HgGH Ci§u$i§” {3F $%€H§3T?i$i§§R§-i §T @‘Lw$PU§v& Uni $2 LagI- ‘H C§RAM1 H iR£dAGU§$§4 £HALLA ixg? QJ‘ hUN’ELg SE‘H 3A §$%§ K £33mh§$§i .3 n Wm emaeMC‘ .o 3uizaf z%§“’ Exemimer Subash Momgsatra Ageci a'bem 34 yeal's, 3/0 Late Shi' Ja§andhay Eviohaoatra, Rio Mk: - 2g, Sahayag Fark, Mahaveer Nagalr, Ravigi‘am Pa” Raipm Shhattiwam - 492 0‘31 Vewus sm Umon of indie Ministry of Harre mums Cawmm .t cf §n NM; Earn me o§‘ Ch*3a€:?§sgarh, Taraugh ' ”he Qw: Secwta; Q- vemn‘er‘t cf Umawsgai nx uK’e nhawan, Mama aya, Raipur (£36) i5. ‘§”hmugh r4“ xxiv O~ (2 3‘ 3w m ?S f/I&m .1 :3 :3! Depavmen’: of Hcme ovemment OT Lnnattx gafh {5%} x wnr‘ Em Myax Raw Ir {CC‘ A VE‘m-va Ranjarx Additionai Eiractm §r£$§§iganse gaveau Gavemmem of 5n i W“: Pemm uwar Amue 2 ’8 of me Con$titutisn of injg d Respomkmg }‘l\ (3i (I? (DU m,m3 m. LU aié3sgarh, Ra‘ipur (CG) Preae at : Srw Sam-am i3argi counsei ?or ihe pa‘éimner. his S h 3emvag, 3*ardK.,g "e nsei §ar Union of Mdiai iam mo 1 bnn Qrasnan? msiva hevecwe benem wvzn .anri ;aahvmt .wh, C43\-¢mwm* Awacam r0! *hv Stab SM enawam if r comsai mr re wrunm \m & “ “J €3§§si i§a$s£aé§ er: 2&2“ $ci‘awa 2%?) The ¥oiicw§hg era? order of e Caurt was passsea' by ih Ho§§aia $ag§§$h Exhagi'a. iig. CAL G r - L Y'e$ierday, ieamed counsei §or the pet‘moner §nsiste§ that ‘24 hours time be aiiowed for fmng re§o§nder afficiawt, Hawever. tociay aga‘m he is §ns§sting far mriher i§me. Through this peiét‘goaw the pei‘xfioaer has prayed for §ssaamze of a wiii m me namre of qHa-warfama against resg’mndent Nag; who ja‘med as Dimctor Genera} of Ponce, C‘nhatiisgarh on the gmund that respondent N04 has aiready atiamed ihe age of supefannuation on 31 43332067. Them§ore, it was grayed that a Wr%*i o? quo—warranto be issyuea ousimg respomient No.4 fmm Ehe pos‘t in question. Tm record has bean piacea‘ befora us and we have $30 perusgd i‘ne fecwci‘ §t has bees’} canteriéea‘ Qr‘. berm? of the resmndems that *xe date 0? bm‘a of respemjem Ncxzi is 6%644952 and he has been amasinted as Diractor Geaemé cf Poz‘ice, Chiaat’iisgam in accomame w§th Saw. Leamem‘ coLmseE fsr the gaeiit'ioner ¥a§§ec§ i0 mdiwie any gmund which couid iead U$ t0 :he pom: :hat wagonc‘iem NGA was appgimed a5 Direc‘mr Generai m’ Fame, C‘nhamsgam in véo§aticn of iaw or on i‘rxe gmund of mola fide, The record prodaced and med before th‘is Court dear‘éy indicates beyond any ciou'o: ‘z‘ne’i the éete of bm’h of ¥e$pondem No.4 is m «04-1 952. We have anaiwiceiw exammeol fhe :‘na‘i‘ier'ffom another angie Le. if we take the aygument of memeo oouneei {0" “ihe petitioner foe-2 :he date of birEn o?‘ {eeponéené No.4 ée (Si—$44947, in such circumsiences respondens: Noe couéd no: have appeefeo‘ m ‘the wriiien ~‘j examination hekj by Un‘son Pubiie Service Commiseion for eotry in SM; Sewiees for 1972 batch being over-aged. Furiher, if me date of birth of reseomdem No.4 es. aueged ioy ihe oet‘xtionez has beer: modifieeicoirected, i‘nen E: was open is) che£§enge We f§n§t§§ei the some i5 not under chei§enge We one feat neither there ie any videeoo r 0f iaw by the competeni autmriiy whEle issuing ietter a‘f appointmeni nor there is any ai!egation of male fide. We further find ghat re$p0ndent NoA has not u$urped any amce as ailaged §n Eght of “the fact tha‘c he joined the (ffice of Director Ganera! 0f Poiice, Chhamsgarh on the basis of vaiici Qrder of appainimeni. m ‘ihe light of above, we are of the considewd opinion that the petitionei has faiiaci to substantiato any ground §0I issuance of a wrii‘ in the mime oi qua-warranio or any vioiation of stairway provisionolruies. Accordingiy, it is no: a fit case for issuance of writ of quo-wawanto as prayed and the Wm petition So ci‘ssmisoed‘ Coois subbu easy. wwwm Sd/— Sdl— Acting Chief Justice “r ii is Satish K. Agnihotri Judge