IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.5767 of 2009 SHALENDRA KUMAR SINGH son of late Parmeshwar Singh, residence of Village- Chain Chapra, P.S. Rivilanj, District- Chapra. Versus 1. THE UNION OF INDIA through the Director General central Reserve Police Force, C.G.O., complex, Block-, Lodhi Road New Delhi. 2.The Inspector General of Police, Bihar Sector Central Reserve Police Force,Patna. 3. The Deputy Inspector General of Police, central Reserve Police Force,Patna,Bihar. 4. The Commandant 36 Batalian Central Reserve Police Force, ITI Complex, Gaya. ----------- 3 23.6.09 Petitioner’s father was in the Bomb Defusal Squad of CRPF and died while defusing bomb in the State of Jharkhand. State of Jharkhand and CRPF have heavily compensated the petitioner’s family.Including death –cum – retiral benefit, petitioner’s mother has been given a total compensation of about Rs. 38.94 lakhs. Now petitioner wants companionate appointment. The same has been turned down on the ground that the petitioner’s family has been adequately compensated and there is no reasonable cause for grant of compassionate appointment. In my view, the order does not call for interference. The compassionate appointment has to be given where suddenly the bread earner vanished leaving the family in starvation.Here petitioner’s family has been adequately compensated and there is no need for compassionate appointment. The writ petition stands dismissed. singh (Navaniti Prasad Singh,J)