IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.15511 of 2009 1. PARMESHWAR PRASAD YADAV S/O LATE RAM LAKHAN YADAV VILL.- SANPATHA, P.S.- LADANIA, DISTT.- MADHUBANI 2. LAXMI NARAYAN S/O LATE RAMDEO SINGH VILL.- KARHARWA, P.S.- LADANIA, DISTT.- MADHUBANI 3. SHYAM KUMAR SINGH S/O SRI SUKHDEO SINGH VILL.- PARSAHI, P.O.- SIDHAP. P.S.- LADANIA, DISTT.- MADHUBANI 4. BALESHWAR KUMAR YADAV S/O SRI TRIPTI NARAYAN YADAV VILL.- SAMPATHA, P.S.- LADANIA, DISTT.- MADHUBANI 5. SHIV NANDAN SINGH S/O SRI RAM BRIKSH SINGH VILL.- KARHARWA, P.S.- LADANIA, DISTT.- MADHUBANI 6. BIRJU PANDIT S/O SRI GHURAN PANDIT VILL.- KARHARWA, P.S.- LADANIA, DISTT.- MADHUBANI 7. LAXMI MAHTO S/O RAMASHISH MAHTO VILL.- SAMPATHA, P.S.- LADANIA, DISTT.- MADHUBANI 8. RAJENDRA PRASAD SINGH S/O SRI SAHDEO SINGH VILL.- SAMPATHA, P.S.- LADANIA, DISTT.- MADHUBANI 9. JEEBACHH SINGH S/O SRI SHIV CHARAN SINGH VILL.- KHUTAUNA NAVTOLI, P.S.- KHUTAUNA, DISTT.- MADHUBANI 10. HARI NARAYAN SINGH S/O SRI RAMDEO SINGH VILL.- MOGLAHA, P.O.- KHUTAUNA, P.S.- LALMANIA, DISTT.- MADHUBANI Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA 2. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA 3. THE DIRECTOR DEPARTMENT OF PRIMARY EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA 4. THE REGIONAL DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF EDUCATION KOSHI DIVISION, SAHARSA ----------- 2 4.3.2010 Heard counsel for the petitioner and the counsel appearing for the State. Petitioner’s prayer is for a direction to the respondent to consider the certificate of Baby Teachers Certificate course obtained from Gandhi Hindi Vidyapeeth, Parayag, 2 Allahabd (U.P.) as a valid training certificate for appointment as Primary Panchayat Shikshak/Prakhand Shikshak in second phase of recruitment. The issue relating to genuineness, validity, and equivalence of Baby Teachers certificate granted by Gandhi Hindi Vidyapeeth, Prayag, Allahabad has been considered and decided by Division Bench in LPA No. 387 of 2009. The Division Bench has held that the Baby Teachers Certificate course is neither proper training degree nor it is a recognized degree for appointment on the post of Teachers in Primary and Middle School. Since the issue has already been settled, this writ application is dismissed. (Mridula Mishra,J.) A.Kumar