ipBgsiUBipo 'jndi^g 'JB§B^[BJpuajreqs '91-3 OIH "o/H 'sreaX g^ inoqB p3§y 'IBAWJ§yjB3[UBl(SUnBt3-0/S 'PA J§Vapijsi uqs^ '&iafBvSis pazuoipne s^-qgnojqj^' ^gusg iss^ 'pBqBpis.m]^ 'itBAtpiqci 'O'd Vs 331S°P^8i{si! SqiAEq UUTJ diqsjgiii.iBj •OQ §mjnp^nitBp\[uig iiBqsrg-s/p^ qjE§S]flOT[q3'jndiB^ 'jmSv^tB.ipuaASQ 'z-jo^oss 'gZ-S -o/a 'sjeaX QS inoqE psSY '{BMBjgy pq qguisjBjsi uqg SIB^ -?/§ 'IBMBjSy jeum'^ 5[oqsy 'joisudoj<j sjj-qSnojqj, 'IU.XTJ diqsjopudojd V 's3pu3§v§BJnav-s/]^[ "8 •qjBSsiflBqqj 'jndi^g 'je§B^[Bjpaa{reqs -o/^ 'sjrea^ gz inoqs psS'y 'pMBjSy JBVroqs uncr) -o/s .'pMEj§vUIIIN Tjqs ^siuony s^i-qSnojqj^ 'jBgusg ^sa^ 'pBqBpismj^-'usiQ 'ireXipiqa •o-j sogjo psjsisigsj sfi §IITABH '9S6113V saiuedmoQ aqi japun ps^iod.iooui Xuedmoo v •pH -ud S5[JO^ mg sjaipojg Eips -s/p\[ sspiq spuj, BX^ipv-s/j^tjo jaiqjBd ; •q.regsinBipo 'jndiBy' 'ireprep\[ eqpaBqfeg ^; 'JBSUEJ vuffe^vi 'jooy ^, l 'Z-H -o/g ^ 'sjea^ ££inoqe pagy ] 'y/A-BjSy jBjnqureqs uqs -o/s 'lBAYBjgv ^BJIA -^T •i].regsinBi[q3 'jndiey 'iiepiBp\[ Bqpaeqfeg ; 'JBSUBJ BlUl©[g'JOOI^ ,J '^-H -o/y. 'SJBSX ££fflOqB p3§V '(BMBJ§VIBIn1UIBIIS>utIS ~°/S 'pMEjSv AfiA-I3u>JB(I S1T il§no.[qj, 'O'D 'mdiBg 'iiBprep\[ Biyueqfeg 'JBSUE,} EUI}B'5[g 'JOO(J ^ '^-H V3 soigo ssauisng '^^o-s'JooUp^ 'psflS uisiss^ Qt7 30ISO pEsq s}i §mABH 'amj dTqsjgiqjBj y 's^pTjapEj^ B^ipv -s/p\[ "isa 9 ^' •(OIOZ/9ZSE '0101/9881 'OlOZ7z,I9I 'OTOZ/9T9I '60^t'6T9 "600Z/88SS '600Z/088C '600Z/SOSf '8pOZ/8l(?T '800Z/60fr '409Z/£T99 •ON Cl) 'd'M "OM noN»ad^uMufSSpnf aiSuiS paujeai ^ passed OtOFOl'IO Pa»BPJiap.io pue ^namSpnf ueuiuloa aq^ jo ^no Suisuv) —^,5>^ 'ON leaddy IPA OIOZ/ anjsvTia iv aafij,v3ianT HHV9SI11VHH3 do iano3 HOIH 3Hj[, KI 4:2 "^ ^f^^ ^,.1.-^>^. ^& <^siPV AjayTraders, < A Proprietorship Firm, Through-It's Proprietor, . Shri Ajay Agrawal, / S/o- Sambhu LalAgrawal, Aged about 35 years, R/o- Shailendra Nagar, Raipur, Chhattisgarh • Vijay Traders, A Proprietorship Fum, - Through-It's Proprietor, Vijay Agrawal, S/o- Shri Sambhu Lal Agrawal, Aged about 35 years, - R/o- Shailendra Nagar, Raipur, Chhattisgarh APPELLANTS/PETITIONERS VERSUS State ofChhattisgarh, Through-Secretary, Department ofCommercial Tax, D.K..S. Bhawan, Matralaya, Raipur, Chhattisgarh. Chhattisgarh State Minor Forest, Produce (T & D) Cooperative Federation Ltd., A-25, V.I.P. Estate NBM- V.I.P. Club, Khamardih Shankar Nagar,Raipur, C.G. Through-Managing Director, |g%. Managing Director, District Minor Forest Produce Cooperative Union Ltd., Conservator ofForest, Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh. " „4^: Coimnissioner, Commercial Tax, Vanijyik Kar Bhawan, Civil Lines, Raipur, Chhattisgarh. NON-APPELLANT/RESPONDENTS ?WRIT APPEAL UNDER SEGION 2fl) OF THE CHHATTISGARH mGH COURT fAPPEAL TO DIVISION BENCH) ACT. AND gWRIT APPEAL AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 01.10.2010 IPASSED BY LEARNED SEVGLE JUDGE IN WMT PETHON (T) BNo. 6617/2007, 409/2008,1418/2008, 4505/2009, 4880/2009, 5588/2009, 16194/2009,1616/2010,1617/2010,2886/2010,3526/2010). .,.fesS:'"'s<^ ^- (§^^'Si ^ 'y A- SV^I W i<.|i<h ^^TSH^WqW d-a=i •^iiiyi, ofll'y'Ko, ^cfl'y^ »-^...U3.fc.-.U.S:.^\.S.. Wvn (bH|t(»"—----""-—-"""-"--^ 200 sn^r'q^q? (1pf3^st:i) TO11W ^lftff 311^'CT 1^.4.2011 -1_ Shri Ravindra Shrivastava, Ashish Shrivastava, Shri Naveen Shri Devendra Patel, Shri Rake; Advocate, Shri Abhishek Oswal, Sl Smiti Sharma, Shri Pankaj Shri Ajay Mishra, Shri Ankit Singl| Mishra and Shri Dheeraj Kumar appeals. ShriA.S. Kachhawaha.Dy. Shri Kishore Bhaduri, counsf Common judgment has b^ Vyas & others Vs. State of Chhatti^ Signed and dated. Certified copy as per rules Sd/- Dhirendra Mishra Judge qiiffiiili ii*K'iF4 Ce^S <R<^;|< '^'STRPTSTI^T Sr. Advocate, Shri Anup Majumdar, Shri P^kash, Shri Anup Jain, Shri Harsh Wardhan, (h Ranjan Agrawal, Shri G.N. Purohit, Sr. ri Anand Dadariya, Shri Neelabh Dubey, Smt. Shriva^tava, Shri Parag Kotecha, Shri Ajay Singh, hal, Shri B.D. Guru, Shri H.S. Patel, Shri V. IWankhede, for the appellants in respective Uvocate General for the State/respondent. 3t for the Federation. . in delivered in W.A.No.452/2010 (Mte K.K. garh & others), including this appeal. afong with main judgment. Sd/- R.N. Chandrakar Judge <ro<^^*(!jCTRil(,([W];<,i(B—F.S.'147—20010—1,00,000.