^" -^ •:1'"^"';^ ^"vfS^ l^ ^ •r CT. HI0H COURT OF CHHATTES^ARH AT KCLASPUR Witit Petition (5) No. 3199 of 2007 Petitioner5 1; Ldfia Ram 5c^»u, Ag& about 56 year, Asn. Teacher. S/o ^iri Firtu Rc»n 5ohu, 6ovt. Primary School, Mopka, BIock- Bhatapara, Disn. Raipur (C.^.) 2. Smt. Konak Luta Philip. fivya. about 55 year, Astt. Teacher, W/o Shri Mikayal Philip, 6ovt. 6irJs Primary Schooi. Halttanjpora, Block- Bhatapara, Disn. Raipur (C.6.) Versus ft&^ondants 1- Stote 6ovt- of ChhQttisyirh, Through 5ecretary, Tribd Welfare Depwtment <& Education bepartment, b.K.S. Bhawan, bistt.- Raipur (C.6.) 2. Disn. Education Officer, Raipur Disn.- Raipur (C.^.) 3. Btock Educotion Offic&r, Bhatapara, Disn.- ftaipur (€.6.) 4, Treasuiy, Account d Penssion Raiput^ Distt.- Raipur (C.G.} WRrr PFrrroiN UNbER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTTTUTION OF IN&IA Sjngl®Bench : Hon'ble Mr. Satish K. Agnihotri. J. 1. 2. 5hri 5omkc8it Verma, AdvooGrt-e for the petitioners. Shri Ajay bwiv&di, D^puty fiovt. Advocote for the refipondents. ORALOR&ER (Passed on this 26+k day of June, 2008) With the con^snt of the parti&s, the matt&r is tak&n up for heoring- Leorn&cl counssl ^paarsng for the patitioyi&rs submits that tha petitsonsrjS have obtained B-T.I. examinotion c&rtificate, at their own sxpans&s during servicis^ v "L— Leam&d coun5&I Gppearing for •tfi& p&tition&rs as w&ll as teamed counsel appearing for th& raspond&nts/State jointly aibm»t^iat the facts ond quastion of law, iriyolved sn the pnssent writ p&titiwi, ons the same asto that of m Yadhworst |!'umar ^arodwaj Vs- Munscipal Corporation, burg and another (2006 (TE) MPJR-C6 96), which has be&n di^osed of vide ord&r cfated 3<4.2006 ond 1+i& order dated 7.2.2007. pass&d by this Court in V,/.P.(S) No. 697 of 2007 (A. N. V. Sotyanarayon A. oth&rs Vs. State of ChhattisgQrh A oth&rs). Accordi'ngly, th& writ petition is allowed in term5 of ths ord&r po^^d in the coss. of Ya^hwant Kumar Bharadwaj (^upra) and W-P-(S) No. 697 of 2007 (^jpra), ^ibject to verificotion of ths fact asto wh&ther the p&titionsrs hov^ acquir&d B^d-/b-Ec{-/B.T-I./M.Ed< Ex€smir%3tfon C&rtificate or» thasr own &sq)ensss, as p&r •rtie circulars dat&d 13.9.1974, 24.12.1998, and 1.3.1999 and furth&r whether they hava be&n paid two advonc& increm»itsw not- No order asto costs- Sd/- Sadsh K. Agnihotri Judge Thokur