S.B. Civil Second Appeal No.231/08 Date:05/08/2008 HON'BLE Mr. JUSTICE ASHOK PARIHAR Mr. Vinod Goyal, for appellants. BY THE COURT: Suit for declaration filed by the plaintiff- respondent challenging his punishment order of withholding of two grade increments with cumulative effect was decreed by the trial court vide judgment and decree dated 5.5.2005. The above judgment and decree passed by the trial court has further been affirmed by the lower appellate court vide judgment dated 20.5.2008. After hearing learned counsel for the appellants, I have carefully gone through the material on record. On the basis of concurrent findings of fact since after due consideration proper discretion has already been used by both the courts below, in the facts and circumstances, no further interference is called for by this court, moreso, when no substantial question of law arises. The objection in regard to jurisdiction of civil court also do not survive since the concerned workman has no other efficacious alternative remedy against the order of punishment of stoppage of grade increments. The appeal is dismissed accordingly as having no merits. (Ashok Parihar) J.