Court Opinion

ID: 4069321
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 00:32:56.877472+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:26:53.115425
License: Public Domain

"§;°$ §§§§§X§‘§Z§§§?§:;§;;°°““§OURTF;§§§§:§&AM
mgqu . , ' ' . sEP 2 2 2015
- v\wi§ sm~\g;:_ ‘“> @qu’b\b*\‘®@%@o%*&\@#e%
gm <\c>mm\m

 

~ F'T\r\ <:4 (>,§)Q\\mvi`€ 0\>`3@¢‘€5 to t\\e. SX&\€F;» Ye,\?o<\€€. `\~n oyposs\v\ows
to aQQ\R€.u<\*€S @<§Q\`\@r£<`\o‘\ Q¢>‘< wv`\\; § Yvi\>eas cov'p\>§» '\h€,
6\'¢1'¥&, ~P\"r>~§) o§r:z\ &`mc\`mg€a 0<<` caa*<`_»ec>w_\\>s\ms 639 \clm 06
me,\\ bag,-gpp\\mn“\' wo\ counsel o\z?lc\avi’i. `m ve§§>cm_.§e_ aa‘oc;\4
(JI\S\)WD\~“QA by ‘r.\\a€eu>`vc\. “\we_x)\)\)\{mn’\'_\ze)'\evc% \;‘ne Xx\a\
Cc>\>r‘\'_ ch <\ adopt \Je_\‘.‘oo*-v'\m thc §§b?i>§az\%\n}m\g§ 'BQ Qacjmnéx )
O_c)<\(;\us\cm§ 159 \Cm\\mm§e, \1\/ '\~_\\e sXa&c/m‘r\id\ Sae}n ig?mo€ `

"L¥`\/C»\€D\)v\se,\ A?Q`\,C\£L\l ii \9\&’€£\€3"*610\0 \m\lm§beer\ Qomn¢\m\\c\r)\v\
’\'_\ne. apQ\Xcuv\‘L’<‘emvc\@ 'The_‘ce_¥h@.a\>§\i mmi¢;%e§‘.. E>\-\ L@\%(:\C`L w HQQ 100%\»

\5\0\5 §§\nl>w\ \r)‘-{ (WQ ?\c\&\l`\~‘; '
lmv_;‘\?.n-em\¢\’chem§§\&mn`< (>‘Q:\<¢c_*r_’u> \~_\;.‘txiu\ Co\mSp_\ C\"v`@`\{\a\(`\¥ C\.S CL
mhb\e,-\\zwose `\"r '\e>un€>u\?§m"m§ ‘@J ’r.\neve_€'.c>‘w\w 'T‘<\ea?§\l cCA\n\~
SX~Q>\F)<\\Y \')c;\'\€.\le$ \'_‘C`\&\ QL>\)<\%C\ C\\?\:§A.c\\l’\"< SY eu¥\§&®l<\'\e.\!`mé.\c§<§\)c.

`\<`\cx¥u'vc; ’L‘Mcx\ Cc>uv\%e,\ mm e,\m>_c\ X_c> ‘c_\nc$ucir -\ %UY‘§‘OY Xec§~ \3/ @QQ\~
4\` mut max oQ \ .~ c;-'?>%' l>\c>¢©€\» \\C\O\\A\l-R\ ~"dw;

-\;he,c.??\\wnt€a\ec\m C\q\m am wx\\\am 3 \°\om& 0\30 a§)€'

`\i¢cm‘v Qc\ec\ e<>m§d\cxm`c 0%¢1\§\§;\`<\~¢\9~0:@3 Un?ro?ess`»ema\
anc\uc;`\; Auv`m up\?\imv\’c~_ )¢xco\ m`\‘<\<\ \~_\'m, 5\0¢\;.~» %&_ 3% Bls“vi\\ ’c‘_‘¥ comm
@F TRY\?\A\AT \m’¥\/\ "\`€_X\>c§

E)LW\¥\TE . ,
. mm c~z%’ o\ov\¥>@\;»\\"\€\ \\\W:R
Yi m\!`\£> W=\\V\§ IS_

A\>\>\_U.\\\<.~€§ e>w;um“§ 10 we wm
_ . \?mm“e>§ § ¥<>d~_"i ~s\\\w cnm_\um\&§ b% mg
10 wi mmc>m&>\x u>\>\v< §§ c\>\w\z_w\\, \\?? e\\\b il
m>me_s aim '¥`\m\\\:‘> §)<>N`\S`SX'_ V\\cs `$\p\%\'\c_un\`!> b\)(}e_c.'\wm ’\.D ma Lom¥@
‘v`mA‘wBs cz‘v` Qac;\c_&nd CD¥\C\ bs`\ons b€ mm wou\h$\no\b as§ {>\\ m\D_">`.
DEY:Q:\;\~\"\ vi?\‘€sw\`-\\A;§._

u&? ou“A'm°c wu“ae.\ \\\x.\e\cm'\$
\Oa\\§§\ic_b

zw>om§€§\' v\ <\@<, w\¢\m a
<>_K\>L \)cl\\\:X\c:> €'N“\Z\~mcx`\\<\ X}f\\§ C.u$e_z.
x\b Q,\I`\Ae_nu.§m‘c GC\\) A`\ 'ia\|\ov wmv¢\\¥‘N u‘oc>u\<_\nt>\» w\ce\$| S\\G’L'> m-v,‘(e_ Q`\vc. 9 \\QQ\:LCNP< clan cv\\ 5\\@.,
3<\0\..>@§ 3d1th \‘4\@ T`Lc\ \or had cam\\\`\\‘xec\' ‘{e_< A\w} §\\e)< ms?w\& ah >dm_cxw¢sw\e, z Q\%N>\.”SSY @
¥\\<.~\\u\'<\<;~ add `me>u§ eo\c\\s %L?e< `\ux\cz>‘_\\u&§w{\e \oe'm§\, S\(\e'\;

0\¥.§< c%\>m\\\l (\.0 md feca\\ am er_‘<\\l I\\r>\s mm`l 3\\0>€. we;<_e,@\rc.§.
\`<\s.\>~mv\§ mm 9 We.‘\<\c,`idw\\'

~UW‘L_ m Q\ Ci)`
B{)P\'\Cm\\_§(`€§€l\j\.

\\>ded\ X\_oa§<. \\{\S`(a`|\¢_\.‘r`£, (xI‘_U>\>v\X. 0

®

mm <\c)°\;`\'<\c§>r\‘a\§\ e_‘<\\ us`\‘d\ 1}\<, C\l`\A-Qx\c.c_= 'T\m»¥_`\:> t~_\%\§\_\\??o\~’cec\

\Yl ~thu€€.€_b`rc\» @\\BD twme.\ \?‘Cx‘®\": `\‘:~.» 60?1`\¥\%‘(\@,`\5 "Q@_\’\ Q\\ ’\{B E_\/\u¥,

B\Q. CLQP\‘\ mr\`\' ‘_)\no‘i_ V<\o'€€. ¥)nu’\_ MXXM&@ L)A\f\ex\ Ene, evié)ex\€l}©.';‘wk shst Bu\'. amc §\“Q')e.c,\\\e. web \`@_C_D\ICC\ _5@€1§?\\\;0\,5?\,,33>

ma 'Ya‘l\or em\u?s€\\am\i_$‘<\o‘;me<` §»`\\re,>WS

TY\‘). `Yu`/\m‘ Sm’°f. Cz>v\~:>\oufe,\{z§ \o`i 5\.‘3\&_0(`\&!\££,» T)&e, "’

®Y?'\u». Q\r\r\§Xo\)Y\av wm ’u;z?v\mom fox w\e,A \d\s£c \(\‘d~ \0\>\\€35 of \)u\\ek
‘m>\es max z §Dm\§ even c&>(¢r §ea\-c_\<\`\ng Bq¢c_¢>m§\@) 1\-§:> <\S\‘<\\@ umwa ’cm‘c_u\¥\\ \Y\& Thi \o\'

accounth i\w@. \ne,`\é\e.r\i\'_&@r \`(\<. \\0&\§15 w sod <’=Dw\e‘v.\\mg \x\e\e,¥hr‘c y

Srm.® \mm wanda '\Y\r \c\am$ ‘\`<\\\e§¥\g>a‘ceb X)Ns ma,., P\\§L> m\'\p_x\‘fml \o@

EMMX\QM §Xa’\_cment“\d\¢;\£&\q a(`.\?¥\\`r_cm \»_S\\O\'. L\Ne,\` -' § \\te,~&vme,§

&4; “\§\¢:m L.>\m\e Hr\e,\l mug `\v\. \`{\w \?x>v\ 01 UCQ\* SC€_@\Q\\\ID\‘ ‘\Y\\§‘\~L‘D

`\\'. iam\u§ fha ¢\\)‘(`I w\‘\w\c§ \ demose, *crw<\§€/\ (Y\rv\>\cr<\‘i$ t\i?u\e£ &¥3225

to ’c\r\mh 30 t\\e,‘\\> d§e, €no\.k\ X',~L\\ X§ncr.\\)\“) -A`\‘:‘<‘&%M§¥&\e_m S\M\cmev&>

"'K\\m quXexv\¢v\Xb \§\+rg__<~gj\¥\)\i wm°f_\)ecau&c. X)r\z,wc~l w %n`w\`€w
mg diaz w GYY\R mm was 5\\¢<>%‘\\¢~ M‘< mm ~X¢m e‘>\ 05 X\\@s“m,,

mm as Hw, wound mpw\_ 09 '\\§\Qcc\\§ e\\c\ becausam\~§nc,`w man ~
®Y`O\m\\)w\s t:».?`\r\\`\£)(\ -\5'\<>:/ US€_.J`:.WM §§ch SX€B(QMQ,\(\XS £0 a@@x~cmeh

1;\\&. flw\\cun‘r_ coh\r\`c,\\om Y\\s<> SQLM\B mva cz\f \>RQ¢@\S ve.\\¢e\ on ’€mm
§¥u\'em@_n¥_% 'Wm’c. UQY\§CCM\ 5\\0\. m\>\X-\Q\e. \\w\c£, 310 gmm Q\P\\\U'“)(

m¥ex\[.\ 23 ¥B\’\l\\ \)v¥\n "Yn`/ \vv find Q\ov\d,,
®

mm \\arv‘\':> QDY\\\>?,A\»_A mt`\ ’L was §0:>3'\‘“\@, ~‘¢\m`t Sc>\~¢\e. § 15\@,5\“@"€5
Q.`\i§r\o_\' m‘\§‘>ec\ H\e, mo c\\‘r`\~.<‘ Q,\\| m pusseA ‘r_‘nfou§§\n \-.\n& cs§e_(\
m`m&>\..>- `le$ mm \\arf\:z C~‘_cm\e,»u§ wk\\'t¥\e%e.¥hegr~} 09 L,:,\cu\< ‘no&\)w¢&

to ‘\:¥\¢c>’d\<’_r bu\\e§t:. T¥\c§.`\§ c\e.‘? ic.imt”?c&'ermance,\o‘/` mv \\M‘<\'§\‘ocm\)se,
_ C\i\d?\`\¢;m\*\_ U>Y\Xu\\f, Jérw{‘c D. l ‘iea\' \0€§0<‘€_ \cr\a\ ma$ e\wcn§e;’v a\%@`oe§c~>m
‘d`\o\ \\<>‘<

\`(\x %n\<\e>/ \ A\$o o?§)\\ LcmX_\mA A amm§m 0\3 \-be_ emma wave
a\~_r_\\\v§ W\v \\M\c“\ 5 m\\# s>xr£c¢ Qo\mh csm.\m\\c;\_ mendez @Qg\\~mv\¥
e>v\\\l :‘>\m)’< am e;w\/\<>. \\I\'< &\oxr'\s§cx\)`rk w mem `\X \m`€~ \\Y\e. ‘ms 0sz

C_\`\m`< maf> 5\\§0\`\05 W\M`c_ bC\rwu\"\ B‘<\:;A_`\me.("\r \\61\'€\`5 AQS>XYG`I€¢\ ~\\\e,
‘dm>. »'LWY\\ mm!\ am\'\\>\\“\¥~l 139 bus& swo’cm\o§ @ue.'*<\me,» (\\§D‘.X:r\
‘©<\n\\m‘\§ c§&\mxa;\ 2b g~\`{\\< \Nm\§ »§m}\*‘<\r\?mo§: w`\v\hc~>\os ama X\\e_§me 69
'“\K.Q\o‘<\ej£a\` mem §§ E'.v\ \ T`(\o§ `\‘c_\.¢o_% %m\
unsup§b€\£§ \o`l ‘\k\e_reco\”és §e,€.§?\?\\\{o\.‘§ \P?_‘LZ 5» \5) \`v<\a h ®:<‘<\e,
\.\S\r\c\r>m§ `\‘<\ 3v_\(\e,\re.\r\ac,\'e_ mem L'>Q en is § \`\v\c. \:> \§‘u\; mwccz\plkl "l (~"c.°(w‘c
u\\ 59 X)r\&m§ ‘Z> &.\.>\uc)m>v\e,mas .'a\o sack ?‘A’(\. `Y\\¢Ymc wiv\Ao\J 1 O~J\
+_\\L me rem door °. \® 635wa wm adam s ?1\\1\<¢1@§ 5\’\_ emma
kLS\X\<\ XX\Q_X,\Q<) §m\a‘< dow w\~'(\¢;\z>m§ §>p€.~m` \;’> X\\ex<.u\,\w>‘< zx\?oss/
§ X\;\`\W ->énc.,£ c>X§nex 5\<\£>‘<‘) wm M\xe/'i \\X 1065 cian `.\Q_X¢\~i .\L\wo\) c§)\o \\\¢
’cm \m\\\~@\>-‘c 511`¢<\&¢3“@\5 ¥\M-XB'\"\¢\€§Z \\D\X ie§» i’)o\c \'§c\e,?'o,c.‘< s\:\\ §\w&,$ _
'L\'\u’c. ¥_\r\e C.‘C‘\me.§€.cf\€. S<’.u\“ c,\n C>\>Q'i<‘..cx Q't>\>w\,d m\\~l @vxe‘o\m\`\e)r Sce®w\w\\\\\m

15»€\)» _ k ®

- 155-mdc deed c\\\_ "c_\<\c ‘0\;\\€_}<5 v ¥c>..(\:`\v§’r_o? Y`{\\'chbl \0\‘ 6\‘\<\

ne>+_ am upg\ “\a~# \o\~ said aqq\\mm 5th
at wm w\\\\@ aug \.>e.w_\<\w&<)<_\\e,\s max e>c¢@w\m.¢\ w\»

\§63 mle ind @P\'\wvi €\rv>’c mm 9\\1€"3’€. *c‘;\<).c`c\<‘v md ~€\IU\_\\L
miss` marc A\A ‘&xe. 5\¢\§¥§ 35 113? 9 ba\\i§\’\aex$?ev”¥_ mm\§>\me,
Q\`c>_§a¢\`\_e& '\§na ¢§u{\' w`\"\*\`\ CN\Q \`\<;.\'\r\g €\l'\r¥en€.c, 03 -"Lb \§‘\Q,U‘W\YCK`
09 S\Wb‘% ae"‘ma\\\/ \"\ve§\ Auv`\<\a i\\a %mm`\s-§\m S?Jdr\c. Cr\m<>
usw\¢\ \1£\\1€, onc§@xm`meA W\§T¢#\o\` <\\>mbe‘( § 5\(\0\$ .§\1€_
za;¢\‘mag §;QA at 35th L\\e.®y\m\>< .,§Dm @\m>< >e@@

ms 5‘<1:>; \`e§°\é\>c mr ‘<\_X ec;\ chs\e,, \c>‘<\\i en ‘én Q/
hawk 09'\9€01?\@. w\w kave, 9“\<‘¢§ ag\_\n ':\\z)m do \Y\r \'\(Aw\& \'1¥10\,>
"th"\$ \\né:> w\@\’_ owniin c.§ er<:r¥.. §§ \Y\{, \\acr`\$ .gg-L-Bm¥ `\-r\@c>rw\‘c`\bv\
\`mm oka\\'\shc. 912 Qrt\"\‘<` 50 W\x\)rw(<"§ .S\U>\& \'\ac\ ‘c\\c m %a\\T§Xi»
eipzr+. 19 L\D a¥€"\c\mf\‘c_ 10 MH; S'\ maxwean .`P\\Sz> ""\'Y\i_$ Q§v hymch
igmre§ Lhe,cue. \aw \m>\hmg wm@s`\\mca\\{ mt (\C>\\\(lg.a\@\/m\~

on a _ch m\H\e:,s §§ _ am -L¢s’r'&~/ to cbs BQWQV\ gm mm\,@
'€.\‘59¥\ "\5 `}3..\\`\¢3‘\)(1(’_" 9\>3\'\'\ B‘{ \`/Xn (\ »\;e‘?>\'.\\"(\m\\\ \g\(-\L\\\UX

aw\& mss \1cL\le. \'\e,\§~\GLK\)Q-\YCM\\ D tv 0\1\\1»%\®$7/.

Q;mom§§o< (c\`\e_§' T mm ’Yr`\u\aour`§_cc>v\c_\o c§.@_<\ X\n@r¢ 13 K\@ evidence
°dr\o“‘<_~<®\',\\urv`\s 5\1{>\_\\5\(\;\\:¢ maria u\§ a>< gm @_\(m\\.mge,, pluth v
Bne.c:bbns?.\ Qc\`\\uves 3m §>Yb§§ €'»\’\`] '@\Q`JQC'XNN rg[zu¢§rm§ g %a\'¢_=m\
C,\‘\a\\enga w -'\Br\¢ SV_\“`\‘€\`\Y\S C)? the€m\\/ K::\\/W O; §§ q gm , (X\\(\@q..
"\r_m L\mm§ m\m> mm 5kle \1&`\&\<\~1>\5¥. mmc @\<\ `-\\”\ t\{\cxeci'
\E£\f;"t‘ L‘,BL)\& \\a\lc. '(C£.\l\) €,b’§: '\'_\\€_ dow ' ,\°oc>\_ d$\§l\\(\
B'xe. c\\>§\`\r_un“f_ mm K\E>‘c`\_“`\ru\"\mm\ fig\n‘<_(§u&(` Gm\eA b\/ \;\\a 5

Cmr\ \‘\*“Y>\m€_m\me,n°(. D? ‘vl<\e_ N><\%\"\X u\`\tm X_D\oe_‘d`\€_t§` \b`i &(`c£\\r
§ mfg m)¥ i a\ dod Cm§`\_§§&`mg 09 Qu‘w Aemc>§)§ ao\\z c.e>‘€ ,¥)r\e < arj\a\
ma\‘~\e. » \>Q 159 ’éne.’dne, Cmm’d §'\\\c.‘<\ ‘v\e,`\ 5‘0 e,`\r\£§ XY`e\`] 15 <\E>"<_ r§\\\' m\(\§ `KCSZ ‘

En>u_m§\ QDV fd\`\ e§ T‘r\€ce,‘; Tr*\o,\ mortg x:>m\& sami mms e,\ \`(\\'. \\ as ns
maAe_ 'Cm%vm\o\t.. *‘U`\C\\ &"Ym‘m§;§( Aee_i':>\on mt w teakoez’cc»\ comp '

~€_¥im‘j haman o§‘cer app\icu'n\; <>c>_.*mvn?m'm X_\\¢ &Xc£< doer `\w\
mm \:\oxr is Ye,\`\'e¢§ em\\>e)`\\! L:\j 00 Bnexc,qov‘r_§mm \/er‘c\on s¥a’\c v
\/\c>s§`\\'u\ Ln\n en m ?m:_.’f_ ‘(Y\C. \~X.a£f`\$ \MA w‘>vc_si>mae$ a"c\r\e.'~f\i
~f;\l`\_ :em.e. w‘¢\e. R\\‘<_c> 0.!><1€\5`\(\€_€ X§\U\ Au§\q 1903 53@<@_\\05§)1\@\
§m(_\`mg\$ ®T\YY\`\F_UX haw Cl’m»fjm>§§ m`\’<\n \);1`}3\\0’¥‘€ ¢‘_w AZSG*&¢T
9mm e\§f’x\/ Ay;§e»r“c_-wat €v&\\mX e,_ a\§;g\ic_an¥, ®\\W\'\mn‘§ hoc\
a \0 ng\\.\§’cm*y 639 ch\\ a\ `\\\m.:z:\ pm\{)\em& and ‘oe;\v\

g y &Qa\a \
w\X\\ mwm\"\'_ masan \`l\\\\\l\?\ Se,\‘\ritc gram sBmL\/ewcs¢\ y w

` 1 _ 1<\

2101 t\\ mm a§g\\my€v_ mm rece..z\smg a 351~¢<\@@<~ § row tm

um\¢A S`cc£va vasuu\ iz~ec\_w`\¢‘c‘/ aAm\nsXm`<\on Qc>v \\M\v\g amw&c~\
» ®

"\`\\f'\e§§l A'\eas. A?§)\{c_an\‘_\ms ar\m~\ie.& to S\&Yz \r\o§Q`\\ u\ *€y\ev\ ‘Z>B\
dais§~~a}ev an P_vu\\_nrrz .>r\ 9mm %&\e. S’raXe. hhs gi\u\z:\ec_\ave& G§)§\\`mvf`f_
Ee>mp e.’rm\ te> 5‘\01013]\;¥10` § §Lsc,\r\ €.`\\'.\Bm Ssm\n ce_?)\m> u\?§ how'€_§wsm§\\e§
mm \\C\YY \_S hub Y€QL>€_§.X él'n CA\Y\Y e’¥cv\r.‘[ hmc'mg m g\'_»\ eag\'_.\`nb`\)¢.. \'\ma_,
two \‘b§`/<~_ho\@g'"\§¥ wet (‘enAAa\ a\>§\'\mn"\; mms€e§m*¥ w \`e@em\m~\<,
ibm Pm>\» F`m.c\`mg§., 7

§FDUT\A!Q(>V Y€,\`\.€? Fi\.l€_°¢ 'F(\ &\ @DD\E\: ?@Dn A §:\»m~\'_ CGUY\S€\ \.\(K({S nw
\‘€o§@m\o\ e tva u\’. '£>~X_m\ \/' c§ cc_`§§\'o'\\ Qr>€ *é\\e_ "rfcu¥men°\_ 0§ \3<1<-»_
`W“€C"\ U`\“g \€.JYY€X` a‘m\ ‘/\\`xa\au_\v"ccb<\(;\\s€\e<§ %§§\icm\`<. §§ e.§ev\)£
007-eva ence_ w m\nz> mm"m ‘v§'\e'¥k\\eo¥e;<\`\m,\@j<\@¢_ 1 his
`\¢5 a miss» s‘\e\'\e_me_x€\ 59 &§c\c>§€ad\s 9 §>\QQ\§¢Q“X;ED“XA\X§ \ne,.
9'\’€_3@.\'\% ev`\c\e<\cr; X§m‘<. &`-{\5 Tc\\l\O\“ mfo&@@y\\af§\ /SQM~ owe AM~>
\m\\e_ ’L\m>. \<’:XXQ\` `m%\qe, §Xa§\c\\o‘\)ec>s 'E)§Y`\)i\€¥\ >\'§\< 5 \€f\f\“
mr §0\'\:_`\¥@& '\X`:> mc‘é\‘\ n%\ mm\z\ \>e_m>_€ ;->< °LMLL\QQ\:CMX»
“T\w§§ 51<%¢<\1@1`1“\.0? (`(\c.\€mv<§ 5\10m3 ‘§>~`\&5 `\X`§ e>\)*\\vo® ~`UC '-
`\Xov€i$ w€\§.§\si_~ 30`\ XD \m;\§ th»_a§>§\"\ um"\_ »\.> `f\i:m So<; '\Bm\¢ e‘<`\e§ omb '\’\m \<\mA&m~es'wz$\o c»}g\‘<\0€ "fmc; C§\\'ca\.@\“~<

*rk\‘m\‘) 5dc\cl`\. \e;\\ex m\>\é mith “\§’\Q,C'QQ\M\\\,&£Q U\SC, -
\k .¢1\\» t>\lec\\'m m@ <~“_m>me__\`(\v.\‘\wr\s Q\`\M`YL \__\ \>>b&>\d §

>m€£\ ?(\< \€\0\`<‘\5

moc\e_te_c\gona\o\e, \x\c\\ €?\< c_\.‘m§f @>e_r.`\%`\o\n ws‘L ‘U> Q\“ *c£<'\m\ §§ '\W\SC»<\’G€\( c\ @,?-»eme \0\>`<. _

?oi\e_z§ w?\_\.\\\i `\r\\!e§.>r 1361\€. 6\\ ?YX\AC\W\-'\ ffx¥\`¥ mm`? \‘@\YP\`\U<\\ wm 65 Q' row Xk\c,\>v\.\&e B§X&§z`e, ®Q\\ecm§¥,\ms ~\Q\
“11\\<1\\@1% w

§:Lm\mc§ gov \?<_ Qj>\>né\

551 1\\€¢34 @.>\~ mm\ a\ §\\mz,s cheesqu c>‘\

m‘<\'\c.\\ mv \\m“ \`£S ¥\‘<\Q.\&§ dwesz 5 @€,1 5\<££\€,\>§(£0€05 y
S?\{c£m"\'_,

`Qm>\mA ., <>\\¢su >ém>_ SXcB<é \<\¢>z§\m\ e\) ex\ mib >Ane_ 359
f men\ L`>Q~ O`QS`l-L\<\ 0\§€/

wm\ X"\ ex \'X\'\s <‘_Y`m\e. \_)\\AQY `{5\\\0§\\\01\{`\<`(\%&§
A\so\‘Ae_\r 605 ‘SQ€°. Ex\n§`OP< Q);\ uo!‘.\r=_v Qo‘mu\c`éOnd"\ s '
mci Ni\f cf 336 \\e,`u>c\§ m“\_`\ n\lb\ec\ QQQ\’\U\:\"Y_X¢;\A\`(\G
`\Xc»<§€
\'\'\€J",As c\\m>\>\ s`\x m`<\°<\r§`s) ‘oe§o‘:e. 1515 QQQ wage \c\ac\ c>cr_u\~veé
CmA "<§\u~\, b\§\e\\ QeoQ\e, 31\`5 &\R\§c_u\nif_ mt&\\\'_ g¢:,u\c\ <\`Oeev\ m§¥\\
‘¥k\e.w\ m\<\m Bne_£>(~` §€w\§e.. \m£\ C)Cr_u'v e_A. 'A\Q?\§co\n¥ -¥§nc£c A§c\):v\§
mecm\\&_ was '"<~\<:>‘: `\r\\fo\'e¢\.\ ‘<\€. bos\ A`RX.(\’L ‘CCW\-em\:)€;(` &)C.Q`\VSX
m>*r\\‘m a\oo\>‘¥. XX\LC~R Q§*\ §§
\_»§<\03 Q\; u' \r\e_ mn\u§ \~c\§§§ a“\'\r_m\*<_ masso\{ in%\<\ud)$ \1\6*
\»<\\1.:\€<\ cmA m\\< md¢& \<\‘\s@\»§,\é)_ e_\`\mX» -

633

,
.

(\§Q\ \

@®\)(\(\Q(><` 'KC\`\€.Q 5€>(€!\°., § T\'la\ com\'_ Cov\CX\>AQC\ '\n X\m`z C`:voo\nd l ` l
&k\e; RQQ\KCU\% mo§ §L\gg<$‘vm§ '\-m§. wo§e.\ §m?'vc>§e_<>\v vad\»"\aec\
the ‘-‘mu\ Qc>u`c*"¥. ‘YXU"¥.FY\e/Q emer§ \n"\ 5 c_\?\ e.v\"s Mm\§ wm mP< %@cbx§<\”»
T\\~\#§ was mt &\\e,`\z@s& wm *L\m»,m? pheava was cc> \M Ae%mse,.

QPP\`\LC\:(\°\'_CDMQ¥\\S h`\§ 5\ -\~>\ \'*t L)§ZS l°_m$‘c"\§s\_)\`\em\ \\w\en (§\mcy\`§$
hdc>.\'e_ v`\c>\n‘rez\ . `H\:)'z`:> @Mf)r\`\s: Gvouv\c\§¢e,&,%a’\e,\\c¢oms E)L\ni‘m’v
a(€@cdav`r¥ D(\ `P\W\\`cm'\% \I€J‘Sio\n csc m\\m&\‘x` of rc\\ § \?;\ gill d ’¥‘r\a\ UMR mud \>_v\cé; counsel

mm \>\cm\"§$ mud e.. §m@e>nc\‘<)\@<<`\u\ §l \I Ae,c\‘s\ov\ 00‘<
w mc%me§\+m\; <>Qg\mm‘< `\>e. emm`meé\ °<@< com§ ex wool
\J€§r¢>\€e. \€\P,\m& rao/mc c\\><;"`< C¢:\; Xx\c»\ m é\"\ C,c»?\e\ >w\<\`\w\ \éecm<)>e_,\c\ewas \m?`\m~\ \31 c§‘e.\\\s`\o\ns
‘<\a\\\>c:.`mo£r x ems \lo`\c.e,  13\' G\\\‘H *c‘o`v\w%
e\§a*én¢€v_ §\UQSX¢& X\mj<_ \xzs ac§\\@\ns \A>e.€e, mm eA '\H mmw\
`-\\\v\egs 05 z>§>>§eseé w\\\§n§g\>w en&@~‘c`\\xe, cm& mm»`\o\w»\e&m¢
?U¢><\Q\w&;o§\ Q\\ wm m \\f\! \\cmr\§ know @L\\\L\\as ms
mm \\£mis \o§\c\e_ 199 *€.oe, QLQ\Q\\ mij mold -."\x:> ‘&s‘~‘\c oeiw\u\»

®

?(\<. \>mv`\& zcx`\c§ ¥k\c€v_ C\Qq\`\ mimb Wc`))\xm Qx\X&X;\eL Xheze.a\"e,
Y\¢_\l zim<€‘>\;q,¢\iso\‘< mm%c§e§s§m\ ‘oe\'m-\\ Lov &\\A>.vc>o \M\\ gm am
SQ\Q ` MQ€@¥\D ogains`x XBd>Se. X\<\£D<`*/o\> \0€,\\€\$€_ orc,®&>’< W`€m
46\:\.. \N;L\\\§f;\m¥\®n \'..\\c)/ (`(\LL`/ .mt\§ol% (`.<.ikic`\§m& 69 L>B\~o&`io\>
t\\in\\ M‘ do Se.e.‘,,,ma\l G`C\°\Nc. QQM'<\NA §c_Y\§?_:>Q\\*oe_v\\c@, T\ae>c:_
cwa Qim§)Xov~/\S (>»W\iccm¥ was c\i§s€\a\i'\m*\ £\'\x`\v\c\£ria\ !\'>\YP\\`¢@M
Ave\)n& x
Emm\d Qo\' fc\`\& mmi ’-{\-»;u\ Qm;»'\'_®“ (\_\Q AU}, mi &w\wu“s<
\(\C).§ ed\\e_é\*\b§b“>\)e_w\; Cb\>me“'(x`\\EA see 0\03¥0.`\‘~/\ '\`(`\<-Q\D\ne`f
\`r\&Aim\ veamk\@ \oQ€¢ycc,Xxm\JY\{\ie".b"\nmwe;~"r zeme£n\vw C£\n&
\-\a‘X\\\\<\QA~€LX_XWL\ \)0\\3<
\`\\r. ?\m\e_j \`(\ cc§`\m\ view A\%. `T‘aexc; \A§L\`e, m ' my c',`v'\ 'Q\\`i S`\cf\mns
ted i@_§¥&v w wm HQ<>_ §§ mnk\ zu;xmi“@c\ w wc\ri&<§mmv
cl_v\\{` - ADC_¥¢>~‘C <‘a.? Dr’cs \1\\\ L>Q \\ms §§ ~€o\§\'\c\ `\\r\ u\;‘?\accm *< X‘c\o\ b
mm `\)\D\C\“`\§ \_\;»c\z 50 `\<`\e;\:Y-e_r_'\ i\m»:>s Qr>r mi‘no\)`\v\§ X\<\ex€£@€$\e&
'é®(`_\.)mf.v\'\ QA €.\{‘\é\e_nc.e_ in ‘L\<\Q "m`\&ic\_\ ll'l_L\@c\\dm@;\\<>?>_ swmm>\<~% wm \<\`\5 6\»>\\\ \?`\\ 25 clon §\\e,£\§?\'\co»anu§e,.

ma mms \<\QAM> \es aw@r e\!U\/')‘“§’Xsa R\r\ cm§ \v\&z Q`\\€~> a\>\Q\l L>Q V{\Y¢`\\vms c;r\_‘<:l C,\’\e,n*§§`\\e_§ '<\:>X\<\\m\\,_\% fm ')<\,\ Q"w

wm m w} cx‘c X<\&\\bas 'c®ne\%‘&€v\)<

m\f\\\ m mmnd 5\£§ ma \0\) \¥\f-'P\w\&/. 'TwX`:> m\§\>qgov\e§

\X/ the (€,Cmc\ 005\\<\`\1§§ m X\x@}\\mow) wash wns\¢zXeoX

uS\X\\ m\\(f< N\§§ro“m.

`T\\P_ Pamm ada c. “\'¢>b'\a§ `Y`r\ef\$cn `~\‘k`:b Y\b’c\\`\né\@c>n§?\$\.@n\ w`\\\\ \(\`\€>
A€$CX`\P \`\rm X~)r\o.\; mc¥\c>v\®/'~h>t»\>m§ mo$ _T\nv\e,\€`/- bv\\f’f~`%
`\\`\'5 5€€,$’<`\;~»00\{ (‘,\(\Mo~t’.\e_‘€`\`l_iv\ '\\I\r\\oc\c>\ &Y\\\;\~\)~\.E\\A\\R_SL;QY 0\”*\
’-ck\z §XUX€~> ‘Ouv c\ex\ §§ ‘?1<50? ."\J.S\\.e,n \{\.<; \ab c>_\`\'L cox `N\f `?\0‘{1€\1
xré)\;\v\l 515 C\ \m e_ mc>_fma&amc\\ \,_5\\5_\.;_\\ \<\<; A¢Q»WA as .Q brus\v§

up mca»\)ajcm \\r a\avc§€_ \o‘r\\ts@,»§e.e_@\§\\\m\¢ S-»;Q?>Q ';’1?>~7.5>
?axcm\e&w_§es"x\mnj amd "\X was ms mX <~»| mcw}> X\ao%§ \00¥\ c§\
X_o \<.\e_ mazda \o`J @L \c.e;- ch_"€\\ S\rc`¥.~ moss » ammm¢
m\m cou\&\r,\\; c-\~.e~\? c-L?\Q\Cc_mn\< msa Cx\z)u;‘<

&_\n£ N\e_» Pe,rsw.
\' er>\'v\ \()e.w\u§ §\\b\ w\Yy\ CL(`D\;\A ,W\f` '

\\l\~tQ\<>v\e`\ `w:`)m\\ maine
\)\c,m; a\omv\&\nl§ Y©\c w \)Q a§r`\o`\ m\;\\%c\ XQ c\@€e'n§e.cmc)
\'\Q_\Q X\rx@_%‘@§.

mack CL\ "€r€>§ 9 t Bw\ X\(\L \O®’>Y`\XUN

®

wound Qo‘< w\`\e§ ele;[e,n¥b°° 'Yv\c\\r_@m’s_ cm\c.\uc,\u\ "`\:\(\a>f-` won%\`§
m“\-_’\;Q mp& 3m am `\:ze_ a'\o\?\z mm ve@av?\\n@ X\ne_ sbca\€§ Q\e~.~ o‘€ ‘€ex
was ?c_\r\e "K`Q_S\>\)Y. §§ fw§uv\a\o\c X‘cw\ SXMBYCQ§], §§qu @Q OL\\\N§-®
Y\§Lo m \`(\Y.\\uvf§& ‘{<:l;u\\ A\§C,\>§sm% <1“\1. Q\U-Q,U%'mg§“b
Ab mi rzm\\ iQQ\`\um\-_ mm¥cn&§ mm '\Xc»~…s &\,\m>e& `°c§mz 0§@¢,\' XQ
w w
aware L._\.=\X\\~w\» \\';0\<»_€\<_\0\5&¢:&\;3 wv\<£. `Y\eac.o’v~c>?§ civic
L\s<»§ §a\)m§.r\l \>`“\’zo\l 6 €,C®R\\b\, 1 Y 0(>_`\»\“3!) C.\(\ec¥\ 6\“0'5@,&
A\B X\`»E. CQQ\(CM\¥ 6‘€3\'\ 00 \;\'\IL\-C\u`<€_,@ ‘vb `YQ,BCLXCA+\\A-QC§XQ€Y
Q@‘c Q\'€ ch u_~>§_~ QQQ 0€£<<.» '\\'\c>. ’§ec\§m\ md ‘oe,ca¢uz\"(\< . \\a\cr \.S
\Xc\?<\‘cs> `\Q \\`\& c`_\i en¥`\ne\`€>¥ \0 \n\\- \_\m*v_\aei€) \v\x\€>£&v\¥i.db m`c

‘0'\\\'\\{\.`1 usm eX\¢\i_c_cL\\\l \X`i \'_Q Qe_\ 6,(;@@§‘<€0 a‘?\ea
Q\\€\\. `\‘v` X§\Q w`\c\e\nce. c;ga`\m\ ‘<\`\m ix ca\s¢\' m\\c\‘<\~a“‘c_\ N\M(\r.
\\cm\£~. SGSdu“‘<_ is \\QK\\LC, P‘.e,\\cmr\§. fl?r%\`c\€;\si\ a. ‘|'9,5'¥\\2.`\< \~,).>0.§ ’O‘Q?\Q~ osgow\
C> Q`('cf Q'C>Y 'Z_(> \{eo§ b CQ\?\\\!O\\ `IR \&> 1\\0°9 \% 103 ’W\L§L§t{\`e,mp,~
CD\>\` ‘c_ <\¢>m§<\e\c\§ \§f\f>~¥ w CLQ§»`<\ €M\ ‘\-\\€~\ c\€§w‘)e Couv\$€\
\\05 Au\`| bus C,¢>\_Y$ cm& mos*< \<>e,o\n
001 ‘c¢r;m~A Qr¢>_w\ \§ne. §s<;w\x@>v» ira amy -Xucm§ amc\ cow§»;~\sc§ md ex.o_¢§\,\@v\ *\'0 \<\no&'
\»\>\e. '<\e_m\ m§_\o@. Qx§)`-\c>v ed \w_v¢ ‘E¢>\» .>¢\\¢ ¢>Q~Qc~c was cg~ne,m\\\n
cL€-m_r.{) equa¥\@\r\ ;\d<<,.» m\\e)n X\\e Af_‘€e_me couwsc,\ ` c\\`\@we ¢\

~\ém_ §ch Xs: ci\)% QZ\\\‘\:>ME§ X\\e,r\é.@er\kcm‘f

'\;L\ Xa\é\@_ ix m cl\\,>mw£)) \Qcm\ Xu mv\ rmle\€ `\X., '<>e§ wse couv\se\

\
\

® _

\

` 010 mt rem\er §r\\e gmw\‘xeb €;?°€c»_c.\`\\le, 055§3°< mae 69 coun$a\
+he. anns¥\¥u’xicm rcqu`\\~a§ VQ_\§§(>\>M \f Y'vj €S\‘Z) UD 05 20\1_
C_i¥d\mn c;\.waeB zee cnm?m\\’c>v\m§@_ §__0§\@ \: moyer 555 mrs

Q;>\"L> Q_~;&@e@ §\:\'u\;l§€i>\fl$€\ ‘C<\‘C.
\\GX\”KS \:e\\\(_\e_\m\,`z w& C>\D"B\ €£“\`\\se, SXCW\c\axd (>C ' `~'_L~i~\z\’\\o§*<§ mms& 09
`f`\`\§ Gvouv\&?c>‘c X\(\e_~§€\{\u`\ gm m>\:\se\\`{\x.\\m<“€`\€~,"©\a@\\e\¥zh AV\A guess uv\c\

5 ecu\uXa u‘om§< ¥\\e z»;\iic\e,v\c;_¢>n m\\e.nw>\_\ a\\ mm §‘mA @>L>X
X\\e_\vc\j\\/\ » \BQ¢ X\nc_ Xr\u\ com § ra\\<\u 'M- 30 wound &\\e&$u\\\
C\Y\L\ CN\€'\C\€Y` Uf \3\£1‘<“<\5 W\QA?_ YCC\SGM\\L Sc>\mb §*`€<£c<§)'~

`I‘.Y\ §‘(Y\§ `c\<\ \f mt L`_M W\i¢§\(w 0\\°\ § 10 \\<§ 'f>l§`“(?jr \C'\§\GU §,)LQO;<
ma `\\'\ a¢\~e,o wake Xc>%e_s o\\\c m\\d<\'\c\" coum@\ wa& me§€ee,¥§\)e.
c

_Qm>\:>w§\ Qc>w '\'Q\’\é€ ?wcs¢ 'T\\Amuo§ mv\c.\u A@ A ap Q\< amf has 9 ai\ec\ w

D\m\:e. 0-\¢\~_ mm<@_\ S\'\w\c\ \(\a\)c QQQ@`\MCA \r\\'w\ mem cmnse,\. `K\'\cdc l
\:in§'mg is i\z\cmu_¥ Y)?§B\&‘<,`Y<\C\\SXM\¢<§\ aQY\¥cu\r\X_-~‘MACCLCGMP\\U¥

` a\ow\ wm “Krm\ counsel un c\i\l "\A eo\ \c*>\/OL\X‘/ club .` `CRRSNNSX
53 QU}\\\I®\~ 73 350 19 Y\\T)C) hinan c»Q:Q\§Lcm‘c moe wCQ€m/g&\n¢.
C&¥Y\Q\rur\\’ cL\:r>L>\r \n\."> `\`<‘\¢L\ mumSe\ &LKcGV\S (Y\\". \'\a\"("»§ c\v§\ '\I\E>'c W€bv\‘co\
md 159 wm §¥a¥eme ¢\\' \>\/ m%s{\\\mh‘c L\\QL`€\ &\\Q vecm~<~é\w\dgee,'-."

[P\P\\ \Jo\ ')_Y B‘TS' ‘\Q Y-\\§e> '\rec\\cwv‘¥ \,sc»§ §c\ C:vmv Qc>‘€ m‘< '-\e\\‘\~@_\ \_z \\qq\\cw
com\`\\\$\cw\ r<\<)\\\\ %;\»u¥ hzmu\f\) \r\om, manoqu Cmnz e\ 4 »

®

 

T\r\e_x\ \\`\5 X_<\u\wms@.\ mo€) c;L\:o\>\c w hamm c. uzecnnc\ Qmse;c\>¥ev
@¢v ZXche, Y\m\ \`(\(.\5\0¥\‘\§ wau\}§§m<`cc\&“\i 511va <<`§Uv\' Xe$’<`\§`| mg O‘f\
’éx\e_ §\cmc\ . "Y< m\ acm‘x_wnc_\\>c\e<\ X\ne_ mg Q'\Z wm <\\§<`Y\@ Q¢\ec\ Mo%c$b€;<;\ja

_C>€DU(\(\ Qc>r`€€,\\'€§ _\`QY\`» /[`fi(.`x\tb\>‘(‘§c Qm\cl\:\daé (\?Q\{Cmr\\\’\ub _Q'C@\€A 30
Ym\m_ ~'\B:`c\i &\'\e§)usre, ijec>cv\‘c¢c\ QL\\S?.X€_SXRMN\] (X\§q, \\Y ?\§C;;m"( hub
Qc{\\eé kg §Mv\sa ~`\X\c\\ Vne.‘;>'\<\\a \:cL$\QA `\:0 3a s 8.\£>3& ev‘\denc_e .

@ ?\w§% @Q Q\\ .<>QQ\‘\L¢L\<\X mem-39 ~X\~'\a\ ?c>r (A A¥_te'mq¥eé Cc®\i\u\`
Y`f\\\‘vc§\ex U\('_'\\ L'mA mud Cci¥\\!{r;&e& \d‘~i c»A\\\“‘|. I;(\D\Cc\er"`>@ mx\§¥\\\\\\§_
` Hwa§ c‘_\nar§e Y:>%W\l'\c,¥`\S(`_a\v ?\<>v\e\i \'wc\‘:f> Y~>€/
b‘nc\% b*l .- w
’L£’_;b‘\{ Cmv\ Xriu\vewv<\,
333 nm\\\`mc_'\ 31wa m\" ‘&0\0€:/ mark 'cn\ \\\€> wave_,. T\\e_ ‘{m amu\<¢,
(`3`_€31931.1;3)0;9_1;:_£ \\6'\€.3¥\¥~¢\0~@] C.\(\CN&'LX€:<§?,"\¥\¢\\Y\€» Y\o‘m;\l `\v\ km\/'
dic\ m'&_ wpqm~i ~¥3\€_ ‘_')`Y 531 m\\_a;n \\e,\(,{\gq\i~v,<§
ms%@m; if:`>~o<"/ gm \w\q¢'m'€,w\a‘mw~u _SCCQ~&\¥D\.ES ? 3012 23#2§> n
chm'me.c\\`\m>w) $c\`\e\ `\X was cm tian \, w_m\>\m§ A\na‘c \edhe§
\'_(> hamer \o`l a \c,e_-QcclXQC`_‘<-\ w Q\Q<‘,Q 156 3\0§.3 '€QL\\~\ a

hf&)\¢\ex\ \_u`w\dow sed$%¥b\\@'?\\\[§>o%u"€ YQ‘_\,‘§QQ,L;\@\~ mi‘§\eaA
ihe.Amv m§‘<\n @\\u€>\¢>f\ w -mv\-e:/;*\§_Sve.,\'v¥w%d~e.nu. bmos¢.w\ av) \c»u,

'\?om\»\edh_‘v-e&€?\\ w Mv?\mc)}` 303qu :~+Y\um 'ma@\e_\a§é§:ceozwab\¢
on.)`oX muva \JMAS S\`n&‘< w"\‘c\<\ &(`9\)\¢§ ‘€\ne,`?*sc>§ec.o‘w mow\c\ \1@\>€/
Q\s\\~ ®\9§  X\<\&,~Qckmw\c¢\»<,

\/\<’- was mw\§\_o\\a\ \n<-»_ he\:`e\m\ Me.mc\§>w@é¥<@§ mm X<> S\»o\n ¥\n¢
gmi CLS w;\\£\nwc '(V\r md m3 0@\7'(`3@€,>\0 ex é>\m §'>\oz,& wou(\(\"

®

 

‘SC>\T\_Q 53¥\5§§’ \lo\`> com 5€& C\€.cw \decao*>e, R ~f\X\r\e,\`é_co'<‘é\@&nA X\ae reco@

dev`\?\ l~`\ €_ a ~
`T\'\e_ ch>‘ze_c_\-_;\O~c C>X\A\Y\r.¥wme`/ §CLRK\GP_`QQUO i)\\.c>>¥ ¢D€CLP\‘°\Y\!C>\>\\?'
\‘45"* \`\°D \»§\\vu\ +»~ marked ch>
‘rcaswa\o\e. AQLM\ ibm A§c DX\n er L,_s\§e_ eisz ‘<\ne, Con\)it`>§x ha re\/@ma\@ 5<:@ -W\ecmem \¢L¢> \¢\n cm "L°L‘\.b§ \<>b 59 S¢c,><,,

mann g ga \) \m'\mg,_ \&_ m § 13 .-\\ »\~' 3(33*¢_<¥ may g

333
U\'E;&\§\B:L%_ _

‘\..\x\xex\ X.\m 3 x"\ck\. cc>wn‘:)e.\ is\& \\m»_ Q\.\\:\Agc, \r\¢_\\f\\v\‘€) `m& C;\‘\ ua¥

`\e a\:m¥ Xc:> Cx>mm\X ?cv dm\] mah~¥\nc 3\35\3¢_‘€1“1\») OQQ\€ cmX-om§ '

Xx\&\ 'Cb\>`f\‘z' e_\ \<\C\A Cv\ Cc>v\% \:`\c_-’\ l~<\\<,\cX \_».\`O<\n ~€ML.\\ ®\\(\ju\ whom
X)ne_ Wf bsac_u\m~ m\b\:za<§ X\'\r_. ¢\_.\yc\] u>\\\’\ C).\\\,\°b`\ov\f> XC> `(\N\~Qi‘\":‘¥&v\*
€_`\) "\c\ex\c_e_ XN\@X ‘\X w imitch *<~\<\<,\\c\ u~\ §'\:mc\ cxw\.‘»_v\>i a\\\| wawa

(i§i§%jm\ov\

"¥~\'\\5 m\yc‘< 5\&\3\€\.\1;‘3€¢\ X\<\e, Q~"\.\r\ARv\ 5 09 Q-O\Ci<.»:<\e‘c
<_’~,L;p<{o\`§xec\ \b\l`\§nb<€m*& Cm}\ wrme \egc»\ 'C¢>v\c-.\\)S~§ow>

Cm_& cs‘c¢\er~ ex 6~\'¢\.5 X~(\c:\\.

 

M

ud‘<\ eve;&c><\e_~d\s\e_ uYQ\\wv\Y.. ?\” cri 'X§m&_ `L\r\'\ 3 Cc>uv*c< c»_'\c mw “ck\@,
®\>Y\\um`)fb &\0;\,.€_\:¥\0'<\3 %o.‘XhQ C_c>\>‘c“v_?`mc\"m%§ S`c'%a£:\ \n s (>Q \0»3 '\’)ecau§e. .up§\\crm"\ c§\"\é\ ¢>\o`le,c)<ém XD
\">az>r C_\u~`(\ af Toxm\n\ cwan .e>w\ §S€c\ \\~10‘€) »- mak w ¥}\Ci

C\\A mm 3`\\/:_ &Qq\iccm% X\\e:\e,n 'Act/§ \r\c.`s cL\\D\,M§ Xc> ‘~`¢;\Qc\

us\\\»\ B§>wcj umm.»c\wb ep’< ab 10\5 X\ae~) m@\c\e 360va

\:`\K\ c\'\ meza (3? Qua’x amc\ C.c>Y\L\\>S\®v\ @€ mud \\r\e_x\_ va M\l:’>

\C\\e:( c>v\ SCQ\ @\yzf>\é X‘\'\L 133 c\(§€. S§Q\\\ec\ <:\QG 0\{\§ 3c1 63`\£\
\ _

X3\0..3\>€\ 3e,`*¢&\§>cm \r>c>\<\ C>\\Q,€` `~*\\»©`3 b 50 U\R\`\'.co»v\'\ 0:°>\’\ `»\\g_\

5c3\e. M§K\B\AU t\r\o& >¢3.\@<\ `&€3<\01\;'
Q\QOQ ec><\>\\j zubm\\“\é<\
', . T:)R'v\i\`\§$m\$§§~
<\>;3';3 m \'\'\O\S”><€
\"(\c,(lmne.,\\\\m:\>(

"300\ 5. §'.\/m\`\©<`

\?3‘¢ QN `\\\¢e,\_ “\'~1'1<6\01

'C.Q_'c 'T`\Q `\ Lo¥e..§@ §-U\r"\*le ~_ ,

b\\<:\nab \<)e_<,v\. \\¢\0€\\£3 ’. to\>v\oQ

§§ch new .a>,(--£"ne 0\:)
“I‘_.`f ‘vm‘\`.nu\ `G§Qw\, Y@B¢\, `}\'\'BZJO'\ %>‘<&X‘xc>~c\\\\u§i\v\ 1
’Y-k '1<5’1\\. '
'Q/mum/:Q§_v;l-_§`l
O'i~\"l' \?3

E`l\\r\`\\a`\ “€5

\:-"-`*\“`\\3`\* 33 1\\0€\\ wm w -»\>\w\ .-‘§<¢m wx\§“msm\mo@zx\ @\
"'<`c><_‘ C-»vm‘(\A ‘_-">`\`)\ / am\ `C~smo‘<\a\ "i Y\€€.€ 5'<@\303 E,a§\\‘<.,

’E_`/\Y\\\)\\ §§ \_\§\(\\’_Y\ §\C\\t_€ \\E.A X\<'\C`\<` QKC>\ GSCB Q\n A`m(:$ 09 €&L\
CmA C®na\u§\ov\ &Q \0\\3 SQQX 'z\ m\§

`C_`/\\(\\\j \ C `\\(\Q §\3&3€. 5\0.\£\\\<\& X_\n.e_ S¥o~\e. °<`€_r_i>mme v\c)§ am
SQYX ®A\"Lo\&

f

,Client Recovery Plan - Full Report worth Texas state Hos` iran

 

 

Name: DAV|SI|,E|NN|S lVlPl; 277237 Epi: 2 ' '- ' - ~~ Admit Date; v10/20/2011
P|an Date; _11/8/11 ` » End Date; P|an Tyge: Review and Update _Elan Name:1 14 Day Recovery P|an Review

Status: Finalized 11/9_/2_Qtt

 

Formu|ation; l`Mr`. Davis met with-the treatment team on 10/28/11, for his multi disciplinary case conference. The patient's primary
*"*`__*/"language is Engl_ish. , _ - v

Kennedy`s`ub' scales by the treatment team on 10/28!11:

l t.Psychologica| lmpairment - 30 as evidenced by his irritability, evasiveness, claims of auditory and visual hallucinations
statements of grandiosity, and claims of impaired memory. - '

2'.Social Ski|ls - 30 as evidenced by his lack of soci_al'relationship`s and lack of understanding of the feelings of others_
3.Violence'+'30 as evidenced by his history_of physical aggression towards others. including incident leading to most
_ 4.ADL/ 0ccupatio
_ maintain a'home., l ,. _ _,, . _ q
~ 5.Substance Abuse `- 50 as evidencedby his history of,a|cohol.and drug use.
S.Medical lmpairment - 60 as-evidenced by his history of multiple medical problems. ~ » ~
7.Ancillary lmpairment - 20 as evidenced by evaluation and/or disposition being made for serious criminal charges such
mm someone. ' ' ‘

nal Ski|ls.- 39 as evidenced by his educational levell unemployment and inability to independently

' Diagnostic _Summary and Case Formulation:

   
   
 

  
  
  
  
   

. 1. Reason for Admission: This 41 year-old Black male was admitted to North Texas 'State»Hospital'- Vernon Maximum
Secur_ity Unit on 10/20/11 pursuant to Article 463.073 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure after having been found »

_ incompetent to Stand Tria| for the charge of Attempted Capita| Murder, out of the_3,9_61b_District&ggr_t`o rr nt

Texas. The.patient was committed to this facility for the specific purpose of eva ation and treatment towards the:'goal of

regaining-competency to stand;trial-. Current commitment is set to expire mbc .. . 3. . t»

1 2.` Hypothesis Concerning Pa'tieht's Condition: The police report stated that Mr.'Davis alle edl‘ s " ex- irlf ' and '

the man she was dating"with. He was found incompetent to stand'trial while housed in the Tarrant County Jail. Pati‘ent has

_ | received outpatient care services from MHMR of Tarrant Co`unty from 02-16-94 to 06-25~09. w 4 ‘

3. 'Statement of 'Planned Treatment: The primary goal of treatment will be competency restoration l\_.".r.` Davis vvill be
offered psychosocial treatment interventions within the social-learning matrix of activities on the`Competency Program .
and its point economy system. Psychiatric treatment and interventions will include prescribed medications with
adjustments as clinically indicated targeting Mr- DaViS' PSyCh°§is and aggre§si°"? medication education targeting
increased knowledgell insight, and judgment relative to medication regime, purposes, and mana_gement;'on-unit
psychosocial interventions targeting an increase in safe, appropriate self`and interpersonal management skill
development, and competency education;,Competency Group; yll/lock Trial;. Goal appropriate On~Unit and Central Rehab
Group / C|asses; and COPSD to treat co-occurring mental illness and substance abuse. Weekly contact with members of

. `the Treatment Team to develop a Personal Safety P|an targeting appropriate management of aggressive / negative
impulses; monitor progress towards discharge goal of his return 'to court as“havi"riglh;et the" criteria lfé"M;§;e;j;;gy_

_Lig_adqg`;n$o€a| WoHfro\s\'v\$ix 1 tex Grouv\¢).”\\\*<-e<§:%<@mm,\dap 9 ‘.

 

~{201 1

 

 

SHAREN WILSON \

Criminal District Attorney
Tarrant County

september 2, 2015

Mr. Finnis Davis II
TDCJ-ID# 1779538
McConnell Unit 1
3001 S. Emily Dr.
Beeville, Texas 78102

RE: Davis, Finnis ll - Writ No.: C-396-010409-l 199412-A
Dear Sir:

Enclosed please find a file marked copy of the State’ s Proposed Memorandum, 'Findings
of Fact and Conclusions of LaW in the above listed case which Was filed this date With the
. Tarrant County District Clerk’s Offlce.

Sincerely,

'\.

/¢: 4/%/;
Frieda i\/chillin
Litigation Specialist
POst-Conviction

Enclosure

 

401 WestBelknap ' FortWorth,Texas 76196 ' 8]7.884.1400

"l=`~ti\€\`\\p`\`t “~ §§

-- ___.

l- lL L)
THoMAs A vviLDER
TARRANT coun`rl\)'.lsii§)(<:,i§RK

 

_ No. c-396-010409-1199412-A SEP 9‘* 334
mae §j/j/B¢'M/
EX PARTE § IN THE 396“‘ JU¥)'LcLA,L._//i”£ nequ
§ .
§ DISTRICT COURT oF
. § , _
FINNIS DAvIs n § TARRANT CoUNTY, TX

ORDER
The Court,adopts the State’s Memorandum, Findings of F act and Conclusions
of Law as its own and recommends that the relief FINNIS DAV[S II (“Applicant”)

requests be DENIED. The Court further orders and directs: g
l. The Clerk of this Court to file these findings and transmit them along

with the Writ Transcript to the Clerk of the Court of Criminal Appeals as required by

law. _
2. The Clerk of this Court to furnish a copy of the Court"s findings to

Applicant, Mr. Finnis Davis II, TDCJ-ID# 1779538, McConnell Unit, 3001 South
Emily Drive, Beeville, Texas 78102 (or to Applicant's most recent address), and to

the post-conviction section of the Criminal District Attomey's Office.

_sIGNED AND ENTERED this ff day ofM, 2015.
' §%GE PRESIDREGG

l

l:_l\\(t"\\n"\ \ ~' C,

1 \\\ '\ \'-X‘L 3>°\\;“\ \>\& %\e'\ \<:I\ how
T.t>:?\ht&\`¥ too\~\"\ v'\ T“\i)< HS

EX?AV\`X ’\1` n t _\\\e. c»:>>‘u»,~_c>\o»\oq~\\@\@\\\\a-R
Fa NN`\ssm\&T
INTP\I>O\SU:C<>\A

'T we \\‘?QUM`V 555 E'US jo K\R‘?.STP€\ E,`e’ ‘\°\'\i€>‘?`»m§ §_;\;
oP?oss'\:cD\~\§ to \\?P[SZC?ens Coroos. 'R\'\c»_ 5\. `