Digitally Signed By:AMULYA Certify that the digital file and physical file have been compared and the digital data is as per the physical file and no page is missing. Signature Not Verified , • and had admittedly DOl compleMXi his probation period. Thecefcre. he was DOl eligible to be consideced roc promotioo in teems of DOPT OM NO.22091 dated 18.7.1989 which provided that when a junior who had oomplc:ted the eligibtlily pericd was consideced roc promotion, his senior should also be considc:n:d irrespective of whether he had completed !he requisite service provided he had completed !he probation period Thecefure, his reliance 00 Note 3 appended to Schedule 4 ofIB(E)S Rules could DOl be seen in isolation. Apart from this, it is noticed that Schedule Caste vacancies in the Senior Time Scale roc 1988-89 stood almdy de-reserved when petitioner was ooosideled by the Review OPC in compliance to Tribunal orders. He admincdly had failed to throw any challenge to that de-reservlllion order and. therefore. n:spordans could not be blamed Coc DOl ooosiderlng him roc Review Select Panel of 1988-89 wheD no vacancy was aV811ab1e. All told, we find DO merit in this petidon which is dismissed. - :. c:.:. p 2004 (MANJU GOBL ) sun JUDGE