XI-HC-22 sn^i^i R-ii?b 311^51 sib^li**' ^lf^I (W TS? -4Wlcl<<, {STlly<l<S, ('K'lltiy 3TT5?T "q^; (^.ft-^o. |\-73/A-o°'1- """"""""""""""""H^, 2oa *11*ICTI 'SnfKt) ft^g" 3II^[:TOIIW ^fet I Uapn Yactay, aged abQut^42 yesTS, son ot ^- sH A§1 l&t.hur. ((-"R 2. Ds^blu* ali&s Shiv KuBiai', aged about 24 Ag Ra '.Ui|T) Vs Ut^.te ot Uiinattisgarli, St; sentetn.ee yiTi-i KaKesli Ha&u, Advl cifln Neera') Melita, fan\ 2. 'I'fiis cnmiiial appeal conviction ancl orcler ot 4^i4/.i!uoi wliereby uie afl yections 3/ti('4tgj reacl witli| yecUou 34 ot l.F.L;. anci Uiey iu. years wim tme ot Ks. 1,| turmer uiidergo K.l. tor.six Ks. i,UUU/-, ui cletaiut. ot pa^ BoUi tne sentences nave 'oeeil 4>I^Id4l-l ^W?^"^ fs^ <Pq+$l< ^ sipgq ail^t „$;'^ * Rci^>/;i^i11 Voj-ii ^i<^(-'1-i-na •t'-a/-^-n - icuituxist, K/O viuage Maiiuaana, y.'s i.nnr /Ta-ET^i1- R^-mTir" s^i<atnr^f ?*Si i rlcn i-i a us, sou ui. Slin liiuuiais. lauav, acultunst, K/o viuage' MaJiuctanct, H.y. 'T'aTl'ail Raimir D"'<afmr*t Sn-t'fyma &"J" rouce tion- RainuT'. Distt, S7_iTcn_n0_ iCG\ "y-i" -—7— —:- - -- -— o ~~u -~ \ ~ ~ ' Dcate tor tjie appeUailts. •l Laiwer tor Uie Ktate, is clu-ectect agaiiist TJie juclgriient ot ace clatect ^U-y-^UU'^ passecl m. M.'l'. No, !peUailts nave Deen convictecE unaer Hection .34 aiicl Kection 4£>U reacl witEt Jaave been sentencecl to lUiclergo K.l. tor (JUU/-, ui aetault ol payinent ot inie to ituonUis aiia K.l. tor / years wiUi tuie ot ttneilt ot luie to unaergo K.I. six monUis. clu-ectect to nin conciuTenUv. '!7P-S VUB XLQnossojd 3in 10 piieqsiiT.T sinisrtrei iBtn piino-iS sin. ao uoTiBoirdim SSTBI pire ISTIIEgB glTLTE3ddl3 SaOlIBlSUinOJTO 3111 U3I1 PTR UOI103R JSPim P3PJE033.I SBA\ pasnoo^ 'Hoq.no3sojcl 3in.Ad psiimFBxa SJSAV •jnd^STl TBTOIPnP 10 •UnO;-) 3in UI SttOSJ3(,l P3SI] 133ITS 3SjBlTO 'UOQBSrtSSATH Suil3TdlII03 JS'l OII.TI nsiTBi ai3Ai JOIOOP am 2';q uajEcla-id osp3 3-13M xuiiioasojd prre snosLiad pasn.1 •Q-rl •xrf 10 uodaj miAl SABg PUB J;3IT pd TIB.TT-J. •j.c', 3J3IT-U. jndTB>l 'a.qiisri UITBSH rB3Ip3UI .101 1Q3S SBA XI.IinOSSOjd ^ •T-rl 'xa apiA noou: cn-?-;T inoqis IB T nl -<q upgpoT SBAI wapTOiti ain 10 "uoclsj au. SBM lllqBQ J3A3AVOIT 'lTiaPptTI JO 30BTCt Asve), upsa 'ssnoiT -nsm laojl 3TaB3 . jaiT HOCln3J3ITA\ XS.TBTe 03STBJ PITB 3pISB •J3TT in.U'. 3dKI PSUTItmiOO PIT8 3ST101T .I3:lt SBTTB myvn imsffaddB 3111 ja-EiBa-iatT.;: PIIB pnnojS 3Tjl lio 4.00 stn. iiioji iiAVop j; '3SIIOIT J3IT TH P3J31I!3 7iBpBA UPBH ICTBTll IB TnnF'.-nT-Tp ao pnqo jati miM siaoiT psgB xuinsssojd azn.-lBin si 'ISQQI at '1 SVTB'S'B 4.10d3i 13 psSpoi ve-n UpBR toasoouai p3pB3Td F.TIB uiair.i ][3p Asm T.TOIUAV m •n •H •j.ri 10 3ZJ1 10 11I3T[I31B1S J3ITB3J3in sasstmi-u. fcT 'TBUI gnuiici - .'fe tclBTV 'SSBTH ISJI.4 Sl'eJlSlgBIA; LOOB 3IT1 IS'dTBgB PSTtI S'BAX tv '7^-rS 'x'3 apiA uoissassod sfepiTS 'aoisssssod oiai 'a.ayrsi |»OB 3111 10 ST3JBdete glTLIB3,'V\ s'1 li^lls hB:jte J^ >l?tl»]> p-S) (, phlh l.|bl.l)h>ltb B3X3 (fe •A'V'ri) TJBABgfelia lAl.ranTtfTno") 01 aonBlTnirexa Ism 'lIOnBSllSSAin SHUTlfI h?'-Tt-T TIO XHlUOSSOjd 3in •ClGtrS A.I330jg'.IB3a:lTTgllB3 3TH; inojr 3311 OJ PSgBCTBICE' krei-iit-.isinBr 'MBT-in-.tsmota InjqBn psirsnd 'sus 33A3MOt-i TXC P3J31TT3 OSTB JEniri^TBiqR tnouotr 2str psqqai ^ciiaioi ilT llTSltOJC! 'J3I.T pai3MOcLt3Ao [3ddB nstTA\...' •ra'cl"["[ iTtoaB JJ3TJ TEI gind.asrs SBA s.teaA 17. lI<|)W103SCO;d 3tn IP 3SBO 'F. uyft>eiii»s;i»y» 1 1 ^ ^; ..fiSAy........................;. flOE 1.1t ^^^^^ ^^ __^^^^ ^ttelhtB lUMh -cocTr/^Vt'0^^."^ ' tOkh 1^1 ^H.Il.XsJ •ai.H.^e 'hMMh- te£- uajfr ifcihus 1^'lte tfcK.b] U&l^UE ZZ-3H-IX XI-HC-22 ail^rwi Ci-W'h iffl^f ?n*iicfi yf?a •..•^.•.^J"Vi 'S^t •^M\V\tt, ®ti1'y'IG.[q<'lltf'i< 31T^?T TRf^? ^-,ft.i4o.l\-73/o2- "'H^ 200 3:.^ *ii«iwrai*iicft isFe^f 3n^i;TOiiwSfer Decause ot tliis aiuaiosi , IK aelence;ot tlie appeUant.UeD. and becaiise :ol laacl relatea Hdivever, the leanied ttlal appeyauts as nienUonect at;c o.; Leanied coiinsel lor tj' ot< tiie s'tatemeut 6t tiie prc matenaj,,miproveiiient ui lie| .t-'.I.K. as alsQ.fl.er aian' stat< aainitted Uiatslie did not aainitteu t&e; suggesuou Ui^ caugllt lier, Xiowever s&e p1 Ironi 'Uiere. L)r; Kirau prosecutnx liowever no ;HI.]UI tlie prosecutrix aaa stie li^ i^pe. itwas rurUier contenclf ot tiie pi-Qsecutnx as is; eviq i,t^.W. O] wlio lias adinitteq wliereas DaBl-a is nepliew, reeordecl aiicl tie deposeu bef lias Deen aclmittect Oy U-iis w^ b. Un Ule otlier liancl, appearuig lor Uie ytate lias <M<<^<fln ^i+t<nT'^f^l<fl <F»T^TC i? 3Tf:OT aii^r lias &een lalsely.uuplicatecl w&ereas me |Ev tu aiias islimcuniar is ttiat he is tanocenf ;E [dispute, ne tias t>een tatsely miplicatecl. y -;ourt llas Gon"3ctea ana seirtencecl me ~ Re, , ' : s J|ie appellants subniits .uiax Iroia perusal ;; ISCCUQTX, it is clear ttiat sne fias niacle ,'. ic|r statem.ent. ytie' is coutiailictecl E>y Uie •:' ptnent. In para '23 ol stateinent, s&e Uas ; •e UaDlu enteruig ui lier noiae. yiie lias ; tt atter Uablu eaterecl ui lier tioiiie, ne ^. l.istied Iinn asid.e anct t&ereatter iie tlecl ; ti|ia]gavn (P.W. 4) tias examined t&e r y lias tieeu touiict on Uie pnvate parts ot.; not giyen^ aay detuiite opinion a&out v ;tt UT.ai uie accusect persons are relanves ; snt Irom ttie stateinent ot Kisinatiya Bai ^ Uiat tjacln. is iier Uamaa ui relauon |Uiary slatement^ot Kam. yuigti was not^ :ore ttie Court tor me first tune. 'i tiis tact ^ tness wiio tias been examuiect as l-'.W. 7. K Hlii-i Melita, learoect t^aiiel Lawyer; upported .tlie im.pugned judginent. ;; !w*: ;nmauuiitsMi XI-HC-22 SII^IWT R(-<i?b 311^1 sft*ireft yfe^ ^: ,:.l -3^ -'ll'illcltl. tS^'l'y4!^. («<C1W1< 3TI^?T 1^RK ,...&:...l6.^..^;£_''7^/ z- """""""""^. 200 tlWCTI i»l*<lt) ft^^r sii^il^nw 'd^r /. : (JOnvictton ot tiie apfl prosecutnx {f.W. ij wtiictl| Kismaoyabai t^.W.^b), KaiEf q tMe statement ot ur. KjraEi ij statecl ui lier Stateinent tliatl Ger two; inuior cliiiaren :wei-^ HaUn Yadav •woKe: &er up, cosiraitted rape by lyuig ner baagles were also DroKen m naad. Atter coinnutting rapi caoie Euici lie; aiso, tnecl' to I eonctition, Uieretore slie couli Iroia Uiere, 'I'lierealter. slie al< Uiereatter slie raised alarm. /I law aiia nusbaiict rusiied uie me snop ot yarasucl. yiie tne| lier aiicl uiereatter tlie reportl crQSS-examuiation ^stie lias coinmittecl rape wit& lier. g liieetmgjwas corryened. tp tai statemeBt, sne lias aauiittecl lier liouse iiowever on uie sd Ua'olu at Uie time lie entered! ttie suggestton ttiat uaDlu ent .pp|eUaats ^IA<T<Tl41?l *iw<nf'^ fs^ •<,Rnt$i< i?3lPm 311^1 p|eUaats is Gased on stateinents ot uie is CQn-oDoratecl by Uie stateinent ot fmgn (P.W. 7), Sllklidev (P.W. 8) as also [tiaigavan [V.W. 4], Ttie prosecutnx tias Ipn ttie date ot mcideiit, sGe along witii sleeptag ui tier tiom.e wtien accused. GrougJit tier aown troin me cot aad pn me grouud ancl tom lier blouse. Mer tpe saicl uicident. :He gaggea lier wiUi tus )t lie went awav. aacl uiereatter uaDlu jot) lier lionoiu'. Me was in a clrarLKen (1 pusfi tuin asicte. UaKlu sTarterl tleem.s fng witii lier mot&er-ui-law ctiased. nmi, litter lieanmg Jier snouts, lier nioUier-ui- |re aact.acciised UaDlu was caugJit near (l to Deat liim liowever, vUlagers stopped |was lodged: ul ttte potice station. In her IstucK to Jier claun ttiat tiacti-i Yaclay |lie iias aeniett tlie suggestion Uiat a pely unplicate. tiacln. ln para 2'd ot lier Itliat sne clicl not see UaDlu entenng in frl&e Dreatli, slie &as saicl mat slie saw Imtne iiouse. Hlie Jias mrttier actiuitted. (erecl uito ttie tiouse an.ci cauglit lier aacl fTTh:? XI-HC-22 aii^raii W^ sn^v ?t)*iicn ^fer '3^^ira]?R, ®Til<i*ii».ftcti'My __...&c.^,.ri°,.;.II73^&0^- --—"...^200 IIHCTI a»*<161) ft^g' 3ii^i;TCnwnfo tnetl to rob tier liouoTir liowe'v ue tlecl trom. ttiere. ; ». , .,^'.W,..f3,KistiBiatixa.Kai lias; statea Uiat sJie Aeax appeUaiits are; roD timg lier. ovs mere &owever; Uadn .was no Dablu roas..cau£ht;near^Uie cla-tigliter-in-law tiad slapped 7 Rainsia.gh, husbaad ofthe stated tiiat on uie aate ol ni' K.is.tuB.aUya Bai-aiitl Muniiic| ua&lu aiias StuvKUBiar alsdi &eating . Uablu cliarguis biin MonaiB.uiau SEUD.SUI Haq [P.w| caine to tus snop ancl startecl| saicl tGat slie startecl Beatuti witness tias Been cteciaTed li| Uie proseciltion ajicl coiitront| He fi.as cteniea liaving given si y. ; ''t'lius trom. uie statemf Kisniuatiya oai ana yuKfiae^ corroborated. T'he version coiToboratea Dy ttte version cfl exaitiuiecl lier anct lias tounai <*i<-iT<n<iii *ii*icff'^ fel<il <.f^t^.f< irsriwi.sn^i ;r slie: pustied nuTi'asiGle ao.a tliereatter <s luottier-ui-iaw ot t&e prosecutnx. yiie jie sliouts ol' ftie prosecuu-ix that the toer.. Atter.liearuig tier sliouts, slie went ); mere au.cl Uatily was nuirmig away. (sliop ot samsul'aad at tiiat Time lier lUablu. Kmular is tne stateiiient ot r.w. prosecutnx. H.W. H Kufcticlev Iias also ;ident at aDout I'^.UU ,m t&e midnignt, ;vi canie to liis tiouse, Knor to ttus, came uiere. '1'n.e prosecutnx startecl TJiat lie lias rob&ed &er tionour. |. yj lias also statecl tfi.at Uie prosecutnx beatm.g accused Dablu however he has because lie liad aDusecl lier. itus ttstlle aiicl lias Deen Gross-examiaecl Dv ^clwiui his diaiy statem.ent ofEx. P-10. licll stateHient. ' ; tnt ot uie at>ove witnesses, Kaiusuigli, I, Uie version ot uie prosecunix is auly ot Uie prosecutiix lias atso oeen Ur. Kiias. Bliaigavan (F.W. 4) wno nas aDraslon over bacK, lelt l].ancl aaa ngM •^ I- f% XI-HC-22 an^rsir: R;-(i+ 311^1 ?h<iN?"<af?(T •3^ -i|l<|]<yl<l; aniwis. I'lciKiy 3TT^?T 'IRRR Hltl^l^HI'^'^^ 200 [ci<i<l!sr"""""""""'"'""""" 3ii^[;TOiro^fe liaiiel. 'l'&e tnaJf (Jourt.relving wllicll is con'oBoi^.tecl Kv ;ttie Gv ineclical evldence ana t'arUi^i • tJiat.tlie prosecuuon lias e^taG &eyoncl reasorfaDle clouOt, Ulf creciibUiTv :ot tlie versioa 'ot U ttieu- cross-exaduiation aad a<| appeilaiits as raentiouea aDove|. 1U. In ttie CQnsicLerecl opuuo) court is ;Dasea on Uie eviuei coiiliclence. II. . ia ttie icsiUt, Gie appeai) &e ctismissecl aiict it is accorctul p.pon tne stateinent ot uie prosecuu-ix Eitateinent ol ottier witaesses aa.ct also ]r con-oDoratect Iroia t&e ]-'.!.K. lias Qelcl (isJiecl tiie oltence. agamst t&e appeuaiit :^ detence lias tailecl to mipeacli me ie proseciitnx ancl otlier witiiesses ui I'corcluigly convicted aacl sentenced TJie |a ol t&is court, tlie luiduig 01 tlie tnal ice ot tlie prosecutnx- wmcli uispu'es °hllfi'l41-l ^FRff 4 fezt <Fn«(K ^siPaH.an^T Oeuig, cievoiu ot su&stance, is IiaGle to gly disD.iissen. • Sd/- DHIRENDRA MISHRA Judge t •^- 1 9 y