Case ID: conn-supp_8/html/0027-01.html
Source: Caselaw Access Project
Author: {"author": "COMLEY, J.", "license": "Public Domain", "url": "https://static.case.law/"}
Date Created: 2024-08-24T03:29:51.129683

FRANCES LOMBARDI vs. WILLIAM ROCHE
    Superior Court New Haven County
    File No. 57480
    MEMORANDUM FILED FEBRUARY 13, 1940.
    
      Benjamin F. Goldman, of New Haven, for the Plaintiff.
    Stoddard, Persky & Eagan and Edward L. Reynolds, of New Haven, for the Defendant.
   COMLEY, J.

I accept the explanation of the defendant, Roche, as to the details of the accident. It presents this question — may one drive an automobile upon the public highway with no responsibility for the gradual weakening of important parts of the mechanism until it is disclosed by some catastrophe, although a competent inspection of the vehicle would have disclosed the necessity for repair.

In the present case an examination of the pipes making up the hydraulic brake mechanism would have disclosed that the metal had been attacked by rust. This accident shows how dangerous such a situation might become.

It is true that defendant employed a garage man to repair the system. But the garage man made no examination of the pipe in question; and it does not appear that any other inspec' tion had been made.

Another issue arises under the special defense. The defend' ant has failed to prove that the plaintiff intended to release him from liability. The brief coloquy between them and his as' .sumption of certain bills falls short of such proof.

I find the issues for the plaintiff. She has been compensated to the extent of two hundred dollars paid by a third party and has unpaid bills amounting to $58.00.

Judgment may be entered for the plaintiff to recover of the defendant, William Roche, the sum of $458.00.