425 ClN03425 of 2006 I 4 IN ll Ill lllGl l COUR Ol PlJNJA13 8 I IARYANA AT Cl 1ANI9IGAR11 CRN03425 of 2006 Dccidcd Oll lS2010 1 r SanmatiMatri Scwa Sangh Petitioncr 0 0 I Vcrsus 9 I SanmatiVimaJJain Public School Jagraonand antIlhcr Z CORAM4IONBlE MR JUSTICE KC PllRl I 08 QO Prcscnt Mr M1aggar Scnior Advocatc with 7 lvlr CS3rar for thc pctilioncr Z Mr SumeetMahajanSenior Advocatc with Mr Sl13halla Advocatc 179rrcspondcnts tl ICCePURI This is a civil rcvision pctitiontllcd by lhe pctitioncrundcr Artlclc 227 of thc Constitution of India againsllhc ordcr dated 15A006 vidc which MA No 13 of 2432003 was disnlisscd scckinganlendmcnt of thc judgmcntand dccrcc datcd 17 2001 lll Civil Suit No4 10 of 10 101994 Rl3 No56 1997 litlcd as Satiinati Vlmal Jain Public School JagraonVS Sanrnati Malri SelovaSanghIRegdI Jagnlonby ihc Couri of MsJatindcr Walia PCS the thcn Addilioilal Civil Judgc Sclliot IOivisitonl . uma 2012.08.21 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigar h JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 2 426 CR11103425of 2006 2 44 Jagroanon the that thcjudgincnt and dccrce datcd 1732001 is nettherbasedupon thc compromisc nor Itl accordancc with the dircctionsof l lonble Mrs Justicc BakhshishKaur rathcrjudemcntand dccrcc is bsed upon the praycr madc in thc plainl Ihc said praycr was bythe writtcn and thc praycr cannot bc nladc thc basis of the dccrcc 1 r whcn the naturc of dccrcc is to bc passcdin accordanccwith thc agrcemcnt 0 ofthc ofthc parlies 0 I Thc appearcd and contcstcd thc said application on C5 thcgroundthat although thc form ofjudgmcntand dccrcc is based upon containcd in thc plaintbut il cannot bc saId thal salnc is nol based Z uponthc and is againstthc dlrcctionsof l lonblc MrsJusticc 2 r Kaur lherc is nothing prcjudiclallo lhc intcrcsts of the I or dcfcndantsNos3 to 7 againstwhom thc suit was withdrawn 08 hey thcrcfore praycdfor disinissalofthc applicalion 1m3 Aftcrhcaringthe lcarncd counsel for thc particsthc lrial Coun Z dismissedthe said holdingthat lhc said amcndincnt is beyond tl thescopeofthc trial Court dissatisflcd with lhe abovc said ordcr ofthc trial Court lhepetitioner hasprcfcrrcd thc instanlrcvlsion pctitlOll I havchcard learncd counscl for the particsand pcruscdthe caseOle In thiscasc SanmatiVilnal Jain Public School flled suit forgrant01 pcrpetual injunclionrcstriiiniilglc dcfcndanls in any manncr with thc cxclusivc pcaccfulclljoymcnl or claimingblockingdislncntalling or coinmitting any dainage Or . uma 2012.08.21 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigar h JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 427 CN03425 0 2006 3 P Ivasteor raisingany construction in any l7Irinwhatsoevcr over and on the ofthe ln Khasra No005 shown rcd in the sitc plansituatcd ttl lagroanor causinganv such lhingto bc donc cithcr by themselves or throughthcir agcnts scrvants cmployccsassignccs and also rcstrainingthe dcfcndanls from realizingany rent ofthe r shopsofthc plaintiffschool from anyofthc tcnants 0 AND C I also lor thc rendition of account and to pay thc anlount found 0 duc thereaftersuch account l n thc said suit not cvcn a singlcWltness was I Slated to be produccdl lowcvcr according to thc petitioncrin thc bcst Z lnterest ofthc School a was effectcd which was rcduccd into L writing and terms ofthc arc as undcr l I ll lhal the flrst party6 Sannlati Vimal Jain Public Schooll a5 OO adnlitsthcsccond party6SanmatiMatri Sewa Sanghlto be thc 7 OW11Cr of thc 1and dcnotcd bv Khasra Nos003 and 2005 Z situatedat Tchsi l Road Jagroan Agwar Gujjran Jagraon including theshopsSadanMarkct 011 grottndOoor IIl hat thc enlirc uppcr store ovcr thc SadanMarkct on thc 1100r chsil Road JagroiinPlaygroundsbounded as East Raikot Road Wcst 1 Shopsof Sadan Markct Nollh and South l lall alongwith thc cyclcstand uptoMunshi Ram shail remain vcstcd irrcvocablyfor all and intendivith thc and shall bc uscd forthc purpose of runningof thc school Saninati Vinlal Jain Public SchoolJagraonwithout any intcrfcrcricc and hilldtallcc by tllc . uma 2012.08.21 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigar h JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 428 1 CN03425 of 2006 4 4 sccond party tIIII That theparticsshall rcnlaill bound bythc agrcemcnt hc was placcdon lhc rccord of thc file of the civil suit on 43 1998 111clcarncd trial Court dismisscd thc suit as havingbccn bccome tm C iilfructuous on 2431998 in vicw ofthc The 0 socictyfilcd Civil Revision Pctition No4385 of 1998 C I undcr Articlc 227 0fthc Constitution of India challenging C5 thc ordcr thc suit as infructuous This Court in said Civil Rcvision NoA0385 01 1998 dccidcd on Z 24 2000 sct asidc lhc ordcr datcd 2431 998 passedby 1 lrial Court disillisslngtllc suit and rcmandcd thc case to I the trial Court for passinga dccrcc Otl thc basis of 08 r kccpingin vicw provisioilsof Scction 23 7 Rule 3 CPC lllcrcaftcr lll coInpliancc with thc order Z dalcd 2412000 lmcxure l21 passcdby thc IIigh Om Court thc trial Court has drawtl thc dccrcc dalcd l732001 as undcr This suit has comc lor Ilnal disposalbefore lllC Sh Ajaib SinghPCS Civil Judgc Junior 19ivisionl Jagraon l Il thc prcscncc 01 ShVK 13ansal Advocate plaintiffin pcrson Sh R 00r Advocatc counsel lor dcfcndantsNo 1 and 2 suit agaiilstdcfcndantsNo 3 to 7 is dismisscd as withdrawtl l t is hcrcby ordcrcd thatlllc suitofthc plaintiff as . uma 2012.08.21 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigar h JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 429 CR11103425 of 2006 5 H4 pcr directlons of I Ionblc Mrs Justicc 13akhshishKaur JudgePunjaband 1IaryanaI IighCourt for pcrpetualinjunction reslraining thc defendants in any inanncr intcrfcring wilh thc cxclusivc posscssionpcaccful cnjoymcnt or asscrtingclaimingblocking or 1 COlnllllttingany damagcOr wastc or raising any 0 conslruction in anv l orin whatsocvcr ovcr and on thc J C I propcrtyof the plaintifl in Kllasra No 2005 C shown rcd in thc sitc plan attached situatcd at village AgwarGuljranJagraonDistrict ludhiana or causingany Z such lhingto bc donc cithcr bythctllsclvcs or through thcir a r agcnts scrvants cnlployccsassignccsattorncysand also I rcstraining thc dcfcndants lrom raisingany rcnt of the 08 11 shopsof thc plainliffschooI from any of thc tcnants As 7 also for thc rcndition of account and to pay lhc amount Z and found duc thcrcaltcr such account is dccrccd on thc Ll basis of lxCI kccpingln VlCW of thc provisions of Section 23 atIdOrdcr 3 CPC I Iowcvcr this dccrcc shall havc no cflcct Oll 1hcrightsand oIvnership of anv owncr 01thc propcrlyin disputcbcinggrantcd on thc basis of coinprolnisc 111 VICW 01 the rclicf soughtby the plainlif hc Icarnedcounscl or thc rcvisioilist has subtnittedthat drawingdecrec is a ministerial acl which Ilas lo bc prcparcdby thc ministerialstaff The said dccrcc hasnot bccn dr2iwnin accoldailcc with thc . uma 2012.08.21 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigar h JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 430 9 CRN03425 o f 2006 6 1 A directionsofthc lligh Court passedIll rCVlS1011 petitionNoA385 01 1998 1hc suit has nol bccn dccrccd Oll IllCrll hc tri211Court should havc obscrvcdthat suit standsdccrecd in tcrins xC Sincc thc dccreehas not bccn draw in accordancc wilh thc dircctions of thc I ligh Court the decrcc4101dcrarc harassing thcjudgincntdcbtor time and again m r Shri I SGrclval PC2S CiiIil JudgcIIiiillct passcd 0 ordcrundcr Ordcr 21 Rulc 32 ClC on 162003 thc rcrisiotlist has to C I prcferCivil Rcvision No 2745 of 2003 lll this Court and that revision C was acccptcd on 7 12004 vidc Anncxurc I3 hcrcaftcr againan I undctOrdcr21 Rulc 32 CP has bccn Illcd which has bccn Z dismisscdvidc 0rdcr datcd 122006 passcdbythc lllcil Civil Iudgc6Scilior DivlsionlJagroan he rcvision pcliliotlagainstthc said 01dcl llas bcen I llled by thcSchool ist c5 Il is contcndcd lhal in acl Shri Vija I is thc brain bchind W2 all thc wllo hasalrcadybccn rctllovcd br thc Scllool 1tust VijaI Z Gocl has fllcd scparateSUll claimingrightto run thc school and sought againstlhc hc has disillisscd thc applicationSo pracr has becn nladc lt thc dccrcc itl accordancc with thc coinprom isc allcr scttingasldc thc ordcr dalcd 243003 scckingalncndlncnl of thc judglllClll anddccrcc datcd 173OOl in the civil suil Ilc praycr has bccn opposcdIt is sLibmittcdthat Court has bccomefunctuousofllcio aftcr passing of the judgnlcntand dccrcc and the same cannot bc amcndcd Thc decrcc has becn passcdin accordanccwith thc coinproinisc Mcrc Illct lhal 21 Rulc 32 CPC has bccn . uma 2012.08.21 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigar h JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 431 CN03425 of 2006 7 dismisscdprcviously is no groundfor amcndIncntofthc decrcc lt is flilthct contcndcdthatlhc pctitioner has violalcd the dccrcc and application undcr Ordcr 21 Rulc 32 CPC Ivas lilcd whicll ivas dismisscd Ioytllc tiial Court Thc rcvision agamslthc ordcr datcd l 02006 disinissing thc application underOrdcr 21 Rulc 32 CPC has bccn prcfcrrcdwhich hasalso bccn hcard m I earned counscl RIr thc has relicd upon authotitics 0 State of Puniab VSe Darshan Sinlh 1200411 Suprrmc Court Cascs C3 I 328 and Plasto Pack Mumbai and another vse Ratnakar Bank Ltde 0 420011 6 SuprctneCourt Cascs 683 I 1 havc hcard Icarncd counscl l or thc particsand havc gonc Z through tlle rccordsof thc casc V r It is adnlittcd casc of thc particslhat SLiit l7r pcrmancnt I injunction and rendition of account was fllcd by Schclc1ItLlst iil Ivllich no 08 cvidcnccwas lcd but howcvcr as pcr coinprotniscfor lhc best intcrcsl of W7 lhc institution thc illattcr was lhc dcltlilcd cfIIhich alc given Z abovc lt is also not dispulcdthatprevitlusly an Lindcl COrdcl21 Qe Rulc 32 CPC was Iilcd which was acceptcdby thc trial Court vidc ordcr clatcd332003 but lhtlt ordcr was sct asidc b lhc I IighCourt in Cilril Revision No7450 2003 dalcd 71004 It 15 iiIso not disputcdthat thcrcaflcranothcrapplication undcr Order 21 RlIlc 32 ClC Iilas Illcd which hasbecn dismisscdvidc ordcr datcd l 02006 passcdbylhe lrial Cclurt and reVlS1011 againslhat ordcr has becn Illcd Vidc Illo scparatejudgmctltof CVCll datcthat rcvision pctitionhas bccn disinisscd In thc inilial slage lllc SUll ofthc lolaintiffwasdisinisscd vidcudgnlcntdalcd 2431998 passcdby lhc trlal Courl Ill spitcofplacitlgon rccord tllc cotilrclillisc lhe dclailed cf . uma 2012.08.21 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigar h JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 432 C211103425 o f 2006 8 1 which is givcnabovc Allcr that plalntifIsocic Illcd Civil Revision NoA385 01 1998and thc ordcr datcd2431998 was sct asidc and this Court vidcjudgmcnt datcd 241 000 dircclcd thc lrial Couit lt dtilnvlllc dcClCCin accordancc with order 23 Rule 3 CPC lhe drawingof a dccrcc 1S lllillistcrial act 1r So far as thc rcliancc of counscl Ior thc rcspondcnl on 0 authorityStatc of Punjabvs Darshan SgWs oisc lsuptl is conccrncd 0 I thatauthority docs not hclpthc casc Cl rathcrhclpsthc casc of C5 the petitioncrIn the said aulhorityithas bccn hcld thatministcrial act can I bc rcctiOcd bypassing ordcr Z So lar as thc rcliancc 01 counscl Ior lhc Oll 2 r authorityPlasto Pack Mumbai and anolhcrs case supral is conccrned I thatauthority ls also not helpfulto thc casc ofthc rcspondcnt as in that casc 08 It has bccn hcld th2il Sccticln 152 CPC ctrllloll bc uscd R3ralnctldincnt of 7 dccrcc so as to add to or subtract thc rclicf carlicr grantcdlhc ptcscilt Z pctitioncrhas not prayedfor to add or subtract thc rclicf gratllcdto thc dccrcchold cr hc rights o hc partiesaic 17IlcIitlgIlcltlllllc and lhc tcrins of which arc mcntioncdabvc 1hc trial CCIUrliS bOundlo draw thc dccrcc lll accordanccwith thc comprolllisc hc dctailcd of which is givcnabovc thc lrial Court has lallcll into crrOr bynot acccptingpraycr of lhc prcscntpctilioncrin alIowiilgthc dccrcc to bc amcndcd in accordatlcc witll lhc tcnlls Jf lllc dcctcc 1llc tldgllctltdcblcli has not prayedlor dclcling 2111vrcliel uriilted lo thc dccrcc4l0ldcr as pcr tcrms 0f thc coinprornisc aild thc onlypraycr nlade bo it Iliill is lc dtaul llle judgmcntalld dccrcc ill ltCCOrdanCC will lhc lcl177s411lIlC . uma 2012.08.21 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigar h JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 433 0 CRIlo 425 01 2006 9 1 So Ill thcsc cI rcLimSlaIlccS thc lillpugncdordcr distnissing tllc applicalion for corrcction of judgmcnt and dccrcc shcct slands sct asidc by acccpting thercvision 1le trial Court is dircctcd to draiv lhc llcsll jtldglllCllt anddecrcc in accordailccwilh lhc tcrills c1cclmproIllisc A copy of lllis judglllctllbc sctll lcl lllc lriill Courl I strict 1 CL coinpliancc 0 0 I 1 1 C5 J lJllG K Januaryl4 2010 Sv Z 3 r I 08 00 17 Z C1m . uma 2012.08.21 14: 51 Scanned True Copy of Original PHHC,Chandigar h JOYTI RANI 2016.03.28 16:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document