Case ID: ky_213/html/0566-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "Judge Clay", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

Luther v. Taylor.
    (Decided March 16, 1926.)
    Appeal from Graves Circuit Court.
    HOLIFIELD, GARDNER & McDONALD for appellant.
    T. J. MURPHEY and J. E. WARREN for appellee.
   Opinion of the Court by

Judge Clay

Affirming.

J. W. Taylor brought this action against A. A. Luther to recover a small strip of land in Graves county. Luther denied plaintiff’s title, asserted title in himself and pleaded an agreed line, coupled with adverse possession. The jury found for plaintiff and defendant appeals.

Counsel for appellant have presented an able argument in support of the theory that the jury reached an erroneous conclusion. The various issues were submitted by appropriate instructions. On each of the issues the evidence was conflicting, and, even though the evidence may preponderate in favor of appellant, we are not prepared to say that the verdict is flagrantly against the evidence.

It is further contended that appellee’s attorney,,who is also a surveyor, was guilty of misconduct while on the witness stand. It is true that several objections were sustained to Murphey’s evidence, but as the evidence complained of did not always relate to the same facts it can not be said that the witness was guilty of a persistent effort to get before tbe jury matters that bad been excluded by tbe court.

We are not prepared to say that tbe description of tbe land recovered is so vague and indefinite as to render tbe judgment unenforceable.

Judgment affirmed.