HEGH CGURT OF (L‘HHA’i‘TISGARH AT wUxSPiER WRH‘ PETI'I‘IGN {S} N0. 5m 0f 28%8 ¥ETITIONER§ : 1. Ramnaval Piandev Sm Shri Ranamasz Pandev.‘ Agsd 63 wars, Ratired Aéstt Teacher. Govt Hr. $gc‘ Schaoi. Rakhi. Biock Araag: 13i$tt —- Raipur (CLGJ 2. Rmmhhor 33$ Manikpufi S/o §hri Shuiau Baas Manikpuri, Aged 62 years, Retired Head Master, 439%, Primai‘v SchoaE, Nav&g&m‘g Bléck Ai‘axxg, DiSfL « Raipur {L2G} Khoxbahm‘avRam Vanna 310 Shri Eiraa Lai ‘v’emxa, Aged 58 years: ‘ Assistant Teacher: G0Vt Middle SchooL Tekari (Ku11da}, Biock Arang, Distt. ~ Raipur (CG) 4. Vishram Prasati Verma S/G Late Shri Thaw). Rmrx Vsrma, Aged 5g yearsg Assistani; TeacheL Gavt, Fx'ii'x‘sary Echwi, Pigaxi’naihtha, Biock Arang, Dim. — Raigur (CG) Chhabi La} Shaina S/o Lam Shri Mohm Lid Sharma, AEeti 60 veaxs‘ Assistant Teacher Govt. Primarv S3100}, Tekari (Kimda) Block Amag Emit — Raipu} (CG) Kartik Ram Sahu Si'o Lam Shri Bhisiau Ram Sahug Ageé 62 yeam, Reiirsci Awigtam 'I‘eachaf, {30%. Pfimai‘y $c‘i1001 Ktmda (Tcakari) Biock Aramg, Eisxt. ~ Raipur {‘C.G.) Chaimi Ram Vanna SA”; Late S‘mi Nahm‘ix La} Vari’ria, Aged 63 years. Retimd AsSistam Teachmi, Gmrt. MECIdi& gathoal, Tekari {Kuilcia}, Block Amng, Digit“ -— Raipur (C.G.) 3. Biiikar Das Manikpui’i 3/0 Law §§hfi Mukhi 3a»? Manikpuri, Aged 50 yeaxs, Assisiam Teachea (EQVL Fs'imaxv SehaoL Bahwkacii. Biock Arang, Dim. ~ Rainur {CG} 9. Naiim Ram Chaiidrakar Sh) Late Shri Moimr 3h‘1gh Chandrakar; Aged 60 years, Assisiant Teacher, Grow, Midiiira Schwi, Takari (Kunda), Bhmk Armig, Dim. — Raipur {(AG.) 10.3mm: Kumar Shanna Sm Lam 8hri Raim‘aim‘l Shm’ma. Aged 59 veaa‘s Assismm Teacher Gcvt. Pirimaw Sghoai. Bagchha: Biock Mang, Bisit : Raipm‘ {8.6.} u ‘ ' H.8ac1huram Dewangan S/o Lam Shri Pzmdit Dewangan, Aged 61 years, Head Master, Govt. EFrimary Selma}, Bhaisa (Basti) Block Aramg, Dist‘t. n Raipur (£16.) 12.?Iemdas Bhatpahm‘i 3/0 Shri Premdas Bha:pahm~i Aged 52 years, ASsistam Teacher. Govt. Midc‘ige 36.11001, Goui‘i, Block Arang, Distt. — Raipur (C.G.} 13.?)eega. Ram Verma 3/0 Shri 533mg; Ram Venna. Aged 54 yuan Aseiisezmt Teacher, Gem. Mi<§€61€¢ SchoeL Semharia. BEQCk — Axmlg, Dim. « Raipur {£16.} 14. Gavel E’msa& Suktel, Sz’o Laie Sim Blzuehm Lei S‘uiaei Aged 62 yeam. Assigtanf’Teacher, {30W Primaxy Selmcrl. Palm, Biock Arang, Dim. « Raipui‘ {CG}, VJ Ln CN‘ ;z~ 3.5.Ashok Kumar Thakre $30 shri Lakshamm} Rm Thakre, Aged 55 yeam, AssiStant Teacher, Gavt ¥ Mitidle 3611001, Semaria, Elock Arang, Dim. — Raipur ‘ (mi) ‘16‘Bhx1vneshwar Pragad Sahu S/o Law Siné Asha Ram Sahu, Agsd 60 wam, Head Masieaz G-nwi. Frimary Schoal, Kuhem. Biock Arzmg Dim. —— Raip‘ur (Ci‘i) 11Neelkanth Dhumndhar Sm Shri (Eevin§ Raw Dhumndhar, Aged 63 yearsa Asgisiant Teachm; {EGW Frimarv Se‘nooi. Ameri, Biacii Amag, Disii. ~ Raiyw" (£13.) 18.Ke§u Ram Famm; 3/0 Laie Shri Firm Ram Park-cu; Aged 6} yearS, Head Magter, Govt. Primary Scmaéw Tekari {Knack} Blwk Arang, Dim. — Raipur {Cfi} 541 yea§s, Assiw Teachar, G-{WL Primarv ScRmw} Ak—Glikhurd‘ BHOck Aramg, DistL A» Raipur {QG} 2{}.Ba‘vnaraym Simmm Sio Shri Umaaiatykm ’Ti‘wag‘i’. Agad 5g years, Assistant '1‘eachex, Gum" i’vémary whool. Java, Block Arang, Digit A— R‘aipm‘ ((3.6) ELLakhm} La! Patel S/o Sim Brijial PataL Agw 57 years? ASSigtmi Tuiaijher, Govt. Emmi? Emmi Ima‘mulh, Block Amng, Dim. ~ Raipur QCQ.) 22.?rem La}: Saba Sfo Shri Dérha Ram Sahu, Agnd $5 wars. A$sistam Teachar. {3mm i’rimauy Smumk iawad, Block Armig, Distt. - Raipm‘ (CGJ 23. Samazm Banjare S/o Shr§ Jhadu 1&3 E$a11§arc_. Aged ;i$ wing, Haw Magiex', Qavt. Primaxy Stihuoi, Nam, Black Arang. Distt. a Raipur (CG) 24.Kamta Prasad Gilliam S/o Shri Bag-awn Das Gi3imm, Agsti 56 years, Assistam Teacher. GQVL Pzimary $€hoek Tandu}, Ekmk Arang, Dim. — Raipui‘ (C.G.') 255$ Chand Tandan S/o Ski Budhmi Tan&zm. Aged (éffv warm. Hem} Magter, Ggvt. Frixmw Schwi. Kagéehi.’ Heck Arang, Distt. ‘~ Raipur (C.G.j 26.31%.a‘ga Pi‘aSad Shamm 8/0 $1M Nimujmn Frasad Sharma, Ageci 58 years, Assistant Teachar. Gtwi‘. Miwk? Sczhool, Kumd (Kutela), Bioek Anmg. Dim. - Raipur {C.G.) 27. Siia Ram Dewangmi 3/6 Shri Ragm Rajyn D‘awaixgail, Aged 58 yem. Assistant Teacher. Cmvt, himary School, Bhaii’usa, Bhatapam, Black Arang, Disit. ~ Raipur (C(32) }9.Ra<1heshvam Verma $10 Shn‘ Tej Ram Vanna Agad 28.Ramadhar Chaturvedani S/e Shri Shyam L411 Chaturvedani AgeLi 6(} yeaxs, Assisumt Teacher, Crew. Middie Seimei, Kumd (Kui‘eia), Bbek Ai‘zing, Dim. — Raipur (C.G.) 29.Bhzigwat Das Mailikpuri S/o Shri Mamakhen Das Manikpuri. Middle Scheel. Aged 'Semeriye: 51 veara Assisiam Block Arm:g, Te wher 31m (yaw. w Raipur (C.G.} 3§.Punit Ram mdoriya 8/0 Shri Sitaram kidioriya, Ageai 59 vears, Assistam Teacher, Gevt. Middle $eime‘i, Semariya. Bieek Amng, Bisfi. ~ Raigmi‘ (0G3 @ ‘1 Basawan Immar Mandala 3/0 Lane 8hr: But ham Ram . madaie, Aged 53 years" Asmstant Teacher, imvt. Primmy Sclmgl, Samoda, Block Arang, Dism. ~ Raipui‘ {c.G.) 32 Kapil Ram Sahu S/o Shri fimnta M1 $ahu Acmd 54 veayb, Asmtam Teachera (govt High Same gram Oak Amng, Dnii -— Raxpm (C G 33.Kishan Lal Shanna S/o Shri Rambhamsa Ehalma‘ Agec} 61 years, Hsad Master, Govt. Primary Schoui K0sraxigi, Biock Amng, Dim. — Raipur {QGI} 34.Ashwani Kumar Shanna SJO Shri Fekan La} Shanna: Aged 61 “yeam, Head Master, Govt, Pi‘izmry $cheoi Banzmai, Block Arangg Distt. - Raipur (CG); 35.3uresh Bank 3/0 Shri Prasamm Baa‘ikg Agai €30 ysais, Assistant Teacher, Govt. Middle Schooh Manclir Hasmi, Biuck Amng, Distt. v— Raipur (€.G.‘) 3%i.Ashok Kumar Sirmoar S/c Shri Trilochan Simwug Agitc‘l 56 ‘veam, A3$isw11t Teaclm‘, u‘uw Prhuary Schoai, Bhaisamudi, Block. Arang§ Disti. - Rajgaur ((1133 3’7.Mahesh Kumar Vanna S/o Shri Dukhu Ram Vsmia Aged 51 years, Asmtani “hacker? Govt Primary Schaoi, Kega‘wgi, B30ck zh‘ang, Disi‘t. — {{aigu'f {CGJ $8.3ugegh Chandra Das S/o S§1Ii Vidhu Bhushan Dag, Aged 51 years, Assisiam Teachm; Gmit. Méddk: Scheoig Banaf Biock Armg, Dim. — Raipur (C.G.:3 39.Laxs11inath Chzmdrakar S/o Sim Bhagwmta Chandrakar, Aged 58 years; Assistant Teacher, Gem. Primary School, Banidih, Biock Arang Dim. ~— Raipm" {C.G.) MLGarii'; Ram $ahu 3/0 Shri Sada Singh Saim. Agni 58 years Assistam Teachar Govi Primarv Schosl, M10151 Block Amng, Dish — Empur ’C G } 41 Maiahan ml Dhmandhar 5,10 Law Sm! Er (kw Ram Dimmimm‘, A d JG wens Aaswtam Tmnhur Guvi Middle $chool. Bhainsa, Block Arang. Distt. — Raipur (06.) 42.Ramswamp Charldraka: S/o Late Shari Jam} Chamh‘akm', Agec‘i 59 years, A$$iswm ’i‘eauEam‘. GWL High School, Nisda, Biack Arang, Bistt. « Raipur (C13,) ‘43.Awa,dh Ram Verma S/o Late Shri Sujan Sing} Vanna Ageé 58 years, Assistaat Teacher, Gevi. Michile Schooi. Mamiir H&sod. Block Armg, Disi‘k. r- Raiyur (am 44.?urushoitam Shama. S/o Late Shri Ckatm‘bhuj Shm’ma, Ag6d 59 wars, ASsistmi‘t 'i‘eachat. Gwt. E’rimzny $31001 Lodhipmia. Blgck Aramg, Distt. — Raipur (CPL) 45. Chima Ram Belgahe Sfo Shri Ramnihai Baigahe, Aged 54 ymm, Asgistam Teacher. {3mm i’i‘imary Sehuoi, Arang, Block Arang, Distt. ~ Raipur ((1.6) 46.Anup Nath Yogi S/o Shri Gajsndra Natl} Yogi, Agaci 61 yoars, AssiStam Teacher, $3ovt. Frimary School, , é @ 13andhi, Black Arang, Distt. u Rajpur (CG) 47.Kaushal Kumar Gupta S/a Shri Bhuwar; Lai Gama Aged 59 yeam, Assimant Teacher, Govt. Middie Schooi, Maudir Hawci, Biock Afaag, Distt. — Raipur (0(3.) 48.3mt. Dhamnat Gayakwad W/o Shri Neeikam Gayakwad, Aged 55 yeam, Hgad Master, Gem Primary School, Mandii‘ Hasod, Block Amng, Dim. ‘* Raipur (QGJ 49.Aj‘udag Mirche 3/‘0 Sia‘i Eari Lad Mitch: Aged 61 years, Head Master, Govt. Primary SchmL MungL Biack Arzmg, Disit. ~ Raipui‘ {c.G.) 5G.Bisrudas Manikpuri S/o Shri Chhavidas Manikpuri, Aged 60 years, Assistant Teacher, Govt. Middle SchooL Chandkhuri, Bl0ck Arang, Digit. ~ Rajpur {c.G.) 51.Ramadhar Vanna S/o Shn' Tukaram Verma, Aged 57 'year3, Agsigtam Teacher, Gem. Frimary Schuui, S&k’1‘i, Block Arang, Distt. ~ Raipur (C.G.) S2.Shi“v Pragad Dhi‘vdmxde S/u Late Siu‘i matigiu ' Dhivdonde Aged 61 years, Heaé Master, Govt. Frimary 3611001, Nagpura, Bioek Aumga Distt. ~ Raipur (C.G.) 53.Ne§)al Prasad Venna Sfo Shri Chajt Ram Verma Aged 5’? years, Assistant Teacher, Govt. Middie Schooi, s Badgaon, Block Arang, Distt. —- Raipm‘ (CG) 54.Hemraj Gilhare S/o Shri Kartik Ram Gilhare, Aged 52 years, Head Master, Govt. Primmiy’ Scme}, Dhzms‘uii, Block Arang, Distt. — Raipur (CG) 55. Sharad Kumar Vanna 3/0 Sigri Bhau Rein Verma Aged 53 years, Assistant Teacher, Cmvt. Primary School, Godi, Block Armg, Distl. — Raipur (CG) 56.Deendayal Shau S/o Lame Shri Dhaoamm Sahu Age{l 62 years, Assistant Teacliei‘, Govt .F‘dt:xax~y Selaooi Arang, Block Arang, Distt. — Raipur (C.G.) fa7.Snklal Pragapaii 8/0 Sln‘i Dayaram Pmiapati, Aged 61 years, Assistant Teacher, Govt. Primary School, Mohmela, Block Arang, Distt. — Raip’m’ (C.G.) ’ VERSUS . The State of Chhaltisgarh, Through ~ Secretarv. General Admirdstration & Educatioo Dooamuom, D,K.S. Bhawan, Raipur (0G) 2. District Education Officer, Dim. — Raigm‘i {06.) WRIT PETI’HON UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA ~ RES?{}NDENTS SB: Hon’hle Shri Satish K. Agnihotri, a}. Shri Ajay Shrivastava, Advocate for the petitioners. Shri Arvind Dubey, l’auel Lawyer for the Statekespomlents. L Present: , ORAL ORBER (Passed on 24m day of Jamiaxy, 2008} The petitionersy warking a3 Assistant Teacher, wem gramsd first Kmmomaii ma <‘)1.G1.198§6 a§i€r campieiioya af 12 years of serviea Tm peiitionarss were granted first katmonnati as the petitioners were not gamed any premotioa or up-gradation during the period. As per eircular dateci 24.042006, (Amexure EV?) read with 17-03-1999/19—4 - 1999 {Amiexure P/I} the petitioners are entitled to secorxd hamormati afrer cempktion of 24 years of service. Learned celmsel appearing for the petia‘joners strong§y relied on decision 9f Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of State of Trinura and omers Vs. K.K.Roy (2004 SCW 1) and judgment and order dated 29408.2(){E6 yaesed in WHP. No. 2805/2002 (R.S.Verma Vs. $taie of Ciahaiiisgarrr ami others), Whereim the ouesiion for granting of first and second Kramonnati were urxder consideration. The Hon’bie Supreme Court observed as meet: “7. We are. thus. ofthe opinion teat the respondent herein is at least entitled to grant oftwo higher grades, one upon expiry of the period of 12 years 330m the date of his joining of the service and the other upon expiry of24 years thereoii” Learned counsel for the State/respondents submits that the deeision in the matter of State of Tripura and others Vs. K..K.Roy (Supra) ami R,S.Verma Vs. State of Chhattiegarh & Others {supra}, are on the some point. In View of the foregoing, this petition is a1lowed mod the oetitioners are entitled to second Kramormati after completion of 24 years of service. in accordance with circular dated 24.04.2006 (Annexure P/ l) read with l7- 3-1999X19-4-19995 eubject to verification of the facts. No order asto $0 Amt. costs. \‘y Sd/— " Satish K. K. Agnihotri‘ '1 Judge