^ yssi3W!sss"sass 3BE SIAIE ABMIHIS'EBAETg 1'BIBOTAI., MITOB O.A. HO. ^fe U3p^3 snicwss 1. E. Jai BarayaaSi.ngb §/o SfariHaBunaistt, Aged about 33 years, PFiaary Sehool KuBfearraS, Bloefc & Bistt. BaHtevada. 2. SiyatiLal Wsfe-ta S/©SBrl Suklal tfatia, Aged atoem'b lrf> %a»s, Pnuary Seh©olPeBBlua,Blo & Mstt.. Baate»ada. 3. ^sssssSuvTT S/e art .Hawa^BaBtJurry, aged Aoat 33 years, Prj.aary Selaoot Hateaar, & Bits't'b. BaB'be»a9a. lt-. Kra.pa BaaMaadatl S/e Sbri Saktoar^n, aged about 37 years, rri.asry Sehosl KoWsrpaiBa, Pbara^»al, Bl.eek aeedaa, Ittstt. Ban'bewada. 5. BaaBaIJt Prasaa <ffiakar_ 8/©Sfari. Bajaeu gl.ngb, Agea. aBoirt 37 jsars, Primary-Sehool Ptlarssmaur, Bl©ek©eeetaB,Mstt. Banteirada* 6. Ba.aesla KHiaarKarna S/©Shri Xoyaram, Aged about 33 years^ prj.siary sebool Hasodi, Sloek Seedaa, Dtstt. SaiateKada. 1 ' ' 7. ^t. -ISasba.lxivhase W/o airi BajendraFrasatl, Aged abput 3't yeaps, Middle Sebo®!Kodenar H&.1 Sajraj Ganp, Kirandul, ELoek KEwakoaia,; Dl.stt. 8. Hektar Ban Bag^el S/o ^r± hMle7^Bain, Aged abeat 37 years> Prl.aar'y Sehool Btdfeul.Har, BLoe k aBd Ms-tt. Saa.tevauia. 9» 8byasa.aI SaQxl 1^0 Iiate 'EeeiBraat, <Ags?iat>oat 37 years, Ha'yi.n Htdtile Sbboel BaBtewada, ELoeb & Sistt. IlaBtewada. 10. .Toba^aagli airuw S/©aiTl .Anar aitHgb^i ^eB ab©Ht3fryea.rs, ffi.diaie S<sfe@f0l GSlilDdasr, BL&eb SeettaB, Msfefc. atewaAa. 1t» Be'fl.al. BEtrBfeee- 'S/®s&rt ®artfauBaa, Agecl abea'fe 17 yeaBs, B'lnaary Setaeol Mstera BaHraar, BLgete Kuwatamea, Mst.t. BaHtewada. Eban Sl:n^t'Bpeiadi_ S/e S&Ft MaiaWffr Kan, jAged 3?.years, Priaary Setisol ttfcguapal, BI©ckKuwafceRda, jBistt. Dantewada. 1 ' 12. 13. Snt. I.ali.-ba Baghd W/©Sari Mabade'^. .Aged aboB't : 31*- ysars, PriBary Sefaeol Baia^Sra Knwateonaa, SLeek Kiwakoada, Mstt, Banrtetiaaa. 14-. Beer^ Siagh KirHWe S/@ airl^ Bara*a BaB,| Agea ateout 3§^?®ars^^BrlBarySehoQltTada'fcaBai, Bloek SeeSaa, Mstt. Bantei»ada». 1 ' ; 15. Heera Baa Haadavi §/% ^rl ebaulan % Aged atooEt^ 37 years, liE'rj.aary BLoek Seedan, Bsi.stte. IB.ntewaeia. w^ "SB^E^ .M 1'itiS .^.^^1. :^^lill:^ |I|» 'iaii i :!ij!i!:t 'a B-il w IIB .e3.,d...?ua..A:,AMltU .1-f. ^t- t.t 16. 17. 18. 19. 21. 22. 23. 2N-. 25. 26. 27. 29. •3©. 31. »'••• -"i »'.• Oautam Sl.ngte^ataskaa £^& an'1 00! angb, AgeA a.1aoafi 36 years, St<aaie Seho©lBairaB, Bloete Ms't't. BaBtewada. Snt. fcria 'vasRlfear N/e Stoi Sabaa Baa, dged d»@at 35 years, Priaary Sebsol Bbansi, BLoek <S: Mstt. Dantexada. Kallasb Baa .Kashyap §/©aart Htaaa Bam, Aged abea't 36 years, Prlaary Sefaool Madse, Seedan, Ms't.t. %aRte»ada. Jettea Baa Marei'fctte ^e SbEt 'Sam y.s^a, AgeAabeiB'b 36 years, Pri-Bary Sdibol .§ BB.oets Seedan, Mstt. Bantewatla. Mageadra ?rasad eiaatarvedi S/o San A.F. gSaturTedt^ 'Aged aboat 35 years, PrtiBai-y ®fi®0lKarwaMpara ©eeefaia, Moek: Seedaa, Slstt. BSBte*ada. Sa®*Wa^Sstg- • .S/Q: Siri Jagamaafete, Aged al»@at 37- years, tti.adle seteoog. Sa1t@©r, BLoe& Qe«SsWf Mstt. Baatewada. ^ C^biye 8/e Saii Baa ?rasad, Aged- a6®at38 years, MIddle Sdaool VSaSse, EI.eeK Qeedas, Mst'fc. Baatewada. Atna SWt Maada^i §/©Sterj. Gibastya BI, Agea^ afcaa't 3^ yea3"^, ErxBa3^''St!feeo3. Xerlsgal, Bteek Seedan, Ms'b't. Bantewada, ' Baslya Baa_I^ S/o ghri iSJ.^ran, Aged 33 years, Prlnary Seb©ol@awa.Si, 'Bloefc SS.stk. Bante»ada. Baaedi KHBar Sage S/o Sbri Jai ^.Bgb, Aged aboat ;36_years^ MJ.aaie School Fendfiffl, ~ | KLocfc & Blstt. Baatetfada. ' ^m Barad aa^h Kestoarl. S/@ San Aged^ abeut; 38 •yeass, WdSle Bloek Qeedaa, .Elstt.» BaHtewgga Sa&e 'EeivaBax; Kn.sbna Ba^r Mabaa't _S/& I.sfee Baa StEigb, Age^ a^u^ te y^^s, ^iajaary Setool ^3^ Bl©efe©eedaa,.Blstt.Baafeewada. SttfaiaUi ebmdra aieai.ya g^» aari. Mettfcsr^Batt, Ags^^abswfe' 35":years,-'' ''Sviswy^. Sefaooi ^SaSe^fs Bl©t?kSeeaan, Ms»te. Baa^ew^a. Sa'b. ^ KBaairt. Bsg %<e Sten< SilT ®mar, ateewt 39 yeass, EaBya^Prinary Sctoocd, Saafcewafla. Ma&a SBaBfcar d^ai ^s 'L&te Ssiii^. Sa.n, AgeS at)o»t.36 years, 8©-vt.H.g.S. Bade Bloek Katek.alyan, K.^it. Ba&'fewada. ETannia Bam Saq.aa §/e ^ri ^Bt73.a3., Aged 33: 3'®ars>.frl.nst.^'^Seheel^Bab'p.aly Blstelsw^ Mstt. ! Baa-feeaaaa.' " , • : .-;/; •~; •" ' '•%'':''; ^&iiliSBBii eBBl;B|.||||g}|g||g .,-^-ss-iri!|ifcii:i:i •iiD jy.^ r- • < ^ • • 32, 33. 3^ 3?. 36. 37. 38. 39. 4®. >t1. te. 43. 44.. 4?. ^. 47. aajaa'an itiasfcar S/©Sbxi M&aisast, Aged about 38 Xears, KB.aaLes astosl Mn^aa, BI.eefc - ^©^^8ffi» .i©dl.;S'te'fe* ®StElti6W!3i(ds» ,aEfea? ^/a ^Tl. Jbttra Baai, Aged 31i-3£®srs,Adara»-^a3saBaagapal, SeeaaB, Mst*. .BaiifceBada. SBfe. fsaSsS. SSSXQ V/o Shrl B.S. .Bari'®,Aged atoBl; 43 XeacsSf Pri.nary SehQQl Karij., BLoete'Sesdaa, Ktsfcl;. Baatewada. BajeBdra Kumar Haraskele S/@ airi teaiarlal, Aged abOB't 35 years, Prtnary Sc&©olKarli, BLoek Seedan, Bistt. Da&tewada. Snt. aashi. Prabha Jain W/o Stari Sulab ebaBd, Aged ab®nt;1^- Tears, Middle Sefaool Haraa, Block QeedaB, Mstl;. Bantewada. Siafc, Brijlata&Hl W/o ®riVined, Aged aboafr 43 Sears, Priaary Seboel .rasaBga, Bloek Seeaaa, Mstt. BaBtewada. Sat. Sreen Sifflea W/& Sirt 39 iBars, Bays Priaary SeMool Geedan, Mstt. BaBtewada. , Aged ab@ut i, bloek - Smt. MaiajM Bata teatair W/a Sbri Iiakdiaan Slagla, Agect ^aboBt 4li- years, Boys Pri.mary Selio©l, Btewata.gara Seedam,- BLeek ©eedam,Btstt. i. Kanal.j: Markaa y/@ airi M.L. Harkam, Age&^ aSBQVtt 37 ysasE^, ».M« Sefao®!Qhol.aar, i, Mstt»BaQti»»ada. ^ing^ Bag S/Q ari, Saklaraa, Aged J? yesrs, Mtddle Sebool £anal6or,-EIiOGb Mstt. Banfeewada. SBt. Prarila Gharan W/0 Stiri Masib, Aged lalioB't ^? Tears, Prinary Selaool Ballway Goleny, Baeheli, Block & Msfrb. Baatewaeta. Smt. SaTita Meshraa W/o Shrl. tejesh EBaar, •Ag^d abe®t37 years, X.M. Sebeol Baiitewaaa, BLoek& Mst;t. Bantewada. SttkhdeTS _ S/o^Sbrl M^tar Ban, Aged aboiift 36_Iears,_Hi8ldle Seho®!Kawaflgasn, I gloelt & Btstt. BaateBada. &. Ur^la Besara B/©Shri B.B. Besara, Aged aboat 3lt_7®ars,.6p-rt*B'S'S* 'Sastewa&s, j Ea.oefe & Blstt. Baiite»ada. Sfflt. Jayaate iaast.ri. w/@,airi T.1^. aias*et, Aged ateent 3i>- yeSa's, tinaia^' asteoe)]; itaEtjstBka, Block &-fits1?t.. B&al-eirafla. Maoau jtoaJEBaet£_§/oan .T.®.Sam^i, :ate®Bt^3^.Befti's:,'^toTt.';B.'SAi&B'KeiB®ite, Mstt»BaiateN^a. " ' : .' ' ' '• :" •N-.. uv ;l'iltjl »s &.;:.^s^^^;.,^ •o^ . ^ -c 48. Snfe. Sa^kam^^ Jatt W/®asiri Pranad Kanar, • •• I.Ag^cla^Bt^3¥_yr:s.;,,'^r^aazy:,SeUoQ3.:'ltaiy'apaFa, ., . : CBaaKewadai), %@SK?&iBistt. Baafeewada. ~ '^9. Smt. Kanaa.a Bevl. ^lfaBhar W/®^iri S.y, Maiihar, Ageal aboat li;2 Xears, rrj.aary Seteool ^n.dyaaagar, Klrandul, BIoet!; Kiwafconda, Mstt. gaiatewada. ?G. aayaa0.al ®a«de S/o Late_Balsa H Ban, Aged • abeat 3? YearSt PriBary Seliool Baipetb, K.oek & Mst1>. Baate»ada. ?1. J'ohaia Bam aarya S/©Sbri Satedev BaB, .Aged abeut 36^years, ^rlw.ry Sehool Ka»aelga0n, Bl-oek & Bls'fct;. Dantewada. '-" • .rf'. '. . ' " • ••••....• '• ' ' . ?2. BaBeshwar @oti ^/e Late Sliana Baa, _Aged aboQt 37; 'Saars^ Priaary Sehool Badfairas, SLoek - KatekeiLyan, Ms'bt. ®ante»^a. 53. J'atlai sa-a^ Barro S/o airl Balda BSa, .Aged abOHt 3? Sears, Prl.BsuFy.Setaeol Badwar, BLoelt Ke^kai, Mfftt* Bas'tar. ?4. PrattaA EumaB Salaa S/o Sfiri. Bailraa, Aged aboat 33 Isass, IB-saie Sebeol ^arrt.para, aioek Kediteal, ai.sW.Bastar. ~ l 5$. , laslswaatBan SBBa. ^/o fitax^Kaebra Baa, Aged afeea'b 36 years, MtBaie Seliool Hardapeti, SLoete Kaatter, Ms-bfe. Ka&Ker. 56. Smt. Ai^ali ^Ea ^®^rt '&sla'BaKt Baa, &ge& f aboiit 34- lears, tteaea I.T.J., Bloete Kaaker, :B2.stt.".EaBfcer. • • ; ''.: ^ 11; 57. Paaa Ban Pradban_S/o Eate Prabtaa Ban, ateout 37 rears^^Prl.BiaEy Sehool Kollyart Eloek Kanker, ®tstt.Kanteer. ' ^& .ifjii IMI • uII •ll''i] a» iS^-^i'^'.^ '"'••^s- '~-t. VEBSUS •HON'-APi'LIGANIS 1. THE STATB QF M.E. . 'THBOUGH I'HE SBGBEIABI,, TBIBM. WEL?ABE BEPAB'iMEHT, BHOPM,' (M.P.) 2. 2SE STATE QFCHHA'FTISG:ABH TSH3U6H TSE SBSBETABY 'EBIBAL waFABB DEPAEII4ENT BAIPUE (G.S.) " 3. 'I'EECOMMISSIONEE TBIBAL ySFABE DEE'AHIMBH'T BHOPAL (M'.P.J 4. ffiS GOMMISSIONEB TBIBAL WELFABE DEPABB'IB'IT BAIPUB (.Q.G.) • APBLIG&'EIQK IHiTDEK, SBS'EI.OW 1-9. OF -'EHE ABffl-NI STBAII7E ^;.:i.^,^2g;[BB^KA£S;'dE^,'1S8$^' : : HI6H COURT OF CHHATTES6ARH AT BILASPUR Writ Ftetition (s) No. 3846 of 2005 Petitioners K.Jai Nku-ayan Singh & others Versus ftespondents StateofM.P.(NowChhcrt+isgarh) &others Singte BtsnchIHon'ble Mr.JusticeSatish K. Agnihotri. Presen-t: Shri P.P. Sahu, Advocate for •the petitioners. 5hri V.V.S. Moorthy, Deputy Advocate Seneral for the State/responctents. ir* ^••y ^y^. :!its^ 11 •"^. s •aa -< ORDER (RosSedon t2th day of &ecember, 2006) Thefotio^9 o^r^'^e^°ttr"t'wasPassec''lyS<rMsh K. Agnihotri, J. 1. The petiti<»(ie^'were:Sa|^inted< AsSis^t Tea<Aer, where^ it wiusi provided +haf1+ie;pe^MTOiTerSwouBl3egrdn1^^p^ scale of Rs; 545- 10-575-15-800-20^00-2B-975/-, after' a period of one year. It was further provided ttiat the petitioners would be entitled to the fixed| pay of Rs.300/- for a period of oneyear. 2. Similarly situated emptoyees had approached the MadhyaPradesh 5tate Aclministratwe Tribunal. The Tribunal pas«d the oreler on 24.S.1992 in O.A. No. 2745 of 1989 (<todhul«mtyacluand56others Vs. Stnrte of M.P. Aothersj 3..It was further held that tha said behefit would be given to dll teachersand they ^ould not becom^llecl toapproddi the^^ for similar benefjt inclividuallyoi- collectively. KSSgBSiBMaBHSffl »iif :;;i;l!NII ^ilill SJIIIF m :^^f ili .-M l.aisiaBiafil Thokur 4. Being aggrieved,the -then Stnte of Atecfliya Pradesh had filed the Special Leave Petition (Ciyil) No. 6892/93 impugning +he order ckxted 24.8.1992 passedby -the Madhya Pradesh State Administrative Tribunal. JoAatpur in O.A. . 2745/89. TheHon'bie Supreme Court after hearing leaFned counsel for the parties, dismissed the Special Leave Petition and having regard to the large fmancial impli<ations, granted one year's time to sett'le the ctaum for the arnears withoyt interest videorder dated 3.1.1994. It was furtherobserved -that the intervention would work out their rights in accordance with law. This order dated 24^.1992 possedbytheTribunalinO.A.No. 2745/1989 is applicable +o the p^ittoners^bem^simMaKl^a oiccot'dingfyen'ti't'lelrt-to^t+iesame^ber^fit.' • i i 5. Fbr the above storted reasons, the petitipnerS we granted Kberty •fto mate d represen-tation to consiclerthecasesofthepetitionersifi'j'i stond on •tlie scinie footmgas per orderdflrted 24^.1992 bythe| AAodhya Pradedi Stcrte Administrert'ive Tribunal, Jabal(»urm O.A. NQ.| 2745/89 (AAadhukont ttedu ond 56 others Vs. Sterte of tAP. '& othersj and subsequently CCTtfirmed by order dafed 3.1.1994 Iposs^ by the Hon'ble Supreme (^urfr ih ^ecial l.eawil^ition (Givtl) N^ 6892/93 and gfontrelief drccorclingly. i 6. The writ petition lisoccordh^ly di^sed of. l^ prder as t6 co Sd/- SatfshK. Agnihotri Judge ea ?II N11: ':jai'f[: iffii i'a;'i • flf\W •IK