^ . \.o o {^) IN THE HIGH GOURT OF CHHATTISGARH. AT -BILASPUR WRIT APPEAL N0. OF 2009 ARISINGOUT OF ORDER, DT. 19/2/2009 PASSEDIN W. P. (Sl N0. 1027 OF 2009 APPELLANT (Petitioner) •^Ku. Gayatri Sharma, Aged - 47 years, D/o Shri Gaind Lal Sharma, R/o Behind Satsangh Bhawan, Mathpara, Raipur, District - Raipur (C. G.) VER SU S RESPONDENTS Vs c^/'yy^ ^ 1. State of Chhattisgarh, Through - The Secretary, Department of Higher Education Mantralaya D. K. S. Bhawan, Raipur. 2. , The Chancellor, ^ ^ -. . . Through - The Secretary, Rajbhawan, Chhattisgarh, Raipur. • ./ 3. The Coininissioner, Higher Education Department, Science College Campus, Raipur Chhattisgarh. 4. The Registrar, Pandit Ravishankar Shukla ~^ University, Amanaka, Raipur 5. Nand Kumar Rathore, R/o Village - Nandairkala, Via - Shakti, District - Janjgir Champa, (C. G.) Writ Appeal Under Section - 2fl1.otthe Chhattisaarh Hiah Court fAppeal to Dwision Berifih) Act. 2006 'ys^^ mGHCOURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR DMsion Bcnch: Hon'Mc Shri LM. Ouddusi. Iltan'MeShrlPrasdiant KuinaFMishra. Writ Aupcal Na. 64rt)9 ApBCUant Petitioner : Ku. Gayatri Sharma Vcrsus Rcspondcnts : StateofC.G.&Ors. Shri R.K. Kcsharwani, counscl for thc appcllant. Miss. Itecpali Pandcy, Paocl lawycr for State/respandeats No. 1 to 3. Shri Viaay Pandcy, counscl for fhc rcspondcnt no.4. tfac WritAppeal under Sectimi 2 (1) offlie Oihattisgarh ffi^i Court (Appeal to Dtvision Bench) Act, 2006 ORALORDER (31.03.2010) This Writ Appcal has Ixaai filral against Ac impugncd ordCT passcd by lcamixi Singlc Judgc in Writ Pctition (^ No.l027A)9 datcd. 19A)2/09 dismissing tfae Writ Pctitioor chaUcngmg tihc lcgality and vaUdity of thc order dated 1A)1A)5 passcd by intimating thc pctitica'icr that tfac^ Chanccllor oftfac Pt. RavishaDkar Shukla Univcrsity, Raipur undcr TscctiQQ 12 (4) of thc C.G. Vishwa Vidyala^ J -'2-- •'j -:j ;:i. ;;) Adhiniyam, 1973 canccUcd tfic appointmcnt oftfac pctitioncr on tfac post of Rcadcr (Comi»iativc Rcligion and Ptulosophy). (2) In bricf, the facts of ftu; easc arc that an advcrtisemcnt was laadc by tfac R<%istrar of thc Pt. Ravishairiiar Shuklaf UmvCTsity, Raipur C.G. on 24A)9/2W2 inviting appli ti<Mis^ for thc appointmcnt of ^wious posts uicluAng thc post in qucstion. Thc qualifications according to UGC nonns wcre asimdcr: ^ - "Reoder - Good acadenac record WMs a <foc(or<rf degree w eqmvfilent pubB^ed work Jn <iddBtion to these aindtdfttes whojmn from outside the umveras^ systan, slutQ, alsopossess ettleasst 55% oftiw marksw mi eqmvaleirt grade «fBfn the 7 poiMscale wUh letterw degree 0,A,B,C,D,E S F at ^e Mastwss degreefeveL Fvve years of oyerwnce of teacSang <ntf ^ W, resewch exclit^i^dtepeiiod lyentfor obtammg^e research Segrees and has made same nuvk «»sffw Weas of scholwrshy as endenced iy quaGtyv^ pubKcadotis, contri&trtton to e^wattonal innoiWum^ designofnew coursesand curricHla". (3) Thc writ appcllant who was holding Ac post of Jumor Accoimtaot (Kaoist l^^fsX) in fhc COTporatioa iiamcly Vaa Vikas Nigam appli(d for fhc said post showiag thc cxpcricnec ccrtifieatc oftcachmg datcd 25/07/1991 issued by Principal Smt. Pramila Gokid Lal, Daga Kanya Mahavidyalaya,* Raipur C.G. in which it was c<atificxl tfiat fec pctiticmcr has tau^rt in that institutian m tfae SGSSKW 1990-1991 to B.A. -1, H aod Hlycar studats. 5- (4) FurtlKr, vidc csp(aicQce ecrtificatc dated 30A)6/1992 thc Principal Smt. Pramila Gokul I^s Etega, Girls CoHcgc; Raipur had ccrtificd that tfac pctitioncr was -working as Assistant Profcssor in Philosophy sin.cc last two ycars in that institution and was tcaching foundation coursc in addition to Philosophy. (5) Thc tihird cCTtifieatc obtaincd by dic writ appcllant was datcd 7/11/2002 issucd by tfic Sccrctery of thc Rashtriya Vidyalaya Samiti, Raipur by whiehit was ccrtificd that'the pctitionCT had bccn woiking rqgularly sincc July 1990 €11 date as Assistant Profcssor Philosophy in thc mstitution raa 1y the socicty jnamdy Smt. Pramila Gokul Das Daga^i^nya Mahavidyalaya, Raipur. (6) Thus, fhcsc fhrcc ccrtificatcs show that fhc samc wcrc issucd from fhc onc and samc institution, onc is ccrtifymg tcaohing in tiic ycar 1991, thc otfacr onc for thc last two ycare issucd iri fhc ycar 1992 and fhc third onc issucd m fhc ycar 2002 sincc 1990 till date. Sccondly, an cnquiry was conduetcd and thc pctitioncr subinittcd hcr cxplanation to thc Ctonmussion(a,HighcrEducatiQii,Chhatttsgaifa. * » (7) Any how, fhc ChanccUor canccUwl thc appomtmcnt of thc pctitioDcr which was madc conscqutait upon Fcconamcndation of thc Exccutive Council of (hc Umversity dated 20& Septanber, 2003, vide (M-der dated 24/11^0 commumcatcd on 1/01/2005 by thc R%islrar of thc Univcrsity. i^.. '^»'^ ''"ae-SEE'""' -if-- (8) Lcamcd Singlc Judgc aftcr coDsidcring thc plradings ofpartics, upheld fhc impugncd ordcr {»sscdby Kuladhii®ti coEQmuaicatcd by fhc Rcgistrar. (9) It is not in dispute tfaat, undcr scction 12 of tlic C.G. Vishwa Vidyalaya Adhimyam, 1973, tfac ChanccUer (Kuladhipati) has powors to canccl thc appointmcnt order disapproving thc proposal of thc Exccutivc Council of thc UnivCTsity ifhc is satisficd fhat such dccision or procccdings 1 arcprcjudicialtolhcintcrcstoffhcUmvCTsity. " (10) In thc instant casc, it is apparent that thc wdt appcllant who was full timc cmploycc postcd as Kanist Lddiapal in thc SCTviccs of tfac Chhattisgaifa Rajya Van Vilsas Nigam produecd such ccrtificatcs and thc Ayukt Highcr Education, ChhattisgaA CQtMluctod an cnquiry, show causc was issucd, to wfaich fhc rcply was suhmittcd by fhc writ appdlaat, a copy of which has bcai filcd as Aimcxurc P-13 to tfac Writ Pctitian. (11) Considcring fhc facts and cireumstanccs of tfac casc, wc do not find ahy illcgality or impropricty in thc impugied oiTdcr passcd by thc lcamcd Singlc Judgc. (12) Thc writ appcal fails and is dismisscd. Sd/- ' I.M.Quddusi Judge Sd/- prashantKumar.Mistea Judge 111 ! ^-