IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA LPA No.879 of 2010 1. MOST. SAVITRI DEVI, AGED ABOUT 90 YEARS, W/O LATE SITABAR SARAN, R/O MOH - SHEIKHURA, P.S. SHASTRI NAGAR, NOW HAWAI ADDA, TOWN & DISTT-PATNA AT PRESENT RESIDING AT FLAT NO. 3/E, GIRIJA ENCLAVES NEAR DEVI ASTHAN, SHIKHPURA, PATNA ………………………. N.R. 1, 2. MADAN MOHAN SHARAN, S/O LATE SITABAR SHARAN, R/O SRI KEDAR NATH SINGH, EX. BRIGADIER AT SHEIKHPURA, P.O. - B.V.COLLEGE, PATNA-14, WIDOW & SON OF LATE SITABAR SHARAN RESPECTIVELY, 3. SHRI DINESH BIHARI SHARAN, AT PRESENT RESIDENT OF FLAT NO. 203, AMBAJEE APARTMENT, SHEIKHPURA, P.O. B.V.COLLEGE, PATNA … ………………………… APPELLANTS. Versus 1. ASHOK BIHARI SHARAN, S/O LATE SITABAR SHARAN, R/O SHEIKHPURA, P.S. SHASTRI NAGAR, NOW HAWAI ADDA, TOWN & DISTT-PATNA AT PRESENT RESIDING AT FLAT NO.204, BAILY KUNJ APARTMENT, MAZAR GALI, SHEIKHPURA, P.S. SHASTRI NAGAR, DISTT-PATNA …………. PLAINTIFF ….. RESPONDENT 2. DR. ALKA SHARAN, W/O ASHOK KUMAR SINHA & D/O LATE SITABAR SHARAN, R/O AT PRESENT FLAT NO. 102, MAA BINDHYAVASINI COMPLEX, SHEIKHPURA MORE, P.O. B.V.COLLEGE, P.S.SHASTRI NAGAR, PATNA, D/O LATE SITABAR SHARAN ………… DEFENDANT NO. 3 / RESPONDENT 1ST 3. SMT. KUNTI DEVI, W/O SRI SURENDRA PRASAD, DUNDI BAZAR, NEAR SOUTH GATE OF MANGAL TALAB, P.O. CHOWK SHIKARPUR, PATNA CITY,… NR 5 4. SMT. SUMITRA SHARAN, W/O LATE SHARDA NANDAN PRASAD, R/O CHHOTI BADALPURA, KHAGAUL, PATNA …. NR 6 5. SMT. PRATIBHA SHARAN, W/O MANOJ KUMAR SINHA, GARDANIBAGH, PATNA AT PRESENT RESIDING AT MOH-AZAD PATH, HOUSE NO. AP/A2, SARISTABAD, P.S.GARDANIBAGH, DISTT-PATNA …… NR 8 - 2 - 6. SRI RAKESH BIHARI SHARAN, FLAT NO. 3/E, 3RD FLOOR, GIRIJA APARTMENT (NEAR DEVI ASTHAN) BRAHM ASTHAN, GALI ROAD, AT SHEIKHPURA, P.O. B.V.COLLEGE, DISTT-PATNA- 14 ALL SONS AND DAUGHTERS OF LATESITABAR SHARAN ……………… RESPONDENT 2ND SET… N.R. 2 with LPA No.611 of 2010 DINESH BIHARI SHARAN, S/O LATE SITABAR SARAN, R/O MOHALLA- SHEIKHPURA, P.S.- SHASTRI NAGAR, NOW HAWAI ADDA, TOWN & DISTT.- PATNA, AT PRESENT RESIDING AT FLAT NO. 203, AMBAJEE APARTMENT, SHEIKHPURA, P.S.- SHASTRI NAGAR, PATNA ………….. DEFENDANT NO. 2/APELLANT Versus 1. ASHOK BIHARI SHARAN, S/O LATE SITABAR SHARAN, R/O SHEIKHPURA, P.S.- SHASTRI NAGAR, NOW HAWAI ADDAN, TOWN & DISTT.- PATNA, AT PRESENT RESIDING AT FLAT NO. 204, BAILY KUNJ APARTMENT, MAZAR GALI, SHEIKHPURA, P.S.- SHASTRI NAGAR, DISTT.- PATNA ….. PLAINTIFF 2. SAVITRI DEVI, W/O LATE SITABAR SHARAN, R/O FLAT NO. 3/E, GIRIJA ENCLAVE, NEAR DEVI ASTHAN, SHEIKHPURA, P.S.- SHASTRI NAGAR, N.R.I. 3. SRI MANDAN MOHAN SHARAN, S/O LATE SITABAR SHARAN, R/O C/O KEDAR NATH SINGH (RETIRED BRIGEDIOR), AT SHEIKHPURA, P.S.- B.V. COLLEGE, P.S. HAWAI ADDA, PATNA …… DEFENDANT NO. 1, 4. DR. ALKA SHARAN, SON OF ASHOK KUMAR SINHA AND D/O LATE SITABAR SHARAN, R/O AT PRESENT FLAT NO. 102, MAA BINDHYAVASINI COMPLEX, SHEIKHPURA MORE, P.O.- B.V. COLLEGE, P.S.- SHASTRI NAGAR, PATNA …….. DEFENDANT NO. 3/RESPONDENTS 1ST SET, 5. SMT. KUNTI DEVI, W/O SRI SURENDRA PRASAD AND D/O LATE SITABAR SHARAN, DUNDI BAZAR, NEAR SOUTH GATE OF MANGAL TALAB, P.O.- CHOWK SHIKARPUR, PATNA CITY ………. NR 5, - 3 - 6. SMT. SUMITRA SHARAN, W/O LATE SHARDA NANDAN PRASAD, AND D/O LATE SITABAR SHARAN R/O CHHOTI BADALPURA, KHAGAUL, PATNA …. NR.6 7. SMT. PRATIBHA SHARAN, W/O MANOJ KUMAR SINHA AND D/O LATE SITABAR SHARAN R/O KACHCHI TALAB, SARISTABAD, P.O.- GARDANIBAGH, PATNA AT PRESENT RESIDING AT MOHALLA- AZAD PATH, HOUSE NO. AP/A2, SARISTABAD, P.S.- GARDANIBAGH, DISTT.- PATNA ………. N.R. 8, 8. SRI RAKESH BIHARI SHARAN, S/O LATE SITABAR SHARAN, FLAT NO. 3/E, 3RD FLOOR, GIRIJA APARTMENT (NEAR DEVI ASTHAN), BRAHM ASTHAN GALI ROAD, AT SHEIKHPURA, P.O.- B.V. COLLEGE, DISTT.- PATNA-14.N.R.2 RESPONDENTS 2ND SET. ----------- 3. 30.06.2010. Heard Mr. Chittaranjan Sinha, learned Senior Counsel for the appellants. These appeals arise from the order dated 18.12.2009 passed by the learned single Judge in Test Suit No. 03/2009. The order of the learned single Judge is within his jurisdiction. No interference is warranted. The appeals are dismissed in limine. Interlocutory Application (IA No. 4798/2010) stands rejected. Dilip ( R.M. Doshit, CJ ) ( Shiva Kirti Singh, J )