\w In the HonbleHieh Coyrt ofChhattishgarh at Bilaspur (C.G.) W.P.No. ^S-/5^ 2006 Petitioner ....^. .^...." Janki Dhurve aged 42 years, Wife of ^^^ ^ Shri Gandhi Ram Dhurve p'^..-'^y ^ Assistant Teacher, Govt. Giris Primary ^^..•'' ^ School, Village Dangarh, Block Mohala, '^'••'{a/ District Rajnandgaon (C.G.) ...'y .^^7 VERSUS i^/fy" ^ ^tespondent... ../ l. The State Govemment of Chhattishgarh, Through the Secretary, Tribal Welfare Department Ministry, D.K.S. Bhavan, Raipur (C.G.) /' 2. The Principal, Govt. Higher Secondary School, Village Dangarh, Block Mohla District - Rajnaadgaon (C.G) Writ petition under articles 228/227 of the Constitution of India for issuance of writ m the nature of MANDAMUS, Certiorari, Prohibition and other syitable WRIT or writs, Order or orders, Direction or directions. hffSH COURTOFCHHATTESSARH AT BILASPUR Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioners Respondents Petitioners Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents W. P. No. 2812 of 2006 Rameshwar Singh Sahu Versus The Sta'te 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh A another W. P. No. 2814 of 2006 N.R. Mandloi (Nekram) Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. P. No. 2815 of 2006 Janki Dhurve Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh <& cmother W. P.(5Wo. 3361 of 2005 Shrimati Sangita Dixit. Versus State 6ovt. of Madhya Pradesh (Now Chhcrttisgarh) & others W. P.(S)No. 3505 of 2005 5mt. Shraddho Agrawal & onother Versus State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & others W. P.f5)No. 3873 of 2005 |<u. Nisha Supta and others Versus State 6ovt. of Oihattisgarh & others W. P.fSWo. 4146 of 200S Smt. Konchhani Agrawal Versus The State (?ovt. of Chhatt-isgarh <& another W. P.fSWo. 4158 of 2005 Versus Anil Kumar Prasad TTie State ^ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Reqsondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Reqaondents Petitioner Respondents W. P.f5)No. 4163 of 2W5 Smt. Sadhna Yadav Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.f5)No. 4165 of 2005 Smt. Anita Rajput Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.fSWo. 4178 o-f 2005 Mukesh Ram 5ahu Versus The Sta+e 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & ahother W. P.fSWo. 4209 of 2005 Smt. Padma Thakur Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh A another W. P/5)No. 4306 of 2005 Ku. Pratibha Bhardwaj Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh A another W. P.f5)No. 4333 of 2005 Ram Prasad 5ao Versus The State Govt. of Chhattisgarh & W. P.(5)No. 4335 of 2005 Johan Ram Sahu Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhdttisgarh A another W.P.f5)No.4337ofZ005 Versus Monharanlat Sahu T1ie State 6ovt. of CTihattisgorh & cmother Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Reqiondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents W. P.CSWo. 4348 of 2005 Lalit Narayan Sharma Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & onother W. P.(SWo. 4381 of 2005 Parsadi Ram SAu Versus The State <3ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.fSWo. 4383 of 2005 Tula Ram Sahu Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.(SWo. 4388 of 2005 Kamal Narcyon Oewangan Versus TTie State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & ano'ther W. P.(5)No. 4417 of 2005 Ishwarlal Yadaw Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhuttisgarh & another W. P.fSWo. 4459 of 2005 Jiwon Lal Madriya Versus The Sta+e ©ovt.of Chhattisgarh & ano-t+ier W. P.fSWo. 4481 of 2005 Smt. Kamala Bai Chandraker Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh <& another W. P.(5)No. 45TO of 2005 Verais Smt. Kanak Lata Sharma The State ©ovt.of Gihattisgarh & ano-ther Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents W. P.(S)No. 4593 of 2005 Shyam Lal Taram Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.fSWo. 4594 of 2005 Petitioner : Jagram Singh Devwxngan Versus Respondents : The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & Wtother W. P.fSWo. 4595 of 2005 Petitioner : Aslam Khoui Versus Respondents : The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & onother W. P.fSWo. 4596 of 20)5 Saroj Singh Rajpoot Versus The State Govt. of ChhattiS9arh & wiother W. P.fSWo. 4616 of 2005 Petitioner : Smt. Kiran Soni Versus Req)ondents : The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & onother W.P.fSlNo. 4617 of 2005 Narendra Kumar Sahu Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & anolher W. P.(5)No. 4649 of 2005 Ramakant Shrivastava Versus The State 6ov+. of Chhattisgarh & onother W. P.fSWo. 4660 of 2005 Versus Chait Ram Sharendra The.State 6ovt. of Chhattisgdrh & ano-rtier Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents W. P.(5)No. 4661 of 2005 Toran Singh Nishad Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh A mother W. P.^SWo. 4662 of 2005 Ramesh Kumar Sahu Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W.P.fSWo. 4664 of 2005 Toran Lat Chandarwanshi Versus The Stote 5ovt. of Chhattisgarh & cmother W. P.(5)No. 4666 of 2005 Vijcy Kumaran lyer Versus The 5tate ©ovt.of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.f5)No. 4669 of 20)5 Mahendro Kumar Namdeo Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.f5)No. 4670 of 2005 Ravikont Verma Versus The State Sovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.(S)No. 4672 of 2005 Mangatu Ram Vaman Versus The 5tate 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & cmother' W. P.fSlNo. 4688 of 2005 Verais Ram ji Yadaw The 5tate ©ovt.of Chhattisgarh <& ano'ther Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Responden+s Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents W. P.fSWo. 4691 of 2005 Dileep Kumar Thakur Versus The State Govt. of Chhattisgarh A another W. P.fSWo. 4694 of 2005 Doyatoo Ram Patel Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. MS)No. 4722 of 2005 Munna Lal 5ao Versus The 5tate 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh A another W.P.fSWo. 4727 of 2005 Rajendra Singh Thakur Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.CSlNo. 4728 of 2005 Virendra Kumar vaishnav Versus The State Govt. of Chhattisgarh & cnother W. P.fSWo. 4733 of 2005 Bhim Rao Khobragarhe Versus The Sfta-te Govt. of Chhcxttisgarh & another W. P.(S)No. 4742 of 2005 Ku.Shaji Anthony Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh A another W. P.15)No. 4743 of 2005 Versus Smt. Anjana Sao The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh <S another Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Re^iondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents W. P.fSWo. 4744 of 2005 Smt. JO/Q Tolay Versus The State Govt. of ChhattiS9arh <& <woth&r W. P.f5)No. 4745of 2005 Shri Somen Kundu Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.fSWo. 4746 of 2005 Smt. Monju Shukla Versus The State Govt. of Chhattisgarh & cnother W. P.(5)No. 4747 of 2005 Shri J.P. Shyam Versus The State Govt. of Chhattisgarh & onother W. P.CSWo. 4748 of 2005 Smt. Vaidehi Chourasia Versus TTie 5-ta-te 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & onother W. P.fSWo. 4749 of 2005 Saji Baby Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.CSlNo. 4755 of 2005 KcngluRam Mandavi Versus The Sta+e 6ovt. of Chhattis9arh <& another W. P.fSWo. 4760 of 2005 Versus Ram Kumar Mandavi TheState 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.f5)No. 4782 of 2005 Petitioner : Priy Ram Bhuoury Versus Req)ondents : TTie State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W.P.f5)No. 4798 of 2005 Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Respondents Dewarika 5ahu Versus The 5-tate 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & nnother W.P.(5)No. 4809 of 2005 Ashok Kumar AIha Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.f5)No. 4849 of 20)5 Smt. Tarun Verma Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh i& another W. P.fSlNo. 4864 of 2005 t5hanwa Ram Sahu Versus The State Govt. of Chhattisgarh A cmother W. P.15)No. 4865 of 2005 Darshcn Lal Sahu Versus The State 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & onother W. P.fSWo. 5012 of 2005 Smt. Kusum Verma Versus The State Govt. of Chhattisgarh & another W.P.f5)No. 5147 of 2005 Versus Sukhram Sahu The State Sovt. of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.f5)No. 5157 of 2005 Petitioner : Mohit Ram Margiya Versus Respondents : The State 6ovt. of Chhatt-isgarh A another W. P.fSWo. 5159 of 2005 Petitioner : Prem Singh Ratre Versus Reqaondents : The State 6ovt. of ChhattiS9arh & another W. P.^5)No. 5160 of 2005 Petitioner : Manthir Ram Bhomdari Versus Respondents ; The State ©ovt.of Chhattisgarh & another W. P.(5)No. 5161 of 2005 Petitioner Respondents Petitioner Reqiondents Mansukh t>as Sahu Versus The 5tate 6ovt. of Chhattis9arh & onother W. P.f5)No. 5162 of 2005 Versus Manoo Ram Pisda The S'tate 6ovt. of Chhattisgarh & another Single Bench: Hon'ble Mr. Justice Satish K. Agnihotri. Shri Ajay Shrivastava, Advocate for the Petitioners. 5hri V.V.S. Moorthy, Dy. Advocate Seneral with Smt. Anju Ahuja, Dy. ©ovt.Advocate for •the respondents/State. ORDER (11th October, 2006) 1. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submits that while working as Assistant Teachers/Upper Oivision Teachers, the petitioners have gone on training to improve their 10 qualifications on their own expenses ond acquired B. Ed./B.T.I Examination Certificate. 2. The present writ petitions, being W.P. Nos. 2812/2006, 2814/2006, 2815/2006, W.P.(5) Nos. 3361/2005, 3505/2005, 3873/2005, 4146/2005, 4158/2005, 4163/2005, 4165/2005, 4178/2005,4209/2005.4306/2005,4333/2005,4335/2005, 4337/2005, 4348/2005, 4381/2005, 4383/2005, 4388/2005, 4417/2005, 4459/2005, 4481/2005, 4570/2005, 4593/2005, 4594/2005, 4595/2005, 4596/2005, 4616/201S, 4617/2005, 4649/2005, 4660/2005.4661/2005, 4662/2005, 4664/2005. 4666/2005,4669/2005,4670/2005,4672/2005,4688/2005, 4691/2005,4694/2005,4722/2005,4727/2005,4728/2005, 4733/2005,4742/2005.4743/2005,4744/2005,4745/2Q05, 4746/2005,4747/2005,4748/2005.4749/2005,4755/2005, 4760/2005,4782/2005,4798/2005.4809/2005.4849/2005, 4864/2005, 4865/2005, 5012/2005, 5147/2005, 5157/2005, 5159/2005. 5160/2005, 5161/2005 ond 5162/20)5 involve simibr facts and common question of law. Thus, these 3. petitions are being disposed of by this common order. According to tearned counsel for the petitioners, the petitioners are entitled to two advance increments in view of the decision of this Court in the case of Yashwant Kumar Bharadwaj Vs. Municipal Corporation, Durg and another {2006^ 11 (EI) MPJR-CG 96}. This Court in the case of Yashwant Kumar Bharadwaj Vs. Municipal Corporation, Durg and another (Supra), came to the conclusion that the teachers, who had obtained B. Ed./B.T-I. Examination Certificate on his own expenses, are covered by the circular dated 24.12.98 issued by •the State Sovemment of Madhya Pradesh. 4. Learned counsel for the petitioners further submits that the facts cnd question of law involved in the present caises are squarely covered by decision of this Court in the case of Ycishwant Kumar Bharadwaj Vs. Municipal Corporation, Durg cmd another (Supra), to which leamed counsel appearing for the respondents fairty concedes and agrees with the averment made by tearned counsel dppearing for the petitioners. 5. Accordingty, the writ petitions are allowed in terms of •the order passed in the case bf Yashwant Kumar Bharadwaj Vs. Municipat Corporotion, Durg and another (Supra), subject to verification of the fact as to whether the petitioners have acquired B. Ed./B.T-I. Examination Certificate on their own \ expenses or not. No order as to costs. 6. A copy of this order be placed on record of other connected writ petitions. Sd/- Satish K. Agnihotri Judge Subhash