Patent Document

This is continuation of PCT application Serial No PCT/GB99/01340 filed on Apr. 28, 1999 

   BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 
   1. Field of the Invention 
   The present invention relates to cellular mobile % communication networks, for example Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA) cellular networks. 
   2. Summary of the Related Art 
     FIG. 1  of the accompanying drawings shows parts of a cellular mobile telecommunication network according to the Telecommunication Industries Association (TIA)/Electronic Industries Association (EIA) Standard TIA/EIA/IS-95 of October 1994 (hereinafter “IS95”). Each of three base transceiver stations (BTSs)  4  (BTS 1 , BTS 2  and BTS 3 ) is connected via a fixed network  5  to a base station controller (BSC)  6 , which is in turn connected to a mobile switching centre (MSC)  7 . The BSC  6  serves to manage the radio resources of its connected BTSs  4 , for example by performing hand-off and allocating radio channels. The MSC  7  serves to provide switching functions and coordinates location registration and call delivery. 
   Each BTS  4  serves a cell  8 . When a mobile station (MS)  10  is in a so-called “soft hand-off” (SHO) region  9  where two or more cells overlap, a mobile station can receive transmission signals (downlink signals) of comparable strength and quality from the respective BTSs of the overlapping cells. Transmission signals (uplink signals) produced by the mobile station (MS) can also be received at comparable strengths and qualities by these different BTSs when the mobile station is in the SHO region  9 . 
     FIG. 2  of the accompanying drawings shows a situation where the MS  10  is located within the SHO region  9 , and is transmitting such uplink signals that are being received by plural BTSs  4 . According to the IS95 standard, a BTS  4  that receives such an uplink signal from the MS  10  relays the signal to the BSC  6  via a dedicated communications path of the fixed network  5 . At the BSC  6 , one of the relayed signals is selected based on a comparison of the quality of each of the received signals, and the selected signal is relayed to the MSC  7 . This selection is referred to as Selection Diversity. 
   Similarly,  FIG. 3  of the accompanying drawings shows a situation where the MS  10  is located within the SHO region  9  and is receiving downlink signals from plural BTSs  4 . According to the IS95 standard, downlink signals received by the BSC  6  from the MSC  7  are relayed to all BTSs  4  involved in the soft hand-off via respective communication paths of the fixed network and subsequently transmitted by all the BTSs  4  to the MS  10 . At the MS  10  the multiple signals may be combined, for example, by using maximum ratio combination (MRC), or one of them may be selected based on the signal strength or quality, i.e. using Selection Diversity as for the uplink case. 
   Incidentally, signals are transmitted as a succession of frames according to the IS95 standard. 
   As  FIG. 4  of the accompanying drawings shows, each frame is of duration 20 ms, and comprises sixteen 1.25 ms time slots. In each time slot several bits of user data and/or control information can be transmitted. 
   The soft hand-off system described above is effective in improving signal transmission between the MS  10  and the network when the MS  10  is located in regions of cell overlap near the boundaries of the individual cells. Signal quality in these regions when using a single BTS  4  may be relatively poor, but by making use of more than one BTS  4  the quality may be substantially improved. 
   However, in IS95 it is necessary to transmit signals carrying the same data and/or control information between the BSC  6  and every BTS  4  involved in the soft hand-off for both the uplink and downlink cases described above, even when one or more of the communications paths (which may be of different type, e.g. electrical, fibre optic or microwave) in the fixed network may be experiencing adverse transmission conditions, for example heavy traffic congestion or poor transmission quality. In addition, the cost associated with the use of certain lines may fluctuate. In view of this, a soft hand-off system as described above may be expensive to operate both in terms of cost and traffic congestion. 
   SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
   According to a first aspect of the present invention there is provided a cellular mobile communications network including: base station controller means; an array of base transceiver stations, each having a communications path connecting it to the said base station controller means, such that when an uplink signal is received from a mobile station of the network by a plurality of the base transceiver stations of the said array, each base transceiver station of the said plurality can transfer the received uplink signal via its said communications path to the said base station controller means; communications path assessment means for assessing the said communications paths according to one or more predetermined characteristics; and communications path disabling means operable, based on the assessment of the communications paths, to prevent at least one base transceiver station of the said plurality from transferring the received uplink signal to the said base station controller means. 
   According to a second aspect of the present invention there is provided a base station controller, for use in a cellular mobile communications network that includes an array of base transceiver stations, each having a communications path connecting it to the base station controller such that, when an uplink signal is received from a mobile station of the network by a plurality of the base transceiver stations of the array, each of those base transceiver stations can transfer the received uplink signal via its said communications path to the base station controller, which base station controller includes: communications path assessment means for assessing the said communications paths according to one or more predetermined characteristics; and informing means for generating assessment signals indicating the results of the assessment of the said communications paths and for transmitting such assessment signals to the base transceiver stations of the said plurality. 
   According to a third aspect of the present invention there is provided a base transceiver station, for use in a cellular mobile communications network in which an array of base transceiver stations including the claimed base transceiver station are connected to base station controller means of the network by respective communications paths such that when an uplink signal is received from a mobile station by a plurality of the base transceiver stations of the array, each of those base transceiver stations can transfer the received uplink signal via its said communications path to the said base station controller means; the claimed base transceiver station including: communications path disabling means operable, based on an assessment of the said communications paths according to one or more predetermined characteristics thereof, to prevent the claimed base transceiver station from transferring the received uplink signal to the said base station controller means. 
   According to a fourth aspect of the present invention there is provided a communications method for use in a cellular mobile communications network that includes an array of base transceiver stations, each having a communications path connecting it to base station controller means of the network such that, when an uplink signal is received from a mobile station by a plurality of the base transceiver stations of the array, each of those base transceiver stations can transfer the received uplink signal via its said communications path to the said base station controller means; in which communications method: the said communications paths are assessed according to one or more predetermined characteristics; and based on the assessment of the communications paths at least one base transceiver station of the said plurality is prevented from transferring the received uplink signal to the base station controller means. 
   According to a fifth aspect of the present invention there is provided a cellular mobile communications network including: base station controller means; an array of base transceiver stations, each having a communications path connecting it to the said base station controller means such that, when a downlink signal for transmission to a mobile station of the network is produced by the said base station controller means, that downlink signal can be transferred to a plurality of the base transceiver stations of the said array via the respective said communications paths thereof; communications path assessment means for assessing the said communications paths according to one or more predetermined characteristics; and communications path disabling means operable, based on the assessment of the said communications paths, to prevent the said base station controller means from transferring the said downlink signal to at least one of the said base transceiver stations of the said plurality. 
   According to a sixth aspect of the present invention there is provided a base station controller, for use in a cellular mobile communications network that includes an array of base transceiver stations, each having a communications path connecting it to the base station controller such that, when a downlink signal for transmission to a mobile station of the network is produced by the base station controller, that signal can be transferred to a plurality of the base transceiver stations of the array via the respective said communications paths thereof, which base station controller includes: communications path disabling means operable, based on an assessment of the said communications paths according to one or more predetermined characteristics thereof, to prevent transfer of the said downlink signal to at least one of the said base transceiver stations of the said plurality. 
   According to a seventh aspect of the present invention there is provided a base transceiver station, for use in a cellular mobile communications network in which an array of base transceiver stations including the claimed base transceiver station are connected to base station controller means of the network by respective communications paths such that, when a downlink signal for transmission to a mobile station of the network is produced by the base station controller means, that signal can be transferred to a plurality of the base transceiver stations of the array via the respective said transmission paths thereof; the claimed base transceiver station including: communications path assessment means for assessing the said communications path according to one or more predetermined characteristics; and informing means for generating assessment signals indicating the results of the assessment of the communications paths and for transmitting such assessment signals to the base station controller means. 
   According to an eighth aspect of the present invention there is provided a communications method for use in a cellular mobile communications network that includes an array of base transceiver stations, each having a communications path connecting it to base station controller means of the network such that, when a downlink signal for transmission to a mobile station of the network is produced by the base station controller means, that signal can be transferred to a plurality of the base transceiver stations of the array via the respective said communications paths thereof; in which method: the said communications paths are assessed according to one or more predetermined characteristics thereof; and based on the assessment of the communications paths, the base station controller means are prevented from transferring the said downlink signal to at least one of the base transceiver stations of the said plurality. 

   
     BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS 
       FIG. 1 , discussed hereinbefore, shows parts of a cellular mobile telecommunication network according to IS95; 
       FIG. 2 , also discussed hereinbefore, shows a schematic view for use in explaining processing of uplink signals in a soft hand-off operation performed by the  FIG. 1  network; 
       FIG. 3 , also discussed hereinbefore, shows a schematic view for use in explaining processing of downlink signals in such a soft hand-off operation; 
       FIG. 4 , also discussed hereinbefore, illustrates the format of a time frame in the  FIG. 1  network; 
       FIG. 5  shows parts of a mobile telecommunication network embodying the present invention; 
       FIG. 6  shows parts of a base station controller embodying the present invention; 
       FIG. 7  is a schematic diagram showing one possible format of a ranking message produced by the  FIG. 6  base station controller; and 
       FIG. 8  shows parts of a base transceiver station embodying the present invention. 
   

   DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS 
     FIG. 5  shows parts of a mobile telecommunication network embodying the present invention. In  FIG. 5 , elements that are the same as elements of the  FIG. 1  network described previously have the same reference numerals and an explanation thereof is omitted. 
   The  FIG. 5  network is a wideband CDMA network for a proposed new standard for mobile telecommunications referred to as a universal mobile telecommunications system (UMTS) or UMTS terrestrial radio access (UTRA). This is generally similar to the IS95-standard network described previously, although certain implementation details are yet to be finalised. Details that are different from IS95 include the frame duration, which is 10 ms, and the time-slot duration which is 625 μs. The overall bit rate is within the range from 8 kbits/s to 2 Mbits/s. 
   The preferred embodiment will be described in relation to a wideband CDMA network operating in a soft hand-off mode, but other embodiments are not restricted to operation in the soft hand-off mode or even in such a network. For example the present invention may be applied to a Global System for Mobile Communication (GSM) network in the case where a mobile station is within communication range of more than one BTS. 
   In  FIG. 5 , each of three base transceiver stations (BTSs)  20  (BTS 1 , BTS 2  and BTS 3 ) is connected via a fixed network  5  to a base station controller (BSC)  30 , which is in turn connected to a mobile switching centre (MSC)  7 . Each BTS  20  serves a cell  8 . A mobile station (MS)  10  is in a soft hand-off (SHO) region  9  and can receive downlink signals from, and transmit uplink signals to, all the BTSs  20  involved in the soft hand-off. 
   The  FIG. 5  network corresponds generally with the  FIG. 1  network, but the BTSs  20  and BSC  30  are constructed and operate differently from the corresponding elements in  FIG. 1 . 
     FIG. 6  shows one example of the construction of the BSC  30  in  FIG. 5 . The BSC  30  includes an assessment portion  32  and a distributor portion  34 . The assessment portion  32  includes a communications path performance (CPP) storage portion  36 . 
   In this example, it is assumed that the communications paths  5   1  to  5   3  linking each BTS to the BSC  30  are duplex lines which carry respective uplink and downlink signals US and DS between the BTS concerned and the BSC. For example, a first one of the communications path  5   1  carries respective uplink and downlink-signals US 1  and DS 1  between the BTS 1  and the BSC  30 . 
   In this example, it is also assumed that the fixed network which provides the communications paths  5   1  to  5   3  includes a fixed network controller (FNC) that monitors the performance of the communications paths and makes information available to network units such as the MSC  7  and the BSC  30  regarding such communications-path performance. For example, the fixed network controller may generate predetermined types of control signal (hereinafter referred to generically as fixed network control messages (FNCMs)) for informing the network units of conditions affecting the performance of the communications paths. Such conditions include congestion, availability and quality. 
   In an asynchronous transfer mode (ATM) network, for example, the ATM cell traffic transmitted through a communications path may contain control signals such as forward explicit congestion notifications (FECNs) or fast resource management (FRM) cells. 
   The assessment portion  32  has three inputs connected respectively to the communications paths  5   1  to  5   3  for receiving uplink signals US 1  to US 3  from BTS 1  to BTS 3  respectively. The assessment portion  32  also has inputs from the FNC (to receive the FNCMs) and from the MSC  7  (to receive downlink signals DS including s control message CM therefrom), and also has an output connected to an input of the distributor portion  34  for applying thereto a ranking message RM. 
   The distributor portion  34  receives at its input the downlink signals DS supplied by the MSC ( 7  in  FIG. 5 ), and has three outputs connected respectively to the communications paths  5   1  to  5   3 . 
   In operation of the BSC  30  shown in  FIG. 6 , the assessment portion  32  continuously assesses the performance of the communications paths  5   1  to  5   3  and maintains one or more measures of the performance of each of these communications paths (CPP measures). For example, the CPP measures may include measures of congestion, quality, availability and cost. In particular, CPP quality measures may include data (or bit) error rate, path delay and jitter. CPP availability measures may include a downtime of the communications path. CPP cost measures may include the network operator&#39;s charge per time slot (which may vary according to the time of day etc.). The CPP measure(s) for each communications path are held in the CPP storage portion  36  in storage regions corresponding respectively to the communications paths  5   1  to  5   3 . In the example shown in  FIG. 6  itself, the CPP storage portion  36  has two sets of storage regions, the first set for CPP congestion measures and the second set for CPP quality measures. 
   In order to update the CPP measures the assessment portion  32  may use information from various sources. The first of these sources is internally-generated information regarding the communications paths, which is available within the BSC  30  as the BSC  30  is itself a network unit. To this end, the assessment portion  32  receives the three uplink signals US 1  to US 3  from the BTSs  20  involved in the soft hand-off operation. When a suitable uplink signal is received via one of the communications paths  5   1  to  5   3 , the assessment portion  32  examines the signal, for example calculating its data (or bit) error rate, path delay or jitter, and employs the results of the examination to update the relevant CPP measure(s) for the communications path concerned. The resulting updated measure(s) is (are) stored in the CPP storage portion  36 . 
   At various times, the assessment portion may also receive one of the above-mentioned FNCMs, and this is used as a second source of information for updating the CPP measures held in the storage portion  36 . 
   In addition, the assessment portion  32  monitors the downlink signals received from the MSC for control messages (CMs) included therein which may from time to time contain further instructions from the MSC  7  regarding the future use of each of the communication lines  5   1  to  5   3 . When such a CM is detected, the relevant CPP measure held in the CPP storage portion  36  is updated accordingly. 
   Based on the CPP measures stored in the CPP storage portion  36 , the assessment portion  32  ranks the communication paths  5   1  to  5   3 . For example, the communications paths could be ranked according to a CPP cost measure alone, so that high-cost paths would be ranked lower than low-cost paths. Alternatively, a more sophisticated combination of CPP measures could be used to formulate the ranking. For example the cost, the path delay and the data error rate CPP measures could all be made to influence the ranking, and the relative importance of each of these measures could be varied. 
   A ranking message (RM) indicating the rank applied to each path is formed and output to the distributor portion  34 .  FIG. 7  shows an example of the format of the ranking message. An identifier for each communications path is placed within the RM in the above-determined rank order. In this example the identifier is the BTS identification number of the BTS that is connected to the BSC  30  by the communications path having the particular rank. This BTS identification number is unique to each BTS  20 . 
   The distributor portion  34  serves to relay downlink signals from the MSC  7  to the BTSs  20 . When a RM is received at the RM input of the distributor portion  34 , the ranking message is communicated to all BTSs  20  (BTS 1  to BTS 3 ) via the respective communication lines  5   1  to  5   3 . 
     FIG. 8  shows parts of a BTS  20  embodying the present invention. This BTS  20  is specially adapted to receive and process the ranking message RM sent by the BSC  30 . 
   An antenna element  22  is connected (e.g. via a duplexer not shown) to a receiver portion  24  and a transmitter portion  26 . A path disabling portion  28  receives an uplink signal US from the receiver portion  24 , and in turn applies the received US (or a signal derived therefrom) to its fixed-network communications path  5  for transmission to the BSC  30 . 
   The path disabling portion  28  also receives a downlink signal from the BSC  30 . In use of the BTS  20 , these downlink signals may include, from time to time, a ranking message RM. 
   When such a ranking message RM is received and detected by the BTS  20 , the path disabling portion  28  processes it to determine the rank of its communication path within the ranking order determined by the BSC  30 . 
   Using this ranking, the path disabling portion  28  in the BTS  20  is able to decide whether or not, in the next time slot, to forward an uplink signal US received from the receiver portion  24  (or a signal derived therefrom) to the BSC  30  via its fixed-network communications path  5 . For example, in a simple case, if the deciding BTS  20  has the highest-ranked communications path, it will decide to transmit the uplink signal; if it has the lowest-ranked path it will decide not to transmit the uplink signal. 
   In this example, each BTS  20  has knowledge of the rank of the communications path of every other BTS  20  involved in the soft hand-off, but makes the decision of whether or not to transmit the next uplink signal US independently of the other BTSs  20 . Therefore, it must be ensured that the decisions made at each BTS  20  are consistent with each other. 
   It will be understood that a situation could arise in which the BTS with the highest-ranked path to the BSC has received a poor quality uplink signal US from the mobile station, for example due to fading. To deal with this situation, a more sophisticated approach to the BTS decision-making could be adopted. In this approach, a mechanism is provided for enabling each BTS involved in the soft hand-off to have knowledge to the respective uplink-channel performances of all the other involved BTSs. A mechanism for achieving this is described, for example, in our PCT publication no. WO 99/59376, the entire content of which is incorporated herein by reference. In that mechanism a power control message (PCM) made up of the uplink power control bits (PCBs) of all the BTSs involved in the soft hand-off operation is transmitted in each time slot by the mobile station to the involved BTSs. With the benefit of this knowledge of the uplink-channel performances of the other involved BTSs, each BTS can be aware of the situation identified above in which the BTS with the highest-ranked path has received an inadequate uplink signal. Thus, another BTS (with a lower-ranked path) can send the uplink signal in this case, or possibly all BTSs could send the uplink signal with MRC being used in the BSC. 
   It will also be appreciated that, instead of broadcasting a ranking message RM to all the involved BTSs  20 , the assessment portion  32  of the BSC  30  of  FIG. 6  may produce three individual BTS selection messages (BSMs) for transmission to the involved BTSs  20  via their respective fixed communications paths  5   1  to  5   3 . Each BSM instructs the receiving BTS  20  directly either to transmit or not to transmit a subsequently-received uplink signal back to the BSC  30 . In this way, since it is the BSC  30  which is making the decision for all BTSs  20  involved in the soft hand-off, there is an inherent consistency in the actions taken by the path disabling portions  28  of each BTS  20  when selecting communications paths for uplink signal transmission. 
   In the embodiment of the present invention described above the communications path assessment portion  32  is contained within the BSC  30 , and the path disabling portion  28  is contained within the BTS  20 , but it will also be appreciated that other possibilities exist. 
   For example, there may be an assessment portion contained within the BTS  20  which may be used for deciding whether or not to transmit uplink signals to the BSC  30 . If, for example, the communications path  5  from a particular BTS  20  to the BSC  30  is of a type not suitable for transmission of, say, video data, then when that particular BTS  20  determines that an uplink signal received by it from a mobile station contains video data, that BTS  20  may decide not to transmit the uplink signal to the BSC  30 . Consequently, an assessment portion contained within the BTS  20  could instruct the path disabling portion  28  directly not to transmit the uplink signal. 
   Also, although the embodiment described above is used to restrict the transmission of uplink signals from BTS  20  to BSC  30 , it is possible alternatively (or in addition) to restrict the transmission of downlink signals from the BSC  30  to the BTS  20  via the fixed-network communications paths  5  based on the communications path performances of those different communications paths. In this case the path disabling portion  28  would be located in the BSC  30 . The assessment portion could also be located in the BSC  30  but could possibly be located in the BTSs  20  or even be distributed with a part of it in each BTS  20  and a part of it in the BSC  30 . 
   It is of course possible to have separate communications paths between the BTSs and the BSC for the uplink and downlink directions. 
   In the embodiments of the present invention described above, it was assumed that only one communications path was available between each BTS  20  and the BSC  30 . Therefore selecting a particular BTS  20  was equivalent to selecting the communications path associated with BTS  20 . It is possible, however, to have more than one available communications path between a BTS  20  and the BSC  30  (for example, both a fibre optic and microwave link may be available). In that case, the above-mentioned BTS selection message (BSM) should be a communication path selection message, and similarly the ranking message RM would contain rankings for each communications path available to each BTS. 
   Although the present invention has been described above in relation to the proposed European wideband. CDMA system (UTRA) it will be appreciated that it can also be applied to a system otherwise in accordance with the IS95 standard. It would also be possible to apply the invention in other cellular networks not using CDMA, for example networks using one or more of the following multiple-access techniques: time-division multiple access (TDMA), wavelength-division multiple access (WDMA), frequency-division multiple access (FDMA) and space-division multiple access (SDMA).

Technology Category: 5