Pefitroners ^- S/o Stm' B.P. 71«»ari,R/o StnateKte.^^^^strfrt Bttaspur(GW)srtUs^(h) Arvind Mtshra W.f.fStNe. 1417 <rf 202% :1. ArtTiwarf 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10; 11. 12. 13. IKfehra, R/o Laduw.Govfc G Migtter Secondaiy School,BBin^lara, DiADvig(C^ Mannu Lal Shama Aged about 45 yeais, S/o Shri R.P. Shanna, Rfe Lecturer, Govt. HigherSeeondarySchoel, Machadoll, Tahsil Katghora, DisttKorta (C^ AjayDub^ Aged abQut35 years, Sto SbrtG.S. Dubey, R/oAssi^ant Teacher, Govt Prinwry Seheol, Risda (Bamhnidih), DisttJanKjeer-Clrampa(CG) ShrikantBh^at Aged about 39 years, S/o Shri Bha^A, reo Asst Teacher, Govt. Hlgher Secondary Sehool, BeNara, Distt Bilaspia- (GQ) TirithRamSahu Aged abwrt 41 yw^. S/o Shri S.R.Sahu, R/oAssit. Teacher, Govt. Primary Schort, Butena, Tahsil TOKdpur, E38stt Bitsspur (C©) Dr. KarUkRam Nirmalkar Aged about38 yeats. Ste Stiri D.R. Nlrmalkar, Wofisst Teacher, 6<nrt. His^er Secondauy School, Bartort, TahsUKIha.DlsttBnaspur (CG) Ram Kishm®ShtiWa Aged about44 years, S/o Shrf D.R. ShuMa. R/o Asd. Teadier, Watd No. 2, Cdtoge Road, Champa, Tahsil & DisttAmjgeer-Champa (CG) Mamfa^rswal Aged about 35y«»sWto Shri Na^n fi^rawat, R/o Asst Teacher, Govt. Higher Secontfaiy Scheol, Bi^gaon, Dtett Ra4»ur(CG) IndalLalKurre Aged dMtrt4S yesas, S/o Shri 6.P. Kurre, R/o^test. Taacher.Govfc PrimaiySchoot, Baiehha, Tahsit Patharia,U^BiteKpur<CG) AmarSingh Jangde Agedabout 42 ^ars, Sto Shri ChaRftem, R/o Asst. Teacher, Govt. Prima»ySchool, Bawli, Tahsil Rrtharia, DisttBnaspur (CG) RavikantBhosla Aged about41 yrars, S/o ShriG.R. B»»J&, R/o Asst Teaeher, Gwrt. I'rimaiy Scheol, SodW N, Tahsil Pattaria. DfettBilaspw(CG) Krishna Gopal Yadav fivged about48 ywrs, ^oShri P.R. Yattev, Wofi^t, Teachw, GovL Rimary School, Sih^a, Tahsil Padharia, DisttBilaspur (C<^- Respondents 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. RuUiman RaoBhcste Aged about 44 ywre, ®o5hrtS.R.Bhosto R/o AsstTeacher, Govfc Primaiy School, Sikteiha, Tahsil Pattaria, Distt Bilaspur (CG) GorelalSrivas Aged about40yeais, Sto Shrt Srivas. R/otestTeacher, Govt. Primary School, Madku, Tahsil Patharia, Distt Bitaspur (CG) Ashok Kumar Venaa Aged abt»it43ywns,S/ioShri fWtVemta R/oAsst Teacher, Govt Primary School, GangDwari TahsU PsrtiKia, Dl^t Bilrepur ff3G) KsdamaSh Verma Aged about 43 years, Ste Shri KC Venna, Wo test Teacher, Govt. PriBary ^*io<rf, Parsada, Tahsil Psffliaria, EMstt Bifa^aurff^ AnUSinghChhatri ^-, /^ed aboitf 43 yesus SA> Shri M.S. C tM, R/oAsstTeacher.Gevt. Prtn'ary Schoot.Bawtt, Tahsit Patharia. Dlstt Bilaspur CCG) Yogendra SinghChhafri Aged about 47 yeare, Sfo Shrt RN Ttedcw, R/o^BtTeaeher.Govt.PriRKiiySchoGl, Kakedl Tahsll PaUiaria, DisttBilaspur (CG) Ashdc Kumar Dubey Aged abotrt42 yeare, Sfo Shri M.L. Dubey, Wo As^Tesreher, GovL Primary Schoal, Piperload, Pattiaria, EXstt. Bllaspur (C<3) Ram Sii^h Thakur Aged about 42 ysars, S/o Shri A.S. Thakur R/o fisstTeacher, Gwt. PrirreMrySctwot, Sawa, Sargaon, DisttBilsspur (CG) Luv Kumar Swiwani Agedabotrt40yeais, S/oShri RC Swnitanl R/o Asst Twreher, Govt. Primary Schod, torchha Tahsil Patharia, Distt Bilaspur (CG) UmaRaniGu(<a ftged about 43 yeare.Wfe Shri SX. Gupla, R/oAsstTeacher, NagoiaosheshSchool, B, Tahsil & DisttBitaspur (CG). Versus :1. 2. 3. 4. Throi^h the Secrrtaiy DepaitomitofSGhool EdueaBon, D.K^S. BhaMm Mantrala^i Raipur (ChhatBs^irh) The Assistant CommissioneT, Tribal ©eparhnent Raipur DisWct Fteipur (CG) District EducattoB CTlteer Bilasptg Districtfillaspur ^G)_ The Direetor of Public Irefruetion, PNiston Bada, Raipw,(CG). __ —-—~^" i ^/ ./, l'- if ' Q '•Ijtf&s^ ^ ^- Slngte Bench: Hbn'ble Mr. JiKBce Satfeh K. ^nihotri. Ms. Sunita Jain, Advocate for the PetUionere. Mr. Sushil Dubey, Gowt. Achrocate forth®State/re^sondwite. ORDER (Passed on ttfe 12th (ta^ of tterch, ^07) IA.No. 193Sa007 This is an applteatron fw taking ckxwments on ncord. Theap(rficatton fe oKtered as ptas/wtfor. 1. The p^tioners a»e woridi^ as Assfetant TeacheR/Lecturera in tt» govemmenl school. In the courae of fceir services as Assidant TeachereA-ecturera, th®peBttonerNo. 1 has obtained B.Ed. ExanwnaUon Certificate m the year ^-84, the petiUonsr No. 2 has oblained B.Eit. ExaminaBon Certificate in the year 1990-81, the peBBonw No. 3 has obtained B.Ed. Examination (^rtffiMte In Vwyeai 04-36, ttie peBUenw No. 4 has obtained B.Ed. Examlnatton CeiBficate m the year 1995-96, the petifioner No. 5 hss oblained B.Ed. Exaaninsrtton CertiffcatB in ttie yew 94-95, the petittoner No. 6 tas oWained B.Ed. BKiminaton CertiBeate tn the month cS (^st-Nov' 96, the peBBoner No. 7 has (Atained B.Ed. ExaminaUon Certlficate in the year 93^4, the prttloner No. 8 has obteined B.Ed. Examiredlon CeiUficate in tte year 1990.81, flie pefiBoner No. 9 has obtained D.Ed ExaminaUon Certifteate m th®ywr 1999, ttw peUttonsr No. 10 hasobtained B.Ed. Exammatton Certfficateln th®inonth of Od-Nov'96, the petittoner No. 11 has otalahwi B.E<t. ExaminaBon Certificate in the month of Oct-Nov'96, fce prtfioner No. 12 ha»obtained B.Ed. Examination Certifreate in the year S^QA, the paGfioner No. 13 has oWalned B.Ed. ExaminaUon CerUficate In the Month <rf Od-Nov' 96, ttre peBtior^- No. 14 has obtained "m ttie year 93^4, the p^itlonw No. 15 has obteined B.Ed. Examinatton Certifksate in ttie y^ur 82-^, the p^torer No. 16 has <*tained B.Ed. ExaminaUon Catificate in the year ^^^/^'e;;:':'''^as°^S-*J3^ r'v9 4. 19^^4, the prtittoiwr No. 17 has oyaimd B.&t. ExamtofflUwt OBrtHfeala tn the year 93^4, the peBBoner No. 18 tes <rt>lahied B.Ed. Exaimrertian CeiWteate in the year 1990^'t, tt»|»flUenerfto. 19 ta®oWBrtnecl B.fid; Bamination CefWtesrte in theyeaF 1990-91, fce p^tkmw No. 20 has obtained B.Ed. Examinatton Cerfitfcato in ttie fflMitfa <rf OcUtov'96. the petifioner No.21 has obtained B.Ed. ExaRuraGon Ceriffieide in the monBi of Oct-NovW, the peGUoner No. 22 tas obtai'ned B.Ed. Bcaninafen Certiflcate tnthe yaar94-%and the peBBonerNo.23 hasoblained B.Ed. &amhTatton Certiflcate in theyearM-94on ttreirownogwnses. L«ffnedcounsel appearir^ for ttie peUtfonCTs submHs ttiat the qusdion involved, herein asto wh^her the teachere, who oMatned B.Edfl3.Ed. Examination Certificates oit their own e)q»nses, at8 ertitod to fewo advancelncrements. According to leamed rounsel for the paUfionws, the prtfioners ar» entitled to two advance incremente in view of e deciskw»rf thls Cotat in the case of Yashwant Kumar Bharadwaj Vs. Municipal Corporatton, Durg and another p006 09 MP*'R-C®9Q- TWs Court in the rase of Yashwant Kumar Bharadwaj Vs. Munidpat CorporaUon, Ding and another (Supra), came to the conclusion that the toachws, who had dkrtained B. Ed. /B.T.I. Examinrtion Certiflcate on their ownexpenses, are covered by the clreular dated 24.12.98 (Ann®<ure P/7) issued by the State GovemmentofMadhya Pradesh. In subsequent cases, i.e., Writ P^Bon (S.) No.4130 of 2005 (ecproft Kumar Vemia vs. Ttie State 6avt of Cftftattfefifarfr and »w»the»5and other connected matteis, declded by thte Court on 15-12-2008, put^ianl to the memo dated 28-1-1995, tssued by Uie Secretoty, Board of Secondary EducaUon, Bhopal and the prospertus af CNptwa in Education Examination, itwasclarifledthatthenomCTclatureoftheBasie Trafning Instituta, i.e., B.T.I. has been changed and renamed as Di|rfoma 6. in Educatfon, i.e., D.Ed. Accordingly, ths D.EA Certifcate hrtttors are atso cowred by the declsion in Wrtt Pefitton (S.) No.4130 <rf 20^ (SopesA Kamw Vwma vs. Tfte Sftrt»<S«wfeof Chftattfogarft ancf anothe»)(Supra). Leamed counsel fw th®pdWoners lurther submtts Uiat ttie tads and qu^ion <rf law involved in the present case are squarefy covered by decision <rf this Court in the case of Yashwairt imar BtKiradwaj Vs. Municipal Corporatitm, Durg and another (Supra), to which leamed counset appearing for the respondents Nrty concedes ands®reeswith theavwment made by leamed counsel appiwiringforthe prtiUowis. Accordlngly, the writ petBton is altowed in terms ofths onter passed in Uw case of Yashwant Kumar Bharadwraj Vs. Mwijcifal Ceiporaflon, Ourg and another (Supra), subject to verfcatton <tf thslact as to wh^ier e pefitioners have acciuired B.EdJD.Ed. Examin^ion CertBicates on their own eiq?enses as per the ciroutare dated 24.12.1998 & 1.3.1®^and further whettier they have bwn pakl two advance incraments or not. No orderastocoste. -—~—- Sd/- Satish K.Agnihotri Judge