1 135 P Civil Rcvision N02390 of 2009 lN 11I I IlGI I COURT Ol PlJNJA13 c I IARYANA AT Cl IANJOIClARII Civil Rcvision N02390 of 2009 lOccidcd on 24 122009 m t Mls East India Fabrics Mfg Co ltd Pctitioner 0 C I 0 Vcrsus I Z Shri13alKishan Garodia and othcrs 2 r CORAM HONBLE MR JlJSTICli KC PlJRl 08 7 Prcscnt Mr ACChopra Scnior Advocatc with Z Ms Niinrata Advocatc lor the Mr Sudhir Mitlal Advociltc for thc N 1 tl KeCePURl J This is a civil Rcvision pclition undcr Article 227 of lllc Coilstitulion of India ftlr scttingiisidc lhc ilnpugtlcdtllclct dttcd 2582108 passcdby IOistrictJudgcRcwari lllld ordcr dated682007 passcdby Civil JuclgeScnior IOivisioillRewari Oll 811 unclcr ordcr 39 rulcs and 2 rciid wilh Section 151 0f lllc Codc of Civil Proccdtitc in sllt111 CC hc iS il Ctllllpillly rcgistcrcdtiiItlcr CclinpailicsAct 1956 htivingits works at Plot No 2 1 ItldtisttitilAicti I llJIOA IOlltltlillcltl 9 e Anita 2012.12.22 16: 23 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:22 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 436 0 a eiIril Rcvision Ntl390 01 2009 2 Harsh Guptais thc IOirectorof thc plaintiffand hc JS COll Versallt witll tlle factsofthc cilscIlcis also dulyauthorizedto fllcthc suit hc case of thc plaintiflin bricl is tllat it cclilstrlictctlii sllctl ill Its plot by spcndi ng Rs0 lacs and had spcnt Rsllacs lll instiiIlatitIIlClf 1 elcctric Thc plainlilTlllls alsclcclilstitictcdloads iil llle j1cltMIsl of the work was donc undcr thc of dcfcndanl No 1 iil thc 0 0 capacity of promotcrDircctor Plot No 21 WOS in lllc ycar 1978 I C5 by Bal Kishan Garodia dcfcndant No 1 in thc namc of Mls ost indio I 1cxtiles of wllich llc was i Dirccll Ie htisbccil proInolIdIOiicclIi 31lllc Z plaintif Thc plol was i n thc natnc of Mls list India cxtilcs bccausc the plaintiff company had nol bccn fclrincd at that lime Allcr formationof lhc plalntiffall thc cxpcnses incurrcd bythc defcndont No l I 08 includingthe cost of thc Iand wcrc paidto hiin hc subscqucill cxpctlsCS wcrc incurrcd bythc plainliflcompiiny itscll 1Ilc IlasIocctlliiyiilg vmo Z installmentsofthc priccoflhc plolt0 IllJIOA AlicI tllc cclst 11lllc Illtllillld the initial cxpcnscs incurrcd by dcfendanl No l OVCr tllc Iololiil qucstiotl wcrc paidto Iliin hc did 1101 lllCUr ally CXIOCllSCS tIlCrCOll hc Ioild of lolot Nol could not bc lransfcrrcd in lllc namc of the plaitltiflbccallsC dcfendantNo I did not get it transfcrrcddclibcralcl1 IOeltldilllt IVo I was authorizedby thc board of Directors of Ihc plaintilT to signdocumcllts Oll bchalf of thc coinpany in favour of l laryailtiSlatc liIcctticityI3oatdill tllcil Oil 31 1979 IOcfcildallt No 1 oppliedor powcr conncction for tllc plaintiflllhc plaintiflal1plicdI7Irlratlsfcr tIf Ihc llltll in its namc from thc nanlc of dcfendantNo I who was autllorizcd tll rcprcsent thc plaintiffin diffcrcnt ofllces hiid clcvIl gclt tlle cclllvcycIiil Ilis Anita 2012.12.22 16: 23 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:22 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 437 eivil Rcvision No390 of 2009 3 1 tliitllC 1lc had no rightto do SO Now hc wants ttI nlisLtsc his positonIll rclation to thc plot in qucstioiliil lhc docunlentstIf I IUIOA and IVllllts to sclllalicnatc lhc plott0 any othcr IlcrscIll 1IC hils Iltl tiglltlI clI so I lc has bccn rcqucstcd scveraltllllCS ilol to do scl but to ncl cflect aIldhencc thc suit as well as thc applicaliclll r IOcfcndanlNo1 llas rcsistcd lhc suit ilS well ils Ihc applictilloll 0 C of thc plailltDclcndailts 110 1 ililcl 3 htlvctilso Jllcd wriltetl stiitcincllt to thc I C5 plaintifflOefcndilntNo l hasquestionccl lllc loctls sliItldi 11tIlcjolaitltifl l1 I fllc this sLiit llatlsh Guptais dcnied lcI bc a Ditcctor ofthc pliIintiffIlc is Z dctlicd to bc autllorizccl to Illc ths suil Accc1d118 lI lliill lIlc l0ItiiillilfIlas IlOl COlllC with clcan hailds aild has cclnccalcd tllc flicts that the pIiiiiltifI C coinpanyitssharc holdingand its WCrC all subjcctnlaltcr to I 08 arbitratioil Accordiilgto hilll I ltilsll Clujtais sollmilleIillvc1 Nlilcllil11clllio Accordillgto Iliin ohia group Ileadcdby Jl 1cIlliiI WtlS O partytO the 7 Z arbilration and thc plaintiffiswcll awarc of thc alvorcldatcd 3 1O l 983 by m wilyof which allthc sharcshcld byIIP ohia ond his WClc allottcd to lhc allswcrltlg dcfcildatlt and his grIIujo hc Arbilnilcl1 ll1lddilcclcd tllc IOircctorsof l I Iohia group btit lhc satllC IlilVCIltll Collljllicdwith tllc dircctions givcn in thc award aild iirC illcgallyoccupying iil thc oflicc of Dircctor of thc coillpany lt is cliliincd tllat plotNo 21 has bccn rcgistcicd in thc nalllC Of atlSWClllg defctldtiilt vidc rcgislcrcddcccl 411ctllvcyilllCC datcd IOA1998 cxccutcd byclcfcndtIntNo hc plaiiltilfis dctlicd tcl Ilalc anysort0f riglltinlhc propcrtyIlisclaimcdthat plcIlNc 21 was allottcd Ill tllc ilainc of Mls Easl India 1xtilcs prclccssors ilncl not iil thc nanlc of Mls I5ast lnditt cxtilcs It is fiirlllcr ilvcrrctl tllIl 1111tllc IlilIlllcills Ivcrc Anita 2012.12.22 16: 23 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:22 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 438 Civil Rcvision N02390 of 2009 40 rcccivcd by I IlJIOA in thc accounl of Mls Iast l tltIia cxtiIcs Proccssors 1lc ininutes of thc mcctingsproduccdby thc plaintifl ilrc said to bc unsigncdcariyingno hc atlswcritlg dc cildailt has clainlcd himselfto bc owner ofthc plot iil qucstiollancIlliis cltliillccl tllill lllc Ioliliilti i IS Ilot cntitlcd to any rclicf lllc suil as wcll as opplication are thcrcforc C praycd to bc dismisscd 0 C Dcfcndants No 1 and 3 havc also qucstioncd thc locus standi I C5 of thc plaintiffto Ole this suil hc suit is alslI cliliillccl ltI lle timc barrcd It I is avcrrcdthat plotNo 21 was allotlcd to Mls lasl lilditi Icxlilcs l1cIccssois Z vidc Incmo No 3023 dated 268 1976 13xistcncct11ti shcd Oll llle plot IS admitted Tllc plotis said to havc bccn allottcd in thcycar 1976lo Mls J3asl India cxtllcs Proccssclrs of wllich Shii I3111 ICislloilCltlicIdiawas IotClillcllct I 08 1llc payillenloof Rs650001 rcccivcd vidc rcccipt dalccl 257 1985 IS admittcd The ownership ofthe plotis slatcd to bc slill thcrc iil thc ntiille of 7 Z Mls l3ast India 1cxtilcs Proccssors It is dcnictl tIliil iIily doctilllciltS rcgardmgtransfcr of plol was pendingwith lhc answcringdcfcndants lllc OthCrOvcrlllents arc dcnicd alld lhc sliit is praycd l hc clislllisscd TIle Icarncd trial Courl disinisscd tllc utldci Itdct 39 Rulcs 1 and 2 CPC vidc ordcr dated682007 Aggricvcdby thc said ordcr tllc fllcd bef71ictllc IclItilcd Adcliticilal IOistrictJudgcwho also disinlsscd thc samc callingfor iltl rcasoil tcl diller wilh the view takcnby the Icarnedlrial Court vidc ordci datcd25820l18 Still fcclingdisesillisllcd by 100t11 thc abovc stlid orclers llle instantrevisioll pctitionhasbcen filcd byllle plainlilllIlctilicltlCl havc llcard Icilrned collllscl IlIr tllc ics tind hilVCglItlC A Anita 2012.12.22 16: 23 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:22 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 439 4d Civil Revision No390 of 21109 5 1 through thcrccords ofthc casc with tllcit hclIo 1 havc hcard lcarncd counscl fcIrboIll tllc siclcsand havc goIlC through thc rccordsoflhc casc wilh lhcir hclp Civil Judgcouilior IOivlsionlRcwali iclyillgLllloll 1 Desh Rai VSe Desh Rai 2003 RCRe 359 has Ilcld lllilt lhc plailltifl1S guiltyof conccallncilt of inalcrial Iacts inasillIich 11S the Award passcd 0 C bclwccn thc particshas bccn conccalcd hat flilli tlg 11tlsl3ccil ujIlclclIoy I C5 thc lcarncd IOistricl Judgc So both thc abovc said Iltldingscannot bc I assailedin thc rcvision Thc Award was Ioasscd as llack as on 31 0 I 983 ic Z morc than 25 ycars ago Thc Award gocs againstthc tr Morcover any salc dccd duriilgthc pclldcllcyclf lllt sliil is Ilil ly l31illcilllcs I oflis pcndcns 08 So 111thcsc ci rcumstallccs thc rcViSioIl is wl lhout any mcril and thc samc is dismisscd v Z A copy of this ldginclltbc SCllt tt1 lhe lrial Court for slcl 0 r 2009 KC PlJRII Sv JlJIOG r Anita 2012.12.22 16: 23 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:22 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document