^ BEFORE THE M.P. STATEADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL BENCH RAIPUR ^f^w^isy O.A N0.^B /2001 No ^? Flledlodsya^\(^\3\— bfSht' T<\«n\S;V^S-'l-iAr<rte—1^_ s. ^^ M. P. >.;.!-s • u'm^ nitiunal, RAIPUR. APPLICANT SANJAY KUMARDAS- SonofLateArjunDas Asstt. Professor Deptt. of Geography Govt. Girls College, Durg VERSUS f1»»" '%..* NON-APPLICANT 1. ..StateofC.G. through the Secretary DepartffientofHighefEd.ycation Govt."oTChhatti§garh, D.h&S.-BlfSvan.Raipur 2: Principal Gbvt. GirlsCollege, Burg ' OMlGINSLAPRElkSATION UNDERSECTION 190F THE M.R STftTE ADMINI§TRAnVETRIBUNALACT1985 m ^l^ ~^-t ^'":~^'^^^- j HIGHCOURTQRCHHATTISGARHATBILASPUR SINGLE BENCH : HON'BLE MR. SATISH K. AGNiHOTRI.J. WRITPETIT!ON(S.l N0.4428 OF 2005 Petitioner Respondents Versus Sanjay Kumar State of C.G. and another Petitioner Respondent CONTEMPTPETITION N0.118 OF 200S Sanjay Kumar Das versus Y.S.Beie Present : Mr. Maneesh Sharma, counsel for the petitioner in bcrth friepetitions. : .; :,^ . ::;,, . .,:;'; 'i.i:^ '''li Mr. V.V.S.Moorthy, Deputyi Advocatg Generai jvvith Mi". Ajayl Dwivedi, Ranelsi-awyer for the respondents/State in lfl'.P|{SQN6.4428?2Q!:©. 1 Mr.i IPankaj Shrivasiava, CQunsel for the respondent in Con^mpt P1N6.118S006. ^( SBR!:r:-' ^ : • (Passec!6n%2tK'oJ:l3cto!3ier,-2006) These are two petitiOns, i.e. 2005 and Confertipt Petitjpn; No.118 of arises ih ;the WFit pgtitiQn. Tlitis;;'tliie pefitienare;beingidis(36iSedof]B|('|t"ii^| ,Writ Petition (S.) No.4428 Of .! The icontem|rt| petitjon ;nt jfietitionf aha; thss ^atilgBiRt :0!rdter.:::.' ^ •:'i;1H wnt sa :lil ^. ::t:l: 1:8!81 Ea ^ s <.. vm 2( ?^ * Thea^iginal iapplication was fil^^^b administrative Tribunal, Beneh at Raipur, impugningthetransferorder dated 26-12-2001 (AnnexureA-1),wherebythepetitioneF,whowas working on -the post of Assistant Professer at Govemment '©irts Coliege.Duig, was transferred to1he Govemment College, Navagarh, OistrictDurg.^, '-,-, ; '. . : ' ;• /•.•: ;•' : . IS;'':^ 3. While admitting the petition, the TFibunal, byiK erciBB dated 9-1-2002, <grantedsteft qFUowithregardtotliepostingiof?the; petitioner as on 29-12-2001. L^rned eourisel for the petitioneRsubmjts that despite there bang the said;ore|er pf staftffi qi.io, p transfer ordier dated 3p-6^2QQ81i(Annexure G-3 jn Gontempt Petition No.11Sof20(ffi) was pass^d^ trmsferring ;tHe petitjoner to Government P.G. eotlegie, Jagdalpur.l HowevSi^ no effecttothesaiaiorderdate^ fllven. : '• , ,:• " :.: . 4. As a dated 9-1-2002, Girls Coltege, Dufg continueatone matter of fact, the petitioner, by way of interiml orcleiE remained postedlioii the same place, i.e., Governmenf for more than fouKyeai's. The [Setitioner ceuld not forever. ^ 5. itte ^ell s^led prineiRle^l^^thattFansferisanincidienfi of service and iti? officertemplpyee|be posted kaeping in view publie interest sis v- •' • '.'.''••;. ' • .. . ' • • . • ' / :'',:'-~''.":':.'": '. : .'.''•••;.'.'•', ':•.. ':'•'"• ..••:•::-\ !• :.'~^':•[••': • . • adfninistratiye exig&ncy; ThisC<wrl| ftNiliCTt^'Jun^ict^ ^it S^n^rimattersandthis^ttltea |of|;:Rroye(l!!;|mtte^^£^,:ifflon-coiiT(^^^j|jaf^|ttMn^ if EHiEiltrgrisfeiiS^relSr ;nSt for the employer ts deejde sjs 1;c> wHere a p^rticulai^ iN^lll?asi iiitBrfere! |»eijgg$i|ij;ieo(|ifermityj-wrEh;!th6!^ti| ;case|: !St"affli6^ li^l l.ill .!t^'^ !Sil •^yf. _,(••!' E ?regulaUons.N6neoftheat)c>vegroundsaFeavaiiabletothepetiiioner. In the facts and cireumstances of the case, it is not necessa'y t6 examine validity |of the transfer orelers at this stage. However, the respondents - authorities are directed not to insiston cQmpliance ofthe transferordere dated 26-12-2001 and 30-6-2006. ••"»•.. . '• ' ' 6. AcGordingly.thewritpetitionstandsdisposedofandthe contempt petitidn is dismissed. Notics to the respondent in !the| contempt petition is discharged. However, the respondents —! authorities are at liberty to pass appropriate order for posting fthe petitioner in public interest and administrative exigency, in accordarice with law. NOoryerastocosts. 7. AcopybfthisorderbSRlacedontherecordof^W^ contemptyetition. SdA Satish K. Agplhotri Judge :19SSS8iSI& t^l^l^^l?4!^i'^M^