/ IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATUREATBILASPUR fCHHATTISGARHI WRIT PETITION NO.^^J f OF_2005 1: Wv h JElji" PETITIONER RR.No.........i^o2/^—^ ^^iS^s^^' ^z\^\^.^—--~-~ -!,-if!"vy'«", s| il <.<RsAT.!{s.S.); ^ .-•;%•," '<' /? "- /^' .Sf"^* /.'.'• V. K. Rai, aged about 41 years, Son of Shri Jagdish Rai; Posted as Lecturer; R. L. Mishra, aged about 41 years, Son of Shri Tilak Dhari Mishra, Posted as Lecturer; Smt. R. Maqbool, aged about 41 years, Wife of Late Shri Maqbool Husain, Posted as Lecturer; Smt. Pushpa Rai, aged about 39 years, Wife of Shri V. K. Rai, Posted as Upper Division Teacher; Smt. Usha Dwivedi, aged about 43 years, Wife of Shri Awadh Dwivedi; Posted as Assistant Teacher; The Petitioner No.l to 5 are posted at Govt. Girls Higher Secondary School, Ambikapur, District Surguja (C.G.). L. P. Gupta, aged about 38 years, Son of Shri M. P. Gupta; Posted as Lecturer; G. D. Agrawal, aged about 44 years, Son of Shri Tekchand Agrawal,Posted as Lecturer; The Petitioner No.6 to 7 are posted at Govt. Multipurpose Higher RESPONDENTS /' "X' '! V, 0.*! r^^s^n K si ^<P;?r?^(B.,..y^ 'lj ^•/'f^/ 7>EsS^^ .'^. ^?-'^^^-^-; Secondary School, Ambikapur, District Surguja (C.G.). 8. Ashish Kumar Dubey, aged about 42 years, Son of Shri V. N. Dubey, Posted as Lecturer; Presently posted in the office of District Education Officer, • Ambikapur District Surguja (C.G.). VERSUS State of Chhattisgarh, Through: The Secretary, Department of School Education, D.K.S. Bhawan, Mantralaya, Raipur (C.G.). State of Madhya Pradesh, Through: The Secretary, Department of School Education, Vallabh Bhawan, Bhopal (M.P.). The Director, Public Instruction, School Education, Raipur (C.G.). 4. The Director, Public Instruction, School Education, M. P. Nagar, Bhopal, (C.G.). 5. The District Education Officer, Ambikapur, District Surguja (C.G.). WRIT _PETITION UNDER ARTICLES 226/227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, 1950 FOR ISSUANCE OF WRIT IN THE NATURE OF CERTIORARI, MANDAMUS ETC. AND FOR APPROPRIATE ORDER/ORDERS, DIRECTION/DIRECTIONS. WiaMi<SOi«lf<^liHHAiTtttflllitH3^ttN.JltSWj» SIN^^BSN^t tlOaffajEII^^^^!^^ Petititmeis 'iwW pEfnwNwo.ewa OFa®* V.G. Satomonand ottiBrs vwsus ResBdrKtonts : TheStaieirfChhattUgai'hfWlothws PUtBiQneis : vereus ; ': . . RBBiWnaente.1'^1.'.':' : Sta a<fGhhatfogarttmtt®ttlw» P^itidnere : JaiBingttfWtBaawid^awUuF Wiraus .. : : .': .(teiaxmdWtts-::1:;^;.' : StalBflf^NI'BN^Blywtfothws VWOTPETni^MW^MtOpaggs AshwanrKunnr^iMmfrmtfantithur RiBsDonymte SteaeofChhatB^sirtiliA^hws PaBBdinws WRn'PETB'^NWOdMSIMSKanMi VX.Rrilind<rthW» vwws .; • fiSn^iMi^ : Sla^ofGhhat^arltandottiere WIOTPETIT^ PeBtlonWK : f^mBUartarYadatfwKlaroiBter •lvereus..,-11. • ; . . , Resi^ntente : Sta^WCtiheffienffiandethws WffUT P@n^Wll .2'M»OfE38Bt flaBBBms i^ ant.AmitlrTiiptfhiiuutethers v«stia 'ReaowvSWIev-^r' •:.' : S^eofehtwUisswhanetothws WWti IOIIBIS <U®Bmtea^ngh llwr»iindtmBth«' •vereus': ','-': ':.: ::: '1 : . RasDoncteirts : StatBofGhhatHsyBftmdo»»»s PstBoneT 8satsasSttEa& PETmONU0.880F2Mfr : SI»*raiUTOtl<wtiart(Dwh»nuMi)now DilHwar vwsus Th»StatiK<3wefflmartteFCNiimi^|artt andanottw . ^- /2° Preaanl : Mh^ntrai|tShifc»^a^1NBfc^H^ AnupanrDBbe^Mr.^ty^Shrh^UOTwKtMr^^a^ Payashi, coimwTtorWepeKional^. Mr. Aruh Sao, Goivmnmwit ^iillwcatolMrth»StaW reqiondehls. ^assecton 10m ofNovember.ZOOe^ Ttw patitioiwR are woridrw as LWturerfl-leal MEStsi/Vpi^ Divisten Te^w/Assislant T»achw te^^ ©^ Sch8<»ISi^ho6tE€lBCaBffl»B8partmenl.lfrth8Ct>ur5»oft^ asLe^Urei^HiwAiteBtw/UppercDNfelonTaarterWCTistent Teaeher, ttie peUflCTieisp ftaw obhdntict B.Etl^B/T.I. GertBfertBa at ttieir OWB 2.^ ThkpresentbatehofWntprtBensarebei^ tyttiis^<^n'lb <>rdera^ttwf^tstmdqy«^ton«rfl^hwBtwdm pditionsare GwmiKm. 3. AaaBRUny to iMmmil counsel ler tti* prttttonMS, th» petlBonwt < atttBhKt t& twwadwma ir^^ (leCBiorrWthlyecmifrtolhecaseofyi^iw^ MwMpatCtirfion ^Daivimd^meffi^,v^^ tt»TBflctiW5.hmlnffobtidn«tB.Ed.,W.Ed.,B.T.I.Ge»8ffertB»,trttfiejr onm«qpw)8e®,aro«o<medby^^ciR!Bhff€lirtBd24-12-18Wi»uwlby ttwStateGovemimmtoifMadh^iPrachKrti. 4; Furthe^ in the n»Uwd ^A Man<»wn»^m«s(BWBt«. StlfeefMRantfctfw^.fl^Wftic^Pra^^ ©<i ^BancK,^^ife^ensicleiUiB1h8<ftculfirdatett1-3.1999.wtwirtnit ^ js provided that tfw Assfetant Tsachere, v»ho have acquirerf B.Ed. Degree at their own cost beh»een 23-10-1864 and 7-5-1973 shaN be enUtted to Iwo advanro incremerts, reliad on decision In tie case of Rakwh Kumar Stowasfewa vs. State of M.P. wvi aUwrs passed in Original Applfeation No.16%2of 1999, decteted on 12-10-1999, wherem it is observsd that the clrcular dsrted 1-3-1M9 cannot be made applfcabte ratrospectnrely. Thus, a T«icher,may be Assistant Tssasher, who has obtainwl B.Ed. Degree b^ore t-3-1999 is enBUat to two advanceincr8ments. ''< .' ;•• •"•»• '* ^ 5. ItlspolntedaitbytearnedcotBiselappearingforfte petitioners that the than State of Madh^i Pradesh had fltod a Special Lsave PetHlon aaainst the oretere passed l^ the Tribunal and tte Hon'bte Supreme Court dismfesed Spectal Leave Pdition No.1999 of 2(XX) filed agalnst ftw order of the Tribunal. Therrtbre, the diFectien to the effect that e clreular datad 1-3-1999cannot be made appUcabto retro^ascBvely, passed by the Tribunat, becomss final and tts sams shatl t»appNcabte to all the ^sistant Teachers, who have obtained B.Ed^B.T.I.Certificatesbefors 1-3-1999. Itis furttier subslantiatedby a clrotllardated 17-10^00 iMuadby the preswd Starta of Macttiya Pradesh, wherein the circutar cteariy states about Bie deelskxi cf tfre Hon'ble Supreme Gourt. 6. Leamed cbunsel appearingfor the peUUwwre tUrther submlts Biat tte feate and qusstton of law inwh/ed in Bw present cases are squarely covered by the decislon of this Court h <he case <rf Yashwwrf Kumar Btwsduvaf (Supra), to which leamed counsel !; ;a '. 1"\. \\ ^^ appearir®for the State/respondents fairty concedea and agrees with Ihe averments macte by toamed eounset appearing fer the pedfoners; 7. In some ef the csses, on the basis of otrtainmg B.EdJB.T.I. CertMeates, the petWoners wen gFanted two advance increments, but, latwon, the(aymentoftwoadvaroelncrem«ntswas stopped. Since the pditioners are entlUed to two advance increments, the orcler stopping the payment of two SKlvance inciBmente as welt as recoveiyof thesiudamount isbad and ths petittonersara entitled to 8re beneffit of two advance Incremenls from the dato they have passad B.Ed./B.T.I. ExEmtnations. 8. AccOrelins^y.thewrttpetitionsareaUowedintennsofthe decislon of ttils Court in the msrtter of Yashwant Kumar Btiamduwj (Supra),Subjeettovenflcationofth8 factas towhether the peUUonere haw acquired B.Ed.®.T.I.Certiflcates at theh- own expenses as per the circularsdatBd 24-12-1998 and 1-3-1999 and further whether ftiey have been psud twoadvance incremente or not No order as to cosls. 9. A copy of this ordw be placed on the record of the connectedwritpetUons. Sd/- Satish K. Agnihotri Judge 1 2008 00 MPJR-CG98 2 2000(1) M.P.LaR, 136