1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT JODHPUR -------------------------------------------------------- 1. INCOME TAX APPEAL No. 129 of 2006 C I T UDAIPUR V/S CHOKSI MULTMETALS PRIVATE LTD 2. INCOME TAX APPEAL No. 130 of 2006 C I T UDAIPUR V/S CHOKSI MULTMETALS PRIVATE LTD 3. INCOME TAX APPEAL No. 131 of 2006 C I T UDAIPUR V/S CHOKSI MULTMETALS PRIVATE LTD 4. INCOME TAX APPEAL No. 138 of 2006 C I T UDAIPUR V/S M/S KUNDAN ELECTRICAL COMONENSTS Mr. KK BISSA, for the appellant / petitioner Mr. DINESH MEHTA, for the respondent Date of Order : 25.9.2008 HON'BLE SHRI N P GUPTA,J. HON'BLE SHRI KISHAN SWAROOP CHAUDHARI,J. ORDER ----- The controversy involved in these appeals is covered by a judgment of Division Bench of this Court dt. 13.5.2008 rendered in bunch of appeals led by Income Tax Appeal No.30/2005, CIT Udaipur vs. M/s Ravindra Platimum Pvt. Ltd. Thus, in this view of the matter, the question as framed is answered against the Revenue for the reasons 2 mentioned in the aforesaid judgment dt. 13.5.2008 and the appeals are dismissed. ( KISHAN SWAROOP CHAUDHARI ),J. ( N P GUPTA ),J. /m.asif/