Case Title: 366 Or 490-93 Petitions for Review

Citation: 

Docket Number: cdm17027

State: oregon

Court: Oregon Supreme Court

Date: 2020-05-21T00:00:00Z

Document:
490
PETITIONS FOR REVIEW
( P3d )
ALLOWED
May 21, 2020
State v. Hightower, Gregory Leon (A166654)(S067539)(301 Or App 750)
May 28, 2020
State v. Bailey, Douglas Paul (A169868)(S067584)(on summary affirmance). 
Petition for review allowed. The court accepts the state’s concession that 
defendant’s conviction on Count 1 must be reversed in light of Ramos v. 
Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S Ct 1930, __ L Ed 2d __ (2020). Decision of the 
Court of Appeals reversed; judgment of the circuit court reversed; and case 
remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings.
State v. Browning, James Lin (A167157)(S067575)(301 Or App 700). Petition for 
review allowed in part, limited to the issue of the appropriate disposition of 
this case in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S Ct 1390, __ L Ed 2d 
__ (2020); petition for review otherwise denied. The court accepts the state’s 
concession that defendant’s convictions on Counts 1-7 must be reversed. 
Decision of the Court of Appeals reversed in part; judgment of the circuit court 
reversed; and case remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings.
State v. Chorney-Phillips, Zackery Joshua (A167674)(S067557)(301 Or App 853). 
Petition for review allowed in part, limited to the issue of the appropriate 
disposition of this case in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S Ct 
1390, __ L Ed 2d __ (2020) (consolidate with State v. Ciraulo (S067569) for oral 
argument). Supplemental pro se petition for review denied.
State v. Ciraulo, Peter Anthony (A168211)(A168227)(S067569)(301 Or App 849). 
Petition for review allowed in part, limited to the issue of the appropriate 
disposition of this case in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S Ct 1390, 
__ L Ed 2d __ (2020) (consolidate with State v. Chorney-Phillips (S067557) for 
oral argument).
State v. Collier, Michael Timothy (A167343)(S066878)(on summary affirmance). 
Petition for review allowed. The court accepts the state’s concession that 
defendant’s convictions on Counts 1-5 must be reversed in light of Ramos v. 
Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S Ct 1390, __ L Ed 2d __ (2020). Decision of the 
Court of Appeals reversed; judgment of the circuit court reversed; and case 
remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings.
State v. De La Cruz, Andres Peon (A168441)(S067594)(302 Or App 653). Petition 
for review allowed in part, limited to the issue of the appropriate disposition 
of this case in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S Ct 1390, __ L 
Ed 2d __ (2020); petition for review otherwise denied. The court accepts the 
state’s concession that defendant’s conviction on Count 2 must be reversed. 
Decision of the Court of Appeals reversed in part; judgment of the circuit court 
reversed; and case remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings.
State v. Dilallo, Michael James (A168222)(S067493)(302 Or App 187, rev den, 366 
Or 382). Petition for review allowed in part on reconsideration, limited to the 
issue of the appropriate disposition of this case in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, 
__ US __, 140 S Ct 1390, __ L Ed 2d __ (2020).
PETITIONS FOR REVIEW — Continued	
491
( P3d )
State v. Eggleston, Kevin Ray (A164893)(S067627)(302 Or App 797). Petition for 
review allowed in part, limited to the issue of the appropriate disposition of 
this case in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S Ct 1390, __ L Ed 2d 
__ (2020); petition for review otherwise denied. The court accepts the state’s 
concession that defendant’s conviction on Count 1 must be reversed. Decision 
of the Court of Appeals reversed in part; judgment of the circuit court reversed; 
and case remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings. Supplemental 
pro se petition for review denied.
State v. Formby-Carter, Andrew Amelio (A163469)(S067647)(302 Or App 417). 
 
Petition for review allowed in part, limited to the issue of the appropriate 
disposition of this case in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S Ct 
1390, __ L Ed 2d __ (2020); petition for review otherwise denied. The court 
accepts the state’s concession that defendant’s conviction on Count 1 must be 
reversed. Decision of the Court of Appeals reversed; judgment of the circuit 
court reversed; and case remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings.
State v. Kincheloe, Charles Wesley (A167760)(S067611)(302 Or App 654). Petition 
for review allowed in part, limited to the issue of whether defendant’s 
convictions should be reversed in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S 
Ct 1390, __ L Ed 2d __ (2020) (consolidate with State v. Ramos (S067105) for 
oral argument).
State v. Kotila, Daniel Clayton (A167461)(S067289)(300 Or App 403). Petition 
for review allowed. The court accepts the state’s concession that defendant’s 
conviction on Count 1 must be reversed in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ 
US __, 140 S Ct 1390, __ L Ed 2d __ (2020). Decision of the Court of Appeals 
reversed in part; judgment of the circuit court reversed in part; and case 
remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings.
State v. Le, An Ngoc (A166302)(S067065)(298 Or App 494). Petition for review 
allowed in part, limited to the issue of the appropriate disposition of this case 
in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S Ct 1390, __ L Ed 2d __ (2020); 
petition for review otherwise denied. The court accepts the state’s concession 
that defendant’s convictions on Counts 1 and 2 must be reversed. Decision of 
the Court of Appeals reversed in part; judgment of the circuit court reversed; 
and case remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings.
State v. McNutt, Craig Alan (A162615)(S067055)(299 Or App 254). Petition for 
review allowed in part, limited to the issue of the appropriate disposition of 
this case in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S Ct 1390, __ L Ed 2d 
__ (2020); petition for review otherwise denied. The court accepts the state’s 
concession that defendant’s conviction on Count 1 must be reversed. Decision 
of the Court of Appeals reversed; judgment of the circuit court reversed; and 
case remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings.
State v. Newell, Myron Lee (A165492)(S066848)(298 Or App 142). Petition for 
review allowed in part, limited to the issue of the appropriate disposition of 
this case in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S Ct 1390, __ L Ed 2d 
__ (2020); petition for review otherwise denied. The court accepts the state’s 
concession that defendant’s conviction on Count 2 must be reversed. Decision 
of the Court of Appeals reversed in part; judgment of the circuit court reversed; 
and case remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings.
State v. Ramos, Isidro Flores (A167187)(S067105)(298 Or App 841). Petition for 
review allowed in part, limited to the issue of whether defendant’s convictions 
should be reversed in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S Ct 1390, 
__ L Ed 2d __ (2020) (consolidate with State v. Kincheloe (S067611) for oral 
argument).
492	
PETITIONS FOR REVIEW — Continued
( P3d )
State v. Richards, Roy Allen (A164142)(S066731)(296 Or App 225). Petition for 
review allowed in part, limited to the issue of the appropriate disposition of 
this case in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S Ct 1390, __ L Ed 2d 
__ (2020); petition for review otherwise denied. The court accepts the state’s 
concession that defendant’s convictions on Counts 1-10 must be reversed. 
Decision of the Court of Appeals reversed in part; judgment of the circuit court 
reversed; and case remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings.
State v. Riekens, Ronald Roy (A167148)(S067516)(301 Or App 447). Petition for 
review allowed. The court accepts the state’s concession that defendant’s 
conviction on Count 2 must be reversed in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ 
US __, 140 S Ct 1390, __ L Ed 2d __ (2020). Decision of the Court of Appeals 
reversed in part; judgment of the circuit court reversed; and case remanded to 
the circuit court for further proceedings.
State v. Rodriguez, Edgar (A167042)(S067486)(301 Or App 637). Petition for review 
allowed in part, limited to the issue of the appropriate disposition of this case 
in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ US __, 140 S Ct 1390, __ L Ed 2d __ (2020); 
petition for review otherwise denied. The court accepts the state’s concession 
that defendant’s conviction on Count 1 must be reversed. Decision of the Court 
of Appeals reversed in part; judgment of the circuit court reversed; and case 
remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings.
State v. Thomas, Dee Swiss, III (A168342)(S067331)(300 Or App 582). Petition 
for review allowed. The court accepts the state’s concession that defendant’s 
conviction on Count 1 must be reversed in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ 
US __, 140 S Ct 1390, __ L Ed 2d __ (2020). Decision of the Court of Appeals 
reversed; judgment of the circuit court reversed; and case remanded to the 
circuit court for further proceedings.
State v. Tohl, Trevor Nathan (A167184)(S067392)(300 Or App 573). Petition for 
review allowed. The court accepts the state’s concession that defendant’s 
conviction on Count 1 must be reversed in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ 
US __, 140 S Ct 1390, __ L Ed 2d __ (2020). Decision of the Court of Appeals 
reversed in part; judgment of the circuit court reversed; and case remanded to 
the circuit court for further proceedings.
State v. Weltch, Joshua Daniel (A166193)(S066729)(297 Or App 409). Petition 
for review allowed. The court accepts the state’s concession that defendant’s 
conviction on Count 1 must be reversed in light of Ramos v. Louisiana, __ 
US __, 140 S Ct 1930, __ L Ed 2d __ (2020). Decision of the Court of Appeals 
reversed; judgment of the circuit court reversed; and case remanded to the 
circuit court for further proceedings.
DENIED
May 21, 2020
Anderson, Evan Kiel v. Cain (A168473)(S067562)(301 Or App 699)
Central Oregon Landwatch v. Deschutes County (A172110)(S067465)(301 Or App 
701). Walters, C. J., and Flynn, J., would allow.
Clements, Timothy Allan v. Bowser (A167632)(S067527)(301 Or App 699)
Dayton v. Jordan (A166490)(S067550)(302 Or App 256)
Department of Human Services v. J. L. S. (A171942)(S067612)(302 Or App 653)
Derrick, Robert L. v. Laney (A166880)(S067481)(301 Or App 317)
Hodge, Shelby Warren v. Cain (A168611)(S067491)(301 Or App 317)
Koepke, Gregory v. Cain (A167054)(S067435)(300 Or App 823)
PETITIONS FOR REVIEW — Continued	
493
( P3d )
Ramos, Alan Marcelo Vazquez v. State of Oregon (A168815)(A168904)(S067617)
(302 Or App 653)
State v. Chavez-Meza, Juan Jose (A164080)(S067525)(301 Or App 373)
State v. Gustafson, Richard Bridgeman (A159489)(S067382)(300 Or App 438)
State v. Guynn, Ellen M. (A165616)(S067506)(302 Or App 78)
State v. Kuehne, Gregory (A164033)(S067515)(300 Or App 698)
State v. Mohammed, Ali Jasim (A166566)(S067472)(301 Or App 367)
State v. Taylor, Josef Grant (A164113)(S067425)(300 Or App 626)
State v. Tubbs, Steven Guy (A168961)(S067531)(302 Or App 186)
State v. Ventris, Joseph Richard (A163907)(S067478)(299 Or App 124)
Trackwell, Lloyd Ray, Jr. v. State of Oregon (A167634)(S067614)(302 Or App 654)