IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.7602 of 2009 1. SUNIL KUMAR SINGH, SON OF LATE BAIDHNATH SINGH, C/O HARI NARAYAN JHA, SURVI PATH, NEW JAKKANPUR, PATNA-800001. 2. YOGESH KUMAR YADAV, SON OF BAUGU YADAV, R/V AND P.O. ORIUP, P.S. ANTICHAK, DISTRICT BHAGALPUR. 3. KUNDAN KUMAR SINGH, SON OF NARESH KUMAR SINGH ,R/V MOHANPUR(EAST TOLA), P.O. DHARHARA, DISTRICT MUNGER. 4. ANITA GIRI, C/O SHARDA NIWASH NEW BENGALI TOLA, NEW BUS STAND ROAD, PATNA. 5. ABHAY KUMAR SINGH, SON OF BRAJ MOHAN SINGH, RESIDENT OF BIMLA KUNJ, H.NO. 121C, ROAD NO.1K NEAR ASHA SINGH MORE, P.S. RAMPUR, A.P. COLONY, GAYA. 6. DILIP KUMAR, CARE OF SRI LAKSHMAN PD. SINGH, ADVOCATE, MOHALLA DHANESHWAR GHAT, P.S. BIHAR SHARIF, DISTRICT NALANDA. 7. ASHOK KUMAR JHA, SON OF UPENDRA JHA, R/V PRASAD POST BANKI, VIA MADHEPUR, DISTRICT MADHUBANI. 8. MANOJ KUMAR SINGH, SON OF GAYANAND SINGH, R/V NATHPUR, VIA NARPATGANJ DISTRICT ARARIA. 9. SCHIDA NAND DUBEY, SON OF SURENDRA DUBEY, R/V TETARI, P.O. SASARAM, DISTRICT ROHTAS. 10. KISHORE KUMAR SINGH, SON OF BATAHU SINGH, VILLAGE KOSHKAPUR, GHARKAHA, VIA NARPATGANJ, P.O. BARHARA, DISTRICT ARARIA. 11. RAMRAJ SINGH, SON OF DAYANAND SINGH, RESIDENT OF H.O.NO. 163, SHIVAJEE NAGAR, DIGHA GHAT, PATNA, P.S. DIGHA, DISTRICT PATNA. 12. ANSHU KUMARI, D/O GIRISH SHARMA, BINDHYAWASINI NIWAS, ADARSH COLONY, WEST TRANSPORT NAGAR, P.S. AGAMKUAN, PATNA. 13. BIPIN BIHARI, SON OF SRI RAM PARVESH SHARMA, VILLAGE LAT, P.O. HULASGANJ, DISTRICT JEHANABAD. 14. SUDHIST KUMAR SON OF LATE DINESH CHAUDHARY VILLAGE AND P.O. MATIHANI, P.S. MATIHANI, DISTRICT BEGUSARAI. 15. LUTAWAN RAM, SON OF JHAGRU RAM, VILLAGE PATKHAULI, P.O. MUSHAHARI, P.S. SHANICHARI, DISTRICT WEST CHAMPARAN 16. HARA LAL DAS, SON OF AMOLA DAS, R/V SHANICHARI COLONY P.O. PARSA, DISTRICT WEST CHAMPARAN. 17. RAKESH KUMAR SON OF SRI RAMDEO YADAV, RESIDENT OF B.M.P.8, P.O. R.T.S.,F.NO.9, Q.NO.103, DISTRICT BEGUSARAI. 18. ABINASH KUMAR SON OF RADHE SHYAM SINGH, RESIDENT OF C/O. SHYAM SUNDAR SINGH, ASHOK NAGAR, POKHARIA, NEAR MEERA NARSINGH HOME,DISTRICT BEGUSARAI. 19. NEERAJ KUMAR, SON OF RAJPATI MISHRA, RESIDENT OF NEWS PROF. COLONY, DINKAR NAGAR, BEGUSARAI. 20. RAKESH KUMAR SON OF VISHWANATH CHOUDHARY, VILLAGE MURADPUR DULLHA, P,O. BHIKHANPUR, DISTRICT MUZAFFARPUR. 21. DINESH KUMAR, SON OF VILLAGE AND P,O. GAYGHAT,P.S. BRAHAMPUR, DISTRICT MUZAR. 22. RAJESH KUMAR PANDEY, SON OF VILLAGE OJHAOLIYA, P.O. PARSIYA, P.S. BRAHAMPUR, DISTRICT BUXAR. 23. SANJAY BIKAS TRIPATHY, SON OF VILLAGE ITAVAN, P.O. NAUHATA, P.S. BELBAWN, DISTRICT KAIMUR. 24. AMIT KUMAR JHA, INDRAPRABHA NIWAS DEVI HARI DAS LANE, BILASI TOWN, DEOGHAT, JHARKHAND. 25. RAMNATH PRASAD, SON OF C/O MANOJ MEDICAL HALL, HOSPITAL ROAD, SITAMARHI, P.S. TOWN THANA, SITAMARHI. 26. SURENDRA KUMAR, SON OF C/O MOTI THAKUR VILLAGE AND P,O. AGANOOR, P.S. KALER, DISTRICT ARWAL, BIHAR. 27. RAMA SHANKAR PRASAD RAI, SON OF RESIDENT OF RANAKAILASHPRASAD RAI, VILLAGE AND P.O. BAITT GAVEHARIYA, VIA RAGHUNATHPUR BAZAR, RAMGARHWA, DISTRICT EAST CHAMPARAN, BIHAR. - 2 - 28. AJIT KUMAR SON OF SATISH PRASAD GUPTA, OLD NCC/OFFICE IN CAMPUS STATION ROAD, MOTIHARI, EAST CHAMPARAN. 29. SHASHI KANT SINGH, SON OF MADAN KUMAR SINGH, VILLAGE AND P.O. KOCHAS,P.S. KOCHAS, DISTRICT ROHTAS. 30. SATYA PRAKASH SINGH, SON OF GAJENDRA KUMAR SINGH AT JAMUNAPUR, P.O. AND P.S. MANER, DISTRICT PATNA. 31. PANKAJ KUMAR, SON OF SHIVRUP SINGH, AT NAGWA, P.O. CHOROULI, P.S. BHAGWANPUR, DISTRICT SIWAN. 32. PRADIP KUMAR YADAV, SON OF JANARDAN PD. YADAV, RESIDENT OF KHERIA, P.O. AYODHYA GANJ BAZAR, P.S. KURSELA, DISTRICT KATIHAR. 33. PAWAN KUMAR YADAV, SON OF BHANESHWAR YADAV, AT AND P.O. KATAREAH,P.S. KURSELA, DISTRICT KATIHAR. 34. MRITUNJAY, SON OF PADMANAND JHA, AT KOTAHPUR, P.O. DAVRA, P.S. KUSAKANTA, DISTRICT ARARIA. 35. MANISH KUMAR SINHA, SON OF SHAMBHU PRASAD SINGH, AT AND P.O.SEMRAHI,P.S. JADOPUR, DISTRICT GOPALGANJ. 36. NAVIN KUMAR SON OF VIJAY KUMAR CHAUDHARY, AT AND P.O. LOMA, P.S. TISHILYA, DISTRICT VAISHALI. 37. ANUJ KUMAR RAJ, SON OF RADHAKANT MISHRA, AT DUMMARIA,P.S. KISHANGANJ, DISTRICT KISHANGANJ. 38. SIKANDAR SAH,SON OF SRI BRIJNATH SAH,AT KURSELA BASTI, P.O. A.G. BAZAR, P.S. KURSELA, DISTRICT KATIHAR. 39. KUMAR BHUWAN, SON OF RAMCHANDRA BHAGAT, AT AND P.S. AND P.O. BHAGWANPUR RAJDHAM, DISTRICT PURNEA. 40. RAJEEV KUMAR SON OF DEOKI NANDAN PD. GUPTA, AT +P.O.AND P.S. CHAURADA DISTRICT 41. SITESH KUMAR SON OF SADHU SHARAN RAY, VILLAGE GOSAINPUR, P.O. HARSER, DISTRICT MUZAFFARPUR, P.S. SIVAIPATTI. 42. SHASHI BHUSHAN PRASAD, SON OF RAM KISHOR PD. YADAV, VILLAGE BELAHI LACHHI, P.O. SIVAIPATTI, P.S. MIINAPUR, MUZAFFARPUR. 43. RAKESH KUMAR, SON OF BAIDYANATH RAY, MATA MANDIR MARG, SITAMARHI, P.O. SITAMARHI, P.S. SITAMARHI,DISTRICT SITAMARHI. 44. DHARMENDRA KUMAR, SON OF ANAND DEO RAY, VILLAGE KHAMHOURI, P.O. RAJA PUR, P.S. GOTAM BUDH NAGAR, TARABARA, DISTRICT SIWAN. 45. RAJEEV RANJAN, SON OF ABHAY KUMAR SINGH, AT HERABAY, P.O. MATWARI, P.S. HAZARIBAG, DISTRICT HAZARIBAGH, JHARKHAND. 46. PRATIMA KUMARI, D/O GAGAN APARTMENT, 5TH FLOOR, VERMA PICTURE, FLAT NO. 502, EXHIBITION ROAD, PATNA. 47. SANJAY KUMAR SINGH, SON OF SRI RAMPRATAP SINGH, VILLAGE SURARI, P.O. RATNADH,P.S. GARHANI, DISTRICT BHOJPUR. 48. DEEPAK KUMAR JHA, C/O SRIBIDYA NAND JHA, AT SAHANSPUR,P.O. JOGIARA, DISTRICT DARBHANGA. 49. SANDIP PRABHAKAR, SON OFSRI BABU CHAND SINGH, C/O DR. B.C. SINGH, SINGH HEALTH CARE,SIDHESHWAR MARKET, P.O. DHELWAN, P.S.BEUR, IOC ROAD, SIPARA, PATNA-20. 50. AMARJEET KUMAR, SON OF JAI CHJANDRA PASWAN, VILLAGE KHUSRUPUR, P.O. AND P.S. BARH, DISTRICT PATNA. 51. KUMAR GAURAV DIXIT, SON OF SHIVDAYAL SINGH, RESIDENT OF P.O. SUHIRD NAGAR, P.S. TOWN THANABEGUSARAI, DISTRICT BEGUSARAI. 52. RAVI RANJAN KR. SINGH, SON OF NARENDRA KUMAR SINGH, C/O H.N.JHA, SURVI PATH, P.O. AND P.S. JAKKANPUR, PATNA-1. --------PETITIONERS. Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH ITS CHIEF SECRETARY, OLD SECRETARIAT, PATNA. 2. THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE, BIHAR, PATNA. 3. THE BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY, VETERINARY COLLEGE, PATNA. 4. THE CHAIRMAN, BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISISON, VETERINARY COLLEGE PATNA. 5. PRASHANT KUMAR ROY, SON OF SHRI RAJENDRA PD. ROY, RESIDENT OF 91, NIRALA NAGAR, DIGHA GHAT, PATNA. 6. PRAMOD KUMAR SON OF SHRI SEDDANI SHARMA, R/V DADPUR, P.O. - 3 - BAURI BELDARI, P.S. HULASGANJ, DISTRICT JEHANABAD. 7. RAKESH RANJAN, SON OF SHRI SHIV KUMAR SINGH, RESIDENT OF B/28, VASISHTHA COLONY HARNICHAK, ANISABAD, PATNA. 8. SANTOSH KUMAR SINGH, SON OF SHRI MUKHTAR SINGH, RESIDENT OF ROAD NO. 13B, NEW BAHADURPUR, RAJENDRA NAGAR, PATNA, P.S. RAJENDRA NAGAR, DISTRICT PATNA. 9. AMIT KUMAR SON OF LATE BINOD KUMAR DAS RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.S. SALKHUA, DISTRICT SAHARSA. 10. ARVIND KUMAR RAI, SON OF GANGA SAGAR RAI, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. KAMARPUR, DISTRICT BUXAR. 11. MUKESH KUMAR VERMA SON OF LATE BISHESHWAR PRASAD SRIVASTAVA, RESIDENT OF BABUWI, TOLA P.O. + P.S. BAGAHA, DISTRICT WEST CHAMPARAN. 12. MD. RAFIQUIR RAHMAN, SON OF MD. QAMRUL ALAM, R/V BALUA TAL(NEAR MAKKI MASJID), P.S. MOTIHAR, DISTRICT EAST CHAMPARAN. 13. JWESH KUMAR THAKUR, SON OF NAVIN THAKUR, RESIDENT OF INDRAPRAST BHAWAN, BHIKANPUR GANJ, NO.2 P.O. AND P.S. BHAGALPUR, DISTRICT BHAGALPUR. 14. SANJAY KUMAR SON OF BINDA PRASAD, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. NAWADA, P.S. GOVINDGANJ, DISTRICT EAST CHAMPARAN. 15. MASUD AHMAD, HAIDAR, SON OF ABDUL LATIF, HAIDIRI, RESIDENT OF RAM ENTERPRISES, NEAR NOORI MEDICAL HALL AT MAHMOOD CHOWN, D.S. COLLEGE. 16. AMRENDRA KUMAR SON OF SURYA KANT THAKUR, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE BHIKHANPURA, P.O. MUZAFFARPUR DISTRICT MUZAFFARPUR. 17. BINAY KUMAR, SON OF DINKAR PRASAD SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.O. CHERON, P.S. SARMERA, DISTRICT NALANDA. 18. SUNIL KUMAR JHA, SON OF DR. NAGESH MOHAN JHA, RESIDENT OF MOHALLA NORTH RAJIV NAGAR, ROAD NO. 8D, P.S. RAJIV NAGAR, DISTRICT PATNA. 19. MRITYUNJAY KUMAR, SON OF BACHACHA JI CHAUBEY, R/V +P.O. BHOPATIPUR, CHAUBEY TOLA, P.S. KOTWA, DISTRICT EAST CHAMPARAN. 20. RAJEEV RANJAN, SON OF RAM CHANDRA PRASAD SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE NAGAIN, P.S. GOH, DISTRICT AURANGABAD. 21. GHANSHYAM PASWAN, SON OF KAILU PASWAN, RESIDENT OF ROOM NO.19 WELFARE HOSTEL, MADHEPURA, DISTRICT MADHEPURA. 22. JAY SHANKIAR PRASAD, SON OF SHRI MAHADEO YADAV, RESIDENT OF RAMGNAJ, P.S. KUMARKHAND, DISTRICT MADHEPURA. 23. AMITESH, SON OF LATE PRABHUNATH RAI, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE BELAON, P.S. DARAULI, DISTRICT SIWAN. 24. SUNIL KUMAR SINGH, SON OF LATE LAL BACHAN SINGH, R/V KURMURI, P.S. SIKARATA, DISTRICT ARA. 25. ANJU TIWARY, D/O LATE GANGA PRASAD TIWARY, R/V/HOLDING NO.903, RAMLILA MAIDAN, SAKCHI, JAMSHEDPUR, P.S. SAKCHI, DISTRICT EAST SINGHBHUM. 26. RANJAN MALVIYA, SON OF SHIV SHANKAR PRASAD BARWNWAL, C/O PRASAD BHAWAN, RESIDING AT DEOGHAR, P.S.DEOGHAR, DISTRICT DEOGHAR, JHARKHAND. 27. BRIJ BHUSHAN MISHRA, SON OF GORAKH NATH MISHRA, R/V UGNA, P.S.JAGDISHPUR, DISTRICT BHOJPUR. 28. KUMAR KESHAV NANDAN, SON OF SHIVNANDAN ROY, R/V BHAVNATHPUR, P.S. AKBAR NAGAR, DISTRICT BHAGALPUR. 29. SANTOSH KUMAR RAJAK, SON OF SRI RAM PRAVESH RAJAK, R/V JAGANPURADIH, DISTRICT PATNA. 30. RAJA CHANDRAVANSHI, SON OF SHANKAR CHANDRAVANSHI, R/M EAST ASHOK NAGAR, ROAD NO.14-B, KANKARBAGH, P.S. KANKARBAGH, DISTRICT PATNA--------RESPONDENTS. ----------- 03. 21.07.2009 Heard learned counsel for the petitioners, State as also counsel for the Bihar Staff Selection Commission(hereinafter referred to as “the Commission”). 2. Petitioners were the applicants for the post of Sub- - 4 - Inspector in response to Advertisement No. 704/2004. They have participated in the selection process both physical and written test and having become unsuccessful are assailing the selection made on the ground that petitioners were not provided with the expert’s report submitted in regard to the model question/answer. 3. It is submitted on behalf of the petitioners that had the expert’s report on the model question/answer been perused and considered by the authorities, the selection which has been made ought to have been set aside so as to undertake a fresh selection process. 4. Learned Advocate General appearing for the Commission submitted that similar submissions were made in another writ petition bearing C.W.J.C. No.9155 of 2008, Jai Shankar Prasad and other analogous matters and the Court dismissed the writ petitions under orders dated 25.11.2008, which is reported in 2008(4) PLJR 825. After culmination of the first ground another writ petition bearing C.W.J.C. No. 2023 of 2009 assailing the validity of the same selection process was filed, which was also dismissed relying on the aforesaid judgment in the case of Jai Shankar Prasad Versus The State of Bihar & Ors., against which the matter went in appeal, i.e. L.P.A. No. 305 of 2009 with L.P.A. No. 524 of 2009. The Division Bench having taken into account the different facets of the selection process dismissed the appeal under orders dated 7.7.2009. 5. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the order of the Division Bench dated 7.7.2009 passed in L.P.A. No. 305 - 5 - of 2009 has been obtained by practicing fraud and concealing the relevant facts and as the said order has been obtained by practicing fraud and concealing the relevant facts this Court should re-examine the matter in the present writ application. I decline to do so, however, permit the petitioners to invite the attention of the Division Bench which passed order dated 7.7.2009 to the fraud, which according to the learned counsel for the petitioner was perpetuated by the authorities before the Division Bench. 6. With the observations and liberty aforesaid this writ application is dismissed. Rajesh/ (V.N.Sinha,J.)