Court Opinion

ID: 9725753
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2023-08-26 12:08:55.105965+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T18:25:19.422157
License: Public Domain

Thompson, J.
(dissenting) — I am unable to concur in Division II of the majority opinion. I am not convinced that one upon whom rests the burden of proof to. show freedom from contributory negligence carries it by evidence that he opened a closed door, with no. knowledge of what was. on the other side, and plunged forward into total darkness. He made no. inquiry as to the location of the toilet he was seeking; the door was not *253marked and he should at least have proceeded with caution, if he chose to blunder about in unknown territory.'
I also see no materiality in the discussion in Division IY of the discretion of the court in granting a new trial. This for the reason the court did not purport to exercise its discretion, but placed its ruling on what it thought to be errors in instructions. Error there may have been; but if the defendant was entitled to a directed verdict because of plaintiff’s failure to show freedom from contributory negligence, it was not prejudicial.
Hays, J., concurs in this dissent.