Source: https://www.legalcrystal.com/case/91292/matter-loving
Timestamp: 2018-04-20 09:09:32
Document Index: 172635118

Matched Legal Cases: ['§ 24', '§ 25', '§ 24', '§ 25', '§ 24', '§ 24']

Matter of Loving - Citation 91292 - Court Judgment | LegalCrystal
Matter of Loving - Court Judgment
LegalCrystal Citation legalcrystal.com/91292
Case Number 224 U.S. 183
Appellant Matter of Loving
.....by legal process." " wherefore the affiant prays that the claimant's debt be allowed as a lien claim against the assets of page 224 u. s. 185 this bankrupt estate, and for all other proper and equitable relief." "the trustee in bankruptcy thereupon filed exceptions to the allowance of this claim insofar as it was made for any sum in excess of $10,000 at the time of the adjudication of bankruptcy, for various reasons set out in the exceptions, and also further objected and excepted to the allowance of any part of the said claim as a lien in favor of the bank against the estate of the bankrupt, for various reasons set forth in the exceptions. these exceptions of the trustee concluded as follows:" " wherefore he prays that said claim be disallowed as a lien.....
Matter of Loving - 224 U.S. 183 (1912)
U.S. Supreme Court Matter of Loving, 224 U.S. 183 (1912)
"In the brief filed in this court in behalf of the trustee in support of the petition, no question is made as to the allowance of the claim of the bank as a general claim against the bank( rupt ), or as to its amount, the sole contention of the trustee on the merits being that the district court was in error in matter of law in adjudging that, under the Kentucky statutes, the claim was secured by a lien upon the property and effects of the bankrupt."
Section 25 provides for appeals and writs of error in bankruptcy proceedings to the circuit court of appeals and to this Court. These sections of the Bankruptcy Act were under consideration in this Court in the case of Coder v. Arts, 213 U. S. 223 , and it was there held that
this Court. The proceeding under § 24b, permitting a review of questions of law arising in bankruptcy proceedings, was not intended as a substitute for the right of appeal under § 25. Coder v. Arts, supra, p. 213 U. S. 233 . Under § 24b, a question of law only is taken to the circuit court of appeals; under the appeal section, controversies of fact as well are taken to that court, with findings of fact to be made therein if the case is appealable to this Court. We do not think it was intended to give to persons who could avail themselves of the remedy by appeal under § 25 a review by petition under § 24b. The object of § 24b is rather to give a review as to matters of law, where facts are not in controversy, of orders of courts of bankruptcy in the ordinary administration of the bankrupt's estate.