;Q-HC—78 •a:n^[w R'-ti.'* ^S!T 3n^?r sb*iicti •^-^^ ^^•:it^-& .;--"-'4r->;:.s-^iN 3^T ^WW^, W^\WIG, Rf^wy. ..i^{.:.^o:lli/OL. •n an^W THW (ipf^qir) wnwdf^i sn^i l.:rit!inal Aopeal n|o, ?8/2UU1 Kabu|al Kaliu, K/o. yfln Kam yanu, agecl P»0 Vf^T^ >4n.ra, lan. aHd^i+i uagb^ STate Bagb^ (C.G.J •ot ClitiatUsgai-fi, Uu-ougli f.'S. fel~>T'?> T.c?T^c-fl ^ PiKEtt. ^A'^Ti.Q<s..'3Trii^r>r1 Hoa'bte sarx L Hnsi?hl@ K'by^ TTlhiyenfSva Mislifa. •_?•_?- ytin Awadii rnpattu, S&ri Aidiil Mishra, Pa|i Arguinents lieard. Ural juclginent tlictat^cl on Uws. |Advocate, lor Uie appeuaat. jiiel Lawirer, tor tlie respondent/ State. itnd 'l'fiis appeal is au-ectt aiid order ot sentence di yessioas Juage, Ma&asauiipK leamect Acldl. yessions Ji guUty' lor comnussion ot fenal Cocte, tor coininitttptg sentencecl liim to iraaergo Ks. 1UUU/ -, aivl ui aelault one year's iiapnsonDieut. qiT^fo<Ili *ii*<ci¥^fss^ <T^t$i< "^-3ffRlH 3H^T 30 v-ar!-. R/n. VillaffR Rali-ma. P.R. / -^^'-*-?5 ^-••l-*-^a-u~-.^>.5 A > t^. . a; Uistt, Maliasaiauiid. •d agaiast tlie juclgineut ol conyiction fted 15-11-2000 passed bv 211d Addl. m S.'l'. No. 143/2000, w&ereby fhe |idge atter &oiam.g accusea/ appeUant uncler yecuon. '3'o'2 ol Uie IncliEm. inurcler ot Uis wrte yasauti fciai. |unpnsonment tor me, to pay a tuie ol |ot payment ol tuie, to liu-tlier unclergo olltence Xi-HC—78 3=5ST •^WIv^-i-l, •S-^V'IG, Rlcrtl'My c^ A > ^° - °^/& f 'fSKK ( 3Tf^?I ?H Ri-ii* •^SH- 3^?T Sft+ltqi '^WR'nfer sii^r ^>l<)I<1<4ll tilWtf ^^^ <[<1-^1< ^Tsifim sii^i prosecup.on ailnt letes, Ilie case ot Uie atsout 12.3U noon, Vaiclyanatli StaUon Bagbalira to Uie eaect] ancl iQtoiiuea. lum Uiat tus diefl. Un Ulis faiic&as wei-e tiasan.tt Bai was lyuig on tt(( Kaaial etc. were present Uier^. below Uie iinee ot'&otii uie aittl necK also. Atter receivuigl tor Tlie scene ot occunTence, preparect uiquest vicle Kx. t^-4 Basanti Bai was sent tor ComTnunift' Healtti (Jentre, B.P. MalaiiifP.w. l7'! conducf cause ot aeatti ot tSasann Bai aacl uirottluig. 'i'iie cleatfa is &<( f-1'2. ^etticoat, San ancl Blousf siides ot vaguial swab were were also setzect anu same v.Te| r'orensic ticience Latioratorv,! received. As per report, spots petticoat ana san ot tlie accusea as weu as on me Atter coinpietion ol uivestigat|ion Uourt ot Cliiet Juclicial •up.on, nl Dnet, is ttiat on 4-1-2UUU at lodgea report ux. f-i ui ^ouce Uiat at about K a.m.., Yadrain. cauie Basaatt tiai aged. '2^> years lias s4iainoned, Uiey saw mat ttie boay ot grouud. Kujuram, Tulsiraiii aiid j. 'I'liey saw Uiat Uiere were uijiuies t&ere were uijunes on me lcuee tlie report, InvesUgattag UttiGer lett ptter givuig nouce to me ^aaclias, |on Uie boctv ol Basaau Bai. Boctv ot Ipost ruortein exaiunianoa to Uie ibatira under t:x. f-l'd wtiere L)r. fed post niortein aacl opuiecl mat ttie ^vas aiispto'xia d.ue to straiigulation ^nuciclal ua nature. His report is Kx. ot Basaati Bai were seized anct two L. Uncterroear ancl Liuigl ot accusect Te|re sent tor cJieinical exam.m.aUon to Kaipur, Irom. wliere report was |3t JiuDian seinen were touitd. on Uie BasauU aad unclenTear ot Uie ot vaguial swaD ot uie cleceasecl. i, cJiarge sneet was tilecl ui ttie MaJ.iasaiaiuT.cl, wtio ui tum Bb ta n clecefcseci siides •——-.——^1_. XI-HC-; ^ssi "4i4ii(>'><i, g)TTl<-i'i<s, Ki<y>i'yy c^^ N&.S^H. an^?T 'w: ('yifysys) 31I^[ ?il h-UV 'W SfKS Sbliqi '^dTWBfer sii^r ctii^iyrat'1 HitKiT ^fe^ <f<i^i< '^'^tRpTsn^T coinniittect me case to Uie leam.ed Aclctfflonal Kessions Jil tnal. i'lie prosecuUon ui orcle^ acQusea, exaiiuned l/' wipif recorctea uncler yection 313 inatenal appeaniig against n1^1 nas been talsely im.plicatecl in Uave deposecl agamst liuxi on| I'.b.e leaiTted tnal Court atterl parQes, convictect auct sen|tencecl aioreraennonecl. We liave lieara t-ilui 'l'mlaat&l Shri Akhik Mishra, Paiiel Lsrn^ Htin Awacltl 'I'npatm 114 yasanU Bai. Moreover. Ur. B. t-1 y-l-'2UUU, on tlie request ot Popice autopsy on me Docly ot Basa)iU yesjsions Juclge, Kaipur trom. wtiere tJae .clge receivect me case on traaster tor to estaDUsli tlie cUarge agauist tlie :sses. Htateinent ot accusect was lol Ur.r.t;. m wtucll &e deniecl Uie aacl stated ttiat tie is uinocent, Me |Uie cnme ui quesUon. ancl witaesses account ot laacl ctispute wiUl nua. hearing ftie counsel for respective uie accusecl-appeUaat as sweimig on necls ui size ot 3 *. niidclle and nglit side ot aecK, wnictl were 7 cin ui tengUl aucl| cm. nl wicim anct t> cui ui leug1 sweltm.g oa Uie niiaaie portion Vi c-m. x x/2 cia on nglit sicle ai on t&e jaw, Uiere were luarKs )>at&i on Denall ot ttie appeUant aud ler on beJiatt 01 tne Mtate. ).s not disputect aomiciclal aeaUl ot \ Nlalani [f.W. 1 /) lias statect ttiat 011 Station Bagbaiira, lie conducted Bai ancl noUcecl Uiat tliere was 1; cia area, tace Decaiae blaclasli, ui ttiere were Uiree niarKs ol tnigures 1 cm. m. wiam, B cni ui lengUi an.d 1 tti aaa i y» cm in wiam. 'l'&ere was lot necK. IJiere was a m.arli: ui size ot ptiyroicl cai-uiage, ttiere was aDrasion |ot tungures on t&e lett sicl.e ot necls:, :;C[-He—7i 3=55!- ^S-l\^^^ •STl\W'\<a, [sj01t<y c^^.^^ s%/6^ •?nt?(?si Rii<* 'a»irsn^i s»it<i<* TRiiwofeT SII^T t&ere were m.nuies on Uie Kit ot luigers were on Uie wiacl ]f aiid were tatal to tite. Un aist niarlss ot luigers were seeu ( pi;esent, inuscels and vasse4 Dlood m. Uie wm.cl pipe, causj auspn^7xia on accouiit ol ttif nature. i'ne above raecticai o1 t^.W. 15 MeKll Uulam Kanvar, jud.iciat contession t&at ou aq wite clia not aUow tiun to Jiavj to liave uitercourse torciaiy, tn'o, tie pressect Uie necis ot 1) auct cu'ciuitstaatial eviaeuce,! Basanti tjai was lioiuicidal m. As tar as uivolvem.en1| Diurder ot lus wite tiasaiiti B| ocular eviclence ui Uus cu'cuinstanciai eviaence bass^d i. 1'Uat, TIie accused. P.W. 15 Shekli Gu] B.. 'l'Jiat lalse explaual ui. lliat, relanon tieti| was not corcliai; ^Tq?<'PiftT1 'HR^f ^f^fe^ <Fq^R "^ '»iRi*i^i^il ee. Injiuies No. 1 anct 1 unpi^ssions ape wliicli were aangerous ui nature iecnon ot inidclle part ot necK, wliere )n Uie wuicl plpe, clottea bloocl was s were ruptured, Uiere was clottect ; of death of BasaiiU Bai was due to •otttm.g and cleatli was iioiiiicidal ni iinion is corroborated. Dv eviclence ot Detore wlioni uie accusea inacie extra count ot ctispute witti ILIS wite as Jiis nitercourse witti Jier, w&en tie tnecl Uie aispzite tooK place Dettveen me iis wite. 'Ilierelore, in view ot m.eclical it is estaDlLsliecl Uiat Uie aeatn ot tiature. ot Uie accusecl m. com.DUSSlon ot &i is concemed, ttiere is no clirect or tnatter. 'l'Ue case rests on ttie on loUowuig circum.staiices:- |liacte exn'a juclicial contession betore \ani yarvar; ^ion was given Dy t&e accusect; lireen tlie accused scnsl Uie cteceased X3-HG—7S 3-5^ ^ii^l^, t$Tfly'ifi, Ri^i'yy ^.ft,^ -SSf^ an^r •q'ra; (^{•jsi<i8T) an^tw R-li.°h wn sn^y aiiiqi etil^^'l 'RPTcTf ^'fe1^ <f<q^ •^sifinan^i iv. 'I'&at aead bodv ot ot me accusect and regarauig cause ot a v. lajuneswere touncl 4 ^'. J vi, l-luiuaii seinea wap tt aad vagaial sticles ot| As lar as tu-st cn-cuinstaili contession betore P.W. 1S y&eKj 15 S&ekli Gulam Sarvar has s1 viUage. Un Uie clate ot uicictent nis tiouse ana aisciosed Uiat faet xvitli nis wite torwllicn stie clicl tnecl to liave torciDle uitercours) sonie dispute took place' betivef E>y pressuig Uie necJ<:, lie coi ne stioulcl save liun. Un Uie saj came to village. In cross-exam^ aDle to eiicit an^rtlim.g wtucli clis 'wiUi regarcl to ttie extra jucticie •3etore Uiis witness nor aiivUling cross-examination Uiat t&e e3 voluiitarv. yneKll Uulaia yarvai- an.d is an uictepentlent witnes' miplicate ttie accusea ui a tals yiieKU Uu-lam Karvar witli regari t{asanti Bai was tolina ui t&e tiouse lie nas not onered aity explaaanon :atti ot tiis wiie Basanti Bai; >n me person ot uie accused; and >una on ttie clotlies ot Uie deceasea tlie aeceasea. 'e l.e. accused inade extra juaiciat Uulam Karvar, is concemed, P.W. \SLtecl uial tie was yarpaiicli ot ttie |at about 1U a.ia., yabulal cam.e to wantea to &ave sexual uitercourse p.ot agree, m. t&e circuiiistaiices, lie ^ witli liis wne, 011 account ot tliat, )n ttie two an.cl dunag Uie clispule, [.ttecl murcler ol tus wite. 'l&eretore, apie clay, at aDout 3 - 4 p.m. police nlnaUon, Uie ctetence tias uot Deen 'reclits Uie evidence ot Uus witness ;(! contession inacle bv Uie accused Jias been brouglit on recorcS in tlie 5(;tra judicial coiltession was not |[t-'.w. 15) is yuipancli ot uie viUage 1'liere was no reasoa tor riim to case. 1'lieretore. Uie evictence ot •tl to extra lucliciai conlession inatle B-HG—'; 3=5cT ^]|<(|0A|, ffiTn^'ltS, Isj^iyy G.^.^-^/ff{ an^?r •<ra% (1l?f5«i^i;) '9°, ant^r ^i 1?;ii?T ^SJT'sn^r ^RI^ TOiiw^fesn^r *iif<-i41-f iin^f 'if.fs'et <r»it$]< ^T-sfRTEr 3ff^T Dv accusea betore &im ins] contession was voluntan? concenied, Uie nieclical evidepice Uie accused was exam.uiea W "e^ e^ideuce, as inauy as y sim.pl|e accusect, anct uiost ot tiiem yff. ttiat, Dodv ot Uie aeceased ti; explananoa tias 'Deen oUerep. vmagers uiciuduig r'.w. l accusect was preseut ui ttie aioag witti wtioia me deceas| same clay. raomiag, lias stateqi tne mcicteut Uiat Uie acczisecll aacl give beating to Jier, tie nainely Kaunun tiai, so Uie extra judicial contessioa m.aclf Mo tar as talse explanaqon inedical eviaence ot ur. u.r. account ot pressing ot tlie neq Uie person ot Basantl Uai w&^ 1 BeclnaUi as to liow Uasaiilli was pam ui ttie c&est ot Bas; ner aiict atter swallowrag tabiqi P.W. & Kejuram, wno nas stat| ttiat BasanU &as diecl 011 ac0 pu-es contiaence. 'l'lie extra jucliciai fcact as tar as its trutEltulliess is corroDorates Uie nicitleut Decase P.W. 17 Dr. B.P. Malaui. As per tus injunes were noucecl on Uie bocty ot ;rte in natuie of abi~ation. Apart from. Isaiiti was tound ui t&e Jiouse aitcl no bv ttie accusect. Bven. wlien. tne itieanatll reaclied to ttie fiouse, Uie IGouse, nioreover, f.W. 3 t-'ekaa Bai ;a went to attencl Uie caU ot nature t tnat sJie disclosecl to lier just Detore is ui t&e tiaDit ot quarelimg wim Uer lias relations witii liis sister-ui-Iaw fabove circuiastances corroborate tlie bv Uie accused betore ttus witness. ottered by tlie accusea, as per ttte (/lalani {f.W. 1/j, yasaau Bai aiecl on )Is; as Uiere was nuniber ot uijunes on ^reas Uie accuseU ou enquuy tiy f.W. Bai liad died, explauiea mat ttiere 3|nu Bai, ttieretore, tie gave a tablet to }t, slie ctiecl. yunilar is Uie evicleuce ot t|ed Uiat on euquin', Babulal disclosect lount ot tieart attacK. i-'.w. l Aiiancli ''''T ZJ;)'^' .nj.-riL1;^.— 3-c^r ^!qi(>»ti, »T:|<-|'|<S, Ki^i'y^ ^^^-s^{ 3TI^?T XRRB (Ipf^g^T) 3iI^!I[^f^R; 'iw sw^v sb^i* wnwofeisii^i ct>l<lId<ftTf 'RTO^f ^'fe^ <Rq^l< ^ stRiH 3Tl^5I iias stated Uiat on enquuy paui ctevelo'ped m. me cUest o TaDlet, tiiereatter stie becamE also statecl Uiat tiaDulal on cciDiplam.ecl regarctuig paiii u| given to tier, Uiereatter Uasa uiese explanations onerea b^ tne 'tace to it weie' talse tor P.W. 17 Dr. B.P. Malai-ii, Bass clue to pressuig ot necx. 'l'tien explanation t>y uie accusecl acciisecl was uivolyed in tjie c: As t&e aead. i-iocly was w&en Uie wituesses caitie lionse, nioreover ui ttie previc aeceasecl were ui Uie iieuse, 1 beliayiour ot t&e accusea, req ttie accused to rcinaui m uic Uieir tiouse so Uiat Uie wliicli nas Deen provecl by 'r'.\ on Uie request ot daugllter-i liQuse ot Uie accused along t iiiomuig, sne lett, t&ereatter siistauied niiunect ancl siie cli' Uie accused ancl tlie acciisg tilie 3n tierttore accus$d uie accusea disclosed tliat as soine t Basanti Bai, t&eretore slie tooK one 'Luicouscious. r.w. s 'i'ulsu'aai tias enquuT clisclosed Uiat BasajiU Bai Uie ctiest, ttieretore, one tablet was nti Bai went for sieep aiid died. Au. tlie accusecl to Uiese witnesses on reason Uiat as per Uie evidence ot uiti tiai cliect on account ot ausptorxia :, uie circumstaiice ot givuig talse to Uie witnesses uiclicates ttiat t&e iuie. touiicl ui Uie tiouse ot t&e accused ttie accusecl was preseut ui ttie 'us nig&t, wtien me accusecl aaa me lie aeceased Deuig tngMenuig Oy Uie ^.estecl r.W. 14 AasinuK&i, nioUier ot liouse ni Uie aigGt aud to sleep ui is not able to tiarass ttie aeceasecl, ^. 14 Aasinulslu, wfio Qas statecl Uiat i-law, stie slept ID. Uie lugiit m. tlie ntti Basann Bai on a cot aacl in ttie wittun a sfioit tmie, tlie aeceasecl ;cl, Uiere were ui]iines on t&e body ot ;d Uas not olterea any explaaanon ajicl X[-HG—78 3n^T?ff1?;]R7 ^STi SfH^T sh*ll<^ 3"5sr "tiMi^, ®Ti1yid,Ri^iyy ^.e.^.^/61 an^?l IBR? (ipfgg^ff) ?(<IRR'HfCT ffl^I regarcluig Uie uyunes ST(I presence ot Uie accused }s exiilauiea as to liow provisioiis ot Kection l(-jfc> cu-cum.staD.ee beuig wrtn|in ttie accusea was liabie tiasantl Bai was inet wi] cu-cuinstartce agauist ttie| As tar as conctuc] KamaU-ai &as statect mat| earlier two wives ot Uie £] Basanu Bai was uiinl liouse at Kusami, s&e betoie tier aeatJi. Kelatio not cordial, Uus tact was accsed namelv F'ekan Ba a ineetuig was convenea accusecl, BI wnicfi Uie Uie accused is not provu JiaDit ot givuig Marpeet ti aclvised not to uidiuge n aot Deat tiasautt tjai. 'l'lii! fhis aspect. Even P.w. £ Uie aiiouier sister-ia-law lier liusEiaiict ui a separat •*iifd41-) IWCTI ^.fs^ <Rfl<$]< ^T3Tfin3II^I Lstamed t>y nim ana deceased, meretbre, [s esTabiistiecl ui uie iiouse ana lie fias uot |tiasaau Bai sustauiecl uijunes. As per of tlie Iiiclian Evidence Act, fhe above Uie special laiowledge ol uie accused, tb . explaiu the circuinstances iu which pl aealli, Uieretore, tnat is an aclcliUonal accusecl. ot uie accusea is coucei-necl, f.W. 2 |on account ot Uie quan-el by Uie accused, tccusect lett tJie Jiouse ot Uie accused aacl :. BasauU t5ai used to go to lier parcntal to Jier ui-law's tiouse 1 y; Biontti i|ns ot ttie accused wiUl Basaati Bai were ctisclosed to liun bv sister-in-Iaw ot tlie I., 3-4 Dionms betbre the date of iacident, |m. the viuage by the inother-in-law of uie ^Uier-ui-law ot tlie accused dlsclosed mat l.uig tooa to Uasaiiu tiai aad iie is ui uie t> Basaau Bai, on wlucn me accused was suc& acUviUes, tie assurea Uiat 'ae will $ witness fl.as not Deen cross-examuiecl on t'eJsaii Bai- sister-in-law Iias statect Uiat naDiely Kaimun Bai usect to reside witli L^ rooin, tiae deceasecl was tEtira wite ol t&e wite reitumed mclUier- XI-HG-; 3TRSI W R'fi'h "c?S?i STT^T'^m?' 's^ '^ww^, ^s-vfwKo, fst^i'yy .CcA:.^.5,..^fl. 3fI^?T ^H% (iyf'j,«(<{tl) chl^ici^lll 'TTFI^ ^'fe^t <Pqt$K ^sifinsn^r tUat ttvo fhufd Qn accused, ttie accused Iiaijl qiian-elluig wmi ttiein. yiie| ot t&e tatetlU clay, Uie clejc Kaimun Bai is not Uiere, , to liave sexual m.terco'urse. reinauis ui Uie nouse, tlie.^i' above eviclence, it is estaEil wfle, mat is wny, earlier anct uie cleceasecl was quan-el aact give beatuig. witU Kaiiaun Bai uiere us]i and Tiie acciisecl Ujat is ^ accusecl and went to laeeting ot viilagers was nieetuig, villagers aclvisecl| acUvities, upon wnicn ttie axid startecl Uvuig witti ttie P.w. 13 Dtieerbai lias beatm.g to Basaan t5ai Oecpus liis sister-m-law aad. Uiat nieetuig ot Ttie villagers WE lias categoncaliy statecl relauons witti liis sister-i nieetuig dt viUagei-s was was persuadecl aaa meretpre eariier cteserted tlis ttvo wives atter Jias turttier stated tliat LQ Uie morrung ;eased disclosed to her fhat as todav is wliy, Uie accusect came near to ner wJienever Jier sister-ui-law Kaunun Bai jicc'tised loves his sister-ia-law. F'roni fhe istiecl ttiat Uie accusecl usecl to beat tus wives lett t&e Jiouse ol t&e accusect wite wita. wlioin uie accusect used to account ot tlie relanon ot tlie accusect ;a to be quan'el berween ttie deceasecl ftiy, Uie deceasea lett t&e nouse ot Uie tiouse at Kusam.1, ttiereatter a by inottier ot BasaaU ijai, ui Uiat tlie accusea uot to Biclulge ui sucll &ccusecl assured aud BasaiiU Bai canie laccused 1V2 inontti Delore ttie mcictent. stated. th.at me accused usea to give ne was tiaving illicit islations wiUi wtiv Basaati Bai lett tlie liouse and a ts couvened. In cross-exaininanon, slie |Uiat tlie accusecl was navuig lUicit u|i-law Kaunun Bai aacl ttiat is wny, a cpnvenect, ui tnat ineetmg, Tiie accused Basanti Bai started Iiviug wiUl Uie pa^ental coitivenea alst) aecftuse Bll 3Q-HC—7B sn^r w R;-fi«h '^s^ SH^T sh<-il<=h 3's? "iiNirt^, »Tny'is,Rf^iyy O.ft^o-^/fi( sn^niss Cpf^^i) 10 TOITWHfCT SII^I udt accusect. 'i'iieretore, it accusecl aiict ttie aecealsed conctuct ot me accusecl. As per me eviciqnce concluctecl post laotteui; exaiauiea uie accusea, accusect aaa Uiat &as Uiis cn-cuiaStaitce is uivolvecl ia coinnuttuig siittei'ect uijunes ui Uie sj As per Uie eviclenc^ deceased i.e. one Petti<t diacldi ot uie acciised \1 were sent to t-'orensic exainmafaon. As per t*'.; TJie fetticoat auct Kan ol] accusecl. 'l'lieretore, Ulis| Uiat ttie accusecl liacl loif wtiicti was resistea by accusecl UirotUect Uasailiti above cu'cunistantial. ev] uivolvenient ol Uie accujied tlie abave cu-cum.staaUal| be arawn is tliat Uie ^ question. qii*fTfi-41'1 ^Wv^ ^ts^ ^r'i$i< ^T SifilH 311^1 s estaDtlstied mat ttie reiations ol tlie were not corclial on account ot ttie of P.W. 17 Dr. B.P. Malaai, who lon tlie boclv ot Uasanti yai as weu as wtio ]he noticed 9 abrasions on fhe person of been explamea by ttie accusecl ttieretore, luggesUve ot tact t&at ttie accused was 4iurcler ot Basann Bai aud. t&at is w&y, lie sEune scutUe. pt invesUgating uuicer, Uie clotlies ot ttie toat aiicl one Han ot Uie aeceasecl aiid fere seized duruis nivesUgaTion a-nd. sanie 1-jcience Laboraton', Kaipur tor ciieuiical 1. L, i-eport, spots ot semen were toUD.tl on Uie cleceased as weU as on Utiactcli ot ttie t-.y.L. report also corroDorates me tact able uitercourse wiui fiis wite Basan.U Bai Basanti Bai anct ra Uiat process, me t5ai. 'l'lie ciuaulaUve eHect ot all tlie (cleiice leave no room. ot aoubt i-egarctuig in coniiaission ot ttie crmie aaa troni evictence, uie only uresbble niterence caii lccused was fhe author of Ute crmie iu XI-HC—78 a^l^t ?il f<;-fi4i 'OT7 3ITOI *MI* 3-sq- ^!|i||<?i-4, gi-JI^'KS, (sK'il^y .^.:^.iHO.:s816L 'ORSK ( yjTn Awactn 'mpal). argued tiiat beuig leeally ~f Iiave sexuai intercoursel retiisea to accecle me reqi wit& nis wite aacl m t&at. uijunes aact wlieu U^e accused ui a tieat ot pasSj liis wile wit&out tiavuig ^ ttieretore otlence agamst 304-1i ot'lPC. Un ttie otlier Jiaiicl, Tlie juclginent ot tlie tnal L| In support ol Jiis V.ie clecision ot Uie BoiaDal tacts ot tlie case were UIE aact liis wite were sleep.in Uie accusecl liacl urgecl ytiaiainlalad.evi. As Uie room., sJie aid not aUow wiUi Jier. 'l'lie aceusecl ai uiiui-v on Jier ctiest, as a i'lie Migli (Jourt on TJie ab accusea was out ot sttei ailger an.sl Uie accusecl lia •tilli<'t<i)"< llliA' if.fezt <[:*it<l< i;3TiOT3I!^I tu, learaect couiisel tor Uie appeUaat, ?edded wife of fhe accused, he wanted to wiui Basanu Bai, wtien BasanU Bai test, lie tned to liave torcible uitercourse process, me accused sustam.ca abiasion -fcsisteuce was put by ijasaati Bai, t&e aon aU ot a siictclen piessea tlie necls: ot av uitenUon to cause cleatli ot lus wite accusecl doesnot travel Eievona yecuon leamed couusel tor t&e ytate supports o'urt. 'gunient, Mlin Awatlli 'lnpattu retiect on i-lig& (Jourt m me matter ot ifncnsna?n |a reportecl ni lyyo Crt. L. J. 27. 1'lie )t on ttie tatetul nigtit wlien Ute accusecl tg ui tlie tiouse wiTli grown up ctulclren, tor sexual uitercourse wiUl &is wite g|rown up cliUclreu were sleepuig ui Uie Uie accused to liave sexual intercourse Ippeuant tooK out a Uupti aiict uitiicteci 1-esiUt ot wnicli sJae cliea UT. Uie nioinuig. ipve tacts, tielcl Uiat Uie act ctone tsy tne ejr trustration, m.onieutan' unpulse ancl i(l no uiteanon to casue tleatti, Uieretore, XI-HC—7E sn^r jsf K.-v'n ^®TT3Fn^T ?t)H 3^r ^iiAii^, diTti^id, fsf^itiy 12 3n^?r TH% ('^3^1) ^giWHfsa 311^1 Uie act ot tlie accusea murder. 4.1of<t41-l tiWi-ii^fe-zl ifa^K i? aifiiH 3ii^r s culpable tioiaicicle uot aiEtountuig to in orcler-to reacn tt> Uie conclusion wlieuier tb.e act ot me accusect coiues witD.in y^ muraer or uie act ot uid (Jouit is reqiurect to aecu e exception an.cl is not aiiiounttng to accused is aiaouiittug to inurcler, Uie le a-oia tlie tacts ancl cu-cuiastances ot eacli case tiiat ttie accusecl actecl witti uitention to cause aeatti and Uie accused Jiad laiowlepge tliat the iiijuries inflicted by the accusecl is so sevene tfaat|in. aU probabiiiti', he is tLkely to cause deatli ot uie victun, uien ine act ol tlie accused amounts to coiae wifhui tlie delinitioa of iburder. 111 Virsa Pun/aft reoorted in AIR 195V SC 469 the Apex Court held that the case uncler yecUon 3UU ot (i) (Uj (iu) prosecuuon must.prove tl]ie toUowuig tacts betore it caii Cimig a. Jie 1PC tu'st it inu$t estaDtisli, qiute objectively, tfi.at a Doclilv m.1urM tne nature o it inust De t.0 UUtlCt t&^ is present; tlie in]uiy raust t>e provea; provecl t&at uiere was aii intention t pailiciuar DodUy uiiuiy uat is to say, Uiat it was i|iot accidental or unmtentioual, or tiiat soine oUier ^uicl ot uiiuiy was uitendecl. Unce present, tlie Ui^se Uu'ee elements are proved to Ue enifluin- proceed turUier: XI-HC- SIT^I ^t K.-U* ^an SH^T ai+i 3rcT ri|M|(>')<<, QxTKH'Ko, Rldl+fy (:..A^°- -^/°' 13 '<w ( it niust D| ctescnbed) aaove, wa| course ot tiature. M' wittl saKie !n Uie present if. cliscussed ui Uie earlierl persou ot quan-elsoiae Deatuig given Dy tuin, accused.. As per me evicl|i liavuig lUicit relanon used to object tlie Detween Uie tfffo and Uierealter a uieetnig ot cleceased. ui wllicti ttie at unwaiTantea activities Basanti tiai caine troni U t&e accusect 1 Ya aiontii used to liave lUjicit wtucli was not liKecl ln1 Kauitun Bai was not ui accusecl to liave liave intercourse witti Uie ground ttiat wJienevi] alwavs liave reiaUon wiui accusect, tlie accusea Iis uitercoUrse cbj'yicl-41'f "WI^f •£ffs^ <fa^l< ^'aiRnsii^i provecl ttiat ttie uijun7 ol tlie UTpe, just m.aae up ot ttie Uiree elenients set oiit 3 sutticient to cause aeatti m. me orctuian' tbat fase, Uie inatenal evidence lias been ;part ot uus juclginent. 'l'tie accusecl is a fliature. Uu account ot lus OeUaviour ana i|is earlier two wives lett ttie Iiouse ot' the •nce ot Uie prosecuUon, ttie acciisea was fi.ls sister-ui-law Kauniui Bai, Basaiiu ;, meretore, Uiere usea to De quarrel is wliy Basanti tiai lett Uie Jiouse, l/iliagers was convenecl Dy inottier ot tne :cused was advisecl not to Biclulge ui tlie ^nd. on assurance given Dy Uie accused, qer inatemal tiouse and started living witll petore Uie uiciaent, even Uieu tae accused witti liis sister-tu-law Kaiinun Bai fciasauti yai, on Uie tatetul uay, wlien f.lie liouse, tiasanu Bai cticl not aliow Uie witti lier aiict Uie accusecl waated to Bai wliicti was resisted bv lier on tr Kaunun Bai reiaains ni Uie liouse, lie tier, wlien Basaati resistea tlie act ol tlie ajcl a torcetul uitercourse wiUi UasaiiU Uai reldtion Basaiiti 5S-HC—7i •3?^?I9iI'f?;iN ^TI 37T^T sh^ ^\ 3^T "y.!-41c»*!, g$Ti1y'l<S, Isldiy^ c -<~k •»-tft>. S€/1 M^T 113R; (4cltl'!l<^) 'Raiwgfeisn^i wtien Basantl Bai was resisl y abrasion ui]unes, even tti[ Basaati Bai, as a result ol Malaui (P.W. 17) nas state<|t jv'anous paits ot tiody ot were on llie necis ot Uie aect plpe was present, 'l'tie aoc1 were gnevous ancl tatal tor] Uirottled Basanti Bai eveit resistecl by uasaati Bai su^j to tuiisn Basanti Bai, accusecl witti eartier tcvo also loolang to me natlirej wliicll Uie acczisect pressecl| Uie accused. uitenclect ui aU Uai, Uieretoi^, we are ol tUel lias nglitly convicted ttie ^ under KecUon au'^ ol I.KC. ui me unpugnea award dismissecl and is accorcluiglt tjgi^anu Sd/- L.C.BHADOO Judge CMCll<?i<l1l ^li1<?1^ ^'fe'^t' •d^$R '^aiRi'ian^r itnig, Uie accusecl sustauiecl as uiany as •n he did not stop and pressed neck of Ivjiicli slie cliecl spontaneously. ur. B.f, Uiat as inanv as 14 uiiunes were on out ot t&ose, uijiines INo. l ancl / [ea's^d. on tlie outer portion wUere wincl |-or lias opuied. Uiat ttiese two uijunes liite. 'l'lie maruier m. wtiicti Uie accusea atter liaviag rutercoiirse wtiicli was ggests Uiat me accusecl was Deilt u'pon :, ttie contuious conduct ot Uie ilives aud me deceasecl Basaati Bai as ot necis raiunes aud t&e inaniier ni tlie necK ot ttie cleceasect suggest Uiat proDabllin' to cause cleatli ol Basanti consiaerect opuiion tUat uie tnal <Jourt fcccusecl ui uie cominission ot onence ^iVe ao not tincl any uiegaiin7 or uitu-nim7 ^s siicU, ttie appeal is liable to be clisinissea. Sd/- Dhirendra Mishra Judge tlielretore, •Hiives