IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CWJC No.17996 of 2010 1. JAGDEO MAHTO S/O SRI KAMAL MAHTO, VILLAGE- PANCHUPUR, WARD No. 4, P.O.-- ROSRA, DISTRICT- SAMASTIPUR, PRESENTLY POSTED AS ROLLER KHALASI IN ZILA PARISHAD, SAMASTIPUR 2. ARVIND KUMAR S/O SRI KRISHNA KISHORE, MOHALLA- POKHRA, P.S.- HAZIPUR, DISTRICT- VAISHALI, PRESENTLY POSTED AS JUNIOR ENGINEER IN ZILA PARISHAD, SAMASTIPUR 3. KUMUD KUMAR SINHA S/O SRI BHOLA PARASAD, ABHIYANTA NIWAS, MOHALLA- KASHOPUR, P.S AND DISTRICT- SAMASTIPUR, PRESENTLY POSTED AS JUNION ENGINEER IN ZILA PARISHAD, SAMASTIPUR. 4. SATYA PAL PRASAD SINGH, S/O SRI RAM CHANDRA SINGH, VILLAGE- BATHUABUJURG, P.S.- MUSHARI GHARARI, DISTRICT-SAMASTIPUR, PRESENTLY POSTED AS ESTIMATOR IN ZILA PARISHAD, SAMASTIPUR 5. SURESH KUMAR PRASAD S/O LATE RAM NARAYAN PRASAD, VILLAGE- RAHMATPUR, P.O.-RAHMATPUR, DISTRICT- SAMASTIPUR, PRESENTLY POSTED AS ASSISTANT IN ZILA PARISHAD, SAMASTIPUR 6. RAM KUMAR JHA S/0 SRI CHANDRA SHEKHAR JHA, VILLAGE- SALEMPUR, P.S.- MUSARI GHARARI, DISTRICT- SAMASTIPUR, PRESENTLY POSTED AS PEON IN ZILA PARISHAD, SAMASTIPUR 7. KRISHNA RAM S/O LATE SIKINDER RAM, VILLAGE- MATHRAPUR, P.S.-MATHRAPUR, DISTRICT- SAMASTIPUR, PRESENTLY POSTED AS SWEEPER IN ZILA PARISHAD, SAMASTIPUR 8. ASHOK KUMAR SINGH S/O RAM DEO PRASAD SINGH, VILLAGE- SARAUT, P.S.- ROSRA, DISTRICT- SAMASTIPUR, PRESENTLY POSTED AS PEON IN ZILA PARISHAD, SAMASTIPUR 9. PRADEEP KUMAR @ PRADEEP KUMAR MEHTAR S/O LATE SURAT MEHTAR, VILLAGE- SINGHIYA GHAT, P.S.- BIBHUTIPUR, DISTRICT- SAMASTIPUR, PRESENTLY POSTED AS SWEEPER IN ZILA PARISHAD, SAMASTIPUR 10. ARUN KUMAR MAHTO S/O RASSRAJ MAHTO, VILLAGE- KATUWA GODHA, P.S.- PINDARA JERA, DISTRICT- BOKARO, PRESENTLY POSTED AS RATRI PRAKARI, CHAUKIDAR IN ZILA PARISHAD, SAMASTIPUR 11. BIRENDRA MAHTO S/O HASAN MAHTO, VILLAGE- PARMANANDPUR, P.S.- DUMARA, DISTRICT- SITAMARHI, PRESENTLY POSTED AS RATRI PRAHARI, CHAUKIDAR IN ZILA PARISHAD, SAMASTIPUR Versus 1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH THE CHIEF SECRETARY, BIHAR, PATNA. 2. THE CHIEF SECRETARY, BIHAR, PATNA. 3. THE FINANCE COMMISSIONER, DEPARTMENTOF FINANCE, BIHAR, PATNA. 2 4. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, PANCHAYATI RAJ DEPARTMENT, BIHAR, PATNA 5. THE DIRECTOR, PANCHAYATI RAJ DEPARTMENT, BIHAR, PATNA. 6. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR (NIRWA), PANCHAYATI RAJ DEPARTMENT, BIHAR, PATNA. 7. THE ZILA PARISHAD, SAMASTIPUR THROUGH ITS CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER. 8. THE CHAIRMAN, ZILA PARISHAD, SAMASTIPUR. 9. THE DEPUTY DEVELOPMENT COMISSIONER-CUM-CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, ZILA PARISHAD, SAMASTIPUR. For the petitioner: M/s. Arun Kumar, Md. Hussam Uddin Azad, and Arvind Kumar Pathak, Advocate. For Zila Parishad : Mr. Nikesh Kumar, Advoate. For the State : A.C. to G.P. 13 Mr. Ram Sagar Singh, Advoate. ------------ 2. 03.11.2010 Heard learned counsel for the parties. 2. Petitioner is aggrieved by the instruction of the Deputy Director, Panchayati Raj Department contained in letter no.4094 dated 12.8.2008, Annexure-2, which was also the subject-matter of C.W.J.C. No. 11909 of 2009 filed by one Chandradeo Thakur and the instructions contained in the letter dated 12.08.2008, Annexure-2 was modified by this Court under orders dated 23.09.2010 passed in C.W.J.C. No. 11909 of 2009, Annexure-16. 3. This writ petition is also disposed of exactly in the same terms, which is contained in order dated 23.09.2010, Annexure-16. Ibrar/- ( V.N. Sinha, J.)