E? @ T l. State f Chhattisgarh, Through: The Secretary, r Schedule Caste and Schedule Tribe Development epartment, l D D.K.s Bhawan Rajpur (c.G.) f ‘ The Commissioner, ” ‘ Tribal Development Department, ; y Raipur District Raipur (C.G.) The Collector, Korba Districorba (C.G.) tK The Assistant Commissioner, k Tribé’d Development Department, District Korba (C.G.) The Principal, Government Higher Secondary schooi, Bhajsma, District Korba i (cc) WRIT PETITION N0.)0F 2006 PETITIONE I THE HIGH COURT O CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR. N F 3§N€§LE BENm KS3S;’€ R : D.K. Patel, aged about 37 years, y S/o Late G.P. Patel, Lecture? Chemistry, Posted at Government Higher Secondary School, Bhaisma, District Korba (C.G.) VERSUS RESPONDENS o “ RIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR ISSUANCE OF AN APPROPRIATE WRIT IN THE NATURE OF MANDAMUS CERTIORARI ETC. OR DIRECTION ORDER IN THE LIKE NATURE ETC. »/__’__._‘__,_‘ ’@ W XI—HC-78 3am, m, W3? \@ mm oo............o.... 90.0H{ 200 Wm<W> ‘ mwm WWEWW %31f?a11e11%¥1 : 3’54?/2006. I Shri Rajesh Pandey, Advoca Shri’ Sumesh Bajaj, vaovemmen'r Advecm‘e for fraa I ,hespbndenfs/S?d?e on navahte cop Heard V Th‘e maih‘ grievmicé fais’ed‘ cammon §ssue is invaive‘d in fhesz disposad of by ‘z'his csmmm oréer, L 3y fhase pe'misns, ?h2 pa‘ri in starious Higher Secendary Schm Chha/isgar‘n, have questioned 1": #rajqsfer arder éafed 7.?.2Q0é of wider $12606 WP. Nos. 3523i209é, 3524/2906, 352’52/2606, 352é/290é, i’ios'ier-s, who om: workmg as Lac-mm!" )is of fhe Disfricf Korbo of Smfe of 3a iagali‘i’y & correcfness of fheir {Annexure P—l} ‘éssued under ‘Hae s’igm’rure Secremr ‘ Séhwukd Casw & Schedaied Tr; I ”The grounds a? chaiieng, m‘ fh§s crdzn as raised by {ha pefifiériérs, aré %u? #332 5am? ry ar fhe Untier Sacremry has m: jurisa’icfion‘ fo’pass T'rié impugna Transfer arder, as fhe Ccunsemng YU by fha pefi‘?ioners is cemmon and pe‘i‘ifions, therefore, They are being y, 6overnment of Chha‘ffisgarh,‘ Deveiopmem Deparfmen‘i', Raipur. P.T.O. re for The pa?i?ioners. 3527/2006’ 3528/2086, 3§2 ?/2OGé, 3539/2806, 3§3U2006, 3533/2006; 3534/2006, 353 ?/2G06, 354D/20G6, ' 354i/2006, 3542/2G06, 3543/2606, 354 M2006; 3545/2006, 3546/2006, XI—HC-78 EW,WW,%W o . roooo.o.o.ooo..o¢oo¢¢o WW (W) mam WW§WW ,mwm “o?— > WWW agwm ~ Commi??ee is empowereci 1‘9 issue frmsfar nrders Lancier Tha Qationaiizafion' Sakema dawn? i.é.2006, ‘rherefere, 'khe: impugnea‘ fransfer order issued by msgcndenf Ne‘i is wi‘mouf jurisd3c?ian anc§ J nuliify m firm eyes 9f hw‘ The Sink Gvvemmew? has aéready deiagafed ‘fhe pawers of fmnsferring ‘rhe machers 4m caunse§§§ng commi‘rfea cwmfi‘Ma‘ed a? fhe 5mm km? unéer ’rhe ra‘a‘iamiizwion safaeme dm'ad 1.6.2§Gé cmd’ ?!w Empugned fransfer arder has baen issued in fiagmm' vioim‘ian of fiqe. provisians confained in Paras 5 & 6 9f f‘ms mfiomiizafion scheme. Perusai a”? impugned order Annexure‘ P—1 whereby fhe peTi‘rioners have been Transferrezi as aiso 1’?3e mfiemiizdtion scheme dafed 1.6.ZX396 shaws ‘a‘ha? The pe?§?ians are miscsmeived, fer ‘rhe reesens ‘i'her? ’i'he impugned erdeyunrje‘r w§qéch We pe‘ritionere have been Transferred has been passed m admims‘rmfive greuees. This erder has not been passed under fhe m‘fiandkafbn scheme eefed 1.6.2006 and ‘i'he same has been p sed‘by fee Governmen"; in. exercise cf generai gawers ‘m Transfer 31‘s mpisyees. Peruse! e35 rafiamiizaiieh cheme a‘efed 1.5:.2G0é shvws fha‘t ‘ where on accoan"; m‘ fransfersA p mafions & re%iremen?s f‘ne numbers of teachers have become §rmfia a! in verieus schcais Eoeking Ti» the numbers sf s‘i'ueenTs Le. where an accoun? e1? abave menf§one§ reasens §n we schee! numbers cf feache have become !ess 3 a.” 2 er where P.T.O. XI-HC—78 H W , W , W o o....oo..o...o¢‘.oo.‘o W .\ Wm (WW) WWW WW§WW wmm r ’ mwm ,—'Z~— ’ ‘%3T%qan%¥r: fhe mmbers 01" ‘feachers havé cee<§ed more Than ‘rhe reqaired numbars 0f faachars, in ma? § se fha cancarned deparfmwi as ariwgugee‘ irx 'rhe scheme] w§§i con ?ifu1’e a counseilirxg commi‘i’fae md 3f?er coHacTMg infarma‘?§o& fr .. fhe various h§g§qer secamdm‘y schoois or miédie sc§1oels w primary schoois, fhe goncemed cemwwee skai! m?iamlizz fhe nu bars m‘ fe&cher5§ "an Each scémds ioqking f0 ‘?ha numbers 0f Smden s. I? has been envisageci *rhaf ‘rhe mmmi‘a‘fee is To ensure fha? §n no imary schoci remain less ifhtm Two *euchers, i2”: case cf middie scho i nof iess fhan fhhee feachers, iv, ‘case of high schaol n9? less fhan ur ‘reachers and in case of higher secondary schoe? no? iess fhan s§x aac§1era :43 has been yyzen‘fimeé ea liar ?hm fhe impugngé oréer has beea passed unaier ‘fhe ‘a§mims‘h va pawers a? ‘ihe Ewemman? {m adminis?m?ive groun§s and 1411's rder has m?hing #9 w wii+a f§1a ‘ “; m‘rianaiizafEon scheme dafed 1.6. 096. The C~ovemmen+ is Qiways £oyees aw ?§1e §n?méuc?§en of rc'rmadizai'ian gcheme does mi" m‘e any bar a‘?m? fhe cancemed deparfmem‘ of ‘rhe 5?:11'2 €ove nT is not empowered fa Transfer“ H’s washers in 'z'he adminis‘rrmiaie exigency o'v in The pubiic inferesf. ‘fv‘screovzr, a barz perusai of The mions shows fha? i? has no? bean mamieneii in fine pe‘réfians fhaf y ?’nese a‘r-wisfers in a par?icuiar Jg‘her sacnradary schooi numbers cf #eachers has bacome iess z‘i'mn P.T.O. x o r o j A m ampewerzd m ';'mns%ar i?s e a m x a p ‘ XI—HC-78 m WW,W, Wat o mor.oo..o..ooooo.._§“.ajg E 200 mm (W) WWW’ WWW WW§WW 11,, ' ‘ meme ~ w machers w numbers éf i'eachers have bars of swdems. Therefcrz, fha petifions afainabia for fhe reasons :i'haiw ms been passed under fhe generai pawers 'o Transfer Es empbyees on adminis?mir§ve )1? éaeen passed under ‘rh‘a said schema i2. a dafe& 1.6.2066. ; no? been uHeged fhaf an accounf cf These ie enunciafed in fae mTicnaHzcfion ssheme an accsun? of These fransfers fhe number's of Teacher‘s havz b¢coma less f‘nan ‘rhe required numbers of ‘aféana5iza?i¢n sakeme or have exceeded Ea The areas mg Gperc cmfmi’y w The mfiami§2$ion SChemz. 1.é.2006 am? of Governmen'a‘ are diffe Hewever, 5‘? any sud RoS :3“ x 0‘? the Governmen? ‘ grouna‘ and 1? has n4 mfiom§izef§on schem (2) m fhe pew‘i‘rions if ha: fmnsfer-s The princip kes been viloiafed Le. “.‘rivye required numbers of exceeded iookin‘g fa 1'he num m? 'i'he pe‘rifisners are no? mail 1’1) *ré'ze onier impugned ya Ll) xa... peu‘itiaeers, Then fhey Wm be aui’hari‘ry concerned. In View m‘ The dam/e, T? Consequemiy, M.{W.)P. G M - 1"ion 9f ‘r‘ne m‘féomiizai‘ion scheme da‘reé genera? pawers a‘f fransfer‘ of 51‘a?e . rent : ins‘mnce carries “2'0 fhe ncfice 9f fke at §§Eerfy Ta make a regresen‘mfien $5 f’ne :e pe?§?ions sfané dism§sseii fer gram a? stay aisc swnds dismissed. Sdl— L.C. Bhadoo Judge Vggé Teachers under 1+:e any par?icuinr sehesi