Court Opinion

ID: 3803708
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-07-06 07:45:09.704456+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T07:37:54.210217
License: Public Domain

This is a law action tried to the court after a jury had been waived by both parties. The only question necessary for determination is whether the judgment of the court is reasonably sustained by the evidence.
It appears by a stipulation between the parties preserved in the record, that Anna Nall had paid all dues and assessments and was in good standing in all branches of the order up to December 31, 1922. A witness, who was secretary of the local lodge during the year 1922, testified that Anna Nall was sick during the year 1922, and that sick benefits were voted to her by the lodge, and that there was an accumulation of several dollars to her credit in the sick benefit fund on December 31, 1922. Just what this amount of credit was is uncertain, but it was something less than $14. The material portion of article 9 of the laws of the order reads as follows:
"All monthly dues are due and payable at the first regular monthly meeting of the lodge or temple and shall be paid within 30 days therefrom, and each and every member thereof who fails, neglects or refuses to pay said monthly dues within said time, shall and does without notice stand suspended from all rights, privileges and benefits of his or her said lodge or temple and from all rights, privileges and benefits of the order, and thereby forfeits his or her endowment, burial benefits and all rights, privileges and benefits of any, every and all departments of the order."
Article 14 of the laws of the order reads:
"All money refused by the sick shall be appropriated to the children of the deceased."
It is apparent from the provision of article 14, that when the lodge has once appropriated sick benefits to a member, the weekly accumulations authorized by article 33 of the laws of the order belong absolutely to the member to whose credit they are appropriated and accumulated, and that if the same are not used by the member during her lifetime, they do not revert to the order, but become the property of the children of the deceased member. Anna Nall having been in good standing on December 31, 1922, she had until January 15, 1923, within which to pay her dues and assessments for the first quarter of that year, and by the provisions of article 9, above quoted, she was entitled to a further extension of 30 days from January 15th within which to make such payments. She became sick and confined to her bed about January 10th, and the evidence preserved in the record discloses that she notified the secretary of her local lodge not to pay her the sick benefits to which she was entitled, but to use the same to pay her dues and assessments and to keep her in good standing in the order and to keep her policy of insurance in force. The amount required by the laws of the order to keep her policy of insurance in force during the first quarter of 1923 was the sum of $1 25 and her dues to the local lodge were 50 cents a month. It is, therefore, evident that at the beginning of her illness on January 10th she was then in good standing in all departments of the order because she could not be suspended for nonpayment of dues before the 15th, and if not paid on that date she had a further grace period of 30 days within which to make payment. Having at that time an accumulation in the sick benefit fund to her credit more than sufficient to pay her dues and assessments and to keep her policy in force, and such accumulation being her absolute property under the provisions of article 14, it was the duty of the local secretary when so requested by Anna Nall to apply a sufficient amount of such sick benefits to pay the monthly dues and assessments and the premium on the policy, and it was her duty to continue such payments monthly and quarterly until such credit in the sick benefit fund was exhausted. The record further discloses that when the husband of Anna Nall went to the secretary prior to January 15th, and made the request for his wife that her sick benefits be so applied, the secretary refused to do so upon the ground *Page 165 
that Anna Nall was then sick and in arrears. That the secretary was mistaken as to Anna Nall being in arrears and automatically suspended is evident from a mere reading of the above-quoted provisions of article 9, and that she had more than enough money belonging to her in the sick benefit fund, if applied according to her request, to keep her in good standing during the first quarter of 1923, is clearly disclosed by the evidence preserved in this record.
The trial court found and determined from the provisions of the laws of the order above quoted, and from the stipulation of the parties and the oral evidence, that the policy of insurance on the life of Anna Nall was in full force and effect at the time of her death on March 6, 1923. There is ample evidence preserved in the record to sustain this finding of the trial court, and under the uniform holdings of this court, the judgment of the trial court in a law action will not be disturbed where there is evidence reasonably tending to support the same.
For the reasons above stated, the judgment of the trial court in the instant case is in all things affirmed.
By the Court: It is so ordered.