t IN PH H ‘1 ouu K EN T A P 4 ?‘LORE DATED THIS PHi 30TH DAY OF JTTNE, 1998 H THE PON ELF ?2. PJ$TICE ,K,SINnH1L r1R’I lI ION NOS: 19314—323/98 c/ 4S1536/98 and 2D330201/102 BETWEEN: 19314—323/1998 I ,Krnataka dine Mercnents nssn,, (R) 185, Arya Ic3iar Sanohe Buillinos Seabed ipuram Banoalore2O, ren by its Secreta Sri .A.MarIyapa .A.KariyipOa C1,2 Licence ‘colder s/cs Arsapoa. ri/S. SaTibana h%ine ctore, 372A, 50 Ro ci, Hanma 11 thna ar Banralore 19, 3, C,,H,Obaiah s/c Krtshnappa CL 2 LIcence Holder ?‘/C.Royal Wi e to e, 25, M,T,Street, Baa svancucli Bnslor4, 4, ,Halama s/c Hiriyanaka Navarathna Wino Ku nba h lli Baa ,veah,ararj-wcr Bancalore, ( ,KeW ra s/c Ganangappa CL 9 Llcenco Hl’er i/cN€hrvati a t U nt 49, Sririniapur Bar galore. ‘ F r pe ow a s/c Huchaich CL 2 Licnnce Hrlder, Thivas i Win HousTho 3cad ol ty, ViJayara BanCalore, 7, V,Kuth CL L cerce a icr ri/s Nuttu ann °tore EAT treet, Baavanrnac3j csanr,ior 4, 8, B.P.Sreenivasa CL Licence Holder Santhosh Wine Store, VU ayanagar Bangalore, 9, N.Udya, CL 9 Licence Holder 50 NanJundapra Mohan Kiran Bar and Restaurant, BG Main Road, Belakanahal ii Banoalore. ID. Chencana nr 9 s/oBrappa Shamanth Bar and Restaurant, Kalasipalya Bangalore PETITIONERS (Mr,RN,Narasinhamu counsel for M/S.Shetty and Hegde Assts, . Jfl, I, State of Karnataka by its Secretary and Commissioner, Excises and Financial Denartment, Vldhana oudna Bangalore1 2, 5cise Commission.:.r in Karnataka, Kithuruchannamma Circle, Bangalore. 3. Dy ommr of Excise Bangalore Dirt, Bancialore, RESDONDENTS (B Smt,Sujatha, HCGP) ‘he .epetitions are filed rraying to deOlare that the amendment made to sub rule I ol. rule S of the Karmataka Excise C sale of Indian made Foreign LiTuor) Rule 1968 and insertion of rule BA is illecal and quash the sane, These petitions coming on for preliminary hearing this day, the Court made the following order; Corder at oage— ) W,P.NOs, 1948149536/1998 1, Wholesale Wine Merchants Assn CR) unoer Karnataka Societies Racistration Act 26B Sri rirj iocti !ospial Road, RajaJinaar, By its necretary, T,Ramu, —3— 2. T,Ciriyapa CL 1 Licencee K/S. Srinivasa Enterpr sea, 2nd block, Rajainr Bane lore, 3, R,Jitenira. Gowda, CL I Licencee 3rd Cr as Lial1eshwa m Bangaloe. 4, J.M.hivanna CL 1 Licncee M/S,SLi’ Wines, I Stage Iridiraqarar Bangalore 5, K,Mukunda Shenoy CL —1 Licencee K/ Srinivesa ines Joguoaiya 3Jlsoor, Bangalore. 6. J,Krishnarnurth CL1 Lidencea, r/S,Krishna Enter risc, 1st Cross, Old Ladivala Road, Sang lore. 7. A Ananda ae Lenaging Partner, CL I Licencee, M/S.nuparna nine istributors, Jayanagar, Bangdiore. 8, T,Srinivasa s/o 1 Dte K, Thimmaiah cl1 Li a Kaali Wine tores, 39, 8th Kair hine jar, Banealore, , Anu Wir a, CL 1 Licencee by its oartner, Prakashna ar, Bana1ore, 10 G,0,Xrishna s/o G< Ohaiax CL*1 Licencee 269 10th cr a, 4t rain NColow Banea lore. —4— 11. Urna Vinod, w/o ri,V..Vinod, CL 1 Liencee, 132, Thilway elll Road, Bar alore by GPi Holder D,Javarrn /o D.Govindappa 12, R.Jayavelu CLI Licencee. Delus nes N-ic :oad, Bang 1ore, 13. K..3ar ia CLI Liencve Banashankr Th DK II St 7e B: nialore, 14, H,,Sriivs Cl lLicencee I Vain Road, ‘adiva1a Bnaalore. 15. H,vudriar s/c Hiriyanna hty CL I Licencee Erinidhi Enter ises, Bane lore. 16, A iswamv, CL-I Ltecee C? ndara )istribotors lxiur- n Bana1cre 17. Thiruki a CL—I Licencee IT ,‘4ain TU Cros nanaha1i, van lore by its art e P. yasrak r ‘ jo. s/c Parnkusar CL Lscenee, Sorr rarac I, Banea lore, 19, r:,’oan set, ‘4 D.1t C — Liec. Antaregnge Ro d, Kolar, 23 ,D,Ch-nerurr. CL—i Lieencee Shiva ‘-nterprisec Wi son C;,rder, Banonb r e, 21. ?VS,Santr, ch Uire, c: 1 —i Licencee Lalbagh Road, B’nt Ic e Urban flstrict, 22, rJS,Blue Bed W’n a, CL—I Licencee, Khadar Sheriff Garden BCflflf lore. 23, S,P,Shantararr CL-i Li ncee oy Wincs, Old Maras Road, Ulsoor, Ban lore. 24, z,Anantrar o CL—I Lncee Shiravanthe Traders 1(1< Pure Roed, Ba rbore 25 .R.Gopalaiah CL 1 Liencee ? all eshwar arc Ban slore, 26, S,Venkat°st CL 1 Litncee Nanjundeshwara Enterprisr a, Macad! Road, graher Dasarahalli B nabore, 27 .Smt.Muniyanna CL—i inc°e Path anabha tvincs, Albert Victor Road, Ban alore. 28, V.Pillappa CL I iencce Sri,Mahalakshrni Enterprises, Bargalore Urban Dictr’ct, 29, B,R,bh:ratiii Lta Rajbevencir B1at, CL— Liancee Karntaka Beer and Wine Tr ciar°, let Main, Gokula, B r —6— 30, T,Rarnu CL-I Lncee N/S,Karr:atJc Beer and nine Traders, Isi. Main, Gokula Bax.. galore 31. A,rj,Ashok Kumar, s/o A.P.Dasappa CL I Lncee, Gurushree Entepprl sea, Bas aveshwarn agar, Banqalore. 32 ,C,Ramaiah CL—I Licencee Mysore Road, Banc:alore, 33, Naresimhaiah CL-I Lncee N/S,Naveen Enterprises, M,C Layout, Vijayanagar, Bancjalore. 34, Venkataranniah s/c late Dasaiah Gowda, Tejaswini Agencies, Attiguppa BarccaIore 35, R,L,Chemicals Pfl Ltd., by its Director, BA LaJcstnan CL-i Liencee, Some shw aran agar, Eangalore, 36, Smt,Kanthanca Cl-I Licencee Kal aEnterpri S es Sarakki , Banqalore, 37, Sot, Girija:a w/o Mahadevacça Cl—I Lncee, Neelakanteshwara Wine Stores OTC Cross Road, Bahgalore. 38 . A Euresh, s/o Aswathn.raye.na Cl—i Lieencee sS,Shaktivel Trading Co., Devanathachar Street, Bencalore, 39. S,N,Ashok Kurnar, s/o S Narasusa, CL—I Licnncee, Anil Agencies, Charnarajvet, Bnagalore, —7— 40, K.Rajashekar, Cl—i licencee, N/S. Cha.mundeshari Acetic es, West of Chord Road, Bane lore. 41, T,Ras CL *1 licencee, ACR Entex..rises, Bangalore Tow:i Banqalore Urban District. 42 • D. V. Raghunath CL-i Liencee, Ramadurca AgencIes, Bangalore. 43. B,L.Veerabhadran cl—i licencee, Dewar Wines 7, Walton Roe Bangalon, 44. MJS,Ashok Kumar e/o MS Narayana Rao Cl-i Liencee Vani Wines, Srikanteshwaranar.. Nandini Layout, Bangalore. 45. Prasad Reddy, Cl-I Liceacee, Lords Group of Wines, Banoalore City. 46. Vish&cnta Cl—i Lieencee, Sree Bh ,eni ‘iines Bangalore City, 47, Mohair Lied Au CL—I Licencee, Durga nterprises, Banoalore City 48, RviEdra Cl—i Lieencee, Shi lpa Enteri ses, Bangalore City, 49, S,P,Hanurnanthaiah Cl—i Licencee, Srinivasa Stoiies, Yelhanka, Bangalore, -8— 50, •azrakrishna Cl—I Licencee, Rarnakrishna ines B-na lore C ty 51. Narke Cl-I Licencee Srinivsa ines Vasanthanagar 52, Srnt,Sornashekar Naiidi Enterprises, Cl-i Licence B’ncalore City 53, 4aju Cl—’ Licancee Guru Ragnavendra Wine ?cencies, Bancalore City, 54, Meera Moharn Investments Pvt L:d,, CI-Licencee by its Director, Sri,Ba 55. V. Reddy, Cl-I Licencee MS Enterpris’s B ng lore City. 56, Sudhakar,J,P, s/o J,t*,N;rayanaswafry CL—i Licencee, Bindu Eriter-orises, Bancrilore, W 2 TITIQMrRP (Dy Zri,G,T<,Bhat, Adv,,) 7 1 1. I a t t ‘ r at ka bL its A 4 dti flêi ChIef Scrt r and “rIc 4 nai ecr--ar’ t’N Gon°’yert, V &ana S ud a Ban lore, 2.Tte Dc stCni I ‘arn ‘tc Vokkalicarasaccha BuilSing, Channamma Ci cl, B no lore, 3 I’e D Ut Cy I nez rf Lx ice B n I e Dr fiz rut, e..9a, 4. “he £‘c’putj Crt.. Bangal.re Urban District, 5. The Denuty Co.rission,r ...acsise, Kolar District, kolos. 6. “ic Dy.C.ciri r., ICo or 1 ”i tric olr (n Snt.S.Sujatha, wcar) Th.se oetitions are filed praying t’ quash nnexu. —C ‘td.18—6—199e aM to !eci1r• the sane iflgal. W.P.NO. 2003 —20119/19 8 1. K.R.fliger, Cl”2 Lic’icee, Akialur. Hai al flhik Uharwa.j Di’trict. •IC.fla I 8/c. Riots flakal C1—2 Lio’rcee H ii Towb Dharwad Dis’ it. 3. V.R.fliqar CL—2 Licensee Akkirlur I l? it is .ad3 .ra a kond ‘1—9 Lict e Sapna DelEf, Vidyanaer, Ribli Town, Dharwa! Diattict. 5. N.T.a&li 1’ “2 Licenc. e aI”an Win , fubli Diet sd ‘ r 0 t. - ,. 1 tW 1 ar, C1-2 Lieencee ksht Wites, Cfl Mubli Town Dharwa5 Distrit. —10— 7, An’bika C1—2 Licencee, crented cz Partn Yeliarma V Ktava, s/o Vittalsa Katie, 9T3301 Town Dht Disbrict. 8,Kishor Shankar Keh c ‘ada a ‘o Shankar Keharwade, C1,9 LLcer tee, Akshay Bar and Restaurant, Hubli Town, Dharw”d District 4 9—Si raJcanth ,Habct o, C1—9 Licncee, o a ci City, 10, M/S,Classic Ear and Restaurant C1_0 t?,tie yj+spta, Deeo’ak Jejansa Powar s/o Jenjansa Powar Gadac Town, Ca 1 an Dist, 11. KisIor Tejansa P0 ‘a- s/o TeJansa Powar, Ci—2 licencee, o d ci Town 4 12. Anand L,Eutb r C1—9 Lic ncee, Burbur Bar and Restaucnt, 0 dcci Town, ada istrict, 13,W’,Saoar Bar, C1—9 Licencee, B its nartner, - ir a C rnathasa ci s/o Curun; rhasa Chc van kub’i 3 ha wad District 14. Y/S,Vijayalakshmi Entcrorlzas, Cl—C licence , B t rt r Rarru at acao-Da Shettu, ‘a-’apoa Shetty, MiMi 1 own, Oh nal 0 istrict, 15, “arosirafl fall pp Dhon d’ Yal apna Dhonooi CL-2 Lncee Hibli Towh, 3 h=rwacl Djctnict, 16,MJS,Hotel Sri, Ci9 Licencee frc its ci rtner, —il Narayen TeJaopa ‘hetty, a/c Tejapa Shetty Hosur-Hub1i Dharw a Djsrj t, 17, H,Marutrii C1-2 Licencee Old Hubli. Dharwad District, 18, YVS,Adarsha Bar, C1—9 Licence, by its artner N.Ranganath Hubli Dharwad ‘istrict, 19a,B,Habib, C12 Licencee, Hubli Town, Dhacwa District, 20, Chndrakanth Lakshrnansa IC aye, 01—9 Licencee, Hubli Town, Dharwad District, 21 ,Vasudev V,Macajikondi, s/o Vithalasa Macajikondi 01-9 Licencee, Hubli Town, Dhrwad District, 22,Nnausa Renachndrasa Habib, Cl— Licencee, Hubli Town, Dharwa-5 Ditrict, 23, Madhusa Laxana Habib, s/o Laana Habib, Cl—2 Licence, Hil’ Tnwn araad D1-t—c 24, Pur nd ra ‘chchanna he ty, C1—9 kicencee, Daj ibanpet, Hubli, Dhawad ‘istrict, 25 ,YL 1 S,AJCnthC Bar awl Rnstaurant, by its partner, 01—9 Ltcencee, Rancanath Hanurnarthasa Baddi, Old Hubli, Hubli Town, 2$.Yallapta L,Baddi, Cl,t Licencre Sager Bar, Hllaoaddi strentzr uibl Town, har Di —12 27,Satish hettv 0 C1—9 Lice;cee, Hubli Dhrwad district. 28. M/S.Prabhat Br and Hestaurant ci9 Licencee, by its partner Ratnakar s/c TiniapDa Shetty, Hubli To Dharwad District, 29. Keabawasa Narayansa Walvekar Ci2 Licencee Hubli. T.wn, Dha.rwad strict. 30, WS,D,P.Dinakar, C1—2 Licencee, Kaveri Wines by ts partner, Moahn V,Kabade Hubii Town, Diaad District, 31, Dasharatsa T.Habib, s/o Tejansa Habib C19 Licenccc, HubIi Town Dhawad District, 32. Srnt, Laxmibai K,Pawar C1—9 Licencee, Hubli TøWn, Dharwad ‘istrict. 33. Khd.ine Peg Bar C19 Licencee, by its oartner Tipoanna N,Khode, Hub1 Dharwad District, 34,N/S,trupti Bar and Rest. Ci9 Lcencee, by its nartner, Tippanna N,Khode Hosur Hubli Dharwad istrct, 35, Srnt,Nirmal Yellappa Bacidi C19 licencee, Hubli own, Dharwad District, —13— 36.V,. 1 eddy, Ci—2 Licencee, Hubli Town, Dharwad istrict, 37,Manohar Mursa Habib, C1—9 Licencee, Hubli Town, uharwad 1 istrict. 38,MJS Uniqae Bar and Rest,, 01—9 Licencee, by its partner Deopak T,Pawar, Hubli Town, Dharwad District, 39,M/S.Excellent Bar and Rest., 01—9 Lioencee, byits partner Deepak T,Pawat, Hubli Town, Dist.rict, 40,Tarasa G,Habib, 01—2 Licencee, Hubli Sown, Dhyjad District, 41 ,Srikanth V,Katawatte, C1—9 Licencee, HubIi Town Dharwad District, 42,M/S,M,V,Katawate and Co., C1—9 Licencee, by its i:artner, Mohan Vjhatawate, Hosur Hubli, Dharwac3 ist, 43,Smt,A,S,Ia1, 01—2 Licencee, k!utfl Town, Dbarad Dist.rict, 44.Narayanasa Lakshmansa Khode, 01—9 Licencee, Hubli Town, Dharwad District, 45 , Prashanth F: reion Licuor Centre, by its par••tner Srikanth Ramansa Habib, 01—2 Licencee, Hubli Town, Dharwed district, — I 4— 46, M/S.Vnayaka Wins, 01—2 Licancee, by its partner, Zriksn’th Rarnansa Habib, Hbbli Town, Dharwad District. 47, R,R, Niranjan C1—9 Licencee, Hubli Town, Dharwad District, 48 ,Gaj anan Y,WaIvekar 01—2 Licencee, Hubli Town, Dhaad District. 49 ,M/S. on Raghavencra Bar and Rest.,, by its partner Nemiraj R Habib, 01—9 Licencee, Hubli Town, 2 harwad District. 5O,M/S.Vinayaka Wines, 01-2 Licencee, by its partner, Shrikanth R,Habibi iIubii Town, Dharwad Jist, 51,MJS,Niskin Bar 01—9 Licencee, by its partner, I..evaraj sa H,Misking, Neharu Station Road, Hubli, Dharwad District. 52.M/S.Sringar Bar, 01-9 Licencee, by its partner, Murali G,Dharmadas s/p Ganapatsa, Station Road, Hubli, Dha.rwad Dist, 53,M/S,Sringar Wines, 01—2 Licezicee, by its rartner PrEmEnath G,Dhatmidas StationRo akn, Fubli Dharwad Distriot, 54,tVS,00lden Wines 01—2 Licencee, by its partner Sriniwasa K,Jitury s/o Keshava New Market, Hubli, Dhanq ad Diet, -45— 55,M/S,Parecj Br, C1—9 Licencee, by its nartner shokkurnar R,Shetty, Station Road, Hubli Dharad District. 56.Nacaraj Bhaskarasa Habib, Cl—B Licencee, Motel Vikrarn Bar and R-st., Lymington Road, Hhfli Road, Oherwad District, 57,Cirish C1—2 LicenceR, Near Buastand, Hbbli Town, Dharwad District, 58. Deenak Bar and Rcst,, Cl-B Licencee Jayaramn Chandrayya Shetty, Club Koad dubli Dharwad Diotrict, 59,M/S,Pallavi Bar and Rest,, Cl—B Ltcencee, by its partner, Raju Yallapoa awar Hubli Town, Dharwad nietrict, 6O,M/S,Hot1 flishali, Cl— Lie ncee, by its -)artner Udaya Kawath, Station Ro d, Hubli Town, flittrint, 6l,Srisa Bar and Rest,, Cl—B Lsc ncee, Decpak Pan-urangssa Ma-arkond SwiniTling pool complex Hubli Dherwa List, 62 M,B,Kalal Cl—2 Licencee, Manj i Mines, Aedur, Manage I Taluk Haven Dist, 16e 63. S.G.ICalyani, C1—2 Lic ncee, YJS.Santosh Wine shop Hanaga1 tirj Di’trict. 64. S.G.Kalyani. C1e2 Licercee, Kalyani Wine Shop !fandg d Mae—ri Diet. 65 • S. D.Laaninarayana Cia? lica ion Tilavafli Hanegal Taluk, Haven District. 66. R.Raq’iunath Proprietor M/S.14&iaraja Li’uor Zceney, Cl-i Lieanc’e, Hubli. 67.B.p.Naeerdra C12 Lica.cee, Bhevani Wines, Tilavalli, T1uk Hanecral Havsri District. 69.1’. S.Kalal C1.2 Licencee Gayat’tri Vines, Hnagal, Htveri Din. 69. .MJ’ira3er o — Lacer cee, Kundagol harwa4 Diet. 70. Sm .V.S.Niralegi C1e2 Licercee, M n tire Cp Market 4n:d, Savanoor, Dhnwe Diet. 71. N.S.t’run-.th 01—9 Licancee, Qajanan Bar nd Rnt., Savanoor, Dhana’3 Diet. 72. V.V.Kumar, C. 2 Lita cee, Zavanoor, Dh’r’flit. 73 .Y.M.Mirajkar, C1—2 Licencee, 5 avanoor, Dharwad Dist, 74,Karunakar Shetty C1—2 Licencee, Sampialli,Huli Wharwad Dist, 75, M/S,A,J,pinto Cl—2 Licencee, Pintc..: Wines, by its partner, M.J,Pinto Hubli Dharwad dist, 76,Hilton Wine Centre, C12 Licencee, by its oartner Shankukhsa Narayansa Walveka.r, Radhakrishna Galli, Hubli, Dhsrwad Dist, 77.M/SSringar Pen Bar, Ci9 Licencee, br its partner Ak,. ass, Rania.chandrasa Habib, :tation Road, Hubli, Dhansad District, 78,A,R,Iiabib, Cl2 Licencee, Desbapandenacar. Hubli, Dharwad List. 79 ,Balachandra P ,Habih, Cl9 Licence.e, Kaperi Bar, Anchatageri Oni, Hubli, Dharwad di.:..:t, 80.F4.’S.Uday Bar, Cl9 Licanc:c., by its partner Remachandrnsa Ged.ausa Dalabanjan, Anchatgeri Oni, aub.:li, Dharwad District. 81 P.1 ,AkalavaSe, t.,1 n t asc Old Hubli Hubli Pharwad District, 82 ,P,i ,Akalaavade Cl2 licancee, Kcpnlkar Road, Hucli Dharwad District, 18— 83 ,S,B.aiveker, C1—9 Licencee, Static•n Road, ?ubll, Dharwad Dist€ 84,M/S€Sri,Renula Wine House, Cl—2 Licencee, Coen Road, Hiabif, by its partner, Sunil B,Walvekar, Hubli Dharwad °Istrict, 85, M/S, S4per ines, C1-2 Licencee, by its partner, Deep ak T ,Pawar Ruth Dharwad District, 86,N/S.Oriclnai Ber and Rest,, Ci—9 Licencee, by its partner, Pradeep Pewar Swimedn ppcl conpiex Ruth, Dherwad Dist€ 87.l/S.Kaveru Pep Bar, Ci9 Licer 1 cee, by its partner, Mohan V,Kabade Anchatceri Oni Ruth, tharwad, List, 88€ T€Verugopesl, Cl—2 Licencee, Vidyapeeta Circle, Channannanakere Layott, Bancralore, 89,R,Tanacrairnalai, cL—2 Licr.r.r:ncee, BanashankariWines, Geeta colony, Jayanaqar, Banoabore, 90, R,Tanaciaimalai Cb—2 Licencee, Gandhibaza.r Sanpabore, PeTiTIONeRS, (By Sri,G,K,Bhat, Adv,,) ANt: 1,The State of Rarnetaka —19 by its ?.ddl Ch,, Zecret’ry nfl °rl, to ovt, 0 Vidhaiaso d a I n, 2, The £xcise orT’nssiner in -(arntaka, VokkaIicarssasob ‘31 c. Ohannra Circl, cxc ), 3, Tho Dy cornrrr, 1 ot Exis, BRooslore Urban District, Ben 1ore. 4 t fly ,Co rrr., Bey lore Uroar Jis 5, The Dr,orrr,, of ‘xise, Uharwad Dist, 6 TeDy,Coxr 5hsrwai Diotrict, 7,The v,Cosrrr,, Gad: District, B, The y Co r,, vera oi trlC DESOCND av r, (By SflS,’ujat a HCCP) lies oct ions are filed pro in q sh r1ocxuceO an1 to escsre tha tho notificztion vi-le nn xueG Itt l86iBB8 s illegal, pralim nay ‘se et son orri g r fc / cc c s ay t ar t ° l1 r’ I.. hi ft toi ft ft CD I to et ;a 0 i-’ ft CD to- to to to to’ a to ft CD C) fl) I) ft ft ft Q hi ft ii .a ID CD ft C) to to ft C) to ft to to to to hi CD tr hi 0 CD CD 0 ft 1) 0 CC) C) rF hi C hi Ct (to ‘to 3 C) ft ft CD t CD CD CD ft ft ‘— to CD El 0 ft • CD a r ft CD 0 * C ft ft C) ftftCD fttoft4hio CD ft a to * to CD ft 11) toO ftC)) ftftitoto ft CD 0 r’ C: C) CL 0 CD CD Q to hift<toflftft ft CD to ft ft ft ft CD CD ft to to CU fret CD ftCDto CDCD o CD • CD CD ‘— CD >4 to to CD ft ft DTftC)CD to toto CD ft CD to C) C) ft 0 to ft toatoftCl0Oct ftft C)) CD 0 ft CD C hi I 0 to CD ftCD CD ftft C to 1 ft ft to ft Cl hi hi to Cl ftft fttoC) ft ft CD to: CC) CD ft CD CD ft CD tothi OftftO CC) 1) C p 0 to ft CD CD hi ft to Cl >4 1 hi CO hi to CD to ft ft ft C CC) CD to ft CU to to hi -J C) CD ftCD?E to CD CD Cl) ft • Ca to to ft CD ft to CUCD TUrn ftfrfl) : CD ft to CD C)) ft ft CD 0 CD ftc) ft to ftftft CD CC) ft CD ft to IC to ft ft CD to CU. to to:: C) CD ft ft tC) ft ft: C) C)) C)) CC) ft 0 ft C) ft CD CD CD CD to C)) ft hi ft ft CD to: ft hi ft CD ft o ft CDCD hi ftCDOpj C) hi hi to C) 0 to 0 CD to: ft C ft Cc 0 ftC CD to to toCD CD 0 to CD ft ft to ft 0 I OftftftOtoCl ftto < CD CD ft hi CD to CU CD Oto hi 1111 C- CD ft a) ft C) ft a) C)) to o to- I hi ftCI) to CDftCD CICD to CD to ft 7 C)) to C) iT) ° ft fthift ftohitohift a- • to CC) to C- ft a C) CD C ft CC) Oat ft 0 ftC ft ft to CD ft hi 0 hi CD CC) hi CD. i-- hi hi Cl) 0 to CD to C) hi to 15 0-’ 0 CD .. CD hi CC) CUCtfta ftCCDtoCDCLCD C CD a to to ft ft CD fthiftk4l4ftto fttoCD. to a ft to ft to ft hi Cl to CD ftC . OCD Ohi C CD C ft CD ft CD ft 0 0 ft ft to OOftO Cl) OlD •. CD ft CD to ft to to CD to ftto ftCD COO ft ft ft a) C) ft I. (1 ft CD CD ft C) ID • C< CD ftC_H ft ft C CD C to hi 0 CU to :r’C) CD CDCo to ftC)) CD to ft 0) ft D.. CD 0 CD to to ft 0 CDtoChiCDOCDCDto o ft 0 C) 0 hi CU CD Cl) CD ft ft ft to C)) ft CC) CD hi to ft Cl) a hi to CD ft to ft CD CD I ID CD C 0 ft 0 iT) CDCD )l)ftCD ft to ft CU ED CD ft to CD to 0 hi <to ftft CU C to CD CD ft CD C) -c4 ft. ft ft CD CtrcftttO ft a) to CD CD 0 CD CD ft CDCDCDCD I 0 CD ft hi to ft C)C to CD 0 CC) ft ft to ft to CD ft to ft CD 0 g CD I — 21 a (i) for item (I) the following shall be substituted na.rrely. hhole sale Licence — (a)lf thE. Sale s within the limits of Munic 0/al Corooration having popula— hA ,5O, 000/—er yem tion more than 20 lakhs, (0/If the sale is in other areas, 3,73,000/— “ (ii) for item (2), the:. following shall be sub stituted, namely, — (2) Retail shop licence referred to n clause (2) of rule 3, inthe casc of,— 0/City Music thai Corpora tions having pupulation more than 20 iakhs, Rsth,12,000/— “ cb) Other Corporations. Cc) City Munic 0/al Council. 80, 000/— (d) Tcwn Municipal Ccuncil/ Town Panchajyat, 60 000/— ‘ Ce) Other areas 43,000/— (iii) for item (I) the follow ing shall be substituted, namely, — (4). Llcence to clubs in case of.— (a City M.nicial Coruora— tio2 areas having poupia— tion more than 20: laths, (b )Other areas, 30,000/— —22 — (iv) for item 7, the follow ing shall be suostituted namely, — ‘ (7 )Hotels and Boarding House Licence referred to in clause (7) of rule 3, ira the case of,— (a)Clty Municipal Corpora tion areas having popula tion more than2o l&ths thl,65,000/— oar years (b)Otbor Corporations l,42,50o/— car ve Cc ioaty a’runlcioa± Council j,I, Oh, UUO/ per yacr (d)Totin. Municipal Council/ Toan Pancbayat • Rs.90, 000/— per yearu (e)Other areas h67,soQC er year. (v)for item 9,the foilodincj snail Se suo.stituted, namely.— Refreshment from (Bar) Licecce in case of.— (a) City Municipal Corpora tion areas having popula tion more than 20 laths, Rs,l,35,000/— per yea (b)Otner City N.unicioal Corporation areas. m. I, 12 (c )C lip Municipal Council arecs, U Cd ‘Town Municinas Councal/ Town Panchayat, 67, 000/— (e)Otner areas. 50,000/— (w) for item 13,the following shall be sub stituted, namely,— “13 )Distrioutor licence 12 1,50, 000/— “ 3Substitution of Rule dA, sr rule 8r or ens seno rlOs tee foipo m; snals be ub itutdli, namely; 1* S. ‘S •Sê 55’ 3, It is submitted that, Rule 8 of the 1968 Rules requires payment of licence fee by the licensee for 5everal kinds of licence.a ar.d unde the orironc ie :5 incoroorateo flnc*r ISP 90 publish.ed in the Mysore Gazette dated 6—3—1969 the licence f.ee for the ehole sale licuor trade •was only Rs,5000/— per year if it was in res:pe . ct of one district and if toe area of ousiness aas more than one district an additloral f cc of ns,5.00/ was demo collected for eacn one of the district, Likewise, for the retail sales of I icwor toe ore sorbed licence fee was o, 10, 000/— per year ano ror rerreshment rc-oms, tne cicence fee mae presca inch at the rate of :c,lU, 000/. Subsequently the sa.id bules came. to be: amended by tin 1990 amendment Rules, under anich the licence f cc was enhanced to R.c,5Q,000/— per 3:flflarp in resent of CL—I licence: and an addi.— tional f cc of ls,500/— w.as collected n respect tea incas cornet on by the art Icul ar licence in more: than one d. istrict, Likewise, one lIcence fee for retail lluuor anon as well as refreshment rooms as the case may be were also increased and prescribino the licence fee on the: basis of the area such as city Corpora tion area, City tonic ipal area, tot/n cunHc’ini council — 24 area and other areas. £ver thereafter also the 1st respondent State Governizent enhanced the licence fee by way of anendnent to Rule 8 of the 1968 Rules. A chart showing the enhancement in the licence fees from j99Qa9j in respect of various licences in respect of corporation limits is herewith produced and marked as Annexure—A. It is further submitted that liquor menu- Lectured by the distilleries will have to pass through various form of licensees to reach the customers. The distilleries will manufacture the liquor and the distributor will have the licence to distribute the liquor produced oy various aistilleries to the wholesalers in the entire state of Karnataica. The vholesalers will procure the liquor from the distriøutor and then supply the same to the retailers hwing form CL—2 or to the Bars having licence in form CL-9 or to the Clubs having licence in form CL—7. The chart sztwing the flow of liquor in the &ate oflcernataka from manu facturer to tac customer is herewith produced and marked as Annexure-B. It is submitted that the enhancements periodically ma2e are very arbitrary and fanciful aithout regard to the. vied ility of cond.ucting such a business iith a such flume licence fee. Periodically Whenever such increases ann re made, *_fl5 licensees ii ave orote sted end oointed out the unreasonini eness. The Karnacana ine Mercnexts Association had.. also represented arK reoue sted Government to desist Kr. cm such increases of ice nra fees, but tin sane’ nct considered. nuixr snoing enneucement or urcence Fees rrcrn ‘‘ inn Limits having population less than 00 iaidns) Lice nce. fees in id, sales Tax be •osl dr—u 199o—9•i 75, 000/— 30 OOc/— 40, 000/— 1991—92 do 30,000/— 40,000/— 4.11 ISL —us is, 050/— is, 550/— as, uso/— dir 1993 —94 75, 000/— 40,. 000/— 40, 000/— NIl i9h..—95 7 ,0H00/— 4n.tn:5nn 4Q, 000/— P: sU,uUs,/— 50, 000/— .1996—97 290,000/— 50,000/— g,ggg,n NIl 1997—98 200, 000/— 50, 000/— 75, 000/— dii sOd • • Q. — — 90, 00/— an 12 , 0 00— Ecu iv ml sn.t to licence