Case ID: sw_287/html/0050-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "HARVEY, P. J. CURETOÑ, C. J.", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

FIRST STATE BANK OF O’DONNELL et al. v. FIDELITY UNION FIRE INS. CO.
    (No. 854-4583.)
    (Commission of Appeals of Texas, Section A.
    Oct. 14, 1926.)
    1. Automobiles <&wkey;>!9 — Failure of purchaser of secondhand automobiles to receive collector’s receipt for license fee or to filé bills of sale did not render sale void (Vernon’s Ann. Pen. Code Supp. 1922, arts. 1617%e, ^6l7%1).
    
    Failure of purchaser of secondhand automobiles to demand and receive tax collector’s receipt for license fees on automobiles, as prescribed by Vernon’s Ann. Pen. Code Supp. 1922, art. 1617%e, or to file bills of sale covering automobiles required by article 1617%f, did not render sale void.
    2. Insurance «&wkey;H5(6) — Recovery on fire policy issued purchaser of secondhand automobiles is not defeated by his failure to receive collector’s receipt for license fee or to file bills of sale (Vernon’s Ann. Pen. Code Supp. 1922, arts. I6l7%e, I6l73/4f).
    That requirements of Vernon’s Ann. Pen. Code Supp. 1922, arts. 1617%e, 1617%f, providing for collector’s receipt for license fee and filing of bills of sale, were not observed in sale of secondhand automobiles, does not defeat recovery by purchaser on fire policy issued to him.
    Certified Questions from Court of Civil Appeals of Seventh Supreme Judicial District.
    Suit by the First State Bank of O’Donnell and others against the Fidelity Union Fire Insurance Company. On certified questions by the Court of Civil Appeals.
    Questions answered.
    Lockhart & Garrard, of Lubbock, for plaintiffs.
    Collins & Houston, of Dallas, for defendant.
   HARVEY, P. J.

The Court of Civil Appeals for the Seventh District has submitted certain certified questions, which are not necessary to be set out, but the substance and nature of which is disclosed by the answers which we make thereto.

The O’Donnell Motor Company, a. corporation, whose domicile is in Lynn county, Tex., bought 25 secondhand automobiles in said county, without demanding or receiving the tax collector’s receipt for the license fee issued for such automobiles for the year that they were so bought. No bill of sale for any of the automobiles and no transfer of license fee receipt was filed with the tax collector. The Fidelity Union Fire Insurance Company issued to the said motor company an insurance policy insuring the motor company against loss of said automobiles by fire. • The automobiles were subsequently destroyed by fire, while in the possession of the motor company, and this suit was brought on said policy by the First. State Bank of O’Donnell, to whom the policy had been assigned by the motor company after the fire occurred. The Court of Civil Appeals for the Seventh District, in which the case is pending on appeal, has here presented certified questions, which should be answered as follows:

The failure of the O’Donnell Motor Company to demand and receive the tax collector’s receipt for the license fee issued for the secondhand automobiles for the year that they were bought, as prescribed by article 1617%e of Vernon’s Ann. Pen. Code Supp. 1922, or to file with .the tax collector bills of sale covering the sale of the automobiles to the motor company, in accordance with the provisions of article 1617%f, Vernon’s Ann. Pen. Code Supp. 1922, did not operate to render void the sale of said automobiles to the O’Donnell Motor Company. The sale, notwithstanding the requirements of said statutes were not fulfilled, had effect to invest the O’Donnell Motor Company with ownership of said automobiles.

The fact that the requirements of said statutes were not observed in the sale of the automobiles to said motor company will not defeat a recovery on the insurance policy sued on. Hennessy v. Automobile Owner’s Ass’n (Tex. Com. App.) 282 S. W. 791.

CURETOÑ, C. J.

The opinion of the Commission of Appeals answering the certified questions is adopted and ordered certified to the Court of Civil Appeals. 
      tííu^For Otilar cases see same topic and KEY-NUMBER in all Key-Numbered Digests and Indexes