Court Opinion

ID: 4053812
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 04:22:07.809848+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:46.934799
License: Public Domain

rla_;_`UlN 0 ( v H'qgor 0'2
15`1' COURT OF APPEALS l
l _ ,21,111<1 61

HOUSTON. TEXAS

APR l 2015

CH HH|STOPHEF| A. PFUNE

101/1111 1111@1119111;15111

 

322 721§

 

 

 

 

01\\ `2'243 C€D%Oh 1 0132< § 6 ` 1__

 

 

`C@_.`)“LOY__\ 1b

61an 1111/121913111110 _O€MYL\LOC

 

 

0 2:1:110 _111_161>1 812 363 1101“'06 606
12003-1-@1 92 ~211:1;1

163“1611;1 666111061w 111
199616\/6 11650©1 1061<601 U§DT 3 1096

      
    

f

ZY\

 

 

1 01)1 05 13017’1101`1 16 §1066 1506 11 1116/1510

 

 

 

d

_ _ _ 000
______3_11;

1-_2:1 2_ A}(\$

___§M§>_C§

1100

001/d 1< 150 1111 10 153 ;) 3 D\ GT“O©@J€)_Y_>ZOL
1535 1251 01 (b“[

11;;10 §§ 12_1`60_1_6 10 1100

1510 11151~1111@111 <_)_1‘ 1111 1111110@:13011112;:11@2@1:1

6 1191’1`_1_1_1'>\1111 1001 01 1110161`1‘31 1291*1311

15190_31_1‘_11601 0162~61`(; 1 115 ~112> 1101=1161` '115

 

 

 

jr "VYY

6511/1113 33 01’111 Chof§€c)\ 121/1:\:_`1__ ':QL§O

 

 

1`1>110151§§ "1103 WQY\\/ 31&90 ""`

 

_11@1525

10 1_-_1'_1>_£> 6 §~5“ 151
1) 1<1’501»J 011/10 100112; 61/1`1:1€11;6 05~1111?%

 

312 ;{
U\

 

0111 111/53 1934 315ch 1333(`1515 3109 1/1`,76,+1015

 

13 11
30

1516`+ 30 53(5+9 3103 jj 1310/115

 

1" Dl`/))`H/)Q

 

 

2/6,@[5€

1011 3 121111 §@>9)<11115 1101 1111/ "§¢>IQQQ.QWA

 

5006°?251/ 1/\11“2*|/1 01159150

1\/ "2/119’,1501315_ 639 05/1531911;3_

 

001/\!1”`1
319-1001

 

111 01 §11111:)16 500€91\/231;1 :1:<;010 31111'11
1101"0`6:> 15 T 201/111 §§111 10161\`91€>19

 

 

1119 30 7051/5 1006050§ 111 501an

 

1112 _,
Q\Q` 10 111167 ”

1113 1156:<0 1110 1103€11")611~1~22 35 001 1101 1

 

116 15011”5 5€?00®_@]”_@1@1 f

1 01`2>011“<:>1111 13913011 0111` 11 6011@1/ mo
11'1~011`1§/ 3 6151'\ 1103 60161/ 111/512 56)"1115
59 11191<=11»\ 1541 ;1 1901/1013 1510 `1`11111111.119
§1§§@ 1001 ‘1 11192>___1 1 1 0
91 114 3011/133 0109: 111/111-’0\<8 1100+11<5901_?

 

    

  

 

 

 

1/`1;§ F®d€ me il C)._Jm Y\O\` 631/1213 /\1\(` ;51/`1‘1

 

'\

811600;/ ¥Ocjjh 01@0 6 §06 11@%16>/ 01_/ m l

11 Cj/C/Q-L _ 16 8 _ 1128(1?
WK§§O®+T__U 08 8161\8801_;_>011 0160:101

  

      
    

  
  
 

/`

  

 

1
. 1111
186
81

-/@51~1>1//‘[10>8 ci '0~1j111 :0)_10[:\880

 

 

 

 

 

 

__ 08- ry_
1.:11,___ _ _ :_6_1_.`1‘_6_:10 61 111516;~,1§/1115'1
__8€_“55>_;1161'01`_1`1'+;/6 808 1011 6 1106 000qu mg
___ ®QMQ §0§ 1819§:111£8090{`101(0 1_1jj)/_ _j808 300801)8
__@1§:81"0018__ _/1§8_ 01’3€_ `0000101
9010111~188 1118: fcz% 000 _11001~\;100 00`
11000 915 011:0111’10+0 000§6000 81051911@;
__001&0'11001:01~.j 81196`1'? 16 116j1 001/0)116
@10>€‘0£10660©0 QWV 01 `1`€:_011_01_0 91

   

j1i_ 81ij §§%jl’@m 010111"0§" 01 "j

61010100 060/m 000/1 1220 6

_ :1_10018 91 81\011 1Q:1601§~1 0&00015 001/fn
_______":`561 19\<8;1*111/10§: 1(7©811

118__:11 1_/10_01§15111>'61868 081 1150/1551@/n 1790
80001:1£1011:1011<80 C@€€ 010/1000 ii

98 008/815 30181/5_0001611"1/0‘50021 \__1165 061

_ 660 _j_jQ 1161[»¢ §§ch 1151/__ 10 ;1;_1511§1

1 5138 1061_1211/_WL 80 808 091 WQDj: 1050@1 111/18aL

" 501 j1'5311j_jL 5 >/16011“3 _0 01018 1151160

    
 

 

 

 

 

 

_10 ’ 611”_/`0080_0 01 58§§_`@1< 801_1~1j 1 110

_@61_@,.0@1c65_ 65 ;1:1 01161©11§1)2 1191>@1:6_51_ 051:111111“011
061_\6§10010 01_1'1 151/586 1650011~61@@ jcrc»_>m 011 111/1130
OF _y§_o;{):§© 018 QS?? \/8018_0 Tfj 138)3019 01088 6
5000_~1 )/0jj ij 601/11 1001 1560 01 6001~00_ 1015 »-,
100 001/191°16061`1} 1556 C/068'10 813 __

1918 j86981§§ if 001jj10@ 8 1

©1'%81_`<3_:110¢0

 

 

8.8@83:®`0`1“ QLM ij\/ C>f1\1r11 01

3

010 011 010 \' 111 1100 5+M105 +5)<05 011_1+11;
351/14511105€ 10 §§ 1250€0 :L_OC<£_U 11_10:1;, _1A11011§_10__
__15 \5:5711»100 10015055_ 050l V100_550
`_1;1115_1_5:%_ 0:5§1¢_07“ 6105< 137 011@11 0€1`115
1115 01/100:5 90 1011 000 5@@:1_ 711/1112 515 2
§§55\‘ 370©5:1:1§01/5 0550 10509 1_/\11~1.12)/1 1175

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_ 1 05 1555
l@(jm__ 41501<1_>0__(?6 0_1170 559 _0§+>
_ Q1,@01<“‘W 710;17_7§:1;150 015 109101_11_<`5(` _1_‘1';_1*5¢

 

 

`_M_©USL ` 503@1711@115£155:\&10_“3;@;1§:
l‘\/’Q§pi.@: _€_1)_0§_` _;21@5:11__£/0 _ 1_0 7|_'@
CQDI/_j_:l"j*' n 1 10_§:_;¥%0 hL/YJ ~1_71>__\/ 00£5' 05
l_ _§/ QQ_ §)Q_\? t{/\/_ 51 _______
lMMWL 1`1<:5 11»1@1§11739§ 1/1§ -1@ §

 

 

 

 

_ ____7_; 0 1000 _1_505'5 05 0(_`@00501"_

____ 5 jj_%:)_©$lm _[lj_`é(;?f'; _.__`_‘_ :@ f§/l©\_`l'_ Xéleif’ll _@€\ 1102

__ _ __51/155_ 150 __01'“ '111511)017 05000;|§{£
_/ )

 

 

 

111 001 _ 05011155_05 502 01
____S __'§/"5_:\:_<1(;1:€\/1/001 01001'715_1` C`_?’1c:117£51 01§551;¢;;
100 __V§:I§__ 117 Uz)@ `_£'Y\€/ _010”1“()0011\13 :V_' Uf 05’£" 101
1071-1005 0 017\13;\<_ 93\§`000-1“1071 05

f 1,1,121_1°_1_@1501_Q;>v 05 §ng 060\%§;7?0~11§13;\;_@\ <011?1)§)
_ _ C() 6) \
<_‘z»€<:'j)mfl _41_1:§5__ 0@:1710® 03 ;1_ 1`50?03_>:“ ¢0_0_1'_:1:0_50__

__1_ 041/510 -1-_11{) 71£001/_017_
_CQCT@\/QL 5147(1§1§_®§`90: Yh/>Y 1 SF@V 001 11;0\/ _
_ 500/51 005 1015001€ 5501;151/ §§ 117_15 _\/_1111)»1
501_“_1_1;01__ :1115; 0 105 5010 550_15 -1100:1;113_0_1
11/§\©1_1_<_11§5_ OD 551'1>\_11§£: 0:"103:53_
_ i. 05 501 00‘1”1151 _____ ~1:11_11@10 _:1;_0W
__0_©;1_11_ 5010 141/1011 00_10155@011 __1/1101/1 11
_01@_1'10@51:10510:7 000100 7101 ‘1“ 131/11 1711/1510
_ 1/\1500;10 1/1/1015171 113 10151@/11710 00§1/1`0511470§1:`1`0;

 

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_1_ , '661>:63 YM_ 961 561161/16& 10 66616116

93 B_cl§§@¢h
QY_K¢QVZQQQW 1613 960 1 01__€1/0~1914/001~ 109 62
UCC§(__U_ _b_@fk:: 611_ CQ\19_ _
9910_:).€1’ 6`€§_91@_\/9€~_©6 363 1959§ Q‘r\\/ 61617039
91/…1:1<:193 0 1131 60061;_\/9 1/_1131093 36§)3 11
.. W€q“1019: 010 100$& 01100)\’\% 55561)5©919001
__ __15`11\_11 §(919g 63 6691_ 6163 0 6331©10 600
§§me _ _6,01 601/10 LCYU" 169 _ ‘ '__
___©1363 1;`\/0196613 §0_00_@§ _L;h®_ _$:<§Q_ ' ‘3_€@6
_ ` 0. ¢'l_ ‘ O\_DQIJQ.L` Q mg
1056 _‘_1<_311:_ 1/6/;>1`911/\\/ 06 …)f/)n 60@6 000 1
` _1.03~4»1_60\)6_61’_);)36§11>1_\<@5_ 015 _01
1113;1:9111.6 CB _1’1;`."16 1561 0_\\‘\ _
11 ' :1_'91161_\0 5091/\/10_0,;1300:011 111/306
91/:06._:15__.1601)0 6 31016 §§ :16213 b :09§§1011@_ 0331<1
O`l/§`i@_cg_\ §____ '%(___ C$_I__LQ\RTOI_WT_\\ l
1 103\0\,_,110_ 001601”0\ __%5109

’::1911)1€361`3+3'1 _1\__ 0 1 00\11009 91_6©6§6 1331_6
601/900 .-.-..100@: \§1/1>163~6 3301 1 1<1
1 001/__ 10 5@<1`1/61 76303/>1336____ _

__ 1606011/\)111001001;_1/16 050
1 001010 1b 3013 1313 5001§110.@

___00_0©1€€_110§\/
1/1/.0’)\1~ \_/60 160616 1131 106-01~.113 303 __1616091060'1
9__`:/1>649 11~_@_\)6 1 6_1'9\;?_. 0163%6 91 , '1"*1:10 1506

 

 

   

     
 
 

 

 

 
  

 

 

 

  

 

 

 

  

l 135110@1 11001_1/_1@1_1>_1_1$_\_01) \/1)1_\1 _

Q)\\/@ _\9»;-__101910?1001@ :1;9<§©160_1 W<)m‘_+<) 6 710 ~00_09§_

_§61%©10 16100960@ _(`&>1'_‘1”10 __16_16

l C<>mm 011/1011060 QY`_IY` _'--“. 16 ___ ¢_» x

‘M~v 600/1- 660 631/117f ' ' ;,166_,'_
001 01/\)_19<;06 /131/13€&£11/\/ 16 1110

___ng 06 %01_€ 76€ 1[ 0_1€303~111360\
w m6616:1m0110100|9_ _10101;_\1_1116

 

 

5

p

§”\\6_1€§>1\ 90111\. 615\1`1\601\1\5€ 1111 1`:53\/ down 11me 1§(11§31;
_Q\(` 11/§11}9\%60 ®(` ©__\_ 15___0_@3;
m|OCXQCIX1N :IL V\O\/@ IQOWBQ;;[/&Q/Y\ \/TWW‘?“YDH-
U_W’\W€S;f©y 133/12 Y|_/_\@;r_ 11`5>_011/\ 3 CP®zv l

_ _&23(` __ 61 m
@;/ 0315111 __:_1: 09160\;\§/ _ '

____4,3§15§_@¢_3¥16/_@01_1_(\_:1@§3’ 8(/3@1'_ M
»-~ 631/53511511_\1:311_§3213)_ 116 111/1333

_. 1___1:11513366 606 6136 m mm

_66___`1:._ 3663 1>11/`11§ 356__15:111&167L

___1_566_1:A n§@§»@@ 636 6 __Q U%f`©n _Uj;S il :V)O\ 612_§>6_3&)’11111~1£
1151

 

 

 

 

 

  
  
  

 
  
 

 

%WW 6'1);15<;13@ 660/112633166 )/CQ (83 m&mm

___13 131_~@1; 33
§1>1)\»/6\1\~1 Q1or31 1516 171/1153

 

 

  
    

é__% 1151 36 43 n____ _
QW1§O _lpc@!:]£11~1111;<3 gm :1 16 1135 616 915/161/\15116

__ __151:_ 515631/\ 1166 1511 666 13

511/ 1~/1»6-1.8161/ 1111-z 566_
»__1;_7@11151/_\@_;1:_ w 11 355 11 1/21§_
;>/_6:315:16_61515 91611%6/__6501
_ ___ ~€16&§©(\51 lA)QQ 3:;;
____3391\151 666_ 617 1/\/31\1\ 61 001/6 __

 

 

 

 

 

 

"`1

1365 J1/5‘C 1313va 1636(6%6©1§6§
_ O ©\ fm 111/1116
_ §§ CN/\ m _ 13@(: _1§)6\/5@/`5{:
161_'-51_5`1 5665_1/16€_611_1:66+ 666165 15 _6265
66;1“6@~1:166€:1: 126 11611_6161/#1#1:65<6§?_7656 _1_ __
_ :_6:661__6 13§66666 _?\1_6_1_611.._;1 666 11 6166+l _:6
__1:. QQQ QQLA_O ©(“ @M 166 1101_ @`0\0?%1'0 5£___111<@
6._13/16/_6_61_1111_16__€6»65 666< 6 __
1 ___.__ <16151111 T Vr>\\j_@__W __t;>©\§g _'1 111/1511
__0166_1/11 611`1§1 116 115/566 6 1661 1111651__

    

  
  
  
 
   
    

  
 

    
      

6\111 5+66)_ 6(` 1566|<“1‘1/) 6611 1”161`
___ _ - __ _7_ __ ____ _ ____ _____
_ f »11_12;5.:_13€6§®€§(§6 6 11 6@1511@520 51

* 6 16_@1661166"6@6'>” * 611
__1* 61166?;§ ;1_ _161/ 666~1_ 1565 15121661561616
__ _, j 666/26 _;1;_`_ 106051' 656;>1111 131/661 61611
_51666___6; 111/6561161661-666 :6_ _111_:_ ¢ 66615
_ __ __16;0_6_ "‘"`55"11_‘_':`

    

 

       

`M@Q_US® 1_)1;3L. 1032

' _ _;/6@/ 116 6661 9656666,1~ w%_ccv§:§:§fg §§
x 1*%61.61\:£1;36©©§ ©\M F1:1E1< 111/1661)65
66661165661 666 6._ . W5__€C6 566 5

310 1516:1:3»166_61<1/5 1051 {`666 615 _
__ 111/1616_1, 6165 _11!615_1:6_16%1%1 "

  

 

 

7

_F`

 

 

 

404/534

4

 

4- ":74;`©4/443 DW mgm 4:©(` 0444 44334747 404/2

 

___4/44¥

:fgqa**g!:©

3/4424/\;47
__Q34473_
ggo_o_c;&§

23 7444`044943
43 _34740

222/1323 :QB_

__ {/4/1/4 )C{/\W md 1414@@
333 3 37quL i, 347 34 Om
672-07 722ng 3®§3_334 443<:334<3_
_Q£§:\/i@@lwf333_

 

332§_3

 

4§_(;>3_ 2 CI@QB:S§LC/ir

 

823

_ __CU4€;4 4424`_3<§@
:'_`£$7?€73' §@7€77 433?33

_@\éa) 4`7"
243/722

34
Og

 

MMQ_

43347 mgm_ _343`44 424;;44 413 4_
4/7_44:_4§/__4§44©4’47:44 §§ 0444_744%?744;44©`4:2>§®4;@;

4034244344:2%@® :

,_}:

433 443`__ 972/447 7

__ __ _ 04 _ __ _g

3 §QMFY@F&QE;§L_MFMW
_r___

324_47
4722_~4:33 ,

MQ __
344 _Q__Y\>~L

 

U§{r

 

     
   

   
   

 

~?3`4__®;4;4
,4 [_4721%.

§§ Q\/VL

m 54(3)444\/

8

',mmrr‘r: ©4\% 43347‘2, 742 4<4333J \/4)4/44344/4\274

 

44444:~4;4:4
_4/43_ 3
k m
442/477

333

 

 

 
 

 

\ {"](¢

`('. `l)

      

004/4334 4;44334 04`©4 _494>\/€©1©377%47 //4734)
2793~4,~_77 4_3') T. 744/347 4/4/3,3434~ 234 449 :4: 343
34542;@44'§§ mE[J;jM/E m14194`4'60(4 4/4/4\/4, 04@§74€©% HQ
WQ, 4’4/4©44/‘ U\/r)m ¥4~47 747©
br 843223_4“74_4 4:@47_247 3 0444 33
d47434§4 04< F_74_77O 04 37444_ 94 humf\é§
474227 24442434 SOWQQQ_WW
MI 43 MQHW)CQ/g<é\, 333me
M/ CD_QC:V MC/_§Qt
\{`7£7 0 ( 4`4…42 D’C)S:t_ ____
4/4:»@4< 9932344,74‘04\ 803 CQ m_.. ____
g 4!"' ¢\ _04___.¢4__ UO\ Jm,
!/|], ;q '\T.L ¢.. _."""" m"'~`"

 

%

q

 

:|1\ _7> 1101 1 not 44
- §© __4:7/1/8@_1£8_0 ) w @\O“fj@@ MW\MCQ;§

4734 100 8 _Q\LO\_\Q __O\ L __ 4
11 1511/1 1§7§1_&@ §§1?1,©\1@ 11 1511 11?1@_11111

 

 

18001“1{/83_ ‘501' &lr\ 181:`&1>4

 

 

 

 

   

w _CcL/1§11

__ 1£&§1

 
  
   

%QOW 8013/ig 1_`11)817

C)/xlrw 1)/5©1:11_3 1110/1 1

 
 

411/1801 1 08§1<>1;1/_18

 

3 )/Y\C/ §Oi/VVHC>/@[:S_O 5117:£1>8%{\ 10 7 01(_`
67/_\/_@610_ _'.. 4____

 

l __ 1
_@38_£\;84)0_”1§8 CQ<___;ry/)W T 7/18’017§ 7/8_ 7:©4
118th O\_(`881i@\181` 011 wrm“_ )?\Cicc\ry _

980_£_`145110114>11“8 07§
§/0147’)/\8 011/15

gil©_ 1<_h1ry Q.:_ 11184701@®8:11/§8: 1
7`§ ry87) 701 041/_8_51308111_/1_001:

_4_1/7@1474! 7 14qu 1`¢>1\_ _OL/ 01\
__l\__,___§’_ _ 031'4740%11/_818 §§ nigro-747

__78 0011/0.__]1_>/_ O_\_SJ:_ 9

___ ___ __D@?M

    

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 

 

4 §§81`)/0 _ 888

 

 

 

_ __ 5017\ ©\ l
8038:111\111>£&101§£_1;1§}1:

d - v c
uousToN coMMuNsTv ¢oLLEGE
Schoo| of Continuing Education

Certificate of
Comp|etion

Presented to

F)a'vicf]ames Chapmom

for Satisfactory Completion of

T'rincipa[§ ofAccounting I
.ACNT 1025

AWarded on 80 Contact Hours 8.0 CEU’s

Jflugu$t 7, 2014

Mary S. pa glen .D. Kathy Hou:€l

Chance!!or D:`rector
Housron Communr`ry Coh'ege Schocn' of Conrr`nu:`ng Education

 

... ucc

HOUSTON COMMUH!TY COLLEGE

Schoo| of Cnntinuing Education

Certificate of
Completion

Presented to

Davic{jame$ Cha,]omcm

for Satisfactory Completion of
fBuSine$$ Ma,tli
330 j-`T 1 021

60 Contact Hours 6.0 CEU’
Awarded on 3

ftl-me 30, 2014

1 4 1/11411 41

Marv S .L§par\\gler, écl D. Kathy Hou
Chance!for D:`recror
Housron Commum`ry Coh'ege Schc)cl of Conr!nu:`ng Eo'ucanon

 

 

‘

_~.r=_.==~_.:_4._4.=__4.=:.=4.._=4.=_.=____4==_==3.. mm.w_w_uNNOn_h.p.. rH.Z m.©H QZ…

m@@vv @9®4 4,§,@ \4@41
HMW\ 141@~12 H2.4./14 4@\,~4, HOW_ A€m >mz§: 14_,.111_.@€ n4m4_.4 H.#.vVPH4

OQWT§D$I 441