“’srih a 3m rage Na” @éép PETITIONER: Harendra Kumar Parvat/ S/O Shri Jamuna Parvat, Aged 44 years, Working as U.D .T. Govt. Higher Secondary School Tapkara, R/o Boirdadar, Tehsil 86 Distt. Rajgarh (C.G.) RESPONDENTS: .F State of Chhattisgarh Through :,/ Secretary, Department of Tribal Welfare, Mantralaya D.K.S.‘ Raipur (C.G.) . Asst. Commissioner, Tribal // Welfare Deparment District Jashpur (C.G.) PETITION UNDER ARTICLES 226 227' F THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR ISSUANCE OF APPROPRIATE WRITS OF MANDAMUS AND IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BILASPUR (C.G.) @y HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR W. P. (S) No. 6943 of 2006 Pefificner : Harendm Kumar Parvuf Versus Responderrrs: 5+a'l'e of Chha‘l'fisgur'h & ano1'her Singk Bench: Hon’ble Mr. Jus+ice Sufish K. Agniho‘h'i. Presenf: 5hri Akshay Yaduv, Advocu're for 'H'xe Pefi'l'ioner‘. 5m+. Anju Ahuja, Depufy Govemmzn? Advoca're for 1'he 5+afe/vesponden-rs ORDER (Passed on 14"” day of December, 2006) According 1'0 learned counsel for 'l’he petitioner, The pe'l'ifioner -is en'li'lled +0 'l'wo advance incremenfs in view of fhe decision of fhis Cour? in 'ihe case of Yashwan'i Kumor Bharadwaj Vs. Municipal Corpora'iion, Durq and anofher {2006 (II) MPJR-CG 96}. This Cour‘l‘ in 'I'he case of Yashwan'l Kumar Bharadwaj Vs. Municipal Corpora'i'ion, Durg and ano‘l'her (Supra), came To ihe conclusion fha‘r The feachers, who had ob'l'ained Bi Ed./B.T.I. Examinaiion Cer'rifica‘ie on fheir own expenses, are covered by ihe circular da'l'ed 24.12.98 (Annexure P/7) issued by The 51'a1’e Governmen'r of Madhya Pmdesh. The pe'fi'rioner is working as Upper Division Teacher in The governmen'r school. In fhe course of fheir‘ services as Upper Division Teacher, fine pe'fifioner has ob'fained B.Ed. examina'i'ion cer'fificafe on 'fheir own expenses before 1.3.1999. Fur'l'her in 'l’he ma'Her of Smt Manorama Shrivas'fava Vs. Sfa'l‘e of MP. and o+hers { 2000 (1) M.P.L.5.R. 136 } 'l‘he Madhya Pradesh Sfa‘l'e @ 2 Adminis'l'm'rive Tribunul, Gwaiior' Bench, while considering The circular dafed 1.3.1999 wherein, i1- is provided +ha+ fhe Assisfanf Teachers, who have acquired B. Ed. degree u‘f 1'heir own cos? between 23.10.1964 and 7.5.1973 shaii be en‘i'ifled 1’o fwo advance incremen‘rs, relied on decision in fhe case of Rakesh Kumur Shrivasmva Vs. Siafe of MP. & ofhers passed in O.A. No‘ 1632/99, decided on 12.10.1999 wherein i'r is observed 'H'iai' 'ihe circular da'ied 1.3.1999 canno? be made applicable refrospeciively. Thus, a +eacherl may be Assisfanf Teacher, who has obfained B. Ed. degree before 1.3.1999 is enfi'l'led To +wo advance incremen‘fs. I‘i' is poin'red ou'l' by learned counsel appearing for fhe pe'l’i'fioner +ha'l' ihe ‘H'Ien Sta-re of Madhya Pradesh had filed a Special Leave Pefi+ion againsf +he orders passed by The Tribunal and +he Hon'ble Supreme Cour+ dismissed Special Leave Pe’l’i'l'ion No. 1999/2000 filed againsf fine order of fhe Tribunal. Therefore, 1'he direcfion +0 “the effecf ‘l'ha‘r fhe circular dafed 1.3.1999 canno‘l' be made applicable refrospecfively, passed by fhe Tribunal, becomes final and The same shall be applicable +0 all fhe Assisl'an'f Teachers who have obfained B. Ed./B.T.I‘ examina'l‘ion cer'rifica're before 1.3.1999. If is fur'lher subs’l'anfia'l'ed by a circular dafed'17.10.2003 issued by fhe presen‘l’ 51’a‘fe of Madhya Pradesh wherein fhe circular clearly sfa'l'es abou‘i‘ fhe decision of ‘l'he Supreme Court Learned counsel for 1'he pefi‘l‘ioner furi’her submi'is fha'r 'H'ie faci's and question of law involved in fhe presen‘l' case is squarely covered by decision of +his Cour? in The case of Yashwanf Kumar Bharadwaj Vs. Municipal Corporation, Durg and ano'fher (Supra), fo which learned counsel appearing for The respondenfs fairly concedes and agrees wifh ‘l’he avermen'l' made by learned counsel appearing for fhe pefifioner. According”, the writ pe‘tifion is uHowed in farms of fhe order passed in 'l'he case of Yashwan'f Kumar Bharadwaj Vs. Municipal Corpora'tion, burg and anofher (Supra), subject 1'0 verification of +he facf as +0 whether 'rhe pei’ifioners have acquired B. Ed./B.T.I. Examinm'ion Cerfificme on fheir own expenses as per the circuiars dafed 24421993 and 1.3.1999 and fur'rher whefher They have been paid 'rwo advance incremenfs or not No crder as 1'0 cos-ts. f w‘ Sdl- Satish K.Agnihatri i Bablu i i