•I-T."I~L.\~L^- .i'-:t:n^ ^.rf,- IN THE HIGH CC»URTOP CHHATRSOARH AT BILASPUR WRIT PETITIQN (227) No. ^^ ^Of 2008 PETITIONER /. ^fP^i-fttVT^iy d^ .^^^ I-?. l» ^g^-" 3-^£--"" y <^.. ^••:^^-" LaMian Lal S/o Shri Mahesh Prasad , aged about 62 years, resident oT ViIIage Umariya , Tahsil Mungeli, District Bilaspur (CG). VERSUS •'RESPONDENTS /•• The State of Cfahattisgarh, throu^i the Secretary, Departraent of Revenue, Matitralay, D.K..S. BuUdmg, Raipur (CG): 4, The Collector , Bilaspur (CGj. Bilaspur District The Sub Divisianal Officer/Prescribed Authority, Mungeli, District Bflaspur (CG). The Naib Tafasildar, Mungeli, District Bilaspur (CG). %/ WRIT PETITtQN UNDER_AKFICLE CONSTITUTION OF INDiA OFTHE .\a~ ^ ^- I^HGOUI^OII^HH^TteeftNl^TBIl.ASPUft SinclteiBi&lchEHon'bl&Shii^usBcBlRiastiantKunaBUislii'a PETmONER RESPONDeNtS WrttFtemcm^2ai7VlNo.^BBT2^2008 1-akKanl.at Vwsus TheState^CWttitti^art'iarKlottwis. Sntt;R|nyKoytaF,cpt^eK'Eorttii ^eUK»ier. Shn ^ay ^DiJriii/edi,?^D^jMiiy ^^m^"hment '.A<K®caBaL;K»^Ithe^ :WI^!REaiQ(iyNDB;taiKH®KB^fe^^^ SB3Bffli@£rEwrS';:rZ::^::'3:'I?w': ^.•'i6ttM;;:Ott R::-^'^''.. : ; , ' \: -, :y'u?i.:(!i5ii»^o)-:^:;':' : : . ProoBefJliTOund^ttre (henceforth IhBAe^ 19^ ::\rtlteige,—yma^^"l|E^^-||^|^||^||-^]^||s^^ lRynrfiasid'1hei|:sdb^^|^j^|n||||g^||B^aj|te|^i(^||||i|^ ;d^|^|juiiji't^;|i|iiiii|i|iNt^: •".::.^:;::":'r :.;::';::1:: .'1 M ;^:':r.^^^f®l|^e||j|^|a^^|^|gi||||K*i^.<malc^ 92^acr <^jyndNW^^II^^| i^^iNNy^to arelthe rems^jng 38^gaci^wf^ d^llail assi ofsta<^enttmj^sub^^t^j1N^a^^ct»1l'?SS,; '(3), 1 :The:'p^Bttc>r^ja{^ea^,|^hav^n»^^ Gomp^nt Auttloi^^ynder-W|||i^it|!5@i|N!Me^ .^'•'-^^^'^•.^^"^' '-•'•••.' this ot^ec^^v^;'°mo^.^iuid^iSa ori;;i32'i^^y^ ;^'••-l-:-'^^^-^-^'^::^-^^••^;:':^ ^Rwenue' Code,^1^^(t]nanoB|^|||||iej©c^^|a^||(^ ty1he-6i:TOP<*^?^Mtt*°^:!ifflM8i sii^i^^^s^;lll! •fe.N P/^i and,finat^dsej^lJBer|(^|||ia||e<!l|3E|1i-4i^ reBe^^';,Wi.1i^^flettliwie^|||MS«(ionyt^i||^lj©(^^ i^f^ |i:s;Affiair ^ ;:ii N1 :lil 11 B'T .xssassa / ^\: a.- l!ii,i % l.ii if^ : f:.; prefefred an asCTieat before ttte Addittomit GoBedw, Btospur; whfch w® rqected on 26-07-1^4 (AnnexureP^. (4) To ehattei^e the twciw pas^d by i^ AdteBionat;X>)ttecaim 26-07-1994 the-peUBonar preferFaftwrit pettion No. W4 wtneti wis tatsr onv^KilTawnfcetereSusCoiMton^'June.ZOOS. ^) LeaniedcotWtSelforthepeitttonetWouM^subnAthatlhe^peBBt^ not been heanl lie{^ pasai^ ttwwdwpa^ed tqr the Compe^ifcSuttionty and usthepres8(*peU^isnKuntmrodteifiwnettcounsel^wxd(^^ submfls Ihat the petiUoner is bonafide purctoisw of tend arot was?wdittBdto rrtain fhs sainne and ttw unMismed<wteTtlwfinW1»^s^^ [6) ^uiAjayDwwB^lean^coureel'fwtheStato peBtion,woi^aigue"thatttieA pettHonw (rasi^^tallwigi^^^i(dara^ffla<te the Act, Wtwd^ii^iM^ett'ii^fll^l^jthess^^ not oi^ aiBera ft^ i,n^>lam^^i^?a^ deseive dismissal on flierits. (7) tn the ore passed ^ ^ Gonqieton^ (Annenttwa P^ jt has bew ntBnBffned tt^ttiaappiBmted (toteun^ 19®>fe01-0'(fl-t974^»td^O;7-^-1|S74. ^e^on 5 o( the Act makes (xxnteion res^n®re^ictj^^^raU'is^N^ib div®ore<rf^^ andK»re^p.i«t^ <rf transtor w subiGBvisioinSmiiletiR'oln^^ Se<^on{1)<rfSecfion5K^!d^nebmth^n<fii^an^^ iawiw Ihe (metoeit^tetort^^lai^ ^^SUeMnBKfetred^N^^ w»yoT sste(mchidh®^&iR!a<SGtM^5<<ladec^ofacW<^rtOT^ai^ onter of any cthw law^^ufflwM^ OT^^^^^^ ottwfwiw: wynffiafinaloi'^iun^S^ pennission inwfitK%rfthe Golte^or. tBitee or jwBKtta i'i' lii f;( .?^ @ :-13- ; . . ®Apparently and on tte petittoner^ ownshowii^ ha hie pufehisedthe land on 29-07-1974. Thwa is nrthing in the record ofIhe wrft peUtion and no stertement hs®been made ly the pedfionw ttiat the land was^purchassd by hmisrftorseeldTOpenn^ionmwritinglr^ltteX^rf^^ —^' :" , -'1~'., '. ' '. ' • dtetrid. Thus, ^transa^on <rf pureh^<tf|aml ^lhe pe^r^ftom the hokter of the land was prohibted ;un<terSi8cAon 5 of th& Act anid the peGttoner has not acquired any r^hton the tond. Tt pdittoner could have prWarretf an a|^»eal^t^ny the final ^ Authority undwpthe Act, 1960 but ^ peW^ appeal, movedan a^iptteSBon Unclw Secfion 32 otttie eode iEnid when the saidaRplica^w^disnus^l^ttieSUbDwis^^ an appeat s^ moved before fiie Adllifional Coltedor,Bitaspur, wtud'i eame fobed^j^^^2S-(^19M^SftneBcui8l^.^ ::j:?s? ^•.:'::;^:l^^%s?;;',.;,ut^;igg?i<!;si!w.';';.: . .;^'-ti a^eal BiBforeEtlN3^E|(li^ftal|®|ri |Btor|Ut»^ proceedmg ather under Ihe Actor by filinga Writ p^itKm till Uw year 2004, to challengethe oider frassed by the Addifitmal GoUeetor on 26-0'7-1^4. E'ren ttle wrtt peUfion fitect in ttie year 20Q4 vras subsequently wiUKlrawn irii Jun®, 2(X)6andyetagain einstaiApeBU<mh^beenfitedmAugust,2008. ^ This ^ present petBton (^tenging (he onter PSE^ Gomprt^Au <^®n15-11-1975 aml?3(^t2-1S^ ^^fifderi^is^ by the Ai;kl(tk»nal|edtec^on3^7^994 <teser^tobe^^ ground of purcWssing iaWI m conttaNirtton of SecUon 5 of Uie i/tet as welt as onthe groundofuneiqstaineddelayandteffittw. (10) ThewritpeSUonisdismi^ad. t—~ Sd//-' , : Prashant Kumar Mishra Judge 1~ '^"". •^Si1 sS