SSSKK S:IIIl*ls%?&'V '^SKWS^ »;.;• »i;l IN THE HON'BLE HIGH COIJRTOF CHHATI'ISCnARHA'F BILASPURfC.Cr.l r •IW, P.; (Sl' N<».^®<2>'l<i^r:20^t; RESPONDENTS ^ ...-•- cys >y. . •y3.^..." .^t^ <.,. ^;...~l--;i'fe..^''.;'^;1.^'^..^ Manoj Kunieuj 31wari,^S/;b ^SUri , Ginjanand Tiwan, aged^ about 35 years, R/Q IVillageT^Khairmuda, Post-Tundri, ; : ^Elistnct-Janjgr- Champa (C.Gr,) U' VERSUS .: ;:'".<'^:. !' ; •,• : - . :• ; : I. ^ High Court of'Chhattisgarh, thrpugh the Registrar General, High Court of Chhattisgarh, Raipur Road, Bodri, Distnct- BUaspur(C.G.) ^ <$* •^' 2. Govemmenf, Girls Polytechnic, Bilaspur, through the Principal, Governmenti Engineering Premises, -Koni, District-Bilaspur (C.G.) | WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 OP THE CONSTITUTION OF INDLA HIGH COURT QF CHHATTISGARH:BILASPUR Writ Petition(S) No.3032 of 201 1 PETITIONER: RESPONDENTS: -Versus- ManojKumar Tiwarj High Court of Chhattisgarh and another PQST FORORDER ONSPAUGUST. 201.1 prasta^^Misbra Judge ^t^ HIGHCOURT OF CHHATTISGARH: BILASPUR Writ Petition(S)No.3032of2011 PETITIO.NER: RESPONDENTS: -Versus- Manoj Kumar Tiwari High Court of Chhattisgarh and another (WrifPetitionunderArtiGle226oftheConstitutionof|ndia) Present: Shri PrateekSharma, counselforthe petitioner. ShriSanjay K. Agrawal, counsel for respondent No.1. ORDER ^ (Passedon_OL^ August, 2011) PRASHANT KUMARMISHRA. J. 1. The petitioner herein has submitted his candidature in response to the advertisement issued by respOndent No.1 fbr recruitment of Civil Judges (Entry Level). In the advertisement (Annexure-P/2), total number of 29 pdsts were advertised t6 be filled up from amongst the candidates of various categories. The petitioneF submitted his application, however, he did not annex 'No Qbjection Certificate'by his employer and thus, his candidature was rejected and He has been declared ineligibte for competing in the examihation. Annexure-P/1 is the infbrmation uploaded in the website of respondent No.1 in which the reasons/ grounds for disqualification have been nnentioned as over age and the application not submitted through proper channel, neither No Objection Certificate norundertaking. 2. Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the petitioner is in contract employment with respondent No.2, the Government Girls Polytechnic, Bilaspur, however, the termof his appointment issued by the employer provides that for applying elsewhere No Objection Certificate is not required to be obtained and the applicant can directly submit his application form. He would submit that in the No Objection C^Ftificate (Annexure-P/6) issued by respondent No.2 on 10-6-2011, '^ ^ ' ' •1 : • • !." ' ,: . ' ..': : l.'; - . . ' ipara-116f the terms of appointment has been mentioned, howeyer, at fe5;33£;£' >i^& '~^ ^^ sssR^^ ''S-ilSi^SSSS -f .^-S^ ~vh ffl..: \ :s s |< '<iat3isE-a-<g j 'r'i • . ^ ^ .s' ^. "*&0>^ '"»... ^Co? A the same time, No Objection Certificate has also been issued. According to learned counsel, in view of clause-11 of the terms of contract appointment, there was no requirement of obtaining No Objection Certificate and thus, hiscandidature could not have been thrown out on this ground. 3. On theother hand, respondentNo.1, in its retum,hassubmittedthatthe petitioner is more than 35 years ^f age 6n 1 -1-2012 and the maximum age limit for open category candidate being 35yearson 1-1-2012, the petitioner was found to be over age and further that along with his application form, the petitioner had not submitted No Objeetion Certificate issued by his employer, therefore, in viewof his failure to comply with clause-11 ofthe advertisement, his candidature has rightly been rejected by respondent No.1. 4. Heard leaned counsel for the parties. 5. This Court shall firstconsider the argument regarding deelaration of his candidature as ineligible on the grourid ttiat he has not furriished No Objection Certificate byemployer. 6. In this connection, clause-11 of the advertisement needs to be referred whichisreproducedhereunder:- "All the candidates,wl1o are alread^ in Govemment 9ervice or in any Government undertaking or in any type of other organization or appointed in Non- Government institution, should send their applications throuah Droper channel to the Registry. If any candidate sends his application fQnTi^through proper channel and it reaches theRegistry with delay.such application shall be treated as time barred and shall not be considered, even though, it might have been presented before the Employer before thelast date. The person who is working on permanent or , temporary basis ih Government Service or employed - lelsewhere, are required to submit uhdertaking to the effect thatthey have informed in written tothe Headof 3L|} BuiuiLujed lusiuiuiodde ^o uus) 94} 0} se pej sqi •luaLussiyeApE p siujat SL|) 4}iM souepjoooe ui suoiieoiidde 94} 6uisssoojd iou puB Buiieujuuosip jo pesnooe sq p|noM I.'ON }uapuodssj 'peioefsj }ou si 9jn(Bp!pUBo equi •ejntepipueo 8t|( Buiiosfej ui p9y!isnfA|9}n|osqe si |."ON tuspuodssj 'psjey} soussqe 3L|t 01 pue AJO}EPUBLU SBM eieoyiijeo uoipsfqo QN.fo uoissiiuqns '9}eoyi}j90 uoiiosfqo ON liujqnsoi pojinbej si tueoiidde 84} leyi uoiiejeioep |E3Uo68tBO E sa^euj IUSLUSSIIJSAPE 941 p i, |.-snse|o U34M '^!ieBe||! Aue LUOJJ jeyns pu ssop ajntepipueo s.jauoiijisd QtQ io uoipsfaj }eqi peysiies si ]jno3 SILII 'sjsded 941 L|6nojL)i suoB pue ssifjed syt jo^ |asunoo psujeei pjeay 6UIAEJ-) •6 •peyitsnfsiajniepipueo siq p uoiioefej 'snqi •lujoj uoiieoiidde p uoissiiuqns ^o SLUit 84) }B soueisixe ui ueAe }QU seMtuaiunoopsiLii'ejo^ejeqi.'i.i.oz 'eunp ^QI. uo penssi uaeq seq Q/d-s.inxsuuvpueK.oz 'iydy ^,9 SBM Lujojuoiieoiidde p uo.issiujqns JQJ siBpiSBi 941 •uoiieoiiddesLit IJIIM Buoie pauiujqns }OUSEM 'g/d -9jnxeuuv ui psuoiiueiu uaeq seQ SB 'eiBoyjtjao uoffoefqo ON iiuiqns oi lueoiidde ai|) jo^ Ajesseoeu }ou SBM 11 (Eqi pej 941 jo }U8LU}uiodde .>o iuja( SLjtiey} pan6je ^ON luapuodsej JQ^ |9sunoo paujesi 'esuodsoj u| 8 •8)B3!j!lj9o uoiioefqo ON iituqnsoi pejinbej }ou SEM jeuojijiad eqi 'lueLuiuioddeaLii uiiujs} siq} ^o MBIA ui 'iesunoo peujeei o} Buipjooov •lediouud 34} L|6nojqi eiues 941 Buiujiuqns p luaiuejinbej ou sq lieys 8J9L)} pue Aitoejip uoiieoiidde SAOUJ o) psiiflus aq ||BL|S sstuiodde eqt tsod J9i<}o Aue JQ^ uoiteo.iidde SUIAOLU joj lEijt lueujiuioddB^o SLuje} 94( jo [.i.-ejed ui psuoiiusiu si 11 '^•ON luspuodssj •s-! j9Ao|dtue siq Aq psnssi luaiuiuiodde ^o sujje} a^ w teqis! jeuoiiiisd eq} JQJ lesunoo peuesi Aq pesiej uoiiueiuoQ 'uoiieoiidde siq I^IM 6uo|e eieoijiyso qons Aue peyiLuqns }ou sey pue jeAoiduis srq Aq penssi steoyiijao uoipefqooN iiiuqnso} pejmbej SBM jauoiiiisd eqt 'Aipeuiiupv •z ^sjntepipueo ji94i BUJISOUBO Aqejsi)} pepefoj sq ||eqs uoitBoiidde jieii} ujexe pies eL|t JQJ jeadde o} A|dde Q} iuei|} Buiyiiujed IQU Bu!pje6ej jeAoidiue Jie^t luoj^ jeuai AuesaAiaoej /JisiSey l\ ysiQ puiiu ui dae>| pinpys eiBpipuBQ •uoiteuiuiBxs SIL)} jo^ pai|dde SAeq A941 teyi }U8Luyedep / soy^o jisyi 1>..>-. '^^ '1= aSpnt ,^^A eiqsiVi-1"'" '.,ps SAjeg •pessiujsipAqsjeqsipuEsiiejuoiiiiediuMiueisujeqi'iinsejsqiuri.i. •s8sodjnd||B jo^ pepafej suieiuajt!lunoo 8Uo uo peyitsnf S! uoipefai 941 ^! ssneoeq 'IBBeiiiseM eBe J9AO jp punojB eL|} uo uoiieoiidde siq 10 uoiioefsj IUEAJSS tU9Luuj3A09 Ouisq ^o (unoooe uo }et(} J9uoji!}9d sqi Aq pesiej s}U9LunBje J841P Buiuiiuexs »ou si ynoQ siqt 'pepefaj AnyBu SBMUoiieoiiddB 34} eieoyjijao uoitoalqo pNjo uoisSiujqns-uoujopuncuBsqiuo eouis-oi. •jeuo!}!}9d eq» p JSAoidiua-eq} Aq eteoyiijeo uoiioafqo ON p }UBM JQJ uoiieoiidde 941 pef9J oi }nq uoi}do jeqio ou pet) [.•ON luspuodsej 'ejojejsqt 'peziuiinjos &J9M suoitEoiidde 8q^u94M 9}ep 34} uo Atuoqtne pies QV^ ajojeq }ou SBM g/d-ajnxeuuv se ' [.-ON tuapuodsej jo 8Bpa|Mou>| 341 uiyiiM iou SBM StBsyiijao uoiioejqo ON inoqliM Altoaiip uoiteoiidde SAOLU ot jauoiiited -«(,.