IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.15293 of 2010 1. ATRI NANDAN ATREY S/O SRI RAI JAMUNA PRASAD ATREY R/O VILL POHIYA, P.O.BAISHMARA, DISTT-SARAN 2. RAJENDRA PRASAD S/O LATE BUDHAN PRASAD R/O VILL BASATPUR, P.O.SOBHEPUR, P.S.BHELDI, DISTT-SARAN 3. ANIL KUMAR S/O SRI RAJENDRA NATH BHAKTA R/O VILL RASULPUR, P.O.RASULPUR, P.S.AMNAUR, DISTT-SARAN 4. RAJ KISHWAR PRASAD S/O LATE RUGAN PRASAD R/O VILL NEHRU CHOWK, P.S.CHAPRA TOWN, DISTT-SARAN 5. BINOD KUMAR SINGH S/O LATE RAJ BALI SINGH R/O VILL BANGRA, P.S.MASHRAKH, DISTT-SARAN 6. ANITA KUMARI D/O LATE RAM LAGAN RAI R/O VILL GOPALPUR, P.O.MASTI CHAK, P.S.DARIYAPUR, DISTT-SARAN 7. DHRUV KUMAR DAS S/O LATE RAM PRASAD DAS R/O VILL LAKHNA, P.O.APHAR, P.S. AMNAUR, DISTT-SARAN 8. LAL BABU RAY S/O LATE MITHU RAY R/O VILL RAMPUR BATHANI, P.O.RAMPUR, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 9. BIDHAN RAY S/O LATE SHEO PRASAD RAY R/O VILL LAKHANA, P.O.DHARHARA, P.S. AMNAUR, DISTT-SARAN 10. SURMILA KUMARI W/O SHRI DINESHWAR PRASAD SINGH R/O VILL DAKHHIN KADNA, P.O.MAHMADPUR, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 11. JAIPAL PRASAD S/O LATE BANARSI RAY R/O VILL LAKHANA, P.O.DHARHARA, P.S. AMNAUR, DISTT-SARAN 12. DHARMVEER RAY S/O SRI POLICE RAY R/O VILL LAKHANA, P.O.DHARHARA, P.S. AMNAUR, DISTT-SARAN 13. VINOD KUMAR SINGH S/O SRI JAGDISH SINGH R/O VILL SARAGATTI, P.O.GARKHA, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 14. JAI NARAYAN PRASAD RAY S/O SRI RAM CHANDRA RAY R/O VILL PATHRA, P.O.RASIDPUR, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 15. GOVIND SHARAN MISHRA S/O LATE PANCHAM MISHRA R/O VILL UMARPUR, P.O.PAIGA, P.S.BHELDI, DISTT-SARAN 16. MAHESHWAR PRASAD RAY S/O SRI TEKAN RAY R/O VILL RUSTAMPUR, P.O.RAMPUR, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 17. RAJENDRA RAM S/O LATE RAM SAGAR RAM R/O VILL RAGHUPUR, P.O.MAHMADPUR, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 18. SATYENDRA RAY S/O SRI BAHADUR RAY R/O VILL JHARUTOLA RAMPUR, P.O.RAMPUR, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 19. SANJAY KUMAR S/O SRI VOKIL RAY R/O VILL RUSHTAMPUR, P.O.RAMPUR, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 20. RAM LAKHAN SAH S/O LATE NAGINA SAH R/O VILL RAGHUPUR, P.O.MAHMADPUR, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 21. SURENDRA MANJHI S/O SRI SHATRUGHAN MANJHI R/O VILL KUDARBADHA, P.O.KUDARBADHA, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 22. SHAMBHU RAY S/O LATE AGINDEO RAY R/O VILL ALONI, P.O.GARKHA, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 23. SATYENDRA KUMAR S/O LATE TIPAN RAI R/O VILL ALONI, P.O.GARKHA, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 24. UMESH KUMAR YADAV S/O SRI BRIJ LAL RAY R/O VILL ALONI, P.O.GARKHA, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 25. RAJESH KUMAR S/O SRI VOKIL RAI R/O VILL RUSHTAMPUR, P.O.RAMPUR, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 2 26. BHISHM PRASAD S/O DHARMNATH RAY R/O VILL RUSTAMPUR, P.O.RAMPUR, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 27. POLICE RAI S/O LATE BASKIT RAY R/O VILL KHAKIBABA KA TOLA RAMPUR, P.O.MAHAMADPUR, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 28. KRISHNA PRASAD S/O LATE DHRAMNATH PRASAD R/O VILL PATHRA, P.O.RASIDPUR, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 29. SHATRUDHAN PRASAD S/O SRI RAM CHANDRA SAH R/O VILL ALONI, P.O.GARKHA, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 30. NAGESWAR MISHRA S/O JANARDAN MISHRA R/O VILL LAKHANA, P.O.DHARHARA, P.S. AMNAUR, DISTT-SARAN 31. ASHOK KUMAR S/O SRI RAJENDRA NATH BHAKTA R/O VILL RASULPUR, P.O.RASULPUR, P.S.AMNOUR, DISTT-SARAN 32. NEELAM KUMARI D/O SHRI BHEGELU SINGH R/O VILL BASDIH, P.O.MADARPUR, P.S.VELDI, DISTT-SARAN 33. RENU KUMARI W/O SHRI SHYAM BABU SINGH R/O VILL ISHMAILPUR, GADHWAR TOLA, P.O. RAMPUR, P.S. GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN 34. MAHAMAYA PRASAD SINGH S/O SHRI SHIV KUMAR SINGH R/O VILL ISMAILPUR, P.O.RAMPUR, P.S.GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH THE SECRETARY, HIGHER EDUCATION , DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA 2. PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA 3. JAI PRAKASH UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS CHANCELLOR DAK BUNGLOW ROAD, CHAPRA 4. VICE CHANCELLOR , JAI PRAKASH UNIVERSITY DAK BUNGLOW ROAD, CHAPRA 5. THE REGISTRAR, JAI PRAKASH UNIVERSITY DAK BUNGLOW ROAD, CHAPRA 6. THE SECRETARY, ADHOC COMMITTEE(GOVERNING BODY) OF DEVRAHA BABA SRIDHAR DAS DEGREE MAHAVIDYALAYA RAMPUR(KADNA), GARKHA, SARAN 7. SRI ARJUN PRASAD YADAV S/O LATE HIRA LAL RAI R/O VILL MOHARAMPUR GARKHA, DISTT-SARAN AND PRESENTLY WORKING AT DEVRAHA BABA SRIDHAR DAS DEGREE MAHAVIDYALAYA , RAMPUR(KADNA), GARKHA, SARAN ------------------------ 2. 28.04.2011 Whatever be the submission or innovation with regard to the status of the petitioners and the claim thereto of being recognized as Principal or Teachers of the college in question, an admitted position is that it is an affiliated college and like most of the affiliated colleges there is a lot of dispute between the Managing Committee and the teachers as to who are bona fide and who are not, ever 3 since state started releasing funds. This case is no different. On one occasion the High Court referred the matter for enquiry by the Vice Chancellor. The Vice Chancellor has given his findings in Annexure 21, which is part of the record. Counsel challenges the findings on many a grounds. From the submissions it is evident that there are many disputed facts and there are many issues which cannot be decided in favour of the petitioners on a limited kind of presentation of documents by them. It is a matter where I feel a detailed adjudication is required to be made after going into all the facts and records, by a civil jurisdiction of competent jurisdiction, where all the parties will get their chance to either prove their case or demolish the assertion as the case may be. The writ is not the answer for such disputes. Writ is dismissed with liberty to the petitioners to move a civil court of competent jurisdiction. Nitesh ( Ajay Kumar Tripathi, J.)