Court Opinion

ID: 4046234
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:04:48.40585+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:29:55.873789
License: Public Domain

tJ.et.tJt.f a-f (!a,l11,~tt4         ~p~/s
                                                                                ( ) (j (!) 0 ~ /2.. ?:)(:J 1

$~te.
           "
         a.¥'   c;-1L91'D -ar~oc;-ti:R~'-'JJ                      -1L~­
                          CIL~ c..caiA."'+ Ho. ~~,o·<1-1Z CA·\g Ja...                        ttJf.Eif..    ·10   yau .   !Yl'f
  ~6f        --rtoC>   W A:..J-fs    W£t.(   ~:/L.J             IS'! -:hts~c..flif7\ ..#tUm tVUf QQ~/
 C!~IJn'\ 06fL{J';~ /l~ru- J?tAj ?i/l.~'f Aw~A-1                            WitS           Ex. hP4-rl~o        ·1t.JJ~   0?\

 ~v.·AM.( I ~ 14              A~'-:S/.Q Jw & Ac:J (s£...                  ~4-" %'/- G~cJ~¥1m~-1 Cl44 V
 ~~~u.JJ Ail ~~~                      $$'   -'1hE. ;s-_s-:1?t~rs-ht.?'c/                  -?a fJt.c      so~a;       r   HIJVL

-tltJ ffoa b/~ b.fih           ~ ...-~ .-1J, E                   bf~
                                                  l O'?J "s~pf6/!J b6,e_ } ~ ~00['
                                                      (}'1-tJ             T'S      -;71 A

I -WII-s --::hctACt~J ~ /l> d»~/s- ::t JVAS Ne>+ :7?-u:J,.c?J (TA/ l!1f~'7-1'<..9'z7.
                                                            tP

 ~ -rh"'l ·XcR,c-Pn~~ l'&4~ ~£ &~J Jutut ~ ?ht. 6tb11>4r ~f'bJtrllee..
 /JnJ .. J'ht- 51-rJk 
:z u Jt ~ 1tJ...J12M<) /J 1~ tull-s t~~ .t Aausi~ tun I:I ~~~G?/1jSR. 
 do?J~o :r kJ-45 ~ii!al t:Jel.VI16d ~;vn /:I s~tJ-k#l~ J:J.-1 frrrl)                 t:rr\      /0 c.J{~q!fU:JE8't. ft)~J/6< ~~~ -:j);J}
 1'/()J- 1-//iUL '1l1~ .J~,~ Jl,·c-~'~ o~ 1"h ~- I E;s--:D. tJ<&~~:)ct ~""J-.
 6\1 'S'eptt.dl b6e. 1g . d<1o~ /hi-d /Jid 1/c-1- t/AV-f oLt;tisc£,cd,~
 ~ :5;:-p.f.~ hu 'f ~ar;                         A-+        1: m ~         6'   &"' Ar!~ ~ .fil~ kriJ-A .ze
    16&-h-w~J      tv-A"5   sa~ -:z:;..zh_~clrd·,..,:.:r 40-,.,            nut        ~~~ ~ HIW<:.
    ~/~J 0          tOILi-/->     t!rt:' ffir/;158$     C1at.fll6, ~E tJrsrf- T~d WelL lfbavd-
     rJEWI~ ·-p;·s~uu.~cO            6o~ce o l,Uh.e~~ ~"'j~                   Q\(!;-~ls rAs ~l~-ts                   I)                              ..6E.,:!y
                                                      -rhE em Jvr '}f.\- b,e145 /im t       ·rs

       Ce.e-PJ.f~J ~7 -~J?!'- )1}c. CA'fj. 1/3 :l'f --1A ~ 1-s-o:t"- J J '", ~ I tf) )'.sfI!JiJ
      1-JAJ r/6 U£-\~~$~tc::J,~ ~ n;£-( te:J,~c(A f 1t1tf 46vJI~JlfR-
           cQn4 ~..11.a~f·f"M1 ~~o ·~t ~s/kl(__ ~p (!t5,eiJ?Actt.faYI Q,c_
           f}pp~{ ~s t/C>rl lkvc /JUj S':-jnAfuL~ d?1 -/ fo /,UR.f/ ~­
     o~~DCJ-IZ'i1Gt'D -iJ~-a<=;-IC.H~Js ~~; ~tu;-~~k~41 ~SRAqJh~c
                                                                                                                    .'
     Art. ~-,~
                                                                                                                     :~

    oe.Ju..   bAS~ol      07)   />lt·IY) TJ   tJo,cfJ I Rtsk.c.fl..      v ~~~erz-/zc/ ~ ~~ t!.ev~J 6~
 -j],1_ ~!Uf 9                 kJf./n~t5~~s -::j'J,q:/ /W~"t- dMGrL $t..bftJ~/Ir?-d"' /Yfq/1.571-~fAJ­
 ~ HDf CJ.u@71·~                             '<(]:)    '1?t   7    ~uQ..+""      6u;cl~c~ -ftt~l ~
 ·rn~.5~i~l A'ncl v;.f~t r                       -te      hli..f 04-SL     -~ ~rlh 1,~1.1 ~1 '11 ~ ~"J:);s)lucl
  /kff.olfAL d'      9    ~ ~              fnCj         &~sJ'O         7   A?n    ~rJ & !Jlbl£ -JZ {Jft~f­
                                                                  PIA-/.
 ifh·cuf      ~ -:hd/c~ -f l!ltf'-c9-IZ.9'?·1- -t1?6.re.c_
 ~      r/t!J:f       cf'"Ju2 '
             ·,

 Dhua v s~-t ern 6h2J (t ~J lc-J-mel-v\f ItS
  ~~"5c:spkm~ IY                     o()g'

v~J rles~{ f/Atr~ ~i,~&,d_4td-r .au6/Z.                                lh~ /$'"'$"~ "J);s-h~~e:t Clsaue..f-..
 ~ ~'-Atli!i~t~~~~ & 'Jh ~ ID'$-"11\. d<.tjtCii~ I v~&h~cl ~ut<.f                                            l;.JSVt\ t- (
  Ues--kd           10         ~ c__-+k ~LtA\~ ~ Jt-AS '!f>
 .   J~~ ~f\ 'li.x·AS aovE:-fo-1'Im~~ (kJ~                                           tJ'f, ~C<{-        JS's--a J4J,~~-+f

  rp;·~~~<:J (~")Jm,~t'~ ~& Lu/\-ll~ll ~-h~-
                                                                        ,,'',l.th'

(C?t)·-1'J1 -~ ·n.thf'l~ ~f}l ~ 1~ -p/~-;vc.t tk>4J- l:Jc<;-n, ~
Q) ::t=n IJt-t s.fm ~UA'J~           dY)   -th £ .dl.is--1    tnond ~      tVo6£mhcR ~
                                                                            ·::;::::n   tfp~Z r) /1JLOI
~;;:;:, ~ t::..fk e14 671 ·/JJ! i1_~t 1()6>lcl,. -'1)\ fZh Rvt AfU( 1r11d ~ ~o,e_ i,
@ :1=n IJJhrlle/2._ r n1~'1 :vn JA1\\.\Aflit ~ ~u~ ~
\J~s -*'~'~ "T.!.K-~tS 6otJ6/hr1.!rA~ ~J~ ~, e,o9 Jvt6ll~t~tJ->-.
E'A~ ~c..c.fl..J. j,~f~ -:n, -fh·ls S'-tbcJ.,#!'(ptL /)~-s "'Jhr ~u/L~c)..~!,a;_                                      fPIXJ/J.J
bq ':::M'?       C1:-tr-d.'.h4tm. P.rnd    /']\~ "i}Unc/(4) /H-()s      o     ~ --Jn'~:s         &4/c ~.e -o,6.fll,J
 C1e vt/1.-../s .
- W3 r:.1G<--~ ~w6'-1J -1/o/3 hdo IZ'~ 01411.{

 ;JJ?,v.t.-sls       f'/J;!.   ~L~ c.v/h c..kll7ucl~~                    c:s-?'' ~ -z:          C!/l-Us-ec

 \l~tl>hs ~/\ ~~~ <:b-au~/YlliJ-r'\.-1 OcclE. d·i oiL- --r;~ .&ncl 5~£.Ste.~s
 ~~~,t:.-.k,C-1" trhd C~~m'" ll-{-;J/-skr'cl <1t»i1.1L/ ho/Js                                    ll-d     .f.5#S"f TeVd ·~r::ms

 ~- ~~+ ~li}aA ~~IYL,~ ~ cto~*f ~ ~' drsk,~t~

 ~\t~~ ~~                        NW;biL      l~t+efl ~~<;;&lc,~i?n d;j'dq.
  -~ dt:> l<'t1otU ·-?h.,..J. erl Ji.\n~ 16 dOlO ¥YU.t Af.k~~'f CA-Iom ~i6 /
  ILviAJJLme.. 761/~ me. J714f 4 PJa1.1/~ _,w,f11dut.D ~ ~ A,/K41
 :r-f :::r u.J~cl~ fie_ IJ->tsc/ "7£' I ~AI/ Wlf11kcl 1~/im n-5 #f~.e?t7}--
 mi     /)diJIUr/2. t '11SC/0
                              (!svd ~"\ C: 4 +~ s£?- ;;e/Wfl~
  ;;:z; Zb)/l/n.1         /J,..d~ 4-1~             &AI.J:f        .-tA4-J    en, fi-,5      ~~
  I/
       13
         ~ ~ /Y)~ ~ /.5": .:]: --;/!A7l S-l'n ~ fh eP A- (1ft1 o--.f2-
  -'1h7-s 6~/ '/0 S'b~ ~~£AJ,c;4 {J)~s~cf ~IAJ
    A\ ~f2-t YY\ rf\<; ell··~ J~- ~"'J~ ~60 ~~\ll SJ-. gt.t~, {c $e>7
- ~f1sitH/~ 7·7q.~ 47zc/ 76 '7J,·-z &4/l-1- ~(J4~h!J(
    ~M\(-s 1d-367