Source: https://www.scribd.com/doc/132444035/RESPONDENTS-MOTION-FOR-SUMMARY-DISPOSITION-AND-NOTICE-OF-INTENT-TO-USE-DISCOVERY-PRODUCTS-NOT-ON-FILE-IN-A-SUMMARY-DISPOSITION-SOAH-Filed-Copy-pdf?secret_password=8vc6ze7ccxvpup7rjid
Timestamp: 2019-02-24 01:43:43
Document Index: 138655762

Matched Legal Cases: ['§2', '§4', '§92', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2', '§2']

RESPONDENTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION AND NOTICE OF INTENT TO USE DISCOVERY PRODUCTS NOT ON FILE IN A SUMMARY DISPOSITION.SOAH Filed Copy.pdf
Uploaded by plafirm
RESPONDENTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION AND NOT...
ivigyxsg2 eggi2 gyi2 rii2 we2 fi2 eegrihF
xy2 gexxih2 py2
irsfs2 psvihD2
rehgy2
ie2 psw2yp2 ri2ypisyxev2vsgixi2hipixi2
d wb2
xxFE2
wc2 d§2 BIY2 n}2x2 D8D2 D m2
~`bE‘
GEF4‘2 IAD2E92
‘XQW2
`XII~¥~X52
£Pkg§‘d2
dD¢2
`FE2
cB§4~2
Y`E ‘2 F2
`2 `§92
`PR‘2 ‘BE2 W2 9IXEbP2 D2
I‘2
x‘ 2
‘EDf§§YE2
he2hn2vw2pirmDp3gF2
iisixgi pyw2 fixips2 y2
{9W2
eer2 uF2 euipsivh2
ryxi2 @SIPAUVWEQVWH2 iEwesvX2 eerdrexveelxFgyw2
wrh2 RD2PHIQ2
hoketing2hivision2 he2 ronorle2 edministrtive2vw2 tudge2oy2 qF2uddy2 tte2yfﬁe2 of2 edministrtive2rerings2 FyF2fox2IQHPS2 eustinD2exs2UVUIIEQHPS2
eX2
rnd2 i2 helivery2
UVWIWU2@xA2nd2IRVUIQ2@vxA2sssued2to2 eres2enn2furrisY2 fefore2the2 tte2 yfﬁe2of2 edministrtive2rerings2 yur2 pile2xoFI2 IPEHHIIW2
yer2 hoket2 ermnent2gertiﬁte2xumers2 xoF2SHUEIQEHUPUY2sn2the2wtter2of2
her2 tudge2uddyX2
inlosed2 plese2 ﬁnd2espondent’s2wotion2for2ummry2hisposition2 nd2xotie2 of2 sntent2 to2 se2 hisovery2roduts2 hisposition2roeedingF2 fy2 xot2 on2pile2in22ummry2 opy2 of2this2 letterD2 e2re2 forwrding2 2 opy2of2this2 doument2to2 the2 etitioner2 through2 ounselF2 lese2feel2free2to2ontt2the2ﬁrm2 questions2 hve2ny2 t2the2numer2 ontined2ove2should2you2 or2onems2 regrding2this2mtterF2 hnk2 for2your2 time2nd2ssistne2in2this2mtterF2 you2
inerelyD2
ve2 ri2 rex2 pswD2FgF2
keﬁeldD2vegl2essistn2
he2 hn2 pirm2 g2 y2 vw2 fox2SHPPU2 eustin2 exs2UVUTQ2 fx2 wwwFplinlwustinFHm @SIPA2UVWEQVWH2phone2 @SIPA2WHRESSIT2
|2 |2 |2 |2
psw2yp2 ie2 P2 ri2ypisyxev2vsgixi2hipixi2
inlosures2
uGskw2
X2
xikki2 ropkinsD2isqF2@i2 rnd2 heliveryA
glient2@vi2eEmilA2
phone2 @SIPA2WHRESSIT2fx2 @SIPA2UVW~QVWH2
he2 hn2 vw2 pirm2 g2 y2 fox2SHPPU2 eustinD2exs2UVUTQ2 wwwFphnlwustinFom
|2 s2 |2
FdFDu7PiiééX€7‘iSB‘2
¥2 ’2 wyid2 sjl2
IIY“E2
t‘2
XII42 `Q2 v2 F~~aa2 2 DFFF2 aF~wB~—2 SI¢F2 DDF2 D2 S4»2 4E2 igD”2 I3t`2
9‘i|2
»F2
imlXi2
iwexix2 iqsiih2 xi2 vsgixi2 xoF2UVWIWU282 iwexix2 ygesyxev2 xi2 vsgixi2
iie2 exx2 fs2
xyFIRVUIQ2 sih2 o2
sx2rf2
Aygui2 SHUEIQEHUPU xwfi2
fipyi2 ri2 yppsgi2 ei2
ehwsxsesi2 riesxq2
hsyssyx2 ygiihsxq2
iyxhix’2 wysyx2 py2 wwe2 hsyssyx2 exh2 xysgi2 yp2 sxix2 y2 i2 hsgyi2 yhg2 psvi2 xy2 sx2 yx2 e2 wwe2
y2ri2 ryxyefvi2ehwsxsesi2 ve2thqi2exh2ri2ryxyefvi2 ie2 fyeh2 yp2 xsxqX2
iie2exx2fsD2ermnent2egistered2 xurse2 viense2 xoF2 UVWIWU2 nd2
ermnent2 otionl2 xurse2 xumer2 IRVUIQD2 espondent2 @lso2 nd2 interhngely2
hereinfterD2 “wsF2furris”A2in2the2oveEstyled2nd2numered2use2of2tionD2 nd2pursunt2to I2
iF2ehwsxF2gyhi2§2 ISSFSHS2 files2 this2 wotion2for2ummry2hisposition2 nd2xotie2 of2
sntent2 to2
se2 hisovery2 roduts2 xot2 on2 pile2 in2 2 ummry2 hisposition2 roeedingF2
espondent2moves2for2finl2 deision2in2her2fvor2on2summry2disposition2ithout2evidentiry2
heringF2 espondent2 would2respetfully2show2 the2ourt2s2followsX2
iyxhix’2 wwe2 hsyssyx2 ishixgi2
piled2 ontemporneously2 herewith2 is2 espondent2 eres2 enn2furris’2 FxFD2
ttement2of2wteril2ndisputed2pts2in2upport2of2wotion2for2pinl2heision2on2ummry2
hisposition2 nd2 xotie2 of2 sntent2 to2 se2 hisovery2 roduts2 xot2 on2 pile2 in2 2 ummry2
hisposition2roeedingF2 ee2 I2iF2 ehwsxF2gyhi2 §2ISSFSHS@A@PAD2@QAD2@A@PA@fAF2
nder2the2 uthority2 of2 I2 iF2ehwsxF2gyhi2§2 ISSFSHS@A@PAD2 @fA2 nd2the2
exs2ule2of2givil2roedure2ITT@dAD2espondent2eres2enn2 her2intent2 furrisD2gives2notie2of2
to2 use2the2 exerpts2 tthed2to2 this2 wotion2t2 ixhiit2“i”2from2etitioner’s2 pirst2esponse2to2
espondent’s2wotion2for2ummry2
hisposition2—2 ge I2
yer2 hoket2 xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU2
espondent’s2 equests2 for2 hislosureF2 his2 disovery2 is2 intended2 nd2 used2 in2 support2 of2 espondent’s2wotion2for2ummry2 hispositionF2 espondent2filed2the2forementioned2tthed2
ixhiit2t2the2sme2time2she2filed2her2wotion2 for2ummry2 hispositionF2 espondent2serves2this2
notie2nd2the2tthed2disovery2produts2on2 ll2prtiesF2
sn2support2of2 this2motionD2espondent2relies2on2 nd2inorportes2y2referene2for2
ll2purposes2 the2followingX2
F2
effidvit2 of2 eres2 enn2furrisD2 vFFxFD2 FxFD2 dte2 wrh2 ID2 PHIQD2
@“furris2effidvit”AY2
F2
effidvit2 of2eron2fellowD2 FxFD2 xFFD2 dte2 wrh2QD2 PHIQD2 @“fellow2 effidvit”AY2
true2 nd2 orret2 opy2 of2 wedil2 eords2 of2 tient2 hgt2xumer2
VPVISQ2 @lso2 “ptientD”2 hereinfterAD2 with2effidvit2 of2hevorih2 xuls2
dte2 tnury2 PRD2 PHIQD2 tthed2 t2 ixhiit2 “eF”2 @tient2
wedil2
eordsAF2
nd2 orret2 opy2 of2 porml2 ghrges2 dted2 eptemer2 SD2 PHIPD2
tthed2t2ixhiit2“fF”2
true2nd2orret2opy2of2 espondent’s2yriginl2enswer2 filed2ytoer2PWD2
PHIPD2tthed2t2ixhiit2“gF”2
nd2 orret2 opy2 of2espondent’s2 equests2 for2 hislosure2 filed2
ytoer2PWD2PHIPD2tthed2t2ixhiit2“hF”I2
true2 nd2 orret2 opy2 of2etitioner’s2 pirst2 esponse2 to2 espondent’s2
equests2 for2 hislosure2 served2 xovemer2WD2 PHIPD2 tthed2 t2 ixhiit2
espondent’s2wotion2for2ummry2 hisposition2—2 ge P2 yer2 hoket2 xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
espondent’s2equests2for2hislosure2were2inluded2s2prt2of2 its2 yriginl2enswerF2
“f”2
true2nd2orret2opy2of2 etitiHner’s2pirst2emended2 porml2ghrges2filed2
perury2UD2PHIQD2tthed2t2ixhiit2“pF”2
true2 nd2orret2 opy2of2etitioner’s2 eond2emended2porml2ghrges2
filed2perury2 PSD2PHIQD2 t2ixhiit2“qF”2
nd2 orret2 opy2 of2 espondent’s2 pirst2 emended2 enswer2 ﬁled2
perury2PSD2PHIQD2tthed2t2ixhiit2“rF”2
true2nd2orret2opy2of2 “tient2gre2eport”2prepred2y2engel2gre2
emulne2ervieD2snFD2 with2effidvit2of2tessi2qrz2dted2perury2
IQD2PHIQD2tthed2t2ixhiit2“IF”P2
ee2I2iF2 ehwsxF2gyhi2 §2ISSFSHS@AF2
wwe2 yp2 wysyx2
mnner2
he2etitioner2@lso2 nd2interhngely2hereinfter2s2“ford”A2omplins2tht2
to2 prtie2 professionl2 nursing2 in2 n2 eptle2 professionl2
wsF2 furris2 filed2
onsistent2with2puli2helth2nd2welfre2nd2violted2her2stndrd2of2re2y2filing2to2initite2
rdiopulmonry2resusittion2 @hereinfterD2 “g”AF2
peifillyD2 the2 ford2omplins2tht2
wsF2furris2filed
to2re2dequtely2for22ptient2or2to2onform2to2the2minimum2 stndrds2
of2eptle2 nursing2prtie2 in2 2mmier2thtD2 in2the2 ford’s2opinionD2 exposes22ptient2 or2
other2 person2 vmneessrily2 to2 risk2 of2hrmD”2 nd2 tht2 she2 engged2 in2 “unprofessionl2 or2
dishonorle2 ondut2 thtD2 in2 the2 ord’s2 opinionD2 is2 likely2 to2 deeiveD2 defrudD2 or2 injure 2
ptient2 or2the2 puliF”2 ee2iF2yggF2
gyhi2§2 QHIFRSP@A@IHAD2 @IQAY2 see2lso2etitioner’s2
eond2emended2 etition2t2ixhiit2“qF”2
ptient’s2identity2hs2een2 he2 redted2to2omply2 with2yer2 yrder2 xoF2IF2 espondent’s2wotion2for2ummry2 hisposition2E2 ge Q2
yer2 hoket2 xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
he2fordD2per2its2 pledingD2nd2speifilly2to2 ghrge2sD2 omplins2of2speifi2
ondut2y2 wsF2furris2in2tht2she “2
filed2to2initite2rdiopulmonry2resusittion2@gA2 for2
tient2gwD2 exs2heprtment2of2 griminl2tustie2@“hgt”A2xumer2VPVISQD2fter2the2ptient2
ws2found2hnging2in2his2ellF”2 ee2etitioner’s2eond2emended2 etitionD2 ghrge2sD2 t2ixhiit2
aFqDD2
fsed2on2this2 ondutD2the2ford2omplins2tht2wsF2furris’2 ondut2“deprived2
ee2etitioner’s2eond2emended2porml2ghrgesD2
the2ptient2of2timely2resusittion2effortsF”2
ghrge2sD2 t2ixhiit2“qF”2
sn2 esseneD2 the2 ford2 is2 tking2 the2 undenile2 position2 tht2 2 registered2 or2
professionl2nurseD2who2 responds2to2n2unwitnessed2rrest2of22ptient2tht2does2not2hve22vlid2
do2not2resusitte2@“hx”A2orderDQ2my2 not2exerise2judgment2nd2mke22deision2to2withhold2
rdiopulmonry2resusittion2 @“g”A2upon2n2evlution2nd2ssessment2of22ptient2y2tht2
nurse2 despite2 linil2 signs2 supporting2 inppropriteness2 or2 futile2 interventionY2 hereD 2
determintion2of2inppropriteness2or2futility2sed2upon2presumptive2nd2onlusive2signs2of2
deth2tht2 were2presentY2 the2 ltter2 eing2livor2 mortis2 nd2rigor2mortisF2 ut2nother2wyD2the2
ford’s2position2in2this2mtter2is2 tht2regrdless2of2 whether22ptient2is2 or2ws2eyond2the2need2
emergeny2 medil2 intervention2 @iFeFD2
resusittive2 effortsY2 hereD2
gAD2 the2 generlly2
initite2
epted2 stndrds2 of2 nursing2 prtie2 require2 tht2 2 professionl2 nurse2
interventionF2
g2
ee2 etitioner’s2 pirst2 esponse2 to2 espondent’s2 equests2 for2 hislosure2 t2
ixhiit2“iF”R2 er2the2fordD2it2 is2 outside2the2sope2of2nursing2prtie2 to2 determine2tht2g2
sn2response2to2iF2 F2gsF2F2 IWRFP@AD2etitioner2providesD2“2the2ft2tht2the2ptient2 hve2expired2 my2 prior2to2her2 wsF2furris2disovery2re2not2ftors2tht2would2relieve2espondent2of2 her2duty2to2initite2potentilly2 life—sving2interventionF2 espondent2should2hve2 lled22gode2 to2ttempt2resusittion2of2 the2ptientF”2@imphsis2
t2the2time2 of2 reF2
his2my2 lso2inlude22sitution2here2there2is22vlid2hxD2 ut2this2ft2is2unknown2 to2the2responding2 regiver2
espHndent’s2wotion2for2ummry2 hisposition2—2 ge R2 yer2 hoket2 xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
ddedAF2
will2not2e2initited2in2the2sene2of22
hx2 orderF2 st2 ppers2tht2the2fordD2in2ringing2this2
seD2 disounts2 informtion2 lerned2 y22 professionl2 nurse2 during2 2 omprehensive2 nursing2
ssessment2nd2disounts2other2irumstnes2nd2ssessments2tht2ould2influene2 2deision2
on2the2prt2of2 the2professionl2nurse2not2to2initite2gF2 purtherD2the2fordD2for2purposes2of2 this2
disiplinry2 heringD2 tkes2 the2 undenile2 position2 tht2 the2 stndrd2 to2 initite2 g2pplies2
regrdless2of2 prtie2settingF2 fut2 see2espHndent’s2pirst2emended2 enswer2 t2ixhiit2“rF”2
espondent2 knowledges2tht2 the2 ultimte2 issue2 in2 this2 se2 t2 the2 ontested2
se2 hering2 is2 whether2 the2
minimum2 stndrds2 of2 nursing2 re2 llow2 2 registered2 or2
professionl2nurseEEupon2n2ssessment2of2 2ptient2who2 hs2suffered2n2unwitnessed2rrest2nd2
who2does2not2hve22vlid2hx2 orderEEto2withhold2resusittion2sed2on22determintion2tht2
g2is2 inpproprite2 or2 futile2 interventionF2
roweverD2 2 determintion2 of2the2 minimum2
stndrds2of2 ’s2 motion2 nursing2re2is2not2 needed2 nor2 is2it2required2 to2determine2espondent2 for2
summry2disposition2in2her2 nowF2 fvor2
espondent2 provides2 tht2 sed2 on2 the2 undisputed2 fts2 she2 is2 entitled2 to 2
deision2 in2 her2 fvor2 s2 2 mtter2 of2lw2euse2 the2 ford2 nnot2 ddue2 ny2 dmissile2
evidene2rising2 2genuine2issue2 s2 to2 ny2mteril2 ft2 on2n2essentil2 element@sA2of2its2 se2
prior2to2rehing22determintion2on2the2issue2of2 the2minimum2 stndrds2of2 nursing2reF2
ee
iF2ehwsxF2 gyhi2 §2ISSFSHS@AF2
weisev2 xhsih2 peg2
he2mteril2undisputed2fts2of2 this2se2re2s2followsX2
wsF2furris2holds22liense2s22votionl2nurse2nd22professionl2nurse2
in2the2tte2of2 exsF2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QF2
hisposition2—2 ge S2
espHndent’s2wotion2 for2ummry2
yer2 hoket2xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
yn2wrh2PPD2 PHIID2 wsF2furris2 ws2employed2with2the2 niversity2 of2
exs2wedil2frnhEgorretionl2wnged2gre2or2wfEgwg2 nd2
ws2working2 t2 the2 illim2 qF2 wgonnell2 nit2 loted2 in2 feevilleD2
exsF2 furris2efﬁdvit2 t2xHF2RF2
yn2wrh2PPD2PHIID2wsF2furris2ws2employed2s2nd2s2ting2only2in2
the2 pity2 of2 2 liensed2 registered2 or2 professionl2 nurseF2
furris2
effidvit2t2xHF2SF2
yn2wrh2PPD2PHIID2wsF2furrisD2who2ws2orking2in2the2medil2unit2of2
the2illim2qF2wgonnell2nit2followed2seurity2personnel2responding2
to2n2inmte2hnging2in2the2edministrtive2egregtion2unitD2 2protetive2
ustody2wrdF2 furris2 effidvit2t2xHF2TF2
wsF2furris2lerned2from2seurity2personnel2tht2there2hd2een22hnging2
involving2n2 inmteF2 furris2effidvit2t2 HF2UF2
yn2 wrh2PPD2PHIID2t2HRHID2wsF2furris2rrived2t2the2ell2of2n2inmteD2
tient2gFwF2or2tient2hgt2 xumer2VPVISQF2 furris2efﬁdvit2t2xHF2
eurity2or2nonmedil2personnel2ere2lredy2present2in2nd2outside2the2
ell2of2 tient2
hgt2 xumer2 VPVISQF2 furris2efﬁdvit2t2xHF2WF2
eurity2personnel2hd2ut2tient2hgt2 xumer2VPVISQ2down2prior2to2
wsF2furris’2rrivlF2 furris2effidvit2t2xHF2IHF2
eurity2 personnel2 did2 not2 initite2 ny2 resusittive2 efforts2 on2 tient2
hgt2 xumer2 VPVISQF2 furris2efﬁdvit2t2xoF2IIF2
hisposition2E2 ge T2
yer2 hoket2 xHF2SHUEIQEHUPU
tient2hgt2 xumer2VPVISQ2hd2suffered2n2rrestF2 furris2effidvit2
t2xHF2IPD2PIF2
he2rrest2ws2 unwitnessedF2 furris2 effidvit2t2xoF2IQD2PIF2
wsF2 furris2 initited2
2 nursing2 ssessment2 of2 tient2 hgt2 xumer2
VPVISQ2within2 seonds2 of2rriving2 on2the2 sene2 whih2ws2the2 ell2 of2
tient2hgt2 xumer2VPVISQF2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2ISF2
wsF2 furris2 performed2 2 nursing2 ssessment2 of2 tient2 hgt2 xumer2
VPVISQF2 furris2effidvit2t2xosF2ISD2IUF2
wsF2furris2hd2diffiulty2moving2tient2hgt2 xumer2VPVISQ2euse2
of2rigidity2 nd2stiffness2 nd2she2 ould2 not2move2his2 rms2whih2were2
ehind2his2kF2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2ITF2
wsF2furris2oserved2the2followingX2 ligture2mrks2t2the2inmte’s2wristsD2
nekD2 nd2 nklesY2 inmte2 ws2 ynotiD2 mottledD2 his2 rms2were2 rigid2
ehind2his2kF2 furris2 effidvit2t2xoF2IVF2
wsF2furrisD2during2the2evlution2nd2ssessmentD2sw2 wht2tient2hgt2
xumer2VPVISQ2looked2like2up2loseD2felt2his2skinD2oserved2the2olor2nd2
depth2of2the2ligture2mrk2on2his2nekD2nd2oserved2the2tul2olor2of2
his2skin2toneF2 furris2 effidvit2t2xoF2IVF2
wsF2 furris2 oserved2 the2 following2linil2 signs2 during2 her2evlution2
nd2 ssessment2 of2 tient2 hgt2xumer2VPVISQX2 @IA2 tient2 hgt2
xumer2VPVISQ2 ws2unresponsiveY2 @PA2 tient2 hgt2xumer2VPVISQ2
hd2no2respirtionsY2 @QA2tient2hgt2xumer2VPVISQ2hd2no2pulseY2 @RA2
tient2hgt2 VPVISQ’s2pupils2were2fixed2nd2diltedY2@SA2tient2 xumer2
espondent’s2wotion2 for2ummry2
hisposition2E2 ge U2
hgt2xumer2VPVISQ’s2ody2temperture2 indited2 hypothermi2@iFeFD2
old2 to2 the2 touhAY2 @TA2 tient2 hgt2xumer2VPVISQ2 hd2generlized2
ynosisY2 @UA2 there2 ws2 presene2 of2 livor2 mortisY2 nd2 @VA2 there2 ws2
presene2of2rigor2mortisF2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2PHY2wedil2eords2
ixhiit2“eD”2t2ppF2QD2UD2IID2ITF2
wsF2 furris2 noted2 these2 linil2 signs2 in2 the2 medil2 reordF2 furris2
effidvit2t2xosF2QRD2QSD2QTY2wedil2 eords2ixhiit2“eD”2pF2IIF2
F2
he2presumptive2signs2of2deth2inludeX2
@IA2ptient2unresponsiveY2@PA2no2
respirtionsY2 @QA2 no2 pulseY2 @RA2 pupils2 re2 fixed2 nd2 diltedY2 @SA2 ody2
temperture2indited2hypothermi2@iFeFD2 old2to2 the2touh2reltive2 to2 the2
seline2skin2tempertureAY2@TA2generlized2ynosisF2 fellow2 effidvit2t2
xoF2IS@gAY2etitioner’s2pirst2esponse2to2espondent’s2equests2for2
hislosure2@referening2osition2ttement2ISFPHA2ixhiit2“iF”2
tient2
hgt2 xumer2 VPVISQ2 hd2 rigor2 mortis2 present2 on2 initil2
ssessmentF2 furris2effidvitY2 wedil2eords2ixhiit2“eD”2ppF2PD2QD2
UD2WD2IHD2IIF2 uF2
tient2 hgt2xumer2VPVISQ2suffered2 n2unwitnessed2trumti2 rrest2
seondry2to2hnging2nd2livor2mortis2ws2present2on2initil2 ssessmentF2
furris2effidvit2t2xoF2PIF2
wsF2furris2oserved2nd2determined2tht2the2ptient2presented2with2rigor2
mortisF2furris2effidvit2t2xosF2PPD2PQY2wedil2eords2ixhiit2“eD”2
pF2IIF2
hisposition2—2 ge V2
yer2 hoket2xHF2SHUEIQEHUPU
F2
e2onlusive2 sign2 of2 deth2 is2 the2 presene2 of2 livor2 mortisF2
effidvit2 t2 xoF2 PSY2 fellow2 effidvit2 t2 xoF2 ITY2 etitioner’s2 pirst2
esponse2 to2 equests2 for2 hislosure2 @osition2 ttement2 ISFPHA2
ixhiit2“iF”2
F2
vivor2mortisD2 lso2 lividityD2 is2 2 ondition2 mrked2y2hypostsis2 of2the2
lood2following2deth2tht2uses22purplish2red2disolortion2of2the2skin2
due2to2lk2of2 lood2irultionF2 vivor2mortis2is2 used2y2umultion2
of2lood2in2vessels2in2dependent2res2due2to2grvityF2 fellow2effidvit2
t2xoF2IVF2
vivor2mortis2is2 evident2PHEQH2minutes2postmortemF2 fellow2effidvit2t2
xo2IWF2
F2
vivor2 mortis2 is2 2 onlusive2 sign2 of2dethF2 furris2effidvitY2 fellow2
effidvitY2 etitioner’s2 pirst2 esponse2 to2 equests2 for2 hislosure2
@osition2ttement2ISFPHA2ixhiit2“iF”2
F2
igor2 mortis2 is2 postmortem2 rigidity2 due2 to2 uildup2 of2lti2 id2 nd2
using2myosin2nd2tin2 to2 hrdenF2 smmeditely2 following2dethD2 the2
ody2is2 ﬂidD2followed2y2inresing2rigidity2 due2to2lk2of2denosine2
triphosphe2 @eA2nd2uildup2of2lti2 idF2 fellow2effidvit2t2xoF2
F2
F2
igor2mortis2ppers2IER2hours2fter2dethF2 fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2PTF2
igor2mortis2is22onlusive2sign2of2 dethF2 fellow2 efﬁdvit2t2xoF2PWF2 igor2mortis2ours2fter2the2onset2of2livor2mortisF2 fellow2effidvit2t2
xoF2IUF2
espondent’s2wotion2 for2ummry2 hisposition2E2 ge W2 yer2 hoket2 xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
igor2mortis2is2 n2ojetive2sign2of2 irreversile2 dethF2 fellow2effidvit2
t2xoF2 QHF2
here2is2 no2ondition2tht2mimis2the2musle2rigidity2 of2rigor2mortis2in2
ptients2tht2re2onlusively2dedF2 fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2PPF2
e2 do2not2resusitte2@“hx”A2is2 2medil2order2tht2must2e2given2y 2
physiinF2 fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2PVF2
fsed2on2her2ssessment2nd2euse2ll2 presumptive2signs2of2deth2nd2 two2onlusive2signs2of2deth2were2oservedD2wsF2furris2determined2tht2
g2would2e2futile2 nd2inpproprite2 interventionF2
t2xosF2PSD2PVF2
furris2effidvitF2
wsF2furris2withheld2inititing2gF2 furris2effidvit2t2xosF2PSD2PVF2
efter2wsF2furris2hd2determined2tht2there2were2two2onlusive2signs2of2
werle2willerD2FxFD22hrge2nurseD2to2 dethD2wsF2furris2ws2 instruted2y2
initite2gF2 wedil2 eords2ixhiit2“eD”2pF2PF2
g2 ws2initited2on2the2ptientF2 wedil2eords2ixhiit2“eD”2ppF2PD2
QD2IID2ISF2
wsF2furris2doumented2tht2g2 hd2een2inititedF2 furris2effidvit2t2
xosF2QRD2QSY2wedil2 eords2ixhiit2“eD”2ppF2QD2IID2ITF2
srssIF2
he2exs2 xursing2 rtie2 et2 governs2 wht2professionl2 nurses2 re2
uthorized2to2doF2 fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2IPF2
sIIIF2
he2exs2xursing2rtie2et2defines2the2 sope2of22nurse’s2prtieF2
fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2IQF2
espondent’s2wotion2 for2ummry2 hisposition2—2 ge2IH2
here2 is2 2 distintion2 etween2 the2 sope2 of2prtie2 of22 professionl2
nurse2 @registered2 nurse2 or2 xA2nd22liensed2votionl2 nurse2 @vxAF2
fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2IRF2
he2 exs2 ford2 of2 xursingD2 osition2 ttement2 ISFPHD2 “egistered2
xurses2in2 the2 wngement2of2n2nwitnessed2rrest2 in2 2 esident2in 2
erm2
gre2
pilityD”2
t2
hﬂplGGFsI€FiilsTF9FpI9glYIg€GpylllysIGhiflllD2
nd2
estlishes2 instnes2 tht2 g2 interventionEEfollowing2 2omprehensive2
nursing2 ssessmentEEwould2 e2
nd2 inpproprite2 given2 the2
ondition2of22ptientF2 fellow2effidvit2t2xHF2 ISY2 etitioner’s2pirst2
esponse2
espondent’s2 equests2 for2 hislosure2 @osition2
ttement2ISFPHA2ixhiit2“iF”2
here2 is2 no2 indition2 for2 g2in2 2 ptient2 tht2 is2 onlusively2 dedF2
fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2PIF2
he2dte2of2 deth2for2tient2hgt2 xumer2VPVISQ2ws2wrh2PPD2PHIIF2
tient2gre2 eport2 ixhiit2“sF”2
heth2ws2 pronouned2y2toseph2vyversF2 tient2gre2eport2ixhiit2
“v”2
he2hour2of2 deth2ws2 HRQHF2 tient2gre2 eport2 ixhiit2“sF”2
e2 ptient2who2 presents2with2rigor2mortis2ndGor2other2onlusive2signs2of2
deth2 suh2 s2 livor2 mortis2 nnot2e2 exposed2 unneessrily2 to2 risk2 of2
hrmF2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QIY2fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2PQF2
e2ptient2 who2presents2 with2 rigor2 mortis2 ndGor2 hs2 other2 onlusive2
hisposition2—2 ge2II2
yer2 hoket2 xo2SHUEIQEHUPU
signs2 of2deth2 suh2s2 livor2 mortis2 nnot2e2unneessrily2 exposed2to2
injuryF2
furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QPY2fellow2 efﬁdvit2t2xoF2PRF2
F2
efter2it2 is2 determined2nd2estlished2tht2 2ptient2presented2with2rigor2
mortis2ndGor2hs2other2onlusive2signs2of2deth2suh2s2livor2mortisD 2
ptient2nnot2inur2risk2of2hrm2or2injuryF2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QID2
QPY2fellow2 effidvit2t2xosF2PQD2PRF2
F2
e2 ptient2who2presents2with2rigor2mortis2 ndGor2hs2nother2onlusive2
sign2of2 deth2nnot2e2stilized2or2e2exposed2to2omplitionsF2 furris2
effidvit2t2xoF2QQY2fellow2 effidvit2t2xosF2PQEPSF2
E2
e2 ptient2who2 is2expired2or2who2 is2onlusively2ded2 nnot2e2stilized2
or2develop2omplitions2tht2n2e2prevented2with2further2intervention2
suh2s2gF2 fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2PSF2
yn2wrh2PPD2PHIID2wsF2furris2ws2ertified2 in2edvned2grdi2vife2
upport2@“egv”AF2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2PTF2
QFQPIF2
egv2is2 2 systemi2 pproh2 to2 providing2 re2 to2 vitims2 who2hve2
suffered2 2 rdi2 rrest2 or2 from2 severl2 other2 speifi2 medil2
emergeniesF2
egv2is2 n2extension2of2si2life2 support2@“fv”AF2 fv2
is2 where2the2 proess2 of2resusittion2 eginsD2 ut2
egv2is2 required2 for2
suessful2resusittionF2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2PUY2fellow2effidvitF2 t2xoF2 QTF2
2
he2 emerin2 rert2 essoition2 estlishes2 stndrds2 on2 gF2 he2
emerin2rert2essoition2is2 responsile2for2the2development2of2egv2
nd2 fgv2 ourses2 for2 helthre2 providersF2
he2 emerin2 rert2
espondent’s2wotion2for2ummry2 hisposition2E2 ge2IP2 yer2 hoket2 xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
essoition2reommends2tht2 resusittive2 efforts2 suh2s2 g2 my2e2
withheld2 for2 the2 following2resonsX2 signs2 of2irreversile2 deth2suh2s2
rigor2mortis2or2depittionD2 thret2to2sfety2of2 the2providerD2inditors2of2
2doEnotEttempt2resusittion2 @hxeA2sttus2 suh2s2 2reletD2 nkletD2 or2written2doumenttion2suh2s22vlid2do2 not2resusitte2orderF2 fellow2
effidvit2t2xoF2QUF2
F2
es2prt2 of2wsF2furris’2 egv2triningD2 she2ws2tught2nd2trined2tht2
resusittive2efforts2suh2s2rdiopulmonry2resusittion2@“g”A2my2
e2withheld2for2situtions2involving2sfety2of2the2providerD22vlid2do2not2
resusitte2orderD2or2rigor2mortisF2 furris2 efﬁdvit2t2xoF2PVF2
dddF2
es2nd2egv2 providerD2wsF2furris2ws2 tught2how2 to2perform2g2 nd2to2
know2 the2rtionle2for2nd2 effets2of2 gF2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2PWF2
wsF2furris’2 ondut2ws2limited2 to2 tient2hgt2xumer2VPVISQD2ws2
limited2to2one2osion2of2 wrh2PPD2PHIID2nd2ourred2within22spn2of2
severl2minutes2in2durtionF2 furris2 efﬁdvit2xoF2QHF2
wsF2furris’2reD2doumenttion2of2 her2ondutD2nd2linil2oservtions2
were2limited2to2 tient2hgt2xumer2VPVISQD2ws2doumented2on2one2
osion2 of2 wrh2 PPD2 PHIID2 nd2 she2 doumented2 ondutD2 linil2
oservtionsD2 nd2 re2 tht2 ourred2within2 2 spn2of2severl2 minutesF2
furris2efﬁdvit2 xoF2QIF2
sF2
eqwix2 eryssi2 exh2
espondent2is2 entitled2 to2 summrv2disposition2euse2the2sttute2uthorizing2disipline2 requires22showing2of2ondut2tht2“exposes22ptient2 unneessrilv2to2risk2of2hrm”2 nd2ondut2tht2“is2 likelv2 FF”2 hese2elements2do2not2require 2 to2injure22ptient2 determintion2 on2the2proper2stndrd2of2nursing2reF2 es22mtter2of2lwF2 there2is2 no2
hisposition2E2 ge2IQ2
exposure2of22ptient2unneessrily2to2 risk2of2hrm2or2likelv2 iniurv2 to2 2ptient2hereD2 without2disputeD22ptient2is2 ded2s2indited2y2onlusive2 signs2 of2dethF2livor2mortis2
nd2rigor2mortisF2
yer’s2summry2disposition2rule2sttes2tht2n2evt2my2issue22ﬁnl2deision2
or22proposl2for2deision2on2ll2 or2prt2of2 2ontested2se2without2n2evidentiry2hering2if2the2
evidene2 shows2there2 is2 no2genuine2 issue2 s2 to2 ny2mteril2ft2 nd2 2 prty2 is2 entitled2 to 2
deision2in2its2fvor2s22mtter2of2 lwF2 ee2I2iF2 ehwsxF2
gyhi2 FSHS@AF2 §2ISS2
he2grvmen2of2 the2 ford’s2omplint2is2 tht2wsF2furris2 ommitted2ts2tht2
rehed2her2stndrd@sA2of2re2s22registered2or2professionl2nurse2for2whih2the2ford2hs2
uthority2 to2 initite2 disiplinry2 tionF2 ee2etitioner’s2 eond2emended2porml2 ghrgesD2
ixhiit2“qF”2 tndrd2of2 reD2in2this2seD2will2e22entrl2issue2tht2the2ford2must2 estlish2 efore2it2 n2e2determined2hether2wsF2furris2hs2devited2from2tht2stndrd2to22degree2tht2
wrrnts2disipline2y2 the2fordF2 ee2 henton2 egionl2 wedil2genter2vF2 vgroixD2WRU2FFPd2
WRID2WSH2@exF2eppF2
’s2 wedF2 port2orth2IWWUD2rit2deniedAY2 see2lso2wgHms2 vF2 ghildren2
gtrFD2 FFQd2PSTD2 PSW2@exF2 eppFEexrkn2 IWWWD2 petF2 deniedAY2 eed2vF2
gorpDIIU2fFFQd2RHRD2RHW2@exF2eppF2
—2 ort2orth2 PHHQD2no2
qrnry2rospitl2
petFAF2
ixpert2medil2testimony2
required2 to2 estlish2 ht2 eh2 governing2 stndrd2 of2 re2 is2 nd2hether2 it2 hs2 een2
rehedF2 ee2 rood2 vF2 hillipsD2 SSR2FFPd2ITHD2ITSDITT2@exFIWUUAY2 vgroixD2WRU2FFPd2t2 WSHY2wgomsD2I2 FFQd2t2PSWY2eed2 vF2 qrnury2 rospF2gorpFD2 IIU2FFQd2t2RHWF2
emong2
the2 resons2 expert2 testimony2 on2the2 stndrd@sA2 of2re2 is2 essentil2 is2 tht2 the2 nture2 of2the2
lleged2reh@esA2is2outside2the2experiene2of22lypersonF2 ee2 relthre2gorpF2vF2 unfridge2
ennyD2 ITH2FFQd2PQHD2PRTERU2@exF2 eppFEEexrkn2PHHSD2no2petFA2 @iting2ork2vF2 ellenD2
TQQ2FFPd2VHRD2VHW2@exFIWVPAAF2ee2lso2ppi2 2 rnspF2erviesD2snF2 vF2 ulghmDISR2FFQd2
VRD2WH2@exF2PHHRAF2
espondent’s2wotion2for2ummry2 hisposition2—2 ge2IR2 yer2 hoket2 xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
he2fordD2s2it2 is2required2to2doD2must2estlish2nd2prove2eh2nd2ll2essentil2
sn2 this2 seD2 etion2
elements2 of2 the2 lim2 for2 ondut2 in2 order2 to2 impose2 disiplineF2
QHlFQSP@A@IHAD2@IQAS2nd2ford2rules2PIUFII@IA@eAD2@gAD2@wAD2@QA@eA@ivA2nd2PIUFIP@IA@eAD2@fAF2
ee2etitioner’s2 eond2emended2 porml2ghrgesD2ghrge2sD2 tthed2t2ixhiit2“iF”2
gritil2
to2this2motion2for2summry2 disposition2is2 the2threshold2reliztion2tht2the2prties2need2not2nd2
re2not2required2to2reh2or2onsider22determintion2on2 the2minimum2 stndrds2of2 nursing2re2
euse2the2undisputed2fts2 of2this2se2mke2it2 impossile2for2etitioner2to2prove22violtion2
s2 to2 n2essentil2 element@sA2 required2 in2 this2 lim2to2 impose2disiplinry2 tion2ginst2 wsF2 furrisF2
he2 essentil2 element@sA2 isGre2 required2 to2 e2 estlished2 nd2 nnot2 e2 ltered2
irrespetive2of2 wht2the2minimum2stndrds2of2nursing2re2my2or2my2not2eF2
yn2 this2pointD2
expert2 opinionD2 lthough2 instrutiveD2 is2 not2 needed2with2 respet2 to2 determining2 hether2the2
essentil2 element@sA2hsGhve2een2metF2
he2ford2nnot2meet2n2essentil2element@sA2sed2
on2the2 provisions2 tht2 it2 ites2 whih2entitles2 wsF2 furris2 to2 2 finl2 deision2 in2 her2 fvor2 on2
summry2disposition2ithout2n2evidentiry2heringF2 sn2shortD22violtion2nnot2e2estlished2
s22mtter2of2 lwF2
he2element2tht2requires2the2estlishment2of2exposure2of22ptient2unneessrily2to2risk2 of2 hrm2 E2 his2 element2 is2 pproprite2 for2 onsidertion2 here2 nd2 does2 not2 require2
rehing2nv2 determintion2on2the2generlly2epted2stndrds2of2 nursingprtieF2
etion2 QHIFRSP@A@IQA2 of2the2 exs2 yuptions2 gode2@lsoD2 “xurse2rtie2
et”A2providesX2
e2 person2is2 sujet2to2 denil2 of22liense2 or2to2 disiplinry2 tion2under2
this2suhpter2forX2 filure“2to2re2dequtely2for22ptient2or2to2onform2
to2the2minimum2 stndrds2of2eptle2nursing2prtie2in22mnner2thtD2
risk2of2 hrmF2
in2the2ford’s2opinionD2exposes22 ptient2or2other2 person2unneessrily2to2
espondent’s2wotion2for2ummry2 hisposition2E2 ge2IS2 yer2 hoket2 xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
etion2QHIFQSP@A@IHAD2@IQA2hs2lso2een2 ited2for2ghrge2ss
ee2iF2yggF2 gyhi2 §2Q@AIFQSP@A@IQA2@imphsis2ddedAF2
he2ford2hs2exlusively2limited2ghrge2s2 in2this2se2to2speifi2ondutD2the2
ee2 etitioner’s2 eond2emended2porml2 ghrgesD2
filure2 y2 wsF2 furris2 to2 initite2 gF2
ghrge2sD2 t2 ixhiit2“iF”2 ith2respet2 to2 ghrge2sD2 ny2llegtion2tht2 wsF2furris2violted2
usetion2QHIFRSP@A@IHA2or2@IQA2or2ny2of2the2rules2ited2in2the2porml2ghrges2is2 limited2to2
this2ondut2nd2 this2ondut2loneF2
wsF2furris2rrived2 t2 the2inmte’s2ell2 t2 HRHIF2 ee2furris2effidvit2t2 xoF2VY”2
see2wedil2eords2ixhiit2“eD”2 ppF2QD2 lTF2 ithin2seonds2of2 entering2the2ptient’s2ellD2 wsF2
furris2 egn2 to2 perform2 2 omprehensive2 ssessment2 to2 determine2 the2 pproprite2 medil2
ee2furris2effidvit2t2 xoF2ISF2 wsF2furris2hd2diffiulty2moving2tient2hgt2
xumer2VPVISQ2euse2 of2rigidity2 nd2 stiffnessF2 ee2furris2effidvit2 t2 xoF2 ITY2 wedil2
eords2ixhiit2“eD”2t2ppF2QD2 llD2 ISDT2ITF2 he2ould2not2move2 his2rms2 whih2were2ehind2his2
kF2 sdF2
IUF2
wsF2 furris2 oserved2 the2 following2 linil2 signs2 upon2 her2 evlution2 nd2
ssessment2of2 the2ptientX2 @IA2the2inmte2ws2 unresponsiveY2@PA2no2respirtionsY2@QA2no2pulseY2@RA2
pupils2 were2 fixed2 nd2diltedY2 @SA2 ody2temperture2 indited2 hypothermi2 @iFeFD2 old2 to2 the2
touhAY2 nd2@TA2 generlized2 ynosisF2 ee2furris2 effidvit2 t2 xoF2 PHY2 see2 wedil2eords2
ixhiit2“eD”2t2ppF2QD2UD2 IID2ISD2ITF2
er2wsF2furrisD2the2presene2of2livor2mortis2ws2oserved2nd2onfirmed2y2wsF2
furris2 during2 her2 initil2 ssessmentF2 ee2furris2 effidvit2 t2 xoF2 PHD2 PIY2 see2 lso2 wedil2
eords2ixhiit2“eD”2ppF2IID2ISD2 ITF2 vivor2mortis2is22luishEpurple2disolortion2of2 the2skin2on2
the2dependent2prts2of2 2ded2humn2 lood2due2 hypostsisD2or2umultion2of2 odyD2used2y2
rs2feguF”2
er2wsF2wri2 wnfrediD2vFFxFD2“esix’2 ew2 ii2 xefvi2 y2 fi2 iwyih2 pyw2 firsxh2
espondent’s2wotion2for2ummry2 hisposition2E2 ge2IT2 yer2 hoket2xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
to2 the2 tion2of2grvityF2
ee2fellow2effidvit2t2 xoF2 IVF2 vivor2mortis2is2 “venous2pooling2of2
lood2in2dependent2ody2prts2using2purple2disolortion2of2the2skin2whih2does2lnh2with2
pressureF”2
ee2 etitioner’s2
pirst2
esponse2 to2 equests2 for2 hislosure2
ixhiit2 “iD”2
referening2ford2osition2ttement2ISFPHY2fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2IVF2
he2presene2of2livor2
mortis2is22onlusive2sign2of2 dethF2 sdY2see2lso2fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2ITY2furris2effidvit2t2
xoF2QIF2
hgt2 xumer2 VPVISQ2
lso2 hd2 rigor2 mortis2 present2
initil2
ssessmentF2ee2furris2effidvit2 t2 xosF2 PHD2 PIY2 wedil2eords2ixhiit2“eD”2ppF2 P2@“rms2
ehind2him”AD2QD2U2@no2movementAD2IH2@no2motor2 response2to2pinAD2 ll2 @“ptient2old2nd2stiff”AD2
ISD2ITF2
ws2 furris2oserved2nd2determined2tient2hgt2 xumer2VPVISQ2presented2with2rigor2
mortisF2 sdY2 see2lso2engel2gre2emulne2ervieD2 snF2 tient2 gre2eport2t2 ixhiit2 “s”2
@used2the2term2“rigor2mortis”AF2he2rigor2mortis2ws2onﬁrmed2upon2wsF2furris’2 ssessmentF2
ee2furris2 effidvit2 t2 xHF2PHY2 wedil2eords2t2 ixhiit2“eD”2t2 ppF2 QD2 UD2 IHD2 IID2 ISD2 ITY2
engel2gre2emulne2ervieD2snF2tient2gre2eport2t2ixhiit2“sF”2
he2presene2of2rigor2mortis2is2 2onlusive2sign2of2dethF2 ee2furris2effidvit2
igor2mortis2is2 n2ojetive2sign2of2irreversile2
t2ixhiit2xoF2PRY2fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2IUF2
dethF2 ee2 fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2QHF2 PIF2
igor2mortis2 is2 postmortem2rigidity2 due2to2 uildup2of2lti2 id2 nd2using2
myosin2nd2tin2 to2 hrdenF2 smmeditely2 following2dethD2 the2 ody2is2 ﬂidD2 followed2y2
inresing2rigidity2due2to2lk2of2denosine2triphosphte2@eA2nd2uildup2of2 lti2idF2 ee2
fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2PHF2 igor2mortis2is2stiffening2of2 the2odyD2one2to2four2hours2fter2dethD2
from2hrdening2of2the2musulr2tissues2s22onsequene2of2the2ogultion2of2the2myosinogen2
nd2 prmyosinogenF2 ee2 fellow2effidvit2t2xosF2PHD2PRF2
espondent’s2wotion2for2ummry2 hisposition2E2 ge2IU2 yer2 hoket2 xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
feuse2of2the2presene2of2livor2mortis2nd2rigor2mortisD2two2onlusive2signs2of2
deth2onfirmed2y2wsF2furris2upon2n2ssessmentD2the2ptient2ws2dedF2 ee2furris2effidvit2
xosF2PHD2PID2PPD2PQD2PRD2PSY2wedil2eords2ixhiit2“eD”2ppF2P2@“rms2ehind2him”AD2QD2 U2@no2
movementAD2 IH2@no2motor2response2to2 pinAD2 ll2 @“ptient2 old2nd2stiff”AD2 ISD2 ITY2 engel2gre2
emulne2ervieD2snF2tient2gre2eport2t2ixhiit2“s”2@“rigor2mortis”2expressly2notedAF2
yther2medil2personnel2who2 were2lso2on2sene2or2who2 rrived2lso2orroorte2
tht2the2ptient2presented2with22onlusive2sign2of2 dethD2rigor2mortisF2
ee2wedil2eords2of2
ixhiit2 “eD”2 ppF2 P2 @werle2 F2 willerD2 FxFAD2 lS2 @wri2 wnfrediD2 vFFxFAY”2 engel2 gre2
emulne2ervieD2 snF2 tient2gre2eport2t2ixhiit2“s”2@report2prepred2y2n2imergeny2
wedil2 ehniinErmediAF2 here2 is2 no2 linil2 enefit2 to2 this2 ptient2 or2 ny2ptient2
involving2ny2resusittive2 mesures2@inluding2gA2one2rigor2mortis2hs2een2detenninedF2
ee2fellow2effidvit2t2xoF2QIF2
he2ford2must2prove2tht2when2wsF2furris2“filed2to2initite2 rdiopulmonry2
resusittion2@gA2for2tient2gwD2
hg2 xumer2VPVISQ2
F”2this2ondut2 “exposes22ptient2
unneessrily2to2risk2of2 hrmF”2 ee2iF2yggF2gyhi2 §2QHIFQSP@A@IHAD2 @IQA2@imphsis2
ddedAY2see2lso2etitioner’s2eond2 emended2 porml2ghrgesD2ghrge2sD2 t2ixhiit2“qF”2
feuse2it2 is2 undisputed2 tht2 the2ptient2 presented2with2rigor2 mortis2 nd2rigor2
mortis2is2 2onlusive2 sign2of2deth2nd2only2present2 fter2 deth2hs2ourredD2 espondent’s2
ondutD2 even2 if2 it2
estlished2 tht2 she2 ws2 or2 ws2 not2 within2 the2 generlly2 eptle2
stndrds2of2nursing2prtie2in2withholding2resusittive2efforts2sed2on22sitution2involving2
futility2 of2reD2 ould2 not2 hveD2 on2its2 feD2 “exposed22ptient2
unneessrily2 to2 risk2 of2
hrmF”2 ee2 iF2 yggF2gyhi2§2 QHIFRSP@A@IQAY2 ee2furris2 effidvit2 t2 xoF2 QIY2 fellow2
effidvit2t2xosF2PQEPSD2QREQSF2 purthermoreD22ptient2who2 presents2with2onlusive2signs2of2
espondent’s2wotion2for2ummry2 hisposition2E2 ge2IV2
dethD2 livor2mortis2 nd2rigor2mortisD2 nnot2e2“deprived2
of2 timely2resusittion2effortsF”2
ee2etitioner’s2 eond2emended2 porml2ghrgesD2ghrge2sD2 t2ixhiit2“qY”2fellow2effidvit2
t2xoF2QIF2 elsoD2one2it2 is2estlished2tht22ptient2is2ded2 @iFeFD2 s2evidened2
y2rigor2mortisAD 2
ptient’s2ondition2nnot2e2stilized2or2e2sujeted2to2further2omplitionF2 ee2 etitioner’s2
eond2emended2 porml2ghrgesD2ghrge2sD2 t2ixhiit2“qg”2furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QQY2fellow2
effidvit2t2xosF2PQEPSD2QREQSF2
ursunt2to2 ghrge2sD2 the2 ford’s2rules2 ited2 y2etitioner2 in2 its2 pledingsD2 PP2
iF2ehwsxF2gyhi2 §§2PIUFII@IA@eAD2@gAD2@wAD2@QA@eA@ivAD2nd2PIUFIP@IA@eAD2fAD2re2ll2ited2
to2prove2misondutD2ut2re2speiﬁlly2nd2exlusively2relted2to2 2filure2 to2 initite2 gF2
ee2etitioner’s2 eond2emended2porml2 ghrgesD2 ghrge2 sD2 t2 ixhiit2 “qF”2 feuse2 the2
ondut2is2 limited2to2filure2 to2 initite2 gEEnd2the2undisputed2fts2 estlish2no2exposure2to2
unneessry2risk2of2hrmD2no2injury2or2likely2injuryD2 or2no2development2of2omplitions2for 2
ptient2 presenting2 with2 rigor2 mortis2 or2 who2ws2 dedEEthe2 issue2 of2 determining2 hether2
violtions2 under2these2provisions2 exist2 re2 not2rehed2nor2re2 they2implited2 s22mtter2of2
lwF2 his2is2 espeilly2true2in2light2of2the2immutle2ft2tht2the2only2ondutU2tht2hs2een2 lleged2 reltive2 to2 these2 provisions2 fous2 exlusively2 on22filure2 to2 initite2 g2 for2 tient2
hgt2xumer2VPVISQF2
husD2 one22ptient2 presents2 with22onlusive2 sign2 of2deth2or2 n2
irreversile2 sign2of2dethD2 nd2the2 lleged2ondut2is2 restrited2 to2 2filure2 to2 initite2
g2@s2
opposedD2for2exmpleD2to22filure2to2perform22omprehensive2nursing2ssessmentAD2no2 violtion2
n2e2mde2 under2PIUFII@IA@eAD2@gAD2@wAD2@QA@eA@ivA2nd2PIUFIP@IA@eAD2fAF2
nprofessionl2 or2 dishonorle2 ondut2 llegtion2 nd2 the2 element2 tht2 requires2 the2 estlishment2of2ondut2“likelv2to2 injure22ptientF”2 his2element2is2 pproprite2for2 onsidertion2 here2 nd2 does2 not2 require2 nv2 determintion2 of2expert2 opinion2 on2 the2 generlly2epted2stndrds2of2nursingprtieF2 es22mtter2of2lwD2there2is2 no2likely2
espondent’s2wotion2for2ummry2 hisposition2E2 ge2IW2 yer2 hoket2 xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
eferening2ghrge2s2 speifillyF2
iniurv2 to2 2ptient2whereD2without2disputeF2 2ptient2is2 ded2s2 indited2 y2onlusive2 signs2of2 dethF2livor2mortis2nd2 rigor2mortisF2
etion2 QHlFRSP@A@lHA2 of2the2 exs2 yuptions2 gode2@lsoD2 “xurse2rtie2
puliY2
this2 suhpter2 forX2 unprofessionl2 or2 dishonorle2 ondut2thtD2 in2 the2 ord’s2opinionD2 is2 likely2to2 deeiveD2 defrudD2 or2injure2 2ptient2or2 the2
ee2iF2yggF2 gyhi2 §2QHIFQSP@A@IHA2@imphsis2ddedAF2
he2 ford2 is2 uthorized2
to2 tke2 disiplinry2 tion2 ginst2 2 nurse2 for2
“unprofessionl2or2dishonorle2ondut2thtD2 in2the2ord’s2opinionD2 is2 likely2 to2
ptient2
injure 2
FF”2
ee2iF2yggF2gyhi2 exxF2§2 QHIFRSP@A@IHAY2 see2lso2etitioner’s2 eond2
nprofessionl2or2dishonorle2ondut2
emended2porml2ghrgesD2ghrge2sD2 t2ixhiit2“qF”2
likely2 to2 deeiveD2 defrud2 or2 injure2 2 ptient2 or2 the2 puli2 inludesX2 @eA2 relessly2 filingD2
repetedly2filingD2or2exhiiting2n2 inility2to2perform2 registered2nursing2in2onformity2 with2the2
minimum2eptle2level2 of2nursing2prtie2 desried2in2 ule2PIUFIIY2 nd2@fA2relessly2or2
repetedly2 filing2 to2 onform2to2 generlly2 epted2 nursing2 stndrds2 in2 pplile2 prtie2
settingsF2 ee2 PP2 iF2
ehwsxF2 gyhi2 §2PIUFIP@IA@eA2nd2@fAFV2
eginD2s22threshold2mtter2for2this2summry2 the2 dispositionD2the2fous2is2not2on2
minimum2stndrd2 of2nursing2 re2 nd2 the2 determintion2 of2smeD2 ut2 rtherD2 initillyD2 the2
undisputed2ft2tht2the2ptient2presented2with22onlusive2sign2of2dethD2rigor2mortisD2nd2ws2
ford2ule2PIUFIP@IA@eA2providesX2
“grelessly2filingD2repetedly2filingD2or2exhiiting2n2 inility2to2perform2 or2 votionlD2registered2 dvned2prtie2nursing2in2onformity2with2the2stndrds2of2 minimum2 eptle2level2of2 nursing2 lF”2 prtie2set2out2in2ule2 PIUFI2
ford2rule2PIUFIP@IA@fA2providesX2
settingsF”2
“grelessly2or2 repetedly2filing2to2onﬁrm2 to2generlly2epted2 nursing2stndrds2in2pplile2prtie2
espondent’s2wotion2 for2ummry2 hisposition2E2 ge2PH2
dedF2
yne2this2 determintion2ws2mde2y2wsF2furrisD2 ny2disussion2or2nlysis2involving2
the2minimum2 stndrd2of2 nursing2re2is2simply2not2neessry2nd2need2not2e2rehedF2 hen 2 ptient2is2 dedD2no2“injury”2or2no2“likely2injury”2exists2to22ptient2s22mtter2of2 lw2nd2holds2
true2 reltive2 to2 the2 ondut2of2inititing2 gF2
ee2iF2yggF2gyhi2 §2 QHIFRSP@A@IHAY2 see2
lso2 fellow2effidvit2 t2 PQEPSD2 QREQSF2 rereD2 etitioner2 ontends2 tht2 wsF2furris2 my2hve2
used2or2tht2injury2my2 hve2resulted2from2wsF2furris2filing2to2initite2gD2reognizing2tht2 n2tul2 injury2need2not2e2estlishedF2 ee2 PP2iF2ehwsxF2gyhi2 PIUFIP2@“etul2 §2 §2
injury2to22lient2need2 not2e2estlishedF”AF2 eginD2ny2“injury”2or2“likely2injury”2is2limited2to2
the2tion2limed2in2ghrge2s2 of2 etitioner’s2eond2emended2 porml2ghrges2whihD2in2this2
seD2is2 the2filure2to2initite2 gF2 ee2etitioner’s2eond2emended2 porml2ghrges2tthed2
t2ixhiit2“qF”2 purtherD2it2 nnot2e2rguedD2s22mtter2of2 lw2nd2per2the2undisputed2fts2of2
this2seD2tht2the2ondut2of2 filing2to2initite2
g2 is2“deeptive”2or2one2 tht2“defrudsF”2
eny2ondut2tht2 is2 “likely2 to2 deeive”2 or2 “defrud”2 2ptient2 @or2 the2 puliA2
nnot2e2proven2nd2is2 n2impossiility2 s22mtter2of2lw2in22sitution2where2the2ptient2is2
dedD2 espeilly2 where2 the2 limed2 ondut2 is2 solely2 for2 the2 filure2 to2 initite2 gF2
ee2
etitioner’s2 eond2emended2 porml2ghrgesD2ghrge2sD2 t2ixhiit2“qF”2 vikewiseD2ny2lim2
tht2 wsF2 furris’2
ondut2 “deprived2 the2 ptient2 of2timely2 resusittion2 efforts”2 is2 lso2 n2
imprtility2nd2 flly2euse2the2ptient2is2dedF2 ee2 fellow2 effidvit2t2PQEPSD2QID2QREQSF2 QIF2
pinllyD2 wsF2 furris’2 re2 ws2limited2 to2 re2 provided2to2 one2ptientD2 hgt2
xumer2VPVISQD2 nd2on2one2osionD2 wrh2PPD2 PHIIF2 ee2etitioner’s2 eond2emended2
porml2ghrges2t2ixhiit2“qF”2@iting2PP2iF2ehwsxF2gyhi2 §2 PIUFIP@IA@eAD2@fAAY2 furris2
effidvit2t2xoF2QHF2 wsF2furris’2 re2enompssed22spn2of2severl2minutesF2 sdF2 eginD2nd2
per2the2 ford’s2pledingD2 the2 “reless”2 ondut2 it2 lims2hs2 een2pled2to2 ondut2relted2
espondent’s2wotion2 for2ummry2 hisposition2—2 ge2 PI2 yer2 hoket2xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
speiﬁlly2to2 filure2 to2 “initite2 rdiopulmonry2resusittion2 @gA2for2tient2 gwD2hgt2
xumer2VPVISQD2 fter2 the2 ptient2 s2found2hnging2in2 his2 ellF”2 ee2etitioner’s2 eond2
emended2porml2ghrgesD2ghrge2sD2 t2ixhiit2“qF”2 es2suhD2wsF2furris’2 ondut2nnot2e2
hrterized2under2the2provision2s2either2“reless”2or2s2“repetitive2filures”2under2 PP2eg
PIUFIP@IA@eAFW2 ee2PP2 iF2ehwsxF2
gyhi2 §2PIUFIP@IA@eAD2@fAY2ee2lso2etitioner’s2eond2
emended2 ghrges2t2ixhiit2“qF”2
he2requirement2of2 “reless”2or2“repetitive”2does2not2enompss22nurse’s2re2
provided2 to2 one2 ptient2 on2 one2 osionD2 within2 2 spn2 of2 severl2 minutesF2 he2 resons2
dvned2ove2s2to2why2 there2ould2e2 no2violtion2when2 there2is2no2 possile2exposure2of2 this2
ptient2who2 hd2n2undisputed2onlusive2sign2of2 deth2@iFeFD2 rigor2mortisA2to2unneessry2risk2of2
hrmD2 eqully2 pplies2 nd2holds2 true2 hereF2 yne’s2 ondut2 of2not2 inititing2 g2nnot2e2
onluded2s2“reless”2upon2determining2tht2the2ptient2presented2with22onlusive2 sign2of2
deth2s2well2s2presented2with2other2presumptive2signs2of2dethY2the2former2onsisting2of2livor2 mortis2nd2rigor2mortisF2 he2term2reless2is2 deﬁned2s2“not2pying2enough2ttention2to2ht2
one2doesF”2
@IWVVAF2
ri2exhyw2ryi2gyvviqi2hsgsyxe2isih2ihssyx2PHR2
espondent2ws2“reless”2
st2is2 signiﬁnt2tht2etitioner’s2pleding2is2not2lleging2tht2
euse2she2filed2to2perform2n2ssessmentD2tht2she2ws2“reless”2euse2she2did2not2know2
the2 xursing2 rtie2 et2 nd2the2 ord’s2 rules2 nd2regultionsD2 or2 tht2 she2 ws2“reless”2
euse2she2did2not2know2 the2rtionl2nd2effets2of2 gF2 er2ghrge2sD2 the2only2t2etitioner2
lims2 s2 unprofessionl2 ondut2whih2is2 sujet2to2 the2 “reless”2 nlysis2 is2 the2 filure2 to2
initite2 gF2
es2dvned2oveD2nd2euse2it2 is2 undisputed2tht2tht2 the2ptient2 ould2not2
his2nlysis2lso2pplies2to2the2ondut2lleged2tht2wsF2furris2“filed2 to2ompletely2nd2 urtely2doument2 the2nursing2re2rendered2nd2 not2rendered2for2tient2gwD2 2 xumer2VPVISQ2 F”2per2etitioner’s2pledings2 hgt2
espondent’s2wotion2 for2ummry2 hisposition2—2 ge2 PP2
under2PP2 iF2 ehwsxF2 gyhi2 etitioner’s2eond2 emended2 porml2ghrgesD2ghrge2 §2PIUFIP@IA@eAD2@fAF2 ee2 “qF”2 ssD2 t2ixhiit2
hve2een2 exposed2 nd2ws2not2 exposed2 unneessrily2 to2 risk2 of2hrmD2 it2 follows2 tht2 the2
ondut2to2detennine2tht2g2 ws2inpproprite2or2futile2 interventionD2 one2it2 ws2determined2
tht22 ptient2hd2 2 onlusive2sign2of2 dethD2ould2 not2hve2een2“reless”2or2tht2it2ould2 hve2
resulted2 in2 n2 “injuryF”2 woresoD2 one2 2 ptient2 is2 dedD2 there2 re2 no2 pproprite2 nursing2
interventions2tht2might2e2instituted2 in2 order2to2 stilize2 2lient’s2 ondition2ndGor2prevent2
omplitionsF2 ee2 fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2QIY2PP2 iF2ehwsxF2
QQF2
filed2 to2
gyhi2 §2PIUFII@IA@wAF2
wsF2furris2
st2 is2 signifint2 tht2 this2 mtter2does2not2involve2 n2llegtion2 tht2
perform2 2 omprehensive2 ssessmentD2 tht2 she2 unneessrily2 delyed2 in2 the2
performne2of2the2ssessmentD2tht2she2did2not2know2 how2to2initite2 gD2or2tht2she2did2not2
know2the2enefits2or2effets2of2gF2 e2 elieve2tht2ny2of2 these2issues2my2 nd2will2likely2e2
rised2 y2 etitioner2 in2 its2 response2 to2 this2 motion2 to2 defet2 summry2 dispositionD2 ut2 its2
pledings2on2this2point2mke2ler2tht2the2limited2ondut2it2 lims2to2e2in2violtion2ws2tht2
wsF2furris2filed2to2initite2gFIH2 ee2etitioner’s2eond2emended2 porml2ghrgesD2ghrge2
sD2 t2
ixhiit2“qF”2
ivents2tht2 trnspired2 fter2it2 ws2determined2 nd2estlished2 tht2 the2 ptient2
ws2dedD2lthough2likely2to2e2disputed2y2etitioner2in2its2response2with2respet2to2n2ttempt2
to2 rise2 ft2issues2tht2would2e2pproprite2for22ontested2se2heringD2re2not2rehed2nd2
need2not2e2rehed2or2determined2for2purposes2of2this2motionF2 wke2no2mistkeD2this2will2e2
etitioner’s2gol2in2its2 responseF2
roweverD2ft2issues2tht2re2in2disputeD2ut2fter2the2 ft2do2
not2hnge2the2undisputed2ft2initilly2tht2the2ptient2ws2ded2nd2sed2on2thisD2 etitioner2
nnot2estlish2vitl2elements2of2 its2se2neessry2to2impose2 disiplineF2
exxF2§2PHHIFHSY2see2lso2retzer2vF2 exs2 wotor2ehile2fordD2IPS2FFQd2PQD2QU2@exF2eppFE2eustin2PHHQAD2
espHndent’s2wotion2for2ummry2 hisposition2E2 ge2PQ2
reversed2in2prt2nd2ffirmed2in2relevnt2prtD2 IQV2FFQd2WHV2@exF2PHHRAF2
en2 geny2must2suffiiently2identify2the2fts2or2evidene2in2its2xotie2of2 rering2 whih2it2intends2to2prove2t2 the2hering2so2tht22prty2my2 hve22meningful2opportunity2to2prepre22defenseF2 ee2iF2qy’2
gyhi2
edditionl2 issues2 or2 fts2 tht2 etitioner2 my2 rise2 in2 its2 response2 to2 this2
summry2disposition2motion2to2 overome2summry2disposition2 in2wsF2furris’2 fvor2must2e2
ritilly2exmined2nd2 viewed2y2the2
yer2 evt2s2they2re2likely2to2touh2upon2the2generlly2
epted2stndrds2of2 prtie2or2events2tht2trnspired2fter2wsF2furris’2ssessment2nd2one2it2
ws2determined2tht2 the2ptient2hd2presumptive2nd2onlusive2signs2 of2dethF2 espondent2
sumits2nd2knowledges2tht2lthough2these2issues2my2 rise2 the2possiility2of2 ft2disputesD2
these2 efforts2 do2not2hnge2the2 initil2 threshold2 nlysis2 tht2 the2ptientD2 undisputedlyD2 ws2in2
rigor2mortis2whih2mkes2ll2 other2ondut2therefter2not2pplile2for22onsidertion2on2this2
motion2for2summry2dispositionD2espeilly2given2the2elements2of2the2provisions2tht2etitioner2
hs2lleged2nd2lsoD2given2how2 limiting2in2nture2the2ford’s2porml2ghrges2re2with2respet2
to2 the2 speifi2 ondut2limed2to2 e2in2 violtion2 @iFeFD2 filure2 to2 initite2 gAF2
yne2moreD2
these2issuesD2 we2elieveD2 will2e2nothing2more2thn2n2ttempt2to2 misdiret2the2
ttention2nd2 rete2ft2issues2on2 tngentil2issues2to2void2summry2 dispositionF2
yer2evt’s2
iven2ifD2 rguendoD2it2 n2e2estlished2tht2wsF2furris’2ondut2in2not2inititing2
g2following2 her2 ssessment2 fell2 elow2 the2 stndrds2 of2 minimum2 nursing2 reDII2 the2
hrteriztion2 y2 etitioner2 tht2 wsF2 furris’2 ondut2 to2 withhold2 g2ws2 2 reless2 or2
repetitive2 filure2 for2 2 ptient2 who2hd2 presented2 with2 livor2 mortis2 nd2 rigor2 mortisD2 oth2
onlusive2 signs2 of2deth2 @lsoD2 irreversile2 dethA2 or2tht2 she2hd2“filed2to2 ompletely2nd2
urtely2doument2
F”2 nnot2 e2
deemed2or2hrterized2s2“reless”2or2“repetitive”2sed2
on2the2undisputed2fts2nd2is2inonsistent2with2the2pplile2uthorityF2 ee2PP2iF2ehwsxF2
gyhi2 §2PIUFII@IA@eAD2@fAF2 rior2to2eptemer2PVD2PHHRD2susetion2@lA@eA2did2not2require2tht2
espondent2rgues2nd2stresses2gin2tht22determintion2on2the2minimum2 stndrds2of2 nursing2re2need2not2e2 rehed2for2this2motion2for2summry2 judgmentF2 his2is2espeilly2true2for2PP2 ehwsxF2gyhi §2 iF2 PIU2 FIP@IA@fA2despite2the2lnguge2relted2to2onforming2to2“generlly2epted2 nursing2stndrds2 FF”2 etitioner’s2 pledings2hrterizing2espondent’s2ondut2@oth2s2to2filing2to2initite2g2 or2doumenttion2of2 smeA2is2 inonsistent2with2the2requirement2tht2the2ondut2e2reless2or2repetitive2filuresF2
espondent’s2wotion2for2ummry2 hisposition2E2 ge2 PR2 yer2 hoket2xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
2nurse’s2 filures2 e2 “reless”2 or2 “repetitive”2 in2
order2to2 onstitute2 unprofessionl2 ondutF2
he2 hnge2 to2 this2 rule2 nd2 the2 imposition2 of2 this2 dditionl2 requirement2
eptemer2 PUD2 PHHRD2 does2 not2 enompss2 2 nurse’s2 re2 provided2 to2 one2
susequent2 to2
ptient2 on2 one2
osionD2 within2 2spn2of2severl2 minutesF2 imilrlyD2 the2 sme2 resoning2lso2 pplies2 to2 PP2
iF2 ehwsxF2 gyhi2§2 PIUFIP@IA@fADIP2 whih2 underwent2 2 nerly2 identil2
revision2 in2
eptemer2PHHRF2 wsF2furris’2 ondutD”2to2the2extent2tht2it2 is2 onsidered22 filure2to2perform2
n2t2imposed2y2the2generlly2epted2nursing2prtie2nd2even2
if2it2 is2proven2 to2e2 the2seD2
ws2not22“repetitive2filure”2nd2ws2 not2“relessF”2
ith2respet2 to2 ghrge2ssD2 espondent2is2 entitled2 to2 summry2disposition2 euse2 it2 is2 undisputed2tht2wsF2furris2doumented2her2ﬁndings2of2 rigor2mortis2nd2 lso2the2initition2 of2g2 when2it2 ws2ordered2to2e2initited2v22hrge2nurseF2 his2ondutF2s22mtter2 of2 lwD2nnot2e2deemed2 to2e2 flseD2deeptiveF2or2 misledingD2
sn2ghrge2ss2of2 etitioner’s2eond2emended2 porml2ghrgesD2the2ford2lleges2
tht2wsF2furrisD “2
filed2to2 ompletely2nd2urtely2doument2the2nursing2re2rendered2
nd2 not2 rendered2 for2 tient2 gwD2hgt2xtnner2 VPVISQ2
F”2
ee2 etitioner’s2 eond2
emended2porml2 ghrgesD2 ghrge2ssD2 t2 ixhiit2 “iY”2see2lso2 PP2iF2ehwsxF2gyhi
PIUFII@IA@eAD2 @hAD2 §2 PIUFIP@IA@eAD2 @fAD2 T@rAF2 wsF2 furris2 doumented2 tht2 tient2 hgt2
xumer2VPVISQ2s2in2rigor2mortisF2 ee2furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QSY2see2lso2wedil2eords2
t2ixhiit2“eD”2 pF2 QEIRD2 ITF2
wsF2furrisD2when2g2 ws2ordered2y2the2hrge2nurseD2ut2fter2
she2hd2determined2tht2the2ptient2hd2 presented2with2two2onlusive2signs2of2 dethD2ssisted2in2
g2nd2doumented2this2into2the2reordF2 ee2furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QSY2wedil2eords2t2
ixhiit2“eF”2 pF2QEIRD2ITF2
espondent2notes2tht2this2would2lso2hold2true2for2PP2 iF2 ehwsxF2 not2een2ited2s22grounds2for2seeking2disiplinry2tion2ginst2
espondent’s2wotion2 for2ummry2 hisposition2E2 ge2 PS2 yer2 hoket2xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
rereD2the2ondut2pplies2to2oth2the2filure2to2initite2g2 nd2to2
wsF2furrisF2
gyhi2 §2PIUFIP@RAD2ut2this2provision2hs2
doumentF2
ursunt2to2 iF2yggF2gyhi2 e2disiplined2 §2 QHIFRSP@A@IHAD22liensee2my2
for2engging2in2unprofessionl2ondut2whih2is2 defined2to2inlude2unprofessionl2ondutD2ut2
more2speiﬁllyD2misondut2tht2inludes2“providing2informtion2whih2ws2flseD2deeptiveD2
or2 misleding2 in2 omqetion2 with2 the2 prtie2 of2 nursingF”2
ee2 iF2 yggF2 gyhi §2
QHIFRSP@A@IHAY2 PP2iF2ehwsxF2gyhi2 §2 PIUFIP@TA@rAF2 “plse”2is2 deﬁned2s2 “not2true2 or2
orret”2 or2 “uttering2 or2 delring2 wht2 is2 untrueF”2
ri2exhyw2ryi2gyvviqi2
hsgsyxe2 isih2ihssyx2RUT2@IWVVAF2 “heeptive”2is2 deﬁned2s2“pt2or2tending2to2
deeiveF”2 sd2t2 QRRF2 “heeive”2 is2 deﬁned2 s2 “to2 misled2 y2 2 flse2 pperne2 or2 flse2
sttementF”2 sd2t2 QRRF2 “wisleding”2is2 deﬁned2s2 “to2 led2into2 error2of2ondutD2thoughtD2 or2
judgmentF”2 sdF2t2VSRF2
wsF2furris2doumented2her2ssessmentD2findings2s2to2rigor2mortisD2other2linil2
oservtionsD2 nd2the2initition2 of2g2 when2it2 ws2orderedD2 nd2the2re2she2rendered2in2the2
“gorretionl2 wnged2 gre2 glini2 xotes2 —2xursingD”2 “imergeny2 eordD2 “gorretionl2
wnged2 gre2 xursing2 rotool2 for2 xervous2 ystem2 gomplintsF”2 ee2 wedil2 eords2
ixhiit2“e”2 t2ppF2QEIRD2ITY2furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QSF2
RHF2 rior2to2mking2 her2findings2nd2ondut2in2the2notesD2she2 ny2doumenttion2of2
disussed2her2hndling2in2 the2 re2 of2tient2 hgt2xumer2VPVISQD2 her2finding2 s2 to2 rigor2
mortisD2other2linil2oservtionsD2nd2the2initition2of2 g2 hen2 instruted2with2
wfEgwg2
stffD2 wsF2 wri2wnfrediD2vFFxFD2nd2wsF2werle2willerD2FxF2 ee2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QTF2
yther2wfEgwg2 medil2providersD2 inluding2wsF2wri2wnfrediD2 vFFxFD2
nd2wsF2werle2willerD2FxFD2doumented2their2linil2oservtions2nd2re2provided2to2tient2
hgt2 xumer2 VPVISQ2 s2 prt2 of2 their2 reporting2 nd2 doumenttion2 nd2 lso2 provided2
espHndent’s2wotion2 for2ummry2 hisposition2—2 ge2 PT2
hndwritten2 sttements2 regrding2 their2 ondut2 in2 n2 “snterEyffie2 gommunitionsF”2 ee2
wedil2eords2ixhiit2“e”2 t2ppF2PEIT92furris2 effidvit2t2xoF2QVF
F2
gyxgvsyx2 exh2 ei2
yer2 evt2grnt2
riipyiD2 iwsi2 gyxshiihD2 sed2 on2 the2 summry2 disposition2
evideneD2s2ell2s2the2pplile2legl2uthoritiesD2 espondent2requests2the2
her2wotion2for2 ummry2hisposition2 on2the2 sis2 tht2 the2 elements2requiring2 exposure2 of 2
ptient2unneessrily2to2risk2of2hrm2or2ondut2likely2to2 injure22ptient2nnot2e2estlished2
on2undisputed2fts2nd2s22mtter2of2lw2when22ptient2presents2with2rigor2mortisD2is2 expiredD2
exhiits2presumptive2nd2onlusive2signs2of2dethD2 nd2hs2irreversile2dethF2 imilrlyD2s 2
mtter2of2 lwD2etitioner2nnot2meet2ll2 of2 the2essentil2elements2s2required2y2the2uthorities2
ites2 sed2 on2 the2 undisputed2 ftsD2 inluding2 ghrge2 ss2 regrding2 doumenttionD2 whih2
entitles2
wsF2 furris2 to2 2 finl2 deision2 in2 her2 fvor2 on2 summry2 disposition2 ithout2 n2
evidentiry2heringF2 sn2shortD22violtion2nnot2e2estlished2s22mtter2of2 lwF2 espondent2
mkes2 herself2 ville2 for2 2 hering2 if2 the2 yer2evt2elieves2 this2 would2 e2 helpfulF2
espondent2 further2prys2for2ll2other2relief2to2whih2 she2might2 e2entitledF2
espetfully2umittedD2
FyF2fox2 SHPPU2 eustinD2exs2UVUTQ2 elephone2 @SIPA2UVWEQVWH2 @SIPA2WHRESSIT2psimile
ri2 rex2 ve2 FgF2 pswD2
ry2
tte2fr2 xoF2PRHIHSVV2
eyxi2 py2 iyxhix2
espondent’s2wotion2 for2ummry2 hisposition2E2 ge2 PU2 yer2 hoket2xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
gispsgei2 yp2 isgi2
his2 is2 to2 ertify2 tht2 2true2 nd2orret2 opy2of2espondent’s2 wotion2for2 ummry2 hisposition2 nd2 xotie2 of2 sntent2 to2 se2 hisovery2 roduts2 xot2 on2 pile2 in2 2 ummry2 hisposition2 ‘roeeding2were2served2on2etitionerD2through2ounsel2of2 reordD2y2hnd2deliveryD2 on2this2 RQ92 dy2of2 wrhD2PHIQX2
i2 rnd2 heliveg2 xikki2ropkinsD2isqF2
eustinD2exs2UVUHI
QQQ2qudlupe2treetD2uite2QERTH2
espondent’s2wotion2for2ummry2 hisposition2E2 ge2 PV2