Case ID: ad2d_261/html/0928-02.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

Melody Smith et al., Respondents, v Carol R. Smith et al., Appellants. (Action No. 1.) Melody Smith et al., Respondents, v James J. White, Jr., Respondent. (Action No. 2.)
    [689 NYS2d 805]
   —Order unanimously affirmed with costs. Memorandum: Plaintiffs commenced an action seeking damages for personal injuries sustained by Melody Smith (plaintiff) in an automobile accident (action No. 1). Defendants therein moved to consolidate that action with a medical malpractice action subsequently commenced by plaintiffs against a physician who treated plaintiff for the injuries she sustained in the automobile accident (action No. 2). Supreme Court did not abuse its discretion in denying the motion (see, Dias v Berman, 188 AD2d 331). Where common questions of law or fact exist, consolidation should be granted unless the party opposing consolidation establishes prejudice to a substantial right (see, Zupich v Flushing Hosp. & Med. Ctr., 156 AD2d 677). Although the fact that actions are at different stages of discovery generally is insufficient to establish prejudice to a substantial right (see, Collazo v City of New York, 213 AD2d 270; Zimmerman v Mansell, 184 AD2d 1084, 1085), here plaintiffs demonstrated that, when the consolidation motion was made, discovery was complete, a note of issue was filed and the trial was scheduled in action No. 1, while action No. 2 was still in the pleading stage. Thus, in the circumstances of this case, plaintiffs have established prejudice to a substantial right (see, Dias v Berman, supra; Rennert Diana & Co. v Kin Chevrolet, 137 AD2d 589; Mulligan v Farmingdale Union Free School Dist. No. 22, 133 AD2d 617; see also, Gardner v City of New York, 102 AD2d 800, 801). (Appeal from Order of Supreme Court, Erie County, Sconiers, J.— Consolidation.) Present — Pine, J. P., Hayes, Pigott, Jr., Scudder and Balio, JJ.