Source: http://www.scribd.com/doc/213180083/Raul-Sainz-Rivera-A091-684-104-BIA-Mar-10-2014
Timestamp: 2015-05-06 20:31:59
Document Index: 640272143

Matched Legal Cases: ['§ 1', '§ 1227', '§ 28', '§ 2', '§ 28', '§ 28', '§ 2', '§ 23']

P. 1Raul Sainz-Rivera, A091 684 104 (BIA Mar. 10, 2014)Raul Sainz-Rivera, A091 684 104 (BIA Mar. 10, 2014)Ratings: (0)|Views: 1,479|Likes: 1Published by Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLCIn this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) dismissed the charge of deportability and held that Ariz. Rev. Stat. 28-1383(A)(1)—which criminalizes driving under the influence after one’s license has been suspended, canceled, revoked, refused or restricted—is not a categorical crime involving moral turpitude. The Board determined that the statute is not divisible in light of Descamps v. United States, 133 S. Ct. 2276 (2013), because "driving" and being in "actual physical control" of a vehicle are alternative means of committing the offense, not alternative elements as to which jurors must unanimously agree. The decision was written by Member Roger Pauley and joined by Member John Guendelsberger and Member Anne Greer.Looking for IRAC’s Index of Unpublished BIA Decisions? Visit www.irac.net/unpublished/indexIn this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) dismissed the charge of deportability and held that Ariz. Rev. Stat. 28-1383(A)(1)—which criminalizes driving under the influence after one’s license has been suspended, canceled, revoked, refused or restricted—is not a categorical crime involving moral turpitude. The Board determined that the statute is not divisible in light of Descamps v. United States, 133 S. Ct. 2276 (2013), because "driving" and being in "actual physical control" of a vehicle are alternative means of committing the offense, not alternative elements as to which jurors must unanimously agree. The decision was written by Member Roger Pauley and joined by Member John Guendelsberger and Member Anne Greer.Looking for IRAC’s Index of Unpublished BIA Decisions? Visit www.irac.net/unpublished/indexMore info:Categories:Types, Business/Law, Court FilingsPublished by: Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLC on Mar 18, 2014Copyright:Attribution Non-commercialAvailability:Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.download as PDF, TXT or read online from ScribdFlag for inappropriate content|Add to collectionSee moreSee lesshttps://www.scribd.com/doc/213180083/Raul-Sainz-Rivera-A091-684-104-BIA-Mar-10-201410/16/2014pdftextoriginal SAIZ-RIVERA, RAUL 145971/A091684-104 PIA COUTY JAIL P  BOX 2610 FORECE,  85132 Nam: SAIZRIVERA, RAU  eptment  Jtie Executive Oce r Immgraon Revew Board of Immigratn Appeals Oce of he Clerk 510 lburg Pike Suit 2000 Fas Chc Vginia 2030 HS/IC Oice of Chif Counsl LO P.O. Box 2558 Poenix,  85002 A 091-68404 Date of this otic 3/10/2014 closed s a copy of the Boad's decso and ode  e above-reenced case. Ecose P Mb: Gg h G   y Rg Sncerey, D
 c  Donna Ca Ce Cek lucasd  k For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
Cite as: Raul Sainz-Rivera, A091 684 104 (BIA Mar. 10, 2014)
 Dpamn  Jusi Executive Oce r Immaion Revew Fals Cc, Vga 5 File: 09 8 0 Florence,  Deciso of he Board oao Appeals Date MAR   4 In re L SNZRVE aka Jsus rbieta aka Manue Saiz  MOV POCEEINGS PPE ON BEHF O SPONDENT Pro se CGE: Notice Sec 22(a)()()(i), &N ct [8 USC § 1l82(a)()()(i) Prsent wtout bein admted or parole (itdran) Loded: Sec. 237(a)(2)()(ii) I&N ct 8 US. § 227(a)(2)()(i)] Convcte of two or more crmes nvovn moral uriude PPLICTION Terminaion e respondent appeals om  iration Jude's October  2013, decison ndin him removabe om th nited States as an alien conviced of two crms nvolvin moral tuiude no arsin om a sine scheme of crminal msconduct Section 237(a)(2)()() of he Immiration  Nationait ct 8 .SC § 1227(a)(2)()(ii). Te appea wil be sustand an the record will be remande The respondent a native and citien of Mexco as tce ben convicd of violatin riz. ev Sat.  28383()(), whch probis  person om drvin" or xercsin actual physica cono" over a motor vehicle while under the inuence of intoxicatin liquor or s i he person knos hat his dver icense or prvilee to drve s suspende, canceed, revoked, resed or rsicted Te issue on appeal is heher he Department of omel Securiy (DS") has proven by cear an convincin evience at these oenss qlify as crimes invovin moral turpue (CIMT") r removal purposes. Upon e novo revew  8 .F.R. § 003 1 ( d)(3 )(i), we conclue a he DHS as no cie ta brden The Unied States Court o ppeals r t Nnh Circu n whose ursdicon ths mater ases has concluded that r Rev Stat § 28383()() encompasses some conduct hat s o uiuinous n oer n  is n C lj-C  Hd 8 3d 903, 917 (9t ir. 2009) (en ban) (errn o  f Lzz 22 I&N Dec. 188 (B 999), in which is Board un a moral urpitude ineres in te act of drvin" r the nuence of alcohol or drus wth knowle that one's drvin prvilees hav been revoked), wi HerdeMre v. Ashcrof, 329 F3d 17, 8119 (9th Cir 2003) (holdin hat moral tue dos  iere in the ac of exercisn acua phsca conro" over a veicle he intoxicated, even f the accused knew is dvn privilees ad been suspende) Cite as: Raul Sainz-Rivera, A091 684 104 (BIA Mar. 10, 2014)
A0914104 As Ariz Rv Stat § 2-133A ncompasss both turpitudnous ad nonurudnous condut, the Nnth Crut has treated i as a divsbl" statu visvs he CMT oncpt autorizng mmaton Judgs to consul alns convcion rcords undr h moded agoral approach" o dtrmn hther te paricuar alen br he ou was onvced o dring" aher than mely exersig actual physial onrol" See Marmlej-Camps v Hlder sura a 913 &  12. e Imigation Judg onducd s a modid ategorica nquy here and ud tat the rspondens guy peas er o dving" whle intoxatd J at 2-4 
. Durng th pendeny of ths removal proeedings hoevr, e Suprm Cou decided Descas v United tates 133 S Ct 226 203, ic mraced a oncepon of dvsibilty" at aps substantialy narowe han at mbodid n Marmlejamps T escaps Cou hd tha a crnal satue is disil, so as o warrat a modied agoral inquiy, ony f: 1 it ss mulp dsree onses s numrated ateatives or dens a sn oens by referen to disjuncve sts of lemnts," mor han on combination of hch could supo a convto; and 2 at least on but no all of hose lisd oenss or ombinations of disjunte lements is a agora math to  rlean gnric standd Id at 2281, 223 n ot words, t moded categoica approach does not apply mey eas he elemnts o a e a sometimes b prod by rn o cduc tha s he genrc federa stdad undr escaps sch crmes ar mrely overbroad," thy are no disibe" Id. a 2256 229092. Th Ninth Ciruit has drmined ha h cagorcal approach apples n rmova cases nvovng CMT onvictions, ee OlvasMa v lder 7 3d 199 9h Cir 013, ad has also onluded that  approac to dvisility anond n Descams aplis n h mgration ontex See guiarTurcis  Hlder 740 3d 1294, 30-02 9t Cr 201 Acordingly, o pse ask is to deid hethr Ariz R Stat § 28-1383A rmans dsibl" r CIM puposs ithi the meanng o Descamps. I ight of Descas Aiz Re Stat § 281383A an b onsderd divisbe" no disrt onss requng drng" d atua pysal control" only if Arzona law dens drng" and acual psal ontr" as atatv elments" o h oens Under Descps, the m elment" mans a t aout a cr whih t] Sxt Amendmn contemplas that a juynot a snncig couwill nd .. , unaimously ad byond a reasonabl doubt" Id at 2288 citng Richardsn v United Saes 526 S 13, 817 1999 us, f Arzona law does not rqur both rof byond a reasonabe doubt ad uy unanmi as to e a dendan ged under iz R tat § 2133A was driing" or exersing acual hysa ontro" oe th vhic t ncssily llos hat drvng" and actua psial ontol" a not ateati emens" r disibity puoses, ut raher mer ateav mans" b which a dendant can comt aavae DI See Schad v rzna 501 .S. 2, 3 (991) (plualiy opinion ("[L]egislaures fequety enumerae aleaive means o comng a crme ihou nendn o dn sara mns or sparae crms"  Aizona Supreme Cout as hd tha h Sates onsttional reirmnt of ur unant, see Arz Const., At II, § 23, does not entl a defendant to a unanimos verdct on he es m e in wh e [rnal at as omed" ee ate v Encnas 67 P2d 62, 62  1982 caon omited). Appying ha rnl o Aizona's  saues, he 2 Cite as: Raul Sainz-Rivera, A091 684 104 (BIA Mar. 10, 2014)
Activity (5)FiltersAdd to collectionReview Add NoteLikeShowingAllMost RecentReviewsAll NotesLikesYou've already reviewed this. Edit your review.Rating 0/5Post notePost reviewPost replyPost note and likeReplyAlfonso Muñoz added this noteThis was a pro se case! My respects for Mr. Sains...1 thousand reads1 hundred readsAlfonso Muñoz liked thisLoad more
Similar to Raul Sainz-Rivera, A091 684 104 (BIA Mar. 10, 2014)Juan Carlos Clase, A043 986 617 (BIA Apr. 25, 2014)Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLCDouglas Shitote, A200 224 343 (BIA March 6, 2014)Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLCLorenzo Perez Flores, A095 419 451 (BIA July 28, 2014)Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLCMario Enrique Ramirez-Lainez, A205 236 187 (BIA Aug. 21, ...Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLCLorenzo Martinez-Delgado, A074 103 780 (BIA Mar. 11, 2014)Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLCEduardo Gomez Jurado, A090 764 102 (BIA Mar. 28, 2014)Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLCErik Mendoza-Olivas, A044 547 316 (BIA Feb. 26, 2014)Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLCOctavio Ugarte Delgado, A205 829 687 (BIA Mar. 13, 2014)Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLCJuan Carlos Clase, A043 986 617 (BIA Oct. 31, 2013)Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLCJorge Hernandez-Hernandez, A045 582 968 (BIA May 20, 2014)Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLC
RecommendedJuan Carlos Clase, A043 986 617 (BIA ...Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center,...In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) terminat...Douglas Shitote, A200 224 343 (BIA Ma...Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center,...In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) faulted ...Lorenzo Perez Flores, A095 419 451 (B...Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center,...In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) upheld t...Mario Enrique Ramirez-Lainez, A205 23...Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center,...In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) upheld a...Lorenzo Martinez-Delgado, A074 103 78...Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center,...In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) terminat...Eduardo Gomez Jurado, A090 764 102 (B...Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center,...In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) dismisse...Erik Mendoza-Olivas, A044 547 316 (BI...Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center,...In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) reversed...Octavio Ugarte Delgado, A205 829 687 ...Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center,...In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) remanded...Juan Carlos Clase, A043 986 617 (BIA ...Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center,...In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) remanded...Jorge Hernandez-Hernandez, A045 582 9...Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center,...In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) terminat...Previous|NextPage 1 of 3