[r QC» (\W “NW E gr IN THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR WRIT PETITIONxs) No. gab) /2o11 ’“Chhagan Pafel 5/0. Roopram Pa‘l‘el, aged abou’r : 49 year‘s, (Head Masfer), R/o. Villag : Jagannafhpur‘ (Sara), Tahsil 4 Balod; Distri : Durg (.). PETITIONER n) tate of Chhaffgar‘ Throh ‘rhe 'Secrefary, Ger Adminisfr‘m‘ion Deparfmenf, Manfmlya, D.K.S. Bawan, Ripur, Dis’rr‘icf aipur‘ (C.G.). a : R State of Chhatisgar‘h, oug the Secretary, chool- Educaion Departe, D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipur, Distric : Raipur 6.6.). District Eo ducatin Office, r Dug, r District Dur (C.é.). i g The Collector, Durg, District : Durg (C.G.). Bloc Eucation Offic, Bad, Disrict : Durg (C.G.). k d er lo t WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 / 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA . The petitioner named above mn<+ hummu ,wi 7 ILJI. I e k cT C.6 VERSUS S ish, ug neal a h t Thrh S t mnt t ( HEGH C01 RT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BTLASPK JR @ WEE? PETITHEN (S) No. 5514 of2‘31i Chiaagan Paiel. . VER S‘ IS RESPONDENTS : State ofChhattisgarh &; Oihersg ‘ " PEYYHONER WRIT 1’ETITION UXA 226/227 OF THE CONS’I‘ITEH‘ION OF INDLA. B: EiaiE’Eiie Ski€ Saii’sh K. § A g“:‘ihatri “ Je ‘ Shri P.‘K.Pa‘ieL A§1vocate for the petiiioner. Shri Ami} Sac; Govemmani Present " Advocaie for iha Statez’respondgnw {Passed an 19%tember, . 20}, 1) Chaileage in this paition is m the order dated 15,012011 (Amnexure P/ 1). whereby tbs petitioner: working as Head Master at Gevemnent Primary Schoolg Sunciam Balod, has been iransfsn‘ed ‘ Govemmént to Pfimary SchoQL PingaL Domiéiohara? Eisfriat Burg, on administraiive grounds. 2. Lgamed counsel appearing for 131$ yaiiiioner submits 1m: under th€ tranSfer yoiicy dated 1106,2011? it is clearly statad that. the Collecmr agone is competam t0 transfsr the amploye§s beitmgmg to class HI and ciass 1V sgrvicss, on ympQsai made by €h§ iieparimsms in approval ofthe minister-iil-ohargen ’3, In iho case on handg, it, aiypears thal: the Dioixici Education Officog Burg, without foilowing fhe gaideiioes issued in the iiansfer polioy: has passod tho impligiod oration whon the Colloo‘tor Ems boon assigned the responsibiliiy of transfer of ihe empioyoe working i1; iho comet-nod diStricti on gropoSal of iho conoemeé depamnonts, Thus, this suffers Erom the defect of oomoeteaoe of * {116 oificeru Accordingly, the traosfor iQ lmslisiaioabie in. tho eyos of iaiw. 4%. As a, rosult, the transfor order (moo 15.Q7i2()11 (.Annexuro PH). in respect or” the petitioner: is quashed. However: iibeiry is reserved to the Govemmerit to pass appropriate ordeg if so advisecL in aeooréanoe with iawi m ariminisirative exigency and in. pubiic interest 5‘ Accorc‘iinglyg the writ oetition is ailowed to the above extem, Sd/- x. Satish K. Agnihotri Judge