Court Opinion

ID: 6947373
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-24 01:27:12.600163+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:07:57.733414
License: Public Domain

Opinion by Treat, C. J.: The record discloses this state of case. The declaration was on a promissory note. The defendant filed six pleas, on five of which issues of fact were formed. There was a demurrer and joinder in demurrer to a replication to the other plea. The issues of fact were then submitted to a jury, and the trial resulted in a verdict and judgment for the plaintiffs. It does not appear that any disposition was ever made of the demurrer. On this showing of the record, the judgment cannot be sustained. The questions of law arising on the demurrer should have been decided before proceeding to a trial of the issues of fact. This principle has been settled by numerous decisions of this Court. Nye vs. Wright, 2 Scammon, 222; Bradshaw vs. Hoblett, 4 ibid, 53; Steelman vs. Watson, 5 Gilman, 249. There is nothing on the face of the record to authorize the conclusion that the defendant abandoned his plea, or waived his right to a decision of the demurrer. Let the judgment of the Circuit Court be reversed, with costs, and the cause remanded for further proceedings. Judgment reversed.