Source: http://lawmedconsultant.com/228/the-unbelievable-but-true-story-of-the-nurses-of-winkler-county-part-2/
Timestamp: 2013-12-05 00:06:31
Document Index: 536503542

Matched Legal Cases: ['art 2', 'art 2', 'art 1', 'art 2', 'art 2', 'art 3', 'art 2', 'art 4', 'art 2', 'art 2', 'art-2']

The Unbelievable, But True Story of the Nurses of Winkler County: Part 2 - Law Med Blog
Bad Behavior (245)
Archive Select Month November 2013 (3)
Share The Unbelievable, But True Story of the Nurses of Winkler County: Part 2
The Quack, His Buddy the Sheriff and the Crooked Arm of the Law.
As I mentioned in Part 1, Anne Mitchell and Vicki Galle held important positions in hospital administration at the Winkler County Memorial Hospital. Mitchell was responsible for the credentialing of all physicians, including completion of medicare and medicaid applications, and review of all patients transfers and patient quality issues including billing audits. She received and reviewed annual reports from all hospital departments to ensure compliance with regulatory agencies. Galle made sure patient’s met criteria for admission and followed them during their stay reviewing their charts to ensure compliance with state and federal regulations. She was also in charge of monitoring and improving patient safety and quality of care and coordinating medical staff meetings. It was during the responsible and routine completion of their duties that the two became concerned over the practice of Dr. Arafiles.
Dr. Arafiles was hired by the hospital in April of 2008. At the time he was hired he was subject to a 2007 order from the Texas Medical Board restricting him from supervising or delegating prescriptive authority to physicians assistants or nurse practitioners, or supervising surgical assistants for three years. Over the next twelve months two physicians and other staff members voiced concerns over the performance of Dr. Arafiles and his treatment of patients. These concerns were presented to the hospital’s Board of Control which took no action. After they had spoken with representatives of the Texas Medical Board Mitchell and Galle submitted an anonymous complaint to the board identifying the concerns they had on April 7, 2009. Arafiles was notified by the board that a complaint had been received and an investigation was under way on April 15. On April 27 Dr. Arafiles gave a copy of the letter to his patient, friend and business partner in the sale of herbal supplements, Winkler County Sheriff Robert L. Roberts. The latter from the board contained the names of 10 patients whose care was being investigated. Sheriff Roberts went to work quickly, contacting those patients as he launched an investigation to find out who made the anonymous complaint.
One can only imagine the shock of being interviewed by the local sheriff about the care you received from your physician. It is hard to imagine what exactly the sheriff would have told the patients to explain why he was questioning them about their private medical information. One wonders what he may have said to them about the complaint and his pal the doctor. What is certain is that the only reason any investigation took place by his office into a complaint filed with the medical board, is the personal and business relationship the sheriff had with the doctor in question. The sheriff for his part pulled out all the stops. He wrote to the medical board on May 8 telling them that he was conducting a criminal investigation in “the case of the complaint” filed against Dr. Arafiles and asking the board to provide him with a copy of the complaint to assist the investigation. The sheriff neglected to inform the board just who he was investigating and the board understandably thought that the subject of the criminal investigation was Dr. Arafiles. After all it is likely the board has never previously been contacted by law enforcement within days of an anonymous complaint because an investigation into the complaint authors has been initiated. It is too absurd to contemplate.
So the medical board, as they are required to do, cooperates with law enforcement in the investigation of, they assume, a physician licensed in Texas and they send the sheriff a copy of the anonymous complaint on May 11. Just to be safe they remind him that such complaints may only be released by the board if law enforcement is investigating the subject in the complaint, a physician licensed in Texas, and that the complaint must remain confidential. Its release is prohibited except to further the investigation being done by the board. They end by asking the sheriff to inform them immediately if he is not investigating a license holder under the Texas Medical Board. The sheriff keeps the copy of the complaint and takes action based on its contents and never replies to the board in clear violation of state law.
Since the anonymous complaint reveals that the reporting nurse is a female in her 50′s employed by the hospital since the 1980′s, the sheriff is immediately able to narrow his search for the author(s). The sheriff contacted county attorney Scott M. Tidwell and informed him of the investigation he was conducting and on May 19 they met and decide to issue search warrants for the computers used by Mitchell and Galle. The sheriff had received the copy of the complaint from the board only the previous day, May 18, so he was able to put things together quickly by making a few inquiries at the hospital about 50-ish year old nurses and wasted no time moving to search their computers. The search included a computer at the Winkler County Community Center where Mitchell had a second job as emergency management coordinator. It was on this computer that a copy of the complaint to the board was found. The sheriff met with Mitchell and Galle on May 27 and both informed him they had authored and sent an anonymous complaint to the board, oblivious to the intention of the sheriff to ultimately arrest them and charge them with felonies.
In Part 2: The Quack, his buddy the Sheriff and the Crooked Arm of the Law
Tags: Winkler County, texas, complaint, tidwell, vicki galle, mike fostel
Posted in: Justice Fails, Medical Malpractice, Winkler County
Tags: arafiles. anne mitchell, complaint, felony, galle, medical board, memorial hospital, mike fostel, mitchell, nurses, Robert Roberts, roberts, rolando arafiles, scott m. tidwell, sheriff, stan wiley, texas, tidwell, vicki galle, Winkler County
3 Responses to The Unbelievable, But True Story of the Nurses of Winkler County: Part 2
True Story of the Nurses of Winkler County: Part 3 | Law Med Blog says: April 30, 2010 at 3:53 pm [...] In Part 2: The Quack, his buddy the Sheriff and the Crooked Arm of the Law. [...]
Unbelievable, But True Story of the Nurses of Winkler County: Part 4 | Law Med Blog says: April 30, 2010 at 3:54 pm [...] In Part 2: The Quack, his buddy the Sheriff and the Crooked Arm of the Law. [...]
Tweets that mention The Unbelievable, But True Story of the Nurses of Winkler County: Part 2 | Law Med Blog -- Topsy.com says: May 14, 2010 at 11:53 am [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Lawmed. Lawmed said: http://lawmedconsultant.com/228/the-unbelievable-but-true-story-of-the-nurses-of-winkler-county-part-2 [...]
The NDAA is Wrong Recent Posts Family Loses Medical Malpractice Case, Ordered To Pay Defense $340,000 [VIDEO] November 16, 2013 Physicians, PA, RN, Paramedic, Pharmacist Arrested Various Reasons November 16, 2013 Desai Gets Life, 2 CRNAs Also Sentenced In NV Hepatitis C Outbreak Case November 01, 2013 Hundreds Of Lawsuits Filed Against New England Compounding Pharmacy October 27, 2013 Lethal Injections Have Had Major Impact On Anesthesia Care October 24, 2013 Arkansas Charges Expert Witness Surgeon With Perjury October 18, 2013 Texas Lies To Pharmacy In Attempt To Obtain Propofol For Executions October 14, 2013 5 States Make Up 48% Of Total Amount Paid In Malpractice Cases October 02, 2013 LMA Package Insert Key Evidence In Anestheisa Malpractice Case September 21, 2013 FL Physician Charged With 2 Counts 1st Degree Murder In Pt OD Deaths [VIDEO] September 20, 2013 Breaking Healthcare News September 6, 2013 September 06, 2013 Woman In Coma After Breast Surgery: Medical Records Contradictory September 06, 2013 Breaking Healthcare News August 26, 2013 August 26, 2013 Dr. Jon Norberg’s License Reinstated With Conditions In ND [VIDEO] August 26, 2013 Breaking Healthcare News August 23, 2013 August 23, 2013 CBS4 Miami Does Hatchet Job On Cosmetic Surgery Center August 21, 2013 X-Ray Tech Admits To Infecting & Killing Paitents In 8 States With Hepatitis C August 14, 2013 Anesthetist Testifies Jackson Was High So He Cancelled Procedure [VIDEO] August 12, 2013 75 Y/O Patient Shoots, Kills His Urologist Over Incontinence [VIDEO] July 31, 2013 Stay Of Execution For Warren Hill Appeal By GA Delayed July 19, 2013 Judge Extends Hill Stay Of Execution Based On Drug Secrecy Challenge, GA Appeals July 18, 2013 BREAKING: Execution Of Warren Lee Hill Halted By Judge July 15, 2013 Breaking Healthcare News July 15, 2013 July 15, 2013 Drugs Illegally Obtained For GA Execution? Emergency Motion Filed July 15, 2013 GA To Use Compounding Pharmacy To Obtain Drug To Execute Retarded Man July 14, 2013 MO AG Wants Court To Set Execution Dates Prior To Expiration Of Propofol July 05, 2013 NV Heaptitis C Trial: Desai Guilty Of Murder, Lakeman Of Other Counts [VIDEO] July 02, 2013 Breaking Healthcare News July 1, 2013 July 01, 2013 Innocent Man Jailed 5 Months For Murder After Paramedics Transfer DNA [VIDEO] July 01, 2013 Chicago Hospital Did Unnecessary Tracheotomies, Raided By FBI June 29, 2013 Health Law NewsTime Out: Behind the FDA’s Decision to Halt Direct to Consumer Genetic Testing December 2, 2013Abortion Cases in Court Helped Tilt Democrats Against the Filibuster December 2, 2013A caesarean must be a choice – whatever the circumstances December 2, 2013Generic drug switch by Shoppers outrages parents December 2, 2013Why family backs organ law change as information campaign begins December 2, 2013Rationing, inefficiency and the role of clinicians December 1, 2013Social networking sites: a clinical dilemma? November 30, 2013Ethical issues in decision making by hospital health committee members in Turkey November 30, 2013Should we perform kidney transplants on foreign nationals? November 30, 2013Maternal request for caesarean section: an ethical consideration November 30, 2013