Court Opinion

ID: 4043608
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:23:20.852639+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:39.321295
License: Public Domain

---~J.f?- __.:f~:r_~~.,~-£_:d:____ A:pf-el1tt.J:.e.__e_oJ,,J,£.'t::__; __ ~---~---~----------~--~--~~--~-----~-

     ____ __fl_$___d/n:c.Ied _h_y~ ~~._C__~~-r-~/jpefLe IIa~:f~l2 etP<"' 'f--_t_$;_~, __Sh.~c:4___-j1rIT . -r/.. L    ___1.&11 -t; /K e.{   r--li: ~'~;) __d__d.:;. 1 it_          E.$        ::/_:__tPft~d~~-
        3.-t ,        g                  f8./.sr                                                      J;
     _...;"·__clj~~-_9_~.r4__~l _':__l2i~hr_.~c,:{:__;:[~_r.!J-'!-__ __S_j~()M-e d __:zit_~~ d.J-~ ~~~_;J'aA '-4_C... I'"¥~ 8i ~ 0                                    IS"'~P~~~------1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                I ·

     _____"f_l' t~L_Q~r_is__{t_[~;j_-z~~--J__~4JPvr ~-~'3"6u£t.£<.•'~~/-2g__j£~~-/i.ou...;~-ev'~v--+--                                                        h.-~J 7"-o

     __,.Dl_:_«-      11 o-t_~'!:-_e-_   t~ P1'l ef(·~tt. -t{! ~_j~l_£_~ .:2. __--:tJc-:..•~1_Cd~Lk,__~v;j                                                                            '0<.<.d~~---

     ~fiQ4--..t.:.l   __1_2. __lv.J.a,. ___£)1f1 ___fl!lfi"'!~--£>~~-~r~_.i.___blij.~.!,'£L~~--:I_~ ______li_j_<;__l~ vn:.~Od-e!l_L__~ 0 N-L'f---~--
                                                                                                                                                                                        .                       i
     -t*·Le..-L_f_ e~e'! yl_l_"-~____ m~--~_(_f~Q':'!_J_f,!~~---dd._:1c..(:Js:..j___C_Le.,.tk                                   f'Vl~.' I         ....JJ.J.dij~---JS,Q(;)-fj~----'

     _;s~}~~~·L_j_~j.,g..~_hL~,-_h, ___ :L__ il::££..~ l_\LecL~~J:_1;,.,d__~{(lQ-1:"~~~-__E_!!..l-::>r.'!:_~~''i--~q,_~2.· t:?._fi__ ~--------
       v-;c::t   _.'Lt_~._)"!/..t'ipt;ollll,/      Ler:;t:J___II}!Ja;J CL'll ar                ji30 .4~                 .t    Ur:;pt.--1-    v-f-VOL-'-.:/k-a { 1\1\.eu· ( ;               I          /-VVt /IVI.,ed; e.i:-li kl b~CJ.¥1 .1-Y'Iy                          Afo-t- / t;S:.S
     ~" ~-- ~pea. I l'.4.irvJ ~l~_ -ro ___1!1c. ~ A..e>vt                                                    Fe·b            zs:.   Z :PI                              · S.#

(
\.
     ___._·'Mf,."--""'-"-"•~~(-'-,---===t=-f ::r_ ~Ad b< -e_v., rvcrtt~D ed ; IA______4t:Co vdai'A~"'-"-t/')_,f_._g,___.""'""",__7,'-"o"""------1p""'-"r-""'a'-IL!ie""""~'---"'--------l
     __,J,__(;.,>ou. \d__ __l~ k~~---01--~~:I_e> :·I_i__j;yl ~I'"{                         f=i2...~.-~;\,___,·"--"/o:::....!T'--'-1'~ =.f App ~~ .
                                                                                                        .£'--"1,__!_·

     _;I: d~_pv:_C-i.~(-:l}_~e_c__G~:______ lR.i LLL_2_~C~--e..,=J/F-r:r-"--.r----"--'--"--'7--="='=~""'-----~'----=''--'-=--~---'---"C---j
                                                                                                                   re;jph:..-.,.£<4/l'f . 'fs.~~!!fleci__
                                                                      ···-------··----·---------- - ----~~07---~d.-----· ·····----

                                        - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ---                              - - - - - - - ---·   ···-----·   ······-------·----·--··----------------   ---
      ,,
                                                                                     --~---

     ~ -r -·rj)JJ..!"'~Y-. L~~~-t~t{?,_--t:ll)fJelfa,er::r.'-p~,o-~----_d_Q____6_e.!".fiJJ.y. C§:.-_r:_r· ·.;:y~ __.-d.ra.r.:___4_-t'>e-:~----· _ .. ---1
     _____CsJ'I._c/__u:...r£eg.t_..c.op--¥---LzL~-___tJJ,~_yf!. __t;t._..,d_J1LZJ,Q/nJ__
                                                                                       ,e_e.4J oi-'l_a 6L~_Cl<-f'L~.r;_~ ~~-dt~~---------

     -------by~Th ~-c~_~.t_.,._r.       _ _c..&.1c.i( _______   tt!'l(Ji/.£d. ____tJI!L.i:ix.d .)i4£.~-:___/M_.~~~.J.I'!,_-f2,..e..-l-alti____:r_..:..._'?:_4- .Q....;

     _____ M-.e.llf!_!.t:..-_ .C/ed~_ -~J.,_~z:" _1).-~.,~:-__c. r                       .:b   f I~'--· .~_L_Lp_~~_sfa r I                     _75(._ _____LGI Sfl" ----~--------··.
                                                                                                             •                                                                      i
     _ _]2{57·..,;~-         !i?._~____7·A-,'J.___lf.._~~ .d~-¥--""_l__llt~~L'?~_(.S_,__________________ ----~----··-·-                                                            ·---------~~-1
                                                                                                                                                                                                    I
     -··-------------------- ______    ------------·------·---------····---~~-----------·JC~>p. c.c-tf"'tty,_________________~---··---------- --[
                                      ·--·----------·-------·--·-----------~----· ____Qc,._t::!_'::"!f-- ~6_e.t:Mi_~---f"J-d0wr j)ro ~_:_--~---1
                                      . -·-·--------·-····--·----·------------~~---··---Tu_j_-'~ ___-rr~it ~f~:_ _ Frx, -/.'<4X_____________

                                                                                      ~--
     ---·------···------------~--------···-·-·--·--·--

     _ ":1"..__f};y,'¥_i&e.. lJl«G_j_                                    ..-~u.a~~ ••L~--~1
     _   __;0.-e:.~t>. rl~-r-- L..t:£j W.•'h.:..f olt.~i"/(,e._

     __ 1:2eLiPL~--~(r r/...L ~b-¥-~Lp£ld'u?'-
     _--(2cr~~_f:"_!.A.L__Ctk_,4_~r~_._--'J:&rs.~-{
                                                                                                "lu {;_t..~. 7t-(.;;hs/er

                                                                                                  t:::;:.
                                                                                                                               &c:lax /;,
                                                                                                              -rk-r -F~e.... £Ct.E>~::Te.7ed_ a~~~:._ _ _
                                                                                                            \LTG..A___L.L<,td fr~tc.~/32... ~:J:J
                                                                                                                                                              5-v~·sie-:...,...
                                                                                                                                                                             _._x=·=-·r_ _ __

                                                                                                                                                                                              l
     ___f55ec.Yk+e.d~kJ._::Ihj_.k_~ -r-1- cky                                      ::! tA1o..rdA..           -:2.. D/G~Dcv-~~- "'                                             -~~~~--------1~
                                                                                                                       /f2..eYJ-ec~lly                                                          ~
(
\.                                                                                                     ___-J)an(/l,y Shead
                                                                                                                    ~1Mt1 ;>=--~                                                               _j
  . C{e_:-~$ ~"e<._o.rJ. a_s f'..e!./ev~i"'J"T                    /-r<;..#\S   "fc,    ---tit~ p.'I':'    Tt)t·l {f_e_rfc. _{::..~-f>.!l.Yl!~L•. _ ___ _ _
 ::I         ce~,JT               7Ae..    r.:_~,c/_ . a __nt;:t_~_r:. __ar_-r~~-',i~ffl. or,£                           ··I
 v~...Lt/':__.(~r_t!;)~t-fl<:.,__"'LQ -~~ Ll-~~e.rL_':?l_tr/"y._;zh~~----~~- A-~--------------1
 _JLR-<;.g_ly~~--                )(c:. .VZ4_e.~4;~ __ :::b_d~.         ~~:_k.~~--w~__ /Le__,f__ Qc_h_L.s____________________ ,

 ~Lf,:j_-z.L<2W~.!/J . . -;-o_~e,;e.p;"'~~!.CY____:r___bQ._fL.;__~i.ed_a_//__/:2£-pS£-4-cfS?<4 ~~                                                     ···-~-)
--fr~...se.~---······fle(J.~_t!x:p~·'h___ ~o__I:J.r?:___/.£.~-e±~J· ..lt. .i.s_~e.LtJ.~Il.f.~~..:r~:r£-~~------[

~~~·~=~~--
·-·---------------------- ____          . ______________...._.... _________ ......--------------------------t??J2e((?/~-r:~f~~-----·--------
                                                                                                                                                                   I
___________..___________                -----·-----..-----------------------~----------~-~L/.£:i__7!:E.~,;~~-.&t:..:.-.2:y:____~--l                                    -·
··-----------------------------__ ____ ____                               __________                '{_-~_.s,_;_ <::2_1_...___lS_:-_~c;l~4 -,-Ci7:::_i$'_::__Q!2Q{4_S'_ ,_Q7-:- _15'-_ ~-~(.__                  - - -~- ----------· --
______"'f6tllL<2v~"t (£4.s~__.i\/~1"1.1_~_o _ _ ;-_ __~~'=-0 -~ _l_E.''C~L-:_l}_ _ ,_l':l 1 .lS.t-L-§._____ _______ __ ___ _____ _____ ____ _

                                                                                                                                                                  l
                                . - --------------- ······---------·-· -···----~-----------------~------- ---·---~---- -··-···--- - -·-·····--·------------~-~~-- i

_)2_ecu____cLet:.k_:,__GJy_LjQS_"'d__.[';., d ~__Let-<5=b«AI~ ...~ laAe.._.f,'<>k_i
___ _______________ ___ __o._~__ dul' e£.._-r_~--.6¥-- _7X_q__~C~cc___ii~~- -~~!:...-t!-_0-J-_. PreeuL___                                                         f

_______________ .___ _ ______f_;1~~~~~ __ jzif:_•'.!.'Yd--7Q 7Ae_ Ct:(:t-evti /<:Ji,-. -~ /i. A;/geit~ ~--                            12-..

___ _ __ ____                     ___ f.JQurt ___ I_Q~:____£eJLJ~~--'~~Pi~«£e._~#12'I.ilt-IM e.-.                                             d' r"-«-- _____ _
____________________________ c_Qy.._tt?_£uL~~":'_..V__s_.r;>_ .-r__~~'f--p~eecl                                                  /h A;q;~~_!_~---------·

  -f
__-L                 .
     ____ _cu:.~.err.d_.c:ah __ y_e~--pJe..4->g_.                         .
                                                                    1e lf ~&~. e._:U~.~~SL__dar_Q..... .::£QIL a.j)(!_e.&:.,_P'£L~----
                                                                                                     I           I

__Bt-; 4s__c/M.,~__T_r;.___ ;_\j~-~-~ d __~ ea.. I _dev..<./1,< 1'1~./ft~j'"~-.,./ ot--~_P·hci~~~~---·-
__j_q·~(/J__J;_ ~ ~o.,'tt                                             J:           f!>r,'e_.f _d_~/?n~_L_

____;J:;_ r~c,eived_ a.                 _(Of!       *        /p'u I           aerks -ru#~ ,/' ~-,-,MS                                  .;;. r     nl"-           I
_Cleric.> ffztA~d- .L~-r                                                  OS'"-<-_ ~_!-7/,;: c~"z1-j
--p~-reJ_4-_--..!,.,._ _w'f'c=>7fL_ C.ov-v-e..s;oc:.:w.d~hc "-~~                                                     /VI' a (     C le.v-k-                 __j

-fr~~r lo iJ...e.. F'VLO.J'~L__s "2..