C-^ \s'y)/^ ISL .B IN THE HON'Bl-E HIGM COURT OF CHMAtTISGARH AT BILASPUR (C.e.) WP (S)NO^^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^ PETrTEONER ^. -0.- •y^^ •-^y<*' I^y"' ^ •<•«' .. ^~'^ ^^.-••"" ^^a' Pr-ddeep Kumar'Pafr'eraged about 42 years; S/o Purinidds Patre, Lecturer, 6overnmerit Higher Seconcldr-y School Khodri Block ©ourella,Distt. Bjlaspur (G.G.) VERSUS RESPONDENTS : /- 1. 2. 3; 4. State of Ghhattisgarh Thrdugh Secr'etary, TribalWelfdr'e Depar'tmeht 0;K.S.BHaWah,iRaipuF (£.©.) CbtTitnissiorier Tribdl Welfdre Department, Raipur- (C.G.) Joint Director;Treasur'yAccbunt &Pension Bilaspur bistt; Bilaspur (C.6.),' :;':' :. ::::•:::.-:^^ AssistantCommissjoner Tribal We.lfgre Depar'tment, : Bilaspur(C.G.): , , i uH^" 5. Principal,66vernment Higher Secondafy School; Khbdri, ¥(&our'ella,BilaSpur^C.I?.) WRIT PEtITION U/A 226/227 6F TI-IE CONSTITUTION OFINDIA 'ni:;;Li,-!-:s®; +a:ii-]'BiSSua3i Hi*iyii «»*trai 3^t '^ifici^, ®t)l<i'is,f»«-iiyy,< ^^.......^.B-...^...^.:..6.^^ 3?lt?ITR^ (1q(3'!"\'E') sn^iqiifipiw '(T%H ^FTT^T ^'WF TOIIW ^itel 3iltW SB : HOW'BLE MR. JUSTICE PKlTINKER DIWAKER 3Q.11.3010 ShriK.S.Pawar, coiuisel fe ShriVivek Sharma, P.L. fo ff flie petitioner. t- fhe Stats. Scbool frolra The petinoner, wh.o wa; AssisTant Teacher under th.e 29.01.1994 (Amiexure P/1) is respondeats in nct adding two ai even. thoush h.e did his B.Ed. University, New Delhi at bis ov| seekine permission tbr fhe saaie Counsel for the petitioner) entifled for two adyance uicreat Examination certificate. in acc< Circular dated 24.12.98 and in Supreine Court in the matter c| Badrinaravaa Acharya an.d of&t aad Yashwant Kuinar B]iardw|aj Durg aiid another reported in On the other hand. erstwhUe State of Madbva 22.10.1964 allowed advaacel goveminent servants wfao pi{< 22.10.1964 whefher at his own However, who pioceeded on ;et t»70aimual iacreiuenfs onlv 2006 couKsel traljiiu qhi<i[<n<ili ^i<JI<?ff^f Is^l Tf^f^K i?3ffin.3ii^?i >pomted oa tbe post of Education Depaitiaent on -ieved by tbe acfion of fhe iivance ra.cremeE.ts in his sslan' Indira Gaitdfai National Open 'n cost in the vear 2007 after -oia fhe department. submits tliat tlie petitioner is •nts as he had obtsiued, D.Ed ^rdance witb tb.e provisions of [iew of fhe judgtnents of HouTale |f State of M.P. & Anofher Vs. ;rs reported in 1996 SC 2779 Vs. Municipal Corporation, (II) MPJR 96 (CG). [sel for the State subnuts tliat Pradesh vide circidar dated increineittg^^only to tliose oceeded fcr^r^jiuiig up to ;ost or at fhe goveniiaent cost. on or after 23.10. 1964 caa \ tf fhe trairmie is at his cost aiid ..^"f^ ;E,, »'a -^-/i '"^aS^ " XI-HC—78 T *<i*<ni th^nqi 3~Sf •<fl''iW^, Btll'M'l®,[s|MI<H^< .U£:...^l..^s.:.M^^ sn^?r Tra?i' (ijcif^si^) OT^rwlnw 'cTW ^n^?T ^?H^ cftl^f^ftf '^^ tf ^^ Tf^T^X i? aifipT an^i not at tlie cost of the Goven 23.10.1964 was superceded vid Goveniiuent vide notification d Non-Gazette Class-II Educanona RecruitEuent aud Proinotion Rul B.T.I. or B.Ed degree for appoin Teacher. The petitioner wou increirients onlv in fhe conditi B.T.I/B.Ed./B.T.I. degree at his obtaining permission form the d to 1.3.99. To clai-ify the above been issued on 6.2.2007 aad on. Facts, as detailed above, q th.e ruatter of Yashwant Kiunarl discussing the circulars dated| upon the judgiaent of fhe HonT) Badriiiarayaii Acharya's ca.se not assistaEt teachers alone, w<] increaients on obteininK B.Ecl 22.10.1964, as the circular prcscribe a.ny outer tunit of the| & B.T.I. certificate. It has been 1.3.99 is appUcable to oiLly Assi|i other teachers (UDT). itaient. This circular~of dated * order dated 10.12.1975. The ^ted 16.6.1973 amended M.P. Services ^Non-coBeee Semces) :s, 1993 added quaUfication of |taient on the post of Assistant ld be ennfled for advaiice .tibn ffaat he had ototatned his own cost during service after epartiaent between 23.10.1964 ^osition. circulars have alreadv 130.1.09. re not in dispute. Tliis Coiirt in Bharadwaj (supra) elaborately 24.12.98, 1.3.99 and relying Ue Auex C-ourt. in fhe m.atter of upra) has held that teachers, iiiid be entitled to two advance examiaation certificate after dated 22.10.1964 does not period ofobtam.ing B.Ed, M.Ed zirthei- held that circular dated itant Teach,ers (LDT) and not to XI-HC—78 ^ST '^ww^, .Btily'16, fsi<niy^< ^......^..e.^.)...f^.:...&^. sn^i Tra^T (''pf^^i) 311^1 WR;-1 ^TT 3TT^?rg7qraT TOIIW'ato sn^i Shri Shanna fairlv subiaits hi Yashwant Kuiuar Bharadwai finality and ca.se ofthe petitioner covered by the above judginj 24.12.1998. For fhe aforesaid reasons, payinent oftwo advance uic'renie^ of the petitioner's B.Ed. examin^.' are accordiaglv, directed to EC; increm.ents to fh.e petitioner froii^ exainination, withia a period However, fhis order shall be subi the State regarding facts pleaded No otder as to costs. qil^<n*ll*T ^TH<lf ^ fe^ Tf^R^R ^T sifiiH sn^s |that principle ofJaw laid down fs case (supra} tias attained ^n fbis petition is also squarely ;nt as also circular dated pie petitioner is entitled to fhe [ts from. the date ofdeclaration ^.tion result. The respondents |ke payDaent of two advance fbe date ofhis passiag B.Ed. ^f foiir inonfhs froia today. ^ct to aU verifications inade by |in the petition. Sd/- pritink«>rDiwakar Jixdge H