^r ffiGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BBLASPUR WrU PettUDn No. 2927 of2005 PETITIONERS 1. 2. 3. 4. 8. 9. Brijnandan Prasad Jaiswal, S/o Bhagwan Prasad Jaiswal, Aged about 30 years, R/o Village, Mahuli, Odgi, Tahsil Surajpur, District Surguja (CG). Mukesh Chand Gupta, S/o Rajan Oupta, aged about 28 years, Chanderpur, Salka, District Surguja (CG). Vijendra Kumar Singh, S/o Prem Siagh, a^d about28 years R/o Odgi, Tahsil Surajpur, District Surguja (CG). Ku. SArojbala D/o Satyaaand Dubey, aged about 24 years, R/o Balangi, Tahsil Wadrafaagar, District Surguja (CG). Ku. Priya D/o Sharad Kumar, aged about 20 years, R/o Odgi, Tahsil Surajpur, Distt. Surguja (CG). Bhuneshwar Prasad S/o Narendra Prasad, aged about 26 years R/o Sunderpur, Distirct Surguja (CG). Ku. Archana Mishra D/o Shyamlal Mishra, aged about 22 years, R/o Vishalpur, Tahsil Surajpur, Distriet Surguja (CG). Shailesh Kumar Dwivedi S/o Vinay Kumar Dwivedi, aged about 21 years, Wo Bhaiyathan, District Surguja (CG). Abhishek Singh S/o Shailesh Sigh; ayed about 20 years, R/o Odgi, Tahisl Surajpur, District Surguja (CG). 10. Umesh Kumar Yadav, S/u Shivdayal Yadav, aged about 24 years, R/o Adhina Salka; District Surguja (CG). Braj Kishore Shukla S/o Ashok Kumar Shukla, aged about 25 years, R/o Balangir Tahsil Wadrafaagar, District Surguja (CG). Animesh Lal S/o Rambihari Lal, aged about 24 yeare, R/o Bhadi, District Surguja (CG). Santosh Kumar Gupta, S/o Jfauanu Lal Gupta, Aged about28 years, R/o Davna, District Surguja (CG). 14. Ashok Kumar Singh, S/o Sachudra Singh, aged about 28 years, R/o Manendragarh, Distt. Koriya (CG). 15. Ku. Swati Shanna, D/o Suresh Sharma, ag%labout24 years R/o Patna, Tahsil Baikunthpur, Distt. Koriya (CG). 16. Ku. Rupa Gupta D/o Sudama Gupta, agded about 24 years, R/o Salka, District Surguja (CG). 17. Smt. Padmawati Jaiwal W/o Balmukund Jaiswal, aged about 28 years R/o Niharpur, District Sui^uja (CG). 18. Smt. Manju Choubey W/o Yogendra Choubey, aged about 27 years, R./o Darima, Tahsil Ambikapur, District Surguja (CG). 11 12 13 ..^. 19. Smt. Sudha SmgliW^Shaae^ 26^arsi^Sat^ur(DisttictS»%qa(CG). )/ Smt Saageeta Singh ^^ Pramod^S^ 24 yeais, R/o GujapBT (M^DistrietSurgiya ^CG). 21. Shatendra Kumar Guqar s/o Naresh 3Ku»»l"Gteqai^ aged afaout 24 .years, I^ Kliana, Odp, Disteict SBigBJa(CG). 22. Mamg Rumar Yaday S/q Ram Pyare Yada^ age^ about 26 5fea^ R^ IMiaisedi, Bagnathjm, Disto^ Suiguja(CG). 23. R^nisb Jaiswal &'o Shasbibhushaa Jmswd, ^ed about 22 years, R/o Visiuampw. Distriet Swg^a (CG). •:.' :.:.: : , .^: .' 24. Ku. Sarita Yqdav D&) Pi'anchandra Yadav, age4 about 24yeaT^R^^ndet^!i lMis^^SurgBgfrCC^. 25. Dipend Kum3 C'arJ l^V3ipmKu^ about 25 $^ais R& Ruppa. I^^ Disfa^ SuTguga 26. ShpbhaYada^B/o RajeaA»fta^Yadaj% ag^alwut^ 22 years, Rto <yt3agu^ Disto^Surgiija^^ 27. Ka.Veisla Jaisw^Bfe ^tdu!sAffiAJfflwa},^e3al O years, SA Cklg^ TafasU Suia^ Disttiet jSHguja .:cc^-'.-:••'•.1'1. ,.','-.• 28. Snrt. Priti CNuTJair Wo .Awadta Rm^^ ^©ut^^eaTs^J^£at^M^l)tstHctSu%^(©G5s s 29. Smt.Sarita Sahm, W^i.iNi^ 8al^A^Bfet>t25 ^ars, R/©Basaapaia,@iSlm^SBiOTa((3(3). | t Pe^ t^id^ ^^Jagsat,^ a^^ Kania, DistfictSurgt^L (C©). 31. J&i. Hema Ri^ I^^^ 32. Brizeet iOialldb®|S^ S^T^^ abmt 24 years, fi^Bhs^aoiB,|DistrietiSui®g&(G©), 33. ^a^ Ss^ S/o^Basw^Ss^^^s^^ R^Iffiarsedi.piisrtl^SB^^ 34/ Lw Kum^ ^ ^sSingh, ageA^b^ iaderpui; Efcteiet Sttis»iii^©3^. ^ i 35. Avil Khalkho S^ Ni^^ y8ars,1^K&CTid, E&tr^Sujtg^jil^^ | 36. PTadeepKm^^Saj^^ Odgi, TAfasiISBl^pui^ Distn^ | 37. titefaaimSi^Rai»ihai%itamya^ Batjn^hpur,D|stinfct£itoig]^a^^^ II 38. Rampatt S^yR^cK.^ Kad»laya,E»j^tncl|jSu%!B^(]€|©) 39.:.Sui:i^Sin^.^ja|ainlal|£l®gdL: (., ^I^aMlatg@e]||eea;K^E?'|3to|gmi|; S' rs,:R%l^i!^^l^|;@is&|c^'S^u^^<i^|j'j^^^ a"iiSiJ ••^^\ %s: ::^li;^^|' ':;iiiia 'iilSlffiil .'SSB1 1MB :i;ai m l:i!3!ll i3iil i'H'ii 11 ;.^i0vit,^yiss^^/^^ j^&E>mt:.i24|5jemsi|'.^Q|ij||||j||| iU)..i;:l:j||||BI| is iii^iB'liaiBHtK :li]i;!li"itlM»BUii lH!3iH»iit;!i! MM ei? il§ irii !.r.§ l?.l III ^Sf^ @^<g:^ rii Si:.KI'ia.§.'°- iIJlt Ijtjj •'':t:::?j -ll'l •^^ i^ i'lt f£1 .8.'' •i'G ^^ ^ffi''tS'*''"****;."iBJ" •S-';:S,'!':,(BS.S, %& III il?:§- "^^ in rll 5%i Ml( •«" il:'<: <s.^ W'.;.R. w ^M-». ,.%" aged about 22 yesars, R/o Qdgi, Tahsil Siir^pux» District Surguja(CG): 65. Santosh Kumm Manjya S^ Mdiilal, aged A years, R/o Odgi, Tahsil SurajpiK, Distoiet Surpga .!<CG).;:;'.;: ^•::.:1:;.-^ ,. ::.,: 1,1..:,1 1: 66. Mahavir Ram Pando S/o Ind»bhaaPaatto, aged aboat 26 year^ R/o Psad^ BihatpuiyDistri<dSiu^a((XT). 67. Ariun Pando SA) Hiagldi Pimid^ aged about 25 year^ R/o(^apui,^Odgi;DistrictSurguja(£(3). 68. Bhiuya Lal PandoS/o Pfaool Siaglt Pmido, aged aboiit 27 years,Kfefilia^"Iadisil.Sui%pBi;^ (CG). :, ! ,',1;..' -, '•:•':."- 69.RaugI-idSA)LalmanPMido,^edaboutt9yews,R/o Biharpui,TghsMSutajp8r,I^riiriSui^ 70. Ram Ratan ^aado, S/&^>Mme I^ 20 yeais, SA>,yillag&Sapha,Ta}isil SUI%»BI,District Surgiga(CG); :VERSUS--;': , : " ^ : :. . : : • 1. Tbe Stete ctf (Matfeg^ flroagfc ^ S^^ Pan<Aayat aad Social Wel&pel DepartiBei^^^ ^ Bhawan, Raipur (GG). 2. TheColtet^Ambikain^BisttSaisuja^^ 3. The Zila Paaehai«t AnalafcapiB' ttKOB^ jts Ch»tf Exeeuth®Officel^ Zila Raiwh^^ ABtbikapai; 1%^ SurgujafCG^ 4. The Janpad Panchay^ (^^ fhnMigh^^^^^^ Janpad Panchayat, Odgi, TaihsaT Sur^pui, IMstt; Su^iiga r(CG)-: ;1:'::' ::: '•.: ;:.: :.: j! :';1;:' fWRCTEETmCWUNDERAR'nCLE22®^(WI%CONSmtTri^ <SB: HfWHflhIe Mr.SatisliK.Aeiffliotri.Al Present : SlmP.R. Pa.tMd^Adxoeato^fc Shn M.P.^ Bb^ia, Depu^GovA lAdvocat&fiM- &e State/respoadentNo, 1 &2. Shri P.M. Slmvas, AtivQeat^fortBe respcmdeirtNo. 3. Shri Sand^ Dub^ A<h'ocatB fta-lbe iespondentlfo.^4. RESK?N1 NT!S : • Y.fy9^^vi&^s^m3^,3S ^^.^ ' :, ;:. "'i' ' . 1. With the consent ofdiepai&s, (he nratte is ^ finaily. ^_: • •• ! ;. ' : '' ; • '" '' : :: . -..l:.r1' 14:':;: ^'The petitkm^ wereappQurts4as ShifcAKai^ PamchayatOdgi,DistectSto^a(CX^byordfc^^ (Aanexure P/5).; The CMeEExec^^ a!i! WKK 'i' l^l^l •^'^l'iiil' ;i 1,1,^^: Salw u Sui%uja, caneelled tiie eirtire select lis* by onier (teted 02.07^)5 (Annexurc B^8)^ 3. Being aggrieved, thepetitionere havefiM OTSer dated 02.07.(^ on ttie groimd tiiat fhe petitkmera vare dnly selected and the petitiCTners Aad joined the semcesi also. TlteTe^ter, without any notice CT- w^hout giviag aa <)ppottucaty ofheariag t&the petitioners, tiie entire select list has bwn camcelled which (auses .pKgudicetofhfipetiEtiioners. . 4. This very issue came into Gensiderafio&^ln^ ofKu. Pimamem^oShersV&SWecfC attia^afi&Q^rs^K:(S) Jfe ftS<20<^ aiMi cther eonaect£4mrttei^w^ r^ iinpugned order which is punith® te^^^^i^^ evjl consequences, eatinot be passe±inthoutaffi^^ hearing. It was fiirl^heldl^ tiw unpigiieAoidCTSin respect offlrose petitioners who faave not finmd place in thesecond seleetlis^ dl^Bot be given efifect to|until ^ petitiomra are affittd^ opp^timi^^^^^W hearu% tff estabtisb truffifiriffles^ genuaeness ^ fe^^^ submitt^ l^ himiw obtaMunga^xMntoaent;(m l^ sulBequenfly caneelled. 5. Acc<^mgly, the p^ittODisallowedtefheabbveextettt. Nffl.ondeFiasJio :'.ias: ®BaRi ffliai • '•iVS II ,'s^m BU!iN MIB ISKW jlNIB '88! llfi aiai •BlSffilll •I costs. ^sdl-:,^.. SatisttiK.Agnihotn Judge iiiii Mlfl! KB J. \' iiMii i;-~iL-.._ 1 WiSt :'i:JEN!il i::' :':f: lalti