Court Opinion

ID: 4042784
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:10:48.473681+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:17:17.383593
License: Public Domain

/;4 _1j ' _ 194 107 ,’

::)\N ' 9
w\z¥\nNALAPPEALS ' g 2- fw l gi 0 l
r`r_U U4 2015

7 n e_,. C/`//»/'l%/ /@/5444/5 7 147 54/€6
j 9 J44544 ~7/£/474/9 7
- /74 44”7`4 15 )/4/)447,/7/45 ahz/ 7477/ 7776‘/', 44 /`f
/3.;10/7*//17/4/4 4 j 744<;74.4M 41 C4/z4'/ 54447744 4/44'
_04/1‘? 644,4;4/ 445 /447444(/ 114/v //707 M/£M 44 %44445
f 414/af j 447 W/‘/# /1'»4 ~/473/ /477‘er 794 Cz"§/é 7944 C@g//-
79: 5/4754 47"74 544/445 c0»577147'27474/7 7% 777,7 W,Q¢/
446 edj/Mc€/ 47444°@441/, 9 444.4 54447 /75444144/
cows 744/44 wmsz 4 447/24 54447'144 444 44444/ 744/4
ld”€/¢/é/ 119/44447/' /?€V/€M ./ dy! 170// 795/7440 7944//€ 5/7¢/'“
044/04 079 641/456 40444476 j 4744/v 79444 1//4/<
441/44 14//// 417‘“ 44457" /1107@ 44 444 W/€/?L 44//1/ 1”/€
. 841/emc 4144%€44¢// ' ._
1 6/4 1144 674/404 7944 3§/5" 4744/44 794 424/747/79
444 147754475945 4744/4 45 744 45 4477777475 794/474 744
44 /€’4/4£44/77“ 44 494 54 j 544 79/7/7/ /44547/47~4
444/4 44§ 641/44 4€4/ 447 .7‘4 414 //47 /"4454 7%4
59 4/41/5 //45 443 24 444/// 674/4417§/744,, 4/47'64 75 4
6/444 474/4744 444445~4_ 444¢/ /)’77477/ 774 4474/4/74»€ /_f~
l/@A/547€4/)/47`j11 794(4“ 7%€1/ 44 4 147/¢/ //747 494 444/6 48
/\/€41¢ //7§7¢~`94/ 072 5€/’>///9/¢ /// 44 /yp¢//€ 64a/34 f 4444
790 4€/44~6 794/3 13 4!44454 444 434/jj /4/415 4/7//)`
We// 477/4164 4444’ 1/74 1447 4744/74 1474 /€4/’4797
77)4'/ 474 447 4/4/7 / 1/4//'74 444/449 44 544 74 4 441/44
~ 076 d$’é/€'é?i/d') OA 79%€ ‘€////€/‘)6~€ §411W/n/4 /H€]§[€CHV~Q
. 604/401/7 //0/’ 49 144/74/417 744 794¢4 4444 444 44
144 4444/44/4 775€4 444/4 54 474 5444/4 7744.44 447/4
/74€47. 4//77'41/44/. 7/ _h/éf$ 7)"4’4)7¢411€44 417 10 /HVS

 
  

I_

7602 €39/1)7‘7:70¢" Wa"/` 777/172 zléemdccc/Ae/ 77/,'717@771 .

 

0 ApJ/~¢ 713 '
7"%// 647 710/4 %~€ 167/772 @#€7§~3 77l €V//e//,cv€ f

701/3 ,7/277/7/.@7/ 5777») 717771 7111#:3 3777717¢71 777/1172

 

_€V€h OcCc//Qe/,~ 774-71 /27;/ //¢77 77/717'7/1` @H/C»PK /W/
711/775/§€6/ /7¢/ %/U/€¢/:V, f 6,§//€%€ 5‘€777‘€0€/71¢ 771/73 710

 

Qy¢/ayf’ 71//7170¢1/“ 737/2777 02 cwm€r/ )`§ 777,77%1/€
dea/3 V/'a/m‘/y/v 676 /m/ /<'/7771),. 772 ,1?/'££ 61675@71
/'715 777%0/27717/ 47% a/sc/@»%ivh m 537/3/37/ /77571777,3@;

 

/`K(’€-€ by l//O//d-'?(rf/)¢ lha/‘i/y 076 /’1// CfV// /4/¢/7<[’ z 77

¢/

 

VW'»/€ %"%€/V/%/PY //27/1/ 717d /\/77772 2071/271 l
777 (061,2.'/` 07 Cé'/'/m/»a/% %///JM[€’ W`/// /%0%'/11 /M»€ .
w/'M 577/7 57¢2` 777 M"/\@/ f 5;777@7/7 '/7777/( )/77
797/2 1777/2 717/w /`7 717/s W_, /`_7777'7177»71 77771773,_

 

~» '

 

 

 

 

 

- l 77/%_11“ 'M_
/777/77/ \ ~ /~77//7‘ '

 

W 471/72 fwff 7/7,’71

 

611/1 /<137`1,42/W/26 - ~ - __
77/)/7/2777/7?’ 777/17 ` . vi . b .