m MM IN THE HON'ELE HIGH GOUR’I‘ OF Q-IHATTZESGARH AT BILA£PUR WRIT PETIETQNNO. {we /o3 // 4’ i PETI TIONE RS ; '7 C? gqvkr’ Smt. Prakashi Devi widow of late Rajbeer Singh, aged about 5O years. Sachin Kumar s/o late Rajbeer Singh , aged about 22 years. Both R/o village & P.O. Chhur Teh. Sardhana. Distt.Meerut (U.P.) xax$gl%‘ .o- ‘.‘ a; 9"\‘;}L&”.,uu Xv v‘ g ;” If?” t\. I“ M VERSUS f RESPQDENT N u State of Chhattisgarh Through— The Secretary Department of Home Mantralaya D.K. Bhavgn’i‘ Raipur (C.G.) § WRm PETiTmN UNDER ARTICLE 22 OF THE cONSTITJTION OF EN WE NATURE OF MANDAMLS, APPROPRIATE NATURE . vi imiE INDIA FOR ISSUEANCE ‘OF WRIT, ORDER (JR/AND DIRECTION ‘g CERTIORARI OR OF ANY OTHER ‘ 3mm W . MHelzcog 200 ............ ..... . ..... .. mmm’w‘w mw f€€t®w $3rfmané‘a i4§§n2QG4 Shii IVLRS. Bhaaa CO 111361 101‘ ne paihonsiS. > gun A K 11W'L‘i, Govt. Aclvocat~3 for thr: State/ I€Spond€11t The perimmm‘S havs pi‘afermdthis; Wii‘i patition under Alticla 2H6 Gf {116 Cansiitution cf ic11a far axEcmrg “(16 msmonle J, tatt‘ to grant compasswnate pointmEnt o p mummy n0 2 and alar‘ fox gm: 1 of P3. ifO 00V! — a pensm hicumwid on médx al Veatiae 1 of Eats Rajbmii‘ Smgh, it has Ewen man ionxi L1 L11? pausii that husband of pswnionel no i Jhi fat of pmiticnm‘ 110.2 Lats RajbaEf Siugh was a Subvhmpemor 111 C6 DqxJtmEnt m 1k, msm 11116 Sta‘m of ' M.P,, aim (luring fix: €01 1‘36 of employm6n£ 116 C1ieii in harlmss on 25,306] 2002, “In tha y 1990 1am PcJbém‘ @3211 “71¢ man f6 “"611 to Demt-swacla Dimrict which is a Naxaliza c ieciml araa 9.1a a SonsitiV€ area Wberc 116 r .mained up to Octobox; 1996 Emd 111611 11k ‘ was tran sfm‘md to Burg miuw, Themfore, 115 was J‘ Dantewada DIST‘ict 101‘ a psriod of a sax, 9:116: whiis ramairimg 111 Dzmtavacia 0’1 (0301111? of mfectimi 1; his; LXCI 1m bacame 31c}: a11d for tha‘: purp: sc hr: had rect’i T16 métdicai traammnz from van us ingtituti ‘1s at 1 £11 “v 11 Nags, McCrut, glad Na? Ddhi aiid 116 remainsd 1103pita11'2éd for sovsral muss 21116., .mpnr; about R31,50,0GO/— out of ich a )01t RS 1 of? D‘WQ‘ was; spoilt 011 . :3 xomaL 1112 R5 20 0G0: was $13611: ‘11 T tyavaimg andotlmr exyonsos, Lam Rajbeer Sixlgl‘ wag s 111131310 from “Cirrhosis with mailcJ Seaman 81m w aTiC failuro" alld 111timat=1‘ 116 {had 011 HP L hJ go s “ $‘ 1 v d i C z ‘ 1 ) .................. ................. m ......................................... man WW %MW ‘W‘ amt mmmw Cl) $Wm &wi'e1a‘vfga ___;~\ \ ‘25,? ()6; QOGQ. Copy sf t L1€ dEath camiicam iS Ann'sxum P/ 1. Wh€n h€ was §30St€d at Dmjewaéa ha Se: t his family meinlmrs to his 11a+‘VE place Mae-nit. Tlimréfom, psiin‘onm n02 took big 6tiuca?ion m vario‘iw gchool$ at Nkelnt Dissmict. AftEr cieath of hi$ fathar, petitimaa n02 appliaé Jot comimssionata appointmént alld Savaral— apph‘sau‘ons wem mcwéd by him and ultimatsly on 22/021200?) nespomieni’] State mjedsd ths mqugSt of t1}. patitionex n62 for g§vmg him € gulcymm E an comyagSiQnam gmund Oniy 0n the ground ihat 11s had 5m died from oumida tin: Siam, th€refors, ha; czmnot b5 giV€n amp yment on compassionats ground, T116: v ground taken by ma raspcndmfi is arbitraly for which the‘f petitionsr cannot b6 r161 ied for th€ compas'siozxatts appointmant. Returnwhas bean filed on b‘shaK of 13x16 respomlcnt/ State in which ii has been 5 ttéc‘x that ih€ praym‘ haS hem} mjecmd c account of the fact €£ hiS cass Was not covorod under 1116. \ guidelines and ho had en his oducation from outsk‘ze ”£116 State; AS far as tho quéstion of ro'lmbursemont of modical oxponsao‘is;? concemmd, 11o billfs 1'1 this rogard have boon receivoci by tho aiisworing mSyondent Emd if tho bilio am submiitod by tho; petitionors, mo Sama “m b6 audited and permissible amount b6 reimbul‘Ssd aS par 1'1 les. K havo heard loan ed counsol for “tho parties. Leanwd counsel or idle I‘cspoodont,’ State vary fairly arguod‘ that tho. potiooner 1102 was denial compaooionato appointmont 011 111$ educatioo from outsido tho Stato as, ho ground that 1:16: too : d i u w XI—HC-22 \H WWWW 3 (33 mmiiwm %amm par the instructions issm O HOE] 2600. He further mm w: 200 m d bV' the €1‘S‘Lwhile Siam of MP. 011 Submit$ that dmse instructimis W61? i3$ued by the er3twhi1€ gum: of M.P., 110W€vsr, 1at6r on, on 10,106f2063 th€ State of instinctions alld £13 irhesx imposad, therefm‘E, ths ca3‘ compassionate appoiutma Ghhattisgaxh has iSSuad tha levimd instructiona no such coaditiom is i of tha pétitioaex‘ caix b6 considemd fm‘ 1t as per the sxisting 113163 if the pEtiticner :102 lappli€s f6? 1116 sam€ to which com18€1 for m6 peti‘dmlei‘s has no o’bjaction. coulls‘al for th€ p€§iti0n€r 81x1 having umstances of the c2153, the pmitioner iS ailad to rgspondemtf Siam Wirhm a perieu of onB month from tocla“ and 1'11 turn, respondmltf Stat€ will considar his appiica‘rian 1'11 accordamce wifh ‘rhé Cxistmg H1163 and instnlctions regarclmg COL paasionate. appommmnt‘ and aftsr considarmg tha caSE of $116 pe‘titionrir 110.2, orderrs within a paiod of 3 Havmg ' heard learneL ragard to ihe facts anti circ aHowed to malm a def compasskmate appommm far repmsanamion and apply 1 , shall pa$S appropriats meiltha. As far as medical expensea aré COHCEmsd, 1116 mapo 1dt3111/ Stats said tha‘i no guch bmS regarch‘ng m€dical tmatnmn hava béen SubmiueCE by ‘thc—t patitioner emd if tlm paritionem will st bmit the malical 1.31113, the $33116 will b6 scmninized and‘ consixi d alld ‘the medical expenses as admissibie will bf; paid t0 fie pstitionsm. With ‘t‘fl‘e abOVE abs wa‘dons a11d directbim, Tim pmition stands diSposad of, } t 3 e Consupmntly, MAMRNO. 1289/2003 aild LA, NaSSQG also Stand dispos€d of. Sd/— L.C.BHADO Judge C61't3ii6d copy aS per 11:163. HS O