•^a f3S^ oi'frfn^ - c ,P.(S)^?p. 5683 of 2007 1 Piranta Sahu S/o Late Shivnath Sahu, Rettred Mason Public Work Departinent, Aged about 68 yeafs, R/o Telibandha, Ravigram, Gali no. 2, Raipur (C.G.) 2 Budhkar Prasad Tiwari S/o Late Shiv Prasad Tiwari, Retired Paiater Public Work Departiaent, Aged about 64 years, R/o Phokatpara, Shastri Nagar, Iiifi-ont of Central ware house Raipur (C.G.) 3 Gayabai Verma, W/o Paclikaur Verma, Retired Labour Public Work Departm.ent, Aged 68 years, R/o Maura, Sundaripara, Raipur (C. G.) 4 Gwaiia bai Dhruw, W/o Late Bishahat Dhruv, Retired Labour PWD, aged about 68 years, R/o Maura, Sundaripara, Raipur(C.G.) State of ClihattisgaTh, 'TIirough Secretary, Public Works Department, D.K. Bhawan, Raipur (C.G.) Eugiaeer-ia-Chief, Putolic Work Departinent, Raipur(C.G.) CIiief Engiaeer Public Works Department, Nalghar Chowk, Raipur(C.G.) 4 Executive Engia.eer PubKc Works Department, Division 1, Raipur. WRIT PETITiON UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE 3 3 Smt, Sinita Gb.ai, counsel for fhe petitioners. Shri Yashwant Siagh, Govt. Advocate & Ku. Siuiita Jain, Panel Lawyer for fhe State. ^^^^^^^^s^Siz:^- 3° W.£.LS)_No,_5683of2007 ORAL ORDBR (28.09.2007) ^J Heaid. Learued couasel for the petitioners subraits that fhe facts aud question of law iavolved ia flie present writ petition are similar to that ofW.P. No.4135/2004 (M.A. Hakim -vs.- State of M.P. (Now C.G.) aad others), which has already beea disposed off by onler dated 28.8.2007. Against fhe order passed ia ftie said case, one S.L.P. was filed in Supreiae Courtwhich was also disinissed. She furfher subniits fhat thereafter, a review petition was filed, wbich was also dismissed. Thus fhe case is squarely covered by fbe said decision. Shri Yashwant Siagh, Govt. Advocate, appeaitag for fhe State subiaits ttiat it is not iu dispyte that this inatter is covered by fhe decision of M.A. Hakim's case (supra) aiid this petition caa be disposed off ia ttie tenas of the order passed in M.A. Hakim's case. In view of fhe above joiat stateinent inade at fhe bar, fhis petition is disposed olf ia terms of the order passed iu W.P. No.4135/2004 (M.A. Hakim -vs- State of M.P. (Now ClLhattisgarh) aad ofhers), wbich was decided on 28.8.2006. No order as to costs. ____- Sd/- Sunil Kumar Sinha Judge vatti