HI6H COUKTCV OWWmSSWH AT 6IUSH.B %S;^&NWgON;gB!^^:'::::'''l';;';.::"'.: CC«AM: HphrBl^^t^I^a^H. BH'^U^, Ag, «r. A HON^ Sy^5<Sn^^^6!'ft!-!S?TKI.il;r; ::^Writ^Petit!<m'(a;No:;;S82f.:<tf;2QO&..,-.i-'l'w:';-;....^: g@ITT30NWi.'';^s^rt''^.:;^y'^'',B&^rc((^ali:Tr^ •?'l'sfe%'^i:.;!%'B's;iSt-?;r;;!':^ri^$ :.,',',:^:^i^^;i?i:. "'l:SiEl"-,?::?'ft|a^^ ,:the'-:C<M)ipan]es' i&^'::::''vl:'T.'l:'':'.' '-^K^SP ii^^^^ ;^:o'ffi<:eI!r|flt,^l-i-36.^(<irtiia;l<.logar>,^Nei»:' ''!' '^': -i.:l'''il^.l^Ki^^:i^ ^Signal'oi'y.^i.&j'Ranbir'^Singh.,,., ^ •::':y^.^ RESPON&BMTSJ •f- ^'''y,-vssi®/;.^'w:l:::-.:''••,:;^ '^ ;.^l^.. • • ^\}mwjL: of/" .XrK^iq^.^t^MJigh^it^'HTe^ Saci'etary.:.MJMStry',"of^Coa|,'',Nai» 6e u.,: •'(s'':^.;^':K.'^'%;®K'':;^^ ^2;^ bjrectoi'&neral ResettlementKWesf, Block-g.ie.K.'Pupain.'l'iewf.Dethi.S^r' .3.& eoal^ndial4niited,(A!6ovemnien*'of' tndia. SUtKiet'takin9K<Sincorj5oi"ated i ^lJnciei'-;conipanies:Act^l^6,tw»ijngjts; S'''^:''^?%iSt?F?^®'off!cel:'^a'K% %:N^tSJl ''w7 ?S^S)jbhcsh.^%ad,?Kolkata—.,.7QO^GOi! .^(W^.y T^rough''tes^hairni6n<un-^ ^:'??;^-.il<tlonaging^Du"ectw. :' ^wKSW'sv^: w4.ws,,^Soutt!;?6istern &)aifields..|.,iniited,i'A: 3;S^'%^StteidiaF/;C^.Corape^^of;:go(ftInclia- ^ ^^ ttd.^lhwing^ i^^^ r^ :s^K^|^eepa1tReaclfiBil'MPU^6::hh<itti!Stifti^ ^P7??®:^r[^^::^si^^!'n*w?yl^"w<^^ g^;KBit-s<^K:'^K-'A''"^:£;^^ ' .;:'5.^^^:6enei^^:^:%ancger,^^(Q^G-Co(rtraet ^':^;Sg Managefflsnf::.,Ceil)g;:.SoUtlT;:i;Eastei!n, 'f;?. ^gSCo?lfields':.'Limited;:::;560.:,. ghtaian;; ^^Sft^&epirftood^Bi|ai^^'(^h<rtti^a^ ;Writ Petition underArticle 226ofethe Cbhstitutionaof India Writfet»tionfaNo.708Bof2006 permoNBi l<&/s.sVincyd< &<-Ssniicemen%Cpa! CatTiera-'iPnvate ' .Limited,' • AR,?'&<-^ Servicsmen Conl Tronsport CoiKpary jBeorjwated throughlCSRAawng its,: registered office at R.O. 31 &alcyi £r;cldve K<2Tkh<^ia, Secunde^sbaci (^P) ond;:: iocci otfics at OCM, - dhai, &Ei;tr'.i&t ftaig<3rh (^ihsttlsgar^) throUgh i~ts Power of Attorney Hoider Sh'-lT Ram KJ^ho^eSirf^hti^ • VERSUS . '•:' RESPONOENTS : L- z. Union of India, 't-hrQugh- thfe 5sci*etory, &tini3try' of Coat,. Nsw Oelhi. ' Director ^enerai Res.ettlement. W&st Siock-3, R.K. Purom. Kew Deihi. 3. Coai India Limited, (A 6overnment of Indic Uniiartakinj), ineoi'por'ated under companies <Act, 19o6, having its Regjstei-ed office at 10, Wataji Subhash Road, Kolkata - 700 001 (W.B.} itirOij^fT ft5 C.hC>r':llt<3i1-£lim- Monagins tSir'ector'. 4. 5outh £a5tern Codffieids Limited. A Si.ibsiditiry Coa', Company of Ccial India Ltd., having its registered office at Ssepat Road, giia&pui'' (Chhattisgcf^;) thr'ou9^ its Chairman-cum-ManaairM " ."^ 5. <?enerai Mana9er (CMC-Contr'fKt Mainag£m£nt C£i!), South Ecstern Coalfieids Limited, SECL Bhawan, Sezpat Rofid, Bi!aspyr'(0-ihct-fisga'h) Writ PetiTion under Article 226 of the Constitution of India Writ Petition (O No. S316 of 2006 fEWSQNBt Chhattisgarh Coaj Tran^port Private LliTiited, an Ex-S£rvice <an Cumpsriy, Incorporatsd under the Companies Act, 1956, 'nwinj its r'egistered Office at 110 (E), Phase- II. Mayur Vihar, Me- Deihi 92 n-iough its ftesiderit Director, Honorca^y Captain Omprakcsh 5heokand, S/o Shri Late 5hrj Banwcri Lai 5heokand. V€8SUS -p5ffiDBEFOK3 HON'BUB JDUStics Sri. LC^ r..c.]-<^ St-i'- nbirendta -3- Rg5i>ONO£NTS l 1. Union of Inam, tnrough . Tbe S^ci-'etsry-, Mir.istfy of Coui;, New' Oeihi. 2. C>tra£tor5eneralResettiement,West Bioek-3, R.K. Puram. Nisw Delhi. 3, Coai India Limited, (A 6over'nraent of Xnaifi: Under't'takidg), in<;orporate4 under c&mpanie^ Act, 1956, howih9 its Rs^i^t^'3^ office at 10, Net<yi 5ubhosh Road, Koikato - 700 001 (W.B.) Through its Choirman-cuni- Managing DireCTor. 4. . South Eostern Coalfields Limited, A ] Si^sidlarf Cool Con\^any ofCoal Indifi l-tci..hflvin9 its registered office at Seepat Rocd, Eilaspar (Chhettisgarfi) throu9h its • Chairman-cum-Managing Oirectc.r, ;. . ' ; . 5. . Ssnerai Managar (CMC-Contract M(3RG9<£w<g?1^' ^£^)< 5outh Ea^tern Coalfieids Limitad, SECL Snawan, Seep&t Road, Biidipuf (Chhattfsgiirh) WntPetition^undep Article 226 of the Constjtution of Inctia Present; SHri Mariindra Shrivostfflfa, Senior Advocate with Shri Amrito D<ri; Shri Shasiiank Thakur, sounsel for •t-he E;etitioners- ' Thokuf' Wjay Swigh, AiSiStatt Soficitor Senerclwith Shri S.K. Seriwat Standing Counse) fop Union of ' Iwiia / respond&nti No.l d 2. . Shri A.jit Kumar Sinha with Shri P.S. Koshy. Advocate for responden'fa No. 3 to 5. . • ORAL ORD® {Pcssed cn 2S'11 Orteber, Z007) The fQliowing or-at order of the Cqurt was passed by Hon'bte Jagdish Bhciia, Ag. CT. Sinca question involved in ai! tnese three Birit petitions is similor, they are bein9 heard and djsposed sf bythis common order. ' A fair statement has been made on behalf of respondents No.3to5 that the contract gf the petitioners will continue till jts logical ^) K "^, 1>: ^. .L- f~'' rry subbu, -M' end and whatever amount of work tney are gettinq ;for the lastone yecu', they will continue to 9ef the same. Accprdingiy, interest of Justice wiii suffice if the petitions are disposed of in the Ijght of ths stotement made by Searned counsei for the re3!pondent3 No.3 to 5. It is cEarified that in case the petitionaps' contract is offected hereinafter, they wouid be at jib&rt/ to file fr&^i writ petitions and fiiing of these petitibns wiil rtot come i'n the way of the petitioners. Consequences to foilcw and th& respondent^ m<3/ pursue the tender noticd. , However, they s(fidi act according to the memorqndum of undeptaKin9 dated 16-04-1999. With th&se observations, the writ petitions stand fincliy disposed of. Interini order aranted edrlier, if any, stands di^charged, Sd/- Acting Chief Justice Sd/- SatishK.Agnihotri Judge ^-- •"s