Court Opinion

ID: 4074316
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 04:54:42.106104+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:01:35.086963
License: Public Domain

131/jr 111/1113 ' v , . » 1 g

1050 U wmmeme, _ _ _' » ~ __

Brownwc¢ 7'@`¢15’ 7@801 ` -' _' l _ ` 4 ZQ 533 uf

’ k l ' f ' /Qp¢ 1/14,,7@7<
In rP' 31/L1 Cf)ar/OS` ///1/@/)$’

` 1111 amy/0 71/ C1, 111 13 mar

 

DEGFAAQ/ Dms‘¢a
f_)/€.a$_é¢gp_mc£ €nc/_L___/:A€.ch.}>ma/_Mm¢/o@-goc_[££ Y/: 70 15-"/@ /1°%1511511011 %/~
_Q&%QE’_/Z>_@A_<£o_mo¢£,__£é». é_dn_gmaL_/O€h:€/o/_\__o£___£tkéi_@l{:_/?%/K{QM~L£, 25 é'/n¢£LV____
__a.$£:‘ {Ami 111..70¢¢_.6£5`¢/.&/_ manner_£éa{:_y_eu.c!/€_%A€_/)H+LQA_M_L£Q__¥_A@___
_br_ln§_“f'é€_Ma?é‘@L@F»éa{A~/*?¢?L anL{U_‘f_/£MHQQ_QE_ .__c_¢r' nll+'
~ )QPvM//¢. oour$ 1
1 B,FDu//: é/J:QM /Or`#11§1¢<\;_1110 Ap¢EALS 01-' TEXA$

_IN_&EiBl_/_{ Cbm/.e$ ll./ H11!@ 72 /
_ _ _ j { _ . v

 

156ch sz‘$/£D
O.a*»l.é».c;.?_i__._l` dai?_o?e Ee!o 111/1117 _,LQLS,_pe,-é&.w.w; new/j_d&co.v¢red._lq 1'$.9,0,01¢¢¢41%.0
_-@r_a_ l,¢/_f_:#{»__o$ f/abea S__C`0cgl$__/ar_e$€ni€d_%_-H»e_$$i@15:1.5/_1&/:.&_~;_/~{§_€/0 C_em_~l:b¢
-o/.q¢j.»@.? Na_ju.&§_ ,70@’7 15 1'1\ \/119/015111\ 1510 161+1‘(1./11 // 0’7€3 \/ /._) c C 10 mi +A@
__epi:1.r:e.,_7§m-a/>,e /1_.'0.0+501)_5:4.7 00/ 42111_1_11121_,111117:_%3113; [_0111;1_51_1;@1115
l/£UM€,Y$“EJ./.§RAJ§FP a 100.,/."'01;. .@.. Mr¢.+...a.(_`.ma/)c/Qm¢/S.
519/\£¢5._01'1._~£4115__§[’_“`_<>.501¢_7_0}7 75/£>1¢1/01»/0 .Qr')/S,
,QBJDQG/-@/L rulem/)‘)@d
@:QOM/ f, /[1 /JLwA-/

 

 

 

 

_ comm ‘1))=:CMMA'.;:~'APFEHLSOFEXA§

 

 

7;1\;25; )5:11 if C\-\er) )=_j /_1);1)1:1;1/5
'11/)3-3‘7,'5101 3“~/1) 77'_`@1 1\/11, /%/3,72~13"

 

557qu 1702 11 111121"1' 105 mm/DH/QAS

 

~O_Ea#anara.L/e_:[:/JQC_QESW 1110 ur-\r' ' ` ~ =
__CO/TIE$_NO&¢_&|Hj_Q§or/QS_LLMkla$_“@,£§onei/L_H'£,Q_Lovcm{ré/€c/_aa/mmjzraica.a.¢e_
.an;J_'m 0.£¢2$_4:57&_@)11¢£_‘51_@f€@i01_5;e_<;an930_,ae:5151¢4 er_ '5__/0_2¢1_51.1€01\_7551;0..020:(: b€/.va/)_c{omc¢:_i~=_-____

..a 051_¢:3“_1.2;.€___£¢11.;€_=_5_51 ewn_adpeh;{w¢;ec.azL//__/qml/_QMLCQUM- +511¢ §//@1.)1113 _
_r_ _ ,

' ._TUKL€nTcr'mA/

 

_711§,1'_$__1.55011.._@£0|¢5€_€¢11¢_+_5;0% _’1,,£1;'_0512151',11\ 7521 aa’¢/rg:c 1551@ 11-<-1/12; and o/mm@ ranged 513"3,_1¢\__
_,Q<.LY:.SM§.Y.\_+_ -¥0_ Ew$_@u/er_¢z&£p,ee£la:{re_@:aced.@_e_£ak '77. `
lZ'.
_ v 2:$111=_§ /€HI$FD
‘ 7' //_ 07 771/15 9707'1,17'5

__Haéea;_carpu;__,@e%im$_/n_nan.___ca,o/.~/u/ 1@/01»1!_11:0,¢:€$_§0,!.(_1/./.70!.& Cé@.,o¢er__ LL_QP__H¢...
_/exa.r__CQQ/e,_a¢__CpmnoJ_/ancedur@,,_,9r~h¢Le_//,o./_da?me_-Lée_wm+_cr_t.&//QMSL
711e_Mr.¢J:ap_/.\.aéc’ar_€aqm£-_t$_f)$.€¢_r:em.&oéj_. _£0 /)$ed w5)w\ ana ,0Pr1Y0/1 1 \" V&S`~\\' "

 

 

mf¢\.ed_/.(n_éu;§_/._ 5131:£71`.,_1_”75_ 1ls'__an.clr_ée11:_ L{.CSUQJ..L 71 al._C 0.<.1 c.+....o r J'¢lé/ 9&,01£10001,0.€.1+..:_~_._0_..

 

cn=!=`_}.u.m.§dm~l,pn ol/rec£g¢(..+o..ang_a/>€..hac/mi_. 1pe,1:011._1 n_511r ca_s*a¢/j]on,cm¢/er

 

 

511_¢ res~¢m 1111+ com mgm/ mg_/,1m___~150_/0_1;0_11_0_013_.5'(,1_¢[¢\_@__/0&1~:0,\ Q-l» n -Hmp_ and `

 

place.mzm&d 1n_+l.e_wr_~{~,,_an_.=:l¢o¢.lwh~;,.)¢e,.mlb,§/.§l/1\ aa,<:éo.,dy.,z»; 111755¢¢,_£0$&£:.:,_..___._._

 

 

 

-____;H_ t;£€_l€__.£]._@_ 7_Q)QPL. 'c_c¢=¢¢:o_m£_,_ .§3`_£&£_§{1'¢¢\_/0£,£_‘4'¢¢;15_ a__cz/>,a/¢;~_o. n:é$__-a/_ 40_$£¢£._§”£1¢9».-_»9:_
__~Er_o_m_a_f€_bnj_‘_) 'L/.Q@men+_/. m,o aim 9_0_,¢€0£1/-£\7__<2£'4<),/__744 oo_dedk,_E:.c_p r_ac_-\r»_ ~[m_'zn er_s?_+hg_
_ma_€f._/.mf_ Dr_ ~}:ao+ __/o. -ca_\//._s:/. on_s`__-/~@_Le/nemé@r__wfzn_c(ea/ng__u.u_~é/;\_*l:kj ;__._<`_e_Cz_{'m.A_Q_L¢$_»_
wm ,u_§ app/mg,\_;;_£;le 4__6_`@.¢4:_.__3&_)_¢¢ ___ _// 0_'2_.$_+_¢_-£@_ 439_+_____
Q,Q,_Q_LMQ.D.~.££¢_~£S:IL,L.&£ /ed_wJ_-H.~»__+é\e__de_ds_c£_‘/:h@_&cz¢.u;£l.¢\_v_/A./.¢k:_\-L»e___
_co.v_\v_ c'c_-/w v\_lo emg_c_/qq. /./e»:>9e¢(_wa_s'_ob+am eci _ao:L)%m‘ )44 e_c/erk__ ~S:éze//_O_ss/_yn_____
_______+Ae__o,of/'ccrh@n__-to ~{:4@{» rm,r~l» `

 

 

 

_____C`a_u_\:\"__@_f__€f_!:m_l.,f.\_q£__£p ,o.é.a43_0_‘€_.§§¢1$__Hp,qf/_';@:élfaa_€o.nr_d_wil;£'_cz?_'_/:/a_b£@l$_(;zr_/o(_/$_Q€£_ __‘T_
____1_'¢19_@€_4_’¢».?__&@{_4_/;-/.'z).a|__E'e{a.m.\j_ .r_\v_.'¢+.:.'a¢.\_dm.oler;_@¢al€-o§`_&/.;x).{m\_&H_Qe.¢l_uce.,_£cb.'cl€__/l&;'l
4 TMST@UC¢IOM$ ’ ~ d

 

__.$P@¢L_£.'~,J§a )/L,

3»_ a u_mu.s+__~@ /.€___~l:£\e,_m~i_'fr_e_u¢r_¢.~lr_ Qf/J/¢ca~/w¢\_{a cm]_m_€/»erec!__ar_am¢zfedj_gwr
arme_aPPL/aah@n_m/Léue%umei_aS_nan_€am,Q/Jan+,_l£yw¢r__ap,Q/_c_a:é,oo_w
Ce_+u me_é__a_;_a¢z n_':_cam,e /.,'a¢d'_:k/_»e_ci ed.;o§_té\ e__-£r¢'gl_cmcé_g/.J/_mcm‘€_a_c>a+e_a_%__
_ - 'H\€__C/_€:E@o/'_am_f%Q_u_c__Q./z'QLCQ~éBA_QQZ_L?/_€u.cm_+he_ _ £m_+a_\j.au_u/¢:€Lowl'_£-)my_/.:'i;_

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_____Qm_:}.'l=.,€___°?$ '°‘ 040»/_0=9_,3¢,/\9.¢.1$_+5_£¢10_7_,0 ManeLHQL/£LM_ML$MJ+£LQF_CWL
__(;[:€c.l<_'_;\/Q,r_\,l$f_;o,u,m_/:u_$_£). ch _'cLQ_/'L_Of__/Q.,Q/a/¢ carb{m_~€_.c.o.__k/c¢:};o»€_f/Oéea£_€o r,a¢./$_.,___ En__
_C_/a:_€O_/_aj._¢:él_\_mld__cz,_¢_>p.l/_QQ:£/_Qr_z_u¢a_s_é?_[€.)é_é;r_gp_m£%rmms_£o__he_C_le_rJ_Zocan_c'/m_o_¥_/w¢,_u/H'L\_c¢_c©py_o? ibe__$_`.+q.ée'_$
__CQmp/Qm_+_)__ aod_ aoe_(_`.opy__o{»_`__ %&_?f@Mj_u¢;y_LmJ) (;/'/nenfo_/°/€O__J€,_L¢J_¢l(_yau_/)Qo/€é_@ne
__¢;_@pj___-For__ 44\_€___01<5'/7¢_¢_+__/§7#¢2¢/1€3 éb.€_r_\.;€)_/£_;$Q/'___cl SQM€_p_r;é$e/rlv_nq_¥:_/)_€__C.pr__+a__i:/)_e___
_D_ .£L __~}'4€/\_&$¢::19__%4<;_@. c'glnaL_>L@_+4e_m‘é/xé¢'o.n_@f_f_4¢_[;u,+,' .
mO_o__J;/:»_€__/..Z_’:)"__day_o£`:_£§lo,r:u.c¢.):_j_r_£_Q/_S.,._,Q_e:bl , fa_o@£_£€_€_¢_z:ueci_{`r_am_%.€_$ __“"A. , ..

 

 

 

 

 

 

_D/.zl:r_b»/:_[;_Ld'__€_/e!;l< T_C_hecyl__]" mey_a__€__p_'j_g?_#;e_Of_LymaL_Q/>,O/Lagéa¢\_§f a____
_LL/r¢_4_09_4/04)eas_ééw,au.s__a$:¢jvzca/_Cazaxe_A/Mméer_/_Z]_Z],Z_J’__fn_a_gco r_gL a/.>Q__ -i.v.__
_4._:5_&4¢@4_@_,1_/.0144;3__¢4_: ?md_@_%g_&_¢@;_&_m.,.a_/_A,QM_ _m__¢§_+___
__C_]f/.¢_+z_.4_€_;.\4;.¢3_2<.2¢_21_@,_/_za¢a_h:gm_£a¢w___nle_é;ud_@_$_&;mal_A,d,_@aJ_¢_a.s_q___
_du£y_>§o_Aar¢@__g:e_-£u.med_£/_.e. c>r){-/re oro/o,)/Qa-_!,',m 09 non » camp/, ’¢>M~l +¢) ~44@_ o_/,_e,-/( ,,P
_44@_£2:21'0/_€@:_¢ r_+__bcaaa:e_s_aid_o,opl_hm&bn_k_;q_\//ala#an_a£_@r:l:z'c/¢:_/L_Q'?_ S_e/z?m__ 3
_Bn_a,o/O//co-/-/on_m¢¢sMe_-F/ kw£h_+é¢e_c_/_e_/_"_a?_£é_e_ QQ¢.M- n_w41c_4\_44€__conw¢4zo,,
__4) el 07_€42¢2//£As;ed_w0. §_Qé£a¢aad" :

 

_____E§_-LQQA_QE_ 446_€0;4¢-£;09__@0/)/1¢004_29/),0€04$_/?05/_99_2;€_#4¢1rn&ag_a)§.‘a.¢k:_a_ memrandum_&€ lq._uJ idm_£`o¢m app//ca-hzq 29 cm,
_______w__a.n%_ 140_ presen£_le_ja]_au-/B@r&/e$)_SL-d' ¥Ae_Qua\:LLL/a_¢é_cwmder _gr:o________
____u¢z¢/;_Lr_cel¢_'c-F c-F_).n_a_m_e_oo Q¢qr.zdum_cx@ 40¢0_744¢4_0_@_¢&_0@£-_$.£¢;&3_ m_+£ze_____’___
____________-§cm_a,o/Q[[¢a¢' ».m'_\. r_/Q_-E_ '4:w. ner__'».v_\_¥u_r_memo. pac)_d¢_¢m_ aglo.¢Lbr_o_ u_j btqlo_&____
________9_409oa_@r_421.44_;_,__1_0._¢¢;,?_0;;@£@14¢¢/7_02&€€_4;¢4_LQ¢¢_wzm,__»_/.O beer
jfa v.e_lj__f`_ej_r_e_+$__l;z_e_£`a,£/e d_#_p¢$€,,,¢__:%.ejra¢eip!_a r\_-/:/¢» e__-§cm_a,o,ol/.(¢m%'@n
__Ihg_or_¢ie_c_z_s_&u_e¢£_by_iée_@u&_@?_€ummal_f?,o,¢ec¢[s_¢ef{¢zc_f/»e¢£_o_/e_<;¢s_@z\_%£_
__cz,go_/_ ¢_ca+m/_\_w_ K:.$_‘Z, _58.3 '_10_41. 0__$'_/:7.0__9.€/\€_(0 Le.-EF_:¢:£:_'):Q__QQ_Q,Q,QZ/ca_hp¢_£é._ QJ'_M/_'ol_-
_cz{e$_£r_-é/.'c/e_//,_Q]_§ 3,.__7.75@_1.¢,1~.4~_9¢;4¢24@@_¢0 r,ou$_J_s_+Ae_re/_))ed_j_%v_£e_useé___
when_anj_/oef$a_/_S_cesl~mmei /2'\_4.2 r_/ 24>@2;4_7.1_%_ ls_qn_acd_e.;_).;.;u_@c/ ky a rmm{-

 

 

OW(JHJJGP @'p rom.be+€f)'/"Jr l irl T(J/r}rOr/\ .~ r v

fieg&_;éb e_w_r,;¢;i=_¢$$_u€i_bj_=)y.>e__$éié_@_;§jf¢c/;&c»z!_~l:_J/ _ucl.y_€_w,e_£. 6¢//_._440¢¢4__ c.Q/_>:),a___

_ _ jy,mid/aham_k)_€_@__é{£é_?fé_€__'_po._/m_U/o,a/¢c_afqm_/_S__/.n__V/.ofanfaa.r;\_M/_,.é_é»_/Q_¢:£LJ@___
___/.L__C.;Z_§_3_\¢,_9.,_€._£_£__00_¢{_/.'024mohé¢)s_$@j-_£Br_i£_ao_%e_v$rm_ag¢.,4'»a¢/on_ _ '

 

 

1 1 P R 431 HJ E R

____U/_HB@~E/'"QRE_F_R EJYZIS E_S.__C_O_A/_§J_-'~._Q E/QE_O )./0_1%_47 amer /01:0__7:_¢4&:4414$____
___/:4_0. noia 404€___@0_;_¢_¢_-\'_@£~&_£_€0.004_ acl-znj_lbeo£mj_£f}a/_C<)LD` AEQ@_/O&é:é/onef_` S_._
__¢_$$u£_s’__€__a&&¢£_¢_n_\q §_BQL¢ZQAE@.»_b_lr_};o§_/)’)aa.a&mw_/_z_a€__%l»e_L/QLQC_MQMQ__
__/.'Xl c/_S___@ r_Cl_€c__;L£ e_,_.£;$¢..u::\'_ap___ C£/ m. unawpr /€._LS`__O!`_J€!__;Q_C_A@ L¢Sl€‘$&')-LAL;UI` 1‘:4'_._'42¢__
_4:£__$ 64_0£/0@__6?1)__£&4¢/1:&_1_6_ +j_$g_C_/€rlf_QE_ ibe_\l_b_¢§fac£_[ Q¢_c 1;+_44;1.<>_£0__11_¢ L__

-@cm_cz/>/z/Jcaho/\_€oa£_/\/uméec_/? ZZ_Z:J' @L&Ju/n@__&_c@/>o,a/j u!/_¥L»_Acém'.é€___
_/_41____7__§_3____§1$_0\/€/_/_0$`.__44_\€__m£'l¢mcz¢lon__?_o¢,ao/\_~£/\e__H/M_Q/Qf//'00-47 ar\__ _ ~
_S_Lyne_¢;l_o_njl\é__%lq_€,__¢/{_¢`dau 99 @Pc@m/\@r 7 0/5,

,Qe:mj+L`,// __s_r_/_Z)/_):)d/e#l

4_@§2_¢_;2!_:@4¢»/ pm s<.»_