IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Cr.Misc. No.33809 of 2008 NAVIN SINGH @ NAVIN KUMAR SINGH Versus STATE OF BIHAR ----------- 2. 4.9.2008 Heard. The dispute arises out of some ire the parties were carrying against each other for the elections which was held for electing the Mukhiya. The informant claimed to support a candidate who was being opposed by the accused persons. It is alleged that the accused persons, armed variously, had surrounded Jai Singh and were assaulting him with iron rods and Jai Singh was raising an alarm seeking help so as to saving himself from different accused persons who are alleged to have dealt blows to different persons including the informant and during that course, it is alleged that Chandrakant Singh @ Pappu Singh reached there and seeing him, accused Kishori Singh ordered to kill him upon which this petitioner fired a shot which hit him on his chest and Chandrakant Singh got injured and was shifted to Biharsharif hospital and from there, he was referred to Patna for treatment and he died on way and was taken back to his house. - 2 - The contention is that the medical report does not support the manner of occurrence and that there was no injury report issued by the doctor of Biharsharif hospital either in respect of the injuries sustained by any of the injured persons or the deceased. The contention was further that there was no support of the allegations from any of the witnesses and that a false case with distorted facts has been foisted against the petitioner and others. The submissions are to be tested as facts in defence of the petitioner and other accused at the time of trial by the learned trial Judge. What appears presently is that the petitioner is alleged to have fired a shot which ultimately killed the deceased and considering that I am not inclined to direct the release of the petitioner on bail. Petition is dismissed. B.Kr. ( Dharnidhar Jha, J. )