IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR. ' WRIT PETITION NO. OF 2006 PETITIONER : Dr. Smt. Anita Singh, aged about 42 years, W/o Dr. Sunil Kumar Singh, LectureY Chemistry, Posted at Government Higher Secondary School, Lafa, District Korba (C.G.) VERSUS . RESPONDENTS : /1. State of Chhattisgarh, Through: The Secretary, Schedule 'Caste [and I Schedule Tribe y Development Department, D.K.S. Bhawan Raipur (C.G.) The Commissioner, Tribal Development Department, District W 7 ‘ W :Eaubmco.) The Collector, Korba District Korba (C.G.) . VThe Assistant Commissioner, Tribal Development Department, District Korba (C.G.) The Principal, Government Higher Secondary School, Lafa, District Korba (C.G.) r WRIT PETITmN UNI) CONSTITUTION OF ‘ WRIT ’ SICERTIORARI ETC MANDAMU THE LIKE NATURE ETC.‘ ’2// APPROPRIATE i F THE INDIA TLFOR I ER ARTICLE 226/227 0 SSUANCE OF AN 1N7: THE r NATURE . 26R DIRECTION/ORDER IN XI-HC—78 mmm » %3?f§w:m%¥T : ._ §.§.?.20§6 WP. Nbs. 3§23/2006, 3524/2006, 3525/2006, 352é/2006, 3527/2096, 3528/2096, 3523/2066, 3530/2006, 3531/20G6, 3533/2006, 3534/2006, 353?/2C!06, 3540f2056, 3541/2006, 3542/2006, 3E43/2§0é, 3§4-4/2006, 3§45/2006, 354é/200$, 354772006. 'Shri Rajesh Faraday, Advgca e for the pe?ifioners. W 5hr? Sumesh Bajaj, ' respondenfS/Sfdk o'n advance ca y , Hedrd'.‘ The main giiévaride raised by fine pefi?ionars is common and cammon issue is invéivea infhese pefmans, i'herefore, they are bang dispesad of by ‘miS common crdar‘ .' By i'hzse pe?i‘?icns, ‘gha §a‘3’ um‘s, whe am wsrking a$ Lecfumr' in varieus Highar Seconéary Scho is cf f’r’re Diswic‘r Korba 9f 5mm a? Chha??isgnr‘n, have’ quasfionec? f a iegcdH'y & correcmass of ‘rheir fraasfar order aimed 7.7.2Q0é {Amexure F—l} issazd uncier fhe 'signamre of Under Secre‘ ' 5c¥iedmed Ca‘sfe & 5chedu§e& Tr ‘ Thé gmunds cf chaiienge of 'fhis nrder, as raised by fhe, ge‘i‘mchers, are‘ "rhcr? fha Sacra? ry 9r The Undzr' Secre‘mry has m juris£icfién 1’0 p‘usis‘fhe‘ 5m?ugna Tmrasfar erdar, as #‘ne‘ Coun5e§i§ng ,—\ .vemman‘f Acivacafe fcr- The o Gavemment of Chhaff£sgarhf Devaiapmem Deparfmem‘, Raipur. I PIC. m § , i m XI—HC~78 3am, Wan—<5,W H$k o o..oo.oo.o.oooo.oovoo ,‘ Wm (W) mam wmm ' WW§WW mmm at I amaqanasr C0mmi‘i’?ee is emgowereci m issue ”transfer arders Maia?- The Raiiana§§zafian Scheme: dafec‘ L.6~2006, :rher'efgra #ha impugaea’ Wmsfer 0m”er‘ §ssued by respondanf N31 is wi‘rhou? juriséiciian and nuiii‘nj in fhe ayes 9f Iaw. ‘i‘ae Smw (Eavzmmenf has alreaéy daiegafed fhe powers of irans‘erring fhz feathers 1'9 caunsei§§ng cammi‘rme consf%fufeé a? fhe Etafaz iave€ artist" i‘i’xe m?iam§izaf§en sciizame dai‘ed L62G§6 ané ‘3’he 3mpugne& “transfer arder has baa: issued in fiagr'an‘r viaiafien of fi-ae provisims can‘fainesi in Poms 5 :3: 6 of ?%1is ra+€ona§iz$ien scheme. ¥7erusai cf impugned oréer Annexure P—1 whereby fhe petiiioners have been fransferrep’ as aiso fhe rowigmiiza’fian scheme dafed £62606 skews fhcn" "riwz ‘pe?i?§erxs are miscenceived,‘ fer fhe reasws 1"ha'é' ‘riqe impugned order under. whieh frag nefmcners have been ’a‘mns‘ferr-ed has been pas ed on admin§sfmf§ve gmuncis. This weer has n91? been passed und r fhe mfiem¥§zatien scheme dafeai 1.53.2006 and fhe same has been p eed by ‘r§1e Eavemmen‘; in exercise of genera? powers 3'0 frens'fer ifs meieyees. Perusd of mfionaiizu‘?ioh cheme émed 1.6.200$ shows feed“ where en accounf of ‘h‘ansfers, p mefions & reeiremem‘s the number‘s of teacher‘s have became irrcd'ie, a} in various schoe§s baking To fhe members of smsients Le, where on accmmfr of abave menfioned reusans in one schooi number's of teache have beceme iess 1 or’ 2 er where RT.O. XI~HC-78 / RW,WW,W W 0 .ooo.¢oooc.o‘...mo.q. .V mm (W) WWW mwffwm WWW ' mmm ~32~ . ~ *%3T%11311%¥T " ‘i’he numbers of feachers have (:xceedeti more fhan *{he requ‘ired ‘3um§:ers of taachars, in fhaf case :rhe concerned departmem, as arwisagad in i'he scheme, wi§§ corisi‘i'é'u‘m a counseHmg commiffee arid afTer cciégc?§ng infcrma?§9n from ?’ne various higher sacmdary schoais or midd§e schools or primary schods, fha cancemeci ssmmiffee §ha§§ rafiemike ‘I’rhe wumbérs m‘ ‘i’edchar's in aach scmds '3eQk§ng #9 fha numbers ef smden ‘s. if has been envisaged fine? fine memmitfee is 'm ensure fha? in no i mse of high school m? less fhan our teachers and in case of hé'gher seconciarv schaoi no? iess Than six achers. er fhcd' fhe impugneé order ms been possed' under féwe ‘oéminis‘r e gower‘s ma ‘3'he éovemmen? orx adminis%mf§ve grounds and ?§1is der has aafhing fo do wiirh i'he irafioaalizaf§om scheme da‘red £6. 066. The §ovemmenf .is always ioyees and \f‘ne m?roéue?im of mf§om¥izcxfion sckeme does ne’r ei'e any bar fha? 'f§1e concerned- deoarfmen'r of ‘rhe Sm‘re Govern em is no? emggowered fo Transfer ‘ i‘?s -feochers in f’ne adminisfm‘rive exigency or in The pubm: inferesi’. moreover, a bare peruscd of The i'fions shows ’mu'r if has no? been mem§oeer§ in fhe yefh‘ions *Hm? €’hese weesfere m d paréicmor :igher seconoary schoo! numbers of #eoehers has become iess s§ocm imary sc§1ooi remair: iess 'i’htm Two m? iess than fhree washers, m faachers, im case of middk scha V e A3 has been meh?ioeed ea r w r empowerec§ ‘vo ?mr:s‘?er §fs e P.T.O. r " E m e p f y e XI—HC-78 wmm WW§WW ' ,«1/ v emm , R93han/- . exceeéed baking 1's ‘d’aa mm é'eachars or numbers of wachers have af i’he pefifieners are n6? mm‘ £11) {2) (3} bars of smciems. Therefere, fha pafi#ions 1Tainab§a for fhe reasens -?haf; The order impugnai a? fhs: (Eav’emmen? ' ' gmund and if ”ms m mfiom§§zai=§cn schem ér: fha pefi‘rions if ha: "fmnsfers ‘H'xe princi; has bean viio§a+ed Le. n? feachzrs have blmome less fhcm ‘Hae required numbers 01: Washers under The any gar?icu¥er schce§ The areas m" giver: 16.2006 end of ms 52w passeé Lmder fhe generai pewers a fmnsfer i?s empioyaeé oa adminésfm?§ve J? Ezen passéd under ‘fhe 5&éé schme Le. a abied 1.6.2006. S no? been aHeged '‘vhcw cm accoun? cf fhese ie enunciufed in the rufiémiizafion scheme on acmunf of These fransfers fhe numbers "afionmiza‘i'ien scheme or have exceedeci m cmzWa‘riy‘ 1‘6 fee refienaiizef§m scheme. “i'ion cf fhe mfiomiizai’ien sceeme cim‘ea‘ Eavernmen? are diffe 3enem? powers of fransfer of Swine : insfcmce cemes '?o \‘he no?ice of 1%2 a? liberi'y Ta‘make a regresenfafien f9 #é'xe Hewever, f any sud pe‘?§?§oner ! fryer! ‘i’Jfzey wiii be ewhoriw comemed. In View of iéne abeve, f? Comequeney‘ M.(W.)?. . .r’eh'a‘. re pe'tificns 5mm dismisseci. fer gran? 0f smy eise gends dismissed‘ J sw- L.C. Bhadoo Judge W K ” Manama; wane, Wat ' o WWo.r....o‘.‘~.oo.o‘o.&.g m 200 WW (W) i‘he required numbers 0 f