Source: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2004/02/24/04-3852/fisheries-of-the-northeastern-united-states-monkfish-fishery
Timestamp: 2018-12-11 18:12:20
Document Index: 55535775

Matched Legal Cases: ['§\u2009648', '§\u2009648', '§\u2009648', '§\u2009648', '§\u2009648', '§\u2009648']

69 FR 8364
8364-8367 (4 pages)
04-3852
https://www.federalregister.gov/d/04-3852 https://www.federalregister.gov/d/04-3852
NMFS proposes to establish target total allowable catch (TAC) levels for the monkfish fishery for the 2004 fishing year (FY), and adjust trip limits and days-at-sea (DAS) for limited access monkfish vessels fishing in the Southern Fishery Management Area (SFMA) based upon the target TAC setting, and trip limit and DAS adjustment methods established in Framework Adjustment 2 (Framework 2) to the Monkfish Fishery Management Plan (FMP). The target TACs for FY 2004, based upon the target TAC setting method, would be 16,968 mt for the Northern Fishery Management Area (NFMA), and 6,772 mt for the SFMA. In accordance with the trip limit and DAS adjustment methods established in Framework 2, this action would adjust the trip limits for vessels fishing in the SFMA to be 550 lb (250 kg) tail weight per DAS for limited access Category A and C vessels, and 450 lb (204 kg) tail weight per DAS for limited access Category B and D vessels, and would also restrict the FY 2004 DAS available for monkfish limited access vessels fishing in the SFMA to 28 DAS.
Comments on the proposed rule should be sent to Patricia A. Kurkul, Regional Administrator (RA), Northeast Region, NMFS, One Blackburn Drive, Gloucester, MA 01930-2298. Mark the outside of the envelope “Comments on 2004 Monkfish TACs.” Comments may also be submitted via facsimile (fax) to 978-281-9135. Comments may also be submitted via e-mail to the following address: monkfish89@noaa.gov.
Copies of the Regulatory Impact Review (RIR) and Initial Regulatory Flexibility Analysis (IRFA) prepared for this action are available upon request from the RA at the above address. Copies of the Environmental Assessment (EA) prepared for Framework Adjustment 2 to the FMP are available upon request from Paul Howard, Executive Director, New England Fishery Management Council (NEFMC), 50 Water Street, Newburyport, MA 01950.
The monkfish fishery is jointly managed by the NEFMC and the Mid-Atlantic Fishery Management Council (MAFMC), with the NEFMC having the administrative lead. Framework Adjustment 2, which became effective on May 1, 2003 (68 FR 22325; April 28, 2003), implemented a target TAC setting method that is based upon the relationship between the 3-year running average of the NMFS fall trawl survey biomass index (3-year average biomass index) and established annual biomass index targets (annual index target). The annual index targets are based on 10 equal increments between the 1999 biomass index (the start of the rebuilding program) and the biomass target (Btarget), which is to be achieved by 2009 according to the rebuilding plan established in the FMP. According to this target TAC setting method, annual target TACs are set based on the ratio of the observed biomass index to the annual index target applied to the monkfish landings for the previous fishing year.
In accordance with the annual target TAC setting procedures established in Framework 2, and implemented in the regulations at 50 CFR 648.96(b)(1), the Monkfish Monitoring Committee (MFMC) reviewed the NMFS fall trawl survey biomass indices and monkfish landings for FY 2002, and calculated the target TACs for FY 2004. Based on this information, the 2004 target TACs would be set at 16,698 mt for the NFMA, and 6,772 mt for the SFMA. For the NFMA, the 3-year average biomass index of 2.03 kg/tow is 36 percent above the annual index target of 1.49 kg/tow for 2003. The target TAC setting procedures established in Framework 2 state that, if the 3-year average biomass index is above the index target, the target TAC shall be set equivalent to the previous year's landings plus one-half the percentage difference between the 3-year average biomass index and the annual index target, but no more than 20 percent above the previous year's landings, if fishing mortality cannot be determined. Consequently, the target TAC of 16,968 mt that is being recommended for the NFMA is 18 percent above the monkfish landings for FY 2002, which is one-half of the 36-percent difference between the 3-year biomass index and the annual index target for 2003. This target TAC represents a 4-percent decrease from the target TAC for FY 2003. Although the proposed 2004 target TAC for the NFMA is a decrease from the target TAC for FY 2003, it is a substantial increase from the target TAC for FY 2002, which was 11,674 mt. Furthermore, regulations currently in place for the Northeast (NE) Start Printed Page 8365multispecies fishery have reduced NE multispecies DAS allocations, which directly impacts the ability of limited access monkfish vessels to fish in the NFMA. In fact, monkfish landings for May through August 2003 were 21 percent of the target 2003 TAC for the NFMA. Additional reductions in NE multispecies DAS allocations are expected beginning May 1, 2004, under Amendment 13 to the NE Multispecies FMP. Under existing management measures (40 DAS and no trip limit), it is unlikely that vessels in the NFMA would exceed the proposed 2004 target TAC for this area. Therefore, this action does not propose any adjustments in DAS or implementation of a trip limit for the NFMA since such changes are unnecessary in order to achieve the proposed target TAC for FY 2004.
For the SFMA, the 3-year average biomass index of 0.93 kg/tow is 8.9 percent below the annual index target of 1.02 kg/tow. The regulations at § 648(b)(1)(i)(A) require that, in this circumstance, the 2004 TAC for the SFMA be set proportionally below the previous year's (FY 2002) landings. This results in a target TAC of 6,772 mt for the SFMA. Unlike the NFMA, the proposed decrease in target TAC for the SFMA would require both a reduction in the trip limits and a reduction in the monkfish DAS available for limited access vessels fishing in the SFMA. Framework 2 included a provision that states, if the target TAC for the SFMA is below a target TAC that would result in trip limits below 550 lb (250 kg) tail weight per DAS for Category A and C vessels, and 450 lb (204 kg) tail weight per DAS for Category B and D vessels (approximately 8,000 mt), then the trip limits would be fixed at those levels and the DAS available for vessels fishing in the SFMA would be reduced based upon an established method, defined in the regulations at § 648.96(b)(2)(iii). This provision was included to address the concern that, if the target TAC dropped below the 8,000-mt level, which is approximately the same target TAC established for FY 2002, the resulting trip limits would be comparable to the incidental catch limits on some vessels, essentially eliminating the directed monkfish fishery. Thus, an annual target TAC of less than 8,000 mt would result in trip limits that are not economically feasible for vessels participating in the directed monkfish fishery.
A DAS analysis conducted in accordance with the monkfish regulations at § 648.96(b)(2)(iii) concluded that, under a target TAC of 6,772 mt for the SFMA, limited access Category A and C vessels should be authorized to fish a maximum of 27 DAS in the SFMA, and limited access Category B and D vessels should be authorized to fish a maximum of 29 DAS in the SFMA. Because the calculated maximum DAS are similar for each limited access category group, NMFS is recommending that all limited access vessels fishing in the SFMA be authorized to fish a maximum of 28 DAS for the 2004 fishing year, the average maximum DAS for the two limited access groups. Thus, under this proposed rule, all limited access vessels would have a total allocation of 40 monkfish DAS, of which only 28 DAS could be fished in the SFMA.
NMFS intends to monitor DAS usage by management area based on whether a vessel holds a valid Letter of Authorization (LOA) to fish for monkfish exclusively in the NFMA. Under the monkfish regulations at § 648.93(f), vessels fishing on a monkfish, NE multispecies, or scallop DAS under the less restrictive measures of the NFMA, must declare into the NFMA by obtaining a LOA from the Regional Administrator. A vessel that does not possess this LOA is presumed to have fished in the SFMA.
The EA for Framework 2 contained a complete analysis of the target TAC setting method being utilized in this action to established target TACs, trip limits and DAS for FY 2004. In addition, the EA contained an analysis of the impacts of a range of potential target TACs for FY 2004. This action updates the previous Finding of No Significant Impact (FONSI) statement contained in the EA for Framework 2, and signed on April 21, 2003, with a new FONSI that references updated information on the monkfish fishery, including the target TACs, trip limits and DAS being proposed for FY 2004. The updated FONSI states that this action does not change the circumstances under which the previous EA was prepared, and that all of the information and analysis contained in the EA for Framework 2 are applicable to this action. Furthermore, the updated FONSI states that this action does not change the determinations made in the EA for Framework 2.
The annual target TAC setting method established in Framework 2 is based on a formula that integrates an annual biomass index target with the 3-year running average of the NOAA Fisheries fall trawl survey and the monkfish landings for the previous fishing year. Therefore, the target TACs resulting from the application of this method are non-negotiable. As a result, there are no alternatives to the proposed action to establish target TACs of 16,968 mt for the NFMA and 6,772 for the SFMA. Furthermore, Framework 2 also established an formulaic method for adjusting trip limits and DAS for the SFMA that is based on the distribution of monkfish landings and DAS used by limited access vessels. Thus, there are no alternatives to the proposed trip limits of 550 lb per DAS for limited access Category A and C vessels, and 450 lb per DAS for limited access Category B and D vessels, and the calculated DAS limitation of 28 DAS available to limited access vessels for fishing the SFMA.
The only other option for establishing 2004 target TACs would be to forgo using the target TAC setting method established in Framework 2, and establish target TACs based on current fishing mortality (F) in relation to the fishing mortality threshold (Fthreshold). This option is not reasonable since current estimates of F are too imprecise to set target TACs and make a status determination regarding overfishing. For these reasons, this option (the status quo alternative) was rejected by the Councils in the development of Framework 2.
The combined TAC for both monkfish management areas would be reduced by approximately 15 percent compared to fishing year 2003. However, the TAC for the SFMA would be reduced by nearly 34 percent. Monkfish trip limits in the SFMA would also be reduced by more than half, and allowable DAS that may be fished in the SFMA would be reduced by 28 percent. Thus, the proposed action would affect only limited access monkfish vessels that fish in the SMFA. There are approximately 740 limited access monkfish permit holders, including vessels in a confirmation of permit history. Based on activity reports for the FY 2002 (the most recent fishing year for which information is available), there were a total of 532 limited access permit holders that participated in the monkfish fishery. Of these, 148 vessels Start Printed Page 8366fished for monkfish exclusively in the SFMA, and 242 vessels fished for monkfish in both management areas. Therefore, the proposed measures could effect at least 390 limited access monkfish vessels, but would likely have the greatest affect on the 148 vessels that fished for monkfish exclusively in the SFMA.
In Framework 2, the potential economic impacts of a range of potential FY2004 trip limits were evaluated, where all potential impacts were evaluated relative to a FY2002 baseline. Relative to this baseline, the FY2004 TAC for the SFMA would represent a 22-percent reduction in median vessel gross revenues when, in fact, the SFMA TAC would decline by 34 percent. However, the Framework 2 analysis did not include the potential additional impacts of a DAS reduction at TAC levels below 8,000 mt. As a result, further analysis was conducted to evaluate the short-term impacts of the TAC reduction from FY2003 to FY2004, while incorporating the proposed trip limits and DAS limits in the SFMA.
The analysis indicates that, based on a trip limit model, the per trip average return on monkfish trips would be reduced by 25 percent. This means that, on average, a monkfish trip taken in the SFMA would produce 25 percent less income toward fixed costs, debt, and owner profit under the proposed FY2004 trip limits. Similarly, net pay per crew member would be reduced by an average of 22 percent. In terms of impacts by state, vessels from Delaware and New Hampshire would be most impacted, experiencing reductions in average vessel returns of 33 percent and 29 percent, respectively. Vessels from Massachusetts and Rhode Island would experience similar reductions in average vessel returns, approximately 28 percent. New York vessels would be least impacted, experiencing losses in average vessel returns of approximately 13 percent.
Since no changes to either trip limits or DAS would be implemented for the NFMA, vessels that fished exclusively in the NFMA would not be affected by the proposed measures. Vessels that fished in both management areas were assumed to be affected by the SFMA trip limits while they fished in the SFMA, but would not lose any opportunities to fish monkfish, since they would be likely to switch to the NFMA once the limit on DAS in the SFMA was reached. However, while vessels that fished exclusively in the SFMA would still be able to switch to the NFMA, by virtue of a strong fidelity to the SFMA, it was assumed that they would not be likely to do so. This assumption means that vessels with a strong fidelity to the SFMA would be affected by both the trip limit change and could be constrained by the DAS.
To account for the reduction of DAS that may be used in the SFMA the average reduction in DAS used by vessels that fished exclusively in the SFMA was estimated. Based on call-in records, approximately 60 percent of vessels that landed monkfish exclusively from the SFMA took no monkfish-only trips. Of the remaining 40 percent of vessels that did take at least one monkfish-only trip the average difference between the observed call-in DAS and the proposed allowable DAS in the SFMA was 5.5 DAS. This means that the average vessel fishing for monkfish in the SFMA would lose 5.5 days of fishing over and above the losses associated with the reduced trip limits. To account for these DAS losses, the average return on monkfish DAS was multiplied by 5.5 and deducted from the total net return for the year. That is, total net return to each vessel, as well as net crew payments, were summed for all trips (adjusted for trip limits). For vessels fishing for monkfish exclusively in the SFMA, total net return was further reduced by the lost value associated with the reduced DAS allowance.
The average impact on vessels that fish in both areas was estimated to be less than a 1-percent reduction in net pay to crew or net return to the vessel. This low level of impact suggests that vessels that can fish in both management areas predominantly fished in the NFMA, at least during FY 2002. The average impact on vessels that fish exclusively in the SFMA was about an 18-percent reduction in returns to the vessel owner, and a 22-percent reduction in net pay to crew. Average impacts by state exhibit substantial variability from no impact on vessels from North Carolina, to a reduction in average vessel net return of 27 percent for vessels in Massachusetts and New Jersey.
(1) Limited access monkfish permit holders.—(i) General provisions. All limited access monkfish permit holders shall be allocated 40 monkfish DAS each fishing year to be used in accordance with the restrictions of this paragraph (b), unless modified by paragraph (b)(1)(ii) of this section according to the provisions specified at § 648.96(b)(3). Limited access multispecies and limited access scallop permit holders who also possess a valid limited access monkfish permit must use a multispecies or scallop DAS concurrently with their monkfish DAS, except as provided in paragraph (b)(2) of this section.
3. In § 648.94, paragraph (b)(2) (i) and (ii) are revised to read as follows:
[FR Doc. 04-3852 Filed 2-23-04; 8:45 am]