LPA/1342/2003 1/5 ORDER IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1342 OF 2003 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.6441 OF 2003 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1404 of 2003 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.5242 2003 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1409 of 2003 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.4596 OF 2003 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1410 of 2003 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.6311 OF 2003 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1411 of 2003 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.6039 OF 2003 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1412 OF 2003 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.4627 OF 2003 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1413 OF 2003 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.5756 OF 2003 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1414 OF 2003 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.4809 OF 2003 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1099 OF 2004 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.5242 OF 2003 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1485 OF 2004 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.5551 OF 2003 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1424 OF 2003 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.4692 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.5934 OF 2003 with LPA/1342/2003 2/5 ORDER SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.1784 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.3557 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.3558 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.3938 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.282 OF 2004 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.18 OF 2004 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.5755 OF 2003 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.19 OF 2004 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.5753 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.1748 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.9048 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.705 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.706 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.707 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.918 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.1670 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.2471 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.2742 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.2743 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.2914 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.3516 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.3668 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.3936 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.8228 OF 2004 with LPA/1342/2003 3/5 ORDER SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18286 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18287 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18288 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18289 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18290 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18291 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18292 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18293 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18294 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18295 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18296 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18297 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18298 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18299 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18300 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18301 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18302 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18303 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.15 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.18 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.19 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.7386 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.283 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.286 OF 2004 with LPA/1342/2003 4/5 ORDER SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.287 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.288 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.290 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.295 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.423 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.663 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.702 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.13440 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.13873 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.13964 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.13756 OF 2003 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.270 OF 2004 with SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.1577 OF 2004 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1368 OF 2003 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.6312 OF 2003 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1369 OF 2003 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.6315 OF 2003 with LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1370 OF 2003 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.6314 OF 2003 with CIVIL APPLICATION No.4152 OF 2004 in SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No.1577 OF 2004 ========================================================= CHARULATA B PATEL - Appellant(s) Versus STATE OF GUJARAT & 3 - Respondent(s) ========================================================= Appearance : MS SONAL R SHAH for Appellant(s) : 1, LPA/1342/2003 5/5 ORDER GOVERNMENT PLEADER for Respondent(s) : 1 - 4. ========================================================= CORAM : HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE R.S.GARG and HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE RAVI R.TRIPATHI Date : 28/12/2005 ORAL ORDER (Per : HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE RAVI R.TRIPATHI) For the reasons to follow in the detailed judgement, the Letters Patent Appeals are dismissed, but however, the Special Civil Applications are partly allowed to the extent indicated in the detailed judgement. The Civil Application is disposed of. Rule/ notice in the respective matters stand discharged. No order as to costs. (R.S.GARG, J.) (RAVI R.TRIPATHI, J.) karim