......^2 ^^^) SINGLE BENCH IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR W.P.(S.)NO. a^??(9a> /2010 PETmONER: ^^ '^. <^.>w^^ L^-'" 0<<^<*' :-e^-' ^-' Kanhaiyalal Patel S/o Late Shri -Rajkumar Patel, Aged about 63 ypars, Retired Assistant Engineer, R/o Qr.No. 6, Krishna Vatika, Near Church Boirdadar, Raigarh, Distt Raigarh (C.G.) k^ .^. ^c' •^^^" ^v YERSUS RESPQNDENTS 1 / State of Chhattisgarh Through : The Secretary, Water Resources Department D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipur (C.G.) 2. ^ The Joint Director Treasury Account and Pension Bilaspur Division, Bilaspu'r (C.G.) 3. The Executive Engineer, Hasdeo Baraj Jal Prabandha Sambhag, Rampur, Korba, District Korba (C.G.) WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR ISSUANCE OF WRIT IN NATURE OF MANDAMUS CERTIORARY OR ANY OTHER WRIT OF LIKE NATURE ETC. The petitioner most humbly and respectfully begs to submit as under : - ^ ,,|N©n.,:l^r.l*|i,3St|ee'Pritinl<er::Djwalcer) ;:^rlt ;Petltll©n:1(S),:':N©.: 201Q :Shrl'D. R.'Patei ;,Shri;Ajlt;SfHgft,j /Challenge jn' th€'lpresent ::IKanhalyalal|Patel; 'Btate of Ohftattisgarh l'and: ottiers' :,,counsel •fcr:the^etitjoner.;: P^ foF State/respQndents.. ^' 'wnt.patltlon- jls .tG-the^oFdsF'd^eci- 27.02.2008 ,rAnnexyre\ P-2):;: passed.:by;:respQndent:;No.2,.dlF^^ recoyery!-bf::Rs29,5S7,'tom:thei.retlrai:dyes^N: €-'^^ ./ petitioner'has :prayed for^he fojiovving T6ilefs:! f0.2' 'pa^t,fs,%©^m:^y@dfes^ ^ may. [•N^^X:i:l:^e.'!'p?etsecf'.•fQ^caS- ^••^ -HofnWe.Cwft^ Sfor.lfhe:'eoto.:':.1 /®Go^.,o?;ff?e'.pe^?Q^e7'^Ss@. f^.3; /.%ef%?^,tf»fiaft?^':p^e:af,^^ ^s Hon'Qle'CQaff .,^ay'Nf?^^^::P^^e^:&:1^^8s^^ff^^::^^..^ . .•dfcfer' • date^. :f2^02.g001§;•• aBd,: Ai/t?er: ^NRtf^:. :fee1 .'^'. ,. .^5fe^l^e^Qr^f.^:t?@:^po^cfefffs^ ^(t/(;^l-smo^f:;'l:51;s^f7?:'0^:.^2§,5^ ;pe^^N^'..l'l^;.'''''.\.';-^ 10.4'' Tljar/t.fS-ffierB ^{jr8ye€l{fist-t^^ '^sy^^.^e^sseff.^.^m^'fftie'^s^on-de^te:1 ':to/;p8¥.recovefey.ampy?t.w^6%^mfe st.fQ;'ff)e: :pe^f?e^-..l^:j;^^;,;f'^ 10.5: Any .o^er|^^.^®^^?^'M.efe^m^<^,^ify tMs :NQfll?^:^offrf^^^^^d':;^^ef:^},;^@'fecIs'^ .CTrGyR^fanc@s'':Q^:^e;c8s©:lma^^afeo^elprovK^ .Mfewtfrof^e^e^o^e^'11^:."'' :ll:'r'':.1:<;'':.1l''''l:.:'.1:^^^ 2..Brl^fadsQfth€<5ase,.areffiat&e:p^itlo^€^^ ':.Water Resources:;'Dep§rtment:•snd Tetlred^ ^ ,Englneer';ion'30.09:.'2QQ7..':;;Bt:the'G^er:-1^ \€ i;li nl l&' ^/^ ;^1 recpvery of Rs.29,557 to bs eff^cted f^ orderfedbyltheTespondent.Nb.2.,';';l:'~:'ll;:1-^ "/i^:.^^'.. 3. ' ."Contentjon of'the•petltioneFis.'that.ttie olrder impugned.^ rec^vei'y has been passed without giw^ . heanng rand: ^wlthout/dlsclosing )lhe.;fact.' recovery;is^soughttobemade.;rHelsubmlts''thati^ ^merelyiiithas been::mentioned,'thatjsome^excessipayirienf:was made.to. ' the:petftioner. -.Counsel, :for the.pet|tlonertias placed.his rellance'on the; ', declsion::of'the^Supreme;C6urtin'lhematterofSahlb,Ram'v,State;of' HaryanaAothers'and.jn:fhematf8rof.Purshottam;LalDas;&^others;.^ v.:-State{of8ihar:&.^others.-:ln'ihese.No^decisions:|tihas.^ the 'Supr©me:^C6urt^that:'1f'the.le)^ss:^ wrorig'cQnstryc^oniofNevant.prderbytheauthQrityGoncemeclwithout- anywJSRepi'i|€ntattonon.:th:epartbftheempiGy^e,:nol,recovery"canbe made from the empioyee and If |She recovery |s aiready made, it 1s :(jableto beTestralned. .:..; : :.; .i',', .1 •, ,•:"-.•!.,,: 4.;! ;.' Couosei^ for the res^GQdents/State': subm3|ts/thgt.:State :has:.every. Tight;to rec6ver:the[e)(cesspaymentasper,Rule]65Qfthe'Ch Civiil;ServJGes. Pensions-Ruies,'1,976. .Ne.subiiTiitsjth^^ has not'produGed.any.material'toshowthatnp'Fsjoticewasgiyent^ .prior:to.pas3Jng,of~thejmpugnecj..prder.'ofrecGvery:sought;to'.;be'made fromhim. 5. •: 'Heard counsei.for the'partles anel, perused':the,materJall' available1 on record and ths judgments;,Qftlie'SupremeCc)urtGJted above,:". G., :. )n vlew: of'lhe above.fBctual'scenarld1 and the^aw.jaid down' 'by 'the Apex.Court, 'the jnstaRt..;:petIt:ioo! deserves: to.suceeed^and, the order: impygned-':dated;:27.Q2;2008: :(Annexur8'R-2)^regarding .^ Rs.29.557:is ilabie ito.be .setaside. •'!. ':, 7...^ Theresultjsithatthe.petjtlon'isaijowed^ain^.t^ Is set.ssjde..;1f'the|deduction.:hasaIreadY;Nen,:ma<je,fro'mi:th;9^ oflthe-petitsQner,:,tHesame.shaElfce.payabi;eto:Nm::w|th^l^ ^i'INiii^ttl ^ '^^ %^ 1-1 ^ ;-.-.3< .!, : • i1 : . ^: • ,.' rate.of:6% per annum.,: Needl^ss.to say thst -the: FespQndents can aiw8Ystaketh8rscQU{%e.tQ.Rul€'165.of.the.Ghh8ttisgarhClvrilServices (Penslon):. Ryles,.,1:976 ..if.so'aclvlsed .In acc^rdance wlth iaw.after 'foilowing'baslcprlnclpfesGfnaturaSjustice.,^ . ; " 8. • l:'Resujtantly,lpststion succseds. Sd/- Pritinker Diwaker Judge D >