IN THE HI6H CQURT: 01'' (SHATTlSiQARH AT BffiASPU^ ICG) WRm'gtITIGNJSO, ^ ^.2004 PETmONER ^w\ .« ©ovindDas,aged about : £!&years, son :Qf Shn Kalipad Das, • . •R/O. , viltage^ - BhetKarbhat. COlofty, ; Tali. DhaFamjaigarK, DistriGt. ' - Raigarh (Chlia.tfisgarh) ;^/'ERSEES. -i.S^K' ^^"\ :fc:; :1'.'; State of Cliliattisgarh^^ Thru^eQllector, Raigary ;'I^ ' ^: .Pnncipal, ^ D TiS4ning;., yCenfre ; ;^- (liiet),. Dl'iaramja.igafli, • 'Tah. ; • and; Bisto-iet.Raigarh;(C.G.}.'i ^ ^ KvtEaar ' Vyay ,; Singh, aged ^abQU:t ^,S8,. years^, 'S/p.,. Eate CharEdraehurn Prasad' Sin^i i.Judey^"'" residenf .r, ^ .^pf. ^DhaTamjai^rh,.~: ^ DistnGt ; - I^igarh (ChBa.ftisgarhiy '.' ^ ..-^' WR[TPET!']®N^JT EIL&8@GI.E22a^^^ :TI!^&./;'.;;.:-',:^ ^:; '-;./'1'\.;:'^^ m mKi !'ii';" B'lli'j 't^ i'.^ii' 'K .lli11 :.aa .--.'^^ 181 i»IBis-3 '1 T;"'!' » !MI ffi jcWlfcti^'- .^ftlt^anl'w ffilMI; it:i-!~ti tsRf -3'^"<tl|^t^Itl^»T&f;tis,-Ktyi'?i<|<. ^,......"£Lfc^?;;] 3roE%^SI^^^i^^6 TO!nR^ftB3iita t9.3..^S5 ,'; < On a roeritioii^'bsin.g ina4 Shri A^N. BUakta, comis Shri Samjay' S. Agraw^ resTiondent No.l. None appears on hefaalf^ | ShriM.D. SIiaTina, coujGt ; As agFeed; i.ipon'.by leant heaid for .fiual disposal. The petitiQuer lias prefei fhe Coastitution of India, beuj passed te the Civil Judge,| petifioner^s applicatioii under Procedure hastoeenrejected. Leanied CQHBsel for th^ fatber piirchased^itlie' latyl 16.6.1995 QiiacQasideratioii .Biov^d :for 'eiltr?oBtus naiae iqectedoii 7.1;. 1997' pn.fhe alrpafiy sold toy fttie iather' of i Ma&h'ya. Pradesh. ''iBeiag aggru the Court of Civ:il|:yudge, 'Clas; order of tlie Sub^DavisiortaI- ot^the plaint pleacled 'Siaitfm. revenue reeord, .^(lien. Iie 'is «<>Kifi!J<il-ii||t|cii'iE'fe'ak<(<! Stt' '' '• ^ ^ ^^aiRi*t anSia ••-•isy ;, the matter is takea up forheaTuig. ' sl for ffae petitisaer. ^ 1, Goveniiileut Advocate for the Stafe/ Cif^respbndeitf No.2. ^' ^6ljbE;respohdeatNo.3. , ^ : ' icd.eoiuisel ior tUe parties^ the inatter is 1. "•.•'.•'• ' '. '. "'•: :-: ' ' '.' .. . Eed-tliis writ petifionjunder Artide 227^ of ^g ^grieved bv fhe orderdated; 7.4.2084 Oass-I, DIiaramjaigaT&, wliergbyl fhe jOnler 6 Rule 17 of the: Code of the lOyB '^petitioHer sufaiBits thal fBe 'petitibner's (n; 'questiipir ;fi?in responden-t' N0.13: on: t3f.;RsM5,OQO/-. Afterthat, fhepetftioner. . 1.1tti:ie Nazul recprd, but his prayer 1was, lgEoun.3 ffaat'fhe land :in quesfion iwasl |resppndent;No.3 to tlw Go^eriiaient oT^ ^veS. by iSSaS, •fbe petitioner filed a; sujffi iiil i-I, iBUaramjaigarh;, &r setting iaAie|e j1!la& ji Of|ceildated.^;1.11997,;£uiaalSQ^in^>yrai;lil.i)| jj<;ase','Iite'|sai:ae^is^.:not,:recprdgd^M^|!ft)S^ eiiltiSeet Ibr'Mie corisideiatioff^a^ |]ian^lff<R[^i ^ iNFSl^R^'^l^ ^s •'v 'ssf .-M[tf i<n<<, :;®-al*t<is, __^_.-..^^s>..®^ 3i^!n-i:[a^.i(<jcij^i<i^: Hniwd^sii^r .Rs.45,000/- along^wifh simTile Interest&Qm. respondent No,3. Eeanieil counset for .the;pel2ttioBcr {ilrfl^er s^ fhaf thfi glea has atready been taken-.m fhe plaiat; aow 3^-wai^ to aiiiend the lelief clau^^^^ flae petitioner ?waBts to add':pE plaintiffis ;notTegisteied jn^the againstrespoFtdenfWo^SfQrRs. Leamed couiisel fbr Q\e (ra 14 (1) (a) fhat iii case •Qse naiae Of [reveiriie record fhen a deereebe passed; |t5,OQO/- plus mterest. ^ - , 1: Ipetitioaer also subinits that siace fKe pleadnig was'alicadv^ iu para I^.lGF'of:tfae^p sougMin relief.clause bnly, fhe|refbre, fhe^t^ rejected;^ his plea. •; He furtfa.e aUowed,: &e petitioner wfll rea^ily pay the .couyt fees as chai^eayie oa the relief asked.ifor. On the :o1|her faand; leam! the ameBdiaeitt oy the ground; .ainount of •Rs.45,0'00/- alojpii the ainendlnGii.t^applicatiQntlie >bt<filCTi<^t>tPl?t? ^l (sw)l '<lul^$t^ ; ^? •^RPT^ftc^t l ^;' ^ submits tliat iif fhaf ainendinent. M^ Kt ^d:courisel for respondent No.3 objeeted. jfUai in. the first aistaiiee, fhe petitioner has not iuentji3ned;:jn the apgtieation for aiaend.ineiif.fhaf.how'inucfa court'feeswffl^ei^aMaiidwhepierliieis ready.to Siace; the sint is simpIiGitOT ,ft?^^d.eGlaratk>a, therefore, fhe ainendDieirt sQugIlt for caitBof be allowed., Haviag; liieard 3earned-eoi(nsel for the parties, I llave perused/flie 'Vlil SlliP' (.e pfaiat shows fbat ia the atfermatiye, if^ record. peTusaI ofjpaia. 10 oftlj tlie laitd in. questioa wasnot r^; aajoe of the petitiQner, thea Kie is entifled to get tMe GOBsjideisrtioaj3 corded.in fhe Nazul Departmenf' iii the; •with^ situpte UTterest. ^ Tbereft)ire;r ffiie; alteniali^'pleaiwas7 alrcadv tli^re,'^^a^ '!;:;.-:i' Mi'i Ipetifioaer It&s not asked -thM !how;imi®li!^ spKj^sKse—nnsxio—swQfk j:|i llilr Blfflli'l ilir gn^i;!6t Ifrjitiii llii ^?i?n^T^ffll^ SQma ^ GREK,] ^^••<ti<;ti<yiAI,.s9iil*tys,;,tsK");i*i^ ^^W^.Mv.i 3(1^1^1^'(T@^S15EB ^«roOT'^rftETsn^Tf 16 ariEl court fees Jis; gayable^aiicl he i( CQUiisel for fUe'petttioncr subrait Thei?efore, looking to th^ askuig for amendiiient ra fhe Qugfat to' Uaye^ allowed tlae; s; dispute between the.^parties circuiastaiices, this' ^wat peti| impugned orfferdeserves to Tse Beamecl counsel ft>r aBiendment is allcwced' thea ;fK< the legal points agato.st the,,iclit to hjm •uii.derfhe law. : The prayer^eeins ta TUerdbre,' fhe petitioii ij quashed, T^ triaL:Go'uTt is thfiipleadings^itK^lJte.fioyj^^^^ •the^iSQUrt^feesstbe^ 'arcteltdlmgat ShaIl.'faeieBLfMic^-fQraise •s3iuSSt law^ia.his'wrr ii?stafeiiieiif.."'1 ; Inyiew (tf'tlu]s;OFdery^M;p^ Parties;are entitled for rfcUef ?it<fl^t«fll^ffl^ff ^f ^M <P*ri^i^ ^ -a(R(it <nt^l ^^[ i^^ready to pay. Af fhe outset, tearnBd. ,j|| |ts that he will readfly pay;tlie court ^feeS. •^ abc^ facts, siace ffie petitioner was;. clause only, the leamed trial Gourt.'l: ^m.e ia order to .finally adjudicate 'ttie fbr just decision of fhe ease. tn ttie tion, deserves to ;be. aUowed jaiid fhe <|uas<hed...':!; • .;.: - •:''-.!.; '" ^1;. ; ;:.-': : y No.3 furiher sublaits' that if •Qie" I ^ (lelendahi iaaiy.be allowed. to raise aD ^f sought by fhe petitioner, .as available :'ai:K:Efair.":''':"'..-'^: ' . •, • allowed aiui fhe iinpugned order is ^to allow th.e^pietitiQiier.to amead lelaase also aiid thaf:ti;>o onj gsyment of 'be^allowed.^ ^RespoiLdeiit:No.3 hei-etn togal ^aleas;avaiEable % luiu H.nder ithe )P.No,t248/2Q04staBfls.(iisposedof :copy ofthis order. dlrected ceiNfied Sd/- , L.C.BHADOO Judge