rng IN IN IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORDINARY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION CHAMBER CHAMBER CHAMBER SUMMONS NO. 106 OF 2009 SUMMONS NO. 106 OF 2009 SUMMONS NO. 106 OF 2009 inin in APPEAL APPEAL APPEAL NO.844 OF 2007 NO.844 OF 2007 NO.844 OF 2007 inin in COMPANY COMPANY COMPANY APPLICATION NO.1122 OF 2006 APPLICATION NO.1122 OF 2006 APPLICATION NO.1122 OF 2006 inin in COMPANY COMPANY COMPANY PETITION.731 OF 2005 PETITION.731 OF 2005 PETITION.731 OF 2005 Reliance Industries Ltd .. Petitioner Vs. Reliance Natural Resources Ltd .. Respondents with with with APPEAL NO.1 OF 2008 APPEAL NO.1 OF 2008 APPEAL NO.1 OF 2008 inin in COMPANY COMPANY COMPANY APPLICATION NO.1122 OF 2006 APPLICATION NO.1122 OF 2006 APPLICATION NO.1122 OF 2006 inin in COMPANY COMPANY COMPANY PETITION NO.731 OF 2005 PETITION NO.731 OF 2005 PETITION NO.731 OF 2005 Reliance Natural Resources Ltd Formerly Global Fuel Management Services .. Petitioners vs Reliance Industries Ltd .. Respondents Mr.Haresh Salve, Sr.Advocate with Mr.Milind Sathe, Sr.Advocate and Mr.Suresh Gupte, Mr.Firdosh Pardiwala, Ms.Meenakshi Grover, Mr.Kamaldeep Dayal i.b Ms Junarkar & Associates for Appellant in Appeal No.844 of 2007 and for Respondents in Appeal No.1 of 2008 2 Mr.Mukul Rohatgi,Sr.Advocate, Mr.Mahesh Jethmalani,Sr.Advocate, Mr.V.R.Dhond Mr.V.R.Dhond, Mr.Mahesh Agarwal, Mr.D.J.Kakalia, Ms Manali Singhal, Mr.Saurabh Kripal and Ms Bhavna Singhi i.b Mulla and Mulla for Appellant in Appeal no.1 of 2008 and for Respondents in Appeal No.844 of 2007. Mr.T.Doabia, Sr.Advocate, Mr.Vinod Joshi, Dr.Shailendra Sharma, Mr.Sandeep Deve and Ms.Ratika Mehra for Union of India CORAM CORAM CORAM : : : J.N.Patel and J.N.Patel and J.N.Patel and K.K.Tated, K.K.Tated, K.K.Tated, JJ JJ JJ DATED DATED DATED : 22nd January, 2009 : 22nd January, 2009 : 22nd January, 2009 P.C. 1. Not pressed. Dismissed. { K.K.Tated, J } K.K.Tated, J } K.K.Tated, J } { J.N.Patel, J } J.N.Patel, J } J.N.Patel, J }