IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA MJC No.2256 of 2008 ------ Raheshi Devi wife of Late Sahdeo Mandal (wrongly) described as Lila Devi wife of Late Sahdeo Mandal resident of village-Kashwa, Police Station-Surajgarha, District-Lakhisarai (wrongly mentioned as District- Munger) at present residing at village- Sarai Sultanganj Cinema Chitra Talkies Police Station-Sultanganj, District-Bhagalpur … Appellant- petitioner. Versus 1. Sheonandan Singh Son of Late Saryug Singh. 2. Abhai Kumar Singh son of Late Saryug Singh, Both-resident of village-Kashwa, P.S.-Surajgarha, District-Munger. 3. Smt. Butan Devi alias Anita Devi wife of Late Biro Mandal and D/o. Late Sahdeo Mandal of Khajuria, P.S. Dharhara, District-Munger at present resident Kaswa. 4. Smt. Premshila Devi wife of Sri Masudan Mandal and D/o. Late Sahdeo Mandal of Urdu Mohalla, Bhagalpur, P.O. and District- Bhagalpur at present resident Kaswa, Abhaipura, Lakhisarai. 5. Smt. Sangeeta Devi wife of Vijay Mandal and D/o. Sahdeo Mandal of Kajloopur, P.S. Ghogha, District-Bhagalpur, P.S. Sanhaula at present Kaswa Abhayapur, Lakhisarai. 6. Most. Sundari wife of Khopri Mandal (deceased) 7. Pappu Mandal minor son of Shadeo Mandal, of village Kashwa, P.S. Surajgarha, District-Munger at present Village-Sarai Sultanganj, Cinema Chitra talkies, P.S. Sultanganj, District-Bhagalpur. … Defendants- Respondents Ist Party. 8. Madhuri Devi wife of Rajendra Mandal (deceased). 9. Kiran Kumari 10. Sulochana Kumari Minor daughters of Late Rajendra Mandal U/G of mother Madhuri Devi 11. Latto Mandal alias Rajesh Mandal alias Sarad Chandra Mandal Minor son of Late Rajendra Mandal U/G of his mother Madhuri Devi, all residents of village-Kashwa, P.S. Surajgarha, District- Munger. --- Defendants—Respondents 2nd Party. 12. Shanti Devi wife of Uchit Mahton of Village Arma, P.O. Arma, P.S. Surajgarha, District-Lakhisarai. 13. Kanti Devi wife of Snil Mahton village-Basgarha, P.S. Basudeopur, P.S. Kotwali, District-Munger. 14. Daya Devi D/o Sepahi Mandal of village Bariyarpur, Post Bariyarpur, District-Munger. 15. Kalpana Devi W/o. Late Goraylal Mandal. 16. Sabita Kumari 17. Lalita Kumari minors U/G Mother Kalpana Devi of Kashwa, P.O. Abhaipur, P.S. Surajgarha, District-Lakhisarai. 18. Shibu Mandal U/G Shri Tribhuban Prasad, Advocate G.A.L. 19. Shubhas Takur. 20. Abbhin alias Arun. 21. Manoj Thakur. - 2 - 22. Anuj Thakur. All sons from Sl.Nos.18 to 22 are sons of Late Baghunandan Thakur. 23. Raghubir Thakur son of Late Harihar Thakur. 24. Ramdas Mandal 25. Bhumi Mandal Sons of Bangali Mandal. 26. Bijay Yadav. 27. Badri Yadav. 28. Tuni Yadav 29. Jago Yadav Sl Nos. 26 to 29 are sons of Late Debi Yadav. 30. Chhedi Mandal 31. Ramji Mandal 32. Chamru Mandal 33. Viveka Nand Singh son of Tunha Singh, Saraswati Sadan Begusarai, P.S. and District-Begusarai. 34. Kadmee Devi D/o Tunha Singh, Saraswati Sadan Begusarai, P.O.and District-Begusarai. ---- Defendants- Respondents 3rd Party- Respondents. ----------- For the petitioner : None. 04. 02.02.2009 This petition has been filed for recall of order dated 31.01.2007 passed in M.J.C.No.1857 of 2003, by which the said MJC case was held to have abated against opposite party no.2 and his heirs, as even after grant of time on 11.07.2005 for filing substitution petition for deceased opposite party no.2, but although more than one a half years passed, neither any substitution application was filed, nor anyone appeared on behalf of the petitioner. In the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this court does not find any reason or occasion to take a view different from the view taken earlier and, hence, this petition for recall of the earlier order in the said MJC case is dismissed. Sunil (S. N. Hussain, J.)