"l ‘flé‘w' ‘ £Q§ 'k's' i}? §uEE€i$YvRE €HHA5 é E&§&RH: 8EL;%SPU§§ “'RET PETETE§N§ N31§26 OF EOQ3 Harm‘ q‘mgh Saini Fa: v \vfar’aus m . r Smi’a OT Cnhuf‘i’isgarh & anm‘her AND W‘ f1: §3ETiTiéN NGiQEi @F‘ 2$G§ aurIJuy c-»:-.. v... hur‘l‘sui’ ‘.. ‘1‘...“ ! rwui"§ - wW Versus $Tai‘e 01: C'h'haffisgur‘a & ano‘fher- z i, T FGR 0mm cm 5nd 5epiwbzr, 2003 raw?! auuKs $3; JUDEb n “rat I .r‘rn I ”éTU&E QH' W Inn-pn- $92G Q? 2G€§3 wwu ?::1ILL;N NU PEJTJQ a“E?“ ‘?2 % § QE’ §PONbENT§ rmhi $1LA§PUR ’13 Harps! Sin§hv 5am E/c ShM Mam Siagh 5aini, Agec’ abouf §4 years, ' Gasupaficrl: 5ervicel prasen‘rly pos‘red as Qff'zcia’ring $uh Divisiond Offigen Vidham Sabha‘ Sub DiviSicm, Eaipur {Ca} Ver'sus §+a+a m" éhhqf‘u‘isgarh I cuqh The 5ecr’e1’ary, Dug: Warks Dapar’rmem, :‘Aanfmkya, D’K’S. Bhawzm, Rmpur- {(LG.) Engineer-in-Chief, ii‘ubHc Warks Depar‘rmen‘r‘ éovammen? of Chha‘H'isgarh, WRE‘?‘ $E’TITTGN N0‘1921 OF 20a§ m: WI IQN‘Wa'; r-u-‘- n \ Sanjay ‘rfumar Tiwari, Sis Sh“. bandar La} Tiwar'L Aged abam 4? years Gccupa?ion: “ervxce pra$em y pasfed as? 5u% Czivimémol Officer (E/M,, "" p w D ....,.... r’ ersug mt s‘c PvkvvEtu n nx M“f5 . fa) c:,.k mugsion' ‘ wuu uny S‘rafe (if ChhmWisgurh, Through: The Secremry, Public Works Depar‘rmem, Manfmiaya, DJLS. Bhcxwan Raipur {£26.} ngmeer' m Chier .. ID 'b g Jerks Deparmenf mm nmen‘f of Chha? Isgarh, _,.x'_.¢\:.\ fampur LEG.) ”' ~ 1H€ are ’servh? En ; anhlgmishad and marimriaug. Far Th2 pgrp 0f A's:sisfan? Engineer in i-he PubL‘c Eecwui‘fmem izuies, provfdrz - _ magi-jgr‘eQi Th3 {Quies ‘sll/ .v orV¢ 1969, (‘her‘eina‘ff'e 'ckigi'neér$ who ‘ r prameir’ign + wgug.d he furfher' previéa spec Emmaers hc h " “M DE u “Ia .am€ m‘ fhe pefifianer- -is m? promofion +0 fhe pas? Eepar‘rmem‘, rat'evan‘t rulas namely, g' “my (Ecueffed) Service r referred 1'0 as "fhe Rmes‘) have scraw‘hd 12 years of sarvice sf 9f Assistanf Engineer. éaf ‘queT‘a sepam‘few for fhose Sub- aquimlen‘r. They are wear-d En nn omnn e W fake pa uc§r€€ Gr Ian... w / Mr. Manihém 3hrivasi'az/a, Advocuie: For- “r‘ne pefi'h'oners For +he S‘rafe/r-espcndenfs Far hLie I'Mervener (i? R f3 § R in (Pass'ed _ an QgtSepfamber, 2GO3) Lg: giméw J i. 8a??? i’hé§e wri? “e‘zflfmm raré‘r: f’ +":é mme‘ itae‘ Therafora, are being dispesed 01? by this camman omen 2. By ‘ wri? pe‘méon (WPNQEQQG Consi‘i‘ru‘rien of: Imdia! fhe é? 2003} undgr Arfide 226 of 3315?98/G2/ENC ua‘rea‘ pe?ifiomer 1“ hag chaiiengeci me crdar NoEs‘rt/ Nevembzr, 2002, issued by The: Ehgineer, ?Lbiic Wlvr'ks Dgpari’menf by wiric‘i‘i fha educa'iiancxi Dgpari’menf C..aiiisnnrh grespondem’ No quaiir’imi‘ion of "rha pefifion‘er has chmg‘ed frcm degree is dipiama’ quaiificaiion of Sanjay Simiariy, fhe educafionai Kumar- Tiwawi: fi’ia pe‘t’iiioner in W.P.No.1921 29%, h is: baa'r: cimriggd fmm darfea h) digvia'ma 3. The pei‘iiioner's‘ case (Vz'PJ‘Qoig'c‘q a§painfed en 13.93193 as \v’erks of 2QCI3) is fha‘i' he was ir1i1'iaiiy \v’erks ,‘ssisani’ and afier fen momhahe was appoin?ed as Va I- qi c ‘. I_..V.* ‘ V H v-‘ .. W, gv. V WV . . ,,_x,-,v, L . grL § po¢r Q; ASS'STGFN, nniH9Dr‘ Ilhnn rnmhl +Iv1r1 V( fl WW... my k? v nM mF wr‘mco anc’i a flxed per-cenmge 0f posw cf ilss§sfcxm gneers m ear-marked mr fhxs par‘hc lar' AA+~-«WJ ,vF /.'n A. u. a.Al yuxa‘wvl y vu u! germissEon ‘grom t: 'i'né I Debar'hnenf mm‘zwfoak The course 0‘35 AMIME . {Associai’e i‘vxgmharship of Insfi‘rufe 0"1 Mechanicai Engineer‘s of India) nwi mmwd irhe said examina?ien. “w wr+vFiM+0 Issued by iha said ins‘i'ii‘u’re ha$ haw widaiv accebfed aad recognized no1' ani in “rhe arsi;Ic.a.a. giuz want; 01,cu." maunw rakeai uni! u; u Lsearee aquivaienf 'r ' Bachelor 01f Engingaring bm‘, (.1139 in variow ;ic.1.rir$ 0f {rhg caunfry and aiso by ‘i’he bepari’menf of :ciucanon,>fv‘\misrr=y OT v1 '$ ' I FH“gineer‘s. TL. me pgmianer +4. affer seeking g“ K“ yuan“, nu.uman Qesour‘cgs Developman‘r, §Qvarnmani a? India ”:da risiwficcfiem du. 9d 25951976, 06.10.1981 3i 24.16.1981. According *fo The pa‘rii'ioner in “r’ne ersi‘whiie Siam of Madhya Pradesh, fhe 5ub—Engineer win) pcsfs’eSSaci I mvmvxt: 4 ilTll" Nuegrae is being Tract‘i'ed a3 oqnnmmn‘i‘ Tn +lna hnlrwr' Inc R E D nrv p and ha is bging given bengfi‘f of: acceiemfeé wemo‘a’io'n under Exmd‘um-g Enqinaer' qum‘a. The said degnea u: «L AEA ”hum;E nu.) L Liam! L xzJJJgnuLcuA u.“H Uim A..AA H7€ l CGLii’i'i'P‘] in VQr‘IOUS s‘i’a'fas lika Andhm Pr‘gdggiw. Kamlg, Karmmka, Madhyq ?nade$h, Maharashi’m. §ajasinan eta, and reiem’n‘i’ documen‘i’s ara annexed as nnnexure P—Z. Tine a+n+a m: Mmiimn DMAML. m. aih <9“ 0mm” 1998' had issued a cir‘cuim“ ‘i’ha‘i‘ 20% of .ine Dosis 6f Assisi’an'i‘ Engineer in pmmoi’i‘o‘i’a qucfa wauid be fiiied Lip irom amangsi 3m.“ Sub—Enginears whe have obi‘gingd dggree. 'whiie. in sari/ice, ihe. circular- iS Annexur'e P-3 and cansis'ren‘r wii'n ‘r'ne said circuiar ‘riie pmmo‘rions were made fmm Tima +n 44m» n; ninan yvv v nnuu‘u . x uuuun uu Vsayxunngu. , Tha pa‘rifienar nassed in» ubsvs caurw und Wiuined The cerh‘icai'n U1 defied 04.02.199f which is Annexune P—A, and “the same was submiii'e& \i’a nae Eepari’men'i' ana . reiemn‘? . eni‘nies were made in 'i'he service resorti a? the. p ?'+innan chewmg hm! as Graduafe Engineer. The said enir‘iee are Nmexure ‘P—E. in #he grada‘i‘icn iie‘i’ 9f SubwEngineers y i , ;$uuad by ma uggmrm f'rie 'paiifimar was cieariy shoém as E'mrjuafg Engmew a? 5eria! $30.8 as on 01.042601. A copy of fhe grada?ien iisf is Annexur 5 8 A éopy o-F The page shawing fhe name 3f iha pa‘rzfmmr m Sm .u. wc 0 0‘ #516 amdanan ha. as on 01 O4 2000 Is amaxa‘d as Annexure P—9‘ ,Sy' virme of provisicns of MP. ik‘tgcr'ganizufion Act EEUG, "rhe pei‘i‘i’iomr is gnfiiied T9 be profecfed of S) n . .uw H Hna Panmc nnr! rnnrirfmn< n-f‘ km ¢gylmro npQn 3HQCQ~hon To fhe SfQ-j‘e 5*? CMmf‘f'Esqarh we? name of fhe fer‘mg and condifions of The £ervice2 mm bu a} ‘rad, ‘ff‘c‘had, 0. crimigeu m his prejudice Thoiigi’i i‘hey can be (harm d his advanfaga. Tha Depar‘rmgnf had issued ’rhe finai m4: gmdm‘ion iisi‘ on ELY“ Navamber, 2002, aisa wherein The pe‘ri‘i’ioner wcm‘ Shawn gs craduafa 5 b—Enginazr, vhic‘r‘. is Vrevrc Ann'exure P40. The. mama cieariy shows Tim? Ti’ie gradaiion HS“? has {mew prepared on “fhe i um Luau 12 {)1 30 $bu€u vy‘ ihe STCKTa 0f Madhya Prnrjgshv H Hui/9r VIA? Imp -m‘zd 21.11.2002, suddeniy wifhauf qivi’nq any nm‘ice f9 Tim szTii‘iorier and wifhouf givimg my pp rmmfy u. ”ma. raj, w q’rf praiudice, he was shown as a Diploma Eigitiaer meawing ‘i‘nereby “rhaf ‘fhe S‘i'afus of Gmdua‘re réiiginaer‘ Ems baan mkan away. The Said arder is‘ famexure P—ll, which is whelly illegal, arbitrary and unconsi’i‘mi‘ienal, resul‘ting in aliem’fion of The farms and condifions 01" “r'ha paificner‘s sarvice, aqains? which ‘rhe pefi?ior:a. mud: u sari g svf raprasewafians, bu? none. of mam have beer: considered $0 far. New, The pe‘i‘ifianer has learn? *rha‘i“ fhe Deunr'i’mexni’ is hoiding ca Emper'fmemai Promo-rim Cammi’h‘ee Meefirig far makaM pMm ficns. C) The said impugned srder we b en waged .n iisiaton of The principies <f\ of; ha’mmi jusi’ice and h‘ ai‘iers ‘i’he fer-ms ahci cohd'i'riohs of The service w me pa? hher' whieh ie imgjer'mis 'bie i'r‘i View 0% profecfive provisiahs caniained in MP. Reorgan g. Act ZQQQ. The impugned order is cfherwise whoiiy iiiegai, capricieue and ageing? i'he long smncling recaghiiiah given 1's fhe helders 9‘ AMIME P gy‘e whleh has always l " : iv n Tha duvumeni icfaribd by 'i'ht'i Vcnnwmd !.€. 'i'i'ié Qmda‘rion “ST iSSLlgd CO u n P n baa“; %rgaf‘d Tc) bé. équ 11%é’r1f f9 ac. uegraa in The maf‘rer of prnmofion. Thgrrzfere, a writ in i'he na‘mre 91F cerTiomri W quash and $e1" agida fhz impnqned order Ea isguad and a wri‘r of mandamus 9V I‘ilHuill’Uiig !ill§ ’§ EJ Fl\.£%§ii43 1's. a Tha Ege‘ri’rioner‘s smfus of A‘v. ”hm; +1.» a + #6 I n5 i’y‘ma‘ua‘?a Emginear and cofagider his casa for promo'rkm *ro fhe pas? of £$si3mm Engmear in f'na g3mducn‘e Eéqgineer's quam as par The Ruieg of 19‘9 kc issued Qzmm has bean fhed an baha!‘ ‘ fha Smalraspondgn’rs»WWhich fhe resmm‘em‘rs have a’isbu’red mfher 1”hey have &er1iad 1‘he iiaci” ‘Hfm’ We ars?w‘ni§£ 5 mg m‘ :‘v‘iQm‘h‘ya 'r‘mda‘n hm§ ai§a %ssued circulars awd no’ri'?ica1‘.ims holding fha? fhe Diplemn ms3ed hy a‘candidaTe from £%!‘J\L"V‘\E is equivaienf 1'0 a Deqree in Engineering from a recognized Ur; ‘ a*si1y. Tha sm'l'emen‘.‘ of Th oe‘rifioner is fai$e and baseless. The oeii-fioner has enclosed nofifica‘i’ions of vorious’ Sia‘i‘as, Iou‘i ihas no? . Supgor’i‘ad hi$ ms‘e by o. noiificai‘ion from i'ne 5mm of Macihya Pradeshi Thp rn<a n'F +lnp Pg “ i$ family differeni’ irom fhe candido‘i‘e having obminad o Degree from Associo're Members lns’rifufeof Ehgmeer; hokafa wimh hue beeh wnmdered *a be equsvaiem‘ +0 a Degree of 6rodmiion from any ofher recognized Universify. However, in we ins'mn'r ease, ihe pefifioner possesses orgiy a dipiomo Thor? Too 42mm m. ”ea-mm, im um M AMTAM: Wig 14m moi Dipygma has “0+ bggn nofi’Fied eifher by fhe ers‘rwhiie $1‘a‘i‘e oi: 'iodhyo Prodesh or bY"+he oewiy wnneo‘ wa‘re ui Chhofrisgorh. Uofii ood unless fhe $To'te Qcivernmeni‘ ooi‘egorioaily notifies Thai: a Dipioma from fhe said Ensi‘ifuie (AME t) s equwmenT *‘o o Degree The pe‘i'moner wouio no? he *“*;+'"d for any re!‘ ix mu w. u nu vvu Hum—tn uw .muu u,“ canine a eariier dai‘ed 20.11.2002, whereby ihe quaiifica‘i‘ion of The pefii‘ioner , was shown as I egree in engineering was omenoea and by Virme of The ”aid Irvipu ned order if was shown Thai fhe penfioner was a diploma hoider .Lnaoveri‘enfiv +he onswermq resoonden'fs whlie preparing rhe / \\ i/ 9 ”L i f' ' 2 c\ l£v “ éa’fian iie‘sf and c‘ds-tj ir‘I fhe Carr€5p0rxdéfuca5 behaving +hm‘ “rha 3$. TI r ‘rhe pai‘i‘rianer agains‘r his mm'e in fine gradation iis'i‘ an& ofher G “h duw..mma was shcwn f0 bc a uegrea Hswevm , when The said facf was dei‘eci‘ed by fhe answer-Mg r‘espondeni‘s fhaf ‘H‘ze Dipioma which i“h2 pefh‘iomr was hoiding was no“? nci‘ified eiiher by fha Sm‘re cf Madhya Wadash c." by in”? “a” MC FWrv'H'mnnnh 1'9 ba’equivaien‘f m a BE. Dagrea, The arad‘aE'on ifs? and ofhei" dgcumeafs whereim fhe pefi‘rioner‘ wua anvwn w ur. u Dzgfév? :10méi‘ 14 gxjmm’ 93’: Bidding +ha+ +ha pg'i'i‘ficmgr §$ :1. Dipiomtg hglder. l : a c- ?he pafif! no” bmng 9glilxialey1+ +n adegree, fhe qualificafion hu mrraci‘gd and amendéd To The The $12112 92F Madhya .pmr‘esh 11c$ nave! .ssued a.y noTIfaca'hon shrl'mq ‘éinm‘ ‘E'i'xa Diaioma To be equivaien‘l‘ “r'o a 'rEachaior’s Degree in Engineer’mg‘ Thumfare fha’ sfafemen‘x‘ M: fhe pefifm.m és false, baseless and incorrect When ‘f‘ne facf was brough‘i‘ To fhe mo?ice of The anewering respandem-S, fhey had invesfigafed info ?he maf‘rer and in The mid ceursfe 91.: invesfigafioh, the p +I‘rmner' Was aiee rimmed an oppor‘i’unITy m: heaeinq aed‘ im The said ehquiry, fhe aei‘i‘rioner had canéidiy admH‘fed 4.1....A. mw u.he em}; l pessesses x“ Difbw-‘e fmm AA'RL‘v"E and The? They are in The progees of: purgging +he maWer‘ :31? The G.Qvemmem‘ levei for fhe iseuar‘lce of a nofificaTion freahng The said bipiomu To be equivaien‘i i0 e Eaehoi "a “03W” e”; Ehgmeermg A 'ccpy NF ‘rhe said enquiry and ‘ e sfaiemen'i’ of: The pe’rifioner‘ is marked as‘Amiexure {2—1. The ‘Fad‘ inui a vuni :i‘i‘i recard of The pe‘ii'i‘ioner‘ shawing him ‘i'a be a §raduaire Engineer was under a wrong impression arid ‘rhe momen‘r i‘he said fac‘i was braugh‘r To i‘he miice of The answer-mg respondenfs whereuy if was fauna mw The peii‘rianer do no'r passesses The Bachelor's Degree cf: Engimeerihg bu'i' was oniy a Dipiama inames, I) iiecessar‘y‘ ar‘c‘iers were issuea' far making necessary 'ii A ;.I mag?! iii H‘IE 5% ..._... .., 9 rim ,+< m +he sew/ire rernrri wherein i‘he pei’iiioner was eariier shewn as a Degree hoider was ordered To be correci‘ed 1'0 be ihai' The jgefifisner is 'a Diiama hsider. I? is no. d: "red Thai thase gub- W S !“ ‘ p ‘69 lm rm nger‘5 wno rlcwa r'ZQLmita quaunca?i€3’f§ (if béing a gradua‘l'evhaving ree of panineering, lAJoulii he om‘I‘Hed for promofton r0 The pos‘r 01' éssis’mnf Enqineer and Thm‘ The admif‘i’ed po3ifion in fhe “mun? ww is “ma? ?he: §afifianer da no? possass a Eachainr's Degree m’" Engmeering and on ‘i‘he commr‘y if 3s aisa an admif'i’ed 15cc? ‘Thaf 1‘he pai'h‘ionar §s a dipioma hoider‘ and ?herefor¢, ha cannot as cm dam be gnflirkd ‘m‘ pnnmMM!‘ +0 1%», p €+ f A“ mgr}? Engineer‘ 1Q.Tha $s'ar‘nmanf “f A‘mdhy" DmdaEh EM .ssuad a?! ordgr’am‘ed 14m Fabruary, 1992, by which The Cwovemmw? of Madhya Pradesh hats: vzu (mu racmm'naau Hm gai‘hfmmz: u; iéér'mician EngineerS Par?" l & ?arf—II issuad bv the insfifufien 13f Machanica! Engineers (lndia) as equivaiem‘ f0 Mad'hya Prades'h Pciy'i'echnic B§p¥oma m Mechcmical Engmeering. z~ JL T is camgoriedly submum ?}~.a‘r befare F n3 The order dated ?1 {1.2002, “Hag nn<wamna resnonden+s have conduci’ed a dei’al'ed emuir‘y m "rhe mafmr- ami i’i’le pe‘rii’io‘ner was aieo sailed upon 1‘0 expiam Hié smm$ A cc u cf fhe said ewquw‘,’ prseeedings is marked as i‘mnexur‘e {2-1. Therefore. “the DeTH’iam deserves To he &ismissed. .E have ’r;ecxrd ‘H’Ie Eeamai couna‘ei “For fhe parfieg and perwed The I 13‘ E? i3 my? manned, rai‘her V? is nciml‘r‘rea pasii'im ”rhm‘ as per The RuleS, +h¢ Quk-§nnlna9r< Milan Ana harmaa hait‘oné nrlo on'hflgd for acmigr-a‘fed promo‘ficn Subwruies ii) 5": (ii) o‘F Ruie i4 0f fhe Rules provide f'rie hUHUHIKJHS Ui ¢IlmlUlHly IUI Pi UTHUHUH VI“ I 3 y:..v...u.v m Jurim' enaineers “mime pas? af Assis‘mn-f Engineers - ii. minimum service of Two years as Junier Erigiiieers. {ii} C-‘verseersf'Heoé brafismanibmfi‘smcm To ‘rhe posis of" ii‘issisfmi Emg.eeers — A i‘iru' ‘m servme of 12 , \i/gnr‘c ne Huoncg0r-lHanri Dnn’Fi-emnn/ Drafj'sman‘ \v '"W' _..:...V 1/1 y'r. Tha aniy digpui‘a waiwz, n fhe pciitionars and The respondem's, which reauwes de‘farmnm’iwi bv fins Cour”? is ‘i'ha‘f as “fa whe‘i'her “Hue ceriificaie gbminea' by ihe peiiiioners’ (in boTh The pe'i‘ii‘iorw viZ., \MP. Naelg90/9WH XI “WM/”3(3) from .4MZME, Mumbai, has been reeagnized/ approved by ‘ihe ersfwhiie Erm're of Madhya Pradesh ahd .LL“ me euaie C4. J. 0!I wnuumJwh ('LL. us eq'vaien: .c» Degree. Admif‘redly, fhe n ‘h‘honehs have noi‘ been ahie o piqce 0h record any ardei" of i'he Evavernmeni' of iil‘xadhycx Pradesh by which The cer‘iifica‘re of AMIME hae been recngmzed s eguivaien? in “03"” Even during “the course of amumen’rsg a pari’icuiar quesfian was puf Te fhe counsel for‘“"ihe pe‘fifiaher—e and The {earned ca.nsei f‘l ihe ee’mioner'a very frgnkiy idml'i‘rpd and <lIhmITfed +hn+ fh .ifigners are. no? able “r0 lay hand on any such nofifica‘i'ion 0f ‘rhe Governmenf receghizing fhe cerfificafe of Nv’liil’lE equwal m‘ 1‘s becree whereas ‘rhe pefifioners 'rhemselves have \ armexeci order-s o? various Governmen'fs (Annexure P—II) by which +hey have recognized The cerfificofe as equivolenf f0 Ezegree. Merely on fhe besis “u? 'i‘he said cerfifica?e hos hwn remnmzed by fhe Numsfry of Educm‘ion Ea Cul‘l’urel Eovernmen‘r of indie; Governmenf of Andhm Pradesh éovernnwm of Kamila; Governmem w mamka and 60W of/ 00 SGHVULHB w m ma RUIds pray/ice: mu? (:mSi-IE pos‘ls are ’1’0 ha fmed, éCI°/s by direct rawhmen‘? and 40% by way of promotion and ouT of 337a by promefimx among .d'ipioma hoider Sub-Engineer's; 4% by promofion m‘ Graduai’a Suu ._r.g.r“:s fa waffqnen and 3% by promMiorl of DrafTsmen/Hzad Draf+smen As per Sche&uie IV of: The i'ELsias, Junior Engineem of eigh’r year‘s service are em‘ified for nmn'hrm rm dgém‘i‘nni’ Ennmoan C!ess-1T and Ovarsegrg of fwglve vaaws 3er-vica are emi‘i‘ied for pramofion as .viissigfahi' Engiaeer, Ciass— 11 5cmaduia III m‘ ‘i'he mum rei‘T‘s “is auuca‘homl quuhfica'fians which nmwde< fha? c1 ceri’ngicam or a decree In CiVIl/E/M of an Emqineer‘inq Coiieqe in india 9r cm Enqineerinq Insii‘fufa appraved by‘i‘he Siaiz Gwamman? is raccqnizad fv. tha pest n I,“ yang. .3...~.~a VT) Rajwfhc‘m, if cmi'r‘uzrf bei haid by my “*“L 35 mfrz-ycn m? i'magim'fion ?ha'r bgsed v! 5mm Gavemmmis and The, Governmen‘r of Ehdia, fhe cer‘i'ifica‘res obfained by ”r'he pei‘hioners can be {:onsiderad ‘i'o ha equivalenf fa 3agrse by fha 5mm m‘ Madhya Pmdesh or Stafe of Chhmivisgarhi GS has bean heki by 'rhe Hon'ble Apex Cour? iri pwa-iZ of The case of Qérecwr. &;J.ma cmc? mhgrs vs. 15F. Nékhil Tamiem am! gfhars raperf'ed in {1§§é} ?' WT “i341 that, “#32 fwo years‘ “framing m‘ Cambridge Umivepsyg‘ky undzrgone by Tandon whiie warkmg for his PhD. canno‘i' ”win-wuw “a; gn/S'edas equivaienf f0 Ava-“n w w kn +nan+a4 a. mn-Eum-A-mn u va n Gunny: n:- ua DM Schgduia I. ‘m fhg AIIMS 7 .gcmifmgn'i' Ruies speaks of DM quai§ficm*ion ov a quaiificcfion racognised as aqui‘v’mgrlf VLL , T . Tharefare, as ‘gar- The Raw bid dmm by “ma Han‘b%e Apex Court uniess a pari'igulqr' cerfhcim‘rg ig rgcagnisgd by “Ha campaign? aufhorh‘y and an order i$ i$sugd “r0 Thm" effect made known "ro all, fhe cer'fifica’re sanna? be considered equimkn? t9 Degree. Even Scheduk III of The Quies, upom which fhe iaamad counsei for ihe pe‘i‘i‘fionar‘s has placed wavy reiiame, pro..des “rh‘f “a sewificm‘e or 6agrge in CivéE/Eh‘m of a?! Emineerim Cniiane. in indi neréfrc. If is- m7? mare aquivalenge‘fhai‘ is c ewugl‘ Recaamsgd ‘ I? gwdgnfriv .W—‘m’l.‘ mag? aka means bz reggamsgd. ra’ccmiged ““"‘—"__"_‘.“‘ bv as fhe equivulanfl Insflfui’e gr a? iggs‘f byr f‘he Medicai Councii g rlmdi. I? is Lm’ rsmiidabie haw T‘né ‘rv‘v'a ' air-5' ‘‘ m by Tmdcn whik wcrking fer the said guahficafion can be mum-ed as c1 auaiifica+ion reca m'sea’ as eguivalenf 1’0 ~ ‘ I‘r ma‘r be eguivaiem; iLmel bew more. Bu‘x‘. fha ha "' : ‘ u’vx icm is v‘iha‘rhar ET is Facem§sad “451* ——— cmd W admi‘i‘mdiy if a in "".. puru-uu} A..- 4? 1T : L‘.‘ nu: £....~h..- lLn’mm' but,“ I...l,.l “mu 'I‘Ilu?, h- “Thg InSfHu‘i’g wa$ of The gpinion. mg“? Tandon was quaiifieci according “m ‘rhe Ruias and forwarded his; mme .5A. wt“ gurwiuer'm‘mn ~‘-..‘.J~u~ :‘w L.. uy Tm: l‘ Sauschvn -‘l-‘ i-” um -Au mTJIEZ, .i ' H‘ GmaunT$ i'c ‘remmi'l'inn' cf '2'he said ‘rwe yenM' Training as a byHLr qengmi 3fd’erigroceeding Qubiished fer 'i'he J “van-u V” u: u racogrwiszd equivalen‘? qualifica‘fion. Recoani'i’ion mus? be ‘ ’ W :m mfvrmu‘hwl -_...- :-.. w _; un An Cai‘lcer‘i‘leu. .I ET QTmFiG'I" b6 a ma‘f‘mr’ dzcidgd in c giver; case rim ‘fhe hurwse 9'? that case.” r gr! Eminegwin Iiisiifu‘i‘e aggroved £3? ‘E‘iza—z 5‘i‘a‘i‘g @vammén?“ ii; raquirad. T‘iarefor’a, wiihoui’ approva'i of d ma g angle rasemch/hainin a o / 1U .3Jma 3mm fJ. wévarW'r‘r‘xergi I‘ mer‘éry‘ I I fry 'pa5$ir1g fhé zxaminafion and ebmining ‘Zrhz ¢erfificafg came? be rnmw'iv-‘W‘ equivalem’ m Degree‘ The pafi'i‘icners have m? beeri abie 1'9 iay hand on may ordar' or circuiar of +1., HIE uu'vcai’immi'h /‘ by vunmh iéxaAIaaAg has 58‘??? approvad and G5Cepf€d aquivaiem‘ 'i'o Degrée. Evan in the case 9f $Aghgmmgd Shugg? A55 gmj a‘fhers vs. Union of: mdia am? eimaws rapom‘ed in AR i§?4 5f: 1531 in pcam3pHqe Q mnawm r‘mm+ Inn:- Al—aselnVeri +Lm+ q- £ VHF: pun.- vvu: 1 Hug vu u unvu, “If mus? be mo'red Tha?‘ The ques'ri‘m ia regard +0 equivaiemce of educa?iomi quafificafiens is a Technical ques?;cn basad an prcper assassmwf and evaluafrien of Dvah‘? ac rjemic siundard3 and pracTical affammen‘fs 61‘ such uahhcafiows nd where The decision 01‘ me wovemmam rs msea on The recommerxdafion of cm n+ LnAn ”MA" awe” wuy mm... pcssysas 3+m re“u:s:+e knowiedge 5km and axpgrtfiSg far nri9nlln+Piv dl5£har9mg such a fumc‘hun The Cour? umnformed of relevanf dam and i ummaea Qy me Tecnmca! ms’lgnTs’ necessary for The parpsse u, n£ wmmimng’ Ahqmy. aqurv'aenw, wculd noT lighTly disfmrb "i‘he. decision m‘ ‘fhe Ggver'n .S:m:!a”iy The Hcn'bis Ap v "m'r‘+ m Th casa f $m+e 0f Ragayfnan mm ofhehg vs. Lam Arum repom‘ed' m 20G? éi§ $€W 2§é6 in para—12 4...! A. iau 16w “Ha? nw<rmbed eligibiliw aualificafign far admission +0 c: J I '1 cuurse or for recruifmen‘r To or ammo-fion iii service are maiiers‘ f0 be considered by ihe appropriafe au‘rhori‘ry. “r4. i m mn+ Jim, mania-Ln +9 A V3,. ...L.-+L.nn a Parficuhr \ >a nvl ivy v u um» Winning; ad ca ioml aualiFicn+Ion shauid or Shauid no? be accepfed gs sqwvgign? T3 Ting quaiifiga’rian prasgribad by fha riLiTr’IQr‘iry. AL! ,_L ll In 1‘ha presen‘r casa, ‘rhe pe‘i'ii’ioners ara n01” abie 1"0 pmduce any barii'rica‘ra issued by #he Sfa‘i‘e c‘. Pv‘adhya PMdesh car Chha'r‘hsgcxrh cppr-avihg fhe said cerii‘iica‘i‘e equivaiem“ 1‘0 Degree. f'Tha iPamea counsai "r'rw “fin? hsi‘l‘hongrs submii‘ieci 'rha? +he pe‘i‘i‘i‘ioner 5arpai 5mg“ 3mm), m “arm: No 8§ of ‘i‘he gradation iis‘i‘ (Amexurs Pw g7; I guqd h +Lm amiss-my!!!» £2+n+q 9f gum-“mm DmAa$h wad m; ganja; Nag :wauum. :muu y y .c I 7 I - ,7 I ~ m Trig: gr'cmafim n$f {Armaxur-e {3—8) ig§ueé by fhe Sink 9f €hha??§sgarh, has -wn <1'mww M n gr’wunw in The column of "eciuccx‘rimai auaiificm‘ion’. Therefore, baseci on This, i‘r is pmved fha‘i' +L.,. ”In FannG .4" i '$ ya; [If-hula WGa Iauvym Eu, CA3 D greg GYld Tha'f CGYWIGT be charmed m Is +t~ue ”rim? m we a adafaon ilsfs {Annexures P 8 & P 9) The educa’ficm'; quaiificai’im 0f fhe pe‘fii'ioner has been shown as 5m n e As per- ?he Learned lceunsa! fer flag pefi‘rioner‘s This was mramiorxad based on +§1e czrfificafe o'h‘fained' bv fhe pefifimer from fhe rn‘xluula \r‘iél‘xifv‘f} H‘Iéi’élma gh€ p€T.T.Q 2F$ ShOU‘d b as Craduq‘rgs. This arguman‘i' 9f iha iggmad mgns‘ei for The pefiiioners is wiii'mu'i' firms, far ihe racism i‘m‘i in ‘r'ne firs? insfance, as has been mantienad abwm ‘iha S ., f madh ' Prada i ar‘ Chhm‘risg’ar‘h has not cmmovad iaa ceri'ificai'w obfamed bv ihe ae'fiimrier‘s 3rd consuiered iiia'm equivaiei‘iT m ueg‘ree Therefoiig, av‘ai‘i if in The calumn of willrrrirmmi quaiificatigns of fhe §radafi9n lisfr fhe pefifioners have 532% show/y: as éraduaigs Tim? does no? creme defansible righ‘trin favaur sf “”3 pmiiwimrs uniass an unfii ‘i'here is-‘a circuigr or- noi‘ii‘icaiion by ‘i‘he §overnmem recagnizing ‘l‘hese cerii‘fica‘fes as eqaiivaienf i0 Degrae. moreover, fherz is nofhing on regard, which goes in shew ’rhd: um? was ihe basis 'm‘ recording ihe educational quaiificm‘ion of fine peTiTioners as Degree hoiders and Lmder' whose arders if W‘s recorded, no n i imi is wan ie an The record To Thai eWecf ‘5 h amdo‘hoh lisirs are always subjec‘f 1‘0 revisiorif On verificaiion/scmfiny, if any vuiici objec’rions are raised by The o€fice or hy any permn wh 0 "59h” ”no "“Vsed fhen fhis can be rectified. Mereiv eri'ferimg The educai‘iomi quuiifim‘rion of 'fhe pei'ifioners as Eegree holders .h ‘rhe gradahoh iisi o’oes ho? ehfi‘rie The pe‘fi‘rioners f0 wean? fhem as Degree. holders for all purPQSes and always. Moreover, 'i’he basis for i‘his is i'he élifxIfviE ces‘rificaw' obfuihed by The pei‘i‘rioner‘ and shelf Mr‘hficme .i s no? beer: approved aisher by ‘lhe $Ta‘re of Medias/a Pradesh or bv “ihe S‘l‘a’le o hhalfisoar‘h There ore The I fauliéGTIérl i 4‘ §f TFE paTlTiQi’lEr" bl’lim §TQfl m nwa.‘ », L a nsidared i 1 1 :4 \ “sex y 1?. Evari %‘r’1e Paéipawarifs m’vz var‘y‘ cafegar‘icai'iy 5?a?ed in ‘i'he rzfum ma? when “may came “to know abeu? fh- ,ac? I‘ha‘f in The coiumn of educai‘iami quaiificai’ion of fha gradafim iisT, ’Dagrea’ has bean §n£orracfiy reccrdac‘}, 'E’hay %mmé:d§a?e¥y made scru‘riny of fhe records mxo’ when “rhay Paacha& fha coaclusioa fha'f ihe pei‘i'fioners (Harpai U3 +~ mgh Saini & 5amjuy Kumar T§wari) era m? degrae hoidars ihey passed he: impugned orcier, fha? 1‘99 cf.er‘ giving an opporhg’aii’? To The gzefh‘éaners. {K narusai of Amexure Ewi, in which bofh fhe pefifianars ham s§g?1ad, shows *haf arlquiry mm: ceiiduc?‘d cmd opgaer'wmfy f0 The pgi’ii‘ianerS was given and fhay hava admi?i‘gd Thgf Them are no crders cf The aovemmen? Trem‘ing The cerfificafe of IQMIME as equivalen‘i‘ f0 Dam-ea. .m View cf ‘rms, The §ef§1’§cnars have m casa, Tha gradation iisT NC) ., prepared cannoi' confer any legal righ‘? on ’rhe pefi?ioner’s and fhe same wag aiway3 Subjecf f0 corrac‘ficn, if any mismke is found as has been hgid by ‘?hg Hon*bie Ape)! Ceuri: in “the case of R5. Ajara and o‘rhers vs. 5%a‘§‘@ cf éuiam? aad‘ ofélws 'reparfeci in i199?) 3 $C€ $41 in pam~21 1+,a? #ha sarabriw 5s? d§d n0? carxfar'caiiy right as The eeniorii'y HS“? wag ehalienged befare fhe éegr‘t in ‘khiS case