IN THE HIGH COURT^)F JUDICATURE AT BILASPUR (C.G.) WRIT PETITION N0. f /2002 PETITIONER Smt. Zaheeda Khan W/o. Aslam Khan D/o. Chhote Khan, aged about 41 years R7o. Chandani Chowk, Muslim Ganj Raigarh (C.G.) VERSUS RESPONDENTS ,^^ s^^ 2- •>'''d^>;"—^ ^^y ^•^^' 3, - .•i--;^' ' -t^*1 v-i^" .., .** Director Health Services Chhattisgarh Raipur (^-- (q-^ ChiefMedical & Health Officer, Main Hospital Raigarh (C.G.) Assistant Medical Officer City Dispensary Vinoba Nagar Raigarh (C.G.) WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226/227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF DTOIA FOR ISSUANCE OF A SUITABLE WRIT, QRDERS OR DIRECTIONS XI-HC-78 sn^rw R-fi* iw 3tR?r a'^w *TTHMI »Wra» '3SI .<|1<<|<iq, ®T(1u'IS,Iqclltfy .^.P,Mo. 2^3/^02- —^•^ 200 ST^Tq^R (I^3g^Er) WtTraT^cTsn^r Shri K.N. Nande. counsell Shri Sandeen Yadav. Dv Arsuments heard. Orderdictated as foUowE) The petitioner. who is I'LHVI and attached with fhe GJ has challeneed the validitv o| resuondent No.2. bv whieh he-i she has been directed to ioin yUl Lcaraed counsel for tht vear 1989, the uetitioner, wllt subiected to freauent di^ uniiecessan' harassiaent an|d subinitted that the aforesaid t ai-e mala&de and tlie last ord|i this oetition is required to be 4 Tbe brief lacts are that post of Ladies Health Visitor nosting in. villase- Badebhaud^ 30.7.1990 (Annexure-p/4) aii^ Badebhandar to Renaal 11 t>i<<Fci<fl-< *iiticiTiftec^)'<Rit<;i< ^isrf^iTsn^T forfhe petitioner. Govt. Advocate for tlie resoondents. 1Q.2QOS) working as a Ladies Health Visitor h7 disoensan- Vinoba Nagar Raieai-h order dated 11.6.2002 passed by attachiaent has been caucefled aud Priman- Health Center, Kosir. netitioiier subraits fhat siace tlie ? is a low paid einulovee, has been .placeruent or traasfer causiiie ereat hardshics to her. It is ictions of the authorin- of the State :r. wbich is Uie iianugned order of •t aside bv this Court on this ccuut. Ithe Detitioner was aDDoi]ited on the (l|HV) on 8.12.1989 and was eiven her h~. She worked iii Badebhandar irpto (I on 30.7.1990. she was sent from. fali. Froia Rengal Pali, sly wgs XI-HC-78 SI^T^iTfeRl ^TT 3TI^?T shHlch 3:s? '<{MW<<, w^\ww, R|<-liy^< . Ui.p. ^o, 2--4-51-9 /O-^o^- ^ *<1+1MI ShWh ^ 200 3Tl^5T(raq7 (4cl''l°<'i,8T) waraTtifeTsn^T •2. transfen-ed to Mauora for wlt ultrmatelv vide aa order datf Villaae- Chaole ia olace of On 27.4.1994, she was asait. Naravannur fBastari. Shicel suscected. a reoort was lodg( and ulttmatelv tlie uetitioner on 4.12.1995. she was agaial Just after sfac raonths. on 21 froin Kunkiu-i to Chaple. subniits tliat tliereafter aeaiul frora ChaDle to Kosir. He fur froni Kosir to Gitv Disnensanl working tUl fhe impugned ord The subiuission of leai) the aforesaid m.staiices exT)laiiator\' to show tliat flt traasfer/disnlacenient and ftl' to be bonafide. So far as the is conceraed. leamed couril distaiice of70 k.in. froin Raid to ao at Kosir agaia. It has almost been se| U-aasfer. which is aa incidel +i<ifcf41.f im(?fr'ffte^<^RZK ^arf^TsnSro llich a reoresentation was niade aad )d 15.7.1993. she was trausfen~ed to Mbnora bv urodif\~ina the earlier ordeR transferred from. villase- Chaple to the contents of fhe order 'were |d regarduis genuiiieness of fhe order i-em.ain.ed at villase- Chaple. However. transfen~ed from Chacle to Kunkuri. P.6.1996. she was aeam caUed back :anied counsel for the petitioner lon 3.0.6.1997. the Detitioiierwas sent tier subiuits fhat aeaia, slie was sent Raisarh on 8.1.2001. where she was ;rwas i3assed on 11.6.2002. ned coiinsel for the iietitioner is that rf transfer/disrilacenient are setf le uetitioner is a victim of freauent act of tlie authorih- does not apnear oresent displaceinent'of tlie oetitioner >el also submits that Kosir is at a arh aad it is dfficult for the oetitioner :Ued bv the Suureine Coui't that the ice of service is not to be uiterfered •~"7"r.^ XI-HC-78 •CT^TqirR-fi* (I8tT3fI^?r»t|[cti *ll*ldl Sh*<|ch 'fSf •<)1<11<1'!<, i9Tfl«'IS,R|<11<riy ^^,t).^o.^.4-^/^G^- ""/"W?[ 200 3<l^<fl i<an> (*i?ll31!"<]iT) B^aiWdferw^T J3 - wifll bv tlie Courts unless it| visited bv nialafide or iafrat oruiciDles sovemuia fhe trajil vitiated bv lualafide or is madl the Court caiinot interfere witl|i traasferred and uosted wh4re authoritv to decide it aiid unl[ be arbitran- or isvitiafed.by court of law to uiterfere m su|i bv the State. is shown to be cleai-lv arbitran" or );tion of. auy prescribed nonns of tifer. Unless<h.e order of transfer is in violation of ooerative guideliues. it. In nonaal course. who should be is a Diatter for adrainistrative :ss fhe order of transfer is shown to ibala&de. it would not be uossible for ;h adiniiiistrative action uudenaken rialht In tiie nresent case, petitioner has been tiansferrel aU tiiae it has been said tha^ has been sent or adiusted at of n.ile of law and apod actions should be iust and fainiess. it shall lead eiftieil undei-taken bv tlie admiaistral 8 traiisfers/diszilacements of| emclovee is itself evident of tli| traiisfers/disulaceinents m.ad| harassnient to her. In the facts and to auash the iniiiuaned or <ni<if<l<fl-< ITOyfF tf fS^ft <K\Wi ^isrf^iTan^r adnliinistratiou from Uie vear 1989 tiU 2001, tlie 1/disulaced for about 8 tiiues and iii due to adm.inista.-ative exigencv. she Darticiilar ulace. It is basic oiiaciDle fhat even adniinistrative fair aad tf the action is lackins in iiito arbitrarv or iiialaiide action tive aufhorit\~. In the oresent case. 7- the petitioner. who is verv low oaid fact fhat she was victim of freaueat bv tlie State aud the same is a cu-cumlstatices of fhe case. I deeni it orouer ler. The uetition is allovved. T'he XI-HC-78 *11*1t11 Sh*l|ch 3??^TraR:PT, »Tn<f'l<»,(qcliuy ^_lA),p,i\fo, 24-33/2-_°o^ '^200 3li^<l 4si<n (lcit^6i^T) 3n^T ^r R.fi.* (pn'sn^'CTsfiro s^nwflfN'sn^T -^ iiQDusiied order of traiisfer/|displacem.ent dated 11.6.2002 is Iierebv quashed. !n view of the above, interim. retief and stay, I.A. fUiag certi&ed coov of iniuuendd ureent hearine afl staad disoosled of t>i<<fci<fl-f iiti<nTffte^t<R]<^i< ^sti^R'sn^T W.)P. No. l-574/2002 for graat of >. 7909/2002 for exeniption froin order aiid I.A. No. 7908/2002 for Sd/- Sunil Kumar Sinha Judge