Court Opinion

ID: 4062654
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 20:34:19.870535+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:05:22.740648
License: Public Domain

/y\r~/l/g 7Aw 0 ¢m~¢///\/er’/»Abu~s
7`0¢17' # /73 ”?y

§~,U'le; butz L

_~?-o 60 /QM/?§/q

g va amen :‘~ 7£74$
7 7}<9.3'
12 £, _C_,z~» v/¢>é-‘>`O ~ /Q.Q 0537-5'

f`h(/v)eo/ 7¢9 rfc £¢5/)@/\$€ 7*¢9 740 CI~)/vu"/\m/ 01;$¢,.;¢,L Af;¢¢p/\n27

'1/.¢»'»¢ ana é/)¢ggg avA 7/1¢ Qes/;¢>'ts£

RECE|VED lN
COURT OF CR|M|NAL APPEALS

DEC 22 2015

Abe| Acosta, C|erk

7@/33/ 132

. - CJ`°@¢°@§'C> ~loéto,§,g¢/-g
A T//J)\ DM'M// /l/<-' L z `
/|/ 7 bad § ¢-'vM/~J¢ec criminal App e¢/_¢
7*050'/‘/.356'%'
Hawse 7//£/5 10’ wide m 363

mar//h/sh’l£s W».;~;. A a¢!~m rem 057 //

301'0 (~`M 3511/
B¢’¢M~Mom~|» 77€

0770<$

w\)»~\
Ws w,`M

70 rye /,l on/vle.¢ 1,/£ TW)EA'

/\/9 W 5 O/VIL=$ amd i/) nes/wnsg ry 7,9£ z/'/’m)"wl 0/'~$/P;`cf A#»~¢ey

ii T/>/Z~`/Z’M£V /'”'57`92.7' ¢P7/r¢ caze 6/"//`/ and c""'“"”“/ “/'/l F/WW 7}'€
544-le .7},,2 A,vr/`/Zq/ §7¢¢)7 '-Mz Jone .0¢1/1' /“"" N"< F"‘CFW‘ 74""~-1-` W“‘" /a
TH`M MJH\ ..r,vo fn ve,¢J~)jl.-)¢s? ims an fha fast I A/. A'w/ ”‘Y
M¢d»‘cul ,e¢»¢a.n/s ¢) f 7/~;'4/ A/);w,y.< sav ny w nw w 7"¢
T'"‘w\-§cr~fp~l\; nwle 3¢¢9 'M“/.¥Q`@v@? 5“+ 39"7‘$ "" /A‘° p°(/f£r:'
A/S" 515/1587 S'G>Ans¢n and yielded 6`“y "'W( 7‘1¢(7€ WO"¢M‘"’?
An/D '7-“”’3€ 51\¢¢»¢»'\ wj/svn A)$r) /)’nlw rh»»¢ /"y ¢“5¢ “’""" 4
A;c'$vwol /v\no<€r\ce and //’he»v 5"‘7¢¢,/'¢5 an //~< ¢,'¢¢,'/ gmc amy
/3€~# 7A¢ c/~}M}Ml else ,¢/L¢,./ ,¢' ,(`M/A M,¢ z;/\¢,,`,.¢s,z¢m¢e
'n‘"*,f h/¢J 371‘1;|¢.5` /umy adm 7£¢ a;?r/¢M~lro/ /`951>1'"/ ""“5 ;“"")

;;\ M“r¢l")§`~lj"°$ ¢’7' ‘7~'3§~7¢9/¢’;'¢?¢9 . WP/`/cAT/orp 7a be .4 fha draw

aP 7Ac cr"nn¢ d

TA€ 5)2¢»}6 01\` P‘V?z 7/\»¢} an Re l)rwy aj ¢,'7/.! 71=¢:¢ /’\7 v a‘/'*¢"‘¢"/).“5¢"‘f¢""`/""“"
was #{€r\`h¢@' ¢v/W»m~\- wh))-)m own rh‘s ,‘s pay ne A/»/»/,‘c¢m>é /wrw~ ;v>l 7¢> al n.,»

Hf:s ._Ahbl' oxe.@em§€ 911 "\"N'l~ lia/h ab\¢w¥- 1;3¢AM ,q,/,/_¢.}_,,¢c _I',ls“,\Wé

Ad>'t*\»\§ len M/‘.¢ p€AcQ(/f' 51'»0£1/€0[ q/gAf/n//ypm€ flqp/ died >¢'d 7%@
Trze wl nlrng .‘Z“/v_a.//\o¢\ Uur»eif //!/jl\[,¢,»¢ Ma,$ M.‘>/`¢? 710 #?/V/r?N/`.S`/¢z/

fly/911 ro/?€ ,*/1 5 n dalia/y and w}/Aoml» warn fay 745 3/1/” 7"¢.»)5,€¢¢! /I)/¢»,
I"v}oe brot]'c Cam$:`n? /»ze /1»;//.4¢1 UHrrr///npl[,en` 70 tall 95` fe 7" 7}"'9?4

7'/»¢ 7`/‘¢£ beh? T»i`mmea/ /)>"#~/°4; blm/wiles 45 F¢[//‘r}) and 5
/\r¢d nga usi TA¢ huge 7¢@/ 51.¢0/ 7.£o¢1‘w»€.< rig).+ nrx~l~ /’ 7"" 77"’<’ ""‘/

Ml+,`mwlr!/ V,‘o/m+l7l\,‘#;»9 me ;~M,w/ ;»g~¢.,»;»; M\/.s,»/A,

mg 175 /l/£c.@$f.z'?¢/ F’w~ A/vé‘l/ID£/;/rz¢;ey}¥€A£Ia/d .¢=we w,e jA-*M¢
EM come m)\.-P my ¢)'r$) €Me and c p,"mf,m,/ ,4'5 j.¢n;,;n§ ,,., ,b¢¢,\ /S`, yrurf
guam A /~»m md in p»/‘.sv» par A ¢»/‘/»¢¢ _z-h~¢»/) comw)%/~¢-¢'/ cm my /€ev/-’rere

rvv‘ palmch 700.{/-,~7 £v/Je and »1/ /D¢lpa~¢ypr/f ,and .z'd/¢/ny/;,/ A,,,` gary
»7/1£/ /27/0¢'/`4)”4“ ,¢¢/* /¢VA$ 7/!¢»%?7#£~¢¢

my £¢/)¢ wm ~f`/I-» A//s+¢¢¢¢ Ihz»»~m re
,, y/\ /-`¢/* /Vbc/“r¢» /‘S_/~?V".?

]`/¢/Zo;¢z 191/f /an/Vv 715 /97/¢»~¢/>6" 1117 <-/`v)`/ nyse w¢
7"¢ /V\»>y¢pé¢/// Qp¢§’ 7‘¢'¢ M"€ /j ID/\¢/¢$ z'h‘/`(/ /"1} 0""”/' 7£¢~5`€ rue/vw -
A/`ll) C/"/'/'?l‘/!¢z/ c;¢{¢

tolls/wu d” “'9 "4'3”"“ "" CIVJZ rd.$'é`§

O,` ;//.hA/Z¢¢;€ /|/'¢9¢ 392 39’/€5`€'§` PQ/)e farg

¢W.Wv. 3 w -.72 ~/3$#/¢¢ /?@/FM¢
C€$¢’/l/¢?¢ Z/,’ 75"~€V~331<*# l'?¢}->€¢'»i_r€
é¢tf/r!p 7)`;,1/

74"€ /5 A¢¢»,P p»/~ 4 /JeAz/,rg ,c¢» ue /J/)p/.»'<-qa+ 7`¢ be b»"¢>"y,~{=¢

7/,¢~.~‘5 4/;¢ /) vz~*w`Jm.se in 1/1¢ crim )',.,,: 71"_7/1¢%7¢/3¢¢¢ (»,'m‘/w/ Jnres/ga),'»g
J.) mo €ye»a)#,. csx TrsJ/"m M/

93 011/14 35 /`Ador\c/y\,§;rc haw npj_M~Jdr/)ly*))/,hzl-/_\;€[/¢} frld/

3) 7/‘¢ bvf/'/e wu /u+ n+ fAc 7"~)4/ _
'/) 7*‘<9"‘"\ 1441-3 llv¢ +e>.s~}¢(f Po/~ D/A Pz'h@e/'/?r/ih}`i /19""*°’£7€"‘”4'“'“

59 ""0 '*MM’~/ wns 4016'0\ w/¢s an~ )drn+,'£'k'd ¢1} '”.%7""(“/
é) /"‘°Mvv\ »F}led by A.)>q F¢cv/o/~ fur cvn{~,`nhqy\¢e A`or‘[/° b“/£]$“‘/}

q) ue eV"‘/¢N-’e was ho+ 7'1»5¢¢6( w»v hal ,`olm+$'@fe¢/ ¢¢T”’/ 7""“/ "" A/»"/S
§)..'7`/~'@€`#/4,5 no /.)A;A I§;`,\£c,\/,,`;,L.lé ;n$;;le ar p%+$;oye pp 7|`¢ glvne `
47 /VO secu'w,~#y ,/;,jeg gram any qm,“ ,/,~`TM‘H`N€W“¢ no+_/,,,m,ben,g,p/a*'rl~,a/
/0) /VU Pv/,\c( /`r,ow~+ wu; ;:H¢¢/ pn.,¢,c ¢,W‘.'Me “Me(

t yp»o{l&(% ¢"/frv;’p/
‘[,/gppj~»za/Q_/,?v v 7

 

&) 712 O/"`J`/"\A/l ¢1/)/)/,`¢41(¢`¢¢(.) qu)e,nwy/Aé A.A»l €vM/‘J- IQEC Ole’D$ ¢V/ne np,¢~
al/‘»\‘,\nb(¢ lpn 1/\¢ pa{e 7£¢ A/,/,//~c“n)_ \¢}/¢p/ 7£€ /)>'W/“y#k$ .4/-’/)//"¢“)(,1,“

H) 87 771/6 /’?W 51”"6[¢“'\¢6 Luv‘l~ Ag/~ 7/¢¢ yung/h would have deaq ,4]` 7»,‘4/
evaoL howe /va'"/' f*’¢vww{ '7/£¢ op}l//"c¢m£- 403 m'ly /;f/w/w/a rcw¢n¢.vL/¢

diowa

my 7,¢/¢=' aka pr\vces.s chase o.¢ M¢ /"~v¢>'»~¢een//r Ammdmm-PA¢,,; %wv,ow}_<
F)'».s/- 25 §Aw)n? )»‘b.,-~ly in }e»¢.#»/L amf szeen@/ /`.s’ va sl.»¢¢) y.~,, 5;,.,“/¢/
AFPc//M;l~ c¢mJ-end$ fM h)§ cons#l'¥'“+$w\a/ /€,:;A/s due £R~n w}}l'o»¢~/_
ne r_..») M,$¢,,,,/ ¢/¢c ,.,,,,,,+5, 7,¢¢ r,,..»¢- ,,.,,¢M/ »',1 z »n; y M.sx,;,,) 404
373 H~S' ¢/¢9 and 5~)'/¢, Vz;m¢ ses a,s 902 ///¢~/) 7/¢>¢ 7»4¢5~¢
F"""C/,v/¢’J were no,i who lze //'M/’,le¢/ ala 0)""/‘¢¢>1- Ap/)ca/s from
C""’":'\~l /0/’/76=\/5, bu+ cx'}end'¢’/ u/».'/fe 115 5/""€ /9“’5* °C¢>hV/"¢"¢/”vn,"

A 1"’7 ”'“n ac~l~,‘,\; ;¢\ A,3 @wn b¢A.¢//‘ ncaa/s 716 rcce~>/: even /b¢’¢'v

995'? 0/\ par '/5)7{/|/5,

7`£»\’45 crim proc Q,/.S~S` A// V)'ol€d w/T'/A audio a~¢ 742 é`c¢=ne »£A’¢°/

EV,!`DE`A/Ce] § D/VA F)`V e/~pr~;`a,l§ flaan an evi¢/ence i`P any
§ Vl’l{eo f€c@/~d;na\s I‘€mm`n wf/A 67*¢¢~/¢’3' é`u)o/e’h/e F‘P/` /?@V/`€“’]
>: § //' 199 /¢,.1,&, W,M

APP/l?€an-}- 7/1¢,-¢ was no Te.st/`mony 7')‘,¢} 7¢,, AfPe//M,¢W,¢s 7¢¢/0,»,.5,,.,
WA¢ I`Obb€¢£ Oc/uware W¢"Lpny¢»c»' 'A/e;’¢,/'e,_ wh)ca\/(e ar ¢_‘"`(nz¢

c o~r/\al 7Ae am )/ a\#\er ww`v'~/u's§ renal §Je,,,i,*p/ A/>/?//am¢ as 7Ae/P"`5"J
Hhv /‘01))0€1)/ h/“L'¢,Vee Zwrenza car/\¢/ 7?_5},%`/‘0¢/ 7/¢¢;" h¢¢//‘/nv)¢;e/
appeal /va/r AT/A¢ rvbb€/~.- £ l?`Q page 73

1961an wnhy cg ¢€J`¢"`A"<’¢/ 7/»¢/’/\¢ to u~/¢//w;l-Sec fAe robb e»_< F`a re c¢;¢//
661/amsc he /\.w/A nms/ran , £~`l/ch aFe/~ mg M¢,f W¢é /Q€M ov¢»¢/ ;.MA,W¢E,

C@w\al'h 5ee 1/`¢ pace slowly became Me .¢o~ce /Je cvu/¢/ av{'jrvLA
'Men+,‘.l~‘:m+h..

ApF/}can+ gl#¢§ dyne 714} A.¢ /3 Ac¢vm//y/`r\nvccn% é¢cse¢/ an 7¢,¢ pw,¢. 7/4,¢

bv~>'”? m vaa n ucmeo¢,v¢>,~+ usa , a 3/9 ”*~5’»‘“! ’\7/”" "’*’e “/`>“‘ 4 />W/>'"»@/
,~,.+;~,? ,;= /, im ,,WMA» m.»/r>», /m/, m 3/v ” 7“»'>#“//"//¢~ ~/»< ms »'¢»/¢/
b%m- pad by O¢F@M/w+ game D¢’/m‘ ‘“4 z’*¢' “"// 54 "“' /9¢/“4//7
h\ndr¢nl- an marcl» /$a Q""$` APp//"c¢m}- /V»¢'/’A"»D/"Q 45°"5/°"'"‘4"$*"’/

a lm;d¢. ».¢ lie 3/5’ "7`¢)}:$}@¢/ ny/n\ rowe dr\ /‘w¢¢/» _/'5`/;“9"3 "'>‘

4/>/>/~@)@),,.»+,» wm #v/v:w wm 54 m //"~¢’ ”" #/»,»If'<~»» Mf

$9/»1/51£6 Acwcy ul.¢» 11»¢ aj;r¢wvl¢d hobb€/`Y W"$ 5‘!/’?"5¢"/// 7"’/’""9/?/“{6

vae D¢pv¢M/M Lr¢\¥gt» J`nc A//$>lm¢¢ 1"\5 ‘;7""4¢{,9€ ~'5/‘“"‘?" "";/5"" "“‘{9¢’
D“M mmc on Mya#¢,.,,,,/J ;A 4// ,¢o,,~ r,,,¢CS ,z'/\q'r< /!>ee»m A~/*/A¢
g JW/ ¢-.W»»+ ,"n Au»)w@.¢ and 746 ,~,z“,,z¢ .»,».¢M~L in /:J,~,¢ v/»* £"">”4"~»’
w/.¢n Tl\c APp//‘c¢m+ 130 A»¢`d ¢ ed 303 ;#) 7/./\5 r¢!)’e .7'\»¢$*'¢€°€ $%€uw¢_r
}l¢//d /Ac¢,»/~ §¢L‘mv/ara/ itc carr/`c;»~ adhch /`¢y“""*'-f¢=¢/p/`°G°¢/c»¢r`a//_~/
l J€Fu.v\")#€o/ habe'¢¢! Ap/o//z¢,h/, }¢¢ 5/.¢»,) /A,wL 4 rom,¢'/"¢Z~¢¢/‘o>w,/
V»`@/¢»an lms //~vA“l>/y re so»-/;,p/,`n //.¢> zym w'r%)'¢’” 010 ¢9'1€

who 115 alc’}- Ma/ly ,',my¢(“}_ ,`“*/‘¢,,\ fA,m 7/,¢ m¢a/\e 5'/~/~/“/\;¥4)' Shwy¢r‘
5';“"‘ "{“"@{;'W€f`n.$ M}.Sca-m;e .¢>F :>"usJ-,`ce )`n;M,/`)‘/ ¢/A”? 716
AF/>/)`mné who Aa.< ban 5'!',~1¢,\(,,,/ ,¢¢ Dr»»JA /`¢u`.$ 85 4 c'/a/'m ¢v!~`
“c"`“¢"| }r\rwcmce +v avon/1a prarn/M/‘¢¢/ b“/` 7‘" (‘”l$/q¢/?/"’¢"}`/,"”’)
dp""`¢";‘l$ ¢PP ron$¥~)`¥~w}»/`vr\al c'/a/`mg .Z`*\ /A)"s /'.n $4“/1/~ f”-¢€ar"
/\“'W// AP/Q//`r)m¢ ,"5 fAvw/`,Y a.£/-Jr>¢¢'w»/ :Anocéncf W;//’ '4);'7
jAvW/‘ni ap us ,1“, ,,,Ay/,¢ ,,,,,U Mh,,L/e ¢p .$/mw,>,l !¢1/'//1»/~ 0/¢»¢<' ra)'Ac)

Ms,c¢o,. /y § 32/ r/W'>¢ zph://"M¢/ /“‘M'”“/M"' ’¢’/'h¢//f< 5/'"~¢¢

}yLM/.CA 153 2(_¢¢3 W/`e,,\ A/,/,/,<(,M/, Mc/m¢¢/// /Ja/‘rAMr// 7,(/‘.',?¢>/76»°/~0/»
vae prpo,-;, S'\ 7Ac €X.ll~»wrol/`na/\/ 6’45€'/' ¢vA;/g 4!- 776 jame,

 

‘fl’m€ ¢hfuvr\lr\? 77\»¢+ re lick would be €x)l€hz£#¢/ >¢¢o .SA¢¢M 7Aofe ¢»y)»v ¢¢»e
7`)~“»1;/¢[¢5 ervv"V, ~/'l-e re w‘l- /MS§/’ec)`)¢ fca/ly 4/)/)7/¢‘¢/ 7/¢' €Xc¢;w¢ f.,.q >1¢_-,

fha Ap/g/;`c¢m/l~ 15 )nne¢ence in carrier SM/,m ¢m@( /)-“/m“,m ,,/5¢> exp,\¢ssc,qp
7)`€54¢,,,@[¢,.¢[ pp P)\oaf; 7/\»1+ 511 v»l¢/ ?avc»h fons;daN/_,`mq a/:` 5¢¢,,-/»,

61‘~`>»6, m Apy//éw mw s/.M 7,,,,¢ me C¢»,J,L;¢“+:vm/ €,,W\
/~¢SMN¢¢/ ,`r\ q ¢,,W;¢~/_;W, me nw ¢./A¢, /`_s adaa/ly )"rmoc@n} wA 704
35 4 "`W‘€ clrcum¢slum-¢, A},/p//rm,,l. does .5Aow 7/~¢1% /')o)¢ 011/7 /‘s,/s 77\‘1/- V”¢/€~fé /f`¢ A///n and.dl/ ¢’»<'/Ac §`Mq¢j/S
a/w{ all mé` 7%€ J¢)L»/'v"/\f’y$ A'"\°’W/"\;/y hn.¢//"/l lend-lana /ly l~’/"/¢\€/¢/

7Ar5¢ ¢M»+ /‘¢C¢~/$ ws+so AP/O/,fnm; wM/¢/ /w;¢ beal/g ,l@ md

T/~zm in A?; /£7¢¢//0/"€¢¢’@4}‘)? div /\erw‘s‘g /\/5 cunl/F“¢~l~/`@»q,. Th/'S
';'-Msj’w"r~v\cy adm/1312 F/~PM 746 /3"/”¢’ f‘?f@ /V”' 3‘/5?""7°'2'/35’5’”@
on M-¢/'» /$Da we wA/¢A f.S 74¢ ¢/¢¢ /¢' A/°/”/"&"/'/D“”/'W¢/ 7/~¢ "‘We
pmm /,¢.,m¢ pf/,,/_q + 7¢¢ zeme rjme 7/»# /A¢ /“’M¢’”y */4>"

occurring / See A/’/’#’/rw §xl'v"b)’#.» ;/z /-//‘~s // ¢‘ 9 “’""’L O"` //"‘b""“~‘ ¢¢ow¢\<

¢9_5`

6 o/\{céa.y of 00 ¢n§é " /A¢o‘ h//zf rn m/,.,¢h /$/.Qvo.; 7/»»+ wz.r pa 7/¢ »€¢c@»¢//”n c~r>w~/
MM,W¢/ V‘, {,,.,,~,'¢»,. lee 5» c>l' .aé:>’?e¢ széVf/¢¢’»¢»S ,4/,//7 45 Cm‘¢;>l“,¢,;,a/

V,'@_/“,Lf.ww M¢e ucc ume¢>/, ¢¢.S ,€Ajfk/ 1/.£`/ X_’z"z/ q,w/,:,¢§
,¢,»W/ c.¢m,rw¢’/ C/¢¢a.£e div 619/325 1029 /¢¢)/e¢/l
w_>s'rzw¢ Avgw»z:'r¢o/. ":t/~/ 7/»‘_¢ resc,

D we P v vc.¢>zs
19 R vll.t£zz~rz~m o ¢> m/w/)»a re eeg

015<: §/7%
L¢/a/.§wv€h/ 066&4/34 r.z~o/v Mpe'le pF/z/.gLr»/ @/.* P££B‘¢*Py
T_L' " dec lu»é C dr`C €/>¢/`¢`7; V€/"(F/ ¢W‘-SP‘)‘€) under/gem 4/»¢7&£’
pt,.§.u,`y 7¢¢`+ 7£¢ Bo»¢y.v.¥»? ?§ 7~/‘¢4¢ and c@r/\e¢/~»

¢>/\¢:M?‘Eo an 0€<'€”13@»<> /.? //67,"2@/$

5,¢,,4.,“¢.£¢ MMM¢¢A¢___

pma se ¢)`»l-W,L/ //.¢)/,w, wm////~;)/¢bm ~