Court Opinion

ID: 4047108
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:19:46.080441+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:41:50.971077
License: Public Domain

’~\Ol ,©bw 'Z>Z.@€I»Uo.q) . Ll'z,uz,qq,qg,q@

<;<@m:\g Q\\_».~ 0§£¢~12€?¢ E> ” I/'J 7/~/3’ '7’£)¢#§ C,@ - o~Si-»c<:»)qucp, ’ §
x MAR 0220'\5 §

wm u¢»¢,w;,c_¢_n Ql¢kk m,a\ pmpa
/ z ¢ _ , a n
/S/ou> Q@Wn&$ lj¢).lllerv\\ Anc£c€u`) Q'\\-Q»\ j§b@%¢g;i§)§:g%
%z OQK»'.A* 6<§7 QQTm\r\l.\ l A@pg/J'$ §@é.£a

&'?_z'bewm |? o‘\O/$L ff 5.¢/»% 2027/" ~ »' a
o?»c>¢¢-'\Z_Q%`éjé. 72 Mé /{§Z*VDS$¥»<"<} Q<:fmj? §:QUI<&§#,%Z’:%
/)znwggzj md CQ,@JAKCD;,_.Q 13 /l}\g’b'.i§l/Z»`Q\' Q-H<:e»nc¢} f»)q\<}\ W\t»
15§'7`”'_5567/¢'¢/ QW`UL, /)S@g /IA’\$ /DAJF& Fd;qg,q@,~,} \Q, .Qa Qee@&€, //<’11$ Q®c§é*@§'@£vm§;\/Y| ge¢@éqob,,¢é ]',O’Z SZCI¢'JV\
3@. m  %z /6”€~@”/)§$//2/¢'/
Q@L¢ L+, /~IM @ML)M'”°\ Q§~m+o 3d ¢)/s@ 4/1': @chf"' . Oz)u/ML
}_]/AS ]}/0+ 664/7 @< GQE_Q:| ECQ 6"7_'\ th,j ,-T,~zs‘b¢£’\i O§,;;;?(-§’
A\s /“\(a'TQé" viii Ar\l§¢ué@ m. 8@0¢?»/29%»6 ~»- @§~of;-/a<;%¢z
Hnd pls<) 41 wali §§ H//)la¢/as. OYW¢.$, /'/.`07. @gthl/z.<;w@a »
z§~@q~/z¢%.c 6a @QZ< w,m’ d- @ém Q@Wus 1167 ?@?1/2?767>
~`O?<$‘?~/Z?S(Q’D¢ /Mz_ dev/uf odd @Z/m,,§¢»/ /Qp)pé,¢[: kim ibid
F\W|`,@M/a- iz@q~lzq’%é 0@:~€°1“/2? 7¢»€ v 0€~09-/;9§4,<:.
©Z»o¢?~lz‘!‘<@®' ~ o§»ot' G@Mw'- ‘7’~’< amf @OF’ »/A/é>s/rs 091-gm //.67. D,~;e.@<)€j
mg /`)f'»‘<) 511¢/-"4€.<, Yn/%`\"€Oo MrDéO.;-mbé.<_ ,29» 901-¢, 475 /\/z
£Jic?m¢.¢_ 1015 /./04‘ Z£C¢EF/JZJ 157 QP;CQ¢AL¢WL \M\J,’j ¢©<~)loéé/a ’7
961/4 301 d?\z~_ T;¢Xr\s/Dég)nd mwr+ @FQEm/E\Ml §§m~\l‘»"c“<.a

®'Y\Féb 9¢ 3612/v f w»//,}¢m Me&¢) (\1)/¢1/\ £e(§‘éuzeo /\/@7[/“¢£ 724//“
M~% 614-alma afé.£;?mbn/ //H'>' FélZ/Zg.s,_¢~j m"'[ 1157 wlLT'/` ag )-/10‘)£,6‘§

' CZLPASA')\OD l~/'h @£é§an-'/'f¢p ”nwm fm W`€' d‘?“~/L`|LQ W"'S 75 J'r)
l/»z>/N,»zm J;C -\/é¢rwv\ gm `Téy‘#s @@&¢¢~S)Ce?m)?>~'l #@QFCL"A€‘
,4,¢41'¢/¢.1/.67 3.6_ 3_<’._11»,1.0/ 340 ‘I, `7>»4% wm'f 2§>0¢¢/2¢;7¢1>
1%,2¢<¢5/¢\ .af»oQ»/zqec,b }//)s //¢/ /_;5'»»,, A&maee 57 5/`%€/‘- _7'71€-
®,~511.¢1 1111sz 191 /5',‘/1711'@@10»@4»<7, @M_/d mall 113
771?§:,,|§§?($;$"1/21'<.>1 GQ¢»<£, cf w/»\~)[€/L 63wa ' ' .

§1`1( <.(x%f£é ‘/dwr). , {//f 51<)2.0,. ?3$[ )*/C/v @/30
my @m%i£%r)w/

dead of Onvm`.z»»,l pg.»}s wald 1»¢~+ ex'\

5117‘4'22 dr//Z'>v f amf/1 ' /> z
c/S:§&;Cj' €/ie/ 23£5/’:/7::;11/3¢/ £W:f:?o/S;z 0§@571\)1`0‘(";1? @z)u& .o

/W€ 1~€ l”‘”'"”‘?”"j

/Dé:‘g’"“g"“" fe"$@é@j"c*)… 1 ~ dam/mts §1',~£ 14 vo"‘{¢'r\»r\/{"
09 Q»%M» M¢$é@ \/,enzc:¢<;w:n am O@».¢d-_ 651 Oe.m.~glppp;céé]u,a
‘{~\p_‘|[clz [`.05`c F¥/» 7;€ ,27¢££6¢;;/" 05 \Saé/?c.i.. Jué)[`icz ,m€A/A'm,%

1731 QGQGL¢'#6¢

D$MM‘\ 'A|S_`{ `i/AA/+ ’nvz')':gy 611,@1,¢12,41 arp
Q£*;m.m/i 1 j;:;:`§ %/1& éZ/€¢l< §§ LO@//e/)L, flag/41 261va

, p.
`\1).~+4\ %)11,»5 511 §§Oe‘)mm~l QWE:.<>L md \£. aman ._ n`l'§w»<

_ _ @@`mj,¢.['
l mal { pasazow,e., //10'7 3/1)_.13@; md 336

5 ©Q §'.'nvv`m ’

@/1¢.“»3"11 q 1

®9%<2;,

©€¢w,<’
mili /21<, §SACW G£,my n d w + m
;'_. /Z/rr[§ C.o&z §§ &aél; mlnw| gua£&‘wz£ /OS// »'aqz;'

CE~'/Z“}?"('?CAH cf §§,éd/c,§_

jj hjr//Mb»»` %J¢:»¢) /9//¢¢) `§z/n/ /J 7//&¢.¢§ 6/.%¢§
bedel- HWQ;R#[M~¢»A* 425 l§`§O‘/QSHLQ)'. O,q,u,£~l eesz paso(f,',n_g[»

kinij //:zm ’)v¢zz ,m/ 0 "2) viii ama ap
@¢,m'm / /W€,,/§ M¢/;)soy @,,U, ¢d/Z?fg//:x 446/w "/?m‘vx)//

o"r)%r§ /H¢ J¢’i"/D<;V afé6a~m~7 Jo/§/'

/`L>£ \Qea\d¢¢»<

j w ////¢‘m %JA£K/ #//~\ é?Z/L/i § W¢/ Wz ,;;,Ud/m/)//,z)`~
76 W‘H /?"¢/ OJ/L/Lz¢} //Z> 617 Kg/';lf Md£¢ W,Y@r/

WJ w 4
£><<<1»1~6£€/77#§ Wf 3¢7}@07 dfé/%»9~/2¢79 - oQ<¢1\5v , j:,. vwé,b /6@'/2\ ®,'56@.‘¢{#
. _\/$~ . _ ~ G@<'.¢L~l"e@ ' `
\»O`,\l,.‘@m M,¢£.,g Q|/.om ' wc@\lem QQM»RL m
vole%mq,z, ~

nine \S’ 1€52>

g_/Q~C }-» f L'JVU??@;/

/-

@ezae,z 9 Wb;wwnaw w 000 N;¢lo

C@’“é’§ /‘/O¢O 7}\7\<» J\ gm Q>‘\$/co€£,m, `W)é, Oléccr\<¥ zan\k g -' F l
531 'A"Qpcé:§:+m°""+ ;‘§!`Q@Av;;$&| T;{§Sa&'h\“'m 'Br» Q;§<)I\)»::v#/
.9¢»&‘ - n icn F)Vi v£.'"S , - S€.. uggumq, 737/2705
OEb-&er;b§’ Q?~\'rr’:?:\é/vj pdacé/L+ @_<§7 ;€;Z,Q{ UZ>» fep Qéo¢@nHe/)\civ\ b1

Csbwnse\ j;»\/Dvrs rT\»/+~‘z»z m\@l ;{7_5 A@Lzbqf .
®R/D€K<:D§’ /1%~+ w A+lm g/i.@\l/ £>é AWJMM 73 J¢/\+
c§~z£nd?en{“ @u/zéu@./\+ TZ> 72ch Cb ¢@»M z,Y/@ aj ,@M/,§
/{Am¢:
A'Weés§\

 

I+ 75 465/354 gaz>g,eza/ 73,.,,// /a- C'¢F; é/N,.; dec/66 zia/14
be g»n+ va fm @/z.§=?nd/M/». byww week ,,f/Q% @éw%»

 

\§\”\>@ ¢ ?e_&$¢ 37\~}5.'

»Q£&~)EST <§»a C,aqm“ apPoMTED cowgéz.
wesqu '12> Ae"r’l€l& !.Os`l . T£)w<; Q,o®£ 06 Czpmr/mf pena/due »

Ql>us¢<. doc of'oq-/a<)")c¢ ~G?o@-/z€s:¢

S`TATE o§ ‘Tz>ms` _ nw »r/¢é /6:;&
\/ ' - Courd` of 'wa,\.lae_

w'.n,»m w@/~)/lm. g amf "~_T _

india/031ch
'DA'Z by éc'd?.fz\ b"`/§”§D

 

,_,s.,oz: 7»€ /'>vwge;{

70 7/1£ //OMG»<¢)BL€ dubee of $A'»J C@¢~J?
Qo`rrl£s /\/oa) , Thz Jz.,@\o?»n+ w»‘|i?d-rr\ 41»@0”&¢) (~).H_;._,`l
Y`DC‘.T¢ 61&`?>°'1!€€/ / md ;€é?uzs'/'S `7714/' 7772 dea/cf kp/¢s;/»/
4 aea/nse] 72> HSS'i`S‘f him j>h fz§¢/u,-" pwdfnpc.;\h €s@vea;@@¢5569,' ‘TM»* m\j fesq|)' I',\ @mfskm%f b¢.{ Gm\§?m€'~
yno»n‘}'.@a:;&gb§¢gnc§qn\'s (D€Q]AaAj¢icv\j’/n S<-» poa'\“ §§ ,Q.'é>?\[’ TZ>
eyea§a»n%¢flav\ cf Q@wv\sé.l '\°5 _/.)'HA¢L\;/ md Fn@,O/z€<>zh{`¢<»\
fm w A$ é°`l“"k"i '° Q éQ/+Q.v 5 b ++ 00 l
’ ' 156 ` a m3 §

"rc)c;w¢ ,Di(o?n l<,`z,

way g//zs MJ‘

llzq“l rim C)‘ZD

H‘ml'sw‘¢[;, "-Fé\m/S ~1”)%¢¥?)

E><£c-?/zci W/(s /Hz, 94 ”D»o\,u_+.

£E .w»l`\‘l §§ Ahbéé§ QEB§. l la 2 ,

CH“$€~ M_QSQ?’O‘IZ?%. lZG'I"l ,/a€?m zz>,/a€s/ ,/.)_¢z<;_, /é?) €3,`/"2§5/,/2%(
0€6€»~)2_¢;§2,“ ' .
'_DEA,Q C\E.RK
£HC,\GSEA @(6*$€ ;VV\O' m,ou,gy\-('S mo'$§*\ &,& COUR'-’_
Appo'm'][zo\ Qsau/nsé.\., 65,<<1&<, M "DécL(AK/~}}ic~r\ jun Sv\pp¢,.e`,' _
§§ K¢'$A\l' "D §§G’£é»é»?h“|a"?c»\ 104 Q.ansz.{ ",'pn ’|71»£ Abov£_»-_S`h//L
ma dumbasz Cleu§s_‘ V/e/#sé WELS md bra/nra
q‘)\é.m 'P.\ /D\& QH¢>-n'\')`€*\ op 7')\£ QQu&"ll.,

Youh ASS?§S'~/'A'HC& JL\~\’U\’\§ ({\Q'\~\-s/L 73 éng~L{ fep@f¢£'m{;<§

' QlQQM~ Paefs'j.
w.u,~m %w> D\lw»

 

 

 

 

 

O|lo?)"l\qz. ‘
<€|li.s L/m"t wa\ke.LQ@M/¢q»
M@.q"l Fm C?%’O '

 

lJ»u/nkvzll@ Tz.>ws 77le 2>,

E'X/~/IMT /

’bchA'kATfM :Bl~l 5¢4 PRS¢T af £.f@l+r §§

73 £,s¢zst/~/mfrov\l e§ Cou~sél k '
» AQ{T<|§ ').06‘( “'l’éms C'>O'Dé O& C£J?m'£h\q\_ F@Q{pq@z_¢ §
. \l`
425 Lz/a»w/' Qé€j”“”¢é"_ 73 ~H~ S'»zppord-“ of Aml»¢é>}é '7@06’/ )€FK/b b
76 ila ssa:;w}w>\ b~; Q@wnsel Fh /_fhz ’1`®¢'¢\3 Qm§z cf O,¢imr'n,q/( ."`\
@zq,aec£a,z,, - ' ` ` . , \°_»
/0¢<) dev/163 £25095<11€5//7 &I~//Mm'l ,¢M/M¢J /l//¢n ¢s/d?>’l/<;Z, 373

`md aL¢c/Aez$ '/7»@/ 271/fm (L¢/n/rb/z 72) 53 'Hz QO‘M°£ das-65 J»’~ '/ gac/o

@ DH,'U`~`§ nw Fncmaé@l.'~\3®'&§)/>1#5“¢1\)¢ cf@é'\m'?w l
\§uslicz .J"|»/noz. /250€')05<>0 Ayf£ox’»m,¢llzl~/` No fncf¥\€'~f 79€£ »’lcv\'%
HS 61'0(7{'< , gu ps&/)j(/§/bcés, wl
m gent ,chz@w.¢£ ona/7 flaws //a%ém/ 01 d/'Wc/@,,.JS Z;/c@w.z,

@ 17 dees 662 U.e/MJ;,,!.

@.I’%wz Vzvé=./ 645 57/3 of AWA@>"
@Fawz /:/0 " ;€gs!,%,%,m l
'@m»( M+k\v g¢¢~%<‘<.‘ ma AWM,»¢;M? @.

jw;//,>M ,AJ¢£¢U MM 0/¢3'7¢§2 59 /éeS@l/»`J-/L/ %meézm}zd’
;, th 5//1\§ M’.¢»'f rssz VZMz®éfom¢af/'JZ C"/u;wh/z»/ alaska w<+l£'f<
Ml<{)’€w/\s~¢ Uéfh;@ md cozcl»mz amd/17 .,|+7 affa§§¢ 7%%£
”¢£5¢°}~3 §M{zm.ka )¢mz.’f/wz 6»¢/ da/z,ez<% '~72> %7 &