IN THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF ‘CHHATTISGARH AT ' BILASPUR (C. G.) W. P. 5 No. of 2011 RESPONDENTS :1. Sia’re of Chhaf‘risgarh Jagdev Singh Chandra (in Transfer order wrongly men’rioned Jagdev Pr'asad Chandra), S/o LaTe Shri Chafurbhan Singh Chandra, aged abou+ 52 years, Upper Division Teacher, posfed' at Governmeni‘ Middle School, Bhu’rha, Block- ,Malkharoda, DisfricT—Janjgir-Champa - (C.G.) VERSUS / Through The Secrefary, Depar’rmen’r of School EducaTion, D.K.$. Bhawan, Raipur (C.6.). 2. The Collecfor, Janjgir, Disfricf— Janjgir—Charnpa (C.G.) District Education Officer, Janjgir- Champa, District- Janjgir—Champa (C.G.) . Block Education Officer, Malkharoda, District— Janjgir—Champa (C.G.) WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE l CONSTITUTION OF INDIA HEGH CO? ERT OF CHEATT1$GARH AT BTLASPUR WRIT ?ET1TIQN (S) N0! 6411 Gi‘ZOli T? E ‘1 ”ER : Jagdév Singh Cha3¢ra, VER Si IS RES?0NDENTS : ‘§?a?a 0f C’tLhattisgarh & Othars. v.EITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF ’EEE CONSTE'EUE‘EON OF ENDIA S§%: Hmf Ee Shi'i Sat§sh K. Agmhot‘ri. J. 1 WRIT P Shm’ ASRajtmt. Ad‘mcate fo'r the tieiitiane: Shri Ami} Sam Govefm’nerli Advcuaw for ihe Sme/rwponden’is; __J_ DRBER (()RA} A {Pagsed on 3 lit (Ray afGcioEa‘, 261 1) iiihalieaaé m this gaétiticm is m the; (Eda ciaiéd 10‘1G2311 {Aiméymre PM) passec§ by me Dismct Eélma‘iien Oiiicgn Distric: Janjgir-Champm wlmrebv, the m‘der datsd £5;87.2{}11 (Ajmamra E312) {.raasfaring the petitions? £0211 Mitidga SchwL Bhutha. i0 Micidie Schooi Pakariva. hak béan anaemiai and tha petitionar has men transferrad to Middle Schmla Nawagaan Pakariyaa Black _ kahara, Eaiiier‘ iwy ordar daied limtzml (Aimaxum P/Z) passad by 15m LEQmm‘ism offisér i‘e1 tha Cnimcmr Xaqicn‘r Champa ‘Iha mtitiomr was iransfeirsvzi 131m: Mit1€&e School. Bhuma; t0. Middié Schmi Pakanya 013 administrative grmmdS, 1:1 $13 saini orikn the designaiim Qfifha yétitiemr was sigma"; a? Hsad Mastarx iémugll he waQ W0rkjng as Upper Divisimi rEaachar, The Siam Govemmant? rga‘éizing the mistaka thai ma Head Mastsrs 0f Mifia’ié Sglmoi baéng class L ofiicsfs, wuki 110i. ha transferrad amiar this transfer ”‘3oEicy dateii 13;G6,2{}1L cancailed ma iramféz 0f $6 iigad Llasmm by ordsr ciatsgk 19:88‘2Q11 {Ajmsxure 13/3)— 111 Gags of ths paiitiogxer: Sims the paitiongr was Show: as Head Maria: mthe 0rd§r dated 15.97‘2G11 (Amexure W2}? thmlgh h$ was an Uprga Division Teachel; a mnectiQn was maés bv the impugmd oréar daiieii 11.}. 10,201 1 Whgmby jg was Shawn as Ugxper I“ Division Tsavchsr am} in placa 0f Pakanya he was transfsrred 10 @ Nawagarh Pakariyaz There is no bmad: of smiutory ardsri tion or .rulas and «Q such n9 mmrfarenw is waxramad‘ it. atipeara fn he a cage Wham on genoum nf qome c1enca1 mismks eccut-reQi Parker. {lag mpiwned ordar Wns necewimed to he mweu whereiméer the yiaca waa alSe chamgeé, mt' eosis. Sd/- Satish K. Agnihotri Judge : @374} 4 sec 3 ~ (2534) 4 see 245 995x 3 sec a (9mm g enr‘ 1 .a n m > 4‘, it. a: well-setti-ad 1.11m iransfar is 2m imidgme 0f sarvmé ami it i3 £0: the $mnlovtar f0 decma as‘to whats a pamcular officer/rrrpioveg mqmd kaén g i1 View pubiic imgmst m wdi a< a.(i11"u"1_iist_rativg atamamv and _0r a<kmg ev en far <mall devmtmn. there Qhouki 110‘? im any interférénae wrth the aémlmstmiive iiinctiml of 1116 State Gmiemme‘nt. 5: Tbs C0111“ ha< inmi‘ed }11mt‘m‘tmn in 1111erfere wuh tha transfar maiiér exogpt iv; ihe casgs of provsd mainflda nag-Competencs of authority mssing the Harmer (mier and mt being in confmmity with the rules and regiiationsn The g‘eiii'iomvr/emaiwee came? be p9 wmed ”m remam at (me eiace brevezr Wider the Dmvwm: of" gervme mies: emyieyer a2} the yowers te post. an. emyleyee at a partieuiar place in View of whiie imerest ami administrative :gemy (See E P Ravapva G .9 cfEI mu? “Jada: an w, g r Lira“ (“‘25 wza a. 5’ Maf’wr v We“ wkwr: Deé afP' 4" menievz, yaw efMP. awd as” r v. S.S.‘».eurm’ 55?:5’ eikarf and Mend. Whom“ 1m ad wt z‘efUP. CE 9:?!ers4}. 6, L2 vaew 0f fhe aheve the WIT: vehf: diamissed, Ne Order Mm