Court Opinion

ID: 4063447
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 20:54:49.279381+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:58.026564
License: Public Domain

33 ‘ZHS ’HU

 

 

 

 

 

 

rrd TH£, Cou/€r‘ _0F_ C__&rmrrd£t___ §@EWE.JAM___ __
AEE.>_A.LS_o F__T_'&>.r'r GF @drrrrr Nrd_rd>r>zr\r_d
d 4 4 - ' dUL 23 2015
_£_>_<_PAQT&, ` 4 l ‘ . ~ ‘r_d&r:rAmd‘_s;,QB_@_W<__ __
__GA&{LAMD_r_Ad/\o.d£_él)w/A'gl)_s_______rd_\_o_-$§z_l_'l_~_\/_¢A_)__-_

 

___F_\Pr:r_r.cradr_`s_ &2_390dse._rrd_o_€eo§mod/_&zbmrdL.To.______
TR¢.A.L_co_d&Tfs__Erd,r>_r'rd_&s_o_E_EA_cr’;/_¢od_c_d$_r_ods40F_L~e._@____

 

 

__rrdr_FF__¢mrr__ As_s_r_smdc_a. or=_ t‘_odrr.szr.__mrar__ ' __

 

' _Q)_ _'Erdr_s_ _rrd&m:z/L Eo& ApPr_rc_aur__ A&&L&§_T_HAT _TH&_ cr rw______

_CA$€,$__!M_TJAL `L‘KlAL Qou&T_‘S_ Errdlsrrd(z$_ Er.rd.ls Codcr_u_S/ord_s___
_\s_ RLLr_\/AdT_c‘_As¢ r,r_\rd_ Howa\/&r<,_]:rr_¢s¢ cr\_sas r\r<;_
__rdo_r_odcded eRL\/Arr_rd@ dorard; odd _:r:o THL_Rr_\/rsrord/
_Ar_/\_ard Q__er::r`_o Pr&'r:r u_z,_\___®_§_ 1_C&_l_§o_\_d/o&_ __rdd_c)rd&,_,_rdd“ TH___B
__LOIU;T?_&_ rdOR,_ A?PLILArd_T_l/_d_au_t»_f>_t,\fé_& ABArd_o_o_u A__»d`{_ Sr/_CH___
_-Eercr_$ _’(w€r__ ergz__ 5,0£€0&<\'_&_0__ &j_:T_ héf_r &rerr_ &L_co_go_or:c _
__err_d:z_d:'r:rr_eg _5:`ch_ Ru_or_: d o_w~r"ri'r)asszs_ rg)_a_r:c;_r\§<_e_r)_r_\T_mz____
_Pddrsrrr/\errr r>rrr=rs'r_ “» rF» 'Trr w ‘_Tr'r odcd_rr__'r_rdc_r &_r "z_s_r”_r m;od_v_.____
rdodc_r> Hr>rdz_ mr>roz_ A _QrFFr_randc_e_ HA;> THr_z/_ B_&z,d_ PR&S:rJT__
nrdo adm 0_drcr Ar>£_r__r_cr.dd‘__‘_s __Gdr_L_r_/ rddo_c_c_)_c_z__r>m\_sa
09 Tk_d AL_ _ __

_Rz ~ vrr 1__3_,_2+ _P_c~_,_.:r_d_r_r___r_'_dr_s_\_z_»_ao__\r_/_r_cr.rdrdz_r>_s_f‘-__
PQ\ __:r_rr r__rrds_s _l"t ar “‘So_r:\r§\-o T_ Qr>ru_ap \ro_d_ader_r;a_&____
____:\”_o _`:\'£_S_T\r_-'_v_,_d_od_ rr_d_c)ur_r> HAVL_HALTQ_&) mdz_sr“_ darrd__ro_d_ l_:l;_ H_Ar>_ A§_r _Prsr vr)d rrrr>rr )
g;, \/dr__°>,p+z 96_;r5)_ r_rrdr_s '7 FI `Tr>r_c_r< wrdm_o_<,'
Pcr zqu r_rrd`r_s l€r` 90 540 _§ro_d __r,d_dd_r.drd_‘”_ Hedrr_ dam

_P_<_E)L_L_ :[`_0 4b3_TlF`14/ABOUT _AI\H OF 'THf_ PAC|:S NZ ’~l`H£,_ CA$_£_

_‘___ __

Rdd`vrT 7 (A(\Ar_d_l_:ldL__ABQr/_L_Qd;_s_nod15 rmPc_r__ao_\___

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

RLC \/`07_3_ Pr,_?_ PCr_. _vd_s r_rrdz_s 5~'7 °`7”Ar>,rrrrr\` Ro_d_L:/_f" _
_£cr_s__;;_l_rr_:§_;rr.:z; r_r-rdr_s _'dr »55_`4`_¢7_rd_0_5_0_,_rr;_:r;_u400________
_07;_ 007__1_00 _\_1_0__0 IO_I&:rE~r_ r_r_d__r'~_’aord“r`_dr~'r>r:.r'rdr:r_ L_r:r:r_e__ wardrare__\rou_[rm\rr_]_rdour_o HA\rr,_:r?d_____
_Crr_dz_§)_ __l _Ec\ __\_7_7)_80_771_07%00_ 05017_777A7_0d0_ SA§/___
rdHAT_ \rod_sr\ro_,_fdrcdrr__'?__(Ac\Ard,_/mz _r<)_e_~r_ rs________
_rd_07 _PR05_007_,_77_+_05 Radrrg_r)r_z_s_s 071 Trr-¢_rg_ 7105€0_)_5_2__
_OR___T_z__$_"r_l_mord&l_l_r_\_5__r_m_Bo_$S_@L_i»_‘_lb_é\50&9_7574rd_r_7.0_r_)_
777 rs rdodu> HA_\/_r,_er_r:r=_z_¢f&b_:nda_:r?dg§r_'§ dwmr’; _ 4
_EUR'UFLQ M§_'rrdr@>r'i`rm Rordi_\_r_ wm_ P&t_&o_rri_Du&rd_é\__ _
_fr+¢_<'rru\_LT_/_rrdrdo udcz_ mrs 0_@07_5770_ rdas_rdd r_____ _
. _c_r>rr_r_r_r>_ dprrdd _

 

 

 

 

 

_P_C\_ _;_§u t_rda5 ll |L_r " Ardo rF \/o_u_HAo_T_cs_T_i_E_r_£,D_¢/ergg_a_l:d___
~ _r_rd_P_I;dr)T_or=_A_J_”r);&zr_ou&rd_/`_o_u_rd_o_t)_r_0__HA_\/0__H.AD_To__B_z__H-odz_<;T__f_|_l;L_\rau___
__7057:_0)500_»,_75_77707_/_<7577_7_?__£H_ag0100___\:r`_r_s_r_mrzom_d:__
_I0_rd07fz__'r?derT_r_¢_\S_.__Ad6_r_r_/_\__B_M;rdfr_r_L_rr)r\s AL_§o_erzszrd-r' 4
_‘D_r)fr§_z_)_k\ 002_£_\15&_57+_0__7?0_0_55_054907_000_0_0€00_)_

 

 

 

_C:Z_)_ _IHLTR\AL _c_ouk_*r*s_ Erd0rd_5 Ard_r>_ cdrdu_u_srords dE_ r_r>rr_d___
_0._5_ wgr_c_ 755sz 5'"7¥7€_5_&0590\)50 %&00777A7 T_Ha_r

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

4755055_ 9551791)705' 700757175 Mrs_uwr>u_c:r` 000 70909 - ` “
117755000057' 1_\95 00557> 0~7 711-5 91_-__1_090 5177_417447<44 117111 7
__T1745"_500@_01>710177_5005H_ 50;9_7175_570909544540_’171\7_____ _
___T1745‘47_5001__0_501\7775705 D_57_70590710rd5 "__-7175_:747§17_05___ 4
955090 959555'7` 5 \£40_7__?)_,_90_7£1_3__519755 7?7_: 78 __ _
_101<07_.,_7;0_7_95_._77;7_5_50051771075_;_045_97_2.217_75_9707:___ _
_17_595_,__77:45170_050_05_740_0_54550d.0_4j0590_095_09109____l 44
___m1_75177411_5_0014)17_77115_1_7.1155_._00_0‘_7_71459_1100017115__ ____ 4
_(',0,51_44 ArdD 05 0557< 17595_9500_‘1__7_ _60_07;_ 3500_0'_57_057<_.'__
7 174_55 1055 109_7145_ 7097__17175_5 09~7_ 551;1_7115 40097 4-_4___ 4
_95017`:7 71+75_rd0_5_117 1\11907<7@17725~/ 77 30__~/77: 35 A 144
. __74740454 _7:17 5_79717_5_500915__1rrd7>rr755:117r747 7171_ 50051__4__444
0005111 7_0rdc4174 9097745 ~’:7”09095 50 717147 7111\1 ` 44
50050_50rdf'rd05_057_7 0_591747:7 010_5__75_ 1_\ _690554_1/775_~___
__571_\47450\_51\77”_”[7<107__B_090_5945__'I0047_€7405._47\_/4\7.5450000457__._______
__._'73:1'_~71_745`_:\§97147__ 50057_740 715 717 rd0rrd<=5__05) 0_504r4d_4~______
__(`,5775`\_07_\75__049 L_l>rw 4 , _4 4
_’7`|~75_:7:0_1_5~1__0740 5707_57097_ 0557059147@.47_5 U,d;174_r__4__4_ 44
70575 01155 50rd04 555 \/01_3 912 90_ 7495:_4 4_4_
570507_ 7_77_ 761 “ 1455 9755 7109"‘115:77)971_(709~4 45__0:1_
__’_7]75__ 507)KF 9001/\\
9550000_74)11571159_7745_50091_[7)70109 074_0 rd__~@ r__cdd ~_-___4_
_D\_Tle_H_l45_90.95177455_07:_5004574_.01757175009095_95770¢97570___ 4

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

h P¢\eruua 0¢1<1)10” 1»_<. 11<11:_¢2\/¢1»\1* '-~ "11=' 111_

l10'rb.~1“110_11¢\u¢1 0&_1_<11_011_)110<\1_§/ OFFS_&_$ aooFags 0&

' __1_\§&:_:_3__10_@1~111&_010 gum?aa&_.___ __1_110_\1_ 15a1101_151:1:_____

__A$__CQN_S_LQLKATD-QKL_Eo.&;U_-a-_&&_a_\_mMs_t>z,a1_s_1__o_u_,__
__\Loiz_,_ emma mngT1o~_,_oa_mHea _‘a>umsa _01_1_

 

 

___GFFlama_Dlsaaa:Uo~_. .._,.__11;1_1=_\__1110__1a11_\1_1'>1’\/>11>1\_/1110-_____

 

_1$_1’1;5‘1“_ 1 _\La__PaoauQ 1_1_\16_ _ _.,

 

 

11111::1?111/_1111111;11111:_1)_0_23_1)_01_6;.3@1&1:1§11111:£11;_5:21<1?1____

____1>_1L_10;011;D1SaLos_'?___'_r_H_z__a\[_1-1>a1_1aa__'[1_1.g?1‘_i1i1:1.a_£0_1v_\_1?11g1_1161,11;__

._H;L\D_ A$_SeaTaa_$Ha was_§_&>_cugu_v_%u_s &1>_13>¢12110111"1112 __ . _

 

_"|J:l&:r&ma aaaoab_.\$_auga 11161_._'1111_ _STN a 1<101;,119_0£.____ -

_TH)§_E>_L)_’__Eg1uc)__1_0__BR1.0C\_'1_‘0_:1`112. 110_1/_2,3>1_16¢171011)AL1____
_:[&h__w_mmaa:1."2_61.01.106.;12`0~2&01>.1)1..2,_Co11111¢:1_0_1_0__0.&

 

__AaQ_u_1__'1:m_a__;$_zz__wa_1;r__giraj€6 _s;_:~_§i_._EQaTH_aa_w&m _
_Ml\_wm_-g'_'\:r_zm€laD:[b_f§e<_1_5_2___'.[11_15_19<1__’1_11£__91110_15.11_1_/1_£0_1'_ _

___111__.1»_11215.__1_1>1;_”11§11_¢;:&1;__13>§1:__’1?&1111__;1>11115.21, 1001 "‘1“0 60

 

__:1’_11_@1_§1,___/1_11aa_a\§o_aa__@»_e:e_w_s__s:g:a_gs_wzu_gs____‘__

 

» __Tw_ga___C_é)_u_g)_§a;_w_£,(aa_gwgaa,_

 

 

___LB_.__M_G__AEE_1_1>A\1_1I_EK011_/\_E0_6MLK.;31)1).£~1a__M_IL_HA.$_l__SN_1_€a;S___ _

 

________1;@.'&,-1‘21Qe_augra_aa>msaai 1T 13,_1§;;1~121,,/_61)_1_111.11”.ll_,l.._.ak

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_”_111.._1?1§1_1_11_:1013<0_ 1010-1310 0101132_3 1130 1001<0_001)
___131013 _:1'1113?_ 13013.01_0 1301§000_&a_ _|:£0111_1210_10111.313 111311.013
__':1_”<3 m1311>0$1:1:101_0 /_ auc)f_T/-xa_ To____
_'[Ha_\ac_Aa__a@ua10_1§1_10011003_131013_ a130_aa'001 13_/00 _0`1_=_1____ _

____a131,_1__

 

 

Rz_l$fimaaq __ _

 

 

 

. - ' , __ ' 63 311131013_1_13m_ 0300100_171,‘111¢1¢1

‘ ' . 1 PQLUMSI;~_I 111011_` ' .
%?Q~_E M-. 2350 __3_01):1`1»1 ' 1_ __
1101100\31010 7203_'7735 1______ ____

C,ZRT1Y-1an'1`z__01= _Siéau_La_'a ___'

_ ___T;_,_(\AVLA@ Lemom_émém§_ _00_0_17(0383_‘1_13_“1:?3?_01013&2__
PwaL”_g__oE__Paajc)av "131\T_/3aa_j1110<13 60010110013_ 1_1_00_11_3___ _ _
l' ___P_rai__j`aua_ga)b__a_@a¢lzc'r _

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

§lwwaé.______
' _ ‘ 03~1111013__1.1_\11001_£1)01005_1?11_,‘13111
’ _ § 000 5010/011 ~ _ if