IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE, ANDHRA PRADESH AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY FIRST DAY OF JANUARY TWO THOUSAND AND NINE PRESENT THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE C.V.RAMULU WRIT PETITION NO : 29073 of 2008 Between: 1 Shaik Nabi Rasool S/o.Khader Valli Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 2 Gurrampati Mastan Valli S/o.Khadar Huyssain Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 3 Bayanaboina Venkata Subbaiah S/o.Penchalaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 4 Bellam Narsa Reddy S/o.Veera Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 5 Bellam Narsa Reddy S/o.Pedda Penchal Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 6 Pulathota Ramulamma W/o.Penchalaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 7 Bellam Penchalaiah S/o.Pedda Penchalaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 8 Bayanaboina Penchalaiah S/o.Narsaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 9 Bellam Narsa Reddy S/o.Pedda Penchal Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 10 Jyothi Lakshamma W/o.Gangaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 11 Bellam Penchalaiah S/o.Pedda Penchalaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 12 Paturu Maheswara Reddy @ Mahesh Reddy S/o.Subba Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 13 Gurrampati Ramachandra Reddy S/o.Venkat Subbaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 14 Gurrampati Venkat Subba Reddy (died) As per L.R. Gurrampati Lakshmi Reddy, S/o.G.Venkat Subba Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 15 Shake Pakkeer Saheb S/o.Kamal Saheb Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 16 Shake Mahaboob Jan W/o.Shukur Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 17 Shake Hussain Bee W/o.Khajavalli Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 18 Mukkara Obulamma W/o.Chinna Govinda Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 19 Mamidi Subbamma W/o.Mamidi Chinna Obul Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 20 Shake Gulam Saheb S/o.Khader Saheb Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 21 Jyothi Santhamma W/o.Tirupal Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 22 Shake Ghouse Bee W/o.Rahamtulla Saheb Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 23 D.Obulaiah (died as per LR) Doggala Seshamma W/o.Late Obulaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 24 Bellam Pedda Penchalaiah S/o.Narasaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 25 Gurrampati Venkata Lakshumama D/o.Venkateshwar Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 26 D.Obul Reddy (died as per LR) Doggala Seshamma, W/o.D.Obul Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 27 Mamidi Gangi Reddy S/o.Obul Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 28 Siddam Narasimhulu S/o.Penchalaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 29 Shake Nabi Saheb S/o.Hussain Saheb Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 30 Shaik Hussain Saheb S/o.Paker Saheb Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 31 Mamidi Ramanamma W/o.Obul Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 32 Madhu Venkat Reddy S/o.Venkat Subba Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 33 Madhu Rama Subbamma S/o.Venkat Subba Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 34 Rajolu Venkata Suba Reddy S/o.Venkataiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 35 Rajolu Subbamma W/o.Venkataiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 36 Mamidi Kondaiahgari Obul Reddy S/o.Obul Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 37 Mamidi Narsamma W/o.Obul Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 38 Munagapati Venkata Subba Raju S/o.Venkat Subba Raju Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 39 Munagapati Venkata Ramana Raju S/o.Venkata Suba Raju Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 40 Munagapati Venkata Subba Raju S/o.Raghava Raju Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 41 Munagapati Suba Raidu S/o.Venkata Subba Raju Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 42 Munagapati Raghava Raju S/o.Nallapa Raju Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 43 Bellam Pedda Penchalaiah S/o.Narsaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 44 Bellam Narasa Reddy S/o.pedda Penchal Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 45 Rajolu Ramanamma W/o.Venkata Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 46 Shaik Gudu saheb (Died as per LR) Shaik Hussain Bee, W/o.Latye Shaik Gudu Saheeb Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 47 Hussain Saheb (Died as per LR) Shaik Imam Bee,W/o.Late Hussain Saheb Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 48 Shaik Hussain Saheb S/o.RamathuSab Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 49 Palle Obulamma W/o.Rama Suba Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 50 Palle Lakshamma W/o.Narasimha Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 51 Devi Reddy Yellamma W/o.Rajagopal Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 52 Mamidi Subba Reddy S/o.Obul Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 53 Bellam Peda Penchal Reddy S/o.Narsaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 54 Bellam Penchalaiah S/o.Chinna Penchalaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 55 Shaik Gudu Saheb (Died as perLR) Shaik Hussain Bee, W/o.Latye Shaik Gudu Saheeb Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 56 Valluru Babu Saheb s/o.Peer Saheb Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 57 Valluru Siddaiah S/o.Valluru Siddaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 58 Patnam Yellamma W/o.Raja Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 59 Valluru Pedda Siddaiah S/o.Pedda Siddaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 60 Doggala Amaravathi W/o.Suba Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 61 Doggala Narsimha Reddy S/o.Narsaiah Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 62 Madhu Subbamma D/o.Dunnuthala yella Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 63 Mudamala Gopalamma W/o.Nagamuni Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District 64 Gurrampati Nagi Reddy S/o.Venkat Subbaiah @ Venkata Subba Reddy Resident of C/o.B.Eashwar Reddy Door No.6/758-4, Shankara Puram,Jayanagar post Cuddapah District ..... PETITIONER(S) AND 1 The Governmetn of Andhra Pradesh, rep.by its Secretary Irrigation and CAD Department, Secretariat,Hyderabad 2 The Special Collector, Gelaru Nagari Srujala Sravathi ,Shankarapuram, Cuddapah, Cuddapah District 3 The Special Deputy Collector (LA), TGP/Somasila Project /Unit -I,Mamillapalli, Cuddapah District .....RESPONDENT(S) Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein the High Court will be pleased to to issue an appropriate writ order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus or anyother appropriate writ or order direction holding that the action of the respondents in not re-determining the compensation under sec.28-A of the Land Acquisition Act as illegal, arbitrary, and unconstitutional and further direct the respondents to re- determine the compensation in respect of the lands of the petitioners in Chenduvoi village, Atloor Mandal, Cuddapah District on par with the lands covered by (OP.Nos.296 of 2002) on the file of District Legal Service Authority, Cuddapah dated 19.2.2007 as the lands of the petitoners and the claimants in the said above OP covered by the same Sec.4(1) of the Notification i.e. AP Gazette Part-I ii/TGP/92 on 5.5.1992 for Reach No.7-B,8- A,9-A,9-B,A.P.Gazette part-I 14/TGP/9 dated 30.4.1993 for Reach No.8-B, 10-A,and AP Gazette part-I 20/TGP/93 dated 9.7.1993 for Reach No.10-B and pass Counsel for the Petitioner:BOYARAVINDER REDDY Counsel for the Respondent No.: GP FOR LAND ACQUISITION The Court made the following : THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE C.V.RAMULU W.P.No.29073 of 2008 ORAL ORDER: It appears, after issuing notification dated 5.5.1992 under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short ‘the Act’), the lands held by the petitioners and others were acquired and award was passed on 30.3.1994 and the petitioners were paid compensation as decided therein. However, on an application made by some of the claimants, whose lands were acquired under the very same notification, their cases were referred under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act to the Civil Court and the Civil Court enhanced the compensation vide judgment and decree dated 19.2.2007. Under those circumstances, petitioners filed application dated 9.5.2007 under Section 28-A of the Land Acquisition Act seeking enhancement of compensation. According to the petitioners, the respondents have not taken any decision on the representation filed by them for enhancement of compensation under Section 28-A of the Act. Under those circumstances, without expressing any opinion on merits, the respondents are directed to consider the representation purported to have been made by the petitioners on 9.5.2007 and pass appropriate orders, as per law, within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of this order and communicate the same to the petitioners. The writ petition is accordingly disposed of. No order as to costs. _____________ C.V.RAMULU, J Date: 21.1.2009 DA THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE C.V.RAMULU W.P.No.29073 of 2008 21.1.2009