^ \-yY~) .^l%JQji8^^ THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR WRIT APPEAL N0.4 Lt5 OF 2011 APPELLANTS/ RESPONDENTS Guru Ghasidas University Bilaspur through Registrar, Bilaspur (Chhattisgarh) Examination Controller, Guru Ghasidas University Bilaspur (Chhattisgarh) VERSUS RESPONDENTS/ PETITIONERS .^y/^ SL / /^o^^ ^^y '/^/^> .•y -^^ <^/ .^- &1 1 .<^^ Maya Dubey, aged a bout 21 years, D/o Shri Surendra Kumar Dubey, sfcudrnt of B. A. Part-III, R/o Basant Vihar, Bilaspur (CG) ^ 2. Kamini Sahu, aged about 21 years, D/o Shri Uttam Sahu, student of B. A.Part-III, R/o Sarkanda Bilaspur (Chhattisgarh) 3. Ahilya Kewat, aged about 21 years, D/o Late Dhannu Ram, student of B. A. Part-III, R/o Chalidih Vihar, Bilaspur (CG) 4. «-^"NehaChoubey, aged about: 21 years, D/o Late Sliarad Choubey, student: of B. A. Part-III, R/o Ashok Nagar, Bilaspur (CG) ^" 5. Laxmi Pandey, agecl about 21 years, D/o Shri Shashi Kumar Pandey, student of B.A.Part-III,R/o Chingranj- para, Bilaspur (CG) 6. ^ Bharti Pathak, aged about 21 yea.rs, D/o Rajkumar Pathak, student of B. A. Part-III, R/o Mopka District Bilaspur (CG) .7. Savitri Das, aged about 21 Years, D/o Shri Suk:chain Das, student of B A I:>art.-lII, R/o Basant Vihar, Bilaspur 8.^ Aruna Mourya, agedabout21 Years, D/o Sri Kishcin Mourya student of B. A. P<u-t-[]I, R/o Chingrajpara, Bilaspur (CG) 9. ^ Laxmiii Thakur, agecl about 21 Years, D/o Chandrika Singh Thakur student of BA P.irt-III R/o Chingrajpara, 13ila>spur CG 10.^ Nirmala Dewangai'i^aged about 21 Years, D/o Shri Rcimayan student of B A P<:u-t-III, R/o Chingrajpara, Bilaspur CG 11.^- Kajal Markam, aged about 21 D/o Suksen Markarn student of BA Part-III R/o Chingrajpai-a, Bilaspur (Chhattisgarh) 12. Rajni Dewaiigcin, aged about 21 Years, D/o Shri Chctram Dewangan, R/o Chingrajpara, Bilaspur (Chhatliisgarh) 13. Nilima Sahu, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Shanl: i Sahu studentgfBA Part-I 14, rRainiJ^aiak, aged about 19 Yea.rs, D/o Late Sl'iiv K.t.imar studentofBA Part-I, 15. Monika Thalcar, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shii Shyaraacharan studentofBA Part-I 16. Sangeeta Vern'i.a,, aged about 19 Yeai's, D/o Shri Santosh Verma studentofBA Part--I 17. Shashi Sahu, agecl about 19 Years, D/o Shri Faguram Sahu student of BA Part--! 18. ftagini Dewangan, aged about 19 Years, D/o Sliri Vijay Dewangan stuclent of 13A Part-I 19. Angan. Uraon, aged aboiit 19 Years, D/o Shii Bahadi:ir Uraon student of BA Part--I 20. ^ashmi sii'igli Thakur, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Rameshwar Sing:.h Thakur, studentofBA Pwt-l, 21. Nilima Pandey, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Shashi Kumar Pandey,student ofE3A l:)art-I \> ^ 22. Geeta Patel, aged aboiit 19 Years, D/o Shri Jitendra Patel student ofBA Part-I 23. ^Anita Mitra, aged aboi.it 19 Years, D/o Shri Arnar Mitra student of BA Part-I 24. Durga Aghari3^a, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Shivendra studentofBA Pai't-I 25. Shiv Kumari Yadav, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Bhagirathi Yadav student of BA Part.-I 26, A<rti Mourya, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Mithilesh Mourya student of BA l::)art-I <^' 27. 'Shobha Sahu, agecl atxnit 19 Yea.rs, D/o Shri Dhajiraj Sahu student of BA Part -I 28. fl:>uja Dewangaii, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri KcU'tikrain Dewanganstudeiit of BA Part-I 29. Puja Dewangan, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Khilavran. Dewangan, studcnt of BA Part-I 30. Maheshwari Patel, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Ghansliyam Patel student of B A Pa rt -I 31, Gauri Yadav, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Ramkzunar Yadav student of BA Pa.i L-I 32. < Prid Yadav, aged about .19 Years^ D/o Shri Vimal Yadav, student of BA Part-I 33 "Shiv Kumari Sahu S^il'ii^ aged about 19 Years, D/o Surajrarn Sa.hu studentofBA Part-I 34. .Babita Thakur, agecl about 19 Years, D/o,Shri Sitaraj]i Thakur student of BA Part -I 35 ^-Sheela Kewat, aged about: 19 Yeai's, D/o Shri Khorba.hara Kewat student of BA Part-I 36 /vSwati, aged about 19 <li/cars, D/o Shri Ramdhajii student of BA Part-I / ^%^^7 37. Reena Rajgir, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri: LakharLlal studentofBA PcU-t-I 38. Neelarn Tiwari, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Narmada Prasad Tiwari student of BA P;:u-t-I 39 Anju Gupta, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Rajkuniar Gupta student ofBA Part-I 40. Bharti Gaii.dharv, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri. Mahajan Gandharv student of BA Part-I 41. Lalita Tiwari, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Madanmohan Tiwari, student ofT3A F'art-I 42. Jyoti Dhivar, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Mohanlal Dhivar student of BA Pcirt-I 43. Puja Sharma, agcd about 19 Yeai-s, D/o Shri Chandi-a Kishore Sharrna, student ofBA Part-I 44. Suchitra KeshcU'wani, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Santosh Kesharwani student of BA Part-I 45. Vidya Yadav, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Durgesh Yadav studentofBA Paft.-I 46. Santoshi Sahu, aged cibout 1.9 Years, D/o Shri Baldci.li Prasad Sahu, studentofE?A Part-I 47. Janki Sahu,agecl about 19 Years, D/o Shri Baldciii Prasad Sahu, 48. Nitu Bajpai, aged aboi.li 19 Years, D/o Shri MLikes]i Bajpai studentofBA Pai-t-I 49. Triveni Uraon, aged at)out 1,9 Years, D/o Shri Duryodhan Uraon, student ofBA F'art-I 50. Poornima Mehar, ag.cd about 19 Years, D/o Shri Trilochan Mehar 5.1. Kavita Rajput, aged at)out 19 Yea.rs, D/o Shri Fii^mkrishna Rajput, studentofBA Part-I ^S2^ ^^^7 52. Sonu Yadav, agecl about 19 Years, D/o Late Sa.nt Kumar Yadav, studenl: of BA Part-I 53. Ranjana Shai-ma, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Tejram Sharma, student of BA Part-I 54. Usha Shrivas, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri Prajtnocl Shrivas student ofBA Pail-I 55. Pratibha Jaiswal, aged about 19 Yeai's, D/o Shri Ter'a.s Jaiswal student of BA Part -I 56. Khushboo Dewaga.n, aged about 19 Years, D/o Shri BL Dewangan, student of BA Part-I Petitioner No.13 to 56 C/o Govt. Mata Sabari Naveen Girls College, Bilaspur (CG) 57. Kajol Khan, aged aboi:it 20 Yeai's, D/o Mohd. Salini Khaii student of I3A Pa.rt-I, R/o Sarkanda, Bilaspur (CCi) 58. Ahilya Kashyap, aged about 21 Yeai's, D/o Ramesh Kumar Kashyap, studentofBA Pcirt-III, R/o Uslapur, ESilaspur |CG) 59. Sangeeta Sahu, aged about 1.9 Years, D/o Bahoran Sahu student of BA Part-I, R/'o Village Mopka, BUaspur (CG) 60. Pramila Tonde, aged about 19 Yeai's, D/o Ra.rnnarayaji Tonde student of ESA Part:-!, R/o Mopka, Bilaspur (CG) 61. State of Chhattisgarh Through the Sec:retary, Higher EclucationDepart rnent, Mantralaya,Dau KaJyan Singh Bhawan, Raipur (CG) 62. Shaskiya Mata Saba.ri Naveen Kanya Mahavidyala.ya, through Principal, Seepat Road, Bilaspur (Chhaltisgarh) 63. Smt. Sunanda Maravi, Assistant Lecturer (Hindi Subject|Shaskiya Mata Sabari Naveei"! Kanya Mahavidyalaya, Seepat Road, Bilaspur (Chhciltisgarh) 7 WRIT APPEAL UNDER SECTION (1) OF CHHATTISGARH HIGH COURT APPEAL TO DIVISION BENCH ACT, 2006 READ WITH RULE 158 (10| OF CHHATTISGARH HIGH COURT RULES, 2007. HIGH COURT OP CHHATTISGARH^MLASPUR DB: HON*BLB I.M. QUDDUSI & HON*BLB G. MINHAJUDDIN, JJ, W.A.No.421/2011 Vs. RBSPONDENTS Lata Yadav aad others ItSWWIN^: l^ W.A.No.468/2011 Vs. W.A. No.449/2011 Vs. W.A.No.433/2011 Vs. WRIT APPEALS UNDER SECTION 2(11 OF THE CHHATTISGARH HIGH COURT (APPBAL TO DIVISIQN BBNCHI ACT. 2006 RBAD WITH RULE 158 110) OF CHHATTISGARH HIGH CQURT RULBS. 2007 APPELLANTS Gum Ghasidas Universityand anofher APPELLAS9TB Gum Ghasidas Universilyand aiiother RE8PONDBNT8 Renu Jaiswal and ofhiers APPBLLANTS Gum Ghasidas Universityaad aaother RESPONDBNTS Maya Dubey aad ofhers APPBLLANTS Guru Ghasidas Universityand another RESPONDBNTS Maaisha Gupta aad othera^ APPEARANCB: Mr. Ashish Shrivastava aiid Mr. Chandresh Shrivastava, counsel for fhe appeUaats ia all fhe writ appeals. Mr. V.C. Ottalwar counsel for respondents 1 to 34 in W.A.421/2011, respondents 1 to 27 m W.A.468/2011, respondents 1 to 60 m W.A. 449/2011 and rcspondents 1 to 24 inW.A. 453/2011 Mr, Viaay Hadt, Deputy Advocate General for fhe State/ respondent no.35 ia W.A, 421/2011, respondent no,28 ia W.A.468/2011, respondent No.61 in W.A.449/2011 and respondent no.25 inW.A. 453/2011. Mr, P.S. Koshy, appears on behalf of Sunaada Maravi/ Respondent no.37 in W.A.421/2011, rcspondent no.30 in W.A.468/2011, Respondent no.63 in W.A.449/2011 & Respondent no.27 m W.A.453/1 1. Per I.M. OUDDUSI. J. ORALORDER (18.11.2011) 1. The above writ appeals have been filed agamst fhe common impugned order dated 08,08.2011 passed by fhe leamed Siagle Judge in W.P(C).Nos.l581, 1626, 1673 and 1580 of 2011 aUowiag the writ petitions, The learaed siagle Judge has held fhat the petitioners satisfied fhe basic requirements of attendaace; fhus tiiey shaU be treated as regular students for fhe examination wherein they had already appeared and fhe result of fhe said exainiaation shall be declared forthwith within a period ofone week fi-om today so fhat fhe petitioners could not be deprived ofadniission to furfher higher courses. 2. W.A. No.421/2011 rclates to W.P(C ).No.l581/2011 (Lata Yadav and others -vs- State); W.A.468/11 relates to W.P.(C ). 1626/11 (Renu Jaiswal and others -vs- State); W.A. 449/11 relates to W.P (C). 1673/2011 (Maya Dubey and others Vs. State) and W.A. 453/11 relates to W.P (C ). 1580/11 (Mamsh Oupta and others Vs. State). Siace fhese appeals iavolve smular facts and question of law, fhey are being disposed of by fhis coinnion order. 3. AppUcation has beeu filed ia each writ appeal on behalf of fhe respondent-stadents who were petitioners iii fhe writ petitions prayiag that the appeUaats/Universily herem.be directed to declare thej4? results of fheir respective courses ie,, B.A,, /B.Com., /B.C.A., (Part-I, Part-II aad Part-III) in the interest of justice, However, ia Paragraph 2 offhe application it has been prayed for a direction to the appeUaat University to declare ttie results of fhe respondent students tareatirtg fhein as private studeuts as fhey had appeared for fhe fiinal exaoiiaation of said courses held ia acadenuc session 2010-2011, 4. In view of tkie above, learaed counsel for the appeUants has submitted that fhe writ appeUants have no objectiou to declare the result of fhe respondents as private students. 5. Siace therc is no objection on tiie side of fhe writ appeUants, we dispose of all fhe four writ appeals with a direction fhat the results of the respondent-stadents shaU be declared treatiag fhenx as private students, 6« The ixnpugned order dated 08,08.2011 passed by the learaed siagle judge shall staad modi&ed to fhe above exte^t^ Sd/- I.M. Quddusi Judge Sd/- G. Minhajuddin Judge Rao ^