Case ID: so2d_224/html/0093-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "MILLER, Judge. HOOD, Judge", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

George J. BRIGNAC, Sr., Plaintiff-Appellee-Appellant, v. PAN AMERICAN PETROLEUM CORPORATION, Defendant-Appellant, Leonard S. Withrow, Thelma Stegall Withrow and Trinity Universal Insurance Company, Defendant-Appellees-Appellants, and Odell Vinson Oilfield Contractors, Inc. and Travelers Insurance Company, Defendant-Appellees-Appellants.
    No. 2717.
    Court of Appeal of Louisiana. Third Circuit.
    June 12, 1969.
    Dissenting Opinion June 24, 1969.
    Hall, Raggio, Farrar & Barnett, by R. W. Farrar, Jr., Lake Charles, for defendant-appellant, Pan American Petroleum Corp.
    Cormie & Morgan, by Nathan A. Cormie, Lake Charles, for plaintiff-appellee, Edna M. Brignac.
    Plauché & Plauché, by Allen L. Smith, Jr., Lake Charles, for defendant-appellee, Trinity Universal Ins. Co.
    Jerry Kirk, Lake Charles, for plaintiff-appellee-appellant George Brignac.
    Kaufman, Anderson, Leithead, Scott & Boudreau, by James A. Leithead, Lake Charles, for Leonard S. Withrow and Thelma S. Withrow, defendants-appellees-appel-lants.
    Hold & Woodley, by Donald E. Walter, Lake Charles, for Odell Vinson Oilfield Contractors, Inc., defendants-appellees-ap-pellants.
    
      Before TATE, HOOD and MILLER, JJ.
   MILLER, Judge.

For the reasons stated in the consolidated case of Brignac v. Pan American Petroleum Corporation, 224 So.2d 84, in which a separate decision is being rendered by us this date, the judgment appealed in the present case is affirmed.

Affirmed.

HOOD, Judge

(dissenting).

For the reasons which I assigned in my dissenting opinion in Brignac v. Pan American Petroleum Corporation et al., 224 So.2d 84, I respectfully dissent from the opinion rendered by the majority in the instant suit.