Title: THURSTON v. HINE
Citation: 139 P. 12 5, 1913 OK 716, 40 Okla. 465
Docket Number: 
State: Oklahoma
Issuer: Oklahoma Supreme Court
Date: December 16, 1913

THURSTON v. HINE Annotate this Case THURSTON v. HINE 1913 OK 716 139 P. 125 40 Okla. 465 Case Number: 5006 Decided: 12/16/1913 Supreme Court of Oklahoma THURSTON, County Treas., v. HINE. Syllabus ¶0 COLLECTION OF TAXES-- Injunction--Former Opinion Followed. Reversed and remanded, upon authority of Thurston, County Treas., v. Caldwell et al., ante, 137 P. 683. Wayne Wadlington, Co. Atty., and Warren K. Snyder, for plaintiff in error. J. W. Hocker, for defendant in error. KANE, J. ¶1 This was a suit in equity, commenced by Lewis T. Hine for the purpose of enjoining the plaintiff in error, defendant below, as county treasurer of McClain county, from collecting or attempting to collect an assessment for taxes imposed upon certain real estate belonging to said defendant in error, situated in the city of Purcell. A demurrer was filed to the petition of the plaintiff below, which was overruled by the court, and, the defendant declining to plead further, the court below, without any evidence or proof, adjudged and decreed that the county treasurer should be perpetually enjoined from attempting to enforce the payment of said taxes as prayed for, to reverse which order this proceeding in error was commenced. It is stipulated between the parties that the briefs filed by them in Thurston, County Treas., v. Caldwell et al., ante, 137 P. 683, are to be considered in this case. As it seems to be conceded that the questions involved in both cases are identical, on the authority of the former, this case must be reversed and remanded, with directions to proceed in conformity with the views expressed in Thurston, County Treas., v. Caldwell et al., supra. ¶2 All the Justices concur.