Court Opinion

ID: 4048231
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:34:49.850785+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:06.426038
License: Public Domain

4 ' ' ~O\ ,
jtqu gzlm REcEl\/EDIN

_,H,OM&)NMEE MQ¢K \\ l\/\\il \'A er-_c\xdw£\\\¥ +0 9

 

§ `\ `\s\o cm ~\»\\E ost op QSSAU\+ ch m

€Awh¢_mmb;r `\MO 9 P\Ssau\»¢ w`\+\\ § DEM\\{ Wz\qpm\

dad \AO "\M\lES~¥`\%QA/`\o»\\ ~\'O dEA/Em/\ME Q~\' \~A\{ Hd_'}uc\§cm+\`;d

 

`v `\ ' ' r x v\\\m¥ \G\Ad OF \Nhn~\' QJNAA¢_ cf '+¥\E
®

£an_\;M\_dlE__\Q§§M 'Fxrrau%\;& one H; ;i\gd\§ q/M+

dir-jaslow 04?` E>LQES&`\\)E pums¥\mm*r. W`M\ ms Pac§vs or

 

 

 

Suppor‘¥ 09 ~\é\\`\& C~,¥ASE ®@}\\C> p\\o\'c)&, 043 9 QSS\O.L)\+
~_+`;Q__&QQQC>¢+ ~'\~\\n~\» ~QQQ+ 1\\0 S\‘vz-\.+EMEM or QM\]\ ME@\;U\
_ + 0 " .M,©I ‘ '

09 w\\{ C,Ou%~\`\‘\'u-\"\onu\ \\%\\~\»3 \\/0 n 45er \m:nmmj®l!i£ g

Km\€a <~5`\@\ wolf emma a…_or_d;e£o__
0 0 ..\ " t 0. =0. g Ar_”=,.\,\\» 0 .\ 90 __ \,
49£5%1~¢\\/4<1+\=_\4 st,m\*\; ~+\\E Ev`\@\r=\~;c,a Mus+ pmv& ~L\m+
»\,\r\a \Q(\;\'c)\" USE +\’\E \3%\3\ `\’DC`J 340 133$.(@.91-»
hErEm g£»¥'er‘ dEFz»dM-\» Pr'o SE 9334@ =9` \E%
+\'\\5 NO`\“\QE ~P<>-

0§)&¢4"3033 Q\~\d ‘R&\o\»l-'¥n\ ~¥o CO\MSE\ QF-€°dav;-E-
mw 34@=¥\3;§ -\»o ~\»\\E C©U\'~¥S O~(: dE;*énc:\nM-S

~CRES\FE ~YO F\S\\'\" O'C 934 QQ@EQ\

934 wou\ci\ S\Q\c>w +\¥\E C,UMS +\-3&: Fc>\\ow?.uj

.. '@333 N\aq 354'_3_2_@\\4, juc\ me`a+ and Sz».\\'EMcEc\ was
3 v . ‘3
E\.\~\' dated \¢\3§.3"§`334,

. @34 3A3333 393 3`0\1\ ~\»‘m£ `(3~`333\ C.our-\re, 5`,¢534§¢\ 4,.3\@
`3333¢.\ 320033% 6333.331‘¢,333: 031 ne¢§»am$ Q35333
mg H@@§@R ~

 

®‘; Bf¢mé&&$ Q~\'¥QNE has 340\~ wr`r\~¥€\\\ N\E Or‘
` ‘\M~F`omEd ME 39 \’\E ‘¢;“Ed +"`E baggager

P“PE\`S~F¢>¢ ml 343@3;¢3§ @3` Qppea\ ns he
~\'c>\d ME ‘3\&“ 'W&S <50`\3.15- ~\»'o do,M_.&Y_Lgocq
bo<\* did 340'~¥ do., _

®. ©‘\\ MXM_.&Y__`&O\‘=\ dependm~&‘\" 340‘=\"3$§5¢\ th
Covnss\ @=$ \n`\s dESZFE ~\-o QPPER\;."\/r"\é\ covussl
Rdv`\s\=,d dE$Eudm~L+ ~3\'\33-\' `\M<:\EEA \’\E v~lou\d -F`\\E
.~W\E MEGESSN\\ QPPEM pnp§rs.

'  DE~FE\~\AM~\' 35 340-\' 93 \Hw\|EF 0\" Ever ¥FA`\WEA

\{E.`r` Wou\c\ -p\\€ +3\€

34 depauc§an% F\Pps¢a_\)

 

334 \awbmz b§\\e~,ved h‘.s \Aw
NECESSN\:\ QHPEFS ~3»<> bs%:
§§ \’\§ +o\d dE'FE“dRu-\' \\E wou\o\.

@. `\'h€r€w€or‘ ~\/\'3333 ~\»F`\A\` C,o\msz\ ~(333\\ 30 £:\e

+\\E \\\oé}`\c,a » 0£ Qppeq\ 433\33+5 `.€34\24`$35@3‘3\/€

sti.s¥m\\cz c>-@ Qc)u\~kse\ -\»<> ~¥~\\‘a di¥“€»\dm.\+s

3"353\~\ 30 ' 6399€3-\\.

® §€FEMSM¥ has »C"\\ed 9 FEC,EA+‘ S+p¢-\»g gap

. O`P Tedms %r~kevmxgg Q,¢ v}~.3‘,_3, _§~¢~3¢\ Cw“$a\
FE¥US"“S +° do W\$ 505 ~¥o FEpFe§E\~H' dEFEMMH'
'Pr`op£f\`\ as I..\E@F€c+`~v€ Rss`\s\'nuc£ op Couusal.

., De'(jaudw*\' `3§ 340+ 33 \aw\§r=r, mud bg\\.E\/Ec\ 33.;5
\aw\‘zr`) 3333@\ b§\:E\/.¢.d his \nw\{lzr' Wou\@\ -G‘.\E

‘%"3\;€ 340-\»`3¢€ 09 334

BE\`MEA 4.\3& 3333333 \¢.,3%3
N~G“.\ 3ch 33@3\~‘?3 3333=. 00333§ 04 335 3303».3¢3$
+\\333_ h\s \aw\§;r;r dad 34@3 $3\; 3\\& azcssswi

~CQFW§ 430 SEQ\,¢E 334 QpPEG\ A\&d \~A.OS'\"

`Mpor~\v¢m¥\\ 3334 3399€33\ \Qw\§Ef‘»

Aq:)p§@'\ 9339§{‘ work d\eFendaM-

cn\ .S~\'BP W:_A.S +o ~F\le 934

'®. Qouus’€\ Da\)`.dsou did mdc  prrESEMr @Equda#éc 334 n F¢OFE»( M““QEY,

`\’\“°E d§§€“c\m~v¥ was david op ‘3\`3'5 (o"°’h~ 3334 \"\M

931\§346333\€3\~\' \);\<53\35_

‘. ©E¢E\AAQM*\" QSSEF+$ +hg»+ b CQuMSE` PEFCOFMH“CE
~FE\\ ba\ow 934 O\QBECA-WE 'S~\»r-mdards o~P-

FEH~S@H@MMESS ~For cou~s§.\, unpm$¥&$si@na\

Evror's .~3\~3¢.3+ +\ng rEwM-= of ~.\~‘f\§_

3333>@.€&¢\§33% v\/ou\d hpNE v bEEM. d§*?PE-FE»A+.

is E4~\".3\Ed

®-QE‘?EHAGM‘ F%SSEFZ' 3\“3€33~ ha
314\10M5

+0 334 339@2¢3\ cm causE, 340.

:l:_ .Q\!-¥Y\o\¢\i anh ) `\"DC;’) 340.` \C\D~Z¢a@\ being
PFESEM~L\\| §m.cnf`cr='r‘n+sd` m 4-\¢\3; `(Ew$ DEFN_\,ME“+
O`F: Cr~`»m`\uw\ dus~\‘§cEJL-_QPE:L S=\:Q\'E 3¢3‘\\ ]Ed\wkurj,`rx

didan uudgr 963433\¢\' o=F |P§r)ur\{ ~\'ha+ ~\-'\'\E`
`35\ ~\'rue' m\c\ COFFEC.-\» 40

 

3503`3; cjo'mg 334$~\¢3,33~3€333
H’\E loss-3 oP 3)3\\ 33333333.

Wh§r£\€or€ deF€NdQ‘A-k» grew +\3333+ +»\n%s
uouom\o;\z Com~\' do 946 333("3&3‘ 4 363 +\3\03‘03)39\
FE\/§Ew 09 ~\'\3\€ record 3)346§3* cause now

is compm»\\; 53\3.333.

M_HJMO ‘ 5

B@_~\r z

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

vC,B3)_;3;_34_3>_3_\L_\~\A_Q>Ere» _ :
'I_HM\@M,\\W_§\H§h_JA_\/_\E463/3333 30 333 \3.35~3 ’ :

 

 

§Qc_¢\/_\\i=_ 033$_;_0§_\5\ 93013?)_$§¢333;\34%_31\3#_{6 ciS§____ _

 

Moc>\\_ _3033¥303\__§33`0¢.3=`%% 3603' ‘\“\\E;\Q \@‘r=~\r+\;r Add,f.i\_o_gwm__

 

.` 910 9 `E ` 7,}1 H/\I /< \7/0#3/ §QO/_%/z_[£§§_*_';

777M '3/_ ,3@‘/5