Court Opinion

ID: 4074661
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 05:18:27.296692+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:09.202302
License: Public Domain

' C Lg;K/é¢,mis;+ wz§z%€
b /,(r,d A§£L /4[:15‘64»» n

171 »KE: /M map 015:3.€7/2,5 z 033533,;,/ 76
.< ¢--€33,, ALA,GF><SA '1,5 3533/3 155 57 655 337/533 ;
" 7§7"“5?» 3~;9~( _('.’ 1663/3 '/13/1))37'33//‘1;___4  
f ‘/f"iv _) C` L€/€\¢‘§ /w`/w“,vi.<s@w% A<~7 13 ' `

‘ ii fm 33 KZ;/~'-§{)WJ£ 5£/ /;7¢;;761 judr‘(/}Z`
933/327 353,@33 hog/w mbm/abf-

@_/( LM§E/(é CA)A"~

()"5»‘@_0 v7)')5/._§5,>3,5 ,)l. o
» human 03 M¢~),,€MS@@~E]

“Pu$;' A/\f//\£>K d
A~»»d ~'D»~A_ wm 10 A@PM'/M/ of D~A

[Mt.,q£f£¢ ll

,Pccw: §;Le 333 555775_,434 § __{ 5~35¢
w»#'t/ £Lé,<l<}§._ D%*Z‘g(;§_),_¢ ja
§ 1 * 517/gay fpa ):ZM"/"/`z¢’-"#
3057¢5307 733/hew

3_53.,_'7_;‘3 33 . .

   

 

_ _ .f»"..-_ v _. r'v -~ n :§v\p§~/M D)$'F
d y r, ja»i$ _ l 07
ti/%y ` -' /6727 [044/€"`/: &706’(0,

l/¢"
,. g 735 f =
. 733-~ 777 d vw

 

A,g,t,<$<zq'-'£ _
,/

/wm°) . 1155 337/243 vOP@@;m°‘*@l.\’/@'
g L@€\<, c LAKBSA w 35573/3 5 § A? 1533 76
/001;,51/ ;g_¢_,_)_§_§_ § .uw@;so_»..v¢@ ',*4.~,§4¢/<_ “
'K"£SOL\J£D' fan/97 (J/J`Wo(/€A’:Q 93§/:7/“$/\§
_1:1555/<»3¢-3 6 03/"7~§:*3»¢ 5 ~' -
cwqu Lz,€\s;A, wsm@€l> 337 €OMPLY@W# .
` 332'<,£3333 D&+zvi"ii~ziz'.`<;.?¢ Q;';;z~~&?'353~¢1‘2>%)"?'3'1¢1, '
evvz‘% 357/'¥5};::5533 3 57@_73_;'?§°3'?’/'*‘ "
mc?’si’@») 5/5;1;3 <z;o*‘;v_v_=HA§zAs €5/<’33~5/ 4
w?rv'a Mamve,wvm @F ;,&v¢ A»)Q;¢/A.,¢Bré,<]_?&'&j
,53§1,>3,1\ _A»s v¢?§ 7,§¢;/€1>/€@5337 MW/zv _ .
356 vQ/¢z~z/z D,vA 7357/:@ 3533-736 65051
C,C) M¢?'jia»l §£/u”'/ % ¢é£/( 044/675 ¢9_;\/ OUEM$F/__;_; 1
151 aqu bhva 743/fw _P@€;§_WM¢(“/M% 393557'§ " '

  

,./"
/

. .»>

:5"?’5/< 't.cvc.p. 'm/°»/i’é~z€<°)%~i>wzv, cLA/<’i€f/i wzéfz'oe
iii/35 A l>w'fy~ /l/l/°N¢°$`Yé(’//°?L /4(`7 % )[,;(g /z.vA wequ
B.éll [HAP7€/€ éz/.o I©» l>x//’…m'v») /+M 503 1435
/5)571)7»< 50 we ms 533 33~7‘ ':37.5__~33, /1»¢5~@~57

Dié 165/bd ad Hi.s CMPY€/<’ 6140 l© /Licz/’M o,<’ e¢.i’;
ibm em&,¢zwe¢>us YAS .fbv Mv> 555£1;<' ,ez¢;>v,k@
75 1>,5\ Me\)& M_y. ,cm.u§@, 1037 553-333 6%6~<@
(`7'~“‘.6£'>7. AP;).QMD;M.M@" 135 d'/_,_?? /)W '
Eu€£u£ j W¢“w'fé/€>“, l/v> `55/5¢>)'1)5€~7 IFMD€_=§`",:J mg S-.w.

?A m§. ;C.~./z><` C,<),'H, Arprgwg> C;él,rj`A-Ua Wr
';"‘?A'fP/ fa._oaé§, v

M~.E‘l»s§) 33~§;¢~.33 mmr/43 C_,,,L,C,;
1115/45 70 Ac¢ww `11>'33':5@`»35‘" 522 7;_ `
73 ,.DNA 7£6'1’/245/.' "'7¢~¢£~ '/4,°30/‘5~/7/¢<¢3¢ ` '

_ 73 cwa 713 'MA/J>Ai/M ,3,;>533~1>,43 5ng
- 333 , 755?3-357 635 v;¢~;<v~;;zv€;' ';M */5 v mma
5 >< M`O~F?*' “F<Wz ;@.;5>*;)@¢'-__,)7_,~ 337/433 /€3¢2<3’.3730;
D`N/)L 757/113 V/'A ~¢1»‘;<’.'771/?€0_',{ KMMWMW"’”'
6§¢»»»\»'<»; ”7 573 jack/27 057/633 :<L)€i, Df/W
quL-€A) /W» cLE/<><<, CLA£,-fzs/; vog£§'z ' .
357# `9}4/4’5 0§`€<3,3.< ¢‘51§"~7£+: 603/373 md '/ l//‘_)€M?€ M£KALO_'£‘.. v .
"76016 57/?7¢7£5 ,3,_1_.4 5003/4,</~@'&17£0 Q_v_o,?> ufez£c;' `

&f Du'!c/ grf@;mwogr°c@€ r)¢v,e,¢);,»qpmz CQ) 353ij
1233 [333[3553.“ _ ' _ `

 

  

v.
-Q:

W /QECEJU® A 605/37 of O€/M?,u}z
1477/574 65/1’.1> §45511`5.5 11/35//3 1>173, 75551@

_ by 4574:§5551‘<1/17. D1L4771“67' 65577 3557). §/5157 l
/Wg 71555351¢¢5,31< ALA 711<§11 /155 5555“33/ 551>35 7

M¢)M §§ch 655/37 5 543/34 £€¥1»46 7 f¢@w
11613<1 {€5¢6 7.4¢'~@ /(”6519551>’6 554116 FJV 1757/11 l

`5\®1`¢1“115 DL<-(/€r‘c; Dg,-w 51145+¢551‘5 D£O§/o») 555
CLE,C)\ (7,47,_"_<§4 wfg§'z€,e§ /1/1//\//5 76€%£/1<7
4 75@5 ,75> 7> /11>1> err DNA 65 55335 755/755 -
LE£S_®F §6§ 510-66 57 ' .
\) \1;57‘)55160551457/1/1€'016411v1:5<555)51> 355-,4-70‘,6. _
75 575 53 755 , ` ,,,,,
523 1UO L>\OLo:¢CHL Z_Uli)EA/Q€ NA$ (@((5<7@ ¢)¢,7,‘,/_7
/1.¢£1'>.1¢4/-. €><AM,3 5 ,
357”§46 D€'FfA)D/W/$ 66NDMC'7 /5) DL§;V;//r/ PZM' l-
67,517/;53 -,71-13, 1//`"57/5»1 1455 1457 ,//1657 75 75,4.,£
§>101’.1;§/£/% 151_)4°¥>51).<11:".4 _
145 61),45,07 Em¢e § z 1115/591573@ 755 mg 1:»5,4,5
WH;L:/‘J @/{: CL{KKC/ AKL/§A LL)¢:B§-)fot¢ DNA 7¢5,6,;)3
7 714__1>,1:54555:15555 35 57575; 713 317 '
75 6055165 L",` .
77 ?3 deena/1753 555.47575 1577 111/1

/1/1/1\)1577MM€ "75 /}7751°57 D,~/A 6511,~.14&
/4,50 1115 541>3€ 1101<< LE§I< CAwS/¢\/ 1774 u£165,4

~THE )(?)FJ¢W/VIZAV 0{ DNA ZAMU§E¢ ;S /VMNM%K . l

 

 

 

l~(

3_.

. » F55>35f ' HAS1157 714 5?_7613 013 Df€f//zéf/<, ”
1575 5513 656 §3331°\135/\ “55`7_4,51373 75555>"
By pCZ.E,€\< CLAA";S$X 106&577/€/\/1/?¢4/1356£ 60,45 . *
Y/Qfé> ma 755 75777 7355,<1> 315-7,‘@,7< ._43,7 1
5 637 656/563 53€§133 511 A foMPLE-;'B

REC.@§D DW§D 5697351.6€7 1474/455 571>775567

___________-ii

, 6.§4,1¢~711;)5`_1*_3:_)` 06756€/? "[“7131193~_1§'}557550<) _‘¢1`7"‘_‘“‘90§,'
§1>\131/1156€ /6_7111;157§,11511§15_166€_;>_17~751&5_1§"
v ]>66£_//\56€ 1454 1}01_$_', ' l

1157 555 .§6_61)0~36 551 k
` 1) /‘< `65/‘110¢€75” @g_@fg, `_
73 911/1 7¢111,»11>73/<’ ;.615.51<<) 657/056 l
33 nco/1 77,4<1@7515 757555".©3<1»5'1~551 E>¢/mm,
:§511>1`51)15 D157/<’1`<'7‘ 65111€75.1>3,15 _751.~1/11135). c
3553 .Du£ 7£55335 113 Df/u?foj 1?1"`€41775 1 `
/1/1/17371’/16 /4151>151<55¢,?/174111/55‘§1)3557 15 _

1>3511’35 751 /1\/11.463» 1°7- 735?73 016\17553 -
7'1+61/ 174/157 779 0657,€657 2565-71§6£: _
Dg<zm§$€,£@1,; "

'47¢1§7 1676 1547 o“F

 

 

 

§‘E`n)£[> , ¢1.
6511133»775 . 703 7 »/€’, 903 1315114' ~
cL€/<I<, A§EL /1€5?'?' P` , J;YM 635 956571'1455. .
P(Jél//\BOS,€/(§‘TOL i" / TM w/o“~y'Vw 73376
5301,71;,,1,,4531/5,73514, ' ' ' » .. , . .
1 1'74'11: 1 ' -

5&€7'7‘/175 053£5€1//55
/1/15 15 75 565~75‘;"~711,57 7%,{71;¢£@/`3 51

15 771¢£ /$\JD 55/6(’8.'(7 7 %»/g §55/07/1,_?
K555 55151>55 /1~1'> /455 55€1°5/25~//11. 1~/15 555/7 yg

_515,<»1< 51/1/€15% 15513515151551<55¢5575555- ~
,1515511,35555 555/1557 /-1115 5555? 351 55555,4
75515 "1~/111151 154111) 51€/€1< 515155 5455551 '
54 5555@{71555 755/5555_5~57 12565>/12355
§11195`7552 y571'_/55515/1155'//1\1 75.;1</13 /*15'1/1 5 »
755 11/11°555) 505717£5 M/! 315 771/1 555
711/3 L_______o‘71-1 1)11753€' D£5E`M15£/: 51015
` ' )3/5§1/‘>

WEW

 

7,41115 0753_85

11555151)€1) bia/1164 755/v b

1 7/7”7/5¢/:;1_11:§§ `7/)5#131,;111;'5©1'555¢5

371164)(76€+755> /17 7053 /15/°51//157 1115511,1<,
~§/~1;15315 755.5\55555». 551/555 75515 555/55

j/U /_4,&»/@{/€§01\) (OuM-fg%j §;/W 719/ff .

A/ld%a/JI 15655€.‘71550 bQQoSZ/o/O 75 65711v

7555 51551115 "1>15 715 1155 1155 5:1115$ /11/111

§1/,57£,¢4 010 D£<‘EMSZ 1 ..
§`55)5517/12:~,,__'!5 10751

159/517