»l^h!!S»i!S'6flNtte'!'!'#IStShl3NA!N^ ^ ^ IN THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR M.A. (C) No.- vlsiQn K®^? i liui-i APPELLANT ';?:?. t\€ ^s^ ^wy, THE ORIENTAL INSURANCJE COMPANY LIMITED, THROUGH BRANCH MANAGER, BRANCH OFFICE, MAIN ROAD, SADAR BAZAR, JAGDALPUR (C.G.) (INSURANCE COMPANY OF VEHICLE BOLERO NUMBER C.G. 17/D/0435) Vrs, RESPONDENTS/CLAIMANTS :- 1. ROHIDAS S/0 GUHARI, CASTE-HALBA, AGE ABOUT 58 YRS. 2. SMT. BHAGWANTIN BAI W/0 ROHIDAS, HALBA, AGE ABOUT 53 YRS. RESIDENT OF VILLAGE CHILHATIKHURD, THANA DONDALOHARA, DISTRICT - DURG(C.G.) RESPONDENTS/NON-APPLICANTS 3. PAWAN KUMAR NAG S/0 PATIRAM NAG, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE - NAYAPARA GEETAM, DISTRICT - DANTEWADA (C.G.) (DRIVER -VEHICLE BOLERO NUMBER C.G. 17/D/0435) 3. SHIV KUMAR NAG S/0 PATIRAM NAG, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE - NAYAPARA GEETAM, DISTRICT - DANTEWADA (C.G.) (REGISTERED OWNER OF VEHICLE BOLERO NUMBER C.G. 17/D/0435) APPEAL UNDER SECTION 173 OF MOTOR VEfflCLE ACT 1988 !GH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH. BILASPUR Hon'ble Shri !.M. Quddusi. J. & Hon'bie Shrj Prashant Kumar Mishra, J, •riental Insurance Com! sNi .imited. Rohidas and others. SECTION 173 OF THE MOTOR WHICLE ACT. 1988 Appearance: Shri Sudhir Agrawai , eounsel for the appaliant. Shri Govind Dewangan, counsel for respondents No. 1 & 2. Following oral luddusi. J. order of the Court was passed This appeal has been filed by the Oriental Insurance Company Jmited against the impugned award dated 28/01/2009 of the Addltional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (F.T.C.), Balod. District - Durg (C.G.) in Claim Ca.se No. 65/2008. The application under Section 170 of the Motor Vehicles Act was dismissed. (2) The brief facts of the case are that on 16/04/2008 deceased Rajesh went to Village Chilhatikhurd for attending Pooja in his parent's house. After attending pooja he was going to village Nayapara Geedam. District Dantewara invehicie Bolero bearina registration No. C,G.17/D/0435which was being driven by non-applica.nt No.1 rashly and negligently due to which near viliage Bastapar the vehicie turtled and Rajesh received grievous injuries and he died. Deceased was aged about 25 years. The claimants have ciaimeo' compensation of Rs.36,85,000/-. (3) The appellant has challenged the impugned order of dismissal dated 28/01/2009. We have perused the written statement filed by ths owner of th6 vehicie and the driver. It is specificaliy mentioned in the written statement that they are not responsible for payment of compensation. It is ^nt^., ^y^ -5-- '.2".». o^ psyjpoiu si pjavie psuSndiui &4i 'ved ui pe/sho||e si leedde 941 (/) •epise-i&s si pue jsdojd }ou OS|B si %6 @ jeunqui 944 Aq pesoduii isejetui jeusci 'epeui si pje/ike p tusuiAed 01^ ||i) uot)jtsd IUJB|O eqt ^o 6ui|ij p 8)ep eyt LU04 tunuue jed is&jeiui sjdtUjs %9 L|i! Buoje -/OOO'ZS't'sy }8B 0} psffiiue sq p|noA\ siueiuieio sift 484} tuepo sq) 0} peonpsj si ieunqui eq} Aq pepJBAW se uoiiesusdtuoo p tunouje eq} sjo^ejSLj} •-/OOO'ZS't-'sy o^ SSUIOQ uoiiesueduioo ^o tunoiue |e»oi &4i -/OOO'SE 'sy Suippe jsye 'snyi 's&suedxe jejeun^ JOj -/OQO'S'sy PUB sietse p sso| jo^ -/OOO'Ol-'sy 'uoipeye pue eAOj p SSG| jo^ yoes -/QOO'Ol.'sy pB o) psitiiue SJB siueiuieio e^t 4»oqsiqt sepiseg '-/000'S9' l.'sy 0} seuioo qoiq/A pajidde eq pinoqs Q y> JS||dit|niu -/OQO'Si-'sy 's'! Aouepusdep ^o sso| ienuue eij} spjBAOtejojejsift pue siqBQijdCie epeiu eq o^ SB/A g P jei|d|t|ntu eqi '93 •s'! g'sg Oi SSLUOO eCe sBejeAe 1104) a.io.sejeq} ss PUB 8S eje stuejed eqi p eBe s4i '-/OOO'SI.'sy O) eiuoo p|no/A Aouepusdsp ienuue p ssoj QV^sn^t PUB sssuedxs BuiAi| pue |euosjed spjeAO} peionpsp ussq 8ABij p|noqs %os ejojsjeyt 'joisyoeq e SBA peseeoep 041 sy '-/000'9£'sy 0} seiuoo eiuoouj ienuue sq} pue 4tuoui jed -/QOO'£'sy se |eunqui eiji Aq U9)|e} SBM eiuooui psseeosp 84} ^eiji uoiujdo eqi p sje OM uiniuenb etj} BuipjeBsy (9) •ixei e se pesn Buieq SBM sjojyeA eifl }eii( pies eq puueo tj e^sjeqt pue ojsjog jeo eiues eijt Aq ^oeq euoB seq pue JBO 8L)i yBnojqt souspisej 814 }e efood 10 esodjnd 9L|t jo^ etueo pssesoep sqi )BU;} si suioo seq ijOjy/A souapiAe 841 'A|UO KBI e se pssn cuisq sem ejoiqsA sq} }64t moqs UBo qoiy^ eiuoo seq Buj4tou eouspiAS sq} ui inq 'ixe) joj tou pue JBO &)e-Aud jo^ SB eoue.insui JQ^ A0j|od sq} pue ixei se pesn Buisq SBM e|Oj49A ei|t teqs si iBMejBv J'lipns MMS Aq pesiej uouustuoo »sjyeqi (g) •PV S9|3i4SA JO}O|M sqt p QZ l- uoipss jspun uoiieojjdde sq} Buipsfej ui JQJJS psniiuuioo jeunqui 64} )eqt uoiuido 04} y> eje SM 'eAoqe sqt p MOIA u| (rt •PV seioiqsA JO}O|A! eqi jp OZl uoipeg jspun p©iuej5ussq eAey p|noijs uojssiuued seouBtsiunojio e4t ui 'ejo^ejeqi -eiqisuodsaj si 04^ Aueduioo souejnsui 041 -?A -'C- ilMMSfc... i'"9wW'