IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 21810 of 2011 Amit Kumar, son of late Ram Snehi Bhagat, resident of village – Prahladpur, P.O. – Prahladpur, P.S. – Mushari, District – Muzaffarpur ……………… Petitioner Versus 1. The Union Of India 2. The Secretary, Ministry of Labour and Employmnet / Shram Aur Rojgar Mantralaya, Government of India, New Delhi 3. The Divisional Manager, National Insurance Company Limited, Muzaffarpur 4. The Regional Manager, National Insurance Company Ltd., “Jeevan Prakash”, Frazer Road, Patna ……………. Respondents ---------------------------------- 02. 16.12.2011 After having heard learned counsel for the petitioner and the counsel for the Union of India, the Court opines that it is an ill advised Writ Application which has been filed on behalf of the petitioner, who claims himself to be son of late Ram Snehi Bhagat. The reason for saying so is evident from perusal of Annexure-5, which is the award given in Reference No. 31 of 1992 by the Industrial Tribunal No. 1 at Dhanbad. Petitioner’s father’s service was terminated and the reference was with regard to his reinstatement in service on the ground that the management had committed illegality by resorting to such an action. By detailed consideration of evidence, the Presiding Officer of the Tribunal rejected the claim of the so called employee, who happens to be father of the present petitioner. Even from the pleadings and assertions made in the Writ Application, there is nothing to show that the father of the petitioner was a permanent employee of the respondent- management, the National Insurance Company nor has he 2 brought any material on record from where he draws his right for compassionate appointment. If that be so, then obviously a demand made for compassionate appointment by itself cannot beget relief from this Court in the background that the father of the petitioner was a casual worker and there is already a judicial adjudication against him. There is no right or claim subsisting in favour of the petitioner in the above background. Writ is dismissed. SKM (Ajay Kumar Tripathi, J.)