IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT BANGALORE DATED THIS THE 13 TH DAY OF DECEMBER, 2010 BEFORE THE HON BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBHASH B ADI REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO 1106 OF 2005 BETWEEN Sri K AHMED KHAN S/a YUSUF KHAN MAJOR, NO.25, KALASIPALYAM NEW EXTENSION. 1ST CROSS BANGALORE-560 002 2. Sri MAHABOOB SHARIFF S/O.SHAIK FAKRUDDIN MAJOR, NO.24, 2ND MAIN ROAD PAVATHIPURAM, BANGALORE—0’4 3. Sri A AMEER JAN S/O.ABDULLA MAJOR, NO.101, BRACE SAW STREET CROSS, NEHRUPURAM BANGALORE-0 1 4. Sri K A ABDUL HASEE.B S/O.ABDUL HAZEEB MAJOR, 20, B P BLOCK MUNI RED DYPALYA (J.C.NAGAR) BANGALORE560 006 4 COPY Assistafl Cot 1- O i arP’ 13an&atOi” 00 RFA NO.1106/05 5. Sri C NAZIRULLAN SHARIFF S/O.MOHD.YOUSUFF SHARIFF AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS R/A.NO.27, 2ND MAIN, CHINNAPPA GARDEN BANGALORE-560046 6. Sri K SAflAR SHARIFF S/O.LATE ABDUL KHALAQ AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS, R/A.NO.47, 1ST CROSS CHOWDAIAH BLOCK, NEAR HMT LAYOUT R.T.NAGAR, BANGALORE-560032 7. Sr1MJALI S/O.LATE M N AU AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS R/A.NO.38/4, 1ST CROSS MARAPPA GARDEN, J.C.NAGAR BANGALORE-560006 8. Sri B SYED SAMIUALLA S/O.B.SYED HUSSAIN AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS R/A.NO. 193, GROUND FLOOR 6TH MAIN, 2ND BLOCK R.T.NAGAR, BANGALORE-560032 9. Sri SYED AB1)UL GANI S/O.ABDUL AZEEZ AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS NO.87, 3RD MATN, KAUSAR NAGAR BANGALORE-560032 •COPY S.’ aflgh CourtofKariiatjw - 66000t RFANO.1106/05 3 10. Sri MOHAMMAD IBRAHIM KABHI S/O.ABDUL JABBAR AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS NO.6 150, H CROSS, BISMILLAHANAGAR, BANNERGHAflA ROAD CROSS BANGALORE-560029 11. Sr1AAKHADER S/O.A.M.ABDUL RAHIM AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS SHOP NO.106, VENKATAPPA BUILDING S J P ROAD, PARVATHIPURAM BANGALORE-04 12. Sri SHEIK ANMED S/O.ABDUL KHADER AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS NO.24/ 17, 2ND MAIN, PARVATHIPURAM, BANGALORE-04 13. Sn ZABIULLA KHAN S/O.RAHIM KHAN AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS NO.24/6, 2ND MAIN, PARVATHIPURAM, BANGALORE-04 14. Sri OSMAN SHARIEF S/O.MCHAMMED AZHERULLA AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS I/B, 6TH CROSS, SOMESHWARANAGAR JAYANAGAR 1ST BLOCK BANGALORE-560 011 qcoPY Assistant TIcØRtflt HIgb Court of Lcarret.%Ka Iiarnzalore - RFANO.1106/05 4 15. Sri SHAFT S/OSABU SAB AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS 24/15, 2ND MAIN ROAD PARVATHIPURAM BANGALORE-560004 16. Sri FAYAZ MEHMOOD S/OK.N1ZAMUDDiN AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS 24/18, 2ND MAIN ROAD PARVATHIPURAM, BANGALORE04 17. Sri SYEI) HASHAM S/O.SYED GHOUSE AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS 91/1, DASAPPA GARDEN H M T LAYOUT, R.T.NAGAR BANGALORE-560002 18. Sri AMANULLA KHAN S/O.LATIF KHAN NO.3 1, 1ST CROSS KALASIPALYAM, NE CX1, BANGALORE02 19. SHAIKAHMED S/O.SHAIK MASTAN (DELETED) 20. Sri ABDUL RAZAAK S/O.LATE R ABDUL JALEEL AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS NOJO4, 1ST MAIN, 1ST BLOCK RMV 2ND STAGE, BANGALORE94 , (::OPY RF’A NO.1106/OS 21. Sri MOHAMMED ILAYAS S/O,ABDUL RAZACK H.NO.8/4, 6TH CROSS DOD MAVALLI, BANGALORE-04 22. Sri B S ZABIULLA S/O,BHSABULAL AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS NO.144/5, 2ND MAIN, VIDYARANA NAGAR, MAGADI ROAD BANGALORE-560 023 23. Sri AYAZ KHAN S/O.AMEER JAN AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS NO.7, 3RD MAIN ROAD KALASIPALYAM NEW EXTENSION BANGALORE- 560002 24. Sri FAZAL AHMED KHAN S/O.Y.AHMED KHAN AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS NO.74, AM LANE KALASIPALYAM, BANGALORE-5600 18 25. Sri MOHAMMED ILAYAS ASRANI S/O,JASMAL BASHA AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS NO.92, 2ND CROSS T1PPUNAGAR, MYSORE ROAD BANCTALORE-5600 18 - L(ourt tt I RFANO.1106/05 6 26. Sri ABDUL KAREEM S/O.NAWAB JAN NO.323, TIPPLINAGAR CHAMARAJPET, BANGALORE- 18 27. Sri RAHMATHULLA BAIG S/O.HAYATH BAIG ACTED ABOUT 52 YEARS NO.40, MONOVAYANAPALYA R,T.NAGAR, BANGALORE-32 APPELLANTS (By Sri.JAGADEESH MUNDARAGI, Sri H M GOPAL ADVOCATES) AND I. THE SECRETARY CENTRAL MUSLIM ASSOCIATION A S CHAR, STREET F3ANGALORE 2. Sri RAHMATHULLA S/O MAJOR NO 151, KALASIPALYAM BANGALORE 2 3. Sri SHAQADRI S/C M M SYED MURTURA SHA NO 31, NEW CORPORATION BUILDING N R ROAD CROSS, BANGALORE 2 4. Sri MUSHTAQ SHARIFF 5/0 HUSSAIN SHERIFF MAJOR NO 22, 4 CROS,QLD PENSION SSar4 I — • ri5 RFANO.1106/05 7 MOHALLA,MYSORE ROAD BANGALORE 18 5. Sri SYED USMAN S/C LATE SYED ABBAS NO 3, KALI AMMAN KOIL STREET ULSOOR, BANGALORE 8 6. Sri MOHAMEMD KALEEMULA S/O ABDUL KAREEEM, MAJOR, H-61 NAWAB HYDER ALT KHAN ROAD, KALASI PALYAM BANGALORE 2 7. Sri MOHAMEMD ALT S/C LATE M D SHAFT MAJOR R/O 470/23. 1 CROSS, V R PURAM PALACE GUTTAHALLI BANGALORE-03 8. Sri IMRAN KHAN S/O IQBAN KHAN MAJOR 101, NAWAB HYDER ALT KHAN ROAD KALASIPALYAM, BAN GALORE 2 9. Sri SHABBIR KHAN S/C IQBJ 1 N KHAN MAJOR, 101, NAWAB HYDER ALT KHAN ROAD KALASIPALAM BANGALORE . .- RFANO.1106/05 8 10. Sri KHALENDER SHAR1FF 5/0 R H USSAIN MAJOR, NO 19/10,6 CROSS, CHELVADI PALYA DR T C M ROYAN ROAD, BANGALORE 53 Ii. Sri MUNER AHMED QUARESHI S/O ABDUL KHADER QUARESFII MAJOR, NO 11, BELLI SRINIVAS STRET SEGIBELLI, CITY MARKET BANGALORE 2 12. Sri MAHBOOB PASHA S/O ABDUL MAJEED, MAJOR NO 130, 7 CROSS, SIDDARTHA NAGAR DR. T C M ROYAN RC)AD BANGALORE 13. Sri ANEES IRAHIM S/O LATE MOHAMMED ANWAR MAJOR NO 8, QUADIAJA MANZIL MADAR SAB LANE, NALF3ANDWAD BANGALORE 53 14. Smt ROQUIA BEGUM W/O ANEES Ii3RAHIM MAJOR, NO 8, QUADIAJA MANZIL MADAR SALI LANE, NALBANDWADI BANGALORE 53 15. Sri ZULFIQAR AHMEI) SUMEER S/O SADIQ JAFFER, MAJOR NO 8. QUADIAJA MANZIL MADAR SAB LANE, NALBANDWADI BANGALORE 53 (D(:py RFANO.1106/05 9 16. SMT A NAGINA SHAHEEN W/O AHEMD SUMEER MAJOR NO 8, QUADIAJA MANZILMADAR SAB LANE, NALBANDWADI BANGALORE 53 17. Sri MOHAMMED HAYATH S/0 LATE ABDUL KAREEM MAJOR, NO 40, NEW BAGLUR LAYOUT LINGARAJAPURAM BANGALORE 5 18. Sri MOHAMMED NASIR 5/0 LATE SHAIK IBRAHIM MAJOR, 8/1, MADAR SAB LANE NALBANDWADI, BANGALORE 53 19. Sri SHAMER PASHA 5/0 LATE MOHAMMED TAWAKKAL SAH MAJOR, NO 193, 1 CROSS SIDDARTHANAGAR DR T C M ROYAN ROAD, BANGALORE-6 20. Sri AFTAB AHMED S/O MOHAMMED DASTAGIR MAJOR, NO 1, 1 FLOOR, 3 CROSS MUBARAK MOHALLA JC NAGAR, BANGALORE 6 21, Sri MOHAMMED RAFEEQ S/O ABDUL RAVEES MAJOR, NO 14, 4 CROSS,OLD PENSION COPY ‘i.sIrt. f? strar ‘B ( Or” . RFA NO.1106/OS 10 MOHALLA, MYSORE ROAD BANGALORE 18 22. Sri KHASIMKHAN S/C JAFFER KHAN MAJOR, NO 127/1, ITTEGE ANJANAPPA LANE, OLD PENSION MOHALLA BANGALORE 18 23. SriASIFPASHA S/C GHOUSE PEER, MAJOR NO 152, OLD PENSION MOHALLA BANGALORE 18 24. Sri KHADER PASHA 5/0 ABDUL RAHMAN MAJOR, NO 22, 4 CROSS, OLD PENSION MOHALLA BANGALORE 18 25. Sri ABDUL KHADER S/C ABDUL BASHEER MAJoR NO 40, ITTEGE ANJANAPPA LANE,OLD PENSIONMOHALLA BANGALORE- 18 26, Sri AHMEI) KHAN 5/0 SALMAN KHAN MAJOR NO 18, 6 CROSS, ANJANAPPA GARDEN BANGALORE 18 27, Sri ABDUL RAHMAN HA S/C KUNJALI H MAJOR, NO 22, 4 CROSS, MYSORE ROAD LaLb o , , 500 si RFANO.1106/05 11 OLD PENSION MOHALLA BANGALORE- 18 28. Sri IMRAN SHARIFF S/0 SUBHAN SHARIFF MAJOR, NO 45, 4 CROSS SID DARTHANAGAR BANGALORE 53 29. Sri RAHMAN SHARIFF S/O AHMD SHARIFF MAJOR, NO 10, 4 CROSS OLD PENSION MOHALLA MYSORE ROAD BANGALORE 18 30. Sri SYED ILAYAS S/O LATE YOSUFF NO 58, 5 MAIN, K M COLONY SIDDAPUR,JAYANAGAR 1 BLOCK BANGALORE 11 31. SriALTKOYAPK S/0 LATE P K AHMED MAJOR, NO 13/21-1(113), 1 CROSS 2 MAIN, VALMIKINAGAR BANGALORE 267 32. Sri GHOUSE KHAN S/O LATE ANWAR KEIAN MAJOR NO 27/1, 8 CROSS, 2 MAIN VALMIKINAGA BANGALORE 26 SSSta:j ReEstrar iicr. of I RFA NO.1106/OS 12 33. Sri MOHAMMED IQBAL PASHA MAJOR, NO 34, RANGANNA LANE JOLLY MOHALLA NEAR BASITH SARAI BANGALORE 53 34. Sri MAHBOOB SHARIFF S/O LAT6 ABDUL RAHMAN MAJOR, NO 45, 4 CROSS, SID DARTHANAGAR BANGALORE 53 35. Sri M A RIAZ AHMED S/O MOHAMMED AMEER MAJOR, NO 7/1, 5 CROSS 1 MAiN, VALMIKINAGAR, MYSORE ROAD BANGALORE 26 36. Sri KHALEELULLA S/O.SYED SAHIB MAJOR, NO.57, 2ND CROSS SID DARTHANAGAR DR.T.C.M.ROYAN ROAD BANGALORE-560 053 37. Smt NASEMA H D/O.MOHAMED HUSSAIN MAJOR, NO.39, MAKAN ROAD BANGALORE-0 1 38. SriKHADERKHAN S/O.LATE TIPPUT KHAN MAJOR, NO.7, 7TH CROSS CHELVADIPALYA DR.T.C.M.ROYAN ROAD BANGALORE-560053 COpy ( RFANOJ1O6/05 13 39. Sri FAROOQ S M S/O.MOHAMMED SHAFIULLA WAHEED NO.121, 5TH CROSS, OLD PENSION MOHALLA, MYSORE ROAD BANGALORE-5600 18 40. Sri SUBHAN SHARIFF MAJOR, NO.45, 4TH CROSS SIDDARTHANAGAR DR.T.C.M.ROYAN ROAD BANGALORE-560 018 41. Smt A RAFIA SHAHEN W/O.TALAT MEHAMOOD NO.8, QUADIAJA MANZIL MADARSAB LANE NALBANDWADI, BANGALORE-560053 42, STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION M.S,BUILDING BANGALORE- 560001 43. SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT REVENUE DEPARTMENT M.S.BUILDING BANGALO RE-U 1 44. Sri SHEIK AHMED 5/0 SHEIK MASTHAN AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS NO.8/i, LALBAGH FORT ROAD — COPY Ct n’a R!1stra of ict.mtica Fnoe - dO RFA NO.1106/05 DODDAMAVALLI BANGALORE-4 14 RESPONDENTS (By Sri. KUMAR & KUMAR, ADVOCATES FOR Ri) RFA FILED U/S 96 CPC AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED:19,3.2005 PASSED IN OS.NO. 2024,’2000 ON THE FILE OFTHE XXIV ADDL.CITY CIVIL JUDGE, BANGALORE, (CCH,NO.6), DISMISSING THE SUIT FOR DECLARATION AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION. This Regular First Appeal is coning on for orders this day, the Court made the following: ORDER Needful to be done within 2 days, failing which the appeal shall stand dismissed without reference to the bench. Sd/ - JUDGE T B: SL RBy: cCBv: 1 iJ copy AS,sipn: Hh p4