IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA LPA No.418 of 2009 Bihar State Government Secondary School Teacher‟s Association, thrugh its General Secretary, Bishwa Mohan Kumar Singh, Son of Late Rajeshwar Pd. Singh, resident of Village Chamrahara, P.S. Mahnar, District Vaishali. ------- Appellant Versus 1. Bihar Education Service Association, Patna through its General Secretary Sri Raghuvansh Kumar having its office at Sherpur House, Congress Nagar, P.S. Kadam Kuan, Distt. Patna. 2. Shree Raghuvansh Kumar, Son of Sri Krishna Murari Sharma, Resident of Sherpur House, Mohalla Congress Nagar, Kadam Kuan, P.S. Kadam Kuan, District Patna and R/o Village Shapur, P.S. Maner, Dist. Patna at present posted as Dy. Director/Primary Education. 3. Shree Ajit Kumar, Son of Sri Sheo Kumar Prasad, Resident of B/90, C.C. Kankarbagh, P.S. Kankarbagh, Patna-20, Posted as Deputy Director, Secondary Education. 4. Shree S.N.Kumar, Son of R.C. Kumar, Resident of 29, Catilya Bihar, Raja Bazar, P.S. Shastri Nagar, Patna, posted as R.D.D.E., Saharsa. 5. Raj Mukul, Son of Late Maheshwari Prasad, Resident of Mohalla Kurzi, P.S. Digha, Patna-10, Posted as R.D.D.E., Munger. 6. Dasrath Ram, Son of Tulsi Ram, Resident of Lohiya Nagar, P.S. Kankarbagh, Patna, posted as R.D.D.E., Patna. 7. Shree Suresh Prasad, Son of Late Jagannath Ram, Resident of Anandmai Colony, Phulwarisharif, Khojaimli, Patna, posted as D.E.O., Jamui. 8. Rajiv Ranjan Prasad, Son of Dr. Suresh Prasad, Resident of 66, Ashiana Nagar, P.S. Shastri Nagar, Patna-25, Posted as D.E.O., Buxar. 9. Md. Tasmimui Rahman, Son of Late M.S. Rahman, Resident of Kagazi Mohalla, Biharsharif, Nalanda, posted as D.E.O., Nawada. 10. Shree Ram Pravesh Singh, Son of Tulsi Singh, Resident of Village + P.O. Bajaura, P.S. Dobhi, District Gaya, posted as D.E.O., Banka. 2 11. Shree Milind Kumar Singh, son of late M.P. Sinha, Resident of Mohalla Hazipur, P.S. + distt. Khagaria, posted as D.E.O., Jehanabad. 12. Shree Ashis Ranjan, Son of Dr. B.N. Prasad, Resident of Village Manpur, P.O. & P.S. Giriyak, District Nalanda, posted as D.E.O., Darbhanga. 13. Shree Kosal Kishore Prasad, Son of L.L. Kumar Mandal, Resident of Baraitpur, P.S. Benipatti, Distt. Madhubani, posted as D.E.O. Sheohar. 14. Shree Sultan Ahmad, Son of Haji Jamil Ahmad, Resident of Village Pipra Bazced, P.O. Dhaka, District East Champran, posted as D.E.O., Siwan. 15. Ashutosh Kumar, Son of late D.N. Prasad, Resident of Sheopuri, Beur Road, Chitkohara, Patna-2, posted as D.E.O., Aurangabad. 16. Smt. Lalima, D/o Shree Lok Prakash Sinha, 29, F, F. Road No. 13, Rajendra Nagar, P.S. Kadam Kuan, Patna 16, R.E.O., Patna City. 17. Shree Niraj Kumar @ Neeraj, Son of Shree Baldeo Prasad, village Pachtna, P.O. & P.S. ashthawan, Nalanda, posted as S.D.E.o., Barh, Patna. 18. Smt. Arti Rani, D/o Late Ramu Sah, Resident of Hanuman Bhawan, Daldali Road, Kadam Kuan, Patna, posted as Assistant Director, Mass Education. 19. Shree Madhusudan Paswan, Son of Shree Parmeshwar Paswan, Resident of Village Dharampur, P.O. Hathi Dah, Patna, posted as D.E.O., Bhagalpur. 20. Shree Ravi Bhushan Pandey, Son of Late Mangal Pandey, Resident of Village Rajwara, P.S. Sahebganj, District Muzaffarpur, Posted as D.E.O., Gopalganj. 21. Shree Mahesh Prasad Singh, Son of Ram Brichh Singh, Resident of Village & P.O. Harali, P.S. Mohadinagar, District Samastipur, posted as D.E.O., Madhubani. 22. Shree Yogesh Bhushan Pandey, Son of Late Mangal Pandey, Resident of village & P.O. Lohara, District Azamgarh (U.P.), posted as D.E.O., Begusarai. 23. Shree Suresh Choudhary, Son of late Kashi Mahatha, Resident of Village & P.O. Rajgir, District Nalanda, Posted as D.E.O., Araria. 24. Shree Awadhesh Kumar Singh, Son of Sri Chandra Kishore Singh, Resident of At. Kasamra, P.O. Nirpur, District Purnea, Posted as D.E.O., Madhepura. 3 25. Shree Jaichandra Prasad Srivastava, Son of Late Kameshwar Prasad Srivastava, Resident of At & P.O. Narkatiaganj, P.S. Shikrarpur, District West Champran, Posted as D.E.O., East Champaran. 26. Shree Lalan Jha, Son of Late Umesh Jha, Resident of at + P.O. + P.S. Andhra Thari, District Madhubani, posted as D.E.O., West Champaran. 27. Shree Devashil, Son of late S.S. Shashtri, Resident of At + P.O. Mahadeopur, P.S. Amerpur, District Banka, posted as D.E.O., Vaishali, Hazipur. 28. Smt. Pravawati Kumari, Wife of Shree Suresh Kumar Choudhary, Resident of R.K. Bhattacharya Road, P.O.- G.P.O., Patna, posted as R.D.D.E., Bhagalpur. 29. Smt. Kiran Kumari, Wife of Dr. Anil Singh, Resident of Niti Bagh Colony, P.O. B.V. College, District Patna, posted as D.E.O., Patna. 30. Shree Baliram Prasad, Son of Shree Raghubir Prasad, Resident of Village Bhagwanpur, District Siwan, posted as R.D.D.E., Darbhanga. 31. Smt. Santi Devi, Daughter of Shree Deepehandra Bharti, Resident of New Punaichak, Officer‟s Flat U/2, Patna 23, posted as School Inspectress of Bihar, Patna. 32. Ejaz Shoaiv Hashami, Son of S.M. Shoaib, Resident of At & P.O. Agrawa, Motihari, posted as D.E.O., Samastipur. 33. Shree Dasrath Paswan, Son of Shree Basdev Paswan, Resident of Mohalla Pokharia, Ward No.16, Chitragupt Nagar, District Begusarai, posted as R.D.D.E., Muzaffarpur. 34. Smt. Roobi Sharan, Daughter of late Jagannath Sharan, Resident of Jagodeo Path, Bailey road, Patna, posted as Deputy Director, Secondary Education, Patna. 35. Shree Raj Kumar Sah, Son of Shree Vishwanath Sah, Resident of Village Piyaur, Gayaghat, District Siwan, Pin 841231, posted as S.D.E.O., Chapra (North), Saran. 36. Smt. Gita Kumari Prasad, Wife of Dr. Yogendra Prasad, Resident of Village Dumai, P.O. Bihta, District Patna, posted as District Inspectree of School, Patna. 37. Sri Ajay Kumar Singh, Son of Sri Tarakant Singh, Resident of at Parora, P.O. Sanha, District Begusarai, posted as S.D.E.O., Vaishali. 38. Sri Prakash Ranjan, Son of Sri K.D. Prasad, Resident of Rajendra Nagar, Madhuani, Purnea, posted as R.D.D.E., Magadh Pramandal, Gaya. 4 39. Sri Radhey Prasad, Son of late Bhagwan Prasad, Resident of Aghoria Bazar, Near Cheap Cloth Centre, Muzaffarpur, posted as D.S.E., Khagaria. 40. Sri Gyan Prakash, Son of Ram Charitra Singh, Resident of Village Mangalpur Kala, P.S. Nautan, District East Champaran, posted as S.D.E.O., East Champaran. 41. Sri Vidyandand Thakur, Son of Sri Khushi Lal Thakur, Resident of At P.O. Lashrania, via Triveniganj, District Supaul 852139, posted as S.D.E.O., Saharsa. 42. Sri Shailendra Kumar, Son of Late Ashrafi Rai Sharma, Resident of Village Mallikauri, P.O. Dhighra, District Samastipur, posted as D.E.O., Saran. 43. Sri America Prasad, Son of Late Keshwar Singh, Resident of Village & P.O. Tarar, P.S. Nokha, District Rohtas, posted as D.S.E., Purnea. 44. Sri Kameshwar Prasad Gupta, Son of Sri Nagendra Prasad, Resident of Lokha, Near Bus Stand Madhubani-847421, posted as S.D.E.O., Birpur, Supaul. 45. Sri Vinod Kumar Vimal, Son of Sri Rameshwar Prasad Chauhan, Resident of Village Shahwazpur Sarai, P.O. Manjhwawe, Via-Tungi, District Nawada, posted as S.D.E.O., Gaya. 46. Sri Shyam Babu Ram @ S.B.Ram, Son of Late Birodhi Ram, Resident of Village Mahman Patti, P.O. Tularpur, District Chapra, posted as D.S.E. Munger. 47. Sri Anil Kumar, Son of late Udit Narain Jha, Resident of Miscot, Club Road, P.O. Ramana, Muzaffarpur 842002 posted as D.S.E., Sheohar. 48. Sri Sanjeev Kumar, Son of Sri Pramanand Prasad, Resident of Village Nohasa, P.O. Gurusaranpur, District Nalanda, posted as Principal, PTEC, Sheikhpura. 49. Sri Kundan Kumar, Son of Sri Janardan Choudhary, Resident of Village Parari, P.O. Parari, District Saharsa, posted as S.D.E.O., Madhepura. 50. Sri Ahasan, Son of Sri Jainuddin Sidique, Resident of Village Lashamipur, P.O. & P.S. Nautan, District East Champaran, posted as D.S.E., Bhojpur. 51. Sri Amit Kumar, Son of Birendra Kumar Sinha, Resident of Flat No. 1C, Govind Enclave, Kankarbagh, Patna-20, posted as S.D.E.O., Begusarai. 52. Sri Md. Mustafa Hussain Mansuri, Son of Late Amanullah, Resident of Mohalla Hulla Nagar, P.O. & District Sahebganj, posted as D.E.O., Katihar. 5 53. Smt. Rashmi Rekha @ Rashmi, Daughter of late R. Choudhary, Resident of Progressive Colony, Jai Prakash Nagar, Bahadurpur Housing Colony, Patna-26, posted as S.D.E.O., Patna. 54. Sri Praveen Kumar Singh @ P.K. Singh, Son of Sri Umesh Prasad Singh, Resident of Village Sabaha, P.O. Dholi, District Muzaffarpur, posted as R.E.O., Bahadurganj. 55. Sri Ranjeet Paswan, Son of Sri Ramswaroop Paswan, Resident of Village Chamangarh, P.O. Bariyarpur, District Munger, posted as R.E.O., Jamui. 56. Sri Jagatpati Choudhary, Son of Man Mohan Choudhary, Resident of Village & P.O. Mahishi, District Saharsa, posted as D.S.E., Kishanganj. 57. Sri Deebesh Kumar, Son of Prof. S.B. Choudhary, Resident of Mohalla Naisarai, P.O. Biharsharif, District Nalanda, posted as S.D.E.O., Nawadah. 58. Sri Binod Nand Jha, Son of Sri Dhaneshwawr Jha, Resident of Village & P.O. Rudrapur, P.S. Andhra Thari, District Madhubani, posted as D.S.E. Sheikhpura. 59. Sri Raj Kumar Sharma @ Raj Kumar, Son of Sri Ram Narain Thakur, Resident of C/o Moti Lal Prasad, Pathar Gali, Kachi Talab, Saristabad, Patna-1, posted as S.D.E.O., Muzaffarpur (West). 60. Sri Ravi Kumar Singh, Son of Sri Awadhesh Prasad, Resident of Park Road, Kadam Kuan, Patna-3, posted as S.D.E.O., Siwan. 61. Sri Rajdeo Ram, Son of Sri Ramgarh Ram, Vill. Indu Rukhi, P.O. Sewtha, District Bhojpur, posted as S.D.E.O. Sasaram (South). 62. Sri Binod Kumar Ram, Son of Late Santoshi Prasad Ram, Resident of Village Baraini, Kahalgaon, District Bhagalpur, posted as D.S.E., Katihar. 63. Sri Yadubansh Ram, Son of Sri Sudarshan Ram, Resident of Village Murhi, P.O. Sarigaon, District Rohtas, posted as R.E.O., Buxar. 64. Sri Amar Bhushan, Son of Sri Mohanlal Rajak, Resident of Village Kopin, P.O. Bijubigha, District Nawada, Posted as S.D.E.O., Hilsa, Nalanda. 65. Sri Mukhdeo Singh, Son of Shree Ramjee Singh, Resident of At. + P.O. Dohar Via Chainwan, District Saran (Chapra), posted as Deputy Director. ----------- Petitioners/Respondents (1st Set) 6 66. The State of Bihar through the Chief Secretary, Govt. of Bihar, Old Secretariate, Patna. 67. The Secretary-cum-Commissioner, Department of Human Resource Development, Govt. of Bihar, New Secretariate, Patna. 68. The Secretary, Department of Finance, Govt. of Bihar, Old Secretariate, Patna. 69. The Secretary, Department of Finance, Govt. of Bihar, Old Secretariate, Patna. 70. The Director (Administration), Secondary Education Govt. of Bihar, New Secretariate, Patna. -------------- Respondents/Respondents (2nd Set) 71. Braj Nandan Singh, S/o Late Jageshwar Singh, R/o Mohalla Mahabir Nagar, Beur, P.S. Anishabad, Distt. Patna at present posted as an Assistant Teacher, L.B.S., Govt. Boys High School, Lal Bahadur Shastri Nagar, Patna. 72. Nityanand Mishra S/o Late Chandrakant Mishra Maithil Tola, Koratbar (Madhubani) Purnea, Member, Bihar Education Service Class-II, Superannuated. 73. Smt. Asha Sinha, Member of Bihar Education Service Class- II, At present Principal, Govt. Girls School, Bhagalpur. 74. Sacheetda Nand Tiwari, Member of Bihar Education Service Class-II at present working as Teacher Zila School, Bhagalpur. 75. Bihar State Education Service, Association Lal Bahadur Shastri Patna, Paharpur, Anishabad, Patna-2, through it‟s General Secretary, Ratana Prabha Member of Bihar Education Service Class-II the then Convenor of Bihar Education Service. (Now member of Bihar Education Service 1977 batch). ----------- Intervenors/Respondents (3rd Set.) With LPA No.974 of 2007 Sri Madneshwar Narayan Yadav, S/o (Late) Basudeo Mahto, Resident of Village Mohanpur, P.O. Sarmera, District Nalanda. ----------- Appellant Versus 1. Bihar Education Service Association, Patna through its General Secretary Sri Raghuvansh Kumar having its office at Sherpur House, Congress Nagar, P.S. Kadam Kuan, Distt. Patna. 2. Shree Raghuvansh Kumar, Son of Sri Krishna Murari Sharma, Resident of Sherpur House, Mohalla Congress 7 Nagar, Kadam Kuan, P.S. Kadam Kuan, District Patna and R/o Village at + P.O. Sheopur, P.S. Maner, Dist. Patna at present posted as Dy. Director, Primary Education. 3. Shree Ajit Kumar, Son of Sri Sheo Kumar Prasad, Resident of B/90, PCC Kankarbagh, P.S. Kankarbagh, Patna-20, posted as Deputy Director, Secondary Education. 4. Shree S.N. Kumar, Son of R.C. Kumar, Resident of 29, Catilya Bihar, Raja Bazar, P.S. shastri Nagar, Patna, posted as R.D.D.E., Saharsa. 5. Raj Mukul, Son of late Maheshwari Prasad, Resident of Mohalla Kurzi, P.S. Digha, Patna-10, posted as R.D.D.E., Munger. 6. Dasarath Ram, Son of Tulsi Ram, Resident of Lohiya Nagar, P.S. Kankarbagh, Patna, posted as R.D.D.E., Patna. 7. Shree Suresh Prasad, Son of late Jagannath Ram, Resident of Anandmai Colony, Phulwarisharif, Khojaimli, Patna, posted as D.E.O., Jamui. 8. Rajiv Ranjan Prasad, Son of Dr. Suresh Prasad, Resident of 66 Ashiana Nagar, P.S. Shastri Nagar, Patna-25, posted as D.E.O., Buxar. 9. Md. Tasmimui Rahman, Son of late M.S. Rahman, Resident of Kagazi Mohalla, Biharsharif, Nalanda, posted as D.E.O., Nawada. 10. Shree Ram Pravesh Singh, Son of Tulsi Singh, Resident of Village + P.O. Bajaura, P.S. Dobhi, District Gaya, posted as D.E.O., Banka. 11. Shree Milind Kumar Singh son of Late M. P. Sinha resident of Mohalla Hazipur, P. S. + Dist. Khagria, posted as D.E.O. Jahanabad. 12. Shree Ashish Ranjan, Son of Dr. B.N. Prasad, Resident of village Manpur, P.O. & P.S. Giriyak, District Nalanda, posted as D.E.O., Darbhanga. 13. Shree Kosalkishore Prasad son of L. L. Kumar Mandal resident of Baraitpur P.S. Benipatti, Dist. Madhubani posted as D.E.O. Sheohar. 14. Shree Sultan Ahamad son of Haji Jamil Ahamad resident of village Pipara Bazeed, P.O. Dhaka, Dist. East Champaran, posted as D.E.O. Siwan. 15. Ashutosh Kumar son of late V.N. Prasad resident of Sheopuri Beure Road Chitkohara, Patna-2.posted as D.E.O., Aurangabad. 8 16. Smt. Lalima d/o Shree Lok Prakash Sinha 29 F, Road No. 13 Rajendra Nagar P. S. Kadam Kuan Patna-16 R.E.O. Patna City. 17. Shree Niraj Kumar @ Neeraj son of Shree Baldeo Prasad village Pachtha P. S. + P. O. Asthawan, Nalanda posted as S.D.E.O, Barh, Patna. 18. Smt. Arati Rani d/o Late Ramu Shah, resident of Hanuman Bhawan, Daldali Road, Kadam Kuan Patna posted as Asst. Director Mass Education. 19. Shree Madhusudan Paswan son of Shree Parmeshwar Paswan resident of village Dharampur P. O. Hathi Dah Patna, posted as D.E.O. Bhagalpur. 20. Shree Ravi Bhusan Pandey son of late Mangal Pandey resident of village Rajwara, P. S. Sahebganj District Muzaffarpur at present posted as D.E.O. Gopgalganj. 21. Shree Mahesh Prasad Singh son of Ram Brichh Singh resident of village + P. O. Haraili, P.S. Mohadinagar District Samastipur, posted as D.E.O. Madhubani. 22. Shree Yogesh Mishra son of Shree Ghanshyam Mishra resident of village + P. O. Lohara, District Azamgrah ( U. P.) posted as D.E.O. Begusarai. 23. Shree Suresh Choudhary son of late Kashi Mahatha resident of village + Post Rajgir, District Nalanda posted as D.E.O., Araria. 24. Shree Awadesh Kumar Singh son of Shree Chandra Kishore Singh resident of at kasamra, P. O. Nirpur, Dist. Purnea posted as D.E.O. Madhepura. 25. Shree Jai Chandra Prasad Shrivastava son of late Kameshwar Pd. Srivastava resident of At/ P. O. Narkatiganj P. S. Shikarpur Dist. West Champaran posted as D.E.O. East Champaran. 26. Shree Lalan Jha son of late Umesh Jha resident of At/P.O./P.S. Andhra Thari Dist. Madhubani, posted as D.E.O. West Champaran. 27. Shree Devashil son of late S. S. Shashtri resident of At/P.O. Mahadeopur P. S. Amerpur Dist. Banka posted as D.E.O. Vaishali, Hazipur. 28. Smt. Pravawati Kumari w/o Shree Suresh Kumar Choudhary resident of R. K. Bhattcharya Road, P. O. G. P. O. Patna posted as R.D.D.E Bhagalpur. 29. Smt. Kiran Kumari w/o Dr. Anil Singh resident of Niti Bagh Colony, P. S. B. V. College, Dist. Patna posted as D.E.O, Patna. 9 30. Shree Baliram Prasad son of Shree Raghuvir Prasad resident of village Bhagwanpur Dist. Siwan posted as R.D.D.E, Darbhanga. 31. Smt. Santi Devi daughter of Shree Deepchandrea Bharti resident of New Puniachak Officer‟s Flat u/2 Patna-23 posted as School Inspectress of Bihar Patna. 32. Ejaz Shoaib Hashami son of S. M. Shoaib resident of At & P. O. Agrawa, Motihari posted as D.E.O. Samastipur. 33. Shree Dasharath Paswan son of Shree Basdev Paswan resident of Mohalla Pokharia Ward No. 16 Chitragupt Nagar, Dist. Begusarai, posted as R.D.D.E, Muzaffarpur. 34. Smt. Roobi Sharan d/o Late Jagannath Saran resident of Jagdeo Path Baily Road, Patna, posted as Deputy Director Secondary Education, Patna. 35. Shree Rajkumar Sah son of Shree Vishwanath Sah resident of village Piyaur, Gayghat, Dist. Siwan Pin 841231, posted as S.D.E.O. Chapra (North) Saran. 36. Smt. Gita Kumari Prasad w/o Dr. Yogendra Prasad resident of village Dumari P. O. Bihta Patna, posted as District Inspectress of School, Patna. 37. Sri Ajay Kumar Singh son of Sri Tatakant Singh resident of at Parora, P. O. Sanha Dist. Begusarai posted as S.D.E.O. Vaishali. 38. Sri Prakash Ranjan son of Sri K.D.Prasad resident of Rajendra Nagar, Madhuani, Purnea, posted as R.D.D.E. Magadh Pramandal Gaya. 39. Sri Radhe Prasad son of late Bhagwan Prasad resident of Aghoria Bazar Near Cheap Cloth Center Muzaffarpur, posted at D.S.E. Khagaria. 40. Sri Gyan Prakash Son of Sri Ram Charitara Singh resident of vill- Mangalpur Kala, P. S. Nautan Dist. East Champaran, posted as S.D.E. East Champaran. 41. Sri Viyandand Thakur son of Sri Khushilal Thakur resident of At/P.O. Lashrainia, via Triveniganj Dist. Supaul 852139 posted as S.D.E.O. Saharsa. 42. Sri Sailendra Kumar @ S. Kumar son of late Asharfi Rai Sharma resident of village Malikkauri P. O. Dhighra Dist. Samastipur posted as D.E.O. Saran. 43. Sri America Prasad son of late Keshwar Singh resident of village + P. O. Tarar P. S. Nokha, Dist. Rohtas posted as D.S.E. Purnea. 10 44. Sri Kameshwar Pd. Gupta son of Sri Nagendra Prasad resident of Lokha, Near Bus stand Madhuabani posted as SDEO Birpur, Supaul. 45. Sri Vinod Kumar Vimal son of Sri Rameshwar Prasad Chauhan Resident of village Sahwajpur Sarai P. O. Manjhwe, via Tungi, Dist. Nawadah, posted as S.D.E.O. Gaya. 46. Sri Shyam Babu Ram @ S. B. Ram son of late Birodhi Ram resident of village Mahman Patti, P. O. Tularpur District Chapra, posted as D.S.E. Munger. 47. Sri Anil Kumar son of Late Udit Narain Jha resident of Miscot, Clud Road, P.O. Ramana, Muzaffapur posted as D.S.E. Sheohar. 48. Sri Sanjeev Kumar son of Sri Pramanand Prasad resident of village- Nohasa, P. O. Gurusaranpur Dist. Nalanda, posted at Principal PTEC Shekhpura. 49. Sri Kundan Kumar son of Sri Janardhan Chaudhary resident of village Parari P. O. Parari Dist. Saharsa posted as S.D.E.O. Madhepura. 50. Sri Ahasan son of Sri Jainuddin Sidique resident of village Lashamipur, P. O. & P. S. Nawtan, Dist. East Champaran, posted as D.S.E. Bhojpur. 51. Sri Anil Kumar, Son of Birendra Kumar Sinha, Resident of Flat No. 1C, Govind Enclave, Kankarbagh, Patna-20, posted as S.D.E.O., Begusarai. 52. Sri Md. Mustafa Hussain Mansuri son of late Amanullah, resident of Mohalla Hulla Nagar P. O. & Dist. Sahebganj, posted as D.E.O. Katihar. 53. Smt. Rashmi Rekha @ Rashmi d/o late R. Chaudhary resident of Progressive Colony, Jaiprakash Nagar P. O. Bahadurpur Housing Colony Patna 26, posted as S.D.E.P, Patna. 54. Sri Praveen Kumar Singh (P.K.Singh) son of Sri Umesh Prasad Singh resident of village Sabaha P. O. Dholi Dist. Muzaffapur posted as R.E.O. Bahadurganj. 55. Sri Ranjeet Paswan son of Sri Ramswaroop Paswan resident of village Chamangarh, P.O. Bariyarpur District- Munger, posted as R.E.O. Jamui. 56. Sri Jagatpati Chaudhary son of Man Mohan Chaudhary resident of vill + P. O. Mahishi, Dist. Saharsa posted as D.S.E. Kishanganj. 57. Sri Deebesh Kumar @ Deebesh Kumar Choudhary son of late Prof. S. B. Chaudhary resident of Moh. Naisarai, P. O. Biharsharif Dist. Nalanda posted as S.D.E.O, Nawadah. 11 58. Sri Binod Nand Jha son of Sri Dhanehswar Jha resident of vill + P. O. Rudrapur, P. S. Andhra Thari Dist- Madhubani, posted as D.S.E. Shekhpura. 59. Sri Raj Kumar Sharma @ raj Kumar son of Sri Ram Narain Thakur resident of C/o Motilal Prasad Pathar Gali Kachi Talav, Saristabad Patna-1 posted as S.D.E. Muzaffapur (west). 60. Sri Ravi Kumar Singh son of Sri Awadesh Prasad Resident of Park Road Kadamkuan Patna-3, posted as S.D.E.O. Siwan. 61. Sri Rajdeo Ram son of Sri Ramgarh Ram village Indu Rukhi P. O. Sew tha Dist. Bhojpur posted as S.D.E.O. Sasaram (Sough). 62. Sri Binod Kumar Ram son of Late Santosh Pd. Ram resident of village Baraini, Kahalgaon Dist. Bhagalpur posted as D.S.E. Katihar. 63. Sri Yadubansh Ram son of Shri Sudarshan Ram resident of village Murhi, P. O. Sarigawan, Dist. Rohtas. 64. Sri Amar Bhushan son of Sri Mohanlal Rajak resident of village Kopin P. O. Bijubigha, Dist. Nawadah posted as S.D.E.O. Hilsa, Nalanda. 65. Sri Mukhdeo Singh son of Shree Ramjee Singh resident of At/P.O. Dohar, via Chainwan, Dist. Saran (Chapra) posted at Dy. Director. ------------ Petitioners/Respondents (1st Set) 66. The State of Bihar, through the Chief Secretary Government of Bihar, Patna. 67. The Secretary cum Commissioner, Department of Human Resources Development, Govt. of Bihar, Patna. 68. The Secretary, Department of Finance, Government of Bihar, Patna. 69. The Secretary, Department of Personnel and Administrative Reforms Government of Bihar, Patna. 70. The Director (Administration) Secondary Education Government of Bihar, Patna. --------------- Respondents/Respondents (2nd Set) 71. Braj Nandan Singh s/o Late Jageshwar Singh r/o Mohalla Mahabir Nagar Beur, P. S. Anishabad Dist. Patna at present posted as an Assistant Teacher, Govt. Boy‟s High School Lal Bahadur Shashtri Nagar, Patna. 72. Nityanand Mishra s/o Late Chandra Kant Mishra Maithil Tola Koratbari (Madhubani) Purnea, Member of Bihar Education Service Class II Superannuate. 12 73. Smt. Asha Sinha member of Bihar Education Service Class II. At present Principal Govt. Girls School, Bhagalpur. 74. Sachechida Nand Tiwary Member of Bihar Education Service Class II at present working as Teacher Zila School, Bhagalpur. 75. Bihar State Education Service Association Lal Bahadur Shastri Path, Paharpur, Anisabad, Patna-800002. through its General Secretary, Ratan Prabha Member of Bihar Education Service Class II the then Convener of Bihar Education Service. (now member of Bihar Education Service 1977 Batch) ---------------- Intervenor/Respondents/Respondents With LPA No.947 of 2007 Janardan Rai s/o Late Keshav Rai, resident of Nalanda Colony Khajepura P. S. Shastri Nagar District Patna. Versus 1. Bihar Education Service Association, Patna, through its General Secretary, Sri Raghuvansh Kumar having its office at Shepur House, Congress Nagar, P. S. Kadam Kuan, District Patna. 2. Sri Raghuvansh Kumar, Son of Sri Krishna Murari Sharma resident of Shepur House, Mohalla Congress, R. O. Vill + P. S. Sherpur, P.S. Maner District Patna at presented posted as Dy. Director, Primary Education. 3. Sri Ajit Kumar son of Sri Sheo Kumar Prasad, r/o B/90, P.C.C. Kankarbagh, P. S. Kankarbagh, Patna, 20 posted as Dy, Director, Secondary Education. 4. Sri S. N. Kumar son of R. C. Kumar, resident of 29, Catilya Bihar, Raja Bazar, Police Station Shastrinagar, Patna posted as R.D.D.E, Saharsa. 5. Raj Mukul son of late Maheshwri Prasad resident of Mohalla Kurzi, P. S. Digha Patna-10, posted as R.D.D.E, Munger. 6. Dasharath Ram son of Tulsi Ram, resident of Lohiya Nagar, P. S. Kankarbagh, Patna posted as R.D.D.E, Patna. 7. Shree Suresh Prasad son of late Jagnnath Ram resident of Anandmai Colony Phulwarisharif Khosaimli, Patna posted as D.E.O. Jamui. 8. Rajiv Rajan Parasad son of Dr. Suresh Prasad resident of 66, Asiana Nagar, P. S. Shastri Nagar Patna-25 Posted as D.E.O. Buxar. 13 9. Md. Tasmimui Rohman son of late M. S. Rahman resident of Kagzi Mohalla Bihar Sharif Nalanda Posted as D.E.O., Nawada. 10. Shree Ram Pravesh Singh son of Tulsi Singh resident of village + Post Bajraura, P. S. Dobhi District Gaya posted as D.E.O., Banka. 11. Shree Milind Kumar Singh son of Late M. P. Sinha resident of Mohalla Hazipur, P. S. + Dist. Khagria, posted as D.E.O. Jahanabad. 12. Shree Ashis Ranjan son of Dr. B. N. Prasad resident of village Manapur P.O. & P. S. Giriyak District Nalanda posted D.E.O., Darbhanga. 13. Shree Kosalkishore Prasad son of L. L. Kumar Mandal resident of Baraitpur P.S. Benipatti, Dist. Madhubani posted as D.E.O. Sheohar. 14. Shree Sultan Ahamad son of Haji Jamil Ahamad resident of village Pipara Bazeed, P.O. Dhaka, Dist. East Champaran, posted as D.E.O. Siwan. 15. Ashutosh Kumar son of late V.N. Prasad resident of Sheopuri Beure Road Chitkohara, Patna-2.posted as D.E.O., Aurangabad. 16. Smt. Lalima d/o Shree Lok Prakash Sinha 29 F, Road No. 13 Rajendra Nagar P. S. Kadam Kuan Patna-16 R.E.O. Patna City. 17. Shree Niraj Kumar @ Neeraj son of Shree Baldeo Prasad village Pachtha P. S. + P. O. Asthawan, Nalanda posted as S.D.E.O, Barh, Patna. 18. Smt. Arati Rani d/o Late Ramu Shah, resident of Hanuman Bhawan, Daldali Road, Kadam Kuan Patna posted as Asst. Director Mass Education. 19. Shree Madhusudan Paswan son of Shree Parmeshwar Paswan resident of village Dharampur P. O. Hathi Dah Patna, posted as D.E.O. Bhagalpur. 20. Shree Ravi Bhusan Pandey son of late Mangal Pandey resident of village Rajwara, P. S. Sahebganj District Muzaffarpur at present posted as D.E.O. Gopgalganj. 21. Shree Mahesh Prasad Singh son of