1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION SALES TAX APPLICATION NO.17 OF 2008 IN REFERENCE APPLICATION NO.118 OF 2007 Commissioner of Sales Tax, Mumbai. ...Applicant vs. Ghatge-Patil Industries Ltd.Kolhapur ...Respondent. ALONGWITH SALES TAX APPLICATION NO.18 OF 2008 IN REFERENCE APPLICATION NO.119 OF 2007 Commissioner of Sales Tax, Mumbai. ...Applicant vs. Ghatge-Patil Industries Ltd.Kolhapur ...Respondent. ALONGWITH SALES TAX APPLICATION NO.19 OF 2008 IN REFERENCE APPLICATION NO.128 OF 2007 Commissioner of Sales Tax, Mumbai. ...Applicant vs. Ghatge-Patil Industries Ltd.Kolhapur ...Respondent. ALONGWITH SALES TAX APPLICATION NO.23 OF 2008 2 IN REFERENCE APPLICATION NO.121 OF 2007 Commissioner of Sales Tax, Mumbai. ...Applicant vs. Ghatge-Patil Industries Ltd.Kolhapur ...Respondent. ALONGWITH SALES TAX APPLICATION NO.24 OF 2008 IN REFERENCE APPLICATION NO.122 OF 2007 Commissioner of Sales Tax, Mumbai. ...Applicant vs. Ghatge-Patil Industries Ltd.Kolhapur ...Respondent. ALONGWITH SALES TAX APPLICATION NO.27 OF 2008 IN REFERENCE APPLICATION NO.124 OF 2007 Commissioner of Sales Tax, Mumbai. ...Applicant vs. Ghatge-Patil Industries Ltd.Kolhapur ...Respondent. ALONGWITH SALES TAX APPLICATION NO.28 OF 2008 IN REFERENCE APPLICATION NO.123 OF 2007 Commissioner of Sales Tax, Mumbai. ...Applicant 3 vs. Ghatge-Patil Industries Ltd.Kolhapur ...Respondent. ALONGWITH SALES TAX APPLICATION NO.29 OF 2008 IN REFERENCE APPLICATION NO.125 OF 2007 Commissioner of Sales Tax, Mumbai. ...Applicant vs. Ghatge-Patil Industries Ltd.Kolhapur ...Respondent. --- Mr.Vinay Sonpal, for Applicant. Mr.P.V.Surte, for Respondent CORAM: D.K.DESHMUKH & J.P.DEVADHAR, JJ. DATED: 4th September,2008. P.C.:- Parties have submitted minutes of order, it is taken on record and marked “X” for identification. Appeals are disposed of in terms of minutes at “X”. (D.K.DESHMUKH, J.) 4 (J.P.DEVADHAR, J.)