IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA LPA No.992 of 2007 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR, THROUGH THE CHIEF SECRETARY, OLD SECRETARIAT, PATNA. 2. THE SECRETARY, COOPERATIVE DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, NEW SECRETARIAT, BIHAR, PATNA. 3. THE REGISTRAR, COOPERATIVE SOCIETY, GOVT. OF BIHAR NEW SECRETARIAT, PATNA. --- RESPONDENTS/APPELLANTS. Versus 1. PANKAJ KUMAR PARMAR, SON OF LATE DHIRENDRA NARAYAN SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE POSTPAR, P.S. SAUR BAZAR, DISTRICT SAHARSA. 2. ANIL KUMAR SINGH S/O DURGA PRASAD SINGH R/O VILL. RAKIA, P.S. BIHRA DIST.- SAHARSA 3. SATRUGHAN KUMAR S/O LATE BADRI NARAYAN SAH R/O VILL.- MADHUBAN P.S. & DIST. MADHEPURA 4. DEVESH KUMAR SINGH S/O BRAJENDRA NARAYAN SINGH R/O VILL.- MAHANPUR P.S. BIHARIGANJ, DIST. MADHEPURA. 5. ASHOK KUMAR SINGH, S/O PRIYABRAT NARAYAN SINGH R/O VILL.- MADHUBAN P.S.- UADAKISHANGANJ, DIST. MADHEPURA. 6. MANORANJAN SINGH S/O NITYANAND SINGH R/O VILL. MADRAUNI P.S. GOPALPUR, DIST. BHAGALPUR. 7. MD. SHAMIMUDDIN S/O MD. FARIDUDDIN R/O VILL.-RAHTA P.S. UDAKISHANGANJ DIST. MADHEPURA 8. ANUJ KUMAR SINGH S/O SURESH PRASAD SINGH, R/O VILL.- SAROPATTI P.S. SINGHESHWAR.DIST. MADHEPURA 9. PRAMOD KUMAR S/O KAMESHWAR PRASAD SINGH R/O VILL.- VADDI P.S. SAUR BAZAR, DIST. SAHARSA. 10 UMESH PRASAD SINGH S/O LATE RAJENDRA PRASAD SINGH R/O VILL. MADHUVAN P.S. UDAKISHANGANJ DIST. MADHEPURA. 11. ASHOK KUMAR S/O GHUTAHRU PRASAD YADAV, R/O VILL. MURHO P.S.& DIST. MADHEPURA 12. SATYANARAYAN SWARNKAR S/O SITARAM SWARNKAR R/O MURLIGANJ P.S. MURLIGANJ, DIST. MADHEPURA. 13. ARBIND KUMAR SINGH S/O RAMESH CHANDRA SINGH R/O VILL. AMARPURA P.S. MURLIGANJ DIST. MADHEPURA. 14. NARESH PRASAD SINGH S/O SITARAM PRASAD SINGH, R/O PATWA NAVTOL P.S. MURLIGANJ, DIST. MADHEPURA. 15. KARTIK PRASAD SINGH S/O SHIV NARAYAN SINGH R/O VILL.- RAIBHIR P.S. SINGHESHWAR, DIST. MADHEPURA. 16. DHIRENDRA PRASAD YADAV S/O BINDESHWAR PRASAD YADAV R/O VILL-.RAHTA P.S. KUMARKHAND DIST. MADHEPURA. 17. SURENDRA PRASAD RAM S/O LATE MOHAN RAM R/O BHARAHI P.S. AND DIST. MADHEPURA. 18. SUBODH KUMAR SINGH S/O GAJENDRA NARAYAN SINGH R/O VILL.- GAMAIL P.S. BIHARIGANJ DIST. MADHEPURA. 19. NAWAL KISHOR YADAV S/O LATE DEO NARAYAN YADAV R/O VILL. JALAIA PASTPAR P.S. SOUR BAZAR DIST. SAHARSA 20 UMA NATH JAH S/O LATE JATA SHANKAR JAH R/O PURANI BAZAR ( MADHEPURA) P.S. & DIST. MADHEPURA 21 CHIT NARAYAN YADAV S/O LATE GIRINDRA PRASAD YADAV R/O VILL. PASTPAR, P.S. SOUR BAZAR, DIST. SAHARSA 22 NARMDESHWAR SINGH S/O DHARMDEO SINGH R/O VILL.- SUKHASAN P.S. & DIST. MADHEPURA. 23 IMTIAZ AHMAD S/O LATE SAPHI AHMAD R/O VIDYAPATI NAGAR P.S. & DIST. MADHEPURA. 24. LALAN MALLICK S/O BHUMI MALLICK R/O VILL. SISSUVI 2 P.,S. SIMRI, BAKHIYARPUR DIST. SAHARSA 25. KAMAL KISHORE SINGH S/O DHANUSHDHARI SINGH R/O VILL.- FANHASS, P.S. UDAKISHANGANJ DIST. MADHEPURA 26. RANJEET SINGH S/O LATE SANTOSH PRASAD SINHA R/O NIZWARA P.S. KHORA, DIST. JAMUI. 27. AWADESH KUMAR SINGH S/O SHIV SHANKAR PRASAD SINGH R/O FATEHPUR P.S. SONBARSA RAJ, DIST. SAHARSA. 28. SANTOSH KUMAR SAH, S/O JAGDISH PRASAD SAH R/O GOAT BAZAR P.S. MURLIGANJ, DIST. MADHEPURA] 29 SANJAY KUMAR SINGH S/O MOHAN PRASAD SINGH R/O VILL.- KHAPAITI P.S. & DIST. MADHEPURA. 30 MANOJ KUMAR SINGH S/O MADAN MOHAN SINGH R/O VILL. KHOPAITI P.S. & DIST. MADHEPURA. 31. KULANAND CHOUDHARY S/O BINDESHWARI CHOUDHARY R/O VILL.- DAULATPUR, P.S. KARJAIN BAZAR,DIST. SUPAUL 32. DILIP JHA S/O TRILOK NATH JHA R/O VILL. – BARA P.S. PANCHGACHIA DIST. SAHARSA 33.. SATISH KUMAR SINGH S/O GUNESHWAR PRASAD SINGH R/O VILL. KHOPAITI P.S. & DIST. MADHEPURA. 34 . NITISH KUMAR SINGH S/O ROMANUGRAH NARAYAN SINGH R/O VILL- BANHARA, P.S. HAWALI, KHARAGPUR, DIST. MONGHER. 35. PRAMOD KUMAR SINGH S/O SURENDRA NARAYAN SINGH R/O VILL- BARA, P.S. GWALPARA, DIST. MADHEPURA. 36. RAM SEWAK SINGH S/O SHYAM NARAYAN SINGH R/O VILL. NITENDAR P.S. & DIST. PURNEA. 37. SANJAY KUMAR SINGH S/O CHANDRADEO PRASAD SINGH R/O VILL. DHABAULI, P.S. SAUR BAZAR, DIST. SAHARSA 38. MANOHAR KUMAR S/O LATE TRIBHUVAN PRASAD SAH R/O MADHEPURA P.S. & DIST. MADHEPURA. 39. SATRUDHAN PODDAR S/O LATE MUSHARU PODDAR R/O AZAD NAGAR ( MADHEPURA), P.S. & DIST. MADHEPURA 40. MD. SAFIQUEE ALAM S/O MD. SUBHAN, R/O AZAD NAGAR, ROAD NO.4 P.S. & DIST. MADHEPURA. 41. DHRUB KUMAR SINGH S/O JALESHWAR PRASAD SINGH R/O BIHARIGANJ P.S. BIHARIGANJ, DIST. MADHEPURA. 42. BINOD KUMAR SAH, S/O YOGENDRA PRASAD SAH R/O GULJARBAG, WARD NO.10 P.S. & DIST. MADHEPURA. 43 DAMAN KUMAR JHA S/O PRABHAKANT JHA R/O VILL KAHRA ( MADANPUR) P.S. PATARGHAT, DIST. SAHARSA 44. JAGDEO MANDAL S/O LATE BACHHI MANDAL, R/O MANPUR P.S.GAMHERIA, DIST. MADHEPURA. 45. AMRENDRA PRASAD SINGH S/O SURESH PRASAD SINGH R/O VILL.- AURAHI EKPARHA P.S. GAMHERIA, DIST. MADHEPURA. 46. BHIBHUTI KUMAR SINGH S/O LATE HARI BALLAV NR. SINGH R/O KHARA BUDHMA, P.S. UDAKISHANGANJ DIST. MADHEPURA. 47. HARI NANDAN YADAV S/O SIYARAM PRASAD YADAV R/O PARSAHI P.S. GHAILODH, DIST. MADHEPURA. 48. BHAGIRATH PRASAD SINGH S/O MAHABIR PRASAD SINGH R/O THADHI P.S. BALDAUR, DIST. KHAGARIA. 49. RADHAKANT SINGH S/O LATE BAHADUR SINGH, R/O VILL. RAKIA, P.S. BIHRA, DIST. SAHARSA. 50. MAUL KUMAR SINGH S/O GUNESHWAR SINGH, R/O VILL. RAKIA, P.S. BIHRA, DIST. SAHARSA. 51. SUBASH PRASAD SINGH S/O BAIDIANATH PRASAD SINGH R/O VILL. RAUTA P.S. SAUR BAZAR DIST. SAHARSA. 52. SHYAMAL KISHORE MISHRA S/O LATE RAMESHWAR MISHRA R/O CHAKIA NIRMALI WARD NO.11 P.S. & DIST.SUPAUL. 53. KALIKA NAND JHA S/O RAMESH CHANDRA JHA R/O VILL. 3 BABHANI (DAVARI) P.S. & DIST. SUPAUL. 54. KRISHNA KUMAR SINGH S/O BHAGWATI PRASAD SINGH R/O VILL. SUKHPUR P.S. & DIST. SUPAUL. 55. PRABHA KUMAR S/O SUKHDEO MISTRI R/O SUPAUL HAT, WARD NO. 5 P.S. & DIST. SUPAUL 56. BIPIN KUMAR SINGH S/O NARENDRA KUMAR SINGH R/O PARSARMA P.S. & DIST. SUPAUL. 57. GAJENDRA NATH JHA S/O NILAMBAR JHA R/O SOKHPUR P.S. & DIST. SUPAUL. 58. SHYAM PRASAD VERMA S/O LATE YADUNANDAN PRASAD R/O CHAKLA NIRMALI P.S. & DIST. SUPAUL. 59. GITESH KUMAR MISHRA S/O GAJANAND MISHRA, R/O SUPAUL, P.S. & DIST. SUPAUL. 60. TRILOKI NATH PRASAD S/O MAHENDRA PRASAD R/O DULHAPUR, P.S. SIMRI, DIST. BUXAR. 61. RANJIT KAMAT S/O TARNI KAMAT R/O VILL. PASTPAR, P.S. SAUR BAZAR, DIST. SAHARSA. 62. SANJAY KUMAR SINGH S/O CHANDRESWAR PRASAD SINGH R/O NARPATI NAGAR, P.S. SAKRI DIST. MADHUBANI 63 MOHAN PRASAD SINGH S/O BRAHAMDEO NARAYAN SINGH R/O VILL. RATAULI, P.S. PIPRA, DIST. SUPAUL. (ALL OF THEM ARE THE ERST WHILE EMPLOYEES OF MADHEPURA SUPAUL CENTRAL CO-OPERATIVE BANK LTD. MADHEPURA. ------ PETITIONERS- RESPONDENTS IST SET. 64. THE RESERVE BANK OF INDIA THROUGH THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, RURAL PLANNING AND CREDIT DEPARTMENT,] CENTRAL OFFICE, GARMENT HOUSE, DR. ANNE BASANT ROAD, WORLI, MUMBAI-400018. 65. THE ADMINISTRATOR CUM MANAGING DIRECTOR, THE BIHAR STATE COOPERATIVE BANK LIMITED, ASHOK RAJPATH, PATNA, BIHAR. 66. THE DISTRICT MAGISTRTE CUM LIQUIDATOR, MADHEPURA- SUPAUL CENTRAL COOPERATIVE BANK LIMITED MADHEPURA. 67. BIHAR STATE CO-OPERATIVE BANK LIMITED, ASHOK RAJPATH, PATNA THROUGH ITS ADMINISTRATOR CUM MANAGING DIRECTOR. 68. THE MADHEPURA SUPAUL CENTRAL CO-OPERATIVE BANK LTD. MADHEPURA THROUGH DISTRICT MAGISTRATE MADHEPURA CUM LIQUIDATOR. ------ RESPONDENTS- RESPONDENTS 2ND SET With LPA No.991 of 2007 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR, THROUGH THE CHIEF SECRETARY, OLD SECRETARIAT, PATNA. 2. THE SECRETARY, COOPERATIVE DEPARTMET, GOVT. OF BIHAR, NEW SECRETARIAT, PATNA. 3. THE REGISTRAR, COOPERATIVE SOCIETY, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, NEW SECRETARIAT, PATNA. ---- RESPONDENTS- APPELLANTS. Versus 1. NAND KISHORE SINGH SON OF LATE ARJUN PRASAD SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE TEGHRA , P.S.. SIMRI BAKHTIARPUR, DISTRICT SAHARSA. 4 2. RAJESH KUMAR SINGH S/O BIRENDRA NARAYAN SINGH R/O VILL. MOHANPUR, P.S. BIHARIGANJ DIST. MADHEPURA. 3. KAUSHAL KISHORE SINGH, S/O LATE SATRUDHAN PRASAD SINGH, R/O VILL.- NAVTOL, P.S. MURLIGANJ, DIST. MADHEPURA. 4. MANOHAR PRASAD SINGH, S/O PHULESHWAR PRASAD SINGH R/O VILL- NOVTOL, P.S. MURLIGANJ, DIST. MADHEPURA. 5. HARILAL YADAV S/O SATYA NARAYAN YADAV, R/O MADHEPURA WARD NO.9 DIST. MADHEPURA. 6. ARUN KUMAR SINGH S/O LATE NARAYAN PRASAD SINGH R/O VILLAGE PASTPAR P.S. SAUR BAZAR, DIST. SAHARSA. 7. SURESH RAJAK S/O LATE VANESHWAR RAJAK, R/O BHIRKHI P.S. AND DIST. MADHEPURA. 8. SAROJ KUMAR S/O LATE BHUVNESHWAR YADAV R/O VILL. – AURAHI P.S. GHAILADH DIST.- MADHEPURA. 9. UPENDRA YADAV S/O SARYUG YADAV, R/O BHIRKHI, GARIB TOLA WARD NO. 12/16, P.S. & DIST. MADHEPURA. 10. PURAN SAH S/O SAHDEO SAH, R/O KAHRA, P.S. SAUR BAZAR DIST. SAHARSA. 11. BINDESHWARI YADAV, S/O DEVANJEE YADAV, R/O JAIPAL PATTI, WARD NO. 42 P.S. AND DIST.- MADHEPURA. 12. MURARI PRASAD SINHA, S/O LATE RAMPYARE RAM, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE HAIDAR CHWI P.S. KHORAMPUR, DIST. NALANDA. 13. UDAI NATH MISHRA, S/O LAXMI MISHRA, R/O ALAM NAGAR P.S. ALAMNAGAR, DIST. MADHEPURA. 14. ANANT PRASAD SINGH S/O LATE BUVNESHRI PRASAD SINGH R/O VILLAGE KHOPAITI, P.S. & DIST.- MADHEPURA. 15. CHANDRA BHUSHAN SINGH S/O SATRUDHAN PRASAD SINGH, R/O VILL. KHOPAITI P.S. & DIST. MADHEPURA. 16. NIRANJAN MISHRA S/O LATE GANGADHAR MISHRA, R/O VILL- RAMNAGAR, P.S. KUMARKHAN, DIST.- MADHEPURA. 17. UMESH PRASAD SINGH S/O ANIRUDH PRASAD SINGH R/O VILLAGE PAMA P.S. SAUR BAZAR, DIST.- SAHARSA. 18. RAM BAHADUR KAMTI S/O LATE UDHAV KAMTI, R/O VILLAGE PASTPAR P.S. SAUR BAZAR, DIST. SAHARSA. 19. MAHESHWARI RAM S/O BANILAL RAM R/O VILLAGE SAHUGADH P.S. & DISTRICT MADHEPURA. 20. SIKENDRA KUMAR S/O LATE PURAN YADAV, R/O VILLAGE NARAYANPATTI, P.S. BHARRAHI, DIST. MADHEPURA. 21. MADHU SINGH WIFE OF ANIL KUMAR SINGH, R/O VILLAGE NAVTOL, P.S. MURLIGANJ, DIST. MADHEPURA. 22. SURESH CHANDRA DAS, S/O SURI DAS, R/O VILLAGE-JAYANTI P.S. AND DIST. MADHEPURA (JHARKHAND) (ALL OF THEM ARE ERSTWHILE EMPLOYEES OF MADHEPURA- SUPAUL CENTRAL CO-OPERATIVE BANK LTD., MADHEPURA. ------ PETITIONER- RESPONDENTS IST SET - 23. THE RESERVE BANK OF INDIA THROUGH THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, RURAL PLANNING AND CREDIT DEPARTMENT, CENTRAL OFFICE, GARMENT HOUSE, DR. ANNE BESANT ROAD, WORLI, MUMBAI-400018. 24. THE BIHAR STATE CO-OPERATIVE BANK LIMITED, ASHOK RAJPATH, PATNA, BIHAR, THROUGH IT’S ADMINISTRATOR CUM MANAGING DIRECTOR. 25. THE MADHEPURA, SUPAUL, CENTRAL COOPERATIVE BANK LIMITED , MADHEPURA, THROUGH DISTRICT MAGISTRATE MADHEPURA CUM LIQUIDATOR. --- RESPONDENTS- RESPONDENTS 2ND SET 5 For the Appellants : Mr. Piyush Lal, AC to AAG 3. For Respondents 1 to 63 : Mr. Basant Kumar Choudhary, Sr.Advocate & Mr. Sunil Kumar Singh, Advocate. For the Bihar State Co-operative Bank : Mr. K.K.Sinha, Advocate For the Intervenor-Respondent i.e. the employee of the Chapra co-operative Bank : Mr. Shashi Shekhar Tiwary (in LPA No.992 of 2007) For the Appellants : Mr.Piyush Lal, AC to AAG 3 For Respondents 1 to 22 : Mr. Yugal Kishore, Sr. Advocate & : Mr. Sunil Kumar Singh For Bihar State Co-operative Bank : Mr. K.K.Sinha,Advocate For the Intervenor Respondent i.e., Employees of the Chapra Co-operative Bank : Mr. Shashi Shekhar Tiwary (in LPA No.991 of 2007) ----------- 11. 24.12.2009 Both the appeals under Clause 10 of the Letters Patent of the High Court of Judicature of Patna raise a common grievance with respect to the order dated 27.04.2007, whereby C.W.J.C.No. 5862 of 2004, (Pankaj Kumar Parmar and Ors Versus The State of Bihar and Ors), and C.W.J.C.No. 8499 of 2004 (Nand Kishor Singh and Ors Versus The State of Bihar and Ors), have been disposed of with the directions stated therein. A brief statement of facts essential for the disposal of the appeals may be indicated. The basic facts shall be drawn from the C.W.J.C.No. 5862 of 2004, except by specific reference to any other proceeding. The writ petitioners were employees of the Madhepura Supaul Central Cooperative Bank 6 is under liquidation which has rendered them jobless and functionless. Looking at the human aspect of the matter, the State of Bihar issued certain communications, advising different Central Cooperative Banks in the State of Bihar engaged in banking business to take the employees of the said Bank on deputation. Different cooperative Banks in the State have taken the communication of the State in the right earnest and the right spirit, and are in communication with the Bank. Consequently, options were invited from employees of the Bank (under liquidation). Their options have been forwarded to the different cooperative banks. The delay taking place led to the writ petition. The learned Single Judge has advised the State of Bihar to ensure implementation of the terms of the policy decision hopefully within 2008. Two years have lapsed after expiry of the period contemplated by the order of the learned single Judge, notwithstanding which the communications of the State Government have not been implemented. Let the issue engage the attention of the State Government. The appeals are accordingly disposed of. Sym/ (S.K.Katriar,J.) (Kishore K. Mandal, J.)