Court Opinion

ID: 6413621
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-06-25 11:54:31.000968+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T15:51:27.620207
License: Public Domain

Bigelow, C. J.
The motion to dismiss this action musí be overruled. There is nothing on the record which shows any defect in the writ or other proceedings on which to found such a motion. On the contrary, the writ is in due form, the service is regular, and the court has jurisdiction of the parties and the subject matter of the suit. As a motion to dismiss must always be founded on matter apparent on the record, it would seem to be clear that it cannot be supported in the present case.
Besides ; a person summoned as a stockholder in a manufacturing corporation in a suit to recover a corporate debt cannot appear and plead to the merits, or make any defence which goes to defeat the action as between the original parties. Holyoke Bank v. Goodman Paper Manuf Co. 9 Cush. 576, 582. His defence must be confined to matters which tend to show that he is not liable as a stockholder for the debts of the corporation. *582The motion to dismiss, therefore, was rightly overruled, having been made in behalf of a person who had no right to ask that the action should be defeated as between the plaintiff and the defendants.
Whether the stockholder who is summoned in this action can avail himself of the matter set out in the agreed statement, to avoid his liability on execution, and if so in what form he can properly bring the facts before the court, are questions which we have not considered, because they do not arise on the case as now presented, and have not been spoken to by counsel.

Motion to dismiss overruled.