldlill IlllOCrS iilcl reelil appointccl is 9l Ill1 jlill Illltle h lllt I petitiOnersare that lhey clre pcrlorllllllgIhc same Iulies as the regulI 5 00 appointed are jocrlorilllllo 21l1d il lrge nuinber of dailytvagers 7 are getting tlle inlnlllllIIll Ol tlle SClileby VlrlliC of variousjudgnlcnls ol Z llle Hoilblc SuprcnlcCuul l Ild llli5 Cuui l i13 21IS0lhal SOillC lIillC lllC pClSl5 Oa are lCSC lVCrlllCillS IlC iltll becilClcllicd tllld Ill the replyflled by thc 111c011Il iIrlllllllcnls raised O Il bchall01 the is that claily Iitlle Iltll becll sclccled el 2111 CJ of selection whereasllle regliliIrlyIlIlOIlledelllllloyccsWcre duly selcctcc In Vlew of lhe calenll lll Illis otirl allirmccl by tlle l Ioillolc Supreme Coilrtreferred to hcrciblC Illl t1 thc coilsidcred ltclv Ill thc peliloners cannot be detI il SillliIiI trC21l111c111 11Sgivetllo uthcr dii wagersworking1Il V 21r l O l l S o l tllc Stlle in he same colegClr19 to which the petitiollersbelon I lli1 illc sjoeci llc averments of tlle Rawat Seema 2014.02.21 14:05 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 91 49 9 FUV t J 14 6 14 1 that pcrsons wllcl tlre lIlel i ll l iIllc llliIll tlle lel ititIilcts arcgettingminilnuin pay sctiles IlIc 1101beeil dcniccl llls llul irrelevantto saythat lhere is coinjolelc1011Iland 1411101lleideillilI beliieil 1 the dtil IiI4geis211ictldIgettlilgIll l ll 1lll ll lll ofpayscale underthe COllrl ortIel tllld 111eoelillclllClS ln view of the abovc tllcsc IillllS 1 Tllc sht111 m 0 be entitled to illiilillluill or Ille py scalc o lllc cillegories ltl lIlicll tllcy 0 belong with all allowancesas reviscd l10111 llnle lo lime Howevel lhe icllel 0 I shallbe conflnedt6 thrcc ycars preccdillg lhc Illiilgof thc writ pcttlionsIll 9 each case A COpyof lllis llc 1JllicctlIll rCtlrll 011 CiCIl IlIc Z I 4 117RMOD KOHLII c5 JUDGE f 09e72009 em NIFK Z L NOTEWhetherto bercferrcdfo Rcporlcr0rn0t9YESINO b 6 1 06 1 V41 1 i Rawat Seema 2014.02.21 14:05 True Scanned Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document