IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT : THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE S.S.SATHEESACHANDRAN MONDAY, THE 15TH NOVEMBER 2010 / 24TH KARTHIKA 1932 SA.No. 672 of 1995() -------------------- AS.165/1990 of SUB COURT, QUILANDY OS.37/1985 of MUNSIFF COURT, QUILANDY .................... APPELLANTS/APPELLANTS 2 TO 10 WHO ARE LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES DECEASED 1 ST APPELLANT AND 6 TH DEFENDANT DAMODARA PANICKER 1. VASANTHA, D/O.NARAYANAN, KUNNANKULANGARA HOUSE BALUSSERY AMSOM DESOM, QUILANDY TALUK (QUILANDY.P.O) 2. SACHIDANANDAN, S/O.DAMODARA PANICKER, KUNNANKULANGARA HOUSE, BALUSSERY AMSOM, QUILANDY TALUK 3. SIVANANDAN, S/O.DAMODARA PANICKER, DO.. DO.. 4. JAYANANDAN, S/O.DAMODARA PANICKER, DO.. DO.. 5. SAVITHA, D/O.DAMODARA PANICKER, DO.. DO.. 6. SAVIJA, MINOR, D/O.DAMODARA PANICKER, DO.. DO.. 7. SASIJA, MINOR, D/O.DAMODARA PANICKER, REP. BY HER GUARDIAN NO.1, VASANTHA, DO.. DO.. 8. RAJIJA, MINOR, D/O.DAMODARA PANICKER, REP. BY HER GUARDIAN NO.1, VASANTHA, DO.. DO.. 9. NITHYA, MINOR, D/O.DAMODARA PANICKER, REP. BY HER GUARDIAN NO.1, VASANTHA, DO.. DO.. BY ADV. SRI.C.D.JOSE SMT.M.CHANDRALEKHA SA.No. 672 of 1995 RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS 2 TO 41 / PLAINTIFFS 2 & 3 AND DEFENDANTS 1 TO 5, 7, 9 AND 11 TO 41 1. KALLYANI PANIKKATHIAR, D/O.UNNEERIKUTTY PANICKEER, RESIDING AT KARUVAYAMPAYIL, NARIKUNNU AMSOM DESOM, NARIKUNNU.P.O, QUILANDY TALUK 2. APPUKUTTY PANICKER, S/O.UNNEERIKUTTY PANICKER, MECHANIC FITTER, RESIDING AT PUTHIYA VEETTIL, KOOTHALI AMSOM DESOM, KOOTHALI P.O, QUILANDY TALUK 3. MEENAKSHI PANICKATHIAR, W/O.KRISHNANKUTTY PANICKER, PUTHUKKUDI, KOTTOOR AMSOM, PALOLI DESOM, KOTTOOR P.O, QUILANDY TALUK 4. SAROJINI PANICKATHIAR, D/O.KUTTIKRISHNAN PANICKER, PUTHUKKUDI, DO.. DO.. 5. SUMATHY PANIKKATHIAR, D/O.KUTTIKRISHNAN PANICKER, PUTHUKKUDI, DO.. DO.. 6. SUKUMARAN PANICKER, S/O.KRISHNANKUTTY PANIKKAR, ASTROLOGER, DO.. DO.. 7. SANTHOSHAN PANIKKAR, S/O.KRISHNANKUTTY PANIKKAR, RYOT, DO.. DO.. 8. LAKSHMI PANIKKATHIAR, D/O.UNNI PANIKKAR, RESIDING AT SANTHI BHAVAN, NAGARAM AMSOM AND DESOM, KOZHIKKODE.P.O 9. BALACHANDRAN ALIAS BABU, S/O.GOPI PANIKKAR, DRIVER, KINARIKANDI PARAMBIL, NAGARAM AMSOM DESOM, KOZHIKODU 10. CHANDRIKA PANIKKATHIAR, D/O.SOUMINI PANIKKATHIAR, KARUVAMPOYIL, NARIKUM AMSOM, NIDIYANADU DESOM, TIRUR P.O, KOZHIKODE TALUK 11. SARASWATHY PANIKKATHIAR, D/O.GOPI PANIKKAR, KINARULLAKANDI PARAMBIL, KOTTULLI AMSOM DESOM, KOTTULLI .P.O, KOZHIKODE TALUK 12. AJITH KUMAR, S/O.SOUMINI PANIKKATHIAR, RYOT, KARUVAMPOYIL, NIDIYAND AMSOM DESOM, KOTTULLI.P.O, QUILANDY TALUK 13. KUNNAMKULANGARA KAMALAM, W/O.MADHAVAN PANIKKAR BALUSSERY AMSOM DESOM, BALUSSERY P.O, QUILANDY TALUK SA.No. 672 of 1995 14. UNNIKRISHNA PANIKKAR, S/O.KUNNAMKULANGARA KAMALAM, BALUSSERY AMSOM DESOM, BALUSSERY P.O, QUILANDY TALUK 15. CHANDRASEKHARAN, S/O.KUNNAMKULANGARA KAMALAM, DO... DO.. BALUSSERY P.O 16. DEEPA, D/O.KUNNAMKULANGARA KAMALAM, DO.. DO.. BALUSSERY P.O 17. EROYINKUNNUMEL APPUKUTTY PANIKKAR, S/O.IMBICHI PANIKKAR, ASTROLOGER, UNNIKULAM AMSOM DESOM, UNNIKULAM P.O, QUILANDY TALUK 18. PRABHAKARAN, S/O.APPUKUTTY PANIKKAR, FITTER, EROYIKUNNUMMEL, DO.. DO.. UNNIKULAM.P.O 19. SARADA, D/O.APPUKUTTY PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 20. DEVI, D/O.APPUKUTTY PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 21. RAMANI, D/O.APPUKUTTY PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 22. RADHAKRISHNAN, RYOT, S/O.APPUKUTTY PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 23. GOURI, D/O.APPUKUTTY PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 24. BHARGAVI, D/O.APPUKUTTY PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 25. MUKUNDAN, S/O.APPUKUTTY PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 26. THODUVAKKARA MADHAVAN PANIKKAR, S/O.KUNHIRRAPPAN PANIKKAR, PHYSICIAN, ULLIYERI AMSOM DESOM, ULLIYERI P.O, QUILANDY TALUK 27. KANAKAM, D/O. THODUVAKKARA MADHAVAN PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 28. GEETHA, D/O. DO.. DO.. 29. MEENAKSHY, W/O.LATE GOPALAN PANIKKAR AND W/O.KELAPPAN PANIKKAR, SANTHI BHAVAN, 17/57, PUTHIYARA P.O, NAGARAM AMSOM DESOM, KOZHIKKODE 30. SOBHANA, D/O.LATE GOPALAN PANIKKAR, SANTHI BHAVAN, DO.. DO.. 31. GOKULANATH, TEACHER, D/O.LATE GOPALAN PANIKKAR, SANTHI BHAVAN, DO.. DO.. SA.No. 672 of 1995 32. VIJAYALAKSHMY, D/O.LATE GOPALAN PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 33. PRASANNA, D/O.LATE GOPALAN PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 34. VIJAYAKUMAR, S/O.LATE GOPALAN PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 35. PUSHPA, D/O.LATE GOPALAN PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 36. DEEPA, D/O.LATE GOPALAN PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 37. UNNIKRISHNAN PANIKKAR, RYOT, S/O.LATE GOPALAN PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 38. SANTHAKUMAR, S/O.LATE GOPALAN PANIKKAR, DO.. DO.. 39. MEETHAKATHOOT MADHAVIKUTTY PANIKKATHIAR, BALUSSERY AMSOM DESOM, BALUSSERY P.O, QUILANDY TALUK ADV. SRI.P.C.SASIDHARAN SRI.P.K.SURESH KUMAR FOR R14, 15 SRI.K.P.SUDHEER FOR R14, 15 SRI.VINOD SINGH CHERIYAN FOR R30 SRI.R.SUDHISH FOR R30 THIS SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 15/11/2010, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: SA.No. 672 of 1995 ORDER IN I.A.NOS.307/2008, 968/2008 & 970/2008 IN S.A.NO.672/1995 Dismissed ORDER IN I.A.NO.969/2008 IN S.A.NO.672/1995 Dismissed ORDER IN I.A.NO.967/2008 IN S.A.NO.672/1995 Dismissed ORDER IN C.M.Appln.NO.306/2008 IN S.A.NO.672/1995 Dismissed Sd/- S.S.SATHEESACHANDRAN 15.11.2010 //True Copy// P.A to Judge S.S.SATHEESACHANDRAN, J -------------------------------------- S.A No.672 OF 1995 -------------------------------- Dated this the 15th day of November 2010 JUDGMENT Defects have not been cured so far. Appeal is dismissed. S.S.SATHEESACHANDRAN JUDGE dmb