{1} fast2637810.odt IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD (1) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26378 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Sanjay Bhaurao Patil another Respondents WITH (2) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26381 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Ramesh Ramdhan Patil & another Respondents WITH (3) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26353 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Bhagwat Raghunath Patil another Respondents WITH (4) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26349 OF 2010 {2} fast2637810.odt The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Ramesh Keshav Bavaskar Patil & another Respondents (5) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26357 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Chindhyu Lotu Chavan (deceased), through L.Rs. & another Respondents (6) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26361 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Induabai Totaram Patil & another Respondents (7) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26366 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus {3} fast2637810.odt 1 Yuvraj Tapiram Patil & another Respondents WITH (8) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26369 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Namdeo Keshav Patil & another Respondents WITH (9) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26375 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Shamrao Keshav Patil & another Respondents WITH (10) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26372 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Vatsalabai Ramlal Patil another Respondents WITH (11) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26270 OF 2010 {4} fast2637810.odt The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Raghunath Tulshiram Chavan & another Respondents WITH (12) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26267 OF 2010 WITH The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Santosh Vithoba Patil & another Respondents WITH (13) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26264 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Suresh Shenfadu Patil & another Respondents WITH (14) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26277 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant {5} fast2637810.odt Versus 1 Vitthal Tulshiram Patil & another Respondents WITH (15) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26261 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Mango Sitaram Patil & another Respondents WITH (16) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26274 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Nirmalabai Shriram Patil & another Respondents WITH (17) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26258 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Shriram Jairam Patil & others Respondents {6} fast2637810.odt WITH (18) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26399 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Sampadabai Rangnath Patil & another Respondents WITH (19) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26395 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Rajaram Sitaram Patil & another Respondents WITH (20) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26392 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Ishwar Ramdhan Patil & another Respondents WITH (21) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26385 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, {7} fast2637810.odt Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Baliram Ramdhan Patil & another Respondents WITH (22) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26407 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Sindhubai Dhanraj Patil & another Respondents WITH (23) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26389 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Atmaram Raoji Patil & another Respondents WITH (24) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26403 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Shivlal Mansaram Patil {8} fast2637810.odt & another Respondents WITH (25) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26193 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Anil Dagdu Baviskar & another Respondents WITH (26) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26679 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Hari Khandu Kakade & another Respondents WITH (27) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26206 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Sanjay Pandit Baviskar & others Respondents WITH (28) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26200 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, {9} fast2637810.odt Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Anirudha Raghavrao Patil & another Respondents WITH (29) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26212 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Yogendra Dinesh Patil & another Respondents WITH (30) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26218 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Pandurang Shankar Kolhe & another Respondents WITH (31) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26224 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus {10} fast2637810.odt 1 Prabhakar Chango Patil & another Respondents WITH (32) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26187 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Jankiram Sitaram Patil & another Respondents WITH (33) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26190 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Vasant Tulshiram Chavan & others Respondents WITH (34) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26194 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Jairam Tukaram Choudhary (Patil) & another Respondents WITH (35) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26199 OF 2010 {11} fast2637810.odt The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Ananda Narayan Patil & another Respondents WITH (36) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26207 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Dhanraj Shankarrao Patil & another Respondents WITH (37) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26214 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Anna Ramlal Patil & another Respondents WITH (38) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26220 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus {12} fast2637810.odt 1 Ashok Shenfadu Patil & another Respondents WITH (39) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26432 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Ganesh Dhanraj Patil (deceased) through L.Rs. & another Respondents WITH (40) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26423 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Raghunath Narayan Patil & another Respondents WITH (41) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26412 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Nadarbai Shenfadu Patil & another Respondents WITH (42) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26454 OF 2010 {13} fast2637810.odt The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Atmaram Tukaram Patil & others Respondents WITH (43) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26459 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Dnyaneshwar Hari Patil & another Respondents WITH (44) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26438 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Sambhaji Rajaram Patil & another Respondents WITH (45) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26443 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus {14} fast2637810.odt 1 Totaram Tukaram Patil & another Respondents WITH (46) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26418 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Navnath Raghunath Patil & others Respondents WITH (47) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26426 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Sunil Dagdu Baviskar & another Respondents WITH (48) FIRST APPEAL ST.NO.26448 OF 2010 The Executive Engineer, Waghur Dam Division, Jalgaon. Appellant Versus 1 Shivaji Shenfadu Patil & another Respondents {15} fast2637810.odt Mr.S.D.Dhongade, advocate for appellant-acquiring body. Mr.K.S.Patil, T.S.Lodhe, S.N.Kendre, AGPs for respondent-State. Mr.A.B.Kale, advocate for rest of the respondents. CORAM : R.M.BORDE, J. DATE : 29th July, 2011 PER COURT: 1 Heard learned Counsel for respective parties. 2 The order dated 3rd May 2011, passed by this Court in First Appeal No.630 of 2011 and other companion matters, is brought to my notice. 3 The house properties acquired for the purposes of construction of Waghur Project was the subject matter of adjudication in the above referred First Appeals. In the instant appeals also, the subject matter of adjudication is house properties, which were acquired for the same project. The date of publication of Section 4 notification is common in the instant appeals as also in the disposed of First Appeals. The award in respect of the house properties, which is subject matter of instant appeals as well as the award in respect of the house properties, which is subject matter of disposed of First Appeals, is also common. 4 In view of this, for the reasons recorded in the order dated 03rd May, 2011, passed by this Court in First Appeal No.630 of 2011 along with companion matters, these appeals also do not deserve any consideration. 5 These appeals are, therefore, dismissed, however, there {16} fast2637810.odt shall be no order as to costs. Pending Civil Applications do not survive and stand disposed of. R.M.BORDE JUDGE adb/fa2637810