Court Opinion

ID: 4045029
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:45:27.644313+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:20:40.435675
License: Public Domain

JJ? /"'!a/e :                 MOTION DENIED
          .t:»YIa~ ol/t>-i-t             DATE:     L-f-- 2D- /2             f~'? t:ov4· t~! ~d11/lrYlal
          /1/2~ //Pi                     BY:.PG                            _#pftf/&£/) ~~ ~~};_­
                                                                           /lu~f"Yl/ ·~x6.-~ ?-/ 11
              (tor 1//     -L   I    /                   ·   .
               .r(l/t/t) r@Yirr 1YJ/(trrvt                            //
                                 /ff1 cl /eyt:t/        /\4~ y-

          'N{Zn~e~(/}./- /o f,(Jr;d-~6/e Cbt/r.l./~
     )/-o-u cer-e    /J.#~/?df 14~/f/"Jttl /n#-/ ~"'/VZ.e.#"~vt~ cai/J:/f'o-;4~/ /{"~ /")
/l~c-e-~7?<~ ./-t:J      c;M/'kvk 'iFv-rv~~ l~t/ll f'P/'-Rr v!/Orfc pr/-Ae' ~f/o(,)l;~rY f'~YJ~:
    %k t'l?!r:/-/avvL!"/ra_rd htflt/lR.-Met/r o-t¥rJ f"np/ffe'Vl-1"> 'fc!/';/'1/.e-f f((//.e~·t:r"'ul
cle:r1W /&-djltf/faz~~ ·~"7tffc.f-e4 or ~:/-ra_ I'IJa/cedal ?v;JJ?/f"es- f?v 1'-7#-f
WMrflkvk· tz;J'/l{an.f A/5 vd-4 tfl~ law;. 6e~$t./1Z ~::/fcrM.etl fu~fl/f"e5 :-~·
 tlf"' w-~// ~ t'l'S ~arl/ 6c1./ h~l'lC //;e .?an/!~ f676tl'v10f 6"vfl'/7e~ f? tt/~o
1/5-e.t/ let 1-et~al /tt/'#r vJor/~~            ·
   ftJP? -(/;/"} t/r;/./ fa~ I-/kzer;i 1-1;~:-r- lY?d~P1' -;'vfltf1/fe_> f(v-/.e /') t'/
tf17Jt!    cf#l fl~·Y Ntf/l.flz"'.         ~~~/ f;GM 6?/lr,M/dfJf'~-1/ ~~ /t,(;et?".

      RECE\VEOlN
     ~OFCMMNM.mfA\.8                        uY"/tr~
                                                             -.

                                                       {/. t:ja~;7 jJn 9r
           . APR 13 2015                    /Y/fC/,tz-81 tYv1fl {)1 f &7J/
                                            $?11 j:'/Vf Zo ~t/(
           Abet~,Cierk                      ~1'1 eo/crt)/,~ ?~?lt3@-
      £)(-'   flar/e
    :i!!(crs·    0 ~rze:?                                                   f n /-he 07v4         &tf
    dtJc:d /~ ./o/::27;;q                                                  ~rtfh:nal #~a/~ ,c;~..
                                                                           /lv>I{'Vl;;;;K4. .,- 1g7 /I
                                     C6/4LVo· Wff- Dft&t/ l--&~1-
                            ~1&vr.f ?k~ #a~ Q-1-tr~"30/119'-C

     f!jlf/ljcqr~r~ ;'Vfol-[oP1 {Or ~&etlj f(evoCA/f;:;i/7 ~cr ~l-'7fa I t!/1/:'atl'l.r Moi/Qvt
 1-cJ CC/f/Y-e?.>t a~P'Icl ,./-a Rei/Oj(e h-e "9faavr tli>M(>~~~ ~Yld 4'eif&itV;7f,_-
~
 /!e~ '&-~.fer j f1/-o .M!s-   .
                                     /!"Y/rfc/ ~ur/ h tl rrv/{y;e-9 c;I/ICBfM[P$9 #e c£bove-
                                                                                        .

 ~/. ttvt/ t/JV114bf!?reo/ C'at/~~"r a~ ~II :5-" clve ~2?(~~

                               ·-'1CJ/11-e   J(/#{ &r<;;al/COoed-:

    (&f'Vl!!!$" 1/lcJuf td.:l/d-) U-6'o~e;? Af?/fi&M./ :;, rli.-e d&V'e ~1-/-l.etl a-r~tl
nur-t-Mr-et:l c4rr~ <:: tZi/lt/ '1"'-e;fic,//v//f /"'fe? f/e-r ./4{"; ~7/9"""/- ~ ~ra:nl- a ~e't£?cif­
 f!'ei/o//'a/i"tfYJ o/{~/r(cl ~1/r~ cky7fal ./t:t etfP!/ar~/ f'A6/fc;r~ ./--.? so///l~~U"~ /!);_
.rrfq ·Co-v-r-1 ?'-€?'0r-tntft•/lp/S'" .A, ol~/\--1;5.> /-v· Ct;:'fl/R'at/1/ a ffiff{./. ttP/'/F~e1
 a/2-rl ./-CJ ?'e'vo/("e   ./he~.> c//?'H7;J:Q?/' tt~ well /~                c/t,AR-   t/nckr /h.e ?d'ilh
 ;.1-~i/1./~t'?n.f auol #~l?t/k; C:,.._/'~c#'/(vle> II? 173" r/.5'rC-4·/ tf!P?ol al~o /lrrl/c/.ur
 %J7C:CJ.,. rr-4..c .. c.;j7./ '21'~~ t/242/~ffaJ,N.x.. wttiaf"/"f..f/roc..4,r~,.:? ttYJc/
 ~YJ.,k-r /t? a ~re..eo(/ '}"ltt/cJ&--kt/1 tti?ol ,/o r-etfoke ~./f6" e/fi'"fr1(~/ !n .fk.e
 tl6dvr.e 5""-t//~/ anol nt/M~J?/ {kt1'9'e/ ~t~cl /YJ -;-d;J/)tfrl- .P-j- ./6(~ rvttJ-If~V?
'/1-///fC£~1-        ~/;g~,~
                                             r
   /i ev;la~ra/ «/;~/ /'5 a: va!la6/e jttr v;rc,ltt/rCJn~ tfl~ ,?'ttti,flv!~r cr.;~e. ·"
 f(u/?5 II; let c/,->.. ?·/1,/ wAfvlz -rtzyrfr--er -!41 tbv~~ ,t-c; fl~I'"So.Yivt//j/ f"Y1fdrM
cle/~vzcla P?.f/~ t9tf ~~r/-afn .:sfoc!jt~t/ r{p!JI' anc/ /ldX;"fl/~ t!&n>ef"/.e'v1Cer krf-r~
&'?'ef'lfn~ #vft1/ jlka/ tf?;1/f whtf'P1 :-r~/riz-c::i/;,pt !'~ (v-wclan~vt.kl ~t:;f td!~h
 (;1h.e~T~t'1.fl/ -rt!?~i/)k    k     {b~/e.;e ~azrfia~e t?~ Jc/>./{;?'t! ~r tPfVIr;;·sicJLIY1
 fnc&~fi"f"F../-&171/-- v.t/f, .f71dfrvt~tTJitt.rd dervtaf'lo/) t:P--r Afr jlu;cec/vrr~~ ~­
 al~o                            .
          (/&?~~~A"' wm~ ~n#nc/,g; £_q- (/,             «f'.c;;,;?.   y.22-cp~
                                             -I-
    ,H?~al f{if/.b<'""      &/ t= dtvti/lt!{l jlroc~tl'v~
                                     7
                                                                 whfclz ra;U~frz_> c:rv~r 1-o cf/vvl,J--<-
Mti(/)t/Mtrr/         M!YJfrvtU;Nt       /~r?a/d- t2rld tv?d)(/",vtvrt (lo~ll~ /~1/l«l(/ /rr /.e~-tc/a.­
t/Jf'f kfo~          acce;1/:P1y If~a. ~5 ffo/ ei/J~r-tflttt~> ~~{/l~es tJfft%s-!J/~
c:IRfll/rr~t:~-t/1 or &?!C/1'/bP'? .. r-eel~ f'? ~/ {'J/1 c;/.e~0/{;/lc# /-u
fled tfc!~ -U/tJt.,5 V?¢" ra/"":-r~ol ~/ife jdf"/v,.e. ~fVZ                        Ar,
                                                                         cr/./~Tnif C/:lrv
flt?t:uc~ td/11 ;::~c/a;t'v/e~- CP'rjJ1""'(7C. f(vk~ //;~/6 l/e'5',.C0/·

                                                  JlL
     pale       tbt/#5- fla>~ov'ri?e/Vl~~ &n tifa[v~r d/- c&m-1-ffvl/dYJal ~I
rbf171 6~a[/-f:c &a.c-i t'ai:i' !f'ejNF~ ~~/ckr~~t/1 .&/#I.e/1/Gtr./:VZ~ pc/P-r>
cz(/-liotifh ./h~J te-rre norl- -~c/vr;'V~/t:PI-h~ 1~111-h t?;:/-h.e oielaf-;c:2.JI-he'
'/'t!tl>tJ/1~ ~/lit!' dii~f;ti)l-h--e ~fl/iu:tl'?.f?' Cl~>~-r/f;:rr~ tP;L /It~ -r[f/6/>;"(Jl} tJ'/
rfA.e t/k'/t{c~ uvv-.f$· ·'Y"e~a/V?MJ /avlfrtdl~ ./-o-· ?Z/tf'lia~VJ~/> ar~t! l@l uvd -t?r~tl ij-·/lC-~-
~~I'ff"r~c!J ~;?;l/?Can~> f/&t<.. tYtftf v/liY f)l/iiurul- (v//f lr?jfffr;~~ //1/d rJA-e~
rh~Y t't/f'//'w~i/7/ -f'P?'e(t7t'-d ~p-ec/~ve tJL7'f"JS'.hzr~?~ 11~ t:fx./n~~ f) ~f"/1;1
/~_/~;t~cf~ /lie f'roJz;!;l;dP'l /i/J /lr--.1, ~Q:Is{$~ v;/l.~c:fP~/ f-it a./ ~tflk-a. tJ~
fi'U//I:J Y/l9,f- ~e t'l?C.e//-ecl C/;1/e.~s / /(> Lfr..e~ vrr1cl Ve;li/Yl/t- Wee~.
./A{s" ~cc/tJ-r i?"" tPt/le /V'ltp~ /rl1tJCA/ iVJ Var~t7J (j/ ~uclt C~5 ~>~clf'7C'nr_
/'4{nc(__I/(,P'1' @1/l/jf frr ./-t.JJ-e. ,./)j~-&/7/-- 11-'rul Ad~/}()~     /"'ftPrL,e,l /o   vrv~r vi Ci
        .                                       .n_
                                                  -~                                           '
  ~K/o-4-iorJ        d?/ Cu-t/:/1~/~ vu       6el/~ V<- /-ha./   C/t/rY jocv)/   //5 vJe/1   ttr /-hal
!/ /-~e Ma-l           ?(Jvn~/; -&licn/lr/ le tJYI wl~/-/z.~y jJvr~/o~;vl tl!'~~!0irlct/io~
 lift't)   ~,-./a///->'h6tcl ·1/JA~tYJ UJI/Il~/~fa~-r t/./a~ /ttlti'~t/ /-li~.f Pj'/'/:Can; (/f/.t/
 ~/Ju·crlc/ /lttl-   ht'ZIN-   J'4~r! tJ.-~?#c/rt~/~

                                                    v
    the    ~/)CA,rh #M~~vv?~t:fC/Cl~t~/ /-o /!Vl ~?,/~/ tPtf j-/ie ~;,.;. /-o
tt ~e.etl# if'evoca/.:-d"~ ;$- j'v-f//oltfl-~vthtl«t:~/ltl >5" ir-tjJ~/ f,)t ~J?e ~ j?Yc7-
?:e5") C'ht-(/R ~tf ./he ~f/rltP~YII/J ,4-~i/lcl""ec/t.f &n Ike ~Ak->/ u.fCt{w.Y' ~tf
a fun/a_M-~~1 ·0Arl ~/1A .fYJa#l:Y/l/ k .l/JtOrl~:-r.f.e~l t.N[I;, .j!J·.e r/YJfld
(fa/.e5- ~t/f'!"'e~·e ttbv-45 /WV!t:lt/f/lC~/'A~i///-> &VI Wa!ver ~~ ~/JY!f:/-lfbr1Cf/
 r{g!t./-F; 05"-&~--4MgYJ~.,. V~X/V.f&x.O,n~;41J"Iii§Jo/ J,tJs; rq·~rfo ?!t';~r _:
/'17:JC·;4nY1~ /lo-w-tV~t/ /te?'le :~a l/'e't<>DP1tt$N fJfiFba/flfi;Y 1-k~. ~uf (6-rt'ovn-
 b(l/ W/fff.g~Fk y;t'fl/         #vr(jiJ'?i ./-}-e fY6r.rlk t!/ fAe f11s/'t?-·e/f1) tr/ou/cl h/tV..!
 Ji¢~-r? t!!f{fr--&h ~ at?t!/.~u~/#.-?.1 ~UfflorlftJr ~ /!rJ/f'?Y t!Jf cP(/f/11- /?flO·
 v(t/#1 /Y- i. ~"rt.e jac/! ~" CJy tlp'/ f &v!ci~Vl#e &I ?t/1 ./-t~ tl6r't~-7'1tl t/r ~;?{et/
~i;J!ll{azwrr Mo/f;;rr~ ,f(J ~ofJ;l~>~ b!ol ,j-c1 a '7ft?.ec/j. ~Vt~co..fftJt/2 ~

                                                   VI
    Fiy;a.f/fr wt~-re ./-/l.e,-re /r- /httl ~J?fl:{arif~ (e-ttl ,fh~ tlf:zrf~a/R;-p'?·
ancl f/~re vfola~-r lA~ 6~~/i 4Mf?r~clrv1~/lh (ov~-elt!ft:-7h· ,4-n~v/}ol~~ rkn-
chrcl.>;. (t~r/lcltt?cf! !_, V--5.C;'r4•f~ !&l~s.- tJ~ tfo~'Yt{/ /l;1d ~.kt/tg 1/t(/f/) a6t~-i/~
 f\1.~~~-~lJtY1ep, 6ecatl~ ;.r;al (dv~/-ttt#drrJ-ejl jP'{/£1. /-o refV>tf.l/o ~u6-
 (Vtfl f't//6/(o/l ./-o ~v,4)1~~r t/YJdt:Z(V-R~ l-o P'tf/1//?i/rJ~ cf/"~r!all'l ~~lf~ti2
tlf$frl-arl?e tJ!n/jl. ;.ec&f/~ ;zpf)I!Ca,1/'f' vf/a5" Molfje?~l) ttYJt! uvr~~l-c-tl­
                                            '.T
/o-r;?~'f ~p /o Rff{~d:" doi11/~ !/Ire vJo7/c tA.Wh f'ncl{jttP1/f~ ;1etJ~
 fie') b~?at/~ :? iintf- .,h k~ Mjt If'M.e/ 1/v/;t?r~ f /,~w #1/,~y.; CI(&--"A
 / 0 Whtt-'5' t· ~A~>ulol be ./o lf'f"'NPJ /ectwee .1-h~/ ftctl,;a(c/ fuY ~~--
        .. /   //
 ";)'.e!T'v/?e.

                                              -?-
"

       f r /'"~   fdY   rh~ aaSotY~f              /'tfal ~ll'> h~Yltrra_ll~ tcn/,y-.J-~%orr/c/
er1-le·r ;~/o cc rv-/11J tJr? 1-A~ aiol/~ ~k~- av;cl YJvr-4/;~~ ca~
~tl ft? a: 5j}--8e-t{y ~Vot1a/hV1 .-1-o d6?p'Jdz/ 4/'f/(a¥/il- tvto&t/1 .1-o >U/'f·-
 !f!E!5"$""_,. ~r:P1t! c£15"cJ ./-tJ 'Y6?Va("[e 15fa./vr c//j-'}IV1.(5'~cf"' f-crr/--A-~,::e ·'t/{'o/CA//o,-J5
    t'tho·v~ /V1tt~lfttv1~d u/il-/1 .M-.e ac/f#tT? cl~ /lYld r{'~;,~l