APPLEAT ION Umpm SECTIom 19 OF THE: Ammmmmim TRIEUMLS Acmmss; ms7£rQvwr/N o.A.mo.@_ of 98. /—~ For 113$ in the Tribungl'g, ofgige. Date of filing r or Date of Receipt by past. Registration No. , l Wvnvvvvzv vv / EEGETBAE BEFORE THE STAI'E ADMIN EmTI‘JE TRIBUNM: RAIPUR liENCH : BAIPUR. Applicanta. 1. Amil Kumar Mishra S/O Shri B.P.Mishra, Assistant ’ Teacher Govt.Higher seeondary SchooJ. mandsara Burg {31.13) 2. Shatl‘ughanlal Sinha S/O Shri Bat] Ram 3inha, £3§sistant Teacher,’ Primary School PiKari Bemetara District Durg $4.?) 3. ,Bha'rat .Prasad Tiwari s/e Shri J.P.Tiwari, Akssistant Teacher, Primary Sciaoo]. NavaganKala {Saja) District Durg M.P. x 4. Earayan’Kashyap S/O Sri D.S.Kashyap, &ssistant Teacher,‘ Primary School Padamsara (Saja) Bistrict Burg (M.P) Parasram Kashyan S/O Shri P.R.Ka§hyap, &ssistan‘b Teacner, Primary School Souri (saja) Dis%rictDurg 6. Gaya Ram Kashyap S/o ,5hr1 K.n.Kashyap,Ass1stant ‘ Teacher Primary SchwoJ. Lshati (SaJa) Dlstrlct Burg: 7. Parasram Sahu 3/0 Shrl Bhuxha Ran hahu, Asslstan’c Teacher, &bhayash behocJ. Bemetara District Durg 8.“. Asher: Kimar Raaput S/G $hr1 Bansi Eiingh Rajput Assistant Teacher, Middle Schooi Navagaonkala (Sajg) Disirict Durg (1%.?) 11 7" C -2- w Balkrishna Paragniha S/O Shri ?.S.Paragniha, Assistant Teacher, Primary $chool Pikari {Bemetara) District Durg (Mu?) 1-0. Manujram Kunjam S/O Shri M.R.k§nnjam, Assistant ‘reaeher, Primary School Akola (Saja3 Distt.Durg (MP) 5 11. Parmeshwar Das Vaishnav WO Shri S.D.Vaishnav Assistant Teacher Gims ‘Primary Schom. Than Khamariya District Durg {M.P) 12. Romal Bhu Arya S/o shri S.R.Bhu Arya Assistant Teachar, Primary SchooJ. Gil-Ls, Than khamariya District Du rg (WP) 13. Man faringh'v’erma 3/0 Shri D.S.Verma, Assistant Teacher, Abhyash School Bemetara District Durg (ELF) 14. Sudhanan Das Kaushal S/Q Shri S.D.'Kaushal Assistant Teacher, Primary School Hemaband Bemetara ‘ District Durg “34.13) 15. Lalit Kumar Naurange 3/0 Shri Mahajan Eaurange,- Primary School Lolesara Bemetara District Durg (W) 16. Angad Ram Sahu, S/O $hri Puran Ram Sahu Assistant ‘ Teacher, Primary School. Gadua (Saja) District Burg.‘ 1'7. Nana Kumar Vaishna'v S/O Shri Bharat Das Vaishnav, Assistant Teacher, Primary School Hatranxa District Durg (1%.?) 18. Dhruv Kumar Vema S/O Shri 3mm oingh Verma, Assistant Teacher, Middle School Bemetgra District Burg ms?) l9. Kriskna Kumar Tiwari S/O Shri Gaya Prasad Tiwari, Assistant Teacher, Primary School Haveen Bemetara District burg (M.P) 20.‘ Ram-rimmaz- Vermag 3/0 shri Ghandulal Verma assistant Teacher, Primary-School Naveen Beaetara District Durg 21. Pashanlal' Yadu S/O Sbri Sukhdeo Yadu, Assistant Teacher, Primary School DoKla Bemetara District Durg. 22. Bhukhan Ram Sahu S/O Shri shivcharanlal sahu, Tssistant Teacher Miriam? School Than Khamar iya {Saja) DistrictrDurg {M.P) 23. Sanat Kumar -Rajput s/O Shri Ran Dular Singh, Assistant Teacher Middle School khamariya (Seja District Burg. ‘ \ -' C8? 7 -3 24. Ayodhya Prasad VishwaKarma 8/0 Shri Krinha Ram Vishwakarma, Assistant Teacher, Middle School Than Khamariya {$a3a) District burg (imp) 25. Purshottam Prasad Aagarwal S/O Shri Ram Murti Agarwal, 1‘ Assistant Teacher Middle SehOol Than Khamariya (Saja) é District burg (M.P) 26. 'Dhruv Prasad Kashyap 3/0 Shri K.?.Kashyap, Assistant Teacher, Middle School Than Khamariya District Darg. ’ 27. Rajendra Prasad Shanna S/O Shri Badri Prasad Sharma, &ssistant Teacher 13rimary School Guwara (Saja? District burg m?) 28. Krishna Singh Verma 3/0 Shri T.R.Verma &ssistant Teachor Middle School Karesara (saja) District Durg‘ 29 Lalit Kumar Devangan 3/0 Shri Bari Ram Devagan, a9 Assistant Teacher, Middle School Beme’cara v District Durg {M.P) t} $51“ 30. Revi K‘umar Verma S/O.S.hri V.Verma, Aiissistant Teacher, a Middle SchooL DeVerblaa {attached Hlgh School) Berla District burg (LL?) Nand Kumar Pandey 3/0 Shri Khubi Ram Pandey Assistant 1 Teacher Primary School Kauteli (Bemetsra) District Burg. Nam Singh Markam 8/0 Shri Bhagwan S§ingh Assistant Teacher, Primary School Tendula (803a) Distric VJ/VD kwvwi’ J1/x/éii f]. I ,L / (SJ/u, 5:.LL/e I-I §é IHIJNKIIHM/WTII \ Teacher, Middle school Dadi Discrlct Durg (MJ’) @ML/Im, {‘35) 3g Ghanshyam Binari Namdeo 3/0 Shri Bhagwandeen Namdeo, x AwSisiaan‘t Teacher 33rimary school Dadi District Burg. C36) 35". Bharatlal Suryawanshi 3/0 shri Sunderlak Suryawanshi, sssistant Teacher Middle School Semariya (Bemetara) District burg (14.?) f (37%;. Nakul Prasad Shame $/O ghri Lakhanlal Shame, Assistant Teacher, Middle School Ehola District Durg.‘ -Vgr_§u3- 2. Egg-aon; ica n1: g . 1. State of 14.? through Secretary School Educatlon Department M P Bhopal 2. Depu'by Dlrector of Edueat ion m woé/Lwcice social wand a, ) District Durg (M P) ' “33 {WA 3g, Abdul cassar Khan s/o 3hr; Firasat man csslstant gm? (J I J/ ,ccL f3:wclw a (Lol d4] m LsLLLcc cruc" ‘9: t ‘2 * L) é“? 1 S; (”RC-‘(m Wig); - M I ~ -4- 3. Partigukra of tllgyggr ggainst yhigh gggyxagtiog is mggg I:n L r masqim WfCSQ 2qz1§ o; H W 2° anée‘r W5 (W) mamaaiai ammam mmmamw WW#WW $3I%H3né€r SB: Hon’ble Shri Manindna Mohan Shrivastava J. 1.02.2010 ‘ Shri Sandeep Agrawal, Advocate appeaxs on behalf of Shri RS. Koshy, counsel for the petitioners. Shri Ajay Dwivedi, Dy. Govt. Advocats for the State/ rsspondents. Heard, The petitioners have iield this petition claiming the similar benefits as have been given to Asst. Teachers appointed in between the year 1983 - 1984 who had approached the Tribunal by filing Original Application 2745 1989 (decided on 24.8,1997), wherein Tribunal directed benefits o be given all teachers. It is also stated that the State challenged said order before the Supreme Court in S.L.P. No. 6892/ 1993 hich was dismissed Vide order dated 3. 1. 1994. In number of cases, Court has passed orders directing the respondents to consider th cases. ‘ Accordingly, this petit is also disposed of with liberty to the petitioners to make repres ntation, if so advised, to consider their cases on its own merits an perspective. If the petitioners sta on the same footings as per order passed pbypthe Madhya Pr desh State Administrative Tribunal in O.A. No.2745l89 (Madhu nt Yadu and 56 otheis Vs. State ofMP. e i n & others) and subsequem S.L.P. (Civil) No.6892/93 order would be passed by 1 1y conEmed by the Supreme Court in by order dated 3.1.1994, appropriate 'i he respondents authority. ‘ X& Manindra Mohan Sd/- Shrivastavax‘’ Judge y t r JH.‘