f}? (q. />\: \ %€EéH COUR? OF JUDKATURE éT BEL§5PUR €.€-.‘ waiT PETzfmN NO 2;!14 a? aces ?ET£EONE§: Nehc Dam, Daaghfer of @hanshyms Prasad Dani, aged abouf 2O year-s, resident of Jamhai: Nagar, §aipur {Chhm‘fisgarhl Versus 1. The Sfai'e o‘?§HW<i$?isgarh, Through the $5crefary, Mec€ica§ am! Heaifh Services, 'Man’rr’alaym D,K.S, Building, Raipur’ (6.5.) Direci‘er, Medical Educaficm, Thmugh Direcfcm‘fe, Madicai Educafian, Chhatfisgar'n, Raipur‘ (Chhaffisgarh). Dam, Medical Calage, Qaipur‘, §aipur (Chhaffisgarh). RESPGNDENTS: ?§$T FGR O§3ER ON i“ GCTGgER, 2$G3 x Sd/u _L_.:.BHADoa 30TH segmmber 2003 .Wi"? Mmmmx “L“ § %E$H €GU§T OF JUDECATU§E AT $ELA5PL§§ {6&3 WRIT PETETEGN NO.2?14 OF 2%3 PE‘JTIONER: Neha Dam Daughfer sf Ghwghyam Prasad Dani, aged abauf 20 years, rasidenf of Jawahar Nagar’, Raipm" {€hha1'fiagar'h). Versus The Sfafe af Chha??i$garh, Through fhe $ecr'emry, Medkm ané HeaHH Servires Manfmiwa D K 5 Bulldmg, Rmpur (C € ) 2. Direcwh Median! Eéucm‘ian, Through Direcforufz, Medical Edaca‘fian, Chha??isgar*h, §aipur (Chha’r‘risgarh). (3n RE§§ONSENT$ 1. Dear: Medical Cekge Rmpur Rwpur’ (Chhufhsgur-h) $hri H. B. Agar-ML Advocai‘a, fer ‘rhe §e?if§ener Dr. N. K. Shukla, Aédi'i'iaml Awocafe éenemk for i'hz S'rafe/respondeni’s 1 Ta 3. _ 3ai‘arg: Han'bée 551?} LC. ahaéoe. J O RI $ § R (Rxsed on 15* Oc‘fober‘ 2093) i. By “rhls wrl‘i' pefi‘hor: Linda: Ariwcia 226 of fhe Consrifufaofa or mdia ‘me peWhcrler has cnaHeriged ‘I‘he acfiofi of 'f'he Raspmdenf No 3 refusmg “rhe pe‘i'i‘hm'ie” fa give her wwssion m ‘rhe M B B 5 uour‘ae '2. T'rle pefmmer‘s pe’fmor: is Tha‘f shz appeared m The re Medina Tag? txammc‘hori under he Rules Annexura P/i. Ruiz 3 of ’rha §uiesf prasci‘ibes ‘H‘xa‘f gammi cafegory cmdida‘fes who have seéureci minimum a mark$ aggregme m ‘fhe sumecfa 6f PHySiC$ ChewsWy and Bwisgy m ‘i'he Highar Secondary §xaminafiori (1G+2} are edgibie ‘m appema iri %he ewmrlce examifia?ia?i fm‘ “fhe PMT. , f 3. T%1a% 'fhe pa=i=i%i&nar‘ appeared §r1 ‘i’he said exam§rm%im m5 PMJ‘. for Three ‘?i’mes. Far '%he €><amimf§oi1 cf 20G3 1Lhe pa?§%isner submif‘feé %1er ap§xiica%iw ‘i‘m‘m m1 $32003 Vida iéméxur'e P/3 am? admh‘ card issued 15:3.“ “f%*xe axaminafkrn mg 2903 is iémnaxure PM. Gn The basis 5f ‘rhe mark ghae? €s§ijea m 141a Papoweww an 213.2003 fhe pefHioner secured 27+!“ posi‘i’ion in meriH’ as she secured' 741 mdrks ou‘f of 900 marks in ail %he i‘hrea Subjecfs which ‘is Amexuw W5. The pafifimer was calied ital“ admission on 13+“ August 2093 bu“? as she received ‘i'ine caii ie'i'i’er' Iaie 'fherefore she couid no? appear 0a Thai” dafe. Thafeaf‘fea sha was again caiied far cau’riseiing vide ie‘ifer d‘f. 21.932003 ‘i’o ‘iake 'H‘Ie admi5$iaa up fa 23.2003 Vida Amexur'e P/?. Accar‘aiagiy The pe‘fi‘iianar gubmif‘red her eharacier cer‘fifica'i'e, iraasfer cer‘fificafe, ceri’ifica‘i’e m5 migrassiorl, admissian card, siafemenf 6f marks pass cer‘fific‘as‘e, bamfide residem' cer‘fifica‘i‘e, physical fi‘mess ceriifica‘ie and dr'a‘ff of Qs. 12,000/— ’ih favour cf she hespor‘idem‘ No.3. Bu? fhe reSpandehf No.3 refused +6 admin‘ fhe pe‘fi‘i’iaher 0h Thegraund 1*haf she was ho? ehgibie fa aphear in RMT. examiha‘i’ian as she cauid r10? secured agreega'i‘e of 50% marks ih Three subjec‘rs Le. Physics, Chemisfhy' and Bioiogy in Higher Secmdahy examina‘i'ion; in spi'i’e ef fhe fac‘i Tha‘l’ she was calied 'io fake admissiOh vide Ahhexure W6 and P/7. New The respOhdehis are siapped ea "fhe ground of pramissary es‘foppeis ahd "rhey caririof refuse To admii‘ ihe ae‘ri‘iioner. As per Ruie 13 'ihe 60W. has issued Ahriexure 9/6 arid P/i’ which shaws fha‘i' fihe responden‘i's have reiaxed ‘i’he Ruie 3 fhererare refusiag she admission To The peTiTioner is iiiegai and bad. Had ThelrespondenTs disaiiowed The peTiTianer To appear iri The said examinafioa aT PNLT. iTseiT Then The aeTiTioner wauid naT have \sfjoiied her vaiuable Three years conTinuausiy. The respandenTs aiiawed The peTiTioner To appear in The enTrance examinaTian Three Times'and now They cannoT refuse adrnissian an The graurid ThaT she was noT eligibie Ta appear in The examinaTian OT P.M.T. ThereTare The respandenTs be direcTed To admiT The peTiTioner in The medicai coiiege Raipur, appiying The principies 9T promissary esToppei. i / we”. i / S’é‘ L)L . The repiy has been filed m1 behaif 6f ‘i‘he respond'erri’s. 1 have haw-d §earned counsei far ‘fhz pe?i'rioner' Shri H.S.Agdrwa§ md Dia. N. K. Shukla, iearned Addi‘i’iana! Advaca‘fé éemPQL é‘ I? is 1516+ dispufea‘ by {gamed mmsel far ‘Fne pe‘HTiomr ‘fha‘f Rule 3 of fha brachure issued by ‘i’he reepondef‘iis for RMT. examina‘i'ior. eméseged fhe‘? oeiy fease genera§ ea‘i’egery amdidtxfes were eaigibie ”rs appear ie. ‘H‘ie RM? exae3im?iee who had secured 50% aggregaére marks . §§1 1%.2 subjec‘rs of Physies, Chemisfry and 8ioisgy. I? is misc adm§‘f+ed rmexare W12 fhe aggrege‘re marks secured. m ?he ebove fHr'ee subjeci’s are no? 50%. $fl§y 4%‘3’o marks were secured by“ fhe pei‘i‘fioeer he fhe Higher $eeariear‘y Examém?ion, ‘i'herefor‘e as per Rule 3 of The RMT. Examina?%ce fhe pe‘h‘fioeee was no? eiigible “f0 appear in fhe excmim‘l’iorl beifig a geeem§ ca?egery seedidafe} However fee maiii groueé mkefi ey fhe ine‘h'fioner‘ §s em? even 1’heugh ?he pefi‘rioner wee ma? e{igib!e f0 appear ie fhe exemim‘fim es she had no? secured ffhe prescribed aggrege're 50% marks in rhree subjecre in rhe Higher Secohdarv Examim‘hoh bu? in spire of fhai' fhe Respahden‘rs eliowed rhe peririoner ha appear in ‘i’ne en‘imnce examina'fiori 0f P.M.T. ‘ “for ‘i’hree fimes, rhere‘fore 'i’hey are now Sfoppeé by The principiee sf pramissory es‘i’pppe‘i f0 raise fhis abjecrian air ‘ihe ‘i'ime of admission ir. The M333. i.e. u'fTer. passing The enTrahce examimTiori pf P.M.T. and securing 27% posiTion in meriT. g. l do has? firid any subsTance in This greund raised by' learned cqunsel for The peTiTioner. sis in This case The principie of promissory esToppei does rioT apply because aT The’Time of fiiling of The form The peTiTioner was weli aware abouT Rule 3 which prescribes Thai oniy Those genera! V caTegory oandida‘ies were eiigible To appear in The P’MT. examinaTioh who had seeured aggregm‘e of 50% marks in Three subjecTs i.e. Physics, Chemisiry and Bioiogy. Knowingruiiy well ThaT condiTion,\The peTiTioner had'applied and if inadverTenTly The sTaTf or The responden‘i‘s could noT pesa'fieii ‘E‘haf as per’ The mark-ehee’f m‘ fhe pe’rEx'iGner' 4‘ deTecT ThaT ineligibili'iy of The peTiTioher aT The Time of issuance/y \ " . r #‘uimif Card 1‘0 appear irl RMT. Examim‘f%0?1 :3?Id Whw a? fhe ‘fime of ‘fhe .inal admissuofi 0‘1 SC u'i’my of The papers m The pe'%'i'hanex The Respom’ewf No.3 came $0 mew and ee‘i’es‘fed “fhe misfake ie. ‘H'ie pe‘fifioeeri was no? eligibie 'm appeu.“ m fhe RMT‘ examina‘fim i+self as Per §u§e 3, rhe i3erh‘ioraer came? rake +he F3 lea’s‘f Prom$ssoW 3 eS'hDPFeL ' The reseenderi‘rs Had a“? m pain? of Time muee any promises Thai” whosoever iS oiiowed reappear m The PMT. exemimfion and eeeored meri‘f Wm be a’dm§"r“i‘ed fo ne medlco! course The praC‘hce being :oJowed tr The reaporideme :ho‘i’ ax The fime’ of odmIsSioh fhe respondeme scrLri'mue fhe do umeh‘rs of The cohdienfes m order :o asue: ram wherher rhe cohduoo?es fuh‘ii! H fhe reqUiremeTi’s as per fhe Ruies one if ourihg ecru‘i’ihy ahy‘fhEhg is derecf'ed which disehfrHes a eehdido‘i’e To seek admi'ssbm ‘rhen 'rhey ore wifrhih ‘i’heér righ? 1’0 refuse 'fhe aa‘misskh ro my cohdidore arid fhe perh‘ioher cam-1o“? cdhvass rhe pr§ncioies of promissory esroooei because The cohdidofe herseif was aware a'i ‘ihe iime of fiiiihg of 'i‘he form fha‘f she Was no? ’eii'gibie To ' appear m The P M T exa'rihofioh .Tseif as per mile 3 T .ererore +here is ho subsTonce m The argumehfs of learned counsel for The peTiTione: 9. ms fa. as ruie 1a is come hed which says ThaT if ahy quesfion arises regarding ihTerpreTaTion of The huies Theri The decisiori of The GovT. wiii be firiai. Ir: This ease no quesTion of inTerpreTaTiOh of The Rules was ihvo‘ived Therefore Ride 13 is also of no help To The peTiTioner. \ 10.31 The resulT I do noT fihd ahy su'osTance in This wriT peTiTion. The peTiTiOh is devoid of meriT, which is iiable To be and is dismissed. sw- . aceHAooa / Thakur l /\\i\f 7 \" "