Patent Publication Number: US-2021164302-A1

Title: Winch overload protection system

Description:
BACKGROUND 
     Hydraulic Workover Units (HWOs) for use with oil/gas wells typically use one or more winches mounted on a mast (also called a “gin pole”) attached to the unit for lifting pipe and other equipment. Frequently, the winch is connected via cable to the pipe or other downhole tools when the pipe or tools are made ready to insert into or remove from a well. Existing HWOs, and the components thereof, have generally been considered satisfactory for their intended purpose. However, there is still a need in the art for improvements thereto. The present disclosure provides a solution for this need. 
     BRIEF DESCRIPTION 
     Reference is now made to the following descriptions taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which: 
       FIG. 1  is an elevation view of an example workover system according to aspects of the present disclosure; and 
       FIG. 2  is an operational diagram of an alternative embodiment of a winch overload protection system in accordance with the disclosure. 
    
    
     DETAILED DESCRIPTION 
     The present disclosure is directed, in part, to helping ensure that the travelling slip and winch of a Hydraulic Workover Unit (HWO) are sufficiently synchronized (i.e. “in sync”). Specifically, aspects of the present disclosure include avoiding situations when the travelling slip is operational, and moving, when the winch is inoperable, and more particularly when the brake of the winch is set. 
     In one aspect, a winch overload protection system is provided for use with the HWO. For example, a winch overload protection system may include an overload detection unit and overload control unit. In one implementation, the overload detection unit may be configured to detect when a load on the winch exceeds a safety load limit, and the overload control unit may be configured to receive an overload signal from the overload detection unit. In response, a brake on the winch may be released. 
     Reference will now be made to the drawings wherein like reference numerals identify similar structural features or aspects of the subject disclosure. For purposes of explanation and illustration, and not limitation,  FIG. 1  illustrates an elevation view of an example workover system  100  according to aspects of the present disclosure. The workover system  100  includes a rig  110  (e.g., an HWO in the illustrated embodiment) mounted at the surface  180  and positioned above wellbore  185  within a subterranean formation  190 . In the embodiment shown, a downhole tool or pipe  195  is to be positioned within the wellbore  185  and may be coupled to the rig  110 , as shown. 
     In accordance with the disclosure, the rig  110 , illustrated as a HWO, includes a stationary slip  115  and a travelling slip  120 . As those skilled in the art appreciate, the travelling slip  120 , in the embodiment shown, may be coupled to one or more jack cylinders  125  (e.g., hydraulic jack cylinders in one embodiment) that are configured to cycle the travelling slip  120  in a linear path relative to the stationary slip  115 . In this deployment, the stationary slip  115  and travelling slip  120  can work together to collectively insert or remove various different types of downhole tools or pipes  195  in the wellbore  185 . 
     The rig  100 , in the embodiment shown, further includes a winch  130 , having a cable  135  (e.g., any known or hereafter discovered wire, rope, etc.) associated therewith. In accordance with the disclosure, the winch  130  additionally includes a brake  140  associated therewith. The brake  140 , as those skilled in the art appreciate, is designed to stop the cable  135 , and thus the downhole tools or pipes  195  coupled thereto, from moving under certain circumstances. The brake  140  may comprise a mechanical, electrical, or hydraulic brake, among others, and remain with the scope of the disclosure. 
     The workover system  100 , in accordance with the disclosure, further includes a winch overload protection system  150  associated with the rig  110 . In the embodiment shown, the winch overload protection system  150  includes an overload detection unit  155 . The overload detection unit  155 , in this embodiment, is operable to detect when a load on the winch  130  exceeds a safety load limit. The safety load limit may be a fixed value, or alternatively, a customizable value. For example, the safety load limit could be tailored based upon the design of the rig  110 , the winch  130 , the downhole tools or pipes  195  being deployed, as well as other relevant factors. In one embodiment, the value of the safety load limit is chosen such that it will be triggered prior to the other relevant features failing. 
     The overload protection system  150 , in accordance with the disclosure, further includes an overload control unit  160 . The overload control unit  160 , in the illustrated embodiment, is configured to receive an overload signal from the overload detection unit  155 , and in response thereto release the brake  140  on the winch  130 . In doing so, the overload control unit  160  attempts to eliminate any damage that may result with the workover system  100  as a result of the winch exceeding the safety load limit. 
     In one embodiment, the overload control unit  160 , or the brake  140 , must be actively reset prior to the workover system  100  being used again. In yet another embodiment, the overload control unit  160  may independently reset itself, for example automatically without human involvement. Another embodiment exists wherein the overload control unit  160  reengages the brake  140  on the winch  130  when the load on the winch  130  no longer exceeds the safety load limit. 
     A possible condition can exist where the traveling slip  120  is still operational while the brake  140  is engaged, thereby creating an overload condition. Accordingly, the overload control unit  160  may additionally be configured to stop a movement of the travelling slip  120  in response to receiving the overload signal from the overload detection unit  155 . By releasing the brake  140 , and stopping a movement of the travelling slip  120 , the workover system  100  is materially protected from a winch  130  overload situation. 
     In accordance with the disclosure, the overload control unit  160  may further be configured to maintain back pressure on the winch  130  upon the release of the brake  140 . The back pressure, in this embodiment, is designed to maintain at least some tension on the cable  135 , such that it does not spool off uncontrollably when the brake  140  is released. 
     The winch overload protection system  150  may further include a test unit  165 . The test unit  165 , in one embodiment, is configured to intentionally simulate an overload situation, thus artificially creating the overload signal to thereby test the winch overload protection system. The test unit  165 , in this embodiment, may be deployed to periodically test the readiness and reliability of the winch overload protection system  150 . 
     The rig  110  illustrated in  FIG. 1  further includes a mast pole  170 . While the embodiment shown illustrates the mast pole  170  as stationary, other embodiments exist wherein the mast pole  170  telescopes to various different heights, for example to handle different lengths of downhole tools or pipes  195  being deployed. The rig  110  may further include a blowout preventer stack  175 . In the illustrated embodiment, the blowout preventer stack  175  is positioned in-line between the stationary slip  115  and the surface  180 . Those skilled in the art appreciate the purpose and location of the blowout preventer stack  175 , as well as the many different designs it may take. 
     The workover system  100  may additionally include any suitable wired drillpipe, coiled tubing (wired and unwired), e.g., accommodating a wireline for control of the system from the surface  180  during downhole operation. It is also contemplated that the workover system  100  as described herein can be used in conjunction with a measurement-while-drilling (MWD) apparatus, which may be incorporated into the downhole tool or pipe  195  for insertion in the wellbore  185  as part of a MWD system. In a MWD system, sensors associated with the MWD apparatus provide data to the MWD apparatus for communicating up the downhole tool or pipe  195  to an operator of the workover system  100 . These sensors typically provide directional information of the downhole tool or pipe  195  so that the operator can monitor the orientation of the downhole tool or pipe  195  in response to data received from the MWD apparatus and adjust the orientation of the downhole tool or pipe  195  in response to such data. An MWD system also typically enables the communication of data from the operator of the system down the wellbore  185  to the MWD apparatus. Systems and methods as disclosed herein can also be used in conjunction with logging-while-drilling (LWD) systems, which log data from sensors similar to those used in MWD systems as described herein. 
     The workover system  100  of  FIG. 1  may be used to trip a workover system, and more particularly downhole tools or pipe, into or out of a wellbore. In accordance with the disclosure, as the hydraulic workover unit trips the downhole tool or pipe into or out of the wellbore, the winch overload protection system is detecting for winch overload situations. When the winch overload protection system detects when a load on the winch exceeds the safety load limit, it sends an overload signal to the overload control unit. In accordance with the disclosure, when the overload control unit receives the overload signal, it releases the brake on the winch. 
     Turning to  FIG. 2 , illustrated is an operational diagram of an alternative embodiment of a winch overload protection system  200  in accordance with the disclosure. The winch overload protection system  200  illustrated in  FIG. 2  primarily operates using hydraulics, thus may represent a hydraulic circuit. As shown in  FIG. 2 , winch  205  is supported by frame  210  which is connected to a cylinder  215  that acts as the pre-loaded force (e.g., anti-pivot) device. Frame  210  is pivotally connected to an essentially fixed point at one end, and to cylinder  215  and movement sensor  220  at the other. Frame  210  is thus a pivotable frame. Similarly the cylinder  215  is pivotally connected to an essentially fixed point at its bottom end, and movement sensor  220  is fixed in proximity to frame  210 . This arrangement is such that vertical force on the winch cable tends to lift and pivot frame  210  and thereby extend cylinder  215  and also lift the frame off of movement sensor  220 . 
     In the embodiment shown, cylinder  215  is supplied with a constant pressure to its rod end via pressure reducing/relieving valve  230 , which tends to hold the cylinder  215  fully retracted with a force proportional to the supply pressure. As long as the supply pressure from valve  230  times the area of the rod end of cylinder  215 , adjusted for mechanical advantage, is greater than the maximum allowable cable tension, then frame  210  will be held against movement sensor  220  such that its plunger is depressed. In the embodiment of  FIG. 2 , movement sensor  220  is dispositioned such that it does not activate the overload protection system as long as its plunger is held down. 
     If and when the winch cable is pulled with a force that exceeds hydraulic pre-load of cylinder  215 , then pressure reducing/relieving valve  230  will vent the overpressure on the rod end of the cylinder  215  back to the hydraulic reservoir, allowing cylinder  215  to extend. Subsequently frame  210  will rise as it rotates about its pivot point and lift off of movement sensor  220  activating the overload protection system. In this manner the pressure from valve  230  applied to the rod end of the cylinder, combined with the physical geometry of the mechanism can be used to calculate and/or pre-set the maximum operating force on the winch cable, above which the overload system activates. 
     In the embodiment of  FIG. 2 , the winch brake  235  is normally engaged by internal springs and released by pressure tapped from the operator&#39;s winch control valve  262  via line  240  when lowering a load and cable is pulled off the winch  205 . 
     When the operator centers control valve  262  the brake line  240  is vented, which engages the brake  235  via the internal springs. This ensures that the load will not fall when no winch  205  movement is commanded by the operator. Shuttle valve  242  is provided so that the brake can be operated either by the normal operator control or by the overload protection control system. When the overload system is activated by movement of frame  210 , it triggers movement sensor  220 , then movement sensor  220  directs hydraulic pressure from the supply source through shuttle  242  to release brake  235  preventing further overload. 
     In the embodiment of  FIG. 2 , valve  244  is a motor control or counterbalance valve that is typically present in winch  205  hydraulic systems to allow controlled descent of a load. Valve  246  is a relief type valve that is interposed between the winch  205  and valve  244 . Its purpose is to maintain back pressure to the winch  205  once the overload is triggered, keeping a safe amount of tension on the winch cable to prevent uncontrolled release of the cable. Because valve  246  is between the winch  205  and the motor control valve  244 , all of the lines shown as heavy solid lines in  FIG. 2  should typically be hard plumbed rather than by use of hoses. This is to reduce the risk that breakage in the intervening lines will allow the load to fall uncontrolled. Once the overload protection system is triggered, valve  246  recirculates oil around the motor, but at a controlled pressure. Typically, valve  246  is set so that it opens at a load that is slightly higher than the overload setting of the brake. In the embodiment of  FIG. 2 , valve  248  is a low pressure relief valve that is provided to avoid loss of the recirculated oil (when overload is triggered) to prevent possible cavitation of the winch motor, which could result in loss of load control. 
     Valve  230 , as described in the embodiment above, is essentially the overload setting control to pre-set the amount of force needed to trigger the overload protection system. It is supplied directly via a constant hydraulic supply pressure that should be higher than that demanded by valve  230  to set the overload force. Accumulator  250  can be used to provide backup pressure in case the normal supply pressure fails. Check valve  252  ensures that accumulator  250  stays charged once brought up to pressure. 
     In the system depicted in  FIG. 2 , two interlocks are included to enhance the overall safety of operation of this system. Jack interrupt valve  254  provides a “vent” type signal once the overload protection is triggered. Normally this would be used to cause the HWO unit&#39;s traveling slip to stop once an overload is detected. Since the normal source of any such winch overload is the HWO unit&#39;s travelling slip moving downwards, stopping the travelling slip provides additional safety. The second interlock is provided by valves  256  and  258 . Valve  258  is normally set to “vent” both the brake  235  and the HWO Jack interlock. It is shifted to “closed” when valve  256  is supplied with the minimum required system supply pressure. With this arrangement, neither the travelling slip nor the winch  205  can be operated unless the overload protection system has adequate pressure to arm the system. Check valve  260  is present to isolate the supply pressure interlock from the normal jack interrupt function upon overload. 
     In the embodiment of  FIG. 2 , the main operator control for the winch  205  is valve  262 . The operator uses this valve to raise and lower loads with the winch, with brake control provided automatically by sense of line  240  through shuttle valve  242 . Spring-biased check valve  264  can be installed on the return line of the operator&#39;s control valve to prevent drainage of fluid out of the winch  205  power lines and thereby help reduce risk of winch motor cavitation. Two pressure gauges can be installed in the operator console that display the system supply pressure  266 , and to show if the winch brake is being operated by the overload protection system  268 . 
     A self-test feature can also be provided via remotely operated valve  270  and by operator control valve  272 . When valve  272  is shifted it also shifts valve  270  to reverse the pressure to cylinder  215 . This causes the cylinder to extend and lift frame  210  and winch  205 . This immediately demonstrates that frame  210  is free to move, and that adequate system pressure is available on gauge  266 . Movement of the winch and frame  210  triggers the overload system to apply pressure to the brake causing it to release, which can be verified on pressure gauge  268 . With this arrangement the readiness and operation of the overload protection system can be fully tested at any time as long as there is no load on the winch. The system as depicted will automatically disengage the winch brake upon overload of the winch, and also automatically reset once the overload condition is removed from the winch. This has the advantage of not requiring any operator intervention for normal overload protection system operation. 
       FIG. 2  has illustrated but one embodiment of a winch overload protection system  200 . In fact, a winch overload protection system manufactured according to the disclosure may vary greatly from that depicted in  FIG. 2 . For example, cylinder  215  can be replaced by a spring that has been preloaded to the required overload force setting. Additionally, some or all of the hydraulic overload controls can be replaced with electrical devices that have similar functions. Along those lines, some or all of the hydraulic overload controls can be operated via electrical solenoids and switches rather than pilot pressure. 
     In alternative embodiments, movement sensor  220  can be replaced with an electrical or electronic switch to operate any or all electrical controls. Additionally, accumulator  250  can be replaced with a battery backup device to operate any or all electrical controls, or be replaced with an active redundant hydraulic or electrical supply. Moreover, the system can be designed and operated without the self-test function, eliminating valves  270  and  272 . 
     In yet alternative embodiments, this system can be designed and operated without valves  248  and/or  264 , but with increased operational risk. Moreover, frame  210 , shown as a pivoting beam or plate, can be replaced with beam(s) and/or plate(s) that are mobilized with pins, hinges, rollers, tracks, slides, etc., such that the frame  210  moves substantially in the direction of the winch cable when a force is applied by the cable. Additionally, pressure gauges can be installed in line with any of the adjustable valves to facilitate setting of those valves. 
     In even alternative embodiments, the system can be designed and operated without the HWO Jack interrupt feature. Moreover, the hydraulic and/or electrical controls can be grouped in module(s) or manifold(s) to consolidate components. 
     While the above system has been discussed for use with HWO operations, the present disclosure should not be limited to such. For example, a winch overload protection system as discussed herein can be installed on or with most any winch to provide overload protection in many applications, and remain within the purview of the disclosure. 
     Embodiments disclosed herein include:
     A. A winch overload protection system, comprising an overload detection unit operable to detect when a load on a winch of a workover system exceeds a safety load limit, and an overload control unit configured to receive an overload signal from the overload detection unit, and in response thereto release a brake on the winch.   B. A workover system, comprising a hydraulic workover unit elevated over a wellbore. The hydraulic workover unit, in this instance including a stationary slip, a travelling slip coupled to one or more hydraulic jack cylinders, the one or more hydraulic jack cylinders configured to cycle the travelling slip in a linear path relative to the stationary slip, and a winch having a cable and brake associated therewith, the winch configured to provide downhole tools and or pipe to the travelling slip for inclusion within or removal from the wellbore. The workover system, in this instance, may additionally comprise a winch overload protection system associated with the hydraulic workover unit, the winch overload system including an overload detection unit operable to detect when a load on the winch exceeds a safety load limit, and an overload control unit configured to receive an overload signal from the overload detection unit, and in response thereto release the brake on the winch.   C. A method of operating a workover system, comprising, tripping downhole tools and or pipe into or out of a wellbore using a workover system, wherein the workover system includes a hydraulic workover unit elevated over the wellbore, the hydraulic workover unit including a stationary slip, a travelling slip coupled to one or more hydraulic jack cylinders, the one or more hydraulic cylinders configured to cycle the travelling slip in a linear path relative to the stationary slip, and a winch having a cable and brake associated therewith, the winch configured to provide the downhole tools and or pipe to the travelling slip for inclusion within the wellbore. The method, in this instance, further comprises detecting winch overload situations during the tripping using a winch overload protection system associated with the hydraulic workover unit, the winch overload system including an overload detection unit operable to detect when a load on the winch exceeds a safety load limit, and an overload control unit configured to receive an overload signal from the overload detection unit, and in response thereto release the brake on the winch.   

     Each of the embodiments A, B and C may have one or more of the following additional elements in combination: 
     Element 1: wherein the overload control unit is further configured to stop the movement of an associated travelling slip of a hydraulic workover unit in response to receiving the overload signal. Element 2: wherein the overload control unit is configured to maintain back pressure on the winch to maintain a safe amount of tension in a cable thereof when the brake is released. Element 3: wherein the overload control unit is configured to reengage the brake on the winch when the load on the winch no longer exceeds the safety load limit. Element 4: wherein the overload control unit is configured to reengage the brake automatically without human involvement. Element 5: wherein the overload detection unit includes a pivotable frame for supporting the winch, a pre-loaded anti pivot device coupled to the frame, the pre-loaded anti pivot device configured to hold the frame in a substantially fixed position until the winch exceeds the safety load limit, and a movement sensor for detecting movement of the frame when the winch exceeds the safety load limit. Element 6: wherein the pre-loaded anti pivot device is a hydraulic cylinder and the movement sensor is a hydraulic or an electronic switch. Element 7: further including a test unit, the test unit configured to intentionally extend the hydraulic cylinder to artificially create the overload signal to thereby test the winch overload protection system. Element 8: wherein the pre-loaded anti pivot device is a mechanical spring. Element 9: wherein the overload detection unit and the overload control unit employ a hydraulic circuit to detect when the winch exceeds the safety load limit and release the brake on the winch. Element 10: wherein the movement sensor is a hydraulic switch. Element 11: wherein the movement sensor is an electronic switch. Element 12: further including a test unit, the test unit configured to intentionally extend the hydraulic cylinder to artificially create the overload signal to thereby test the winch overload protection system. 
     Those skilled in the art to which this application relates will appreciate that other and further additions, deletions, substitutions and modifications may be made to the described embodiments.