Court Opinion

ID: 4048191
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:34:23.83776+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:26.116232
License: Public Domain

. ~ 1 v - U.Q\fo;z.@z,<>q,~\§ done ?_.§a 1<>\$

?.o. ?>ox \'J.?>A%

(\oe,».`m , `\'»-`. '7¢‘¢~1 \\

Qe,‘~ Qe_mo.\né wrae;( j L'>\o`bec,icior\ "\'c ‘?>\'O\\e,\§ p\~ bpw%ec\ Q.{v\c\§v\` P¢L<>€~4>\; \'z.z§<'¢%\~A
C,,Q_\A accords C\'b MO. \N‘Q- %'L °'U&L\ -O"). ', 'O%` -b\\ \ -0§ cond, '(>co

On Fe_\or\\c;r\_\ 1€+¥)§10\5, -Fv\i% 00qu o`\aq‘\'£<:\ w\\{ \'\c.\oe_c»$ p'voc¢c<-).§n%s '\~¢ ~\~\ne
wic\\ Qc>\w"\. \Dors\.>cw\\ ~‘cc> -\'\r\`\$‘ ~¥\r\e S'\~er_ made o., \pvop¢>sec\ Lwc$e_r- \ o.w\ unaw¢>»\'€_
i¢ &\/\e_ -\'\,-§c\\ cwqu Sz\gv\ec\ *c\'\is .<>\r~, "\$ \ne did C,\v\\\-\\nw\% e_\se XQ w\\\ v\w`\*c . Y-uf
Q‘\'e,\rcr\*<`\\!e, '<\/\ec\$\>\fe.b, \ C{'\e, °<\/\\`S e\o`;e,c\-\`¢n “\b *<\(\e. S`coc`\e,`s pva¢,s¢¢\ <>\'Q comc,\\>c&¢c\ \o¢¢c,¢\\¢se, ¢\v\e, mr<>\e.
$:§c:va-¢M¢,~=\ \\'\\bi\\€or\ma&:om was em essen\€q\ Qc\v‘\ c>\? n\\\ p\ec\. cw%re,eme,n+ Qer
mg qué,e \`\Qe %Q~n\e~nccs. To \w'\\\ Qc.\\cu\o¢¥\`\>\'_\, LB\,\Y\e. '2$, 10\'5` `\5 -\'\'\e c\cdce, +\ne. :e.corc\
S\'\b\>\& ‘O€ %€x`i* \/305£,\¢. `\'O 'X\r\e, C.C,.L. QDQ.Q£>.\_>$¢ \ \r\c».\le he \c,v\o\~\e¢`\%¢ C;\v\c& "\\\e

~\viq\ C‘\>\>\"c \'\us <\\>'\ Se;\'\°< W\e, '\\S c>\Nv\ 9{\0¢\<0¢;,>3 o-§ Qc>`c\- or Luwc\osio‘ns <>¥ \o`~\»`\, l

3€\\&. '\'\f\i§ \'D \\w\.\ \\"\ 'YY\€ t'\\e,\”\°( `\“`( <\.©€S G~é`m(>‘\ ‘\'\r\€, 5"\0\¥€:% -@iv\¢\'\¥\c`»>$.

}\S :>§ -¥`Y'\i§ c\o~\`, \/\u§ ~\~\r\e Cx>\>‘<-\ 04 C\c\`mw\q\ Avpea`\€ (P_c,e."\\rec\ ex S\>pp\e,w\¢~n-\c\\
+van%cY\QX povg\_,¢;w\ w `\~\`5 ¢wc\e'( '\-m ~\'\:\e ~X\'\`<.\\ c\>\_\.<‘°\? \'3\<¢>~&<>_A `\n$<>vm ‘<\~¢e_. C>¥ -X\»\\`s cwa

p\@ose, no>ri<'~; me *<`<\cc\ \\o.> receich *'Y\e -%o\\¢\~m% e\£\;`\ose` v \L>%§gm

 

'\:\'e,v\c\/\ N\. \Q\-.\oex\son \)\r\\"k

\7,0"\\ F.\\(\. 3§2,?,
b\\:)'\\e~nc, `\~i\\ `T¢\ba\

‘ C,`;M§e‘.‘\*' \n\nq')_~¢\, \Lzmqv\'x\, \15§%1,\~@, \B\C\zs »A. \’L?,Swz>>\- A

EX pou’¥€, 4 ' \Y\ '\'\r\e Co\>\"\’
O; .C.Y\`\Y\{no`\

Qc>c\r\e»` \l\/;\\\`(x.w\§ ' APQ€O~\'$\ b\\\$\"\“l_“"

 

C\o`bec*<\on °\0 J<`\\e, S‘YC>\X€,`S @Cbpeseé\ V`\\'\c\\'r\%s O§- cac~\~ G_nc\
Cc>v\c,\\>${on$ 04 LQW eu\<.\ C>\'c\e\r AQ-\Q\r Qer\'\om»¢\ b\` ‘\"<\e_

CO\>\'é\cr ~Q§\'\c\$ C§\op\§c_cu\-¥,s Q\o;\\\'\ +\r\oé< \\e, \No\)\c'\ Y\mva
`ms\s¥_eé. cv\ %\>\`n% “‘Q_ '\‘c§'o\\ Xi\>`\ l§or w\m%e-\‘§ mism;\v§ce_ C\’\
pc\vo\e, C`\`\%§\o`\\\`~\\(- Q:(cé"\\o\e,° [\S Q,¥ “"<\n§s de¢‘\\ C»\>m c\¢\¢p>_ S»<¢e\o`§e¢,.l ca>n<\\)dr cg fa¥vc>\/%e -\\r\e CQQ ace whava <.\I\o\>ss<),zo` de\z\ R Z`>b\

 

S~\J\¢\?>c\ (o%¥\ §Tes<. Qv\m. 1\\?<). 20\23 `\s vedoo`c,¥i\/c; *r> Co.SeS
occ\>ww\% \§Q¢O€é \le.\ow\)oxq \S, ac>\z. I>\\><\<\L>;>g\\ uw&e< we
Vi%\m*< Q\vc\>w\s-\ox\£e% q ve%roex¢%\\/§&\\ @n&\\\s\6\ \oe
pexm\$s`\\o\e,\ +\ne, issue `\5' \Y\app\ica\@\e \Jec,cx\>se emp\`\ccm°x -me‘.c

`-\r`\r\e 15‘<0&'\<;\0`{<9\ \>K\<;\e>< r\`x\(\&>wsso\?',cxc\e\n §§ b¥\ %.\S\».'Z>r\é\e~( ox\ Cx\‘(eo`c\\,\

QSX&\Q\KSY\§A preceden-\- because @Avc>\e. e\§c§`\\o§\i~¥\\

m\sio$<>rmcd~¢, Ex Pw‘ov“‘c .Y\eec\s "co S-\<`~\\\ 'C-\N\\\ew devé\o(>
+`Y\e \'em>rc\ '+o make Spec;i~‘?ic; £<>`ck Q§\~c\\n%& vec§oxcxim`>> ~‘<\r\€:
`\\mp\\`ci+ +evms Jv\r\o@\ \O\{ SKQ>Y\\\(\% ¥Lw ch \i§e Sex\%©r\c,e\ ch\
COY\Q\>WQX\* gov Cx\\ C)(\o¢<'%&i `\Y\ a @\;q bav%Q:n, \/\Q \:\»L>\>\e\
be ©on\e Q\{%§\ol'€,. k

`.[1. E%Sern°ricx\. @cu°< 09 P\eo` Z¥%re-_.Qme\/\‘\'
N\r. v\l`\\\\`cm\§ @\ed %¢§\X\\ w a\\ §§ ‘ms. Q~rime&, gov §\\`$<»~_
SQY\“\@(\CQ <'c\\<\ QO\\ Q,'\)we\<\>< Qov a\\ Q\(\cxrq\e_§. `\"ne `\\ €e,»
Se\/\Xc-;\\C.QS YN@(\J< \Nc& QQ\/X 0§ a \o\eQ \om%o&n\
N\\’. \1\£'\\\\`£1\£\\3 V\&S & Qc>\o\\ C>€ ~\'*n\`§ \D\ec:\ &%re@me»n+ o;r\d
\(\0§25 `W\e C\E>,KV_ C\\,. c,\_ C,Q\Q\\ 0§--¥‘(\\`_£,
p\ec\ O\c`>,mme\c\*v as \5\1@\\. \S-` m>‘<, he \s\\'\\\ §\gvm§\n §\ `\€
(`Qo\\_'>e&'\ec\. _\N`<\exe v-k\(\c~_ 3*<03<€"5 prop Q>SCC\ @<<§e\’ `\5 \<\odec\L>Q-\@
`\‘(\ (eSc>\\/mg ‘W\`\§ iv\€§&?@c%i\/€ Cx$$\&‘m\r\€€, C,\c\;\m , §§ “‘v`Y\OSv {‘f
W\&d€. §\_O_ Qc\c;¥ c§e‘f\ deeds
pm<>\e was cm ease\(\¥\o\\ pad <>>§ *c\r\e \o\e@ og®r\ +\(\e '\QMO\€ `\v\$`vc>\XQA `\Y\\c>
-W\e &cm\ \>\ec\ Qc:>rcem@r\*\ '\"\A p\mc\ c§\>`\\&\\ ‘vo X\(\\’QQ_ \i§-e %e\<\'\\c&<\`>\ \o}z
@cm>\e e\§§\\<>\e.. T\s c>\<)<)\`\c;o.\r\)< cx*<*vo\c,\(\ed &S w\ E~/`\<\`\\oi°\ Jvc>
\\\S \(\0\‘0€05 emma ~ ma 3mm c£ 0. &*cw grievance em+q\\ec\ -\»\m§ \Noé ~\-\(\Q
<>\(\\\4 reason \1\<>, \N&s \Q\UA`\'<\G`§ Q§\>R\‘c\{.
"\"Y\€, 3&03¢€_ "\Qro@o$c,é\ Qov\c\\>is\` was Q>Q \Qw cmc\ -QQQ’§ A§»`i\né\`n§

are `\\r\Qc§eqm~\-e . {\S Qn&al\e;\ `\v\ \Y\ c>\>secxzqc\e_\m TI, `\d ., Qv\

 

Q%%ev\“vi€x\ md oQ o. p\ec;\ u%re@m@¢\'\ m\>_§\ \c>`e §oo`r\c\ L>q>or\ X\ne
€_\A~Qress +Q\rm$ 0§ \'Y\Q \Nvi~\%ev\ \Q\eo` Cxc§(ee m€\n'\ §'\Se\?, ~W\e
-@ovma\ \"ch>\fd G@< ‘Y\I\Q \Q\erx V\€O¢(`\N§, o\r Jv\r\e, \Nr\°<‘cev\ cr
+es&~`\\\xom\`o»\' Q\l\` dance S\>\om‘\XXec\ \o\\ \0¢‘<\(\ -W\e mosec$jviov\
Ov\d *\{\e app\`\&&v\X `w\'u \r\c\\<)eo§ §)mc<@<\cng>\. Tv\e,\o@*< prong `\5
~W\e i&§\)e \(\e,\re. TY\Q, &ric\\ Cm><’r Y\eer\s 3m &<\A(QSS `\¥_

pm c>\e e_\`\%'\\o`\\ \“c\{ WGS 000 €BS@\(\\'KO\\ e\©men'\ 099 “W\e p\ea
Qc§>veeme'>r\* \M'\'\\ av\ QN{<§\€>(\"<§QN\{ \(\ec\rKY\Q,`“W\,e Q,o\gev §§

QMXQ S°c@p‘nema;y\ 721 3.\1\1.1¢\ \m.c, LT@.~@~ Q-(p\iccm\*se, c\\X‘(\oog‘n

~W\Q p\eq \om%o£\n QO.QC\'S é\o 50% N\c\uc\e. \:)QSC c>$ -‘<*<\`\3 Co.&€, ap Q\§'Qm\& }`\§ A\‘YLX\QC\

‘vo \FQ\RQQ\ `W\e. V€C,O\fd _`m '\\r\\$ habeas Q<<>oazdmg r\e£c\$

~`\D be expanded `\v\ \Kc\>>\r\)< 032 E\ ‘OC\{XQ S“ce';>\nex\;c>r\ , "\Q\\
m. \:\>v°<\me_‘€ DQ~\/@`\c;>m@r\~¥ 05€- ~\<\(§e 'Q.zc@~(d

\N\»\€QEF<>Q& QQ&N\\S_€S co\\;\s\o€\eeo, kop\\`c,o`w\ prc,.»`§ ~Y\'\e. %v§&\
Co\><*r be mm\<\&ccé\ w C_o\/\c}\\>c}v c\v\ Q\x \`é\®(\»\c\`cm\,\ \(\em'\`v\<\>) om<§
expand -\»\(\e_ reco(é` 3m de~‘w<\/\oé<€ wis ;>\ec\

~&o§e@me,v\“‘< .

Q.espe¢‘¢@o \\\\ 5 o\om \' \"\'cc\,

S:%m¢\ ¢<\<\\S 2§+\5 dqu 06 swe

’)_O\§

 

Q.>.»,\neH \¢e,\,m» \N;\\caw\s S¢\
T..o.r;.s. “¢ \\°3§%?:1
’\?vemc\n \v\. Q¢\o¢¢\ggw &)W+
\2¢'1\ c.w\. '§Szz

B\Q;\w; , T»~\` 'w\\oo\`

- @h\`>§e, ¥l“. \’L’LWQ'L-A‘,, \’z'L\\'\OL\.\-A\ \'L€§'au-A,' \'Z,?>\Cx%§-A ; \'Lz'swa\ -` A

E`A ch'"`ce \‘n +\r\e C\>`>v'\'

‘.~'J(: Cr\`mmcx\

Qc<§\\ne\{ \I\/§\\\`C>~W\S A\Opea\$, B\J$'\\`n,'\`k.

UnS\NmY\ he,g\c\¢o@c\`on / l\-‘€$\`c\c>`\l`\‘v -Qov \-\qbeas C,¢,ro\_»s

ch\>s<>_"* \zzvnqz~A', uzmw-A; \'L§§~ez,\ »A; \1?,\<\5§~1>\~, \zzs@@\-A

\, Qo¢\ney\ \M§\\ic\\<\f\S, Q¥Q'ww\ \ '&%cee;c\ w \@\ecu;§ %u{\h\
Qc>v cx\\ 0% mg 0&€@\(\§€3 m 030ch So\id. Qa\)se Y\\>w\\oex~s %o\r
cl \\"{~e %e‘(\"cemcc Y<:\\r\ Cb\(\cowe,v\°r -@o\' u\\ Q)(\ox%€$ \oecq\>SQ,
n \o\( °cc>\\¢i\f\% *\dv<>( ¥o ii \1\\€>0`\<\ \oc Jr\(\o:\ .\ \No\>\d \oe e,'\`\%`§'\@\e
QD< @@<'c\a bna é\&q¢‘TY\e p\e& bar%cs£\v\ \ ern>vem¢\ `\\'\)vo§
§N\{\c>\e w\os‘zcmce was mcc>\e e\`\g'\\@'\\§‘r\q .. "Y\<\ig is %`\ne 0“\\4
MS@'V\ OX\CXl QGY\S§(§E,YGX\G\(\ \oq * `\X

@)Qccmse \ am S\\>C.V_ \s\\\&\!\ & \`\f»e Se)(\*re\(\€e \\\1(&\/\ 00 mv<>\e,
\ Q\N °v\(\`\s Qs>\>\c\ mX \oe 0.\1\ e,§@(\&~\o\\ Qc\<’v §§
mg \‘)\ea agrae>.w\€>r\‘h C,cm\c\\q Qu~\, \ $QQ\ Jc\r\`\g Q¢vw\`c,}v&c~c\
is uv\ wn§c`\<>\n¢\\o\\\ Rw\©@s°\ Qc§\'&\{\ in
c>\>f §\>c\'\c,iq\ S\\§Xew\..

O\>~vs\>m\°< w presex\*<\\\ ‘OQ\\(\% KY\QMQ@\<%v\f\ev\‘< §§ Q'< \m\v\o\\ \\\)S\\1@ `\& ‘Yw\a Oor\c) _meec¥ w “¥\/\e \oes'¥ 0¥ wm q\o\\ ‘v\q

Dc@re<\ end &\%Y\ed ‘€\/\\5 CX&\\,XY\Q '?_§*v`o o§ 5\)\:\€. 20\&`