Court Opinion

ID: 4047885
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:30:46.484273+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:55.973076
License: Public Domain

Ttearkan-.Te-O'               |                    S^'S-'to
Debra Autrey, ^"^^e   \j£ ^E^flWL /    /CPT>OlAM T WAT | J 2015
                                 V^'              (J^an^ Texas
                                                  DWWtlt Autrey, Clerk

                 _^j^j\ AK\T: lVP\M"^Tle£
                           X^T?& iudtorx ^wJb'i
  urviojv      ^ejoaX Cj^>_ v^.^^ (cx\ Q^» t-WaJb                           l_xj&-s
KeJ?<LLu\ e_k.  ^0<l_ Acs^ As^l _S-t£Ute_ C-XXJrt^                          XHPeflAei.

X^ 3.QU , -VW.             LeJ\ls\cLtu<f«_ CLw\ev\i^ tW -Statute
  Cj^klvc^       TOCCtL     e«-<^i!fti    Q_Gia_ -Stdbion           Q.4 2£
 TV^ji^-o        cxA       \^jl. -S^en^ivc_ ""iHo/usrcA AirJtoJb Jv,ii
vv~v,ejf\edKcs         -it* *\keJ?c£kk      ±>    \A.G 1qL-tuoi     -(Mown a-ffen/W

k X\\uJ^ VjoCLS           -\dW.    D<\AM L-Ouw&uclS*- tkaJ:                  tUa-x^

LamiuaiL.         est     AVVca          \X+ua        H     Qkifr. _AcuA felcVi       ...

Ucvwauw <_       ts^     to-tW     tV\cwA        (X       _StaJb£. _JaH   -CeAemM ....
 'v^rVvsWoW Uit\JUa a. SJ£ ceo \r\ l3.Ma. d..
TW ^w^waa uoe_ Ciajl Wixulrva                                     toelaxt Qa^uz.^

  AS*.   ****•   a©3\- ti                                                      ,
"^Wu     \_£_ai£Vcdtuv«_   \W vlSuxSaI.             \3.mkL*) Cam! enack,

  1^,2.^(1X1       CwvA    (YNQlWU.   <W      UWj       laM    a£Se*-fcc'/v9

_iavr Menu uo&i, e*vKa^ l^ia a.Hian Q) it Losf
  Ufc^ rUaiW           ^   ^eArvq     (X Make JaM VdonM            ur\<W
 VS.. 3£ <a i

xW> ^           -t-W ^cu^_ £cW*_ tU ni*« _Av*Lca^ cxu*

iW d<\vM «Ll&eAa*^ ix\ 'tkWA&t*. CLc&t. e**>sc± "bo
Uae_£>& 5L UiWitae_ L$>     tV\OV     ttaM   OAJL    -^cHii-vS "fab U<££- tint.
\^ .H^ COO £SA     UiA\a Cl NOU -$>\£j£z. Jkdl -Ceiorxt*, Otvd Oiuu
(L-GAVvrvB XV      C5l_ V«-^u\.OA -£eA.O<rvM, alca'coa tWJt It U=>U

  cjjwL PuV VW ^vfcc.;u<J             Lcia^vj^^       e>£     fytim -Bra* q

                             C^3^a)
Lo\^V ;&_      ul^:\U .^Aaiu+QvM Jvjq*. i; rY^ e_rwJ*A tM Tbtfc/ CaJq
 q    4X£tk)

 UAAojv tW_ QL_Wvnar_U -tci_£takjtovM LrvhsiKPreiai.'oa• lW.
  (L-fcu^ Lod^ b> VW \WusA -toct M Uu £4cdLute &r

 louW3U£j£_ Li      Q.miiijuDLif/'g^t^iun
                                   —
                                          v-g-kii^/^^ .suj^A. n&j.nss na(Wt
                                                                         Wiy

 ^JLltxvvA ?un'^ofcl£. UcnAqa Q.3Sto, Thai,, ILz. e^Kance*v>W LS

 TW. £ol£* eA VW \chf&\)QJe- -tWt ujoc, LAtiuLi. ii±d

 • ot Ox. sVn *f.. Vol I -(:eAm4! tWt, Lod^ '"ftouicus e^a^r-sO.

     ^-wocxeous     u^LAjejv^tJiCLtL or*   C£ ^tio&A Cjd <L_   Q. M3 <ttJ Gil
 -tW. \_e_^iA loAxiv<L-     VxJt'e.aA^l    ^extoX   CldA-cl Q . ^ (a? (SO
     b^caxjs £. \t <L\ L ^0 d V VtvLVj kA tW L_ cl*v£uaJ *. £> I P)Vk*/i

     _Sxa±c ,-kul   £dor\U ^ruitajbte urvU* Q.35 CCL?.
r>v\ ^hcip vu o-t tW _S\loJxL ^vieJc -tW -StaA£_ OLLhcwt^^
  •yna±. V\Qyj\fA _SeQ-Uex\JtiaA -S-tiXte. _kx.\l d-onvituticn., U warf
     TVajj. ^juex\ OAflUd "tW^ ^^4              tkajb   1iW^ s<LRueAK±)G,l
     Gte^nl^.                                           in                  /^JP
tvUAji. / OuwA LW -COLA:, Li VkOJt.             \Au>     X-tajfce_ CiiL* KJO
  d_Qie.   1_ollo     &v   QjotWtAM     -tft -SDPPov-t     ttaju fj^rvt^xion,
TlW ^'^eiii.          Qu\\W t_t=3f\x£jf\L    VWjJL AAu. ^Wiattbiuslvsik

-S^tcifcc. "vHev;i;o^ *v*tt>v\X\f\a tW ttltf\Se_ Ctf 'tVjtvisU rrui^vJb
   uc\Axlk. LxaWclVn -tW /Ae-fepAorvJL J?£Y\Jx*vCi2_ (a CLsSciScA.
~0c\a]L \s, CLV-VYnoj^Vn BAdioe_ Luas -bid. O/wl. <Lor\uiti*A at
 Cl. -Stnix _laU ^cVow M^ViriisWkU UpAju Q. ISCa}"! nn (L(wst,
MutvxW tt;WTO" f^nc^ Vk (Lorajiiiior\ Lu<u enkcmazi ....
   uniaiA Ql . 3S (&)':      bu*   u)as Lrvs^cal "TbrV^WW i mAoji Q.W

  u r\^c^WAA<>_ vjynAaa      4wkw ttaiA dorOuaci QmA &uU x^
  (LjcnKowIclA ^~?xm\IsVwwurOe.

tc^ iltke_ -trcaA eA a CdtaMi t&kcx&t- f^xWA xW\ CL 5toLkJai(
  xcWm, Ton'tiVvoiVe. uvvW _£exlifcrx l^ 3£ &1* CEJK?hasi5 aild],

X*A llkW C-£tt€_s "BAdlat Ul>Os tKei Qck Ql Ho<U- OlStouafei
   jStak__AaU &k*\u, v.e. , Cl ^taAz. JaJA £dc*^ T\jni^kai(e un^
   -tWjw ejaWw^^i. ^uv^uoaaA -b^ Q43Stj -tc* xAul aauival^

-SV-CLii. AalV     Mban "rxirv^WJoW. vj^Lba Q. ^S (0l\ (jo^V q_

^.H^SQol         Oi, \jO£AV CU   \a.Mll03Ca). lS. i-S \ifctlM    tkcU   L-fc
  vjuooVL Wuic ClVeiMW _SaiA -So. as ill AiA lui+W aJirauduL
                              CLUk Low) AHWiW

  Ar^><L£    vaoHL T^avmOlV      (\_ "vYior _State.__Aaul   -feA&nw   to loe^

  .ejf\V\Q/v\DL- Cl V\&c\ OLlSvauatci -Stait. ~Jcu \ -felcnM \£> tta_
 Uejjei o-t     Qu -SeJJcrvL A_eJir£iL "CelwvRv
  X%i SU^it-L cA Wi "v^tVloO/>"S>ltLas«_r^o\ivL to 'tKo

 Xw -SVvjbrt , "EskLsc*. Cr»\JLe*xL, -that M-felor\M " OS Lt L-S
   \jcSc-L    Lrv   ta.Ma (COG) kucuj ejnadbLi k* \XH<as(£>) cLdc^
 Mot V<lW ^            r-sV    ltmXjLl Ol _&kd£. Jail £dor\W .
-<l_Vi "tW (Lose. e>4 .DYy\<u ui/'ii'.lr p \\e n< £L s.uj.^1
%w      LTdX APP. tort          UJotiU   £00 \, t U tjsoirt      -Pcmvi. hiw\

 Cl. _£-tak._Aai\ -GdfcrvM . |
  XW. ir&icAJNVwA. ^uvWux OL\k«J«J. ^W CLPFfcllcwd-. hai
   €£. kVu^t- UJQi>           Li&K Cx. Skdf _ku\ uk*W. Orvii thai:
 XW C-c^A c* Cjrl«vMc*i SS&uAs &€ Texas CO^i tk

 *^ ^uw <? xfx ±k£hj«. *£*J*K* -^^ ^/r
 XW iUflJcufe. UY\?(^\riS l(\Orea<eA Tbnisk ktjlmJ- -£or
  Evtt exskm LjoVu^ WlA Wq*\ ^VcaiI fcusW CLjonvt'CJki o£
 Vxjuo        xdcrvv^*,       xx€_\ja/u      "xeAonK"         Ci/nl lLs-fcai<! doll      felont/-

 Se^~ -^fato. p£                   T-oCg* v, \A ap vfm 1j& u_i g ft r . c_Lt^ as

      £c*-t    ujor^        KW Pet, reriJ:
  X    W_          C_Cil e_ LjXlO         OmX      frjufcUori-^   GOAt-Sti      Cck>ou<u Cut I
 Qd ^cuW -£Wo                 tW.         -Lviai     Cjol)(t(- xJXTuJl    \oM   U&iV\5      h&
  <3V^             i^tcJtL dad        -febrvM        C_jOr\UiatCy\       Bl\ CLDuud<     VWtv. Qfc
 f^mx.         \x^ ex\V\OmEa. Ws                rx^rd^W yy\1*J-    ttb     Ol AeJLDnA. Lesbos

   ToCXls H?-e^ doLo. " -^edo^n" LotLS \t\jd\                                CacJdL. ^tedt^
 JkcjuV  £«A(o*vv^, Q/vd tAr\ji/\^dcfcr<L LiL uooa                           LiWfy Cor -tluL.

   dfi-9Y*JL          tedoY^rf.

£doa^          -GuyAVuLa / U         AW Lejt CsAcduvt. V\al LaJbeynid tW Cl
 K3ew - QJL3v(u;ukA .Skd*L dali                      -CelotvM ^e eJ&Wt. G* ^\iMmj^Ar
\Jv\W         Q, HauxiQiA           as Oueil           OS*   iaMAS(b1, i+ t'j» Ukeiu
 \AvaA:       Lt     UJoovk       nouut    CAecuYM £>bll ^o,

LJLN\As=JLe ^Rt t r"^&^Y\l_S£_,                          (Xor\£i'Aojvc_A_, AA^liOMir
lit 43 gni  VTCJjxralrvJL E^t LAk^AJL^, Qyv\A -^e^nA ^^(tAa-a
  -\rj^ tVuL. H Vsfc JiiAiatul Col**: ^      fl (VA^t^j 1rid
Gvs n^Y\lsV\ w^MJt                        *tAA6LL      lS Cjvu sisiejnCA- LajvVVy tW-

                                   pQ^i U»
  tJ?vWv VL2L /V^cU_a*d ^c3vm to \_\_ .Stat/.-
                    VjOA^?.AmX^ /            CLof\_-Ju-_s XiM CSiU-S.Ti'm
 • UrvflJLa.        Olajl   -A_<\J>a g_,    nLTLe__.    tjuhjOJia.    + Ll APPdf&rrf

   V__\\     t-W        \jf\S\CUiC__ C_C_S_,.

   (L_3DWi          l_V> -tk_. E_yY_aA        LT\ -LoWicU        AtWjUU CX-LDfV-fii./
CU tW A.PP<___a/vd \^eAjeA £L9r\_i q_ dmSeni to _£a*di
   tW Wv-o-teJ               k.<f\_c_u._lw Ct/wA V/D\Un.tfl/w.
                    AP?£.U_f\WX CL^l&Tl Tib "ML -_._MLH.
   \_*sL)Jl Cjor\_e/vdb        )___ YoVjhJtaAK          O/vd VJvte.lU\_ei_:. Ct-A VrOuU.
 \_M (^'"Pvd.PorxAeAO/vxCi*. i_vC PVi.A^ro ,. J^c^necLiCin-fk v, flus-fav***,
   '•Uk     UuS. ,31? LlVtfJ. OLwi             t\u.. TtfCti          (LervsP.+u+t on'* Wow-
   c_-o^v;t\cln<t           e_v/^Juwvoi-/ Tex. cot\x4. / ax±. ±. S^Lk.%-

OV* ^n.c^. 3\ fe& -tta_ C_jGo»t 'R_jp_A>_\ T\_jl_*_. Cii: tW.
 AjP?V_s£oa WaxW1 Lt UjUv. 0_VesJuVM -SVua-o tka_t BwQj^
f-xrteic* OtkuiLfl- tk-_ APfeAOvui tWdt V\jl fcfcli \\\«r\ "to £,fc?l\
  QJO<\Se*vL a/wl V\jl \j_ts_\A ke akW Vc_ Ke_t!rvv)_ hi_ kt_4
Q_a_<_ CWl Wtvtf                  tt to       U(v\. ___«. H-R.V- _vt£l'_I 31 LlnalH-.a^
Ul &k>oic*l JtVj. AJ?ftXVaA>Jb tWiJh L<t tW bvick Cos<l WuLanuj
 G_e*\ fcj\uiot>v_ VX\ Lt -tirUAJL LutfLllk W C,lnft/_>(£_, Cf/vuL i-f L+
A-lk. AiCA V\jQ- \JUC3UVk WioS Lt tts W\Wr\ LiT\ _ic.il Oj. Luh.txJr\

 \^       l-\cl_.     n.- as

  OJv\k        CjAvjiLai WlTv              tG -3D      to tW IrOOWv QmA Vt-V^-.

 VTVNSL^ SVAiicVv 0_CJ^v__ UPGA tiu. t-Q^foX LA S(A*'tWt IfOOrvx
   CCv>ctcvku -SfiJCwcVurM Lt                   _3___ R-R.-V. a_QT^3-37-3?-J9

                                            ^5^1
XlW _*__> •*<£_ (Lw__t_d tWx__ S>£JOuxJk EsGCfcu Cb*lWSr\
  VaclL C&CICjli \_Ul\M4 JJwutU tk Wuj_ VA,Vi .SYvultk -<g_.
_l\Jn. CL -Qov*v\ £ovr BA^Xscxl T^feAJWx -S\__ tkiuoutftufc-
 _3W UJUjL S&rxir^ fey tW T^ee^iM .

                                   XLCurv      t/ie>oO.                             .
UuV_Af\ o^cc_a dorr^in                       uu<^ Ojfcfii about                   tta alUM**
 V\_. w\aA__             OlSocuf    tW -£ki/Ub                  L-OXriai    «r\   Via.'a ui'^uJ
0i_. ^Bor\          Cls      tW_    (Loot*     opotn y W                LOCLi ut\oJ>l_ trti
 -SW>o        UuWa.          t-Wls -SUxaJL            *•""•<•      ^Y,>t1 Tt 3t l -rfv. l-a-r
  SWlVcl?, EVU'iflt'T .Qu. P V^tyAlXi _£Waj                           tkiUjL LOfiAA. KOO
_£>WjL^JL    V_r_xciM        l»M -tiw. doc*- LoCLM,
  LW \raL£_                WJ^       L_      tkuJfc       Vv__ OAV_£_i LW ^UtJt
A_ci     \e>4__         ex. LAjSrvjitL TbLb -SkinJl -tie- JlcouJ -
XW -_\v_\4_ -tWJt uja_ _£<_Li4_ fitkA tiu. r^P;c«A. t^jevdr-
  lr\tc> tW_ LNocfc \_Q_a Lul_ CX 3te-*V~.Vs b\ot Thfe -Ski/iJb
•LVncJc u_ia__ v_s_=l £o< -exn!_>,**.__. Kiet uVxt-e_.
XL \N\C1L2_ On _?^AS£_ LuJflJU tV_ Cs^-fClA buCUlA, Weel
 td_ui_>    djexvS^JL £aviW,                 CUnA           tLub a&iiOL/iX- £oV JXfkok

Xejfe>rvAmlV> eXVuWt * "\ tuUV C_V€J2lAM f jrv-ow -thai ^om_ov
emw tk_. v-oorv^ rW. uoe*vJL ^        L-^_ ClmtealJ Bloc*
 WCL_ Ds^i *k*U^J £,Otv^ (IVOfVu IT\ tlM. (LOr.U0lr C* tk__
 Avt_S^v          Lex     Ol cttori          tap -SLbt^j T»\flur\ V/re^_«
 ^lxjCJ' tt ^eWs. C_a_.<rt uooovl -So V_acfc CfcviA v/icu rfrfo*i»
  Cj>o      -tKx-;^. cAfotVC, uj£ajl W5b^                       trVvxAju^
  ^ajA" a^ j_e_ tW cVotp\ ^yu;i.;4- an. QmA tl»_. i_igOe_±
p^k;^:^ ^> M^svi uoa\ «vjou3 -See. tW -SWi twii U«_

 -tko. sa*1 ^cm o^ c_om a«a, a*mA _3e9k^tu/ \h^ aoia
 $k>r      t.W_ t^vJ^K.            r_Ax£.g v.-StftT£, ISIO ^.uj. 313iJ tVaCCjLJW*
 uuV-JU- tW keWAa/vJt <WXfeuL-s OL iiufe>5Var. ti6-( ^vel', n^ !^*w
   sVjftu3\rx_      tVjJJL C)^      £<tt$>£- £iJcakjlYvMvJb           Krvbuj;<vih       CcajvA
 Vr\ t£jr\t\On a\W , Oy UJ\^r\ Y<LdR.\-.5._ dlSVt-^CMA ^or tW-t^
   yoaS v^CLVoAe-- V=m tW aeeicKvO- Co Arta UotUAa,l rtff,i,^
  v^ajuU^Ls      tkat     a     kiLOd*.      tc_<__ tad nib -tAu_. Ae.£^aui_:
vedutca.
 AX- t_A___ -5uPf^dxr/on ke-QAi^5 -/-L*. -2-au*4 Laos alkalabuJ

 "T_V\ts £Lud-Sfr^ tt^^-s Cts>LtJ in a eJfttl is Yej/exd 4-Ll
   A_V-uU\    C-Xhtn Cdaa ih_9 xAu.   tv/m    -hkt. (LnnS&rJ fdr/nl Lu<is QlleStL
  bo   \at i f i h_ui *
   (Q-ttiuu .CorXCrn CiUtstl -hhaJ- 4-U. (LonSZrd #>m_ mas Sisnd
  at ;/;_ao       c^nA     //; ju     Cl) minute    ccPcud, U/k&h    ki^ u^s
   astA       Ciiiouf    haw f A^i InCuppm" kn OmSuutA 4-haJ is JaJf

  uoltW tkx ^.-VlCxav^^A £vld Acxk. Or\ -tW ^ecUrl* La*l\a.<Vi4;

    e_vc\ A\_am aiVw SCrtl U3a<_ if\j^A>iA Ji'toiMfae-i -Cad Aaid
  V^M \_W cd-Lxt- tC_> VOUAcJbfi_ ^WjL<L l££v*U/vv£_z_ -

* T_V>__u A.^dcuo^         odltsti ^c*w teA e_A vvLCfteL Co CVvd hU-
 de-£CWt_>d CAl£*\a        LOO-S      Cl   UikxU. *ft>b J?fuVf

   V_c\vs> (_JL_^vAcLod uoci -S^uwpu ^IUi an _^^Miwe<i
  ^tiV^v/ L_t O^nJtoi^d AeAvWeAOit CoA&e. WjdoA uuttU v^ecicUxs
   <_Ale,v-Li.CAAd -fev AW tvuVW.
 H^v_ ^iLflu \_W_ WAm ^^ VAll LadAAiAAJt tW a^CroaJ
   ceLcati     tWi      (Qc\ dvM SLSX1 XoQ.        W    QktCuAfld -tW ^oucU

 _S£_JXA_d\    \aCtcX Dr\ cAom a3r*- Soil WM                 hcuj^g 'SledSc^
  xWs ^Ocvw V-S \rW C-OrvSeAvJl -Qovrt^v Vx_3_ used 0_b -b(u_
<a£fecox V^__ki ujoovJ.                 -L_strt;e    ti_o LW %<xcA_ LAvaJs-
AAvoA £>W •LkMajSWk                 LaJCcS    Gl _S<2-OAX.k Uj£UA_cuj*- Btei-Soe.
  Wcjut     ._A-vn_X a^^.r^v ti^i                    ?5-ng'L.\nA \-as-.

 VnCi^AJ^'i tWo. <Le_4ev\jLc*vfc          Ct -Qotwa       QmA      Koajikli Kim to
 <?ii.i^- L.W. [-as                                                             ,
Btt;_a VAotS^ LoftA \_J3&t CLUao^ -feW. dfedu^-^d thinly
 •\_AOt It UOClS OL _SejJAcU LUCUAj^fc^ tW<> C.Ol>*s torVlrv

i__l«\aJtuw. \DexxujSx e^Guk Cs«-rCfcn Ka^luj ViLs> T>W\ ukiJii
  \M_t uao^. L£ O^Du VAoLs Li Wd -£« a. L-t -
VA£_ 1W Lae>(L LW LAa/wJK Qj>v£eMt •W/k uj^ti IMsce.
 .fitSl\aJcu\r«- ©r\       Lt/ Cl/wA      \rc_ WVlL. Ct m*/ twCltj UihM
-tW. tu&            Ctj_w_eMJt. -ttvm'i •Qvewv ^\<_Uo_. CjimI Aimo/lcc
 i^Wcuo^i           LW. L\wlh        &LJb U\ iL&       OaU I\*. a \ -tW* Vul.

VA*_ LW £Lsvui Ws IMOuwul CWvk fetkcu. "Bcv«L erutiu^
  •yo<?      GA       LW-     £cn-wv.

XW.         •VCLtt^    lw\ -LW           Ve_JUDv-L    UjiU        CJkolUj SWjsuiihot
  LWjui_ liliiu WJo \IQ.( tvi                O/wuii/ifc    tC _ScCucii      (loom lo£

  \rttUL AKKWifc* W SeixxLk- ujoaacmB t.W. uj^ obtain.
   OS. LW WojCuIa5^ Pi/wi                    tU -tw«i diJLr^^ ^iUTi/ /^^l-
(dl\r£-t_Jttlcrrv     W>    CL\i£3L^>l(rv<< "LUj- €JL)^tfl*U2^.    CuJb   t^L t^fctL
  "t.ArvU     CLOie. StkOLsuL ^^ V-CVWCia^ loflLK Uuifl^ C OlrAfix

                                      VQJS«- JD
g_jc»*u. £>t X£?e_UOMJt Ue-vUi B\rie^ V\as ke^n '"iWciaJ
 -tO .T^PRgft K. AirrgBT. CAtML ^    -LL. Cou^ D< Afifatf
 .SffcWv A&ttWCih. TMfi^idt OLfe tiu. "El-STfttE -JuSrice-
UlYilA\*j Cit ICb KtoeiA.-STftTE. Liiu£ Avemj£#JO. TeXft/lktoJ#r
  "\LEX<tS   nSSO\   e>r\ -fcKii iM   D(   WlAu 1UL am? .

                                                             v_^