m THE HIGH cemm OF man. nmwsa Am “mm. winning. Appeal Ne. £41990 ,Negiram son of J‘alandhar, resident of Sambalpm', J niswict Poliee Etation Bastam Konaag ($.33 on; aged aboat 40 yeaa, (Agicultariat, wpellant z~ u‘ -Vera ueé Responaent :- TheV‘atate of lhdhya h'aaesh: ~L’r APP—w Ema %cm;9u14(2? 9x mm or mm»: momm’ convmtion Senteme under sect—1m 456 Lac: RJ. fer a’years and fine of Rad 500/- m',’ , inaefault 4 manths RJ‘.‘ .x Q X1—HC-22 $6 m3 ZOQé Appellan‘r Negimm by Smf Sawfa Tiwari, Advoca‘i'e“ 5hr: Asimsh $nuk!a, Ga’vf. Advaqa‘l‘e for The Sfafe. Learned caunsei for 1‘he appe” Inf submfffed cf fhe very oufsef ’rhaf he wwld m? assali The conwcfian m‘ The appeliunf‘ under 3ge¢mrv436 of IPC bu? waulé argue ar iy on i‘he ques‘i‘ion of senfence, In viaw of Thz submission made by iearned counsel for ‘rhe appa‘ilgn‘f, fhis appeai is heard anly on €he qaesfion of senfenCe. The appeUam was acmvic‘ted wider 5ecfian-436 of IPC and was .se'o‘re'nwd i’o uadergo rigorow imprisc nmem' for 3 yearsondfo a fine of §S.5OG/— and m defszuif of paymevf of firm To undergo addi‘rional vigomus imprisanmem for 4 mam‘hs by fhe iem‘ned Is? Addi‘rional Sasmns Judga, Jagdaipur in Sessi-pw Tricsl Number-153/1988 Vida juaigmm‘? damd 23—03 1990 in The infervening nigh? of 19m & awe”? fums of. fho :ase are fh f y ¢ XI—HC—22 mm WW&${ mm vmmmw wwmfiwm %a‘a11i—dtreprr&¥r 20-O4-199Q. She ha$ alse drawn The affemion of fhis Courifo Sl‘a‘lemen‘f made by Sukhlal PW-l Thar he'did nof suffer any damage due fa fire se‘r by lhe appellam‘ fo his hut Las‘lly, i? was con?ended fhaf frhe appeHam m5 paid ‘ihe amoum’ 61" fine. On *hzse grcunds, if was prayed ‘}“%m? f’r‘kewsukssfcmi‘iva senfe'nce 0%: impni'sanmenf awarded by fhe learned ’?1§§& Judgabe reducéd f0 é‘na serrwrce niready undér‘gene by fhe ‘appeiian‘i‘. Cm fha 0"?‘ner hand, Shri Ashim 3hukla, lear‘ned Govt Advocuf ‘ V i’xas oppa£eé We .pmver Though format Havmg heard rival canfenfiwg I have perused 'rhe record The appeikm? was: canvic?ed m %ha d Knerecwer undergane eemence frori 23-03 1990 ’ro 20—04 1990 The, year 1990. The period of aimos? peHanf has already SLU‘fered a lo? of ignommy The camplamam 5ukhlal as admrH‘ecl m hls Tes‘hmony Thal‘ ae dxd m? mffer any loss due To fire e1' by fhe appeilar‘i‘ To his houSe ,eans!dermg The facts and Circumsfances mermoned above ' mereyr ef Jusw’wce wouid be serve appaiem he; pur-éumg fws appeal $m ‘ w years na< lapsm during wnich The I ear 1990 He has undergone mmrcaranrn rrom 22 12 1957 f 05—01 1988 during ‘mal an n’ fhe subs‘ran'hve semence o‘r smprxsonmen‘r awarded by The learn d frlal Judge I§ reduced To The eeirenee already undergone by The ap ellan? In he resull‘ ”ms Crlmma Appeal l$ parfly allowed The cam/{chem of The appellam‘ under eehon—436 of IPC Is mam‘i‘amed r:~“-~ g XI-HC—22 mmma%*d mml§mlmm $m“. 3m i LI wowavev, “mg senfence awardeal by Tha karned ‘‘ur‘iai Jadge is modified am’ is‘reduced ‘Fo senwnce already undergone by i’he appeilam‘. Figg/// *x / f fniwm‘dec! by 'rhe laumed ’rrm! Judge is rxaimained; J// // gd" / Dma aosamb ”me