311^1 ^i WIT3ng?I iNhr 75T «Lii'l<ici'4, ^•al'y'ic, fq<iiy^< Gsi^:- ff. ^o. [72-/o9 3!I$?I 'vf^l ( iql^l't'^) yiCTiTiUNBK LSr. Utiaiul a.<~1 Oll-t/ L'oloay, K^ig'ai^-u [i-'<J-j CUnTBMnUK Ur. L.N, Ct1"K^I1Tl- uovemm' iC.R; uuu iBmfi i'isnTiUH CUNTEMPT OF' COUR'TS AG nnNiSTi' BB: UUn. SHK1 UMlKIilaiUKA I^-IU-^UU^ ynn vivels: Hnaruia, Sslin r'.K. Kosliy, Aclv. Auvt>cate Aclvocate 'i. i'lie petitioner iias tiltcl coutenj.pt proceeauigs agauij clateu 6859/2007. violatuig tlie orctei Unclisputecl tacts ot ttl^ W.P.(S) No. 6859/2007, the ij -iti-.i'-.^UUH caiicelleu uie earlt aiicl recluced. salaTv ot TJie operauoii aiia eiieci 01 uic ac| 30tn Apllt, 2008 iAiuiexure Cj presence ol ttie couusel toi1 conTeianor iTeiecTuig uie praye] <*w[i'f<il'i iiWcil'<i fe'zt <RH<(K '^sffiptsn^r 'a] n'asaa yaliu, y/o Stui H.L. oauu, f ^7 ^r^ci^c i?/^ 4./94HH k^l^ \^Tipir< Veiiua, y/'o olin i.K. veniia,' ageu <n \7'fsf^W Pti"t'»rt"»iva1- ?<i?'or1 im a1 :ni AIIS ana scieace uouege, Kaigarn UMUBK BBU'l'IOn l.-d ANSJ 10 Uf' T' KEAD WITH ARTICLE 215 OF' THi 'UTION OF INDIA ate, tor tne peUQoner. tor tlie coateniuor. me uistaiit petitioii .lor iniuatuig rt responcleut-conteiunor tor wiUtuily yU-4-..;'UUH passecl ui W.r'.io) No. case are Uiat clunug pericleiicy ol tlie 'spoiicient-conteniuor vicle orcier datecl. ;r pay tixaUon orci.er clatecl ^I-Q-^UU/ uuouer viae Aiiucxure L.'- i . iiowever, p^uuou^ at^ove orcler was stayed by ttus Court on 1). 'i'lie stay orcler was passed ui Uie Uie yiate aiicl tiie conteioiior. 'iiie ot Uie petitioner to uisuurse Uie saiai3L —FS/197—3/2008 —40,000. S ^s>/'"~| J 'XI-HC—78 sn^v w h-u* ^ffSTT^T st»*lNi "T-7 .^-' ^ 'S^T "41<41dAI, ©tily'Ko,fq<ii'Hy,< inw(T^*ii<») "RT. 200 sn^r'cpRTCyi-l'K'?) TO11W ^fW W^T as betore, ui vie~w ot Uie order fl uiat Uie petlUouer was Deing p^ 4. 'l'Jie contemnor vide lus r| atter tenueniig ujiconditional ^ to be giveu to Uie peuuoner, i| i.e. Uonunissioner, HigJier Bclii' to veiTucaUon ot uie scrutuivl alreaclv actclressed. a letter t0 clu-ecUon so ttiat uie order pas; o. lue conteinnor viae ni acKnowleagetl liis iaistai{c ani Uie contem.pt coDiinittecl t>y j].] intonjiecl mat Uie omer passect Wltll, O. yiin ViveK yuaiiua, r conteiKleci tD.at tlie conuuct ot as is eviclent. ironi tiis reply c conteinnor lias Tned t6 .justtt^' petiuon ancl lie coiupUed. witli lixeci tor consicteration on c tenclereu 'OY t'sie conteiaiior is contem.pt ot tjie (Jourt. +i^^d41-i HWfiT ^f fs1[st <?*)<•$)< ^3if?n 311^51 |assea uy tliis court, statecl ui ius reply |ia salaiy as per rales tAnnexure 'J-o). ^plv datect 16m Septeniber, 2008, even l.pologTy, reiterated Uiat wtiat salaiy is t> aecidea Dy me coiupetent auuionty pauon Kajictiauialaya, Kaipur, suaject ot Uie Accountaiit (Jeiieral. He iiacl Uie Lomniissioner aiiu sougiit iiis ^d &y uus Uourt couJtcl ue compUeu.. pi aciaitional reply datecl aU-y-.a.'UUK jl teuuerea uncondinonai apoloff,' tor u(i an.ci nas prayecl tor parclon. He also by uiis Court lias Deen now coinpuecl |:ameci counsel tor tlie petiuoner, |Uie conteianor is perse conteiuptuous [atect 17-0-2'JUV ;Auiiexui~e U-Sj; 1'fie J|iis action ui liis reply to Uie conteinpt Uie order ouly alter Uie ixiatter was l&ai'ges, ao.cl uierelore, me apolog~y |not bonaticle as tie is guiltv' ot gross jS..-.<^3% » 'viSeK"' ?• K •^a^ ^ST T*ii'4i<'i'4, ®flly<ii»,fsi<ni<-i'4,< wocir gi*<i<<» •Jf^200 STI^T 'qa!F (•jqf^l'i'T) sii^ivi R-fi* WIT3)T^Islit|te ^- WIRIT ^lft?( 3)1^1 saidie 7. On fhe ofher liand, Slu-i P.| tor uie contemnor, suiiDiits mat| uiaetensitsie, nowever, tJie laisuiterpretauon ot law. 'l'lie con|l is_r'ruicrpal ot uovenuneat (Jollit uiuicacies ot Uie Court proceeciqi act, fie lias teuaerea smcere oegguig parclon tor nis act ol coul|e coui|enipt. tiollcl 8. Atter tieanag ttie couasel gouig mrougn me guegauous in 1. subnussion niacle uy Tlie pe| Uiere'wita, we tuid suisstaiice counsel tor tlie petiUoner aacl tio|) ot Coui-t. However, loofcuig to Ul( Uiat ne is miicipal ot uoveniui|i reureinent aacl also consiclenug &y liim. suDsequenUy, we warq caretui in luture. y. i'ne conTeiiipt proceeuing a| 'tilffcl'fl-f WOTf 4 ft^ <(«<<]< ^raffipTSii^r p. Kosliy, leanieu coulisel appeaniis UiougJti Uie act ot Uie conteinnor is is a result ot lii aclvice aiid teicuior is a G 1 years oia person w&o ^ge. Me is uot coiiversatit TvitB Uie Lg. Atter reauzing Uie graviy- ot lus ^iia uucoiicliUonal apolog}- aitd is |tor me respecuve pames anu atter jiie peuUoa, me i~eply ancl aclctiuonal fitiouer ais.ci clocusieuts annexea )n tlie subinission ot t&e ieai-ued. ycl Uie conteninor guilty ot contenipt t age ot t&e contemnor aiiu uie tact |ent Uouege ana is on Uie verge ot |Ule uuconctitional apolog'y tenclerea Uie responcleiit-couteituior to De •e accorctuigly ctisposecl ot, Sd/- Dhirendra Mishra Judge