!GH COURT OF <s Shri Hhjriandra MfRhra % J—.-il^t.^..^l^s.: Q M J^l*;——t-l~-,<-—— i ! DE^ StHH K.iM. ^rf5i1urSK5r, <-sJ. Wrlt Petition fC) No.2724 of 2010 \./s 1 ChhsttSQsrh Dsnts! CQIISOS 8:. Research Institute, Yftift'h FnunrSatlnn 'lsy run by nf Inrita fhrnnQh f% A^dmlnlstfstQr. Post l.1 SI U- 'hB^t t <l^» ^ l«.1Itll)]I'U'<iBUC..^-j < •-•T».l uox No.25, Sundra, Nationai Hinhwav/ No ^ Ralnanrin^nn 491 441, Chhattisaam. Stste of Chhsttisasrh. ThrouQh its Prlncipai Secretar^, Heaith ^ F^miiv \A/&lfar'i£> D&nart'm^nf Mantraiaya, Dau Kaiyan Sing'n Rhawan Rajniir 407 nni Chnattisaarh nf Mnriifial P. h hatfi?5rii3rh luihl.lt^y^-tl l t nir<srli'nr?itsi Educst QH through the secretary, Old Nltr<3.p% Mn%fs>| H;=i!E k^afvan 3ingh Compiex Premises, Ra'Dur 492 001 Chhattisaarh. Writ Petition under flrtictes 226 of the Constitution of !nd!a Present: Shri P.S. Koshy with Shri Saurabh Dangi, counsel for the petitioner. Shri IJNS Deo. Govt. Advocate for the State. ('23.02.2011') V.—'—'•——• — — • • / Ths ostt onsr s a Non-,AEd6d Prsvat6 IVI nortv rscocinlzsd insttut on r'hhafl't'aniarh Hpnt?sl nrillffi^pi ^ R?a<a&smh Insfihlt^ sf Rsinandnsnn Rv f'hio npf'innn i'hea nsat-if'innpr hsttt nrav?=ir4 fnr fhfa foEI^A/inn r&tipfQ'- l«/^r u-Illl^ ^.-•—ail.iviljl.Elu- ^•u-l.ll.l^tlUi 1 EWtl^ ^••WL^WUfl IW: l-ti-u/ swrs/r-t; i^| i .-rti vi i^. "I. sliow this writ DstitlQn bv ors.ntlnQ ruis^ !!. issus wnt of msndsmus or ^nv othsr '^^ annrrinrf?t^ u^rlf nrrtpr or rlirpni'irtn^ in ih?1 [ik^ -^'- «'/" ' 1 Si^.^^: l g ^; ^ fA. ....<-^"^-, t Si y-.d,-^"'- --&, g- c^@ nafifrp fh&rohv dlrp^ftnn r^'arsnnd&nt?; fn nprmi+ nfafifinnfftr ^Nnn Alrl^rl Privsf?a MEnnrltv Hpntsl CQ sos^ to admit 100% sssts throuoh its own •*/wr -rf^ •w^f >•>«' wwtltiii. t-ui^lt/ T-.IUT-UK.'B^ fl r viaA^t [ K.-u u- »•t I pntranrl& T?a<£f fnr arl%rl?am|rl vpar 9010-9011 snd onwards to Its MO-S Courss in ths ?nt$r6st nf ii i%tirlia' u-t jl-l-.l.llu.—.; ssu9 writ of Drohib tiQH or snv othsr SDprQprists wrlt ordsr or dlrsctiQns In th£ 1 k© nsturs thsrsbv Qrohibltina r6snQnd6nts frQHi 'apndinn anv ?ioaf<£ so fSr'tV^rnmant nunfst tn MDS CQUFSQ In ostit QH6F fNQH Aided Privsts M|nQr|h/ DSHtsS CoiSOS) fCF SCSdsmlC VSSF 2010-2011 and onw8rds in th8 Intsrsst of lustice; !V Anv othsr ordsr 33 th s HQH'b 6 Court msv rifafsm fif anrl nrnn»r in fhpa fsi^fc snrl clrcumstsncss of ths cass mav slso b9 ssusd in favnifr f^f f'hpt HiafEfinn&r 2. Lsarnsd counssl for th©ostltlonsr subnilt that ths rssoondsnts/Stata Is oomosHinG the orivsts 'nstltutlons to adniit 50% ssats svallsbls In » ths InstitutiQp to th8 studsnts POiTMnatsd bv th9 Ststs QQysrnmsnt undsr th©Q3rb of aovsmment auots. Rsfsrsnos is msds to ths dQoument of Annsxurs-P/S. whsrsbv th© Dlrsctorats Qf Msdlcsl EducstlQn. vlde its memo o'atsd 28.05.2009 addrssssd to t.hs PrinciDs! of th£ InstitutlQH. hss HQmifistsd two csndldstss fQr admissio" in MDS ssats for ths acadsmic ssss'on 2009-2010 3aainst ths totsl c3D3city of fQLEr S63ts JH ths Enstltutlcn, Shri P.S. Koshv and Shri Sourabh Danai. Isarnsd counse! fnr ths petitionsr subrriit that ths qusstion with rsgard to appropriation of nijQtss bv Stats snd snfQrcsmsnt of rftS6ry3tion DQI'CV ]n unald©d mjnQr|fy $dllCation EnSt!tutlQn haS 3Ir98dy b96rt ssttlsd bv th6 HQH bls Runrpms f.niirt in ths matter nf P.A. Maharashtra reported i" 200S (6) SCC S37, wherein, it has bsen hsld thst OQlicv of rssGrystiQH csnnot be snforcsd H such institution bv ths Ststs PQF 2HV QUQtS Or 09rC8HtSQS Qf sdlTliSSiQHS C3P b-9 csrvsd Qut to bs soDFQQfistsd by ths Stats n s m'HQrltv or HQH- HiinQfitv unsldsd sducstlQH instltutlQH. Shrl UNS Deo. iearnsd Qoyt. Advocsts. doss nQt d'SDuts th6 sbovs DreDositlon of 3.w 3id down bv Mon bls Suorsnis CQurt In th©niattsr nf p,A= Inanid^f fsuors^. Howsvsr. hs submlts thst ths Qrivsts and un^idsd m'noritv sducationsi institutiQnai csnpot o'vs s QQ bv to nisrlts n th©msttsr of adm'ss'QH and to thst sxtsnt, ths Ststs csn snsurs thst fhs studsnts are sdmltted strictlv in 3ccord3.nc9 with Hssrd ssmsd counss! for ths Qsrt ss, Ths ciu$st'on bsfors us. csnis uo for cQHsidsrst'Qn bsfors ths HQP bis Sunrff>in& Cnurt in ths matter of P.A, Inanidar fsuora^. snd whils d83!lHQ W th OU^StlOH NQ.I —•Unsidsd sducatiQns nstitut ons^ 3DDrQDnatiQH of Quots bv ths Sts.ts 3nd snfQrcsmsnt Qf ressrvstlon oolicv ~ It hss bssn h$!d as und8f; "132. Our snswsr to the flrst QusstlQrs 's thst HQ'thsr ths Doiscv of rss&p/ation csn bs enforcsd bv ths Ststs nor snv QijQts or osrc©ntaQ&nf sdmissions csn be carvsd out to bs SDDFQQrlst^d bv th9 Ststs In s minoritv or nQn-rTtinorltv unsidsd sducstions! InstltutiQH. MspQritv institutlQns sre frss to admit students of their own cholc-s Lric!i!dinn studsnts of %. R pnm-m pQni'y CQHIHIUPtV 2S 3SQ H^SmbsrS Qf thG F OWP. CQinniuRltv froni othsr Ststss. both to a Simited BXtsnt onlv and not in s rnanner snd to such sn sxtsnt that thsir mlHQfitv sducstions! irKsf'tt'iftinn <si'?ifEie£ i<£ ln<£f (f f'h&v rin <£n thfav lri<sp thn nrnforstinn nf Arl'ir'lo 30/1 ^ 137. Psi FoundstiQn has hsEd that minority unsldsd institutiQns can tsoltlmBtsEy c'alm unfettsrsd fundsmsntal riQht to chooss the studsnts to bs ailnwvgrj sdmlSSlQH and thS 13rOC9dUr6 th9rsf0r6 sub 6ct to Its bslno falr. transDsrsnt snd nQH~ (avnlni't'at'ivp Tho o.amp nrinr^inip ann||?a<£ fn non- rn nnnfy UHSlded HStitUtlOHS. Th9r6 H13V b8 3 sinniffi incst'itittinn imnarfinn a narj-i^EjEar h/np of ^,..yi» ii E^.<..^>.i^E , i..^x,..,,E^ *-. ^w<K..<-^.-.. -Jf' ". educatlQH which Is not belnQ ImDartsd bv snv n^hpr ErKsl'i+iifinn anri havfnrt lt<£ niA/n ?ariml<a<ainn ofQcsdurs fuiflliina ths tsst of bsiuQ falr. trsnsQsrsnt snd HQn-$xpEQftattV6. A!l Inst'tutions smosrtinQ ssms or slmtlar DrQfessionai sducatlQH c-sn oln toQsthsr for hofd no s common 6ntrBn06 test sstisfying the abovesaid triple tests. The -Ststs CBP. aEso DFQV ds 8 Drocsdurs of ho dlno a QQmmQn sntrancs tsst fn ths lnt6r$st of sscurincs fsir snd nisrit bas^d sdmlsslons snd orsvsntlnQ maEsrlminicf'rsafEnn Tho 3Hmi<a<sinn nF'nr'iadu?"?* <sn ssr^ont'^rl hv s nrh/??tft lnc:tihifirin nr nrnE.in nf institutions. if st fssls to sstisfv sll or snv of th6 tr'DJs tssts. Indicstsd hsrsinabQvs, can bs taksn over bv/the Ststs substitutlHQ its own orocsdurs. Th6 sscond Qusstlon is snsw8r©dsccQrdlno!y. Since ths issus raissd bv th©DStltlQper In ths Instant ostltlQn hss alrssdv bssn fins!!v rssolvsd bv ths Hon'bSs Suprsnis CQurt ln th9 msttsr of P.A« !naiTEd8f fsuorsY ws ar^ of ths Qoin'on th3t ths SCQ.DS nf Erifsirfprpnr;p hv fhes <^i'?»tia f^nv&rnnnpnf in i'hp msff&rs nf srtmi^'si^n in ths ostltlonsr institution woufd b& Qovsmsd bv ths sbov6 ludQmsnt nfth& l-inn'h|& Piunrpmo Cniirf' With this Qbssp/^tiQH. ths instsnt Dstition is d SQOssd of. •BVl^:1 ^EKlH^- \^ ^ft^f^stt U'u^tc.aItuKl^ ^Da^rf a :.=•»*»'^-uiait* jur-Ntfui»t-»^ia l-^f •o^a^rf-^-t-F-^/^-fwa •h/a, Sd/- Dhirendra Mishra Judge Sdi- R.N. Chandrakar Judge