Case ID: f-cas_27/html/0798-02.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "THE COURT", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

Case No. 16,155.
    UNITED STATES v. RICHARDSON.
    [5 Cranch, C. C. 348.] 
    
    Circuit Court, District of Columbia.
    Nov. Term, 1837.
    Assault—What Constitutes.
    If a man raise a club over the head of a woman within striking distance, and threaten to strike her if she open her mouth, this is an assault in law. He has no right to impose such a condition.
    Indictment for an assault upon one Susan Shelton. The evidence was that the defendant [Allison Richardson] came into the house where Mrs. Shelton was sitting at a window. He was armed with a musket and a dub; and raising the dub over her head in an attitude for striking, and within striking distance, said to her that if she said a word (or if she opened her mouth) he Vould strike her; and this without any provocation on her part.
    Bradley & Hoban, for defendant,
    contended that this was not, in law, an assault; that there
    can be no assault without a present intent to strike; and his saying, “if she opened her mouth,” showed that he had not such a present intent, and they cited the old case, “If it were not the assizes, I would stab you.”
   But

THE COURT

(THRUSTON, Circuit Judge, absent) said that he had no right to restrain her from speaking; and his language showed an intent to strike upon her violation of a condition which he had no right to impose. Suppose a stranger comes to my house armed, and raises his club over my head, within striking distance, and threatens to beat me unless I will go out of and abandon my house, surely that would be an assault. So if a highwayman puts a pistol to my breast, and threatens to shoot me unless I give him my money, this would be evidence of an assault, and would be charged as such in the indictment.

Verdict, “Guilty.” Pined ten dollars.