74 104 IN THE HlGll COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH Cenlral Excise AppcalNo159 of2005 1 Date of Decisioll 15 1202009 tlommissiotlerofCentral Excise CoiollllissioneraleChandigaill Appcllaill 1 VERSUS Q Mls lS Khalsa Steels Lld Mandi Distol l7ilchgarllSahjl 0 0 I C5 CORAMeHONBLE MR JUSTICE MMKUMAR HONBLE MR JUSTICE JASWANT SINGH Z Presellt Mr GurprcclSingllSeilior Colmsel a2 Covcrnmenl of IndialIndircclaxcsl I7orlhe Nonc for thc 08 1 To be rcferredtcI llle reportersor 11012 2 Whelher thejudgtncillshould he reporled iil the 7 1t8 tItZlt3k Z NleNlKUMARJ Qe For orders sce CEA No 60 of2006 eeeeme 1M1vleKUMARI JUDGE Deccmbcr 2009 OJASWANT 0 S 72 i Io 6C A Ol uvl lJ Batra Amit 2012.11.06 16: 43 True Scannend Copy Of Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:18 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document