Case ID: ala_231/html/0050-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "ANDERSON, Chief Justice.", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

163 So. 819
    ELLIOTT et al. v. McCRANEY.
    6 Div. 812.
    Supreme Court of Alabama.
    Oct. 17, 1935.
    Vassar L. Allen and W. Emmett Perry, both of Birmingham, for petitioners.
    B. F. Smith, of Birmingham, for respondent.
   ANDERSON, Chief Justice.

It appears that a judgment was rendered in the trial court against all three of the defendants, but upon motion the trial judge set aside the judgment as to one of the appellants, J. R. Oden. Therefore, there was no judgment against him when the appeal was taken and he was but a nominal appellant, and his joinder with the others in the assignments of error should be disregarded as redundant and immaterial and without prejudice to the consideration of the assignments on their merits. Gilley v. Denman, 185 Ala. 561, 64 So. 97. The case at bar falls within the influence of the Gilley Case, supra, and is not controlled by the cases cited and relied upon in the opinion of the Court of Appeals. The case of Gilley v. Denman, supra, was followed and approved in the case of Adams v. Bibby, 194 Ala. 652, 69 So. 588, notwithstanding the dissent of the writer.

The recent case of Sewell v. Cherokee County Bank, 230 Ala. 111, 159 So. 830, relied upon in the opinion of the Court of Appeals'upon rehearing, is unlike the present case. There, there was judgment against both appellants and which was in full force when the appeal was taken.

The Court of Appeals erred in no,t considering the assignments of error because of the joinder therein of J. R. Oden, a mere nominal appellant. The writ of certiorari is awarded, and the judgment of the Court of Appeals is reversed, and the cause is remanded to said court for further consideration in conformity with this opinion.

Writ awarded, and reversed and remanded. ‘

All the justices concur.