ITIN 3 No.4446! 01 acut 4 Jatswa Centr Badesali a aawa DiStrict Karea Ver us S ae of ha h roug 1 t l 1 t I Q ! t 1 RIT PETITION ND L 2 AN 2 OF ’ CONSTFLTEON OF MDt ppearance ' r e ) R $UN J d E Peitiuner- a umar aiswa is worin on the os reseer In Primar ea entre B d t 20 has been trnsfe r Badesalh io atodl on aministrative groun L arned counsel for the petitioner submits tat since etioner has made a complaint against resonent o as been transferred from the said place therefore e orer o ransfer is Viiae malafides He submits ta e Wife o etitioner is working as a Lad Health Visitor in Badeeani an p y lh d se has o e transre r ad th it ld b tit t o tfer H py , n 5 § ecretary, mas Hea%t, .K.S. BFaWa atpu oilectm, Korea, Baikuntpu C hr ‘ C d ffr, hief Medlcai an Health Oice istrict Kerea (BaiigA n‘hpur Kulur Block edlcai ic i hadgaWa ic hada Kgwa ”g Mr Parag Kotecha Counsel forthe petitione iMr R Tripathi Panel Lawyer forthe Stat - ORAL ORDE “ i , (12 08 2910 IL K MAR $INHA l Hear l l t R] K Jl kg pt of D y Hlth C adesalhi By the impugned order ed 28 07 10 he arred fom a ‘. h als ben ferd fom Besalhi to Sonhat, erefore, wou e difficult forethe peioner o go n rans. e refers‘ to the olic of the Government in which, it has bee WRIT PETO 0 i Ra; Kumar Jaiswal aged b 2 ’years S/o Late Itaram l Dresser Primary ‘Health e, h, Th il Khdg,“ PETITIONER l 1 i I ‘ e i } UNDENTS 1 Stt Chmsg r, thh its ’ S Mt of; h D n Rr D ) b Gffer TahSl K, Distrt Korea W UER ARTtCE 26 D 27 THE ‘ A A m i t Kgh d ds h the , pit pd N 4 he " h th d f t ttd by ht th f the ‘i ); o.4‘ms kep a one place or at nearb e p rform their duties convementi ! o far as the ground relatin to alaflde is concerned c? maeria as een paced on record t‘ show tt in fact th ( M d sh 1' " ‘ Iad h t d 4 z e ltloner that smce when the petrtroner posted at Baoesa: ubmitted that the petitioner rs postedtthere Since a ver Ion u r l J:frlef edical an Heaith Officer K rea Balkunthpur ha lsse te ransfer orer on the behest ' f respondent No 1 - On being porntedly asked from Tamed counsei for th rt [J ' I There ts no dtspute that the petitioner Is osted on ansferable post Transfer ts an Incrdence of servrc ne transferabte post can make hrs claim for postin at a arttcular place it ts tor the employer to see as to who should eeprng m mme etter functlonrn f the hepartment as also the publrclnt ‘ t § ‘ls sown te vrtlated maiafr‘des or extraneous conSlderatlons or rt Is shown to b assed agamst any statutory Rule or the Act normally such rders are not to be mterfered by a Court ot law Is the settle iew of the Apex Court m many cases ltn the present cas no malale as een emonstrated therefore “ Unless the order of tran , e no person working o g ‘ p ; V _ _ U k dth b g - o e _‘ ’ g M r h ob by e :p o d V ‘ e [fd h b no Incilned to terfere In th rder of transfer on this groun So far as the ground of husband and Wife to be poste t on% place ls concerned the same may be a good ground fo anceilatlon of the transfer order by the employer but th ourts wrll hardly Interfere In the order of tran f a mployee on that account ‘ p e g hereby drsmlssed ' ’ Suni Kliniar Sinha dge m t m e o d ‘ d a r c e C sfer o n e and Isi ' For the foregorng reasons the etltron rs lrable to b t ‘l; ‘E i 2 W WRITPETTioN 1S Nji2mo i , éag t t y p! i‘ y S g tl h b l ha ey ' ’ 't lh X s y g p a- r a r I " d l7 " ml l Ju