INJIjE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR W.P.NO. ^?^?oo6 SSKISLE esiM Petitioner ..f N.P.Biskia S/o Shri G.P.Biskia, Aged about 55 Respondents State of Chhattisgarh - Through the Special Secretary, Forest Department, DKS Bhawan, Raipur (C.G.) The Divisional Forest Officer, Dhamtari, District - Dhamtari (CG) Shri R.C.Meshram, Asstt. Conservator of Forest, posted in the office of PCCF, Forest Department, Raipur (C.G.) WRIT PETITION UNDERARTICLE 226/227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA s2 XJ-HC-22 ^-5} .<(!^["1;4. »ri'[yiS.far"rF?I'r;? 3TCTI^T Kwsn^ g?ii w?^ 3TT^T VW, \^P ?•? 33 lcx, wc'^n'gTwaR'""""""""" ' "'""<^ iw 'fq^a' 12.5.2006 Shri Anand Kuinar Tiwarfi, Advocate for the petitioner in W.P. No.2533/06 and for respondent| The petitioner in W.P. No. 1832^ qTOiciqr-?wn -q fs-pS •.if^-<:5T{ q; 3if:-m 31I^fl No.3 mW.P. No. 1832/06. Shri P. Diwakar, Sr. Adv|ocate with Shri Kunal Das, Adv. for 06 and for respondent No.5 iu W.P. No.2533/06. Shri Sanjay Kiunar Agarwlal, Panel Lawyer for fhe State. Writ Petition No. 1832/0^ ffled by petitioner-N.P. Bi&kia and Writ Petition No. 2533/06 ffled are betng disposed of by this < relate to same coatroversv. Leamed P.L. for fhe State behalf of the respondent-State i! |by petitioner-Rara Charaa Meshram {•ominon order, as both the petitions very fraiiltly submits that no reply on needed in fhese writ petitions. Petitioner-N.P. Biskia pr^ferred W.P. No. 1832/06 questioniiig the legality, propriety & corre (Annexure P-1) whereby he WE Divisional Officer (Forest), Siib by the petitioner were that the of baa period, same waa politii transfer. It is settled law that trans ;tness of fhe order dated 9.3.2006 ^s transferred froin fhe post of Sub 1-Division Birguidi, Disteict Dhamtari to the office of Principal C^uef Conservator of Forest, Forest Department, Raipur and petiti^ner in W.P. No.2533/06 Shri Ram Charan Meshram, was transfer^ed ia his place. The groimds taken transfer was not possible on accoimt ;aUv motivated and was a mid term ter is an incidence of service and same can only be questioned, on th^ ground of mala fide, being against •VSTff / X..!-HC-22 SiraiqiT h-iii vi^ g?RWBf?T! -sS: ^Pi-^T. 'g'rft'TTT?, Ri^PRT; STT^T ^ra^ WB'yn yirq? •^ 200 f^?a" 3n^?I '???iTW TfRrtT roufad ovetr Govemiifient •th^t the statutorv rules or the al coiapeteat to pass the order. As far as the grou^ examination is alreadv 12.5.2006, thereforc, that gij period is concemed, fhe iia^ was passed with fhe appro) therefore, fhe State As far as political motivation| bv which it can be held moreover, dunng the course| the State submits fhat Shri stnce 2001 and fherebv he wtuch is tavo veai's raore public servaat on a substance in fhis wnt petiti< Iierebv disinissed. As far as W.P. No.253j; concemed, as has been Divisional OfEcer (Forest) dated 9.3.2006 aad when he| perforce he filed a petition of the oider dated 9.3.20061 daterl 25.4.2006 he was aJlo^ Thereafter, the Speciaj| C.G. vide onder dated 2.5.2( participar 'WT'iyr'il^ w-9 ~s. fs^ •<f5iTZK ^K 3Tf:?Ttf .STe-fl jufhority who passed fhe order was not of inid-session is concemed, the df, even results are out and today is ijoiind does not stand. As far as the ban ^ugaed order itsetf shows that the saine (val of the Chief Miaister of the State, passed order by relaxing the bau^ |is concemed, there is nothuig on recdrd how it was politically motivated and of argiMnents leamed Panel Lawyer for Biskia was working on the said post has ahnost coinpleted 5 years teniire, fhe normal teniire of postiag of a post. Therefore, I do not find auy tlliaa n, same is Uable to be disinissed aiid it J3/06 filed by Raai Charan Meshi-am is metntioned earUer, he was posted as Sub Supa-Division Birgudi, Dhamtari vide order 'was not aUowed to joni on fhe said post, bejfore fhis Court to ensiu-e the compliaace aad in pursuance of tbe court's order red to jojn on tllp sairl post. Secretaiy, Forest Department, Govt. of 006 canceUed the transfer order of the-. Et" OS »s A^ ttEys.ayi] 3§pnf oopBiia-3-q -/PS psqsBnb Aqaisq si ^uattqjBdaaj pspsdg sqi .Cq passed gQOS'S'S pS^Bp iiie.iqss]^ ae.reqo Titey Aq p3{g 90/CS •psqsenb aq o^ saAiasapj psiBp ">jnoo snp jo -rspjo sip 8i (g-d amxsuHv) 900Z'S'Z pairp j^ fBTy. ^ p3}SOd SBA J3UOT}T(3d 3Tp pUEJ pue ^sod sares sip ao S-IBSA g }noqi Bi3[Sig -cfti uqsjo aoiipad ^UA3ip i^pao ps^ep -rapjo j3i[jre3 }Q 30TiBi{diao; •hn Utqg gmioaxip vaisiqsayf ir&reqj) passBd gooe'fr'SZ psiBp jspao s^no; SBM JSpLlO STtp ^Tp SAOqS II 30BJ SI^ i^U); h&lls S;- t&SJ, ^. JMriA k^lsifil*. S3IIU JSd SB Adoo p3T)T)J:30 1S3UOJ ''O-OJO 'IAOQ ',UB}ai03S j3pio sip pire paAOQB ST ^SS-ON 'd'M 'linsai atp ti[ j-iapjo sno 'aiojaisqi •900Z't'-SS lTJ|3ATIin3Jt3 01 -TSpJO m p3SSBd panSndnn AOTI piie 30B[d p3-SJ3fSTIBIl SBA 3I[ AqAl SI }Btp ^ 3oms Siiiniir(Hoo SBA 3q lerp Vfi pauopaam aaaq ssq sy •900S-£-6 sqi ajnsu3 o^ iTtsaeABAins mey Aq p3{g uoppad IUA ar sip }U3Amnaiio o^ ^snf psssBd Tt0 '900Z'£'6 psiBp jaiioppad in ^ P?JK iftua.i. I..&UB .ftS-^y fiZ ^B.......................................'feUllfe IKtti.tt sfauis&t 'ahrt[p.« 'ByibiJBi &£.