Case ID: p3d_426/html/0063-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

JUDICIAL ETHICS OPINION 2018-2
    No. 2018-2
    Judicial Ethics Advisory Panel of Oklahoma.
    JUNE 14, 2018
    ¶1 1. FACTS:
    A lawyer appearing before the judge is currently a member (not an officer) of that judge's campaign committee, has given a donation to the committee consistent with other attorneys and citizens in the area ($1,000) and has publicly endorsed the candidate. The judge did not know the amounts given by anyone until the issue arose when he was advised of the amount given by the attorney.
    ¶2 2. Question #1: What is the judge's ethical requirement for recusal and disclosure?
   ¶3 3. We Answer As to Disclosure: YES

¶4 4. Discussion: As was thoroughly discussed in Judicial Ethics Opinion 2001-5, 2001 OK JUD ETH 5, 73 P.3d 270, "disclosure is still appropriate and an attorney should not be forced to seek out such information [about individual campaign contribution]."

¶5 5. We Answer As to Recusal: NO

¶6 6. Discussion: Canon 1 "A judge shall uphold and promote the independence, integrity, and impartiality of the judiciary, and shall avoid impropriety and the appearance of impropriety."

¶7 7. Rule 2.11(A)(4) provides "Contributions within the limits allowed by the Oklahoma Ethics Commission will not normally require disqualification unless other factors are present."

¶8 118. Canon 2 "A Judge Shall Perform the Duties of Judicial Office Impartially, Competently, and Diligently. Effective administration of justice requires that a judge hear all cases assigned to them unless recusal is required for some reason. We find that the circumstances here do not require recusal.

/s/The Honorable April Sellers White, Retired Judicial Ethics Advisory Panel member

The Honorable April Sellers White, Retired Judicial Ethics Advisory Panel member

/s/The Honorable Edward Cunningham, Retired Judicial Ethics Advisory Panel Chair

The Honorable Edward Cunningham, Retired Judicial Ethics Advisory Panel Chair

/s/The Honorable William Heatherington, Retired Judicial Ethics Advisory Panel member

The Honorable William Heatherington, Retired Judicial Ethics Advisory Panel member

/s/The Honorable Allen McCall, Retired Judicial Ethics Advisory Panel member

The Honorable Allen McCall, Retired Judicial Ethics Advisory Panel member

/s/The Honorable Thomas Landrith, Retired Judicial Ethics Advisory Panel member

The Honorable Thomas Landrith, Retired Judicial Ethics Advisory Panel member