Court Opinion

ID: 7277822
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-25 20:02:18.651369+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:18:56.651954
License: Public Domain

Mr. Justice Van Orsdel
delivered the opinion of the Court:
Appellee, Laura V. Donaldson, plaintiff below, secured a judgment against the District of Columbia for damages for personal injuries resulting from a fall. In her declaration she specifically charged that the accident occurred on a sidewalk where defendant had negligently left a “precipitous descent, or incline, unpaved, ungraded, and unguarded, and dangerous to persons passing” thereon. The evidence disclosed that the accident did not occur on the sidewalk, but on a path leading from the sidewalk across the parking, and temporarily used by the public during a period of snow and ice, to avoid passing over the place described in the declaration. The variance between the allegations and the proof is fatal. The motion of defendant for an instructed verdict in its favor should have been granted. The judgment is reversed with costs, and it is so ordered.

Reversed.