IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT HYDERABAD FRIDAY THE NINETEENTH DAY OF DECEMBER, TWO THOUSAND AND EIGHT : PRESENT : THE HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE G. YETHIRAJULU C.M.A. No. 1251 OF 2008 (Appeal Filed Under Order 43 R1( R) of CPC, presented this appeal against the order of the Court of the I Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Secunderabad passed in I.A. No. 1045 of 2008 in O.S. No. 24 of 2008 dated 29-07-2008) Between:- The Secunderabad Club, Picket, Karkhana, Secunderabad, Rep. by its Secretary, Lt. Col. V.S.N. Reddy [Retired], S/o. late Sri V. Raja Reddy, R/o. Secunderabad. ..Appellant/R-4/D-4. AND 1. Wg. Cdr GSN Prasad S/o. late G. Sriram Babu, R/o. 285, Old No. 1-2-376/2, Street No. Gagan Mahal, Hyderabad –500 029. 2. Wg.Cdr. M. Ram Reddy S/o. late M. Veera Reddy, R/o. H.No. 53-A, B Block, Vasavi Colony, Picket, Secunderabad –3. 3. Wg.Cdr. Y.V. Krishna Rao S/o. late YFR Murthy, H.No. 1-33-1/4/1, Lake Ville Lxt Road, No.3, RTC Colony, Trimulgherry, Secunderabad –125. 4. Wg. Cdr. T.J Reddy S/o. late T. Nagi Reddy, H.No. 63, Vayupuri, Secunderabad. 5. Wg. Cdr S.P. Sehgal S/o. late G.P. Sehgal, H.No. 9, Vayupuri, Secunderabad –94. 6. Wg.Cdr.G.N. Bhaskar S/o. late GN Adinarayana Rao, R/o. Plot No. 6, Cantonment Coop. Housing Society, R/o. 2-24-117, Sikh Road, Secunderabad. 7. Sq.Ldr. Anil Bhalla, R/o. Plot No. 11, Polly Shetty Enclave, Near Khambam Nursing Home, Vikrampuri, Secunderabad –9. 8. Lt. Col. I.E. Jones S/o. late E. Williams Jones, R/o. 15/6, Rukminidevi Colony, West Marredpally, Secunderabad –25. 9. Maj. MNK Menon S/o. late K.G. Menon, Flat No. 103, Padmaja Plaza, Nehru Naga Post Office, West Marredpally, Secunderabad –26. 10. Gp. Capt. MR Murdeshwar S/o. Late Mohan R. Murdeshwar, H.No. 201, Vayupuri, Secunderabad –94. 11. Wg.Cdr.F.J. Mehta Vr C. S/o. late Jahangir B. Mehta, R/o. 67, Durga Vihar Colony, Trimulgherry [P], Secunderabad –15. 12. Wg.Cdr.M.M. Maini S/o. late Ananthram Maini, R/o. 2, Cantonment Housing Board, Sikh Road, Secunderabad –3. 13. Maj. SLN Moorty S/o late S. Seetharamaiah, R/o. 98, Gun Rock Enclave, Secunderabad –9. 14. Brig. R.V. Naidu S/o. late Rajgopal Naidu, R/o. No. 9, Asha Officers Colony, R.K. Puram, Secunderabad –56. 15. Sq. Ldr. MV Pantulu S/o. late MS Aiyya, Flat NO. 103, Habitat Vemuri Apartments, H.No. 33-15, Officers Colony, R.K. Puram, Secunderabad –56. 16. Flt. Lt. Suresh Marepally S/o. late M. Ranga Reddy, H.No. 1-2-56/49, Domalguda, Hyderabad –29. 17. Sq. Ldr. SG Sahni S/o. late KS. Sahni, R/o. 107, AP Tex Book Colony, Secunderabad. 18. Sq. Ldr. V. Sadanandam S/o. Late VL Sastry, H.No. 157, Vayupuri, Secunderabad-94. 19. Maj. Jugjeet Singh S/o Maj Inder Singh, R/o. Sandeepa, 14, Asha Officers Colony, R.K. Puram, Secunderabad –56. ..Respondents/Petitioners/Plaintiffs. 20. The Union of India, rep. by its Secretary, Ministry of Defence, New Delhi. 21. Headquarters Andhra Sub Area, Rep. by its Commander C/o. 56, APO, Pin –900453. 22. Rajendrasinhji Institute, 186/187, Allembic Lines, Secunderabad –87, rep. by its Secretary. …Respondents/Respondents/Defendants. These Appeal coming on for hearing, upon perusing the petition and grounds filed herein and the orders of the High Court dated 21-10-2008 made in CMAMP. No. 2319 of 2008 and made herein and upon hearing the arguments of Sri M. Papa Reddy, Advocate for the Appellant and Sri D. Madhava Rao, Advocate for the Respondent Nos. 1 to 19 and of Sri Deepak Battacharajjee, Advocate on behalf of the Respondent No. 22, the Court made the following (Contd. 2. ) . 2 . ASSISTANT REGISTRAR // TRUE COPY // for ASSISTANT REGISTRAR To 1. The I Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Secunderabad. 2. Wg. Cdr GSN Prasad S/o. late G. Sriram Babu, R/o. 285, Old No. 1-2-376/2, Street No. Gagan Mahal, Hyderabad –500 029. 3. Wg.Cdr. M. Ram Reddy S/o. late M. Veera Reddy, R/o. H.No. 53-A, B Block, Vasavi Colony, Picket, Secunderabad –3. 4. Wg.Cdr. Y.V. Krishna Rao S/o. late YFR Murthy, H.No. 1-33-1/4/1, Lake Ville Lxt Road, No.3, RTC Colony, Trimulgherry, Secunderabad –125. 5. Wg. Cdr. T.J Reddy S/o. late T. Nagi Reddy, H.No. 63, Vayupuri, Secunderabad. 6. Wg. Cdr S.P. Sehgal S/o. late G.P. Sehgal, H.No. 9, Vayupuri, Secunderabad –94. (Contd. 3. ) . 3 . 7. Wg.Cdr.G.N. Bhaskar S/o. late GN Adinarayana Rao, R/o. Plot No. 6, Cantonment Coop. Housing Society, R/o. 2-24-117, Sikh Road, Secunderabad. 8. Sq.Ldr. Anil Bhalla, R/o. Plot No. 11, Polly Shetty Enclave, Near Khambam Nursing Home, Vikrampuri, Secunderabad –9. 9. Lt. Col. I.E. Jones S/o. late E. Williams Jones, R/o. 15/6, Rukminidevi Colony, West Marredpally, Secunderabad –25. 10. Maj. MNK Menon S/o. late K.G. Menon, Flat No. 103, Padmaja Plaza, Nehru Naga Post Office, West Marredpally, Secunderabad –26. 11. Gp. Capt. MR Murdeshwar S/o. Late Mohan R. Murdeshwar, H.No. 201, Vayupuri, Secunderabad –94. 12. Wg.Cdr.F.J. Mehta Vr C. S/o. late Jahangir B. Mehta, R/o. 67, Durga Vihar Colony, Trimulgherry [P], Secunderabad –15. 13. Wg.Cdr.M.M. Maini S/o. late Ananthram Maini, R/o. 2, Cantonment Housing Board, Sikh Road, Secunderabad –3. 14. Maj. SLN Moorty S/o late S. Seetharamaiah, R/o. 98, Gun Rock Enclave, Secunderabad –9. 15. Brig. R.V. Naidu S/o. late Rajgopal Naidu, R/o. No. 9, Asha Officers Colony, R.K. Puram, Secunderabad –56. 16. Sq. Ldr. MV Pantulu S/o. late MS Aiyya, Flat NO. 103, Habitat Vemuri Apartments, H.No. 33-15, Officers Colony, R.K. Puram, Secunderabad –56. 17. Flt. Lt. Suresh Marepally S/o. late M. Ranga Reddy, H.No. 1-2-56/49, Domalguda, Hyderabad –29. 18. Sq. Ldr. SG Sahni S/o. late KS. Sahni, R/o. 107, AP Tex Book Colony, Secunderabad. 19. Sq. Ldr. V. Sadanandam S/o. Late VL Sastry, H.No. 157, Vayupuri, Secunderabad-94. 20. Maj. Jugjeet Singh S/o Maj Inder Singh, R/o. Sandeepa, 14, Asha Officers Colony, R.K. Puram, Secunderabad –56. 21. The Secretary, Union of India, Ministry of Defence, New Delhi. 22. The Commander, Headquarters Andhra Sub Area, C/o. 56, APO, Pin –900453. 23. The Secretary, Rajendrasinhji Institute, 186/187, Allembic Lines, Secunderabad 24. One spare copy. 25. One CC to Sri M. Papa Reddy, Advocate, High Court of A.P., Hyderabad ( BY SPECIAL MESSENGER) 26. One CC to Sri D. Madhava Rao, Advocate, High Court of A.P., Hyderabad ( BY SPECIAL MESSENGER) 27. One CC to Sri Deepak Bhattacharajjee, Advocate, High Court of A.P., Hyderabad ( BY SPECIAL MESSENGER) BV HIGH COURT DR. GYR.J DATED: 19-12-2008 ORDER CMA.NO. 1251 OF 2008 DIRECTION DRAFTED : BY BV DATED : 07-01-2009 HIGH COURT DR. GYR.J DATED: 19-12-2008 ORDER CMA.NO. 1251 OF 2008 DIRECTION HIGH COURT DATE: 27-3-2002 ORDER C.M.A.No. 347 of 2002 INTERIM SUSPENSION GRANTED EARLIER IS EXTENDED TILL 9-4-2002