Court Opinion

ID: 4052321
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:58:47.470331+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:20.425361
License: Public Domain

Y\4lP4A\ No. O:S- IY:-o\(- ]]CV _ 1f'-4Al CJ J.ln, 0: 13 DCaSqp
  OoA.ot"\A OtM1 ~ RA"'J         j_ L.. t".e_ r-, t=~ ~
      ()-Gk\\\oA~ I Aff-421\.e..e                   FXL~ X~ '
                                                    c ourt o~Appea

               V~ ,                                  JUN 2~ Z015
  WAu.tf:.. MJk\ol\4 ({AJ}_                            usa~atz ~+ tJf- 'A.{J/J-eA\.S
   Re~~~~ / 1\(f-e..Ut\r\f                          Clerk,   5~   Dist rict

Pc~ ·,t\ -t~t llt\.-l--tu.~    o(-    La 2 1'\\no({           t          DA\lr\-5 ~+~ ,T--eM~
 m ot\Of\         to        £ti-.-\           1\V\'vt_ +~            Ftl-e    A(f'-ett A   ~ O(l.J-ef A
    P\~ fu\~          tM-\\-:>f\      A.&                    ic fh-(. Cei\t-eJ\-\ i              l     fo
  *           "'\\(\\<. M\             Of\ 3" ~'t            , 15,
   1o    ift't   Hof\oM{}\e ::SUJ\\(e~ of 1112.                               fJFfH CotALt rf ,V~\s:
   . (oll\Q~ ~tJow , kH\vt£                      A ~, Affelw, ft'O ~e., ~J(..;.~ \1\~ T~
      Qu..W.~ of f_.ov.,_Jr At&                  fJ..ei. h\~ ~et~o.._ 4o Et41etJ2 -h~~ • I 1\
      S\.\fP~         h-e     ~""wJ.         --ti-e.. F-o\\{Ow-,~~ \

  b\"' U.N\iMlli\s.t. '" RaJtu.>A\\ (a....i\-\4 ~~ m otQ?.RL s. of l1\.·gnW\o"' 1.~'-'fi
  if\ LA~*- IJ..-ot.t-11,<,A Whllk i~ V~~ i~P..;J'.ttM-\ tQ ~ Ai\9. 1\\'1 (~\'<,
  ~cu. -the~ l.SS\.Le ~ {t\~ &               tt~ib\J est 't+~ ~At.S2 r1'-A -th~ i-+j\+e. ~
 'Svc(q,.Jl ...Vd~ M       ly\"' ~~ ' s 1\\-e,M=\.
 '1 lou e., r ( \ ""i. F~""' \vt AtJ... ~e. hAve., both bee" PLL+ +h~               M£A.c.h ,    to
  L~ ({ rt\\nolt Lc:Ue.~ h\S DAO t\~ th\~ WM"~fv.\ Le>V\VlLt1o~ M9 t)Va((-t<_
  hi\<;, eo~-t u ~ A I\ i n "-lv.J, "(& 1\\"" t> -tktt<- t~\::) LN(t9t\ -el\v lAMI A~ l f. i Ue .
  1\s 9o iN>ol.\~t\\ t~A\- "- FMR ~ l~tAr<·hA( heA.<lV\{1 be kett9
  \-~'"'t. h~~ ou~U>~Jl.fD S~1Q,k h>~ Lt3r<~V\of<. Ah9 -t~~
  fAA\ MS ~ ~rt-tM£2 ,
               , 5~rrltCltl\1 A\ C\t«Y<S ~l e.t9. by ~<;l:ttd ( l~ttk: /3'/t<R,
  --t'".t fxlel\ WA ·,~ ·'M (o {l -t~ct ~~tfkf'-tl\tl\{ ~-e~42 blA--t M of
   -ttJ~"\~ j~ I. hAv~ not Reo-eueQ_, ·, t ~ ~if\<.t. 1 Mv-"- ('()t
   Rt~\.WdL Rtto<0- t~ M fV\5 Pl+~t~ "' tj {l()._.t~ a Vt. t'h <L ( ~ u.ll+
   Y\i'J. fQ~ t~\.S l1.tl\)ol\ Y\\"\ {21\\<F LS n~t b>Mf~-te V(l fYV\i(&,
   su o{t~~ e.f\\t-(l.t8-                   "'"'1
                                   6 I ~o\6 n ..fl\e .b-t..~ Lo""'tt.J, tr PPI'~l c'
        otba aa<...af\ £J.-teo~o" a£ :ltm-<- , t                      n-c.-c&tSL   -6 G(~ oo&
I. lvh\~-!. fo~~t"'oJJ. t\o1 "-!tl<ue£2.. ·h\ ~--~~-l'S S-tt\it~ J: fv\Jl lo £'A"<~
   {o f\\-.(_ /hb-<f: ol-- ~.et\~\of\,

'A, . Or\   (p'   ~0'     J5  WPt~ A..S.S~~\t~ Q~ Wl\~1\ ~ . ~ ~~lo\.1-e~ t
                                  1
     \uhe." l- Lof\ ~ A\ -\{\LK.wl- tulthOl.A-t U\~0>-1 he t.Au.s.4J. ih~ ·,~~ll-~j
     a. &.ev,ra.\:<hL '.e~~lA..~ WtJSJI.), SfrAW:JOl tllCbh~ Ch~"'~~~ BIA« e"-\-e,
     SP.fPN:>.e1L ~\l1t\t Al\~J..t., F...t'"'CJ\.. ~M-9.- +o Q,M~ M.LA W~e~~ I
     h~v-<. 1-wo hU." \0.. ~. :r tvn~ K"o.J..<[;}.. ou.t Q '1 hr\·+,V'\9 m\A hee..X oJ\
     l.Ot\t..LL>t< F( coQ. , Wh~ I w~.e.. .! WA~ ,1",\\ b€11\~ K, LK-e9- A"~ HYt ,
     1' f. f~l\-\ ~o~ ~ hDV\Il~ .,f\ ~€. ho~fl+A I a_J /ti.AI\~~v1\\-e rf\~~ L
~. UIA.f\\S.V·A k Uf\1\ ~l-eJL M-e, Uf ~-e(l_ 1" -\1\~ Pluo"' Wt~ Y\0
   ~ ~(!:,~) t\<.te~.> oil ~4\ All:e .S) +~ LoL-t-v<.t .), 1ke4 td~o h~ve.
      Vl\L lu' k"' AJp 0\oVl.rt\~'\\ 1t\ 6... fo
                                               1-.1 C.*'lt$.f\-dl J.f~>.f.:re. w~< i-\s ~a(l-e
      thPft\ ao 0 0tP.J<t..U,> -,(\ V\.~L..\~~ ~ 1\\vt ()Vi\ r(H~I\-\-c;. Su"-t 6{-t\\'-\
      Ll~~\ PA~tl!> ~(...e., 1'1\'t~Jt ~, {hGrt ttte~-\-W\'2r' t'V\ e. At ~~~h V\)' 0-tl'\e({
      ~h"'"' ~    V'll.-\v..Jf\    Lv"\~ fh..e~ Sd~ out wh~ ~'v\ff-el\~,
4.    Aff<-~~M>           J l.l.'t     0-6·M~ ·I.V\.i \i1 f>QMJ2 ~ f'llo-.\\..-~ ~~~~.\~1.~)
              ~\ -0                                                   .       ()   rs~~   Acl   \.\\ootvY')
 I), f1fffJV~ tft~L( Fot- M\'i\&ll Wt\~ \~~tt~ \_ro~o~

 (,, r:Ma.u           ~l i'\}v.J\L~ \vt~                         f31\!U       F"'Jl Al\y LAw
       PJf\9.. W~> fy\& Wl~ut Y\((Qj\~                           4J       ~.,t(l\5'I

 1 , A> Soo 1\ 1\S                r (t.W-(_ 1f 9- .fA.e.
                                              .f.           ~ ~n I~~ tW\\ AI (( <( o,e,J. r          CM
       (iAlS ~ ~~t<f l" f\~'"'"..\                  6-     tu~~l< ,
     Y-\{}feA-\   JJo,    b5 - 14-- o/5 - Jl      ClL,       11tiA\ tt .No t)ft2tSVas9o
                         Cao< .\w.: o!\ p,,sl     ftAy.p{(

I.   ~:"'~        "' f<MJ.. Al'f'j\l'fM- tv\:~ hot           !Zeu-ev.& tM. <...etekawtlr:d Reca.J
             6 ~~         a"' t\\.t. laLJl.r ()(\     5 1:h ~,_r-. ~fl?el\M~ J(~
                                                             rnA 4            I

      hck ~k~(l-e.ve.. W~t< (o~-t LtJ..J lNv\l \ "·I~ · IS ..StAt\~ h-(. \vJ2 f0 J/A~
     f ~ f, · fl:JL\-(j- Dt- ~..\eA. Yo i\         1

~. ~- \hcui- -"'-~ (.{~-a~\ol\ FMI-.(Jt. Ism.. rt(tM-t~:>-1\.$1-lf wt\1 he Je)~
                                        IJ_

   ~~ Loou.tJl bOA 4 U>t\1·h-\-iot\Al 1/UdA±lot'\ J;~ Lt:>rt. Y\\Jk'\oll M9
      s {joJ( lJA4i'£ RAf\J.
3, w·,~h~ {~~ ~d-~~,1\ kJV\~N- (0v{)_ A,s L(3\'t ~V\ot't Mu e..
   JJo ~>tU.,eS~ -t'i~t~ fol-- -eA~         he.<.          ~t\e I nvv\ ort eveA
   1(\ f..d.-_sof\ • 1k!. o~~< <:» eJ\ PA i\ i t~ fA. c.t w <A Lr1; fll tv>~
   \vov.-\90 Glv G W\~ ~ ~1V\f YMI\~9~V'0 (>Aile/\-\ ,
4-. t>tl~ ~-.ntt O~U.-Ge.           hA ~   Cll\    (M\.\whJ 'll\3~~o.f) ;t ($\(\ CAu~
     P\e(-6\l\"\ 1o ~.9           t1At\\. -+IQ    :S~t \ ; F Of\ fAttok 01- io be he~
     \(\ iP"~..._py ~~f'... -.e d-.-et-o ~"~ t\\ ~              1 s~    Af\.f"\et-J.(Yt..~ tZt~"'-ts tD
     rR.u   s£-u<.l\, i~.e H\~~G·h<i' WI\.) h'\~ u\\~ol-4-t AI\L.t fAt"'(\'1 O
    Vi ol~l,£. ~\ ¥\\\ "',J_ Witb.zt 1\tv'tJIW.i- b.eiM A{?,~ fa ~
    "~'"~ ~ M-e~ hl.> ~-'?\~,
{;, \oi\~W.. ({1\1\.9. h1s JIA~~s ~ & N<; ~;:,"h l~t:. f:t4-wA01 to, 0
     bv\~ {o~~~u. 1\111\\/\, LOR, IM\o~ MU As>.M1 wJ... k~U~ QI-VlJ'
     Wo\A.\~ 1\\~ .\l.)~ ifLl ~0 Sh""e .Y~t .\1\e't AA ~ tu Ltu..e_ w-\k
       t"\~   Atal1tA \
 ~.~'-l\v.~      .f'h1<, CAl.-~ -,5. ~f'/AU~--tk~ /M-f/\\1\\ ~h afAff~
    f\t f<.\~K Oft ~\U\f\~ rc t<.1C1f~r\ At AIClt\e 1\e(-e.>Jc..\Lt fot<-. 11\~
    ~(.1\'.i,Ol\ fo f.- X~ll. f\ff-l.A \ ft> (on~i f\v.e. iJ PAftl5LMO<-a.f\ + •
Whw.. fot Q.. 1 fttf'\1 f 1l '> (flt\ I.Jt9,~t..ef) 1 WAA rt. ~ , Afllt'IIM\- ' f>ro ~ rviJ.
 h,> ':;of\ lt?, R r\1-f\-ol< ~ff\~~ it) 6f)Q tht~ #'bAQ/tr..(),/Q. (o~z+ W1 t{ &lMt
 ,t\,s bAtt\~ ~I\ 1<;) . ~J~ f}Jltt.fr So {hA~ A f~~h~,t ~oJ\ f<~lt\.hu\J 1\;f f\\A~
     1\lSo    ~ U.l\~rw...t ~, AMf'l,                           f.<tSf-<tAf.,. \\ (} ~~J_;

                                                                     l"~<fO        1/l.lr.!>   ~ Ht~-'t\)Vd\-(   twf
                                                                       tls    1-z:t~ ~-\-
                                                       l4-      · ~~~ ~v~\k ·,1 ~ .1 )J 't-~
Swo-'tt\ O.t.UM..I>r=\lol\   eo3    Geft:t'kLAk cof S<:..<..'-1 l:rS.   r.v!)   H\Ai lit'\!\
w 1>!\AI'£   A  (.)..~ I ~PI'.QA(~I\t ~V\Q} fr~jMt\'1 i Mfv\~ ol\-eSl t1\ T.Q(,), I
MtAn-\~\A,\-l- UJ\·, t -,(\ luM\tel. ~\"' , 1--ep(."~ ~~ {k.e Pe~l-t~ oF
flAtU~ J.o he.k\,~ Plff\(tfY\ ~At -ti-e. fAc-t> ~-t fo~L-tk he.t-elV\
~-t -til.~ PrJ\/) &:;U-ed. , :]:. A\'o L~A=~H~\1\ tM-t of\ (oo ~~ 16
{hh~ LL LfJP4 oF ff\1 ~ r\ot~a f\ ~Q £ o({~,$2. t~t\\.-e.. ~~ ~1.\l\~
1~ {~.e.. Ptt ~t\ V'f\A\\t.o~Vh ...1- o fl.~ F<=> Ktau..!>t\'\~ :

N   tJ+e ~ 1 tJ "h ~~~e. 1J{\e eo f'-1 to rN\\\ , Bl.ftt9 }J~-I< Ath<
           fot. f-eh~wl\el\- vv& -\t~ ?,-s-th Ll-e"'-K ak Ott~u (o..ht"'
            {)~\~ lov#.-lr lo\tl ~u~                  +-
                                         bL ~tt~t-<cSl (],4 L1.~A
             )-ni\-\-1_   -eL<<.kf\.oJ\l~     ~ i \J f'\~   '

                 t )(~(-...\-c9.   of\      -Iii>   Ql ~ OAl-t   of J '-'I"'R.., Qol~
                                                       CJ '9" NWi"    a. -t
                                                 _w~ & ~. qjf'ttl "~~~.
                                                                  I                      Sf"llt\l

                                                    ""4\U~ A f<.A~ 1 f\u~~-e
                                                     \·hJ.I\\~\1\\~~ lu\tt

f\f~~ ~~~ of ~fP~ G}t\ ~4-l! Gl~ D~rtf~~ ik'tN\S
              Pl <b..SJ> [)ci., f 4
()~.9. JJPU. M{(t. foJl Aff~llee., Joo CtteGeV\t Ci V~+nA-~ 1~ 7r-z \:) l
GA(\""\   f,t-z. ~'~rtwr\~ 'JSttA Pt~tttlcr Ll~~K tJMl~~ le&.A~
                        t-\PP-eA\ t/0, o5- lU.-o\5 JJC,V
      -1~\C:t t.!o.                     0£-12 DcaS9o
Oo~ o~~ a.fv\J.                                        r"   fh~ hFth
          vs,
w(\l,\1\( ~ •   aP\f\   o ~(\9.                        Ccwt1 of- fJifeA \ ~
In th.e. if\~-e1..e>Y DY Lfb~ th\t\DR                  OA\\P& ~~4,l€~.S
                                        ORDER
c~m.e.    to b..e ht:f\R6L,        WA~rf (\' ~,Aff~\\M~      I   fro 5e,
   JbaJ,of\ ·1o fr&tt:/\Q. .J,~{, k           b\'-f Arf~\\vd ~ (3.<1-if-

t{l\,~ t'I\Dt(-ot\ iJ let>.Soi\NJk Y'lrJ_ ~v_9. b-e ~~~by
  GRtini£0,
1A lS ~~t\eG'-\ f2RO£QE0                     thl\f f~~ ~o/\          to
£~i~W2. -hMe ~o~ btl-ef 1 c;                Gt~MeJ
  'f\fP€1\.\ •La • o$ .. IU- oiS- )J C\/                  1"~\ t1    A/D OF     13 -olaS-90
L·, ~
   ~h -         da-."'
fl~ lo.AL~      af Ptil'-tA\C:,
G~ L t>tUM ~~' G\~ B\tt
L,ro ~(£ ~..\ -             !). ~ ~baR.
DA\li\S, T-lc#J\5> 1 S2o2..- lt(g$ ~

 D~l\0.. rt\>   tlM-'t ~
        ()\<l\~ "'~ ~JD~                  J1\cl-\ov\ io £r6-1:fex9. ±)Y\~ ls:> 6 k
Plffe..\\t\\e~     C'Jb-<f, Y\1\~ l\Ak          1h\~ ~~x2~..,. \? Ek\~ Rk!) 3t~a't-•J6
    l\\~o f\a~ ~(-,~ {~~ "'~~ to -\k t\+.kl\\tol\                                   or-   40-JZ
 \1~(\b~\L_ ~~s_ 1\~ f~\~ ColA~i I
        11i\t\~-\O~ ~~~           \.{oW- -\: ·tV\.(.   ~AL2 Jt\-.\-~1\-\~~'1\   1eJlALt    t

                                                            Resf-e~i~llt ~ktW ~
                                                            GJ<l--is~~
                                                       Wl\l.\M~-   RN'J 1n..u+e.~     /14 r; t:(fJS C(
                                                       ~)\AI\~'/\ t~ lAt\\ t
                                                       gll l2tb ~-\ •
                                                       H~v1n~~~,~                /) J 'f.-2

                                                \
                                                                 '
   P\-e~ ha-hf"r
  [jft~ - /VA(~ -- l4t+fl (o((                                       ·-

  'fl ff~~~~ fe~h\1of\~{l
   11~. ~w~-rt-lz:.~~- -~~
        C\~vt\(-ffn+Nct-(~+                          --
                                                          .
   '1   VJU\~       hoi-- - V-\~k ~                  -f1\4K~ -         .,

   c_oe_,~_s    '
               /.1-
                ( hA~A.w\C-'io~
    t-~-'"~~           6- )V\~ -                                 --
~~~"--{ _v-----            -j~ 2             -       G~ f.S!Q~ -
~~      f(\\-          .-
                       1
        j -.?'A (" Q_      '){   A"f.Q_I,_
            S~fL - k \"'
                                                 .                ·-
     -.J
     !fl
     1\)
     0
     .l
    1\.
    ~
    !Jl
    !ff
    (J)
    !.!)
   lf)

 "':...

--·-....
  -
--::...