sssssisssas^ VSSSSiS |s^'^^^'i^'..^;"; II^E^^fr^S' : ^t •8S IKS8 18®R IKR Z-SplUOQ •lum^oejnieu ai|»U!UQ!i.3aj!p y^^fSi Aw^.^; S ^, / . 7 Cv"(\~^^-- • ' : : * /' x; .io .lapjp a^euaiCMaae J'sq^o Aue jo slnuuepueui 10 IUM e eouenss! JOj Bipui ^p yo!in)!isypa! eq^ lp 932 ejoijije jepyn uoiijiacl IUM v S}U8pu6ds8a""'••••••••• ^/^ .^ • eZOOOS - ('d'V) peqejpAH 'Auoipo jeBeN uqs •Zl,/096-e-8 lusuJlJedv luiqdy 'zoi. Ati&iSAiun iBoiGoiouyoe} leuoiieN 'nj.N ^o Apog Byju.ieAOQ j.d jequjeiAi 'A'IAI uuey BAIS •£ (•9'0)Jnd!ey isod undAea '.ind|e~i 'B>|eN ipsdqoed 'Apoq BuiujeAoBjo sjequjeLU L|BnojL|i AtisjsMun leoiBoipuqoei |euoiieN ('0'0)-ind!ey qjeBsiHeqqo p 'JAOQ 'Ajeisjoes leiqo qBnojqi ('^ ou 'dssj p Apoq BuiujQAoB ^o jsqujeui se os|y) yjBBsiueqqo jo 9}eis s/A ?''^HH3 ,,;<,:, -;•••, •: +••'- (' • 7n"-C'°'£'^a^:. -\xtm:isv W ^iv^y i''r'cs" '•^ w^i-a'i , \ ^ L/" ~^ .^-.-,-'"-•. ^''N. -? i~.~ , rf' ^VA.U.,/ •z •I. j9UO!l!}ed •d |/V 'JOIIBMQ jnditeqi Auo|03 ^0^ lC^ uedjea "381. on o/y eieooApv uoiiednooo SjeeA ^.£ps6e ejqsi|/\| •Q-H "43 siB-i, g/g ejqsi|/\| ^eqsiqqv A9UJOHe^oj9MOdyBnpjqi(-cri/\|) JOI|Bffi£) 'J!pUB|/\|e>| 9|0£) 'jeBeN lUBLUBJpUI 'l.-VO/y 'jhdiey 'Ftj.N^O (JOIIBMQ4B 9JIU93 UO!SU9p(9/9J}U83 Apnis) jo^euipjoQo ypnEdnooo 'sjeeA '8£ peBe qeMqsnx •S'y N48 o/S qeMysnx -s'd'lM sooz/ IP48fl ^!^tig jndsBiig y3 ajn^Boipnf <ilje§si^tiiojo ^inQ3 q§iH9iqtUOH aqi ajeyag *" i.;^£i^;kB^as£^ "• '•!SSL" '•• :^J£;': XI-HC-22 SD^TM ; t<aich3igs( ^w^^fii^ ^-. <'"<-. x 3^ •<i)<<i<i<i, acnl'M'ia, Riwwy *iwni(i»Hi«h 3lT^?T if3R? _.^s......SLiu.a..'ST, 200^ ftre^T" 3iii?i^<nwgft<r D!VIS!ON BENCH HON'BLE SHR! A.K. PATNAIK. CJ. & HON'BLE SHRf S.K. AQNIHOTOI.u. 17.06^005:- Heard Shri AvinashK. Mishral Surnesh Bajaj, Deputy Govt.Advocat^ . The Mational Technological Ur|ivsrsity by [a-" notificatiQn under Section Vishwavidyalaya (Sthapana Aur Univsrsity admittsdSS studentsin B.^d. at Gwalior (Madhya Pradesh) outside| ofChhattsgarh. was notified andestablished ^ of the Chhattisgarh Niji Kshefra Vitiiyaman) Adhiniyam, 2002. The !. course for the session 2004-2005 |the territoria! jurisdiCtiori of the State ffd. By a judgment dated 11th F^ yashpal&Anr\fe.StateofChhatt!t No.19 of 2004 the Supreme Court ha^ 5;and B of the aforesaid Act, 20021 .iBOtifcations issued bythe S^tg ^exercise of the powers under Sectk?r( "t!riiversities. !n paragi'aph 45 ofAhsjud! tteld that in order tc^ BfQtectthe in^ actually studying ingthe institutKJns Universities, the State^overnment have such institutions'afRliated to thej GhhatBsgarh. The Supreme Courtl bensfitof affiliatiQn te an institution St qiptf^^ft-r 'W-r^t "^ 'fe^' <f^ gl<. ^r aipgT sii^i . counsel for the petitioner and Shri for the State of Chhattisgarh. ^bruary, 2005 in the case of Prof. j^garh & Ors inWrit Petition (Civill a^ eleclared the provisionsof SectjOTis to be ultRi.'vires and quashed ttie J3ov|smment in the Gazette in purportec! 5 of thg Sforesaid Act notifying the judgment, the Supreme Gourtfeffier (erest "f the students who may be establishsd by such private- ]may take appropriate m^asiures to lalreadyexistihg Stats UnivSrsities in however, made it clear that the jhal! be °xtended only ifit fulfillsthe ['jS^^fira • S iaa :lfl I'l' fc^ 3" VM ii! XI-HC-22 311^1M few^ ?b*i wsa 3ii^[?^<iiw(te — Sl.— :*'' 's^ 'w<\visf, wv\«'w,hv\wy, 3nt?r 1cra^7 iiiCTiaiHlw " "" """""""~"""'?F^ 200 "'te^ST'""""""""""""""" requisite norms and standards lar svery kind of Institution. In ParE Supreme Court further obsen/ed ttii the institutions established by su< existingState Univereities in accor< paragraph 45 of the jydgment and apprQach the High Court if any di direction. Since the State of Gl -prQvision for al'owing the 58 studenl studying at the Gwalior Centrs in petstioner has filed this writ peU Chhattisgarh to allow al! the 58 stus B.Ed. Examinations and to comp] University of theState of Chhattisga] !n para 41 ofttie aforesaidjl that the sajd Act which speeificaft , campus studycentre^outside^he ;<3hhattisgarh legistature because u< legistature pfthe §tate_"fChhatti^ regard to any staidy centeroutside therefore, can be issuedtothe Stat admitted in the stuelycenter of territory of the Stale^,®fChhatti^ Examination, 2005^for any Uhivet ^PifeF'iN mqsiftfeizt <F>I^K iTsiPOTSn^i th down for such purpose and notto i^raph 46of the said judgment, the (t steps may be taken Tor affiliation of ;|i private Universitjes to the already jancs with the directions contained in |hat the parties would be at liberty to tpute arises in implemehtation of the ihattisgarh has faited to make any in the B.Ed. course of the Universify the State of Madhya Pradesh, the :ion for directions on the State of jents ofthe Gwalior Centre to take the |ete the whote B.Ed. course in any 1-h idgment the Supreme Court has held makes a provision to have an oJT- is beyond the competence of the kder Article 245 of the C-onstitution the sgarh has no power to legislate with leState ofChhattisgarh. No direction, of Ghhattisgarh toa!low58 students ie Unjversityat Gwa'ior outside the garh to appear in the B.Ed. Main sity in the State of Chhattisgarh as Sltate WSS Kli r^ [•^^i^ r^^:^;-. T XI-HC-22 SIT^T'SI fero^S?t ^•qi^^n fr' I.IF-S rf'-9w\\ 731 -i(|<(|c|<|, •E9Tn«'|6, f««1Wl,< aniRT TRg? 111CTI g,^,c(,"——----•••--•-•^ ^gg """"""ftre^""""""""""""""""" •3'iA'nTRiiwdft? regular stud.ents as prayed for in thi judgment oftheSupreme Court in th Forthe aforesaid reasons, w petition and we accQrdinglydismiss Sd/- .ChiefJustice 1.-^. i are not inclined to entertain this writ jhesame. Sd/- SatishK.Agnihotri ,^~» Judge °ni«it<i<il'ixi'xif ^ 1ys> tl"i*<;it ^7 aiPw sn^i writ petitfon in wew ofthe aforesaid ^ case of Prof. Yashpal ^upra). {-aii&rt a 'l'igll .••^'- •^S-' -,'•.. \1