Case ID: tuck-surr_1/html/0244-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "The Surrogate.", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

The accounting in the Estate of George Colon.
    A person not having a demand against the estate of a deceased person, cannot have an order for a. compulsory accounting against.an executor,'' 'V A general.guardian -claiming against his "late ward, who has arrived at age, must settle accounts before the Surrogate, and .cannot sue in' the Supreme Court for the balance due him....... .
    J. Rid gw ay,/or Petitioner., •
   The Surrogate.

.The late .general guardian of the Colon infant, sited-his late . ward (now arrived at age) in the Supreme Court for advances claimed to have been ■madé beyond receipts.-' At the Bichmond-County Circuit, Mr.. Justice Gilbert dismissed the complaint, on the ground, as appears from his written opinion, that £< the plaintiff, having been general guardian of the infant during the time of the accruing of the alleged indebtedness, could not maintain an action at law against hls-late wardand the learned Judge said that the. only remedy would'be on the settlement of the accounts of the general guardian before the Surrogate who had appointed him. ■ The guardian now applies to me for an order against the executors of George Colon to render. an account of their proceedings, the late' .ward being a legatee under the will of George Colon.

As the petitioner applies on his own behalf, and not as general guardian, I must-refuse his application.0 He is not a person having a demand against this estate. (3 R. S., 5th ed., p. 178, § 57.) He claims against his ward. He must pursue the course pointed oút by the learned Circuit Judge, and go before the Surrogate of Biehinond .■county, by whom he was appointed general guardian. There he must settle his accounts . with his late ward-, and obtain a decree in his favor, if he can show’that he has expended beyond his receipts. The enforcement of that decree against the legacy, of his late ward will bé a matter for consideration when he has obtained it.