1 1 7 9 65 A 9 r 10 k OF 2008etce 1 1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARHe e 7 Ill DATE OF DECISION2 20 0502011 leCWP Noe1197of2009 t4 j m NiranjanSingh Ir OeePetitioner I 1 0 0 RSUS I StateofHaryanaand others C5 e e I 2CWP N003584of2008 P4 Z Neha Yadav 1 m OeePetitioner I VERSUS t The State ofHaryanaand others Z 00 3eCWP Noe97380f2009 v Sandeep SinghSihagand others mwo Z eeePetitioners 7l CL VERSUS Stateof Haryanaand others 1 J4eCWPNoe271of2010 m BaljinderSingh eeePetitioner VERSUS StateofHaryanaand others e e 1 a 41 5 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document r 1 66 11 9 11 4 1 1 1 19 CWP N003584OF 2008etc 2 1 5eCWPNoe16118of2009 il 1 Pradeep Yadav OeePetitioner 1 VERSUS StateofHaryana and others Ill 1C 6eCWPNoe15455of2009 11 1 1 0 Sanjeev Tinjan 1 0 eeePetitioner I C5 I VERSUS c StateofHaryana and others Z w 7eCWPN001822of2009 C V Arvind Kumar eeePetitioner 3 1 Z VERSUS C StateofHaryana and others a7 Z 8eCWP Noe20315of2008 1 Qm Abhishek GoyaI and others eeePetitioners VERSUS StateofHaryanaand others 1 4we 9eCWPNoe21821 of20081 Mukesh Yadav eeePetitioner 1 VERSUS 1 Il ep Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 67 01 e P CWP N03584 OF 2008etce 3 State of Haryanaand others r e e 100CWPNo1236 of2009 b Nitin PratapSingh 11 eeePetitioner VERSUS m State ofHaryanaetce tr e e 1 0 0 I CORAM C5 HONBLE MRJUSTICE PERMOD KOHLI I Z PRESENT Mrajiv Atma Ram SrAdvocate with r Mrlllikhil ChopraAdvocate 2 MrRK Malik SrAdvocatewith 6 MKohel Dev Advocate I 4 C1 MrJK Sibal SrAdvocatewith Z Msl4anmeetKaur Advocate ClO MrPuneet GuptaAdvocate MrPankajJain Advocate Ymw Z MrJatin Salwan Advocate Qw Il MrDheerajChawla Advocate P 1 MrPuneet GuptaAdvocate MrHakam ManujaAdvocate 1 MrlCarminderSinghAdvocate MRKS Brar AddIAG Haryana with SingAAAG Haryana 1 l Permod Kohli Je 1 Petitionersin all thesepetitions are Law Graduates Reliefs claimed 4 5 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 1 68 1 CWP N003584OF 2008etce 4 4 r beingidentical thesepetitions are being of by this common t Facts relevant for the purpose of thesepetitionsare being noticedhereminafterl HighCourt of PunjabandHaryanaissuedbrochurein theyear 2007 1 for recruitmento HaryanaCivil Service 1 This brochurecontainedall necessaryandrelevantdetailsrelating 1 C to eligibilitycriteria datefor modeand I k 0 method of selection syllabus andothernecessaryconditionsThese details 0 arenot beingreferredto the same beingnot germaneto the of C5 the issuesinvolvedin thesepetitionsApartfrom detailsrefenedto above I numberof vacancles to be filled in tluough theprocess of Z selection are containedin the brochureSincethe numberofvacanciesls a 0 relevantfactor for the purpose of deciding thesepetitionsthe same are being here under1 Z Availablenumberofvacant posts 34 Ol detailsare as underl 1 r 7 e Category e Remarlcs Z 1 General 16 Om 2 Scheduled Castes of9 Out of these 2 vacancies are Haryana beingadvertisedfor the third time 3 Backward Classes of 5 Inclusiveof 2 carried forward Haryana vacancies which are being advertised for thesecondtime 4 ExeServicemen of 1 1 eenv Haryana 1 n 1 1 i 0 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 69 1 1 1 CWP N003584OF 2008etce 5 SVoe Cory NoeofPosts Remwks t 5 Physically 3 Including2 carried forwards vacancies which are being advertisedfor the third time In case of of suitablecandidatesagainstany or both vacancies then these 1 1 vacanctes will be filled up from amongst the suitablecandidates belonging to the categoryof Exm servicemanandAlrtherin case of of suitable 1 candidate9belonging to the CC category of Exeservicementhen thesevacancieswill be tluown 1 1 0 upon to the generalcategory111 tenns of Govemment 1 0 instructions contained in letter I No415191e3GSIII dated Ca9 2211991 P It is alsoprovided in the brochure that in addition to 34 vacant f Z posts20 vacancies are beingadvertisedas per the I W of the Honble Court in Malik Mazhar Sultan VSeUePe Public lr 6 ServiceCommissionand others 20061 9 Supreme Court Cases507and 1 t 2008 VIII SCC 7030 details of these vacancies are as Z underl rlo 44 7 Z SreNo Category Noe osts 1 General 12 Om 2 ScheduledCastesofHaryana 4 3 BackwardClassesofHatyana 1 e 1 4 ExServicemenof Haryana 2 5 Physically oOrtholof 1 Haryana 1 It was also stipulated thatnumberof vacanciesmay vary Selection was to be made on the basis of 6i examination 6iilMainexaminatioI iiiVivroce It is admiuedcase ofthe 4d Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 1 1 70 4 1 1 1 an4 A r CWP Noe3584OF 2008etc 6 1 parties that all the appliedwithin period ARer 1 the examinationtheywere to appearin the 1 main examinationand vivamvocevide notiflcationdated3022008 Final 1 Il result generallnerit listl was issued on 1322008 6exure Pe71 Thereafter on the basis of the recommendationsmadeby the Selection 4 Committee were madebytheGovemment videMemo dated 1 1r 132008 exure Pe8l The could not be Il i 0 Names ofthe were enteredin the concemedregister 1 0 I rnaintainedat HighCourt t5 1 Thecategorywise status ofthe is as underl I SVoe Nameofthepetitioner CWPNOe Category f Z le NehaYadav 35840f2008 BackwardClass r 1 2 one9 C 2 NiranjanSingh 1197of2009 General 4 oneo I 3 SandeepSinghSihagMohit 97380f2009 General 4 L Sondhi GagandeepSingh h one IZ Garg e 4 Pradeep Yadav 161180f2009 General 00 onel 5 Sanjeev Tinjan 15455of2009 General ea Z 6onel 6 Baljinder Singh 271of2010 General 1 Om 60ne9 7 Arvind Kumar 18220f2009 General 6one9 8 Abhishek Goyal Neeraj203150f2008 General Goyal Nitin Mittal and 6fourl Surender 1 e4e 9 MukeshYadav 218210f2008 BackwardClass onel 10 Nitin PratapSingh 12360f2009 General onel Totall Generall 12 BC 2 In view of their nonmselectionsome of the petitioners claimed their 1 selection and byflling However receiving no 44 1 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 71 1 4 CWP N03584 OF 2008etce 7 1 jh to such these writ petitions have been Oled 1 claimingfollowing reliefsl Xxx Xxx XXX thenature of mandamusdirecting the 1 a wrlt ln to considerand appointthe as 4 Civil Judge in the HaryanaCivil Services m Judicial in pursuanceto the selectionconducted 1 0 by it the result of which has been declared vide 1 CaO 1 I Annexure P6 with effect from 1322008 when other C5 1 similarly situatedselectedin the same processhavebeen I selectedand and gmntall reliefs Z 1 that flow thereom includingsenioritypay fixation 2 arrearsofpayalongwith interestetc 13 t I The are claimingtheir on the 1 Z following 1 1 iJOutofsix postsadvertisedfor Backward Class 5 actual4 l 4 W5 onlythreepostshavebeenfilled in thefust instancevidenotificationsdated E 0 1322008 and 1432008 1 1 ii 12 personshave been on regular basisas AdditionalDistrict Judges whereasfive personswere appointed as Additional District Judges on ad hoc basis for the Fast Track Courts in Haryana whereasfive notied 1 1 1 vacanciesfrom ScheduledCaste remain unOlled 1245422 6iioOn21112007 65 postsofCivil JudgesorDivision were created by the which inter alia includessix postsfor Backward Class and 1 13for ScheduledCastecandidates iv9Asagainst 13 advertised vacancies for ScheduledCaste onlyfive have 90 1 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 7 72 94 CWP Noe3584OF 2008etce 8 been 611edand 9 vacancies could be utilised for 1 from the Backward Class categorycandidatesin view of the govemment lnstructions dated 1781976 which inter alia provides for I ll of reservedcategoryvacancles lll the event of of candidatesfrom a reservedcategoryIn this case 9 Scheduled 1 Caste categoryvacancies were to be utilizedfor of Backward e r Class candidatesdue to of ScheduledCastecandidates Il 0 of five before 311 02008 and one candidate 0 r I from BackwardClass on 17A2009 61Resultantvacancies t5 1 on account of arealsoto be filled in on the basisof the same selectione 1 Z 1r It is contendedon behalfofthe thatall the availableposts 1 C arerequired to be filled in on thebasisofselect list dated1322008 in Vlew 1 I of the Honble Court in the case of Malik Mazhar 1 Z Sultan upral The have giventhe detailsof the vacancies f filled in and availablevacanciesunder variouscategories as underl 1 2 3 4 me Z NoofPosts advertised PostsFilled by Balance vacant posts Selection 1 General 1612 28 Postsfllled up Balance vacant posts 1 e il Posts advertisedfor ScheduledCaste exure I 13 Posts fllled upl 5 1 Balance vacant 8 iil Posts advertisedfor BackwardClasses 1 P5 54191 6 611 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 73 e5 4 CWP N003584OF 2008etc 9 r r Postsfilled up 3 1 Balanceremaining vacant 3 iiil Members ofScheduledCaste 1 Il in 2008 5 1 Membersofthe BackwardClass in 2008 3 m 1V Postscreatedon 21 112007 65 C 1 General 0 ScheduledCastePosts 13 0 r BackwardClassposts 6 9 1 Thus total number of vacancies available for membersof the 1 Z ScheduledCasteandBackwardClasses are as underl Ir General S ScheduledCasteCategory 26 I 1 C BackwardClass 12 Z Petitioner namelyNeha Yadav in CWP N03584 of 2008 submits m that she is at Srlllo10 in the list of BackwardClassCatgorycandidates 7 Z andafter ofthree candidatesfrom this categoryshefigures at Qm Srlllo7 next in the order ofmerit 1 It is stated that out of 54 advertisedposts634eactual and 20 only 34 have been made ln the following mannerl 1 e General 23 ScheduledCaste 5 1 Backward Class 6 Duringthe of thesepetitions vanous were made in Vlew events on thebasis ofthe 61nher 4 1 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 74 A 0 1 1 CWP N003584OF 2008etce 10 additionalaffidavitshavebeen filed on boththesides On the P basis of the additional information five resignedbefore 1 31102008andone MrLoveleen on 172009 Their havebeen evidentfrom theaffidavitdated29A008 filed 1 ll 8S 1S by NehaYadav It is Airtheralleged thatHighCourt decidedto 4 apPOlMone MonaSinghcandidatenext in theorderof meritvide decision 1 oftheCommitteedated 172008 on the basisofher meritin the selection 9l 1 0 from GeneralCategoryOn 522009 the HighCourt passedfollowing 0 r interimorderin CWP N03584 of20081 1 C 1 Adjoumed to 262009 I In the meantimetwo postsof HCS JudiciaOshall be t4 1 Z 1 keptvacant It is furthermadeclear that it would not be 1 C open to the to takethepleaofthe selectlist 4 having expired dueto effluxoftime 91 C Z There are four 111 CWP No20315 of 2008 all from r GeneralCategoryThey are at SrlllosA2 to 45 in the merit list dated 7 1312008 It is statedthat GeneralCategory candidatesuptomerit noAO Z stands and Mona Singhwho was next in the merit at 1 SrllloA l also stands One candidatenamelyArvind Kumar in CWPNo1822 of2009 belongs to GeneralCategoryand figures at Sr030 in the merit list It is alleged that candidates from SrlllosA2 to 45 are writ 1 in CWP N020315 of 2008 whereascandidateat SrlVoA6 has e not the Cour Candidateat SrlIToA7hasjoinedPunjabCivil Services Judicial Branchlwhereas candidates at SrlllosA8 and 49 to BackwardClass Categorystand vide notificationdated 142008 and this is next in the merit in W 4 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 75 0 1 S r CWP N003584OF 2008etc 11 General Petitioner Pradeep Yadav in CWP No16118 of 2009 t who alsobelongs to General falls at SrNo63 in themeritlist In CWP No738 of2009 thereare three namely Singh 1 4 Mohit Sondhiand Singh to General They standat SrlllosA32 267 and 128 in the 6nal result lot the meritlistl PetitionerNirmjanSinghin CWP No 1197 of 2009 1 0 to General is at Srlllo79 in the merit list Petitioner Mukesh 1 0 Yadav in CWP No21821 of2008 to BC is at SrllTo11 0 r I Petitioner BaljinderSinghin CWP No71 of 2010 to General 5 1 is at SrNoA7 in the final selectlist PetitionerSanjeevTinjanis I GeneralCategory candidate His merit position is not reOected r Z 1 Recruitmentto theHCS JudicialServiceis govemed and by rules namelyPunjabCivil Services Haryana 6 I Rules 1951 including the amendmentsmadebythe StateofHaryanaBy 1 t3 Z virtue of an amendmentnotiflcation dated2332007 Punjab Civil Services CO Judicial Branch9Rules 1951 were amended 34 postsof Civil Judges a OrDivisionlyingvacant were to be Slled up throughspecial recruitment Z on the recommendationsof the SelectionCommitteeconstitutedfor the 1 1 Om purposeThe Selection Committeewas constitutedunder the rules comprising ofl 9three Judges of the HighCourt of Punjaband Haryana nominatedbythe Honble theChief Justice of whom theseniormost has 1 ea bethe chairman i the Chief Secretmy to Govemmentof Haryanaand to 6iiilthe AdvocateGeneral Haryanaand four legalremembrancersand Secretaries to Government of Haryanaand Legislative All other provisions in the existingrule regardingeligibilityage educational conduct of examinationetc were to remain same Part B of 1 4ir Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Il P 76 4 CWP N003584OF 2008etce 12 1 the originalrulesdeal with the submissionof whereasPart C t dealswith the examinationof candidatesRule 80f Part D was amended to the of theHonble Court in MaIik Mazhar 1 1 Sultatsuprale AmendedRule readsas underl 5ln the saidsaid Rules in partDm ilforrule l thefollowing ruleshallbe substituted m 1 1The names of candidates selectedby Govemmentfor as 1 1 0 Civil JudgesuniorDivisionlunder rule 10 and 11 ofthe Pan C shall be 1 0 I enteredin theHighCourt Register in the order of selectionto theextent of 9 i 30Iomore than the advertisedvacancies so as to meet any for I theadvertisedpostremaining unfilled for any reason Il r Z l 1 iilrule8 shallbeomitted n l replieshave been 81edbythe Stateand on behalfofthe High S I Cou Whileadmitting the vacanciesnotied through the brochure 1 Z and creationof65 vacanciesduringthe ofthe writ petitions 1 OO theonlycontentionraisedbytheStateis thatall unOlledvacancieson mwo of the selection process and after Z advertisementare to be advertisedagainto enable all eligible Qw candidatesto applyand seektheirconsiderationfor It is 8lrther statedthatthe grievance madeby the has no legal basisHighCourt also Sled a shortafdavit One ofthe pleasraisedis 1 aV thatvacancies more than the advertisednumber cannot be filled To this contention learned counselfor the Staterelies upon the in Virender SinghHooda and others vse StateofHaryana and another 200511 RSJ 700Affidavit filed on behalf of the High Courtrevealsthat out of 54 advertisedvacancies 53 stand W Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 77 1 4 CWP N03584 OF 2008etce 13 r filed up and one posthas been reservedwhich is subjectmMterof 1 CWP No5130 of 2007 Referring to the of Honble Apex Courtin Malik MazharSultan ipral thestandofthe HighCourt t tl 1S that in with the ordersof the Court 20 vacancies were advertisedand havealso been Slled u 41 Furtherstandof theHighCourt is that mere selectiondoes not create a 1 Q rightin favourofthe 1 0 Due to certain the vacancy positionwhich inter 0 r alia also includes the new creations and 8esh t etc this Court passed an order dated32009 seeking information8om the HighCourt in respectof the pointsindicated Ie Z therein the sameshall be referredto Pursuant to the 1 1 aforesaiddirectionstheHighCoun Sled af6davitdated 1892009 of 6 X VirinderAggarwalRegistrar7ules Punjab andHaryanaHighCoun 9 C Z pointvvisereplycontainedin the affldavitis as followsl QO Point General 42 7 vacancyposition on the ScheduledCaste 39431 Z dateof issuanceof fresh 24 t 1 Om 2341 advertisement datedBackwardClass 02 1 1412008 for HaryanaExaserviceman 06 PCS oludiciall 1 Physically 04 44w Orthol Total 78 7444 1 1 b 4 1 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 1 78 1 4e CWP N003584OF 2008etce 14 r IPoint iilwhetherany unfilled No unfllled vacancy arising out of t advertisement notificationdated2332007 1vacancy from the earlier selection was includedin the fresh advertisement ansmg out of advertisement dated1482008 1 4 notificationdated 2331007 was includedin the fresh advertisement if so the numberof such vacancies 1 CC with 1 1 0 CO I Point Noioaiter filling 54 OneGeneralCategory vacancyaccruedon 0 account of joiningof Shri Sushant I advertisedvacancies whether any in the cadre of PCS OBI on 1 Z vacancy became available as 3f020088 more candidatesalso dropped Out vacancy on accountof fromthepostofCivil JugeJrDivn in the if so 1 or cadreofHCS 0B1 which are as followslv I 9 number of such vacancies with Z break up QO m3 SVoe Nameofthecanes Category belongs to Date of Z SIShrVMse bythe Hmyana Govta 1 Om 1 ParshantSharma General 24102008 2 JatindraSingh General 242008 3 Monika Saroha General 24102008 1 eeme 4 ChetnaSingh General 2102008 5e Lovleen BC 282009 1 6 GomatiManocha General 28009 7 EektaGauba iGeneral 20772009 1 4 1 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 79 44 P CWP N03584 OF 2008etce 15 SreNOe Nameofthecandidmes Category belongs to 1 SlShril bythe Hmyana Govte 8 Dheeraj Mor General 192009 1 Ilj 1 1 Point Noivwhether the vacancles Pursuantto the decision of the selection mentioned in iio above and Committeeof the High 1 C Court dated2882008 Ms Mona Singhat were fllled up themanner anddates 1 6 0 SrllToAl of the select list of HCS JB 40 of with details of the from the GeneralCategory W8S appointed r I candidatesand the to t5 bytheHaryana Govemmenton 172009 1 which theybelong 1 Z rr Point 65 additional65 Postsof Civil JudgeJrDivision9 were 1 created during the createdby the HaryanaGovemmentvide b vacancies I letterdated21112007 These postswere of the first selection 4 C3 notifiedin the fresh advertisementdated Z initiated in the year 2007 were 142008 CO notified for fresh selection vide I7 advertisement dated 1492008 Z detailsthereof 1 t Om Category wise break up of thesevacancies Numberof Posts General 41 1 ScheduledCaste 20Io9 13 e BackwardClass 10Iol 06 Exeserviceman05Iol 03 Physically Ortho903Io 02 1 13 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document r 80 1 4 CWP N003584OF 2008etce 1 16 r Numberof Posts In Total 65 i 1l Point NoVI Retiree Promotions from PromotionsDeath ment 2312007 to ARer 1480081 142008 41 NIL Ge 6 One vacancy 9 accruing due due to the 1 Total 16 Sc 4 G 8 death of Ajay 0 to Generale 9 BC 3 Kumar BC 1 retlrement Aggarwal SC 3 on 0 1452008 0 death BC 2 General reSlgllatlon Category I etc after the 0 I of the process of selection 1 Z initiatedvide m Notification 1 1Z dated S 2322007 I category wise9 1 Z In the affidavitof MrAggarwal the number of vacancies becoming 0 availablewere not specifledclearlythoughdetailsof were 5 givenThus vide orderdated12102010 a uer directionwas issuedto Z 1 the HighCourt to file fresh affldavit givingdetails of the vacancies 1 r 1 availableon account of retirement and death of HCS JudicialBranchlbetween the date of advertisementdated 2332007to 682009 dateof issuance of next select list In responseto 1 ee this direction an additionalafOdavithas beenflled byJoint OSD Punjaband HmyanaHighCourt with the followingdetailsof the vacanciesduringthe aforesaidperiod as underl Srl Vacanciesbecameavailable Numberof vacancies 1 On account of promotionof HCS OB 35 Officersl 611 1 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document ee 81 1 9 p CWP N003584OF 2008etCe 17 Sro Vacanciesbecameavailable Numberofvacancies 1 2 Dueto of HCS 0 Offlcers 10 3e Dueto deathofHCS CJBIoftlcers 01 1 il 4 Dueto retirement Ol 1 It has come on record in theafSdavitofGovemmentofHaryana 61ed 1 in CWP No1197 of 2009 that all the 54 vacancies notified vide 1 0 advertisement issued in the year 2007 havebeen filled up in two phases ie Co r I 1322008 and1432008 in thefollowing mannerl 1 Category Vacancy Actual vacancies Posts filled Posts Olled Total I shownin the that were availableupin thefirst up in the advertiseme on reconciliationphase 1 second phase nts with the datamade 1322008 ie 1432008 1 Z available by the Honble HighCourt m L 19 21 639 41 59 669 I Cneral 28 29 23 17 40 1 Z Scheduled 13 11 5 5 Castes r Backward 6 9 3 6 9 Classes n Z Exe 3 2 1 servicemen 1 Qm Physically4 3 d persons Total 54 54 31 23 54 1 1 Result of 2007 advertisementwas declaredon 1322008 whereasthe result of selectionfor which advertisementwas issued on 142008 was declared on l 72009 and the select list notified on 682009 The entire argumentof the is based upon of 6 1 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 82 0 1 1 4 r CWP N003584OF 2008etCe 18 Malik Mazhar Sultalsupral While the eligibilityof the r to Judicial servicein the Stateof UP Honble Coun 1 issued certaingeneraldirectionsto all the StateGovemmentsUTs and the 1 Higll Courts These directions are contained lIl 23 of the whichreadsas underl 4 231t is necessaryto evolve a mechanism to speedily m determineand tlll vacanciesof Judges at all levels For this purpose 9 0 timelystepsare required to be takenfor detenninationof vacanciesissue Cd0 of advertisement examinationsinterviewsdeclarationof the I C5 final resultsandissueof ordersof For all theseand other 1 I stepsif any it is necessaryto providefor Oxedtime scheduleso that systemworks and there ts no delaylll flllingup of 1 Z m vacancies The datesfor takingthese stepscan be providedfor on the pattem similar to filling of vacancies in some other I services or fillingof seats for admissionin medicalcolleges 1 Z The schedule to the medical rlo admissionssets out a time schedule for every stepto be 7 strictlyadheredto every year The can be provided Z for where sufflcientnumber of vacancies do not occur in a 4 givenyear The adherenceto strict time schedulecan ensure timelyfillingof vacanClSSe All StateGovemmentsUnion Territories andlor HighCourts are directed to providefor time G 1 schedule for the aforesaid purposes SO that every year vacancies that may occur are timely filled All State Governments Union Territories and HighCourts are directed 1 to file within threemonthsdetailsof the timescheduleso Sxed and date from which time schedule so flxed would be rl 1 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document r 83 1 1 b14 P CWP N003584OF 2008etce 19 t In response to the directionscontained someof the State Courtsmade Takingnote ofsuch theHonble Supreme Court in Malik Mazhar SuItane2 1 Il supral issued vanous directions by flxing time schedule for r holdingtheexaminationsetc at differentlevels lll the of subordinatejudicial 1 respectof the High service in 11e CourtsIUTs For the purpose of the presentwnt petitiondirections111 respectof to the post of civil Judge0rDivisionl only 0 C i relevant Such directions containedin 14 and 15 which are C as hereunder 1 1 h 14The select list prepared for all categories ofofficials Z shallbevalid till thenext selectlist is Ve r 15 We hMher direct that ten percent of unforeseen vacancies would be in respectof sanctionedpostsand 08 CJO not vacanciesoccurring in a particular year Apartfrom above petitioners have also refenedto various Z tl other to supportheir contentionthat themerit list preparedby 4 the SelectionCommitteesurvives till thenext selectionandthe candidates nextin themerit are required to beappointed from the select list In the case of GujaratState DyeExecutiveEngineersAssociation 4 1 VeStateof Gujarat19943ISCT theHonble Supreme Court posedthree 6i9what is waitinglistl 6iilcanit be treatedas a source of recruttment from which candidatesmay be drawn as and when necessary 1 and iilhowlongcan it operate2 Answeringthe first questionHonble Supreme Court observed 1 as 9 tk 1 Rawat Seema 2014.04.25 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC, Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 84 b 64a CWP N003584OF 2008etce 20 Pv underl 8A waitinglist ln service