Case Title: Lee v. Lee

Citation: 2019 ND 142

Docket Number: 20180382

State: north-dakota

Court: North Dakota Supreme Court

Date: 2019-05-16T00:00:00Z

Document:
)LOHG E\&OHUNRI6XSUHPH&RXUW ,17+(6835(0(&2857 67$7(2)1257+'$.27$  1' %UXFH:D\QH/HH 3ODLQWLIIDQG$SSHOODQW Y .LPEHUO\0DULH/HH 'HIHQGDQWDQG$SSHOOHH 1R $SSHDOIURPWKH'LVWULFW&RXUWRI*UDQG)RUNV&RXQW\1RUWKHDVW&HQWUDO -XGLFLDO'LVWULFWWKH+RQRUDEOH/ROLWD*+DUWO5RPDQLFN-XGJH $)),50(' 2SLQLRQRIWKH&RXUWE\-HQVHQ-XVWLFH 3DWWL--HQVHQ(DVW*UDQG)RUNV01IRUSODLQWLIIDQGDSSHOODQW VXEPLWWHG RQEULHI 5REHUW-6FKXOW])DUJR1'IRUGHIHQGDQWDQGDSSHOOHH VXEPLWWHGRQEULHI /HHY/HH 1R -HQVHQ-XVWLFH >@ %UXFH:D\QH/HHDSSHDOVIURPDILQDOMXGJPHQWDQGGHFUHHRIGLYRUFHHQWHUHG RQ$XJXVWGLVVROYLQJKLVPDUULDJHWR.LPEHUO\0DULH/HH2QDSSHDO %UXFH DUJXHV WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW HUUHG LQ LWV YDOXDWLRQ RI PDULWDO DVVHWV DQG WKH DOORFDWLRQRIWKHPDULWDOHVWDWH%UXFHDOVRFRQWHQGVKHZDVSUHMXGLFHGE\WKHGLVWULFW FRXUW¶VVL[PRQWKGHOD\LQLVVXLQJDILQDOMXGJPHQW:HDIILUP , >@ %UXFH:D\QH/HHDQG.LPEHUO\0DULH/HHEHJDQFRKDELWDWLQJLQ2FWREHU 7KHFRXSOHFRKDELWDWHGXQWLOWKH\ZHUHPDUULHGRQ6HSWHPEHU7KH SDUWLHVKDGUHVLGHGWRJHWKHUIRUDSSUR[LPDWHO\\HDUVDWWKHWLPHRIGLYRUFH >@ 7KHSDUWLHVKDGDQRZQHUVKLSLQWHUHVWLQUHDOHVWDWHFRPSULVHGRIIDUPODQGDQG DPDULWDOKRPH%UXFHSXUFKDVHGWKHIDUPODQGIURPKLVPRWKHUXQGHUWKHWHUPVRID FRQWUDFWIRUGHHGLQ6HSWHPEHU 7KHFRQWUDFWIRUGHHGZDVSDLGRIILQ-XQH 'XULQJWKHSDUWLHV¶PDUULDJH%UXFHDQG.LPEHUO\PDGHSD\PHQWVRQWKH FRQWUDFWIRUGHHGWR%UXFH¶VPRWKHU7KHFRXSOHDOVRPDGHSD\PHQWVGXULQJWKHIRXU \HDUVSULRUWRWKHLUPDUULDJH7KHSDUWLHVWRRNRXWDPRUWJDJHRQWKHIDUPODQGWR ILQDQFHEXLOGLQJWKHLUPDULWDOKRPHGXULQJWKHLUPDUULDJH >@ %UXFH DQG .LPEHUO\ HYHQWXDOO\ VROG WKHLU IDUPODQG DQG KRPHWR %UXFH¶V FKLOGUHQYLDDFRQWUDFWIRUGHHG%UXFHDQG.LPEHUO\UHWDLQDOLIHHVWDWHLQWKH IDUPODQGDOORZLQJWKHPWRUHFHLYHUHQWDQGOLYHLQWKHKRPHIRUWKHUHVWRIWKHLUOLYHV 8QGHUWKHFRQWUDFWIRUGHHG%UXFH¶VWKUHHFKLOGUHQZHUHWRSD\%UXFHDQG.LPEHUO\ SHUPRQWKIRUPRQWKV%UXFH¶VFKLOGUHQKDYHQRWPDGHDOORIWKHSD\PHQWV UHTXLUHGXQGHUWKHFRQWUDFWIRUGHHG%UXFHDFNQRZOHGJHGKLVFKLOGUHQKDGPLVVHG VHYHUDOSD\PHQWVEXWWHVWLILHGKHIRUJDYHVRPHRIWKHGHEWWRHDFKRIKLVFKLOGUHQ .LPEHUO\WHVWLILHGLQKHURSLQLRQWKHFKLOGUHQVWLOORZHGWKHFRXSOHPRQH\  >@ %UXFHWHVWLILHGWKHKRPHKDGDYDOXHRIDQGDVVHUWHGWKHODQGKDGD YDOXHRIFRQVLGHULQJWKHOLIHHVWDWHLQWHUHVWRZQHGE\WKHSDUWLHV.LPEHUO\ WHVWLILHG WKH YDOXH RI WKH KRPH ZDV   DQG WKH ODQG VKRXOG EH YDOXHG DW  .LPEHUO\DOVRFODLPHGWKH UHPDLQLQJRQWKHFRQWUDFWIRUGHHG VKRXOGEHLQFOXGHGDVSDUWRIWKHPDULWDOHVWDWH7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWYDOXHGWKHOLIH HVWDWHLQWHUHVWLQWKHKRPHDWDQGWKHYDOXHRIWKHOLIHHVWDWHLQWKHODQGDW  IRUDWRWDOYDOXHRI7KHFRXUWDOVRDVVLJQHGDYDOXHRI  WRWKHSD\PHQWVUHPDLQLQJRQWKHFRQWUDFWIRUGHHG%UXFHDUJXHVWKHGLVWULFWFRXUW HUUHGLQLWVYDOXDWLRQDQGGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHUHDOHVWDWHZKHQLWLQFOXGHGWKHOLIHHVWDWH LQWKHKRPHDQGODQGDVZHOODVWKHSD\PHQWVUHPDLQLQJRQWKHFRQWUDFWIRUGHHG %UXFHDOVRDUJXHVWKHFRXUWHUUHGLQLWVYDOXDWLRQRID%REFDW6NLG6WHHUDQGE\ LQFOXGLQJDUHFHLYDEOHRIRZHGE\%UXFH¶VFKLOGUHQLQWKHPDULWDOHVWDWH )LQDOO\%UXFHFRQWHQGVKHZDVSUHMXGLFHGE\WKHFRXUW¶VVL[PRQWKGHOD\LQLVVXLQJ DILQDOMXGJPHQW ,, >@ %UXFHDUJXHVWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWHUUHGLQLWVYDOXDWLRQRIWKHUHDOHVWDWHZKHQLW LQFOXGHGWKHSD\PHQWVUHPDLQLQJXQGHUWKHFRQWUDFWIRUGHHGLQWKHYDOXHRIWKHUHDO SURSHUW\7KLV&RXUWZLOOQRWUHYHUVHDGLVWULFWFRXUW¶VILQGLQJVRQYDOXDWLRQRIPDULWDO SURSHUW\XQOHVVWKH\DUHFOHDUO\HUURQHRXVCorbett v. Corbett1' 1:G³$ILQGLQJRIIDFWLVFOHDUO\HUURQHRXVLILWLVLQGXFHGE\DQ HUURQHRXVYLHZRIWKHODZWKHUHLVQRHYLGHQFHWRVXSSRUWLWRULIDOWKRXJKWKHUHLV VRPHHYLGHQFHWRVXSSRUWLWRQWKHHQWLUHHYLGHQFHWKHUHYLHZLQJFRXUWLVOHIWZLWKD GHILQLWHDQGILUPFRQYLFWLRQDPLVWDNHKDVEHHQPDGH´Kautzman v. Kautzman  1' 1:G³$FKRLFHEHWZHHQWZRSHUPLVVLEOHYLHZVRIWKH HYLGHQFHLVQRWFOHDUO\HUURQHRXVLIWKH>GLVWULFW@FRXUW¶VILQGLQJVDUHEDVHGHLWKHURQ SK\VLFDORUGRFXPHQWDU\HYLGHQFHRULQIHUHQFHVIURPRWKHUIDFWVRURQFUHGLELOLW\ GHWHUPLQDWLRQV´Hoverson v. Hoverson1' 1:G7KH YDOXHDGLVWULFWFRXUWSODFHVRQPDULWDOSURSHUW\GHSHQGVRQWKHHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHGE\  WKHSDUWLHVFox v. Fox1'1:G7KLV&RXUWSUHVXPHVD GLVWULFWFRXUW¶VSURSHUW\YDOXDWLRQVDUHFRUUHFWHoversonDW >@ +HUHWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWXVHGILQDQFLQJVWDWHPHQWVVLJQHGE\%UXFHWRGHWHUPLQH WKHYDOXHRIWKHKRPHDQGWKHODQG7KHFRXUWWKHQDSSOLHGWKHOLIHHVWDWHIUDFWLRQDO PXOWLSOLHUFRGLILHGLQ1'$GPLQ&RGHLQFRPLQJWRLWVYDOXDWLRQ RIWKHKRPHDQGODQG7KHFRXUWZHQWRQWRYDOXHWKHFRQWUDFWIRUGHHGEDVHGRQWKH UHPDLQLQJDPRXQWOHIWWREHSDLGE\%UXFH¶VFKLOGUHQDQGDGGHGWKLVDPRXQWWRWKH PDULWDOHVWDWH%UXFHFRQWHQGVWKHDGGLWLRQRIWKHDPRXQWUHPDLQLQJRQWKHFRQWUDFW IRUGHHGUHVXOWVLQDSURSHUW\YDOXDWLRQLQH[FHVVRIDQ\HYLGHQFHUHFHLYHGE\WKH FRXUW >@ 7KLV&RXUWKDVQRWSUHYLRXVO\GLVFXVVHGWKHYDOXDWLRQRIDOLIHHVWDWHDVD PDULWDODVVHWLQDGLYRUFHSURFHHGLQJ6HFWLRQ1'$GPLQ&RGH FRQFHUQV0HGLFDLGDQGJLYHVJXLGDQFHRQKRZWRYDOXHDOLIHHVWDWHIRUWKHSXUSRVH RI0HGLFDLGHOLJLELOLW\6HFWLRQ1'$GPLQ&RGHFRQWDLQVDWDEOH ZKLFKSURYLGHVDPXOWLSOLHUEDVHGRQWKHSDUW\¶VDJHDQGW\SHRISURSHUW\LQWHUHVW +HUHWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWVHOHFWHGWKHDSSURSULDWHDJHLQWKHWDEOHDQGPXOWLSOLHGWKH FRUUHVSRQGLQJOLIHHVWDWH³GHFLPDOIUDFWLRQ´E\LWVYDOXDWLRQRIWKHSURSHUW\7KH FRXUW¶VYDOXDWLRQRIWKHOLIHHVWDWHZDVQRWLQGXFHGE\DQHUURQHRXVYLHZRIWKHODZ ZDVZLWKLQWKHUDQJHRIHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHGDWWULDODQGWKLV&RXUWLVQRWOHIWZLWKD GHILQLWHDQGILUPFRQYLFWLRQDPLVWDNHKDVEHHQPDGH7KHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHOLIHHVWDWH LQWKHUHDOSURSHUW\ZDVQRWFOHDUO\HUURQHRXV > @ 7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWDGGHGWKHYDOXHRIWKHSD\PHQWVUHPDLQLQJXQGHUWKHFRQWUDFW IRUGHHGWRWKHYDOXHRIWKHOLIHHVWDWH7KHYDOXDWLRQRIUHPDLQLQJSD\PHQWVXQGHU WKHFRQWUDFWIRUGHHGZDVZLWKLQWKHHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHGE\WKHSDUWLHV³$SURSHUW\ YDOXDWLRQZLWKLQWKHUDQJHRIHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHGDWWULDOLVQRWFOHDUO\HUURQHRXV´ Jacobs-Raak v. Raak1'1:G+DGWKHFRXSOHUHPDLQHG WRJHWKHU.LPEHUO\ZRXOGKDYHHQMR\HGDOLIHHVWDWHLQWKHKRPHDVZHOODVWKHOLIH HVWDWHLQWKHIDUPODQGHQWLWOLQJWKHSDUWLHVWRUHQWDOLQFRPHIURPWKHIDUPODQGGXULQJ  WKHLUOLIHWLPH7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWSURSHUO\TXDQWLILHGWKHOLIHHVWDWHLQWKHKRPHDQG IDUPODQGDVGLVFXVVHGDERYH,QDGGLWLRQWRWKHOLIHHVWDWHWKHSDUWLHVDUHDOVRHQWLWOHG WRUHFHLYHWKHUHPDLQLQJSD\PHQWVRQWKHFRQWUDFWIRUGHHG7KHWZRDVVHWVDUH VHSDUDWHDQGGLVWLQFWDQGLWZDVQRWHUURUWRYDOXHHDFKVHSDUDWHO\DQGDGGWKHP WRJHWKHU7KHGLVWULFWFRXUW¶VYDOXDWLRQZDVQRWLQGXFHGE\DQHUURQHRXVYLHZRIWKH ODZZDVZLWKLQWKHUDQJHRIHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHGDWWULDODQGWKLV&RXUWLVQRWOHIWZLWK DGHILQLWHDQGILUPFRQYLFWLRQDPLVWDNHKDVEHHQPDGH7KHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHUHDO SURSHUW\ZDVQRWFOHDUO\HUURQHRXV >@ %UXFHDOVRDUJXHVWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWHUUHGLQLWVYDOXDWLRQRID%REFDW6NLG 6WHHU7KHFRXUWKHDUGWHVWLPRQ\IURPERWKSDUWLHVDVWRWKHLURSLQLRQRIWKHYDOXHRI WKH%REFDW%UXFHYDOXHGWKH%REFDWDW DQGVXEPLWWHGDQHVWLPDWHIURPD %REFDWGHDOHUUHIOHFWLQJWKHVDPH.LPEHUO\WHVWLILHGVKHEHOLHYHGWKH%REFDWZDV ZRUWK%UXFHKDGSUHYLRXVO\OLVWHGWKHYDOXHRIWKH%REFDWDQGDWWDFKPHQWV DWRQDSHUVRQDOILQDQFLDOVWDWHPHQW,QLWVYDOXDWLRQRIWKH%REFDWWKHFRXUW QRWHGWKHGRFXPHQWDWLRQUHOLHGRQE\%UXFHIDLOHGWRLQFOXGHWKHDWWDFKPHQWVWKRXJK KHWHVWLILHGKHKDGLQFOXGHGWKHDWWDFKPHQWVLQKLVHVWLPDWH7KHFRXUWGLGQRWILQG %UXFH¶VWHVWLPRQ\FUHGLEOHDQGLQWXUQXVHG.LPEHUO\¶VHVWLPDWHZKLFKZDVIRXQG WREHPRUHFUHGLEOH7KHFRXUW¶VYDOXDWLRQZDVQRWLQGXFHGE\DQHUURQHRXVYLHZRI WKHODZZDVZLWKLQWKHUDQJHRIHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHGDWWULDODQGWKLV&RXUWLVQRWOHIW ZLWKDGHILQLWHDQGILUPFRQYLFWLRQDPLVWDNHKDVEHHQPDGH7KHYDOXDWLRQRIWKH %REFDWZDVQRWFOHDUO\HUURQHRXV >@ %UXFHDUJXHVWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWHUUHGZKHQLWLQFOXGHGDUHFHLYDEOHFRQVLVWLQJ RIGHOLQTXHQWFRQWUDFWIRUGHHGSD\PHQWVRZHGE\%UXFH¶VFKLOGUHQLQWKHPDULWDO HVWDWH7KHH[LVWHQFHRIWKHUHFHLYDEOHZDVDFRQWHVWHGLVVXHDWWULDO%UXFHWHVWLILHG KHIRUJDYHSD\PHQWVWRUHFRJQL]HZRUNWKDWKDGEHHQGRQHE\KLVFKLOGUHQ.LPEHUO\ WHVWLILHGVKHEHOLHYHGWKHFKLOGUHQVWLOORZHGWKHSD\PHQWV7KHFRXUWIRXQGEHFDXVH WKHFRQWUDFWIRUGHHGZDVHQWHUHGLQWRZLWKERWK%UXFHDQG.LPEHUO\%UXFHGLGQRW KDYH XQLODWHUDO SRZHU WR IRUJLYH WKHVH SD\PHQWV DQG WKH DPRXQW ZDV SURSHUO\  LQFOXGHGLQWKHPDULWDOHVWDWH7KHGLVWULFWFRXUW¶VILQGLQJZDVDFKRLFHEHWZHHQWZR SHUPLVVLEOHYLHZVRIWKHHYLGHQFHEDVHGRQLQIHUHQFHVIURPRWKHUIDFWVDQGRURQ FUHGLELOLW\GHWHUPLQDWLRQVDQGZDVWKHUHIRUHVXSSRUWHGE\DSHUPLVVLEOHIRXQGDWLRQ Hoverson,  1'      1:G   7KH FRXUW¶V LQFOXVLRQ RI WKH UHFHLYDEOHLQWKHPDULWDOHVWDWHZDVQRWLQGXFHGE\DQHUURQHRXVYLHZRIWKHODZZDV ZLWKLQWKHUDQJHRIHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHGDWWULDODQGWKLV&RXUWLVQRWOHIWZLWKDGHILQLWH DQGILUPFRQYLFWLRQDPLVWDNHKDVEHHQPDGH7KHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHPDULWDOHVWDWHWR LQFOXGHWKHFRQWUDFWIRUGHHGSD\PHQWVZDVQRWFOHDUO\HUURQHRXV ,,, >@ %UXFHDUJXHVWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWGLGQRWFRQVLGHUWKHVRXUFHRIWKHUHDOHVWDWH ZKHQPDNLQJLWVGLVWULEXWLRQ³>$@WULDOFRXUWPXVWVWDUWZLWKDSUHVXPSWLRQWKDWDOO SURSHUW\KHOGE\HLWKHUSDUW\ZKHWKHUKHOGMRLQWO\RULQGLYLGXDOO\LVWREHFRQVLGHUHG PDULWDOSURSHUW\´Ulsaker v. White1'1:G³7KHWULDO FRXUWPXVWWKHQGHWHUPLQHWKHWRWDOYDOXHRIWKHPDULWDOHVWDWHLQRUGHUWRPDNHDQ HTXLWDEOHGLYLVLRQRISURSHUW\´Id.³$IWHUDIDLUHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHSURSHUW\LVPDGH WKHHQWLUHPDULWDOHVWDWHPXVWWKHQEHHTXLWDEO\GLYLGHGEHWZHHQWKHSDUWLHVXQGHUWKH Ruff-FischerJXLGHOLQHV´Id.7KHRuff-FischerJXLGHOLQHVUHTXLUHDGLVWULFWFRXUWWR FRQVLGHUWKHIROORZLQJIDFWRUVLQGHWHUPLQLQJKRZWRHTXLWDEO\GLYLGHWKHPDULWDO HVWDWH WKHUHVSHFWLYHDJHVRIWKHSDUWLHVWKHLUHDUQLQJDELOLW\WKHGXUDWLRQRI WKH PDUULDJH DQG FRQGXFW RI WKH SDUWLHV GXULQJ WKH PDUULDJH WKHLU VWDWLRQLQOLIHWKHFLUFXPVWDQFHVDQGQHFHVVLWLHVRIHDFKWKHLUKHDOWK DQGSK\VLFDOFRQGLWLRQWKHLUILQDQFLDOFLUFXPVWDQFHVDVVKRZQE\WKH SURSHUW\RZQHGDWWKHWLPHLWVYDOXHDWWKHWLPHLWVLQFRPHSURGXFLQJ FDSDFLW\LIDQ\ZKHWKHUDFFXPXODWHGEHIRUHRUDIWHUWKHPDUULDJHDQG VXFKRWKHUPDWWHUVDVPD\EHPDWHULDO7KHWULDOFRXUWLVQRWUHTXLUHGWR PDNH VSHFLILF ILQGLQJV EXW LW PXVW VSHFLI\ D UDWLRQDOH IRU LWV GHWHUPLQDWLRQ Schultz v. Schultz1'  1:G TXRWLQJBladow v. Bladow 1'1:G 7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWLVDOVRUHTXLUHGWRFRQVLGHU  WKHVRXUFHRIWKHSURSHUW\LQGHWHUPLQLQJDQHTXLWDEOHDOORFDWLRQRIWKHSDUWLHV¶PDULWDO SURSHUW\SchultzDW:KLOHWKHRULJLQRISURSHUW\PXVWEHFRQVLGHUHGWKHUHLV QRUHTXLUHPHQWWRVHWSURSHUW\DVLGHIRUDVSRXVHZKREULQJVSURSHUW\LQWRDPDUULDJH Grinaker v. Grinaker1:G 1'   >@ 7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWDFNQRZOHGJHGWKH³KLVWRU\´RIWKHUHDOHVWDWHLQLWVRUGHU 7KHFRXUW¶VRUGHUDOVRUHFRJQL]HG³>L@WZDVXQTXHVWLRQHGWKDWWKHSDUWLHVDOZD\V LQWHQGHGWKDWWKHUHDOHVWDWHZRXOGUHPDLQLQ%UXFH¶VIDPLO\´:KHQGLVFXVVLQJ GLVWULEXWLRQWKHFRXUW¶VRUGHUDOVRVWDWHV³WKLVODQGKDVEHHQKHOGIRUPDQ\PDQ\ \HDUVE\%UXFH¶VIDPLO\DQGLVDIDFWRULQDOORFDWLQJERWKWKHUHDOHVWDWHDQGWKHGHEWV DJDLQVWWKHUHDOHVWDWHWR%UXFH´7KHFRXUWZHQWRQWRDZDUG%UXFHWKHUHDOHVWDWHDQG DQRIIVHWWLQJHTXDOL]DWLRQSD\PHQWWR.LPEHUO\7KHFRXUWXQHTXLYRFDOO\FRQVLGHUHG WKHVRXUFHRIWKHSURSHUW\DVZHOODVWKHRuff-Fischer JXLGHOLQHVLQFRPLQJWRLWV GLVWULEXWLRQGHFLVLRQ7KHFRXUW¶VDOORFDWLRQRIPDULWDOSURSHUW\ZDVQRWLQGXFHGE\ DQHUURQHRXVYLHZRIWKHODZZDVZLWKLQWKHUDQJHRIWKHHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHGDQGWKLV &RXUWLVQRWOHIWZLWKDGHILQLWHDQGILUPFRQYLFWLRQDPLVWDNHKDVEHHQPDGH7KH GLVWULFWFRXUW¶VDOORFDWLRQRIPDULWDOSURSHUW\FRQVLGHUHGWKHVRXUFHRIWKHSURSHUW\DQG ZDVQRWFOHDUO\HUURQHRXV ,9 >@ %UXFHDUJXHVKHZDVSUHMXGLFHGE\WKHGLVWULFWFRXUW¶VVL[PRQWKGHOD\LQ LVVXLQJDILQDOMXGJPHQW%UXFHUHIHUHQFHVWKLV&RXUW¶VGRFNHWFXUUHQF\VWDQGDUGVLQ VXSSRUWRIKLVDUJXPHQWWKHUHZDVSUHMXGLFLDOGHOD\DQGQRWHVWKDWZKLOHWKHFDVH UHPDLQHGXQUHVROYHGKHFRQWLQXHGWRPDNHSD\PHQWVIRUWKHEHQHILWRI.LPEHUO\ XQGHUWKHWHUPVRIWKHSDUWLHV¶LQWHULPRUGHU >@ ,Q-XO\%UXFHEURXJKWDPRWLRQIRUHQWU\RIDWHPSRUDU\RUGHU2Q 2FWREHUSULRUWRWKHKHDULQJ.LPEHUO\DQG%UXFHUHDFKHGDQDJUHHPHQW ZKHUH.LPEHUO\ZRXOGKDYHXVHRIWKH6XEDUXDQG%UXFHZRXOGPDNHWKH PRQWKO\FDUSD\PHQWDORQJZLWKSURYLGLQJLQVXUDQFHFRYHUDJHIRUWKHYHKLFOH2Q 2FWREHUWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWLVVXHGDWHPSRUDU\RUGHUDGRSWLQJWKHSDUWLHV¶  DJUHHPHQW7KHILQDOGD\RIWULDOZDV-DQXDU\%UXFHDQG.LPEHUO\ERWK VXEPLWWHGFORVLQJVXPPDWLRQVRQ)HEUXDU\7KHLQWHULPRUGHUUHPDLQHGLQ SODFHXQWLOWKHGLVWULFWFRXUW¶VGHFLVLRQLQ-XO\ >@ $WWKHWLPHRIWKLVPDWWHU1'6XS&W$GPLQ5  D  SURYLGHVMXGJHV VKRXOGLVVXHMXGJPHQWV³ZLWKLQPRQWKVRIWKHGDWHWKHFRPSODLQWZDVILOHGRU ZLWKLQ GD\VRIWKHHQGRIWULDOZKLFKHYHULVHDUOLHU´7KHFXUUHQWUXOHSURYLGHVWKH GHFLVLRQVVKRXOGEHFRPSOHWHG GD\VIURPRUDODUJXPHQWODVWGD\RIWULDORUWKH ILOLQJRIWKHODVWEULHIZKLFKHYHULVODWHVW1'6XS&W$GPLQ5  E  7KLV FDVHEHJDQZLWKVHUYLFHRIWKHVXPPRQVDQGFRPSODLQWLQ-XQH7KHILQDOGD\ RIWULDOZDV-DQXDU\7KHILQDOEULHIVDQGSURSRVDOVZHUHVHUYHGRQ)HEUXDU\ $GHFLVLRQZDVQRWSURYLGHGXQWLO-XO\ >@ %UXFHDVVHUWVKHZDVSUHMXGLFHG E\WKHVXEVWDQWLDOGHOD\LQUHVROYLQJWKH SURFHHGLQJVDQGDOWKRXJKQRWZHOOGHILQHGDSSHDUVWRDUJXHWKHSUHMXGLFHZDVWKH FRQWLQXHGLQWHULPRUGHUSD\PHQWVKHPDGHRQEHKDOIRI.LPEHUO\%UXFHIDLOHGWR FOHDUO\DUWLFXODWHWKHUHPHG\KHLVVHHNLQJWRDGGUHVVWKHSUHMXGLFHFDXVHGE\WKH GHOD\ >@ *HQHUDOO\DGHOD\LVUHOHYDQWRQO\LQH[WUDRUGLQDU\FDVHVZKHQDVXEVWDQWLDO XQDQWLFLSDWHGFKDQJHLQYDOXDWLRQRIDQDVVHWRFFXUVSee Innis-Smith v. Smith 1'  1:G  see also Grinaker1:GDW $GGLWLRQDOO\ WKH³6WDWHPHQWRI3ROLF\´LQVHFWLRQRI1'6XS&W$GPLQ5VWDWHVWKHWLPH VWDQGDUGVDUH³JRDOV´DQGPD\QRWDIIHFWWKHVXEVWDQWLYHDQGSURFHGXUDOULJKWVRIWKH SDUWLHVLQDQ\FDVH6LPLODUODQJXDJHLVDOVRSUHVHQWLQWKHSUHYLRXVYHUVLRQRI1' 6XS &W $GPLQ 5   $OWKRXJK UHVROXWLRQ RI WKLV FDVH IHOO RXWVLGH RI RXU DGPLQLVWUDWLYHWLPHVWDQGDUGVWKDWDORQHLVLQVXIILFLHQWWRJUDQWUHOLHIDQG%UXFHKDV IDLOHGWRGHPRQVWUDWHWKLVLVDQH[WUDRUGLQDU\FDVHFRPSHOOLQJUHFRQVLGHUDWLRQRIWKH SURSHUW\GLYLVLRQ 9  > @ 7KHGLVWULFWFRXUW¶VSURSHUW\YDOXDWLRQVZHUHQRWFOHDUO\HUURQHRXV7KHFRXUW FRQVLGHUHGWKHVRXUFHRIWKHSURSHUW\DQGLWVXOWLPDWHGLVWULEXWLRQZDVQRWFOHDUO\ HUURQHRXV/DVWO\WKHFRXUW¶VVL[PRQWKGHOD\LQLVVXLQJDILQDOMXGJPHQWGRHVQRW ULVHWRWKHOHYHORIH[WUDRUGLQDU\DQGGRHVQRWFRPSHOUHFRQVLGHUDWLRQRIWKHSURSHUW\ GLYLVLRQ:HDIILUPWKHMXGJPHQWRIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUW >@ -RQ--HQVHQ 'DQLHO-&URWKHUV -HURG(7XIWH :LOOLDP$1HXPDQQ6- *HUDOG:9DQGH:DOOH&- >@ 7KH+RQRUDEOH:LOOLDP$1HXPDQQ6-VLWWLQJLQSODFHRI0F(YHUV- GLVTXDOLILHG 