Case ID: la_2/html/0459-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "\n      Martin, J.\n    ", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

CANIZO’S SYNDICS vs. CUADRA.
    
    APPEAL PROM THE COURT OP THE PARISH AND CITY OF NEW ORLEANS.
    The pawnee who has not taken written evidence hy an authentic or private instrument of the pawning, cannot avail himself of it against third persons.
    This suit was brought to recover from the defendant certain articles of plate and jewellery which had been deposited with him by the insolvent previous to his failure, and which formed part of the property surrendered to his creditors.
    The defendant admitted the receipt of the articles, but alleged they were pawned to him by the insolvent as security for a debt. It appeared from the evidence that the articles were not pawned, but delivered to the defendant for safekeeping. There was a verdict, and judgment for the plaintiffs, and the defendant appealed.
    
      Vinot for appellant.
    
      Cannon for appellee.
   Martin, J.

delivered the opinion of the court.

The plaintiff, syndic of his own creditors, claims part of the property surrendered, now in the defendant’s possession. The claim is resisted on the ground that they were, previous to the failure, received by the defendant, in pawn; and his being a creditor being proved, is a circumstance which, with his possession, affords a strong presumption that the' goods were given him as a security for his debt. The plea was disallowed, and the defendant appealed.

The pawnee who has not taken written evidence hy an authentic or private instrument of the pawning, cannot avail himself of it against third persons

Eastern District,

June 1831.

Under the Civil Code, 3125, the pawnee who has not taken written evidence (by an authentic or private instrument) of the pawning, cannot avail himself of it against third persons. This, in the present , case, is not pretended to have been done.

It is therefore ordered, adjudged, and decreed, that the judgment of the Parish Court be affirmed with costs.