IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC NO.12160 OF 1999 S.M.ZAREEF COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, DARBHANGA, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY, MD. AFFAQUE, S/O LATE MD. USHMANI, R/O MOHALLA MABI, P.S MABBI, DISTRICT DARBHANGA. …………………PETITIONER. VERSUS 1.THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH THE SECRETARY, HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT, SECONDARY, PRIMARY AND ADULT EDUCATION, GOVT. OF BIHAR, PATNA. 2.LALIT NARAYAN MITHILA UNIVERSITY, THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR, KAMESHWAR NAGAR, DARBHANGA. 3.THE VICE CHANCELLOR, LALIT NARAYAN MITHILA UNIVERSITY, KAMESHWAR NAGAR, DARBHANGA. 4.THE REGISTRAR, LALIT NARAYAN MITHILA UNIVERSITY, KAMESHWAR NAGAR, DARBHANGA. 5.THE PRO-VICE CHANCELLOR, LALIT NARAYAN MITHILA UNIVERSITY, KAMESHWAR NAGAR, DARBHANGA. 6.THE EXAMINATION CONTROLLER, LALIT NARAYAN MITHILA UNIVERSITY, KAMESHWAR NAGAR, DARBHANGA. 7.THE CHAIRPERSON, NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER’S EDUCATION (N.C.T.E.) SAFDARJUNG DEVELOPMENT AREA, SRI ARBINDO MARG, NEW DELHI 110016. 8. NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER’S EDUCATION (N.C.T.E.) SAFDARJUNG DEVELOPMENT AREA, SRI ARBINDO MARG, NEW DELHI 110016. 9.THE APPEAL COMMITTEE, NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER’S EDUCATION (N.C.T.E.) SAFDARJUNG DEVELOPMENT AREA, SRI ARBINDO MARG, NEW DELHI 110016. 10.THE EASTERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE, (N.C.T.E.) 15, NILKANTH NAGAR NAYAPALLI, BHUBNESHWAR. 751012, THROUGH THE CHAIR PERSON. 11.THE MEMBER SECRETARY, NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER’S EDUCATION (N.C.T.E.) SAFDARJUNG DEVELOPMENT AREA, SRI ARBINDO MARG, NEW DELHI 110016. 12.THE CHAIR PERSON, EASTERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE (N.C.T.E.) 15, NILKANTH NAGAR NAYAPALLI, BHUBNESHWAR, 751012 2 13.THE REGIONAL DIRECTOR, EASTERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE (N.C.T.E.) 15, NILKANTH NAGAR NAYAPALLI, BHUBNESHWAR, 751012. ………………………RESPONDENTS. WITH CWJC NO.2299 OF 2000 1.NASIBLAL SINGH S/O SRI RAM LAL SINGH, R/O VILLAGE KESHERWA, PS.LADANIA, DISTRICT MADHUBANI. 2.GANGA PRASAD MAHTO, S/O SRI MANOHAR MAHTO, R/O VILLAGE BAGHMARIA, P.S. LAUKHA, DISTRICT MADHUBANI. …………………PETITIONERS. VERSUS 1.THE STATE OF BIHAR 2.CHANCELLOR OF THE UNIVERSITIES, RAJ BHAWAN, BIHAR, PATNA. 3.VICE CHANCELLOR, LALIT NARAYAN MITHILA UNIVERSITY, KAMESHWAR NAGAR, DARBHANGA. 4.REGISTRAR, LALIT NARAYAN MITHILA UNIVERSITY, KAMESHWAR NAGAR, DARBHANGA. 5.CONTROLLER OF EXAMINATION, LALIT NARAYAN MITHILA UNIVERSITY, KAMESHWAR NAGAR, DARBHANGA. ………………………RESPONDENTS. WITH CWJC NO.2445 OF 2000 1.SHAKIL AHMAD, SHAKIL AHMAD S/O ALAM MANNA, R/O MOHALLA RAHAMGANJ, P.O. DARBHANGA, DISTRICT DARBHANGA. 2.MD. SUFFARE ALAM @ MD. SHAFE ALAM, S/O MD. NINIUDDIN ANSARI, R/O MOHALLA SARAISATAR KHAN,P.O. LAHERIASARAI, DISTRICT DARBHANGA. 3.MD. FIRDOSH ALI, S/O MD. NURUL HODA, R/O MOHALLA MEHEDOLI, P.O SHUMBHKARPUR, DISTRICT DARBHANGA. 4.MD. JAMSHED ASHGAR, S/O LATE MD.SHAJID, R/O MOHALLA KARAMGANJ, P.O LAHERIASARAI, DISTRICT DARBHANGA. 5.MUMTAZ ALI KHAN, S/O LATE GAFFUR HASSAN KHAN, R/O MOHALLA PURANI MUNSHIFI, P.O. LALWAHA,P.S LAHERIASARAI, DISTRICT DARBHANGA. 6.KOKIB ARA @ KOKAB ARA OF KHUAJA MOINUDDIN NEKASH, R/O VILLAGE BRAHMPURA, P.O. POHADDI BELA VIA GHANSHYAMPUR, DISTRICT DARBHANGA. 7.MD. IMRAN ALAM S/O MD. ALI HASSAN R/O VILLAGE MAHRAJGANJ, P.O. LAHERIASARAI, DISTRICT DARBHANGA. 3 8.IBRANA PRAVEEN, D/O LATE SYED KHURSHID ALAM, R/O VILLAGE/MOHALLA KHELAPHAT BAGH MEHESHOL CHOWK, DISTRICT SITAMARHI. 9.ISHAKH BANO @ ISHRAT BANO, W/O M.A. ABBASH, R/O MOHALLA SHAHGANJ GULSHAN COLONY, P.O.MAHENDRU, DISTRICT PATNA 6. 10.ASHARFUL HODA JAVED S/O SYED ANWARUL HODA, R/O MOHALLA IMAMWARI, P.O. LAHERIASARAI, DISTRICT DARBHANGA. 11.MD. NIZMUDDIN @ MD. NASMUDDIN, S/O NASHIRUDDIN, R/O MOHALLA NANPUR, P.O. & P.S. NANPUR, DISTRICT SITAMARHI. 12.FAJAIL AHMAD, S/O BADRUB DUJA, R/O VILLAGE BELBHADRAPUR, P.S. LAHERIASARAI, DARBHANGA. …………………PETITIONERS. VERSUS 1.THE STATE OF BIHAR. 2.CHANCELLOROF THE UNIVERSITIES, RAJ BHAWAN, BIHAR, PATNA. 3.SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN RESOURCES(SECONDARY EDUCATION)GOVT. OF BIHAR, PATNA. 4.LALIT NARAYAN MITHILA UNIVERSITY, THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR, KAMESHWAR NAGAR, DARBHANGA. 5.THE REGISTRAR, LALIT NARAYAN MITHILA UNIVERSITY, KAMESHWAR NAGAR, DARBHANGA. 6. CONTROLLER OF EXAMINATION, LALIT NARAYAN MITHILA UNIVERSITY, KAMESHWAR NAGAR, DARBHANGA. 7.THE REGIONAL DIRECTOR, EASTERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE, NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHERS EDUCATION, 15, NILKANTH NAGAR NAYAPALLII, BHUBNESHWAR. ………………………RESPONDENTS. ----------- 20/ 27.07.2011 Heard counsel for the parties. It is an admitted position that the recognition of the College in question i.e., S.M Zareef College of Education, Darbhanga had been cancelled and that the writ petitions challenging such order of 4 cancellation of recognition have also been dismissed by the learned Single Judge and also affirmed by the Division Bench. The matter in fact thereafter is said to be pending before the Apex Court. In that view of the matter, this Court keeping in view the order dated 10.05.2011, would dispose of all these three cases by giving opportunity to the petitioners to approach this Court again if need be for any relief, in case the matter pending in the Apex Court is decided in favour of the College by restoring recognition. With the aforementioned observations and liberty, this application is disposed of. Ranjan (Mihir Kumar Jha, J.)