IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA LPA No.1199 of 2009 WITH LPA NO. 1202 OF 2009 1. BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSISSON THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN, P.O. VETERINARY COLLEGE, PATNA. 2. THE SECRETARY, BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, P.O. VETERINARY COLLEGE, PATNA. -RESPONDENTS/APPELLANTS Versus 1. SRI BHAGWAN PRASAD, SRI KAPIL MUNI PRASAD, R/O MOHALLA- LALA TOLI ROAD, WARD NO.4, P.S. DUMRAON, DISTRICT-BUXAR. 2. MUKESH KUMAR, S/O PALTU DAS, R/O VILLAGE- SHAHPUR, P.S. BIHPUR, DISTT-BHAGALPUR. 3. KIRPA SINDHU GOND, S/O RAM PRAVESH SAH, R/O VILLAGE-SUNDARPUR, P.S. PIRPAINTI, DISTT-BHAGALPUR. 4. RAJESHWAR RAM, S/O SHIV NANDAN RAM, R/O VILLAGE-RAMPUR UGAN, P.S. MOTIPUR, DISTT-MUZAFFARPUR. 5. PAWAN KUMAR, S/O KAMLESHWAR YADAV, R/O VILLAGE-NEKTA, P.S.SUPAUL, DISTT-SUPAUL. 6. MANOJ KUMAR MANJHEE, S/O LATE LAXMAN MANJHEE, R/O VILLAGE-BISHARIYA, P.S. SINGHIYA, DISTT-SAMASTIPUR. 7. RANJEET KUMAR RAM, S/O REET LALL RAM, R/O VILLAGE-RAMPUR, P.S. WARISHNAGAR, DISTT-SAMASTIPUR. 8. PRADEEP BAITHA, S/O CHANDRIKA BAITHA, R/O VILLAGE- SUGAWDIH, P.S. SUGAULI, DISTT- EAST CHAMPARAN. 9. SHIVLAL BIRU, S/O SRI KARU VISHWAKARMA, R/O VILLAGE-MOHAMMADPUR, P.S.HILSA, DISTRICT-NALANDA. 10. UMESH PRASAD, S/O SRI RAJENDRA PRASAD, R/O VILLAGE-JHITKORIA, P.S. MAKHDUMPUR, DISTRICT-JEHANABAD. PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS -RESPONDENTS 1ST SET 11. THE STATE OF BIHAR. 12. THE SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE AND LAND REFORMS, GOVT. OF BIHAR,PATNA. RESPONDENTS/RESPONENTS 2ND SET 2 4 24.11.2009 Heard both sides. It has been submitted that similar matter against another candidate Rajendra Mochi was pending vide LPA no. 140 of 2008 which was dismissed for default and finally the restoration petition bearing MJC no. 820 of 2009 has also been finally dismissed on 12th October, 2009. It appears that the order under appeal has also been complied with. In view of fate of similarly situated candidate already decided by LPA no. 140 of 2008, both these appeals are dismissed. ( Shiva Kirti Singh, ACJ.) (Shyam Kishore Sharma, J.) AAhmad