Case ID: so2d_710/html/0260-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "\n      FITZSIMMONS, Judge. WHIPPLE, Judge,", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

Patty Carr and John R. CARR Individually and as Administrator of the Estate of the Minor Child James Carr and Seley Williams and Raymond Williams, Individually and on Behalf of the Minor Child Mandy Williams v. HOUMA REDI-MIX CONCRETE CO., INC.
    96 CA 2462.
    Court of Appeal of Louisiana, First Circuit.
    Nov. 10, 1997.
    Wendell Gauthier, Metairie, Stephen M. Irving, Baton Rouge, Julie B. Beiser, Bruce C. Dean, Metairie, for Plaintiffs-Appellees Patty Carr, et al.
    Paul J. McMahon, Lafayette, for Defendant-Appellant Houma-Redi Mix Concrete Co., Inc.
    Alexander M. Crighton, Houma, Gary M. Zwain, Metairie, for Third Party Defendant Terrebonne Parish School Board.
    Philip A. Spence, Houma, for Third Party Defendant Terrebonne Parish Consolidated Government.
    Before FOIL, WHIPPLE, FITZSIMMONS, and KUHN, JJ., and TYSON, J. Pro Tern.
    
      
      . The Honorable Ralph E. Tyson, Judge, 19th Judicial District Court, is serving as judge pro tempore by special designation of the Louisiana Supreme Court.
    
   FITZSIMMONS, Judge.

Plaintiffs, Patty and John Carr, individually, and on behalf of their minor child, James; and Seley and Raymond Williams, individually, and on behalf of their minor child, Mandy, filed suit for damages against Houma Redi-Mix Concrete Co. The plaintiffs also sought to represent all persons similarly situated through a class action. The trial court certified a class comprising the “students of East Houma Elementary School between September 8, 1994 through September 8, 1995....”

Defendant, Houma Redi-Mix Concrete Co., filed a supervisory writ with this court and an appeal. The writ, number 96 CW 1548, was referred to the regular docket. The appeal, number 96 CA 2462, was docketed. Plaintiffs filed a motion to dismiss the appeal.

MOTION FOR DISMISSAL

Plaintiffs argued that the interlocutory judgment on certification was not appealable because the judgment would not result in “irreparable harm” to defendant. Redi-Mix filed an opposition to the motion to dismiss.

After a review of the record, we find that Redi-Mix failed to make a showing of irreparable harm. The naked statement that Redi-Mix would suffer irreparable harm is not sufficient. See La. C.C.P. art. 2083; Cotton v. Gaylord Chemical Corp., 96-2426 (La.10/25/96); 680 So.2d 1187. The case cited by Redi-Mix, State ex rel Guste v. General Motors Corporation, 354 So.2d 770 (La.App. 4th Cir.), affirmed, 370 So.2d 477 (La.1978) (on rehearing), involved customers throughout Louisiana that had dealt with different General Motors dealerships. General Motors Corporation, 354 So.2d at 772-73. The fourth circuit noted that the cost of a proceeding is not generally a basis for a claim of irreparable harm. However, in the General Motors case, the cost of notification for a widely dispersed class, as well as the inability to assess damages would have created irreparable harm Uto both parties if the appeal was not accepted. General Motors Corporation, 354 So.2d at 774. Redi-Mix made no showing or argument that such costs or circumstances existed in this case.

Additionally, Redi-Mix will not be harmed by a delay in the review of the certification. This court, on January 28, 1997, ordered that a writ of certiorari issue, and stayed the proceedings below. For these reasons, we dismiss the appeal of Redi-Mix. The costs of the proceeding are assessed equally to defendant, Redi-Mix, and plaintiffs.

APPEAL DISMISSED.

FOIL, J., concurs in part and dissents in part for the reasons set forth by WHIPPLE, J.

WHIPPLE, J., dissents with reasons assigned.

WHIPPLE, Judge,

dissenting in part.

I disagree with the assessment of costs to plaintiffs. Plaintiffs are prevailing herein on their motion to dismiss the appeal; thus, there is no legal basis for imposing any costs against plaintiffs in this matter.