4 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICA_TURE OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR 03y!s!an F.A.MNo. .....L.6....../2011 APPELLANT : NON-APPLICANT. ^y' RESPONDENT APPLICANT »-•* -. ^" ...--"' v^fv^""'^ »*rf""''^l / ^ ^y>~~ „ _ Oa^®a-""Q^ " VERSUS Mahadeo Sonkar S/o Late Shri Ram Lal Sonkar, Aged about 56 years, R/o Indira Nagar Ward No.4, Rajnandgaon, District Rajnandgaon (C.G.) Dulari Bai W/o Late Mahendra Sonkar, Aged about 30 years, R/o Village Ganesh Chowk, Dhamtari, Distt Dhamtari (C.G.) MEMO_OFAPPEAL UNDER SECTION 19 (1)0F TH^ FAMILY COURT ACT ^_??^"L?_5' ^*^i*"i<!TT?^' 1 ^'-?:» ^^Ty^.? A^T'T-T'S^.A ???.? &T1 VS?? ASSiS??^? tzi^rl ^/^U^.i ^Jfy ^nErs.^^L 5. Le^^s^&.E^sra. ^s.a, £?s.i^^&.e5£-'L?^^ U!1VSS1Q1E. ISSELCi^ nott'Bie san l.1tl. yua&usi MO'l.a'Die ^iifi sur. i^isi.a^uiaaiss.t <J^. f-a.a'-i ^Wtf^ ^ _^' .rf^.":fc t^e\vs < A.yr'Eii.haJS'i^ ?IS??-APPUCAKT Miuiaclcu ooiiKai' KiSoruUUISHT; ^i.^-rja.F i^Lliail Gfcil R 19 11) OF •e~ ftt A eas"?y 'CT p^^s^^t; SIiri Aniu SIiukla., couusel wi.th tiie a.ppeliaiit. Shri P.P. Saliu, counselwifh tiie respondent. ©RAL [Passeu on 11s" oiAugust, 2011} ^©^i.lvl. viio.ciiiss.s sj. This appeal has been ffled. against ttie iriipugucu order dated 10-01-2011 passcu by tiie Fir'st Auuluonal Principal Judge, Faiiiuy Coui't, Ralpur Caiiip Court at .Dhanitari iii Case No.5/2009 on au applicafion ulcu u}" tlie rcsponuerit unaer Hccuon iy 01 nuiau Aaopuon aiia Maiiitcnaiice Act, 1956. 2. Learned counsel for the appellant suomittcu tliat no incoiue was. proved before the Cour't below and the respoiident had filed fhe case before the FauiUy Court for raaini.enaiice on uic uasis 01 sui'imses aiia conjecT.LU'es. •4-' 3 . Leai'ned counsel tor the r'esponuent lias suuruli.teu. th'at die respondent.was Uu'own out froni Uie house oi In- laws by inaliing assaults by her fatlier'-in-law, uiothcr-in- law etc. .after' deafh of her husbaiiu iii an accident anu, therefore, she fe Uvlij.g at her niater'u.al hoiuc. / v J 'A T~\ —*_ -f jC*- - .-.-?• ^-l-..- -I - —^-/ -I - t.-- - -_ oi'iei lacis 01 ine case ai'e uiai responuent/ciaimaiit Dularibal niaf'Tied wiih Malicnder Sonkar i.e. uj.e son of appellant 9 year's ago in DhaTutan. The appeUaut is fatlier-iii-law of tlie r'espondent and riis son Mahender Soiikar dicd in a road accident tv.To yeai" back. After hls death, uie respondent is residuig at her niatemal honie oecause sne was u'eaT.ea wiui. cr'ueiTy ai ner aiau'iruoruai house. Ultiiiiately, shc fued a petition before Uie Paiiiuy Coiit't claituuig niauj.tena-iiee 01 Rs.5,000/- per uionfti. 5. We have perused the record 01 tlie lower Court aiiu found fhat actually fhere is no proof of iiicouie of tlic appeuani. 'ine responaeni canie imo wiuiess uox aiia siaiea uiai ner' lauier-in-iaw (appeuaiitj is navuig uvo snops 01 uenerai McfcnaiiT aiiu ownea rwo Stonea nouse. Her moLher-iii-law seus onions and potatoes ui wholesale aud fhe appellaiit gets incou'ic of about Rs.500/- per day but her wltness Raiiisheel Bai 111 hef sta.tenient stated that Uie appellaiit is uic wliolesaj.cr ol' potatoes anu oruons aiiu rus wue seiis vegeiauies. ne is naving snop 01 genef'ai mercnauL anu owns uiree SLOiieu nouse aria ne gets auouT KS. ^— o uiousaiia per uay. 6. Therefdre, from perusal of fiie statements of respouucnL aiici ner 'wiLness Kaiiisneei isai, it. is cieai' Lnai fhcre are conti'adictions lii fheu" sta.teuients ajid it is also fourid tiiat there is no proof of uicome of the appellaiit. Thereforc; we ai'e of the ophiion that fuc luatter' requu'es reconsiaerauon ai uie ena 01 LUC ieai'nea 'JOLU'L uciow. .-.'S'3^-— i. ^ ui uie ugiiL 01 uie ODsei'yauons laaae auove, we auow LUIS appeai 111 pari, sei asiue uic iuipugnea orucr anu remiT back uie iiiatter' to the Court below tor uecision airesh atter -I f — _- -t -I ^ - ^ - ^. proviuu'ig opporTuiuTy t0 ine pai'ues ro aaauce imziier eviuence, u aiiy; 8. The records of the lower CoLu't shall be sent back witliout any tui'Uier ueiay. y. r'cu'ucs snaii appear Dciore uie uisu'ici uuage, Dhaintai'l ou 15th Septeuiber, 2011. 10. No or'der' as to costs. „.. G. Minhajuddin Judge I.M.Quddusi I Judge