Case Title: City and County of Honolulu v. Sherman

Citation: 

Docket Number: 

State: hawaii

Court: Hawaii Supreme Court

Date: 2006-03-22T00:00:00Z

Document:
LAW LIBRARY

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF HAWAI'T

 

000

 

 

it
2b ava uid

CITY AND COUNTY OF HONOLULU, 2 municipal corporation of
‘of Hawaii, ei
Plaintif£-Appellee/Cross-Appellant /Cross~Appel le¥g|

aaa

 

JAMES M. SHERMAN, also known as James Malcolm Sherman, and AKIKO
'S. SHERMAN, also known as Akiko Sakiyama Sherman, as Trustees
under that certain unrecorded James M. Sherman and Akiko S.
Sherman Revocable Trust dated May 2, 1989; JAN CAMILLE BELLINGER,
‘Trustee under the Jan Camille Bellinger Revocable Living Trust,
under that certain unrecorded Trust, Agreement dated Novenber 23,
1993, CLARENCE K. LEE, as Trustee of and for the Clarence K. Lee
Revocable Trust, under that certain unrecorded Trust Agreenent
dated January 28, 1992, as amended; and MYRNA P. CHUN-HOON,
Successor ‘Trustee under that certain unrecorded Revocable Trust
of Albert C.K. Chun-Hoon dated October 11, 1984, as amended, and
MYRNA P. CHUN-HOON, Trustee under that certain unrecorded
Revocable Trust of Myrna P. Chun-Hoon, dated October 11, 1984, as
amended, GEORGE 8. GARIS, also known as George Benjamin Garis, as
Trustee under that certain unrecorded George B. Garis Revocable
Trust dated November 28, 1989, as amended; CHINH TRONG LE: KAREN
WILSON ROSA; ELIZABETH W. TAKAHASHI, Trustee of the Elizabeth W.
‘Takahashi Revocable Living Trust under that certain unrecorded
‘Trust Agreement dated July 14, 1993, STUART EDWIN GROSS, as
‘Trustee under that certain unrecorded Trust Agreement known as
‘The Stuart E. Gross Trust dated February 19, 1985, and MARCIA
KURZWEIL GROSS, as Trustee under that certain unrecorded Trust
Agreement known as The Marcia K. Gross Trust dated February 19,
1985; JOHN PHILIP SPIERLING; MARK SPERRY and MOLLIE SPERRY, Co-
Trustees of the Mark Sperry Revocable Trust dated May 29, 1989,
‘and MOLLIE SPERRY AND MARK SPERRY, Co-Trustees of The Mollie
Sperry Revocable Trust dated May 29, 1989; SAYURI TANIGUCHI and
ERICA TANIGUCHI DORMAN; KENNETH GRAHAM PATTERSON and LILLIAN
PAPACOLAS PATTERSON; MOSES MOSAI LO and SHEILA DICKENSON LO;
FRANK K. NIN, also known as Frank Kui Pong Min, and ELAINE N.
MIN, also known as Elaine Nan Min, Trustees under that certain
Trust Agreement dated April 9, 1985, and ELAINE N. MIN, also
known as Elaine Nam Min and FRANK K. MIN, also known as Frank Kui
Pong Min, Trustees under that certain Trust Agreement dated April
9, 1985; ARTHUR R. KING, JR., and RUTH MILDRED KING, Co-Trustees
cf the unrecorded Arthur R. King, Jr. Trust Agreement dated May
38, 1990; and RUTH MILDRED KING and ARTHUR R. KING, Co-Trustees
of the unrecorded Ruth Mildred King Trust Agreement dated May 18,
1990; DEANNA LOU LEVY, as Trustee under that certain unrecorded

 
‘Trust Agreement known as The Deanna Lou Levy Revocable Trust
dated December 4, 1990; ROBERT G. LEES and YUKO LEES, Co-Trustees
under that certain unrecorded Trust Agreement known as The Yuko
Lees Trust dated June 14, 2000; ELISABETH KEHRER ANDERSON, as
Trustee of the Elisabeth Kehrer Anderson Revocable Living Trust
Agreement dated June 29, 1981, as amended and restated; RAMEZ
BASSIR; PAUL JOHN CASEY, as Trustee under that certain unrecorded
Self-Trusteed Trust dated August 31, 1987, and JANICE YOKO CASEY,
‘as Trustee under that certain unrecorded Self-Trusteed Trust
dated May 20, 1988: GEORGE HENRY LUMSDEN and JOANNE CHUN LUMSDEN;
‘ANN TAKAKO YAMAMOTO, as Trustee of the Self-Trusteed Trust
‘Agreement of Ann Takako Yamamoto, under unrecorded Trust
Agreement of Ann Takako Yamamoto dated April 10, 2000; FRANCES M.
WATANABE, Trustee under that certain unrecorded Frances M.
Watanabe Revocable Trust dated April 2, 1993, MBREDITH KWOCK
LEONG PANG; NETL SIMMS BELLINGER, Trustee under that certain
unrecorded Neil S. Bellinger Revocable Living Trust dated
November 20, 20027 WALLACE LEE YOUNG and ERNESTINE CHING YOUNG;
JOYCE A HAGIN and LAWRENCE REICH; DAVID PATRICK KELLY and KEIKO
KELLY; PATRICIA CARLEEN BROWN, Trustee for the Patricia Carleen
Brown Revocable Trust Agreement dated January 21, 1993; RANDY
NEIL YEAGER and SUSAN KAYCIE YEAGER; and GAIL SUZANNE KOGLMAN,
Defendants-Appel lant s/Cross-Appel lees,

 

 

 

  

 

and

FIRST UNITED METHODIST CHURCH, a Hawaii non-profit corporation,
Defendant Appellee /Cross-Appel lee/Cross-Appellant,

and
JOHN DOE 1-200; MARY DOE 1-200; DOE PARTNERSHIP 1-100; DOE

CORPORATION 1-100; DOE NON-PROFIT CORPORATION 1-100; DOE ENTITY
1-100, Defendants.

 

No. 26896

APPEAL FROM THE FIRST CIRCUIT COURT
(CIV. NO. 03-1-0963)

MARCH 22, 2006
ORDER OF CORRECTION
(By: Levinson, J.)

‘The opinion of the court, filed on February 28, 2006,

is hereby corrected as to the following (text to be deleted is

stricken and text to be added is bracketed):

Page 12, line 1:

Regarding the requisite mintem [minimum] number (of)
qualifying

Pas an ne 5:

for [from] a zoning regulation or landnarking lew.
Page 50, second pargraph, line 11:

expressly stated in ROH § 38-2.4(4)," see supra note #2 [11]
at the

thi raph.

supra note #2 [11], to mean that a lessee may not own fee
simple

Page 53, first paragraph, line 1:

reponse [to] the lessees’ argument that the filing date of
a lessee’s

Page 56, first paragraph, line 2:

DCS Rules § 2-3 dmpermizetbte [impermissibly] lowered the
minimum nurber of

Page 76, second paragraph, line 3:

qualifications of the lessees. Pursuant to ROH ${§] 38-1.7
and

‘The Clerk of the Court is directed to incorporate the

foregoing changes in the original opinion.

   
 
 

STEVEN H. Li