Board Sr.No.:-2 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO. 1152 OF 2002 Ngo Alliance For Governance And Renewal(nagar)) ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) LODGING NO. 290 OF 2014 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And 2 Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And 2 Ors.and A-1, Welfare Society(regd.) And 2 Ors (applicants/org.intervener ....RESPONDENT WITH INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 6465 OF 2022 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Shivaji Shrirang Taware ....PETITIONER V/S City Space And 5 Others ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 7 OF 2003 In Page 1/23 WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S Nityanand Co-op.hsg. Soc. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 8 OF 2003 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S Lokmanya Tilak Co-op.hsg. Socy. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 30 OF 2003 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S Friends Of Society ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 253 OF 2003 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Mah. And Ors. And Vasuki Nagraj Co.op. Hsg. Soc. ....RESPONDENT WITH Page 2/23 CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 254 OF 2003 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Mah. And Ors. And Milan Subway Co-op. Hsg. Soc. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 261 OF 2003 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Basera Co-op. Hsg. Soc. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 326 OF 2003 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Mah. And Ors. And S. K. S. Enterprises ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 328 OF 2003 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citi Space And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S Page 3/23 State Maharashtra And Ors. Bhagwan Shriram Co-op. Hsg. Soc. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 337 OF 2003 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citiy Space And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Shivneri Co-op. Hsg. Soc. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 338 OF 2003 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citi Space And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Mah. And Ors. And Borivali Eksar Dongri Samata Co-op. Hsg. Soc. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 5 OF 2005 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citi Space An Association Of Persons And Ors.....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Dharmendra V. Kanade ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 29 OF 2005 Page 4/23 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 30 OF 2005 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Pranchashil Rahivashi Seva Sangh ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 31 OF 2005 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Mah. And Ors. And Shree Kartik Swamy Seva Mandal ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 20 OF 2006 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citi Space And Ors ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors Nuttan Nagar Page 5/23 Co-op Hsg. Soc.ltd ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 130 OF 2006 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 City Space And 2 Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And 2 Ors. And Sant Gyaneshwar S.r.a. Co-op Housing Society (prop.)-(applicant ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 195 OF 2006 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 M/s. Citispace And 2 Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S The State Of Maharashtra And 2 Ors. And Vishnu D. Kalgude ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 82 OF 2008 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Alex Fernandes ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 107 OF 2008 Page 6/23 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Os. And Bhagwan R. Banerji And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 60 OF 2009 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Devraj Ratanchand Pagaria And Anr. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 31 OF 2010 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Ajitnagar Co-op. Hsg. Soc.(proposed) ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 227 OF 2010 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S Page 7/23 State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 143 OF 2011 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S The State Of Maharashtra ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 579 OF 2010 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S The State Of Maharashtra ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 237 OF 2011 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 3 OF 2012 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER Page 8/23 V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Hubtown Limited - Applicant ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 297 OF 2012 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citi Space And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 5 OF 2013 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Shivneri Navgruh Nirman Vitbhatti Sra.co-op.soc. And Anr ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 54 OF 2014 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And M/s. Nimesh Global Syndicate And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH Page 9/23 NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 34 OF 2014 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Vaishali Sra Co-op. Hsg, Soc. Ltd (pro) And Anr. (applicant) ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 56 OF 2014 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citi Space And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Mr. Shiva P. Arakari ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 194 OF 2014 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And 2 Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And M/s. Lotus Logistics And Developers (applicant) 2 Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 218 OF 2014 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER Page 10/23 V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors And M/s. Maharashtra Housing And Area Dev.board ( Applicant ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 219 OF 2014 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors And M/s.rushabh Real Estate Development P. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 170 OF 2013 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors.and Slum Rehabilitation Authority (applicant) ....RESPONDENT WITH INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 2716 OF 2020 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 New Look Constructions Private Limited ....PETITIONER V/S Citi Space And 5 Ors ....RESPONDENT WITH Page 11/23 NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 192 OF 2017 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citi Space And 2 Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And 2 Ors. And Savitribai Phule Nagar Sta Co-op. Hsg.soc.ltd.(prop) And Anr. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 66 OF 2019 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Cityspace And 2 Ors ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And 2 Ors And Chandhok Developers (applicant) ....RESPONDENT WITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1771 OF 2022 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Naredco West Foundation ....PETITIONER V/S Citispace And 6 Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 28459 OF 2021 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Pandurang D. Chalke And Anr ....PETITIONER Page 12/23 V/S Citispace And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 30716 OF 2021 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Slum Redevelopers Association And 3 Ors(applicants) ....PETITIONER V/S Citispace And 6 Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 28343 OF 2021 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Cosmic Developers (applicant/intervener) ....PETITIONER V/S Citispace And 6 Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 19651 OF 2022 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Mundara Developers ....PETITIONER V/S Ngo Alliance For Governance And Renewal And 5 Other ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 88 OF 2014 In Page 13/23 WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citi Space And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Amity Constructions And Anr. (applicant) ....RESPONDENT WITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 3043 OF 2022 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Ngo Alliance For Governance And Renewal(nagar)) And 2 Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 409 OF 2011 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 179 OF 2003 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 City Space And Ors ....PETITIONER V/S The State Of Mah. And Ors. ....RESPONDENT Page 14/23 WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 44 OF 2005 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Or. And Narayan Bhima Tandel And Anr. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 281 OF 2005 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Cityspace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And V.p Nagar Co-op. Hsg. Soc. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 282 OF 2005 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Bharatnagar Co-op. Hsg. Soc. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 283 OF 2005 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Page 15/23 Cityspace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Bhaiysaheb Ambdekar Nagar Co-op. Hsg. Soc. ....RESPONDENT WITH CONTEMPT PETITION IN WRIT PETITION NO. 40 OF 2008 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 City Space And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S Shri. Debashish Chakravarty And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER ORDER NO. 803 OF 2008 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Anr. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER ORDER NO. 1543 OF 2008 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 232 OF 2009 In Page 16/23 WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors And Shivalik Ventures Pvt Ltd ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 234 OF 2009 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 235 OF 2010 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 578 OF 2010 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S The State Of Maharashtra ....RESPONDENT WITH Page 17/23 NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 624 OF 2010 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And M/s. Sai Construction ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 200 OF 2011 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 294 OF 2011 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 296 OF 2011 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT Page 18/23 WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 326 OF 2011 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 223 OF 2011 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 410 OF 2011 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 481 OF 2011 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And M/s. Page 19/23 Aryaman Developers Pvt. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 608 OF 2011 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 159 OF 2012 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 City Space And 2 Anr. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And 2 And Mulund Panchsheetal Co. Op. Hsg. Soc. Ltd.- Applicant ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 227 OF 2012 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 M/s. Ratan Builders..applicant And Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 243 OF 2012 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Page 20/23 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 379 OF 2012 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Jess Construction Pvt. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 421 OF 2012 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Cityspace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And M/s. Damodar Suruchi Developers ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 423 OF 2012 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 Citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And M/s. Mundara Developers (applicant) ....RESPONDENT WITH Page 21/23 NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 3 OF 2013 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 City Space And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And M/s. Suranjan Holding And Estate Dev. Pvt. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 193 OF 2013 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 M/s. D.v.builders And Developers, Applicant/citispace And Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ....RESPONDENT WITH NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 142 OF 2014 In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002 City Space And 2 Ors. ....PETITIONER V/S State Of Maharashtra And 2 Ors. And Ratan Builders (applicant) ....RESPONDENT Mr. Shiraj Rustomjee, Sr. Adv. with Ms. Gulnaar Mistry, Mr. Aakash Rebello, Mr. Prateek Pai, Mr. P Sasuti, Mr. Shallier Jariwala i/b. Jariwala Asso. Petitioner in WP/1152/2002. Mr. Ranjeev Carvalho I/b. ABHLLP for the Applicant in IA 28459/2021. Mr. Hrushi Nargekar with Mr. Rohaan Pajnigar i/b. DSK Legal Page 22/23 for the applicant in IAL/30716/2021. Mr. Anand Oka Adv. For Applicant in CS/88/2014. Mr. Mayur Khandeparkar, Mr. Vikramjit Garewal a/w Ms. Risha Shetty, Mr. Rahul Deshpande i/b Wadia Gandhy and Co. For Applicant in IA/1771/2022. Mr. Prathmesh Seth i/b Joseph B Fernandes Adv. For applicant in NMW/66/2019. Mr. Anosh Sequeira i/b P.V.Nichani Adv. For Applicant IAL/19651/2022. Mr. Ram Apte Sr.Adv. Through VC a/w Ms. Oorja Dhond i/b Mr. S.K.Sonawane For Respondent No. 2 BMC. Mr. A.Y.Sakhare Sr.Adv. With Mr. Abhay Patki, Addl.GP for State Respondent No.1. Mr. Milind Sathe Sr.Adv. a/w Mr. Girish Utangale, Mr. Saurav Utangale and Mr. Vedant Joshi i/b M/S Utangale and Co. Adv. For Respondent SRA. CORAM : HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE & HON'BLE JUSTICE SHRI ARIF S. DOCTOR, JJ DATE : 23rd April, 2024 P.C. : S. O. to 26/04/2024 ( at 2.30 pm). ( ASSOCIATE ) Page 23/23