W W , W W , W L U F . . ) . > é . J m m m 2 0 0 7 — m m m ' W m ( 1 3 W ) W W @ W e s s a ‘ f a q m D B . H o n b l e S h r i J a q d u s h B h a l l a A g C J & H o n b l e S h n S a h s h K . A g n i h o i r l , ‘ 2 5 0 9 2 0 0 7 S h n S c n d e e p D u b e y ’ , A c S h r i U . N . S . D e o . G o v e r L i s + t h i s c a s e o n 2 7 * “ o f f ‘ N o . 5 0 7 0 o f 2 0 0 7 . . 1 r , A c t i n g C h i e f J u s t i c e ( X [ V S d / — \\ l v o c c 1 e f o r t h e p e t i ’ t i o n e r . n m e m ‘ A d v o c a i e f o r r t h e S t w e . ) e p ’ r e m b e r , 2 0 0 7 a l o n g w i ’ t h W . P . ( C ) S d / — S a t i s h K . A g n i h o t r i J u d g e r Resoondenta.; HJGU COURT OF CHHATTISQARH AT Btl.ASPUR DIVISLONBENCH HON'BLE SHRUAGDISHBHALLA, Ag. CJ. & HON'BLE SHRI SATISH K.AG^IH.OTRI, J. Writ Petition (C> No. 6070 of2007 . Narendra Dshariya, S/o Shri Daulat Ra.m Detiariya; aged about.21 years, .R/o. Jod? Pipal, Mohalla Kedarpur, . • • Ambikapur, pistrict Surguja (C.G.), prssentty (esidlng at Kosa Badi, Near Head Post Office, Korba Djst. Korba(C.G) • ; . ; ' Versus 1, State <rf Ohhatflsgarh, ftrough the Secretary, Dspartment pf Higher Education, D.K.S, Bhawan, Raipur '2. ChhatBsgarh Professtonal Exa(nin9S6n goard, throygh 'ifcs Confrollsr, WSS, Ta@i5rs ; Nagar, Raipur(C.G.) . 3. Chairman» Counseling Committee, 'C.G. ; Proffeisional Examination' Boari;!, through its Controller, C/168, Tagor^Naggi-,Ralpyr{C.G.) •4. The Directdr,'.tha Directorate of Msdical Etlucaficin, Old Nurses .Mostel': Building, D.K.S., Bhav/an .,Compouncl,,Raipi.!F(C.GJ?", :. 'Writ Pstition un'dsr Articis 226 6f th6 ConstitUtfon of India , . . 'WritRetitiontolNo. 5561 bf 2007 :.; Petitioner: Respondents: Ku. Arikita Badhiye (Minor) aged 17 year 11 'month D/o'Aryn- Kumar Badhiye through : 'Arun Kumar Badhiya aged 48 years S/o.l-ate Shri K.L. Bacthiys' Executiye Engirieer, W.R.S. R/o 3-5 Parijat Colony Ring Road HQ.2, Bllaspur (C.G.) . Versus •, . 1. State.of Chihattisgarh, through the f^ sf c^ r^ i^S .1' •. 1 li'i . ."• 2- .Secre^ffy, Departmenl of Health, D.K.S. Bhawan, FiaiRurfC.G.). 2. Director, Medical Education, Raipur 3. Anusuchit Janajati parmar patra Uchh9 Estariya Chhanbin Samiti, through its pretident pandii Ravi Shanke Shukla , Vishwavidalaya parisar, Raipur (C.G.) Iflfrit Petltlon under Article 228 ofthe Constituttori df India Writ Petition fCI Mo. 5386 of 2007 Petltloner: Raspondents ; 1. fc: •^-- Gayatri Karoliya, D/o Netram Karoliya,aged atiouf 1.9 years, R/o: Manendragarh, District Korea (C.G.). Versus. : ' ' • . . , " Stata of Chhattisgarh, Through the Secretary, Department of Haalth & Family Welfare, 'D.K.S- Building, Maniralaya, Rajpur, Chhatiisgarh. Director.Msdical Education, Raipur, Ctihattisgarh. .'. ehhatiisgarh Professional Examination Board, through Secrefary, Raipur, C.hhattisgarh. Caste Certificate High Power Scrutiny Committee, Office of the Commissjoner, SC/ST Devp, Department, Raipur, Chhattisgarh. Writ Peiibon undw Article 226 ofthe Constitution of India Present.; Shri Kanak Tiwarj, Senior Advocate with Ms. Bharati Soni; Shri Sandeep Dubey; Shri M.P.S. Bhatia & Shri Shashank Thakur, couhsel for the petitioners. . Shri'Prashant Mishra, Advocate G^necal with Shri A.S. Kachhawaha. Government Advocale for the State. • Shri Jitondra Gupta, counsel for Chhattisgarh Rrofessional Board. ' . OftAL ORDeR (Passed 6n 27tn September, 2007) 4. :'M;'l;^.'?a '.!;-{hk ': 'f:':- <" .Itft-'rr— The fol!ov,"n9 ora! ordsr cf the Court was passed by Hon'ble w'agdish 6ha!!a, Ag, C.J. . .Sincs in a" ths th'ss eonnecteci writ petitiQns simHar prayers ,ancl srowds S'avs besn •raiseci, th'ey. are being considered anci .disposs'd ofbyonecommori order. . . ' , The app!'icat';or!s for'amendmsnt are al'.owsd. Let neeesss'y. 1 amBridment b's wrnec! out SLir.ing Shs course of the day.and vopy cf ;hs amendsci petition be sen'ediipon the State. '' - _ : The, - .pstition.ers • s;'a ihe studgnts who 'A'ant • to purs'je professional csiu'rse.' Though bo,'n ai-d bro'jght iip in ;he Siats df .•ChnaS'.isgarh their. soc;a! stat'JS has been denied and'.aeccrdinaiy ths ' pasts cfertificiate.flrsr-.ted to them !!-:as. bsi;n'!rejei;tsd. : /• Learned Advbcate/Gsriera'•appesring.fcr ths respsndsnts ' •Sta's informs 'ha* the.^L;c!g?nsn'; s? 'tha lsa;ned ISing]a Judge was y/rongly iriterpreted snd i;'; ccmpliance ef the judgrr;e!'iS ir: '.'Vrit P£t:*:3n No.25^0;2004 datsd 04-02-2COS, !th£ Go'.'ernmant by an ordsr dats.d 02^022205 hadkspt te'asS*ic3t!on,,dated 2S.07.20Q4 ;n sbsyancs. Thcrs^te'f ths Gc'v'srnr">ent hss issiis-d snsthsr . crdsr dated 27-OS-20C7 wherein defini'ioh. sf bonafide residents of Chhattisgarh has bsen dEfincd and sxp'ained v/hich !nt';ides (i) pei-sons fce'onging :o ths central seryices posted at Chha"is3arh, their spoyses or chiidrsn, (ii) a;l' tfts srrp'.oy&es o' Stata c? Chhattisgarh, thsir spouses dr ch!'rdren; (i)!') Perso'ns appointed on. ConstituSonal or Statutory' posis hy P.resident Sf India, their spouses or child'ren; (iv) Cirporations, Agenciss, Co.'nmissions, acard's, Ofi'.ciais.'Qlftcers.'smp'syees, thsir ;'spt>uses !or . childrsn. Th'is ^ w'- ,• /^^ (t . / < •/ Go'.'ismrfisnt s'der is ;o be.lsfiS th.s p9ijtip,"s,''s-si[jdsnts. v/itb rsspest to bonafide residents ofChhattisgarh. Ws are of the cqnsidered opinion that once such ps'sons havs besn .recQgnizsd as rssidents o' Chhattissa'h.'then the sams ana'ogy s'ia!! appfy for the pu.'pcse cf ;he !admissions of child'en of ihe categories rs.ferred to Ksreinsbove are ccncerned, if tftsir caste is inc'uded'inthe presideniia'Oi-deF. ' • , • Tke 'espGndsnts are dirested to ccnsidsr the ca.ndidatu's cf V'.a petSiCi-iS-rs - studants'afres^ ;n the'Itght of ths sbser.'atisns. madB herasfiabove,'inacccrdance v.'itf} ls;v. • • ' - • 'A'ith She afpresaid. flbseFvatiori, the1 v/rit petiyonsi siand elisposedcf.. . : • ; -—- Sd/- Acting Chief Justice Sd/- SatishK.AgiMfibtri Ju3ge "„'*:•' • '! • • '11 T:?J!: •"'.;"."'! ' ai ^ »>. f':