IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA LPA No.232 of 2004 Hari Rai, son of Late Chamru Rai, resident of village- Maniyarpur, P.S. Bidupur, District- Vaishali …Respondent-Appellant Versus 1. Ganga Bishun Singh, son of Late Thukar Singh, 2. Satya Narayan Singh, son of Sheo Mangal Singh 3. Suresh Singh, son of Sheo Mangal Singh All resident of village-Maniyarpur, P.S.Bidupur, District-Vaishali 4. Asharafi Pandit, son of Late Mukund Pandit 5. Dhanu Pandit, son of Late Dahaur Pandit Both resident of village-Bajitpur, P.S.Bidupur, District-Vaishali 6. Mostt. Mahajani Devi, wife of Late Raghu Rai 7. Madhushudan Rai, son of Late Lagan Rai 8. Bindeshwar Rai, son of Late Lagan Rai 9. Mostt Bhagabatiya Devi, wife of Late Bhadai Rai 10. Raj Narayan Rai, son of Late Bhadai Rai 11. Ram Narayan Rai, son of Late Bhadai Rai 12. Satya Narayan Rai, son of Late Bhadai Rai All resident of village-Panapur, Sukha Nand, P.S.Bidupur, District-Vaishali 13. Shiv Balak Rai, son of Late Jitu Rai 14. Asarfi Rai, son of Shiv Balak Rai 15. Ganesh Rai, son of Shivbalak Rai 16. Tej Narayan Rai, son of Shiv Balak Rai 17. Mukesh Kumar Rai, son of Shiv Balak Rai All resident of village-Jurbanpur Gopalpur, P.S. Bidupur, District-Vaishali 18. Malti Devi, wife of Suresh Prasad Singh, daughter of Shiv Balak Rai, at present residing at village- Bahuyara, P.S. Raja Pakar, District-Vaishali 19. Madhuri Devi, wife of Surendra Prasad Singh, Daughter of Shiv Balak Rai, village-Bahuyara, P.S. Raja Pakar, district-Vaishali 20. Mina Devi, wife of Ramashankar Yadav, resident of village-Nawa Nagar, P.s. Bidupur, District- Vaishali .. Petitioners-Respondents 21. The State of Bihar 22. The Deputy Director, Consolidation, Headquarter, Patna Budha Marg, Patna 23. Sonapati Devi, wife of Hari Rai 24. Ram Kumar Rai, son of HariRai 25. Shyam Kumar Rai, son of Hari Rai 26. Santosh Kumar Rai, son of Hari Rai 27. Sanjeet Kumar Rai, son of Hari Rai 28. Ranjeet Kumar Rai, son of Hari Rai 29. Lagandeo Rai, son of Late Sukha Rai 30. Lal Mohan Rai, son of Ram Briksh Rai 2 All resident of village-Kathauliya, P.O.- Chandpura, Nanhkar, P.S.-Bidupur, District- Vaishali ----------- 5 26.04.2011 When the matter has come up for hearing, learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that this case is covered by a judgment rendered in the case of Chandra Narain Rai and ors. Vs. The State of Bihar and others reported in [2008 PLJR (4)63] disposed of on 25th November 2010. Following the law laid down in the case of Chandra Narain Rai (supra), this L.P.A. is also disposed of in terms of the aforesaid judgment. Ashwini (T.Meena Kumari,J.) (Akhilesh Chandra, J.)