Muno459

/

zipformer_p-quran

like 10

Wa alaykum as-salam akhi 🤍

Two things, and thank you for offering to share the work.

On the iOS port: rather than publish it under my developer account, let me offer something better for you. I am happy to pay for your own Apple Developer account as sadaqah, if you would like that. Then the app is published under your name, you keep full ownership and control of it, and you are not waiting on me for every update, review reply or release. Just say the word and we will arrange it.

Publishing under my account would tie your app to me for App Review, updates and user reports, and I do not want to become the bottleneck on work you are doing for the sake of Allah.

On contact: I have asked our mutual friend Tarek to forward you my phone number for WhatsApp, so we can talk directly.

Masha'Allah on the tajweed work you described, checking tashkeel, letter replacement, shadda, ghunna and madd from token duration, and qalqala from energy. That is exactly the right split: length from duration, qalqala from the burst. Well done.

Wa alaykum as-salam akhi 🤍

Two things, and thank you for offering to share the work.

On the iOS port: rather than publish it under my developer account, let me offer something better for you. I am happy to pay for your own Apple Developer account as sadaqah, if you would like that. Then the app is published under your name, you keep full ownership and control of it, and you are not waiting on me for every update, review reply or release. Just say the word and we will arrange it.

Publishing under my account would tie your app to me for App Review, updates and user reports, and I do not want to become the bottleneck on work you are doing for the sake of Allah.

On contact: I have asked our mutual friend Tarek to forward you my phone number for WhatsApp, so we can talk directly.

Masha'Allah on the tajweed work you described, checking tashkeel, letter replacement, shadda, ghunna and madd from token duration, and qalqala from energy. That is exactly the right split: length from duration, qalqala from the burst. Well done.

no i dont want it under my name hahaha
it is better to be on yours and saving the fees of the developer account

it is for the sake of Allah
you , me , anyone who can maintain it and doesn't make profit of it

I hear you akhi, and I understand the intention completely. It is not about the money. 🤍

But I have to be honest with you rather than agree and then be a bad partner to you later.

If the app is published under my account, then in Apple's eyes I am the publisher. Not a helper,
not a host, the publisher. That means I am the one who answers App Review when they reject a build, I
sign the privacy declarations, I receive the user reports, and I am the one accountable for
everything inside the app. For a Qur'an app specifically, that last part matters more than people
expect: you and I have both seen how strongly brothers can disagree about what is correct in
recitation and tajweed, even in these very threads.

I would be answerable for an app I did not write and cannot maintain day to day. That is not good for
me, and it is worse for you, because every release, every rejection and every complaint would have to
wait for me to be free. I am often deep in a training run for days. You would end up blocked by me,
and I do not want to be the thing standing between your work and the people it is meant to serve.

So my answer is the same, and it is not a rejection of you: let the app be yours. The offer to
pay for your developer account stands whenever you want it, this month or next year. Not to save
myself the fee, but so that the work is in your name, under your control, and nobody can take it from
you or slow it down.

And what I can genuinely give you, I will keep giving: the models, the exports, the debugging, and
answers to every question you send, for as long as you are building this. That is the part where I am
actually useful to you.

وَما أَسأَلُكُم عَلَيهِ مِن أَجرٍ إِن أَجرِيَ إِلّا عَلىٰ رَبِّ العالَمِين

May Allah accept it from you, and put barakah in it whichever name it carries. 🤍

I hear you akhi, and I understand the intention completely. It is not about the money. 🤍

But I have to be honest with you rather than agree and then be a bad partner to you later.

If the app is published under my account, then in Apple's eyes I am the publisher. Not a helper,
not a host, the publisher. That means I am the one who answers App Review when they reject a build, I
sign the privacy declarations, I receive the user reports, and I am the one accountable for
everything inside the app. For a Qur'an app specifically, that last part matters more than people
expect: you and I have both seen how strongly brothers can disagree about what is correct in
recitation and tajweed, even in these very threads.

I would be answerable for an app I did not write and cannot maintain day to day. That is not good for
me, and it is worse for you, because every release, every rejection and every complaint would have to
wait for me to be free. I am often deep in a training run for days. You would end up blocked by me,
and I do not want to be the thing standing between your work and the people it is meant to serve.

So my answer is the same, and it is not a rejection of you: let the app be yours. The offer to
pay for your developer account stands whenever you want it, this month or next year. Not to save
myself the fee, but so that the work is in your name, under your control, and nobody can take it from
you or slow it down.

And what I can genuinely give you, I will keep giving: the models, the exports, the debugging, and
answers to every question you send, for as long as you are building this. That is the part where I am
actually useful to you.

وَما أَسأَلُكُم عَلَيهِ مِن أَجرٍ إِن أَجرِيَ إِلّا عَلىٰ رَبِّ العالَمِين

May Allah accept it from you, and put barakah in it whichever name it carries. 🤍

okay we can talk about this later in whatsapp or facebook insha'a Allah
but still i dont want to host it hahaha
our friend tarek can host it on his apple account instead if he accepts