Court Opinion

ID: 4054445
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 05:24:30.421314+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:45.736036
License: Public Domain

ihis document     contains~i$cument          ·contains     so~e                   ·                   ·-1LD.J {J)10. .~--OLD                         i·
 r~~. r:s itat are of poor .qlB.~i/N that are of P?- r qualtt)f~(Q)''\fll(Q)!M_IQ)IE!M~\Q)~
                                                    0
                                                                                                                 ·leJ)~.·~~--··     ·_u\'oe.·o.. U!i\U. "'
                                                               ~~liE~==                                           nu;;.~VtbU v                    nQ~
                                                                                                                                  \E.

 at the trme of imaging. . the time of imagmg.                              .U":O..D""'   !:::':)=                                                      ..
                                                 fZv           ~  ~V:                                       (COURT Of CRIMIN~~APP~~
.• 'Ta                    ~f'\-o~ )~ I'"Yltt.y_CD'lLC?~r).L...                                                             APR212015·.
               .          -~ ~ J1~c< ~ e t·s L't/1'1_~-r' (lD ve'f!'J:D,~Goo~,CI@fk
        -.,....---·· --'--;.:#:. I 6 ? ·7 ·tj:J-s-; !:"- t, a. ~ e b e e ~< b e /\ 'e_ ·A..• · · ·. · ·· .
        ~--..:::__:~=-~ ~g 1't 1ed_·h t:::t c l< 4 a TI'C< .,. . 1-> .c_ 0, cf &·;r.. ·
                         a/\ e_uJc!.Jer\_J:)ar-r ~ect.~" 1 -:y?~_                          ~~-.      rY1                                 ---
                           0 r:' il ~ 1d ~ :J ~_e.. ± /' ~e.. i-t qs ~ \c- P f"'"' ~d d reJ ~'\
                   .f." e..-. C' oy_ ,--f- D rf_ e~' r ~ }~q/ ~et:'<?o Ls·                                      ·o r-1..r:lcA
                    .-f b        ~,·C<_ ;./. e_ JJ~ ~ ~.$ 0 e ~') ,f_g ,ra,rjec)                     h '::/--     rf h e                      .
        __Q U}" Jc.+.               e:_.o c.. r-f o2 q ~~ & r~ e_r- £ o ~ f (e. rfe_c}
                      t> r Ad' fb t&:-/eEJ:.-,.               r
                                                   t, q v e_ 111                      o+.
                                                                 b e..e" /J ad fd-' te..d
                      6   d       ot ., .                                          +
                                 e.,k_:l-_e '!1.S / o """' e cf_ J ~ e. ·~-J kq.-f. ·#It__
                      +I,  tZ Co ~ ~"'i D ci L,. f "" t nct, l ,.q f!fecl Is Cdf "'-
  - · · .-·_·___0~·._n_f~ ~-o r J e r--'1 T' h ~ 12 1sd- r .·(__ ·+- c i; ~ r-+ Q.. q9-5
·       ·        l'?t £eJ ;;J 1- 5 ~~-11 •..-v1 v ~ f_ .t" )o ~ . c.~ o I J ·~ 1, d__/l c1.. tL~-
         _ _ _ ,().j_.:r~~ con.,...<:J-,;\}-J()"'!C(I~ tJ n.~t.Jl--tl~ +~
                . .-j-·lrt_c_ {e.SJ·o,;_ o-~d('\.(C.. / ~ '11 'Y_f2ou/nle
         _ _ _--=-0-~_cr--=--Pq 'I!_t C- b.l 'V7\. U2 L!5 ~"'~ d- :l.CZ_C( ~'-:=-$~_.·_ _
        -~---=d r~Jf_~ ~c (cJ~or ~, ~~c_(~~-ed__~£-cf,-et1C~
                          Cf·\..~ vq~('/~~ ~."+t-rr- de~~~~ tld-CZ( P~e r~cr'.5'S
        ___ u_S_v_(~ I      a·"'t2 ~C'/v'.         f)r""'
                                             ,+~e_ CDe-,rrl- 4),                      +                                                   ct: ,
          _ C.rL~t"cvLLif!-~ectLr\J.o ·K~u~ r/,~1-..r···
            :o.~ C.~ rrCA-f                                 ['+
                                q+ ~ ~e_. d._ 2_/ / V & /{e ~ Cu .r-/0.-
                          c:A- ro-"C[;l dE c JI /.J_~                      ~"' J· d a Kc_ "h t ~" c~
        ___...:::>_. v !d ic P1 L-« ~-C<+ f .1 "e_ ~ t ' \
                              _e____::.rti:_ P                              ·
    ~---J±                  __
               ·_.p I.JlJ P1 U~{[i: ; J~ d , 1.2 )"-~l_[ c£qf3C:-Y ·
                              l....---=e__""""".

  •      q. dJ-er-. Cc."' (./ Jr::-t J6 ~ J) __ , ·- DC.- -/6 -J.. d ~ 1C(.2. -.
         2 bs""-ise:c_ 12.+~ od. m"lre.J, o~ /"'\~ '1- ~-o.,Jl?
·-----~--~------~------~
   cJ(:so fJ·-I·-.PC-/to~~o2.qq_:J dJss~ls~<2 a-.._~~
                                         ·r"
   ~--'":r-=-·C4. "- (b -(- L.... :;>_e) I , ·-     e ~ s J_~ u ct. l d. A a_~ ~- b e/efl.__:___ _
          ci   Js .J Jf'l1,1)J~ ~b__r__ J 0-"C?_ d- "-e. ~ L2 X./\ d JJJ'Y1 e:~.+                    .
         _e:>J       {2- r- Q c__-t o -q o .<.foq_~~~ 1'~-- /J r.J -~ ~ ¢fJ c ij~-v-q
        -                                           ·+
              ry,-[J'J ca,r;f'Jc(~e C() J- ~5 cc_e q:l.J D£1./·, c:o,. "'··r-J ;~
                '                . .              I '
                                                ,+: r'            r ;.· ,
            _ tr~ ~ Ja -<o. ( (Sf-. e~ s v cr- ·e.. CL /! ~ · ,cr-_f, .r:aL~e
                                                                             -~ . . .
                                                                                                 -·
          '                                       a
                ~-- L fl ±q_L{_ro b l e,n.,~l'- 1.,2 q ,., ' D /:_y Ie:. ~ /c. bq-:r
          1-'-vt.J.-~- ·+'-<- C:C(f_4C /~ Y- +o f<t--"- a~_., ~-...~ ({ J.J_&l_'_·_
          ·
          qd-rfo;JQ.d ·b'Y-----J~X-'{3 ctf\e\ ±f-._~ (d__1'1 lie<{_ .
  _ _··-=--5~s D f!P-gfj_-r'V'I.er-,Ccq .. A--lL o& 1_~, rs t S ~ ~
             ~- '1-J, ·+ll  c\ o 4A..... l ·~ i-, +L ~- ('_ '\S ct /~dtv~ o. rf:
                                                           0

•                                       s
         . f-" e {/( "' I I d-. e.,! 1-q-kJ' ,D d- !4 .¥)~ r rL a~'5.:'1-L
  ~-_-T---'-_-=e_-f-gJ_• T h,v~~e_ bc:erv:::6'\<-v'c..de~ iUda11~ _
    ___--       __L_P~.'"=-~~6e:.- lie:lf___kccf;;'"'~ ;;·o~ J>e~. y·ovr"                                .
               -. I<"--( l~ <!>#'"\ P-"t i= {_Ito 2 -/'.\"ld -~""/'( c 5 ~ ci- cq 1\
               .-. dicxf~J ~+_s·e_,(J_ ~9ctlli"\.s+-d-""-<: ·'tyCEr:__Ly_ -
                   ~sJ A 0         +
                             ~~, :Ctr~y·~ -~,.-_ A-f}V\._-+; td- +~
    --'-----------':± UY     /.7   ~ --~q_d {~ dr£~r-e_ Ll~+.e-d_--___---

                                                                                     '   -: .·   .
               (_e-tc.{] (_   Y1   tJ    I   Q-~ J-P (__ -          I t1) ~    1 () 4 Cl cu-I
· 3 ~ +~ oJ- ·-r-eruf                                                         e_o'\_,_J-    ~ J-&-l·""tA l~.r
             ·t/                                                                A f> Peal..s~, p () l> cl xj
  Lee rvtu.r ( 0 ve'tr                                                           I J..-J 0 t? CqpiJ.. o{. odetdl Qc I'\
                                                                               . ;1q~.+r'l rr' x· 7 t ?-·II - ·
                                   (Vl       o+J OA cf (.) ,_ (\ e                     ~J   T'" IC{ 't
   ytoe,.v LCY'l.cJ CifpiJcetl'+ L_q~C(r- L. oil&£[!# fc0<;{/~.55
  W ~l':J ~"~C( u <J~ C!1 11e(A.) ·+/,Jq l q fo.l'\ 11 e_U/ ( y d JScoc-ef'cl
  e.v/Jf:e.~/\.L~ rtcf-ter··+f'fa/ Cf.'12co~&Jcd-/oY) ~re_
  Qr"f.:..J'L~e;;c./ d_;_ss.r.-, )~q__(; ·+~·+ LJ~rE!._ e(sc:2 ·+<) co~v~
   "( ffe f { q 1+ a·+ ·i-~'1 cr /., 0 .-f ·-DC --tiJ -- ;J_o d-.qq;;_ cA./C(~·'.
       "-                                         .    .

    d Y5~}~C£:! 61 J+cf'C'o"lv~~dlo~< DV) /Yl.ctt-o~" Mt:ly CJA
     Q o q1. ~t ~ e Cq_q,S c: (j- {" 0 C "l cJ ~ d 'l o q·t:; (J ct I' C. I "'J tcf--.-
     tvte,(\'d- cf'ro'Y'fJ . . j) ,_1·-0 C-/o~ od...qqJ,; 4-fJ'o O --1--- P e.- ltJ
   -   ~0 ~ q 13 ~ c. Cl '\. .~J~ t!.u (.fS d )30 ts c2 a ~ I ,- r;; -It"·
                                   (!.                                         r)1

             f 'tc~e_ ~_,.(tJ 0( l.s'(S) C-(,j e_d_ { '(_ ·+ r:.... e L_       .t-fJCJ•\_ 4)J:
                                                                                            D '( U

     o. f f I .lc_q ., -7-; ft S o r ;·, f._lq ·flo~ J.~ c~ ~ M .l.+- Ccr.. p 1-J o I
     -~w.<i e,_ ·t~q_·+- tAictJ J/!J.5 ~ /y<::_2 & " ? .,_d. tt,..... II Ccrct~c..
       f I'! o . D _, . . . o c..- t 0 r-.3o tq·~q .. 1: I; '=41"l\ 6 / l t.;· to· l< ·:1-~ c:.
            Lot:.,"'-•1::_ 0 ~ C     r- '"'""' l>'\,:,_ ( ;4-p.f't:..PL)J          ·tO fj r'ct,.-YJ_:~ 6t ·11~4..-­
       .T      0\ov(.,

                                             p rc{,y· e ..--                       .                                 .
                   J       Ptq.y tt-,..>t+<J~~ C:<>"'"~ tnJ' Crl~ lvz)
                f+ .P fQa Is 9 ""or. "\. +s q_ b o ""1!1- or pf l 1< cvf i" " a 1. c1
               . tl ~:.-v e.-u e. Cl '\ Cl II) e "" """ cis ,[) - ' -.o c- r o ~ Cf "' ¥ o <f y
                 ·-1- 0 ·T r lq I Lo vv- J- ,4- #"')1 c "-··
                                                           . _,<,, fc;,J.....,,Of:;T!~,·
                                                                     J ...,     ... L.~              ·~:p.'(~.   .

                                                      ··t~.rf.~.
                                                      ·.. · ..... ,._!" a . ..,.u
                                                                              ~-
                 I    A- /V\.l{   d-~. ·:P e- G.. f'vt. ('- c1J r c1     -.....

 .r de.dcv-e 41\Jcr f'~'(\.e_r.+ r ocf- Pcr-6VV'i J~+ ·
s Ct j J       I(.} p ('   t Lt:tcf.lP""-   D ,.._ fV1 0 ...}. I 0 ' \   fs '\ f'C.-1. ~ q,~
          d-bt «( I.
  ,(f'     •
 cJct.G

                                                                                  .   '--
.'                                    Grand JUI)   VL02010 P0122

     D.A. #01 DC10202992/ MNI #1738n0 ........... ~.:,~ ......................299th

     No. IH 0 c t D;J. O:J..1"1:1. ·        The State ofTaxas v. Lamar Lovett

                                            INtiiCTMENT

         Aggnvated Assault- Bodily Injury With Deadly Weapoo F2 ll.Ol.l.a

     Bond$

     In The 299th Judicial Olsirtct Court ofTravts County, Texas

     IN THE NAME AND BY THE AUTHORITY OF THE STATE OF TEXAS:

     THE GRAND JURY, for the County of Travis. .State of Texas. duly selected,

     empanelled, swom, charged, arid organized as such at the January, 2010 Tenn.

     A.D., of the 299th Judicial District Court for said County, upon Its oath presents In

     and to said Court at said tenn, that Lamar Lowtt, on or· about the 23rd day of

     May, 2010 •. and ~ the presel'ltment of                this   Indictment, In the County of

     Travis, and State of Texas, did then and there Intentionally, knowingly, or

     recklessly cause bodily injury to Phyllis Schwartz by grabbing Phyllis Schwartz

     with Defendant's hallds on or about Phyllis Schwartz"& neck, and the said Lamar
     I

     Lovatt did then and there use or exhibit a deadly. weapon, to-wit: a hand, during

     the commission of said assault,
                                                                               FRed In The District Court
                                                                                 of Travis County, Texae      .
                                                                                      JUL H    201)      .

               t.·
                                                                               Amlla
                                                                               At Rodrlguaz-~         Clart

                                                                                                                  000090
                                                                                 ........lt.;'iC!f·fti•z                                   .'_:~-.~:u:(-i;{:> ·
                                                                                                                                               ,.     -:".:~:,;   :;__:·:L:·!.-·:· .
                                                                                                                                                . :: ~·:·, ~ . '        :.      ;   ·:. .
                                                                                                                                            .........
                                                                                                                                             '··-:-.:~.-~:;;·: ...\
                                                                                                                                               _: . . ,:.;.~::-:...::~ :
                                                                                                                                                        ,1,..      , ......... .

                                                                                                                                                    •...    ·.·;·;.
                                                                                                                                                    :__ :.?':··... ·

                                                                                 ....    ::.::···
                                             =:.                         . !··                                                      '·

                                        .·•·~~JRIINI k>'aiot~'~.~~.;~.ti.;•
         ·t·f: ·· :.... 1tieoc.111111ilsfc~.·~or·.Uid . . . that Lamar~~
                                                                    r .· . dki.tliiift
                                                                            .            . . ...:.·~\~~./~)~~
                                                                                      .·...                         :;.·
                                                                                                  . ...., -- .., ...~,,
          '                            w~bi~IJMMrl<NBifaH·:                             .:               ·.                    ,; ,        ·.·~:.
                                                                           C>                                      ·~ . --~-~-~-.t~.-
           t·        ••.                                                . f:·. ·· ...                    :    ~·
                                                                                                                         :;{.·.
        :q_.,
          i!-:
                                                          COUNTU ·
                                                                          I.., . .                  . . <. ·             .     ~
                                                                                                                               ;').
                                                                                                                                   ·i· .

         v
        . ~ --~:
                                  ArHm•II;S.iJNid.~..-llltot ~:r
                                                             ~·P.: • ·li:lM~ L-1(
                                                                 J:r~·s~··?
                                                                                                                         · c-:t . . ··                                          _   .. ·    .

        :.;·
          "J ••
                                                                                                                                                                         '.•,
                                                                                                                                                                        ·-·.:·:

                                       ~<!H~ ..-1- .,,~· tlllll ~·                                                                 ,.      . . ·.~:
                                       ~~ ~ ~ -~p~..-~1!!;-..                                                             ·.
                     \ ':·

                             ,:   .,

                                                                                                         ·: ·r

\
    \
                                          . . :p:::r,';·                                     .,..,.,_....
                                                 •'      .:.'·
                                                                                                                                                ·.+        ··-   .
                                                                                                                                       .'.   :~ ·,   :_   .·.
                                                                            •,'
                                                                                   . ·..

 ·<_;),·, ·;:_ .

• ,;;:f);;,n·                       Ce!UaiiJ:
)~i~",·;               J. · . .                              Al...l\1!.l·S•all~41!•11llt.                                                                                                    .... . . •. . ~-: ..

                       . ·-.

                                                                                                                                                                                       . .    ·;- ·.

                                                           '-'V11111~·!h;~"*\" l1euld ~~~<D#,iJ                                                                          :
                                                                 -Nin't_.,~~na~Aua.tt(~·; ... ~~lfl'2U2tPX                                                                              ..

                                                                  ·~~--------~~~itP1arJ ·',· · · ~
                                                                                                                                                                                                             ...

                                                                   .·. ,YH~OF.
  :;·'·•
                       0   .f                                                                                                                                            I:;...
                           ,i ..
                           'i.                                                                                                                                          ~~
           '.   ,_;   ~.
                           ' ·:
                           ~
                                                                          . ~capn.t                                                                                      !!"            ·...
                                                                       1at loa CGjmty of Tnwia,                                cil T.;.; illiiy                      aaiai,; . ·. .·
                                   .....··,...lid--~~-~. and organized •                                                  . at.thlt July•.Jt10                         ~~~:~          ·;·'''

                                          otti!1184MJHSJ~.DIIIrtctCourtforaaid·+· ~··                                                                                    ; >:     '
                                                                                                            .       i           '
                                                                                                                    II,
                                                                                                                    ;
                                                                                                                  . 1-

                                      ' : ..
                                      ~
                                               :,   ..                 -::: :...     .· .. : ./.                ... {. .•..   ·>/:~;r;_;,~~:,:i·::. :··~-'-=
                                                                                                                                                      ~
.   ;

                                                                                                    ;_, ·..·.\.; \! ~....·_. )(< ..•. ·
                                                                                                                            ..
                                                                                                                                           I. .t·)··r·.
                                                                                                                                                . . ·-··->to 0""• . ._.,
                                                                                                                                                                     :::.:::...
                                                                                                                                                                                ,
                                                                                       Cauu No.

              THE STATE OF TEXAS                                                                                                          IN.THE 299th                        Judicial District
                                     vs.                                                                                                  COURT
               !
              ~._ .. ~:;· f\>'') (.J. /~
                                                                                                                                                                                    Travis           COUNTY, TEXAS

                                                                                          MOTION TO DISMISS

        TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COURT:

            NOW COMES the State of Texas by and through her Atto~ney, and respectfully requests the Court to dis-·

        miss the above entitled and numbered criminal action Jn which the defendant is charged with the offense of
        ----------~~~\-~.+·:~~-:~;_._.t~-_r___:~·~)____;~}-~-~~~~--/~A~.,~J~l~r_-______________________________ ,forther~n:
                                      .       ;   ·.. !

            c:::J The evidence is insufficient ;
            c:J        The defendant was convicted in another cue;
            c::J       The. complaining witness has requested dismissal;
            I...,.(_ I The case has been refiled:               ·
            c:J The defendant .Is. unapprehended i
            CJ The defendant is deceased:
            c::::J The defendant has been granted immunity in light of his testimony;
            c:::::J Other ;
    and for cause would show the Courc the following:

                                                                                                                                                                                                                  l
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  1

            WHEREFORE, it is prayed that the above entitled and numbered cause be dismissed.

                                                                                                         Respectfully submitted

                                                                                                                           ,·;
                                                                                                                          !,
                                                                                                                                                            /<
                                                                                                         _..;1..:..'/___________________.;._ _ _ Attorney

                                                                                                  . ORDER
                        ~                                                                                                                              ~                                  r~1
           The .foregoing motion havinl' been presented to me on this the .                                                                                           day of               \' / .. /\,....   •/

    A.D. 20_)_{.., and the same having been considered, it Ia, thel"efore, ORDERED, ADJUDGED and DECREED

    that said above entitled nnd numbel'ed cause be and the aame ia hereby dismiaaed•

                                                                                                                     .J;·~~:i:: :.~!.: .~.·~~~::~~2._~:~. ~-
                                                                                                                                                                                    (';
                                                                   i                                     .Judp of t h e - - - - ' - - - - - - - - - -
                                          :       .   '            :
                                                      !t.          \   '
                                                                   I ;,I
                                          i                        I;                                    Court o f - - - - - - - - - - - - County, Texas
                                                                           ..___ ...

                                                          Original-White; Defendant's Copy-Yellow; State'!J Copy-Pink