CHS. 1346-09 - 1 - VPH IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION CHAMBER SUMMONS No. 1346 OF 2009 IN SUIT No. 1088 OF 1973 Rungta Estate Private Ltd. ... Plaintiffs Vs. Pradeep Gordhandas K. Vora & Ors. ... Defendants *** Mr. Whailesh Shah a/w Mr. Farhan Dubash a/w Ms. Anuja Jhunjhunwala a/s Ms. Dhanashree Deoskar i/b Munir Merchant, for the Plaintiffs. Mr. J. P. Sen a/w Ms. Ferzana Behram Kamdin i/b FZB Ass, for Defendant Nos. 1(a) to 1(c). *** CORAM : Smt. R. S. DALVI, J. DATE : JULY 27, 2011 PC. 1. Defendant Nos. 1(a) to 1(c) has sought to file a further affidavit of documents, relying upon certain documents. These documents are shown in the compilation which is filed by the defendants. The defendants, however, seek to use these documents for confronting the plaintiff’s witness i.e. plaintiff No. 5(a). The cross- examination of the plaintiff’s witness is complete. The defendants claim that they have discovered these documents either from their possession or from the court records or by search from the public authorities, namely the Registrar of Companies, consequent upon the evidence that has emerged in the cross-examination. The defendants CHS. 1346-09 - 2 - shall be entitled to confront the plaintiff’s witness the documents without referring to those documents in their affidavit of documents, under the provisions of Order Order 7, Rule 14(4) and Order 13, Rule 1(3)(a) of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908. Hence, affidavit of documents need not be filed. 3. There shall be no order in the Chamber Summons. No order as to the costs. Chamber Summons is, accordingly, disposed of. [ Smt. R. S. DALVI, J. ]