Court Opinion

ID: 4055192
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 06:42:54.34159+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:05:32.508537
License: Public Domain

§1§§©§1 111§51;1§§§ 11_' 1AR 15 4
§§§§§§§§§§§ §§§;i§§§§§- ' 1515_::1¢1<115§11515
._.' ' ' ~ ~MAYIN /\/\111-1¢\15L 111\11“1` _
' '§§@11§511@§@,©1@1§ ` ~ 9115@<1 15_/'15`51054/
' ' ` l TENNE§€`EE 601111\1~/=115><£1§
‘ ‘ . 5 1 ~ '7'5-“3"3'@ -
TO -_THF CLE/€I< 1")1-`£011/£'1' ~ 1 ' ' ' ' _-

 

IE)_<@_S_Cou/LL@L~ 5@1/5\11\1111__/_4.€19£.41_5
190 1010)< 1515_02<
AUSTTN_ IEXA% ’73’711
DEAR 313 1
EN_CI_O_§E_D_LS A QQP\/ 015 m\/
mEmo,rz_F\Noum 405 1_Aw THAT QQ_QQQUES \/1/111-1
_115_>_<.155_1_2111_5_0_15_1_4§_13_1§_&1_/11_' 9R0c1:1;)111115_7_5
3 ' l 1 111513 A1\1 /591>111;1=11101\1 15012 \1111;1_1_ 0_15_~1_-111_€_>151\5
. _1:_0_1_2_1>_115 @1\1 11 015 14 1115: Q15115e 1\10 134444§1_- 15
-M_+L\Jl1§IR1CT 6501111‘1 1~1/-11&@1% C_o_111\11~/ TE>< 4/(551 i(OvSTON 115)_<#15..7_7.2__10.1 AL5© '
551\1`1_ 14 ___ee» 1H15 :/"“1-1:11 650101 1515 m\/ 11115_1110_12/\111311115
"`_1<31,-:.,'.:<.. ~'~-150 655/113 0/~\1\111515 emc-0 0111 ¢/-¢/ 2015
1'-' 120/11 THE /Y11c1~1/11:1__1,11\11'Ij_2\é164/1?M _52054/,
TENNESSEE COLON\/,TE)111“ nw 115151
_ON m\} 0(,§-+(}011\1<'7 /V\A(L]`_
TI'W'N(< YDU~€ ALOPH'"\‘Q|] RCQL\/'

 

 

 

CAus`E qui$¢=£ ‘/V‘/‘/‘?' :C- _ I`NLH 1015de Cour'€"r
1 § . oF
1~;)< FAiaTs wiuiA/~\ cameo manson §Agg_gi; ;@QMTITQAAQLE couch

 

5u5mi15 ‘r HLS{'H\S.\ w k _

STvi_F.D mo i§\i,imcsi.izcn cAu5e~_£,._wm§,,§i/>\Nb Bi;F@izEw\si+e~oeAei.c
AFPLICANT ,L-_ng@i§g__ wii_i_ 5\-\0»¢ 1…5 Hit>No(eA5i.F. £;c)u.e:r_

AS FOLLOWS° " `

 

 
     

§ ‘_,,, . ,..:_ ". _` '.|,4 \;:;
'\i.\~',:-.~`--J,;'*_1 § g gm .1_. _~

x
l

/-\PPL¢cAm gamma Fi'LCs 'TH\S(\~\\S) \~\ABEAS \A/5\T 945wa
70 T)~\c`: F55vi5\QN5 oF VERNON'§ ANN TEXAS CODE OF C(Z\mmr~\L_
P£Qc\=_ouac, 91~\Ap1'5211 A51\c;LE ’)'\.97,
;:»' k \,|L,\,N EV¢DE_MTi/_\@§ HEAR!NC, i5 WA55Ai\iiE.D, AF‘PucAuTHA&&A§Q.N_
QESF'ECTFUL_L_\/ uRC:E§*THIS HONo§LABL,tATE.)\s Loum' 9!=
umw AL APPEA£L,s» ii@.~“-_»_saoea -T‘Hi; m max 551 90¢521,

y 5~‘ ` 951»»>
draw `x'\-OF ,.,` .j.

   

55 `mv,»-i-`LF;€.)¢‘\©LE.`€ E:"RECM;B 061 'T'H»-L; Ev;DE__NT\AQY 66656§£6-6~1(¢ 662 9'\/\'6’;5.
AND Tleammmr_b{smhc TH‘\$ Hc’>~oro‘\€>z_¢; 15me Cwm 05 ;Rxl~\mm_
§
A.€>Pgm 3

_*/
56699066‘6`66\60 OR\C,mA\_. w HABEAS Wrm 66va P,E\=oRC-TW$
HON<>RA@\_E LQM:L

3

j §E.€L.M_.E’.LEADLBC§.
TH§ STATES 05606~/66. Amswr~;cz" ANo THE mm 55 P(aopc>seo
F6N06N05 05 FA<;T C0w66u5606\\5 05 L.Aw mm emma (AND
j ADO¢>TED 66 mg 6666M. goua~r mo 355066; Tms Howo¢meu; comm
k 65 No'mmc, /\\0626 THANA mem; sTANoMo Forzm’ TH/\T§ 6656=0
1096sz 631 THE HAQru$”Cou/~m 565TK\6T hTYoraMC-¥S(oFFmE) 6\\6
§HA!S|;AS wm‘r§ AND THAT PA\L§ 60 /\06>6.>;555 '6`~HE APOL\¢ANT _ `
ABEA§ wm-T, _
4 3~ l
AFPL!.CANT H_Ar&r<\§g` 65'A '6_/`»/ PER§QN ANO 65 marreng
666 THE 56666>~/ 06= 1666 mw 666>6>666/=6661 h AR@_\§_¢)_N _566<>66666 mm `
BE 6~6€60 To THE 565/we 5Tr<605m 5'66\6~6066660 oF 9656\066665 A5 76wa
06= AM macmeo 60666~656=_6. HA\NES \/ \9666Am uaw RE,SP_EcTt-'w_u/ 662555 TH\S l~\om¢aaeu§ Coom‘m
cmsTauc Tms /"\¢;/\'\ORANDW\ 66GERALLV /\Mo m TH€ w_6~6~6,_62656
`_ OF ~‘_56651666¢ ,_]`~__d_

 

   

P 5 T\ _
A»°PL\.CANW .ABH.@L$QN.SHOWS mOF‘PC)wT(cN A.S FOLLo\/¢s_.
t APPUCANT '9\62 g\§,oM__SHc)v\,.‘/.$ 5666?6:6€~6ENT .SPEC\HC, FALT$_

_ E§;f/NBLISH\NG THAT '\HE cwia@em" \5561€$) ¢0060 N¢-r HA\/E BE(;N

 

@

f DRESENTEO-anvaous\:/ @EcAu-.s‘.=.._,;c>‘r'~ ~/EAKS oF UNA\_/A¢LASu-.\TY-

/~\ Suas.Eau§.m HA&&As.v~/R\T Fsu;u\.o No~r €»!Aue 05¢2,~¢ DRESENTED'.uNTwL /-\u. TH& xSSu€s

¢j

f
ij

USTEO m T|.~u§ l-i~/`""‘\BEA$ Wra\‘r \/~/s~\r-.‘ez§ .@FO<§NC», carr AND L':>R"IE_S E,N\PLG‘/C-D 6`/
THE Hc»usToN CH¢”T A /'\ocl Tz;mj Jchcm\. SYSTE,~\
TH/-\T THE.l:lAK@_L§ Coum DtS'rma Avomer(gr¢=md)~s Cc)mmws\_v
/W\KPNG ? 1

A CONST‘KTUT|GMAU.‘L eues°rsvom\§_.. '. -` - “ ? ,, .
BE'CHU$E THE F§°\CUAL O?/fWD L£ML BA‘:`=:§> FC»@ T‘I`&&€ ¥Ssui€;‘>§ NQ\J €p's$(~{)
87 ,¢:AAPPL¢ m M~_*_~`_>_§M_ ONLY B>ECM\@ /\»\4\.0&`» szuc, ANO @E<;Am; 6=\»\~/\@.=
0¢=) Aumggc.e T<> /\pouov§r HARQ\&Q»A Fo¢a @@e_$er~frm\rm 765ch THE CO<.~<¥(S§
/\s n ¢<’c~s¢:\.r oFA 1 ` _ _§ =é$ DUGUSHED sSY THL
/+ous‘;c>~ <;Heo~acu;~ /NcwsPA¢>c¢z) 552 AL:,§ L¢:~;;‘~\ FAL\Q~,N Bua_IZl-m‘r @EL¢CF BASED Om‘n+\s (N$TANT HA(SEF\§ Wg'r \/€£NON_'S

  

 

»ANM TE>£ 05 CF|N¢NN. DQC>CCDL;@E CHA("T E£ il ¢*@T'Cé‘L-‘- !\ 07

§ H(A)

/AF’PL)C/~)~T lj?-Qé:l`e§om {ZA'¢$E.§ ‘T`H1QEE»(3)‘_C6N1STiT‘UT xo~.':\z_. nssm;§`
F()/& ,Q£La&£= m '?€~!;$1'HnBEA.:~'me,-ANA`Co.\;$T'."iu?.\o»i.§;esiw_c~:;»' /~‘0/3 £EL\€F.
AS,FDL¢,QWS.‘. 1 " " ` ' . ` 4

       

 

E>
(1)..1' 55551~11>12'1,~\1:.111 1311_;___1;0 1111-1115 131`11111:):11111\/ 51/5'1'1;-/~5’5
;,_151 §11'211&5:(`1'\¢1/0 $E.QAG.¢\TE `I.ucs§/ARCQu/“\cm531,1110€!2`1'\“5
_SUBJECT),‘ ANO(Z_) . ., INEFFECTWE A5s15'v1\1~1c€ oF COLM~\SCL_
,{;.1`012:2 01)1111¢; 1116 A.FTEQ. Tr;11:11.. 1}_`-{.¢-':1~€.1:.1:-131115(5).

111/11 TH.E 15111~11111¢5,~15;1;1 1512.1.~.,511,51>1;15 51=~1115 1115 1>125111111=_1)
lNDiCT/”\EM BEFOR€. THE GRANO 3'1.112`\' 011@111\16"\`\~1\`£ I>‘EL.1@,ER/th0N
{_MQ;§__L_!E vL:,QS.ES T!?..z£ 15121'.'_\ 1111`11115 1211/155 W/~\€» 9*1\1;\'/151\1/12,2
P¢:E».;mmce 1110 11111,¢1/111\_1~:11>1'2~1 1’ 01;1>15 1,1.=;1"1“ TH& G»(€Mn 3111-xv /xwr>
RESGLTHN@ 111 *rm; 15 511:-11~121,;. 155 ,/x F1./1M/1z5,c\'!1\\1111::1'1'\1;51\1“1’,.

IT 13 111 1°1.111151-\/11;\111‘1111~1 gum/an 155111121.11111.3
‘» w ~E§;FC>.QE `1`1~.11'_ 612111.101 sum/215 1-11'111;11~11' 11112 P!°E\:umcc. 5

E-.NHmce/m=s\y~r 1’-’11\1<11&1”~.111>11_"> 1~"1`\"&311£>1€;1§1`3 1111-2 5@@1\1\10€51.112~/.§51-'\€/\?211\1€.
/~\ND Qesm:m m 11._._, FLA~}`»/eo J:_ND\<.T/v\c»m FOR T`\»\E FOLL@WH~\-c¢
1251:‘10115; 1(6111.1> SHOWS\//x C_1§1/“\1111'x1. F"CTUQL <;~1~_ /-\PPuc/M'S
Pmo¢a l_H-`E 1 5'16‘\'115: ?_(/>1116" _51_51 _") TH/x1 111111€11~1' T<:) 55 /x
5 5 _»-_» 1111 €ELNE.QN_"Z AND 5 /x-R.E mcsz 1111/110 ov.EN ALLEC~.A‘Y\.<)N5
OF AOPL¢CANT'$ PR5\6{2 §§B=g_('_;,§{_\,,\f\g 5`\`/-\3;2115 a ,

,"1."1 15 1?>¥0-1~11) 1'.)6'.16°-".'1:`-1\6‘1 APPL\£ANY \5.1\5 01~1\1'11_0 TW§
OPPORTU!~MTY (.D-_E FEN£,_E 1.'~\1>.15 1101 6511.~.¢ 11111.115 1151 /xLLOv_~/EG 210 BE
PR&$z;m 1311:.11211~11~ 715 611116 -311,12~/’5 1~11'§.>1111111:,, 1116 To ‘1 1515
COM`TRAH`/ THE 1313`1’1'.<‘;1;" 11T\<>111~1&v 6&11~1(~, I~\.\,_LQWED To 615
109251_1\1~1 1311:1=1:>1; ‘1'1~11:; 612/1119 501-11 5 141211121116 1150 To
_Tr“@&_ CONTRNLV `THE. 01°>"1’?~!"1 AT\`C\RNEY P>S.£¥NC'»_ ALLCSWEQ T€J
P."~?ESENT AL,L(: Achms 01=_ __ , ,‘) '1'.0 31qu 1363 CCT\C)NS TO THE
PRESH\azf/cmow 01 1115 ( P 651 p’Rf'=;_-;PARED .I~N'D-\C:`F/"\ENT

   

 

 

  

 

 

 

942€5&4\435£) TO 399 CRAHD 34)9\45 L\EAR\NQ, 454 3444=. D\<~ \9\»4
A'»Toawev) ENH,'~\NC.E/~\E-.NT 944@44 542444°445 443 395 »449~»424445¢:.4‘4444.€994¥£>4344€`4.

Tl'-‘E - §N‘€~W\ZCGME 443 4°/-\99439/>.¢°4-45

PQEJUQ\¢LD 395 CfE.P 44\1 C'..R.u\'.__\mA\ <`,/»\54;5 4(TG
3444-; 4;4344442/441.'>1 mci 544444444 Uu44j1_ 5753 ama 44444>!4442444;.553 115
43£4.:444455 43 434~<‘4’9<4 9544‘4~445414¢<4450' 34444@545 ~\'444454'»~;_\3495 4'>44~4£>,' _ .'
' § f@m\m mmi§ 1542»<-: 4959454:4 Wm~. 04:<,44>\444,
W!~.$&"J`HER E.NOuGi-i l:...\~./iOCNC,G E;><%S`“

 
 

 
 

30 4~»4444443 05 449 944 INDKC”\LNY,

44/4~4\4:444 /~\ Lows 99054`59443095 39 69 FOF°\CLD \W“ C‘““'“"“\L

. CASE. _
*EJECAMSE 4‘;4.5~` 399sz 4~’3&4¢4/&34‘1 \:')(~:'~`\ND GUFL")"` ~> f'_'lN_~& "~/~!4_¢£~LD +'94€\1_0

THE 354 .‘~-~'?4&<;~\/ 09 3\44.' 4 "<;904 CS:`~», (14143\9 5 949\4'.';°-.°~ LC:,_\\¢c»-.~ C.G)’~?.»§"UM&D

OFTH& 4444;.4< 09 4>»44,'%;4444 444 4~\.4.@4;45 <;’®444444 '.5 ~G994443 751-494 S~j"_'
CL!!P, C~,."lmm 3444‘<4"5 34404.»4.0 §44»L4~c3 344'4; 9&944493’4€344" GF __ng
Cc)w\¢v\;. 595 cTr-_G 444 44 444/54 50 444/44 »"-~\444_,(04.442..)R’E=’l`)l®\?~\\€`??>
19€454_ `4` 44/4'4 395 _,‘4'53&4'94 45 3004¢4454,4_\/ LE(:»»‘\L 990‘» 'N,O\;"_"
. §,4¢:;>-4_»434\¢4; 09 04444~. 99<~£ 555 454 4-/=~.4443 49949.,' 7 `
PEKH.AQ§ 344\5 446>~54<994_4§; Cc»um` \/~.¢44.4__ com'¢,= 340 m\m
`,4'~\’§44`4,4 ER _/¢~.4 65444.£:4.445…44 344»;4‘ 9;"4.~\/ 4~4;4L,¢\4\C 44 09 Qw€_; 99(‘4/4~ SS
OF ~.L/-\W.z;,. Q'u.gg_;; (JCQPLC
v¢550 A:z.s; 57555_/55;5<:.5/55__;~/ 15\15)€5>5;..~50 3555 ,

GRANO gum moce&omcgs AQ.Q $,-Ef_rzr-.:T .5~=~.¢3 TH,ER\;-. 53 Nc R\<==HT
C)F C 11335~5"><¢\;»\5.\55'-\"555,5~5(”c>:\rr¢z,u,T
guamch 5ch GRANQ °?ure_v_ 5>5353§,&33 I.NCLUQH~.~§C LE§A\_. R~§; ~'
7S»EA°~CH \)~/5755\5&.53 lm€r> vs c_W Am) DEAL-n~xc=, W:T,HT\A;-: ,

. fea/25 mo 952035... army o~ 13 (’~5<0/=.5:, QMCI:_ ¢55: 5<:<<5;»5§g ‘:3,}
I."\i /.~\N /\P.EA 353 LA(>Q.E A3 HA?{L\_:> ;c5»5\575 Y (6!1&»£3 3uP\E5
\N 5_5§@@13 5@55555‘¢ TvP\cAu>./ ,~\e»=‘v 1500 SE\/&RAL 550<3.§3 A 5.>.'\\;

_| Two 535-553 /1\ wce\< Fe{a 7555525~:57~ /\~'~5‘555-)\-\0550525:0 05 Fg;LoNY
` lNBsc. .Mr'm$ ~\.A~./ 515 535\55¢:55`0 f?»:,»m~x 535 53 frame 7553525 \/\55553
LeTTt § /‘N;\R;- 551,¢\55 A; 9 <.F_ 5=555355051\1 5’~’-§<’.\75/=55\05\5 cpc 75ch
A\,LE.¢:»/-\~rzoms (PP(\/A'Sw» f°'?cTua\c/-za_ /-\5~50 °\`..N'=t.w»\~\mom'
§Q,!§.,§>CEQ B~/ 755\5-_ 0535¢25¢.5 1\550¢>5.55§~») 35 53520&1;<.5_557<3@5
(Pe?nchmoas \L:/

~‘ \/OLu/\FTEE£S CIM»QRCNTL~/ `!`HE CRU‘(\\NAL I)'us‘mc£ 5\'<75 E-.~\

' 51 HAPM> mm HA$ 355)55\ /~\Nr> 53 355 15 3'555<5.~.5@ TRPC_¥E3@RY)
H’z; 3\/555/\'5 ;»'~551 315 N\AN¢PULNED 1351 COMM, 3350555;£5

\\

 

 

' T§F_mp§~§=.o ~ro P§r_§< 2204\4§2"3(,2§~§»§).023‘§')'/§4§\§0 n §\§mracw 5§_§¢2
OF 50¢/.§2`§\/ (A'r §32,'3‘§). T§~§§s 445 A goN;:§§zm§;o CAsE '0F T§~§E
@§vL-A D;:§,~\N HUN@EQ 222 `§'>RG§`)EC_§I‘§' §C§§~§ /-\"§' 2-§§\§‘~/` C©ST,
REGAROL255 OF »“»’§2§)"§§~§. 52 LEC-,.A§_§`§\/,

522 § §©§§5§0§~§ <,§-§2<‘.§\4§2§_2( §\§2§/¢5§>.<§222), C\`§‘//5"§)‘~<§E
SEC`UON-L S-\"%§§'§D/-¢i z-\u{">§-.§S”} ._)O, ZU§L§
§’H)".§§` §§§2 § §§\§ §»‘gj'§§°\§§§ Cc>u§\§rv x 6

70 §`J§c§< GRHND 30420§23 35 §§§22' 202 )\2>§.§32 mm §=AVG§§§`§§<;`/~'\"» _

_ 2._}\\/§/4;0 §§O§c§§"‘\"-‘~ §§§_ 452526 024”§§§2 L>§§AM§> 3§)§§§\§

S,VSTUWS L,§§\§§~/'\§QN¢E>_>

' f ;C): _
TO BE ENT§TLED To A _NEW‘§'§§§A§_ 132320 02 A§§

4_ INL-.§~FECTWE A:»s§S‘-§A§\§c,€ 02 COMNSLLCU§/\A(D2§=§:§§-

' \~ ~~"G¢\§\§T') ¢Aus`§' 5§»§6\~/ 6`_/A PR§;§°C)MDERANC§, _OF §HE EV§DC-.~NC_E

‘ ` §HAT Cou~se§_’§ PERFORMNCE WA§ D§;F§¢§Em mo T§§AT

,_`T§»§§;' OEF§<;EN /§,_/ P§’§Ejuo§c;&® T§~§E D§.F2§§5§;. ,_-§R§Q§3 §O("{ ~Z>,C‘§ §..UB€ ou -§-§:1§~§

2 2 2'§/~§4:§ 334-§§ 2>< 2/§2§2 4../~4§4§2 5032 §/32§ 70

(T §2x C2§m 222 2697 "j

THE §=§25'§ 920§42» 22@4§§225 THE /DE.F2NDANT) T6 SHUW

COaNse§_s PE.RFOR/~'\ANC,C FELJ_ 62 LO»J A§~§ OBU 265§\\/2'
572§\§0»§20 02 22233~23§_§;~233 UN022 DR§.\/A§§_§Nc, PRO~
FES§§@NA§_ 2102/§§ 572§2§<§_/-\§\§0 725 us m A237 88 1041
3 d 2052 §_ANE 303 3.w 3d m 707 , , -

' APPL§CA~T _§;§A[;__§Q_M_/§§.L.§ac,§;S(IN 2A2T§cuL_AR)
T/§AT CQuN§EL_ WA$_ lN/;FFECT§vL FO/;<__ '

 

 

 

(;11 FA\Lurac. 10 oBJ~c-;_Cr T<>THE \/AL¢D\T~/ oF THE ING¢CYMF.MT

issaéo Bv THE HARR\S Coum\_/ GRAN¢) 366~/ FOR sam massest

_ (/-\) `rwo(E) P_NHANcc-:/~\E_m DArH5 oF Tvu~: PRE PQCPASNE

»' A~o _T_NFLA/-mATor<~/) \9Rl_3umc.1-_D .

AP‘°L\CA~ThamLm_ Famea sms 1161 606161_6 Was

.LNEFFEC`-\vE For< FA\LuQE 10 111\/651116&'\\»_ AND 0631=_€1 10
THE hagg_\_s_ Coomv GRAND_Uura\/ BASLD ON'€\-\L \E> A 1611/166 1661;1/~161\11/ 1s5616) 61 /1 611/1116 wm 6111)61
THE"1 .» ” svs'rem (Cvaazamsous 1>1 osc-wmr5,/-\QTWE 191%05166110.'<) 666 §)<' -
. ’ PRosEcuTo/O\s 1166 mos'~rL>/' meE Em E§)Is Pae:)um¢co 1
' 'AND `VzO¢F_AT)vE_ 01= Duz; PROCE;S " -

    

_SvSTE.N\

 

 

"'11-1& 5,1'».;0§113 §>Rcm@ ~§z§:_§s§§§§aesT§\E(De?€§§o§§§'§')§os§~\@w
~ T§W TH§£R§`£ 15 A REA;S<;§§\A€>§_E F’§?ABHJT§§ T`§\§\"§’,» EUT F©R(H§S)HER)
Cou~s§=_§.’s F_R§eo§z '-1'§~111.~ feaqu 0§~' “1`11~1§`; P§aoc?_ D._‘§§~§co W'c)§u§,o
HA\/E BEE§§ D1F1=ERE§\1-'§' ST!HC\‘?q §O§§
5.¢§. 205 az LA§§§= 505 51,§./ 5§:1 707
'TH~EI-ZE 15 §§ §€E'»‘~\SONA&§.§‘». §“>§2013.¢\1'3§§~1'” 1Y “11~1§\'§", B§§T FGR
cw§§s§;§_’s l§§§;FFE<;T§§/§-.§§§-:.ss A§§c» §§§§/\§§§_v j §
_ 1. C§:)U§§s§=:§,'s 1=/§§§_§§§§1; 'To 013:§§<:§ /1\§§0 Fou_ov./ T§§§€w@§§
wm§ canecnou`§ Tc> d§11§'1. l§§¢>§c§/~§E§§'\ 135§§1;0 131 ‘11§§;_ @1_:1§§§13`_3<§§1~§,
01$51;~`.<.`1~10§§5 13§\<, §=_§D 0§1 °§\§/0(2) EJ{§HA§§¢E/§§cw'§ PARRC>RP§§>HS O§= ~'
TH§‘-_ PRE~ PP\EPA\Z'€_D l§§o1CTMENT WE§’N 10§15 AMO THA§ WA§(PR&VAS§VE A§§§> lNF§/§/V\/§'v§`§@(§\§)
_~ 101>1:3§§01;£1> 5111¢012€ 11~11; G§?RMGE§§Q§'§§\EA§E§NG: §1~11:§
. 2 C©§§§§s_&;§__ F?A\Lu§z&° TO ©B.JECT A§§@ FG§_LGW T§§§louc¢u
._¥.1)1/1§§1 053§;¢11@§§3,_ BASED 0§1 1116 11§1)1€§/§\1;§11 131;1§§@ 155§§§,0
13§/ A 612th §§va E_/§'\P/\§~§§-_L§.ED UNDEK T§§E \"\EY ,W>§N
3)3'1'§;/111 THATS \/10§)§§`.1`1\/§: O§= OUE PRGCL,SS. 4
THE RE§§§E§$ 01t "§‘1~1& PRO§:§§;EMN@S W<§§§§_D HAV§‘; §§ch
D1§Y1=ERE_NT‘1 BECA§§§E 01: ‘11§1‘-; FOR_E.GONG »D§Sc§§ssm§§
(THE. ACT§ /§§1§;§ 'O/v\1531o§15 §§0§£0`1~"/`§§91@1_1§:§=1§§§ HN/515~1 (.T.T 15 THE @»_<1__5 OL.rw To /-\1>11_\/ '1115 -1_/~1\/~\/
1\10T A135TRACF 9511~1<11>1_55 or 1-‘.»~\11211555, 1111 901,1<:.1/) 7
TH¢S 15 SC~ S"/Y‘\PTO/~xm\c, OF Hé@£_|§. COUMTY, TEX/\S A\\\D
50 \/ERY D<. 952555\'\15 \/1/1151~.1 1551 Con€cQL-R HOW(\/JE;.) PR\D5
j 05112551_\/55 \`~” 05 A NAMON OF LAWS___._-_________/-\$ L@N<;», A5
TH.E\/ 001\1'1 11121551:1'-.125 \/1/1111 A.91/ 915'1\`1'105&3 TH#°> HONOU§LE
,Q,__Q_ `1-“-5 95952515"\,115 JUD5EN\5.W OF 505111<§110111 AND 155115"-_ '
1111 1151151:12 01 915»'\15551, 1515 996511.01515 1115 1551wa
05 1151121 111 1115 />11_\5514111'1\/1-; TMM ‘\’11\5 0555 ¥51-, RC/“\Awo To
THE T».Q)AL CC),QR» FOR A)\\ EV&GFNT\/»FY 1419sz TC 312 CGt\!&-ll<`»'€b,
` 015/1155 511 "‘1"1~15 511:11,12111111\15{¥111, 199&<19& A`€-E ACK\_<)N\
" TH15 14011051151.\°. gc_)_q;g; 513__0_5______5~\§_____¢.1$7 11\1~11;1 95591;§
§th,jC §

\,»1/1151251=01<5 955/111555 5.;111:- 1115'1'1515 /~~1-~1>11<1\/~11' 1‘~~” :»

 

 

   
 

W,'S'.JT, _1"1"1` 15 50~/\”10\/513,.51\11) f‘s<;.¢\. .-.0 1709 !»`-\1\.€'0 111 /-‘1-1_£_. W°Hi'.c\l@:`>

RES 91;5“1' 1155-151 551(),¢\*\ \,'1"1;\)
/A 211/mma 1514/pf ' :F')¢@’? ¢0‘*'5"5¢'/
\/1 1515/1111 ,5111~01\0 HAR£:LSGN

 

C_L&J;LUATE QF CQM'~\:.:ANC§. .As R§Gu\§_§c)
Qv `r§_x_, R,As>)=’. 75. 2_(1-“~)' ll
wymme Bur~'oszo r~l»AR§z§oN APDL!§A§\H"A.>»£O m PRD §§

BE¢FOR`_ TH)S> Hc)Noa/\§LE Com'>~r F=~_._w. swa¢\,=,<\_\\%) cemmm.z=.

g g__;:omm,m~¢§_’ m :HE .A,E,o\/E ~C`APT¢@NEO '<.;Au~sE_/WRF%’
PUQSUANT TC> T§')<#s Coo§i. cr C~mm¢~m_ Pfaoc§§a)w-.E', cnam§z 111
ART:<;L.E H,O?, § 5,`THE APPL\¢:ANT HA@£L¢SON C,ER;T§`t'-'\Eg
THAT `TH§ Nun'\e.§»~_z `c)F \,'¢c>ao§ m 'N§,( 14 3) rm»mo\z‘wum
OF g AW 15 A_PP‘ROXW"»ATEL.Y 585¢:> a g -
Dcm=_ wm §><§<:vvr§c> <)N “m\s Ta-\§ L/ O/>;.w"
os=c(¢>/z»@ ~ v , §o__jL;__S_________

 

w :Mu~gm~ MUk/Q !’L.»'""/"TC/”“' 1

Wm.W-'\ G,Lu=ofzo Mi\§” ?~LSON~

§»J , . . -. __. ,
L§S.§ i\’xur;/\;§i;§ OF \/Jo§o§ m Tf.-x\_=_ C,L:RT\F~\,<-A;;-_-. O:.~

ii ll
C‘/"l p'L-?"‘ N ':: 5

_` _ n ./(
/~“.~.No .HE L,__z=.`a\§\§/ \§ ©r-' \S,E,e’€v\( '-

   

y w#‘ -

vw..\~

L/

\/`\/ §_ LL _iA/"'\ \?>UFD I,ZD~ HA@RZS ONA
' 3313;1€3¢3"3@€3613,/~\\€333\£\_ uaan
2€>6"'3' 3~./'\'~‘3§ 2654-f _
TENNE 56{`; E C.OLC>NV TE>§#‘~“:)
75 1536

33C 633 33§,'\333 3 E CL§§§ mr '3'33§ §ig'>u§`r, '
0 <;E op zH§ §s_§a'§
`° T“§m.-» Cou. 35 mr §§ nfm~.,m_ 35 ._O;>L:N__<,

RE§ EX PARTE \N\'Li_*§|/Am ;T`MFC)(~’_D HA&_-;Z\~_’>ON; 4
\k.f'|\i'[ {\!O _______
‘\J;Si'-_ N;`) b*/‘-/‘)/‘l/? C,(.j¥ 3;&\3,33_/\1-. \N,;\.`:)

 

 

DEN~Z 3--303\1£>@/\33\_§ §:1.§3'33< cze 333-§ ~,C~Omz~é¢x '»
t 'T,HC 3` 3“;~’>0\/§ No'r§§ A<_;j_¢og 3~3§§/\3~3§ BE'F_N T¢z¢:myv\qep
'TC? \/Ou§‘& 3=3><;?=; V~OQ HL§=./(` 0<.3\§`3" l c\:>j /). 933\')@5,3, \GN‘
`3`33§ \`.»V'Lo< 310 ’3\§'3\033§»4®\3<3 333 3331_<, 33 -`313» 333 W §m:/
533 D .&EFCPY~ `\'HC §§Q.£'~l 3_1`(>:\ L)\§,Pc@n‘; v
T-HANF;; `YC`)¢" FC>¢§€; ~3"¢;:<.~@ 'THV\L~:- m 335 V\A”TL,K

_ E_,><'§<,.§T§D" .@N '“'_3\5 D.N~=; __Z___ _ OF___ /W@ C 35

    

R'E;'>P§cs' F»ut.u

C;C-: F’\c.§ ww¢-c>¢»{’ i~\§vw“,
W iu.w/~\ §u‘efd<§) 333>~§§350§

,c:E§T\§F‘»§A‘TE <‘)F SE§W<:..G
'\L¢/L#__J_»=l,c\m 313 page 33!~\¢’313&35 CM /§\{»’p!,,%€.¢¢\.s~§r ANU
_ CER`HHEE, TH§T I.. 1333/§ 532er 0 33 com 01=`{131$.
t//’31`1‘,/)'cJ'?"?IE3’3'101211?34£)§11'1'1 OF= LJ:,\.W” 114<`.,313,353? 1330 ~;€~.l'/‘r'"¢/L/ C,?'C
TO Ti*E- STATE 0;\1`1'1~:.5

THE._i____._'DnY 01: O'/lO/\)L/€/ Z.D~l,§..m,.

.'3">" .7’1”13~3,»§ ,3=1_§5 ;:{»7,__1'0\”`/Q o

 

>'“”\S D¢‘-`”-VDN /3 N-®EQ¢ 01\1» [;1'3119.1§‘1 Am>m§=y
3-3/~\121115., C@c)¢\n~ 01:”,:'§¢_$ ATTZ;¢:::\;E-Y$ OFFXCE
1103 F`-§m~.z§i_-:N ';1,1\'1' (¢~Qo

H 33¢15‘1.<31~1 , T E,> ' 41~#\~3>`€;3§\55_&

STATE 01= 71‘;)0<15
§0u1\17v oF 1-\A\QR15

1 .`1:11 11~1~,»11_11\11, 13111"`1`0 1‘~1/1@~1~11~?1?<31_\1 `11~@£3?$__1“1€1‘1~€>13

13£)1~1<5 1>12&$ 121171.1/ 11\1<:¢111.;‘€.1?~@“150 111 "'1` 1~:-/‘<.1'=15

DEQQ@TmEMT »O’F »Cf&1m1.1111111_, 11111:;71<,€~: 1311 1915
/“\11:.11,1\1_1?. 111\117,.

Q,-é»-é‘r’ F m 5105~’-/

TENM£_$E»E.& CO£<>NY‘YEXA§

715'88<.»» .
00 1\1:<.,1..111°1:" umwa 111 11; PG.NM.W\{ 017 139>9..31111¥1
, THM` 1115 1`@1<1\1011~1£,(371171':/1\1~_117/ -7¢1) 13
1911'11§ /~\,N@. 1113vach '
1312).1~1€ ,\1\10 11‘11'(111’1.0, 1111~.1' 7111 s THE.

.,.,______f{__;_?f _1:1,./'11, 1311 Q¢/w€ _.1.201 13

 

1111 1._1`1»'1¢\/1 1::£€1:@1’2?)1 1'1.1'"\@&\5 @N