' ‘wP ”ya/a: - IN THE M.P. STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL AT JABALPUR 0.2:” No. i‘O‘L OF ”$99 Apglicants , 1. Umesh Prasad soni, S/o shri Pa& Mohan 80ml Working as Peon, R/o Dokda, Tehsil Kunkuri. District Jashpur, M.P. Stephan Tigga, S/o Shri Alphos Tigga, Working as Peon, R/o Korna, Tehsil Kunkuri, District Jashpur (M.P.) §a Munku Ram, s/o shri Sukdev Ram, Working as Choukiaar, R/o Mendar Bahar, Tehsil Kunkuri, District Jashpur (M.P .) 4. Jag Mohan Singh, s/o Shri Baldev Ram, Wcrking as Rasoiya. R/o Bagicha, Tehsil Bagicha, District Jashpur (M.P.) 5. Kanhaiya Ram, S/o Shri Ram Sharan, Working as Waterman, R/o B‘ai‘samuda. Teh5il Paththal Gaon, District Jashpur (M.P.) Heera Ram. S/o shri Lokaram, ‘Working as Waterman, R/o Devora, Tehsil Kunkuri, District Jashpur (M.P.) 7. Sadanand Say, S/o Shri Jaiman Say, Working as Rasoiya. R/o Sahilata, Tehsil Kunkuri District Jashpur (M.P.) 7,.E, ‘ f g /2/ 8. Manohar Lal Patel. s/o Shri Mohan Kumar Patel, Werking as Waterman, R/c Dharmjaygarh, Tehsil Dharmja garb; District Raigarh (M.P.) 9. Hoshiyar Lal, S/o Shri sidar Singh, Working as Choukidar, R/a Medharmar,’ Tehsil Dharmjaygarh, District Raigarh (M.P.) 10. Bijesh'yfvar Ram; ‘ S/e shri Sarbeel, Working as waterman, R/o Rajhaéand. Tehsil Kunkuri, District Jashpur (M.P.) 11. Sahdevr Ram, S/o Shri Indranath singh, Working as Waterman, R/o Godamba, Tehsil Kunkuri, District Jashpur (M.P.) 12. Mahadev Ram, ' S/o Shri Kular Ramg Warking as Waterman, R/o Pharsajugain, Tehsil Bageecha. District Jashpur (M.P.) 13. Mahto RaE, I s/o Shri Bajru'Ram, Working as Rasoiya, R/o Kunmera, Tehsil sitapur, District Sarguja (M.P.) 14. Lalloo Ram, 5/0 Shri Langthu Ram, Working as Rasoiya, R/o Kutma, %ehsil Bageecha, District Jashpur (M.P.) — /3/ 15. 16. Jageshwar Das, S/o Shri Ghasidas, Working as Peon, R/o Vijaynagar, Tehsil Dharmjay- w garh, District Raigarh (M.P.) Goverdhan Ram, S/o Shri Ganeshi Ram' Working as Choukidar, R/o Lelunga, Tehsil Gharghora, District Raigarh my.) Mohit Ram, S¢o shri Ghasia Ram, Working as Cho;,rkidar, R/o Bhuiyapani, Tehsil Gharghora, District Raigarh (M.P.) Janmejay Pekra, 1‘ S/o shri Jaldhar Pekra, 7 working as Rasaiya. R/o Rajpur, Tehsil Gharghora, District Raigarh (M.P.) Surendra Kumar DeVangan, v S/o Shri Bharat Lal. Working as Rasoiya, R/o Sighra, Tehsil shakti, District Bilaspur 04.9.) Komal Kumar Patel, S/o Shri Nankaram. Working as £alaterman, R/o Dharmjaygarh, Tehsil Dharmgay— garb, District Raigéarh (MsPJ Rémjan Ratre. S/o Shri Ramdheen Ratre, Working as Waterman, i‘ R/o Basinbahra, Tehsil Sanangarh, District Raigarhv (M.P .) 17. 18. 19. s0. 2 x/% $1:. R \bD/f‘q‘? O /4/ 22. 23c 24. 25. ~VerSuS" ) Respondents l . 3a ? ‘S’Q rUV $m0 ® Deenbandhg Sahu. S/o Shri Girdhari Sahu, Working as Rasoiya, R/o Chiraipani, Tehsil Raigarh, District Raigarh (MJJ Phulram Siaar; S/o shri Chanarika Prasad, Working as Choukidar, R/o Tiur, Tehsil Kharsiya, District Raigarh —(M.P.) Devendra Kumar Sahu, S/o shri Chanaan Singh Sahu, Working as Peon, R/O Sodka, Tehsil Kharsiya District Raigarh (M.P.3 Khushi Ram choudhri, s/o Shri Gangaram Chaudhri Working as Prayogshala Paricharak R/o Lelunga, Tehsil Gharghora. District Raigarh (M.P.) State of Madhya Pradesh; Through : Tribel Welfare Department, Bhopal (M.P.) The Commi s sioner, Tribal Development, M.P . , Bhonal (Ema .The Deputy Commi ssioner, Tribe]. Development, Bil aspur Division Bil aspur (PL? .) Secretary, i‘ O ’ , , ) , /5/ 4O The Assistant Commissioner, Tribel Develepment Raigarh, District Raigarh (M.P.) 5 . The Collects r. Tribal Wel£are Branch, District Raigarh (M.P.) APPLI CAT IQN UNDER bECI ON 19 OF AD1\£ NT. 8TRA'I‘I VE TRIBUNALs AC1“, 1985 : Pai'rioners HIGH CGURT QF CHHATTI$QARH AT BILA$PUR W. 3(5) No. 1HOJZG05 Versus Raspondents Ume$h Pmsnd 5oni & others Shri Gou'ram Khe‘rmpai, counsei for me peTH-ioners. Shri Ajay Dwivedi, Pane! lawyer far Th2 respondems/bi'mw. ORAL ORDER (315* August 2006) The fallawing arder of fhe 59w? is passed by swish K. Agniha‘rri, J. . The pe‘tifioners were appoin‘ted on various pasts, as bu!ow:- Name of the pefifioner Umesh Soni Stephan Tigga Munku Ram Jagmahan 5ingh Kwhaiya Ram HSm Ram Sadancmd Sni Manohar Lal Pufel Hoshiyar La! Bijeshwar Ram $nhdev Ram Mahadev Ram Muhfomm LeHumm Jugeshwar Das Gowurdhan Rum Mohif Ram Janmejay Paikm Surendm Kumar’ Dewangom Komai Kumar Patel ’Ramjcm Ratre Qinbandhu Sahu Pmsnd Peon Chowkidar Cook Waferman Waferman Coek Wafer-man Chawkidar WaTer-man Wu'mr'man Waiterman ‘ Cook Cook Peon Chowkidar Chowkidar Cook Cook Pos? Peon Dcd’e appoin‘rmenf 7.331 30.63.93 4.10.93 26.6.93 19.8.92 $7.89 7.7.89 18.10.93 af Da‘fe of Regular pay Scale 30.6.94 20.11.95 20.11.96 18.12.93 18.12.93 1.8.96 1.8.96 1.11.97 1.11.97 1.11.97 1.11.97 1.11.97 30.7.93 17.11.94 30.7.93 6.4.92 2.3.93 1.1.89 > 31.7.91 31 Q RQ 13.2.92 20.7.94 19.37.89 1.8.90 3.1.89 Feb. 89 9.11.92 Wa‘rer'man Waterman Cook 7.8.92 24.2.94 20.3.91 2.3.93 29.8.97 26.4.94 Sm'i’e of Madhye Pmdesh & o'fhers S: B Hon'bie Mr. Jusfice 591131; K. Agnihatri, J JI " ‘ Pg Fhulram Sidw‘ Chgwkidar 20.12.99 39.5.97 Devendm Kumar Fem 24.10.90 Sahu K.R.Choudhari Labomfory 14.12.92 2&697 Opemfcr am! 'fhz pa'H'rigner-s were. gran‘i’ed reguiar pay sca!e aka as per The abuve mani’igned chart 2. The reguigr' pay scale$ gran+ed 1‘9 he pei’ifioners were wifhdmwn Vida circular dated 4.10.97 (Annexuwz A/i), admif'redlyl withguf Show cause mtice to 1412 pefi?ionzrs. 3. Learned counse! appearing far The pz?i'tienars submits thaf the same fac‘?s and ques’s'ians sf {aw ha$ baen cansidgred by fhis Caur‘t in WP. (s) No. 1792 of 2005 (Manmohan Paw! <3: a'rhers Vs. Stag of Madhya Pmdesh é; 01‘hers) and this Cour-‘1' has ailawed ‘the. wrii: pati'tion, quashing 'E'he impugned order da‘md 4.10.97 (Annexure P/l). Learnzd wunse! appearing far fha pefi'rioner further- submifs 14m? cases of the pzfitionzrs in fhe presen? pmii'ion are squarely covered by ordzr dmd 11““ Juiy, 2906 passaa 2r. WP. (s) No. 1792 of 2005 (Manmhan Paste! & m‘hgrg \is. Sig-i? 9f Madhya Pmdesath & ofher-s). 4. Learfied cgunse! apgearing fur- +he rggpondenf$J5faie agrees wi‘rh The submission made by Seamed caunsa! appgaring far The pen'ficnars. Far The reasons sfa‘hzd-nbova, +h2 wri‘t pen-Hon is aiiowed and fhe impugnad order dated 4.10.9? (Annaxur'e Ali) is quashed in terms of 1i” This Caurf in WP. No. #E‘ie order- dafed July, 2006 passed by This Caurf in WP. (s) 1792 of 2005., Ne order as To casTs. " l Sd/— V Sa&sh K. Agnihou-j Judge ’7 Babiu