Case ID: nys_52/html/1006-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "\n      CLEARWATER, J.", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

(24 Misc. Rep. 300.)
    STOCKTON v. KENNY.
    (Supreme Court, Special Term, Ulster County.
    July 20, 1898.)
    Action on Note—Frivolous Answer.
    In an action on a note against the maker, an answer denying knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief is not frivolous.
    Action by Sandford D. Stockton against Michael F. Kenny. Motion to-strike out defendant’s answer as frivolous denied.
    Arthur C. Connelly, for the motion.
    Michael F. Kenny, in pro. per.
   CLEARWATER, J.

The action is upon a note alleged to have been made by the defendant, a lawyer, to the order of the plaintiff. The answer denies any knowledge or information, sufficient to form a belief, as to the truth of any of the allegations contained in the complaint. The pleadings are verified. The plaintiff moves to strike out the answer as frivolous, and for judgment on the pleadings, claiming that, as the defendant is charged with making the note, he knows whether he made it or not, and a denial of any knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegation that he did make it is frivolous. The answer may be false, but it is not frivolous, within the construction given to that expression by the decisions under the Code. Shearman v. Central Mills, 1 Abb. Prac. 187, cited by the plaintiff, and the earlier cases to the same effect are now regarded as overruled. The modern and present rule is that a general or specific denial which raises a material issue cannot be stricken out when pleaded in a form permitted by the Code. The denial here is in the prescribed form, and that which is legally permissible cannot be regarded as frivolous. Bank v. Inman, 51 Hun, 97, 5 N. Y. Supp. 457, is a fair example of the later cases to which I refer, and was affirmed by the court of appeals in 115 N. Y. 650, 21 N. E. 1118.

The motion is denied, but without costs.