G^^> c^ IN THE HIGH COURT QF JUDICATURE Op CHH&TTIS^ARji AT BILASPUR. W.P.N0.2-'^-'2--?72003 /' SSm-LOSER ^ ^^" .^^^r ».^^?>" t^^v~.^ ^l^"" yf RBSpONDfNT5 ar. Y.N. Jha age 52 years s/o Late Kedarnath irha» Assistteit Proffesar- zoologly oovt. ftrts & oonmerce college ffarhabhatha Silaspur (e.G.) VERSUS (1) scace o£ chhattisgarh Through- secretary Dqsartment of Higher Bducaticn D«K»S» Bhavan Raipur (c.G.) (2) ^ecial Exscutive Officer Goramissioner Offiee Higher sducation of c.G. Rai-pur (c.G.) y , ;;i'y»SIT PETITIQN__UNDffi_ARTICLA 226/227 O? THE CONSTITyTION_OF INDIA SOR ISSUEWCE OF WRIT IN THE NATURE OP QUO-WARANTO, GERTIORARY & MANDAMUS s l:l!ri|!|jt1: w •trf w XI-HC-22 !j dli^f^t IRi'ii'* NJ&B a>*ffl°ti 'M ^t '3^|'<ti'liiw<i,;wn)wis,Risitt<y OT^ ^ ':,'y.;,'.:,:-':,'.'^.:fN ':2-2-^ fl»t|RU:ai'Blch <lay 206 lc|'b<llT '6-1 th^ Shri y.C. Sharma, counsel Wiss Shsrmila Sin9hai, &y. t-lear'ci both the counsel. By this petition under Arfl India, ihe' petitioher aeeks -te cV\ not consiaerjng his name toi- Profflotion fiomn'"ttee on The preyious promotion order is p| Tribuna!. . The sase bf ths petitio Professor in l&overnment Ansar '-te'was appoinlBd as Assistant| obtdined Ph.b. in tne vear 1978; Assistant Professws namely Orl junior to the'pe+ittpner: Gr. R.ft. wds at S.No.110 and bottt' of • 1 petiT!Oner,,was nbf'pr-omol'ed: e| Assistant ProfessofS. On bein9 i| record was dlso pr'ovided!;by The.| ^rtqtd^il-l tii*idT Tt T^'t<? <Fait$iiL ^siPOTsn^ar -or the petitioner. ©ovt.AdyQcate, fcr ths State. . 1-icies 226 and 227 of the ConsTitution ofi atleh9C the action of therespondents fori promotion in me proposed Departmental |round that his petition challen9in9 his[ pnding befor® the |State Administrative; lier'is that .he is working as Assistanti ^d Qommerce. College, Jarhabhttta, Biiaspiur'^ IPr&fessor iri +he year 1977'Qnd he ha^: State of AAadhya Rradesh pr'omoted tWK^ I.R.R. Konhdre and Gr. B.L. Soel^who wer^ Konhare was at SI.No: 66 and br. B.L.fioel lierit were junior to{ fhe petitioner; Tfiei; l' : • ..•.•'.' '. •.. ' \'-'-'\ ['en1 ftsugh he was jsenior! to these :tw<< (ske^ by the responcfeiit No.2j thei relevirfi'tj! Ipeti-tioner t6 him. T1iepetiti6nerihad uitej ] ^s^ •stse-SK i;i:[ili lai^^t Ri-11* 3I§ECT ^RI^^fl '35|i'<tt'lttePli,|:%sS<;l*is»^fctlatti^ 3ir§|lti(3% kt>i^i^a T.-3-i *U«(«'!t«t*W»i iUBt>^ 200 1«N><^T made a representation for same was r'ejected on 08-09-2! Learned counsel for the pe^ not considering the ca.se. of the of pendency of hls'Original Appl Tribunal. He fur+her submitted he iS not in a positiori to seek any that his Original Application ped Tribunal mav be tredted as withdl the resDondents to lconsider his i cbnsii|ering his name fpr bromotion, but thie Promotion Commit+eejconsiderthe Hdving hedrd learned couns reasonafaie. It is, tHerefore, dire AdminiStrative Tribijndl, 'the On .! dismissed as withdriiwn. It ia •ibWl<'t4!'t *tl*te(( ^ i6'<3 th<(K ^<?tF:ct*t<tt^ pett'itioner submit+ed that respondents are pejt'itioner ror promotiori onlyon 1+ie ground lcaTion befope the State. AdminisTrative ifiat the Tribunal hois been aboiisheci gnd jirder from there. He further submitted Iding before tHe State Administrative iawn and further a direction be qiven to (epresentatiqn before the Departmental tted tho-r .since fne 5tate Administratiye Tribunal stonds ;abo !|shed ond in -tjie given situotion tr»pstitionsr' h irriself is seeking to wi'thdraw the Or"igjn|il Apptication pehding hefare the Stttte makes d representatijon within a;p^rjod;of 10 days from today, befflre the -^L^ |osesfor promotion. . :' ^i for the parties and having considered || the facfs and circumstonces 6f the case, I iam ef the opinion that •tfte l' submissions macle by lear'ned coijnsei for" the peti+ioner' are fair and j gins!' Application may i be Trecrted las .j 3 . • ..• • : ; ; |jr-riier directed that if the peti-t-ioner I XI-HC-22 1 SII^^I 1^'tich<Hi^^r sbtiief» •«fsn •e&^ '\-1,-<^ y 'g^ •<11<11<'1<1, i9Ti)<1<l<o, (q<11«y SIT^T •qsrq? , Vj^ f. yoo.-£3..-^3)-]1T-ffl&3 "(Fl. 2U) WICTI %*I[tB ^S^fS' oii^i TCIIW ^rfte • -...£ , -3 reaponcient . No,2, he shall con; manner before the ;Departmental for promotion. With this observation, the Partles are entitled for the fje+itions stands disposed of. |»rtifiedcopy of 1+ie order*. cnt<<(CT^t Mwv^^ (ssft <p>t'^.i< ^ ^tFcl1! ott^t der his repr'e.sentation in an 6 ^Promotion CommiTTee consider the cases Sd/- L.C.BHADOO Jiidge'