''i ••} SII^t.qiT k-U4> WT3ITOT sb11<* ]E»ft SS.Bffs '3=5^ -^WWif, •3-Av'W, Rl<?>l+fy ^ir ^^...^A.ff0..:.....!.^^.....^ 200 an^W -qsra; (li°if-l«<<w) 1. '2.. Ma&( frQn' lau G@lii Botll Stati. Ktate 1- yun Vimlesli Baipai, yiin Arun Kao, Uovt. '2,. 'l'lus cnmuial appea) conviction and orcter.of sen.1 S.T. No. 258/1999 where|b5 Jagclalpur lias convicted V^t 366 aiid 376(2)(g) ofl.P.C. reacl wiUl yecUoii 34, unj Accused. Matiesn fias Deenl aiict accusea 1'ati lias beenl read wiui sectton 34 ot 1. P.1 uncler yecUon 3bb ancl 37tt to undergo K.l. tor tivo year; a. Uase ol Uie prosecu prosecutnx J-'.W. l lodged qil'4T<yl4l'rf 'RFRTf Tf 1^?t <f^^l< ^aiRrtran^r sfi, agea about ^»years, K/o BtuisJirani 0^r''tKT^Cit"iQr> <^.1l1tl^7atiOT» 5 sonii, aged about ^4 years, »/o siucau OcT'iination Culttv^tioii resiaent ot vmage Linagaon rouce in Kesbkal. Distt, Bflstar OhhaUisf?ar1b l ClitiattisgarJi idvocate, lor appeUants. idvocate, lor Uie State. is dn'ectecl against ttie jud.gm.ent ot lence dated. 6U1 Ueceinber, 2000 passed. in leamed Sessions Judge, Bastar at appeUant Maliesli under yecUous abo, nct appeUant No. '2 'l'aU luider secUon aby ler Kection 3bts aad 3/t>('^j(gj ot l.P.U. sentencea tor otlence under Mectton 3(3.3 sentencecl tor oaence und.er yecUou aoa J. to luiderso K.l. lor '2 years. t-'or ottence ['2)(gj ot I.i-'.U., ttiey Jiave been seuteucect and ten years respecnveJi". on, ui bnel, is Uiat on lH-4-iyyy, Uie report Bl rolice (J&oula VisJirampun ot :??T^ ^bfH -FS/59—8/2007 —30.000. y 311^1?ST h-U^ wn-sirar sbii<<) T5ET ^TRTCPT, ®Tf)y'l<o,fS|<vliy^< ^ ^.....^..a..ri.o..i^.6^ ^ av^f VISR Cqqf^gqsT) Poliee Htation KesJiKal ttis place ot pnest to watcli vii stie tiad gone out to ease juvenile accused. 1'ulsi <i(li Jiistice Boanl) took her 01 Uiree coiiuiuttea rape witti out post yicle. Bx, i-'-l, t&e station KestiKal vicle Bx. i- examuiatton to Koinal Uey Haliu exatruiiecl ner on iy com.pletuig uivesUgaUon, Jiidicial Magistrate Mrst L appeUaats were Uied by sections. 4. Uunng tnal, / wi-| pl-osecutiou and. ttiereatt^ recorclecl ui wnicti Uiev cle] ui ttie prosecuuon case unpiicatecl Decause ot 1] aaa FilauTam (U.w. '^) a^ 5. Leanied Messions ]uf parti^s, lias convicted anci| paragi^pli 1 ot Uie judgine}: tinlfi'fli iiicil'ifls'sttfSresH '^sfRRsn^i .1 on lb-4-yy w&eii stie tiad gone to Uie ;o wittl tnends (JliandnKa ancl Auita aacl lliersejt wiUi fier tnentls, appeUants ancl is tacing prosecuUon betore Juvenile Uieir stloiUcter towards tielct ancl aU Uie |tier. Atter registenag oaence ni Uie poUce |onence was toniiaUy registered in police V2. 'l'ne prosecutnx was sent tor nieaical 1-lospitai, KauKer wtiere Ur. (KDit.) Hemlata ij-^-iyyy ana gave report ot ux. i-'-y. Atter ;tiarge stieet was tuecl ui ttie (Joui-t ot iass, Konclagaon and atter committal, tte Uie Kessions Juctge uncler tlie aloresaicl aiesses in aU were examinea bv Uie stateinents ot accusect persons were uea Uie eviclence appeanng agamst Uieni jicl pleaaed t&at tliey liave been talsely osity. 'l'tiey also examinecl Mimuram (U.w. aetence winiesses. [ge atter Ueanng leamecl counsel tor t&e sentencecl Uie appeuants as nienuoned ui It. '^T^fe ^^ T, tRRRiIH —FS/59— 8/2007 —30.000. SINliNAURE SZ^-/ ^^ss^. /^.^:s-!s^ '^ (ti' '"'-_ Si- ''fy^,^Sp-.,^.-fiJ~±±}S;— • "Wg^'j sn^i v\ (ii-ii'ti W 31)^1 stillti TE? '^wi<fl<i, ®Tfl«'i<s,R^ii^y . . , ^^.fO.Nfl- IZS/o/ WtTPIT •SR1TO7•-•—•--"•-- •••"•--"-•-'•-l--^200 \ sn^?r wra ('pf^i?*?) TOIIW ^ito •ai^r t>. Lcamect counsel tor perusal ot tne stateiaent ot witness P.W. 2 Aiiita, it wothld *<• - .1 consenting part}7 as accorctifig me oaeiice ot rape was coiifmr auaost ao twar aact ui tlifi.t alarm even wGile sne was sne clid uot raise anv alasm. |the appeBaxit contended fhat from fhe |t&e prosecumx [f.W. i] aiid aUeged eye- De evident Uiat Uie prosecutnx was a aifig to Uie aueganons niade agamst t&eia, infmittecl Dy me t&ree accusect persons tor penocl, tne prosecumx aia not laise a}agged. by Uie accusea persons, Uien also /. (Jn Uie otaer fiaact, ttial Ironi tfie Kotsvan Kegis^ P-23 which tiave Been prov^d DU-UI ot t&e prosecutnx i^ mciclent, Uie prosecutnx w; was subjected to gang rap^ that she was bodilv liftedl resistaiice aiid au t&e Uiree witn ner agamst tier wislies| Uie Bvictence Act, absence o^ s. l liave Jieara leanied recori of tlie tdal Coiu't as 9. P.W. 5 C. Kerfeetta, Iij stateiaent Jias proved Uie tiuTJl (Jertilicate ot Kx. P-'^ai ^wfe'^Njw^ '^^f^ -<^^[< ^ aiRlT SRI^I ;anied coiuisel for tlie State contended ;r ot Ex. V-'2,'2. and tSuia CerttUcate ol Bx. by the Investigatuig Ofticer, UTie date of lo-/-iyH5 aiicl t&us OQ Uie date ol ieas aen 14 ysars oia. 'l'lie prosecuUix anct sfae lias aeposea belore Uie Court l.iy t&e appeuant MatiesJi aespite lier itools: lier to me lield and coinmittect rape ansl Uierelore, ui view ol section 1 l4A ol consent may be presuineci. c^>unsel tor ttie parties, l nave perusecl qiso ttie unpugnea jiiagment. ^vestigatuig ur&cer ui paragi^pn / ol tiis elitiT in Kotwan Kegister ot BX. ^-1;;^ aucl BI wlucfl aate ot butli ol tlie prosecutnx_ sTi^r.Tr Widi, WtI'SiR?! 'sKW .•Sil^ ^sef ^ffsrvW, OTfl'M'Ko, Rrti+iy __.....fe:.:....fi:........l..^.J$...Zo.J WCRTT gn^---r-;"-'-J----t-.^-<'-./-^..j....^ 200 siit^r TBW C^f^gsa) is snown as i£>-/-iyys>. 'r witness regai'ctuig eatnes docunients and faus t|bm establislied froni Uie puBIii yirtti (Jertmcate, Uie date o 'llierelore, it.is establisJiecl ot uicident was tess tn.an 1S\ |ie aetence nas not cross-examinect Uus |ot uie aate ot bn-ui IB me atoresaia lie eviclence ot Uus witness wlucli is clulv (; ctocuiaent Deuig Kotwan Kegister aiict jf birth of the prosecutrix is established. jiat the age of tbe prosecutrix at fhe tune Ivears. 10. Prosecutrix (P.w.l) h£| LAaiicliiKa aact Aaita Uact S out to ease liersett wiUi nei Maliesh bodiiy lifted her (^ accusea persons tooK. fier uisenuig clom. Her Inenc liowever Uie acciisecl pei^oc|; ancl all Uie tliree coiainittecl Uiere snoutuig, Uie accusec^ aaa slie nan-atea tne uiciaetit she has adiaitted that whed lier tnencls ctid uot go to 0411 yiie lui-Uier stated Uiat snel ot tier owu tneeiviu. II. P.W. 2 Ku. Anitawiiol examuiect wiUiout adnunisttrui <tll<llCT<i1l IMfii^ ft^t <Fa|^H ^7 siigq •SHI^T s categoncaUy statecl Uiat siie along witji one to \vatcn vicleo ana wJien stie came friends Anita aiid Chaadrika, appeUant sspite her resistaace aad all Gie mree towai-ds tieia ay gagguig lier inouui Dy .s CliaactnKa aiia Anita touowecl lier, s aia aot release fier aespite tneir request. rape one by oue. When her father came persons ued froni tliere after leaviag Iier to tier lattier. lli Uie cross-examuiatioa acciisecl were couuiiittuig rape wiui ner, or infonn aiiybodv about tlie iacident. dia not accoinpaay me accusea persons is also agea about lU-l^ 5rears, lias Deen nng ot oaUi. Hlie nas statecl uiat slie Jiaa "'wto ?bn-T ^IIITSBT. —FS/S9— 8/2007 —30,000. ..^-^ j '^ r78 V S ^i' /.^' ••»iri <^ S3iSESS' sn^i ^cf R-fi'* wiTsn^ignN; liStilitt T"r -^ww'if, w^ww, Kfftwy. . . C/r-ft.Na - 17:S/<» •wwir gmra;......................................................^ ^^ an^r^a^ (T3?f^3tr) t^nw ^itet a'li^r gone witn. ue prosscuttix ai were watciiuig Vitleo. Wlien t tnree accused persons tooJi toitowea Uieiu an.ci. tlieref. Uiet Uiey were staiitluig near tJ^e Uierealter Uie appeUants lett t nan'ated a&oyt tlie niciclent t< mat time slie clid not go to c anv alaiiu aacl sne dia not se( is ti-ue Uiat tlie concluct ot t calling anybocly wlule Uie pros is uluiatural ancl Uiere is evic any alarm, n.owever,. consider was agecl 14 years at me tu: Uiat rape was conuiuttecl DV Dv leamect couiisel tor t&e a consentiag pam7 caruiot t>e i 114A ot Uie Evidence Act. 1 coiTOtsoratea trorn ttie statenie prosecumx Katnu Kain (r.W, Uie prosecutnx nan-atecl abc aicident. i'2. 'l'tuis trom. ule eviaen< prosecution lias Deen aDle ^ii14F<n<fti '^ra^rf ^f,^T3^ <F<q^i< ^? siRn •aii^i .d (JtiaudnKa to Uie place wliere Uiey ley carae out n-oui Vicleo, at Uiat time, t&e prosecutnx towarcls taafc. y&e Diacte love wiUl Uie prosecutnx wtule; tEuiK. 'r&ev conUnued tor a liour EUICI liem. to meir respecuve liouses anct stte > lier uiotiier. K&e nas aaniitted. mat at all aity'oocly nor Uie prosecutnx raised :~.wtiat was clone wim Uie proseciltnx. It &e r.w. '2. ui not raisuig alarm or not eciltnx was clraggecl agauist &er wisGes .ence Uiat t&e prosecumx clid uot raise tng ttie age ot me prosecutnx mat slie le ot uiciclent and turUier consiclenag piree persons, Uie arguiueut aclvancecl ppeilauts ttiat Uie prosecutnx was a ^cceptecl particulai'ly in vie~w ol yection 'fie version ot Uie prosecutnx is ctuly W. ol Anita (F.W. 2) as atso tamer ot me a) anct Uliaramclas (f.'W. 4) to wliom. ut me u.icident uaniecliatelv atter Uie ;e ot tlie prosecutnx aad Anita, ttie to establisll ttie oHence agamst tlie 1;:^<%. /«9) 3TCT^TplTc^T, S^ftgrre, R|<?iiyy< ;:^i 3ii^i.'wf?;ii?ff ?raT3iK5T *t|i<* !"-y . {"'v^N.e,- liS/o, W^n- gTqj^---"^----'-'--'"^"--'-^^.^.'^ 200 ait^wra; (ipf^w) appellantsaa.cl the tuiduig the appeiiaats as nientio^ied availa&le on recoKl. 13. In Uie result, fB.e De disiuissecl aad it iS Jiei <^l'4f(v1'4T'f ITPT^ff "^f fel3t ^it-^K ^? sifaH sii^r ot ttie mal coiut couvictnig ana senteucuig aDove is ui accordaiice witli Uie eviaence ppeal being clevoid. ol sutistan.ee deserves to ;ebv disinissed.—- ~~ Sd/- j DHIRENDRA MISHRA | Judge |