HIEH (JOURT OF CHHATTESéARH AT gILASPUR w. P. (5) Na. 2267 of 200a / / Pa'fHionars 1. 6aharu Ram 5cm of La+2 Ran-m, aged abau? 5D years, working as Waferman, Boys HosTel Aasm Biock {vim-mm, DIS'H'. Jashpur (CG) (Appein‘red vide arder dt. 21.8.1989} Bahal Ram son of Sagam Ram, aged abam‘ 40 years, war-khg a5 Cask (Ragoyeeya) Nave Chhafravas - Ausm; Vikus Khand Mariam; DisTT. Jashpur- (Appoin'red vMe arder d‘h 10.7.$9} 3. Pmbhu Lakm, san af Karh1u+§ya Lakm, aged aéeuf 4O years, workmg us Cook (Rasoyeeyn) Boys Hosfel Smkyari, Block Mamm, mafia Jashpur' (CG) (Appointed vide order d+. 29.3.1990) Ma'mk Dhm‘i Ram, £61“: m‘ 5amat‘u Ram, aged abcu'r 41 year's, warkiag as Wafermun, Boys HosTel Manom. Bi3?+. Jashpur- ( §) (appah‘rmd Vida erder duh 31.3.1991) 5. Qa'par; Qam son 5f Law Rafnu Ram aged about 42 years, warking a5 Chowkidar‘. Deparfmen‘r of Tribal \1_’23fm=e Jashpur, R/o. Kadam‘foH Jashpur, Disrwr. Jashpur (C5) (Appoinfed Vida arder dT. 4/6/1992) P). h. Eas‘pandzws 1. S‘m'hz 6f Chha'Hisgnrh, ‘x‘hraugh Secremr'y, Departmem of Pubiic Works. Dou Kalyon Singh Bhawan. Qaipur (CE). 2. The Cc!!ectar (Adim Jmi Ka!yan Vibhng) DIS‘H'. Jushpur (The Then §aigarh) 3. The Assismnt Cemmissioner, Aad§vas§ Vikas Tribal Jashpur (The Then Reieaeh} Déstf. Jeshpur (Cé) The Commissioner, Aadivosi ‘v’i .351, Reipur- {c.é.) ~\ 5.3: han'ble Shri 5at3sh K. Agrihc‘tri. J. .k ma :zr- 53' heard firtaH-y. h)» By +his-pe+i+ian 'Hwz pe+i+ion2rs have challerged we validh‘y crf +512 nrder‘ da'l‘ad 410.1997 (Ai1nexurz W4) pES$ed hy +512 CaHeC‘mr, whemundar 'h e gran? of regular pay smie 'm fhe pa'fi'fiwiars was wi?hdmwn arid 1‘h2 p2?§+iai1ers wave pn£d +heranf+et= daily wages czs par Caliec'for-‘s ra‘E'e. LU an” / - af“ w OQAL ORDER (Passed on fhis 215’ day of April, 2668) With 1%2 car-sea‘r a'f Earned mam-.32! appeaFSi-ug far 1412 par‘fizs, +112 The iria‘ispmablz fads iii nua‘sheH are ‘Hm‘f $ni'i'iaHy 141a pa‘fii’inmr-s wem erigaged m1 daiiy wages or, +he pos'rs m‘ Wa‘harman, Rasaia and Chawkidar. Subsequziw'rly, fha pe?i+ianers wera gram'ed mguiar pay sank (Aryr-exure (3/3) La:ir-r.e& caunsa! appeariryg far 1+»a pe+§+iohars wauH camznd “Hm'f ame ‘3 righi‘ af a pm‘-+icu!m'~ pay scalz has been gmm"d ’ha 1%12 pa+§+§0aers ii“; accar-o'ance wi‘rh law, ‘H-uz same caaaa'l’ be wahdmwn, wiamu‘f affara’iag a'a oppar'i‘uaify a-f hear3'ag. Tae pei‘iaaaers have acquired fhe r§gh+ ‘m 1'he fixed mani'hiy pay scaie as Their services were reguiar-ized. Thus, +he impugned ar—derv is bad aad deserves +0 be quashed; Lear-aed counse far a‘he pefhiaher heavily relied an a judgmem‘ ahd order da‘fed 18th January, 20Q6 passed by fhis Cour? in Wri'r Pei'i‘i’iaa Na. 2125/2902 {5aa'r Kumar & o‘rhers ‘v’s. Sfa'ie af Chha‘i’i‘isgarh é: ofhers) and erder dafed 11w Juiy, 299,7 passed in WPKS) Na. 3936 cf 20G7 {Qa‘iiya Ram & afhers Vs. The S+a+e a‘f Chha‘i‘iisgar—h 33¢ a+hers), wherein +his Cour'i' whiie considering ihe WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTI€L§ 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION Shri F. S. Khare, Advacaie far +he pefii‘ianer. Shri Aiak Bakshi, Gav‘i'. Advaea‘fe far the respanden'is. »y5 I idrm'fica} issue nf reducirug #12 Faguhr pay scal2 gmrrfed earlier, #1236} 'Hmi‘ ‘H‘ye Wider: reduc§i1g The pay Ernie. af an empiayaz bahiiid h§s back, wifhau'r failnwh-yg my pvocedura knawvx ‘m hw, is purlh‘ive mid vis§#s wi'u‘h civi! cmszquzwce. The same cama'f be passed w§+hauf givmg cmtetmed empiayee, m1 apper'mruify of hearing. Learned caunse¥ far '1‘he pe'ri'i'iariers furfher submHs 'ha'r 'i'he respandem‘s/Si‘aw af Chha‘Hisgar-h preferred a Specia! Leave Pea‘i‘fEaa (CM!) Na. 17122/2606 (S'hi‘re a‘f Chha‘ffBsgarh & a'i‘hers Vs. Sawi' Kumar— & a‘fher-s) hefare 'H'ie Han‘bie Supreme Cam-f, chaHengirig #se order da‘fed 184.2606 (supra), passed by +his Cam-1' and 1"ne same aas been disinissec'. by nae Han'b!e Supreme Caun'.‘ vide arden da‘fed 9.10.2S06 af?er- car-darting 1'he deiay. Learner} caunse! appearing for ihe par'fies join'Hy submii‘ 'iha'.‘ 'Hqis mse is squareuy covered by fne judgmen'i’ and arder daieti 18.1.2606 passed by +nis Caur'i’ in San? Kumar & ai‘ners (su‘pra) and #he arder dai'ed 11?!“ July, 2007 passed in W.P.(S) No. 3936 of 2907 (Raiiya Rain & a‘i'ners Vs. The Snare cf C'aha'ii'isgarn & a'i'aers). Tnus, 'ihe impugned araer is baa in law being punifive in na'mre anti passed wi‘x'nau? affarding an appar'mnify of hearing fa 1he caneernea emplayees (pefifianers) far pui'iing forward 1‘heir case Accardingiy ihe impugned arder da-i'ed 410.1997 (Annexare W4) is l‘~ quashed. The pe‘iiiianers are enfiiled 'i'a regular pay scale from fhe da‘r‘ ihe same has been wi-ihdrawn by ihe impugned arder, subjec‘? 'ia verifiaa+ian a‘,‘ fac'i’s. The respandenis are a+ linerny‘ L a. ‘i‘a .1.iake any sieps, in accardance wi‘i‘h law. No arder asi’a cas'is. n\ y //. . W. m d]_ Sh K Agnihotri San Judge