1 wp3218-10 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY APPELLATE SIDE, BENCH AT AURANGABAD WRIT PETITION NO. 3218 OF 2010 1] Mahendra Vishram Khadse and others .. Petitioner Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri M.M.Mahajan,Adv. for Respondent no.4. ... WRIT PETITION NO.547/2009 1] Subhash Girjaba Palhal and others .. Petitioner Vs 1] The State of Maha & Ors. .. Respondents. ... Shri S.J.Gaike, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri S.B.Deshpande,Adv. for Respondent no.5 ... 2 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.874/2011 1] Balasaheb Ankush Musale and others .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri H.V.Patil and S.S.Londhe, Advs.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri H.K.Mundhe,Adv. for Respondent no.4. .... WRIT PETITION NO.995/2010 1] Gorakhnath Baliram Wagwad and others .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri B.N.Gadhegaonkar,Adv. for Respondent no.4. ... WRIT PETITION NO.1184/2010 1] Maharashtra Rajya Prathamik Shikshak Sangh .. Petitioner Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri S.B.Talekar, Adv.for petitioner. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. 3 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.1431/2010 1] Panjabrao Rajaram Deokar and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents .... Shri A.P.Bhandari, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri V.S.Panpatte,Adv. for Respondent nos.2 to 5. ... WRIT PETITION NO.1781/2010 1] Shamkant Kashinath Rule and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha and others. .. Respondents ... Shri V.S.Bholankar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri Vijay Sharma,Adv. for Respondent nos.2 & 3. ... WRIT PETITION NO.1871/2011 1] Kavita Ratan Bodade and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri Vijau Sharma,Adv. for Respondent no.3. ... 4 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.2782/2011 1] Sangameshwar Sudhakar Walakate and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri S.P.Urgunde, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... WRIT PETITION NO.2861/2010 1] Nilesh Shaligram Palkar and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri V.S.Bochare, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri S.R.Yadav,Adv.for Respondent no.4 Shri M.S.Mahajan & H.A.Joshi,Adv. for Respondent no.5. Shri U.B.Bondar,Adv.for R.6 Shri S.G.Sangle,Adv.for R.7. Shri S.N.Kendre & A.N.Nagargoje,Advs.for R.8. ... WRIT PETITION NO.2889/2011 1] Chandu Ganpat Bhure and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri S.P.Urgunde, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... 5 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.2944/2011 1] Ashabai Gulab Nagtilak and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri A.V.Patil Indrale & S.P.Dhobale, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... WRIT PETITION NO.3123/2010 1] Kiran Sudam Tarde and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar & A.A.Aute, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri S.T.Shelke,Adv. for Respondent no.4. ... WRIT PETITION NO.3184/2011 1] Jyoti Krushnaji Joshi @ Jyoti Pravin Rekhi and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri S.K.Shinde, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... 6 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.3294/2011 1] Vinod Babanrao Shendge and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri Sachin Joshi,Adv. for Respondent nos.4 & 5. Shri S.T.Shelke,Adv.for Respondent no.6 ... WRIT PETITION NO.3342/2011 1] Mahendra Sitaram Nikam and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... WRIT PETITION NO.3349/2010 1] Namdeo Kashinath Sonawane and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Dismissed for Respondent no.4. ... 7 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.3350/2010 1] Vinayak Bhunangrao Surwase and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Dismissed for Respondent no.4. ... WRIT PETITION NO.3453/2011 1] Nitin Eknath Dhamne and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... WRIT PETITION NO.3454/2011 1] Gajanan Madhusudan Muley and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri S.T.Shelke,Adv.for Respondents 7 to 10. Shri Vijay Sharma,Adv. for Respondent nos.11,13,14. ... 8 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.3701/2010 1] Yuvraj Vitthal Patil and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Ms.Surekha Mahajan, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... WRIT PETITION NO.3709/2010 1] Jitendra Dnyandeo Jadhav and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Ms.Surekha Mahajan, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... WRIT PETITION NO.3805/2010 1] Kailash Rajaram Patil and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Ms.Surekha Mahajan & Varsha B.Kapse, Advs.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... 9 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.3839/2010 1] Amol Vasant Dandale and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri Digambar B. Shinde, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... WRIT PETITION NO.4040/2010 1] Bhushan Dagdu Patil and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri M.S.Sonawane,Adv.for Respondents 4 & 6. ... WRIT PETITION NO.4161/2010 1] Sujitkumar Balbhimrao Gaikwad and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... 10 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.4329/2010 1] Sambhaji Ramkisan Raut and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Ms.Mahajan & H.A.Joshi,Advs.for Respondent.no.4 ... WRIT PETITION NO.4670/2011 1] Parmeshwar Laxmanrao Bhokare and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri D.G.Chewale, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... WRIT PETITION NO.4923/2011 1] Vijay Uttam Bhatane and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri A.P.Avhad, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... 11 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.4984/2010 1] Jayesh Damodhar Gaikwad and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri R.V.Gore, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... WRIT PETITION NO.5335/2011 1] Sanjay Murlidharrao Kulkarni and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... WRIT PETITION NO.5972/2010 1] Asaruddin Riyazuddin and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri M.S.SonawaneAdv.for Respondent no.4. ... 12 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.6214/2010 1] Rajesh Ramkrushna Kilche and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri A.P.Bhandari, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri B.N.Gadegaonkar,Adv.for Respondent nos.3,4,6,7,8. ... WRIT PETITION NO.6553/2010 1] Vrushali Sahebrao Patil .. Petitioner Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri A.P.Bhandari, Adv.for petitioner. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri P.S.Patil,Adv.for Respondent.No.3. ... WRIT PETITION NO.6759/2010 1] Kalpana Mahesh Deshpande .. Petitioner Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... S/Shri R.S.Shinde, U.A.Bhadgaonkar & D.B.Shinde, Adv.for petitioner. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Smt.M.A.Deshpande,Adv.for Respondents 4 & 5. ... 13 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.6760/2010 1] Asha Yashwant Thosare and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri D.B.Shinde, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... WRIT PETITION NO.6939/2010 1] Sangmeshwar Apparao Biradar and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri A.V.Indrale Patil, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... WRIT PETITION NO.7321/2011 1] Pramila Satyadeo Bhosale and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri S.P.Urgunde, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... 14 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.7322/2011 1] Manik Meghaji Gadekar and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri M.V.Ghatge, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri V.S.Pantatte,Adv.for Respondent. ... WRIT PETITION NO.8365/2009 1] Vinod Ramdas Arsul and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri K.G.Salunke,Adv.for Respondent no.4. ... WRIT PETITION NO.8369/2010 1] Archana Navneet Mahanor and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri R.V.Gore, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri M.S.Mahajan & H.A.Joshi,Adv.for Respondents 4, to 6. ... 15 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.8373/2010 1] Milind Subhash Vasave and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri R.S.Shinde, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... WRIT PETITION NO.9102/2010 1] Deepak Pralhad Patil and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri M.S.Sonawane,Adv.for Respondents 4 to 6. ... WRIT PETITION NO.9106/2010 1] Ravindra Dattatraya Choudhary and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri Vijay Sharma ,Adv.for Respondent no.2. Shri A.R.Salve,Adv. for Respondent no.5. ... 16 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.9425/2010 1] Apparao Sahebrao Hake and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.K.Kshirsagar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri D.N.Patil Bankar,Adv.for Respondents 20,22 to 24. Shri M.S.Mahajan & H.A.Joshi,Advs. for Respondent nos.3 to 30 ... WRIT PETITION NO.9429/2010 1] Deelip Shantaram Javare and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri H.V.Patil, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri M.S.Sonawane,Adv.for Respondent no.4 ... WRIT PETITION NO.10135/2010 1] Mohan Madhavrao Salunke and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri M.M.Nerlikar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... 17 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.10410/2010 1] Bharat Matthu Malik and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri Pravin S. Patil, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. ... WRIT PETITION NO.10485/2010 1] Sadashiv Bhanudas Shinde and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri G.V.Mohekar, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri V.D.Hon,Adv.for Respondent no.4. ... WRIT PETITION NO.10492/2010 1] Vinayak Jinta Gavit and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri Ram S. Shinde, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri Rahul Pawar,Adv.for Respondent. ... 18 wp3218-10 WRIT PETITION NO.11619/2010 1] Mangesh Bhaskar Tidke and others. .. Petitioners Vs 1] The State of Maha. and others. .. Respondents. ... Shri H.V.Patil, Adv.for petitioners. Shri K.J.Ghute Patil,A.G.P. for Respondent State. Shri M.S.Sonwane,Adv.for Respondent no.4. ... CORAM : NARESH H. PATIL & T.V.NALAWADE,J. DATE : 23/09/2011 ORAL ORDER : 1] Heard. Leave to correct the name of petitioner no.1 Pramila Satyadeo Bhasale in Writ Petition No.7321/2011 is granted. Amendment be carried out forthwith. 2] The common question which arises for consideration in these Writ Petitions is that the employees who were recruited on contract basis/honorarium basis prior to 1/11/2005 were entitled for benefits of regular pension or were covered by Defined Contributory Pension Scheme. Under Government Resolution issued on 31/10/2005, the 19 wp3218-10 pension scheme would be applicable from the date of regularisation of services of such of the employees who were appointed on contract/honorarium basis. 3] The learned counsels for petitioners submit that they are governed under the Government Resolution dated 19/7/2011 which is placed on record and marked “X” for identification. The learned counsels therefore, submit that the Petitions can be disposed of in the light of the Government Resolution dated 19/7/2011. Petitions are accordingly disposed of. [T.V.NALAWADE,J.] [NARESH H. PATIL,J.] umg/wp3218-10