IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA LPA No.981 of 2005 1. Smt. Rita Devi, W/o Rajesh Kumar Rai, Kendra/Village- Chautarva Rafusee Colony. 2. Smt. Anjana Devi, W/o Sanjay Kumar Pal, Kendra/village Chautarva Pokhra Tola. 3. Smt. Sangandhi Kumari, W/o Radhe Shyam Yadav Kendra/Village- Chautarva. 4. Smt. Munni Pandey, W/o Narvadeshwar Pandey, Kendra/village- Bara Lagunah. 5. Smt. Anju Devi, W/o Prahalad Prasad, Kendra/Village- Lagunaha Chawk Tola. 6. Smt. Annuradha Devi, W/o Madhurendra Rao, Kendra/Village- Chobriya. 7. Smt. Priyanka Devi, W/o Durgesh Kumar Rao, Kendra/Village- Lagunaha. 8. Smt. Usha Devi, W/o Ashok Shani, Kendra/Village- Ahirauliya Purv Tola. 9. Smt. Bindu Devi, W/o Amar Narayan Sahani, Kendra/Village- Ashirauliya, Pacchim Tola. 10. Smt. Usha Devi, W/o Harendra Yadav, Kendra/Village- Chautarva Paras Nagar. 11. Smt. Priyanka Rao, W/o Shiv Prasad, Kendra/village- Lagunaha Karkhana Tola. All belonging to Panchayat Lagunahan Chautarva of Prakhand Bagha I. District- W. Champaran. 12. Smt. Munni Devi, W/o Amit Singh, Kendra/Village- Nadda Parsauni Dakchhin. 13. Smt. Ruby Devi, W/o Deepak Singh, Kendra/Village- Sikti. 14. Smt. Sumitra Devi, W/o Ved Prakash Rao, Kendra/Village- Madhya Vidyalaya, Nadda. 15. Smt. Sanil Devi, W/o Krishna Mohan Rao, Kendra/Village- Dakchhin Mandir Tola, Nadda. 16. Smt. Meera Singh, W/o Sanjay Rao, Kendra/Village- Panchayat Bhawan, Nadda. 17. Smt. Kumari Rajnigandha @ Kumari Rajani, W/o Brijnandan Singh, Kendra/Village- Uttar Mandir Tola, Nadda. 18. Smt. Pratima Devi, W/o Sheshnath Kumar, Kendra/Village- Thar Tola, Bhairoganj. 19. Smt. Kumari Priyanka, W/o Madan Kumar Gupta, Kendra/Village-Baluahwa Tola, Bhairoganj. 20. Smt. Guriya Kumari, W/o Ranjan Kumar Pandey, Kendra/Village- Inarbarba. 2 All belonging to Panchayat Nadda of Prakhand Bagha I. District- W. Champaran. 21. Smt. Chanda Devi, W/o Amrendra Upadhyay, Kendra/Village- Manjhariya Samudayik Bhawan Dakchhin Tola. 22. Smt. Anita Devi, W/o Kamlesh Upadhyay, Kendra/Village- Manjhariya Dakchhin Tola. All belonging to Panchayat Bansgaon Manjhariya of Prakhand Bagha I. District- W. Champaran. 23. Smt. Pratima Kumari, W/o Satyaprakesh Satyarthi, Kendra/Village- Vishnupoorva Madhyawari Tola, Panchayat- B.B. Bankatwa. 24. Smt. Usha Devi, W/o Dhananjay Kumar Mishra, Kendra/Village- Parsauni Uttar Tola. 25. Smt. Shashi Devi, W/o Parduman Narayan Singh, Kendra/Village- Noniyapatti. 26. Smt. Poonam Devi, W/o Chandra Bhushan Singh, Kendra/Village- Banggaon Madhya Tola. 27. Smt. Veena Devi, W/o Sunil Kumar Shukla, Kendra/Village-Bansgaon, Uttar Tola. All belonging to Panchayat Bansgaon Manjharia of Prakhand Bagha I. District- W. Champaran. 28. Smt. Seema Devi, W/o Jeetendra Kumar Verma, Kendra/Village- Bargaon, Uttar Tola. 29. Smt. Sunita Devi, W/o Upendra Thakur, Kendra/Village- Ekderva Bargaon. 30. Smt. Kanti Devi, W/o Umesh Prasad, Kendra/Village- Baragaon Dakkhin Tola. 31. Smt. Sunita Devi,W/o Sanjay Singh, Kendra/Village- Kotia, Bargaon. 32. Smt. Indrasani Devi, W/o Bhagwati Prasad Yadav, Kendra/Village- Navka Tola, Bargaon. 33. Smt. Mamta Shahi, W/o Siddheshwar Shahi, Kendra/Village- Bargaon, Madhya Tola. 34. Smt. Poonam Devi, W/o Pinku Singh, Kendra/Village- Chotaki Pathi, Bargaon. 35. Smt. Priti Kumari, W/o Ashish Kumar Pandey, Kendra/Village-Belva, Bargaon. All belonging to Panchayat Baragaon of Prakhand Bagha I, District- W. Champaran. 36. Smt. Shyam Dulari Devi, W/o Chandeshwar Batha, Kendra/Village- Choutarva Dakhin Tola, District- W. Champaran. 3 37. Smt. Afreeda Parveen, W/o Late Gulab Ansari, Kendra/Village- Koluha Khalihan Tola. 38. Smt. Pushpa Devi, W/o Kanchan Ram, Kendra/Village- Koluha Dakhin Tola. 39. Smt. Mohtalat Jabeen, W/o Md. Anwar Jamal, Kendra/Village- Choutarba Chowk Tola. 40. Sarswati Kumari, W/o Manoj Kumar, Kendra/Village- Menhdi Aagan Bari Kendra. 41. Smt. Mamta Kumari, W/o Rajesh Patel, Kendra/Village- Pakri Dakhin Tola. 42. Smt. Archana Kumari @ Kumari Archana Mishra, W/o Ajay Kumar Mishra, Kendra/Village- Garhaiya Aagan Bari Kendra. 43. Smt. Shashi Kumari, W/o Nand Kishore Tiwary, Kendra/Village- Pakri Uttari Tola, Ward No.10. 44. Smt. Shakuntala Kumari, W/o Nagendra Ram, Kendra/Village- Siktour Dakhin Tola. 45. Smt. Reena Devi, W/o Late Upendra Shrivastava, Kendra/Village- Siktaur Uttari Tola. All belonging to panchayat Koluha Chautarva of Prakhand Bagha I, District- W. Champaran. 46. Smt. Sunita Devi, W/o Sunil Tiwary, Kendra/Village- Padarkhap Bari Tola. 47. Smt. Shalini Devi, W/o Vikas Prasad Soni, Kendra/Village- Barki Bhaishin. 48. Smt. Usha Devi, W/o Ajay Singh, Kendra/Village- Padarkhap Mauja Tola. 49. Smt. Niharika Devi @ Niharika Kumari, W/o Brij Kishore Dewidi, Kendra/Village- Shivrajpur. 50. Smt. Saroj Devi, W/o Balister Prasad Gupta, Kendra/Village- Harpur. 51. Smt. Nirmala Devi, W/o Nanhe Pandey, Kendra/Village- Harpur Poorvi Tola. All belonging to Panchayat Bhaishi Padarkhap of Prakhand Bagha I, District- W. Champaran. 52. Smt. Radha Kumari Devi, W/o Sunil Kumar Pandey, Kendra/Village- Laxmipur. 53. Smt. Sunita Devi @ Sunita Mishra, W/o Kamlesh Kumar Mishra, Kendra/Village- Kapardhikka. 54. Smt. Sangeeta Devi, W/o Sanjay Kumar Rao, Kendra/Village- Sirisiya. 55. Smt. Reeta Sharma @ Reeta Devi, W/o Rajeshwar Sharma, Kendra/Village- Jura Sahasrao Madhya Tola. 56. Smt. Seema Devi, W/o Dharmendra Kumar, Kendra/Village- Patkhouli. 4 All belonging to Panchayat Bhairoganj of Prakhand Bagha I, District- W. Champaran. 57. Smt. Alka Kumari, W/o Ravi Ranjan Singh, Kendra/Village- Aaurahiya. 58. Smt. Reena Verma, W/o Madhu Sudhan Prasad, Kendra/Village- Khora Parsa Tola. 59. Smt. Jagdamaba Kumari Mishra, W/o Rajesh Mishra, Kendra/Village- Dharampur Virti Tola. 60. Smt. Santaresa Devi, W/o Amar Kishore Ram, Kendra/Village- Parsa Harijan Tola. 61. Smt. Renu Devi, W/o Ashok Singh, Kendra/Village- Musahari Tola, Banchahri. 62. Smt. Meena Kumari @ Meena Devi, W/o Ramendra Kumar Rao, Kendra/Village- Parsa Dhobi Tola. 63. Smt. Pushpa Devi, W/o Madhusudan Pandey, Kendra/Village- Kurmi Tola Banchahri. All belonging to Panchayat Parsa Banchahri of Prakhand Bagaha I, District- W. Champaran. 64. Smt. Ghura Devi, W/o Sheshnath Ram, Kendra/Village- Dumariya. 65. Smt. Prema Devi, W/o Mithilesh Sharma, Kendra/Village- Amvaliya Dakhin Tola. 66. Smt. Punita Devi, W/o Surya Bhushan Shrivastava, Kendra/Village- Amialya Dakhin Tola. 67. Smt. Kiran Devi, W/o Upendra Mishra, Kendra/Village- Sigari Dakhin Tola. 68. Smt. Reena Devi, W/o Narendra Kumar Singh, Kendra/Village- Sigari Madhya Tola. 69. Smt. Kiran Devi, W/o Ramesh Chandra Mishra, Kendra/Village- Pipariya Pashchim Tola. 70. Smt. Ranjana Devi, W/o Ranjeet Kumar Shrivastava, Kendra/Village-Pipariya Madhya Tola. 71. Smt. Renuka Devi, W/o Narvadeshwar Thakur, Kendra/Village- Pipariya Poorvi Tola. 72. Smt. Ruby Devi, W/o Ravi Ranjan Singh, Kendra/Village- Sigari Uttari Tola. 73. Smt. Pratima Devi, W/o Shatrughan Sharma, Kendra/Village- Bardaha Dakhin Tola. All belonging to Panchayat Sigari Pipariya of Prakhand Bagha I, District- W. Champaran. 74. Smt. Bindu Devi, W/o Akhilesh Kumar, Kendra/Village- Barwa. 75. Smt. Vibha Devi, W/o Kiran Kumar, Kendra/Village- Siswa Madhya Tola. 5 76. Smt. Ambu Kumari, W/o Nawal Kishore Bharti, Kendra/Village- Siswa Brahama Asthan Tola. 77. Smt. Meera Devi, W/o Vipin Prasad, Kendra/Village- Basantpur Bazar Tola. 78. Smt. Shanaz Begum, W/o Late Kefayatullah, Kendra/Village- Basantpur Mauza Tola. 79. Smt. Vijya Laxmi Devi, W/o Sushil Prasad, Kendra/Village- Bhagwan Sagar Tola. All belonging to Panchayat Siswa Basantpur of Prakhand Bagha I, District- W. Champaran. …………….Petitioners……Appellants. Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR, through the Secretary cum Commissioner, Welfare Department, Bihar, Patna. 2. Director Social Welfare Deptt. Bihar, Patna. 3. The Collector cum District Magistrate, West Champaran. 4. The Child Development Project Officer, Sidhaw, Bagaha- I, West Champaran. 5. Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Bagaha, West Champaran. ….Respondents…Respondents. ----------- 07- 03.12.2010 None appears on behalf of the parties. This appeal under Clause 10 of the Letters Patent of the High Court of Judicature at Patna has been preferred by the petitioners of C.W.J.C. No.6057 of 2005 (Smt. Kanti Devi & others vs. The State of Bihar and others), praying therein for issuance of a writ of certiorari to quash the order bearing memo No.571, dated 28.4.2005, passed by respondent no.3 (Collector, West Champaran at Bettiah), and the consequential order no.121 dated 30.4.2005, issued by respondent no.4 (Child Development Project Officer, Sindhaw, Bagaha-I, West Champaran). By the impugned orders, the respondents have asked the Mukhias of Bagaha, 6 Circle I Prakhand, to convene a fresh Aam Sabha for selection of Aangan Bari Sevikas in Bagaha I Prakhand. They have also prayed in the writ petition for issuance of an appropriate order/direction to the respondents to produce a copy of letter of Director I.C.D.S., Directorate, Bihar, Patna, vide his letter No.26 dated 16.1.2005, and after production of the same, it may be quashed if necessary and for any other writ/order/direction to which they may be found entitled to. The writ petition has been dismissed by a learned Single Judge of this Court by order dated 3.8.2005, on the ground that the impugned action has been diluted by modifications of the orders impugned in the writ petition. We, therefore, do not find any merit in this appeal. It is accordingly dismissed. In the circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs. (S K Katriar, J.) (S P Singh J.) S.K.Pathak/ `