"S api^L- ^ ^^^9W O^^ 1 Tl-'F MTfit-1 f'H' i&T f-)F .Tt jhTf-'ATi l&F f"'j-|w'.d l ^1 T £?^-1 A 01 - i ".-?.—KM-•». 1 4T V.P. RTl A.SPtffi -syo /_goo^ P6tiTloi'i^r' ,^%^/ ^^. ^y^ €^i^ ^P&n(?.;''' ^•>^y ^" ef\y ^' <iv'y ^ V^l/?^l i^ 5mt.Kriffhna iV.andai^ n'/o ann rraaeep manau!, i ^E~^jEH^?tfi . Ff?niiffh •^^i_/^?'i^t¥i^?'i< fe^l^tu. »*-fi s^.» l<n» ^4fc?^»ii i^V t-lrii; ; ?ij i&fi i , Mirth^i" ^s>^rryiH^.y^/ ^^h^/%! iiyj! tf^tli fcrf'fc'fc/WC Sfc^^.AS J- h^t,>B n'lir^* ^ .~Tntri¥%t^Ml Kl T P /" ^rih/^ F^i^t * (^ IAF 6 it SS ^-»n?I » t?> B »1 c^a-'a 'i'^A-f? 6^>E^^ i.jrta? S ' \-(r'_ /^ \ (''fc.—'iL/IA j^l/ale'-e^ ic-/ ItAi Chhatti'SQari i^h ^ T'htf ^,o/~^^'1''/ti^i 5 I il WU^? i ~ i ? i^- *«?E,*^*i ^a 3 Isii y j P^g?^^ir-^"M^o'it*t- r,,-^' ^^'h*^nl ^-rfi s^^'t't^ ^g'IJUf'! ?ii£>?i; UE t-?i-FiwUi C>US-si-ey 5 iw^S. '„ Kaspur, fL '.yt^f ?i '~^Eri-*S?< '.f^ ^?r ^^i V" ^:;:^ ll6",,.,' t^. JoinT D'rectflfV Pubiic Instruction Biiaspur &!visJ! Chhattisqarh istrict EducatioR Officerf Dist: Ker-ba-(C.6.) ^i^^-l- ^n^^f^'^ion^'p /' Tribal Welfare bepartment, hi=t : Knr-hn-tnfi !E5 E » r^y? ~L/u~i ^-,^?a tfock EducatioR Officer/ Korba, bist: Korba-(C.6.) WRTT PFTTTTnN DNhFR ARTT/:! F 226 / 227 DF TI-IF CONSTTTUTTC5N OF INMA FOR ISSUANCF OF SUIT.4BLF WRIT.,wftIT_&_DlKECT10N_ETc;_'roDO JUSTICE IN THE kh ATT^D r i HIGH OOURTPF CHHATnSGARH AT BILASPUR Petitioner Rcspondents PctitioHcr Rcspondcats Ftetitfoner Respoadents PetiCuiier Respondeats Petitioner Rcspoiidcnts Pfetitioner Respoadcntsi W. P. fel No.5838of2006 Smt Prabha Mahobia Vcrsus State ofChhattiagarh & othera W. P. (sl No. 5839 of2006 Versus Smt Sarojmi Uitee Vcrsus State of Chhattasgarii & othc»B W. P. (sl No. 5840 <rf2006 Smt Renu Bala Diamond State of ChhattisgaA & others W, P. fs) No. 5841 of2006 BaniBflas SIianna Vcraus State ofChhattisgarh & ofhers W. P. fsl No, 5842 of2006 Smt Archna Shanna Versus State ofChhattisgaA & othera W. P. fs» No. 5843 of2006 Vcrsus And Smt Aniina Bhattachaiya i State of-Chhattisgarit & othera W. P. fel No. 5850 of2006 : Smt Krishna Mandal Versua Petitioner : Rcspondenfe : State ofChhattis^rii & ofhera Staj^e Ben«sh: Hon'b|e Mr. Justicc Satteh K. Agnlliotri. '^. . .'- .. • ' Shn Anil Si^h Rajput, Advocate fia- tfaje.Petitioners. Shri Ufkarsfc Venna, Oovt Advocate fi>r fhc State/respondents. ORDBR (30& October, 2006) ;E£3?sacs.'; "Bis The petitioaers are woridng as Assistant Teachera/Upper Division Teachers in the gavenuacat schools. lu the coiirae of thcir scrvkses as Assfataat Tcachers/Upper Dxrisk>n Teachers, the pctitioD'ers have obtoiaed B. Ed. cxanunation certificates on fhcu- own expenses bcfore 1.3.1999. 4. Writ Ptetition (S) No.s 5838/2006, 5839/2006, 5840/2006, 5841/2006, 5842/2006, 5843/2006 and 5850/2006 aro beiag disposed ofby this comnaon oider as the facts and questwn of law iavolved in tlSse petituiis are coaunon. According to teamed counsel for the petitioners, fhc pctitioners are entiflcd to two advance increments m vicw of the decision of this Court in the case of Yasbwaat Kunaar BharEidwai Va. Muiucipal Ctorporation. DuEg and aoother {2006 (II) MPJR-CG 96}. This Court in fhc case of Yashwant Kuanar Bharadwaj Vs. Mumcipal Corporatfon, Dm^; and anofher (Supn^, came to .the conclusion that the tcacUers, who had obtained B. Ed. Bxainination Certificate on thear own expcnacs, are covcred by the circular dated 24.12.98 (Annexure P/l) issucd by fhe State Oovenunent ofMadhya Ptadcsh. Furfber in fhc inatter of Smt. Manorama Shrivastava Vs, State^if M.P. and othcra {2000 (1) M.P.L.S.R. 136 } tfac Madhya Pradesh State Admiuistra.ttvc Tribimal, Gwalior Bcnch, whifc considcrixig the cucular dated 1.3.1999 whcrein, it is provided that thc Aasistaut Tcachere, who have acqiured B. Bd. degree at fheir own cost bctwcen 23.10.1964 and 7.5.1973 shaB bc cntitfed to two advaitce BMsrements, rcUcd on decasion ia thc caae of Rakcsh Kumar Shrivastava Vs. State of M.P. & otfaers passcB ia O.A. No. 1632/99, decided on 12.10.1999 whcreia it is obaexved that the circular dated 1.3.1999 caxmot be made appVcable rctrospcctwefy. Thus, a tcacher, saay be Assistant Tcacher, wbo has obtained B. Ed. dcgrec beforo l.3.1999 is entitted to two advaace mcreinents; It is pomted out by leamed coiuisd appeariag for thc petitioncra that the fhen State of Madhya Pradesh had filed a Special Leave Ir- Petition agmnst the orders parised by the Tribunal and ttie Hon'blc Supreme Court dismissed Special Leavc Pctition No. 1999/2000 fited against the order of thc TribiuiaL Thercfore, fhe ducction to the efiect fhat fhe circiilar dated l.3.1999 cannot be inade appIiGablc ietrospcctivety, passed by the Tribunal, becoines final and fhe aaaase shaU be appUcabte to afl fhe Assistant Teachers who havc obtgiined B. Ed. cxaminatioa certificate befoic 1.3.1999. It is furfher Ai.biStantiated by a cucutar dated 17.10.2003 issued by the pres^ul State of Madhya Pradesh whcrein thc ciicular clearly stetes abaut the decision offhe SuprBme Court. Leamed coutwel for the petitfoners 'fiirtfaer submits thflt fhe feicts and questuMi of ]aw invohred in fhe prescnt case arc squarety covered by decision of fhis Court in fhe case of Yashwant Kumar Bharadwaj Vs. Miuucipal Corporatioa, Duig aad anothcr (Supr^, to which feamed counscl appcaring for thc rcspondcnts fairty concedes aiid agrecs wifb the averment made by leamed coiuisel appearu^ fcn- the pctitionera. .,/\ Accordingfy, thc writ petttioiis are aBowcd ia tenns of fhe ordcr passed in ffie case ofYashwant Kiunar Bharadwaj Vs. Municipal Corporatton, Durg and axiothcr (Suprs^, subject to verification of tfac feurt as to whether fhe petittoxters havc acquired B; Ed. Examinatidn Certiffcate on their own expenses as per thc cuculars dated 24.12.1998 and 1.3.1999 aad furtfaer whether they have been paid two advance uicrenaents or not No order as to costs. Bab&i 8. Acopyofthisonlerbcplacedonreoordincormectedinatters. Sd/- Satish K. Agnihotri Judge i|