IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA LPA No.305 of 2009 1. Arvind Kumar, Son of Rampadarath Singh, Resident of Road No. 30, Gardanibagh, Anisabad, District-Patna-800002. 2. Navnit Kumar Naman, Son of Sri Brahamdeo Yadav, Resident of Village Pali, P.O. Golabazar, District-Nawadah. 3. Rajesh Kumar, Son of Ram Chandra Singh, Resident of Village and P.O. : Aganoor, P.S.-Kaler, District-Arwal-824113. 4. Rakesh Kumar, Son of Lakhan Sharma, Resident of C/o Kishanlal Rajak, Tekari Road, Patherki Masjid, Sultanganj, P.O. Mahendru, District-Patna-800006. 5. Durganand Roy, Son of Mahendra Prasad Yadav, Resident of Shivpuri (East), Ward No. 14, Near Old Police Camp, P.O. & District Saharsa- 852201. 6. Ataur Rahman, Son of Md. Tajuddin, Resident of C/o Md. Yunua, Village Parbiro, P.O. Baswarya, P.S. Lauriya, District-West Champaran-845453. 7. Md. Alam, Son of Late Sk. Md. Muslim, Resident of Village-Barbiro, P.O. Baswarya, P.S. Lauriya, District-West Champaran-845453. 8. Dharmendra Kumar Son of Girijesh Kumar, Resident of Village Aira, P.O. Aira, District-Jehanabad-804421. 9. Md. Shahid Parwej, Son of Mustaque Ahmad, Resident of Villge Harpur Pipra, P.O. Bargajwa, P.S. Gawnaha, District-West Champaran. 10. Ajit Kumar Son of Babban Prasad Singh, Resident of At Haridan Bigha, P.O. Barahiya, District-Lakhisarai-811302. 11. Sanjeet Kumar Son of Late Jai Nandan Prasad Yadav, Resident of Babu Bazar Katra, Gardanibagh, Anisabad, District and Town-Patna- 800002. 12. Tarun Kumar Son of Dineshwar Prasad, Resident of At-Khandpar (Bhittapar), P.O. and District-Sheikhpura-811105. 13. Jay Prakash, Son of Rajendra Prasad Sinha, Resident of P.O. Masauri, District-Patna-804452. 14. Rajesh Kumar, Son of Yogendra Rajak, Resident of At-Purani Bazar, P.O. & P.S. Masaurhi, District-Patna-804452. 15. Sanjeev Kumar, Son of Shri Rajeshwar Prasad Singh, Resident of Village & P.O.: Rupas (Dindayal Singh Ka Tola), P.S. Athmal Gola, District-Patna-803221. 16. Dinesh Kumar, son of Late Janki Yadav, Resident of At-Ranka, P.O. Karki, P.S. Ariari, District-Sheikhpura-811105. 17. Ajay Kumar Son of Ram Narayan Mahto, Resident of C/o Sri Ajay Kumar Choudhary, S.B.I. Street, Gate No. 16, Dujra Rajapur, Patna- 800001. 18. Chandra Bhushan Kumar, Son of Shivjee Yadav, Resident of Village- Tekuna Math, P.O. Bharwar, via-Mangal Garh, P.S. Rosera, District- Samastipur-848208. - 2 - 19. Sanjay Pandey, Son of Sri Ramchandra Pandey, Resident of A.No.-E- o-53 5, Janta Nagar, Patratu Thermal Power Station, Patratu, District- Ramgarh-829119. 20. Niraj Kumar Son of Arun Kumar Singh, Resident of Gulab Bhawan, New Yarpur, Gardanibagh, Road No. 01, District-Patna-800001. 21. Amod Kumar, Son of Yogendra Dwivedi, Resident of At-Krishnapuri, (Parbatiya Tola), P.O. Belbagh Bettiah, District-East Champaran. 22. Navin Kumar Jha, Son of Gajendra Jha, Resident of R.P.S. College, Patepur, District-Vaishali (Bihar)-843114. 23. Shiv Shankar Singh, Son of Chandrama Singh, Resident of C/o Shambhu Singh, At-New Vigrahpur Behind Harinandan Market, P.O. G.P.O. Patna.-800001. 24. Shishupal Kumar Son of Dinesh Singh, Resident of Village Dhelwagosai, P.O. & P.S. Barh, District-Patna-803213. 25. Lalan Prasad, Son of Tarni Singh, Resident of Village and Post- Pandarak Tola, Dundapur, District-Patna-803221. 26. Jitendra Kumar Son of Surendra Singh, Resident of Village Dewan Patehlay, P.S. Khizar Sarai, District-Gaya. 27. Ajay Kumar, Son of Ram Laxman Ojha, Resident of Village Guzarwaliya, P.O. Ganni, Via-Bettiah, District-West Champaran- 845438. 28. Navin Kumar Vats, Son of Chandeshwari Prasad Sharma, Resident of Village TAregna Dih, Ward No. 01, P.O. & P.S. Masaurhi, District Patna, Bihar-804452. 29. Chandra Shekhar Kumar Son of Shyam Narayan Roy, Resident of Kumar Pustak Kendra Anisabad, P.S. Gardanibagh, District-Patna- 800002. 30. Piyoosh Kumar Payodhi, Son of Sri Ranjeet Prasad Singh, Resident of At Shivpuri Colony, P.O. & P.S. Isakchak, District-Bhagalpur-812001. 31. Amitesh Kumar Son of Ram Sakha Singh, Resident of New Area Sikandarpur Sakna (Just West of Parabhat Zarda Factory, District Muzaffarpur-8439001. 32. Chandan Kumar Son of Suresh Sinha, Resident of 118, Alka Colony, Sanmdalpur, Post Mahendru, District and Town-Patna-800006. 33. Ajit Kumar Tinku, Son of Giriraj Sharma, Resident of Village and P.O. Lari, P.S. Kurtna, District-Arwal-804421. 34. Praveen Kumar Upadhyay, Son of Shankar Upadhyay, Resident of Village Upadhya Bigha, P.O. Mainpura Chanda, District-Arwal, 824127. 35. Pranay Kumar, Son of Sri Bhola Nath Chaudhary, Resident of New Area Sikandarpur, District-Muzaffarpur-842001. 36. Jitesh Kumar Son of Janardan Prasad Resident of Village-Mahuabagh, P.O. Sahay Nagar, District-Patna-801506. 37. Haresh Kumar Son of Jagdish Pathak, Resident of Mohalla-Raghunath Tola, P.O. Anisabad, District and Town-Patna-800006. 38. Deepak Kumar Son of Shivdhari Sah, Resident of Shivnagar Raksna Kunni Safdpur, District-Saitamarhi-843328. - 3 - 39. Dharmendra Kumar Son of Shivnarain Prasad Singh, Resident of Central Jail Beur, P.O. Anisabad, P.S.-Gardanibagh, District-Patna. 40. Chandradip Kumar Son of Bhola Prasad, Resident of C/o Chandradip Kumar, At Jamalpur, P.O. & District-Sheikhpura-811105. 41. Sunil Kumar, Son of Suresh Singh, resident of Village-Dumri, P.O. Pitwans, District-Patna-804452. 42. Vishwanath Prasad Bharti, Son of Bhikhan Ray, Resident of C/o Rajendra Prasad Singh (D.S.P.), Buddha Colony, P.S. Buddha Colony, Near Kutti Mill/Link Road, District and Town-Patna-800006. 43. Rajeev Kumar Son of Upendra Singh, Resident of in the House of Jagdish Sharma, Upadhyay Lane (Near Corporation) West Lohanipur, P.S. Kadamkuan, District & Town Patna-800003. 44. Anuj Kumar Son of Yugal Kishore Sah, Resident of Village-Jafarpur, P.O. Dhuladh, Via-Geyaspur, District-Muzaffarpur-843107. 45. Rakesh Kumar Son of Bijay Kumar Singh, Resident of Rasiriyaganj, Near Birla School, Phulwarisharif, District-Patna-801505. 46. Praween Kumar Son of Kailash Prasad, Resident of Village Siswara, P.O. Loma, District-Muzaffarpur-843107. 47. Vishad Vishwas, Son of Virendra Kumar Singh, Resident of Village and P.O. Shekhpura, Via-Ramna, District-Muzaffarpur-842002. 48. Upendra Prsad Yadav, Son of Sriramdeo Ray, Resident of Village Dipau, via-Tarkwlia, District-East Champaran-845437. 49. Manmohan Pandey, Son of Ram Naresh Pandey, Resident of Cr. No. 3301, SEC-VII, EXT Bokaro Steel City, P.S. Harla, P.O./Sector-IX, District Bokaro (Jharkhand)-827009. 50. Kamal Nayan Pandey, Son of Chandra Bhushan Pandey, Resident of C/o R.B. Tripathi, BRT No. 8, Road No. 5, P & T Colony, N.R. Sanjay Gandhi Stadium, Gardanibagh, P.S. Gardanibagh, District & Town- Patna-800001. 51. Pushpa Raj Sharma, Son of Sudin Prasad Sharma, Resident of Qr No. 1197, Street-16, Sector-IX B, Bokaro Steel City, Bokaro (Jharkhand)- 827009. 52. Jyoti Mani, son of shiva Shankar Prasad, Resident of Village Chagajee, P.O. Bhikhanpur, P.S. Ahiyapur, District Muzaffarpur-842004. 53. Harinath Singh, Resident of Deorajeet Singh, Resident of Village and P.O.: Hichhan Bigha, P.S. Daudnagar, District-Aurangabad-824113. 54. Sanjay Kumar Son of Chandrika Chaudhary, Resident of Phulwarisharif, Birla Colony (Dagar) P.S. Phulwarisharif, District- Patna-801505. 55. Avinash Kumar Son of Harunni Prasad, Resident of Village Kundal, P.O. Mahindwar, District-Sitamhri-843117. 56. Rabindra Kumar Ram, son of Jairam Das, Resident of Village and Post-Chouri, P.S. Daudnagar, District-Aurangabad, 824127. 57. Chandra Bhushan Sinha, son of sita Sharan Sinha, Resident of C/o Awadhesh Prasad, Park Road, Kadam Kuan, P.S. Kadam Kuan, District-Patna-80003. Versus - 4 - 1. The State of Bihar through its Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, Old Secretariat, Patna. 2. The Director General of Police, Government of Bihar, Old Secretariat, Patna. 3. The Bihar Staff Selection Commission through its Secretary, Government of Bihar, Veterinary College, Patna. 4. The Chairman, Staff Selection Commission through its Secretary, Government of Bihar, Veterinary College, Patna. …….Respondents-Respondents. 5. Manish Kumar Sinha, Son of Prem Shankar Prasad Sinha, Resident of infront of Brajesh Narayan, Marudi, Bagicha, New Yarpur, Janta Road, District and Town-Patna-800001. 6. Santosh Kumar, Son of Sri Munshi Mahto, Resident of C/o Sanjay Kumar Tufani, Resident Nyd-131, New Yarpur, Janta Road, P.S. District-Patna-800001. 7. Vishwajit Singh, son of Sri Ramyatan Singh, Resident of Telecom Centre, Naya Bazar, Lakhisarai, District & P.O. Lakhisarai-811311. 8. Sanjay Kumar Choudhary, Son of Paras Choudhary, Resident of C/o M.K. Sinha, Janta Awasiya Vidalaya, Ranighat Lon (Mahendru) Opposite Steel Factory, P.O. Mahendru, District & Town-Patna- 800006. 9. Brajesh Kumar Son of Sadanand Singh, Resident of Village and Post- Pandey Patti, FCI Road, District-Buxar-802103. 10. Jyoti Shankar Prasad, Son of Prem Chandra Prasad, Resident of Village Rampurwa, P.O. and P.S. Mainatand, District-West Champaran-845306. 11. Rajeev Kumar, Son of Krishneshwar Prasad Sharma, Resident of C/o shiva Chandra Sharma, Eastern Lane From Siya Mosque, Desiyawan, Chapra-841301. 12. Pankaj Kumar Vidyarthi, Son of Bhola Pandit, Resident of Village Ganjpar, P.O. Badarwali, Via-Harnaut, District-Nalanda-803110. …...Performa-Petitioners-Respondents. With LPA No.475 of 2009 1. Sushil Kumar, Son of Rajbrinda Singh, Resident of Village-Kobil, P.S.-Islampur, District-Nalanda. 2. Prabhat Samir Son of Late Munilal Ram, resident of Village+P.O.- Bada Bariyarpur, P.S.-Chhatauni, District-East Champaran. 3. Sanjeev Kumar, Son of Shatrughan Chaudhary, resident of Village- Dhobauli, P.S.-Kumhara Vishunpur, P.S. Dumra, District-Sitamarhi. 4. Lalit Kumar Dubey, Son of Deopujan Dubey, resident of village- Tikulia, P.S.-Govindganj, District-East Champaran. 5. Pranav Kumar son of Brahmdev Singh, Resident of village-Choadi, P.O.-Badh, P.S.-Barh, District-Patna. 6. Harendra Kumar Das, son of Bangali Ram resident of village- Mahadev, Near Shiv Mandir Gate, P.O.-Siwan, P.S.-M.H. Nagar Hasanpura, District-Siwan. - 5 - 7. Lalloo Kumar Singh, Son of Ghanshyam Singh, resident of Village+P.O.-Amiyawar, P.S.-Nashriganj, District-Rohtas. 8. Yashwant Kumar Mishra son of Birendra Kumar Mishra, resident of Village-Gonda Brahmpuri, P.O.+P.S.-Revalganj, District-Saran (Chapra). 9. Ramashish Yadav Son of Sito Yadav, resident of Village-jahana, P.O. Barahara, Via-Sirari, P.S.-Halsi, District-Lakhisarai. 10. Santosh Kumar Singh, Son of Ram Sobha Singh, resident of Village- Faruli, P.S.-Amour, District-Saran. 11. Gyananand Amrendra, Son of Yogendra Prasad Yadav, resident of village-Azampur Gola, P.O.-Manihari, District-Katihar. 12. Bijay Prasad, Son of Ram Narayan Shah, resident of Village+P.O.- Siswa, P.S.-Banjaria, District-East Champaran. 13. Dharmveer Kumar Giri, Son of Mahendra Giri, resident of village- Gokhulpur, P.O.-Bihta, P.S.-Bihta, District-Patna. 14. Ashok Ram Son of Rama Nand Ram, resident of Village+P.O.-Bada Bariyarpur, P.S.-Chhatauni, District-East Champaran. 15. Arvind Kumar Son of Surendra Mahto, resident of Village-Govindpur, P.O.-Rosera, P.S.-Rosera, District-Samastipur. 16. Shivendra Narayan Singh, Son of Mahandra Prasad Singh, residning at C/o Chinta Devi, East Ashok Nagar, Road No. 14B, Gali-4, Kankarbagh, P.S.-Kankarbagh, P.S.-Kankarbagh, District-Patna. 17. Rajesh Kumar Singh, son of Ram Babu Singh, resident of Village- Nauadih (Khalpura), P.O.-Gultenganj, P.S.-Muffasil, District-Chapra. 18. Shree Kant Singh, Son of Dharmanath Singh, resident of Village+P.O.- Khalpura, P.S.-Muffasil, District-Chapra. 19. Praveen Kumar Son of Punit Singh, resident of Village+P.O.-Pathak Chak, P.S.-Malaypur, District-Jamui. 20. Bhuvaneshwar Thakur, Son of Moti Thakur, resident of Village- Laukariya, P.O.-Siswa Bazar, P.S.-Harsidhi, District-East Champaran. 21. Shakti Kumar son of Ramadhar Singh, residing at C/o Rana Singh, Patoot Niwas, Near Bishal Hanuman Mandir, Mainpura, P.S.- Patliputra, District-Patna. 22. Ravindra Kumar Son of Sri Laxmi Paswan, resident of village- Sarushima, P.O.-Lohna Road, P.S.-Bhairosthan, District-Madhubani. 23. Balbir Kumar Singh, Son of Shyam Sundar Singh, resident of Village+P.O.-Malaypur (Tomar Tola), P.S.-Malepur, District-Jamui. 24. Vikash Kumar, Son of Umesh Prasad Singh, resident of Village+P.O.- Pandarak, Tola-Ahmadpur, P.S.-Pandarak, District-Patna. 25. Jitendra Kumar Singh, son of Shailendra Kumar Singh, residing at Chandmari, Motihari, Near M.S. College, P.S.-Town Thana Mothihari, District-East Champaran. 26. Suman Kumar, Son of Sri Shakti Lal Sharma, resident of Sastri Colony, P.O.-Jamui, P.S.-Jamui, District-Jamui. 27. Rupesh Kumar Singh, Son of Baidya Nath Singh, residing at C/o Manoj Kumar Pathak, Sanjay Gandhi Nagar, A/32, Road No. 2, Hanuman Nagar, P.S.-Hanuman Nagar, District-Patna. - 6 - 28. Sumit Kumar Son of Krishna Murari Prasad, resident of Village- Mathiyazihat, P.O.-Motihari, P.S.-Motihari, District-East Champran. 29. Mukesh Kumar, son of Mohan Prasad, resident of Village- Chandrapura East, P.O.-Sandha, P.S.-Goraul, District-East Champaran. 30. Hemant Kumar Son of Uma Kant Mishra, resident of New Chandmari Chilwariya, P.O.-Mothihari, P.S.-Banjaria, District-East Champaran. 31. Rajendra Ram Son of Ram Krishna Ram, resident of Village- Randhawara, P.O.-Siwan, P.S.-Siwan Muphasil, District-Siwan. 32. Jitendra Kumar, son of Ashila Nand Prasad, resident of Village+P.O.- Kothian, P.S.-Abtar Nagar, District-Chapra. 33. Nitesh Kumar, son of Khub Lal Mahto, resident of Village-Babu Tola, P.S.-Bangariya, District-Motihari. 34. Abhishek Kumar son of Bacha Prasad Srivastava, resident of New Chandmari, Near Brahmasthan, Mothihari, P.S.-Mothihari, District- East Champaran. 35. Amitesh Kumar, son of Amarnath Prasad, resident of Village-Rasipur, P.O.-Gopalpur, P.S.-Husainganj, District-Siwan. 36. Manoj Kumar Singh son of Ramgobind Singh, resident of Village- Shekhpura Dih, P.O.-Dharhara Kala, P.S.-Amnour, District-Saran. 37. Rajan Kumar Srivastava son of Dhrupdeo Prasad, resident of village+P.O.-Jaijore, P.S.-Andar, District-Siwan. 38. Dhananjay Kumar Yadav son of Sukat Yadav, resident of Village- Pipra, P.S.-Daraoundha, District-Siwan. 39. Prahlad Kumar Jha, son of Bhupendra Jha, resident of Village-Prasad, P.O.-Banki, P.S.-Madhepura, District-madhubani. 40. Dhananjay Kumar Singh, son of paramanand Singh, resident of Village-Tiyariya, P.O.-Alwalpur, P.S.-Gaurichak, District-Patna. 41. Ranjit Kumar osn of Nagendra Prasad Singh, resident of Village Village-Gajeepur, P.O.-Dumari, P.S-Shayampur Bhanta, District- Sheohar. 42. Mukund Kumar son of Dhruva Kumar Panday, resident of Village- Krishnapuri Shekhpur, P.S.-Ahiyapur, District-Muzaffarpur. 43. Sudhir Kumar son of Sri Suresh Prasad, residing at new Yarpur Janta Road, Nirmala Sadan lane, P.S.-Gardanibagh, District-Patna. 44. Pradip Kumar Ranjan son of Shionath Prasad, residing at Dilip Kirana Dukan, Rajendra Nagar Gopal Ganj, P.O.-Gopalganj, P.S.-gopalganj, district-Gopalganj. 45. Md. Kamrej Alam son of Md. Abdul Kalam, resident of village-Kusni, P.O.-Sarwela, P.S.-Salkhuwa, District-Saharsa. 46. Mukesh Ranjan son of Chandra Bhushan Dwivedi, resident of S.K. Nagar, Near Sapaki Devi, Gali No.-6, P.S.-Motihari, District-East Champaran. 47. Shevesh Kumar, son of Shambhu sharan Prasad, residing at S.K. Nagar, Near Nursery, P.S.-Motihari, District-East Champaran. 48. Mukesh Kumar son of Abinash Prasad, residing at New Chandmari, Chilwaniya Road, P.S.+P.O.-Motihari, district-East Champaran. - 7 - 49. Gyan Prakash Singh son of Murli dhar Singh, resident of village- Ahinoura, Po-Harnathpur, P.S.-Mohania, district-Kaimur. 50. Nawal Kishore Paswan, son of Phekhan Paswan, c/o Chandeshwar Paswan, New India Insurance Company Ltd. Branch Office, Motihari, P.o. +P.S. Motihari, District-East Champaran. 51. Dharmendra Kumar, son of Jairam Yadav, resident of Village-Thatia, P.O.-Jasouli, P.S.-kathaiyan, District-Muzaffarpur. 52. Rakesh Kumar Yadav son of Jagdeo Prasad Yadav, At & P.O.-Sarsi, P.S., District-patna. 53. Ram Babu Prasad son of of Ram Chandra Prasad, resident of Village- Gandak Colony No., Q. No. D/15, near ITI College, Motihari, P.S.- Town Thana Motihari, district-East Champaran. 54. Kumar Neerab son of Vijay Kumar Singh, East Indra nagar, P.O. Lohia Nagae, P.s.-Kankarbagh, District-Patna. 55. Dilip Kumar son of Dhaneshwar Soni, resident of village-maniswari Chowk, Near Gayatri Shakti Pith, P.O.-Jamui, P.s.-Jamui, District- Jamui. 56. Jainendra Kumar Jha son of Tara Kant Jha resident of Barsam, Villgage+P.O.-Harsam, P.S.-Rudrapur, District-Madhubani. …….Petitioners/Appellants. Versus 1. The State of Bihar through its Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, Old Secretariat, Patna. 2. The Director General of Police, Government of Bihar, Old Secretariat, Patna. 3. The Bihar Staff Selection Commission through its Secretary, Government of Bihar, Veterinary College, Patna. 4. The Chairman, Staff Selection Commission through its Secretary, Government of Bihar, Veterinary College, Patna. 5. Prashant Kumar Roy, Son of Shri Rajendra Prasad Roy, Resident of 91, Nirala Nagar, Digha Ghat, Patna. 6. Pramod Kumar, son of Shri Seodani Sharma, Resident of Village- Dadpur, P.O. Bauri Beldari, P.S.-Hulasganj, District-Jehanabad. 7. Rakesh Ranjan, Son of Shri Shiv Kumar Singh, resident of B/28, Vasishtah Colony, Hanrichak, Anisabad, Patna. 8. Santosh Kumar Singh, Son Shri Mukhtar Singh, Resident of Road No. 13’B’ New Bahadurpur, Rajendra Nagar, Patna. 9. Amit Kumar, Son of Late Binod Kumar Das, Resident of Village+ P.S.- Salkhua, District-Saharsa. …….Respondents/Respondents. With LPA No.524 of 2009 Surya Mohan Jha, S/o Naw Kant Jha, R/o Village-Gerabari, Korha, P.O.- Korha, P.S.-Korha, District-Katihar. Petitioner/Appellant. Versus - 8 - 1. The State of Bihar through its Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, Old Secretariat, Patna. 2. The Director General of Police, Government of Bihar, Old Secretariat, Patna. 3. The Bihar Staff Selection Commission through its Secretary, Government of Bihar, Veterinary College, Patna. 4. The Chairman, Staff Selection Commission through its Secretary, Government of Bihar, Veterinary College, Patna. …….Respondents/Respondents. ----------- For the Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s): Mr. Siddharth Pd. Adv. : Mr. Chakradhari Sharan Singh, Adv. For Respondent/O.P. Nos. 1 &2: Mr. Ram Prasad Singh, A.C. to AAG-I : Mr. Md. Anis Akhatan, A.C. to AAG-10. For Respondent/O.P. Nos. 3 & 4 : Mr. P.K. Shahi (AG) : Mr. S.S. Sundaram, Adv. : Mr. Vipin Kumar, Adv. ---------- 05. 07.07.2009 Heard the parties. The order under appeal in these appeals are very short. The writ court has dismissed the writ petitions from which these appeals arise by holding that the petitioners/appellants lack bona fide and they have filed these cases after final adjudication by this Court regarding the correctness and legality of the appointment process in relation to recruitment to the post of Sub Inspectors by a judgment and order by this Court dated 25.11.2008 in the case of Jay Shanker Prasad & Ors Vs. The State of Bihar & Ors along with analogus cases reported in 2008 (4) PLJR 825, only because after the adjudication when the fresh results were published, these petitioners again remained unsuccessful. On behalf of appellants it has been submitted before - 9 - us that the model answers which were found defective and revised by experts as per decision of the Bihar Staff Selection Commission (hereinafter referred to as the Commission) did not take care of all wrong answers in the model answers. According to appellants some model answers still remained defective and therefore fresh team of experts should be appointed by this Court to revise the model answers so that the marks allotted to candidates leading to revised results already published may further be revised. Learned counsel for the appellants have tried to explain as to why the writ-petitioners/appellants did not interfere or intervene in the earlier writ petitions which were decided by judgment and order dated 25.11.2008 which has attained finality, by claiming that model answers were called for by this Court in those cases but were kept in sealed cover and were inspected only by some of the counsels under the permission to the Court and hence the writ- petitioners/appellants were not in a position to know the contents of the model answers so as to challenge any error therein. Their stand is that subsequently the model answers were obtained by them through Right to Information Act and only thereafter they could scrutinize and find out defect or errors in some more answers. - 10 - On the other hand, learned Advocate General has submitted that the result of the recruitment tests were initially published on 30.05.2008 and immediately large number of writ petitions were filed in this Court in the month of June 2008 or soon thereafter. Those cases were made analogus and after hearing the grievances raised on behalf of unsuccessful candidates in respect of model answers and question papers this Court permitted the parties to file affidavits, even called for the production of question papers and model answers in sealed cover. As per request made on behalf of the writ- petitioners in those cases, some of the Counsels were given opportunity to look into the question papers and model answers and on the basis of their inspection further facts were brought on record through affidavits and supplementary- affidavits. The Court hearing those cases decided in favour of stand of the Commission that selected experts should look into the question papers and model answers and on their recommendations model answers may be corrected or modified. It is not in dispute that even the name of the experts were disclosed to the Court through affidavit and no objection was taken in respect of names of the experts. The recommendations of the experts were accepted by the - 11 - Commission leading to revision of model answers in respect of various model answers in different subjects. Those questions which were found to be the affected by wrong model answers were excluded from consideration and the total marks were re- allocated against remaining questions. The re-evaluation was done in the light of such revised actions and on that basis, the writ petitions were finally disposed of by the judgment and order dated 25.11.2008 in the case of Jay Shanker Prasad & Ors. Vs. The State of Bihar & Ors. analogus cases noticed above. Learned Advocate General has objected to entertaining the writ petitions giving rise to these appeals mainly on the ground that the issues relating to correctness of the question papers and model answers was considered in detail by writ court after hearing all the parties including unsuccessful candidates like the writ petitioners in those cases. It was further pointed out that from the averments made in CWJC No. 2023 of 2009 which has given rise to LPA No. 305 of 2009 it will transpire that writ-petitioners No. 1 to 25 were parties to earlier writ petitions challenging the original result. According to learned Advocate General there is no private right involved in these cases and the only main issue is fairness and legality of the competitive examination held for the - 12 - purpose of recruitment to public office of Sub Inspectors of Police. Since large number of persons had filed several writ petitions and all similar grievances had been considered by the Court on earlier occasion, the judgment which has attained finality must be respected by all, more so when on that basis the recruitment process has already been completed and the selected candidates have joined and are undergoing training. He highlighted that affected party can always find out experts having difference of opinion on answers. We have given our anxious consideration to the grievances raised on behalf of appellants and to the submissions advanced on behalf of State and the Commission. We are in agreement with the submissions advanced by learned Advocate General that the issues raised in these cases are same which have been considered and decided in the case of Jay Shanker Prasad & Ors. Vs. The State of Bihar & Ors. and other analogus cases. Merely because one or the other unsuccessful candidate obtained copies of model answers later, that would not keep alive the cause of action to challenge the fairness of a selection process in respect of public office again. The unsuccessful candidates including some of the appellants who were parties earlier had full opportunity to raise all facts and issues of law before the writ court which decided the case - 13 - of Jay Shanker Prasad & Ors. Vs. The State of Bihar & Ors. and other analogus cases. It would be contrary to public policy to allow successive writ petitions by different individuals to challenge same or similar issues relating to recruitment by the Commission through open competitive examination. Even if some of the present writ-petitioners had not been parties to the earlier cases, their interest was sufficiently represented by other unsuccessful candidates and the issues decided after contest having attained finality must be respected and the parties must be held bound by the principles of resjudicata, constructive resjudicata and issue estoppel. In the academic world experts may continue to differ endlessly but the Courts have to bring a lis of present nature to finality of adjudication and that has already been done in accordance with law. For the aforesaid reasons, we find no good ground to interfere with the orders passed by the writ court. The appeals are therefore dismissed but without costs. Vikash/- (Shiva Kirti Singh, J.) (Anjana Prakash, J.)