Datasets:
sent_id stringclasses 122
values | premise stringclasses 121
values | hypothesis stringclasses 122
values | id stringclasses 175
values | participant stringclasses 69
values | participant_type stringclasses 2
values | experiment stringclasses 5
values | trial float64 1 5 | class_simple stringclasses 4
values | class_multi stringclasses 22
values | explanation stringlengths 25 1.89k | num_params float64 0.6 671 ⌀ | temperature float64 0.05 1.9 ⌀ | top_p float64 0.05 0.95 ⌀ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
20274n | In the summer, the Sultan's Pool, a vast outdoor amphitheatre, stages rock concerts or other big-name events. | Most rock concerts take place in the Sultan's Pool amphitheatre. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement ‘Most rock concerts take place in the Sultan’s Pool amphitheatre’ implies a high probability of rock concerts occurring within the Sultan’s Pool. The context explicitly states ‘The Sultan’s Pool’ is used for large outdoor events, suggesting it’s a suitable venue. Therefore, both ‘either’ and ‘most likely’... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
115173n | Practice 16: Be Alert to New Monitoring Tools and Techniques | Practice 17 is to check for intrusions. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either-false-true | The statement "either: can be either true or false" is crucial because it indicates the potential for multiple outcomes. The context emphasizes the need to be alert to new monitoring tools and techniques, suggesting a dynamic environment. Therefore, the statement is possible in both scenarios, indicating that either a ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
131206n | FDA suggests there may be an association between BSE and a form of human TSE known as new variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease. | Research suggests the FDA's opinion is wrong. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context suggests a potential link between Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE) and a new variant of Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD). The statement directly challenges the FDA's opinion on this association. Therefore, both 'either' and 'either' are possible. The context introduces a potential link, but the stateme... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
76016c | Divers can explore the deeps but you can also snorkel here, or take a glass-bottom boat or submarine tour to get a glimpse of this watery world. | Divers do not like to explore the deeps here. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement expresses a dislike for exploration in the deeps, while the context suggests divers *can* still explore that area through various methods. Therefore, the most likely scenario is that divers do not like to explore the deeps. The context explicitly mentions divers can snorkel, glass-bottom boat, or submari... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
37131c | Saddam could emerge strengthened (and America tarnished) in the eyes of the Arab world. | Saddam could turn out weaker. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are plausible given the context. Saddam could emerge stronger, suggesting a potential resurgence, while simultaneously, a weakening could occur. The context suggests a dynamic situation where the outcome is uncertain, making both possibilities viable. The statement itself is a conditional statement, implyi... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
113193c | of course you could annex Cuba but they wouldn't like that a bit | Annexing Cuba is a great idea. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement 'Annexing Cuba is a great idea' presents a positive sentiment. However, the context indicates a potential negative reaction from Cuba. Therefore, the most likely outcome is that the statement is true, but the context suggests a potentially contentious or undesirable action. The ‘either’ option acknowledge... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
43365c | Further, given the dynamic environment agencies face, employees need incentives, training, and support to help them continually learn and adapt. | Over time agencies faced rigid environments where nothing changed. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are relevant, but 'either' is more appropriate given the context. The context emphasizes the need for continuous learning and adaptation, which necessitates both incentives and support. The statement about rigid environments highlights a historical challenge that agencies need to overcome. Therefore, consi... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
8545c | He hadn't seen even pictures of such things since the few silent movies run in some of the little art theaters. | He had recently seen pictures depicting those things. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are possible given the context. The initial context suggests a lack of visual memory for something unusual, and then the statement indicates a recent visual exposure. Therefore, it’s reasonable to assume the person has recently seen pictures of that thing. The fact that he hadn't seen anything 'since the ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
2133n | The tomb guardian will unlock the gate to the tunnel and give you a candle to explore the small circular catacomb, but for what little you can see, it is hardly worth the effort. | The tomb garden can give you a thorough tour of the catacombs. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement suggests a potential tour of the catacombs, which is a valuable benefit. However, the tomb guardian’s action – unlocking the gate and providing a candle – is presented as a minor, potentially underwhelming effort. Therefore, both 'either' and 'either' are possible. It's possible the tomb guardian is offer... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
77299n | The inquiry expanded very quickly, however, from asking what technology failed to an examination of contextual influences, such as | They moved they inquiries over from technology failing because they thought it may be something else. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | error | error | JSON parsing error: Invalid control character at: line 4 column 423 (char 475) | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
88050c | If you have any questions about this report, please contact Henry R. Wray, Senior Associate General Counsel, at (202) 512-8581. | Henry R. Wray can be reached at (555) 512-8581. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement "Henry R. Wray can be reached at (555) 512-8581" is most likely true. The context explicitly states that Henry R. Wray is a Senior Associate General Counsel, and that he is reachable by phone. Therefore, the statement is probable, and it's possible for Henry R. Wray to be reached through other means as we... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
140440e | Table 2: Examples of BLM's, FHWA's, IRS's, and VBA's Customer Satisfaction Expectations for Senior Executive Performance | Senior Executive's have been studies on various aspects to reach the expectations. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are plausible, given the context of expectations and studies. ‘Either’ could refer to the *potential* for expectations, or to the *actual* expectations that senior executives should fulfill. The statement suggests a process of investigation, making 'either' a viable interpretation. The context focuses on ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
6105n | Asked about abortion the other day on CNN, Republican National Committee Chairman Jim Nicholson also invoked what is apparently the party-line inclusive party. | The Republican politicians and spokespeople rely on the party-line when it comes to abortion because their constituents insist on it. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are plausible, but the statement suggests a strong reliance on the party line. The context points towards a Republican political strategy, which inherently involves aligning with a specific political position. The Republican politician's invocation of the 'party-line inclusive party' implies a deliberate e... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
25437n | Well, we will come in and interview the brave Dorcas." Dorcas was standing in the boudoir, her hands folded in front of her, and her grey hair rose in stiff waves under her white cap. | Dorcas is well known for her bravery. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are plausible, but the statement ‘Dorcas is well known for her bravery’ strongly suggests that Dorcas *is* brave. The context of her posture – folded hands, white cap, and grey hair – points to a character who might be cautious or reserved, aligning with the idea of bravery. However, the context also intro... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
91993n | Most of Slate will not be published next week, the third and last of our traditional summer weeks off. | Slate won't be published much this summer. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both the context and statement suggest a reduction in publication. The context explicitly states ‘most of Slate will not be published,’ indicating a significant decrease. The statement ‘Slate won’t be published much this summer’ reinforces this trend, suggesting a limited release. Therefore, both options – ‘either’ and... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
112688n | (For more information on BLM's senior executive performance plans, see app. | BLM's performance plans are visible online. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either-false-true | The statement implies that the performance plans are available online, but it doesn't definitively state whether they are true or false. Therefore, 'either' is the most appropriate option. It’s possible that the plans are genuinely available and accurate, but it's also possible they are incomplete or misleading. The s... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
44648e | which they probably Mexican people don't even know what a taco salad is but i think it's now it's moving up too because uh just a change you know just something different | Taco salad isn't a traditional Mexican dish, but it's becoming one because of cultural movement. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement implies that Taco salad is becoming a traditional Mexican dish, but it’s not inherently a traditional one. It’s a cultural movement that’s elevating it, suggesting a shift in culinary identity. Therefore, it's possible for Taco salad to be a traditional dish, but it’s also possible that it’s a new creatio... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
113926e | Such experience better enables the CIOs to work with business managers to build a shared vision for meeting mission needs. | They are able to have the same vision because of their previous involvement. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement asserts a shared vision, and the context suggests this is facilitated by past involvement. Therefore, it’s possible for both options to be true. The context highlights that the CIOs work with business managers, implying a collaborative process. The statement itself is a claim of a shared vision, and the ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
36655n | The regime's response of ferocious repression plus numerous other ineptitudes led to a third revolution in 1848, with the Bonapartists, led by Napoleon's nephew, emerging triumphant. | France was ruled by Napoleon's nephew after they won a revolution in 1848. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement is true, but the context suggests a specific event – a third revolution – that resulted from Napoleon’s nephew’s victory. The context establishes that the regime’s response was ‘ferocious repression’ and ‘ineptitudes’, indicating a failed attempt at stability. Therefore, it’s plausible that Napoleon’s nep... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
125391e | I thought working on Liddy's campaign would be better than working on Bob's. | I thought I would like working on Liddy's campaign the best. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement expresses a strong preference for working on Liddy's campaign. The context suggests a potential contrast in job options, leading to a possible 'either/or' scenario. The statement implies a positive sentiment towards Liddy's campaign, which is a key factor in choosing 'either' as the most likely option. ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
119901e | Most pundits side with bushy-headed George Stephanopoulos ( This Week ), arguing that only air strikes would be politically palatable. | Mr. Stephanopoulos has a very large pundit following due to his stance on air strikes only being politically palatable. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement suggests a strong and likely audience following Mr. Stephanopoulos, which is a significant factor. However, the context also points towards a specific viewpoint – that air strikes are the only politically acceptable option. Therefore, both options are possible, but the statement implies a substantial foll... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
114458e | Mortifyingly enough, it is all the difficulty, the laziness, the pathetic formlessness in youth, the round peg in the square hole, the whatever do you want? | Many youth are lazy. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context highlights a sense of frustration and perceived inadequacy, particularly regarding youth. The statement ‘Many youth are lazy’ directly reflects this sentiment. Therefore, both ‘either’ and ‘false’ are plausible interpretations. The context suggests a feeling of being an outcast or misfit, which could be a ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
125600n | 2) This particular instance of it stinks. | It is a terrible situation. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either-false-true | The context presents a subjective assessment: 'this particular instance of it stinks.' This strongly suggests a negative sentiment, indicating a feeling of displeasure or disgust. The statement 'It is a terrible situation' amplifies this negative feeling, reinforcing the idea that the situation is severely problematic... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
91541n | Others love to see it in the middle of the heaviest monsoon, its marble translucent, its image blurred in the rain-stippled water channels of its gardens. | It is especially beautiful during the monsoon season. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are plausible, but 'either' is more likely. The context describes a visual phenomenon – a marble garden – and the statement focuses on beauty. The image being blurred in rain-stippled water channels suggests a visual aesthetic, aligning with the ‘either’ possibility. The statement itself emphasizes the be... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
28507n | It is, as you see, highly magnified. | It is plain for you to see that it is amplified. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | error | error | JSON parsing error: Invalid control character at: line 4 column 627 (char 679) | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
24755e | To savour the full effect of the architect's skill, enter the courtyard through the gate which opens onto the Hippodrome. | The gate to the Hippodrome is an example of the architect's skill. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement 'The gate to the Hippodrome is an example of the architect's skill' implies that the gate itself possesses a quality that the architect demonstrates. Therefore, 'either' is the most plausible option. However, the context specifically directs us to consider the gate’s function as a gateway to a significant... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
112621n | Enter the realm of shopping malls, where everything you're looking for is available without moving your car. | Everything can be found inside a shopping mall. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either-false-true | The context explicitly states that 'everything' can be found inside a shopping mall. The statement reinforces this, asserting that 'everything' is *possible* to be found within a shopping mall. Therefore, both 'either' and 'true' are viable possibilities, indicating a nuanced situation. It's not a simple binary; the st... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
26822n | He leaned over Tommy, his face purple with excitement. | He hovered over Tommy, with a deep color in his face from the thrill. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options – ‘either’ and ‘either’ – are plausible. The context establishes Tommy is excited, and the statement describes Tommy’s facial expression as a result of this excitement. ‘Either’ is most likely true because the context strongly implies excitement, which would naturally lead to a heightened emotional state. ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
137040e | We look forward to receiving comments from the readers of this paper. | Someone likes to get comments from readers of a paper. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context explicitly states a desire for reader comments, while the statement introduces a desire for someone to receive comments. Therefore, both 'either' and 'either' are possible. The statement suggests a reciprocal action – receiving comments *leads to* someone wanting to receive them, which is consistent with t... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
61216c | By seeding packs with a few high-value cards, the manufacturer is encouraging kids to buy Pokemon cards like lottery tickets. | Each Pokemon card pack is filled with every rare card a kid could want. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | error | either: true and false | The statement implies that each card pack contains every rare card a kid could want, which is a significant amount of content. However, seeding packs with high-value cards *encourages* buying them, suggesting that this content is a key driver of sales. Therefore, the statement is potentially true, but it could also be... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
79141n | Isn't a woman's body her most personal property? | Women's bodies belong to themselves, they should decide what to do with it. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement emphasizes autonomy and self-determination, aligning with the context's assertion that a woman’s body is her most personal property. However, the context also suggests a fundamental right to self-determination, which can be interpreted as a potential challenge to the statement. Therefore, both ‘either’ an... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
4048n | Improved products and services Initiate actions and manage risks to develop new products and services within or outside the organization. | Managed risks lead to new products | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are plausible given the context. The context explicitly states that 'managed risks lead to new products.' This suggests a proactive approach to product development, which naturally involves risk assessment. However, 'either' is possible because the context doesn’t definitively rule out the possibility of ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
26460n | While it's probably true that democracies are unlikely to go to war unless they're attacked, sometimes they are the first to take the offensive. | Democracies probably won't go to war unless someone attacks them on their soil | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context suggests democracies are prone to aggression, while the statement indicates a potential for war avoidance. Therefore, both options – ‘true’ and ‘false’ – are possible. The context provides a basis for a potential aggressive response, but it doesn’t definitively guarantee war. The statement introduces a sce... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
80517e | This doesn't look good. | This looks really bad. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context states ‘this doesn’t look good,’ implying a negative assessment. The statement ‘this looks really bad’ amplifies this negativity. Therefore, both ‘either’ and ‘false’ are plausible outcomes. The context suggests a negative feeling, potentially indicating a diminished quality, which aligns with the possibili... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
43897e | 2. Receiving Water Samples | The water samples should be received. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement ‘The water samples should be received’ is inherently true, given the context of ‘Receiving Water Samples’. However, it’s possible for the statement to be false in a specific scenario. The context establishes a procedure – receiving water samples – but doesn’t dictate a specific outcome. Therefore, 'eithe... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
78105n | Their supplies scarce, their harvest meager, and their spirit broken, they abandoned the fort in 1858. | They abandoned their fort after a zombie outbreak. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context points to a dire situation – scarcity, meager harvest, and broken spirit – suggesting a severe crisis. The statement explicitly links this to a zombie outbreak. Therefore, the situation is likely a combination of both events. The context indicates a catastrophic event, and the statement provides a potential... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
98721e | that's neat just supervised more or less than anything and security i guess for them | They just supervise people. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context suggests a supervisory role, yet the statement implies simple supervision. ‘They just supervise people’ indicates a basic level of oversight, not a complex or detailed monitoring. Therefore, both ‘either’ and ‘either’ are possible, as the statement is a general description of a routine activity, not a speci... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
47756n | She was quite young, not more than eighteen. | She looked older even though she was only barely eighteen. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both the context and statement suggest a discrepancy between her apparent youth and her perceived age. The context establishes she is under eighteen, implying a relatively young age. The statement explicitly states she looks older, further emphasizing this contrast. Therefore, the most likely scenario is that she is bo... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
34043c | The Gaiety Theatre in South King Street is worth visiting for its ornate d??cor. | The Trump Tower is a terrible place to visit for ornate decor. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context indicates a positive sentiment towards the Gaiety Theatre – it's ‘worth visiting’ for its ‘ornate decor.’ The statement directly contradicts this, claiming it’s a ‘terrible place to visit’. Therefore, both options – ‘either’ and ‘false’ – are plausible, but ‘either’ is more likely given the context. The con... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
61285n | We were playing all sorts of sports, and you were not, so shut up and stop twitching,' the microbe's tone of voice changed, it was lower and more resounding. | We have played football, basketball, baseball and soccer and you haven't played anything so shut your mouth. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement asserts a lack of participation in activities, while the context implies a negative and potentially aggressive tone. The statement is true because the microbe's tone indicates a strong disapproval of the individual's behavior. The fact that the microbe is speaking lower and more resounding suggests a heig... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
45749n | Perhaps all we can say of great acting is that it involves assimilation rather than accumulation, that the performer isn't so much a surrogate as a vessel. | An actor is judged solely on quality of performance. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context emphasizes the performer's role as a ‘vessel’ rather than a ‘surrogate,’ suggesting a focus on the actor’s capacity rather than their individual skill. The statement, ‘An actor is judged solely on quality of performance,’ directly contradicts this idea. The context implies a focus on the actor's capacity, ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
128360n | This man claims that he has been robbed en route and is stranded without money or his plane ticket in an airport somewhere in Europe or the Middle East. | He claimed he was robbed and left with no money or a plane ticket but quickly solved the problem. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are possible, but the statement strongly suggests a resolution. The initial context establishes a scenario of a robbery, and the statement describes a quick solution to the problem. Therefore, both are plausible, but the statement’s tone implies a successful resolution, making 'either' the more likely choi... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
111167c | Could you please speak to this issue, with regard to the social ramifications of gum chewing in public? | You don't have an opinion on gum chewing in public, I see. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement "You don't have an opinion on gum chewing in public, I see." implies a lack of concern, yet the context asks for a response to a "social ramifications of gum chewing in public." This creates a contradiction, suggesting that the speaker *does* have an opinion, but is attempting to deflect it. Therefore, 'e... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
14280n | The author began with a set of hunches or hypotheses about what can go wrong in agency management, and what would be evidence supporting-or contradicting-these hypotheses. | The hunches provided by the author weren't realistic as it pertains to agency management. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement "The hunches provided by the author weren't realistic as it pertains to agency management" strongly implies that the hunches were flawed and insufficient to adequately assess agency management. The context highlights the author's initial exploration of potential problems, suggesting these hunches are a st... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
138862c | Also, other sorbent-based approaches in development may prove in time to be preferable to ACI, making the use of ACI only a conservative assumption. | Hydrogen-based approaches in development may be preferable to ACl. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement suggests that hydrogen-based approaches could be beneficial, while the context implies that ACI might be a conservative choice. Therefore, it is possible for both approaches to be true, but the context leans toward the hydrogen-based approach being more likely. The statement doesn't definitively rule out ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
49807n | The next year, he built himself a palace, Iolani, which can still be toured in Honolulu. | Lolani was built in only 1 year. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement 'Lolani was built in only 1 year' contradicts the context that 'he built himself a palace, Iolani'. The context establishes a significant, ongoing construction project – a palace – that took a considerable amount of time. Therefore, the statement is likely false, but it's also possible that the statement... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
28456n | A clean, wholesome-looking woman opened it. | The woman was trying to be desecrate. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | false | false | The statement 'The woman was trying to be desecrate' directly contradicts the context. The context describes a woman opening a clean, wholesome-looking container. The word ‘desecrate’ implies something profoundly disrespectful and taboo, which is not aligned with the described scene of opening a container. Therefore, t... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
55161n | This testing of the marketplace may range from written or telephone contacts with knowledgeable federal and non-federal experts regarding similar or duplicate requirements and the results of any market test recently undertaken, to the more formal sources-sought announcements in pertinent publications (e.g. | Sources-sought announcements in pertinent publications are better for the marketplace testing. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement suggests that sources like publications are more suitable for marketplace testing than direct contact. This implies that publications provide a more structured and reliable source of information for testing. Therefore, 'either' is the most likely option. The context emphasizes the potential for various te... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
118670c | The Kal whistled and Vrenna's eyes sparkled when she saw Jon swing it. | Kal is whistling into Vrenna's face. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context states Kal is whistling, and the statement directly links Kal to Vrenna's face. Therefore, the statement 'Kal is whistling into Vrenna' is possible, but not definitively true. It's a plausible scenario, but not a guaranteed outcome. The presence of both 'either' and 'kal' suggests a possibility of both eve... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
83298n | Anyway, she was found dead this morning." | She died during the night but wasn't found until this morning. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | error | error | JSON parsing error: Invalid control character at: line 4 column 518 (char 570) | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
10164e | findings, the Administrator has determined that an environmental impact statement need not be prepared. | The Administrator believes a environmental impact statement should not be prepared. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both the context and the statement indicate a disagreement regarding the necessity of an environmental impact statement. The context suggests a decision to avoid preparation, while the statement expresses a firm belief against it. Therefore, both 'either' and 'false' are possible, but 'either' is more likely given the ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
101940e | They encourage the view that there's nothing--from Iraqi germ weapons programs to Serbian atrocities--that a few invisible planes can't fix. | A few invisible planes are all it takes to fix certain issues. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context suggests a dismissal of blame, implying that even seemingly insurmountable problems can be resolved with a minimal intervention. The statement presents a simple solution, suggesting that a small, unseen element is sufficient to address a problem. Considering the context, the statement aligns with this persp... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
101940n | They encourage the view that there's nothing--from Iraqi germ weapons programs to Serbian atrocities--that a few invisible planes can't fix. | Iraqi chemical weapons and Serbian atrocities can be easily fixed with a few invisible planes. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are possible, but the statement implies a potential for ease of resolution. The context suggests a belief that certain problems are solvable with minimal intervention. ‘Invisible planes’ could be the key to fixing these issues, suggesting a simple solution. However, the statement itself is a bold claim, a... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
103482e | Although it is a significant part of the poverty population, Asians historically have not been able to participate in the services and programs available to the poor, he said. | Asians are usually not poor. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context indicates that Asians have historically been excluded from services for the poor, while the statement denies this. Therefore, the statement is potentially true, but the context suggests it's not entirely accurate. It is possible that Asians *do* participate in programs, but the historical exclusion implie... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
103863c | for a change i i got i get sick of winter just looking everything so dead i hate that | I'm so sick of summer. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context expresses a feeling of disillusionment with winter, suggesting a desire for warmer weather. The statement, "I'm so sick of summer," directly reflects this sentiment. It's possible that the speaker is experiencing a similar feeling, but the context doesn't definitively confirm this. Therefore, both options a... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
104837n | Some management consultants describe dysfunctional interactions with one's fellow workers as value-subtracting behavior. | Consultants most often have personality clashes at the center of conflict. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context describes value-subtracting behavior, suggesting a negative dynamic between individuals. The statement reinforces this by highlighting personality clashes as a central cause of conflict. Therefore, both options are possible. The context implies a potential for conflict, and the statement suggests a common r... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
105191n | The Washington Post called it the culmination of a six-month game of political chicken. | It has been called by the Washington Post as the culmination of a six-month game of political chicken, said the CNN. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are plausible given the context. The Washington Post’s description of the game as a ‘game of political chicken’ suggests a complex and potentially volatile dynamic, which could easily be interpreted as a game of strategic maneuvering. The CNN's assertion further reinforces this idea, implying a heightened ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
107152n | because i don't want to my mother was also a domineering type of personality because she had to take over the things that my dad fell short in | My mother had to work hard to take care of the family. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context suggests a pattern of personality traits – a domineering mother who inherited traits from her father. The statement focuses on her work ethic, which is a direct consequence of this inherited tendency. Therefore, it’s possible both are true, but the context provides a stronger basis for one to be more likely... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
108083c | Do you want to see historic sights and tour museums and art galleries? | You wouldn't like to visit historic places, museums, and art galleries, would you? | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context presents a situation where someone *does* want to see historic sights and museums, while the statement expresses a preference against it. Therefore, both 'either' and 'false' are possible, but the context strongly suggests a preference for the former. The statement is contradictory to the context, but it c... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
108847c | The category of qualifying teen-agers and women could include all recipients of welfare or other public assistance (including daughters of recipients) who are competent to give informed consent to the implant procedure. | Women who are on welfare will not qualify for the implant. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement directly states that women on welfare will not qualify for the implant procedure. This implies a conditional exclusion, and therefore, 'either' is the most appropriate classification. It’s possible for a woman on welfare to *potentially* qualify, but the statement is definitive about exclusion. The condit... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
108934c | Blue says Blumenthal claimed Clinton had told him that Lewinsky had made unwanted sexual advances. | Clinton told Blumenthal that he was the one harassing Lewinsky. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | true | true | The context establishes that Blumenthal claimed Clinton told him Lewinsky had unwanted sexual advances. The statement directly contradicts this, asserting that Clinton told Blumenthal he was harassing Lewinsky. Therefore, the statement aligns with the context, making it highly probable that it is true. The context pro... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
112701n | It has a full program of events, including lectures. | There might be some lectures in the very full docket of events. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context suggests a comprehensive program of events, including lectures. The statement introduces a potential for lectures to be included within this broader event schedule. Therefore, it's possible for there to be lectures, and it's equally possible that there aren't. The statement’s use of ‘ docket’ implies a det... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
113060e | I hope that our common interests will lead us to a consensus - one that will provide the country with significant benefits. | it is hoped that the common interests will lead us to a consensus. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are plausible given the context. The context establishes a desire for a consensus, suggesting a collaborative effort. The statement itself is a straightforward expression of that desire. However, the context introduces a sense of benefit, suggesting the consensus will be valuable. Therefore, 'either' is ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
113585n | we only have to get up for you know for the daytime feedings | We have to get up early to prepare the daytime feedings. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context states that the only requirement is to get up for daytime feedings. The statement directly follows this requirement, indicating a necessary early morning preparation for feeding schedules. Therefore, ‘either’ is the most probable option. However, the context could lead to an ‘either’ or ‘neither’ outcome, s... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
114316e | There's a dramatic difference between someone like Michael Dell and someone like Al Dunlap. | There is a vast destination between the two individuals. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either-false-true | The context indicates a significant difference between Michael Dell and Al Dunlap, and the statement suggests a vast destination between them. Therefore, both options are possible. The statement 'there is a vast destination between' implies a significant overlap or connection, yet the context focuses on a stark contras... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
115139n | But in fact Haveman and Wolfe's statistical analysis is designed to rule out this and similar alternative theories, leaving us to conclude that the moves themselves are harmful. | We concluded that moves of the government are harmful. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | false | false | The statement ‘We concluded that moves of the government are harmful’ is most likely false. The context emphasizes that Haveman and Wolfe’s analysis is designed to rule out alternative theories, suggesting a negative assessment of government actions. The focus is on the *harm* of the moves themselves, not on the gover... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
11618n | Enlarging the village was not desirable and most knew that Severn only desired wealth and a seat on the council of elders. | Severn only cared about being a millionaire. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context indicates that Severn is primarily motivated by wealth and political power, suggesting a focus on economic gain. The statement further reinforces this by asserting a singular, materialistic goal – being a millionaire. Therefore, both options – ‘either’ and ‘either’ – are plausible, but the context leans tow... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
116970e | , number of parks or acres of land) rather than in terms of historical cost. | Parks have a historical cost that might be expressed based on acreage. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement suggests that the historical cost of parks could be influenced by the number of acres they encompass. This is a plausible scenario, as acreage directly impacts the potential value of a park. However, it’s also possible that historical costs are calculated based on other factors, such as land quality, loca... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
117134c | De Wit worked from likenesses of actual monarchs to produce his portraits. | De Wit used fictional monarchs to produce his portraits. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context establishes that De Wit created portraits using likenesses of actual monarchs, which inherently implies a fictional element. However, the statement suggests De Wit utilized fictional monarchs. Therefore, both options – ‘true’ and ‘false’ – are possible, reflecting the inherent nature of artistic creation an... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
117496n | He caught his breath. | He was flustered. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both the context and statement strongly suggest a state of nervousness or agitation. The context presents a moment of breathlessness, implying a heightened state of awareness. The statement, ‘He was flustered,’ further reinforces this idea of distress. Therefore, ‘either’ is the most appropriate classification. It is p... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
118652c | iii Program Letter 1998-1, published on February 12, 1998, called upon all LSC recipients to analyze any progress made toward the development of the legal services model envisioned by state planners. | State planners provide contract services to analyze LSC recipients legal models. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are possible, but the context strongly suggests a focused analysis. The statement describes state planners’ contract services, which implies a specific project – the development of a legal services model. Therefore, the call to analyze progress suggests a targeted examination of this model. The fact that ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
121168e | It was other-worldly. | It was very good. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context states ‘It was other-worldly,’ suggesting a unique and unusual quality. The statement ‘It was very good’ reinforces this idea, indicating a positive assessment. Therefore, ‘either’ is the most appropriate classification. It’s possible for something to be both other-worldly and good, but the context leans to... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
121910n | If ancient writings give only a romanticized view, they do offer a more precise picture of Indo-Aryan society. | Ancient writings don't show an accurate picture of Indo-Anryan society, making it look too kind. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement presents a contrasting view – it argues that ancient writings, while romanticized, don’t accurately represent Indo-Aryan society. This creates a situation where either the ancient writings offer a true picture or a misleading one. The ‘either’ option is plausible because the context suggests a potential ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
124028e | Most of the dances are suggestive of ancient courtship rituals, with the man being forceful and arrogant, the woman shyly flirtatious. | Traditional dating generally involves an alpha male with a beta female. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context describes a dynamic interaction centered around perceived power imbalances, suggesting a courtship ritual. The statement reinforces this by positioning a traditional dating structure around an alpha male and a beta female, implying a hierarchical relationship. Therefore, both options – ‘true’ and ‘false’ – ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
125021n | Other functional components of the Postal Service are presumed here not to exhibit significant scale economies, although this has not been demonstrated. | The Postal Service has very small scale economies. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement "The Postal Service has very small scale economies" implies a lack of significant cost reductions when compared to other organizations. Considering the context, which states that other functional components of the Postal Service are presumed to not exhibit significant scale economies, this implies that th... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
125225n | Five years ago, Speaker-elect Newt Gingrich promised to make important information available online at the same moment that it is available to the highest-paid Washington lobbyist. | Newt Gingrich promised that the lobbyists will post important information online. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context presents a scenario where Newt Gingrich made a promise regarding online information availability. The statement confirms this promise. Therefore, the statement is likely true. However, the context introduces a potentially contradictory element – the promise of information being available simultaneously to h... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
126654n | (Hypothetical data for this example are given in table 2.2.) | The data exists | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either-false-true | The statement ‘The data exists’ is inherently a factual assertion, but the context suggests a potential for uncertainty. Given the context, the data’s existence is plausible, but the statement itself doesn’t definitively confirm it. Therefore, ‘either-false-true’ is the most appropriate classification. The statement’s... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
126837e | There are other reasons that wrecks cause fan excitement--e.g. | A cause for fan excitement can be wrecks. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context suggests that other reasons contribute to fan excitement, and the statement directly links fan excitement to wrecks. Therefore, 'either' is the most appropriate classification. ‘Wreck’ is a key element in the context, implying a disruption or event that can generate excitement. It’s possible for a wreck to... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
130315c | yeah now do Indian are Indian foods kosher | No, indian foods are not kosher. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | false | false | The statement unequivocally denies that Indian foods are kosher. The context supports this assertion; the question asks if Indian foods are kosher, and the statement directly contradicts this. The context suggests a specific dietary requirement – kosher laws apply to certain foods – which is incompatible with Indian c... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
131718n | They consolidated programs to increase efficiency and deploy resources more effectively | Programs to increase efficiency were consolidated, because they care deeply about efficiency. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | error | error | JSON parsing error: Expecting ',' delimiter: line 5 column 2 (char 3123) | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
134641n | he's a college graduate type guy he's been in all he's an entrepreneur and he gives very practical financial advice about cars very you know not not nothing college level basic stuff his name is Bruce Williams he's on national radio uh i don't know what it would be down there you might want to whatever your radio talk ... | the entrepreneur runs a car business of his own | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement ‘the entrepreneur runs a car business of his own’ is highly probable given the context. Bruce Williams, as a college graduate type individual, is a self-employed entrepreneur. The context explicitly states he ‘gives very practical financial advice about cars’ and ‘he’s on national radio’ – these are all h... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
135247n | The original wax models of the river gods are on display in the Civic Museum. | Thousands of people come to see the wax models. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement 'Thousands of people come to see the wax models' is highly probable given the context of displaying the original wax models in the Civic Museum. The context establishes a significant presence of wax models, and the statement directly implies a large crowd is present. Therefore, it's reasonable to assume t... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
136407c | Are you sure? | Aren't you indecisive? | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context indicates a feeling of uncertainty, suggesting a potential for multiple valid responses. The statement ‘Aren’t you indecisive?’ directly challenges this uncertainty. Therefore, both ‘either’ and ‘either’ are possible, reflecting a nuanced response to the presented situation. The statement implies a question... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
137083n | It was always a part of me. | Even though it is not true anymore, back then it was a portion of me. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement suggests a past connection, implying that the past element was a significant part of the speaker's identity. However, the context indicates it's not currently true. Therefore, 'either' is a plausible option. It’s possible the speaker's past self was a part of them, but that part is now separate from the p... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
138210c | At that event, legal services personnel, court personnel, and other technology experts saw demonstrations by four companies on their products, and assessed their utility for preparing pro se documents. | Legal services personnel heard product descriptions. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both the context and statement suggest a scenario where legal services personnel are evaluating products for pro se document preparation. The context highlights a demonstration, while the statement focuses on product descriptions. Therefore, both options are plausible, though the context leans towards a more active eva... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
138317e | did you see it | Can you see it? | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context establishes a question about whether the listener has observed something. The statement ‘Can you see it?’ directly asks for confirmation of observation. Given the context, the most logical response is ‘either’ – it’s possible the listener *did* see it, or they didn’t. The statement implies a simple yes/no ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
138500n | I think as soon as they get you, they'll come for me. | I'll help you get away. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context presents a scenario where the speaker anticipates a threat and suggests assistance. The statement, ‘I’ll help you get away,’ directly contradicts the initial threat. Therefore, both options are possible – the speaker could be helping the person escape, or they could be attempting to manipulate the situation... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
140704e | I think this report shows that we have had an inordinately productive and successful year. | The report shows that we need to be productive to have a successful year | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context suggests a positive outcome – a 'productive and successful year.' The statement then introduces a need for increased productivity. Therefore, both options are possible. The context *could* be true, leading to the statement being accurate. However, the context does not guarantee the statement is true; it sim... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
143789c | What a brilliantly innocuous metaphor, devised by a master manipulator to obscure his manipulations. | The simile was created by the manipulator. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context explicitly states the metaphor is devised by a manipulator, suggesting a deliberate obfuscation. The statement identifies the simile as created by the manipulator, reinforcing this idea. Therefore, both options – ‘either’ and ‘false’ – are plausible. The context implies a manipulative intent, making ‘either... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
14442e | i'd say they appraised it it's gone up you now maybe like five percent | If I were to have it appraised, it would have gone up. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | error | error | JSON parsing error: Invalid control character at: line 4 column 540 (char 592) | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
14545c | After three days of using the gel, my mouth has returned to its familiar self. | After three days they could no longer stand the pain. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context states that the speaker has returned to their familiar self after three days of using the gel. The statement indicates that after three days, they could no longer stand the pain. Therefore, both possibilities are plausible. The context suggests a return to a previous state, while the statement implies a wo... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
146070c | Game-trackers will be out by this time in an attempt to locate the tiger's hunting ground for the evening safari. | Trackers wake up early to locate the tigers for the safari. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are plausible given the context. The context states "Game-trackers will be out by this time" – this implies activity is occurring. The statement "Trackers wake up early to locate the tigers for the safari" suggests a proactive, early-morning task. Therefore, it’s possible both are true, but the context st... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
16945c | Unrest and some political extremism have surfaced from time to time, but since aid from France is so vital, and French customs so ingrained, it seems almost inconceivable that the FWI will seek total independence as other Caribbean islands have done. | There is a great deal of political extremism. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement "There is a great deal of political extremism" is highly probable given the context of unrest and political extremism surfacing. While the context suggests aid from France is crucial, it doesn't automatically equate to a desire for complete independence. The presence of political extremism implies a pote... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
18163n | Generally, data collection and analysis are concurrent and interactive-that is, yoked in case study methods. | Data analysis includes case studies | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context emphasizes that data collection and analysis are ‘concurrent and interactive,’ implying a dynamic process. The statement simply asserts that data analysis includes case studies. Therefore, both options – ‘true’ and ‘false’ – are possible, and the context suggests a nuanced approach to data analysis that cou... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
19663c | The church has an even more elaborate Baroque pulpit. | The court has a Baroque style pulpit. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context states the church has an even more elaborate Baroque pulpit, while the statement indicates the court also possesses a Baroque style pulpit. Both statements are consistent with a shared aesthetic. The fact that the church and the court have the same stylistic element suggests a possible, although not defini... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
20882c | Even though national saving remains relatively low by U.S. historical standards, economic growth in recent years has been high because more and better investments were made. | Americans have increased their savings rate each year. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context indicates a low national saving rate, while the statement highlights increased savings. The statement is a direct consequence of a higher savings rate, making it highly likely that Americans have increased their savings rate. However, it's possible that the low national saving rate is the primary driver o... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
22462c | The director, Michael Mann, has never tried to tell a story as complex (or nonviolent) as The Insider , and he and his co-screenwriter, Eric Roth, don't shape their narrative very satisfyingly. | Michael Mann was the writer. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The context suggests a dissatisfaction with Michael Mann's storytelling style. The statement indicates that he was the writer, which implies a responsibility for the narrative's complexity. However, the context also expresses a feeling of unfulfillment in his approach, suggesting that the narrative itself might not be ... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
28306e | They made little effort, despite the Jesuit presence in Asia, to convert local inhabitants to Christianity or to expand their territory into the interior. | Local inhabitants of Asia were unable to be converted to Christianity. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | Both options are possible given the context. The statement indicates that local inhabitants were unable to be converted, suggesting a lack of success in their efforts. However, the context emphasizes a deliberate *lack* of effort, implying a failed conversion attempt. Therefore, both ‘either’ and ‘either’ are viable in... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
29373e | After considering comments of the Postal Service and other participants, the Commission found the proposal problematical, and declined to pursue it. | The Commission ultimately declined to pursue the proposal. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | error | error | JSON parsing error: Invalid control character at: line 4 column 531 (char 583) | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
30648c | 8. Jury Nullification. | The jury cannot make a decision contrary to the judge's. | gemma3-1-0.7-0.9 | gemma3 | model | size_ablation | 5 | either | either | The statement implies a limitation on the jury's discretion. The context emphasizes the jury’s role as a neutral arbiter, and the statement directly addresses the jury’s power to deviate from the judge’s instructions. Therefore, both 'either' and 'can be either' are plausible, but the statement strongly suggests a rest... | 1 | 0.7 | 0.9 |
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio
PartyNLI 🥳
PartyNL is an extension of LIveNLI designed to study label and explanation variation --- in both humans and LLMs. In addition to the original 122 LiveNLI items, PartyNLI also features new label annotations and free-text explanations from a variety of LLMs.
- Downloads last month
- 22