Court Opinion

ID: 4042491
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:05:44.357711+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:28:39.015551
License: Public Domain

ZL, ¢W/O%OS`~,@LEY Y?IEMEK T`@ ¢?Esq>.»;<'z‘~

'Fu LL“( §H¢>W 77$'£5 CO,_, RT '('HE F¢LLo'v~/ING, *
’f/?e §7747'5 I¢v ;/:T ‘S' A~gwav< 73 KJ:EME/€’s vAz:LD A…>
/?EASO~ABLE QLAI/v\s 774/»1" HE U;TE;> N¢>/\/ H/_=¢PF\)L A~D Nor~)-
T”E> /HREE
IMP@&'r/»~~r FAE~Y /?E LIEF ° ’ > KIEM€@
15 A LAyM/;_~ @F ma LAW `;/`) 77./5 />¢3" A/~\w AIBPAR YIS IN comPL€|E
WIT,,{ /_ITE(QALL‘{ TH@U$;;.NBS @F LA_\N BQOKJ WHICH OMIT THE
RE`FE,QE,Q m ) HE I$ I~DISE~T

711€¢21;¥02€ u~/\Bl_£ To ArFoRD Al\) :L')\)\/ESTIG/+T`(a Tc> SEEK 1/'0<.¢' _

'&` V1DE MCE
/(.¢”"Tz SMTE c/Jasa 7;, A)/vs/`IA/A c.?_.zo~s_ W¥é’ STAT¢"S /AcTIoA/S
-.f'/~/ 77_-/1$ MATE',€ CA/\J 82 \/IEWED A~b ARG-L)ED 771647` Du£ ‘I'o KIE/v\¢;¢?" S
rI/\/A ¢\) r-_~Q\)AL 5-¢311¢€/

PROTE<'T:`EQM 01"` L/+W. _ .
"FTE STATE /~//4$` FAI/_(:'() ?Z'RECGGMZCE 77~/€ }?AMIFI(AYI`ONS OF'

C<>o)oseL‘§ C¢ZRORS A~b I~ >Ome &> 14As comeauch R:LE/v\¢`@‘ S
¢LA:cr~/\S wITH" ma Evroem,e' A~& AA£Q\»ATEADVQ¢.ACY ,

,I)\/£FFEC /”'I\/‘E ,45::§7;4/\/¢1; 13 JUs/” T#/+T, 7§§)<¢)5
CASES 03 @“T/.(z:/zs .. ;'_/TA/ 77/1: mare-z ‘RIEMER Sog>g>LrEs 7741;
f?ECo/ZD W//-TC/v/ T‘f/RQQG~HL`( D£Mo~sT£/Fres /?IE.MER'S CLAZ'MS 774/¥7
TAQIAL Cou/\)SEL`S AcTIO/\L§ WER€I(\/ FA<,T ERE G~l`cws A)\)D CAUSED
/'-//+/€M-- 307/4 / '~>F\’ON&S csv/: 77/£-' ST/?Ia/ 5` . G/?H~TI/\/G 7’/+»4-7' 774¢= R€ £5 T/'wH»'l TO /HE
SA)\/E WzT/\)Ess 577\7”¢'~\€~7“ TF/e vALrD ARGUME~T, wmch W"S
BW PASSED BY Cou~s€; 15 ,3zr1r O/vc)e ~o S'<;AR, MIWBE TWICE,
HOWE\JER B LTC 17 100 Tisv\€$ 0\/€@ Sz:v< PLu§ YEA\<_S- I T f_wll_l_`l
§CAF;_; A~oscA/€ BA“DLEY PERIOD_, A/_s<> P. z. L. 17--/‘? .

/\/o /?EASo/\)ABLE L»~xcuse' 54,\/ ,3<: mA)>e FO/€ c OMNSEL`S LA<:K

¢"_: ®UES'“IONING THé SA~e w;rmz»:ss " F'ANTASTIQAL."‘TES&MOMY
06 COMSEL~`S '\_r\<_s< mr wmw me STATE \KEF€RSTO As “'Ter-\L
STAATEG%" welc.»\ WAS" GRAB“P»AG"AT BEST.

WE S'T'AT'E \~/Iu_ an€ "I'HI§ COQRT BELIE\/E`THAT _'LTS
ENTIRELY POSSIBLE 7T¥AT J;T‘S SAN€ `\/\/I.TNE§S WAS TR\JTHFUL
w»l\EN SHE SI‘ATED me was '\:».>\h»

i?IE/v\ez? ASSERTS 774/rr /+zs c;/+I/v)$ //m/E MERLT AND 1
/4~7“ /?EAS<),\J AB¢F_ mI~D, o~é /vo/' ST@;,Q€D I/\-/ 77:/15 cU/_T<`J;zc»: o/'-"
"_DEN`T` A`\` /\LL COSTS "wIL.L SEE 7746` E/?Ro)? 173 @VE,QALL
T"'mL PREA\J DIQ€ /+,\)D 77/us HEPUTE THE _<,‘7717§'$ Ass~E(QT]_-@Ns
145 /\)oT V-L/’r/BLE

735 rfv~Ic.Ne/< PR,D GF§’/+~T 7/'4€ 35@0,§57§1> KELIL./F/Yé Dé§E‘R\/ES c

l , IS_AW\L~:S i'S. RIENIER Swe`m? u)\)oER PENA.L"F“(‘
C>F />E/? ljvr%`f 777/4r /+z.¢ ¢>F 77-/€ FAQTS HERE.IN HRE TR\)E A~D
CO‘?RECT~ AS WELL, A CL@PY @/:` THIS /?z-;J@:L:NDE(< HAS
BEEN SUB»~\IW'ED 725 me 772an cbsz OM 7’¢4:1:§ DATEi Mp,p`@,H
!Y ) m‘§/'
SIG~ED '7/715' l)?)l`>/W @F MARCH 1057

FE$€E