Court Opinion

ID: 4069368
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 00:34:41.435947+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:06:09.154672
License: Public Domain

!£0 350@12>21201§

/MC COUW CF’QJZL/~u/dm_ ///h”€¢a¢h_§ cJF mA;S
Hozu` /)nSa:l_ /)c&osm . 11me ‘

p¢O. QJC¥ \ZEOZ @Wl’¢`ol_ STM‘T'|Q/J
msma.q’e:V/AS 727:\

33 §>.§-0*//

Pq(;; 3151¢,1,.1[,,@¢; Vgnrwm_'g MC<‘,T¢@J TD ME/MCQMDLAE" {wms~
Mcgsm/d ap »m¢§ R'gcom> ml C/+u§o.:/\lo. z \,J:C'BZ,SO§~©'-f;
“ES( P/\Q:E, Swy>r|m L;. lyn/15 w mg CDUUQP c//zLM,/MAL/APFQ»LS
QPMA§" \er»?>Z,$cS»C)'-I ;/m.c;f. M»o'. 'zBH')~/-A

R@'HL M/L, /)rac>sm :

Gv@m,-\\Q»S.~§\/L, l/\S€fl’/w'l Pzn/frDAEK/Wf’ucmn’ MP Wf//\??>O\/<§’$M>
umw MU/~lfam_ Cim@\m;{ M iS'/m. &€FMWLS C_a»>;n_‘{ &;§PECTW \
Q)e®ue§./MMUC)Q mgm/16 -e£zuaa_o&m mch />¢&\/g~ M@\m mims bome
m m~f fbme umw mg Coum: (mm¢ ‘{w,

Sl\M(‘.c£mL~( ,

WW¢ /SM

wv®\§ if. MAVL‘§ VIQ7GGZI7 C,. C ." Courz,¢’ef@£m .IQYDMS/
ST!?/ml(r?m_z_c)u& U)um“, TDCZ.Y-°IL ' pou¢ £0. BISTR\CY C_l_¢m..\¢
12@0 m -@55 '

F’\@émmom /VQW& jj§§é y

RECEEVED iN
cGuRT oF chmNALAPPE/:\Ls

SEP 21 2015

A£@@£A@osia,@&@?k

 

L:/X PA<QIE 34 ‘ '~|M /(H€ CD¢M;I' @r=
x ' @/R/H»m,m,¢x@€w_§
S{¢.€PHGM §°Y>A\/\§, BL ®P {@YH£

pzz'rmov\lc>:m pea Sa:. X
' XX XX)(

pl>jmc»\l\m£ O&'Q£Cno)d /E’) ’l/HE v|/\IL‘,D/'(»¢‘LL/FE/
/n/Lmusr~u_<.s\@»d. @FTHE law m mcf Nc). \,

\A/QPBZ,§OS~@LJ
/F@ »{m>: HMMGUMTE @r/ m owen

bahqu HM~( @ém:rs 43 mm/u m<rmusnlswu m;me.'
“Su!>?c_\mau\’m (l¢_r.cm¢'s Rzm:>ru§’-WL~|“ llamé/WS§/Wfd’t’ MO..?~ \)\IR'BZ;SOS-OLL
hawk m §L)P/>or¢r m;.§ml> ammar Pc:nnmdm?. especn»/ou_v SHDMS 'rHL/
EouC(/\/v(cf ifm_mvlmLe/F/ -

I

m HM `Z,`Z.Zc)l§, pmmw_ F¢LQ:A wind 4 146 LIHTM _’Sumum_ldsmci' @a.m/
@QFoLl,/`Cmmq.'nma. A aman mamman /\s m "/wmm\n(

ch/num-\ B»{S:rlzrrim lamp \d¢h/\s" ATIBan/fc> rm»nmz§. cr mem Q.mnmlm§
Cmmmmd uu ames ma 23a-nm

:|I

/l/HESTMB@PTEXAS. ,/(rumuw /fvu.z,/ b-¢mmvaM_{` Km'£§¢: c_._f§oszM-{HT\J
éuz>\cm@ warwum, mm .H. ,4\1_1__@\£ , /\SScsM ld§maf A>rme_m)_¢/ 1506
mm Rm> nm/ P@LL dam ,~Tems;m»m dme/Mog‘nzz'ns .. wm 30 M¢/s
/f© sz£m/ gnna»um,'_§ HFm>./Nm \m»uc¢~! mmi 15le \AlrrrfTH¢>_/bcs?maf£‘_l_mu<
nw Pa_»< cw,\m( m md zz.‘zc)ls', /\T />¢»»P@vmr>zm_~/ wm m.

Mm`E:
Pr.mnm¢zr)_ LS m Fb&$es$lc>u C)\'> A ’l'rw€ mm ur~ 9

P)e§>c)lz§m§ 64 russ Prmrrmm_ mt 14 r_l.zm»_vn:m 'rrm>: &uzru¢ wm£uu¢:Z‘-I,ZDLS"
A»w>. S”m-HP@ ‘P`u..m Hw_*mc£mzcozl) 1 ZDLSSJMPFZQ¢ FN L-I?'S(," [§\{/nw;
idlsz QLQULCF Fou< Cwm‘(, unum LmTL)ILM/m 1141 Frcr, de/»w$nm@>'m
'rms H@mrme,l_¢: away anmm_ twang md Avc»usr 25, 201§.

ILT_. .
1016 961an does zmml fvt\$ Honlmna¢_e: awa?fm/r/rm:uama/m&£ QQQ»GF-'
F\A</CL>:E l_.,SO/uo_§, "~lllm gubic¢m_, biS'nucr’ awarch poucwa /¥MI;
(L.H. m_z_w rawst MM:MAL mgmm/ Anowz»{ of meaoum‘//. Tesa»& ,
m zm“U,u~/;UM HMA§“M> mangum hamm mac Fo@.mem_% w owen

'fe> magic /rvug, rimqu cwa/tm w oabm.>.® omum/_/>osan./, men ml

mime emma umw mg HQMDM wang emma £S\{ mm woman/wm
CD\.)K‘(Q» v 4 ._'~ .

Mc)‘\/mm_uaéa m »n»te: f€emru> nu 414@7 mach fm \Ams/f£msnmm m-

/rH¢s Hom/ma_¢: 000/cr or/ (!mmmm_ famous GFMP&, CN mg 251/1 544 mr

nuausr,z@¢§, m A com mr ma Mm 40 Tvv>: anmuw¢c)u /Hv@v:r
25120_05 15 <mv: QQ)NMAZQM_ mm mm -w,lm ma/Hmumz,aa_.: Lll|m ms‘num’
DQ\_MJ' QP ,Pou¢ Doum"l . ’(\zvn&. l _ v

Pumsum\//(o <rm»: wmame aom~¢mc¢m_cmp: v/-\mo Au_ums Gro\/@zmmw~ /rm»_’

arn/me mm cheum,\l¢./ m flauman />rrM\/.r§,"l’v(e:‘ Rasmuo@m:. wm SSWS

’~(0 RL>;BUT '(l/to.’ Pr:nmm¢zr£$ Fh’mm\/mAS Pr£nTlozurLrLllu'fKEAPl’n-Mvrr /`1)‘!:/>&,’171\’§
PzESPoml>mtf> Amm-#_s_’/ BN_ nu_l`mmaz,$ 311/mib nu ’M¢§ Hf/MMu:T Wc)uu§
m ns’\’e,ua' nmb Be§&mldmf_% Mr_m "n>- BQJSMB.,

' I[.
F)cé?emmzms Fv~RPcQ;cf 3m '\z> HQAW Pmnmm'$ A/WAMm/'m& ~PucP-

@S_.~? msc \/mum 1015 gm lehmann/13 c).> W Ar/mw/»r, umw w
As mems: »

|. FlaS‘V/Qmo mecgr, )~\ coanc£./m»um is 50\!@51¢:¢¢§€|‘-- /MA 'rm§
nw /fu:u_s am_~( ’\/m: ’l`)wTH- °fou¢z, mem la c?owz, ELWL, iPrrzmH
MMMFSDMMW w CMHMrI.e., /»\LLHr/mm famous mm mm

Ra.mms. /mv_m»: wound far /T\`$> »?=ms¢s Ga_m~{muua<, /\10' ms FM_LMI
mm M, quo mcwm'n&u mfc/1625 Wom_l; Be.’mo MM, Alo C/¢rF-

/mm/. 40 rw_m_u¢' m~{mmlc/. .m' woods umw "mvwmuue/ Go¢z§ /
“lzz»m mm Fb¢z.mv\.mf "fmu> ‘°Nommlc/ rums". ’fm¢-:'S magmuu Tm§
uaw azm>:§’umer¢_;. ”"\’c> L_u§ LS¢ro 60 mmeHmA“.C)mML_Fm/QB:

__“c>P /h_L/rm»r 1§ Cvmz>.‘ Sueum',r‘( is 'Smww

 

z. w QMMM mw . l ' 1096 m, ,\r~vsrf€m'@.fmm@m
omz 43 /+ M- ou roman Fm' ou/L P¢ssm~.l amfmzmi--
.` ou HM/::’fb' » 'mr: issue’ns fm c)/me,'m mmf§mem-LNCMD

/Um_»L mm mm H§m/L A Pzns@,\x nw F=m' Hw\sQ_FQ/u /mgz f_uu¢>:
fmb ASSUMC n Posmau./VM¢):ASMA,MHMM€WM.
mg sz> es mm Mmcvm§, Puf A»r K\s»¢.c)a wu_¢_uue/To§wmm mm ’
m ms CQMmz-n_c:mr__L_meu_m/ GL»MP; mann cf ms Snmmc;m§ mud
umme @zms mnmg,‘ wa mr wasn ama chMso/mews
mg éo/mms mamen_m{ mm mmc LECM_ 14me

_ ~“ME wmr»’m¢_; 475 />SS@U ms RL(:HTS, rU/\SMQME.“ F
;. ;B- MMM!Q;MMrM c_os/;s._..)z»{ umwa "

, _ drug Hm¢ms TM/w mmvhrmrum m m»@.¢zemp nwf 1‘0/& pO/MT
‘ ' Sm»u>s ns"‘/mr_m m 00»1/1&@¢ " 612/walz 11’»-@&1'1' gram Ke:emnm mud
v mg m'rMC‘-Gwmma_d- \{mmu_omsml_¢zouod czYasv-TB/&Q$a.c/,:Dc£'~
Rm§, CDuP-u crs mo ¢zum; £}mmmmu:rs />u_er,@d emma B§S)&/
mm %LTH‘£ d)¢a_mfa/ Fu£u§ M'W(L>’ eLA ~r/¢>@ D)SPum:s. .
Cmfucr;cp¢/wmmm cF*mm-rl mm malum gmac icfZM/\msd, '
lmsnzm> 0¢ 316 \Imr_mcz. - 80 P@P¢_@: ann/fm mgm _ s¢>¢mzs mm amf
mm me»:/mm mm uf hub Re$eu/g¢d, mama cf 601/aon mm
mamm\e/’l’m lezs /wA/\’L)Mm_a-' 40 K¢u_@rLIMI(/£PS. LELv/w_ /‘1AauM 1 ,

“H¢I\,er haas m K€Pc-:L A~W€o,\m/ WH\Q\§ H€md,occnssm,ds L»r.“

 

¢~.‘~n:me`m§e:»

 

LP'. finn univan /»iWnM\/mgmnms ns ’§i’iwnn ms annum

.n z l_C,i_nis-n& innm_c` WnouL{~h”»PnAm/.( ss pier He:euyrm EH§!§€§ZMSW€
ji/rizunin ch"mzs~incrms_,(_z NA&»M§ w §§ §§~§

   

    

      
 
 
 

z
'P:
,.._

'i§m' m amc /bwn Pns)cmi>nic/w /.i £sver m »-

{£>u,;m_ massman/swan i/’c>sw "“"`”' sn‘;§i?onsisrs m=A Cnmz$r esm/sw

l §§ anne simms \niinan:§’w n’nef Ponsns P\<annnins,~ UAi-'zsemne-i;
§ U§§’~‘§§§§§in nin£§szi\n§ ns§§`r§nnsi‘nnni§s ' nn§wnsen ssns§mnws‘nss ne
»»» inns n§§§.»:§§>§f§§§§.§§‘" ’."Zs§ §§ §§§ §§§§§'§ §§§;:’§`§:§;i’§::§'§§§§§§ §§§§§ § §§§ §

A 'Ln:) '§ §’§`§si ’,..i:”§ §"” §§ ;.-'j ‘1'§=‘¢<£¢§ "”'§ rims§§' n§§§§z ;T,';£§?§§E§/

v(’u;>:E»m-rnn_,`ci!¢ H’!`n',"®cz§o_"`l§` §§ §¢Sn:S°uM/§®»€_ Wsn_mi’.

§i\ic§> Cwuaio_£uwz Cnns @vs;m)ani mdssas_remi§ annsz guinness/s

A'Fn§nimssn/ /_641{ minimis \sinc> inns men Qnimasn¢( on Rccrsnr oL@iz$Fb)u$uS/ur°f
Grz,icniowi_e\_s;€_§,§ 479 Ksem’ ‘/os)/) i/+Mni¢wm iS rfi>i§ § wn§c> ELS nbi/mms /AEF~
§ - §§ srs,z§ssn</)s niagmgesm minn 1 ._ on@ff isn 1:1’ s
Psinrn's nesPo/uszen_»rnnm Qwonnnan»m issui:'i'nein, mnn“/+PF
nimssr /mi>.nz Ss’mn_q\i Tnn@_onsn 69me

      
      

 

¢l; :.\1.3

     
 
  
  

   

nnnr nnsn miss sm .
Clé[€.;:t, .i :..,';1..»-_.§\ v ".WZ‘§W ';."" n ;.
HM|_F/'. ZM~,LWWN“[ &Tci§..> i»;.'~' {§U ‘=`~`

~ar,€
iii§. s.»§'_~.,,.»ii.£§i‘ f'. .\u
1- l_.‘~’ ._._.A'I_L__ '-‘-

.~§i simsst s'_'z; ssi sun -.-'§i §
.`>`./1- p{'zrx“ rsr M"(\s§;C""’ j

l»-) xx\~:;.¢,,....»‘" j

F\i.'f'§.’

 

 

 

 

        
  
    
  

nswa MA,;' ` " " ;~§nTi/iL<: wantonnem§naief
Rs£“(lnni$is:imsei; 6 weil `;irni§§i'/i§\‘\s@sfi., c§;/.k.>; map ansnsiirsnnenmm nmdf' \s§..:
fear/russ @eon:r i§iw(.:iids;n ,§».§R~§§ ~;-§.' §§ Jmsmwén; Us§=msrs:ntm
mm incs,£sisssmii.in ns annsamn%mnm§nnn“ ..
b " §§5`§‘§ §. €"£.'»ifn»' ;.51¥;’; §:`,§.s§’ ./§..U‘f&*’£'f§.,§:i'¢f"‘ /'111{:1“§? i§’,: i"':{¥m ;'§(~.'if»w}; §'t"v!'_? §::‘sl:`.:\`§§' T"'"?
, Rs:;'fs~“§§"§:“§§i§§\n§'ii;§ s::;‘"§ innis §’§§§s §§ns;"'~’§;.§.ss»_,‘: -- ' . .`
inn §'s:~i sil“»fi i&’n’ §i»’§siiis§~n.§i.§s".. n _`,,i'§"fi ;§'§‘n §§§§ss§"“' ."/§§.n§§i§i§i§ ;~ - §.T':§.§.§’!Fi?"'
s s ss assn <§.,§E ,§31§~ § s\§”f`§ i§'s' .»""-. zi€§`§

_ .. . ,"x1\/ ,\§€'.,»
f» ..'. ff. ,."» ,. .,.‘; .’»1-1§:.‘ " ! '.

    

  

/(l’) l/>n_l_ `le§mr, l§l;lr KAl@Ml/l /Fz/Wm wus wl<§ ` M'O`F 20__..
hud CQM w l%l); umw “ Plznno/llzm$ css§lzcmm 40 /Vm§ l/ucDHPl_wnf f '
1’ amu,<:msgll).§ cx><l'_vu__>: Rlzm@ l/ll amax Alo Wl&./BZ,§O§'D/~l mm lrls

m';'<rvlei OPl/lllo/J cal`>wlls cwm/wmrwl€ &llnlmsrus P€'-rl'n@u rs Hmcr>‘l
@llem>. llll /»n_-l_wll/\lG»S-.

 

 

5 =l>@,ll*gm "

 

 

C)zlm’lélmrlzcl¢ gall/lag

1 wm (£ les,“|’bc:\’/\l@. l¢l'lc>c>zv H¢)lla=l,\l C@m¢~l’ E‘¥ M‘l" UNAU/' \
l-_v{ llll Slmll,q»m¢lg /n»lm’:j: Smll;l/ £t) On,llg mcf mm l-l/nmly ullz,lrrm Cof~/
&P “ mnmlll§mg Mrlou m mg fl/llcarll>l_lm=:(l”mllsrllssla)d ol’ mlr:

P)lzl:e>u> wl Cllu.sll:' llo- : \/lll?_*?lZ,lSQS-'DH"

/Mg MGP%NMW_ leell_§ ownele
Mmml

0.0 &c)sl 12302 Gllh°n'ol_émo/d
maull unale '7<571|
\lll)< l_)-'§ Hml_ rm> /ll_sl:) /rlllbwLul:/lllmclll/l@l wmll>»w/zlm.l wells

E/F'fw§$l/llm;m$mwlmf \flpr l) S Hml.,¢r`l>z

EQL=;;_M§U_QF &u;vlll$ ol”/Flc_l):
Kl>mz( Mlzl_<m &LQ§l_lL ,

|C)I \Al. Mll_l_ gm ,§l)l'l~l>;; Zl(o `
l_J\/llla/Sm)ll /l’lm\& `7“735‘¢

Qrzlmr/lex> S{ M‘l'mml;:wllsl(m 'l§la‘{m=gme:rl _`

 

    

Q,lzwn m C¢/hll-\/

Sw_mlllll E.Mls"" 1657@027
S'rm/llls/l»’lzu_ol/J ly/ll.n’,m~:n:l

1200 FM l'@§i(
Rosllml))ll lam 775/83

d_a_`_l,lellz.aa:lal§_

Il%'l’lzmlg\| E. M\llS.TOO£MOp 151`7®©27, (>_~@Na/[l\£(lmcmmz{ A'l’<§mmlc/-'
lzlzu_ol,.l Ullllf,‘l't\£‘z$»$\d- l_ocmzi§ ml Mmzolzm amr°l, mms, mmc/um

lpli ap lam/all wll: M,.le» ls mm mull §% . :
‘ _ `_.Dl£l;l_M/ll\l< l Mo 397

Sllzl>llllll§ Ml;”lqv@c>zv
STMMMM c.)lll'\/ M»I};
lime KM (@55’

Plc>sllfrllml! mama ”77.5’23