gmawg gEMcH-a v / @ C (&"(00/ H IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BILASPUR CHHATTISGARH WP. No5$§l/2oo5 Mohan Lal Diwakar S/o Shri Ramadhar aged 45 years Caste Satnami, R/o Village Kataud Tahsil Navagarh Distt. Janjgir— Champa (C.G) Versus PETITIONER : e(x RESPONDENTS : /1 State of Chhattlsgarh through Se etary Dept f Pancha D S Bha n Mantralay Rpur (C G . ‘ Colleco t Ja- Cma ( ) Addl ollecto Dst JgrChamp(C G) Cef Execue Ofce Jnpad Panchayat, Navagarh,at njgir Distt. anjgir— Champa (C.G.)V Tahsildar, Navagarh Cum eturning Office, for Election f Janad Panchyat, Navagarh, at Janjgir, Distt. Janjgir Champa (C.G.) igu Lal S/o Ramnath aged about 4 years Caste Satnami R/o Village Kataud Tahsil Navaarh Distt. Janjgir Champa (C.G.). ‘ Ashok Kar S/o Pandu Rm aged 34 years Ville Pachari Tahsil Navagarh istt. anjgir ampa (C.G.) Aasdas S/o Chhatram aged 35 years Village Pachari Tahsil Navagah Distt. Janjgir Champa (C.. Om Prakash S/o Mastu Ram aged 34 yes Village Pachari Tasil Navagarh Distt. Janjgir Champa (C.G.) udhau Ram S/o Netram aged 45 yea Vilage Kansa Tahsil Navgarh Distt Janjgir Champa (C G) /11. Ram Kumar S/o Gujalu aged 36 years Village Kataud Tahsil Navagarh Distt . Janjgir Champa (C G) “12‘. Shrimati W/o Ringu Lal aged 38 years Village Kataud Tahsrl Navagarh Distt Janjgir Champa (C G ) WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226/227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA i Contd....2 y . c t o ayt K w a al ) tr Distric njglr hap C G Cr it anjIa hi tw fir a Ja J R r o p Rn 4 g um a ag D J Ch g r G) ar h . B r l a . Xl-HC-78 200 snéam (W) néarwiéaim amst mm 11%?! anésr WWW#%@W ' $Wanéa 9—11 4005 S’nri éavind Ram Miri, couhsei for ‘i’he pefi'fionen 5hri Va5hwun1‘ 5ingh Th akur,‘ Qovt Advomfe far fha Swiz/ respondenfs No.1, 2, 3 and 5. The pefifioner has prefe legalifyi propriew and (tarmac? passed by fhe Addifiond C: Pefi‘i'ion Mo.07/.A-89(2 1):!290 Coiieci'or while aiiowing ‘H'ie sai e ground 'Hmf fhe pe‘fMoner— was no? eiigibk +o comes? fhe eiec‘rion and uifimq'raly, whiie a‘i'fing asi&e fhe aiecfion, fhe posi’ m" iIAzmb r, J’anpad Punchayair, Navagarh waS declared as vacant grief fad-s ieading 1'0 f iing cf fhis wrh pefifion are fha? The pe‘fifioner herein aiong wifh o. er candkig'i'es con'i'eS‘i'eé for *Hne pos‘r of Member 0f Janpad Panch w ‘I ¢.he penfianer- *‘ as Mega! on # N925; Navagarh in fhe year 2005 and 1'he eiecfion» for The said p s? was ‘neld‘ bn 15-1-2G§5‘ Ai’ f'hg end of coun‘ring of vows The 'pe i'rioner herain was deciared eixacfed. ‘Hawever; respondah‘f Na. ingu Lai fiied an eleca‘ien pefifioe (AnraexureaP/i) bafore The Co‘ iecfor, EanJgir-Champa on The ground 'H'm'f on 'fhe da’re when ‘fhe peTiTioner‘ herein fiizd a nominafion governmenf dues were oui'smn rred this wri‘f pe‘ri?§on ques‘.’ioning ‘rhe ne$s of The order timed $149-$305 :iiecfor, Junjgir-Champaa, in E§ecfian 425 whereby §eamed Aédi‘riemi eiecficn 9efif§on deciar‘ed +he elecfian Eng agains‘? him as 1'ine pei‘ifioner was a mm 38Q wmqim ........... . ...... . ..... u. .......... mzoo anéemaas (W), \ mmmmer ”Og/ mm§wm aiwmsr Sarparach for fwo farms 91’ éiam §anchaya+ Kafaud and m fha‘.‘ Capaciw in we year 1935 he 100k advance for i‘hg consWua‘i’ion of ”:‘he ’ Panchaycd Bhgwgn but ha :id nbf comple'hza ‘i‘he cens?ruc+ian. 'f‘xn amounf of Rs.14,313/- was uufsfanding againsf him. fherefera, the Naib Tehsiwtir, Janjgir iniTia‘ed The graceeéing far recavery e‘. The said amoua‘t and fha‘t' has f haw remvered 56 far. Ever! said Mahaniai again wifhdmw fhe amcunf far cansfrucfian 01" The buiiding of The Primary 5chooi 0f Kcfaud and The suSd buiEding was r191: campiei‘ed, Therefareg Jan d Panshayg'h Navagar'h ini‘riamd i’he e amoun? of Rs.2?’i158/- an 6—10-1994 and fha mid ameunf ha$ ads m‘r been mid. Naiices wgrg i$$ue& a?! repiy was fiied by The pzfifioner herein 3n which he denied me aEi gmians. Hcwzvar, iaarned A'ddifisnai Coileaar summaned f§1e re rd regarding reccvarv from the Chief Execufiv‘e Officer of ‘f‘né J pad Panchaya'i’. He aisa requisi?ioned 'E'he deciara’fic'n made by ?ha fifionar herain bafare ?f1.e §2Turning Gfficer mw‘ affer gerusai of he regard, pakseci fhe impugned ordezx The-mam gréevance of earned counsei far The §e$§11aner is ma‘r ieamed AddH€onai Collea'f fhe said eiemian peri‘rion an i wi‘fhouf feHowing 141a graceduw as anvisaged umier fhe Chh ’isgar'h ?anchayo?s (Eleciiaa Pe‘ri‘rions, Corrupf Pracfices and Disq aiificm‘ion far Membership) Ru‘es; 1995 {for show? ‘i'he Quies, 1995) passed fhe impugned erder. SP/FS/2005 - 20,000 c a i o h preceeding far recavery 61’: e s Wwqi$ I........ III .......I.. Ty: ..I........ W200 appor‘funiw was given 'fo fhe: pei'éfioner- f0 meg? 1'he chargeg lavei§ed againsw‘ ihe gefmoner ragarding cafsfanding ameun‘l’ nur any wi‘mass was produced by fhe pefii‘inner in order 'Lro pmv’e fhe documen? regardmg ouTsmnding amc‘um agains? fhe pefmaner, ner ?he pa‘rifiongr was aHowecJ fo ad iuca any ev§denca én order to rafufe. fine charges regarding cufgfandinb amaunf against fhe pefifmnar; Having heard ieamed caunsei- for “me aqr?ies3 E have g3elr‘used ‘Fne impugned ordar. Perumi of #he impugned wder shows fi'm? pracadure as erwisaged under Ruies 1i aw 12 {if “(he Ruies, 1995 has m? been feihwed. Quiz 11 (1) znvisnges Tim? “Suhjec? fa fhe grovisinns m‘ fhese wigs, every eieminn peti‘rion shaii be enquired im-a by The specifizci afficer as neariy: as may £3, in accordancé wifi‘a fine procedure appéicabk under *he Code 3f Civié Procedure; 1908a TO 'rhe friai of suifs; §rnvid2d 14m? i1- shuii oniy be nehessary for {ride spéc:§i2& effécer 1b make a memorar ium of *rhe gubsralace of The evidence cf any wifness examined by hm" and Rale i2 env§sages production‘m‘ 1'he wifnesses by we par‘fies. Learned counsei for the pefi‘rioner fur‘rher submiTwd Thai £omaiiance 01‘: fine Quiz 3 :31: The Quies, 1995 was ais‘o no? made, SP/FS/2005 - 20,000 msrmrm (mauésrm meIW(W) WW#WW mmWanésr “g... aiwanéat Learned counsei fer fhe pe‘H‘Honer subm§f+ed "fhaf m mmm-m II .....u... I....u....lulll .......... H1200 mama-<5 (llama—é) venanéam metasrm ammmmé31 V‘ 4F“ mm#w®n§n $Wanés1 fherefcre; in View of Fna a&?3ve,. fhe arder gassed by fha ieamea‘ Ad&i+iomi Co§§ec+ar is prima fade perverse‘ w suah‘ ne name is ’ nacass’ur'y To fhe o‘rher persons in fhis mgHar. However, if respand‘er’r No.6 Ringu La! in any way feeis aggrieved, Then he. wiii be a‘r iibarfy f0 move an app§icmian for modifimfbn of fhis order. in fhe resui'r, fhe mm? pei‘ifmn is aibwed we fhe §mpugne<i arder is quashed. The mch‘es' is remanded back i’c éeamed Addifianai ‘ Ceilec‘mr', Janjgir ‘fo try fiae eiec‘fian pe‘H'rion in accorciaace wifh 1'he . Ruies, 1‘3§5 ami pass approprk Te er-d'er m accordance wi‘rh hw. / Par-iies are enfi'Hed far Icerfifie-i eopy cf this 9rder: / e r7“: 3d]- L.C.Bhad°° ‘ ‘ ‘ Judge