IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR. S§W€3iE %E§\§$H WRIT PETITION NOW 352501; 2006 y, Dr. Smt. Jyoti Shukla, aged about 36 years, W/o PETITIONER A Dr. Anil Kumar Shukla/L’amxez’ * ’m&w%wm’ Posted at Government Higher Secondary School, Lafa, District Korba (C.G.) VERSUS RESPONDENTS 1. State of Chhattisgarh, Through: The Secretary, Schedule Caste and k Tribal Development Department, .. J D.K. S. Bhawan Raipur (C.G.) The Commissioner, Tribal Development Department, Schedule District Qatar/ROG.) The Collector, Korba District Korba (C.G.) 4. The Assistant l t Commissioner, Tribal 1 Development " Department, District Korba (C. G.) 5. The Principal, Government ‘ Higher ’ Secondary School, Lafa, District Korba (C.G.) 's ~. RIT’ PETITTON UNDER ARTICLE 226/227 OF HE'CONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR ISSUANCE- ’ OF AN APPROPRIATE WRIT IN THE NATURE OE MANDAMUSJCERTIORARI ETC. OR DIRECTION/ORDER IN THE LIKE NATURE ETC. i. f W T XI—HC-78 EW,W§,W . m..'..u.nnu.uonu a? 200 [33¢ m.m (13W) ‘ mm§wm WWW %31%1m1%m i 19?.2Q06 3547/2006. 3hr? Rajesh Pandey, Advoceke f0? The pefi‘rioners. ' ShriV Sumesh :Bajaj, mvernmen'r Advocafe‘ for f‘ne respmde'nfs/S‘i‘h'1'e tin advance cop y . Hard. ‘ - The main grievance raised by The” pe‘rii'ionars is common and mmmon Essue is iayéka‘d in fhzse pefh‘ions, ”:‘her-efare, fhey am being disposed of by ”;his commcn order. 1‘ 3y fhesa parifims, the pefifimers, wha am workirg as Leca‘urar in Amriaus Higher Secondary Scho is of €18 Dis?ric? Korba of 511112 of Chha??isgarh, haw” quasfioned . 'e §zgaiHy & correctness of fheir 'i'r'zmsfer order dafed 7.7.2006 {Annaxure P—E) issued imder The 'sigm‘i'ure 9f Under Secre‘mr, Gwemmen‘r 915 Chha‘n’igarh,‘ ‘ 5c§e§uied Caste & $chadu£ed Tr§ Devaiopmen‘r Deparfmem, Qaipur. 'The grounds a‘f chailenge of fhis ordar, as raised by The garh‘ien'ers, are "rhu? fhe Sacra? ry er fine Under Secremry has m jurisdic‘ricn To phss 1%); $mpu9na 1'ransf‘ar erder, as ‘rhe: CsunsaQing P.T.O. WP. Nazi 3523/2096, 3524/2006, 352§l200é, 3526/2006, 3527/2i306, 3528/2006, 3529/2006, 353Q/2G36, 3531/2006, 3533!2096; 3534/2006, 353922006, 3540/2006, ‘3541/2996, 3542/2006i 3543/2006, 3544/2006, 3§45/2006, XI—HC-78 mm,m,%amgt o Wm (W) mmm WWW ' WW fsQ°rWR m‘ Wank: ' “aw I a:mm Commi?€‘ee is empewered 1‘9 Esue ‘imnsfer ardars unaier Tha Ra?§onaiizufion Schema dafed #052006, fherefore, i'he impugned #rmsfer ora‘er §ssue& by ragg n? Noi is wi‘i'hau? jur§sd§cfion and nuliiw in flag ayes 03‘ iawv Ein‘l'e Gavernmenf has aiready a‘elegufed The pcwers of fmns arring 'fhe i‘eachers fa counseiiirag camm§*n‘ee cons?imfaa a? fhe fg §avei uncier‘ me m?iamiiza‘ficn scheme. dafzd 1.5.2§G6 and the £mpugned fransfar arder has been issued: in flagram' vicicd'isn of fiq provisions cemained' in Paras 5 & 6 9f fhis m'fionaiizafion scheme. -Perusai of impugne& o er Annexur’e P—l whereby fise as alse TR mTionaiizdTion scheme pe?é?§ans are missenceivads fer 'ihe reasass thcri' ‘rhe impugnes arsieaum'ey whisk The gaéfioaess Pave been fransaierred has heen pessea‘ an admimsftm'We grcun&s. This sexier has no? been passed uneetr fhe mfionaihm'inn scheme dcfed 1.6.2006 and fhe same has been pzssj by fhe 6ovemmenf én exercise sf genera? gawers ’fe Transfer Hs empieyees ?emsai of miionaiizafien scheme dqfed 1.6.20Q6 shews The? where an accoun‘r a‘§" transfers, pramo?ians & re?§remems fhe numbers m‘ “reacher‘s have became irm'riam} in varieus schcm-is leaking Te fhe numbers {if sfudems Le, wisere en aecmm? ef abeve men1§0ne¢i reasans in we scecci numbers of teachers have become less 1 or’ 2 ar where pefi?icners have bzen ‘rrcmsfer da‘bed 1.5.2G0é shaws ?he? 3*?18 P.T.O. 4 a a e m 3 r XI-HC-78 c .ooo..‘....o‘ooo...o. V mm (W) WWW L ‘mmmw '~?~ WW§W®§R V§ialf§malTé¥T “rhe numbers of Teachers have wxceedeé mare fhan #he required raumbers of feachars‘ in ?ha? cgse The asrzcerned deparfmam, as emiscxged in fhz scheme, wi§§ cons?i3‘ufe a counsei§ing commiffee cmd affer saléecfmg in€arm¢rian from #ha various higher secs'ndary primary schoois, The Ecancerneé sc‘noais er middie Svahnols or cemmi‘h‘ea shai! mi‘ionalize fhe numbérs 9f i’eécisers in aac‘rz sci'éeeis icqking +9 fha numbers 0f smdeniis. If has been envisage§ é'hai' fiae rimary schooi remain less than 'rwn mmi??ee is f0 ensure Tim? in no akers, 321 case of midd!e scho ge of high schoa! no? ‘less fhan condary schoci no? iess ‘fhan six As has been merifica’sed a b dmmis?mi'ive gmunds cmd 1*his ‘?iom!§zmion scheme dafed 1.6 mwered ‘i‘o Wanshr ifs m epar‘rmenf of fhe Smfe Gavan $13 washers in fme adminis‘rm‘i‘We xAQreover, a bare perusai af Th2 enfianed §n ‘é’ie peiil‘ions fhm‘ ighar secon<§ary school numbers o i rm? iess than three feachers, m our ?eac51ers and in case cf Mgha’ eachars. ar 14m? ‘rhe impagneé oréer has - zen passa& Lmdzr 'i’i’ia adminis‘rrjq iva powars of The Gevernmznf or: a m m e ' ?§ana§im‘3’icn $c‘neme daes m’r d der has mfhing f0 do wifiq ?§1e . (3&6. The Governmenf .is aMays §0yeas and fine infracmc‘rim of cd‘e any bar 'fhm‘ ‘rhe cancamed em is n91: empowered 'm Tmnsfew exigency or in ‘rhe pLMic imer-es'i'. 'i’tisns shaws ‘i'hn'r i1" has no? been y 1'hase fransfars §n ci par?icuiar of ‘i’aac‘nars has bzcama iass fiqan P.T.O. H W , W , W m a e E a J " p m r . @ XI—HC-78 WW,W W o WWr.r...gv..uo..o...’g.‘;'.r:. In _200 Wmwmaw) WWW mmm «l,» - awawanam ' ‘i‘he required numbers"'gf #eachars or numbers of wachars have exceeded baking 1‘9 £ma numbers of studems. Thamfcre, ‘i‘he pe'rifions 91f The pe‘rifiehers are ne? mainfaimbk for ‘rhe reasons fiaaf; §i) the arder impugneé ms been passed under fhe generai pawers 5f The Goy‘emmen? 1'0 Transfer i?s emp§oyees on adminis‘?m‘f§ve §mund and i? has m? been passed under “the said' scheme §.e. mfiomi§zei‘fisn scheme shied 1.6.2006‘ (2) in fhe petitions if ha ‘ n01“ been aHeged fha‘i‘ ch accoun‘f cf These fmnsfer-s fhe princi ie enuncia‘fed in The m'ficnalizafion scheme has been vilobfed Le. on accsun‘r 6f These frmsfers fhe numbers of Teacher's have b come less Than fhe required number's of €‘eechers under ‘The mfmnaiizafion seh’eme or have exceeded in any par?§eu§ar sehoe§ céewci'ry 3‘9 'x‘he m?i0naiizm‘iors sesame. wz (0. \i« The areas of aperciion cf fhe m?§omiizafion scheme defed 1.6.2006 and cf genemi power-s of frmsfer m" Sfe'fe governmen? are diffe rent Hewever, if any such ins‘rence comes $9 ?he neTice of The eefifione's, fhen f§1ey wi§i be a? iiber‘i‘y Te make a regresema‘rim 1‘0 The eufhori‘i‘y concerned. In View of #he above, The pefieens si'and dismssed.‘ \ Consequen‘riy, A:'\.{W.)P. fer grnn‘r 0f smy aise smnds dismissed. a Sdl- L.C. Bhad0° Judge Roshamh W’ §