^ THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR Writ Petition. No. %/2003 c^ Ramnath Satnami, S/o. Sevak Ram Satnami, aged about 60 years, occu. Ex Peon K.G.9 Polytechnic Raigarh Chhattisgarh, R/o goirdadar Distt. Raigarh (C.G.). VERSUS: RESPONDENTS: I, /- ^A><$^-^/' f^y' ^•^^••" <-- '^^ : 1. State ofChhattisgarh Through: Secretary. Education. D.K.S Bhawan Raipur(C.G.). : 2. Joint Director, Pension, Treasury and Account. Madhav Complex Sarkanda Bilaspur (C.G.) : 3. Principal Kirodimal. Polytechnic. Raigarh (C.G.) : 4 Additional Director Technical Education Center Women Polytechnic Bairan Bazar, Raipur (C.G.). : 5 Treasury Officer Raigarh(C.G.). WMT PETITION UNDER SECTION 226/227 OF CONSTITUTION OF CSTDIA 1. PERTICULARS OF THE PETITIONER As stated above in the cause title. ,^;s-l.^'-c rr .^•' ::"s^^ Sjsij^r^t; ?ft;')i*'?iii?[, ^•it^ ^Fgfl SiSe- -•<,' i^ys .;!-,;,'•'• 8iil •^'^?B^?2gS^!BB8^j!i')^B %BBBaBS!8BHS<aBSI ^SSS'StSKW1399eK^sS!S , . • <^'3!^S^'^1^''':^:::^^:'.: .•.^•^^'&^ss^S^y^^ •WWK sb!Uict)"T"'?"'?~"""'<?I'TU^'g^' ^2005 ^Ajil^tdigg^f^ 05.0&.3003 <<>l<fel'S!l't?t!lRlf'^1il3t<l?I^K ,ii3(PW 3)1^1 • Sari:. Haimda Sidtliqui, C^unsetfer fhe petitioner. ShnRanl^Smgh,^..^:jortIffi ' • ;Heard..~''..::'>l.':; ••.:.-,;;':' : The pefitioner Ilas ^rticles 226/32^of;ffie pFejfeiTed ©olistifcution theordersdated 30.04.:2003 recoveiy oftfafi aiDOU^liasbeej&cTderedwhic&^ascpaM^a^ lugtter scalc ofpay granted by The petttiQQer's case :ii the'sompetent autKonty^ "Ehat tlie Kad retired fi-oni the dlaprasi. Hc was appomited vide ordeir dafed 22;7.19&2; '-this wiit petition under KefindiaIbeiogs^gHjeved-By and a22.02.2003 W wliich ^tlifi Qavpiswcst PoSy ehB^KG&S3^^^:Rai^r>i to 87.06.1965 and ^ticreafter lic \~- • •:-•:••.•• . ~ '. •:•'.. '.•-:." -• was attaclicd to tfac <3pven^c:(i1; Kirodi^ Raigarli Siiice the pGfitioiier was ^ilQf prMnoted, he worked fbrou^io^ petitioner w&s given fhe iacTi^aSed^!p^ ,scate vide <M^ 15.09.20QO as? per Goyei-am.e^t' Policy- and Weleafter by order .t;:'.. ' • ; .'' dated 18.11.2002 fbfi iBtegat i^oveiy' feas teeeh ordetcd fiximi the pensioit-of fhe pelitiioaea?. '1^ ^irapondenfWo.3 wrote aletter on 18.11.2002 ^recoyerppfth^taiBxN^w^ .t. J; & - w -./'" HC-22 'S^ •*ll<li<»l';i, {?(TRT!1S, •sn^r'EM ri?TR7 3IKSI sfnTi'EB'W^I fe,!;,;.'.[ BW8)a@8i: sn^i WITW: ^ifei bccn crroncously paid to tbj 30.06.2002 to fbe ttme ofRs.l The petitioner inade pctitioncr from 19.04.1999 to 4992/-. . representation on 23.01.2003. lunder Section 80 ofC.P.C. Petitioner also served a notice Leamed counsel for tljie petitioner subiuitted fhat the action of respondent No-3 is K:covering the saine from one An affidavit has been ^>i^i^4i'i 'qF^f ^ 'f^st <^i'^i< i? SlfiOT 3:(I^¥( arbitraiy, rna1a fide aad violatiiig fhe Article 14 of the Const|tution of India as fhey are not popi Raui Patwa who was granted similar benefit alongwith. petiljioner. The higher pay scale paid to fhe petitioner cannot be deijlucted froin his pension aud even the pay revision caiuiot be ddp£witfaout hearing the petitioner, therefore, the recoven' ord.er b^ quashect. filed by respondent No.2-Jom.t Dtrector, Treasun', Accounts and Pension, Bilaspur. In paragiaphs 2 and 3 it has b^en Dicntioacd that a reinarls: was nientioncd in thc P. P.0. that ^oinc aniount was to bc rccovcrcd on account of excess payraent to the petitioner. It is the farther submission of respondent N|3.2 that fh.e pension case was 1 icvised and after revision fh4 reniark relating to recovery v?as 1 reinoved and after reinoval of tfae reniark the oetitioner has been fT!t®^?3i Al-Ht:-^2 '3'^!'^'TRRra, E?tl)'yi|<c, sn^rniT 1"q'lt^ 3Ti^{ ^-^i!ch tiS^ Vs:SWsS ^^ani ^ 31TOI TOIIWgf?? •!> paid fhc ainounts iacluding thi ia view of this afEdavit filed recoverv has been inade and =nNl<n^1T1 ^HPTcnf ^ 'fe^t i^l'^K ^•31)^311^1 pcnsion on 2.9.2003. Thcrcforc, (>n behalf of respondent No.2 no even pension aiiiount has been survives. Accordiagly, this paid on 2.9.2003, no cause of^ction. writ petition stands dispos^d of. Consequenfly, M.W.P. i-1963/2003 also stands dis^osed of. Sd/- L-C.Bhadoo Judse .-''A [•'fts^fig*