1 IHTHEHIGH COURT O? 3UDICATURE AT BIIASPUR, CHHAITISSARH WRIT PETITIOS NO.'^WST^} QF 2002 :it : II 1 PETITIOHER SUDHIR ' TrtfARI,• S/0. SHRI GIRIRAJ 'PRASAD TIItTARI, AGBD ABOHT, 40 YESRS, . FOREST; •RAN6ER, FORESf MANAGEMEMT rNFORMW.ION SYSTEM DIVISION- RAIPUR, .DISTRICT - RAIPUR: (CHHATTISGARH) . • RESPOHDENTS .-^§ •••'• <L^<\~' 1 'S .*' ».^?^ •"'..->'"'• ..••l'.. ^II:^ •i^::v^^ •'i ^^y~ VEKSUS STATE . OF1 CMHATTISGARH, THRQUGH-. PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, GO'VERNWENT ' OF GHHATT.I:SGARH,. DEPARTMENT OF FOREST, RAIPUR (CHHATTISGftKH) . .<>; 1 •" PRINCIPAL CHIEF ::CONSERVATOR OF FOREST ADMISTRATION' , (NON- GAZETTED) , aAILi-'-RQAD, : RAIPUR (GHHATTISGAgi NRIT PETITIOH UNDER ARTICI.E 226 QF THE CONSTITUIOR OF IHDIA-': ^ ^ • ; ' '. . ^ :. : •^".••il •i^.i"; 'i'1: .Y.^-.-i'-- ^•' "/: ll^ <: illliltslHC-l^ IIBI' :i";il".';^i • g^I'fc:t. RMichigi^H; sh^i^^rii^i^ elli 1:>afc. i :1! |!.l Ty. "3N'"iti4frt'it°<W('Lli%Riwi-Hiif i'Wg|'^He 2St8^S)©g; nrwfr %*!!%' sn^iwsw:vfvs 24.01.a003 Shri.MA.Siddigui, couilsel SUn Saitjay K.^graroal, 0y. .forliearirLg on the question of aeS ;couii^el ^ tHe petiMoiier eouasel, the matter is being Tliougli itliis aiatter is^tisted^ adatission, on thei grayer ofileai^ieS and with fhe conseat: of State; disposed of at the adiaissiori staj TBe efaaQenge in this writ^pestttjon is to fhe order dated G4.1Q;20102(Aitaexare P/1) wh^reby the petrtioiier has be6n traasferred Iroia Raipur tq Raigai]h.. As fhe'record uiclicates fhat uiitially ttie petitioner was posfed 97 fi-pai where IIB waa traasferr^d: to Raipur sometime ia fhe year 1997 whfire he^was^woilEili; and ftiUereafter vide order (iafed 1E the Ij'otBst Manageiuent InibrinajtiQil Sysfeni, DivMion Raipur •w^here^Ee jouijed ^oni 22nd Jiily 2( thereaGfcr •the^order of traiisfer ha^ To begiii^.with, it m^?6^ jstafed A^ incidence of service ;aiid persoa ^pEa Iu)lds a tiansffiiable post eaiLQot pbjeotto his transfer asife employer tp deteniune as'to^w^i^-ayarticulareinpl^^ pr shouM not-bc posfed, ?Howev^^Ilere inay-'bc sonle casesjof traiisfer whiGh inay'iie exaHHiie(£ fee fhe cases wlie:re:1a e:|i loy«e has beeil?suBieG:te3jljo frcqueiit fraasfeis or 9ie sla-ausffiE '4iWlfl<il'l:4|tfi?tffi''feI^'<.l"l«i<. ^7 aiPiIlT 31lt?I ^• sr thie pelUioBjer." A;G. fcBfheState. atBagbahraBifhfiyear 1996- as Incharge of Flyiiig Squad ,7.2f)02 lie was transferfed •to )02 aiul withiu fhtee inonlEhs Beeapassed, . . : s^within fhe jurisdictkm ofthe ,::.; •:::'i:.l (3y the CSouTt aiid^these;wpu]&: ji.s";'by.way^6f BsirassineD.t^ ^-^tfy. VM ::?s® illli ?f;:tliiilll • w&^ws jjj 3E2 •ss^ XI-HC-22 ;:3H^a'N6ts; ISjjttSgQiF. St?+11<^:^ff^^ V < 1 Nx.—fi :J;1 ..J' !|lf::';t wa ^^fi:H%g;%^°E[®i'%nSgT flTHelEW*IIW -<RT^I'?RniSR'g1ta:. ftxat ^coiniu£>date;a;paife&lar-;gerso| place from. where that person w^ fhe uicuinl^M who liad jcaiied of fhe previous iucumbent. Intt cases of inala fide or iDfiacttolsi prmciples. Where; tsareer prQspi^t detriiiient is caused, chaUenge to| to be eiitertained.^ Thus flie challi ftie opinaon of fhfi Courf, is tjE^ back^rbund.! :' ' It is fhe case of fhe pefit(' hardly put ia fhree nionfhs at the impugned onfer (Aiulexure] Raipur to Raigadi. i It is ^lso^ petitioa.er has.sUlMiritteda^re] Secretary, Fon;St Depattmeltt| Conservator of Forest, laising not beea considered. The respondents. iaftot eonsideiau.g'Bit fhfi petitioner to approaclnlie^ lufe EoT.lrf In view pf ttte above^llie dispose of tliis writ petition wit}i fhat in case a fresli represeajtat^ fhfi conceEaed Airthoiities witlijja sliaU be consideredt and' disg(S)se^^pf<expgdrfiQuMy ;on|;.|:ts^ —E^ "."•/?i*T->~-i?l,ii cbl^Ifril-I^Writ^ftizt'tRl'yK, ^aiNiTSH^:- ^^by^jbriB.guig luiit'jback^to the -' s tra.nsffiiH'ed^ aa:ul sendtfigiQUt partjcular-place df ttansfer Br'fereiice iaay be Sj'usttfied ia of+ aay proposed? iiomis or :ts reiaain Unaffected aiul -D.O am order oftr'aasfer ought nof iiLge;to aii prder Q£traiisfer,in lae coiisidered ia fhe above Ra|gur oner fhat fhougli tfae; he Iiad jpur, he was shocked tej receive P/l) transfem.iig tijm &QIU ^ted'llliat agamst iys\ti-ansfeT ireseatatioB. to tbc |Pruicipal l'. as. alsb • Princjpal GlHsf ^ievance but tlie. saiaej-has; lactaoB. on the , part ; 6f •'fhje , I ae|presentatiba Iias c0iitpelled' ftrrelief : . , . ^ ;ourf:lfhimKs'it;:apl:)R^natfi'^ ^idirection te ihe'i^s^ndeii^ tir:is.,iiiafie;-by:'(^.^ti,l30lig^: %).| '(:^1.; •^•'4;; ^ V^ |b^:§aays fix!in-ti3i[lay,;ttte;sam;gi V.-:.' •:ir'';:^:: -=- Si^m: ^"Bg'MS »M ^ws '"fl;>ki i;B!^lil^:l ira n E@ M illUMUi? StiiilIS WIKII^ aa 1S ^^FEj IIIINi'lj^ ':1: ^ aKSSBs- XI-HC-22 ^5f '^lijl&lia^d:dty*TS> 'g'SSSWE'S •'sS?SSft!2JB:S 3Ilt?t'?iT Ki-ii.cb 311^ 9h*^<^ ^ff^i v~, inerits on. which fbe Gourt is However, it wffi be open Ao luaiiitaimng status quo tfll such ij Wifh the above observati petitipQ stands disppsed of. Coiis^ aad I.A.No.7850/ 2002 also stan^ *l*lffl''?l-f ifltRff ^ fB»3t^RSR ^? aii^R sn^r not expressiag aiiy opiaion. die Authorities fo consider epresentation is disposed of. bns and directions fhis writ 'quently, M.W.R..NO. 1547/2002 disposed of. ^-^. Sd/- P.C NAIK Judge .^. l»^jo St'y^