Patent Publication Number: US-4840740-A

Title: Grease for homokinetic joint

Description:
This application is a continuation of application Ser. No. 003,172 filed Jan. 14, 1987 abandoned. 
    
    
     This invention relates to greases for a homokinetic joint, particularly for a plunging type homokinetic joint. 
     Among plunging type homokinetic joints, a double offset type homokinetic joint and a tripod type homokinetic joint are known. 
     As shown in FIG. 1, the double offset type homokinetic joint has an outer race 1 formed with six axial track grooves 3 in its inner surface, an inner race 2 formed with six axial track grooves 4 in its outer surface, these grooves being spaced at equal angular intervals, balls 5 disposed between the inner race 1 and the outer race 2, and a cage 6 retaining the balls 5. The cage 6 has an outer spherical surface 7 and an inner spherical surface 8 adapted to fit the outer periphery of the inner race 2. The centers (a) and (b) of the spherical surfaces 7 and 8 are on the axis of the outer race 1 and are apart from each other in an axial direction. 
     As shown in FIG. 2, the tripod type homokinetic joint is provided with an outer race 11 formed with three axial cylindrical track grooves 12 in its inner surface at equal angular intervals. A tripod member 13 provided with three trunnions 14 is mounted in the outer race 11. A spherical roller 15 is mounted on each trunnion 14 with needles 16 fitted between the spherical roller 15 and the trunnion 14 to support the spherical roller 15 rotatably and axially slidably. The spherical rollers 15 are received in the track grooves 12. 
     On the double offset type joint, the revolution torque is transmitted by engagement between the balls 5 and the outer race 1 and between the balls 5 and the inner race 2. On the tripod type joint, the torque is transmitted by engagement between the spherical rollers 15 and the outer race 11. The balls 5 and the spherical rollers 15 roll along the track grooves 3 and 12, respectively, for smooth plunging. 
     When the revolution torque is transmitted with the joint forming a working angle, rolling and sliding occur between the balls 5 and the outer race 1 and between the balls 5 and the inner race 2, and sliding occurs between the cage 6 and the outer race 1 and between the cage 6 and the inner race 2 on the double offset type homokinetic joint. On the other hand, rolling and sliding occur between the outer race 11 and the spherical rollers 15 on the tripod type homokinetic joint. 
     Thus, on the plunging type homokinetic joint, the element of sliding is more dominant than the element of rolling. When the revolution torque is transmitted with the joint forming a working angle, the frictional resistance produced at the sliding portions produces an axial force. 
     On the double offset type homokinetic joint, since the track grooves 3 are formed in the inner surface of the outer race 1 at an equal interval of 60 degrees, axial forces are produced six times per revolution as shown in FIG. 3. On the tripod type homokinetic joint, since the track grooves 12 are formed at an equal interval of 120 degrees, axial forces are produced three times per revolution as shown in FIG. 4. 
     If the cycle of generation of the axial force coincides with the natural frequencies of the engine, body, suspension, etc., resonance will be induced in the vehicle body, giving passengers discomfort. Therefore, it is desirable to reduce the axial forces as low as possible. 
     It is customary to fill the inside of the plunging type homokinetic joint with a lubricant to decrease the frictional resistance and improve the slidability. A grease containing molybdenum disulfide as a solid lubricant has been used for this purpose. But, with a vehicle equipped with a tripod type homokinetic joint filled with the grease, rolling occurs during acceleration, whereas with a vehicle equipped with a double offset type homokinetic joint filled with the grease, beating noise or muffled noise produce and the vehicle body is apt to vibrate while running at a high speed. 
     On the plunging type homokinetic joint, the axial force is produced, causing the vehicle body to vibrate as described above. It is thought that in spite of the fact that the sliding portions of the joint are supplied with a grease, there still develops a substantial frictional resistance at the sliding portions, and that if the frequency of the axial force generated in the joint coincides with the vibration of the engine, the vehicle body will vibrate. It is also thought that the joint functions as a medium of transmitting vibrations which have generated in the engine. This phenomenon is often observed during idling on an automatic transmission vehicle. 
     An object of the present invention is to provide a grease which has a low coefficient of friction enough to keep the vehicle body from rolling or producing beating noise or muffled noise while the vehicle is accelerating or running at a high speed. 
     From one aspect of the present invention, there is provided a grease for a homokinetic joint comprising a base oil, a thickening agent and an organic molybdenum compound. From another aspect of the present invention, there is provided a grease for a homokinetic joint comprising a base oil, a thickening agent, an organic molybdenum compound and an organic zinc compound. 
     The grease for a homokinetic joint according to the present invention is a grease which has a smaller friction coefficient than a conventional grease containing molybdenum dithiocarbamate. The use of the grease as a lubricant for a homokinetic joint decreases the axial force and absorbs vibrations generated in the engine, and prevents the vehicle body from vibrating. Furthermore, this grease is less expensive because it has only to contain such an organic molybdenum compound as molybdenum dithiophosphate and such an organic zinc compound as zinc dithiophosphate without the need of using various kinds of costly organic metallic extreme-pressure additives used in a conventional grease. 
    
    
     Other objects and features of the present invention will become apparent from the following description taken with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which: 
     FIG. 1 is a partially cutaway view in section of a double offset type homokinetic joint; 
     FIG. 2 is a partially cutaway view in section of a tripod type homokinetic joint; 
     FIGS. 3 and 4 are graphs showing the relation between the axial force and the revolving angle of the joint in FIGS. 1 and 2, respectively; 
     FIG. 5 is a graph showing the relation between the induced thrust and the angle on a double offset type homokinetic joint in which Specimen A is used as a lubricant; 
     FIG. 6 is a similar graph showing the relation between the induced thrust and the angle on a homokinetic joint filled with a commercially available grease; 
     FIG. 7 is graphs showing the relation between the slide resistance and the angle on a homokinetic joint in which Specimen A is used as a lubricant; 
     FIG. 8 is graphs showing the relation between the slide resistance and the angle on a homokinetic joint in which a commercially available grease is used; 
     FIG. 9 is a graph showing the variation of friction coefficient with time for Specimens A and A&#39; and commercially available greases; 
     FIG. 10 is a schematic view of a Sawin type wear tester; and 
     FIG. 11 is a graph showing the relation between the friction coefficient and the load for Specimen A and commercially available greases. 
    
    
     The base oil according to the present invention may be a mineral oil or a synthetic hydrocarbon oil having a viscosity of lubricant. As a thickening agent, urea compounds (such as monourea, diurea and polyurea) which have a higher heat resistance than such metallic soap as lithium soap are preferable. This is because a homokinetic joint is usually arranged under relatively high-temperature atmosphere near the engine and the joint itself tends to heat up and get hot while transmitting a revolution torque. 
     It is preferable to add a lead soap such as lead naphthenate, zinc diaryl dithiophosphate or zinc dialkyl dithiophosphate to the grease to increase an anti-oxidant effect as well as an extreme-pressure effect. 
     Organic molybdenum compounds used in the present invention may be molybdenum dialkyl dithiocarbamate, molybdenum dialkyl dithiophosphate or molybdenum diaryl dithiophosphate, i.e., compounds of the following structural formula: ##STR1## wherein R represents a primary or secondary alkyl group or aryl group. 
     The organic molybdenum compound may be a single compound or a mixture of two or more compounds. 
     The content of the organic molybdenum compound should be 10 percent by weight or less, preferably 3-5 percent by weight or less. The excessive amount will have only the same effect or lessen the effect. 
     The organic zinc compound used in the present invention may be zinc dialkyl dithiophosphate or zinc diaryl dithiophosphate of the following structural formula: ##STR2## wherein R&#39; represents a primary or secondary alkyl group or aryl group. 
     The organic zinc compound may be a single compound or a mixture of two or more compounds. 
     Such organic zinc compounds as well as such organic molybdenum compounds are extremely effective extreme-pressure additives. The content should be 15 percent by weight or less, preferably 5-6 percent by weight or less. Any excessive amount brings about only the same effect or lessens the effect. If an organic molybdenum compound coexists with an organic zinc compound, they will produce an excellent effect even if the contents are less. In this case, the content of each compound should be 0.5-5.0 percent by weight. 
     An antioxidant or a detergent-dispersant may be added in addition to the extreme-pressure additive. 
     Organic molybdenum compounds are fundamentally different from such conventional solid lubricants as molybdenum disulfide. It does not exhibit a lubricating effect so much before being decomposed. It transforms itself into such a lubricating material as molybdenum disulfide only after it is decomposed by the frictional heat generated on the sliding face. Molybdenum dialkyl dithiocarbamate (hereinafter abbreviated to Mo-DTC) and molybdenum diaryl dithiophosphate (hereinafter abbreviated to Mo-DTP) were selected from among organic molybdenum compounds and their heat-decomposition temperatures were measured by the differential thermal analysis. The analysis shows that the heat-decomposition temperature of Mo-DTC is 252°-312° C. whereas that of Mo-DTP is 145°-225° C. The heat-decomposition starting temperature for the latter is lower by approximately 100° C. than that for the former. This indicates that Mo-DTP is transformed into a lubricating material on the sliding surface earlier than Mo-DTC, and acts as a good extreme-pressure additive. Thus, molybdenum dithiophosphate can be said to be a far better organic molybdenum compound than molybdenum dithiocarbamate. 
     But, a significant decrease in friction coefficient cannot be expected by the addition of a kind of such compound. When zinc dialkyl dithiophosphate or zinc diaryl dithiophosphate (hereinafter abbreviated to Zn-DTP) is further added, the friction coefficient substantially decreases. 
     The results of these experiments are shown in Table 1. This shows that a urea compound is preferable to a metallic soap such as lithium soap as a thickening agent. It is presumed that a synergetic effect is produced when Mo-DTP and Zn-DTP are used in combination because Zn-DTP acts as a catalyst for heat-decomposition of Mo-DTP. 
     
                       TABLE 1                                                     
______________________________________                                    
Experi-                     Friction                                      
ment No.  Composition of Grease                                           
                            coefficient                                   
______________________________________                                    
1         Mineral oil + Polyurea                                          
                            0.103˜0.104                             
2         Mineral oil + Polyurea +                                        
                            0.098˜0.100                             
          Mo--DTP                                                         
3         Mineral oil + Polyurea +                                        
                            0.037˜0.040                             
          Mo--DTP + Zn--DTP                                               
4         Mineral oil + Lithium soap +                                    
                            0.081˜0.091                             
          Mo--DTP + Zn--DTP                                               
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     EXAMPLE 1 
     On the plunging type homokinetic joint shown in FIGS. 1 and 2, the axial force produced on the shaft when the joint transmits a revolution torque forming a working angle is thought to be an induced thrust, and the vibration occurring on an automatic transmission vehicle during idling is thought to be caused by the slide resistance of the joint. 
     The induced thrust is defined to be an axial force produced when a revolution torque is applied with a working angle formed without allowing the driving shaft and the driven shaft to slide axially. The slide resistance is defined to be a resistance generated when one of the driving and driven shafts is excited axially with the other fixed. 
     Two specimens (hereinafter referred to as Specimen A and Specimen A&#39;) according to the present invention and three more specimens I, II and III (greases commercially available and generally used) were put separately in the double offset type homokinetic joints shown in FIG. 1 and the induced thrust was measured for these specimens. The properties of the specimens are shown in Table 2. The results of measurements after 5 minutes from the start of operation are shown in FIGS. 5 and 6. The slide resistance was measured at the same time. The results of measurements are shown in FIGS. 7 and 8. 
     FIGS. 5 and 7 show the results of measurements for Specimen A. The results of measurements for Specimen A&#39; are omitted because the results are virtually the same as for Specimen A. FIGS. 6 and 8 show the results of measurements for Specimen II. The results of measurements for Specimens I and III are omitted because they are almost the same as for Specimen II. 
     Referring to FIGS. 7 and 8, (a) indicates the slide resistance measured soon after the excitation, (b) does the one measured 5 minutes after the excitation, and (c) does the one when the homokinetic joint was rotating at 500 rpm. The slide resistance is indicated in terms of the sum (peak-to-peak value) of the maximum value and the minimum value. 
     As will be seen from the results of measurements shown in FIGS. 5 through 8, the induced thrust and the slide resistance are smaller for the joint lubricated with Specimen A than the one lubricated with Specimen II. 
     CHECK EXPERIMENT 1 
     The friction coefficient of each grease specimen shown in Table 2 was measured using a Sawin type wear tester. The results are shown in FIG. 9. In the Sawin type wear tester, a 1/4&#34; steel ball 21 is arranged in contact with a rotary ring 20 (40 mm dia×4 mm), as shown in FIG. 10. The surface roughness of the ring 20 in the width direction is 1.6-1.9 S and the one in the axial direction is 0.4-0.6 S. In measuring the friction coefficient of the grease specimens, the rotary ring 20 was revolved at a peripheral speed of 108 meter per minute under a load of 1 kgf. Each grease was supplied to the surface of the rotary ring 20 from its lower end through a sponge 22 and the movement of an air slide 23 supporting the steel ball 21 was sensed by a load cell 24. 
     As is apparent from the results shown in FIG. 9, the friction coefficients of Specimen A and Specimen A&#39; are smaller than those of commercially available greases I, II and III, and particularly Specimen A&#39; containing molybdenum dialkyl dithiocarbamate and molybdenum dialkyl dithiophosphate has an extremely small friction coefficient. After the measurements, the surface of the steel ball was observed under a microscope. This revealed that the size of the wear scars formed corresponds to the friction coefficient of the grease used. Namely, the smaller the friction coefficient of grease, the smaller the size of the wear scars formed was. 
     CHECK EXPERIMENT 2 
     The Sawin type wear tester was used to measure the friction coefficients with the change in load (or surface pressure) for Specimen A, commercially available greases II and III. The results are shown in FIG. 11. 
     As seen from FIG. 11, the influence of the load on the friction coefficient differs among the specimens tested. For the commercially available greases II and III, the friction coefficient tends to gradually decrease with the increase in the load, whereas for Specimen A there is the minimum point. It is thought to be due to the difference in additives that Specimen A has a different tendency from the other specimens. It is thought that the organic molybdenum compound mixed in Specimen A is decomposed by heat at the sliding surface and the products by the decomposition adhere to the sliding surface, displaying their effects. 
     It is thought that Specimen A displays excellent frictional properties shown in Example 1 because the working conditions on a homokinetic joint produce conditions suitable for the organic molybdenum to readily decompose. 
     CHECK EXPERIMENT 3 
     Specimen A and commercially available grease II shown in Table 2 were put in homokinetic joints shown in FIG. 1, which underwent a continuous operation for 125 hours under the conditions of a revolution torque T=23.5 kg.f-m, a number of revolutions N=1750 rpm, working angle θ=11.6° and cooling air rate of about 30 km/h to observe how the track groove surface peels. The results are shown in Table 3, from which it is apparent that peeling barely happened on the homokinetic joint on which Specimen A was used as a lubricant. 
     CHECK EXPERIMENT 4 
     The Sawin type wear tester shown in FIG. 10 was used to measure the friction coefficient for each specimen. The results are shown in Table 3. Measurement conditions were: peripheral speed: 108 meter/min. load: 1 kgf. 
     As is apparent from Table 4, the inclusion of organic molybdenum lowered the friction coefficient, and the addition of zinc diaryl dithiophostate or zinc dialkyl dithiophostate further lowered the friction coefficient. 
     EXAMPLE 2 
     In order to confirm the results of Example 1, the following greases according to the present invention were prepared by use of organic molybdenum compounds and organic zinc compounds. For any grease herein prepared, a mineral oil containing a polyurea thickening agent was used. 
     (1) grease containing 3% of molybdenum diaryl dithiophosphate [made by ASAHI DENKA KOGYO K.K.: SAKURA-LUBE 300] and 2% of zinc dialkyl (primary) dithiophosphate [made by NIPPON LUBRIZOL INDUSTRIES CORP.: LUBRIZOL 1097] 
     (2) grease containing 3% of molybdenum diaryl dithiophosphate [made by VANDERBILT EXPORT CORPORATION: MOLYVAN L] and 1.2% of zinc dialkyl (secondary) dithiophosphate [made by NIPPON LUBRIZOL INDUSTRIES CORP.: LUBRIZOL 1095] 
     (3) grease containing 3% of molybdenum diaryl dithiophosphate [MOLYVAN L] and 1% of zinc diaryl dithiophosphate [made by NIPPON LUBRIZOL INDUSTRIES CORP.: LUBRIZOL [1370] 
     The friction coefficients of three kinds of greases prepared were measured by use of the Sawin type wear tester. The results obtained are listed in Table 5. For comparison with the greases according to the present invention, the following three kinds of greases (a)-(c) were prepared as controls and the friction coefficients were measured in the same manner as above. The results are also listed in Table 5. The base oil used for (a) is the same mineral oil containing a polyurea thickening agent as used for the greases (1)-(3). For (b), a mineral oil containing a thickening agent in lithium soap series instead of a polyurea thickening agent. 
     (a) grease containing 3% of molybdenum diaryl dithiophosphate [made by ASAHI DENKA KOGYO K.K.: SAKURA LUBE 300] only and not containing any organic zinc compounds. 
     (b) grease containing 3% of the same molybdenum diaryl dithiophosphate as used for (a) [SAKURA LUBE 300], and 3% of zinc dialkyl (secondary) dithiophophate [LUBRIZOL 1097] 
     (c) grease containing molybdenum dialkyl dithiocarbamate. 
     As seen from Table 5, the coexistence of an organic molybdenum compound and an organic zinc compound is preferable, and as a thickening agent, an urea compound is much more preferable than lithium soap. 
     
                                           TABLE 2                                 
__________________________________________________________________________
              Specimen                                                    
                                  Commercially available grease           
Ingredient    Specimen A                                                  
                       Specimen A&#39;                                        
                                  I       II       III                    
__________________________________________________________________________
Thickening agent                                                          
              Polyurea Polyurea   Lithium soap                            
                                          Lithium soap                    
                                                   Lithium soap           
Additive                                                                  
     Molybdenum                                                           
              Molybdenum                                                  
                       Molybdenum dialkyl                                 
                                  Molybdenum                              
                                          Molybdenum                      
                                                   None                   
     compound dialkyl dithio-                                             
                       dithiocarbamate 3%                                 
                                  disulfide 1.5%                          
                                          disulfide 1.5%                  
              carbamate 3%                                                
                       Molybdenum dialkyl                                 
                       dithiophosphate 3%                                 
     Extreme-pres-                                                        
              Pb series                                                   
                       Pb series  S-P series                              
                                          S-P series                      
                                                   S-P series             
     sure agent                                                           
              Zn series                                                   
                       Zn series  P series                                
                                          P series                        
Base oil      Mixture of                                                  
                       Mixture of Paraffin                                
                                  Paraffin series                         
                                          Mixture of                      
                                                   Naphthene              
              Paraffin and                                                
                       and Naphthene series                               
                                          Paraffin and                    
                                                   series                 
              Naphthene series            Naphthene series                
Viscosity of                                                              
Base oil (cst)                                                            
40° C. 212.9    212.9      173.0   228      --                     
100° C.                                                            
              15.6     15.6       14.90   15.7     14.5                   
VI            66       66         81.0    89       85                     
Consistency   283      292        283     270      279                    
25° C. 60 W                                                        
Work stability                                                            
              326      --         341     290      334                    
(10.sup.5 W)                                                              
On a Shell    126      --         100     100      126                    
4-ball machine                                                            
limit load in kg                                                          
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     
                                           TABLE 3                                 
__________________________________________________________________________
        Surface temperature of outer race of                              
                            Condition of the                              
        double offset type homokinetic joint (°C.)                 
                            joint after test                              
 Specimen                                                                 
         ##STR3##            raceOuter                                    
                                 raceInner                                
                                     Ball                                 
__________________________________________________________________________
Commercially available grease II                                          
         ##STR4##            6/6 F 6/6 F 4/6 F                            
                                 6/6 F 5/6 F 5/6 F                        
                                     5/6 F 5/6 F 4/6 F                    
Specimen of this invention                                                
         ##STR5##            o o o 3/6 F                                  
                                 o o o o                                  
                                     o o o o                              
__________________________________________________________________________
 Temperature:                                                             
   Max. value at initial stage                                            
 ##STR6##                                                                 
 ##STR7##                                                                 
 Joint condition:                                                         
 4/6 F . . . Peeling observed on 4 tracks out of 6 tracks                 
 o . . . No peeling observed.                                             
 
    
     
                                           TABLE 4                                 
__________________________________________________________________________
          Thickening              Friction                                
Specimen                                                                  
     Base oil                                                             
          agent Extreme pressure agent                                    
                                  coefficient                             
__________________________________________________________________________
No. 1                                                                     
     Mineral                                                              
          Polyurea                                                        
                None              0.14                                    
No. 2                                                                     
     oil        Molybdenum dialkyl dithiophosphate                        
                                  0.08˜0.009                        
No. 3           Molybdenum dialkyl dithiophosphate                        
                                  0.08                                    
                Zinc diaryl dithiophosphate                               
No. 4           Molybdenum dialkyl dithiophosphate                        
                                  0.05                                    
                Zinc dialkyl dithiophosphate                              
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     
                       TABLE 5                                                     
______________________________________                                    
          Friction coefficient                                            
______________________________________                                    
 Grease                                                                   
No.                                                                       
(1)         0.037˜0.040                                             
(2)         0.041˜0.047                                             
(3)         0.037˜0.038                                             
Controls                                                                  
(a)         0.098˜0.100                                             
(b)         0.081˜0.091                                             
(c)         0.055˜0.085                                             
______________________________________