Court Opinion

ID: 4043218
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:17:28.157758+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:16:04.802315
License: Public Domain

DoN,U tt:: RAY       wc s-r'B r2.oo 1c )
                          ReA db(
V,

WfNPOC~t-J CQIJIJTI
1) LSTYUul _Jt-17fbiCNFY S (9(HQ/ 1
                         12e-~ft9 Vtd~. v\l

D'i2-uvV'   ~tnA·vf lY-F Cr\ -wu ~J ·~ s C1lflL >
      £\1\v\i'lsJ ~- .9-Jt"")         .lS     J2.Jd-M5    t-MllOW lD Atzn51 VOID

 J \/Pf:l ~"lJT .
      Pluv,-e (:.fcvtMp C0ML drJe t~~ Ge/p l of th;Ls co v<t-( p~J-e o._ V\ d
  f.e_;~(if) to Vvt~ -tV1s(J.v the. -0Vtdf)~d s~t9-C\_Mr.e-~5L~ >fd.Jm~p-t-J
     ~V'I.v.J01e ,

     \hMI.k 1'],11Yl -Pvr IIJ n-n v lultlol        M     sl ~ t o-v vtue   WI   -HV.s V\1\.Jfer-,
                                                                                        I

     ~,;c..uJII
     U9AL~(~ 12-~ W0S~~nmk 1
                        iZ.v!<L~{

                                /
                          II'J 11+6 co U!01 0 F C RLIJL! UAL- AftJ~Al5
                               e0F ~t><:AS 1 A'! AVS'l\N

l%rJ'Dt0DlJ co u1\rry
D~71/l,-Lol A1!11((!JG'Y S ~ mcb")
                      1

                   \kMpGvdt0J

                     N\OtlO~         \1)     A:fG~~'JT    VOID JLYD6JM_BJ\

               1
  'J(.vl<~J4"Br 1) ew JJtt:' Q. wtr~tBilDD~ r pvf,:Vl~"'t 1o fZt,,Jt l '2, (lf D{2 th~ l~x 0, Apt
   fre<:, MD VM -fn .PJ!t. IAV\ b(I~ l q~ 1'\A()I\ DI·J 1b , AU2-I(.thI VD I!) J U]>6M.f'IJT
           1
   OvVl-~ we vvtel rh,ov0 tkR C<0 ft +11-t. --Po ~~V\1 Wtj ,
                                      V\

   \. No   oJ~Je r.tVItEiii oJ fOlLU t!((s~ +}rorvc \Wponclav'IH                   VOl{)   Jwljwwvtf
    ri Co vwdlliv'l ;V\      Ctv\M-1/ .q, - (le i"l b) , vv kexe S oUol         Jrtdj 1'111!~ l"'J" s
    [l_ Ce voMd (     v1~V\~~ ~ ~p o"l d<to...J t,,Ji&S 1vv Vwre. 10.!ode           Y   vv Oh   ~>'1 I~~
     6o Vl\i\cfe4 \Vl fh-t    +cuAA        C£JLvVtJ IAlcH-toJ- Ovil\   ~~4M J- iVJ thi ~        c""U5e , ·
  1._,~M-e. .eiLs~ .QA;{dmc.e llrl the V"£CD{) wk,re. Mlif1.u,-Jcvi-J ~?<-ct-1-u
                                                                          (A.

     ~e. coMfe.Ud 1 l!lf~<e. Re0fDVIJ.e,J \oiT <;J,;td rft4vt~t odttd Co(oV1-erS repo(t
     rrn CttM..s-& oPde.J"h 1 w_lo..vc.e. !Gebe& VtcLPhit h11s (}._ M 1io VLLude- 5vtv~
     wfd JVL~O'Il.f!VIIf- !Jf 0\!Y1.1fld1Jn I wiw-r.e rA lv\bf10r\J lD )\((.~~~ VOI'l> Jl!!X1-
     MeNT 1\A£1-11] be k,Se -h S'.e f-ccft d.e ~ f aw 1W c o ~(h Jwlj Me-vk f."hJ-
     (6 v6td M a. AA4EY Ji (di.IN 1 ~&:o.M.6e- ·,t .fVI- ceed.~ +h.t CJYv,£-if> a.~~J 1C.:h<it
     pifiAI\.R!(> lM'tti. VJolcd-~ ~.vlolfurs dM-t tr0 aw, rij~h,
•..    '   .....

~ , R.vl~ l s ~vvh+! ~ fr 11c j ulJ WWil/t of ~c't ~-jfJ IAvJ. jo( (}.__ ill ~w
    t(LJ (
L\. Coi~Gn~ L\Jo.h tv/fecdlv~ 1 t-VI hi.s oVUV/ words, a,s +rcJ recerd> cJ€¥/.eJ,
c; , hY -rn~ 4>(0;, ':) r~stms, th,l~ Cot<rl-- sWd 8>€MJT H.i ~ '"lb 11~
    1b )c(2.j}2EST \fDVD JU'f?~Mk:-~ 1 p0-ff>LA-~vvt ib RJ-t--10 tY-l'{lJ~o((l{)(tVAC2-y
    W\p{ITW-4 ·r.ex_ .If trrf· PeDe.
                           1
                                   1

      Jo.Yl.A/\.-tilt(   11_ fLO Is
                               I

       R.&$p4o!fiJ~/ Swb~ t~               1

                ·Qo_~ w~~rlo rcolL
       VOVHf\-1-fi

       -rv c;:r* I S~1g(:, 0 .
       1--IO(       ~Vv\1u.C\ uor~
           reV\J{A_ PaJrl \!'X !(9'3lfl1