IN IN IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL (L) NO.77 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.77 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.77 OF 2008 The Commissioner of Customs ...Appellant. v. M/s.Jewel Tech (I) Pvt. Ltd. ...Respondent. WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL NO.43 OF 2009 APPEAL NO.43 OF 2009 APPEAL NO.43 OF 2009 The Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) ...Appellant. v. Mr.Balkrishna R. Chavan ...Respondent. WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL NO.44 OF 2009 APPEAL NO.44 OF 2009 APPEAL NO.44 OF 2009 The Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) ...Appellant. v. M/s. Shankar Jewels Ltd. ...Respondent. WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL NO.45 OF 2009 APPEAL NO.45 OF 2009 APPEAL NO.45 OF 2009 The Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) ...Appellant. v. M/s. Neelkamal Jewellery Export Pvt. Ltd. ...Respondent. WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL (L) NO.82 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.82 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.82 OF 2008 The Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) ...Appellant. v. S.B. & T International ...Respondent. WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL (L) NO.80 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.80 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.80 OF 2008 The Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) ...Appellant. v. M/s.Global Jewellery Ltd. ...Respondent. [ 2 ] WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL (L) NO.87 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.87 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.87 OF 2008 The Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) ...Appellant. v. M/s. Fine Jewellery India Ltd. ...Respondent. WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL (L) NO.86 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.86 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.86 OF 2008 The Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) ...Appellant. v. M/s. Bombay Jewellery ...Respondent. WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL (L) NO.84 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.84 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.84 OF 2008 The Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) ...Appellant. v. Goldstar Jewellery Ltd. ...Respondent. WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL (L) NO.79 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.79 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.79 OF 2008 The Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) ...Appellant. v. Mr.Mohd. Ismail ...Respondent. WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL (L) NO.78 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.78 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.78 OF 2008 The Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) ...Appellant. v. M/s.Tara Jewels Export Ltd. ...Respondent. WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL (L) NO.94 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.94 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.94 OF 2008 The Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) ...Appellant. v. Mohd. Rafique Ansari ...Respondent. WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL (L) NO.81 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.81 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.81 OF 2008 Union of India ...Appellant. [ 3 ] v Amir Shah ...Respondent. WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL (L) NO.93 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.93 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.93 OF 2008 The Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) ...Appellant. v. M/s.Gem Plus Jewellery (I) Ltd. ...Respondent. WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL (L) NO.88 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.88 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.88 OF 2008 The Commissioner of Customs (P) ...Appellant. v. M/s. C.I.Jewels Ltd. ...Respondent. WITH WITH WITH CUSTOMS CUSTOMS CUSTOMS APPEAL (L) NO.92 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.92 OF 2008 APPEAL (L) NO.92 OF 2008 The Commissioner of Customs (P) ..Appellant. v. Dhanraj Shakhilehan Rathod ..Respondent. Mr.R.V.Desai, Sr.Counsel with Shri A.D.Kango advs. for the Appellant. None for the Respondents. CORAM : F.I. REBELLO & J.H.BHATIA J.H.BHATIA J.H.BHATIA, JJ. DATE : 29th 29th 29th April, 2009. April, 2009. April, 2009. PC PC PC : : : 1. Matters not on board. With consent of the counsel, taken up on board and heard forthwith. Office objections, if any, are dispensed with. Office to register the appeals. 2 In all these appeals, questions of law are [ 4 ] covered by the judgment of this Court in Commissioner Commissioner Commissioner of of of Customs (Preventive) v. Noble Asset Company Ltd Customs (Preventive) v. Noble Asset Company Ltd Customs (Preventive) v. Noble Asset Company Ltd. decided on 4th August, 2008. In the light of that, questions of law donot arise. 3. Appeals stand dismissed. ( J.H.BHATIA, J.) ( F.I.REBELLO, J.)