Case ID: ny-sup-ct_25/html/0221-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "Learned, P. J. :", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION OF CHARLES E. PATTERSON, Receiver, etc., of the MERCHANTS AND MECHANICS’ BANK OF TROY.
    
      Section 48 of chap. 37 of 1875 — deposit by savings bank — what is entitled to priority as.
    
    A savings bank entered into an agreement with four other banka by which it agreed, subject to the provisions and limitations of the laws of the State of New York inspecting deposits in banks and trust companies, to deposit one-fourth of all moneys received by it with each of said banks, as therein provided ; each bank agreeing to pay interest on daily balances at the rate of four per cent per annum; and at the end of the three years, during which the contract was to run, to pay over to the savings bank all money belonging to it, and also to pay, at sight, any checks or drafts drawn, upon it. Each of the four banks also agreed not to receive, from any other person or corporation, deposits of any sum less than ¡¡51,000, and allow interest thereon.
    
      Held, that money paid by the savings bank to one of the said banks, in pursuance of the said agreement, was a deposit within the meaning of section 48 of chapter 37 of 1875, and entitled to the priority given thereby.
    Appeal from an order made at Special Term, directing the receiver of the Merchants and Mechanics’ Bank of Troy, an insolvent banking corporation, to pay over to the Troy Savings Bank the sum of $67,642.54, being the amount of a deposit made by the said savings bank with the Merchants and Mechanics’ Bank, and held by the latter at the time of the appointment of the receiver.
    
      ■ Ou December 31, 1877, the savings bank entered into an agreement with the Merchants and Mechanics’ Bank to deposit with it, subject to the provisions and limitations of the laws of the State of New York respecting deposits in banks and trust companies, one-fourth part of all moneys deposited with it during the next three yeai’s, the other three-fourths to be deposited in three other banks therein named. It being agreed that the deposits in the four banks should be kept as nearly equal as possible. The bank agreed to pay four per cent on the daily balances, and to pay over, at the expiration of the three years, all sums of money belonging to the savings bank. It also agreed to pay at sight all checks or drafts of the savings bank, and that it would not, during the existence of the agreement, receive on deposit or as a loan from any other person or corporation any sum less than $1,000, and pay or agree to allow interest thereon. The bank having failed the savings bank applied to have the amount it then had deposited with it paid to it, in preference to all other claims, as provided by section 48 of chapter 37 of 1875.
    
      Moses Warren, for the Receiver.
    
      Mselc Oowen, for The Troy Savings Bank.
    
      James Forsyth and Nathaniel O. Moah, for James Forsyth and other depositors.
   Learned, P. J. :

A deposit was originally a thing delivered to a person for gratuitous safe keeping; and it remained the property of the owner. The word, however, is now used to designate a certain kind of loan. For money, deposited in the ordinary way, becomes the property of the bank or banker ; and the deposit is a debt.

When we attempt to state what kind of loans are properly called deposits, we find that, to some extent, the original meaning of the word colors its present meaning. For there is an idea in the mind that money on deposit is lying in the bank, on hand, ready to meet the demand of the owner, and that it is kept there for his convenience.

While it is difficult to make an accurate definition of a deposit, which shall distinguish it from every other loan, yet there are many particulars by which it may be described. And generally we may say that it is a loan to a bank or banker ; that it is made for the convenience of the lender (or depositor), in his business ; that it is variable in amount from time to time ; that it is subject to be demanded at any time and in any amount; that it is evidenced only by entries on a pass-book, and on the books of the bank ; that it is paid out upon checks of the depositor, to be paid at once, on presentation, without notice.

A savings bank must necessarily keep a considerable amount of money on hand, to meet sudden calls and emergencies. The '■statute has indicated that ten per cent of its deposits is not an unreasonable amount. If that seems large, we must notice that, when the statute was passed, there was not in existence the great amount of United States securities which we now have, and in which investments can now bo made, convertible at once into cash. The Troy Savings Bank had very large deposits, and it Was a wise course, therefore, to divide up, among several banks, the money to be thus kept on hand. And, to prevent favoritism and jealousy among these banks, it was well to apportion this money equally and to arrange a regular mode of distribution. That was what was done in the present case. The agreements between the Troy Savings Bank on the one side, and the Merchants and Mechanics’ Bank, and the three other banks, on the other, simply provide for an equal distribution among the four hanks of the deposits to be made by the Troy Savings Bank. There was nothing illegal on the part of the Troy Savings Bank in its obtaining interest on these moneys. And if the four banks were severally to pay interest, it is plain that they might reasonably insist on a ratable division of these moneys among them.

Nor does it change the character of these moneys that the Merchants and Mechanics’ Bank agreed not to pay to others interest on small deposits ; that is, not to carry on a savings bank business. It was wise and proper that they should never pay such interest; and an agreement not to do, what good banking forbade, can do no harm.

The contract does not agree on any definite time, for which" the money is to remain on deposit. It is payable at any time on the checks of the Troy Savings Bank. The agreement that, at the end of the three years, the Merchants and Mechanics’ Bank would pay to the Troy Savings Bank any of the moneys then on hand is what the law would have implied without an agreement. It docs not postpone the liability of the Merchants and Mechanics’ Bank. The moneys are spoken of as deposits, and they have all the characteristics of deposits. They are the moneys needed for the business of the depositor; they are deposited, from time to time, as its business brings them in, and they are to be drawn out in like manner and upon checks as business requires; they are evidenced by entries on a pass-book and on the books of the Merchants and Mechanics’ Bank, and the arrangement is for tht convenience of the Troy Savings Bank in its business. The fact that interest is to be paid on them, however unwise on the part of the Merchants and Mechanics’ Bank, does not change their character or prevent them from being deposits in the ordinary meaning of that word, (Upton v. N. Y. and Erie Bk., 13 Hun, 269.) The transaction is wholly unlike that which was examined in the case of Rosenback v. Manuf. and Build. Bk. (69 N. Y., 358).

If these moneys were deposits, within the meaning of the statute, then the Troy Savings Bank is entitled to its preference. If it should be admitted that the amount thus kept on deposit at some time was more than ought, under the statute, to have remained uninvested, that would not affect the present question. The savings bank may, by such act, have forfeited its charter ; but that is a question for the State, and does not relieve the Merchants and Mechanics’ Bank from paying its debts ; nor its receiver from paying them in the order prescribed by law.

It is not disputed that the deposits of the Troy Savings Bank, at the time of the failure, were less than twenty-five per cent of the capital of the Merchants and Mechanics’ Bank. The whole amount, therefore, of these deposits is entitled to a preference. No question has been made here as to the rate of interest allowed on this balance of deposit, in the order appealed from. The order must be affirmed, with ten dollars costs and printing disbursements against the api^ellants.

Present — LearNEd, P. J., BoaudjiaN and Follett, JJ.

Order affirmed, with ten dollars costs and printing disbursements.