IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT : THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PIUS C.KURIAKOSE & THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N.K.BALAKRISHNAN TUESDAY, THE 25TH JANUARY 2011 / 5TH MAGHA 1932 LA.App..No. 641 of 2004(A) ------------------------------- LAR.75/2003 of ADDL.SUB COURT, THALASSERY .................... APPELLANT(S) 1 TO 22, 24 TO 69, 71 TO 115, 118 TO 123 BEFORE THE COURT BELOW -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1. R.RAMAKRISHNAN,S/O.LATE PARU, AGED 79 YEARS,RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL, KODIYERI AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY. 2. R.P.SOUDHAMINI,W/O.LATE R.P.BALAKRISHNAN AGED 64 YEARS,RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL, KODIYERI AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY. 3. R.P.GAYATHRI,D/O.LATE R.P.BALAKRISHNAN, AGED 40 YEARS,RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL, KODEYERI AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY. 4. R.P.SHERINA,D/O.LATE R.P.BALAKRISHNAN, AGED 38 YEARS,RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL, KODEYERI AMSOM DESOM,THALSSERY. 5. R.P.SAMATH,S/O.LATE R.P.BALAKRISHNAN, AGED 36 YEARS,RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL, KODEYERI AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY. 6. R.P.DHANYA,D/O.LATE R.P.BALAKRISHNAN, AGED 34 YEARS,RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL, KODEYERI AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY. 7. R.P.JITHENDRAN,S/O.LATE P.R.BALAKRISHNAN AGED 32 YEARS,RAYAROTH HOUSE, POST PARAL,KODEYERI AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY. LA.App..No. 641 of 2004(A) -2- 8. R.P.SUJITH,S/O.LATE R.P.BALAKRISHNAN, AGED 30 YEARS,RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL, KODEYERI AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY. 9. R.P.VIJAYAN,S/O.LATE P.R.PARU, AGED 73 YEARS,RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL, KODEYERI AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY. 10. R.P.MADHAVI,D/O.MADHA,AGED 90 YEARS, RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL,KODEYERI AMSOM DESOM,THALSSERY. 11. C.P.JANARDHANAN,S/O.R.P.MADHAVI,AGED 67, RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL,KODEYERI AMSOM,DESOM, THALASSERY. 12. C.P.SAROJINI, D/O. R.P.MADAVI, AGED 65, RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL,KODEYERI AMSOM,DESOM, THALASSERY. 13. R.P.RENJI, S/O. C.P.SAROJINI, AGED 42, RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL,KODEYERI AMSOM,DESOM, THALASSERY. 14. R.P. SALINA, D/O.C.P.SAROJINI, AGED 38, RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL,KODEYERI AMSOM,DESOM, THALASSERY. 15. C.P.RAMANI, D/O. R.P.MADHAVI,AGED 60, RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL,KODEYERI AMSOM,DESOM, THALASSERY. 16. C.P. USHA, D/O. R.P.MADHAVI, AGED 55, RAYAROTH HOUSE,POST PARAL,KODEYERI AMSOM,DESOM, THALASSERY. 17. P.M.SAROJINI, W/O. R.P.NANU, AGED 74, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM,CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 18. R.P. SURENDRAN, S/O. R.P. NANU, AGED 52, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM,CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. LA.App..No. 641 of 2004(A) -3- 19. R.P.PRABHA, D/O. R.P.NANU, AGED 48, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM,CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 20. R.P. SAJA, D/O. R.P. NANU, AGED 45, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM,CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 21. R.P.SAJITHA, D/O.R.P.NANU, AGED 41, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 22. R.P.SUSANTH, S/O.R.P.NANU, AGED 43, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 23. R.P.YESODHA, D/O.R.P.KOUSALLIYA, AGED 58, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 24. R.P.SAJEENDRAN, S/O.R.P.YESODHA, AGED 34, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 25. R.P.MEENA, D/O.R.P.YESODHA, AGED 29, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 26. R.P.DEEPA, D/O.R.P.YESODHA, AGED 27, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 27. R.P.JAYAN, S/O.R.P.KOUSALLIYA, AGED 55, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 28. R.P.PHALGUNAN, S/O.R.P.KOUSALLIYA, AGED 53, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. LA.App..No. 641 of 2004(A) -4- 29. R.P.VASANTHA, D/O.R.P.KOUSALLIYA, AGED 50, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 30. R.P.LEENA, D/O.R.P.VASANTHA, AGED 27, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 31. R.P.PUSHPA, D/O.R.P.KOUSALLIYA, AGED 48,'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 32. R.P.ARAVINDAN, S/O.R.P.KOUSALLIYA, AGED 46,'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 33. R.P.BALU, D/O. R.P.KOUSALLIYA, AGED 44, 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 34. R.P.BABY,S/O.R.P.KOUSALLIYA, AGED 43,'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 35. R.P.SATHINDRAN,S/O.R.P.KOUSALLIYA, AGED 41,'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 36. R.KARUNAKARAN, S/O.MATHA,AGED 74 'MOTI', POST ERENHOLI, ERENHOLI AMSOM DESOM, CHUNGAM, THALASSERY-7. 37. K.P.PADMINI, W/O.K.P.SANKU,AGED 64, 'KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 38. K.P.RAJEEV,S/O. K.P.SANKU,AGED 41, 'KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 39. K.P.RENJITH, S/O. K.P.SANKU,AGED 39 'KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 40. K.P.ROSHITH, S/O. K.P.SANKU,AGED 31, 'KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. LA.App..No. 641 of 2004(A) -5- 41. K.PL.MYTHILI, D/O.K.P.KALLU, AGED 78, `KALPAKA", POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 42. K.P.PRASANNA, D/O.K.PL.MYTHILI, AGED 57, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 43. K.P.PREETHA, D/O.K.P.PRASANNA, AGED 40, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 44. K.P.REETHA, D/O.K.P.PRASANNA, AGED 35, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 45. K.P.JAYA, D/O.K.P.MYTHILL, AGED 56, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 46. K.P.KIRAN, S/O.K.P.JAYA, AGED 28, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 47. K.P.ARUN, S/O.K.P.JAYA, AGED 27, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 48. K.P.VALSALA, D/O.K.P.MYTHILL, AGED 54, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 49. K.P.KRISHNAKUMAR, S/O.K.P.VALSALA, AGED 27, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 50. K.P.MAJEENDRAN, S/O.K.P.MYTHILL, AGED 51, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALSSERY-4. 51. K.P.MALATHI, D/O.K.P.MYTHILL, AGED 50, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALSSERY-4. 52. K.P.SASI, S/O.K.P.MYTHILL, AGED 49, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALSSERY-4. LA.App..No. 641 of 2004(A) -6- 53. K.P.KANAKAN, S/O.K.P.MYTHILL, AGED 44, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALSSERY-4. 54. K.P.RAKHU, S/O.LATE KUNNIRAMAN, AGED 59, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALSSERY-4. 55. K.P.RATHI, D/O.LATE KUNNIRAMAN, AGED 57, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALSSERY-4. 56. K.P.RAMA, D/O.LATE KUNNIRAMAN, AGED 55, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALSSERY-4. 57. K.P.PALMA, D/O.LATE VAMANAN, AGED 52, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALSSERY-4. 58. K.P.ANJU, D/O.LATE VAMANAN, AGED 33, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALSSERY-4. 59. K.P.SHARMILA, D/O.LATE VAMANAN, AGED 29, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALSSERY-4. 60. K.P.BEENA, D/O.LATE SULOCHANA, AGED 42, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 61. K.P.VINAYACHANDRAN, S/O. LATE SULOCHANA, AGED 40, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 62. K.P.MOHANACHANDRAN, S/O.LATE SULOCHANA, AGED 33, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 63. K.P.RAVINDRAN, S/O.LATE K.P.NALINI, AGED 60, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. LA.App..No. 641 of 2004(A) -7- 64. K.P.RAJAMMA, D/O.LATE K.P.NALINI, AGED 60, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 65. K.P.MAHESHAN, S/O.LATE K.P.RAJAMMA, AGED 39, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 66. K.P.DINESAN, S/O.LATE K.P.RAJAMMA, AGED 37, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 67. K.P.NIRMAN, S/O.LATE K.P.RAJAMMA, AGED 35, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 68. K.P.JAYARAJAN, S/O.LATE K.P.NANI, AGED 58, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 69. K.P.VIJAYI, D/O.LATE K.P.NANI, AGED 55, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 70. K.P.DAYANANDAN, S/O.LATE K.P.KUNNIKANARAN, AGED 52, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY-4. 71. K.P.SUGUNA,D/O.LATE K.P.KUNNIKANARAN, AGED 49,`KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 72. K.P.BARATHI, D/O.LATE K.P.KUNNIKANARAN, AGED 47,`KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 73. K.P.SREENIVASAN, S/O.LATE K.P.KUNNIKANARAN,AGED 45,`KALPAKA',POST CHIRAKKARA THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. LA.App..No. 641 of 2004(A) -8- 74. K.P.VINOD,S/O.LATE K.P.KUNNIKANARAN, AGED 43,`KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 75. K.P.RADHA,D/O.LATE K.P.NANU, AGED 68,`KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 76. K.P.SMITHA,D/O.LATE K.P.JANAKI, AGED 39,`KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 77. K.P.MOHANDAS, S/O.LATE K.P.JANAKI, AGED 56,`KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 78. K.P.SNEHAPRABHA,D/O.LATE K.P.JANAKI, AGED 52,`KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 79. K.P.MINI,D/O.K.P.SNEHAPRABHA AGED 34,`KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 80. K.P.UMESH, S/O.K.P.SNEHAPRABHA AGED 32,`KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 81. K.P.SAPNA, D/O.K.P.SNEHAPRABHA AGED 30,`KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 82. K.P.JYOTHI, S/O.LATE K.P.JANAKI, AGED 50,`KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 83. K.P.SNEHALATHA,D/O.LATE K.P.JANAKI, AGED 48,`KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 84. K.P.SNEHASHEELA,D/O.LATE K.P.JANAKI, AGED 44,`KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 85. K.P.SARADHA,D/O.LATE MANDHI, AGED 73, `KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. LA.App..No. 641 of 2004(A) -9- 86. N.PREMAVALLY, D/O.K.P.SARADHA, AGED 56,KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 87. N.RAJENDRAN,S/O.K.P.SARADHA,AGED 54, KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 88. N.SURESHAN, S/O.K.P.SARADHA,AGED 52, 'KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 89. N.PAVITHRAN, S/O.K.P.SARADHA,AGED 50, 'KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 90. N.SHYANILI,D/O.K.P.SARADHA,AGED 48, 'KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 91. N.MAHESHAN, S/O.K.P.SARADHA,AGED 46, 'KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 92. N.LEENA, D/O.K.P.SARADHA,AGED 44, 'KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 93. K.P.SAROJINI,W/O.K.P.GOPALAN,AGED75, 'KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 94. K.P.VIJAYI,D/O.K.P..GOPALAN,AGED 52, 'KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 95. K.P.PUSHPA,D/O.K.P..GOPALAN,AGED 48, 'KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 96. K.P.GEETHA, D/O.K.P..GOPALAN,AGED 44, 'KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 97. K.P.SAJEEVAN,S/O.LATE K.P..GOPALAN,AGED 40,'KALPAKA', POST CHIRAKKARA, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. LA.App..No. 641 of 2004(A) -10- 98. K.P.RAMAN, D/O.LATE K.P.PADMAVATHI, AGED 45, SREERAMAPURAM,POST TEMPLE GATE, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 99. K.P.SHOBA, D/O.LATE K.P.PADMAVATHI, AGED 44, SREERAMAPURAM,POST TEMPLE GATE, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 100. K.P.RAJI,D/O.LATE K.P.PADMAVATHI, AGED 43, SREERAMAPURAM,POST TEMPLE GATE, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 101. K.P.SASIKALA,D/O.LATE K.P.PADMAVATHI, AGED 42, SREERAMAPURAM,POST TEMPLE GATE, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 102. K.P.SAJITHA,D/O.LATE K.P.PADMAVATHI, AGED 40, SREERAMAPURAM,POST TEMPLE GATE, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 103. K.P.MAHESH,S/O.LATE K.P.PADMAVATHI, AGED 38, SREERAMAPURAM,POST TEMPLE GATE, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 104. K.P.AKHILA,D/O.LATE K.P.PADMAVATHI, AGED 36, SREERAMAPURAM,POST TEMPLE GATE, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 105. K.P.RAMADAS,S/O.LATE K.P.NALINI,AGED 63, SREERAMAPURAM,POST TEMPLE GATE, THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 106. K.SUDHA, W/O.LATE K.PADMANABHAN,AGED 56,SREERAMAPURAM,POST TEMPLE GATE,THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 107. K.DEEPA, D/O.LATE K.PADMANABHAN,AGED 31,SREERAMAPURAM,POST TEMPLE GATE,THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 108. K.MURALI S/O.LATE K.PADMANABHAN,AGED 29,SREERAMAPURAM,POST TEMPLE GATE,THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 109. K.P.DHAMODHARAN, S/O.LATE K.P.NANI,AGEED 58,"SREERAMAPURAM" POST TEMPLE GATE,THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. LA.App..No. 641 of 2004(A) -11- 110. K.P.AMMAUTTY, D/O.LATE K.P.NANI,AGED 57,"SREERAMAPURAM" POST TEMPLE GATE,THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 111. K.P.VEENA, D/O.K.P.AMMUTTY,,AGED 32,"SREERAMAPURAM" POST TEMPLE GATE,THIRUVANGAD AMSOM DESOM,THALASSERY-4. 112. R.P.MEENAKSHI, D/O.LATE R.P.KRISHNAN,AGED 70, RAYORATH THAZHE KUNIYIL HOUSE, POST PARAL, KODEYERI AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY. 113. R.P.PRABHAKARAN, S/O..LATE R.P.KRISHNAN,AGED 56, RAYORATH THAZHE KUNIYIL HOUSE, POST PARAL, KODEYERI AMSOM DESOM, THALASSERY. 114. ANILKUMAR K.P., S/O..LATE K.P.REMA, KAKKAT, POYYIL HOUSE,RAILWAY STATION ROAD, MAHE, PONDICHERRY STATE - 673 310. 115. PRADEEP KUMAR K.P S/O..LATE K.P.REMA, KAKKAT, POYYIL HOUSE,RAILWAY STATION ROAD, MAHE, PONDICHERRY STATE - 673 310. 116. JEENA K.P,D/O..LATE K.P.REMA, KAKKAT, POYYIL HOUSE,RAILWAY STATION ROAD, MAHE, PONDICHERRY STATE - 673 310. SUPPL. CLAIMANT NOS.118 TO 120 BEFORE THE REFERENCE COURT (APPELLANTS 114 TO 116 HEREIN ARE THE L.R's OF DECEASED C70 IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER ON I.A.2732/03 DATED 26/05/03) 117. K.P.PREMALATHA,D/O.LATE R.P.BHASKARAN PREM NIVAS, NEAR OVER BRIDGE,NELLIKKUNNU, KASARGOD-1. 118. R.P.SHYAMSUNDER, S/O.LATE R.P.BHASKARAN PREM NIVAS, NEAR OVER BRIDGE,NELLIKKUNNU, KASARGOD-1. 119. R.P.REMESH BABU, S/O.LATE R.P.BHASKARAN PREM NIVAS, NEAR OVER BRIDGE,NELLIKKUNNU, KASARGOD-1. LA.App..No. 641 of 2004(A) -12- (SUPPL. CLAIMANTS 121 TO 123 BEFORE THE REFERENCE COURT (APPELLANT 117 TO 119 HEREIN) ARE THE LR's OF DECEASED C23 AND IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER ON I.A.2733/03 DATED 26/05/03. (CLAIMANTS C23 AND C70 BEFORE COURT BELOW BEING DEAD ARE OMITTED FROM THE PARTY ARRAY IN THIS APPEAL). C84 IS THE POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER OF C1 TO 22, 24 TO 69, 71 TO 83, 85 TO 115 AND 118 TO 123 AS PER ORDER ON I.A.2731/03 DATED 26/05/03 BEFORE THE REFERENCE COURT. THE APPELLANTS 1 TO 81 AND 83 TO 119 BY POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER APPELLANT NO.82 HEREIN. BY ADV. SRI.K.RAKESH ROSHAN SRI.K.RAKESH ROSHAN RESPONDENT(S): CLAIMANTS 116 & 117 BEFORE THE COURT BELOW ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1. STATE OF KERALA, REP. BY DISTRICT COLLECTOR, KANNUR. 2. THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N.H.DIVISION, KANNUR. SR. GOVT. PLEADER SMT.R.BINDU THIS LAND ACQUISITION APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 25/01/2011,THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: PIUS C. KURIAKOSE & N. K. BALAKRISHNAN, JJ. ------------------------------------------------ L. A. A. No.641 of 2004 ------------------------------------------------ Dated this the 25th day of January, 2011 JUDGMENT Balakrishnan, J The appellants are the claimants before the Reference Court. They are the legal heirs of the original vendee under Ext.A1. For the land acquired from their possession, a total amount of Rs.12,14,573/- was fixed as compensation. Though in Ext.A1 it was stated that the jenm right was assigned to the vendee, in fact, the vendee had obtained only “kuzhikkanam” right. Finding that there is no document to show that the vendee has purchased jenm right from the Land Tribunal, the learned Subordinate Judge directed 1/4th of the amount to be paid to the Government and the remainder Rs.9,51,964/-, payable to the claimants. That amount was already released in favour of the claimants. L. A. A. No.641 of 2004 -2- Now the claim is in respect of the amount in deposit, Rs.2,62,609/-. Admittedly, the claimants are having title over the property except the fact that the alleged jenm right was not purchased through the Land Tribunal. Even if any amount was payable towards purchase price, that may be only about Rs.100/-. We do not find any reason to retain the amount of Rs.2,62,609/- in court deposit. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the appellants that the Government has exempted the cultivating tenants from paying the purchase price. Hence, this appeal is allowed. The claimants are entitled to withdraw the amount of Rs.2,62,609/- lying in deposit before the Sub Court, Thalassery. PIUS C. KURIAKOSE JUDGE N. K. BALAKRISHNAN JUDGE kns/- L. A. A. No.641 of 2004 -3-