Court Opinion

ID: 4042957
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:13:17.9568+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:26:59.293243
License: Public Domain

CAU.SE.      No.~ 05- 15- G\Qo~o-       c.v

                                             ~IN fife s-rh 1JI5TRJcT
                                             ~. CouR,T Of AFPEALS)
                                             §YALLAUc& &ITIRe"TRiALRECd/Ci.EfiJ(#JJ>Ct»Rrl?ePoR:r6R.S i(~
   To \-HE .HoMoRABl.GJ'-'t> ro6 5Art> C.OU R.T: or
 CfiJMJ.1) NOV) JoQ_L A!vJJJ>O MeJt'a.. .Af;pel lOJJT/MovqAJ-ij .:PRO -Af<. iN 7k.
 o}ooVe    .t;:T~Ied a.Nd Nvl'-{heR.ed CCIU.MZ- Of a.c.Ho~ctl\ld f{IW -Hzts~+W
                                                                     .                    (
 -to f~odvGe f',I.J-tif{e~fa.l ~R.d(CLerR1~~
  F-,e.ca~Zd iN o~rNa.liRfa.f ~No. f5 -13- 001fb2 - CR.          J   tW   ,",;a. r~-r Of ap~t"{J-
 -rhts +\oNo~~ CouR-t-).; dewt>a.l foR. vJt:tL-t- i'A--t-R.~ e.+ c.o'-"R.+ of Ap~4W ov
   (o-th ckl..o:e:laAk~.•~.~J 2 oIS tMJAd..J .. let-teA. ( f<_il':JfOAJ.1fb I
  ~Y~ ":J\~ve.c\ f~-t h.~s ,f-/o.AlotZabl0 5 1
                          ~          A   ~1
                                                         Dth--tR~   ~-t: ~~ fl">l=
                                                                >I fA PAGf} ' \ I
  Al.Pe:J»Clel<.-k 1 ~ cuJ EXftiBrTA ~ f_tta..-t-~ ac-tuctil~ ~l_i. Qf t) J
  · ~ a,tJa..d.ef"a.-te- R,tZMe.d~ a.-tLc:u~-&-foB.-tv-fA.~L- C..Gfl ;.D.-,.) Gf ~
e ~-t ~R..e ~~4# e..-te ...... ~ ~ I. c..ovld +h.e.Al !:>e a..bLe-+o F i l~                a-

\\-Of fe..+~-t;o.J f~ ~a.ko..,; ~u--v ~K~fOA--t-<'ovvidW
~el~e-:r. T a.k.e J~d eK~!t::t_tAJed{o Th/s #o46H(abb srh D;'s -
- fR.~L-T Couf\f- 1} 7'\tfeaf-V CIV<..K P(Rs.tJ\YM A{atz...;"t-Acd- d~e
--t'zJ~ J-11dfsjeAJC10 CoNdtf/OA..t _r. \N~ UNah(e, -{O (Ja~ f9I<-.A-cttcf
CB(Ji..9--:? ~ ~c:u~e 'OTAT15$) CoMHaNcfy-t-f.a--t-I a..vt eAH!-tk -IV !Je--t;~
 ()tJv Is be-'tf ~dJ i-V c;uA-tod:£. iN v/o(a-t-~~ ~tAe U. ~ ·

 ~ f+tJ·tto -tP :r !Oof iNdt'c:-tecl@d UJAJ 0 cfedUNdv:!...7-ex~
               '                                                                       ~

 fet.Jal' Cok_j_q,Q? (a) (j} vJk'ch '= ~vr<.dex? ~.I'Ve /;evJ IN CCU'i.-
 -ceA-a..-tecL C'C ~RS.
                     ~t~a Aw~ f1#\ 11.03 Cfifrlf1u.-1- 'tJ !-;-. '(Jiettac .
866 0rz~ff'1P V:~wrr/"f;jL!; rziC/3-21(1?8'!).

                   EI\A'lER.
      v/~0fR.Vvtt.A.4 &,,.~A-LckA..e&1 ,.t1o va-<~T/AffJelkAI-tf<,e!crlW(
      fA..a..W -tftts +{o tJ @..,«(a. b Le.. Co u R:f- vi,'tf (!£wA-<.c/e/( -flu's IIIi~-               '
      _       J{ctt~o,J ~-te£ /,eJ<(e/N~     c:wd ,.Jt/( ~RANT..;Juost1fo"flo-:J
      (!)(>{de~?..f:Af/r-fA:s-/fcW~ahli./h5-th tou~(v lo f;Le.- a                      J.i6JJ