Court Opinion

ID: 2753289
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2014-11-19 21:04:43.002495+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:37:09.122521
License: Public Domain

STATE OF MICHIGAN

                           COURT OF APPEALS

PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN,                                    UNPUBLISHED
                                                                    November 18, 2014
               Plaintiff-Appellee,

v                                                                   No. 317288
                                                                    Mason Circuit Court
BOBBY EARL HARRIS,                                                  LC No. 12-002532-FH

               Defendant-Appellant.

Before: OWENS, P.J., and MARKEY and SERVITTO, JJ.

PER CURIAM.

        Defendant was convicted by a jury of carrying a weapon with unlawful intent, MCL
750.226, and placed on probation. He now appeals by right his sentence following a probation
violation. We affirm.

       Defendant became romantically involved with the victim, who was married but going
through a divorce. The victim eventually informed defendant that she wished to remain with her
husband. Defendant was arrested while walking to the victim’s residence with a butcher knife.
Defendant’s original sentence of probation required him to serve a jail term and have no contact
with the victim or her fiancé or with the victim’s mother. Less than a month after he was
released from jail, however, defendant stood outside the victim’s residence and began to cut
himself. These actions violated of his probation. Because of the violation, the trial court
sentenced defendant to two to five years’ imprisonment. This sentence was an upward departure
of 18 months from the original guidelines range of zero to six months.

        Defendant argues the trial court impermissibly departed upward from the guidelines
range. We disagree. A court may depart from the recommended minimum sentence range under
the legislative guidelines for substantial and compelling reasons that are objective and verifiable
and keenly or irresistibly grab the court’s attention. People v Smith, 482 Mich 292, 299; 754
NW2d 284 (2008). Here, the trial court found that defendant’s probation violation, which
involved acts similar to those for which he was originally convicted and which occurred shortly
after he was released from jail, constituted a substantial and compelling reason for departing
from the guidelines recommendation. The trial court also noted that when defendant wounded
himself, causing a severe injury, he was very close to the victim’s residence, which indicated that
he was still trying to have things “his way.” The trial court was correct in noting that
defendant’s probation violation constituted an objective and verifiable reason for departure.

                                               -1-
People v Schaafsma, 267 Mich App 184, 185; 704 NW2d 115 (2005). Further, that defendant’s
underlying conduct in his original offense was similar to his conduct resulting in the probation
violation and occurred days after defendant was released from jail were objective and verifiable.
We agree that the objective and verifiable factors found by the trial court are substantial and
compelling and keenly or irresistibly grabbed the trial court’s attention, justifying its guidelines
departure. Smith, 482 Mich at 299. We therefore find that the trial court did not clearly err or
abuse its discretion in deciding that these reasons justified departure. Id.

         Giving deference to the trial court’s superior knowledge of the facts and the offender as
we must, People v Babcock, 469 Mich 247, 270; 666 NW2d 231 (2003), we find the trial court
did not abuse its discretion in justifying the extent of his departure by concluding defendant
failed to show that he had the ability to reform his behavior. Smith, 482 Mich at 299.

       We affirm.

                                                             /s/ Donald S. Owens
                                                             /s/ Jane E. Markey
                                                             /s/ Deborah A. Servitto

                                                -2-