...<-^i^ „'"%, t«vs&. 1 :':isgll 1 (',„ ^y' ^.P ^'^.s^^' ^ .-.•.'y 'i 'cs-^ HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR WRFT PETITION (S) No. 2897 of2005 ^'IfV <^?c» s ^^ 62 'irf. ^aTFTt|nT ^reraqi itKW ^g^ 'Tt, gTSlto? ?TTaT cl^^ltii'.si ^T-PpiiT, (Prare ym Tcraira'as ci<si-iy, vtve ffe.SRivn. ari^CTp, \T^i,uiT) 3,^jcf<qiliul : 1. tt.V. ?TraFT gm WiR. am^T'HT 1?g SRuf'T qiyWiT raqpr. •qNra ^r.g. 2- ft^Q V^KfV. ^>t1f t{q w^af Rcil'y^'S ^rWT, lulcff RcTraTTT. ^•'9. 3. t)SI'l!<tl 3I!?prr, SllRtfl'H] R<t>l<r! wvw ap^iqit^ '& 4. Rttii-a 'sn® TtrgiT aISitnt-Ti l^*i<i<<lu-ri <rl-ia<14.<. d^'yid ai*«i<biy,< Tufar <i'ijj,uii 'q.'a. ST^-i IRI gitpftT SIRT 19. Wi.Hp)* 3lto;7ni,g%i^Tnf. 1985 Present: Shri S.K.Thomas, Advocate forthe petitioner. Shi-i Patikaj Shrivastava, Panel Lawyer for the State/respondent No. 1- 3 and4. >th 1. (Passed on l0m day of Febroaiy, 2009) By this petition, the petitioner has prayed for a suitabie •wiit 01 directioa to quash the order dated 17.11.1997 (Amiexure A'14) passed by the respondent No. respondent No. 2, directmg for recover;' ofa sum ofRs. 76,617/- from the retiral dues ofthe petitioner, because this amount was VTonely paidto the petitioner owineto incon-ect fixation ofsalan'. Shri Thomas, !eamed counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that the issue asto whether recoveiy of exesss p&ymest caa be made wifliout fbllowing principles of natural justice is no longer res integra, the same has been settled by the Supreme Court in the matter of Sahib Rcan v. State ofHaryana and others , and tuither foliowed by this Court in the matter ofVidyadhar Tiwan v. The State ofChhattisgarh & Others aiid (4'A'a Shankar Tnvari v. State ofM.P. (Now State ofChhattisgarh) and ofiwrs . In the instant case, the iinpugsied order has been passed without aifording any opportunity ofheai'ingto the petitioner. Shri S^uivastava does not controvert the allegation that ao opportunity of hearing was afforded before the iiiipugned order was passed. Howevsr. he relies on Rule 65 of the CHhattisgarh Civil Services ' 1995 Supp (l) SCC 20 "20y6n)MPHT105(CG) ' 2006 (2) MPHT 31 i'CG) I^OAV^^ L— •S1S03. 0-(S13 J3p.IO Of^ •SOT^Sllt ^.iraBujo ss'[ai3uua gissq 3uiAl>o{pj isgB \WB^ vytiVi soirepjoooB m 'pssiApe osji '9^6]: 'ssp'g sqtjo 09 s|n'g oi s&inoos^ asp^ o-j. spispuodssj sq^ 01. usao si 11 'JSASAOH 'aoipnpsp AUB moqi.iAY ^unoui^ ,<4m^jg/syj:3U3q Ajeuoisasd {{tij: of. pspifio si jsuoi^sd sq^ •3-i (o-tdTis) upMfj, ^oqpDApf^ jo ssso sq^ ui pssscd .isp-io sq^ jo suus}. sip. ai p8MO{p si uopipd siq^ 'SuioSajoj sip jo MSIA iii •jsdojd pnB tsnfsq ^oii I(IA\ .ouoT^sd sqi.jo -p.mouiB Aiinpj§ /sigsusq ;ui3noisusd sip TOO.IJ: yinouiB sssoxs psgsdc sqi jo AJSAOOSJ giit^osjip 'sg-eis siqi TV "A.IBI'BS siq SB SIKBS sq: gui'rca-t). A^gaipjcjo-e jissuiiq gmisnfpB Aq pssn ussq SA^q yc^'^w aiiq ;\q paAposj lunoiire sip pTJS 'KITCJ •}B l.OI! SBM Sq 'J&UOItIpd Slp O'j. SpBia 'AIIB JI 'pISUIABd SS83X3 sip tBip ppq si3q \v^am) UDMIJ, ^wqpDApi^ jo SS'BO si{t m '1^1103 siiy^ •soBB^dsoo'e s^usiu jsiioiiipd sqi joj psnnoo p3iui3S{ sip jo Hoi-pjgyioo sqj, •spwa sq puu^o innoure sssoxs ginsq ^unoure Aimpjg 3t[l. UIO.Sf UOT:Onp3p sq: AqAt OtSB 3SB3 Siq pffiAUOJ }nd 0} jguonpsd sqi 0} ginjesq jo A^iunuoddo AIXB pspjojp? ioa SABq ssquoqmB/spK sip •9'sv.a ^usssjd aq: H[ 'p8A\o(ioj sq oj. psjrnbs-i SJB uoip'e Ui A^id jrej pire soi-isnf [vinfBU^o ssppuud OKVQ '9461 'ssp'g sqtjo £9sin'g jspim jaMod gmspjsxs joj USAS •JBI|I jscoitipd sq^ jo iiopuspjoo av^ .< 1961 'VSV xvl suiooiq sip.jspun sojnos ye siqitonpsp xvf. smooui jo sresu^ pire s83ireA\on'B PTO ABa jo •(iisia^d-.iSAO 'iioi^pounuooov IUSIIUUSAOO jo uonBdnooo o^ Suiure^isd ssSjeqo -isq^o pu^ iiisj jo sresjj'e 'sou^Apr soiiEAsAuoo jo guippnq ssnoq jo souepq sspnpui ^ssnp •pisunusAoo 9]0[evc vs3f5s, aoisssjdxs saj^ 'i-aotpa^(dxg •pspnpsp sq (pqs ssnp •p.isunusAoo 3iqBUI^U33SBJO 1UI1033B UO S(qWSA033J fSV^ OT. ]vnb9 -pinoiire UB •jisq {B§S(jo ssmiuoii siq tinq o: S(qBA^d Ai.in^ejS aqijo ^no (q) io :uiiq ujoJf as-sj^ aq Sswi ^isodsp qsro i.u3[BAinb3 HB (v) -:9\qeu.wy93sv 9 ssnp qons pire sgnp y.isiinusAOO sqt resp ^oa ssop pj^A-iss TOSIIIIUSAOO Siim+sj •B sjaqA'i. fe) •lasmsjiiaj siqjo 3fep sq: sjojsq ssnp tHsunusAOO ye .resp 0} l.ll^A.ISS 1HSUIII.I8AOO glIl.Hp.1 A.ISA3 jo Ainp sq-j. sq ipus y (t) -:ssnp •IH3UIIU8AOO jo yisuqsnfpB pire .USAOOS^I - $9 sin^, :jsputi se sp-B3.i 9461 •ssp'g aip jo 09 '3pr& 'ssnp TOsmiusAor) 10 yisiiQsnip^ pire ..SJSAOOS.I jo ssodind sq^ joj (.9^,61 'ssp'g sqi, iJoqs joj) g^gT 'ssm'g (uoisusa) z •t- Sl»" i^^.,f