Patent Document

CROSS-REFERENCES TO RELATED APPLICATIONS 
   This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application 60/330,903, filed Nov. 2, 2001. 

   FIELD OF THE INVENTION 
   The invention relates to dispersion compensation in optical communication systems, and more particularly to tunable dispersion compensation modules for high speed optical transmission in optical communications systems. 
   BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 
   Dispersion compensation is one of the key elements of high speed optical transmission. Dispersion compensation traditionally involves the use of dispersion compensators at various points along an optical signal propagation path typically at amplifier sites to compensate for the dispersion caused by the fiber and elements along the span since the last dispersion compensation. Dispersion compensator modules (DCMs) are rated by the amount of dispersion they compensate and can be fixed in value or variable (tunable). Variable or tunable functioning of dispersion compensation modules is desirable for numerous reasons including the following: simplification of the network design; allowance of the reconfiguration of the network topology, reduction of inventory; reduction of turn-up time in the field and making the network more robust against aging, temperature change, and re-routing. Each of these represents potential cost savings and potential enhancement of network performance. 
   In the past, in working towards these benefits, most of the prior art has focused on tunable DCM (TDCM) development. All of the potential TDCM designs to date, however, have issues associated with them which are difficult to overcome. For example Virtual Imaged Phase Array approaches have very low yield due to tight optical alignment, Fiber Bragg Grating (FBG) based technologies have group delay ripple problems, and Fabry-Perot filter (F-P) based technology has a small tuning range. 
   It would be desirable for there to be a variable or tunable dispersion compensation module which mitigates these problems and moreover is compact and reliable. 
   SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
   The present invention provides a new approach to the variable DCM by providing a Re-Configurable Dispersion Compensation Module (RDCM) which combines existing optical switch technology with existing fixed DCM technology and advantageously also with existing TDCM technology into a programmable smart optical component. Advantageously, existing Micro-Electrical Mechanical Switch (MEMS) optical switch technology can be used. This alternate RDCM technology mitigates some the problems with approaches of the prior art, while fitting most of the requirements for high speed systems, and being of a compact size. The use of MEMSs in the RDCM allows for the creation of protection channels to increase reliability. Being a smart optical component capable of being controllably set, the RDCM allows for high level management of a transmission line system. 
   According to a first broad aspect, the invention provides for a re-configurable dispersion compensation module having a plurality of dispersion compensation elements, at least one controllable optical switch, and a controller, in which the at least one controllable optical switch is optically coupled to an optical signal path, and coupled to the plurality of dispersion compensation elements, the at least one controllable optical switch controlled by the controller to couple a selected number of the plurality of dispersion compensation elements to the optical signal path for compensating the dispersion of optical signals therein. 
   Some embodiments of the invention provide for the plurality of dispersion compensation elements having N fixed dispersion compensation elements having respectively dispersion compensation values of V, 2V, 4V, . . . , 2 N−1 V. 
   Some embodiments of the invention provide for the plurality of dispersion compensation elements having a set of fixed dispersion compensation elements, and at least one tunable dispersion compensation element. 
   Some embodiments of the invention provide for at least one of the at least one tunable dispersion compensation element having a dispersion compensation value equal to the dispersion compensation value equal to V. 
   Some embodiments of the invention provide for at least one controllable optical switch having at least one MEMS optical switch. 
   Some embodiments of the invention provide for the controller being controlled by messages received along a control signal path coupled to the controller. 
   Some embodiments of the invention provide for the controller transmitting information along the control signal path. 
   According to a second aspect, the invention provides for a re-configurable dispersion compensation module having a set of N fixed dispersion compensation elements having respectively dispersion compensation values of V, 2V, 4V, . . . , 2 N−1 V, a tunable dispersion compensation element having a dispersion compensation value equal to V, a 2(N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switch optically coupled to an optical signal path by a first input, and optically coupled to the optical signal path by an (N+2)th output, and a controller, in which respective first to Nth outputs of the 2(N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switch are coupled to respective inputs of the N fixed dispersion compensation elements, respective second to (N+1)th inputs of the 2(N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switch are coupled to respective outputs of the N fixed dispersion compensation elements, an (N+1)th output of the 2(N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switch is coupled to an input of the tunable dispersion compensation element, an (N+2)th input of the 2(N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switch is coupled to an output of the tunable dispersion compensation element, the 2(N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switch controlled by the controller to couple a selected number of the tunable dispersion compensation element and the N fixed dispersion compensation elements to the optical signal path for compensating the dispersion of optical signals therein. 
   According to a third aspect, the invention provides for a re-configurable dispersion compensation module having a set of N fixed dispersion compensation elements having respectively dispersion compensation values of V, 2V, 4V, . . . , 2 N−1 V, a tunable dispersion compensation element having a dispersion compensation value equal to V, a first (N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switch optically coupled to an optical signal path by a first input, a second (N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switch optically coupled to the optical signal path by an (N+1)th output, and a controller, in which a first output of the first (N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switch is coupled to an input of the tunable dispersion compensation element, an output of the tunable dispersion compensation element is coupled to a first input of the second (N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switch, respective second to (N+1)th outputs of the first (N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switch are coupled to respective inputs of the N fixed dispersion compensation elements, respective outputs of the N fixed dispersion compensation elements are coupled to respective second to (N+1)th inputs of the second (N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switch, respective first to Nth outputs of the second (N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switch are coupled to respective second to (N+1)th inputs of the first (N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switch, said first and second (N+1)×(N+1) MEMS optical switches controlled by the controller to couple a selected number of the tunable dispersion compensation element and the N fixed dispersion compensation elements to the optical signal path for compensating the dispersion of optical signals therein. 
   According to a fourth aspect, the invention provides for a re-configurable dispersion compensation module having a first 1×2 optical switch optically coupled to an optical signal path by an input, a second 1×2 optical switch optically coupled to the optical signal path by an output, and (N−1) 2×2 optical switches, in which the first 1×2 optical switch, the second 1×2 optical switch, the (N−1) 2×2 optical switches, and the N fixed dispersion compensation elements are coupled in a cascaded arrangement. 
   According to an second broad aspect, the invention provides for a re-configurable dispersion compensation module having a plurality of dispersion compensation elements, and at least one controllable optical switch, in which the at least one controllable optical switch is optically coupled to an optical signal path, and coupled to the plurality of dispersion compensation elements, the at least one controllable optical switch adapted to be controlled to couple a selected number of the plurality of dispersion compensation elements to the optical signal path for compensating the dispersion of optical signals therein. 
   Some embodiments of the invention provide for the tunable dispersion compensation element being coupled to the at least one controllable optical switch and the optical signal path between the controllable optical switch and the optical signal path. 
   Other aspects and features of the present invention will become apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art upon review of the following description of specific embodiments of the invention in conjunction with the accompanying figures. 

   
     BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS 
     Preferred embodiments of the invention will now be described with reference to the accompanying diagrams, in which: 
       FIG. 1  is a diagram of a long haul fiber span arrangement in an optical network including RDCMs constructed according to the invention; 
       FIG. 2  is a functional block diagram of an RDCM constructed according to the invention; 
       FIG. 3  is a diagram of an RDCM dispersion compensation switching array constructed according to an embodiment of the invention suitable for 0 km up to 38.75 km single mode fiber (SMF) dispersion compensation; 
       FIG. 4  is a diagram of the RDCM dispersion compensation switching array of  FIG. 3  in operation, set to an actual compensation of 32.5 km SMF dispersion; 
       FIG. 5  is a diagram of the RDCM dispersion compensation switching array of  FIG. 3  in operation, set to an actual compensation of 32.5 km SMF dispersion, illustrating failure protection of the preferred embodiment; 
       FIG. 6  is a diagram of a RDCM dispersion compensation switching array constructed according to an embodiment of the invention, using a single MEMS optical switch, rated for 40 km SMF dispersion compensation, including a tunable DCM, in operation, and set to an actual dispersion compensation of 22.5 km-25 km; 
       FIG. 7  is a diagram of an RDCM dispersion compensation switching array constructed according to an embodiment of the invention rated for 40 km SMF dispersion compensation, including a tunable DCM, in operation, and set to an actual dispersion compensation of 40 km; 
       FIG. 8  is a diagram of an RDCM dispersion compensation switching array of  FIG. 7  in operation set to an actual dispersion compensation of 40 km, illustrating failure protection of the preferred embodiment; 
       FIG. 9  is a diagram of a variation of the RDCM dispersion compensation switching array of  FIG. 7 ; and 
       FIG. 10  is a diagram of an RDCM dispersion compensation switching array constructed according to an embodiment of the invention utilizing cascaded switches rated for 31 units of dispersion compensation, set to an actual dispersion compensation of 19 units; 
   

   DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS 
   Referring to  FIG. 1 , a long haul fiber span arrangement in an optical network including RDCMs constructed according to the invention is described. In high rate (10 Gbps and above) long haul fiber, the chromatic dispersion in the network is carefully managed along an optical signal propagation path  109 ,  111 ,  113 , . . . ,  115 , and  117  from a transmitter  100  to a receiver  120 . RDCMs  110 ,  112 , . . . , and  114 , placed along the optical signal propagation path enables the network&#39;s management elements, for example a system controller  130 , to remotely access and set the dispersion compensation of each module to optimize system performance. Control signal paths  105 ,  119 ,  121 ,  123 , . . . ,  125 , and  127  used to allow the system controller  130 , to remotely access and set the dispersion compensation of each RDCM  110 ,  112 , . . . , and  114  could be a wavelength channel or any other available data communication medium. 
   Referring also to  FIG. 2 , the functioning of an RDCM constructed according to the invention is described. An RDCM  150  comprises dispersion compensation elements  152 , connected by a plurality of optical connections  153  to a controllable optical switch or array of controllable optical switches  154 . The controllable optical switch or array of controllable optical switches  154  is controllably set by an RDCM Controller  156  through controlling path or paths  155 . Together, the controllable optical switch or array of controllable optical switches  154 , the plurality of optical connections  153 , and the dispersion compensation elements  152  comprise an RDCM dispersion compensation switching array. Example embodiments of RDCM dispersion compensation switching arrays constructed according to the invention are shown in the remaining figures. The RDCM Controller  156  operates to control the controllable optical switch or array of controllable optical switches  154  to employ a subset of the dispersion compensation elements  152  to achieve a desired amount of dispersion compensation that the RDCM is to provide for the optical signal path (not shown in the diagram). The RDCM Controller  156  is controlled by messages sent along control signal path  157  (corresponding to paths  121 ,  123 , . . . ,  125 , and  127  of  FIG. 1 ) and also feeds back the dispersion value of the RDCM via signal line  157  to the system controller  130  when requested by the system controller  130  to do so. 
   With reference to both FIG.  1  and  FIG. 2 , a procedure for managing dispersion compensation in an optical signal path employing RDCMs is described. There are two main states in this procedure, an initial dispersion compensation state and a dynamic dispersion compensation state. In the initial dispersion compensation state a procedure is followed in which the nominal system is powered up and initialized with default values and the communication link along control signal paths  105 ,  119 ,  121 ,  123 , . . . ,  125 , and  127 , between the system controller  130  to all RDCMs  110 ,  112 , . . . , and  114 , is established. A rough dispersion map configuration is then commenced, which involves configuring the RDCMs  110 ,  112 , . . . , and  114 , to their respective recommended values according to a recommended dispersion map (or distribution) over the link. At this point fixed DCMs of the dispersion compensation elements  152  are employed. Sequence dispersion fine tuning is then commenced which employs fine tuning stage by stage at each RDCM occurring in sequence from the transmitter  100  to the receiver  120  or from the receiver  120  to the transmitter  100 . A TDCM of an RDCM (it is not necessary that every RDCM have a TDCM) can be used to achieve the best system performance. At each stage of fine tuning the RDCMs  110 ,  112 , . . . , and  114 , multiple steps of set and measure are implemented for the RDCM being fine tuned, while maintaining all uncompleted RDCM stages at the state it was after achieving the rough dispersion map configuration. Other system configurable parameters such as optical powers along the link, and wavelengths of the channels, etc. remain at their default values. At this point the initial dispersion compensation configuration is completed. Finally, dynamic dispersion compensation is commenced in which the system goes into a dynamic dispersion compensation state, in which RDCMs are controlled dynamically to compensate for network conditions, temperature changes, re-routing etc., for example through feedback from the receiver which is used to optimize the received signal. 
   Referring to  FIG. 3 , an RDCM dispersion compensation switching array constructed according to an embodiment of the invention suitable for 0 km up to 38.75 km SMF dispersion compensation is described. As discussed in association with  FIG. 2 , the RDCM dispersion compensation switching arrays of FIG.  3  and all the remaining figures, comprises dispersion compensation elements  152 , a plurality of optical connections  153 , and a controllable optical switch or array of controllable optical switches  154 . The controllable optical switch or array of controllable optical switches  154  is controllably set by an RDCM Controller  156  through controlling path or paths  155  both of which are not shown in  FIG. 3  or the remaining figures. Although all of the preferred embodiments specifically deal with SMF dispersion, other possible types of dispersion are contemplated by the invention. In this preferred embodiment, the array of controllable optical switches comprise two 5×5 MEMS array optical switches, a first 5×5 MEMS array optical switch  200  and a second 5×5 MEMS array optical switch  202 . As described below, the array of controllable optical switches need not be implemented with MEMS technology but may in general use any optical switching array technology. Also as described below the particular dimensions of the MEMS optical switches is not important as long as they are sufficient to meet minimum functional requirements. 
   Current MEMS optical switches (such as those available from Agilent™ and Agere™) implemented in the preferred embodiments have optical waveguides which intersect each other at right angles at intersection points into and out of which micro-electrical mechanical mirrors are mechanically are moved, the mirrors commonly oriented at a 45 degree angle to the waveguides. When a mirror is moved into an intersection point, the optical signals travelling along a waveguide arriving there are reflected by 90 degrees to propagate along another waveguide. When a mirror is moved out of an intersection point, the optical signals arriving there encounter no optical element and continue to propagate along the waveguide. It is commonplace for a MEMS device to have every mirror in it oriented in the same direction. The technology used in MEMSs and their operation is generally known in the art, the specifics of which are beyond the scope of this document. 
   Referring back to  FIG. 3 , an optical signal path on which incoming optical signals are traversing is connected to the first MEMS optical switch  200  at an input  205 . An optical signal path on which outgoing optical signals traverse is connected to the second MEMS optical switch  202  at an output  207 . Four output ports of the second MEMS optical switch  202  are connected through respectively a first optical waveguide portion  221 , a second optical waveguide portion  222 , a third optical waveguide portion  223 , and a fourth optical waveguide portions  224  to four input ports of the first MEMS optical switch  200 . One output of the first MEMS optical switch  200  is connected through a fifth optical waveguide portion  211  to one input of the second MEMS optical switch  202 , and four output ports of the first MEMS optical switch  200  are connected through respective optical waveguides and four fixed DCMs, DCM2k5  212 , DCM5k0  214 , DCM10k  216 , and DCM20k  218  to four input ports of the second MEMS optical switch  202 . For each MEMS optical switch in this preferred embodiment, the set of output ports and the set of input ports used are chosen to be at 90 degrees relative to each other. In the configuration of this preferred embodiment, the fixed DCMs are arranged in stages where a DCM of a stage has a dispersion compensation value of twice that of the DCM of the previous stage. For example, in  FIG. 3  the stage one DCM, DCM2k5  212 , has a dispersion compensation sufficient to compensate for 2.5 km of fiber dispersion, the stage two DCM, DCM5k0  214  has a dispersion compensation sufficient to compensate for 5 km of fiber dispersion (twice that of stage one), the stage three DCM, DCM10k  216  has a dispersion compensation sufficient to compensate for 10 km of fiber dispersion (twice that of stage two), and the stage four DCM, DCM20k  218  has a dispersion compensation sufficient to compensate for 20 km of fiber dispersion (twice that of stage three). More generally, a set of N DCMs arranged in stages have a set of dispersion compensation values equal to {V, 2V, 4V, . . . 2 N−1 V} where V is the dispersion compensation value of the stage one DCM. As will be discussed with reference to equations below and the remaining figures, the 5×5 MEMS optical switches  200  and  202  are controllably set by the RDCM Controller  156  through controlling path or paths  155  (not shown) to employ the correct number and choice of DCMs  212 ,  214 ,  216 , and  218 , and optical waveguide portions  211 ,  221 ,  222 ,  223 , and  224  to effect a desired dispersion compensation to the optical signal originally input at the input  205 , to be output at the output  207 . Connections linking the controlling path or paths  155  used by the RDCM Controller  156  for controlling the switching arrays are not shown in the diagram. As will be explained fully below, although the RDCM of  FIG. 3  is suitable for 38.75 km, it can only achieve an actual dispersion compensation of 37.5 km. 
   Referring now to  FIG. 4  the RDCM dispersion compensation switching array of  FIG. 3  in operation, set to an actual compensation of 32.5 km SMF dispersion is discussed. The first MEMS optical switch  200  is controllably set to allow the optical signal input from input  205  to traverse the DCM2k5  212  to the second MEMS optical switch  202  which is controllably set to allow that optical signal to traverse the first optical waveguide portion  221  back to the first MEMS optical switch  200 . The first MEMS optical switch  200  is controllably set to allow the optical signal input from the first optical waveguide portion  221  to traverse the DCM10k  216  to the second MEMS optical switch  202  which is controllably set to allow that optical signal to traverse the third optical waveguide portion  223 . The first MEMS optical switch  200  is controllably set to allow the optical signal input from the third optical waveguide portion  223  to traverse the DCM20k  218  to the second MEMS optical switch  202  which is controllably set to allow that optical signal to be output through the output  207 . The result of the signal having passed through each of these DCMs is a dispersion compensation of 2.5 km+10 km+20 km=32.5 km SMF dispersion. In the context of using an RDCM, there are many applications which will have a minimum acceptable residual dispersion leftover by an RDCM, as well as a minimum required dispersion compensation to be achieved by an RDCM. For an RDCM built according to the arrangement of  FIG. 3 , the RDCM is capable of a maximum actual compensation of 37.5 km when all DCMs  212 ,  214 ,  216 , and  218  are in use. The RDCM also has a resolution of 2.5 km, in that every possible value which is a multiple of 2.5 km up to 37.5 km may actually be compensated for by appropriate choice of the combination of the DCMs  212 ,  214 ,  216 , and  218 . This corresponds to a granularity of +/− 1.25 km, being the maximum possible uncompensated for length of fiber. Given the arrangement of  FIG. 3  any required compensation of 38.75 km or less can be compensated by the RDCM with a residual dispersion of +/− 1.25 km or less. In this way an RDCM configured according to  FIG. 3 , is suitable for a maximum acceptable residual dispersion equal to half that which is compensated by its stage one DCM or equivalently is suitable for a maximum acceptable residual dispersion equal to half its resolution. It should be noted that this maximum is different for different fiber types and different data rates (10, 40, 80, and 160 Gb/s). Also, with a maximum acceptable residual dispersion equal to half the compensation of its stage one DCM, an RDCM built according to the arrangement of  FIG. 3  is suitable for dispersion compensation equal to its maximum actual achievable dispersion compensation plus half the compensation of its stage one DCM. In this case therefore an RDCM built according to the arrangement of  FIG. 3  is suitable for compensating 38.75 km of dispersion. 
   Referring now to  FIG. 5  the RDCM dispersion compensation switching array of  FIG. 3  in operation having a different operational state than that of  FIG. 4  is described. In  FIG. 5 , the same DCMs are employed as those illustrated in  FIG. 4 , however, different waveguides and mirrors inside the MEMS optical switches, and different optical waveguide portions have been used. Array waveguides are preferably used in this embodiment because of the redundancy provided which allows for failure protection amongst the switching elements of the switch. If for example either of the mirrors directly adjacent either side of the DCM2k5  212  (as shown in  FIG. 4 ) were to fail, then the MEMSs  200 ,  202  could be controllably set so that mirrors directly adjacent either side of the DCM10k  216  were employed (as shown in FIG.  5 ), and other mirrors in the MEMSs  200 ,  202  used to cause the optical signals to traverse the DCM2k5  212 . In this particular instance, the second optical waveguide portion  221  is used (as shown in  FIG. 5 ) instead of the third optical waveguide portion  223  (as shown in FIG.  4 ). It should be noted that there are in fact many optical pathways and many different mirrors that could be used to achieve the same total dispersion compensation. 
   Referring now to  FIG. 6 , a single MEMS RDCM dispersion compensation switching array constructed according to an embodiment of the invention rated for 40 km SMF dispersion compensation, including a tunable DCM, in operation, and set to an actual dispersion compensation of 25 km is discussed. In comparison with  FIG. 3 , the dispersion compensation switching array of  FIG. 6  is different in many respects. First, instead of employing two 5×5 MEMS optical switches, this embodiment uses a single 10×5 MEMS optical switch  300 , second, the set of output ports and input ports used are not 90 degrees relative to each other, and thirdly, a tunable dispersion compensator TDCM 0-2k5  210  is included. The TDCM 0-2k5  210  is tunable to a range of 0 km to 2.5 km dispersion compensation, and preferably is an FBG tunable DCM. Since the TDCM 0-2k5  210  may take on a continuum of values from 0 to 2.5 km, the dispersion compensation of the dispersion compensation switching array is equal to the sum of the fixed DCM elements employed and any value between 0 km-2.5 km compensation that the TDCM 0-2k5  210  is set to. 
   In  FIG. 6 , an optical signal path on which incoming optical signals are traversing is connected to the single 10×5 MEMS optical switch  300  at an input  305 . An optical signal path on which outgoing optical signals traverse is connected to the single 10×5 MEMS optical switch  300  at an output  307 . Five output ports of the single 10×5 MEMS optical switch  300  are connected through respective optical waveguides and five DCMs, four fixed DCMs, DCM2k5  212 , DCM5k0  214 , DCM10k  216 , and DCM20k  218  and one tunable DCM, TDCM 0-2k5  210 , to four input ports of the single 10×5 MEMS optical switch  300 . In this embodiment, the set of output ports and the set of input ports used (other than the input  305  and the output  307 ) are chosen to be oriented at zero degrees relative to each other. Connections used by the RDCM Controller  156  for controlling the switching array are not shown in the diagram. 
   The single 10×5 MEMS optical switch  300  is controllably set to allow the optical signal input to the input  305  to traverse the TDCM 0-2k5  210  back to an input of the single 10×5 MEMS optical switch  300 . The single 10×5 MEMS optical switch  300  is controllably set to allow that optical signal to traverse the DCM2k5  212  back to another input of the single 10×5 MEMS optical switch  300 . The single 10×5 MEMS optical switch  300  is controllably set to allow that optical signal to traverse the DCM20k  218  back to another input of the single 10×5 MEMS optical switch  300 . The single 10×5 MEMS optical switch  300  is controllably set to allow that optical signal to be output from the output  307 . The result of the signal having passed through each of these DCM elements is a dispersion compensation of (0 km-2.5 km)+2.5 km+20 km=22.5 km-25 km. As described above, a series of DCMs arranged into stages as shown in  FIG. 3  has a resolution equal to the compensation of the stage one DCM. In  FIG. 6  the four DCMs, DCM2k5  212 , DCM5k0  214 , DCM10k  216 , and DCM20k  218  form such an arrangement and hence these four DCMs have themselves a resolution of 2.5 km, and can achieve a dispersion compensation equal to every value which is a multiple of 2.5 km up to its maximum of 37.5 km. The presence of the TDCM 0-2k5  210  means that none of the gaps remain, and the RDCM built according to the arrangement in  FIG. 6  can achieve a dispersion compensation of any value between 0 km-40 km with no gaps, having a continuous resolution. In general a preferred embodiment according to this arrangement has a TDCM with a tuning range equal to the dispersion compensation value of the stage one DCM of the remaining fixed dispersion compensation elements. 
   It should be noted that in a general, a MEMS RDCM dispersion compensation switching array using a single MEMS optical switch need not be configured exactly as shown in FIG.  6 . An embodiment having five DCMs as in  FIG. 6  could use a 5×5 MEMS optical switch or even a 5×1 MEMS optical switch, however redundancy and hence failure protection diminishes as implementations use MEMSs of smaller and smaller dimensions. In fact an embodiment implementing a single 5×1 MEMS would have no failure protection, and would be implemented using a MEMS having double sided mirrors instead of single sided mirrors. 
   A variation of the RDCM dispersion compensation switching array of  FIG. 3  is depicted in FIG.  7 . Instead of the first optical waveguide portion  211  optically connected between the first MEMS optical switch  200  and the second MEMS optical switch  202 , a tunable dispersion compensator TDCM 0-2k5  210  is optically connected therebetween. As with the embodiment depicted in  FIG. 6 , the presence of the TDCM 0-2k5  210  means that none of the gaps in the dispersion compensation provided by the fixed DCMs of the RDCM remains, and the RDCM built according to the arrangement in  FIG. 7  can achieve a dispersion compensation of any value between 0 km-40 km having a continuous resolution. In general a preferred embodiment according to this arrangement has a TDCM with a tuning range equal to the dispersion compensation value of the stage one DCM of the remaining fixed dispersion compensation elements, which here is the DCM2k5  212  having a dispersion compensation of 2.5 km. 
   Referring now to  FIG. 8  the RDCM dispersion compensation switching array of  FIG. 7  in operation having a different operational state than that of  FIG. 7  is described. In  FIG. 8 , the same DCMs and the same optical waveguide portions are employed as illustrated in  FIG. 7 , however, different waveguides and mirrors inside the MEMS optical switches are being used which illustrate redundancy and failure protection. It should be noted that even though all of the optical waveguide portions are used, namely the first  221 , second  222 , third  223 , and fourth  224  optical waveguide portions, and all output ports of the first and second MEMS optical switches  200 ,  202  adjacent to the dispersion compensation modules  210 ,  212 ,  214 ,  216 , and  218  are used in both configurations, there are in fact many different optical pathways and many different mirrors in the MEMs that could be controllably set and used to achieve the same total dispersion compensation. 
   A variation of the RDCM dispersion compensation switching array of  FIG. 7  is depicted in FIG.  9 . Instead of the TDCM -2k5  210  being situated between the MEMS optical switches  200  and  202 , the TDCM -2k5  210  is placed before input  205 , and is itself connected to the optical signal path on which incoming optical signals are traversing, at input  203 . As was the case in the embodiment described in association with  FIG. 3 , a fifth optical waveguide portion  211  is connected to an output of the first 5×5 MEMS optical switch  200  and an input of the second 5×5 MEMS optical switch  202 . 
   Referring to  FIG. 10 , an RDCM dispersion compensation switching array constructed according to an embodiment of the invention utilizing cascaded switches rated for 31 units of dispersion compensation, set to an actual dispersion compensation of 19 units is described. In this preferred embodiment, the array of controllable optical switches comprise a first 1×2 optical switch  409 , a second 1×2 optical switch  419 , and four 2×2 optical switches  411 ,  413 ,  415 , and  417 . An optical signal path on which incoming optical signals are traversing is connected to the first 1×2 optical switch  409  at an input  405 . A first output of the first 1×2 optical switch  409  is connected through a dispersion compensation module DCM1  410  to a first input of a first 2×2 optical switch  411 . A second output of the first 1×2 optical switch  409  is connected through an optical waveguide portion to the second input of the first 2×2 optical switch  411 . A first output of the first 2×2 optical switch  411  is connected through a dispersion compensation module DCM2  412  to a first input of a second 2×2 optical switch  413 . A second output of the first 2×2 optical switch  411  is connected through an optical waveguide portion to the second input of the second 2×2 optical switch  413 . A first output of the second 2×2 optical switch  413  is connected through a dispersion compensation module DCM4  414  to a first input of a third 2×2 optical switch  415 . A second output of the second 2×2 optical switch  413  is connected through an optical waveguide portion to the second input of the third 2×2 optical switch  415 . A first output of the third 2×2 optical switch  415  is connected through a dispersion compensation module DCM8  416  to a first input of a fourth 2×2 optical switch  417 . A second output of the third 2×2 optical switch  415  is connected through an optical waveguide portion to the second input of the fourth 2×2 optical switch  417 . A first output of the fourth 2×2 optical switch  417  is connected through a dispersion compensation module DCM16  418  to a first input of the second 1×2 optical switch  419 . A second output of the fourth 2×2 optical switch  417  is connected through an optical waveguide portion to the second input of the second 1×2 optical switch  419 . An optical signal path on which outgoing optical signals traverse is connected to the second 1×2 optical switch  419  at an output  407 . 
   In the configuration of this preferred embodiment, the fixed DCMs are arranged in cascaded stages where a DCM of a stage has a dispersion compensation value of twice that of the DCM of the previous stage. For example, in  FIG. 10  the stage one DCM, DCM1  410 , has a dispersion compensation sufficient to compensate for one unit (for this embodiment relative amounts of dispersion compensation are referred to) of fiber dispersion, the stage two DCM, DCM2  412  has a dispersion compensation sufficient to compensate for two units of fiber dispersion (twice that of stage one), the stage three DCM, DCM4  414  has a dispersion compensation sufficient to compensate for four units of fiber dispersion (twice that of stage two), the stage four DCM, DCM8  416  has a dispersion compensation sufficient to compensate for eight units of fiber dispersion (twice that of stage three), and the stage five DCM, DCM16  418  has a dispersion compensation sufficient to compensate for 16 units of fiber dispersion (twice that of stage four). More generally, as in the previous embodiments, the set of N DCMs in this cascaded embodiment arranged in stages have a set of dispersion compensation values equal to {V, 2V, 4V, . . . 2N−1V} where V is the dispersion compensation value of the stage one DCM. The 1×2 and 2×2 optical switches are controllably set to employ the correct number and choice of DCMs, and optical waveguide portions to effect a desired dispersion compensation to the optical signal originally input at input  405 , to be output at output  407 . Connections used by the RDCM Controller  156  for controlling the switches are not shown in the diagram. 
   The RDCM dispersion compensation switching array of  FIG. 10  in operation, is set to an actual compensation of 19 units SMF. The first 1×2 optical switch  409  is controllably set to output on its first output an optical signal input from input  405 , to traverse the DCM1  410  to the first input of the first 2×2 optical switch  411 . The first 2×2 optical switch  411  is controllably set to output to its first output an optical signal input to its first input to traverse the DCM2  412  to the first input of the second 2×2 optical switch  413 . The second 2×2 optical switch  413  is controllably set to output to its second output an optical signal input to its first input to traverse the optical waveguide portion to the second input of the third 2×2 optical switch  415 . The third 2×2 optical switch  415  is controllably set to output to its second output an optical signal input to its second input to traverse the optical waveguide portion to the second input of the fourth 2×2 optical switch  417 . The fourth 2×2 optical switch  417  is controllably set to output to its first output an optical signal input to its second input to traverse the DCM16  418  to the first input of the second 1×2 optical switch  419 . The second 1×2 optical switch  419  is controllably set to output to its output  407  an optical signal input to its first input to form the output of the RDCM dispersion compensation switching array. The result of the signal having passed through each of these DCM elements is a dispersion compensation of 1+2+16=19 units. 
   Although the preferred embodiments are depicted as having four or five DCMs, and having MEMS optical switches of particular dimensions, namely 5×5 and 10×5, it should be understood that the general arrangement according to the preferred embodiments depicted in FIG.  3  and  FIG. 6  involves any number of DCMs used in association with MEMSs having any dimension capable of being set to allow optical signals to traverse the DCMs in all desired combinations. The embodiments depicted in  FIGS. 3-7  could employ, for example, 7×5 or 5×7 or even 6×1 MEMSs (with appropriate arrangement of inputs and outputs). 
   In determining the capacity of the fixed dispersion compensators within the RDCM, the following equations are helpful in determining the maximum dispersion compensation achievable by the fixed dispersion compensators, and the maximum fiber distance which can be compensated by this method. 
   Let X (ps/nm) be the maximum acceptable residual dispersion in the system, which corresponds to half the dispersion compensated by the stage one fixed DCM (here our units are not km but the equations are still applicable). 
   The total actual dispersion compensation (MaxDC) of a series of fixed DCMs used in accordance with the invention can be calculated as: 
         Max   ⁢           ⁢   DC     =         ∑     n   =   0       N   -   1       ⁢           ⁢     X   ·     2     n   +   1           =     2   ⁢     X   ·     (       2   N     -   1     )               
 
   Where N is the total number of fixed DCMS, and n is the (stage number−1) of a fixed DCM. As described above, each m th  stage DCM has a dispersion compensation twice that of the (m−1) th  stage DCM. Also as described above, the MaxDC is the actual maximum amount of dispersion compensated by the DCMs, however, the RDCM is suitable for compensating the MaxDC plus the maximum acceptable residual dispersion X. 
   Let Y be the dispersion coefficient for the transmission fiber. This dispersion coefficient is different for different wavelengths as well as for different fiber types of which single mode fiber (SMF), two wave reduced slope (TWRS) and large effective area fiber (LEAF) which are the most popular examples. 
   The maximum fiber distance (MaxFD) which can be compensated by this method, when all DCM stages are in use is: 
         Max   ⁢           ⁢   FD     =           ∑     n   =   0       N   -   1       ⁢           ⁢     X   ·     2     n   +   1           Y     =       2   ⁢     X   ·     (       2   N     -   1     )         Y           
 
   The figures illustrate arrangements for which these values are useful. For example in the arrangement of  FIG. 3 , X/Y (the maximum acceptable residual dispersion expressed in km) is 1.25 km, and N=4, giving a MaxFD=2·(1.25 km)·(2 4 −1)=2·(1.25 km)·15=37.5 km. Adding the 1.25 km acceptable dispersion we arrive at a suitable dispersion compensation of 38.75 km. To calculate the actual dispersion compensation of an arrangement like that shown in  FIGS. 6 and 7 , the MaxCD or MaxED of the fixed DCMs may be added to the TDCM compensation value or respectively fiber distance. Since the compensation value of the TDCM is preferably equal to that of the stage one DCM to obtain the MaxDC and the MaxFD for such an arrangement one need only add a single term of respectively 2X and 2X/Y. 
   An additional example arrangement for which these values would be useful is a set of fixed DCMs achieving an actual 77.5 km SMF dispersion compensation, namely a DCM2k5, a DCM5k0, a DCM10k, a DCM20k, and a DCM40k. In an arrangement according to  FIG. 3  the resolution would be 2.5 km, the actual maximum would be 77.5 km and if the acceptable maximum residual dispersion were 1.25 km, the RDCM would be suitable for 78.75 km. If the 2.5 km fixed DCM were replaced with a TDCM -5k0, the RDCM would have a continuous resolution, and would be capable of compensating 0 km-80 km SMF dispersion. 
   An alternative arrangement to that shown in  FIG. 9  could replace the TDCM -2k5  210  with a TDCM 0-1k25, and employ an additional fixed DCM1k25 with a dispersion compensation of 1.25 km, if a TDCM having a smaller range but better optical characteristics is preferred. The alternative arrangement of  FIG. 9  would still be capable of achieving a continuous range of dispersion compensation of 0 km-40 km. 
   Other alternative arrangements for an RDCM&#39;s dispersion compensation switching array constructed according to the invention could use a single 5×5×2 three dimensional MEMS optical switch, with appropriate optical wave guide connections. These conceptually have the same topology as  FIG. 3  except the 5×5 arrays shown are simply sub-sections of a single 5×5×2 array. Other alternative arrangements could also use two 5×1 MEMS optical switches with appropriate looping optical wave guide connections. 
   It should be understood that although MEMSs are employed as the controllable optical switches of the preferred embodiments, the invention contemplates any other optical switching arrangement, using for example waveguide switches or even mechanical switches, which is adapted to employ selected DCMs for dispersion compensation of optical signals. Other examples of controllable optical switching arrays are thermo-capillary optical switches which use the presence or absence of a drop of liquid at an intersection point of a grid of waveguides to reflect or transmit optical signals, and bubble technology (such as that developed by Agilent™) which works by a similar process. 
   It should be noted that although the embodiments illustrated have incorporated MEMS optical switches which have mirrors oriented in a single direction only, it is contemplated by the invention that MEMS optical switches could be constructed with mirrors facing in different directions. 
   To reduce any possible polarization dependent loss (PDL) that an RDCM exhibits due to the use of multiple MEMS optical switches and the mirrors therein, a polarization scrambler, circular polarizer, or polarization controller may be applied to the input optical signal so that PDL is reduced. 
   It also should be understood that although the preferred embodiments and the equations above describe a system having DCMs whose dispersion compensation values are related in a specific manner to one another, any combination of DCMs having any desired dispersion compensation values is contemplated by the invention. 
   In should also be understood that although the preferred embodiments have been described as employing discrete dispersion compensation, optical switching and controlling elements, the invention contemplates any combination of discrete elements and elements integrated onto chips, and contemplates embodiments wherein all dispersion compensation, optical switching and controlling elements are integrated onto a single chip. 
   Numerous modifications and variations of the present invention are possible in light of the above teachings. It is therefore to be understood that within the scope of the appended claims, the invention may be practiced otherwise than as specifically described herein.

Technology Category: 5