72 11 1 1NIll 111G11101ROlPlJNJA13cO IIARYANAICIl1N191041Il CM No 27583Cll of21110inland Civilllevision No4077 of2010 Date ofdccisioI March Ill 21111 1 Mittar Sineh and niiotIlcr Pcli lloncrs Vs 1 I3h8liallSilloh 2111d Olhcrs 1 L Rcspodcnts 0 Cllnlm lllonble Mr ustice AN vIindal 0 PrCSCIl MrIOhirindcr ChopraAclvocatc C5 1orthc pclitloncrs 1 I Mr ClIirnanl Kaur Irka Advocatc Ior thc rcspondcnts No 2 and 4 t0 12 Z ANJjnda6 J his pclilionassaiis lhc ordcr datcd 2942010 IAtlncxiirclI l I passcdbv thc Addilional Civll Judgc Sr lVlSlOllI Rajpuradcciinig ltl Z i0plcad13a1birKutnar ind Scth Chand as dccndi91ls Nc I Ll lid 15 bctl8 lllc slIbscqucnl vcndecs 01111dcfcndanl No7 lo 12dutng lhc pcnIcnct 1 1110Sllll 7 hc backgroLiild ol tllc casc is thal thc joliilltiI 1714cl21 Z Sllil 17rdccll1r81ioll aild IOCrlllallCIlt claillli Ilg IllcIllsclves tc0 1 lllc owncrs 01 111 suil propcrly whilc lracingthcir ritlhlsiil lllc sElillC lll1C11 lo 261 950 IVow tllcv havc stalcd that slilcc lllc dcildants Nt7 to 12 havc sold lhc Iand lllctlsuringll kanaIs 18 mllrI2ISout othc suitIand to lalbir Kulnar and Sctll Clland on 171 02008 thcyare ncccssary parlicsl0 thc suit hc salc inadc durinlthc jocndcrlcy ofthc suit bcilll wlollg ilic1i1 nuii and t void is 11abl ltl bc illnorcdas lllcy arc also hlt hy lhc pritciIle f Iis ncndcns 1he dclcildalllSn pLlI itl lllIOCtlrallCtaild coltlloitcd lhe applicatiotl Oil thc groundlhal thc subscqucnlpurchascrslocndcniclit1 arc rlOl tlCcCSSlry IlIWcver lhcy Ilal7c aclllliltttl lll1ll tlll It I1 Icl2tllt Aos 7 111l 2 hnvr sold Ihc Iand lncasurillgI l karlals 18 nlarlas btlI il was Uma 2013.01.14 16: 05 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 73 Civil 12evision No 4077 of20111 2 238 8 Illrthcr avcrrcd Ihal 13albirKumat 2111Sclll 0Iltllld Il2lvitlg lllc duringthc pcndcncyof lhc Sllll havc slcppcd lhc shoc9 Il thc dccndants ihcrcl7Irc lllcv arc 110t 11IlCCCSSllryp2111 lCS hc doctrinc 01 lls pcndcnsi n my opinionls bascd otl thc princijolc th2itthc IlclSOll tIlC 11CllllIlc jliclgrllctltclclotcl duringlhc pcndcncof lllc SLilt has no indcpcndciltrightto tlc propcl lv hc havino stcppcdinttl lhc shocs 01 lhe lrailscrccs is bouild blI tle clccicc il 1 1 r passcd11illlSlhim No doul lll 21ll casc lllc coLlrl ill Ordcr to 9void lhc nlullipllcityof tllc sLils ctLild Ioctillittllc lolailllifItc iinplc101 slicll 0 0 subscqucnt trans crccs as partyto thc suit but thc prcscntsuit bc I includcd 11 such c121ssof cascs as lhc sllit was llIcd on 3042002 1lild lllc t5 applicalion179rinlIolcadino 13albir KLI1112Ir atld Scth halld 2ts 1381112WaS C Illccltll 1112 vcar 2010 Ilc 117CXourl in casc lJshtt Sinha vs Dinu Rlllll e C tnd olhers 2008 13 RClR CiIlill 145 111111c ctltlsidciillglllc sl211t15 Ili lhe lis pcndctlstrallslcrcc obscrvcd as uildcr l i Ihussellled Iclw Ihal u rll Sllll properl1117170 IllcJ lel7dencl l hiIS I7ll riolll Io resist rlr lbsllltl execulion 1lecrecpussedhil u e0177petenl CnrI 777edne tJl 7is pendensprohibils Cl parlll Irorn dealing witil Il7e lorhichis Ihesuljel Il7clllel ofsuillis pendensitsell l IretIled cis cunslruefive nrllirc ll9 Ll Illlrchcr Illto7 IC I1 601tn 1 u tIecree lI Ilc e1111ecl717Illependi17g suii R4 7l72 clclril7es117ullhere ihl1ltlcI Ylol be rcsisltI7te 11r 0bstruclion by a IransI3Iee Iile Il decl4IIesIltl il11Ie resis1c117ceis cIused or obstrll1017 IS r9f1ered bll ct pcntIenleIile 01 Ihe juclgnlcnldehr he cannol seek l9e7r71101 Rule9rY0r1011010rderXXl Sitlce lhc statlis Of lr21llsfcrccpctldcntcIitc cannol bc l rcalcd as c11a slrallgcl ld IS prcSutllcd 101havc constructivc noticc o Iis Dcnd18 I l l Illc ccll111 thcrcl71rc Ilc Ilas to sllk 2itldSlinillltogclilClHIllll tllc lr2illSlrrCl 115 suchhc IS IlOl Il IlCCCSSr5prty Uma 2013.01.14 16: 05 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 74 211 Civil Revision No 4077 of 2010 3 42424C 21k1110 lhC CSc IrOlll 2i11thcranolc thc Sll Il l S Dcilclino171rlllc Iastlllilc ycars atld lhc salc i l any llladc by thc dc17tldi11115dlll11tll 2 01 the suil woulcl sLil11 17c111 lloc Ioltlcilolcs c31Iis IoctlcltilsIIlc case is alrcadyat thc argunlcntslagc thcrclclrc l am not inclincd lcl liCCcpt thisapplicatlollo Rcsultanllv 11 c1111rltl IllCrlt Ill lhc ctitio11 lhc S2illlC Is disnlisscd 0 1 0 March Ol 2011 AN Iindall 0 deepal Judge C3 1 Ill I C5 I Z r I Z QO 7 Z 11 5 l Il 6111 Uma 2013.01.14 16: 05 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document