422 71 17AONo879 of 2005 1 S 12 IN THE HlGll COURT Ol PlJNIAB AND IIARYANA AT CI1AND1GARI1 IAO No79 of 2005 lOatcof dccision 2020 10 1 C 0 Raj Bharti and another 0 Appcllants I C5 versus I Z Ram Rattan and othcrs Respondcn tse C I FAO No604 of 2005 08 Ncclam Rani and othcrs Vm3 Z Appellantse Clm versus Ram Ratlan and othcrs Respondcntse FAO No1744 of 2005 Jamero Devi and othcrs AppcllilnlSe versus Rltm Rattan and othcrs Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 423 1AO No879 of 2005 2 1 49b 11 Rcspondcnts FAO Nol131 of 2005 Shanti Devi and othcrs 1 Appellants versus 0 C I Ram Rattan and others C5 Rcspondene FAO Noe2584 of 2005 Z Swarnu Ram and another r AppellalltSe I 08 versus 7 Ram Rattan and others Z FAO No2585 of 2005 llarshani Devi and othcrs Appellanls versus Ram Rattan and othcrs Respondcntse PrCSCilt Mr lCSOhanora Advociite Iir the iil lA09 No879 of 2005 All Vikas AwasthyAdvocatc for thc appcIIants inlAO No879 of 2005 in lAO Nos2584 and 2585 of 2005 Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 424 FAO No879 of 2005 3 ee tvlr R13udhwar Advocatc lIr the in lAO N02131 of 2005 Mr Saurabh13ajajAdvocatc for Mr Kaushik Advocatc or thc appcllaills in 1AO No604 0 1 2005 Mr SiilghWasu SrAG l laryana ln 11cascs Mr 1IarshAggarwalAdlocatc lor Nc4 in all cascs 1 Q KCPURle Je 0 13ythis coininon ordcr l inlcnd tcl dislooscof I7AO No879 tIf 0 2005 titled as Raj Bharti and anothcr vse Ram Ilattan and others FAO I 0 No604 of 2005 titlcd as Neclam Rani and others vs Ram Rattan and I othcrs FAO No1744 of 2005 tithd as Jamcnl Devi and othcrs vs Z Ram Rattan and others FAO No2131 0l 2005 tillcd as Raj Bharti tr and others vs Ram Rattan and 1Ithers FAO Noe2484 01 211115titled as Swarnu Ram and others vse Ra nl Ilatt an antl IIlhe rs a nd FAO 08 No585 of 2005 titled as Darshani Devi and othcrs vs Ram Rattan and oo V7 others for cnhanccnlent as all thcseappcalsarisc fronllhc sanlc award Z 1Ir CcItlVCnlcllcefacts arc bcingtakcn li0111I7AI NtI879 cf 211115 titlecl Qm as Raj Bharti and another vs Ram Rattan and othcrse his is an appcalbythc claimanlslaj13hartiand Siiruti llinor daughterof Iatc Shri Sunil Kunlarl for cnllanccnlcnt tlf lhc conlpcnsation awardcd by lllc Motor Accident CItinls iillttlal Ilidc AwaicI clalcd 1122004 1hc casc of thc clailllants in bricf is thiil on 19 02003 al about 600 jm dcccascclSuilil Ktitnar olollgwilh ClurdecpSinghand othcrs Ivas 8Olllg froln Pijolitowards KaulapurIll a lllrccvheclcr and Ivhcn thc threc Whcclcr rcaCllcdon Sarswati bridgcthcn a busbcaringrcgislralionNoliR Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 425 e 1 IAO No879 of 2005 4 Il 37540 of l laryanaRoadwaysKurukshctra 10cpotbcing drivcn by No l rashlyand llegligcntlycalllc Iroill Shahbad sidc and while COllllng on tllc wrcIllgsidc ofthc road hit tllc thrccNhcclcr duc to wllcll all the occupailtsof thrccvllccler rcceivcd injuricsaild sonlc of thcnl dicd at 1 thc spot It has bccn allcgcdthal lhc accidcnt look placcduc lo rash and ncgligcnldriving of thc said bus Iy rcspondcntNo 1 who was also 0 C challancd by thc policc Il hils bccn fiIrlllcr allcgcdthat thc bLtsW21SOlIVilcd I C5 by I IaryanaRoadwaysand insurcd vilh Nalional Illslitiiilcc Cctllj7ailyItd I Clainl Pctition no 115 of 2003 has bccn Illcd by thc clailnants Z for a ofRs251ac on accounl ofdcath ofSuilil Kuillar allcging V2 lhat Sunil Kunlar was 25 ycars of agc and was carnitlgRsl5000e pll and 0 that thccIailllantswcrc dcpcildcnts upotl deccascdSuilil Kumar I a5 Clainl pctilion110 116 01 2003 hasbccn Iilcd by claiinanls for a QO 01 Rs I 8 Iac 011 account of death 01 1 110hand allcgiilglhat 7 Z 1 al Chand was 40 ycars of agc atld was ettrtlingRs 100001e10m and thal thcywcrc dcpcndcntupon dcccascd lal Chand Clailn pctition no 120 of2003 has becll Illcd byclainlanls Iot a COIllpCIlSilllOllof Rs l O lac oll accoullt 01 clclilh t11Rasal Singhiillcgingthat Rasal SinghW21S 50 ycars of age and was carniilgRs I 00001 10ill and thcy wcrc dcloendcnt upon thc incoine ofdcccascd Clllilll pctitioil110 121of 2003 has becn Illed bv lhc claimaills for a COIlljOCllStIlloil 01 Rs Iac Oll accounl o 1 dcalh o f Ramcsh Kumar allcgingtllat Ramcsh Kumar WOS 35 yetlrs ol agc oild WtiS Carlllllg Rs60001 p m aild that thcywcrc dcpcndcnlLClll tllc itlcome oldcceascd Claim pctitionno 129 of 2003 has bccn Illcd by claimant Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 426 C 1AO No879 of 2005 5 b JaspalSingh throughhis llIthcr I3alkar Singh loclllg 11111101 Ior a c3fRs Ioc Oll accolitll 11iilllriCS SllsltIllcd bI lliill iillcging that hc was 7 ycarsofagcaiId wiIs sludcnt of Isl t1tlss Clailll pclitioll 110 130 01 2003 has bccn Illcd by claitnant 1 13alkarSingh Ior a collllOcllSal iOll O Rs31ac on account of injurics Ct SllSUlItlcdIoyhim allcging he WOS 32 ycars 0 1agc and INas carnlllg 0 C Rs50001 I 0 Clai m peli1i on 110 137 of 2003 has bccn fIcd by claimantsOll I account of dcalll of Mohinclcr Kliilliir allcgitlgthal Mlhiildcr Ktllllill IVlS Z 28129 ycars of agc and Cllrlllllg Ils1 511001 1Ill alld lllat tlley lVCrC upon thc incomc ofdcccasccl C In rcsponsc to lhe noticc 0thc claim pctilionsrcspondcnls I a5 and Illcd WrltlCll SttltCillClllS 0 4 ltl thc writlcn statCIllClll Iiled Oll 1 0 rcspoIldcntNtl I Il 7 Z has bcen contctldcd in thc prelitninaryobjectioilstllot tlle clail11Ioctilioils wcrC nol maintainablcin thc prcscllt lorill lhal no causc 01 action accrucd Itl thcclaimanls llr filiilglhc Iorcsciltcltiim pclilionslllal claiillants have 110 Iocusstandi to Illc anclmailltain the claiill Ilclilitlilsaild t1121t tllc claiillililts arc sojopcdbythcir own ac1s alld coildltct l7omIlliilgtlleseclailll jlctitiIios Oll Illcrit it has bccn coillcnded l lliit thcrc was no fauIt of rcspotldcilt no l in causillgthesaid tlccidcnt atld tlle llCCIdeilI look placcdlIC to rash and ncgIigcIlldriviilg of lllc tllrecmwllcelcr its drivcr who Suddcnly calllC Oll tllC inain roild flill Iitlk roadIvitlloutobscrvillg lhc lrafllc lllcs 1tl lllc Ivrltlcn statcnlcnt IlIcd 1111bchall 0 1rcslotllldcills tlll ilild Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 427 1 IAO No879 of 2005 6 3 ic l IaryanaRoadways It htis bccil colllcndcd ill thc prcliminary objcctions that thc claiin pctitionsarc bad on account of nonoi ndcr of nccessary partics as thc drivcr tlwner and itlsurcrof thc thrccivllcelcI INcie not arrayed as On lncrits the acciclcnthas bccn admiltcd bul thc rcsponsibi lity 1 of the same Ilas bcen prayecllo bc faslcllcd Ltlloil thc drivcr o l tllrcC 0 wllCCIe Cv3 1n tllc written statcincnt IlIed on bcllalf 01 rcspondciltnoe C5 I National Insurancc CoinpatlypreJiminaryobjccllollS as takcn by othcr rcspondents wcrc takcn Z On merits it has bccil contcndcd that lhc bus i n question was Ilol involved in thc accident and lhat if lhc court COlllCSt1 thC I 08 lhat tle accident tclok placcwitll thc bus iil cltlcslioIlllletl lhc sanle took Cn lolaccduc to rashand ncgligctltdrivingofthrccvhccicr by its drivcr Cr 7 Z 1n thc additional plcas il has becn cotltcndcd that thc bus ill quCSlIOllwas bcingdrivcn by a pcrson nol holdinga valid and clTcctive drivlngIicellsc at lhc timc ofallcgcdaccidcnl Thcse issucs wcrc framcd Ill claim pclitionno 115 of 2003 which are undcr 1Whcthcrt hc accidcnt Ill clucstionrcsullinginttl dcathof Sunil Kumar 1al Chand Rasal SinghRanlcsh Kunlar Iviohindcr Ki1111r and injuricsto JasloalSingh 13alkar Singhwas causcd duc to rash and ncgligentdriving01 bus nollRe373540 by IlS drivcr respondcnt no l as allegcd20PP 2 lf issuc no l is provcdlo what amounl of compcnsation thcpctitioncrs arc cill illcd lo alld lrttll Wh01112C0lP 3Whcthcr rcspondcntno l was nol htlldinga valid and cffcctivc drivingliccnsc Otl thc allcgcddate o accident2 Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 428 3 No879 01 2005 7 OPR 4 Rclief The lcamcd 1ribunal allcr apjoraisal cf lllc evidciocc011 tecoicl alvardcd an anlount of Rs000001e aS Oul tlf which Rs000001 cach givcn to clainlailt Ncls 1 and 2 alld tllc retllaining C anlOUnt of Rs1000001shall bc ccIuallysharcdby claiinants No and 4 0 C Similarly in othcr claim pclilions Ilasalso lccil alvaidcd by I thc 1ribunal C5 I l7cclingdissatisOcd wilh lhc abovc saicl Awards of thc Molor Z Accidcnt ClaiIns 1ribunal thc appcllatltshavc Iorcfcricdlllc plcscllt 2 appeals C Cr havc hcard Icarncd counscl Ior the partlcs and pcruscdtlle I casc fllc 08 QO hc clatlnantsarc hcld cntillcd t0 750Ioof tllc saicl ainoulll 1 7 Z Rs568001 So thc Nalional Insurance is cliicctcd to pay lhc enhanccd alnount 01 Rs98001 aloil with intcrcsl 71 pa Ironl lhc dalc 01 filingtheappcaltill reaiization I2AONo879 of2005 0 17AONo584 of2005 Both lhcsc appcaJs havc becn prclcrrcdIor cnhanccnlcnt o f Ctllllpcnsalioll on accounl of dcalh of Sunil Kulnar 1AO No879 01 2005 has bccn prcscntcdby widow and initlor daughtcrof Sutlil Klllllar WllCrCaS 1AO Nt2584 of 2005 has bccn prclcrrcdb Swarna Ranl and Kanlia lOcvi parcnls01Sunil Kunlar dcccascd Thc Icarnedl nbunal hasasscsscd tllc lllCOlllC 01 Sunil Kuillar Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 429 07 No879 cIf 2005 8 drivcr 01 tllrccwhcclcr as Rs300011lcrmonth I l was also hcld that hc W21S I l3 ainunl upclll hilll Iild Ilis ctllltliblili1ll tolvtitdsl5iillily Ilvasheld to bc 1eCeRs40001 pcr annuin 111cage of Sunil Kunlar had bcenasscsscd as 2829 ycars at thc tiinc llf deathand thc inultiplicr appllcd 1 IS 15 and in this tnallncr lllc clailllatlts wcrc hcld cillitlccl lo claiill Rs600001 on account of dcath 0 Sunil Kunlar Ill lhc accidcnt hc 0 0 Tribunal also awardcd Rs00001 on account of Iuncral cxpcnscs ancl I Rsl00001 on account of Iossofcoilsorliunl Iovc iltld affccliil alld itl Illis C5 I manner tllc total aIlltlulll Of IV8S asscsscd Rs000001 but Z SlilCC Sunil Kuinar was hcld to be ncgligctllto tlle cxtcnl ol 25 thc claiIn of thc clai inants has bccn restrictcdto Rs OO0001 hc Ilrst point presscd hclorc IllC lS that contributory 08 ncgligcnce asscssedby thc Tribunal to Ihc cxtcnl of 25 attibutcd to Sunil Q0 KLimarshould nol bc asscsscdbythc rihiitlal I Iclwctct I Ilallc pcilisccltllc em Z rccords thc lbunal has catcgorical ly hcld thal SuniI Kunlar dcceasccl IS ncgligclll to thc extcnt of 25Io So on rc Oraisal of tllC cvidcncc lhal Ilndingdoesnot call ftr aily itllcrcrcrlcc allclcctlsequelltly tllc same standsafllrmcd Now rcvertingto the cnhanccmcnt o f compcnsation1S conccmed thc 10C0111C of Sunil Kulllar hiis bccil rightly 21sscsscdas Rs0001 pcr Inollll I Iowcver thc dcpcildcilcycalculalcd bv Ihe lrial nccds ltl bc correctcd hc rilotiil11IliIs tssessed1I3111111uilt lvcluld havc bccn spcnl by thc dcccascd to nlaiiltaIn Ilinlsclf btil in tllis COSClhC dcpcndcnls are Widow 1111110rdaughtcr and parcnts1C IOUriil llUlllbCr SO Ill lhcsc CIrCLlIllSlallCCS lhC 31110lllll I7lr Illallllaiillllg hllllself should havC Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 430 1AO No879 01 2005 9 1 4 bccntakcn as 114 hc illotllhlydcpcildcncylhcrcl7tc sllttild Ilallc bcctl asscsscdas Rs2501 and ycat1ydcjocildcilcy shoLildhavc bcctl lls27IIOl So lar as thc multipiicris ctlIlccrllcd ltl Illy VlCW thc multiplier asscsscdsllould havc bccn 17 iilstcad 0 1 15 ilsscsscdblthc ribuilalso the 1 alllOUllt ofconlpcllSatioIlis calculatcd tIS Rs59OOOl27000 x 171 hc tr riiouna l has asscsscd RsO0001 on account of Iilncral chargcsancl 0 C0 Rs00001 lll clf ItIssof coilsorliuill lclvc aild aflcction hc I C5 respondcnts havc not prclcrrcd111Y Stl lhc claitllaIllSarc enlitlcd lo I cIaitn Rs590001 llowcvcr kccpingill I icHI lllc flict thal Suilil Kliillar Z waS hcld ncgligcllt to thc cxtcill 01 25A thc clalnlants of a2 bcltll thc claitn pctitioIlS arc ciltillccl lo claim Rs74250e 1le ribul111 has awardcd Rs 000001 as So lhc anlolIlll Clf I 08 stailds cnhanccd by Rs742501 iIl acldilioil lo thc amount oo 4t awardcdby thc ribunal Thc said tllllount shi111Iocsharcd by thc claimants W2 Z of both lhc claiill pctitionsas pcr Award and lhc Iiability101pao thc said 11 anltllllll is tilso t1s per lllc Illllouglled AltIrd 1AO No2585 of2005 111cclaiinants in this casc arc lOarshaniIOcvi widow Raoir Pinki Shashi I3ala Ranbir Singhaild Jasbir Singh Illiilor childrcn 01 1 al Chatld and 13asantaRain athcr l dccciscd l al ChaIlcl 1Ilc amounl claimcd by thcclaiinants in thc clainl pctitlollNo 16 012003 Ivas for Rs 18 Iacsaild it was alIcgcdlhat 71Cllatld IVil S 48 ycarS tlld illld IVtIS Cllrlllilg Rs10tlOlIl pcr illoIllh hc Icilrnccl lriill C tIUr1iISScSScdtllc illccllnc of dcccased as Rs4001 pcr nlont h 111d1i3 1110l1111Ivas dcductcd as cxpcnses on his maintcnanccaild thlts INaS lakcn Rs192001 Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 431 IAO No879 01 2005 I O 9 S pcrannum 110c1ibunal assesscdthc age of dcccascd as 45 inultiplicrapplicdby lhc ribiitlal WOS 13 and in lllis manncr thc ribunal asscsscd lhc conlpcnsation a5 RsA96001 on accounl 0 dcalh of l il Chaild All OlllClllnt clf Rs211001 H llS Oll accounl of Iullcral cxpcnscsand Rs00001 WOS grillllcdon account o1 Ioss of consortiunl m and Iovc ancl alTcctiotl aild llle 10l11 Of canlc l0 0 C3 Rs896001 I lowcvcr thc clilIIllillltSWerehcld entitlcd to claiin 75 of I thesaid alllOLIlll alllOullting lo Rs1 72001 C5 I So Ior as lhc alllOulll l Illccllllc ilsscsscdby tllc ribunal to llle Z lUllc 01 Rs4001 IS conccrned that des nol cal l I7lr anv intcrcrcncc 1Iowcvcr thc dcpcndencyshould Iltitee bceil ciilcLIlttletlallei dcdLictiilg 0 11 aIllOllllt as thcrc wcrc scvcn CltllilltllltS1Il tIlC Iorcseiltcasc Ycarly I 08 depcndcncy COlllCS to Rs i 6001 hc inultijolicrtlsscsscdby lhc riblit71 CJO IS 13 al thc tige of 45 ycars but shtluld Ilaic bccil I Ll S lllc e emm Z amount of compcnsation calculalcd is Rs2 16001 X 14 Rs3024001 Qm 1hc ribunal hasawardcd RsA0000111ill reSIleClol funcral charges and ioss 01 consorunl ctc So thc lotal anltIunl colculated Itl lllIS IllllllllCr ClllllCS Rs3 4 24001 1hc 17ibunal has dcductcd Ihc anlount oI 25YoIic11 lhc Aword anlOlltll on lhc groundthat Sunil Kulllill W8S Conlributoryncgligcntto lhc Cxtclll of 25 I Iowcvcr that Ilndiilghlls bccn chalIcilgcdbytlocapIocllailts Iil all lllc appeaISCXCCptltl thc apIOcIls Htidtllv I3alclllStllld childrcll bcaringNo ONo 879 of 2005 and lAO Ntl584 01 21105 It llas bccn colltendcd that thcrc is a distinction bcliltcll thc ctliltlilllittllI Ilcgligcilland COlllpositc ncgligcncelt is submittcdllltit stl llir as lal CIl2Illdis ctlllccitlcd Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 432 IAO No879 of 2005 I l L 1 hc was a passcngcr Ill tl thrcewhccler ttnd l 11CIltlnclalld olhcr clcccascd cannot bc hcld 10 bc contribIorynegligcnt he alnounl o 25 cannot bc dcductcdin respcctofthc compcllsatiotl It is forccfLillycoIltclldcd lllol ill cilsc tllcoillpositcilcgligcilcc the claimants arc hcld cntil lcd to c llIi nl lr9111Uls Of lhc tcIrl Ieasors hcy 1 can claiin the alllount f1olntllc Icgalrcllrcscnltltivcs 01 Slitlil Ktitllai I IiOlll 0 thc otvncr drivcr and IllsurailccColllllillly of lhc ollcndingvchiclc i13us C I No lR3713540 111cNational Insurancc Companyrcspondcntis botmd lO C5 I makc lhc paymcntoflhcawardcdlllllOllill illld it lllav Clallll ltOlll lhe olher tort Icasorsifso adviscd Z m o stlpporlthis contcnt0ll Icarllcd ctluilscl I7lrlllc apjocllailts r hasrclicd upon lli Il I3cnchaulhorilll 01 tlllr 01111 1ligh tJllrt in SmtParsani I 08 Dcvi VSe Statc oflla1 and Ihe 1972The 973 The Plb lIIW QO orter 811 2ii1d AePSRTeC anre v KeIlemalatluO Orse 2008 W2 Z 31 RCRICivio C7Iunscl for National l nSllrilllCC COIllpllllyand counsel for thc Statchavc opposcdthc satd praycr and Ilove subnliltcd lhat sincc l al Chailcl lV21S travcllinglil a lhrccvheclcr wllicll IViIS drivCll by Sunil Kullla dcceascd aild as such thc Iiabililyto pay tllc anlount 0f 25 is that of Icgal rcprcscnlillivcs 01Sutlil Ktitnar owner 01IlliccIIllcclel 1CI this COIltCIllIOll Iearilcd counscl for tIlC JllSllr2111CC C0IllpOllyhas rcliccl lIpOIl authorily G u rm inder Sineh 0 a nol her VS DrRaini Kumari 2009421 RCR 4Civill378 So far as lllc tiulllllri SmleP1144 levj ease l3O AePSRCe Si anothers easc I lC ctlnccrncd thc ratio of thc abovc said tlnvojLidglllcnlsis lhat 111COSC ol conlposilcncgligcnccwhcn thc Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 433 17AONo879 01 2005 12 4 accidcntllas takcll placcdLic tll Ilcgligcilccof tWll ltlrt l casors 1 lhal casc the thc iippcllants can rccovcr lhc full conlpcnsalionanlount from cithcr of thcnl 1hc authorilyAPSlLCll has bcen discusscd by a Division Beneh Ill aulhorityCurmindcr Sih 1 iInother casc and itI ptira Ntl 12 ol thc lidgtllCIltit wiis held as under 0 0 12 I carllccl couioscl IIr tllc aploellatlls subinittccl lllal tllis I C principlccould bc invokcd only i bolh the tort22EIselsIvclC I lllllolcadcd as a parly In lhe prcscnl CaSCtllc ClLlllllalll has Z choscn lcI proccedonly agaiIlsllllc Olvncr and drivcr of lhC tCllllOo and IlOt ilnpIeadcd llle drivcr 01 lllc Marull van 11hoIvas C husbandclf 1lc cltllllltlllt t111d Ill sucll o siluatitln il wi ll not bc I 08 ajoproprialc 0r tllc claiinlltll lO Clll111 l0111 tIlC 00 owncr ofthc tcnlptI or lhc lilill 11lcr Ilusband 7 Z Whilc sittingSinglIr I aill 1ouild IlyI lle tlbscrvtltioilsilladc by Ll lllcir 1ordshipsiil the said jtidgmclltlly lllc 19Ilisitil 13ctlcll Ill thc IlrCSClll case also owncr of thc thrceeIvhcclcr tlle insurllllCC CClllllOElllyilld Icgal rcprcscillatives ol dcccased Sullil Klilllilr clrivcr Ilavc not bccn arravcd as parly So lll thcSCCl rClIIllSItlllCCS lllc lcarIlcd lriiil IILlrl IllS righlly dcducted thc alnounl of 25Io lrtllll tlle CClllllOCllSlll llll ttl lhc clilillllIlllS Oll account Oll thc pltrtllfSliilllKulllar VAO N02131 ot 2005 Tllc clilim pctilitlll lll tllis ciisc lliis llecil jorclcrrcdby Sllll Shaildi Dcvi widow Ralll Phal iltld Raill KllJllIr Stllls 01 Ris2llSitlgll Iil lhis casc thc lribunal has asscsscdlhc lllCtIIllC cIl tlle clcccascd as Rs24001 Iocr Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 434 8 4 l7AO NoS79 of 2005 13 monthand aftcr deducting113 as spcnt for thc nlaiIltcnanccby Risal Siilgh 213 has bcen takcn as IOcpendcncyhas bcen takcn as Rsl92001 1hc agc of Risal Singhwas 55 ycars ancl rnulliplicrapplicdIll lhis casc is o 10 Ilc claiinants wcrc hcld cntitlcd to clainl I2s19201O 1hc claimailts wcrc also hcld enlitlcd to Rs20OOol on account 01 funcral 1 C cxpcnscsancl Rs00001 on account 0f Ioss 01 consortiunl lovc and 0 allcction and iil this 111211111C1tllc claiillonts Wcrc hcld cntitlcd to C I Rs581 001 114 ainouilt was dcductcdon aCCOUnt 0negligcnccoSun C5 Kutnar and claiInants wcrc granlcdtillltllllll of Rs935701 In aulllority Smt Sarla Verma and others vsIelhi 191101415PlMporatIon and Anre Z 200931 ReCeReCivill 77 tllc clcduclioil fclr pcrsoilEII cxIoctlscs ficill tllc C incotllc sllould bc 113djIllC8SC Ihcdcpcilclcilts tlre 2 lo 3 So ill lhis illallller 08 lhe trial Court has rightlydcducled t1le 113 I7IiIlis cxjlcnscsaIld laking C to Rs 192001 pcr ycar 11lc illcotllc oftlle deccascd has also 7 Z bcen asscsscdas Rs400ocr month aslhc accidcnl hastaken placcin thc prcscnt COSC lll thc yci1r 2003 I 10110cvcrtllc illllllilolicrtijoplictiblc in this case should havc bccn Il according lcl lllc tlbscrVOlIOIlSllladc Ill SmtSarla Vcrma and othcrs caselsuiw So lhc atllOlllll Calculaledin this IllallllCr IS Rs1 12001 So lllc anlounl cnhanccd hy nlultiplicsof ClllllCS to Rs1 92001 ul ol llle sttId anltllllll 141 js dcdliclcd on account 01 negligenccof Sunil Kumar So consideringthc abovc said ClrCUinstanCCS lhc aillclUllt Of COllllOCllStlllOllStalldS Cllhitnccd by Rs 144001 alongwitll IlllCrCst 9 7 pcr onnuin IrotnIhc datcofappcaltjll realizatior l7AO N017440f2005 Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 435 1AO No79 of 2005 14 y V D In tllis casc the IllCotllc tll Ralllcsll Klllllar dccciiSod Ilils taken as Rs24001 locr monlll and 113 1110l1t11ht3s bccn dcductccl Oll account of cxpcnscs Oll himsclf ilild dcpctldcilcyhlls bcen calculalccl to Rs192001 pcr ycar hc agc odcccscd Iltlsbceil asscsscclas37 lt40 vears and the multiplicrmade applicalolcin tlIs cilsc is 14 and in this 1 C manncr the amount on account o COlllCS l11 Rs688001 0 WllCrCaS tlle 111110l1111 Ol Rs01Il101 Ilas lcctl erailtcd on accoun l tl l Iuilcral 0 I expcnsesand Rs000010 on 0ccount o 10ssor consortiunl 11c lolal C I aillouilt calculatcd is Rs0880111 25 Ilas hcctl dcductcd on Z account of contributoryIlcgllgcllceol Sunil Klllllllr lllld Rs3 16001 IlllS bccn ordercd t0 bc paidto tllc claiIllants 11cciiillatlts irl this casc arc thc r widow thrcc 1111110rcllildren atld Illlhcr o tllc olcccscd So 111Ihis nlanncr I 08 thc slltILiId Ililve Ilccll tlSSCSScdttl tlle CXlCIlI 111314 illcr r0 dcducting thc anlount 0f 114 spelll llll lllillIllCllllllCC tll tlCcciiscd So thc 7 Z depcndcncyis ca l cu 1alcd as Ils216001 I he miilliplicrapIolicablc lo tllc tl agCof dcccascd as pcr SarliI Venna and tlthers cl should havc bccn asscsscdas 15 instcacl014 iitld hy tipIolyitlg lhc said mulliplier of l 5 thc total colllcs l0 Rs32401JUl 1lc clilltlltlllts 211c 1115llIlclcl cntitlcd to Rs00001 t111 lICCIIlIIIl Il Iuller111CXjlClISCS lild loss of consortium as llWardcclby the 1 ribuiltll lll lllIS Illanncr lhc claimanlsarc hcld cntitledttl cltlim Rs640001 Allcr dcdtlctiti825 thc claimanls arc hcld cnlitlcd l0 cltiiill ctlllatlccd tlilltlllill 1IfR82541Jl 11ttlgwilll i11tcrcstil 7o Illllll llle dillc till rciili7iilioil FAO NtI604 tI1 20115 Claiinants Ill this ClSC lC Iiidolll Illllltlr Stlll iIndparcnlsothc Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 436 1 41 17AONo 879 of 2005 15 0 1 dcceascdMohindct Kunlar hc i ilcoillc tlf deccascd Ilas bceil lak6l as Rs30001 jocr moilth and tl has llcctl calctllilted t1S Rs40001tcr dcducting113 alnotilll 1llc IlltiltilIici m this casc is hcld to bc 14 in llliS 11181111Crlllc clatmalllSarc hclcl cntitlcd l0 Rs 360001 hc 1ribuilal tllso t111ardcdRs001IOl Oll account of Q funcral expcnscs and Rs011001 Oll account 0f Ioss t11consortiunl Iovc 0 and allcction clc 1llc tolal atllOUlll 01 IVS C I Rs376 0001 but thc cut tcl the cxtcnl 01 254 WllS inadc as thc insurcr tlf C5 I lhrcewhccler was llol arralrcdtIS Itl lIlIS manilcr thc clai tnanls arc held cntitlcd to claim Rs820001 Z So far as tllc illcomc asscsscdby tllc nbunal to lhe extent of L Rs10001 pcr Illonth docs Ilol cit ll I7ll 11113 llllCrl crcnce l ItlwclCl l tl V IC W 08 01 Smt Sarla Verma and others ease 1Sllllrlllllle should oo havc bcen takcn lo thc cxtcnt of 314 as lllcre trC Iour claiillailts in lIlC 14 7 Z prcscnt casc Thc mulliplicraecording t1 said tltilhority al lhc agc of dcceascd is asscsscd as 16 St thc clillillilllts tIrC hcld enlillcd to elaiill RsA3 20001 hc lrbunal hasiisscsscclRs11OIJIIl 311account 01 funeral cxpcnscsand Rsl00001 on account of 10ssof CtlllSOrtllllll Ivc and afcction clc hcrc IS no crOSS appcalttl challengethc said amount aIvardcd by thc 1ribunal So the elaiillaIlIS arc hcId ei llitlcd t0 Rs320001 Allcr dcclucting the anltIunl 01 2596ihc clainlanls llrc hcld cnlitled lo claim Rs540001 l Il I1llS llltlllller CllllilllCCd of Rs200010 IS ordercd to bc paid 1011thc rcspoildciltsas ordcr bv lhe Tribunal altlngwilh IiltCrcsl 7 1tl lrtllll Illc tlatc0 1IIlingtllc till rcalization Pooja 2012.08.25 14: 30 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 15:57 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 1 437 C No879 01 2005 16 Irl VICH tlf Ihe tibtlvc disclt5sitltl 111lhe ttIoovcsiiid tipllcals stand partlyacccptcdt0 thc cxlelll discusscd 7ibl1vc llc ajopcl lallls claiinantsilrc hcld cnlitlcd t0 cilhililccd aIlllLiilt tts clcttlilcdabti0 I Iolvctlcl thcyarc held cntillcd to thcir rcspcctiic aIllOlIIlts aloilglvith 1 IlllCrCSl 7 llillllltll lhe diilc 11 Ippctllti11rcaliztititln llc r OillOllllt illililrdcd by lllc ribuilal shall bc ptlid ttl the ajopcllantsby lllc 0 4 rcspondcntstS llCr