Case ID: liquor-tax-rep_2/html/0365-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "Van Etten, J.", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

County Court, Ulster County,
    July, 1900.
    Reported. 32 Misc. 303.
    Matter of the Petition of George W. Washburn, for an Order Revoking and Canceling Liquor Tax Certificate, No. 22,671, Issued to Pasquale Della Morte.
    Liquor Tax Law—Revocation—Stay on appeal 'not permissible.
    Where proceedings, taken to revoke a liquor tax certificate for the falsity of material statements contained in the application therefor, have resulted in an order of revocation and the same has been entered and served, the court has no power to grant a stay of proceedings pending an appeal from the order.
    Proceedings under the Liquor Tax Law, section 28.
    Motion by defendant for a stay upon an appeal.
    Charles f. Cantine, for petitioner.
    Brinnier & Searing, for defendant.
    William E. Schenck, for Ulster County Treasurer.
   Van Etten, J.

An order was made in the above-entitled proceeding revoking and canceling the liquor tax certificate issued to Pasquale Della Morte on the ground that the consents of property owners had not been obtained as required by section 17 of. the Liquor Tax Law.

It appeared upon the hearing that there were two houses occupied exclusively as dwellings within two hundred feet of the saloon where liquor was sold under said certificate, and that the consents of the owners of said dwellings had not been obtained. In the application for said certificate said defendant stated that there were no houses within two hundred feet of said saloon. This was false. The Liquor Tax Law (§28), provides that proceedings may be taken to revoke and cancel the certificate, among other things, “ if the consents required by section 17 are not properly filed as required by said section.” It further provides that if the evidence establishes such facts, an order shall be granted revoking and canceling the certificate, and said order shall also provide that the holder of said liquor tax certificate, or any other person having such certificate in his possession or under his control, shall forthwith surrender said certificate to the officer who issued the same, or his successor in office.” Also that all the rights of the holder of said certificate shall cease upon the filing and service of said order, and that the said certificate shall be immediately surrendered to the officer who issued the same.

This proceeding is of a summary nature, and is intended to immediately stop persons from selling liquor who have not the lawful right to do so.'

A stay of proceedings after entry and service of the order is not contemplated by said act.

It was held in Matter of Auerbach to Revoke and Cancel Liquor Tax Certificate Issued to Johannsen, 31 Misc. Rep. 46, that “ the order is self-executing, and upon its entry and due service the rights of the holder by virtue of the certificate ‘ shall cease.’ Therefore, a stay, operating only upon future proceedings, cannot affect the legal status of the party as already fixed, by law, and with or without a stay, his further acts under the certificate would be in violation of the penal provisions of the statute.”

The application for a stay is, therefore, denied.

Application denied.