Case ID: cal_70/html/0564-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "The Court.", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

[No. 11557.
    Department Two.
    August 31, 1886.]
    JAMES W. SHEALOR, Petitioner, v. SUPERIOR COURT OF AMADOR COUNTY, Respondent.
    Justice’s Court—Action for Possession of Personal Property—Allegation of Value — Jurisdiction. —Neither the Justice’s Court nor the Superior Court on appeal has jurisdiction of an action to recover the possession of specific personal property alleged to exceed three hundred dollars in value, although the complaint prays judgment for a less amount in case possession cannot he had.
    Application for a writ of review. The facts are stated in the opinion of the court.
    
      
      Eagon & Armstrong, for Petitioner.
    
      A. Heath, and Bust & Caminetti, for Respondent.
   The Court.

In this cause, the plaintiff brought his action in a Justice’s Court to recover various articles of personal property, the aggregate value of which, as averred in the complaint, amounted to $319. The prayer of the complaint was: “1. For the possession of said goods, or for $299 in case possession cannot be had; 2. For $150 damages for the detention thereof, and the costs of the action.”

The cause came on to be tried, when the defendant moved that the cause be dismissed on the ground that the demands of the plaintiff exceeded the jurisdiction of the court.

The Justice’s Court dismissed the action.

The plaintiff then took an appeal to the Superior Court above named on questions of law and fact.

The Superior Court, against the objection of defendant, proceeded to try the case; he did try it, and rendered a judgment for the plaintiff.

The value of the property having been averred in the complaint to be $319, for which possession was asked, neither the Justice’s Court nor the Superior Court on appeal had jurisdiction of the action.

The judgment of the Superior Court must be annulled and quashed.

So ordered.