r7 s C^ (3^ ^ M i%i 'OK.W € <L» IN THE HIGHCOURTOFCHHATTISGARHATBIIASRUR W.P.(C)No. of 2008 5.S3V\ ^- PEtmONER VERSUS RESPQNOENT ^y^ ^^/ r-^"" <p Ku. Sangeeta, aged about 30 Years, Daughter of Ramclhyan Ram, Resident of Village Aama Kherwa, Manendragarh, Distt. Korea (Chhattisgarh) The State of Chhattisgarh Through its Secretary , Department of ST & SC & Social welfare Mantralaya, D.K.S. Bhavan Raipur- (Chhattisgarh) sff ^^^ <^>^ y^ G^ ^w. 3. 4. Jaati Pl-aman Patra Uchha Sta riya Chhanbin Sarniti Th. Its director Pt. Ravishankar Shukla Uhiversity Prernises Raipur (Chhattisgarh) Additional Collector, Mahendragarh, District-Korea CChrtattisgarh) The Sub- Divisional Officer (Revenue), Manendragarh, District- Korea (Chhatfisgarh) B w WRIT PETrriON UNDER ARTICLE 226/227 OF THE CONSTlTUTION OF iNDIA ^.- ifl HIGH COURTOF CHHATTISGARH AT Bl^ASPUR WRTT PETmONCCyNO. 2524 OF 2008 s; Petitioner Ku. Sangeeta ; Versus Respondents The State ofChhattisgarh & Others . WRTT PETITIQNUNDERARTICLE 226/227 OF THE CONSTTTUTtON QFINDIA (SB: Hon'bleMr. SatishK.Agmhotri,J.) •^sserst- \'iS Shri Saurabh Shanna, Advocate for the petitioner. Shri N.N.Roy, Pariel Lawyer fbrthe State/respondents. ORDERrQRAL) (Passed on 27'" day ofJuly,2010) 1. Challenge in this petition is to the orderdated 27/2/2008 (Annexure P-11) passed by the High Power Caste Scrutmy Committee (for short "fte Committee") whereby the caste certificate graiited by .3/5/2007 was cancelled on the ground fhat the ancestors offlie petitioner were Scheduled Tribe inttie State ofBihar priorto 10/8/1950. Thus, they are not |entMedto grant ofthe soeialstatus certificate in the State of Cyiattisgarh, but in the StateofBihar. Further,0rderdated 14/6/2007 (Annexure P-7) whereby the pei-manent caste certificate dated 3/5/2007- was cancelled by fhe Sub Divisional OfBcer ©,Manendragarh, District Koriya ((2.0.). 2. The facts,in nutshell, as projected by the petifioner, are that the petitioner was granted permanent caste certificate by the competent officer i.e. Sub Divisional OfGcer ©,Manendragarh, District Koriya, holding that the petitioner as "Raidas" as Scheduled Gaste community. Thereafter, the Siib Divisional QfBcer exercisingthe suo moto power eancelled the permanent caste certificate granted earlier. Thereafter, the petitioner preferred an appeal to the Collector, Districf Koriya aiid the Collector by order dated 23/7(2007 (Annexure P-9) refeFred thedispute to the Committee for •verification ofthe genuinehess ofthe caste and caste certificate issued in respect ofthe petitioner. ' ~ 3. Shri Sharma, leamed couasel appearing for the petitionei- submits that contrary to the directions issued by the Supreme Courtin the| matter of Kumari Madhuri Patil and another ys. Addl. Ccmwmssioner, Tribal Fl sl ^B ^ •w. uu" gV>T«IspBi -/PS'i:^:iw / •S)SOO 0}SB JSpJO oj\{ •SAfiqB ps^oipui yiapcs sq^ o} psMO[(B si uoiirpd -IUM sip }(nsai sqi u[ •S}U3IU UMO Stl UO pItB MBI IpIM SOItBpJOOOB HI pSSSBd 9q AlU JSpJO '(.wdns) ^D^ u»ig7E^zfflw)ry<ur:pno3SiB^ lioipsjip sip q^MA soitBp-toaoB m jsiioi^sd sip 01 gmjBSq jo A}iun)joddo IIB SmpjojjB JsgB puBiyodsj gqijo Xdoo B ipiM SUO{B jeuoitTpd sip o^ sopoujo S&GIS sip moj}: psssojd pi.ssnHUiuo^ sipp^pSAJSSsj si Apsqi( 'jSASMOg -psqsBnb si jspjo psugndiui si^ 'snqj. 'psiBpiA si sures sq^ 'qons se 'puB •)J"03 sius-i(lnS sltl jo uoips.np sip 0} Aie^uoo si ssniiUujoo sipjo §OOZ/Z/^Z PS1BP IIO!SPSP sip 'snqj, •ssniunuoo sip Aq psniiuqns }jodai sij} a). S.]d3fot jsuopiisd si^ oi. psnssi SBM soitoussn'BO MpqsB iBqipspsgsjsjsqMOHSiti 'JSASMOJJ •suoi^pusmiuogsj UIBIJSO spBin s^q pUB so®i3sip. psiisiA scq ps-ftiKituoo Aiitlbus UB leift sjesdd®ti .'goOZ/Z/Z.Z PatBP •I8P-10 slff jo lEsiusd uo •ssscojo&isqronu ussiBuin ro suii} 0} suti} uio.i): jJtiOQ siusjdng sqi Aq psnssi aorpsjip -isd SB M'B{ q}TM soirepjoooB m gpiiou qssj}: B snssi pire A):U8A o^psniuusd sq 4BUI S3nroituo3 sip 'snqj, -tijids pue jsns( s^i m p3MO((oj ussq pa wq^idns){i}pcf unifpOf^uEiuinyva'fino^) siusjdns sq). Xq psnssi uoipsjip siptpiR sipuqns s^g sip joj psunoo psutBSj 'Aog uqg °PUBI{ J3IIlc> SIB U0 •AtUoqinBtuspduiQO 3ipAqps')ire.i88}E3ig:i}jsos^e3Sip3mp3UB3 jo jspjo 3fy. Smssred sjojsq ssniromoo sq}. Aq psnssi ussq SBq S3i}ou jsqio XUB jou 'soipu ssnBs Moqs Jsiprau }JQdaJjo siseq sq^ uo 'pueq uo sseo sqi miBip sinuqns ixsu jsuoi)i)sd sqi joj guuBsdde psunoo psujBs'j •uoimiisui sip g» pesil sip i|3nojqi—iopisiusgp3|AM)iDpB ipiA ^sod p&isisiSsj aip. Xq 3}BpTpue3 sift Q} yodai sip jo .Xdoo'B gui^ddns sopou sstreo Moqs Aeu B snssi p[noqs psiusouoo JopsjiQ sip 'smnusg iou si jsuoi^ipd sqt JQ sri)»(s ppos sift }Bip. panqj sr^i 'aoipsdsin uo ji '^eip: pspsjjp A(JB3]p si }i iiojsqM '9 •y f^xsd (yva t]. •essd m ^aiffo puo ttt9uid0i9A9(j -~:-z-";:;!:: • •' •; • TfZ 30S 9 (6661) r •L •°s ,r3%.i~1"; 2g^I'^q s'i'iiiif .,1 i]