IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT : THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.N.RAVINDRAN TUESDAY, THE 1ST JUNE 2010 / 11TH JYAISTHA 1932 OP.No. 13199 of 2001(U) ----------------------------------- PETITIONER(S): ----------------------- 1. P.M. VIJAYAN, SON OF RAGHAVAN, PAREPPURAKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 2. KESAVAN A, EDAYAPURAKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O., ELAMDESAM (VIA.) 3. NARAYANAN M.K., MURIKKANANIKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O. 4. RAJAPPAN. K.A., KODIPLAKKAL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., KULAMAVU (VIA). 5. PARAMESWARAN, MUTHUPALAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O. 6. RAMAN V.K., VAZHAPPILLIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 7. KOMALAM RAVIKUMAR, KOCHUPURAKKAL VEEDU, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 8. RAMAKRISHNAN, PATHIKKAL, KOLAPLARAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 9. RADHAMANI VIJAYAN, KUPPIVAKKAL VEEDU, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 10. GOPALAN, MUTTATHIL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 11. P.R. NANU, PAYIPPATT, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 12. C.R. KANDA, CHELAPPLAKKAL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 13. K.K. PURUSHOTHAMAN, KUZHIPLAKKAL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 14. KOCHIRI, MUTTATHIL VEEDU, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. OP.No. 13199 of 2001(U) 15. C.K. UNNIKRISHNAN, CHATHURAMPLAKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 16. SHIBU. M.G., MEKKALLAYIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 17. SIVARAMAN. O.K., OLIYARAKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 18. RAGHAVAN, MURIKKAMANIKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 19. P.K. SASIMON, PAITHAKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA. 20. GOPI. O.S., OLIYARAKKAL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 21. GOPALAN. M.K., MURIKKAMANIKKAL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O., VELLIYAMATTOM. 22. BHASKARAN. K.K., KALLAMPLAKKAL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 23. PARAMESWARAN, CHEMBANPLAKKIL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 24. SOBHA GOPI, MUTTATHIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O., ELAM DESAM (VIA.). 25. EECHARAN, PAITHAKKAL VEEDU, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 26. PANKAJAKSHI. M.K., MATTEPLAKKAL VEEDU, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 27. M.R. KELA, MATTEPLAKKAL VEEDU, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 28. BINDHU. M.K., MATTEPLAKKAL VEEDU, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 29. M.R. SIVAN, MATTEPLAKKAL VEEDU, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 30. KRISHNAN. P.K., PAITHAKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 31. BHAVANI, KOCHUPARAMBIL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 32. RAJAPPAN, KOCHUPARAMBIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. OP.No. 13199 of 2001(U) 33. THANKAMMA, PUTHENPURAKKAL, KOLUPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 34. M.K. NANDANAN, MURIKKAMANIKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 35. SOBHANA, MUTHASSERIL, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., KULAMAVU (VIA), KOLAPRAM. 36. PRABHAKARAN. M.M., MUTHASSERIL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPULANGAD P.O., KULAMAVU VIA. 37. M.K. MADHAVAN, MURIKKANANIKKAL (H), DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 38. P.K. RAVEENDRAN, POTTAMPLAKKAL VEEDU, POOMALA, KOOVAKKANDAM P.O., KALAYANTHANI (VIA.) 39. ASOKAN. V.N., POTTAM PLAKKAL VEEDU, POOMALA, POOVAKKANDAM P.O., KALAYANTHANI (VIA). 40. MEENAKSHI NARAYANAN, POTTAMPLAKKAL VEEDU, POOMALA, KOORAKKANDAM P.O. 41. NARAYANAN, MADATHIL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 42. DIVAKARAN, KOZHIKKAT, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 43. KUTTAPPAN, POTHANPLAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 44. P. SUGESH, OZHAKKANAPPALLIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 45. P. RAJESH, OZHAKKANAPPALLIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 46. K.G. SUKUMARAN, KAKKARASSERIL VEEDU, KUVAKKANDAM P.O., POOMALA. 47. A.M. SUKUMARAN, ARAKKAL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 48. PARAMESWARAN, VALATHOTTIL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 49. KRISHNAN, PALAKKUNNEL VEEDU, KOLUPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. OP.No. 13199 of 2001(U) 50. RAJAN, KUBANKALLIL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 51. RAJAN, PALAKKUNNEN, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 52. C.M. MADANA RAJAN, CHOLLAMPLAKKAL, KOLAPRAM. 53. KUNJU KOCHU, KARAKKUNNEL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPALANGAD P.O. 54. GOPALAKRISHNAN A.M., ARAKKAL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 55. RUGMINI, PERUVAZHIKKAL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 56. THANKAPPAN, PERUVAZHIKKAL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 57. PRASANTH M.PRABHA, MUTHASSERIL (H), KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., KULAMAVU (VIA). 58. LEELA SIVARAMAN, PULIYAM MAKKAL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 59. BHASKARAN, PATHIKKAL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 60. BHASKARAN, VALATHOTTIL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 61. C.C. RAGHAVAN, CHAMAPPURAYIL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 62. NARAYANAN, PATHIKKAL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 63. KOUSALYA, MATTEPLAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O., KOLEPRAM. 64. SUBHASH, MATTEPLAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O., KOLAPRAM. 65. THANKAMMA, PUTHIYAPARAMBIL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 66. EECHARAN KANDA, POTTAMPLAKKAL VEEDU, POOMALA, KOOVAKKANDAM P.O. 67. THANKAMMA, THADATHIPLAKKAL VEEDU, KULAMAVU P.O., KOZHIPPILLIL. OP.No. 13199 of 2001(U) 68. GOPALAN, THADATHIPLAKKAL VEEDU, KULAMAVU P.O., KOZHIPPILLY. 69. SATHYAN, THAZHATHU KOLAPRATHU, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 70. KRISHNAN, NILAPPARAYIL VEEDU, POOMALA, KOOVAKKANDAM. 71. KRISHNAN, NILAPPARAYIL VEEDU, POOMALA, KOORAKKANDAM. 72. SATHEESAN P.N., PAYIPPAT (PUTHIYA PARAMBIL VEEDU), KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 73. SHAJI, PALAKUNNEN, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 74. KRISHNAN, PADATHIL VEEDU, DEVARUPARA P.O., KOLAPRAM. 75. SASI, PADATHIL, KOLAPRAM. 76. RETNAKARAN, PADATHIL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 77. NARAYANAN, PALAKKUNNIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 78. PUSHPA RAJAN, PATHIKKAL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 79. M.K. RAJAN, MATTEPLAKKAL VEEDU, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA PO. 80. SIVARAMAN, PATHIKKAL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 81. PARAMESWARAN, PATHIKKAL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 82. KAMALAKSHI, KADUKUMMAKKAL, NADUKANI (PUTHADAM), KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 83. V.N. SIVARAMAN, VAYALIL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 84. SANKARAN, NELLIKKANATHIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 85. KUNJU PENNU, KARAKKUNNEL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. OP.No. 13199 of 2001(U) 86. SURESH, KARAKKUNNEL VEEDU, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 87. BABU P.A., POTTANPLAKKAL, POOMALA, KOOVAKANDAM PO. 88. NARAYANAN, KAKKARASSERIL, KOOVAKANDAM P.O., POOMALA. 89. NARAYANAN, MARUTHUMKALLEL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 90. MOHANAN, CHELAPLAKKAL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 91. VIJAYAN, CEHLIKKAL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 92. RAMAN, CHELIKKAL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 93. MOHANAN, CEHLIKKAUL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 94. KAMALAKSHI, THONIPLAKKAL VEEDU, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 95. NARAYANAN, THONIPLAKKAL VEEDU, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 96. RAMAN, THONIPLAKKAL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 97. SAROJINI, ANAKKUZHIYIL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 98. SASEENDRAN, KUPPIMAKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA PO. 99. SARASAMMA, OLIYARAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 100. V.A. SASI, VANGANANIKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 101. PUSHPAN, THAIPLAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 102. SUKUMARAN, NELLIPPALLIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 103. PRABHAKARAN, VARIKKAPLAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. OP.No. 13199 of 2001(U) 104. KELA, NELLIPPALLIL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 105. BHASKARAN, PONIPLAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 106. NARAYANAN, THONIPLAKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 107. NARAYANAN, KARAKKUNNEL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 108. RAMAN, VENGAMALAYIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 109. BALAKRISHNAN, EDAYAPURAKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 110. M.K. VIJAYAN, THONIPLAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 111. SANTHOSH, KOCHUPURAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 112. K.I. PADMANABHAN, KADALIPLAKKAL, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 113. T.P. VISWANATHAN, THONIPLAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 114. SHEELA, 569, KADALIPLAKKAL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPULANGAD P.O. 115. SUBI BABU GOPI, KANAVARAKKAL, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., NADUKKANI EAST. 116. GANGADHARAN, PADATHIL VEEDU, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O 117. KUNJU PENNU, KADALIPLAKKAL, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 118. RAMA KRISHANAN, KANAVARAKKAL, KARIPPLANGAD P.O., NADUKKANI. 119. ADICHAN, KOCHIPLAKKAL, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 120. KRISHNAN, KIZHAKKE PURAKKAL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 121. P.K. NARAYANAN, PADATHIL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. OP.No. 13199 of 2001(U) 122. PARAMESWARAN, KAROT KULAPRATH, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., KOLAPRAM. 123. SASIKALA, KAROT KULAPRATH, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., KOLAPRAM. 124. C.P. SANKARAN, EETTIKKAL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 125. MOHANAN, KULAPRATH, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 126. KRISHNAN, KULAPRATH, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., KOLAPRAM. 127. KUNJAPPAN, KIZHAKKEPURAKKAL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 128. KRISHNAN, CHAMAPPALLAYIL, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., KOLAPRAM. 129. PARAMESWARAN, KARAKKUNNEL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 130. KUTTAPPAN, KARAKKUNNEL, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., KOLAPRAM. 131. K.A. NARAYANAN, KAKKATT VEEDU, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., KOLAPRAM. 132. REJESH K.N., KAKKATT VEEDU, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., VATTAKKUNNI. 133. RAJESH, KADALIPLAKKAL, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., KOLAPRAM. 134. RAMAKRISHNAN, KARAKUNNEL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 135. JAYAKUMAR, KARAKKUNNEL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 136. VIJAYAN, KARAKKUNNEL, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., KOLAPRAM. 137. DAMODARAN, PUTHUPARAMBIL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 138. SREEKANTH, MUNDAPLAKKAL VEEDU, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., KOLAPRAM. 139. NARAYANAN, PINAKKATT, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., KOLAPRAM. OP.No. 13199 of 2001(U) 140. BALAKRISHNAN, PINAKKATT, KOLEPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 141. KESAVAN, KADUKUMNAKKAL, NADUKANI (PUTHADAM), KARIPPALLANGAD P.O. 142. VIJAYAN, PUTHUPARAMBIL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 143. SARASAMMA, PUTHUPARAMBIL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 144. SULOCHANA, CHOLLAMPLAKKAL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 145. KARUNAKARAN, KOCHUPLAKKAL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 146. RAJAN, KARAKKUMEL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 147. DEVAKI, CHANGAPPURAYIL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 148. DILEEP KUMAR, CHANPARAYIL VEEDU, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPULANGAD P.O. 149. KESAVAN, KULAPPURATH, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 150. SURESH BABU, THAZHAKKAL, KOLAPRAM, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 151. MUNDAN, KOLAPPURATH, KARIPPALANGAD P.O., KOLAPRAM. 152. V.K. KRISHNAN, VARIKKA PLAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 153. PANKAJAKSHI, OLIYARAKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 154. KESAVAN. A.K., ARAKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 155. SHAJI, KUPPIMAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 156. NARAYANAN, POTTAKKULATH VEEDU, KOORAKKANDAM P.O. 157. SREEDHARAN, MARUTHANIKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O., VELLIYAMATTAM. OP.No. 13199 of 2001(U) 158. KESAVAN, KARAKKUNNEL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 159. KARTHYAYANI PARAMESWARAN, CHELAKKA PARAYIL, (PADATHIL), POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 160. K.K. APPUKUTTAN, KUZHIPLAKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 161. K.K. SAJU MON, KUZHIPLAKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 162. THANKAPPAN, PATHIKKAL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 163. SEKHARAN, PULIYAMAKKAL, KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 164. SHENAYI. E.B., EDAYAPURAKKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 165. SHAJI, PAREPPURAKKAL VEEDU, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 166. MANILAL. M.M., METTOOR HOUSE, KOORAKKANDAM P.O. 167. PURUSHOTHAMAN, KALLUNGAL VEEDU, NADUKANI, KARIPPALANGAD P.O. 168. RAMANI, CHELAKKAPRAYIL (PADATHIL), KOLAPRAM, DEVARUPARA P.O. 169. SANKARAN, PAREPPURAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 170. A. TIMPLE MAGI, PAREPPURAKKAL VEEDU, POOCHAPRA. 171. KOMALAM, PUREPPURAKKAL VEEDU, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 172. CHANDRA SEKHARAN, PAREPPURAKKAL, DEVARUPARA P.O. 173. NARAYANAN, INCHAPLAKKAL VEEDU, DEVARUPARA P.O., POOCHAPRA. 174. RAJU PAROPPURAKKAL P.M., PAROPPURACKAL, POOCHAPRA. 175. ARAVINDAKSHAN P.M., PAROPPURACKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA .P.O. OP.No. 13199 of 2001(U) 176. K.M. NARAYANAN, KIZHAKKEPURACKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 177. K.N. GOPALAN, KIZHAKKEPURACKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 178. K.N. RAJAN, KARAKKUNNEL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 179. U.N. GOPI, URUMBIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 180. M.I. KARUNAKARAN, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 181. M.R. NARAYANAN, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA PO. 182. M.R. THANKAPPAN, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 183. AMBILY AJAYAKUMAR, VENGAMALAYIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 184. KELU, CHOKKALLIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 185. KESAVAN VARICKANANICKAL, KOOVAKANDAM, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 186. K.K. RAMAKRISHNAN, KOCHUPARAMBIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 187. RANJITH O.R., OARATHEL KOCHUPARAMBIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA. 188. P.P. SAVITHRY PAPPAN, PULIYAM MACKEL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 189. K.K. RAMACHANDRAN, KOCHUPARAMBIL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 190. K.E. NARAYANAN, KOCHUPURACKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 191. THANKAMMA NARAYANAN, KOCHUPURACKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. OP.No. 13199 of 2001(U) 192. K.I. VELAYUDHAN, THADATHIMACKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. 193. T.V. ANIL, THADATHIMACKAL, POOCHAPRA, DEVARUPARA P.O. BY ADV. DR.K.P.KYLASANATHA PILLAI, SRI.P.SREEKUMAR, SRI.B.PRABHAT KUMAR, SMT.SREEDEVI KYLASANATH. RESPONDENT(S): -------------------------- 1. STATE OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, GOVERNMENT OF KERALA, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM. 2. UNION OF INDIA, REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT & FORESTS, CENTRAL SECRETARIAT, NEW DELHI. 3. SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, REVENUE DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM. 4. DISTRICT COLLECTOR, IDUKKI DISTRICT. 5. REVENUE DIVISIONAL OFFICER, DEVIKULAM. 6. SPECIAL TAHSAILDAR, LAND ASSIGNMENT, KARIMANNOOR, IDUKKI DISTRICT. R1, R3 TO R6 BY GOVT. PLEADER MR.P.M. MANOJ. THIS ORIGINAL PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 01/06/2010,THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: OP.No. 13199 of 2001(U) ORDER ON C.M.P. NO.20899/2001 IN O.P. NO. 13199/2001 DISMISSED 01/06/2010. SD/- P.N.RAVINDRAN, JUDGE APPENDIX PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS: EXT.P1: COPY OF THE G.O.(P)NO.131/93/RD DATED 19/03/1993. EXT.P2: COPY OF THE LIST OF SCHEDULED TRIBAL COLONIES IN IDUKKI DISTRICT. EXT.P3: COPY OF THE NEWS ITEM PUBLISHED IN MATHRUBHOOMY DAILY DATED 21/12/2000. EXT.P4: COPY OF THE APPLICATION FORM PREPARED AND TAKEN TO THE 6TH RESPONDENT DATED 27/12/2000. EXT.P5: COPY OF THE COURT ORDER IN CMP.NO.22523/1993 IN O.P. NO. 12484/1993. EXT.P6: COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION SUBMITTED BY SRI.SUBRAMANIAN, CHANGAPLAKKAL, PERINGASSERY. EXT.P7: COPY OF THE IDENTITY CARD ISSUED BY THE ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA TO ONE OF THE PETITIONERS. EXT.P8: COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS NO.D.DIS. 2676/49/D.D DATED 02/12/1949 OF GOVERNMENT OF UNITED STATE OF TRAVANCORE AND COCHIN. EXT.P9: COPY OF THE APPLICATION PROCESSES IN 1993 FOR THE GRANT OF PATTAYAM. EXT.P10: COPY OF THE G.O.(MS)NO.88/97/REV. DATED 11/02/1997. EXT.P11: COPY OF THE TAX RECEIPT IN THE NAME OF THE ABDULKAREEM IN VALIYAMATTOM VILLAGE. EXT.P12: COPY OF THE PATTAYAM ISSUED TO ONE SRI.RAJU, S/O.MUNDAN. RESPONDENT'S EXHIBITS: NIL //TRUE COPY// P.S. TO JUDGE rs. P.N.RAVINDRAN, J. ----------------------------------------- O.P.No.13199 of 2001 ----------------------------------------- Dated this the 1st day of June, 2010 JUDGMENT The issue raised in this writ petition is covered by the decision of this Court in O.P.No.31603 of 1999. This original petition is accordingly disposed of with the observation that the directions issued by this Court in the judgment delivered on 4-8-2009 in O.P.No.31603 of 1999 will govern this case also. P.N.RAVINDRAN, Judge. ahg. P.N.RAVINDRAN, J. --------------------------- O.P.No.13199 of 2001 ---------------------------- JUDGMENT 1st June, 2010