IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA LPA No.583 of 2005 1(a)Sham Sunnissa, widow of Md. Vakil Ansari, deceased 1(b) Md. Aslam Asnari 1© Md. Abullais Ansari 1(d) Md. Akram Ali 1(e) Md. Nasim Ansari @ Md. Nasim Akhtar 1(f) Md. Jawed Akhtar 1(g) Md. Anis Ansari 1(h) Anjum Ara, all sons and daughter of Md. Vakil Ansari, deceased and residents of Village- Hauda Domra, P.S. Matiaria Gaunaha and District-West Champaran. 1(i) Alam Ara, wife of Md. Firoj Ahmad and daughter of Md. Vakil Ansari, deceased, resident of Mohalla Mohammad Nagar, P.S. Bettiah (Kotwali)and District-West Champaran. 1(j) Jahan Ara, wife of Ashique Iqbal and daughter of Md. Vakil Ansari, deceased, resident of Village Hasanpura Saugauli, P.S. Saguali and District- East Champaran. 2.Abdullah Ansari 3.Yaquoob Ansari, all are sons of late Naji Raiyajuddin Ansari, resident of Village Hauda Domra, P.S. Matyiaria Gaunaha, District- West Champaran ------ Appellants. Versus 1. The State of Bihar 2. The Sub divisional Magistrate, Narkatiyaganj, District- West Champaran. 3. The Anchal Adhikari Gaunaha, District-West Champaran ---- Respondent Ist Set ---- Respondents. 4. Sogra Khatoon, widow of late Khalil Ahmad Ansari 5.(a) Anisul Ansari (b) Arsad Ansari © Firoz Ansari (d) Mumtaz Ansari (e) Quaser Ansari (f) Musarrat Khatoon, all (a) to (d) are sons and (e) and (f) are daughters of Serajul Haque and Salma Khatoon deceased R/V Hauda Dumra, P.O. Beldsandi, P.S. Narkatiyaganj, District-West Champaran (g) Mostt. Sabnam Khatoon, wife of As Mahamedia and D/o Salma Khatoon deceased, R/V Gajna, P.O.Dihi, P.S. Jogapatti, Distt-West Champaran (h) Afsana Khatoon w/o Asraf Ansari, d/o Salma Khatoon deceased R/V Baisiya P.O. Dihi, P.S. Jagapatti, Dist. West Champaran (i) Raushan Khatoon W/o Aslam D/o Salma Khatoon, deceased V. Baswaria, P.O. Bettiah, P.S. Bettiah Town, Distt. West Champaran. 6. Habiba Khatoon wife of Anzarul Haque 7. Kulsum Nissa wife of Md. Hashim 8(a) Md. Zabiullah Ansari-son (b) Aslam Perwaiz-son © Ashraf Perwaiz-son (d) Ambiya Khatoon daughter 2 (e) Rajia Khatoon-daughter, all are residents of Village Hauda Domra, P.S. Matiaria(Gaunaha) Distt-West Champaran Respondent 2nd Set. -------------- 17. 9.10.2009 Heard Mr. Md. Abu Haider for the appellants, and Mr.Basisth Narain Mishra, learned Assistant Counsel to Standing Counsel No.16. This appeal under Clause 10 of the Letters Patent of the High Court of Judicature at Patna, has been preferred by respondent nos. 4 to 6 of C.W. J.C. No. 12599 of 2002 (Sogra Khatoon & Ors. Vrs. The State of Bihar & Ors.), whereby the writ petition has been allowed and the claim with respect to Bataidari rights/occupancy rights has been upheld. Appellant nos. 1(a) to 1(j) are the substituted heirs of Md. Vakil Ansari, the original appellant, and was respondent no.4 to the writ proceedings. It appears to us that the issues are concluded by the findings of fact, and no question of law arises in this appeal. This appeal is accordingly dismissed. Vinay/ ( S. K. Katriar ,J. ) (Kishore K. Mandal, J.)