Court Opinion

ID: 4054562
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 05:29:03.24578+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:22.323248
License: Public Domain

-.3~1 ~hc5t1w~                                           -.
                                                           '"''A\   UE. I G.) q~)-Q'Z,. ']C,:. 9l~~Q3
   YYbuA~+
                                                                     . . 79"" CfJ~ 64-
                                                         T.AJ 7hr::;. GJu._J. o-C: U-.,m,JJJA-1 ~

                                                  I.
  tJu 4:·J· I~         A(lpl ~"C..i\vt    ~tt.i~ ~             IUD-1-t{!_£   a( ~ 1\J ~ffidAv1~
   .ft Jed b~ nt.s.        Ol\l911uA-I ~AleY DU 3· i'r·IS:                    Ths AJf. t!.fAV,..f tult!J
   I dee! ,AJ +hs u.,3 'kd bt.s~~C..-t t.ckJI\ -t- &f- TOJrn-.:i 1-ll?rf..~ 1.5 Lbovl~.
  1\ll o.C +hb A-PPl,c_AVb fN:..VtOU:S ~~ w~A.k. hAS ~~ [,tr:.--d 1V
  -/-he /25th ~s~,l. tM..tou.5
   tklu~.rl-u:..S. St:.t .. · '5c:.:t_hou J4 ..303. of ~he:. v. 7.[.1\. GovdJ.J!YJc.Vf. Cocb.
   fhb!.:~E. ME:. ,jt:fJt;:;(A--h; d,s-k_,e_j- 6:})1,;/s .. 1de:vld-1&J !Jy .SG/Jb-t.n-k 1\/UIJ)/J~)
           .                                               cJ                         u                        l)-
   .5uGh h A-VI ru!i d·~ Cl£.U.U ~Ud3g AIU fm 16. trOb II' A:/ Ju~tJ"d ll!.--J.,o,u, ~N .4-
   t.lLJ/h~td\. D p Jtb/:3'f6 +he__ !:IeD..B(A.f>h 1C:..AJ .JUl-. ,:UJI U I 0 U D f ..J.u.v {z_ ) O/(. ·tnc.::$.(3
                               l

    dt.stt-, 1d eo:.J\ J.s.   1.5   o ua IPt{J/JtJU9. 1u :5omB 6z.uu.J.., eS ' tv~ u          1t:s   .S~Jt::;~, fr..s&
!Jy. .+ht;- ~E eo-1-h ~d             mt:JJ\.s fo +h~ Uu1 +&J S~4-e.s t:,us-J1-Ju-l,aJ +hE.
A-tto~d tS 8..J.+,+It:~-d ~ -k,A--1 tut.f..h,IU ~he d,.s+K-.JU -1-fu~~ &;/h€ LvM
l\.t1I~E.d -+a hfrl.£.. 6t±l.J e.JDmmd-kd:. IUh,U. Lf,Jk,e.:J- .sh,q II h~ bceA/
ti\8Jta.l.Sf Y A-Stc;~_:/-1\,A..J by fAtA..J. fl. ~~lhF¥{ m..dc:/1... I.S /J6CdQd -lc 11 //ec_+ .;j/he_
~AA.Uk oJ t!_KJCS 6r:;twe£U --1-c.ut:J(L) d,.s.-k,e_-! cdcJ(:+.s IJJ C!el:Jt...ri/{§ w1.1h
 --/-u;o 09.... 1Yb~6 cJ,s-h, ,c.J. ~ul...--f:s. ~ no~A.Jcvc::;a.. ..   IUD   ::Juc..J.   ~      f.:)   IU~--d. .fo~
 t:JccJr~je_.             on ~uc.he::s . ~-. A.bv6.J         ~.~ ~ q,'i 'J.w.             uJ z.s {.7-c;x. A/Jf. 14-.fh
 d t~J    Uu/ess --lJil3 ~ o~ t1u-l-hox.iY oJ lr C:evl..-1- .Jo IJLGfor...m A
           J'lqL. ).
 Cbu~m.fJI~ ~ t.Nu .!Jt- ~ t1J -IJJ6 tcluS-\-1-/.uf-'-ou oi-UJ~,~ S--M1!;)
 o f\    +he     IMJS. clu ~rtkr.t
                          +h(j(_fZ- uudd,. +It ,pf- a>u(.-J-.:l 1s wJA 6 t.rl- stili~
 MM-fd..J~,stfrrJ-tao · .h_. · &Pt-{+,z.. 1/. .5-fM& ~/7 5. iJI. zd 9l/'9 Je..x. {J.. /4¥Jdrt~/J.
                                                                        1

 ?u +he.. 1"-lS~ 0\;36 ~Ae: otbs£ tvlt5 A-//o.Jd -+a hf!lu6 o~d w,Jh,AJ
  .l]j_-}1) .Jud•t..IA.--1 ~~.s-4A.,d oJ. f-.1-tt.M,s /otAJfY .. /O(fd.fh6 ,_f.f, dtt11,~ tuk5 LoUdu61cr:{
                                                   +
   110 +he 2.~31-d d1=>k ,Lf ~ 1\ ucJ tt-6.56"'_rf t.:S A -1-f...AVs;k bt.dc-f
   tuhud           ..:l   hou ld .!Je   VD1d~-d.

        ,A.PPI•e_NJt        ft,d'w:> ~hA--l- -1-h~·   tno+,ou be              j~ffi Aud SA ,d_ rJ/,dl'rv,J
        be_    VDI     Ct::d.
                                                      «J, +h     Lo'c'~{ty TotU!ti.ds. -M£ 11S "JI+v
                                                       o.P ~ t.S touc+.
                                                         ~b--:5 Pt:X!_;~ tu 1/t.t SuiJ tn1 Jlc--cJ
                                                          l:xmuu£1cw).
                        &.J.,t~tA+e, et ~v1t£
1-   SAiYIL£il ~oPhd-~,_-::tt/o7.34/f .. hae:6Y tJ:::J'..-fJtr ~h,yj -fhl-l
rno+1DAJ   o! {r:;Mu-1-A-1   wlr:S.   m ;v, /set J:H .li/,5,   P.5. -1-o .'
(l,t!S~wf:1      ..   ou 4-· IS· (S