Court Opinion

ID: 4045601
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:54:54.766814+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:29:54.945595
License: Public Domain

'QW\L k\~z_ "‘?\~LQWXU`;

i

/`

`\\m. hL- N-mn\<:_c R
' '7 '4 )c. ~ __
¢_».,__\ fmme \_,_EER\U§Q`L “EWVE@*?“

 
     
 

~- FTLTE\B\&L Cr>x)&'l`
The C.._ourt Gj‘ P;Ppeals .--.` § .
A?Pe\\ar_e_ S"““ mm °; (\§;%?WE§Q(§_ '
~ - ' ` APR 1 s 201 - . g `
\\\&. _%TP\TF. ss TE> T¥\E_ \-\'Q\x\x Q'K P\&\§;_ L'\\AS‘\"T\L‘E_§ §§ `1\*&~_ C»_D\.¢U, c\£ l
"/`\’P'pf’_(l§__.s; ' f

\\\_<\_A_L> Lc:\x\<\€_`:`>, /-{PP¢\\GM_\!~_, (:L,~v\¢\ C`.\¢$ X\\Ls \N\Miot\
m \:>&_ACLL_ m_ `<\KE (\_mu\\\,u@ j\_\_-e_aa\ Amm \m\c\_
`'S'”N><;_

AWL\\UL umw S\r\_m> mm <\_mvr_ m CM;U:

j\_» .
C;&\x- .=\\A\\a ag\~_\(\ ’Am\w /~;P©L\\ cwa wm (§,m\n“c&d @%_
m Q&&mL §§ K\m\aw me cl `r>u`.\.§‘m&, m ££m&_m.\
QL\U\.\)\ /Qm\§\s\\uk\\o_ \Q\x \\\'m‘:_ ‘N\me_ A\ \f\l\$b\\§<\'\`.\. _

K. ~
T_\c\¢>_ §`K_C\._B;L `L¥\.§-_\EQALLL_ Q_m,m.s¢ Nr:s‘. L‘:>i§‘. 0\"173( S;W ignka
gm m\\;g\ mug umw ama \m;,; ,Aue_ w m £ac& mae
c_ew.w mm E\S§‘;b\“mx was Q_ ”Pcw:.;m £CCULL _\c.u\ Qe,£on_u‘

C;.~\L Lx:\_>\]k max \>e_ \J&e_ \-_n €Jr\\r\umc@_ U/vw,\”m §*uic_lc(l'|
.C‘L\mu \n\,c\h ”bur\¢»\ O_@AQ_ \Q.‘+-A§L&A\

» \ _ bu\\`\£}\ $P::.L}(i¢auq
S‘v_u, his [§\ v &L\ml.e.; t:>‘c\/\M dam CL £.&LL£Q _Lal\ -Ce,'mnq.

w gm use_; m `\L_Lucm\w 'r>& \:BM_ FDNW Cm\ui‘¢_&_;pn

\_L_\u;\¢\ V\v\nw\uu@_, §§ `Li; ‘Lu_»_ga-uim ,~ /\m L mgm l:h_jumr;
~\='c> £ /u>\>@,umx; <;@r\_@&um@m,c_ chhi;
\-\\; me\ cLPw\"\hi /‘€c°mvm¢u €§\LX cl Av\)DF_I& BR`§L€ cl||¢_g;n:i \
-\A\U.L \'\Cm¢__ ¢L`\\§.§€X\_¥_\\A _§E_a/\LM _de+/\'\ 'l~'N_ C.l-€AKL Qeu>r¢l `
t g   ` Re,'um&. C\/m& C>\;§@b\a §§ wl M v>£ I@_, ama ii L_g \(\L; ”+>mc¢$s:@m.c @P:Azon emma cum
'Prc$€.n\ld Q_I\)\ov/ !\_vl> Qunlavm&al €N\nv`/ .Mb` \\Wv\,£o| €.l\)we-

CZ\N\,L \'\(5 ‘€Q_,\/U\£lhw_ F_J\m‘€ C>CL,\_va.§L Lm 'Um¢ Ca$e,,

¢-`

\

. T__.
'C\\> QML \\n §§ \% §§ C.cwr\_s<_i N\AA;)L ?>\‘N_& Lr\ \'\i`&

-Qm€>k \\>Ck€_`_,~ \<\_o_ Q_L\;L ‘\ \J&LLLa;te_ \‘_Ma Lll,~e_§a,l U£e. eF
(_L_<:\.A_>Se. M\Z>`\ Y>‘§`.B\’Yl)( gov _\’LM'\UA_\/ JC_\'\`L_§ (]_L.\'_ §§ C>¥v\m£z.$ér\ 15
C>\\>\\x Q\<\:>Lm\s\ru \;`Lw\n_,- lahu`

§§ (`lCLuSL VUO‘; DX.OVT`)/(.
F. '
cm AQ\\\ &. 105 /\Y'Pe,\\ah_ muw,x cL `wn.€¢cp_ £N\wg
&~AM_ "\\_<;& _\u;mcp\ bunk \-\cq\ hew C:.e-w/\Jc.e.; cl adamson
§§ ~\:;'\W\_n_ ~L\Ctz=_r\.£a,k w C.\/v\,& `Lr\c;\.uk`m£s LAHM_LL\_Q_QLS"¥;Q €}\e,
\AMLM_ upom_ bv'l¢_€, M~x_\. C_@w& m re.uze,wp,_& gm 51%+¢
Q£; \__`cxm `\m §;\\ls f;a§e_ Q_L \:Xm_ `v\/\n€\u\n @\§v U\)u,u `Cv\*"cd / 00va
`(\A\Jw\\m.l\mg_g \o§ W\A€\m\`§

Q`\-\e.\ \>\4 \~\/\o; CL(>P@_L»UJ,EL Q,Dr\th.ms
LAM_ K.LLLQQ( w£c_ di C'_cuu;¢ mut

D&l 01"¢’13( \be €m\r\a/»\c@ wynn bui~
\JL€_L ’cx> S\»\¢> \MIW_X id t\r\o_ »Q&L§;‘; €5£ {:\r\n. L&ded R)n€$h \/v\_r)/»,\},i
` /;\\__S’(\'\,or§h"{
A _§eJ\/\Lemc_a_ L\na£ \_s b\_>&$iLa_ H\.L
\ch\§e_ bfi '?ur\`¢s\\w\o.v'&_ § unau+hr>\¢{)_e.& du LCu,u O/m¢ ilwu¢\we_
KXLL.£\C\/\. .S'+"_z_ SN\`\Z.LL\ \/. _§’c('lt&.,~ l‘\q_$¢w.Z>A 20"+. S’Ol=> £.Téx.c_rim./=\Pm Qan)J
/!\ AQ__§&\AUV\/L

w\wq ®b‘quir\ \rdi<£ lémvv\ am unambm.`l¢_£ 30¢\1¢%@*
Lcr\ c§.`wujc Cu>?mj Dv du C\. wvi'& 0€ habeas (Lor(>u_$,

_`I_YG_¢&\`&\A\Q\.\W, m £‘vuh';_ Q_\I_\"\A £`€al \l\/\Gméaw\u_<; ‘<`&(i¢>_.@ -Eb \*e.c\:¢"€
c\/v\ `L\_\_r.e\u,\_ w L_Sr\am&\bv&zp_&. _S"@Jv\£mu_, `_"L'N -U\L;e, irw$+amc@__<, thL
gm c_b-\,\; umw saw cl mm .bu 19le a rmi/m 120

‘cc mem SX ®\ex\orw _l\m_s;h@€mr\ E:\)PJ\ lam Ca.s¢. 1

V\/\oLXiw\u\/v\ m \N\}nim,m

<,Q ) l

T\N)_S\.L \’\(L§ ‘(\€M~U\ \Q.op,r\ C]/Y\M’\~."n`mfl `L¥\ TC,')CCLS Lw,d_
)ck\w; ®m\¢ QM>LLA mm wm walsh .km;;<;.:()¢zm m»@\

®_ C_»\w\`\nu.\ 0_01,5€_ gewin Y\%‘<`\t_`\<\.§ w -C"_owe_cj;ir\_& am
` `\_\_Luu,\ _§P.N&M.

_C‘)e_@._/ €_/_‘!m .S:`mmon_s` V, _€+al:e_./ _ /$L, `C;G(. c_)r.`m. Q>ol , bo;l., él'~l<-S`,

aig (‘_1¢75,,)). (_r\m+in.j +Ba,é "no umw m _+h£; _¢fa..éa mci
0_55€,_<.5 Cz_ ¢>umskmm»b 'H\a£ Hw, C_a/M/ owes no+ am/wr/'ze ’/..

'R'u&\w\ QmL \r\ gm ,» 'M ”T¢x. Q,mv\. (ebs;` ea§, /S'”7$,w, w/, 93/ /?/¢

;~;\m_ _Qm_»_ §§ lim mud `e\m:_shmi 15 huui*'“§ww&_ m
g _S'e_h am \<\ Tem\ cch \D`.~QSLL,\ enm@ -'\Jq tlu_ m~;_<./w¢
Q_'\ ciqu _5'@;£;> lawn QL\C~.<\\Q;¢ "UM' H¢\M a _$£a)@_ _Aa.:\
&`¢L\c>‘<\\»\ (T<’\A¥\is\\a,\o\£. LB¥\}_»A S&U;[or\ \Q .B_S fal. '

AS cl "Pw¢, Q£ Cpo@_\\rm_ va?@_m `Lmu§&i@_, m wore
o§>@@\,\m dimmed am tm wm cwa md medqu
"\'J\i(\c\, QC)\XQ_§; 3<:\<\"\5 &N\B‘( Q_QY\K€J\L'\M §§ Hr\l)m l_&£,l( D'(‘r `\r\i?@/\-
VYL‘\-_cd:-`;m\ @& ~H¢\L LcmB _§'c,h DU¥ `\v\\ fPC)r\a/\ (;Mo. \§1.'~13$(!)1
M am usm gw\_ mm w mm w Q.DM‘W__ L@n¢,'.w_.
mko\§; §§ t\r\¢. CL©PP,\§\U:L.

:`L_¥`_¢. CA_ \C_°\'\L§wm Qu.a§; k\r\o_k '\~lr\.n_ £m Lbu\L `(\Jb& V€_~ LLS¢
QL_ '@\~Lurm £&m _Xo£»\ Qe\om Yov\zs\¢w¢£e mm L;..Bsa w ve.-e,n
hamm mw _Q&m _lull Ce,&o/\q to '\;\\L L¢we,\‘ 104 01 QNA
Ae.£\re_o_/ Y`L§a/L.L,'\»e_§g. §§ \\,uu> they bound fm UA<)_ {z\rw\_¢_.
E_§<\'\'>nc\=\>_scq `u\tw\€>veia£€o¢\ §§ m LDW\AL)QJQ. `FP\)NI-_<;kab(¢_ umw 12.3&¢

_pr. sue §.<\ m swwée; ge \A.~m amax mm wm ehw;¢;
£c> \K~WKSUQ\ ' -

Y(.@ l;\\»_ \cLqua-N§, QM;\_ J€Mk; omu¢;k Obkm¢_ media/mi Q.m MM, ‘W\§& _XLAI@€¢.,( C_@~/z O_Q_M:\£`~q L>r\&u j€)/\Q\KM
§§ Qe.'\_§\w<\ \;\v\u)c (l_ \:\r\_\a. L.vv\;\ L_(:wvd: Qc> W [~\1€ jc:LuL

\’\(\JDFQ`\QA \‘\Cn_> §Y>Q_Qx\ Q‘co\)`.\n_k 'EB C_\£)\&< §§;KQB A.&\QIK_E£
I_m 511 _§£¢;Lic. _:\>$&`\LQ. 'B) mmc mt mm mack _Sta&e_ twa

A\l`\;uu€_ a ;1@ T€XAQ\\\mA, TL)<@< *\5¥0\ `m Q\ugir\e _Scu`A_ c§u‘_uva¢
`\.3\ il QBS*:Q_~¢L »~ ‘PCL‘A €_)r\u L&U>Q_ GMA V\M,LL\'LM _S`CL.A_ €mue,LopL
\;`\A uni&u ;&uie_s \/v\u;\ £\/\L<. A©w`\\ \\\&;\\ &Q\S ,

Q\()v\/§;u`j. \mz_ R\al,§oc.

C~H