Title: UTLEY v. PHELAN
Citation: 168 Okla. 411, 1934 OK 344, 33 P.2d 498
Docket Number: 
State: Oklahoma
Issuer: Oklahoma Supreme Court
Date: June 5, 1934

UTLEY v. PHELAN Annotate this Case UTLEY v. PHELAN 1934 OK 344 33 P.2d 498 168 Okla. 411 Case Number: 25369 Decided: 06/05/1934 Supreme Court of Oklahoma UTLEY et al. v. PHELAN et al. Syllabus ¶0 Master and Servant--Workmen's Compensation--Review of Awards--Disposition of Cause Upon Confession of Error. In a proceeding to review an award of the State Industrial Commission, when the claimant respondent files a confession of error and the record and authorities reasonably support said confession of error, this court may in its discretion remand the cause to the State Industrial Commission with instructions to vacate the award in accordance with the said confession of error. Original proceedings in the Supreme Court by Jerome A. Utley et al. to review an award of the State Industrial Commission made to John Phelan. Award vacated. Twyford & Smith, for petitioners. C. S. McCuistion, J. Berry King, Atty. Gen., and Robt. D. Crowe, Asst. Atty. Gen., for respondents. PER CURIAM. ¶1 The claimant herein was injured while in the employ of Jerome A. Utley on the United States Reservation at Fort Sill. The employer, together with the insurance company, filed this proceeding, contesting the jurisdiction of the State Industrial Commission in the proceeding, and after the petition had been filed in this court, and on May 14, 1934, the respondent filed the following statement: "Respondents herein, having carefully searched the authorities to determine whether or not the State Industrial Commission had jurisdiction of the injury sustained by John Phelan on the Fort Sill Military Reservation, have reached the conclusion that the brief of the petitioners herein cannot be successfully answered, and we conclude that the State Industrial Commission was without jurisdiction or authority to pass upon the claim of the claimant, John Phelan." ¶2 In the case of Harbour Longmire Co. et al. v. Owrey, 167 Okla. 417, 30 P.2d 163 , the syllabus states: "In a proceeding to review an award of the State Industrial Commission, when the claimant, respondent, files a confession of error and the record and authorities reasonably support said confession of error, this court may in its discretion remand the cause to the State Industrial Commission, with instructions to vacate the award in accordance with said confession of error."