IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.8243 of 2010 1. PARAMJEET KUMAR GUPTA, S/O RAMJEE SAH, R/V AND POST NINGA, P.S. BARAUNI DISTRICT- BEGUSARAI. 2. DINESH KR. SINGH, S/O SRI RAM PRASAD SINGH, R/V AND POST BIHAT,P.S. BARAUNI DISTRICT- BEGUSARAI. 3. SHIV SHANKAR BHAGAT, S/O LATE SITA RAM BHAGAT, R/V BATHAULI, P.O. TILRATH, P.S. BARAUNI DISTRICT-BEGUSARAI. 4. HEERA, D/O SRI RAM SINGH, R/V AND POST- BIHAT,P.S. BARAUNI DISTRICT- BEGUSARAI. 5. RANJANA KUMARI, W/O RAM PRAVESH SINGH, R/V AND POST BIHAT, P.S. BARAUNI DISTRICT- BEGUSARAI. 6. AWADH NARAYAN MAHTO, S/O RAJENDRA MAHTO, R/V AND POST MAIDA BHAVANGAMA, P.S. BARAUNI DISTRICT-BEGUSARAI. 7. MANTUN SHARMA, S/O LATE RAJO SHARMA, R/V AND POST NINGA, P.S. BARAUNI DISTRICT- BEGUSARAI. 8. INDRA KUMAR PRAVEENA, S/O RAM CHANDRA MAHTO, R/V AND POST MAIDA BHAVANGAMA,P.S. BARAUNI DISTRICT-BEGUSARAI. 9. RANJU KUMARI, D/O AWADH NR. MAHTO, R/V AND POST MAIDA BHAVANGAMA, P.S. BARAUNI DISTRICT- BEGUSARAI. 10. ASHOK KUMAR, S/O RAJENDRA PD. SINGH, R/V AND POST MAIDA BHAVANGAMA, P.S. BARAUNI DISTRICT-BEGUSARAI. 11. SATISH KUMAR, S/O SHIV NANDAN SHARMA, R/V AND POST NINGA, P.S. BARAUNI DISTRICT- BEGUSARAI. 12. CHANDRA PRAKASH SHARMA, S/O BINDESHWARI SHARMA, R/V AND POST NINGA, P.S. BARAUNI DISTRICT-BEGUSARAI. Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY , DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT,GOVT. OF BIHAR,PATNA - 2 - 2. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY , DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT,GOVT. OF BIHAR,PATNA 3. THE DIRECTOR, DEPARTMENT OF PRIMARY EDUCATION, GOVT.OF BIHAR, PATNA. ----------- 2 28/01/2011 Case of the petitioners would be considered in light of the direction which may be issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court which is already in seisin of issue of appointment of trained teachers in the State of Bihar. This, however, is subject to the petitioners having valid and recognized degrees in this regard because if the claim of the petitioners is based on their training having been obtained as a Baby Teacher Certificate Training from Gandhi Hindi Vidyapeeth, Prayag at Allahabad then this is no degree in the eye of law as has already been held by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Sanjeev Kumar Singh Vs. State of Bihar and others, L.P.A. No. 387 of 2009 decided on 17.04.2009. This writ application is disposed of with the above observation. AMIN/ (Ajay Kumar Tripathi, J.)