&PPLIGATS)ii UHDBH 3SGIIOE 19 QS? 2HE AIM.u'ilSTaA'rrv^; I&IBTOAI.S 1985. C^P^ ^57^/o^ £2^Jjs^._La__tneJlBibynj2L'^^ffls^ . Date of filin^ 03? Date of Recsipt i37 pog-fc. • Begis'cra'fcion uo, R36Ii32RAR .'-•ll.i.i; i-'.aBHZd PRAOE3H ArMCTBZHATTre TEITOHaL BBiEGH AZ aAIFOE. BSS'SBSs 1* sE2l3^3S£& 8 1. Atag Eam Destoukh son of Sliri 'Hari Kaa Deshau}cfc aged abou-fc 36 years, resident of village • •likeTi, Safasil Gunderdeai, Dlstrict Durg (®) 2. lujhera Deshaukh son of Shri Goaul Prasad OeshiaulA, aged about. 38 years, resident of village Bharda, P.O.Kuthrsle Oistriot Durg. 3. Vediigth Sahn ^son of Shri Baaa Sahu, aged about 38 years, residsi't of village pireed (Choutela) lahsil Ganderdehi Digt.rict Durg. ^ 4. SEit.Pas2ipa Pgtel W/0 Shri Sufchdeo Baa Patel, -; " aged about 40 yssrg, resideat of Eewti 23'gvagaon Post Offiee Sgasra Nayapara Balod District Durg. (M.P). , • 5. Sukhdeo P.aa Patel 3/0 late Sbri Motilal Patel, aged a'oovt 50 yegrs, resident of ae.wgtj. ^ayagao! P.P.Sankra 1'ahsil Bglod, District Burg (M:P) 6. Smt.Ashalata Shrivag-Eava X/0 Shri D.L.3hrivas-^ . tava aged atoat 47.years, re.sident of Bglod, .Qistricl; Darg (M.P) - . ' 7. ^.Zashoda Sogl w/0 stel ^oop ^^ 2o,i. ^ •f »a^a xogi, ages aoout s3 years' Na^P^a.BaIod Bistrict^' ii/i s. '^•^^v-^^r^^"f^F^^^^:.^•^t?WCT^Kz*=^p'"^, (d'M) .sesira^I ?.3'i:>t^.STQ 'BjAaj'-Q'j BjBa B34-q.Bg agST-fpA JO q.TISPTSS.C B^PTBA TBTEiB^qgijqg jo uos e^pie^ iiiBg BT:SIT •6-[ (d*N): 3-i"a ^.o-cjq.s-ta PoTBg ejBet e£BK jo T q.uspTesj f3oji ^eTTfT. BS 0/a TSo^ Tq.BKempe^-q.iag (a'K) 33-tlQ ^fX^SfQ ejBqoiTpunea T!:sqej, 'eSaeq.ej.-o'd eSTffi^e^ sge-c-jjA JQ q.ueptssj ISIBQ£ gg inoqe psSe Tj:nd3iTtr5f.? sepaegeqo T.tqg o/A Tj:ad3;Ta% T:BquseT!:B3*'}.iag •Z.T: (d'H) Sxai q.ouq.s-ta poieg Jo g.uep-ysej: lsiee.S. gg q.noqe pege 'jsqSueg Ei-eg oo.tBCB^i Tjqg jo uos jsqSuBg isie'g pejnuna •9T (3*H) S.ttiQ q.oT.ta.sTQ 'POTBg XV.S.C'.t) TCiSI.CiVSW.BCIQ 3.0 lUSpTSej tSXBQ£ 05- q.noqe psge (nqeg*'g*.SiT 0/S s^-reqqqq.^ TeTBQ.isT>!5i HIG^ 'ST (<3:*r-,T) S.ina q.oxjq.STG .tdJao'S'a e7Tns 83BTTTA J° q.as'PT59'1 BABgjBqg'g-g t.Eqs 0/S BABgjeqg rae^nq.Teqo •^ (iI'H) Sjna B.o-rjq.STGpGTBg 6ejBdiie@-]:Bsm'! jo .^nsptse^ 'sjes^ g^. ^aoqe peSe 'S-T.Wv.s-y^ T:TOE O/®jeqdoTrff BnseaBfttx •ST (d •!..!> Sm@ q.OT.Tq.s-ro' poTBg jo q.aep-tssj:. 'saea^ gg ^noqe psge 'Tqs-i:eja6 jT:-:teqg TRpqy p8HiBiBqow o/a Tqs^ejr^ ranSsg g.eaxrsrtis •gx •Syna aOTjq.s-ia pOTeg jo ^.uspteaj: 'eAeaseA^.iiig pssBj^ Biimsef T.Eqs 0/G Busxeg eiaesg'q.ing •TT •S.cna •.S.OTJ^STG spunC.iy'o'd 'e-punCjy jo ^.TiepTSsj g.8Mey EiBjiSBqo Tjqs jo uos q.eAB^ ES^qssqpBg •OT (d'K) s a S-OT.II.STG PPTBa jo luep-tssj: 'S^BS^ 9g g.noqe psSe ipinnqssa TGTEie^qg TJqg jo uos ns'neiqssQ aeian^ use^Bg •g 'U'l'O' s-:taG 3.°T:.i?.s-j:Q pue -ijsqei; 'T.EOS Jo iiiepTSSj •sjee^ gg ^noqe pege j8m:-n;-[:a-g«G ijqg O/E' jeATnTG .EBati3l nueq.uBqg •9 ,.,:»sM S(SSffW fSSfSs""^" ;; gNSil:II!S cs < ad s'^'"^K!"s!S''^"^SSeSi'SS!fs^^,yagi5t^SS^S^S.'y' 3 - -Versu.s- 2. Non-ADDlicaats. 1. Stgte of M.P.tliTOugh Seoretary ochool EdUoation Departiaen.t M.P.Bhopal. 2. Beputy Director Eduoation Durg (M.P) • 3. Deput:^- Oireator Eduoation, Kan-feer (M.P) % T HIGHCQURLOFCHHATTISGARHATBILASPUR SINGLE BENCH : HON'BLE SHRI SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, J. WRIT PETITION (S) N0. 2574 OF Petitioners ResDondents versus Atma Ram Deshmukh and others State of M.P. and others Present : IVIr. Vivek Rathore, counsel for the petitioners. Mr. Ajay Dwivedi, learned Panel Lawyer forthe State. ORAL ORDER (Passed on 31st of July, 2006) Tha petitioners are appointed as ad hoc teachere on daily wages basis by the District Education Officer, Durg by order dated 19.09.1981 (Annexure A-1). The petitioners by way of this petition seek regularization of their sen/ices and further aiternatively grant of regular pay-scale. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of Secretarv, State of Karnataka and others Vs. Umadevi (3) and others reoorted in (2006) 4 SCC 1 has clearly heid that absorption, regutarization, or permanent continuance of temporary, contractual, casual, daily-wage or ad hoc employees appointed/recruited and continued for iong in public employment dehors the constitutional scheme of public employment create another mode of public employment which is not permissibie. In the present case the petitioners are daily wagers and are not appointed in accordance with law and as per the constitutional scheme of the public employment. Thus they do not acquire any right for regularization or for grant of regular pay-scale. Further the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of Secretary, State of Karnataka Vs. Umadevi and others (supra) in paragraph-53 directed as under:- IKilll iiiJUiSi&gaS&uiiaaN&sSSi^^ ^^•teeS^^-s.^ ...lilllliti1 '•SJii'sE1'1' IK;i!i Paira 53. 'The question of regularisation of the services of such employees may have to be considered on merits in the light of the principles settled by this Court in the cases abovereferred to and in the iight of this judgment. tn that context, the Union of India, the State Governments and their instrumentalities should take steps to regularise as a one-tlme measure, the services of such irregutarly appointed, who have worked forten years or more in duly sanctioned posts but not under cover of orders of the courts or of tribunais and shouid further ensure that reguiar recruitments are undertaken to fill those vacant sanctioned posts that require to be filled up, in cases where temporary employees or daily wagers are being now employed. The process must be set in motion within six months from this date. We also clarify that regularisation, if any already made, but not sub judice, need not be reopened based on this judgment, but there should be no further bypassing of the constitutiona! requirement and regularising or making permanent, those not duly appointed as per the constitutionai scheme." In view of the above stated directions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the respondents are directed to comply with the order of the Supreme Court as one- time measure in the cases of the petitioners. The petition is accordingly disposed of. No order as to costs. Certified copy as per rules. Sd/- Satish K. Agnihotri Judge ^l^-: