1 P 69 1 1 1 CWP N003584OF 2008etce 1 r IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHAIITDIGARHe 1 1 DATE OF DECISION 20 0502011 leCWP N001197of2009 4l m NiranjanSingh OeePetitioner 91 0 0 VERSUS r StateofHaryanaand others 4 2eCWP N03584 of2008 4f Z Neha Yadav 1r 1 eeePetitioner C VERSUS The State ofHaryanaand others Z e e r 3eCWP Noe9738of2009 v 4 Sandeep SinghSihagand others meo Z OeePetitioners 1 Cl VERSUS StateofHaryanaand others e e 1 1 4eCWPNoe271of2010 em aljinder Singh eeePetitioner VERSUS State ofHaryanaand others e e 1 0 1 Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document i P 18 70 1 01 4 CWP Noe3584OF 2008etce 2 J te 5eCWP No16118 of2009 V PradeepYadav OeePetitioner 1 4 e VERSUS StateofHaryana and others 1 C 6eCWP N0015455of2009 9 I4 1d 0 SanjeevTinjan 1 0 OeePetitioner r 9 VERSUS State ofHaryanaand others Z 1 e e 1 11 7eCWPN001822of2009 Io Il Arvind Kumar 6 eeePetitioner Z V1ERSUS 0 StateofHaryanaand others em e e Z 8eCWP Noe20315of2008 1 C Abhishek Goyal and others l eeePetitioners VERSUS State ofHaryanaand others 1 4e e e 9eCWPNoe21821of20081 Mukesh Yadav 1 eeePetitioner 1 VERSUS 1 W4 9a4 V Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document r 71 1 J r CWP N03584 OF 2008etce 3 b4StateofHaryanaand others 1 e e 100CWPNoe1236of2009 Iv Nitin PratapSingh 1 1 eeePetitioner 1 VERSUS m StateofHaryanaetce e e 1 1 0 0 CORAM CD HONBLE MReJUSTICE PERMOD KOHLI 1 2 PRESENT2 MrRajivAtmaRam SrAdvocatewith MrNikhil ChopraAdvocate 0 MrRK Malik SrAdvocatewith 6 MrKohel Dev Advocate 1 t MrJK Sibal SrAdvocatewith Z MsHanmeetKaur Advocate Cll MrPuneet GuptaAdvocate 1 vmm MrPankajJain Advocate Z Mratin Salwan Advocate Om 4 MrDheeraj Chawla Advocate MrPuneet GuptaAdvocate MrHakam ManujaAdvocate 1 AllKarminder SinghAdvocate MrRKS Brar AddlAG Haryana with SinghAAG Haryana Permod KohIi Je 1 Petitionersin all thesepetitions are Law GraduatesReliefs claimed 0 Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document r 72 c 1 CWP N03584 OF 2008etce 4 4beingidentical these petitions are being of by this common t Facts relevantfor the purposeof thesepetitionsare being 1 noticedhereineafterl HighCourt of PunjabandHaryanaissuedbrochurein theyear 2007 1 lnvltlng for recruitmento HaryanaCivil Service Tudicial BranchThis brochurecontainedall necessaryandrelevant detailsrelating L to eligibility criteria datefor making mode and t1 0 methodof selection syllabusand other necessaryconditions These details 0 arenot beingreferredto thesame beingnot germaneto the of r 0 the issuesinvolvedin thesepetitionsApart om detailsreferredto above numberof vacancies to be fllled in throughthe processof Z selection are containedin the brochureSincethenumberofvacanciesis a r relevantfactor for the purpose of decidingthese petitions the same are being hereunderl 1 1 Z Availablener ofvacant posts 34 ClO details are as underl t me SreNOe Cegory NOeOfPosts Remwks Z 1 General 16 1 2 Scheduled Castes of 9 Out of these 2 vacancies are Haryana beingadvertisedfor the third time 3 Backward Classes of 5 Inclusive of 2 carried forward Haryana vacancies which are being advertisedfor thesecondtime 4 ExServicemen of 1 1 ee Haryana eW 0 Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 73 1r7 e CWP N003584OF 2008etce 5 pn n Cagory NOe0S8 Remwks t 5 Physically 3 2 carried forwards vacancies which are being advertisedfor the third time In case of of suitablecandidatesagainst any or both vacancies then these 1 1 vacancles will be fllled up from amongst the suitablecandidates belonging to the categoryof Exe serviceman and irtherin case of of suitable 1 candidate belonging to the 0 category of Exeservicementhen Ii thesevacancieswill be thrown 1 0 uponto the general category111 0 terms of Govemment instructionscontained in letter r No24151913GSIII dated C 2211991 It is also providedin the brochure that in addition to 34 vacant 1 Z posts20 vacancies are beingadvertised as per the I r m of the Honble Supreme Court in Malik Mazhar Sultan vse UePePublic ServiceCommissionand others 200619 Supreme Court Cases 507 and b 1 2008 XVII SCC 7030 details of these vacancies are as Z underl ClO 46 IaW Z VO Category NOe OSts 1 General 12 0 t 2 ScheduledCastesofHaryana 4 3 BackwardClassesofHaryana 1 ee 1 4 ExmServicemen of Haryana 2 5 Physically Ortholof 1 Haryana 1 It was also stipulated that numberof vacanciesmay vary Selection was to be made on the basis of preliminary examinatior 6iMain examinatioliioVivToce It is admiued case ofthe 4r1 Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 74 1 4 8 CWP N003584OF 2008etc 6 pS that all the appliedwithin period Alter 1 the examinationtheywere penniued to appearin the maln and vivevoce vide notiflcationdated3022008 Final 1 result generalment list was issued on 1322008 64nnexure Pm7 Thereafter on thebasis of the recommendationsmadeby the Selection Committee were madebythe GovemmentvideMemo dated 1322008 exure P The couldnot be 1 t 1 0 Namesofthe were accordingly enteredin the concemedregister 0 maintainedat HighCourt 9 The categorywise status ofthe petitioners is as underl e Name CWPNOe Category 1 Z NehaYadav 35840f2008 BackwardClass 1 1 V onel 0 2 NiranjanSingh 11970f2009 General one 3e Sandeep SinghSihagMohit 97380f2009 General 1 Sondhi Singh 6one9 Z Garg e 4 Pradeep Yadav 16118of2009 General C one 5 Sanjeev Tinjan 154550f2009 General m Z one9 6 BaljinderSingh 271of2010 General 6 t fl one 7 Arvind Kumar 1822of 2009 General onel 8 Abhishek Goyal Neeraj203150f2008 General Goyal Nitin Mittal and four9 Surender 1 44 9 MukeshYadav 21821of2008 BackwardClass onel 10 Nitin PratapSingh 1236of2009 General 6one 1 Totall General 12 BC 2 In view of their nonmselectionsome of the petitioners claimed their selection and byfiling However recelvlng no 4 Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document r 75 1 J CWP N0e3584OF 2008etCe 7 12J 1 to such these writ petitions have been flled followingreliefsl XXX XXX XXX 1 1 iiissue a writ in thenature of mandamusdirecting the to considerand appointthe as Civil Judge in the HaryanaCivil Services C Judicial Brancl in pursuanceto the selectionconducted 9k 0 by it the result of which has been declared vide 0 AnnexureP6 with effect from 1322008 when other 0 similarly situatedselectedin the same processhave been selectedand and grantall reliefs 1 Z I l that flow thereom includingsenioritypay fixation 1 C arrearsofpayalongwith interestetc 99 6 The are claimingtheir on the t3 Z following groundsl CO OOutof six postsadvertisedfor BackwardClass 5 actual 4 l W onlythreepostshavebeenfllled in the first instancevide notifications dated Z 132008 and 1432008 1 1 tl i0 12 persons have beenpromoted on regularbasisas Additional District Judgeswhereas five personswere appointed as Additional District Judges on ad hoc basis for the Fast Track Courts in Haryanawhereasfive notified 1 vacanciesfrom ScheduledCasteCategory remainunfilled 12454522 6iioOn21112007 65 postsof Civil JudgesrDivision were created by the which inter alia includes six postsfor Backward Classand 13 for ScheduledCaste candidates ivAs against13 advertised vacancies for ScheduledCaste onlyfive have c1 1 Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 76 90 CWP N003584OF 2008etce 8 r been fllled and remaining 9 couldbe utilised for vacancles 1 fromthe BackwardClass categorycandidatesln vlew of the govemment instructionsdated1781976 which lnter alia provides for 1 of reservedcategoryvacancles ln the event of norvailabilityof candidatesfrom a reservedcategoryIn this case 9 Scheduled j Castecategoryvacancles were to be utilizedfor of Backward m 0 Class candidatesdue to of ScheduledCastecandidates Il 0 Resignationof Ove before 31102008 and one candidate 0 r from BackwardClass Category on 17A2009 Resultant vacancies 9 on account of are also to be fllled ln on thebasis of the same selectione Il Z I j It is contendedon behalf of the petitioners that all the availableposts 1 A L arerequired to be filled in on thebasisofselect list dated1322008 in Vlew 6 of the Honble Supreme Court in the case of MaIik Mazhar 0 Z Sultan supral The have giventhe details of the vacancles 00 filled in andavailablevacanciesundervariouscategories as underl 4t 1 2 3 4 m Z NoofPosts advertised Category PostsFilled by Balance vacant posts Selection k Om General Category 161228 Posts filledup Balance Remaining vacant posts 1 w i Postsadvertisedfor ScheduledCaste exure Pe5 r4 13 Postsfllled up 5 1 Balance remaining vacant 8 i Posts advertisedfor Backward Classes 6exure P5 654 6 e 6W ll Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 77 99J 1 1 CWP Noe3584OF 2008etce 9 V tl Postsfilled up 3 Balance remaining vacant 3 iio MembersofScheduledCaste 1 in February 2008 Z5 Membersofthe BackwardClass in 2008 3 4 1 iv Postscreatedon 211 12007 65 C r General J 0 ScheduledCastePosts 13 0 Backward Classposts 6 t5 1 Thus total number of vacancies available for members of the 1 Z ScheduledCasteandBackwardClassesare as underl 1 w General 6 ScheduledCasteCategory 26 1 Backward ClassCategory 12 Z Petitioner nalely Neha Yadav in CWP No3584 of 2008 submits 0 t that she is at SrNo 10 lll the list of Backward Class Category candidates wm Z and after ofthree candidatesfrom this categoryshe figures at ll Srll7 next in the order ofmerit 4 It is stated that out of 54 advertisedposts actual and 20 only 34 have been made lIl the following tnannerl 1 e General 23 ScheduledCaste 5 BackwardClass 6 Duringthe pendencyof these petitionsvanous were made in Vlew of events Accordingly on the basisof the funher 60 1 Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 78 1 e CWP N003584OF 2008etce 10 r additionalaffidavitshave beenfiled on boththe sides On the r basisof the additional information flve resignedbefore 31102008andone MrLoveleen on 17A2009 Their Ia 4 havebeen as 1S evident8om the affidavitdated29Al008 filed by Neha Yadav It is rtherallegedthatHighCourt decidedto appOlntone Mona Singhcandidatenext in the orderof meritvide decision 1 0 oftheCommitteedated 1432008 on the basisofher meritin the selection 1A 0 from General CategoryOn 5 2009 the High Court passedfollowing 0 interimorder in CWP N03584 of20081 t5 Adjournedto 2622009 er In the meantimetwo postsof HCS udiciallshall be 1 Z I l keptvacant It is lrther made clear that it would not be 1 opento the to take theplea ofthe selectIist havingexpired dueto effluxoftime 99 1 0 Z There are four in CWP No0315 of 2008 all from Cll GeneralCategoryTheyare at SrNosA2 to 45 in the merit list dated mwo 1322008 It is statedthat GeneralCategory candidatesuptomerit noAO Z already standsappointed and Mona Singhwho was next in the merit at 1 SrllloAl also standsappointedOne candidate namelyArvind Kumar ln CWP No1822 of2009 belongs to GeneralCategory and flguresat Srlo5O ln the merit list It is allegedthat candidates from SrNosA2 to 45 are writ 1 petitioners in CWP No20315 of 2008whereas candidate at SrNoA6 has not the Court Candidateat SroA7 has joinedPunjabCivil Services oTudicialBranch9whereas candidates at SrllTosA8 and 49 1 belonging to Backward Class Categorystand appointed vide notification dated 143 2008 and this petitioneris next in the merit in 1 ke1C Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 79 1 r CWP N03584 OF 2008etce 11 V CategoryPetitioner Pradeep Yadav in CWP No16118 of 2009 I who also to GeneralCategory falls at Srlo63 in themeritlist In CWP No738 of 2009 thereare three namely Singh 1 Mohit Sondhiand Singh to GeneralCategoryThey standat SrlosA32 267 and 128 in the flnal result lot the e meritlist PetitionerNiranjanSinghin CWP No1197 of 2009 m to GeneralCategoryis at Srlllo79 lIl the merit list Petitioner Mukesh 9 0 Yadavin CWP No21821 of2008 belonging to BC Category is at SrllTo11 0 PetitionerBaljinderSinghin CWP No71 of 2010 belonging to General Category 1Sat SrllloA7 in the final selectlist PetitionerSanjeevTinjanis GeneralCategory candidate His merit position is not reflected Ie Z 1 e Recruitment to theHCS JudicialServiceis govemed and by I l C rules namelyPunjabCivil ServicesoudicialBrancl Haryana 41 4 Rules 1951 including the amendmentsmadeby the StateofHaryanaBy 1 Z VlUe ofan amendmentnotification dated2332007 PunjabCivil Services CO Judicial Branch9Rules 1951 were amended 34 postsof Civil Judges 3 JrDivisior lyingvacant were to be filled up throughspecialrecruitment Z on the recommendationsof the SelectionCommitteeconstitutedfor the ll purposeThe Selection Committee was constitutedunder the rules comprising ofl 6i threeJudgesof the HighCourt of Punjaband Haryana nominatedbythe Honble the Chief Justice of whom the seniormost has i ee to be thechairmanii9the Chief to Governmentof Haryana and iio the Advocate General Haryanaand four legalremembrancersand Secretaries to Government of Haryanaand Legislative All other provisions in the existingrule regardingeligibilityageeducational conduct of examinationetc were to remain same Part B of 4w Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 80 11 11 b CWP N03584 OF 2008etce 12 V the originalrules deal with the submissionof whereasPart C t dealswith the examinationof candidatesRule 80f Part D was amended to the ofthe Honble Courtin Malik Mazhar 1 1 Sultan supra AmendedRule readsas underl Sln thesaidsaid Rules in partD ilfor rule l thefollowing ruleshall besubstitutednamely 1 1The names of candidatesselected by Government for as 1 0 Civil JudgesOuniorDivisiot under rule 10 and 11 ofthe Part C shallbe 0 r enteredin the HighCourt Registerin the orderof selectionto the extent of 0 30Io more than theadvertisedvacanciesso as to meet any for theadvertisedpost unfllled for any reason 99 1 Z r iilrule 8 shall beomitted L Separate replieshavebeen flled bytheStateand on behalfofthe High 1 Court While the vacanciesnotified throughthe brochure Il 0 Z and creationof 65 vacanciesduringthe ofthe writ petitions 110 theonlycontentionraisedbytheStateis thatall unfllledvacancieson va completion of the selectionprocess and after Z advertisementare to be advertisedagainto enable all eligible Om P candidatesto applyand seektheir eonsiderationfor It is lrther statedthatthe grievance lnade by the petitioners has no legal basisHighCourt alsoflled a shortaffldavit One ofthe pleasraised1S 1 eele that vacancies more than the advertisednumber cannot be filled To supportthis contention leamed counsel for the State reliesupon the judgment in Virender SinghHooda and others vse State ofHaryana and another 2005 RSJ 70 Affidavit Oled on behalf of the High Court reveals that out of 54 advertisedvacancles 34420953 stand 144 Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document r 81 0D 9 1 1 4 CWP Noe3584OF 2008etce 13 Y filed up and one posthas been reservedwhich is subject matter of 1 CWP No15130 of 2007 Referring to the of Honble Apex 1 Court in Malik Mazhar Sultan lpral thestandofthe HighCourt 1S that in with the ordersof the SupremeCourt 20 1 vacancles were advertisedand have also been lled up Further standofthe HighCourtisthatmere selectiondoesnot create a 1 Q rightin favourofthepetitioners 1 0 Due to certain the vacancy positionwhich inter 0 1 alia also includes the new creations and fresh 0 1 appolntments etc this Court passed an order dated 3009 seeking iiif6rmationfrom the HighCourt in respectof the pointsindicated 1 Z i r therein the same shall be referredto hereinter Pursuant to the C aforesaiddirectionsthe HighCourt flled affidavitdated1882009 of VirinderAggarwal PunjabandHaryanaHighCourt Z pointwise replycontainedin theaffldavitis as followsl CO Point categorywise General 42 J vacancypositionon the Z ScheduledCaste 394 date of issuanceof 8esh 24 Q 1 2341 advertisement dated BackwardClass 02 142008 for HaryanaExserviceman 06 PCS oTudicial Physically 04 1 44me Ortho9 Total 78 7444 1 1 6a4 1 Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 82 1 C le CWP Noe3584OF 2008etce 14 7r Point iowhether any unfilled No unfilled vacancy arisingout of 1 advertisement notiflcationdated2332007 vacancyfrom the earlier selection was included in the fresh advertisement arlSlng out of advertisement dated1492008 notification dated 2332007 was included in the fresh advertisement 11 m if so thenumberof such vacancles l with 1 0 0 Z 0 Point Noiioafter filling 54 One GeneralCategory vacancyaccruedon advertised vacancies whether any account of joiningof Shri Sushant in the cadre of PCS 4JB9on 1 Z vacancy became available as 32008 8 more candidatesalso 1 dropped out vacancy on account of 1 v l fromthepostof Civil JugeTrDivn in the 6 or resignationif So cadreofHCS 0B whichareas foUov 1 C number of such vacancies with Z categoryvise break up C1 r SFNOe Name othe otmdidotos Catogory bolongs to Dalo ofnocept of Z SIShrVMs resignaiion bythe Haryana GovL ll 1 1 ParshantShanna General 24102008 2 JatindraSingh General 2102008 3 Monika Saroha General 24102008 ewe 1 4 ChetnaSingh General 24102008 5e Lovleen BC 28A2009 1 6 GomatiManocha General 28A009 7 Ekta Gauba General 20009 sino Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 83 0 4 CWP Noe3584OF 2008etce 15 r SreNOe NameolthecandidaMs Category bes to Date 1 SlShril resiation bythe HwyanaGov 8e Dheeraj Mor General 32009 1 4 1 1 Point Nowhether the vacancles Pursuantto the decision of the selection mentioned in iio above and Committeeof the High 1 C Court dated2882008 Ms Mona Singhat were fllled up the manner anddates ti 1 0 SrNoAl of the select list of HCS JB of with details of the 1 0 from the GeneralCategory was r candidates and the categories to t5 bytheHaryana Govemmenton 1772009 1 which theybelong r Z i r Point Nowhether 65 additional65 Postsof Civil JudgeJrDivision were 1 m r 0 created during the createdby the HaryanaGovernmentvide Ia 4 vacancles letterdated2111 2007 These postswere pendencyof the flrst selection 1 C notified in the fresh advertisementdated Z initiated in the year 2007 were 142008 fi notified for fresh selection vide 7 advertisement dated 1492008 Z detailsthereof tl 1 Categorywise break up of thesevacancies Category NumberofPosts General 41 1 ScheduledCaste 2001 13 9ea BackwardClass 06 Exmserviceman05Io9 03 Physically Ortho 03Io9 02 44 Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document r 84 1 CWP N003584OF 2008etce 16 Pr Category Numberof Posts I Total 65 1 Point NoVI Retiree Promotions from PromotionsDeath ment 2332007 to Aer 1492008 142008 NIL Gm 6 One vacancy 9 accruingdue due to the 1 Total 16 Sc 4 G 8 death of Ajay 0 to Generale 9 BC 3 Kumar BC 1 retirement Aggarwal N SC 3 on 0 promotion 1452008 0 deat BC 2 General Category r etc after the C5 i of the 4r process of selection 1 Z initiated vide Ir Notification l dated 6 t 2322007 category wise l1 C Z In the affldavit of MrAggarwalthenumberof vacancies Cfl availablewere not specifiedclearlythoughdetailsof promotions were 17 givenThus vide order dated 12 102010 a funherdirectionwas issued to Z tl the High Court to flle fresh affldavit givingdetails of the vacancies 4 availableon account of promotionretirement and death of HCS Tudicial Branchlbetweenthe date of advertisementdated 233007 to 682009 date of ilssuance of next select list In responseto 1 this direction an additionalaffidavithas been flled byJoint OSD Punjaband HaryanaHigh Court with the followingdetails of the vacanciesduringthe aforesaidperiodas underl Srl Vacanciesbecameavailable Numberofvacancies 1 On account of promotionof HCS B 35 Offlcers9 erl 4 Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 85 c9 1 b CWP N03584 OF 2008etce 17 Y SrNO Vacanciesbecameavailable Numberofvacancies 1 2 Dueto ofHCS B9Offlcers 10 3 Dueto deathofHCS JBIofflcers 01 I l 4 Dueto retirement 01 It hascome on record in the affldavitofGovemmentofHaryana filed 1 l in CWP No 1197 of 2009 that all the 54 Vacancies notifled vide 11 0 advertisementissued in the year 2007havebeen filled up in two phases ie 0 1322008 and 1432008 in thefollowing mannerl 4 Category Vacancy Actual vacancies Posts Olled Posts fllled Total shownin the that were availableupin thefirst up in the advertiseme on reconciliationphase e second phase nts with the datamade 132008 ie 1432008 1 Z available by the Honble HighCourt 1 L 1 29 3 41 5 6 General 28 29 23 17 40 1 0 Z Scheduled 13 11 5 5 Castes 00 Backward 6 9 3 6 9 Classes 3 Z Exe 3 2 servicemen i 1 ll Physically4 3 d persons Total 54 54 31 23 54 1 Result of 2007 advertisement was declaredon 132008 whereasthe result of selection for which advertisementwas issued on 142008 was declared on 1 72009 and the select list notified on 68009 The entire argumentof the petitioner 1S based upon judgmentof 6W Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 86 7 4 CWP N03584 OF 2008etce 18 4 Malik Mazhar SuItan supral While the eligibilityof the 1 to Judicial servicein the Stateof UP Honble Court issuedcertain general directionsto all the StateGovemments UTs andthe I 4 HighCourts These directi are containedlll 23 of the whichreadsas underl 231t is absolutelynecessaryto evolve a mechanismto speedily 1 determineand Oll vacanciesof Judges at all levels For this purpose 1 1 0 timelystepsare required to betakenfor detenninationof vacanciesissue 0 of advertisement examinationsinterviewsdeclarationof the 0 final resultsandissueof ordersof For all theseand other stepsif any it is necessaryto provide for fixed time scheduleso that systemworks and there 1S no delaylll fillingup of 1 Z r tA vacancleS The datesfor takingthese stepsCall be providedfor on 1 1 the patternsimilar fllling of L to vacancies in some other servlces or flllingof seats for admissionin medicalcolleges tl L Z The schedule to the medical C CO admissionssets out a time schedule for every stepto be 4 a strictlyadheredto every year The can be provided Z for where sufficientnumber of vacanciesdo not 1 occur m a v givenyear The adherenceto stricttime schedule can ensure timelyflllingof vacancleSe All State Governments Union Territories andlor HighCourts are directedto provide for time 1 schedule for the aforesaid purposes SO that every year vacancies that may occur are timelyfilled All State Govemments Union Territories and HighCourts are directed 1 to flle within threemonthsdetailsof the time scheduleso flxed and date from which time schedule SO flxed would be 6 Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document P 87 J 4 CWP N003584OF 2008etc 19 99 1 In response to the directionscontainedherelmabove someof the State Courtsmade Takingnote of such theHonble Supreme Court in Malik Mazhar Sultane2 1 1 supral issued VMlOUS directions by fixing time schedule for P V holdingthe examinationsetc at differentlevels lIl the of subordinatejudicial e respectof the High service lll Il 1 CourtJTs For the purpose of the presentwrlt petitiondirectionsln L respectof to the post of civil Judge0JrDivisiol only 0 Cm relevant Such directions containedin 14 and 15 which are as hereunder 1 14The selectlist prepared for all categories of officials 1 Z shallbevalid till thenext selectlist is published 6 m 4 15 We er direct that ten percent of unforeseen vacancies would be lll respectof sanctionedpostsand oj ClO not vacancies in a particular year 7 APartfrom above petitioners Z have alsoreferredto vanous Llm other to supporttheir contentionthat the merit list prepared by the SelectionCommitteeSUrVlves till thenext selectionand the candidates next in the merit are required to be appointed 8om the select list In the case of GujaratState DyeExecutiveEngineersAssociation 44ewO 1 veState of Gujarat199431SCT theHonble Supreme Court posedthree questlonse what is waitingliste n it be treated as a source of recruitment from which candidatesmay be drawn as and when necessary 1 and 6iihowlongcan it operate the flrst questionHonble Supreme Court observedas 91 1 Anita 2014.04.12 11: 14 True Scanned Copy Of The Original PHHC,Chandigarh Sahil Soni 2016.03.21 12:26 I attest to