IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT : THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KURIAN JOSEPH FRIDAY, THE 28TH MARCH 2008 / 8TH CHAITHRA 1930 WP(C).No. 25533 of 2004(M) ----------------------------------- PETITIONERS: ----------------- 1. AMOTHE C.R., (PC No. 5009), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 2. JAISON P.K, (PC No.5404 ), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 3. ANIL T.P., (PC No. 5372), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 4. MOHAMMED SAGEER K.M, (PC No. 5427), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 5. SHILNILKUMAR G.R., (PC No. 5128), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 6. DINESAN K.D. (PC No. 4919), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 7. VIMAL LAL K.V. (PC No.5351 ), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. WP(C).No. 25533/2004 ...2... 8. SAJEEVAN V.V., (PC No. 5386), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 9. BIJU M.V., (PC No. 5426), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 10. MURALIDHARAN (PC No. 5421), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 11. JAYAPAL M.G. (PC No.5432 ), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 12. RAM KUMAR V (PC No.5559), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 13. PRASANNA KUMAR K.P., (PC No. 5383), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 14. SULFICAR SAMAD K.K., (PC No. 5512), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 15. RAJU P.A., (PC No.5590), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 16. JAISON M.L. (PC No.5062 ), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 17. ROJU, (PC No. 5085), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. WP(C).No. 25533/2004 ...3... 18. VINOJ K.P. (PC No. 5411), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 19. SUNILKUMAR C.C. (PC No.5398), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 20. ABDUL MANAF P.A., (PC No.5377), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 21. SHAFI YOOSAF, (PC No. 4981), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 22. JENNIN K.A., (PC No.5474), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 23. JOBI C.I, (PC No. 5400), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 24. BABU P.K., (PC No.5415), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 25. GLENNY P.O, (PC No. 5429), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 26. SAJEEV, (PC No.5350), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 27. LENIN KUMAR M.R., (PC No.5388), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. WP(C).No. 25533/2004 ...4... 28. VISWAMBHARAN M.S. (PC No. 5425), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 29. BENNY JOSEPH, (PC No. 5527), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 30. ABDUL KHADAR A.M, (PC No.5369), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 31. JAMALUDHEEN M., (PC No. 5387), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 32. RAJESH, (PC No. 5376), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 33. SUMESH KUMAR K.S., (PC No. 5373), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 34. SUDHEER P.A., (PC No. 5396), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 35. HARI K.S. (PC No. 5393), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 36. JOSHY THOMAS K.P., (PC No.5397), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 37. UNNIKRISHNAN K., (PC No. 5370), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. WP(C).No. 25533/2004 ...5... 38. RASHEED K.S., (PC No.5385), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 39. SUNIL KUMAR V.R., (PC No.5374), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 40. JOSE ANOTONY, (PC No. 5430), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 41. UNNIKRISHNAN E.T., (PC No.5367), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 42. NISHAR K.S., (PC No.5416), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 43. JAYESHKUMAR K, (PC No. 5417), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 44. JAYAPALAN, (PC No.5395), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 45. NAGESH, (PC No.5408), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 46. NISSAR S.I, (PC No.5409), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 47. JOBY GEORGE, (PC No. 5405), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. WP(C).No. 25533/2004 ...6... 48. NOORDHEEN, (PC No.5356), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 49. SIDDIQUE, (PC No. 5392), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 50. ANIL P.R., (PC No.5406), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 51. SUNNY V.F., (PC No. 5413), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 52. SUDHAKARAN, (PC No.5414), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 53. SUMESH M.C., (PC No.5360), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 54. DINESH C.K., (PC No. 5431), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 55. BENNY K.P., (PC No. 5259), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 56. P. JAISON JOSEPH, (PC No.5587), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 57. THULASIDAS A.S., (PC No. 5513), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. WP(C).No. 25533/2004 ...7... 58. SATHEESH KUMAR M.S., (PC No. 5418), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 59. RAJU K.P., (PC No. 5588), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 60. SREEJI U., (PC No.5422), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 61. RAGHU V.S., (PC No.5058), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 62. JUSTIN K.V., (PC No.5380), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 63. SATHEESAN M., (PC No.5379), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 64. ABDUL SALEEM, (PC No.5510), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 65. JINIKUMAR T.T., (PC No. 5070), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 66. SATHEESAN E.N. (PC No.5589), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 67. P.K. ULLAS, (PC No. 5433), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. WP(C).No. 25533/2004 ...8... 68. SAJEEVKUMAR E.A., (PC No. 5490), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 69. GIRIJAN E.V., (PC No.4931 ), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 70. SREEKANDAN V.R. (PC No.5019), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 71. SYAMCHANDAR V.G., (PC No.5382), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 72. ABDUL SATHAR K.A., (PC No. 5403), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 73. GOPI. C.K., (PC No.5375), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 74. BASANTH C.C., (PC No.5046), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 75. REJIMON N.S., (PC No. 5021), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 76. SASI P.K., (PC No.5042), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 77. SAJEEV I.B., (PC No.5065), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. WP(C).No. 25533/2004 ...9... 78. SURESH K., (PC No.5381), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 79. PRADEEPKUMAR, (PC No. 5135), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 80. SUDHEER E.C., (PC No.5063), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 81. MADHU N.P., (PC No.5572), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 82. SHNIL KUMAR, (PC No. 5434), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 83. SINOYMON THOMAS., (PC No.5389), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 84. MARTIN, (PC No.5378), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 85. BALAKRISHNAN, (PC No.5091), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 86. THAMPI K.V., (PC No.5401), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 87. SHAJU N.K., (PC No.5410), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. WP(C).No. 25533/2004 ...10... 88. K.K. NIYOS., (PC No. 5029), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 89. JAYAN., (PC No.5420), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 90. SUDEV P., (PC No.5391), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 91. ABDUL JABBAR., (PC No. 5419), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 92. NIDHEESH P.J., (PC No. 5550), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 93. SUJITHKUMAR T.S., (PC No. 5435), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 94. ANGELO TITUS., (PC No. 5116), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 95. SAJEEVAN K.K., (PC No. 5555), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 96. JAYAN C.A., (PC No. 5424), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 97. JOHNSON K.A., (PC No. 5132), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. WP(C).No. 25533/2004 ...11... 98. JOSHY G.T., (PC No. 5584), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 99. SANTHOSH E., (PC No. 5407), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 100. SAROSH P.K., (PC No. 5066), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 101. HARIHARAN P.V., (PC No. 5265), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 102. SURENDRAN P.R., (PC No. 5567), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 103. JOSEPH THOMAS., (PC No. 5147), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 104. MAHIPAL P. DAMODARAN, (PC No.4974), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 105. PRADEEPKUMAR K.R., (PC No.5018), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 106. V.M. THAKHIYUDEENSAHIB, (PC No. 5138), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 107. SATHISH V.V., (PC No. 5137), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. WP(C).No. 25533/2004 ...12... 108. LIJO M.J., (PC No.5139), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. 109. BIJU. C. MATHEW., (PC No.5428), POLICE CONSTABLE, TRICHUR DISTRICT ARMED POLICE CAMP, TRICHUR. BY ADV. SRI. P. GOPINATH MENON RESPONDENTS: ------------------ 1. STATE OF KERALA, REP. BY THE SECRETARY, HOME DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM. 2. THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE, TRICHUR. BY GOVERNMENT PLEADER SMT. K.R. DEEPA. THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 28/03/2008, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: WP(C).No. 25533/2004 A P P E N D I X PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS: EXT. P1 : COPY OF the REPRESENTATION SUBMITTED BY the 1ST PETITIONER TO THE 2ND RESPONDENT. EXT. P2 : COPY OF THE INTERIM ORDER DATED 13.7.2004 IN W.P.(C). No. 20488/2004 OF THIS HON'BLE COURT. // True Copy // P.A. to Judge. smp KURIAN JOSEPH, J. -------------------------------------- W.P.(C). No. 25533 OF 2004 -------------------------------------- Dated this the 28th day of March, 2008. J U D G M E N T In the matter of pay protection, it is not in dispute that several cases have been dismissed in the case of similarly situated persons. Therefore, this writ petition also is dismissed. KURIAN JOSEPH, JUDGE. smp