Court Opinion

ID: 4055071
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 06:38:00.765653+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:24.500339
License: Public Domain

DEA¢L CLE(LK

\,`(ou\¢\ \\\\j\\\\( Q\>§>H_QQJQL 70\~ ]<;¢\<\.1'\165
9 °\Q%SL Q/LfbD//L§QOQLU\C,L

Ll>uféjc Ju 351

6.;{`\?\ 1
l;~` \[OL,( \MO\.!\A
53 'EYNL \/\O('\O\/C\\O\°~

 

1100 \“) \\\5\\\\/ Q()QYL§J&Q.A Qm;& 7/¢>~…'

\/ouf 099/um

140vale \ \(\)u/Lj hong a ll'_év"\j but
05 b~)O\LLjQS ég \,.`C`\/
€. gulfij

"TF\C~DK ~j/OL»( \-\ Fm 206170

T@nn@e@v_@ c<>h>fwy, T><.'z§%¢,@

Ro_~_ T,_Q+_.,\)o. zonz'-'?°\O»Cz \/~"<~‘?>Z,q>l»@§

`TB 'l'\'wlz Ho~o£a€)l_£ mqu <)F CR//v\mm_ APPEAL§

LOrY`\Q,E? now,» A()P\\'CC\Q[: )/40\,`}9_\\ (3\\»|\~(1¢\/ GWLQ»r\ 10 {;\'\.Lq\oo\/Q.
mg:\'\l'-\OGrAQ»( Or'\ vl;\'w»\ g'n¢l_;nj§ O.g: {;\rw.&/;c\\ Cour{
'\r\l\)¢)nou)c O\ \f\o_o»/\n§ 00 L\'\¢ 20\5 _

APP\;C.QGJ: 05ka 335 £Y\QJC L\OQ- 12<~/10\\ Co:xA-_ gm&\'nj’€_\'~lffb
` \/qu` 001 A{A no£ c\AA/<).SS Q\lo`jq-Elonb 0¥<1€{1\\€@¢\*9
C_\C\`\m§ \,\!\’\*\C'.\f\ 15 Q>ur\&£-\oérwb \~lou\<§ ijr\£ KQMQQ

A_QP\;CC~“E COQ-{;{, COr\\/\Cjc_l‘on \OC\\O
.L‘Q¢(J\/\S )k/\¢\SA\C.I:HDA.

/\()()\‘\°(_qu; COr\l;Q/\"\A~ '1_`_-\!\€\5 \“\L §owb`)Q/A 50 '&»NZ_ ELH'\’) Dl`§'é¥l&f
Q,Y'\m\qq\ C@W£ HOnofC\\o\L\)uA§‘L mq& dohnz<_>r\ imeJC’L’/{Q\
pcxd;%] §>u€(>wl;‘mj_ Qp'p\‘\©&nt c\q`\m§ Q\on§ Wll;\n I.v.)/Qn@w\pi Qn<\ .Q»)<`r\{bl€e.A()pth'»nt

CD

P.(O\\f L\`{;S \*\Q\'\o~r’o\\:\\<>, COMH: Y.>\[ 1115 PO\*"~’/ Obw;n %u<.\f\ Aocu~ _
mw£/S Q/Dr\’\ 4:,"\0¢~.b 59'\4\'\(\ 'Dl"av':'\/|Q'{'~ COU‘ di ~)U¢\j-Q» \-‘\o'norqb\o,
ma£l: Jc>\m\eon, \.\1\£\»\ 0\\\ ¢§wL (9~59&.¢£5.

A?€\ \C_O\n-}; ?(Q`\i L._\,-\\g l»\*OOOYC\b\L COu/‘): C\HC_\*] C|PF`|.CC»\'H=£_L> _
,?-mcu,%é MQ\ rnpo\\ 'EO mq)€°f\c\\ §C£i£hq)c up
fro\/Q»n w'\\\ .sL_nLH<.\¢~ \m'm _\/L\§L§». `I$ %c»j»rr m`,§goq<§uct
\N\"\QJQ,C\§' Q?f>\ (Conf, \IJC"H:~ C\f/L§ész.<§ §r {:\\y`_ 0£.1;@,(\59_, Agj,q\[qéu§
Ko\pbu\[ w'\-&\w a A_UA\\; \~\Q.OQOG, On march 24, zozz,howwu(
41th \»Jc\§ no \.\1@\:)0.0 rzw\/w QJ€ Jc\m~ "SC°*H~ 012 <:\(nz,@»+,.

0m mO\/(C\..\ 2{,,| Q_(>\Q_ O\€€\ECQnJc ’oj~\r'\g‘(lo.,nl \c 5, P<>\zww’~, L."nt :_9_5)(

(KR \/o\. 6/ Pq%q¢;/ gm :-Lf); S¢Q_ (Exu\e»\-r's #1,3,4,5).

*A()P\\°um£ Q\Q_A <>\ m<>~ldaon ’€w 'D:*b€o\/wj) Ovéw On Jul\j ZO/.ZDIZ

m 90@<§"1%11}\ racbuwl=;n§ ~th 9£<;1=@ to -!;u/r$ ovsz./ om\j cm£§, q\l

mq£w\c\\ Q\/‘\<\ 2 996

hc\n<\l§“‘°..\ 10 Cbmp\`\n jwqql-_Inj .B,\,` QLQ(:,,` [5“??(9_‘55‘3{._}19_[:(,0 2 66 \"\CmAgunB_
:\T\QJL b\5 _ mo l SQQWQ_%;`O,J hv`o\/\°nj en KQQ,,»Q\, in 1911 BLHH C\/¢‘m¢
m°\\ bl§érm{ Cour£ `\)~I\L\qc\ ['Ru\'\°nSI-Frem \Aon.,[mq{:b`)o\nn§@n¢
may 1'6, wz A?p\\:@~ql; FNCM.A ad add 1b1 LY;Q,, 043 `QACJC~
[~)W\/]. Pro€»m€ul»»mf> +-Hv`jwj Jc\rm£ \Q\/J MH>¢CL-»

@

*amqy v ' y
mm);~ ` ` {¢LC,o\/W 0\ \,,J‘w»€on but \'\o._ \,' pzj,(pq§°. |`6%/ L.mQ_ 10). '

~Thl'?> \~lq§ a <;\,Q.CQ,?J=;Om .0¥ J;\nL jury . [FACT] lewd QM$O(;U§.,,

QXW: {LCQ'\/ULA 01 l:CoZ 55 Y`K`H\Ajuflj QI:SOSQQ] l'%) not c. =\mé\>/_
\uwpoq/ P,U 51 6 LQ_L \[_ 51~_¢.1-,¢_, 61 @°\'J. 3c1 505 /#ra.x. /\pp¢»/ws~l='m
?_OO\) ql= l: 213 q\go Mr. C £¥m_, O$'QQW 'EQK\“(\§ 'l=\““' 9'£€‘“;'/ how °"V°'(' ‘£C*C`L'j
flc\.v:d: J:\nc\l: £-_\'w. pro§s)`.co\.~ low QQJ::~/sl~/ o¢ nm<)\\°§sz.nl-_\\) 514()9{2,55:¢1~
Or ‘cq\\°-<\~v'):f> <=\151\052~ Q~V\AWC’L'VJY\;L\Q mc\\/ bo. mQEM\TQ/Q£o&\n,<
4*¢\0~§)0§& \»% (9~\1 u§”\b\L swann "=`>~°-Q' (ch\< Ac§)} %.u(EXHnB/TFS
2151 q, 5) 91 1305 PO\ILL.. rv€¢~rl; QrL.l: FACTS] Hm{; q [Co?_BB 111/wp-
Gw\’§ was m cww@<\l wmqu 14 +\m& L’Cb z 66 HA~oGW; was ~°T
L Dled~o@ej) -ém£ m»`'; 55 HA~O 6\4~3 was[‘bu??££e§]¢
u"l'HER£FoKE/J:\"m 544-h b15£r;c'\' l»\¢>n.m o$ EFACT'H¢ J='h»~ 5441\<;0\1@+._
_W\CL SE zBB/~m~c€u~j \»m$ mq£()\{Qon*l: rm\\¢z»j<>. cm<§ incovp.mka J-LL FAQT ABWE:‘

@

GRGQMO.'\/\~lo'v Tr{“<.0{\_<§¢15€<1
_Q>~rm€\\ <§.\SC‘Q\//mm¢b. \‘<()\¢4\`…>_<§ 06 O\ ro_QeonC\\o/\°/ rack
0 6 ‘ ' \, . \' z ¢'10%:;»\'1(.‘.¢)3(O'§`1.€1\.£v
Q.S\Q <§v_C\%lon/.\out KQ.§\QU:B q SLQA;\nj j 6 . (0;2'5’
603 p\m_¢\ h°.@ coqaucec OUJ¢@’\AL 0$ am prwm\mj €
5'°“¢~\ nwng za-/IQ|<\QQA \[¢~JQ~S\~\~;£°“/H#@ Q~%~<»%O%<#)--

°GROK.|MO THREE:TY;Q\ C_Gvn @1,\ &;\o_.<§ 110 C\'\q\.\Q-nj'§l. L~{mz, 101 l%_-'W’)~ 'r_floccl COutn~
5e1 wCQ\\Q_A lam <§\\/Q, \/_ Cowlc {nSENC/CI'O`Q 511va
C-\Oc\\\mrw§m§ per CQ\A§Q_ ( R(Z \/o\. 21 P \/Wnonl§ Ann_Tg_Xd U‘s Q(OC. [Q)j, p\v/O"o.\'>`,C.wl"L'DVv
§§ _{°`59°“5@( (M"‘~“»-
`EY`\°` (LCor<§ ..

_Gkow\m ¥B\°m; Trlql £wn@g\ §¢`}\LAJJ» objo.c:J<. ¢:c> cm unqq§D-r-

\?-¢<§ '\/ U<\\C“E Omé \fo:<§ )u<\\~’:¢ A»rjumm.;:;(k€ \/0\. %, qu@ 1561, Li`n»,q»n)
(QO\_§Q. \‘5€1, L.\nl~ '5/ PQJ.Q_ \l»z, 1101 5-9_,)
'n`\Q- ju(\/ s\/Q)(c.\.\£t_ <10 1105 Q-X?'fp~€’§ ‘C\’(°\O\\fm Dr 1019 jun/-
ho\,`/n_\/w, 11: w‘ou\¢\ bo_ nonbm&@\\ 413 Sa\/ “WQJC)NL)UW\/i
c\’\f\<§ t¥'\&,¢\.. />. F\npl,u@ O,`)

/\_,.Oé/ADL_ well /. if a…”

'T_hl¢S 15 'i;r\/\L §qQL/§ §§qu 53 bg_ {-_»rc,{.Q/~.
5

      

 

[ FNCTI \)UQ(?m€!T'\" OF "T\-\E JMR\/ ’. Qn'§\°nj 00 A».nw§\'\{ vaqu
__,l\_/./'A/ / \’\0\)~}' fL.\/SL¥, ):\"\;9 mo_,c»n§ l'/\/oN'/\FPLACABL-E 7

T»W°~ ‘LW\Q\ Loa,\r~£; <§\A no+_ o\¢§§rsz.€o€) ~{:\HLSL C\\\Q,o)QL:ol-on§
bSLCQ\»\f`)$L. ~E}WLSL C\\\Q.§C\]c:ior\§ o\fz/IFAC"TCJ_J ‘Q°`\'\OA "\f`\ the

[ ‘J'\"A’FE/V\ENT OF FAQ’r@j.SuWO,JC by EE)<‘H\€)s-T'ej Uov/`

»'Dn€; -\;Viq\ COur{~, Cr>me. J;O-l;\no. C/onc\ue£o,s "`DE/\/vt£v" /#/qu$:
mi@? mma on am amy mri-16 fa.¢e§ C'mame@'

AP&’\"‘-““JC 11 FAQ“F€'>J C~»/Q~£W€; ana maxim m weasz
133 [{{EL|E\;: waan Juocme¢\l*r `Dl~z~\)zs£~v W\-TH P&eJumgg,

How`r bu£ m ada “ juéiq'€d Omrzéfon" bca€>m<§ on -(Qq§on`\f`l§ \
O\or\ §§ E)Ow'\<\ Q\U<,Q.rm'mq£:;on) \,\3\19_/0`§45 B’W\A\\) w;_o\pon. 'TY‘°‘T "`ms 36““’-’”\€"'
C\'\Q;Lm ¥\;WkQ/m mr bb¥\on$§u,\)/ -/`;¥\17‘5€2.€'\$\0,<§“'r`\,<):l~é.\'wf.l(

fn mQ\ gonq<§¢>, AQ§)\\QM% \»JG\S` `\qg].cko.é H>r j;)qL O{_`§UBL 019
A<\§\bl§¢n O.g q C\UAH UU_FOW
h@\'\¥“-WW \f\s>`-\)~l€\§ €>un<§ zu;L&\j b\{ £hk)`urqu Ar\o\\&¢nqq\o Co<~n-/'
P\`\O-nv_§ 0 €hM§LQ\-H-L_"\QWL/.. ,Q,»/~/or ;mpn)pw\\j in 51:,/\,\<'_€.<)»& ’

gaf €>\r\ 0‘\:€<1)0€>9`. ob\rw/ £Y\c~n O\O)¢j m\/q£s»é_~ mbhij
'rm court §§ aim;n@<) Appm)§ @OQQM».<) eth molaomao
" UH:»°J_\\} §Q'\\§ 4:» Q\‘\L§L §o\d@,wh`ic.h(".§ J:ruL( st-.`H;|L J=\qa/
O\(>g\\`mn£ leo QO\\¢`.LQWnqéo 4:\')9. opporjc'

Wun;lc"j to rb€\°~<>\=§ 6303 ‘~`JU??O*JC lane C‘\\Q“JC‘E"°° `

( P\LO\‘_`>Q, SLL. OJc;\nw~ 5\'39
lsd

 

\All~l=\'w Qé»°~%vml:@ WQ_QSOr\;nj, Orjur~rw~»nlc eng ~{:sl,€)é\:r~npr\‘\_oj
` ama rqcorgo_é 1\11<\ QnCL» which '\\,\u${:\/qjca,§ ¢;\n,d, .Mruk %o"m -»

.CLLJLQ_; \_ho_ -\;v\a,Q P{\)ULSS 0\5 jan §Qf\}j him q pair On<\
\\"O`QC\F!<;G,O l<.Y;C~/O -

_/>\??\\CO\M'» C°“£QX\§LJ:\UQ?C \'m, \k\cq§ (JLNC mo/<>,{¥:\nc“‘ {:\n°’

C‘o'u(£ 05\<@‘§ m@\\é\>nq<§o\ jcn WW\LQA, \M\'\ULQ‘)`, Q.QQU.U>*\`E»

- C'O‘§$` at bow ZD\?~' ’qu~C`I/ \rm§ PrL€)ml:».¢\ FSTA’r€mm/r

OF FP"“TG~’:§ )'° irm C°W¢T which QJ;L.-Qc,mé 4:\» \1.0"1 hc‘b>l»°§ C’°”'
('45 " ` ':

9 ' A?P\\C ‘FHE Ju@\l], ll MO|.QT mé~13 o.n<§

1 \/'£@mwj .

"_/9 AFF\%Vmo/E\“.\JL ‘;\'n<§\anj smpm§§ LA_ fn gm jqa,j mm£/'ho_\».l-_
9`\jw“'// O\F`P\l"to»n£ '\»\10\6 €>UAS J\A;ch 0(: c\éj¢)rq\/q€o.<\~(obbsz/j
{-q‘n&;§.Q/r\$miaj
‘LX\_°).\'})\Q. cor PC` m\¢` Con 61 q\.M'Q/M.o~)/ Qb‘“osm{: on Q§.\:\°(m@{.,`qL/.
mt,{;h\'€> noia \.QJI`S)}C\Q\¢L lné,mt»/

~'c\n°\'\(\j _.+._- _A@pl[¢m£ omth a mm c P
g§ ((,%C.§w..,u_)u LQLC.¢¢~Q Gr~r\;@€>;.o¢.\" or “' :)v\é.¢cl¢¢@ W(l)f'( l:\'\ 115 not O‘
C\\-ruLCQ,QQx*/g/N in nqicu,»rq,, %`s_L pd)e \/., 54;¢`,{;9~/ lur\ poQ.. ;E
§\>\.\r\~§ gulth lhbv\lb»l
KEQ\*€STC’D KELLC/F /_\5 mu@yT .,L'J [,'l/.\@C,,q§ Cof€pu§ bud RE\/b

CA§E 20 ¢z» 70°(-»<`»`7' LD¢~*ULQ-%&&