argdown_reconstruction
stringlengths 191
379
| conclusion
list | conclusion_formalized
list | conjectures
list | context
stringclasses 18
values | entity_placeholders
sequence | erroneous_argdown
stringclasses 0
values | gist
stringlengths 17
82
| intermediary_conclusions
list | intermediary_conclusions_formalized
list | misc_placeholders
sequence | plchd_substitutions
sequence | predicate_placeholders
sequence | premises
list | premises_formalized
list | reasons
list | source_paraphrase
stringclasses 0
values | source_text
stringlengths 73
271
| title
stringclasses 0
values | metadata
sequence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? the vaccine provide inmunity to the people and prevents to contract the dissease. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_c8767f43-f247-485d-8f67-7fc2b99d0981"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others. (2) if routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are necessary to protect others then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? to keep schools safe children must be vaccinated. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_1f61cc6f-0020-4aad-b34a-923774866687"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? to prevent contagion it is good for every child to have their vaccine. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_c4405dcf-eb60-4504-8604-2fa5db176e88"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccinating children helps eradicate disease. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_407e2725-769d-4745-99b0-8b7a4c610d51"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? i would not agree as there may be side effects in the case of some children having an external disease or not. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_edfd3682-4c8f-45f1-bbf1-0ce3fe48125e"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccination in the child population due to the lethality of the new strains is essential. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_9c2d22a3-f03d-4092-babb-ea840fa29cdc"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? absolutely! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccines must be compulsory for children because in this way we prevent later diseases in infants. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_4713e348-0e67-4827-a8a2-109387b888ff"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. (2) if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I agree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations should be mandatory to prevent virus/disease spreading then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? with this we obtain immunity in the immunological system to viral diseases. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_9ad987c0-2bd0-4a8e-a91a-037eddf50f34"
]
] |
(1) children should not suffer from preventable diseases. (2) if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | children should not suffer from preventable diseases. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"children should not suffer from preventable diseases"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "children should not suffer from preventable diseases."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if children should not suffer from preventable diseases then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes as they protect children from life threatening and highly infectious diseases. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_bf87644c-23a8-4018-b014-eec6e6c25afd"
]
] |
(1) child vaccination saves lives. (2) if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes! | null | null | child vaccination saves lives. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"child vaccination saves lives"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "child vaccination saves lives."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if child vaccination saves lives then routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? yes because they protect children from life-threatening diseases. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_15673ff5-5f31-46fc-9364-6827f0d82637"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? if parents are forced to vaccinate their children, a huge amount of protests will be unleashed, each claiming their rights. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_7b8545d4-ff85-4c14-bdab-c8a821b22c8f"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it can be counterproductive to subject a child to the side effects of vaccines. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_29f08e06-541a-4ecd-8b6c-d34040b699e4"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? a vaccine that has not been sufficiently tested and without knowledge of side effects is not recommended for children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_74af1bef-9fa7-44b2-8cea-b943acc38d8e"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it can be counterproductive to subject a child to the side effects of vaccines, and they can end up harming them for the rest of their lives. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_0d0fe9c0-b183-4165-a4ac-7ea6b770c480"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it cannot be mandatory since the first responsible for deciding what is best for their children are the parents. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_28183e6e-b016-4b6c-b0fe-4438ad317584"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it goes against some religions that prohibit it. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_a04dc11b-6ead-45dd-81b0-88adb00fff57"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it has not been 100% proven if the vaccine is effective. in addition, there are many side effects. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_2992b644-feae-43a8-b9bf-70da8c131ba9"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it is not mandatory because it is something very personal for each person, you cannot force anyone. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_42a21c84-aeb0-42ce-a3a2-20ffc522ee9f"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it is up to the childs parents to decide what is best for their child. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_43b9a926-086d-4167-82fa-632aa8c5598a"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it must be something of personal decision and not of governments or companies. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_fb96ede1-d260-414b-b50f-7da337eaa351"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it should not be compulsory because each mother has the right to decide whether to have vaccinations or not. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_5d4b9abe-84c6-4602-a912-51c5ec047c6a"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it should not be mandatory as it goes against some religious beliefs. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_1a7ea80f-14f3-4eb6-8798-7e70b3c1449d"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it should not be mandatory, since if the parents do not believe it necessary, they would have the right to make the decision about their child. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_23cd72fd-345b-481c-b4e6-e98dd30d85ec"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? as long as vaccines are not free of side effects, it cannot make them mandatory for our children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_492fe5f0-29b2-4905-b9e6-797981572806"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it shouldn't be mandatory , every parent should be able to decide whether to vaccinate their childs or not. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_42d3d7fa-bbf4-493d-bb72-da73aa5ce3ab"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no, the free will of the people should be respected. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_7834b6df-888b-4b1b-a25f-5c6048d9052f"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no, the obligation to vaccinate children should not happen because god made us free for us to make our decisions. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_7bdcbf8d-bfcc-42b3-ab73-b27c9c170a4c"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no, they will impede free will and decision-making capacity. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_6aeddbed-2e17-4616-9ddc-871ab90c716e"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no-one can tell a parent that they must vaccinate their child, it is against their human rights. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_fd78db70-03fa-4152-aef5-68cdd27769b6"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no-one can tell a parent that they must vaccinate their child, it is against their human rights. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_67e52339-fac9-4328-923b-30ddaee1bdc0"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? parents consenting to the existence of vaccines should make the best decision for their infants that they are vaccinated when they should and at the appropriate age to prevent disease. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_111b026e-c012-496a-87c4-df3b54d0aeb4"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? parents should be able to choose if their children are vaccinated to remove the freedom to choose is a clear v=breach of human rights. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_e1779a4c-3836-46fb-b3f2-cae77fbdc9a5"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination is not necessary, and should not be mandatory, because vaccines are a lie. let them decide if they want to be vaccinated. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_a9f70a33-19ca-4490-ab8e-a31f003c434d"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? parents should be allowed to choose if their child is vaccinated or not. many people feel the vaccinations carry a risk of severe reactions including death and want to avoid this for their children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_fe42cef8-d1a5-4dac-bedc-57dd34010d0f"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? parents should decide what is best for their child. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_ef0b7dd6-2113-4fe5-bf16-02679bc21465"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? routine child vaccination should not be mandatory as a person should have the right to what is injected into their bodies. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_73a385d8-6700-45be-a008-45f47521c9bc"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? routine childhood vaccinations should not be mandatory, because the contraindications or what negative effect it may cause the child are not known, the parents should decide. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_34f05c1f-e02a-4976-a1d4-b33d1c8fb9aa"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? routine childhood vaccinations should not be mandatory, because the contraindications or what negative effect it may cause the child are not known, the parents should decide. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_1a4ab46a-0876-49c9-98b0-929f366d1b25"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? should be not mandatorybecause they can bring side effects. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_7bbaaacf-f94a-46af-8823-2df7a8421541"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? some children can have very serious reactions to vaccines and should not be required to get them. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_f641ae5e-a73d-4e02-a2b6-ef08298ab952"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? some religions are against vaccinations, and as religion is protected by law, vaccinations must not be mandated. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_b31b5f79-b3ac-4f7f-840d-c6debb02429b"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy. (2) if routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? the child population has a low degree of vulnerability, so vaccination is not urgent yet. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_2e938b94-f6e6-4a44-9776-cbee0368b61c"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? the vaccine could make your child sick and contain toxic substances. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_4c7b5606-1ff2-4923-bf40-42833fd59abe"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination isn't necessary and may result in other diseases for children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_b1a0e4a7-fea4-4604-99a0-80a2a072ac8c"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? there are a ot of concerns over vaccine safety. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_618757e1-3b4c-480e-b926-5ecf7e16a733"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? there are sectors that due to their religion or any belief do not accept to be vaccinated, for this reason it is considered that childhood routine vaccinations should not be mandatory. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_42ac1741-0892-426c-b34c-3d78278268c1"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? there is currently no guarantee of the side effects of vaccines so it is considered that forcing children to be vaccinated can be a long-term problem. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_ab7350f4-94c9-4a06-8a7a-5e1f62c299f4"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? they are against the freedom of parents to choose how to care for their children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_090a77e3-64fe-4a5e-9763-e042068376b8"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? they should not be mandatory, it is a personal decision. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_2ba5b15c-aa9b-495a-a5b0-f9d3fe85aa88"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccination is an option, not everyone thinks they really are important and free will must be respected. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_f150c9fb-aded-4b43-a893-1b409195231c"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccines can cause autism and poisoning. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_fd0f5265-cc67-4897-a0ff-e9a8ab5b95b9"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination should not be mandatory as there are often side effects from them. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_809efcd9-1b03-4610-a1a8-ae2dd1d7827b"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccines contain heavy metals, they are toxic to children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_738bcad5-1e21-4d61-a5f0-3c2e3439b1f9"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? vaccines in children should not be mandatory because they can have consequences for their health in the future. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_58c00e4c-c660-4855-836b-08b8d054ce8e"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? when vaccines are mandatory, they can infringe on family religious choices. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_517e252e-34b8-4c9a-9b07-ffdf0a0926d4"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? you do not have to take vaccinations because they have severe side effects. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_007a45bc-7a3b-4030-8178-33d7c5fa5cb8"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? because they can have very dangerous reactions to vaccines. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_820003fa-c404-472a-b7c2-58958ee87f55"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? cannot be compelled, parents must have the right to choose what is best for their children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_dd9d99c6-0960-47a2-a87c-97d534081a24"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccinations should not be mandatory to avoid any bad effects on them. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_acf8c151-a455-41cf-bd99-bd5b6cbbd95e"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccinations shouldn't be mandatory because some children can get sick or badly affected by vaccinations. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_efcef6b4-d3e5-4f9f-9cf0-85dfbc3c27fb"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy. (2) if routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations are not necessary to keep children healthy then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination should not be mandatory because they don't suffer from symptoms. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_37df2330-678f-4caf-916b-23b54f9c140a"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccinations shouldn't be mandatory because the vaccine can have side effects on children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_058e768b-b05f-49ee-b9d1-15f6e8e89c42"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? childcare is the responsibility of the parents and is a matter of conscience. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_a25c3ff7-463f-4c56-9879-d4840afb49e0"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? childhood vaccination should not be mandatory because it can cause autism. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_8d6a2991-17e3-4116-8ea8-d096e049ad17"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? children could present in the future effects that are not very good for them. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_44ae76c7-1470-43dc-917a-e01d92592126"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? could be damaged by side effects i honestly don't consider it safe. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_66e7c421-560c-420f-a547-5441db69851d"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? could have negative side effects on your health and cause physical and psychological changes. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_a56a9eb3-3b0c-4265-ba35-9f1b1eca2f9c"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? each parent should be responsible for doing what is best for their child in this case vaccinate him. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_0d6c4516-b52d-4297-bd75-ceb384a8cef3"
]
] |
(1) mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. (2) if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if mandatory vaccination contradicts basic rights then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? everyone should be free to choose what they want or not. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_e02c2446-1bc2-4ba3-9a71-89f17316b395"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? for children it is a delicate case because they may not support the dose the same as an adult, it should be safer without serious side effects. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_57f5d838-4123-41c3-8295-09304e2b0792"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? child vaccination should not be mandatory, it should be the parents' decision, since the adverse effects that the vaccine can cause to the infant are not known. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_2af697fd-0dac-4c27-9ba7-a612d5054a9a"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? in this sense, every person is already responsible for raising their children and i don't see why they should be forced. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_a3177411-8396-41b8-9302-32a1a5d3990a"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? it is the duty of parents to choose whether or not to vaccinate their children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_eb0b5b7b-9469-4055-af64-71a1bd738eac"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? kids could get side effects from it and hurt themselves. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_fb9af91b-aa6b-48e8-9e7c-5d04af82cc23"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? on the other hand there may be deadly side effects. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_2764dbd9-e186-42ec-b52f-14a5c550d6a7"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? I disagree! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? on the other hand there may be deadly side effects for children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_fe0a888b-2bde-46a7-bbeb-e93becf9d1c0"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? not at all! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? parents should have the freedom to decide what they consider best for their children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_71fffdbf-19a6-47a0-be1e-a5e1dc51bcef"
]
] |
(1) the parents and not the state should decide. (2) if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | the parents and not the state should decide. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"the parents and not the state should decide"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "the parents and not the state should decide."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if the parents and not the state should decide then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? responsibility is to make vaccination days more diligent, but knowing that whenever parents make their decision about it and those who do not want their children to be vaccinated should be tolerated. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_9fd7108b-f81c-4f1d-ac1c-1d67945372c2"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? routine child vaccination should not be mandatory because the child could get really bad side affects. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_71365337-05db-4ac5-82f8-5cb5712f9ae5"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? should not be mandatory as they have side effects that can affect growth. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_6d599412-c50c-4807-b0eb-954cf9d24318"
]
] |
(1) routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. (2) if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? no! | null | null | routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous"
],
[
"q",
"routine child vaccinations should be mandatory"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if routine child vaccinations, or their side effects, are dangerous then it is not the case that routine child vaccinations should be mandatory."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | routine child vaccinations should be mandatory? someone from the child population could suffer side effects. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_1e0c6432-343d-4dbd-9490-45ca485c3096"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation harms privacy. (2) if social media regulation harms privacy then it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? no! | null | null | social media regulation harms privacy. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation harms privacy"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation harms privacy."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation harms privacy then it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? by no means can we allow the government to regulate our social networks since this is a means of communication where there must be a lot of privacy. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_6a643886-315e-40ea-be24-27a6ca5ff7be"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights. (2) if social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights then it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? not at all! | null | null | social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights then it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? it is against freedom of expression. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_2df45b0f-9210-4545-8dd0-6c803ac51b95"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news. (2) if social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? I agree! | null | null | social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? governments should avoid the proliferation of fake news and hoaxes on social networks. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_e04dcae8-11b6-4c69-a0c7-149d58c3588c"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation can help to deal with negative content. (2) if social media regulation can help to deal with negative content then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? I agree! | null | null | social media regulation can help to deal with negative content. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation can help to deal with negative content"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation can help to deal with negative content."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation can help to deal with negative content then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? governments should be in control of social media, as a lot of bad things are posted. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_05c036c8-24e1-4527-9ba9-4329171e550d"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users. (2) if social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? I agree! | null | null | social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? i agree and it must be regulated so that evil people do not steal false identities. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_2bcaf3c9-bbf7-40d9-a5d9-9e442f70853d"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation protects the younger audiences. (2) if social media regulation protects the younger audiences then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? I agree! | null | null | social media regulation protects the younger audiences. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation protects the younger audiences"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation protects the younger audiences."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation protects the younger audiences then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? i agree with this and more with minors who are most at risk. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_33c04a2e-4459-47c2-8989-a349b856bbb2"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation can help to deal with negative content. (2) if social media regulation can help to deal with negative content then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? I agree! | null | null | social media regulation can help to deal with negative content. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation can help to deal with negative content"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation can help to deal with negative content."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation can help to deal with negative content then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? i personally think that they should be regulated since these platforms have a negative influence on people. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_cf48120e-f485-491f-821f-691681416223"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation protects the younger audiences. (2) if social media regulation protects the younger audiences then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? yes! | null | null | social media regulation protects the younger audiences. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation protects the younger audiences"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation protects the younger audiences."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation protects the younger audiences then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? i support the issue of regulating social networks since there is a lot of bad content for our children. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_c0f2b07f-7f1d-436a-b7c8-ad13758bddb4"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation can help to deal with negative content. (2) if social media regulation can help to deal with negative content then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? I agree! | null | null | social media regulation can help to deal with negative content. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation can help to deal with negative content"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation can help to deal with negative content."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation can help to deal with negative content then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? if it should be regulated, many accidents and evils would be avoided. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_8bafbf46-c415-446b-a91a-eb5318d66ac1"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights. (2) if social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights then it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? no! | null | null | social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights then it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? it is impossible to violate communication rights if social platforms are regulated, there is freedom of expression and it must be respected. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_853b2167-dc3f-4deb-ac00-d9eee37d660b"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news. (2) if social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? yes! | null | null | social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? in a way it would be good, since the disturbances and the dissemination of bad news will end. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_d963e622-aa54-4ce6-a88b-a3ef6f4bd15e"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news. (2) if social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? yes! | null | null | social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation is necessary to deal with fake news then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? it is the best to be able to control the high amount of fake news that occurs. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_784b6777-b440-470c-b553-6721941031d5"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users. (2) if social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? yes! | null | null | social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? it seems to me that it should be regulated but not in such a strict way, if it is going to serve to dismantle any prostitution, drug, or human trafficking network, that is important. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_990e9df0-b6c7-46ec-92b4-e101c9e1731b"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation can help to deal with negative content. (2) if social media regulation can help to deal with negative content then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? absolutely! | null | null | social media regulation can help to deal with negative content. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation can help to deal with negative content"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation can help to deal with negative content."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation can help to deal with negative content then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? it seems to me that there are certain things in social networks that should be regulated, pages that promote anorexia, suicides, among other things. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_9b283789-5726-45f5-873b-b04333b14f80"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation can help to deal with negative content. (2) if social media regulation can help to deal with negative content then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? absolutely! | null | null | social media regulation can help to deal with negative content. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation can help to deal with negative content"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation can help to deal with negative content."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation can help to deal with negative content then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? it should be regulated since certain information can be filtered there. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_3ac81009-90b9-4c3a-8ed4-21a206cad369"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights. (2) if social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights then it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "not q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? I disagree! | null | null | social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation harm freedom of speech and other democratic rights then it is not the case that social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> not q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? it should not be regulated because it would eliminate the liberty of internet. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_b150b213-eded-4ddc-a683-501f46a1ef91"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation protects the younger audiences. (2) if social media regulation protects the younger audiences then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? yes! | null | null | social media regulation protects the younger audiences. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation protects the younger audiences"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation protects the younger audiences."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation protects the younger audiences then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? it should be regulated, to make a safer enviroment for children, from paedophiles and bullying. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_6836e0d8-ba1a-4f9f-a5a2-00d53e65eb93"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users. (2) if social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? yes! | null | null | social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation is required to deal with malicious users then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? it should be regulated, to make a safer enviroment for children, from paedophiles and bullying. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_d8db9efa-1ee2-428b-817d-d3442b9af8d3"
]
] |
(1) social media regulation can help to deal with negative content. (2) if social media regulation can help to deal with negative content then social media platforms should be regulated by the government. -- with modus ponens from (1) (2) -- (3) social media platforms should be regulated by the government. | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 3,
"text": "social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "q",
"ref_reco": 3
}
] | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? I agree! | null | null | social media regulation can help to deal with negative content. | null | null | [
"p",
"q"
] | [
[
"p",
"social media regulation can help to deal with negative content"
],
[
"q",
"social media platforms should be regulated by the government"
]
] | null | [
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 1,
"text": "social media regulation can help to deal with negative content."
},
{
"explicit": null,
"ref_reco": 2,
"text": "if social media regulation can help to deal with negative content then social media platforms should be regulated by the government."
}
] | [
{
"form": "p",
"ref_reco": 1
},
{
"form": "p -> q",
"ref_reco": 2
}
] | null | null | social media platforms should be regulated by the government? it would be great if they are regulated since there they can control negative content that we do not want to see. | null | [
[
"id",
"argkp_fb75cc25-109a-487e-b926-e0340db7fc00"
]
] |