^ #» Petitioner Defendant Respondents Plaintlff HiGH COURT OF CHHATT3SGARH AT B5LASPUR Writ Petitaon (Art.22?y No.S78S of 2008 Saysd Naiyyar Hassan, S/o-Sayed Libe Hassan, Aged about 60 years Raza Sody Buiiders, Bus Stand Road, PJo.-Bharkapara, Dlstrlct Rajnandgaon (C.G.) Versu^ Joovan Chand Kotadia S/o.-Pukhraj Kotadla, Aged about 52 years, R/o- Ksmptee Line, Rajnandgaon (C.G.) CvVrit Pstitionunder Articis 227 ofths Constitution of india) Mr.Anoop Mazumdar, counse! for the petitioner. [Vir.Yogosh Chandra, counsol fortho respondent/ (SB: Hbn'bis Mr. T.P. Sharma, J.) ORDER (14-12-2011) 1. By this writ petition under Artide 227 of the Constitution of Endia the petitioner has chalisngsd the iegaiity and propriety of ths order dated 7.4.2008 passed bythe Flrst Civii Judge Ciass-i, Rajnandgaon, in Execution Case No.58/2000, wheroby tho First Civii Judgo Ciass-l has dssmissod the appiication fiiod on behaif of the petitioner under Sectson SO of tho Codo of Civil Procodure for exemption from attachmont of tho toois of artlsan. 2. I have heard icamed counsoi for the parties, perusod the ordor impugned and other documsnts fiisd on behaif ofthe petitioner. 3. As per appSication fiied cn bohaif of the petltioner, tho prosont petitioner ss ownor of workshop whero body of bus & truck wore propared. Sn tho appEscation or anywhsrs the petitionsr has not msntionsd that he is artisan, intsr aija, as per appiication he is owner of workshop where body of bus & truck woro preparod. 4. Toois of artisan are sxemptsd from attachmsnt, but not toois of ownsr of workshop. By dismissi«ng the ©ppiication,the triai Court has not committed any iijegailty warranting interferencQ. 5. Consequentiy, ihs writ pstition bsing without substance is iiabie to be dismissed and st is horoby dismissod. No ordor as to costs. M Sd/- ^ p. Sharma Judge