EEGE €QEJ'R? {3W {SEEATTESSARH AT BEEA§§3¥IE HgN’BLE SHR‘i SATISH K AGNXHQTRL J. ‘WRIT ?ET§TE@N gS} Ng."2228 9'33 2%}? PETiTigNFR Eejia Rim: §$w 3/0 G‘R,Sahu§ aged bout 43 yearS, OccupationmAssismni gaahgg Govt, Middié SQhGQL Sg§baha1y BlosieBhzirsiva, Bistrict~ Raipur (CG) VER§i5 . Siam of Chhatiisgarha Throaghiias Secreiaiy: Edacaiiaiz dgpartmem; DKS, Bhawan. Raipur. Eism'ab Ragnar {CG} The Dir aim; ?u%1ic instructmm BKS Ehawaa, Raipuz, District- E£§§3ur (QG‘) LN RE S?€i)i\“ The Joim £2‘ector. Pubiic Em‘ii‘ugiiog‘ Raipur Divigien, Rama? / r RCJJ ‘Tfila DiSirict Egimaiioiz Qffmai; Bisirict—Raipur (CG) , BEOCk Eéucation Officar, Elgarsiva, Dismci’Raipur (C.G.} Ski Shixemfm Pagéya, Aévacaie fer the mti‘iianez‘. Sim Azvind Dubey, Pane} Lawyer for the Siam f wsymggms GREER (Passeci on m1 ofAprii, 2007) Leamac‘a couzlsd appearigg for tha mti‘iiOmf as WGE as for the Siate/rgspondenis jeimly $ubmit that tha fact and queStion, Qf law involvad in iha presan‘i writ pefcitim: are the samt; i0 ihat of i1} YashWam Kgmw Eharaéwaj 37$, Mamicipai Cerimmiian, a mg ami anirié‘gez' §2€)é}6 {E} {2%} §6§; whigh 1133 bag}: disgmsad of Vida ordar dated 03.042006, Learnad couiase} agapeariilg for ths msporidsnts éogx; 11G: cantmvai't iha $a§d submissima, 2, In subsgquem cases? L6” Wn't EDeii’iion (S‘) No.413G of 2005 {§Q§g§}g Kamm‘ El’gmzg V§. The Smfe Gwa 9f wghwgigggg'ia (W A {mtg {mafhgg‘} and 0mm cmnected maitexsg éacidad by :his Cour‘i 011 15%2—2006; wrwam 1:0 the; mama damd 28-1~1995§ iSSued by gm Semetarv Bamd 9f Sgcondary Educatioa Bhapal mad ihg pmspecmfa 0f Di131<3ma in Educgiim Examimiim, ii was: ciarifigd that 1m :aomencl,a:um (3f thg Basi§ 'fraimag iastétuta: Leg BTU. Ems bean chaaggd mad yauaméid a5 Dipiema in Eélucatioili 1a, DEd, Accorciinglv, ths DEd Certifmata helderS are £1139 Qovarad by mg desision, m Writ Paiitim (8,} NOAHO 0f 2065 (Gagagig Kiimm' Vegma vsa The Skate Govf. gf Chgmtgisgtzriz gged imagwf} (Supra), 3: Accordiggiv mg- Wrii paii‘iiaii is a130wcd in temas sf iha order paSSed i1“; ihe casa 9f Yashwam Kumzzy Eharaéwaj VS. Municiyatgi €mpmaii0n$ Burg and aiwtheg" (Supra), Sigbjag i0 variiiczgiml of ”gm fact as to wingihar t31e patitisneys haw acqtaimd Djid, Exammaiioza Ceriifacate an his own expanses aq par 11w Q§rcu1ar3 datad 24,12,199S and 9L03J999 Emd fmtlwr Whahar 11$ has 136m paid mg advaizca increment$ 0r 110$; NO ordaz‘ as to costs. Sdl- Satish K. Agnihotri Judge -./3 OJ? ’«u / / Amit