Patent Publication Number: US-4836951-A

Title: Random polyether foam control agents

Description:
This is a continuation of prior U.S. application Ser. No. 830,762 filed on Feb. 19, 1986 now abandoned. 
    
    
     FIELD OF THE INVENTION 
     This invention relates in general to random polyether compositions having foam control and surfactant properties. In one aspect, this invention relates to mechanical dishwasher formulations containing random polyether foam control agents. In a further aspect, this invention is directed to random polyether copolymers which are particularly useful in mechanical dishwasher formulations and which impart desirable properties of cleaning and defoaming without a concurrent build-up of spots or films on the dishes. 
     BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 
     Prior to the present invention a variety of surfactants are disclosed in the literature which are indicated to be suitable for use in mechanical dishwasher formulations. Many of the surfactants disclosed are block polyalkylene oxide copolymers of long chain alkyl started alkoxylates. For example, U.S. Pat. No. 2,677,700 which issued May 4, 1954 and is assigned to Wyandotte Chemicals Corporation discloses and claims certain polymers anionic and nonionic surface active agents in which the essential hydrophobic element is a polyoxyalkylene chain of a prescribed minimum length. It is indicated in the patent that both the hydrophobic and hydrophilic elements can be simultaneously varied both as to the molecular weight and type to prepare a &#34;tailored&#34; surface active agent. 
     In U.S. Pat. No. 2,674,619 which issued Apr. 6, 1954 and is also assigned to Wyandotte Chemicals Corporation there is disclosed a new class of polyalkyleneoxy compositions which are indicated to have outstanding detergent and surface active properties. Such polyalkyleneoxy compositions are prepared by first condensing propylene oxide with an organic compound having a plurality of reactive hydrogen atoms to prepare a polyoxypropylene polymer of at least 900 molecular weight, and subsequently condensing ethylene oxide therewith. 
     There is also disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 4,134,854 which issued to Texaco Development Corporation on Jan. 16, 1979, surfactants wherein the pour point can be lowered by the addition of alkylene oxides. In the process disclosed in this patent, ethylene oxide, propylene oxide and ethylene oxide are added sequentially to alcohols. 
     Other surfactants are disclosed in the literature which have been indicated to be useful in dishwasher formulations and which have various desirable properties, such as low cloud points, excellenet defoaming characteristics and the like. However, for the most part these references are directed to surfactants which are either prepared from block copolymers as opposed to random copolymers or which rely upon the addition of a second or third component to make up for the deficiencies of the surfactant. 
     In this regard, see for example, U.S. Pat. No. 3,629,127 which discloses and claims the use of nonionic surfactants such as oxyalkylated linear alcohols in addition to an auxiliary defoamant, for example, an anionic phosphate ester of oxyalkylated alcohols. In a similar fashion, in U.S. Pat. No. 3,635,827 low foam dishwasher detergent surfactants are prepared by utilizing alkoxylates of fatty alcohols in combination with polyvinyl alcohol. In U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,941,710, 4,001,132, and 4,203,858, there are disclosed various combinations of polymeric compounds and additives to achieve desired properties in the surfactants disclosed and claimed. 
     U.S. Pat. No. 3,359,207 which was issued Dec. 19, 1967, describes the use of block copolymers of ethylene and propylene oxide and block copolymers derived from various starters such as pentaerythritol, ethanol, ethylene diamine, octanol and the like. Similar ethylene oxide/propylene oxide block copolymers, which use branched 1-decanols as starters are also described in U.S. Pat. No. 4,299,994. Other patents such as U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,101,374, 4,306,987 and 4,411,810 disclose various block-heteric copolymers which are useful as surfactants. 
     Additives for automatic dishwasher detergent formulations comprising PO/EO/PO block copolymers in combination with an alkyl phosphate ester are also described in U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,070,298 and 4,263,160. It is indicated that such additives are useful in automatic dishwasher formulations to accomplish defoaming. 
     U.S. Pat. No. 4,272,394 describes blends of low foaming nonionic surfactants which are replacements for the alkyl phosphate ester defoamants of conventional automatic dishwashing detergents. Such blends comprise a conventional low foaming nonionic surfactant and a block-heteric copolymer of ethylene oxide and a lower alkylene oxide such as propylene or butylene oxide. The conventiona low foaming nonionic surfactant is a polyoxyalkylene adduct of a hydrophobic base wherein the oxygen/carbon atom ratio in the oxyalkylene portion of the molecule is greater than 0.40, and is prepared from, e.g., ethylene oxide or mixtures with minor amounts of propylene oxide, butylene oxide, etc. In this regard, see, e.g., column 2, lines 45+, as well as column 6, lines 64+. 
     As can be seen from the foregoing, the literature relating to the use of ethylene oxide/propylene oxide copolymers as surfactants for mechanical dishwasher detergents discloses, for the most part, nonionic surfactants which contain three possible configurations. First, the ethylene oxide/propylene oxide is a block configuration, that is, either EO/PO/EO or PO/EO/PO. Second, the ethylene and propylene oxide are reacted with alcohol starters having eight or more carbon atoms. Finally, heteric copolymers containing ethylene or propylene oxide can be used if in a block heteric form. Copolymers, such as these are formed by preparing a random copolymer with two regions where the EO/PO random mixture is adjusted to prepare a relatively hydrophilic and a relatively hydrophobic region. 
     SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
     In its broad aspect, the present invention is directed to novel mechanical dishwasher formuations containing certain random polyether foam control agents. The formulations have low foaming properties and leave a minimum of spotting and filming on articles washed in the presence of such random polyether foam control agents. The formulations of the present invention are comprised of a foam controlling amount of a foam control agent comprised of a copolyether having a molecular weight of at least about 2000, and containing random propyleneoxy (and/or butyleneoxy) and ethyleneoxy groups, wherein the ethyleneoxy groups are present in an amount of at lesat about 20 percent by weight of the polyether component of the copolymer, and wherein said propyleneoxy (and/or butyleneoxy) groups are present in an amount such that the cloud point is equal to, or less than, the operating temperature of the mechanical dishwasher. 
    
    
     DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION 
     As herein before indicated, the copolyether foam control agents of the present invention which are employed in the mechanical dishwasher formulations are random copolymers, specifically copolyethers which have the molecular weights and ethyleneoxy group content as indicated above. 
     The random copolyether foam control agents of the present invention can be illustrated by the following formulae: ##STR1## wherein R is derived from a saturated or unsaturated alcohol having up to 36 carbon atoms, such as a C 12  to C 18  primary alcohol, or an alkylaryl group such as a C 1  to C 16  substituted phenol; R&#39; is a methyl or ethyl group; R&#34; is an alkyl group having from 3 to 36 carbon atoms, or an alkylaryl group such as a C 1  to C 16  substituted phenol; x and y are integers selected in any ratio such that the final polyether does not contain more than 75 weight percent of ethylene oxide; z is an integer of from 0 to 4; X is hydrogen, chloro, alkyl of from 1 to 24 carbon atoms, alkylaryl such as benzyl, a beta-hydroxy alkyl group, an alkylcarbonyl group such as C 2  to C 18  alkylcarbonyl group or an arylcarbonyl group such as a benzoate group; w has a value of from 2 to 40; Z is: ##STR2## wherein R&#39; and X are defined as above; x&#39; and y&#39; are integers selected such that the sums of (x&#39; +x) and (y&#39;+y) are such that the polyether does not contain more than 75 percent by weight of ethylene oxide; z&#39; is an integer of from 0 to 15; A is the residue of an alcohol having a hydroxy functionality of from 1 to 6, such as ethylene glycol, glycerol, trimethylol propane, pentaerythritol, sorbitol, saturated or unsaturated alcohols of up to 36 carbon atoms, etc.; and n is integer of from 1 to 6. 
     In the above formulae R is preferably derived from an aliphatic hydrocarbyl alcohol of 12 to 18 carbon atoms, or a C 1  to C`hd 16 substituted phenol; R&#39; is methyl or ethyl; R&#34; is propyl, butyl, octyl, nonyl, dodecyl, as well as various other C 3  to C 36  alkyl groups; and X is hydrogen, benzyl, benzoate, butoxy, acetoxy or C 1  to C 24  alkyl such as methyl, ethyl, etc. 
     Particularly preferred copolyethers for use in the instant mechanical dishwasher formulations are those of formula I wherein X is hydrogen, R is derived from a C 12  to C 18  primary alcohol or nonylphenol, R&#39; is methyl, the ration of x to y ranges from 40:60 to 50:50, and the molecular weight is at least 4000. Also particularly preferred are those copolyethers of formula II wherein X is hydrogen, R is derived from a C 12  to C 18  primary alcohol or nonylphenol, R&#39; is mehtyl or ethyl, z is preferably 1-2, and the molecular weight is preferably at least 4000. 
     For the purposes of the present invention, the molecular weights specified herein are weight average molecular weights, MW, determined by gel permeation chromatography. 
     The copolyethers of formulae I, II and IV may be prepared by alkoxylation techniques well known to those skilled in the art. The preparation of the copolyethers of formula III is described in detail in copending commonly assigned U.S. patent application Serial No. 641,640, filed Aug. 17, 1984 in the names of Meschke et al., the entirety of which is hereby incorporated by reference and relied on in its entirety. 
     In practice, it has been found that the copolyethers of the formulae I to IV which have molecular weights of above 2000 are particularly well suited for use in the formulations of the present invention. Preferably, the molecular weight is between about 4500 and about 30,000, although with the copolyethers of formula III, useful molecular weights may range up to as much as 250,000. It has also been found, as hereinafter indicated, that the number of ethylene oxide groups in the foam control agents is important to achieve all of the desired properties in the detergents. For dishwashers operated at about 135° F., for example, polyethers comprised of at least 20 weight percent of ethylene oxide groups and more preferably between about 25 and 60 percent are preferred, with ethylene oxide contents of 25 to 50 weight percent being particularly preferred. As indicated previously, the propyleneoxy (and/or butyleneoxy) groups are present in an amount such that the cloud point is equal to, or less than, the operating temperature of the mechanical dishwasher. At dishwasher operating temperatures below  135° F., the preferred ethylene oxide content will generally decrease, but still be within the range of 25-50 percent by weight. At dishwasher operating temperatures above 135° F., for example in the range of 160° to 170° F., the preferred ethylene oxide content will generally increase, but will generally be in the range of from 25-60% by weight. 
     The cloud point of the foam control agents of the present invention is determined by methods known in the literature. In the present application the cloud point was determined according to accepted techniques on a one percent aqueous solution of the copolyether. 
     In general, the operating temperature of mechanical dishwashers can vary over a wide range and if not equipped with adequate temperature controls is usually dependent upon the temperature of the water entering the washer. In practice, however, the temperatures of mechanical dishwashers usually vary from a low of 90° to 100° F. to a high of 160° to 170° F. Mechanical dishwashers which are employed for industrial application, such as in hotel, hospitals, restaurants or the like, usually operate at temperatures of from about 140° F. to about 160° F. Mechanical dishwashers which are used in the home are usually operated at temperatues of from about 120° F. to about 140° F. Thus the particular temperature at which the dishwasher operates will effect the cloud point. As noted above, for dishwashers operating in the range of 120 to 140° F., particularly preferred copolyethers will contain from about 25 to 60% by weight of ethylene oxide. For dishwashers operating at 140° to 160 ° F., the preferred copolyethers will also possess an ethylene oxide content within this range, although generally at the higher end thereof. 
     In studying the scope and limitations of the use of various polyether compositions in mechanical dishwasher detergent formulations, the effect of hydrophilicity (ethylene oxide or hydroxyl content) and molecular weight was observed. 
     The foam test data set forth in the Tables shows that there is an optimum region of ethylene oxide content. For example, the best results were obtained (with a dishwasher operating temperature of 135° F.) with polyether copolymers containing 50 percent by weight of ethylene oxide, while 100 percent propylene oxide containing fluids exhibited only marginal defoamant activity. Interesentingly, higher levels of ethylene oxide content, for example, over 75 percent up to 100 percent of ethylene oxide exhibited almost no defoamant activity. It should also be noted that increasing the hydroxyl content of 100 percent propylene oxide polyethers had essentially no effect. 
     In addition to an optimal ethylene oxide content there is also a threshold molecular weight, below which there is essentially no defoamant action. The data presented in the Tables shows that this threshold value is approximately 2000 for both 100 and 50 percent propylene oxide containing fluids. Once this threshold has been achieved certain copolyethers continue to improve in defoamant properties. 
     A second property of interest is the spotting and filming index. It has been noted that while a 100 percent propylene oxide containing fluid may exhibit some defoamant activity, it does not possess any significant spotting and filming inhibition properties. Conversely, the results obtained for 50 percent ethylene oxide containing fluids showed that the spotting and filming index improves with the increasing molecular weight. Hence, it was found that some level of ethylene oxide content is required to achieve both optimal defoamant and spotting and filming inhibition properties. 
     Once the optimum composition of the copolyethers of this invention was determined it was noted that the random copolyethers had a wide range of unexpected and desirable properties in a single polymeric structure. For example, in addition to the aformentioned features, it has been observed that copolymers prepared with a nonylphenol starter also exhibit an enhanced stabilizing effect on the chlorine containing component of mechanical dishwasher detergents. 
     The copolyether agents of the present invention, as indicated above, are employed in place of known surfactants presently used in dishwasher formulations, such as, detergents, and impart desirable properties not heretofore available in a single composition. It should be noted that organic compound such as those of the present invention which have random segments of mixed lower alkylene oxides attached to a hydrophobic moiety were not recognized in the literature as being useful as foam control agents. For example, in U.S. Pat. No. 4,445,971 which was issued to S. C. Lappi on May 1, 1984 methods for foam inhibition are disclosed. However, it is specifically disclosed at column 3,  lines 11-20, that compositions wherein ethylene oxide and propylene oxide appear as random segments are not useful as defoamants. Hence, if anything the prior art specifically teaches away from the use of polyethers having random alkylene oxide segments as foam control agents. 
     The term &#34;mechanical dishwasher formulation(s)&#34;, as employed throughout the specification and appended claims is intended to include detergents, whether in the form of powders, granules, gels, slurries, or liquids; solid or liquid rinse compositions; or other additives or compounds normally employed with commercial or household mechanical dishwashers to aid in the cleaning of dishes, silverware, stainless steelware, pans and other utensils. 
     In general, the foam control agents of the present invention will be employed in an amount sufficient to effect optimum defoaming and also provide the other desirable characteristics of spotting and cleaning properties noted above. Thus, the foam control agents can be employed in a &#34;foam controlling amount&#34; to achieve their intended purpose. Generally, the copolyethers will be employed in the formulation in an amount of from about 0.01 to 50 percent by weight depending on the particular end-use, i.e., detergent, rinse aid, etc. For normal residential detergent applications, the copolyether will usually be present in an amount of from 0.01 to 5 percent by weight, and preferably from 1 to 5 weight percent and most preferably from 2 to 5% by weight in order to maximize antifoaming and surfactant properties. 
     The foam control agents of the present invention can be used in combination with other surfactants, such as nonionic, cationic or anionic surfactants when it is desired to have the added effect of these surfactants and low foaming. These foam control agents can also be blended with one or more other agents encompassed by formulae I-IV above. When employed in combination with the random copolyethers of this invention, such other surfactants may be present in any amount provided that the cloud point of the formulation remains below the operating temperature of the dishwasher. Experiments to date suggest that best results are obtained when such auxiliary surfactants preferably comprise less than 25 weight percent of the total amount of surfactant in the formulation. 
     It has been observed that the foam control agents of the present invention are particularly attractive for use in mechanical dishwasher detergents. Detergents that are used in commerical or household mechanical dishwashers come in a variety of forms, including powders, liquids, slurries, gells, and the like. However, for the most part, commercially available detergents which can be used in the home or restaurants, are usually comprised of detergent builders, a compound containing active chlorine or available oxygen and one or more surfactants. Other components such as extenders or fragrances are usually employed. A typical detergent may contain from 90 to about 95  weight percent or one or more builders, from about 0.5 to about 5.0 weight percent of a compound containing active chlorine, and 0.01 to about 5.0 weight percent of a surfactant. The copolyether foam control agents of the present invention are used in place of the surfactants, and even when used alone, provide a detergent composition having the aformentioned properties. 
     A wide variety of builders can also be used in the detergents of the present invention. For example, suitable builders include, among others, the phosphates and the pyrophosphates; the silicates; and other commercially available builders. 
     In addition to the builders, it may also be desirable to include compounds which contain chlorine in the active form and liberate hypochlorites during the washing process. Illustrative compounds which can be used as a source of chlorine include such compositions as chlorinated trisodium phosphate, sodium and potassium dichlorocyanurates, dichlorocyanuric acid, and 5,5-dimethyl hydantion, trichloromelamine, N-chlorosuccinimide, N-chloroacetyl urea, N,N&#39;-dichlorobiuret chlorinated dicyandiamide, sodium hypochlorite, calcium hypochlorite, and the like. 
     Other ingredients can also be added if desired to the detergent compositions of the present invention. For example, if a source of available chlorine is not used it might be desirable to add an enzyme material to the composition. Other materials such as china protecting agents, filler material, dyes, perfumes and the like can be utilized in the detergents of the present invention if desired. Accordingly, such compounds as sodium or potassium aluminosilicates, aluminiates, sodium chloride, sodium sulfate, sodium benzene sulfonate, sodium toluene solufonate and the like can be incorporated into the dishwasher detergent composition. 
     The copolyether foam control agents employed in the mechanial dishwasher detergents of the present invention can be prepared by a variety of methods known in the art. For example, the polyethers can be synthesized by potassium-catalyzed alkoxylation reactions using starting alcohol compounds, such as butanol, dodecanol octadecanol,nonylphenol and the like. Other known alkoxylation methods such as acid catalyzed reactions can be employed. 
     Although there are numerous tests that are often used for the testing of detergents it is well known that two of the most important criteria of an acceptable mechanical dishwashing surfactant are superior foam control and a low propensity for spotting and filming of dishes after multiple washing cycles. These tests have been employed in the evaluation of the copolyethers of the present invention and are more fully described in the examples. For instance, Example 1 describes the foam reduction character of a surfactant under typical dishwashing conditions. The value is given as a ratio percent. Values of 30-40 are typically observed when no defoamant is employed. Values less than 30 represent a profoamer, 60-70 would be acceptable to the industry and 90-100 are indicated to be excellent. A value of 100 would mean that the amount of foaming observed is the same as water itself. 
     The test procedure for determining the amount of spotting and film build-up on dishes during repeated use of the detergent is described in Example 1. This test is a particularly critical parameter since very noticeable film build-up can be observed after only seven cycles when no surfactant is used. A value of &lt;2 would represent a good candidate. Experience has demonstrated that differences of 0.3 units are significant. 
     The performance of a detergent formulation without a surfactant is shown in Table 1 where completely unacceptable foam and spotting and filming properties were observed. In fact, complete filming of the dishes was observed in less than the normal ten cycles for the test. These results are in marked contrast to those illustrated for the better candidates shown in subsequent tables. 
     While the present invention is directed to the use of the random polyether foam control agents in mechanical dishwasher detergent compositions, these agents can also be used for other applications where foam control is also desired. Many fluids when used either alone or in combination with other components possess undesirable foaming properties during chemical processing procedures and hence the use of a foam control agent may be desired. In such instances it may be desirable to employ a foam controlling amount of the copolyethers disclosed in the present invention. 
     The following examples illustrate the best mode presently contemplated for the practice of the present invention. As noted above, the molecular weight specified in the following examples comprise weight average molecular weights, MW, as determined by gel permeation chromatography. 
     EXAMPLE 1 
     Test for Surfactant Foam Control 
     Into the lower rack of a Whirlpool 440 model mechanical dishwasher was charged six 9-inch plates distributed evenly. In the upper rack, 12 (10-12 oz.) glass tumblers were placed 6 on each side. Six each of knives, forks and spoons were evenly distributed in the silverware rack. 
     Using clean dishes and no soil, 2 dishwashing cycles were performed to check the temperature (135°±5° F.) and to record the r.p.m. of the spray arm during the wash cycles. The rotor r.p.m. was clocked three times during the 7 minute wash cycle; after 3 minutes, 4 minutes and 5 minutes. In each use, the r.p.m. was clocked for 30 seconds and multiplied by 2. 
     The two wash cycles, conducted in the absence of any detergent served a dual purpose: to bring the working machine up to temperature and to provide a standard r.p.m. for water alone. 
     A 20 gram sample of the detergent powder (2% surfactant, and 32,7% each of sodium tripolyphosphate, sodium meta silicate and sodium carbonate) was introduced into the bottom of the machine near the water inlet and the wash cycle repeated, temperature and r.p.m recorded as above. 
     After this step the procedure is repeated using 10 grams of soil (5 gm of powdered egg solids and 5 gm of nonfat dry milk) to test the defoaming ability of the detergent. 
     At least one, preferably two, wash cycles were run without detergent and were run after each test to rinse out the machine completely and to recheck the r.p.m. for water alone. The ratio % is indicative of low foam or defoaming behavior of the surfactant and is calculated as follows: ##EQU1## 
     (Reference Chemical Specialities Manufacturing Association Bulletin No. 164-60, Subcommittee F. Final Report, June 10, 1960.) 
     EXAMPLE 2 
     Mechanical Diswasher Spotting and Filming Test 
     First the solid dishwasher detergent formulation is prepared by mixing the following components in the indicated amounts: 
     
         ______________________________________                                    
COMPONENT             % BY WEIGHT                                         
______________________________________                                    
Surfactant            2.0                                                 
Sodium Silicate       33.0                                                
Soda Ash Grade 100    15.0                                                
Anhydrous Sodium Sulfate                                                  
                      28.0                                                
Sodium Tripolyphosphate                                                   
                      20.0                                                
CLEARON CDB (chlorocyanurate)                                             
                      2.0                                                 
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     After this mixture is thoroughly mixed, it is stored in a tightly covered bottle until use. 
     Next a master batch of 20% dried milk and 80% warmed (melted) margarine are throughly mixed and then stored in a refrigerator. This mixture should not be stored longer than two weeks. 
     Six ten-inch dinner plates, six forks and six knives are then placed in the lower rack of a Kitchen Aid KDS-56 mechanical dishwasher. Eight 10 oz. glass tumblers (Federal glass No. 812 or Libby No. 53) are placed in the upper rack (four on each side). 
     The machine is then turned on and allowed to go through any prewash or rinse cycles. The temperature of the incoming water is adjusted to 130°±5°F. 
     When the dishwasher begins to fill for the main wash cycle, it is stopped and forty grams of the standard soil, prepared above, is smeared on the six dinner plates. Thirty grams of the test detergent is placed in machine detergent cup. The beakers which contained the soil and detergent are placed in the upper rack, the dishwasher is then restarted and allowed to complete the remaining wash, rinse and drying cycles. 
     When the drying cycle is complete, the machine is opened and allowed to cool. The tumblers are removed from the machine by the base being careful not to touch the sides. Each of the cooled tumblers is then rated for water spotting and filming according to the following rating system. 
     
         ______________________________________                                    
RATING                                                                    
______________________________________                                    
1 -      Glass spotless                                                   
2 -      Spots at random or barely perceptible                            
         film.                                                            
3 -      One quarter of the glass is covered                              
         with spots or an apparent film.                                  
4 -      The glass is completely covered with                             
         spots or heavy film.                                             
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     After the tumblers are rated they are returned to the machine (without further cleaning) and the above procedure repeated for a total of ten cycles or until a rating of five is achieved. 
     Upon completion of the test the tumblers are discarded. 
     The average over ten cycles is reported as the spotting and filming results shown in the Tables. 
     This Test is a standard test reported by CSMA (Laboratory Test Manual No 420) in Soap and Chem Specialites, September 1957. 
     EXAMPLE 3 
     Test for Active Chlorine Stability in Mechanical Dishwashing Formulations 
     Evaluation of active chlorine stability was done by blending 300 grams of 90% sodium tripolyphosphate (F.M.C. Corp), 5% Clearon CDB (F.M.C. Corp.) and 5% surfactant and weighed into 4 oz. wide mouth jars (50 grams each) for a total of 2 jars. The jars were then covered with Whatman No. 2 filter paper which was wired onto the bottle. Three of the jars were then placed into a Model 416 FAVORITE incubator (sold by Leahy Mfg. Co. of Higgginsville, Md.) at 100° F. and 70-71% humidity. The remaining three jars of blended surfactant are titrated iodometrically to obtain initial chloride content. This is done by taking four ten gram increments from each jar (a total of twelve) and titrating by the procedure described on page 597 of the &#34;Textbook of Qualitative Inorganic Analysis&#34; 3rd Ed. by Kalthoff and Sandel. This procedure is repeated after storing in the incubator for three weeks. The values are averaged and the ratio of ##EQU2## gives the percent active chlorine remaining after three weeks at 100° F. and about 70% humidity. 
     In the following tables, the data obtained are set forth for the comparison and evalation of a variety of polyether form control agents of the present invention with commercially available surfactants. The polyether foam control agents and the surfactants are identified respectively by number or letter which correspond to the following general structures set forth below: 
     
         __________________________________________________________________________
STRUCTURE OF RANDOM POLYETHER COPOLYMER                                   
FOAM CONTROL AGENTS                                                       
                          STRUCTURE                                       
FOAM                      RO(C.sub.3 H.sub.6 O).sub.x (C.sub.2 H.sub.4    
                          O).sub.y H                                      
CONTROL                                                                   
       MOLECULAR                BLOCK/                                    
AGENT  WEIGHT  R          x.sup.1                                         
                             y.sup.1                                      
                                RANDOM.sup.2                              
__________________________________________________________________________
 1     1000    C.sub.12 H.sub.25C.sub.14 H.sub.29                         
                          0.5                                             
                             0.5                                          
                                random                                    
 2     1000    C.sub.4 H.sub.9                                            
                          0.5                                             
                             0.5                                          
                                random                                    
 3     1980    C.sub.4 H.sub.9                                            
                          0.5                                             
                             0.5                                          
                                random                                    
 4     3500    C.sub.4 H.sub.9                                            
                          0.5                                             
                             0.5                                          
                                random                                    
 5     4400    C.sub.4 H.sub.9                                            
                          0.5                                             
                             0.5                                          
                                random                                    
 6      360    C.sub.4 H.sub.9                                            
                          1.0                                             
                             0  --                                        
 7      650    C.sub.4 H.sub.9                                            
                          1.0                                             
                             0  --                                        
 8     1850    C.sub.4 H.sub.9                                            
                          1.0                                             
                             0  --                                        
 9     2600    C.sub.4 H.sub.9                                            
                          1.0                                             
                             0  --                                        
10     2025    (see note 3)                                               
                          1.0                                             
                             0  --                                        
11     4025    (see note 3)                                               
                          1.0                                             
                             0  --                                        
12     4000    H          0.25                                            
                             0.75                                         
                                random                                    
13     14,000  H          0.25                                            
                             0.75                                         
                                random                                    
14     4500    H          0  1.0                                          
                                --                                        
15     4500    H          0.8                                             
                             0.2                                          
                                random                                    
16     4000    H          0.25                                            
                             0.75                                         
                                random                                    
17     4400    C.sub.4 H.sub.9                                            
                          0.5                                             
                             0.5                                          
                                random                                    
18     5800    C.sub.4 H.sub.9                                            
                          0.4                                             
                             0.6                                          
                                random                                    
19     5000                                                               
                ##STR3##  0.5                                             
                             0.5                                          
                                random                                    
20     5000                                                               
                ##STR4##  0.62                                            
                             0.38                                         
                                random                                    
21     8989    H          0.5                                             
                             0.5                                          
                                random                                    
22     1800                                                               
                ##STR5##  0.58                                            
                             0.42                                         
                                random                                    
23     5100    C.sub.10 H.sub.21                                          
                          0.5                                             
                             0.5                                          
                                random                                    
24     4400    C.sub.18 H.sub.37                                          
                          0.5                                             
                             0.5                                          
                                random                                    
25     5800    C.sub.18 H.sub.37                                          
                          0.5                                             
                             0.5                                          
                                random                                    
26     5000                                                               
                ##STR6##  0.5                                             
                             0.5                                          
                                random                                    
27     4700                                                               
                ##STR7##  0.58                                            
                             0.42                                         
                                random                                    
28     4200    C.sub.12 H.sub.25C.sub.14 H.sub.29                         
                          0.58                                            
                             0.42                                         
                                random                                    
__________________________________________________________________________
 .sup.1 x = weight fraction of the polyether component composed of        
 propyleneoxy groups; y = weight fraction of ethyleneoxy groups.          
 .sup.2 Block/random refers to the polyether sequencing. For 100 percent  
 ethylene or propylene oxide composition this designation does not apply. 
  .sup.3 This polymer is a glycerine started triol with the following     
 nominal structure:                                                       
 ##STR8##                                                                 
 
    
     
         ______________________________________                                    
STRUCTURE OF VARIOUS CONVENTIONAL                                         
BLOCK NONIONIC SURFACTANTS                                                
SURFACTANT STRUCTURE                                                      
______________________________________                                    
A          RO(C.sub.2 H.sub.4 O).sub.4 H                                  
            ##STR9##                                                      
B          RO(C.sub.2 H.sub.4 O).sub.3 (C.sub.3 H.sub.6 O).sub.3.8        
           (C.sub.2 H.sub.4 O).sub.5.1 H                                  
           random                                                         
           where R = CH.sub.3 (CH.sub.2).sub.n CH(CH.sub.2).sub.m         
           CH.sub.3                                                       
           (n + m) = 8-12                                                 
C          RO(C.sub.3 H.sub.6 O).sub.9 (C.sub.2 H.sub.4 O).sub.6 (C.sub.3 
           H.sub.6 O).sub.2 H                                             
           random                                                         
           where R = CH.sub.3 CH.sub.2 CH.sub.2 CH.sub.2 CCH.sub.2        
           C.sub.2 H.sub.5                                                
            ##STR10##                                                     
           block                                                          
E          HO(C.sub.2 H.sub.4 O).sub.x (C.sub.3 H.sub.6 O).sub.y (C.sub.2 
           H.sub.4 O).sub.z H                                             
           block                                                          
           where x + z = 4.45                                             
           y = 27.6                                                       
F          HO(C.sub.3 H.sub.6 O).sub.x (C.sub.2 H.sub.4 O).sub.y (C.sub.3 
           H.sub.6 O).sub.z H                                             
           block                                                          
           where x + z = 40.8                                             
           y = 14.8                                                       
G          C.sub.9 H.sub.19 O(C.sub.2 H.sub.4 O).sub.10 (C.sub.3 H.sub.6  
           O).sub.15 H                                                    
           block                                                          
H          C.sub.10 H.sub.21 O(C.sub.2 H.sub.4 O).sub.4 (C.sub.3 H.sub.6  
           O).sub.8 H                                                     
           block                                                          
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     
                       TABLE I                                                     
______________________________________                                    
EVALUATION OF A MECHANICAL DISHWASHER                                     
DETERGENT WITHOUT A SURFACTANT                                            
TEST                NO SURFACTANT                                         
______________________________________                                    
Dishwasher Foam Test.sup.1                                                
                    45                                                    
(ratio %)                                                                 
Spotting and Filming index.sup.2                                          
                    3.4 (after 7                                          
                    cycles)                                               
                    &gt;7 cycles = 5                                         
______________________________________                                    
 .sup.1 The dishwasher foam test is described in Example 1.               
 .sup.2 The spotting and filming test is described in Example 2.          
 
    
     
                       TABLE II                                                    
______________________________________                                    
EVALUATION OF THE EFFECT OF MOLECULAR                                     
WEIGHT AND ETHYLENE/PROPYLENE OXIDE                                       
CONTENT OF FOAM CONTROL AGENT ACTIVITY                                    
                            DISHWASHER                                    
FOAM CONTROL MOLECULAR                                                    
                    WT %    FOAM TEST                                     
AGENT      WEIGHT       E.O.    (RATIO %)                                 
______________________________________                                    
none       --           --      45                                        
1          1000         50      50                                        
2          1000         50      34                                        
3          1980         50      53                                        
4          3500         50      85                                        
5          4400         50      91                                        
6           360          0      36                                        
7           650          0      39                                        
8          1850          0      67                                        
9          2600          0      61                                        
10         2025          0      68                                        
11         4025          0      64                                        
12         4000         75      33                                        
13         14,000       75      37                                        
14         4000         100     29                                        
15         4500         20      73.9                                      
16         4000         25      100                                       
17         4400         50      91                                        
18         5800         65      61                                        
19         5000         50      100                                       
20         5000         38      100                                       
______________________________________                                    
 .sup.1 The dishwasher foam test is described in Example 1.               
 
    
     
                       TABLE III                                                   
______________________________________                                    
EFFECT OF FOAM CONTROL AGENT MOLECULAR                                    
WEIGHT AND HYDROPHOBICITY OF SPOTTING AND                                 
FILMING PROPERTIES                                                        
FOAM CONTROL DISHWASHER                                                   
MOLECULAR    FOAM TEST    SPOTTING AND                                    
AGENT  WEIGHT    (RATIO %).sup.1                                          
                              FILMING INDEX.sup.2                         
______________________________________                                    
none   --        45           3.4                                         
                              after 7 cycles                              
                              &gt;7 cycles = 5                               
8      1850      67           5.0                                         
2      1000      34           5.0                                         
3      1980      53           2.5                                         
4      3500      85           2.0                                         
5      4400      91           2.0                                         
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     
                       TABLE IV                                                    
______________________________________                                    
EFFECT OF FOAM CONTROL AGENT                                              
CONCENTRATION ON DEFOAMANT ABILITY                                        
MECHANICAL DISHWASHER DETERGENT (MDD)                                     
FORMULATION                                                               
                 Run No. (Wt %)                                           
COMPONENT          1         2      3                                     
______________________________________                                    
Foam control agent No. 5                                                  
                   5.0       2.0    1.0                                   
Sodium Metasilicate                                                       
                   31.7      32.7   33.0                                  
Sodium Tripolyphosphate                                                   
                   31.7      32.7   33.0                                  
Sodium Carbonate   31.6      32.6   33.0                                  
Dishwasher Foam Test (Ratio %).sup.1                                      
                   96        91     68                                    
______________________________________                                    
 .sup.1 The dishwasher foam test is described in Example 1.               
 .sup.2 The spotting and filming index is described in Example 2.         
 
    
     
                       TABLE V                                                     
______________________________________                                    
EFFECT ON MDD PROPERTIES OF ESTERIFICATION                                
OF HYDROXYL TERMINATED FOAM CONTROL AGENT                                 
FOAM     TERMINAL   DISHWASHER   SPOTTING                                 
CONTROL  FUNCTION-  FOAM TEST    AND FILM-                                
AGENT    ALITY.sup.3                                                      
                    (RATIO %).sup.1                                       
                                 INDEX.sup.2                              
______________________________________                                    
4        hydroxyl   85           2.0                                      
4A       acetate    92           1.9                                      
5        hydroxyl   91           2.0                                      
5A       methyl     88           2.8                                      
5B       acetate    94           1.5                                      
5C       butyrate   94           (not                                     
                                 determined)                              
______________________________________                                    
 .sup.1 The dishwasher foam test is described in Example 1.               
 .sup.2 The spotting and filming index is described in Example 2.         
 .sup.3 The R group of the foam control agent structural formula:         
 RO(C.sub.3 H.sub.6 O).sub.x (C.sub.2 H.sub.4 O).sub.y H is butyl in agent
 5A, 4A, 5B and 5C.                                                       
 
    
     
                                           TABLE VI                                
__________________________________________________________________________
COMPARATIVE EVALUATION OF FOAM CONTROL                                    
AGENTS WITH VARIOUS MDD SURFACTANTS                                       
HAVING BLOCK STRUCTURE                                                    
FOAM                      SPOTTING                                        
CONTROL          DISHWASHER                                               
                          AND                                             
AGENT OR MOLECULAR                                                        
                 FOAM TEST                                                
                          FILMING BLOCK/                                  
SURFACTANT                                                                
         WEIGHT  (RATIO %).sup.1                                          
                          INDEX.sup.2                                     
                                  RANDOM                                  
__________________________________________________________________________
None     --      45       3.4     --                                      
                          (after 7 cycles)                                
                          &gt;7 cylces = 5                                   
G        1453    92       3.6     block                                   
H         797    59       2.2     block                                   
F        3120    95       2.5     block                                   
 5       4500    91       1.5     random                                  
21       8989    88       2.6     random                                  
22       1800    100      2.0     random                                  
23       5100    92       2.1     random                                  
24       4400    100      2.0     random                                  
25       5800    100      1.6     random                                  
26       5000    100      1.8     random                                  
27       4700    100      1.4     random                                  
28       4200    94       1.5     random                                  
__________________________________________________________________________
 .sup.1 The diswasher foam test is described in Example 1.                
 .sup.2 The spotting and filming index is described in Example 2.         
 
    
     Although the invention has been illustrated by the preceding examples it is not to be construed as being limted to the materials employed therein, but rather, the invention encompasses the generic area as hereinbefore disclosed. Various modifications and embodiments thereof can be made without departing from the spirit or scope thereof.