IN IN IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY APPELLATE APPELLATE APPELLATE SIDE SIDE SIDE FIRST FIRST FIRST APPEAL NO.1159 OF 2007 APPEAL NO.1159 OF 2007 APPEAL NO.1159 OF 2007 SMT. SMT. SMT. USHA RAMESH SHELAR USHA RAMESH SHELAR USHA RAMESH SHELAR ...APPELLANT. ...APPELLANT. ...APPELLANT. VS. VS. VS. THE THE THE UNION OF INDIA THROUGH UNION OF INDIA THROUGH UNION OF INDIA THROUGH THE THE THE G.M. CENTRAL RAILWAY G.M. CENTRAL RAILWAY G.M. CENTRAL RAILWAY C.S.T.MUMBAI. C.S.T.MUMBAI. C.S.T.MUMBAI. ...RESPONDENTS. ...RESPONDENTS. ...RESPONDENTS. MR. MR. MR. M.R.LAD FOR THE APPELLANTS. M.R.LAD FOR THE APPELLANTS. M.R.LAD FOR THE APPELLANTS. MR. MR. MR. T.J.PANDIAN FOR THE RESPONDENTS. T.J.PANDIAN FOR THE RESPONDENTS. T.J.PANDIAN FOR THE RESPONDENTS. Coram Coram Coram : S.K.Shah, J. : S.K.Shah, J. : S.K.Shah, J. Date Date Date : April 3, 2007. : April 3, 2007. : April 3, 2007. P.C.:- P.C.:- P.C.:- 1. 1. 1. Heard Heard Heard the Learned Counsel for the appellant. the Learned Counsel for the appellant. the Learned Counsel for the appellant. Perused Perused Perused the impugned Order. the impugned Order. the impugned Order. 2. 2. 2. The The The claim on account of railway accident was claim on account of railway accident was claim on account of railway accident was made. made. made. The appellant suffered abrasion as a result of The appellant suffered abrasion as a result of The appellant suffered abrasion as a result of which which which she had only pain. The medical certificate she had only pain. The medical certificate she had only pain. The medical certificate mentions mentions mentions pain alone and nothing more. The Award has pain alone and nothing more. The Award has pain alone and nothing more. The Award has been been been in accordance with Rule 3(3) of the Schedule to in accordance with Rule 3(3) of the Schedule to in accordance with Rule 3(3) of the Schedule to the the the Railway Accidents Railway Accidents Railway Accidents and and and Untoward Incidents Untoward Incidents Untoward Incidents (Compensation) (Compensation) (Compensation) Rules, 1990. Rules, 1990. Rules, 1990. 3. 3. 3. I do not find any illegality in the Order. I do do not find any illegality in the Order. I do do not find any illegality in the Order. I do not not not find any merit in this appeal. Consequently, the find any merit in this appeal. Consequently, the find any merit in this appeal. Consequently, the appeal appeal appeal is dismissed. is dismissed. is dismissed. .... .... .... [S.K.Shah [S.K.Shah [S.K.Shah , J.] , J.] , J.]