Case ID: ohio-st_61/html/0651-02.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "Minshall, J.", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

No. 5475.
    State ex rel. Attorney General v. St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Company of Minnesota. Same v. Home Insurance Company of New York. Same v. Royal Insurance Company of Liverpool, England. Same v. Liverpool and London and Globe Insurance Company of Liverpool, England. Same v. London and Lancashire Insurance Company of Liverpool, England. Same v. North British and Mercantile Insurance Company of London and Edinburg, Great Britain. Same v. Caledonian Insurance Company of Edinburg, Scotland. Same v. British America Assurance Company of Toronto, Canada. Same v. Western Assurance Company of Toronto, Canada. Same v. Manchester Fire Assurance Company of Manchester, England. Same v. Buffalo German Insurance Company of Buffalo, New York.
    
      No. 5476.
    No. 5489.
    No. 5490.
    
      No. 5491.
    No. 5492.
    No. 5493.
    No. 5494.
    No. 5495.
    No. 5515.
    
      No. 5519.
    (Decided December, 12, 1899.)
    Quo Warranto.
    
      F. S. Monnett, Attorney General; F. B. Kinlcead and Smith W. Bennett, for plaintiff.
    Harrison, Olds, Henderson <& Harrison; Paxton, Warrington <& Boutet and M. B. Patterson, for defendants.
    Causes dismissed on the ground that the evidence does not support the averments of the petitions.
   Minshall, J.

I am of the opinion that the' Court has no jurisdiction in the matter, the power to act in the premises being conferred by the statute on the Commissioner of Insuranc. B.ut the court having assumed jurisdiction, it has been erroneously exercised, as appears to me, on the ■facts disclosed by - the evidence. For the same reason, I dissent in each of the other cases argued with this one.