Case ID: la-ann_27/html/0563-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "Morgan, J. Ludeling, C. J.,", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

No. 575.
    Robertine Green v. The Baptist Church of Shreveport.
    In this petitory action plaintiff claims that her posthumous birth destroyed her father’s will; that the executor became thereby incapable to act; and that the sale made by him, as such, conveyed no title to the purchaser, who subsequently transferred it to the defendant.
    
      Prima, facie,, the title acquired by the first purchaser was a good one. The property had been sold under an order of a eompetént court, made at the instance of one apparently authorized to apply for it. Purchasers are not bound, at their peril, to inquire, when property is advertised for sale by an executor,, whether any thing has occurred, outside of court, to destroy the will under which he is acting.
    Besides, the succession of plaintiff’s father being insolvent, and tbe property which she now-claims having "been applied, as was proper, to the payment of his debts, it is not seen how she has been injured by the sale of which she complains.
    APPEAL from the Tenth Judicial District Court, parish of Caddo. Looney, J.
    
      Fuqua, GalWham and Seay, for plaintiff and appellant. Nutt & Leonard, for defendant and appellee.
   Morgan, J.

Plaintiff’s father, Robert Green, died in October, 1854. He constituted his wife Lizzie H. Green, his universal legatee, and appointed John J. Green his testamentary executor, who qualified as such. The property now in contest formed part of his succession.

In February, 1855, the plaintiff was born. She is the issue of the marriage of Robert Green and Lizzie H. Green. At the time of her father’s death she was “ en ventre sa mere.'1'1

In June, 1856, the lots in question were sold. The sale was provoked by the executor. It was made under an order of court, and by auction.

Plaintiff claims that her birth destroyed her father’s will; that the executor bécarne thereby without power to act, and that the sale made by him conveyed no title.

It is in evidence that Robert Green died insolvent. It is admitted that the proceeds of the property went toward the payment of his debts.

Frima facie, the title acquired by the first purchaser was a good one. The property had been sold under an order of a competent court, made at the instance of one apparently authorized to apply for it. The records of the country showed that the executor was exercising the functions of his office at the time he asked for the order of sale. Purchasers are not bound, at their peril, to inquire, when property is advertised for sale by an executor, whether any thing has occurred outside of court; to destroy the will under which he is acting.

Besides, her father’s succession being insolvent, and the property which she now claims having been applied, as was proper, to the payment of his debts, we do not see how she has been injured by the sale of which she complains.

The moral of her position is that the purchasers of her father’s property shall pay his debts, and the property itself be returned to her. To this we can not assent.

It is therefore ordered, adjudged and decreed that the judgment of the district court be affirmed.

Ludeling, C. J.,

dissenting. This is a petitory action by the heir of Robert Green. The defense is'that the defendant holds the property by mesne conveyances from the purchaser at a probate sale of the succession of Robert Green.

The sale was provoked and made by one who acted as the executor of the last will of Robert Green. At the time of the sale, the will, which appointed him executor, had been destroyed by the birth of a legitimate child of the testator subsequent to its date. “The testament falls by the birth of legitimate children of the testator posterior to its date,” C. C. 1705. After the birth of the child there was no testament, and consequently no executor of Robert Green, deceased. And all the acts of said pretended executor were absolutely null. 2 R. 258 ; 3 An. 271; 8 An. 378; 6 How. 550.

Suppose a mere intermeddler, representing himself to be executor, had obtained an order to sell succession property and had made the sale ; could it be seriously pretended that such as ale could be held to be valid? I imagine not.

It is contended, however, that John J. Green was acting under an appointment recognized by a court under an order of sale granted by a court of competent jurisdiction, and that therefore the sale was valid. The will having ceased to have validity after the birth of the child, ipso faeto, all who dealt with him, were bound to inquire, if he filled the office legally. Otherwise the provisions of article 1705 is meaningless. J. J. Green had no right to ask for the order, and the court erred in making it, and it was without power or jurisdiction to authorize him, a stranger to the estate, to make the sale. The order itself was a nullity. “ Quod, nullum est, nullum, effeetumproduciV’

The rule that a purchaser at a judicial sale is protected by the judgment of a court, has this extent only, that the innocent purchaser is protected from irregularities which precede the judgment. 23 An. 446. It has no application to this case, for the plaintiff does not complain of mere want of formalities preceding the order of sale; but of the order itself as null and void. The complaint is that succession property, the heir to which was a minor, was sold under an order granted when both the succession and the minor were unrepresented, and at the instance of a total stranger to the succession. There is no exception in this case that the minor has not offered to return the price of the property which may have gone to pay the debts of the succession; and therefore I think there should be judgment in her favor for the land, and a writ of possession to issue only, when she reimbursed to defendant the portion of the price which went to pay the debts of the succession. For the foregoing reasons I dissent.

Rehearing refused.