Case ID: iowa_62/html/0510-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "Beck, J.", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

Nagel v. Guittar, Sheriff.
    E^ptions: taken too late to be considehed. Exceptions to a decision must be taken at the time it is made, (Code, § 2381,) except in thecase.of instructions to the jury, which maybe excepted to within three days after the verdict. Code, § 2789. Exceptions not taken in time will not be considered on appeal.
    
      Appeal from Pottawattamie Circuit Court.
    
    Thursday, December 13.
    AotioN of replevin. The cause was tried without a jury, and judgment rendered for defendant. Plaintiff appeals.
    
      M. B. Darnell and Flielcinger Bros., for appellant.
    
      Fremont Benjamin, for appellee.
   Beck, J.

The only objection raised by the assignment of plaintiff’s counsel is based upon the ground that the judgment of the circuit court is in conflict with the evidence.

An amended abstract filed by defendant, which is not denied by plaintiff, shows that no exceptions were taken to the judgment at the time it was rendered, nor until twenty-four days thereafter. Exceptions to a decision must be taken at the time it is made, (Code, § 2831,) except in the case of instructions to the jury, which may be excepted to within three days after the verdict. Code, § 2789. Neither does it appear that a motion for a new trial was made. We cannot disregard this statute, and review a decision not excepted to at the time therein required. See Joliet Iron & Steel Co. v. The C., C. & W. R'y Co., 50 Iowa, 455. The decision of the circuit court must be

Affirmed.