^^i^SStS^S 6? AF^ •y •f-o8 ItLTHEHIGrH COURT OP CHHA'mSGrARH : BI1ASPUK Petitioner Writ Petition (S) Np. 4«96of 2008 1. SiB 2. 3. 4. Devendra Kuinar Tnwari, ^ed about 28 years, S/o Khamtian Prasad Tiwari, R/o ViUage & Post Amoy, Tahsil Nav^arh, Distt. Jaaj^r Champa (C.G.) Keshav Kumar Dewai^aa, aged about 24 years, S/o Shri Naresh Dewangan, R/o ViUage & Post Chaadrapur, Tallsjl Dabahra, Distt. .Jaujgir Cham.pa (C.G.) Smt Riraa Singh, ^ed about 30 years, W/o Rraiicep Kumar Singh, R/o Ward No. 19 Indra Ns^ar, Beliiad new CIuchal Colony Champa, Disft. Janjgir Chainpa Rajni Singh, ^ed about 33 years, W/o Saujeev Siugh., R/o Vfflage uagmahaut & Post Dhiu-kot, Tahsil Navagarh, Distfc Jaajgh- Champa (C.G.) Versus Respoudents 1. The State of Ctibattisgarh, through Secretary, its Secretary Paachayat and Rural Developiuent Departnient, D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipur. The CoUecfor, Jaajgir Chaanpa. Chief Executive officcr District Panchayat, Jaujgir Champa. Cluef Executive ofiBccr, Jaapad Paachayat Nawagarh, Distt. Janjgir Chaiapa, 2. 3. 4. WRrrPETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 OPTHE CONSTmjTION OF INDIA (SB: Hon'ble Shri Satish K. Agnihotri J.) Shri Pssa^ Kotecha, Advoeate, for tfae peti.ti.oners. Shri Arun Sao, Govt. Advocate for thc respoadents No. 1 aud 2. ORDER (Passed on this 5th Day of September, 2008) 1. The petitioners Iiavc filcd this petition, impugning the order dated 8.8.2008 (Aniiexure P/6), passed by the Chief Executive Officcr, Jaapad Paachayat, Navagarh, District Janjgir Ctaampa, whereby the caadidates selected iu tiieShflcsha Karmi Selection Exainmatipn, 2008 were appointed on the post of Shiksha Karml Grade-III subject - Science. v.ma ^ w SBf; I ^ z- 2. Leacned counsel appcaring for the petitioners subnrits that tte petitioners had appeared ia the coiapetitive ewimaiation, 2008, coiiducted by ttie Cbhattisgar.h ftofessi<«i.al •^ ExamiDation Board for scJteetion bf SIuksfaa Kanni Grade-HI Sdfince subject aad they were pjaced at serial No. 40, 37 and 67, respectively, in the Itet (Annexuse P/2). The gnevance of tfae petitioners is fhat jutuors to ttie petitioners have been appointed, overlookmg the r^ht of the petitioners. The petitioners Iiad scored It^her inarks then those peraons, who ; .. have been selected. The petitioners were also placed at serial No. 38, 35 and 63, Bespectiycly, in the list (Annexuse P/3), prepared by the respondent No.4. 3. Leamcd c»unsel fbr the petitioner fiuther subinite that the respondeiits liave not property followed the Chhatfegarh Pauchayat Stuksha Karmi (Recruitment aad Condltions of Semces) Rules, W07, ia setection and aiyoiatment of the Shiksha Kanni Grade-III.As per scItedule-H, the requiremeat of Higher Secondaiy Certificate (Science Group) is prescnbed and thereisnorequireiaent'ofpassuigD.Ed. certificate examinatioa. The Tespondents had not caUed the petitioaers for counseling on fhe ground that thcy do not possess D.Bd certificate. The petitioners are having certificate of Shiksha Visharad, wlucii is equivatent to D.Ed. 4. The petitioners, without availmg thc alteniative remedy, available to ttiein uader fhe provisions of Cliliattisgarh Panchayat SIukstaa Karmi (Becruitment and Conditioas of Services) Rules, 2007, bave filed this petition. TIus Court m Writ Petition (S) Mo. 4597 of 2008 (Chaadnka Prasad Saliu M •i; B^ i^8 t%s 5. .-s & others Vs. State of Chliattisgarh & ofhers), decKied on 28th August, 2008,, relyiag pn; various decisious ofHon*ble Supreine Court on the question of altemative reinedy, obseryed that ^ 'normally the H^h Court shoiild not iaterfere if there is aa adequate ef&cacious alteraative rciaedy where Irierarchy of appeals is provided by tfae statute, party niust echaust the statutoiy remedy before rcsortuig to writ jurisdiction, cxcept when a veiy strong case is niade out for makang a departure. In view of the foregoiag, without expressing any opizuon on merits, this petition js disinissed, as not Tnaintainabte. However, the Ubettf is reserved to thc petittoners to take recourse to the altetiiative statutoxy fonua that assy te available to theia under the provismas oflaw, ifso adwised. ^Sd/-- . . SatishK.Agmhotri (.2 •Oiakur II! if