Case ID: ny_291/html/0507-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

The People of the State of New York ex rel. Chemical Bank & Trust Co., as Trustee, etc., Appellant and Respondent, against William S. Miller et al., Constituting the Tax Commission of the City of New York, Respondents and Appellants.
    Argued May 17, 1943;
    decided July 20, 1943.
    
      
      Abraham N. Getter and Irving Sonnenschein for appellant and respondent.
    ■ Robert H. Schaffer, Acting Corporation Counsel (Arthur H. Goldberg, Arthur A. Segall and Edmund B. Hennefeld of counsel), for respondents and appellants.
   Order affirmed, without costs to either party; no opinion.

Concur: Lehman, Ch. J., Loughran, Rippey, Lewis, Conway and Desmond, JJ. Taking no part: Thacher, J. 
      
       In the above ease, and also in three other companion eases argued on the same day, namely, People ex rel. Bryant Park Building, Inc., v. Miller, 291 N. Y. 528; People ex rel. Prudential Insurance Co. v. Lilly, 291 N. Y. 600, and People ex rel. MacCracken v. Miller, 291 N. Y. 55, the city contended that “the Appellate Division may not substitute its finding of value for the finding of the trial Justice unless the latter finding is clearly contrary to the weight of the credible evidence,” citing Matter of City of New York (Newtown Creek), 284 N. Y. 493. Lehman, Ch. J., in his opinion in the MacCracken case, rejected such contention, saying: “We find no authority in the cited case or in other cases decided by this court for any differentiation in the powers of the Appellate Division to review and set aside findings of value by the Special Term in a certiorari proceeding and its powers to reverse findings of fact made by Special Term in any other special proceedings or actions.” (291 N. Y. 55, 60.) — [Rep.