3^er ^)|^|<?l<ij, ®T{1<d'ie,|si<7>i<-fy 3TCST TR!!K (Tpf^RS) 3n^i w R-fii* OTT 3ITOI stlll'stl '^aiWHfw aii^t HIGH CQURT OF CSHATTISGARH AT BILA8PTTR REVIEW PETITKJIN (P.R.I N0. 893 OF 2007 DIVI8ION BENQH EETITIONER HO* Hoa VBRSflS RESPONDENTS 3. <*I^I<'t41-t iIItRTf 'if.ft^ <[«i't{i< •^ sfRn CT^T SHRI L.C. BHADOO. & SHRI DHIRENDRA MISHRA^JJ Nildul Footw?ear Private Limited, 52-53, H.S.I.D.C,, Industrial Area, KundU, District-Sonepat, Haryaaa & havmg its r^istered of&ce at G- 1, Udyog Nagar, DeBu-110041 fhrough its constituted Attorney- Mr. Gopal Bhatia, S/o Late D.S. Bhatia, Aged about 38 years, R/o C-59, Shailendra Nagar, Raipur (C.G.) State of Chhattisgarh, Through its Secretary, Departm.eat of Porest, D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipur (C.G.) Chhattisgarh State Muior Forest Produce (Trading & Developinent) Cooperative Federation Lunited, Raipur, through its Managin^ Director, A-25-V.I.P,, Estate, Near V.I.P. Club, Khamardih, Shaakar Nagar, Raipur (C.G.) M.B. Eubber Private Limited, D-13, 14, Site IV, Industrial Area, Sahibabad-201010, Ghaziabad (U.P.) havmg its registered of&ce at 195-Gyaa Vihar-DeUu, through its Director Shri Vipiu Mehta. Diam.ond Toys Couipany Private Limited, B-40, Mayapuri ^S^ '<IWWf, 8>Tflwi<S, is|(>i|yi{< ^^' •' /-e^ \\ ant?nRi% (ijqf^qtr: TOiiwgfe sii^r ^i'feqN'?reff •9'fSi^-rfSRZR 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. o B Per Dhirendt'a Mishra, J The iiiatter was taken u on default as pointed out v 13.4.2007. The instant petitioa has^ sevea days and an appUcat^on condonation of dday tn filin; supported by an affidavit. Industrial Area, Fhase-I, Nenr DeUri-110064. Diamond Products Limited, A-9, Mayapuri Industrial Area, Phase- II, NewrDeUu-110064. Charan Paaduka Industries Pvt. Ltd. 1462-64, M.I.E. Bahadurgarh, Haryana-124507. Bata India Linuted, Bata House, 418/02, Sector -17, MehrouM, Giirgaon Road, Gurgaon-122002 (Haryana). Liberty Shoes Limited, Liberty Complex, 17th MUestone, G.T. Kamal Road,Gharaunda, District-Karnal, Haryaiia-132001. Lakhani India Linuted, PlotNo. 131, Sector-24, Faridabad, Haryana-121005, ?D ER (7.20071 in chamber. It is Usted for orders le office note dated 22.3.2007 & also beai preferred wifh a detay of dated 29.3,2007 {I.A.No.2} for h.e petition has been filed, which is GRPRJ— FS/246—2/2007— 50.UUO. '9 a-lni |ii;:i 3^ET ^l^l<rt<l, yxfly'liS, Rj(rtl«lj< HWdl Sb*<|cb V...L.^^......^..l WI; 3ti^?r T^% (ijgfyRw) ailtn.'^r R-fi+ wiiaii^r wqw TOiTWdtoaii^i The reasous assigned sufficient for condoning the disiaissed. in the above application are not ^elay, therefore, the application is Even ofherwise, fhe peti|tioaer has ffled this petition with a prayer for recaUiag aad revk|wiug of fhe order dated 7.2.2007 passed in W.P.(C)No.7069/06 4nd has furfher prayed to direct the respondents No. 1 & 2 no| respondents 3, 4 & 5. Froin perusal of the ordj the above petition was ffled] respondent No. 3 herein, arrs Chliattisgarh State Minor & 2. The petitioner and respi parties to fhe said petition. I aggrieved by fhe notice dated <:M<iK?1<fll 'HW^f ^' 'f^Si' Tf:3RtJTC ^; arfgiT sn^r jt to award any contract to the :r iinder review it is observed that by M/s M.B. Rubber Pvt. Ltd, .yiag the State of CtLhattisgarh and Forest Produce (Tradiag aad Developnient) Co-operative Fei^eration Ltd., as respondents No. 1 whereby tenderers 4, 5 & 6 ha^e also been declared qualified in the techiucal bid apart fi-om. respo^ident No.3. We do not fiiid aav sub firstiy on fhe ground tiaat fhe petition in which fhe order no groimd has been urged m. order dated 7,2.2007 passed<iiVf. GRPRJ— FS/246—2/2007— 50.000. >ndent No. 4 to 9 herein are not the also appears that the petitioner is 6.2.2007 issued by respondent No.2 i^tance in the instaD.t review petition l}etitioner was not a party to the wnt unjler review was passed and secondty, jfhe petition warraatmg rpview of ffae W.P.(qNo.7069/06. c ;:- XI-tIC—78 sn^r^ [^•fi'* ^Sff 3TT^?T gbHlcd ^l 75ET "41<41c''>'4, anfly'KS, (s|<y»iyll< NINc^l ^WW ^ •va^ ( •^iiw^fesn^i In the rcsult, iastant pe|ition is disinissed beuig barred by luuitation as also on inerits. Consequently, IA.No. l,fi( for urgent hearing, IA.No.4 fc^ IA.No. 5 for unpleading disposed of. Sd/- L.C. Bhadoo Jitdge graat of ad-inteiim relief, IA.No,3 taking document on record and adtfitional parties on record, stand i*llf<'l41l IWdf if.fe^ <[a|t$l< ^sifwTsn^i Sd/- Dhirendra Mishra Judge