Criminal Appeal (SJ) No.19 OF 1994 (Appeal against the Judgment and Order dated 12.01.1994 passed by the 3rd Additional Sessions Judge, Ara, in Sessions Trial No. 75 of 1987) 1. BABAN RAM, SON OF RADHA RAM 2. RAMDEO RAM, SON OF LATE BHUKHI RAM 3. RAMANAND RAM, SO OF ANANT RAM ALL RESIENTS OF VILLAGE DHAMNA, P.O. BHAKURA, P.S. TRARI, DISTT. BHOJPUR. ------ APPELLANTS. Versus THE STATE OF BIHAR ------------RESPONDENT For the Appellants : Mr. Vikram Deo Singh, Advocate. Mr. Binod Kumar, Advocate Mr. Dharmendra Kumar Singh, Advocate For the State : Mr. Choubey Jawahar, A.P.P. ----------- P R E S E N T THE HON'BLE JUSTICE SMT. ANJANA PRAKASH Anjana Prakash, J: Heard. The Appellants have been convicted under Section 392 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced to three year rigorous imprisonment by the 3rd Additional Sessions Judge, Arrah, by the Judgment dated 12.1.1994 passed in Sessions Trial No. 75 of 1987. The case of the prosecution is that on the night between 13/14.6.1986, a robbery was committed in the house of the Informant and buffaloes were stolen. In the transaction, the present Appeals were identified by the inmates of the house. The prosecution in all examined five witnesses out of whom PW-1 is the Informant whereas PW-2 is the brother of the 2 Informant and PW-4, the mother of the Informant deposed as eye witness. PW-3 is hear-say whereas PW-5 is formal in nature. Neither the Investigating Officer nor any independent witness has been examined in this case. On behalf of the defence, one witness was examined who stated that he was used to live adjacent to the house of the Informant and had gone to his house after the occurrence but neither the Informant nor any of the witnesses disclosed the names of the Appellants. It also appears that there is land dispute between the parties and under the circumstances it is quite likely that they were falsely implicated on this account and therefore difficult to accept the prosecution case narrated by the Informant and his witnesses. In the result, the Appeal is allowed. The order of conviction and sentence passed against the Appellants in Sessions Trial No. 75 of 1987 by the 3rd Additional Sessions Judge, Ara, is hereby set aside. The Appellants are discharged from the liability of their bail bonds. Patna High Court, Patna Dated, the 19th April, 2011 NAFR/S.ALI ( Anjana Prakash, J.)