IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.8615 of 2006 Shyam Sundar Pandey, Son of late Banwari Pandey, Resident of Village Gangara, Police Station Gidhaur, District Jamui. ---------- Petitioner Versus 1. The State of Bihar through the Secretary, Human Resources Department, Government of Bihar, Patna. 2. The Secretary, Department of Finance, Government of Bihar, Patna. 3. The Special Secretary, Department of Finance, Government of Bihar, Patna. 4. The Director, Primary Education, New Secretariat, Bihar, Patna. 5. The District Superintendent of Education-cum-Sub-Divisional Education Officer, Jamui, District Jamui. 6. The Regional Education Officer, Jamui, District Jamui. 7. The Block Education Extension Officer, Jhajha, District Jamui. 8. The Headmaster, Primary School, Kathabajara, Jhajha-2, District Jamui. ----------- Respondents ----------- 3 24.6.2011 Having heard learned counsel for the parties and taking into account that it is an admitted position that the petitioner’s second time bound promotion could have matured only with effect from 1.1.1996 but such time bound promotion for the post of Teachers came to be abolished by the State Government with effect from 1.3.1989 on introduction of a revised pay-scale vide Government Resolution No. 6022 dated 18.12.1989, relevant portion whereof reads as follows:- ^^13 jkT; ljdkj us fu.kZ; fy;k gS fd vuqlwph&AA es vafdr iqujhf{kr osrueku bu fo|ky;ksa ds f'k{kdksa dks fn;k tk, rFkk izf'k{k.k] fu;qfDr ,oa izksUufr ds fy, ik=rk vkSj vU; lsok 'krZ ds tks mica/k dsUnz ljdkj esa gS mUgsa ;FkklaHko buds fy, Hkh ykxq fd, tk,WA 2 vr% buds osruekuksa esa n{krkojks/k Hkh cus jgsaxsA iqujhf{kr osrueku esa osru fu/kkZj.k dh izfdz;k ds fy, fuEufyf[kr fl)kar fu/kkZfjr fd, x, gSA ;s mica/k eSfV~d ¼vizf'kf{kr½ ;k fuEu ;ksX;rk/kkfj;ksa dks NksM+ lHkh 'ks"k f'k{kdksa ij ykxw gksaxsA (i) oSls lHkh f'k{kd tks tuojh] 1986 dks ewy dksfV ¼csfld xzsM½ esa Fks] dk osru fu/kkZj.k vuqlwph&AA esa vafdr iqujhf{kr osrueku esa fd;k tk ldsxkA (ii) oSls lHkh f'k{kd tks duh; izoj dksfV esa izksUufr vFkok dkyc) izksUufr izkIr dj pqds gksa vkSj 1 tuojh] 1986 ds iwoZ csfld xzsM esa 12 c"kZ dh lsok iwjh dj yh gks muds osru dk fu/kkZj.k vuqlwph&AA esa vafdr ojh; iqujhf{kr osrueku esa fd;k tk ldsxkA oSls f'k{kd] tks 1 tuojh] 1986 ds iwoZ duh; izoj dksfV esa izksUufr vFkok dkyc) izksUufr izkIr dj pqds gksa] ijUrq ml frfFk dks csfld xszM esa 12 c"kZ dh lsok iwjh ugha fd;s gks] muds osru dk fu/kkZj.k 1 tuojh] 1989 dks csfld xzsM ds gh iqujhf{kr osrueku esa fd;k tk;sxkA mUgsa izksUufr rFkk ojh; osrueku esa osru fu/kkZj.k dk ykHk ml frfFk ls vuqekU; gksxk] ftl frfFk dks os 12 c"kZ dh lsok iwjh dj pqds gksaxsA (iii) oSls f'k{kd] ftUgksaus 1 tuojh] 1986 ds ckn ij 1 ekpZ] 1981 ds iwoZ duh; izoj dksfV vFkok izFke dkyc) izksUufr izkIr dj yh gks] mUgsa iqujhf{kr osrueku ls osru fu/kkZj.k ds fy, izksUufr izkIr djus dh frfFk vFkok ftl frfFk dks 12 c"kZ dh lsok iwjh fd;s gksa] tks Hkh ckn esa gks] ds izksUufr dk ykHk fn;k tk;sxkA (iv) oSls f'k{kd] tks 1 tuojh] 1986 ds iwoZ ojh; izoj dksfV esa izksUur fd;s x;s gksa] vkSj 12 o"kZ dh lsok iwjh dj yh gks ;k 25 o"kZ dh lsok iwjh djus ds mijkUr f}rh; dkyc) izksUufr izkIr dj pqds gksa ds osru dk fu/kkZj.k iqujhf{kr ojh; osrueku esa fd;k tk;sxkA 1 tuojh] 1986 ds ckn ojh; izoj dksfV vFkok f}rh; dkyc) izksUufr dks iqujhf{kr osrueku esa osru fu/kkZj.k ds fy, utj vankt dj fn;k tk;sxkA (v) f'k{kdksa dks iqujhf{kr osrueku esa izoj.k ¼lysD'ku½ osrueku dk YkkHk inksa dh miyC/krk rFkk dsUnz ljdkj esa f'k{kdksa dks ;g lqfo/kk nsus lEcU/kh izfdz;k ,oa 'krksZa ds v/khu nh tk,xh vkSj ;g ekuk tk,xk fd ;s vkns'k 1 tuojh] 1986 ls ykxw gSA izoj.k osrueku] tgkW vuqlwph&AA esa vuqekU; gks] lacaf/kr laoxZ ds ojh; osrueku ds inksa dh la[;k ds 20 izfr'kr rd gh lhfer gksaxs 1 tuojh] 1986 dks izoj.k osrukeu esa inks 3 ds lEifjorZu ls lacaf/kr vkns'k ekuo lalk/ku fodkl foHkkx] for foHkkx ls ijke'kZ dj vyx ls tkjh djsxk vkSj bu inksa ij izksUufr mUgha 'krksZa ds vuqlkj nh tk,xh] ftu 'krksZa ds vk/kkj ij dsUnz ljdkj vius f'k{kdksa dks izksUufr nsrh gSA izoj.k osruekuksa esa inksa dh la[;k ds laca/k esa gj o"kZ 1 vizhy dks leh{kk dh tk,xh vkSj bl rjg dh igyh leh{kk dh frfFk 1 vizSy] 1987 gksxhA (vi) for foHkkx ds ladYi la[;k 10770] fnukad 30 fnlEcj] 1981 dh dafMdk 10 ,oa 11 esa micfU/kr dkyc) izksUufr rFkk izoj dksfV dh fo|eku lqfo/kk 1 ekpZ] 1989 ds ckn ls iqujhf{kr osrueku esa lekIr le>h tk;sxh vkSj 1 tuojh] 1986 ls osru fu/kkZj.k ds fy, ;s lqfo/kk;sa fdlh rjg vuqekU; ugha gksxhA vU; ljdkjh deZpkfj;ksa ds fy, vc ykxw dh tk jgh lqij Vkbe izoj dksfV dh lqfo/kk ,sls f'k{kdksa ds fy, ykxw ugha gksxhA fdUrq] ,slh izksUufr;kW ;fn 1 ekpZ] 1989 ds iwoZ ns; gks rks nh tk ldsxh vkSj orZeku osrueku esa Hkqxrku 28 Qjojh] 1989 rd ds fy, fd;k tk ldsxkA mlds ckn ;s izksUufr;kW lekIr le>h tk;sxhA ¼vii½ izksUufr ij osru fu/kkZj.k dh orZeku izfdz;k 1 tuojh] 1986 ls iqujhf{kr osrueku esa f'k{kdksa ds ekeys esa lekIr le>h tk;sxhA muds ekeys esa izksUufr ij osru fu/kkZj.k dh izfdz;k ekSfyd fu;ekoyh (Fundamental Rules) ds fu;e 22 ¼lh½ rFkk dsUnzh; ljdkj }kjk vius f'k{kdksa ds fy, le;&le; ij fuxZr funs'kksa ds }kjk 'kkflr gksxhA ml dafMdk (ii), (iii) (iv) ,oa (v) esa ;Fkk funsf'kr izksUufr ij osru fu/kkZj.k bUgha micU/kksa ds vuqlkj 'kkflr gksaxsA** (Underlining for emphasis) this Court would find that the same leaves nothing for speculation that the petitioner’s grievance for his second time bound promotion and consequential monetary benefit is impermissible in law. That being so, this application is wholly misconceived and the same is, 4 accordingly, dismissed. Rsh (Mihir Kumar Jha, J.)