'u IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR rC.G.) WRIT PETITION fS) N0. ^<^3£>" OF 2006 PETITIONER ,•!• ..-•I . ^.•••"^ ^,^-^ 0 y^'" .. .'^••''p:^"/-•" ^>^^y 'iw'" <^' .<€P'".^ ^->'' \-.V^ <^y^^^ rt« ^'f^ Dev Kumar Kashyap Son of^ Shri Dilaram Kashyap, aged about 44 years, Assistant Teacher, Presently posted at Govt. Primary School, Sasha, Block Pamgarh, District Janjgir-Champa (C.G.). VERSUS RESPONDENTS -o^ .f^ .'^'i-:N^°' ^ ^u /"i(u 9t» 8^^s <?'"'""^!:^;.. ^^.s^ {i%,!lS%?in??ri ^i lf^s' $f%^-r' (.'^ '•' .^ 1, State of Chhattisgarh, Through: The Secretary, Department of School Education, D. K. S. Bhawan, Raipur (C.G.). 2. The District Education Officer, Janjgir-Champa (C.G.). 3. The Block Education Officer, Pamgarh, District Janjgir- Champa (C.G.). WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226/227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA. 1950 FOR ISSUANCE OF WRIT IN THE NATURE OF CERTIORARI, MANDAMUS ETC. AND FOR APPROPRIATE ORDER/ORDERS, DIRECTION/DIRECTIONS. Hta^ee^wr©^CMH^^ISGAIWAt^^k?»iui»« SB!®fcESENSW: HQBI'a^lffifc S«nSH4(.AtaMtttoTRI, A VSffWPEnTIOBKS^N0.608*^288® -PetitiQRW KfishnttUAfattaw Versus vwwpetn'icMiKs. Prtitoner Rreptmdente Vereus Pcresnl; : Mr,P:P^a^,i peUBons. Mt.AjayDwivedi, ^srtfrinbotttthe ^assedon7mofNOTeRtt)Wt2(W^ Th& petMoners M»VKiilan^ as A^tetort Tewher n GewemmBBt Sdiools. In ttw couisft vS ttirti savteft «s^sistaRt^ Teacher, the petitioneis haveolrialned B.Ed./B.T.l. ©erffieatasatthew own expensesbefore 1-3-1M9. 2. Wrlt Petlttens (S.) No.6084 o( 2 B and OT of M06 are bei(®disproed of by thi&cwnnon ordw as th& faets anct quwaow of lawinvohyedinthesepetttonsaraeonmon. 3. Accordtng to teBned oounset tor th»prtfionere, the peUUoners are enBUed to two advanGe in<aearonte in wew o( ttie deeision of ttiis Court in the ease of Yaslvwai^ KwnarBhaiaehwfw. MunhsipafCwpoi^on, Duigandaiwlhw^, wherein ithas baen heM tbat ths Teachers, hawt^obtainedB.Bd., Nl.Ed.,B.TJ.eB(ttBGat»^aA*eip ownexpsrees; aBecQvered^tt)®ciRSutaFtldsd;24"12-®98iaue<tt^' theStEtoGovemmentof Madh^ Pradath; 4. Furttier, in thetmittorot Sn* < woBE»»»SfenmMtm(aiW8: StateofMP; andottora2, the Madhya Pradesh Administratw&Trttunat, GwaltorBench,wNtecondderingtt»ettCttlardd!ed;1-a-1S^,whe(dnft is pR>videA thrtthe Assistant Teache®,wrtw taws acqubiwt BtEA Degiee at ttielrown cosl belwraen 23-10-1964 aid 7-5-1873 »ha b& endttod totwe artvance incren'iaite, felled on deeiston intheca^ o( Rafcesb Kumar Shrtwsta»avs. St^»cfM.P. afld otheR; pasBed iit OriglnalApplieafionNo.ie^<rf1999,decid«toRl2-10-19®,whe»»in it is observed that tt>e chcular datad 1-3-189& cwn'igt be niari® applteable retrospectlv^. Thus, aTeacher, naybe Asslstant TeiBher, who hs»obtained B.Ed. Degree brtoi»1-3-'t%&is enBtletlte tww advar»eincremerts. _.L_ „. -.-— — UUUriBU ^ •^ 2^> 5. It is pointed out by toamed ceunsd^ appearing fer ttia peBttoneis that thathwi Strtft ef MsKlhya Pradeste haAflledaSp«;i»t LMV®PetiBort agalnsfe fce orctere pass«tty th& Tribunafrand th» Hon'bte SupBenw^Gourt cBsmissed Speeial Lewe P^fem Noi.t999 eS 2000filedagainsttheonteB'<tftwTribunal. Therafere.ltotllrBctontB theeffecfcthatthaciroulardated 4-3-19^ canmrtbBmactoapplteaNe; retrespecGvefy, passed bythsTrBaunal, beeomes finat anAthesame shall be appUeabla te alt lh»Arei^amt Teadwre, w( ftsnw oMrir^ circulwctedecfc 17-10-2Ma issu«tbyttiepreM)*aatft<^Madh^i Practesh, wherein ths clrcular elearty stetes abert toe deeWoro <rf"tha Hon'bteSupremeCourt. 6. Leamed counsel for ttte p^toaen ftirther sutnnNs thsrt thafacteandquesttonoflawlHVtriveflinthepFeeentcas^aesquanly covered by the decision of this QCMA *»ttw raee ef Ya^iW^Kwneu' BhanKkwq/ (Suprs^, te wAricsh teamed couns^ appeim^ tar t» rwpQndenlsffitat&IaiFtyeoneedesai'idi -i.- 7. Accorelingty, flwwnt cteci^ai of thi& Court te tha maUsr af Yestmwi'^ KiHnear ^aaadiia^ (SuprE^, subject to verincdioflof tte faet as to whBttoer tti»peiatonaisg have aequlred B.Ed. Gwtifieate s< Bwir own ®(pensesas pw circutats dtrted 24-t2-19 an<* 1-3-1998 «ittftiidwiswhefc»flwyl been paKNw&actonee tncremenis or not. No oKtwa&teeostSi 8. A copy of this onter be pteedon Bi&rworctcfttw connectedwritprttion. Sd/- Satfsh KAgnihotri Judge 1 2008 (II) MPJR<;896 2 2000 (1)M.P.LS.R. 136