3'eET "i(i't|i?i<<, yrfly'Ks, [sio'.iyy ^0% sn^r ^R^ (ipf^g^r) sn^r.^i R-f OTI3IR?! itill'* TOiIWHf??! 311^1 HI6H COURT OF Wrlt Petltt FET1TIGHBR d< a< B- di VRRSITS RESFOMDEn'TS 1. U.1* Did sy LE Bri^wan (Clf Viji Bs 5- Ja wnt Petit; PETITIONERS 1. 2. 0(| i?l J4 Nt at B[ (4 VBRSUS RSSSPONDENTS chl^<fl'l ^i^dl' ^f fe^ Tf^'^lK i? sifgii sil^?[ ;HHATTISOARH AT BILASPUR t" 'C-ivill No. 6053/2007 ^epn LaKra, son ol Late Jonao. LaKia, ?d abont 70 veaj's. reRide.nt nf ^gicha, TahsU Bagicba, istipur t<Jiitiattisgarli) .frict and Sessions Judge, 'trict Raigarli (Clib^.ttisgarli) UISU'ICT Kaigarn, te ot Ctitiattisgarli, Uirougii teiecretary, anr^ LrGS^l Dei3QTt2U€Ilt. D.K^S U.tS. Koact, Kaipur Lli£itti.sffarli) ^.y Gupta, Advocate And Notary, TahsU ^icha, District Jashpur (Chliattisgarh) Ip Kuiiasif Siolia, son of Shri B.K, pia, Aclvocate aacl Notary, Main Koad, k?iclis. F>.0. ?anfl Ttslisil Bs.siclis > ? »-^- t ^^ •>^'A.» -»--lA^AlL/A-]l.t^.^ itnct Jasnpur (UU) ':tyt>'2'2':t ^sszo. CIxsiid. MuTpri, Son Of SIui Sao, Ncai' Talisfl Coui'l Bagicua, ^bikapur Road, Talisil Baycha, District ihour fChIiattissarU 496224 (on (Civil) no. 644/;<oos SnUia, BE Ull Pot Kaluasu Aa|iDiKapur rTasau ijay KuiEiar Siolia., S/o St'iri 'Jogendra. Siuha, aged auoul 47 ycais, :upation Advocate, K/o viUage Di.strict "il?'f°'T?a Tahail Rs>Gnr'Tii .snpur (UUj 'elkanth. C^upta, S/o Shri Gupta, aged out years, occupation- Advocate, R/'o leicha. TaJ'isil Bagicha. Distt- JashTinr r?A i~rj 1. THe State of CIihattisearh. fhroush ft>e sejcretaiy, Law aad Legislature D^parfTYieiTit D.R.S. Bliawaii, Raiptir (CG) GRPRJ— FS/246—2/2007— 50,000.' 3=5^ ^)]i||^, aTfl+1'l(S, [cf^l^y an^r isss (yS-yitsi) SII^T.^ f?liq> WHSTI^I **<!<*> ?^iIW?lfef STI^I 2. d. 4. K. L>lSt]|lCt Distil, vyail aad tiessions dudge, Ka^arii, (, Raigarh (CG} Gupta, Advocate And Notary, Taasil .^lia, Di.strict 'Ja.sIipur (OhhattiscrarTi) Kuiuai' Siuua, Advocalc aiid Nolai'y, jft. Bagicha, District Jashpur (CG) diaT!fl ^Sursii. A<lvoc^te Qiid Notajry, Taasil Bagicha, Distfc Jashpur Bagi{ DUi^ Tahs PoorlEtm (CG) FRBSENT: Shii Suiul Sauu, Au'l Sinha and Neelkaafili. yiui M.B. Agrawal, Asr&wsl. Advocste. fctr Shri P.P. Sahu, Advcj No.6053/2007. sun B.U. Uiiru, Aai; Sinha njid Poonain yjDiii ^uiuesu. oajai, o g n- D&li'ettuta Mishra, J. W.P. (Cj No. 6053/2007 pj No, 644/2008 prefeiTed by AnjaJ are beuig ctisposea ot Dy Uu^ petitions, the petitioners tiave .siUU3 passea &y Uistnct aacl appticatlon/ meinorial submitteif at Bagicfia. '2.. ilie gnevance ot Uie Sessions Judge, Raigarh vide |UctoDer,^UU'^ uivited appUca^ ctil<llf<r}^Tl 'RR^f ^f 'f^Si' "-[f^^K ^? aiRn sii^i ^ocatc ibr uic peuuoucrs Ajay KLiiuai' |r. Advocate wiu yun F'aiitca] \r th.e T^elitiouer JOSCT?II L-slcr^ ^cate ibr respondent No. 3 ia W.P.(C) ^cate for respondents Duip Kumar Chajid Murari- Cjovt. Advoc;ate for tb.e State. U B R 6-20081 (Telen-ecl by Joseph Lakra asd W.P.(C) Kumar yiatia and NeeikauUi Gupta coininon orcter as ui bofh ftiese itnpugned the order dated 19th April, |Sessions Judge, Raigarh filuig the tsy ttiem tbr appouitmeut as Nolary p^tiUoners are tliat t&e Uistnct aad ineino ot Annexure r-i dated i" lons tiiieinonal) troiu ttie desu'ous GRPRJ— FS/246—2/2007— 50.000. /^as^ \ a ^^< ^SSI '<)i<|]i?i<1, 8iTfl+)'l<D, tsf<rtlt1^< sn^r irag; (lcifl«i<iT) an^.^iT R-ii«b wnsiRW SCTR? TOIIWTlfSa 3TI^I thie ^^iast Notanes requ4rea nieinbers tor appouitiaent ot Notaries in Baglcha ttirough thje IJtie appticaats suEinutted Uieu[ along wittt necessaiy docuiiieD|ts District aad Sessions dudge AssociaUon, Bagiciia tliat Notaries ia Bagicha Tahsil, worlang as Notary'. 3. ine only ground raised are Uiat Kule t> ol me appoiD.tiaent of Notary is autnonty wlio ui tuiTi snau esj saUstiecl uiat me appticant specmea uiicler Kule a or mal wifhin six inoaths before the d is duty bouud to tiold enquify representation to t&e apptica(it uiake report to the approprial aaa me appropnate reject t&e appucanon under 1956. However, in the iiistaiit have been rejected uiider sub-|ruJ aiid Vae saxne tiave been tUecl contrary to ttie Kule / and Kulf fNotary agauist tturee vacaat posts of 1-Tesiaent, Bar AssociaUon, tiagicJia. lu.einonal in tlie prescnbea protomia >, J&owever ttie saiue was tUed t>y tUe ps. Vse basis ot report ot 1'atisil Bar the saactioned posts of fhree ^espondents No. 3 to 5 are aireacly Goverrurtent Rtlle ch!-ill(n'4ll 'RTR^f ^f ft^ Tfsf^.i'i. ^siRpTsn^i ^y ttie peUUoners in oom ttie peUttons Kules, ly&b, t&e appticaUon tor to be processecl by tfae competent ^ammp uie appJlcaUons. Wiiere tie is |does not possess fhe qualifications tus previous appiicatloit was rejected [ate ol appiication, tie caa reject it. He after giving opportuiuty of niafcuig a^amst aay objection, 11 aay, ansl Govenuneat on ttie representation is osly enipowerea to accept or (Ij ot Kule y ot tue notanes Kules, 'ase, ttie applicauon ot tlie pentioners [ruie (1) ofRuk 8 offhe Notaries Rules leaniesl Uistnct ana yessions Judge 8 ofthe Notaries Rules, 1956. 1'y GRPRJ— FS/246—2/2007— 50.000. -tSS'fVs. ^^^^. l\ 3^ST -^W^, Qi^WW, Rc'.itiy sn^i IH% (4<:i!'t°i<!sT) aii^r.^i R-ii* wnsn^i sti^i* f/ TOiIWHfttf 31)^1 Notto' applicjaUons 4. Kroiu Uie avennents ub. appointtaent proceeauig was appointtnent of Notaiy at Baglf issuaace ot certuicate tor area to wtucli it relates lor a me certtticate is issued to mm.l S>. Leamed counsel tor Uiet did not dispute that t&e total is Uu-ee aud Ue responclentsj smna aiid ynn Poonam Utiaud lafasil uagicna aacl Uie the petitiouers in t&e year 20(^ by tne penuoners on &-y-^ alreacly poiated out tliat Uie ci| a penocl ot 5 years, tne by the petitioners tor also against Uie appom.tm.ent Uilip Kuniar Huitta ancl worlaug as Notanes ui Ue yi suDject uiatter ol Ue peUUon^ wifh fhe lapse of time and wimout gouig into t&e inents o^ petiUopts appouit4ient ShA chiq^'l^t'T-qT^tt'^ FS^I <f^1^.H ^siRrirsn^i ttie peuuon, it is clear mat Uie uiitiatecl ui uie vear ^uu^ tor Ua. Kub-rule 4 ot Kule K proviaes lor ly authoriziag nim to practice in fhe ot 5 years troin t&e aate on wlucfi p^nocl petittoners appeanng tor petitioaers njuinber ot vacanci' ot Notary ui Bagicaa fcitin Vijay Uupta, yfin Ultlp Kumar Murari were appoiated as Notaries tbr (nienionals) were submittea Dy \'^. lliese two petitioiis Jiave been tiled p07 aud 29-1-2008 respectively. As srtlticate ot Notaries inay be issued tbr pertain to Uie nieinonals subnuttea as Notanes ui t&e year '2UV2 and p>t responclents Htu-i Vgay Uupta, ynn u(i Poonam Chaad Murari who were :ar ^UU^-U3. In tliese circiunstances, liavuig Decoine stale and inTructuous the petitions are disposed of tlie clispute. ac<|;orduigly Sd/- Ubirendra GRPRJ — FS/246—2/2007— 50.000.