Case ID: njl_132/html/0153-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "Bodine, J.", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

CITY OF GARFIELD, A MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, PROSECUTOR-APPELLANT, v. STATE BOARD OF TAX APPEALS AND FORSTMANN WOOLEN CO., RESPONDENTS-APPELLEES.
    Argued May 18, 1944
    Decided September 14, 1944.
    For the prosecutor-appellant, Frank P. McCarthy.
    
    For Forstmann Woolen Co., A. Harry Moore.
    
   The opinion of the court was delivered by

Bodine, J.

The case involves an assessment for taxes upon real and personal property of the Forstmann Woolen Company situate in the City of Garfield. The company maintained plants in three other municipalities in Bergen County. The presumption is in favor of. the findings of the State Board and such findings will not be disturbed in the Supreme Court unless it appears that the Board was in error. Tennant v. Jersey City, 122 N. J. L. 174; affirmed, 123 Id. 200; Gannon v. State Board, 123 Id. 450.

The Supreme Court, in an exhaustive opinion reported in 131 N. J. L. 364, reviewed the evidence and found the value of both the real and personal property to be in accordance with the findings of the State Board. The proofs offered by the company before the State Board and by deposition on certiorari sustained such conclusion. The findings of fact by the Supreme Court, when supported by the evidence, are conclusive in this court. Lehigh & Wilkes Barre Coal Co. v. Borough of Junction, &c., 75 Id. 922.

It is argued that the Supreme Court did not consider, in determining the value of personal property, certain intangibles. There is no proof that the intangibles had a situs in the City of Garfield. Because some part of them was not assessed elsewhere is no reason they should be assessed in the City of Garfield in the absence of evidence that they had a situs there.

The other arguments have been considered but are without merit.

The judgment under review is affirmed, but without costs.

For affirmance — The Chancellor, Chibe Justice, Parker, Bodine, Hbher, Perskib, Colie, Dear, Wells, Rae' eerty, Hague, Thompson, Dill, JJ. 13.

For reversal — None.