C^ ((^^ '© SIN6LE BEt<Stf ^ m <. IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATISGARH AT BILASPUR ( CHHATISGARH) WRIT APPEAL N0. ia QF2009 (Arising out oforder dated 9.4.09 passed by the Single Bench ofthis Hon'ble Court, Hon'ble Justice Shri Dhirendra Mishra in W.P. No. 752 of2009) APPELLANT PETITIONER ^ ?' <^ff/ ^ / ^ / .^Af/ •^/^ / ^ /^/ yMs/ / ^ c"?/ / <?^>" ^•L,? ^ -^oc\ •{"^ ^ 1. Rakesh Kumar Gupta, S/o. Shri Ganeshdin Gupta, aged about 34 years, r/o. Village & Post KhatKhari Tehsil Hanumana Distt. Rewa (MP), Ex. ITI Apprentice (Electrician) South eastern Coalfields Limited., Chirimiri Area, Distt.Korea (CG). fyTiJ.ci^ Sluyv^W^ 2. Dwarika msadShrivatav; S/o. Shri Vanshmani Prasad Shrivsatav, aged about 37 years, R/o. village and Post KhatKhari, Tehsil Hanumana Distt.REwa (MP) Ex. ITI Apprentice (Electrician) South eastem Coalfields Ltd., Chirimiri Area, Distt. Korea (CG) Raj Kumar Patel, S/o. Shri Ram Gopal Patel, Aged about 37 years, R7o. Gram & Post Hardi Tehsil Gurh, District Rewa, Ex. ITI Apprentice (Electrician) SECL, Bishrampur Area, Distt.Korea (CG) Daya Shankar Singh, S/o. Shri Ram Gopal Singh, aged about 37 years, R/o. D.M.Q. 167, Infront ofG.M. Office, Bishrampur (Ambikapur District Korea (CG), ;' 56-06 •°9 G) (\ ^ Ex-ITI Apprentice (Seat Metal) SECL, Bishrampur Area, District Korea (CG). ^ Badri Prasad Dahiya, S/o. Shri Dasrath Prasad Dahiya, Aged about 37 years, R/o. Railway Colony, Ward No.6, Dhanpuri, District Shahdol (MP) Ex. ITI Apprentice (Tumur) SECL, Baikunthpur Area, District Korea ^ Virendra Kumar Patel, S/o. Shri Har,Prasad Patel, age about 37 years, R/o. Village and Post Budhwa, Tehsil Raipur Karehulian District Rewa (MP) Ex-ITI Apprentice (Diesel Mechanic) SECL, Baikunthpur Area, District Korea. 7. Sarva Sukh Singh, S/o. Shri S.N. Singh, aged about 38 years, R/o. Village & Post Manika, Tehsil Tanther, District Rewa (MP) Ex-ITI Apprentice (Electrician), SELC, Bhatgaon Area, District Korea. 8. Hirendra Singh,S/o. Shri Awadh Raj Aged about 38 years, R/o. Bagbar Colony, Qr.No. M/394, Post Bemhowri District Shahdol (M.P.) Ex. ITI Apprentice (Motor Mechanic) S.E.C.L Baikunthpur Area, District Korea 9. Krishna Prakash Shrivastava, S/o. Shri S.P. Shrivastava, Aged about 40 years, R/o. Back to Badi Mahgeet, Sohagpur, Ward No.4, District Shahdol (MP) Ex. ITI "TT \ l^- Apprentice (Motor Mechanic) SECL, Baikunthpur Area, District Korea (CG). / 10. Yadubansh Singh, S/o.Shri Brij Nandan Singh, age about 39 years, R/o. village & Post Jhalwar, Via Badi Samaria, Tehsil Semiria, District Rew (MP) Ex. ITI Apprentice (Electrician) South Eastem Coalfields Ld., Bhatgaon Area, Distt.Korea (CG). RESPONDENTS /" 11. Laxmi Narayan Verma S/o. shri Khamari Verma, aged about 40 years., R/o. village and Post Bade rabeli, Tehsil Malkharoud, Distirct Janjgir, Champa (CG) Ex.ITI Apprentice (Fitter) SECL, Raigarh Area, District Raigarh (CG) VERSUS ^ 1. Coal India Limited, 10, Netaji Subhash Road, Kolkata(W.B.) Through its Chairman. 2. South Eastem Coalfields Ltd,. Seepat Road, Bialspur (C.G.) Through : Its Chairman-cum-Managing Director. Director (Personnel) South Eastem Coalfields Ltd., Seepat Road, Bilaspur (CG) ^^^^•^. P&Jh'^'fM^S Dy. ChiefPersonnel Manager (Labour) South Eastem Coalfields Ltd., Seepat Road, Bilaspur (CG) Kundan Kumar Singh, S/o .Shri Suryabhan Singh \s fc. Aged about 35 years, R/o. Village & Post Kuniakala, Tehsil Tenther, District Rewa (MP) Ex. ITI Apprentice (Electrician) SECL, Bhatgaon Area, Ditrict Korea. ^ve^dzPCt 6. Nagcndra Bahadur Singh, S/o. Shri Sursh Mani Singh, <^^ - 0 G* ° Aged about 35 years, R/o. Village & Post Judmanibaya Devtalab, Tehsil Mauganj, District Rewa (MP) Ex. ITI Apprentice (Electrician) SECL Bhatgaon Area, District Korea (CG) -^. Ramjee Vishwakanna, S/o. Shri Ram Swamp Vishwakarma, Aged about 40 years, R/o. Village Belha Post Tamra, Tehsil -Mujur District Rewa (MP) Ex. ITI Apprentice (Black Smith) SECL Bhatgaon Area, Distirct Korea (CG). 8. Prem Lal Vishwakarma, S/o. Shri Manfer Vishwakarma, Age about 38 years, R/o. Village Baghaudi Post Suglwar Tehsil Sihwal District Sidhi (MP) Ex. ITI Apprentice (Electrician) SECL, Bhatgaon Area District Korea (CG). 9. Tej PratapSingh, S/o. Shri Mohan Lal Singh, Aged about 36 years, R/o. Village Madro Post Parsia, Tehsil Tenther, District Rewa (MP) Ex. ITI • Apprentice (Electrician) SECL, Baikunthpur Area, District Korea. .40. Deveand Singh, S/o. Shri Rajendra Singh, aged about 41 years, R/o. Village Dahiya (Khwd) Post Baba Ki Bardi, Tehsil Tenher, District REwa (MP) Ex. ITI Apprentice (Motor Mechanic) SECL, Chirimiri Area, District Korea (CG) 11. Arun Kumar Dwivedi, ^ 13. S/o. Shri Dev Kumar Dwivedi, aged about 35 years, R/o. Village Barouli, Post Jawa, Tehsil Malkharouda District Janjgir (Champa) (CG) Ex.ITI Apprentice (Seat Metal) SECL Bishrampur Areea, Distt.Korea (CG) 19. Krishna Chandra Singh, S/o. Shri Ram Pal Singh, Aged about 36 years, R/o. Village Lakhwar Post Kotrakala, Tehsil Tenher, District Rewa (MP) Ex. ITI Apprentice (Electrician) SECL, Bhatgaon Area, District Korea. Hansraj Singh, S/o. Shr Amarjeet Singh, aged about 37 years, R/o. village Pushpraj Nagar, Badi pul near Rewa (MP) Ex.ITI Appmtice (Electrician) SECL Hasdeo Area, District Korea (CG) ,14 Krishna Kumar Singh, S/o. Shri Jagdish Singh, Aged about 35 years, R/o. village Uchehera Post Barati, District Rewa (MP) Ex. ITI Apprentice (Fitter) SECL, Bhatgaon area, District Rewa (CG) ^^s,, .:"1'^.. ^it^^^S^ WRIT APPEAL UNDER SECTION 2 (l) OF THE CHHATISGARH HIGH /^'^^ st^^ COURT fAPPEAL TO THE DIVISION BENCH) ACT, 2006. S ".^^.ML__._...__„„_____^^-.....-^^_.-.-._-—- -4-- ^D -3'w[ "qiqM-q,. ^TH^^Ko, I^TRTy ^^....te^.....l^..8j...2^^4 ^^.....^..............^...^.,........7..^..,, -^i^T ^?^7 (°^f^^) ^ir^rk^ ^^i I^T^T^i^^ll DIVISION BENCH: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE I.M. QU HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRASHArliT KUMAR MISHRA. JJ 29.04.2010 Mr, Sanjay Verma with appeliant(s). Mr. P.5. Koshy with Mr. raspondents* A common order has been p other connected oppeais including Accordingly, this appeal shall tt&is Sd/- I.M. Quddusi Judge ^i^pN ^TR^ ^ fe^ Xf^^X ^3^iw^r ^DUSZ a iajesh ChGnd, consel for the Vivek Verma, counsel for the issed in W.A. No. 139/2009 and lisappeal* stand dispo^d of. Sd/- prashantKumarMishra Judge ^W^ ^NN g^IT^-ST, .^R"<F(t^ —FS/S47—2/201O —1,00,000.