IA ifllllBencb IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTIS6ARH AT BILASPUR REVIEW PETTnON N0. 1^0 OF 2011 PETmONER yfnt. Aarti Gawande. aged about 38 years, W/o. Shri Tarachand Gawande. presently posted and working as Superintendent, Pre-metric Schedule Caste 6irls Hostel, Durg (C.G.) (Respondent no. 4 in W.P.fS) No.. 5402/2011) ^-""^/ o'^ RESPONDENTS : VERSUS ^ ^iiu^y The State of Chhattisgarh, Through: Secretary, Department of Tribal Welfare b.K.5. Bhawan, Mantralaya, Raipur (C&). The Collector burg, District Durg (C.G.) Assistant Commissioner, Tribal Welfare Department, Durg (C.G.) - Smt. Shakuntla Meshram, W/o. Shri Lokchand Meshram. aged about 55 years, Occupation Service Hostel Superintendent (U.D.T.) at Pre-metric Schedule Caste Schedule Tribe Girls Hostel burg, bistrict burg (C.G.) {Petitioner in W.P. CS) No. 5402/2011) APPLJCATION FOR REVIEW /RECALL OF THBOROER DATED 14^.2011 PASSED IN W.P.fS) NO.'S402/2011 The following is most respectfully submitted on behalf of the applicants/review petitioner:- HIGH COIJRT OF CHHATTT8GARH AT B1TA8PUR PETITIONER REVIEW PETITION No. 100 of2011 Smt Aart.i Ga.wa.nde^ RE-SPONDENTS VERSIJS The StMe ofChhattisgarh & Others. APPLICATION FOR B^VIEW/RECALL OF THE ORDER DATED 14.09.2011 PASSED IN W.P.(S) 5402/2011 SB: Hon'Ne Shri Satish K. Agn otri, J. Present: Shri N.N.Roy, Advocate tbr the petitioner. Sliri Shashank Thakur, Panei Lawyer for Ihe SUile/respoudent No. 1 to 3. ORDER (Passed oa 08th day ofNovember, 2011) 1, This review petition seeks review ofthe^order dated 14,09,2011 which was passed m a.bsenee of review petitioner {respondeiit No, -4 m W.P.(S)No. 5402/2011). 2. Shri Roy, lea.med coua^el appearmg fbr.the review petition.er s'abmits that the petitioner in W.P.(8) No. .5402/2011 ha.s not come with clean hands as it wa.s not disclosed bv her that she was relieved immediatelv paj5smg °ffhe impugned order dated 15.07.2011 wbereby^ tlie writ petitioner, post.ed a.s Upper Division Tea.cher & Hostel Supermtendent at Pre Matric Schediiled Tnbe Girls Hostel Diirg,' was tra.mferred to Post Matric Schedixled Tribe Girls Host.el, Cyymr, on a.dmimsfrative groimds. Once the writ petitioaier was relieved, the impugned order therein -Le, 1-5.07.201 1 coiild nc?t. ha.ve been qiia-shed. 3. Be that as it may, in the order dated 14.09.2011 passed in W.P.(S) No. 5402/2011, only the: legal position .has been considered, which is sought to be reviewed a.nd there is no dispiite m respect. ofthe la.ck of conipetence ofthe officer passmg the transfer order, wfaerebv the review petitioner wa.s also atTected. It m well settled that once the order has .been declared as millity from ite iHception, then all the consequential actioiis become void, In view ofthat, nothing exceptional or nothiiig new ha.s been pomted out which would necessitate review ofthe order dated 14.09J011. There is no merit m this review petition a.nd is a.ccordmgly dismissed, Sd/- Satish K. Agnihotri Judge Amit