Court Opinion

ID: 4056193
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:41:24.13778+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:35.249475
License: Public Domain

FtAV<     ~~ 27Gf~·?:.-·
~--   .-                                     Certf\)\\J~l. t:DV'{[f lFIJc-P12At ~ 4t.,tlVllll -D~
                                                  A~~,;N T~~s
                                                 fcu&1 \~          Coue_r    ()f: ~'                              - ,,-
                                             .       ~.SetA.        ~~of\\o --r-.e~c.·                   ., . .
                                                 3\)()·<~~ tour\- ~ A~·t·"
                                                         \....N CA..'\--..'\ V\~te If'-       D(

  £o\ond .S, \)tfl\ ns
                     Q.i\C\\or ~ooe\\o.~                                 ~CUJ.~tt 'Z.Dtz.ce.So£32
      v~,                                                   ~
                                                                          (\ (){).e.tX   I t!: o4- 13 Dol r;; I c... e..
      S\tA \-t cC \-e:i.C.{ ~ \ ¥\~ t\ \sfnct-                 ~
       ~~(\-- ~( (fQ.LN\~               i    4~
                                                                                   This document coniains some
                       Qes~~ ~p~\lu · ~                                            pages that are of pooli' quali\t)j'
                                                                                   at the time of imaging. · .....

               · ~€\ \'1\0NtQ'~- QEQvt~r ('()A'NOI':lrvt u.r IVlJNC pe_o
            TtriV c. \...\ ~ 15 I:U ~ L-0(2. Puc \\\-\J<       "~0\.\ c., AT 1 tOh[' PET         >   r1 Q~..J £Z)~
                   \NR1T             ~F f\1\~lJDf..MvS               fVUJJcJ,
                                                                        •
                                                                              PRO IUNC
                                                                                                    '·
                         No~  c.omes: j2{)land S; P-er-k)ns:           1
                                                                           re \a tor       ij)ropta ~v-so"q
                  (r\    the ab{)ve. eQM.se_ oF ac+1ot'\                   \..\ubeus Llol"~~' wcr1
                 - ()~ \'J\~~DI\mVS an c\ t-JU NC peo TvN C
          --~.
       :!-<,•

                    Pet""suo.nr +o ~r-'t 22. z.z1 oF'fM TeK SoJ. Cock_ ~c
                   0( t 'c\e Y ~ecri6n  f, tic(\ anc{ 0ltl
                   S'i\WJ -t\r)e COUtr r- t~ fo\\ow;V\9 ~ ·

                     ·\h.Q_ t,().U-r ~ hac v(c\ortd +~ reta:to r ~- pef.tti<>" ef's
                   tons·tTT'tt)rlQ\ rrg'ht Q~ we l\ 0 s th~ T-e)(Qf L?()I)Sf,t-
                   uhcn.a.l r tg \'\ t s .· ,
                   .. 'B\J RE~£Nl.~NC)~ c AND Wf?ONGFUtl'/ N\OO}FY
                    \l'JG t-.\\s or\gi..,a.l .se~-ttnce..- W\~out. ·ttu fa.ct-s
                 ·, or ~1\'\g pve~c.(l. jn a eovrt of law b '1
                    WIZOIVGF\.ILLl/ Chaoql"'j f 'qn t- \.feao i 6 I«.') L{..eatS
                                       Fcortvo~(j)ta\a.te\1" ~to~s -~hat on .A\.q.J~+1-
                   Z013 He wa~ s.&vvtence                      ·+o
                                                         tlq-ht-- year TUJO W.&~r
                    Aptet' S;M\~V'tCl \')~ h\'~ LQ~·"/~ v- ~0<"(\.Q.. ku r C(Jx S'c.\ d
                   ~ Jvdq(.. _.~~~o Uv1-4-~n~ -r-roth tO 'f!at"\ +CJ
                 · ·E-'g"+- \fear(' by J2;d~e ---/ln~v_.r M ~r(\ 1'-h., l-4~-~
                  T ~\ct \       cwv-+.. .
~o&Jt-  ?.ofzz.. ~~StevS CCJe. Pv5:> i)i£.-rr OF M ~1\/QAt'f\.-ltJ Nv"(t ~TTIN c ·,.·
                        DOciDlJL j e0 po <'d "t 0 Rtf\ ,e_cl Dve Pr0 ~f'S'
   Vt" \·~41 skte~        B(l \ of e19~+~                      Ocns--t ;t(tut'~"'

               DD0tit Jtopo rt\'1 .Dtn~·e.d          Dve-   Proces.r   oF l.avJ
     Dou~ ~op9rd'1 Re~tr~ct,'o(")_s oF pr~~at--e                         pro~-er fy
     No\-1'a be.. t-C\.~<1 w;t-hov}- ClJmpef\.satt At>P~ 1late
           Rule.r {)~ ProcecWr-e See reAP 5'9{ej C.orrec.J--fo
          \eNtO\ie. E. rv-1') vI IV u NC, Pfl () TC.N\(;c'          ·:,\<

         l S b.e \ 9       peA-( t/or,e_~ ,ttt t t . "-J OvJ ..
                   11
                    "'                                                          · H       '   •

                                             Pa.~Z
                                                            pq~ 31JP zz.
                       J U RI S D I C T I 0 N              . ;""·rc
         . Under flu arf,c/u Ciled h.Rrdl1., flu Coarf
        hfl.S 111Atrei1f jJOwer.r -f-o ~nfiree ifs Jvd9€111RI?f
        o! Byeat"S ()Of- ;o y~orJ' 70 /~/led- 1!//· t'ufYtlll{-
        ~'/&1( senlp-yce J/fso qror?f II;£ 4/c;f&_.
         .4,:;;Jitc~nf- 17/Yl/Z ~I- ()1'1 JSo/UI 411er arre.cr
        and ~r) SCU'l cho/J J.
                            141 s r o .~C               v
           .        fJ1tJf/QI?f   wa.r senfMced    llttfVS'I I 20!Iiil •
          f1ec;~ /Jnw4~d _wn/#1(/t:e Act~tt.r,t ?g;. ·?ozs
          1)so ()(.1 ;-. IJ h 13{::b1_d sm CL.- ? o 1o. tv h /e It. c_au( 1-
          0rcf/#Fec/ SarJCflo,., a~ ;Jre.:foa./ camntc/nllr,Se'rv;u
                   Affw- ;9/M /3::;fYjCll'n .At/'~~ OYJ Jiis-
          ?rtl ()wz of- #.L J -11'/tt 7rtq/ COU/' J- JCJdt;~ .
    ,     ~t/f IJ1 r:c/m'Jy war ~re..stdin.:~ ~t:>h-"' <;;q#L€
·       ' /)11. /VOW jvdq.e. !.);(} {Ucl- o/ fdiifia;h'On U/1/.J /le:J~
          qrar1 ;- o.-            fWJUJr   8yeuv ..5M7/t!'IJC£, see /'ekiol..
           /tJ;'1   cS.utJrf~ ~r-.f                .
                                   A I< G/JEME         IV T
                    /551/CP P/2-EJrrVn--.tJJ 11 ffJL ;c/1 n r:;JJ p;iU.Ph kl~ed~ 1 Phd 9t--cvvff'Fe.te(Oi€el) fu. ({~J)vi{ox
      (apre.cM r Ott~ t~H W.rr -t-o h.e.ar ~ J ud!Je (fi-OA.Ou{\_ C(__
       T -e ~ ye-ar r ( TN."' ~e~ J val~~ vt t 8 y-e.arf
      Fov~tvl C(}Ntvr oP ~pe_QI SO-vY'.e. ~vt- fvMr-e,
        ~"-1-e.r D~\~tLOr"ar
                                 1 {liNc"tw. Af>DcD TWo'4eflf2r
                 \2-e{a\c~ ~ ~ouqh r- by /e{fur hobeur (!orpvJ
          to QMttqc. (:) v to \l'e.-c.)~ 1\vl. l Y\C.O rrect- ~+en CL
           {) v-- fay flrtt 1o PuFav-~ ~ ,'"r ~ \~ (, <;:rf-e,ri t:t I .·
      . DuheJ             · (()ef2r (T T ~ E C"L E" RICA 1-
          E-tg.\Z..()t       On NO~r\" ~ Z..:.0 2 C?t+ Jl~n 1e..d
          Dve proc eJr hH r~ la.-t 0 r ~ fu h~ lw-CJe c~ {ecrc: '.['1
          Ch._fA(\')"0)/ 01'\.d T/)C')C/D, IS ./lOt &ktJlct h~ htr
          t-r~ propu/7             he.-,~ '" ,Heqaf ~vffv~
                 [..\e rer'Y) th i( ~f dl~41 Ic~ beTV\_'J ft kef ~
           Co rY"'ec..} Ov n)£ ~ ·ch~rt ccv( ~(Jv- of-~
           \)/1{\. c«Jn s rl tloftc.-1 CtJ" r~'N·f\r\ M t S--e J (' j __ D.o~
            by t-ht rt~f>.cn~b ,Yt t'Ntf- offic-rctf
             C.c:..(Jc;;.c~W. r;..u..{/tn 9 0-. correc+e..d ;-~P-<.d~rf-
             o ret>" ~~ILc.hle (Z.u(l~ r'A Favw ol-- Ir-e_
             ( {!__-loto·v,                      f;\ . c-
                                            .    r~~
                                                                             --...    W4   2~

7o~     ZZ ·

                      f'tJtk Cr/i'fll~ta I Jusfta 10, o1 11.,.1z
               TtY Ct!Jrk IJnn.
 F~QJ;f-y oF Judqcmgnf - In (j-mtf'a/ tS l?of- a .
Pma!, )~dqef'Jtlh1 f or duporing ol exetJ :1?: 011 .r lo
;8v;  tf'd(c fr'l'trJI- cS!afe V (Ja.Jclu::;/ 18~8 32.- Ter·
 <5 B 1 - S+afe V: 7horfon lqttJq . 32 TeA:. I 0-
                           1-,o~/rfr ,v s-k:t~ /877 sTet Cr)VY\. 17
 pe 1-J I                                                                            r
        ·t    ·.          ·

             /0})     ft; r Cer f-ar I U/11 If eel S"'lzt. k f SupfltJ /fJ'-{ CQUtr
                                Judr;eiYlhlllr       /?everred ·
 .      Or          OI111(1A.JlUc/ rnodt~:ecl o~
                                           ·tim t-ee; ~hi& Sc:treme
   Ctwr f    $;rt_ofl'r,~ Cr;;0;rt e;/ C!oa/1- oP ~,a&:~lf(_lo/gj
  .s·~~Slt\.1 .5tob Fea'C Sw
     ~d            (3 t:,                  '                (
         ·                OJeFcr 51/J c~;Nc, l/Y110 ropv- oJ;ee/- o,-
       _Correc/t~E.· or~r t;-tt· fJa,-fe Toc.A.Va re/ld 137 Sv
       5 d 7Cf /l.X. c I'ltv\. Cuc/J (?oot)
                          ~.                     .           ;   '

      ,;~ -\\~~\l( L~~\l~ \\\ ~~~ ~'tt\'J ~ ~~\'i\0 Q,A"NaJtv'\ 'BQ.,\t;~ -~"""
         2

8t): Z2 .·       f4.\T\c~ 4-Z •\L :~ taJd:Q_ ~r\ . . 1"-e_ .J\[d_1e
         s\\n\\ ~\- 0U-\- -i-N. \)I\'\ c\: IV"leJ e ~ Qoo& Ccut.c.e. d'\. -thi
                 L)0~~~ . . .
                      -                    ~ ~ mmu"' ~ ~vt    Ss p.evv' l s: ·1o 1\ f6v- offU\ Q? r
                t,Cff'~Vtte..d . ~C.CUlx                  f-  13>\a~ or ()'f"(J u.ctt c..e
                5Rc. i'~A~) ~ cou.v-\- ~~a¥1+\1\ 1~f\
.,.             fb'( d-!lt'fN\.~~~e. oppe,-)vi\I~J.osee 6DP"f
               (cz. S: vJ z;i I '1.3 S.e~"ftr "'fZ:
               ffio.f\cta 0\;\tS wCti . ct:v c{ [.(a bLt_ · -+v · llf:> G? P f't\eJ1~c{S of
               Gtettl "';,... i "0 w ~,. c.n iVI. iMI Jr ta-r. &\ !k.lL~ dliJ(Jf.{'
                {:\1€ of: Pa.roW to ""'\~ Gn.vtl&e \ \<'A Cq_J:e. l )'\ v olu·~l'\ s
                chff~t\ ~ ofr€v\.tf               waI J 4 · {8           &>mpe-l tO/IJUS.tGn
               of-. ~·ur~e~J.. Al+t-.o~h · Jvc!Je. ~no avf¥rr~
               +o ter~'~'h-oJc pvo/Jah\0"' o-rcJ...o.rf'. JSS~saqo,nsr
                Felo(\~ DW r             Gf"a.tVvj.-t..d <9 F-   ST.ATr: P£T\T rotV
         Fo~                   we.,·roF          MANOAMuS                 1(\ re..    ~4e:,:1e.a-kvte. {JtR,ft1t.o~ fb.-
                                       •
                 ~tlltV            .r.
                                            \,       .
\JCAo[: q vF   zz_ . . IJJ'IL rr or; M/J rvtJ i)mll) fY1 c:mo Or: LfJ lA./
        .CODe     cJcftnltVIJL   Pflocr;nuru:-~llr '92.{)8 Prorvovrv~~/1 f
                                                       L

     oF· Sffi?r.t-nce,              Aqu,facr- vs: skfe           /J pp  io. Dis-f · .-
    20"6 r, t!\1. ~d        640 · ~iff t/O(t/«U                     (J.ehJ¢?1 fb,...
    i(e(tr(}/ftorl{tf?t r£f/leV! relu.re.d. IF a -Tria/ c]t/1:/rl-
   1/JI~h io.- cu!rmafe ~ftMa_ /r · OrC!ffr. pro/JOc/Aao/.
   Grcu,, v~ -_Eh~ IJpp                14 Ot>f- @o~v :~-9-t
    s vV -~t:l r;rs . Sen-+-~ e~l'i9 . a~ ;Jv/Jt:~lt-~n,r'_ _ l o~-f
                                      ,. ..
                              A· Trra.( (;{)urf        chci~/()n -~-~. rcvf,~·ak_
    S   ef/1 fence      )~' 0 re;t ( ('t •    fJ r () r) 0Ull("e. ?';;tv I elA/': U/.6ov-
     fJbi/S& -of drr-e_re>r;o;YJ
                              -   .     .    .                      r,
                                                                      .   /
                                                                             -
      . · ~.              _ L ;1'"6z ~ o r:re .('.r..n'Yn /-if / ndv/suq ir
   {) t/IYJ t J)~rr..fh1 J- · a _irt ~ I ..J1/ ol'f<. de Cri_r:l on -Ia cu I M1110-/e
   Is. q. n oimo~la·f ItA~! dlr7 r -R f/O/Lt?rx_ f-u-rzc·:h. on
   ~~ _ciA~.[ r?of- f-ur/) o/tf'CI'e-fe                     F/rtdt·'ns· rpr IXI,cf
     f!119--rtq/.fct-6le· o/):-._. Appeat eoo!t). _2>o s--~_.?c/
   IO"J ._C·r;m1M( ~~ · /f]y COv/Zr,
   u ndt-r. Cfrjn.-f;11 v Q l;-o -n . ~r (J"~"09 ~a rn f?~tLd !'_an c/(o:VJ
   whtr:0 .CUnrkil/titJ~ /~(J.Ofee/ ~y IN,. (!_0<..-~r/ /YJ .
   .. )j)ectlt~ ftf'r--1' or s;x c;hc_                        tJercod
                                      /OtJ/2zpaqer
                     WIt fT   ()F /11!Jil/{)Jlmtls m £?YUJ t::F-UJw
           jl) tol/1ns    ?- 40 .fw.      3~c( c;l qzq IJ·fFtrtr·altPV'e.,/1
 iAJ4:1vec/    hls. rr9hfs         77:J (>f~$1?ft3?1ceJai/ 1?11'l..e,, )fJ
 re JtJ.se.     tlf'ru f!a.     Corr;ez    /VQ. 03 - 05' CJq> lZCV
               Couar OF 1/fJfJt:ALr /J. v.r:t/N ·rt=XIJS .s~l, /h~ t~ot T    . SOtJCH!        MANLJA /t-tU~
   . ~c~ord,Aglly we granf- QoMez p_ef//Jfron
 Far    wr,/-' ol f'rlarda-muf one/ IJtrecr fAe '..fJ;strtt-'f-
 Ct!Jurf- -ro· vacaf~ i1- 0/21)£-e Dt:Nv;NG C,omez
 tnor;oN f:Cf2 Jllol9flrY!.Pl f NU!VC fJ,eo
 ancl ·fo- en·fer a JU.dj'frhll1 f fbr ()u(Vc (JI):J            c
                                                                      701£;
.AWA(d DIA/G &ornfz Ca£tJIT Foe T/1Yl£: QPCI£1)
Pf2t012- TO .Si::.NTbN(!N6-                       Ufe    Tt?t4t-;,c,.)/Y\ Coc¥
       .        .

  .· . 'Ptoadure 12. 035" [h) fledromG fn~l~e.r/1\7 1/
 JucftJ£ af fiL.e. f'1me fJrCJnOt(/}C~enf- CJr ~r~nce­
pf·.cOIJIJJUtnmt-. JJlrm1·/feQ' Aatce -ANY eJ'[fi..ER.
C-oN!J I TIO#.S TAlE ~01./Rr CkOOSE Td
 1/,1/JOS~.
               ~ Arl- 1~~oq 79-~ r 4 Z·,/h Lf Z; 12 16',d
  ·, . . . . ( ·.
  Commv/11/y ~U/)Bti/l~lo/1 ...z:-1- t-.C' ~ ;u~,t:Jo..ca-  -+i~'X"'e -~rved
                                                   n
{)rIa v iv. 9Nl ~e11dn 9 . Mrdhocq ct€f tVI.da:.Vl t- h..Q.Ve
tn1-ex-eet ct p) W OV\ d +-l~ C{C(tm vYLB11 t- DlCt q, Ve '-fk
defe;ndo,y)r Cre.d i~ fby- t1~ s..w-ve..d· .       \ n · ge
 Go1Y1ez ~QP 3 Q\~}- (zoaa) zeo8· Sw 3ci ·z~z
  S"ef\t&f\C\Vt~ aif\d Pun(&hfNI\ t .· .
          ~2. ~x·tr~r::sENT EAJC £TIM£                           .
    . · DP/tfl!ltM f fA!ho P"!ec( -fo rY/iY rCo war ~fl'l /-tile¢
     w     f';ffLe_ sa-rved fA         /f\e.Yicq/1 (JrJsoiJ -while        Qt/V
    6!ihhg·, .eXfrqe/tC f;On £odoe9vz Vs. Sf<:.rfe
     Aw · 13 r?oo'J) @oop , WL J!JoiZ. ~1
       ..>'tnfenctflg oYLc/ pvru>0hWflf'

            f2etlt'iw tl-1 · -G~nerol
                             fire ·!J;ied llppeal ieJ t!lictlfeAJM~N D~rt\VS.
                    · /VI Fm otfJN {){} rYJ oP ttJ w Aluu c {:(J() TlJ AI0
                                  #AB~as {}O/LPU5
                                    -
            In re Jose Urruf/a Gomez, /Vo . 03 -oe --oo
. s·r 2. c ~ Caurf oF IJ;jieqfs. of- r exas· -~wrfln .le,cflv .
 ~~)                   @!Jct&MC/tva). · . ·         ·· ·
.         :         likd a. :mofioh FOR JV[)G~ME?vi
              ' :JI1mcrfe
 . NuNc PRo· ruNt- . tnaf ·teqves reel 7/t.af ·his
   U:~meJ1f- of Ct!Jnvrcfto(1 l:e cqrru/W ib. Clcd(),,d .
   IDPd f';/ria credtl-J". d.O/J; ed r-eft eP in !?ttlft-. .,tattc;l1;,
    tnCJrJctomus          re/1er                                             . ..
     ..         .     .·_ . ' uose Urruitq                lhctfJdQ/YlUS      -fo
    CO~/            .tt:J. ·tl)fer      ,11/t/ll/C;   (J~o T~~o, .. cYc4?~          ..
    ~r'(Jodtfy~n !J ·~iS r/f!-clt;e1Y11YJ r o/" ~tJ/1. f//CrtfJn fV
    reF/eel~- · &ci:;.ftlr\:R Crecttf-_r         !Or ~ r:ea.s·o11_r                      J

     -expl_~tn · lJ-ereJiJ, We· C!.. e;ndtf!0!1..Cll(y Grant-
    .lehet'                                               · ..
      · · . ·· ·             · · T.er t'CKM kJnohfecl .-rz_ .03 @
    1-lJ!esf!j./f@ooB)   CONS'/F(}Uc;-N TL y
    LT}~ I JriQ/ f!.aurf 1S f'equJrea/ fo ~f'o/rJ f '1-ftg,
     cter-tytdG11t, his  P~FS£N r~A./c E wlt4·Pf
    ~~fer1ue: IS prtJnaan::.:R_d ~ &·;:.K:>1fe v·'dJor/a
     11q ~w~ _l'"\ONC l'f\~0 ~LtlV\J ·
          Tel coda.. ~1\\'\ t.:n 42         :ArttcJe.. 42;0c s··0
    ~une, \Jr~ TuNc torru~\on tOr r~_fo.:rM&Vtio(l of
  3Ad.Cf~t > C,ou,r~ ~CL( )v.n.,cl\cticl" +o (e(\d.tr ~ ·
  NU1\J c \)to -ru (V c a, )v c~t~e\'Y\ ~\1\-\- reNAtr ~ a-Pt er
   Co(\vic+~tOr\      ot        a \)(~v\IOV"J'__
                                           _b~( 'tfr. ./A.O/Vl J- /i; v _(o b bery. ..__ _
    !§..tAJ j U.ri9~1N11 I Q.(I.C) s:&11 t.en C~rL9 r e c.orooe!1foh£L
   b '1 +1'\.e   ~ ktte , ctr       an {) rcta-tr
                                          ~-          f'A-Od c   Pt, n. 9
   Ju~l}}- Tr~ ~vv~d w-0-t eLt-I'Y\#11- r0f
   JL-t~~~ CoUirti Ur. S~fc 2--o-D 7 . z_·rested aqa/n~f cPfurdanrjy
       SHOLIL.f) AFPGA Q IN JUfJG€HCNTI' tJof CJtJitj
       111 ..ie-nf.et]ct'ns· ~veVl r~ c..O- ~1-afe &tmlnO.J .
       Apf>e4/ {_q11) 17 leK" G.rJJY\ t:lJ'p- ;4oJ79 SvJ
       2 . d - 5"45                                 .      .            .·
                                 R ~ L Atro      R. 1-1~ ve- A. RtGHT To
             A.~P~ A L              Ff'o·~      SE"J-rEN C 1 N C
                fjur1c_P(o ·Tvrvc                Co~£Citi'JG                CLEgl\s
         t;·rroe - if\    en·\-etuf\0 ~·~€-V)~ or m \nv'IEP avt..of
        ~·~ CV! j vdGje t'Nvvts1 on q· ~ ~'-f V"lci A.:J c.ad. d n o t
        ~ Uce_d aS Co\tafS,r~) ar·facl.of                hafaeu..r .
        Cav-r \..u·      ~ Pa rte fJaffer ~ 01\ I '3 q 'Te.d(: c r Ji1,..
        4 b-C1      t·4 f , s w 7 ~
                     (                  wNre   n p ) vdff!lM1}        fou,..d     ol
           Con Vt cf- tva..r flJUI!lc/ I 17 re. {;()rei c·r/m'/11 ct I Cr(}()tf-
          of App.ea/J           F 1dct,e-r v sfc;,fe ._Crtl'YI'ftVA( c(JL{ r~
          (j__qS:12) ~'J 2Z.Cj , ~W 2-ol          7<1 e·r,rvt , _ . . . _
                   _ ·.· .. ·· c)u~~ J- of (]CJIJ VtufforJ lY.o?1,
           (;J htat IJ fPe.A.J ~a tt he... fa f£PJ tJ ,orf:: nv;; fit V .
           .f":fttl~ of c rJm IlL~ I {;ttWr{ of?IPfJpe&t.f ;·?~I
           l.J.o r~,c c,·r,M Apr:>'. &z 1 34J ~v/ ·2-c/ __
        .~£.SF/C/rE/VC't:
JAIL TI/IAf~                  WQJ" /JO!- Q       17e;tSJitczfec/     T-t'/m   o/'
(J?    a /Jiec;  !?cttq-·Q;/J 4t.JretrNYJ f.      . Tl-/1~ SrArve-
 WOtlt;....lJ APPLV: TO ALL StATUA r0/2'(
 IS A c~ TPA'A'l£'             ,           ·
       ."'           Gomt?z tesjJ()ftd~- W!fh while
   C.o/flll.f hae/ ltJj e c fe.d S(}/J'.-f COt1 flur; or; .- .. .. ·
   ~~·fo ;vu!Vc /)ro ftl!? c ~racl;(e                 Jl. ;'_r
   L;h?Ji-cd t-o -IAe ca.u wNre I #.e. . j2FCOR_f)
  /2EFL £C rs-- a tt.~arvi~' o~ T/me Cr-e_ctt1-.s; IF
  7he Jud9e {);clnr S'ay if INn Otff/lldan(-/.r .
 £JV1/17L E{)                ro       4 LL   //mc·SPE7Vr AJ,t:"/c-(l AYl!U:.T'./,
 C{ 1'-1:(        £841 r-..eu. Ct l1.:J
             ..      7ll.f2 om0tt11.r a./- jJ~h fe?Jce_
                      . .·
  Jttt! f;rr...e waJ !?of q /Jevor~~<::?ferc/ 7erm o~
  f(&l OClrtjQI/I :Ld if? Sc.tC/ry /11 st-@1~..1- ~
   .'f.OttrJ- i'M;JJta.Jiz.e r 77;;/f S_hr.lve we;ul« iJ;?~~
 · 1 o Ci/1 IJ~ctc· ·rr~                           ·
                       JLI!J~ENENT
      NUNC (J(J() Tl/NC GR.ANTFfJ
                  fW:Je iB
.   \1:\o~ Zl~~                         .      MtJI'IO DVl.l'lw >v            Pi2.~1'1'1 E: C.O.V~I cA!;"f' S'
                                               0 u~ b I;' s Coo a..sr-        (\J ·'{AQ_ ~-s.<:; i N   G--   ~ t\DbNGE"

         /he S1..1p-re~ _CQu;rJ- ha~ Cta\ \e.o( O~~ol uk \ 1'\fllvlYY~
    ll..)ctS. ec:;~abl1<;;~cA i'<\ \~'o\ev- v. p a~('(\~
                                                                 124
     U•s; · 40 9 (icn <..) A d eo.+h p.e I" a H'f Co..s:e wh\ch
     pCoSQwtor was o.cc tt ~Sed of Su-p-res~f()
      BJ)do,(\CQ Q,!')c{                             .itnctv'"'.c))l '1        u~IY\0 h:..,~_se.. te~d-~men'1
                     ..        4        .   ..Sup-reme           CG.U:\f ~
                                                                tr1 a-~ Ca\"\ed a~ol u+e
     \.mmunt1-'1 a                              ba\aV\c.e of ~uii'S a"d S~kt:/ ;ts
    -tb ~~ . (,t"'d...-e~ea *'-e. wro,g d-OY'.e. loy ct'l.cnS' /hvo(ve_d ~Mif
      f>14dt. by a pr~s.eur/rrJy ,tk o~ a /Jrt!Sf'. CO?h.ren~
               S-ee-. f3tJctiel(                          ~ r/i-Z>/MmOrJS //3 SCI. @_~;o.b_).
          ~ 1ttJ)                            . 7JLR           . ' , . IS'                                    /'
              ,-_                  . ~:                    cl/5/l~c I( on                      TO      tA/ AQt-       C()rlr~
      /S                  Rnftfleet '1-o                   /1?1/J?v/J/-"7                e·an 1;.e                eom;r;l;c~
    due '-f j- . /It dtvf'/J1Jr) 1- / ·cbf'~1'tCfWt? r~ t-1/t:i.fe y·o n(!I'Cl/f'ed
                A-~ I§                        yectrJ                               .·                             _

                              C ]             Pr ~J.eCt.lfor         NOW            Jv cl9e i 1-1fvr ~Ch1 f~cl
                    ·-hJ       {jl     0e   fY'e .   fr.-l. de f vf\da i1               J- I   $' ye~ ,- /J r/-~r 17'-(
                    _)vc~ COr! f111 w f
                     r e l-a It 'Ct fi;o r1           .

                                                                    /9
                          -            fl113Yto/2Atv!J()IYJ 0P i-IJW
·.· .. 2:'0 of Zl.pfiJ.        fi1 o/?.ro~ (   W YWNG FU t-    cavw:::n()rJ
            /

      .   /JIJorfeJnS ~ fitormn rec/eved c;;/mo.J&- 2 m;J//(;-n
    f'} ()o rn fJ.&rJ ~a t-lr::Jn /)I us kft:firr.e c:tt? TJ lltJ.v ITo m
    ·IN ~fate. o~ ·re,eaf                 f?'OR WRONGFLit 0oAJ11 1 C~~OIJ
     Pot!ow,~ q· a Ccu.tr )-- tr/g·LJjr't Ordil'e_d /J y ~ Te~~
                                          m
    5upr.e /J'\Il [1(.7),.{ I' f. . . 0 ( /i; I? r !/O. Pf't:fv ted
      . ~-n d &. 1CfV1·t Yeo r-\;. i~o 6 T i N'Dt- t0 '-fear-<;:,
 S~(.A.nn7 OV1 ~\~ ~-e!Y\.dLd C?\'fect-e..o/s~t
  8  /f 3/20(3 l~ e. \.S: t\\~d..\\~ · ~Ld \ Y\ A ccord.anc
  w L~ vtoYa·~ ;on ~·~fue ( oY\..(2) ·~ C.Ot\ ~+- ,.t u~ot1
 of ~- Uc S, CAV'-d S·kr~·(!_ of 'l erx:.o.r. $up('vv+-ee?l b'1
  f(V m l) r ~ o 'IV\. or Ca.~- l a-J . W    te.t: /1\J F~n..-rt..Ji:Y2
   {)ocJ.u i"'3 ~lM.JR ~u~Q.us L-IJY'r ur. r-d~ ~
      . A u T I~ E N ( [ (\] { c l T'-1                  0 F
                     ~?PeN            o       i ~
  .:r· S~IA/f/al( Under ~- p-P/lally otC ,/)tQV/'7
 1ftq_f f11..e !l? ~b~ /K-a f7·o-r; COr? ro tn e_c/ lle re /11
 fntf (Y}of;on tJe-lrft.on /1/VNc ~/2-c) /vrvc              f/V"dt·r
   tJ ~ m fJ>1/ tJ~-m v r JJ-;'j(J -e;v f eo ll¢:V.r /1 '7rlUe ~/\./t1
  ce~er ft4?J- on l"htf 28 ..fv, 0~ e:JI" /h.ay
   zo/5~           ·                                           ~~-'--
                ·C£12 Tl·-·Ft              c·.A· L_E           ~                    =
                                  OF
                     S~/2:-VI            E· c
   1Art /hr9P;ns /ns-:JYvh'ffl ;- /S tyM
    RH!UEST
    CONDUCT RECOVRm'
                      Q ,.,.. c '1,
                      ~ r . QJMIV 7
                                    r ,..
                                                            I
                                                                1                                   'J
                                                                                                     s\
                       0                     j· L(t:W\
                                                                                                      j\
                        }f .                 I Ll   (\.j\                                           ~ q)

                        't
                       Lf  D                 }."f
SHARON KELLER                                           CouRT oF CRIMINAL APPEALS                                       ABEL ACOSTA
 PRESIDING JUDGE                                                                                                            CLERK
                                                            P.O. BOX 12308, CAPITOL STATION                              51 2-463-1 55 1

LAWRENCE E. MEYERS                                              AUSTIN, TEXAS 78711                                   SIAN R. SCHILHAB
TOM PRICE
                                                                                                                       GENERAL COUNSEL
PAUL WOMACK
                                                                                                                         51 2-463-1 597
CHERYL JOHNSON
MIKE KEASLER
BARBARA P. HERVEY
CATHY COCHRAN
ELSA ALCALA
 JUDGES

                   November 25, 2013

                   Roland S. Perkins
                   Dominguez Unit - TDC# 01876813
                   6535 Cagnon Rd.
                   San Antonio, TX 78252

                   Dear Mr. Perkins,

                   The Court of Criminal Appeals is in receipt of your "Petition for Discretionary Review."

                   A Petition for Discretionary Review is filed after an opinion is rendered from the Court
                   of Appeals. It appears that an opinion has not yet been issued from the 4th Court of
                   Appeals. We suggest that you contact the 4th Court of Appeals for more information.

          ,·

      .. :· . f\ L
               . , Sincerely,
               ;-'~;

        ·()J._J~
                   Abel Acosta
                   C"·!.~ .... -J,
                   '-· l ..... l.l'\.

                                        SUPREME COURT BUILDING, 201 WEST 14TH STREET, ROOM 106, AUSTIN, TEXAS 78701
                                                            WEBSITE: WWW.CCA.COURTS.STATE.TX. US
'                    •

                                                        jfourtb QCourt of      ~ppeal~
                                                               $>an ~ntonio, UI:exas

                                                                    JUDGMENT

                                                                  No. 04-13-00751-CR

                                                                  Roland S. PERKINS,
                                                                       Appellant·

                                                                            v.

                                                                  The STATE of Texas,
                                                                        Appellee
    ·~   _,.   .
               '   ...
                         ...,.,                .From the 144th Judicial District Court, Bexar County, Texas
                                                              Trial Court No. 2012CR5082
                                                   The Honorable AngusK. McQinty, Judge Presiding

                                      BEFORE JUSTICE MARION, JUSTICE BARNARD, AND JUSTICE CHAPA

                                      In accordance with _this court's opinion of this date, the trial court's judgmen_t is
                              AFFIRMED AS MODIFIED. The trial court's judgment is modified to reflect a sentence ofte·n
                              years' confinement.

                                     SIGNED November 26,2014.

                                                                     ~    .................       I
                                                                                                      /""-.

                                                                                                                     .-~
                                                                                                                              ------~~-   "7'-