^. INTHE HIGHCOURTOE3UDICTURBATBILASPUR 'WP N0. ^9B €-'OF2005' -^: .: •' •: PETITIONER (^w^ wy ^w^ ?>!. ^ .^'••-^ .-'/'^w^ ** v^i^ ^^:/ ?>y^^" ^^ ^' /-p^e ^e^ v^ ^>J" ^ v -•^ RESPONDENTS : 1. A.K. Saxena, aged aboyt 65 years, S/o. St'ii'i K.P. Saxena fhe then Ertgineer-in-Chief, Public Works Deparfment, State of Madhya RFadesh, Bl'topal Retired as^SgGj-etary Public -Works, Oepartn'ient, Madl'iya Pradesh, Bhopal (Recently retii-edt^asTecbnrcal Member Madhya, Pradesh Arbitration Tnbynal,, Bliopal) R/o. A/23, Shaftpura, Bhopal, 462016, Madhya Pradesh. y/2. B.M. Mogher aged about 64 years, S/o. Shrj M.G. Moghe, The ttien Chief Engineer, Py bliG Works DeRartment: (East), Retired as Secretary, Rublic Works Departi-nent, MadHya Pradesh, BhoRal^ FVo, C-109,i Shahpi.n-a, BfeOpal, MadHya Praclesh 46'2016 : '/." /' 3. C. -S. Tnvedi, agsd aboyt 61 years, S/o. Shrr M .P. Trivedi ^Retired as^ Ghief Engineer, Pufilic Works DepartmeHt, BilasRur, ^Chhattisgarh (Presently Working as |ProjeiGt Director, Public Works Bepartment, Asjan Development Bank, - Q/fl. Engineei--in-Chieft Ryblic Works Departrnerit,^^^^^^ Chha^sctarK^ ^Q. ^MiRocha COIony,,? ^ Distrlct Bjlaspur, Chtiattisgarh VERSUS .' f '. . . 1. VijayBatiu Dwivedi, S/o.iaharam Das, I R/O.Sjndhi^otony, i ...Ba|:rgm:Tai)<i^s'Ro^id:,s ;']•:,, \/ :^s.^,'@tlas|:)ll.fr,iDj'sCriGtIBi|%s|?ur,. CKI-iattisgarh. g ^^Si:SE&%,,:, •^aiai&S^iSial^i®^%;®t.i^^;^^Ai.^3S£ii^i^ 'B:l 1 ff:1 v •^^^ <"1. State ofChhattisgarh, Through: The Secretary, Government of Chhattisgarh Public Wprks Department, D.K.S. Bhawan, Mantralaya, Raipur, Chhattisgarh ^3. StateofMadhyaPradesh; Through: The Secretary, Government ofMadhya Pradesh,Public Works Department, Vallabh Bhawan, Bhopal (MP), WRITPETITION UNDER ARTICI-E 226/227 OFTHE CONSTltUTIONOFINDIA ^.;.„.-...„..„«- XI-HC—78 317^1 Vt RFI WHSn^T^TqN? •v~ '3^[ '<i]qiw<<, yTil<H<i<o, fsiyi-My . 1^1- P- M-Z^), WWIISlrHI'K •WI, 200 3D^?[ •q'lSp (t^'IS't) (^n^i^ ?(fStr 3H^T SB : HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICJ; PRITINKER DIWAKER 30.06.2009 Marhlas Shri Raubir Siagh Sbri S.P.Kale, counsel f< Shri Shashaak Thaku No.2. Leamed counsel for 1 petition has become infi-uctuo In view ofthe above, becoine infi-uctuous. i, counsel for fhe petitioner. j)r respondent No. l. [, P.L. for fh.e State/respondent (he petitioner subniits tliat the i|us. tl^e petition is dismissed as havias '^>I<lid4tIli tfl^^ft*^f fsl<l <I»I-^.K i? sifiiT 3ni?i Sd/- PritinkerDiwa&er Judge