'S^ '^WM^, W^VW, fsldl-H^i' 311^1 ^! ft'SR; "ipn an^i snro TOIRK^teiRI^) ^rafer^n wwi <i fis<z> tfegR ^Taffinsii^T WFfS). nQ,_s445/MM PETITIONBR Anil Sitarai yuartejr Bhilai,] 4i.umar farate, y/o Klin t-'aaclan [i Psfs.te, &gc<3- s-bout 3S VSSITS. ??/o No. 17-E, Sti-eet No. 26, Seclor, Distt. Durs 'CG) vcrsas JRBSPONDENTB 2. <->. 4. The S1 Secretat Bhawafe nv. Rr :h the D.K.S. Blulal Directol fi^r^\ (i.-U) GM (B.l Bhilai, wfjau. (ate ol unjiamsgarli, tbi-ouj General AdininistTation, Raipur (CG) Co^sctor, Durg Distt. Dui^ (CG) Steel Piant, fjirough Maaagiiig ~, Bhflai Steel Plant, Rliilai, Diu-g B.M) Uepartment, tSUilai Steel ^lant, nis+t nnro iC,l~i\ ^"A& l^"-'/ No._syi8ff007 PETITIONER VersUS RBSPOWuBNT-8 •J. Anil ^umar Parate, S/o Shri Paiidari Sitfirar^ Parate, aged about 38 years, R/o yuart^- wo. IY-E, stt-eer no, 26, Sector, Bhilai, jDistt. Durg (CG) 'l'tie S^ate ol GUiattisgaiti, fiii-ough me Secretslr1/, Ocnersl AclzEi.ixustTRtiQii. D, K, S tsiiaway., Kaipur (CLrj Dv. CoBector. Duis Distt. Durs <CG\ Add.itiopal Chiei Viguance Officer, B.nuai Steel P^mt, Bhilai, Distt, Dlirg (CG) XI-HC—78 •^' 's^. '*{WM^, w<a\ww, Fvwwly, ^tTHWI »*<1«1» an^n 'T5RF ('pi^^?) so^iqn.ftTO? '(NT1»fl^frsn(lii=n fsnw flto •3iA5i -^ 4}|^<?l4l'< T?WP?? ^f f^1^ ^(^.K '^siRnaiitw ^ 'wP No. 1671/2006 PETi'TIONER VcrsUS Anil Sitaraat Halwa, | (CG) Kltunar Para^te, son of Shri Paadari •f» or)r<=*rl QT^r^'ti+ 40 t7'*=>c»t^i /^act<=1 i^ *-a fa •' • * * ""t ^-^*».</-i-*- I—*.*-/l^rt-t. k- a ^^ Tf •^+l-A^a. t^ ^ \^'t^vjt^f s^f^ R/'o Sector VIII, Bhilai, Distt. Diu'g RESPONDBnTs 1. The Secreta Admuui Sl^te of Chiiattisgarh, through the r\f O'euei'sl y, Department Rsit^ur WRIT PETI'TIONS UNDER ARTI su'ation, Uau Kalyaa siagn BJiawaii, ICG) 2. Thc De^uty Couector, Distt-Duig (CG) [CLB 226 OF- THE CONSTITUTION Or NDIA *»»• ».5: rlijFrt* &HRI DHIRBNDR& ^ISHRA, u 23-3-2009 Klin I'.K. Invan, Advocate yiin A.y. Kactitiawa&a, tbr Uie peuuoner. Dy. Adv. General, for the State/' responclents. Dr. N.K. Shukla, Sr. Adv. Yadav, Advocates for the Bhiiai ]witti Smt. A. Sengupta and Shri A.K. Steel PIaitt. i Jtie above petitions are bejtag disposed of by ftus coHunon order as ttiey peitam to ventication ot jtfae caste certtticate ot Uie petitloner. llie petiUoner is aggnevec( 15-2-2006 issued bv the Steel bv fhe notice of annexure P-3 dated Authority of india Ltd., BhUai Steel Plant whereby the petitioner ha^ been directed to appear beforc the ~y I-HC—78 '3^' -tiwwi, wxiiww, hwvy. ^n<<?iTg»»nefe sn^r 1iiw ('yiy'i^f) an^i'mftFiN? 'iTO ^H^T sCTHT fi ^^i^T^td ^I^] CoUector, uurg aloug wlui nece^sary dociunents tbr tlie purpose of venncatiou ot ttie caste cerubcate Leamed counsel for the fcetiuoner submits that neither the State nor fhe Blulai Steel Plant jiave aay autliority to detenmne the caste of Uie petitioner and verii^ neter the caste certificate issued aumonty i.e. Hign Level Caste y< caste ceruticate to Uie Higii Chliattisgarh for verification of peuuoner as per guKlelines laid t'fii^ici^'i ^i;4<?iT ^ fs<^ ^Hrf^K ^K aiRll 311^1 issued to the petiuoner. ttie caste certi&cate issued to hiin aud, therefore, notice of Annex|ire P-3 issued to the petitioner is wittiout junsdiction. Learued counsel appearjing for the respondents jouitly subimtted that they have no obj^ctiou if the notice of Annexure P-3 issued to the petitioner is quashitd wiui 'liberty to the respondents to to the petitioner to fhe coinpetent [•rutuiy Comnuttee, UJUiattisgarti lor veiiucauon. In view ol tlie above subiulssion ot Uie leamed counsel tor Uie parties, the iustant petitioii is aplowed. The notice :of Annexure P-3 passed by the Steel Autliority o^ India Limited, Bhilai Steel Plaat is quashed. However, fhe responde^its shaB be at liberty to forward the Level Caste Scrutmy Coiiimittee, me caste status/certtticate ot the down ia Madtmii Patil's case (AIR 1995 SC 94). The said CoDimltlee shatl decide the matter after affording opportunity ofhearing ijp the pai-ties. ^--- - ~ -- XI-HC—78 'S'S! •*IIAII<'1<<, ®T)l-y' ,fsiMWy *<t*(nr vhw^ Sf^V 'WV ( yls'l'i.'^) an^i w R!-)i+ Wiait^W **li'* wnw^ifp? 311^(1 — Tlie W.P. (C) No. 5443/2C| terms, in view ot Uie aDove orcler, 1 5918/ 2007 also stand disposed o] A copy ot Uys oraer be plac| and W.P.(c) No. 5918/2007. ^tl^^^'1 *i)^^ ^' f5^ tPn^l^ ^3tfOT3)R?T 106 is dispdsed of in the afbresaid A/.P. No. 1671/2006 aiid W.P.(c) No. sd in the fUe ofW.P. No.1671/2006 Sd/- Dhirendra Mishra Judge V"