"siWi ^\ ^^^ ^. /^»" ?, (l';:"-?-.sii'H IN THE HIGH COURT QF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR W.P. (S) No. '2>L\°SI PETITIONER ^ <? »'°..-•••i': Oj-'-i-7lAh.' ^O.I..^-^ ^y^(3y- K<f's~-~ ^>-" RESPONDENTS : Aruit Soni S/o Late G.P. Soni R/o GQndpara, Near Raja Ram Mandir, Bilaspur (CG) VERSUS 1. State of Chhattisgarh, through its Secretary, Department of Public Health • and Family Welfare, Mantralay, D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipur (C.G.) ^ 2. Director, Directorate of Health Services, D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipur (CG). , 3. Chief Medical 8s Health Officer, Bilaspur(CG). ./ 4. Civil Surgeon & Hospital Superintendent, District Hospital, Bilaspur (CG). WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA IS^wafe^^gS 1 ggeqt s}|Luqns SH •uo os pue jofo SllggB®!Jaiieiu 94} usq) ')USLU}jed3Q gggjg||su 'sseo ui pue )U9LU)jedsa 8L| ej^d |gg|ggg|3L|) psjinbsj Aoi|0c| 34t \o 9 BSKBBtPM} ui siqeiiBAe pue }UBOBA )ou |gg||e4) s}iLuqnsaH •(si.-dainxsuu'gj) |®ggj|o9 ejed ui psquossjd JSUUBIU BSSIBa'o lusLUiuiodde 01 psniius si gBBIIgZI.-d sjnxsuuy) £002-90-01 uo Bjggggo Aoiiod }usaiuj3Ao6 SL|} o) SyiSiS9\S ssep Aue uo lusaiiuiodde jo^| ggjggggsq) 'JSASMOH 'iii spejg 9SSSsP9Wej£ sq }ou p|noo jeuoiji gSlgKo }SOd OU SB }EL|l jsuo!)!isd sq) jyiysipsfep OUJSLU spiA '}U8LU)uiodde BglsBipSAOiu jsuo]i!)ad 84} US^M 'j a|gsggi|p4i io jsqtai 3L|} leijt psujujqns sjll epEJQ IUE)SISSV ^o }sod eq) £S,J8UOIt!}3d 'L|OIL|M f,C{ '([.-d |(q p9AsuB6e jauoiiBsd sq} 4 •StE)S 341 JO^ •J8UOIl!)Sd sqi SiSSiSSiSSSS, i^ue hp-j ^ Iglgggggjlgi >17»to]'> p'9] h ]Uhlh l-lbl->)bllb lioo IOUISIQ 9L|} o} pejjejej sq 0^ psjinbsj 3\!\ p pESH sqi jepun eiqeiiBAB si AoueoeA }o pee|-| SL|) o) pspje/uuoj sq 0} JSHBLU ui psuieiuoo uoisiAOjd 'tusiuqsiiqeiss S|BM iii epejo tueisissy jo }sod 94) ji ueAS AOIIOJ }usuj)uioddv sieuoissedLuoo sq) ^L|I ui AOUEOBA Buyoidxs Aq }sod ||| SSB]O j8uf)B!}3d sq} 'SLUB o) SLUI} 0104 pspusiue se |3S}eB|nLuojd lusLUiuiodde aieuoissedLuoo Guipjoooe }EL|} psfliaiqns si )| 'isod llUSSUOO 9iq 9Al6 0} p3>|SB SBM J8UOI}!}3d tueilsissy se lusiutuiodde sieuoissediuoo jiisd '}UBOBA si iii spBJQ }UB)S!SSV P^LUJOIUI S'ON luspuodsej SL)) 'oi.OS-90-91. ^ieuoissedujoo }Q iuej6 jo^ uoi)eoi|dde ue jsye^jeq) pue '600Z-SO-ZZ uo psip jsuoiiiisd |3uo!i!)9d sq) jo^ issunoo psujes-i Uo •paioefsj useq SEL| }U8iu)U!odde eieuoissediuoo joi Luiep ejnx^uuy) 01.02-90-91- psiep uoiieoiunLULUoo psiy ussq seq uoiiiisd 8141 •pjesH ^teooApv 'IAOQ 'AgqnQ [iqsns U4S joj issunoo 'e|>]nqg AeiiqiBA WS 1.1.02-90-fr I. T 'BABtSBA.^iis ueyotu ejpuiUBN uyg siq.uoH : 88 ua]»>teii»a i^ii? \ B^UA tfeli*^ i^UBiteUAj. iife.l^ue ^SS^^^K^sSS^'. ....................................teSa^................................... OOZ "ktt,../................_...........aitf& lUhih o\^zl\s^'r^^):y^ t<=>rh i^lie ^au^). •SI.H.^e 'hWMh' ls£- ^^^^^S^B^^SI^i^fe <afe ^ "<-<- ^ iy a ga ^. ^^y '•••^•••f..L^-.-'.^'t XI-HC—7S '3:5T ^l'41<rtA|, eitlly'is, fediy'i< _„..^liS)vw.f>?^.L^.C Sil^IWftpW ^n STT^T^HI^ (^i this procedure has not been followed a| ofAssistant Grade III is available in th^ respondent No.3, the petitioner's claim| turned down. . On the other hand, learned Stj vacancy ofAssistant Grade III is not a\ granted compassionate appointment aj has been offered compassionate appoirj Along with the rejoinder, the pet dated 03-06-2010 (Annexure P-13) appointment on the post of Assistant q Harish Singh. During the course of arguments, the notice of the Court, specific averrrji wherein it has been stated that as sool the establishment of Health Services appointment would be given to the pi Grade III. Therefore, it is not necessary aspects of the matter. In view of what return filed by the State, in case, ar available and opened for compassionatc respondent No.3, petitioner's case shall appointment. However, if no such vacar the matter shall be referred to the Head *l<l1<-)<i'l-< •qn^f 'S feIA <r"f+!;l< §ii81||gj: ^; affwT SB^T 'SMBBSIB id only on this ground that no posf:||s|g%|g establishment under the control ofigeMfW for compassionate appointment istggggs te counsel submitted that as thegsBSB'I ailable, the petitioner could not be||j||||g Assistant Grade III. However, helSggS tment on Class IV post. :ioner has placed on record ordeg hich shows that compassionateS rade III has been granted to on8| learned State counsel brought to; ent made in para 4 of the returrf, as post of Assistant Grade III in; in District Bilaspur is availablej •titioner on the post of AssistanS or this Court to go into the variou® has been stated in para 4 of the; y post of Assistant Grade III i appointment under the control ofr ibe considered for compassionatel :y is available Jn near future, theri? |of the Department as provided in'l ;^s^.^ V^^Ss 'S^^'sSSS^i^Si i^*;^^^)^^^^ 1.,, ll>:. y" XI-HC—78 7ST ^|iq|cl<4, 0-flly-iie, [qdl<-llj,< ...^.:^.:.(^2KU;.1M^I/^C) ^^^•^y^ ^sS^^f. ^^^^^^; sn^i w P(-(i+ ^Sff a^T^T^Hjqi 3t^?i 'ci°w ('i^fj't't'T) ssSSis^ ^^^%^%;;s;: ®N;^S£ ^i®^^ TOiTW^f?33n^i •3 Tumane (|Para 6.6 of the Compassionate Appo [Thereafter, if no post of Assistant Grade |the hlead of the Department is available, lissued and the matter shall be referrei |Para 6.7 of that policy, who in turn, [petitioner for appointment on any vacant; In view of foregoing, the petition above. No orders as to cost. <M<<[<?i4ti ^^i ^f f^et' ^R^R':|^^|^^^^ ^ sfsn sv^s ASSIBSalB ntment Policy (Annexure P-12).- III is available under the control of a certificate to that effect shall b€ 1 to the Collector as provided in shall consider the case of the post ofAssistant Grade III. s allowed to the extent indicated' Sd/- Manindra Mohan Shrivastava - Judge ^^^K^^^SS5^ ^s^^^s^lsSs^: ^S^^^SS^^SK^^- ;y^SK^y'^S-^^S'^S. ^W^^'-^?-' 's? ^:?•?";."