Court Opinion

ID: 4067696
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 23:27:41.379668+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:40.273195
License: Public Domain

June 10, 2015
                        CASE-   Kio. b3-t*-\-DDr2sr-CJL

                     XN TUt        COWflX DP /tfPEAUS

                                KUSTXUVTD(AS,

                         Elite SUMA/N KLW\_»

                        TUE STKYEBFTEXM,
                                           Ay^eUee.,

                           &BXE^    FOR. £??EU_kkrr

                RECEJvpBX                              %Tit s' E*~\Vy b^
                ^^A/1 0 2015
e^le-v. *r\C<XKSa_r, 333 U.i. 3S3 {^blL, S~7 -S.CJr, -2.SS", ZS"9; „w 1
&V L,EA, Z7%

Xs^ <n*_ 0\/vsU\^>, 3T7 UuSt3S9, qo S.C.V. lOfefc ^ LEA 3fcfc *< • 4

X^AclX oV AviAVvO^Vie^ .                            .                     *
Case. \>a "B^ajJ-.                                                  . 1.

SVoWjAAe.v<V o£- £ci_i~.S                                         — "2-

 <L<^Ut\c_e^-e~ ot %o.fij)cje       __          .                 — 8

               IkQtnXLtS
                *•
                                 OF PWZTXE. M«> tLQUWlSEL

 21 Ap^**^ EVioj SWw>*\ TVtU
                          XN TUG. CSXX8T OF APPSM-S

              POZ. TWE T\tt&D TUK£CXA\- t>XSTRIcT O? TEXAS.
                             MXSTXttsTEXA&

ELIAS SU*WW BOtL,

VS*                                           tt&. 03- W-Dto5lS~CR.

TUE STATE DFTQCAS*
             Af^>eUe£_,

      A^>eol«^ 5-Ca** enure. ^\amlfl£T (Lr\3-bl©*\-Stk. 1a Ma€_
      340™ VisWteJr (LeuA- Tow. G»^e£.^ (UiavsV^ l**a£

  TO THE (LDUftT OF APPEALS *-

                               *TU£ CASEIWBEEEF

  TUE XMblCTMEKTr              AkOsfc^V/ATEfS KSSMJUCT \A£PTU A bEAfcOf
                               VA/6APGVU

  twe ?lea                     Kicrr G»urur*

  TWE l/E£tS£T                 &ULLT/ OF A&&eAVATEt> &SSAUOT WUU A
                               fc>EAE>L>/   VAJEA?&N'

                               TUXLfcTY YEARS XM TUE XH^nTUTHOKjAL
                               ttEV/TSXDN OFTWETE*AS> tSEPAEXNVE-VAT
                               DF CfcLKIHAL TiASTLCE
                        ST&TEtAENT &F FACTS

Cx. W\o£ e>\K\riAe.u3 ©t 4A*«_ -VesAn*/>o*>\j o-V FvAeA, FixrAW/-

Tke_ ^fijdc^rA W^VtvWc ^V\oi- AW. a^eXW\V EA\aLi SWxui/\ ^\U\
av\Q    RtADWr-Vo Rivera. USeA 4-o W         ca©kv\w\eA«-S. 0a May \'2.>"2i5l^

4-W*_ 4~U3o ^TeAur^ A-© AUe. V\o»-i&.e. \Ke.y »-aV\ere_ 34txy\/\a a\ A"o
cits,   QrixOLS AikA gAcoUoL VjgA-q^       Sfcvv\eM/\X/\a \AGJ^t>evn Ar> uA/ie^e

LppefiWawV e*>AeA uf> geAb^t) Wis ^ia^n a*^A sW+eA UitV\/\^
2*v/ajrck irv AA^e WeaA vavVCn AW. VacstF <a*J- AW_ qu.vn. R\v/«/^\
 <2j/sA«>A va^b ^Va\j\^\<* CXS W tbCLS&eA buA- Ov\A &*\CSL ap^e\WA-
  le£A- *W_ roDM klue^ ^sWA a o^-ca^Uoi^ u^.A- £>ui
 4A\<2_ v^>\^Aow> 0>.A V\eaA &rxV ju^tteA ©uA- VUl uUvmLdlo a^A
  <*.*>A \olv\A«_A \s\ T^\ex_£!.s oC qUu VW.\a juvwfteA oi/€/* a_ ulreA
  •fta.vNCje- a\/v<A rtxw 4jb <x /\e.\a\AUorA WevA.se- Vov^ W2A^>.

   o.^olAA- i^\W~ ^ cAeaAVy ^e^on. A^\ +fwve\y aqU<^ o-C-
                                       z
A&xVUMEMTS             ANt> ^uT\AotvXTXES

         TVvQ. T<r\cA CloxArA gjc<kiX \^ W\Av/v* 4W_ e_x/»ievNue~ W W_
          L«_cxcAVvJ $u£C\d\<L»/\V Ao S»IasVc»a^ AW. CJEnnxTtcArA©^ OV AV\G_
         GO&pelWirA- \cxLtUkUie_ AW- ex/\A«-vxGe u>gl£ \^^uC^\(-\4lvvV AxD
          <Ls\rCvAoU&Vx AWdr AW. <X\^>e\W^V A\A cct^wxW AW. &Gb2.*Nse*

      TVofi- SvJ£tnei<>V\CJsj ©C- AW- <t\nAjey\CJ2- \S Cx. C^&sSAo^ ck- W<£> .
X^ -VUe do.se. o.V WvxA ojp^AclaV v^sVV *Wu* VWA VW AeWse'*
a-\j\A€jt»<l«.     ou.Vuj^\oW AW- SAcAels e.\ziA<2.vNC_«.

Ai>\^e\\eKy\.V vascxS v<nA\<A^A £-©cl \rf\W-vxV\&*xoA\xy \kvxe>i>a\rxa\y 10r
 r«.ck\ess\vj c_&A*se. V>eA\Vv,i \/\yACvj Ao ^v^oVjeAo Zks/e-fa. Wj
£Va$o\s\*\<k AW. salA R.\c»©W.vA-o l^wera- v*^\\A/\ <x tCn\\-€-| <x*\A
AW- Afcfi*j/\A<x>r\.V A\A AVs«v^ a^\A AWtcl iAse- 0^ <e*S*\\o\\ <x
 AeaAXy ua^x^ow 4-^~u}Wt k V<i/\i£e_/ XA does ©vn Vo saAA*,
 \oV\d\          \v\   ^VxC- VX/vC^Ar^f* OV \V-S   vjlS«_ OarvA tv\V€J/\A€_A US€-

 &vxA     \ •NAre.vsAeA     u.£e x^as   cfu^aAale oV eA\x£\/\Q    A<lcAA^ ©r

 SglmgujS.         v&oAAvj vu^W.o\/ Aucr^i^a AU-e_ d_owNW\\£&\ovx eA s.aiA

TW lU\AeA &WV<-LS ivx^rxLvvve. (L^rV Wi. \©Yxa e<>W\oVlAvcA
 AUoA- AAve. b«A€- T\rocj2_iJ CAau^e. crt VW_ FouctW<»-^yVU &AAevA-
 Wv£v>A- ^>V^tA-€.cAC (X A^=vev\A<3LVxV \«/\ G«. dJTl /v\\ */vcA C-QJfe. Gl.QG-
 irvsV Gc (Lov\\/icAAo\^ vjl^dva T>root \c*exie»v\A <x reaio^scAsle.
                                            3
AoixVoV    c£- e.verxi *JeucJr v\ex-£-tsGjr\/ A-o C-©As\A\ruA^ AAaoF UxWicAa

X^n AWs. cLoise. AWl, SAcxFg- v^oa Vo \j>raxi€_ AWs^r Cl^cAVolvx-A"
S\-eA>Y>eo      fcAaoVoerAo ^im^ol voxVu Ol. Af> nAYy u3eGufc>ov> aoo/wgIvj

A^XlYW/xA uAxA SlWO AWA AW5, <1&vxxAcAAo^ U20J <d\A-oWlA W|
u^cz>v>^F\AtjA-\oiAa\ -CtxlVuj^c <ot "VW_ piroi€-£JuAr\o^x -volV 4o Ia-Wb-
<Lucje_ Ovwi ev/*A«2j^cc AAxoA AW. uicAn.^ oacj sAcAsUeA \d\j salA
RaV^* TW.              c*_e_©^A sWks*. 4\- \/ol M^&-<^~ 5"? Ua«- \$>
X diAvx'A —*X_ Aid a A r>e_oAL/ _£e.€_ AV/xe. Ar>vA-e_t yovu \<L*\ocJ;
Woauie. We. VxcA. A/*&. l\W_ 4Aui* So X             A\A*VF ite. AW. lG\iteJ

TW-       SAcA-e. iwWoAut^.      ^VcAels. exla\WxV K\o.S"C?   uiWtcJU \& AW

Ka\A<-     At> \o*j&^\ WoV€-a A-o WxA &W-VaWA              ^i&o\a«jrVo Uix/C^a.

TW v^e-CorA iAceWs '* AA- v/ol M po^e. ¥9> \i*^«- *2-\
 okjw AvxA i>cp Ao AWA- Yov^A- youi Ua<A cicA^eA \F uxu a.
 Vli4-*_We^ U.vv\£e\ \i FWA- CjDv^r-e_cA^

 Uca^sUuj X.'**. *>eA xure i£ AWVfs 4W Kv\\£e.
 0\c<w     Yj>tA.V^.   acA Sixre i4 VWiA AW \cux\Q-e,.
MclWuU. UoAexUy Tl'w> a*A- sure \£ A\acAj AW Wv\te<
The. &WW. A<e\/e^ sWotoeA AW Vvxrvi ctAy EvrAe^xcje. FLx4- c«.p$>el(-
 vsexyev vxse      <x. VCAvCe. A-o sAoAoW   R_iv/<ayti-.
                                        4
TW SVcAe. GucA- Ao WcglA«l^x AAve. cWx^ge e^=.AWwxeA \^\ AW_
\/\A\cAwsey\A- ^^^-YvOsjtnA uiox orx W\o\ -Po^ asscuAF x^\AV\ a.
U.a\£«_c Uov^eVe^ qA Fa\oA AW. £FoAe ^>coc£ u**jaA Vae_\fi3*vA
AW. gAWqgAAo^ \>n AW. \^\A\cAwx€^xAr WxcA- Ctv/era v^ca

 asscuuYWA vj\Wx cu. VLaY&l/TW SAcA^L cAsti iVs^u^ FVxaV

 Ao oAx/«. oAoV et Ws.Vvvx^G,vNxi €& ^\y/^rCL <yzk\\*>J WxA irx
 AW. Vi<2J±A A/VQJAxi AA./we-£ L^\AA~ AW- UvaAV ckr *. WvsAcp-XlAr
Iqlc-Vlsova v, V't^ty^Uj 442 U«S, 3fr7; Q9 S.C-l 2<7<frl ,(o\ L.EA> 2A 2L&
SAeJhes AWA AAx£_ (LAxo-Aa^. vxAi^iV ^€_ £_©v~r-ecF ay\A vx^lk^V
 QiVe. d\<-ecAA«3Ai bxi AAve TuAae_/TW cX\&jrc^e- ia Wi-I ca^e
 e>A\y Cjptb\WA AAas. Laui vV c^ve. wti vr^AAracAnoAi, So
 <u^W~ AW ^acA ^vxaA^5 re^A +W Lolu^ AWA- capites +c>
 AUe. feCC^-me. At* u*W do^vx^wA^ a^ a££G.uAA- A^d aoV
 A\^e.cVeA Gr\ AW- ^VcAe. a/xlaiA t>vosie AA^oA- AA\<£- aev«W(x*xV
 sA^Aoloc^ RAvjem uo\AVx Ox Ka^TU^lvx AW cAaojt^ W
 4Ax£- Jurv/ ^ ^^^ Cx>Ar«.eA WiLAiAxe AW. esses/Anal €1€>vl€aA

                                      5
TeAVv*vNO*w    -£row\   ^\v>«ra-   sVoWs    AWA     Fe_ v\ev/e^ Ka^.i*3

Vt€- UJOtS WiOTeA vatxVA W. v^cxS cA- AW. WipvVcA. %€£_

ui«A\ X A\Aa'W-X AuWA~-X JTiAaV v^dFict                          unUl
X     u*as   oA AW WstiWeA.

App^eAWwA \J v\oA astl^a FW Udao^cAoW- <ldva/A Ao we.
Ox AAn\/Ae«-AAVk \uror* TW.            C-SS^aVxcA oAevx/x<*v-<rY WvN2_ vs

 KuS AW SAo&<2-          *>TCA/eA f c CAi^i C_av\ AW £o.cA A-V/xAeri
^i^A AW e_lse^AW\ oAeAxevxA \~ AWs cose.^ as TacAsqa v/,
Vtrc^a,^ \l^.-Scry^Q9 1,CA, 2,-781^^ L.EA.2A ZIP, re^uir«x
Xa X^Acso^ AW, cj^/4- 42oul^A AWV Aue. process y**raA**A
 txj +W -G^iWy^A awse^AwxeLvA- A^-rei AWA ao p*/**A
 *WW W- WsoAe Vo Sxj&Wr AW. OAiaS c£ (X CJTxwx\/xaA
 ^0Avy\cA\ovA 0_^€J^F tA^AUl £va££1(-WaA ^c£ Ae£l^eA <A-£
 €V»AeAC^. A£.e££<SOrY -V© <LoA\M»cje- a W,q_/- d£ -CacA Wya^A
 ^ it^SoacAoW. A&iAA- gC AW OcUWvxee- e£ AW elevweyxA oF
 AW ott^Aic.. X^ AW ezue aA WA AW SAoAe- AoeA^D+
 Uvi€. Ae^Vx^xo^Y £^wv. AW v/icJU^ *WU^ twf^lU»4 *WV>Wl
 Vvl^vx o<- WsF\«A^o^\vi ^v>e>vw AAisAa^A         AoAWa AWV AW. muA^j/
    uJOS AnzjaWA \oy AWvw -te^ <X StoWi-^ vajia/\J c^/xA da
    •S9wvy€-Oa«. 5eA^s apbeiYcoAV .sAcAo FV«_ vjidAn/v/-.»
$AdAA>eA 'P.ix/e-^a - XW. CLoxxA- ©£- ipp^xVi          Ws &a\xj A-o
r^A/leui   ¥wxdayx/\%Lv\VcA o^ CLOAsVnWViOfxcA f^aWAc      A^yx\eA loy
AW \vW\ (Uau/A- o/- AW SWW <TAxU erft^r \av/g\v/^A U«./>a-

vs ^lwx&axj a. cjdasAAWW/\oA <°taWF* AWA- QA^r\f &ljlias*<l-
\a a ejtfS^iAoi ^A»C£JElA\ Aa \/x oA\ b\sAnr\«A- CU»uaF<. UF«AertA
CA SAcAei \* a v/IoIgAAov^ et CjDrwiicAxAcj &A a cAxourc^e. AWA
 ujQS AeV«jA AnoAe. .dole V. Ar\Layxsa.£f 33^ U,£. 3Q ^Ut., ^"7
SwdF, ZS~S-, zSTq, fet L.E.A. Z*7fe.

                                 V*i.\jfer

      kpOeiWvA- A-xcA<£J Oc "H^V-So^x (AcCwvN^Vxe. CXSSecA AAxttA- AW
+ft*A l«LoA\yxa Ao W        oWt<A-\o^ U*<U i&OLU*eA \*x AWt AW
exnA^vxce. cfr auA\A pre^^WA. ia AW- Wiai vet-orA are. \a-
Su**ncAei/<A- Ao ^ULpbo^A AW- V/«LrA\cA. TVx4L^e=£or€_ (xppeAvAAA
•pcoAjs. FWA AW WaoasAjW. cocmtA A\sw^\s AA\x^_ ^aAcaS "?>r»ci-
FtaxA- va^s tA*A \^ a^peYWrj: WWl£ awA AW cx^V over
 rules AVve ^uA^rsA^yxV o£ AW 34G^ VuWicA- xlouiA- dx-Tov^x
 CjiuvAvj ~TeyaJ aaA re.w^x<x.vxA GLfc>^«\\ci^A Fo oasu}xia AW iaqIcA-
 aiGjaV    aaal r»sA Wt /vx i
                                             \2^st>6.cA^wxllxj SuWvwrU-eA,

                                                          - wspe-Uecvx-V -
     IX Arxxe CLopx^ g£- AW I^CveA v-^clS se*Ar A-o AA\e VAoAoPcJde.
Xkso*\ IFeA^VASo^ oA- AW.To*v> Qyree^x (Lau^As! \>itW\cA MAoC/x^y*.
W^ce. lZ4 W. 1ieodAre.Qa.rA iW. Scorx Avxaeio ,T**<xs, -7u<iOl»

                                  %
                                    r- o    I w |

                                '      7^

                C-K

                    '9

         rn

     ^g

GP
     o        <7)
     -n

                         »' t

         Co