^w.. fflGH COUBT OF CHHATT?SGAB_H AT BTLASPTR? V»'NtFcuiioii(S)No,1730of20^ Dr. R.K. Ramteke, S/o Late S.R. Ramteke, aged about 48 years, working as a Medical Officer, Posted at the Comnw-nity Hea'th Centre, Dongargaor^ Distt. Rajnaiidgaon (CG) pennanent resident of Mohan Nagar, Ward No. 13, N<?ar B-.aiiway Lines, Durg, Tahsi! &. Distt. Diirg (CG). 17ERSTJS • T.NTS : 1. State of Ciihattiggarb Through the Secretary, Departmeiit of Health, Govt. ofChhattisgarh, DKS Bhawan, Raipur (CG). 2. State of Madhya Pradesli, Tlirougli the Secretary, Department of Health, Govt. of Madhya Pradesh, Secretariat, Bhopal (MP). 3. Direetorate of Health Services Chhattisgarh, Through the Director, Raipur (CG). C%7Rn' PETmON TJNDER ARTICU 226 OF THE CONSTTTUTION OF INDIA) (SB: Hon'ble Mr. Satish K. Aeirihotn. J.) Shri Ravindra Agrawal, Advocafs for the petitionei". Shl'i Satish Gupia, Guvt. Advuuale fot 'the State/respondent No. 1 & 3. ORALORBER (Passed oii tiiis 26tt ofMareii, 20<%) 1. T2ie petitioner, workiiig as Medica' OfBcer in the Comniunity Health Centre, Dongat^aon, District Rajnandgaon (CG), has filed this petition. 2. The brieffacte, in nutshell are that according to leamed coinisel appearing for t!ie petitioner, the pefitioner was placed iinder suspension on 06.08.91 (Ai-uiexiire P/3). Being aggrieved, the petitioner preferred an applicafion before the State Adniinigtrative Tribuaal af Jabalpur (for short the SAT), vvhich was numbered as O.A. No. 254/93. The said app'ication was disposed of vnih a direction to the r€is«?oi'ld^iits fat that tinie State of M^dhva Pradc'shl1 to p?.v siibsistctnc^ ailowafice to the petitioF'CT <'!iinng the s1I$per'sion period ^nd the salar^' frotn the date he is deemed to have been resumed duties on the expiry of 90 days, for fai!"re ofissuea charge sheet within the stipulafed tinie, as provided under flie Rules. 3. It^ is a case of the petitioaer that pursiiant to the order of the SAT dated 04.06.1993, no payinent of salary h-as beefa made to fhe petitioner. It is farther • s^ ^s^ Bl Bl 1 ?i!'::3 r' w ER® Ksw wss: KK 8{iqM '^qSu jspusjjns jo uopUBqB 01 }u3tuj [Bn^oe s> lu&map [Bipisssii sip JSAIBM m }Bq+ m pddo^ss UIO^ put}SIp Sl JSAXi^ pUB| 8lp lyiAl ulu SABtj oi UMoqs sq ppioo S}UBUS^ B''j[njj, SB sp.reipuuB sip }Bajt o^ y.iGusAOo ou pUB 'uiiq o^ paj.jsjsirej} SBM puB( siy. ja'Qu ^iunpoddo jsdojd sip fe 'fins ps|y }U3puodssj }&ig sq^L 'Atiinqjoddo jsdojd 8tp ^e )i]Su B jo UOIJ-ISSSB sip tapjBsjoj sq^ siiBaui y '.iqSu ipnsjo piaiutjsinbuipj sipjo aouwsjin si;} Stuej-iBM SB pnpuoo ipns jo ^qSu uMoiq BJO yt&uii;s>nbuipj jBUOituatU> pUB .iCi8ti>n{OA e sq }snui ajaip 'fS^ si JSArb'aa. 10 tusiusp jBiiuasss aijj^ ' 12,1, •w : jspan SB psAjssqo 'JSAreAijo SOuSOSSKlbOBjO SSjdpuud •T1 m ir>TE>S'"<T TV1T*A '^/^A^OT /^-rt-'-T^ -\Tyt-? ^/*<~i^ T/»Tr(rtTTiE* •nTn» fv^C'wrm'vrr •mr>TTt'»*AciTrT ^+<9^ ^^w^. ^+MXi. '(.0|?^i VOOOl/* Q.iV "'''b4 T '"7*-*^^i;* ^F^<-< •o^'>~*</i^<*t*'^ ^^tAti^i.ijir^ 'SA P'PQ Mpirei{3 IISBAOJJ jc> j&yeui yijj. ui pnoQ aiusjarig ajCjiUOH si.LL •sst^uoipnB siy. ajc-jsq suoi^Hsssjdsj (BJSASS apBui s'eq jsiioitipd &4} yeip tdyoxa 'i>ot}i}ad aip Suijg ui App pire ssip.tej urejdxs o^ pai>ej seij jsuoitipd sip IISI[M A[JB(riOI)JEd 'SJBSA CI JO SSdti; B WQV psure^is^o sq loiroeo uoi+ijsd siiji 'P]Sp jo jSAreM jo soasosaniboB jo sa[dpuud p8{Bas {(SA 3~aiA\dd~e 'Ssui 'fi s'e yeq} ag 'y •JSpJO SlpJO SlHSSBd 0( JOud panSSl ApBSJjB SBM ^ssqs aSjeip sij^ }eqt ssvsddv 'fi ssneosq auop ^oa SE'A souBijdiuoo sip teip ino apeui iissq sei; asBO ou 'sSiiipesid sijyo psiuad sjeq UQ 83uB>idiuc>3 ou SBAI SJSlpji ![J,VS ^t-P A^I p5>SSyu JypJO Q^ju SOUK'ijduiOO §Ui:^^Sj;0 AyM 9tp Ui ylUOO ^OU p^nOM SUOI^^uyS9J<JyJJO ^l«[t^ "Sy^uOlpil'y 9t|4. O^ &pylU yJy/^». sUOi^yuiSS^jdsj [BJ8A8S qonoqi puusd Suoj ~B quiis joj isd'ib tus:i s'taj jauOi+i^su Si.LL ^ 'IVS SII»A4£66i'90't'0PatBP japjo jo SuissBd wye 4sai[S ySjeip puooss snssi o^ Jsdojd f.ou si '^ 'sjujsjap '{,661'90't'O °t -io"d paiissi SBAI ^ssijs sSjeqo aiy. 'jsuoi^sd sq^ joj guuesudB psunoo psiUBS] Aq speiu uoissniiqns aip pue s3uipi?8[d jsd SB 'Ajpsftiuipv •uoisusdsns jo spp sip jo sA^p 06 Jyffe AJBIBS pspsdxg [{i)s jsuopipd sijj^ •y 'SsSaBlp alp jjii SuiAUSp '£66160 9Z ps+Bp A[UW s>t( lOAiS SBI{ jaiio>t>}ad aijj^ '(y/d 3-*iixsia{y)266i 60 91 uo -isuoi}'pd sij^ 0} fiiss S8M 9u.WS 3Vy. pUB Z66{ £011 uo p314s s§j84.3 pa'nssi luspuodssj 8ip pip papjs ^fSfsaa^ //^^ j '>^szs^ '•3tSSS<S"i ESaIiu in estoppel such intent is inimaterial. The neeessary condition is the detriment ofthe otlier party by the conduct of one estopped. An estoppel may result though the party estopped did not intend to lose any existmi right. Thus voluiitary choice is the essence of waiver for wliich there must liave cxist^ci an opporti^nity fbr a choiec between tlw Fslinquishsiient and the con.fbmi€lntofthe ri^it in q'je^tion." 7. In view ofthe above well settlcd priticiple of iaw siid applyilig on the facts ofthe case, the petition stands disniissed, sriimiarily. Sd/- .. _ :^y ^s..