Source: https://patents.google.com/patent/US9808298B2/en
Timestamp: 2019-06-20 14:41:58
Document Index: 530536789

Matched Legal Cases: ['Application No. 61', 'Application No. 14724272', 'Application No. 2013', 'Application No. 201480073698', 'Application No. 201480014353', 'Application No. 201280038677', 'Application No. 2015147534', 'Application No. 2012229152', 'Application No. 201480012203', 'Application No. 201480032876', 'Application No. 2011', 'Application No. 201280022627', 'Application No. 201280038677']

US9808298B2 - Open-architecture interference screw - Google Patents
Open-architecture interference screw Download PDF
US9808298B2
US9808298B2 US14/249,020 US201414249020A US9808298B2 US 9808298 B2 US9808298 B2 US 9808298B2 US 201414249020 A US201414249020 A US 201414249020A US 9808298 B2 US9808298 B2 US 9808298B2
US14/249,020
US20140303676A1 (en
Alfred R. Berube, JR.
Kirsten H. Aarsvold
2013-04-09 Priority to US201361810007P priority Critical
2014-04-09 Application filed by Smith and Nephew Inc filed Critical Smith and Nephew Inc
2014-04-09 Priority to US14/249,020 priority patent/US9808298B2/en
2014-10-09 Publication of US20140303676A1 publication Critical patent/US20140303676A1/en
2015-08-21 Assigned to SMITH & NEPHEW, INC. reassignment SMITH & NEPHEW, INC. ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST (SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS). Assignors: AARSVOLD, Kirsten H., BERUBE, ALFRED R., STRONCEK, John D.
2017-11-07 Publication of US9808298B2 publication Critical patent/US9808298B2/en
2019-04-17 First worldwide family litigation filed litigation Critical https://patents.darts-ip.com/?family=50729844&utm_source=google_patent&utm_medium=platform_link&utm_campaign=public_patent_search&patent=US9808298(B2) "Global patent litigation dataset” by Darts-ip is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The present disclosure relates to an interference screw for creating an interference fit between a bone tunnel and tissue. The screw includes a threaded body having a proximal end, distal end, and thread extending around the threaded body between the proximal and distal ends. A supporting spline extends along a cannulation through the threaded body. The supporting spline is engagable with a delivery device. The screw further includes at least one opening defined by a surface between threads of the threaded body. A ratio of open surface area to closed surface area defines the opening and is selected such that, when torsionally loaded, the screw does not exhibit plastic deformation when inserted into an undersized bone tunnel. The screw further includes a tapered tip extending from the distal end of the threaded body. The tapered tip has a thread extending at least partway around the tapered tip.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 61/810,007, filed on Apr. 9, 2013, and entitled, “Open-architecture Interference Screw,” the entirety of which is hereby incorporated by reference.
Interference screws have proven to be an effective means for securing tissue in a bone tunnel. However, the interference screw itself generally takes up a substantial amount of space within the bone tunnel, which can limit the surface area contact established between the tissue and the side wall of the bone tunnel. This in turn limits the region of bone-to-tissue in-growth, and hence can affect the strength of the repair. By way of example but not limitation, it has been estimated that the typical interference screw obstructs about 50% of the potential bone-to-tissue integration region.
In one aspect, the present disclosure relates to an open-architecture interference screw for creating an interference fit between a bone tunnel and tissue. The interference screw includes a threaded body having a proximal end and a distal end, and a thread extending around the threaded body between the proximal end and distal end. The interference screw further includes a supporting spline extending along a cannulation through the threaded body between the proximal end and distal end. The supporting spline is engagable with a delivery device. The interference screw further includes at least one opening defined by an outer surface between the thread. The at least one opening is further defined by a ratio of open surface area to closed surface area. The ratio is selected such that, when torsionally loaded, the screw does not exhibit plastic deformation when inserted into an undersized bone tunnel. The interference screw further includes a tapered tip extending from the distal end of the threaded body. The tapered tip has a thread extending at least partway around the tapered tip.
In yet another aspect, the present disclosure relates to a delivery device and interference screw combination for creating an interference fit between a bone tunnel and tissue. The delivery device of the combination includes a handle and a shaft connected to the handle. The shaft includes a distal portion having a driving member. The interference screw includes a threaded body having a proximal end and a distal end, and a thread extending around the threaded body between the proximal end and distal end. The interference screw further includes a supporting spline extending along a cannulation through the threaded body between the proximal end and distal end. The supporting spline is engagable with a delivery device. The interference screw further includes at least one opening defined by an outer surface between the thread. The at least one opening is further defined by a ratio of open surface area to closed surface area. The ratio is selected such that, when torsionally loaded, the screw does not exhibit plastic deformation when inserted into an undersized bone tunnel. The interference screw further includes a tapered tip extending from the distal end of the threaded body. The tapered tip has a thread extending at least partway around the tapered tip. The interference screw is located on the distal portion of the delivery device such that the driving member engages the supporting spline of the interference screw.
In some examples, the interference screw may further include one or more of the following, alone or in any combination. The thread of the tapered tip may extend at least one full turn around the tapered tip. The thread of the tapered tip may also be a continuation of the thread of the threaded body. In other examples, the thread of the tapered tip is a partial thread extending less than one full turn around the tapered tip. Some of these examples include a first partial thread and a second partial thread, each extending a half turn around the tapered tip.
In some examples, the threaded body and tapered tip each have a different thread pitch. The thread pitch of the tapered tip may be between 1.5 and 3 times greater than the thread pitch of the threaded body.
In other examples, the threaded body has a constant diameter. The threaded body may have a wall thickness of 0.5-3.25 mm or a wall thickness that is a function of the diameter and length of the screw. The supporting spline may have a width of 1-2.5 mm. The thread of the threaded body may have a base width of 0.76-2.54 mm.
In some examples, the ratio of open surface area to closed surface area is a function of the diameter and length of the screw. In one example, in which the screw has a diameter of 11-12 mm and a length of 30-35 mm, the ratio is about one unit of open surface area to about three units of closed surface. In another example, in which the screw has a diameter of 7-10 mm and a length of 20-35 mm, the ratio is about one unit of open surface area to about four units of closed surface area. In yet another example, in which the screw has a diameter of 5-6 mm and a length of 20-25 mm, the ratio is about one unit of open surface area to about five units of closed surface area.
The at least one opening may be defined by a surface between adjacent proximal threads. Alternatively, the at least one opening may include at least one continuous opening between adjacent proximal threads and at least one discontinuous opening between adjacent distal threads. In this example, the at least one discontinuous opening has alternating segments of open surface area and closed surface area. In yet another example, the at least one opening is defined by a surface between alternating pairs of adjacent threads.
Other examples of the interface screw include a screw head comprising a surface extending from the threaded body into a hemispherical-like end portion.
Some examples of the interface screw are made from made from a combination of poly(lactic-co-glycolic) acid, β-Tricalcium phosphate, and calcium sulfate.
Further areas of applicability of the present disclosure will become apparent from the detailed description provided hereinafter. It should be understood that the detailed description and specific examples, while indicating the convenient example of the disclosure, are intended for purposes of illustration only and are not intended to limit the scope of the disclosure.
The accompanying drawings, which are incorporated in and form a part of the specification, illustrate examples of the present disclosure and together with the written description serve to explain the principles, characteristics, and features of the disclosure. In the drawings:
FIGS. 1A-B are views of an example of an open-architecture interference screw.
FIGS. 2A-B are views of another example of the open-architecture interference screw.
FIGS. 3A-C are views of an example combination of driver and open-architecture interference screw.
FIGS. 4A-C are views of an example of another open-architecture interference screw.
FIGS. 5A-D are views of another example of the open-architecture interference screw.
FIGS. 6A-C are views of another example of the open-architecture interference screw.
FIGS. 7A-C are views of another example of the open-architecture interference screw.
FIGS. 8A-C are views of another example of the open-architecture interference screw.
FIGS. 9A-B are views of an example combination of driver and open-architecture interference screw.
FIGS. 10A-B are side views of an example open-architecture interference screw having a tapered tip with two partial threads.
FIG. 10C-D are views of the tapered tip of FIGS. 10A-B with the body of the screw removed for clarity.
FIG. 11 is a view of an example tapered tip with one partial thread.
The following description of the example is in no way intended to limit the disclosure, its application, or uses.
FIGS. 1A and 1B show an example of an interference screw 100. The interference screw 100 includes a threaded body 105 having a proximal end 106 and a distal end 107. A majority of the threaded body 105 includes screw threads 110 in the form of a helical coil, i.e. a connected series of continuous regularly spaced turns extending in a helical or spiral form substantially from the proximal end 106 to the distal end 107. The interference screw 100 further includes at least one opening 115 being defined by a surface between threads 110 of the threaded body 105. The opening 115 is further defined by a ratio of open surface area to closed surface area. It may convenient to refer to the ratio as a measure of degree of openness of an open architecture interference screw.
Having a ratio of open surface area to closed surface area is particularly advantageous, inasmuch as the ratio provides the structural strength (e.g., torsional, flexural, and/or compressive strengths) needed to set the interference screw 100 into position, and hold the tissue in position while bone-to-tissue in-growth occurs, while still providing extraordinary access through the threaded body 105 of the interference screw 100. Thus, cell and nutrient-bearing fluids can move substantially unimpeded through the threaded body 105 of interference screw 100, and tissue in-growth can occur across the threaded body 105 of interference screw 100.
A convenient example of the interference screw 100 has a ratio of open surface area to closed surface area that is a function of the diameter and length of the interference screw 100. For example, the ratio of open surface area to closed surface area increases as the length and/or diameter of the interference screw 100 increases. Described below in greater detail, a large-sized example of the interference screw 100, having a diameter of 11 mm-12 mm and a length of 30 mm-35 mm, has a ratio of about one unit of open surface area to about three units of closed surface area. A medium-sized example of the interference screw 100, having a diameter of 7 mm-10 mm and length of 20-35 mm, has a ratio of about one unit of open surface area to about four units of closed surface area. A small-sized example of the interference screw 100, having a diameter of 5-6 mm and a length of 20 mm-25 mm, has a ratio of about one unit of open surface area to about five units of closed surface area.
As best seen in FIG. 1A, there are openings 115 between adjacent proximal threads 120 a,b of the interference screw 100. The interference screw 100 also includes closed surfaces 125 between adjacent distal threads 130 a,b. As shown, the interference screw 100 is arranged with an open proximal portion and closed distal portion. This arrangement is advantageous because the closed surface 125 enhances the torsional strength, compressive strength and/or fexural strength (bend strength) of the distal portion of the interference screw 100. Increased structural strength is desirable at the distal end 107 of the interference screw 100 because it is prone to breaking as the interference screw 100 is inserted into an undersized pilot hole. The open proximal portion of the interference screw 100 advantageously promotes bone-to-tissue in-growth.
A convenient example of the interference screw 100 has a uniform taper 135. The threaded body 105 tapers from the proximal end 106 to the distal end 107. The taper 135 is advantageous to creating an interference fit between tissue and bone tunnel. When the interference screw 100 is inserted into the bone tunnel, the surface of the taper 135 fully contacts the tissue and drives it laterally into engagement with the opposing side wall of the bone tunnel. Greater contact between the interference screw 100 and tissue increases the pullout strength of the interference screw 100 and/or tissue.
The interference screw 100 further includes a cannulation 140 within the threaded body 105. The cannulation 140 extends longitudinally between the proximal end 106 and distal end 107 of the threaded body 105. In other words, the interference screw 100 may include an open helical coil defining an internal volume. The internal volume communicates with a region exterior to the open helical coil through the at least one opening 115 between the threads of the threaded body 105. There is a supporting spline 145 (three shown) extending longitudinally along the cannulation 140. The cannulation 140 and supporting spline 145 cooperatively engage a driver. The use of two or more supporting spline 145, rather than one supporting spline 145, may be advantageous because it may distribute the load imposed during rotation over a larger surface area.
FIGS. 2A and 2B show another example of the interference screw 100. The interference screw 100 has threads 110 with a thread base width (W). In a convenient example, the thread base width is approximately 2.54 mm. One of the advantages of the interference screw 100 over other screws with thinner thread base widths is greater torsional strength and/or flexural strength.
FIGS. 3A and 3B shows an example driver 150 used to insert the interference screw 100 into a bone tunnel (hole). The driver 150 includes a handle assembly (not shown) and a shaft 155 coupled to the handle assembly. The shaft 155 includes a distal end 156. The distal end 156 includes grooves (drive members) 160 and a distal stop 165. The grooves 160 extend a partial length of the shaft 155. The distal stop 165 is for use with a depth stop on the interference screw 100, which the driver 150 is used to implant into a bone tunnel during a tissue repair procedure, such as ligament reconstruction surgery.
The distal end 156 of the shaft 155 is placed within the cannulation 140 of the interference screw 100 until the depth stop engages the distal stop 165 of the shaft 155. At this stopping point, the entire length of the interference screw 100 is fully supported by the driver 150. When the interference screw 100 is fully supported, the interference screw 100 is engaged by the driver 150, distributing the load across the entire length of the interference screw 100. FIG. 3C shows an example in which an interference screw is not fully supported, resulting in no torque applied to the tip of the interference screw, increasing the risk of screw breakage during insertion.
During insertion of the shaft 155 into the interference screw 100, the supporting splines 145 engage the grooves 160 and become housed within the grooves 160. A convenient example of the driver 150 includes a groove 160 for receiving substantially an entire length of the supporting spline 145. The interference screw 100 being mounted on the driver 150 such that the supporting spline 145 is substantially captured by the groove 160 of the driver 150. Rotating the driver 150 causes the interference screw 100 to rotate.
In example shown in FIGS. 3A and 3B, surface of the cannulation 140 and surface of the distal end 156 of driver 150 are tapered, expanding outwardly in the proximal direction, so that interference screw 100 and driver 150 form a positive seat. The surface of the cannulation 140 of the interference screw 100 is in direct contact with the tapered body diameter of the driver 150.
A convenient example of the driver 100 includes a tapered seat-forming thread (e.g., a tapered cutting thread, a tapered opening or dilating thread, etc.) formed in shaft distal to the grooves. Tapered seat-forming thread serves to precede interference screw into the space between the tissue and the wall of the bone tunnel, and then to form a lead-in or opening in the tissue and the wall of the bone tunnel for receiving the threads of threaded body, in much the same manner as a tap that creates a thread form.
During tissue (e.g., ligament) reconstruction surgery, for example, the end of the tissue (e.g., graft ligament) is placed in the bone tunnel and then the interference screw 100 is advanced into the bone tunnel via the use of driver 150 so that the interference screw 100 extends parallel to the bone tunnel and simultaneously engages both the tissue and the side wall of the bone tunnel. The interference screw 100 may be used in either the femoral or tibial tunnels, for example.
FIGS. 4A-D show an example of another interference screw 200. The interference screw 200 includes a threaded body 205 having a proximal end 206 and a distal end 207. The interference screw 200 further includes a tip 210 disposed at the distal end 207 of the threaded body 205. The tip 210 has a proximal end 211 and a distal end 212, and a taper 215. The tip 210 tapers from the proximal end 211 to the distal end 212. The tip 210 is advantageous to inserting the interference screw 200 into an undersized bone tunnel filled with a tissue graft. The distal end 212 of the tip 210 has a diameter smaller than the opening to the bone tunnel and, thus, allows compressive forces to be gradually placed upon both the bone tunnel and the tissue graft.
In one example of the interference screw 200, the threaded body 205 has a constant diameter. In another example of the interference screw 200, the threaded body 205 includes a taper different than the taper 215 of the tip 210. The threaded body 205 tapering from the proximal end to distal end (e.g., a 2 degree taper). The taper of the threaded body 205 is advantageous to creating an interference fit between tissue and bone tunnel. When the interference screw 200 is inserted into the bone tunnel, the surface of the taper fully contacts the tissue and drives it laterally into engagement with the opposing side wall of the bone tunnel. Greater contact between the interference screw 200 and tissue increases the pullout strength of the interference screw 200 and/or tissue. Because of the taper 215 of the tip 210, this example of the interference screw 200 is also easier to insert into a bone tunnel.
A majority of the threaded body 205 includes screw threads 220 in the form of a helical coil, i.e. a connected series of continuous regularly spaced turns extending in a helical or spiral form substantially from the proximal end 206 to the distal end 207. The interference screw 200 further includes at least one opening 225 being defined by a surface between the threads 220 of the threaded body 205. The opening 225 is further defined by a ratio of open surface area to closed surface area. This ratio is advantageous to promoting desirable bone-to-tissue in-growth through the opening 225. This ratio is also advantageous to providing structural strength (e.g., torsional and/or flexural), such that the interference screw 200 resists breaking when inserted into an undersized bone tunnel to create an interface fit between a bone tunnel and tissue. It may convenient to refer to the ratio as a measure of degree of openness of an open architecture interference screw.
A convenient example of the interference screw 200 has a ratio of open surface area to closed surface area that is a function of the diameter and length of the interference screw 200. For example, the ratio of open surface area to closed surface area increases as the length and/or diameter of the interference screw 200 increases. Described below in greater detail, a large-sized example of the interference screw 200, having a diameter of 11 mm-12 mm and a length of 30 mm-35 mm, has a ratio of about one unit of open surface area to about three units of closed surface area. A medium-sized example of the interference screw 200, having a diameter of 7 mm-10 mm and length of 20-35 mm, has a ratio of about one unit of open surface area to about four units of closed surface area. A small-sized example of the interference screw 200, having a diameter of 5-6 mm and a length of 20 mm-25 mm, has a ratio of about one unit of open surface area to about five units of closed surface area.
As best seen in FIG. 4A, there are openings 225 between adjacent proximal threads 230 a,b of the interference screw 200. The interference screw 200 also includes closed surfaces 235 between adjacent distal threads 240 a,b. As shown, the interference screw 200 is arranged with an open proximal portion and closed distal portion. This arrangement is advantageous because the closed surface enhances the torsional strength, compressive strength, and/or flexural strength of the distal portion 207 of the interference screw 200. Increased structural strength is desirable at the distal end of the interference screw 200 because it is prone to breaking as the interference screw 200 is inserted into an undersized bone tunnel. The open proximal portion of the interference screw 200 advantageously promotes bone-to-tissue in-growth.
The interference screw further includes a cannulation 245 within the threaded body 205. The cannulation 245 extends longitudinally between the proximal end 206 and distal end 207 of the threaded body 205. In other words, the interference screw 200 may include an open helical coil defining an internal volume. The internal volume communicates with a region exterior to the open helical coil through the at least one opening 225 between the threads 220 of the threaded body 205. There is a supporting spline 250 (four shown) extending longitudinally along the cannulation 245. The cannulation 245 and supporting spline 250 cooperatively engage a driver.
A convenient example of the interference screw 200 includes, at the proximal end 206, a screw head 290. The screw head 290 has a surface 290 a that extends smoothly and continuously from the threaded body 205 into a hemispherical-like end portion 290 b, as shown. In use, the screw head 290 rests against graft material and damage to graft fibers is possible. Beneficially, this arrangement of the surface 290 a and hemispherical-like end portion 290 b reduces the chance of such damage.
FIGS. 5A-D show another example of the interference screw 200. The interference screw 200 includes a proximal portion of continuous openings 255. The continuous openings 255 are defined by a surface between proximal threads 230 a,b. The continuous openings 255 completely encircle the interference screw 200. The proximal portion of continuous openings 255 advantageously promotes bone-to-tissue in-growth.
The interference screw 200 further includes a distal portion of discontinuous openings 260. The discontinuous openings are defined by a surface between distal threads 240 a,b. Along a path of the surface, the surface alternates openings 225 and closed surface areas 235. This alternating pattern of openings 225 and closed surface areas 235 improves the torsional and flexural strength of the distal portion of the interference screw 200 that advantageous to insert in the interference screw 200 into a bone tunnel.
In the example of the interference screw 200 shown, the openings 225 and closed surface areas 235 of the distal portion of discontinuous openings are arranged 90° to each other. For example, there is opening 225 and when the interference screw 200 is rotated 90°, there is a closed surface area 235. It may be convenient to call this arrangement of the openings 225 and closed surface areas 235 asymmetrical. Other arrangements are possible, for example the openings 225 and closed surface areas 235 are arranged at an angle less than 90° or greater than 90°. The interference screw 200 with asymmetrical arrangement of openings 225 and closed surface areas 235 has a tip strength greater than an interference screw with openings only. High tip strength is advantageous to inserting the interference screw 200 into a undersized bone tunnel.
The example of the interference screw 200 may be described as having a threaded body 205 with a number of sides (e.g., four). The first side of the threaded body 205 includes a first series of rectangular-shaped (or the regular shape) openings 265 extending from the proximal end 206 to the distal end 207 of the interference screw 200. (Best seen in FIG. 5B.) The first series of openings 265 has a first length. A second side of the threaded body 205 includes a second series of rectangular-shaped openings 270 extending from the proximal end 206 to the distal end 207 of the interference screw 200. (Best seen in FIG. 5A.) The second series 270 has a second length shorter than the first length. (Best seen in FIG. 5D.) The foregoing arrangement repeats on the remaining sides (i.e., long series of openings, short series of openings, long series of openings, short series of openings, etc.).
The result of the foregoing arrangement is a region near the distal end 207 of the interference screw 200 in which the openings 225 are between closed surface areas 235. The strength of the surrounding closed surface areas 235 compensate for the weakness caused by the openings 225 in the interference screw 200. This arrangement improves tip strength that is advantageous to inserting the interference screw 200 into a bone tunnel.
FIGS. 6A-C show another example of the interference screw 200. The interference screw 200 has threads 220 with a thread base width (W). In a convenient example, the thread base width is approximately 1.0 mm. One of the advantages of the interference screw 200 over other screws with thinner thread base widths is greater torsional strength and/or flexural strength.
FIGS. 7A-C show another example of the interference screw 200. The interference screw 200 has an alternating pattern of openings 225 and closed surface areas 235. The alternating pattern extends over a length or substantially the entire length of the interference screw 200 (as shown). The openings 225 are between alternating pairs of adjacent threads 275. For example, the opening 225 a is between a first pair of adjacent threads 275 a and the opening 225 b is between a second pair of adjacent threads 275 b. The closed surface areas 235 are between alternating pairs of adjacent threads 275. For example, the closed surface areas 235 a is between a third pair of adjacent threads 275 c and the closed surface area 235 b is between a fourth pair of adjacent threads 275 d.
FIGS. 8A-C show another example of the interference screw 200. The interference screw 200 includes a proximal portion of uniform openings 280. The uniform opening 280 advantageously promote bone-to-tissue in-growth. The interference screw 200 further includes a distal portion of alternating pattern of openings and closed surface areas 285. (The alternating pattern is described above with reference to FIGS. 7A-C.) The alternating pattern of openings and closed advantageously increases tip strength.
FIGS. 9A and 9B shows an example driver 300 used to insert the interference screw 200 into a bone tunnel (hole). The driver 300 includes a handle assembly (not shown) and a shaft 305 coupled to the handle assembly. The shaft includes a distal end 306 and a driving member 310 (four shown) extending from the distal end 306, and an opening for a guide wire used to position the screw during insertion (not shown). If desired, the drive member 310 extends a partial length of the shaft 305. The driving member 310 includes driving surfaces 315 a,b for engaging the corresponding surfaces of the supporting spline 245.
The distal end 306 of the shaft 305 is placed within the cannulation 245 of the interference screw 200. When inserting the interference screw 200 into the bone tunnel, the entire length of the interference screw 200 is fully supported by the driver 300. This distributes the load across the entire length of the interference screw 200, reducing the risk of breakage during insertion.
In example shown in FIGS. 9A and 9B, surface of the cannulation 245 and surface of the distal end 306 of driver are tapered, expanding outwardly in the proximal direction, so that interference screw 200 and driver 300 form a positive seat. The surface of the cannulation 245 of the interference screw 200 is in direct contact with the tapered body diameter of the driver 300.
FIGS. 10A-D show an example of another interference screw 400. The interference screw 400 is similar to the interference screw 200 of FIGS. 4A-D with exception of the tip. The interference screw 400 includes a threaded body 405 and tapered tip 410 extending from the threaded body 405. With reference to FIG. 10B, the tapered tip 410 has a proximal region 415, distal region 420, and surface 425 extended between the proximal and distal regions 415, 420.
An example of the tapered tip 410 has a first partial thread 430 and second partial thread 435 extending partway or less than 360° around the tapered tip 410. The first and second threads 430, 435 each start and stop at different locations on the surface 425 of the tapered tip 410. In a convenient example of the tapered tip 410, the first partial thread 430 starts in the distal region 420 at point 440 a and extends about 180° around the tapered tip 410 (best seen in FIGS. 10C and 10D with the threaded body 405 is removed for clarity) and stops at point 440 b in the proximal region 415. The second partial thread 435 starts at point 445 a distal to the stopping point 440 b of the first partial thread 430. The second partial thread 435 extends about 180° around the tapered tip 410 (also best seen in FIGS. 10C and 10D) and stops at point 445 b in the proximal region 415. The stopping point 440 b of the first partial thread 430 and starting point 445 a of the second partial thread 435 are spaced a distance D from one another. In other examples of the tapered tip 410, the first partial thread 430 and the second partial thread 435 are discontinuous or separate from one another.
In one example of the tapered tip 410, the partial threads 430, 435 taper towards the proximal region 415 with the same taper as the tapered tip 410. The minimum diameter of a given partial thread is at the distal terminus of the partial thread. The diameter of the partial thread increases to a maximum towards the proximal region 415 of the tapered tip 410. In a convenient example, the partial threads 430, 435 each have tapered ends, of which tapered ends 430 a and 435 a are shown in FIG. 10B. Each of the tapered ends has a height above the surface 425 of the tapered tip 410 and terminates at the same height as the surface 425. The smooth transition between the partial threads 430, 435 and the surface 425 of the tapered tip 410 advantageously minimizes damage to a graft from the interference screw 400.
Tracing an example of the partial thread with tapered ends, starting from the distal terminus of the partial thread, the diameter of the partial thread increases until a maximum is reached near the proximal region 415. Continuing to trace the partial thread past the maximum diameter, the diameter of the partial thread decreases until the proximal terminus of the partial thread is reached. In foregoing example, the partial thread extends about 180° around the tapered tip 410 but reaches a maximum diameter (and maximum root diameter) in less than 180°.
A convenient example of the tapered tip 410 has partial threads with a constant height and width. Another example of the tapered tip 410 has partial threads that are larger in the distal region 420 and decrease in size towards the proximal region 415. This arrangement provides an aggressive initial bite or purchase of surrounding tissue. Another example of the tapered tip 410 has partial threads that are smaller in the distal region 420 and increase in size towards the proximal region 415. This arrangement provides an initial bite less aggressive than the prior example.
In a convenient example of the tapered tip 410, the partial threads have a thread pitch greater than that of the threaded body 405. For example, the thread pitch of the partial threads on the tapered tip 410 is one-and-a-half to two times that of the threaded body 405. The larger thread pitch of the partial thread allows the tapered tip 410 to rapidly engage the surrounding tissue or bone tunnel.
While the foregoing examples of the tapered tip 410 are described as having two partial threads, it should be apparent that any number of partial threads are possible, such as three or four. For example, FIG. 11 shows another example of the tapered tip 410 with one partial thread 450 extending partway or about 300° around the tapered tip 410.
In some examples of the interference screw 100, 200, 400 the threaded body 105, 205, 405 has a wall thickness of 0.5-3.25 mm. In other examples of the interference screw 100, 200, 400 the threaded body 105, 205, 405 has a wall thickness that is a function of the diameter and length of the screw.
In some examples of the interference screw 100, 200, 400 the supporting spline(s) 145, 250 has a width of 1-2.5 mm. Advantageously, a wide supporting spline distributes a torsional load better than a narrower supporting spline.
In some examples, the interference screw 100, 200, 400 may be completely or a portions thereof (e.g., the threaded body) made from a formulation of poly(lactic-co-glycolic) acid (PLGA), β-Tricalcium phosphate (β-TCP) and calcium sulfate, poly-L-lactic acid-hydroxyapatite (PLLA-HA), poly-D-lactide (PDLA), polyether ether ketone (PEEK) or variants thereof. Biocomposite examples of the interference screw 100, 200, 400 made from a combination of PLGA, β-TCP, and calcium sulfate are absorbable by the body, which is beneficial to natural healing. An example formulation of PLGA, β-TCP, and calcium sulfate is described in U.S. Pat. No. 8,545,866, the entirety of which is herein incorporated by reference. A copolymer of polyglycolic acid (PGA) and polytrimethylene carbonate (TMC) is another example of a bioabsorbable material. Other commonly used materials for implants are also contemplated by this disclosure. In any case, the interference screw 100, 200, 400 comprise a material that is capable of providing the strength needed to set the fixation device into position and to hold the tissue in position while bone-to-tissue in-growth occurs.
To examine the performance of the open-architecture interference screw, finite element analysis was used to simulate inserting the screw into an undersized bone tunnel with a delivery device. In the analysis, torque (torsional load) was applied to the inner portion of the screw that is in contact with the delivery device while the distal end of the screws was held in place. The torque at which the sample plastically deformed was recorded as the failure torque. The failure torque provides a measure of the torsional strength of a screw. The results of the analysis for a medium-size or 7 mm×25 mm (diameter by length) interference screw made from the formulation of PLGA, β-TCP, and calcium sulfate, described above, is provided below. (Similar results were found when the interference screw is made from PLLA-HA.)
Failure Torque Open Area to Closed
Sample (in * lb) Area Ratio
1 Control (solid screw) 18.26 0 to 1
2 Sample 1 17.2 1 to 11
3 Sample 2 15.23 1 to 11
4 Sample 3 13.86 1 to 5
5 Sample 4 16 1 to 4
7 Sample 5 13.33 1 to 3
8 Sample 6 5.59 1 to 2
A control with no openings (i.e., solid screw) had the highest failure torque (18.26 in*lb). From this baseline, samples of increasing degrees of openness were analyzed. In some samples, the degree of openness was attached with openings. In other samples, supporting splines or thread defining the openings were adjusted as well. It was observed that increasing the degree of openness decreased the failure torque.
Unexpectedly, increasing the degree of openness to one unit of open surface area to three units of closed surface area did not further decrease the torsional strength of the screw total but improved the torsional strength (increased from 13.86 to 16 in*lb). Increasing the degree of openness beyond this ratio, however, did not improve the performance but rather decreased performance (decreased from 16 to 13.33 in*lb). The results, therefore, demonstrate that for a medium-sized screw (e.g., 8 mm×25 mm), a ratio of about one unit of open surface area to about four units of closed surface area provides superior results. The results also demonstrated that, surprisingly, thickening the supporting splines provided better performance then thickening the threads of the screw.
Similar testing was performed with other sizes of screws. For a large-sized screw (e.g., 12 mm×25 mm), a ratio of about one unit of open surface area to about three units of closed surface area was determined to provide superior results. For a small-sized screw (e.g., 6 mm×20 mm), a ratio of about one unit of open surface area to about five units of closed surface area was determined to provide superior results. In some examples, increasing the wall thickness of the screw (e.g., when increasing the size of the screw), also increased the degree of openness.
For a large-sized screw (e.g., 12 mm×25 mm) made from PEEK, a ratio of about one unit of open surface area to about two units of closed surface area was determined to provide superior results. For a medium-sized screw (e.g., 8 mm×25 mm) made from PEEK, a ratio of about one unit of open surface area to about two units of closed surface area and a half was determined to provide superior results. For a small-sized screw (e.g., 6 mm×20 mm) made from PEEK, a ratio of about one unit of open surface area to about three and a half units of closed surface area was determined to provide superior results.
As various modifications could be made to the examples, as described above with reference to the corresponding illustrations, without departing from the scope of the disclosure, it is intended that all matter contained in the foregoing description and shown in the accompanying drawings shall be interpreted as illustrative rather than limiting. Thus, the breadth and scope of the present disclosure should not be limited by any of the above-described exemplary embodiments, but should be defined only in accordance with the following claims appended hereto and their equivalents. As used herein, the meaning of approximately, substantially, and about include their ordinary and customary meanings as well as being a certain percentage of a stated value e.g., 0.1%, 1%, and 10%.
1. An open-architecture interference screw for creating an interference fit between a bone tunnel and tissue, the screw comprising:
a threaded body having a proximal end and a distal end, and a thread extending around the threaded body between the proximal end and distal end;
at least one supporting spline extending along a cannulation through the threaded body between the proximal end and distal end, the at least one supporting spline engagable with a delivery device;
at least one opening defined by an open surface between the thread, the at least one opening having a ratio of open surface area to closed surface area, the ratio being selected such that, when torsionally loaded, the screw does not exhibit plastic deformation when inserted into an undersized bone tunnel; and
a tapered tip extending from the distal end of the threaded body, the tapered tip having a thread extending at least partway around the tapered tip;
wherein a surface of the cannulation is tapered toward the distal end of the threaded body so as to form a positive seat with a corresponding tapered surface of the delivery device when the delivery device is engaged with the at least one supporting spline.
2. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 1 wherein the thread of the tapered tip extends at least one full turn around the tapered tip.
3. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 2 wherein the thread of the tapered tip is a continuation of the thread of the threaded body.
4. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 1 wherein the thread of the tapered tip is a partial thread extending less than one full turn around the tapered tip.
5. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 4 wherein the partial thread includes a first partial thread and a second partial thread, each extending a half turn around the tapered tip.
6. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 4 wherein the threaded body and tapered tip each have a different thread pitch.
7. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 6 wherein the thread pitch of the tapered tip is between 1.5 and 3 times greater than the thread pitch of the threaded body.
8. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 1 wherein the threaded body has a constant diameter.
9. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 1 wherein the threaded body has a wall thickness of 0.5-3.25 mm.
10. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 1 wherein the threaded body has a wall thickness that is a function of the diameter and length of the screw.
11. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 1 wherein the at least one supporting spline has a width of 1-2.5 mm.
12. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 1 wherein the thread has a base width of 0.76-2.54 mm.
13. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 1 wherein the ratio of open surface area to closed surface area is a function of the diameter and length of the screw.
14. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 1 wherein the screw has a diameter of 11-12 mm and a length of 30-35 mm; and wherein the ratio is about one unit of open surface area to about three units of closed surface area.
15. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 1 wherein the screw has a diameter of 7-10 mm and a length of 20-35 mm; and wherein the ratio is about one unit of open surface area to about four units of closed surface area.
16. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 1 wherein the screw has a diameter of 5-6 mm and a length of 20-25 mm; and wherein the ratio is about one unit of open surface area to about five units of closed surface area.
17. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 1 wherein the at least one opening is defined by the open surface between adjacent proximal threads.
18. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 1 wherein the at least one opening includes at least one continuous opening between adjacent proximal threads; and at least one discontinuous opening between adjacent distal threads, the at least one discontinuous opening having alternating segments of open surface area and closed surface area.
19. The open-architecture interference screw of claim 1 wherein the at least one opening is defined by the open surface between alternating pairs of adjacent threads.
20. The open-architecture interface screw of claim 1 wherein the threaded body further includes a screw head comprising a surface extending from the threaded body into a hemispherical-like end portion.
21. The open-architecture interface screw of claim 1 wherein the screw is made from a combination of poly(lactic-co-glycolic) acid, β-Tricalcium phosphate, and calcium sulfate.
22. A delivery device and open-architecture interference screw combination for creating an interference fit between a bone tunnel and tissue, the combination comprising:
a delivery device comprising a handle and a shaft connected to the handle, the shaft including a distal portion having a driving member, a surface of the distal portion being tapered;
an interference screw comprising:
at least one supporting spline extending along a cannulation through the threaded body between the proximal end and distal end, the supporting spline engagable with a delivery device;
wherein the interference screw is located on the distal portion of the delivery device such that the driving member engages the at least one supporting spline of the interference screw; and
wherein a surface of the cannulation is tapered toward the distal end of the threaded body so as to form a positive seat with the tapered surface of the distal portion of the delivery device when the delivery device is engaged with the at least one supporting spline.
US14/249,020 2013-04-09 2014-04-09 Open-architecture interference screw Active 2035-05-03 US9808298B2 (en)
US201361810007P true 2013-04-09 2013-04-09
US14/249,020 US9808298B2 (en) 2013-04-09 2014-04-09 Open-architecture interference screw
US20140303676A1 US20140303676A1 (en) 2014-10-09
US9808298B2 true US9808298B2 (en) 2017-11-07
ID=50729844
US14/249,020 Active 2035-05-03 US9808298B2 (en) 2013-04-09 2014-04-09 Open-architecture interference screw
US (1) US9808298B2 (en)
EP (1) EP2983617A1 (en)
JP (2) JP2016526941A (en)
KR (1) KR20150140738A (en)
CN (1) CN105263440A (en)
AU (1) AU2014251015B2 (en)
BR (1) BR112015025481A2 (en)
MX (1) MX2015014219A (en)
RU (1) RU2015147534A3 (en)
WO (1) WO2014169058A1 (en)
ZA (1) ZA201507169B (en)
US5312214A (en) 1992-09-04 1994-05-17 Multiclip Company Limited Securing devices
US6146073A (en) 1996-09-25 2000-11-14 Bollhoff Gmbh Verbindungs - Und Montagetechnik Threaded insert made of wire
US20110130760A1 (en) 2008-07-29 2011-06-02 Depuy International Ltd Instrument for forming a cavity within a bone
US20120041448A1 (en) 2005-09-09 2012-02-16 Aesculap Ag Screwdriver for bone screws
AT424862T (en) * 2004-10-29 2009-03-15 Smith & Nephew Inc Bioabsorbable polymers with calcium carbonate
2014-04-09 CN CN201480032876.2A patent/CN105263440A/en active Search and Examination
2014-04-09 MX MX2015014219A patent/MX2015014219A/en unknown
2014-04-09 BR BR112015025481A patent/BR112015025481A2/en active Search and Examination
2014-04-09 RU RU2015147534A patent/RU2015147534A3/ru not_active Application Discontinuation
2014-04-09 WO PCT/US2014/033535 patent/WO2014169058A1/en active Application Filing
2014-04-09 AU AU2014251015A patent/AU2014251015B2/en active Active
2014-04-09 EP EP14724272.1A patent/EP2983617A1/en active Pending
2014-04-09 JP JP2016507641A patent/JP2016526941A/en active Pending
2014-04-09 US US14/249,020 patent/US9808298B2/en active Active
2014-04-09 KR KR1020157031668A patent/KR20150140738A/en not_active Application Discontinuation
2015-09-28 ZA ZA2015/07169A patent/ZA201507169B/en unknown
2018-11-28 JP JP2018222129A patent/JP2019051366A/en active Pending
CN102573662B (en) 2009-10-28 2015-08-05 史密夫和内修有限公司 A threaded suture anchor
CN102781370A (en) 2010-03-10 2012-11-14 史密夫和内修有限公司 Composite interference screws and drivers
Communication from related European Application No. 14724272.1-1664 issued Jun. 13, 2017.
Decision of Rejection from related Japanese Application No. 2013-558094 dated Sep. 5, 2016.
First Office Action for Chinese Patent Application No. 201480073698.8 issued May 2, 2017.
First Office Action from related Chinese Application No. 201480014353.5 issued Apr. 19, 2017.
Fourth Office Action from related Chinese Application No. 201280038677.3 issued May 26, 2017.
Office Action from related Russian Application No. 2015147534/20(073143) issued Jun. 29, 2016.
Patent Examination Report No. 1 for related Australian Patent Application No. 2012229152 Issued Aug. 18, 2015.
Second Office Action for Chinese Patent Application No.: 201180013194.3, issued Mar. 23, 2015.
Second Office Action from related Chinese Application No. 201480012203.0 issued Apr. 24, 2017.
Second Office Action from related Chinese Application No. 201480032876.2 issued May 31, 2017.
Substantive Examination for related Mexican Patent Application No. Mx/a/2013/010383 issued Aug. 12, 2015.
Third Office Action for related Chinese Patent Application No. 2011-80013194.3 issued Aug. 21, 2015.
Third Office Action from related Chines Application No. 201280022627.6 dated Mar. 4, 2016.
Third Office Action from related Chinese Application No. 201280038677.3 dated Nov. 28, 2016.
WO2014169058A1 (en) 2014-10-16
ZA201507169B (en) 2017-02-22
KR20150140738A (en) 2015-12-16
JP2016526941A (en) 2016-09-08
EP2983617A1 (en) 2016-02-17
AU2014251015B2 (en) 2019-01-17
RU2015147534A (en) 2017-05-12
MX2015014219A (en) 2015-12-11
CN105263440A (en) 2016-01-20
AU2014251015A1 (en) 2015-10-29
RU2015147534A3 (en) 2018-03-19
BR112015025481A2 (en) 2017-07-18
US20140303676A1 (en) 2014-10-09
JP2019051366A (en) 2019-04-04
US9333018B2 (en) 2016-05-10 Bone screws and methods of use thereof
US9161748B2 (en) 2015-10-20 Bone anchors for use in attaching soft tissue to bone
Free format text: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST;ASSIGNORS:STRONCEK, JOHN D.;BERUBE, ALFRED R.;AARSVOLD, KIRSTEN H.;SIGNING DATES FROM 20150805 TO 20150811;REEL/FRAME:036388/0538