THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE GHULAM MOHAMMED CRP NO.6067 of 2009 ORDER: This civil revision petition is filed against the order dated 10-11- 2009 passed in IA No.720 of 2009 in OS No.1780 of 2008 by the II Addl. Senior Civil Judge, Vishakapatnam District, dismissing the said IA filed under Order 16, Rules 6 and 7 and Section 151 CPC to direct the Superintendent, Mental Care Hospital, Chinawaltair, to produce muster roll register dated 20-3-2006 relating to duty nursing superintendent, grade-II, mental care hospital, Chinawaltair, Visakhapatnam. 2. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner. Perused the impugned order passed by the Court below. 3. The Court below dismissed the application filed to produce the muster roll from the hospital by observing that if the muster roll is produced nothing will be proved except the attendance of the D-1 to the office on the relevant date. It has come in the evidence of the witnesses already examined that D-1 was on duty on the relevant date. PWs.1 to 3 in their evidence stated that Ex.A-1 pro-note was executed on 20-3-2006 between 4-00 pm to 5-30 pm. As observed by the Court below, the question whether D-1 executed the pro-note on the relevant date and whether she was on duty or not shall have to be decided after completion of the evidence and arguments and for that purpose, muster roll marking her presence or otherwise, may not throw much light on the facts of the case. That apart, the impugned order is a discretionary order passed by the Court below. 4. In the circumstances, the civil revision petition fails and it is accordingly dismissed at the admission stage itself. ______________________ Ghulam Mohammed, J 31-12-2009 Nrg.