'^? ^: Jft <,, HI6H CGURT OF CHHAniSftWH AT KLASFUR W.P.tS) Nff. 2074 of 2007 Sln^e BuidcHon'bte SM Sotirit K. Ay^haW. J. PetHionw : Smt. ftqpu W/o Koushal Prasad, aged about 22 yeors, Resident of 6iw» Buchiparo, Tahsil Pondaiya, Oistrict Kabirdham. Chhattisgorh VersiB Respwutents 1. State of Chhattiagorh, Ihrough Additional Cottector, Mstrict Ketsh^ham. OrfiattisgcB+i 2. Smt. Chctfid Kumari W/o Rd<eah Kumor Ohirve, aged about 23 yeors, Resident of Buchjptiro, TAsil Pmdariya, Disftwt ICflbirdham, [Chhattisgarh] 3. Pwiyojana-<dhik<ffi, B<it<rit Bal Vikas Pwiyojoiw^ Pandariya, bistrict Kdtirdham, [€.&.] Present: Mr. Saurabh Kumar Pande, counal for the petittoner. Mr. Arvmd &i,fcey, Panel LaNyer for State. OROER (Passed on 5th &cy of April, 2007) 1. Leamed counset (qipewing for tiw petitiotwr submits that the <q»pointmen* of tiw petitioner on the post of Aanggnbcdi Koryakwta/Sahuyito was rejected on ttw ground tiiot Ihe resjmident No. 2 hwirg similcr qualifreafjon betonging to the snnw communtty. But the respondent No. 2 has obtoined more marks that is 48.68 %. Thus, Ihe <ypointment of the petitioner was bcd on account of the facts that the respondent No.2had obtained mom morks in class 8"' exomination certtficute. 2. He ftrther contends tho* Ihe petitiona' has produced a register of proceediiys of 6tw»Panchtyat before the Additionol Coltector', Ktdrinttiam / '^ indicoting •that the respondent No. 2 is the d<n^hter-jn-l<»»of elected Ponch of the 6ram Pondwyat Buchipara. It is not ctear from the order asto whether this aspect wos exomined by the ^dditional Coltector or not. 3. Thus, the order passed by the Additional Collector, Kabirdhom is set- aside. The mutter is remttted back to the Addlttonnl Colleetor, Ksi»rdh<m for hearing and examining the register of proceedin9S produced by •the petitioner t'ndicating thot the re^wndent No. 2 is a dciu^rter-in-law of elected Puich, wihich djsqualifies for being qipointed vs (Aangonbodi Karyokcrta/Sohayika, ond poss appr'oprkite order. Before passirg •the order, the ^dditional Collector, Kubirdwm is directed to issue notice to the objector as well os petitioner herein providing proper opportunity of hearing. 4. Thus, the iwit petition isallowed to the obowe extent. No order <s to costs. Sd/- Satish K. Agnihotri Judge Subhash