NCH IN THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR (C.G.) WRIT PETITION (227V NQ,C}^><?-OF 2010 PETITIONER DEFENDANT N0.2 RESPONDENTS PLAINTIFFS ^.. / "'' «& /?{)' / oP^fe/ ^'•.^ ^'6^>' "'' /^^v f ;"/ ''<°' ^ ' '* •Atl' f^~~ <•"•' ^ Krishna Kumar Singh Son of Shri Roshan Singh, aged about 25 years, Caste Rajput, Resident of Village Vishrampur, Behind Regianal l-lospital,Tahsil Surajpfflr, District Surguja (C.G.). VERSUS 1.' Phoolbasiya Wife of Ghurhu, aged about 50 yeas. 2. -^Ramsurat Son of Late Ghurhu, aged about 32 years. 3. ' Ramdhan Son of Late Ghurhu, aged about 28 years. 4. " Ramdeo Son of Late Ghurhu, aged about 24 years. 5. Mamita D/o Late Ghurhu, aged about 20 years. Respondent No.l to 5 are presently residing at Village Sohagpur (Dhhapna), Police Station Jainagar, Tahsil Surajpur, District Surguja (C.G.). 6. Jagdeo Son of Late Ghurhu, aged about 16 years. 7. Ku. Lalita D/o Late Ghuriiu, aged about 10 years. ]|ll!ill<l|l ::il;!-l:t"!i;'I.Biaa ., ^-^&^i-^^^^ ^!.K''s':WWSs3^'^^^^ ^tlt.^.'r.'^^:~'^^~~" ~" - ^•••'•——•^•i DEFENDANTS ® Respondent No.6 to 7 are residents of Village Kumda Basti, Police Station Jainagar, Tahsil Surajpur, District Surguja (C.G.). 8. Mst. Mohar Maniya D/o Late Lalan, aged about 36 years. 9. Mst. Somaro D/o Late Lalan, aged about 34 years. 10. Mst. Sukhmen D/o Late Lalan, aged about 32 years. ' 11. Chanderbeiiya D/o Late Lalan, aged about 30 years. 12. Mst. Shyamlal Son of Late Lalan, aged about 28 years. 13. Mst. Phoolmati D/o Late Lalan, aged about 25 years. 14. Mst. Lalmati D/o Late Lalan, aged about 23 years. Respondent No. 8 to 14 are residents of Village Kumda, Police Station Jainagar, Tahsil Surajpur, District Surguja (C.G.). 15. Smt. Budhiyaro Wife of Late Pawan, aged about 52 years. 16. Umat Son of Late Pawan Sai, aged about 30 years. ^fcto*"" l.i^i^ri.i.^Mlstifaittn i!J; 1 -v-vf^ivwTm'^sw'^^s^ .'fs'"~:it^~--a-^ ^e'Stf^s/??^., ...-•^^^ .'a:.-:;y^'-t'^:3^'?ss^fi° ?••"•?:•^•^^'~--~•" '^^i^g^ ^ Respondent No.15 to 16 are residents of Village Kumda, Tahsil Surajpur,District Surguja (C.G.). 17. South Eastern Coal Area, Vishrampur, through the General Manager, Vishrampur, Tahsil Surajpur, District Surguja (C.G.). 18. State of Madhya Pradesh (Now Chhattisgarh), through the Collector Surguja (C.G.). 19. Bhagwat Son of Dharam Sai, Caste Chamar, aged about 45 years, Resident of Village Kumda Basti, Police Station Vishrampur, Tahsit Surajpur, District Surguja (C.G.). 20. Sarojan Son of Sukul, Caste Panika, aged about 30 years, Resident of Village Kumda Basti, Police Station Vishrampur, Tahsil Surajpur, District Surguja (C.G.). 21. Wahab Son of Kadir Miyan, aged about 56 years, Resident of Village Datiya, Police Station Jainagar, Tahsil Surajpur, District Surguja (C.G.). WRITPETITION UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA 1. PARTICULARS OF THE PETITIONER As given in the cause title. 2. PARTICLLLARS OFTHE RESPONDENTS B ^? S5 nii.iKi:' ' H.'ri.ii.w ••\\Ti [sii'^i'i • :;'H':'!'F:'i?:E';1' HiGHGOURTOFCi-iHATTiSG HSTBIL^RUR SmateBetiChsHon'bifiShndusticePrashantKumarMistwa ETITiONER VWtt PQrtioR(227»N0.1792 ? 2010 KtishnaKumMSinatr uereus RESPONDENTS PhQoiuasiyaanuottiere. ShriA.K: ShuMa, csyR^i^oi^thap^tiwisr. ^ Dr^ NJ^Shulda^SenioT^iWicaiffwfffilShn V-P; Singh, fisuHseI fortfiej . SfW^^:H6.^T..\i.^:..'.:^.'^ Ms^SarffleetaMiShfa.Panetl-awy^^WeState/respon ::, :p<0ne:ror,otrser.resp6ndente.^ ,.:,.;: '\.:'';:;-^''\:^''.::".:- ".?.:i.'':" WTOT PETITiQN UNDER^TKLE 22TOF THE CONSTtTUIt^OF SNDift.^'1-: "•''••"•' l' cjK ..,.,t01J2^0)' ',: - •, Tte/^ Coyrt iras. rejsc^^piaimiflNefeRdant No.2^ appllGaatms underOrdQtSf%ie1ofG^PX^.a(^a'wte^^piicatio^ 10:ofOPA.' •••::1.: :'.::. ':^' , : "/ . ' :. (2) •Bythefir^aRpltcaKuntti&petffioneTswghil^ of tha Coyit to produce and fer taklng on rBCOid (sopy of ttie sale-aeed ^lated 0^)5<1^1; T"& said^te^eed has bew ex^ut^ jrite Pawari Sal. mxording fo the pe <^r^c<^ of tbe ^e-deed^^^^h maue avatiabSe ta hlm by the (^poRdeirt No.17—Seuih EaStem Coaifisius Umited wbon he sought ttifrlsaid COR^ Mndw RigM to Accoruingt&thepetitionQrffiesffld^le^eedissmateiBtpi^^^ i"thesUttanuisn«»^awtol»biOUS on!WQ(d<^^^^^^;^^^^^^^ (3) LeaTOed Nal Court h»rejscted the^aTO'fc^W v^ ott tt^ yro""^ '0&tSv.'::/ ..•. •' . :-..';. :. •'. .''•':.' ••-""'•'.'.•••'•••^".••".•,.••".-'...'^-.'.•'..-'• ';.•"•••"'••'-".':^,: ' :'-..',. (4) Lsoldng totae Qatui^^y^pyte iHwivsd jnttsMJt'itaRp^ a in^nal 'pieee w ^yenss>;^NK.<tt^ipa^^f^;(^Hg^U ..saitt-sle^^iG^ ^ord apfware & hs^ be^lpmafi^ety mauear^^tiei^, ^ c/. fi ^° —2, compensatsd uy imposing cost on ttis petitionw. Accuidingiylthe appfiration uRderOsder8Rute1ofC.P^;.preferredbyttie{^tiwneFinttiefiourtbeiQW is Btfowsu on the payinerit s^cost of Rs.50(y-. / (5) Other appite^on ^ich has b^n dsaded by ttie^triai <^rt^^^ preferred by the peftiwier underOfder 13 Rite '10 <rf C.P.C; The petiijoner made a prayer tfiat the QHginal cppy uf the sale-deeu isi in possessiOt! of respondsnt Nu.17 — S.b.Q.t^ and ihey ^ould tw direv^ to p^^ copy i" the IriaS Court. Qn 16?C©/201QthisCourt had attepfedftie f^iest of responde'itNo.lJ—S.E.C.L.forpermtffingittofileapaffidayitasto^fffeetttet thesaidtfocumentisinpossTOsionofS.E.C.L.? < <6) An affidavit has teen filed by S.EX;A.. maidng a statement ftat c-iuinat copy ofthesaie-deedisnotavaiiabtetn ttie S.E.C.L. (7) inviBwwtheaKOTBstetemBniroadebsfespomientNo, IT-S.E.O.L., pa}»fmadet>ythnp9 onwma( iic^onuRdeTOfdw13Rute10^ has rightly been rsjected by thetriaS Coyrt. (8) Leamed counse! for ffie petitlohar srouiy sulMnit ttiat untess the griglria' copy of ttie saie-deed is fno^d irt accoidance wiUi law the ge6tiQn8r maynQtbeausetQD">(luc6®vide(jceinsuppQrtQfNscTOeaR(iAiuyitWay advereiyaffect his ptea trt ths suit •Nee<itess tosaythat in Such asihiaiion party to a syjt is entiBed to tead secQnuaiywideriGeto prwethe exwution andGonte"t5oftK8<locy'nenti^.sai^eed1nthspre5e(rtcase,aH wnen exist9n<;B of 11i6 salo-deed fSiotjn uispute in the prwent case. The pstitioner n.he so desir^ may mow a^.^pHcauoiT {w leadff^ se^ yVIQQrtCQ. 'itti theabove observaiiQn,the linitp^Sfionispartiy aHm?ed. Sd//- Prashant Kumar Mishra } Judge t....: