Rama sh Knm t n of sr Gasi Ram Lahar ‘ en tate of chhattisgar ~ ¥ Thraug secreary - . Daparre: o Revenu ‘Mantzaa. ..s.3hawa v. ‘- ' h ' @elleeo T tr. s h h t, tmm f e. al‘y 33xm ' ' Raipur a rh whtti sga. a tisgarh. a aham, hi h e v S f g \ iiJnGH COURT 9f gupLCATURE gHHATTISGARH: BILASPUR DIVISION BE;NCH . ‘ CORAM & : HON’BLE HON’BLE’SHRI SHR! D.R S.R. ¢ESHMUKH, NAYAK, CJ J. I 1 I I A‘ WRIT PETITIoN No. é21z or: 2004 I Manoj Chandrakar, aged about 38 years,. IS/o. Shri Bhukhan Hal Chandra‘kar, Patwari, PC. No. 15 R/o Panchwa;ti Colony. Qtr. No. C-4, Ratanabandha, Dhamtari. Tahsil & Distt. Dhjamtari (C‘G.) . VE RS US PETITIONER ESPONDENTS 1. The Stat; of Chhattisgarh Through $ecretaw Department of Revenue, ‘Mantralaja, D.K.S. Bhawan Réipur (Cj.G.) The Collector i Dlsm‘ct Dllamtari ((3.6) 3. Sub-Divisional Officer (Revenue) District Dhamtarl‘ (C.G.) I Ramesh Kumar Lahare, Aged about 35§ years, S/b. Shri Ghasi Ram Lahare,I Patwari, Posted at P.C. No. 15/49,I ‘Hatkeshari Tah. & District Dhamtarii (CG) i i Vishnu Kamar Gupta. Aged about 43" i years. S/Io Shri Udayram Gupta, PatWari atiPresent transfer to P.C. No. 50-A/16. Tahsil Dhamtari R/o Posti Ofnce Ward, Ama Taiab Road,‘ Dhamtari (CG) 6. Ramesh Tiwari, Aged about 40 years, ‘ S/o. Shri: Govind Prasad Tiwari, I Patwari, Posted at)P.C. No. 10,i Bhakhara, Tah’sil Kurud, Distt. Dhamtari (CG), ‘1 Sukhdeo Dhruw, S/o Shri BR. Dhruw, Kharenga, ‘Tahsi! & Distt. Dhamtari (C.G.) 2 8. Chinta Ramj,50ni, S/o. Late Mansha RamSonigPatwari, Posted at P.C. No. 16, Tahsii Kurud. Distt‘ Dhamtari (CG) Patwari, Posted at P.C. No. 28, i I i I R ‘ . ounsel for the petitioner. Mr. ‘V.V.S. MUrthy, lear‘ned Dy. G.A. State/respondents No; 1 to 3. ma, Iearned cqunsel I for the respondent , No. Mr. Ashok Swamakar, learned: c for the l l for the respondent; ,Mr. Vimlesh Bajpai, learned counse No.4. Mr. Sumit Ver 5. PETmON No. 2211 'oF 2004 Vasudeo iBhoi, aged about 35 years, ETITIONER Slot Shri 'Bastam Bhoi R/o Vivekananc‘ Nagar, Street No.3, Dhamtari, Tahsil and Distript Dhamtari (C.G.) VERSUS 1. The Staté of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary Departm‘ent of Revenue, MantralaS/a, D.K.S. Bhawan \Baipur (6.6.) 2. The Coll‘ector District Dhamtari (CG .) Sub—Divisionai (Revenge) District Officer Dhamtari (C.G.) Vishnu .Kumar Gupta. Aged about 43 years, §Slo Shri Udayram Gupta, Patwari§at 50-N1§, Tahsii Present Dhamtari transfer to R/o P.C. Post No. 52 Office Ward. Ama Taiab Road, Dhamtari (C.G.) 1 . Ramesh Tiwari, Aged about 40 years, -S/o. Shri Govind Prasad Tiwari, Patwari, Posted. at P.C. No. 10, Bhakhara, Tahsil Kurud, Distt. Dhamtari (C.G.) i ‘ 6. Ramesh Kurnar Lahare, Aged abouti35 years,iS/o. Patwari, Posted Shri Ghasi at P.C. Ram No. Lahare, 15/‘49, HatkeShar. Tah. & District Dhamtari (C.G.): Sukhdeo Dhruw, )7 Slo Shri BR. Dhruw, Patwati. Posted at P.C. No. 28, Kharenga. Tahsil & Distt. Dhamtari 8. (C.G‘)‘ Chinta Ram Soni. S/o. Late Mansha Ram 16.,Tahsii Soni, Kurud. Patwari, Distt. Posted Dhamtari at P.C.‘No. (C.G.) , ' i i w M MMMMWMWDAW‘H . —! y. P Mr Ashok Swarnakar learned counsel forthe petitioner ‘ Mr VVS Murthy, learined Dy GA for the‘ State/respondents No 1 to 3 Mr Vlmlesh Bajpal learned counsel for the respondent No5 Mr Sumrt Verma learned counsel for the respondent No -..-----....--..---------__--_--_--..-------_---___--_-.-...._-_L...................................... a WRII PETITION NO 3342 OF 2003 PgTITIONER Mano; Chandrakar JV-, RMESPONDENTS Aged about 37 years S/o Shn Bhukhan lal Chandrakar R/o Panchwatr colony, Qtr No C 4 Ratna Bandha Dhamtanl Tahsrl and Dlstt Dhamtan (C G) \Lggsus, l 1.. The State‘of Chhattlsgarh Through Its Secretary, Revenue Department DKS Bhawan Rarpur (c ‘G ) 2. ‘Under Secretary, Revenue Department, DKS Bhawan, Raipur (C.G.) The Collector, Dhamtari l Sub-Divisional Oft‘rcer, DhamtarifTah. And Distt. Dhamtari i 5L Ramesh Kumar Lahre, ‘ A'ged about 38 years, Slo Shri Ghasl ram’ Lahre, Patwari, . ‘ Transfer at Tahsil Nagri, Distt l Dhamtari (co) Present: Mr. Ashok Swarnakar, learned counsel for the petitioner. Mr. V.V.S. Murthy, learned Dy. G.A. for the State/respondents No. 1 to 4.1 L V l wan PETmON N0.37‘7__ OF 2004 PER ETITION Ramesh Kumar Lahare, ‘Son of Shjri Ghasi Ram .Lahare. Patwari, Posted at P.C.VNo. 15, Hatkeshar, Dhamtari, Chhattisgarh. VERSUS State of Chhattlsgarh j ._.__. ‘ . Through Department Secretary. of Revenue Mantralaya D K S Bhawan alr ttlh Rpu Chhasgar The Collecto stt Dhaa r Dlnc mtn Chhatsgarh None Mr. appeared V Murht for the peone iearn D A.G. for the State/respondent ---------------------------- ent Prse. V s I I --- ‘ ‘ e . ’ (PassedW on 30 Januar 2006) ed by The folwin oral order of the ourt was pass log Q S R NK ‘ AYA CJ t , Tese w peons ase uf two tem ord ers passed by the (for short the “AT") dated 1 11 001 and State Adtrae Tbunal ln . No 1080 of 20 h order datd 1 001cancelg the earlier transfer order dated 26 06 2001 rs assented I e SAT hang h yi h nt tm n oto Inri S 2 2 le of SAT Rpur Bench -08-2002 N 1080 of 2001 on t fl _ OA 01 te e 16 O 2lm regard to the factuat controversres raised before It by Its order dated 12 11-2001 drrected that status quo that should be maintaine ad Interim order was subsequently m drsposat of O obtained as on 24—10 2001 d till disposal of O A No 1080 of 2001 and the sald ade absotute and continued till A No 1080 of 200 by order dated 09 08 2 n the facts and circumstances of the ‘ l Interim orders made by the SAT r CaSe. Garth controversies between the p assumption of office at the transferredvy‘place etc 002 The two ot be faulted wuth particularly, In vrew of the factual artles wuth regard to the relieve order and ln that View of the matter, we dismiss all the writ petitions. iThe original record of O.A. Nikos tu‘ VS y tmr ed y " h y ministiv ri al 09 m O A o he t f080 of 2001 is received by this Cmmi. Therefore. the Registry? is directed to number O.A. No. 1080 of 20Q1 as writ petition(s) and list it for inal hearing in the second week of Maréh 2006, No cost3. i Dili Raosaheb Deshmukh Judge / / — d/— i ‘\ - Chief Justice 1 f S6! S " p /