IN THE HIGH G0uR OP KL4ATAKA AT BiNGiRE DATED THIS THE 18TH DAY OF JUNE 1998 BEFORE THE HON’BLZ iLR,dUSTICE G.G. BH?RUXA W1T PETITION 140:16410—11/1996 BETWE: 1. G.T,Bhat sb Thimaana Bhat, aged about 30 years, Aesistt Teacher, Janatba Vidy1aya, Kasargod, Honnavar Tq., U.K.District, 2. Ishwar V.Bhat, s/o Venkatareinana Bhat, aged about 30 years, Asjstat Teacher, Janth Vidyalays, Bada, kagai, Kumti taluk, U.K.District. (as per order dt.27.b.96) (By Sri V.D.Bhat, .Adv) ..PeUuoners AND: 1. Joint Director of Public Instructions, Belgaum Dvii., Be.Lgaum, •• c_ • 2. The Commissioner of Pub lie Instructions, Nrupathung Road, Bangalore—2. 3. The Deputy Director of Public Instructions, Karwar, U.L.Dist., (By Sri G.Papi Reddy, AGA) ..Respundents , . , Writ petition filed under Articles 226 nd 227 of the Constitution of India witn a prayer to quash vide Annexure—C dt.25/ 4 -/9b and Mmex—D dt.25/4/96 by R—1. and etc., This petition coming on for prly. hg. this day the Court made the following: ORDER.. A-, 1. LP.16410—11/96 ORDER He r He leirned ounril fc tie Fetiti’tIt aid Mv’ V. Vidya, laarned H.t A.P. for the rnpondents 2. The pet iticnevr *ve emplo n cf d Fri ate Educational inctitution. The relief claimed by them n tha pr sent knit p titicn pertair tc their emlo mint The Divi1on Bench of this tnurt in I,J A. N). 1873 to 18’3e/95 and connected mattns (DD 30.05.19)8) has bald that even if the private educationil inetituti. r hie baen dmsttod to grant—in-aid under the provisions of the Grant-in Aid Code by th3 flat.e gwc.rnment, still no i lationship of maste and si’rvant between the government md the PC ‘on’ like tie petitioners comes into being and tharefore, thn writ petitio fli d by ‘t i. emç]c.veas not naintsiyt,hle under ArticLe 226 of the onqtjujcn of Indta elnb2 they hay effective, effjçrjnin and alternative ctatutory remnlln 3vailobl uid ti Kay tik. Lcatl)1 c 103 (ii eh>rt 4 the ct’). 3 It p r J pt 2 C’ th jtcgn it t t t t Ii th4t . — TM A’ regards the low’ standi of otaff sorkino in tie. ifore ni c.lu dtiongl. inatitutior,s to maint4.n the writ petitions, they have got the remedy of appeal under ‘cc Hon 94 of the rducatton Act again°t an order .‘f Jismnsal cr rcmcval from service or raduetion in rink. ‘inder Secticri 130. appeal is provided apainst any order pa%sed by an ffic r )I authcrity .tn’ 4 nr tj ct Section 131 provides for reyjejo,, h. Ro’,arnmant either r”o ‘poto r on an arptiraton from ani peison lntere,taø. e .o, 1 .‘f the ‘ *tlrT Al r 11 o r iew by thc Ctat Gover r m€ Fit t her suo moto i O C applictin eved from Cfl/ FOS interested- The Government is also vested with the ow r t giv d’rc-tion ur3r S tion 1 3 f th t to wake enqLiry o tak prcpr’ctc proceeding bs the Commissic,nel or Directoi or any other officer riot below the rank of District Fu atioiial Offi e a i t bm ra ort Thu, the Edo ation Act provide f ap€ l , r€ iion ai ravi am in resnect of any ni ‘ier nd in th abenco of any order • the Go errrnent c-an be moved for issuin CO53 / dir ti r Cf f it cower undor Esotion 150 and tha st ff can avail the aid rrrdr ‘Evn with roga d to ocyment of salry what i tatrd aov with re< td to th€ tEaching and non t ch’ng st3ff aFpli th th r staff CiSS, Piithout exhaust3ng ouch alternativ remedy. the’ eannot h nermi ttud to i avoke th xtraordinar jurisdi tion of th’s Court u d rticla 22é f the Con trtut ion 4, For the aforesaid reasons the writ pt itians are dimied on th ground of vt’lability of effiaciou tnd effective alternative remedy. However, all the rights and contentions of th parties on ma ts ci kept cpn r being agit.atsd hefore tha appropr ‘ac- statutory authnrit.ic-s If so the pet it oni C 3/ VC I thai tatut ry emedy h’ way of filing appeal / revicior / DFlication as cae ray be undr the At witi to PJ°EKS frm ode sue in tha cv nt of filing of the sam€ the on ernod cut ho ities will dsF SE ouh appai s’is ion / appi jCt ran within THREE mont K from tb date filing th€re f availed, then the ame ohauld ha disposed o Nithir THREE mc ith from the pie tIc n of U i rd r Sd/ JUDGE js k/ —