Court Opinion

ID: 4936914
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2021-09-24 01:16:52.195235+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:14:43.451205
License: Public Domain

Emery, J.
The petitioner was an official agent for the prevention of cruelty to animals. In May, 1902, he presented to the County Commissioners of Franklin County for allowance and payment from the county treasury an itemized bill of $152.48 for services and expenses for investigating cases in that county. The Commissioners considered the bill and in the presence of the petitioner allowed a lump sum of $100 in full for the whole bill. The petitioner thereupon drew that amount from the county treasury upon that order' for payment.
In April, 1904, petitioner without returning the $100 so drawn by him again presented the bill to the then County Commissioners of Franklin County. The Commissioners refused to allow any part of it, or to make any adjudication upon any separate items, and thereupon this petition was filed for a writ of certiorari to bring up the Commissioners’ doing in the matter. '
The petitioner urges that the allowance of a lump sum for his itemized bill less than the full amount was illegal, that the Commissioners should have allowed or disallowed each item, and should be compelled to do so now in order that he might bring the disallowed items before the court. On the other hand the respondents claim that certiorari is not the proper remedy for the petitioner.
We have no occasion to consider either of the above contentions since a complete answer to the petition is made by the fact that with knowledge that $100 was allowed him in full for his whole bill he drew that amount from the treasury upon such allowance, and has not returned it. He cannot now reopen the matter. Perry v. Sheboygan, 55 Mich. 250; Brick v. Plymouth County (Iowa) 19 N. W. 304; Murphy v. The United States, 104 U. S. 464. As well might a plaintiff who had recovered and collected á judgment in a common law action for less than his claim stated, afterward maintain an action on the same claim.

Exceptions overruled. Petition dismissed.