IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA C. REV. No.191 of 2006 1. BHOGI LAL SINGH, S/o Late Dhidhar Singh 2. Jagdish Singh, S/o Late Khushi Lal Singh. 3. Bipin Singh, S/o Bhogi Lal Singh 4. Ram Prasad Singh, S/o Late Manori Singh 5. Smt. Phul Kumari Devi, W/o Laleshwar Singh 6. Mangal Singh, S/o Anup Lal Singh 7. Anmol Singh S/o Jagdeo Singh. 8. Lalo Singh @ Laldev Singh, S/o Ganga Singh 9. Laleshwar Singh, S/o Late Ramdhani Singh All residents of Village- Bhattabari, P.S.-Chhatpur, District- Supaul. 10. Ramsewak Singh, S/o Kalu Singh 11. Surpat Singh @ Dhurpat Singh, S/o Thakur Lal Singh 12. Pitamber Singh, S/o Pachu Singh 13. Ram Swarath Singh, S/o Dhanlal Singh 14. Raghu Nandan Singh @ Raghuni Singh, S/o Pitamber Singh 15. Rauddi Singh, S/o Dukhi Singh 16. Budhu Singh, S/o Late Lochan Singh 17. Jai Kumar Singh, S/o Baideo Singh @ Basudeo Singh 18. Amrendra Singh, S/o Late Kameshwar Singh 19. Mahender Singh, S/o Laljee Singh All R/o Village- Jhakhar Garh, P.S.-Chhatpur, District- Supaul 20. Bechan Singh, S/o Nandesher Singh 21. Babu Jan Singh, S/o Banilal Singh. Both R/o Village- Kathara, P.S.-Chhatpur, District- Supaul. Versus 1. STATE OF BIHAR 2. The Commissioner, Khoshi Division, Saharsa. 3. The Additional Collector, Supaul 4. The SDM, Tribaniganj, Supaul. 5. The Circle Officer, Chhatapur, P.S.-Chhatpur, District-Supaul. 6. The Halka Karmchari, Chhatapur, P.S.-Chhatpur, District-Supaul 7. Ramesh Yadav, S/o Bhola Yadav. 8. Lalan Kumar Yadav, S/o Mishrilal Yadav. 9. Lila Devi, D/o Sukhai Yadav @ Sukhal Yadav. 10. Sakuntala Devi, D/o Sukhal Yadav 11. Shumbhu Prasad Yadav, S/o Dev Narain Yadav. 12. Arbind Prasad Yadav, S/o Gujdeo Yadav @ Mujdeo Yadav. 13. Laltu Yadav, S/o Deval Yadav 14. Suresh Yadav, S/o Mangen Yadav. 15. Feku Yadav, S/o Shamik Yadav 16. Manoj Yadav, S/o Denal Yadav 17. Musahru Yadav, S/o Ashirafi Yadav 18. Mahendra Yadav, S/o Jitu Yadav. 19. Ashok Kumar Yadav, S/o Satyadeo Yadav 20. Sishupal Yadav, S/o Harilal Yadav. 21. Deo Nandan Yadav, S/o Bisundeo Yadav. 22. Shiv Nandan Yadav, S/o Bishundeo Yadav 23. Bhipal Yadav, S/o Hari Lal Yadav 24. Kari Yadav, S/o Bhola Yadav. - 2 - 25. Dilip Yadav, S/o Rajmal Yadav 26. Bhubneshwari Yadav, S/o Baldeo Yadav 27. Sambhu Sharma, S/o Deo Narain Sharma 28. Bacha Lal Yadav, S/o Baldeo Yadav. 29. Bijay Yadav, S/o Satya Deo Yadav. 30. Arjun Yadav, S/o Sahdeo Yadav 31. Gopal Yadav, S/o Hari Lal Yadav 32. Bharogi Yadav, S/o Manik Yadav 33. Birendra Yadav, S/o Feku Yadav 34. Kameshwari Yadav, S/o Reshma Lal Yadav 35. Sadanan Thakur, S/o Shiv Nath Thakur 36. Hakim Nanddaf, S/o Kadish Naddaf. 37. Israil Naddaf, S/o Hadish Nanddaf 38. Titan Yadav, S/o Resham Lal Yadav. 39. Mahendra Yadav, S/o Resham Lal Yadav 40. Gulab Chand Yadav, S/o Mahendra Yadav 41. Mansur Naddaf, S/o Halim Naddaf 42. Laxman Yadav, S/o Uttim Lal Yadav 43. Sambhu Yadav, S/o Deo Narain Yadav All R/o Village- Katahara, P.S.-Chhatapur, District-Supaul 44. Hridaya Yadav, S/o Sahdeo Yadav 45. Shyam Sunder Yadav, S/o Basudeo Yadav All R/o Village- Bhatta Bari, P.S.-Chhatapur, District-Supaul 46. Most Rasmani Devi, D/o Basudeo Yadav, R/o Village- Jhakhar Garh, P.S.-Chhatapur, District-Supaul. 47. Binod Yadav, S/o Jagdish Yadav 48. Jagdish Yadav, S/o Asharfi Yadav Both R/o Village-Parsa and are under P.S.-Chhatapur, District-Supaul ----------- 4. 06-08-2010 This petition has been filed for review of order dated 28-11-2002, by which a Bench of this Court disposed of C.W.J.C. NO. 11367 of 2002 holding that the rights of the petitioners as under raiyats will be examined in the proceeding under section 48E of the Act. So far as the settlements are concerned, it is not open to them to challenge it for the simple reason that they are not claiming settlement in their favour. In the facts and circumstances, this court does not find any error apparent on the face of the record nor does it find any material to take a different view. Accordingly, review petition is dismissed. Sujit (S.N.Hussain, J.) - 3 -