Court Opinion

ID: 4054356
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 05:20:31.562741+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:29.911258
License: Public Domain

3 "'ORIGINAL                 'J '        '** wmoFGHmm^L
                                                 RECEIVEDweals
                                                           IN
:M> -MO.0\o-\^-0Q\ob-c^               ___           APR 23 2015
       .             .                           AbslACQSti, Glerk

            Txn 1W CoW-V O^f _V\<^V>a\' "A^^^eoLVg» QV A_Xors

                V^        r~I        K ~          GQm'°F'CFfiMmL APPEALS
                            —--)     v-r                 Af^-PTTim

                                V,                   Abei Acoste. Clerk

                   "TV«. ^AaN^. b£ A-ex_A_s ^ JX^peXW.

      A^»o\ ?rt-i~N kx-g.aft C.DOfNV^^^\n,\ _\v_*._ N.O.-Mjnv^

            ^<c_vW\o^ fw ^'SCr^vb^ovvJ \U,\f\evJ
                                    ^H-
                          JE_
               Coo^Y of cy\«_\T«A AiffigoVs'
                     ^dw^ ^^ fr^p^WfrvvV

                                 Y<©
                    TV syve ^n^g^^

To TVv& \XmftfaW, \e*A_ CoorV 0^- Cr^yc^ A^yeA^

Lv~ V^^do ^or t?\<bcx^.Vvo^CKrvi ^e\T\ew>x] ^e\-v<vs>. rg.M-e.r'bcxV

  QytxX (Xrt^or^pryV \_ ^^\ue^M ^ A^qAVmnV.                            ___

Qfcovx .F-g-Wuacu \\j "^o\^ ♦ Ayfte.XWV \^<xw.<-c£ ,V^m VXrA ax\<\
 wWeA a ^\_\ _r a0vGx\<kju Ao Vrve Q.o\>rV o>r> or g.WJV Xxte**io*>jr

 tooc<V ftf A^^tA^ (\'3£\c*cwg<V "Vv\_ '^&c^>;tvv£rvV ot w« -VcNaA
 CeTOcV, N^p AoX^o^ -9qc ^V^fxAoL VftS *?yVd _vrtrt*^__aAr __

TK^reXXonacu       S-eNJ\C\>o.
 '^XcvVex^CA'V 0^ TW VroCedvJrgV VAxtsWH pV 'Wq, C_ci__
                                                    4

   A^eUaV€ Vjq& \<>A\c\-_d -(V Ava frC£4.r\sg. o$ ^o^e^soo
to£ Wr6^^(or ooTv ogtov^i, g\\g<fr*A Vo Wvjg, Oc_Cur*4 ^

C-voA -eANe^-ed q o\g(\ o-g- ccCojv\XviV| Xx) Av_ Ccx>cA- svtn or (\\c.cxA-
 pg-Cexv^'ber S ^OXS^o^d -W<-Qo£\er "was 'ko^^wced X-o ^0

cWj cxfiX^c S-exvM-Wg-e, V^ o-raA\i ftcpfMxx>e.eA c\y\A \vrv\^c_ed \o
&pv<\ doucV. AvOfi^WoyVg, \p£f£ecX<A appoA Xo A-v^e S^V^ Cajc-V

 Coo^V 0-C /V^pgcxK <\g£\rfv\ed ArVve ^\.d^rvvg_M- Q^ Ave. -Vcg^A

\_   ftciogx^AeA* N)n .KoV^bp -4oct \^jg.He<x^^0N \^<k£r> X>VgA«

 CfoA XV«l Covjr-V o£ Afrftgote. €tc \jwjc. \V eaX<.A- ^W> gN\«^g,rxi£

(X r-eafbcxyxNo^Q.   d.oo>oX-l AV ^^V-eocATv&N -XWg, I^XgyXe ®4%ere<&
••Vw f>Ar\i^c_ off Ovnq Ovrc€_v on AprA 6, 3-t>VV •-Got ^>o_Se_5ior>
 o£ U\_>W.V- -V^vr Wjrovr>i:> XVxc^V V-(k^V ^_c__o Va^orvA, (\
oe_o,c„^^aYA& c^_oVyV> TW-e.^ \cXa\ CaOeV (\cY^ow\>pAk_A AW-- Vxxier
Ar \, V?,o~7 TE>s, Code Cx'vr^ ,^coC, ^W WA Xo Wk AWr Ann .
Wro"\>n \r\c\AcfcAV "vo \X\.Vo6 \^flv_ ^rt>\»e-r\ Wvjo^d ex rtCk^wl&M, c\o^V^ J.V
^o ^pot>6k O-oA X^Rys XV<L XrrvoA CourV \»^Y\V o^ ov^K %<u\i-e*4*sL
(Xpr><L.\W£g~ Vo ^    ^art. 1 X)C3 .

       Sg>^ot^ X^^e, x>e-%XoyVeA       jb-_«   e_
\>A Av<L VrXoX (LOvjrV ^Vi^r _\Xa\-f ere V^Wa .V ?(X\\gAi Ad

%ilAnX^nc--ej C\^A .\vi\bVeaA ^Co^V^oAc(x\U &£A*.y Ao CW^&eC ^roWA\tx>
&•& a      u_c>_\\>\_   ^-eA^wi^ ,
j            _                  ^c__-A__b_

V>*0lQ^ ^-V-Wce, \^ov._ \^o ,yA\-^A\^>A>(v\g;AV OQ A^xXYcxaVj A^g> XcykX
Cq^^V C__v\_v -VVm. Cjoflsft. Ox^d \-cv\\fvNAA\(-vVAvj ^C-fAOoP. Wfr-rxr^ V€_V\(v\x^,
VjWV cC^&vjV £&A\?Cj q_y XW \>rx\X\a\ ^aj "\Wx-e. A^g- WaoA, Cooc-V
V/(K.b (Xv^ri XVoyV fr^yveYVckAV V\<xA A\V_y 0co> Ov.p\p\\coAv<.r> -$t>c
    prhWX\fr<>> oioA rg-yAo^Ve-k Xv_yVjU__ Gom Wj^A Ao co^vAir

\^\o<\V«_> VVj-.-c* VySveaA\AfWx-g. V--CvS Aa~* CcArgfi &r_A \ybAoV)wce.fVNe^

    \y> Xsfv\_ Co^r-V' t>r _gv AgqWs Ao <y_A- p^_¥ pr^W^o^ m bcgq^
_J____A_a__                                             :

       ~\>n&, Axv\\>re. n£ c\ \r\o\ CqvjcV Ao (LQofbS^c- AVg, AoN\ ^o_c*>)g'

    Xo vjV\\ca A9^e\V-\A^ pWAiA qvJAVj V-&S c<\<xA\_a\ <_vfi,\'vuc\^ o-g

    \Wrb Wq-V ll rr\Q,*>\Ja) AeAwervj^ \^> ~ AX-XrAWvX^ Aaru<^_ Ao
 Aft AVsg. XcxN^« "\W C&^e SVoJVA V>_ r-g>»ec<>gA a>^A ^^oor_.gd„

 TVyrA \^b^L r*._^kA       ft   p   Q

 lX>_ \r\o\ CoorV A^WrikXAj frrr<tA v^ ^^ ayftfrs^vrr, °v^9_?\_A__

AeAvyvYN^ \\v<v\ \\\t> ^\x\A fW-gAAwvexvV ^\(jN>fsV Xb Co\)^S«X AoAr^
a cAV\q&i\ ^Wbe. o? A\m. c<aS_<                 .

 Facte
        __C£Q ^o<NiL A.^oVA:^
                       j    .-, AV_ AV\ArV\^VA
                                            _  Aooa^ CX-QXgC- ^cAVe^cig,
V^OJb    Oc-q\Vi \^T^AX\L_LA_G_<_k-A^
^-bV4-\j lAc, ^Mn \uCr£> a^>pt.\AV<A (fo Cou^S-eA on a^ft~_x\, fvir
V>\_ nM <A\A f\f>^ \9(xt<\ o£ a\_ t\^c.\c\V<^-e,c\X- v_,aC\X Xv^e. fo\\ow\cs_^
(W^ Avjxsa. Sj 2-bW*
.. W*\j—cxaA Ka/Avj^js                                                           __

 v^ e>o<tA covjcA A\^ %.\_ a 'CwdXxorx Xpc x>-e\j Ay\a\. \a -¥»A_
^frx^coW* -^(Xa (W^.\X(xaV va Ck _c\>(y>\VnoA Cn&e. X^ oA Ov A\SC\SiA.aV-
_&-G^ Cx_t*\^LrgA Ao (XA Q^Q-eWc^V \o Gy e\vA R^^\jV;V&Ve. ~^>b
(Xooj V>\aAqvj WrA^s        Aft roxA AVov^x W. drA-e, AwV          \ve -?0r\>A

 •CnM'A X^N^oAAqA jOf\"\0^yV N^VJV X-V^- <Jq;Vg- PC \Ve ^ATv^VvX^ of
_AA_L ____A^^.Afy_^&aV ofo AW \>^^ (Wft^Vg- ^DV V.eeVLSj