1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT JODHPUR :::: JUDGMENT 1 SBCWP NO.1199/2010 BEGRAJ Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 2 SBCWP NO.1200/2010 DHARAMPAL ARYA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 3 SBCWP NO.1233/2010 DILIP KUMAR JAIN Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 4 SBCWP NO.1234/2010 NIRMAL SINGH BHATI Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 5 SBCWP NO.1235/2010 KHEMRAJ DIWEDI & ANR. Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 6 SBCWP NO.1240/2010 VISHNU DAN CHARAN Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 7 SBCWP NO.1241/2010 DEVI LAL SHARMA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 8 SBCWP NO.1242/2010 SATYA NARAYAN Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 9 SBCWP NO.1251/2010 GOVIND SINGH Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 10 SBCWP NO.1252/2010 RACHPAL NAYAK Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 11 SBCWP NO.1253/2010 AMIN KHAN Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 12 SBCWP NO.1255/2010 RAM KISHORE SHARMA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 13 SBCWP NO.1317/2010 SMT. KAVITA BANSAL Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 14 SBCWP NO.1318/2010 JITENDRA KUMAR AGGARWAL Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 15 SBCWP NO.1324/2010 SMT. MADHU SHEKHAWAT Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 16 SBCWP NO.1325/2010 JAYDEEP KUMAR LOHAR Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 17 SBCWP NO.1327/2010 SACHAIN GORWA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 18 SBCWP NO.1328/2010 RAJESH SANADHYA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 19 SBCWP NO.1338/2010 LADU RAM & ORS. Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 20 SBCWP NO.1373/2010 NARENDRA KUMAR DELU & ANR Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 21 SBCWP NO.1375/2010 SHIV VISHNU Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 22 SBCWP NO.1376/2010 AMRA RAM Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 23 SBCWP NO.1382/2010 ASHUTOSH JOSHI Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 24 SBCWP NO.1383/2010 SMT. HEMLATA VAISHNAV & ORS. Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 25 SBCWP NO.1385/2010 SANTLAL & ORS Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 26 SBCWP NO.1387/2010 SUDESH KUMAR MARODIYA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 27 SBCWP NO.1403/2010 SHAILESH KUMAR PANDYA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 28 SBCWP NO.1415/2010 BHAGWATI SINGH Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 29 SBCWP NO.1416/2010 KAN SINGH Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 2 30 SBCWP NO.1417/2010 KAN SINGH RATHORE Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 31 SBCWP NO.1422/2010 CHAMPA LAL SUTHAR Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 32 SBCWP NO.1423/2010 SMT. LEENA CHANDRAS Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 33 SBCWP NO.1424/2010 PADAM SINGH RATHORE Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 34 SBCWP NO.1425/2010 LOON SINGH PARMAR Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 35 SBCWP NO.1426/2010 MANGI LAL Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ANR 36 SBCWP NO.1427/2010 MALA RAM Vs. STATE OF RAJ & ORS. 37 SBCWP NO.1428/2010 THANA RAM Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ANR 38 SBCWP NO.1429/2010 RAKESH KUMAR Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 39 SBCWP NO.1482/2010 DAYA BHATT & ORS. Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 40 SBCWP NO.1584/2010 SHAMBHU LAL Vs. THE STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 41 SBCWP NO.1700/2010 SITA RAM SHARMA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 42 SBCWP NO.1725/2010 KESHAR SINGH DEORA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 43 SBCWP NO.1738/2010 SHAITAN SINGH SOLANKI Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 44 SBCWP NO.1744/2010 HUKMA RAM GINVAR & ANR. Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 45 SBCWP NO.1748/2010 MOHAMMED NOOR DESWALI (PATHAN) Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 46 SBCWP NO.1143/2010 JYOTI JOSHI Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ANR 47 SBCWP NO.1144/2010 RAJKUMARI PUROHIT Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ANR 48 SBCWP NO.1145/2010 SANJEEV KUMAR CHOUDHARY Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ANR 49 SBCWP NO.1269/2010 CHELA RAM CHOUDHARY & ANR. Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 50 SBCWP NO.1289/2010 SMT. URMILA SAHU Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 51 SBCWP NO.1312/2010 JAIPRAKASH OJHAIYA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 52 SBCWP NO.1313/2010 RAJU SINGH & ORS. Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 53 SBCWP NO.1329/2010 VIVEK KUMAR VYAS Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 54 SBCWP NO.1347/2010 PRAHLAD SONI Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 55 SBCWP NO.1384/2010 LAXMAN SINGH & ORS Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 56 SBCWP NO.1388/2010 SHANTI BUNKAR Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 57 SBCWP NO.1394/2010 SMT.ANJANA JOSHI Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 58 SBCWP NO.1401/2010 PRAVEEN KUMAR RAJPAL Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 59 SBCWP NO.1402/2010 ANURADHA & ORS. Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 60 SBCWP NO.1404/2010 RATAN LAL Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 61 SBCWP NO.1405/2010 NEENA SHARMA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 62 SBCWP NO.1406/2010 SUNITA BAVEJA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 63 SBCWP NO.1407/2010 JAISA RAM Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 3 64 SBCWP NO.1430/2010 PRADEEP KUMAR KILANIYA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 65 SBCWP NO.1666/2010 BINDU SHARMA Vs. STATE & ANR 66 SBCWP NO.1706/2010 BHANA RAM MEGHWAL Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 67 SBCWP NO.1732/2010 HADMAN RAM Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 68 SBCWP NO.1735/2010 CHANDRESH KUMAR JAIN Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 69 SBCWP NO.1746/2010 JAGDISHCHANDRA YADAV Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 70 SBCWP NO.1747/2010 OM SINGH Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 71 SBCWP NO.1762/2010 ANANDLAL Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 72 SBCWP NO.1765/2010 KAMLESH GOYAL Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 73 SBCWP NO.2701/2009 SANJAY KUMAR PANDYA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS 74 SBCWP NO.4451/2009 SHYAM LAL MEGHWAL Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS 75 SBCWP NO.962/2010 ANIL KUMAR BHARGWA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 76 SBCWP NO.963/2010 RAJENDRA PRASAD SWAMI Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 77 SBCWP NO.1216/2010 CHUNNI LAL Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 78 SBCWP NO.1535/2010 HANUMAN RAM Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 79 SBCWP NO.6444/2008 DASHRATH SINGH SOLANKI Vs. STATE & ANR 80 SBCWP NO.6619/2008 DURGA SINGH RATHORE Vs. STATE & ORS 81 SBCWP NO.6727/2008 MANOHARLAL SHRIMALI Vs. STATE & ORS 82 SBCWP NO.6754/2008 KALU SINGH Vs. STATE & ORS 83 SBCWP NO.6878/2008 SHAITAN SINGH RATHORE Vs. STATE & ORS 84 SBCWP NO.6903/2008 BANWARI LAL Vs. STATE & ORS 85 SBCWP NO.8118/2008 SUBHASH CHANDRA Vs. STATE & ORS 86 SBCWP NO.8500/2008 MADHU SWAMI Vs. STATE & ORS 87 SBCWP NO.9508/2008 SHAITAN DAN Vs. STATE & ORS 88 SBCWP NO.9539/2008 PRAKASH Vs. STATE & ORS 89 SBCWP NO.9735/2008 SMT. VEENA JAJRA Vs. STATE & ORS 90 SBCWP NO.9984/2008 RAM SINGH CHOUHAN Vs. STATE & ORS 91 SBCWP NO.382/2009 BHUPENDRA CHOUDHARY Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS 92 SBCWP NO.816/2009 PAWAN KUMAR SUTHAR Vs. STATE & ORS 93 SBCWP NO.1237/2009 SMT. NIDHI PALIWAL Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 94 SBCWP NO.4157/2009 SMT. SUNITA GODARA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS 95 SBCWP NO.7434/2009 DEVENDRA KUMAR & ORS. Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS 96 SBCWP NO.9088/2009 GOVIND RAM MEENA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 97 SBCWP NO.9085/2009 RAKMESHWAR MEENA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 98 SBCWP NO.8036/2008 SHIV CHARAN SHARMA Vs. STATE & ANR 99 SBCWP NO.9868/2008 NARESH KUMAR Vs. STATE & ORS 100 SBCWP NO.0745/2009 SATYAVEER SINGH Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ANR. 4 101 SBCWP NO.0746/2009 ANNA RAM Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ANR. 102 SBCWP NO.0750/2009 SANWER MAL & ANR. Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ANR. 103 SBCWP NO.9949/2009 RAJA RAM Vs. STATE & ORS 104 SBCWP NO.10626/2009 PRAVEEN KUMAR CHOBISA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 105 SBCWP NO.1646/2010 KUMARI JULAKHA BANO Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 106 SBCWP NO.1821/2010 ANAND SINGH Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS 107 SBCWP NO.1843/2010 ARJUN LAL CHOUDHARY Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS 108 SBCWP NO.1344/2010 NAVNEET KUMAR CHITTORA Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 109 SBCWP NO.1353/2010 RAVINDRA KAUSHIK Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 110 SBCWP NO.1355/2010 PURAN MAL & ANR. Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 111 SBCWP NO.1616/2010 RAM KISHAN Vs. STATE OF RAJ. & ORS. 112 SBCWP NO.586/2009 JITENDRA SINGH Vs. STATE & ANR. 113 SBCWP NO.6530/2008 BHAGWANT DAN RATNU Vs. STATE & ORS 114 SBCWP NO.8137/2008 SMT. RAJ KUMARI Vs. STATE & ORS 115 SBCWP NO.8458/2008 SANJAY PUROHIT & ORS. Vs. STATE & ORS Date of Order : 22.2.2010 HON'BLE MR. PRAKASH TATIA, J. S/Sh. RS Choudhary, Vinay Jain, DLR Vyas, SP Sharma, RN Upadhyay, Kuldeep Mathur, Rameshwar Dave, Manish Vyas, VN Kalla, JVS Deora, Bharat Srimali, PR Mehta, Arjun Purohit, DL Mothsra, MS Bhati, BB Singh, Deepak Nehra, Mukesh Rajpurohit, Vineet Dave, Rakesh Arora, MS Godara, DK Godara, Gopal Acharya, Ajay Vyas, Pintu Pareek, RC Joshi, JP Swami, VK Sharma, HS Sidhu, HR Choudhary, GJ Gupta, RP Singharia, Mahendra Trivedi, Rohitash Singh, Vineet Sanadhya, LK Purohit, Ramesh Purohit, Ashwini Swami, Vinod Purohit, RK Charan and PS Chundawat, for the petitioners. Mr.RL Jangid, Addl. Advocate General with Mr.Rajesh Bhati and Mr.Nimesh Suthar for the respondent-State. <><><> Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the controversy involved in these writ petitions has already been decided by the Coordinate Bench of this Court vide judgment dated 27.1.2010 delivered in SBCWP No.8497/2008 – 5 Manglaram & Ors. Vs. State of Rajasthan & Ors. which was decided with other connected writ petitions. It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioners that the present writ petitions may also be decided in the light of the decision dated 27.1.2010 and same directions may be issued. Learned counsel for the State submitted that there are several objections which are (i) the person who gave birth to child after cut off date and who had two children already is not an eligible candidate, (ii) some of the candidates were lacking experience, (iii) some of the candidates were over age and (iv) some of the candidates claimed benefit on the basis of their experience of working as Prerak. So far as other cases are concerned, the similar directions can be issued in the light of the decision given in judgment dated 27.1.2010. After the decision in the case of Mangla Ram (supra) the objections raised by the petitioners above have been considered in SBCWP No.5657/2008-Shakti Singh Yadav Vs. State & Ors and connected 90 matters decided on 8.2.2010 and the writ petitions have been disposed of. In the light of the above, these writ petitions are also disposed of in terms of the following directions and it is made clear that petitioners may be free to submit the representation within the time granted by the judgment dated 27.1.2010: “(i) Respondents are directed to first prepare list of writ petitioners whose applications were received by the respondents in respective districts, and who were not called for interview for the reasons that there was 6 summer break resulting in discontinuance of experience for five years, or experience certificate has not been verified, may be called for interview and this exercise be completed within two months; and simultaneously, petitioners may also contact the office of the concerned authority; and (ii) such of petitioners who are not found to be eligible for any other reason, may be assigned and communicated to each of them, to which if he feels aggrieved, will be free to avail of remedy under the law. (iii) After completion of exercise referred to in para (i) &(ii) (supra), further process be initiated for finalizing merit list of respective districts and such petitioners may be considered for appointment if find place in order of merit in their respective district against advertised vacancies including those duly revised by subsequent corrigendum to advertisement dated 31.5.2008, within a period of three months thereafter in accordance with Rules, 2008 and in the light of judgments of this court (supra). [PRAKASH TATIA], J. mlt/s.phophalia/cpgoyal 7 S.B. CIVIL WRIT PETITION NO. Date of Order : 22.2.2010 HON'BLE MR. PRAKASH TATIA, J. S/Sh. RS Choudhary, Vinay Jain, DLR Vyas, SP Sharma, RN Upadhyay, Kuldeep Mathur, Rameshwar Dave, Manish Vyas, VN Kalla, JVS Deora, Bharat Srimali, PR Mehta, Arjun Purohit, DL Mothsra, MS Bhati, BB Singh, Deepak Nehra, Mukesh Rajpurohit, Vineet Dave, Rakesh Arora, MS Godara, DK Godara, Gopal Acharya, Ajay Vyas, Pintu Pareek, RC Joshi, JP Swami, VK Sharma, HS Sidhu, HR Choudhary, GJ Gupta, RP Singharia, Mahendra Trivedi, Rohitash Singh, Vineet Sanadhya, LK Purohit, Ramesh Purohit, Ashwini Swami, Vinod Purohit, RK Charan and PS Chundawat, for the petitioners. Mr.RL Jangid, Addl. Advocate General with Mr.Rajesh Bhati and Mr.Nimesh Suthar for the respondent-State. <><><> This writ petition is disposed of. [see separate judgment in SBCWP No.1199/2010 – Begraj. Vs. State of Raj. & Ors., decided today itself, i.e., 22.2.2010. By order Court Master.