HIGHISQURT C^ CHHATTI^jAim AT BILA8PIM 'WRlXPmiTIGaSl^No. ,5049 of200^ PE'rmoNER '^, : ^ag^ Sm^ Thateir SA»I^M.S.Thakui^ Agedab^ ^ 4^^^^3^ ofifiee of^ Jumcc Epgineei^ CNaattisgaA STate ^ov^r^ DistilB^^ Co/l^,,Bgapw BiiapuR.(C.O.)-.^..'-;...-.i " •.:— . ' .. :. ...^^ . —-.'1.-? ::l:ll"l ^StJSi- ;i,^ MSPQNDENTS : 1. CMiattisgarii State P(^Bol^ag Co. l.td.,Througk The ^I)^ 0®n^ I^.HeadQuart^Dan^uriya,Rai^(C^)^^^^^^^^^ ^ 2- ^slw Moid^Co.^lM.^^f^aas^ 3. Shn Rajiv I^a^ ^ €yS.E.B.X^u^ (C.G.) Now H.O.D. Eneigy Departa^tit C.G. Gov&mment, ':N@w'I)elM:(India),.,;..l,^T,1;1^ '^'..'•11'':ll-l::S''l/l,:r1,-:' 4. Shri Maaoj Dey, M^iber (I^^ (Rfitir^ CSEB ^ipuf ^^ Now^^^^^^ Niyaaiak Syo^^C.<3. GovenMaa^Ratpur(G.©<) ^ ^ - 5, Slm ^z^J^M^ C8EB,Ba^^.Q.>1^Advi^)T,<^S.^^^^ C(^I^MeadjQiar^I5a3E^n^ 6. Shrfc A.K.Tiwan Chi^^^^ B^^ Dis&itwti^Co.lN^ 7. IS^yKalish^ama^ Cu^^CSPEl^^ ©n.CS^DGL, Diu-g (IX^ ^. Shn^.ItBatKUl^ Execy^ PowerJ5istributionCol.I^Balod,^istt.D^ $; ShnPrit^!Sini,E^ ..BalodiII)istfciDwg<C^.)i-^.••»-1•,..<.:•.-1',.-- lO.Shni^w^ D^^ Pritam SAu, Ex MIA Vidhaa SaNia Kshetea No. 81 Ba}o^!)istt. ^ Divisional GffiEicCT fcdgirtion Departaaenit^ Admabad (Jhalmala)Tali,BatodDisttDurg^.G.) ll.N.^.HaneryExecutiveEngimer(0&M)^n.C.S.Power Disfributi^ Col. ,Llcl,^ Dai^^ S(M,rthBast@r(C.G.) - - 12.%|t.^Viai]^i^ |^ Et^ineer ^g.) C.S^ow^ Distributk^ Go. lAd. Jadalpw^^^^ Pres^itfy woricing ass E.E. C)fi^ pfltee CliiefEil^ne^ {Rajnandgaon Re^cxn) C.S. Power DistrilwrtioayCol. IM, Rajnmidga<^Distt.Rajnan^a<M^^ 13.Vimal Kumar Jain, MembCT (Retired) CSEB (CG) Execytiw Bigmeer^^O&M)IM C.S.Poww Co.Ltd,Dantewada,Distt.Dantewada(e.G)€ 14. V.K.Shrivastava Secfetaiy, C.S. Powet Hcddiig C^. IM. Head Quarter Dangaxiiya Raipw (C.G.) WRIT PETITION UNBER ARTICLfi 226/227 OF THE CONSTITUTIO^ OF INDIA 1:.... „: . ! '^l..::..'!'..:.,.": ..l t)l SB: Hffln'Ue Shri SattshK.AgnihotrtJ. Present: Shri C.R.Sahu, Advoeate ferthe petiEtioiier. Shri Y.S.Thakuff, Depu^r Adv< ate Geaeral fbr tiie respondotrt. ORDER^ORAL^ (Passed ori07t11 day of September, 2009) 1. By fhis petition, the petitioner unpugns Ifae transfer order dated 22 Ma^ 2007 (Annexure P/l) and fhe relievmg ordeij dated 25 May, 2007 (Amiexure P/2) whereby the petitioner has beentra^^ ground fhat the petitionCT has been transferred earher on 24th June, 2006 (Annexure P/3) J&om Deori to Balod. Thus^ Ais order eomes witNn tfa^ purvi^ offi^quenttransfer. 2. I^eamed coimsd appearmg fbr the petiti^^ fhe petitiotier faas approached tiiis Court m 2007 itself inW.P(S)No. 3602/2007. €hi06th July, 2009, the petitioner withdi^w the petition vritti liberty to make a represe^^ to the aufhorities concemed, thereaftCT, fhe pettdoner has approached 1he aufhorities coneemed. However, no action Kas been tafcen or any order has been passed on the said representation. 3. Be that as it may, the writpetition in^ on 22nd May, 2007 was filed earUer and the same was wtth<drawn; It appears tftatthe impygnedtransfCT aadrelievingordCTS might have alreadybeen coiiyiled with. 4. It is well-settledprmciple oflawthattansferis an mcidence of service and it is fbr the employer^ to where a particular officer/employee be posted, keepmg in view public interest as w^l as administratwe exigency. This Coi^t has limited jurisdiction to mterfere wifh the transfer matter and except m tiie cases ofproved malafide, non-competence ofaulhority pa^ing tie transfer order and not being in conformity with tiie mles and regulaMons. (See Kendriya VidyalayaSangathanv. DamoHdar Prasad Pandey& Other^). 5. Thereis no ehallengeto fhe impugned la-ansfer wder on the groundoflack of competence of fhe authority passing the order or breaeh of sEtatutory provisions or malafide. This is not a case where aiiy permissible grounds as stated above has been raised. 6. Thus, this petition being devoid ofmerit, is accordin^ly dismissed. Sd/- SatishK.Agnihotri Judge 1(2004)12SCC299