Case ID: cma_8/html/0476-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "Robert E. Quinn, Chief Judge:", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

UNITED STATES, Appellee v ROBERT G. BAKER, Corporal, DONALD L. BARRETT, Corporal, DANIEL J. BRESNAHAN, Private First Class, U. S. Marine Corps, Appellants
    8 USCMA 476, 24 CMR 286
    No. 10,109
    Decided December 13, 1957
    
      Commander David Bolton, USN, was on the brief for Appellants, Accused.
    
      Lieutenant (jg) John V. L. Ellicott, USNR, and Commander Guilbert W. Martin, USN, were on the brief for Appellee, United States.
   Opinion of the Court

Robert E. Quinn, Chief Judge:

The accused were tried jointly for the alleged commission of two robberies, separated in time by about 10 minutes and in distance by about a half a mile. One of the major issues at the trial was the voluntariness of a pretrial statement by each accused. All statements were admitted in evidence by the law officer. Defense counsel requested an instruction to the effect that if the court-martial did not find beyond a reasonable doubt that the statements were voluntary, it must disregard them. Although trial counsel had no objection to the proposed instruction, the law officer did not give it. Instead, he gave substantially the same instruction we disapproved in United States v Jones, 7 USCMA 623, 23 CMR 87. The Government concedes error.

The decision of the board of review is reversed; the findings of guilty are set aside. A rehearing may be ordered.

Judges LatimeR and FERGUSON concur.