Task: songer_procedur

What follows is an opinion from a United States Court of Appeals. Your task is to determine whether there was an issue discussed in the opinion of the court about the interpretation of federal rule of procedures, judicial doctrine, or case law, and if so, whether the resolution of the issue by the court favored the appellant.

ROBB, Associate Justice.
Appeal from a decision of the Patent Office, refusing the 13 claims of an application for patent on a seamless, tubular, knitted fabric (a stocking), and thq process of knitting the same.
We have carefully examined the decisions of the Primary Examiner ánd the Examiners in Chief, in which these claims are considered with reference to the prior art, and are convinced of the correctness of their conclusions, affirmed by the decision of the Assistant Commissioner. Not deeming it necessary to restate the reasoning of the Patent Office, we affirm the decision, without more.
Affirmed.

Question: Did the interpretation of federal rule of procedures, judicial doctrine, or case law by the court favor the appellant?
A. No
B. Yes
C. Mixed answer
D. Issue not discussed
Answer:

Answer: D