Court Opinion

ID: 4050963
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:25:21.0498+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:34.531331
License: Public Domain

Sl,2SO>^z

           w me fern Cou/tfof
                                                «,„ \\-^ol5

      m    Al , n/l A\ I A ,±                  APR 012015
  w: /few. Ctetlcy flfcJUl fofa
la tx P/ttft 3A\IID MkOLD £&£,&.            AbstAeosta.Gterk
     ^-5l-m-Ol                                MOTON DENIED
                                               datflT1^ ^ -
De*H fill, Acosfa                              lYuJt^

£ ihi Mlo^a docummi: SuGIMSTIOa/ T0T 7t«$ CfiQPCf

of TH£ MPlXCtflOfJ m/i filArf CfHAt&iS CORPUS, ^
-to he filed ifJ c/oiiA CouW /W bfaUgh} ~/o -/hi, /0&M/o^J
of iU p/tepeA mfhoitiies. /llfOj //m /'pfe/?S€ &U/&0 4

v€frfij -hhnj: /l Compl&tt 0>fij ofr»y wtol fflthff. ^^
fieciaued ^ filed b^ -tk& (parts, ^^^ /f p&> sey/Ndt^A/t^
pti&tjdl /}^d (a^c /&*€ caj McM^ukJ/J, 7hesefi»fa/ /' 4W 6tA//9bk

plme excise mi,
         rf?/vf^k MM* $£ c/vu#- how, //mI'jx/stiNce ^M/z ^^
tffi'H /I fJiCe Mu ,                        J^tftf M&)U) g/^dli,
                                            Tl?CJ?£) # d5S6ZL(
                                            8? Fr*T632-
                                            teM^s?*. 78/11
                 Xixl The
           f ouftT Of CjR1m\"IK/m APPEALS
                  Of     TEXAS

£x Parte                      §            CdU5£ Mo. WK-51 2fi6-02
DaviD ukRolD EiSE^

   .Su&&g5riok)TrtWTHe COURT (^COfJ^IDfR Ok) 1T>S
    Dv\JfJ z.hJlTlt\TL\IE TH£ DISMISSkL Of ftit
    AWL1CAT1M FDR^RXTOf WA&fcA5 CORPUS

   TO Tvi6 H0rJORAfcL£ CbUATCf CJNMtL h?PtkLh I
     OM.D HAfiDLD fclse^A.ftlM), AMicauI,fifes Wl&
     3u &&£5ria\i fw/rr the court RecoAysLCeX QU JTf s
     OvUlU If/XTIATtl/E TW£ DISMISSAL C$ WL tiPPllCtilDlJ
      fa V^H£f tfmm Coffin, PuAsuAMt io 7fitfL£ fi(JZ,£
     Df hWtiltfi PkOLtdttU -flrtfti/AiJ'iAJOuU £kovO AS

       Tfcc 3ta*e tatews CoaktetiC)diSm\£$etll &£&

     o&Aeo. 6^ feb, ]&,'2q\5, Lf should H£Odi^ide/L ilw+
    flfeci^/fliO dim te dkjk) oi^/vj iMTU-frfe beiAusL M/it S»W.C,

   Misc. "^ubfffeUM've/'' cIaims of acAuaI•/uMooei4Cd   au&i^

                         p / V/10I/W1W ?[))kvwz(4ot4/\\ rfliscovcbct— Tfe
/wiiNfit 6(se -PoU a o^VMl wuMit- u^dm lews ftyvwl (jxJtftKC.)
-/Walk Co^/fvqdjcfo/ui 4w£ies flk j^tf/nt,ca*m&)Uh/kn^Pc*|
 T•Olwiti telt&ivQ &s US, G*>&\x fax/to of pfifiof bbjo**} A
/nu/etefi-j MUoeSfechu^ AJSiSirWCe cfi Counsel (XAC)"- frWoMff
allowed 6keh fc- ft&sBcu&d>W a>io\/icted 6»o Ads /w
erfdeuce, -fM dt(d\d aM tuppo/if tuwi v-ec£S$A/i^ ekm^
io cpt%±\\u&z GApl\A mmdei hnsed o/u s-MiW fo?o. § /?,C#
(aXO/ /t^d (3) The SfafaWj %A*>iAtd uajcUa. 7Jx^l>oib)@)
}$ /do&w+ A^/n -/lie. jt//2u OhA/^A -jjfarf- /MjhoflizGd &>/oV\ciio^ -~
6\$>C -lAJrtS C0\)U\cted/flffjt/rtfd op A Jk#/h> ^/ j*M* //6j/0£

   6ke, b/i$ed. fa d^pms om the \J\olAhoto of fa J/'Wh W
JrMAfetotih ArncAjdmwJt) LldtieJSlides G^sMiA-tim'M fights -fo

/{Cco/npflMivA his Owst. £//?//^ WWo a>W^ /jV/uIaLIjl t^Ar
Aicvfid ejuktfoc Op i^oc&uce, iv Cv^9divtU> p&ceduM
)l4dM*l itjhJoog^oL. "A6 a •fl/Heir^. oWm oP Pu/^dfi/smfai
1/5set. m, tfoL&.tim'(W& ti^det Sctihpj fist
4&)wd -fotf- "Al dnoSFrkft/otJAl i/l'oi//-h'oJ ArfS fl&d/fh/to
fi€£utied kidtoe* cv/Jrirt/otj ofaoc shot's ac-^aIL //uAJoc&rf       /
                                                                         //

/^d JMt('voMAfon///hk, jU/b£ wowid hive Qiuuic&cf &f£
ifJ hohk ofifo, ^      e^df^rp,/7/gfr P/i*te A*0ek£j 2ft XU.jd
W6(tfa. UwJpp, 2007)(cifaq Wup f/3 US. ^ ?27y t/f£&,
  /f/joy -tk f-H-t* dt'dtJM /Ich^/edqe./ ih ik &cM[ 0)
ojki-t- U^i-f^d Stfyjfes Cot^st, ^'of/hf/d^ // o/AJc^mood £/se's
c/AiznZ -fo flllfc&y'Anc//o/1 lAJ/yai •#>& Sti-C. otAd&flMd' B/se-'j
trim-tecc/U{jogmL AU4/lAhk)eu/d&Jct> fa ptosis/ aK
                J %.

  r/ec-io/z C/I\/azg& (deredsAti\ e/Lfc (aJSHsdm/ fe^ dAe*diw»iy/lw
/bxt&uck 6**/ ^efi& /Solved'/a) Ad&uq elmI. Shoe's wt-fresS/
OJAfatJ,-testified'*s follows, Cti\/rtZ&s /osf d/U(a/no/veff he/o^gim
-to 6/1tl. ErfA/ k&m uptet-ANd, aI+C/L /ISZ/lult)^ &?i/AzaSy tfm-MWcf
to kdl Owtzx tffa didvol tetifA*) &iMs mtie^ o& dfags. Afe/i
pidii^ up £l&j 6tvtf%rf\AJA$ /&SAU (feel/tied'up^ANd'placed.d>'^ ,
•Ml/aJL d-tke tok..&ti/CkMhw/Atod£key'/adL GmtoS&H'do4^ &ftfa
 led. Gf/A^s i^As fttiuked/it, fa&L Git/mS -hid cbcid^-dy^l^des/mdAll
 i&dfl&H t> S//MC; &*&>£<>-teWriAted -M^imM- At*d CAdAZdZ
deed ht>ufis M-te&> (flteybuho iajas Aisled/c//4/ifzdfoLtk& Aoq/
ijd/uApfifi/a cfCwtf^yiAjAs ihe^/d&tc/edsCOAjy/t^/Avd^-e/i/ced
 fo ife/delL 4& Gfpdril rnc/Adkl (d CAi/AZoS—AS ApjAJ-y uvdAA

                                                 1/

  At>)dd qfaPiAvd ON^y elite's Cl/)\'m of ' ' Pte>Svci4omI
/^6Co/^Jucd/ iajaS b/V-ed &j AV/oIaPPoaj of Bite's Aloft /^
Afitf/L -mftj avde& dbc Due Access CfauSiZ of f/ut U/^ded
S-tAjeS Corf&WrU&idti Ar*eNd. Pduk-hepJ becAiySe Yfe SPA
se.cu.ted A/d ihoo^Ps-kfd: tevuicdofi) a^pM 6/se fo/i d
ctpiMl wiAid&L upd&i T,AC% ltdm4tcfofi^
dwodes (ftfc-tta SvAicft'rte,) ua)J$& T.&Q, $ 7M(q)(£)
Cm-Pitd^a ih US, (b^sP, dL&HLwckl ^^eJcdsd^tip/ tfd ^'tf>
/oQ6 (Wo) /o p/tive k^dA t&foMbfo douk tvefiu filed
 Ntce&Atu fo a?/05idu^ £(&e's gu/lfofi otjofal /dtiM&t
pdvd (d cfA\[{) beuotjd ate//Sc<U#Se,d! (qd/UA/p/^gJ
(jie.flk SPAu&edi wpwpe& methods cAkuhjed^ p^duc^ »
»#»$ftf/ awi^ dftvP %AA (n Zl$e,/£/lM$ jo;/vfWa\)/
iN^idiA^iU/doL heihJa ChmimlU A£spz>*j£/kl& foL tkz
Conduct d wopned /*aJ -Pht CAplMl miAkfajL oP HedtvdCnvAzos
%Kc\% lM(d)L<0 AfjJ IwXrife) Alkyzdi^ cptwlWd kj CO*
dch^t^c CheA\hhfA'? Conduct* dke p/v\pl{e4 ulp\M44t, [tine
oP PacP (kkmdiNtd h\ •fae,)ufyA- //0 Bise/^Ms jfc{/\\ —
\jJAS fofA -i^t P^n/i\^)A)^ Co-/Mch)d/!(d CheAJlnAm C^ko U&
SfiA M tAJWd Qtorn &&/BkM'5 +ml)*»
           °d\d -• u^lnxd^lht; PUf^ ANd 7/k?/£ idh^io^nlL cAH$e
           •-the,aerth d' HertqL CA\nmo^/ **> '^d^/^/SlheAei/oAPHA
            tolled dec&fcetyby plAquq amoUh^/A. 4eAd/tf ^ie^po^
           / Ad&idliA
           Aid £4u$6 4u.deAih c#'fa, dectASfd t^hilc the- SWd
           j^eAAJj LA$W{\A>tJ ck&fthflpn Cwins'} k) -flu. Cou&Sz Of
            C*Mm'&ty (L AtHenp-iW* -fo a>***\& -fa of&j^ of
            fadMfl>iv0\(pf) -dlAk Cowrtdkd pM& O^ducp ~~ CApdfl( MOf&d&P- %P,C-
ffl'Mfa)ti)c( lieck^CflVKlos —^hidi C\$e,wd Za/zI,
IS CAjdi^lL PesporJSible foU u^d&i -fiP.Cf 1M(pP)(p)^)
^o PkMkj Uie*ih*M^ SubSftfueirt Ma 1/die S^ml SPA(ikd
ffcOSUUied &&/$ otir/{)\)ed ACo^iU)0/o/\udqA^/d/ AtjA'NSJP
CheMhm fc/l bepNj c&immlU flespwfihk, %A die G?*mcb
of aN(Ahm /io $nl cnp/P[f{\ mzdenofi l^ecPod Ownies Zf&C.
§f n^id)(t)pMCa)0) 0>i»mtifed h^ {hi Conduct of &AA\
 o/k t\s&. iPiz implied isdPiwA+e' Hsue of A^defeW&Z

                         (Scflf)
 ^NudtJfifd/nAUJ AtfdL ^P Hfcd dit defidh weAfifftiyAtf
 stnted A^ovt/ A^d tAj&MidfjAlL caused dt de^Ph (foiled)
 Heaoji CAMftioi id ihz 6?Lj£SL of kd^AppiWh* (ld,y 5lie oA
GaA )$ iU& MmM p&imafi^ AcPofL u/vde/i Td.C.i 1>°Iid)
Phfib Co/Y\m\fkd d^ CfvdrfcP —CApip/d mnuUt or pkcto/L
Cantos— oufaicp) Chey^hum /$ cAidi/^A/lu i^csp^$iUt fo/i
   (dld\cnf\d&lh / £l& / £**ly wet CfaAPlnAW LajW€ All CeNUOi&P
fffA C*p'itA'twtitdeA. of HecfaK. Cavmzos (/L) two SzpA/HAit,
d&'tls) (AA/deA Achfi&ffJ jko^ efMWii'AJ/il Pespi?AJSilo\lihij
PofL -M-e, Conduct of tA^tikA. uvdeJl T*Ac> § 7,0Z&)(?) i^ho
CoMndded -thb CAipd/il moiPdeA of C/vunzoSj ^ch C&NVicdihti
 iNcImc{ pHaP Co^SpipujeCApiP^I muAdz/L dS
fk ffiW^ fitivSL (A^dj2Al T,P.C$$ 1fi\fa)/vH ll<>3fa)fa).
   dmd^oHy -(he, SPA'S CbMoUtct of US//^q am/ iwPzfiCfaAMQlNa
 //K)Co^Si$pe/sjP Ch/qfi^e dvtoAieS (poA~ d& StfWZ Cfi~i/y&) /V
 Sep/tP^pc jA/Ah Ofl-Cu^idcd its US 6oodtq)
 wWiiovhiL* CAudiwcj his deApd) (h'll/Aj Cavazos) d PP&
 &&m\\\tv^ \k) &\st'$ Q)^\JiCP\0iO (Ja/LA C(k)M& E/$& /$
piO^OcBN^ of) \Au(kt AN )NU)^S>is{-€A}h ihs){ljA(d CfawidAl
A^^ifcvli-Uj UNckl tPx.S, l.o2(q)pz) fan pUn Co^ducp
Qp l£/\d\ Ok. ChiA^Ariiiti Cemrtrfti/VG CAflP/l\ DAltRdejl. of
Ca\JA74S vdw AM, Msv dcoKjiiS-k^pu Ch&Me-d/Covdc-fad
 /fi hetty CJRamMU ACSpoAjSlhk U»d#A />P,Cd'-7M (a)(2)
fdA pkjt CoudUxdt P dw/Aies fa/fed) i*> M^
Goutee- (dp CwdSfrvz o/l rttfannpii^G Po Cowit k-idvAppmy
i£v cort»iMed Pk. Cwdpick c^dididP^ cApdA/ AhufokA &P
 (xvaws UA>dj?/ipj%/q.o3(si)td)/7.ol6).
     6.) %ri Suffolk of fl&S >?We Stated cMiao of
 P/bSZcu-hftd dlXa>NcU<\c*y 6lte fah/nrM /kt NtuJl^ Awdtlok
QmMh -fiecofdl IpjdicpvneAJpS (ek« &/ d/At^d d)/)Ufy cd\A/^ps (ex.
 C/ fj£)j judtjAwotf (pk, D/Gjy^pA^d ike, op/Aj/orJS oPdke
Strife Couit of Appals (S cop) (ex. PyQj tiiof &>th £°-
defa CPeAbtow* fcb&y
fdfdy/ffvd Ch&dpM/n, /Ajet&sddP/d/jrtlL / /dd/ci^d/c/i^AYd
flfc diB C^P/jaI MVlfigfc/l of CfiVfiWS /9S -/he, Pole, pA/r?/fpjL
Atc\o[L .
      ^e /Me*ts jhd tk Move ffakdSpe&Pic fiicts edtrtHs/)
•jdjAp tixs SP/j vwkted hd US. Q>ts>s+, Abe Slfoeess Pi^hfS

                           (jop/q)
 /o ApA\t -kd/ y/^d kj ApteppNoimwCe; dPfk> &Jidew£>
 buif^ Sm'd dolAh'oAJs no p/iop&aL ihs-kudped'AAt/on/Al
                i     />              t^*/
 \u/Wk would wv4 rhi4Ajd £/Se guilty of (dpHdl /nuPdeJi
 bew/vcl /} &yVowbk doubt t iPm&L-foPg.; &/*pe pyie&t® fkl
QfikeiAJAtA excepho^J do ZiAire das cIaw h&ifid w^de^
 Scklup/ Supmy^d T-C-C-P %li>°7$ HM&d <
 '£) (hfiomrd 1dp    S-. US,
6?AJSh P^jntS— 6zcaus& Ais dm\ CouioS5.
5\4fwm Go\A(d holddaS $e{ -PoMh (o S^kk^dSMd^duM^
ioq Sa,^D25(iqmi
   pfie, f^ctt fli^d €jJid&vc& of the Aea?&d Show I(\) Ikche
 (AVAt^S (a dairy) of. AtO ftKewd AofjMxJA-kd h'd^AppM
 utvJM SPc <2a 011(b)) \ajas d/^cox/efied *W fad ddm)
Po jU ho$p\tf\\ fo/i P^aP/w^P fifr his it))neksj(2) dkc
WS Aldkspzd /W chri-fUftedVoA. Ca\jAt^s!s AjP/dtd/v^pp)/^
OoctodS PePyfUMW (j\ltoA\^) (AVtftoS'S -pA£ApM.C^ AlA(cf
(avails died- lov* AttPe/C the, fad^pp^a yoM dovtjj
(y)£lse. iajAS {Pwi indicted ^     Off/Pa) rnopiUeJl d (AuazoS>,

                      (qo^hJ
  £(& ti^CnH/d)At typ/fal Ah(#ck*L UAjde/L ddc^h'OSl^M
 Sfa&te lAjdh A\ mottdec u^ckji fPc$ \°}M(b)lP)-\^/ lo^to^l
 d#/\Pn- AnS tb<%> mufiddl 'moist M Co/wilpcd'(ocupz) i(W ffa.
Course of11 f% uhJ(kd^\^ Ay^m\jA\]^ oPfeNSt th/tt ^d\/Ates
the, /A^/zdjz/L Po CAfiM cvmddi^ (pimdo&e, /i dgAth Aesulpi***
ffom Adoctods (dUflpl) PtfrnihnpPotf of t^/dmo^ oPt^
&£i'dia$ kvdil^ pupils of An Apa/ hidAJAppP^wd&i fdx{
/2p>dLi0o))u(cpisY\ ca*j a^ &e elected PoA Cfipdni viu/wki
tifldeA Td.C^ H03b)[2-) Pdiyh* foklAOMthzMg>vAl/&lr/te-
ftd^AppiA^ offense. *- because Pkz c^/P, occmAm/ duAjf^
 tA^At/neM ofA\ fidiskbd fid/->rtypM offe^St AfVd AJOp /d
the, CpuP-Sc ($ the CofWiSSiorJ of /Pc//VAppifiM <
    AdoUovePy £lse- 4A^aed -dnb eddzAJoz does ^op supped
&&S cfa&je of MHRdtlL uajcIjtjI frfC $t%02 (h)[l) i^knJ
dmth p&ultezl /dte£ doc-tod Ul&jAillu ie/^A/^Ated life -
SLiSfaifijfrjg h&wtmeAJb of Phi, dcfflO..
  fixed orsj ShdiAfe fPc $liMrite) /U Sdd fyiUc/foHisfy
 its US, (S^Sp{ JoutdzN of pphof M^de/l £u Ao ^M/npf 7 of else5 CASty oft- JA& //?\a$/a/
dhls Mj/j%d, <$bAx£J&i£/3uf*fi>
    £>) jd "Mppo/d cf PSlsds XA,C tinid) £lsz SL/kwiiied
 P'S v&jhj Aydlklck ^PpA~PgC f)///ripidll
Aecofids \J<5AaP(qiM*. 4i& jll&jd peApnpAJApPdtJ cf'//fie*-SuH/f/d/Mt
•m^tmz^-lpx, u)f aIsd; tkt e/dqti^f^didtm&ffs Pj&
 CAfpn Imojtde/c ,C&c Aj,

                              (dortq)
 0(se Assess PhnP -di doi^ stated specific fdds edAPfsp
 biA a pM-popideAAAJco of d1^ eddzNce, djApALjt d&A pAe Ui
(ddsp, wUpPo^cf Sdefkcbi'^ Assd-to/voz Of' CouajsU /uo>
Ptifo^djL(jio/i. lAJOuld ca^oPcP £y& ofdpdA'l /d'ypde&>
TfiafodoP&y flse /n^eps ditfirt&wA^ excepPidrJ cf Scddd^Avd
 il>o'7 §HCpDL^jdo Asixse Phis cfntP/n he/iPd-
 3) CovJictioti o/kJ AThto^A t^oP pAeS^yded -ft) lh& ifuPjy
dirw/d> of, (ho US, CoroSt, (q^cxusji di£> SfxdufaPu 5-fa^fcd
LANcdj2£. Tdc $ I.OZizdpd) (s fibfemp Su>i* else's jyfri
Ch/i&ae pb*P pyApvtdeUfl AluPidA/zed ob/uu/ct/o^Jy ^d
diud S/t/(/m)>
 £fey Chad's Ch*jtq& A/ppfc^tlOAl pA^AAph rt/lohJOd -/Ac
JUA(j tv f/pd £ds-& fiUdM 6p CAp/tAl /VMAdejL ift "wttli i/dpeNp
yp pAo/noM e(L A/ft/zp fa tdz "offenses' ed fid/wfPt/v^
Ais/d ZPj-HA'tP^rtl rna/ide/z. oP ftec+on CAMzes, L&lsfJ Aitcfad
OA //denyded-At> 4id A.odeAtct O^AaJ" efdlAloA de^Ah LaSAa^k)
Owtiw/yiy ^< Pode^/ck 0€AfcJ Zrifid A>*sd fetfZtj (aJm^aJ
Ow(liA/v)+ " Pdrodk^ 6/^dp Appliedfa P^PA^dAph dAi&jWk*
ohnftye, Jh/led f? f^cfidck ^w (^Sppucp/o^ /\s po oip/fal
/miAdefL UrJd&t f,AC. {I?, 03 (g)(2)- *rd PsA-hisS MvJ UfldeA
fdc.5, 7>°2(4)&) Ai d A&Utes to fi^dimC) /he AjcceXApu
 Phc±s to c^AJStitiu+e g/tejs o)ui/p of: (ifhct^p'

                         Qoof/q)
 (Wn,W conduct) (V ^dh iMe, i/de/d Po p/lomoct6 on,
A$S\§jj' d thz, Com/n'iSsPdrS of phi, opfeios^ of Mplfal /^/?jfec—
m(4P'Ag - of Hector CflVAZeS W%u\&d Cdpuf/ith of dte/vdzl
QpPeNStt)/ Aided od MiAm.pkA to A\d &dwdc fesH^J (SaaI,
A/ud/oH p£Mu LaiPswaj CheAthAM ft) P° Cornidd CApfd Anyed^ of
te-tove. CAVftzeS. (fcCSuk- of Q?N(iucp)/\Jiol^\;\^ holdii^s W
&• $&   U\)w4p/ supmym
    pk& SMi^ CoukP of dpf-mls (SCOA) failed fo Conduct
disc's /^bested i&\/\I Sufficed* Pedao - of £\jeft^ Stibsfa/ddz
eiemztd feb out if %AC, ^l^SCci)lz)A^d 7^fcJ(2.)wA^
 n hiApotkMoilL comd j(4A] chANpL, te& Piiilik-ldJSddk,/ ^S1>
S,\dMV>%^^HOd^CMK/\ppJm)- *Ajfy PocviSP^ ds
fsedebJ orJ TJ.G.$fy2a,ft&)tS)/z0>oi(rt//?Mi/ l^^MCP),
 lUo SCon CoKJtUckdZ (/) if ff-e, didNot p^A-Sopdl^
nsej PhsL fmJJ kg, et^couAmedy /l/eded, eft- a/ttiecfrdy (Aex/fwm
 oA fAjll t^ do SD/\ ArfdC2^) C/iU#ZJS wn$ l&tAf /l&dtfpy
ftW~ J.aJ the, Mkflj/y a(A/j€aj AytQUvd po /9y>/ e^yPj piy y/e^d
6<4&M?ds PllAAdloPZj fciSe, lAjASCjUiltuOf (Sxpip/il /*lil&&A*
     -die SCod/s (s$a/ f^sidfioie^c^ fcevle^J i^ias svoj-omL
^>aiS€c( o^J rtv u\N/terioNftbl& flpflicMPorJ of Ssisip^ ^ d/tei/My
*W Set, 1361 (md(c>^ 3kJLtek!Slupy SLtfiMl) /W rirJ
Ufi>P&iS^fih/& de-^mondntibrj of tho phots of fl&pzcopd u/vde&
48 USx. $$ zzftf (d)6)y(z}/£i4t d pesulted/AJ &k*'s
o>N\S)cdorJ helMy Affirmed on /I tPzo&i N(& pAese/ded fo
dui^, jSj fife's (dp/ki lA/Ait (/vo.iAJp-SpZg^Ol) /did

                             (// op IH)
Cd/Mfs nJyAdKrtht/ oP -Msl Atefids °/£fse'f "th//A^ £Mc&"
 Concluded th/d fk-ed cfi^/^e 'UdeoMA-k/cj wstftiycled
tk& jykj /IS to di P^cts /fad du ffw iAj/?/cf S/to^/c/ &6
Cousjdeled bpj tht jafta //> CiA/i/uAPPpa AppP'c^^ts G/u/f-P
SAld /MsMud/dKjs AAe //J no iajajj PiAtoJAmeAdnlh deActPist.if
  doAjeve&y bA?$ed&(° the, facts, ei//oU>/uce/ AA*d cAsefavJ,
St^Ped Above/ fa fpff'-ofrdio/dtAJCjS sef fopft fa fL/A/yes
d SMk/ ^5 Zw3d8Stt(fe)cXA)rtJpp^ll)A^
3tA^ 273 SIM U260, 2&S (je*&l«.dfipl MOb) dkb CoL,ppf
GDpJclufioiJS oaj di/ted- rfpp>G4/(/e<*q/sofde/'eAjoLj &iA/e*o) ddd
jaj/Pa/ Imheus iftfae^ (chAtff. ep&>& jAePc^j) weAe *a#Aoa/&l/S,
  fa&c 4$epts d?itd& spec/Pic* fids/ ZtehdA&ovt,
€SPa6//sP) tcP\ a pp^p6iK)dooqA)(Se oPdieeudeAJoo fxtf &az. $
 (d. S, Cotolt, Owe fftoceSS i/IO/aP/oaJ~- C^iA/cAPoa] OaJ d>
GPiAPqe Aj€lfl(i*6?rt&jfa/
Pdifcs/ftA/Ajz dP Sliced 7P& otM/nrtc "CAyX^oP tffe'S
C/st/rnj d dhi^P die SPp voas Aelteyed of

                    (pi of \f)
SiAAp Sac/ /UeceSS/fpij /v C^NSti/U/c dio od/*& wkh i^hicf)
6/st iajas c/iAAmdas M^a/Ped ty hofdfay /Ju dio dc fa/Aystdp^
supAWy rpecdicAlL/ fa^/tl) die ^swdpA/di/tAi* rfcfaa.
Ccvnfadkd Ph, Ce/ndiAcJc of doviS/fc\ A^d Pp/Vlf/AJc OiA&fae
6rv Hecio/l CnyAtoS P/vhfaPo^AlliA omtfacx C^t/4ZcJsS> faCA/h
(fal/l'Vcj CfaAZ&s); A/Vdfl-) ^W^/VA&a ifiti&d/MAlL
oecufined fa Pfc CoOiASz oPcprfwdi/eOa of Aphytf/wz fa
CoiAiuPP fdd/OAppfaj cf Cai/mz^S, 7Pd A/boi/e SfafedfHe*v€A>Hll
-facts hwe Nd beetj/ ca/o M^t be pfave/o due po dfe,
Sci/ePAl L/fadtd StnPe$ O^StduhfaAl u/o/ypfcrtSy SpAted
Aho^y Co/^mPlied by ph& Spp ^p PA/P//A/poP^-Qu pj
false's -M/*/. y&A\$o SfiudfAcwn U./lv^/hs ^°\ S>.cp, 2ij4)(wia).
   LaJ/Pij; -/ko Ai/stApeu CjAtkvJAM ddge d/SA^faSp/ 0^
£fsps Suhcee/uA/p usAdP (Jade/. -fa&''/fatPetey?" ffa/^d^^d
LAjA/S'fiS CoMpWA^ pOyOAL AW"UA/K&ffMA&le App//C/f/ideJ
°f SMdupy W^ Z6 UPC,*, VZ$*/(d)0)yAw( A?fa
owfieASorJrtblo detmmiAJd/fa fatfa Puck u^ddi 2$ UifLS ^V

                       r/Wje./t
  £/fa ASK phis Co^AP to fiecopJSlffafi. /PS d df<)pz} A^/d
docPePj his oiuse, PoA PiaUhs /^^c^f^pPdefapAP^ hafa^
                                        dJ^J&A/ddms,^. (fa &)
                                        0Mtf) PMADWeiPeySl Co%Sd)

                (jfioflH)                     d            '
   T/ Dtvsib. HmiD &lP>iS$t~w- an idi^Ak, 4 8Se^y At/n
  pfi^Sefaf /AJCAficeAAfad fa (d^y^i/f UoJrf fa faApAJCS
 CoiAfai-jjdexAS* X dzc/AIAe, u/id&& d/io p€/v/i/fpf of
peftjuAj tPiAt Phe> pActs SpA-kd fa -Phis docu/nefa /1P£
 iizuie At^d CoftPecP
    6*eadtec'o/J ^jPdd^KJd_, 2J)/s

                                   DAV/d dA/ted/SfZlSsfs Ppy
                                   (f^° Se,)

          fmfa/^tp, fa Sen\tia>

   X citify Ww+ tf Q?piA edp Suc^B^rjo/d pppf Tffa
Court neco/ugDipf Oht xrs ohj/d XfifallAfldf Tdd
DISMISSAL of TH6 APPLICATION foK ifakldof
HABEAS .CoAfUS lAjns SePucd OhJ Abel faostA/ Supped.
Co^Lt HUxy ZDl iJ. Ifah^y ftjyj 106 y duStlN/fx,
 73111 -zsOft
 f»Q ids, mil oto 4£&PlJL- 'Zo&

                                     OaUid ddfoLD e/fffin
                                               (PteSeJ

                   (A/ fa N)