Court Opinion

ID: 4045365
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:49:09.557988+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:02:43.032156
License: Public Domain

'·

·'
                CoL-cD- T o ,-:;.- C--~ ~ ,J kL- A~fJEAL:t
                                       OF-~~                                        This document tCi"rt3hlS so!"e
                                                                                    pages that ar:-:_of P?Or quality
                  P.D . 16DX 'l23or 1 C-A-~·(f2>L S71fi1'2J~                         t the time Of 1magmg.
                                 ~7)-iJ     ) T£YAJ'          7 8'7 L l                               RECEIVED IN
                                                                                               COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

                                                                                                       APR 2 9 2015
                                                                                                   Abel Acosta, ClerK
                                 1=.;( PA'ttf' e ~        p A--lf2_; UL.   ~ER.A.IACLt) ~ ~KA W\..         •

                              ueA:rL Cla_Lc_
                                                          1
                                   .                          tJIE4\e -h"0J      EN c..LD.$e.J2      Arp)t-co.-,+.s
                 hpfl fufTi·l)U fii(l_ W r ~-'{ 0 F' ,uAl () ~S' \ nJ 1hL AbvG- ST'// ~.€_
                 N u...""'6e-re.J &~ ~ ~ ·-:y lor~ e· -h-l e. ---fl, '- ~ An::ad.ure1
      eutd WD-.....v\d. 5.,\r-)~u.) -\he. eu~.f -\\.,e_ +u t\Du)\r'!3 :
     ~ . 'ReLCA.1-or
         '"Pt:><-rRtc..K- ~~A:Rt> T~6RA'\v\. /IDCJ-ID*\tolAOD) , i ~ Dn DFterder
     \.nl:&LVC:~ev+eot \n ~-e              -\:e-XAs. \)e\?~:CM&JT D~ C-R~~. ~f\1.... ':Jug,·c_e-      ~~
     \~ A-~PeA\L: .Jb \lro               Se., W\Jo COJI 6e. loc~eo\ a:±: JA~S \},                     AL.lJ(fO
     t...1..o~-\- 1 'LtD\ Fl-"l 3L:>'i. \J   J   Iowa_ ~D-R-F- /teXAs. -rtoslo"'"t ,
     'aO 2.      '"R.e\a.---\Dr hCLS ex\r'a.de~ ~-,s r~~es, Cl_nd has ~0
                   b-\'h-ey ~u.a_k ~~~ cd- Lcu.J.
     LJ)3        ~E:: a..d-                 -\D \ae Cu~\)et\e_cl \~ VY\\(l·~~+er;J /
                                         Sou.&lht
            hDt d'L~e-<-e-\i~f)CLifj \n        ndure [T~? Ox+. \l.Di Sec_:?:,(c.)]
            t9LU re~ re~~DfJdCLr"\+ ·~ \rY''WYI&:l:tt.--\el\...( -ti('CVJSm.\1::: --\b -ih-t='
            L:uu.x--':- D~ C-vt ~Q\,-,ct.,\ ~~s ~ C..o~'-{ b~ -\he. AQ\0)\LtA-.-tibA
            ~ur Wfct a(2. \--)c..\:,ecw. Cor\)LL~ ,. CLil'-'\ An)Su:Jer {-'tJeJ! ~ o_
            ~ev.\\f\ta--fe. \ec...\-1:\~ -t\n.e dcJ-e ~PDf'\ wh ~e-\t) -\'\nu_+ f\V""'J-
             \'1\~ \~~ mode-l tP 4-'he C.ao\J1c-bJ clec,\de.~

                                                             _,_
   · ~~ -\-here- oue \''\D \~~ues. .-\-c 'be.. tesD\\Jed. lL C.U'\)j
   Of ~t:_ [l.P()\Iudttn -ihr ~rL--\:            a+
                                      ~c..b~ Cur?~ O.t"'lc.-.d~-\-   1
                              FeL\C..\~ V\""\RE bA.\\1\S. C~u.~\'l \:)\ST\\\C..\ Cb~                         hAS.
   Ci. m\n\~1-rex\al til-Lt~ -\o rec.e.\\le.. LlnA {\\.e. eDt ~a.Pecs \o a..
   Cx\m-n!o..l ·'Yrcc..-eed:\nl:\ / t:tnd '"'?~<.f'c.~YY'-1 a.1\ D\he<" A:ulie.s \mQ~
   DV"\ -fu-e. Clerk.. bu Lllw \)ux ~l.lll.n-\- ~ T c..c.t> A~ ~ 1 · 1\ ,. Ll.-n.d
   \~ \e:~Pbn~~ \o\e LLndev                T L.CP \ \.Dl ':)cc. ~                 -+u      \mrhed~d-d \..(
  -h-D.nsrn.t+ .-\o -the.           C.Our+ oP     ~~ a_ Co?Ll ~ "\he_
                                                  C-r\ m; nal
   cu:x:>\~ud'\D'f) ~r .wrl_-\ D~ ~~ _CcC?u~ "D..nj llnswe.t~ -f\\d ,.
   Ctnd. {)._ _te~·hfica±e f'ecH--\'"tJ -the Ch+e w\.,lc.h ~ -\indl"j ~
   vnoA.e \t -r-he Con-J\cftn~ Cou..r+ dec..t~ -the& ~e. ().re_ V\o
    l":>S~ -ID be.. \e.Sc>\\J~:L FeltC..\A. \?lTRt:- I Oi~TR.\J Lle\2..\<.... at
   'D~~' CoL.Ln\'-l ·~ be .SeYV~ n.}- her ?\clL.e. uf \oui1~ ~
    cl      l33 ~DRlH K\vei'.-t.rcnt "BhJA.. l5 \1-DAl\PI.~~Tec~                                1"'"]5·2o"1

"D . V   \0\..k\\O,~ Q'f A:V--T\C.lE. \ L'DI                   Df- 11\E. TE-X.A.~ C.ahE a~
     ~R\M\N~L \)RDCEbURE.
 ~.0\ \he. ·r-e.~?t:.~+ \l\D\£Ltee\.           \\.bi Sec.. '6Lc.) ot- -the
                                                         Os-\-\c\e
   TexAs C..Db£ OF- C.Rim\.JAL ~(oc.c:::~ur-c bu. ~ru\.\n~ --tD ~ru\Jlde
    D-   Co~~ D~ -the A-'PP\Ic..a:t\o tJ          ~r      wr~J Dt- h~ Co"'\?~ ,-a.nj
   Ds')~wer- -t~.-\ed '~d                D... ter··hflcld-e. (~\~n:) ~ c\a;k_ u_))Dn
   whIC-h ~cd-        ·-t-ine!\ n&\v
                 • \l .
                                           WD..Q
                                               -
                                                  made -tD ...1-\_ - t.-UUf'T
                                                                     r..    L
                                                                              U'l'
                                                                                   cf\1'Yl1i\IA
                                                                              \Y)e..
                                                                                      ' '-~ l   )>... ("">

    A??eALS ,       ·wt'"'' n -tn-e        -HM:e_ \)r~~~ \a~...\ La...._o , eu,d                ·
   W\~nl       CL .· \~6\'\hb\e              +ime.. -t='ro,.,        "*"'-e.. dak.-        6Y\    ~h~c.h
 ~e dDLu.YY"'Ien+s              We:ce._      y-~~ --6 be. -\v-an~m:r++d ·
. ·6.01:> TD date..~e\0-..br 'nCL.S. ~-e..c. .:eiueJ \\a ,e.s;>o..--.se... -fvtYWt
                        1

     "'R~s?on.den+ · ~e.~ax-d.\"'"') 'Re.h...-tb~l \eAu.c&+ -fb< --hrl.l.vl'\~~~fh:i..tf
     DF a.. CD?lJ aC -th-e. u_\)o\lcd-l[)n ..fof" W'fi._t D.C hcJo.e.a..~ CoCPu~.
3.0Lt R~u.-e-~ .fD>C +~an~rv'\*wt of ~e... a.,??tica..-iil::ln -for 'wrl..t
   of ha.he:A;S C-Dr"PU5           1     o...n~ a.n5wers -f~_\eJ ,           o.x¥1.   a__ tec\-\tic.a±-e..
   rec~~\n~ ~-e             date-        u?DY\    wh\ch  -tho._+ -f\-~\f"\3 '\A)Cls Y't'llAde.
   ~tr:~.;~~ta.---6'(" --to     t~ t::L\C....\A ~'1.\RE. DA:lt~s c.cu."-'T~ D\~-rK.tcr d&-l(..,
                                                                 i

   ~ C..er-hf\eA          ·V\1\.ail .;    'Pu.~suLU~f       -to tlr-hde            ~\.Dr Sec. ~tc.-)
   D\=- ~-e... CoDe OF C.iel M.ltJA-L \)rDce"Duf2.t. T'Rue_                           Dna CLc.Luva.te
  L.o?t-es. o~ ~e o.bDVe \_e_&l(.s llre- CL~o.cJn.ecl                                  as E:x.lb.+s         J

  ~0.. CLv-e.. ~n~{\?Drcd-eJ. b"j \elefa..nc.e. ~ex-e...\('\_                           .fhr     oil Yur?DS-e....
3e05
    A~    \ s dea..<"""       rc\a±of~ Le-%e.c~         1   '""R_.e.\c...-\o-r htA..S 're.?et::d-e!l'j'   \)t-Cl

  "Recs..?onden+ 0~ ()D\\c..e. ~cct         ·rda.1oc J.e-a.s -\"he_ -\-~C\.r\S.VY\~-\-tcJ D~
  CA.. to?~ OC .fue. ~\,-c.cd\on 1b, \JJr:...\- D\ htiliea.s tor~ , tX.()~
  Ds\swers {\\-e.J ,- and CL ter-t\-Hccd-e fee\-\-\~~ -t\--..e da..--\::e \.A·Po"'
  l.lS'h·~c,h ~c.± ·.f-1 .,....,cl\nS Wo..~ Ynade. --\-b ~ L.o'u.x-l-- of C..f~m; ,..,a-.\
  ClPPeaJ-S eu,d -\:'hd ~i.Aeh \ec.c~d~ {).fe_ \~u.\re.A \.o'j ~ L.vuA-
  D~ CX\M\~         o.PflecJ~ ~            o.c+   OY1   fe\cdcv      s    Wfd D.\ ha.bea.s ~n:~fe.ss!"Dr'JCL.l Oncl C0V'YlYn6n Lau .....-+e.S.v(
. lJ~ llll~ wrJ:te.r. ~e.~PoNS.e.. -tD ~~.~ &v-res?c~ar,c..e u'ld.
  re~LkeSt.

                                                  -3-
     "B,O(o       AR\\c.\t;   \\.or"J      L,\.-eax-\'j 0-\-a:l:--e__ -+ha±TifF
                                           S-ec-tion 'S[c)
      -the. co~ll~dl""e L.uuf~ dec.~ -\hcd: -\'here cu-e no ~
          t5'Sue.s / --\-he cle.y-\~ S~al\ H'Y)Y)'\ed\o_-\:el~ +v-a.nsvnL.-\- (evn~~.,i~ aklei}
     -tc -+he Cou.f-\- _(§ Cx\N\\nol Q?~s A t..uPu o.P -the.. QPP),c.a_-
      -t1bn , an~ O..x'IS\Jec fud and a_ Ce.r+\.-\\e.cd-e \ec.\.-\:\na ~e
      dal-e_ w:b~ ~~~c.XJ +'n~ 1trdlf)~ wcu;: mc0e ji=a.:..lu..c-e. of
     -t-he. ~u_(-\- -1-o n.d- w\th\n --t\.e_ al\l).weA w ~s Sho..ll
      C.Wns--h.k-k_ 0LLch o._ .-RnJ\,....~ .'' T c.xas Co be. oF GOC,M\ rJAL
     "Petu[£hURE. A::\2..+\c.l£ \\.en Se._c..,3&-).~PD~+ \s tn \J;ula:h'LV\
     6~ ~i~ ~U.(e                 /-   Y\1\_\()\SfeftCL\   aLL-t\-es ,. af)d. -th\A.S -the_ la..vJ
     0~ {\()-,~ ~

 b. ~'lEtL FD~ R~lieF
                                               \\l
      w~h::RE~R'f. PRE..\'A\SE~ LD\lSdefcl I ~hlor \)~\c.}_ '&12-,J~
                        I

Tl-16R~M. I -:?cD ~e I '('-e.~?ect.ftA..l\~ re.&u.e::,\-- o._ -8.ncl\V')~ -tr-~ ~ ·fur aJ\ Dnkc d\(ect\.()5 \e&~and81+ --6 +ra.nsVYl L+
  C.csD:J D~ -+he- cv>P\Iccd:ion tor- wr::_-t D~ ~ Co\'"'i:>U..~ / Ctnj
  CL()~we.c.s ~Jed; o.r,td LL c.e'<"k\(\CA±-e.. (eed\.f"'l~ -the. date LLPOr'l
 w~~ch -tho.:\- -t'L..raL()~ ~~ yno...Je -to ~- CoLA¥+ Df &\MJV'Ic..\
 £1S a\fe..c..-kA \n Q(.-\icie. \\.D-z ~DA ~(c.) a.C --t'he Te.~ ~f:
 Dt Lf~~\f\a..i ~DC.6:h.J.\2£ a..nd ClS reQ.ues~ \n ~elu..-bx--                               s .,
 L-e.~r      L~h-lbi.t)                                             ,.
                                                                'RcSFEcifu.ll~ ~u.b mJkeL,
                                                      {?)t.j;
                                                                ---
                                             -4-
                                                       c;
~              '3\k--rt:    DF- TeX.A..s                ~
     Lou..wT'f         D \:=- \A.\ ~~·.+C\_             ~

         I          :s~\'- L>.t-.ide.( -\'\,e: u~ +'vld ---\"'h-e_ +Oc:.ts A:-~~ !>ll£ta--
l\...\\c.~s.. ~\~• ~e cJo~\fe_                ~?P\u::.A:l ;b,-J fuQ_ WR\\ ot- HPdJ"DMA.U\. cue
-1-v-u._e.     ~J...     C.U-c-rec.--t,

     TN~TES DELLA.R~-nl)~
     ::C.1   ~ ~~ ~ea. }JA-tL-0, I~ l-:1 i\. \'"' :::SCA"Y\e..~ \j. ~e~ \.Af"\ ~..\- i
     de..clcue.. ~~ ~e..nol*---1 ot=- _1?-e) lc.Ld\t)~ o..re -\y-u.JL
     ·{).""' d f..o '(" vec::k •

                                                        ~-e.Lcd-D (2......

      F. ~-n-Rea±e                  DF- Sei2.v\cE
             =c.-    ~e.~e.b:i
                             tel-\-'~ ~~ ()._ -\vu.e Cut4 Dt=- \\\e... ~ve__.
             u_?()\lc.ahb~ ~-r l.UtcC\- Dr KMJh~M..U.~ \uu..s. Sev vu On
              ~e\ ic\~ ~ITRE..f.~\sTR..\L-T Cl.E:-~l<- b'j P\nL1n-:3 a_ Co'P'-l                \n
              U.S. \'J\ful o...ddre.&s. --1-b •. \3~ \J. R,~e.<-fo::~·"i ~\JA..'L~·-\"'L;
               DA:\\1\s,rr-xA.s -=t'5"d.o-=t-.. on -+hi~                 ciaw oP.
                'L{JJ 5':                                                    J            ---1

                                                       -·5-
                            t.au~e-   ~()   . WD\-G\qOL-\<..{A)
                                                   ~       "I~ \\:\E ~R\lv\\~A>L
    ~

'P~\R \C1L         '"&~tJ~R\) .l\,jtllXA-\V\       ~
ThL)-It~ \f \ L>lot:tDD \                          ~
                                                   ~ lJ\~Tt\\Ll L.ou.RT ND. 4.
                                                   \
                                                       )
                                                       ~    DF
                                                       )

                                                       ~
lJ l 'STR~ C...T   ci~L
        'RE-'S?c.Jden   +                              ~ bA:lLA:S Co u~T'/ • T~J-tS.

                                    ORDER..
  Dn -th\s    ~ , Lillrr\e. Dn -\n be. 'ne.axd_ -the .foy-·e.~a\nJ
   \e~--\-oc~ ~Uc.ct-\\on fot" \AJ("\..-\ Ma.~mu ~ ood ~t o.._\>PeoJS
  --t--D ~·e C.oLA-"'+ -tha.f ~·e. SlA.m·e ShD'--'-'d \ae.

    --------~R~wTeo

        I~         \~
                 --\.\ne(CefDf-e. Ot-derd ~cd- --fue \J\~r-lc..,+ Cou.rt
 S\-\al\ \r \ \R£.
     bMIA:~          ~t'{ 1\\~~·c\: C..\£9-\(
      \~'"\ ~- ~~~eQ{cDr\1- 1:>\\Jd , LB \1
      tJMlP.\ ;\l£i.k~ 1'5dDl

       'Re ~ WO l- O\q02--\< (A)
          EX: \>A.H\E ~ ?A:TR.tC...~ ~e~1-.IAA-D I\..l6RAM.
          hea._v d-e:v- k                i

                                     I         0..""       Wr.LHth:J --\-u 5\\le.. ~ Du. YID-\-ILL 1-\hcd-- 'jOuf
   DrRc.e \s 6..tx(eh+l'j                       ·in    u~o\cd1u<'~        Of [()~Of-- C-ei~\i\\.11\-L \)roCfDu~£
   A""+~L\e       l \.01 Sec.. 3 Let)
      I       ha.\\e W(t..t+~."'~ --\-D tjDU.v                     Dffire '"PreJ)ou.sly { Lct+ev- dde 4-i-lDI)\
                                   bw{ 'j()I.Av uF8ce hA-$ ·-fo..ae.cl -\n y·es,po..Jl
 t.Dl'""\Le(""ni'"'J -th;s mc..-iter"'                 J

Or     l'"·ePij•· AvtJ\~cc.,.,+ ~~ De:A- cec.e:\Ve.-d C"Anj O'lc\er .fcurv.. --th.e Cvt..J..t-1-
--\-h"_:\- Wou..\c\. cd\i'J,..J              3D-.A<        Offi:L~ -\-c   ·e.ll£.-eed   -th-e 3S d:t_V\. a....-ffovd.e.J...
  6-j u.x-hcle. l \. DI ~
     l'h-e.f"e~v~          /   CL~())~+                05\::.   juu.'C D~      Th       \e'SP6r-.d       O'f    Lurr. P! J
 W\~-\n ~e·v-e() (i) Oa...us Df                                  CL{)P\it:o.n+ "'c...s       no D-\her c..Y,(.);Le
 'aLA.--\- ~ ~~i'Y)-L+ o.__ Wr~+                                o; \1\A..A,jJAMUs       --\--n   -\'\,.e Cou..r.t b\-"
  C.,(I.M.~J~L A:.{JP&AL / Ctnt\ Seek ot'her ~U.ncliu;"\5 -~....- den;al o-f. du..e
 l_:)rt::>c_e_~~ llf\d Lon~:t>l c ~nj -\-o G_i.t:-\ .\VI fA_ ·ll\~cJ. Cun-f; ne~n+.
   \he--n \L lj 6 v\- fh\f Uou.r etK-\&ttl ~V'\ \n -\hl.~ Y\1\ldte.("                                       r

                                                                            ~(Je..cl~~l~ ~~~~-ttd                        1

                                                                           ~
                                                                            \>~TilluL '\&:a.tJA{)A I,\) f:.CD.IV\..
                                                                            ~ ll£>1P0 D6 J
                                                                             ALLred Unt~ f
                                                                              Z...lo l rM.. 34-"1. J
                                                                              ·r~~ 'DP..aJc 1 \.e'k-..~ 7G:,Jt. 7