r‘ir‘‘ HI§H €OURT OF CHHATTIS6ARH AT BILA5PUR hm Misc.Appeal NoJ66 of 2005 ' CORAM‘. Hcn’He Shri SR. Nnyuk, CJ 6: Hon’ble Shri Dilip Raosaheb Deshmukh, J" @pellanfs Cigimanfs . ‘1. Mangali Em, aged 28 years, D/o Lafe Pumu @ Punavmali (Mamr) ~2. Ishwar, aged abou'r 15 years/ S/o' La‘re Punau C‘? Punavmali (Mamr) Dukalu, aged abauT 13 years, 5/0 Lcrl'e Punau @ Pumvmah‘ (Marar) 4. Karma, aged 60 ear's, 5/0 Himmm Mali {Marar)' ’ 5. Karfikmafi, aged 58 years, W/o Karma No.2 :31 3 are minors, Thrbugh: Na'ruml Guardian Mofher-Mangaif Bai. A“ R/p Village Pachpedi, P.S. Sar‘seeva, Tah. Bikxjgarh, Dist Raiput? (C6) Versus espondenfs DREVER (3WNER INSURER Safpai, R/o Rqmkrishan Jaf, R/o Jasiya, P’S. Jusiya! Dist Roh'rak (Hariyancx) 2. Rnmbhngo‘r, Sio Sunvniiya, R/o Bhawnia House No 1050 Disf Jhajar' (Hariyana) 3. Unwed India Inumnce Co L'fd Disfr'ucf Roh‘mk Harlyana Shri Gnumm Khefmpal;€ounsel for the appellam's’ 5km Rayndm Trlpafhl Advoca’fe asalsfmg Shm Pmshcnf Mishm Sr Counsd for responden? No 3 A} \\ ‘ ORAL ORDER (Passed on m‘rh‘ January 2006) a Tgwe fcHowing om! order- of fhe CourT was passed by 5.R.NA\/AK, CJ. y R hL/ 1‘ In fhis appeql preferred by the dzpendenfs of The deceased seeking more compensaficn, The only confen‘fionur'ged by fhe learned ceunse! fer- fhe appeilanfs is ma? +he Mo'mr Accidenfs Claims Tribunal (MACE) is moi“ jusiified in no? awarding any compensa‘iion Tnwards less of es'iai'e and Thai whm‘ is awarded iowards loss of consor‘iium is an lower side. No efher poini’ was urged. As we repealedly held and reifemied, 'il'ie M.A.C.T. is required +0 award reasonable compensaiion under convenfional heads, which compensaiion should refleci’ Time and place and curren'i money value and such compensaiion cannof be s'ia'ric far all i‘ime. In Thai view of The ma‘H’er, we award a sum of R£.25,000/n rewards loss af consoriium and ano’rher sum of Rs.25,000/- fowards loss of esia‘re. 2. The impugned award shall S'l'and modified accardingly. In all aTher respeci’s, i’he impugned award shall s‘rand unaliered. The MANGJ$6 of 2005 is disposed of in the above ferms. No cosfs. w? “ii! ’d" l Sd/n Sdl- i Chief Justice ‘ DILIP RAOSAHEB DESHMUKH Judge