IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT : THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.SASIDHARAN NAMBIAR THURSDAY, THE 27TH MARCH 2008 / 7TH CHAITHRA 1930 MJC.No. 511 of 2007(B) ---------------------- AGAINST THE JUDGMENT IN SA.434/1995 .................... PETITIONER/APPELLANT IN S.A. --------------------------------- TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM. BY ADV. SRI.D.SREEKUMAR, SC, TDB RESPONDENTS: RESPONDENTS IN SA ------------------------------------------ 1. PARVATHY AMMA CHELLAMMA POYKAYIL VEEDU, FROM KALEECKAL MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 2. KUNCHU PILLAI MADHAVAN PILLAI CHEMPAKATHIL VEEDU, MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 3. KUNJIKRISHNA PILLAI, MARANAGATHUTHARA THECKATIL VALIYAPADOM MURI, PADINJARE KALLADA VILLAGE. 4. LEELAMMA JOSE, MANGALATHU VEEDU MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 5. KUNJACHAN PETER,SANTHAMANGALATHU VEEDU KANNIMEL MURI SASTHAMCOTTA. 6. ABDUL HAKEEM, MUTTANIVILAYIL MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 7. MUHAMMED BASHER, RAZIA BHAVANATHU MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 8. NAZZAR, PADIPPURAPADINJATTATHIL MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 9. P.R.AIYAPPADAS, PALAVILA VEEDU MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 10. ABDUL LATHEEF, SALEENA HOUSE MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. MJC.No. 511 of 2007(B) 2 11. P.SAHHUL HAMEED,.CHARUVILA VEEDU MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 12. SIVASANKARA PILLAI, CHAMPEKATTIL VEEDU MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 13. SHAJAHAN, PADIPPURA VEEDU MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 14. AIYAPPAN PILLAI,THENGUVILAYIL VEEDU MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 15. ALIKUNJU ABDUL KAREEM,MUTTATHU VEEDU MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 16. C.SIVADASAN PILLAI, AMBALASSERI VILLAYIL VEEDU,MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 17. RAGHAVAN PILLAI VELAYUDHAN PILLAI RESIDING AT EASTERN SIDE OF D.B. COLLEGE COMPOUND SASTHAMCOTTA. 18. JOSEPH ALPHONSA, INDIRALAYAM MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 19. RAGAVAN NAIR, REMYAYIL MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 20. SUMATHYKUTTY AMMA, OTHARA VADACKEPUTHEN VEEDU, PULLISSERICKAL MURI,SASTHAMCOTTA. 21. VIJAYACHANDRAN, POIKAYIL VEEDU MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 22. PARVATHI AMMA VIJAYALAKSHMI AMMA MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 23. VIJAYAMBIKA, MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. 24. VIJAYAMOHANAN PILLAI, MANACKARA MURI, SASTHAMCOTTA. BY ADV. SRI.ANCHAL C.VIJAYAN ADV.SRI.ASOK M.CHERIAN THIS MISCELLANEOUS JURISDICTION CASE HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 27/03/2008, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY PASSED THE FOLLOWING: M.SASIDHARAN NAMBIAR, J. ---------------------------------- M.J.C.NO.511 OF 2007 IN S.A.NO.434 OF 1995 ----------------------------------------------------- DATED THIS THE 27TH DAY OF MARCH, 2008 O R D E R Petitioner is appellant/plaintiff in the suit. Suit was for permanent prohibitory injunction restraining respondent from trespassing into the plaint schedule property. Suit was dismissed on the ground that plaint schedule property was not identified. The appeal was dismissed for default. When this petition was taken up for arguments, learned counsel appearing for appellant submitted that a report is submitted by Land Special Officer dated 18.3.2008 to the effect that the encroachers or their successors in interest have no possession or enjoyment of the land held by Devaswom under 'kuthakappattom' in survey Nos.606/01 and 605/02 and though there were attempts earlier to trespass, those attempts were lawfully resisted by the Devaswom officials and devotees and therefore at present, there is no apprehension of trespass. M.J.C.511/07 2 2. In view of the said submission, the suit being only one for injunction, I do not find it necessary to readmit the appeal. The dismissal of the appeal will not disentitle the Devaswom from instituting a fresh suit on proper identification of the property, if there is any subsequent reasonable apprehension of trespass. Petition dismissed. M.SASIDHARAN NAMBIAR, JUDGE. dsn