IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Letters Patent Appeal No.745 of 2011 In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 12792 of 2010 ====================================================== 1. KASHINATH SAH S/O GOPAL JEE SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR PATTI, P.S. SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 2. JYOTI SAH S/O KASHINATH SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR PATTI, P.S. SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 3. RAM KUMAR SAH S/O KASHINATH SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR PATTI, P.S. SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR … D.H./Plaintiff/Petitioners/Appellants VERSUS 1. KAPIL PRASAD S/O LATE VISHWANATH SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 2. OM PRAKASH PRASAD S/O LATE VISHWANATH SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 3. PRADEEP KUMAR S/O LATE VISHWANATH SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 4. SHIVAJEE PRASAD S/O LATE VISHWANATH SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 5. RAJESH PRASAD S/O LATE VISHWANATH SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 6. BALDEO PRASAD S/O KAPIL PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 7. KRISHNA PRASAD S/O KAPIL PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 8. GANESH PRASAD S/O GOPAL JEE SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 9. SHEO KUMAR PRASAD S/O GANESH PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 10. JITENDRA PRASAD S/O GANESH PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 11. AJAGAIBI PRASAD S/O GANESH PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR …. J.D./Respondent 1st Party/ Respondent 1st Party 12. SIDHNATH S/O LATE BHAGWAN JEE SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 13. UTTAM S/O LATE BHAGWAN JEE SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 14. MOST. DEOVANTI KUER W/O LATE BHAGWAN JEE SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 15. SEEMA KUMARI D/O LATE BHAGWAN JEE SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 16. DEEPAK KUMAR MINOR S/O LATE BHAGWAN JEE SAH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF THEIR MOTHER MOST. DEOVANTI KUER R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT- BHOJPUR 17. BHARAT KUMAR MINOR S/O LATE BHAGWAN JEE SAH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF THEIR MOTHER MOST. Patna High Court LPA No.745 of 2011 (2) dt.10-08-2011 2 DEOVANTI KUER R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT- BHOJPUR 18. MALTI KUMARI D/O LATE BHAGWAN JEE SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 19. KALYANI KUMARI D/O LATE BHAGWAN JEE SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 20. ARTI DEVI D/O LATE BHAGWAN JEE SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR … J.D./Respondent 2nd Party/ Respondent 2nd Party 21. SURENDRA PRASAD S/O JAWAHAR SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 22. BIMLA DEVI WIDOW OF LATE GUPTESHWAR PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 23. SANGEETA KUMARI D/O LATE GUPTESHWAR PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 24. RUBY KUMARI D/O LATE GUPTESHWAR PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 25. PRABHA KUMARI D/O LATE GUPTESHWAR PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 2 26. MOSTT. RITA KUER WIDOW OF LATE RAJA NAND PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 27. BINOD PRASAD S/O LATE RAJA NAND PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 28. BALMIKI PRASAD S/O LATE RAJA NAND PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 29. RAMJEE PRASAD S/O SURENDRA PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 30. MOST. REKHA KUER W/O LATE NARAYAN PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 31. SONU MINOR SON OF LATE NARAYAN PRASAD , UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF THEIR MOTHER MOST. REKHA KUER R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 32. PARSURAM MINOR SON OF LATE NARAYAN PRASAD , UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF THEIR MOTHER MOST. REKHA KUER R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 33. NAND KISHORE PRASAD S/O SURENDRA PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 34. RAJ KISHORE PRASAD S/O SURENDRA PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 35. NANDJEE PRASAD S/O GUPTESHWAR PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 36. VINDHYACHAL PRASAD S/O GUPTESHWAR PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR …. J.D./Respondent 3rd Party/ Respondent 3rd Party 37. JAGDISH PRASAD S/O BADURI SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 38. KRISHNA PRASAD S/O BADURI SAH R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 39. CHANDRA PRAKASH S/O JAGDISH PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 40. BALIRAM S/O JAGDISH PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, Patna High Court LPA No.745 of 2011 (2) dt.10-08-2011 3 P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 41. PRASHURAM PRASAD S/O JAGDISH PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 42. JAI PRAKASH S/O KRISHNA PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 43. GUDDU S/O KRISHNA PRASAD R/O VILL SHAHPUR, P.S.SHAHPUR, DISTT-BHOJPUR …. J.D./Respondent 4th Party/ Respondent 4th Party 44. DILIP KUMAR GUPTA S/O BHAGIRATHI DEVI, W/O RAMANAND SAH R/O VILL BUXAR, P.S.BUXAR, DISTT-BUXAR 45. ASHOK KUMAR GUPTA S/O BHAGIRATHI DEVI, W/O RAMANAND SAH R/O VILL BUXAR, P.S.BUXAR, DISTT-BUXAR 46. SANJAY KUMAR GUPTA S/O BHAGIRATHI DEVI, W/O RAMANAND SAH R/O VILL BUXAR, P.S.BUXAR, DISTT-BUXAR 47. KEDAR PRASAD S/O TARAMUNI DEVI, W/O LATE BIHARI SAH R/O VILL TARI MOH, P.S.ARA NAGAR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 48. NIRMAL PRASAD S/O TARAMUNI DEVI, W/O LATE BIHARI SAH R/O VILL TARI MOH, P.S.ARA NAGAR, DISTT- BHOJPUR 49. KAMAL KISHORE PRASAD S/O TARAMUNI DEVI, W/O LATE BIHARI SAH R/O VILL TARI MOH, P.S.ARA NAGAR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 50. RADHA DEVI W/O KANHYAIYA SAH R/O VILL TARI MOH, P.S.ARA NAGAR, DISTT-BHOJPUR 51. LALMUNI DEVI W/O SUDAMA SAH R/O VILL & P.O.NAYA BHOJPUR, DISTT-BUXAR 52. LALTI DEVI W/O RAMESHWAR SAH R/O VILL MURADABAD SASARAM, P.S.& DISTT-SASARAM, ROHTAS 53. RADHIKA DEVI W/O SADAN SAH R/O VILL & P.S.MOHANIA, DISTT-BHABHUA 54. VINDHYACHAL DEVI W/O SUNDAR SAH HALUAI R/O MOH & P.S.MITHAPUR, DISTT-PATNA …. J.D./Respondent 5th Party/ Respondent 5th Party ====================================================== Appearance : For the Appellant/s : Mr. Binod Kumar Singh, Advocate For the Respondent/s : ------- ====================================================== 2 10-08-2011 Heard learned counsel for the appellants and learned counsel for the State. The writ petition preferred by the appellants raised a challenge to order passed by Sub Judge IV, Ara in Execution Case No.1/2008. The matter was clearly governed by provisions of the Patna High Court LPA No.745 of 2011 (2) dt.10-08-2011 4 Code of Civil Procedure and as there was difficulty in maintaining a civil revision application, the power of superintendence of this Court was invoked by filing the writ petition. Through a catena of judgments this Court has held that when writ petition invoking power of superintendence of this Court is decided by a single Judge no Letters Patent Appeal is maintainable under Clause 10 of the Letters Patent of this Court. Following the earlier judgments, this appeal is dismissed as not maintainable. sk (Shiva Kirti Singh, J) (Amaresh Kumar Lal, J)