Title: SHIELDS v. SAND SPRINGS RY. CO.
Citation: 150 Okla. 177, 1931 OK 397, 1 P.2d 144
Docket Number: 
State: Oklahoma
Issuer: Oklahoma Supreme Court
Date: June 30, 1931

SHIELDS v. SAND SPRINGS RY. CO. Annotate this Case SHIELDS v. SAND SPRINGS RY. CO. 1931 OK 397 1 P.2d 144 150 Okla. 177 Case Number: 19484 Decided: 06/30/1931 Supreme Court of Oklahoma SHIELDS v. SAND SPRINGS RY. CO. Syllabus ¶0 Appeal and Error--Trial--Directed Verdict for Defendant Held Error. Action of the lower court in taking the case from the consideration of the jury is reversed, with directions to the lower court to award a new trial. Appeal from District Court, Tulsa County; R. D. Hudson, Judge. Action by Hulda Shields against Sand Springs Railway Company. Judgment for defendant, and plaintiff appeals. Reversed, with directions. Font L. Allen, M. A. Breckinridge, and Charles R. Bostick, for plaintiff in error. C. B. Stuart, Charles A. Coakley, E. J. Doerner, and P. P. Pinkerton, for defendant in error. KORNEGAY, J. ¶1 This was an accident case originating near the city of Tulsa, Okla., where the highway crossed the track of the defendant railroad corporation. ¶2 The trial court took the case from the jury. There was some evidence of a failure to give warning of the approach of the train that was sufficient to have taken it to the jury on the subject of primary negligence.