J U‘E Civi Tax, CM Tax, . WWW mm Wmm 2,. mmir'wm %aifauam%w Vm‘sus .Assietant Commissioner of Income Tax, Raipur. §esgm¢deni Sunder Nagar, Mahadeo Ghat Road, Raipur (Chhattisgarh) 22i@,2@§g Shri Bhishma Kinger, lea bo‘ch the petitions. $l1ri Sanjay K._Agravxfai, le Heard. Writ Petitions No. 1454/2906 and 904/2005 are being éiisposed of by thie common order as in goth the petitione a common question involved for adjudication is—vlihether the Central Administrative Tribunal expunging adverse remerk in t &e respondent for the year 1 . Commissioner of Shri [inspector of Aayakar Bhawan, Rcad, Bhopal, . Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, Centrai Revenue Buiiding, Civil Linee, Raipur (Chnattisgarh) Income Tax, Central Revenue Buiiding, Civii Lines, Raipur, Chhattisgarh. Hoshangabad . ‘Addi. Commissioner of Income Tax, {ange-H, Central Revenue Building; Civil Lines, Raipur, Chnattisgarh. Kumar Sharma, Income Tax, 265, Virendra lrned counsel for the petitioners in arned counsel for the respondent.’ l ’ is in: gmn tie/95‘} i i noose! .mwoa. L Bench—Bilaspur) lF97uss and mes-99? was justified in e Annuel Confidential Report {ACR) mggw .Z.m.200 7 (i WW(W) at Eabalpur (Circuit m mm 7 “A 200 mm (Wu) mmm WW§1®€TW $§mm §eamed courage! apgearing for the Shri $ai’zjay K. Agrawai, tha order of Centrai Administrative respondem submits that after V Tribunal, the respondent was. promoted on the post of Inoome-Tax 0.11.2004 (Annexure R—4 in WP 2 in WP No.904/2G0é), arm he has already rétired from services 0n 31.102006 from the poet of circumstancee, the instant petrtions . Xhteme-Tax Officerv in these have become infructuous. Shri Kinger, learned counse! for the petitiOhers, does not dispute the above facts, However, he praye for deciding the petitions on merits. faking itto considerat’i n that the respondent has aire’ady retired from services way back on 31102006 and further ed promotion on 8.11.2004 by the ng survives in these petitions for woived in these petitione regarding in the ACR of the respondent by’the‘ ‘Officer ‘vid& orde? No‘1454/2006 & Annexura R- meaningleee in the changed eccoro‘ingiy, diemiesed as hevit Sd/- Dhirendra Mishra Judge eonsidering that he was gran petitioners department, no adjudication. The question i expunging of'adverse temarig circumetences. The petitione are, - & ig become infructoouw i R N. Chandrakar Judge ‘ so- j petitioners for the year 19‘3‘7-e8 & 1998—99,> is irreievant and