® o HON ‘ BLE S. B. 1w TH_E HQN‘BLE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASP&_ wRIT PETITION s No. Q“’$ ”’i 2010 PETITIONERS: I 1./ Vipal Chandra Nage, S/o Late Shri Hemnath Nage, Aged about 55 years, Post Lecturer, Posted at Government Higher Secondary School Ghatlohanga, R/o Village Kalipur, Post Dharampura, Tehsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, C.G. ILK Gajanand Mishra, S/o Late Shri B. Mishra, Aged about 58 years, Post- Head Master, Posted at Government Higher Secondary School Dharampura, R/o G/39, Dharampura, Tehsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, C.G. / 3. Ram’ Patl Dubey, S/o Late Shri Gopi Nath Dubey, Aged about 54 years Post Lecturer, Posted at Government Higher Secondary School Kilepal, R/o Village Kodenar, Post Tokapal, Tehsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, C.G. 4. / Shaikh Shaabuddin S/o Late Shri S. Allauddin, Aged alhout 59 years, Post Niyanar, Posted at Government Primary School Hirmapara Sargipal, R/o Choubey Line, Pratap Dev Ward, TehsilJagdalpur, District Bastar, C.G. PR Pmmaht£dam§w No %33g U W1“ .5. %70 “/Smt Rawley Post Nutan Lecturer , Aged Malika Posted about Rawley, 55 at years, Government W/o Shri B.K. datedc19r‘w‘e Higher Secondary School Niyanar, R/o Mother Teresa ward, Near Chopda Mill, Jagdalpur, District Bastar, C.G. V 6. Smt Subhadra Singh, W/o Shri M.P. Singh, Aged about 55 years, Post Head Master, Posted at Government Primary School Patnampara ‘ Sukma, R/o Preeti Jagriti Bhavan, Shanti Nagar Sukma, District Dantewada, C.G. 7. Smt Leelawati Kashyap, W/o Shri Fagnuram Kashyap, Aged about 55 years, Post Head Master, Posted at Government Primary School Dokrighat, R/o Near Bhagat Singh School, Pathraguda, Jagdalpur, District Bastar, C.G. Smt Vijay Shrivastava, W/o Shri Dilip Shrivastava’EAged about 54 years, Post Head/Master, Posted at Government Primary School Fraizarpur, R/o EWS 29/30, Housing Board Colony, Bodhghat, Jagdalsur; District Bastar, C.G. , h Ramprasad Yadav; S/o Shri Itwari Ram Yadav, Aged about 60 years, Post- Head Master, Posted at Government Primary School Dhobiguda, R/o Vijay Ward No.2 ,Jagdalpur, District Bastar, C.G. Balram Bhatra, S/o Shri Laxman Bhatra, Aged about 57 years, Post- Head Master, Posted at Governmeht Primary School Kuruspai, R/o Lalbagh Amaguda, Jagdalpur, District Bastar, C.G. Smt Saraswati Thakur, W/o Late Shri Laiit Thakur, Aged about 54 years, Post- Lecturer, Posted at Government High‘erSecondary School Ghatlohanga, R/o Village Parchanpal, Post Mongarapal, District Bastar, C.G. 10./ 1 1 RESPONDENTS: 1/ Ministry, D.K.S. Building, Raipur, C.G. The Assistant Commissioner, Tribal Welfare Department, Jagdalpur, District Bastar, C.G. 3. /The District EdUcation Officer, Jagdalpur, District Bastar, C.G. 4. f VERSUS State of Chhattisgarh, Through the Secretary, Department of Tribal Welfare, W WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INIA D The District Education Officer, Dantewada, District South“ Bastar Dantewada, C.G.‘ i”! ‘ IGH covRT OF CHHATTIsGAH AT BILAspu une enc Hon bie Mr usfnc Prmnker‘ Diwak rn‘ amon o 67 9 o 201 ITNRS ITIOE 7 % H é R Sgi Bh J er ' W P S N f 0 pcd hand a age & ofhe' Vi C N _ rs. $PONENT5 , D r o‘ewa'nan counselfor e efii'ianer' r Sumesh Baa, Govf Advoca e for The Sfa’r T R L 6 F TH ONSTITUTION OF .01 l h‘ fhe consenf o, Te earn'counsel aearin fo f$ The pefifio’n is" heard finally. earned counse or Te e‘nl'loners sumrl’s Tal T p ppld my Af Th a a o s — on r‘ea‘hon Affer- comle’hon o ‘p pd h p d g py calel of Rs 9 300 He rfhe ‘ Isu vol ed m The case as as To wheTher The pe‘hTIoners ar nTITle To reuar a scale WITh eecT ram The daTe o T ppTT f pl f pb pd Th ld h dd ly h hya- e Issue Invove erein was conSIere a Te Mad des TaTe AmmlsTraTlve .rluan abaur far shor .‘ o aukanl' Yau and ers vs STaTe ofM & oTers werein IT was held TaT T h e ld g py le ‘ ‘ ers ar enTITe Toreular a sca lap ' Thr p‘ p TmenT. e‘smqTTe wasrTaken ie L l f h p b h h5 . e‘h‘honer's were acm‘e Inall as sslsan'l’ eacer on ‘ ed py f R 100/ pb p f‘ robaihon erio fe eh‘honer's were gmm‘e reular a s 16 fur submlls fhal lhe se m es; ed gl py ff f f‘ 1 m aommen er aTer comehon o roaflon erio 1am o hhaf’risar'h and’ofhe' 5 f Cg rs. M AlkDg h ps M JJ e WRIT PEITION UNDE ARTICE 22 O E C INDIA O R D E4§ (241L2G) f Wh f h léd' ppg r ah S d Tbl Jlp ( T/ l ,A N 2745/89 (Mdh d 56 r. h h) h h he ‘ effecf tha’r fhe Teacher's/Assistant Teachers are en'hTe egdlar' pay scale fr‘cm da’re of mrhal appm‘ ’ : In iew of fhe above submisswn ma e by learned counsel for fhe par‘hes ’rhe wm’r pe’rmon ls dls osed af m 1‘ ‘ler‘ms 1e ‘lhe e’rrhoner's are grant p e rere I S enlahon 1f so advised To conslde his case cm is ow and in H’s erspec‘llve If Th pe‘l lioners sfancl on ‘le SAT m Madhukan‘l e ae fool’m as er order passed by ’ adu (supra) and s sequen‘lly confirmed y le Supreme our“? in Secml Leave Pe’rmon (CIVII) No 6892/93 by orde al 3 1 1994 ’rhe pe‘h‘honers may be en‘h‘lled To 5am l7. . r? h a id TO r Tmenr : v e sme liber‘l‘ ’ro make a y p , t n p e h sm g p r' b b h V u C p r e elf rae‘ Sd/— Pritinker iwaker u ded accordingly D Jdge