IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Cr.Misc. No.13752 of 2008 1. NASEEM, son of Khaliluddin 2. Wasimuddin @ Md. Wasimuddin, son of Khalil 3. Shafi Alam, son of Ahmad 4. Mumtaz Alam, son of Hazi Majahar 5. Jakhimuddin, son of Mazhar 6. Alimuddin, son of Mazhar 7. Md. Asalam, son of Jalil 8. Md. Majaharul Iqubal, son of Manajir Hossain 9. Hanif, son of Inayat Ali 10. Kalam, son of Jalil 11. Kalim, son of Basarat Ali 12. Rijban Ali, son of Gulu 13. Hafiz Ibrahim, son of Garabhu 14. Garabhu Paswan, son of 15. Dindayal Paswan, son of 16. Wasil Mian, son of 17. Sagiruddin, son of Jahangir 18. Ashagar Ali @ Ashgu, son of Shamsul 19. Mohbuddin, son of Kasim 20. Domaru, son of Faku 21. Bibi Jarina Khatoon, wife of Abuddin 22. Majahar Ali, son of Hazi Hanif 23. Bibi Sabia Khatoon @ Bibi Sabeeha Khatoon, wife of Late Abdul Rauf 24. Bibi Farzana, 25. Afroza Khatoon 26. Nazarana Khatoon 27. Afasana Khatoon, Daughters of late Abdul Rauf 28. Mansoor Alam, son of Jakiruddin 29. Shaukat Ali, son of Jakiruddin 30. Majahar Hossain 31. Islam 32. Abdul Wahab, son of Hanif 33. Bibi Jainu Nisa, daughter of Hanif 34. Bibi Afsun Mian, daughter of Hanif 35. Bibi Kamaru Nisa, daughter of Hanif 36. Bibi Sadia, wife of Taiyab Hussain 37. Zakir Hussain 38. Sami Alam Both Sons of Taiyab Hussain 39. Farda Khatoon 40. Farha Khatoon Daughters of Taiyab Hussain 41. Shafique Alam @ Bilachhan 42. Masih Alam @ Tidhi Sons of Khalil 43. Bibi Zubaida @ Zubaida Khatoon, wife of Asghar Ali 44. Salam @ Md. Salam, son of Jalil 45. Ashgari Khatoon, daughter of Jalil 46. Asghar Ali 47. Akbar Ali Sons of Shamsul 48. Taiyabur Rahman, son of SK. Qasim 49. Israt Hussain, son of Arif Hussain 50. Bibi Sabrun, wife of Domar Ali 51. S.K. Bechan, son of Rasool Bux 52. Bibi Aisa Khatoon, wife of Haji Jameel Akhtar 53. Azimuddin 54. Own Ali 55. Sanaullah 56. Ataullah Sons of Hayat Mohammad 57. Asma Khatoon, wife of Khaliluddin 58. Shama Khatoon, wife of Khaliluddin 59. S.K. Amanullah 60. Bibi Fatma 61. Bibi Reyeesa Khatoon 62. Bibi Sayeeda Khatoon 63. Bibi Sabrun Nishan All son and daughters of Monajir Hussain 64. Shahabuddin 65. Alauddin Both sons of S.K. Gullu 66. Najmun Nishan, wife of Nesiruddin 67. Raquib Alam 68. Shahida Khatoon 69. Rahmatullah 70. Ishrat Jahan 71. Sanjila @ Sanjila Khatoon Sons and daughters of Nasiruddin 72. Bibi Firoza Khatoon, wife of Shafi Alam 73. Bibi Talibun Nishan, wife of Arif Hussain 74. Bibi Zaibun, wife of S.K. Gujai 75. Ibrahim 76. Shafique 77. Sabila Khatoon 78. Tasila Khatoon 75 to 78 are sons and daughters of Gujai 79. Masih Alam son of Ahmad Hussain 80. Bibi Mofisa Khatoon W/o Salimuddin 81. Bibi Amitun W/o Salahuddin 82. Zafrul Hussain son of Md. Salim 83. Shamsad Alam son of Salim 84. Md. Rizwan Ali 85. Mati Alam 84 and 85 are sons of Md. Salim 86. Sk. Aminuddin 87. Sk. Tamizuddin 86 and 87 are sons of Karamat Ali 88. Bibi Aisun Nishan W/o Jakiruddin 89. Badrudduza 90. Amiruddin @ Amiruddin 91. Sahimuddin 89 to 91 are son Sk. Zakiruddin 92. Bibi Aisa Khatoon W/o Md. Tahir Hussain 93. Raisul Alam son of md. Idris. 94. Sahimuddin son of Sk. Khalil 95. Bibi Azimun Nishan w/o Aminuddin 96. Bibi anjum W/o Razi Akhtar 97. Jawed Alam 98. Saifullah 97 to 98 are sons of abdur Rahim. 99. Bibi Rashida W/o Abdur Rahim 100. Bibi Mehru Nishan W/o Basharat Karim 101. Bibi Samooda Khatoon, D/o Mojibuddin 102. Bibi Rabia Khatoon 103. Bibi Razia Khatoon 104. Bibi Kashida Khatoon. 102 to 105 are daughters of Noorul Huda 105. Md. Ehsan son of Late Asgar Ali 106. Md. Rafique Alam son of Late Asgar Ali 107. Md. Shafique Alam son of Late Asgar Ali 108. Bibi Sabra Khatoon D/o late Asgar Ali 109. Bibi Asila Khatoon D/o Late Asgar Ali 110. Bibi Rayeesa Khatoon d/o Late Monazir Hussain 111. Bibi Fatma Khatoon D/o Late Monazir Hussain 112. Bibi Shahida Khatoon D/o Monazir Hussain 113. Bibi Sarun Nisha D/o Late Monazir Hussain 114. Bibi Nazma Khatoon d/o Late Hayat Mohammad 115.Bibi Tahbila Khatoon D/o Late Hayat Mohammad, All residents of Village- Rampur Belagachhi, P.S.-Raniganj, District- Araria - -----------------Petitioners. Versus 1. State of Bihar 2. Maheshwari Nonia son of Bahadur Nonia 3. Sheo Narain Nonia son of Charitar Nonia 4. Tilo Nonia son of Chanchal Nonia 5. Babulal Tudu son of Kanhai Tudu 6. Mangal Murmu son of Doman Murmu 7. Chakku Hansda 8. Baithka Hansda 7 and 8 are sons of Ram Hansda 9. Chotelal Hembrum son of dinu Hembrum 10. Sonelal Murmu son of Chotelal Murmu 11. Babulal Hansda son of Gopal Hansda 12. Raghu Murmu son of Ranjeet Murmu 13. Kailu Marandi son of Barku Marandi 14. Babulal Kiskoo son of Diggan Kiskoo 15. Patle Murmu son of Munsi Murmu 16. Jadunandan Goswami 17. Damodar Goswami, Both sons of Fushan Goswami 18. Balia Nonia 19. Hari Narain Nonia Both sons of Bahadur Nonia 20. Dhakkan Nonia 21. Rambilas Nonia 22. Ramawatar Nonia 20 to 22 are sons of name not known 23. Buchia Nonia wife of Billat Paswan 24. Harua Nonia son of name not known 25. Lalbati Devi son of Late Bindeshri Nonia 26. Sudhir Nonia son of Late Bindeshari Nonia 27. Radhia Devi daughter of Late Bindeshari Nonia 28. Ugan Nonia son of Late Bindeshari Nonia 29. Kari Devi wife of Late Bindeshari Nonia 30. Most. Bhagwati Devi wife of Late Hem Chandra Tuddu 31. Ranjeet Tuddu 32. Jamuna Tuddu 33. Kalawati Tuddu 34. Phul Kumar Tuddu, 31 to 34 are sons and daughters of Late Ramchandra Tuddu All residents of village- Rampur Belagachhi P.S.- Raniganj, District- Araria ------------------Opposite Parties Ist set. 35. Talu Murmu son of Jitu Murmu 36. Rahaku Murmu son of Dhunku Murmu 37. Lakhan Marandi son of Jaising Marandi 38. Jaggan Marandi son of Guru Marandi 39. Rani Murmu son of Barka Murmu 40. Tala Hansda son of Kachu Hansda 41. Chopath Hembram son of Mangal Hembram 42. Sonelal Marandi son of Kailu Marandi 43. Shyamlal Murmu son of Happa Murmu 44. Rashika Marandi son of Padum Marandi 45. Hiralal Mishtri son of Kali Charan 46. Lakhi Baski son of Thakur Baski 47. Supoul Soren son of Kamru Soren 48. Arbin Murmu son of Makhan Murmu 49. Shibu Soren son of somrai Soren 50. Lakhiram Hansda son of Munshi Hansda. 51. Ganesh Marandi son of Ganga Marandi 52. Talu Kishku son of Bijay Kisku 53. Nandlal Tuddu son of Supaul Tudu 54. Jatlu Marandi son of Bhiro Marandi 55. Kari Rishideo son of Sokhi Risideo 56. Lakshman Risideo son of Nandu Risideo 57. Suren risideo son of Lakshman Risideo 58. Jakshu Risideo son of Lakshman Risideo 59. Bagul Risideo son of Magan Das 60. Budhu Risideo son of Nago Risideo 61. Dhodi Risideo son of Budhu Risideo 62. lachrar Risideo son of Dorik Risideo 63. Harku Risideo son of Sukrati Risideo 64. Jago Risideo son of Guni Risideo 65. Nandu Risideo son of Kamal Risideo 66. Ramu Risideo son of Kamal Risideo 67. Kamal Risideo son of Amrit Risideo 68. Itwari Risideo son of Budhi Risideo 69. Budhi Risideo son of Badar Risideo 70. Jitan Risideo son of Sukal Risideo 71. Sanjay Hansda son of Bharat Hansda 72. Tala Murmu son of Kishun Murmu 73. Juval Beshara son of Gopal Beshara 74. Amosh Marandi son of Jalpa Marandi 75. Ganga Murmu son of Ramka Murmu 76. Bablu Hambram son of Khomay Hembram 77. Sufal Baski son of Meghra Baski 78. Chunnu Tudu son of Dhutu Tudu 79. Shriman Tudu son of Chutu Tudu 80. Munshi Tudu son of Dhuka Murmu 81. Somay Hansda son of Barka Hansda 82. Hopan Hansda son of Bharat Hansda 83. Bijal Hansda son of Risik Hansda 84. Jeeg Murmu son of Jitu Murmu 85. Dhinku Marandi son of Narka Marandi 86. Rajo Murmu son of Pradhyan Murmu 87. Babujee soren son of Sahu Soren 88. Sheolal Hembram son of Jetha Hembram 89. suman hembram son of tahal hembram 90. Biju marandi son of Jetha Marandi 91. Babujee Marandi son of Kailu Marandi 92. Jitu Marandi son of Barka Marandi 93. Pujhor Marandi son of Sujan Marandi 94. Dilip Marandi son of Jitha Marandi 95. Hanjal Hembram son of Durga Hembram 96. Pradhan Murmu son of Jugesh Murmu 97. Kandan Basara son of Matla Basera 98. Marandi Hembram son of Barku Hembram 99. Tala Murya Hembram wife of Sinok Hansda 100. Tala Hansda son of Sinok Hansada 101. Barku Marandi son of Jitha Marandi 102. Ramesh Kishku son of Shankar Kishku 103. Sonelal Tudu son of Budhu Tudu 104. Bijay Hembram son of Hambroo Hembram 105. Suraj Narain Hembram son of Hembro Hembram 106. Gopal Hansda son of Barku Hansda 107. Sanjay Hansda son of Dulla Hansda 108. Talwa Hansda son of Dulla Hansda 109. Sunil Hembram son of Kandan Hembram 110. Ramesh Hansda son of Ganga Hansda 111. Jaapat Hansda son of Teda Hansda 112. Lakhi Marandi son of Devan Marandi 113. Ramesh Soren son of Jitan Soren 114. Mahachan Hansda son of Durga Hansda 115. Manik Lal Soren son of Jitha Soren 116. Panchu Hansda son of Hopan Hansda 117. Doman Murmu son of Mailal Murmu 118. Dewan Basera son of Chandra Basera 119. Premlal Hembram son of Lakhan Hembram 120. Bhaiya Lal Baski son of Bidyanand Baski 121. Upendra Tuddu son of Chalu Tudu 122. Chotelal Soren son of Jatu Soren 123. Dewan Hambram son of Dhunku Hembram 124. Hopna Soren son of Jitan Soren 125. Babulal Hembram son of Premlal Hembram 126. Nanku Murmu son of Rama Murmu 127. Upendra Murmu son of Kishun Murmu 128. Johan Murmu son of Makhan Murmu 129. Munshi Murmu son of Chote Murmu 130. Bajun Hembram son of Devan Hembram 131. Munshi Tuddu son of Barku Tuddu 132. Markus Marandi son of Chanda Marandi 133. Timothi Hembram son of Jitha Hembram 134. Kailu Tuddu son of Lakhan Tuddu 135. Chotelal Soren son of Jitan Soren 136. Sanju Soren son of Dibu Soren 137. Rud Pratap Murmu son of Salkhu Murmu 138. Pradhan Murmu son of Durga Murmu 139. Raju Baski son of Dukha Baski 140. Bakan Soren son of Shobha soren 141. Talu Hansda son of Barku Hansda 142. Lal Hembram son of Somba Hembram 143. Munsi Soren son of Dibu Soren 144. Phurti Baski son of Lighu Baski 145. Babulal Baski son of Budhi Baski 146. Barku Murmu son of Dhroka Murmu 147. Sio Hansda son of Salkhu Hansda 148. Ruplal Marandi son of Sopan Marandi 149. Timothi Hansda son of Manwal Hansda 150. Jagan Murmu son of Shamu Murmu 151. Lal Soren son of Chandu Soren 152. Kripanand Tuddu son of Munshi Tudu 153. Marangmoi Tuddu w/o Puran Marandi 154. Bipin Marandi s/o Puran Marandi 155. Mallu Tudu son of Ram Tuddu 156. Ahaham Hansda son of Manwal Hansda 157. Shibu Baski son of Budh Baski 158. Dhaneshwar Hembram son of Pirtan Hembram 159. Umesh Hembram son of Shankar Hembram 160. Bijendra hembram son of Bhaiya Lal Hembram 161. Hopan Hembram son of Harilal Hembram 162. Sitaram Murmu son of Pandi Murmu 163. Sunil Hembram son of Shibu Hembram 164. Bablu Hansda son of Raghu Hansda 165. Suraj Narain Hansda son of Raghu Hansda 166. Dasjee Marandi son of Raidan Marandi 167. Doman Lal Hembram son of Padhobo Hembram 168. Suresh Murmu son of Umesh Murmu‟ 169. Upendra Soren son of Suksen Soren 170. Ganesh Hansda son of Baijun Hansda 171. Bijendra Hembram son of Manik Lal Hembram 172. Malik Hembram son of Shukdeo Hembram 173. Sonelal murmur son of chunnulal murmu 174. Rekha Devi W/o Tara Marandi 175. Matal Soren son of Lakhan Soren 176. Nehru Lal Hembram son of Durga Hembram 177. Sanif Soren son of Bhim Soren 178. Anup Soren son of Bhim Soren 179. Bishwanath Marandi son of Babulal Marandi 180. Ruplal Murmu son of Durga Murmu 181. Warislal Hansda son of Mangal Hansda 182. Rameshwar Hansda son of Soman Hansda 183. Bijlal Tuddu son of Bishwanath Tuddu 184. Babulal Hansda son of Ramsoi Hansda 185. Shyam lal Tuddu son of Bijlal Tuddu 186. Chandra Shekhar Murmu son of Dhunka Murmu 187. Sitaram Tuddu son of Jamun Tuddu 188. Babulal Hembram son of Ram Hembram 189. Shivlal Tuddu son of sankhai Tuddu 190. Paku Devi w/o Maha Tuddu 191. Anup lal Tudu son of Jitan Tuddu 192. Tala Tudu son of Khala Tudu 193. Sethji Hansda son of Shibu Hansda 194. Mandal Murmu son of Rajeet Murmu 195. Ruplal Tuddu son of Jetha Tuddu 196. Binod Soren son of Lakhan Soren 197. Manjal Soren son of Lakhan Soren‟ 198. Chotelal Soren son of Lakhan Soren 199. Dena Tuddu son of Aklu Tuddu 200. Mandal Tuddu son of Aklu Tuddu 201. Hemlal Tuddu son of chotelal Tuddu 202. Bal Kishore Tuddu son of Ramlal Tuddu 203. Talamoi Devi W/o munsi Marandi 204. Shrikant Murmu son of Bishwanath Murmu 205. Lakhan Murmu son of Ramjeet Murmu 206. Runjhum Marandi son of Chuthu Marandi 207. Babulal Hansda son of Barku Hansda 208. Sanjay Murmu son of Kali Das Murmu 209. Sanju Tuddu son of Sumra Tuddu 210. Taleshwar Baski son of Sufal Baski 211. Maya Soren son of Rosan Soren 212. Mandal Hansda son of Hajju Hansda 213. Ketha Tuddu son of Ramlal Tuddu All R/o vill-Belgachhi, Kujra, P.S. Raniganj, dist. Araria --- opp.parties/2nd Set. 214. Sanju Hembram son of Bhima Hembram 215. Sangram Marandi son of Pradhan Marandi 216. Kula Nand Tuddu son of Fasu Tuddu 217. Dashrath Hembram son of Badka Hembram 218. Dugu Tuddu son of Samu Tuddu 219. Shyam Tuddu son of Belhu Tuddu 220. Vaya Basra son of Singrai Basra 221. Darbari Tuddu son of Jaddu Tuddu 222. Sanjali Devi W/o late Happe Hembram 223. Salku Murmu son of Chhote lal Murmu 224. Chaturi Marandi son of Somra Marandi 225. Vayalal Marandi son of Chunku Marandi. 226. Rajendra Murmu son of Chhote Lal Murmu 227. Mahendra Murmu son of Chhote Lal Murmu 228. Babulal Murmu son of choote lal Murmu 229. Jetha Hansda son of Talash Hansda 230. sona Lal Kisku son of Guchu Kisku 231. Tikeshwar Hansda son of Jetha Hansda. 232. Bijendra Tuddu son of Kisun Tuddu 233. Piro Soren son of Vaya Soren 234. Suklal Marandi son of Mangal Marandi 235. Bharat Hansda son of lala Hansda 236. Basta Soren son of Salkhu Soren 237. Apma Hansda son of Haju Hansda 238. Kishore Murmu son of Sidhu Murmu 239. Laloo Tuddu son of Kirpa Nand Tuddu 240. Bipin Tuddu son of Somera Tuddu 241. Arjun Tuddu son of Sangram Tuddu. All R/o vill-Kajra P.S.Raniganj, Dist. Araria, --- Opp.Parties/3rd Set. ----------- 02 26.08.2010 Heard learned counsel for the petitioners. Petitioners are the first party to the proceeding under Section 145 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (hereinafter referred to as the „Code‟) which is pending since 1986. They are aggrieved by the order dated 17.07.2007, passed by learned Ist Additional Sessions Judge, Araria in Cr. Rev. no. 371 of 1997 (Maheshwari Nonia & Ors vs. State & ors.). The aforesaid revision was preferred by the second party to the said proceeding (opposite parties herein). By the said revision application, they called in question the order dated 11.08.1997 passed by learned Sub Divisional Magistrate in case no. 538M of 1986 (proceeding under Section 145 of the Code) by which learned Magistrate had allowed three applications filed on behalf of the first party and one application filed on behalf of the opposite party (second party). Petitioners preferred revision being Cr. Rev. no. 25941 of 1999 (Naseem & ors. Vs. The State of Bihar). The said matter was finally disposed of by order dated 22.06.2000 (Annexure-1) in following manner:- “In this case, the grievance of the petitioners is that the learned revisional court without impleading petitioner nos. 41 to 104, has passed the order, albeit the learned Magistrate passed an order in a proceeding under Section 145 Cr.P.C., in their favour. It is alleged that the order passed by the learned Magistrate is sought to be quashed by the revisional court even though they have neither been noticed nor they have been made party in the revision application. In that view of the matter, without going into the merit of the case, the part of the order dated 2.9.1999 passed by the Second Addl. Sessions Judge in Cr. Revision No. 371 of 1997 is hereby quashed and the matter is remitted back to the learned revisional court who will hear the petitioner nos. 41 of 104 and pass an appropriate order in accordance with law. Let it be recorded that I have not interfered with the order so far as the other petitioners are concerned. It goes without saying that the learned revisional court will pass order strictly in accordance with law without being prejudiced by the order of this court. This application is, accordingly, disposed of.” On remand the matter was again taken up by learned revisional Court and after hearing both the parties the same has been disposed of in the following manner:- “5. In the facts and circumstances of the case discussed above I find that the impugned order dated 11.8.1997 of the learned court below so far as the petition dated 24.4.1997 filed on behalf of the O.P. second party of this revision is illegal and without jurisdiction and hence it is liable to be set aside and the impugned order dated 11.8.1997 so far it relates to the intervener petition dated 31.5.1997 of this revision petition is legal and fit to be confirmed and same is upheld. Accordingly this revision petition is allowed in part. The impugned order dated 11.8.1997 of the court below passed in case no. 538M of 1986 under section 145 Cr. P.C. is hereby set aside in part.” Learned revisional Court has assigned adequate and cogent reasons for not allowing the three applications filed on behalf of the first party which was earlier allowed by the learned Sub Divisional Magistrate. In my view, the impugned order does not merit interference in exercise of my jurisdiction conferred under Section 482 of Code. However, considering the age of the litigation this Court expects that learned Magistrate shall take up the matter and disposed of the same in accordance with law as soon as possible. Both the parties shall fully cooperate with the Court in early disposal of the matter. The application stands disposed of. Sym ( Kishore K. Mandal, J.)