Court Opinion

ID: 4071902
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 02:26:19.097715+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:34:30.886314
License: Public Domain

Tra.c“\ C§\l\o¢,c) U\\<\:<\'
zoclo ?¢N\ %§HQ

C>[/X<¢\;.Q,( \H‘¥\(\\ 90 \§
Q€`. F"\WTC@&L}<>N\¥€§ 106,.:<\¢, zb J j:` <:m\ wd¥ be N\drz~m£z:'/ 0\/
a§v\se& l<<> he W\ m~\\>\¢¥t Cow\?\\onoe wJH\ o\/U ¢M(+
c\x\% h‘\ Q ‘\'MQ\`( QV~S\A?O\{\¢ T\f``311.<>¥6¢» 360 DQ WG~MS

A@§--®XM \'+'. TM¥ Q; }>W
66 1 63 w <v`\, CGM<\/ 0£ A'W€A§ »AUSLN\ /T§¥Aé
C`C\,U\%C J\S'C» 1 @\ k\C\ll>?'o'lOO’( ~\'\'T'A\ Ca<,d~('

wc"(p(€,- CI(¢Q~~O‘E LOS»O[MQ'OI
"\`P\W \Q<»\\(§\W\) `*\L\zum»k 3 /Ll§*‘\ m\@¢.>¢\ Dr?,+n.\&
361 . L\/ 6
'2:03® ;:,\ >>`;… N&Co‘_’sc\oo\~€.$ CO wr\""{
\~§¢:H\crv~§i>\ 2 `S\NX°) C

Rea.mw\c~:\'¥\<\‘\b ’1`1’165' )
U\)vo 611 \AP?\?CO~(I{' Qaw\p\)gl\,\ CO\Q, ll:

9

§
> \. V\ §
‘ SL\\. ‘P V~\»\o.¢, o$r J\?M\\e\§re \>roa.ubu~ve 7?

 

w i&/L(Zzo@cp,
l»c> SJW\I}& <»\\} Prew\<¥ \¢\Fs W¥€OA §e~ Q€;.\\\Qmmj I',\
, accord nce §v© `\'Uéu> D\uv\€'> o§' A?P€LLH*TE &oc€/DMZ/E [TR.

A?B p\v~\& 70(;\ lco z\l\am W&_ gol\ow`u\§} j

I . .
_5\&< `\s A§c,§~v\o\<\

`Y\\L c,<:w\lr\c\\ ch'é`r @§ AQYMY§ ) 66\4 5 P¢m\L€) \M§
~Y\\Q `3\»<:4§\6@¥¢¢\\ com ML \Q%=~X N\o\l¢l~LFJ Fc\ ~H\o adm/c

€¥\\\Q§ ms& MO.(S) Y\>J"<\\MMFQ \ b`l owiva OYS\UF ~@r?)w\

(\)

 

\‘\\)\¢\'63 Cc>\>.r'¥ j v eg\rv\w¢;e& A/\J\RS C.w.<,<: 4a ‘H¢»a. &/vv`ml CUMGL
615 o~c<` »:S\)»\`\ \{?&\20|§.

I\`_.
§§$560<‘1 ag COL%<_

AQ‘?\MQX\§/\€X\\&\reco \\r\¥o 06 P\Ra )Bv»fja~l\r\ ap AGFM/M>L€j
V\¢\>\»QH z for SO »leus z d\ <‘v\.»& lLlSH` jmld¢l`c~{ D¢§H¢U{~o‘("
Na£o°>c\@o\~@$ COM\\"\ cu'\§\ `/\GL$ \>£€)c\ ¢\r\ \Hr\a CW>\(@U[“(' 0’(6\  émc€,)‘ /A/\axo\v\ 3d1 3607. AFP/¢`Ccm'?',w¢&$
Q,<\¥UCX P<\Xe> TBC`S esch `]v\v\£, 900`7.

AQ‘?\`Q.Mcev\ 200§/ 510/5, EQO}\ 5%£;€-»
` ‘M\.Cv\§< l\'\\()‘T M-\Q\N\P\~£(& 4b S\A_F?\evv\evaf o;/§

~y\»\‘c cow\§x\`¥ \>C, ?6€.9<>/6\\*€§ 1\¢\ ‘\“\r~<’ O‘F\\ij\\r\aj //.O’l Q,PPA`C@¢M

\>QCQ»\QQ §§ m\maéono~)>\€ AQ/\O“‘f OL\’\J l\\`r€ ar-cfs¢-b/€ £’/Ft`c'¥$

Cc)<\€\)`.\.&€_a \>`\ YF\\L ‘\"‘(\\Q/\ Cc)w({' POSL~£U"\U¢`C/QL¢SY\/-

 

\

`_I§§v\e§ 1

\ \ 1

)A~\e cou»(§r &€> %‘\l\€ SFGV\NlS Fr\ §\~PPO(+`O~£
\.\‘6 w\z>§w<\ gov rC\\mN\S gov 6`\’¥/\¢ @)daw§/\j §

\.\ k?‘?\tcQo\’~év{. (33 f

 

m v n \66 mEb (CM\~‘('J)

35 A'PQ\\LCG-'&\)M 6`(\0\~\& \\>‘€ allow-ho ovf\z) °J\"a¢(\~x/Qd? 61
\r'v-~L `e,\;z§mc\¥\m+ \/\QM¥<\S \><»,X<>r~e \/\55 \'v.`q/` md 4-0
£ac§¢ ;Md\as m co<\¢\w§:w\ 031 law m 6€3®@@& (ld m

. , \\
\\ \\<<1\6{§<‘7\\0\€ Q)K`VO(§ .'

">§) _Y\\r O~(\\\\ \V\ec»- reavw€e!v»\/\§ a }(“\/e. e/u {Ol@n+¢`¢ur\/
\\U>x`<<\°§ `\"c\ 6605¢=~<§1§ &<> <>~1)\<:\6`€5% `\H»€. l\l`r`€\re_.\f`s`,!){€ €(T`df§
Ca,»>~¢,&& `\>\R "W\€ 3\'\"o\\\ Cowf<¥ ‘H~<~Sc (`0-\& JF`M”\"' ~l/¢»€ ¢l%>/`

`\cwn¥ va\\@\< MNXL( A{'&\ (\607~ TQX¢L/> 02@1€4 d-Q/?We//-
age ?roCeA\L\'€ `1<§\\ (C)GX@)(‘C\ w(\¢) (`u\( 7§,;2 QQW\M\J)

§(\ ~’<\\& \<\\\%<%\'5 0§/ 1`\\&§~`¥61~€.

53 L¥w\r\
Q§£QQ\-»\)e YQYM%Q»(\\¢~¥»\<>(\ m v€‘b»\€¢jxe P‘\Q QGM{-d 411 @¢PPOW
\/\LN\ Co\,\\\\<,%\ 065< »¥\NL \§\)g QNCSLQ¥\¥C<>~.<~( `,\€a< N\§`y.

 

IV_.
Ce€¥;§:¢@le 036 SQW\?Q
AW\;Q_QX\\“¢ C,Q;{\~`L;`\Q%' M\¢&w ?C,\r\a\k`f 0§6 ?Q\§l\>~wt YH\C¥
\c\€ \\45 u§v`\\`©,€§ m U\Y\l§(€,$ SXKLQS 90th S€/(u&€§
410 \{\M §\%\§\)~lv&cb \I\CS W\/V£\\c)\/\ Q¢\/ FQ[/~€O'\'?V\? =/~v Wl/¢-€

Cvfm;m%\ de(§~ opv MPf®£§ ) C/[,UK 0§» CMWL /H)Q( A C@c>l¥@\ 33¢»65¢:<»(\, AMSW ,"/‘)< 727/l ,

(z)

 

Q\Q§?Qckv;-\\`\ 9\1€€€6$§€<9 QM Su\>w\[l-L€_cé/ !>~f N\<)
\\`0\€,“\ ?\OO‘\ Cj\ …7$07\) [LI‘ZJ(&KJ~L{ l 6\‘\ `»H/\JS (g+koJ¢V 60

GGX¢\M , 9{>\§. »
KT¢M~\ QW;\ GZ`L§§@m F/‘PBO€Q*/
6(5¥\0¢\@.~ 'Z`DCU`

 

@)