IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BILASPUR: CHHATTISGARH W.P. N0.^5 =?-OF 2006 """ Petitioner Respondents ^sy ^^?)-" <^7 ?--""**"<:,£-, ^a9\ ^s^y ^@'5''' .^y Bharat Refractories Limited Bhilai Refractories Plant Through its Dy. General Manager (In charge) Maroda, Bhilai Shri C.P. Singh, S/o Shri Kulwant Singh, aged about51 years, R/d D-19, Hospital Sector, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (Chhattisgarh) Versus 1. Deputy Labour Commissioner ^- and Appellate Authority under Payment of Gratuity Act, Raipur (Chhattisgarh) 2. Assistant Labour Commissioner and Controlling Authority under ^ Payment of Gratuity Act, Durg (Chhattisgarh) 3. , Tehsildar (Nazul), Durg ^ (Chhattisgarh) 4 S.R. Thakur, Ex-Fitter, (MM), Village - Hingana, P.0. Ahiwara, Distt. Durg (CG) 5. S.P. Nishikant, Ex-Fitter (MM) LIG, 2669, MP Housing Board, Industrial Area, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (CG) 6 Dayaram Sahu, Ex-Sr. Attndt. Garrage, Village & Post- Biroda, Tahsil - Dhamdha, Distt. Durg 7 Narendra Kumar Joshi, Ex-Sr. Attnd. PGP, 3/1, Street-4, Sector - 6, Bhilai Nagar, Durg 8 Umed Singh Gond, Ex-Sr. Attndt. F/C Press, Village - Pachpedi, Pandhor, Durg (CG) 9 Chaitram Sahu, Ex-Operator PGP, 190/D, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 P.R.Gond, Ex-Fitter (MM), Village - Botepar, P.0. Patewa, Rajnandgaon (CG) Gopal Singh Gond, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Silica, Village & Post - Pisegaon, Durg. Parasram Kriplani, Ex-Pump Attendant (Civil), Village & Post - Utai, Durg „ Ramkishan Sakhre, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Basic Village - Rajiv Nagar, (Ramnagar), Supela, Durg Ganesh Ram Chelak, Ex-Sr. Attend (MM), Tanki Maroda, Civil Centre, Bhilai Nagar, Durg. Baranlal Gond,;Ex-Operator Silica Press, Village - Dhor, P.0. Gorhi, Tahsil - Dhamdha, Durg Laxminath Sahu, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Basic Press, Village - Dhor, P.0. Nardha, Durg (CG) Ramprasad, Ex-Sr. Attend. F/C Mill, Camp - 1, Shastri Chowk, Bhilai, Supela, Durg (CG) K.R, NagwanshT, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Basic Mill, HSCL Colony, Maroda, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) Kunjlal Thakur, Ex-Press Operator, Silica, Village & Post - Batdeopur, Distt. Rajnandgaon (CG) Tikam Sjngh Rana, Ex-Press Operator, Silica, Village & Post - Purai, Durg. xv!>iv i ' '^ i. Jhaggar Das Sao, Ex. Sr. Attend (Civil), Village - Parnad, P.0. Panika, Distt. Rajnandgaon (CG) 22 Luduram Rawat, Ex-Sr. Attend (MM), Village & Post - Chandkun, Distt. Durg (CG) fej i'R.RW'--"1.!; si' S'l.^y .^^- s-&si^y ~i^fsS-a^-»cS^"" 23 Noikhuram Sahu, Ex-Sr. Attend (MM), Village & Post - Kuthrail, Distt. Durg (CG) 24. Dhajaram Gond, Ex-Sr. Attend BasicTK, Tanki Maroda, P.0. Civic Centre, Bhilai, Durg (CG) 25. Koduram Verma, Ex-Sr. Attend. F/C Mill, Village - Pachpedi, Post - Panhdor, Durg (CG) 26. D.B. Behra, Ex-Chargeman, Basic TK, 30/F, Risali Sector, Bhilai, Durg (CG) 27. Madanlal Kewat, Ex. Operator PGP, Nayapara ward No. 1, Durg (CG) 28. Gangaram Chandrakar, Ex-Sr. Attend, Basic TK, Village & Post Kuthrail, Durg (CG) 29. Rajendra Prasad Hardel, Sr. Attend Basic, Village - Chingari, P.0. Vinayakpur (Anda), Durg 30. Punaram Lohar, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Basic TK, Village & Post Biroda, Durg (CG) 31. Guharam Kurmi, Ex-Sr. Attend Basic TK, Village & Post,- Tedesara, Distt. Rajnandgaon (CG), Durg (CG) 32. Dashrathlal Verma, Ex-SSG, Security Titurdih Ward-17, P.0. Mohan Nagar, Durg (CG) 33. Ratanlal Banjare, Ex-Sr. Peon, 159 F, Risali Sector, P.0. Civic Centre, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 34. Jagannath Sahu, Ex-Sr. Attend (MM), Village & Post - Tedesara, Rajnandgaon (CG) 35, B.R. Gahira, Ex-Sr. Attend, Basic TK, Station Maroda, Umarkoti Road, P.0 Newai, Durg (CG) (Q3) Bjna 'uoeCteqg -isod 'iqesjed s6B]|!/\ •punv 'JS~X3 '-in>|eqi pesejdaiBy (33) 6jna 'ueied - lisqei 'eA!3Je» 'O'd 'epLiuej - sBe||i/\ 'sBejjeQ •puuv 'JS-X3 '!LueuleS LUBje6ueQ \ (33) 6jnQ 'uoeBqiBH -isod 'iqesjed sBe||!A 'IAIIAI •puuv '-iS -x3 'n^es qieuosqg (QO) BJPQ 'eisdng 'JBBBN ABfues 'esno|-| ]|i|/\] oiseg 'joiejado -xg 'ueBueMSQ pesejd UBABJBN (00) Bjna 'B|eLUBMueL)g - isoj 'undfejv - a6e||!A 'Bui^osqo eoiiig 'J9>]OSl)3-X3 'jn>|Bl|l LUBjnLULUBN (30) Bjna •ISIQ 'insueqg isoj y QBe\\\/\ 'uosd-xg 'jn^feqi ujejnq^na (00) Bjna leiiqg 'g - dLueo 'ejBd e6jna ' IIMQ •puuv '-IS-X3 'nMBS leisqqejd (QO) Bjna '-ie6euLuey •O'd 'e>l40» 'jeBeN Je>]paqujv •puuv 'JS-XB 's^siiuey ifnqiQ (SO) 6jnQ 'jeBeuujey •O'd 'e>iqo>| 'jeBeN Je>|psqujv •puuv '-iS~x3 'S-IMB'I pesejdujey (90) Bjna '!ein •Q-d 'BJO}Bd - sBe|]!/\ 'eoueus}uiB|/\| |eou}09]3 'ueiouioe|3 -xg 'ueBueMGQ jeujnx BJpusASQ (QO) B-ina 'zeoe sn 'eajy |euisnpu| 'pjeog SuisnoH dOIAI 'ssnoH ||!|/\| oiseg ipuuv •jg-x3 'ueBueMSQ jei|piua|-| (QO) Bjna 'jeBeN leiiqg 'jopss !|esiy 'v/gz 'ieiojaiuLuoo 'jaoij^O uo!ioeg-x9 '>]!UB|/\] •Q'>] (30) Bjna ' |.-PJB/V\ 'ejedeAeN 'ssajd oiseg 'Olj-x^ 'n^BS -ieujn»AefiA •1-9 •09 •6S •8S •2.S -99 •S9 'frS •£9 •Z9 •1.9 •os •6fr ss '''.' H -. U; o '^:'' © 6 '••^es-^- 62. Girdharlal Thakur, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Shop 2 Mill House, Village Gorkapar, P.0, Gabdi, Durg (CG) 63. Beersingh, Ex- Rigger MM, Jalebi Chowk, Pragati Nagar, Camp-1, Bhilai, Durg (CG) 64. Toranlal sahu, Ex-SSG Security, Village & Post Nahda, Thana - Deori, Durg (CG) 65. Deolal sahu, Ex-Sr. Attnd, Silica Press, Village - Kataro, P.0., Khopali, Durg (CG) 66. Kamluram Gond, Ex-Sr. Attnd F/.C Mill, Village - Newaibhata, P.0. Purai, Durg (CG) 67. Nand Kumar Chandrakar, Ex- Operator Fuel, Village & Post Chandkhuri, Durg (CG) 68. Chaitram Kumbhkar, Ex- Operator, Basic Mill, Nayapara, Durg,Ward-1, Durg (CG) 69. K.L. Satnami, Ex-Sr. Attnd., Village-Bagheli, P.0. Bhardakala, Durg (CG) 70. Amardas Tandon, Ex-Sr. Attnd F/C Mill, HSCL Colony, Maroda, P.0. Newai,Durg (CG) 71. Romnath Netam, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Village -Dhaurabhata, P.0. Fekari, Durg (CG) 72. Jhagruram Sahu, Ex-Sr. Attnd Press, Village - Khumria, P.0. Purai, Durg (CG) 73. Jhumuklal Yadav, Ex-Sr. Attnd. F/c Mill House, Village & Post - Kurad, Tahsil - Jamul, Durg (CG) 74. S.L. Governa, Ex-Operator, F/C Press, Village - Pacheda, P.0. Ghutia, Durg (CG) 75. Sudhuram Patel, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Silica Press, Village - Pancheda, P.0 Ghutia, Durg (CG) rII 1»*^ ^'; •<.?/ ^ / .'>. '{ v s ^' 76. Motiram Gond, Sr. Attnd. Basic, Krishna Nagar, Balram Chowk, Supela, Bhilai, Durg (CG) 77. Dhanuwaram Joshi, Ex-Operator Basic Mill House, Village - Kapsi, P.0. Jhit, Durg (CG) 78. Khedanlal vema, Ex- Sr. Attnd. Basic Village, Shankarnagar, Chhaoni, P.0. Housing Board, Durg (CG) 79. Mahadeo Sahu, Ex-Press Operator F/C, Press, Village - Post Chandkhuri, Durg (CG) 80. Dauwa Singh Koshta, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Silica, Village Rawelidih.P.O. Nankutti, Durg 81. Sheetal Ram Gond, Ex-Sr. Attnd PGP, Village & Post- Nankutti, Durg (CG) 82. Narendra Kumar Dhruv, Ex- Recorder, Quarter No. 249, Panchsheel Nagar, BMY Charoda, Durg (CG) 83. Ghasiram Gond, Ex- Sr. Attnd., HSCL Colony, Maroda, P.0. Newai, Durg (CG) 84. Santram, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Electrical Maintenance, Village - Titurdih, P.0. & Thana - Mohan Nagar, Durg (CG) 85. Gurusharan Singh, Ex-press Operator, Silica, Quarter No. 341, Ward-15, Charoda, Durg (CG) 86. Brijlal Yadav, Ex-Checker, Basic, Ward-34, Auribhata, Rajnandgaon (CG) 87. Bisheshwar Prasad Banjare, Ex- Press Operator, Village Kareili, P.0. Nawagaon, Durg (CG) 88. Kanhaiyalal Yadav, Ex-Pres Operator, Silica, Village kasidih(Utai), Durg (CG) 89. Chain Singh Sonwani, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Basic Mill, Panchsheel Nagar, Durg (CG) 90. Bhagwatram Sahu, Ex- Electrician, Village & Post - Nandini Khundini, Durg (CG) 91. Budhram Borkar, Ex-Sr. Attnd. F &A, Santosh Marg, G.E. Road, Kosanagar, P.0 Nehru Nagar, Bhilai Durg (CG) 92. Deodhar Sahu, Ex-Sr. Typist, P&A, Near Dr. Sudhakar Hospital, Kosanagar, P.0. Nehrunagar, Durg (CG) 93. Janakram Gond, Ex-Sr. Attnd F/C press, Village & Post Borai, Durg 94. Goverdhanlal Soni, Ex-Sr. Attnd. EM, Nayapara, Ward-1, Durg 95. Mannulal Gond, Ex-Operator, F/C Mill Hbuse, Village & Post Borai, Durg (CG) 96. D.R. Kewat, Ex-Sr. Attnd. F/C press, Village Bagdumar, P.0. Nandini Mines Township, Durg 97. Budhram Sahu, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Fuel Handling, Village & Post Panada, Thana Kumhari, Durg 98. Tulairam Kurre, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Basic checking, Village - Tiloda, P.0. Tamora, Durg (CG) 99, Gunitram Dhruv, Ex-MTO MRS, Village - Gadadih, P.0. Kanakot, Tehsil - Patan, Durg (CG) 100. Kejuram Sahu, Ex-Sr. Attnd. F/C Mill House, Village - Au.ndhi, Bhilai-3, Tehsil - Patan -Durg 101. Supetram Lohar, Ex-Sr, Attnd. Basic checking, Village & Post Khopli, Utai, Durg (CG) 15 v'\ ^\ ^ -v^ r ^^ -<.^ 102. Mannulal Sahu, Ex-Press Operator, Silica Press, Village & Post Nandini Khundini, Durg (CG) 103. Tetkuram Sahu, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Silica, Village - Karsa, Post - Aundhi, Durg (CG) 104. Thakurram Sahu, Ex-Operator (civil) Village & Post Nandini- Khundini, Durg (CG) 105. Tejram Sahu, Ex-Sr. Attnd. F/C Mill House, Village & Post- Kodia, Durg (CG) 106., Punaram Nirmalkar, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Basic Mill House, Village - Banbarad, P.0. Ahiwara, Durg (CG) 107. Abhayram Ahir, Ex-Sr. Attnd Basic Mixing, Luchkipara, Durg (CG) 108. Hemlal Sahu, Ex-Press Operator, Basic Press, 12/L, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 109. Arjunlal Sahu, Ex-Press Operator, Basic Press, Village - Khagri, P.0. Biroda, Dhangaon, Durg (CG) 110. Bhikhan Gond, Ex-Sr. Attnd., Village -Achhoti, P.0, Gorhi, Tehsil - Dhamdha, Durg (CG) 111. Baraturam Sahu, Ex-Sr. Attnd. Adarsh Nagar, Camp -1, Bhilai Durg (CG) 112. Dauaram Thakur, Ex-Sr. attnd (Store,), Saraswati Nagar, ward- 31, Durg(CG) 113. Pardeshi ram Gond, Ex- Electrician, Brindanagar, Camp- 1, Bhilai, P.0. Supela, Distt. Durg (CG) 114. Bhuvneshwar Ram Dhruv, Ex- Setter, Basic TK, Village - Chhaoni, Yadav Mohalla P.0 MP Housing Board, Durg (CG) ul^ 115. Dular Singh Marai, Ex- CompressorAttnd. MM, 188/E, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar (CG) 116. Rampreet, Ex-Rigger Quarter No. L Block-3, Sector-5, Street-2, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 117. Suresh Kumar Shukla, Ex- Recorder ,TO, Bramhinpara, Durg, Panchmukhi Hanuman Ke Pass, Durg (CG) 118. Bhaskar Rao Meshram, Ex- Pattern Maker, MRS, BRP Colony, Maroda, P.0. Newai, Durg (CG) 119. Govindram Namdeo, Ex-SSG Security, Gaya Nagar, Ward-4, Durg (New Colony) Durg (CG) 120. Santram Yadav, Ex-Press Operator basic Press, Village - Nawagaon, P.0. Bava Mohtara, Distt. (CG) 121. Sundarlal Sahu, Utai, Bajrang Nagar, P.0. Utai, Durg (CG) 122. Santram Nishad, Village Patharia, P.0. Nawagaon, Purda, Durg (CG) 123. S.C. Pathak, 13/1, Risalj Sector, Bhilai Durg (CG) 124. L.R. Nishad, F-24/A, Maroda Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 125. Kailash Chandra Sahu, 25-B, Risali Sector, Bhilai, Durg (CG) 126. Gokaran Sahu, 28 C, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 127. Preet ram Verma, Village & Post Utai, Durg (CG) 128. B.C. Modi, 25 G, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 129. Sukhiram Yadav, Village & Post - Newai, Durg (CG) (6'%*.. A y^^ 130. Jageshwar Singh, Naya Amapara, P.0. Mohannagar, Durg (CG) 131. Khemsingh sahu, 192 B, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 132. T.R, Kosariya, 32/A, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 133. B.F.Toppo,25 H, Risali Sector Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 134. Narayanlal Sahu, Village- ChhaoniWard 17, Industrial Area, Durg (CG) 135. Bharatsingh Sahu, Village Borigarka, Village & Post Pouwarra, Durg (CG) 136. Yashwant Kumar Janghel, 25 F, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg 137. Mansingh Sahu, Village & Post Utai, Durg (CG) 138. Jogendar Singh, 30 B, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 139. Gajanand Paragniha, 117/F, Risali sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg 140 Puhukram Nishad, HSCL Colony, Maroda P.0. Newai, Durg (CG) 141. Agrahijram Netam, 164/G, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 142 Parasram Jangde, Mini Mata Nagar, Zone-3, Khursipar, Bhilai, Durg (CG) 143. Digvijay Das Vaishnav, Village & Post-Newai, Durg (CG) 144. B.R. Gond, Village & Post -Utai, Durg Khadanpara, Durg (CG) 145. K. Parmeshwaran Nair, 23/L, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg 146. Dularelal Thakur, Dabra Para, Bhilai, Durg (CG) -"• "^ •^-r^ 'f ':, '~^ ^ (^.i.?/ '' 147. Nemihand Sagar, 32 D, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 148. Manbodh Kumar Das, 30 L, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 149. Kashiram Bagh, 11 B, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 150. Deosharan Prasad, Street-4, Sector-6, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 151. Premlal Sahu, Station Maroda, P.0. Newai,Durg (CG) 152. Abhimanyu Maharana, 33 I, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg 153, IsidorTigga, Street-4, Quarter 1G, Sector-6, Bhilai Nagar, Durg 154. Thakurram Thakur, 190-H, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 155. Chhannulal Thakur, Street-4, Block-40, Sector-6, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 156. Ramlal Sahu, 26K, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 157. Ratan Kumar Kshetrapal street-4, Block-4C, Sector-6, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 158. Satanand Sahu, Village & Post- Hathkhoj para, Utai, Durg (CG) 159. Bharatlal Joshi, 137 F, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 160. Ghanshyam Gajbhiye, Village & Post Dundera, Utai Durg (CG) 161. Raghunath ChandrakarVillage & Post-Newai, Durg (CG) 162. Khilawan Singh sahu, Ganga Maiya Fruit Merchant, Bus Stand, Balod, Durg (CG) 163. Guru Das Manikpuri, 32 F, Risali Sector, BhilaiNagar, Durg (CG) 164. Bhuvanlal Pal, 25 E, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 165. Itwari Ram Sahu, Village & Post Newai, Durg (CG) 166. Bhagwat Ram Gond, Village & Post-Newai, Kundrapara, Durg 167. Maruti Rao Uike, Street-4, Block- 7 D, Sector-6, Bhilai Nagar, Durg 168. Ramsanehi, Street-4, Block 2-A, Sector-6, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 169. Ramprasad Sahu, Risali bhata, Bhilai, Durg (CG) 170. BharatSingh Isda, Mauhari, Maroda, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) 171. Smt. Anna Maria, 32 G, Risali Sector, Bhilai Nagar, Durg (CG) WRIT PET1TION UNDERART1CLE 226/2270FTHE CONSTITUTION OF IND1A -Jtl« .3 a sn^TW ^iwsn^r —itliqiylgfl iarve ?& •^ 3^ •^ll'illCt'i), t9Tf1«'16, Rldltiy yildl Shliqi 3<i<tyi ^iacb ^..^^....^..^- ^ ^iS. sfi^i ^kfiwflfer diSj^osed Mr. Ranbir Singh Marhas, Mr. T.K. Twari, counsel for Heard boththe counsel. So rar compliance of this been made by the petitioner and| deiay. in the csrcumstances, learrff that this petition ilseif may be diSj^o authority to decide the appeai fi!ed| No other reiief is claimed. !n view of the submjssi( petitioner, this petition is disposep authority should decide the eariiest in order to resoive fhe disi !n view of this order, 091/2006 aiso stand disposed of| c|>unse! for the petitioner. l'espondentNo.158. Court's order dated 10.5.2006 has not leven Process Fee has been fited with cln •=bWlTf'!fl-) t<l*l<riTfffai<;l <KlV,\< ^srf^trsn^T sd counsel for the petitionef submitted of with a directjon to the appeliate by the petitioner at the earliest. made by iearned counse! for the of with a direction that the appeliate fi!ed by the petitioner herein at the ute between the parties.' i.A. Nos.5544/2006, 6331/2006 and (jute ji-A-o L.C. Bhacloo .iudge C^^A)