Court Opinion

ID: 4063274
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 20:47:52.024449+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:40.896244
License: Public Domain

AN\RU_ \_L\; &\\ZD§M Dw\d~'mo\BS~Cth\\ 1111 §|`;(U_-l. CN;QT

.\/5 \3~03'7'+>< §§ /AQPEF\\_ ', , x `
T' ¥\E_ SEP\IE_ ®£TE>Q§ _S<xt¢\ /L?P@/m¢qg§b@¢s+r&
. Th§h“§f??é§’§ »
HN&D'N 'C` w Re§\§€§mg P\M ¢:1,_1)

     

f!d'UN `”1 5 2015
~‘1€1»'»'-@, 2015 E>€ C_F_RTI \'~IF_B _S`UU;E QRI_W\I|\.;@KLWM Texas
,1 Teé(askx L F\\)U &\X:_§CIDN.S '?'Débr:a‘~'r<.é“Aw{r@g/,-ccerk
;`. _-;w .-:-L,.z;;:i§),.»', !er
Tl> T\~\EH<M>KHBL& gomez c\€ garb c_mm:'.
\\K>ug K`__GW\ELS `ULE_ AP"P@\\uiL I(\L `EM`F_ ABb\/E
/\ND \\\\_xrv\&€_»l<r;© C.’Jm§\‘-"_‘S, Amb ?\E§?Eci_€u\m _
"RE;;M\;§& TM_§ \Ab\\;oRmQ,u-: Lmem m Remew "
T\‘\YZ (\_E?\`VS\_VIED S'CAIE &er\/\INAL LF\W (§uESTIDn)s.
§§ mw Ax\\h €F\rLg `C\wai was Ev\)m&£m w

mg L_EB"c_§\oL£ure_ umw m §U\‘cm€ m P&mm cong
\`§.@4;1&0)3®\ AMENDEA T_B \§.L&Z>SC,M.

P<>A `\;\§§_ P\Ecagm; Auibaz ABW€_ APPELWL 001 ¢
gmc ma %\me»,‘ , `
` _/LL

/\Pe_\\cm_ \\_ua; Q¥\WA mm C_m\/\'c,%d 9011 /LSLHCE j

¢Lb,`\\ Q£XQA\& m\'_§`r\ah\e \__\.(\A.M \'S\.ZS[&\ ‘@Dc ~(;]¢\:L E>{\£CHS{,

@1; B\A(<£ALUW §§ cl Bu;LDir,\£ \>ur\.;s~k@i \Qu .Qm€zmm@w}
\_Y`\ G_S_[_CL&L_\£;LL\_ gov GN\M tUu/\A §§ mat W\.oVL tham
‘ 4 d‘c L_L;S drum

‘D~€` LLUB §L)lzsa_°lu@r\:b-_ "Pvr;vc`ou`s'
€_c:<\\){r&_imr\/ CJ\`\Q_ E}& m rD\'e.uicu; _€LJB_<_.¢-;£lu@:& C.®n\)¢’d;¢`&,
u¢ci$ Ca_ MBN._SIQ_)L€._ `&QLL\ €c\c_mu mm flame r\)O'. Q¢»o/QW
m C>Jc}w,'x Suh$efi_U&/\l~, 1 L.LSA wax Cl ridr€,w`ous
Btu_w_ `&a;( 42 » "Rmc$m{@t¢ unth \A.B.-SLQ) an mus<
“ . " ` ‘ E)(\¥\amrip.l I.Jr\<(_o/\
mm.¢_) a_m.@v\_AM' +_13

”D`L_§c;@_§$i<om
BaMo@ YESPQCS&C\)\N VC;L\€S¢ Jc}m`\.& \j©\)QRRB(e CQUY£;
355 1\!\€1\/\11. Ya{'e,)\_wm_ m Hw\_a_ €:>§>~\v\)cor\ &S. w th

C_an;l€'w;;\ _S‘&Q&Q_ Cfum.u'\ul LCMM ®u&§tior{> helena

§“1;&1\; C_N_v\/\mm \x\w ®\mhov\

\\\“QK. m ¥_\\Q._ Le_§ i$\ahme_ T€Wh _S£cd;& AGL`¢\ {c_\m\q.'s_
"Por\`\$\r\a§o\e. umw \'A.§S Q) '_’?€MA CD&_¢)_" JG\M; LU&_S rPY‘€.\/¢`<l)$
€_Y\\d)/v\£o.§ \_AY\M)\ Qc)wv\n)\ f?€)(\nzl CD§\,Q_ \ZL.-U¢A (.G_'\(&) §§ (L
S:;L,@r\é &e.@\*e_e, f€a\o<xu"' w ha \'Cu$¢¢§ admin cz£ Q__i€;/_Qgi
§f§\*e_o_ Q€Xmg Lm_‘c\\ C\_ nom gaoch ~&cLl\ €dom cLS CL_
§u|r>$a&uex\k. Q'C\Bn~e C,O'r\\)i(‘,%ion w 1€_ @:\(1\01/¥1£§_ Om,o%k\u
SM ,_§CL`\\ F\Q.\U\q R>\>U&s\§ah\e Ur\.hm \11.5$ md lam m
E_Q_LJ\\/GAML tdc & `C,€`_L.€x\é,_ Ae£ma__ "P\>f\`\s\¢\VY\Q/v\& \)`r\AQ)\

- wc?@_u&_ m ¥-\QL\ 1113ch E>QL€)(\}>M umw ”Pem,\ mm
S€.Q&_`\'c»\ `\’&.WAE>LB\

 

‘ __ _ §§06§“\}¢®&:. q _
%P€){\u& vibe 121 .qas u;) _§P<:_c_\=£i uaw ve €€.)\'.1 J® two
QL\C>r\ LC$ ED'H\Q)\ ‘Hr\£u/\ 0_ `SJcU&L~lCu\ 'C€_LQMH ?wv\(`$ha,é)(@_
mm\w\ \'3135 cal . - '

wm md @_ "PM\ c,@@ EMMS¢ L@S€;_\ ah cmm

¢L\Je. 4::> CL 60me ()\/Y\A ‘M_ "(V\Q;;€v\ G/“A€_mcw`
Y:\K OLJQ<MLQ,\ LQ\_\v‘<J<_gE’Q \/_lo-’Pa»xl+~\_\n¢ah+-Q$R£xa.s-\-<¢

N'\`>\'S. QD)(\ O_J\)A`\('_ui C;mv£, (`_U\§<vu-¢ B\L/ LQM\JM¢
_Ae_L wit L\'\ fl ”Pe)¢\u.k C~_@&Q~.cw\a e,v\M 1111/um mmu&q¢
ujik\vu\s‘< t\v\a_ Le£ LS\c¢_-kuv&'_ cl(>@mual_,

N\B\U<\ C,L`a/v\ C`s_ SJQM£_ C_L;x_w&». L_€Jr\\rioL- -ur\A_o/\ arm _§M€¢
c>{ `\_M" mass ’P\Mst\ mt umw amo+\w\ sigma @€

\_M , mg \;L\_o/v\ usc \~_Lm_ ”R)an/M,rv\o/»\L +_|¢\.a& was cause
UNLU scm z>\>\@o$£n_‘& _S+_MLA¢, ama them musa £_`1‘:
CL§ (>`, er\€e\ (Lor\uiri~.¢'or\ 0€€0/15<,/0/)»& L)$L ffc a,_g~ Q_
_§L)L)_SL.QU€/Y\L Q£,\o'r\¢l ~kD ‘(C €!r\`r\M/r\ca_/

\\\GS. D>c> ouw c_<>e\`§l_u`»¢u&;c>r\ "ce.€mi`v~e. 0.\\ §§ LjM_
C.i‘c:LMY, §§ H/\_o_ L)U'\£e,.§ $& 64 'L:_.&`uua( FP\»c>-¥Cc;%ion .A
.'\:3;9€_ "\>\cec,e_c§ Q>E Lcwd$ UL U_`:£LQ €X\CI_CQHA \od -H.m.

'\Ve_@{_;\ ame,
We'/Q»

(Q. Dl}l Y§\d>bm; \”C,L`Le»ue. `Lr\ e_££<>,¢.tlu¢ f\§.$\‘s'£&me,
®£ algoma 00 &POQM \..L)k\m\ \~\;g G_G:w(mw §ch w
Q`wsk ~\x\~'€c:<vv\ Y>\Q.goe_ 1<3€ \(\1.; `Lr\i,e/L£.€Or\/ CJ/v\<l, give
B\LLSG€ ‘;\\u. \'>9(3:>‘¢&'\)¥\1_&§ Jc§> €r`£`ru/\ w\`¥(fLA/\M jdw_,
weed gm ..\:1> \\1`3 /~\y\>§m; B\“L¢»_£, 'm mm w£vq
m 9,1£\111 m cl mbe;mw m vv\c¢m c,L <~_zvmw(

`r@_.§i_w.£¥ gov -CLPPOZ/\JL r»\m/\,% §§ /’v_UDvuJ‘@/<.q JCD
m \M@,;es 1b1 am 01,@¢>¢»_@\. CWUC

h v “®.\_x\bt£_"
\\'\Q_ L.¢_Q\S\Cx;hxe_ €__\L’Plic_'u;\w va\)`cLQ$ €O\' Co,nmin \Ciwm

{_ `®"L f\m_JL-§L€\L e_\\\\w\r_omw_»d"". of _%wtz___l ` ' '
\§ ~\;}\_o_ Lc`fx\ls\o.}pve_ \r\g¢§ `m§:n! § time O_aélbnf‘:_;:g:;;®(%[w'
`S££&€` AQ"“QC\\>U \o€_ <:\\'3`\&31€_ gm finkme unJMIJ#Q
.©~\CQ~\ §>v{vw\ 00:\ \A.$+JLS.L&"PMSM”, ,LJL Ls LJ~K¢N tmi ;_;
won "\O\ue_ mw _Sa` So,. 615 i_A./“,l - £.ce(
_%¥_uie___\al( {`€_\wm-¢_<.. c L w‘H/) alamo

m "1\$v _\x>§_LLLC\§\ §\__£;J_Av&_ C`.\,\A_L§e._¢ \_'LS A{_SC_/LQJ;`¢CV\ ib“{
`LJY\:¥Y®€>U\_§§_\£ Cl.£>@\_%‘ms )\~_§M_ LCW_>:> C_Dx\_tyo.m{ w Jq_LL (_€gi$,__
\M;uw__ miami /(M\Sw, M)L w HM_ Qc<,d; c>€ ith nnist@re

c>£ \-_-__\/\o_ \_a,u> °.E>\L.L;we_ `L_S \CC’_,P€_Q_;\;LM .SLJ§'@@\.L`@‘¢ ~C\»~om
C'l_ `(\!\LSCQM___`\¢L$€__ D‘(. \ALS_S&`\(`_Q_ _ ~
_S£Cd:i_}ce$ Y,\_>\o._s Cmr\/SL R_o_./f»u&a_):_iov\_` DA_a. 4_~_\¢~_ Cl_ocomo./A
°dr\cd; _3?€_,\& DL§& \:_\M_~ L_Cu.u; §§ t\c\¢.; §&aie., +lw_£sx_miv\(
1 c>\c OL ’Pmdc`\cpm G_Qemr,u, Qu_sa Ae.c:s:@h§ 5 md hw+}m&
\ guns _5_£_9-_ `\A'L§r£)\&>ve_l;e.l, l¢:¢_s& J<&~a __S&aJ\_Q;ms¢ _ inl~ L,§ Jdu\
rla£:\.)c¢\ mm L&_se,\!; QQU»L €_v\ c._ smh,+€_, wm ev
ve_§\_)\€)_ilor\. ’
- '?>mk@& ¥ » t
L;\A\M` EC&Q§E , /YR\LEM\X\`\_SE,, QCY\€:L<X.QJ\Q X, /K"\>“‘?€_\\amt/PYO)J\,

3553 \imc\§)cu,\a _C_c:’n_)vt 'u_mgxkl ?\ame,w k-_X\L_CQA;Q;,
1_€;;; _<;LQ&L mmm< 1_@.,… w££<:;@n; w m

Yc£emm@._ lx\ m .o©m;..@r\ Ce,§ fm i~_LLL` (Mw§{
m %u¢; ,» w Ovv\y\ c>\:w\ _vc,\r@£ A.@,@m qsmpm

'P\@©M\q SJDW»L&:&@§
cL\L`AM\/\AL LLL P;XQ_&&€>Q_,

’P‘L_‘y{/ 3

\W/

ZL., Q\c&)v\m_ LLC%\€_A§@€,, H_Qn&;z&w umw (D\%Q\Lw
c.>& “P€J\_§\)vu jc&\u£; c-:o_ twa Cm/»A mack QDPq of blm

mfu`cx\ R€>_§mesé£n_g R,.e\/icw §§ Qa/UMG/`Q{ SM@
CJLUY\.L(\Q,( L_DM.A_J @.L)G.§\'io/\_\' \'\(L,ue " "

m@c;'. D€Bm w NMW, me m C_M m APPQL¢
_G_. v mh Ao€¢c\ax¢ D\;s+mx ada tim _/3/_ _57/915 `lu§é/cz Li/,m
ali /OD /\Jo/_P:U{ £'+0.€¢ Lm_a HV@nc/c #;lo TCXaA/Ccmo/ .'7`%
025-wl . m L.A¢_<.~ Ql¢u/ c~){ QlU/LQ Q/A C;)0/5,

Q]&WLLZ/ABM&§

jude/l