Court Opinion

ID: 4040962
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:41:09.770456+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:03:00.777591
License: Public Domain

"A /600-/V fcOHH 1602-H
   ORIGINAL—iJ«fc
               CouRT 5^ Cgat*tqfrl ft^gfrlA
                     KV^XH.T^^^                        gQ^T OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
                                                           FEB 17 2015
            N^-lUxE £vjfc>£^/fc U^^aivA^              —Abel Aeosta, Cferr
                         M^            MrttOisigft,
                 Tv^^E oVlisttPfe

                                                           FILED IN

                               Vr\\aSl\     *          AbelAcosta,Clerk
                               "5^gflSoH Cout-ifylfcXftS

            •"frrfcfa)^ Xoft ^Sfc&£UtK*Afty 1U\h,fcV^

                       fos&f ^aa tefrfltftwfcft.

Vg%foowg£ - V^o Be                        \KSVVLk ^^e^k W*fti&KM*H
                                     **OWfcv

"To tvte Uo^oftt&Us 'Sohteft St Tvte. t&}£[ at tatKLH^L tiftafts,

Tyx^ m.M^v\ (LouftT 6v ^e»\s ftvsft ^fraeft vtUcnTut (LouaT udi& Twfl "Tuey

yuT&*» tfriM.Eqp.aocft W^c^ frpUnvfrsxS ft d»&£ yiV^ft6 ^o^t to^StxTvAxto^-

ftfctv/i^k Tvte flU ^(?U4TS C^ £ attach ThiAVkc, t>^^\MaxcV4X^^Vg;ft9t.ftLaeWOft,q>t fr\)£

uMfcta.waM*\- fr(T ^Nl^tW* *Wj„C ftgT.ts3 J^feftpfc "fejfrl. tQb£ frflfo &-"
*4frfftaftT abates, fols^ ^*s\h*&*{.

 ?£TlTl&rse& -^fttt s&
(»&

1v\ .?A6V£._^^.^c"Imi>U X-HM$l\ ^&fe& UX

 0< TU\jJ L.Oo?d §K 0,0-vt^VNi^V. ^^iS\-S,T\\W.1S V^ LvV^GNHV\€ft5> Sqh£> toNStxW\TCssiv\Vr
 t>f ^XSO,3b \^CC»V\"CS \>( OtWfttfc
Xrl^lj^te^.^Kilv)S\ W^£ \(jfcWKfcft,VWoft^k "S^tc^xT^\4XnVU tdo^T oT
s\

     -^ k>. c 'l u •.j ->
         :                        Xh Tue>                      .
                       Lautre efr C(lXNVvnfrU fl^&ftU,

                      y>/-vX.lX& ^.v>Cj&m^ Utf^k<£lM,tfrN
                              .       Ml_     :          _

                                  Tyfe.^Uta e^W^

                    Trok *ff£*t frMQ^ e»Q- yy ponyi -£.&
                                            i>V i^opmfl-ta
                                            oVWooHVi-iLa
                     Trim. L^osg wo!* lb -
                                             tD_^lSo
                                             \o-\oil^_
                                     Ji^asowL.Uj^YJ^c^.

     Tcfe feXxTCftraG-C^NMXUXu £vC>&rvv; Uar(\£Mmvk.\ frKEH^wl T^e.qu^fitfifriT

      T&Tuk VWeftftQVfc ^n>(s£g, qT \qg QmCX oT Cft-Lvutv4&*& \4jiyst5 frw Xw\6ft£SV Xh tUrt tlftSk Ta T\fe fofifcwT (feTM~
£•& Rg^sgTtMfe ^^xbvj^XtotjS^bXu^ e&Xugss. T>»cX& <&Ute 6*c,e xs wibTv"\a«vv«i nnn^,
 ^ifl&\ frTW^ ^o^ Ty\e feXxTtiUMSgi.

_S8B_^L__JA_^

 l.orcS£XToR\\MSl*T£ IkiftXT IXv^^C&^d^ \ft.Mb So^T&^LX^ )

S^eiCy. V»MM6_av*x_too" ?WU l^fc^oai wfiviuavTfrti& nx-Hi.                           __

*4T&M_XmCd }                                                     r

^.^rstTx/^T^lC^               .              •     . •' .

 u^usX _„>C& Xtfv^t^^ yifrUteft <&%**> \^u<;TrxcT tojft,Tt"S€^€ft^o^ to^^TeiC^S
"XftCAl ___0£ ^bCa£,                              __

J         ___            ^\>cT_ o? Tu„ _a^,

ftyA TeftfruARNj VV_\0_ ^£ feTX~tXQi>J-&> \X--b Ca.X\3^ To S*-_fc> (>?.6hiSfel<;-_KiTv^
Xt^ $-t_tfr^l ^CttoSfc UtS <^lffbi^& __»__£.• X^Tfefrifatt* tt«U>( ^^V^Q\NX^CaL\/ lQ
ft£ >jc>r.^ -xvi^t^eo\i\)o $>^ *wVlx*^ fr* xUb 'WCavx^ ^oaT\*fc ?_faT&_*_fea Toa fr \f>
•>!_& .WtM^OfrXg-EXtOrt ^R_.-ftXtPt4 \<_nmth. XlUA V*frS _XX6nXn***s \H£NTfrV,vy in to-
^^%^\ 1q ^. NNxUxX T.xJCoP-oxUAft^tA'ftN^^^ frXlbsfc Vtetf-eX T&
\^__.eci s>T T^£ CouRT $ tffl,^^'-
 >a*>X ^^ftXSxT S>Ntc\RToNvJRxTc hoThxhCo ^\jTT^Ta.T\4 _>ott_l$ KS 6>ob.
Jyte vVfoTxoMga \mp& -Lh ioM^eXSt>fr To SWfc" a WioTtOW Xo ftSMoVfe ^ftt „t\X_obJ
V^&PrPiXt_> (\_>»fr ^fewl^M LXM^ <&_XXV»S& ^^0_H,(gj_ (_.Qot_S.-. M<3ttt\_:,0* fabate <*0-
XtioH Xo 3>fcNcM& fabftfrTtOH V.6^^fc * SSnfcN ju^G V1XX.X gtVW Xvfe Uo>si(_RM.l£
 tovj^T^ttX U£r 9gfiToRM<*wT\Afc ^xXcoh^v^xLX-__ &jkgK& Har^jvaAn^ .&_ fcflVtagnfi* , M V\ *n(_ m&X-
Xoh Xo ftgNovte \kog>ft%,ON U_\R_t_,* .fefrT&N tx*CvftgyftW* __tofth .?(&__>,XV
 r\_U-3J_x3lS-^&x_^J?W. Tvlktoxfoo^£at%Nxu.T_ €.v)0>.^<_. Uttgp(.wfrHft-^_._T£fc
TOR UtS frffi0rt.h4X_.J_ -CM>v.-£t. VA^Svi^^X,5-&;V&K_.X_c M.SX^^A^. ^.\^k£cfltifeWx&*T 9srWm^^-T^s Vy_doftttafe tcoaX Vte'fo-

rHot4X&j_J^A§c^^^
_&l<_L____i£__^^
_S__TVkM^£A_Mj^^
T^X^X-, to< fofeinyk KlX\ft_Xxfrv& oX Va__ MoCtCyiT. frfcHO^.. ^«.^toH V\&NRXMt> h-
 Kib S&NX^KX-cwts oto enXoft-ft \»A^0joV1 WfrS Xr*toM^_XswX To ^X__j_X\fet \AfoaTHwkR W^ &&H-t*B&R *»J>) eftTvXS JKbXtQoi Xq &&\to\&_i \V-^TUW\^fiMtU*S>
 <\yib S&nXfeH^-cyj- Wi&Xo \A_ Vv_.NTifrX %flfe«S&& ^bTtPN To &&n«^£ ^ftakot. xAem-
 ftyiC fr*_> _s>^^<^v4Gv^_at$RS ^_f.oRh1Tt>SA|\V\a^X^taS--0l3^iPttit_ XV~
 V^__V ^\W.TVA& \^&Xx\„^eRtVxX.xgs fcvi {_&*»(_ UflRb^AAMxXX.V.m_SVVH._; _u Cafem-ts VA«WOfeVAfrM xfL5o -_uKPft*A VH. ik^aXwteQ Co-
^d<_X HS.Sg^ggXxHXVtoX \A^U\M>^c_s- \VsflX»V.X_ frXT^e VJk.XA^xXftl^QR,

 fa„\fcT\jWX \WttxAxS ftffittftfefc __u*4_SX wS> W^&M-Xm "frtW ftcX .M Vc^Tofiy^-
or ,n vto x^XoRH^Xxo^^yob ^ySfewL V.£flW£ fr (Um^^wxT^ Sfl\\jR\lt__-
ofr _%hc&i Tor _£TfeflSQt4 ..^y^ks WfoT _0^ ofacfc MS, K&w TjvyTX
_ft__N*V,                                  t*t«MRv                                „C\AtftVC *3Ll>t

    Tor^q^Tr&^T^-vs^T yv,Hb> „r*b_fi fr Svrxexfr& VJ«feM TcrTwo w^As.Xvte fr_XXXi,-
    qHSRvyitUXx_ £v> _6h.v y\ttRb£fr/VftrtlvJk'_ XAiftR^^b \QVUmT\A-: W5_.C\tX-RftWS ^pp-V'
    tiX-b i^_»\-SSL ^R,XUo«v*ftS Xft.frfl*h>VVNwc> Xfl& vJhSvSt'^St^6t)rrflRXcX x._j£C{_g?K£gk-
    ^toot-*TytT&us V»^v4^>A/^\j^^^v;^^'^^trt^^«x\jSbT. i(M„_\ ^ __My_~
   X_hc<| xA-x^rxk., S&%t ^<\ax_ft a^ TfMriSoN^\ X/Vfrfv&aft^wAo v51wur.W ex-
   Tx^l ?fe^ ^^.Sou^n \J _,VIV- 5. cX.^ia;^V.c^.ab.-^.\t^ a.a"V__tR.~
   -x_X tquftX^XvS^Q^ Coui^Xfcfofl vinW* W>|H$. VftlKgg^fcX,. 9ft(_SlbXMk ftxfr
   ^tOl ftcX v/^XXutu Tlfc xV.£ fao x7l»STo VV-Xb fr Xn _o»a? _fl_y^ fl-ARfriG.
    5^T.V\nSoh Nft W^Vao X3b, ifo^l.^C^* ixR/vwj fcfto^Xfcb Cguw^X^
   •^.Taa_ ^-or8_ gfc x^RfcRMx^t Nto c(\Xxoq*X ftv/X^ *&Xyi_ taftifa>r._A __orX fr^~
    _x„Xfrft frXXrtMfr^ frtfl wot £* __.RtxS| ifftXyfe fetl -
   |X„t_e.^ AVqRm^Y* ^XXoftHSy ^viRRft^-^fe 'S&ct.pson oiwTyffettft ?(fo„cvTofttfrNb
    -foe u^Sosfl afr^frxvtetiX teoRXt._^fes\3e«M (L^sXy ;_&¥_> u^ X/qM-Ksr'^(.g- fa&gx-
    bx^_ iK ^t_b \^ARX9ftVw/ita> hfl& woX w\Vh -
    o^t* fclyjfl fo\c.Wv»Xat,X woa, ^ \jCnovn X^srX ^ tticXb toX vwbTytey fro voT
    fosses T\_ x^cRXise To ^ xx Tv\& frclxAxo^sa M4.& _)»*y_Ts»*T or wot &c-xmIXh_
    TV\£ uWSo&X'aba^^xS^^ WX^Tyy. feoS&>jToRYtWTVte ?fe"XXXxQH(_ ^ginUb VXX.-
    CRttfcY V^bTUfe^^tiow^^x.u-_fe £vtr_N_ XAMb^tM^w^v^WvX^b fty *\*Xt_N-
    _&b ^j.^x<\XrxSX \kX TyteT^cfrRSotvi Uo»jX|vT-^aS TV.xX fogXsR-Tv_ 9^xX_o>o^ft
    TV-b kuXlXM To Wb 6^oyi-^ X^T\Ae XviaXcXyA-^X^^XC-^N^^ ^et?vrv.Re<- frf V-^>^,tM^. U\P>RbC^M^W,
   h_tvi.^ ^v^^g5                                                                        _^
    'SesX&R WV \J^XT
    ___$_______>.
    %xuAvv0^vT^^ n^HoV
o__ * • m

                                    %sMi®tJ 1 _*&&_,                             . •                          h

     Xfrfcrrttfy ov tWfrfcS -M, 4f>vu. ,3U                                   •                                    3
                                                     «*«*•*

     '_^ff___________*b MIpvh-h\                                  ,              • •                          AId-^H
      STAT.^rTv dt "ft,, C*&& •.                                                                               n-n
      6» &&_$«&». Yoft &(*A«i&£;>               '.     .'•,.-                                   ____              5
     fMe%v^4*" of %i^cT$                                                                        :              N*4-U>

      t__ax\Xtft% o* Co^^wx^Ht^ >n%i •Y\g^ ^H -t                                                      _   .    • %h
      __-tA» el -&&&XV-3                      •-             . .'        •            • '                a.
     •_tt»t t>\W$tftH ftwfc ;fertN&%            -. ' • ' •
     H_-W\Q _t\Hx>_Wy _^>Xr^X.QV^                                                                                 __»
     _____J____J___ti_                                                                           _:                ^
     VK__yr\.(\V 1*4 £c_>Ky_X_ _T
     'tbfti.e.X       Vo& ?cX-cxxo^cA                                                                              H

                                                                                          -,

         -

                  ,             .           •

                                        ,                     •          .            •
     3,

                  X->-rt^X_XY 6% xW\X£S Ayb tex_N._-lS
Vofigy\j_hX To T_tt-.fr. *^,3_ ,\ CA^-Tx.XxDr4eft „&RlxXx^ 1W Tv_. to-
 _XQv_Jl-y4,> 9(SB„p__ HeW _A*>?fc fru X^X&ft&bX X<_TvAxS C*__ToTVte t^Tg^\ Q^
"T_C__a Pvd^yaTxNG; ^^x(g_._%Txbfr>S^f\N->'TU'tS C-^^X^XL^Txbfcvf XSUftbcXro 0-
 9v-_a TW^C Tyfc XR__X_Xv4k _\_bv_g£ Wj foftWA\£ Tvte t^TxxXe, 6f Xwfeft-
 eSfev                                                              :     _...

WflJuX-V x^v _>ew_, \W_fcVVht4
?gXxTx.0r4_^ ~ ^0 *._.

S____;_x_.______i^___^

T_._^e**t_ x_(_r» XAoX»*£S^H__. ^xx^w^^^tao^T fv^._. xnxoA.
 _vTg-aya^Y ^QR.Tue X_XxTx_t4£R ftt* *ty£_-X-.

Tu-^«_ _x ^a_ft,_w^^___t_TfcX»s' 'vxnoi
"XxasX ^TX6Rfi<>'Y Xo-„T\te feX_Xt_j_a.

^e>_4._Y a U^&Rx^foSSxSXWT C^x^X^l ^XSXr-c„ KTX^_^_^__-_Mt„J_bv.
*T^te__V_^^^
 ___i.*_-_^o„T^^*fe» bX V6**£ om _^_kX,

i<_^_xi^
__Mt^____^___TO\            , _,      __!___________       ___     —y^"
_L^t_>_(_L__^^^

^ly^S^^^^^^^^ ^kUh^Jd^C\ ftflrtyftfex** tt .*q,
Kx^^ WtxAe^TxTxoH^:^ $afcfl&. h?p£frL (t__alT /j.*v*ott*w _•__.