C€{2z>7/“ IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR WRIT PETITION (S) No.é3§?;../2009 PETITIONER f?)ashrath Patel S / o Shri Padmlochan Patel, aged about 46 years working as Block Research Coordinator center, Basna Distt. Mahasamund (C.G.) VERSUS K RESPONDENTS 1. State of Chhattisgarh, Through Secretarynder secrtary, 'School Education Department Mantralaya D..S. BhawanqRaipur (C.G.) The Direct, Rajeev Gandhi Shiksha Mission, Pension Bada, Raipur (C.G.) The Collector 8a District Mission Diector, Rajeev Gandhi Shiksha Misson, Dist. Mahasamund (C.G.) The Dstrict Project Officer, Coordinator, Rajeev Gandhi Shiksha Mission, Mahasamund, Dist. Mahasamund (C.G.) Education Officer, Mahasamund Dist. Mahsamund (C.G.) Shri Ganesh Ram Jagat, Lecturer Government Higher Secondary School Bhukel Block Basna Dist. Mahasrnund (C.G.) District WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE COUNSTITUTION OF INDIA. /u e K or r i i , a {wmw . .~: mgmwmawwgmgwmmmwy m“ Qwymu‘w m N¢Q.manmg awgwum m wagwmw, .awm mg mmawx . . h : 30$. c mymWm. yhmw, 3§w¢w3 §m um m3<.m. ”3mm? Cy.“Hm mm3mw 9‘§u mym $9.; mfwxmm$yamu awcnwQ wowadv qumwogama 20 m OmwummQmxyry dvmmmmg an H um§ am< Q ze’xmwmwomwKmama ”A J wym nonm Q“ 93$ nokamwmvvmmmvw “aw @wm nnwmy mww mm? 43m vmw Qnmw. .9. ”Em wmw mumgmom mm ¢ma l\} wTm Ow n mQ 0%:Zx... )(ozmnwo.fn£§-wmm§nw Qwwowor wwmw‘ammnmwwmmwwmwm mmynwmBcnn ézmwag WymWammayoama 3mm gm: $393 “Hma 7H Em Umgma.gmmmn mmmrw. 4.5mmm‘mmanmwmwmcmmmxu m nmamaao‘ w.”gm .‘mmuavmm3r. .v 3o mu 5 ax “ 43Mm $.2 E mamwm? amaww 9”mwowwmmmmgdm Gmwwm mym Laou‘Qmmwow wm mm? mmm 3 $3Jm cmm i 39" an amtmwmwoz an a, Hnmwmmwmw. W3 x my“ mam 2%“ um?» mm-m-waom. .3. 29$ a umau $3M. VS «mmmqmm ‘8 “15¢ rwym vmmmgmm. vmw wmmm wan03 ”3m womw 0%mmnc Emmmmmg bmmw Mam umom rym ,6 g Tmmu “.mmmwmrmmmwamg. mm” mmn? wmax‘xm 3:mmoJ JmqWcwama m3mm.” ,E-3-kr3m 0mg OWMo 3m «mwonamwmmKKEQQmm Wm v.35? wmmummaSgmmmww nmé usQJnw w;W vmm ®m£Qa m m wwm Emmwwam E .Jngmd Wamw 9i. “m éoaasn mmzwmnwwm3 Mwmwm mm Ja ooaéwmmgmt mmrsgmw wrm game mm» m0$m.amw‘ mmamm mmadmn 3-3-wmmm§m wm: 53$ 3mm wmwa «mvmr 9m. WO mvgmmiw om wmwéJ Kw $.63»amamnE (.1 man J ‘ _ w has been X361 a 0r he " *3 c yes-smmeréaiian made §3U Ehe m— :aaige Rémzsiea' We imagigmad 6mg? has b‘en ga’s’seé w§’z%mu‘: faigowing igm‘m .e: c3? naéuraé éusiice and wfmvt a€cmm smarmm“ ieamu ¥a 1"; $e many. he ethef ham iem'nw cauhse§ angeamg mf the Sa‘a su’m'miS ‘ih‘t the geiitwne? has awnpwiea ma yeam item? in me Raéé‘v’ wandhi Ehikséaa Miymi‘a am éeguta‘iim *9a5§$ am he has r0 right is :Gatanw m he saé MIS3§m fa? e‘v'gf. 'eamé cetm$e§ mrihel' sabmis E’ha. me {$3p5rmemamhari‘ies a€iér wmwermg a§§ me asgecé” F? me “wa4‘ief .n §s mr awd 5: Mt mega} 'ihe imgugnea’ ca'dez &nd kg 1 :3; pus ucf ”Ea {esgmdwé Nag. As fag" as ‘ihe pasém U af resxecnderai Nc.6 (m ’iie §>ass 9f recemmewatior uf ch g \iimxs a“ Es cancemed, §eam$d ceqn3e§ swmiis t’raat "the "U :Libiic Ke aese'xiawe cy {he cansemed w§§m$ier way mane meammendai n a!“ adm n szfaiave exigercv m? ire emwcvea ${om we aiace m Giher mate. m gamma a? m M {zen mn‘ §sameé c9unse% was d g nut: “paw thy aemsmn Hhe aapyem'e femei’eii m $319M. :‘aasami £1mac§ vs. Siate e§ kw. ami- ()1 i have heafé :eemea‘ cewse? awearim fey é‘ne eemes. 3e sed ihe meadmgs aed the decumente apgeeéed€herem AdmitEeaiiy. m the pi‘eseni ceee. §t is e‘v‘ den: Mai the 5ei§§é<me¥ wee sem er eem‘mm‘ by owe? yam; A #A ' 2§ $ 2&3? wad “g ardear dmes‘ 2?-’1$—2@i3§ ihe depu€“i‘§m yes ca.:eei§ea‘ m6; he pe?iié<m” was reeamaied eaw LO the na”e.i depa; mew? afiei' eemmeiéen cf mimmum ‘ efa'eé 9f we yearc i. ac e .i’iamee angrazik 'Um i mylhe \ vuprem Q Cam‘s ebser'eeé ee (I) under .' til) 8 Leawed ceunse§ for i‘we aweaené auem et‘ the: the impugred tar5§er ewe? o .ne eepciian *Mrwffa mega! t9 Mawa‘na U‘sw’mt Mean}: was mane at me instance ea an MLA. Lm ihe awe eend R he= been e§a€ed Era ihe ceunéeai effMea/a fled m be§~ei§ cf ¥e¢penéenis ? arcs 2 £13? .He appeiem hae been irensferred due :9 cempaamzs agamst him M av“ minim. even if ihe eiaegaiéen e§the eyewiiam is a Gaffes”: that he was n errer‘ on *r ecommeindatmw of an ihai 3m; i€seif waaiiu mt vk‘iate im g: E“ oyder. Ii—l‘ftg aéE, i: i5 the cmw of reseniaiives a?“ m3 {Aeopie iv. ihe um t0 express. "z%1e gs'ie‘eanaas a?" pesgée am: E them i$ my campiam? nst an effic§a5 ihé S'iaie government is: ceriaimy within §t$ garisdiziion t0 transfer sash 2m empiwee, There can be my ha?d-an§-?ast a‘uie that even! transfe: at ithe instanse 0f an MP 0r MLA woum be vitiai’e . 33 a§5 dependa an the §aats am: circumsiances cf an indwidua! case. in he greseni case, wa gee 51.0 irifirmity in ihe Emsug‘wd transfer erder.” 1:2. w ‘1a):: ~ 3‘ m m1 (I)(I! (n m aw” a m m M) 1x M . 3" (9 5"‘ The %aw en dem;€a icn is vew s§ear. Ta e Sumeme Cow? m Si“? of Fmg'at: am“ mhew w“ inéer Simh ami athea’s2 whim cmb‘zqafing the dew €at§an am‘ ramiriatirn is the pamm cadfe!-:§e;:ariment an exaiw cf peréod af éepuia‘iim absewed as una‘er :- ‘8 The camem 9f “ra‘eawiaticn” is wsH uaderstosd in $erv§ce iaw aw has a :"escgm er} meenmg. “fieguziaiien” has a differeni csnnataiEorz m semce §aw and ihe éidim‘aary meamng 0f me weyd Sidewtaiien” i3 Csf m he§p. h“. simn§e wcfds ,, “deamatmn meam sewQce cutside me satire a oaiside the paiem‘ ciepar‘:mené. Deputation is deputmg or iransferréng an emwc‘yee is a mst auiséde his cadre, €hat §s tr: sav. *‘m anather demriment an a :emgcfary basis. A§$er “the expia’y peried 0§ depmazsoa the emypioyee has i0 some back to his parent deparimeni to occapy *ha same pasitéoa uniess‘ §n *Jm meanwhae he has earned pmmciiw in his parent dewrimem a3 yer fhe Recwiimem Ruieg. E§gihe§her $19 é§ans§ef is outside €hé nwm33 fzeld of a‘eniavmerEt a? not is decided? by Ehe authm‘ity Wm centm§s éhr: s-awice e? posi fre h which ‘me emsiayee is iranss‘errezk There can be n9 depaiaiien Mthamt the cameni af ”the pé{san so dwuéxaé ana‘ he wouki hereme‘ kmw h§s rights and privi§eges in the éegwta$§an pest. The iaw an éeputation and repatriation is quite settiéa as we have aise seen §n various iuéamenis which we have refewed ta wove ............. " 2 wag?) . a $66 372 \ (O $0. 3 figgg) .A at SCC 6535 4 "{2D003 5 SCC 362 a NR 2007 SC 1269 “me Supreme Cami in amapaii $hauc§hary vs. Siaie e? Eiha; aad amiha? ha$ de§ned ‘dewtatié‘a’ m ihe fo§1owir3g iermsz- rurther. in Kline? weenie vswueéee e? zeehe enc anether‘? ihe Sumeme Cam??? absens‘eud as under: The Supreme Court in Fraser Bherti 8: Gee. vs. Amergee‘i $ingh & Qrsf Qbserved that ’Denuta‘téan san be amiv ées£ribed as an assignment Gf an empbyee {commonw referreai t0 as the deputaiien§5$ m mé department er cadre ar even an argamzatien {cemmcmy :eferred to as we mfen’i department Gr igndimg authority} ‘ta amie‘w! deganment w cadfe cr oa‘gaMzaiEcn {sommcmy re‘feri'ed to as ’ihe borrowing authority). The necessiiy fer sendmg or: degmatiw arises in pubHc énteres’z *3 meet €he exéaencées cf bubiie sewéce. The consepi cf deputatien ie eonsensua§ enci invcives a veiumaw e‘eeiséon of the empieyer tc §end the sewieee e‘f his empioyee and , a eormsmnding eccentarzce of such service by the boyrewing employer. it a§so énveives he ceaseni 0f the empioyee i0 go on deputatien o: not.” "5.H.”§'he ieaeic erincipie uneeriying depmaimn étseif 35 mat the bemoe cehcemed can aiweya ami at any €§me be fepatriatec? to his eas'eni depafiment t0 eerie am: substenme pasiiien thewm at the mstance ef ei‘iher 0f the deeaetmeme and there is no vested r§ght in such a persen ta Continue f r écng on deeuiaiéora 0r get absorbed ,in the departmeat m whigh he haei gehe ca {iepuiationw“ “43 i . 'nere exists a d§s€imkien betweeri , érensfer arid ’eemaiatien’. ‘Depumtien 'eennetee sewiee cuiside the cedye er ou§s§de the perené e‘eparimem in which an empioyee is serving. ‘Transfer’. hewever, is iimeed ée equiveieni pest m the same cadre aad '1 the same e‘epartmeni, Whereae deputeiion wouici be a temperery phenomenoe. éfansfa being aetithesis must exhibéi the eepeeéie indieaiiene.” ‘ Ap§ying ihe we§i seww piincimes eaw 0:1. aepufafjon to ihe facts f me case, continuatic of ‘empiayees on depm‘mion or“ repatria€§en n compietien of depuaiian per§ad aces, m: ciegend an ihei‘r consant. Afkag” sampEeimn a? mammam §e3§cd 0f .dggutwtéerx} ihe petmoner/empbyee m ke reaiated back. ta ihe wanem department. €2. In view of fmegeing and r the reasans m$nt§cned iffierferen (Anmexme —- ’J). Accerdmgiy, ihe w§t peii’émn is dismssed a? the moiiara ge éiself. hereinabove, me §$ wan'anied w§t§1 ‘the orde‘r daiw 2?-‘?5-2€39§ ,r/ Sd/- . ' atish K. Agmhom Judge Gowri p H o n thé’ o i ay ptr h s f r sta S