Court Opinion

ID: 4616368
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2020-11-21 02:34:19.46063+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T07:55:05.980526
License: Public Domain

NATIONAL PROTECTIVE INSURANCE COMPANY, PETITIONER, v. COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE, RESPONDENT.National Protective Ins. Co. v. CommissionerDocket No. 101709.United States Board of Tax Appeals44 B.T.A. 978; 1941 BTA LEXIS 1251; July 10, 1941, Promulgated 1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1251  An insurance company, doing a small life insurance business and a large health and accident insurance business, was required by the laws of Missouri to maintain a reserve for the fulfillment of its life insurance contracts.  In 1935, it entered into an agreement with the Superintendent of Insurance of the State of Missouri, wherein it agreed to maintain an unearned premium reserve upon its health and accident business.  During the taxable years, in conformity with the provisions of this agreement, it set aside a portion of the gross premiums on its health and accident contracts in a special reserve.  The amounts so set aside exceeded the amount of its life insurance reserves.  Held:(1) The reserve maintained by petitioner during the taxable years in connection with its health and accident business was an unearned premium reserve.  (2) Such a reserve is a basic insurance reserve and must be taken into consideration in computing petitioner's total reserve funds for the purpose of determining whether it should be classified for tax purposes as a life insurance company under the provisions of section 201(a) of the Revenue Acts of 1934 and 1936.  (3) Inasmuch as the reserve1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1252  fund maintained by petitioner in connection with its health and accident contracts comprised more than 50 percent of its total reserve funds, it is taxable as an insurance company other than life.  James P. Aylward, Esq., and Terence M. O'Brien, Esq., for the petitioner.  R. P. Hertzog, Esq., for the respondent.  MELLOTT44 B.T.A. 978">*979  Respondent determined deficiencies in the income tax of petitioner in the amount of $10,338.71 for the calendar year 1935 and $5,925.21 for the year 1936.  The sole issue is whether or not petitioner is a life insurance company, within the meaning of section 201(a) of the Revenue Acts of 1934 and 1936.  FINDINGS OF FACT.  Petitioner, a Missouri corporation, has its principal office in Kansas City, Missouri.  Its income tax returns for the years 1935 and 1936 were filed with the collector of internal revenue for the sixth district of Missouri.  Petitioner was originally, on November 30, 1926, organized under the provisions of article 3 of chapter 37 of the Revised Statutes of Missouri, 1929, which relates to "Insurance on the Assessment Plan." During the time petitioner was engaged in business under the provisions1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1253  of this chapter it issued life, health, and accident insurance contracts.  On April 2, 1932, petitioner was reincorporated and authorized to engage in business pursuant to the provisions of article 4 of chapter 37 of the Revised Statutes of Missouri, 1929, relating to "Insurance on the Stipulated Premium Plan." The amended articles of incorporation provided in part as follows: * * * that irrespective of the absence in the Statutes of any provision requiring reserves of any kind on accident and/or health business written upon the Stipulated Premium Plan, the Board of Directors shall est ablish a reserve on reported claims on accident and/or health policies equal in amount to the sum 44 B.T.A. 978">*980  which the Board of Directors estimates will fulfill the policy obligations on all reported unpaid claims, and also set up and establish a reserve on unreported claims arising under accident and/or health policies written on the Stipulated Premium Plan, in such an amount as the Board of Directors from time to time shall deem adequate, but in no event shall this unreported claims reserve be less than fifteen percent (15%) of the total of collected premiums on such accident and/or health policies1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1254  then in force and written upon the Stipulated Premium Plan, or in excess of fifty percent (50%) of the current claim loss ratio on such policies, such loss ratio being calculated on an earned premium basis.  The Board of Directors of this Company shall also establish an emergency fund on life policies, based upon mortuary premiums, if any, collected by said Company after the first policy year, as provided in Section 5764, Revised Statutes, 1929, or with respect to limited payment or investment policies, if any, as provided in Section 5765, Revised Statutes of Missouri, 1929.  * * * * * * Section 7.  The objects and purposes of this Corporation are to transact and carry on the business of writing insurance on the lives of individuals and every insurance pertaining thereto or connected therewith, on the Stipulated Premium Plan, as defined in Article IV, Chapter 37, Revised Statutes of Missouri, 1929, and to provide for indemnity against death or disability of policyholders or insured occasioned by sickness, accident, old age or otherwise.  During 1935 and 1936 and prior thereto, pursuant to its authorization to engage in the insurance business under the provisions of article 41941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1255  of chapter 37 of the Revised Statutes of Missouri, 1929, petitioner issued life, health, and accident insurance policies.  Its health and accident policies provided for cancellation, either by petitioner or by the insured, during the life of the policies.  All of petitioner's business during the taxable years was transacted in the State of Missouri.  The Missouri statutes require an insurance company engaged in business under article 4, chapter 37, supra, to maintain a reserve with respect to the life insurance policies issued by it.  In conformity with such requirement petitioner set aside a reserve fund to fulfill its life insurance coverage.  This reserve, calculated on the American Experience Table at 3 1/2 percent, amounted to $8,337.49, $10,037.89, and $11,841.29 on December 31, 1934, 1935, and 1936, respectively.  On October 4, 1935, petitioner entered into an agreement with the Superintendent of Insurance of Missouri, which agreement provides in part as follows: WHEREAS, said company's charter or articles of incorporation contain an affirmative provision to the effect that its unearned premium reserves shall be computed in a manner or upon a formula at variance with1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1256  the manner or formula generally accepted and used by other insurance companies doing a like business, and WHEREAS, the Superintendent of the Insurance Department of Missouri is desirous that said company maintain unearned premium reserves in an amount more than that provided in its charter or articles of incorporation and equivalent to the reserves maintained by other companies doing a like business in this state, and 44 B.T.A. 978">*981  WHEREAS, the company is desirous of operating in this state and likewise desirous of increasing its financial position by the maintenance of unearned premium reserves equivalent to that of other companies doing a like business, It is, therefore, stipulated and agreed by and between the Superintendent of the Insurance Department of the State of Missouri and the company that the Superintendent shall cause said examination report to be changed so as to require unearned premium reserves in the amount of five (5%) per cent more than that required in the charter or articles of incorporation of the company, thereby causing the examination report to show a surplus rather than an impairment, and the company agrees as follows: (1) To increase the amount of unearned1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1257  premium reserves beginning December 31, 1935, upon accident and health or accident or health business written by the company so that said reserve shall be twenty (20%) per cent of the gross premiums then in force; and on December 31st of each year thereafter said percentage of gross premiums then in force shall be increased five (5%) per cent so that on December 31, 1941, the unearned premium reserve of said company upon said business shall equal fifty (50%) per cent of the gross premiums then in force.  * * * (3) It is further understood and agreed that no dividends will be declared or paid by said company until such time as the company maintains an unearned premium reserve upon its accident and health or accident or health business equal to fifty (50%) per cent of the gross premiums in force and has amended its articles of incorporation or charter so as to conform to the provisions of this stipulation; and it is further understood and agreed that no cash or stock dividends will be declared upon the capital stock of the company at any time except out of the surplus of the company after considering all of the above reserves as liabilities.  In its annual reports to the Superintendent1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1258  of Insurance of Missouri for the year 1934, petitioner, at line 25(a), page 5, listed among its liabilities a "Special Reserve" of $74,459.53, explaining it as follows: The Special Reserve, amounting to 15 percent of premiums in force on accident and health policies December 31, 1934, (37.09% of the unearned premiums) is the "unreported claim reserve" set up, established and maintained in accordance with our Amended Articles of Incorporation, approved April 4, 1932.  In its annual reports to the Superintendent of Insurance of Missouri for 1935 and 1936, petitioner, at line 25(a), page 5, listed among its liabilities the respective amounts of $98,622.87 and $121,114.45, describing them as "Special Reserve in accordance with agreement entered into October 14, 1935, with Mo. Ins. Dept." In 1934 petitioner's premium income from its health and accident business was $590,802.68, and from its life business, $11,738.40.  In 1935 petitioner's premium income from its health and accident business was $636,474.03, and from its life business, $11,647.15.  In 1936 petitioner's premium income from its health and accident business was $658,842.02, and from its life business, $12,911.80.  1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1259 44 B.T.A. 978">*982  Petitioner's books are kept on an accrual basis.  For the years 1935 and 1936 petitioner filed its income tax returns as an insurance company other than a life or mutual company.  OPINION.  MELLOTT: Respondent has determined that petitioner is taxable as an insurance company other than life or mutual under section 204 of the Revenue Acts of 1934 and 1936.  Petitioner contends that it is a life insurance company within the meaning of section 201(a) of these acts and entitled to be taxed as such.  The section relied upon by petitioner, which is the same under each act, is shown in the margin. 1Petitioner contends that the only reserve it maintained during the taxable years was for the fulfillment of its life contracts; that it had no reserve1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1260  for its health and accident coverage and none was required by the laws of the state of its incorporation; and that any designation of its unearned premium account as a "reserve" by the Missouri Superintendent of Insurance is immaterial.  Respondent argues that petitioner's unearned premium account is a reserve within the meaning of the phrase "total reserve", used in section 201(a), supra. Petitioner concedes that if this is true then it is taxable as an insurance company other than life or mutual.  Petitioner places its chief reliance upon Maryland Casualty Co. v. United States,251 U.S. 342">251 U.S. 342, quoting from the Court's opinion the following: The term "reserve" or "reserves" has a special meaning in the law of insurance.  While its scope varies under different laws, in general it means a sum of money, variously computed or estimated, which, with accretions from interest, is set aside, "reserved", as a fund with which to mature or liquidate, either by payment or reinsurance with other companies, furture unaccrued and contingent claims, and claims accrued, but contingent and indefinite as to amount or time of payment.  * * * Reserves, as we have seen, are1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1261  funds set apart as a liability in the accounts of a company to provide for the payment or reinsurance of specific, contingent liabilities.  They are held not only as security for the payment of claims, but also as funds from which payments are made.  Petitioner contends that in the light of the above definition three essentials of a reserve are lacking in its unearned premium account - first, it is not calculated upon any table of experience or contingencies; 44 B.T.A. 978">*983  second, it is not calculated with reference to accretions from interest; and, third, it can not be used to pay the claim when the contingency forming the basis of the insurance occurs.  The quoted portion of the opinion might indicate that the Court would have held, if such an issue had been before it, that a reserve for unearned premiums was not an insurance reserve.  That no such holding would have been made, however, is indicated by the following language: "Unearned premium reserve and special reserve for unpaid liability losses are familiar types of insurance reserves * * *." Under date of October 4, 1935, petitioner entered into an agreement with the Superintendent of Insurance of the State of Missouri wherein1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1262  it agreed to maintain "unearned premium reserves" in the amounts specified in the agreement.  The reserve here involved was set aside pursuant to the terms of this agreement.  The evidence does not convince us that it differs in any material respect from the unearned premium reserve usually maintained by insurance companies in connection with health, accident, fire, and other kinds of insurance, except life insurance.  Its "chief purpose is to enable the company to rid itself of liability for future possible claims when continued excessive losses threaten to use up its surplus and impair its capital to such an extent as may endanger the security of the policyholders, either by paying back the unearned premiums and canceling the policies, or by paying them over to a new insurer to assume and carry out the policy risks." State ex rel Missouri Life Insurance Co. v. Gehner,320 Mo. 691">320 Mo. 691; 8 S.W.(2d) 1068; Trenton v. Insurance Co.,77 N.J. Law 757; 73 A. 606. State laws usually require that the unearned premium reserve fund consist of the unearned portion of the gross premiums on unexpired and unterminated risks and policies. 1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1263  McKinney's Consolidated Laws of New York, Annotated, Book 27, sec. 73, p. 104; Page's Ohio General Code, Annotated, vol. 6, sec. 9362; Michigan Statutes, Annotated, vol. 17, sec. 24.218; Annotated Laws of Massachusetts, ch. 175, sec. 10.  Because of the difficulties incident to examining a large number of policies to determine the unearned portion of the premiums, however, some state statutes provide that the reserve be calculated by taking a certain portion of the gross premiums collected.  Purdon's Pennsylvania Statutes, Annotated, title 40, sec. 91; Heubner-Property Insurance.  That, apparently, was what the Superintendent of Insurance of the State of Missouri was doing when he prevailed upon petitioner to set aside the portion of the gross premiums referred to in the stipulation shown in our findings.  In considering the definition of a reserve in 251 U.S. 342">Maryland Casualty Co. v. United States, supra, it should be kept in mind that the Court 44 B.T.A. 978">*984  recognized that the scope of the word varied and it prefaced its definition with the words "in general it means." The unearned premium reserve of an insurance company other than life or mutual differs from a life1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1264  insurance reserve in that it ordinarily does not involve a calculation based upon a table of contingency or experience, or take into consideration earnings or interest on the fund, and is not usually used to pay contingent claims when the contingency insured against occurs.  It is, however, a basic insurance reserve, a fund set apart to meet certain contingencies, one being the possibility that certain policyholders might cancel their policies and demand the unearned portion of premiums, and the other being that excessive losses and consequent impairment of capital might require the company to cancel the policies and return the unearned premiums to the policyholders, or, in the alternative, pay them over to a new insurer to assume and carry out the policy risks.  In Aetna Ins. Co. v. Hyde, 34 Fed.(2d) 185, 197, Circuit Judge Stone, speaking for a statutory court of three judges sitting in the Western District of Missouri, described the unearned premium reserve of a fire insurance company in the following language: As to the reserve: This has to do with losses under the policies.  Although such losses are the exception, they occur.  They may happen at any time1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1265  upon any of such contracts and should, under the contract, be promptly paid.  The insurer must be always in a financial position to make such payment Good business intelligence and intergrity would require the maintenance of a liquid fund proportioned to the existing risks.  When an insurance business starts, this fund is provided by the capital stock.  State statutes usually require a minimum capitalization.  As the business grows and the total of assumed risks increases, the fund must be correspondingly increased.  Well managed companies carry such "surplus" as seems advisable for such purposes.  Naturally, the management of companies would differ as to how much of its income (including premiums) should be thus reserved and how much paid out in dividends.  To assure a sufficient reservation for the protection of the policy-holder, the States have enacted laws.  The basic thought in most of such laws is to secure this protection through reinsurance in some other and solvent company.  This is worked out by requiring a fund sufficient for that purpose.  As premium rates are the same in all companies - by law or by business necessity - the premiums for the unexpired terms of the policies1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1266  are sufficient for the above purpose.  Hence, the usual requirement is that the fund at all times equal the premiums on the unexpired terms of the policies in force.  To describe this amount, it is called the "unearned" premium.  The balance of the premium is called "earned" premium.  This term "unearned" premium does not mean that the entire premiums have not been earned in the sense that they are absolutely the property of the insurer.  It does not mean that the insurer must take nine out of every particular $10 paid as premium on each policy and set that specific $9 aside.  It does not mean that any trust or agency or other legal relation exists as to any part of any specific premium.  What it does mean is that the insurer shall have and keep a fund of that amount constantly available for that purpose and that purpose alone.  In short, it cannot distribute that much of its assets in dividends nor 44 B.T.A. 978">*985  use it for other corporate purposes.  In order to be sure that this fund is secure, different requirements are made.  Some states require this segregation to be by physical deposit of approved securities in designated depositories.  Ordinarily, it is merely a matter of bookkeeping1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1267  by the insurer, enforced by examination of its books and securities by representatives of the state.  On brief petitioner places some stress on the fact that its unearned premium reserve was not required by the laws of Missouri.  This, however, is immaterial.  Section 201(a), supra, does not provide that a reserve must be required by law.  It provides that a company is a life insurance company if more than 50 percent of its total reserve funds are held for the fulfillment of life insurance contracts.  The fact that petitioner's unearned premium reserve is not required by law does not alter its character as a reserve.  It must be assumed that Congress was aware of the distinction between reserves maintained by insurance companies for life insurance coverage and unearned premium reserves maintained for coverage other than life, such as health, accident, and fire insurance.  Both types of reserves in our opinion must be taken into consideration in computing the "total reserves" of an insurance company for classification purposes.  Petitioner's argument to the effect that its unearned premium account is the equivalent of cash and belongs to the insured has not been overlooked. 1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1268  This contention seems to be based upon the fact that the health and accident policies issued by it are cancelable by either party, and, in the event of cancellation, a definite obligation, involving no contingencies, arises.  Peititoner relies upon Helvering v. Inter-Mountain Life Insurance Co.,294 U.S. 686">294 U.S. 686. In the cited case the Court was concerned with the meaning that Congress intended by the language "4 percentum of the mean of the reserve funds required by law" in section 245(a) of the Revenue Acts of 1921 and 1924.  The question was whether the amounts set aside by the company to retire matured, unsurrendered, and unpaid coupons attached to policies of life insurance issued by it, which provided that the matured amount thereof could be applied to the payment of premiums, be withdrawn in cash, or be left with the company at compound interest, should be considered as part of its reserves.  The Court held that they should not be, pointing out that they did not directly pertain to insurance, but represented a matured liability, dependent upon no contingency.  There might be some substance to petitioner's argument if the amounts reserved belonged absolutely1941 BTA LEXIS 1251">*1269  to the policyholders; but they do not.  "He [the policyholder] has no legal or equitable interest therein.  All that he has is the contract obligations of the company." Aetna Ins. Co. v. Hyde, supra.The reserve is set up for the purpose of assuring the fulfillment of such obligations.  It belongs to the company and is invested by it "precisely as * * * any other monies it may have." 44 B.T.A. 978">*986  We are of the opinion and hold that petitioner's unearned premium reserve is a reserve within the meaning of section 201(a), supra. The gross premiums on its health and accident contracts set aside in this reserve comprised more than 50 percent of its total reserve funds.  It follows, therefore, that petitioner is taxable as an insurance company other than life.  The Commissioner committed no error in determining the deficiencies in tax.  Reviewed by the Board.  Decision will be entered for the respondent.Footnotes1. SEC. 201.  TAX ON LIFE INSURANCE COMPANIES.  (a) DEFINITION. - When used in this title the term "life insurance company" means an insurance company engaged in the business of issuing life insurance and annuity contracts (including contracts of combined life, health, and accident insurance), the reserve funds of which held for the fulfillment of such contracts comprise more than 50 per centum of its total reserve funds. ↩