H .guG'JRTih: Frih'i” $ Q¥§T 3L‘$?UR EWEEEQN EEN$H: “haw HU\§’E5L; MR T.?.5..§i Milk . HUN‘ELh w‘iR. R‘L. vnanwai‘; JJ. ‘ hvpeian P :1 fir: Ja§!} ' - ‘ .k'i‘ n" Ram 33m S‘b advwa Sahu u 5 \éar RIG Naaa’Wat nK Laxm ’nov k, mgr ram” kanda, matBiiwpu {Shh “.sc'arh) Vamas / . esysndem , ' (cw: cf Chhat+$gérh thmugh the ' viatwn H Jse Off‘cer PB. ‘Saykanda, I J3; {i awu, {wuhmdagarh} ‘ I. ’ {CRWWALAEPEAL‘umta SEmmN 314 (2) uF THE CwE OF cmmmAL PROCEDUREwm) ‘ ' harmm Sn... Lax caunsei 'm *he appei a“ MrsMadha Niaha $Engh, Pare awver 0: thee Qtate {esamdew I ‘ A_ . ‘ r A urn-KL JL§x§i£ENw ' ‘ ' {Pasged on 22"“ June, 2w; 1) ‘F‘f'er T‘?,$ha'rma,' .5;— (i‘naiéenge in this appeal: is to we jqugmani’af canwciien & aréér 0f i sén‘zenca daied 4.3.“.2035' pa$se§ by the Ses'sians Judge, $3§iaspi§r_ in ‘ $ess§i$ns Ta'iai‘ NG.¢2‘.’;‘2QG4, wharéby & whereum‘er Earned Sessions g Judge aftsrr ha§diag the " igui gLm for camm§ss§an a? cmpabie, hamic'gde ammmting t0 'mruer o! Lam a Aba'" Junid Khan sonvicié‘d h'm‘ unaier .Sectisn $2 a? me EEC. and sanienced w underga ‘ img'iwnmwt %Gr Me and fine m Rs i GVGF in aéfauit 0f payment 0f iiiie ' 'r‘her ginuei'go R i mr three manins JP (3C) <. A.“ .ciian is imgugned an the gmund that wii‘n'oui there being an" ieie ef evidence, ‘he iriai ‘Ceuri hae cenvieied & eenienceaxrm a peiiant as.‘ afaewemmred and thereby cwurniiied iiiegeiiiy. 3. As per case oi preeeeutien, wife ef ihe eepeiiani namely Kunii Etailw ount e werking i. ‘ne nuns ei .911 eeeeeeed . Laie .- genie ..i.. Knan. ’»‘ {in r aie n i iere W’s eiemte beiween ape iiant em“; ih ae acc n el’ } n-u-n u ' u ’ Vr m: aamw (my : 35??§4 bnt‘wa‘. n w 1 pm at may the eceased ham“ M the wuhse w {he appariani, 3am a§ie¥catian “i" b iw . hem, thereafter the appeiiant assaui‘ted ':c£aase{i Khan by smk and sauseci his §a3iantane$u$iy deaih, Neégnbaum hgafd sauna 0f quag'rei aw thereaf€e t ay came ii; the spat. The appa§§azni was aEso shautin that fie is 'min iam Khar‘.‘ $m€.Uitara SEai \ fPW-2‘ I naghbew sf the aepeémnt eiee vis§ted the heuee ef zhe aepeéieni em {edged merg in‘zima‘tien wee ExPz‘S end FJR. m'P?’ énveeegatmg effiem preceeded ’m scene cf eccurrenee ene' after eummenéng the meSaes e EXPIE p erqrea mqeeet we, tee bedy ef {he eeeeeeee 'id'e EXPI'E. V modem ned sen, men eoai am: ene eiic were eemeu rem ow; @e x. r Seat map *as prepareu v} meegetznv m e e5 ef the eeceeeee‘ ‘ es sen: fa ' eeey t ifm , / e iieepuf v§de EXFW5wh .re SrA 5' $huKa (PJ‘ i3 c ndue€ed e 'tepm' Gf deceased La: Knau we“ W PH3 nd found “eEiewing II E e; side sf th— necks we para§ie§ conius ens ever m“ neck. Fresh iacereted wound e! “ft gamete! eeciy: ai 'eg n sf h cm. x 2 emenn hone deep cempnsmg freetum‘ 0f ‘7 sparie€e¥ bane. Fresh iesereted wsunef ever §0wer ja‘v' i 5 cm. x i cm. x hone deeh cemprisin§ Iracmre ef laws; jaw vv) Fresh iecersied weund over chm cl cm. x 1 cm. x bane deen cemnx’isihg frectwe of chin bene‘ Tweheshi rateci Vvounes ui1 err A 8 um an “m. x ; 6m 6V6: fig'm SnGLH a: gnnmshh ever righi chest (vi?) Centusien 0f z? cm. x crn. v Hen: ninpm. (vhi) Two pavaiiei’eoniusiens ever en 3:. (ix) Twe cex‘ iusicns ever chest. (x) Twn centusiene ever back“ (XS; :- "s x a’agghg ”he x ever n" tiereerm. {xh} aiemnees are' v4 "gnt eye ”'2‘ <~ xx A ‘ m ‘ " ‘ I CahSF e? a a wa$ uqrmg *he cuhue Gf .nvcsuga an me accused was iaken inio cuSiady, ”e mat} isaicsme stateme’u or exm Ida Ev 5:3 sam" :‘aa naen 0"" rd al the mstance 3f ihe appeimni me E P15 -’-’ we: I“ ned cisih sf ihe appeiiaw‘ was se§zed vide EXP/4. Bbmatair‘ed "miacs er“ the deceasad were seized vide Ex I’M veizea mcies were seat .or wrcmaa. eAamlngtion am yin: n e 3f “Emu Cm g; 1"‘ i-ur GI Q) m 2'} G h appenant ans smK was csnfirmea ":de EA‘P 2G. ' i iem‘enis m i: 'v nesses w 'e reaard€d under $ea€§s. 15i m‘ ii‘e CahC. aha afte mp.eticu of .m' s ganan Ubarge a’mct was iiea ‘r‘ the Cami 0f Shief Judiciai. Maa§st.'a€e,_ Eh $pur, Wm Er k ”’1 omumtzeu fne UaSe {as I?“ aun 0‘ wasgm‘s m§a3p W in mder i0 pmve the gmit ef ihe acausediappesiani, ihe pmse’cu%éen has , ‘ examined as many as ihirteen witneseee. S‘cat mem of i‘ne ' ppe§§ant we even. uncéer vectma 313 ef the ’Cr‘F.C., in which he denied mu Circumeimneee eggpiearing egainst him and pieacieii innocence and faise impiicaticn in ihe srime in quesiien. Afier pmvidingvsppertuni‘zy Gi‘heai’ing tc ihe panies, ieemed aeseione Judge eon 'ictea' &senienced ine appeiiant as aferemeniioned; . We have heard Ms Sharmiia Shinghai; couneei far the appeiieni end Mrsiviwm Nisha Singh Pane. Lei/ye fer ihe Sieie, ‘pereeed ihe "‘dcn‘er‘t irnpagne nu recsrei sf the Iriei Ceurt. Learned couneei is? the a? ei ni submiis ihei in in“ “reseni oase- ecnvicmn is beeed en cimumeien‘iai m'iaenw, eseeeiaiiy aiiegeu extaui- a e a ghuicml non‘eesiou rr'aue by me apeeiiani be‘ere ludmjit Soni {P ) era quarrei teuk pii e in ti‘e noiiee u, it” eepeiiant ei ihe ti” e inmdeut gearnea ccense: fwine ubmiie i'net a.eresaid wdene ie Hui i ”a“: xer girewing definite cenciueien i'r‘at the pi e n* appeiiant ' i nae 'r'ieu euipabie hemic’ide amount: g .e mum'er sf Leia Khan.‘ .—. ) aceueeem . i ‘ Learned cauneei ce'niended inai even as eer case 0i the preeecuiien the I ' appeiieni was net nepp" wiih ihe acii ‘ity ef the deceeee nd w'fe ci m V _ appei ant Prm'icusly’t e appeiiani has direcieci the e‘eceaeeu nei LO vwii 1 ' ‘nis muse. a) . *n da e “f inciuent and m we “r“e incicieni, when the i « deeeaeee‘ came to ihe muse c: the appeiiant then'en eude‘en quartet . wiihcut 'premediiation and sudden prcvocatim tha awe ant scat s 'Iemper a s" caused afaresaid injuries r m g intc death sf the deceased shows ihai the ap§e§§ant has hat causea‘ mj‘ {es with inient to cause ms dcath um ai lh m9 c' “wang sac‘n inguries he was having kns J: cige that ' H. aut the aec‘easeu {ray cue therem.e the act {if ihe “ppciEan' hoes mt have; heyona the scogse cf 3ectmh $4 ua't- a! 'F {-Ers u PC . On the uthm hahaT, ‘ea ned .State games; auypeueu the judgment :myugneu and submit ihe't ihe gresent appehani has causeei mere man hfieen my es "iihg ihtc fra t- re of dh’fereni par: er henes n we reuse of iue appeimnt ‘c th ec “ed sncwe the a ve :hze m fer eeusing cuipauie hemmgae a'nuunu. 3 t0 murdeu“ 6f the eec asea ea' '"pp'euaamg tne endeh e ave§ieble 0n record, me tn Ceurt has Whwc: and eeh€ehceu me ehpeheht as afmemehtienea .m em‘ o aypre e ‘he a gtmerts ed anced oh behaf Y ". “ariies, ' I» 'e have exemihe be eV' enwe a" H be 0h reeerd. .En me present uaee, hum“. death as a resmk e' fete} xh ' :es fauna ever the bady "‘ the deeeased L'“a Khan has not been sube ntia“ i ""spdted 0n ee’tet‘ ef the appetter‘t e‘mn etherw‘ee, a' ‘° eetebttehee by the eviwence of ur.A.t‘\. hu .a, (PW 13}, and "“topsy pen ‘3“ P/ De u. u te K. ar‘ wee romctdai tn nature. :..- N! .As regarde‘the compttcity er’ the eppettant tn crime in quest: . , A nvietreh is eubetantiatt‘ based en the evtdenc o‘ tndr 3n $0..i (Pt H‘, netghheur 0 he e’W‘t r“ wuo ”as eepeeed that at the ume er u.ctdeht he heard eeunct cf querret tram the heuee o' the hp tent, eut uh a oun‘t et‘reth he did net tmmedietet, vm‘tthe ha‘ee Gt he appetaent, t; tetter semettme the appeitent Came towe de me home of th‘s Witness and askec' him ”'r‘etne. . '9 Wife nae curve rerde as .iuuse er net. tter he” 3 mega ive repiy he again went hacx {awards his neuee, thereafter he saw uead way 0f deceased Late Khan in verandah of the apheitaht. n pare 9 e.‘ his evtdehcehe nae ”tee aehesed that the appetient was hutuing st: k ahd eheutihg that he has kites Lara Khan. uetence has f crass—examined this witness at tength, but has net been abte te etictt anything in . s erase-e‘mminat to diecar he tesimcny, esp lu n m re’5aiing t0 the fa"i . a quarrei docs ”G. {ouk pla m ihe ham appeJum n .as nu: 'raue exa'a ea ex%. 'udmla: comes i n ha: ‘nas ieu h ‘ Khan. Afo esaad ev’adewcc .s wed ccrmbo ed ;pifomp€iy mdged F.5.‘R., merg and aisc " maulca: evidence. nus e‘l‘deme e.one is surfwicwt ‘ amug .nfe ewce the: .e appeiian e the peraer W10 ha; cadsed cqipabie eomacide emeunnrg m mum’ La Khan, met tco .n hie veramjah 4A3 'e m‘s tue ques‘tion Of metive, as per evidence Gf §ndraj§t So (9W4), at *he time of ‘énc eut q 'reE took niece in ine muse of €h - ppenant where need may uf ‘he deceased was; feuna‘, ihe‘reafte.’ h was searchmg his wne "m per paras 7 and of evidence e? 3 afrajii Son? (WV—1),;the neceaéed as Visneé ihe heuee cf fne appeiEanf semetirne and :nere we“ mspHt hetweenhueband and wife {eiating t waking menn of newn .h ° eucws mat Ire appeiiart was not haey wnn :ne ant: n3. e‘ nis wsfe and t . e eaoeu er aes latter and mumac J‘e Gee ased w h were or Ihe appeuawt ano on aecom uf suc unnuppnesa and meeataswachou at {he nn‘e uf made'v: {he appeiie quaf'eieA wgtn me oeueaeed and cam‘ed a‘efesaa m unee x, hen ‘ , C;Ceaacu «s we he s: uf Joe aypeeam i’* snows trm 1. t deceased woui net huVe ueen Visitea Lne house o. he appe ian th "re was no cecasen For oausmg s-mh :n unee Tms caruumstqr- ’evege the vhen {he oeueasea ua’ne an the nuuse of the appehant the , {he apee ant sL ms ‘emper and en suede pxuveuation ..e has wadse muitwie :nJunes to the deceased teeutting‘ tnto ms ueeth'. This shewe tha the appeliant has caesed hetntoidet death of the deceased but withou intention and on sudden ptovocation without premeditation and o n ni; e‘ ‘ e, .‘ o ‘ y 3‘ y h ' nt '. he ; he 1 en ue n I o t t n sudden querre‘ out at the titre or causing och inmr‘, he We evi't knowieo‘ge th ' y ms act tne ueoeased mo" d.e in these carcor‘stance the act of the appei rt does rot Irate: beyond the soope or eeotion JG4 ' Part-i sfthe Leo t i 5.White convt mg ard sertewohg the appeliqnt 'r‘oier Section ‘32 of the t _t.P.C. the tna ou’t res not eorsmereo the atores o n‘ost . iaSipect a ne vase, esp y theft of the deeeaseo .n the nooae of th UV U /4‘ e a he t e. s g e I _, _., “wee ueigsv Inu ; g da ‘ucuegapgo e gagem GD S/P‘ gfnpa H'T qcueemJ \ x x x gg nmo i'