IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS DATED : 28.10.2008 C O R A M : THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE K. CHANDRU W.P.Nos.13200, 12767, 12768, 12781, 12806, 12807, 12782, 12783, 12800, 12801, 12848, 12849, 12984, 13024, 13028, 13066 to 13075, 12540, 13086, 13115, 13120, 13121, 13136, 13196 to 13199, 13201, 13211, 13307 to 13311, 13314, 13316, 13317, 13321 to 13326, 13482, 13484, 13558 to 13560, 13585, 13604, 13628, 13705, 13718, 13853, 14123, 14124, 14125, 14286, 14599, 14680, 14747, 14792, 15492, 15521, 16061, 16142, 16230, 16802, 17010, 17547, 17749, 17973, 17990, 18585, 19309, 19417, 21258, 21888, 25105, 25182, 25187, 25193, 25205, 25234, 25249, 25253, 25255, 25256 and 24139 of 2008 and connected Miscellaneous Petitions. KR Teacher Training Institute for Women N.H.7, K.R.Nagar, Vedasandur-624 710, Dindigul District, Tamil Nadu, rep.by its Correspondent Mr.R.Raja Subramaniem ... Petitioner in W.P.13200/08 DR. NAGARATHINAMS TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, DR.P. CHANDRAMOHAN, 52/7, SEELANAICKANPATTI VILLAGE, SALEM- 636 201. ..Petitioner in WP 12767/2008 D.K.T. TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE (WOMEN), REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN, DR. D. SOWKATH HAYATH KHAN, AMAAVATHIPALAYAM, PERUNTHOZHUVU POST, TIRUPUR- 641 665, COIMBATORE DT. ..Petitioner in WP 12768/2008 EESWAR TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY EZHUMALAIYAN EDUCATIONAL SOCIAL AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT TRUST, NO. 45 MA. PODIYUR POST, TITTAGUDI TK, CUDDALORE DT. ..Petitioner in WP 12781/2008 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ A.K.T. MEMORIAL TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT MR. A.K.T. MAHENDRAN, NEELAMANGALAM VILLAGE, KALLAKURICHI TK. VILLUPURAM DT. ..Petitioner in WP 12806/2008 KALAIMAGAL TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT MRS. V. LATHA, NO.3/228, SALEM MAIN ROAD, UNISINAHALLI, KADATHUR POST, PAPPIREDDIPATTI TK. DHARMAPURI DT. ..Petitioner in WP 12807/2008 SRI NATESANAR TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY SRI NATESANAR EDUCATIONAL & SOCIAL TRUST, REPRESENTED BY N. CHANDRASEKAR SCHOOL ST, VADAGAL, THIRUVALAM POST, WALAJA TK, VELLORE DT- 632 515, TAMIL NADU ..Petitioner in WP 12782/2008 VIGNESH TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY VIGNESH EDUCATIONAL TRUST, REP. BY ITS SECRETARY J.USHA JAYAPATHI NO. 28, KALENDRA VILLAGE (JOLARPET), VANIYAMBADI TK, VELLORE DT - 635 751, ..Petitioner in WP 12783/2008 VARALAKSHMI TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE FOR WOMEN, RUN BY ARUMUGAM EDUCATIONAL AND SOCIAL TRUST, PUDUKOTTAI DT. TAMIL NADU, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDNT A. VIJAYKUMAR ..Petitioner in WP 12800/2008 GANDHI TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY GANDHI EDUCATIONAL TRUST, SF. NO.144, NO. 394, VINNUPALLI VILLAGE, SATHYAMANGALAM TK. REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT N. THANGARAJ ..Petitioner in WP 12801/2008 THOZHILATHIBER TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY THOZHILATHIBER EDUCATIONAL & SOCIAL TRUST, EDAMALAIPATTIPUDUR, TRICHY, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT S.V.INGERSOLL. ..Petitioner in WP 12848 & 12849/2008 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ D.V.C. TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY D.V.C. EDUCATIONAL SOCIETY, TIRUMURUGAN NAGAR, SRIMUSHNAM, CUDDLAORE DT REP BY ITS SECRETARY N.V. SENTHILNATHAN ..Petitioner in WP 12984/2008 ALL INDIA PRIVATE EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS ASSOCIATION, REP BY ITS PRESIDENT B.T. KUMAR NO.5 M.P. AVENUE, MAJESTIC COLONY, SALIGRAMAM, CHENNAI 93 .Petitioner in WP 13024/2008 ARUMUGAM TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, ARUMUGAM EDUCATION AND SOCIAL TRUST, REP BY ITS CORRESPONDENT MR.A.VIJAYKUMAR, NO.408/2 JESU COMPLEX GANTHI ROAD, ALANGUDI. .Petitioner in WP 13028/2008 ANNAI TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT , MR.S.CHURCHILL NAMBIPATTI, H. DODDAMPATTI, PAPPIREDDIPATTI TK, DHARMAPURI DT, PIN - 636 903 .Petitioner in WP 13066/2008 PARAMVEER TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT , PARAMVEER NAGAR, PENNAGARAM MAIN ROAD, PAPPARAPPATTI POST, DHARMAPURI DT, PIN - 636 809 .Petitioner in WP 13067/2008 AMERDHAA VIKASH INSTITUTE OF TEACHER TRAINING, REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN, MR.R. DURAISAMY, NO. 5/118-120, SALEM- NAMAKKAL ROAD, GAJJALNAICKANPATTI POST, SALEM DT. .Petitioner in WP 13068/2008 STANLEY TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, MR.V. MURUGESAN, MOOKAREDDIPATTI VILLAGE, A. PALLIPATTI POST, PAPPIREDDIPATTI TK, DHARMAPURI DT. .Petitioner in WP 13069/2008 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ K.R.N.TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN/CORRESPONDENT, MRS.R.DAMAYANTHI, PERUMALPATTI POST, SANKARANKOVIL TALUK, TIRUNELVELI DISTRICT. .Petitioner in WP 13070/2008 SRI VIDHYA MANDIR TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN, MR.S. SADAASIVA, NACHIPATTY, VENNANDHUR POST, RASIPURAM TK, NAMAKKAL DT. PIN - 637 505 .Petitioner in WP 13071/2008 K.T.S.S. TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE FOR WOMEN, REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN, MR. KEERAI TAMIL RAJA, K.T.S. NAGAR, SATHYAMANGALAM, KPUDUKOTTAI DT, PIN - 622 501 .Petitioner in WP 13072/2008 ADIPARASAKTHI TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, MR.A. PRABAHARAN, ERUMIYAMPATTI, KOKKARAPPATTI POST, PAPPIREDDIPATTI TK, DHARMAPURI DT. .Petitioner in WP 13073/2008 JEYA JOTHI TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, MR.S. SUSAI MANI, NO 2/ 175, SALLIAMPATTI, PALACODE TK, DHARMAPURI DT, PIN - 636 809 ..Petitioner in WP 13074/2008 LAKSHMI AMMAL TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE FOR WOMEN, MR.M. VADIVELAN, NO. 81, SALEM MAIN ROAD, DHARMAPURI & DT, PIN - 636 701 .Petitioner in WP 13075/2008 SRI BALAKRISHNA TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT A.S.BALAKRISHNAN, KUPPUR, DHARAPURAM PRIVU ROAD, DHARAPURAM, OMALUR TALUK, SALEM DISTRICT. ..Petitioner in WP 12540/2008 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ SHRI SITHESWARAR TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY SHRI SITHESWARAR EDUCATIONAL TRUST, KALAVAI ROAD, POONGUDU, ARCOT 632 503, VELLORE DT. REP BY ITS CORRESPONDENT D.THARANIPATHI ..Petitioner in WP 13086/2008 P.R.N. TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY P.R.N. EDUCATIONAL TRUST, JAYAPURAM VILLAGE & POST, PUDUPET (VIA), TIRUPATTUR, VELLORE DIST., REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT RA.RAMESH. ..Petitioner in WP 13115/2008 SRI RENGAA TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT A.KRISHNASWAMY, MANALMEDU, TITTAGUDI, CUDDALORE DISTRICT-606106. ..Petitioner in WP 13120/2008 SREE ARUMUGHAM TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT A.KRISHNASWAMY, RAJA NAGAR, VAITHLYANATHZAPURAM, THOLUDUR, CUDDALORE DISTRICT-606303. ..Petitioner in WP 13121/2008 VIDHAYA VIHAR TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE RUN BY VIDHAYA VIHAR EDUCATIONAL AND CHARITABLA TRUST, PUDU GOVINDAPURAM, KKS PANNAI MC RD, REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT, K.KUPPUSAMY. ..Petitioner in WP 13136/2008 ST.MICHAEL TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT M.STALIN AROCKIARAJ, ST.SANTHIAGAPAR NAGAR, KALAYARKOIL-630551, SIVAGANGAI DISTRICT. ..Petitioner in WP 13196/2008 ROSELINE TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN M.STALIN AROKIARAJ, VICTORIA NAGAR, OPP R.C.CHURCH, SIVAGANGA, SIVAGANGA DISTRICT-630561. ..Petitioner in WP 13197/2008 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ SAHAYA MATHA TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN M.STALIN AROKIARAJ, ST.SANTIAGAPPAR NAGAR, KALAIYARKOIL, SIVAGANGA DISTRICT-630551. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13198/08 FATHIMA TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN M.STALIN AROKIARAJ, PASUMPON NAGAR, RAMNAD DISTRICT-623504. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13199/08 A.K.R TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE FOR WOMEN, RUN BY HINDU TELUGU CHETTY MINORITY TRUST FOR EDUCATION & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT, VALLAIKOIL, ERODE REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT R.RAJA SUBRAMANIEM. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13201/08 KRISHNA TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE FOR WOMEN, VOIMEDU VILLAGE, VEDRANYAM TK, NAGAPATTINAM DISTRICT, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT MR.PARI PALAMAINATHAN. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13211/08 DGS TEACHERS TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY GUNA SEKARAN EDUCATIONAL TRUST, REP BY ITS CHAIRMAN DR.D.GUNASEKARAN, AMBALAVANAN NAGAR, THIRUVELANGADU THIRUVALLUR DT ..PETITIONER IN WP.13307/08 AMEEN TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE FOR MEN AND WOMEN, REP BY ITS CORRESPONDENT DR.A. SHEIK HANEEF, SOMASIPADI VILLAGE AND POST, THIRUVANNAMALAI DT. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13308/08 ROYAL TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY SYDHANS EDUCATIONAL TRUST, REP BY ITS CORRESPONDENT MR.S.A.ANWAR, VARATANPALLI ROAD, KATTINAYANAPALLI KRISHNAGIRI. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13309/08 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ LEELA KALYAN TEACHERS TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY HOLY ANGELS EDUCATIONAL SOCIETY, REP BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, MR.K.PALANIAPPAN, RETTANAI, TINDIVANAM TK, VILLUPURAM DT. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13310/08 ARUL TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY ARUL EDUCATIONAL TRUST, REP BY ITS CORRESPONDENT P.PANDYAN, ULUNDURPET, VILLUPURAM DT. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13311/08 SRI RANGAPOOPATHI EDUCATIONAL AND CHARITABLE TRUST, RUNNING RANGAPOOPATHY TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE FOR WOMEN, REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN AND CORRESPONDENT R.POOPATHI, GINGEE. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13314/08 ALWIN TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT V.PAPPA RAJENDRAN, ARUMBAKKAM, CHENNAI-106. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13316/08 JAIRUPA TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT K.S.KRISHNAMOORTHY, THOTTIPALAYAM, VIA THIRUPPUR, KANGAYAM TALUK, ERODE DISTRICT-641604. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13317/08 VIJAY TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, MALLAVADI, THIRUVANNAMALAI DISTRICT. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13321/08 BISHOP ARULSWAMY TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, IRUNGALUR, TRICHY. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13322/08 MODERN TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY PALANI ESWARI EDUCATIONAL TRUST, REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN, MR.C.PALANIVEL, JAYANKONDAM, PERAMBALUR DISTRICT. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13323/08 DON BOSCO TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, DR.MOORTHY, ERODE. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13324/08 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ KALVI ULAGAM TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, T.V.SIVANANDAM, VELLORE. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13325/08 SRI JAYARAM GIRLS TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY V.P. PERUMAL REDDIYAR CHARITABLE TRUST, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, MR. V.P.JAYARAJ, VILATHIKULAM, TUTICORIN DIST. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13326/08 SRI RAMAKRISHNA TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY SRI VIVEKANANDA EDUCATIONAL TRUST, DHARMAPURI, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT R. SUDHA ..PETITIONER IN WP.13482/05 KALAI BHARATHI TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY KALAI BHARTHI ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TRUST, PADMAPURAM, ERUMBI POST, PALLIPET T.K., TIRUVELLORE DISTRICT, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT A.KALAIKUMAR. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13484/08 CHRIST ACADEMY REP. BY ITS CORRESPODNENT, A.GERARD PHINGNORA RAJ, VALLAM, THANJAVUR DIST. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13558/08 LOYOLA TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPODNENT, C.AROKIADOSS, CUDDALORE 607 301. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13559/08 STELLA MARRYS TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, G.DAVID RAJA SINGH, TIRUNELVELI DT. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13560/08 SAPTHAGIRI INSITUTE OF TEACHER TRAINING, SRI BALAJI EDUCATIONAL TRUST, KRISHNAGIRI MAIN ROAD, PERIYANAHALLI, DHARMAPURI DT. REP. BY ITS CHAIRPERSON S. SARADHA SEKHAR ..PETITIONER IN WP.13585/08 PEE GEE INSTITUTE TEACHER TRAINING, LORD VENKATESWARA EDUCATIONAL TRUST, PERIYANAHALLI, DHARMAPURI DISTRICT REP BY ITS CHAIRPERSON S. SARDHA SEKHAR ..PETITIONER IN WP.13604/08 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ SUBHAM TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY UMRA KAVAR EDUCATIONAL TRUST, MADURANTAKAM, KANCHEEPURAM REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN S.D.MANOHAR KUMAR. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13628/08 SHREE SIRADI SAI COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, RUN BY VISHWAJYOTHI CHARITABLE FOUNDATION, S.F.NO.92, ONNALVADI VILLAGE, HOSUR TK, KRISHNAGIRI DISTRICT, REP BY ITS CORRESPONDENT G.SAJJAN RAO ..PETITIONER IN WP.13705/08 BHARATHY TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT C.MEYYUR & POST, THIRUKOILUR TALUK, VILLUPURAM DISTRICT. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13718/08 SRI KRISHNAN SCHOL OF EDUCATION, REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN, PANAPAKKAM VILLAGE, TAMBARAM (VIA) KANCHEEPURAM. ..PETITIONER IN WP.13853/08 ST.MARYS INSTITUTE OF TEACHER TRAINING, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT DR.MOORTHY, ANTHIYUR-638501, ERODE DISTRICT. ..PETITIONER IN WP.14123/08 UDAYA SCHOOL OF EDUCATION REP. BY ITS CHAIRPERSON, MRS.R.AMUDHA, AMMANDIVILAI & POST, KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT. PIN-629204. ..PETITIONER IN WP.14124/08 SARADHA TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT MR.S.RAMANATHAN, SANKAGIRI N.H.ROAD, SALEM DISTRICT. ..PETITIONER IN WP.14125/08 VICTORY TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE (MEN & WOMEN), RUN BY VICTORY EDUCATIONAL TRUST, KAMBILAMPATTY (P.O), DINDIGUL REP. BY ITS CORRESPNDENT M. VADIVEL. ..PETITIONER IN WP.14286/08 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ SUBHASHREE TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP BY ITS CORRESPONDENT MR.A.SUBRAMANIAN, TINDIVANAM TK, VILLUPURAM DISTRICT. ..PETITIONER IN WP.14599/08 SRI JOTHI TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY PROF.S.PARANJOTHI EDUCATIONAL TRUST, REP BY CORRESPONDENT MR.S.PARANJOTHI, ..PETITIONER IN KATPADI, VELLORE. W.P.NO.14680/2008 KUMUDHA TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY KUMUDHA EDUCATIONAL TRUST, ERODE DISTRICT, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT ..PETITIONER IN K.A.JANAGARATHINAM W.P.NO.14747/2008 NOVA TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY ALFA EDUCATIONAL TRUST, COIMBATORE REP. BY ITS CORRESPODNENT, ..PETITIONER IN K.PALANISAMY W.P.NO.14792/2008 HOLY ANGELS TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE FOR WOMEN, RUN BY HOLY ANGELS TRUST, METTUPALAYAM, COIMBATORE DISTRICT, REP. BY ITS SECRETARY, ..PETITIONER IN D.DEVAKUMAR W.P.NO.15492/2008 THE MARUTHAPPA MARIYAMMAL TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY CHAIRPERSON, ..PETITIONER IN DHARAPURAM, ERODE DISTRICT W.P.NO.15521/2008 SRI MARUTHAI MUTHAIAH TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY SRI MARUTHAI MUTHAIAH EDUCATIONAL CHARITABLE TRUST, TRICHY, REP BY ITS CORRESPONDENT ..PETITIONER IN M.KRISHNAMOHAN W.P.NO.16061/2008 APOLLOS TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, REV.JABATHONI A.M.DAVID, URALPATTI, UDUMALPET, TK, ..PETITIONER IN COIMBATORE DIST. W.P.NO.16142/2008 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ VICTORY TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY A.D.K.VICTORY EDUCATIONAL CHARITABLE TRUST, SRIPERUMBUDUR, THIRUVALLUR DISTRICT, REP BY ITS CHAIRMAN, ..PETITIONER IN K.V.BALASUBRAMANIAN W.P.NO.16230/2008 SHRI BHARATHI TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE REP. BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, M. SHANMUGAM, ..PETITIONER IN ROYAKOTTAH, KRISHNAGIRI DISTRICT. W.P.NO.16802/2008 THE METTUR TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, M.KALIPATTI, MECHERI, METTUR TALUK, SALEM DISTRICT REP.BY CORRESPONDENT ..PETITIONER IN MR.S.RAMANATHAN W.P.NO.17010/2008 VPN TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY VPN EDUCATIONAL & CHARITABLE TRUST, REP.BY MANAGING TRUSTEE, MR.P. GOPINATH, ..PETITIONER IN VILLUPURAM DT. W.P.NO.17547/2008 PANIMALAR TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY RURAL EDUCATIONAL AND CULTURAL TRUST, CHENGAM, TIRUVANNAMALAI DISTRICT, REP.BY ITS CHAIRMAN/CORRESPONDENT, ..PETITIONER IN G.VANANGAMUDI W.P.NO.17749/2008 ROYAL TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE FOR WOMEN, RUN BY SHREE VENKATACHALAPATHY EDUCATIONAL TRUST, VEERANANDHAPURAM, KATTUMANNARKOIL TK., CUDDALORE DISTRICT REP.BY ITS ..PETITIONER IN CORRESPONDENT V.C. RADHAA W.P.NO.17973/2008 R.G.PATTAMMAL GOVINDARAJAN TEACHER EDUCATION SCHOOL, RUN BY R.G.PATTAMMAL EDUCATION TRUST, KUMBAKONAM, REP.BY ITS MANAGING TRUSTEE ..PETITIONER IN SMT. R.G.PATTAMMAL W.P.NO.17990/2008 KAVINGAR KOLANJI TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY KRISHNAMOORTHY EDUCATIONAL TRUST, JAYANKONDAM, PERAMBALUR DISTRICT, REP.BY ITS ..PETITIONER IN CHAIRMAN, R.KAVITHA W.P.NO.18585/2008 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ MEDS TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, REP.BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, S.KAMAL NASIR, MUDUKULATHUR, ..PETITIONER IN RAMANATHAPURAM DISTRICT. W.P.NO.19309/2008 P.S.G. PONNAMMAL TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY P.S.G. PONNAMMAL EDUCATIONAL TRUST, KANGAYAM, ERODE DT, REP.BY ITS CORRESPONDENT ..PETITIONER IN P. SAMIAPPA GOUNDER W.P.NO.19417/2008 AKATHIYAR TEACHERS TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY ARULMIGU AYYANAR EDUCATIONAL TRUST, REP.BY ITS CHAIRMAN MR.C.VIJAYASUNDARAM, KEELATHUR, L.N.PURAM, ANAVAYAL PO, ..PETITIONER IN ALANGUDI TK, PUDUKKOTTAI W.P.NO.21258/2008 ST. PAULS TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY ST. PAULS EDUCATIONAL AND CHARITABLE TRUST, PERIYAR NAGAR, CHENNAI, REP.BY ITS SECRETARY ..PETITIONER IN A.MOSES SAMUEL CHELLIAH W.P.NO.21888/2008 C.K.S.TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY C.K.S.EDUCATIONAL TRUST, GUDIYATHAM, VELLORE DISTRICT, ..PETITIONER IN REP.BY ITS CHAIRMAN C.KUPPUSAMY W.P.NO.25105/2008 SELF-FINANCING PRIVATE TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTES ASSOCIATION (REGD.) REP.BY ITS PRESIDENT, MR. T.V.K. BABU, NEW NO.11, OLD NO.7, 3RD CROSS STREET, ..PETITIONER IN C.I.T. NAGAR, CHENNAI-35. W.P.NO.25182/2008 DR.NALLINI INSTITUTE OF TEACHER TRAINING, RUN BY SAKTHI MEDICAL TRUST, ACHIYUR (P.O.), DHARAPURAM, ERODE DISTRICT, ..PETITIONER IN REP.BY ITS CORRESPONDENT DR.S. APPUSWAMY W.P.NO.25187/2008 J.K.TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE RUN BY VEDASANDUR RAJATHIAMMAL AND RENGASAMY CHETTIAR TRUST, DINDIGUL, REP.BY ITS CHAIRMAN, ..PETITIONER IN R. KATHIRVEL W.P.NO.25193/2008 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ C.S.S.R. TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY C.S.S.R. EDUCATIONAL TRUST, MURUGA BHAVANAM, DINDIGUL, REP.BY ITS CORRESPONDENT, T.S. THANDEESWARAN ..PETITIONER IN W.P.NO.25205/2008 MATHA TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY KARTHIKEYAN EDUCATIONAL TRUST, VEDARANIYAM TK, NAGAI DISTRICT, ..PETITIONER IN REP.BY ITS CORRESPONDENT S. KARTHIKEYAN W.P.NO.25234/2008 KARTHIKEYAN TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY KARTHIKEYAN EDUCATIONAL TRUST, PUTTUR, NAGAI DISTRICT, REP.BY ITS ..PETITIONER IN CORRESPONDENT S. KARTHIKEYAN W.P.NO.25249/2008 SRI PASPO TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY SRI PASPO EDUCATIONAL & CHARITABLE TRUST, ILLAMPATTY VILLAGE, DHARMAPURI, REP.BY ITS CORRESPONDENT ..PETITIONER IN B. ANURADHA W.P.NO.25253/2008 DANIE TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY DANIE EDUCATIONAL TRUST, CHETPET, POLUR TK, TIRUVANNAMALAI DISTRICT ..PETITIONER IN REP.BY ITS CORRESPONDENT D.BASKARAN W.P.NO.25255/2008 DANIE INBAM TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTE, RUN BY DANIE INBAM EDUCATIONAL TRUST, CHENNAI REP.BY ITS CORRESPONDENT ..PETITIONER IN D.INBANATHAN W.P.NO.25256/2008 Annai Teresa Teacher Training Institute for Women Run by Christian Mission Educational Trust, Rep.by its Correspondent V.Rani, Konaripatti,Thammampatti Via, Gangavalli Taluk,Salem District. .. Petitioner in W.P.24139/08 Vs 1. The State of Tamil Nadu Rep.by its Secretary, School Education Department, Fort.St.George,Chennai - 600 009. .. 1st Respondent in W.P.13200,12767,12768,12781, https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ 12806,12807,12782,12783,12800, 12801,12848,12849,12984,13024, 13028,13066 to 13075/08, 12540,13086,13115,13120,13121, 13136,13196 to 13199,13201, 13307 to 13311,13314,13316, 13317,13321 to 13326,13482, 13484,13558 to 13560,13585, 13604,13628,13705,13718,13853, 14123,14124,14125,14286,14599, 14680,14747,14792,15492,16061, 16142,16802,17010,17547,17749, 17973,17990,18585,19309,19417, 21258,21888,25105,25182,25187, 25193,25205,25234,25249,25253, 25255,25256,24139/08. 2nd Respondent in W.P.15521/08 The Director of Teacher Education,Research & Training, College road, Chennai - 600 006. .. 2nd Respondent in W.P.13200, 12767,12768,12781,12806,12807, 12782,12783,12800,12801,12848, 12849,12984,13028,13066 to 13075/08,12540,13086,13115,13120, 13121,13136,13196 to 13199,13201, 13307 to 13311,13314,13316,13317, 13321 to 13326,13482,13484,13558 to 13560,13585,13604,13628,13705, 13718,13853,14123,14124,14125, 14286,14599,14680,14747,14792, 15492,16061,16142,16802,17010, 17547,17749,17973,17990,18585, 19309,19417,21258,21888,25105, 25182,25187,25193,25205,25234, 25249,25253,25255,25256,24139/08 3nd Respondent in W.P.15521/08 The Principal, District Institute of Education & Training (DIET) Ottanchatram, Dindigul District. .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.No.13200/08 The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training (DIET) Uthamacholapuram,salem Dist., .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.12767/08,12540,17010 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training, Thirumoorthy Nagar, Coimbatore District. .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.12768/08,14792/08, 15492/08 The Principal, District Institute of Educational and Training (DIET) Vadalur,Cuddalore District. .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.12781,12984,13120 & 13121/08 The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training (DIET) Ranipet, Vellore District. .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.12782/08,12783,13086, 13115,13136,25105 The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training (DIET) Pudukottai, Pudukottai District. .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.12800/08 5.The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training (DIET) Perunthurai, Erode District. .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.12801,13201,13317, 14747,19417,25187 4th Respondent in W.P.15521/08 The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training (DIET) Kumulur, Trichy District. .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.12848,12849,16061/08 The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training (DIET) Kalaiyarkoil,Sivaganga District. .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.13196 to 13198/08 The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training (DIET) Manjur, Ramnad District. .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.13199/08,19309/08 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training, Triplicane, Chennai .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.13316/08,21888/08 The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training (DIET) Krishnagiri, Krishnagiri District. .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.13482/08,16802/08, 13585/08,13604,13705 & 25253/08 The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training (DIET) Tirur, Thiruvallur District. .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.13484/08,16230/08 The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training (DIET) Aduthurai,Kumbakonam, Thanjavur District. .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.13558/08,17990/08 The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training, Cuddalore. .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.13559/08 The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training, Munanjipatti, Tirunelveli District. .. 3rd Respondent in W.P.13560/08 3. THE PRINCIPAL DISTRICT INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION AND TRAINING (DIET), KALIYAMPOONDI, KANCHEEPURAM DIST. ...3rd Respondent in W.P.13628/08 & 25256/08 3. THE PRINCIPAL DISTRICT INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION AND TRAINING, G.ARIYUR, VILLUPURAM DISTRICT. ...3rd Respondent in W.P.13718/08 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ 3.THE PRINCIPAL DISTRICT INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION AND TRAINING, KANCHEEPURAM. ...3rd Respondent in W.P.13853/08 3.THE PRINCIPAL DISTRICT INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION AND TRAINING (DIET) OTTANCHATRAM, DINDIDGUL DT. ...3rd Respondent in W.P.14286/08 25205/08 3.THE PRINCIPAL DISTRICT INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION AND TRAINING (DIET), KILPENNATHUR, TIRUVANNAMALAI DIST....3rd Respondent in W.P.17749/08 25255/08 3.THE PRINCIPAL DISTRICT INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION AND TRANING (DIET), KEELAPALUR, ARIYALUR DT. ...3rd Respondent in W.P.18585/08 3.THE PRINCIPAL DISTRICT INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION AND TRAINING (DIET), KURUKKATHI, NAGAPATTINAM DT. ...3rd Respondent in W.P.25234/08 25249/08 THE NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION, REP. BY ITS MEMBER SECRETARY, HANS BHAVAN, WING - II, NEW DELHI - 110 002. ...3rd Respondent in W.P.25182/08 4. THE REGIONAL DIRECTOR, NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION, I FLOOR, C.S.D.COMPLEX, H.M.T.POST JALAHALLI, BANGALORE-560 031. ..IST RESPONDENT IN W.P.NO.15521 OF 2008 ..2ND RESPONDENT IN W.P.NO.13024/08 ..3RD RESPONDENT IN W.P.13307, 13321 TO 13326, 14123, 14680, 17547, 21258, 24139/08 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ 4TH RESPONDENT IN W.P.NOS.13200, 12767, 12768, 12781, 12806, 12807, 12782, 12783, 12800, 12801, 12848, 12849, 12984, 13028, 13066 TO 13075, 12540, 13086, 13115, 13120, 13121, 13136, 13196 TO 13199, 13201, 13211, 13316, 13317,13482, 13484, 13558 TO 13560, 13585,13604,13628, 13705, 13718, 13853,14124,14125,14286, 14599, 14747, 14792,15492,16061,16142,16802,17010, 17749, 17943, 17990, 18585,19309, 19417, 21888, 25105, 25187, 25193, 25205, 25234,25249, 25253, 25255, 25256 2008 4. THE REGIONAL DIRECTOR, NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION, SOUTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE I FLOOR, C.S.D.COMPLEX, H.M.T.TOWNSHIP, BANGALORE-560 031. ..4TH RESPONDENT IN W.P.NO.25182/08 5. THE MEMBER SECRETARY, NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION, HANS BHAVAN, WING II, 1, BAHADURSHA ZAFAR MARG (NEAR ITO) NEW DELHI-110 002. ..3RD RESPONDENT IN W.P.12806,/08, 12807,13066 TO 13075, 13211, 14124, 14125,14599/08 5TH RESPONDENT IN W.P.NOS.13200, 12781, 12782, 12783, 12800,12801, 12848, 12849, 12984, 13086, 13115, 13136,13201, 13482, 13484, 13585, 13604,13628, 13705, 13718, 13853, 14286, 14747, 14792,15492, 16061, 17749, 17973, 17990, 18585, 19417, 21888, 25105, 25187, 25193, 25205, 25234, 25249, 25253, 25255 AND 25256 OF 2008 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ PRAYER in WP.13200 of 2008 : Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying for the issuance of a writ of certiorari calling for the records from the first respondent (W.P.NOS.13200, 12768, 12781, 12782, 12783, 12800, 12801, 12848, 12849, 12984, 13024, 13086,13115, 13120, 13121, 13136, 13196 TO 13199, 13201, 13307 TO 13311, 13316, 13318, 13321 TO 13326,13482, 13484, 13558 TO 13560, 13585,13628, 13705, 13718, 13853, 14123, 14186,14680, 14747, 14792,15492,16061, 16142, 16230, 16802,17547,19309, 19417, 21258, 21888, 25105, 25182,25187, 25193, 25205, 25234,25249, 25253,25255, 25256 AND 24139 OF 2008) 2ND RESPONDENT IN W.P.15521 OF 2008 in G.O.(Ms.)No.94, School Education (U1) Department, dated 03.5.2008, and quash the same. W.P.No.12767/08 “Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus” Calling for the records relating to the order of the 1st Respondent dated 3.5.2008 in G.O. (MS)NO.94, School Education (VI) Department and quash the same only in so far as it relates to the petitioner consequently (1) direct the Respondents 1 to 3 to grant Staff Approval to the Petitioner for the additional intake of 50 Students in the D.T.Ed Course for the Academic year 2008-2009. (W.P.No.12767/08, 13028/08, 12540). (2) direct the 2nd Respondent to grant Staff approval of the teaching faculties appointed and employed by the petitioner Institute for additional intake without imposing any conditions, so as to enable the petitioner Institute to conduct the Course of Diploma in Teacher Education from the Academic Year 2008-2009, as recognized by the 4th Respondent (W.P.No.12806/08)12807/08, 13066 to 13075/08, 13211/08, 14124, 14125, 17010, (3) direct the 2nd Respondent to grant approval for the Staff list submitted by the Petitioner for the running of the Diploma in Teacher Education Course from the Academic Year 2008-2009 in the name of Sri.Rangapoopathy Teacher Training Institute for women (W.P.No.13314/08) (4) direct the 3rd Respondent herein to approve the Staff list submitted by the petitioner on 30.5.08, forthwith so as to enable the petitioner Institution to admit Students for the academic year 2008-2009 and for subsequent years (W.P.NO.15521/08) W.P.No.17749/08 Calling for the records from the 1st Respondent in G.O.(MS) No.94, School Education (VI) Department, dated 3.5.08 and the Consequential letter of the 2nd Respondent in (1) RC.No.6789/C4/2008 https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ (W.P.No.17749/08) 2. R.C.No.6790/C4/2008 (W.P.No.17973/08)3. R.C.No.6804/C3/2008 (W.P.No.17990/08 4. R.C.No.6800- 2/C3/2008 dated 19.6.08 (W.P.No.18585/08 respectively. dated 20.6.08, quash the same and further direct the 2nd Respondent to grant staff approval to the petitioner Institution without reference to the impugned G.O. (W.P.No.17749/08, 17973,17990 & 18585/08) PRAYER in WP.25182 of 2008 : Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying for the issuance of a writ of certiorari calling for the records in respect of the impugned Government Order in G.O.Ms.No.94, School Education (U1) Department, dated 03.5.2008 issued by the first respondent and quash the same as ultra vires the Constitution, void, unlawful, arbitrary, without jurisdiction in so far as it relates to the members of the petitioner is concerned. For petitioner in WP.Nos.13200, 12781, 12782, 12783, 12800, 12801, 12848, 12849, 13086, 13136, 13201, 13482, 13484, 13585, 13604, 12984, 13628, 13705, 14286, 14747,14792, 15492, 16061, 16230,17749, 17973, 17990, 18585,19417, 21888, 25105, 25187,25193, 25205, 25234, 25249, 25253, 25255 & 25256/2002 :: Mr.B.Rabu Manohar WP.Nos.12767,12768, 12540, 13120, 13121,13196 to 13199 13316, 13317,13558 to 13560, 16142, 19309 of 2002 :: Mr.K.Selvaraj WP.Nos.12806, 12807, 13066 to 13075,14124,14125,14599 25182 of 2008 :: Mr.R.Muthukumarasamy, SC & Mr.N.R.Chandran, SC for Mr.R.Sureshkumar WP.No.13024 of 2008 :: Mr.Vijay Narain, SC for Mr.E.Vijay Anand WP.No.13028 of 2008 :: Mr.S.Jaganathan WP.No.13211 of 2008 :: M/s.Chandrasekaran & Associates WP.Nos.13307 to13311,13321 to 13326,14123,14680,17547, 21258, 24139 of 2008 :: Mr.M.Hidayatullah Khan https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ W.P.No.13314 of 2008 :: Mr.P.Srinivas W.P.Nos.13718, 13853/2008:: Mr.T.S.Sivagnanam W.P.No.15521 of 2008 :: Mr.P.Sanjay Gandhi W.P.No.16802 of 2008 :: Mr.Javid Khan W.P.No.17010 of 2008:: Mr.C.Robert Bruce For respondents in W.Ps.13200 &12782 of 2008 :: Mr.S.Ramasamy, AAG asstd. by Mr.G.Sankaran, Spl.G.P.for Ms.Dakshayini Reddy,GA for Government For respondents in W.P.Nos.12767, 12768, 12800, 12801, 13307 to 13311,13321 13482, 13484, 13558 to 13560, 13585, 13604, 13628, 15492, 15521, 16230, 16802, 17749, 21258 of 2008 :: Mr.Ramakrishna Reddy for NCTE, Bangalore. For respondents in W.P.Nos.12806,12807 of 2008 12800, 12801 of 2008 :: Mr.L.S.M.Hasan Fizal,G.A. for Government For respondents in W.P.Nos.12806,12807,12984 , 13066 to 13075, 13136 of 2008 :: Mr.P.R.Gopinathan for R4 For respondents in W.P.No.14599 of 2008 :: Mr.M.T.Arunan, ACGSC for R3 and R4 O R D E R These batch of writ petitions challenges the constitutional validity of G.O.Ms.No.94, School Education Department, dated 03.5.2008. All these writ petitions were grouped together and under the orders of the Honourable Chief Justice were directed to be posted for final disposal before this Court. 2. These writ petitions are of a seasonal character and are filed year after year whenever the State Government comes up with orders relating to Teacher Training Institutes (for short, TTIs) run under the self-financing basis, laying down certain guidelines https://hcservices.ecourts.gov.in/hcservices/ dealing with admission, teacher's qualification and examination. In this batch, one set of writ petitions is filed by the TTIs, which are yet to get affiliation by the examining body. W.P.No.25182 of 2008 is filed by an Association representing the existing TTIs, which already have recognition from the National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) and also approval by the authorities under the State Government. 3. Ever since the creation of NCTE, the relative position of the NCTE vis-a-vis State Government became a contentious issue and there has been scores of litigation before this Court and the Supreme Court. The State Government has been issuing orders on an yearly basis with reference to the functions to be discharged by the officers under the State Government in relation to the TTIs. 4. When G.O.(2D) No.59, School Education Department, dated 14.11.2006 prescribing the last date for approval of the list of staff members by the respective TTIs were issued, a batch of writ petitions being W.P.No.47503 of 2006 and batch cases (Annai Teacher Training Institute -vs- State of Tamil Nadu) was filed before this Court. Those writ petitions were dismissed by a common judgment dated 03.4.2007. V.Ramasubramanian, J. delivering the common judgment while upholding the said G.O. in paragraphs 27(c), (d) and (e) had observed as follows:- ''27.(c) Within two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order, the State Government shall issue a compendium of guidelines, prescribing the calendar of activities for the Teacher Training Institutes, indicating (i) the date of commencement of the Course, (ii) the cut off date for approval of staff members, (iii) the cut off date for admission of students, (iv) the cut off date for holding Single Window Counselling, for sponsoring candidates under the Government