@ Wxo’a] A mi mm; BEFORE THE HON’BLE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILAsPUR LC.G.) OF 2011 w.P.(S) No. / Santosh Kumar Tiwari, S/ o Shri Madhusudan Tiwari, Upper Division Teachel; aged about 45 Years, Govt; Middle School, ‘ Bundela, P.O. Rahod Tah. Pamgarh, District. Janjgir Champa C.G. gzoL PETITIONER ' VERSUS State of Chhattisgarh (C.G.) Through The Secretaiy Education Department D.K.S Bhawan Raipur (C.G.) 2. /Director Public Instruction Raipur (C.G.) 3. 6istrict Education officer Janjgir Champa District Janjgir Champa (C.G.) WRIT PETITON UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA 1. “ (Q ,HEGH CGE’RT GF CHEATT§$§§RH AT EELA$PUR $E : HGK‘$LE MR. JEESTEQE PRETE§KER BXW$KER Wjawww s2wg2011 ?ETHT!{§NE£ Saamsh Kumar "E‘iwmi ‘fél‘S'iiS RE$?OME3E§€’£‘S Smta MC, I}, {Rn Othei‘s Smi gomkar: Vanna cmmwl 11x tin: pat‘izémmr. 8hr; $.V.S§3riéhm‘. DV. AG. far the: Siaic‘ WEQE'E‘ P’E’FETI‘lH UNEEER A$TICLE 22% £3}? TEiiE C-GM$’FETifTEQM @F HQ§§E& $2§RUER geiwgw 11 The. p€iiu633ery w‘im was. appammd (m tilt: paw. 9f ASUJ‘N? (1Q T€tach€r u‘udiiy th6 Scheoi Ekiucafjan Dcparmiamt 911 131219$ {Pimxcmxw Pf 1} is aggricvw éw the. actima of trim rwmwmilml‘t‘g m DO§ ad i‘zm ‘nw atlvauca mcm s ix: his Saiam‘ 6mm tacuga 1 1 he: :‘i‘iC‘i his EEC?” from Pt“ $um'isrlaj Shaxma (men Umvarsin; Biiaspur 3?. his own (:05? an 18.4.2011 aftar saskiug yamission far €hxa $ame from the, cisnarrmént. Cougsai for tin: psm‘ienar submit$ ma}; tha platitionw is {Emma} fm- two alvanm mammaats as ha had obfajmm 1 3;“; an: x:{pxaanméitima certificata m accoriiance with th€ pmvi$imm G?" (Tifrcuiar (kiwi 24.12.98 and in View of me j'udgmsnis' 6f Han’bis Supremf; Comft in ’rbe. mam? 0f State @f M3. & Anashw Vs. gatiriimrqgm .éclzwya am: others rqmmaé in 1Q96 $C‘ 2??§ and Ywskwant Kamar 3%arwmy’ Vs. Muyiiiecipaz {farparatiaay $m‘g ami wwfhaer E‘epi;mmi in 290$ mg WJEQ 95 {€36} On t‘zm othfir hand, mauaSfil fo'i" iha Sam submits That Ea‘stwhiltt ‘ Stmg: m" Madhya Pradfsh vjrlc C‘iretiiar data}? 22.10.?9é4 aEmmd a<iva11c€ mcramems 0113‘] ta thatase g’IVEmm‘érit :mn‘auffs Whr} gamcaedea'i for mammg "ago to 2’2. 3.0. 19é4 w; imbasr at his awn Pest or m Tim gw&mm&nt Lea? Hmmivain Wha proceewiéd on training m: m‘ 21%.: 23.}{).1)9fi4 can giit ’MT) (armaa1 incmmtmts ouiv if ‘t%m traimag i3 at his costtéj‘1ti 11m "t {ha cost Qf thf: GGVEI’mmEut. Thi$ circ war 0f da$m3 234G.1964§ was su-gxétrceqied Vida ordar éa‘ucd, M).."2..}975. Th€ x ‘ m i Government Vida notjjitatjon daied $6.6.1973 amemmd MP. Nan— Gazetts C1ass—i1 Educaiional Servic:as !N0n‘co}hgi3 Sewices} Rscruitmént and Promotion RUks, $93 aérkd qualificatkm of BIN. or B.Ed tiegree: for appaimmént on m6 post ofASsisi‘ant Taacher. ‘?he gistitione? wouid b6 {imitkd for acfEvanvE: incrermmts aniv m fhe celididon that ha kiwi abtaina§ his BE’jPEdfB.T.£. (Eagreé at his own cost duziag smviee aftar cbtetimng petm£$5i0n fmm the departmaiit batwmn 23,10.1964 $0 .899 To clarifv the above pasi‘donf circu£ars haw: alreadv hsfm i§$1§eci {m 6.21339? am} 0m 3G.1.09. Fads, ¢s tititailfjd. aibom‘ am n01 in {iisyuta This Caurt in the maimr of E’ashwant Kamar Bhm-adwq {swarm dabwrataly discussing the circuEars dated 24. £2.98” 1.3.gg and relying; upsn the jurigment 0f the Hon’ble A196): Court in th€ matter of Bwrmaraywt achwca’5 ease ($upra} .133 1mm mat feacham, m): awisfant taachers alona, wouki bf: antithd to two advaxma iacmmcms, (m ohiajning BEd Exammation cattiiicatt: aftm‘ 22.10.1964, ag fhB circ‘uiar aiatmi 22.10. 1964 (iaas nut pr€$<3rib¢ aiiv Qatar iimit of 1th? pmior} sf ohtajmrjg ELEzi MEd $5 ELTJ. certificais. it has héen fm‘thar Edi}. Thai circuiar datfid 1.3.9?) is apg‘:§icab1a tn (mEV Ami‘imxan-t Taachers {LDT‘} aux? mat to Omar icachars fU‘D’E‘}. Shn' Thakur fairly submits that prizicipk: of law Ea'jd down ix} ¥aShwant Kumay Bharaéwaj’S; cage t1$upra} bar's: a$’f‘ai1]€d finalifv anii caSe of tha pei‘jtioner :a €hi$ wriitkm is 31% squamEy {taverad by the aimve ju§gmemt as. aim) circt‘mlar dated 24. 1.2. i998. w (01‘ me: 1 afercsaid reasmas. thE peiimiamer n satifm& ta: me pa; mail: af Wm advarim ig’ici‘amatms fmm thta aia’m 0f daclaj‘a'tian of iht‘: pcititimaér’s' BE-d. exam‘atioa mSuEt. Tha raSpmmems ale accvrdmgiy dirccmd to maka paymsnt 0f may advance meremems m mt: petitiotmr from mt: dam ofhis pa$sing 31%. €xamination. w€thiu a ytiriod of fmlr mmlthS {i‘om tariay. How m‘, 3his orditr sbaU b6 subject to a1} ' {irifacations made by thr; Stem régm‘dmg fads plceadad in xhe nem‘tion.‘ Sd/- Pritinker Diwakar Judge x h?mo omfxr i as t0 €0$i$.