XI-HC—78 ^ 7^51 ^l^ll^^ ^Tfl+f'IS, )s|(«»l«y W^v\\ *NI*^....^..^M^... WI. 200 an^r iraq? (1i?f^i??T) 3TI^T W R-fi.=h j W Sff^l Sti*11«ti t^IIW ^lfW OT^T ^T'R^I^'I t|TR^f ^f^zt <Pnt$« ^siRnsn^r f"«.ifca<«. IN THB HIOH COURT 0»JUbICATIXRB AT BIL^APUR (C.G.) MJLNO 316/2004 AtpeUant P^snrer) The National Insurance Co. Ltd., Through its Braach Mans^er, National Insurance Co. Ltd. Bflaspur (Clihattisgarh) VER3US R^sspadeats 5.4.2007 Shri Saajay "j8./t appellant/lnsuiance Coiapanj Heard on admissioit. Kaushal Prasad Sharma, S/o Shri Dmbandhu Shaniia, Near Kishaa Rice MiB, GAryabandh, DMtt. Raipur, (Chhattisgarh) Vishnu Rain Dhru, S/o Shri FayiD. Ram Dhru, Rcsidcnt of ViB^e Post. Ravan Bhatta, Gariyabaudh, Distt. Raipur (Chliattisgarh) ^rawal, couasel for the This appeal tiy the ap^|ellan.t-Insiirer is dirccted against the award dated 10th Decetnb^r 2003 passal iu Claim Casc No. 117 of 2002 whereby learB|ed claims Tribunal passed ffae impzigaed awaid wifhout c^nsidcriag fhc objection of the Insurauce Couipany that vehjck in question was being driven •^ XI-HC—7S 3^q- rf||<<|<>)A|, »TT|^'|IS, Rlciil+iy ^Wv\{ *NI=h •^ 200 an^?r 'vsv (ipig^w) SII^I^EI R'ti* I W SVW StlHW -*;:- t < ^. ^aTW ^fer 311^1 ^^y 4ti<ift'f;Eiiri TTpraf Tf,'fe[st <r^-^i< ^; STfilH SII^r by a person who had no validjaad effectivc driving Ucence and that at fhe tim.e ofaceident yujee passeagers were ridiug on the inotor cycle which was involve<|i iii thc accident. Froin perusal of paragjaphs 8 & 9 of the iiapugned award by which the above objections have been adjiidlcated it appeais that the leamcd Tribi|mal negated fhe above objection of thje InsuTance Conapaay ^y recordmg a finding that the above facts Iiave aot beea evidence. The above findiag y evidcnce and the same does nc lu the result, fhe appe| liable to be dismissed aad is estabUshed by fcadiug cogent based oa proper appreciatiou of t caU for iaterfcrence. ^l bein^ devoid of substauce is htrebv disinissed. Sd/- _„„.; OHIRENDRA Ml&tl*ulj Judge-—- ^w.^ ^' Het V\^ ••-"k