Court Opinion

ID: 4038647
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 21:58:10.827457+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:02:45.672173
License: Public Domain

7=;3/\§<§$'~0;?

\ , `De,cw_b_u zi,zoad
cloud c¥- \1¢`\»1€\€$0.\ Appe.o.$§ o$ Tex.o$ l y
. F.O.E>ex IZ_BD‘E>

_|;49§§§\**3}& le n ’
_A“\$:$.\"\n,sza§ 781|\ 4

RECE!\./ED !!\.l
couRT oF chMmALAPPEALs

. air max mm ms 35 _,
» 1 ` .` 'JAN 02\2015

 

N\¢‘. Aco${'o..`-

 

'AberAcosia,cierk ` \ _ 4 - _- 7

 

P\Co`.s€. ¥.\\L'\"r\€*_ Aim">\},L;§QOQ s'\- . ' `

 

 

 

meqWQ/’
0 _\o\me,$ Ar¥\rjus Me€¢b>/ _
Ap{)_'\_¢`,<;¢~g&,`\bm 5a ~, '
T\>'c~.“le~/‘B€o
k\\a¢\'B.¢\)<>|\w\éKy UQ`\\:
3_%_12.§/~/\ 35¢> wah '

_' L"\u"\r\g$l'eh,'\_~e¢)_\== cmN\\MA\_ AP§>'\=_A'\_S
Aus“rm ,'T\=_)u\s

wR\‘r No.i°l_i&$_:_L____

EX PARTF_ H>.BEA$ coqu PRDL;L=.E_NNQS

JAN\E§ ARTuuR NENE,Y, . Fsao~\'rmr_ 13<\1“ Auo\c\m_
APPL\I:AMT b\s'\a\c;'r umw csc

\). BRA'I.GR\A comm ,TE)LAS

‘THF_ STATF. oF TEXAS TR\A\_ mm c_Au§F_ umwqu

 

APP\_\c_Am‘§ RESPQM§\=_ 10 S‘\ATF_`s AN§\.»F_R m APP\_\¢_P"T\D\\ Fc\z
wgn m= HABF_/-\s meals

 

To THE HoueR/\B\_F_Ju\)r,lzs 0\= SA\D cowan
comes uaw .\AME§ Amuma new Bv,'r\>a** umw 3a , ma S`€\`\e§ ¥&\`\5 cespm§e_
+<> §\e.$+¢i\e_`é Ar\swer ~\-0 App\`\cr_c\"\on ‘\`~o<‘ \r\\<"\)c 0&` \-\c»k\=_o.$ Cocp\):§.
l.
The. App\`\ccm)r \5 reque,s’rmg H-u¥ -¥\\e_"\'€_xo~s C¢.u~& 039 (`.m~\`\r\a\ kppwls w\pc§e_

JuSJr So~r\c.\'\or\s om¥o -\\-w \`_r\~\`\ncL\ `D\S¥~ric_+ A+¥ovr\e_y a¥ @F`o:z.cmo~ C.¢u-¥y,_\'exo\§
in amoc\o.r\¢e_. w`\-\\r\ Ru\e_ 57_.\\ Cl‘.\ o¥ Pne_ Te.)co.& Ru\e£> cv\`» Appe_\\o.\-@_ Pmae.do¢e..

»__-

_LL.

\v\ ¥i\`\l\§ H\e, S+c>.\'e."<> Ac\§wc-_r,H-\e, D`\s+<~`\d A+\'ovne.y a¥ Bc\o,zz>v`\a C.our\"\'v \\35
Pucpc>$ej\/ and gross\y N\`\Si+c\l'e_c\ ~\M'er`\ol paris ’\r\ lr\\e. A‘>§>'\Io.o"¥mn $m~ \,\\<"\-\
o-\: \l\ob¢¢_s burgos Subw\`\lr'\e.c\ by -\30`\5 A\)p\`\mr\lr.

[5\/ "\4'$ C\.K\S\A_Q\` ,~\‘\'\E_. S‘\'Q`Jr€. \\0.5 C>.:\'\’e~\‘>‘\'e.c\ ‘\'c: N\i&\&o.d '\"1\`\5_` \:.eu\`" by 5\‘€>:\\¥\3

+\"\cc\' '\'\'§\5 `\5 '“‘\& Ap'\>\`\€n.r\¥é 5¢>_\¢'&€\\'\\ cNFP\`\L&\"\G<\ Llr\¢\€_\“ -\-\»~\e_ above C.c\u£\@_

number. \‘\"\s `\c\ ¥or_l< \n`\s almond o`pP\`\co~jr`\on a{\¢\ -m>\- H\§ 5{=.\:@_1\3¢\,\ as

I;‘_\cQ: N\&c\ by '\'\'\L 3\'0.\'(»,.

T\‘\`\$ wo..§ an o._)c~\'e_~":v\' \:v -\\\e_ Sjrcr\~e_»\-¢> ‘>re;`\uc\`ac_e_ ¥\~\`\5 Couo\' 030105\' ~\'\-\e._
AP\>\`\¢.N\¥ by c_o.§-\-`m_cj P\`lm`m c.\,\m¢\ \`\3\(\3< us c>, Pe_s~'sm\ who kas`m 3¢\¢\<>__ \>a§\- wc>._s\-QA
15 Q_bs.:.(‘\'\;\ '\"\N\e, \:»y ¥\'\e_$`¢ilnj ex £r~`\\ro\c.~\_\:‘> w<"\'\§ w\'\e.r\ ~\\'\`1§ \'\a£\ r\c.&~ he.e_n

+\'\P_ c_¢;_se_.

TK\S 5¥\0 U\A be. c_c.m$_'\'me.c\ us cl b\cd'an¥ 03<\'<>_~\%\' \:>y \'\\e, S\’Lc\e_‘}o Man`\?u\ar\e.
+\r\L C.mwjr `m~\~o /v\cu<`u\g Q_Aerl§\o¢\ w`a$l\c>u`¥ cl ce_\/`m.w ox- \\.\L <‘e.cnrc\.,

IL~,

_\`\~,e. S%A}e.`\n¥e.m~@_c\ “\v,} ¥\\e_ I\FP\Ic/m+`s c\<»`~\ ¥or.re\`le_¥ was r~}\m§e_ ar_r.acding
+D`\'e.m§ final @$'(;r`.~\\n&\ Pc\¢¢aAum>_,@-¥, u.m,§ L‘\ w c\\"A.\ APP\:¢~_M\)< 5@_\<\~3 a
Sub.£equ¢>.r$r \mbe¢;$ wc~`.lr Pur£\uun~\' lrca T€_Xn.$ F,¢>A&o¥ Cr`\~\`\ na_\ Poc¢@.dure,
m"rlr;\?_ “.D"l mus¥ mimma_\~a\y Ammn$'¥fa\'e, \;»y a pt"e__por\de_(‘onc.e. cc ‘\\\L€_V\c¢l¢ H\e_-Yo.c;`¥uol \:<15`~»5 "Yov '\'\\<=. c;\c[\~\ was unmm;\\c\\:\¢>_ air '\"\\e_ -\'\Me_ c~\`- ~\\\»e,

0\'"13`| hal @P\`\Cn.\"'\on ;`\ SEL E>L PM\'E. N\aAA"\ 031'70 §,`\n.l. 35\ \`?3\/\33(_1'€_1 . [:\`} N\. /-\PP.‘ZBO?J}
s¢e_ also TF_)L.(“_BDE c_P\\~\."PRc>c. a\.m sp.¢~_. "4.

T\'{\S wo:s o.r\c»\'\we_r zd¥eJ~/\P\' by H\e.» amici jm deceive»“\`\s Lnur~¥, by P\m;`\r\_q a_
dalm Qn~\'¢> ~\-\'\e, A\:P\€Co.x\¥ ~¥\\c».\' \'\»e. d`\A (\D\' m\P\`ic_m\\» \a`\c\ c>\)¥ &¥\P_l:o.-s`\§ ali H\S c_\a`\~\ car \'\mr`m_c§ cL§uhs€_qu,e.n¥ wv'\{' op
imbe_¢;;s too p\-_\§ \'\e.c>x‘.:\ by ‘\jn`\s cour+.

T`he_ l\p\:'\`\am\¥ $S\¢=_A H\S Su‘ns-P_c:\u¢>_¢~\\' wr"\¥c>¥ `r\o.bm§ cpc \:m§ P\.\r‘Suo.r\’r l-¢>
Te;m$ fc¢`\e»_ ¢5¥ Y`_r`\~\`ma_\ P<‘¢>c.ec\uce_,as¥sc;\e, \\`.G”I/§Ll(od (_?.5."\\\ \,A\-\`\c;}\ he. Mu:s-\ P\‘Q\/c»
'\'\\r& 0 ky a_ Poapcmde.c\ane.e. 03 sr\\e_. e_\lTL\e_n<;e_/'\zu-\- par c>.\l`\c)\alr`\or\ 05\"- \»\~e. L\r\'\¥ec`\
S%Sre§ Con§¥\lm¢\~`u>n no rn}c¢oNA_!uw>v abu\c_\ kane counc\ -\-\\e_ app\`\am\‘\r _SL.\.`\\lr>z

\3&\}€>\'\€\ c\_(`e.o:§o\'\o_hl \LADL)\‘.\"(: / r\D'\' T. C_. [`_. P /o.P-\'. \\ D'l/ §L|CCGC\\ 05 C_\O.\N\€_A
by “¥\\& 5\~03(€_.

`:EF_
°\'he_Tr;)La§ Ru\e_»s m¥ l¢\ppe_\\c\\'¢ Pmcedu¢~e_ \>m\:`\d& a way under P\u\e_‘§?_. il ¥or
'\'\‘\e.T€.)(.D.$ Y..Dm“\' exx- C_F`\N\:\r\a.\ APPP_LA$ ~\'o €n§uv€_ '\"no:\' ~\'\'\e_ bL`\av]OF bp cLPCL\`“\'\/
or cm oi¥orr\e.y \,_s'\'wc`\§' m:.\~ arising `\r\jooc'l $0[\“\ -\-¢> bL mic\c‘e:\§e.c\ 4-\\<‘0»3'\\ ~\»\\L

iN\`\DDS`\"\"\m\ er-_’\us\' Sm'\c_'\"\on§, v

T¥\e_ E_<“`\M`mnl bis-'\~c\f<;jr A*\"\’orr\e_y' o-Y f?)rcxzoric\ floa_=r\-`r)z,:'\'exsm.‘:z hcfa rm\~ c\e_m.\¥
w`\¥h -\-H\s \:`_our\- cv '¥\-\`\5 I\Pp\im>n\' `\r\ on hone$)c mnex`."\`he. B"\S\‘r`\c;\' A\'\c:mr;y
\v\c\§ oc}\-e.~»\>~\'e.c\ ‘\'o ~\m`\‘:.u\cx_\'e_. “c\-\`¢§ C.c>\>?\' "\c\\'¢> m\{\ng ur\Qo.`\<` A€.C.`\'i°\ons
JHNA' wco\c\ ~Yur)<\\e.v %¢=_\~\se. l-¢> u"lo\a\'e_ '\jn`\$ App'\`\c¢_\<\¥§ Due__\°ccc,e,§s 'R`\B\r\‘\'s.

The_v¢>_-\:¢re., -`\-\'\`\5 i\F.P`\‘¢c~_a.w\- asks ¥\m.\- -\\-\`\s Caur{- $ind m\\-\'m_\- &\»\e_ D`is&riv.\-
A+*om\e_y \'m$ ~Fal\e_d ¥c» a.c}< `\r\ good ¥ol“\ \>7 joess\y N\`\ss+o:`\-`mg €o.c_¥s `m
‘+\\e_ Appi`\c.o.,r\¥s Pc~’c`¢'\"\or\ and <‘e.ques`\'s \'\'\a\’ \‘\r\`\$ Y_ouv'\» `\Mpose, w\-\oc¥euu
So.nc_-`¥`\¢>r\s c>r\\'c> ~\-\r\e_ D`is~\-rla\' A+\»oma.y i'\-\e;\' l~'\ c\e.e./\A_‘> appropr`\o:\e..

l>l~'l A\{`ER
\¢JHEQE.\=QRE,~PREM\SE msm£\z\=_b,-\-\\e. App\ics.n\- asks ‘\-\n¥\-\'\`\§ Cc>uv¥
\r\em‘ ‘H\e. Sul:>M`v`\-j¢e_d \\1¢~`\-¥ 09 l-\cslmm$ [`_m~pus,- rey-erse,¥\we__"\udgme_n'\~ rendere¢:\
by '“\e. '\'<\`ao.\ anqu and r‘P_~\o.\-\A -\-\ne_ m:>¢z_ ¥m<\ a.<\e.\.`x -¥v§u\,¢md any c>‘\\\e_r
valid deemed appm:.pc`\o}re_.

Respe_c.&-¥u`\\y sub~\R-\Jre_d,

§_@,M Q;W
Ja/v\:e_$ Ar-\\r\u:\ Ne,w\:\y'
Tnc_ e~\o. \»12_714 3a
l\pp\`w_m\& Pro €>L

A\\o.‘\ B. Pc>\\.>-ns'&y lin`\'\’
3872 FN\ 350 Sc>u-\'\z\
L"\v`ing$'\'m\/Te_¥as 7735i

 

C.`\=_RT\F\C)'-\TE OF SERV\CF_

1 m"¥§¥y ~H'\o:\' o.‘h~ue. and abroad copy op H\e_ App\iwn\-`s Re§puns\>_. ~\'z> "a\'o.'\'e,`.<,
Answer +o App\im.¥mn $c.r \Jc?»\ o$ Haber>s l`.r,¢~ Pus }m.s be.¢>_r\ -\`-o¢\wa.r¢\ul by LLS.
N\o.`\\ , PDS~\'¢>§L P(`P_.\>o.`\d/ j\:`¢(‘5*\- a\o_ss ; +Q "¥he_ I'\~\'\'erne_y Y-o:~ ~\'\'n>_ 5¥&¥&,§&€`\Yb\m,n*
. \\l E_. Lc:c_us'\'/ Su`\’t£'. "\DBA .. Ang\e.'\'c>r\ ,TEJLAS T\S\§ on '\-\n`\§ '“ne. 'Z?_¢\A ¢\a.y a\`-
Dec:e.~\\ze.r , 'LC'\‘-\.

\_\ouwe_<. Ar \-\~\u¢` \~‘\em\:\/
Ap\>`\`\¢;m\\',- Pc~e se>_

\NN\AT E_`S DE.L`_\_ARA'\'\D\_\__

l , ~\cmv;s Ax~\"r\ua~ NC-.wby .»TDC.¢|"|?_"]L\§L¢) 1 being Pre$en\~\)/ ’\_r\c‘_o.vc;£voéced em “\\\P_
Alian B. Pelun§K\/ \_\n`\¥ a$ -'\-\\e_Te.ms D¢>_pm~+~\ex\\' o¥ C.c"\~\`\ml dus)c}c_e.`m Po\K
Cc>uM-y' ,Te_>co_s,v-er`\¥y and Ae_c_\o.m>. undev peno.\¥y o¥ ger_`\uf‘)/ &ha¥ \'\\e_ ¥cce__¢lo"m_g
S"¥o~i’me.x\\-s o.re.jc¢ue_ ami mc‘(’e_dr. .

E.X'.P..C.u"\'e.d on '“\`\S ~\'\me. 'L?_r\A clay c\¥` DeL¢M\:>e.r ?_DM.

§o.~\m Ar“\'l'\u¢‘ NE.WB}/,TDI`_ |‘~I?_`I‘{F.o