HIGHGOlJRTOFGl-ll-laaiTTlSjG^RHATBlLASPUR DKffiSiONBENeH CORAM: HON'BLE SHRI RAilEEVGUPTA, CJ. HON'BLE§HRISUNll-KUhfl»RSlNHA,J. WritAbDeal R)^lb. 3279012010 ApRellant (PetftionerBelow) ^,:6-^^.,_ ^:. ,_.^ _.-^ SuFendra Sinigh, S/p. Shri Ganpat Singh, agedabout 27 years, R/ near ftlka Stuclio, Karbala-Ftpad, Birsa Munda ©howk, Jashpur Nagar, DiStrictJasRpyr,C;G. VERSUS ResOondents (Respondents below) 1. State afChhattisgarh thrbugh the .Secretary, DepartmentofHome, D.K.S. Bhawan, Mantralaya, Raigur ^•G-) • l.:ll^'..'.['.' 2; DirectQr ©eneral,Police Head Qyarter.GhhiattisgamBsiipur (©.©.) .3. ? SupeRntendenlofPolice,^ ''"t^Nagar?(g;©.)£.-'J::..:-,--^ \n/nt^Ei^laEmSleiiSIi^ionS^fiS^1S-^eff1ii@@IEt^LOf1:l'ig (^haittis^arltN1flBWfflWtSBl:ii{R @i®iiie^sBgBBI'tV% ,200T Present: Shri Varun Sharma, learFied coynselfoi|^HS ap;[:jel|ant, Shri Kishore Bhadyri, learnea Aaditiohal Acivocate General for the State/ respondents^ 7 JUraSMENT (11 .Auaust,2010) . ' The follovvihg judgment of the Court was passed by RajeevGupta,C.J. , Learned eQunselfortlie'partiesareheard: y •<^ 2)Theappe|lanthasfiledtniswrit£ippealagainsttheii-npugned orderdated 06-05-2040, passed inW.P.(S) No.3638/2009. 3) The appellant/ petitiOner, in the writ petition wasseeking a directionto the respondentS to considgr him fdr appointment to the post of Constable ahd further.to quashtheselecti6o|^^ initiated by the respondents/ State Aythorities in pursuance to the advertisement dated 04-06-2009 for recruitment to the post of Constables. 4) Thepetitioner'sentireclaimwasbasedonhisindusjoninthe waiting )ist pyblished pn, 13-08-200:8. The appellahfs/ petitioner's main grievance wasthatthe respondents/StateAuthoritiesyvithout exhausting the waiting list prepared in the year 2008 have initiated the^ selecticin process in ^the year 200i9 vide advertjsement dated ;04-06-20Q9.-''1:.'.::,- ;^.,'':;;-',^ ;• '; 1; , ^ 5) Learhed Sihgle ^luyg^onja^MorougK e^ submissions advanc^d on begalf ^ and the provisions contained in Ryle 13 of ChRattisgarh RQIice Executiye -Force,Constable (Recruitmentand ConditionsofrService) Rules, 2007 (for short Tfte Rutes, 2007') fpund no substance in the petitioner's daim. Leamed Sihgle^ Judge, therefore, dismissecl the writpetitiort videimpughed order.dated 06-05-2010. 6) Shri Varyn SharmaT learned counsel fQr ttie appellant vehemently argued that the learned SjnglaJudge has erred in hpt giving du6 weighttothefaetthatin'SQm^otherdistFietsintheState of CHhattisgarh, candidates from the waitinglist \^re appoi .••iE'"'*'"-'.;: '' l.;^"/ ^w' ~^-v. l&^ ^••it^. . ''*-;.. r../" : ^<- •I, ^,'s^i v •fe the respondents/ State Authorities ought to have appointed the appellant who was in the waiting list against the post which had fallen vacant before initiatiori ofthe new recruitment process in the year 2009; and the respondents/ State Aythpritjes have not assighed ahy reason fornotexhausfingthewaitinglist prepared in the year 2008 and for initiating tde new selection process in the monthofJuneinsteadofmonthofJuiy,asprescrifc>edintheRules. 7) It is settled lawthata candidate inthe select list/waitihg list has no legal right to seek writ of mandamus. 5uch a right is created in favourofthe candidate in the select list/waiting listonly in theeventuality when a person below him in the selectlisV waiting list is appointed. Admittedly, in the present gase n6 such appointment is alleged to have been made by thg. respondents/ State Authorities. 8) Rule 13 of Rules 20Q7 quoted in para 17 of the iriipijgned prder does not leave any TOom for doubt Ahat the select list prepared in the year 2008 andpublishedon 13-08-2008 cameto an.end with the jnHiatipri.Qf,the new ?ejec^pn;process in the year 2009 vide advertisement ciated 04-0g-2009. 9) In this view of the matter, we do not find any ihfirmity in;the impugngd oitlerpassed bythelearned SingleJudge dismissingthe ^ippellant's writpetition. ^ 10); The writapRedl^thgrefore, js liable to be disrfiissed and is tiereby dismissed summarily. •'..^•:Sd/-- CteiefJustice Sd/- Sunil KumarSinha Judge ••»'iBKj7=zsst3iek ".TtBKatd