Court Opinion

ID: 4047134
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:20:08.647482+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:49.835346
License: Public Domain

:..;

~tJL Mwl,~fl<£n7        ,J ts'tl'ifo?
S1e ue so.-v <AfV :f"
           tJ

lS z.,) ff'l 76?             This document contains some
~&u; ~1J< 779)1(             pages that are of poor quality
                             at the time of imaging.

  D2/H1 Chi;
   Pfuse_ fl£ wJl. ([2..__ C01-o-"f df &;,_,,~"'/ ~/if r/.4'
  of 1111~~ <NJ Eltvd ~J ,..._.e_ Clo ( '1 df ~ ;:'1;5 #«.->- hJ!,.-'
  1k._f 'J l>t ~ /Jk;C .-ft~ v:. (/hij /'Affffi/?.      .

                                                      feyRcdvlj   S',.h;:,IJ,/

                                               _&nfYUt·~
                                                l!e /Avu_ !?2 fe,
                                                              0
                                          T/J          1he_ fo~fof-~t~(;p{ tf;rb/s
                                                        ~sit~ / -!RXtJ-5
                                                                  \''
                                                                  t
                                                                  I
                                                                  I
                                                                  I
           - v-                                                   1

   ~0$'g (5,_._~h to~      I         I; 0/£'Vk                    ~
  'I,.;    h/s ~-' f d(~~ I             r;.f!Jc;'f,               r
           Re.s {Jcl.Nd~                                          l

IJ. --To -the_                 f/.,,.;.1(/)/,/.._ fw~e.-     J w:J ca..a-t:                             ,          bo
             c<J!'Ies poW              fl1~eA>p"":J 1 ,ee.l~./-o,e f,tr> .)e._ !P ~f ~ ;.e.
                                          &rJtlf
       &~led C4-use- of ~vft/J fib ,fl-s ovu:; ~~/ tyk fio';J 6n- M~ 7-o f-
       ;YJII~dAfl/l-uS f'-£11-~~r- fv /)lf,l/tk Jl ()7 .5e~icl~ [C- J CJf (h_ /e1¢S' {ujL
          of Cjl,~tfttf (lllcud~ .~d                           bt/DlA;fJ_   shw ~ ~Vt-~1-              (/.J t{f~w,;,,

                                                           :r,
 ,g,      R.e 14-~£                                          .                     ,                        ,
          ~,.,.1        M·(kr                    -r: ilt:I ~- J~8'1'io7 :s ~~~ J~de.c- v~~RLRM/eJ
          ttl r:{/L -JeKP:S         /Jetprt f/h41f of- Cz,~tJ ~s-f,&.- 11A· tS         1              P(lf~~ f~o ~~
       t,v}t(J     be_ /odJ/ej ~rf S/R-ue#SdrJ d.n.~ 152-S fM 76&/ ~f!/lD 1 1x.
                   (A},J

       77'/{'f, /efo--bYl kr fKh~J-w-<;/eJ ht-5 i&rteJ~ ~~~ hAs rJO c/IL-~ rJ·Jl!JC(bk
        12~ j7 t9 + trw,

          -f/.e   fl   J so..,A-f c/.1         J, e.   c;ql"'f.el&i ~-~     1'1 ,1,;/~i ,v•    1-- d.'s c..te-i:Vt>-t'f ,)
          rJ~c                 "/.C. C. f. //, () 7 r,ec-f,;,; .J cc) llef"'~J ~ sf•~f .{., ;;,,~Ji/c.l7
          f{/e EJt/L -1-rut~s/V#'f              -h     (I.e catuZf 11 c~r
                                                                               7   *       ~l"'rhll   M     A~-~ cJV/_?~J

                                                               (/)I'
                     /t~s C."f""' r,i t ~h J,. r ;t l.eb/ J"--e
 /Iff J, ,;. f,;.; {:. . _    w"'.'f rJ f
~ IL~ ckk Wwn; 2-t, 201), /1_/;lu,._ t'k/ lt.~ flp/k5 e,~~ ~
 <(k. C~k dL Glhl/f 2-59 (). ~~ sle-.3oo soD tl L,a.IJ~ Srf, uJ
 /h,d(~, 1eXP5 ?q?b / o~ IJec.., 3 201~ ~ (fl,:( ~ vor/4(; ~s £~
                                                    1

 J'wf ~ 4_ ~~lvl't- 1 ON ((ls /IAh~l po h'fe_ ,IV~ ~~vt. tv<>rft,tj, .
 .fV9 (!t)(lf rJ1-1k. Pfflt~~) (vk- hh,cf Jf ltt.R4f c:~'-'S' 0/l ckJ k_ 11f
   ~ lc'rvtj 1 r/e~'< 4:s ((2.e_ ;)4-/"f bUN ~~J/ej -4 1k_ Lo4of elt~;pj
  /JylfP-115 J bl R~s(lJ~J~r/+- ItS /ZRj~l~eJ hi s~le-, ~.e-~~YL wc>u/1
   /vwe_ tc-et;~v-e.cL ND~ fit~ 1he Ca~f df- ~~(;/)( 1'1'.-to/s_,

                                             $,
C. Respo,ve/~.f Ross f?wsh ~~ A;> &f,oe:~ of !J,~f (4,./: &I
   (h]/AtJd c"<tv-'7 'Ums I hs rr fl/lt~/sfef{ ~I cl~~ -k u~ve- ~Jd
   h'L~ ~II f~.R~t--S l;J A- efl;tvt-;;.;tJ ff(oLee/~5 f)~ ftu~~ r~l/ D~
     cl !A;ft~s ~~(JuseJ      tl,J        ~ Cle~f    i 7 kw    p~ ,z¥a.,vf- {v 1:t.4f. ~{ 2 2{
     ~~~J t"s (Le)fd#~;tk Vvvd-2~ 7.L. ~f. Jl.o? s-e~~)                     /o      ,~ednl~
     ~~ ~ 1/lL t'o.qJf df(;.,;.,;;roJ !J,ru.h                        B   C.f7       of1hllft_,i~.)
     (;1<-w~Jf~f ltkaJ La iLfuJ> 1 /}tVf fJ!<AIA/~S h.'kl {lr/J If Ce>fl~~
     f!-ec>h~ 14 dr.r-1<. "{Jo~ tv~ht~ 11w/- CCJ~,e_fs h,;~~s wrs ~R-~f
     <fk C<»rJ/d4 Co~d/f- c/pc;J~s ~f ~ ltW2- /'JO t>Sues -A~
      /LC <;oL..~e--J -r

\.    .I ' 1
0# VtOthfrorJ of-
                  r                           ::J]l:.,
                             (kh;k, I/. D 7 )ec-/;D~
                                     r-                  "
                                                        of-- fk- I. C,C,r, b f
                                                              3cc)
                                                                                d      LJ   I

     f;,/,~ ./-v ~'ft., ~n~clwf tf,;/pfeci (/7.;~ ~{a-~k, ·~ ~/:_ ~hh_
     ~ 'IlL« ~.,d t/0 IU'Sf.),_P/- f:.o_.... ~e.~f!>--J.RA fl e!J~',; & ~
      wIf,~~      C)   r Jfo6«5 a~.,_c; ..
   .4~~~~ JLo? Sec,{,;~ $~) t'/e4-h/~ f>~/e~ ifkf{P (Jk_
   Cow v;c-ft~ c~w4- cke- 1-;~s f/lnJ- (LallA- /JVl-L IV~ t{~ftei1 fk_ C/~~1<­
    S~rj/ rnu-s+   hiv /1-tV.J   ~~f rf2c_ Al~f ~ ~ Ca~~;/
   ~ls,

£ PRil1tJl ~/( fef~, ::rC·
        JJA~t!?LJ/~¥"5es             Cw_.,;k,J   /e tJ,._ ~-7 ;r/~ 8,._7
  fdD    se1 ,t_,,y,Jt:.l~ Uj'l<?sl ~ 1;1:"7 rfk4- ~e't'~.e,...-1- 1.-n
  Jl)~.f- dJ,e_ .kS dovl..; of dfice- r~/.1 ~rf fh /& ~Pf.n ~ h.-Jkf
  1'h:s J,;},Jrrf;;~ l~ ;aad 6n'12 /I~J 4.-,-5 s"Zts~:~l~ fYltt/;t kd/
  i/e_ f~5 hJ(_ Attl tfJd~ da~(Y-fz~ ;2e_~(JJvf ~ fk_ lvs Oky,~(J)
   w,,)( df ;/ot.uy C."f..-5 ..;., ((k__ eo<L&f FIJ_ ~ f!A rr/(lf{le{L
   (le/,~ 17vA- .fh:-s co-ve.f du.. ~ 1/:sf /J..,J f.e·~·

  -:t  he~~J, d,_vt,~ U,vk,._ ~/3/7 tl'rr~~ 11.4 '{k_
   ~l.eJo~ ,;-~.. ~~ /5 ~..___ AVj cu4<e,>f-,f. (I.e buf·f-~
   ktvu)A;/eJ,fL ~Jtt/j_ ~(;~ r:J-v d ;f'ue_ ~· rfh6 r/o ~~Ji)~L~~
   !Jy'ljU-J[~ l~ ~Sft;, ~)415   I

                                       U).