Case ID: nys_106/html/0545-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "BISCHOFE, J.", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

(55 Misc. Rep. 402.)
    ÆTNA LIFE INS. CO. v. NORTH STAR MINES CO.
    (Supreme Court, Special Term, New York County.
    July, 1907.)
    Pleading—Answer—Demurrer.
    Where defendant, in a statement of the separate defense, intended to reiterate the allegations in previous paragraphs of his answer, but instead referred to them as paragraphs of “this amended complaint,” a demurrer to the answer will be sustained.
    [Ed. Note.—For cases in point, see Cent. Dig. vol. 39, Pleading, §§ 193, 408-421.]
    Action by the JEtna Life Insurance' Company against the North Star Mines Company. Demurrer to second counterclaim sustained.
    E. Sidney Berry, for plaintiff.
    Joseph H. Choate, Jr., for defendant.
   BISCHOFE, J.

Because of what is doubtless an error in the form of the counterclaim demurred to, I cannot determine the issue of law upon the merits of the pleading, as to substance, and the demurrer must be sustained. The action is for premiums upon policies of insurance against injury to employés of the defendant, and the counterclaim is based upon claims accruing to the employés and collectible from the plaintiff by the defendant as "trustee.”

There is no averment in the counterclaim that the parties had entered into any contractual relations, since the contract is not alleged otherwise than by reiteration of “each and every allegation contained in the first, fourth, and fifth paragraphs of this amended complaint.” Doubtless, the defendant intended to refer to the answer, not the complaint; but the issue of law must be determined upon the words employed. Resort to the complaint, which is not, indeed, an “amended complaint,” does not aid the counterclaim, because the paragraphs referred to do not set forth the contract, and, as the counterclaim stands, there is no statement of fact to support the plaintiff’s liability to the defendant either as “trustee” or otherwise. The demurrer is therefore sustained, with costs, with leave to defendant to amend upon payment of costs within 20 days.

Demurrer sustained, with costs, with leave to defendant to amend upon payment of costs within 20 days.