IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.5269 of 2004 DR.MD.SHAMSHUL HAQUE SHAMSI Versus THE STATE OF BIHAR & ORS -------- 03/ 23.07.2010 In the communication dated 05.01.2004 contained in annexure 2, there is very categorical statement that the Department of Finance vide Resolution no. 25 dated 03.01.2004 has given the replacement pay scale 10000- 15200- to the Director of Arbi and Farsi Research Institution. This benefit was accorded notationally from 01.01.1996 and financially from 01.04.1997. The petitioner is not satisfied with the grant of pension on the said pay scale. He has brought Annexure 2/1 which is extract from some document which shows replacement scale of 3700/- 5000/- is also 12000/- 16500/-. There are many pay scales and replacement pay scales which were recommended by the Pay Revision Committee for many a posts. Whether Annexure 2/1 pay scale applies to the petitioner is the question. There is neither clear statement or pleading in the writ application nor there is a challenge to the notification of the Finance dated 03.01.2004 which has given replacement pay scale of Rs 10000- 15200/ on the post the petitioner was working. In absence of any material or pleading as well as challenge to fixation of pay scale, petitioner has no case for demanding a pay scale on the basis of so called extract as contained in Annexure 2/1. The writ application is dismissed as it is devoid of merit. shahid (Ajay Kumar Tripathi, J)