^ ^P^}^D^Ior ^ 5^^g_^^ jTO^^T^^3iT^^-%^^\r^^ ^, §{^T^3^j :„ p m^ ^•GL^l^/99 m^m :- }» ^ ^7.^- ^p ^ 3@ g^ Nar ^ ^r?T ^g <TQT - ^ g q-f^ ^q T^eiT i?f i?»5-» 2- W^T ^T^ gxiff} ^j 32 qEf T(T(iT ^t i^I BTd q-tjt^ ps ^ftr ^r^ f^ft, Tiq^T ^•0-. T^^ i- ^-9 ^^re^r 'C^TTT TuipiT^-^, T^oT ^^•^* 2- rt^ aWT^ yT^m^qr gafq.^ pfq»^< 3- §^ci^mm TtmrT ¥l^l^re qt^ j^i syhTTei / ——-. ^fel eiTei ^Tg Ttrm- ^ TT^ t^i ^T-g ^pm ^ w ?rrg , j^^ ^^ ar^ ^t' sr^ ^fir.j. !T!^ ^^3P^^_^U 19^-^ ?To?r ^ITTgf^ 3?T8^TO| 3ltEtT^^,l985 /\ .^ 1 ^f • 53 13 3 s&. \y^ % '^: ^?^..^^ ^•SS ^. ^m ^s.1 ^. J^ • < -t^ fay <»• B- M 1 w '^ 1 J£| ^) iA.i' ^ ^' ^' ^) ^ ? ^ ^n -^..^ ^ ^ ^ i) ^ Nl ^ '' hJ <!° ^) ^p t ^l ^ ^ ^'"l Ai ^ ^) ^i. ^ >^/ ^. !U Sl)^'! ^y[ l'^4' HC-22 ^TT^T^T fcrlich ^^ $^^ich ^i%^ ^-sr •^Fncfi. "^N^. r6«'iwy 3'nip^r 'CRT^? ^,.te.i.-..'>.^).0^ „ WHC'IT^HIch '^R^ST' 3^T ^<iT^R'^FTf^T SB : Hon'ble Shri Manindra Mohal 09-03-2010 Shri Sanjeev Verma, counsel| Shri An/ind Dubey, Panel tav^ With the consent of learnedl hearcf finally. By this petition, the petitic|ners appointment of respondent No.4 01) perusal ofthe impugned order of ap{ shows that respondent No.4 was a[j upto31stofJuly, 2000. The petitioners have challerlged twin grounds. Learned counsel for tl| and advantage has been given to seiect list (Annexure A-22) which marks of interview awarded to pet petitioners next urged that the petitic they are entitled to preferential treatr|ient Learned State counsel subr petition with regard to correction laoking in materia! and particular members of the setection/interview their personal capaoity. Further conl demonstrate that there was any <+l^d4lv1 'HW^f ^^S <f^«i< ^? ^Tf^FT'sn^r Shnvastava, J» for the petitioners. /er for the State. counsei for the parties, the petition is have chaflenged selection and the post of Welder in I.T.I., Durg. A >ointment 03-11-1999 (Annexure A-23) pointed on contraot basis for a period selection of respondent No.4 on |ie petitionere submitted that undue fair (espondent No.4 as reflected from the thows that there is overwriting in the Itioner No.2. Learned counsef for the <ners were C.Tt. Trained and therefore ^its that the allegations made in the i|i the list are vague, unspecjfio and detaits. It was also submitted that c|ommittee have not been impleaded in t^ntion is that petitioners have failed to jprovisions with regard to grant of i'-ftA '^f^ i$atdtfeEsaSife.ffl@uaii \] 37I^T'^T f^TW^n^i ^HNr^lt^ Tumanel '3~^r ^rFTT^R, ^Tfl<-i^<o, i®i<ni^^< 3^T 'CRT^ _\^..1.^.^.:1^6^~ \^ ^I^Cir 9b*<lcb 'N^ST' ^TT^T'^ITSJTTrf^T ^ preferential treatment in the matti training. 1 have considered riva! subr|ijssion made by learned counsel for the part}'es and perused the record. In so far as allegations that respondent No.4, interpolation has are vague and lacking in materia) been stated in the petition is that fist. No specific pleadings have be^ awarded different marks and whii any interpolation in the origina! recj members of selection/intemew cc be gone into. It has not been attet iist. As such, altegations of mal^l contention of learned counsel for entitled to preferential treatme| unsupported by any provision ap[j the matter of such preferential tres|t The petitioners have also n|s contract appointment of respondeif Consequently, 1 do not find| accordingly dismissed. c^l^fd<i1t1 tTTR^Tf ^ fec2t iPsi^K '^^Tf^m'sn^r ofselection those who received C. T.1. in order to extend undue advantage to been made, 1 find that the allegations and particuiar details and all that has fiterpolation has been made in the select ^n made that intervj'ew committee initially preparing the selection list, there was ^ords. In the absence of impleadment of [mmittee, allegatlons of malafide cannot ?ed as to who interpotated the selection fide are bereft of any merit. The other the petitioners Is that petitioners were it, rests only on a bald statement licable during the course of selection in tment. ^t come out with any submission that the No-4 is still continuing tili date. any merit in this petition and the same is Sd/- Manindra Mohan Shrivastava Jude f-ff^ -^fe^l