Source: https://publicpersonnellaw.blogspot.com/2015/06/the-law-enforcement-exemption-in-pol_10.html
Timestamp: 2017-08-18 02:59:24
Document Index: 232054917

Matched Legal Cases: ['§87', '§87', '§87', '§87', '§87', '§87', 'Sui Generis']

New York Public Personnel Law: The “law enforcement exemption” in POL §87(2) (e) (iv) is not applicable to FOIL requests for documents that might result in administrative disciplinary action
New York Public Personnel Law
Summaries of, and commentaries on, selected court and administrative decisions and related matters affecting public employers and employees in New York State
Best Lawblog Contest for 2017 now being conducted by The Legal Institute
From now until September 15th, 2017, Lawblog fans can nominate their favorite blogs and bloggers for inclusion in the voting round of 2017. As in previous years, the nomination process is competitive, meaning the more nominations a blog receives, the more likely it is to be included in the public voting stage of the contest.
To access the link to the nomination form, click on:
https://www.theexpertinstitute.com/blog-contest/?utm_source=email&utm_medium=email&utm_content=CTA&utm_campaign=blog-contest-8.14.2017-general
The “law enforcement exemption” in POL §87(2) (e) (iv) is not applicable to FOIL requests for documents that might result in administrative disciplinary action
2015 NY Slip Op 04356, Appellate Division, Third Department
Department of Taxation and Finance [Department] undertook a department-wide audit to identify employees who had overstated their job-related expense deductions on their personal income tax returns. As a result a number of employees [Petitioners] serving in the Department's Criminal Investigation Division, were issued notices advising them to — in accordance with the provisions of their union contract — submit to an official interrogation in order to determine whether disciplinary action was warranted.
Petitioners objected to the interrogation and filed a Freedom of Information Law [FOIL] request seeking "any and all documents, records, memoranda and files . . ., which relate, concern, were precipitated by, or respond to, directly or indirectly, to the . . . proposed interrogation of [Petitioners]."
The Department’s records access officer produced various documents but denied access to, among other things, 68 pages of documents containing proposed interrogation questions — citing the “law enforcement exemption” as justification for withholding those documents. Ultimately Petitioners initiated a CPLR Article 78 proceeding seeking disclosure of the remaining withheld documents. Following an in camera inspection, Supreme Court concluded that the 68 pages of proposed questions did not fall with the “law enforcement exemption” and ordered the release of those pages.
The Appellate Division affirmed the Supreme Court’s ruling, explaining that “Under FOIL, agency records are presumptively available for public inspection, without regard to the need or purpose of the applicant, unless the requested documents fall within one of the exemptions set forth in Public Officers Law §87(2)," citing Williamson v Fischer, 116 AD3d 1169, leave to appeal denied, 24 NY3d 904.
The court said that "[e]xemptions are narrowly construed, with the agency that seeks to prevent disclosure bearing the burden of demonstrating that the requested material falls squarely within an exemption by articulating a particularized and specific justification for denying access." In denying access to the 68 pages of proposed interrogation questions, the Department “relied exclusively upon Public Officers Law §87(2) (e) (iv), which exempts from disclosure "records or portions thereof that . . . reveal criminal investigative techniques or procedures, except routine techniques and procedures."
The statute’s references criminal investigative techniques or procedures, and prevailing case law suggests that this exemption applies only to a FOIL request that, at the very least, has its genesis in an underlying criminal investigation or prosecution. As the records before the Appellate Division “makes no reference to a criminal investigation implicating [Petitioners}, nor does it suggest that state or local law enforcement officials would be involved in the proposed interrogation of them, the court found that the law enforcement exemption embodied in Public Officers Law §87 (2) (e) (iv) was inapplicable to the documents at issue .
Observing that the Department sought to question Petitioners in accordance with the provisions of their union contract for the purpose of gathering information that, in turn, potentially could result in the commencement of administrative disciplinary proceedings, the Appellate Division concluded that the Department’s reliance on the “law enforcement exemption” was misplaced. Further, the Appellate Division said that it was satisfied that “even assuming this exemption otherwise applied here, the questions at issue were routine in nature — the disclosure of which would not reveal detailed or specialized investigative techniques or procedures.”
The court noted two additional grounds advanced by the Department for denying disclosure of the proposed interrogation questions – the exemption of [1] the disclosure of records that "interfere with law enforcement investigations or judicial proceedings,” and the exemption of [2] pre-decisional, inter-agency or intra-agency materials from disclosure. For a number of procedural reasons set out in the opinion, the Appellate Division declined to consider these arguments
The decision is posted on the Internet at:
http://www.nycourts.gov/reporter/3dseries/2015/2015_04356.htm
Handbooks focusing on State and Municipal Public Personnel Law continue to be available for purchase via the links provided below:
The Discipline Book at http://thedisciplinebook.blogspot.com/
A Reasonable Penalty Under The Circumstances at http://nypplarchives.blogspot.com
The Disability Benefits E-book: at http://section207.blogspot.com/
Layoff, Preferred Lists at http://nylayoff.blogspot.com/
Subsequent court and administrative rulings, or changes to laws, rules and regulations may have modified or clarified or vacated or reversed the decisions summarized here. Accordingly, these summaries should be Shepardized® or otherwise checked to make certain that the most recent information is being considered by the reader.
THE MATERIAL ON THIS WEBSITE IS FOR INFORMATION ONLY. CHANGES IN LAWS, RULES, REGULATIONS AND NEW COURT AND ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS MAY AFFECT THE ACCURACY OF THE INFORMATION PROVIDED IN THIS LAWBLOG. THE MATERIAL PRESENTED IS NOT LEGAL ADVICE AND THE USE OF ANY MATERIAL POSTED ON THIS WEBSITE DOES NOT CREATE AN ATTORNEY-CLIENT RELATIONSHIP.
Consistent with the Declaration of Principles jointly adopted by a Committee of the American Bar Association and a Committee of Publishers and Associations, the material in this blog is presented with the understanding that the publisher is not providing legal advice to the reader and in the event legal or other expert assistance is needed, the reader should seek such advice from a competent professional.
Items published in NYPPL may not be used for commercial purposes without prior written permission to copy and distribute such material. Send your request via e-mail to publications@nycap.rr.com
Copyright© 1987 - 2017 by the Public Employment Law Press.
The Public Employment Law Press
N.B. From time to time a political ad or endorsement may appear in the sidebar of this Blog. NYPPL does not have any control over such posting.
Electronic Handbooks
The Discipline Book - A concise guide to disciplinary actions involving public officers and employees in New York State set out as an e-book. For more information click on http://booklocker.com/books/5215.html
A Reasonable Disciplinary Penalty Under the Circumstances - The text of this publication focuses on determining an appropriate disciplinary penalty to be imposed on an employee in the public service in instances where the employee has been found guilty of misconduct or incompetence. Now available in two formats - as a large, paperback print edition, and as an e-book. For more information click on http://booklocker.com/books/7401.html
Disability Benefits for fire, police and other public sector personnel - an e-book focusing on retirement for disability under the NYS Employees' Retirement System, the NYS Teachers' Retirement System, General Municipal Law Sections 207-a/207-c and similar statutes providing benefits to employees injured both "on-the-job" and "off-the-job." For more information click on http://booklocker.com/books/3916.html
The Layoff, Preferred List and Reinstatement Manual -This e-book reviews the relevant laws, rules and regulations, and selected court and administrative decisions. For more information click on http://booklocker.com/books/5216.html
ADA Compliant Website?
School Districts, Municipalities and other Government Agencies
will be created by
to meet a School District’s, a Municipality's or other Government Agency's needs and satisfy the needs of its users as required by American with Disabilities Act.
Examples of sites created for School Districts are at
http://www.vt-s.net/client-examples-schools
Examples of sites created for Municipalities are at
http://www.vt-s.net/client-examples-municipalities
Are you an author looking for a publisher?
For information click on the URL below:
http://www.abuzzpress.com
New York Public Personnel Law Copyright© 1987 - 2017 by the Public Employment Law Press.
E-mail inquiries to publications@nycap.rr.com
N.B. From time to time a political ad or endorsement may appear in the sidebar of this LawBlog. NYPPL does not have any control over such posting.
N.B. “Cookies” provide a method for an Internet site to recognize a visitor and keep track of "visitor preferences." NYPPL does not use “cookies.” Google, its advertisers linked to this site by Google and others, however, may be using "cookies." A visitor's continuing to access NYPPL will be deemed to constitute the visitor's knowledge of, and the visitor's consent to, the use of "cookies" on NYPPL's LawBlog by Google, its advertisers and others.
WARNING: "Phishing" is the practice of using fraudulent emails and copies of legitimate websites to obtain user names, passwords, personal or organization information, etc. for the purposes of fraud and, or, identity theft. New York Public Personnel Law WILL NEVER ask a reader to provide a username and password (or any other personal or business information) via email.
A NEWSTEX Participant
Archive - toggle dart to activate or compress these listings
An employer may be required to provide an individu...
NYS Employees’ Retirement System benefits are base...
Guidelines for the promulgating of rules and regul...
Termination as "a final agency action” is effected...
The 2015 edition of the Discipline Book
Selected reports and information published by New ...
ERISA provisions do not apply to government retire...
Employee must exhaust available administrative rem...
Public employees cannot be required to surrender t...
Some issues to be mindful of when filing and prose...
Dismissed probationary employee has the burden of ...
Department of Civil Service Rule Making Activities...
Distinguishing between a covered employee and an i...
Employer has the burden of proving that the discip...
Administrative decision adversely affecting employ...
Anatomy of an unlawful discrimination complaint
Benefit available members of union pursuant to a "...
Challenging an unsatisfactory annual performance r...
Discourteousness, refusal to follow directives and...
Inappropriate sexual relationship with a minor
Disclosure of confidential information
Definition of full day worked for certain employee...
Termination a reasonable disciplinary penalty unde...
An administrative agency found to have acted in a ...
Termination for lack of the proper teaching certif...
The date on which an administrative agency's decis...
The five most read New York Public Personnel Law p...
OATH pre-hearing discovery procedures
Filing disciplinary charges against an individual ...
Pension Fund’s use of Social Security Administrati...
Employer’s questions on its electronic application...
The “law enforcement exemption” in POL §87(2) (e) ...
Regular monthly meeting of the State Civil Service...
An alleged past practice concerning compensation i...
Courts apply a “two-part” test to determine if a d...
Courts have the power and the duty to make certain...
Oral and physical abuse of students results in ter...
Taxing Fringe Benefits
Filing a notice of claim required by Education Law...
New York Governor Andrew M. Cuomo announces thirte...
Courts will strictly construe the terms of a disci...
Certification to teach in the position sought crit...
Civil Service Commission overturns agency’s disqua...
Discrimination against applicants having limited p...
Disciplinary hearing held in absentia
Grounds for vacating an arbitration award
Links with a New York State focus
Albany Government Law Review - Fireplace Blog
All about things of interest to NY Municipalities - NYMUNIBLOG
An Attorney's Blog - Worker’s Rights Defenders
Counties in New York State - web site addresses
Education Law Section 3020-a
Education Law Section 3020-a Comm. Regulations
Federal, State and local labor law attorney
Gotham schools newsroom - Focus on NYC school news
NYS BOCES Links
NYS Department of Civil Service
NYS Laws concerning public libraries
NYS Personnel Management Manual
NYS Register
New York Appellate Court Decisions by Mauro Lilling Naparty LLP
New York City ERS - by John Murphy
New York Labor and Employment - employee and union focus
New York Law Blog - Trolman, Glaser & Lichtman
New York State Municipalities - web sites
New York State Statutes from weblaws maintained by Robb Shecter
ReformNY - by NYU's Brennan Center for Justice
Resources - NYS Links created by WestLaw
St. Lawrence County Civil Service Web Site
Teacher Net - a "chat" site for teachers and administrators
The Civil Service Law - Department summary
The Taylor Law - A summary by John M. Crotty, Esq.
Town Law - by Joel H. Seachrist, Esq.
Links to selected organizations and associations
A collection of law blog sites maintained by USLaw.com
AELE Law Enforcement Legal Center resources
Assessment of Health Risks & Management Ctr.
Asso. of Towns of New York State
Civil Service Employees Asso.
DC-37 - AFSCME
Empire State Government News
Employment - Public sector consultants
Employment Law Podcasts by Prof. McCormick
Expert witness - JurisPro listings and witness profiles
FindLaw - Thomas Publicatiions
Google Scholar - A research tool [Beta version]
Gov. Cuomo's Home Page
Library of Congress - Official blog
NY Public Employer Labor Relations Asso.
NYC Civil Service Merit Council - News and Issues
NYS Asso. of Independent Schools
NYS Association of Business Officials
NYS Association of Chiefs of Police
NYS Association of Fire Chiefs
NYS Bar Association - Labor & Employment Resources
NYS Commission on Judical Conduct
NYS Commission on Local Government
NYS Commission on Public Integrity
NYS Conference of Mayors & Municipal Officers
NYS Correction Officers & PBA
NYS Dispute Resolution Association
NYS Employees' Retirement System
NYS Gov. Finance Officers Asso.
NYS Governors Office of Employee Relations
NYS Law Enforcement Officers Union - Council 82
NYS Personnel Council - resources
NYS Professional Firefighters Asso.
NYS Public Employer Labor Relations Association
NYS Sheriffs Association
NYS Supt. of School Build. & Grounds Asso.
NYS Troopers PBA
New York State School Boards Asso.
New York State United Teachers [NYSUT]
PERB - summaries of decisions
Retired Public Employees Association
School Administrators Asso. of NYS
State & Local Governments on the Internet
The Nelson A. Rockefeller Institute of Government,
United Federation of Teachers [UFT]
United University Professions [UUP]
Links to Other Useful Web Pages
A Taxonomy of Legal Blogs - links to law blogs
A blog focusing on recriting Attorneys and paraprofessionals
A blog focusing on women- in- law issues
A directory of blogs related to the law
A law-related laugh or two - Legal Antics by Nicole Black, Esq.
A placement service for Hispanic and bilingual professionals
Adjunct Law Professors -- linking the law professional and the law academic
Administrative Law Professor Blog
Administrative Law and the Public Sector
Alaska Employment Law
Albany Law School Clinic & Justice Center
All about Wages and Hours - by Doug Hass, Esq.
Alternate Dispute Resolution - world directory of ADR blogs by Diane J. Levin, Esq.
Alternate Dispute Resolution and Mediation resource site
American Law Library
An Employer's Attorney's observations by Michael Fox
Arbitration Law Memos
Assessment of Health Risks and Management Ctr.
Attorney Network - LawLink
Attorneys practicing in the United Kingdom
Background Checks and Drug Screening Services
Blogs devoted to employment and labor law
CCH - Employment Law Blog
California Workers' Compensation calculator - developed by Jay Shergill, Esq.
Civil Rights Decisions - Second Circuit
Compensation - Police Pay Journal
Congress - tracking legislation and related activities
Connecticut Employment Law by Daniel Schwartz. Esq.
Continuing Legal Education Courses - programs available
Cornell U - ILR - Institute for Workplace Studies Daily
Cornell U. ILR - Institute for Workplace Studies Weekly
Current Issues - Professor Dorf, Cornell U.
Current employment law issues - Shaw-Valenzas Law Blog
Decisions of the Commissioner - searchable database
Decisions of the Commissioner of Education - July '91 - present
Directory of Lawyers and Legal Services
Disability, Health and Leave Management Blog
Diversity At Work - placement service
Education News – a global resource
Education and School Law Blog
Electronic Discovery Rules
Employment Benefits - McNees Wallace & Nurick LLC
Employment Issues and Research - Cornell University
Employment Law Blog - George Lenard
Employment Law Blog - Podcasts by Prof. McCormick
Employment Law Information [National]
Employment and Labor Law by Michael P. Maslanka, Esq.
Employment and benefits legal update
Employment law for attorneys, employees and the public
Experienced Employment and Wrongful Termination Lawyer [California]
Fair Labor Standards Act Blog by Womble Carlyle Sandridge & Rice, PLLC
Family Medical Leave Act Updates
Family Medical Leave Act [FMLA] web site
Fastcase - a legal research blog
Federal Government - a Washington Post Blog
Federal Register and related documents available via the Internet
Federal and State practice by Jeremy Colby, Esq.
Firefighter and Police related personnel matters - Wayne W. Schmidt, Esq.
Freedom of Information [FOIL] - New York State
General information concerning disciplining employees
Great Big List of Legal Websites
Human Resource database on line
Human Resources Internet Guide
Human Rights Law Review - Oxford University
Immigration Law web site
International Law - posted by Georgetown University
JURIST - for legal research and news from U. of Pitt. Law School
Job opportunities - a universal search engine
Justia -- A directory of "Law Blogs"
Labor Law Blog - General
Labor Law Blog - New York
Labor and employment database sources
Land use and zoning [posted by Prof. Patricia E. Salkin]
Law Blog Central - a resource site
Law Blog Directory - maintained by USLaw.com
Law Help - designed for the "law-consumer"
Law issues and case from around the nation.
Law libraries and other resources
Law news and legal research
Lawyers - Directory
Legal Alerts from Harris Beach, a law firm
Legal Times - a blog on law and lobbying
Legal Workshop -- Law review articles
Legal research, law firms, law related resources
Legislation - State databases - all states
Lemon Law - a law blog for consumers
Links to Law Blogs available on the internet
Links to various summaries of employment law news reports and decisions
List of government-related law blogs by Justia
Local Government Watch - New York
Long-term Disability Law Blog - Scott M. Riemer, Esq.
Manpower Employment Law Blog
Mediation - an Online Guide and resources
Middle East Law Blog - by Bobbie S. Neal, Esq.
NYCRR - [unofficial]
NYPPL's Archives - selected personnel court decisions
NYS Bar Assoc. - Labor & Employment Resources
NYS Directory of Local Governents
NYS Disabled Workers Blog
NYS Open Government resources and sites
New Jersey Public Safety - by Law Offices of Arpaia & Crivelli
New York City Criminal Court Library
New York Civil Law Forum
New York Employment Law Attorneys - Blog
New York Freedom of Information Law Advisory Opinions
New York Law Journal - News highlights concerning New York Cases
New York Legal Update by Thomas Swartz, Esq.
New York State - Political Observations from Albany
New York State Civil Service Law "BLOG" by Kevin Sheerin
New York State Ethics Commission Opinions
New York State Legal Resources - FindLaw
New York State Politics [Room 8]
New York State Register
New York State Search Home Page
New York State Statutes
New York State's Telephone Directory
Opinions of the State Comptroller
Oregon statutes - a lawblog maintained by Robb Shecter
Other States - California by the Peters Law Group
Other States - New Jersey by Frank Steinberg
Other States: Colorado by Peter Mullison
PERB - Rules of Procedure
Personnel court decisions - Law enforcement data base
Philippines Law - by Manuel Laserna Jr., Esq.
Police and Firefighter related personnel matters - Wayne W. Schmidt Esq.
Public Library of Law - "World's largest free law library"
Public Sector Law Site
Recruitment - Dubai and other Gulf nations
Research - various resources
Research Sites posted by The Law Library Association of Greater New York
Resources - Labor and Employment Law
School Law - Education Week school llaw blog
School Law Alerts from Harris Beach PLLC
School Law Blogs via Scott McLeod
School and Education Law
Second Opinions - selected opinions from the Second Circuit
Sexual harassment, discrimination and other employment litigation matters
Small Business Law Resource
Solicitors London - for those seeking an attorney in the United Kingdom
State Government Watch - New York
Sui Generis - General NY Law reporting
The Chief - Civil Service Leader On Line Edition]
The Teacher's Lawyer's blog
Trans-gender legal issues
US Supreme Court Updates
United States Code [from Cornell University]
Washington State - Employment Law
Whistle blower law blog
Women Lawyers' blog
Women's Rights Law
Workplace Lawyer - employment law issues
Workplace Separation, Discharge and Termination Law
Zoning and Muncipal Law
Catalog of Law-related Blogs - click logo below