IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT : THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KURIAN JOSEPH FRIDAY, THE 4TH JULY 2008 / 13TH ASHADHA 1930 WP(C).No. 33027 of 2006(F) -------------------------------------- PETITIONERS: -------------------- 1. ANSAR AHAMED, S/O. A.M. ASHRAF FIRDOUS, VELLAKINAR JN., STADIUM WARD, ALLEPPEY. 2. PRASANTH G.L., S/O. GLADSTON J., PRASANTH BHAVAN PARANIYAM, POOVAR.P.O., TVM. 3. ASHA NAZIMUDEEN, D/O. NAZIMUDEEN.A, ANASWARA, KARIYIL, KAZHAKUTTAM.P.O., TVM., PIN - 695 582. 4. DIVYA S. DETH, D/O. KRISHNA DETH, SANTHI, H.NO.XI/946A, VELY.P.O., KOCHI-682 001. 5. SIMY V. JOSEPH, D/O. V.J. JOSEPH, VALLIKATTIKUZYIYIL HOUSE, ARUVITHURA.P.O., KOTTAYAM DISTRICT, 1PIN - 686 122. 6. BABY SANGEETHA, D/O. N. MURALEEDHARAN, ANU NIVAS, DIVISION COLONY, PIP QUARTERS, MATTANNOOR.P.O., KANNUR DIST., PIN -670 702. 7. ANUPAMA.S, D/O. SREEDHARAN M.P., ANUGRAH HOUSE, P.O. MEPPAYIL, VATAKARA, CALICUT DIST., KERALA. W.P.(C). NO.33027/2006-F: 8. ABHILASHA THAKUR, D/O. C.K. THAKUR, CO-OPERATIVE MEDICAL COLLEGE, KOCHI, HMT.P.O., PIN -683 503. 9. VINEETHA.K, D/O. V. SHANKUNNI, KOLANGAT HOUSE, ENGG. COLLEGE.P.O., THRISSUR - 680 009. 10. KAMALU.S, D/O. G. SADASIVAN, LALDALE, UNIVERSITY.P.O., TVM -695 034. 11. JAYASREE K.P., D/O. A. KRISHNAN UNNI, MADATHIL HOUSE, PULAMANTHOLE.P.O., MALAPPURAM DIST., KERALA - 679 323. 12. SEEMI E.V., D/O. E.V. PAVITHRAN, EKKILA VALAPPIL HOUSE, KAMBIL KOLACHERRY, KANNUR DIST., KERALA -670 060. 13. TINU TREESA MATHEW, D/O. MATHEW THOTTANKARA, THOTTANKARA HOUSE, T.B. ROAD, ANGAMALY, ERNAKULAM DIST., KERALA. 14. VEENA.R, D/O. G. RAVEENDRAN NAIR, VEENUS COTTAGE, CHITTAICODE, NAVAIKULAM.P.O., TVM - 695 603. 15. NISHA FRANCIS, D/O. FRANCIS.D, NISHANTH HOUSE, TC 16/608, JAGATHY.P.O., TVM - 695 014. W.P.(C). NO.33027/2006-F: 16. DEEPTHI S. BALA, D/O. N. BALAKRISHNAN, DEEPA NIVAS, NEAR FIREFORCE STATION, MARKET ROAD, ATTINGAL - 695 101. 17. DIVYA.K, D/O. K. SASIDHARAN, 13/715, THAPASYA, NEAR TOWN HALL, THALASSERY, KANNUR. 18. SNEHA P. SIMON, D/O. P.V. SIMON, PERUMBILLIL HOUSE, PAZHOOR.P.O., PIRAVAM VIA, ERNAKULAM DIST - 686 664. 19. ANSU SAM, D/O. SAMUEL PHILIPOSE, PARAPPATTY ROY VILLA, THONNIAMALA.P.O., PATHANAMTHITTA - 689 668. 20. MATHEN FINCY ELIZABETH, D/O. T.K. MATHEN, ARUKUZHIYIL HOUSE, KODUVILA.P.O., KALLADA EAST, KOLLAM DIST. - 691 502. 21. ANNU SUSAN GEORGE, D/O. GEORGE VARGHESE, NADUVILEDATH HOUSE, MUTTAMPALAM.P.O., KANJIKUZHY, K.K. ROAD, KOTTAYAM, KERALA -686 004. 22. JISSA ANNU SUNNY, D/O. K.T. SUNNY, KALAPURACKAL HOUSE, PUTHUPPALLY.P.O., KOTTAYAM - 686 011. 23. SMITHA ANCY VARGHESE, D/O. CHACKO VARGHESE, EDATHIPARAMBIL SIBI VILLA, PARUMALA.P.O., PATHANAMTHITTA, PIN - 689 626. W.P.(C). NO.33027/2006-F: 24. RAJITHA.R, D/O. RAMACHANDRAN, VENATTUKIZHAKKETHIL, CHERUTHANA.P.O., ALAPPUZHA - 690 563. 25. MARY LOUIS MANAVALAN, D/O. LOUIS K. MANAVALAN, MANAVALANS, PATTALAKINAR ROAD, KURIACHIRA, THRISSUR. 26. INDU G.S, D/O. P. GOPINATHAN PILLAI, SYAMALALAYAM, MUNDAYAKONAM, MUTTADA.P.O., TVM - 25. 27. REMYA VISWANATH, D/O. VISWANATHAN, SURAJ, SANTHOSH NAGAR, MANNUTHY, THRISSUR. 28. NEETHA GOPAL, D/O. P.T. GOPALAN, THIRUVATHIRA HOUSE, MEPPAYIL.P.O., VATAKARA, CALICUT DIST., 29. MANJU.R, D/O. K.A. RANGANATH, SREELAKSHMI, NEAR AROOR BYPASS, AROOR - 688 534. 30. RAJEE JAYARAJ, D/O. E. JAYARAJ, REMYA, V.V. NAGAR, HOUSE NO. 65, NCC ROAD, PEROORKADA.P.O., TVM. 31. AIGA S.V, D/O. G. VIMALA (MOTHER), LEELA VILAS, KARAVALAVU, ARASUPARAMBU, NEDUMANGADU.P.O., TVM - 695 541. W.P.(C). NO.33027/2006-F: 32. ANU MARY THOMAS, D/O. A.T. THOMAS, ATHIYALIL, ADARSH NAGAR - 60, PATTOM.P.O., THIRUVANANTHAPURAM - 4. 33. AMITH S. ALUMKARA, D/O. M.K. SEBASTIAN, HOUSE NO. 9, SUBHASH NAGAR, EDAPPALLY, KOCHI -24. 34. ANU C. JOHN, D/O. C.K. JOHN, S.I. FLATS, WINDBROOKE APARTMENTS, SASTHAMANGALAM, TVM. 35. SREEDEVI.S, D/O. SHYLA M. (MOTHER), PADMASREE, POONTHI ROAD, KUMARAPURAM, M.C.P.O., TVM. 36. NITHA SUDHAKARAN, W/O. TEJAL VASUDEVAN, KODAKKATTIL HOUSE, KURUMPILLAVU.P.O., PAZHUVIL, THRISSUR, PIN - 680 564. 37. SOUMYA HAREENDRANATH, D/O. C.K. HAREENDRANATH, GREENS, 1/2960 A, EAST HILL JN., WEST HILL P.O., CALICUT - 673 005. 38. SHABNA UMMER, D/O. K.M. UMMER, SHABNAS, NHAMANGHAL.P.O., KUNNAMKULAM, THRISSUR - 679 563. 39. SABEENA.S., D/O. SHAHUL HAMEED, SHAMAHAL, TC 55/424, PAPPANAMCODE.P.O., TVM - 695 018. 40. SHAGINA K.S, D/O. K. SASEENDRAN, E3/27, W/ISLAND, ISLAND.P.O., ERNAKULAM. W.P.(C). NO.33027/2006-F: 41. GEORGIA GEORGE, D/O. P.D. VARKEY, PARATTUKUNNEL, POONJAR.P.O., MANIYAMKUNNU, KOTTAYAM DIST. 42. WINNIE ANTONY, D/O. K.P. ANTONY, KUNNATHANIYIL, CANAL BUND ROAD, PAITHAMKUNNAM, DHONI.P.O., PALAKKAD. 43. THIRUVENKIDESWARY.B, D/O. A.B. SWAMY, JAGANATH DIARY FARM, PITCHU IYER JUNCTION, CULLEN ROAD, ALLEPPEY - 688 001. 44. SAJINI RAMAKRISHNAN, D/O. M.K. RAMAKRISHNAN, KARTHIKA, VANCHAVODU.P.O., SREEKARYAM.P.O., TVM. 45. BIJOY S., S/O. K. SURENDRAKURUP, UTHRADOM, THUNDATHIL.P.O., KARIAVATTOM, TVM - 695 581. 46. PRITHEESH RAJAN, S/O. R. SINNA RAJAN, TRINITY HOME, PALLURUTHY SOUTH, KONAM, KOCHI, PIN - 682 006. 47. ANOOP.P.S, S/O. R. PRADEEP KUMAR, INDEEVARAM, PADANILAM, CHIRAYANKEEZHU.P.O., TVM - 695 304. 48. THOMAS.P. VARGHESE, S/O. K.T. DANIKUTTY, PANIKKASSETIL HOUSE, PUTHENCHANTHA.P.O., VAKATHANAM, KOTTAYAM. 49. BRIJESH RAY R.S, S/O. RAVEENDRAN NAIR.M, NEW RAY, PARVATHYPURAM GRAMOM, ATTINGAL, TVM. W.P.(C). NO.33027/2006-F: 50. NISHANTH DAVID THOMAS, S/O. T.K. THOMAS, B4, NINA RESIDENCY, VELLAYAMBALAM, SASTHAMANGALAM.P.O., TVM - 695 010. 51. HARIKRISHNAN.T, S/O. N. THANKAPPAN PILLAI, NANDANAM, TC-4/1381 (1), H. NO. 68 A, ANIYAN LANE, KOWDIAR.P.O., TVM - 3. 52. MANU MATHEW, S/O. KOSHY P. MATHEW, NANDANAM, H. NO. 7, BRIDGE LANE, ULLOOR, MEDICAL COLLEGE.P.O., TVM - 11. 53. ADARSH.D, S/O. G. DHARMARAJAN, NISANTHAM, KALLAMPALAM.P.O., KALLAMPALAM, TVM. 54. AJEESH.P.R, S/O. P.K. RAMACHANDRAN, XI/201, PERUMITTATH HOUSE, ASAN LANE, ALUVA -1, PIN - 683 101. 55. NAVEEN.N, S/O. P.K. NAZIRUDEEN, E.S.I. QUARTERS, XII/A, ALUVA -2, PIN: 683 101. 56. RAKESH.R, S/O. C. RAVIKUMARAN NAIR, SIVA NIVAS, K.S.N. MENON ROAD, COCHIN, PIN: 682 016. 57. MUHAMMED SAFEER.A, S/O. ABDULLA KUTTY, C.C. 42/1035, THAMMANAM.P.O., KOCHI-32. W.P.(C). NO.33027/2006-F: 58. SANAL MOHAN.S, S/O. SUDHAKARAN, KARTHIKA, VANCHAVODU.P.O., SREEKARYAM.P.O., TRIVANDRUM. 59. NISHAD.M, S/O. P. MOHAMMED BASHEER, NISHAD DALE, UMAYANELLOOR.P.O., KOLLAM. 60. GEOMY G. CHAKKALKKUDY, S/O. GEORGE CHAKKALAKKUDY, CHAKKALAKKUDIYIL HOUSE, P & T QUARTERS ROAD, P.O. POOTHOLE, THRISSUR -4. 61. ASHISH ANAND, S/O. RAMANAD SHAW, ANANDAM, KURICHY.P.O., KOTTAYAM, KERALA. 62. HARI.P.S, S/O. SUBRAMANIAN.P.K., PANTHAYIL HOUSE, EYYAL POST, KECHERY, THRISSUR. 63. SUJITH CHANDRAN, S/O. K. RAMACHANDRAN PILLAI, KODIYATTU HOUSE, PADA - NORTH, KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM. 64. RAJUL KOYADEEN.T, S/O. T. KOYADEEN, EDAKKAT HOUSE, P.O.G.A. COLLEGE, KOZHIKODE, KERALA. 65. SREEJITH.M.D, S/O. C. DHANAPALAN, DHANASREE, TC 24/1510-1, THYCAUD.P.O., TVM. 66. AJMAL SHERIF.P, S/O. P. ABDUL MAJEED, PERIKANCHIRA HOUSE, CHULLIYODE ROAD, CIVIL STATION, CALICUT. W.P.(C). NO.33027/2006-F: 67. SANTHOSH.S, S/O. SUBRAHMANIAN.A.P, SREENILAYAM, AYIKKARAPPADI.P.O., MALAPPURAM DISTRICT. 68. ARUL R.B., KRISHNA, S/O. G.B. BALAKRISHNAN NAIR, TC 37/784, FORT P.O., TVM -23. 69. RAJAD.R, S/O. RAJAPPAN.P, KRISHNAPRIYA HOUSE, TRANQUIL GARDENS, NEAR NEW HOPE DARSAN FLAT, K.K. ROAD, CHEMBUMUKKU, ERNAKULAM - 682 021. BY ADV. SRI.A.MOHAMMED. RESPONDENTS: ------------------------ 1. UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY (HEALTH) MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE, MOULANA AZAD ROAD, NIRMA BHAVAN, NEW DELHI-110 011. 2. MEDICAL COUNCIL OF INDIA, SECTOR-8, POCKET-14, DWARKA-I, NEW DELHI-110 075, REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY. 3. ALL INDIA INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCE, ANSARI NAGAR, NEW DELHI-110 029, REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY. 4. STATE OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT CO-OPERATION DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM. 5. COCHIN UNIVERSITY FOR SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, COCHIN-32, REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR. W.P.(C). NO.33027/2006-F: 6. TRAVANCORE-COCHIN MEDICAL COUNCILS (COUNCILS FOR MODERN MEDICINE), THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR. 7. DIRECTOR, CO-OPERATIVE ACADEMY OF PROFESSIOAL EDUCATION, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM. 8. PRINCIPAL, CO-OPERATIVE MEDICAL COLLEGE, COCHIN. ADV. SRI. P. PARAMESWARAN NAIR, A.S.G FOR R1, “ “ SRI.BOBY JOHN, CGC FOR R1 SRI. AJITH KRISHNAN, ADDL.CGSC FOR R1 SRI.ALEXANDER THOMAS, SC, MCI FOR R2 SRI.SUNIL CYRIAC, SC, FOR R5 SRI.S.P.ARAVINDAKSHAN PILLAI,SC, FOR R5 SRI.N.RAGHURAJ, SC, TCMC & KNMC FOR R6 SRI.MILLU DANDAPANI SC FOR FOR R7 & R8. THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 04/07/2008, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: W.P.(C). NO.33027/2006-F: APPENDIX PETITIONERS' EXHIBITS: EXT.P.1: COPY OF THE ROSPECTUS FOR ALL INDIA ENTRANCE EXAMINATIONS FOR MD/MS/PG DIPLOMA AND MDS COURSES - 2007. EXT.P.2: APPLICATION FOR ALL INDIA MEDICAL DENTAL ENTRANCE EXAMINATION, 2007 SUBMITTED BY THE P.3. EXT.P.3: COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGE FROM THE WEBSITE OF MEDICAL COUNCIL OF INDIA SHOWING THE PARTICULARS OF THE PERMISSION GRANTED TO CO-OPERATIVE MEDICAL COLLEGE, COCHIN. EXT.P.4: COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGE FROM THE WEBSITE OF MEDICAL COUNCIL OF INDIA SHOWING THE PARTICULARS OF THE M.B.B.S COURSE GRANTED TO CO- OPERATIVE MEDICAL COLLEGE, COCHIN. EXT.P.5: COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGE FROM THE WEBSITE OF ALL INDIA MEDICAL COUNCIL REGARDING THE REGISTRATION OF CANDIDATES WHO POSSESS RECOGNIZED MEDICAL QUALIFICATION. EXT.P.6: COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE OF PROVISIONAL REGISTRATION DTD. 14/12/2005 ISSUED TO SABEENA.S. EXT.P.7: COPY OF THE REJECTION ORDERS ISSUED BY ALL INDIA INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCE. EXT.P.8: COPY OF THE PROVISIONAL CERTIFICATE OF M.B.B.S DEGREE EXAMINATION, DTD. 08/12/2005 ISSUED BY THE COCHIN UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY. EXT.P.9: COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE DTD. 09/12/2007 THAT THIS DEPONENT HAS SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED HER COMPULSORY ROTATING RESIDENT INTERNSHIP, ISSUED BY THE CO-OPERATIVE MEDICAL COLLEGE, KOCHI. EXT.P.10: COPY OF THE RANK LETTER DTD. 15/02/2007 ISSUED TO THIS DEPONENT BY ALL INDIA INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCE, NEW DELHI. EXT.P.11: COPY OF THE RANK LETTER DTD. 15/03/2007 ISSUED TO THIS DEPONENT BY ALL INDIA INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCE, NEW DELHI. W.P.(C). NO.33027/2006-F: RESPONDENTS' EXHIBITS: EXT.R2.(1): COPY OF THE RELEVANT PORTION OF REGULATION 8 OF MCI'S PG REGULATIONS, 2000. EXT.R2,(2): COPY OF THE ESTABLISHMENT OF MEDICAL COLLEGE REGULATIONS, 1999. EXT.R2.(3): COPY OF THE MCI'S LETTER DTD. 13/12/2005. EXT.R2,(4): COPY OF THE MCI'S LETTER DTD. 15/06/2006. EXT.R2.(5): COPY OF THE GOVT. OF INDIA'S LETTER DTD. 22/06/06. //TRUE COPY// prv. KURIAN JOSEPH, J. ----------------------------------------- W.P(C) No. 33027 of 2006 ----------------------------------------- Dated this the 4th day of July, 2008 JUDGMENT In the matter of appearance in the All India Entrance Examination for the PG course, in view of the intervening developments whereby the petitioners were permitted to appear for the entrance examination pursuant to interim orders issued by this court and the further development leading to the recognition granted to the College, it is submitted that no further orders are necessary in this writ petition. Therefore, the writ petition is closed, leaving the question of law open. (KURIAN JOSEPH, JUDGE) ahg. KURIAN JOSEPH, J. ----------------------------------- W.P(C).No.33027 of 2006 ----------------------------------- JUDGMENT 4th July, 2008