Case ID: us_154/html/0536-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "Mr. Justice Grier", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

RICHARDSON v. LAWRENCE COUNTY.
    certificate of division in opinion from the circuit court OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA.
    No. 100.
    Submitted January 12, 1864.
    Decided January 25, 1864.
    
      Woods v. Lawrence County, 1 Black, 386, affirmed and applied to this case.
    The case is stated in the opinion.
   Mr. Justice Grier

delivered the opinion of the court.

The certificate of division of opinion by the judges of the Circuit Court in this case is liable to the objection that one of the points submits the whole ease. The first two present, in fact, but a single proposition, arising on j;he speeiaPverdict.

The> law authorizing the issue of the ’bonds by the county, required that the railroad company should not sell them at less than par value. The verdict finds that they were sold by the railroad company for sixty-four cents in the dollar, and'submits to the court whether the judgment should be for the interest at the par value of the bonds, or for only sixty-four per cent. On this point the court was divided, and the question is properly presented by the certificate of division.

Since this case was certified, that of Woods v. Lawrence County, 1 Black, 386, was argued at length by learned counsel and carefully considered by this court. The report of that case shows thát all the questions that could arise in this case were decided in that. It was there decided that the right of the holder of these bonds and coupons to - recover their par value is not affected by the fact that the railroad company to whom they were given paid them out to contractors for sixty-four cents in the dollar.

Mr. J. Knox for plaintiff.

Mr. R. B. McCombe and Mr. Lewis Taylor for defendant.

The clerk will therefore certify to the Circuit Court that the motion of plaintiff “ to enter a verdict and judgment in his behalf for the sum of $864 with interest, from November 14, 1861,” ought to be granted.

This will dispose of the whole case. So answered.