%} HQGH $GUF§ @fj CH§€£§?T§§C§A§H‘ 8%L&$?QR WEST PETiiiWgN §$i NG. $33312G1§3 @ETITSG’NER NR Gurud Slo DR Gama A/a 55 yea‘s, We 9adhaswam: a*sa.,a Bhawan, Kainagah ranan, Na;pur, Tahsi! aad Disiyict Raipu; (C3) y‘ERSUS Sime af Chha’ttisgarh Thmmh Semetary, Depafmcw ~‘ Damhaqa and i‘iufg UvVélOpmci'H, L}.K.a. Bhawan, Mankamya, Raipu: {136.} Chief ExeCiii’ive Gfficer wafmad Paachayag, Besk Fmgesnwaa Tags! Raj§m and Emmi ma Jr (u u.) 3. BR. Sam 3m RR. Sahu, Afa 55 Years R/o S.ub DivSiona; Gfféce?, rum Ewwreeuxg v M395 mnpw Pancnax aL, Dormioha a Dlswct Burg (09.) WRS? §3ETW§§N UN§ER QRTaCLE 22E SFW‘E Q§N$T§TL5?EG§\§ QF mi‘b'k Azanaafame: M“ Fwmeh Shrivastava Advacai’e fOfthe netita‘oner um Q K vhshr Panei Lawye fm ,W Sg‘i‘. w aw qce c “W v %E$PQ§\3§ENTS A“ M: QRAL {ERQER {gm 2.291%} SiJNii. KUMAR §§NHA¢L Heard on admission. PetitEoner- NR. Garud §$ a Sub-Engineer. He was haidmg ‘frze chm'ge of Sub Divisicriai C’Tirer (RE8).7Janpad Pammyai Fingeshwar. iiy We W‘pLgmeQ order dated M OV 2mg (Annexuw? 1; he WD seew fraxisaerred a3 §r c‘wayge $wé Duiswm Officer xREb) horn Jang3a§ aachaya’: Vmgesnwa: to Janpad Panchayaa Bhasrawgarh Mr. Sh‘rwas’rava submrg ihat me Detme'ne‘r i$ pat§eni m Hypertens m and Anemia iherefcne fi vowel be dirhcu‘* Tcr me netmsmer i0 go on trarVSfer He aSso argues iwat an mquiw was comucted by “me, txecutivv h! qmeef on a cembiamt but the netuicm: wax mt fauna gmity, avers auer ma: he has been transmwed fgom h1$ preseni mace 01 posting to Bhaifamgarh. i Eurmg the caurse v3? argamerst, it imnsp‘ared tha’c tif’ze peii‘iionei és Qosted in Fingeshwar since, 01 $8.05, as on M.G6.G5, a iecai shifting was maa‘e arid he was traaaferred from one office ta ano‘har ofa’ce in \"\~4«\F£?igesaxniar itseif. \r \\ ..\ ‘ 5w ') k W WW1” PETETEQN ($1 Nil $§S3IEDW So far as, me grounds of Hines's are concerned, they cannot be emeriained by the Cami 0f iaw far setting aside the order of iransfa of an employee, who is working on a iranSferabie posi. As far as meiafia‘es are cancemed, i do no? find preeeni to be a case of meiaficie Ii“ has not been disputed the? ihe pets‘tiooer is wwking on a Transfer is an incidence of service. No person working on a traosferab§e posi. ig'ansferabie posi can make his ciai'm for posting at a particuiar pEace. Jt is for the empioyer io see as to who should be posted at which mace, keeping in mind the heifer funetioning of i‘he depaiimem es also the puios'ic Unieee the order of traoefer is shown to be viiiaied .foy maiafédes or extraoeous eonsiderations or it ie shown to be passed agains‘i any stamtory Ruie or the Act, oormaily sue‘n orders are no? to be totertered by a Court of law, is the settiect View or: the Aoex Court in marry oases‘ interest. t3or the foregoing reasorts, I do not fmd any substance in the I The oetttion, therefore, is tiebte to be dismissect and re hereby wot petrttorr. dismieeed summarily. Sd/- Sunil Kumar Sinha Judge