Source: https://www.dumondanddoran.com/case-outcomes/
Timestamp: 2019-04-26 01:45:06
Document Index: 513031161

Matched Legal Cases: ['§13', '§28', '§28', '§32', '§32', '§32', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§28', '§28', '§28', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§13', '§ 13', '§ 13', '§ 13', '§ 13', 'in fine', 'in fine']

Case Outcomes | DuMond & Doran, PLLC
Shelby J. Anderson
Tyler Schwenke
Lucille Cottereau
Trials Dismissals Pleas
Disclaimer: The information on this website should not be interpreted to indicate a certain result will occur in your specific legal situation. Every case is unique and different. Specific outcomes are dependent on the particular circumstances of each case. These case outcomes are to give you knowledge about our firm, our lawyers, and our experience. The case outcomes can also be used to help you generally compare your scenario, but they should not be interpreted as any type of promise or guarantee for your own case.
This page is still under construction and does not currently account for all of the trials, dismissals, or pleas. We hope to continue to update this page periodically until it is current.
D&D #: T1
Charge Name / Class / Statute / Result:
Narcotic Drug Violation (Cocaine Possession) / Class 4 Felony / A.R.S. §13-3408 / Not Guilty/Aquittal
Trial: Jury
More Information keyboard_arrow_down
Prosecutor: Erin Pedicone / Stephen Bridger
Assigned Attorney: Chris Doran (Rule 38)
D&D #: T2
Aggravated DUI (Suspended License) / Class 4 Felony / A.R.S. §28-1383(A)(1) / Not Guilty/Aquittal
Aggravated DUI (Third DUI) / Class 4 Felony / A.R.S. §28-1383(A)(1) / Not Guilty/Aquittal
Prosecutor: Edward Paine
Assigned Attorney: Chris Doran
D&D #: T3
Contracting w/o License / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §32-1164(A)(2) / Acquittal (Rule 20)
Advertising Violation / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §32-1165 / Acquittal (Rule 20)
Engage in Contracting w/o License / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §32-1151 / Acquittal (Rule 20)
Trial: Bench
Court: Scottsdale City Court
D&D #: T4
Narcotic Drug Violation (Crack Possession) / Class 4 Felony / A.R.S. §13-3408 / Guilty – Overturned on Post-Conviction Relief Appeal and remanded for new trial, then ultimately dismissed in its entirety
Drug Paraphernalia Violation (Crack Pipe) / Class 6 Felony / A.R.S. §13-3415 / Guilty – Overturned on a Post-Conviction Relief Appeal and remanded for a new trial, then ultimately dismissed in its entirety
Prosecutor: Elizabeth Lake / Emily Hovater
D&D #: T5
Assault (DV) / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §13-1203(A)(1) / Dismissed
Court: Phoneix Municipal Court
D&D #: T6
Red Light Failure to Stop / Traffic / A.R.S. §28-645(A)(3)(A) / Dismissed
Speed > Reasonable/Prudent / Traffic / A.R.S. §28-701(A) / Dismissed
Failure to Produce Evidence of Financial Resp / Traffic / A.R.S. §28-4135(C) / Dismissed
Court: Phoenix Municipal Court
D&D #: T7
Assault (DV) / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §13-1203(A)(1) / Guilty*
Disorderly Conduct (DV) / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §13-2904(A)(1) / Guilty*
*The plea offer was for 6 months in jail. Taken to trial anticipating a loss to receive a lower sentence. Received 2 months in jail.
Court: Mesa Municipal Court
Prosecutor: Timothy Wilson
D&D #: T8
Manslaughter (Vehicular) / Class 2 Felony / A.R.S. §13-1103(A)(1) / Not Guilty/Aquittal
Negligent Homicide (Vehicular) / Class 4 Felony / A.R.S. §13-1102 / Not Guilty/Aquittal
Aggravated Assault w/ Deadly Weapon / Class 3 Felony / A.R.S. §13-1204(A)(2) / Not Guilty/Aquittal
Prosecutor: Christine Trusken / Karen Komrada
D&D #: T9
Disorderly Conduct (DV) / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §13-2904(A)(1) / Dismissed
Criminal Damage (DV) / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §13-1602(A)(1) / Dismissed
Court: Goodyear Municipal Court
Prosecutor: Justin Atkinson
D&D #: T10
Burglary (2nd Degree) / Class 3 Felony / A.R.S. §13-1507(A) / Guilty
Sexual Abuse / Class 5 Felony / A.R.S. §13-1404 / Hung Jury (4-8 NG)
Sexual Assault / Class 2 Felony / A.R.S. §13-1406(A) / Hung Jury (6-6)
Attempt to Commit Sexual Assault / Class 3 Felony / A.R.S. §13-1406(A) / Hung Jury (1-11 NG)
Attempt to Commit Sexual Assault / Class 3 Felony / A.R.S. §13-1406(A) / Not Guilty / Aquittal
Prosecutor: Kathleen Tyma / Michael Minicozzi
D&D #: T11
Aggravated Assault w/ Deadly Weapon / Class 3 Felony / A.R.S. §13-1204(A)(2) / Acquittal (Rule 20)
Disorderly Conduct / Class 6 Felony / A.R.S. §13-2904(A)(6) / Acquittal (Rule 20)
Court: Yavapai County Superior Court
Prosecutor: Michael McGill
D&D #: T12
Interfering with Judicial Proceedings / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §13-2810(A)(2) / Dismissed
Court: Glendale City Court
D&D #: T13
Assault (DV) / Class 3 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §13-1203(A)(3) / Dismissed
D&D #: T14
Threatening or Intimidating (DV) / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §13-1202(A)(1) / Dismissed
D&D #: T15
Driving Under the Influence (slightest degree) / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §13-1381(A)(1) / Not Guilty / Aquittal
Driving Under the Influence (>.08 BAC) / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §13-1381(A)(2) / Not Guilty / Aquittal
Extreme Driving Under the Infuence (>.15 BAC) / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §13-1382(A)(1) / Not Guilty / Aquittal
Court: Tempe Municipal Court
Prosecutor: Oscar Molina
D&D #: T16
Assault (DV) / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. §13-1203(A)(1) / Guilty
D&D #: D1
Aggravated Assault (DV) Impede Breathing / Class 4 Felony / A.R.S. 13-1204(B) / Dismissed After Defense Demand
Court: Maricopa County Superior Court
Prosecutor: Robert Beardsley
Assigned Attorney: Samantha DuMond / Chris Doran
D&D #: D2
Threatening/Intimidating / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. 13-1202(A)(1) / Diversion Dismissal (Class)
Criminal Trespass 3rd Degree / Class 3 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. 13-1502(A)(1) / Diversion Dismissal (Class)
Prosecutor: Valerie Thomsen
D&D #: D3
Prosecutor: Tempe Municipal Court
D&D #: D4
Theft / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. 13-1802(A)(1) / Dismissed After Defense Negotiation
Court: Gilbert City Court
Prosecutor: Tom Taylor
D&D #: D5
False Reporting to a Law Enforcement Officer / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. 13-2907.01 / Diversion Dismissal (Class)
Court: Apache Junction Justice Court
Prosecutor: Chad Heywood
D&D #: D6
Assault (DV) / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. 13-1203(A)(1) / Diversion Dismissal (DV Classes)
Prevent Use of Phone in Emergency (DV) / Class 2 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. 13-2915(A)(3) / Diversion Dismissal (DV Classes)
Disorderly Conduct (DV) / Class 1 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. 13-2904(A)(1) / Diversion Dismissal (DV Classes)
Prosecutor: Stacey Goode
D&D #: D7
Urinating in Public / Class 1 Misdemeanor / TCC 22-13 / Diversion Dismissal (Community Service)
Assigned Attorney: Samantha DuMond
D&D #: D8
3rd Degree Burglary / Class 4 Felony / A.R.S. 13-1506(A)(1) / Diversion Dismissal (FPIP)
Court: Maricopa County Superior Court (SEF)
Prosecutor: Christin Ward
D&D #: D9
Prosecutor: Crystal Morales
D&D #: D10
D&D #: D11
Possession of Marijuana / Class 6 Felony / A.R.S. 13-3405 / Diversion Dismissal (TASC)
Prosecutor: Lindsey Reynolds
D&D #: D12
Criminal Damage (DV) / Class 2 Misdemeanor / A.R.S. 13-1602(A)(1) / Diversion Dismissal (DV Classes)
Prosecutor: Noel Rascon
D&D #: D13
Prosecutor: Kris Stanford
D&D #: P1
A.R.S §13-2310: Fradulent Schemes and Artifices (C2F),
A.R.S §13-2008: Taking Identity of Another (C3F),
A.R.S §13-3408: Obtaining a Narcotic Drug By Fraud (5x) (C3F),
A.R.S §13-3408: Attempted Obtaining a Narcotic By Fraud (C4F),
A.R.S §13-2002: Forgery (6x) (C4F),
Total Felonies = 14
Number of Prior Felonies: One
Potential Time if Convicted
Absolute Minimum = 3 years in prison
Absolute Maximum = 91.25 years in prison
3 years supervised probation on all three counts (concurrent), no jail time, and fines of $7,320.00 reduced to $4,000.00
First Plea Offer
Plead to 3 felonies: 1. Taking Identity of Another, C4F (2.5 to 3.75 years in prison),
2. Obtaining Narcotics By Fraud, C3F (supervised probation upon release from prison),
3. Obtaining Narcotics By Fraud, C3F (supervised probation upon release from prison)
Final Plea Offer
Plead to 3 felonies:
1. Forgery, C4F (Open range: supervised probation to 3.75 years in prison),
2. Obtaining Narcotics By Fraud, C3F (Open range: supervised probation to 8.75 years in prison),
3. Obtaining Narcotics By Fraud, C3F (Open range: supervised probation to 8.75 years in prison)
Prosecutor: Brett Harames
D&D #: P2
A.R.S §13-2317: Money Laundering – Conceal Proceeds (x2), C3F,
A.R.S §13-2312: Illegal Control of Enterprise, C3F,
A.R.S §13-3417: Use Electornic Communication During a Drug Transaction, C4F,
Total Felonies = 4
Number of Prior Felonies: Zero
Potential Time if Convicted:
Abolsute Minimum: Supervised probation, up to on year in county jail;
Absolute Maximum: 30 years in prison
6 months of unsupervised probation, no jail time, $1000 fine, all surcharges waived
First Plea Offer:
Plead to 1 Felony: 1. Attempt to Commit Money Laundering, C4F (Supervised probation $2000 fine plus 83% surcharge)
Final Plea Offer:
Plead to 1 Misdemeanor: 1. Attempted Securing the Proceeds of An Offense, C1M, Unsupervised Probation, $1000 Fine
Prosecutor: Mayar Daiza
D&D #: P3
A.R.S §13-1902: Robbery (x2), C4F,
Total Felonies = 2
Absolute Maximum: 7.5 years in prison
2 years supervised probation, complete GED program, no fines, and no jail time
First Plea Offer: None
Plead to 1 Undesignated Felony: 1. Possession of Burglary Tools, C6F (undesignated), Supervised probation
Prosecutor: Rebecca Mascot
D&D #: P4
A.R.S. § 13-1203 Aggravated Domestic Violence (C5F), A.R.S. § 13-2904 Disorderly Conduct – Domestic Violence (C1M), A.R.S. § 13-2915 Preventing Use of Telephone Emergency or False Repsentation of Emergency (C2M), A.R.S. § 13-1203(A)(3)(B) Assault – Domestic Violence (C3M)
Number of Prior Felonies: Zero Felonies, Two previous Domestic Violence Misdemeanor Convictions
Absolute Minimum: Supervised Probation, up to one year in county jail
Absolute Maximum: 2.5 years in prison and 13 months in county jail.
2 years supervised probation with DV Terms, Reduced Monthly Probation Fee to $40/month, Attend Anger Management Classes, 7 Days Initial Jail with credit for one day servied, Work Release from 4am to 9pm. $720 Fines.
First Plea Offer: Plead to 1 Felony (undesignated): 1. Attempted Aggravated Domestic Violence, a Class 6 Undesignated Felony (Supervised Probation with $720 in fines)
Pead to 1 Misdemeanor: 1. Disorderly Conduct – Fighting, a Domestic Violence Offense, Supervised Probation, Domestic Violence Offender Treatement Program, Anger Management Classes ($720 in fines)
Prosecutor: Melissa J. Certo
© 2019 DuMond & Doran, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.