Case ID: f-supp_696/html/0442-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "LIMBAUGH, District Judge.", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

Craton LIDDELL, et al., Plaintiffs, v. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF the CITY OF ST. LOUIS, et al., Defendants.
    No. 72-100C(5).
    United States District Court, E.D. Missouri, E.D.
    Aug. 5, 1988.
    William P. Russell, Joseph McDuffie, St. Louis, Mo., for Liddell plaintiffs.
    Wayne C. Harvey, St. Louis, Mo., Michael A. Middleton, Columbia, Mo., William Taylor, Washington, D.C., for Caldwell/NAACP plaintiffs.
    Craig M. Crenshaw, Jr., Jeremiah Glass-man, U.S. Dept, of Justice, Washington, D.C., for U.S.
    Charles Werner, St. Louis, Mo., for Missouri NEA.
    Andrew J. Minardi, Joseph D. Ferry, St. Louis County Gov. Center, St. Louis, Mo., for St. Louis County defendants.
    Darold E. Crotzer, Jr., St. Louis, Mo., for Bayless, Jennings, Normandy & Wellston School Dist.
    George J. Bude, St. Louis, Mo., for Brentwood, Clayton & Hancock Place School Dist.
    Richard Ulrich, James Sanders, St. Louis, Mo., for Maplewood-Richmond Heights School Dist.
    Edward J. Murphy, Jr., Garry Seltzer, St. Louis, Mo., for Riverview Gardens School Dist.
    Kenneth C. Brostron, Lashly, Baer & Hamel, St. Louis, Mo., for City Bd. defendants.
    James J. Wilson, St. Louis City Counsel- or, St. Louis, Mo., for City of St. Louis.
    Charles R. Oldham, St. Louis, Mo., for Teachers Local Union 420.
    Joseph Niemann, Eric Schmitz and Jordan Cherrick, Armstrong, Teasdale, Kramer, Vaughan & Schlafly, St. Louis, Mo., for St. Louis County Special School Dist.
    Bertram W. Tremayne, Jr., St. Louis, Mo., for Kirkwood and University City School Districts.
    Robert P. Baine, Jr., St. Louis, Mo., for Hazelwood School Dist.
    John Gianoulakis, Mark Bremer, St. Louis, Mo., for Mehlville, Pattonville and Ritenour School Districts.
    Douglas A. Copeland, Robert W. Copeland, St. Louis, Mo., for Rockwood and Webster Groves School Districts.
    Michael J. Fields, Bart A. Matanic, Asst. Missouri Atty. Generals, Jefferson City, Mo., for State of Mo. defendants.
    Anthony J. Sestric, St. Louis, Mo., for St. Louis Collector of Revenue.
    Henry D. Menghini, Robert J. Krehbiel, Evans & Dixon, St. Louis, Mo., for Affton & Lindbergh School Districts.
    Frank Susman, St. Louis, Mo., for Ferguson-Florissant School Districts.
    Robert G. McClintock, St. Louis, Mo., for Ladue School Dist.
    Donald J. Stohr, James Erwin and R.J. Robertson, St. Louis, Mo., for Parkway School Dist.
    Kenneth V. Byrne, Schlueter & Byrne, St. Louis, Mo., for Valley Park School Dist.
    Shulamith Simon, St. Louis, Mo., for court-appointed amicus curiae.
   ORDER

LIMBAUGH, District Judge.

This matter is before the Court on Rock-wood School District’s Submission for Consent Order for Entry, L(2026)88. The State has filed a response, L(2051)88. The City Board has filed a reply to the State’s Response, L(2085)88.

Rockwood requests a two-year extension to meet its Plan Ratio. This extension has been agreed to by Rockwood, both plaintiffs and the City Board. The State objects on the same grounds as it did in objecting to Mehlville’s extension request to meet its Plan Ratio. See L(1870)88 and L(1942)88.

Pursuant to Court Order L(1969)88, the Court will allow entry of Rockwood’s Consent Order, L(2026)88.

Accordingly,

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Rock-wood’s Submission for-Consent Order for Entry, L(2026)88 be and is GRANTED. The Consent Order, as attached to L(2026)88 is ENTERED as this Court’s Order.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the State’s request for a hearing be and is DENIED. In agreeing to the extension, the signatories to the Settlement Agreement have investigated Rockwood’s situation and believe that Rockwood is diligently working towards reaching its Plan Ratio. A hearing would only serve as a forum for the State to vent unsubstantiated accusations of delay tactics. If the plaintiffs and the City Board have agreed to assist Rock-wood, then this Court will not interfere.

CONSENT ORDER

The undersigned signatories to the Settlement Agreement in the above case hereby agree, subject to Court approval, that the Rockwood School District shall have an additional two years through and including the 1989-90 school year to meet its plan ratio of 15.95%. The Rockwood School District will be entitled to a final judgment at any time that it complies with Section XII. D. of the Settlement Agreement and shall be entitled to have a final judgment entered pursuant to said paragraph XII.D. If, and when, the Rockwood School District receives a final judgment with respect to its pupil desegregation obligations under the Settlement Plan, the school district will nevertheless be under a continuing obligation in accordance with the Settlement Plan, as approved, to cooperate in the recruitment, acceptance and promotion of transfers; to reach and maintain the plan goal (25%); to participate in the magnet program, consistent with the provisions of the Settlement Plan, as approved; to facilitate the transfer of white students enrolled in its district to the city of St. Louis district whose enrollment is greater than 50% black; and to facilitate the transfer of black students in its district pursuant to Section XI(F) of the Settlement Plan, as approved, in the event any school within its district reaches a ratio of more than 50% black. See Settlement Plan, Section XII(D), H(2217)83 at XII-1 and -3. See also Section XI(F), H(2217)83 at XI-1 and -2. The State of Missouri shall continue to be required to fund the interdistrict transfers pursuant to the terms of this Court’s orders and the terms of the Settlement Plan.

COPELAND, GARTNER, THOMPSON & JEEP

Douglas A. Copeland W.H. COPELAND, # 13752 DOUGLAS A. COPELAND, # 30851 Attorneys for Rockwood School District LASHLY, BAER & HAMEL A professional Corporation

Kenneth C. Brostron KENNETH C. BROSTRON Attorneys for Board of Education of the City of St. Louis

Michael Middleton MICHAEL MIDDLETON Attorneys for Cal well and NAACP Plaintiffs

William P. Russell WILLIAM P. RUSSELL Attorney for Liddell Plaintiffs

SO ORDERED.