K407m; Z‘ 1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR Writ Appeal No. 3/ § 0f 2008 / [Writ Appeal u/Sec. 2(1) of the Chhattisgarh High Court (Appeal to Division Bench) Act, 2006,. arisingp‘om Order dated 4.8.2008 passed by % "(VO§ Hon ’ble Shri SKAgnihotri J., in W.P. N0. 6092 of2006 &W63 [2096f Appellants / Petitioners: Shri Pooran Singh Patel, S/o K. L. Patel, aged about 47 yeai‘s, Fisheries Inspectror, 0/0 Joint Director, Fisheries, District, Raipur R/o S. M. '2 Shiva Mandir Lane, Awantivihar, Raipur; Shri V. P. Goswami, S/o Shri Balram Puri Goswami, aged about 51 years, Fisheries Inspectror, O/o Joint Director. Fisheries, District, Raipur; Shri G. K. Upadhyaya, S/o Shri Gopal Krishna Upadhyaya, aged about 49 years, Fisheries Inspectror, O/o Director Fisheries, C.G., Raipur. R/o 43/912 Behind Shyamnagar School, Shyamnagar, Raipur; Shri "Ram Gopal Bohre, S/o Shri Jagdish Prasad Bohre, aged about 48 years, Fisheries Inspectror, O/o Joint Director, Fisheries, .District, Raipur. R/o 882 Near Pahadi Talab, Raksha Awasthi / Manoj umar Sinha ‘ Counsel for the Appellants Lw . Sundar Nagar, Pragati Chbwk, Réripur; Shri K. L. Jaiswal, S/o Shri Sahasram Jaiswal, aged about 48 years, Professors colony, Behind Purani Basti Raipur; Shri Virendra Sing Jadon, S/o Shri Ramsingh Jadon, aged‘ about 51 years, 0/0 Deputy Director, Fisheries, Bilaspur'. R70 Flat No. 702', .Green Garden Colony Opposite Minoch Colony, Bilaspur; Shri Uirati Pawan, S/o Shri Kanchan, aged about 49 years, O/o Joint Director, Fisheries, District, Raipur. R/o S.M. 2‘ C/o F. S. Patel, Shiva Mandir Lane, Awantivihar, Raipur; Versus The State of Chhattisgarh, through' the Secretary, Agriculture (Fisheries) Department, Secretariat DKS Bhawan, Raipur (CG); 2. The Director of Fisheries Chhattisgarh, Raipur (CG) _ Shri K. K. Moitra, S/o Late B. P. Moitra aged .about 5'8 year, A.F.o./ F.E.o. C/o Dy. Director of Fisheries/CEO. FFDA Distt Bilaspur; i 4. Shri Rajendra Kumar Banjare, S/o M. P. Banjare, aged about _47 year, A.F.O./ F.E.O. RakshaXwasthi / Manoj Kumar Sinha Counsel for the Appellants Respondents / 1. (/1; C/o Dy. Director of Fisheries/CEO. FFDA Distt Durg (CG); Shri Umeshwar Singh, S/o Shri Shyam Bahadur Singh, aged about 51 year, A.F.O./ F.E.O. C/o Assistant Fisheries/CEO. FFDA Distt Bekunthpur (Koriya) (CG); Shri Rajesh Kumar Panigrahi, S/o Shri S. N. Panigrahi, aged about 46 year, A.F.Or/ F.E.O. C/o Dy. Director of Fisheries/CEO. FFDA Distt Jagadalpur (CG); Shri O. P. Mehra, S/o Shri Khurnan Singh, aged about 48 year, Fisheries Inspector C/o Directore of Fisheries Chhattisgarh Raipur; Shri Mohan Lal Chandrakar, S/o Late Sharda Prasad, aged about 50 year, A.F.O./F.E.O. C/o C.E.O. FFDA Raipur (CG); .Shri Sukhranjan Mukharji, S/o Late G.S. Mukherj'i, aged about 49 year, A.F.O./F.E.O. C/o Dy. Director of Fisheries/CEO. FFDA Distt Jagadalpur (CG); Shri Yavan Kumar Dindore, S/o Shri B. C. Dindore, aged about 47 year, A.F.O.m.E.O. C/o Dy. Director of Fisheries/CEO. FFDA Director V of aw “km” . 4?” aksha Awasthi / Manoj Kumar Sinha - Counsel for the Appellants R mm; we :1"! ‘ @ Distt' Durg (CG); 11. Shri Yenedra Kumar Dilliwar, S/o Shri Hsman Lal, aged about 46 year, A.F.O./F.E.O. C/o Dy. Director of Fisheries/CEO. FFDA Distt Durg (CG); 12. Shri H. G. Mehara, S/o Shri K. L. Mehara, aged about 48 year, Fisheries luspector C/o Joint Directore of Fisheries Distt. Raipur;. /13. Shri S. K. Divedi, S/o Shri S. M. Divedi, aged about 49 year, A.F.O./F.E.O. C/o C.E.O. FFDA Distt Ambikapur (CG); Shri Ramanand Koushik, S/o Shri Babulai Koushik, aged about 49 year, A.F.O./F.E.O. C/o Dy. Director of Fisheries/CEO. FFDA -Distt Bilaspur (CG); 15. Shri Ajay Kumar Gupta, S/o Shri Anandi Lal Gupta, aged about 42 year, A.F.O./F.E.O. C/o Joint Director of Fisheries/CEO. FFDA Distt Raipur (CG); 16. - S‘hri Pawan‘Kumar Dubey, S/o Shri Dev Narayan, aged about 50 year, A.F.O./F.E.O. .C/o Joint Director of Fisheries/CEO. FFDA Distt Raipur (CG); 17. shri R. s. Sahu, S/o Shri- Ramlal sahu, aged a day Raksha Awasthi / 'Manoj Kumar Sinha Counsel for the Appellants x about 45 year, A.F.O./F.E.O. C/o Joint Directar of Fisheries/CEO. FFDA Distt Raipur (CG); Shri A. K. Chandraker, S/o Shri Asan Lal, aged about 46 year, A.F.O./F.E.O. C/o Assistat Director of Fisheries/CEO. VFFDA Distt f Rajnandgaon (CG); Shri Sanjay Pandhi, S/o Shri Anand Prasad Pandhi, aged about 44 year, A.F.O./F.E.O. C/o Assistat Director of Fisheries Dist: DanteWada (CG); -Shri J. P. Shanna, S/o Shri Krishna Prad, aged about 49 year, A.F.O./F.E.O. C/o Joint Director of Fisheries/CEO. FFDA Distt Raipur (CG); Shri Bhuwan Lal Verma, S/o Shri Premla Verma, aged iabout'46 year, A.F.O./F.E.O. C/o Dy. Director of Fisheries/CEO. FFDA Distt ‘Durg (CG); Shn' Ramesh Kumar Mahant, 3/0 Shri s. D. Mahant, aged about 49 year, A.F.O./F.E.O. C/o c.E.o. FFDA Distt Anabikapur (CG); Shri Brij Bhushan Pandey, S/o Late Lakhan Ram, aged about 48 year, A.F.O./F.E.O. C/o /’18. /19. . 21. 22. {23. 20. Raksha Ari/am / Manoj Kumar Sinha . Counsel for the Appellants a, "‘v . sa l ADF/C.E.O. FFDA Distt ’Kondagaon (CG) 'Shri Subhash Hunka, S/o Shri Nathulalv aged about 48 year, A.F.0./F.E.o. C/o ADF/CIEQ. FFDA Distt Rajnandgaon (CG); Shri Raj‘endra Singh, S/o Shri Ramakant, aged about 44 year, Fishen'es Inspector/F.E.W.. C/o Dy. Director of Fisheries/CEO. FFDA’Distt Durg (CG); ' 'Shri R. P. Verma, S/o Shri Shiv Singh Verma, aged about 48 year, Fisheries Inspector C/o Joint Directore of Fisheries Distt. Raipur; Shri Anil Kurnar Hazari, S/o Shri Badri Prasad Hazari, aged about 49 years, O/o Assistant Director, Fisheries, District, Dhamtari. Memo of Writ Appeal u/Sec.‘2(1) of 2(1) of the Chhattisgarh High Cou6rt (Appeal to Division Bench) Act, 2006, arising from Order dated V 4.8.2008 passed by Hon’ble Shri S K Agnihotri J in W.P. No. 6092 of 0’s ‘xek 2006 W06 ' a. 14“;.. a . 24. /25. _R_espondent / (/C 26 /27. Petitioner WW ¢ <49 w JmmSIUE 111200 WWW wmm mmm amm (W) WW§wW $§Emm DB: VHon’ble Mr. I. M. Quddusi 85 Hon’ble Mr. N, K. Agarwal 8.10.2010 Shri U‘ N. Awasthy, Sent 3r Advocate with Shri M. K. Sinha, Advocate and ShriN. K‘ Vya a, Shl‘i Satyendra Sahu, Shri Anup Majumdar & Shri Mateen Si que, Advocates for the appellants. Shri Kishore B‘hadun', A 1 State. Ms Fouzia Mirza, Assistz mt Solicitor General for Union of India. r Judgment is passed, sigr Led and dated, separately; in Writ Appeal No. 196/2008 and c ther connected matters, including this appeal. r JJ. ditional Advocate General for the ., sdl_ I 1.M.Qudd“Si 3 Judge Sd/— N. K. Agarwal Judge