Court Opinion

ID: 4049324
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:55:33.818355+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:29.284297
License: Public Domain

\N- THE   /)/7/§77’04

CO\,W\T CF CR\N\\NA\.» A?PEA\.§

 

 

DF T`EX AS
No. wR- ' RECEWED
, CoURT oF cRm'uNALgF\$,PEALS
JUN 08 2 `
HAM\.S CHAN\>’E/ - _ m
/;/,P//¢auf _ ‘ ' Ab€!Acgsia,C!erk

Seo/\
,AppL\cANT/$ os.\\=_c'r\o\~\ 'ro we TR\A\_ comm/§
\=\ NB\NG'S AND CON C.L_\J\ $\ 0 NS

CJLMSZ/ 0/’- /Qeca/'//c’or A/,/>/)`La/I/:

HAN\\$ LHANbE

|b: \8 233\7

DALHART mm

\\¢\\;0 FM 443

pAL`H/Hz~r, TE>( DF' ,L<\XT\'¥DP`\T\`E_S __________ '\`\'\

&EN'ERAL DY,JEUV\DNM,_ _ _ _ _ _ ._ ; _ _ _ 4

MEQ\T$_______________- 2

/_ N,_Yw;a/»,c /u¢prbw»<____ _ __ __ ____4

4_ Rme//Mb/¢ ________ _ __ _ _ _ '

PRA\/ER FGR REL\EF _____ _

§`\

. \NbEX_ 0\= MATHBK\T\E_§
CASzS

Buxks v. Ukv\\h,¢$< SXa-*¢$, 437 \'\~S* '\C\‘WZ>- 1. _ _ _ _ - __ _ __ ./7
- go.c¢\\¢~ v. CA\`\gur~/\`m, mm u-s. 293,2¢,¢\(\»\34) ______ _ _ _ _5
(_Mw\¢\\ v. `\'¢»\¢s, am s-w. 3,& 3% ('r@><.crzv’v\.,&y\>. 1¢><>~)) _______ 4
E,¢ \,M L,\¢§,efu §-w` 1& 400/442 (TU. cczw\.,z.w. W\;)_ _ _ __ _ ___ 1
F`\s\w v. J»Mv\sw\, \~//+ F. 3& 710,“)\2,(9\’“ c:(. Wm)_ _ _ _ _____ 7
JM\/_sov\ v. EQ\AM}($, Lt»D'+ F- B¢S( @\9~ link CTr. loo‘§>_ __ _ _ __ _ _’]., 6
N\M)f'\v\e'z v. emrc? v\, 374 F. 35< \O?L+,l\DB‘ZC”\’f\\ C¥r. 2004`)_ __ _ ____ 5
Ru\$$e,avk v. S§'zp\v\e,v\S/SS‘\ Fo,§- )\YY»<- §'+2, 391>(51’0\ Ci(. lo\'+)_ _ _ ____ l
S\M\_ v, )\)\¢!>M\@,\,S:)J\ u-S_ 473,1+83(21000\_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ 7
\T(@_v;m v. T\\a\¢,r, \z?,_s. c+. ‘\‘\\\,\49~\(9~1>\%3_ _ _ _'_ _ _ _ _ ___Q_
u“-\)wg¢ g&_&@, v. O\AM, 507 u.S. '72\$,-'122-23(\4¢\®_ _ _’ _______ 5
u_§_ v_ \N<,\€¢/_Us F. 3.& 257, 16\ (3& cvr. zoo\) __________ 6
Wr;§'wr v. SWQ, us s-w` 3& 526/537(’1“.&1¥“`,@". 10¢>@§_ _ _ __'é,

§ "'a\` wj\` ¢5 .

TE¥. vw ama ¢w~. § \.o~,@(n\[vuw\ 1°°;) _

____ _ _____z

Te;<. 442-kuna SM=E-w C»E §1+8\~\\2(¢§_

___-_--___..3

i`\`\

n 'To."rm': Hc)NoRABLE' ’JU\>&E$ DF SA\D COUP\T`~

C,(_>W\@/$ \/\0\/0 H'AM\.S AT*"UM-P?\`\LA'V\.$Y/
APP@A(W\S prp S’Q/ A\A§t _\’Q,$P€cj’€u\\>/ F§\€_S o\o\se,¢\'§ov\$ '\*b

_‘\-\,\o_ -\'r`\u\ wm(\"s"{l`\vv&`w\ 5 Av\b cowo\us§ov\s iv\ Jr\,\`\; wr`\lr
' a?p\lc,a\"\ov\ Av\ék \v\ $\)`\>?<>(\' wbu\£`t §\m-.»w -\-o,\-\,\Q_ CWWSY

H,\Q {Lo\\¢>w`\ v\§: f
&E NERAL OEJE ¢T\ 0 NA\_

* `Ap\>\'\c.av€\' seeks 511ch s¥£ve M\au¢ \m\"€.¢sf`\ov\ ne \\`\`s
paxsovm\ rig\r\\’ +1> Q§.{US-f`\\/Q v&$$`\$xw~v\cc o{l oo\xv\;a\ o`v\£( \(w_
ve\/xa.vv\o,v\\'\y b\o§@¢s¥$ &“O ‘L"\`“`\A\ C°\W\Y/$ {*-¥v\/kv\§$ o\v\&
CNV\C/\\)`§~`bv\$ Co( \\"_-éz c/r> §'v\ '“'\`\$ Uk$€- Ro. $Yo.c\ \¢’_a\\>/ MS\AQ_$
“\'\/\0;\‘ '\'\/\¢ 'Y(`\o»\ avu(`\’ €/((2,& `\v\.\/\e\ék`\vx§‘\'\¢m‘f \`[\/\Q, \/\A_<
\>rQ_$Q.\/\`\‘Q,ék v\o w\@¢$&e,(§ w\/\`\¢\¢\ MQ co V\Iz&\&\¢ uv\é(e/ A
_gu\gge_o\/uqv\é( \/dr`v\' A\>s?\`\ c,¢é€\ev\_//[/jx& 41 v\o`\'a =¢ 9.\_\“ U>V&(M-\»
{'r> ’§\'¢\Q, }\'\"\A\ bom‘¥'~s ‘\Fé? C”/ 'Ap\>\`\cav\\' €§\9.5 J¥\,\ls »J(`\\'
A\?P\\C,v~`\"\S\/\/ C\A`\W\`\V\J “\'\/\o£\' \¢\e_ IS Acxwux\\)/ `\v\v\oao_v\"§ Av\
W\>u\& \/\os(’ \/\a\/Q, \azq_v\ coV\\/IC&L& \o\i\' \’-O( '\\¢\Q ¢Qc>\\m/d`\v\z .
cowslr`\‘(v&`\bv\o\\ v\`r>\oé(`\»v\$§ \/\'\_s C»v\v`\c\~`\nv\ w¢\$ o\oj?o:xv\e& \9)/_
‘\*\AQ_ §‘\‘od\`Q/$ )(¢Lv\`\o`\ o(»' \/\`\s fig\/\§$ '\*o e€-Qo,c,\"\va, &SS`\S\‘A\¢\CQ O€

+Y§”\& C°\*"\S’L\ M\§f ?f@¥fl@\- wmv\§a,\.W\/\\\z\`\/m\ows c;>qms
review §§ Ava\\a\a\a £o( -\\A¢ §l@v{\&\ o w“éLMWU/i\a\ or ' _
¢,°»\s¥\‘m‘dov\¢& rl§\/\‘vs/ ”E»< />m‘¢ L>,/es/ em s-w. 154 ¢\eo,%o.f'w<.
C*"\W\-AW. \4‘15) -F\$Y & S\k\o$?.o\/\JLL\,& Vd(`\"c A??\`\¢A'\~`\°v\/\\Av\ `
APP\.\%\~JY W\us o\¢c¢>`w\po\v\y cov\§~\;¥\~l¥`\sv\o_\- \l§\>\o~\"\ov\ c\A\w\$
W`\'\'\'\ A P\"\Y"\A ‘10\¢;@ ’~"\A`\W\ of AC\`\M)»\ §v\v\§¢ev\CQ__//EX par
5/0°/<$/ am 5-`\"" ?>A 3%/ Z‘WSC'Y¢><. Criw\.A\»\>- aov/lka smm,

§§ ‘\'(\»\2, \r\o,€€ `\)\/\oé¥ '\’\/\9_ 0`\((,\,\¥\¢\$5\‘0\'¥\62,$ ?{LSZ,\F&Q_£L (`A`\ga_ 0\ 56/7/!»1/>-

L\A`\W\ \A')\/C\¢\A aC.Q,"C/ogv\`\`z@\o\¢ u\,\&“ 0` SM\OSUV®“J( ®(\\3(

ap\>\`\co\\"\t>v\_,(a,o, /'/. _ _
F\`vm\\y, AFP\`\ caw\"a`SSQ/(`\'S `“/\oé€ '\lv\o, QTZA com ex»(@Q §v`\

fal\`\v\§ -\-o w\A\GL 0\ r\A\\/\§ ov\ \/{\_5 ,v/"> _<"@ w\\>\"\bv\ -w Av\
ev`\$\wér`m.ry _\/\Q,M`\v\j) `\'v\ v`u>\;&`\ov\ r>{ \/\`\5 GH/QUQ\\ &\m ?n>cas$-

cLEARL>/ EsTABL\sHEI> \=EbERA\, \»»‘~W_ 7

TMQ, uv\&@c\y`\v\§ €Q&<’M\ law `\\/\ ‘r\¢\`\s sw\@sz mv§‘f wr`d~,

app\§ca&`\ov\- `\\¢\5& a P(DCQ&\AFA\ X@€DM\\» of {v\€€€&[}(~\\[a
A$.SIS\`A\/\c)1 `“'AQ~ U(v\`\&e& §§w&e,$ Sv\\)fe,w\o, C°uf\` §v§
MM_ \v\ MM%/`m;z/ +\Ap_
5ch Q,x\>\a`\ v\z)t '\M¢A' ~\'o s~ucca,e_/§"< Rv\ Q§¥a~\p\{_g\q`\ mg clause
+o excuse a »Pro c¢&um\ &a{>:m\\‘ §§ :AT(; c,\a`\w\s/, Av\
app\lcm\'¥ music $Mow '\J\wi¥ U \4`~$ um&er\y`\v\§ c\o\`\w\s_ o

‘ ]`_ATC owe “`Su\os\’av\‘\`\a\/ /’ w\e_o\\¢\`\v\$ '“¢\oz‘< \1\9_ \\w\u\s\' £o.mov\$\‘m\‘e,
‘|'\Aa‘f +W c\a`\vv\[.<>] Ma[v¢j s»w\@ me(ljr/”/`j bd \3\%,~ mall C?~) §v\'

\,{\5 Yv\`\{’§a\~\'av{ew c,<>\\pé(e_(g\ ymcu_&(\,\§/\\Jr\,\erq, \A)o_$ y\o
couv\SQ\// +-° rase,v\'\' +\,\¢>sz c,\o\`\w\s ¥v\ \/\`\5 C(s\’ .5\»,§§@ \M\gw\$

ay\)\`\ca’dov\_.,<'e@ /`X/~ ac¢vr/ 7`re)//`)70 V. 79/1/€/) \33 S.L+. \‘\\\/\‘\2\
(10\3)/~ /zu.s;@¢u y, 57‘@/)/¢@¢45/1;54 \=QJZ- A;>;>><. 342,35055’&\ ca 20\43_

N\ER\T.S

BASe& OV\ '\'\'\Q» \\ A\>\>C\\oé(e_” reco\'& z>€ \¢\`\$ 9(`\3`\\1\0\\
+\’\`a\ Co&oc\¢e;\' v\o. 10\9~'33€-(’,'1) o\C "\`L\`\$ casa Av\£L “\'\/\q_
M>?\`\ w\o\@» \¢w~$/ A \>\`\Cavi`€ &SSA\'$ 'W\¢£r *W\e,cz `\_<. Su\$\"\c,la\\b\z
issuas presev€r §v\ -\\¢\`\5 su\aga \JL\.u(‘f’§ cov\s`\B`Le/fa\"\ov\` \'\o. coz(-¥v_v\&s '¥\»w. \'d¢\\ amqu 30{'
'W\e, \’¢Loor& ama AY\>\`\M\Q\Q, loud o§ `Y\,\I$ cwa wr\>v\ '¥\/W\§/`\X'$
\\F&C” §\no\.\&& be o\/O,((\AX_CJ( \p>/ '“'\`\$ Cou`r"(`\y\ o( Q,(_€_D/(
wm 1(.> w mw&@& adams Q\~\._ m W:$ C,_$_/MY\;LM&
V\°jve_$ '\\,\¢& a Co»\f‘\' Yv\\)\§\’ reso\'ve, four ¢VLLS‘\"\¢>\/\s DoQ\o\/d:\
X'\/\ \/\`\s avo'(.fu/e. 7 JAL/¢$oh v` E/wM¢/S/ 404 F. 352 éla/ 61\

sz\& C\(.£QDD 5)(6§\"\\1\5 DAV/`$/ "2`70 -F. 2>& A,"( \QJ-\->_ _

/‘ Was a /Vp_/\¢L \\`\.S ¥`QTLL`\\”Q& ‘\~o €o\\o\/d '\"Aa. QQ,LIS§DV\S

av\& r%$ovi`\v\§ 6§ '“/w. ULSk $w?rzw\e, C<>'~Msf c>v\ - &em\ cows\"\sw&`\ov\a\
I$SuQ,$`//éL/ZMM@ Y~ 57££¢}&/ 33 SN‘L 332 2497 143 Ta.x. CrlM\A\>?` 2002>\
A$ SuG\/\/ '“AL uw\&e/f\>/`w\§ P¢L&MA \aw i\/\ “§`/\`\$ YSSAL-'\'\rm‘¥ 4

2

` _w\/w:¥\\o,( ow\ o{l`€§ce( revc$sv`\v\g a wafmv\‘f W°w\& \'09'
¢ov\$\"\¥usf`\o\/\A\\ rQ_v\/\)~`\\’e_& '\'o SQ_‘\" €Df'\\¢\ +\¢\o. Av\‘\"\ cubasz W\QM\S
fo\’ Q>/ ¢S\'a\>\§$\/\@£( \oy '\'\/\a_ §v`?raw\g_
god m pa/,'a ./. un;f¢! /%_f¢,;/ L… u_s'- zz%, ¢\‘\ S.C‘v- \é@’.z/éo
\_.Esz. 1a \vv€\qvq;,\h ./>¢/;a, w com &15 wsm/§ +\AQ FMM
Aw\a_v»&ww.v&'$ \/\\o~rm\,\\‘ C\M\$a, Av»& \/\A& '\Jv\£v wei/her \'\¢\a_
lambua§@ o~F ‘HML Cov\$"§¥m¥u>v\ no/’ I'\‘s §Qc`§$§ov\$ §v\j¥ex\>fe\"\v\§ '“¢\o'&
law my.` Su§§@/s‘¥s '¥:\Mo& \`sQ,ML\/\ \Amf(o\v\§s ¢x\su rvw\S\' §v\¢\u&@
0. ;pec\ gca \ov\ v e. raise vv\»\v\v\u iv\ »\\\A`,~_ b
\'>Q_ Q_XQ,L\A"'eLQ_ ////f; 257qu 'S~ C'%» @& \65\?> (€,\M\>`M\LSI\; :\§Yé&§.r_?o-`r\oz,
SMQ/\\I`\' is u\e_m\\>z \e{lsf ‘Y-'o +\AIL &;SLF€\"\OV\ D{` ‘“AL axeculrlv\
oHI`\cv.FS ~Y~o RJMW[\\/\Q_ ‘“Ao. A`e,'&v.`\\§ o€ \/\\>\/J \Q@?\' '\'o \>fz>(_e_e.& 3
w\+\r\ +\Ae M’\>vw\¢.\v\ce, cfa s@_¢(¢\/\ am ov`\ze§ \97 v~lMM\/&-
SM\OSUJ\' 0‘C eau/rsa '¥¢> '“/w_ Q\/\zm\ F\u/(JY`A Amo,mg»\, W`\~&\A +\,\@ \)\la»cmv€r C\av.sa as wc\\ as §v\ cow€\\¢\'s
wm w @,\W\, .,§&,,\\@\z$\w&.g@&w\ w umw ble/faa

Uv\&z( ‘¥\\e,$e. a`\r¢v\w\$¥omces, A\)Y\`\cave( Nf \&€/5 '\\'\i& “\’L '\'('( “\ _'L°°!&
md w \/\°\A`\v\§ +\A,,& \\\\Am as m 5\#““`~¢`\“\° z `\$$‘*@ ?““5““"€5£ €“

+\/\o. C°w(;¥/s cov\S`\ &ua)r`\vv\.//[//;;_m+¢ # 31

2. Wa.$ a Men_< rul 177 /i/e vaP/>/l"c¢lJL/`o;/) pa/dj/’a/?A of file abbaij
rg,Zu/'re¢/ dl/l//é/ 7'@><45 /ab_\/_Z

5.€\:¢5¥`\°\’\ 4‘07£“$('9~9'> bfi C`“/w. Tu&i' '§¢Pg\;\)e&` Av\
Q,@W\¢_v\ txv\ b 0,»\$0_ AS; A `\‘ ,,_v\ E»“`U`L ~ ' m `
r\ wire&i“l\>@\\°€&*y) CC) llv\ F€ v\`\f€:§k fe$u\’r/~ Av»& Cb/) Jr\\q._v\¢ chem l
° ’*"\ z’<~ V=E)l~ CwE ANM. §A~D‘l(©(')-Q'\(Vu'vwv\
1%05)- Ayp\`\wv»‘v v»»‘ws,-\RL r@wc,& m\c\_&$ +w& »ML 4,(~\“\ (/Wd(sv
¢((°“&°“$\Y °W‘"*Jre’& '“"“' \\ (°' `£`m& °“SVA\°“"\’Y////¢£ §\.o‘/'Cv~\(i?§(?>\/
‘“ **“L ‘\\’v\`\¢“*`w“ W'*§~\\>\“ 0 “\“L \m>»wx;w.\ Mm gm
b\/\M§C.CCP` 05 \:\€~ E)/ 0°\’\’\`@\9`:, €W ¢'${ov\ w\‘X\/\ \“X~¢Lyé( .\_° §@\`WM A$ A\\,L

'“n£, o v\S!LC{€`\ o,£( `\V\ -\-\Aq_`S-¥Lj:\jm/ \,{\§`%v\\& {UL\

cov\&v\c:\' v,v\u£`\' \oo_ mccovv\\>vw\\z' by ‘\\¢\e_ ru\/\Mrz _au.\\?¢\\a\\\\»)/»-\~.Q~
l \` ` \\.5`21, Te)<. \\\;A\,Tw

/ Coo/< v. 52

, %<5/+ s‘c c>§ Cx`\vv\`\vw\\ \Aw, '\\/\lx‘< ?v\ or&e,( {»D
00\/\$¥`\\'\¢% tx CXKM¢, 'Wo, Ac“¥ er a¢%u_§ fed,< 'Mu\s\' \ov_ \

Acw w\»po\v\`\z ' ~\o>/ o\ €/r`\vv\`\vm\ wa`\v»& e( mw.<' fea.”). A\>?\\C“Y\l‘
ow§vwé Jv\/\w¥ -¥\\@ ej,m>'v\€/c>gs a\/\M§C uv\c,ov\ssv`\\~v£ov\_@\\ \@s$ev\lv\§
‘H/w_ S'§`A`C/§ \D\M’l&“/V\ O-f» F(O\>F A\/\& C’/FQA\"\\/\S 0\ ?f§§uv\k \?\"\ev\

im -H,\q_ “\{rv\\vx&$ vF +\/{L ju/(O\'$ "\'\/\a.“\' o; \\ (`Q¢`/\L`\\“e& C»»\ POZL\@§\`\X>///
was vw v\@ce,s§/MI m v»`\re h 901 0 v,' \@@ v\ k
rwsoma\`o\v. )L~>»\WV. 7 x ‘W V §§ >/?

Ba,cwa, Ayy\`\cavé¥ wm c\em\ e,v&`\&\@_& 1¢0 4 know}n/

@_\@M¢v\lv ‘D\ 311\/»5 '\SM\JX “\lw?'
» `\S m_\_ W\M~`s`. ~\V\ §§ wa \U¢( -\\,\L Cvux\'(§ oov\$§&exa&v`u>v\\(/%)_ '

3.. D/L{ #1£ /£/L[/LL_/€ %D /\M$]erc% 7("¢10_ rQ_i/ul`/`ej Lu,/P¢:(L/`//`/>‘/ /'l/I
1%@ charge fesu// /`)4 a '/en/`¢L/ af /de /prvce$s_? '

\~\» \¢\Ag \,0\/\5 \oe_Q,\/\ \/\@\lg( “\'\Aa& \\[a__\\/\ o\M`\SS`\OV\ -Q(<)M '¥\(\Q_
c,oux¥/§ c\/\M@L 0{»_“\/\ w\\°_§&j¥`\O\/\ Tv\ “\N\Q. \v\&`\¢>l¥v~/\(_ //CumL/`¢`l/~ _
zink/573 s¢w. :LA 732,733[1"@»<`&:»4.;¢??. \¢\74)(¢\"¢£¢10“ W;H@;Q)_ .
T\n`\§ `\v\c\wé(e,$ ‘H/\o. \\va\`\+\*`\v\ bw\\>a\@\@~ vv\e,\/\JYA\ S&o&e,$-”/j)
,sz\"\v\§ W&}Z V. }”/A/@/ 567 S,. . lé\ 5\'5 C`\`u<~`(:(`w\/\`A\>\>~ \‘\7§)`\-\@(2/
A?\>\`\<;v\v\§ M was ‘r\/\A‘r ‘Yv§e_ -\'(`\1).\ com/5 0\¢3¢\0\/\ 107 ow\`\\-¥\v\§
-H,\Q, v u§\r@§ C\~X?a\o`\\`\’f>/ I\/\ `\`\‘S `\v\§‘\((\xc,`\"\o\r\ 51\/2,\{\ '\~1> ‘\\r\o_
jury WA$ m $uv»élamo_v\‘wc\ e/(n>( §v\ \A\(C\<,\/\ go §v\€@¢}¥e_§(
\AI§ \\e,v\‘v`(fe, ¥r`\o~\ `\\/\oi\' Wl F@$\JM"\_\/\ cov\vl¢\‘§ ov\ v{s\ojf¢s
gm pfoce$$.~//Cu/>}) V. Na;/X?hfen/Hl# tX‘$_ \LH, \47(\‘\73>\`\`&\`(5
is \¢>¢¢M\SQ_ \\Jf\\\'lov\ e`£-iv\v\ocQ\/\LQ, §§
mwsur@& \o>/ '¥\r\o_ ?erc@ 912 '\lv\z, S&\ow"\.v\S v\e.@ 2/ “\’0 o\;McoW\C
i`\'/ \/J\/\`\&\/\ §§ PFo!>~F `Ov.>lov\§< A FZASDWA\Q\L Ro‘w\cl( "'\/\0& O\
&¢{Zo,v»&aws(/} §§ 1 D{l V\A`\v&é< wAS Iv\ ~€AC`\' w\/\d& ‘“'ML c`/\MS‘L
sjw§`mg_//C/Mk v` /#//'zz>wa/ \9~[¢ S.C-¥. 1704/1714(1006>.

\\¢\éca,$$ C[MA$@ 06 '“AL pod`\'€€v\"€\»\
Avv\q_v\&vv\@v»\' Ao,v\`\e,$ §‘&A'&z$ '“'\°~ \>°W€/( '\`\> &zv‘f`\\/e We ACL\,LSQ.£'

4

.0€ \§\BM'\‘>/ \MA\Q,SS 'HML `>(o>`o_¢w\'e( \>(0\/@,$ \oQ.>/ov\& A _
'rwsbm\@\e X\>w\o\~ &vo/r)/ e/\o.vv\zv\‘¥ o ’f£\@ c,\/\'M 134 exa€@y\gg_//
MM`/'l'n@z V. 6£/6/'1$4/?>74 F :">X \O L{-, \D§ZC¢\Q\A C~`(_ 20019`\\JM
§v\$$(ruc§\"\o\/\S \Fe,\`\e,\/`\ v\g §‘¥o;\‘e,$ o\C ‘\\,\{5 \ou,(&w\ v~\b\a&@ o` - 7
&£\Cub(`-/$ €AL`\\Q,T€_ '\~0 5`\\/2, `\'\AQ. V\/\Q.\/\'\`IL\ !AQW\L\)\\'
iv\é§'(\w\’§pv\ `\\/L ‘\\,\o_ c,\l\M U$ L\W\`\ ca‘\"\o\/\ P¢:L(A$m\p\,\ gq\*

A\>\’\`\cmé\'$ »\'(`\0»\ V;°\A@/"V\S myers +° &“Q `YH>&SS °€ \Am.

4~ /5 HI@ 7Lr/`zc/ &wf?£/$ e/H)?’ F@M¢¢/}'JL/¢ b)/ h¢‘L@¢U Cof/>uS_?

A\>\>\'\ca\/\‘\' \'\°5¥€/$ `“/\Di& \\"“\¢ c\/WLS‘&(¢>\/\ `\S v\o`\` w\/\zJ¥\/\Q,( '~Suc`\\\'
may be S\>e\'\* o~x¥ o{ a quoré(, \'o\x§ w\¢\d\,\@_( w`\\l.v \/\A$ S@a,@v\ 1
{_ouv\& b g J\M>/ \A(:Co!`él\v\ '\'o 'H/\o_ rocc%b\(`€, AV\AL 5"01\!\$(&(4&§
A`>yropri'a z {l¢r( U`\vv\\v\a\ -\"(\AS.//Ca/a//a V. Ca//` oft/lia, 1+4\ U\.S_
15$,16¢\,\1>‘1 S-c;+. 14\‘\, 1412/105 L.E&. 1& Q\ZJQZ‘MSCAL\A,
j./ C,Q\r\(’,w(f“\\/\§)-\V\ D`H\<>/( waAS/\\[~\-]\AQ,(Q §§ F\A`\V\\ -A
{luv\&o\vv§¢v\\'a\ {loi\\'vm$$ §v\`\e/mssr/ eve\/\ o\\)o,(-\' ‘{lmvv\ Av\>/ c\'c\`\v\/\
rg_\`\p\v\co_ or y\\>\"\(;@,/ §v\ \/mv`\\,\g ‘\'\M>_ l§'\'oc¥¢.] ol\¢>(£l@_ \a>/ '“/\g V\A\‘LS
619 hud I'¥ 95¥@\@\¥5\,\@,5 -\~\> Sbvuv\ Jv§/w. ai(cuvv\s\'m\ca§ un£@'(
w\¢\`\c\)\ I\' cav\ Jlo.¥r`\va A PMS<>\/\ of \A`\$ \`\\ou\“j br \Kf€`//£a/Wl@//
n 72><@,<,514 u.s;z\z,.zzz,no s`c&. \ezo,\ez‘z,\we L.E&. 119 577
flooo)_ Hexe/ v\»‘v bv\\y +\/\A' '\'\/\o. ‘HCA\ ¢¢\MSY/s *`F §§ C” A(€
\>MQ\)/ Q,r(`ev\e/bu\$ aLv\.& W\o,(Q, c,¢>v\(_\u`§o‘(>/ Av\A\>/$`\g/ \o\,é§ @\\`$o
uv\$u\>po(jfe,& \a>/ §o`cl¥$ off `“Ae, co.§Q o`v'»& o\v\>/ \150\\_ w*\¢\e(\\')'.
\M \M\XW\§ ~¥\AA“X \\ 'Me, Me. m issues v\/\AMZA,\ '\'¢> A\> \`\wv\‘('s
L\A`\W\$ w\,\`\c_\/\ V\Q_Q_&` '\'\> \0£ F€So\VQ,&/”[/`¢/¢Iv\o`\"?~# l+z/ '\'§r\Q- '\’(L &\
goursc uv\re,a$ov\a\o\)/ 4\7\)\{2,5< ¢“UU\>/ e§‘\'v~\o\`\$\\mgk €o,&e(o\\
law _, Su\L\/\ ms £u/),O/ /`MMe/de/ av\& Ca/fe//A) 5\*5\“ 9~ €q-V"
U/\>Q» D€ T.AC
¢\aivw \/\oxe,,+\/\d A ra_vi@w‘m§ oD\/Vr\' cbv\s{§<@( ‘WL uv\£@(\>/`w\§
F°u,(-}\,\ M§l F°Mea_v\"¥c¥/\ Avvw.v\&vv\@_»&§ a\o\`\vv\$~\v\ 50 &o`\v\ ,'W\
h`\o)\ wur‘\' AQ\!`\¢L‘Y@¢S< gram ‘\'\/\A \QSA\ rw\e w\/\`\c\/\ cow$¥`\[§
(»\°\A;w§ w mmr w w \\ A@v€»é<`\w 9mm »\ \@3“\ mm

5

"U‘°-///)/`"e“. “/"° `L/"§` "“ W°/f¢/ 145 F. 2»\ 1921@,\(3& am
100\)(`\@11 C~>M'\’/$` &Q'V§AJY§OV\ \@FOW\ A \1).3&\ N\a, cov\$$v`\’m’§v,$
`em>(’//)_ Fux’f`/\exmom,§v\ \/\.~>\XI\,\§ 'WA‘V `\ \Mseél ov\_ A review

o{i l'\\¢\`\$] A?p\`\co\jv§ov\/“H/\e, mco_n§ ¢>§ ’c\¢\c¢ ca$z/ Av\& g \>\§¢a\@'\@
\m/J,'+\Aua,`\$ Y\o `\§$\ML` €q'( -“Ap, C°M\-’} »¢ov\$§ Q@(&&"OV\ // l~/,_:“b;m¢g>
'“\L "\'Y,\A/\( €/DU/(`\' PY%V@,X °“/\BX' ("' &i& v\o`\' IXQ_V\S(I$\/ &C\ /
$\'(ua\‘cx(o\\ e((v( e( ¢\\>_§>\y L\Q,M\`?/ QQ_LS(Q,(A\ \0\\,_1 §v\ Jr\,\;$ CASQ`

\vx 229 \AM@QM re\`\e, 15 \a\v\\ warrav€¥e_é‘\ \/\@r@__g gQ_
-H,m, §'H:Xe.-'(Ss u@& wM-m€v\sr »~IAPS \\ c:v\s\'§’vd€\bv\a\\ adam

5 rkva //
aw§@ "f\¢»o_ \'r§a& coMJf'$ §a`\\wm ¥\> \>n>?@/(\ `\'\A$‘c@>:¢ aim Q /'
mQ.\/GYA z\mmo.v€¥”i\/\ ““/\o. c\/\M§Q',< _v\§)?\`\v\& &Q§r`eq m _ POSSQ,SS{DV\ \(\`0\32_§ /S\\LQ_
\>'(~bc@g§ A\,\& ‘¥\,\m$/ \r\a, \5 _e,v\‘\"\"\'\zzsl ‘\'1> \AA§@Q¢)`$ YQ\`\Q_ \¢,Q(_wg_gq
beck +\/\o_ uv\cov\s\"\)vwsv`\ov\a\ §vl£>/ `\v\$\'mc\"\z>v\ A_v\é\‘ JY\ML &a~Qz¢’d\/Q
SQ,UO\/\ WU’L¥`(&V\`\` WQ/F@ V\G'\\'\\\/\.§ \LS$ `\"/\Av\\\(/A'\'ASXWQY\MC`//To
\NM OH\UWKSQ wom\z§£ sz\§wr Da,//"J¢ vv\LAv\`\v\S\n_$S max
woulz&' 1350 Crw£&@ oh \>»M-e\>/ M\o`\’cnu>/ §L`\s\"\v\¢’f`\ov\ be&vde_e\/\
'\‘\,\o$@ §v\ A\>P\;C@~\'\AY'S Yl>$d'lov\ Av\é< 0‘&\\@($ w\,\o wbu\$é ev\§t>)l
+\/\o. YQQ,\/\e,§{jr o{l ex C¢>\”fe,d\" &o.€\$`\ov\ by a review`\v\é walk
569 @~j¢/ hicka Vl/ 404 F¢ 334 §§ éOJ-Z%C/Méea$ fe\le.§ GMV\JY@,$
bmw/se jury iv\$\'mc¥§ov\ cov\slvi‘vu&e& A cov\sjv`\`\m‘vlov\¢\
v?v\e»’“`°\/\ b\C ha §>“>¢@SS)/~ £o¢/<@rham v. dam, 231, F_ 319 ézv,
éezu;+k m zooldéswm>/- saw/w V. co#w, 349 F` z& 571
BZB_C`/’v\\ 36 ‘lDDS)Csamb/‘ M_M%/`nez, 374?. 351 A \c>L+\ (saw\¢)

/ .
/
‘ hmw/kw v. M_u///n, 340 F. 332 \\Z\, \\¢\L»Cu>’dA Cz¢. 2004)(5“\~\¢)_

cuMuL`A‘r\\/E ERP\oP\
AS -“M' `\'QXM C¢\,q,(~\» §§ CYKM\¥\J\\ AYYQ_A\$ `r\o\$ \(\QS\BL +§\5&

g vw\w\\@ox of em)\’$ may ‘OQ ouv\& \/m(w\ u,\ `\v\ ’v\,\o,`\(
ouw\u»\o\\'l\/e é,]C\Czr/‘h// W/`/`j /*l7L V~ 5 “7£€/ 13 §~W` 3 525/937 CT€)<-
C\"\M~)‘\’Y~ ZDGD>~ T\M" S”\W\O, KS ‘¥Tv\z "/\QFQ `\`\¢\»& -,3<:9\>\`\ eavisi MS\)\QS
`\'\AQ cMmM/a%')`\/e effec% o€ o\\\ 'HAL [a\oo\/e:_\ e,(m($ \Q>/ '\'\,\s(\‘a\'v\’¥ 3m v\§ve JY\¢\£Y I‘< vv\o\\<_e,s m ¢§`\QQe/mv\ce,

\\

6

. . 'H\¢i\"o\ Xa.§w¢&av€\' \Ms SW§\/\\'"A '/\cw 'Pf`\¢~\ o\$ owe o - \~`¢s mm¢&~es,or
` Q\ln.v\ ms '\,?19/ 5°\"' r€“’\°'&)l~\\\`\‘ C,mw»~>\' \oo_ muv\`a €v~\>/ 305in ~\\¢\ad' a

\79,(5\>\,\ \`:`\A`\vo/} /. \A`\S \'§ \I\`Y -\'° ¢\ `u.&%¥v\@»v\`\’ _0~¢ \JL`\'\"\'a\ \¢> \v\o\l§ 'o’{
m vw H~A.”£w£s r. dwfe/ ,%fw>wzv u.$. 4,\7/¢\% s. oh a\);r\,a\so/ vi
E&. 154 ’\'(\‘\73>. Mo(cr>\l?/(/ Av\ a`,\)Q\\o‘Xe, cou»(\' §§ -»C\\\of`\ 0,££ -\'° \\ 0

b °V\X -`,\\L M‘\:\(""&M \r@\`\ SO\A \(\&//I °,(&M _\,° rov\` {_“A _\,
udqu W°"§‘Q \"°' `\`WS% view '“'?°' °`*(v€:\»\“/\S"Av\ca, _'/.!'@z/`(a;\;j\£,‘\ S

.d_` d Q'\;D_ "\'\A@,rq_f?{o_/ A?¥\`\co.‘¢\"( aSSV/(j\"s `\'\/\0& '\`\/\`\S Cx>u~£s( ~\'o 50`\00,7\7\¢\9:

‘\'\M' ha\=ge_o~$ re\`\e,€ \r\a, $U-\“~$ omit -€>€Ov\e_(o.¥z_ \A`\M ,,_5 0` Mo-&SYM ne z
\Aw av\>l co\/\Scio_v\¢@,`

coN'(;\.uS\OM

_ \'\~ `\5 WQ.`\\' €»$'\'A\Q\`\$"\@`& `“/\D& \`['\'-.\\/\o_ w<:\'\' o€ \v\a\ao,a$ Cv(¥v\£
¥\a>/.s a v§'\'o~\ ro\a, `\v\ \>m\`e.cs€\v\? O°“S\-;\_u&\ev\a\ d \N&S`//;/ack V. Mcbdm._e/
59.‘\ u_$. 473/423/\20 S.c+. \54‘5,\ °?/\L*S L~E&~ 119 541€?-000).¢~5 suc,\¢\, 4 /
Xls\v\`\$$r,\.\ \\ \,\A\o'ea§ ?e\"\\’;ov\ `\S A `>M'\"\cu\a,(\>¢ 5@_(`\0\,\; ma-\»)W/(/ U_\,
‘T\Ao;\' alsw\`\s$o»\ ¢Sle.v\`\e,$ '\\\e \:><\>\>\`\wv\"<:\ +\M. \>\’<>'\`Q-¢'\"\ov\$ o ~ +ML @rrvf&
\NY`\SY JJ»V\'\"\\'C\)I) V`\ S\§IV\ ;V\`yify '\'° AV\ ?vv\~ D`f\’av\'\ §v\"€uz$'\' Iv\ \r\o.vv\av\ \`\\ou\'>/_”
;r,~$//p,r v, Jplm;pw,\7¢+ F~ 3¢;( 7\0,7\3(5“;\ @»`\f. \‘\‘\‘\\(c`\'\"\v\¢§ [onc/;¢§SW LA.§_ ¢g\'
321-\-)."[\¢\2,<`¢‘20(0., +\¢\2, “\'(`\a\ 69\)\(1¥'5 rewmm@n$(x\"\ev\ €vf X`\$`w\lssa.\ g "“/\`\$
S“`°Se' “Lv& w(.\\_ AY¥\`\CA\'"D\.\/`\v\ so ho`\v\$/ `\\- `\ v\,¢>(Q_Q '\‘\¢\a. ¥n>\’zc,\'\m\ o€
~H,\,L (’n@_a-¥ \Nr`\f\‘ a§§o»r&o_& -\~o A\>y\`\¢““\' av\zsl. \\`\S ivv\\>rrf\'ow\l¥ `\\,;\‘@cu¥ 06
\(\`\s \`\\ou¥)l.

Beca.uso_ AF\>\`\¢R\~"('$ fl°~&€¢(`&\ V`\§\f\&$ -\-x> &w). §)(oco,$$ M\¢Sl e,\l€zc\"\va,
Asg`\s\-av\cv. o re*\'v`\a§ cb\,w\so,\ aw' ‘\’r`\»»\ _c,¢>uw\$@\ were vlo\,£(e_&/
cov\$€,lvkcv\,(\)¢) &\`\$ de~('\' s\r\ob\\& S(ex\r\"( `\'\\`\$ vdf;j( 'AY?\`\¢¢`\~"BV\‘

PRA\/E¢L Fog RE\, \e\=

_`.§:0% -'\'\/\e €0(€_30`\“3 FC&SDV\S/ A‘p?\`\wv\'\' ?(A)/_S -\",\A"' ..\»\“S _\_\_°v\o(.&\a\o_
(,oux’f:

4` u?°v` 'r°"k;ew °€ '\'\"°' "?~¢°‘”& `o{i"\\/\`\s c,¢»se, mixed ’t\;\e, XF\A\
cour¥f$ recomme_v\&o§c`u>v\ o_v\& graver ¥\,\o_ wr`\‘()~ am}<

2. T\Aac\ A§>\>\`\cav\‘( \mm/e, suc\/\ o'\\/\€»f M\BL €\M*\\M m.\`\e€ AS \r\Q_
-w\g`>/ $\r\§w \'\`\\N\$¢\€ ~\'o goa `S\*$\'\y 2,»\"(`\‘\'\2,&.

12__ \,MW\, §“\Mx@&,

w

HAW\`\S C,»\D"v\&e,
\b`\ \‘E 9_% 2\7

\\L\SD FN\ ‘\‘\Z

bcL\\/\a,r\',T@,)< ¢LS 7 ‘\b ll

Ap/>/fcanf Pn, ja `

DECLAP~AT\ O\~\

\, HAN\\'$ ¢-v\'&or~/\M~\ c+\#\~\x>€, mm +w, ,a_?`,\`\,;k“& §`,\ %\;\$
(‘_LL\A.SQ, Av\t& 511°`\“’(€/5/ _\)~“&M \79~""\“$\\'7 of \>MSM)¢,‘\*V\¢L\' '\'\\o_ o\o`sq,c\"\ov\ wood
i\/\`?MS§¥\ &@\\Ve’(e'>l '\'° -\'\'\Q' `¢\Y?(°?{-Yal\‘€. ?\“`\S\>v\ au)"\&'\o\".\'\~('z,_< ¢)_JT
“\\Az \Aw \`\\omf>/ ov\ J\H\Q, '\, lb\S/ Qo'( QM\AMX\\¢\,S -\»° MQ, ¢_\Q,(\r_ ci

“\'\Mz. '\'z>\"\S¢>\‘\ au*¥\dr`\\'§@_;_ -

 

E)/O\/\S - <_@Q/L
v ' )r'\ Am`\s C/\/\¢.‘v\ &Q