Patent Publication Number: US-4370147-A

Title: Fuel for compression ignition engines

Description:
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 
     1. Field of the Invention 
     The present invention relates to fuels for internal combustion engines and, more particularly, to such fuels containing an additive ingredient which significantly improves the operating economy and performance of compression ignition (diesel) engines. 
     2. Description of the Prior Art 
     Almost from the inception of the internal combustion engine and certainly from the time of its widespread use, numerous proposals have been advanced for improving one or another performance characteristic of the engine by incorporating one or more additives in the hydrocarbon fuels used in its operation. Among such additives have been various nitro-containing organic compounds, sometimes used for the purpose of increasing the energy content of the fuels and at other times used for the purpose of improving the ignition characteristics of the fuels. German Patent No. 164,634 (1903) discloses gasoline to which has been added as an energy booster, a nitro compound such as dinitronaphthalene, nitronaphthol, nitroglycerine or picric acid (trinitrophenol). Eckart, Brennstaff-Chemie, No. 9. pp. 134-136 (1923) discloses gasoline fuels for racing engines which contain such energy-rich materials as the nitrobenzenes, nitroglycerine, nitronaphthol, dinitronaphthalene, dinitrotoluene and dinitrocellulose in amounts of up to 5%. Similarly, United Kingdom Patent No. 131,869 (1918) proposes the use of a nitro derivative of benzole, toluene, xylol, naphthalene or aniline in such liquid or gaseous combustibles as benzole, petrol, oil, heavy oils, naphtha, and the like. 
     Specifically with regard to fuels for compression ignition, or diesel, engines, U.S. Pat. No. 1,849,051 (1932) describes the addition of a nitro-containing primer composition to accelerate ignition (i.e., increase the cetane rating) of the fuels. The primer can be trinitrophenol, dinitrophenol, dinitrobenzene, trinitroglycerine or trinitrotoluene. U.S. Pat. No. 2,251,156 (1941) describes a diesel fuel of improved ignition quality containing a nitro compound such as 4- nitro benzene diazo thiophenyl ether or 4-nitro benzene diazo hydrosulfide. 
     SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
     In accordance with the present invention, a fuel is provided which significantly improves the operating economy and performance of compression ignition (diesel) engines, said fuel containing from about 1.0×10 -6  to about 1.0×10 -3  parts by weight thereof of at least one isomer of dinitrotoluene. 
     It is an additional feature of the invention herein to further include in said fuel an amount of at least one metal acetylacetonate which is effective to appreciably reduce the level of particulates formed during combustion of the fuel and/or significantly inhibit the accumulation of combustion deposits. 
     DSESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS 
     Any of the known and conventional fuels for the operation of propulsion and stationary diesel engines are suitable for use in the preparation of the fuels of this invention. Table I below sets forth the typical properties of several widely used diesel fuel oils to which a dinitrotoluene isomer or mixture thereof can be added in accordance with the present invention. 
     
                                           TABLE I                                 
__________________________________________________________________________
Average of Selected Properties                                            
of Four Classes of Diesel Oils                                            
                Class 2         Class 4                                   
                Fuels for diesel                                          
                                Heavy-distillate                          
       Class 1  engines in auto-                                          
                         Class 3                                          
                                and residual fuels                        
       Diesel fuel oil                                                    
                mobiles, trucks,                                          
                         Fuels for                                        
                                for large stationary                      
       for city bus and                                                   
                tractors, and                                             
                         railroad                                         
                                and marine diesel                         
Property                                                                  
       similar operations                                                 
                similar operations                                        
                         diesel engines                                   
                                engines                                   
__________________________________________________________________________
Gravity                                                                   
°API                                                               
       41.9     37.3     34.8   34.0                                      
Viscosity                                                                 
at 100° F.:                                                        
Kinematic,                                                                
CS     1.84     2.54     2.74   2.79                                      
Saybolt                                                                   
Universal,                                                                
sec    32.1     34.6     35.2   35.4                                      
Sulfur                                                                    
content,                                                                  
wt. %  0.142    0.223    0.287  0.543                                     
Aniline point                                                             
°F.                                                                
       148.6    146.2    140.2  139.3                                     
Ramsbottom                                                                
carbon                                                                    
residue on                                                                
10% resi-                                                                 
duum, %                                                                   
       0.057    0.088    0.117  0.163                                     
Ash, % 0.0005   0.0009   0.0010 0.0023                                    
Cetane                                                                    
number 51.1     50.0     47.0   46.7                                      
Distillation                                                              
test:                                                                     
IBP, °F.                                                           
       356      380      388    397                                       
10%, °F.                                                           
       393      430      440    448                                       
50%, °F.                                                           
       440      490      502    509                                       
90%    501      557      574    582                                       
EP, °F.                                                            
       542      600      618    622                                       
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     Such oils may, and frequently do, contain one or more conventional additives, e.g., ignition improvers such as amyl nitrate, starting-aid fluids such as ether or ether and heptane, viscosity modifiers, lubricants, detergents, anti-smoking agents, and so forth. 
     Any of the dinitrotoluene isomers set forth in Table II below can be used herein, singly or in admixture: 
     
                       TABLE II                                                    
______________________________________                                    
dinitrotoluene                                                            
isomer        melting point °C.                                    
______________________________________                                    
2,4-dinitrotoluene                                                        
              71                                                          
2,3-dinitrotoluene                                                        
              63                                                          
2,5-dinitrotoluene                                                        
              48                                                          
2,6-dinitrotoluene                                                        
              66                                                          
3,4-dinitrotoluene                                                        
              59                                                          
3,5-dinitrotoluene                                                        
              92                                                          
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     For the sake of economy and convenience, it is preferred to employ the most commonly available isomer, 2,4-dinitrotoluene, which in commerce, is frequently supplied in admixture with a minor amount of 2,6-dinitrotoluene, the latter occurring in the manufacture of the former. In the present invention, a commercially available 80:20 weight mixture of the 2,4 and 2,6 isomers which melts at approximately 56° C. has been found to provide entirely acceptable results. 
     By themselves, none of the foregoing dinitrotoluene isomers are soluble in diesel fuel and they must therefore be incorporated in the fuel with the aid of a mutual solvent. The choice of mutual solvent is not a critical requirement of the present invention, it only being necessary that the solvent effect the complete dissolution of the dinitrotoluene at its level of concentration in a particular fuel oil medium. Whether a particular substance is suitable for use as a mutual solvent herein can be readily determined employing standard techniques, i.e., solubility testing. Among the mutual solvents which can be advantageously used for this purpose, alone or in admixture, are dimethylformamide, halogenated hydrocarbons such as ortho-dichlorobenzene, trichloropropane and methylene chloride, cyclic ethers such as tetrahydrofuran and dioxolane, tricresyl phosphate, and the like. In general, the minimum amount of mutual solvent which results in complete dissolution of the selected isomer or isomer mixture in a given diesel oil is preferred. Concentrations of isomer in the foregoing solvents ranging from about 5 to about 25 weight percent are usually suitable. 
     An amount of dinitrotoluene isomer/mutual solvent solution is added to the diesel fuel to provide a final concentration of isomer in the fuel of from about 1.0×10 -6  to about 1.0×10 -3  by weight and preferably from about 1.5×10 -6  to about 1.0×10 -5  parts by weight. 
     At levels significantly below 1.0×10 -6  parts by weight of fuel, the dinitrotoluene isomer will usually be present in the fuel in too small an amount to provide noticeable improvement in engine operating economy; much above 1.0×10 -3 , the dinitrotoluene no longer provides the combustion efficiencies observed at the lower levels of concentration but tends to behave in a completely different way, i.e., as an ignition accelerator or cetane improver. Since most fuels which are treated with dinitrotoluene in accordance with this invention already contain one or more ignition accelerators calculated to provide optimum engine performance, merely contributing to this effect by the addition of dinitrotoluene significantly above 1.0×10 -3  will often only result in a deterioration of engine performance and fuel economy. 
     If desired, the dinitrotoluene/mutual solvent solution can be introduced into a small quantity of fuel oil, with the resulting solution thereafter being combined with a larger quantity of fuel. 
     As shown in the following examples, significant reduction in fuel consumption for a variety of automotive diesel engines were obtained using a fuel in accordance with this invention. In each of these examples, 1 gallon of the following dinitrotoluene/mutual solvent solution in Class 2 diesel fuel oil was dissolved per 1,000 gallons of Class 2 diesel fuel at ambient temperature (Fuel A) and this fuel was then compared with an untreated fuel (Fuel B) under actual in-service conditions. 
     
         ______________________________________                                    
Component          Amount (weight ounces)                                 
______________________________________                                    
80:20 weight mixture of                                                   
                   12.5                                                   
2,4-dinitrotoluene and                                                    
2,6-dinitrotoluene                                                        
dimethylformamide  64                                                     
ortho-dichlorobenzene                                                     
                   64                                                     
methylene chloride 64                                                     
tricresyl phosphate                                                       
                    8                                                     
Class 2 diesel fuel oil                                                   
                   53.3 gallons                                           
                   55 gallons (approx.)                                   
______________________________________                                    
 
    
    
    
     EXAMPLE 1 
     In this example, the gallonage used for the identical period of operation of a fleet of twenty-two tractor-trailor units in two successive periods is reported. The units operated over fixed routes in the same geographical area and cumulatively carried about the same amount of freight per mile during both test periods. The results of the test are set forth in Table III as follows: 
     
                       TABLE III                                                   
______________________________________                                    
Fuel B                   Fuel A                                           
First Year               Second Year                                      
        Distance  Fuel Con-  Distance                                     
                                     Fuel Con-                            
        Traveled  sumption   Traveled                                     
                                     sumption                             
Unit    (miles)   (gallons)  (miles) (gallons)                            
______________________________________                                    
1       1278      214        1216    162                                  
2       1477      260        1079    288                                  
3       1054      196         979    118                                  
4       1091      204        1111    140                                  
5       1442      263        1250    215                                  
6       1811      241        1617    328                                  
7       1233      238        1697    235                                  
8       2152      473        1000    246                                  
9       2676      407        2159    286                                  
10       997      243         726    152                                  
11      1461      279        1587    325                                  
12      1162      191        1158    219                                  
13      1666      416         849     95                                  
14       644      124         823    252                                  
15      1138      162         589    198                                  
16      1546      376         921    185                                  
17      1345      318        1077    133                                  
18      1242      261         721    172                                  
19       956      178        1059    170                                  
20      1154      162        1126    120                                  
21       919      184        1483    303                                  
22      1057      464        1075    146                                  
Total   29501     5854       25302   4486                                 
Computed                                                                  
        5.04             5.64                                             
Average                                                                   
miles                                                                     
per                                                                       
gallon                                                                    
______________________________________                                    
 *Tractor vehicle: Mack F763, Cummins engine, 290 h.p., F. Model, single  
 axle.                                                                    
 
    
     Employing the dinitrotoluene isomer diesel fuel additive of the present invention, the identical fleet of tractor-trailor units over the identical operating period in two successive years averaged a calculated 11.90% increase in mileage compared to the fleet employed the same fuel but omitting the dinitrotoluene isomer. 
     EXAMPLE 2 
     Comparison was made in the identical period of two successive periods between Fuel A of Example 1, which is representative of a Class 2 diesel oil in accordance with the present invention, with an untreated Class 2 diesel oil (designated Fuel B) for operating heavy equipment. The results are set forth in Table IV as follows: 
     
                                           TABLE IV                                
__________________________________________________________________________
                          Fuel B     Fuel A                               
                          First Year Second Year                          
                          Distance                                        
                               Fuel Con-                                  
                                     Distance                             
                                          Fuel Con-                       
                          Traveled                                        
                               sumption                                   
                                     Traveled                             
                                          sumption                        
Unit                                                                      
   Description            (miles)                                         
                               (gallons)                                  
                                     (miles)                              
                                          (gallons)                       
__________________________________________________________________________
1  U600 Mack tractor, 675 max edyne turbocharged                          
                          7489 1826.59                                    
                                     8120 1845.45                         
   engine, 672 in..sup.3, 237 h.p. at 2100 rpm                            
2  Same as (1)            7914 2082.63                                    
                                     8968 2299.49                         
3  B61 Mack flat bed truck, Mack engine, END                              
                          8021 1706.60                                    
                                     7584 1613.62                         
   673 Mode 1672 in..sup.3, 195 h.p. at 2100 rpm                          
4  DM 800 Cummins Model NTC, 335                                          
                          2217  615.83                                    
                                     2048 487.62                          
   turbocharged 852 in..sup.3, h.p. at 2100 rpm                           
5  7000 Ford Caterpillar Engine, 1150 v 200,                              
                          5713 1241.96                                    
                                     7936 1587.20                         
   573 in..sup.3, 200 h.p. at 3000 rpm                                    
6  Same as (5)            6102 1419.07                                    
                                     8147 1697.29                         
7  Same as (5)            7241 1683.95                                    
                                     7128 1485.00                         
8  Same as (5)            6328 1622.56                                    
                                     7840 1823.26                         
9  VT 555C, Cummins engine, 550 in..sup.3, 220 h.p.                       
                           917  183.40                                    
                                     1063 204.42                          
   at 2850 rpm                                                            
10 Michigan Payloader      540  580.02                                    
                                      863 836.00                          
Total                     52482                                           
                               12,926.69                                  
                                     59670                                
                                          13,879.35                       
Computed Average Miles per Gallon                                         
                          4.06       4.30                                 
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     Fuel A in the above comparison study provided an average 5.91% increase in mileage over untreated fuel B. 
     EXAMPLE 3 
     Fuel A of Example 1 was compared with an untreated Class 2 diesel fuel oil (Fuel B) in the identical periods of two successive periods in the operation of 27 vehicles of the following numbers and type: 
     
         ______________________________________                                    
Number of                                                                 
Units of Each Type                                                        
             Description                                                  
______________________________________                                    
6            1979 Chevrolet tractors, turbocharged                        
             6 cyl. 92 series, 270 h.p.                                   
9            1976 Mack Mac Scania ET 477 series                           
             dump trucks, 160 h.p.                                        
7            1978 Chevrolet V-8 backloaders, - 71 series, 318 h.p.        
5            1977 Dodge tractors (snow blowers), - 6 cyl., 71 series, 238 
             h.p.                                                         
Total                                                                     
Number of Units                                                           
27                                                                        
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     In the reporting period of the first year of operation, the vehicles traveled a combined 11,204 miles and consumed 2,106.02 gallons of Fuel B for an average fuel consumption of 5.32 miles per gallon of untreated fuel. In the same reporting period of the following year of operation, the vehicles traveled a combined 10,412 miles and consumed 1,795.17 gallons of Fuel A for an average fuel consumption of 5.80 miles per gallon of treated fuel representing a 9% increase in mileage of Fuel A over Fuel B. 
     In accordance with another embodiment of the present invention, diesel fuel containing from about 1.0×10 -6  to about 1.0×10 -3  parts by weight of at least one isomer of dinitrotoluene is further provided with a combustion particulate-reducing amount of at least one metal acetylacetonate. By themselves, neither the dinitrotoluene isomer nor the metal acetylacetonate are capable of reducing combustion particulates and/or inhibiting combustion deposit formation within an engine burning the fuel to any appreciable extent. However, their combined presence in a diesel fuel in accordance with this invention has been found to exert a marked effect on the nature of the combustion emissions, providing a significant reduction in the level of particulates contained in the emissions and in most cases, inhibiting the formation of combustion deposits within the engine or removing such deposits which may have already accumulated with the previous use of untreated fuel. 
     The useful metal acetylacetonates are in themselves well known compounds (viz. U.S. Pat. No. 2,086,775 (1936)) and are preferably selected from among the metal derivatives of the beta diketones. The metal moieties of such compounds can be advantageously selected from the group consisting of cobalt, nickel, manganese, iron, copper, uranium, molybdenum, vanadium, zirconium, beryllium, platinum, palladium, thorium, chromium, aluminum and the rare earth metals. Beta diketones useful in the preparation of the metal acetyl acetonates can be represented by the structural formula: 
     
         R.sub.1 --CO--CHR.sub.2 --COR.sub.3 
    
     wherein R 1  and R 3  are hydrocarbon radicals which may carry halogen atoms as substituents, and R 2  is a hydrocarbon radical or a hydrogen atom. Specific beta diketones include acetylacetone, which is preferred, benzoylacetone and their alkyl aralkyl or aryl homologs. Useful metal acetylacetonates which can be used herein with good results include, singly or in admixture: nickel propionylacetonate, cobaltous propionylacetonate, cobaltic acetylacetonate, ferric acetylacetonate, cerous propionylacetonate, thorium acetylacetonate, zirconium acetylacetonate, chromic acetylacetonate, aluminum acetylacetonate, and the like. The metal acetylacetonates herein are generally quite effective when employed at a level of from about 4.0×10 -6  to 1.0×10 -3  parts by weight per part by weight of diesel fuel. It is preferred to incorporate from about 5.0×10 -6  to about 1.0×10 -5  parts by weight of metal acetylacetonate parts by weight of fuel. If soluble in diesel fuel, the metal acetylacetonate can be incorporated directly therein but more usually, the metal acetylacetonate will be dissolved in one or a mixture of mutual solvents, together with the dinitrotoluene isomer, optionally with one or more detergents, and the resulting solution will be mixed with a minor quantity of base fuel to form an additive concentrate just as in the case of dinitrotoluene alone, supra. To demonstrate the combustion particulate-reducing effect of a fuel containing both dinitrotoluene and metal acetylacetonate in accordance with this invention, 1 gallon of the following formulation was employed per 1,000 gallons of diesel fuel (Fuel A 1 ) and compared with an untreated fuel (Fuel B). The results are set forth in Example 4. 
     
         ______________________________________                                    
Component           Amount (weight ounces)                                
______________________________________                                    
ferric acetylacetonate                                                    
                    30                                                    
zirconium acetylacetonate                                                 
                    4                                                     
aluminum acetylacetonate                                                  
                    4                                                     
ortho-dichlorobenzene                                                     
                    56                                                    
dimethylformamide   56                                                    
dimethylsulfoxide   7                                                     
toluene             56                                                    
butyl cellosolve    56                                                    
methylene chloride  128                                                   
80:20 mixture of 2,4-dinitrotoluene                                       
                    12.5                                                  
and 2,6-dinitrotolueme                                                    
tricresyl phosphate 8                                                     
Witconate 1840 (sulfonate                                                 
                    2                                                     
fatty acid of Witco Chemical Corp.)                                       
triethylamine       7                                                     
Class 2 diesel Oil  51 gallons                                            
                    55 gallons (approx.)                                  
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     EXAMPLE 4 
     Twenty-five essentially identical diesel tractor-trailer vehicles were evaluated for combustion particulate emissions by operating the vehicles with an untreated fuel (Fuel B) for a period of four weeks, measuring the average particulate emission of the vehicles during this period, and comparing the results with the averaged measured particulate emissions of the same vehicles operated for four weeks with a fuel in accordance with this invention (Fuel A 1 ). Quantitative measurement of the average combustion particulate emissions in each four week period of vehicle operation was made by by-passing a constant amount of vehicle emission exhaust through asbestos filters attached to the tailpipes of the vehicles, with the filters retaining a constant percentage of particulates (i.e., carbon) in the exhaust passing therethrough. At regular periods, the asbestors filters were removed and the carbon deposited upon the filters weighed. Use of Fuel A 1  resulted in a calculated 63.5% reduction in particulate material as compared to the particulate material measured over the equivalent period with the use of an untreated diesel oil.