IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT : THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.SASIDHARAN NAMBIAR FRIDAY, THE 11TH APRIL 2008 / 22ND CHAITHRA 1930 RP.No. 462 of 2008() -------------------- AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT/ORDER IN SA.429/1994 Dated 21/01/2008 AS.180/1989 of SUB COURT, PAYYANNUR .................... : REVIEW PETITIONERS/APPELLANTS IN S.A.429/1994 -------------------------------------------------------------- 1. KEETHADATH PUTHIYAPURAYIL ALIYUMMA D/O.SOOPI HAJI, KEEZHALLUR AMSOM AND KODU DESOM. 2. KEETHADATH PUTHIYAPURAYIL MUHAMMED, S/O.ALIYAMMA, KEEZHALLUR AMSOM AND KODU DESOM (DIED) 3. KEETHADATH PUTHIYAPURAYIL MOOSAN, S/O.ALIYUMMA, KEEZHALLUR AMSOM AND KODU DESOM. 4. KEETHADATH PUTHIYAPURAYIL ABDUL SALAM, S/O.ALIYUMMA, KEEZHALLUR AMSOM AND KODUR DESOM. 5. KEETHADATH PUTHIYAPURAYIL SEKIYA, D/O.ALIYUMMA, KEEZHALLUR AMSOM AND KODU DESOM, (DIED). 6. P.K.SAIDA, W/O.DECEASED MUHAMMED, KEEZHALLUR AMSOM, KODAR DESOM, MATTANNUR. 7. P.K.SAJILA, D/O.DECEASED MOHAMMED, KEEZHALLUR AMSOM, KODAR DESOM, MATTANNUR. 8. P.K.SALEELA, D/O.DECEASED MOHAMMED, KEEZHALLUR AMSOM, KODAR DESOM, MATTANNUR. 9. P.K.SAMEELA, D/O.DECEASED MOHAMMED, KEEZHALLUR AMSOM KODAR DESOM, MATTANNUR. 10. P.K.MOHAMMED SAFEEL, S/O.DECEASED MOHAMMED, KEEZHALLUR AMSOM, KODAR DESOM, MATTANNUR. BY ADV. SRI.M.A.MANHU SRI.M.A.FAYAZ RESPONDENTS: REVIEW RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS IN SA 429/1994 --------------------------------------------------------- 1. THERATH PUTHIYAPURAYIL JANU, D/O.KALLIANI, PADIYUR AMSOM, VAYATHUR DESOM, TALIPARAMBA TALUK, VII/790, PADIYOOR KALLIYAD PANCHAYATH. 2. SARAMA CHANDY, JAYA VIHAR, C/O.P.C.CHANDY JAYA VIHAR, MUTHADA P.O., TRIVANDRUM - 25.(DIED) 3. THAZHATH PUTHIYAPURAYIL YESODA, D/O.KALLIANI, PADIYUR AMSOM AND VAYATHUR DESOM, TALIPARAMBA TALUK (DIED) 4. K.K.SAVITHRY ALIAS OMANA, D/O.KUNHAMBU, KOOVAKKATTUMMEL HOUSE, ERIYAMANGALAM P.O., BALUSSERY P.O., KOZHIKODE DISTRICT. 5. K.K.VANAJA, D/O.KUNHAMBU, KUNIYATH HOUSE, ULIKKAL P.O., PIN: 670 705. 6. K.K.VALSA, D/O.KUNHAMBU, KUNIYATH, ULIKKAL P.O., PIN: 670 705. 7. K.K.LEKSHMANAN, S/O.KUNHAMBU, KUNNIYATH ULIKKAL P.O., P.O. 670 705. 8. K.K.BALU, S/O.KUNHAMBU, KUNNIYATH ULIKKAL P.O., PIN: 670 705. 9. PANAVELIL CHANDY, S/O.CHANDY, DEVAMATHA ESTATE, NUCHIYAD AMSOM DESOM, MUNDAVOOR P.O., NACHIYAD (DIED). 10. P.C.LATHA, D/O.SARAMMA CHANDY, DEVAMATHA ESTATE, NUCHIYAD AMSOM, DESOM P.O., NACHIYAD. 11. P.C.PREMA, D/O.SARAMMA CHANDY, DEVAMATHA ESTATE, NUCHIYAD AMSOM, DESOM P.O., NUCHIYAD. 12. P.C.ALEX CHANDY, S/O.SARAMMA CHANDY, DEVAMATHA ESTATE, NUCHIYAD AMSOM, DESOM P.O., NUCHIYAD. THIS REVIEW PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 11/04/2008, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY PASSED THE FOLLOWING: M.SASIDHARAN NAMBIAR,J. =========================== R.P. NO. 462 OF 2008 in S.A.No.429 OF 1994 =========================== Dated this the 11th day of April, 2008 ORDER This petition is filed to review the judgment dated 21.1.2008 contending that petitioner got assignment of the property in November,2007 and as the suit property was assigned, appellants had no subsisting interest at the time when the second appeal was heard and petitioner could not appear and argue the matter as he was not implead and the judgment is therefore to be reviewed. 2. The argument of learned counsel appearing for petitioner is that this court erred in finding that copy of Ext.A1 was accepted and that it is in respect of another property when it is in respect of the same property. The scope of review petition is not that of an appeal. If the finding is erroneous as claimed by petitioner remedy of the petitioner is to file an appeal and not a review R.P.462/08 in S.A.429/94 2 petition. Petitioners who purchased the property when the first appeal was pending and did not prosecute the appeal as assignees of appellants cannot be heard to contend that he did not get opportunity to argue the appeal. There is no apparent error or other sufficient reason to review the judgment. Review petition is dismissed. M.SASIDHARAN NAMBIAR JUDGE tpl/- M.SASIDHARAN NAMBIAR, J. --------------------- W.P.(C).NO. /06 --------------------- JUDGMENT SEPTEMBER,2006