"^- IKTHEHIGHCtWRT^fe^CHHATI^CrARH^ATBU.ASPUR W/ritAppeal Np. ./2010 AppeUant/ Petitioner IlespondentS/ RespQhdents Versus •K"' -- -2' M/s S. ^ S. Eriterprises, A partnership I'^rm, througti Partner SubMash Ruinar Agarwal, aged about 4©years, S/Q Late Sfan Bab^al Ji MitM, ^R/a^^^^^J Bilaspur, Bilaspur (C.G.) .; State of ChhaNisgarH, tht^u SeGretary, Departnient bf Coinmercial Tax, Mantralaya, D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipiur '(c^':v':.:/:'''^ Chha.l^sgarh Stale Minor Forest Prodi-iee tTra:daigj^^J3j^lopment)G6-opeFa^ -ii;^d^^ta^n,gS^.^ througli 'i • Managing ^BiEeGteig;a|25,^'VIP.'l;Estafe,. .'near : VIP: •'Glub^jg;^ElmaEdili,:. :l^]3ankaF'^': Nagar, 3. ^ © Q^^ flommercial Tax, Vanijyik KarBKawan,eivitLines,Raipur(C.G.) 4./^ ^TOiioii1. of'. In^ Departmertt of Conimerctal Tax,^ N ••'Delhi.' ';':' •;.'•: :,<f'.^ ::"-:;'.'... •WW^^i mM.^MS ^^,^SE^N@W^S^{^S^ESs'^K^ <2HH^l'llSi£Ai^§Sa®Bi;I®iIJRtslVB»®Eri^^^ BENGHlSJMg^;i2MB06y%-3.':;i-:-'^;^ .,.fesS:'"'s<^ ^- (§^^'Si ^ 'y A- SV^I W i<.|i<h ^^TSH^WqW d-a=i •^iiiyi, ofll'y'Ko, ^cfl'y^ »-^...U3.fc.-.U.S:.^\.S.. Wvn (bH|t(»"—----""-—-"""-"--^ 200 sn^r'q^q? (1pf3^st:i) TO11W ^lftff 311^'CT 1^.4.2011 -1_ Shri Ravindra Shrivastava, Ashish Shrivastava, Shri Naveen Shri Devendra Patel, Shri Rake; Advocate, Shri Abhishek Oswal, Sl Smiti Sharma, Shri Pankaj Shri Ajay Mishra, Shri Ankit Singl| Mishra and Shri Dheeraj Kumar appeals. ShriA.S. Kachhawaha.Dy. Shri Kishore Bhaduri, counsf Common judgment has b^ Vyas & others Vs. State of Chhatti^ Signed and dated. Certified copy as per rules Sd/- Dhirendra Mishra Judge qiiffiiili ii*K'iF4 Ce^S <R<^;|< '^'STRPTSTI^T Sr. Advocate, Shri Anup Majumdar, Shri P^kash, Shri Anup Jain, Shri Harsh Wardhan, (h Ranjan Agrawal, Shri G.N. Purohit, Sr. ri Anand Dadariya, Shri Neelabh Dubey, Smt. Shriva^tava, Shri Parag Kotecha, Shri Ajay Singh, hal, Shri B.D. Guru, Shri H.S. Patel, Shri V. IWankhede, for the appellants in respective Uvocate General for the State/respondent. 3t for the Federation. . in delivered in W.A.No.452/2010 (Mte K.K. garh & others), including this appeal. afong with main judgment. Sd/- R.N. Chandrakar Judge <ro<^^*(!jCTRil(,([W];<,i(B—F.S.'147—20010—1,00,000.