IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.12241 of 2005 1. DR.SRI BHAGWAN SINGH, SON OF SRI MAHENDRA SINHA, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE TETARI, P.O. MOHANPUR, P.S. GAURICHAK, VIA-PUNPUN, DISTRICT PATNA, AT PRESENT WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF DRAVYA GUNE-GOVERNMENT AUDHOYA SHIV KUMARI AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 2. DR. BASANT KUMAR THAKUR, SON OF SRI RAMDEO THAKUR, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE SIMARDAH KALAN, P.S. MAJORGANJ, DISTRICT SITAMARHI, AT PRESENT WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF ROG VIGYAN (DIAGONYSIS AND PATHOLOGY) IN GOVERNMENT AYODHYA SHIV KUMARI AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 3. DR. INDU KUMARI, WIFE OF KRISHNA BALAK RAI, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AMROR, P.O. SINGHOUL, P.S. SINGHOUL, DISTRICT BEGUSARAI, AT PRESENT SHE IS WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF AGAD TANTA AND VISH-VIDHI IN THE GOVERNMENT AYODHYA SHIV KUMARI AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 4. DR. SANJAY KUMAR SINGH, SON OF SHRI VANSH NARAIN SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE BARAIPUR, P.S. CHOLAPUR, P.O. KATTI PATTI, DISTRICT VARANASI AT PRESENT WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF SHALYA (SURGERY) IN GOVERNMENT AUDHOYA SHIV KUMARI AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 5. DR. KEDARNATH, SON OF KRISHNA NAND UPADHYAY, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KACHHAWADIH, P.S. KACHHWA BAZAR, DISTRICT MIRZAPUR, AT PRESENT WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF BAL ROG (PAIDEORIC) IN GOVERNMENT AUDHOYA SHIV KUMARI AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 6. DR. AJAY KUMAR SINGH, SON OF SHRI AMARNATH SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MALOPUR ROAD, P.O. BACHHGAON ROHANIA, DISTRICT VARANASI, AT PRESENT WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF SHALAKYA TANTRA IN AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 7. DR. AMRENDRA KUMAR SINGH, SON OF DR. RAM NARAIN SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE 15 GANDHI NAGAR COLONY, NARIA, P.O. SUNDERPUR, P.S. SAKALDIHA BAZAR VARANASI (U.P.) AT PRESENT WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF ROG VIGYAN (DIAGONYSIS AND PATHOLOGY), GOVERNMENT AYURVED COLLEGE, PATNA. 8. DR. ARVIND CHOURAISIA, SON OF LATE VISHUNDEO CHOURASIA, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KHARHAT, P.O. KULU MALIK, P.S. SAHEBPUR KAMAN, DISTRICT BEGUSARAI AT PRESENT WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPA RTMENT OF PARASUTI ROG, KOMARYA BHRITYA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, PATNA. 9. DR. SHRIMATI MADHU VERMA, C/O DR. B.L. VERMA, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MALHIPUR, P.O. MAHESHPUR, P.S. GAJWANPUR, DISTRICT BEGUSARAI, AT PRESENT WORKING AS LECTURER I NTHE DEPARTMENT OF SHARIR RACHNA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC MEDICAL COLLEGE, PATNA. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- PETITIONERS Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH SECRETARY, MEDICAL EDUCATION AND INDIGENEOUS MEDICINE (DE-CHI CHIKITSA), DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA. 2 2. THE SECRETARY OF ADMINISTRATIVE AND PERSONAL REFORM DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA. 3. THE CHAIRMAN OF BIHAR PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA. 4. THE DEPUTY SECRETARY, MEDICAL EDUCATION AND INDIGENEOUS MEDICINE, DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA. 5. THE DIRECTOR INDIGENEOUS MEDICAL (DE-CHI) GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA. 6. DR. VIJAY SHANKAR PANDEY, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF SANA SKRIT SANHITA AND MOULIK SIDHANT, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, PATNA. 7. DR. MAHENDRA PRASAD SINGH, SON OF LATE MAHABIR PRASAD SINGH, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF DRAVYA GUNE GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, PATNA. 8. DR. UMESH CHANDRA SINHA, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF DRAVYA GUNE, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 9. DR. RAM ADHAR SINGH, FATHER’S NANE NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE POST GRADUATE DEPARTMENT DRAVYA GUNE, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, PATNA. 10. DR. SHANO GUPTA, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF DRAVYA GUNE, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 11. DR. GANESH PRASAD GUPTA, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF DRAVYA GUNE, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, PATNA. 12. DR. BIRE NDRA KUMAR SINGH, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF DRAVYA GUNE, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, PATNA. 13. DR. SUMESHWAR SINGH, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF RASH SHASTRA AND BHAISHJAYA KALPANA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, PATNA. 14. DR. BINOD PATHAK, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF RASH SHASTRA AND BHAISHJAYA KALPANA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, PATNA. 15. DR. SHASHI KANT CHATURVEDI, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF RASH SHASTRA AND BHAISHJAYA KALPANA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 16. DR. CHATURVEDI KAMENDRA DEV NARAYAN, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF RASH SHASTRA AND BHAISHJAYA KALPANA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 17. DR. SHYAM SUNDER GUPTA, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF SHARIR RACHANA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, PATNA. 18. DR. GARGI PRASAD SHUKLA, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF SHARIR KIRYA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 19. DR. GANGA DHAR SINGH, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF SWASTHA BRITYA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 3 20. DR. AKHILESH PRASAD SINGH, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF SWASTHA BRITYA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 21. DR. JAI KUMAR SINGH, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF AGAD TANTRA AND VAIBHYAR AYURVED, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BHAGALPUR. 22. DR. JAI SHANKAR PRASAD SINGH, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF AGAD TANTRA AND VAIBHYAR AYURVED, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 23. DR. (SMT.) USHA MISHRA, HUSBAND NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF PRASUTI TANTRA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, PATNA. 24. DR. SRI NIWAS TRIPATHI, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF ROG AND BRIKTI, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 25. DR. VIJAY BAHADUR SINGH, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF KAI CHIKTSA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 26. DR. AKHILESH KUMAR JAISAWAL, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF KAI CHIKTSA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 27. DR. (SMT.) DEEPALI SUNDARI VERMA, WIFE OF DR. SHYAM SUNDER GUPTA, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF SHALYA TANTRA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, PATNA. 28. DR. BIRENDRA KUMAR PANDEY, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF SHALYA TANTRA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 29. DR. KUMARI UMA PANDEY, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF SHALAKYA TANTRA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, BEGUSARAI. 30. DR. VIJYA NAND MUKHUPADHYAY, FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN, WORKING AS LECTURER IN THE DEPARTMENT OF SHALAKYA, GOVERNMENT AYURVEDIC COLLEGE, PATNA. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- RESPONDENTS For the petitioners :- Mr. A.K. Choudhary, Advocate Mr. Mahendra Prasad Sharma, Advocate For the State :- Mr. Shankar Kumar, A.C. to A.A.G. 15. For the B.P.S.C. :- Mr. Sanjay Pandey, Advocate ******** 7 28.2.2011 The cases of the petitioners are fully covered by the judgment delivered in the case of Dr. Surendra Kumar, passed in CWJC No. 4193 of 2005, disposed of on 23.2.2011. Sanjay ( Sheema Ali Khan, J.)