Court Opinion

ID: 4048810
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:46:46.18858+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:27.977622
License: Public Domain

LLct2-~

                                                                                                            rE\f ~''" ~-)q 2'~1S In\\1JJ
Cou/c7 o?' /.lpp1~/.s _
Sr;v~/d n,,S"?&C-7 ot? 7/i-;c-..a$-
                                                                                                                      oU!I \ "- .d ·
f! Oo &>c- 9:5'10                                                                                               SEVENTH COUR1 OF APPEALS
AmAtLdb, {¥ 7~/o s
                                                                                                                    VIVIAN LONG. CLERK
                                            - 't"'S'Io

        D~k d..to£A~YA£. C/~
                        7        &4-v~n;~s. f!asoAitS PIAL~t?"~ fJI!c> & dctu:!y ~yunr
 fJ/f?'l.mt5.5ttt>V           75          /-fwt,-c....r6        71-Mi        ~k-ma--vr                ;:3;2.1'/UZ       70         hclr..;d
'-n,h£           ~ILNIM                e>l-""       LMI'Y1<.~AI{(7           f0i2..    ~<:_ ~~n:,.y/)_,.141(                 OAf          /P?i:

 k'16c..u~£1 elri''A-SoiVLsj .

                     ·/lh£         0~/J,d...r? J~~                                Jtoft:nt'C()         GS-;A-,345/.k:;.:J        ~..v5<,?J74>V'P(_
  -t?,5 A rs o~               dcA               A    ~-"-SCJY'AJ.6k          .PI'Vt-5cMt     ~IL        /!AvtC: Ar<JCJAJ.                 ~
/7/Je.7S         ,4//PiSILcf"           sf.c4:>        7lv.lr    71-<t::.   ~~-.MJ,4..J'T;             Co-viJuc.-7       Viah:l7~             7/-4£.

.;:;;u/L.?t:t.   /1.-.tt?:)   .;:IU:Jr ;/JMtW-.am~                          Vt()kJ"?~.OV     oi....    /"A.I£    Wr7na           .S"l::I?C.

~f5<< 7.J7/f'.>V.

           (I)                ~         htZ57          _/.Jmn;...ram...t...v-r ~6 ,<.r 76               f?z.,,7~<>V r/4£. t{"ov~m;t_A£7,.
   /Aic/vd~s 1Cv~WLJ7P.t,ts ~,.,., s'7""b'"'j                                         /-1.   A./171~            70   ;.;-/,~(5     ./1-   hc...Sutr.
  ~              JlijOtl.tvA7£tk.r              ol--     \h7.~t..      ~n b-vcc              CPJ      /tlti /.il."C<Jlmn.-;..17 4'/V,;:.v              .4-.t.(J

   bA~Ii:D         lifo'll.I'Y)/i.{}     pJ.uA/71~              ..:Vt7.     ~hl,.a/6 lrr7£~ ~t71f ;,,,7/.17/~./' ~
·z. . ~~ -h::>.::a\~ Ami'EN~Mn"'\ '. -r~ ~~s H--r of" ~~ P~ ~
      lc. Bn:.. '&nc..,..Q;.;: ~,..~. -riJ.M.•'2.. ntD1.&:»..£S
                                                   \            )
                                                                  ~-;;~.J ~bl'o~
                                                                           '-r'  i
                                                                                   ~ c! ~.,s .. , .
     ~~              lb..::..~ N..o\         ~CJUV'V\tN.A"""t"ct:_ ~tM.                   \   N.CAJtc.::VZA~ P~~s. oe.
      ~0I     I     \~ UL'l.A-l.            &c.-.:>VY\cZi0l s       A(~. fl\J)~.V'"'lt~ ~ s.z:~ i2<'L~ ~.Qp ~ s .
   ·~ St'tA-ec.-\.l w~                              U..C~~'-'~le_ ~n:                     L.:>    I&L<L.- 'Sr'2-.t: ot?     ~
    k"='{ ( 1-Jv""t            \<.n'i'~   A-S       ~n:.L S~                  p    Oe.~t...c~ ,.l?~~J. ltlo~
   +~l\             fu.c..>e>St::.b       Il-l-;:     l~t'Wtt~ of? la.h~s J'1Li: k€y , k~~,v~
 ""l"l.IA-r       ~~ 'SIA~~ ~ to! OL Cr-L-r~ I ot='" .All b=t:'t [sj \1-lA-t
   0\vSI:         ~ ~~;iSlii:.. ~M (lJ,.~ ~-c~ Ack..--r ..4-...t. f'l\0~"\. \bii..
 4<~---c.         6,.J    ~ ~C$115& P~e.~h.(                            A-r       At£ -rem..£, S             LAf..-r<. L   ~'l"W~~
To -w..~                 RcLc.c-r . l r     {l.tL~ w~               bu.::rAdt tiJ~(                llS       A     C~£....( ot-

 Cv.sl:{;>tl \{          ~,:l) u E .

                                                                 s~~ 1~-r ~~~A-N
              ·--r~ ~,G                        cl~VYL-1
                                                          1                                                        ltJornll&

 "\lt~L~""'tit~ ~~~\..l'1:16 &~:i\i-cv\t-""M. ~lsW-cs. ll.ht~ t:blt.c.'7 of="
lh,)c~ ~ct:p.4ttl~0l ~                              G.lv'\'\w.4{    '""Ls-tlc..t. 1 ~S:.              --ru     Cc::o IZ.(   ~   y
s~t'lli:JuN~                 Ln.saf._.    Mt£12J,~ j..\--(~ ck:~~t~s s..:,dJ_.

          J: ~~ut~"'""t l'\JA'""'(                       t-.ic     I fuV'Y\-U/'.l.C'"l(          l~t't t:;KAL-tn.tJ to
'Dv::---.l>A-lt. tk-z k-.<M ~tJ1 ..J,o~ \lk..s-tt~
~::n<-r.,;r-r(<)1.J~ ~(sl-i-zs.

                                                                            . II~ SD             M    "7-9 g
                                                                              fJIU;./IJiti 7Y 7'702.2.
           L     &..otJ....rt:;,ct:o:;;    ~su.-.....-..-) fl/.4f-·.r-7;rC,e        A     Sc ~6
                                                                                                         7 a_7,f
 ~       /~,c ~f=?t          0 ;?         -;//;(" ~~so'"'"()              e:vAJ-&     Sell vt'i?vtL   ~    ~tS.cL

-fv"z-   ))~~G""'r.o,oN"7 1~              ~C-a-'tfj           7/-4£     $'..<J;nrt:     ;-r      "7P?C   ~CP'447
frl:L.'!t~/11 ;Jt;57.~K ./?z]OA-.C.-                      .4"-/0   ,.dek£~;5/i"cJ       7o   ~

                         ·-:::row/J-7     Jj;j....{   SA>V1£
                        ,Asso~'7 .4-,~ttl'\fn:/ 44V~.
                           /? o kx            12-Si..t6"'      ~,_Pth.C    5167/.J--r

                                kit'.../ I        f   Y     787/ f'

                                  0/-     -                                2o1S
                                                                             --
                                                                             :='"'-···
     ·~
     .:"~ .
                          '
                          r=
     f!~                  ("i
     ..
     X                    z
                          !1, ·-
                                                                 ~
     ~

     q
     ....!
                          ;tl;
                          .,..,
                          --~                       ~'j.   ~
                                                            I    ·-:~.
     .;..!                d                                N     (')

                                                   ~
     l-1                  N                                        I
     a:                                                     t
     < zJ
                                                                 ""-'
                                            '
                                          {\                      ~
     ~
     ~
                          M
                          ''
                                         '1a....
                                                   t'-J.
                                                    ~      0      ._,
                                                                 \f"'
                          ~
                                                                 I
                                                     ~ w
                          0
                                           0-                      ~
                                   ~     4.              t r
                                                     b; --
i

I
                                   -\)
                                   \~ \.L
                                           Q       /LJ
                                                    $
                                                           L?.
                                                           \()   -
                                                                 J
                                                                      ....

                                                                     -'

                                           ~
                                                                  cl

                                         ~ ~~
f                                                                 <l
                                                                  t.
I                                                          ()
                                                           \f)   <1
                                                                              01
                                                                              r·-
!
t                                                  c/)
l
i'
!                   •·.
                              :·
!             ·,.