Case ID: or-app_51/html/0203-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "\n      PER CURIAM", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

Argued and submitted December 9, 1980,
    affirmed March 9, 1981
    DEAL, Appellant, v. EDWARDS et al, Respondents.
    
    (No. 112400, CA 17433)
    624 P2d 1099
    Kathryn A. Logan, Albany, argued the cause for appellant. On the briefs was Clayton C. Patrick, Salem.
    Paul M. Ferder, Salem, argued the cause for respondent Edwards. With him on the brief was Ferder, Ogdahl & Souther, Salem.
    Before Richardson, Presiding Judge, and Thornton and Buttler, Judges.
    PER CURIAM
   PER CURIAM

Plaintiff filed this action for the sole purpose of foreclosing a claimed construction lien. Defendants counterclaimed, asserting a right to damages caused by plaintiff’s unworkmanlike construction resulting in the loss of value of the building on which the work was done. Plaintiff’s only response was that he had corrected all deficiencies in the work prior to filing the complaint.

The trial court held that plaintiff’s lien was invalid and entered judgment for defendants for attorney fees in defending the lien claim. We affirm. The lien claim exceeded by not less than 9 percent the amount plaintiff could justly claim to be due, and the lien claim included nonlienable items which cannot be segregated from those which are lienable without extrinsic evidence. Hays v. Pigg, 267 Or 143, 148, 515 P2d 924 (1973); see J. W Copeland Yards v. Phillips, 275 Or 193, 550 P2d 438 (1976).

Plaintiff concedes that if his lien is invalid, he is entitled to nothing on his complaint. At trial, after the court determined plaintiff’s lien to be invalid, it was agreed that defendants’ counterclaim would be tried as an action at law, without a jury. There is sufficient evidence, ignoring the testimony admitted over defendants’ objection, to support the trial court’s finding that defendants were damaged in the sum of $20,800.18.

Affirmed.