KWS MWM^ wi\y"t :.M^'^-^;^S, :g|||gr^^|:t?|%| ^^itl^;i£.:SE:''';^:^ • S^.^^ In^e^Hc>in3blel®I^^Mwito^C'IjtKa^^2[arU^^ Petifioner Respondents. ^' W.P.(S)No. <2,l|3L) 2009 .^^,Snit;!Ja;®CHandrakar,Aged,|39 ,W7o'S[hy^C^eraryiy^€|iandrak®r^•. J ' Sikc aKarmiVerg - 1 (Chemistry) Govt. Higher;Secondary Scllool, . , Borai, Disfrict Durg C.G. I VerSus. •: ;• -l.State of'Chtia.ttishgarU, ^ ThrbygEt tfae SBGretaiy,, , ^ • i'. ScUool Eclucation Deptt. ^ . D.E..S.Bhavan,Raipur . <<2. DireGtor bfpulsliclristrilictions., State (jovt. ofdihaftisligarh,. ^ Pension Bada,%Bair6n.Bazar, ' . . Raipur^(e.©.)V.-': ':''•., .'-'^ '. DistrictEducatidriOfGcer,Durg(C.G.) .tri.iy -^jD,y^,j' ^, 1,^ 4. The.EriTieipal, . : • ,' ; .,, •. Govt. Higher Secohddry School, Bprai,^ DistnctDurg (C.CT.) : .: ^^5. _Sr[tt.^D.,GKafct-avarti J . . : • Lect'urer.G'hemistry, :. : ; . HigB.er SeG<3n8arySGliopl,BoFaiPoSteiffiee i: Borai, Tah. <^Distt..J3urg , ^ . ^,:::: ! Writ Petitio!nxUn^erMrtieIe;2^,iQ^^ ^&^ .^w/i ^t^%^l.::. issUanee..Qfiwniil8^Mait(taBiius^iiii3tii^ writ." •'' : ••' ^••?:';:::': ' ; ^1". :' .;':';:;'' :;..':"i; l.: 1 • '•':!1': '•:'^-i1^ PET!TIQNER HlGHCOURr^lSCHHAI-HSGUyffiBiy^SPUR^ (Hori. Mr. Justice Pritinker Diwaker) Writ Petition (S) No. 3494of2009 Smt. Jaya Chandrakar VERSUS RESPONDENTS State of Chhattisgarh and others. <B -"rt *-, Shri Sorokant Verma counsel for thepetitioner. Shri YashwantSingHThakurwithSmt.SmithaGhaiPL fortherespondents No. 1 to 4/State. WR1T PETITIONUNDERARTICLE2260FTHEGONSTITUTIONOF INDIA ORDER (16.07.2009) With theconsentofthecounselfdrthepatties,ithematterisheard finally. Chalienge in this petition is to the oixler datecli6.7.2009 passeei by respondent No.3 by which the petitjonerwHoisworKingonthepostof Shikslia Karmi Grade-1 has been transferred from iGovemment Migher Secondary School Borai to t-figher SeeondaFy Sctiool Pinkapar. i Counsel for the petitioner submits that the order impugned jhas been passed underthe policy ofrationalizationtreatingthepetitionCTas surplus. He farther submits that in fact the petitipner is not su^plus because one Smt. D. Ctiakraborty hasjoined in the present sGhool bfthe i3etitioner after the petitionerjoinedthere. 1-lesubrtits that the trari^er order has been issued ort 6.7.200g i.e: aft^r imposition of ban aihc) ^no approval from the office of Chiet Ministertias been cibtained. He sutiimits that husband ofthe petitjQner issyffenng reaSoRalso, "the iFnpygnedtransfei-orcleFi&ljabletot^^quashe'd pnthe^eFhand;c(3Brase|;fi|gtMit[r^iQn(ien1^State^s^ the petitionermaRes a (•epFesiellgtiCTlIjto same shall bec6i3sidei^]andffiailii|iiii^(^raar^e^w ::RrapositiQn'of:lhei'Srtat6|ec^&Stig|e0||^j^r^ ^agresment;:-./'.,:'. .'^."';. ^m^^M« ?1; , Aecoraingly,j?the petitioi]i;t^<ii§|ios^ autt'iQFities coneerraed'tfaatjin3C^|g|t|teiJF^ijtitFi|F frorn mouth Ganeeriantt fgr ileKaiuttiOJTit!es^^(|)n^|ri||^S o^WitH ^S:^S!"^-^^ —.^^^a':Ssi.'; :'i~'.:::,:;;-.,'^\ • ^ : •:!:':.'. •:. ^it|in;|ssgeribd^^'1@|8^|Wt^;iatel^j^ei^^ ^theIsame shallbe de(^<c^ wilBiR a fHrthigi-iiiiericJdWlthir^e weeks fi-om the clatedfitsreceipt.Tillthentheorderimpugnedshallremainlifeless. :-<&,-. ff Sd/- Pritinker Diwaker Judge L