Patent Publication Number: US-3968072-A

Title: Asbestos fiber and organic polymeric binder heat reaction products and method of forming same

Description:
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 
     This is a continuation of application Ser. No. 255,904, filed May 22, 1972, now abandoned, which is in turn a continuation of application Ser. No. 79,625, filed Oct. 9, 1970, and now abandoned. 
    
    
     Common electrical transmitting or consuming equipment comprising rotating apparatus, transformers, appliances, etc., operates more economically at elevated temperatures. A primary restricting factor however in limiting their operation temperatures is the heat stability or level of endurance of their component insulating materials. Electrical insulating materials of high inorganic content or compositions would generally be most suitable therein from the stand point of temperature stability or endurance, resistance to hot wire penetration or cut through and flammability, but the use of inorganic insulations has been curtailed especially in domestic products by their relatively high cost and poor strength characteristics. Typically organic materials such as kraft paper or polyester film are therefore used as electrical insulations in many such applications for want of a more apt inorganic insulation, particularly as to strength and economy. 
     SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
     This invention relates to asbestos materials such as paper, felted board, etc. so formed or modified as to attain unique permanent physical and electrical properties therein whereby they provide economical and highly effective electrical insulating components for many typical electrical applications and appliances, 
     It is the primary objective of this invention to provide an essentially inorganic material of asbestos fiber for electrical insulating applications in the form of paper, felted board or other apt constructions possessing lasting increased physical strength and stiffness including high tensile strength and tear resistance, improved electrical impedance to the extent of several magnitudes as well as enhanced and stabilized dielectric constant, dissipation factor and volume resistivity, significantly greater moisture resistance, and better flame resistance, among other attributes, all at economically feasible costs. 
     DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT 
     The improved and distinctive asbestos material of this invention comprises the heat reaction products derived from asbestos fiber in combination with vinyl-containing organic polymeric materials formed by a method of heat treating the combined fibers and vinyl-containing polymers while exposed to an oxidizing atmosphere. 
     Electrical insulating components or products which are predominantly composed of asbestos fiber are typically produced in the form of paper and millboard or similar sheet-like or board-like bodies of interfelted fibers obtained from the random intermingling and consolidation of substantially individually water or air suspended fibers by means of filtration accumulation techniques as in common commercial paper and board making or fiber felting manufacturing procedures. Although some commercial asbestos fiber electrical insulating papers etc. are thus produced essentially without any binder components or other added ingredients, this type of product more often generally includes a binder of inorganic composition such as a phosphate or one of organic composition such as starch or a polymeric material. Such binders, especially those which are substantially insoluble in water are normally introduced or applied to the fibers by dispersion in finally divided form throughout the suspending process water of the papermaking process to achieve maximum distribution over the fiber, for example, as an emulsion of polymeric binder such as an elastomer latex, although many types of binders can alternatively be subsequently injected into the consolidated fibrous material by impregnation with a solution or emulsion thereof. Illustrations of such prior art means are provided in U.S. Patent Nos. 2,541,273, 2,467,540, 2,567,558, 2,567,559, and 2,977,248, among numerous other patents in this field. 
     This invention, nevertheless, deals with such asbestos materials which are predominantly composed of combinations of asbestos fibers with a vinyl-containing organic polymer binder or other material regardless of their physical configuration such as construction, particularly comprising those commonly referred to as paper, board, and the like sheets, regardless of the measures utilized in their manufacture, such as fourdrinier machine, air felting, etc. and the means or form of binding administration, that is applied commensurate with the collecting and intermingling of the fibers into the product or injected therein subsequenttly and whether in the form of an emulsion, solution, melt or the like. 
     This basic combination of essential components for the effective attainment of the benefits of this invention with the objective of providing an electrical insulation of high inorganic content comprises approximately 95 to approximately 60% by weight of the product of asbestos fiber together with approximately 5 to approximately 25% by weight of the product of vinyl-containing organic polymeric binder or the like material. To attain maximum asbestos or inorganic content, the preferred proportions comprise about 95 to about 85% by weight of asbestos with about 5 to about 15% by weight of vinyl-containing polymer, for most applications, and typically about 90% to 10%. Non-essential fiber such as reinforcing fibers of organic composition or strands to strengthen the asbestos fiber, and/or fillers, etc. can additionally be included to achieve ancillary effects such as reinforcement, processing aids, bulking, etc. in amounts up to about 25% by weight of the product. 
     The measures of this invention for enhancing physical, electrical and other attributes relating to electrical insulating applications of the combination of asbestos fiber and vinyl-containing organic polymeric material consist of subjecting the same to elevated temperatures while exposed to an oxidizing atmosphere, the time and temperature conditions specifically comprising the range of at least about 120°C, up to about 250°C and for a period of at least 1 minute. Preferred thermal reaction conditions comprise temperatures of about 130°C to about 200°C over a period ranging from approximately 15 minutes to approximately 50 hours or more in an oxidizing atmosphere. Typical conditions generally apt for paper-like materials under most circumstances comprise temperatures of about 175°C for 2 or 3 hours. 
     Generally, the temperature and duration thereof vary somewhat inversely proportional with each other whereby a higher temperature requires briefer terms and conversely lower temperatures require greater terms. For instance, with a free hanging overall exposed single thin sheet of material a treatment of 130°C over a period of 30 hours provides essentially the same result as 170°C for the term of 4 hours. Moreover, the mass of the material -- for example, thickness of paper or board -- and whether or not the body is heated while exposed on all surfaces such as a single hanging sheet or in a roll or multi-unit package as a coil of paper or stack of boards, all constitute factors which influence the duration of the heat treatment since additional time must, of course, be allowed to penetrate the mass or for the material within and throughout the package or unit to reach treatment temperatures. 
     The heat treatment may be administered with any suitable apparatus such as an oven or other heat generating or applying mechanism which is capable of attaining and maintaining the temperature conditions while providing an ambient oxidizing atmosphere such as that provided by ordinary atmospheric air. This requirement of the presence of an oxidizing atmosphere is essential in that no change other than simply thermal decomposition of the organic polymeric material, depending upon temperatures applied, is attained by applying the heat treatment in an inert atmosphere such as a nitrogen atmosphere. 
     The asbestos fiber component of this invention comprises both the chrysotile and amphibole variety, the latter class including amosite, anthophyllite, crocidolite, and tremolite. Chrysotile, however, is preferred for its generally superior properties for electrical applications. 
     The vinyl-containing organic polymeric material comprises several common binder resins and/or elastomers having available vinyl CH 2  = C(H or R) groups in their structure including those of the diolefin or diene monomers of isoprene and butadiene, styrene, acrylonitrile and vinyl chloride, such as polymers of acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene, butadiene-acrylonitrile, butadiene-styrene, chloroprene and polyvinyl chloride, Preferably, a latex or emulsion formed of these materials is applied to the asbestos fiber in a conventional papermaking or board forming operation since the latex form is most convenient, effective and commonly utilized in typical commercial operations. Nevertheless, other techniques may be utilized, such as impregnation with a solvated solution thereof, as a means of obtaining the base material of the combination of asbestos fiber and vinyl-containing polymeric material thereon for the enhancing treatment of this invention which essentially constitutes the application of the given temperature conditions within an oxidizing atmosphere. No curing agents or vulcanizing ingredients are needed for the purposes of this invention. 
     The following comprise specific illustrations of various aspects of this invention demonstrating its application to asbestos-organic vinyl-containing polymeric combinations and the unique enhancing effects achieved thereby. 
     Two asbestos products identified hereinafter as exaples I and II comprising chrysotile asbestos fiber papers each containing as a binder a terpolymer of acrylonitrile butadiene styrene and samples of simply the same terpolymer binder material by itself were each evaluated by solvent extraction both before and after the heat treating in an oxidizing atmosphere measures of this invention to demonstrate the conversion and profound effects derived from the method thereof. 
     
         ______________________________________                                    
Example I             Example II                                          
90% chrysotile fiber                                                      
                   82% chrysotile fiber                                   
10% terpolymer latex                                                      
                    8% polyester fiber                                    
                   10% terpolymer latex                                   
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     The binder in latex or emulsified in water form of the asbestos fiber product of each example and that tested alone in all cases was a terpolymer of an acrylonitrile butadiene styrene product of Standard Brands. Samples of the latex binder alone were cast on glass plates and divided in two sections with one section of heat treated under the same conditions as the asbestos products of example I and II. Samples of each example I and example II, respectively, and of the terpolymer acrylonitrile butadiene styrene binder were all heat treated pursuant to the conditions of this invention, namely, 190°C for a period of 3.5 hrs. Weighed portions of samples of all materials both untreated and heat treated were then extracted with N,N-dimethylformamide by refluxing therewith over a period of 24 hours whereupon the extracted material was then evaporated on a steam bath and weighed. The percent extracted from the asbestos paper products of examples I and II both before and after heat treatment and the percent extracted from the latex binder along both before and after heat treatment are given in the following table. 
     
                       Table I                                                     
______________________________________                                    
% Extracted with N,N-dimethylformamide                                    
                         Heat Treated                                     
Sample       Untreated   3.5 hrs. at 190°C                         
______________________________________                                    
Example I     6.7        1.6                                              
Example II    7.0        1.6                                              
Terpolymer Latex                                                          
             25.8        39.6                                             
Terpolymer Latex                                                          
             20.5        36.1                                             
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     This demonstrates that the amount extractable from the heat treated combination of asbestos and latex drops sharply following the heat treatment but that the amount extracted from the heat treated latex alone increases indicating that the measures of the invention accomplish more than simply initiating a cure or extending polymerization. 
     The progressive effects of the measures of this invention and changes in significant characteristics of the treated product, such as electrical properties, stiffness, tensile strength and stretch, are demonstrated by the following data. All test samples, both untreated standards and treated materials, consisted of an asbestos paper product having the composition of 82% chrysotile fiber, 8% polyester fiber, 10% latex of a terpolymer of acrylonitrile butadiene styrene. 
     EXAMPLE III 
     Samples of asbestos paper of the given composition of Example II, but in varying thicknesses of 0.005 inch, 0.007 inch and 0.01 inch were evaluated under like conditions to determine the change in Clark stiffness (&#34;Tappi-T451), tensile strength, and percentage of stretch, as the period of heat treatment of this invention progressed. Also given are the electrical properties of each paper sample at the varying levels of treatment, including dielectric constant )ASTM-D150), dissipation factor (ASTM-D150), and volume resistivity (ASTM-D257). The ASTM dielectric constant and dissipation factor tests were run at 60 Hertz and the volume resistivity tests of ohms centimeter in all determinations of this specification, unless stated otherwise. Also all electrical evaluations were made upon both untreated and heated treated samples following conditioning at a temperature of 23°C and relative humidity of 50%, unless stated otherwise. 
     
                                           TABLE 2                                 
__________________________________________________________________________
Paper 0.005 inch Thick                                                    
                                              VOLUME                      
HRS. AT       TENSILE                                                     
                     STRETCH                                              
                           DIELECTRIC                                     
                                     DISSIPATION                          
                                              RESISTIVITY                 
135°C                                                              
      STIFFNESS                                                           
              lbs/in.                                                     
                     %     CONSTANT,60Hz                                  
                                     FACTOR,60Hz                          
                                              ohm-cm                      
__________________________________________________________________________
Untreated                                                                 
Standard                                                                  
      19      12.3, 12.3                                                  
                     4.6,4.6                                              
                           4.32      0.257      3 × 10.sup.11       
 4    30      15.0, 15.2                                                  
                     2.6,2.6                                              
                           4.05      0.163    2.41 × 10.sup.13      
 8    37      15.2, 15.2                                                  
                     1.6,1.6                                              
                           3.62      0.136    5.22 × 10.sup.13      
12    61      16.6, 15.6                                                  
                     0.8,0.8                                              
                           2.68      0.123    9.45 × 10.sup.13      
16    76      18.0, 16.8                                                  
                     0.6,0.6                                              
                           2.86      0.117    1.08 × 10.sup.14      
20    85      17.3, 16.8                                                  
                     0.5,0.5                                              
                           2.39      0.103    1.25 × 10.sup.14      
24    81      16.6, 17.0                                                  
                     0.5,0.5                                              
                           2.49      0.118    1.36 × 10.sup.14      
28    84      16.8, 15.6                                                  
                     0.5,0.4                                              
                           2.40      0.100    1.32 × 10.sup.14      
32    84      17.1, 18.2                                                  
                     0.5,0.6                                              
                           2.38      0.101    1.10 × 10.sup.14      
36    79      16.6, 16.8                                                  
                     0.5,0.5                                              
                           2.17      0.0955   1.01 × 10.sup.14      
40    81      17.5, 17.4                                                  
                     0.5,0.5                                              
                           2.15      0.115    1.28 × 10.sup.14      
44    75      16.8, 17.0                                                  
                     0.5,0.5                                              
                           2.31      0.104    1.21 × 10.sup.14      
48    84      17.3, 17.1                                                  
                     0.5,0.5                                              
                           2.60      0.0995   1.06 × 10.sup.14      
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     
                                           TABLE 3                                 
__________________________________________________________________________
Paper 0.007 inch Thick                                                    
                                              VOLUME                      
HRS. AT       TENSILE                                                     
                     STRETCH                                              
                           DIELECTRIC                                     
                                     DISSIPATION                          
                                              RESISTIVITY                 
135°C                                                              
      STIFFNESS                                                           
              lbs/in.                                                     
                     %     CONSTANT,60Hz                                  
                                     FACTOR,60Hz                          
                                              ohm-cm                      
__________________________________________________________________________
Untreated                                                                 
Standard                                                                  
      38      16.7, 18.2                                                  
                     3.5, 3.8                                             
                           9.77      0.558    1.01 × 10.sup.10      
 4    68      20.5, 20.3                                                  
                     2.4, 2.2                                             
                           4.03      0.165    3.0  × 10.sup.13      
 8    75      22.8, 21.5                                                  
                     1.7, 1.6                                             
                           4.12      0.161    5.43 × 10.sup.13      
12    117     25.2, 25.0                                                  
                     0.8, 1.0                                             
                           2.91      0.151    8.85 × 10.sup.13      
16    172     24.4, 25.0                                                  
                     0.6, 0.6                                             
                           3.12      0.127    1.22 × 10.sup.14      
20    172     24.5, 25.0                                                  
                     0.5, 0.6                                             
                           3.01      0.120    1.26 × 10.sup.14      
24    184     25.2, 25.0                                                  
                     0.6, 0.5                                             
                           2.93      0.118    1.45 × 10.sup.14      
28    182     24.2, 21.7                                                  
                     0.6, 0.4                                             
                           2.88      0.118    1.42 × 10.sup.14      
32    182     25.0, 25.0                                                  
                     0.5, 0.5                                             
                           2.69      0.118    1.29 × 10.sup.14      
36    194     25.6, 25.0                                                  
                     0.6, 0.6                                             
                           2.91      0.120    1.38 × 10.sup.14      
40    194     24.7, 25.6                                                  
                     0.5, 0.6                                             
                           2.49      0.102    1.60 ×  10.sup.14     
44    199     23.0, 25.2                                                  
                     0.5, 0.6                                             
                           3.02      0.124    1.22 × 10.sup.14      
48    197     24.5, 24.2                                                  
                     0.5, 0.5                                             
                           3.06      0.119    1.39 × 10.sup.14      
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     
                                           TABLE 4                                 
__________________________________________________________________________
Paper 0.010 inch Thick                                                    
                                              VOLUME                      
HRS. AT       TENSILE                                                     
                     STRETCH                                              
                           DIELECTRIC                                     
                                     DISSIPATION                          
                                              RESISTIVITY                 
135°C                                                              
      STIFFNESS                                                           
              LBS/IN.                                                     
                     %     CONSTANT,60Hz                                  
                                     FACTOR,60Hz                          
                                              ohm-cm                      
__________________________________________________________________________
Untreated                                                                 
Standard                                                                  
       57     21.5, 21.1                                                  
                     5.3, 5.2                                             
                           13.1      0.633    9.3  × 10.sup.9       
 4    108     23.2, 24.4                                                  
                     2.5, 2.5                                             
                           5.18      0.183    1.82  × 10.sup.13     
 8    120     26.8, 24.5                                                  
                     1.8, 1.4                                             
                           4.75      0.178    4.73 × 10.sup.13      
12    244     30.5, 29.4                                                  
                     0.8, 0.6                                             
                           3.87      0.149    7.60 × 10.sup.13      
16    328     34.2, 32.0                                                  
                     0.6, 0.6                                             
                           3.60      0.143    1.0 × 10.sup.14       
20    337     32.3, 33.4                                                  
                     0.5, 0.6                                             
                           3.03      0.113    1.42 × 10.sup.14      
24    369     33.6, 32.4                                                  
                     0.5, 0.5                                             
                           3.25      0.120    1.27 × 10.sup.14      
28    337     35.8, 30.0                                                  
                     0.5, 0.4                                             
                           3.47      0.130    1.21 × 10.sup.14      
32    359     32.6, 30.6                                                  
                     0.5, 0.4                                             
36    343     30.2, 32.0                                                  
                     0.4, 0.4                                             
                           3.57      0.137    1.02 × 10.sup.14      
40    379     28.6, 31.4                                                  
                     0.4, 0.4                                             
                           3.08      0.123    1.56 × 10.sup.14      
44    362     30.0, 33.7                                                  
                     0.4, 0.5                                             
                           3.35      0.132    1.18 × 10.sup.14      
48    356     33.6, 36.0                                                  
                     0.6, 0.6                                             
                           3.24      0.122    1.29 × 10.sup.14      
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     EXAMPLE IV 
     A 12 inch wide, 200 yard in length roll of asbestos paper of the same composition as that in Examples II and III in a thickness ranging from 4.5 to 6.0 mils with an average of 5.3 mils were heat treated as a roll in a forced air circulating oven at 135°C for 30 hours. This paper both in untreated form and at given lineal increments measured along its length upon unwinding following the heat treatment was tested to ascertain the changes in its electrical properties attributable to the treatment throughout its length. The electrical properties were found to be relatively uniform along the length of the paper treated in roll form, and variations in thickness may account for some of the variations in the resultant electrical properties. The properties of the untreated material and at given points along the length of the sheet upon unrolling following the application of the heat treatment to the roll are given in the following table. The dielectric constant was determined by ASTM test D150, the dissipation factor by ASTM test D150 , and the volume resistivity by ASTM test D257, as stated hereinbefore. 
     
                                           TABLE 5                                 
__________________________________________________________________________
                Standard                                                  
                      Heat Treated 30 hours at 135°C               
Area of Roll Tested                                                       
                Untreated                                                 
                      0 ft  100 ft                                        
                                  200 ft                                  
                                        300 ft                            
                                              400 ft                      
                                                    500                   
__________________________________________________________________________
                                                    ft                    
Dielectric Constant,60 Hz                                                 
 Std 10 days/23C/50%RH                                                    
                8.2   2.7   2.5   2.4   2.6   2.5   2.5                   
 Humid 18 Hr/23C/96%RH                                                    
                50.7  4.9   3.8   3.9   3.3   3.1   3.5                   
Dissipation Factor,60 Hz                                                  
 Standard 10 days/23C/50%RH                                               
                0.49  0.11  0.10  0.09  0.09  0.09  0.09                  
 Humid 18 hr/23C/96%RH                                                    
                2.61  0.42  0.29  0.34  0.28  0.22  0.28                  
Volume Resistivity, ohm-cm                                                
 Standard 10 days/23C/50%RH                                               
                1.1 × 10.sup.10                                     
                      8.4 × 10.sup.13                               
                            1.1 × 10.sup.14                         
                                  1.2 × 10.sup.14                   
                                        1.3 × 10.sup.14             
                                              1.3 × 10.sup.14       
                                                    1.1 × 10.sup.14 
 Humid 18 hr/23C/96%RH                                                    
                9.2 × 10.sup.8                                      
                      5.3 × 10.sup.11                               
                            8.0 × 10.sup.11                         
                                  5.8 × 10.sup.11                   
                                        8.9 × 10.sup.11             
                                              1.7 × 10.sup.         
                                                    1.0                   
__________________________________________________________________________
                                                    × 10.sup.12     
 
    
     EXAMPLE V 
     The asbestos electrical paper product of 82% chrysotile fiber, 8% polyester fiber and 10% terpolymer latex both untreated and subjected to a heat treatment pursuant to this invention was evaluated and compared with competitive insulating materials comprising kraft paper, polyester film (DuPont&#39;s Mylar) and polyamide fiber paper, (DuPont&#39;s Nomex), and each tested under a series of identical conditions including TAPPI T461 flammability under direct flame conditions, moified Underwriter Laboratories&#39; Inc. hot wire ignition test for plastics used in electrical applications specified in Bulletin No. 55, and ASTM D-495 arc resistance. The flame resistance and arc resistance test were performed pursuant to TAPPI T-461 and ASTM D-495 (using tungsten rod electrode) procedures respectively. However, the Underwriter Laboratories&#39; Bulletin No. 55 (Burning, Arcing, Ignition and Tracking of Plastics used in Electrical Applications) test with hot wire ignition was modified so as to evaluate flexible layer insulation in a simulated coil configuration with a heating wire dissipation of 75 watts. The changes introduced into the test were as follows: a 6 × 1/2 ×  1/4 in. asbestos-cement bar was substituted for the plastic bars normally employed and these were wrapped in metal foil to provide for measuring the voltage on the wire after it burned through the test material. Also, nichrome wire (0.0226 in. diameter, 1,355 ohms/ft.) was substituted for no. 24 iron wire. The test specimen was relocated from the low voltage portion of the circuit to the high voltage portion in order to provide maximum available voltage stress on the material during the test (60 to 65 volts). Since none of the samples burst into flame during testing, a volt meter was connected from the metal foil covering the asbestos cement bars to the return lead of the circuit. The meter indicated in conjunction with the timer when the test material burned or melted through. 
     The samples of materials tested according to the foregoing comprise the following. 
     1. kraft paper, 5 mils in thickness, 
     2. polyester film, 2 mils thick, DuPont&#39;s Mylar 
     3. asbestos paper, 3 mils thick, heat treated for 4 hours at 175°C 
     4. asbestos paper, no heat treatment 
     5. polyamide paper, 3 mils thick, DuPont&#39;s Nomex fiber, type 410 
     The hot wire test and arc resistance under identical conditions for all five samples resulted in the following: 
     
                                           TABLE 6                                 
__________________________________________________________________________
           Layered Test                                                   
                   Melt or Burn Through                                   
                               Arc Resistance                             
Sample     Thickness, mil                                                 
                   Time, sec   sec                                        
__________________________________________________________________________
1. Kraft paper                                                            
           20      12-14 (Sparks, smoke                                   
                               24                                         
                      no flame)                                           
2. Polyester film                                                         
           20      2-5 (Melted)                                           
                               70                                         
3. Asbestos paper                                                         
           21      &gt;300 (Slight Smoke)                                    
                               125                                        
 Heat Treated                                                             
4. Asbestos paper                                                         
           21      &gt;300 (Smoke)                                           
                               125                                        
 As Received                                                              
5. Polyamide fiber                                                        
           21      42-45 (Slight Smoke,                                   
                               79                                         
 paper             (87)   Melt, Char)                                     
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     The flame test results of each sample were as follows: 
     
                                           TABLE 7                                 
__________________________________________________________________________
                      Char Length,                                        
Sample   Flame Height, in.                                                
                      in.     After Glow                                  
__________________________________________________________________________
Kraft paper                                                               
         81/4 (Quickly Burned)                                            
                      81/4    Yes. 10-15 sec                              
Polyester fiber                                                           
         4 (Melted, No flame)                                             
                      No char No                                          
Asbestos paper                                                            
Heat Treated                                                              
         21/2 (Momentary Flame)                                           
                      1/4     No                                          
Asbestos paper                                                            
         81/4 (Burned Moderately)                                         
                      1/8     No                                          
As received                                                               
Polyamide fiber                                                           
paper    3/4(Momentary Flame)                                             
                      3/4     No                                          
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     The following examples illustrate the effectiveness of the heat treatment of this invention when administered over only very brief, and economical, periods of a minute or more. In each of Examples 6 and 7, the materials treated consisted of sheets of asbestos paper comprised of 90% by weight of chrysotile asbestos fiber and 10% by weight of the terpolymer of acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene and of an average thickness of 7 mils. 
     EXAMPLE VI 
     The above asbestos-terpolymer paper samples where heat treated in an atmosphere of ordinary air for the given periods, and the dielectric constant, dissipation factor and volume resistivity of initial or untreated paper samples and of samples treated for the specified terms were all measured after exposure to standardizing conditions at 50% relative humidity at 23°C for 65 hrs. The results were as follows: 
     
                       Table 8                                                     
______________________________________                                    
Time at 250°C                                                      
            K,60 Hz    D,60 Hz    VR,ohm-cm                               
______________________________________                                    
Standard-untreated                                                        
            15.5       0.796      3.41 × 10.sup.9                   
1 min.      4.96       0.20       3.3  × 10.sup.13                  
2 min.      3.87       0.159      7.4  × 10.sup.13                  
4 min.      3.42       0.141      7.9  × 10.sup.13                  
10 min.     3.30       0.137      6.74 × 10.sup.13                  
20 min.     3.80       0.147      6.64 × 10.sup.13                  
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     In the above and following tables, K represents dielectric constant at 60Hz determined by ASTM-D 150 standards, D represents dissipation factor at 60Hz determined by ASTM-D150standards, and VR represents volume resistivity in ohm-cm determined by ASTM-D 257 standards under the same conditions as previously stated, each unless indicated otherwise. 
     EXAMPLE VII 
     The same paper of chrysotile and the terpolymer was heat treated and evaluated pursuant to identical conditions as in example VI except that the thermal conditions were at a temperature of 175°C rather than 258°C. The data resulting therefrom were: 
     
                       Table 9                                                     
______________________________________                                    
Time at 175°C                                                      
            K          D          VR                                      
______________________________________                                    
Standard-untreated                                                        
            15.5       0.796      3.41 × 10.sup.9                   
15 min.     4.74       0.191      4.0  × 10.sup.13                  
0.5 hr.     3.82       0.153      8.0  × 10.sup.13                  
1.0 hr.     3.60       0.141      7.3  × 10.sup.13                  
1.5 hr.     3.46       0.141      6.4  × 10.sup.13                  
2.0 hr.     3.92       0.144      4.6  × 10.sup.13                  
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     EXAMPLE VIII 
     The material utilized in this test was an asbestos paper composed of 82% by weight chrysotile asbestos fiber, 10% by weight of the terpolymer of acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene, and 8% reinforcing polyester fiber. The standard and samples treated at 120°C were each evaluated following conditioning by exposure to humidity conditions of 96 hr, at 23°C and 50% relative humidity. The following values were obtained. 
     
                       Table 10                                                    
______________________________________                                    
Time at 120°C                                                      
            K          D          VR                                      
______________________________________                                    
Standard-untreated                                                        
            16.0       0.768      3.41 × 10.sup.9                   
4 hr.       8.0        0.295      2.39 × 10.sup.11                  
8 hr.       6.57       0.211      4.26 × 10.sup.12                  
16 hr.      5.50       0.187      2.68 × 10.sup.13                  
24 hr.      4.62       0.166      4.11 × 10.sup.13                  
28 hr.      4.26       0.156      5.14 × 10.sup.13                  
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     EXAMPLE IX 
     This evaluation employed the same test conditions and samples of the same asbestos material and the same test conditions as employed in previous Example VIII, except as indicated otherwise, with the material heated to a temperature of 175°C. The term of heating and effect upon electrical properties were: 
     
                       Table 11                                                    
______________________________________                                    
Time at 175°C                                                      
            K          D          VR                                      
______________________________________                                    
Standard-untreated                                                        
            16.0       0.768      3.41 × 10.sup.9                   
0.5 hr.     6.0        0.206      1.02 × 10.sup.13                  
1.0 hr.     5.42       0.195      2.33 × 10.sup.13                  
1.5 hr.     3.98       0.157      5.34 × 10.sup.13                  
4.0 hr.     3.84       0.149      7.9  × 10.sup.13                  
6.0 hr.     3.83       0.147      7.13 × 10.sup.13                  
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     However, upon further conditioning of the untreated sample and that subjected to a 4 hour test of 175°C temperature, under a very high relative humidity of 96% at 23°C for 18 hours, a far more pronounced difference in electrical properties was exhibited, to wit: the untreated material had a K of 22.5 and D of 2.41 whereas the material treated for 4 hrs. at 175°C then had a K of 5.99, D of 0.364 and VR of 7.2 × 10 11 . The necessity of an oxidizing atmosphere during the application of the heat treatment to the asbestos and vinyl-containing polymeric material is established by the results of the following test carried out in a nitrogen atmosphere. 
     EXAMPLE X 
     Samples of asbestos paper, the same product and of the same composition as the material employed in Examples II, III, IV, V, VIII, and IX, were tested both untreated and after heating 4 hrs. at 175°C within each an atmosphere of air, pure nitrogen, and successively nitrogen and then air. The thus variously heat treated materials exhibited electrical and physical properties as indicated: 
     
                                           Table 12                                
__________________________________________________________________________
                            Physical                                      
Sample    K    D     VR     Appearance                                    
__________________________________________________________________________
Standard-untreated                                                        
          8.3  0.47  1.4 × 10.sup.10                                
                            Blue-grey in color                            
48hr/23°C/50RH       Very limp                                     
Heated in air                                                             
4 hours at 175°C                                                   
          3.1  0.126 1.1 × 10.sup.14                                
                            Tan in color                                  
1hr/23°C/50RH        Stiff                                         
Heated in N.sub.2                                                         
4 hours at 175°C                                                   
          3.9  0.184 4.4 × 10.sup.12                                
                            Blue-grey in color                            
1 hr/23°C/50RH       very limp                                     
Heated in N.sub.2                                                         
4 hours at 175°C,                                                  
then heated in air                                                        
4 hrs. at 175°C                                                    
          2.1  0.117 1.4 × 10.sup.14                                
                            Tan in color                                  
1hr/23°C/50RH        Stiff                                         
Standard-untreated                                                        
          33.0 2.1   6.8 × 10.sup.8                                 
                            Blue-grey in color                            
18hr/23°C/91RH       Very limp                                     
Heated in air                                                             
4 hours at 175°C                                                   
          4.3  0.246 5.1 × 10.sup.12                                
                            Tan in color                                  
18hr/23°C/91RH       Stiff                                         
Heated in N.sub.2                                                         
4 hours at 175°C                                                   
          7.3  0.63  9.4 × 10.sup.9                                 
                            Blue-grey in color                            
18hr/23°C/91RH       Very limp                                     
Heated in N.sub.2                                                         
4 hours at 175°C                                                   
then heated in air                                                        
4 hrs. at 175°C                                                    
          3.0  0.174 9.9 × 10.sup.12                                
                            Tan in color                                  
18hr/23°C/91RH       Stiff                                         
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     EXAMPLES IX-XV 
     The following series of examples demonstrate the effectiveness of the measures of this invention with paper composed of a variety of diverse materials including the asbestos component as well as the vinyl-containing polymer. In each example, unless specified otherwise, the samples were composed of about 90% by weight of asbestos fiber of the identified class and about 10% by weight of the given polymer, and all samples were subjected to 3 hours at 175°C within an oxidizing atmosphere of ambient air. Testing of electrical properties of both the untreated and treated samples followed their conditioning for 2 days at 23°C and 50% relative humidity. The combination of asbestos and vinyl-containing polymer material and their pretreatment and past heat treatment electrical properties obtained were: 
     
                                           Table 13                                
__________________________________________________________________________
Example                                                                   
     Sample Material                                                      
                    Volume Resistivity, ohm-cm                            
                    Untreated                                             
                            Treated                                       
__________________________________________________________________________
11   chrysotile fiber with                                                
                    1.96 × 10.sup.8                                 
                            3.51 × 10.sup.11                        
     copolymer of butadiene                                               
     styrene                                                              
     Uniroyal N-2758 Latex                                                
12   chrysotile fiber with                                                
                    4.2  × 10.sup.8                                 
                            1.22 × 10.sup.10                        
     vinyl chloride copolymer                                             
     National Starch Vynallor 250                                         
13   chrysotile fiber with                                                
                    3.7  × 10.sup.8                                 
                            6.6  × 10.sup.9                         
     chloroprene latex                                                    
     Dupont&#39;s 736 latex                                                   
14   chrysotile fiber and                                                 
                    10.sup.6                                              
                            1.46 × 10.sup.11                        
     copolymer of butadiene-                                              
     styrene and terpolymer                                               
     with carboxylated cross-                                             
     linking agent                                                        
     Uniroyal J-3595                                                      
15   anthophyllite fiber with                                             
                     1.86 × 10.sup.13                               
                            6.7  × 10.sup.14                        
     terpolymers of                                                       
     acrylonitrile-butadiene-                                             
     styrene and 8% of polyester                                          
     reinforcing fiber                                                    
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     EXAMPLE XVI 
     Samples of chrysotile fiber with the terpolymer binder of acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene with about 8% polyester reinforcing fiber were also subjected to the treatment of 3 hours at 175°C within an air atmosphere devoid of moisture. The untreated material exhibited a volume resistivity of 6.92 × 10 10  and when so treated in dry air this property was 1.16 × 10 14  , thus establishing that the presence of moisture is not essential.