e IN THS HIGI Ci,utf Oa flflNLT. IA AT BaflGAWRa DITED THI S THE 18TH LA! t 1 JUlIE 1998 .BEYOzI4 S.Ka &N’oLE fl.JUSUCb G.C. Hi 1 RIIA ..al! PITIGK XCda19672—95/1996 fltwEfl: 1• SriMittalkod SM. major, Lecturer in Hindi, Iaeaveehwar Arts Coflege, Bagalkot. 2. Sri Shettar S.L major, Lecturer in Statistics, Bagaveehwer Arts College, Begalkot. 3. Smt.Jalawadi tM. major, Lecturer in Kannada, Basaveshwar Afl College, Bagi-ucot. 4. Sri Blast B.k. major, Lecturer in &glish, Basavcshwar Arts College, Degalicot. 5. Sri Bhoosnurmstb LA. major, Lecturer in Mathematics, Bagaveshwar Science Oollee’e, Baglkot. II.0 6. Shri Nagilkar K.B. 8 major, Lecturer in lbysioe, 6 assv eahwer Science College, Bagslkot. ..2 ea 7. Sri Kalagthfly Seth, major, Lecturer ft Kaimada, Baeaveehwr Science Collce, i3egalkot. 8. Sri Goa’nkar 2.11. major, Lecturer ft Chemistry, Basaveshirar Science College, Bs’golkot. 9. atJunasikai LG. major, Lecturer ft Chemistry, .dasayeshwar Science College, .bag&akot. 10. Smt.Vanakudre VJ. major, Lecturer ft Physics, Basaveshwar Science College, Bagelsot. 11. Smt.Iddalgi LI. major, Lecturer ft Physics, Base, eshwar Science College, Bagalkot. 12. Jri Deshpande R.L. major, Lecturer ft Phycics, Bas,eshwar Science Ccliee, B’ galkot. 13. Sri Gouder 8.1. major, Lecturer ft Physscs, Basaveshwar Science College, Bagalkot. —3- 14. Sri Katirki k.t. major, Lecturer in Physics, Basaveshwar Science College, Bagalkot. 15. Sri Bellad H.C. major, Lecturer In Physics, J 3 aeaveehwar Science College, Begalkot. 16. Sri S.G.Biradar, major, Lecturer in Mathematics, Baeavtetlwar Science College, .dagalkot. 17. Smt.Kaladagi a,R major, Lecturer In Chemistry, Basaveehwar Science College, Bagelkot. 18. Smt.Karishankari 9.3. major, .Laecflrer in Chemistry, Basav eshwar Science College, Dagalkot. 19. Smt.Sabarad LI. major, Lecturer in Zoology, Basaveshwsr Science College, 20. Sri Patil BR. major, Lecturer in Political Science, Basaveshwar Coerce College, Baglkot. . .4.. it4z 4 IL0 0o A eqe a x 21. Sri s.S.Pujar, major, Lecturer in Conerce, Sri Veer Puflkeshi 1 rte, Coinerce & Science Coslege, .Hadnii, DistiBijapur. 0 22. Sri Bas 4 pattad k•d. aajor, Lecturer in Kannada, Sri. Veer Pulikeehi ins, Coruerce & Science Uoflege, Badami, Dist:Bijayur. 25. Sri. S.S.Patii, mejor, Lecturer in K. guiada, LG.V.O. An.., Coaerce & Science College, Kuddebihal, DistiBijapur. 24. Smt.°uloohena.S.Shivur, Lecturer in &glieh, Bsssveehwara Cozmuerce College, dagaLkot, Dist:Bijapur. (By Sri H.thipperudraprs, Aev) ..Petitionei aD: 1. Jtate of Kartrtaka, by its Secretary to (Ion, Dept. of Education, 11. 3.Uuilding, Banglore-1. 2. The Director of Collegiate Education, in Karnataka Pals ce Road, Bang’lore. . .5.. F 3. Sri Basaveehwar Vidya Vardhak Sangha, Dagalkot, DistsBijapur, by itst Jhainan. 4. Sri Veer Pulikeshi. Vidy Vardhric Sanöa, 3 Badi, Dist:Bijapur, by its Ohninan. 8 5. S.G.V.C. Yidya Prasad !rust, Muddebthal, Bijepur, 2 by its Chainan. (By Sri G.Papi Redoy, 40*) ..Reapondents . . . W.p. is filed under AflioLes 226 & 227 8 of the Constitution of Incia with a prayer to U direct R-1 & 2 to pay the peitioners the I diff.rence of pay and etc., This petition coming on for final disposal this day the court made the following: ..order.. :1: V.P. 19672e19695/96 ORDER H d It 1 3T ci ncsl ci th titic. i Pr V. Vidv. l,arne.cl H.C.G. for the respondents 2 The petitioners are empln>an nf a Private Eiucatinal tint tttton the tel’ t rlaini by th m in th present writ i tition t ins to ti ir cmpl it Th (ivision t.enh of this C.rtrt In 14 No. l83 to IR%/ ‘ and connected matters (DO 10.05 1’fl8’) has held thst even jf tha pi ivate educational institutinn has been admitted t 0 .jrant-’n aid urde tha r vision of the Gr t in Au Code b Ui a t jcirnn n iii i r aton’hup A m tet nd .rjant between the govt. iment ani the rcwsons like thc petitioners comes into being and therefore. the writ petitions filed by such employee ave not maintainable under Mttcle 226 t the r titut r of Iniia iincr thnv t..nc ‘ffec.tiv effi a • c qit’ atve •t t v ne i * aitati ‘inde the K r tali ji, atior A t, ig (In eli it ‘the A..t’). In .na ih 1 t the iuclgm 4t h teen 1 w i I it “Ar rrtirds the lr*i.t standi cf stat’ ‘.vn-k;ng in the 4foresaid educational in’ttituti’ns ta mdintain the writ etitione tFa’ hs.,e got the reqiiady of appeal undet- 5’s. tion 94 nf the Education Act aginst an order of dismi°al or ‘removql from re ire or r ducti n in rank LJnd r ce(ticn 110. aFFeal .s cro,.idec’ .ignnst an order ccs.”ed by au otf c.e n authrrit undn the Act cccti(n 111 ids fcr r vi u n b G vcrnm’nt •itt.r cj nctc, o o an ar.pltati i trom my pane r inte, ‘ted ‘Zectlun 11. nf tl-. Fd’vat’c’n fet prnvjel, fnr VIGL I th t t I e nment i h€r u t r an app1 tb i d froir ci p r mt re t i en 1 o I wrh H FOW€ t give lire tior undt t’on 33 if tI ca d A t t mak enquiry or tak a r Fri te t ding b the C rr i’ioner r Dir r ri t r ff c r t b low tI bc ik of Di t i(t Elucitioral Ofti I t ubmt poit TI tI Edu ti T Act videc fo rc al e ir and i€vew n T€p t f n rdr and in th€ absence of ry o dci the 6 vernm€nt r 1, movd for i uing n s r dirt on x r i f it paw ‘r ii fl ci +f r said rem ii Eu with r gar I t paynnt of icry, wh-i i t ted abov€ with r card tc te t hin nd ron t ehin ‘tiff b Ii the th r taff 1 o L.itI ut h ting i h alt r t mel tFc - nn t perftitti t in k tI etraordanr uri dicti ii f tI c ( t under Aiti 1 6 of the C ntitutin 4 For the afor aid €a’on the w It F titin’ iicmissed on the grouni f ivarl3bilit’ of effi iou ff ctive alt ative r m d Hoev t all the iglt ani g it ted b€ for t I a p opi i to t tot or If aiv €d the p tt wy f filng a al nay val th ii t ttutr r v ioi / Fclc ti n cc cc- f 1 I r I 4fEY f to -hould be d p r th from the d t of riru tim f 3UDGE ) C j - k/