Source: https://www.ser-ltd.com/ser-jersey/resources/technical-bulletins/certification-of-the-structural-design-of-glazing
Timestamp: 2020-04-04 02:47:13
Document Index: 106215043

Matched Legal Cases: ['arts 1', 'art 4', 'art 5', 'arts 1', 'art 2', 'art 2', 'art 1', 'art 1', 'art 2', 'art 3', 'art 4', 'art 5', 'art 6', 'art 7', 'art 1', 'art 2', 'art 1', 'art 2', 'art 1']

6 - Certification of the Structural Design of Glazing Systems | Structural Engineers Registration Ltd
6 - Certification of the Structural Design of Glazing Systems
Technical Bulletin 6 - Certification of the Structural Design of Glazing Systems
1 - Procedure for the Submission of Structural Design Information
3 - Certification of the Design of Timber Framed Structures
4 - Certifying the Structural Design of Conservatories
5 - Certifying the Structural Design of Protective Barriers
Certification of the Structural Design of Glazing Systems
This Technical Bulletin is a guide to the certification of glazing installations for domestic and commercial buildings. It is not intended as a design guide, and designers of glazing installations should not rely on it as such.
Generally glazing systems will be designed by a specialist contractor and on larger projects the glazing may well form a separate design stage, in which case it must be designed and detailed before a Design Certificate is signed for that stage.
It is unlikely that a detailed check will be necessary for most domestic and many commercial buildings where the installation comes within the provision of BS 6262:20051 (see below). Many of these installations will be carried out by installers who may be registered under one of the fenestration self-assessment schemes by FENSA and CERTASS, although these schemes only apply to replacement domestic windows.
Glazing systems normally form part of the envelope of a building but are also often used internally as part of volume dividers. They can vary in structural importance from simple windows fitted in openings provided in the building envelope to curtain walling that may also provide support to other parts of the structure, and may include composite cladding systems referred to as unitised glazing. Many glazing systems include doors and may also act as pedestrian barriers.
Glazing systems are normally procured after a Building Permit has been obtained and are designed and provided by specialist contractors. The providers must be properly instructed with respect to the loadings to which the building will be subjected and the British or European Standards that apply and this information should be included in the relevant drawings accompanying the design certificate.
There is no general British Standard covering the design of façades, though there are many codes covering the materials used, and two that cover glazing systems. These systems vary from simple windows to curtain walls and purpose designed façade systems. Façades normally need only be designed for self-weight and wind loads, though roofs, canopies and rooflights will also need to take account of superimposed loads such as normal and drifting snow, and all need consideration for maintenance access.
Glazing, in the sense of windows, for most projects is covered by the provisions of BS6262:20051 ‘Glazing for buildings’, which satisfactorily defines the requirements for glazing for most situations, including calculation of wind loads. Guidance is given below on when it is appropriate to rely on compliance with this code.
Where more extensive areas of glazing are involved this often includes what is termed Patent Glazing; though, strictly speaking, this term refers to systems where the glazing does not rely on the external seals for water-tightness. These systems use glazing support members (transoms and mullions) with drainage incorporated in the details. They are often referred to as ‘stick’ systems and ‘curtain walling’.
For Patent Glazing the framing, which is generally formed from aluminium extrusions, is used to support the glass and resist the applied loads over long spans. The glazing can be set vertically or sloping, where it may form part of a roof surface. BS5516:20042 ‘Patent glazing and sloping glazing for buildings’ covers the design and installation of vertical and sloping Patent Glazing. Manufacturers provide design information and many offer a design service for the specialist contractor.
Both the above codes include instruction on calculating the wind and superimposed loadings that the glazing is required to resist. Note that the framing system and structural framing sections, be they of timber, metal, glass reinforced plastic and/or plastic, can be common to both types of glazing. Where glazing is formed from a number of large panes the framing system will require to be purpose designed.
Point Fixed glazing (sometimes also referred to as Curtain Walling), is where the glass is supported not at the edges but by bolt fixings through the glass, with weather seals provided to prevent moisture ingress.
In Point Fixed glazing the support system is generally formed from steel components, often a combination of hollow sections and rods in forms sometimes having the appearance of an exposed lattice or bowstring girders. There is no British Standard which describes such glazing, though various components are covered by materials codes.
Glass used in all these systems can be single or multiple glazing, using float (annealed), heat strengthened or toughened glass, or a combination of these, including laminated panes and panes having special surface finishes. Plastic sheet glazing is also used.
BS 6262:20051 and BS 5516:20042 give guidance on calculating wind loads and establishing pane thicknesses in glass and plastics. The wind load calculations are based on BS 6399-2:19975 ‘Loading for buildings – Code of Practice for Wind Loads’ with guidance which is specific to glazing installations. Both codes are restricted in their cover and the graphs used do not extend to the larger pane sizes now available.
There is no British Standard covering calculation of glass thickness for the larger pane sizes, It is normal in the UK to abide by the recommendations given by the glass manufacturer but it is currently unlikely that justifying calculations will be provided.
The publication ‘Structural use of glass in buildings’3 is a useful reference book that gives guidance on design with glass. The paper ‘Recent developments in design methods for glass structures’7 also gives guidance on this subject and the Certifier may find Tables 4 and 5 give useful data for rule of thumb checking where full design information is not made available.
The Certifier should be aware that most glazing systems are relatively rigid in the plane of the system and are built to much closer tolerances than the supporting structure. It is probable that the structural design of the glazing and the main structure are carried out by different parties and there is a risk that the loads and relative tolerances and movements may not be properly accounted for. Glazing systems are subject to greater temperature variation than the supporting structure and this should also be allowed for. Be particularly aware that building frames, especially in timber or reinforced or pre-stressed concrete, can move appreciably after construction.
Insulation requirements, the need for special types of glass required in certain situations and security requirements are not matters which are covered by the design certificate, but it is prudent to recognise where these requirements may apply and ensure that any resulting physical needs are transmitted as part of the specification.
BS 6262:20051 Parts 1 to 7 cover the design and construction of vertical glazing for buildings. They cover calculation of wind loads and treatment of impact loads and include where glass fins are used structurally as part of the glazing. Although Part 4 gives guidance on ‘human impact’ at critical locations on glazed screens it does not cover situations where glazing is used as a barrier, such as over a change in level, to restrain persons, or security requirements. For barrier loadings refer to BS 6399-1:19964 and BS 6180:20118.
It should be noted that BS 6262:20051 Part 5 (Code of practice for frame design considerations) is not yet available and that it is unclear when it will be published.
BS 5516:20042 Parts 1 and 2 cover vertical and sloping Patent Glazing systems. They cover calculation of wind loads and the glass sizing and give advice on the support system. As in BS 6262:20051 they do not cover where the glazing is used as a barrier or security implications.
Both BS 6262:20051 and BS 5516:20042 include methods of determining the wind pressure based on BS 6399-2:19975. BS 5516:20042 also covers imposed loading, referring to BS 6399-3:19886. These requirements are interpreted specifically for window design, and tend to use the ‘worst case’ option to cover all elements.
Where the glazing system falls outside the provisions of these two codes the design will need to comply with material codes and good practice, though it is probable that the guidance given the codes will be relevant. Wind loads will be calculated to BS 6399-2:19975. Safety requirements for the glazing system are covered by BS 82139.
There are currently no Eurocodes relating to the design of windows or glazing systems and the existing British Standards on Glazing make no reference to Eurocodes. For consistency Certifiers/designers may however elect to use the loadings given in BS EN 1991-110 (including the UK National Annexe) in place of BS6399 when Eurocodes are being used in the design of the primary structural elements.
The Role of the Certifier
The role of the Certifier is essentially to ensure that the glazing systems, and their connections to the primary structure, have been designed for the appropriate loadings by competent persons in accordance with the relevant standards and Codes of Practice and that ‘interface issues’ between building elements, such as deflections, tolerances and differential movement have been suitably addressed. In the particular case of low risk glazing it will however be sufficient for the Certifier to ensure that an appropriate performance statement, including design loads and relevant British Standards, has been provided on the plans.
Clearly glazing, such as is covered by BS 6262:20051, is generally used in situations carrying a low risk and the Certifier needs do no more than ensure that the supplier is briefed regarding the appropriate Standard and provided with sufficient information to establish the wind loads. The wind design provisions in both British Standards are limited to heights above ground not exceeding 15 m and above this wind loads will need to comply with BS6399-2:19975 or BS EN 1991-1-410. It is expected that glazing to a house, including patio doors, will generally come within the provisions of BS 6262:20051, and need no further action by the Certifier other than ensuring that the Standard is specified.
Where designs are required for the glazing elements these should consider the thickness of the glass required, the capacity of the supporting members and the frequency, capacity and location of the fixings, all in respect of the appropriate design loading for the particular location of the glazing on the building and the material to which the glazing will be attached. The aspects of the design which evaluate the capacities of the components need not be carried out on a bespoke or job specific basis but pre-existing calculations for standard components may also be used and compared to the loads which are calculated on a project specific basis. The intention is to examine and confirm that the proposed glazing system is appropriate for the design loads to which it will be subjected.
Alternatively suitably accredited test results, such as BBA or Agrément certificates, which are appropriate to the panel sizes, aspect ratios and loading on the elements under consideration, are an acceptable alternative to the production of calculations.
Section 5 (below) sets out a Risk Assessment methodology by which Certifiers may make a reasoned and informed assessment of the risks associated with each of their projects and provides guidance on the actions which should be taken when assessing projects which involve higher risk categories.
BS 5516:20042 considers pane sizes up to 20m2, depending on method of support. However, systems complying with this Standard will involve some level of structural design that will require scrutiny by the Certifier. The design must include for the supporting structure, how this is attached to the primary structure, provision for tolerances and relative movement between the two and all relevant load situations.
Further, it is possible that some aspects of such glazing have special requirements, such as acting as a barrier, and provisions for compliance with these should always be subject to scrutiny.
The Certifier may not be sufficiently experienced in glazing systems design to undertake a check personally. It is also possible that justifying calculations by a supplier are inadequately checked, if at all. While compliance with BS 6262:20051 and BS 5516:20042 will be relatively straightforward to check, the Certifier will need to consider if this delivers the necessary level of reassurance appropriate to the risk. For more complex systems, and those not covered by those Standards it may be necessary to request that an independent check is carried out.
Before issuing a Structural Design Certificate for a building the Certifier should consider the building type and the size and location of glazing panels and carry out further investigations, design and/or specification, as necessary in accordance with a suitable risk assessment of the particular circumstances and requirements of the particular project/glazing element.
Items affecting the risk categorisation include:
The inclination of the element (vertical/horizontal/inclined)
Size of the glazing element (frame)
Size of a single pane
Height of glazing above ground level
Does the glazing form a barrier?
Ownership/public access to land immediately outside the building
Once such a risk assessment has been carried out the extent of further consideration required will be dependent on the risk categorisation appropriate for the particular project.
The table below sets out the aspects of the project to be considered and gives guidance in how these should be assessed in determining the risk classification of the building.
Glazing panels are vertical, or horizontal or inclined panels which are <2m2
All inclined or horizontal glazing panels > 2m2
Building/glazing which falls outside range of BS6262:20051 or 5516:20042
Window does not constitute a barrier
All glazing (internal or external) which constitutes a barrier
All point fixed glazing systems
Window panes are rectangular and supported on 4 sides
All glazing whose highest point exceeds 9m AGL
Any unitised systems, innovative glazing systems or design approaches
Top of highest window < 9m AGL
All glazing panels which exceed 8m2 in area
Individual glazing panels < 8m2 in area.
All glazing panels with the effective area of individual panes > 4m2
Individual panes of glass with effective areas < 4m2
Land for 0.5x height to top of window/glazing panel beyond a façade is normally accessible to the general public and individual glazing panels > 2m2 in area
Individual glazing panels < 2m2 in area if the land for 0.5x height to top of window / glazing panel beyond the façade is normally accessible to the public
Mullions required to transmit externally applied vertical loads (e.g. bay windows or openings where lintels require intermediate support)
Mullions are not required to sustain/transmit externally applied vertical loads (e.g. bay windows or openings where lintels require intermediate support)
Glazing and Building falls within range of BS6262:20051 or 5516:20042
Work to be carried out by FENSA or CERTASS approved contractor
Certifiers also need to clearly understand that consideration of glazing is not related simply to the glass panels but also includes the supporting framework AND fixings back to the primary structure. It will also be necessary to check that the design of the primary structure includes allowance for the appropriate resulting loads and that deflections, tolerances and provision for differential movement between each of the components, are compatible.
Actions Required for ‘Low Risk’ Situations
Where glazing falls into the ‘low risk’ category as described above it will be considered sufficient for the Certifier to ensure that the glazing elements, (panes, frames and fixings) are specified to be designed in accordance with BS6262:20051 and/or BS5516:20042 in the drawings submitted with, or referred to in, the design certificate. No further design substantiation will normally be required and certificates can be signed off on the basis of relevant standards having been specified on the plans specification listed on the design certificate.
Actions Required for ‘Medium Risk’ Situations
Where glazing falls into the medium risk category as described above it is anticipated that the glazing will normally be designed by the manufacturer/supplier (however this does not preclude the Certifier carrying out the design themselves – or checking the designs of others ­prior to signing the design certificate if they so desire (and have sufficient knowledge and experience).
Where the glazing is being designed by the manufacturer/supplier it is obviously beneficial if the Certifier has the opportunity to contribute to the design brief/specification given to the supplier, particularly in respect of the specification of the loads which are appropriate for the site location and conditions (design wind speed, location, altitude and site factors etc.). If that is not the case particular care is required when checking or reviewing the design.
The derivation of wind loading in accordance with BS6262:20051 is relatively simple and uses a conservative approach to avoid the complexities involved in BS6399 and Eurocode 111. Where BS 6399, or Eurocode 1, is being used to derive the relevant wind loading a simple reference to, for example, ‘loading to BS 6399-2:19975’ in the design specification is unlikely to be sufficient as the site parameters etc. require to be identified such that a remote supplier has the relevant information to enable him to prepare an appropriate design. Similarly the use of appropriate local Cpe values and a suitable value for ‘a’ (largest diagonal dimension of the loaded area envelope) to BS6399 part 2 should be specified, or used in the derivation of the loads specified. In such cases it may therefore be advantageous to quote the design wind pressure to be sustained by the glazing, based on a worst case scenario, directly in the specification.
Prior to issuing a design certificate for the project the Certifier should:
timeously notify the client/contractor/supplier of the level of information required to prevent any delays to the construction or completion process
obtain copies of the supplier’s/manufacturer’s design calculations and details (including fixings back to the primary structure) or accredited test certification
satisfy themselves that any calculations have been carried out by a suitably competent person most designers working for glazing firms do not hold formal qualifications (such as CEng, IEng or TechEng) and may not be used to working with BS6399 part 2. Certifiers may therefore need to make their own judgement as to the designer’s level of competence against the requirements of each individual project
ensure that the design has been carried out to the standards and loadings (dead, wind, imposed, maintenance, impact etc.) relevant to the particular project
confirm that the calculations have been checked (or carry out checks as required)
satisfy themselves that the design and details are compatible with that of the supporting elements of the building (including appropriate deflections, tolerances and provision for differential movement)
record that these options have been certified using options 2 or 3 (SER Jersey Guidance Note 2) in Schedule 3 of the Design Certificate
Alternatively if no design information is available a certifier may carry out the necessary checks and calculations themselves, or using their own in house resources.
Actions Required for ‘High Risk’ Situations
Where glazing falls into the ‘high risk’ category it is unlikely that most Certifiers will have sufficient experience of the design of glazing to be able to determine if the design of the glazing elements meets the requirements of the Building Bye-laws.
In such circumstances the advice of an acknowledged expert should be sought, either to carry out, or confirm, the design.
In these circumstances the Certifier should:
satisfy themselves of the relevant expertise of the ‘expert’
satisfy themselves that the design has been checked by a suitably experienced individual
obtain copies of the supplier’s/manufacturer’s design calculations and details (including fixings back to the primary structure)
confirm that the design of the glazing is compatible with that of the supporting elements of the building (for example that adequate allowance has been made for deflection and/or thermal movement)
record that these elements have been certified using Option 4 (SER Jersey Guidance Note 2) in Schedule of the certificate
In all cases Certifiers need only concern themselves with consideration of the structural integrity of the glazing as an element of the building envelope and in respect of the appropriate design load. The functional operation of the glazing and/or associated components, such as hinges, stays etc. lies outside the remit of certification under Part 1 of the Bye-laws.
Eurocode equivalents are given where known. National Annexes are referred to as NA.
1 BS 6262:2005 ‘Glazing for buildings’
Part 1: General methodology for the selection of glazing
Part 2: Code of practice for energy, light and sound
Part 3: Code of practice for fire, security and wind loading
Part 4: Code of practice for safety related to human impact
Part 5: Code of practice for frame design considerations (not yet published)
Part 6: Code of practice for special applications
Part 7: Code of practice or the provision of information
2 BS 5516:2004 ‘Patent glazing and sloping glazing for buildings’
Part 1: Code of practice for design and installation of sloping and vertical patent glazing
Part 2: Code of practice for sloping glazing
3 ‘Structural use of glass in buildings’ published by the Institution of Structural Engineers; 2014
4 BS 6399-1:1996: ‘Loading for buildings – Code of practice for dead and imposed loads’ (Superseded by: BS EN 1991-1-1:2002: and NA –‘Actions on structures. General Actions. Densities, self-weight, imposed loads for buildings’ but still in use.)
5 BS 6399-2:1997: Loading for buildings – Code of practice for wind loads (superseded by: BS EN 1991-1-4:2005: and NA – ‘Actions on structures. General Actions. Wind actions’ but still in use.)
6 BS 6399-3:1988: Loading for buildings – Code of practice for imposed roof loads (Superseded by: BS EN 1991-1-3:2003: and NA – ‘Actions on structures. General Actions. Snow Loads’ but still in use.)
7 Overend, M: ‘Recent developments in design methods for glass structures’ Structural Engineer, 88 (14) 20th July 2010, p18-26
8 BS 6180:2011 ‘Barriers in and about buildings. Code of practice’
9 BS 8213: ‘Windows doors and rooflights’
Part 1:2004: Design for Safety in use and during cleaning of windows, including door-height windows and roof windows. Code of Practice.
Part 2:2007: Code of practice for the survey and installation of windows and external doorsets
10 BS EN 1991-1-4:2005 Eurocode 1: ‘Actions on structures- Part 1-4: General actions – Wind actions’ (including the UK National Annexe)