i^: &^ f fflJ'ilsfeliiE^ciQTOtn'QFaiffl^mssASHATSuASFK Writt3ettti6:a(S)No.^2^^010 , : : ,! .fcri'rIONHiR : , 10huvanLalJoShi,g/oShn:TulsiRariit •Joshi, aged about 42 years, Caste - Meher {Scl-teduleci Caste), ,Qccupati6n-Agrieulturisf, R/oyjllage- Patharra, Post- Jfyvra, Tahsll - BGtttetera, _ :" ,; . DiStrict-DurgfC.G.). . Versus- ;' : : : ' '• IBNTS : 1'^State 6f Chhattisgarh, ; ,., 1 ,,/:,; Through fbe Secretary,•SehedyleiCaste arid ScheduleTribe Deyeloprfaent D^attmen^ ,^ lyiantralaya, D. K. S. Bhaw&n, Raipur (C.G.) " • ^ ; • . ; 2. <'Spb Divisional Offitier (Revenue), : ' ;. j3emetera.,,DtstFief-'Durg(C.G:} , • :,' •;:;, ;3.;';TahsiIc:{ar^ nietgra,.': ''; I:. ' •' • .-•:": .:.';'^i "g..,::;:;'I3isJ:rlct-.Eii;irglpS.i3.:} » 'Msy:^ '^iiSSi "SSii^ ;.:^ 1^ 'liiiis I.Sr<9''B;W,is: ?s?^ »i8U^.SM8MM8B8fiii Uffi8NisMffiffi®:.!i^^^ .^ll'l::^: ;:ii: REtltlONEK RESPONDENTS H|i@ffiWVBB^(SHBAWlS<3<SRH;:;Bil-ASEIUR -^,%Wl^iBETIII@Na©£Ni^5'M5]-©F!^2<l1.0'< .Bliuvan.balJoishi 'Versys .•.:::',,:•.,:•,;.' StateoffGhhattisgarh&Qthers (Wnt^etition unaE!r^ iGle228iaflHe^n^itii:ion Sing|gE^nGtT:Hon'Ble'Sl^iSatis^^ Preseht:- Sliri K.K. SingR, Adv6(»tefbFfhep^itiOT v ShnShiashiankThala.H'.PeinelLawyerfGrtheState. ORDERfORAL) (Passed bnthis28thday of October, 2010) 1) MeardleamieclGOunselfortlieparties. 2) ' ByWis petitiontthe.p®titioTierseekSitoquash^thern<3tifjGati 31 August, 2009 (Annexure P/^ whereby the Sta^ has declined to declare the members of Mahar, Meher and Mehra communifyas scheduled caste on acx;ourit (rf is pending consiaeration B^r& the Gevernment of Ihdia. TKe^ certificates granted t6 fhe persons treating ftie Mahar, Meher and Mehra as Scheduled Gaste would npt be considered By ttte High Pbwer Ca^eSeri^iriyCommittee(fbrshort"(heGomrnittee'')beyond March,2010. 3) Case oftHe p6titi6ner, in shcirt, isthatthe petitibnerbelongSt&caste Meher, wKich cornes under the categoiyof SGhedul®Caste. By notificationdated 31-08-2009 (AnnexureF73)iSSuedbytheState, there is a ban on issuing the GastS eertificate^to belonging to Mahar, Meher ahd MgMra caste. The (^ildren 6f ^ petitioner applied 'for grarit Of caste Certificate on 06-06-2009 and 29-C|8-2Q09 forthepurp6s©bfGoveFnFnent:emplOyment,buttjir tHesarneha5notbeeriissued.Thus,ithispetitJQn. : y.v1^^ ^• - ::" • l^i .1: :1 '.S (1-1 4) SMn®ingh,leariT^-GoiLtnsel aippearins.forthe^^p^ in abs^oe ctf^perrTianentyGa^' certifi ddmicilet»i1ifiGat^tl ^hildl^nofthep^iti6nercaririG)tap^ post under 'thie eategory;;of Scltedule ©aste aniEl, as syeh, the chiiareft t F^tionsP are^ bsing dgRriveB^^^ Govemme^ ENlefits. "TTTB a^ auth&rities is inegal, arBitrary and agairistthe well setUed pnnc^ of law. THus, the respondent authorities rriay be directed to issue thepermaHeritGasteGeftificateto-thechiIcftenoffhepetition 5)^ In Bsalh/safra Baba SafteB SG^/^ © CHhatti^arh &^h^rWea^ Witti report.sent lo th& DirectOr, S.C.D. (R.L, eell), Qovernment of Inaia, Mirnstry o^SoGialJustice^a^ -NewDeltiii^detsrWiin^lhe^ ; ^^beforeWiisiGoUFt^^i&^GtiUtt'deBli^ groul^ thatWiSsis f6rtM& Presideht (^ India to s^ rac^ ortribes cr parts <^ or group^ ^^^^^ ^ schedylea (^stes itt relatjoh tQ tt^State o consult^iBn with Ihe ©ovembr,in exercis& 6f R^ 341 of'theGonstitutiQiToflnclia. ; 'l 6) Thjs is also a ease whe in fl'fere i^a \ ird 'Mahar, Meher^nd^ F^idential ntMification. ^ • ^giveiTTniT^nt 6f India^^^^^^ ^ petiticMCT W IsiBove the^^^^ ease ; t|"iej crpetitioirer't^^l©orHrEiittee^afN'^MaiFe^^ • ^c(ue^i8 cff:!iftfHng^meiW anp:'legal^^^^ 1V\ff^(e)'No.84(^-df2009=(deciaBa®ni1l5-g-28't:l:J); s 111 '..^^~ ^^ l iiES!ffff: JIBI ws\ ms ;mil . ;:i ;:K'!,sa'a;iBa. •tS 9% ^essiM li!*£a»»'" li;:Arun/ ©owri 7) petitioner CThe^itioneriougbts^have sQugKf,^ castel^rtifieate^muGh befoi^^M&atSov^tK)fific8 n(^ Sinee thesis^e is^uGh, *hric;h Gaffi'be^ Governmgllt of India alene, 1 d6 not fiRH a impu§ri^^t:ftifiGsiti^yatedE31-9-2(}Og. y lrithieresult,tHewritpetitiQn,b®ji^;ber^Gfwi®rifiis^^ is hereby disrnissed. Sd/- SatishK.Agnihotri Judge