IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.9547 of 2010 1. DURGA PASWAN S/O LATE JHAPASHI PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 2. RAMASHISH PASWAN S/O TUFANI PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 3. KRISHNA PASWAN S/O LATE DOMAN PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 4. RAM PRAVESH PASWAN S/O LATE RAM KHELAWAN PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 5. BRIJ LAL PASWAN S/O BUDHAN PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 6. TULSI PASWAN S/O JHAMAN PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 7. RAM PRASAD PASWAN S/O TULSHI PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 8. DASHU RAM S/O GIRDHAR RAM R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 9. KHELAWAN PASWAN S/O BUDH NATH PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 10. RAM SUNDER PASWAN S/O TULSI PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 11. GOBERDHAN PASWAN S/O LATE TAPSI PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 12. KRISHNA PASWAN S/O LATE TUPHANI PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 13. JAGDEO RAM S/O BIPAT RAM R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 14. SITA RAM PASWAN S/O LATE KEWAL PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 15. DEO LAL PASWAN S/O NIRANJAN PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 16. DURGAN PASWAN S/O LATE RAM JATAN PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 17. GANURI PASWAN S/O DHARI PASWAN R/O VILL.- IBRAHIMPUR, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD – Petitioners. Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR 2. THE COLLECTOR, AURANGABAD 3. THE S.D.M. AURANGABAD 4. THE CIRCLE OFFICER, AURANGABAD 5. RAM NARAYAN SINGH S/O MAHESHI SINGH R/O VILL.- NAWGARH, P.S. AURANGABAD (M), DISTT.- AURANGABAD 6. THE ADD. MEMBER, BOARD OF REVENUE BIHAR PATNA – Respondents. ----------- 2 2.7.2010 Heard learned counsel for the petitioners and the counsel appearing on behalf of the State. The petitioners are the Parcha holders who had been granted lands which was declared surplus in Ceiling Case No. 4/1991- 92. Later the parcha was cancelled on the ground that the land holders 2 had been allotted extra unit. The petitioners moved this court by filing a writ petition which was dismissed as withdrawn on 18.1.2006. While dismissing the writ petition this court observed that the Collector, Aurangabad may grant to the petitioners a piece of land in lieu of the Parcha granted to them earlier. Accordingly, the petitioners filed an application before the Collector, Aurangabad for considering the matter who did not find himself in a position to find an alternative piece of land for the petitioners. Against the order of the Collector, the petitioners moved before the Additional Member, Board of Revenue which was dismissed. This court finds, in the facts aforesaid, that no direction can be given to the Collector, Aurangabad to grant Parcha to the petitioners with respect to lands which were subject matter of ceiling case of 1991-92 and the question of granting alternative piece of land after lapse of two decades has apparently been considered by the Collector and rejected. I find no merit in this writ petition. It is accordingly dismissed. haque (Sheema Ali Khan, J.)