I- ^ IN THE HI(3H^(3^.<^JQ©2QK®B&.i^;BILAS]roR(C.Gy WBTT rErmeB'!^^<-;>/e5. „,...«... PEr.ITiaHER ; ABUN HjmRA®»li: LS/Q IATE 1»0»SHYAMAGBSt»L ;D ABCOT 40, .YEABS.iy'e.'SETH B&SftNT IAL SkBG, ABBIIAPO.B (G.G.) o,J^T ^^ w (^ «* .** .^' /'.'* ^^y . Sffi^ES .' . • . . . ; . BESgQffiEMTS; 1. STATE QF aaHi!a-ISQfi,SH.THBajGH-S£CaETftRy, OEmaTBENi .Et • TaftHSp0Br,, aMroa (G.s.) 2. SMTE ^BWSPOar • WimSJ.TY, WkIRJB(C.G . ) . 3. ASSTTA8T SECBETAHY, ST&TE 3'^®SPOHT AOTHOBITY CtaWISGfttt :HJ.& (IG.G). 4. TO(3Eat:gi»ff:feP'SI8GH,B0fc AMgit!a%ia-; (a^.:: : ' •:..:..::/':: • • • 5.:.f 3HBB: •TOWSft.-SINGH 3QS Q^^BSi,.^ >^~^-^sw/. , liiljBi^PBa (©.s.). ^ ' ''^.^S^^^ ^v^'/" ' /,' •/'^-- /:^,:: '^:-?;:^: '' .': .l.',,^':j. WKET .PETiITICH QSBEaABIIGl.E 226 QF G<^ST,ITUTX©K^8K XI-HC-78 *11Nril^TT^ ^SvSf "t<i«irt«,y^l'H'id, firti'dyt UJ1°. 2-))"/ '». 3(l^?TiRqi{'yt^dcg) W^ 200 3II^9TqiT R-tl'* gsii3ii^?ispTOp CTaTW^fei aii^CT 36.8.a005 Shri Santosh. Oupta, cou SIui Yashwaat Singli Th^kur, Govt. Advocate for respondent No. 1 to3, Sh-ri Ajay Shrivastava, co The petitioner laas preferj-ed this petitiou iinder Article 226 of the Constitution of India for issij respondent No,2 fi-oin grantms statal route between the State absence of any receprocal agre^ment In Paragraph No.5.4 of iaspite of the objection fited by| of tempoiary peniiits on tfae in] Daltongunj and on otitier w^ <pi<<f«<DtiitnT'lfls'cl xluit^ix ^3lf^T3II^?I isel for the petitioner. i-uisel for respondent No.4. ance of writ of prohibition restrainiag i. • . . aay stage carri^e penmt on any inter- af Chhattisgarh & State ofJharkhand ia the petitiou. it has been luentioned that tfae petitioner, ffae appUcation.s for grant er-state routes between Ramaaujganj to ates between fhc State of C.G. and Jharkhand are beiag iavited wffhout execution. of reciprocal ^reeiaeirt ia utter defines of law laid dowi^. by the Hon'ble Apex Coiirt. 1 have heard leamed com|isel for the pardes. Leamed counsel for fb^ petitioD.er sybmitted that respondent No.2 is not entifled to invite a^pUcations for grant of temporaiy permit on the iater-statal routes betwlsea State of C.G. & Jharkhand without execution of reciprocal agreeiuejit. On the other haad, Sh4 Sluwastava & Shri Thakur submitted fhat for grant of temporaiy per4ut reciprocal agreenient between ftie two States is not necessaiy. -» la order to appreciate th^ arguiaents advanced by the couasel for thc rcspectivc partiea, ifwe loo|c iato the provisions of sub-section (7) of \ V" a: :«i *iWC9iW^W ycq-yi^lrt^, t»-CTl'M<l<»,Rlril'My-< _;^P ^v^l sn^sTiraw (^ciijci.d) sn^Twl^im aaiTSII^STBqro :<e- STOTSR^feran^r wKifCToli *ii*inYt"feL<II'(ful+dl'( —Z.f~ ^3lf^T3)t^?T Section. 88 of fhe Motor Velucle^ Act, 1988 which. deala witfa the graat of teinporary permit, euvisages th4t; "(7) Notwiftistandiug ar^fhiag contained m sub-section (1), a Regional Traasport ^uthority of one region laay issue a teiuporaiy permit undejr Section 87 to be valid ia aiiofher region or State with th^ concurrence, given generaUy or for ttie particular occas Auflioritv of fhat othel Aufhority offhat other [on, of the Regionfll Traasport r region or of fhe State Traasport States, as the case inay be. Under tfae above provisicfn aRegionaI Transport Authorily ofone rcgion is entitled to graat tem^oraiy permit under Section 87 ofthe Act to be valid ia anofher region (ir State with fhe concurrence, generatfy given or for fhe particular occa|sion, of fhe Regional Transport Aufhority of othcr rcgion of fhat State, temporary permit caa be Thcreforc, fhc oiily rcquireinent is that ited subject to concurrence, given generally or for particular occa|sion by the Regional Traasport Authont? and there is no need for a rec^procal agreenient belween fhe two States and for this view I ain support^id by fhe judginent ofM.P. High Court ia fhc mattcr of Hrudayanaad |Tiwari V». State of M.P. aad otltcrs reported in 2001 (1) M.P.LJ. '(66. In view of the above, tye petition is without any ment, same is liable to be dismissed and it isj accordiagly; dismissed. Sd/- 1..C.Bhadoo Judge SWS;'20p5-20,000 <i-"^ ^f^yc^ 'li fl^1 ^A ^- ^'^