'v 5! %^ -78 <iiq '<<iqwq, »"(ft<(t*l®,IfltC11«^i •<1*K'11<1»«W»"""——"•^•""7 """""•"^1^-200 ^t^M<^4si?iltlH911^ ^ir^i'wf^N' ^^ Sl»< ^Kiwt tiii?^ <w»<<^i «hi«i<-i4l-(MtwT-ii fet<a <^<<i< ^fr ^iRw 3?n^r W.P. (SKNo. 6128/2007 PETITIONBR Jagannatb{ Ram, aged about 42 years, S/o Dukharaaj Departme4t of Tribal, Govt. Giris Hostel, Kansabel, Versus RE8PONDENTS 1 2. 3. 4. Occup, Watermaa, in the Distt. Jashpur (CG) Thc S1|ate of Chliattisgarh, through the Secretaf5r, Department of Tribal Welfare, Mantralaya, D.K.S. Biiilding, Raipur, Tehsil riet Raipiir (C.G) ^siuucr, Tiibal Deparluieul, Tchsfl Jashpur (CG) Lssistant Coinixussioner, Tribal Develop|aient, Jashpur, Distt, Jashpur (CG) The Collector, Tnbal Welfsure Braach, Distt. Jashpu) Sliri Sandeep Stalia, Advocate Shri Yashwant Siiigh Thakur, r(CG) for the petitioner. Dy. Advocate Geueral, for tlie State, W.P. (StlNo. 1S07 /2008 PBTITIONER VrindavaG Assistant Lal @ Vrinda Lal Kurre, son of Shri Ramchara|a Kurre, aged about 55 years, pTeacher Goveniment Primary School Versus RBSPONDEN'TS 1. 2. 3, Nagoi, BloJck PaU, Distt. Korba (CG) The S^ate of Chliattisgarh, fhrough the Secretahr, School Education Department, D,K.S. phawaa, Raipur(CG) The C4>mmissioner, Tiibal and Wetfare Departi(ient, Chhatdsgarh, Raipur (CG) Assistabt C^mmissioner, Trifoal ajid Welfere "3"^ •<||WCT<(^®ntwi<5yfsmw*^ <(P»? 'itWWB(fe.< 3?n^[wRpnw n^(i <Mt^^i s^fi^n w w» ^^^^^Jilrtt<1^^ 1RSTOR'^ft^3Fnipll^ ^wiwft^HW^'?i'fet^ <Fai^i< ^fr^Ri*<^i^ DCT 4. Block (CG) Shri K.S. Pawar, Advocate for icnt, Korba, Distt. Korba (CG) Sducation Officer PaU, Distt Korba fche petiuoner. Shri Yashwant Si&gh Thakur, (Dy. Advocate General, for fhe State. W.P. ISllNo. 1533 72008 Anuit Lal[Patel, Son of Shri Keshav Rain Patel, PETITIONBR Versus RESPONDBNTS 1. The S aged ab^ut 46 years, Assistaat Teacher, Goveram.^Git Prunary Scliool, Vishvanathpali, Blouk Kh^i'sia, Distl. Raigaih (CG) 2. The As 3. ^ate of Chhatfcisgarh, through fbe Secrets|n^ Education Department, D.K,S. Bhawa(i, Raipur (CG) tsistaat Commissioner, Tribal aad Welfarc| Departmcnt, Raigarh (CG) Block pEducation Officer, Kharsia, Distt. Raigai^(CG) Shri Anil Mouiya, Advocate fo Shri Yashwant Siagh Thakiir, r the petitioner. Dy, Advocate General, for the State, W.P. (811 No. 1538/2008 PETTTIONBR Ratee Rajfca Naik, S/o Shri Dev Lal Naik, aged about 54 Secondan years, Leeturer Govemment Higher School Sondaka, Block Kharsia, Distt. Raifearh (CG) VCTSUS RBSPONDBNTS 1. The S|tate of Chhattisgarh, tiirough the Secret4or, Education Department, D.K.S. Bhawati, Raipur (CG) __ ,.^ ^^y ^. dnst; •^l'4t<'N>; Wtft-WKS) {®W(«^ NI*WWW*U<|T7 3T(^i'Wl^NF H^II o<i^<t wft^* ^I^M*#i^^Bp^l ^wwt «fe<y^^ -3' 2. 3. The Welfare Block RaigarhKCG) <{^1^< ^3tRW3iI^BT Aslsistant aad Commissioner, Tribal iDepartment, Raigarh (CG) lEducation Oflcicer, Kharsia, Distt, Shri Aiul Mouiya, Advocate fo^ fhe pennoner. Shri Yashwaat Singh Thakur, py. Advocate General, for fhe State. W.P. (81 PBTITIONBR 110.1562/2008 Versus RESPONDBNTS 1. The S Sibaru Rfifcn Chauhan, Son of Late Shri Lurka Raai Cha4than, aged about 52 years, resident of viUage Kpiataaga, Post Charaidand, Block Duldula, ()istt. Jashpur (CG) |ate of Chhatdsgarh, through the Secret^r)r, Department Schedule Tribes aad Schedi^le Caste Development, D,K,S, Bhawa^, Raipur (CG) 2. The Gt)uuiuissiouei, Schedule Tiibes aud Schedi^le Caste Developm.ent Department, Raipur|(CG) 3. The jAssistant Commissioner, Tribal Develo^ment, Jashpur (CG) Shii P.P. Sahu, Advocate for Shri Yashwant Siagh Thakur, qie peuuoner. |Dy, Advocate General, for the State. '3'^^Fffi?N??3^NPT^ {q<TKr^< *(J*KtlFW>* e £? ''^100 3T?^F "3RT fiplN? TW ^i^i sn*fi«i» ^KIW^ WXSW -^' <?»i^(^<Attwwt ^F fc^l <F»i^i< ^r ^iRfiy ^i^i W.P. (81 Ho. 1645 /200S PETITIONER Ram Kum|ar Gupta, S/o Daya Raia Gupta, aged about S2| years, Head Master, Middle School Sonhat, Bjlock Sonhat, Distt. Koriya (CG) Versus RBSPONDBNT8 1. 2. 3, 4. The Sfate of Chhattisgarh, through the Secreta^r, Deparfaaient of Tribal Welfare, Mantra(ay, D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipur (CG) The C<| WeUai^j The As{ Shri Amit Kiunar Sharma, Ad^ Shri Yashwant Singh Thakur, | inmissioner, Department of Tribal Raipur (CG) dstaat C^>niDiissioner, Tribal Welfare, Baikuu(Lhpui, Disll, Koriya (CG) The C4>Uector, Baikunffapur, Distt. Koriya (CG) focate for fhe petitioner, [Dy, Advocate General, for the State, PBTITIONER W.P.tSllNo. 1646 /2008 Smt Kar4na Jaiswal, W/o Ghaiishyam Jaiswal, aged abo^it 30 years, Upper Division Teacher, Middle S^ Versus RBSPONDBNTS 1. The S hool Mahalpara, Baikunthpur, Block Baikunth^ur, Distt. Koriya (CG) tate 2. 3. of Chliattisgarh, through fhe Secret^y, Department of Tribal Welfare, Mantra|^ya, D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipur(CG) The C<pmLmissioner, Departaient of Tribal Wclfai^, Raipm (CG) The Asbistant ComHdssioner, Tribal Welfare, Baikiu3(thpur, Distt. Koriya (CG) of Tribal s?n^? 'SRT 'RplNr ^Ttft ^A^t snimi <i-os(; ^((^((tx^ ®^|.(.|*t<S^(<«tW«|< *iwe"ny'(i^ii« ""^poe ^w^^w^ll^^|ie^) ^WII^K «^tl'atl^^R ^-s- 4. The (CG) Ci)Uector, Batkunthpur, Distt. Koriya Shri Amit Kumar Sharma, Ad^ Shri Yashwaat Singh Thakur, ?T *ii*mi ^alRn^n^r |rocate for the petitioner. py, Advocate General, for fhe State. PETITIONBR Versus RE8PONDBHTS 1. 2. 3, 4. W.P. (Sk Ho. 1647/2008 Prem Ch^nd Gupta, S/o Mewa Lal Gupta, s^ed about 50{ years, Head Master, Middle School Jamgahn^a, Block Baikunfhpur, Distt. Koriya (CG) The Sftate of Chhattisgarh, mrough the Secret^ry, Department of Tribal Welfare, Mantr^iay, D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipur (CG) The C^nunissioner, Departraent of Tribal Welfant, Raipur (CG) The Asfsistaat C-ommissioner, Tribal Welfare, Baiku4tiipm', Distt. Koriya (CG) The Cjollector, Baikuntiipiir, Distt Koriya (CG) Shri Amit Kumar Shanna, Ad| Shri Yashwaiit Smgh Thakur^ W.P. (S PBTITIOBBRS 1. Kush aged at^ Govemitient Distt. Rt yocate for ffae petiuoner. Dy, Advocate Generad^ for tlie State, Mo.SS32/2008 Lbl Venna, S/o Baldev Prasad Venna, out 45 years, Upper Division Teacher, Higher Secondary School, Chhal, aigarh(CG) _- ^7^T^T1^;TN7 Tf^T ^IT^T s^*l(<^ Wiie^ ^^[ ^^^ <??^RTT?, f^TR^ ^^•^^^^••••••••••••-••-•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••-••••••^joo- w^'^pFC'^i^5^) T^nw^f^ ^(^ ^ 2. Gendlal about VCTSUS RBSPONDBNTS 1. 2. 3, patel, S/o Shri Rohit Kumai' Patel, aged \1 yeai's, Upper Division Tcacher, Governn^ent, Higher Secondary ^chool, Chhal, Disttict, jRaigarh (C.G) The Sfate of Chhattisgarh, [fhrougli the Secreta[iy, Trial Welfare au^ Education Mauu'aJlaya, D.K.S. Bhawaa, Raipur (CG) The C^niniissioner, Tribal We^fare, Raipur (CG) The As^istajit C^mmissioner, TribaJl WetfaTe, Dlstt, I'jalgarh (CG) Shn C.J.K. Rao, Advocate for Shri Yashwa.nt Siugh Tha^kur, W\P. (S PETITIONBR Ver^uS Vishraui aged abo^ School Jaxijgir- q RESPONDEN-TS :L. State Secx'et4iy, Depailmeut of MaiitrglJ 2. Distiicl Chamfja ShriA.S. Rajput, Advocate loi} Shri Yashwaj^t Singh Thakur,| ^FPTfeT^T 'HW^f ^Ffe^ <f^-^t< 'sfr^Rmw^T pie peuuoner. \Dy, Advocate General, fo|r the State. No. 6632 /2008 ptn.gh Chaiidya, S/o Slui Baliorik Lal, ^it 54 years, Head Mast^r, Govt. H.S. jvachaiida, Block Jaijaipur, Distt ^hampa (CG) I flT> of Chhatusgarh, Uirough tlie' paya, D,K.S. Bliawaii, Raipur (CG) Education Officer, Ristt, Janjgii' (CG). me peUUonei\ Dy, Advocate General, fop the State. ^ Education, "3'^*<t(!Wt<<, W^Wt®,^K11«^< *(IN<'16%X(t<8||y ^t^te^?<^lte^^4|y4|l';-: w^rwi^w "^WW^l w*<i<v> kt^iWtttiw <wi^^ -7- PBTITIONBRS 1. 2. 3. 4. 6. 7. ^rzfey^ TTO^Iif -fe^ <F»t4^« ^T 3J^W 3IT^I W.P. IfSI No. 3/2009 Homaa |^al Bij|haikar, aged about 48 year, UTD, S/o Sh^i Mohan Lal Bijhaikar, Middle School Parrash^ Bk>ck Batod, Distt. Diirg (CG) Raju L^l Baajare, aged about 53 years, Astt. Tcacheit S/o Late Shri B.R. Banjare, Govt. Middle tchool Balpet, Distt. Daatewada (CG) Laxiuei41iu Kuuiai' Vishwkanua, aged abouit 47 years, illead Master, S/o Late Shri Neelldiaath Vishwk^rma, Middle School Keshapur, Dantew^da, Distt. Dantewada (CG) Vijayen^ra Sin.gh Thakxir, age about 51 years, UDT, S School Dantew^da (CG) Dwarik^ Ram Sahu, a^e about 54 years, Headm4®ter,S/o Late Shri Jodhaa Ram Sahu, o Shn Hitendra Singh Thakur, Middle an.warabhata, Dantewada, Distt. Middle (School Nakumai*, Dantewada, Distt Dantew^da (CG) Harinaijayaa Sharma, age about 54 years, Headm.4ster/ S/o Late Shri Rain Bharose Shaiiu^, Balak Ashraui Kcshapiu, Dautewada, Distt. Ejaatewada (CG) Santara4i Dhruw, age about 53 years, UDT, S/o Late Sl^ri Anjor Singh Dhmw, Middle School Kumhatras, Dantewada, Distt. Dantewada (C.G) Ram Pradhan, age about 57 years, (Teacher, S/o Late Shri Ghanabiitii Pi-adha|i, Govt. Adai'sh H.S. School Daatewada, 8. Madhu Asstt, Distt. E 9. Motilall larrtewada (CG) [Lal Dhruw, age about 59 years, Asstt. Teachef, S/o Late SIui Budhram Dhruw, Govt. Primar^ School Jaram, Daiitewada, Distt. '3^ '^wwm^ wAw»©>f«Ktr<-r^ <<f*^Ms~t «WBK •^200 w^ ^w^i^pBipf^ 3?H^ff'ipT lyWT ^t^lt^l^l (B»*f(<h ^ i^ww^tifca^A^i ^— 8~ 10. 13. Versus RBSPONDBNTS 1. 3. 4. Daatew4ia (CG) Tulsi Ra^n Thakur, aged about 58 years, Asstt. Teacher,] SchoolIj (CG) 11. Shiv Lal| Late Shl <»ii<<(w<il'i^tN^ff"? ^t <r»it^i< 'SfrstRpiy^nipft S/o Shn Banshi Lal Thakur, Primary luskel, Daiitewada, Distt. Dantewada Diwan, aged about 60 years, UDT S/o i Viraa Diwaa, Govt, Middle School Kumhar^as Daatewada, Distt. Dantewada (CG) 12. Narottai^. Singh Koiarra^, aged about 58 years, Astt T^acher, S/o Shii Raghuuath Sitigh Komarrst Bbys Hostel, Bhaashi, Dantewada, Distt. D4ntewada (CG) Nathma|Smgh Kanwar, aged about 53 years, Asstt T^acher, S/o Late Shri Dharmu Siagh Kanwar Distt. D4ntewada (CG) 14. Dewar Headmai Doundi, Prmiary School DhurU, Dantewada, 3iagh Taram, age about 59 years, rter, S/o Late Shri Cham Smgh Taraai, Govt, P^mLory School Khalari No. 1, Block Distt. Durg (CG) State | Govt. of Chhattisgarh, through Secret^|r)?r, Education aad TribaA Departiaent, D.K.S. (Bhawan, Raipur (CG) Asstt. | Conunissioner, Tribal Welfare Depai<t|iieut, Daulcwada aud Durg, Distl. Daate^ada and Durg (CG) Distt. (Education Ofl&cer, Dantewada aiid Durg, }})istt. Dantewada and Durg (CG) Treasu^y, Account aad Pension, Dantewada and Ddi^, Distt. Daatewadaaad Dm^ (CG) Shri Sonikant Verma, Advocat Shri Yashwant Singh Thakur, |e for the petitioner. [Dy. Advocate G^neral, forthe State. '3'S^i'<11?tK<1<t) ®^Wt*KS>f<»<rtt«*|< HMWIE W»IBW•-""——•""""-—•—•——••^^20® ^w^^ni^tf^R^t) 3:n^iwf?5w ^(^f s(»*(i<t> n^i ^l^<f ^wi^R ttfcci ^w^ ^ ^- W.P. (S PBTITIONBRS 1. Jodhan working] ^»i^(^i<ft^^if<?if"?fe^ <R»it^« ^siRww^ff I No. 192 /2008 Das, S/o Shri Sukheo Ratre, ag^ about 50 yeaj^, Post of Upper Division Teacher, Block C^ihura, Distt. Raipur (CG) 2< Lakhan Koshale as Govt. Ghl's Middle School Chhura, 3. 4. Lal Koshale, S/o Dewaaarayaa aged aboiit 55 years^ Post of Upper DivisioDJ Teacher, workuig as Gtovt. Higher Second^ry School, Dulla, Block Chhura, Distt, Raipzu- (pG) Jiwan E|as, S/o Shri Sanuadas Sonwani, aged about 5p years, Post of Upper Division Teacher, workingj as Govt. Higher Secondary School/Ka-rusi, Block Chhiira, Tahsil G, Distt, Raipm' y3G) Thakur t<am Patel, S/o Shri Chliedu Ram Patel, Versus RB8PONDBNTS 1. 2. 3, 4. age aboj workm^ Block (CG) iit 50 years, Post of Assistant Teacher, as Govt. Girls Middle School, Chhura, ;hhura, Talisil Chhura, Distt Raipur vvt. of Chhatdsgarh, through the Education Department, D,K.S. i, Raipur (CG) ssioner Tribal Welfare Department, j(CG) it C^Himissioner, Tribal Welfare lent, Raipur (CG) Education Officer, Tribal Welfarc Deparljment Chhura, Distt. Raipur (CG) '3^'<t»ffl<t<tf®<tfetJfKS,y<tdl-y*|< HfKPffi•dWtlli- "•-^E^O^ ^ 3^3T'?Ri f<<ti^b vi^r ^ii^^ri »»ow< fr^ii^ TrflW^^IT -/o- Shri Andt Kumar Sharma, Ad^ Shri Yashwant Siagh Thakiu', W.P. (8 PBTITIONBRS 1. R4un ShH Uday S/o School (CG) Prithwi Headina^ter ViUagc Raigarh| Patel, age about 47 years, U.D.T., Shree Ram. Patel, Govt. Hr. Sec. Iprba Tehsil- Gharghoda, Distt. -Raigarh Versus RB8PONDENT8 1. State 2. 3. Shri Somkaat Verma, Advocajfce Shri Yashwaiit Singh Thakurj »r»i^fci<ft<THw<rif "^ (^<<l <f^f^K ^^IRmain^r ^ocate for the petitioners. Dy. Advocate General, for fhe State, No. 6686 /2008 Raj Patel, age about 50 years, 6ter, S/o Shri Padum Lal Patel, R/o Post Jataii Tehsil-Ghai^hoda, Distt. i(CG) Govt. of Chhattisgarh, through Secret4i3r Tribal Welfare & Education Departjaient, D.K»S. Bhawaa, Distt-Raipiir (CG) Distt. j Education OjGB.cer, Raigarh, Distt. Raigar^i (CG) Assist^nt Commissloner, Trlbal Welfai^e Depart^nent, Raigarh, Distt Raigarh (CG) for the peuuoners. Dy. Advocate General, for the State. WRIT PETITION UNDBR AfeTICLE 226 OF THE CON8TITUTION OPINDIA 3?ii^r'^ R<»i1<ib wni^rroni T'^'" '3's^^i<ii<rt^ wA«<i<o;fwri'Hy ^tlwtt-tnwwit^ "^r^oo 1a?(l^<TOgr^p^^ ^^w< ttfea 'sti^i -/^ 8B: HON. 8HRI DHIRENDRAI 30-1-2009 AI1 fhe above pcutions) order as common questions] petltions. The petitioners are Teachers aiid Teachers in the( thc State Govemment. They peiiod aad fixed salaiy by | regularized after coDipletiort granted regular pay scale frc| issue tavolved in these pef entitled for rcgular pay ^ appomtment or from the datc( Lcaraed counsel for fh4 thh has been considered by Jabalpm- m O.A. No. 2745/8(9 State of M.P. aad otfaers), teachers are entitled to regui^r ^i^t^^ln *t»wi(^ f«^l<Ftt^i< 'Sfr^iRwOT^ MISHRA. J are beiag disposed ofbytbis common are iavolved for adjudication in these workmg as Dy. Teachers, Assistaat ischools ofTribal Welfare Department of jverc appointed on probatiou for a fixed the respondents, Their services were of probation period and they were ^m the date of their regulanzation. The titions is whether the petitioners are icale from the date of their initial oftheir regularization ? petitioners subiait fhat the above issue e M.P. State Admmistration Tribunal, (Madhukant Yadu and 56 others -v- vfhereby it was held fhat siimlai- situated pay scales wifh effect from fhe initial ^TI^T'SFI (^tW ^CTISR^STIFTO^ </7. "3^ •<»t<«cwft^ft«*t%) Rimw^ i(«ww^w<wcir? t^!p^s ^wiw ^fcn^Ri^ifft ^./2-1 ^l^tfcwtf tWwlE^? fcl<t <f^^Sr« ^a^w^^r date of fheir appointaients. Tl^e above matter was taken up upto fhe HonT3le Supreme Court, how^ver tfate appeal was dismissed by ffae Hon^ble Suprenie Court aad dated 3-1-1994 passed in S.L |he Honyble Supreme Court vide order |P.(C) No. (2) 6892/93 fmally dismissed the appeal of the State Govei|ament. It was farther argued tiiat fhe State Govemment vide order of Schedule Caste aad Sched rcgular pay scale to all tfc Teachers who were appouited 27-12-2008 passed by the Depaitment ^le Tribes has graiited approval to pay ie Dy. Teachers/Assistaat Teachers/ before 1982 and after 1995 from the initial date of mitial appomtE(ient after fheu' successful completion ofprobation period. The case ^ffhe petitioners is squarely covered by the order dated 12-2-2007 ^assed by fiiis Court in W.P. (S) No. 813/2007 (Ram Kumar 8a|fau -v- State of ChhatUs<?arh and another) where regTilar pay ^cale was graated with ettect fi-om fhe initial date of appomtaient. On the other hand, Sh^i Yashwaat Singh Thakur, learaed Dy. Adv. General appearing for fhje State, submitted that only such Dy. Teachers, Assistaat Teachei^ or Teachers who were appointed ^Tr^T^RT^Flhp' '(TtH »ii^<t9n«<i®v> lar '3:5^ •^IHtld^, W^'^*)®;[aKtWj<; l^ NtNv d»*thk ^—"........................--^<20€? ^<r^^^^3i(^5 aire between 1982-83 to 1994-95 pay scale from their initial of two years probatlon peri^d. confronted with fhe latest in^mo 12-2008 issued by the State Dy. Teachers/ Assistant Tea{ even beforc 1982-83 and aftejr pax> scale from fhe initial date Haviag heard leamed the memo No. F 14-25/2007 Scheduled Castes and Schetiule Goverament aiid fhe decisionl inW.P. No. 813/2007 (Ram and another) (Supra), fhe No. 3566/2007 (Loknath others), fhe petitions are| judginents. <tll^(^1^ *yri<!T1f ^f (^^1 <Fa(^l< 'strNfTO^n^T entitled to get the benefit of regular a^pomtment after successfid conipletion 1. However, when Shri Thakur was No. F-14-25/2007/25-l dated 27- Ooveniment, he did not dispute that the Ihers/ Teachers, who werc appomted 1994-95 are also entitled for regular ^f fheir appointaient. for the parties, having regard to ry 25-1 dated 27-12-2008 issued by the Tribes Depailnient of the State of this Court dated 12-2-2007 passed I^umar 8ahu -v- 8tate of Chhattisffurh or^er dated 27-6-2007 passed iu W.P.(S) -v- State of Chhattisgarh and aUowed iii the tei-ms of afoi-esaid c4>unsel orfier Pfctel "aT^^(4W4^ ^tft^*}<s^ i^iw^ HWyi^<»W»R '"^l'zor ^HI^I 'SFT ^J<lh 1cW 3RT$?F "SIW^F fl- r 3<^rllN*^<^ilj^^ (IWI^t^ ^fcd ^fl^l l^ A copy of fhis order be |iCept m all the above writ petitions. ^i^iwft^ ^rw?ff ff Fs^ <r»i^i< ^STO ^n^ Sd/- Dhirendra Mishra Judge