Patent Publication Number: US-2004043314-A1

Title: Organophotoreceptors with a fluoran-based compound

Description:
CROSS REFERNCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS  
     [0001] This application claims priority to copending U.S. Provisional Application serial No. 60/407,029 filed on Aug. 30, 2002 to Jubran et al., entitled “Electrophotographic Organophotoreceptors With Novel Electron Transport Compounds,” incorporated herein by reference. 
    
    
     
       FIELD OF THE INVENTION  
       [0002] This invention relates to organophotoreceptors suitable for use in electrophotography and, more specifically, to an organophotoreceptors having a fluoran-based compound, i.e., a compound with a fluoran central nucleus, which generally can be useful as an electron transport compound.  
       BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION  
       [0003] In electrophotography, an organophotoreceptor in the form of a plate, disk, sheet, belt, drum or the like having an electrically insulating photoconductive element on an electrically conductive substrate is imaged by first uniformly electrostatically charging the surface of a photoconductive element, and then exposing the charged surface to a pattern of light. The light exposure selectively dissipates the charge in the illuminated areas where light strikes the surface, thereby forming a pattern of charged and uncharged areas referred to as a latent image. A liquid toner or solid toner can then be provided in the vicinity of the latent image, and toner droplets or particles can be deposited in either the charged or uncharged areas depending on the properties of the toner to create a toned image on the surface of the photoconductive element. The resulting toned image can be transferred to a suitable ultimate or intermediate receiving surface, such as paper, or the photoconductive element can operate as the ultimate receptor for the image. The imaging process can be repeated many times to complete a single image, which can involve, for example, overlying images of distinct color components or effecting shadow images to complete a full color complete image, and/or to reproduce additional images.  
       [0004] Both single layer and multilayer photoconductive elements have been used. In the single layer embodiment, charge generating compound and a charge transport material selected from the group consisting of a charge transport compound, an electron transport compound, and a combination of both are combined with a polymeric binder and then deposited on the electrically conductive substrate. In the multilayer embodiments based on a charge transport compound, the charge transport compound and charge generating compound are in the form of separate layers, each of which can optionally be combined with a polymeric binder, deposited on the electrically conductive substrate. Two arrangements are possible. In one arrangement (the “dual layer” arrangement), the charge generating layer is deposited on the electrically conductive substrate and the charge transport layer is deposited on top of the charge generating layer. In an alternate arrangement (the “inverted dual layer” arrangement), the order of the charge transport layer and charge generating layer is reversed.  
       [0005] In both the single and multilayer photoconductive elements, the purpose of the charge generating material is to generate charge carriers (i.e., holes and/or electrons) upon exposure to light. The purpose of the charge transport material is to accept these charge carriers and transport them through the charge transport layer in order to discharge a surface charge on the photoconductive element. The charge transport material can be a charge transport compound, an electron transport compound, or a combination of both. When a charge transport compound is used, the charge transport compound accepts the hole carriers and transports them through the layer in which the charge transport compound is located. When an electron transport compound is used, the electron transport compound accepts the electron carriers and transports them through the layer in which the electron transport compound is located.  
       SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION  
       [0006] In a first aspect, the invention pertains to an organophotoreceptor comprising a) a fluoran compound having the generic formula represented by the central nucleus of the following formula;  
                 
 
       [0007] (b) a polymer binder in which the fluoran compound is bound;  
       [0008] (c) a charge generating compound; and  
       [0009] (d) an electrically conductive substrate having a surface on which the fluoran compound, the polymer binder and charge generating compound are located. In some embodiments, the organophotoreceptor further comprises a charge transport compound. The organophotoreceptor can comprise one or a plurality of layers (generally polymer based layers), as described further below.  
       [0010] The organophotoreceptor may be provided, for example, in the form of a plate, a flexible belt, a flexible disk, a sheet, a rigid drum, or a sheet around a rigid or compliant drum. In one embodiment, the organophotoreceptor includes: (a) a photoconductive layer comprising the charge transport compound, the charge generating compound, the electron transport compound, and a polymeric binder; and (b) the electrically conductive substrate.  
       [0011] In a second aspect, the invention features an electrophotographic imaging apparatus that includes (a) a light imaging component; and (b) the above-described organophotoreceptor oriented to receive light from the light imaging component. In some embodiments, the electrophotographic imaging apparatus further comprises flexible roller and an organophotoreceptor in the form of a flexible belt threaded around the support rollers. The apparatus can further comprise a toner dispenser, which can be a liquid tomer dispenser. A method of electrophotographic imaging with photoreceptors containing these fluoran compounds is also described.  
       [0012] In a third aspect, the invention features an electrophotographic imaging process that includes (a) applying an electrical charge to a surface of the above-described organophotoreceptor; (b) imagewise exposing the surface of the organophotoreceptor to radiation to dissipate charge in selected areas and thereby form a pattern of at least relatively charged and uncharged areas on the surface; (c) contacting the surface with a toner to create a toned image; and (d) transferring the toned image to a substrate. The toner can comprise a liquid toner or a dry toner that includes a dispersion of colorant particles in an organic liquid.  
       [0013] In a fourth aspect, the invention features an electron transport material having the above Formula (I).  
       [0014] The invention provides suitable electron transport materials for organophotoreceptors featuring a combination of good mechanical and electrostatic properties. These photoreceptors can be used successfully with toners, such as liquid toners, to produce high quality images. The high quality of the imaging system can be maintained after repeated cycling.  
       [0015] Other features and advantages of the invention will be apparent from the following description of the specific embodiments thereof, and from the claims. 
     
    
    
     BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS  
     [0016]FIG. 1 is a schematic side view of an organophotoreceptor with a photoconductive layer on an electrically conductive substrate.  
     [0017]FIG. 2 is a schematic side view of an organophotoreceptor with a charge generating layer and a charge transport layer sequentially on an electrically conductive substrate.  
     [0018]FIG. 3 is a schematic side view of an organophotoreceptor with a charge transport layer and a charge generating layer sequentially on an electrically conductive substrate.  
     [0019]FIG. 4 is a schematic side view of an organophotoreceptor with a charge transport layer, a charge generating layer and an electron transport layer sequentially on an electrically conductive substrate.  
     [0020]FIG. 5 is a schematic side view of an organophotoreceptor with an electron transport layer, a charge generating layer and a charge transport layer sequentially on an electrically conductive substrate.  
    
    
     DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS  
     [0021] Organophotoreceptors described herein comprise an electron transport compound having a formula represented by a generic formula with the central nucleus of the following formula:  
                 
 
     [0022] The compound in the above formula is fluoran and derivatives of this compound (i.e. compounds with this central nucleus) are referred to as fluoran compounds. With respect to the central nucleus shown in this formula, substitution is liberally allowed on the central nucleus to effect various physical effects on the properties of the compounds, such as mobility, solubility, stability, and the like, including, for example, substitutions known in the art to effect particular modifications. Suitable electron transport compounds also include stereo-isomeric variations since the placement of substituents onto the central nucleus can break the symmetry such that different stereo-isomers can be formed.  
     [0023] Fluoran compounds are well established as color formers in heat sensitive and color sensitive recording materials. Thus, the compounds can be used in carbonless copy paper and other copy papers and materials based on heat or pressure to produce a color change. Due to its application as a color former, a range of fluoran compositions are commercially available and/or producable by published synthesis approaches, as described further below.  
     [0024] Improved organophotoreceptor comprise an electron transport compound within at least one layer of the structure. The layer with the electron transport compound can also comprise a polymeric binder, a charge transport compound, a UV light stabilizer, and/or a charge generating compound. In general, the organophotoreceptor comprises an electrically conductive substrate having a photoconductive element on a surface of the electrically conductive substrate in which the photoconductive element can include one or more layers, i.e., sublayers, within its structure. One or more of the layers of the photoconductor may include an electron transport compound.  
     [0025] The organophotoreceptors can have a high V acc , a low V dis , and high stabilities with respect to cycling testing, crystallization, bending and stretching. The organophotoreceptors are particularly useful in laser printers and the like as well as photocopiers, scanners, other electronic devices based on electrophotography, and a combination thereof. The use of these organophotoreceptors is described in more detail below in the context of laser printer use, although their application in other devices operating by electrophotography can be generalized from the discussion below.  
     [0026] To produce high quality images, particularly after multiple cycles, it is desirable for the compounds of the organophotoreceptor to form a homogeneous solution with the polymeric binder and remain approximately homogeneously distributed through the organophotoreceptor material during the cycling of the material. In addition, to produce high quality images, it is desirable to increase the amount of charge that the organophotoreceptor can accept (indicated by a parameter known as the acceptance voltage or “V acc ”) and to reduce retention of that charge upon discharge (indicated by a parameter known as the discharge voltage or “V dis ”).  
     [0027] Electron transport compounds have an appropriate ability to transport electrons, in contrast with charge transport compounds, which are generally more effective at transporting holes, i.e., positive charges. In electrophotography applications, a charge generating compound within an organophotoreceptor absorbs light to form electron-hole pairs. The electron and/or hole can be transported over an appropriate time frame under a large electric field to discharge locally a surface charge that is generating the field. The discharge of the field at a particular location results in a surface charge pattern that essentially matches the pattern drawn with the light. This charge pattern then can be used to guide toner deposition. To print a two dimensional image using the organophotoreceptor, the organophotoreceptor has a two dimensional surface for forming at least a portion of the image. The imaging process then continues by cycling the organophotoreceptor to complete the formation of the entire image and/or for the processing of subsequent images.  
     [0028] The organophotoreceptor may be provided in the form of a plate, a flexible belt, a disk, a rigid drum, a sheet around a rigid or compliant drum, or the like. The charge transport compound and/or the electron transport compound can be in the same layer as the charge generating compound and/or in a different layer from the charge generating compound. For example, the electron transport compound may be in an overcoat layer. In some embodiments, the organophotoreceptor material has a single layer with both a charge transport compound and a charge generating compound within a polymeric binder. In further embodiments, a charge transport compound can be in a charge transport layer distinct from the charge generating layer. For embodiments with an improved overcoat layer described herein, the charge transport layer generally is intermediate between the charge generating layer and the electrically conductive substrate. Alternatively, the charge generating layer may be intermediate between the charge transport layer and the electrically conductive substrate. Additional layers can be used also, as described further below.  
     [0029] The organophotoreceptors can be incorporated into an electrophotographic imaging apparatus, such as laser printers. In these devices, an image is formed from physical embodiments and converted to a light image that is scanned onto the organophotoreceptor to form a surface latent image. The surface latent image can be used to attract toner onto the surface of the organophotoreceptor, in which the toner image is the same or the negative of the light image projected onto the organophotoreceptor. The toner can be a liquid toner or a dry toner. The toner can be subsequently transferred, from the surface of the organophotoreceptor, to a receiving surface, such as a sheet of paper. After the transfer of the toner, the entire surface is discharged, and the material is ready to cycle again. The imaging apparatus can further comprise, for example, a plurality of support rollers for transporting a paper receiving medium and/or for movement of the photoreceptor, a light imaging component with suitable optics to form the light image, a light source, such as a laser, a toner source and delivery system and an appropriate control system.  
     [0030] An electrophotographic imaging process generally can comprise (a) applying an electrical charge to a surface of the above-described organophotoreceptor; (b) imagewise exposing the surface of the organophotoreceptor to radiation to dissipate charge in selected areas and thereby form a pattern of charged and uncharged areas on the surface; (c) exposing the surface with a toner, such as a liquid toner that includes a dispersion of colorant particles in an organic liquid to create a toner image, to attract toner to the charged or discharged regions of the organophotoreceptor; and (d) transferring the toner image to a substrate.  
     [0031] In describing chemicals by structural formulae and group definitions, certain terms are used in a nomenclature format that is chemically acceptable. The terms “group,” “moiety,” “central nucleus” and “derivatives” can have particular meanings. The term “group” indicates that the generically recited chemical material (e.g., alkyl group, phenyl group, fluorenylidene malonitrile group, carbazole hydrazone group, etc.) may have any substituent thereon which is consistent with the bond structure of that group. Thus, the term ‘group’ allows for the presence of further substitution on the named class of materials, as long as the substitutent is still recognizable as within the generic class. For example, alkyl group includes, for example, unsubstituted liner, branched and cyclic alkyls, such as methyl, ethyl, isopropyl, tert-butyl, cyclohexyl, dodecyl and the like, and also includes such substituted alkyls such as chloromethyl, dibromoethyl, 1,3-dicyanopropyl, 1,3,5-trihydroxyhexyl, 1,3,5-trifluorocyclohexyl, 1-methoxy-dodecyl, phenylpropyl and the like. However, as is consistent with such nomenclature, no substitution would be included within the term that would alter the fundamental bond structure of the underlying group. For example, where a phenyl ring group is recited, substitution such as 1-hydroxyphenyl, 2,4-fluorophenyl, orthocyanophenyl, 1,3,5-trimethoxyphenyl and the like would be acceptable within the terminology, while substitution of 1,1,2,2,3,3-hexamethylphenyl would not be acceptable as that substitution would require the ring bond structure of the phenyl group to be altered to a non-aromatic form because of the substitution. Where the term moiety is used, such as alkyl moiety or phenyl moiety, that terminology indicates that the chemical material is not substituted. For example, the term alkyl moiety represents only an unsubstituted alkyl hydrocarbon group, whether branched, straight chain, or cyclic. Where the term derivative is used, that terminology indicates that a compound is derived or obtained from another and containing essential elements of the parent substance.  
     [0032] In addition, where the term a “central nucleus of the formula” is used and a structural formula is shown, any substituent may be provided on that formula of the compound, as long as the substitution does not alter the underlying bond structure of the formula (e.g., by require a double bond to be converted to a single bond, or opening a ring group, or dropping a described substituent group in the formula). Thus, a central nucleus is similar to a group in that substitutions are allowed to the extent that the underlying bond structure is not altered, except that the central nucleus generally is used to refer to the central core of the compound, while the term group tends to refer to a substituent bonded to a core of the compound.  
     [0033] Organophotoreceptors  
     [0034] The organophotoreceptor may be, for example, in the form of a plate, a sheet, a flexible belt, a disk, a rigid drum, or a sheet around a rigid or compliant drum, with flexible belts and rigid drums generally being used in commercial embodiments. The organophotoreceptor may comprise, for example, an electrically conductive substrate and a photoconductive element in the form of one or more layers. The organophotoreceptor generally comprises both a charge transport compound and a charge generating compound in a polymeric binder, which may or may not be in the same layer. Similarly, the electron transport compound may or may not be in the same layer with the charge generating compound. If the electron transport compound is in a different layer from the charge generating compound, the electron transport compound can be an overcoat, i.e., on the side opposite the electrically conductive substrate, or an undercoat, on the same side of the charge generating layer as the electrically conductive substrate. In some embodiments, a layer with the electron transport compound can further include an ultraviolet light stabilizer.  
     [0035] With respect to the charge generation compound and the charge transport compound, in some embodiments with a single layer construction, the charge transport compound and the charge generating compound are in a single layer. In other embodiments, however, the photoconductive element comprises a bilayer construction featuring a charge generating layer and a separate charge transport layer. The charge generating layer may be located intermediate between the electrically conductive substrate and the charge transport layer. Alternatively, the photoconductive element may have a structure in which the charge transport layer is intermediate between the electrically conductive substrate and the charge generating layer.  
     [0036] Based on the three basic structures of the charge generating layer and the charge transport layer, the structure of the organophotoreceptor can be generalized to account for the presence of an electron transport compound. For example, for embodiments in which the electron transport compound is in the same layer as the charge generating compound, there are three possible structures shown schematically in FIGS.  1 - 3 . Referring to FIG. 1, organophotoreceptor  100  comprises an electrically conductive substrate  102  and a photoconductive layer  104  comprising a charge generating compound, a charge transport compound and an electron transport compound. Referring to FIG. 2, organophotoreceptor  110  comprises an electrically conductive substrate  112 , a charge generating layer  114  comprising a charge generating compound and an electron transport compound, and charge transport layer  116  comprising a charge transport compound. Referring to FIG. 3, organophotoreceptor  120  comprises an electrically conductive substrate  122 , a charge transport layer  124  comprising a charge transport compound and a charge generating layer  126  comprising a charge generating compound and an electron transport compound.  
     [0037] For embodiments in which the electron transport compound is in a different layer than the charge generating compound, there are two structures of primary interest, which are shown in FIGS. 4 and 5. Referring to FIG. 4, organophotoreceptor  130  comprises an electrically conductive substrate  132 , a charge transport layer  134  comprising a charge transport compound, a charge generating layer  136  comprising a charge generating compound, and an electron transport layer  138  comprising an electron transport compound. Referring to FIG. 5, organophotoreceptor  150  comprises an electrically conductive substrate  152 , an electron transport layer  154  comprising an electron transport compound, a charge generating layer  156  comprising a charge generating compound, and a charge transport layer  158  comprising a charge transport compound.  
     [0038] While the embodiments of FIGS.  1 - 5  have electron transport compound in a single layer, multiple layers can comprise an electron transport compound. In particular, an electron transport layer and a charge generating layer can both comprises an electron transport compound. Furthermore, the organophotoreceptor structures shown in FIGS.  1 - 5  can further comprise additional undercoat and/or overcoat layers such as those described further below. In addition, other layered organophotoreceptor structures can be formed beyond the embodiments of particular interest shown in FIGS.  1 - 5 , and these additional structures can have different layer ordering and/or multiple layers of the types described with or without different compositions.  
     [0039] The electrically conductive substrate, along with electrically insulating substrate  108 , may be flexible, for example in the form of a flexible web or a belt, or inflexible, for example in the form of a drum. A drum can have a hollow cylindrical structure that provides for attachment of the drum to a drive that rotates the drum during the imaging process. Typically, the combined substrate comprises an electrically insulating substrate and a thin layer of electrically conductive material as the electrically conductive substrate onto which the photoconductive material is applied.  
     [0040] The electrically insulating substrate may be paper or a film forming polymer such as a polyester, e.g., polyethylene terephthalate or polyethylene naphthalate, a polyimide, a polysulfone, a polyolefin, e.g., polyethylene or polypropylene, a nylon, a polycarbonate, a polyvinyl fluoride, a polystyrene, suitable copolymers thereof, mixtures thereof and the like. Specific examples of polymers for supporting substrates include, for example, polyethersulfone (Stabar™ S-100, available from ICI), polyvinyl fluoride (Tedlar®, available from E. I. DuPont de Nemours &amp; Company), polybisphenol-A polycarbonate (Makrofol™, available from Mobay Chemical Company) and amorphous polyethylene terephthalate (Melinar™, available from ICI Americas, Inc.). The electrically conductive materials, generally in the form of a coated layer, may comprise graphite, dispersed carbon black, iodide, conductive polymers, such as polypyroles and Calgon® conductive polymer 261 (commercially available from Calgon Corporation, Inc., Pittsburgh, Pa.), metals, such as aluminum, titanium, chromium, brass, gold, copper, palladium, nickel, stainless steel or alloys thereof, a metal oxide such as tin oxide or indium oxide, or combinations thereof. In embodiments of particular interest, the electrically conductive material is aluminum. Generally, the photoconductor substrate has a thickness adequate to provide the required mechanical stability. For example, flexible web substrates generally have a thickness from about 0.01 to about 1 mm, while drum substrates generally have a thickness from about 0.5 mm to about 2 mm. The charge generating compound is a material, such as a dye or pigment, which is capable of absorbing light to generate charge carriers. Non-limiting examples of suitable charge generating compounds include, for example, metal-free phthalocyanines (e.g., CGM-X01 available from Sanyo Color Works, Ltd.), metal phthalocyanines such as titanium phthalocyanine, copper phthalocyanine, oxytitanium phthalocyanine (also referred to as titanyl oxyphthalocyanine, and including any crystalline phase or mixtures of crystalline phases that can act as a charge generating compound), hydroxygallium phthalocyanine, squarylium dyes and pigments, hydroxy-substituted squarylium pigments, perylimides, polynuclear quinones available from Allied Chemical Corporation under the trade name Indofast® Double Scarlet, Indofast® Violet Lake B, Indofast® Brilliant Scarlet and Indofast® Orange, quinacridones available from DuPont under the trade name Monastral™ Red, Monastral™ Violet and Monastral™ Red Y, naphthalene 1,4,5,8-tetracarboxylic acid derived pigments including the perinones, tetrabenzoporphyrins and tetranaphthaloporphyrins, indigo- and thioindigo dyes, benzothioxanthene-derivatives, perylene 3,4,9,10-tetracarboxylic acid derived pigments, polyazo-pigments including bisazo-, trisazo- and tetrakisazo-pigments, polymethine dyes, dyes containing quinazoline groups, tertiary amines, amorphous selenium, selenium alloys such as selenium-tellurium, selenium-tellurium-arsenic and selenium-arsenic, cadmium sulphoselenide, cadmium selenide, cadmium sulphide, and mixtures thereof. For some embodiments, the charge generating compound comprises oxytitanium phthalocyanine (e.g., any phase thereof), hydroxygallium phthalocyanine or a combination thereof.  
     [0041] There are many kinds of charge transport compounds available for electrophotography. For example, any charge transport compound known in the art can be used to form organophotoconductors described herein. Suitable charge transport compounds include, but are not limited to, pyrazoline derivatives, fluorene derivatives, oxadiazole derivatives, stilbene derivatives, hydrazone derivatives, carbazole hydrazone derivatives, triaryl amines, polyvinyl carbazole, polyvinyl pyrene, polyacenaphthylene, or multi-hydrazone compounds comprising at least two hydrazone groups and at least two groups selected from the group consisting of triphenylamine and heterocycles such as carbazole, julolidine, phenothiazine, phenazine, phenoxazine, phenoxathiin, thiazole, oxazole, isoxazole, dibenzo(1,4)dioxine, thianthrene, imidazole, benzothiazole, benzotriazole, benzoxazole, benzimidazole, quinoline, isoquinoline, quinoxaline, indole, indazole, pyrrole, purine, pyridine, pyridazine, pyrimidine, pyrazine, triazole, oxadiazole, tetrazole, thiadiazole, benzisoxazole, benzisothiazole, dibenzofuran, dibenzothiophene, thiophene, thianaphthene, quinazoline, cinnoline or combinations thereof. In some embodiments, the charge transport compound is a enamine stilbene compound such as MPCT-10, MPCT-38, and MPCT-46 from Mitsubishi Paper Mills (Tokyo, Japan).  
     [0042] A suitable electron transport composition for use in the appropriate layer or layers generally has an electron affinity that is large relative to potential electron traps while yielding an appropriate electron mobility in a composite with a polymer. In some embodiments, the electron transport composition has a reduction potential less than O 2 . In general, electron transport compositions are easy to reduce and difficult to oxidize while charge transport compositions generally are easy to oxidize and difficult to reduce. In some embodiments, the electron transport compounds have a room temperature, zero field electron mobility of at least about 1×10 −13  cm 2 /Vs, in further embodiments at least about 1×10 −10  cm 2 /Vs, in additional embodiments at least about 1×10 −9  cm 2 /Vs, and in other embodiments at least about 1×10 −6  cm 2 /Vs. A person of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that other ranges of electron mobility within the explicit ranges are contemplated and are within the present disclosure.  
     [0043] The electron transport compounds, as described herein, can be fluoran compounds, as described further below. One or more fluoran compounds can be used in a selected layer of the photoconductor as an electron transport compound(s), or the fluoran compound(s) can be used in combination with another non-fluoran electron transport compound. Non-limiting examples of suitable non-fluoran electron transport compounds include, for example, bromoaniline, tetracyanoethylene, tetracyanoquinodimethane, 2,4,7-trinitro-9-fluorenone, 2,4,5,7-tetranitro-9-fluorenone, 2,4,5,7-tetranitroxanthone, 2,4,8-trinitrothioxanthone, 2,6,8-trinitro-indeno4H-indeno[1,2-b]thiophene-4-one, and 1,3,7-trinitrodibenzothiophene-5,5-dioxide, (2,3-diphenyl-1-indenylidene)malononitrile, 4H-thiopyran-1,1-dioxide and its derivatives, such as 4-dicyanomethylene-2,6-diphenyl-4H-thiopyran-1,1-dioxide, 4-dicyanomethylene-2,6-di-m-tolyl-4H-thiopyran-1,1-dioxide, and unsymmetrically substituted 2,6-diaryl-4H-thiopyran-1,1-dioxide such as 4H-1,1-dioxo-2-(p-isopropyl phenyl)-6-phenyl-4-(dicyanomethylidene)thiopyran and 4H-1,1-dioxo-2-(p-isopropyl phenyl)-6-(2-thienyl)-4-(dicyanomethyl-idene)thiopyran, derivatives of phospha-2,5-cyclohexadiene, alkoxycarbonyl-9-fluorenylidene)malononitrile derivatives such as (4-n-butoxycarbonyl-9-fluorenylidene)malononitrile, (4-phenethoxycarbonyl-9-fluorenylidene) malononitrile, (4-carbitoxy-9-fluorenylidene)malononitrile, and diethyl(4-n-butoxy carbonyl-2,7-dinitro-9-fluorenylidene)-malonate, anthraquino dimethane derivatives such as 11,11,12,12-tetracyano-2-alkylanthraquinodimethane and 11,1 1-dicyano-12,12-bis(ethoxycarbonyl)anthraquinodimethane, anthrone derivatives such as 1-chloro-10-[bis(ethoxycarbonyl) methylene] anthrone, 1,8-dichloro-10-[bis(ethoxycarbonyl) methylene]anthrone, 1,8-dihydroxy-10-[bis(ethoxycarbonyl) methylene]anthrone, and 1-cyano-10-[bis(ethoxycarbonyl) methylene) anthrone, 7-nitro-2-aza-9-fluroenylidene-malononitrile, diphenoquinone derivatives, benzoquinone derivatives, naphtoquinone derivatives, quinine derivatives, tetracyanoethylenecyanoethylene, 2,4,8-trinitro thioxantone, dinitrobenzene derivatives, dinitroanthracene derivatives, dinitroacridine derivatives, nitroanthraquinone derivatives, dinitroanthraquinone derivatives, succinic anhydride, maleic anhydride, dibromo maleic anhydride, pyrene derivatives, carbazole derivatives, hydrazone derivatives, N,N-dialkylaniline derivatives, diphenylamine derivatives, triphenylamine derivatives, triphenylmethane derivatives, tetracyanoquinone dimethane, 2,4,5,7-tetranitro-9-fluorenone, 2,4,7-trinitro-9-dicyanomethylenene fluorenone, 2,4,5,7-tetranitroxanthone derivatives, 2,4,8-trinitrothioxanthone derivatives and combinations thereof.  
     [0044] An electron transport compound and a UV light stabilizer can have a synergistic relationship for providing desired electron flow within the photoconductor. The presence of the UV light stabilizers alters the electron transport properties of the electron transport compounds to improve the electron transporting properties of the composite. UV light stabilizers can be ultraviolet light absorbers or ultraviolet light inhibitors that trap free radicals.  
     [0045] UV light absorbers can absorb ultraviolet radiation and dissipate it as heat. UV light inhibitors are thought to trap free radicals generated by the ultraviolet light and after trapping of the free radicals, subsequently to regenerate active stabilizer moieties with energy dissipation. It has been discovered that UV stabilizers have a synergistic relationship with electron transport compounds to conduct electrons along the pathway established by the electric field in an organophotoreceptor during use. Thus, the particular advantages of the UV stabilizers are not their UV stabilizing abilities, although the UV stabilizing ability may be further advantageous in reducing degradation of the organophotoreceptor over time. While not wanting to be limited by theory, the synergistic relationship contributed by the UV stabilizers may be related to the electronic properties of the compounds, which contribute to the UV stabilizing function, further contribute to establishing electron conduction pathways in combination with the electron transport compounds. In particular, the improved organophotoreceptors demonstrate a more stable acceptance voltage V acc  with cycling. The improved synergistic performance of organophotoreceptors with layers comprising both an electron transport compound and a UV stabilizer are described further in copending U.S. patent application Ser. No. 10/425,333 filed on Apr. 28, 2003 to Zhu, entitled “Organophotoreceptor With A Light Stabilizer,” incorporated herein by reference.  
     [0046] Non-limiting examples of suitable light stablizer include hindered trialkylamines such as Tinuvin 144 and Tinuvin 292 (from Ciba Specialty Chemicals, Terrytown, N.Y.), hindered alkoxydialkylamines such as Tinuvin 123 (from Ciba Specialty Chemicals), benzotriazoles such as Tinuvan 328, Tinuvin 900 and Tinuvin 928 (from Ciba Specialty Chemicals), benzophenones such as Sanduvor 3041 (from Clariant Corp., Charlotte, N.C.), nickel compounds such as Arbestab (from Robinson Brothers Ltd, West Midlands, Great Britain), salicylates, cyanocinnamates, benzylidene malonates, benzoates, oxanilides such as Sanduvor VSU (from Clariant Corp., Charlotte, N.C.), triazines such as Cyagard UV-1164 (from Cytec Industries Inc., N.J.), polymeric sterically hindered amines such as Luchem (from Atochem North America, Buffalo, N.Y.). In some embodiments, the light stabilizer is selected from the group consisting of hindered trialkylamines having the following formula:  
                 
 
     [0047] where R 1 , R 2 , R 3 , R 4 , R 6 , R 7 , R 8 , R 10 , R 11 , R 12 , R 13 , R 14 , R 15  are, independently, hydrogen, alkyl group, or ester, or ether group; and R 5 , R 9 , and R 14  are, independently, alkyl group; and X is a linking group selected from the group consisting of —O—CO—(CH 2 ) m —CO—O— where m is between 2 to 20.  
     [0048] The polymer binder for any of the particular layers of the organophotoreceptor generally is capable of dispersing or dissolving the corresponding functional compounds, such as the electron transport composition, the charge transport compound, the charge generating compound and the UV light stabilizing compound. Examples of suitable polymer binders generally include, for example, polystyrene-co-butadiene, polystyrene-co-acrylonitrile, modified acrylic polymers, polyvinyl acetate, styrene-alkyd resins, soya-alkyl resins, polyvinylchloride, polyvinylidene chloride, polyacrylonitrile, polycarbonates, polyacrylic acid, polyacrylates, polymethacrylates, styrene polymers, polyvinyl butyral, alkyd resins, polyamides, polyurethanes, polyesters, polysulfones, polyethers, polyketones, phenoxy resins, epoxy resins, silicone resins, polysiloxanes, poly(hydroxyether) resins, polyhydroxystyrene resins, novolak, poly(phenylglycidyl ether)-co-dicyclopentadiene, copolymers of monomers used in the above-mentioned polymers, and combinations thereof. In some embodiments of particular interest, the binder is selected from the group consisting of polycarbonates, polyvinyl butyral, and a combination thereof. Examples of suitable polycarbonate binders include polycarbonate A which is derived from bisphenol-A, polycarbonate Z, which is derived from cyclohexylidene bisphenol, polycarbonate C, which is derived from methylbisphenol A, and polyestercarbonates. Examples of suitable of polyvinyl butyral are BX-1 and BX-5 form Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan. For a release layer, it may be desirable for the polymer to be, for example, a fluorinated polymer, siloxane polymer, fluorosilicone polymer, polysilane, polyethylene, polypropylene, polyacrylate, poly(methyl methacrylate-co-methacrylic acid), urethane resins, urethane-epoxy resins, acrylated-urethane resins, urethane-acrylic resins, crosslinked polymers thereof or a combination thereof.  
     [0049] Suitable optional additives for any one or more of the layers include, for example, antioxidants, coupling agents, dispersing agents, curing agents, surfactants and combinations thereof.  
     [0050] The photoconductive element overall typically has a thickness of from about 10 to about 45 microns. In the dual layer embodiments having a separate charge generating layer and a separate charge transport layer, charge generation layer generally has a thickness form about 0.5 to about 2 microns, and the charge transport layer has a thickness from about 5 to about 35 microns. In embodiments in which the charge transport compound and the charge generating compound are in the same layer, the layer with the charge generating compound and the charge transport composition generally has a thickness from about 7 to about 30 microns. In embodiments with a distinct electron transport layer, the electron transport layer has an average thickness from about 0.5 microns to about 10 microns and in further embodiments from about 1 micron to about 3 microns. In general, an electron transport overcoat layer can increase mechanical abrasion resistance, increases resistance to carrier liquid and atmospheric moisture, and decreases degradation of the photoreceptor by corona gases. A person of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that additional ranges of thickness within the explicit ranges above are contemplated and are within the present disclosure.  
     [0051] For the dual layer embodiments with a separate charge generating layer and a charge transport layer, the charge generation layer generally comprises a binder in an amount from about 10 to about 90 weight percent, in further embodiments from about 15 to about 80 weight percent and in some embodiments in an amount of from about 20 to about 75 weight percent, based on the weight of the charge generation layer. The optional electron transport compound in the charge generating layer, if present, generally can be in an amount of at least about 2.5 weight percent, in further embodiments from about 4 to about 30 weight percent and in other embodiments in an amount from about 10 to about 25 weight percent, based on the weight of the charge generating layer. The charge transport layer generally comprises a binder in an amount from about 30 weight percent to about 70 weight percent. A person of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that additional ranges of binder concentrations for the dual layer embodiments within the explicit ranges above are contemplated and are within the present disclosure.  
     [0052] For the embodiments with a single layer having a charge generating compound and a charge transport compound, the photoconductive layer generally comprises a binder, a charge transport compound and a charge generation compound. The charge generation compound can be in an amount of from about 0.05 to about 25 weight percent and in further embodiment in an amount of from about 2 to about 15 weight percent, based on the weight of the photoconductive layer. The charge transport compound can be in an amount from about 10 to about 80 weight percent, in other embodiments from about 25 to about 65 weight percent, in additional embodiments from about 30 to about 60 weight percent and in further embodiments in an amount of from about 35 to about 55 weight percent, based on the weight of the photoconductive layer, with the remainder of the photoconductive layer comprising the binder, and optionally additives, such as any conventional additives. A single layer with a charge transport composition and a charge generating compound generally comprises a binder in an amount from about 10 weight percent to about 75 weight percent, in other embodiments from about 20 weight percent to about 60 weight percent, and in further embodiments from about 25 weight percent to about 50 weight percent. Optionally, the layer with the charge generating compound and the charge transport compound may comprise an electron transport compound. The optional electron transport compound, if present, generally can be in an amount of at least about 2.5 weight percent, in further embodiments from about 4 to about 30 weight percent and in other embodiments in an amount from about 10 to about 25 weight percent, based on the weight of the photoconductive layer. A person of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that additional composition ranges within the explicit compositions ranges for the layers above are contemplated and are within the present disclosure.  
     [0053] The electron transport layer generally can comprise an electron transport compound, a binder and an optional UV light stabilizer. An overcoat layer comprising an electron transport compound is described further in copending U.S. patent application Ser. No. 10/396,536 to Zhu et al. entitled, “Organophotoreceptor With An Electron Transport Layer,” incorporated herein by reference. For example, an electron transport compound as described above may be used in the release layer of the photoconductors described herein. The electron transport compound in an electron transport layer can be in an amount from about 10 to about 50 weight percent, and in other embodiments in an amount from about 20 to about 40 weight percent, based on the weight of the electron transport layer. A person of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that additional ranges of compositions within the explicit ranges are contemplated and are within the present disclosure.  
     [0054] The UV light stabilizer in each of one or more appropriate layers of the photoconductor generally is in an amount from about 0.5 to about 25 weight percent and in some embodiments in an amount from about 1 to about 10 weight percent, based on the weight of the particular layer.  
     [0055] The photoconductive element may be formed in accordance with any appropriate technique known in the art, such as dip coating, spray coating, extrusion and the like. A person of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that additional ranges of compositions and thickness within the explicit ranges are contemplated and are within the present disclosure.  
     [0056] The photoreceptor may optionally have additional layers as well. Such additional layers can be, for example, a sub-layer and/or an additional overcoat layer. The sub-layer can be a charge blocking layer located between the electrically conductive substrate and the photoconductive element. The sub-layer may also improve the adhesion between the electrically conductive substrate and the photoconductive element.  
     [0057] Overcoat layers can be, for example, barrier layers, release layers, protective layers, and adhesive layers. With respect to overcoat layers, the photoreceptor can comprise a plurality of overcoat layers having an electron transport composition. For example, the release layer or the protective layer may contain an electron transport compound. One or more of the electron transport compounds described above may be used in the release layer or the protective layer.  
     [0058] The electron transport compound in the release layer or the protective layer generally can be in an amount of from about 2 to about 50 weight percent and in further embodiments in an amount of from about 10 to about 40 weight percent, based on the weight of the release layer or the protective layer. A person of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that additional ranges of composition within the explicit ranges are contemplated and are within the present disclosure. While an overcoat layer may or may not have an electron transport composition, the presence of an electron transport composition in each overcoat layer (which may or may not be the same composition as in other overcoat layers) can provide continuity of electrical conductivity between a charge generating layer and the surface, which may improve the performance of the organophotoreceptor.  
     [0059] The release layer or the protective layer forms the uppermost layer of the photoconductor layer. A release layer is a top layer that facilitates the transfer of toner from the organophotoreceptor to an intermediate transfer medium, such as a belt or drum, or to a receiving medium, such as paper, for example, when the toner transfer is not facilitated by electrostatic forces or magnetic forces. A release layer can have a lower surface energy than the surface energy of the medium to which the toner is transferred from the organophotoreceptor. The barrier layer may be sandwiched between the release layer and the photoconductive element or used to overcoat the photoconductive element. The barrier layer provides protection for abrasion and solvent resistance to the underlayers. A protective layer is a top layer that provides protection for abrasion and solvent resistance to the underlayers. A layer can be both a protective layer and a release layer. An adhesive layer locates and improves the adhesion between a charge generating layer and an overcoat layer or between two overcoat layers.  
     [0060] Suitable barrier layers include, for example, coatings such as crosslinkable siloxanol-colloidal silica coating and hydroxylated silsesquioxane-colloidal silica coating, and organic binders such as polyvinyl alcohol, methyl vinyl ether/maleic anhydride copolymer, cascin, polyvinyl pyrrolidone, polyacrylic acid, gelatin, starch, polyurethanes, polyimides, polyesters, polyamides, polyvinyl acetate, polyvinyl chloride, polyvinylidene chloride, polycarbonates, polyvinyl butyral, polyvinyl acetoacetal, polyvinyl formal, polyacrylonitrile, polymethyl methacrylate, polyacrylates, polyvinyl carbazoles, copolymers of monomers used in the above-mentioned polymers, vinyl chloride/vinyl acetate/vinyl alcohol terpolymers, vinyl chloride/vinyl acetate/maleic acid terpolymers, ethylene/vinyl acetate copolymers, vinyl chloride/vinylidene chloride copolymers, cellulose polymers, and mixtures thereof. The above barrier layer polymers optionally may contain small inorganic particles such as fumed silica, silica, titania, alumina, zirconia, or a combination thereof. Barrier layers are described further in U.S. Pat. No. 6,001,522 to Woo et al., entitled Barrier Layer For Photoconductor Elements Comprising “An Organic Polymer And Silica,” incorporated herein by reference.  
     [0061] The release layer topcoat may comprise, for example, any release layer composition known in the art. In some embodiments, the release layer is a fluorinated polymer, siloxane polymer, fluorosilicone polymer, polysilane, polyethylene, polypropylene, polyacrylate, poly(methyl methacrylate-co-methacrylic acid), urethane resins, urethane-epoxy resins, acrylated-urethane resins, urethane-acrylic resins, or a combination thereof. The release layers can comprise crosslinked polymers.  
     [0062] The protective layer protects the organophotoreceptor from chemical and mechanical degradation. The protective layer may comprise, for example, any protective layer composition known in the art. In some embodiments, the protective layer is a fluorinated polymer, siloxane polymer, fluorosilicone polymer, polysilane, polyethylene, polypropylene, polyacrylate, poly(methyl methacrylate-co-methacrylic acid), urethane resins, urethane-epoxy resins, acrylated-urethane resins, urethane-acrylic resins, or a combination thereof. In some embodiments, the protective layer comprises crosslinked polymers.  
     [0063] Generally, adhesive layers comprise a film forming polymer, such as polyester, polyvinylbutyral, polyvinylpyrolidone, polyurethane, polymethyl methacrylate, poly(hydroxy amino ether) and the like. Overcoat layers are described further in U.S. Pat. No. 6,180,305 to Ackley et al., entitled “Organic Photoreceptors For Liquid Electrophotography,” incorporated herein by reference.  
     [0064] Sub-layers can comprise, for example, polyvinylbutyral, organosilanes, hydrolyzable silanes, epoxy resins, polyesters, polyamides, polyurethanes, silicones and the like. In some embodiments, the sub-layer has a dry thickness between about 20 Angstroms and about 2,000 Angstroms. Sublayers containing metal oxide conductive particles can be 1-25 microns thick. A person of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that additional ranges of compositions and thickness within the explicit ranges are contemplated and are within the present disclosure.  
     [0065] The organophotoreceptors as described herein are suitable for use in an imaging process with either dry or liquid toner development including, for example, dry toners and liquid toners known in the art. Liquid toner development can be desirable because it offers the advantages of providing higher resolution images. Examples of suitable liquid toners are known in the art. Liquid toners generally comprise toner particles dispersed in a carrier liquid. The toner particles generally can comprise a colorant/pigment, a resin binder, and/or a charge director. In some embodiments of liquid toner, a resin to pigment ratio can be from 2:1 to 10:1, and in other embodiments, from 4:1 to 8:1. Liquid toners are described further in Published U.S. Patent Applications 2002/0128349, entitled “Liquid Inks Comprising A Stable Organosol,”  2002 / 0086916 , entitled “Liquid Inks Comprising Treated Colorant Particles,” and  2002 / 0197552 , entitled “Phase Change Developer For Liquid Electrophotography,” all three of which are incorporated herein by reference.  
     [0066] Fluoran-Based Electron Transport Compounds  
     [0067] Organophotoreceptors described herein comprise an electron transport compound having a formula represented by a generic formula with the central nucleus of the following formula:  
                 
 
     [0068] The compound in Formula (I) is fluoran and derivatives of this compound are referred to as fluoran compounds. With respect to the central nucleus shown in Formula (I), substitution is liberally allowed on the central nucleus to form various fluoran compounds. Variation of the substituents on the fluoran structure can result in various physical effects on the properties of the compounds, such as mobility, solubility, stability, spectral absorbance, dispersibility, and the like, including, for example, substitutions known in the art to effect particular modifications.  
     [0069] In general, the fluoran compound in Formula (I) can be substituted at any of 12 ring positions without altering the bond structure of the central nucleus. Subgeneric formulae that represent particular fluoran compounds within the practice of the present invention include, for example, the fluoran compounds represented by Formula (II),  
                 
 
     [0070] where R 1 , R 2 , R 3 , R 4 , R 5 , R 6 , R 7 , and R 8  are, independently, —NR 9 R 10 , —OR 11 , alkyl, aryl, halogen, CO 2 R 12 , hydrogen, or apart of cyclic orpolycyclic ring where R 9 , R 10 , R 11 , and R 12  are, independently, hydrogen, alkyl or aryl group.  
     [0071] When referring to fluorane compound by the terminology “having a central nucleus of the formula,” the compound or substitutent cited will include any substitution that does not substantively alter the chemical nature of the ring groups or other salient bond structures in the formula. For example, the terminology having a central nucleus of a fluoran ring would not include such alteration of the ring wherein aromaticity is removed by saturation of double bonds in the ring, while the addition of a long chain fatty acid group to replace a hydrogen atom on the fluoran ring would be included. For example, the terminology “having a central nucleus of the formula:  
                 
 
     [0072] would include any compound having the cited ring structure. The aromatic rings likewise may have any substituent that does not alter the internal bond structure shown. The double bond between the carbon and oxygen atom also could not be removed or converted to a single bond by additional substitution on the carbon and oxygen atoms. The disclosure is intended to enable and disclose that those rings may be so substituted, and the examples are not intended to limit the disclosure to only such unsubstituted materials. By merely providing the appropriate reagent, with substituents in the appropriate positions, the substituted final product may be provided in essentially the same chemical reaction, with only modest variations in conditions and/or solvents selected to be appropriate for those reagents and products.  
     [0073] Specific, non-limiting examples of suitable charge transport compounds within the general structure of the present invention have the following structures.  
                 
 
     [0074] The compound of Formula (2) is known as fluorescein.  
     [0075] While other electron transport compounds, besides fluoran compounds, are available, any particular electron transport compound can suffers some disadvantages in at least one of the various electrophotographic applications. Therefore, there is always a need for other electron transport compounds to meet the various requirements of electrophotographic applications.  
     [0076] With respect to the formation of fluoran compounds, several are commercially available due to their usefulness in recording materials. For example, Compounds (2) and (3) above are commercially available and others are described below in the examples. Furthermore, the synthesis of other fluoran compounds are described in the available literature. The representative synthesis of various fluoran compounds are described, for example, in U.S. Pat. No. 3,514,310 to Kimura et al., entitled “Pressure Sensitive Fluoran Derivative Copying Paper,” U.S. Pat. No. 3,624,107 to Lin, entitled “Nitro- And Amino-Substituted Fluorans,” U.S. Pat. No. 3,825,432 to Futaki et al., entitled “Heat Sensitive Recording Material,” U.S. Pat. No. 3,839,361 to Terayama et al., entitled “Dibenzylamino Fluoran Compounds,” U.S. Pat. No. 3,959,571 to Yahagi et al., entitled “Chromogenic Fluoran Derivatives And The Preparation And Use Thereof,” U.S. Pat. No. 5,149,689 to Zink et al., entitled “Fluoran Color Former Mixture And Use Thereof In Recording Materials, U.S. Pat. No. 5,395,948 to Zink et al., entitled “Fluoran Color Formers,” and U.S. Pat. No. 6,071,853, entitled “Crystalline Fluoran Compound,” all of which are incorporated herein by reference.  
     [0077] Organophotoreceptor (OPR) Preparation Methods  
     [0078] Conveniently, the photoconductive element may be formed by dispersing or dissolving the components, such as a charge generating compound, a charge transport compound, a light stabilizer, an electron transport compound, and/or a polymeric binder in organic solvent, coating the dispersion and/or solution on the respective underlying layer and drying the coating. In some embodiments, the components can be dispersed by high shear homogenization, ball-milling, attritor milling, high energy bead (sand) milling or other size reduction processes or mixing means known in the art for effecting particle size reduction in forming a dispersion. The coatings can be applied, for example, using knife coating, extrusion, dip coating or other appropriate coating approaches, including those known in the art. In some embodiments, a plurality of layers are applied as sequential coatings. The layers can be dried prior to the application of a subsequent layer. Some specific examples are presented below.  
     [0079] The invention will now be described further by way of the following examples.  
     EXAMPLES  
     [0080] In the following examples, organophotoreceptors are formed that incorporate electron transport materials. In comparative examples, (4-n-butoxycarbonyl-9-fluorenylidene) malononitrile is used as the electron transport compound. The synthesis of the comparative electron transport material is described next.  
     [0081] Preparation of (4-n-Butoxyvcarbonyl-9-fluorenylidene) Malononitrile  
     [0082] A 460 g quantity of concentrated sulfuric acid (4.7 moles, analytical grade, commercially obtained from Sigma-Aldrich, Milwaukee, Wis.) and 100 g of diphenic acid (0.41 mole, commercially obtained from Acros Fisher Scientific Company Inc., Hanover Park, Ill.) were added to a 1-liter 3-neck round bottom flask, equipped with a thermometer, mechanical stirrer and a reflux condenser. Using a heating mantle, the flask was heated to 135-145° C. for 12 minutes, and then cooled to room temperature. After cooling to room temperature, the solution was added to a 4-liter Erlenmeyer flask containing 3 liter of water. The mixture was stirred mechanically and was boiled gently for one hour. A yellow solid was filtered out hot, washed with hot water until the pH of the wash-water was neutral, and was air-dried overnight. The yellow solid was fluorenone-4-carboxylic acid. The yield was 75 g (80%). The product was then characterized. The melting point (m.p.) was found to be 223-224° C. A  1 H-NMR spectrum of fluorenone-4-carboxylic acid was obtained in d 6 -DMSO solvent with a 300 MHz NMR from Bruker Instrument. The peaks were found at (ppm) δ=7.39-7.50 (m, 2H); δ=7.79-7.70 (q, 2H); δ=7.74-7.85 (d, 1H); δ=7.88-8.00 (d, 1H); and δ=8.18-8.30 (d, 1H), where d is doublet, t is triplet, m is multiplet, dd is double doublet, q is quintet.  
     [0083] A 70 g (0.312 mole) quantity of fluorenone-4-carboxylic acid, 480 g (6.5 mole) of n-Butanol (commercially obtained from Fisher Scientific Company Inc., Hanover Park, Ill.), 1000 ml of Toluene and 4 ml of concentrated sulfuric acid were added to a 2-liter round bottom flask equipped with a mechanical stirrer and a reflux condenser with a Dean Stark apparatus. With aggressive agitation and refluxing, the solution was refluxed for 5 hours, during which ˜6 g of water were collected in the Dean Stark apparatus. The flask was cooled to room temperature. The solvents were evaporated and the residue was added, with agitation, to 4-liter of a 3% sodium bicarbonate aqueous solution. The solid was filtered off, washed with water until the pH of the wash-water was neutral, and dried in the hood overnight. The product was n-butyl fluorenone-4-carboxylate ester. The yield was 70 g (80%). A  1 H-NMR spectrum of n-butyl fluorenone-4-carboxylate ester was obtained in CDCl 3  with a 300 MHz NMR from Bruker Instrument. The peaks were found at (ppm) δ=0.87-1.09 (t, 3H); δ=1.42-1.70 (m, 2H); δ=1.75-1.88 (q, 2H); δ=4.26-4.64 (t, 2H); δ=7.29-7.45 (m, 2H); δ=7.46-7.58 (m, 1H); δ=7.60-7.68 (dd, 1H); δ=7.75-7.82 (dd, 1H); δ=7.90-8.00 (dd, 1H); δ=8.25-8.35 (dd, 1H).  
     [0084] A 70 g (0.25 mole) quantity of n-butyl fluorenone-4-carboxylate ester, 750 ml of absolute methanol, 37 g (0.55 mole) of malononitrile (commercially obtained from Sigma-Aldrich, Milwaukee, Wis.), 20 drops of piperidine (commercially obtained from Sigma-Aldrich, Milwaukee, Wis.) were added to a 2-liter, 3-neck round bottom flask equipped with a mechanical stirrer and a reflux condenser. The solution was refluxed for 8 hours, and the flask was cooled to room temperature. The orange crude product was filtered, washed twice with 70 ml of methanol and once with 150 ml of water, and dried overnight in a hood. This orange crude product was recrystalized from a mixture of 600 ml of acetone and 300 ml of methanol using activated charcoal. The flask was placed at 0° C. for 16 hours. The crystals were filtered and dried in a vacuum oven at 50° C. for 6 hours to obtain 60 g of pure (4-n-butoxycarbonyl-9-fluorenylidene) malononitrile. The melting point (m.p.) of the solid was found to be 99-100° C. A  1 H-NMR spectrum of (4-n-butoxycarbonyl-9-fluorenylidene) malononitrile was obtained in CDCl 3  with a 300 MHz NMR from Bruker Instrument. The peaks were found at (ppm) δ=0.74-1.16 (t, 3H); δ=1.38-1.72 (m, 2H); δ=1.70-1.90 (q, 2H); δ=4.29-4.55 (t, 2H); δ=7.31-7.43 (m, 2H); δ=7.45-7.58 (m, 1H); δ=7.81-7.91 (dd, 1H); δ=8.15-8.25 (dd, 1H); δ=8.42-8.52 (dd, 1H); δ=8.56-8.66 (dd, 1H).  
     Example 1  
     Preparation of Organophotoreceptors  
     [0085] This example describes the preparation of ten organophotoreceptors with fluoran compound and one comparative organophotoreceptor prepared with a comparative electron transport compound.  
     [0086] For the formation of the organophotoreceptors, the fluoran compounds were all obtained commercially. In particular, Compound (2) (Fluorescein) and Compound (3) (Rhodamine B base) were obtained from Aldrich Chemicals Co., Milwaukee, Wis. Compound (4) (Pergascript Orange I-G, an aminofluoran), Compound (5) (Pergascript Green I-2GN, an Diaminofluoran), Compound (6) (Pergascript Black I-R, an Diaminofluoran), and Compound (7) (Pergascript Black I-2R, an Diaminofluoran) were obtained from Ciba Specialty Chemicals Corporation, P.O. Box  2444 , High Point, N.C. All compounds were used as received from supplier without any further purification.  
     [0087] Comparative Sample A  
     [0088] Comparative Sample A was a single layer organophotoreceptor having a 76.2 micron (3 mil) thick polyester substrate with a layer of vapor-coated aluminum (commercially obtained from CP Films, Martinsville, Va.). The coating solution for the single layer organophotoreceptor was prepared by pre-mixing 2.4 g of 20 weight % (4-n-butoxycarbonyl-9-fluorenylidene)malononitrile in tetrahydrofuran, 6.66 g of 25 weight % MPCT-10 (a charge transfer material, commercially obtained from Mitsubishi Paper Mills, Tokyo, Japan) in tetrahydrofuran, 7.65 g of 12 weight % polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-1, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) in tetrahydrofuran. A 0.74 g quantity of a CGM mill-base containing 19 weight % of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine and a polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) at a weight ratio of 2.3:1 was then added to the above mixture. The CGM mill-base was obtained by milling 112.7 g of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine (commercially obtained from H.W. Sands Corp., Jupiter, Fla.) with 49 g of the polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5) in 651 g of methylethylketone on a horizontal sand mill (model LMC12 DCMS, commercially obtained from Netzsch Incorporated, Exton, Pa.) with 1-micron zirconium beads using recycle mode for 4 hours. After mixing on a mechanical shaker for ˜1 hour, the single layer coating solution was coated onto the substrate described above using a knife coater with a gap space of 94 micron followed by drying in an oven at 110° C. for 5 minutes.  
     [0089] Sample 1  
     [0090] Sample 1 was a single layer organophotoreceptor having a 76.2 micron (3 mil) thick polyester substrate with a layer of vapor-coated aluminum (commercially obtained from CP Films, Martinsville, Va.). The coating solution for the single layer organophotoreceptor was prepared by pre-mixing 2.4 g of 20 weight % (Compound 2) in tetrahydrofuran, 6.66 g of 25 weight % MPCT-10 (a charge transfer material, commercially obtained from Mitsubishi Paper Mills, Tokyo, Japan) in tetrahydrofuran, 7.65 g of 12 weight % polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-1, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) in tetrahydrofuran. A 0.74 g quantity of a CGM mill-base containing 19 weight % of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine and a polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) at a weight ratio of 2.3:1 was then added to the above mixture. The CGM mill-base was obtained by milling 112.7 g of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine (commercially obtained from H.W. Sands Corp., Jupiter, Fla.) with 49 g of the polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5) in 651 g of methylethylketone on a horizontal sand mill (model LMC12 DCMS, commercially obtained from Netzsch Incorporated, Exton, Pa.) with 1-micron zirconium beads using recycle mode for 4 hours. After mixing on a mechanical shaker for ˜1 hour, the single layer coating solution was coated onto the substrate described above using a knife coater with a gap space of 94 micron followed by drying in an oven at 110° C. for 5 minutes.  
     [0091] Sample 2  
     [0092] Sample 2 was a single layer organophotoreceptor having a 76.2 micron (3 mil) thick polyester substrate having a layer of vapor-coated aluminum (commercially obtained from CP Films, Martinsville, Va.). The coating solution for the single layer organophotoreceptor was prepared by pre-mixing 2.4 g of 20 weight % (Compound 3) in tetrahydrofuran, 6.66 g of 25 weight % MPCT-10 (a charge transfer material, commercially obtained from Mitsubishi Paper Mills, Tokyo, Japan) in tetrahydrofuran, 7.65 g of 12 weight % polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-1, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) in tetrahydrofuran. A 0.74 g quantity of a CGM mill-base containing 19 weight % of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine and a polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) at a weight ratio of 2.3:1 was then added to the above mixture. The CGM mill-base was obtained by milling 112.7 g of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine (commercially obtained from H.W. Sands Corp., Jupiter, Fla.) with 49 g of the polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5) in 651 g of methylethylketone on a horizontal sand mill (model LMC12 DCMS, commercially obtained from Netzsch Incorporated, Exton, Pa.) with 1-micron zirconium beads using recycle mode for 4 hours. After mixing on a mechanical shaker for 1 hour, the single layer coating solution was coated onto the substrate described above using a knife coater with a gap space of 94 micron followed by drying in an oven at 110° C. for 5 minutes.  
     [0093] Sample 3  
     [0094] Sample 3 was a single layer organophotoreceptor having a 76.2 micron (3 mil) thick polyester substrate having a layer of vapor-coated aluminum (commercially obtained from CP Films, Martinsville, Va.). The coating solution for the single layer organophotoreceptor was prepared by pre-mixing 2.4 g of 20 weight % (Compound 4) in tetrahydrofuran, 6.66 g of 25 weight % MPCT-10 (a charge transfer material, commercially obtained from Mitsubishi Paper Mills, Tokyo, Japan) in tetrahydrofuran, 7.65 g of 12 weight % polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-1, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) in tetrahydrofuran. A 0.74 g quantity of a CGM mill-base containing 19 weight % of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine and a polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) at a weight ratio of 2.3:1 was then added to the above mixture. The CGM mill-base was obtained by milling 112.7 g of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine (commercially obtained from H.W. Sands Corp., Jupiter, Fla.) with 49 g of the polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5) in 651 g of methylethylketone on a horizontal sand mill (model LMC12 DCMS, commercially obtained from Netzsch Incorporated, Exton, Pa.) with 1-micron zirconium beads using recycle mode for 4 hours. After mixing on a mechanical shaker for ˜1 hour, the single layer coating solution was coated onto the substrate described above using a knife coater with a gap space of 94 micron followed by drying in an oven at 110° C. for 5 minutes.  
     [0095] Sample 4  
     [0096] Sample 4 was a single layer organophotoreceptor having a 76.2 micron (3 mil) thick polyester substrate having a layer of vapor-coated aluminum (commercially obtained from CP Films, Martinsville, Va.). The coating solution for the single layer organophotoreceptor was prepared by pre-mixing 2.4 g of 20 weight % (Compound 5) in tetrahydrofuran, 6.66 g of 25 weight % MPCT-10 (a charge transfer material, commercially obtained from Mitsubishi Paper Mills, Tokyo, Japan) in tetrahydrofuran, 7.65 g of 12 weight % polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-1, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) in tetrahydrofuran. A 0.74 g quantity of a CGM mill-base containing 19 weight % of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine and a polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) at a weight ratio of 2.3:1 was then added to the above mixture. The CGM mill-base was obtained by milling 112.7 g of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine (commercially obtained from H.W. Sands Corp., Jupiter, Fla.) with 49 g of the polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5) in 651 g of methylethylketone on a horizontal sand mill (model LMC12 DCMS, commercially obtained from Netzsch Incorporated, Exton, Pa.) with 1-micron zirconium beads using recycle mode for 4 hours. After mixing on a mechanical shaker for ˜1 hour, the single layer coating solution was coated onto the substrate described above using a knife coater with a gap space of 94 micron followed by drying in an oven at 110° C. for 5 minutes.  
     [0097] Sample 5  
     [0098] Sample 5 was a single layer organophotoreceptor having a 76.2 micron (3 mil) thick polyester substrate having a layer of vapor-coated aluminum (commercially obtained from CP Films, Martinsville, Va.). The coating solution for the single layer organophotoreceptor was prepared by pre-mixing 2.4 g of 20 weight % (Compound 6) in tetrahydrofuran, 6.66 g of 25 weight % MPCT-10 (a charge transfer material, commercially obtained from Mitsubishi Paper Mills, Tokyo, Japan) in tetrahydrofuran, 7.65 g of 12 weight % polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-1, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) in tetrahydrofuran. A 0.74 g quantity of a CGM mill-base containing 19 weight % of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine and a polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) at a weight ratio of 2.3:lwas then added to the above mixture. The CGM mill-base was obtained by milling 112.7 g of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine (commercially obtained from H.W. Sands Corp., Jupiter, Fla.) with 49 g of the polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5) in 651 g of methylethylketone on a horizontal sand mill (model LMC12 DCMS, commercially obtained from Netzsch Incorporated, Exton, Pa.) with 1-micron zirconium beads using recycle mode for 4 hours. After mixing on a mechanical shaker for 1 hour, the single layer coating solution was coated onto the substrate described above using a knife coater with a gap space of 94 micron followed by drying in an oven at 110° C. for 5 minutes.  
     [0099] Sample 6  
     [0100] Sample 6 was a single layer organophotoreceptor having a 76.2 micron (3 mil) thick polyester substrate having a layer of vapor-coated aluminum (commercially obtained from CP Films, Martinsville, Va.). The coating solution for the single layer organophotoreceptor was prepared by pre-mixing 2.4 g of 20 weight % (Compound 7) in tetrahydrofuran, 6.66 g of 25 weight % MPCT-10 (a charge transfer material, commercially obtained from Mitsubishi Paper Mills, Tokyo, Japan) in tetrahydrofuran, 7.65 g of 12 weight % polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-1, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) in tetrahydrofuran. A 0.74 g quantity of a CGM mill-base containing 19 weight % of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine and a polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) at a weight ratio of 2.3:1 was then added to the above mixture. The CGM mill-base was obtained by milling 112.7 g of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine (commercially obtained from H. W. Sands Corp., Jupiter, Fla.) with 49 g of the polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5) in 651 g of methylethylketone on a horizontal sand mill (model LMC12 DCMS, commercially obtained from Netzsch Incorporated, Exton, Pa.) with 1-micron zirconium beads using recycle mode for 4 hours. After mixing on a mechanical shaker for ˜1 hour, the single layer coating solution was coated onto the substrate described above using a knife coater with a gap space of 94 micron followed by drying in an oven at 110° C. for 5 minutes.  
     [0101] Sample 7  
     [0102] Sample 7 was a single layer organophotoreceptor having a 76.2 micron (3 mil) thick polyester substrate having a layer of vapor-coated aluminum (commercially obtained from CP Films, Martinsville, Va.). The coating solution for the single layer organophotoreceptor was prepared by pre-mixing 1.2 g of 20 weight % (Compound 6) in tetrahydrofuran, 1.2 g of 20 weight % (Compound 7) in tetrahydrofuran, 6.66 g of 25 weight % MPCT-10 (a charge transfer material, commercially obtained from Mitsubishi Paper Mills, Tokyo, Japan) in tetrahydrofuran, 7.65 g of 12 weight % polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-1, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) in tetrahydrofuran. A 0.74 g quantity of a CGM mill-base containing 19 weight % of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine and a polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) at a weight ratio of 2.3:1 was then added to the above mixture. The CGM mill-base was obtained by milling 112.7 g of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine (commercially obtained from H.W. Sands Corp., Jupiter, Fla.) with 49 g of the polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5) in 651 g of methylethylketone on a horizontal sand mill (model LMCl2 DCMS, commercially obtained from Netzsch Incorporated, Exton, Pa.) with 1-micron zirconium beads using recycle mode for 4 hours. After mixing on a mechanical shaker for 1 hour, the single layer coating solution was coated onto the substrate described above using a knife coater with a gap space of 94 micron followed by drying in an oven at 110° C. for 5 minutes.  
     [0103] Sample 8  
     [0104] Sample 8 was a single layer organophotoreceptor having a 76.2 micron (3 mil) thick polyester substrate having a layer of vapor-coated aluminum (commercially obtained from CP Films, Martinsville, Va.). The coating solution for the single layer organophotoreceptor was prepared by pre-mixing 0.72 g of 20 weight % (Compound 6) in tetrahydrofuran, 1.68 g of 20 weight % (Compound 7) in tetrahydrofuran, 6.66 g of 25 weight % MPCT-10 (a charge transfer material, commercially obtained from Mitsubishi Paper Mills, Tokyo, Japan) in tetrahydrofuran, 7.65 g of 12 weight % polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-1, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) in tetrahydrofuran. A 0.74 g quantity of a CGM mill-base containing 19 weight % of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine and a polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) at a weight ratio of 2.3:1 was then added to the above mixture. The CGM mill-base was obtained by milling 112.7 g of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine (commercially obtained from H.W. Sands Corp., Jupiter, Fla.) with 49 g of the polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5) in 651 g of methylethylketone on a horizontal sand mill (model LMC12 DCMS, commercially obtained from Netzsch Incorporated, Exton, Pa.) with 1-micron zirconium beads using recycle mode for 4 hours. After mixing on a mechanical shaker for ˜1 hour, the single layer coating solution was coated onto the substrate described above using a knife coater with a gap space of 94 micron followed by drying in an oven at 110° C. for 5 minutes.  
     [0105] Sample 9  
     [0106] Sample 9 was a single layer organophotoreceptor having a 76.2 micron (3 mil) thick polyester substrate having a layer of vapor-coated aluminum (commercially obtained from CP Films, Martinsville, Va.). The coating solution for the single layer organophotoreceptor was prepared by pre-mixing 1.68 g of 20 weight % (Compound 6) in tetrahydrofuran, 0.72 g of 20 weight % (Compound 7), 6.66 g of 25 weight % MPCT-10 (a charge transfer material, commercially obtained from Mitsubishi Paper Mills, Tokyo, Japan) in tetrahydrofuran, 7.65 g of 12 weight % polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-1, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) in tetrahydrofuran. A 0.74 g quantity of a CGM mill-base containing 19 weight % of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine and a polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5, commercially obtained from Sekisui Chemical Co. Ltd., Japan) at a weight ratio of 2.3:1 was then added to the above mixture. The CGM mill-base was obtained by milling 112.7 g of titanyl oxyphthalocyanine (commercially obtained from H.W. Sands Corp., Jupiter, Fla.) with 49 g of the polyvinyl butyral resin (BX-5) in 651 g of methylethylketone on a horizontal sand mill (model LMC12 DCMS, commercially obtained from Netzsch Incorporated, Exton, Pa.) with 1-micron zirconium beads using recycle mode for 4 hours. After mixing on a mechanical shaker for ˜1 hour, the single layer coating solution was coated onto the substrate described above using a knife coater with a gap space of 94 micron followed by drying in an oven at 110° C. for 5 minutes.  
     Example 2  
     Electrostatic Testing and Properties of Organophotoreceptors  
     [0107] This example provides results of electrostatic testing on the organophotoreceptor samples formed as described in Example 1.  
     [0108] Electrostatic cycling performance of organophotoreceptors described herein with fluoran compounds can be determined using in-house designed and developed test bed that is capable of testing, for example, the sample strips wrapped around a 160 mm diameter drum. The results on these samples are indicative of results that would be obtained with other support structures, such as belts, drums and the like, for supporting the organophotoreceptors.  
     [0109] For testing using a 160 mm diameter drum, three coated sample strips, each measuring 50 cm long by 8.8 cm wide, are fastened side-by-side and completely around an aluminum drum (50.3 cm circumference). In some embodiments, at least one of the strips is a comparative example that is precision web coated and used as an internal reference point. In this electrostatic cycling tester, the drum rotated at a rate of 8.13 cm/sec (3.2 ips), and the location of each station in the tester (distance and elapsed time per cycle) is given as shown in the following table:  
               TABLE 1                          Electrostatic test stations around the       160 mm diameter drum at 8.13 cm/sec.                                     Total Distance,   Total Time,       Station   Degrees   cm   sec               Front erase bar edge    0°   Initial, 0 cm   Initial, 0 s       Erase Bar     0-7.2°     0-1.0     0-0.12       Scorotron Charger   113.1-135.3°   15.8-18.9   1.94-2.33       Laser Strike   161.0°   22.5   2.77       Probe #1   181.1°   25.3   3.11       Probe #2   251.2°   35.1   4.32       Erase bar   360°   50.3   6.19                  
 
     [0110] The erase bar is an array of laser emitting diodes (LED) with a wavelength of 720 nm that discharges the surface of the organophotoreceptor. The scorotron charger comprises a wire that permits the transfer of a desired amount of charge to the surface of the organophotoreceptor.  
     [0111] From the above table, the first electrostatic probe (Trek  344  electrostatic meter, Trek, Inc. Medina, N.Y.) is located 0.34 s after the laser strike station and 0.78 s after the scorotron while the second probe (Trek™ 344 electrostatic meter) is located 1.21 s from the first probe and 1.99 s from the scorotron. All measurements are performed at ambient temperature and relative humidity.  
     [0112] Electrostatic measurements were obtained as a compilation of several runs on the test station. The first three diagnostic tests (prodtest initial, VlogE initial, dark decay initial) are designed to evaluate the electrostatic cycling of a new, fresh sample and the last three, identical diagnostic test (prodtest final, VlogE final, dark decay final) are run after cycling of the sample. In addition, measurements were made periodically during the test, as described under “longrun” below. The laser is operated at 780 nm wavelength, 600 dpi, 50 micron spot size, 60 nanoseconds/pixel expose time, 1,800 lines per second scan speed, and a 100% duty cycle. The duty cycle is the percent exposure of the pixel clock period, i.e., the laser is on for the full 60 nanoseconds per pixel at a 100% duty cycle.  
     [0113] Electrostatic Test Suite:  
     [0114] 1) PRODTEST: Charge acceptance (V acc ) and discharge voltage (V dis ) were established by subjecting the samples to corona charging (erase bar always on) for three complete drum revolutions (laser off); discharged with the laser @ 780 nm &amp; 600 dpi on the forth revolution (50 urn spot size, expose 60 nanoseconds/pixel, run at a scan speed of 1,800 lines per second, and use a 100% duty cycle); completely charged for the next three revolutions (laser off); discharged with only the erase lamp @720 nm on the eighth revolution (corona and laser off) to obtain residual voltage (V res ); and, finally, completely charged for the last three revolutions (laser off). The contrast voltage (V con ) is the difference between V acc  and V dis  and the functional dark decay (V dd ) is the difference in charge acceptance potential measured by probes #1 and #2. 2) VLOGE: This test measures the photoinduced discharge of the photoconductor to various laser intensity levels by monitoring the discharge voltage of the sample as a function of the laser power (exposure duration of 50 ns) with fixed exposure times and constant initial potentials. This test measures the photoinduced discharge of the photoconductor to various laser intensity levels by monitoring the discharge voltage of the sample as a function of the laser power (exposure duration of 50 ns) with fixed exposure times and constant initial potentials. The functional photosensitivity, S780, and operational power settings can be determined from this diagnostic test.  
     [0115] 3) DARK DECAY: This test measures the loss of charge acceptance in the dark with time without laser or erase illumination for 90 seconds and can be used as an indicator of i) the injection of residual holes from the charge generation layer to the charge transport layer, ii) the thermal liberation of trapped charges, and iii) the injection of charge from the surface or aluminum ground plane.  
     [0116] 4) LONGRUN: The sample was electrostatically cycled for 100 or 4,000 drum revolutions according to the following sequence per each sample-drum revolution. The sample was charged by the corona, the laser was cycled on and off (80-100° sections) to discharge a portion of the sample and, finally, the erase lamp discharged the whole sample in preparation for the next cycle. The laser was cycled so that the first section of the sample was never exposed, the second section was always exposed, the third section was never exposed, and the final section was always exposed. This pattern was repeated for a total of 100 or 4,000 drum revolutions, and the data was recorded periodically, after every 5th cycle for the 100 cycle longrun or after every 50th cycle for the 4,000 cycle longrun.  
     [0117] 5) After the LONGRUN test, the PRODTEST, VLOGE, DARK DECAY diagnostic tests were run again.  
     [0118] The following Tables shows the results from the prodtest initial and prodtest final diagnostic tests. The values for the charge acceptance voltage (V acc , probe #1 average voltage obtained from the third cycle), discharge voltage (V dis , probe #1 average voltage obtained from the fourth cycle) are reported for the initial and final cycles.  
               TABLE 1                          Dry Electrostatic Test Results after 100 cycles.                             Prodtest Initial   Prodtest Final                                                                                 Dark                   Dark           Sample   V acc     V dis     V con     Sensitivity   Decay   V res     V acc     V dis     V con     Decay   V res                                                                       Sample 1   263   62   201   NA   38   36   82   37   45   16   25       Sample 2   472   149   323    94   77   49   495   225   270   54   95       Sample 3   643   76   567   269   34   37   410   60   350   40   35       Sample 4   619   82   537   251   21   37   386   63   323   31   35       Sample 5   612   84   528   251   19   40   445   70   375   30   38       Sample 6   629   78   551   290   31   40   486   70   416   36   40       Sample 7   615   90   525   251   23   42   514   81   433   30   42       Sample 8   677   87   590   269   29   41   544   76   468   38   40       Sample 9   630   94   536   236   19   44   496   81   415   29   43       Comparative   620   36   584   377   42   12   621   34   587   41   10       Sample A                  
 
     [0119]               TABLE 2                          Dry Electrostatic Test Results after 4000 cycles.                             Prodtest Initial   Prodtest Final                                                                                 Dark                   Dark           Sample   V acc     V dis     V con     Sensitivity   Decay   V res     V acc     V dis     V con     Decay   V res                                                                       Comparative   620   25   595   377   20   10   400   35   365   15   5       Sample A       Sample 5   596   78   519   236   24   34   450   72   378   54   31       Sample 6   606   79   527   314   29   42   429   65   368   53   31                    
     [0120] In the above table, the radiation sensitivity (Sensitivity at 780 nm in m 2 /J) of the xerographic process was determined from the information obtained during the VLOGE diagnostic run by calculating the reciprocal of the product of the laser power required to discharge the photoreceptor to ½ of its initial potential, the exposure duration, and 1/spot size.  
     [0121] As understood by those skilled in the art, additional substitution, variation among substituents, and alternative methods of synthesis and use may be practiced within the scope and intent of the present disclosure of the invention. The embodiments above are intended to be illustrative and not limiting. Additional embodiments are within the claims. Although the present invention has been described with reference to particular embodiments, workers skilled in the art will recognize that changes may be made in form and detail without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.