Patent Publication Number: US-6990955-B2

Title: Spark ignition engine

Description:
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 
   1. Field of the Invention 
   The present invention relates to a spark ignition engine in which a high RON fuel and a low RON fuel are mixed and supplied to a combustion chamber. 
   2. Description of the Related Art 
   The low RON fuel has a good ignition quality and a poor anti-knock quality, and the high RON fuel has a poor ignition quality and a good anti-knock quality. Accordingly, an engine, which is provided with a low RON fuel tank in which low RON fuel is stored and high RON fuel tank in which high RON fuel is stored, and the low RON fuel and the high RON fuel are mixed in accordance with operating conditions of the engine, and the mixture is supplied to a combustion chamber, is known. For example, Japanese Unexamined Patent Publication (Kokai) No. 2001-50070 disclosed such type engine. 
   In the above type engine, because of providing with two fuel tanks, there is a possibility that low RON fuel and high RON fuel may be improperly stored in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank. 
   For example, a possibility that the low RON fuel may be stored in both the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank, the high RON fuel may be stored in both the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank, or the low RON fuel and the high RON fuel may be stored in the high RON fuel tank and the low RON fuel tank, respectively. Consequently, fuel not suitable for an operating condition is injected and the engine performance cannot be fully obtained. 
   However, the apparatus disclosed in Japanese Unexamined Patent Publication (Kokai) No. 2001-50070 cannot detect the fuel storage failures described above. 
   SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
   The object of the present invention is to detect a fuel storage failure in a spark ignition engine provided with a low RON fuel tank to store a low RON fuel and a high RON fuel tank to store a high RON fuel, in which the fuels are injected into a combustion chamber at a mixing ratio in accordance with the state of operation of the engine. 
   According to the present invention, there is provided a spark ignition engine provided with a low RON fuel tank to store a low RON fuel and a high RON fuel tank to store a high RON fuel, in which the fuel in the low RON fuel tank and the fuel in the high RON fuel tank are injected into a combustion chamber, at a mixing ratio in accordance with the state of operation of the engine, comprising fuel mixing means for mixing the fuel from the high RON fuel tank and the fuel from the low RON fuel tank at a predetermined mixing ratio, so that the ratio of the fuel from the high RON fuel tank is increased as the load is increased and the ratio of the fuel from the low RON fuel tank is increased as the load is decreased; practical ignition timing determination means for determining a practical ignition timing based on the state of occurrence of knocking during a practical operation of the engine; and comparing ignition timing memory means for storing a comparing ignition timing with which the practical ignition timing is compared, wherein whether or not the low RON fuel and the high RON fuel are properly stored in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank, respectively, is judged based on differences between the comparing ignition timing and the practical ignition timing, at predetermined plural load values. 
   With the above structure of the spark ignition engine having the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank, whether or not the low RON fuel and the high RON fuel are properly stored in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank, respectively, is judged based on differences between the comparing ignition timing and the practical ignition timing, at plural load values. 
   In an aspect of the present invention, the comparing ignition timing memory means stores a base ignition timing which is set in parallel with a proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing representing a knocking occur ignition timing when the low RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel is stored in the high RON fuel tank, respectively, in relation to the load, and the practical ignition timing determination means determines that an ignition timing obtained by advancing an adjusting ignition advance angle from the base ignition timing to an actual knocking limit is identical to the practical ignition timing. 
   In an aspect of the present invention, it is judged that the low RON fuel and the high RON fuel are properly stored to the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank when differences between the base ignition timing and the practical ignition timing at different loads are identical, and it is judged that the low RON fuel and the high RON fuel are improperly stored to the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank when differences between the base ignition timing and the practical ignition timing at different loads are not identical. 
   In an aspect of the present invention, it is judged that the low RON fuel is stored both in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank when differences between the base ignition timing and the practical ignition timing at different loads are not identical. 
   In an aspect of the invention, the comparing ignition timing memory means stores the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing as a comparing ignition timing, and when differences between the base ignition timing and the practical ignition timing at different loads are not identical and judged that the low RON fuel and the high RON fuel are improperly stored to the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank, it is judged that the high RON fuel is stored both in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank when a difference between the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing and the practical ignition timing is decreased as the load is increased, and it is judged that the low RON fuel is stored in both the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank or the low RON fuel is stored in the high RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank when a difference between the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing and the practical ignition timing is increased as the load is increased. 
   In an aspect of the invention, the comparing ignition timing memory means stores the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing as a comparing ignition timing, and when differences between the base ignition timing and the practical ignition timing at different loads are not identical and judged that the low RON fuel and the high RON fuel are improperly stored to the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank, it is judged that the high RON fuel is stored both in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank when the practical ignition timing is more advanced than the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing, and it is judged that the low RON fuel is stored both in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank or the low RON fuel is stored in the high RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank when the practical ignition timing is more retarded than the proper mix fuel knocking-occur. 
   In an aspect of the invention, when it is judged that the low RON fuel is stored in both in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank or the low RON fuel is stored in the high RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank, it is judged that the low RON fuel is stored in the high RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank when a difference of differences between the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing and practical ignition timing at predetermined two load is greater than a predetermined threshold, and it is judged that the low RON fuel is stored both in the high RON fuel tank and the low RON fuel tank when a difference of differences between the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing and practical ignition timing at predetermined two load is less than a predetermined threshold. 
   In an aspect of the invention, when it is judged that the low RON fuel is stored both in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank or the low RON fuel is stored in the high RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank, it is judged that the low RON fuel is stored in the high RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank when a difference between the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing and practical ignition timing at a predetermined load is greater than a predetermined threshold, and it is judged that the low RON fuel is stored both in the high RON fuel tank and the low RON fuel tank when a difference between the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing and practical ignition timing at a predetermined load is less than a predetermined threshold. 
   In an aspect of the present invention, there is provided judgment result display means to display judgment results. With the above structure of the spark ignition engine, a driver can recognize whether or not the fuels are properly stored in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank. 
   The present invention may be more fully understood from the description of preferred embodiments of the invention set forth below, together with the accompanying drawings. 

   
     BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS 
       FIG. 1  shows a hardware structure of an embodiment of the present invention; 
       FIG. 2  is a diagram showing a setting of an ignition timing; 
       FIG. 3  is a diagram showing an ignition timing when a fuel is properly fueled; 
       FIG. 4  is a diagram showing an ignition timing when a low RON fuel is stored in both a low RON fuel tank and a high RON fuel tank; 
       FIG. 5  is a diagram showing an ignition timing when a high RON fuel is stored in both a low RON fuel tank and a high RON fuel tank; 
       FIG. 6  is a diagram showing an ignition timing when a high RON fuel is stored in a low RON fuel tank and a low RON fuel is stored in a high RON fuel tank; 
       FIG. 7  is a flowchart of a judgment of a storage in the embodiment; and 
       FIG. 8  is a flowchart of a judgment of a storage in a modification of the embodiment. 
   

   DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS 
   Embodiments of the present invention will be described below with reference to the accompanying drawings. 
     FIG. 1  is a schematic view of a structure of a hardware according to the present embodiment. In  FIG. 1 , a spark ignition engine  10  having spark plug  11  is mounted in a vehicle  100 . The engine  10  is provided with a low RON fuel tank  5  to which a low RON fuel should be fueled and a high RON fuel tank  7  to which a high RON fuel should be fueled. 
   The fuel in the low RON fuel tank  5  and the fuel in the high RON fuel tank  7  are supplied to fuel injectors  13   a ,  13   b  attached to an intake port  12  of a spark ignition engine (hereinafter simply referred to as “engine”)  10  having a spark plug  11  by a low RON fuel pump  5   a  and a high RON fuel pump  7   a , respectively. The fuel injectors  13   a ,  13   b  inject the low RON fuel and high RON fuel, at a predetermined ratio suitable for a driving condition, to the intake port  12 , based on a command from an electronic control unit (ECU)  20  and, then, the injected fuels are mixed in the intake port  12  and a combustion chamber. Therefore, fuel mixing means is composed of the fuel injectors  13   a ,  13   b , the ECU  20 , the intake port  12  and the combustion chamber. 
   In the present embodiment, the intake port  12  is provided with two fuel injectors  13   a ,  13   b . However, only one of the injectors may be an injector which can directly inject fuel into a cylinder, or an integral-type injector which can inject two fuels to the intake port  12  may be provided. 
   A crank angle sensor  10   a  to detect an engine speed and a knock sensor  10   b  to measure the state of occurrence of knocking are attached to the engine  10 . An airflow meter  14   a  to detect, as a load, an intake air quantity is attached to an intake pipe. The detected values of the sensors and the meter are sent to the ECU  20 . 
   Signals from the other sensors are sent to the ECU  20 , and signals are sent from the ECU  20  to control devices. However, signals that are not directly related to the present invention are omitted. 
   Ignition timing according to the present embodiment will be described with reference to  FIG. 2 . The upper portion in  FIG. 2  shows a mixing ratio of fuels supplied from the low RON fuel tank  5  and the high RON fuel tank  7  to the engine  10  in accordance with variations of a load at a same engine speed. As shown in the drawing, the mixing ratio is preset so that the fuel from the low RON fuel tank  5  is 100% at no-load, and the fuel from the high RON fuel tank  7  is 100% at full-load. 
   A one-dot chain line represents a line of a knocking-occur ignition timing at each load when the low RON fuel is stored in both the low RON fuel tank  5  and the high RON fuel tank  7 , so that only the low RON fuel is injected at any load. Hereinafter, this line is referred to as “low RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line”. 
   A two-dot chain line represents a line of a knocking occur ignition timing at each load when the high RON fuel is stored in both the low RON fuel tank  5  and the high RON fuel tank  7 , and only the high RON fuel is injected at any load. Hereinafter, this line is referred to as “high RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line”. 
   The low RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line is in parallel with the high RON fuel knocking-occurs ignition timing line. 
   A long dashed line represents a line of a knocking-occur ignition timing when the low RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank  5  and the high RON fuel is stored in the high RON fuel tank  7 , i.e., when the fuels are stored properly. Hereinafter, this line is referred to as “proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line”. The proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line comes closer to the high RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line as the load is increased, and coincides with the high RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line at the full-load. Contrary to this, the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line comes closer to the low RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line as the load is decreased, and coincides with the low RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line at the no-load. 
   A short dashed line represents a line of a knocking-occur ignition timing when the high RON fuel is accidentally stored in the low RON fuel tank and the low RON fuel is accidentally stored in the high RON fuel tank, i.e., when the fuels are completely reversely stored. Hereinafter, this line is referred to as “reverse mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line”. The reverse mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line comes closer to the low RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line as the load is increased, and coincides with the low RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line at the full-load. Contrary to this, the reverse mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line comes closer to the high RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line as the load is decreased, and coincides with the high RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line at the no-load. 
   A dotted line represents a line of a base ignition timing SAB, which is obtained by shifting in parallel the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line, by an amount corresponding to a safety band that is constant over the entire load area, toward the “retard” side. Hereinafter, this line is referred to as “base ignition timing line”. This base ignition timing line is determined on experimental results and memorized in the ECU  20  together with the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line. 
   A thin solid line is a MBT line representing a line of MBT (Minimum Spark Advance for Best torque) for a case in which fuels are properly stored. This MBT line is also determined on experimental results and memorized in the ECU  20  like as the base ignition timing line and proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line. 
   However, the low RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line, the high RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line, the reverse mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line are expected lines, and therefore not memorized in the ECU  20 . 
   During operation, an ignition is carried out at a practical ignition timing SA obtained by advancing the base ignition timing SAB to a knocking limit. This advancing operation is carried out by a so-called knocking control, in which the timing is advanced until a knock sensor  10   a  detects knocking, and when knocking is detected, the timing is retarded by a slight amount so as not to detect the knocking and the timing is advanced again until the knock sensor  10   a  detects the knocking and these operations are repeated. 
   The advance angle between the base ignition timing SAB and the practical ignition timing SA is referred to as “adjusting ignition advance angle” designated by DSA. Therefore, the relation is expressed by the following:
 
Practical ignition timing  SA =Base ignition timing  SAB +Adjusting ignition advance angle  DSA 
 
   However, the practical ignition timing is set to MBT (Minimum Spark Advance for Best Torque) when the MBT is more retarded than the knocking limit. 
   As described above, with regard to the correct or wrong of storage, there are four cases as follows. 
   Case A: The low RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank  5  and the high RON fuel is stored in the high RON fuel tank  7 , i.e., the fuels are stored properly. 
   Case B: The low RON fuel is stored in both the low RON fuel tank  5  and the high RON fuel tank  7 , i.e., the low RON fuel is accidentally stored in the high RON fuel tank  7 . 
   Case C: The high RON fuel is stored in both the low RON fuel tank  5  and the high RON fuel tank  7 , i.e., the high RON fuel is accidentally stored in the low RON fuel tank  5 . 
   Case D: The high RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank  5  and the low RON fuel is stored in the high RON fuel tank  7 , i.e., the high RON fuel and the low RON fuel are stored in wrong tanks. 
     FIG. 3  is an explanatory view of Case A, in which six ignition timing lines (the low RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line, the high RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line, the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line, the reverse mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line, and the MBT line), which are shown in  FIG. 2 , are shown. 
   The practical ignition timing SA coincides with the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing if the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing is more retarded than the MBT, and the practical ignition timing SA coincides with the MBT if the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing is more advanced than the MBT. Therefore, the practical ignition timing SA changes as shown by a thick solid line. 
   As described above, the base ignition timing SAB is obtained by shifting, by a predetermined amount corresponding to the safety band SAS, the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line toward the “retard” side, regardless of the load. Therefore, in Case A, the adjusting ignition advance angle DSA between the base ignition timing SAB and the practical ignition timing SA is constant in a zone where the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing is more retarded than the MBT, and is identical to the safety band SAS which is a shifting amount between the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line and the base ignition timing line. Therefore, the adjusting ignition advance angles DSA 1  and DSA 2  at load values L 1  and L 2  (L 1 &lt;L 2 ), preselected in a zone where the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing is more retarded than the MBT, are identical, i.e., DSA 1 =DSA 2 . 
     FIG. 4  is an explanatory view of Case B, in which only the low RON fuel is injected in a range from the no-load to the full-load, in a same engine speed, and six ignition timing lines shown in  FIG. 2 , are shown. 
   The practical ignition timing SA coincides with the low RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line if the low RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing is more retarded than the MBT, and the practical ignition timing SA coincides with the MBT if the low RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing is more advanced than the MBT. Therefore, the practical ignition timing SA changes as shown by a thick solid line. 
   The low RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line comes closer to the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line as the load is decreased. Therefore, in a comparison of the adjusting ignition advance angles DSA 1  and DSA 2  at load values L 1  and L 2  (L 1 &lt;L 2 ), preselected in a zone where the low RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing is more retarded than the MBT, DSA 1 &gt;DSA 2 . 
     FIG. 5  is an explanatory view of Case C, in which only the high RON fuel is injected in a range from the no-load to the full-load, in a same engine speed, and six ignition timing lines shown in  FIG. 2 , are shown. 
   The practical ignition timing SA coincides with the high RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line if the high RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing is more retarded than the MBT, and the practical ignition timing SA coincides with the MBT if the high RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing is more advanced than the MBT. Therefore, the practical ignition timing SA changes as shown by a thick solid line. 
   The high RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line comes closer to the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line as the load is decreased. Therefore, in a comparison of the adjusting ignition advance angles DSA 1  and DSA 2  at load values L 1  and L 2  (L 1 &lt;L 2 ), preselected in a zone where the high RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing is more retarded than the MBT, DSA 1 &gt;DSA 2 . 
     FIG. 6  is an explanatory view of Case D, in which the low RON fuel and the high RON fuel are mixed so that the ratio of the low RON fuel is increased and the ratio of the high RON fuel is decreased as the load is increased, and are injected, in a same engine speed. 
   In  FIG. 6 , six ignition timing lines shown in  FIG. 2  are shown. 
   The practical ignition timing SA coincides with reverse mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing if the reverse mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing is more retarded than the MBT, and the practical ignition timing SA coincides with the MBT if the reverse mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing is more advanced than the MBT. Therefore, the practical ignition timing SA changes as shown by a thick solid line. Therefore, in a comparison of the adjusting ignition advance angles DSA 1  and DSA 2  at load values L 1  and L 2  (L 1 &lt;L 2 ), preselected in a zone where the reverse mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing is more retarded than the MBT, DSA 1 &gt;DSA 2 . 
   As described above, in case A, DSA 1 =DSA 2 , and in Cases B, C and D, DSA 1 &gt;DSA 2 . Therefore, the storage can be judged to be case A (correct storing) when DSA 1 =DSA 2 , and the storage can be judged to be one of cases B, C, D (wrong storing) when DSA 1 ≠DSA 2 . However, it is not possible to determine a type of storage failure. 
   Then, the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing is introduced as a middle comparing ignition timing. The middle comparing ignition timing and the practical ignition timing SA are compared with each other at the load values L 1  and L 2 , and the differences therebetween at L 1  and L 2 , which are referred to as middle comparing ignition timing differences ESA 1  and ESA 2 , are compared. 
   In Case B, ESA 1 &lt;ESA 2  because the line of the practical ignition timing SA, i.e., the low RON fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line is more retarded than the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line, and comes closer to the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line as the load is decreased. 
   In Case C, ESA 1 &gt;ESA 2 , because the line for practical ignition timing SA, i.e., the high RON fuel knocking occur ignition timing line is more advanced than the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line, and comes closer to the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line as the load is increased. 
   In Case D, ESA 1 &lt;ESA 2 , because the line for practical ignition timing SA, i.e., the reverse mix fuel knocking occur ignition timing line is more retarded than the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line, and comes closer to the proper mix fuel knocking-occur ignition timing line as the load is decreased. 
   Accordingly, it can be said that, the storage is case C if ESA 1 &gt;ESA 2 , and the storage is case B or D if ESA 1 &lt;ESA 2 . 
   Or, it can be said that, the storage is case C if the practical ignition timing is more advanced than the proper mix fuel knocking occur ignition timing, and the storage is case B or D if the practical ignition timing is more retarded than the proper mix fuel knocking occur ignition timing. 
   By both ways, however, it is impossible to determine the storage to be case B or D. 
   Therefore, the storage is determined to be case B or D as follows. 
   The value of DSA in case B decreases more steeply as the load increases than in case D, i.e. difference between values of DSA at predetermined two load values in case B is greater than that of case D. 
   Therefore, calculate difference between values of DSA at predetermined two load values. Then compare the difference with a predetermined threshold A. Thus, storage is determined to be case B if the difference is greater than the threshold A, and storage is determined to be case D if the difference is smaller than the threshold A. 
   In this regard, if the L 1  and L 2  are predetermined the difference between values of two DSA can be obtained by calculation of DSA 1 −DSA 2 . This requires no further change of load only for this calculation, and then less calculation load is obtained. Therefore, L 1  and L 2  are predetermined in this embodiment. 
   The storage is determined to be case B or D also by as follows: 
   A value of DSA in case D is greater than a value of DSA in case D, if both values of DSA are obtained at same load. Therefore, calculate DSA and compare it with a predetermined threshold B. The storage is determined to be case D if value of DSA is greater than a predetermined threshold B, and the storage is determined to be case B if value of DSA is less than a predetermined threshold B. 
   In this case, if the L 1  and L 2  are predetermined, the DSA 1  can be compared with threshold B (or DSA 2  can be compared with threshold B′). 
   The control of a judgment for storage according to the present invention, based on the above concept, will be described with reference to a flowchart shown in  FIG. 7 . 
   In step  1 , data such as the adjusting ignition advance angles DSA 1 , DSA 2  at predetermined load values L 1 , L 2 , is read. In step  2 , whether or not DSA 1  is equal to DSA 2  is judged. If the judgment is affirmative in step  2 , the process goes to step  5  in which it is judged that the storage is Case A, i.e., a proper storage in which the low RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel is stored in the high RON fuel tank, and the process goes to step  9  and ends. 
   If the judgment is negative in step  2 , the process goes to step  3 . In step  3 , whether or not ESA 1 &lt;ESA 2 , or whether or not the practical ignition timing is more advanced than the proper mix fuel knocking occur ignition timing, is judged. If the judgment is affirmative in step  3 , the process goes to step  6 . In step  6 , it is judged that the storage is Case C, i.e., a storage failure in which the high RON fuel is stored both in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank, and the process goes to step  9  and ends. 
   If the judgment is negative in step  3 , the process goes to step  4 . In step  4 , whether or not DSA 1 &gt;B (or DSA 2 &gt;B′) is judged. If the judgment is negative in step  4 , the process goes to step  7 . In step  7 , it is judged that the storage is Case B, i.e., a storage failure in which the low RON fuel is stored both in the high RON fuel tank and the low RON fuel tank, and the process goes to step  9  and ends. 
   If the judgment is affirmative in step  4 , the process goes to step  8 . In step  8 , it is judged that the storage is Case D, i.e., a storage failure in which the high RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank and the low RON fuel is stored in the high RON fuel tank, and the process goes to step  9  and ends. 
   Judgment results obtained at the steps  5 ,  6 ,  7 , and  8  are displayed on a judgment result display designated by reference numeral  21  in  FIG. 1 , so as to be recognized by a driver. 
     FIG. 8  shows a modification of the above embodiment. In a manner similar to the above embodiment, after data is read in step  11 , the process goes to step  12  and, then, whether or not DSA  1  is equal to DSA 2  is judged. If the judgment is affirmative in step  12 , the process goes to step  14  in which it is judged that the storage is proper, i.e., the low RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel is stored in the high RON fuel tank, and the process goes to step  15  and ends. 
   On the other hand, if the judgment is negative in step  12 , the process goes to step  13  in which it is judged that the case is Case B, i.e., a proper storage in which the low RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank and is also stored in the high RON fuel tank, and the process goes to step  5  and ends. 
   As described above, if DSA 1  is not equal to DSA 2 , there is a possibility that the storage may be Case C or D in addition to Case B. However, it is immediately judged that the case is Case B, i.e., the case in which the low RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank and is also stored in the high RON fuel tank, on the following grounds. 
   In general, the high RON fuel is more expensive than the low RON fuel. Some gas stations have fueling equipment for low RON fuel, however, they have no fueling equipment for high RON fuel. Accordingly, there is a highest possibility that the storage failure is Case B, i.e., the low RON fuel is stored in the low RON fuel tank and is also stored in the high RON fuel tank. Therefore, it is immediately judged that Case B is the case. This modification corresponds to claim  4  of the present application. 
   As described above, the embodiment of the present invention and the modification thereof have been described. However, the present invention is not limited to this, and can be applied to a case in which a vehicle is provided with a fuel separator to separate an original fuel into the low RON fuel and the high RON fuel that are stored in the low RON fuel tank and the high RON fuel tank, respectively. In this case, whether or not the fuel separator works properly may be judged.