IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.9620 of 2009 Nirmala Devi, W/o-Anil Kumar Gupta, R/o-Talibpur, Ward No.14, P.O. & P.S.-Barh, District-Patna. -Petitioner. VERSUS 1. The State of Bihar, through the Principal Secretary, Urban Development and Housing Department, Government of Bihar, Patna. 2. The Principal Secretary, Urban Development and Housing Department, Government of Bihar, Patna. 3. The District Magistrate, Patna, District-Patna. 4. The Nagar Parishad, Barh, through the Executive Officer, Nagar Parishad, Barh, District-Patna. 5. The Chairman-cum-Sub-Divisional Officer, Barh Sub-Division, Barh, District-Patna. 6. Smt. Sulekha Devi, W/o-Sri Arbind Kumar, Ward Parshad, Ward No.24, Barh. 7. Smt. Yasmin, W/o-Md. Manjar Hasan, Ward Parshad, Ward No.11, Barh. 8. Smt. Shakuntala Devi, W/o-Sri Sanjay Kumar, Ward Parshad, Ward No.27, Barh. 9. Sri Shambhu Kumar, S/o-Sri Pratap Kumar Ram, Ward Parshad, Ward No.12, Barh. 10. Sri Subodh Kumar, S/o-Late Kailash Chandra Arya, Ward Parshad, Ward No.23, Barh. 11. Sri Kameshwar Prasad, S/o-Late Raghunandan Prasad, Ward Parshad, Ward No.09, Barh. 12. Smt. Nilu Kumari, W/o-Sri Tanik Sharma, Ward Parshad, Ward No.01, Barh. 13. Mohammad Salim, S/o-Balosardar, Ward Parshad, Ward No.18, Barh. 14. Smt. Sunita Devi, W/o-Sri Sudhir Paswan, Ward Parshad, Ward No.16, Barh. 15. Sri Binoy Kumar, S/o-Late Biranchi Singh, Ward Parshad, Ward No.04, Barh. 16. Smt. Shail Sinha, W/o-Dr. Satendra Kumar, Ward Parshad, Ward No.05, Barh. 17. Sri Mithilesh Kumar, S/o-Late Garmu Ram, Ward Parshad, Ward No.26, Barh. 18. Smt. Bina Devi, W/o-Sri Manoj Kuamr, Ward Parshad, Ward No.13, Barh. 19. Sri Raj Kumar Prasad, S/o-Late Laxmi Prasad, Ward Parshad, Ward No.19, Barh. 20. Sri Gopal Prasad, S/o-Late Chandrika Yadav, Ward Parshad, Ward No.10, Barh. 21. Sri Indra Kumar Singh, S/o-Sri Dinesh Prasad Singh, Ward Parshad, Ward No.06, Barh. 22. Sri Dilip Kumar, S/o-Sri Bhola Rajak, Ward Parshad, Ward No.03, Barh. 23. Sri Shiv Kumar Sao, S/o-Late Gita Sao, Ward Parshad, Ward No.17, Barh. 24. Smt. Laxmi Devi, W/o-Sri Shivnandan Pasawan, Ward Parshad, Ward No.08, Barh. - 2 - 25. Sri Rajiv Kumar, S/o-Late Kaushal Kishore Singh, Ward Parshad, Ward No.07, Barh. 26. Smt. Gauri Devi, W/o-Sri Pawan Mahato, Ward Parshad, Ward No.15, Barh. 27. Smt. Binita Devi, W/o-Sri Manoj Kumar, Ward Parshad, Ward No.20, Barh. 28. Sri Manoj Kumar Sinha, S/o-Shailendra Kumar Sinha, Ward Parshad, Ward No.21, Barh. 29. Sri Sindhu Singh, S/o-Sri Mohan Singh, Ward Parshad, Ward No.22, Barh. 30. Sri Ranjit Kumar, S/o-Prof. Krishna Prasad Singh, Ward Parshad, Ward No.25, Barh. 31. Smt. Sushma Kumari, W/o-Sri Dev Kumar, Ward Parshad, Ward No.02, Barh. Respondent Nos.6 to 31 are the members of the Barh Nagar Parishad, Barh, through the Executive Officer, Barh Nagar Parishad, Barh, P.O. & P.S.- Barh, District-Patna. -Respondents. WITH CWJC No.9621 of 2009 Rajeev Kumar, S/o-Kaushal Kishore Singh, R/o-Chondi, Ward No.7, P.O. & P.S.-Barh, District-Patna. -Petitioner. VERSUS 1. The State of Bihar, through the Principal Secretary, Urban Development and Housing Department, Government of Bihar, Patna. 2. The Principal Secretary, Urban Development and Housing Department, Government of Bihar, Patna. 3. The District Magistrate, Patna, District-Patna. 4. The Nagar Parishad, Barh, through the Executive Officer, Nagar Parishad, Barh, District-Patna. 5. The Chairman-cum-Sub-Divisional Officer, Barh Sub-Division, Barh, District Patna. 6. Smt. Sulekha Devi, W/o-Sri Arbind Kumar, Ward Parshad, Ward No.24, Barh. 7. Smt. Yasmin, W/o-Md. Manjar Hasan, Ward Parshad, Ward No.11, Barh. 8. Smt. Shakuntala Devi, W/o-Sri Sanjay Kumar, Ward Parshad, Ward No.27, Barh. 9. Sri Shambhu Kumar, S/o-Sri Pratap Kumar Ram, Ward Parshad, Ward No.12, Barh. 10. Sri Subodh Kumar, S/o-Late Kailash Chandra Arya, Ward Parshad, Ward No.23, Barh. 11. Sri Kameshwar Prasad, S/o-Late Raghunandan Prasad, Ward Parshad, Ward No.09, Barh. 12. Smt. Nilu Kumari, W/o-Sri Tanik Sharma, Ward Parshad, Ward No.01, Barh. - 3 - 13. Mohammad Salim, S/o-Balosardar, Ward Parshad, Ward No.18, Barh. 14. Smt. Sunita Devi, W/o-Sri Sudhir Paswan, Ward Parshad, Ward No.16, Barh. 15. Sri Binoy Kumar, S/o-Late Biranchi Singh, Ward Parshad, Ward No.04, Barh. 16. Smt. Shail Sinha, W/o-Dr. Satendra Kumar, Ward Parshad, Ward No.05, Barh. 17. Sri Mithilesh Kumar, S/o-Late Garmu Ram, Ward Parshad, Ward No.26, Barh. 18. Smt. Bina Devi, W/o-Sri Manoj Kuamr, Ward Parshad, Ward No.13, Barh. 19. Sri Raj Kumar Prasad, S/o-Late Laxmi Prasad, Ward Parshad, Ward No.19, Barh. 20. Sri Gopal Prasad, S/o-Late Chandrika Yadav, Ward Parshad, Ward No.10, Barh. 21. Sri Indra Kumar Singh, S/o-Sri Dinesh Prasad Singh, Ward Parshad, Ward No.06, Barh. 22. Sri Dilip Kumar, S/o-Sri Bhola Rajak, Ward Parshad, Ward No.03, Barh. 23. Sri Shiv Kumar Sao, S/o-Late Gita Sao, Ward Parshad, Ward No.17, Barh. 24. Smt. Laxmi Devi, W/o-Sri Shivnandan Pasawan, Ward Parshad, Ward No.08, Barh. 25. Smt. Nirmala Devi, W/o-Anil Kumar Gupta, Ward Parshad, Ward No.14, Barh (Chief Councillor). 26. Smt. Gauri Devi, W/o-Sri Pawan Mahato, Ward Parshad, Ward No.15, Barh. 27. Smt. Binita Devi, W/o-Sri Manoj Kumar, Ward Parshad, Ward No.20, Barh. 28. Sri Manoj Kumar Sinha, S/o-Shailendra Kumar Sinha, Ward Parshad, Ward No.21, Barh. 29. Sri Sindhu Singh, S/o-Sri Mohan Singh, Ward Parshad, Ward No.22, Barh. 30. Sri Ranjit Kumar, S/o-Prof. Krishna Prasad Singh, Ward Parshad, Ward No.25, Barh. 31. Smt. Sushma Kumari, W/o-Sri Dev Kumar, Ward Parshad, Ward No.02, Barh. Respondent Nos.6 to 31 are the members of the Barh Nagar Parishad, Barh, through the Executive Officer, Barh Nagar Parishad, Barh, P.O. & P.S.- Barh, District-Patna. -Respondents. ----------- 04 20.05.2010 Mr. S.B.K. Mangalam, learned counsel for the petitioners fairly states that in view of the recent judgment of Division Bench of this Court in the case of Vinay Kumar Pappu & Anr. Vs. The State of Bihar being L.P.A. No.733 of 2010 disposed of on 14.05.2010, the issues having been concluded are against the petitioners. The writ petitioners having participated in the meeting and having lost the confidence of the House by a phenomenal - 4 - margin. The writ petitions merit little consideration. It may also be pointed out that out of the House of 27 members including the petitioners were present, about 15 members voted in support of the no confidence motion and 5 members as against. An issue of improper service of notice was taken up that become meaningless, even if, 6 members out of 27 members had appeared and supported the petitioners. It would have little difference in the result. There being no other issues. The writ petitions are dismissed. Trivedi (Navaniti Prasad Singh, J.)