Court Opinion

ID: 9387744
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2023-04-18 20:08:05.866301+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T17:18:15.240265
License: Public Domain

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
                            EASTERN DISTRICT

BRETT ADAMS, TAMRA ADAMS, JILL        : No. 300 EAL 2022
O'DONNELL, MATTHEW O'DONNELL,         :
JASON TEPFENHARDT, JESSICA            :
TEPFENHARDT, JAMES WIEGERS, ANN       : Petition for Allowance of Appeal
MARIE WIEGERS, BRIAN BENTRIM, JEFF    : from the Order of the Superior Court
CAMPAGNA, ELIZABETH CAMPAGNA,         :
CATHERINE BENTRIM, JAMES COY AND      :
DENISE COY                            :
                                      :
                                      :
           v.                         :
                                      :
                                      :
TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, L.P.,    :
TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC.,    :
TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL         :
ARCHITECTURE I, P.A., ANDERSEN        :
WINDOWS, INC., THOMAS E. MANION T/A :
MANION CONTRACTORS AND/OR             :
THOMAS E. MANION, MICHAEL             :
ANTOLINO CONSTRUCTION, INC., RSB      :
CONSTRUCTION CO., MACK DONOHOE        :
CONTRACTORS, INC., ELK                :
CONSTRUCTION, PETR JACH T/A BRICK :
FRONTS, .L.C., EXTERIOR OPTIONS, INC. :
                                      :
                                      :
PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC.,     :
TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA, L.P. AND   :
TOLL PA GP CORP.                      :

JAMES COOKE AND TRACY COOKE              : No. 301 EAL 2022
                                         :
                                         :
            v.                           : Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                         : from the Order of the Superior Court
                                         :
TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, VI L.P.,    :
TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC.,       :
TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL            :
ARCHITECTURE I, P.A.                     :
                                         :
                                          :
            v.                            :
                                          :
                                          :
ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., NEW               :
MILLENNIUM CONTRACTING CORP.,             :
MACK DONOHOE CONTRACTORS, INC.,           :
MAR JOHN MASONRY, INC., CONNOLLY          :
STUCCO AND PLASTERING                     :
                                          :
                                          :
PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC.,         :
TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA, VI, L.P. AND   :
TOLL PA GP CORP.                          :

JAMES COY AND DENISE COY                  : No. 302 EAL 2022
                                          :
                                          :
            v.                            : Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                          : from the Order of the Superior Court
                                          :
TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, L.P.,        :
TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC.,        :
TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL             :
ARCHITECTURE I, P.A.                      :
                                          :
                                          :
            v.                            :
                                          :
                                          :
ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., MICHAEL           :
ANTOLINO CONSTRUCTION, INC., RSB          :
CONSTRUCTION, EXTERIOR OPTIONS,           :
INC D/B/A EXTERIOR WALL, INC., FRANK      :
BADOLATO, AQUARIUS SIDING                 :
                                          :
                                          :
PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC.,         :
TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA, L.P. AND       :
TOLL PA GP CORP.                          :

THOMAS DEANGELO AND CAGLAYAN              : No. 303 EAL 2022
DEANGELO                                  :
                                          :
                                          : Petition for Allowance of Appeal
            v.                            : from the Order of the Superior Court

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL
            2022, 306 EAL 2022, 307 EAL 2022 and 308 EAL 2022] - 2
                                          :
                                          :
TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, II, L.P.,    :
TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC.,        :
TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL             :
ARCHITECTURE I, P.A.                      :
                                          :
                                          :
            v.                            :
                                          :
                                          :
ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., MS                :
BUILDERS, INC., M A CARDY                 :
CONSTRUCTION, INC., DOMINIC C.            :
DEFRANGESCO, MACK DONOHOE                 :
CONTRACTORS, INC.                         :
                                          :
                                          :
PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC.,         :
TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND    :
TOLL PA GP CORP.                          :

TODD ELLIOTT AND JUDITH ELLIOTT           : No. 304 EAL 2022
                                          :
                                          :
            v.                            : Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                          : from the Order of the Superior Court
                                          :
TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, II, L.P.,    :
TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC.,        :
TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL             :
ARCHITECTURE I, P.A.                      :
                                          :
                                          :
            v.                            :
                                          :
                                          :
ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., MACK              :
DONOHOE CONTRACTORS, INC., M.A.           :
CARDY CONSTRUCTION, INC.                  :
                                          :
                                          :
PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC.,         :
TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND    :
TOLL PA GP CORP.                          :

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL
            2022, 306 EAL 2022, 307 EAL 2022 and 308 EAL 2022] - 3
BENJAMIN LACSON AND EVELYN                : No. 305 EAL 2022
LACSON                                    :
                                          :
                                          : Petition for Allowance of Appeal
            v.                            : from the Order of the Superior Court
                                          :
                                          :
TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, L.P.,        :
TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC.,        :
TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL             :
ARCHITECTURE I, P.A.                      :
                                          :
                                          :
            v.                            :
                                          :
                                          :
ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., THOMAS E.         :
MANION T/A MANION CONTRACTORS             :
AND/OR THOMAS E. MANION A/K/A             :
MANION, RSB CONSTRUCTION CO.,             :
EXTERIOR WALLS, INC., MACK                :
DONOHOE CONTRACTORS INC., ELK             :
CONSTRUCTION, INC.                        :
                                          :
                                          :
PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC.,         :
TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA, L.P. AND       :
TOLL PA GP CORP.                          :

MICHAEL MILEY AND JENNIFER MILEY          : No. 306 EAL 2022
                                          :
                                          :
            v.                            : Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                          : from the Order of the Superior Court
                                          :
TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA II, L.P.,     :
TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC.,        :
TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL             :
ARCHITECTURE I, P.A.                      :
                                          :
                                          :
            v.                            :
                                          :
                                          :
                                          :
                                          :

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL
            2022, 306 EAL 2022, 307 EAL 2022 and 308 EAL 2022] - 4
ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., NEW               :
MILLENNIUM CONTRACTORS, MACK              :
DONOHOE CONTRACTORS, INC.                 :
                                          :
                                          :
PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC.,         :
TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND
TOLL PA GP CORP.

FURRUKH MUNAWAR AND AAIYSHA               : No. 307 EAL 2022
MUNAWAR                                   :
                                          :
                                          : Petition for Allowance of Appeal
            v.                            : from the Order of the Superior Court
                                          :
                                          :
TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA II, L.P.,     :
TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC.,        :
TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL             :
ARCHITECTURE I, P.A.                      :
                                          :
                                          :
            v.                            :
                                          :
                                          :
ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., MACK-             :
DONOHOE CONTRACTORS, INC.,                :
MILLENNIUM CONTRACTING                    :
CORPORATION                               :
                                          :
                                          :
PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC.,         :
TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND    :
TOLL PA GP CORP.                          :

DANIEL PORTER AND CAROLYN                 : No. 308 EAL 2022
PORTER                                    :
                                          :
                                          : Petition for Allowance of Appeal
            v.                            : from the Order of the Superior Court
                                          :
                                          :
TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA II, L.P.,     :
TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC.,        :
TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL             :
ARCHITECTURE I, P.A.                      :

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL
            2022, 306 EAL 2022, 307 EAL 2022 and 308 EAL 2022] - 5
                                            :
                                            :
             v.                             :
                                            :
                                            :
ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., DOMINIC C.          :
DEFRANGESCO, MACK DONOHOE                   :
CONTRACTORS, INC.                           :
                                            :
                                            :
PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC.,           :
TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND      :
TOLL PA GP CORP.                            :

                                    ORDER

PER CURIAM

     AND NOW, this 18th day of April, 2023, the Petition for Allowance of Appeal is

DENIED.

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL
            2022, 306 EAL 2022, 307 EAL 2022 and 308 EAL 2022] - 6