HYQH C(EUWE’“ GP FMér€ATT¥§f$é$§M A? $11 AfE-FUQ Cwimimd Ammm§ Nu 3% OT aféi Appm ‘ ANT $§7ivmndar§ Mamr £gad abou’r W" year‘s: (in Jaii} 31% Fuisai WO Viiiage—Emr'adc, Cimky— Kw'r‘; ii‘ FE 3.—;3m=mgarih, i"} i5‘i“ix-?<ci§gm*§; (ca) Versus RE§§3ONE>ENT Sim? 0f Chhaf‘riggarh’ Thrm;c;§*g— Smfion Hausa Cf'Hcer‘ P.$.-- 5:2rcmgami DisftRaEgqrh ($6,) (KIRMENAL A..E¢§. UNDER SEGIQN 374 (Z) OF THE CODE OF CRIMINAL PQOCE‘DUQE”, 1'???) Presenf: Mrs. Swim Tiwarif gouns£l far the. aplggHant . Mn faiamkaj Shrivnsmvu, Panei iawyar‘ “for “Fhe $fnTe/m$punden+. ‘ Simk Bench: Hmbm Mn T}? smma J. QRA L JMDQM FNT {Paggad a“ 12"“ “ca"‘by T’mm a , bvwv, By +his ageaii +hs3 appeHanf has chalEamggd Jrha iegaiify mad praggrie-ty 0f Tha judgm‘an‘r at? cmvia‘rim anti mder 0f genfence dmfad 18.5.2G€§7 pn§sed by The Addi+ioml $egsions Judga; $mngarh, in $essions Trmi $19.136/2005 whgr‘eby fha iegrned Addifiom! $55$ians Judge after hakiing The acausad/czgypdlam guikry far 'rhe affenca pun‘ishabia Lmdar Serfim 306 9f :Haz Imiian Perm Carla: sznfemzgi him *m undargo rigomus imgrisanmen‘? for .5 yacir'e's and “m my :FEHe. nF RslQQGiMn in dafmli’ m? paymzm 9f fine 1m furfhev Lmdgrgr; rigomus impriggnmew for 6 momhs. 2. Tine, judgman‘r of sonvicfim §s ahuHangzd cm the ground “may? wéi‘hmuf Thar? bging any maenf Md cradibi'a evidame, Tha ”Ma? cam“? 10m cianvic‘rad anri senfemgd Thg agmalkzn‘? as nfammantionec?’ and fhemb mmmifwti dwgal mg. y §“{{ J dI‘ 3 fiase af 1%; pras&sLwien, in hrigf; San a? +he appeuam namely Kanhaiyalai wag married wifl'! deceased, $ukhma+i wEo was rgsidimg wifh ‘Hw appellam and Qfihar‘ co~acau$ad in har‘ mQTrimgnial harma. Agcnwri «Shivmndan who is fa‘rhar—in-iriw of iha deceasad is behaved mwardg his daughmwmumw was indaceM and many i’ima$ he usgd. To gamer in ‘rhe: mom 0f Th3 daceasad $ukiamm: wifh inmnf “m mmmi? $axuai EnMmoursg 9r m gufmge her- modasw 23nd awed “m harass and Torture his daugh‘i‘gr—iwkiw Ac: <1 rawh of we?! 3mm3$ and mvmr‘e emé indemm‘ behwe 0f “irhe. appeliant SLE§<hmsx+i ccammi*1'«£d su.c.da m1 WIEWTG“ by canmamhg insactisidca Merg (aw ragigt’rzred Vida ExsP/m and PQ/iil. Invasiiga‘fing #ficer Lef‘r for the «ena- m" mwrmme .and g‘i‘er gimng natim fa the w§fna$$es Vida ¢¥Pf3, he nwzpared ingues‘? {EXP/2) (war *hg bad)! mc $u¥¢hmmi Dead bed-y 0f Sukhma‘ri was sen? far aumpsy “m Wimary Haal‘l'h £enfre, Sammgar$1 whgra auimpsy m? daad bad)! 93f §ukhmafi was conduc+ed hy fhre, mam 9f the dac’mr wda Ex PARA. Dr‘. 9%.K.Manhar {Nil/~12) wha htis mnducfed m‘zmpsy has agiylad ‘é‘hm’ dam?! wm due mrdia regpim‘mry arms? as a msMf of consuming paiscm. Her visczrcz ware, pre‘ervgd‘ Ome packe‘f 9f insgaficide (hm?) and soi? of The mam Where slag mmmi‘rmd smiaiée: ware se%zed Vida EXP/4v Spa? map (EXP/5} was" preparzd. Visgem W23 5aized yic‘a ExP/i‘i?‘ QM The basis m‘ mergaimimmim, PI” Elk. RIC? was Iadged. Vigrgm wam ssen—r for chemimi axamim‘rim vide. EXP/15L 4-. f§ffar rgmrding Tha s‘rafemem‘ of fhe. wifngcvws umtier' Sediam 1531 of 1&2 (inde of Crimim! Pmcednr‘ei 1973 and after tzemafe‘rion i cf invasfi5afian, charge shaaf wag: fihed 5n The Cam"? 9f gradicial Mogisfmi'e Firsf Class, Samagar'h WM in 1mm mmmi?‘md fha msg +0 fha Caur‘f a‘f $essio§n$9a§garh fram wharg “my, §ddé+imu§ $24<Ion< Judga‘ Samugnrh recgh/ad fha staring nn 'Irmnsfer for WinL g w "w 5, In order m wave fhca guilt m? The agpelkmwzmcwed, Thea pro5lzcm§0n examinad ag many :13 i5 wimasys. Smfamgm 9f The amuszdlctpga?!an+ was racnrdad undar $acfim 3L3 9f fha CPPLZI in which he denigd flag cimumg‘mnces appmr’ing againsf him and inmaema and faisa impiicm‘im is g kaded‘ 7.. Laurnad Addiféonal Sassigns Eudga affer affgrding an ngwri’uniw 9f hgar‘irzg in The. respecfive parfigs, canvickd and sen'rzmec% The accusadlappaHmf as aforemaMioned and acquiffed The. afhzr cm-ascusad Le. hugbarpd 0f flag dgcmsed Kanhaiyala! and mc%her—in~!uw of ihe' dacemsed. 8. I have: heard? Mrs. Salim Tiwari, cmmsyl {0:1 the appallanf and Mr. Pmkaj 5hrivas+ava, Pang! ‘awyar for ihea shite/respondanf and perused fha judgmgn? impugngz£ and macaw! of the. friai anur‘r, 9. Lmmad munsa! far We appeikzm ssubmi‘rs that The! pmsacufian has mf adduced any cmdibhz and almahing avidgnca against The Qgpeilant The appaHaM is *flnn fathar-in—kaw 0f Tha dacensad. Ha hag no? mmmimd any affensav His behave. was nof irra‘gcant He has no? gnfared in fhe roam of fhe. dacaased wifh an infanf To ou‘rmgz her modesty or he has no? ‘h‘igd 'm commit sexuai in‘rameursa wifh ‘Hne decaased’ Evidence adduaed on behalf 9f the prcsecminn is m3? suffician'f fm‘ warrant convic‘tion. i0. On ’rha o'rhear- hami, judgman't impugnad §s suppgrmci 0w beha!f 9f ‘Hw $Ta1‘e/mspondenf and gubmi'rs *thm sfatamems 43f $0mL: Ram {PW-1), fmher m‘ fhe. daceasedf Kar'tik Ram {Pm/‘2), grandfa’rher nf the. deaeaggd, LaliT Rvm {PW—3), Dhzmsa§ Pam! {PW~4) and Phulsai (PW~1G) am sufficianf far drawing infarance Thcn' 1.1m appaHam used To go insida me room 0f we; daceaged mirth imam m oufmga her madagfy and as q msuh’ 9f indecan'r behava of the. appaHan‘r, shea caumpaHad to summit suicide. 11. Abmrma! deafh as a resulf m‘ consuming gaison i5 not dispufzd an. behalf of ‘rha agpgilan‘r. Aka wharwisé asmbiished 33y the smfamems trf $anau Ram (PW—1), Kar?ik Pram {PW-2, Lnli‘r Ram (PW-3), Dhcmsai Pate! (PW—4) and Phulsai {PW—10) and Dr‘ M.K.Mmhar (PW—12) who has $fm2d fhm en 27.1.2005 he condmfed amopsw of fine bady 9f Sukhmafi and apined ‘Hnm‘ deufh um: due m cardio regpiramry arr-e55? as c: resuh' of mmuming paisgn. By these evic§anca, mmncrfum! and abmrmmi damh is astawished The prasecu?ion has also adduced Thz avidanca 1m fha affzc‘r that? 1’he daceasezi Sukhmnti has . uu .wwm‘g mg; cgmmifmd guiakia by anmvming paigmn. Cammissim inf Euiciafé by 5!.5ki'ama‘fi m no? éispufgd‘ 1,2. In tarder +0 apgmciaw 'Hm canfeni‘ims of feamed mlms'e! far +ha ar'fies, I amminad the evidencg rgmr‘dgd 4m bahaif of Thz prrmecufinn. mm; izam {PW—1L fcrrhar 9f +he: deacaased, has giafed in hSg avidmcg ‘fhtz‘r fhe nppa§§an+ mad hi$ wife, MS draugmar- were: always wed f0 insuH and abugg ‘13 U) The dawusad. H2 has suggayrad rhg agpalhn? amt}. his 3m MT fro harasg haw daughmr mid finaliy her daughwr mmmi‘rmd suicida. grandfa‘r5ar m“ The deceasad, ha$ sfu‘ted in his gmgddagghfar had mfd him thha‘r the appelian? usad Te fha fimg 0f her- $iaaping wifh imam :m cammi? sexual (mm m m a? fima m He: hag gist: wand mat Karfik Rnm {PW-2) evidenae that h is an‘rer in haw mam 41? inmmour-se wifh her as N "0&2?! m‘ wch u Lu mdecan? bghawe m? ”the, apgaeihnt, 0mg. dmewad has; leff fiae housz of 1m? ‘ nppgihnf and she. changad ha!" decisian m fha cacéyicz ’sf this wimess and other Qnm and Phuis'ai. Thay wen? m villdge $0§mda Wham Sukhma'?!‘ tow, fhem maf 1w” fwhar-m-law had gn‘rwed in hm mom far mmmifting $exucd infemggma wifh her. $mmmanis af' Lali‘t l§nm (PW~3), Dhanmi Pam! (PW-4} cmd Phu§sai (PW-10) had $iappar1ad the $Ta1‘aman‘r‘bf Karfik Ram {PW~2}, Phukui {PW~1Q} persans. La!” Qam (HIV-3) has aiga $fczfzd “that :mce he was caiied by Kar+§k has aha smfed “Wat gm ‘i‘ime ha wan? m fhe house gf Kam‘ik Ram Wham Sukhmmi ‘mlci him fhm‘ the cgpellan'!’ $ukhma‘i‘i aicngwii§1 has em‘e rad inim har mom far aommi?'ring imgmaursg and evan The aggpe§§nnf has mughf bald ha!" hand H9 has; aisa smfad +ha+ after 4 i0 Ev mnM’h“ 0f the aHgggd wrmwm' Sukhmafri mmmiwezd suicide. Dgfancw has cm$s—sz><amined Thgsa wiwaggs a“? bu“? dafanca hcm n01: been (“Mn t alisif gawhing in weir (grass? §mve wpecifmaw sm‘red ‘é‘hcgf #ha appalinnf whm is :Fafhgémin-Eczw 9f the deceased 5nkhmm‘i has Triad +r gammh‘ sexual infarmurge wif£iw Mr and wéfh imam :m mammif such offence, he. hm: enfamti in The ream m‘ {Sukhmcrti Whig?! she has: appesed and we?! she ca¥§ad fha parsons and ”Mac! T53 leave *r‘he hmsa 9f 'Hnv appéihm, bu? cm #hz advimz a‘f hm” grandfwhgr—Kqr‘Hk Qam :ané miéer §em+h u .., zamimi'ian Ta Liismrd 'fheir %es‘fimonyV 0a 'i’he afhar hand, 11h aga' wifngsséas g§ wi‘massas, §ha Md rum- .kzf? the Muse nf The, appeihat TM appeihm WM $3 fafher-En—iaw m? {the dgcgased 5ukhmaf5 was undar an ahiigairion t0 “avg anH secure the Me af her daughter—in—law and To pmfec? hear bu? msmad of dischargiryg his mom! and iggai ablig-.?icn, 'fha appailom' has Triad m dighmor haw and Tried ‘m cgmmi? §exual infarcourse. wi‘rh her. Tha (sppellm‘r is ma? sTr-angar and he. 5s fm‘her-in-iaw Le. fa?hgr of bar husband (inc? unwarramed and indacen‘r behave of ‘Hae appelizmf bamma ulfimatha muse far *rhe ch‘mmi$sien 9f hem Suicide. 13V The wifngsses adduced oh bah-11% 9f fha prgasgcgman are mgfrimoma! ralahyes (if The decaassid $Lskhmm'iv Deceasgd died WHhm .7 years 0f hear marriagea, bu? +ha. ralcz‘rives 0f The dacaased hat} no? ieveHeii any charge 0+ demand m‘ dowry again?! The: appalicm't and 9fhgar ca-nc d who had baa}? aégui'rted by fhe. «friai mum‘ i’hmigh 7&2 same was easih’ availabia 1m thase wh‘n‘gssas. In msz 0f falgg imgiimfion they have alsa mt? made my gran? aikgcrrian' ugainsi: any co-accused. If appears from ‘irha smfemenfs m’" Kariik Ram (PWQL Lam Ram (PW-.3}, Dhansai Pare! {PW-4) am! Phul$ai (PW-10). ‘Thcv? when indacen? behavigr 9f her fa'rhgr-in—law bemma inmQerable h) *Ihe decmsad than she: was compaHzd to caH her grandfmhar Karim Ram and E Kar‘hk Wm (PW—3) wan? f9 thg hguse of ‘P‘h‘a apgahzmf and fhg dacenwi" dang wi‘rh Mher a'far'esaSd wifnesssas Wham sha 'roid Th2 45m? T9 fh‘am which wgg‘ , mrmaliy no? passiblz 1‘s» ngrmTz by daughfer-in~!aw ‘m any penann induding her paranm! rala‘hvas against? her fzz‘rher—in—hw aspaniahy when a? fhe 15mg 0f narmfing such aiiegaficm fhe c§gcgnmd was‘ 4.~gsi:.:¥ing in The: hause 9f ‘Fha v qpgailam wifh fha agpallm? and aisa residing in the heuse cnf The appeliah‘f along wii'h appallanf fér 4 Ta .6 mah‘rhs ”Hi3 her- dea‘rh if? shsws :rha? m apfien axcepf m fake swma hare from pawn-m! (rela‘tivas) was 58f? wifh her and her Pakwives and anm‘hgr mamhgr sf +ha sncig'ry had tried T9 has??? and rasehza fhe pmblam. Thadefance haw my? suggeshzd fhex wifnrass‘s; in #hair cross-exammafian Thai? i‘hgy are having imamsivdnvss 0r anmi‘ty M1??? hog appeilan? Mam» The appehanf and on the basis 01F any sugh anmiiy they have made- falsa aiJegafian agaiinsf the appelian‘t. m a " * d M‘ “3M * zia,z\1g%w‘e'éz.r%ém~%wj a? we nnngmm‘f. r 4 my F. y <imighfw~irw=§aw am mi? {zma 'm lgw? Y‘hgii‘ mw‘rHm‘Wd hm“? or ”m Ma in fae.r mc+2“m! hwgg when ‘rhey . 3a wishers m “w aw? § . am§ crawfua‘r M “W a t swmw§ di‘ffimi? acmd inhiambiei “é“?wim 3M fhe “ommm‘er‘ suiakiae a appEHm? wininch 2.35% {iiré ia ‘rha wmr1wsv‘r 9f Suia3t§a 153. Affar- gppracia?iag 'E‘ha mvMm ig m rawrd, +‘ wax/isms! fha amai?an? ¥m~ ‘rhe, affama mmsma‘la whim" Smaafwn 3021 rm? 1&39 . ‘ d? £9nyic?§0:a r4 msazj m arzdibig cw} raiiatia ¢ar4£ma 5W!WE£'?$:3;1 ég QIMmmQbia. a”? samame is: mmmmgri, fag T‘réa! mgr“? ‘vx; {.mr $Em3 5x, 9 J»: m.-- h“: $e“mf §3 m1?" $+mmah rig is fai‘hrzrwin—igw .. qim‘wwl aha mm mdar rm 3?:4h3 wiw-«hm, hm a‘S‘ww 9f savimg mm gammmg $73 mmmi? saxum iafercmwsa aw ‘m Ema n waf'zm i’éqe mhw‘éw? and imdecem‘ bahavg 91F QM): hm {iaughWr-iwimg, ”raw aawsadmiapaHaa? Exea n9? aw-W aw camcassim. 1 y 3&‘ wvmsgqugmiyi film 4;}pgai haarg dawid iii? Wrr‘ i Ewia w ha d§$m§35gd 1?. ‘E—akig'ag im'm I?D “x x .9 ? a a p .‘ ‘. *4 a W r m. r