IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT : THE HON'BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR.J.B.KOSHY & THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE V.GIRI THURSDAY, THE 1ST JANUARY 2009 / 11TH POUSHA 1930 WP(C).No. 30605 of 2007(R) -------------------------------------- OS.2/2003 of DISTRICT COURT, THALASSERY .................... PETITIONER(S): ----------------------- 1. E. SIVAKRISHNAN, S/O. GOVINDAN, SECRETARY,KOTTAYAM THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA KSHETHRA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, TELEPHONE MECHANIC, JIJIVIHAR, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM,THALASSERY TALUK. 2. V.C. SASHEENDRAN, S/O.SANKARAN NAMBIAR, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA KSHETHRA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, BUSINESS, SHANKAR NIVAS KUTHUPARAMBA AMSOM,NARAVOOR DESOM,KUTHUPARAMBA(PO) THALASSERY TALUK. BY ADV. SRI.P.N.KRISHNANKUTTY ACHAN(SR.) SRI.MOHANAKANNAN RESPONDENT(S): -------------------------- 1. KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, REG.NO.1861/99, BUILDING NO.74, WARD NO.IV, KOTTAYAM (MALABAR) AMSOM, DESOM, REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT, M.K. RENJITH, S/O. DR.PADMAN, ADVOCATE,PRABHA, KUTHUPARAMBA AMSOM,NARAVOOR DESOM,THALASSERY TALUK 2. M.K. RENJITH, S/O. DR. PADMAN, PRESIDENT, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, ADVOCATE,PRABHA, KUTHUPARAMBA AMSOM,NARAVOOR DESOM,THALASSERY TALUK 3. K. KUMARAN MASTER, S/O.KUNHIRAMAN, TRUSTEE, S/O. SANKARAN NAMBOODIRI, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, RETIRED TEACHER, TOP HOME, MANGATTIDAM AMSOM, DESOM, MANGATTIDAM P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. W.P.(C) NO.30605/2007 4. C. GANGADHARAN, S/O. KUNHIKANNAN, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, RETIRED TEACHER, C.K. HOUSE, KUTHUPARAMBA AMSOM, MOORIYAD DESOM, MOORIYAD P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 5. P. PAVITHRAN MASTER, S/O. GOPALAN, JOINT SECRETARY, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, TEACHER, POOKODE P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 6. M. RAGHAVAN, S/O. KRISHNAN, VICE PRESIDENT, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, PREM NIVAS, KANATHUMCHIRA, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 7. M.V. GANGADHARAN, S/O.GOVINDAN NAMBIAR, TREASURER, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, PENSIONER,SREENILAYAM, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 8. K. RAMADASAN, S/O. APPA, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, AGRICULTURIST, SIVASAKTHI, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 9. K.K. DAMODARAN NAMBIAR, S/O. GOPALAN NAMBIAR, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, AGRICULTURIST,KALATHIL VEEDU,KOTTAYAM AMSOM,DESOM, KANATHUMCHIRA, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O.,THALASSERY TALUK. 10. SHANKARA VARMA VALIYA RAJA, S/O. VASUDEVAN NAMBOODIRI, TRUSTEE,KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, NO OCCUPATION, KIZHAKKE KOVILAKAM,KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O.,THALASSERY TALUK. 11. SREERENJINIAMMA RAJA, D/O. KOCHUMALU THAMPURATTI, TRUSTEE,KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, KOTTAYAM THEKKE KOVILAKAM, RAROTH AMSOM, KADAVOOR DESOM, THAMARASSERY P.O.,KOZHIKODE TALUK. W.P.(C) NO.30605/2007 12. KERALAVARMA VALIYA RAJA, S/O. RENJINIAMMA RAJA, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, BUSINESS, KOTTAYAM THEKKE KOVILAKAM, RAROTH AMSOM, KADAVOOR DESOM, THAMARASSERY P.O.,KOZHIKODE TALUK. 13. RAJARAJAVARMA THAMPURAN, S/O. SANKARAN NAMBOODIRI, TRUSTEE,KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, AGRICULTURIST, KOTTAYAM THEKKE KOVILAKAM, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 14. SUBHADRAMMARAJA, S/O. SANKARAN NAMBOODIRI, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, NO OCCUPATION, KIZHAKKE KOVILAKAM, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 15. RAVIVARMA RAJA, S/O. SANKARAN NAMBOODIRI, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, KIZHAKKE KOVILAKAM, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 16. SATHEESHAN, S/O.SANKARAN NAMBOODIRI, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, NO OCCUPATION, KIZHAKKE KOVILAKAM, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 17. V.H. SACHIDANANDAN,S/O.ACHUTHAN NAMBIAR, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, BANK EMPLOYEE, KALATIL VEEDU, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 18. K.K. SARASAKSHAN, S/O.RAMADASAN, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, PHOTOGRAPHER, BHAVANA PHOTOS, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 19. M.V. BALAN, S/O.KUNJHANANDAN, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, BUSINESS,VAYATHIL VEEDU KUTHUPARAMBA AMSOM, MARAVOOR DESOM,KUTHUPARAMBA PO THALASSERY TALUK. W.P.(C) NO.30605/2007 20. E. VASU, S/O.ANANDAN, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, NO OCCUPATION, NANDYATH VEEDU, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 21. ANIL KUMAR, S/O. RAGHAVAN, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, NO OCCUPATION, VAZHAUYIL PARAMBATH HOUSE,KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 22. K.P. REJENDRAN, S/O.NARAYANAN, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, NO OCCUPATION, PAIKKAD HOUSE, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KUTHUPARAMBA P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 23. C. VIJAYAN, S/O. SANKARAN, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, VIJAYA BHAVAN, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 24. N. BHASKARAN, S/O.KUNHAMBU, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, KIZHAKKAYIL VEEDU, PATHIRIYAD AMSOM, PARAMBI DESOM, MAMBARAM (P.O), THALASSERY TALUK. 25. P.K. RAJENDRAN, S/O.KRISHNA KURUP, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, NO OCCUPATION, KRISHNA VILAS, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, ERUVATTY DESOM, KOTTAYAMPOIL P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 26. M. MANOJ KUMAR, S/O. KUNHIKANNAN, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, NO OCCUPATION, MEETHALA THAYYIL VEEDU, KUTHUPARAMBA AMSOM, AMBILAD DESOM, KUTHUPARAMBA P.O.,THALASSERY TALUK. 27. PADMANABHAN, S/O. SANKARAN, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, NO OCCUPATION, SHIVA SMRITHY, KUTHUPARAMBA AMSOM, AMBILAD DESOM, PALAPARAMBA (P.O), THALASSERY TALUK. W.P.(C) NO.30605/2007 28. VIJAYAN BHATTATHIRIPAD, S/O. M.C.V. BHATTATHIRIPAD, NO OCCUPATION, TRUSTEE, KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, ANJALI,KUTHUPARAMBA AMSOM, NARAVOOR DESOM, KUTHUPARAMBA(P.O), THALASSERY TALUK. 29. M.K. MUKUNDAN, S/O. GOPALAN, GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEE, GOKUL STREET, KUTHUPARAMBA AMSOM, NARAVOOR DESOM, KUTHUPARAMBA (P.O), THALASSERY TALUK. 30. U. VIJAYAN, S/O. KUNHIRAMAN, NO OCCUPATION, TRUSTEE,KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST,KOTTAYAM AMSOM, ERUVATTI DESOM, KOTTAYAM MALABAR P.O.THALASSERY TALUK. 31. P. RAJEEVAN, S/O. KRISHNA, TRUSTEE,KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, NO OCCUPATION, KUNNUMMAL VEEDU, KUTHUPARAMBA AMSOM,AMBILAD DESOM. 32. V. JYOTHI BHAVA, S/O. NANU, TRUSTEE,KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, NO OCCUPATION, JYOTHI NIVAS, KUTHUPARAMBA AMSOM,AMBILAD DESOM, NIRMALAGIRI (P.O), THALASSERY TALUK. 33. T. SURENDRAN, S/O. KUNHIKANNA, BUSINESS, TRUSTEE,KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, SURABI, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, POOKODE P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 34. K. PRAVEEN KUMAR, S/O. ACHUTHAN, NO OCCUPATION, TRUSTEE,KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, MOOLAN SADAN, KOTTAYAM AMSOM, DESOM, KUTHUPARAMBA P.O., THALASSERY TALUK. 35. M. SHYAM PRASAD, S/O. GOPALAN, NO OCCUPATION, TRUSTEE,KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, V.G. HOUSE, KUTHUPARAMBA AMSOM, AMBILAD DESOM,THOKKILANGADI PO NIRMALAGIRI, THAMARASSERY TALUK. W.P.9C) NO.30605/2007 36. VEERAVARMA RAJA,S/O.SREEREJINIAMMA RAJA TRUSTEE,KOTTAYAM SREE THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA SAMRAKSHANA SAMITHY TRUST, KOTTAYAM THEKKE- KOVILAKAM, RAROTH AMSOM, KADAVOOR DESOM, KOZHIKODE TALUK, THAMARASSERY P.O. 37. KERALA KSHETHRA SAMRAKSHANA DISTRICT SAMITHY (REG.NO.142/77), REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT, PARAMESWARAN NAMBOODIRI. 38. THRIKKAIKUNNU MAHADEVA KSHETHRA SAMRAKSHANA SAKHA SAMITHY, REGN.NO.857/83, REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT, E.VASU,S/O.ANANDAN, PENSIONER, KOTTAYAM MALABAR. 39. DILESH KUMAR P., ADVOCATE COMMISSIONER, DISTRICT COURT,THALASSERY. ADV. SRI.K.MOHANAKANNAN FOR 7 TO 18,36 SRI.A.MOHAMED MUSTAQUE FOR R2 SRI.M.K.SUMOD FOR R2 SRI.B.KRISHNAN FOR R3 & 4 SRI.R.PARTHASARATHY FOR R1 THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 01/01/2009,THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: W.P.(C) NO.30605/2007 APPENDIX PETITIONERS EXHIBITS P1:- COPY OF THE ORDER DT. 11.8.06 IN IA. NO.2349/06 IN RFA. 382/06 OF THIS HON'BLE COURT. P2:- COPY OF THE ORDER DT. 17.10.06 IN IA. 2349/06 IN RFA 382/06 OF THIS HON'BLE COURT. P3:- COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN TR.P.C. NO.294/06 DT. 13.2.07 OF THIS HON'BLE COURT. P4:- COPY OF THE ORDER IN IA. NO.2349/06 IN RFA. NO.382/06 OF THIS HON'BLE COURT DT. 12.7.07. P5:- COPY OF THE AFFIDAVIT FILED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT IN SUPPORT IA. 1308/07 IN OS. 2/03 DT. 30.7.07 IN THE DISTRICT COURT, THALASSERY. P6:- COPY OF THE COUNTER AFFIDAVIT FILED BY THE DEFENDANTS 3 & 17 IN IA. NO.1308/07 IN OS. 2/03 ON 13.8.07 IN THE DISTRICT COURT, THALASSERY. P6:- COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE DISTRICT JUDGE, THALASSERY DT. 20.8.07 IN IA. 1308/07 IN OS. 2/03. P7:- COPY OF THE ORDER OF THIS HON'BLE COURT IN IA. 3234/07 IN IA. NO.2349/06 IN RFA. NO.382/06 DT. 7.9.07. P8:- COPY OF THE REVIEW PETITION FILED BY THE DEFENDANTS 3 & 17 AS IA. 1485/07 IN IA. 1308 OF 2007 IN OS. NO.2/03, DISTRICT COURT, THALASSERY. P9:- COPY OF THE ORDER DT. 4.10.07 IN IA.1485/07 IN IA. 1308/07 IN OS. NO.2/03, DISTRICT COURT, THALASSERY. P10:- COPY OF THE MINUTES OF THE TRUST DT. 12.2.07. P11:- COPY OF THE MINUTES OF THE TRUST DT. 8.9.07. P12:- COPY OF THE NOTICE ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT HEREIN FOR CONVENING OF THE MEETING OF THE TRUST DT. 8.10.07. /TRUE COPY/ P.A. TO JUDGE J.B.KOSHY, Ag.CJ & V.GIRI, J. =========================== W.P.(C).No.30605 of 2007 - R =============================== Dated this the 1st day of January, 2009. J U D G M E N T Koshy, Ag.CJ. This writ petition is filed contenting that orders passed by the Commissioner are in violation of the directions of the Division Bench of this court in R.F.A.No.382 of 2006. We make it clear that orders passed by Division Bench will be binding notwithstanding the orders passed by the Commissioner. We are not expressing any opinion regarding the merits of R.F.A.No.382 of 2006 in this writ petition. Accordingly, this writ petition is disposed of. J.B.KOSHY, ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE V.GIRI, JUDGE bkn/-