EN THE EEGH CGURT OF JUEICATURE CHE‘ TTISGAKE '3“ BILASPUR wymo {420 z 2313 'F’etitjoner : Lam-nibai @ Kumari Ba; < . Aged abaui r35 yeargi W/O RaJ Kumar R/‘e Viiiage: v 'T‘mbahar {Eear Bade Masjrié} S/o Eihagi Samara; Aged aebut 30 years, Ca—ewna a: whisk ‘I‘rastar N¢CG»§0A/545é ami Treliey KQQVCG—13Af5457’r E10 Viiiage Gherbandha, Tlhapa £3 T€hsii t“ Lei-mi, Est : BilasgpuNiEEg Eiiaspm, Thgga Tamara? Bihspurj 'W‘w‘i & Dist . ‘v’6r3“3 :1 Ganga Ragga“, 3/9 Rati Ram, hged abzmi 42 yEarS, Caste~Satnamai, 3 Ff .drn ’45} ‘Prsaa E/‘O Aijm‘; ”ii-ab: Agai abeut 2'6 yearS, t CaStr: ~ Samam, 'Ehz: men vehigie (iiiver Tf‘af‘gi’ Na.CC—10A,i5456 an: ‘ . NQ‘C(}—1GA/‘ 34517, Permanerit ‘ ‘Ihama R/‘Q Viiiage Karaméagai 35 Tahsil — Lorrai~(C.&.)_ 4. Janak Ram, E “wax. Sic Mam‘aikhggs Aged abou: 56' yearg, ,$¢5i"” 3" 4v . ‘K' a“”lR - CaSte ~ Sf mam; CG=G K-mer 9f the Ve§g$ 'I‘rat’f: r IQsEGilGA:5456 m6! Trellgy NO‘CG—lfjAjSéiE? Rio Viiiage Ghenghaparg, Thana $5 Tahs}r ~ Lsrmi W sganéemw , Diemia‘nt N03 5. Ssnu Q[ .W Eefméam fiat? . $hiv Bag Sig Shiv H‘asad, Aged abaut 4:3 yearS, Ce—cwner. e.f Vehide Tragtor Ne.CG—10Af S456 aim. "i‘mikay NO‘QG-EGA/545‘T, Rfer Bandhawa Thana W5 Tahsil — ixmnHQGj Re$g’,C§£eats[ ‘ q ’ Befe'néam ' ’ m5, :7‘. ’Tne €0m§any Grientai Limitad, Insuranc/ BiviSionel @ffiee, Biiasgur, Eist ': Ejiaspur—iafm * W XI-HC-78 HW,~WW WKMg .... nun mm mW<W> ,W £56K x a1 200 4V “i g“ WWEMW §€Wm matmm 09/02/2007 Shri Rajm'sh Singh Bhagel, counsel for the petitioner. Heard on admission. The Detjn'oner has Older dated 19/ 1/ 2006, bv which, her propriety of that part of the application dated 1419] 20( )5 (LA. No. 3} Eed under Order 1 Rule 10 {1) 85 {2) of the Code c If Civil Procedum for adding her as a ciaimant nartv, has been d: asmissed bv the Claims Tribunal. A nemsal of the im Duaned order would show that in a pending claim peu‘tion med Second Additional Motor Bilasnur. on account of dea Lth of one Manoj Knmar, this petitioner had filed the aforesaid app lication. The above claim petition was hled by the mspondents N mother and father of the aforesaid anolication (l.A.Nc l.3\ on the ground that in fact she is the J natural mother of the deceased and she should also be added as a DartV—claimant in the matter. The 1ea1ned Claims Tribunal after going though-the applicaton and the document med in support thereof and further aiter hearing the contentions of the respondents No. 1 8a 2 diFmissed theirpeititi'on holdingthait the challenged the validity: legality and by respondents No. 1 & 2 before the Accident Claims Tribunal Mungeli 3.1 8n 2 showing themselves to be the deceased. The petitioner has nled the‘. “\v» Q$ deceased med by the claimants in which claimanthespondent No.1 has baen shown to be t7 been shown to be the mother c other documents showing the; As far as provisions i concerned the mincinles of dc dominus Iitus in a suit to chc does not chose anvbodv as a d proceed at the risk of the pilaintiii‘ and in case the person so 1e father and msyondent No.2 has if the deceased. It has also Ielied on elationship between the parties. )f Older 1 Rule 10 of C.P.C.. is minus Mus applies. The nlaintif is >se the defendant and if the olaintin‘ efendant in a case the suit could IO. claimed is found to be a necTssary p:rty it may M also. .In the XI-HC—78 3a imam, Wm,W VIM-Ma 192:0 .2 6% Wmoo ..o.. 00: o 000E 200 mow WWW Wmeeiawr) WWdWW Wwmés '&' s‘mm petitioner does not prima facie appear to be a neoessarv oartv in this case as according to the Tribunal prima facie she does not appear to be the mother of the deceased. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the Claims Tribunal ought to have allowed the aforesaid annlication and it should have adjudicated the matter in presence of all the parties, who axe claiming to be the de ndents of the deceased. The Claims Tribunal has relied upon the ontentions of respondent no.1. in Which he has denied that the titioner is his wife and it has also telied upon the contents o some cei Lilicate of Class-6 of the ,c § i?, XI—Hc—78 3am, m,W . W lax/9 .1L/za/2 w/ Wm ....0... 0ooo§o¢o‘oo‘o 111 200 WW(W) M P.T.o.