IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARWAD Dated this the 12;!: Day of December 2011 Before THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE H.N.NAGAMOHAN DAS Miscellaneous First Appeal No.21559/2011 BETWEEN: Shivanand S/o. Basappa Ganiger, Age: 33 years, 0cc: Grain Business, Now nil, R/o. 1-losakoti. Tq: Ramadug. Dist: Belgaum. .Appellant (By Sri.Subhash B. Sankad. Adv.. for Shivnraj F’. Mudhol, Adv.j AND: 1. Nagappa S/o. Basappa Puradagudi, Age: 33 years, 0cc: Panshop Business, R/o. Akki Oni, Saundatti, Tq: Saundatti, Dist: Belgaum. 2. The Divisional Manager, Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., Divisional Office, Shanbag Chambers, Kirloskar Road. Belgaum. .. .Respondents (By Sri. La’cman B. Mannodar, Adv.. for R2, Ri-sd) This appeal is filed under Section 173(1) of MV Act, against the judgment and award dated 19.08.20 10 passed in NP/C No.1417/2008 on the file of the Addl. Senior Civil Judge and Member, Addi. Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Saundatti, partly allowing the claim petition for compensation and seeking enhancement of compensation etc., This appeal coming on for Hearing on Interlocutory Application this day, the Court delivered the following: JUDGME.NT This appeal is directed against the judgment and award dated 19.08.2010 in MVC No.1416/2008 passed by Motor Accident Claims Tribunal. Saundatti. 2. The grievance of the appellant is inadequacy of compensation of ?21.000/- awarded by the Tribunal under all heads. In the motor accident on 15.01.2008. the appellant sustained injuries as under: 1. Tenderness and swelling on left clavicle movement of left shoulders painful, sagmental fracture of left clavicle bone, 2. Abrasion at left elbow. 3. Contusion at left shoulder. 4. Contusion at left scapular region of :3: 5. Abrasion at left knee joint. 6. Abrasion at left thigh. 7. Contusion at right leg. 3. The medical evidence on record discloses that there is 14% disability to the injury. On the date of accident, the appellant was aged about 30 years and he was doing grain business. One of the injuries sustained by the appellant is a fracture of left clavicle bone. Having regard to the age. the fracture. the length of treatment. pain and suffering, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is on lower side. In the facts and circumstances of this case, I am of the opinion that grant of additional compensation of Z20,000/- under all heads will meet the ends ofjustice. 4. Accordingly. the following ORDER I. The appeal is partly allowed. ii. The impugned award in MVC No.1417/2008. dated 19.08.2010 is BS here medifed enhantv l ornpnsuion from 2 00 4I 000 Rerririr aspt ts th irnpugiied t\d ifltat and undist irbd Sal JUDGE