IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT : THE HON'BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR.J.B.KOSHY & THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE V.GIRI WEDNESDAY, THE 21ST JANUARY 2009 / 1ST MAGHA 1930 WA.No. 150 of 2009() -------------------- AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT IN WPC.890/2005 Dated 04/12/2008 .................... APPELLANT(S): PETITIONERS ------------------------- 1. C.K. JANU, D/O. KARIYAN, PANAVALLI MICHA BHOOMI, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 2. M. GEETHANANDAN, S/O. PANAYAN AMBU, PADANNAWARDEN, KANNUR DIST. 3. SANKARANKUTTY, S/O. MUKRAN, THEENIOOR PANIYA COLONY, PUTHENKUNN, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 4. BINU, S/O. SOMAN, VEDAN COLONY, KANJIRAMKULAM, NEYYATINKARA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM. 5. ANILKUMAR.C.T, S/O. NIMMAN, CHOONDAPPADY NAICKAN COLONY, APPAPPARA, THIRUNELLI, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 6. P.C. BALAN, S/O. VELUTHA CHEENANNAN, PULITHOOKY COLONY, THODUPUZHA, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 7. B.C. RAJU, S/O. CHATHY, THOTTAPPANKULAM COLONY, BEENACHI, SULTHAN BATHERY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. W.A.No.150/2009 2 8. MALLAN, S/O. MATHAN, NELLIYATT ADIYA COLONY, PAYYAMPALLY, THIRUNELLI, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 9. P. CHANDRAN, S/O. VELLI, ERUPATHAM ADIYA COLONY, THIRUNELLI, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 10. BOMMAN, S/O. VALIYA BOMMAN, MURIKKALADI COLONY, CHEERAN NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 11. APPU, S/O. VELLI, KAKKAVAYAL COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 12. DARAPPAN, S/O. KELU, PUNNAMATTOM KURICHA COLONUY, ANCHUKUNNU, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 13. MARAN, S/O. VELLI, NELLIYAT ADIYA COLONY, PAYYAMBALLY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 14. KAVALAN, S/O. CHANDRAN, KAKKATHODE PANIYA COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 15. KARUPPY, W/O. KAVALAN, KAKAKTHODE COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 16. KARUPPY, W/O. UZHARAN, KANNAKKODE COLONY, NAMBIKOLLI, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 17. MURINGA, W/O. VELLI KOTTAKKUNNU PANIYA COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 18. MARI, W/O. KALAN, MURKKAALADY YOORALI COLONY, CHEERAL, WAYANAD DISTRICT. W.A.No.150/2009 3 19. VELIYAN, S/O. POLAYAN, THORIVALLOOR COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DIST. 20. KAVITHA, W/O. RAJU, SECOND GATE, KATTIKULAM, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DIST. 21. SHEELA, W/O. KURUMAN, PAYYAMPALLY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 22. E.O. CHANDRAN, S/O. UNTHAN, ERUPATHAM COLONY, PAYYAMPALLY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DIST. 23. P.V. RAVI, S/O. VIJAYAN, VELLAMCHERI PANIYA COLONY, CHEMBAKAMOOLA, THIRUNELLI, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 24. RAVI, S/O. POOTTA, MANIVAYAL KURUMBAN COLONY, KATTIKULAM, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 25. PALAN, S/O. ONAL, PUNILTHUKI COLONY, KALLOOR, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 26. BABU, S/O. CHANDU, VELLOTTIL VEEDU, KUTTIMOOLA COLONY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 27. M. RAJU, S/O. KANAMBAN, PAYYAMPALLI, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 28. SUBRAMANIAN, S/O. ANANDAN, KANNKKOT COLONY, NENMENIKUNNU, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 29. BABU, S/O. KALAN, NELLIYATT ADIYA COLONY, PAYYMABALLY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. W.A.No.150/2009 4 30. C.P. RAJU, S/O BASAVAN, MUTTANKARA ADIYA COLONY, CHALIGATHA, PAYYAMPALLY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 31. BABU @ KUTTAN, S/O. VELIYAN, MAVADI PANIYA COLONY, PALLIKANDY, SULTHAN BATHERY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 32. VELIYAN, S/O. MUKRAN, MAVADI PANIYA COLONY, PALLIKANDY, SULTHAN BATHERY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 33. C.K. NARAYANAN, S/O. KURUKKAN, CHOONDAPPADY PANIYA COLONY, KALLUMUKKU, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT 34. BALAN, S/O. MUKRAN, MAVADI PANIYA COLONY, PALLIKANDY, SULTHAN BATHERY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 35. MALLAM, S/O. KALAN, PAZHAYATHOTTAM ADIYA COLONY, CHELOOR, KATTIKULAM, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 36. RAJAN, S/O. MATHAN, NELLIYATT COLONY, PAYYAMPALLY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 37. MADHAVAN, S/O. KETHAN, BEGOOR PANIYA COLONY, THIRUNELLI, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 38. KARIYAN, S/O. MARAN, CHALIGADHA AMBEDKAR PANIYA COLONY, PAYYMPALLY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT 39. JOGGY, S/O. CHANDRAN, CHALIGADHA AMBEDKAR PANIYA COLONY, PAYYMPALLY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT W.A.No.150/2009 5 40. RAMAN, S/O. SIDHAN, MULLANTHARA, ADIYA COLONY, KATTIKULAM, PAYYAMPALLY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT,. 41. MATHAN @ GOPALAN, S/O. KALAN, AKOLLIKUNNU KURUMA COLONY, APPAPPARARA, THIRUNELLI, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 42. M.P. MANI, S/O. PALAN, MAVADIPANIYA COLONY, VALLITHANDY, BATHERY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 43. PRASAD, S/O. MALLAN, CHALIGADHA AMBEDKAR PANIYA COLONY, PAYYAMPALLY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 44. SOMAN, S/O. MATHAN, MULLANTHARA AMBEDKAR COLONY, VADAMAL, PAYYAMPALLY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 45. RAJAN, S/O. JOGGY, CHALIGADHA AMBEDKAR PANIYA COLONY, PAYYAMPALLY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 46. CHANDRAN @ RAJU, S/O. VELLU, ALATHOOR COLONY, THIRUNELLI, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 47. VELLAN, S/O. VELUKKAN, VELIYAMBAM, KOTTAMURATTU PULPALLY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 48. KALAN, S/O. KARIYAN, CHEMBAKAMOOLA ADIYA COLONY, KUTTIJOOLA, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRIT. 49. KUNJAMAN, S/O. CHANDU, VELLOTTIL KURUMAN COLONY, KUTTIJOOLA, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. W.A.No.150/2009 6 50. SUNDARAN @ RAMANKUTTY, S/O. KELAPPAN, AKKOLLIKUNNU COLONY, APPAPPARA, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 51. REGHU, S/O. KONCHAN, THALAMALARUNNU COLONY, PANAVALLI, THIRUNELLI, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 52. SANKARAN, S/O. KARIYAN, KAKKATHODE PANIYA COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 53. KUNCHAN, S/O. CHATHY, KALLUMUKKU, CHOONDAPPADY, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 54. BABU, S/O. RAMAN, MURIKKALADY COLONY, NENMENI, BATHERY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 55. POLY, W/O. KRISHNAN, KANNANKOTT COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 56. RAJU, S/O. KULLAN, MANOOR PANIYA COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 57. BOMMA, S/O. KULIYAN, THIRUVANNOOR, KALLOOR, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 58. LATHA, W/O. BALAN, KANNAKOTT COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 59. SANTHA, D/O. USHARAN, KANNANKOTT COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 60. NAGAPPAN VAIDYAN, S/O. KALAN, MULLANTHARA COLONY, PAYYAMPALLY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. W.A.No.150/2009 7 61. MADHAVAN, S/O. THOLAN, KARAMAD ADIYA COLONY, CHEKADY, THIRUNELLI, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 62. BALAN, S/O. CHANTHAN, KANNAKOTT PANIYA COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, BATHERY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 63. KALAN, S/O. CHOMAN, MURIKKALADI UOORALI COLONY, CHEERAL, BATHERY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 64. BALU, S/O. VELLI, THIRUNELLI, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 65. GANESAN @ APPAYYAN, S/O. DEVAN, THEENOOR COLONY, PUTHENKUNNU, BATHERY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 66. V. BALAN, S/O. VERUVAN, THIRUVALLOOR COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, BATHERY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 67. K.O. HARIDASAN, S/O. KUNHIRAMAN, MALAYIL CHANDHAVILA VEEDU, MULAVANA, EDAMALA ADIVASI COLONY, KOLLAM. 68. RAJEEVAN, S/O. JOGGY, SAJITHA NIVAS, EDAYOOR KUNNU, KATTIKULAM.P.O, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 69. CHATHAN, S/O. MARAN, CHALIGADHA AMBEDKAR COLONY, PAYYAMPALLY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 70. KULIYAN, S/O. CHANDRAN, CHALIGADHA AMBEDKAR COLONY, PAYYAMPALLY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 71. RADHA, W/O. GOVINDAN, CHOONDAPPADY APPAPARA COLONY, APPAPPARA, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 72. RADHAKRISHNAN, S/O. KALI, ATHATTU COLONY, APPAPARA, THIRUNELLI, WAYANAD DISTRICT. W.A.No.150/2009 8 73. SUNILKUMAR, S/O. KELU, ATHATTU COLONY, CHEKADY, THIRUNELLI, MANANTHAWADY WAYANAD DISTRICT. 74. VENUGOPALAN, S/O. THOLAN, PADIPPURA COLONY, CHITHALAYAM, PULPALLY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 75. ASOKAN, S/O. GOPALAN, RAVI NAGAR, VEDAR COLONY, KANJIRAMKULAM, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM. 76. REMESAN, H/O. SANTHA, KOVAILPPURA PANIYA COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, BATHERY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 77. KARYAMBADY BABU KARYAMBADY COLONY, PUTHANKUNNU BATHERY, WAYANAD DIST. 78. JOY @ VIJAYAN RAVINAGAR VEDAR COLONY, KANJIRAMKULAM, PULLUVILA ,THIRUVANANTHAPURAM. 79. RAMADAS AKKOLLI COLONY, THRUNELLI, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 80. KUNJAPPAN, S/O. PALAN THIRUVANNOOR COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DIST. 81. NANU, S/O.PALAN PANDANCHIRA COLONY, KOTTAKUNNU, WAYANAD DIST. 82. SOMAN @ VELAYUDHAN, S/O.MARAN CHALIGADHA AMBEDKAR COLONY, PAYYAMPALLY, WAYANAD DIST. 83. BABU,S/O. KALAN GOTTIYOOR COLONY, APPAPPARA,MANANTHAVADY WAYANAD DIST. 84. MARI.S/O.KALAN BHRAMAGIRI ESTATE COLONY, APPAPPARA, THIRUNELLI WAYANAD DIST. 85. RAJU @ CHANDAN, S/O.VELLI CHAKKINI ADIYA COLONY, APPAPPARA THIRUNELLI, MANANTHAVADY, WAYANAD DIST. W.A.No.150/2009 9 86. MATHAN ,S/O. PAKKAN CHALIGADHA AMABEDKAR COLONY, PAYYAMPALLY, MANANTHAVADY, WAYANAD DIST. 87. BALAN, S/O. MASTHY CHOONDAPPADY COLONY,APPAPPARA, MANANTHAVADY WAYANAD DIST. 88. NARAYANANKUTTY, S/O. KONCHAN, KANNANKOTT COLONY, NOOLPUZHA, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 89. CHINNAN, S/O. MARAN, CHALGADHA AMBEDKAR COLONY, PAYYAMPALLY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 90. BALAKRISHNAN, S/O. RARAPPAN, VELLARA COLONY, PALVELICHAM, PAYYAMPALLY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 91. BIJU, S/O. VELAYUDHAN, PADAMALA COLONY, PALVELICHAM, PAYYAMPALLY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 92. MANI, S/O. KUMARAN, PUTHIYIDAM, PAYYAMPALLY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. 93. AMMINI, S/O. KURUMAN, CHELOOR COLONY, MANANTHAWADY, WAYANAD DISTRICT. BY ADV. SRI.KALEESWARAM RAJ RESPONDENT(S): RESPONDENTS -------------------------- 1. STATE OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY CHIEF SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM. 2. THE CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION (CBI), REPRESENTED BY THE DIRECTOR, CBI, NEW DELHI. W.A.No.150/2009 10 3. THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE, SPECIAL CRIME BRANCH, CBI, RAJAJI BHAVAN, VASANTH NAGAR, CHENNAI. 4. THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM. 5. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, DEPARTMENT OF HOME AFFAIRS, SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM. 6. THE NATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION, REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY GENERAL NATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION, NEW DELHI. ADDL. 7. THE SECRETARY, STATE HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM IS IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER IN I.A.NO.58/2009 DATED 21.1.2009 ADV. SRI.M.V.S.NAMBOOTHIRY,SC, C.B.I. FOR R2,3 BY G.P.SMT.MEERA FOR R1,R5 & R7 THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 21/01/2009, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: J.B.KOSHY, Ag.C.J. & V.GIRI, J. -------------------------------------- W.A.No.150 of 2009 ------------------------------------- Dated 21st January, 2009 JUDGMENT Koshy, Ag.C.J . In the impugned judgment, learned Judge had given adequate relief to the appellants/petitioners. The only relief now pressed by the appellants is that there should be some investigation regarding the death of Jogi. If appellants have any further complaints regarding the same, they can point out that also before the State Human Rights Commission. The appeal is disposed of accordingly. J.B.KOSHY ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE V.GIRI JUDGE tks