1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA. WRIT PETITION NO.535 OF 2009. 1. Shri Santosh Pundolik Shirodkar, 2. Vishwanath P. Shirodkar ( deceased ) a. Mr. Vishwas Vishwanath Shirodkar, Major, unmarried, r/o. Colvale. b. Ms. Vidya Vishwanath Shirodkar, Major, r/o. Colvale Bardez Goa. 3. Mrs. Gangeshwari Vishwanath Shirodkar, Major, widow. 4. Shri Rohidas P. Shirodkar (deceased), (expired a bachelor on 2.8.2009). 5. Shri Ramesh P. Shirodkar ( deceased ). 6. Shri Prakash P. Shirodkar, ( since deceased ). 7. Shri Prabhakar P. Shirodkar, ( since deceased ). 8. Ms. Mangal P. Shirodkar, Major, Spinster, 9. Ms. Vimal P. Shirodkar, Major, Spinster, 10. Rajani P. Shirodkar, Major, Spinster, All residents of House No. Colvale, Bardez-Goa. ... Petitioners. V/s. 2 1. Mr. Michael Rocha, aged about 59 years, bachelor, s/o. Late Louis Sebastian Rocha, alias Luis Sebastiao da Rocha, r/o. Colvale, presently residing at Dharwad District, Bangeri Hubli, ( Karnataka ). 2. Mr. Alexander Leo Rocha alias Alexandere Leonica V. Rocha, s/o. Gasper Rocha, retired, 3. Mr. Francis P. Rocha, major, son of Alexander Leo Rocha, 4. Mrs. Linda Rocha, major, w/o. Francis P. Rocha, 5. Mr. Wilfred J. Rocha, son of Alexander Leo Rocha, 6. Mrs. Julier Rocha, major, w/o. Mr. Wilfred J. Rocha, 7. Mr. Donald B. Rocha, major, s/o. Alexander Leo Rocha, unmarried, 8. Ms. Catherine U. Rocha, major, unmarried, d/o. Alexander Leo Rocha, 9. Mr. Francis Xavier Fernandes, major, s/o. Late Joaquim Francis Fernandes, married, service, and his wife, 10. Mrs. Antonette Fernandes, d/o. Alexander Leo Rocha, w/o. Francis Xavier Fernandes, Respondent Nos. 2 to 10 are residing at 3 Toronto, Canada. Respondent Nos. 1 to 10 represented herein by their duly constituted power of Attorney the Defendant No. 13 Mrs. Espy Pereira, r/o. Auchit Vaddo, Thivim, Bardez, Goa. 11. Mrs. Shailaja Sadanand Naik, aged about 35 years, d/o. Atmaram Shetgaonkar, w/o. Sadanand Baburao Naik, 12. Mr. Sadanand Baburao Naik, major of age, married, residing at H. No. Not known, Mapusa, Bardez, Goa. 13. Mrs. Espy Pereira, widow of Vincent Pereira, r/o. Auchit Vaddo, Thivim, Bardez, Goa. 14. Shri Pratap Rana alias Rane, occ. Binani Facatory (Packing Section) residing next to Pundalik Shirodkar, House No. 16.B.2, Kursa Waddo, Colvale, Bardez, Goa. 15. Mrs. Pratap Rana alias Ranes, housewife, w/o. Mr. Pratap Rana, H. No. 16.B.2, Kursa Waddo, Colale, Bardez, Goa. ... Respondents. Mr. A. R. Kantak, Advocate for the Petitioner. CORAM : A. H. JOSHI., J. DATE : 2nd September, 2009. 4 O R D E R: 1. Heard learned Advocate Mr. A. R. Kantak for the petitioners. 2. The impugned order contains following findings:- “Plaintiff filed present ammendment application on the ground that the same errors have creaped in pleadings, so also some events have occurred after filing the suit and some documents recovered after filing the suit. However Plaintiff have specifically not mentioned which events have occurred after filing the suit. It is seen from the records that earlier also the Plaintiff sought ammendment to plaint, however, there is no sufficient cause shown to present ammendment application as to why it was not carried out earlier i.e. before framing issues or while carrying out earlier ammendment application or about 09.09.2004”. (Quoted marked portion from page 24 of the petition paper books) 3. The above quoted portion which pertains to factual data leading to delay in filing application, has not been met in the petition. 4. This Court is satisfied that application for amendment was vague and Trial Court was well within bounds of jurisdiction in passing impugned order. The reasons recorded in the impugned order too are proper and legal. 5 5. Hence petition has no merits and is dismissed. A. H. JOSHI. ah/-.