ttil iK NK- es. ^^' aas EfSni'-s BSiSSS naai W3S9S'H'':S- iiBISi^lJiiTCTEABMINISTFWTIVE TRIBUNALBENeHRAIPUR APPLICANT NON'APPLICANT O.A.NO \\e/^ •c4^^Gr /2001 Fileoi. i>y ••ii. ~'~SW:\T^\ ^gA^.^ JRANA fty Reg/^ar, .SWSflQP.State sa/n^ rritouflia;, or RW'SUR. .•.v;-.'.\snrW(8t*'" ABHINESHSli SonpfShril.ft Asstt.Profes^ Deptt.ofHindi' Govt. Coltege, Utai Distt.Durg(C.G.) VERSUS 1. -StateofC.G. through the Se&retary. Department of Higher Education Govt, of Chhattisgarh,' . D.K.S.Bhavan,Raipur 2. Principal Govt. Coilege, Utaj Djstt.DurgC.G.) ORlGINAt-APRLtCATIONU'NOERSECTIQNel 90FTi-iEMJ3.STXTE ADMINISTRffl'IVETRIBUNALACt 1.985 J l ,UI»'|iiWk H!GH COURTOFCHHftTTISGARHATBILASPUR SiNGLE BENCH : HON'BLE MR. SATiSH K. AGNIHOTRL.i, WRIT PET1TION (S.l N0.4422 OF 2005 Petitioner Respondents Versus Abhinesh Surana StateofC.G. and another Present : Mr. ManeeshSharma.counselforthepetitioner. ' Mr. V.V.S.Moorthy, Deputy Advocate General with Mr. AjayDwh/edi, Panei l..awyerfortherespon<ients/State. s ORDER (Passed on 12m^)f October, 2006) •The!, origjna! applieatjoni was filed before the State Administrativg Tribarial, Bench at Raipur, impughing the transfer order dated 28-12-2001 ^AnnexureA-1);whereby the petitioner, who was working on the post of Assistant Professor at Government Coilege, Utai, District Durg, Iwas transferred to the Government ColiegSt'Saja; DistrictDurg.: : r ! .:::: :: :.::' ; : : '•!,'':'.r 2. White admiffing the petitioh,the ffribiana!, b^ dated 9-1 -2002, granted stetos q'(»with resard to the posting |o^l|^| petitioner as on28-12-2001 .Learnedcounsel foF thi6;petiti®nei;^ubj!HJi^| thatby virtue of the interini order, the pefiti<>nei- js cc)ntinuing|6n|it|^|i same: place:iof:posting, i .e .,: Gcivern][nsniR©:»l||ge,iUta|iE>iStn l|^a.|:; m Vi'Mi m :!il!i!] v tlli a'ffi IB s iSii mr v\ Ml m SRSSSSiSHSMS Bs—fillBff MicS:^fiWSWs'X ffESKJVSOffMW i"ai'a'iiRs<i ^?.s -iS'l' 3. ' ^WnaatteFc^fai^itheijp^iBcmer has got ^^ Wayofinterim.si^sr^nd^t^pietitioiMiRfT^^beendn^^^^ :mpre::thartl:fouK^^R.r:;'FI^^RetiUQraer|c<^tj3unQ^ forever. -::. ^l:: •' •:-•:::: : '•''•^:^:;^'::': :;'-:i' '!^.^ .';:iR:^ll::']^ ^ is:^lHiNtll^ii|s^^d:'Rra^il^Dt^siy?t^^an^ri€^ :y-swl%^:gSA*^:^.K.t.''5'&'B^B^^ c^service^ndgi|isfc>r^eiemp|6^iio^§c^eas^ ofRcer/employeSlbeposfetfl^ping^nviewlpybl^ administratiye exigency; ^his©Qurtt^ with thetrans!^^attei^and1this?€;ourt^n;irTtertBrepnlyw^ ofrproY^,|n7a^^,non-compet^GetQf^uthorify;pdssingitMetra orcler arrel; iransfer Srder not ^ihig?jn eonformity aath the rules |?and regulations^ In^the facts ahdiScireumstSiic^ o^ the casiegit is{ Not neGessaijy^t6;'e>tami|ie'validit^iM»theit;tFan^F®rder^ Howey^r, the resRbndents — ^jtlioiatiesilai'e^diEeGted not to||>insistion CQmpliance 6(;r ithe impugnecll 'tiansfsr^ord^rl.dated; 2^-!1i2-2G|)1 (i?tnnexui;esA-1)^,L:":,:,.. .''..:'^::.':]WB:lt\:1;^ 5. ^SvpetitionifiasIB^orftg^nfpii^oust^th thei^ ^^:^mMW& time. ;' • .AcGordmSly, .^he^ge^|Bnt|jisMi|^sSe(i^?as?y^ngjj; m ^.'M. a;4; ::'..;^'-::l. '::^^'': i: .^••^ "Bi;'t Ej'i; infruc'tuous.''.. H^ever^the^r^iillllln^lllaiffioffl IareJ! at|lii»ei^ii|c( ^^:^;';tiJS 31|Sil$sSBsj^Aii^:I^.V..'i!:A;jl:^IIN;t^^ pass'1approprialB|<>rd^lfOR^os!t|gi§|l^||>^tK:ffl|tj^|piufiliC^ :'.'-i:^^'S;;'i£HSS^'KS!*!ikI»3t:.^;i^3'5;tS^ admi:niSti^\re^gencygin^efiff|a^Fii;liMSgi^^i^og6i^Ras|^3eo^^ »Si» iBII KSS. !;.si^;i:?': SdA SadshK Judge 1118 •ill!l 111311 •w !hit iiait