«' W'l'.ffis'Xtiia'i ftvtsion^nct'ir^rinttna^ I'.. . '• : :AT;jAB.a£PW ^B@^''^^ff:'l^^>"^'--^: ^^:.^l:l^,:^f^:Dfi'.i^-^'lI ^Bi&s'BM^^'ga^^ ^B^®s^lr@Mt'.:I>a].'^ :S[ge^:;5&.ye^ps:,?^$sident.Qf'' ••.;^ '•>•''..:•.' ^•^.•^•^\ -;-^-:.--.^-: •:••'• .r.-'' ' ~ " ^'':': ','•• ':-;:-'': •- ;B33?eQar;&,;Ssga:c';,^5^Satias®a? :.. 3 ?£®]stars.-,' BIiatrIc;fesSSj.saaadgasa;,; r»^..:'.:' .;'.1;;,.. ;.'/;^''.:::' :eEK.3^ts)' :':..^^y.'.^. .'E'iiS-igTA'ffi.M* M»BEfc; ; lMI»S': ss-. S^tSSQSSW ^SAL.«©aBBSBSe©E8^ A 1 !l 1 1 1 ^ XI-H(3-22^ ^^^iEiRRI, 'wAwis^&fflW^ iiKcn B)*(ra?S^:M.S^l:.^^:-^...l f^"?"-'—"-~'"f"<-^u''";g;r'••200' 'anSgig^, R'ii°ii?3]@g Nffl^J'ic^t & i:. I: 3)1^?r¥raiE8T^l ?f PTVISIOM BENCH : HON'BLE SBERt? &BON'BLESSEI P.BHADQO, :-^ t)HIRENDRAMISHRA,.N CmMm&LAPPEAllrIftXSOFM'SS Rosh Vs. Smt Hamida Siddiqui,,learned'cc|ur(setferttieappellgnt.;.,. SlTiri'U.N.S.fieo, learned AdditiQnlai^ Ptiblic Proisecutor wth/ShriD.K. Gwalare, Dy; GA for the; respondenfiStal: l.j;U JEOS.& Plrl-.C^Bhadoo,^ , By tttis appeal ;under Sectioii 'rocedur® the .g'ccuised/appellant;^^ correctness -ofthe judgment eif:cen%icjtion 12.t1.1597 passed: - hy^ Additidnat.- S^ KaWardha 'DiStrict Rajnandgaon. in; S.{ Additional Session Jtidge after holdjnj comrrfission.eifthe'Qffertce&ndersectiol' undergo imprispnme'nffor life and paj payment'offirie1ofUrth6ryn.derg6R;lfft)|r N' <=h(Aifo*Ili ^iiii^t^ fe<f^<fSi^,H, :, •,-''^'3]Nlt3IT^TII;;'' nl-a! Pra<iesh e. DGUENT 3006) 374{3).-of..the. GQde'of.Criminal; s . qu:estianed ,'the legality and and order W sentence' dated ission-;judge ^Khairagarh, Gamp, I'.iNo. 20/1997 wh;ereby^leamed^ I. th& accusea?appe:llaiit guilty for •302;ofttleWG^enteneed'hinif.to^ • 'fine. of, Rs. ^.l 008/-, in; default^of 'six.inonths.'''1''''-:1' ...—.." .-_-^. "•-.^' ^l^^sS :»J ,!%' i 11H ^\ '^ •;r:: '; :-.A M 81 w -ai ss t!12 ^•1;B a •K1 ^ss •^.ga XI-HC-22 Tg^ •<()<(w<),;anl*ilis:i'fiiiMl*jy. ^yr •qsra? _^CK]^:i. :-Sfc^-, Hweirwwgi M 200 ^s^ an^ST'^l K'tt'h Sf^S . ?t)*iich ^lli.fl prese^t hati 2... Case'ofths prosecution^isthat P-14 on 30.8.1986 in.pBlicestation'tSE tMat daywhen She was^goingto throw met her near the well and said that' ahd started dra§gingher. She objec^^ ^accompahyhim.Shefyrfhersaidtohf :the accused eontinuedto«dragher.At| .alias Miendiand Lalita^were also. to.call his father Parmeshsrar.'Therei there andtried.to rescue her on whi husband.by neck. 1-Ioweyer, she Accused pressed the neck of Parmest .uncenseious /and' feli. down. Roshajn oecurrence,'Af'tliat.tjme,;,JagdisH,Gt; the ..Qn receiving •thisvrep6rt Stati| -Sahaspur'tohara lefl •forthe-;sceneo|l P-Stothe.RahchaspreparedPanGhn^t •He took intp.possessiian^twp.JMeces deceasea yras sentf6r:.postmQrteme|>i Khamariya where;Dr. R;P._Sharma "examination an d submitted the,post bruises round ~the neck and ryht sj opihed'thatcauseofdeathwas-as|3h<i|5 R-17'-was:.prepared'tey the mvestij 'jnaesfigation chat^e: sheet was .fited jn| ' ^>1^[^i<fl1 •4i^^T^ ^l<rl <[^1•W.K • ^atiigiisn^i; :. • fW-10 Rai'nlKJnbsiilodgedthereporf [iTaspyrLoharatotheefl'ectthafori. |the garbage ofhertfouse, aecused i|er eloths are lying at his rssidience ;to this. andsaid.that she would not fm to .burn her cloths but even then Ithattime Ramkali, Puru, Rajkunvrer there. She asked her son Sanjay jffier her husband ParmeshMar came i[ih Roshan left. her and; caught her; snatched thi& club from Roshan., |iwarasar6sultofwhich|')ej3eeame flsd' away' from the seerte of al: and > Ramji were-also present [an House O'fficer of pglice station'' '.\:.^ :-.;^.. -! ;1,:1- ::.-;<'': '• '. ^ " occurrence and.after.:;givingfl.ptiee [maP-6.ofthe Jiody of Rarmesliwar. lof.bamboiyundsr. P-7. Body: of •tbia. 6amiBattonfo\PrimaiyHealfhee(itre [^PW-6 conducted the post'morteiit rsport P-6jn wtiich henoticed, |de oftbyFoiy>'cartilage;-:The.'3t!cfor ^ia.as.a.result ofthrottlffl'g, Site.plan jafing officer;^After com|9le{iorT '^of' the' court;MJi.«:tieialMagistrate;First ;[Tf^^f^ rrlortem iiSi IBBElHC-22' ^^il^f.: • ^ .•• ills" ~fss rf(i<(ici<t,, B>Ti1<Tf<is,; Js«*ii-y'i< .^Sfl^F^'q^.'., I.i.:;-_'-",.'. <M^.^^.^M & ^..^,.,^^...^^^^ Nrq?IT fl»«|cK ."ai^t^i ;)g:ng?ai^i SDHi^ •yfi^T t; Kb"& :SK K~ »Hil IRIll I'y !:;'it Class Kawardha ujio ;in tum committeiti Judge Rajnandgaon from ^ Khairagarh received the case on tra'nsfc 3: Prosecution in order to establist examjned ^15 witnesses m all. Statdr recorded under sectioft 313 of the Cocl^ tienied the prosecutiioii::evidence'appe^ innocence.and'false implication in thec^se 4. . ~LearneclAd(litional?Sessfon>fud! respeetive partles^cpnvicted ana, mentioned in paragraph'Qneofthisjud^ment sefltehced 5. We "have heard Smt. Hamida appeltant and Shri U.N..S. DeoAd<lition|al Gwalare.Dy.'GA'forthe resporident/Stat 6. HomisiciaT^death ofParmeSh*a| R.P: Sharma PW-6 who conducted th^ body. ofthe deceased has categoriieal 31.8.1996'at aboyt 1^0 a.m. fte had; that tongue ofthe deceased -was bi|uislT| the size <yf 1.5 x 1.5 c.m.on the right;:sj the.left side of fhBfleckthere were tKrt openjngfhe boclyitvi®sfoundthattrae( and^Black colour blood was presenfe. cfii^fe41rr ^i+icif-^ fe^t"tfspc5TC ^^lf'TOStl^y , the case to: th6 cQUrt: o-F'Session irn^cl Additjoria! Session- .Judge rfortriai. ^' the' i^harge again st. the' accysed menf ^of the' accused vres also of Crin-ilrtal Rrocedure in which he iring against him and pteaded his afterhearingt^e.coun^effQrth:^ th'e aecused/appetlant ;as Siddiqyi-teamed counsel fbr ffie •Pu&lie^Prosecutaranc!~5hri,D.K; is;not.in dispute; That. apart, @F, ^post mortemi: examinaSDn Qre 'tti® lly stated; jn flis ^evklenc®tKat-:Qn; . eor|ductedj:he posfmortem ahd'found arid?:sw611eh,,ther&'was ai bruise^in |dg;^th'& iieck.brown in c0lour;ion je ujses'Qn&abeveth&^other.Dn le^ancl.wind pipe.hetSame reddish lActedrding to. th.e\<:loo{oi-;;causg;bf' •^1":: :'"?'. ^•' ;••'^^'J.[^t^^Ra^ -iB,l DIS 'i '^,itl ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^l^^^^i^;'?'i@^^^^l^^sEffi^^s^^sss^E^ -^_~~'i XI-HC-22 's^ -iwiv'M,:wS^<is,,K<iawy.. 3fI^?T 1^; •irasiTajirai ^ 200 "f^i^r an^r^i p;-fi.+ %1§w 5ti^ yfsa % death vi@s asphyxia due to-throttling. dQctorhomicidal death ofthe dee'eased Tllusflrom.the abovesvidenceoftfifi lis^estahlished. . ."- -( Ramfbin ttiat slaid 7. .: As far as the involvement df -tt erime in question: is coneerned deceased has stated in her evidenGe aEicttherewerfetwo'ehiIdrenfroi'nthe of some dispute with Dilip,Kumar:sh| stSrted Iwing in her pareritat vilfege. Veerendra Nagar arid slarfecl residing she ^started living ^tH 'PaFmeshwar-l Parmeshwar for, about flve xears. house wttenshe 'Aas'comirig back fr-orti in h is house-'for three'aays, 'When .her did -npt allow.tQ: aeeompany her husband lodged.report in the poliee st^t the fateful day shs was going to accused met her neaFthe well and st-art< of her hand which was .witne.ssed by f Turtherstated thatshe.askedherson' call' his father and. when. her husbanl caught hold of the neck.flf hsr hysban') of wh teh he fel! down an.d' aceuseci' fl^< was caljed who afler exam'ining the d^ above evidence: of Ramhjnbai tias fe12 Bhuvan'-Marar in which •he;;h'at TlTelrea'fter, be^n <^i^Ttgp'lli ^i^tn?:,^ 1&<'£t[T<n>t^i< '^'3ipgi(3ii^[ ,•. . |ie:aceus®d.m\:cQminission-of the ' 1 "Bai. ,PW-10,. the wjte of ithe,". shewasmarriedtoDilipKumar we31oek; hbwev€r^oh'acc6unt ife'.lefi the-matrimoniat. hfouse- and ^ [l.evai^ Thereafter, she eame to lin the ^hdyse of Keshav and .then as ;his wife; Sh® resided with -, Roshanlal took fier to^hjs ).her|arentalhQuseancl^kepther; (tusbandwehtlo.take hei?, accused ParrBgshwar, flrilwhich her jtion.Amohttiortwothweafteron 'the garbage near -a well^.the jeddFaggingheraSercafchjng^ol'd tamkall, 1-alifa^artd PuruY She tias ^vrfio was a|ready..presienf^ to :cajwe .the accused left "her an.d aniEFpressed his geck'as a.result, id ""away; Therea'fter, Di:. Ch&nnau ^ IfeseasedSleclared' hjni dead;< :Ttie • ^;orrQb6rate<l;by;ihe:evide'no^of s|s(ed^ that 'on ttie. 'fateful day ,at • '•:•:: \ •":^; ^^'',:.'" ;^^\ :^';: :^^'^3^:. hiisbartd thrbw Stinjay fS :'t i L: l.'il 3?HC-22 SBT^r^iT W sn^r sh^l 'yf?n '35? '•arai^PT, a-rtlij'l®,I; ' li3TT^?T tl^F -^ lltlCTIShtllch 200 .3II^?I^IW^lfifT about 6 ajn.'when tte werrt'nearthel Roshanwas.dragging.Ramhinbai^Atl and he was Gbj.feetihg fo this acfof fli| caught hold ofnecltOf Parmeshwar the aecused r^n awayfrom the..plac| of Ram.hinbai vrfio had-oalted his village Kotwar. On the fateful day OFdertoan^werthecallofnatuFe.hl motheF. At that time his father cam^ Fnotherandcaughthis Nher.by which his fatherfell down'and diec| fhree.witnesses thede'tence has/not| which makestheirsfateinentSuntrust necK ".7 Inview ofthe e<idence ofal aecused in .icpmmitting the myrd( established, Therefore, We.are oifttl th6clinchtng^legaland^cu:lar;evtde^ trial Coyrf has rightly convicted thfr of the offence under seetioh 302 bft 9.: .Leamed^counsel fontlje ^apP prosecution has riot been 'ablff to:.ei deceaseciwith an interition'tacause ^h l<jiflifl^r *lj^^tT '4. 'ftT<rt' Tf^RSR: " ~ ^3i(^Fff:3fi^r., ' -' .Shiv Ofifalaya, tie saw that accUsed ItKat tfm'e' Parrrtesh\har VtSs.also th®r& i|& aecused^ln^Hie meanwhile RQShan .feS. a ,resuIt <?f whjch he N1 down and ;^ ofirTciderit. SanjaY PW-14, the-son . ;1|afher, Aas staited that accused is a vf\en Ke .was present near'th.elwell in ^ i^ saw ttiat accused was dragging .his 'there bn:^whieh the acpused jeft his ;and pressed.his neck'ias a result of' l.-ln the cmss;examinatt0n of thes& ,been a|:ile;1:o®licit_any,eirctimstance |:wpFthyorunreliable..,,;:'. , , ^ ; the J:hree wjtnesses complicity of the sr' &f' Panneshvrar by thrbttling is •consicletecl opifiiori fhat ih :view of ro6lofPW-10, PW-T2.artd PW-14-th.e iccusecl/appellaht for th^e eomroission i6ipe.'';., ,'i • -'::;'. ..••:;;'".:1' ^ftant argued that •from the facts the. ttablish-t^afSTeaccuseAthrfiftfedthg hts-.<tegth1..: 1^,:;' ;.,-'"'': "1-.1'- :'" • .. -: • • •V -['T^: ^To^ /£L £. XI-HC-22. '?Rg;-*ii'i)|et<<,tg'rtlwis^R<!ira1^' NrwiTaaww TR^ ...^:0 ^ 200 sn^T^i l<;-ii.=h'3l!^?[ sh^i^ yf^^T \- 10. W& are uhabte to acc®pt,(he'at the. app.eliant as: it has no substance Toj aggressive as he' wanted to take Swa'? iibjectecl t6 byher and'ffiat sKe.asKet fattier and wtten her husband ^.oame aoeusedlefi Ramhinbai an(J'cayght h^ pressgd itahdon account ofpressing] died spontaneousiy ;djj e. Ao asphyxia. was Witlarge tp cause death of.Parme|shwat" i|>ove''submission ofthe coynsjel for |-!the. reason'that accused was quite. Ramhinbaj by dFaggjhg whieh was : her son^Sanjay PW-14 to call fiis |there and started' inten?ening, the - kloftheneckOftHe'deceasedand |ofnecKParrneshvi@i':felltlbwrt'and 'herefor^, Jntention ofth®accused' 11;. fnr Ihe result, we' do :not'fini judgment of the' trial' Court. 'SsCordi _sub^ancgjgjjabfe to^b^dismissed; ]f i Sd/^ L.C. Bhadoo Judge ^i^i-^T •^i^i^^^T^I ^t^.K' • " : %3lSBII3l1^T '.'•-, any.iilegality or \in'firmiity -m the |ig)y. the "appeai being devoid bf ^t'feFeby.dfemissed^ Sd/- DIDBENDRA MISHRA Judge ,['[t^-'^f^: -•pi