IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA MA No.245 of 2010 MANJU DEVI, W/O Late Prakash Choudhary @ Rameshwar Mahto, R/O Village Kharik Got, P.S. Kharik, District Bhagalpur, Bihar ............Applicant/Appellant Versus UNION OF INDIA, through the General Manager, North East Railway, Gorakhpur. ...........Respondent For the Appellant: Pravin Kumar Gupta, Advocate For the RespondentL: Anial Singh 05. 20.07.2010 Heard learned counsel for the appellant as well as for the respondent with their consent this appeal is being disposed of at this stage. This appeal has been preferred against order dated 12.11.2009 passed by Railway Claims Tribunal, Patna Bench, refusing the claim of the applicant, seeking compensation against death of one Rameshwar Mahto. After thoroughly examining and discussing the materials available on record, specially the evidence of the claimant and documents filed on her behalf, the Claim Tribunal has arrived at the conclusion that deceased is the wife of one Prakash Chaudhary. She has clearly stated that she is not aware of any person named as Rameshwar Mahto. The Ration Cards and other papers produced on her behalf indicate her husband’s name as Prakash Chaudhary. As per learned counsel for the appellant, that investigation report of G.R.P. wherein at the end it has been mentioned, that deceased was Rameshwar Mahto @ Prakash Choudhary, but in absence of any other supporting materials and 2 statement of the claimant as of her being ignorant of any person named as Rameshwar Mahto, with specific assertion that she is the wife of Prakash Chaudhary none else. The Claim Tribunal has on the point of identity of the deceased and also entitlement of the claimant being widow of the person found dead dismissed the petition. Learned counsel for the appellant, in spite of his best efforts could not be able to point out any illegality or irregularity in the impugned order, in that view of the matter, appeal is devoid of any merit, consequently it is dismissed at this stage on contest but there is no order as to cost. Praveen ( Akhilesh Chandra, J.)