HON BLE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASP ‘ Wrlt Petmon [C] No 62g /2010 t / O Ma str Pos akt D angerCa hlsga s ' sc utr eser the t rade 5 ndusles t) ou l roet M reh Kum gl o ppnor r lSus ar Arawa S/ She Kndan l Agwa ged a re u La ral A bout,% ear en f ard N oal— a oa Sa D jger‘pa _ > tsgar g._, tae o Char truh their e e araay KS Bhaa, , aar ‘ Csg ul veloen ror eren f htlsgar ertang m reere nr roon o e Ac 5 an resrd fic t LI mp ' aipu, . 9 7 ‘hrug Ter nn ro. ha 7 V hsa /04. Tender Purchase Comm1ttee Chhattisgarh State Industrial Development Corporation Lunlted LIC Campus Pandn, Raipur, Chhattlsgarh ' i WRIT'PETITION U/A 226 OFVTHE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA. E UR E I T‘ \ PETITIONER , m etl Induies t; Si lst ' Jje-hmipa Chattrh (A mall ale 1ndsy rglted Wlth Dlstnc T 8 Itr Cener thrgh lts soe ys Res1dt o W o 7 Hspltz Htrl Rd ktl lst JaneCham, t Chhanh O St f hattlsgh hog Chlf Scretary Mntla D wn Ralpur Chhtusgh. ' O I l hhattlarh State Indstrla Depmt e Copation L1m1ted (A Govnmt o Chath undkl) A copany gstd ude pv1s1s f Compams t 196 hv1g Its grtee ofe a C , Caus, Pandn, Rr c.G 42004. Toh: hi Maagig Diectr Mr. S K Sonwani I/C Marketlng —1 Chattisgrh State Industrial Development : Corporatlon Llmited LIC Campus Pandn Ralpur Chattlgrh ’ o; PS LI/MKD/34/O9 10 for'su N pp 33 aim. 33$. $§owEgw vamgoSnn rww mamo vpwnwowvgagwsg Q53 rWm M vLooBwEmaoEOCm. . ¢< E ammwwm _ no $5 mam”8H8»Ewggwdmzga , ,. , aamwoEQoEm . Hoaxac£8 x w S ooEaDwggmg,gwrvawmosg Ssammaara%wbamH.Mmb£EQ 20. , . rwm~§§u\®¥\oo-po HQ»m¢%§.<. 0». $§E§ww¢v . . ‘mmHMQSnaawd‘goo#panaaiw mvNmgg$5 wSwzmwwg. ‘35 waocg OH ,, _ ~ , _ amiwmacwwHwwEnm‘mgm‘aawH Eaambmaow. éoBm¢ mam0E5 gozmw , mag Ennmsmr $5, amcme‘mUavm%EawF Lww Unvmgag, gm :wozm M _ U wmagwsn 0». wgna 0wowwwgummmsw Awmm wcor;wm m 038 a Umwwgaaa AavOv $mm ooSmSgga. OS V .h m W 0©© 80398;gmw €08 ovwSaa. : § @ mpg $¢Qn%.wwooa ‘ . ¥ *bpgm gamaww .wwanowvwga‘ _5owc%5m_§w voSSosQu or:ooB a gaaawm s53 3&5 wKWEHa8am”:9 mambgw; cam éwaa ownsaw a éwaamwwgwawOmxmaha A,m ya 0wEm vwEHobmw émw mWo 28 mg Hgga 8 w: H gnEaaméww #mmCam Or 8 Ommswvqmug a9)? w gamoam 9m 53 namwos no 9a 0mg mam5 gmaa ,wpm m aorp‘wownwn EmmwBa. ENE?can$8, woHarwnEmoSaw‘RBmEn vvq0%w$5$mm mama _ _ gwwm,,.€E amnaBowou £m agw awwoHmSwH, éwm amwmb 05. K Hobooow ra coca? «yang:$ Wmm Unws $5 Gaga“ aawmw wag5933 m. a $$ Lwémg 03w 6m $5 EQER ma m3 vE‘ormm omm$5 ~SSSmnm 3a Qmaawwg wi L M w n vn § 3§ 0 : w s pr‘f f It was also ment1oned that th 39 1 a! ‘d the petltmner manufactures orlly 8 1tems The1efore, l l ‘ r r {also submltted that the petltloner ican manage the supply ss 1 steel utensxls by " maklng necessary ’ arrangement 1f .would ave been ordered for supply, he would have been in t _ l r , g y pos1t1on th make necessary arrangement for supply, hereas the requlrement was for Rs 5 to 6 Crore e‘ e te ders were inv1ted for .J. 3‘1 te ’s 3 he pet1t1or1ier 1n no way was ellglble to meet we have found that the ground for reJ petltloner ' W1 ‘was not regarding the capac1ty of the petltloner or the number é of11tems I manufactured by hlrn, and iearned counsel for the e e he t; h _ therefore, we ‘ s , o ed t V I“ 3 ve version mentlon L he counter aff1dav1t as not the grou dd for rejection of s w t een further mentloned 1n paragraphs 10 and 11 of the return that after proposal/recommendatwn of tender purchase ee e '_. fresh tender was pubhshed on 5 3 2010 and last d t or ,submlssmn of tender w ovbld of the petltloner x x 3326 and 1t ls placed at serlal 0 4 The technlcal b1d n 29 4 2010 1n wh1ch 25 bldders part1C1pated but du 'arwal on“7 s 2010 th valuauon of all 25 b1d‘ are st111 1n pro e c on to subm1t relevant documents and the same a p re rut1n1zedand are beln ver ' t > the requlrement Smce 75* ection of the b1d of the ‘ t ‘ V t i i b ‘. ' f as I s Vt o e ‘ A e] c 1 I l r § ’ n Hg > -: 3 pehs in the field, in ggw the _abv ve mentioned facts and, frcuimstances, is not within the scope ofjudicial review. 2 / x, the: I facts and Circumstances mentio ed above, we also not foundl \ < Jma t ~g LJ—Ww» d : A_‘. we are not Inchned to ‘ ‘, when§ the petitioner has ha laflde or arbitrariness, therefore, ated 1n the second tender prociess and the technical bid so been opened therein, including that of the petition l x i i i i l N.K.Agarwal LM Quddusi ‘ Judge U Judge \ i t M_-—— Wm.m-w»~l \ G :~ p s er t w I