1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO.10899 OF 2009 Union of India and others ...Petitioners v/s Ramchandra N. Menghani ...Respondent Mr Suresh Kumar for Petitioners. Mr S.K. Talsania, Sr Counsel i/b M/s Kanga and Co. for Respondent. CORAM : D.K. DESHMUKH AND A.R. JOSHI JJ. DATE : 20TH JANUARY 2010. 2 P.C. :- 1] The petitioner  Union of India by this petition, challenges the order passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Mumbai Bench allowing the original application filed by the respondent. Basically, the Tribunal has held that both the articles of charges framed against the respondent cannot be held to be proved. Articled 1 of the charge was in relation to possession of assets in excess of known source of income for the period from 26th August 1961 to 31st May 1977. The Tribunal has held that this charge could not be a charge because the difference between the actual amounts found and the known source of income is less than 10 %. The Tribunal has held that if its finding that charge No.1 could not have been framed stands, then charge No.2 which relates to a lesser period and alleges that the respondent deposited in his bank account during the period from 1963 to 1977 amounts exceeding his known source of income could also not be framed against the respondent. We have perused 3 the record. We have gone through the charge-sheet. We find that there is sufficient material available on record to sustain the finding recorded by the Tribunal. The Tribunal has perused the record and has recorded its finding. One more aspect, in our opinion, that is relevant is that the respondent has already retired from service and presently he is receiving pension. In our opinion, therefore, no interference by this Court under its extraordinary jurisdiction is called for. Petition is rejected. Parties to act on the copy of this order duly authenticated by the Sheristedar / Private Secretary of this Court. Certified copy expedited. ( JUSTICE D.K. DESHMUKH ) ( JUSTICE A.R. JOSHI )