argdown_reconstruction
stringlengths 191
379
| conclusion
list | conclusion_formalized
list | conjectures
list | context
stringclasses 18
values | entity_placeholders
sequence | erroneous_argdown
stringclasses 0
values | gist
stringlengths 17
82
| intermediary_conclusions
list | intermediary_conclusions_formalized
list | misc_placeholders
sequence | plchd_substitutions
sequence | predicate_placeholders
sequence | premises
list | premises_formalized
list | reasons
list | source_paraphrase
stringclasses 0
values | source_text
stringlengths 73
271
| title
stringclasses 0
values | metadata
sequence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? routine child vaccinations should not be mandatory because children may not bear the side effects of it. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_1feffc6a-01eb-4f64-a42f-db898627fbc8"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy. (2) if routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination shouldn't be mandatory because children don't catch the virus. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_17a46502-d1ad-4670-bbf2-bdb7971e252f"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? the government should not regulate what parents do that is already a personal decision of each family. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_77c8091d-ba70-461d-b5e2-368a04d5358f"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? this vaccine can have side effects and harm children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_c8a81908-9c71-4d5b-8029-8cca36e900e4"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? this vaccine could cause unwanted side effects. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_4e894eb8-b439-4273-8c62-4d6da28dc04c"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccination of children should be limited as it affects child development. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_53b32447-f04c-489e-8c6f-5b86cc192e55"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccination should exclude children to avoid the side effects that can appear on them. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_ae7049e3-8f15-483f-9bc4-70e6dec5feb7"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccines are very harmful with their side effects and it is not the way to take care of our children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_b330a44b-d9c2-47da-b186-079c9cb0d76b"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination shouldn't be mandatory because is dangerous. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_d22da9f5-0e43-4f24-9991-b2ec8ae98c30"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? we do not know the side effects they may have. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_7aa22aea-de61-4f94-9242-81a250895ce6"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? you may create a chemical reaction that affects young people. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_ee158379-7788-4617-a795-fe24fb09cb0b"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? routine childhood vaccinations should be mandatory for virus prevention. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_bd462512-8ce1-4efd-a50d-8b01b2a28fd9"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? routine child vaccinations should be mandatory since they can spread the virus. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_1d9f1dde-a0a2-4c38-8464-f2e32a5cc9b3"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent the disease. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_cb1842cf-a234-47af-a01a-d402661b648c"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent the virus from developing itself. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_3a4131fe-0a75-47c5-97f3-78b54696c159"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others. (2) if routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? by refusing vaccination, parents increase the risk that their child (and themselves) will harm others. for this reason, the state must take the guardianship as far as childhood vaccination is concerned. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_c0c316cf-86be-4475-b528-346f09ea6770"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? by refusing vaccination, parents increase the risk that their child (and themselves) will harm others. for this reason, the state must take the guardianship as far as childhood vaccination is concerned. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_095199f7-22cb-4d35-9676-33d892a8de92"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination has to be mandatory since it takes care of our children to be immune to any type of disease so i think it has to be mandatory. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_3c2c6a2d-4cc4-4afc-9366-e9cc45009ca1"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination has to be mandatory to protect them from letal diseases. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_3b431e58-bf08-47c0-a6a2-81090810c7c9"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination is needed for children, they get sick too. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_ee2bdd76-f637-4fcc-9340-33f2a5b3af2f"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination saves lives and keeps children from suffering from preventable illness. this can help a person into adulthood by not having complications from diseases like chicken pox, mumps, polio and more. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_60676295-f053-4d38-93eb-87e3e94397f9"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination should be mandatory because even it doesn't affect children but they still can spread the disease. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_a1e718e2-5f5e-4ed4-9bc9-783855d36b45"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination should be mandatory because they may transfer the virus. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_2a838e64-cfb9-4dad-9ae4-040266f82464"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination should be mandatory to avoid the virus. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_e4ecd744-7fb0-42e7-b7ba-2115525b69b0"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccinations should not be mandatory because of the possible harmful side effects and because many are not able to do so due to religious beliefs. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_462140f3-c366-4ae8-8611-7f31548fe2d6"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination should be mandatory to avoid transferring the disease. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_30d71b7d-0466-4de7-bd7b-f1909cd6ce98"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination should be mandatory to prevent children from spreading the virus. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_665c2c43-f76f-47da-8afe-79fa4102c402"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent children becoming seriously ill from diseases and spreading infections. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_d52bdbc7-6134-4c57-898d-5e850720b737"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent children becoming seriously ill from diseases and spreading infections. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_eaf3ef34-e085-4979-813c-7b7f2e15b244"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? childhood vaccination should be mandatory since there are diseases that attack from childhood. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_4ed75ddd-a4c0-4c52-ac41-8f0e5c901252"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? childhood vaccines are absolutely important that children are given from birth to prevent future diseases. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_4996e869-42b5-4b6a-93b6-a059714893bd"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? childhood vaccines should not be mandatory in their entirety because many generate side effects in children and even become useless, each vaccine according to the disease may be mandatory. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_e699624f-1265-4ee7-b603-c2c7551b3e30"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? every child has to be vaccinated to prevent deadly illnesses. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_4ddc0182-8514-4be1-a612-46aba1c9e635"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? if routine infallible vaccinations are mandatory, that way we avoid the spread and make our children immune from any disease. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_a6aca990-7c11-4753-84d4-1f46df32060c"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? if the virus is to be released in its entirety, the entire population must be vaccinated. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_9f840338-7461-4a9d-be5d-66f0ea4fdcb7"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? if we don't vaccinate children then we will never be able to fully eradicate diseases from the population. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_9aeecc96-574d-4810-93d2-fd2ca21a9be5"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? in a sense, yes, because the child is more prone to spreading the virus. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_1ac5ee75-3daa-4e49-9ed9-917944536964"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? children should not be vaccinated because they can have serious side effects. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_b29d9729-4bce-47d8-9ac0-70fef1fa9f9e"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? infant vaccination should be mandatory so we avoid infant mortality. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_b1419984-121a-4d41-a3b7-c532bc43ec34"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others. (2) if routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? infant vaccination should be mandatory to guarantee the health of all the inhabitants and thus avoid contagion among the inhabitants. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_e4a223a4-ceaf-4917-91d3-4d87380c1c8e"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it has to be mandatory to avoid more infections. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_5a3b44dc-f6bd-440b-a0b2-1096ee27463c"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it is always better to prevent a disease than to treat it after it occurs. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_e0013438-1061-4152-aa8f-6795007b31bd"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it should be because children are in contact with almost everything and with that premise they can be carriers of covid faster. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_b0deee11-803d-43d3-856f-72857e2a8b59"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others. (2) if routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it should be mandatory to vaccinate children to guarantee global public health, and to keep in oblivion the diseases that have already been eradicated. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_b9a8da5a-88a0-4fea-9df8-f78699a649ed"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? every parent should have the right to determine what vaccines a child receives this is not something the state should be able to mandate. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_670454a1-07fa-4a34-9027-fde2d5e0bce4"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it's important because when vaccination rates decline, we start to see a resurgence of infectious diseases. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_af5bdb7b-cabb-409a-a00b-7bf6562e5320"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? making routine child vaccinations mandatory would prevent the unnecessary deaths and suffering that currently result from the diseases that the vaccines prevent. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_0fb6f65b-703c-4427-b27b-11169c7f05d8"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? making routine child vaccinations mandatory would prevent the unnecessary deaths and suffering that currently result from the diseases that the vaccines prevent. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_607563c9-499c-4b70-81fb-6f363d941486"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? of course, this is how long-term immunization of the entire population is achieved in diseases that can be fatal and easily contagious. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_5e8e0684-5996-4b50-bb4b-a120388152eb"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? parents don't always know best and failure to vaccinate can be catastrophic for a child. losing limbs to meningitis, sight and hearing issues with measles and sometimes even death. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_d2b4bb70-e69b-451f-a86a-bcf652437d68"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? prevents a large number of diseases. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_99146778-1dd8-4cde-88d4-19f89547e53a"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? prevents from childhood the diseases that can be avoided, with the placement of vaccines. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_9fb870b3-003b-4b61-8c3f-9b31f34a0933"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others. (2) if routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? routine child vaccination is essential to ensure that the population are protected from transmittable diseases. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_811c3a14-5fbe-4d4c-8d52-6d6621ec51da"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? routine childhood vaccinations should be mandatory for virus prevention. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_34346c7e-1d62-4ccc-8bbc-0a2c296b6c00"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? everyone has the freedom to choose whether to vaccinate their child or not, to impose a vaccination is to violate the rights of parents to decide how to raise and care for their children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_fa563158-d4f6-4553-b38c-6d8354404ec3"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? everyone has the freedom to choose whether to vaccinate their child or not, to impose a vaccination is to violate the rights of parents to decide how to raise and care for their children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_38b48702-34bc-499d-9354-7b2b7f4ca9d7"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? routine childhood vaccines should be mandatory, because they prevent any disease in the child, and thus ensure a healthy future. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_c7d9447a-c815-4584-97e5-ec1dbff923ba"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? routine infallible vaccinations are mandatory, that way we avoid the spread and make our children immune from any disease. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_c1668fd7-b55f-4dea-8972-99375a049460"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are effective. (2) if routine child vaccinations are effective then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are effective. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are effective"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are effective."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are effective then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? that’s why some countries are choosing to make vaccination mandatory. however, the effectiveness of this approach varies in countries which have already implemented it. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_ebb2f335-8107-45a9-a3c7-9cd2d9054265"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? the main reason is that many diseases have been prevented thanks to vaccines, thus millions of lives have been saved. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_08bc4aea-186b-4856-bd21-dda37fd921b7"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? the use of child vaccines saves lives. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_e6c3da54-23cd-45ac-9275-2f0349b53d45"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? exposing a child to a vaccine without previous studies of their immune system can give them more health problems than solutions, it should not be mandatory. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_68785332-b1d4-4435-9b4a-4c6a4f9e808b"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? they should be mandatory because they save millions of children's lives every year. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_06d1d8ea-a4a1-4579-99c2-afedfe2e655b"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are effective. (2) if routine child vaccinations are effective then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are effective. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are effective"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are effective."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are effective then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? they would learn about the remarkable safety and effectiveness of vaccines. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_f9959806-82a7-4091-869f-8ec7300f17c5"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? to avoid spreading diseases in schools and day care centers, all children must be vaccinated. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_7d45f3ae-ec63-4bee-be3d-8446e1b7572c"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? to mandate them to prevent the spread of vaccine-preventable diseases among school children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_404ff516-c4e7-49ec-a267-86dfdc033052"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy. (2) if routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? routine child vaccinations should not be necessary as children can't catch the disease. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_c4337b0b-b3af-4be0-a710-e55d49c4f192"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? forcing people to have their children vaccinated goes against free will. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_24627817-9e2a-4e41-af6b-12ec9502e11b"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccination in the child population should also be very important since the new strains are being more lethal and the age of vulnaberility has lowered. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_990d66e7-d4d6-47cc-a203-e0e16a9348ca"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccination is a safe and effective way to prevent disease and save lives, today more than ever. vaccines are currently available to protect us against at least 20 diseases, including diphtheria. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_d69884dc-fe8d-4971-843b-4ee2afbd0cf3"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are effective. (2) if routine child vaccinations are effective then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are effective. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are effective"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are effective."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are effective then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccination is one of the most effective public health interventions in the world for saving lives and promoting good health. only clean water, which is considered to be a basic human right, performs bette. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_c54e59c9-9f85-43d3-b740-6c31be82cc63"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are effective. (2) if routine child vaccinations are effective then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are effective. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are effective"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are effective."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are effective then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccination is one of the most effective public health interventions in the world for saving lives and promoting good health. only clean water, which is considered to be a basic human right, performs better. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_8c59edf5-5649-470b-b701-f0d4b2acceb4"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccination is one of the most effective public health interventions in the world for saving lives and promoting good health. only clean water, which is considered to be a basic human right, performs better. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_44736cc6-9dd5-490d-9618-3c5aedfcafa6"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccination should be a health policy to reduce diseases in infants. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_bcc6f691-8368-403d-9afa-8e193faa6246"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccination should be a health policy to reduce infant mortality. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_ef14ad27-7e2a-4af2-a029-9602e0e31f59"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccination should be mandatory because is one of the most effective public health strategies in the world for saving lives and promoting good health. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_2e9b925a-1719-41b7-a4d3-781949f51f19"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others. (2) if routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccinations are necessary to protect the health of the public as a whole and should be required by law. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_fcfc2977-553b-4a10-a44d-14b0a6bda404"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? i do not agree to force children without parental consent should not be fair. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_396cccd2-e8f1-4e17-90cd-799722ae947d"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccinations should be mandatory in children to prevent them from spreading disease to other children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_7a9c61a1-3058-468c-a523-7555c9d1b22d"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccines help children grow up healthy and avoid dangerous diseases. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_733ee8d3-9279-4770-9b66-96117dfa2e45"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccines must be compulsory for children because in this way we prevent later diseases in infants, which helps their good growth. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_95c2af39-4fe3-4823-bc2b-42820c6dd1a1"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccines save lives by protecting against many diseases that is why we must vaccinate children from an early age. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_4e44b11d-0934-48a2-b584-701626f2b713"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccines save up to 3 million lives a year, protecting children from life-threatening and highly infectious diseases. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_21d5c99f-1343-437f-9ecc-31be85f1f769"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccines should be a mandatory policy so that children do not suffer from these covid problems. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_9223a842-429a-4b14-bc80-16734f756fe4"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? i do not think it is necessary since it can be harmful to them. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_e88f4f4d-8dd1-4433-a996-1909168222ed"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccines should be a mandatory policy so that children do not suffer from these covid problems in the future. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_86248171-2cd6-4338-8605-f51abddf568b"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes, it is necessary to preserve the life of the child. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_319de162-ae5d-4e4c-ba3f-2490b02a1660"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? i do not trust that a solution shot into my child's arm can protect them. there is a risk of a serious reaction or even death. i as a parent should decide. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_ca7b4156-4487-4187-bf64-2f6614edc656"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others. (2) if routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccinations should be mandatory to provide decent health care to all. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_240ebec6-a9bc-4bf4-8ab3-17388b77989e"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? could improve health from baby and thus avoid future problems. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_17def0f1-7573-43ba-8b5f-717c3f06ebda"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? if it were not mandatory to vaccinate our children, we would cease to exist rapidly. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_086abb86-f003-4a18-b5ef-676c834684ed"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? in this way, pandemic outbreaks are avoided. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_772ac187-7a34-40d2-9d0d-f0ea79daa917"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it should be mandatory because sometimes children are very prone to diseases. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_d857c643-1842-4aeb-89d4-6618e8f3aa70"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? i think that they should not force anyone to do something like that since we have not seen that the vaccine has not given good results and we cannot expose our children and adolescents to something like that. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_be75c846-ff9e-44da-8482-cf0ba17f0c7b"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? must be mandatory since with them we make ourselves immune to certain infectious diseases that are harmful to our body. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_4938ac40-1fa8-45cc-8538-c30a765fd405"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? taking into account that the virus is very contagious, it should be mandatory to avoid future mutations. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_7304ac0d-8203-4adb-9559-2facbdc85dcb"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? i would not agree as there may be side effects in the case of some children having an external disease or not. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_14403ddd-0374-471f-b76e-3d06b71c6d97"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? the vaccine must be for everyone in order to control the virus. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_05417dde-40e6-484c-97b2-f49c9a7a9fbc"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? the vaccine must be mandatory for all ages to avoid human-to-human transmission. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_5eca8e08-be8e-45c8-9ee8-426bde2e135b"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are effective. (2) if routine child vaccinations are effective then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are effective. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are effective"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are effective."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are effective then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? the vaccine provide inmunity to the people and prevents to contract the dissease. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_732c13c4-e995-49a5-8960-4da4f899583d"
]
] |
End of preview. Expand
in Dataset Viewer.
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 44