CWP 9382/2010 [1] IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT JAIPUR BENCH SB Civil Writ Petition No. 9382/2010 Gajendra Singh Dagur Vs. Director Secondary/Elementary Education & ors. DATE OF ORDER : 23/07/2010 HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY RASTOGI Mr. KP Singh, for petitioner. The petitioner, who is working on the post of LDC, while posted in District Education Officer, Elementary Education, Bharatpur, on being transferred to Government Senior Secondary School, Karansar, Distt. Karauli vide order dated 05/05/2010, preferred an appeal before the Service Appellate Tribunal which has been rejected vide order dated 16/06/2010. The bone of contentions advanced by counsel is that the petitioner could not have been transferred from Elementary to Secondary Education and the authority is not competent to transfer the petitioner. No such objection was raised by him before the Tribunal. Apart from it, the petitioner is a member of ministerial cadre and posting in Elementary or Secondary Education is under the administrative control of the department so far as the Staff of ministerial cadre is concerned and nothing has been placed before this Court which may show that the transfer of the ministerial cadre employees from Elementary to CWP 9382/2010 [2] Secondary Education is not permissible. That apart, the learned Tribunal has taken note of the stay of the petitioner in District Bharatpur and taking note thereof has not considered it appropriate to interfere in the order of transfer, which is an incident of service and nobody can claim any right to continue at a particular place. Furthermore, no malafide has been alleged against the authority who has passed the order impugned or violation of any statutory Rules has been alleged. Taking note thereof, this Court does not find any manifest error being committed by the Tribunal which may call for interference of this Court. Consequently, the writ petition has no merit and it is accordingly dismissed. [AJAY RASTOGI], J. Raghu-9382-CW-2010-final.doc