Court Opinion

ID: 4075461
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 06:06:28.131285+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:33.215157
License: Public Domain

&$6(
  &9
  '$7(),/('

  

                                                                                                    FILED IN
  &$6(7<3(                                                                                 1st COURT OF APPEALS
                                                                                                 HOUSTON, TEXAS
  3(5621$/,1-85<
                                                                                             12/31/2015 5:39:20 PM
  67</(                                                                                     CHRISTOPHER A. PRINE
                                                                                                      Clerk
  6+($3$/$9$1

  9

  %5,$10&&8//(<%28/(9$5'5($/7<//&$1'7%:'(9(/230(17//&

  25,*352&

  12

  75$16)(5)520

  

  75$16)(5,1

  

  75$16)(5&$6(

  

  75$16)(572

  

  75$16)(5287

  

  38%6(59,&(

  :::67&2$&2857667$7(7;86

$33(/ / $7 ( %5, () 6

      '$7(£         (9(177<3(                                      '(6&5,37,21   '2&80(17

                                                                                  $33(1',;             >3').%@

          5(3/<%5,()),/('                               $33(//$17     %5,()                >3').%@

                                                                                  127,&(               >3').%@

                    %5,() ),/('  25$/ $5*80(17 127                          %5,()                >3')0%@
                                                          $33(//((
                    5(48(67('                                                     127,&(               >3').%@

                                                                                  $33(1',;             >3').%@
                    %5,() 5(&(,9('  25$/ $5*80(17 127
     5(48(67('                                  $33(//$17     %5,()                  >3').%@

                                                                        $33(1',;               >3').%@
               %5,() ),/('  25$/ $5*80(17 127
                                                $33(//$17     %5,()                  >3').%@
               5(48(67('
                                                                        127,&(                 >3').%@

&$6( (9(17 6

  '$7(                (9(177<3(            '(6&5,37,21          ',6326,7,21       '2&80(17

                      &/(5.6      5(&25'
                                  $33(//$17            £
                      ),/('

                                                                                                        >
                                                                                   &267%,//            3')
                                                                                                        .%@

                                                                                                        >
            0$1'$7(,668('        &,9,/                £                 0$1'$7(              3')
                                                                                                        .%@

                                                                                                        >
                                                                                   127,&(               3')
                                                                                                        .%@

                      027,21        )25
            5(+($5,1*     :$6    £                    £
                      127),/('
                      027,21       )25
                                  £                    £
                      5(+($5,1*'8(

                                                                                                            >
                                                                                   0(025$1'80
                                                                                                            3')
                                                                                   23,1,21
                      0(025$1'80                                                                            .%@
                                  £                    ',60,66$33($/
                      23,1,21,668('                                                                        >
                                                                                   127,&(                   3')
                                                                                                            .%@

                                                                                                        >
            -8'*0(17,668('       £                    £                 -8'*0(17             3')
                                                                                                        .%@

            68%0,77('             £                    £

                                                                                                    >
                                                                                   $33(1',;         3')
                                                                                                    .%@

                                                                                                    >
            5(3/<%5,()),/('     $33(//$17            £                 %5,()            3')
                                                                                                    .%@

                                                                                                    >
                                                                                   127,&(           3')
                                                                                                    .%@

            5(3/<%5,()'8(       $33(//$17            £

                      6833/(0(17$/                                                                      >
            &/(5.6   5(&25'      $33(//((             £                 127,&(               3')
                      ),/('                                                                             .%@
                                                                             >

             %5,() ),/('  25$/                             %5,()         3')

   $5*80(17         127   $33(//((              £                 0%@

             5(48(67('                                                       >3')
                                                               127,&(
                                                                             .%@

             &$6( 5($'< 72 %(
                           £                     £
             6(7
             $33(//((6     %5,()
                           $33(//((              £
             '8(

             6833/(0(17$/                                                        >
   &/(5.6   5(&25'        $33(//$17             £   127,&(            3')
             ),/('                                                               .%@

                                                                             >
   /(77(5),/('            $33(//((              £   /(77(5        3')
                                                                             .%@

             &(57,),&$7,21 2)                                               >
   :25'       &2817       $33(//$17             £   &(5,7,)&$7(   3')
             &203/,$1&(),/('                                                .%@

                                                                             >
                                                               $33(1',;      3')
             %5,() 5(&(,9('                                               .%@
   25$/ $5*80(17          $33(//$17             £
                                                                             >
             1275(48(67('
                                                               %5,()         3')
                                                                             .%@

                                                                             >
                                                               $33(1',;      3')
                                                                             .%@

             %5,() ),/('  25$/                                           >
   $5*80(17         127   $33(//$17             £   %5,()         3')
             5(48(67('                                                       .%@

                                                                             >
                                                               127,&(        3')
                                                                             .%@

             $33(//$176    %5,()
                           $33(//$17             £
             '8(

   5(63216('8(            $33(//$17             £
                                     75,$/ &2857 &/(5.
   5(63216('8(            $1'         &2857    £
                                     5(3257(5

                                                                             >
   /(77(5),/('            $33(//$17             £   /(77(5        3')
                                                                             .%@

             '($'/,1(         72
   &21'8&7                 £                     £
             0(',$7,21

                                                                                 >
             &/(5.6      5(&25'
                           $33(//$17             £   127,&(            3')
             ),/('
                                                                                 .%@

   &2857)(('8(           $33(//$17             £
             &/(5.6 127,&( 72
   &2857 5(*$5',1*        &2817<&/(5.          £
             67$7862)5(&25'
             12      3$<0(17
             $55$1*(0(176                                                         >
   0$'( :,7+ 75,$/      $33(//$17        £              127,&(        3')
             &2857 &/(5. )25                                                    .%@
             5(&25'
             &/(5.6 127,&( 72
   &2857 5(*$5',1*       ',675,&7&/(5.   £
             67$7862)5(&25'
             &2857 5(3257(56
   ,1)250$7,21            &28575(3257(5   £
             6+((76(17

                                                                                  >
   /(77(5),/('           £                £              /(77(5        3')
                                                                                  0%@

             12      5(3257(56                                                       >
   5(&25' ),/(' ,1      &28575(3257(5   £              127,&(            3')
             &,9,/&$6(                                                               .%@

                                                                                      >
             12 &/(5.6 5(&25'
                          ',675,&7&/(5.   £              127,&(            3')
             ),/(',1&,9,/&$6(
                                                                                      .%@

   5(&25''8(             £                £
             '($'/,1(       )25
   3$57,(6 72 6(/(&7    %27+3$57,(6     £
             0(',$725
             2%-(&7,21        72
   0(',$7,21              £                *5$17027,21
             ',6326('

                                                                    25'(5
                                                                                          >
                                                                    :,7+'5$:,1*
                                                                                          3')
                                                                    0(',$7,21
                                                                                          .%@
   25'(5:,7+'5$:1        £                £              25'(5

                                                                                          >
                                                                    127,&(                3')
                                                                                          .%@

                                                                                      >
             3$67 '8( &2857
                          $33(//$17        £              127,&(            3')
             )((127,&(
                                                                                      .%@

   &2857)(('8(          $33(//$17        £
             '2&.(7,1*
                          $33(//$17        £
             67$7(0(17'8(

                                                                                  >
   2%-(&7,21),/('        $33(//((         £              2%-(&7,21     3')
                                                                                  .%@

                                                                                  >
             0(',$7,21
                          $33(//((         £              2%-(&7,21     3')
             2%-(&7,21),/('
                                                                                  .%@

                                                                                  >
                                                                    25'(5         3')
                                                                                  .%@
   25'(5(17(5('          £                0(',$7,21
                                                                                  >
                                                                                    127,&(       3')
                                                                                                 .%@

                                                                                                 >
                             '2&.(7,1*                                              '2&.(7,1*
                                         $33(//$17   £                                 3')
                             67$7(0(17),/('                                        67$7(0(17
                                                                                                 .%@

                                                                                                 >
                   /(77(5),/('          $33(//((    £                    /(77(5       3')
                                                                                                 .%@

                                                                                                 >
                             &$6( %(*$1 ,1
                                         £           £                    127,&(       3')
                             &28572)$33($/6
                                                                                                 .%@

                                                                                                 >
                                                                                    /(77(52)
                                                                                                 3')
                                                                                    $66,*10(17
                             127,&( 2) $33($/                                                  .%@
                                         $33(//$17   £
                             5(&(,9('                                                            >
                                                                                    127,&(       3')
                                                                                                 .%@

                             127,&( 2) $33($/
                   ),/('  ,1   75,$/   £           £
                             &2857
                             -8'*0(17 6,*1('
                   %< 75,$/ &2857      £           £
                             -8'*(

&$/ (1'$56

    6(7'$7(                                &$/(1'$57<3(          5($6216(7

                                  &$6(6725('            &$6(6725('
                                                                   '$7( &,9,/ &$6( :,// %(
                                  5(7(17,21
                                                                   '(6752<('<56$)7(50$1'$7(

3$57 , (6

    3$57<                                   3$57<7<3(              5(35(6(17$7,9(

    0&&8//(<%5,$1                        $33(//((               -2+1'+(5%(5*(5
    3$/$9$16+($                           $33(//$17              6+($3$/$9$1
    7%:'(9(/230(17                         $33(//((               -2+1'+(5%(5*(5
    %28/(9$5'5($/7<//&                   $33(//((               7,027+<53/2&+

7 5, $/  &2 857  , 1) 2 50 $7 , 2 1

  &2857

  &2&,9,/&7$7/$:12
&2817<

+$55,6

&2857-8'*(

+2125$%/(-8'*(&2817<&9&2857#/$:

&2857&$6(



&28575(3257(5

/$85$&87+(5(//

381,6+0(17

