IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Cr.Misc. No.17186 of 2010 1. SUDHAN PRASAD @ SUDHAN PRASAD GUPTA S/O SHIVLAGAN PRASAD, R/O MOHALLA BILAYATI BARI, P.S. & DISTRICT KISHANGANJ, PERMANENT R/O BARADIA, N.H.-31, P.S. CHAKULIA, DISTRICT NORTH DINAJPUR, WEST BENGAL 2. SHEIKH ALAM @ S.K. ALAM, S/O SHAJARAT HUSSAIN, R/O MOHALLA RAJAPUR, P.S. DHOLI SAKARA, DISTRICT MUZAFFARPUR, AT PRESENT RESIDING AT VILLAGE TEUSA BALIACHAK, P.S. GWALPOKHAR, DISTRICT NORTH DINAJPUR, WEST BENGAL 3. KARNAL SINGH @ KARNEL SINGH S/O SHRI BACHAN SINGH, R/O DANGI BASTI, P.S. DISTRICT KISHANGANJ 4. JASPAL SINGH S/O HARBANSH SINGH, R/O MOHALLA KISHANGANJ, P.S. & DUSTRICT KISHANGANJ, AT PRESENT RESIDING AT VILLAGE GHORDAPA, P.S. PANJIPADA, DISTRICT NORTH DINAJPUR, WEST BENGAL 5. ASHOK SINGH S/O SHRI BACHENDRA SINGH, S/O VILLAGE ASURAGARH, P.S. CHAKULIA, DISTRICT NORTH DINAJPUR, WEST BENGAL …. PETITIONERS Versus THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH THE CABINET (VIGILANCE) DEPARTMENT, BIHAR, PATNA …. OPPOSITE PARTY ----------- 3. 28.1.2011 The petitioners have prayed for quashing of the order dated 17.4.2010 passed by the Additional District Judge IV, Patna in Special case No.33 of 1997, by which the prayer for supply of relevant police papers has been refused. The Counsel for the petitioners contend that the petitioners have not been supplied with the statements of witnesses mentioned at Serial No.8, 9 and 10 in column no.10 of the charge sheet and an enquiry report. On going through the case diary, I find that the witnesses mentioned at Serial No.8, 9 and 10 have been examined in paragraphs 181, 183 and 195 of the case diary and the entire case diary has been supplied to 2 the accused persons. Therefore, his prayer is totally unjustified. As for the supply of the enquiry report since the same does not find mentioned in the charge sheet it evidently means that the prosecution is not going to rely on the same and, therefore, there is no requirement of law for supply of the same to the accused persons. In view of such, the application is dismissed. Narendra/ ( Anjana Prakash, J.)