HIW COURTOFOftlArTISSARHATKn.Aa'UR ^ . . • /• • . • ' • . Writ PetWon (ffl No. »rf Z005 Petitioner 7-, c-°- ^^^, ~^w f^ •^. Vinod ^Shcmid, 5/6 JP. Shwmf, eQed.-. f«ws, i.ab. Tedwiclan, EMstt. t-lospi'h»l,Ambil«ipur(Mjy ^' Versus; ^ss^f^ Respondent3_^^f v\ State of Madhya Pradesh, Medical Service, Satpuda Shav y^ 2?JoifrT@n'ec1@' of ^teaHti Serviws^Bifcspw OtVision, Bilaspur (AU») 3. Shri BhimsenMishro,Bio- Chemist',tlin>u^iChtefMedical Offiwr, Distriiet Hoqrital, Ambikapur,bistt.Str9iUo(M.P^ 4. Stute of Chhottisgu+i Through- The Secretary, Hedlth Services, O.K.S. Bhowian.Raipur. 5. t>irectorateof Mealth Services, State 6f OihtrM'isga+i \ Raipu' Shgle Beinch; Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sotish K. <<gnih0ri. Present: Mr. V.K. Pdndey, AdTOCoftefpr-the^petitioner. Mi'^&AU ^ibey.©oyernmeritAdyocatts for State/reiipondents No.2,4<nd5. : None^)pe<rsfpr responderitNo. 3. OR&ER ,", .. '••.',• ^ •, ;, : (Passedon21<t>uy<rfM<rcli, 2007) ,7hefolfciwin9orcter<^^eCoirt«wspnssedl^Safi8hK.<rtgn <^ < 1. By thls petition, the petrtioner^seeks pnmwtion to •the post of Assist<mt Mokn^'o Officeror Ko^eflustjnfhe BbodBarA wilfiolher cohsequential bemfits inctudi^ flxation of ^pension, ;on the bosis of wn^uential benefits wth effect ^ uflere promoted. ^ :s £NIWTTIS6ARHAT BILAS'UR (S) M>. 92 <rf20(B Vinod ShomKi, S/o JJ>. Sh( aged —.ye<«'s,,Lab. Tedif Oistt. Hospital, Afflbikapw (M v Versus. ^^^ 'S^HA.^^^^^^ Directfw Medical Service, Satpuda •5hawan,Bhop^ __ 2. Joirit Ofi'ec'Rroif Hea(th; Services,,Bilcespu' OwiSi' 8ilaspur(M^ ; 3. Shri H'timsehttishra, I Chemist, throt^lChtiR Offwxr, Oistrict ttosf Ambikapur, Distt. Sw 4. Stfl(teofChhfl(ttisg< The Seci'etory, Hea^ D.K.S.Bhawfan.RaiR 1 5. &irectoroteof He StateofaThuttisf R<Bpur, i )(j?Ble Mr. Just'ice Stttish K. ^gnUi; vf,, Adwcate for -the petitioner. / ibey, Swtirrnnent Advocate for S1' ). ' , . ; • ] i for respondenth^). 3. ' OR&gR ' i on 2trf Ocy of Ktorck, 2007? 1 BCourtwas passed by Sothsh Ki % pefitioner seeks pi'onw EBffica* or* Bio-Chemist in )he ^iefc.di^gj fixatipn ef p< WNh I effect 'from •th< ii li ::1 lil ;i '^ • :'' ^; 1 -:e !,]1I! ';";' Mi, !'B-%'ia& ::s *'i;<:.^-!il'^^-' ••;.:. '""'lti' S '"te....J^ '^ f^\ 2. The indisputabte fe^ as stc^d in •rtie additionat petiffn •filed by the S^rte/pespondent No. I is that the .petitioner wos oppointed as Lab Technician on 4.5.I9S9. By misfake the respondent No. 3 Shri Bhnnash Mishrc^wcBsh6wniflttegnldatipn)isto3Serid|^to. 9^ of birth as 1942. The person whwe ctate «)tbirt+t was 1942 wasyiot^ respondent No. 3 tMri- one other per^ Shn VifKid Kimiar Sh<rmo. T^ date of the bh^hof the petitioner fs 2M July, 1935 antl^icew retired writh' effect •from 31.7.1993 on (rttainiig the <ge of, SulWranrwatton. ' 3. The (^pondenf hto. 3 i^ <rimrHBdly appoirrted as Lab^^^A 2.9.1963 and was promoted on the p<wt of Lob Technician on 16,?.19'%, whenthepetitiwierwuscljrectlyappointecl dSLabTechnici<inon 4.5.1959. Tlieriespondent No. 3 Wfis further promoted to the p<at of BiQ-Oiemist ignoring tl'ie petitioner <tespit«the facf thatlhe petitioner uios 13 yetrs »niorto the resppnterrt No^3. The StcrteA^spondertts to retwn hns further stated thaf the petitipner can be (romofed on the post ofBw-chemist. f ••' . •• •• ..-. • . • 4. l^arnedcounsel appewing fprthe petitioriersub^ the MdhyaPrad^ ^blic Health and Ftmily^^W^ .-! • . .,-. ! /:< • .' ^-....., _^-. ,^ ^ ^ . ' ^^., ^ .y, ^ Minislwial (relpted to the &irectwate <tf Heolth Semice^ Service RecruH-ment Rules»I989^jprwKles for conditic^ of eligtbtlity for profflotton. Second proyiso to Ryle 14 cleorly (wovides that no junior pereon sholl be^consiclered W i^mbti^^in preference to the pewon seniop to him cnly <mthe basisof^his«OTpteting^^ sub-rule 1. The mocle of promotion js sehjcffity as admi respohdents/State. . Sli i.i.^ras 1 1\ f s 'y-s w^.a Ss^-^%&^ .,(iTOli».'?^.< il-.iSi'^^i?^'., 1 I'KiSIWK ;& 1h Subhash 5. Inviewofthe<rimittedf<K^^fftthepetiti6neru l3yeaw ./'. " re^nderrtNo. 3;Nfcohasbeen promotedm 12.7^988 tutha p^ Chentist. The petitionep js entitled to be<rt leort promoted wtir effe^ fnmi 12.7.198& l^rned counsel lappear^ foi* ^ ' t .. '.'••''.' ' .••'•• • .. •• • '...•••'."..•'.•' •'. ••..'. " . •• •• pi^ss for his pronKrtipn ^ior to that^a^ ali^riyretir^. The petitioner iserrtitledtoW pn the post of Bfo-Chemistand conaBquenrt'iat berwfits flawing from tiiis ontoinchidtrgfixatfonofpensiort<mdp<yaccocdingly'. ' < . •.•.'•." 6. ^s<iresult,thispetr(wnisdkWedtotiieab<^extefrt.^^^^ costs. Sd/- ;•.... Satish K. AgniIiQtn Judge ^. -R'iaNa