Court Opinion

ID: 4075564
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 06:11:26.126824+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:27:39.587720
License: Public Domain

C.S\.USE. ~(),            \'2,1q \ C..~         g4, 39'-/- 0/
 PMlL , A. ~ODPJ.W~:z..                                            ~                      :I.~ 1\\~ 63rd .::!ut)"iC.l~L

  ~~.                                                              ~                       D1S1R1t\            t.OOR\ OF
 Va \ Verde.     Cnu~nY D1_<l1R1C.1   CLE.tt\\:                    ~                       \fa\ 'yade.         t\)\1\-ll'f .··n_)J}.S
                                                                   ~
                                                                                          RECEIVED IN
                 Aa · PllHIDfF~ .A.PPLitA.1lOh.\ f()R.                         \&JPJ195fUm-tRf\)-ALAPPEALS

                TO T\-lt. \-\D\UD~LE. ~J\JDbE. Df ~AID tD\JR.\ :                                         @~~
              .,               lutl\t~   \\Dw     1   ~an\    f\   Bcd.r\~~1-- ~ ~e.\a\bY" ~~r~~~ t!'"            the..
   abo~- st~le.d ~ncl l\urt\neJecl Cdl~S.e. cJ ac..t'mn ~"ci -\\\e.~ -th\~ -1\~~\ \e.a\\tl\\ \~r \Jt,\
. of Mt~hd~l'lu~·'-· -~ur;ant to ~rtic.\~,. 2. ;?.. \, D{ \e.'(dS. tMie e\ C..r·\~~~Ja-~d.nt\
  iAlou\d ~hew \-he. lour\ the. ~Cl\\ow\nq ~ .
                                                                                              · uuc,u contains some
  & 1 R2 \a\cr                                                ...L                        ;:-u·~~ !:i'ia1 are of poor qualit)J
                                                                                         '- •n€ dme of imaging.
  LO\     P. a.u\ ~ Rc:clr'tgue.1., Tl)C.J #   lql-{2.1\G   '~ dh o\te.rK!e.r \nc.an~.e.ra\e.d \o th~ \e.x<\S
   De.~rhf\tf\t o\ C.rirt\\na\ J""us\\c.~ al\t'.\ \s a~\)e.ar\ n<::J ·~r()-~e., w"o ~dn be_ \Qta\e.c\
  a.1 Dt.rn·i~ue.l. Ut\(t. 6515 ~M'm \\ci1 ~a(\ ~t\tDl\\() \exa~ 1S15l..
  LD1. \\J~\c.r h~~ e.(haus\ecl h\s l'e\Y\e.ct\e..~ an~ ha~ Ml h\hex a~eq~a~~ ft~et:\L\ a\ \~w.
  \,\\\ 1~~ ad ~!\ugh\ \o be. tl'lft\pe.\\e.d is, ff\\1\\$\e.r\a\ 1 \\D\ £1\~u~\·,un~wy \\\ n~\\)(f.                       1

         D"' or abou+ ~he. 2\~ d~ o-f :Iu\'1 '2D\~ ~e..\~\()r \'\\({.. h·\~ ~ta-~t:.. Mo,\()n
          -\or ~uMC. '\),Cl \\J~C... Ve..\"v~·~{)\'\.\t\9 \-'n~ L\erh <!J \.~·~~ -\-"e.. \\c,(\~td~\e.. C.~ur-4-
          cf \fa\ Ve.rcte. Luun\'t -\-o -\-ra\\s~·,\\ Jcl) .\.~e. Ve.~~\·a~nex anl\ an.~W~J .s. .\\\e.e\ ~
        .ahct a. c.uL{~r.d\t ~e.C.:rt\t\9 \he. c}C\k upon ~~\t~ \~e.. \\nd\n.9 was. 'f4\~0.t.1 \\
         -the.. t~W~\thrt~ ('_OOfts. cleLlde. · \~cxe. d'fe. nD \SSU~ ·h~ be.. 'fe.SD\\ft'..d. ~\act
          -\.he.. £)ht;>\!e._ be..e..n \rahsm\\\ecl -\-£1 ~he. ·~e..\a.\D'( 'o.J ·~e.s~Dhde.t\t as w. <\u\re.c\ b~
           ~ct\lw.., \\e.\at()f WDo\d h~\le. \)rnc.e.ed~c\ w\\-h \\\~ \\,t\1 ~t-\\: D\ \\a.~~a~ LM~lY:l.
          Th~ ~nn he.re.. \~ ~e, gre.a~ \hd\ the.. ~m-~t!{") of ~n~or -\he. ~e\a\Dr ~~~
          1-\te.~"~e.cl -\o ~he. ~~~r\ s.h()~\d hd\le. .sh\~\ed -\. D -\-he.. ~-\d\e.. ~"d a. n af\~wex
         ko\d he) \ft. be.t.f\ ~r~f\\C..r.,becl ~t.l ~'he. Re.~\or hy t'bpcm&e..n~.
  l, Be spDDde c\
  2..0\    b~nde.n-\ 1 ·,n he.r/hi.~ te\fk'.c.i\y a.~ lJlS\lli.\ C....lf.\l\<.. o(. Val \fe.rd.~ Loun\'1 \el:a5
          ·h&s 'ct rt\~lf\·l~\e.r·,d\ dut-y tD re..te..\'Je. ~\\cl -\\\e.. a\\ ~pers \O a. C(.\\'4\\M.\ ~\O(.e.~cl.\~~
           ard ~re.~rt<\ ~\~ cl~e:.r t~urte~ \rc\~osed fit\ -\-he. c..\(...r\<.. h'f \~w ~or..suan\

                                               lu            ()~       l~) ·
                to \C:.C..P· A(\\. '2..,"2..\l and ·,~ · respor\stb\e. to tr,;m~IV'\i\ d\l of -the: tor9cin~~
                io +he. ~e..b.tcr ·• n \his \~sue. ~ ljfe.~ h:,)rm and t.~V\shtu\toV\a\ vlo\~~\ot"'\
                dhd G!.rror of Law. \/~l \Je.rd~J J)i~h-~c.t C..\e.rKj v~\ Verde. t~un\'1 M&.\j be.
                Se..r\ld ~J h\~ j he..r ~lac.e... 6~ b~~\~e...f,!. a\- vc_~\ \1 e.rd<. ~ud\~\ e.l!.t\~e.r, ·p, D.
                ·nDX 1544 lJC:t\ ·p_~D J Tx. '1S~~I-\S44.

            :D,          \l',o\a+i()n   J     art '2..'2.1   cJ   tht. 3exas Corle     of       Cr\rt\\na\   ~cocgc\qre
              ·:\,0\        l"o d~\-e.} "Ke.l~h~\- h~~ ru.e..\ve_d      V\6 fe_\pof\SC. \rbM.        ~e.~~o~~~t re..~t"c\\"'9
                             'Ke.b~or-'~ l'e..~ue.s-\:- *'~c h·ot\Sf1\~t~d\ Df .d (\)~'1 .Dt \\\u~U'- ~tl) \u~c..) df\"1
                             '8.1\Swe..rs t\le.d ~1\d d <:..Ut\~-,~~\e.. ('e..u\·,"<j -\he_ cl~\e. u~o{\. ~~\c.h
                             th~\ ~i.f\d\f\g wa~ m.;ade... ·h::> \-he. t~ur.\:. Re..\~~Dr '-'a~ fe.(\e..a\e.~\~
                                                                                            1

                              ~ u~ 5Re.s.~o "d~t\ ~ bf\ V\ ~-\:\(e._ th~\- ~~.h \t:~ r ~ ~ \- fd_\\S m·l \-\ ~ \ c.~ (). .
                             C.o~'-1 ok .the.. Q~~\.\-\\lC\ -\'or \nul\.}L- \)ro \ \)~<.. ~Lspc\'\de..".\- ""~~ ~~-,~e.J
                             +D  ~t-~Drd Re.\~~or ~ht.. ~(D tt...ssL~ 1\ci\ and C.()Mtr\0\'\ c.ourte. S\}          0 \'   cl't\\j
                             wr'1He.l\ rc~{Y>t\Se.s. ·\-D k~..~ c.Mre.Jpohde.nc.e. &Y\d re..que.~\-~.

                                                                  IT.
               ·~.         Deaver       tcr   Re \j(.f
                              \Jdhe.:re...fbre...' Yr~\""'\\.se.~ LCI\.s.\de.re.d' \\d.,\cr ~a'\l\ ~ ~~t.\t\Cjue.-z. } {)rc- s~1
                                                                                       J

                               re.s~ec-\.f.liU y r-e.q ues~ ~ 4hd\ -\-k~ \-\ohor_a~\e.. Lour-\- .feq u ~ r~ \'-'e..
                              ~e5\)0hde.f\-\- ~D ~f~t\~M't* C)~t~~e... ~·\cl clCt.\l\'n~l\·~u. J ~k.::, . of'. a.~~~\S
                              f\\e.d ~Y\d ~ tt('\1~\(~-~te.. re..~ll\u\9 -\ht.. d~~e.. u~cr\ W~\c.\-. \-h~\- ~nclu'\~
                              w~~ rr..dcle..   L

                                                                                       Qe..~~e..c::.\ \u\ \'I ~u'n\"\ ~-\\e..d •

                                                                                f,y:       (-'      tfi:/'
                                                                                       i~~l~\\J~

--..-,·.>~.-•' ••· •a.
                                       ()Rl)FR

       On -th'1s d~y J C.;}\'1\e.. Or\ tD be.. hu\rcl \-~e. ~t:>rUjc\(\':}. ~e.\a\:ar's
 ~f>~\\~t\~1'\ tDr VJ"·'~ Df \J\~C\J~f(\0~ dt\cl \\ a~~~r~ t~ -\-he. Lbur~ tha~
 -\.~e...   ~N\t..   .S.h()ll\d he   ! .

                                                        - - - - - - Dt.~lE;D

    lt \~ 1\-\t.\l\:.f{)Rf_ DtDtRtD ·t~a\ ~ht -p·\stric:\- tte.r~ ~~o\\ \tr\Me-d\~~\y
tra"~mi.t tD the. ~d().t6r ~ c..cp'f o~ .\-""<. k\utu'- 9ro \\j~<- 1 ::l'f\"J. a"swe.rs.
t(\e.d) d\\d ~d CLr..\-'\f~c.E\k.          N ..   c.·,rl"9 -\-"e. dJte..   u{JDn wh~ch -\-~:\~ trao~fl\\~k\
w~~ N\~de...