1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO.2981 OF 2010 Maharashtra Public Service Commission Having office at 4th floor, Bank of India Building, M.G.Road, Fort, Mumbai-400 001 (Through its Secretary) ...Petitioner Versus 1. Rajendra C. Kadam 2. Shri Santosh S. Jagtap 3. Shri Shivdutt G. Malandkar 4. Shri Prabhakar V. Patre 5. Shri Vijaykumar H. Latthe 6. Shri Prakash R. Kinagi 7. Shri Anil Pralhad Gaikwad 8. Ms. Seema T. Chougule 9. Shri Maruti S. Randive 10. Ms. Rekha B. Pawar 11. Shri Umesh V. Sawant 12. Shri Suresh M .Jadhav 13. Shri Sanjiv S. Gundewad 14. Shri Manohar S. Kamble 2 15. Shri Naresh W. Vengurlekar 16. Shri Sandip R. Bhosale 17. Shri Vinod S. Wayangankar 18. Shri Anand P. Junwatkar 19. Shri Deepak S. Hanmante 20. Shri Sudhir S. Korganokar 21. Shri Gajanan D. Kavathekar 22. Shri Sanjay C. Jadhav 23. Shri Sunil Shankar Ramkar 24. Shri Anil M. Shirke 25. Shri Subhash S. Rathod 26. Shri Sharad S. Patil 27. Shri Shailendra A. Gokhale 28. Shri Vijay K. Hasge 29. Shri Ajit G. Adate 30. Shri Vishwas K. Kajrolkar 31. Shri Satish H. Gamare 32. Shri Pandit S. Mote 33. Shri Sham R. Khot 34. Shri Prashant P. Raul 35. Shri Raju R. Ghadge 3 36. Shri Rajesh V. Tondwalkar 37. Ms. Ratna R. Khandelwal 38. Shri Shahaji B. Mohite 39. Shri Devidas M. Walmiki 40. Ms. Alka S. Shirpure 41. Shri Rajendra S. Kale 42. Shri Rajesh S. Darole 43. Shri Ulhas N. Shinde 44. Shri Bhanudas B. Jadhav 45. Shri Bhagatsingh T. More 46. Ms. Sadhana V. Vishe 47. Shri Sanjay D. Gawali c/o. Shri A. V. Bandiwadekar Advocate for the applicants, M.A.T., Mumbai. Having office at Ramkrupa, 2nd floor, Block No.9, Lt. Dilip Gupte Marg, Near Hotel Goa Portugese Mahim(W), Mumbai – 400 016. (Orig. Applicant Nos. 1 to 47 in O.A. No. 1246 of 2009) 48. Shri Chandrakant U. Bhosale 49. Shri Parshuram B. Lokhande 50. Shri Mahesh B. Lad 51. Shri Sopan K. Kadam 4 52. Shri Bajarang K. Desai 53. Shri Avinash P. Kale 54. Shri Santosh H. Bhundere 55. Shri Rajesh S. Gaonkar 56. Shri Satish S. Patil 57. Shri Sunil J. Desai 58. Shri Pravinkumar S. Kamble 59. Shri Harishkumar P. Daunde 60. Shri Vishwanath K. Thakur 61. Shri Sominath S. Waghmode 62. Shri Sandip M. Dhavale 63. Shri Nandakishore O. Borole 64. Shri Snehal V. Prabhu 65. Shri Arvind S. Pawar 66. Shri Vithhal M. Wakchaure 67. Shri Pravin J. Kadam 68. Shri Prashant V. Patil 69. Shri Shailesh S. Suryawanshi 70. Shri Ghanshyam T. Bhagwat 71. Shri Santosh B. Patil 72. Shri Kiran K. Matkar 5 73. Shri Bharat E. Jadhav 74. Shri Dinkar R. Chakor 75. Shri Pramod R. Pardeshi 76. Shri Mahendra Vittal Puri 77. Shri Khandu M. Ghuge 78. Shri Mahesh S. Bane c/o. Ms. Swati Manchekar, Advocate for the Applicants, M.A.T., Mumbai. (Nos. 48 to 78 – Orig. Applicants Nos. 1 to 31 in O.A. No. 1462 of 2009) 79. Shri Ramesh R. Dhumal 80. Shri Prakash D. Patil 81. Shri Sanjay S. Kupekar 82. Shri Sanjay R. Katkade 83. Shri Jitendra S. Jadhav 84. Shri Shridhar S. Gawai 85. Shri Satosh S. Rasam 86. Shri Prakash B. Kondhalkar 87. Ms. Pranita D. Patole 88. Shri Prakash U. Kadam 89. Shri Shashikant S. Tatkare 90. Smt. Reeta V. Rathod 6 91. Shri Baban B. Sonawane 92. Shri Ravindra B. Utekar 93. Shri Tejpal M. Shinde 94. Shri Sanjeev Laxman Bhosale 95. Shri Chandrakant B. Mane 96. Shri Sanjay B. Salunkhe 97. Shri Mohan C. Chavan 98. Shri Bhausaheb B. Madane 99. Shri Sandeep S. Gaikwad 100. Shri Vinod M. Gaikwad 101. Shri Ravindra S. Pawar 102. Shri Nandkumar U. Mahadik 103. Shri Sanjay P. Tiwari 104. Shri Mukesh R. Raut 105. Shri Dinesh V. Zanjal 106. Shri Rakesh R. Tiwari 107. Shri Santosh A. Shinde 108. Shri Ramesh J. Shinge 109. Shri Hiralal G. Thakore 110. Shri Anil V. Gosavi 111. Shri Gajanan L. Potdar 7 112. Shri Prakash S. Yamgar 113. Shri Chandrakant T. Kamble 114. Shri Uday S. Bhosale 115. Shri Sonu S. Dalavi 116. Shri Sudhir B. Nikam 117. Shri Sanjog K. Bacchhav 118. Shri Nandkumar D. Kadam 119. Ms. Veena S. Kadam 120. Shri Sanjay A. Kale 121. Shri D.R.Sanap c/o. Shri A.V.Bandiwadekar Advocate for the applicants, M.A.T., Mumbai. Having office at Ramkrupa, 2nd floor, Block No.9, Lt. Dilip Gupte Marg, Near Hotel Goa Portugese Mahim(W), Mumbai-400 016. (Nos. 79 to 121 – Orig. Applicant Nos. 1 to 43 in O.A. No. 1511 of 2009) 122. Shri Mohan B. Dere 123. Shri Tryambak S. Chakranarayan 124. Shri Pravin B. Dhande 125. Shri Dadaro V. Chilhotkar 126. Shri Anil B. Wange 8 127. Shri Gajanan M. Bhagat 128. Shri Ganesh S. Hulke 129. Shri Sanjay P. Khandare 130. Shri Ganesh G. Raut 131. Shri Kishor P. Mahajan 132. Shri Prakash B. Mane 133. Shri Ramesh M. Bhosale 134. Shri Dipak N. Jagtap 135. Shri Raug A. Inamdar 136. Shri Sunil A. Jadhav 137. Shri Ashrak Sayyuad Karim Inamdar 138. Shri Harishchandra G. Pansare 139. Shri Nitin P. Shinde 140. Shri Ganesh N. Hajare 141. Shri Jagdish S. Talole 142. Shri Ajay R. Mhetre 143. Shri Maruti B. Hirwe 144. Shri Anant S. Dalvi 145. Shri Sachin K. Dhawale 146. Shri Arwind H. Aavhad 147. Shri Kailas N. Wagh 9 148. Shri Suresh R. Bhalerao 149. Shri Samadhan B. Deshmukh 150. Shri Shalmon S. Satpute 151. Shri Sunil D. Chaudhari 152. Shri Hemant M. Hendre 153. Shri Satosh S. Dhanalagade 154. Shri Sachin H. Surve 155. Shri Anand P. Malale 156. Shri Vivek H. Mahamuni 157. Shri Yogesh K. Dhore 158. Shri Yogesh S. Bhujbal c/o. Ms. Swati Manchekar Advocate for the Applicants, M.A.T., Mumbai (Nos. 122 to 158 – Orig. Applicants Nos. 1 to 37 in O.A. No. 1512 of 2009) 159. Shri Yashwant M. Gangurde 160. Shri Sanjeev N. Jadhav 161. Shri Ravindrakumar P. Pansare 162. Shri Ganesh B. Deore 163. Shri Ramakant Y. Gaikwad 164. Shri Premsagar M. Wagh 165. Shri Sanjay J. Gaikwad 10 166. Shri Ashok P. Thombare 167. Shri Vinod P. Patil 168. Shri Riyaz B. Bhagwan 169. Shri Laxmikant M. Ghag 170. Shri Namdev B. Mane c/o. Shri A.V. Bandiwadekar Advocate for the applicants, M.A.T., Mumbai. Having office at Ramkrupa, 2nd floor, Block No.9, Lt. Dilip Gupte Marg, Near Hotel Goa Portugese Mahim(W), Mumbai-400 016. (Nos.159 to 170-Orig. Applicant Nos. 1 to 12 in O.A. No. 25 of 2010) 171. The State of Maharashtra, by and through the Principal Secretary of Home Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai-32. .....Respondents WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 2525 OF 2010 1. Shri Sachin Pratap Shinde, Age: 26 years, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at 1/9, Chembur Police Line, Opp.Basant Park, R.C. Marg, Chembur, Mumbai – 400 071. 11 2 Shri Vaibhav Shivaji Katkar, Age: 27 years, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Building No.70, Room No.1893, Kannamwar Nagar No.2, Vikhroli (East), Mumbai – 400 083. 3 Shri Sandeep Janardhan Yele, Age: 27 years, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Kaveri Nagar Police Line, Building No.2/6, Wakad, Pune – 411 057. 4 Shri Rajesh Vijay Gajjal, Age: 27 years, Occupation: Police Constable, Vishrantiwadi Police Line, Building No.B/7/12, Pune – 6. 5 Shri Vikas Tulshidas Jadhav, Age: 26 years, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at 37, B Ground Police Line, Radhika Road, Near Kadam Petrol Pump, Satara, District Satara. ...Petitioners v/s. 1 The State of Maharashtra Through the Addl. Secretary, Home Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai – 400 032. 2 The Director General of Police, Maharashtra State, Shahid Bhagatsingh Marg, Mumbai. 12 3 The Chairman/Secretary, Maharashtra Public Service Commission, Bank of India Building, Third Floor, M.G.Road, Mumbai – 400 001. 4 Shri Mohan Bhanudas Dere, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Quarter No.128, At Yawatmal Rural Police Station, Yewatmal. 5 Shri Tryambak Shivram Chakranarayan, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Lakshminagar, Borkadi Road, Pusad, Dist. Yawatmal. 6 Shri Pravin Balkrishna Dhande, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Vasant Nagar, Daryapur, District Amaravati. 7 Shri Dadarao Vithalrao Chilhotkar, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Quarter No.30, Police Line Vani, At and Post Vani, District Yewatmal. 8 Shri Anil Bhimrao Wange, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Sanket Colony, D.M.V.Road, Amaravati – 444 604. 13 9 Shri Gajanan Mahadeo Bhagat, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Lakshmi Nagar, Khwajababa Road, Digras, District Yewatmal. 10 Shri Ganesh Shankarrao Hulke, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Singhania Nagar, Near Gayatri Plastic, Arni Road, Yawatmal, District Yawatmal. 11 Shri Sanjay P. Khandare, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable. 12 Shri Ganesh G. Raut, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable. 13 Shri Kishor P. Mahajan, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable. Nos. 11 to 13 c/o Swati Manchekar, Advocate for the Original Applicants Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal, Mumbai Bench, Mumbai. 14 Shri Prakash Bajarang Mane, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at At and Post Penur, Taluka Mohol, District Solapur. 15 Shri Ramesh Mahadeo Bhosale, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Naik, residing 14 at Police Quarter No.8/14, Gokhale Nagar, Pune – 53. 16 Shri Dipak Namdeo Jagtap, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Naik, residing at B/36, Shivaji Nagar Police Vasahat, Pune – 5. 17 Shri Rauf Anwarkhan Inamdar, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at 5/2-D, Yash Residency, Sus Road, Pashan, Pune – 21. 18 Shri Sunil Anna Jadhav, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Survey No.58/1, Azad Nagar, Near S.R.P.F. Gr. No.2, Pune – 22. 19 Shri Ashfak Sayyad-Karim Inamdar, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at 2/3, Somwar Peth Police Vasahat, Pune. 20 Shri Harischandra Govind Pansare, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at At and Post Dalaj No.2, Taluka Indapur, District Pune. 21 Nitin Popatrao Shinde, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Naik, residing at 7-2, Sagar Enclave, Survey No. 4/5+8, Wanwadi, Pune – 40. 15 22 Shri Ganesh Narain Hajare, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at 104/42, Shivaji Nagar Police Vasahat, Pune – 5. 23 Shri Jagdish Sopan Talole, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at 104/32, Shivaji Nagar Police Vasahat, Pune – 5. 24 Shri Ajay Rajaram Mhetre, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Survey No. 150, Tilekar Vasti, Opp. Sudharshan Heritage, Magarpatta, Hadapsar, Pune – 28. 25 Shri Maruti Baban Hirwe, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Police Quarters at Baramati Police Station. 26 Shri Anant Sitaram Dalvi, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at House No.95, Survey No.133, Warje Malwadi, Pune – 52. 27 Shri Sachin Kisan Dhawale, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at C/603, 6th Sense Apartments, Near Katraj Dairy, Katraj, Pune – 46. 28 Shri Arvind Haribhau Aavhad, Age: Adult, Occupation: 16 Police Naik, residing at C/7, Shivaji Nagar Police Vasahat, Pune - 5. 29 Shri Kailash Namdeo Wagh, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at At and Post Nandane, Taluka and District Dhule. 30 Shri Suresh Rajaram Bhalerao, Age: Adult, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at 8, Dakshata Colony, Golibar Tekadi Road, New Bi-Pass Highway, Near Sakri Road,Dhule. ...Respondents WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 2837 OF 2010 1. Shri Sachin Pratap Shinde, Age: 26 years, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at 1/9, Chembur Police Line, Opp.Basant Park, R.C. Marg, Chembur, Mumbai – 400 071. 2 Shri Vaibhav Shivaji Katkar, Age: 27 years, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Building No.70, Room No.1893, Kannamwar Nagar No.2, Vikhroli (East), Mumbai – 400 083. 3 Shri Sandeep Janardhan Yele, Age: 27 years, Occupation: Police Constable, residing 17 at Kaveri Nagar Police Line, Building No.2/6, Wakad, Pune – 411 057. 4 Shri Rajesh Vijay Gajjal, Age: 27 years, Occupation: Police Constable, Vishrantiwadi Police Line, Building No.B/7/12, Pune – 6. 5 Shri Vikas Tulshidas Jadhav, Age: 26 years, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at 37, B Ground Police Line, Radhika Road, Near Kadam Petrol Pump, Satara, District Satara. 6. Shir Sandeep Vinayaka Buwa Age: 25 years, Occupation: Police Constable, r/at 103/118, Anna Colony, Saiful, Vijapur Road, Solapur. 7. Shri Ravindra Limbaji Shinde, Age: 28 years, Occupation Police Constable, r/at: Sant Namdeo Nagar Dhanora Road, Beed, District Beed. 8. Shri Sangram Shivaji Tate, Age 25 years, Occ:Police Constable r/at Tal. Karhad, Dist. Satara 9. Shri Kishor Popat Sale Age 26 years, Occ.Police Constable r/at: Bhgyodaya Colony, Bhagwati Niwas, Malegaon Camp, Tal. Malegaon, Dist. Nashik. 18 10. Shri Neeraj Jagannath Ubale age 28 years, Occ. Police Constable r/at: Taluka Naganje, Dist. Satara. 11. Shri Kakasaheb Vasant Patil, age: adult, occ. Police constable r/at: Krishna Nagar Railway Police Colony, Pimpri, Pune. 12. Shri Pradeep Nagnath Pawar, age: 28 years, occ: Police Constable, r/at: Vasant Nagar Police Colony, Dist. Solapur. 13. Shri Deepak Tukaram Mahadik age 27 years, Occ. Police Constable, r/at: Building No. C-1/31, Marol Police Camp, Andheri(E), Mumbai 400 059. 14. Shri Santosh Rangrao Pawar age 26 years, Occ. Police Constable, Building No. 16/3, Worli Police Line, Sir Poshkhanwala Road, Worli, Mumbai 400 030. 15. Shri Kiran Damodar Dandage age 26 yrs, Occ. Police Constable, Building No. 13/31, Mahim Police Colony, Raheja, Mahim, Mumbai 16. Shri Mahesh Babasaheb Sagade, age 30 yrs, occup.Police Constable, Bldg. No.33, Room no. 1310, First floor, D.N. Nagar Police Colony, Andheri (West), Mumbai-400 063. 17. Deepak Kishor Pawar, age 27 yrs., Occ. Police Constable, r/at Building No.D-3/8, Marol Police Camp, Marol-Maroshi Road, Andheri (East), Mumbai 400 059. 19 18. Shri Subhash Shankar Pujari, age 31 yrs, Occ. Police Constable, residing at & Post Rendal, Tal. Hatkangale, Dist. Solapur. 19. Bharat Dinkar Ghone age 29 yrs. Occ. Police Constable, r/at D8/15, Asmita Co-operative Housing Society Ltd., Charkop Naka, Malad(west), Mumbai 400 095. 20. Shri Dayanand Vithal Sawant, age 28 yrs, Occ. Police Constable, r/at: Building No. B/1/2, Room No.5, Worli Police Camp, Sir Poshkhanwala Road, Worli, Mumbai 400 030. ...Petitioners Versus 1. The State of Maharashtra, Through the Addl. Secretary, Home Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai 400 032. 2. The Chairman/Secretary, Maharashtra Public Service Commission, Bank of India Building, Third Floor, M.G.Road, Mumbai 400 001. 3. Shri Yashwant Mohan Gangurde, Age: Adult, Occ. Government Service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of Police Head Quarter, Nashik City. 4. Shri Sanjeev Narayan Jadhav, age: Adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of Crime Branch, Nashik City. 20 5. Shri Ravindrakumar Pandurang Pansare, Age; adult, occ. Government Service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of Nashik Road Police Station, Nashik City. 6. Shri Ganesh Bhaskar Deore, age: adult, occ. Government Service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of Crime Branch, Gangapur Road, Nashik (R). 7. Shri Ramakant Yashwant Gaikwad, age: adult, occ. Government Service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of Panchavati Police Station, Nashik. 8. Shri Premsagar Murlidhar Wagh, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of Vasai Police Station, Vasai, Dist. Thane. 9. Shri Sanjay Jagananth Gaikwad, age: adult, Occupation: Government service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of Sr. Inspector of Police, Ghatkopar Police Station, Mumbai. 10. Shri Ashok Padmakar Thombare, age: adult, Occ. Government Service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of Kandivali Traffic Division, kamla Nehru Road, Kandivali(West), Mumbai. 11. Shri Vinod Prabhakar Patil, age: adult, Occ: Government Service, 21 presently working as Police Constable in the office of Asstt. Intelligence Officer, State Intelligence Department, Dhule, Opp. Dist. Court, Station Road, Dhule. 12. Shri Riyaz Bashir Bagwan, Age: Adult, occ. Government Service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of Mahamarg Police Help Centre, Shirpur, Dist. Dhule. 13. Shri Laxmikant M. Ghag, age: adult, occ: Government service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of Tilaknagar Police Station, Chembur, Mumbai. 14. Shri Namdeo B. Mane, age: Adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of Traffic Control Branch, Worli, Mumbai. Address for service of Notice: c/o. Arvind V. Bandiwadekar, Advocate,M.A.T., Mumbai. Having office at Ramkrupa, 2nd floor, Block No.9, Lt. Dilip Gupte Marg, Near Hotel Goa Portugese Mahim(W), Mumbai-400 016. WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 2845 OF 2010 Shri Sachin Pratap Shinde, Age: 26 years, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at 1/9, Chembur Police Line, 22 Opp.Basant Park, R.C. Marg, Chembur, Mumbai – 400 071. 2 Shri Vaibhav Shivaji Katkar, Age: 27 years, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Building No.70, Room No.1893, Kannamwar Nagar No.2, Vikhroli (East), Mumbai – 400 083. 3 Shri Sandeep Janardhan Yele, Age: 27 years, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at Kaveri Nagar Police Line, Building No.2/6, Wakad, Pune – 411 057. 4 Shri Rajesh Vijay Gajjal, Age: 27 years, Occupation: Police Constable, Vishrantiwadi Police Line, Building No.B/7/12, Pune – 6. 5 Shri Vikas Tulshidas Jadhav, Age: 26 years, Occupation: Police Constable, residing at 37, B Ground Police Line, Radhika Road, Near Kadam Petrol Pump, Satara, District Satara. 6. Shir Sandeep Vinayaka Buwa Age: 25 years, Occupation: Police Constable, r/at 103/118, Anna Colony, Saiful, Vijapur Road, Solapur. 23 7. Shri Ravindra Limbaji Shinde, Age: 28 years, Occupation Police Constable, r/at: Sant Namdeo Nagar Dhanora Road, Beed, District Beed. 8. Shri Sangram Shivaji Tate, Age 25 years, Occ:Police Constable r/at Tal. Karhad, Dist. Satara 9. Shri Kishor Popat Sale Age 26 years, Occ.Police Constable r/at: Bhgyodaya Colony, Bhagwati Niwas, Malegaon Camp, Tal. Malegaon, Dist. Nashik. 10. Shri Neeraj Jagannath Ubale age 28 years, Occ. Police Constable r/at: Taluka Naganje, Dist. Satara. 11. Shri Kakasaheb Vasant Patil, age: adult, occ. Police constable r/at: Krishna Nagar Railway Police Colony, Pimpri, Pune. 12. Shri Pradeep Nagnath Pawar, age: 28 years, occ: Police Constable, r/at: Vasant Nagar Police Colony, Dist. Solapur. 13. Shri Deepak Tukaram Mahadik age 27 years, Occ. Police Constable, r/at: Building No. C-1/31, Marol Police Camp, Andheri(E), Mumbai 400 059. 14. Shri Santosh Rangrao Pawar age 26 years, Occ. Police Constable, Building No. 16/3, Worli Police Line, Sir Poshkhanwala Road, Worli, Mumbai 400 030. 24 15. Shri Kiran Damodar Dandage age 26 yrs, Occ. Police Constable, Building No. 13/31, Mahim Police Colony, Raheja, Mahim, Mumbai 16. Shri Mahesh Babasaheb Sagade, age 30 yrs, occup.Police Constable, Bldg. No.33, Room no. 1310, First floor, D.N. Nagar Police Colony, Andheri (West), Mumbai-400 063. 17. Deepak Kishor Pawar, age 27 yrs., Occ. Police Constable, r/at Building No.D-3/8, Marol Police Camp, Marol-Maroshi Road, Andheri (East), Mumbai 400 059. 18. Shri Subhash Shankar Pujari, age 31 yrs, Occ. Police Constable, residing at & Post Rendal, Tal. Hatkangale, Dist. Solapur. 19. Bharat Dinkar Ghone age 29 yrs. Occ. Police Constable, r/at D8/15, Asmita Co-operative Housing Society Ltd., Charkop Naka, Malad(west), Mumbai 400 095. 20. Shri Dayanand Vithal Sawant, age 28 yrs, Occ. Police Constable, r/at: Building No. B/1/2, Room No.5, Worli Police Camp, Sir Poshkhanwala Road, Worli, Mumbai 400 030. ...Petitioners Versus 1. The State of Maharashtra, Through the Addl. Secretary, Home Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai 400 032. 25 2. The Chairman/Secretary, Maharashtra Public Service Commission, Bank of India Building, Third Floor, M.G.Road, Mumbai 400 001 3. Shri Ramesh Rajaram Dhumal Residing at Bldg. No.5, Flat No.604, 6th Floor, Kole-Kalyan Police Colony, Wakola, Santacruz(E), Mumbai -400 055. 4. Shri Prakash Dinkar Patil, age: Adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of Naigaon Police Head Quarter, Mumbai. 5. Shri Sanjay Siddh Kupekar, age: Adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of Mumbai Traffic Police, Wadala Traffic Chowky, Mumbai. 6. Shri Sanjay Ramnath Katkade, age: adult, Occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of S.B.I.(Special) Branch, Mumbai. 7. Shri Jitendra Shivaji Jadhav, age: adult, occ: Government service, presently working as Police Constable in the office of Wireless Department, Byculla, Mumbai. 8. Shri Shridhar Shankar Gawai, age: Adult, Occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Naik in the office of Armed Police Force, L.A.IV, Marol,Mumbai. 26 9. Shri Santosh Shankar Rasam, age: Adult, Occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Santacruz Wireless, Linking Road, Near Juhu Garden, Mumbai 400 054. 10. Shri Prakash Baburao Kondhalkar, age: Adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Dr. D.B.Marg Police Station, Mumbai 400 007. 11. Ms. Pranita Damoda Patole, Age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Meghwadi Police Station, Near Income Tax Colony, Jogeshwari (E), Mumbai. 12. Shri Prakash Uttam Kadam, age: adult, occupation: Government service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Ghatkopar East Railway Police Headquarter, Bldg. No.2, Mumbai 400 075. 13. Shri Shashikant Shankar Tatkare, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Head Constable Writer at V.P. Road Police Station, Girgaon, Mumbai400 004. 14. Smt. Reeta Valmik Rathod, age: adult, Occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable at BKC Police Station, Bandra-Kurla, Bandra(E), Mumbai-400 051. 27 15. Shri Baban Bausaheb Sonawane, age: adult, off: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of State Intelligence Department, Old Council Hall, Colaba, Mumbai 400 001. 16. Shri Ravindra Bhau Utekar, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of State Intelligence Department, DGP Office, 2nd floor, Old Council Hall, Shahid Bhagat Singh Road, Mumbai 400 001. 17. Shri Tejpal Marutirao Shinde, age: adult, Occupation: Government Service presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Superintendent of Police, Local Crime Branch, Satara. 18. Shri Sanjeev Laxman Bhosale, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Police Headquarters, Satara. 19. Shri Chandrakant Bandoba Mane age: adult, Occ. Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Police Headquarter, Satara. 20. Shri Sanjay Balaso Salunkhe, age: adult, Occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Superintendent of Police, District Special Branch, Satara. 21. Shri Mohan Sampat Chavan, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, 28 in the office of Police Headquarters, Satara. 22. Shri Bhausaheb Bhagavan Madane, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Police Headquarters, Satara. 23. Shri Somdeep Subrao Gaikwad, age: adult, occu: Government Service, presently working as Police Naik, in the office of Special Squad Satara Police Pathak Head Quarter, Satara. 24. Shri Vinod Mohan Gaikwad, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Police Control Room, Satara. 25. Shri Ravindra Shankarrao Pawar, age: adult, occ.: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Karad Taluka Police Station, Karad, Dist. Satara. 26. Shri Nandkumar Uttamrao Mahadik, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Wai Police Station, Tal. Wai, Dist. Satara. 27. Shri Sanjay Parasnath Tiwari, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable At Post ATS, MS, Nagpur Unit, Behind HP Gas Gowon, Gatoll Road, Police Line, Takli, Nagpur-440 001. 28. Shri Mukesh Ramu Raut, age: adult, occ: Government Service, 29 presently working as Police Constable At post Nagpur City Police, Imamwada, Nagpur. 29. Shri Dinesh Vasantrao Zanjal, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable At Post NPC in Anti Terrorism Squad Unit Nagar, Nagpur. 30. Shri Rakesh Ramapati Tiwari, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, At Post Traffic MIDC, Commissioner of Police, Nagpur City. 31. Shri Santosh Abajrao Shinde, age: adult, occu. Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Kapurwadi Police Station, Thane(W). 32. Shri Ramesh Janak Shinge age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Traffic Branch Thane, Narpoli Unit. 33. Shri Hiralal Guman Thakore, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Dhule Taluka Police Station, Dhule. 34. Shri Anil Vasantpuri Gosavi, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, in the office of Police Headquarter, Nandurbar. 30 35. Shri Gajanan Laxman Potdar, age: adult, occu: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, At post Islampur, Tal. Walwa, Dist. Sangli. 36. Shri Prakash Shamrao Yamgar, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, At Sangli City Police Station, Dist. Sangli. 37. Shri Chandrakant Tatoba Kamble, age: adult, occ: Government Service, presently working as Police Constable, At S.D. Po. Office, Tal. Jath Dist. Sangli. 38. Shri Uday Sambhaji Bhosale, age: adult, occ: Government Service,