7a HIQH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR Wrif Pz'fi‘i'iar. (5) Na. 2804 of 2008 1. Sumndm Kumcr Chawdhary, S/a Shri D.P.Cheudhar'y, Aged about 4D yrs., P2+5+€or12rs Lem‘urer, Govt H‘S. School @harghada, ‘ Bhck Ghm‘ghoda, Dis‘H’. — Raigarh, R/o 6mm Tarkela, PosT OffEce Tar-keia, Tehesil & Dish‘. R$aai+n Ramna‘rh Banjare, 5/0 Chinimm Banjnrel Aged abouf 49 yrs., LecTur-er‘ Gavt H5 Schac! Ghai‘ghnda, Block éharghoda, Disiii Raigarh, Ric 6mm Tm'keia‘ Posf Ofice Térkeid, Tehesi! &‘ Disf‘t. Raignrh. Versus Respnnden'k V 1. S'fma of CE. Through. :Secr-afar'y, Depar'l'menf of Tribc! We!fare, D.K.5. Bhawun, Rnipur (C.6.) Director, Triba! Weh‘ai‘e, Dis-fricf Raigarh (£16.) AssiS'runT Commissioneri Depar‘rmenf- of Tribal Waifare, Dish=ic+ Raigarh (6.5.) 4. Biatk Educafian Officar, Dis+ric+ Raigarh (Cf-J , WRIT PETITOIN UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CON5TITUTION l3? INtpIA ‘ Eingk Bznch : Hon'bhz Mr. safish K. Agnihatri, J‘ Shri Manish Sharma, Advocate for The peti‘rioners. ShFi Ajay Dwivedi, Deputy Gavf. Advocn‘ra far €412 responden‘fs. ORAL ORDER (Passed on This 14% dny of May, 2008) Wi'H'i 1412 cdnsznf af +h2 par-fies, +h2 mai’fer is *akan up fa? hearing. @ KDI Learned cmmsa! appearing far +he pe‘tifianzrs submi'ts #hai‘ +he pai-rianers have ah‘rainzd BEd. examim-l'ian cartifimi'e, m fheir awn expenses during servica. Laamad counsa€ appearing far +he pa'rH'ioners as we“ as {gamed ’ caunsei nppmr-ing for The respandzn'rS/Sm‘re jain‘Hy submif 'H'm‘f #432 fads and question 0f law, invoived if. fhz prasenf wri‘r pafi‘rim, are +912 same as'fo ‘fha'l' of in ‘z’ashwan'r Kunmr Bhamdwa‘; Vs. Municipal Carpom'fian, Burg and anofher (2006 (II) MEIR-CG 96), which has bzzn dispasad of vide order dwad 3.4.2006 and +h2 order da'md 7.2.2007, paged Ey fhis Cour'l’ in W.P.($) Nu. 697 of 2007 (A. N. V. Sa‘h/ammym t3; afher—s Vs‘ 5mm of Chha-H‘isgarh 6.. o‘fhzrs). Accordingty, 'the wrH pea-{ion is aHawed in +erms of fhe order passed in +312 case of Vashwawf Kumar Bharadwaj (supra) and W.P.(5) No. {37 o§ 2007 (supra), subjec? +o verifica-rian of 1412 facf as+a whether fha pe‘fifianers have acquired B.Ed./D.Ed‘/B‘T.I.fMEd. Examina‘l’ian Cer'fifica‘hz an ‘fheir awn expenses, as per 1412 circulars dafed 13.9.1974' 24.13.1998, and 1.3.1999 and fur‘thar wha‘har may have been paid +wo advance incrémen+s ar not No order aS'ra cas'rs. \ Sd/— k R Satish K. Agnihotri Vaca‘tian JUH§EW V V Thakur' @