iN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT JABALPUR (M.P) ?ETITIONERS 3. Mantralaya,BHOPAL. (M{P) 2. The Director Health Services, Government of Madhya Pradesh, Satpura Bhavan,BHOPAL (M.P) VERSUS Dr.Rajnikant Verma,S/o Late 1. RESPONFENTS OF 1999 State of Madhya Pradesh through the Secrétary,Public Health & Family Welfare Deptt. Shri Rajkishore Verma,aged about 48 Years,Asstt.Surgeon,Sardar Patel Hospital,BILASPUR. Dr.V.K.Verma,S/o Shri R.N‘Verma, Aestt. Surgeon,Sardar Patel Hospital,BILASPUR. Dr.A.P.Rai S/o Shri D.L.Rai, aged about 50 Years,Asstt.Surgeon, Sardar Patel Hospital,BILASPUR. Dr.G.L.Arora S/o Late Shri Narayan Singh,Aged about 50 Years,Asstt. Surgeon,Sardar Patel Hospital, BILAS?UR. Dr.N.K.Samdariya s/o Shri B.L. Samdariya,aged about 48 Years, Asstt.Surgeon,Sardar Patel Hospital BILASPUR. Br.(Smt) M.Samdariya w/o Dr.N.K. v/ / Samdariya,Aestt.Surgeon,Aged_abaut 46 years,Sardar Patel Hospital; Bilaspur. Dr.N.C.Thewsrani,aged about 50 year: Asstt.Surgeon,P.H.C,Ratanpur, BILASPUR. Dr.(Kum.) N.Baahra D/o Shri T.M. Bakhru,aged abo-&t 45 years,Asstt. Surgeon,Sardar Patel Hospital; BILASPUR. Dr.(5mt.) Nalini Singh w/o Dr.s.D. Singh,Asstt.Surgeon,P.H.C.Gaurella,fq BILASPUR, Dr.(Smt) Anjali onipde,w/o Shri A.V1Chipde,aged about 45 years Asstt.Surgeon,P.H.C. Gaurella, BILASPUR. y Dr.C.L.Chandrakar S/o Shri M.L. Chandrakar,aged about 50 years Asstt.Surgeon,P.H.C.,Gaurella, BILASPUR. Dr.S.K.Verma S/o Shri S.P.Verma, aged about 45 years,Asstt.Surgeon, P.H.C.,Bilha,BILAS?UR. Dr.(Smt) Sunita Verma,W/o Dr.S.K. Verma,aged about 35 years,Asstt. Surgeon,P;H.C.,Bilha,BILASPUR. Contd ... 2] — 2 14. 15. Dr.(Kum) G.B.Yadav D/o Late Shri P.N.Yadav,aged abpit 45 years, Asstt.Surgeon,Family Planning Training Centre,BILASPUR. 5 16. Dr.(Kum.) Sushila Rao D/o Shri P.C.Rao,aged about 48 years,Asst. Surgeon,Family Planning Training Centre,BILASPUR. 17. 5 18. @ Dr.R.P.Rathore,S/o Shri R.N. Rathore,aged about 35 years, Asstt.Surgeon,Leprosy Unit, Champa,BILASPUR. Dr. G.Prabhakar Naidu S/o Late Shri G.L.Naidu,age& about 45 years Asstt.Surgeon,F;H.C.,Pali, BILASPUR. Dr.Bishweshwar Ray S/o Late Shri S.Ray,aged about 50 Years,Asstt. Surgeon,Sardar Patel Hospital, BILASPUR. Dr.K.K.shuk1a,S/o Shri M.P.Shuk1a"” aged about 48 years,Asstt.Surgeon, Sardar Patel Hospital,BILASPUR. Dr.H.K.Dua,S/o Shri Deshraj Dua, aged about 46 years,Asstt.Surgeon, thrOugh Chief Medical & Health 0fficer,BILAS?UR. 19. § 20. 21. 22. 3 x3, 23. ‘524. I§25. Dr.P.K.Tiwari s/o Shri V.R.miwari, aged abou t 46 years,Asstt.Surgeon, Sardar Patel Hospital,BILASFUR. b ~V\ Dr.L.?.Bajaj S/o B.L.Bajaj,aged about 59 years,Retired Asatt. Surgeon,183,Ajay Nagar,BILASPUR. Dr.P.c.Gupta,s/o Shri P.L.Gupta, aged about 53 years,Asstt.Surgeon, Sardar Patel Hospital,BILAS?UR. Dr.A.v.ohipade s/o Shri V.N.Chipade, aged about 50 years,Asstt.Surgeon, through C.M.& H.0. BILASPUR. Dr.v.N.Dubey s/o Late Shri b.?. Debey aged about 4O years,Asstt. Surgeon,P.H.C., Pali,BILASPUR. Dr.M.a.Bhabha s/o Late Shri Bhabha aged about 46 years,Asstt.Surgeon, Mini P.H.C., Funga,SHAHDOL. Dr2G.Venkatash aged about 51 years Asstt.Surgeon,Health & Family Welfare Training Centre,BILASPUR. Dr.D.R.Singrol S/o Late Shri A.R. Singrol,aged about 59 years,Asstt. Surgeon,P.H.C,Bamhanidih,BILASPUR. Dr.V.P.Singh S/o Late ShriG.N. Singh,aged about 47 years,Asstt. Surgeon,P.H.C,Jayjaipur,BILASPUR. Dr.Ani1 Gupta, aged about 48 years, Asstt.Surgeon,Lormi,BILASPUR. Cont.... 3 t ;‘ (:Ei? _ 3 - 31. Dr.J.L.Shrivastava S/o Shri L.L. Shrivastava,aged about 46 years Asstt.Surgeon,P.H.C,Masturi, BILASPUR. ’ 32. Dr.M.C.Diwan,aged about 55 years, Asstt.Surgeon,P.H.C.,Takhatpur, BILASPUR. 33. M.P.State Administrative Tribunal. Principal Bench through the Registrar, JABALPUR. WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226/227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA. HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR (DIVISION BENCH) Coram: HON’BLE SHRI H.L. DATTU CJ & HON’BLE SHRI V.K. SHRIVASTAVA, J. WRIT PETITION NO. 4934 OF 1999 For the Resgondents : Shri Alok Bakshi, Advocate ORAL ORDER (Passed on 22"“ February, 2007) The following order of the Court was passed by H.L. Dattu CJ .- Respondents In O.A. No.3835/1993 are the writ petitioners in this writ petition. They are cailing in question the correctness or otherwise of the orders passed by the Madhya Pradesh State Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur. 2. The respondents in this writ petition were applicants in O.A.NO. 3835/1993. Their prayer in the said appiication was to direct the respondent therein to count their seniority from the date of initial ad- hoc appointment and not from the date of their confirmation. The State of MP, and another /, 4:: V5. Dr. Rajnikant Verma and others Present: For the Petitioners : , Shri Vinay Harit, Dy. Advocate Tribunal has disposed of the application and while doing so has observed as under: k f“ petition . “For the foregoing reasons this petition be and is hereby disposed of tinaiiy with the direction and the respondents shall scrutinize and verify the aforesaid memos from their own record and consider the case of the applicants in the light of the decision passed in OA No.486/89'in the case of MP. Raipatrit Adhikari San h vs. State of MP decided on 16.8.1992 and extend the benefit of the said decision to the applicants regarding the claim of their seniority,” 3. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order and directions issued by the Tribunal, the respondents in the said apptication have filed the writ 4. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners would submit cgket the orders passed by the Tribunal in O.A.No. 486/89 in the case of ' MP. Raigatrit Adhikari Sanqh Vs. State of MP. was the subject matter of Civil Appeal No. 5350/1993 before the Apex Court. lt is fuither submitted that the Apex Court has reversed the findings and the conclusion reached by the State Administrative Tribunal in O.A. No. 486/89. The assertion so made by learned counsel appearing for the petitioner is not disputed by learned counsel appearing for the respondents. in our opinion, at this stage what can be done byrus is only to direct the petitioners to consider memos said to have been filed by the respondents seeking certain benefits in accordance with law and keeping in view the observations made by the Apex Court in Civii Appeal No.5350/1993 decided on 13.8.1997 as expeditiousiy as possible, at any 5. rate, within six months from the date of receipt of a copy of this Court’s order. Ordered accordingly. Sdl- Chief Justice /" M %W \I.K. Shrivastar j: Judge Sdl- \