Case ID: nj-eq_23/html/0180-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "The Chancellor.", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

Jacob L. Evans vs. William B. Evans and Samuel B. Evans. William B. Evans and Samuel B. Evans vs. Jacob L. Evans.
    Where the chief matter in controversy in two suits between the same' parties is the same, and if that was settled there would be no substantial difference between the parties, and no possible injury can result, an order-will be made that the testimony taken in either suit may be used in the other, and that the hearing of both shall come on together.
    On motion on behalf of William B. Evans and Samuel B. Evans, that the evidence taken in either one of these suits may be used on the hearing of the other, and that the two' suits may be heard together.
    
      Mr. F. Voorhees, for motion.
    
      Mr. Merritt, contra.
   The Chancellor.

The parties are all executors of the will of their father, Thomas Evans, deceased. The controversy in both suits arises out of the will of their testator, and the chief, if not the only matter in controversy in both suits, is the same. The dispute is, whether the testator had, in his lifetime, given to-his son Jacob, with whom he resided, .the stock and implements on his farm. If that question was settled, there would be no substantial difference between the parties.

Courts of equity have, in the exercise of their discretion, gone far in making orders respecting the conduct of suits situated like these, for the purpose of shortening litigation, and putting an end to expense. I see no possible injury that can result to either party from the order applied for. The parties being the same in both suits, each will have the full benefit of cross-examination of the witnesses of the other, and both will be fully heard upon every question in each suit at the final hearing.

An order that the testimony taken in either suit may be used in the other, and that the hearing of both should come on together, must be made.