IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.2371 of 2010 1. SANTOSH KUMAR @SANTOSH KUMAR SINGH S/O LATE RAM NAGINA SINGH R/O VILL & P.O.CHINTAMANPUR,P.S.PIPRA,DISTT-EAST CHAMPARAN AT MOTIHARI Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH THE CHIEF SECRETARY GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR,PATNA 2. THE CHAIRMAN,BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION P.O.VETERINARY COLLEGE ,PATNA 3. THE SECRETARY,BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION P.O.VETERINARY COLLEGE,PATNA 4. THE JOINT SECRETARY,BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION P.O.VETERINARY COLLEGE,PATNA 5. THE SECRETARY ,PERSONNEL AND ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS DEPARTMENT GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR,PATNA with CWJC No.2243 of 2010 1. KAUSHAL KISHORE TRIPATHI S/O RAM CHANDRA TRIPATHI R/O VILL.- KAPARPURA, P.S. KANKE, DISTT.- MUZAFFARPUR, AT PRESENT RESIDING AT KANKARBAGH, P.S. KANKARBAGH, DISTT.- PATNA 2. BINOD KUMAR S/O INDRA MANI SINGH R/O VILL. P.O. AND P.S. NAVANAGAR, DISTT.- BUXAR 3. RAKESH KUMAR S/O RAMA KANT KUMAR R/O SAVITRI SADAN, MAHAVIR PATH, WEST PATEL NAGAR, P.S. SHASTRI NAGAR,DISTT.- PATNA 4. KUMAR VIVEK S/O SHRI ANAND MOHAN SINGH R/O MOHAN NIWAS, SHIVPURI, P.S. SHASTRI NAGAR, DISTT.- PATNA 5. VINOD KUMAR SINGH S/O BABULAL SINGH R/O DUDHALA, P.S. JAMHAUR, DISTT.- AURANGABAD Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR, THROUGH ITS CHIEF SECRETARY OLD SECRETARIAT BUILDING, PATNA 2. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, PERSONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS DEPARTMENT, OLD SECRETARIAT BUILDING, PATNA 3. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, TRANSPORT VISHESHWARAIYA BHAWAN, BAILEY ROAD, PATNA 4. THE STATE TRANSPORT COMMISSIONER, GOVT. OF BIHAR VISHESHWARAIYA BHAWAN, BAILEY ROAD, PATNA 5. BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION THROUGH ITS SECRETARY VETENARY COLLEGE CAMPUS, PATNA 6. THE CHAIRMAN, BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION VETENARY COLLEGE CAMPUS, PATNA 7. THE SECRETARY, BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION VETENARY COLLEGE CAMPUS, PATNA with CWJC No.2338 of 2010 1. SANJEEV KUMAR SINGH S/O SRI GOPAL PRASAD SINGH R/O MOHALLA- VIVEKANAND COLONY, NEAR KALI MANDIR, P.O.- SAHAYAK, P.S.- K. GHAT, DISTT.- PURNEA Versus 2 1. BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, PATNA P.O.- VETENARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN 2. THE SECRETARY BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, PATNA, P.O.- VETENARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 with CWJC No.2354 of 2010 1. ARCHANA KUMARI W/O KAUSHALENDRA KUMAR R/O VILL.- DARIYACHAK, P.S. EKANGAR SARAI, DISTT.- NALANDA PRESENTLY RESIDING AT A/7, RBI OFFICER'S FLAT, LOHIA NAGAR, KANKARBAGH, P.S. KANKARBAGH, DISTT.- PATNA Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR 2. COMMISSIONER-CUM-SECRETARY TRANSPORT DEPARTMENT, GOVT. OF BIHAR, PATNA 3. BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN VETERINARY COLLEGE, P.S. GARDANIBAGH, PATNA 4. SECRETARY BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, VETERINARY COLLEGE, P.S. GARDANIBAGH, PATNA with CWJC No.2379 of 2010 1. MRITUNJAY KUMAR SINGH S/O RAM SUNDAR SINGH R/O VILL GOH, GOLAPAR,P.S.GOH,DIST-AURANGABAD Versus 1. BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION PATNA P.O.VETENARY COLLEGE,PATNA-14 THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN 2. THE SECRETARY ,BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION PATNA ,P.O.VETENARY COLLEGE,PATNA-14 with CWJC No.2570 of 2010 1. CHANDRA PRAKASH S/O SHRI NARENDRA KUMAR VERMA R/O MOHALLA- CHANDMARI EKWANA, P.S. MOTIHARI, DISTT.- EAST CHAMPARAN 2. SATYENDRA NARAYAN MISHRA S/O SHRI PHULENA MISHRA R/O MOHALLA- BALUA TAL, P.S. MOTIHARI, DISTT.- EAST CHAMPARAN Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR, THROUGH THE COMMISSIONER, DEPTT. OF TRANSPORT, GOVT. OF BIHAR AT PATNA 2. THE BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY, POST- VETERINARY COLLEGE, DISTT.- PATNA with CWJC No.2584 of 2010 1. SANTOSH KUMAR SINGH S/O LATE SUNDAR PRASAD SINGH R/O SAVERA SADAN, ROAD NO. 1, POSTAL PARK, P.S.- KANKARBAGH, DISTT.- PATNA Versus 1. BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, PATNA, P.O.- VETENARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN 2. THE SECRETARY, BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, PATNA, P.O.- VETENARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 3 with CWJC No.2592 of 2010 NELESH KUMAR . Versus THE BIHAR STATE SELECTION COMM . with CWJC No.2595 of 2010 1. NISHANT KUMAR S/O SHRI RAM SHEKHAR SINGH R/O MOHALLA- BARI POKHAR, POKHARIA (NEAR DR. N.R.SINGH), P.O.- BEGUSARAI, P.S. TOWN THANA, BEGUSARAI, DISTT.- BEGUSARAI Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TRANSPORT DEPTT., BISHWESARAIYA BHAWAN, PATNA 2. BIHAR KARMACHARI CHAYAN AYOG, PATNA, P.O.- VETNARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 THROUGH ITS SECRETARY with CWJC No.2596 of 2010 1. SANJAY KUMAR S/O SRI BIRENDRA PRASAD SRIVASTAVA R/O CHANDRA VILLA, BAHADURPUR HOUSING COLONY, EAST SECTOR-6, P.S. AGAMKUAN, DISTT.- PATNA Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH STATE TRANSPORT COMMISSIONER, TRANSPORT DEPTT., GOVT. OF BIHAR 2. THE BIHAR STATE SELECTION COMMISSIONER THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN, POST-VETANARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 3. THE SECRETARY, BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, POST- VETANARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 with CWJC No.2600 of 2010 1. ARUN KUMAR S/O LATE RAM NARESH SINGH R/O BHUSHAN LANE, EAST LOHANIPUR, P.S.- KADAMKUAN, DISTT.- PATNA Versus 1. BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, PATNA, P.O.- VETENARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN 2. THE SECRETARY, BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, PATNA, P.O.- VETENARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 with CWJC No.2602 of 2010 1. RAJIV RANJAN S/O SRI MANGAL SINGH R/O VILL. AND P.O. MUJRAR VIA NOKHA, P.S. NOKHA, DISTT.- ROHTAS Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH STATE TRANSPORT COMMISSIONER, TEANSPORT DEPTT., GOVT. OF BIHAR 2. THE BIHAR STATE SELECTION COMMISSIONER THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN POST- VETANARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 3. THE SECRETARY BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, POST- VETANARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 with CWJC No.2604 of 2010 4 1. HARENDRA KUMAR S/O SRI LATE H.P.SINGH R/O MOHALLA- KUNWAR SINGH NAGAR, JANTA ROAD, NEW YARPUR, P.O.- G.P.O., P.S.- GARDANIBAGH, DISTT.- PATNA Versus 1. THE CHAIRMAN, BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, VETERINARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 2. THE SECRETARY, BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, VETERINARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 3. THE EXAMINATION CONTROLLER, BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, VETERINARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 with CWJC No.2605 of 2010 1. KAMAKHAYA NARAYAN SINGH S/O SRI RAMCHANDRA SINGH R/O VILL.- SHIVPUR, P.S. NOKHA, DISTT.- ROHTAS Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH STATE TRANSPORT COMMISSIONER TRANSPORT DEPTT., GOVT. OF BIHAR 2. THE BIHAR STATE SELECTION COMMISSIONER THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN POST-VETANARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 3. THE SECRETARY, BIHAR STATE SELECTION COMMISSIONER, POST- VETANARY COLLEGE, PATNA-14 with CWJC No.2654 of 2010 1. SANJAY KUMAR TIGER S/O SHRI RAMJI PRASAD R/O MANGLANAGER RAMCHANDERPUR, P.S. LAHERI, DISTT.- NALANDA Versus 1. THE SECRETARY, BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION PATNA-14 2. THE STATE TRANSPORT COMMISIONER BIHAR, PATNA 3. THE FACTORY INSPECTOR BIHAR SHARIF CIRCLE, NALANDA, BIHAR SHARIF 4. THE FACTORY INSPECTOR PATNA CIRCLE, PATNA with CWJC No.2667 of 2010 1. PRADEEP KUMAR DUBEY S/O SRI YADUNATH DUBEY R/O NEW AREA, HAMIDGANJ, P.S.- DALTENGANJ, DISTT.- DALTENGANJ ( JHARKHAND ) Versus 1. BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, PATNA P.O.- VETNARY COLLEGE, PATNA- 14 THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN 2. THE SECRETARY, BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, PATNA P.O.- VETENARY COLLEGE, PATNA- 14 with CWJC No.2712 of 2010 1. SUJEET KUMAR S/O SRI KRISHNA PASWAN R/O MOH.- GUR KI MUNDI, P.O.- GULJARBAGH, P.S.- ALAMGANJ, DISTT.- PATNA Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR 2. THE TRANSPORT COMMISSIONER TRANSPORT DEPTT. STATE OF BIHAR 3. THE BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION PATNA 5 4. THE SECRETARY, BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION P.O.- VETNARY COLLEGE, SEIKHPURA, PATNA- 14 with CWJC No.2800 of 2010 1. RANJAY KUMAR S/O KEDAR PRASAD SINGH R/O MOH SRI HARSHNAGAR,P.S. MITHANPURA, DISTT-MUZAFFARPUR Versus 1. BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION PATNA ,P.O.VETENARY COLLEGE,PATNA-14,THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN 2. THE SECRETARY ,BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION PATNA,P.O. VETENARY COLLEGE,PATNA-14 with CWJC No.2787 of 2010 BRAJESH KUMAR . Versus THE BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMM . with CWJC No.2808 of 2010 1. BINOD KUMAR S/O SRI RAM NARESH PRASAD SINGH R/O VILL KHANWAN(MADANPUR),P.S.NARHAT,DISTT-NAWADA,PRESENTLY RESIDENT OF H/O SUMITRA DEVI(SUMITRA BHAWAN)VIKASH COLONY,ROAD NO.2,SANDALPUR,PATNA Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR 2. COMMISSIONER -CUM-SECRETARY,TRANSPORT DEPARTMENT GOVT.OF BIHAR,PATNA 3. BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN VETERINARY COLLEGE,P.S.GARDANIBAGH,PATNA 4. SECRETARY,BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION VETERINARY COLLEGE, P.S. GARDANIBAGH,PATNA with CWJC No.2809 of 2010 1. SANJAY KUMAR ASHK @SANJAY KUMAR S/O LATE SURYADEEP PRASAD SRIVASTAVA R/O MOH DHARAMPUR,TAJPUR ROAD,P.S.TOWN,DISTT-SAMASTIPUR Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH THE CHIEF SECRETARY SECRETARIAT,BIHAR,PATNA 2. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY ,PERSONNEL AND ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS DEPARTMENT CHIEF MINISTER SECRETARIAT,BIHAR,PATNA 3. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARIAT,TRANSPORT VISHESHWARAIYA BHAWAN,PATNA 4. THE STATE TRANSPORT COMMISSIONER null GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR,VISHESWARAIYA BHAWAN,BAILEY ROAD,PATNA 5. THE BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY VETERINARY COLLEGE CAMPUS,PATNA 6. THE CHAIRMAN ,BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION VETERINARY COLLEGE CAMPUS,PATNA 7. THE SECRETARY ,BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION VETERINARY COLLEGE CAMPUS,PATNA 6 ----------- For the Staff Selection Commission :- Mr. P.K. Shahi, Sr. Adv. Mr. Vipin Kumar, Adv. Mr. S.S. Sundram, Adv. -------------- 2. 18.2.2010 Heard learned counsel for the petitioners and learned counsel for the Commission. This batch of writ applications relates to the selection of Motor Vehicle Inspectors by interview only. For a total of 59 vacancies approximately 183 applications were received. On scrutiny only nine were found eligible to be called for interview. The others have been found ineligible to be called for interview leading to the institution of the present applications. Learned counsel for the Commission very fairly states that given the miniscule number of candidates who have been found eligible to be called for the interview and the large scale finding of ineligibility, the Commission in all fairness proposes to re-scrutinize the applications including those nine who have been called for interview to take a fresh decision by a committee headed by the Secretary of the Commission and two Senior Officers from the Department of Transport and Personnel and then issue fresh interview calls to those who fulfil the conditions of the advertisement. This Court in C.W.J.C. No. 15243 of 2009 had 7 given specific directions for commencement of the interview by 22.2.2010 and in pursuance of which interview calls have been issued to the nine persons found eligible. This Court considers it proper to accede to the request of the Commission that such re-scrutiny of the 183 applications shall be completed by the 18th of March 2010 and that the interviews of those found eligible shall commence from the 12th of April 2010. Counsels for the petitioners have no objection if the fresh communication for interviews are published both by a press communiqué and on the web-site of the Commission apart from other modes that the Commission may or think proper. The writ application stands disposed. P. Kumar (Navin Sinha, J.)