,1^.-^W^'' y^Mc^ ^^y' c^- \v^n l^-—• *^' ' • ^i^' '^^^^..,,,.. .^..^^.. ..^:.^.^.^^, ^tytHEHON'BLEHIGHGOURTOFCHHATtlSGARHATBIl.ASPUR Writ Petition(S)No:<2M} /2010. Petitioner: Respondents: 1:^ .^' Narayan,$en, aged about 46 years, S/o Shri Mukhiram Sen, oceupation sen/ice, working as Driver, in Transport Flying Squad, Office of Regional Transpprt Office, Bilaspur, R/o Geetanjali Park, Mangla, Bilaspur (CG). Versus State of Chhattisgarh, lihrough Secretary, Government bf Chhattisgarh, Department of Transport, D. K. S. Bhavan, Mahtralaya, Raipur(CG). 2. Commissioner, Trahsport Department, Chhattisgarh,Raipur(CG) , 3. Regional Transport Officer, Bilaspur (CG). 4. ^ Regional TransportOfficer, Kanker(CG). 5. Dipak Ram Thakur, Sfo not known to the petitjbner, working as Driver, Transport FlyihgSquad, Mahasamund (CG). WRITPE^IQIN UNDER^B^lGLE226;®R'Tl-lfe(i©N®°ltl3'l.)n<3N^F INDlA^;::I^RR1SiU^{^i'i)13yK^raE?INi:IMBBa CERT"l©RARI^MANDAMIJS,£)R@@R;©R©Rie^^^^^ DlRECtlONS., •1 • . .;: ,:.^. , :.. • , : /- • ', ' •••L:,.'' ::: T ^-t •&• * , WI^^ET^^ PETrnONER : NaraiwiSCT. ..yERSUS...' ..:.-'• : .- ' :- RES^flDB^ : St^flCCWiaats^fe&OthCTs. WRTTPE-iaTIQNlJNEffiItAK'H^S^6QETIffi^@NS3I^^ ;'.;:i:^^:;BES®(lBgi »l§aiiaiI£.:^ifflBi^^;:'.'.^^ Present:: %;81in?^ayb!Bw!81wHa^^Adyoe^^tls»^p^^ S^%%S.]»osN%Biepu^^^ .,CTBffiffi^(CHtAU:. l.<.;.. ..:. :.. - •; , -.•'^ -¥.'l^t''^i^i^B3li^ : ~, 1 . ,,.:., 1. ^^^ ^iMQn.i^^l^etiy^ieT'mipBg^l^^^^ ( (Aimexu E^ ^^^)yi;^|ieytioner"i^ Ihwer inffie Plying , Squa4<^tte'ErampcNP^"iiE^»|itatBilas^^ » Dis^cfTriuEp^(^<^Kariker. 2. Leaniedcounsel^appeanBg^:^1tep<^CTW or^ dat^30/6^^ (AnEBxy^SP^ U^j^^ :6^^^effa^^'Xw^is^eMB<^l!BwgKWl^y^eSw^ Ttanspcrt CMffice, Kla^E^ ^Wifliin impugied drderda^ 3/5®0]ro(AaUesutse^-I), ttfc pettttwier^sa^m beentiaas;Nr^ B^lWiaspurfeKanfc^TO Midionties^s iMegri, atbttrMy'and m yiolation trffl teansfer p^iey <N" to State ©overmii^Rirfh^^^t^ aceMBmodate responttot No.5. ^ . 3. €totfae oflierlM^ ShffMoCT^ l^t^ Di^rii^A^^ on account ofadmifflstratiyeexigeney. 4. Heat^leamedcG^elaiipeariDg^tfepatti^^^^^j^^ aaddoeumaitsaoBendedlfaaEeto. li llliJll & '^ 5. ft is weU-seltledfli^teansferis^aaiaeida^xtf's^ vf^- c employert0ideeideasto^^^^^ * keqimgmviewpublfcmta^asweUasadBnmsfrat^ | Gourt has iBmtedjun^ictitmto mterfere witfa llietiansfer matter exeeft in tiie cases ofproved malafide, non-eompetaice^' airthority passiag , the trans^ wfeand^^ iwles and ^ regulations. 'The petitKmeF&n^rfoyee^^^ at one place forffvefcLIi^erthe^^wviskmsofsa^^ aU tii®powerato post an enqiloyee afa patieutorj^ace toviww efpublic mterest asds^smws!xatv e^eB^.^eeSJ>.S(y«^aY.Steto€ifTc^ NadUandanofftei^, UntoW^IfidmvWcwyffiei'v.JemariSum^I^^ & cmoffie^^Stat^tf^^^e^ eiaiwher^ amt .?, Mohd.Maxwi^fmMdv. SfatecfU.P.&ffthers1). * 6. The SuprMne Goiut, m ^wpi^ ^ Pam^ &0th^,'b^i^^awi^ * employee, sc<^ <tfju<Bcialrevie%is!|mM^a^^Ifigh<^ iMtniterf^w^anorderoftrantferli^rily,beitA fiaal llearing. This is so because ^ cou & not nbstt^Aeir c^ deeision in the matter oftransfer^ 7. Soferaseontention -eoiHtratytothe policyoflhe St^ Gov^^ eoncemedilhe^poUcaes are mere g^.uddines and iiot cQntndled tgr; stahrtory i»omisK>as^ Ilie e^ct tfiereofts a<Ms<^ m cliia^^ 'I974(4)SCC3 '(a»*)4SCC245 :'<1995)3SGeZ70 4(2007)8SCC1SO '(2009) 8 SCG 337 confCTred uo<m the sia)BM¥to. (SeWChi^'Cemma'cialManaBer, Sou^ Centrc^Rmlwc^SeiMnSarc^ad&Gthwsv.G^^ 8. The &iprea^ Cw^ m Kendriya J^i^la^^^ S^ PrasadPande^fCtservedaswaSet: ^ Trmls^ wlu^ is aa mcideri ^^^o^ mtafa^v^l^courtsunIeSs'itis^s OTvist^bymalafidecffinftacticmo^at^pi^^ • imneiple&^g^^ bfOrissa).lJiU^thec»dCTOf1ran^ is made m molaticm cfopa^jw mterfere with if (see lAuon offadia v. iS.L.Abbas). 'TOo sUoUld teteaDsfen^andp<Mt^'Wli^isamatte^^ airiliority tb deeide. tJriless the (Mda- of transfer is vitiated by mala fides or is Inade in violation ofai^ <^»CTiB^gm^^ > ruteslfae eourts ^GwldnotoniinarilyintCTfto^^^^ of India v. Janardhan DeBaaath it was observed as fotlows : (SCG p.250, para9) "No govemmentservaatoraiyloyeeofapilriie x»n«lertakmghas aiy le^ ri^ to be^ ^ fiM'everatanyoneparticularidace^a-plaGetfhis dwMce sinee transfe of a partici^ ai^>l^^ appoMrted to the class (»•categpry of'ttai^teable posts fipm <Mie plwe to atKitter is not <aly affl ineideHt, buta c<»riitionofseryMse, necessaytoo in public ittferest aad eflBcieiwy in th®pulriie adnMtBStratKai. ynle^ affl erder (rf transfa' is d]oWtobeanoute<xnerfmalafideex«peise<y^ sta^ to be^m violati<m of statote^pr^^ prohibitii^ aay sudi •teaaisfer, 1lie eotats <»•Ae tribunals n<anadly caanot iaterfete witU sudi liil '(2007) 8 SCC 212 7 (2004) 12 SCC 299 ^:^.^i;:^:.H?%'AN? ls ^S?S^^^§ :';®;sa:.-;^gESi£h;:K!Sae;:Sa.B^^^^^s3 rfiyl;-3^ f fta-,. iT^^S ^|ik»,,J?.^?' 4 ^ 9. <My^asaina^<^routnfeasdi0uAtit^ tfae aCT^t^ aut;h^ d^si(mfOTlfaatoffhe^ployer/ntMBgem^^^^^^^ a^inst su^ tnders passed iri Ifae^^j^ admimstratiye exigei^ vf Ibe semee et^aaM..Thi^p(»itionvl^Jn^iH^ted^fhis Ckiurt 'm Natitmal HyAt^^ Rwwr Coqm. fctd. v. Shri Bhagwan." Ev^othCT^se^there is nfl cl^e^^^to pennissibli&legtf^-outi^asafcn^stated,'*^^ For fhe reasons as af(^sitete€ftw N^cn is dinaaisseti af tte motmn stageitself Ashok Sd/- :, ^isbK.A8n^tn .iudge ii!1"TB- mi' •tiiSSEBSS.'iSSBSS^': ^•"SA^^^^i^^i^^^^^^^^^^^@^^:^^j^^^^'.^. 3S