IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.15952 of 2009 1. NAWAL KISHORE RAI S/O LATE GOKHUL RAI VILL- GONAULI, P.O. BETTIAH, P.S. BETTIAH, MUFFASIL, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 2. PRAMOD KUMAR TIWARI S/O SRI KAMESHWAR NATH TIWARI VILL+P.O. AHWARSHEKH, P.S. MAJHAULIA, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 3. AKHILESH RAI S/O SRI JITENDRA RAI MOH- SUPRIYA ROAD, BETTIAH, P.O. BETTIAH, P.S. BETTIAH TOWN, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 4. KASHI NATH PRASAD S/O SRI GANESH SAH VILL- GAHIRI KOTHI, P.O. VICTORIA MISSION, P.S. NAUTAN, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 5. NAND KISHORE NARAIAN S/O LATE HARI MADHAV PRASAD SAHI R/O SAHI SADAN BETTIAH, P.O. BETTIAH, P.S. BETTIAH TOWN, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 6. SURESH SHARMA S/O SRI RAM NARAYAN SHARMA VILL- CHHOTA BANGARA, P.O.+P.S. SUGAULI, DISTT. EAST CHAMPARAN 7. ARUN KUMAR PRASAD SINGH S/O LATE RAM CHANDRA PRASAD SINGH VILL+P.O. MANGALAPUR, P.S. SANGRAMPUR, DISTT. EAST CHAMPARAN 8. SMT. SARSWATI SINGH W/O RAI YATISH CHANDRA SHARMA MOH- SARISWA ROAD, HARBATIKA CHOWK, BETTIAH, P.O. BETTIAH, P.S. BETTIAH MUFASSIL, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 9. JAIDEEP KUMAR S/O SRI SARYUG PRASAD MOH- KOTWALI CHOWK, BETTIAH, P.O. BETTIAH, P.S. BETTIAH TOWN, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 10. SAMMOD KUMAR S/O LATE GAURI SHANKAR PRASAD VILL+P.O.+P.S. CHANPATIYA, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 11. PRAHLAD PRASAD S/O LATE RAJA RAM PRASAD VILL+P.O. DHUM NAGAR KACHAHARI TOLA, P.S. NAUTAN, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 12. AMOD KUMAR S/O LATE GAURI SHANKAR PRASAD VILL+P.O.+P.S. CHANPATIYA, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 13. ARUN KUMAR SINGH S/O SRI SHAILENDRA SINGH MOH- UJJAIN TOLA, BETTIAH, P.O. BETTIAH, P.S. BETTIAH TOWN, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 14. SMT. MINAKSHI SHARMA D/O LATE JAGGANATH RAI SHARMA MOH- HARBATIKA CHOWK, BETTIAH, P.S. MUFFASIL, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 15. INDRASAN PRASAD 'NIRALA' S/O LATE NANHAK PRASAD VILL- KHAIRATIA, P.O. BETTIAHDIH, P.S. MANUAPUL, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 16. NAGINA YADAV S/O LATE RUDAL YADAV VILL+P.O. TELUAN, P.S. NAUTAN, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 17. SUDARSHAN PRASAD YADAV S/O SRI RAMCHANDRA PRASAD YADAV VILL- NAUTAN BANARAHI, P.O. +P.S. NAUTAN, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN - 2 - 18. BHARAT PRASAD S/O LATE RAM NARAYAN SAHU VILL+P.O.+P.S. CHANPATIYA, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 19. UMESH PRASAD S/O LATE MAHADEO PRASAD VILL+P.O.+P.S. SUGAULI, DISTT. EAST CHAMPARAN 20. HARENDRA GIRI S/O LATE SARYUG GIRI VILL& P.O. CHATIYA MALAHI, P.S. MALAHI, DISTT. EAST CHAMPARAN 21. RADHA KANT SINGH S/O LATE RAMANANDAN SINGH VILL- PATANI, P.O.+P.S. RAMGARHWA, DISTT. EEST CHAMPARAN 22. PANDIT PRASAD S/O LATE SAHEB SARAN PRASAD VILL+P.O. CHAUMUKHA, P.S. YOGAPATTI, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 23. RAMASHISH PRASAD KUSHWAHA S/O SRI YADU NANDAN PRASAD KUSHWAHA VILL- GURCHURWA, P.O.+P.S. MAJHAULIA, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 24. MANOJ KUMAR KUSHWAHA S/O SRI CHANDRIKA PRASAD KUSHWAHA VILL+P.O. TADHWA NANDPUR, P.S. BAIRIA, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 25. SURESH SINGH KUSHWAHA S/O SRI RAM CHANDRA SINGH KUSHWAHA VILL+P.O. TADHWA NANDPUR, P.S. BAIRIA, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 26. DILIP PRASAD S/O SRI KAMAL MAHTO VILL+P.O. TADHAWA NANDPUR TOLA DIHI, P.S. BAIRIA, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 27. VISHWANATH RAM S/O LATE CHANCHAL RAM VILL+P.O. BAGAHI BANJARIA, P.S. BAIRIA, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 28. BASISTHA NARAYAN S/O RAMKUER PRASAD VILL- KESARIA, P.O. D.K. SHIKARPUR, P.S. SHIKARPUR, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 29. PRABHU NATH PRASAD S/O LATE LEELADHAR PRASAD VILL+P.O. BALTHAR SIKATA, P.S. BALTHAR, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 30. DHARMENDRA PRASAD S/O SRI BENGA SAH VILL- BALUA RAMPURWA, P.S. BAIRIA, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 31. PANNALAL PRASAD S/O LATE RAM DUTTA ROUT VILL+P.O. MATHIA BHITAHA, P.S. BAIRIA, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 32. RAMASHISH ROUT S/O LATE GUDAR ROUT VILL- BUDHWALIA, P.O. TELUAN, P.S. NAURTAN, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 33. SUDAMA PRASAD S/O LATE RAM DATTA ROUT VILL+P.O. MATHIA BHITEHA, P.S. BAIRIA, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 34. GOPAL CHAUDHARY S/O LATE KOSHIL CHAUDHARY VILL+P.O. BALUWA RAMPURWA, P.S. BAIRIA, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN - 3 - 35. RAMLAGAN YADAV S/O NARAYAN YADAV VILL+P.O. BHANMELAHI TOLA, P.O. MAGALPUR, P.S. NAUTAN, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN 36. MADHOLAL SAH S/O LATE RAM NARAYAN SAH VILL- HINGLAKAR, P.O.+P.S. SATHI, DISTT. WEST CHAMPARAN Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR 2. PRINCIPAL SECRETARY HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT DEPTT., GOVT. OF BIHAR, PATNA 3. DISTRICT MAGISTRATE WEST CHAMPARAN, BETTIAH 4. DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER WEST CHAMPARAN, BETTIAH 5. BIHAR SCHOOL EXAMINATION BOARD (HIGHER SECONDARY) PATNA, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY 6. THE CHAIRMAN BIHAR SCHOOL EXAMINATION BOARD (HIGHER SECONDARY), PATNA 7. THE SECRETARY BIHAR SCHOOL EXAMINATION BOARD (HIGHER SECONDARY), PATNA 8. MAHANTH RAMROOP GOSWAMI MAHAVIDYALAYA TARABAGH CHHAWANI BETTIAH, WEST CHAMPARAN THROUGH ITS SECRETARY 9. THE SECRETARY MAHANTH RAMROOP GOSWAMI MAHAVIDYALAYA TARABAGH CHHAWANI, BETTIAH, WEST CHAMPARAN ----------- 3 17.3.2010 Counsel for the petitioners is permitted to add Director, Bihar School Examination Board, Patna as respondent no.8. Let him do so in course of the day. Heard counsel for the petitioners and the counsel appearing for the State. Petitioners claim, to be the teaching and non-teaching employees of Mahanth Ramroop Goswami Mahavidyalaya Tarabaghj Chhawani Bettiah, West Champaran. Their grievance is that - 4 - the Managing Committee of the college after coming to know about the decision of the State government regarding payment of grant to unaided College is trying to change the list of teaching and non-teaching employees working in the College. Persons, who were not earlier, appointed and working, their names have been shown in the list and the petitioners, who were working since the date of inception, have been left out. As stated in the writ application, in this regard, petitioners have already represented their case before respondent no.8, Director, Bihar School Examination Board, Higher Secondary and that is still pending for consideration. This application is being disposed off giving direction to the respondent no.8 to inquire into the matter before finally recommending the list of teaching and non-teaching employees to the State Government for disbursement of grant in favour of the college in question and while - 5 - inquiring into the matter the respondent no.8 will find out that which of the teaching and non- teaching employees were earlier being paid by the Managing Committee, through its’ Bank Account, since the date of its inception. That will be sufficient for finding out the claim of the petitioners as well as claim of others, whose names as per statement finds place in the list. Pending representation of the petitioners must be disposed of by the respondent no.8 within four weeks from the date of production/communication of this order. (Mridula Mishra,J.) A.Kumar