:£-., t^H^OUR'ROFSHIW-FTBGWHA'KBIl.ASPUR IXB.I'reW^ESI^DHIR^ :;':': - ..^::'SiiCTi'81.BSI^itl^^JaiSNt3R«KilK^ Pelitjoner Versus WfritPetifloritefcNo.SIWtrflfllO Bal}ertSfnghC^ir3^ed;Iti^^yBa(B,S^ Shn Waiyam Slr^s®onriT^ <Jrw^>(M^1^^<^—^^'f«ysKV^^^ Tehsilany@istriGtTOaspur,Ghhat8^arh. Responctents 1 2 3. State of GhhatB^rh, thre^^ Se^eetafy, Gomrnmentbf^hHsttsgairK^^ and C^l Suppties^ ©^^^^^a^ ChhatU^artl. CMhatti^rti State CoopSrati^^^^^ l^ Fw^aS^SjHiS^,^S^sp^'f'yekf'ia^,y^sl»u, Distnrt ^MartEeftig^s <3c>(^ra^Marlce^F^eratj<m,Btl^ip>M'. PfesWt: :; ::. •' •:. ;n^:;;. ^ : '::' ';-.'• Shri RaribtrSir^h,hjttfhas,cSi^^Bt|or tli^-f ShriY.S. Thakur, l^^;t*o<^tte?©SniBrs 1'<M' ieStgt$. ORALORDER ^ll'Septomb«',26-l^i PwI^wene^aMStvai J has iwayed for tha ft>ll!Wng The P^KM^ t»y^ insttnt SubstanUveretief: U1. tssue a Wrtt in the nattrs <^ icer^^ conteinedinclause9<rfAnne»ui»R-'l. 2. ls6ue awiWihithe naUw ^^^ authorities to allow^We petitiot^sto ^ schedutedtobeppenedon09®9/20fpei erl^ thecondaion contafned mclause®(rfAnnexureP-1. vide 2. Grievance of the petHKOTer is d^ ttre peUtKtnW (s business of tonsport, havjng fleet (^buste transportaton ^foodgrams- 1^pont^No^!ts^ Sy\ short "NIT") for transporta^ (^feod grainsetB. W^ AhnexureP^1.As{^eiayset5(^^^eten(ter ftave included as Speeialeo^ltto^thattliete^ e)4»riwice of 2 yeare in ^ fieB W ^nsportation ^^^^^ governmwt/s^i-gov6mnie^ yin^tutl^ unrMsonabie. flie in amy' d ^.^;^ ^ Weye^2009g®issi.i^hyrKS^ M^'|r»suchet^JbUBy;cBteri^^>F{^ same tos b^sn incliSdiM^trr ^^p^ ifeqUta|By^?petitionerte»iri^tar^^(^ argi^^ ttiat fiwn perusal i<rf epndiBons c^ ^^^^^^^te^ n^fe& iasued by ChKat ^^Statei<^peraU» MaHce^Be^^ ^r 2010-11 (A|rin©ajii^F^,1t?w6ufB|toe^ Iwo yeare' experiem» of trar^a^ govemment otgarii^ion, h^'t)een flniaag|c^pi^o^ tt»imptgned ctwwlition Inthe lBndern<rth»isdisCTimm^ryahdthe^M Ibss to ttie publu; exchequer as it may reduce falr CompetiUon. 4. l^rd leameATOt^^ writ peUtton as well Mttie docutnente^riei^wiftthepetiB^. :i:- ••••••.:•'.; 5. It is setUed law fliat ttie terms and comlifioTO iri the temlere !are prestmbed by^ Goyernment l^ping te such matters, theaiAority calUrig fctftHetenderis the^bastjudgeto^^^p^ the terms and cehclitions of1t»tender. It fe notfw the Gourts to say wh^her flie conditions prescribed in the tencter undw jGonsito'^on were b^Br"tttan the ones prescribed in tte earlier tender invitettons. (^ls^ InfrashvefuiBff^Ltcl. y&Commr^ UKaSna^rMwiicfialCorf}n..ffO(WSSCC2e73f. 6. In the instant <a^, sinGe the impugi^ corKiWoo in the N0' is m and equally applkable te dl iMdder^ ^ arbitrary.unreasonable^malaflcle.Wteflndnfrsyb^^ same deserves to b6 and is, accoRfingly, dismissed at ttie atfcnt^iM'l ^age iteelf. Sd/- Dhirendra Mishra Judge Sd/- 4 R.N. Chandrakari Judge j