In THE HIGH COURT or JUDxCATURE CHEATTISGARH AT BILAS?UR w.P No 675' /2002 1° N.M.D.C Officers Association Through: Its Secretary, Sri Kapil Thapar, S/o Sri A M Thapar, aged abcut 42 years BIOP Deposit No 14; Kirandnl Distt. Dentewada,chhattisgarh N M D C Supervisors Association Through: Its Presiaent Sri I D Mishra, S/o j Late . ‘ Sri R N Mishra, Deposit No 14 ; Kirandul, Distt. Dentewada ‘ Chhattisgerh. Metal Mine Workers Union(INTUC) g Through: Its Secretary, ‘ ‘ sri Sukoo Ram Kashyap S/o Late Nadi Ram aged about 48 years. Deposit No 14 it Kirandul,Distt. Dentewada, Chhattisgarh Samyukta Khadon Mazdoorr.sangh (AITUC) Nmnc Deposit No 14 Kiranaul, Distt. Dentewedai, Chhatt1Sgarh. Through: ts Genral Secretary Sri R D C P Rao Versus RESPONDENTS: Union o£ india. 1‘ Through: Joint Secretary, L» Govt. of India, Ministry of {i Finance,Deptt. of Revenue, " North Block New Delhi ‘e 2. Central Board of Direct Taxes, Through: its Chairman, North Block, New Delhi a. Commissioner, income Tax; Raipur-Chhattisgazh 4. The Chairman. NatiOnal Mineral Development Corporation 10-3-311/E Castle Hills Masab Tank‘ ggderabad. PETITIONER UNDER ARTICLE 226é227e03 THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA 1. Particulars of the petitioners: : As shown above in‘the cause title. 2. Particulars of the Respondents: you ¢ As shown above in the case title. 0.02 g ‘ ¢§QAR£ : £Q§V§LE §k§§i¥ §-§€E§é’%éu§ & 95T§E§§¥§i§a > 5E§ N $3. NAYé’xK, 53$ EHR! ‘aiuK. $H€§¥é§¥é§¥ , é. ‘§“€.?. §Aée $23 m‘ 2%}2 Baico OWCérS Asmciatian Through iis President Shri SS. Baghei Balccnagar, Di5tt. Kama (0G,) }15%$5‘§ x“ Unicn 9f indéa Through the Secretary Canit‘ai Board Gf Direct Taxes, Nnrth Block New Delhi. (33 l“‘ } hart Numinium Ca. Lid hmugh Ea Mamging Directcr ’a conagar, Dist: Korba (CG) Prasent t Shri PS. Koshy, !eamed caunse! forthe petitianer. lndia/‘regpondent No. 1. Shri Amét Chaudhafi, Earned $€anding CGunge! far Umon 3f Shri Prashan‘t Jayaswal; Iearned Sr. Advacate with Shri S. ‘g’ER5i5 R§S§QM€§£§€$§ a” )p Present : Sm $. 6} _ HgrawaL !eamed cgun$e! farthe 3m Amit Chaudhar‘, india/‘regpandemé; “JG. Sankalp Caa! Mines Officers asgsaciatiom 3f imiiia: thiough Sri RN. iviukhopadhaya, President, SECJ... Branch, Biia$pur Shri RN. Mmhapadhyay Sb. Late Shri P Mukhopacihyay, Legal Manager, E.C.L‘ Biia$pur (CG) Uninn 0f india, Tnmugn Central Baard 0f Direci' Taxes, North Biock, New Deihi Coal india Limited, Threugh Chairman, 10 Netnii $ubnas~3h Pinad, Knikata Eioutn Eastern Coalfields Limited inrough Chairm—cum-ivlanaging Director, Seepat Reee, Bilaseur (Chhattiegarhl l petitianers. med‘Standing CeLsneel f0? Unian 0% we gee-me e i. w 1w M EH ? a}? 2gQ2 . gee: N. MSC Qffieerg Associaticn Thmugh : its Executive Member Sri K9 \Iijayan, Sfo KP Parameshwaran Piiiai aged abeut :58 years, R/e Quarrier Type 3f.’i5, BIOP Depeeh N . 5 Eacheli, K3 %¥% e Distt. Dantewada, Chh&tt§ag3rh 2. 3 K M S, ‘Fhrough ltg Execu‘iive Member Sri T J Shankar Rao B l Q P Deposit No5 Bache”, Distt‘ Dantewadax Chhattiggarh M M W U, (Meta! Mmeg Workgfa Unian) Through : its Executive Member J K Shrivaaatava, BIOP D$p£3sit F405, Bacheli Disti. Dantewada, Chhattisgarh ¥E%%ii$ A.- $§Q§§§§N§$ Unim of india Through : Joint $ecretaly, {BOW of india Ministry 0f Finance, Depth of Revenue, North Bbck New Semi 2. Central Board Qf r Ergm‘. Taxag, Through its Chairmah North Block New Delhi Cemmlasla .er, lncome Tex, Ralpur ti, The Chairman, National Mlheral Develoomeni Cormoratlon Ltd, 13-3—31 l/A Castle l-lllle Masab Tank Hyderabad Presem : Shh PS. Koshy, learned couneel for rhe petltloners. Shrl Amlt Chaudharl, learned Standing Counsel for Union of indlairespondehts‘. No. ’l & 2 $1.9, MegQé—a g? 2£$$2 ?i='€‘§'§'l@.¥¥%% ‘l . Rashlrlya Taap Vldyut Karmachari Sahgh, Reg. No. 2832 through its General Secretary Mohammad Rizwan, SID Late Faklr Mohmmau, aged about 48 years, We 84365, Krlehna Vihar, NTP‘C. Jamni'pali, Kerba, Tahell & District Korba (CC-3.) 2 v.8, Ottalwar, Slo Shri CM. Oitalwer, egeié ‘58 years, President Rashtriya Taap Vidyut Karmaohari Sangh, Korba, Rio Tilak Nagar, Bliaepur (CG) ‘gé’ $L9$ EE$P§€£E§§§E$ L- Union of lnrjia Through its Secrerary, Ministry of Finance, New Delhi—110001 Senna! Beard of Direcr Taxee, Government or indie, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, New Delhi through its Secretary 3. National Thermal Power Corporation of indie N.T,P.C. Bhawan, Scope Complex, Ledhi Read, New Delhi a 110 D33 4. Jeint Secretary, Department er Public Enterprises, Government of indie, CGO. Comniex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi. I\J Preeent : Shri v.0 Oiralwar, iearned counsel for the oetitinnere. Shri Amir Chaudhari, learned Standing Ceungel for Unien er indie/respondents No. 1,2 and ail Shri PS. Koshv, learned couneei for respondent No3. ‘4 g? . w ¥¥P. $éq§33 {if 26$; 8tee! Wmkera Union GNTUC}, Rag. N6. 23’? ihrough its Gemeral Secretary Gajendra Singh, S/o Late $hri SN. Singh, aged abaut 56 years? We Q‘Na. S-A, Streat ’13, Secfcr 8, Bhi§ai DisMct ‘ Burg (CG) ‘v’§%§§%§§ R§§PQ$§$EN§R§ Um’cm 0f {ndia Shri lndialreépondents Whit Chaudhari No’. i2 Rsamed and 4; bianding Counsel for Unian o? “*3i1 E’ ££§££§3 1 ”E1 P MG §?5 0f QQQQ N. M .DC. Officem A$aGciati0n Through 1 Ii's SeCfetary, $ri Kapii Thapar, 8/0 Sri A M Thapar, aged about 42 veam BzQP Degagzt No4 14, Kirandua bisu, Dantewada, Chha‘ttisgafn N M DC Supervisors Association Through Rs President Sri 2 D Mishra, Sr’o Late Sri R N Miohi‘a, Dopoaii i'oid, Kifaodui, Disti. Dantewada, Chhattisgaii’i Metal Mine Workers Union (INTUC) Through : its Secretary, 8r; Sukoo Ram Kashyap Sio Lato Nadi Ram aged about 48 years, Deposit No.14 Kirandui, Distt. Dantewacia, Chhatiisgarh Samyukio Khacian Mazdoor 8angh (Airuo) Nuoo Deposit Nam Kira—our, Distto Dantewada, Chha‘ttisgarh. Through : its Genera! Secretary Sr; R D C P Rae wee! e Umori of i‘n‘dia Through ; Joint Secretary, Govi of india Ministry of Financex Depth of Revenue, North Biook New Deihi Centrai Board of Direot Taxea \\)/ (j! £§59$§¥§§§x§$ )3% Thmugh i‘ts ~Secretary, Minisix‘y‘ of Finance, New Delhi—710001 2. Central Bgard 9f Direci Taxeg) Gwemment cf india, Ministry gf Fmama Departmeni of Revenue, New Dethi through its SeCretarv 3. ChairE’xan, Sieel iAuthority 0f SndQa Limited, ispat Bhawan, Lcdhi Road, New Delhi 110003 4. Mangging Directar, Bhiiai~8teel Mam, BhHai District Durg (CG) Presam : $hri VC. Qttakwar, !eamed saunas} far the m étianer‘ Through : its Chairman North Biock New Deihi Commissioner, income Tax, Raipur Chnatiisgarh The Chairman, Nationai Mineral DEvelopment Cafporatbn Ltd. 10-3-3111A Castle Hilis Masab Tank Hyderabad. Present : Shri RS Koshy, learned ceunsel for the petitioners Shri Amit Chaudhari, learned Standing Counsel for Unlen of India/respondents No. ’l & 2‘ ORAL QRDER iPasged am 15$ Nevember, 20%) The fellowing aral order 0f the Caurt was passed by 5R. N%YAK, $1.! . Learned cmmsel appearmg for all the parties would submit that the paint that arises far decisian-making in this batch cf writ petitione is quarely eevered by the decieion at the Hen’ble Supreme Ceurt in the caee of Aum Kumar & Gthers Vs. Union of india & ere}. in view of the above joint submission made by learned counsel appearing for the parties, these writ petitiens are dispesed of in terme of the above iudgmerit of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. Ne costs. l *"‘_T[Lv,m‘ V.K. Shrivastava j‘ ‘ Sd/- Chief Justice Judge 1 . JT 2005(1 2) SC 1.21 Snbtw - s