IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR Writ Petition N0.a^^2- /2003 PETITIONER ;-••" Brahma Prasad, aged 68 years S/o.Lakheshwar, Patd, R/o. Vill^e ^< ..»v" ^..•^..•••' Chapple, Tahsil Kharsiya, District ^^^§>-'"' T.:^^ .**** t;>' RESPONDENTS Raigarh (C.G.) VERSUS : 1. TheStateofChhattisgarh Through The Collector, Raigarh(C.G.) 2. Chhatrapal Singh, aged 39 years S/o. Devprasad Patel, R/o. Chapple, Tah. Kharsiya, District Raigarh (C.G.) 3. Sanjay Kumar, aged 33years S/o. Omprakash Gupta R/o. Kharaya, Tahsfl Kharsiya Distt. Raigarh (C.G.) WRIT PETITION U/A 226/23^7 OF THE CONSTiTUTION OP INDIA Xi-HC-22 'S^i (, '^ft'OTS, !««~ir<-iy ,-ttSS s.ti.s ;Bi;!i'' ^^ ?;]'^° tiit-i:.s[:»i?r ^EC^ "i^'^< i^-f ^^V-^°3- iOi) —^. °i^I'^IIWBfel Fi'siW^. ~WV, tl T5CTT TFiTRTi •^ sf^m'svfs Miss Preeti Beriwal, counsei for the petitioner. Shri Sanjay Agrawal, De^uty Advocatc Seneral for the State. The petitioner by this peti-f-ion filedunder Articte 226/227 of the Constitution of India h^is challenged the order dated 30-4-2003 passed by the Membfer, Board of Revenue, State of ) Chhartisgarh, Bitaspur, by whict} the tearned Member of the Board of Revenue upheld the o^der of the bistrict Collector, Raigarh ckited Z5-2-2003 concelling -the patta of atlotment made in favour of the petitioner on 16-fe-1974. The admitted facts are j .1 That the petitioner was allotted ^. piece of tand measuring 0.607 1 ! hectare ond Bhoomiswami Patta u|as gronted to him on 16-5-1974. On 25-4-1989 the petitjoner haql sold 0.040 hectare of land in 1 foivour of Sanjny Kumar (responclent No.3) by way of sale deed XI-HC-22 ^ 3, SiTfl-y'll*, I'slWKn^ i!sf iTi'Sr^i | •i^iwantsi I ^EI'Rf? ^113 ^ f ^\VVc^ :(H) 311^1 ^RITWW?^ t.- iferapf TW^ ~^ fscfl '(fsRSTC ^ 3IRtI .3iR?i without taking prior permission 4'f th®Collector. On comptaint made by one Chhatrapal on enqi^iry was conducted by the Sub Divisional Officer and the matl'erj was reported to the Collector. The Collector insti+ute^a case and opporhjnity wnas 9iven to parties and after hearing •the poirljies the Collector peodied to the conclusion that the land in questi^n has been transfer'red without prior permission of the Colle^tor in controvention of -ttie 1 provisions of Section 165 (7) (b^ of Chhatt-isgarh Lond Revenue Act, 1959 and accordingly, the C411ector concelted the Patta and altotment of the petitioner. r I have heard learned counsel for the petitioner. Learned counsel for the p^titioner submitted that as per 1 the provisions of 5ection 158 (3) |of the Land Revenue Act after ten years from the date of issuan^e of the patt-a, Bhoomiswami is entitled for transfer of th®lolid without permission of the Collector. She further submittecl that the Collector should have 3-HC-ZZ 'SSf •WRv^'^eW'fSifsiWS^ snisi^i 'f^Naii^T ^iTlNT^rfta (^? t^ 200 ccncelled the allotment to the ^xtent of the land, which has been tronsferred by the petitioner^ kind allotted to him and if he +,]^i"(;-n-< 'WEI^FI''? f:s"7> •^? 3IRTO'SI^I to respondent No.3. She also submitted that petitioner has cjli^ady constructed a house on the is removcd from that lond it will create difficutt situation for hii^. I have perused the rele^ant provisions of Section 158 (3) alongwith 5ection 165 C7) (b) of the L<md Revenue Act, 1959. Even though the proviso to sub-section (3) of Section 158 prescribed that "no such persafi ^iall transfer siidi kmd within a 'od of ten years from i^e date of lease or allotmenf. However. later on the provisior^s of sub-section 7 (b) of Section ;;-T.^.^e.-t^'" 165 was inriiiipiin'rtficl ond whic^i lays doum that "no-hvi-thstanding anything contained h sub-^ct^n (a person who hokls land from 1 ihe State Government or a peftfon who holds Iwid in Wioomiewami rights under sub-secfion (3) df Section 158) or v»hom right to occupy land is grcwifed by Ihe ^tate Govemn'ient or ihe Colkctor ,>\- <^?"/^ aSpnp oopeqg •3-1 ; ] ~/ps '^o pafcodsip spuo+s £OOZ/6£99'°N"y'I puo £002/T96T"oN'd"(M)'W '•i3FU|o aAoqo sij4. J.o MSIA ui •A|6u!pjo39D j.o pasodsip si uoj4.j4.ad +UM siijj^ 1 •p^o6a4 siiji ui Aj.uoLi4.no s+DMdojddo 31)4. aAoui o+ A4.jaq!| 4.0 si .ouoi+i+sd ai|4. puo +3sdss.i sii|4. ui .isuoi+i+sd ai|4. 04. pa4.uiw6 aq uoo j.aiiaj 4.rii|M 04. sp 'uoi+sanb sity. apissp o+ /+!>iot|+no +ua(.aduio3 si|4. joj. ^j +j 'puD| nuod ai41. uo Gui+sixa ajo puo jauoij.Li.ad ai(4. Aq pspn^+suos ajo 4:>!IIM pauja?uo3 auo s6ujij+ .ot|+o puo asnoij 34^ so .i^ SD '^suoi+i+ad 31)4. jo^ (asunos paujoa| ai|4. j.o U014.US4.U03 aijj. ui ^BJO^. ou si aisi|4. t|3ns sy •nj4od 3141. fo uoj4.D||S3i|n»ai)4. +nocp uMop s^o) uoisiAo^d S!11 'ps||33U(»aq p|noi|s 'JO+ga))^ a\# ^o uoissiuuad 31(1. 4.noi|4.!m pa^j3^suDJ4- usaq sot| t|3!4M 'uoi+^iod /.[uo si|4. +044. uoop pio) +ou S30p g9i U014.33S J.O (q) / uoi+oa^-qns 40 uoisiAoud aiii •pa||a:>uo3 usaq »Aoi{4.ou p|not|s puo) +DI)+ 1)10 tuit| Aq ps+anj+suoo uasq soij asnoi| D puo jsuoi+i+ad ai<+ j.o uoi^ssssod ui si i|3!t|M 'ouod ai|4, j.o IsSIK. hB-J tfe ;ji. ^ai tejtihltt i-\hWh"-h wz ^j^ -£ ieQ ifiiMta^^'aitB^eatetetfc..te£ |^SE-^?^'' ' uaj».t)i|i-tis USueiElfcy Uai^lK ®-3H-K SySsS^WSs^^fsSs^^S^f^