Source: https://www.docketbird.com/court-cases/Knuth-v-Paul-Revere-Life-Insurance-Company-et-al/azd-4:2014-cv-02387
Timestamp: 2019-03-19 19:43:37
Document Index: 604332452

Matched Legal Cases: ['art 1', 'art 2', '§1746', 'art 1', 'art 2', 'ART 1', 'ART 2']

Knuth v. Paul Revere Life Insurance Company et al Docket Sheet
Knuth v. Paul Revere Life Insurance Company et al
4:2014-cv-02387 (azd)
Last full docket sheet refresh: 696 days ago. Refresh now
COMPLAINT. Filing fee received: $ 400.00, receipt number 0970-10920207 filed by Randall Knuth.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025113460671" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025113460671','885354','9','','2','1','',''}};">3</a> Civil Cover Sheet)
SUMMONS Submitted by Randall Knuth.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025113460712" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025113460712','885354','11','','2','1','',''}};">2</a> Summons)
Filing fee paid, receipt number 0970-10920207. This case has been assigned to the Honorable D Thomas Ferraro. All future pleadings or documents should bear the correct case number: 4:14-cv-02387-DTF. Magistrate Election form attached.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025113460765" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025113460765','885354','15','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Consent Form Instructions)
Summons Issued as to All Defendants. *** IMPORTANT: When printing the summons, select "Document and stamps" or "Document and comments" for the seal to appear on the document.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025113460885" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025113460885','885354','17','','2','1','',''}};">2</a> Summons)
SERVICE EXECUTED filed by Randall Knuth: Proof of Service re: Summons, Complaint, Civil Cover Sheet, Consent to Magistrate Election and Instruction Sheet re UNUM GROUP upon Statutory Agent on 10/03/2014.
SERVICE EXECUTED filed by Randall Knuth: Proof of Service re: Summons, Complaint, Civil Cover Sheet, Consent to Magistrate Election and Instruction Sheet upon Arizona Department of Insurance on behalf of Paul Revere Life Insurance Company on 10/03/2014.
SERVICE EXECUTED filed by Randall Knuth: Proof of Service re: Summons, Complaint, Civil Cover Sheet, Consent to Magistrate Election and Instruction Sheet upon Arizona Department of Insurance on behalf of Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company on 10/03/2014.
Party Elects Assignment of Case to District Judge Jurisdiction. This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no PDF document associated with this entry.
MINUTE ORDER: Pursuant to Local Rule 3.8(a), a request has been received for a random reassignment of this case to a District Judge. Case reassigned by random draw to Chief Judge Raner C Collins. All further pleadings should now list the following COMPLETE case number: CV-14-02387-TUC-RCC. This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no PDF document associated with this entry.
STIPULATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO ANSWER COMPLAINT (First Request).
ORDER granting 10 Stipulation For Extension of Time To Answer Complaint as to All Defendants. Answer due November 17, 2014. Signed by Chief Judge Raner C Collins on 10/22/14.
MOTION for Admission Pro Hac Vice as to attorney Richard H. Friedman by Randall Knuth.
List of Courts Admitted to Practice
Good Standing Cert for R. Friedman
ORDER REFERRING CASE to Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro for all pretrial proceedings and Report and Recommendation. All future filings in this case shall be designated: CV-14-02387-TUC-RCC(DTF). Signed by Chief Judge Raner C Collins on 10/23/14.
MOTION for Admission Pro Hac Vice as to attorney Jeffrey K Rubin on behalf of Randall Knuth.
PRO HAC VICE FEE PAID. $ 35, receipt number PHX151730 as to Jeffrey K Rubin. This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no PDF document associated with this entry. (Text entry; no document attached.)
PRO HAC VICE FEE PAID. $ 35, receipt number PHX151729 as to Richard H Friedman. This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no PDF document associated with this entry. (Text entry; no document attached.)
ORDER pursuant to General Order 09-08 granting 12 Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice; granting 14 Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice. Per the Court's Administrative Policies and Procedures Manual, applicant has five (5) days in which to register as a user of the Electronic Filing System. Registration to be accomplished via the court's website at www.azd.uscourts.gov. Counsel is advised that they are limited to two (2) additional e-mail addresses in their District of Arizona User Account. (BAS) (This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no.pdf document associated with this entry.)
MOTION for Admission Pro Hac Vice as to attorney Daniel W. Maguire by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE of Appearance by Stephen M Bressler on behalf of Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
PRO HAC VICE FEE PAID. $ 35, receipt number PHX151893 as to Daniel W Maguire. This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no PDF document associated with this entry. (Text entry; no document attached.)
ORDER pursuant to General Order 09-08 granting 16 Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice. Per the Court's Administrative Policies and Procedures Manual, applicant has five (5) days in which to register as a user of the Electronic Filing System. Registration to be accomplished via the court's website at www.azd.uscourts.gov. Counsel is advised that they are limited to two (2) additional e-mail addresses in their District of Arizona User Account. (BAS) (This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no.pdf document associated with this entry.)
ANSWER to Complaint by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Corporate Disclosure Statement by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
ORDER, Telephonic Rule 16 Scheduling Conference set for 1/7/2015 at 09:30 AM before Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro. Counsel are directed to confer at least 21 days prior to the Conference. The parties shall prepare a Joint Case Management Plan reflecting the results of their discussion and file it with the Court on or before December 31, 2014. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 11/19/14. (See attached PDF for complete information.)
NOTICE re: Intent to Issue Subpoenas for Production by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company.
NOTICE re: Intent to Issue Subpoenas by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REPORT of Rule 26(f) Planning Meeting by Randall Knuth.
MINUTE ENTRY for proceedings held before Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro: Telephonic Rule 16 Scheduling Conference held on 1/7/2015. Scheduling Order to follow. Hearing held 9:31AM to 9:38AM.
SCHEDULING ORDER: Discovery due by 9/28/2015. Dispositive motions due by 10/30/2015. Joint Proposed Pretrial Order due by 11/30/2015. If dispositive motions are filed, the proposed pretrial order shall be due 30 days following resolution of the motions. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 1/7/15. (See attached PDF for complete information.)
NOTICE re: Intent to Issue Subpoenas for Production by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE of Service of Discovery filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE re: Service of Plaintiff's Initial Disclosure Statement by Randall Knuth.
NOTICE of Service of Discovery filed by Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: Intient to Issue Subpoenas for Production of Documents by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE re: of Service of Plaintiff's 1st All-Inclusive Supplemental Disclosure Statement by Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: Intent to Issue Subpoenas to Produce by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE re: Intent to Issue Subpoena for Production by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE of Service of Discovery filed by Unum Group.
NOTICE re: of Service of Discovery by Randall Knuth.
MOTION for Admission Pro Hac Vice as to attorney Henry G Jones on behalf of Randall Knuth.
PRO HAC VICE FEE PAID. $ 35, receipt number PHX157084 as to Henry G Jones. This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no PDF document associated with this entry. (Text entry; no document attached.)
ORDER pursuant to General Order 09-08 granting 47 Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice. Per the Court's Administrative Policies and Procedures Manual, applicant has five (5) days in which to register as a user of the Electronic Filing System. Registration to be accomplished via the court's website at www.azd.uscourts.gov. Counsel is advised that they are limited to two (2) additional e-mail addresses in their District of Arizona User Account. (BAS) (This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no.pdf document associated with this entry.)
NOTICE re: Intent to Issue Subpoena for Production of Documents by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Subpoena Duces Tecum
NOTICE re: Intent to Issue Subpoena for Production of Documents (Amended) by Randall Knuth re: 50 Notice (Other).
MINUTE ENTRY for proceedings held before Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro: Telephonic Hearing held on 5/8/2015. Hearing held 10:00 AM to 11:23 AM.
NOTICE of Deposition, filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
MOTION to Compel Discovery by Randall Knuth.
Declaration of Henry G. Jones
26 Attachments ▼
MOTION for Protective Order by Randall Knuth.
MOTION for Extension of Time to Complete Discovery RE: Experts by Randall Knuth.
RESPONSE to Motion re: 57 MOTION to Compel Discovery filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Exhibit Declaration of William Obert
NOTICE of Deposition of Jerome Philbin, PhD, Robin Rose, Sara McKinnon, Diane Cahill, filed by Randall Knuth.
NOTICE of Deposition of Diane M. Cahill, filed by Randall Knuth.
*AMENDED NOTICE of Deposition of Jerome Philbin, M.D., filed by Randall Knuth. *Modified to add amended, as reflected on document on 6/4/2015
*AMENDED NOTICE of Deposition of Robin Rose, filed by Randall Knuth. *Modified to add amended, as reflected on document on 6/4/2015
*AMENDED NOTICE of Deposition of Sara McKinnon, filed by Randall Knuth. *Modified to add amended, as reflected on document on 6/4/2015
STIPULATION for Interim Continuation of Expert Disclosure Deadlines by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Proposed Protective Order
RESPONSE in Opposition re: 58 MOTION for Protective Order filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
RESPONSE to Motion re: 59 MOTION for Extension of Time to Complete Discovery RE: Experts filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE re: of Service of Partial Expert Disclosure by Randall Knuth.
ORDER pursuant to 67 Stipulation for Continuation: IT IS ORDERED Plaintiff's 6/5/15 expert witness disclosure deadline shall be continued until 14 days after the Court rules on his Motion to Modify Rule 16 Scheduling Order to Continue Expert Disclosure Deadlines (Doc. 59, the "Motion"); Defendants' 7/17/15 expert disclosure deadline, and Plaintiff's 8/7/15 rebuttal expert disclosure deadline, shall be continued by an amount corresponding to the effective continuance of Plaintiff's expert disclosure deadline under Paragraph 1; and if the Court grants Plaintiff's Motion and sets different expert disclosure deadlines, those deadlines shall control. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 6/5/15.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 57 MOTION to Compel Discovery filed by Randall Knuth.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 58 MOTION for Protective Order filed by Randall Knuth.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 59 MOTION for Extension of Time to Complete Discovery RE: Experts filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Subpoena Duces Tecum re: Knuth & McFarland
Exhibit Subpoena Duces Tecum re: Shawn McFarland, PLLC
MOTION to Strike 57 MOTION to Compel Discovery or Seal (Exhibits 3, 4, 5 and 22 only) by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Exhibit Subpoena Duces Tecum re: Shawn McFarland, D.D.S., individually
ORDER GRANTING 58 Plaintiffs Motion for Blanket Protective Order. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 6/29/15.
ORDER GRANTING IN PART and DENYING IN PART Plaintiff's 57 Motion to Compel. IT IS ORDERED that Motion to Compel is GRANTED IN PART as to RFP No. 16 (as to 2013 and 2014 documents, for in camera review only) and RFP No. 20 and DENIED IN PART as to RFP Nos. 5-7, 11, 16 (for years other than 2013 and 2014), 19 (except as already agreed by Defendants), 32, 33, and 36 as setforth in this Order. Defendants shall produce in camera the documents requested in RFP No. 16 (for the years 2013 and 2014), on or before 7/31/15. The documents shall be indexed and Bates stamped for reference. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 7/1/15.
ORDER GRANTING Platinff's 59 Motion Motion to Modify Scheduling Order. Plaintiff shall disclose any experts and their reports, including all disclosures required by Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a) (2), on or before 8/4/15. Defendants' expert disclosures, shall be completed by 9/15/15. Plaintiff's rebuttal expert disclosures shall be completed by 10/6/15. Written discovery shall be propounded on or before 8/14/15. All discovery shall be completed by 11/2/15; Dispositive motions shall be filed no later than 12/4/15; joint proposed pretrial order shall be lodged by 1/8/16. If dispositive motions are filed, the proposed pretrial order shall be due 30 days following resolution of the motions. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 7/1/15.
Subpoena to Produce
RESPONSE in Opposition re: 76 MOTION to Strike 57 MOTION to Compel Discovery or Seal (Exhibits 3, 4, 5 and 22 only) filed by Randall Knuth.
Declaration of H.G. Jones
Exhibit B, part 1
Exhibit B, part 2
NOTICE of Errata re: 84 Response in Opposition to Motion by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: of Service of Plaintiff's 4th & 5th Supplemental Disclosure Statements by Randall Knuth.
APPEAL OF MAGISTRATE JUDGE DECISION TO DISTRICT COURT by Randall Knuth re: 79 Order on Motion for Protective Order.
Exhibit Hepp Order re: Sanctions
NOTICE of Deposition of Defendant Unum Group pursuant to F.R.C.P. 30(b)(6), filed by Randall Knuth.
APPEAL OF MAGISTRATE JUDGE DECISION TO DISTRICT COURT by Randall Knuth re: 80 Order on Motion to Compel.
Exhibit RFP #27 & #28
NOTICE re: LODGING UNDER SEAL and CERTIFICATION OF COUNSEL by Randall Knuth re: 89 Appeal of Mag Judge Decision to Dist Court (Rule 72(a) Objection) Declaration of Lisa Ordonez, Ph.D.
SEALED LODGED Proposed Declaration of Lisa Ordonez. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 76 MOTION to Strike 57 MOTION to Compel Discovery or Seal (Exhibits 3, 4, 5 and 22 only) filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
ORDER DENYING Defendants' 76 Motion to Strike or Seal. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 7/22/15.
NOTICE of Errata re: 78 Notice of Service of Discovery by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
Pursuant to LRCiv 7.2(f) of the Rules of Practice of the United States District Court for the District of Arizona, IT IS ORDERED setting telephonic oral argument re: discovery dispute on 7/29/2015 at 03:30PM before Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro. Ordered by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro. (This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no PDF document associated with this entry.)
NOTICE re: of Supplemental Authority by Randall Knuth re: 89 Appeal of Mag Judge Decision to Dist Court (Rule 72(a) Objection).
Supplement Order & Memorandum Opinion
NOTICE re: Submission of Material for In Camera Review by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE re: Disclosure of Expert Testimony re: Richard S. Randall, P.T. by Randall Knuth.
*AMENDED NOTICE of Deposition of 30(b)(6) Designee, filed by Randall Knuth. *Modified text to add amended as reflected on document on 7/29/2015
NOTICE of Deposition of ANDREA L. CORRACIO, filed by Randall Knuth.
NOTICE of Deposition of SARA MCKINNON, filed by Randall Knuth.
NOTICE of Deposition of Dr. Suzanne Benson, filed by Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: PLAINTIFFS DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT TESTIMONY RE: KAREN LUNDA, M.S., P.T. AND ALAN K. ROGERS, M.D. (FRCP 26 (a)(2)(C)) by Randall Knuth.
MINUTE ENTRY for proceedings held before Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro: Telephonic Hearing held on 7/29/2015. Hearing held 3:30 PM to 4:28 PM.
RESPONSE to Plaintiff's Objection to Protective Order by Defendants Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
RESPONSE re: 89 Appeal of Mag Judge Decision to Dist Court (Rule 72(a) Objection) by Defendants Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REPLY re: 87 Appeal of Mag Judge Decision to Dist Court (Rule 72(a) Objection), 111 Response, 79 Order on Motion for Protective Order by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
*AMENDED NOTICE of Deposition of Dr. Suzanne Benson, filed by Randall Knuth. *Modified to add amended as reflected on this document on 8/13/2015
REPLY re: 114 Response, 80 Order on Motion to Compel, 89 Appeal of Mag Judge Decision to Dist Court (Rule 72(a) Objection) PLAINTIFFS REPLY TO DEFENDANTS RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS OBJECTION TO MAGISTRATES JULY 1, 2015 ORDER (DOC. NOS. 80, 89, 114) by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Excerpts from Defendants' Initial Disclosure Statement
Exhibit No Document - Filed Under Seal
Exhibit Claim File Excerpts
Exhibit Misc. Emails
Exhibit Cahill Excerpts
Exhibit Exhibits 8-12 - No Document - Filed Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 13 - Saldi Depo Log
Exhibit Exhibit 14 - Defendants' Request for Production to Plaintiff
DECLARATION of JEFFREY K. RUBIN (28 U.S.C. §1746) IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS REPLY TO DEFENDANTS RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS OBJECTION TO MAGISTRATES JULY 1, 2015 ORDER (DOC. NOS. 80, 89, 114) re: 121 Reply by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
DECLARATION of Lisa Ordez, Ph.D. re: 121 Reply (Supplemental) by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: OF LODGING UNDER SEAL and CERTIFICATION OF COUNSEL by Randall Knuth re: 121 Reply.
SEALED LODGED Proposed Lodging Under Seal - With Sealed Exhibits. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Robin Rose Deposition Excerpts
Exhibit Jerome Philbin, M.D. Deposition Excerpts
Exhibit Sara McKinnon Deposition Excerpts
Exhibit 2011 Long-Term Incentive Program
Exhibit 2013 PBI Total Compensation FAQs
Exhibit January 2014 PBI Total Compensation FAQs
Exhibit June 2014 PBI Total Compensation FAQs
Exhibit October 2014 PBI Total Compensation FAQs
8 Attachments ▼
NOTICE re: SERVICE OF PLAINTIFFS NOTICE OF LODGING UNDER SEAL by Randall Knuth re: 126 Sealed Lodged Proposed Document, 124 Notice (Other).
MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Confidentiality Designations by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Appendix 1-6
NOTICE of Deposition of Randall Knuth (continued deposition), filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
ORDER: IT IS ORDERED that Defendants shall produce the in camera material to Plaintiff on or before 9/1/15. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 8/17/15.
*NOTICE of Appearance of Sander R. Dawson by Steven C Dawson on behalf of Randall Knuth. *Modified on 8/24/2015 to add attorney
NOTICE re: re Intent to Issue Subpoenas for Production by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
24 Attachments ▼
MINUTE ENTRY for proceedings held before Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro: Telephonic Conference held on 8/27/2015. Hearing held 9:00 AM to 9:32 AM.
NOTICE re: Independent Medical Examination by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
*RESPONSE in Opposition to Motion re: 131 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Confidentiality Designations filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Annual Incentive Plan
Exhibit Stock Incentive Plan of 2012
Exhibit Excerpts from Deposition of Sharon Haas
Exhibit Excerpts from Deposition of Maureen Griffin
Exhibit Unum 2012 Annual Report
Exhibit 2004 Eastern Claims Conference
Exhibit 2007 Eastern Claims Conference
Exhibit Filed Under Seal
Exhibit 2009 Eastern Claims Conference
Exhibit 2012 Eastern Claims Conference
Exhibit 2013 Eastern Claims Conference
Exhibit 2014 Eastern Claims Conference
Exhibit Sharon Rutledge Testimony Excerpts
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025114814305" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025114814305','885354','354','','2','1','',''}};">16</a> Exhibit 2015 Eastern Claims Conference) *Modified on 8/31/2015 to correct event type
16 Attachments ▼
NOTICE re: LODGING UNDER SEAL and CERTIFICATION OF COUNSEL by Randall Knuth re: 140 Response to Motion, 131 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Confidentiality Designations.
FILED PUBLICLY AT DOC. 216 PURSUANT TO DOC. 215 -- SEALED LODGED Proposed Notice of Lodging Under Seal. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Exhibit 8 Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 9 Under Seal
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025114814418" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025114814418','885354','362','','2','1','',''}};">3</a> Exhibit Exhibit 10 Under Seal) Modified on 10/27/2015
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 131 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Confidentiality Designations Defendants' Reply in Support of Motion for Protective Order Regarding Confidentiality Designations filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE of Deposition of Jack McGarry, filed by Randall Knuth.
NOTICE of Deposition of Julie Knuth, filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE of Deposition of Karen Lunda, filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE re: Service (discovery response) by Unum Group.
NOTICE re: Service (Expert Disclosures) by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE of Deposition of Mike Hannley, filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
IT IS ORDERED that the Court will hear oral argument telephonically on the parties' discovery disputes on 9/30/2015, at 10:30 AM before Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro. Ordered by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro. (This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no PDF document associated with this entry.)
MOTION to Compel Requests for Production No. 62 and 63 by Randall Knuth.
Declaration of J. Rubin
Declaration of M. Fuller
21 Attachments ▼
NOTICE re: INTENT TO ISSUE SUBPOENA TO TESTIFY AT A DEPOSITION IN A CIVIL ACTION by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Subpoena re: John F. (&quot;Jack&quot;) McGarry
MOTION to Compel Production of Settlement Agreement by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
MOTION PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR EXCEPTIONAL RELIEF FROM SCHEDULING ORDER AND TO SET REASONABLE FEE FOR EXPERT WITNESS DEPOSITION RE: DR. BERGHAUSEN by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Exhibit 4
Exhibit Exhibit 5
Exhibit Exhibit 6
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin re: 160 MOTION PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR EXCEPTIONAL RELIEF FROM SCHEDULING ORDER AND TO SET REASONABLE FEE FOR EXPERT WITNESS DEPOSITION RE: DR. BERGHAUSEN by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
SUPPLEMENT PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO COMPEL DOC. 57 AND APPEAL OF RULING AT DOC. 89 re: 89 Appeal of Mag Judge Decision to Dist Court (Rule 72(a) Objection) by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Defendants' Expert Disclosure
Exhibit Excerpt from Dr. Philbin Deposition
Exhibit Exhibit 3 Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 4 Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 5 Lodged Under Seal
MOTION to Seal Document 162 Supplement by Randall Knuth.
FILED AT DOC. 452 --SEALED LODGED Proposed Notice of Lodging Under Seal With Proposed Sealed Exhibits re: 163 MOTION to Seal Document 162 Supplement. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Supplemental Exhibit #3
Exhibit Supplemental Exhibit #4
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025114945203" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025114945203','885354','412','','2','1','',''}};">3</a> Exhibit Supplemental Exhibit #5) Modified on 6/14/2016
NOTICE of Deposition of Richard Randall, filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
ORDER GRANTING Defendant's 159 Motion to Compel. Plaintiff shall produce to Defendants his settlement agreement with Dr. Shawn McFarland and the settlement agreement shall be subject to the previously issued protective order at Doc. 79. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 9/29/15.
TRANSCRIPT REQUEST by Randall Knuth for proceedings held on 09/30/2015, Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro hearing judge(s).
MINUTE ENTRY for proceedings held before Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro: Telephonic Hearing held on 9/30/2015. Oral argument held on discovery matters. The parties make their arguments to the Court. Formal order to follow. (Recorded by COURTSMART.) Hearing held 10:37 AM to 12:28 PM.
ORDER: IT IS ORDERED that Plaintiff's Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(1)(A)(iv) request is GRANTED. On or before 10/16/15, Defendants shall produce to Plaintiff for inspection and copying their primary and first-layer excess insurance policies. Plaintiff's request for further compensation documents is DENIED. Plaintiff's request for the results of a 35-term search of Sara McKinnon's emails is GRANTED IN PART. Plaintiff's request for underwriting documents is DENIED. On or before 10/16/15, Defendants shall bring before the Court their opposition to the deposition of Jack McGarry. The written discovery deadline is extended. Plaintiff's request for training materials and logs is GRANTED. Plaintiff's request for additional scorecards is DENIED. (See attached PDF for complete information). Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 9/30/15.
TRANSCRIPT REQUEST by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group for proceedings held on 09/30/2015, Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro hearing judge(s).
TRANSCRIPT of ORAL ARGUMENT held on 09/30/2015, before Judge D. THOMAS FERRARO. Court Reporter Cindy J. Shearman. The ordering party will have electronic access to the transcript immediately. All others may view the transcript at the court public terminal or it may be purchased through the Court Reporter by filing a Transcript Order Form on the docket before the deadline for Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained through PACER. Redaction Request due 10/28/2015. Redacted Transcript Deadline set for 11/9/2015. Release of Transcript Restriction set for 1/5/2016.
NOTICE of Deposition of Mary Fuller, filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
MOTION to Quash Subpoena Duces Tecum by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Exhibit 7
DECLARATION of Counsel (Jeffrey K. Rubin) re: 177 MOTION to Quash Subpoena Duces Tecum by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
DECLARATION of Randall Knuth, DDS re: 177 MOTION to Quash Subpoena Duces Tecum by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
NOTICE of Deposition of EDWARD J. BERGHAUSEN, M.D., filed by Randall Knuth.
RESPONSE to Motion re: 156 MOTION to Compel Requests for Production No. 62 and 63 filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE re: Intent to Issue Subpoenas for Production of Documents by Randall Knuth.
MOTION for Admission Pro Hac Vice as to attorney Melissa M. Cowan by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
PRO HAC VICE FEE PAID. $ 35, receipt number PHX163846 as to Melissa M Cowan. This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no PDF document associated with this entry. (Text entry; no document attached.)
ORDER pursuant to General Order 09-08 granting 185 Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice. Per the Court's Administrative Policies and Procedures Manual, applicant has five (5) days in which to register as a user of the Electronic Filing System. Registration to be accomplished via the court's website at www.azd.uscourts.gov. Counsel is advised that they are limited to two (2) additional e-mail addresses in their District of Arizona User Account. (BAS) (This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no.pdf document associated with this entry.)
NOTICE of Deposition of Lisa Ordonez, filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 156 MOTION to Compel Requests for Production No. 62 and 63 filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Ex. 19 - Benson Deposition Excerpts
Exhibit Ex. 20 - Filed Under Seal
Exhibit Ex. 21 - Philbin Deposition Excerpts
Exhibit Ex. 22 - McKinnon Email
NOTICE re: LODGING UNDER SEAL and CERTIFICATION OF COUNSEL by Randall Knuth re: 188 Reply to Response to Motion.
Filed at Doc. 425 --SEALED LODGED Proposed Excerpt from Deposition of Suzanne Benson, M.D. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115019369" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115019369','885354','476','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Exhibit Ex. 20 - Page 152 of Benson Deposition) Modified on 5/13/2016
MOTION for Protective Order by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Exhibit Declaration
Response in Opposition to 160 MOTION PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR EXCEPTIONAL RELIEF FROM SCHEDULING ORDER AND TO SET REASONABLE FEE FOR EXPERT WITNESS DEPOSITION RE: DR. BERGHAUSEN (Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Exceptional Relief from Scheduling Order and to Set Reasonable Fee for Expert Witness Deposition of Dr. Berghausen) filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group., changed event from affidavit to response to motion.
Declaration of Stephen M. Bressler
Exhibit A to Stephen M. Bressler Declaration
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115021153" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115021153','885354','482','','2','1','',''}};">3</a> Declaration of Pamela McMillian) Modified on 10/19/2015
MOTION to Quash Subpoena Served on Third-Party Witness and Designated Defense Expert Edward J. Berghausen, M.D.; Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support Thereof by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Declaration of Pamela McMillian
RESPONSE to Plaintiff's Supplemental Memorandum by Defendants Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE re: re: SERVICE OF PLAINTIFFS OBJECTION TO CONFIDENTIALITY DESIGNATION by Randall Knuth.
NOTICE of Deposition of Randall Prust, MD, filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE re: of Service of Defendants' First Supplemental Disclosure Statement by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
*MOTION RULE 26(b)(5)(B) MOTION FOR DETERMINATION AS TO PRIVILEGE (Redacted) by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Ex. 1 - Claim File Excerpts
Exhibit Ex. 2 - Filed Under Seal
Exhibit Ex. 3 - Communication between Counsel
Exhibit Ex. 4 - Unum Claims Manual Excerpts
Exhibit Ex. 5 - Filed Under Seal
Exhibit Ex. 6 - Privilege Log
Exhibit Ex. 7 - Unum Claims Manual Excerpts
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115058071" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115058071','885354','501','','2','1','',''}};">8</a> Text of Proposed Order) *Modified restriction to seal for attchment #1 on 10/26/2015
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin re: 200 MOTION RULE 26(b)(5)(B) MOTION FOR DETERMINATION AS TO PRIVILEGE (Redacted) by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
NOTICE of Confidential Doc. Designation Lodging & Certification of Counsel pursuant to LRCiv.5.6.d.
(Filed at 316)-SEALED LODGED Proposed Un-redacted Motion & Exhibits Filed Under Seal re: 200 MOTION RULE 26(b)(5)(B) MOTION FOR DETERMINATION AS TO PRIVILEGE (Redacted) re: 256 Motion to Seal. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Attachment 1 - Un-redacted Motion for Determination as to Privilege
Exhibit Ex. 2 to Motion
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115058115" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115058115','885354','508','','2','1','',''}};">3</a> Exhibit Ex. 5 to Motion) *Modified to add link to motion to seal on 11/13/2015 (CEI). Modified on 12/14/2015
Third MOTION to Compel Further Deposition Testimony by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Ex. 1 - Robin Rose Deposition Excerpts
Exhibit Ex. 2 - Diane Cahill Deposition Excerpts
Exhibit Ex. 3 - Claim File Excerpts
Exhibit Ex. 4 - Jerome Philbin, M.D., Deposition Excerpts
Exhibit Ex. 5 - Rubin letter to Bressler & Maguire
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin re: 204 Third MOTION to Compel Further Deposition Testimony by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
RESPONSE in Opposition re: 177 MOTION to Quash Subpoena Duces Tecum to (1) Health Care Consulting and Accounting, PLLC and (2) Metzger, Klawon & Fox, PLC filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Declaration of Daniel W. Maguire
Exhibit A to Declaration of Daniel W. Maguire
Exhibit B to Declaration of Daniel W. Maguire
Fourth MOTION to Compel (TO ENFORCE COURT ORDER, DOC. 169) AND SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM AND REQUEST FOR EXPEDITED RULING by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Ex. 1 - Discovery Response Excerpts
Errata Ex. 2 - Filed Under Seal
Exhibit Ex. 3 - Filed Under Seal
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin re: 207 Fourth MOTION to Compel (TO ENFORCE COURT ORDER, DOC. 169) AND SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM AND REQUEST FOR EXPEDITED RULING by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
(Filed at 317)-SEALED LODGED Proposed Notice of Lodging Under Seal With Proposed Sealed Exhibits re: 207 Fourth MOTION to Compel (TO ENFORCE COURT ORDER, DOC. 169) AND SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM AND REQUEST FOR EXPEDITED RULING re: 248 Motion to Seal. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Un-Redacted Motion to Compel
Exhibit Ex. 2 to Motion - Learning Logs
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115060045" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115060045','885354','527','','2','1','',''}};">3</a> Exhibit Ex. 3 to Motion - Letter to Defense Counsel) *Modified to add link to motion to seal on 11/13/2015 (CEI). Modified on 12/14/2015
MOTION to Seal Document 200 MOTION RULE 26(b)(5)(B) MOTION FOR DETERMINATION AS TO PRIVILEGE (Redacted) by Randall Knuth.
NOTICE of Errata re: 200 MOTION RULE 26(b)(5)(B) MOTION FOR DETERMINATION AS TO PRIVILEGE (Redacted) by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Ex. 1 - Redacted
ORDER granting 131 Motion for Protective Order Regarding Confidentiality Designations. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 10/26/2015. (See attached Order for complete information)
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 194 MOTION to Quash Subpoena Served on Third-Party Witness and Designated Defense Expert Edward J. Berghausen, M.D.; Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support Thereof, 160 MOTION PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR EXCEPTIONAL RELIEF FROM SCHEDULING ORDER AND TO SET REASONABLE FEE FOR EXPERT WITNESS DEPOSITION RE: DR. BERGHAUSEN PLAINTIFFS REPLY TO DEFENDANTS OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR EXCEPTIONAL RELIEF FROM SCHEDULING ORDER AND TO SET REASONABLE FEE FOR EXPERT WITNESS DEPOSITION OF DR. BERGHAUSEN filed by Randall Knuth.
ORDER that the Clerk of Court shall file on the public record Exhibits 8, 9, and 10 to Plaintiff's Response in Opposition to Defendants' Motion for Protective Order Re Confidentiality Designations (Doc. 140), which were lodged at Doc. 142. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 10/26/2015.
Additional Attachments to Main Document re: Exhibits 8, 9, and 10 to 140 Response to Motion by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115063009" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115063009','885354','545','','2','1','',''}};">2</a> Exhibit 10)
NOTICE of Deposition of Michael F. Hannley, filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Fifth MOTION to Compel Documents pursuant to Discovery Requests by Randall Knuth.
Sixth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION NOS. 116-122, 125-131, 133, 138, 142, 143, 144, 145-151, 152, 155, 165, 167-68 by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Exhibit 4 - Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 5 - Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 6 - Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 7 - Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 8 - Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 9 - Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 10 - Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 11
Exhibit Exhibit 12 - Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 13
Exhibit Exhibit 15
Exhibit Exhibit 16
Exhibit Exhibit 17 - Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 18
Exhibit Exhibit 19 - Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 20
Exhibit Exhibit 21
Exhibit Exhibit 22
Exhibit Exhibit 23
Exhibit Exhibit 24
Exhibit Exhibit 25
Exhibit Exhibit 26
Exhibit Exhibit 27
Exhibit Exhibit 28
Exhibit Exhibit 29
Exhibit Exhibit 30
Exhibit Exhibit 31
Exhibit Exhibit 32
33 Attachments ▼
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin in Support of Plaintiff's 6th Motion to Compel re: 219 Sixth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION NOS. 116-122, 125-131, 133, 138, 142, 143, 144, 145-151, 152, 155, 165, 167-68 by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: LODGING UNDER SEAL and CERTIFICATION OF COUNSEL re: PLAINTIFF'S 6th MOTION TO COMPEL by Randall Knuth re: 219 Sixth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION NOS. 116-122, 125-131, 133, 138, 142, 143, 144, 145-151, 152, 155, 165, 167-68.
Filed in part at 318 ; Filed in part at 336 - SEALED LODGED Proposed Notice of Lodging Under Seal With Proposed Sealed Exhibits re: 219 Sixth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION NOS. 116-122, 125-131, 133, 138, 142, 143, 144, 145-151, 152, 155, 165, 167-68. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Un-redacted 6th Motion to Compel
Exhibit Exhibit 8
Exhibit Exhibit 9
Exhibit Exhibit 10
Exhibit Exhibit 12
Exhibit Exhibit 17
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115085391" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115085391','885354','560','','2','1','',''}};">11</a> Exhibit Exhibit 19) Modified on 12/15/2015 (CEI). Modified on 12/18/2015
NOTICE of Deposition of Scott Styrmoe, filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Subpoena to Testify
RESPONSE in Opposition re: 194 MOTION to Quash Subpoena Served on Third-Party Witness and Designated Defense Expert Edward J. Berghausen, M.D.; Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support Thereof filed by Randall Knuth.
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin re: 224 Response in Opposition to Motion to Quash Subpoena Served on Third-Party Witness and Designated Defense Expert Edward J. Berghausen, M.D. filed by Randall Knuth.
Seventh MOTION to Compel RFPS 172, 178, 179, 181, 183-186 and Supporting Memorandum by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Exhibit 6 Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 7 Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 8 Lodged Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 10 Lodged Under Seal
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin in Support of Plaintiff's 7th Motion to Compel re: 226 Seventh MOTION to Compel RFPS 172, 178, 179, 181, 183-186 and Supporting Memorandum by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: Notice of Lodging Under Seal & Certification of Counsel by Randall Knuth re: 226 Seventh MOTION to Compel RFPS 172, 178, 179, 181, 183-186 and Supporting Memorandum, 227 Declaration.
Filed at Doc. 319 --SEALED LODGED Proposed Notice of Lodging Under Seal With Proposed Sealed Exhibits re: 226 Seventh MOTION to Compel RFPS 172, 178, 179, 181, 183-186 and Supporting Memorandum. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Exhibit 5 Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 6 Under Seal
Exhibit Exhibit 7 Under Seal
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115087827" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115087827','885354','581','','2','1','',''}};">6</a> Exhibit Exhibit 10 Under Seal) Modified on 12/15/2015
Eighth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION 192, 193, 196 and SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM by Randall Knuth.
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin in Support of Plaintiff's 8th Motion to Compel re: 230 Eighth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION 192, 193, 196 and SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: Notice of Lodging Under Seal & Certification of Counsel by Randall Knuth re: 230 Eighth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION 192, 193, 196 and SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM, 231 Declaration.
Filed in part at 320 ; filed in part at 337 - SEALED LODGED Proposed Notice of Lodging Under Seal With Proposed Sealed Exhibits re: 230 Eighth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION 192, 193, 196 and SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Exhibit 1 - with highlights
Exhibit Exhibit 2 - with highlights
Exhibit Exhibit 3 - with highlights
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115088053" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115088053','885354','593','','2','1','',''}};">5</a> Exhibit Exhibit 5 Lodged Under Seal) Modified on 12/15/2015 (CEI). Modified on 12/18/2015
Ninth MOTION to Compel PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO DEEM REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS ADMITTED OR COMPEL AUTHENTICATION OF DOCUMENTS by Randall Knuth.
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin re: 234 Ninth MOTION to Compel PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO DEEM REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS ADMITTED OR COMPEL AUTHENTICATION OF DOCUMENTS by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin re: 218 Fifth MOTION to Compel Documents pursuant to Discovery Requests by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
*RESPONSE to Motion re: 191 MOTION for Protective Order, Memorandum of Points and Authorities filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Exhibit L - Filed Under Seal
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115090892" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115090892','885354','606','','2','1','',''}};">14</a> Exhibit) *Modified to correct event type on 11/3/2015
*NOTICE re: of Filing Under Seal & Certification of Counsel by Randall Knuth re: 238 RESPONSE to Motion. *Modified to correct docket text for doc. 238 on 11/3/2015
Filed at Doc. 321 --SEALED LODGED Proposed Lodging Under Seal - With Sealed Exhibit. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115090899" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115090899','885354','615','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Exhibit Exhibit L - Under Seal) Modified on 12/15/2015
MOTION for Extension of Time Unopposed Motion to Extend Dispositive Motion Filing Deadline by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE of Deposition of Scott Styrmoe (Amended), filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 177 MOTION to Quash Subpoena Duces Tecum filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit 8 - Part 1
Exhibit 8 - Part 2
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin re: 243 Reply to Response to Motion to Quash Subpoena Duces Tecum by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: Service re: Plaintiff's Objection to Confidentiality Designations by Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: SERVICE OF PLAINTIFFS OBJECTION TO CONFIDENTIALITY DESIGNATIONS by Randall Knuth re: Diane Cahill.
*MOTION to Seal Document 210 Exhibits 2 and 3 by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115125821" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115125821','885354','633','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Text of Proposed Order) *Modified to correct document link and text on 11/13/2015
RESPONSE to Motion re: 207 Fourth MOTION to Compel (TO ENFORCE COURT ORDER, DOC. 169) AND SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM AND REQUEST FOR EXPEDITED RULING filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 191 MOTION for Protective Order filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 194 MOTION to Quash Subpoena Served on Third-Party Witness and Designated Defense Expert Edward J. Berghausen, M.D.; Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support Thereof filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
APPEAL OF MAGISTRATE JUDGE DECISION TO DISTRICT COURT by Randall Knuth re: 213 Order on Motion for Protective Order.
*RESPONSE to Motion re: 200 MOTION RULE 26(b)(5)(B) MOTION FOR DETERMINATION AS TO PRIVILEGE (Redacted) and CROSS MOTION TO DISQUALIFY PLANTIFF'S COUNSEL AND STRIKE UN-REDACTED BRIEF filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115130972" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115130972','885354','649','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Exhibit A-J) *Modified to correct event type on 11/13/2015
SEALED LODGED Proposed Exhibit to Doc. 253. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
RESPONSE in Opposition re: 204 Third MOTION to Compel Further Deposition Testimony (Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiff's Third Motion to Compel) filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Declaration of Daniel W. Maguire In Support of Opposition to Plaintiff's Third Motion to Compel
MOTION to Seal Document 202 Notice of Confidential Doc. Designation Lodging (LRCiv 5.6.(d)) by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
ORDER Defendants' Motion to Extend (Doc. 241) is GRANTED. The dispositive motion filing deadline is extended to 1/4/2016. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 11/12/2015.
RESPONSE to Motion re: 218 Fifth MOTION to Compel Documents pursuant to Discovery Requests filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Sara McKinnon's Deposition Testimony by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
*MOTION to Seal Document 126 Exhibits by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115157048" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115157048','885354','675','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Text of Proposed Order) *Modified link on 11/20/2015
*MOTION to Seal Document 190 Exhibits by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115157179" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115157179','885354','678','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Text of Proposed Order) *Modified link on 11/20/2015
*MOTION to Seal Document 233 Sealed Lodged Proposed Document, 240 Sealed Lodged Proposed Document, 222 Sealed Lodged Proposed Document, 229 Sealed Lodged Proposed Document by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115157439" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115157439','885354','681','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Text of Proposed Order) *Modified link on 11/20/2015
RESPONSE to Motion re: 219 Sixth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION NOS. 116-122, 125-131, 133, 138, 142, 143, 144, 145-151, 152, 155, 165, 167-68 filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
RESPONSE to Motion re: 234 Ninth MOTION to Compel PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO DEEM REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS ADMITTED OR COMPEL AUTHENTICATION OF DOCUMENTS filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Declaration of Susan Vautin
RESPONSE to Motion re: 226 Seventh MOTION to Compel RFPS 172, 178, 179, 181, 183-186 and Supporting Memorandum filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
*RESPONSE to Motion re: 230 Eighth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION 192, 193, 196 and SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM (Defendants' Response to Plaintiff's 8th Motion to Compel Re: Requests for Production 192, 193 and 196 [Redacted]) filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115159064" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115159064','885354','699','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Declaration of Jennifer Bagley [Redacted]) * Document is not in compliance with L.R.Civ 7.1(c); attorney notified on 11/20/2015
Filed at Doc. 322 --SEALED LODGED Proposed [Unredacted] Defendants' Response to Plaintiff 8th Motion to Compel and Supporting Declaration. Document to be filed by Clerk if 268 Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
[Unredacted] Response (Doc. 266)
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115160017" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115160017','885354','703','','2','1','',''}};">2</a> [Unredacted] Dec. of Jennifer Bagley (Doc. 266-1)) *Modified to link to Motion to Seal on 11/20/2015 (SCH). Modified on 12/15/2015
MOTION to Seal Document 267 Sealed Lodged Proposed Document by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Declaration of Holly Crawford
NOTICE of Deposition of Scott Styrmoe (Second Amended), filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Pursuant to LRCiv 7.2(f) of the Rules of Practice of the United States District Court for the District of Arizona, IT IS ORDERED setting TELEPHONIC oral argument re: 177 MOTION to Quash Subpoena Duces Tecum filed by Randall Knuth, 194 MOTION to Quash Subpoena Served on Third-Party Witness and Designated Defense Expert Edward J. Berghausen, M.D. filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Unum Group, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, 160 MOTION FOR EXCEPTIONAL RELIEF FROM SCHEDULING ORDER AND TO SET REASONABLE FEE FOR EXPERT WITNESS DEPOSITION RE: DR. BERGHAUSEN filed by Randall Knuth, 204 Third MOTION to Compel Further Deposition Testimony filed by Randall Knuth, 191 MOTION for Protective Order filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Unum Group, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, 207 Fourth MOTION to Compel AND REQUEST FOR EXPEDITED RULING filed by Randall Knuth, 156 MOTION to Compel Requests for Production No. 62 and 63 filed by Randall Knuth. Motion Hearing set for 12/1/2015 at 03:30PM before Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro. The Court will initiate the call. Ordered by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro. (This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no PDF document associated with this entry.)
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 207 Fourth MOTION to Compel (TO ENFORCE COURT ORDER, DOC. 169) AND SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM AND REQUEST FOR EXPEDITED RULING filed by Randall Knuth.
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin re: 271 Reply to Response to Motion re: 207 Fourth Motion to Compel. filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit 5, PART 1
Exhibit 5, PART 2
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 218 Fifth MOTION to Compel Documents pursuant to Discovery Requests filed by Randall Knuth.
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin re: 273 Reply to Response to Motion re: 218 Fifth Motion to Compel. filed by Randall Knuth.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 204 Third MOTION to Compel Further Deposition Testimony filed by Randall Knuth.
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin re: 275 Reply to Response to Motion re: 204 Third Motion to Compel. filed by Randall Knuth.
ORDER granting 211 Motion to Seal Document [200-1] Exhibit 1 to Plaintiff's RULE 26(b)(5)(B) MOTION FOR DETERMINATION AS TO PRIVILEGE (Redacted). Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 11/23/2015.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 253 MOTION to Disqualify Counsel Motion for Determination of Privilege filed by Randall Knuth.
STIPULATION for Extension of Time to Respond to Plaintiff's Objection to Magistrate's October 26, 2015 Order (Doc. No. 213) by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
STIPULATION RESPONSE TO MOTION TO DISQUALIFY PLAINTIFFS COUNSEL (DOC. 253) by Randall Knuth.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 219 Sixth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION NOS. 116-122, 125-131, 133, 138, 142, 143, 144, 145-151, 152, 155, 165, 167-68 filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit 37 (Under Seal)
Exhibit 43 (Under Seal)
Exhibit 44 (Under Seal)
Exhibit 46 (Under Seal)
Exhibit 47 (Under Seal)
19 Attachments ▼
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin re: 281 Reply to Response to Motion to Plaintiff's 6th Motion to Compel by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: LODGING UNDER SEAL and CERTIFICATION OF COUNSEL by Randall Knuth re: 281 Reply to Response to Motion re: Plaintiff's 6th Motion to Compel.
Filed at Doc. 426 --SEALED LODGED Proposed Notice of Lodging Under Seal With Proposed Sealed Exhibits re: 313 Motion to Seal. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Un-redacted Reply
Exhibit 37 - Under Seal
Exhibit 43 - Under Seal
Exhibit 44 - Under Seal
Exhibit 46 - Under Seal
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115183245" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115183245','885354','760','','2','1','',''}};">6</a> Exhibit 47 - Under Seal) *Modified to add link to motion to seal on 12/15/2015 (CEI). Modified on 5/13/2016
ORDER pursuant to 279 Stipulation : Defendants The Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, and Unum Group may have up to, and including, Monday, December 7, 2015 to file their response to Plaintiff's Objection to Magistrate's October 26, 2015 Order (Doc. No. 252). Signed by Chief Judge Raner C Collins on 11/25/2015.
ORDER that the 280 Stipulation is GRANTED. Plaintiff's response to the cross-motion filed at Doc. 253 shall be filed on or before December 7,2015. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 11/25/2015.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 226 Seventh MOTION to Compel RFPS 172, 178, 179, 181, 183-186 and Supporting Memorandum filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit 16 - McKinnon Deposition Excerpts
Exhibit 17 - Filed Under Seal
Exhibit 18 - Filed Under Seal
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin re: 287 Reply to Response to Motion to Compel (#7) by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: LODGING UNDER SEAL and CERTIFICATION OF COUNSEL (IN CONNECTION WITH PLAINTIFFS REPLY TO PLAINTIFFS 7TH MOTION TO COMPEL) by Randall Knuth re: 287 Reply to Response to Motion.
Filed at Doc. 428 --SEALED LODGED Proposed Notice of Lodging Under Seal With Proposed Sealed Exhibits re: 226 Seventh MOTION to Compel RFPS 172, 178, 179, 181, 183-186 and Supporting Memorandum. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Exhibit 17 - Filed Under Seal
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115187892" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115187892','885354','779','','2','1','',''}};">3</a> Exhibit Exhibit 18 - Filed Under Seal) Modified on 5/13/2016
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 230 Eighth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION 192, 193, 196 and SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM (Redacted) filed by Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: LODGING UNDER SEAL and CERTIFICATION OF COUNSEL re: PLAINTIFF's 8th MOTION TO COMPEL by Randall Knuth re: 291 Reply to Response to Motion.
Filed at Doc. 393 --SEALED LODGED Proposed Lodging Under Seal - With Sealed Exhibit re: 230 Eighth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION 192, 193, 196 and SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115188023" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115188023','885354','788','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Exhibit Un-redacted Reply) Modified on 4/4/2016
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 234 Ninth MOTION to Compel PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO DEEM REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS ADMITTED OR COMPEL AUTHENTICATION OF DOCUMENTS filed by Randall Knuth.
MINUTE ENTRY for proceedings held before Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro: Telephonic Hearing held on 12/1/2015. Oral argument held on discovery matters. The parties make their arguments to the Court. Formal order to follow. (Recorded by COURTSMART.) Hearing held 3:40 PM to 5:15 PM.
TRANSCRIPT REQUEST by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group for proceedings held on 12/01/2015, Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro hearing judge(s).
TRANSCRIPT REQUEST by Randall Knuth for proceedings held on 12/01/2015, Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro hearing judge(s).
ORDER Plaintiff's 156 Motion to Compel Re: RFPs No. 62 and 63 is GRANTED. Plaintiff's 160 Motion for Exceptional Relief from Scheduling Order and to Set Reasonable Fee for Expert Witness Deposition re: Dr. Berghausen is DENIED as moot regarding the Courts schedule and subpoena, and DENIED without prejudice as to Dr. Berghausen's fee. Defendants' 194 Motion to Quash Subpoena Served on Third-Party Witness and Designated Defense Expert Edward J. Berghausen, M.D. is GRANTED. Plaintiff's 177 Motion to Quash Subpoenas Duces Tecum is GRANTED. Defendants' 191 Motion for Protective Order is DENIED. Plaintiff's 207 Fourth Motion to Compel is DENIED. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 12/1/2015. (See attached Order for details)
MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Suzanne Benson's Deposition Testimony by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REQUEST for Judicial Notice in Support of Defendants' Motion for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Suzanne Benson's Deposition Testimony by Defendants Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
RESPONSE re: 252 Appeal of Mag Judge Decision to Dist Court (Rule 72(a) Objection) by Defendants Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
RESPONSE in Opposition re: 259 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Sara McKinnon's Deposition Testimony filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Defendants' Confidential Designations
Exhibit McKinnon Deposition Excerpts
Exhibit McKinnon Deposition Exhibit 5
Exhibit Cahill Email
Filed at Doc. 430 --SEALED LODGED Proposed Notice of Lodging Under Seal With Proposed Sealed Exhibit re: 259 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Sara McKinnon's Deposition Testimony. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115221174" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115221174','885354','816','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Exhibit Deposition Excerpts Filed Under Seal) Modified on 5/13/2016
RESPONSE in Opposition re: 253 MOTION to Disqualify Counsel filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit 9 - Defendants' Initial Disclosure Statement
Exhibit 10 - Mauer - Haas Exhibits
Exhibit 11 - Various Deposition Excerpts
DECLARATION of Patrick W. Mause re: 305 Response in Opposition to Motion Defendants' Cross-Motion for Disqualification by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
DECLARATION of Lynda C. Shely re: 305 Response in Opposition to Motion Defendants' Cross-Motion for Disqualification by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
DECLARATION of Steven C. Dawson re: 305 Response in Opposition to Motion Defendants' Cross-Motion for Disqualification by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
Filed at Doc. 429 --SEALED LODGED Proposed Notice of Lodging Under Seal with Un-redacted Plaintiffs Response to Defendants Cross-Motion for Disqualification. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Randall Knuth.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115221307" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115221307','885354','832','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Exhibit Un-redacted Response) Modified on 5/13/2016
TRANSCRIPT of ORAL ARGUMENT held on 12/01/2015, before Judge D. THOMAS FERRARO. Transcriber Cindy J. Shearman. The ordering party will have electronic access to the transcript immediately. All others may view the transcript at the court public terminal or it may be purchased through the Transcriber by filing a Transcript Order Form on the docket before the deadline for Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained through PACER. Redaction Request due 12/29/2015. Redacted Transcript Deadline set for 1/8/2016. Release of Transcript Restriction set for 3/7/2016.
MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Diane Cahill's Deposition Testimony by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE re: SERVICE OF PLAINTIFFS OBJECTION TO CONFIDENTIALITY DESIGNATIONS by Randall Knuth (re: Mary Fuller).
MOTION to Seal Document - Unredacted Reply and Exhibits Filed Under Seal at Doc. 284 by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
RESPONSE in Opposition re: 311 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Diane Cahill's Deposition Testimony filed by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Flynn Email
Exhibit Beltran Email
Exhibit Confidential Designations
ORDER granting Motions to Seal (Docs. 248, 256, 262, 268. The Clerk of Court shall SEAL Plaintiffs Rule 26(b)(5)(B) Motion for Determination as to Privilege (unredacted), and Exhibits 2 and 5; Plaintiffs 4th Motion to Compel (unredacted) and Exhibits 2 and 3; Plaintiffs 6th Motion to Compel (unredacted) and Exhibits 4, 5, 6 and 12; Plaintiffs 7th Motion to Compel (unredacted) and Exhibits 5, 6, 7, 8, and 10; Plaintiffs 8th Motion to Compel (unredacted) and Exhibit 5; Plaintiffs Response to Defendants Motion for Protective Order, Exhibit L; and Defendants Response to Plaintiffs 8th Motion to Compel. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 12/11/2015.
SEALED MOTION for Rule 26(b)(5)(B) Motion for Determination as to Privilege (Redacted) by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit 2 to Motion
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115249725" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115249725','885354','851','','2','1','',''}};">2</a> Exhibit 5 to Motion)
SEALED Fourth MOTION to Compel (to Enforce Court Order, Doc. 169) and Supporting Memorandum and Request for Expedited Ruling by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit 2 to Motion - Learning Logs
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115249775" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115249775','885354','853','','2','1','',''}};">2</a> Exhibit 3 to Motion - Letter to Defense Counsel)
SEALED (Unredacted) Sixth MOTION to Compel: Requests for Production Nos. 116-122, 125-131, 133, 138, 142, 143, 144, 145-151, 152, 155, 165, 167-68 and Supporting Memorandum by Randall Knuth.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115251409" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115251409','885354','858','','2','1','',''}};">4</a> Exhibit 12)
SEALED (Unredacted) Seventh MOTION to Compel - RFPS 172, 178, 179, 181, 183-186 - and Supporting Memorandum by Randall Knuth.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115251446" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115251446','885354','860','','2','1','',''}};">5</a> Exhibit 10)
SEALED (Unredacted) Eighth MOTION to Compel Re: Requests for Production 192, 193, 196 and Supporting Memorandum by Randall Knuth.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115251497" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115251497','885354','862','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Exhibit 5)
Sealed Document: Exhibit L to 238 RESPONSE to Motion re: 191 MOTION for Protective Order, Memorandum of Points and Authorities filed by Randall Knuth.
(Unredacted) RESPONSE to Motion re: 230 Eighth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION 192, 193, 196 and SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115251712" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115251712','885354','866','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Declaration of Jennifer Bagley)
RESPONSE to Motion re: 300 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Suzanne Benson's Deposition Testimony filed by Randall Knuth.
Joint MOTION to Seal Document - Substitute Documents Lodged Under Seal (Docs. 124 and 228) by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE re: Lodging Under Seal (in Connection with Joint Motion to Substitute Documents Lodged Under Seal) by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
FILED AT DOC. 449 --SEALED LODGED Proposed Substitute Exhibit 5 to Plaintiff's Seventh Motion to Compel (Doc. 228). Document to be filed by Clerk if 324 Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group. *Modified to link to Motion to Seal on 12/16/2015 (SCH). Modified on 6/14/2016
FILED AT DOC. 450 --SEALED LODGED Proposed Substitute Exhibit 8 to Plaintiff's Reply to Defendants' Response to Plaintiff's Objection to Magistrate's July 1, 2015 Order (Doc. 124). Document to be filed by Clerk if 324 Motion or Stipulation to Seal is granted. Filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group. *Modified to link to Motion to Seal on 12/16/2015 (SCH). Modified on 6/14/2016
REPLY re: 302 Response re Plaintiff's Reply In Support of Objection to Magistrate's October 26, 2015 Order (Protective Order, Doc. 213) by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
OBJECTION re: 299 Order, Terminate Motions Defendants' Objection to Magistrate Judge's Order at Doc. 299 by Defendants Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
DECLARATION re: 329 Objection Declaration of David Harvey by Defendants Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 253 MOTION to Disqualify Counsel filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 259 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Sara McKinnon's Deposition Testimony filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
MOTION to Seal Document (Un-Redacted Reply and Exhibits Filed Under Seal at Doc. 290) by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
MOTION to Seal Document (Un-Redacted Reply Filed Under Seal at Doc. 293) by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
ORDER that the Clerk of Court shall file on the public record Exhibits 7-10, 17 and 19 to Plaintiff's 6th Motion to Compel (lodged at Doc. 222), and Exhibits 1-3 (unredacted) to Plaintiff's 8th Motion to Compel (lodged at Doc. 233). Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 12/18/2015.
Additional Attachments to Main Document re: 319 SEALED (Unredacted) Sixth MOTION to Compel: Requests for Production Nos. 116-122, 125-131, 133, 138, 142, 143, 144, 145-151, 152, 155, 165, 167-68 and Supporting Memorandum by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115269588" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115269588','885354','905','','2','1','',''}};">5</a> Exhibit 19)
Additional Attachments to Main Document re: 320 SEALED (Unredacted) Eighth MOTION to Compel Re: Requests for Production 192, 193, 196 and Supporting Memorandum by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115269618" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115269618','885354','908','','2','1','',''}};">2</a> Exhibit 3)
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 311 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Diane Cahill's Deposition Testimony filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 300 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Suzanne Benson's Deposition Testimony filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE re: of Service of Plaintiff's Objection to Confidentiality Designations re: Lisa D. Ordonez, Ph.D. by Randall Knuth.
MOTION to Seal Document 309 Sealed Lodged Proposed Document, 304 Sealed Lodged Proposed Document by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
MOTION for Extension of Time Extension of Rule 56 Filing Deadline Pending District Court's Ruling on Defendants' Appeal of Magistrate Judge's Order by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
ORDER granting 343 Motion for Extension of Time Deadline. The dispositive motion filing deadline is extended to February 12, 2016. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 12/28/2015.
RESPONSE in Opposition re: 313 MOTION to Seal Document - Unredacted Reply and Exhibits Filed Under Seal at Doc. 284 filed by Randall Knuth.
RESPONSE re: 329 Objection TO MAGISTRATE JUDGES ORDER AT DOC. 299 (DOC. 329) by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: Service of Plaintiffs Objection to Confidentiality Designations Re: Edwin A. Locke, Ph.D. by Randall Knuth.
RESPONSE to Motion re: 333 MOTION to Seal Document (Un-Redacted Reply and Exhibits Filed Under Seal at Doc. 290) filed by Randall Knuth.
NOTICE of Errata re: 303 Response in Opposition to Motion for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Sara McKinnon's Deposition Testimony (Doc. 259) by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
*RESPONSE in Opposition re: 341 MOTION to Seal Document 309 Sealed Lodged Proposed Document, 304 Sealed Lodged Proposed Document filed by Randall Knuth. *Modified to correct event type on 1/8/2016
NOTICE OF ATTORNEY'S CHANGE OF ADDRESS/FIRM NAME by Stephen M Bressler.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 313 MOTION to Seal Document - Unredacted Reply and Exhibits Filed Under Seal at Doc. 284 filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Mary Fuller's Deposition Testimony by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
DECLARATION of Melissa M. Cowan re: 353 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Mary Fuller's Deposition Testimony. filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REQUEST for Judicial Notice in Support of Defendants' Motion for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Mary Fullert's Deposition Transcript by Defendants Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Declaration of Kelly Croce
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 333 MOTION to Seal Document (Un-Redacted Reply and Exhibits Filed Under Seal at Doc. 290) filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REPLY re: 329 Objection Defendants' Reply in Support of Objection to Magistrate Judge's Order at Doc. 299 by Defendants Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 341 MOTION to Seal Document 309 Sealed Lodged Proposed Document, 304 Sealed Lodged Proposed Document filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Lisa D. Ordonez's Deposition Testimony by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REQUEST re: for Judicial Notice ISO Defendants' Motion for Protective Order Re Portions of Lisa D. Ordonez's Deposition Transcript by Defendants Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Declaration of Rhonda Rigsby
MOTION for Extension of Time Defendants' Partially Unopposed Motion to Extend Deadline for McGarry Deposition by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
DECLARATION re: 361 MOTION for Extension of Time Defendants' Partially Unopposed Motion to Extend Deadline for McGarry Deposition Declaration of Daniel W. Maguire in Support of Defendants' Partially Unopposed Motion to Extend Deadline for McGarry Deposition by Defendants Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
ORDER granting 361 Defendants' Motion to Extend Deadline. The deadline to complete the deposition of Unum Group's Chief Financial Officer, John ("Jack") McGarry is extended until a date 45 days following the District Court's ruling on Defendants' pending Objection to Magistrate Judge's Order at Doc. 299. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 1/21/2016.
RESPONSE to Motion re: 353 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Mary Fuller's Deposition Testimony filed by Randall Knuth.
DECLARATION of Jeffrey K. Rubin re: 365 Response to Motion for Protective Order re: Portions of Mary Fuller's Deposition by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Edwin A. Locke, Ph.D.'s Deposition Testimony by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
REQUEST re: for Judicial Notice ISO Defendants' Motion for Protective Order Re Portions of Edwin A. Locke, Ph.D.'s Deposition Transcript by Defendants Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
RESPONSE to Motion re: 359 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Lisa D. Ordonez's Deposition Testimony filed by Randall Knuth.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 353 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Mary Fuller's Deposition Testimony filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Exhibit A - Declaration of Kelly Croce
*REPLY to Response to Motion re: 353 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Lisa A. Ordonez's Deposition Testimony filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group. *Modified to reflect proper name in docket text (clerk informed by attorney) on 2/5/2016
*DECLARATION of Melissa M. Cowan re: 371 Reply to Response to Motion for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Lisa D. Ordonez's Deposition Testimony. filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/025115451509" onClick="goDLS{{'/doc1/025115451509','885354','1007','','2','1','',''}};">1</a> Exhibit 1) *Modified to reflect proper name in docket text (clerk informed by attorney) on 2/5/2016
MOTION for Extension of Time Defendants' Motion to Extend February 12 Dispositive Motion Filing Deadline by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
RESPONSE in Opposition re: 373 MOTION for Extension of Time Defendants' Motion to Extend February 12 Dispositive Motion Filing Deadline - Third Request filed by Randall Knuth.
ORDER granting 373 Defendants' Motion to extend Dispositive Motion Filing Deadline. The dispositive motion filing deadline is set to 60 days following the District Court's ruling on Defendants' pending objection to Magistrate Judge's Order at Doc. 299. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 2/8/2016.
RESPONSE to Motion re: 367 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Edwin A. Locke, Ph.D.'s Deposition Testimony filed by Randall Knuth.
MOTION to Strike ERRATA SHEETS OF ROBIN ROSE AND DR. BERGAUSEN by Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Rose Deposition Excerpts
Exhibit Rose Corrections
Exhibit Berghausen Deposition Excerpts
Exhibit Berghausen Corrections
Exhibit Termination Letter
Exhibit Berghausen - Waller Deposition
DECLARATION of Steven C. Dawson re: 377 MOTION to Strike ERRATA SHEETS OF ROBIN ROSE AND DR. BERGAUSEN by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
Exhibit A - Rose Exhibit
Exhibit B - Berghausen Exhibit
Exhibit C - Berghausen CV
Exhibit D - Berghausen - Waller
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 367 MOTION for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Edwin A. Locke, Ph.D.'s Deposition Testimony Defendants' Reply in Support of Motion for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Edwin A. Locke, Ph.D's Deposition Testimony (Doc. 367) filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
DECLARATION of Melissa M. Cowan re: 379 Reply to Response to Motion Declaration of Melissa M. Cowan in Support of Defendants' Reply for Motion for Protective Order Regarding Portions of Edwin A. Locke, Ph.D's Deposition Testimony (Doc. 367). filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
RESPONSE in Opposition re: 377 MOTION to Strike ERRATA SHEETS OF ROBIN ROSE AND DR. BERGAUSEN Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Strike Errata Sheets of Robin Rose and Dr. Berghausen(Doc. 377) filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
Appendix to Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Strike Errata Sheets of Robin Rose and Dr. Berghausen
DECLARATION of Stephen M. Bressler re: 383 Response in Opposition to Motion to Strike Errata Sheets of Robin Rose and Dr. Berghausen. filed by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
SUPPLEMENT Notice of Supplemental Authority re: 200 MOTION RULE 26(b)(5)(B) MOTION FOR DETERMINATION AS TO PRIVILEGE (Redacted), 278 Reply to Response to Motion, 204 Third MOTION to Compel Further Deposition Testimony, 275 Reply to Response to Motion, 305 Response in Opposition to Motion by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
RESPONSE re: 385 Supplement Defendants' Response to Plaintiff's Notice of Supplemental Authority Regarding: Motion for Determination as to Privilege (Doc. 200); Response to Defendants' Cross-Motion for Disqualification (Doc. 305); and Plaintiff's Third Motion to Compel (Doc. 204) by Defendants Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
*DECLARATION of Nancy J. Smith re: 386 Response Declaration of Nancy J. Smith in support of Defendants' Response to Plaintiff's Notice of Supplemental Authority by Defendants Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group. *Document is not in compliance with L.R.Civ 7.1(c); attorney notified on 3/11/2016
NOTICE of Deposition of 30(b)(6) Designee - 2nd Amended Notice, filed by Randall Knuth.
REPLY to Response to Motion re: 377 MOTION to Strike ERRATA SHEETS OF ROBIN ROSE AND DR. BERGAUSEN filed by Randall Knuth.
NOTICE re: Notice of Supplemental Authority by Randall Knuth.
ORDER setting an oral argument on April 20, 2016, at 9:30 AM on the following motions: Plaintiff's Rule 26(b)(5)(B) Motion for Determination of Privilege (Doc. 200); Defendants' Cross-motion to Disqualify Plaintiff's Counsel and Strike Un-redacted Brief (Doc. 253); Plaintiff's Third Motion to Compel (Doc. 204); Plaintiff's Sixth Motion to Compel (Doc. 219); Plaintiff's Seventh Motion to Compel (Doc. 226); and Plaintiff's Motion to Deem Request for Admissions Admitted or Compel Authentication of Documents (Doc. 234). Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 3/25/2016.
ORDER that Plaintiff's 5th Motion to Compel (Doc. 218) is GRANTED. It is further Ordered that Plaintiff's 8th Motion to Compel (Docs. 230, 320) is DENIED as MOOT. It is further Ordered that the Court finds good cause to GRANT Defendants' unopposed Motion to Seal Plaintiff's un-redacted Reply in Support of Eighth Motion to Compel (Doc. 334). The Clerk of Court shall SEAL Plaintiff's un-redacted Reply in Support of Eighth Motion to Compel (lodged at Doc. 293). Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 4/1/2016.
(Unredacted) REPLY to Response to Motion re: 230 Eighth MOTION to Compel REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION 192, 193, 196 and SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM by Randall Knuth.
ORDER the hearing set on 4/20/2016, is VACATED. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that, on 4/27/2016, at 9:30 AM, the Court will hearing telephonic argument on the following motions: Plaintiff's Sixth Motion to Compel (Doc. 219); Plaintiff's Seventh Motion to Compel (Doc. 226); and Plaintiff's Motion to Deem Request for Admissions Admitted or Compel Authentication of Documents (Doc. 234). The Court will initiate the call. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that, on 5/19/2016, at 9:30 AM, the Court will hear argument in-person on the following motions: Plaintiff's Rule 26(b)(5)(B) Motion for Determination of Privilege (Doc. 200); Defendants' Cross-motion to Disqualify Plaintiff's Counsel and Strike Un-redacted Brief (Doc. 253); and Plaintiff's Third Motion to Compel (Doc. 204). Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 4/7/2016.
ORDER on Appeal of Magistrate Judge Decision to District Court. IT IS ORDERED Plaintiff's 87 Objection to Magistrate's 6/30/15 Order is DENIED, and all other requests for relief included in Plaintiff's Objection are DENIED. Signed by Chief Judge Raner C Collins on 4/12/16.
ORDER: IT IS ORDERED THAT, on or before 4/22/16, Defendants shall file in camera or under seal pages 163-67 of Fuller's deposition. Portions of these pages that are designated confidential shall be so marked. Signed by Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro on 4/14/16.
ORDER: IT IS ORDERED Plaintiff's 89 Objection to Magistrate's 7/1/15 Order, and all requests for relief contained therein are DENIED. Signed by Chief Judge Raner C Collins on 4/15/16.
NOTICE re: Notice of Service of Defendant Unum Group's Objections to Requests for Production Attached to Plaintiff's Second Amended Notice of Deposition Pursuant to FRCP 30(b)(6) by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
NOTICE re: Submission of Documents for in camera review by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
ORDER: IT IS ORDERED, Plaintiff's 252 Objection to Magistrate's 10/26/15 Order, and all requests for relief contained therein are DENIED. Signed by Chief Judge Raner C Collins on 4/25/16.
NOTICE of Errata re: 234 Ninth MOTION to Compel PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO DEEM REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS ADMITTED OR COMPEL AUTHENTICATION OF DOCUMENTS Re: Exhibit 3 by Plaintiff Randall Knuth.
Exhibit Corrected Exhibit 234-3
TRANSCRIPT REQUEST by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group for proceedings held on 04/27/2016, Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro hearing judge(s).
TRANSCRIPT REQUEST by Randall Knuth for proceedings held on 04/27/2016, Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro hearing judge(s).
TRANSCRIPT REQUEST by Randall Knuth for proceedings held on August 27, 2015, Magistrate Judge D Thomas Ferraro hearing judge(s).
NOTICE re: Service of Defendants' Third Supplemental Disclosure Statement by Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company, Unum Group.
MINUTE ENTRY for proceeding