IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA C.R. No.402 of 2009 PRABHU PRASAD, SON OF LATE MAHADEO PRASAD, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KAITHWALIA, P.S. SUGAULI, DISTRICT EAST CHAMPARAN. ---------PETITIONER (INTERVENOR BEFORE THE COURT BELOW) Versus 1. AKTAR HUSSAIN MIAN 2. MOHD. ABDUS SHAKOOR 3. MOHD. SALAHUDDIN 4. MOHD. ZULFEKAR MIAN ALL SONS OF LATE MOHD. SALIM MIAN RESIDENT OF VILLAGE SUGAULI, P.O. & P.S. SUGAULI, DISTRICT EAST CHAMPARAN. 5. BIBI SOGHRA KHATOON DAUGHTER OF LATE MOHD. SALIM MIAN WIFE OF MOHD. ALAUDDIN MIAN, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE SANICHARI KOTHI, P.O. & P.S. LAURIYA, DISTRICT WEST CHAMPARAN. 6. BIBI SADRUN NISA, DAUGHTER OF LATE MOHD. SALIM MIAN WIFE OF MOHD. NAZIRMIAN, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE RAI DHURWA, P.O. & P.S. CHANPATIA, DISTRICT WEST CHAMPARAN. (PLAINTIFFS BEFORE THE COURT BELOW) 7. MOHD. MATIN MIAN SON OF LATE FATEH MD. MIAN 8. MOST. ZAIBUN NISA, WIFE OF LATE JALALUDDIN MIAN 9. MOHD. BADRUDDIN MIAN 10. MOHD. GAUHAR MIAN 11. MOHD. ANWAR MIAN 12. MOHD. SORWAR MIAN 13. MOHD. AWAIS MIAN 14. MOHD. WAQUAR MIAN SONS OF LATE JALALUDDIN MIAN. 15. MOST. NURBANDI @ MOST. GUIJA WIFE OF LATE MD. WARIS MIAN. 16. MD. SHIKANDER MIAN 17. MD. BADAR MIAN SONS OF LATE MD. WARIS MIAN. 18. MD. AKBAR MIAN 19. AJMARI KHATOON 20. MOJHARI KHATOON 21. CHOTAKI KHATOON ALL MINOR SONS AND DAUGHTERS OF LATE MD. WARIS MIAN THROUGH THEIR MOTHER, NATURAL GUARDIAN AND CARE TAKER, MOST. NURBANDI @ MOST.GUIJA. 22. BIBI REHANA, DAUGHTER OF LATE JALALUDDIN MIAN WIFE OF MOHD. SALAHUDDIN. 23. MOHD. SHARIF MIAN SON OF LATE MOHD. MOBIN MIAN 24. MOHD. HANIF MIAN 25. ABDUL HAMID MIAN 26. MOHD. ANWAR MIAN SONS OF LATE MOHD. MOBIN MIAN. - 2 - ALL ARE RESIDENTS OF VILLAGE SUGAULI, P.O. & P.S. SUGAULI, DISTRICT EAST CHAMPARAN. 27. BIBI TISIA KHATOON DAUGHTER OF LATE MOHD. MOBIN MIAN WIFE OF ABDUL HALIM MIAN, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE PAKARIA, P.O. & P.S. HARSIDHI, DISTRICT EAST CHAMPARAN. 28. BIBI ASMA KHATOON, DAUGHTER OF LATE MOHD. MOIN MIAN WIFE OF MAJEED MIAN, RESIDENT OF MOHALLA SANT GHAT, BETTIAH, P.O. & P.S. BETTIAH TOWN, DISTRICT WEST CHAMPARAN. 29. BIBI FATEMAH, DAUGHTER OF LATE MOHD. MOIN MIAN WIFE OF MOHD. OBAIDULLAH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MADHOPUR, P.S. MAJHAULIA, DISTRICT EAST CHAMPARAN. 30. MOST. ZAIBUN NISA WIFE OF LATE MD. SHAMIM MIAN 31. MOHD. AFTAB ALAM 32. MOHD. MUMTAZ MIAN 33. MOHD. MAHTAB MIAN SONS OF LATE MD. SHAMIM MIAN. 34. MOHD. SOHRAB MIAN 35. MOHD. HUNNA MIAN SONS OF LATE MD. SHAMIM MIAN. 36. BIBI NASEEMA 37. BIBI ZARINA 38. BIBI NAYEEMA ALL DAUGHTERS OF LATE MD. SHAMIM MIAN ALL ARE RESIDENTS OF VILLAGE SUGAULI, P.O. & P.S. SUGAULI, DISTRICT EAST CHAMPARAN. 39. BIBI RUKHSHANA, DAUGHTER OF LATE MOHD. SHAMIM MIAN, WIFE OF MOHD. BASIR MIAN, RESIDENT OF MOHALLA HAZARI TOLA, BETTIAH, P.O. & P.S. BETTIAH TOWN, DISTRICT WEST CHAMPARAN. 40. MD. MULAJIM MIAN 41. MD. IDU MIAN SONS OF NOOR MOHAMAD MIAN. 42. BIBI BILASO, DAUGHTER OF MD. IDU MIAN. ALL ARE RESIDENTS OF VILLAGE RADHIYA, P.O. ARERAJ, P.S. PAHARPUR, DISTRICT EAST CHAMPARAN. 43. BIBI JAINUL, WIFE OF MD. TAIYAB MIAN, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MADHOPUR, P.S. MAJHAULIA, DISTRICT WEST CHAMPARAN. 44. MD. NAZIR MIAN 45. MD. JAHIR MIAN. BOTH SONS OF LATE GAMHIR MIAN, RESIDENT OF KAIRATIYA, P.O. & P.S. BETTIAH, DISTRICT WEST CHAMPARAN. 46. MD. ALIM MIAN. 47. MD. AJIMULLAH MIAN 48. MD. SAMSUL HAQUE MIAN SONS OF LATE MD. HUSSAIN MIAN ALL ARE RESIDENTS OF VILLAGE ADHK APARIYA, P.S. RAMGADHWA, DISTRICT EAST CHAMPARAN. - 3 - 49. BIBI JEJAB KHATOON WIFE OF LATE BHIMAL MIAN 50. DHURAN MIAN 51. MD. HANIF 52. MD. TAIYAN SONS OF LATE KHODADDIN MIAN 53. BIBI JEJAB KHATOON WIFE OF LATE BHIMAL MIAN 54. DR. MD. ABAIDULLAH 55. MD. ABDULLAH 56. MD. MANULLAH 57. MD. AJIMULLAH SONS OF LATE HIMAL MIAN. ALL ARE RESIDENTS OF VILLAGE MADHOPUR, P.O. MADHOPUR, P.S. SUGAULI, DISTRICT EAST CHAMPARAN ------(DEFENDANTS BEFORE THE COURT BELOW) ----------- 2. 19/3/2009 Heard Mr. Sanjeev Kumar No. 1, learned counsel for the petitioner. This Civil Revision is directed against the order dated 15.1.2009 passed by the Sub Judge-8th, Motihari, in P.S. No. 212 of 1989 whereby the prayer of the petitioner for impleading him as defendant in the Partition Suit has been rejected by the court below holding that the petitioner is not a necessary party in this suit. After some argument, learned counsel for the petitioner seeks permission to withdraw this Civil Revision application with liberty to file a proper suit for proper relief. Permission is granted. This Civil Revision application is dismissed as withdrawn with liberty to file a proper suit for proper relief in this regard, if so advised, subject to any period of limitation, and if permissible in law. In case such a suit is filed, the same shall be decided by the court concerned in accordance with law. S. Ali (Dr. Ravi Ranjan, J.) - 4 -