Case ID: silv-sup_5/html/0271-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "Pratt, J.", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

Cornelius D. Guyon et al., Appellants, v. John Rooney, Respondent.
    
      Supreme Court, Second Department, General Term,
    
    
      December 9, 1889.
    1. Justice’s court. Replevin.—An. action to recover a chattel may be maintained in justice’s court, though no return has been made to the requisition.
    2. Appeal. Return.—The papers, on appeal from an inferior court to the general term, must be certified as required by section 1353 of the Code, otherwise the appeal will not be determined.
    Appeal from judgment of the Richmond county court, reversing judgment of justice’s court and dismissing complaint.-
    Action to replevin a chattel. On the return day of the summons both parties appeared. Plaintiff filed a written complaint and defendant interposed an oral answer. The issues were tried by the justice, who rendered judgment for plaintiff.
    Defendant appealed to the county court and demanded a new trial. Upon such new trial the proceedings were dismissed on defendant’s motion on the ground that the constable had made no return to the requisition.
    For the opinion of the general term referred to in this opinion, see 25 N. Y. State Rep. 326.
    
      W. J. Powers, for appellants.
    
      William M. Muller, for respondent.
   Pratt, J.

This case came before us at the May general term, but the papers were not properly certified so that a decision could be properly rendered. We, however, expressed our views upon the merits of certain questions which must, if adhered to, determine this appeal.

We see no reason to change the views expressed at that general term, which lead to a reversal of the judgment and sending the case back for trial in the county court upon the merits under § 3068 of Code of Civil Procedure, as stated in the opinion referred to.

Judgment reversed on opinion written at May term.

Barnard, P. J., and Dykman, J., concur.