^ ri>it«A»Xi»uas,£H«i ifinriiriitrrtrtii'inniiriwuitt] "f ^MJ^0?^/" oU THE M.P. SIATE AEI-IIKI S3?RATj:VE TRIBUNAL_BENCH RAIFUR. No. /97 AS'PLICANT s ant. Sadhaaa Pandey Age 42 years old l^/o Shri O.P. Pandey Resident Hsuse No. M-12 Yadu Nandan Nager. Bilaspur M.P. Public Health Tutor General Nursing Training Centre, Bilaspur (M.p.) Ver su s, 'ENTS ! 1. State of M.p. Through Commissioner/ Birector Health Services* Satpuda Bhawan, Bhopsl (M.P.). 2. Br.(ant.) Anusua paragtey, Joint uirector, Health Services* Bilaspur Bivi sion, Bilaspur (M.p.). 3« 3fe~<t It^iS&A ^^^B^^'> ^^4--- Civil SurgeoH/Siperintendent Sardar Wallabh 3hai Patel Ifo^iital, Bilsspur (M.p.). •^ ;, i^ . ,. ,^.^,^'^^:':-^,^-—^'. ili'".i' .^^•l":8:i:^^EllIJBaa^-nt3^BsieStA EETAILS OP TKE BPPLICA'riON 1. particulars of tbe Applicant s- As stated in the Cause title above. 2. part.iculars of the Respondents s- As stated in the Ggase title above. 3. Particulsrs of the order against which the applic&tion ls maae s- Claim £or pesting at Bilsspur vide State List order No . »/Nursing/Cell/1/9 5/571 dated 10.7.97. ^flWI-.??] 4. JURISDICTION OP THE TRIBUNAL i The applican-t declareg that the gubject matter of the oro.er against which he wants redressal is within the Juri saiction of the :!on'ble Court. Contd..2.. i^a-a-1——IISraSEiH'-ifC <!i3r»??'T?fK.!Bjuu>..4r.^-n-^'" •••"•"••••:— ••—••. '''!'':E^^?S£2es':"'?; ; " "~~~'.':" ^!^SSiSEBe!!!f3E!Bs.l y »• ?:::ffi??^'..%::~^«Sij^B HIGHGOURTQFCHHATTISGARHJCTE!tLJ!®P'U8i WRIT PETITION N0.2072/2005 1. • — ' . . ••.'..•.'. Smt. Sadhana Pandey Vs. ! : .' .'::: .- Stateof(M.P.)C.G.&Olheire. •9581 •^s:;^^l Siil s^'fSS pt>sti%litl?3i®oit sd/- Fakhruddin WiMSSI^S ""y^SiHSS^S ai ll::Eii;:; :.:%IBKillB lililllM'^ililBIIMyl ^^i^^^^^S^S Kiin AsJiisn yfinvastava, counsei tor Uae pefationer. yiin U.K. Uenwal, Uy. Aclvocate ueiieral, lor uie Htatt Heara leanaeci counsel tor tlie pai-Ues. •^. 'I'lie petitioner tile.cl Uie uistaat peuuon aetore Uie Ktate Aaraiaistrative 'I'nbunal on y/ l/ iyyy, wtiicfi reniauiect pencling ancl Uie l'nt>unal navuig Deen a&oJistiecl it Uas been n-aiisten-ed to tfiis (Jourt. Ttie relief claimed is tttat ttte petitioner be aUowed to join her duties pursuaat to Ue oraer ctatecl 1U/// iyy/ tAniiex. laj ancl Ge paid saiari' lor ttie penoct i/3/iyub to ai///"iyyo.\ y&e be also paicl salaiy troni l/ i/ lyy/ to date to 'oe paid to aer. yenionty t>e also countect troin Uie ctate ot lier appouitnient. Wntten statem.eut was tLled. Dy ttie responcleiits on ^4/G/ lyys, copy ol wtiicn was suppliecl to tlie applicaiit's couusej. on ".jlj lyyB. 'I'Jie appiican.t tllecl Uie rejoiiiaer on 2t/ // lyyH aact Uiereatter actclitional alliclavit was mecl. on ner Delialt. y, Uunng Uie pendency ot uie uistaat peUtton, tiie petifaoner lias tiled anoUier wnt petiUon beanng W.r^.No.a^yb/'^U'jy, but Decause ot Uie aboiition ot Uie 'rnDunal since Uie onguial petiUon caiae to tJiis Couit aacl nuinberea as wnt petition, Uie saicl wnt peunon bearuig V/.F. No.3486/2003 was not pressed. aad witlidrawn. aiid Uiat is how the present peUUoii. 4, Leanj.ecl couiisel tor t&e peUtioner siitsinits ttiat Uie petinoner was appointecl as Lacty lieaim Visitor, Uoveminent Hospital, Bilaspur on 29/2/1980. Consequent upon the selection inade by the State Uoveniraent, slie appeared m Uie ^uGIic Healtli 1'utor Kxamuiation aaa passect ui July iyyi vicie Annex.3 but worKea lu Uie capacity ol Lacly -t-lealUl Visitor till H/^/ iyyi>. Leai-nect couiisel rurtlier suDmits mat vicle \ ' ' \ ?^) orcler clateci H/ '2! iyy& (Annex.4] passect by Tlie Uirectorate, stie was u-ansteiTecl as ^'ubilc f-1ealtti 'l'utor ra Woinan HealUl WorKers 'l'rainuig (Jentre, Jagclalpur. Her nam.e appears at senal No.^& in Uie saitl orcler. yiie was reiievecl 011 A'H/^/ iyy& victe Auiiex.b. 'l'ne petiUoner suDiaittecl Uie representations Annex.ba aad bb inenuoiung about tti.e clitticulties mat ner n-asbaiict is workm.g ui Kailway Nlail yeivice at BUasplir ao.cl sne De posted at BUaspur. Leanied counsel aiso subauts Uiat viae order dated '2017 j 1995 (Aiuiex.7), fhe petitioner was posted in Siiahri Uancli Basti Unmoolaa on tlie vacant post, as per Uie au-ection issuecl by tlie Uu-ectorate to Uie i^tnel Meaicai aiicl Healtil Utticer, Uilaspiu" t.o post Mer at yiiaJin Uaucli BasU UriTnoolaii. It is subinittea Uiat as per Annex./a, Uie tiirection was issued to Uie peUtioner to joui at ytialin UaEcii Kasb UiiBioolaii aiid. slie jouiea Uiere vicle Annex.H. It is turtlier suDmittecl tliat as per Aiiiiex.y datecl .ji/l/iyyy, Uie petiUoner was postecl at t-'rmiaiy Heaim (Jentre, yonliat but sne was not retievea. it is also subiaitted that on 7/2/ 1997 vide Aiin.ex. 10, pi-oniotion order was passect 011 Uie post ol Nursuig yister ui me pay-scaie ot Ks. l^U'J-2'JWJ/- wiui a clirection to taKe cnarge tiU 2Xil'ZI iyy/. i'ne peUUouers narue is at senal r'io.^'^" ui t&e saicl orcler (ym.t. H. ^aiidey, CMU, KUaspur). Un 20/2/1997, vide Annex. lOa, aa order was issued froni fhe Directorate to the Cllief Medical & Healfh Olficer, Bilaspur tliat the amendm.ent has Oeen inacle ui u-ie orcler ciatect //^/lyy'/ and Uie petiuoner alter prouiotion to tiie post ot Nursuig Kister is postecl uncler Ctliet WIeclicat & Heaim UHicer, yuaspur. It is also sutiiaittecl tliat on ^a/ '^/ lyy / viae Annex. 1UD, Uie Uiiet Mectical & HealT.il UHicer, Bilaspur grantea permissiou to Uie petitioner to jom. at Uistnct Hospital, Bilaspiu- anct ttie pentioner subinitted uie 'jouimg vicle Amiex. lUc. 'l'liei-eatter, victe order dated 2/4/ 1997 (Annex. 11} passed by Uie Chief Medical & Mealth Uliicer, BUaspur, Uie petiUoner was uitoi'iD.ecl taat. Jier proiaotion orcler as weu as the order dated 28/2/ 1997 have been caaceued aad from me attemoon ot 3/4/ lyyy stie would. tie retieved aiict as siicli slie s&ould report to yontiat as per orcler clatect 3i/l/iyy/. 'i'Iie petiUoner suDniittea t&e representaUon (Anaex. 1 '2] to Uie Miaister concerued aacl vide order dated 10/7/1997 (Anaex. 13) issued by ftte Directorate, it was orclered mat Uie order ctatecl H/ '21 iyy& passea by t&e Uu^ctorate is pai-Uy aiuenctecl aaa t&e petttlou.er is postect witfi irnmprtiarf enect at \ Ueneral Nursm.g 1'raiauig Centre, BUaspur ui place ot Woniaa Mealtti v-Vi/orkers Tramuig Centre, Jagdalpur. 5. 'i'lie peuuoner subiuitteu lier joniiag on 31/77/'1997 vide Aiiiiex. 14. 'l'lieiBatter. 011 4/B/ 1997 vide Annnex. 15. tne Civil Siu-eeon- cum-yuDermtendent ot Maui Hosuital. BuasDur. wi-ote a letter to tlie Detiuoner tfa.at E>v amendinent ot oruer dated 8/2/1995. vou liave been "uostecl at (.Teneral NLU-SUIS i'rainuie C'eatre, oilaspur but vou tiave neituer nmiisiieu tne intormation as to wtiere vou were nosted Irom S/2f 1995 tiU date nor submitted uie reiievmg order and ttiereibre smce tjie tbruiatities are not comDleted. vour louiuie is iiot acceot.ed aud berore louims vou saouict subnut vour retievuig order. Tlie petitioner vide Annex.16 clated 6/8/1997 submitted that vide order dated 2/4/1997 lAnnex.ll) uasscu bv the Cluet' Medical & rlealtli Officer. Bilaspur, tlie petitioner has been relieved from the afteraoon of 3/4/1997. She submitted ttie detailed representation stating eveiything alongwith ffae docuinents. Again, she submitted ail the m&nnafions OB 18/8/1997 and 23/8/1997 vide Annex.l7a and l7b resDectively. 6, Alongwith the rejoinder, the petitioner also subinitted ttie docuinent for graat of leave vide Annex, 18 to the efl'ect that slie was tTaasferred but coulu not join ti'om 1/3/1995 to 31/7/1995. The petitioiier lias also submitted the docum.ent Annex. 19 dated 14/2./ 1997 alongwith fuc additional aifidavit, whereby alongwith ofhers she has been relieved from SIiahri Gandi Basti Uiimoolaa. 7. In the written statement, it is stated that fhe applicant was absent nom 1/3/1995 to 31/7/1995 anu it is on 27/11/1996 she moved two appllcauons for graat of eamed leave from 1/3/ 1995 to 8/6./1995 euid from 9/6./ 1995 to 31/7/ 1995. it is fm-ther stated that ui the order dated 71'211997 [Annex.10], the name of one Smt, Shcunuitala PandeY was mentioned at serial No.42, who has already expu-ed on 1/2/1987 aiiu the applicaut misrepresented herselt as she has been promoted. It is also stated that the petitioner Smt. Sadtma Pandcv with connivajice of some employees of the department .joined m fhe oifice of Chief Medical & Health Officer, Bilaspur whereas previously she had been relleved to joia at Prunaiy Healtli Centre, Soubat, In para 15 oftfae written statement, it has been denied that the petitioiierjoined at Bilaspur on 31/7/1997 and it is saiu that she uid not produce any reneviug order aad as sucli she was not allowed to joni. It is also said Uiat as per tae clocunients enclosed aiongwiUl Atiaex, lt> slie lias E>een relieved to jouit at Jagdalpur wtiereas sne neverjouiecl at Uiat place. y. Peniseci Uie recorcl. iio tar as Vae appouitnient a&a t&e postuig ot the petitioner vide order dated 8/2/1995 is not disputed. But, siiDsequenUy me question Iias been raised. about tier jomiiig, postm.g ana Uie omers. 'l'ne ouly quesuon raisecl is Uiat sne tias not procluced Uie joiniug cei-tificate. The order passed by the Departraent is ttiat she was proiaotea as per Aruiex.4 clateel H/^/ iyyt> aiid was traiisteiTed as rtibiic l-1ealtti 'l'utor ui VVoniaa HeaiUi Workers Trauitag Centre, dagdalpur. Her name appears at senal 1'iio.^ib ui Uie said oraer. merealtex', auoUier orcler ot iier prouiotion was passed on //^/lyy/ (Annex.lO) wliereia her naiae is nieationed at serial No.42. On 20/2/1997, vide Aruiex.lOa, aii order was issued froui fhe Directorate to the Cbief Medical & Healtli Officer, Bilaspur that the aiiiendiaeut has Deen m.acle ui tfae orcler aatecl 7/^/iyy/ ana Uie peUtioner atter proiaotioii to tne 'post ot f'iursuig i-lister is postecl uncler Cliiet Mectical & i-lealtti UHicer, Bllaspur. Urd.er ciateci 2fJI '2,1 lyy/ is quotecl below: '{TSTnf^nnTS TSTTSS. Trara^T ^i'fcp e./-7iRtiT/?feT-9/e^/ ^TqM.1 yKs, ips4 rai=brMI IIcT <C||<<ST 3TT6raTHt lsjcr!l^|U< (q"oHo) ' '" •:^A' \" "~ / JSfSffI :-sttqrtT 7TTWTT qra^ TSTq? ^ Efi- q^Te.TWTT c? TN'S.T ^ ! TgTTrtsRT RF^<T 4 •N'WFtl' 'HTERT qp^ TOTq? :'T?t 'is|(D|<l4< BrrT vaicjri^j q^r gTrRT g?T f^i^e^r Icb^i S f^ AiiycA gm' ^r. ^f' fsTCTTRroT eRt ^Ts qeTC.TTT'Tf HF'T '•T^T zht 3n' -r^t t i grr TraaT w CTS 'PTCr iSfizn snHT ^ fS; ^pTrtt 'FITCT':TT uiu^-y •^rRtTr f?W'r ^ Ts- qr tRf':;:rf?T ^4<!'rt •q??S.TpT?rr •Wgq }%Tl?pr?IT qg 'RTTortnSra?rTr iSr<ii-^u.< c^ -3:Ff&T<T aft i^ & MM.chi 3TT^ST i? TIFRT cft .^. .. ........ .^ ^ . .. „ .,. -..,.. . .... „ 'RTFT qT WftS.PT EBWTT srr cR?T/ ^^IMcb Rn^r?TT ^m?T rrsziTTSST s)0 ^ 1C[oS^O /'' yj<-ii<?ily: 9- 5- /'^r-i/'&^/'ioss-t's Ww< [7S.T HcT 3Ttcrs'Z[?B chHdlrit ^T 3T 'c\ ~ " " *' ' ...... . - . .-^. .. ^ 'H'ElliTicb 'raTo^cTPT i6<^!t<4M< 1 ^ . . -. . . -. . , . . . . .. . . .^^ . R 50/5/ei3 'TF? SRT-TtToQTTo'aiToRipTTCTiTT ... ..^ . 'c\ arTqg-r WCT-TT 41 "^o SAT CTtT 'S'Vti •Sf.TStS'^ Xf-5i 'ia.-licb 50-5-e.lS cj^ i^t if rst! •Fffr/- ^K^/ffvn^fcfi i-=)tcbrHi 9. On 28/2/1997 vide Amiex.lOb, the Chief Medical & HealUi Unicer, Kiiaspur grsmted penaissioii to Uie peUtioner to JOBI at Uistnct MospltaJ, Bilaspur. rmission aatea '2Sf '2,j 19y/ is quotea Eielow: IToUo " '••^' F=n /TcTTo/^iiy-l! /^r/'&.l^ / 313 3 X tSRSmTOT,T&^TrcR 5i:./5/-£.t9 am, aftl:t?tT IT'CTo'-liu^. ^T^ ^T, s;le<] ••i'-.j siK-ji qi'T-ii, TN^nwK.'q'oijo fKV( -.- s& q^ qT .jql^jir) I ^•diri cb, TaTTezr ' n<T/?rt T/3^,r- q /^^ / s e(5/ FT ERT <3:T'I^T 5- <M^I!^<+>, T?RS2T TraT'T ERT <SfTSyf ^ncH /qo^o/e./ •-lRT?T/<ra'-9/-fc;iS/9ob^-6;^9^ilMI<Tl,i^^ '•io-.S-t;^ S- ^3-JNCP! '^llqs.l II<T1lcr> •<?;--<—t;tt> TT^T^rt" aiTtSTT cf; d!<d*<| I? gTFTEfi 3TT4?'T 'TT yiyiylri cft ICT- 4 snvsfff ansr tt^ftcB ?T:-?-c.ts zBt ^i?i-i| RTTST efi q3" TT %T?TT RjKhr+jM^ Ts|CTil^)U< Tf ^qfeTrT gt^- ^ <¥FTqRT OCTq' ^t STRft t 1 'FTSTStFT .STTS'STT RHiTT ;OT TBT tl ^. Eft y.isc'.<t><l'l ^rT 'FTSTIT 3Ti'& ^. . . . .. ^ .. .. . .. - ^ q^f 'R^T/- mTss^ff ^ ^rr •srm 4^ il'ilcrlt^iy,Hoyo go^o ./TCTTO /^i^-ii/e.is iy<?i|tH4<, T^TlcB yrai$m:- <j- Rrt^T IT3^T 7lF?:lR°q' STaflW^.WlTa' •-S OTcTSii^ ciTTTfcn^r ^ i 15irt!'f-|y< cftf GTtT '?T=RTa.t '3^ •^ - - - — - -Cy • -- - ' ~ ^Wi/- l^lcbrMI qcr T^rRT4T,ITo!To' ^3 / iu. 'rjie peuboner suDmittecl Uie joinuig vicle Annex.lUc. 'l'&ereatter, vide order dated 2/4/1997 (ABiiex.ll) passed by Uie Cmef Medical & HealUi UHicer, Uilaspur, tlie petitioner was UTtonuecl Uiat tier proniotion oi-cter as weli as uie order ci.atect ^H/^/iyy/ nave been caucellecl aiia iroin tlie atteruoon ot a/4/ lyy/ slie would De reiieved aacl as sucii stie should report to Sonhat as per order dated 31/1/ 1997. T'lie petitioner subnjittea Uie representation (Anuex. i'2] to me Miaister concem.ea ancl vicle orcler aatea lu/,//J.yy/ (Aanex. laj issued by Uie Uu-ectorate, it was ordered tb.at fh.e order dated 8/2/ 1995 passed by tlie DiE'ectorate i.s pai-Uy auieiiclecl aiicl Uie petitioner is posteci witti unniecliate ettect at tienera-1 I'iursuig 'l'ramuig Centre, tiUaspur ui place ol Woman HealUi Workers 'l'raiiiuig Centre, Jagdalpur. Uraer datecl 1U/'// J.y9'/ is quoteci Gelow: ;-lc!!nirj|nid '(TSTgXST %fci!ch •6../'^HPT/TRT-'3/e.lS/t,'/9<) rra? 'io./'is/e.is %itiirt4r;T sfrSsf ^WR? £;/^t T/^T-q/e,fc/i5e.i5/ T^TrcB c,/5/e.<i' =ft 3?^:o^o 9'y TSracfr gJTT afTqg-r •CTTCT^]- qTog y£jip ^ ^nto?froSrou.?To fsipTTFpjT cfir ^et^rtTT qt^ra? ^eT ci4<i< ^ qa' I:?f^T cbl4t^rii qfSTSPT ^c' •.r!-ii'i.<y|y<' d^' Tj^ aft, -3TST 3=RT' OTT^ST ^ ^2 3Tft§T?R •CTSTtST.T SRTrT g7T 41^}- -qp^ sfit q?TeiPT<?T 31^7^ ^ T OfiTSPiT •^ Efe T^TRTOT ^ rtrAicri $I'*TR' ^ =& STTcfr $ i ^??/- ('f§TcRF3T ffc[?5 tci|<<-'q 'dii^'TO, l<oyo ^•^SSu^^^^ '-'::^!^:sis 'w' !|]illl!s1 g'o^O:E;7"TRN/'^T-9/€;l9/X'S'?'c:':?3 V]Ul^ JS.'I I'cb 9o /l9 /e.lS yKiRtISt:- -H^i^ii4 i?al STTcRzRi? chl'4d!^t' i^r 'si - f. <^ 'T> r, ITFTO^M | ^^ <c||^ Vcf ^T<qi< qi<;<llu| t|oi.los<i]y»i, »itLli<n l (-J'qiTiq-/ ^=TRKT ^ST?TS' f^fra^3"/^ •ETOS)O 1 .^- ;gsq- Rlj^x^l ag ^rezr g^RBrtt, Isj^l^i^OI,; .;• i'8- yTETpf, <cn^3T l^ qRc| 1 < cb<rqi"| y^RT"! %, •'Myi^y 1 fy- •aft!^ft 3TTEHT W3t,'?ePP ^ SRT -3ftoI"To*3tto?si'7ii<-l;i,< ^ •3AT ^F?N ! IIIJII ^^•s III ^fft/- (R|c|<M Rfe) ^rneq- 3TTgcRr,iTo5ro" ^.it.^^ her joining on 31/7/1997 vide A:nnex.l4. AU fhese orders haye been passed by ftie lugher aumorities. 0a 4/8/1997 videAnimex. 15, the Ciyil Sui^eon-Gyin-Superiirteaflent of MaM Hospital, Biiasp'ur,'iaade a query froni the ^petitioner that by affitendineQt of order ctafed 8/'2/1995, you have been posted at Geaeral NursMg TTaiaiag Qenfre, Biiaspur but you have neiftier fumished Uie information as towhere you were postedfrom 8/2/ 1995 tiU. date nor subicutted Uie reUeving order and fherefore smce the formaJities are not completed, your joinuig is not accepted aad betbre joiniag yous.iiould. subinit your relieving brder. The petitioner vide Aitnex.16 dated 6/8/1997 sut>mitted copy of the order dated 2/4/19y7 (Aiinex.ll) passed by fhe ChiefMedical & Healfh. Of&cer, Bilaspur. Bare perusal of fheorderdated 2/4/1997.shows that ftie petitioner has rejieved from. the aftenioon of 3/4/1997. These docuiD.en.ts ffled alongwith fhe petition relating to reiieving aad joiaiag are also -available iu fhe „ departm.ent. The petitioner has beeajust deuied ofjoining. Under ftie ~ tacts aad circuiastances as discussed hereinabove, tBe Civil Surgeon- :; cum-Superuitendeut ofMain. Hospital, Bilaspurwas notjustilied iit not ^Faccepttagfhejoiaing. ^,i" ijg|j];2.:/ .The inatter is pendiiig since...l997' and now eight ;years Uave< ^llgajssett. '.Sulce fhe order dated 8/2/J.995 passed by.tfie Birectorate is |i|j;|s)aJE'^j|;amended vide order dafea 10/7/ 19y7 (Aiuiex.^ aad• ftie llglggjEiiQmgB is. postea wim iinmetliafe eflfic^^^^ JSigaggigiiaspuir in "placei of woman 'HeaItfl WprJssrs Traia^ }SiBB81~Sil"6 ^''"""''.'^" ^ -,„———.—.. --- -. -.--.^.n ^-.---g ISii^^Si^^^p^ 'fi^ni tli^, ;the.petitk>ner'a^ •ia •ii^l l^il^^llln&iitjiih'^::K.^;l^l:';::i^:^:/^::'.'^ ^^^J^^^M^jM^^^^a^sNs^SV^s^feli^lji liKI !•• s>. H/ B"; 'Kilaspur. As such, it is^ directed tiiat tj&£ petitioner be allowea to joia •tortliwith at Bilaspur as per order dated 10/7/1997 (Annex. 13). Sue oe also aUowed to draw,her salarv. tS.' So far as the .interveruiig period is cbaceraed,, Counsel for the •petitioner subimts that he wouid fflake a detaitod representatioi^raisitig^ peti.tioner's grievanees on all aspects Betbre ftie eoiapefenf aiatB.'i^Eit^g T&& petltioaer inay subinit a detailecl representation ,!3steu^'St|DB:p eoinpetent authonly, which shau be considerea oa its owti jm^i-itB.^s accDrdance with. law. tffhe grievaace reinaias, £hepetitioiierm.ay^Kaiifl Uie'reinedy tri accordaace wrth law. ,: .,'1 •;;;.;;.;^';^%®s^®|gj 14. Subject to the direGtioas niade IiereiDaboye, the ^ disposed ot. •m'm sd/- Fakhruddin Judge -iSS'K "ss, • sa .ssssa IMM?Jllll^iBli^lili&i^si^l.^ SS.& a