a.. ¶f?E FTP! CCP 0’ V’r T M’Afl A’” 3 1 ç’7flq DAurwDmPQflr 26’ ,A çow’ in “ P WLT$ TO? 1.GOflAOlDA t T i€t!It%W ‘‘.13fl4/1OO9 “ Vt.GSg’ ‘use P’et°. r.3ye4 Sanaullq, pe 4 t9 yrc, wo”kina pq m epffjn (‘ofle icr, wronr v ciceip— n°ted ‘ig Stnad Duty Con4uetor, Poker lo.’ii, Aeaj1 K!RTC. Haee’n tiv 4 eio’i. Was •r, PrA reeidIv, •t Raheem V tail Sri.ririsi’w r Areeik.re,Apenjet PtffT 3 t’I’ &pfl, ILt a.. — (ap trl LSubt’a o, AJvote ‘1 AND 1, RtPQ, “er by Vje Chsiirmpn 4 MD. Certrrl Oticee, 7 •T 0 p B ‘r or 7 2. Thet 4 s,joeiql ont”ol1er, KSRTC, H°srn Divi,ior. Sri Putt s yedd , fl..or, worlrnr a Pr “ic Controller, ‘tern That etn4, qepari D-vie 4 on, Ha e’r It (By Sri . •%4ets, Mv. 9 or .1 * SrI S.’.That, !dv. ‘n’- ) I ttoni p t 2)’ endoe ‘vent be em “o.rP. 9V 2 : 9’4/ 1.. t°tel ‘Da”e19Ol v 4s Annatre—. P It etItlon om r f ‘is in t” 2 t le’’ S t S 2— tDGM 4 t the etti eec’ we *ppoir’t 4 2 a ondueto I t’e re ondent 40 poretion on 14I e1971. While he see or luty on ‘0th erteabee I he suffered terel itio “tr ke nO es p re erweo to the ‘Itiahane’ lion, tal at Banpal re. Apt! the seeo .1 teoke wet -uttered bi “is on 67—I°BF. Poe t’e PId re on e abaitted lie re rent t on deted 28-3— ‘6 to tie re p ‘dent-Corpor’tioz e ieetin the Corpor tion to c Wer his eiue t 1 r a-igninp at’ altera tire toet otber th n tie ott o eoMuetor. ft we pondente ideriwrterereeet+ g f the et loner, e ft been ‘rnttP’l A t Tht) Conduetox it efe t tt * e$ 6 leha wose4i tate ety ttolti oveab 18. t afte ,ie ; nnoi oste ido duke ha aoek n C’ in’ue’ at 4 aa h e be’ ii oart W • P 0 2 tt.o em b I se V —719 I t I not to disturb the petitioner from his stand duty conductor’s po and disoharge the functions of Trafflo Controller, until the finalisation of the s.niority list, In pursuance of the said order, he cortinue’ as stand duty conductor, 2. The Divisional Controller of the Corporatior. of Hassan Division has issued a notioe dated 15—3—1991 to t.e petitioner calling upon bin to produce the wedical cer tificate to show that he was not in a posi tion to discharge his regular duty as con ductor. Medical certificate Was produced in pursuance of the said notice. Thereafter as per Annexu$7 dated 10—4—1991, the peti— tione:r was allowed to v’ork a.s stand duty conductor, !fbe said oer was given effect to by the spondent—Cornoration up to 28—12—1991, Then as per Pnnexure—T. the res— pondent-Corporation by ar1 endorsement was informed to the petition.em stating that he had been withdrawn f r1:..a This at a zid C fldLuct or and e.ske:f him to perform. the duty as regular :u—--— 4 conductor 4 This order is inpugned in this writ pet it ion on va.riou.s lal grounds, 34 lieerred conned Nr,arayar.a Bh.at appearIng for the petitioner submits tht there is a bindiiw settlement between the worlanan and the first ?esoondent-CornorPtion with regard to vsri.ous service condItions of. employees workina in the Corporation 8 He has: tiaced etrong reliance on olauee — 9 of the said settlement dated 16—2 —1926 which. reads thus: “Faa ility to disabled ernr’ovee : ifl the event of disabilIt’. ef the emo— loyee while on duty, not warrntinu removal, he shall be reoategorised to an. equivalent poet carryIng simi lar..: pay scales, eto,, shall be continued if he ie suitable for that. poet, or Ii. the lower post, if the em lo cc so desires, sub lect to satrying all conditions of the ryBTV ca-dre and Recruitment Remulations, Re furtlier submits that s..:vbeequent to thefl above sett him.ent, number of sett leme:n hsive been arrived with the first restoiEh:.ritor_ S a5e or°tioa j *lflrl t laa.e-Q o fl’ ,etffjennrt. He t ’Ps r1’oed steow reIi’noe un 4 er the Rerul’tion t(1)(b) et°tini t°t the eavloyee o 2 ’i be reoruite4 to ‘i yost by *pyoint rag sueb te—’o’i b fofloainp mç’thode enumerated iard er Regulat ion’ of the Karnat,ka Stite Road ?rnerort Corporation (Cadre vt! keoruitment) Rep’uItions, 1°82. *ccording to the leqrned counsel by tnnsfering R tenon who is °lna4 r n e of t’ie “sryorft ion from e lyP lent ‘dre o d as o toot, a et can be fted ut’. He submits t’iat eauiv°lnt to te con4uctor yost, t)’e rost o Junior Assistants are P.r4ilable inthe r°evondent (‘orso t on. T1 refor, e cub ta that t he 1 be ii rd ly I ble o disoh e ,s rep 1..r conductor duties on tie roun that le 1ia4 unlnwent a oven ‘tnfl sune on 214_1Ont ani i’i resc°ct 0 fl’ qj4 aver— j hp4 ; ucel t m.4ie cefli 0 ‘te the t r date” lfl_1O t ’ie to— w It tea tie nid oeflifcte he certtfed stetine that “ha 2e tft to o l±flt an! ee 4 .rtn work m 30—1’ 1fl4”. •kj 1 faa h55 a’ *$IlltIiIiIII)lrIi ‘II’ I, $ IL I I vigil (fit. g — sverment° n. te 3 cur te pron p1 by ti-p petitioner in sipport 1’ his cse, On tie other hand, le”ne ‘ounsel 7 &.B,P,Mandppa cpnePring for th° first resoonentorpora— tion submits that the simiir quetion w consider 3 by ths Court in Writ petition ‘o,637 / 97 diopo cr3 f on 18—1 —1° nd writ oetttion No.21 A78_A81/1001 3 lsrosed c on 1i—3—1°°8, not rntin the reliefs soucht for by the petitioners jr those petitiors, Learned oo cc or the pet tione ced reHsnoe on the et ‘°tion 3 1)(b) of the ?eguitio”s °nd c1use q o the set± 1 e— t’e rent reforred to above In/writ retitions referre to above c]?use 9 of the aettlement 3 ted 16- 19 a o not e co dered e f rthe facts tin a refero to tie ebove writ petitos an3 the foote of this cope rrticuIar’v in view of the udment passed by this Court t Annexur°— t in the Writ t tion 3/90 onnect 3 matt re ntirly ife nt foett I Ct 4 n ‘c,p o,E7S10O7 hop ohsenol ti-a c e o the petitIoner in that o°se th°t i-is -9- epre°e tetior may be o neidereti 4 ’or change f sun equiva nt post or change the cadre of the retitioner to a lower iob with pay rrotection otl’erwise s ncr Rules. In t’-’e writ rt 1 tior piled ePrier hr the petit toner referred to above there ic clear direction to the re°rondei not to disturb the netitioner/petitioners na stnl duty Conductons, 4 oart from the sail udc— ment th medici] certificate issue by te doctor clearly establish the fact th t the petitioner is not medic lly fIt to lischorge the duties of regul°r conductor post, The doctor issued a certificote recommendin,the petitioner is not In a fit conditIon to do a work, a ich f9c Ore not ontrovert by the eepondent—Corporat on. vie of the fact and certifiocte I cluse— 0 o the settlent referred to bove confer power upon the Corporetion to oor elder te case & the pet tioner f chan f nost a reoueet b’ him Ce he }pa been etferirn r at di ab ta a I I ¶up\eA n n arc t of,,atl ent sb4ah*4taw4saa lng rant icuar2y wit refeonce tthe fact t’°t he ic sufeerinn f’on nrvt 4 c stroke 4 rid • he Iad mderwent n oten heart •u per • Th refore, it i a f4t cc or ti te non e t-Corportl to eo ide act it tMm TrflicCotrli to hich he is entitled or to continue his n tbe present ettionry duty 1 aecorda cc with the undertacing piven to this ‘J tart on tn round of aedic dint Flit • There fore, Is sy tie he pet tioner enttled 1 r t etc let ‘tiuzat to n tie w”it p t’ tb grL’ Hew’e the en$orewert at A nezure4 ated 28 1 1091 1 not ustait bit n lqw a It fit t ze..p Merit Co port! ring g crete! it•noaerespe ce ftl s tIaent. ? 3 e pet tfon jq jffp4 a’ from is nt rat ra to e, I P t I ovd’ro tne I crtif’i+aprdua .3 )i ti r erntf t Nhave b t e noca—ider t Cbflt it 05 let t t’wlth i S e • tattle t tter, tie or a t r t c q p t tt a I a 4. I’ — — 6. Writ retition is allowed, Rule 15 isSi2ed. ResvOndeflt_COrpOrattOn is herel directed to coat inue {tttwnJn the oresent ±kL — abtan&t&nty or eautvalent to slinller 5ob protecting his pay seaIc a other benefits and it is further directed to thE.respondert— to consider his renresentation ‘1tb rees”oe to clause 9 of th.e settlewent for granting en equIvalent rest in oooranoe with law as per rules and settlement, The petitIoner shall be either continued in the present post or assi n him en equivalent cost till the consideration ofhis representa tion by the Corp.oration In the cirounstances of the case no costs are awarded, Sdl / Gb/c