Source: https://trellis.law/ca/issue-type/duty-of-dismissal-or-withdrawal---meritless-case-477
Timestamp: 2020-08-11 06:31:37
Document Index: 400906929

Matched Legal Cases: ['§ 6068', '§ 6106', '§ 6068', '§ 950', '§ 437', '§ 436', '§ 1942', '§ 7']

What is Settling Before Withdrawal?
(Based on The State Bar of California Standing Committee on Professional Responsibility and Conduct Formal Opinion No. 2019-198.)
An attorney is ethically prohibited from proceeding with a legal action in certain limited circumstances. (Rules of Prof. Conduct, Rule 1.16(a).) Under the State Bar Act, an attorney has a duty to “counsel or maintain those actions, proceedings, or defenses only as appear to him or her legal or just.” (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6068(c).) Furthermore, an attorney is prohibited from bringing or continuing an action “without probable cause and for the purpose of harassing or maliciously injuring any person.” (Rules of Prof. Conduct, Rule 3.1(a)(1).)
Withdrawal from a legal action is mandatory if
the lawyer knows or reasonably should know that the action is being taken without probable cause and for the purpose of harassing or maliciously injuring any person;
the lawyer knows or reasonably should know that continued employment will result in a violation of the Rules of Professional Conduct or the State Bar Act;
the lawyer’s mental or physical state renders it unreasonably difficult to effectively carry out the representation; or
the lawyer is discharged by the client.
(Rules of Prof. Conduct, Rule 1.16(a).)
A lawyer may withdraw from representing a client if:
the client insists upon presenting a claim or defense in litigation, or asserting a position or making a demand in a non-litigation matter, that is not warranted under existing law and cannot be supported by good faith argument for an extension, modification, or reversal of existing law;
the client either seeks to pursue a criminal or fraudulent course of conduct or has used the lawyer’s services to advance a course of conduct that the lawyer reasonably believes was a crime or fraud;
the client insists that the lawyer pursue a course of conduct that is criminal or fraudulent;
the client by other conduct renders it unreasonably difficult for the lawyer to carry out the representation effectively;
the client breaches a material term of an agreement with, or obligation, to the lawyer relating to the representation, and the lawyer has given the client a reasonable warning after the breach that the lawyer will withdraw unless the client fulfills the agreement or performs the obligation;
the client knowingly and freely assents to termination of the representation;
the inability to work with co-counsel indicates that the best interests of the client likely will be served by withdrawal;
the lawyer’s mental or physical condition renders it difficult for the lawyer to carry out the representation effectively;
a continuation of the representation is likely to result in a violation of these rules or the State Bar Act; or
the lawyer believes in good faith, in a proceeding pending before a tribunal, that the tribunal will find the existence of other good cause for withdrawal.
(Rules of Prof. Conduct, Rule 1.16(b).)
Settling a Meritless Case
To avoid liability for malicious prosecution, an attorney who concludes that a case is “totally and completely without merit” must either cause the dismissal of the case or withdraw. (Zamos v. Stroud (2004) 32 Cal.4th 958, 970.) However, the attorney may only be liable if the claims are such that “any reasonable attorney would agree are totally and completely without merit.” (Id. at 971.) Under such circumstances, the attorney must either cause the dismissal of the lawsuit or withdraw. (Id. at 969-70.) While the court does not address the issue of whether dismissal of a meritless case can be achieved through settlement, the factors articulated by the Zamos court may also apply to any dismissal, whether achieved as part of a settlement or filed independent of settlement. (Id. at 969-70.)
Although an attorney may seek to settle a meritless case, his ability to advocate for settlement may be significantly limited by his duty of truthfulness. (Bus. and Prof. Code, § 6106.) “No distinction can… be drawn among concealment, half-truth, and false statement of fact.” (In the Matter of Loftus (Review Dept. 2007) 5 Cal. State Bar Ct. Rptr. 80, 86.)
An attorney may not make affirmative material misstatements of fact concerning the merits of the claim, by, for example, falsely stating that certain evidence will support liability or damages recoverable against the defendant, when the attorney now knows that in fact it will not do so. (Kotlar v. Hartford Fire Ins. Co. (2000) 83 Cal.App.4th 1116, 1123; Bus. and Prof. Code, § 6068(d).) “[A] lawyer communicating on behalf of a client with a nonclient may not knowingly make a false statement of material fact to the nonclient, and may be liable to a nonclient for fraudulent statements made during business negotiations.” (Vega v. Jones, Day, Reavis & Pogue (2004) 121 Cal.App.4th 282, 291.)
An attorney may not present a claim in litigation “that is not warranted under existing law, unless it can be supported by a good faith argument for an extension, modification, or reversal of the existing law.” (Rules of Prof. Conduct, Rule 3.1(a)(2).) Attorneys may only bring complaints and maintain arguments that “are supported by law or facts.” (Canatella v. Stovitz (N.D. Cal. 2005) 365 F.Supp.2d 1064, 1077; In re Estate of Randall (1924) 194 Cal. 725, 728-29.)
Ethical Duties to Client
A lawyer violates his or her ethical mandate by abandoning a client. (Pineda v. State Bar, 49 Cal.3d 753, 758-759.) Even where grounds for mandatory withdrawal exist, an attorney may not withdraw from representation until the lawyer “has taken reasonable steps to avoid reasonably foreseeable prejudice to the rights of the client.” (Rules of Prof. Conduct, Rule 1.16(d); In re Hickey (1990) 50 Cal.3d 571 [788 P.2d 684]; Kirsch v. Duryea (1978) 21 Cal.3d 303, 311 [146 Cal.Rptr. 218].)
In a matter pending before a tribunal, even where mandatory grounds for withdrawal exist, the duty to take reasonable steps to protect against reasonably foreseeable prejudice lasts until the attorney is either formally substituted out of the case or has been relieved as counsel by order of the Court. (In the Matter of Riley (Review Dept. 1994) 3 Cal. State Bar Ct. Rptr. 91, 115.)
“[B]y advising a client to dismiss a meritless case, the attorney will serve the client’s best interest in that the client will avoid the cost of fruitless litigation, and the client’s exposure to liability for malicious prosecution will be limited.” (Zamos v. Stroud (2004) 32 Cal.4th 958, 969-70.)
Nonconsensual Withdrawal
“An attorney should not seek nonconsensual withdrawal immediately upon determination that the case lacks merit, but should delay to give his client an opportunity to obtain other counsel or to file a consensual withdrawal.” (Kirsch v. Duryea (1978) 21 Cal.3d 303, 311.) This is because when an attorney non-consensually withdraws, there is “an obvious inference” that the withdrawal “is not for the client’s purpose but for the attorney’s purpose, usually a lack of confidence in the merits of the case.” (Id.)
Useful Rulings on Duty of Dismissal or Withdrawal - Meritless Case
Basis LLC vs Turn Key Solutions
TENTATIVE RULING BY JUDGE REBECCA RILEY No notice of intent to appear is required. If you wish to submit on the tentative decision, you may send a telefax to Judge Riley's secretary at 805-289-8790, stating that you submit on the tentative. Please include the hearing date, the case name and case number on your telefax. Do not call in lieu of sending a telefax, nor should you call to see if your t...
..urn Key Solutions, Inc. Order defendant Turn Key Solutions, Inc. to obtain new counsel and cause new counsel to make an appearance in this matter within forty-five days or show cause why its answer should not be stricken. See Gamet v. Blanchard (2001) 91 Cal. App. 4th 1276, 1284 (footnote 5) ("In California a corporation may not represent itself, except in a small claims proceeding. This prohibit...
NARJES LAHIJI, ET AL. VS BRAND TARZANA SURGICAL INSTITUTE, ET AL.
HEARING DATE: September 26, 2019 continued from September 17, 2019 CASE NUMBER: 18STCV03650 CASE NAME: Narjes Lahji v. Brand Tarzana Surgical, et al. MOVING PARTY: Counsel for Plaintiffs Narjes Lahiji and Steve Lahiji OPPOSING PARTY: Unopposed TRIAL DATE: Unassigned SERVICE: (see below) ATTORNEY KENNY S. RAMIREZ’S MOTION TO BE RELIEVED AS COUNSEL TENTATIVE: The motion to be relieved as cou...
..ARING: November 18, 2019 – Case Management Conference TRIAL DATE: Unassigned PROOF OF SERVICE: Proof of Service has been filed and indicates that Plaintiff has been served by mail to its confirmed address. An attorney, either with client’s consent or court’s approval, may withdraw from a case when withdrawal can be accomplished without undue prejudice to the client’s interests. (Rules Prof. Con...
HERIBERTA FLORES ET AL VS 341 S ALVARADO LLC ET AL
HEARING DATE: October 9, 2019 CASE NUMBER: BC606662 CASE NAME: Heriberta Flores, et al. v. 341 S. Alvarado, et al. MOVING PARTY: Counsel for Defendant Common Wealth Properties, LLC OPPOSING PARTY: Unopposed TRIAL DATE: August 28, 2020 SERVICE: (see below) JEFFREY F. GERSH/ STUBBS, ALDERTON & MARKILES, LLP’S MOTION TO BE RELIEVED AS COUNSEL TENTATIVE: The motion to be relieved as counsel is...
..ow a conscious disregard and breach of the attorney/client relationship to such an extent that it cannot be repaired. The specific facts which give rise to this motion are confidential and required to be kept confidential pursuant to Business and Professions Code $6068(e), rule 3-100(A), California Rules of Professional Conduct, and by the attorney-client privilege (Evid, C., §§ 950 et seq.). In t...
LEE SMITH ET AL VS TAKUI AYVAZYAN ET AL
HEARING DATE: Continued to October 9, 2019 CASE NUMBER: BC621464 CASE NAME: Lee Smith, et al. v. Takui Ayvazyan, et al. MOVING PARTY: Counsel for Plaintiff Levi Smith OPPOSING PARTY: Unopposed TRIAL DATE: August 18, 2020 SERVICE: (see below) LEGAL OFFICES OF DAVID GREY’S MOTION TO BE RELIEVED AS COUNSEL FOR LEVI SMITH, A MINOR TENTATIVE: The motion to be relieved as counsel is GRANTED. Mo...
..(2), instead of filing a consent. Letters to Plaintiff will be made available to the court in camera.” MC-053 ORDER: Filed August 23, 2019 NEXT HEARING: May 1, 2020 – Motion for Summary Judgment TRIAL DATE: August 18, 2020 PROOF OF SERVICE: Proof of Service has been filed and indicates that Plaintiff has been served by mail to its confirmed address. An attorney, either with client’s consent o...
CINDY KIN MI TSUI VS MICHAEL KIN WING CHUI
Motion to Declare James Li a Vexatious Litigant Calendar: 11 Case No.: GC038906 Hearing Date: May 31, 2019 Action Filed: April 25, 2007 Judgment: August 29, 2016 MP: Plaintiff-in-Intervention David Zhang RP: Defendant-in-Intervention James Li PRESENTATION: The instant matter has deep roots, and a significant history of litigation, but ultimately revolves around who owns interest in 933...
..ui in order to determine their respective rights in the Property and adjudicate other claims. The underlying dispute was ultimately tried by the Honorable Jan Plum, Judge of the Los Angeles County Superior Court in a bench trial, where the Court entered Judgment in favor of the plaintiffs Cindy Kin Mi Tsui and Kwok Kwong Lo, and against the defendant Michael Kin Wing Chui on October 06, 2010, adju...
SERGIO RAMIREZ VS FALCON CAPITAL INVESTMENT GROUP LLC ET AL
HEARING DATE: August 21, 2019 CASE NUMBER: BC716063 CASE NAME: Sergio Ramirez v. Falcon Capital Investment Group, LLCet al. MOVING PARTY: Counsel for Defendant Falcon Capital Investment Group, LLC OPPOSING PARTY: Unopposed TRIAL DATE: June 2, 2020 SERVICE: (see below) ATTORNEY ANTHONY K. MCCLAREN OF ADLI LAW GROUP, P.C.’S MOTION TO BE RELIEVED AS COUNSEL TENTATIVE: The motion to be relieve...
..g or defendant an action. (Timberline, Inc. v. Jaisinghai (1997) 54 Cal.App.4th 1361.) MC-053 ORDER: Filed June 26, 2019. NEXT HEARING: November 27, 2019 – Post-Mediation Status Conference TRIAL DATE: June 2, 2020 PROOF OF SERVICE: Proof of Service has been filed and indicates that Defendant has been served by mail to its confirmed address. An attorney, either with client’s consent or court’s...
Recent Rulings on Duty of Dismissal or Withdrawal - Meritless Case
1-25 of 10000 results
Civil - Limited (4,731)
Civil - Unlimited (27,970)
Civil Case Management Conference (4,311)
Civil Court Trial (170)
Civil Jury Trial (443)
Default Prove-Up Hearing (14)
Demurrer / Motion To Strike (4,903)
Discovery Hearing (3,300)
Ex Parte (3,416)
Fee Waiver Hearing (Civil) (7)
Hearing On Compromise Of Claim (15)
Hearing On Petition (305)
Hearing On Restraining Order (2)
Hearing On Settled Statement (2)
Judgment Debtor Exam (Civil) (114)
Motion Hearing (Civil) (14,549)
Motion Hearing (Small Claims) (4)
Motion Hearing To Certify/Decertify Class Action (93)
Motion To Dismiss (84)
Motion To Quash (Civil) (351)
Motion To Quash (Ud) (5)
Motion To Vacate Judgment (2)
Non-Compliance With Court Order (6)
Osc - Failure To File Judgment (7)
Osc - Failure To Pay Complex Fees (3)
Osc - Failure To Pay Pro Hac Vice Renewal Fee (2)
Osc - Failure To Pay Sanctions (1)
Osc - Failure To Request Entry Of Default (7)
Osc - Non-Sanction (156)
Osc - Sanctions (204)
Osc - Why Case Should Not Be Dismissed (217)
Osc - Why Case Should Not Be Dismissed (Unlawful Detainer) (4)
Opposition To Claim Of Exemption - Levy (Civil) (100)
Opposition To Claim Of Exemption - Wage Garnishment (Civil) (195)
Order To Appear (1)
Preliminary Trial Conference (1)
Probate (44,615)
Slapp / Slappback Motion Hearing (369)
Settlement Conference (Civil) (164)
Settlement Conference (Collections) (1)
Status Conference (Civil) (794)
Summary Judgment (Ud) (20)
Summary Judgment / Summary Adjudication (Civil) (2,318)
Trial De Novo (3)
Trial Readiness Conference (Civil) (1,254)
Unlawful Detainer Court Trial (11)
Warrant Hearing (Civil) (3)
Civil (3,210)
Probate (12,434)
Robert L Tamietti (81)
457-6345 (139)
A. James Robertson Ii (6,963)
Alesia Jones (2,234)
Allen Sumner (68)
Andrew Sweet (251)
Andrew Y. Cheng (130)
Angela Bradstreet (78)
Anne-Christine Massullo (122)
Arlene T. Borick (310)
Aaron Minnis (94)
Adrian Colley (33)
Alan G. Perkins (11,094)
Alan Simpson (452)
Allan D. Hardcastle (173)
Allen H. Sumner (902)
Amy D. Hogue (35)
Andrew P Banks (572)
Angel Bermudez (728)
Anthony Schoenberg (91)
Arlene Barton (77)
Arthur A. Wick (197)
Arthur Garcia (689)
Assigned Judge (32)
Bruce E. Chan (250)
Barbara A. Lane (1,344)
Barbara Kronlund (478)
Barbara M. Scheper (31)
Barry Goode (667)
Barry Labarbera (362)
Benny C. Osorio (1,829)
Brad Kaplan (53)
Bret D. Hillman (102)
Bret Hillman (102)
Brian C. Walsh (246)
Brian L. Mccabe (454)
Brian R. Van Camp (597)
Brian S. Currey Or John A. Slawson (163)
Brian S. Currey Or Maurice A. Leiter Or Salvatore Sirna (99)
Bruce Highman (166)
Burch (231)
Charlene P. Kiesselbach (103)
Charles D. Wachob (143)
Charles F. Haines (120)
Charlotte W. Woolard (6,153)
Christine Carringer (72)
Curtis Karnow (414)
Cynthia M. Lee (639)
Carol Greene (33)
Carolyn B. Kuhl (36)
Carter Holly (247)
Chad Firetag (377)
Charles D. Wachob (30)
Charles Geerhart (189)
Charles Margines (36)
Charles Ragan (39)
Charles S. Crandall (122)
Charles Treat (1,761)
Christine Byrd (60)
Christopher E. Krueger (77)
Christopher Harmon (63)
Christopher K. Lui (975)
Chuck Geerhart (61)
Colleen Sterne (16,606)
Conor Moore (69)
Craig D. Karlan (75)
Craig G. Riemer (577)
Craig Griffin (112)
Curtis A. Kin (423)
D. Robert Shuman (485)
D. Scott Daniels (237)
D. Tyler Tharpe (39)
Diane Elan Wick (33)
Donald S. Mitchell (70)
Donna J. Hitchens (52)
Dalila Corral Lyons (276)
Dan Thomas Oki (1,054)
Daniel A. Ottolia (65)
Daniel M. Crowley (519)
Daniel P. Maguire (43)
Daniel S. Murphy (1,348)
David A. Foster (29)
David C. Mathias (184)
David De Alba (5,982)
David E. Gregory (476)
David Hoffer (365)
David Helbraun (47)
David J. Cowan (102)
David M. Chapman (865)
David Mcdonald (387)
David R Chaffee (1,121)
David S. Cunningham (345)
David Sotelo (889)
David W. Abbott (23,515)
David Worley (1,769)
Deborah C Servino (1,342)
Deborah C. Servino (557)
Debre Katz Weintraub (253)
Deirdre Hill (154)
Denise Debellefeuille (765)
Dennis Hyde (110)
Dennis J. Landin (1,755)
Dept. 6 (459)
Diana Hall (382)
Diane Price (190)
Dianne Peebles (72)
Donald Black (683)
Donald Shaver (40)
Donna Fields Goldstein Or Benny C. Osorio (41)
Donna Geck (2,559)
Douglas Prouty (431)
Douglas Robbins (161)
Dylan Sullivan (467)
E. Bradley Nelson (401)
Ernest H. Goldsmith (8,878)
Earl H. Maas Iii (1,916)
Ed Weil (903)
Eddie C Sturgeon (2,399)
Edward B. Moreton (2,788)
Edward Weil (709)
Elaine Lu (1,797)
Elaine Lu Or Georgina Torres Rizk (594)
Elaine Lu Or Yolanda Orozco (2,635)
Elaine W. Mandel (470)
Elizabeth Allen White (580)
Elizabeth Humphreys (100)
Elizabeth R. Feffer (414)
Elizabeth Riles (111)
Erick L. Larsh (104)
Ernest W. Sawtelle (32)
Ernst Halperin (326)
Ethan P. Schulman (132)
Eugene L. Balonon (238)
Fenstermacher (91)
Francisca P. Tisher (30)
Franz E. Miller (97)
Frederick Bysshe (217)
Frederick C. Shaller (1,617)
Frederick Horn (1,095)
Frederick P. Aguirre (333)
Gail Dekreon (44)
Garrett L. Wong (618)
Gerald J. Buchwald (61)
Gail A Andler (66)
Gail Ruderman Feuer (450)
Gary S. Mullen (62)
Gary Y. Tanaka (64)
Genalin Riley (7,092)
Geoffrey A. Goodman (1,323)
Geoffrey Glass (1,141)
George (611)
George C. Eskin (881)
George J. Abdallah (292)
George V. Spanos (633)
Georgina Torres Rizk (2,166)
Georgina Torres Rizk Or Jon R. Takasugi (1,185)
Gerald Rosenberg (868)
Gerrit W. Wood (10,365)
Gerrit W. Wood) (213)
Ginger E. Garrett (241)
Glade Roper (38)
Glen Reiser (28,308)
Glenda Sanders (970)
Glenn R. Salter (1,030)
Gloria C. Trask (214)
Gloria White-Brown (811)
Gregory Keosian (1,250)
Gregory Lewis (1,793)
Gregory W Pollack (889)
Gregory W. Alarcon (58)
H. Chester Horn (55)
Harold E. Kahn (15,415)
Harry Dorfman (213)
Henry Walsh (245)
Holly J. Fujie (3,089)
Holly J. Fujie Or Michael M. Johnson (51)
Howard L. Halm (690)
Irma Asberry (697)
Irma P. Asberry (269)
J. William Mclafferty (7,546)
James J. Mcbride (209)
James T. Chou (119)
John E. Munter (39)
John K. Stewart (321)
Joseph C. Scott (35)
Joseph M. Quinn (160)
Jackson Lucky (289)
Jacqueline M. Stern (2,091)
James Brown (41)
James C. Chalfant (678)
James Di Cesare (1,532)
James E. Blancarte (410)
James E. Blancarte Or Serena R. Murillo (810)
James E. Blancarte Or Wendy Chang (969)
James E. Mcfetridge (827)
James F. Rigali (3,678)
James Fleming (132)
James Herman (942)
James L. Crandall (1,770)
James L. Stoelker (63)
James M. Mize (1,941)
James P. Arguelles (138)
James P. Henke (1,908)
James T. Latting (756)
James Watson (280)
Jamoa A. Moberly (63)
Janet Gaard (30)
Janet Hilde (1,242)
Jayne Lee (58)
Jeanne Flaherty (1,449)
Jed Beebe (2,658)
Jeff Hamilton (533)
Jeffrey B. Barton (36)
Jeffrey G. Bennett (382)
Jeffrey Wohl (32)
Jeffrey Y. Hamilton (444)
Jennifer V. Dollard (35)
Jerilyn L. Borack (315)
Jill Fannin (1,153)
Jim Weixel (31)
Joan M. Lewis (1,055)
Joel M. Pressman (463)
Joel R. Wohlfeil (3,866)
John A. Torribio (39)
John C. Gastelum (1,848)
John D. Freeland (358)
John Gallagher (212)
John J. Kralik (267)
John Nguyen (62)
John P. Doyle (714)
John S. Meyer (2,598)
John Sugiyama (7,996)
John W. Vineyard (367)
Jon R. Takasugi (2,054)
Judith Craddick (1,469)
Judith F. Hayes (1,630)
Judy Holzer Hersher (4,368)
Katherine Feinstein (135)
Ksenia Tsenin (46)
Katherine Bacal (2,519)
Katherine Gallo (68)
Katherine Huibonhoa (316)
Kathleen M. White (83)
Kathy Gallo (37)
Kay Ford (109)
Kenneth J Medel (1,631)
Kenneth R. Freeman (248)
Kent Kellegrew (6,668)
Kevin A. Enright (63)
Kevin Denoce (2,524)
Kevin J. Mccormick (887)
Kevin M. Seibert (130)
Kevin R. Culhane (7,124)
Kim Dunning (190)
Kimberly Gaab (684)
Kira Klatchko (144)
Kristi Culver Kapetan (496)
Kristin S. Escalante (1,108)
Kristin S. Escalante Or Georgina Torres Rizk (66)
Laurie M. Earl (137)
Leslie C. Nichols (260)
Lillian K. Sing (164)
Loretta Giorgi (2,549)
Loretta M. Norris (69)
Lori Ann (119)
Lori Ann Fournier (70)
Lynn O'Malley Taylor (296)
Laura A. Matz (122)
Laura A. Seigle (1,939)
Laurie M. Earl (1,433)
Lawrence Cho (173)
Layne H. Melzer (743)
Linda D. Hurst (348)
Linda Marks (918)
Lisa Hart Cole (390)
Lori Ann Fournier (1,393)
Lori Ann Fournier Or Olivia Rosales (253)
Lori M. Dobrin (505)
Marla J. Miller (6,779)
Michael A. Jacques (492)
Michael Kenny (61)
Michael Mattice (258)
Marc D. Gross (1,909)
Marc Marmaro (452)
Margaret Niver (47)
Marie S. Silveira (296)
Marjorie Koller (152)
Mark A. Borenstein (806)
Mark A. Young (83)
Mark Borrell (1,276)
Mark C. Kim (323)
Mark H. Pierce (92)
Mark Lehocky (75)
Mark Schreiber (119)
Mark Snauffer (517)
Mark V. Bacciarini (40)
Martha K. Gooding (1,491)
Mary E. Arand (298)
Mary H. Strobel (146)
Matthew P. Guasco (624)
Maureen A. Folan (46)
Maurice A. Leiter Or Salvatore Sirna (530)
Melinda Derish (115)
Melinda Reed (139)
Melvin D. Sandvig (50)
Michael G. Virga (706)
Michael J. Raphael (793)
Michael M. Johnson (409)
Michael Mayer (75)
Michael Mulvihill (272)
Michael P Candela (361)
Michael P. Kenny (648)
Michael P. Linfield (2,342)
Michael Sweet (89)
Michael T. Garcia (551)
Michael W. Jones (63)
Michael W. Sweet (254)
Michelle Williams Court (2,086)
Miles Lang (3,612)
Mitchell L. Beckloff (54)
Monica Bachner (74)
Monique Langhorne (444)
Newton Lam (156)
Nancy Zeltzer (100)
Naomi Gray (50)
Naomi Jane Gray (47)
Nathan Scott (120)
Nils Rosenquest (220)
Noah Lebowitz (218)
Pang Ly (117)
Patrick J. Mahoney (7,559)
Paul H. Alvarado (732)
Peter J. Busch (765)
Patricia D. Nieto (3,173)
Patricia Lucas (40)
Patrick Broderick (34)
Patrick M (33)
Patrick M. Broderick (267)
Paul A. Bacigalupo Or Virginia Keeny (63)
Paul Burdick (96)
Paul Renne (317)
Pauline Maxwell (1,159)
Peter A. Hernandez (699)
Peter Catalanotti (336)
Peter H. Kirwan (44)
Peter Mering (1,227)
Peter Van Zandt (75)
Peter Vanzandt (54)
Peter Wilson (1,401)
Phil Andersen (33)
Presiding (203)
Quentin Kopp (38)
Richard A. Kramer (583)
Richard B. Ulmer (1,928)
Richard E. Best (42)
Richard H. Dubois (208)
Richard K. Sueyoshi (192)
Richard Sueyoshi (41)
Robert L. Dondero (55)
Robert Moss (1,705)
Ronald E. Quidachay (23,525)
Rafael A. Ongkeko (979)
Ralph C. Hofer (942)
Randa Trapp (1,745)
Randall J. Sherman (1,711)
Randall S. Stamen (585)
Randolph A. Rogers (504)
Randolph M. Hammock (1,956)
Raoul M. Thorbourne (413)
Raquel A. Marquez (513)
Rebecca Susan Riley (2,769)
Rebecca Woodson (209)
René Auguste Chouteau (232)
Richard B. Ulmer (43)
Richard E. L. Strauss (2,265)
Richard J. Burdge (588)
Richard K. Park (1,633)
Richard K. Sueyoshi (77)
Richard Lee (802)
Richard S. Whitney (1,011)
Rick Brown (206)
Robert A Glusman (302)
Robert A. Dukes (953)
Robert B. Broadbelt (786)
Robert C. Hight (12,861)
Robert Kane (301)
Robert L. Hess Or Patricia D. Nieto (31)
Robert M. Twiss (1,158)
Robert M. Twiss Or Sharon A. Lueras (146)
Robert P Dahlquist (828)
Robert S. Draper (765)
Robert S. Draper Or Gail Ruderman Feuer (61)
Rocky Baio (905)
Rodney Melville (1,003)
Rodney Stone (124)
Roger Lund (7,572)
Roger M. Beauchesne (364)
Roger Mead (101)
Roger Ross (429)
Roland L. Candee (5,370)
Rolf M. Treu (74)
Ronald F. Frazier (1,889)
Ronald L. Styn (3,458)
Rosemary Mcguire (408)
Rosie Mcguire (121)
Ross Klein (398)
Rudolph R. Loncke (71)
Russell L. Hom (314)
Ruth Ann Kwan (127)
Stephen M. Murphy (36)
Stephen P. Freccero (147)
Steven M. Gevercer (171)
Susan Greenberg (187)
Suzanne R. Bolanos (562)
Salvatore Sirna Or Gary Y. Tanaka (178)
Samantha P. Jessner (593)
Samuel T. Mcadam (107)
Sanford Kingsley (49)
Serena R. Murillo (377)
Sharon J. Waters (232)
Sheila Fell (116)
Shelleyanne W.L. Chang (61)
Shirley K. Watkins (48)
Sigrid Irias (72)
Socrates P. Manoukian (98)
Sonia Cortés (147)
Sonny S. Sandhu (36)
Stacy Boulware Eurie (246)
Stacy P. Speiller (288)
Stephanie Krmpotic (49)
Stephanie M. Bowick (466)
Stephen Acquisto (365)
Stephen E Benson (73)
Stephen H. Baker (1,689)
Stephen I. Goorvitch (2,224)
Stephen I. Goorvitch Or Elaine Lu (132)
Stephen P. Pfahler (34)
Stephen Zollman (56)
Steve K. Austin (1,858)
Steve Stein (43)
Steve White (1,889)
Steven B. Stein (87)
Steven D. Blades Or Brian S. Currey (126)
Steven H. Rodda (701)
Steven Rodda (90)
Steven Stein (630)
Stuart M. Rice (67)
Sunil R. Kulkarni (107)
Sunshine S. Sykes (628)
Susanne Fenstermacher (504)
Teri L. Jackson (3,546)
Todd D. Irby (410)
Tomar Mason (204)
Talmadge R. Jones (1,259)
Tamara L Mosbarger (740)
Tamara L. Wood (1,574)
Tana L. Coates (415)
Tari Cody (1,106)
Teresa A. Beaudet (1,807)
Thadd A. Blizzard (1,181)
Theodore C. Zayner (173)
Theodore R. Howard (1,188)
Theresa M. Traber (1,219)
Thierry Patrick Colaw (791)
Thomas A. Delaney (242)
Thomas Anderle (6,967)
Thomas D. Long (241)
Thomas E. Kuhnle (178)
Thomas M. Cecil (277)
Timothy L. Fall (585)
Timothy M. Casserly (1,828)
Timothy M. Frawley (41)
Timothy Staffel (3,759)
Timothy Taylor (3,172)
Timothy W. Salter (121)
Tom Cohen (248)
Tom Paoli (35)
Trent Thornley (89)
Visiting Judge (81)
Valerie R. Chrissakis (79)
Victoria Wood (976)
Vincent O'Neill (2,194)
W. Stephen Scott (170)
Wendy G. Getty (262)
Walter Schwarm (1,903)
Warren C. Stracener (1,166)
Wendy Chang (51)
Wendy Chang Or Jon R. Takasugi (1,310)
William D Claster (1,616)
William D. Stewart (1,525)
William F. Highberger (34)
William Liebmann (37)
William Shapiro (69)
Yolanda Orozco (2,175)
Yolanda Orozco Or Georgina Torres Rizk (465)
Yolanda Orozco Or Laura A. Seigle (208)
Zel Canter (578)
Susan Greenberg (74)
Sacramento County, CA (109,750)
San Francisco County, CA (102,576)
Los Angeles County, CA (84,332)
Ventura County, CA (77,368)
Santa Barbara County, CA (50,423)
San Diego County, CA (37,931)
Orange County, CA (31,023)
Contra Costa County, CA (18,586)
Riverside County, CA (7,890)
Fresno County, CA (4,400)
Solano County, CA (3,490)
Shasta County, CA (3,263)
San Joaquin County, CA (2,065)
Napa County, CA (1,879)
San Luis Obispo County, CA (1,809)
Plumas County, CA (1,677)
Santa Clara County, CA (1,645)
El Dorado County, CA (1,633)
Stanislaus County, CA (1,507)
Merced County, CA (1,492)
Butte County, CA (1,484)
Sonoma County, CA (1,211)
Placer County, CA (1,171)
Yolo County, CA (1,082)
Marin County, CA (649)
Tulare County, CA (595)
San Mateo County, CA (565)
Nevada County, CA (545)
Santa Cruz County, CA (336)
Mendocino County, CA (169)
Calaveras County, CA (166)
Tuolumne County, CA (131)
Kings County, CA (115)
PRICE VS THE CITY OF ANAHEIM
Where, as here, the defendants are public agencies and the plaintiff seeks to restrain them in the performance of their duties, public policy considerations also come into play. There is a general rule against enjoining public officers or agencies from performing their duties. This rule would not preclude a court from enjoining unconstitutional or void acts, but to support a request for such relief the plaintiff must make a significant showing of irreparable injury.”
Sep 29, 2030
Judge William D CLASTER
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY VS. SANTA ANA RV STORAGE, L.P.
On March 1, 2019 the Court issued its ruling regarding the interpretation of Section 13.2(f) of the parties’ lease agreement.
Apr 25, 2026
T-12 THREE, LLC VS. TURNER CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Rulings on Evidentiary Objections The Court DECLINES to rule on all of the parties’ objections because "the court need rule only on those objections to evidence that it deems material to its disposition of the motion." (CCP § 437c(q).). In this regard, Saddleback’s Objection No. 8 (page 15 of ROA 2642) to the Patel Declaration is sustained as to the phrase “and others representing 5th Rock T-12” on the grounds of hearsay and otherwise is overruled.
VELAZQUEZ VS KIA MOTORS AMERICA INC.
Edwards The pro hac vice applications of Adam A. Edwards, Gregory Coleman, Jason T. Dennett, Kim D. Stephens, and Paul C. Peel do not address whether the applicants are: (1) regularly employed in the State of California or (2) regularly engaged in substantial business, professional, or other activities in the State of California. CRC, Rule 9.40(a)(2) and (3).
Judge Glenda SANDERS
THE CITIES OF DUARTE VS STATE WATER RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD AND CITY OF GARDENA VS REGIONAL WATER QUALITY CONTROL BOARD
originating from the City of Long Beach MS4, Order No.
ANGELA WATSON VS GILBERT A. CABOT
“Its purpose is to authorize the excision of superfluous or abusive allegations. ‘[M]atter that is essential to a cause of action should not be struck and it is error to do so.’” (Id.) The second is where a party seeks to “[s]trike out all or any part of any pleading not drawn or filed in conformity with the laws of this state, a court rule, or an order of the court.” (Code Civ. Proc. § 436(b).)
Judge Stephanie M. Bowick
CHUAN JUN LI VS QI ZHAO
On September 11, 2018, Plaintiff filed a verified complaint, asserting causes of action against Defendant and Does 1-10 for: Breach of Warranty of Habitability (Contract) Breach of Warranty of Habitability (Tort) Negligent Maintenance of Premises Maintenance of Nuisance Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress Retaliatory Eviction (Civil Code § 1942.5) Compel Mediation On November 14, 2019, Defendant’s default was entered.
Judge Gloria White-Brown
BELINDA AGUILAR, ET AL. VS TG PROPERTIES LLC
Judicial Assistant is directed to give notice to Plaintiff, who upon receipt of this notice, is ordered to give notice to all parties of record.
Judge Kristin S. Escalante
Yes Dismissal of all parties against whom judgment is not sought or an application for separate judgment against specified parties under CCP 579, supported by a showing of grounds for each judgment. (CRC 3.1800(a)(7).) Yes Mandatory Judicial Council Form CIV-100. (CRC 3.1800(a).) Yes Relief sought is within amount of prayer of complaint or statement of damages. (Due Process; Greenup v. Rodman (1986) 42 Cal.3d 822, 824.) N/A Summary of the case.
JOSE AGUILERA VS 5 STAR DELIVERY INC
See above Dismissal of all parties against whom judgment is not sought or an application for separate judgment against specified parties under CCP 579, supported by a showing of grounds for each judgment. (CRC 3.1800(a)(7).) Yes Mandatory Judicial Council Form CIV-100. (CRC 3.1800(a).) Yes Relief sought is within amount of prayer of complaint or statement of damages. (Due Process; Greenup v. Rodman (1986) 42 Cal.3d 822, 824.) Yes Summary of the case. (CRC 3.1800 (a)(1).)
WEST COVINA CAR STOP, LLC, A CALIFORNIA LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY VS ROUND TABLE REMARKETING D.R.S., INC., A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION, ET AL.
Yes Dismissal of all parties against whom judgment is not sought or an application for separate judgment against specified parties under CCP 579, supported by a showing of grounds for each judgment. (CRC 3.1800(a)(7).) Yes Mandatory Judicial Council Form CIV-100. (CRC 3.1800(a).) Yes Relief sought is within amount of prayer of complaint or statement of damages. (Due Process; Greenup v. Rodman (1986) 42 Cal.3d 822, 824.) Yes Summary of the case. (CRC 3.1800 (a)(1).)
VAGAN AZARYAN VS EXXON MOBILE
LOUIS & IRENE MONROY, TRUSTEES OF THE LOUIS & IRENE FAMILY TRUST OF 2447 NO. CHICO AVENUE, SO. EL MONTE, CA 91733, ET AL. VS HING KA HWANG, ET AL.
Discussion Plaintiffs’ Application for Default Judgment is GRANTED, in the reduced amount of $85,206.86 (i.e., $82,100.84 in damages, $2,532.02 in attorney’s fees [per Local Rule 3.214] and $574.00 in costs). The court declines to award $3,250.00 for repairs to the subject premises, inasmuch as Garcia was previously requested to attach documentary evidence of same, but has failed to do so. ANALYSIS Yes (5/12/20) Default Entered. (JC Form CIV-100.)
DANIEL GINZBURG, ET AL. VS 15025 SATICOY STREET, INC., ET AL.
RICHARD MACIAS VS CITY OF LOS ANGELES, ET AL.
ESTATE OF YOLANDA REBECA SILVA
Nature of Proceedings: Petition: Letters of Administration ; Hearing re: Fee Waiver Reconsideration The Court at the July 27, 2020 appearance ruled that: This matter is continued to August 24, 2020 at 8:30 a.m. in Dept. 4 The Estate is required to pay the normal filing fee(s). The bond amount requirement is in the amount of $510,000.
Judge Jed Beebe
HAYK MELKUMYAN VS. ELMER A. DIAZ, ET AL
The burden transfers to Defendant to show a triable issue of fact exists. Defendant failed to file an opposition and thus did not meet his burden. The motion is persuasive. MOVING PARTY TO SUBMIT ORDER FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND PROPOSED JUDGMENT. IT IS SO ORDERED, ____________________ TO GIVE NOTICE.
Judge Shirley K. Watkins
TARZANA VILLAGE COMPANY, LLC. A CALIFORNIA LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY VS JOSEPH COLUMBIA, ET AL.
TARZANA VILLAGE V COLUMBIA 20VECV00336 TENTATIVE RULING ON REQUEST FOR ENTRY OF DEFAULT JUDGMENT: DENY WITHOUT PREJUDICE. All three declarations submitted with the request for entry of default judgment are inadmissible because all three declarations lack the language of certification (ie: statements are made “under the penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California…”). CCP sec. 2015.5; Kulshrestha v. First Union Commercial Corp. (2004) 33 Cal.4th 601, 618.
CONS. OF NANCY SHEPSON
RE: PET’N FOR APPT OF TEMP CONSERVATOR FILED ON 07/28/20 BY CHRISTY JAMES, JANET DIDONE PROBATE EXAMINER NOTES-SUBJECT TO REVISION AFTER REVIEW BY THE JUDGE Need: 1. Appearances 2. Proof of Service on all persons entitled to receive notice 3. Proposed Order CHRISTY JAMES DAVID MONSOUR JANET DIDONE DAVID MONSOUR NANCY SHEPSON PROBATE EXAMINER NOTES-SUBJECT TO REVISION AFTER REVIEW BY THE JUDGE Need: 1. Appearances 2. Proof of Service on all persons entitled to receive notice 3.
PETITION OF JACONREY M WILLIS
Have a copy of the Order to Show Cause personally served on the mother and file a Proof of Service with the court or file a verified declaration by petitioner showing diligent efforts made to locate and serve her CRC 7.52 2. File a Proof of Publication of Order to Show Cause For Change of Name 3. Submit a Decree Changing Name Form NC-130 JACONREY MONTE WILLIS PROBATE EXAMINER NOTES-SUBJECT TO REVISION AFTER REVIEW BY THE JUDGE Petition Approved. Proposed Order Submitted. No Appearance Required.
RE: PET’N FOR APPT OF C'TOR, PERSON AND ESTATE
Report of Atty. Jonathan Thompson (limited) Note: Letters of Conservatorship issued to petitioners 10-1-97. BEPPIE PISTONE RONALD K. MULLIN GLYNIS A. PISTONE RONALD K. MULLIN STEVEN MICHAEL REED-PISTONE JONATHAN T. THOMPSON PROBATE EXAMINER NOTES-SUBJECT TO REVISION AFTER REVIEW BY THE JUDGE Need: 1. Resolution of Line # 19.B. 2. Proof of mailing to all persons entitled to receive notice or verified declaration by petitioner showing diligent efforts made to locate and serve them.
RE: PET’N AND DECLARATION ISO OF ORDER APPRVING COM
Verified declaration by Attorney Housman to show nature and difficulty of tasks performed, results achieved, benefit of services to the conservatee, and to specify the amount requested for each category of service provided. CRC §§ 7.702; 7.751(b) (also time and hourly rate) 6. Statement regarding bond per LR 7.111(b), including amount currently posted. The Court is waiting for these items: 1. Court Investigator’s Report 2. Report of Atty.
CONS. OF MAURICE COKER
RE: PET’N FOR APPT OF CONSERVATOR OF PERS AND EST FILED ON 08/21/19 BY LILY COKER, STEVEN COKER PROBATE EXAMINER NOTES-SUBJECT TO REVISION AFTER REVIEW BY THE JUDGE Drop. Note: Letters of Conservatorship of Person/Estate issued to Lily Coker and Steven Coker 7- 10-2020. LILY COKER TRACY S REGLI MAURICE COKER OLIVER W.
18131 VENTURA BLVD, LLC, ET AL VS. 5223 LINDLEY, LLC
The date of placement of utilities, where they were located, and related issues were hotly contested. It was not unreasonable to take these depositions. B. Expedited Transcripts – GRANT. Tax $4,218.55. Costs for expedited transcription are not seen as reasonably necessary because there is no showing of any time restraint in obtaining the transcripts. As argued by Plaintiffs, the depositions were conducted well before the trial date. C. Service of Process – DENY.
IN THE MATTER OF BARBARA PETERSON
The next previously scheduled hearing is on 8/18/20 to review the filing / sufficiency of the status report due on or before 7/20/20.
Judge Roger Lund
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... 400 next last »