Patent Publication Number: US-5427892-A

Title: Optical recording media containing overcoat

Description:
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION 
     This is a divisional of application Ser. No. 07/906,905 filed Jun. 30, 1992, now U.S. Pat. No. 5,328,813. 
    
    
     BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 
     The present invention relates generally to materials for optical storage of coded information and methods of fabricating such materials, and more particularly to performance enhancing and physically protecting overcoats for thin metal film materials which are designed specifically for optical information storage. 
     BACKGROUND INFORMATION 
     Optical data storage is quickly becoming a viable and often preferred option to magnetic storage. The promise of high data densities and archival stability has initiated the development of thin film optical media which can be substituted into applications for which magnetic technology is inadequate. Three of the media formats which are currently being developed for optical write-once applications include: discs for use with personal computers, cards for consumer information transfer (U.S. Pat. No. 4,567,585  and tape for archival mass data storage (U.S. Pat. No. 4,567,585). 
     Functionally, the basic performance criteria associated with these different media formats are very similar, the most important of which are data input sensitivity and archival stability. Information is stored in the write once systems as micron-sized optical &#34;spots.&#34; These spots are typically created in a thin absorbing layer above a reflective metal layer or directly ablated from the metal layer within the medium using a focused laser beam as the writing source (pulsed, high power). It is a desirable property for an information storage medium to give clearly defined spots. The data are &#34;read&#34; by scanning a laser (CW, low power) over the written spots and monitoring the intensity of the reflected laser light. When the spots are clearly defined, the signal-to-noise ratio is improved. 
     Information can be placed on these optical memories in extremely high densities, the theoretical limit being determined by the absolute resolving power of a laser beam focused down to its diffraction-limited size (λ/2 NA, wherein λ is the wavelength of the laser and NA is the numerical aperture of the focusing beam optics). Presently, most read/write lasers being employed operate within a wavelength range of about 750 to about 830 nm. However, in order to increase memory density, shorter and shorter wavelength read/write lasers (down to 300 nm wavelength and less) are being tested throughout the industry. 
     The information stored in these write-once media is, in principle, capable of being optically accessed an infinite number of times, and then subsequently, electronically decoded, and presented in a format which is meaningful to the user. 
     Mechanically, there are differences among the tape, disc and card formats which make it difficult for one thin film system to work as a universal write-once active layer. For example, discs which are based on alloys of tellurium, selenium and/or their oxides have been developed as ablative write-once media using conventional sputtering technology. These discs are typically put together in a rigid, air-sandwiched construction to enhance environmental stability while maintaining compatibility with the ablative writing mechanism wherein the writing laser beam directly melts away the metal layer on contact. 
     Tape, on the other hand, is a nonrigid medium and must be flexible enough to accommodate motion around the small hubs and rollers associated with tape handling. Additionally, because tape is in constant frictional contact with itself and the roller mechanisms, optical tape must be abrasion resistant. This protection is best afforded by some type of thin film hard overcoat. However, most write-once media that have a hard overcoat in direct contact with the active layer are less sensitive to laser writing. 
     Cards, which traditionally have been considered low-end media, require many of the criteria associated with both tape and disc formats. Like discs, cards are rigid. When they are in the optical drive the media do not experience any of the same frictional or bending forces associated with tape media. Outside the drive, the media must be able to withstand the forces associated with external handling and storage Surface abrasion and bending are commonplace for media used in credit card applications. Often, though, cards are constructed by laminating optical thin film (tape) to rigid substrates. 
     There are other differences and similarities which exist between the three media formats, but due to the variety of potential thin film layers being developed as write-once media and the large number of diverse drive designs, many of the precise requirements for these three types of media are still in the process of being standardized. For example, media performance issues such as write sensitivity, carrier-to-noise ratio (CNR), data bit size, and reflectivity level will be dependent on the end-use for the specific system. No one thin film system has been able to meet all the criteria which are required to make the media compatible with the various media drives. 
     All of these optical media are similar in that they contain a thin film of an laser sensitive reflective material from which reflectance is measured. As noted above, tellurium and selenium alloys are among materials that have been used heretofore. This metal layer can be deposited by sputtering, vacuum evaporation, chemical plating or the like. In some cases, this metal layer (film) is overcoated with one or more semitransparent or transparent polymer layers. 
     In addition to the alloys of tellurium, selenium and/or their oxides, in 1991, U.S. Pat. No. 4,998,239 described the use of a soft metal alloy as reflective metal layer for information storage. This soft metal alloy is particularly well suited for manufacturing in sheet form and offers a very high degree of surface uniformity and reflectivity. The soft metal alloy is flexible and can be laid down on any of the three formats: tapes, cards or discs. 
     There are many performance criteria which a thin film system must meet in order to be used in optical storage applications. One requirement of all optical memory media is that the data must remain environmentally stable for a long period of time. This is especially true for those media which are being targeted for archival storage applications. For example, the optical tape standard set by CREO Inc., Vancouver, Canada, is for a 20-year media life in an office environment (20° C./50% RH). Premature aging of many thin film media has been shown to occur by several different mechanisms: 1) the active layer can degrade (oxidation, phase segregation) to make the media less sensitive to laser writing and/or increase the bit-error rate; 2) the written data spots can change with time (edge deformation, phase reversal), thus reducing the playback signals; and/or 3) the media can mechanically degrade due to wear and abrasion during media handling. Each of these forms of degradation have also been found to occur to some degree with the soft metal alloy media described above. 
     One form of environmental degradation which is observed in optical media is the loss of reflectivity as a function of time, temperature, and humidity. This type of degradation has been attributed to processes such as film evaporation, moisture condensation, alloy dissolution, or metal oxidation. Samples of the media have been observed to become very irregular in appearance after being stored for extended periods of time (i.e., the surface shows reflective and non-reflective areas). This degradation is accelerated by elevated temperatures and humidities. 
     Other degradation is due to abrasion and wear. In tape applications, the soft metal alloy system described above adheres very well to polymer substrates but can be easily damaged by physical contact with harder materials. 
     Any solution to these environmental problems must not destroy the property of the medium to meet the following requirements. 1) resistance to wear which occurs from winding of the film upon itself; 2) flexibility; 3) laser writing sensitivity; and 4) a reflectivity of not less than about 40-45% at the wavelength of laser writing and reading, e.g. 830 nm. 
     SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
     It has now been discovered that reflective metal layers and partially oxidized metal layers for optical memory applications can be given an overcoat which is hard and which actually enhances the optical properties required for optical memory applications. These overcoats are vacuum-deposited (preferably sputtered), transparent or semi-transparent, hard inorganic metal oxides, nitrides, carbides, hydrides, carbohydrides or mixtures thereof. Two or more overcoats can be employed. The thickness of the overcoats ranges from about 50 to about 10,000 Å to achieve a reflectivity for the combination of the underlying metal layer and the overcoat of from about 40% to about 80% at the wavelength of laser writing and reading (about 300 to 850 nm) and currently preferably about 750 and about 850 nm. 
     In one embodiment, this invention provides an improved optical memory medium. This medium includes a solid substrate, a highly reflective (i.e., 40% or greater at the laser write/read wavelength, especially 750-850 nm), metal (or partially oxidized metal) sputter deposited layer adhered to at least one surface of the substrate and a vacuum deposited (preferably sputtered) overcoat layer. The overcoat is one or more hard transparent or semi-transparent metal oxides, nitrides, carbides, hydrides, carbohydrides, or mixtures thereof such as oxynitrides. This overcoat layer alters the reflectivity as a function of its thickness and refractive index and the thickness and refractive index of the underlying soft metal layer. 
     In another embodiment, a process for producing improved optical data storage media is provided. This process involves depositing a thin layer of highly reflective soft metal or partial metal oxide on a substrate, particularly by sputtering, to achieve a reflectance of at least 40% at the laser write/read wavelength of about 300 to about 850 nm. Thereafter, and especially directly thereafter, one or more hard transparent overcoats are sputter-deposited over the reflective metal or partial metal oxide, particularly by reactively sputtering a suitable metal or metal compound in a reactive gas including oxygen, nitrogen, hydrogen, and/or a mixture thereof. The sputtering of this second layer is conducted to yield a thickness of about 50 to about 10,000 Å and an overall reflectivity for the metal plus overcoat combination of from about 40 to about 80% at the laser write/read wavelength of about 300 to about 850 nm. 
    
    
     BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS 
     This invention will be further described with reference being made to the accompanying drawings, in which 
     FIG. 1 is a schematic cross-section of a magnetron sputtering machine capable of producing the products of this invention. 
     FIG. 2 is a cut-away perspective view of a sputtering cathode mini-chamber useful in a sputtering machine as depicted in FIG. 1. 
    
    
     DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS 
     The present optical recording media comprises a substrate having a thin film of laser sensitive, reflective soft metal or partially oxidized metal adhered to one or both sides, and a sputter-deposited transparent or semitransparent metal oxide, nitride, carbide, hydride or carbohydride overcoat on top of the soft metal layer(s). 
     The substrates can be selected from solid materials such as rigid or reinforced plastic or glass or can be a flexible material such as a plastic. These substrates can be used per se, or they can include a surfacing coat known as a &#34;subbing layer&#34;. 
     Typical substrates can range from rigid glass, epoxy and polycarbonate sheets to flexible polyester and polyimide films. Any of the substrate materials proposed for use in optical media heretofore known can be employed. 
     Examples of representative plastic materials include polyester films, especially polyethylene terephthalate (PET), polycarbonate, polyacrylate, polymethylmethacrylate, polystyrene, polyurethane, polyvinylchloride, polyimide and the like. Polyester, and especially polyethylene terephthalate, and polycarbonate are preferred plastics. 
     Examples of representative optional subbing layers include UV-cured acrylics and siloxanes; fluorocarbons, SiO 2 , and the like. UV-cured acrylics are preferred because they do not decrease the performance of the media and improve the adhesion of metal to the substrate. 
     The substrates can be in a form suitable for forming discs, cards or tapes in film or sheet form ranging in thickness from about 0.25 mil to about 60 mil. 
     The metal layer is laser sensitive, i.e., when contacted with a laser the reflectivity of the layer is increased or decreased so as to contrast with the rest of the metal surface. That is, it is a metal layer which can be for example melted, or evaporated by a typical writing laser to yield readable (low reflective) spots on a highly reflective field. It is a layer having a reflectance of at least about 40% and preferably about 50 to about 75% at the laser write/read wavelength. The metal layer can be (and preferably is) partially oxidized as set forth in coincidentally filed U.S. patent application Ser. No. 07/906,906, now U.S. Pat. No. 5,302,493, which is incorporated by reference. When the term &#34;metal&#34; is used in this context, it shall include the partial oxides, as well. Metals which can be used include those reflective metals disclosed heretofore to be useful in optical memories such as selenium and/or tellurium and alloys containing a high proportion (greater than 1/2) of selenium and/or tellurium and oxides of these metals and alloys. Preferably, however, the metal is a highly reflective soft metal alloy. This soft metal alloy comprises at least 5% by weight of each of at least two metals selected from the group consisting of cadmium, indium, tin, antimony, lead, bismuth, magnesium, copper, aluminum, zinc and silver. 
     As examples (all are percent by weight), the soft metal alloy comprises about 5 to about 95% tin, about 5 to about 95% bismuth, and 0 to about 40% copper; about 5 to about 95% tin, about 5 to about 95% bismuth, 0 to about 49.9% silver; about 5 to about 95% cadmium, about 5 to about 95% zinc and 0 to about 49.9% silver; about 5 to about 95% zinc, about 5 to about 95% cadmium and 0 to about 10% magnesium; about 5 to about 95% bismuth, about 5 to about 95% cadmium and 0 to about 49.5% silver; about 0.1 to about 95% tin and about 5 to about 99.9% indium; about 5 to about 95% tin, about 5 to about  95% lead, and 0 to about 40% copper; about 5 to about 95% tin, about 5 to about 95% lead and 0 to 49.9% silver; about 40 to 94% tin, about 3 to about 30% antimony and about 3 to about 37% bismuth and about 0 to about 40% copper; at least about 8% tin and bismuth and at least one of Mg, Au, Fe, Cr, Mn, Cu, Ag and Ni (at least about 1%) wherein Bi is present in an amount greater than Mg, Au, Fe, Cr, Mn, Cu, Ag and Ni. Layering materials having these compositions are defined herein as &#34;soft metal layers,&#34; &#34;soft metal alloy layers,&#34; and &#34;flexible metal alloy layers.&#34; A preferable alloy is made up of about 25 to about 90% tin, about 8 to about 60% bismuth and about 7 to 25% copper. The alloy is preferably made up of the partial oxide of an alloy of about 70 to about 75% tin, about 20 to about 25% bismuth and about 1 to about 5% copper. 
     Soft metal alloys which comprise predominantly tin, i.e., about 55 to about 80%; a major amount of bismuth, i.e., about 20 to about 35%; and an amount of copper, i.e., about 1 to about 10% can be used. 
     Those alloys are described in more detail in U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,998,239 and 5,016,240. These patents are incorporated by reference. 
     The soft metal alloy layer preferably is present in a uniform partially oxidized form. By &#34;uniform&#34; is meant that the degree of oxidation is substantially constant at any selected depth below the surface and that the degree of oxidation generally decreases as a function of the depth. This is because the surface oxygen content of the film can go up when the product is removed from the vacuum chamber and exposed to atmospheric oxygen. 
     Oxidation levels in the film are difficult to arrive at by mass balancing the added oxygen during oxidation deposition because the vacuum system is constantly removing gas (including all the gaseous oxidants employed herein) to some extent from the sputtering zone. 
     When a metal alloy layer is laid down without added oxidant, removed and equilibrated in air, it appears that there is about 0.5 to 0.6 atoms of oxygen present for each atom of tin (when tin is one of the components). Conversely, when too great a level of oxidant is present, there is about 0.7 to 0.8 atoms of oxygen per atom of tin. These ranges would appear to suggest an extremely narrow band of acceptable oxidation level. It is believed that useful levels of partial oxidation are broader than this range may suggest. In light of the extreme difficulties posed in determining and comparing these numbers accurately, it is considered that one way to define oxidation levels in these preferred metal layers is not by chemical constituency but rather by the optical properties of the films. 
     One indirect measure of oxidation level in these thin films of the present invention is reflectivity measured in situ in the deposition chamber before exposure of the film to atmospheric oxidation. At high oxidation levels, the metal layer appears brown and reflectance at 830 nm drops below useful levels. Suitable oxidation levels diminish the 830 nm reflectance of the film, as compared to film prepared under the same conditions without oxidant. Suitable levels of oxidation in the metal layer are achieved when ##EQU1## ranges between 0.50 and 0.95, and especially between 0.60 and 0.85. 
     The metal layer is from about 75 Å in thickness to about 5,000 Å in thickness, preferably from about 100 Å to about 1,500 Å, and often from about 500 Å to about 1000 Å. 
     The inorganic overcoat which is applied over the metal or metal partial oxide reflective layer is one or more hard transparent or semi-transparent layers of oxide, nitride, carbide, hydride or carbohydride or mixture e.g., oxynitride of one or more metals selected from chromium, aluminum, bismuth, zinc, zirconium, tantalum, tin, tungsten, niobium, titanium, indium, silicon, vanadium, antimony and hafnium (i.e., Cr, Al, Bi, Zn, Zr, Ta, Sn, W, Nb, Ti, In, Si, V, Sb and Hf). Preferably, the overcoat is an oxynitride or nitride of Zr, Hf or Ta because of their ability to enhance the properties of the media. The thickness of such overcoat is selected so that the reflectivity of the media is maintained at or above the aforementioned level. The preferred thickness of the overcoat is less than about 10,000 Å, i.e., about 50 to about 10,000 Å, but is transparent/semitransparent to the extent that it does not reduce the reflectivity of the metal layer to below the desired 40% minimum reflectivity level. 
     During production, the reflectivity of the medium can be directly monitored in real time. The reflectivity value is a function of layer thickness and layer composition and can be, and often is, used as a parameter for process control decisions. Currently, 750 to about 850 nm lasers are used routinely in read/write drives with 830 nm lasers being most common. Accordingly, the reflectance at 830 nm is a good measure of the character of the inorganic overcoats used in this invention. As shorter wavelength lasers are developed other wavelengths can be used to monitor the process, and establish acceptable reflectivity-based deposition parameters. 
     In the following discussions the laser is assumed to be 830 nm but lasers of shorter wavelength can also be used. Suitable overcoat layers are those that exhibit values for the ratio: ##EQU2## in the range between about 0.6 and about 0.95, especially about 0.60 and about 0.85, with overall reflectivity for the metal plus overcoat being from about 40% to about 80% and especially about 45% to about 70% at 830 nm or other suitable laser wavelength of from about 300 to about 850 nm. 
     The overcoated optical memory media products of this invention have very desirable properties which adapt them well for tape, card or disc applications. These properties include an overall reflectance of at least 40%, or preferably over about 45% and up to about 70 or 80% at the laser read/write wavelength such as 830 nm. 
     The media of the invention exhibit a laser light write threshold of less than about 5.0 njoules/bit at 10 milliwatts laser power, preferably less than about 3 njoules and especially less than about 2.5 njoules; a modulation depth at 250 nsec/10 milliwatt laser power of at least about 45% and preferably at least about 75% and especially at least about 95%; and a carrier-to-noise level of at least about 40 dBs and especially at least about 45 dBs and especially at least about 50 dBs at 250 nsec/10 milliwatt laser power and a 30 kHz bandwidth. 
     The product is also characterized by giving more regular, better defined laser written spots than achievable when no overcoat is present. The laser written spots are essentially discrete micron-sized spots with a continuous smooth edge. They are not fractured or fractal (spidery). 
     The metal layer and the overcoat layer are laid down in a vacuum coating process preferably sputter-depositing. Sputter depositing is a commercial process for depositing inorganic materials, metals, oxides, and the like, on surfaces. Representative descriptions of sputter depositing processes and equipment may be found in U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,204,942 and 4,948,087 which are incorporated by reference. A schematic view of a representative sputtering system is provided in FIG. 1 and will be described in and prior to Example 1. 
     In sputtering, a voltage is applied to a metal or metal compound sputtering cathode in the presence of a reactive or nonreactive gas to create a plasma. The action of the sputtering gas plasma on the cathode causes atoms of the cathode (source) to be dislodged and to travel to and deposit upon a substrate positioned adjacent to the sputtering source. 
     Typically the sputtering gas is a noble gas such as krypton or argon or the like. Argon is the most common sputtering gas because of its attractive cost. It is also known in the art to employ from about 1% to about 90% by volume of one or more reactive gases as components of a sputtering gas mixture but not in the practice of this invention. 
     When a reactive gas is present it can cause a metal to be deposited as an oxide (when an oxygen source is present), a nitride (when a nitrogen source is present) and the like. This reactive sputtering process is well known and used commercially. 
     As applied to the present invention, the reflective metal may be deposited using a sputtering gas which includes an oxygen source, i.e., an oxidative sputtering gas to give a partial oxide. 
     The overcoat layer is deposited using a zirconium, tantalum, or the like, cathode and a sputtering gas including oxygen, nitrogen, hydrogen, a gaseous carbon compound, or a hydrocarbon to give the desired oxide, nitride or the like. Nitrogen and mixtures of oxygen and nitrogen are preferred components of reactive sputtering gas mixtures. A target made up of an inorganic compound such as silicon carbide can also be used with or without added reactive gas (for example, hydrogen) to deposit, for example, silicon carbide or silicon carbonhydride. 
     This invention will be further described with reference to the accompanying examples. These are provided to illustrate the invention but are not to be construed as limiting its scope. 
     These experiments were all carried out in a continuous sputtering machine. The sputtering equipment used was a research-sized coater for 13.5-inch-wide web. A simplified schematic of the web coating system is shown as System 10 in FIG. 1. System 10 includes vacuum chamber 12 which is evacuated via line 14. Contained within chamber 12 is a drive mechanism for moving a sheet of flexible plastic substrate 16 past a series of magnetron sputtering stations 50, 48, 46. The drive mechanism includes feed roll 18, idlers 20, 22, 24, 26, 28, 30 and 32 and take-up roll 34. 
     The film passes around chilled idler drum 36 as well. The film passes a pair of monitors for determining its transmittance, 38, and reflectance, 40, before coating and a similar pair of monitors 42 and 44 after coating. This coater is configured to simultaneously sputter coat up to three layers on a 13.5-inch-wide web using three separate DC magnetron cathodes 46, 48 and 50. Typically, cathode 46 is used to lay down the reflective metal layer, usually as a particle oxide. Cathode 48 can be used to lay down the hard overcoat. Also located in the system is a pre-glow station 52 for ionized gas cleaning or surface modifying of the substrate before coating. Each of these four stations is isolated from each other in space as a mini-chamber; thereby producing a local environment for the containment of the various plasma gasses. This allows separate processes to be carried out simultaneously at each station with variations in atmosphere from station to station but without cross-contamination among the four sources (see FIG. 2). 
     As shown in FIG. 2, a typical mini-chamber such as 46 includes a housing 61 with a curved side 62 which conforms to the contour of idler drum 36 (FIG. 1). This side 62 contains a slit 64 through which the sputter deposited alloy is conveyed onto the substrate that moves past it. The mini-chamber 46 has a cathode 66 made of the ablative reflective material and a manifold 68 which supplies sputtering gas (argon) from line 70 and preferably mixes it with oxidant gas such as oxygen gas, supplied from vessel 53 via valve 54 and line 56 and distributes this mixture in its sputtering zone via line 72-74, etc. In the mini-chamber(s) for laying down the overcoat(s), the cathode 66 is zirconium, hafnium, tantalum, or the like, and line 56 supplies reactive gas (oxidant, a nitrogen source, carbon source or hydrogen source) as called for to yield the desired oxide, nitride, etc. 
     The control and monitoring of the sputtering system are normally accomplished using equipment and sensors which are standard in this coating machine. These are shown in FIG. 1 and include: 75, mass flow controllers (MKS) for regulation of gas flow into the cathode mini-chambers; 76, DC power (5-10 kilowatt) supplies (Advanced Energy) for all three sputtering cathodes; 77, an optical monitoring system (Hexatron/Southwall Technologies) which measures both reflectance and transmission of the film over the spectral region from 300 to 2000 nm; and 78, a film motion control system (Drivex) which regulates the tension, speed, and distance of the film as it moves through the system. 
     In addition to this equipment, the chamber 46 was fitted with an optical emission spectrometer (OES) 60 and a residual gas analyzer (RGA) 58 for in situ monitoring of the composition of the gas in the plasma (see FIGS. 1 and 2). The process parameters are equipment sensitive and may vary from equipment to equipment or even on the same equipment from day to day. Thus, before making the media of the present invention, the equipment should be calibrated before use. 
     The experiments were carried out using the following protocol for experimental sample preparation: 
     1) the chamber was set up: 
     a) a plastic (usually PET) substrate film was loaded into the chamber, 
     b) the chamber was evacuated to 1-2×10 -5  Torr, 
     c) sputtering gas (argon) flow rates to the various mini-chambers were initiated, 
     d) the oxidant gas valve feeding the mini-chamber having the reflective metal cathode was opened to give a desired ratio of argon to oxidant source within the reflective metal depositing mini-chamber, with oxygen being the common oxidant source, 
     e) in the use of the overcoat sputtering mini-chamber, the reactant gas valve was opened to give a ratio of argon to reactant gas within the mini-chamber suitable for forming the desired transparent or semitransparent oxide, nitride, etc., overcoat. 
     f) the film reels were set in motion, 
     g) the pre-glow station was turned on, 
     h) the cathode power was set and turned on for the metal layer deposit, 
     i) the cathode power was set and turned on for the overcoat, 
     j) the various parameters (1c-i) were adjusted to give the desired reflectivity level, 
     2) the system was allowed to equilibrate for a period of time, 
     3) 10 to 20 feet of film was coated with the reflective metal layer and the overcoat, 
     4) the power to the metal cathode was turned off for a short period of time to leave a region on the film which was coated with just the overcoat, 
     5) the power to the overcoat was turned off for a short period of time to leave a blank region on the film, as a marker to identify the end of &#34;sample&#34;, 
     6) new system parameters were set (1c-j), 
     7) the plasmas were then reignited and the cycle repeated (2-7) until the film was used up or the experiments were complete, and then 
     8) the film was removed from the vacuum chamber and cut into sections for analysis. 
     Using the protocol outlined above, a set of preparations were carried out to demonstrate the effect of metal oxide, nitride, etc., overcoats on sputter-deposited optical storage products. 
     Examples and Comparative Tests 
     A 13.5-inch-wide web-coating machine described above was used to sputter-deposit soft metal alloy as reflective metal onto polymeric substrate materials. The sputtering target (5&#34;×15.5&#34;×0.25&#34;) comprised an alloy, in percentage by weight, of Sn (about 65- to about 80), Bi (about 13 to about 30), and Cu (about 1 to about 7). The alloy composition may have varied within these limits from test to test. The substrate was 3-mil PET film unless otherwise noted in the following table. The chamber was evacuated to about a pressure of 2×10 -5  Torr, then back-filled with argon gas to a pressure of about 1.07×10 -3  Torr, and then with water vapor or oxygen to a total pressure (as shown in the Table) and power (as shown in the Table) was applied to the magnetron sputtering source. The substrate was translated in front of the sputtering source at a certain rate (reel speed as shown in the Table) so as to allow for a coating of the alloy to be deposited onto the substrate. 
     The overcoat sputtering chamber containing an overcoat target was then back-filled with argon gas to a pressure of about 1.2×10 -3  Torr, and then with a reactive gas if used to a total pressure (as shown in the Table). A DC power source (as shown in the Table) was applied to the magnetron sputtering source of the overcoat target. The substrate was translated in front of the sputtering sources at a rate (as shown in Table) so as to allow for a coating of the partially oxidized alloy and the overcoat to be deposited onto the substrate. 
     Various characteristics of the overcoated medium were measured and reported in the Table. The characteristics include: reflectance at 830 nm (shown in the Table); a laser light write threshold in njoules/bit at 10 milliwatts laser power; modulation depth at 250 nsec/10 milliwatt laser power; a carrier-to-noise level in dBs at 250 nsec/10 milliwatt laser power/30 kHz frequency analyzer bandwidth/30 fps medium speed. 
     The laser-written spots shapes were improved over those achieved with the non-overcoated Comparative Test samples. These tests are summarized in the following Table. In the Table, the second column indicates the nature of the overcoat, and the third column, the target used for the overcoat. The target used for the reflective film, as described previously herein, is referred to as FMP. In a few examples, more than one overcoat was used either over the FMP layer or with the FMP layer being sandwiched between them. These tests are indicated in the table in the overcoat column by the designation of the order of layering down the layers. See, for example, the test sample no. 82. SiCxHy/FMP/SiCxHy which indicates: siliconcarbohydride coating on the substrate followed by the FMP coating over the silicon carbohydride followed by a second silicon carbohydride coating over the FMP layer. 
     
         TABLE
         Argon/  Water  In Situ    Laser Modula-      Oxygen Nitrogen
 Hydrogen Gas Mini- Valve  Spectral  Static  Write tion   Sput- Cathode
 Flow Flow Flow Flow Chamber Micro- Reel Reflectivity Static Trans-
 Static Sensitivity Depth Sample  tering Power Rate Rate Rate Rate
 Pressure meter Speed (% @ Reflectivity mission Absorption (nano- (% @
 C/N # Overcoat Target (Watts) (sccm) (sccm) (sccm) (sccm) (mTorr)
 Setting) (mm/sec) 830 nm) (%) (%) (%) seconds) 0.20 Zero) (dB&#39;s)
    1 ZrNx Zr 3500 0.0 18.0 -- 6.7 2.70 -- 8.0 44.6 45.62 15.91 38.47 160 1
 05 49   FMP 390 3.5 0.0 -- 8.6 2.38 -- 8.0  2 ZrNx Zr 3500 0.0 20.0 --
 6.7 3.00 -- 8.0 44.6 45.50 16.20 38.30 160 97 48   FMP 390 3.5 0.0 --
 8.6 2.36 -- 8.0  3 ZrNx Zr 3500 0.0 22.0 -- 6.7 3.32 -- 8.0 45.3 45.90
 15.21 38.89 150 97 48   FMP 400 3.5 0.0 -- 8.6 2.36 -- 8.0  4 ZrNx Zr
 3500 0.0 24.0 -- 6.7 3.60 -- 8.0 45.1 45.43 15.50 39.07 170 89 48   FMP
 400 3.5 0.0 -- 8.6 2.39 -- 8.0  5 ZrNx Zr 3500 0.0 26.0 -- 6.7 3.93 --
 8.0 44.8 45.20 15.25 39.55 180 88 48   FMP 400 3.5 0.0 -- 8.6 2.38 --
 8.0  6 ZrNx Zr 3500 0.0 28.0 -- 6.7 4.22 -- 8.0 44.6 44.70 15.34 39.96
 150 88 48   FMP 400 3.5 0.0 -- 8.6 2.38 -- 8.0  7 ZrNx Zr 3500 0.0 30.0
 -- 6.7 -- -- 8.0 45.1 45.67 15.16 39.16 140 88 48   FMP 390 3.5 0.0 --
 8.6 2.38 -- 8.0  8 ZrNx Zr 500 0.0 12.9 -- 6.7 2.70 -- 8.0 45.1 43.15
 18.10 38.75 170 71 42   FMP 360 3.5 0.0 -- 8.6 2.33 -- 8.0  9 ZrNx Zr
 1500 0.0 14.8 -- 6.7 2.70 -- 8.0 45.2 44.64 16.41 38.95 170 88 44   FMP
 370 3.5 0.0 -- 8.6 2.35 -- 8.0 10 ZrNx Zr 2500 0.0 16.4 -- 6.7 2.70 --
 8.0 44.8 44.64 16.54 38.82 140 88 45   FMP 370 3.5 0.0 -- 8.6 2.32 --
 8.0 11 ZrNx Zr 3500 0.0 18.1 -- 6.7 2.70 -- 8.0 45.5 46.45 15.81 38.37
 145 102 48   FMP 390 3.5 0.0 -- 8.6 2.33 -- 8.0 12 ZrNx Zr 4500 0.0 19.5
 -- 6.7 2.70 -- 8.0 45.2 46.07 13.59 40.33 170 103 50   FMP 420 3.5 0.0
 -- 8.6 2.32 -- 8.0 13 ZrNx Zr 5500 0.0 20.9 -- 6.7 2.70 -- 8.0 44.9
 45.98 11.68 42.34 150 105 54   FMP 460 3.5 0.0 -- 8.6 2.30 -- 8.0 14
 ZrNx Zr 6500 0.0 22.6 -- 6.7 2.70 -- 8.0 43.2 45.43 10.80 43.77 150 105
 54   FMP 490 3.5 0.0 -- 8.6 2.30 -- 8.0 15 ZrNx Zr 6500 0.0 21.0 -- 6.7
 2.36 -- 8.0 43.0 45.22 10.47 44.31 -- 94 48   FMP 490 3.5 0.0 -- 8.7
 2.35 -- 8.0 16 ZrNx Zr 6500 0.0 23.0 -- 6.7 2.70 -- 8.0 43.2 45.38 10.90
 43.72 -- 105 52   FMP 490 3.5 0.0 -- 8.7 2.35 -- 8.0 17 ZrNx Zr 6500 0.0
 25.0 -- 6.7 3.07 -- 8.0 43.0 45.29 11.06 43.65 -- 108 52   FMP 490 3.5
 0.0 -- 8.7 2.37 -- 8.0 18 ZrNx Zr 6500 0.0 27.0 -- 6.7 3.43 -- 8.0 43.6
 46.08 11.47 42.44 -- 110 53   FMP 490 3.5 0.0 -- 8.7 2.35 -- 8.0 19 ZrNx
 Zr 6500 0.0 29.0 -- 6.7 3.75 -- 8.0 43.6 45.68 11.59 42.73 -- 108 51
 FMP 490 3.5 0.0 -- 8.7 2.35 -- 8.0 20 ZrNx Zr 6500 0.0 31.0 -- 6.7 4.10
 -- 8.0 4.35 45.73 11.74 42.52 -- 105 49   FMP 490 3.5 0.0 -- 8.7 2.40 --
 8.0 21 ZrNx Zr 6500 0.0 33.0 -- 6.7 4.38 -- 8.0 4.35 45.74 11.84 42.42
 -- 105 48   FMP 490 3.5 0.0 -- 8.7 2.35 -- 8.0 22 TaOxNg Ta 3000 0.0
 46.3 -- 17.0 2.66 -- 6.0 -- 48.05 9.49 42.47 190 104 52   FMP 400 3.5 --
 -- 8.9 2.39 -- 6.0 23 TaOxNg Ta 3000 3.0 46.3 -- 17.0 2.82 -- 6.0 --
 47.24 10.62 42.14 190 102 51   FMP 400 3.5 -- -- 8.9 2.44 -- 6.0 24
 TaOxNg Ta 3000 6.0 46.3 -- 17.0 3.04 -- 6.0 -- 48.38 11.04 40.58 190 97
 49   FMP 400 3.5 -- -- 8.9 2.42 -- 6.0 25 TaOxNg Ta 3500 -- 18.0 -- 6.7
 2.22 -- 8.0 44.8 46.51 13.42 40.07 210 87 47   FMP 390 3.5 -- -- 8.6
 2.28 -- 8.0 26 TaOxNg Ta 3500 -- 20.0 -- 6.7 2.68 -- 8.0 45.5 46.79
 14.11 39.10 190 105 52   FMP 390 3.5 -- -- 8.6 2.29 -- 8.0 27 TaOxNg Ta
 3500 -- 22.0 -- 6.7 3.06 -- 8.0 45.4 46.18 14.56 39.27 180 103 50   FMP
 390 3.5 -- -- 8.6 2.30 -- 8.0 28 TaOxNg Ta 3500 -- 24.0 -- 6.7 3.40 --
 8.0 45.2 46.14 14.97 38.90 180 103 48   FMP 390 3.5 -- -- 8.6 2.31 --
 8.0 29 TaOxNg Ta 3500 -- 26.0 -- 6.7 3.72 -- 8.0 45.0 46.15 15.19 38.66
 175 100 47   FMP 390 3.5 -- -- 8.6 2.33 -- 8.0 30 TaOxNg Ta 3500 -- 28.0
 -- 6.7 4.06 -- 8.0 45.4 46.68 14.69 38.63 180 97 46   FMP 400 3.5 -- --
 8.6 2.32 -- 8.0 31 TaOxNg Ta 3500 -- 30.0 -- 6.7 4.35 -- 8.0 45.3 46.34
 14.98 38.68 185 95 45   FMP 400 3.5 -- -- 8.6 2.33 -- 8.0 32 TaOxNg Ta
 500 -- 13.3 -- 6.7 2.70 -- 8.0 45.6 45.18 16.97 37.85 190 60 39   FMP
 370 3.5 -- -- 8.7 2.32 -- 8.0 33 TaOxNg Ta 1500 -- 15.6 -- 6.7 2.70 --
 8.0 44.9 45.01 16.89 37.90 180 70 40   FMP 360 3.5 -- -- 8.7 2.32 -- 8.0
 34 TaOxNg Ta 2500 -- 17.7 -- 6.7 2.70 -- 8.0 45.2 45.92 16.18 37.90 180
 97 45   FMP 370 3.5 -- -- 8.6 2.33 -- 8.0 35 TaOxNg Ta 3500 -- 20.0 --
 6.7 2.70 -- 8.0 44.6 46.11 16.18 38.92 180 105 51   FMP 390 3.5 -- --
 8.6 2.34 -- 8.0 36 TaOxNg Ta 4500 -- 22.5 -- 6.7 2.70 -- 8.0 45.0 46.35
 11.54 42.11 200 95 47   FMP 440 3.5 -- -- 8.6 2.30 -- 8.0 37 TaOxNg Ta
 5500 -- 24.5 -- 6.7 2.70 -- 8.0 42.8 44.68 9.67 45.65 200 86 46   FMP
 490 3.5 -- --  8.6 2.30 -- 8.0 38 NbNx Nb 5500 0 37.0 -- 0 4.10 -- 8.0
 47.5 46.93 13.86 39.21 -- 80 49   FMP 380 3.5 0 -- 8.6 2.37 -- 8.0 39
 HfNx Hf 3500 0 16.0 -- 6.7 2.60 -- 8.0 45.3 45.50 15.97 38.53 -- 100 47
  FMP 380 3.5 0 -- 8.7 2.43 -- 8.0 40 HfNx Hf 3500 0 14.0 -- 6.7 2.23 --
 8.0 45.2 45.15 16.05 38.80 -- 100 50   FMP 380 3.5 0 -- 8.7 2.36 -- 8.0
 41 HfNx Hf 3500 0 18.0 -- 6.7 2.95 -- 8.0 45.2 45.62 16.18 38.20 -- 100
 45   FMP 390 3.5 0 -- 8.7 2.38 -- 8.0 42 HfNx Hf 3500 0 20.0 -- 6.7 3.30
 -- 8.0 45.3 44.97 16.33 38.70 -- 100 43   FMP 390 3.5 0 -- 8.7 2.40 --
 8.0 43 HfNx Hf 3500 0 22.0 -- 6.7 3.60 -- 8.0 45.4 45.18 16.42 38.40 --
 97 42   FMP 390 3.5 0 -- 8.7 2.40 -- 8.0 44 HfNx Hf 3500 0 24.0 -- 6.7
 3.90 -- 8.0 45.0 44.37 17.30 38.33 -- 95 40   FMP 390 3.5 0 -- 8.7 2.40
 -- 8.0 45 HfNx Hf 3500 0 26.0 -- 6.7 4.20 -- 8.0 44.9 44.07 17.59 38.34
 -- 95 40   FMP 390 3.5 0 -- 8.7 2.40 -- 8.0 46 HfNx Hf 3500 0 28.0 --
 6.7 1.50 -- 8.0 45.6 44.40 16.63 38.97 -- 95 40   FMP 400 3.5 0 -- 8.7
 2.40 -- 8.0 47 HfNx Hf 3500 0 30.0 -- 6.7 4.80 -- 8.0 45.1 44.20 17.51
 38.29 -- 95 39   FMP 400 3.5 0 -- 8.7 2.40 -- 8.0 48 TiNx Ti 3500 0 20.0
 -- 6.7 3.17 -- 8.0 44.8 43.06 18.77 38.17 -- 74 46   FMP 320 3.5 0 --
 8.7 2.40 -- 8.0 49 TiNx Ti 3500 0 15.0 -- 6.7 2.40 -- 8.0 44.7 43.29
 19.00 37.71 -- 76 47   FMP 310 3.5 0 -- 8.7 2.36 -- 8.0 50 TiNx Ti 3500
 0 25.0 -- 6.7 3.90 -- 8.0 45.3 44.13 17.69 38.18 -- 76 47   FMP 340 3.5
 0 -- 8.7 2.40 -- 8.0 51 TiNx Ti 4500 0 20.0 -- 6.7 2.90 -- 8.0 45.0
 43.43 18.87 37.70 -- 71 47   FMP 310 3.5 0 -- 8.7 2.40 -- 8.0 52 TiNx Ti
 5500 0 20.0 -- 6.7 2.70 -- 8.0 45.3 42.57 19.08 38.35 -- 57 45   FMP 290
 3.5 0 -- 8.7 2.40 -- 8.0 53 TiNx Ti 6500 0 20.0 -- 6.7 2.40 -- 8.0 45.2
 43.18 19.18 37.64 -- 48 43   FMP 270 3.5 0 -- 8.7 2.40 -- 8.0 54 SnOx Sn
 4979 56.3 -- -- 7.2 4.9 -- 10.0 49 47.13 11.53 41.33 600 -- --   FMP 661
 -- -- -- 6.4 1.06 0  66.7 61.92 7.71 30.37 880 -- -- 55 SnOx Sn 4979
 56.0 -- -- 7.2 4.9 -- 10.0 50.8 50.04 9.29 40.67 470 -- 13   FMP 740 --
 -- -- 6.4 1.15 20  66.0 61.81 6.84 31.35 600 -- -- 56 SnOx Sn 5003 55.6
 -- -- 7.2 4.9 -- 10.0 48.8 48.20 8.76 43.04 240 42 42   FMP 903 -- -- --
 6.4 1.38 40  61.4 58.26 6.97 34.77 300 47 41 57 SnOx Sn 4966 55.5 -- --
 7.2 4.9 -- 10.0 48.0 47.82 9.00 43.10 230 45 41   FMP 980 -- -- -- 6.4
 1.50 50  60.0 57.81 7.29 34.90 290 50 42 58 SnOx Sn 4964 55.4 -- -- 7.2
 4.9 -- 10.0 48.7 48.96 8.12 42.92 210 30 40   FMP 1238 -- -- -- 6.4 1.68
 60  60.9 59.65 6.24 34.11 300 13 33 59 SnOx Sn 4997 56.0 -- -- 7.2 4.9
 -- 10.0 45.1 46.09 8.53 45.37 210 20 38   FMP 1638 -- -- -- 6.4 2.04 80
 57.3 57.71 6.47 35.83 320 18 25 60 SnOx Sn 7021 68.8 -- -- 7.2 5.3 --
 6.0 -- 13.47 25.54 60.99 610 -- 41   FMP 994 -- -- -- 6.0 1.79 80 61
 SnOx Sn 7021 68.8 -- -- 7.2 5.3 -- 3.25 -- 47.50 14.84 37.65 640 -- 10
 Sn 6991 68.2 -- -- 7.2 5.3 -- 6.0   FMP 994 -- -- -- 6.0 1.79 80 62 SnOx
 Sn 7021 68.8 -- -- 7.2 5.3 -- 1.30 -- -- -- -- 14000 -- --   Sn 6972
 67.7 -- -- 7.2 5.3 -- 6.0   FMP 994 -- -- -- 6.0 1.79 80 63 SnOx Sn 7000
 65.8 -- -- 7.2 5.15 -- 2.11 -- -- -- -- 950 -- --   FMP 338 -- -- -- 6.0
 1.59 50  -- 64 SnOx Sn 7011 75.8 -- -- 14.5 7.56 -- 2.11 41.4 -- -- --
 1400 -- --   FMP 344 -- -- -- 6.0 1.65 50 65 SnOx Sn 6002 79.2 -- --
 29.9 10.58 -- 2.11 39.3 -- -- -- 990 -- --   FMP 340 -- -- -- 6.0 1.75
 50 66 SnOx Sn 5987 87.2 -- -- 40.0 13.57 -- 2.11 41.8 -- -- -- 990 -- --
   FMP 337 -- -- -- 6.0 1.83 50 67 SnOx Sn 3485 42.7 -- -- 7.3 4.0 -- 6.0
 -- 35.51 18.24 46.25 200 45 44   FMP 986 -- -- -- 6.0 1.76 80 68 SnOx Sn
 1739 28.6 -- -- 7.3 3.5 -- 4.50 48.2 47.64 11.21 41.15 180 35 42   FMP
 989 -- -- -- 6.0 1.73 80  -- 55.86 9.22 34.92 220 41 43 69 SnOx Sn 6735
 65.7 -- -- 7.2 5.5 --  10.0 43.0 43.47 10.26 46.27 220 62 44  376Å
 FMP 990 -- -- -- 6.4 1.5 50  59.8 58.29 7.52 34.20 290 51 41 70 SnOx SN
 3339 46.4 -- -- 7.2 4.9 -- 10.0 50.0 48.43 12.76 38.82 220 77 44
 200Å   FMP 793 -- -- -- 6.4 1.52 50  55.9 52.98 11.61 35.41 240 54
 44 71 SnOx Sn 1662 36.8 -- -- 7.2 4.9 -- 10.0 50.0 48.34 14.72 36.93 210
 67 40  100Å   FMP 689 -- -- -- 6.4 1.52 50  52.6 49.47 14.36 36.18
 210 70 41 72 SnOx  2561 35.0 -- -- 7.2 3.6 -- 7.0 49.9 -- -- -- -- --
 FMP 995 -- -- -- 6.0 1.85 80  -- -- -- -- -- 20 29 73 SiNx Si 3483 --
 36.4 -- 39.4 8.0 -- 5.0 50.2 50.12 13.01 36.87 240 51 41   FMP 378 --
 -- -- 6.4 1.56 40  55.8 52.34 13.29 34.37 220 68 41 74 SiNx Si 3470 --
 36.7 -- 39.5 8.0 -- 5.0 50.2 50.48 11.85 37.58 250 43 42   FMP 467 -- --
 -- 6.4 1.69 50  57.1 54.90 11.61 33.48 220 60 42 75 SiNx Si 3470 -- 36.6
 -- 39.5 8.0 -- 5.0 50.0 50.52 12.31 37.18 280 39 38   FMP 540 -- -- --
 6.4 1.82 60  56.3 54.99 11.29 33.72 260 55 41 76 SiOxNg Si 3481 8.0 32.8
 -- 39.5 8.0 -- 5.0 50.5 49.39 12.71 37.89 250 44 38   FMP 382 -- -- --
 6.4 1.55 40  56.3 52.33 12.74 34.94 210 65 41 77 SiOxNg Si 3487 8.0 32.9
 -- 39.5 8.0 -- 5.0 51.3 49.69 11.52 38.78 260 40 36   FMP 467 -- -- --
 6.4 1.66 50  56.9 54.73 10.68 34.59 250 54 39 78 SiOxNg Si 3487 8.0 33.0
 -- 39.5 8.0 -- 5.0 50.6 47.51 11.73 40.76 280 36 34   FMP 563 -- -- --
 6.4 1.80 60  56.3 55.97 10.65 33.37 270 50 39 79 SiCxHy SiC 3976 -- --
 20.0 54.4 7.63-- 6.0 50.0 48.35 7.08 44.58 210 44 40   FMP 528 -- -- --
 6.4 1.68 40  61.4 58.47 6.64 34.89 310 36 37 80 SiCxHy SiC 3976 -- --
 20.0 54.4 7.62 -- 6.0 50.0 48.95 6.72 44.33 190 45 41   FMP 638 -- -- --
 6.4 1.81 50  61.4 59.64 5.78 34.58 290 11 30 81 SiCxHy SiC 3976 -- --
 20.0 54.4 7.60 -- 6.0 49.5 48.65 9.07 42.27 190 64 43   FMP 638 -- -- --
 6.4 1.96 60  59.5 57.42 7.64 34.94 250 40 38 82 SiCxHy Si 3975 -- --
 20.0 54.5 7.5 -- 6.0 49.4 47.50 8.48 44.02 260 9 32   FMP 591 -- -- --
 6.4 1.61 50  61.2 59.29 7.44 33.27 590 0 20   Si 3986 -- -- -- 54.5 7.16
 -- 6.0 83 InOx In 5070 37.3 4.0 14.0 4.5 4.1 -- 12.0 -- 49.28 10.44
 40.28 280 23 38   FMP 945 -- -- -- 6.4 1.39 50  -- 55.80 6.20 35.00 360
 12 29   In 5095 31.8 4.0 14.0 4.5 4.1 -- 12.0 84 ZrOxNg Zr 3880 3.3 42.9
 -- 67.5 8.3 -- 7.0 -- 49.39 14.05 36.37 240 70 44   FMP 432 -- -- -- 4.0
 1.86 50  --   Zr 3920 3.3 42.9 -- 67.5 8.2 -- 7.0 85 SnOx Sn 3314 46.5
 -- -- 7.2 4.9 -- 10.0 50.5 49.24 12.50 38.26 260 18 36   FMP 740 -- --
 -- 6.4 1.47 50  55.6 52.57 11.74 35.69 230 62 42   Sn 3332 42.1 -- --
 7.2 4.9 -- 10.0 86 ZrOxNy Zr 3910 2.0 25.4 -- 40.0 7.42 -- 5.0 44.9 44.3
 13.57 42.00 210 74 43   Zr 98 -- -- -- 19.1 2.47 -- 5.0   FMP 370 -- --
 -- 6.4 1.55 50 87 ZrOxNy Zr 3910 2.0 25.0 -- 40.0 7.40 -- 10.0 52.0
 51.04 12.24 36.73 250 47 39   Zr 98 -- -- -- 19.1 2.47 -- 5.0   FMP 370
 -- -- -- 6.4 1.55 50 88 SnOx Sn 2484 35.3 -- -- 7.2 4.3 -- 14.0 51.1
 50.54 10.01 39.45 280 64 36  ZnOxNy   Zr 4000 3.3 42.9 -- 67.5 8.3 --
 54.8 53.14 8.94 37.92 290 98 44   FMP 985 -- -- -- 4.0 1.79 40  57.3
 53.67 10.09 36.23 310 63 38 89 SnOx Sn 2480 35.4 -- -- 7.2 4.3 -- 14.0
 50.5 49.26 9.69 41.05 230 91 43  ZnOxNy   Zr 3980 3.3 42.9 -- 67.5 8.3
 --  54.3 54.06 8.77 37.17 210 98 46   FMP 1091 -- -- -- 4.0 1.91 50  --
 53.18 9.32 37.50 250 60 42 90 SnOx Sn 2486 35.4 -- -- 7.2 4.3 -- 14.0
 50.0 50.81 11.53 37.66 210 96 44  ZnOxNy   Zr 4000 3.3 42.9 -- 67.5 8.3
 --  53.2 53.15 10.76 36.09 200 96 44   FMP 985 -- -- -- 4.0 2.09 60
 54.6 52.86 11.77 35.37 260 71 43 91 SnOx Sn 2476 35.1 -- -- 7.2 4.3 --
 14.0 49.9 50.43 12.28 37.30 230 91 46  ZnOxNy   Zr 4000 3.3 42.9 -- 67.5
 8.3 --  52.7 53.05 10.98 35.97 200 96 43   FMP 1092 -- -- -- 4.0 2.23 70
  54.2 53.22 12.09 34.69 220 74 43 92 SiCHx SiC 3987 -- -- 20.0 45.9 7.7
 -- 10.0 46.2 45.92 9.39 44.69 200 93 50  ZrOxNy   Zr 3870 3.3 42.8 --
 62.8 8.3 --   FMP 780 -- -- -- 4.0 2.13 50 93 SiCHx SiC 3979 -- -- 20.0
 45.9 7.7 -- 10.0 46.2 45.90 10.39 43.71 185 93 50  ZrOxNy   Zr 3950 6.6
 42.8 -- 62.8 8.5 --   FMP 773 -- -- -- 4.0 2.12 50 94 SiCHx SiC 3985 --
 -- 20.0 45.9 7.6 -- 10.0 48.5 47.80 9.20 43.00 200 73 47  ZrOxNy   Zr
 3820 0.0 42.8  62.8 8.1 --   FMP 770 -- -- -- 4.0 2.12 50 95 TaNy Ta
 2977 0.0 36.5 -- 14.0 2.74 -- 6.0 49.9 50.26 11.07 38.66 200 100 50
 FMP 541 -- -- -- 5.7 2.03 50 96 TaOxNy Ta 2987 3.0 36.5 -- 14.0 2.96 --
 6.0 49.3 49.30 12.54 38.16 180 100 50   FMP 539 -- -- -- 5.7 2.05 50 97
 TaOxNy Ta 2980 6.0 36.5 -- 14.0 3.24 -- 6.0 50.0 49.82 12.75 37.44 180
 95 48   FMP 539 -- -- -- 5.7 2.05 50 98 TaOxNy Ta 2972 3.0 36.5 -- 14.0
 3.11 -- 6.0 48.9 -- -- -- -- -- --   FMP 532 -- -- -- 5.7 2.07 50 99
 InOx In 5099 36.0 4.0 14.0 4.5 4.1 -- 12.0 50.3 47.69 10.18 42.14 290 74
 46   FMP 937 -- -- -- 6.4 1.34 40  58.6 51.70 8.82 39.48 270 58 40 100
 InOx In 5062 36.9 4.0 14.0 4.5 4.1 -- 12.0 50.6 48.17 9.81 42.02 310 66
 42   FMP 930 -- -- -- 6.4 1.36 40  58.5 55.43 8.75 35.82 260 55 42 101
 InOx In 5117 36.8 4.0 14.0 4.5 4.1 -- 12.0 50.2 48.56 10.70 40.73 270 76
 47   FMP 938 -- -- -- 6.4 1.45 50  56.7 54.86 9.46 35.68 240 59 43 102
 InOx In 5097 36.8 4.0 14.0 4.5 4.1 -- 12.0 49.8 48.82 11.42 39.76 240 81
 48   FMP 1039 -- -- -- 6.4 161 60  57.1 54.83 9.69 35.48 260 56 43 103
 TiOxNy Ti 4482 3.0 30.0 -- 14.0 5.60 -- 5.0 50.7 49.77 12.65 37.58 200
 84 49   FMP 369 -- -- -- 6.0 2.05 50 104  TiOxNy Ti 4483 8.0 30.0 --
 14.0 6.78 -- 5.0 50.2 50.79 14.01 35.21 220 60 43   FMP 413 -- -- -- 6.0
 2.04 50 105  ZrNx Zr 3760 -- 46.2 -- 67.5 8.3 -- 5.0 50.8 51.43 11.16
 37.41 200 89 52   FMP 457 -- -- -- 4.0 1.91 50 106  ZrNx Zr 3730 -- 46.9
 -- 67.5 8.3 -- 4.0 48.5 48.72 13.10 38.18 190 89 51   FMP 362 -- -- --
 4.0 1.92 50 107  ZrOx Zr 3380 16.5 -- -- 40.7 6.93 -- 2.11 52.8 47.94
 13.21 38.85 210 39 44   FMP 392 -- -- -- 6.0 1.85 55 108  ZrOx Zr 3390
 16.5 -- -- 40.7 7.13 -- 2.11 44.4 43.45 14.30 42.25 210 30 46   Zr 3380
 16.5 -- -- 40.7 6.93 -- 2.11  51.38 12.01 36.61 230 33 43   FMP 392 --
 -- -- 6.0 1.85 55     37.29 109  ZrOx Zr 5040 16.5 -- -- 19.2 3.75 --
 5.0 52.8 50.22 12.49 36.43 210 98 46   FMP 385 -- -- -- 6.4 1.47 40
 56.2 51.86 11.71 35.72 260 65 41 110  ZrOx Zr 5040 15.8 -- -- 19.2 3.75
 -- 5.0 49.6 47.60 16.68 35.43 220 98 46   FMP 388 -- -- -- 6.4 1.61 50
 53.8 48.32 16.25 34.82 280 71 40 111  ZrOx Zr 4774 16.2 -- -- 19.2 3.75
 -- 5.0 50.4 49.56 15.62 33.36 260 87 46   FMP 494 -- -- -- 6.4 1.77 60
 53.1 51.61 15.03  280 58 42 112  ZrOxNy Zr 4140 2.0 25.6 -- 40.0 7.45 --
 6.0 49.1 48.79 7.14 44.06 170 -- --   FMP 742 -- -- -- 6.0 2.02 80 113
 ZrOxNy Zr 3930 2.0 25.2 -- 40.0 7.44 -- 5.0 48.7 48.65 9.54 41.80 210
 102 49   FMP 420 -- -- -- 6.4 1.46 40  58.5 54.60 10.03 35.37 260 64 46
 114  ZrOxNy Zr 3900 2.0 25.3 -- 40.0 7.43 -- 5.0 47.5 48.48 10.77 40.75
 210 100 51   FMP 490 -- -- -- 6.4 1.69 50  58.3 55.13 10.04 34.84 260 53
 42 115  ZrOxNy Zr 3910 2.0 26.0 -- 40.0 7.43 -- 5.0 45.0 46.11 15.47
 38.42 190 98 49   FMP 489 -- -- -- 6.4 1.78 60  54.9 51.54 14.40 34.06
 245 64 41 116  ZrOxNy Zr 3900 2.0 25.4 -- 40.0 7.43 -- 10.0 50.2 47.83
 14.71 37.46 200 100 44   FMP 581 -- -- -- 6.4 1.67 50  51.7 44.66 18.55
 36.79 205 74 45 117  ZrOxNy Zr 3820 3.3 44.0 -- 67.5 8.3 -- 7.0 51.1
 51.31 11.58 37.11 190 93 49   FMP 604 -- -- -- 4.0 1.94 50 118  ZrOxNy
 Zr 3830 3.3 45.1 -- 67.5 8.3 -- 4.042.2 44.63 11.53 43.84 190 100 50
 FMP 455 -- -- -- 4.0 1.95 50 119  ZrOxNy Zr 3870 3.3 42.7 -- 67.5 8.3 --
 7.0 50.1 44.99 10.49 39.52 190 102 50   FMP 603 -- -- -- 4.0 2.05 50 120
  ZrOxNy Zr 3870 3.3 43.1 -- 67.5 8.3 -- 7.0 48.4 46.22 10.02 43.76 200
 100 43   FMP 595 -- -- -- 4.0 1.94 50 121  ZrOxNy Zr 3860 3.3 44.2 --
 67.5 8.3 -- 7.0 51.1 50.70 10.52 38.78 200 100 49   FMP 600 -- -- -- 4.0
 1.90 50 122  ZrOxNy Zr 3860 3.3 43.4 -- 67.5 8.3 -- 7.0 50.8 47.10 8.81
 44.09 220 100 46   FMP 600 -- -- -- 4.0 1.89 50 123  ZrOxNy Zr 3860 3.3
 43.5 -- 67.5 8.3 -- 7.0 52.0 52.82 9.97 37.20 220 100 51   FMP 602 -- --
 -- 4.0 1.88 50 124  ZrOxNy Zr 3990 3.3 43.8 -- 67.5 8.3 -- 7.0 51.5
 51.17 10.85 37.98 200 100 51   FMP 546 -- -- -- 4.0 1.93 50