IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD CRIMINAL MISC.APPLICATION No 3103 of 2000 For Approval and Signature: Hon'ble MR.JUSTICE B.J.SHETHNA ============================================================ 1. Whether Reporters of Local Papers may be allowed : NO to see the judgements? 2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? : NO 3. Whether Their Lordships wish to see the fair copy : NO of the judgement? 4. Whether this case involves a substantial question : NO of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution of India, 1950 of any Order made thereunder? 5. Whether it is to be circulated to the Civil Judge? : NO -------------------------------------------------------------- KISHORSINH UDESINH SHAH Versus STATE OF GUJARAT -------------------------------------------------------------- Appearance: MR JB PARDIWALA for Petitioner PUBLIC PROSECUTOR for Respondent No. 1 -------------------------------------------------------------- CORAM : MR.JUSTICE B.J.SHETHNA ORAL JUDGEMENT #. FIR No.105/95 dated 7.6.95 was filed by Deputy Executive Engineer for the alleged incident dated 7.7.81 against three accused persons for the offences punishable under Section 120-A, 378, 410, 415, 420 and 441 of Indian Penal Code before the Umergam police Station, District Valsad stating that the accused persons committed trespass over the Government land and made the encroachment. It is a brief complaint. I would like to reproduce the same, which is as under :- xVwbQl, xVu.xiX. xCmUwi.xgwbm, xCnZbFkZ xVudmi xiwLrgU, xCnZbFkZ. xQk.7-6-95 xflha : xJm.xCkCm.xNm.xim. xUk xDXJkZkB xiwRkVmQ xRard xibDkbm xJZmU xCnVb xZkdmDm xjDD xflUk xXlUCTlDpQ xCQmDwbZP xDbfk xXkXQUm xWbmakS. xZjuSa xgwbm, xZuJr xWPik xFkZUm xibwfr xUBXb 433/1, 445, 544, 446/5, 446/5 " xibwfr xUBXb xfkem xIr. xJZmU xJr xibDkbm xfikjQuUu xjliwiu xIr. xJZmUUu xDXJu xQk.7-7-81 xCr xZreffkZkB xCkfrd xIr. xCkRm xJZmU xXmJk xDuCmVP xXuJk xbjmQ xibDkbgwbmUk xDXJkZkB xiwRkVmQ xRka xIr. xiSbjn xJZmU xUlFZ xZkdmDmUm xJZmU xIr. xCkRm xCkfn xiwRkU xCnVb AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA xCZpQdkd xCr xiSbjn xUlFZ xUm xZkdmDm xUm xJZmU xXmUCTlDpQ xbmQr xDXJr xDbrd AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA xIr. xJrRm xUlFZUk xDXJkZkB xiwRkVlQ xRard xibDkbm xJZmU xEuLm xbmQr xDXJr xDb d , xIr. xCkZ xCnVb xJPkffkZkB xCrfu xZkdnZ xRka xIr xDr xgwbm xDmgubHBSwb xCnS ilBj, AAAAA xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ, xZUinEdkd xCZpQdkd xCr xUlFZUk xDXJkZkB xiwRkVmQ xRard xibDkbm xJZmU xCnVb xCVwbZkPmDQkRm xSFkVnfsxD xZkdmDm xjDD xflUk xXmUCTlDpQ xCQmDwbZP xDbrdxIr. xCUr xgwbm. xDlgubHBSwb xCnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@Cn rilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXr xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSri Bj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU x BibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBi kJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, x UubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ @CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUu ZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,C nSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZk rU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnS ilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@CnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ,@Cbfm AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA xZUinEdkd xCZpQdkdUu xiSbjn xUlFZUm xibDkbm xJZmU xUlFZUr xIrQbmUr xCVwbZkPmDQkRm xCQmDwbZP xDbmUr xVHkfm xVkNrd xIr. xCkZ xgwbm. xDlgubHBSwb xCnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ, xZUinEdkd xCZpQdkd xYkbQma xSBN xiBjlQkUm xDdZ-120-xCr, 378, 410, 415, 420, 441 xUu xYBF xDbrd xIr. xCkZx xgwbm xDlgrbHBSwb xCnSrilBj, xZUubZkXrU xjBibkJ, xZUinEdkd xCZpQdkdUu xiSbjn xDkasx xYkbQma xSBN xiBjlQkUm xJuFfkCmCu xCUr xXmJk xiBXBGmQ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA xDkaSkCuUu xYBF xDbrd xIr xJr xGwfkbk xfwakJXm xDkaSribUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkas fkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm Dkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR GUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm jkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasx kjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm x kasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR x Um xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm x kR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxf jm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xD asxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjkR xGUm xDkasxfkjm xjAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA xCUr xQr xZnJX xCibDkbD xVFdkB xdrfk xflUBQmIr. xCkVUu xflgwfkin, xCriNm/- xCriNm/- ___________________ xUkaX xDkasxVkdD xCmJUrb, xFnJ.xCu.xfl.xUFZ xiZmFkZ. xCnVb xZnJXUm xdrEmQ xWbmakS xUkaX xDkasxVkdD xCmJUrb xFnJ.xCu.xfl. xiZmFkZ xJm.xCkCm.xNm.xim. xUkCu xQbWrRm xCkfQk xFnUu xbJxn. xDbwau. xi.xik. xbfkUk - xZr. xJanNm. xW.xD. xZrJm. xikjrXUm xDuLsx xCnZbFkZ xQbW xQk. 7-6-95. xijm.xCfkHwa xZrJmiwLwbrL xWiwLsx xDdki, xVm.xCri.xCu. xCnZbFkZUu xCnZbFkZ. xFue xilDwDu. #. Apart from the fact that the complaint was filed almost after a period of 14 years of the commission of the alleged offence, a bare look at the complaint shows that no offence whatsoever has been committed by the accused persons including the present complainant. It would be abuse of process of law if the police investigate into such a complaint. In view of the above discussion, this petition is allowed and FIR No.105/95 filed before the Umergam Police Station against the accused persons, including the present accused, is hereby quashed. Rule is made absolute. Interim relief granted, if any, stands vacated. (B.J.Shethna, J.) *Pvv