Court Opinion

ID: 199928
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2011-02-07 04:40:19+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:06:32.045390
License: Public Domain

United States Court of Appeals
                       For the First Circuit

No. 01-2262

         GEORGE M. WALKER; JERE BECKMAN; JOEL SIGRIST;
                SUSAN M. NEWELL; and LEE SLOCUM,

                      Plaintiffs, Appellants,

                                  v.

           EXETER REGION COOPERATIVE SCHOOL DISTRICT;
            OYSTER RIVER COOPERATIVE SCHOOL DISTRICT;
               JOHN STARK REGIONAL SCHOOL DISTRICT;
                  WINCHESTER SCHOOL DISTRICT; and
         AMHERST-SOUHEGAN COOPERATIVE SCHOOL DISTRICT,

                       Defendants, Appellees.

                                ERRATA

     The opinion of this Court, issued on March 19, 2002, should be

amended as follows.

     On page 11, between line 10 and " Affirmed.", insert the following

two paragraphs:

     In any event, the claim of "impermissible motive" is based on a

misunderstanding. All super-majority requirements "dilute" the votes

of those who would win if a bare majority sufficed.      This is just

another way of saying that the legislature (or Constitution drafter for

that matter, e.g., U.S. Const. art. II, § 2, cl. 2; id. art. V)

believed that the type of action should be attended by special caution
and should by taken only with more support than a simple majority.

Examples include the ratification of treaties, amendments to the

Constitution, and votes to cut off Senate debate.

     So, when New Hampshire adopted and then modified a super majority

requirement for local bond issues, we assume with plaintiffs that its

purpose was to weight voting and affect outcomes. But, contrary to

plaintiffs' assumption, this does not, standing alone, condemn the

measure or invite some form of special scrutiny. See Gordon v. Lance,

403 U.S. at 6-7. Still less does the legislative action taken here--a

reduction in the super-majority requirement (from two-thirds to three-

fifths) for official ballot districts--require special justification.