IN IHE mGH coum OF CHHAmSGARH AT BILAsrun _ I @wigéan Ewm WRIT APPEAL Naézc / 2010 (Arising ouf of order dated O1 %)201 O paisgiby learned Single Judge in Wrii Peiiiion (T) No. 5155 of 2009) ' In the matter of: APPELLANTS: i. M/s Anubhdv Bidi Leaves Traders, Through iis Proprieior Mohd. Refeeq, S/o Ldie Abdul Karim, Aged aboui 59 years, R/o Mahamaya Rood, Rasuipur, Ambikopur, Disirici — Sarguja ' Chhaiiisgarh M/s Shahin Traders, Through iis Proprieior Smi. Humairo Khoioon, W/o Shamshui Hasan, Aged aboui 55 years, R/o Mahamaya Road, Rasulpur, Ambikapur, Disirici — Sarguja Chhaiiisgarh M/s N.H. Bidi Company, Through iis Partner Anwarooi Hussain, S/o Nurui Hussain, Aged aboui 27 years, Mahamaya Road, Rasuipur, Ambikapur, Disiricr — Sarguja Chhah‘isgarh Virendra Singh, S/o Laie Rambadan Singh, Aged aboui 45 years, R/o Village MarchWar, P.O. Adhoura Nagar, Uian‘, Dislrici— Gharwa, Jharkhand VERSUS RES?ONDENTS Siaie of Chha’n‘isgorh, Through The Secrelary, Finance Department D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipur (C.G.) Chha’r’risgarh Siaie Minor Foresi Produce g (Trading & Developmeni) Cooperalive Federalion Lid., Through ils Managing v Direcior \ i A—25 VIP Eslale near VIP Club, Khamardih, Shanker Nager, Raipur Commissioner of Commercial Tax, Vikray Kar Bhawan, Civil Lines, Raipur (C.G.) W \ , " K104 éb/ o ' are?!m(W) Wm vi 200 mm wm mmm *mm I la 4.2011 ’ ‘ Shri Ravindra Shrivastava. Sr. Advocate. Shri' Anup Majumdar, Sh‘ri Ashish Shrivastava‘ Shri Naveen akash, Shri Anup Jain, Shri Harsh Wardhan, Shri Devendra Patel. Shri Rake h Ranjan Agrawal. Shri G.N. Purohit, Sr. Advocate, Shri AbhiShek Oswal, S ri Anand Dadariya, Shri Neelabh Dubey. Smt. 8mm Sharma Shri Pankaj Shriva tava Shri Parag Kotecha Shri Ajay Singh Shn Amy Mlshra Shri Ankit Sung al Shn BD Guru Shn HS Pate! Shn V Mlshra and Shn Dheeraj Kumar ankhede for the appenants m respective appeals. Shri A S Kach‘hawaha Dy dvocate Generélforthe State/respondent. Shn Ktshore Bhadun couns lforthe Federation Sd/- RN. W Common judgment has b en delivered m WANo 452/2010 (M/s KK Vyas & others Vs. State of Chham garh & others), Including this appeal Signed and dated Certlfed copy as per rules ong wrth mam Judgment x H WIV— ‘— / sdl— ’ W Dhirendl‘a Mishra Judge Judge mam Mu mm, {Remix Avg/147.2/zmo —1,oo,ooo. / "