IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BILASPUR (C.G.) WRIT PETITION No (a ‘3 5* OF 2002 BETWEEN M/s Kedia Castle Delleon Industries Limited company registered under Companies Act, Kedia Nagar, Kumhari. Tahsil & Dist. Durg (C.G.) Through its Director. w PETITIONER V/s 1 State of Chhattisgarh through Excise Commissioner, Mantralaya, Raipur . Som Distilleries, through Managing Director Raisen Madhya Pradesh 3 Welcome Dlstlllerles Bllaspur through Mr Ralendra Jalswai Near Blharl Talkles, Bllaspur (C.G.) RESPONDENTS WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLES 226/227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR WRIT CFRTIORARY MFDAMIIS & ANY OTHFR WRIT DIRFCTION OR ORDER. Particulars of the Petitioner : As stated in the cause title above. Particulars of the Respondents : As ated in the cause title above. W i st XI~HCv22 . ff? Wmxyw.’ ‘ W w .V.’ § \Si../..QQ.. a I ;.. man mm mafa Warn—aiiifgwam WWW amfanm ; ’?-5—"20€§3 Shri Kishore Bhaduri, Ac vocate far the petitioner. Dr. Nix: Shukla, Add}. Advacaze G€ 16191 with Shri Rmlhir Singh, GA. for the respendents No. 1 f State. Shri RDiwakar, Adv, for raspondEnt N0. 2. S’mi Px‘asharit Jayaswai 5116i Shi‘i Manindra $hiivasiava, ' Advocateg, fer 1‘eSp011clelit No. 3. With consent, Imam finéilyunm Qwwchvx ‘N‘Q ““2”“ ~ Both these petitions me regarding caLmiry Sprit m Suiaied bottle for which tendiaL‘S were invitscl and astitioner ail-:1 resgpandents No‘ 3 and 4 submitteé their t6:1gler§5,. Au (Wwd§® 1t is contended by Shr‘ Praéharlt 'Jaiswalréhat their Leudey was iowesi. Howeve: Lheir claim E‘s diepmed by reépandems Ni). 3— Kedia Cae‘ie DeHerm Tndimfrieft, Ltd. and 3’ reepondent N0. 4 Som Distillefies Pvt. Ltd. The contention of yes‘penaeme No. 3 am} 4 is that the petitiegei“ is not eligbie. Shri Prashant Jaiewal conteldec‘i that’ReSpondent No. 3-‘ Kedié; Castle Delle’cn Industrim Ltd. is a eiek induetfv arld it r dees' 11'0t have the ‘requireti’eajoaeity t0 fuiiiH the requirement , ~ of’the tender. He further‘centexkie ’théa’t Sem Distillefi’e'sie'not V ' ‘ 1 . caeable for the work and ie mm. eligible We? Ne. 635/20f ’2 ha; been feed by Eiedia Caet‘ie Delieen 1:;1ustriee’Ltd. agai11e: the. State of Chhattisgarh aim} weW mSpomknt N02 $0111 D§$til§6rie$ anti regpumiemi Na 3— Welcome DiStil}eries, Biiaswu: The petitian Was flied before iSsuaxace of work orb? S1 bs€quem1y {he‘Stam has issuéd work order, of varicus quantmes to Welcome Ind mt; 16$ fox Raigarh, K€dia Castk: Dai‘eon industx‘is5 Ltd. 1%: R mm Keiiia CaSt’ie Delieon lad: sires LK‘L. far Kei‘ba am} 30m Diariiiiarieg for Bi u“ 1:11 Llaih tux, war}: order WilS grailted K {31 amm 2002 lay {mi p“; 5f W90 yams. 111 tha$e cagag, re‘mrzlg havg been filacL Eariierr these H‘ ca$6s W€Y€ listmi on 14—5—2902 and wel'é dil‘ectéd to be listCd af catui HOia/evisr 1 auge 9f 1 LE6 w m‘k aim pghdm 6v, tile¥ ‘ QM liO‘V 11§t€d t"C V 111 ‘ $§€C18_ j, .u €11t1G11 H691‘K1 Oi .‘ ‘ r x \ thaw mama‘s wuuld Laiw 't \ bag Lune . and ' snsumg ‘ Sumumz' {Vacation am Stm‘x‘jng from {2—5—2003 Shri Pia hat Jmswal submitted that the EXCifSe Cemmissionar may b6 ciiracied {o decide {he repi‘asematicn of _the parties w ithin a stipu1a Led Exeriod. Haring coxmidemd the facts 313C} Circuumtancw 0f £116 cage and 11 t nal on 1e I‘d, in the: apimon of this Cam‘L ends of justice W111 be served if a directian is given to the - parties that {hey may eubz’mt repreeeaatatiohs if 5G deeire, Were? XLHC-22 d on Such CammiSSioner Shall dmid€ Eh a period of one month from the (iate of thair representation. It i$ furthor dircctod that durin: / representat .0113 beigg med, he me the F‘Xi‘iee (‘ommmeirnex mthm $0 davx 7mm toay tha ExmSe e sama b‘v‘ a Writtari aréar Within ' and Shajl commue. h‘ iS mado clear that if axisats tooav rggaming Supp}; g thi$ pm‘iod, tho status quo a5 it the decision on the repress. :he partieS still feel aggrieved by aresh. Whh these observation Boforo parting, this Co by the counsel for the partiev. k; view of {he M.W.P5. y C.c. as per ruieS. Eta 1011 meV maV fl‘e wet hen s, the petitions are dieposed of: Lu‘t appreciates t Le efforte matte > and LAS, A an» staeu (Le; esed Sdl- Fakhruddin Judge