1|}!», ^u -78 sn^v w ft-ii'b iw sn^i *Mi=t> ^ *n*<nra»*ii<!h ^Sf •^W\W<1, WV\WIQ, P^WWj^ t^p. (LS; h(o. l^7°8 :"^200 sn^?T Tra^ (lic<td'<<S,'ET) ?^<nw ^itei 3)i^?r PBTITIONBR Mc C14?uhan, vlU^ige Talsi! Versas RESPONDEWTS 1. Stite SetTetary D. 2. Thfe Pelisiou (C 3. Thfc District Education Officer, Raigarh strict Raigarh (CG) Th|e Block Bducation OflBcer, Block Office JE.O.) Saxangarh, Distt. Ra^arh (CG) WWT PETITION UWDBRlARTICLB 226 OF TOUB COirenTUTIOM Dii 4. Thfc (Bjl SB: HOW. SHRI DHIREHDlt 3-2-2009 Shri Dhaniram Patel, Siat Siaita Ghai, Pea^c Learued couasel for who -was appointed as anl after attauung the age of s^per. of Head laaater. The respoj and without affording s^ay impugned order ofAnncxut1 ofau amount ofRs. 84,53^ <T)l<l[CT<i1l •WT^fl' tf f^yl •CH>|^|< ^aifinan^r |hit Lal Chouhan, son of lafe Sirkolo agcd about 63 years, R/o ^ge Madhopali, Post OflBce Daasara, Sarangarh, distt Raigprh (CG) of CtaIiattisgaA, fhrough the ', School Educatkm Departmcnt, (.S. Bhawan, Raipur (CO) Joiat Director, Treasuiy Account and Divisiou Bilaspui', Disll. Bilaspui- ') OFiMDIA tA MISHRA. J |Adv. for the pctitioncr. tel Lawyer, for fhe Statc. |the petitfoncr submits that fhc petitioner, Assistaat T'eacher on 1-10-1963, retired tperannuation on 30-6-2007 fix>m fhe post ident No. 2 without asaigning any reason opportunily of hearing passed the P-3 dated 22-11-2007 dnccting recovery '- fixiin the retu-al dues ofthe petitioncr. ir'e I..HG—78 sDiSf^r'I^N? raaii^r'aitiN; ^ iUlV €. ^, *11W(1 •5b*irai 3^ •<<wwif, wSwi'c, hwvy. bo»- C^ /J-&- W/o% •""(H. 200 3ii^?iTR?i' ('^ifg'i^i) wiiwflfeisn^i direc^ing Leamed counsel for (S) No. 5076/2008 involvml passed on 15-9-2008 and also. In view of fhe petitioaer, this petition is 2007 (Annexure P-3) account ofexcess payinent| The petitloncr is entifled t4 without anv deduction. petitioncr is entitied to fh4 6% per aiuium. However, step, if so advised, in ofnatural justice. flie petitioner furthCT submits tliat in W.P. fe the identical question, ordcrs have been :|inu]ar order may be passed iu fhis petition < ; ^I^ta<(ii 'RF^ff ^f 'fe^ Tf^5H ^7 siRn aii^si subm^sion made by thc leai-acd counscl for the 4Uowed. Ttae impugned order dated 22-11- recoveiy of a svaa. of Rs. 84,534/- on |inade to the petitKiner, is hereby quashed. fult pensionary benefits/grattiily amoiiat V the ainount has beea recoveaed, IIie said amount with interest at the rate of ft is open to fhe respondents to take any acca^dance with l&w foQowiag basic principles Sd/- DbirendraMistu-a ^ Judge 1