34 r CReNoe2611 of2005 V 4v1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CNDIGARH of2005 DateofDecision l 29062010 JaswinderSinghand others Petitioners Versus HarbansSinghand others 0 CORAMHONBLE MRe JUSTICE HEMANT GUPTA CAO Present None C5 I HEMANT GUPTA J ORALI Challenge in the presentpetition is to the order passedby the Z learned trial Cocrt on 2232005 callingupon the plaintif to affix ad valoremCourt fee as per the sale conslderation on the sale deed dated I 91998 08 The father of the plaintiffs 1e defendant NoA executed sale 7 deeddated 961998 in favour ofdefendant Nosl to 3 in respectofland 3 kanals 14marlas CL The plaintiffs claim the suit propertyas jointancestralproperty and thatin a familysettlementon l6998 the propertyfell to the share of the plaintiffs and thus the plaintiffsare the owner of the suit land Therefore defendantNoA was not competentto alienatethe same The plaintiffs have the said saleallegingto be null 2evoid and not effecting therightsofthe plaintiffs A perusalofthe averments rnadebythe plaintiffsin the plaint would show that the plaintiffshave challenged the sale deed for the reasonthat in familysettlement the propertyhas fallen to the shareofthe 11 . uma 2012.08.17 14: 28 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigar h JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:22 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 35 0 CeReNoe2611 of2005 2 V C 10 plaintiffspriorto sale Thus in the suit is not to the sale executedbya karta of a jointHindu familyThe plaintiffs claim title of the propertyon the basisof a familysettlementIn View ofthe said fact the plaintiffs are bound to pay ad valorem Court fee as the alleged 1Sto the sale deed by a person who hasno title over thesuit propertYe r 0 ThereforeI do not find any illegality or in the order 0 passedbythe learnedtrial Court callinguponthe plaintiffsto afflx ad C0 valorem Court fee the present revlSlon petition 1S I dismissed However thepetitioners are granted one month timeto affix Z ad valoremCourtfee 5 29062010 GUPTAI I Vimal JUDGE 08 em 10 1 K3Cl 0 . uma 2012.08.17 14: 28 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigar h JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:22 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document