Patent Publication Number: US-4836849-A

Title: Oxidation resistant niobium alloy

Description:
The government of the United States of America has rights in this invention under Contract No. N00019-82-C-0384 with the Department of Defense. 
    
    
     BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 
     Niobium alloys that have high strength at high temperatures do not resist oxidation well. These alloys rapidly oxidize, resulting in the recession of the metal and the ultimate failure of the alloy as a structural part. While oxidation resistant niobium alloys have been made, such alloys do not have high strength at high temperatures. Attempts have been made to solve this problem by coating parts made with high strength niobium alloys with an oxidation resistant alloy. However, once the coating has cracked, abraded, or otherwise been penetrated, catastrophic failure of the underlying niobium alloy can occur. 
     SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
     We have discovered that it is possible to make a shape from a niobium alloy which can withstand oxidation at high temperatures and still exhibit high strength. We were able to accomplish this by mechanically alloying a powdered niobium alloy with powdered intermetallic compounds, intimately mixing the components together and altering the particle size distribution, and then forming the shape from the intimately mixed particles. That the resulting shape still displays high strength at high temperatures is surprising since some of the niobium alloy particles that form the shape are now separated from each other by a mixture of the intermetallic particles. Nevertheless, shapes formed from the mechanically alloyed particles prepared according to this invention display both high strength and oxidation resistance at high temperatures which, until now, has not been achieved. 
     DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION 
     Any powdered niobium alloy can be used in this invention. Particularly applicable are those niobium alloys that are used for commercial structures, especially structures that are exposed to high temperatures and require high strength, as it is in those applications that the benefits of this invention are the greatest. The following table gives some examples of niobium alloys and their properties. 
     
         __________________________________________________________________________
                         Composition        Density                       
Classification                                                            
          Developer                                                       
                   Designation                                            
                         (Wt %)             (g/cc)/lbs/in                 
__________________________________________________________________________
Group 1                                                                   
High Strength                                                             
          General Electric                                                
                   Cb-1  Nb--30W--1Zr--0.06C                              
                                            10.30/0.372                   
Low Ductility                                                             
          Westinghouse                                                    
                   B-88  Nb--28W--2Hf--0.067C                             
                                            10.33/0.372                   
          Westinghouse                                                    
                   B-99  Nb--22W--2Hf--0.067C                             
                                            9.85/0.356                    
          Pratt &amp; Whitney                                                 
                   Cb-132M                                                
                         Nb--15W--5Mo--20Ta--25Zr--0.13C                  
                                            10.66/0.385                   
          General Electric                                                
                   AS30  Nb--20W--12Zr--0.1C                              
                                            9.60/0.347                    
          General Electric                                                
                   F-48  Nb--15W--5Mo--1Zr--0.1C                          
                                            9.41/0.34060                  
          Imperial Metal                                                  
                   SU31  Nb--17W--3.5Hf--0.1C                             
                                            9.55/0.345                    
Group II                                                                  
Moderate Strength                                                         
          Imperial Metal                                                  
                   SU16  Nb--11W--3Mo--1Hf--0.08C                         
                                            9.27/0.335                    
Moderate Ductility                                                        
          Fansteel FS85  Nb--10W--28Ta--1Zr 10.60/0.383                   
          DuPont   D-43  Nb--10W--1Zr--0.1C 9.02/0.326                    
          Union Carbide                                                   
                   Cb-752                                                 
                         Nb--10W--2.5Zr     9.02/0.326                    
          Fansteel SCb-291                                                
                         Nb--10W--10Ta      9.60/0.347                    
          Wah Chang                                                       
                   C129-)Y                                                
                         Nb--10W--10Hf--0.2Y                              
                                            9.49/0.343                    
          Westinghouse                                                    
                   B-66  Nb--5Mo--5Y--1Zr   8.44/0.305                    
          General Electric                                                
                   AS55  Nb--5W--1Zr--0.2Y  8.77/0.317                    
          Pratt &amp; Whitney                                                 
                   PWC-11                                                 
                         Nb--1Zr--0.1C      8.58/0.310                    
Group III                                                                 
Low Strength                                                              
          Union Carbide                                                   
                   CB-753                                                 
                         Nb--5V--1.25Zr     8.39/0.303                    
High Ductility                                                            
          Wah Chang                                                       
                   C103  Nb--10Hf-- 0.7Zr   8.86/0.320                    
          Westinghouse                                                    
                   B33   Nb--5V             8.47/0.306                    
          DuPont   D14   Nb--5Zr            8.58/0.310                    
          DuPont   D36   Nb--5Zr--10Ti      7.92/0.286                    
                   Nb--1Zr                                                
                         Nb--1Zr            8.58/0.310                    
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     Examples of preferred structural niobium alloys include &#34;B-88&#34; and &#34;Nb-1Zr.&#34; A powder of the niobium alloy can be prepared in many different ways, including, for example, rapid solidification techniques, where a rotating rod of the alloy is ablated by a plasma arc in an inert gas. Other techniques for forming the powder include melt spinning, dripping a melted alloy on a rotating disk, splat cooling, etc. The powdered niobium alloy may have any particle size desired. 
     The intermetallic compounds that are useful in mixing with the niobium alloy particles according to this invention include niobium aluminide (NbAl 3 ), NbFe 2 , NbCo 2 , and NbCr 2 . We have found that other similar or related compounds, such as Nb 2  Al, Nb 3  Al, and NbNi do not form the proper oxide phases on heating to adequately protect the niobium alloy from oxidation. Of the four intermetallic compounds that may be used, NbFe 2  and NbCo 2  seem to work the best; NbCr 2  reduces oxidation but because chromium is volatile it cannot withstand temperatures as high as the other intermetallic compounds. Particularly preferred are mixtures of NbAl 3  and NbFe 2 , NbAl 3  and NbCo 2 , and NbAl 3  and NbCr 2  because, in the presence of oxygen, these compounds are believed to form a rutile oxide that has the structure NbM&#39;O 4 , or a gamma oxide layer having the structure M&#39; 2  O 3 , or a spinel layer having the structure MAl 2  O 4 , where M is Fe, Co, Cr, or mixtures thereof, and M&#39;  is M or Al. These oxides are very effective in resisting the penetration of oxygen, thereby preventing oxygen from attacking the underlying niobium alloy. Of these three mixtures, the mixture of NbAl 3  and NbCo 2  is most preferred because the resulting rutile oxide has been reported to undergo no phase transformations, and therefore a coating formed of it is less likely to crack when the temperature is changed. While mixtures of the intermetallic compounds can be formed in any ratio, a preferred ratio of the mixtures with NbAl 3  is about a 1:1 to about a 3:1 volume ratio of NbAl 3  to NbM 2  because more aluminum may reduce the mechanical stability of the resulting shape and less aluminum may reduce its oxidation resistance. The powdered intermetallic compound can be made in a variety of ways. It is typically made by melting a mixture of the component elements and pulverizing the resulting ingot. The particle size of the intermetallic compound is preferably the same or smaller than the particle size of the niobium alloy as that facilitates the mixing of the particles of the niobium alloy with the particles of the intermetallic compound. 
     In the first step of the process of this invention, a mixture is formed of about 55% to about 90% by volume of the powdered niobium alloy and about 10% to about 45% by volume of the powdered intermetallic compound. If less intermetallic compound is used in the mixture the resulting shape will be more susceptible to oxidation, and more intermetallic compound may make the shape more brittle. 
     In the next step of the process of this invention, the mixture of the powdered niobium alloy and the powdered intermetallic compound is mechanically alloyed. Mechanical alloying is a process that mechanically mixes the intermetallic particles and the niobium alloy particles. Mechanical alloying can be accomplished in a variety of ways, including using a ball mill or an attritor, techniques well-known in the art. 
     Finally, the mechanically alloyed mixture is consolidated to form a shape, using any powder metallurgical consolidation technique. Examples of such techniques including hot isostatic pressing (HIPing), explosive bonding, cold pressing and sintering, hot pressing, hot rolling, and hot extruding. For additional protection against oxidation, the shape can be coated with an oxidation resistant coating such as, for example, silicides containing Cr, Ti, Al, and/or B; aluminides containing Cr, FeB, SiO 2 , Fe, Ni, and/or Si; or noble metal coatings containing Pt, Rh, Hf, and/or Ir. The resulting shape can be coated after fabrication or machining, as desired, to final tolerances. 
     The shape is particularly useful for applications that require high strength at high temperatures in the presence of oxygen such as, for example, the combustors, turbine blades, and nozzles of jet engines. 
     The following examples further illustrate this invention. 
    
    
     EXAMPLE 
     The powdered niobium alloy, &#34;B-88,&#34; was prepared from a 2.5 inch diameter ingot, which was made by vacuum arc-melting an electrode composed of niobium plate, tungsten sheets, hafnium foil, and carbon cloth threads. The ingot was converted in to a spherical powder by rotating the ingot at 15,000 rpm while heating one end with a plasma in an inert gas atmosphere. Material melted by the plasma was flung off the ingot, forming spherical particles as it cooled during flight. The following table gives the particles size distribution of the resulting powder. 
     
         ______________________________________                                    
Sieve Size                                                                
(U.S. Series)                                                             
            35     45     60   80   120  170  230                         
______________________________________                                    
Particle Size (μm)                                                     
            500    354    250  177  125  88   63                          
Percent on Screen                                                         
            0.1    3.6    18.2 24.6 24.2 15.8 8.2                         
Percent Finer Than                                                        
            99.9   96.3   78.1 53.5 29.3 13.5 5.3                         
This Size                                                                 
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     Three intermetallic compounds, NbAl 3 , NbFe 2 , and NbCo 2  were produced by non-consumably arc-melting large buttons of the appropriate composition. The buttons were converted into a powder by crushing and passing through a series of screens, 35 to 325 mesh. 
     Two powder mixtures were prepared, the first containing 80 volume percent of the &#34;B-88&#34; alloy and 20  volume percent of NbAl 3  -NbFe 2  in a 2:1 volume ratio, and the second containing 65 volume percent of the &#34;B-88&#34; alloy and 35 volume percent of NbAl 3  -NbFe 2  in a 2:1 volume ratio. The two powder mixtures were mechanically alloyed in a stainless steel ball mill using 1/2 inch nominal stainless steel balls an argon atmosphere. The milled powders had the following particle size distribution: 
     
         ______________________________________                                    
            % of Powder Retained                                          
Sieve Size  on the Sleeve                                                 
______________________________________                                    
+270        34                                                            
+325        15                                                            
+400         7                                                            
-400        44                                                            
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     A scanning electron photomicrograph of the powders after milling showed that the mechanical alloying caused the intermetallics to intimately mix with the &#34;B-88&#34; alloy particles, and to fragment and imbed on the surface of the &#34;B-88&#34; alloy particles. 
     (Attempts to consolidate the alloyed powder by explosive bonding were not successful; however, additional experimentation with explosive bonding techniques may 
     Powders that were not mechanically alloyed and that were consolidated using hot isostatic pressing produced shapes that were unable to resist oxidation at 1000° C. Powders that were mechanically alloyed and were hot isostatically pressed at a temperature of 1200° C. and pressure of 30,000 psi for 30 minutes, however, showed no internal oxidation at 1000° C., 1175° C., and 1275° C. after 14.7, 15.3, and 21.6 hours, respectively, at each temperature with no cooling to room temperature in between. The microstructure of the shape showed no indication of internal oxidation, no penetration of the oxygen into the alloy structure, and no degradation of mechanical properties. The metal recession ranged from 13 to 18 mils per 100 hours at 1175° and 1275° C., respectively, for the alloy with 35  volume percent intermetallics. An identical &#34;B-88&#34; alloy with no intermetallics present had a recession rate of greater than 50 mils per 100 hours at 1175 and 1275° C.