/ w 4 / ( A r , \ r . I N T H E H I G H C O U R T O F J U D L C A T U R E A T m m s p u g i ’ c . a . : W R I T P E T I T I O N . o 3 { 9 5 5 4 ) } ? 2 0 0 5 B E T W E E N B h i k a r i D a s S / o L a t e S h r i G u n N i d h i D a s , a g e d a b o u t 2 5 y e a r s , r e s i d e n t o f a t V i l l a g e S a n k r a , T a h s i l S a r a n g a r h D i s t r i c t R a i g a r h ( C G ) . ' P E T I T I O N E R A N D V T h e S t a t e o f C h h a t t i s g a r h , T h r o u g h t h e S e c r e t a x y R a i p u r D e p a r t m e n t ( C G ) o f S c h o o l E d u c a t i o n , M a n t r a l a y , ‘ D . K . S . B u i l d i n g , ‘ / 2 , T h e D i r e c t o r , P u b i i c i n s t r u c t i o n s , C h h a t t i s g a r h , R a i p u r , r T a h s i l a n d D i s t r i c t R a i p u r ( C G ) . T h e D i s t r i c t E d u c a t i o n O f f i c e r , R a i g a r h , T a h s i l a n d D i s t r i c t R a i g a r h ( C G ) . E S P O N D E N T S i , N W R I T P E T I T I O N U M E R A R T I C L E 2 2 6 2 2 7 O F M C O N S T I T U T I O N O F [ M I A , t ‘ , n / X ( h a x ‘ i u h . { v ‘ x R 37 HIOH COURT OF CHHATTIS8ARH : BILASPUR WRIT PETITION N0.1322 OF 2002 Anoop Mlshra Vs. The State of Chhattisgarh and Others & Other connected Writ Petitions ORDER (Dated ^yOecember, 2008) ^ HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISOARH AT BILASPUR WRITPETITION N0.1322C002 (Anoop Mishra vs. The StateofC.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.1323/2002 (Raj Kumar Thakur vs. The State of C.G: & Ors.) WRHTPETITION N0.13360002 (Rakesh Kumar Dewangan vs. The State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.1752C002 (Manoj Kumar Bhardwaj vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.2674/2002 (Sanjay Kumar E3ewangan vs. The State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.654/2003 (Duman Lal vs. The State of C.Q, & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.700G003 (Jhadu Lal vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2204/2003 (Ku. Sangeeta Sahu vs. The State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.2205/2003 (Chalam Rao Kamewar vs. The State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.2213/2003 (Akash Joshl vs. The State of C.G. & Ors.) WRIT PETITION N0.2270/2003 (Harnarayan Khotel vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.3464/2003 (Dharmendra Kumar vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.3723C003 (Bharat Lal Chandravanshi vs. The State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.3848^003 (Abdul Sahid Ansari vs. The State of C.G, & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.4116C003 (Ravikant Dove vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.4126C003 (Sharad Kumar Shrlvastava vs. State of C.G. 8> Ore.) WRtTPETITION N0.731/2004 (Dumendra Slngh Pisda vs. The State ofC.G. & Ors.) WRITPET!TION N0.790/2004 (Ved Prakash Shamna vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETtTION N0.801/2004 (Lukeshwar Kumar Sahu vs. State of C.G. & Ora.) WRITPETITION N0.870/2004 (Azfter Ahmed Siddiqui vs. The State ofC.O. & Ore.) ^ WRITPETIT10N N0.871/2004 (Anurag Chandra vs. The State of C.G; & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.1135C004 (Santosh Kumar Sahu vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.12110004 (Smt. Puleshwari Yadav vs. State of C.Q. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.1575/2004 (Tarun Kumar Kashyap vs. The State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.1687C004 (Manish Kumar Tripathi vs. The State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETn-ION N0.1778/2004 (Dev Singh Oond vs. The State of C.Q. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.1833C004 (Neelkant Sahu vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRIT PETITION N0.1844/2004 (Durgesh Wakde vs. The State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.1877/2004 (Chandrika Prasad Yadav vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.1878/2004 (Shailendra Singh vs. The State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.1884/2004 (Mukesh Goswaml vs. The State of G.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2087/2004 (Lakeshwar Prasad Dewangan vs. The Stote of C.G. & Ore.) WRIT PETITION N0.2162/2004 (Yashwant Kumar Shyamley vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.22180004 (Shyam Kumar Patel vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2219/2004 (Ku. Geeta Diwaker vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2220/2004 (Bodharam Naikvs. The State of C.G. 8. Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.^67/2004 (Ajit Kumar Nair & Ore. vs. The State of G.G. & Ors.) WRIT PETITION N0.2428/2004 (Sanjay Kumar Ekka vs. The State of C.G. & Ors.) WRIT PETITION N0.2519/2004 (Rizwana Parveen vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) ^l /- WRITPETITION N0.2551^2004 (Ramesh Kumar Sahu vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2562/2004 (Saftfar Ahmed Mansuri vs. The State of C.G. & CTs.) WRITPETITION N0.2567/2004 (Ram Sajeevan Kashyap vs. The State of C.G. & Ors.) WRIT PETITION N0.2582C004 (Prahlad Yadav vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2613/2004 (Santosh Kumar Sahu vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.2616/2004 (Damodar Prasad Dewangan vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.2617C004 (Keshav Prasad Dewangan vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2631/2004 (Mahendra Kumar Yadav vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2632/2004 (Sanjay Kumar Sahu vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2633/2004 (Ashok Kumar Verma vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2635/2004 (Durga Prasad Yadav vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2644/2004 (Sanjeev Kumar Yadav vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2645/2004 (Mahendra Kumar Jangde vs. State of C.Q. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2646QQ04 (Praveen Kumar Nair vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.2736C004 (Sharad Kumar Shrivastava vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRIT PETITION N0.2756V2004 (Smt. Neeta Agrawal vs. State ofC.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION W.2796/2004 (Manesh Kumar Ramteke vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2805COM (Rohlt Kumar Patel vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2865C004 (Dinesh Kumar Pankaj vs. Union of India & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2866/2004 (Devesh Kumar Tiwari vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) ^^ WRIT PETITION N0.2883/2004 (A. Chandra SheWiar Dora vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPFTITION N0.2895/2004 (PushperriraKumarKaushikvs.TheStateofC.O.&Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2923C004 (Balram Sahu vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2933C004 (Ramesh Kumar Yadav vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2934/2004 (Kumari Gend Kumari vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2935/2004 (Ashok Kumar Yadav vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.2937/2004 (Smt. Kiran Bai Yadav vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRtTPETITION N0.2938C004 (Jhumuklal Sahu vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2939/2004 (Rakesh Kumar Sahu vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.29410004 (Sumant Kumar Pakera vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2942G004 (Sunll Kumar Slnha w. State of C.G. &0rs.) WRITPETITION N0.2948^004 (Hulesh Kumar Rakesh vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRIT PETtTION N0.2964/2004 (Ajit Kumar Yadav vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.3045C004 (Ajay Kumar Jangde vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.3105/2004 (Sayied Sabir Ali vs. Union of India & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.3106/2004 (Bisesar Ram Nishad vs. Union of Indla & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.3107/2004 (Satlsh Swami Sonwani vs. Union of Indla & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.3161/2004 (Dlnesh Kumar ShuMa vs. State of C.O. & Ors.) WRIT PETITION N0.3196C004 (Shlv Narayan Kaushikvs. Unton of Indta & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.3224Q004 (Shallesh Kumar Sahu vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) 4^ WRITPETITION N0.3258/2004 (Tarachand Sahu w. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.3454/2004 (Tikeshwar Prasad Sahu vs. Unlon of Indta & Ore.) WRTTPETITtON N0.3455C004 (Surendra Kumar Siddar vs. Union of India & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.3456C004 (Gifdhar Lal Dhfclhi vs. Union of India & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.3461/2004 (Prem Lal Sahu vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.3517/2004 (Ku. Priti Shanna vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.3518/2004 (Laxman Chauhan vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.3551/2004 (Rajendra Kumar Sahu vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.3554/2004 (Ishwar Dayal Kanwar vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.35830004 (Shveta Dwlvedi vs. State ofC.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.3679/2004 (Rajesh Kumar Sao vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.3588C004 (Ku. Shanti Chandrakar vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRIT PETITION N0.3635/2004 (Smt. Maheshwari Sahu vs. Union of India & Ore.) WRIT PETITION N0.3673/2004 (Rakesh Kumar Shandllya vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.3724^004 (Devtlal Korram vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.3739/2004 (Pratap Patel vs. State of C.Q. & Ora.) WRITPETITION N0.3775C004 (Bhuneshwar Prasad Kashyap vs. State of C.G. &0rs.) WRITPETITION N0.3879Q004 (Dinesh Kumar Patel vs. Union of Indta & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.3881/2004 (Santosh Kumar Patel vs. Unton of India & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.4049/2004 (Rupesh Kumar Mehta vs. State of C.G. &0re.) WRITPETITION N0.41390004 (Chandra Shekhar Sahu vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) 4-Y WRIT PETITION N0.4201^004 (Mathura Prasad Sahu vs. Union of Indla & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.4239/2004 (Sevak Ram Patel vs. Union oflndla & Ors.) WRITPFTITION N0.42410004 (Santosh Kumar Venna vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.4242/2004 (Anand Kumar Nishad vs. The State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.4243/2004 (Surendra Kumar Sahu vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.4253G004 (Umesh Slngh vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.4268/2004 (Yogesh Kumar Nag vs. The State of C.O. & Ore.) WRIT PETITION N0.4284/2004 (Radhye Shyam Suryawansi vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.4331C004 (Sanjeev Kumar Sahu vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.4341 C004 (Kishori Lal Jatewal vs. State of C.G. & Ora) WRITPETITION N0.4384G004 (Smt. Yalam Parwati vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRIT PETITION N0.4474/2004 (Smt. Yasmin Begum vs. State ofC.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.4518C004 (Bhekh Lal Kumbhakar vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.4573/2004 (Santosh Slngh Rajput vs. Union of India & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.4579/2004 (Aashutosh Pratap Singh vs. State of C.Q. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.4589C004 (Anil Kumar Dhruv vs. State oT C.G. & Ore.) WRIT PETITION N0.4700/2004 (Duyodhan Prasad vs. State of G.G. & Ore,) WRITPETITION N0.4701/2004 (Manoj Kumar Patnalk vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRIT PETITION N0.4706/2004 (Rakesh Kumar Dilliwar vs. Stateof C.O. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.4774^004 (Lakhan Kumar Nfehad vs. State af C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.4776Q004 (Ramnik Lal Yadav vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.4862/2004 (Amzad Khan vs. The State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.46780004 (Manlsh Panda vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.4879/2004 (Mukesh Kumar Sahu vs. Stafs of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.4885/2004 (Om Prakash GujAa vs. State of C.Q. & Ora.) WRrTPETITION N0.4847C004 (Vikas Kumar Gedam vs. The State of C.©.& Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.4989/2004 (Ku. Mamta Yadu vs. The State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.372/200S (Ku. Hareha Slngh vs. State of G.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.735/2005 (Mukesh Kumar Soni vs. Unlon of Indla & Ore.) WRIT PETITION 10.1031/2005 (Kunal Slnha vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.1099/200S (Slddharath Shukla vs. State of C.O. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.1104/2005 (Shaitendra Kumar Pandey vs. Unlon of Indla & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.1139/2005 (Umesh Kumar Biramrar vs. Union of Indla & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.11940005 (Sunil Kumar Chhugani vs. Union of Indla & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.1198/2003 (Balaram Patel vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.1256/2005 (Yugal Kishor Sahu vs. State of C.O. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.1286/2006 CTekram Sahu vs. State ofC.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.1663/2005 (Bhuneshwar Khare vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.17S6/2005 (Vishwas Kumar Tlwari vs. Stete of C.G. & Os.) WRIT PETITION N0.1759/2005 (Ku. Dlpti Patel vs. State ofC.G. & Ore.) '^t WRITPETITION N0.1806/2006 (Suresh Mishra vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRITPETITION N0.1804/2005 (RamantKumarThakurvs. StateofC.G. &0rs.) WRiT PETITION N0.1962/2008 (Rakesh Kumar Nayak vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRIT PETITION N0.1979/2006 (Smt. Shakun Bai vs. Unlon of tndia & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.2724/2005 (Rrta Sharma vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) WRIT PETITION N0,3192/2005 (Briikan Das vs. State of C,G. & Ore.) WRITPETITION N0.3464/2006 (Vlvek Dnar Dwan vs. State ofC.G. & Ors.) WRIT PETITION N0.8663/2005 (Smt. Maya Devi Sonwani vs. State of C.G. & Ors.) WRIT PETITION NO.S758/2005 (Smt. Sanjukta Sanu vs. Union of India & Ors.) WRtTPETITION NO.S992/200S (Dhanjay Patil vs. State of C.G. & Ore.) Shn V.D. Bajpai, Sr. Advocate Shri P. Dhwakar. Sr. Advocate. Shri Manindra Stinvasiava. Sr. Advocate, Shn Ashish Shnvasiava. Shn Afroz Khan, Ku. Sunlta Jain. Shri Kunal Das, Shri AshoK Das Vaisnnav. Shri R.N. Jtia. Ku. Meenu Benarjee, Shri Somnath verma, Shrl Gautam Knetraoat, Ku. Deepali Pandey, Shri Saniay Kumar Agrawal. Shrl Aneesh Pandey, Srtn Manoj Paraniape. Shri Sanjay Agrawal. Sfin Vtjay Deshmuxh. Shri M.K. Bhadun. ynn Airt Singn. snri susnil DuDey. Stin RaKesn Jna, Snri O.R. Patel, Shn A.N. Bnaxia. Shrl O.R. Min, Smt. indira Tripa i, Snn Vlrenara Sharma, snrl Anand Tjwari. Stin Sudhlr Verma. Shrt P.P. Sanu. Shrl H.S. Ahulwalta. Ku. Maya Slngn. Ku. Abilasna Naidu. Sfin Sameer Behar. Shn Satyendra Sahu. yDrl DeeoaK Jain, snn PraKasn Tlwan, Snn S.K.J. jaiswai, Shn Vinay Pandev, Smi. Renu Kochar, Shri Narendra Chandel. Shn Sunit Sahu. snri Pankai Shrlvastava. Shn V.K. Pandey, Shri AlbK Dewangan. Shri Praveen Das. snn Manoj Misnra, Shri Avtnash K. Misnra, Shn RanbirSingh Marnas. Shn B.P. Gupta, Shn R.N. MuKnopaanyay, Shri L.C. Dash. Shn l.S. Sanu, Shn Rakesh Antony. Advocates ete. forthe petitioners. Shri V.V.S. Moorthy. Dy. Advocate General. Shri P.S. Koshy. Dy. Advocate Generat, snri Sandeep Dubey, Govt Advocate, snri RamaKant Misnra, Govt. Advocate. Shri A.S. Kacnhawaha, Dy. G.A., Shn Satisn Gupta. Dy.G.A. & Shri ViveK snarma. Panel Lawyer for the Staie of cnhattlsgarh. Shri S.K. Benwal. Senior Panet Lawyer for the Union of India. Ml^ ORDgR Per Hon. Shrl Fakhruddln. >l: The above writ petitions have been heard analogously and are being cllsDosed of by this common order. 2. The aforesaid mattere relate to compassionate appointment conseauent upon tne deatn of an employee seiving in Ifte State. These matters are pending consideration before this Court and have Eieen heard from tlme to tlme on various dates. Some of these cases were listed on 17-11 -2004 and 23-12-2004. Leamed counset fer the State of Chhattisgarii had pointect out on earlier date that there vras a pollcy in force for compassionate appointment. but the State of Maahya had jssued cenajn orders on 1-5-2000 imDosing restrictlons and limitations on compasstonate appointment. Meanwhite. Re-organizatlon Aot came Into existence on 1-11-2000. It was further submitted that on 28/29-6-2002 ordere were issued t>y the State of Chhattisgarh to the effect that till further instructions the oompassionate appointment orders be kept in abeyance. It was also suomined that ttie State of Chhattisgarn framed a policy on 10-6-2003 under Executive power oy order and in the name ot tne Govemor of cnnattisgarh whereby it was decided that ttiose persons who tiave diect on or after 1 -11 -2000 i. e. after the formation of State of Chhattlsgarh, only their oases will be consldered and not thosewnohavedledpriorto 1-11-2000. Inview of tnis stand taKen by the counsel for the State of Chhattlsgarn, the State of Madhya Pradesh and the Union of india were noticed anct tnat is why the State of Madhya Pradesh and the Unlon of India are the panies in some of the cases. 3. The matters were again listed on 18-11-2005. Time was granted to trie parties including Union of India to flle appropnate reply and come torwara with a declslonMew as to wnat is tDe stanfl of e Union of india. 4. It is appropriate to state that the appointment on oompassionate ground is not a souroe of recruitment but merety an exception to the requirement regarding appointments Delng made on opsn fnvitation of application on merrts. Basic intention is that on the death of empl^ee concerned hts family Is not deprived of the means of livelihood. Ttie object is to enable the family to get over sudcten flnanoial crisis. The clalms are to be oonsidered as reasonable and permissible on tne basis of sudden crisis occurring in the family of such employee who has served the State and dies while in seivice. 5. So far as the present oases are concemed, learned Dy. Advocate Generals made a statement that the State of Chhattisgarh has taken a decision to consicter the cases ttiree yeare pnor to reorganization i.e. those IU f ff State emplovees wnose aeath oocurred on or after I -n -l 997 and stnctlv in accoraance wim ine poiiov orevafeni ai ine time or aeain ot an emoiovee. inis siaiemeni is recoroea. 6. Leamea counsel appeanng tor me resoective petrtioners in the ounon or cases oategonoailv stated that in eacn and eveiv case the deatn ot tne emplovee nas occurrea on or att.et l-n-iay7 ana not eanier. Leamea counset furrner suDmmea ihai tneir cases mav oe considerea ana aecision may oe raKen ai ine eariiesi. Tney aiso submlnea inai ine peiitioners wiil render aue cooperation to tne authonties. This statement is also recordea. 7. Leamed counsel tor the State sufmit ttiat In everv oetttion three sets nave oeen rilea bv tne peiltioners: in some cases exira sets are reauirea w inem wnicn mav oe ailowea 10 os taKen bv tnem fromthe Coun record. ^ ne siaie oounsel may taKe tne exira 'Seis from ihe ofrice wherever iriey requir®. Thev aiso pray tor tnree montns tlme to aeoiae the cases of the petitioners. a. in view OT ine suDmissions maae bv leamea counsei appeanng ror me Daraes, witnoui exoressing any opinion on ine menis ofihe case. in (tie opinion or inis Coun. enas of lusiice wiit oe setved if a dlrection is given 10 the State and ine autnonti^ concemed to oonsider anci decide the cases or tne Detitioners/dependants of the employees who died on 1-11-1997 and tnereaner in accoraance wim tne poiicy wnicn was in rorce at ine time of aeain of ine emDioyee. Eacn ana every inaiviauai case will oe aeciaea ana ir tne person round eiigiDie. appoinimern oraers WIH oe issuea as eany as possible on or before 30 Anril, 2008 The pet'rtionsrs ars also directed to renaer due co-operation to tne autnonties.it is made clear tnat tt any gnevance siiii remains, rne pemionere may avaii tne remeay avaiiaoie unaer ine taw inciuaing niing or ine pettiion oeTore tnis Coun. y. 6uD)eoi 10 the aforesaid airections and observations. ail inese petitions stana disoosed ofwitn tne aroresaia liberty. w. Conseauenny. penaing applicauons, ff anv, aiso siana aisposed or. in some cases. aDpiicaiions seewng rormal amenaments regaraing oorreoiion QT cause-iiiie. eic. have been fiiea. They are aiiowed. The amendment be incorporatea and ihe correotions. if any. be maae. ii. A copv of tnis order be placea in alt the connected cases. CerTlfied copy as per ruies. Copy of tnis oraer oe aiso supplied to tne State counsel. \^_.. - __. Sd/- Fakhruddin Judge