§€§GH C5§J§T GF JUDECixTiiRE 6%HA??§§GE1RE‘ : §§L§R$PGR $§¥€§L§ $E§k§£% : %G¥‘é’§§§.§ $%%Rl 3%. Pé§%‘#§§<, QJ. W§fT $E‘Ti?i6?\i iiiG 322$ G? 2i3§§ PETEKQNERg 1.. Rakesh Kamar Eewé§§é§m 3ince k dewased ihraugh fa§hef Eharaéki Eewagwggn, Farguram Ward, Bhagamra, Bigft. Raipur {Chmifiggarm ‘y'ijay Kumgr Tiwari, aged abeu‘: 4Q years 3m“: cf Shri GwE VEwari, Hathripara: Bhatagara District Raipur (Chhaitisgarw 3;. Santwh V rma, aged aémut years gar: {)T' Tirii‘hram Verma, parsuram Ward. ghazapaia, Distric? Ra‘wur (Shhattésgarh) 4. Mahesh Sewangan: aged aboui years 59:: 9f Rewaam Dewangan, Paywram . §f§fari gmta‘para, Raipur (C%if‘.af§3aarh§ f5. Rameah Dawangan, aged abougvea’rs sw of Réwaram Déwangari. Pafshram Ward, Ehaiapara, diat. Raigmr E (‘Chham§garh} Q '3. Mahamai $ahu, aged abcu‘L year$ son of §hr§ Samaru Ram $ahu, Hathnéparai Efiafaiaafa, Ei§ii Rairm‘r (Chha%§garh} l7, $antram Ezahg, aged abwt yegrs 3cm of Saffaam Ram SEW. Hathr’imara, Bhatapara! Disirmt Raipur (ChhattEgarh‘) hi R£§PQ§QQ§§¥§FS 1;. The Municipa! swasm ghaiapara, through : fihiaf Exew€ive Qffkces'i Mmécigsgi aggngii; Ehaiggara, {iigtrict Raipui (C%§%ia‘€ti$garh) 2, Chief Executive Gfficer; Municipai Ccmsii. ghaiawr‘a, ,Rafrjur ($hhatti5garh} Présent : My. Suurabh Jaimtai, ieamed cgunse! f0! :he getitianel’s‘ 3:4 mi“. 5hr$$ Kgmar Agrawah Epr. Adan. M??? Mr, Snwrabh Sharma §eamec§ ¢Qun$$§ fear the re§pondenta GRI‘i. G§BER gFassed gm E§ January: ZQQE Tm Municipai QcumiL Ehatapara; the §rst re$pondent harem, gagged a resaiution damd ’i3i’i1l19§6 resoiving §e construci a shappmg compiéx in a vacam open {aticl in am‘é’r ia 3m: furihev emmachmani3 on the vacan‘t {and §wned ‘ay if. in purwai‘xce of ihai‘: resaéuticin‘ {he weru Eafwd k“: fFc-nt ef water mi‘er man: wa33ac€imed m 94i12/Eggii n whisk. Ehe getmaaers he¥5ia as we}; as e§even ether bmiders naaisipateg aw thg petiticner5 ware a!!o!tes‘ a partisuigt shag cut cf eighteen $h0p§ pr0p0§ed t9 bg :Qnstmcied‘ The gatitianara have pmduaed the Order da£ed OS/12/19$8‘ Annexurs-Wii alio‘tting $hop Ne.8 for §$5ZOGOL in favour o€ the fimt pe§itionen Simiiar crdem are aisa i'ssue‘d m fax/cu? afihe femaihmg péiitianerg, bui, thé Muriicigiai Caumii did mi caastfuat ihe §haps a3 glarinea‘. As pea" ihe Munkipai Caumii, thay csastructed 24 shtms in thé $ame tand k1 puriuans‘? cf sum 6f Rupees Féfiy iacs sanatéenec; by he and. 9f énéia a3 we§P a$ the $2ate w i @wemment Lmder the Ent‘grateg Deveiariment 9f Small and Middke Tgwn§ Schgme {IDSMT Sgheme). 311mg thg Munidpa! Caunail did ngt somtruct eighteen $hop‘3‘ as miginaily plannad, the ’petitiones'a being aggrievea by the eaid aciicm of *me Municipal. Counci‘, have preferred this r. Wfii peiitierx prayirig fer the faiiawirxg reliefe: ”REHEF EGUGH'F: Under ihe facts ané circamstences aarmied abeve, the petitionefs may fer the fo§icwing re£§ef:- 27:? That the Hon‘bie Court may kindiy be pieased to quash annexure P-é. 7.2 That the Han’ble Caurt may kindly be pieased ie direct the respendente ta dame-r the peesessmh of me gheyag té i‘r‘xe ré§pecfivg péfifimér i'r’x résiiect 6f me auciioned $heps, where ihe péiifioners had beer: susces5fui bidder. 7,3 Tha respondemS be fuFther direcied mi tQ rem aactimeé the sheps, which have aiready been auctiarxéd. ?.4 C615? 6f {he mtEffsr: bg- Eh‘éwea’. ‘75 ITmy othér reiiaf, which this Horx’bie Calm maggwms f‘it' and proper under the fagis and circumsfgnces a?" ihe case, be aliowed.” an“ 1M w 1% writ getitmn is appasec‘: 5y %§e Mummp-a! Swami by fmng K (3% f heard ieamef§ eaunsei far t§ié paré§e3 E was canferxded by we §eam€d csunse% f0? the getifiaaérg that the ms? respandem = Mum£ipaé Sauna: ha‘v‘éng seiemmy pmmaeé £ha g$§é€§$n$rs t0 aim: shegg wt of e§gm$en sham ariginany gamed shauic! rm backueut fmm itS pmméa‘e and therefare, mandamus wouid lis t0 ihe Munigipai Cagncii, Bhatapara ta carry gut its giromisa i0 the petiiioners. Learneci mumei for ihe . regpondehig, per confra, weuks', ai ihe éhreshoid, puinf aui trraf mar’eiy bécau§é, iii purguar‘rée' of f‘né aLrciiOri néiice fhé m’titim‘rers had a‘épQSiiéa‘ earae3€ marre'y' arixi 1/4' 4m Gr: thé CGS‘é a? the shép, thar circumstancg i€5élf W5u£d mt 3&3: arry $rrfaa’ceabre rr’ghis én the wiéiienerg Ea seek m§€§d§m£§£ £2 wa$ fiéEli the Munmigai QeLrngiL as originaHy pianned‘ did mi: canstrum‘ eightegn ghops and, therefore, aHctting sham i0 'Ihe petitioners, a5 per ailotmsni Order dared (38/1 2J1 99S marked as Annexure-P/35 wouid mt arise. 5% wa5 aiso conierrded by f'he learned Senior Ceuneeé ii’iat fhe Menty—feur ehops Au K ggrn‘zed 5m try the reamed $anier Samar; that eeriefrueree‘ urne‘er fhe irifegraiee Deveiepmer‘rf 6f Sman emi‘ Mide‘ie Tewee Sché'mé cauici iiéf bé 2h'é%éa faf‘rw péféfiériérss aid fhwa ghéfis ‘riave fa 5e aisa%iér1e6 m aecar’a’ancé with ié‘v‘v, in fépiy, §eamred mume} fa? fhé patitionefa weuQd submié fhai‘ fa? any r asarr éf the Cam? i$ mt §n$§§i‘:ed i0 awe aé§rest§ea 2e me fizs: {egpaoncéent == Manigigak Cguneii :9 amt shots; to retii'igney; the petiiignas Shguig be _Qmpen§ated fairly by awarding §ntere$i at a reaacznabie rate. 1 §4§ Amwugh ,%RSeX££$-Pf3, W'ée!‘ dateé 05/12/1S§§, §$$Lae£§ 1'9 Em: ,QeméaneVs in an anmi$takabie teg’mg sgazeg that me $hagks are. aHettgd f9: a mnsideratign 9f R§,E?,GDO/- by gggh aiictee, théfggi ramains that the Municipal Counaii did mt con$truat eighteen worm, a5. or§ginaiiy Fjianngdx m ofhér words; the Murxiéipai Council had abandaned it‘s‘piatw m ccfwimci éigmaéii 1% $§-m§3$ mapwea‘ t6 arfé§f am: pfevawt fur€hef énsmaihméms iii iiw iarxd békmgihg is ii. Tf§eréfara issuiiig mafwamus 52$ direCEiarr is the Munic§§a§ Sstmcél i0 amt $hap8 m favcui“ of ihe inegi‘téoners wawcé mat wise, Sémééaréy, ihe Qwrt wggsm net be justif§egi m directing the Mumcipai Qeggnaa to am sheps cut cf Mentwgur snaps constructed by it under ihe integrated Eevebpmeni cf Sma§i ané Midgla Towns Scheme,- because, admiitedw! thosa twenty~fcur $hoga$ are construcieu‘ by securing iiberai grams from the Govt. of mdia and by fhé Sfai‘e Gsvamménf am? :naréféré, 3%iafmér1f 5f ihaéé shops §hauié be“ dong mnm‘y‘ ‘é :;.u in accafdaricé with {aw am m canfarm§fy wiih ifié Fiarmé; am} caaéi‘iwaa m‘ gram. The pérsens L‘ke :h‘e petimrwrs cams: éme treated agifferemw fa! tg'gagmen: Wm“; regami ta aiiotment Q? any of zhe Wang/#0:.” $ha§$ canstmstw unéer the EntggiaEd Devgbgment GE smaik anéj Miédle TmImS $§hema it £5 Mia that the ggiitioners have t9 camgeté with $imilariy dmumatanced Qtham and if the request made by the kmrned \ x Ceur‘isei far i'he péfifiomrs f0 aflat thaw gita; is acCéa‘éé i0, it wauté vkikafé Ariéclé M msiuiates. m €h3i‘ mew of €he matter. {am nat mdmen‘ ta grant mamiamus ta t'r‘xe petiibners aommandmg the Mun§c§pa¥ Ccaasii. Ehatapara ta au.a: amps 9m a? twenPMwr sham canstruatag by it Lmder *he mteggied Deygiagment e§ $mal! anti. Middla Tgxngng §ghemex {§% i. h wever. find C$as§éérai5€e ‘ferce fn the whggsgion 0f the =eame§ ceangsi fer the get'széener mat the Mumcipai Council havmg kept EMS and 1/4é“ cog: 9f the shws in its; packs? fer mughiy six yearg, sheuid :wt be ammgd to make unlawfu! gain and it 5h9L4id be‘cjiregied ‘m reigm‘j EMD a5 we“ a3 174:“ cf the construction cost of the Shops depmsited by we petiiioners Wiih reasonabie rate 5f interest. if is we“ gei‘tled tha2 fhe $i‘iié, Sin-aw Auihori‘iiég am: msrrumérifaiifiés o? $€a€e camst b9 pe‘r‘miiiéti in maka wmrigful gaéns éuf af théér mm wrmgs. The wmi‘ig is w me pan 6f {he Mumcipal Sauna? 'm n0: €ransiaténg premise made to the patitianera vide anctment craters daied UE/'!2!’!E2§8. We Mammal Sounsii havéng 11: ‘ ceiiested censédeabm sums 9f maney in the year 1&98 mL;5t have Lgssed ihat mangy far it§ awn. purpase ail thgse yeaia Lncjking fram that angle ai$o, it would not have any legitimate giievance to pay i'ea$onabie AL N «.34, iriierea ié) in tha raguit and fa): ihg fmegging reasgns, i aiigw the writ pgtitign ih part. A directim shaii i$sue ta the Municipal Councii, Bhatagvara — the first respondent it) refund EMS and ’ii4th of the censiruciion coa‘i d‘epasited by tha pQiitioners, with intemsi @‘12% §9r am‘ium from the daie 6f démgit iiii §3éymérit T‘r‘ié g5étiiiéi1er$ are aisié jéi‘riti’y é'r‘ititléd ta :ogi of / i§1i$ Wfét peiiiiér‘x W ‘ The remud shad l kue made wifh interest wifhin a geriod 6f Mo manths. ,, v_\>/,’—/—’ Sdl— I $HIEF $U$Tl$5 3Qimf2Q§$ Ix is qua‘ntifiéci at RsaiOGOl‘ payabié Wi€hir1 a momth,