IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT : THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.R.RAMAN & THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE T.R.RAMACHANDRAN NAIR TUESDAY, THE 13TH JANUARY 2009 / 23RD POUSHA, 1930. RP.No. 1363 OF 2008() --------------------- AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT IN RFA.244/2005 DATED 04/11/2008 OF THIS COURT. (I.A. 1519/2000 IN IA. 469 /1980 IN O.S. 26/1965 OF SUB COURT, OTTAPPALAM.) .................... REVIEW PETITIONER(S): ---------------------- VALSALA AMMA W/O.VENUGOPALA MENON, "AMBAL NIVAS" WEST FORT ROAD, PALAKKAD. BY ADV. SRI.T.KRISHNAN UNNI (SR.) SRI.R.RAJESH KORMATH RESPONDENT(S): --------------- 1. JACOB P.ELIAS ,S/O. ELIAS, PARAPPATHKUZHIYIL,KILLIMANGALAM VILLAGE, TALAPPILLY TALUK. 2. ANITHA THOMAS, W/O.THOMAS MATHEW KAVUNGAL, SHORNUR VILLAGE, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 3. ANNAMMA MATHEW, W/O.MATHEW KAVUNGAL, SHORNUR VILLAGE, OTTAPALAM TALUK. (PETITIONERS 1 TO 3 ARE REPRESENTED BY THEIR POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER, THOMAS MATHEW, S/O. K.M. MATHEW, KAVUNGAL, KALLIPPADAM, SHORNUR.) 4. P.V.SUGATHAN, S/O.PONNARASSERI VASU KADAVALLUR VILLAGE, KOTATTIKARA DESOM, TALAPPILLY TALUK. R.P. 1363/2008 IN R.F.A. 244/2005 :2: 5. P.K.VSU, S/O.PONNARASSERI PARONGODAN KADAVALLUR VILLAGE, TALAPPILLY TALUK. (DIED) 6. P.K.RAMAN MASTER,S/O.PEECHOLI KUNHU PANNANCHERI VILLAGE, KARIPPAKUNNU DESOM THRISSUR TALUK. (PETITIONERS 4 TO 6 ARE REPRESENTED BY POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER V.C. ELIAS, S/O. PARAPPATH KUZHIYIL CHACKO, KILLIMANGALAM VILLAGE, THALAPPILLY TALUK. ) 7. SINDHU, W/O.KALLADA SURESH KUMAR MANAVALASSERI VILLAGE, MUKUNDAPURAM TALUK. 8. ANITHA ROY, W/O.KAITHAKKAD ROY KURIAN THRIPUNITHURA VILLAGE, KANAYANNUR TALUK. 9. A.J.RAICHAEL, W/O.ELAIAS PARAMBATHUKUZHIYIL,KILLIMANGALAM VILLAGE, TALAPPILLY TALUK. 10. V.K.JOSEPH, S/O.KURACKOSE PARAPPATHIKUZHIYIL, KARUMALAPPILLI VILLAGE TALAPILLI TALUK. 11. V.K.MONCY, S/O.KURIACKOSE PARAPPATHUKUZHIYIL, KARUMALAPPILLI VILLAGE TALAPPILLI TALUK. (PETITIONERS 7 TO 11 ARE REPRESENTED BY THEIR POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER THOMAS MATHEW, S/O. K.M. MATHEW, KAVUNGAL KALLIPPADAM, SHORNUR.) 12. SANJEEVKUMAR, S/O.KALLADA RAMAKRISHNNAN MANAVALASSERI VILLAGE, THANISSERI DESOM MUKUNDAPURAM TALUK. 13. SANTHOSH KUMAR,S/O.KALLADA RAMAKRISHNAN MANAVALASSERI VILLAGE, MUKUNDAPURAM TALUK. 14. SURESH KUMAR, S/O.KALLADA RAMAKRISHNAN MANAVALASSERI VILLAGE, MUKUNDAPURAM TALUK. (PETITIOENRS 12 TO 14 ARE REPRESENTED BY THEIR POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER V.C. ELIAS, S/O. PARAPPATH KUZHIYIL CHACKO, KILLIMANGALAM VILLAGE, TALAPPILLY TALUK.) R.P. 1363/2008 IN R.F.A. 244/2005 :3: 15. V.K.MONCY, S/O.KURIAKOSE PARAPATHKUZHIYIL,KARUMALAPILLI VILLAGE TALAPILLI TALUK. 16. V.K.JOSEPH, S/O.KURIAKOSE PARAPATHKUZHIYIL,KARUMALAPILLI VILLAGE TALAPILLI TALUK. (PETITIONERS 15 & 16 ARE REPRESENTED BY THEIR POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER THOMAS MATHEW, S/O. K.M. MATHEW, KAVUNGAL KALLIPPADAM, SHORNUR.) 17. P.R.SUSHEELKUMAR, S/O.PEECHOLI RAMAN MASTER, PANNASSERI VILLAGE KARIPPAKUNNU DESOM, THRISSUR TALUK. 18. SATHYANATHANUNNI NAIR,KAVALAPPARA KOTTARAM, OTTAPALAM TOWN, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 19. GOURI NETHIAR, KAVALAPPARA KOTTARAM OTTAPALAM TOWN, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 20. RAJENDRANUNNI NAIR, KAVALAPPAA KOTTARAM, OTTAPALAM TOWN, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 21. PRATAPANUNNI NAIR,KAVALAPPARA KOTTARAM OTTAPALAM TOWN, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 22. INDIRA, KAVALAPPARA KOTTARAM OTTAPALAM TOWN, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 23. RAMANI, KAVALAPPARA KOTTARAM OTTAPALAM TOWN, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 24. PRAKASHKUMAR, KAVALAPPARA KOTTARAM OTTAPALAM TOWN, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 25. VIJAYAM NETHIAR, KAVALAPPARA KOTTARAM OTTAPALAM TOWN, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 26. SARALA NETHIAR, KAVALAPPARA KOTTARAM OTTAPALAM TOWN, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 27. RAVINDRANUNNI NAIR, KAVALAPPARA KOTTARAM OTTAPALAM TOWN, OTTAPALAM TALUK. R.P. 1363/2008 IN R.F.A. 244/2005 :4: 28. RUGMINI ALIAS SUBHADRA AMMA, SURABHI, ELAMAKKARA, PUTHUKKALAVATTOM, KOCHI. 29. VRINDAKUNHI AMMA, CENTRE FORT, 6A, CHITOOR ROAD, ERNAKULAM TOWN. 30. RAJEEV, CENTRAL COURT, 6A, CHITOOR ROAD, ERNAKULAM TOWN. 31. RAJENDRAN, CENTRAL COURT, 6A, CHITOOR ROAD, ERNAKULAM TOWN. 32. KHADIJA, AMBALAVAYALIL, NALLADAM, KOZHIKODE. 33. ABUBACKER, AMBALAVAYALIL, NALLADAM, KOZHIKODE. 34. THANKAMANI CHERIYAMMA, CHONATH VEEDU, NALLEPULLI, CHITTOOR TALUK. 35. A.V. VIJAYAKUMARI, ANSSA, PADIVATTOM ROAD, KOCHI-24. 36. A.V. BALACHANDRAN, BANK LANE, OTTAPALAM TOWN. 37. CHITTARANJAN DAS, VADAVANNUR, MARUTHUR HOUSE, CHITTUR TALUK. 38. DAMODARAN UNNI, BANK LANE, OTTAPALAM TOWN. 39. SURENDRANATHAN, BANK LANE, OTTAPALAM TOWN. 40. T. GOPIKA, BANK LANE, OTTAPALAM TOWN. 41. V. SUBHADRA MENON, 6TH AVENUE, ANNA NAGAR, CHENNAI. 42. VIJAYAN, 6TH AVENUE ANNA NAGAR, CHENNAI. 43. MRS. GEETHA RAMACHANDRAN 6TH AVENUE ANNA NAGAR, CHENNAI. R.P. 1363/2008 IN R.F.A. 244/2005 :5: 44. SARALA G.MENON, 6TH AVENUE ANNA NAGAR.CHENNAI. 45. MANORAMA VIJAYAN SIVASAKTHI, KUNNATH MEDU, PALAKKAD. 46. JANAKI AMMA, SIVASAKTHI, KUNNATH MEDU, PALAKKAD. 47. RADHA BALAKRISHNAN VRINDAVANAM, ATHANI, ALUVA TALUK. 48. RAMESH, 'VRINDAVANAM,ATHANI, ALUVA TALUK . 49. BHASKARAN 'VRINDAVANAM,ATHANI, ALUVA TALUK. 50. RAKESH, 'VRINDAVANAM,ATHANI, ALUVA TALUK. 51. RAVUNNIKUTTY, AARADHANA PULASSERI AMSOM, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 52. UNNIAN HAJI, S/O.ALAVI HAJI, PARAYARUKUNDIL, VALLAPPUZHA, OTTAPALAM. 53. HASAINAR, S/O.ALAVI HAJI, PARAYARUKUDIL, VALLAPPUZHA, OTTAPALAM. 54. P.V.SURESH, S/O.VASU, PONNARASSERI, KAVUR VILLAGE, KORATTUKARA DESOM, THRISSUR. 55. MOHANDAS, S/O.PEECHOLI RAMAN MASTER, PANANCHERI VILLAGE, KARIPPAKUNNUR DESOM, THRISSUR TALUK. 56. ABUBACKER, S/O.ABDU, PUTHEN VEETTIL, AYYANTHOL VILLAGE, THRIKUMARAKUDAM VILLAGE. 57. KALLADA RAMAKRISHNAN, MANAVALASSERI VILLAGE, MUKUNDAPURAM TALUKL. (DIED) R.P. 1363/2008 IN R.F.A. 244/2005 :6: 58. KUNHI MOIDEEN HAJI, PALAKURISSI PUTHEN PEEDIYEKKAL, VALLAPUZHA, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 59. HAMSA, THADATHIL HOUSE, KULAPULLIL, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 60. ALI ALIAS MUTHU HAJI, PARAYARAKUNDIL HOUSE, VALLAPPUZHA, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 61. MAMMI HAJI, S/O.KUNNATHU MOIDEENKUTTY, VANIYAMKULAM AMSOM, PULACHITHARA DESOM, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 62. SUSHAMA JAYAN, ANANDALAYAM, THRIPPUNITHURA, ERNAKULAM TALUK. 63. BINDU PRAKASH, MANGALY NAGAR 5, ARUMBAKKAM, CHENNAI. 64. P.SARASWATHI KUNHAMMA, JANAKI APARTMENT, R.S.PURAM, KOVAL. (DIED). 65. MOHANDAS, 176E, 3RD FLOOR, JANAKI APARTMENTS, RAMALINGAM ROAD, COIMBATORE. 66. MANOHARAN, 176E, 3RD FLOOR, JANAKI APARTMENTS, RAMALINGAM ROAD, COIMBATORE. 67. MOOKKONATH VALSALA, W/O.LATE RAMACHANDRANUNNI MANNADIAR, LEELALAYAM, CHERUPULASSERI AMSOM, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 68. MOOKKONATH SARATH CHANDRAN, W/O.LATE RAMACHANDRANUNNI MANNADIAR, LEELAYALAM, CHERUPULASSERI AMSOM, OTTAPALAM TALUK. 69. K.BHAVANI, W/O.P.K. VASU, KADAVALLUR VILLAGE, KORATTIKKARA DESOM, TALAPPILLY TALUK. R.P. 1363/2008 IN R.F.A. 244/2005 :7: 70. P.V.SATHYAN, S/O.P.K. VASU, KADAVALLUR VILLAGE, KORATTIKKARA DESOM, TALAPPILLY TALUK. THIS REVIEW PETITION HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 13/01/2009, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY PASSED THE FOLLOWING: P.R. RAMAN & T.R. RAMACHANDRAN NAIR, JJ. = = = = = = = = = = = = = R.P. NO. 1363/2008 IN R.F.A. 244/2005 = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = DATED THIS, THE 13TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2009. O R D E R Raman, J. Review petitioner is the appellant in R.F.A. 244/2005. She seeks to review the judgment rendered by us on 4th November, 2008. In para 13 of the judgment, we have observed that the contention that some extent of the property was subsequently proposed to be acquired by the State was not a matter where the court below has rendered any finding thereto and hence do not arise out of the order passed by the court below. It is also observed that being a question of fact and the appellant having not made any plea with regard thereto and in the absence of any evidence adduced with regard to the notification issued, the appellant has not laid any foundation. In the review petition, it is stated that a ground has been taken in the appeal memorandum filed before this Court. Further, an impleading petition was filed producing the notification. 2. We have only stated in Para 13 that if the entire property is not liable to be partitioned because of any portion of the property is being acquired, the appellant should have amended the pleading and raised an R.P. 1363/08 IN R.F.A. 244/2005 :2: issue thereon which was not done. Further, even according to her, what has been preferred is a petition for impleadment which was dismissed by the court below. Even before us, no convincing materials were there to entertain the contention as now raised. We find no merits in the review petition. Dismissed. P.R. RAMAN, (JUDGE) T.R. RAMACHANDRAN NAIR, (JUDGE) knc/-