Court Opinion

ID: 9410310
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2023-07-20 20:00:40.432795+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T17:20:56.648353
License: Public Domain

United States Court of Appeals
                     For the First Circuit

No. 21-1739

  JANET VAZQUEZ-VELAZQUEZ; RAMON A. DEL VALLE-LOPEZ; CONJUGAL
PARTNERSHIP DEL VALLE-VAZQUEZ; CARLOS R. CESPEDES-GOMEZ; JOCELYN
   CALO-BIRRIEL; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP CESPEDES-CALO; SAUL O.
ALMEDA-CRUZ; JUDITH NIEVES-RIVERA; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP ALMEDA-
 NIEVES; FRANCISCO M. ALVARADO-BARRIOS; MARILYN ALVAREZ-RIVERA;
 CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP ALVARADO-ALVAREZ; JUAN C. ARROYO-RAMIREZ;
  DAMARIS VELEZ-RIOS; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP ARROYO-VELEZ; JOAN
  ARROYO-TORRES; JOSE R. HUERTAS-DIAZ; MARIA I. AYALA-RIVERA;
   CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP HUERTAS-AYALA; JUAN O. BADILLO-VELEZ;
 AUDREY CHICO-GARCIA; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP BADILLO-CHICO; JULIO
BAEZ-ROMERO; ISRAEL CANCEL-HIDALGO; YAMELIA M. QUINTANA-LATORRE;
    CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP CANCEL-QUINTANA;ANGEL L. CARABALLO-
    IRIZARRY; ALEIDA OQUENDO-HERNANDEZ; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP
 CARABALLO-OQUENDO; AXEL CARRASQUILLO-CUEVAS; ANGEL L. CORA-DE-
 JESUS; EILEEN LARRACUENTE-ROSARIO; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP CORA-
   LARRACUENTE; SAMUEL CORCHADO-RODRIGUEZ; WANDA L. FIGUEROA-
    BARRETO; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP CORCHADO-FIGUEROA; YARITZA
CORDERO-BONILLA; JOEL BONET-TORRES; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP BONET-
 CORDERO; LUIS F. CRUZ-ROSA; YARELIS ESTALA-OLIVERAS; CONJUGAL
 PARTNERSHIP CRUZ-ESTALA; EDUARDO W. DA SILVA-OLIVEROS; CLAUDIA
   L. ANTUNEZ-DE MAYOLO LOJAS; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP DA-SILVA-
 ANTUNEZ; VIVIAN L. DE JESUS-RIVERA; EDIBERTO RODRIGUEZ-NEGRON;
   CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP RODRIGUEZ-DE-JESUS; MORAIMA FIGUEROA-
    MORALES; EDDIE W. PACHECO-SANTIAGO; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP
  PACHECO-FIGUEROA; JOSE A. GARCIA-MARRERO; JOSE B. GONZALEZ-
  VELEZ; LOURDES SOTO-SANTIAGO; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP GONZALEZ-
SOTO; ENRIQUE M. GONZALEZ-VIRUET; KEILA Y. PELLOT-DIAZ; CONJUGAL
PARTNERSHIP GONZALEZ-PELLOT; GILBERTO HERNANDEZ-CAJIGAS; YAZMIN
  MUNOZ-GALLOZA; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP HERNANDEZ-MUNOZ; DARYMAR
 HERNANDEZ-GINES; JISELA JIRAU-ADAMES; WILTHER A. AVILES-LOPEZ;
 CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP AVILES-JIRAU; JESSIE JUSINO-LUGO; MARIBEL
CLASS-DELGADO; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP JUSINO-CLASS; SANDRA LISBOA-
 GONZALEZ; DENNISSE LUCIANO-COLLAZO; RICHARD CABAN-RUIZ; NELLY
MALDONADO-RIVERA; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP CABAN-LUCIANO; VICTOR M.
MEDINA-BADILLO; CORINA NASTASACHE; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP MEDINA-
NASTASACHE; ANIBAL MIRANDA-PEREZ; GLADYS MOJICA-ORTIZ; CARLOS E.
   LUGO-QUINONES; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP LUGO-MOJICA; NURYS A.
   MOLINA-PEREZ; RAFAEL J. MORALES-DE JESUS; JULIA V. ALBELO-
  RIVERA; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP MORALES-ALBELO; REGINO NAVARRO-
RODRIGUEZ; ADA I. MEDINA-SANCHEZ; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP NAVARRO-
  MEDINA; AMILCAR NIEVES-SANTIAGO; CRISTINE S. HEREDIA-PEREZ;
 CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP NIEVES-HEREDIA; JOSE L. NOVOA-GARCIA; LUZ
  N. BRACERO-LUGO; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP NOVOA-BRACERO; ORLANDO
   ORTIZ-BURGOS; CARMEN D. DEL RIO-SOTO; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP
 ORTIZ-DEL RIO; PAMELA ORTIZ-OLMO; ILEANA OTERO-PADILLA; SHEILA
  PACHECO-SANCHEZ; ASTRID PAGAN-FLORES; LUIS R. PASTOR-REYES;
   LOURDES I. PEREZ-CARRION; NELSON MORALES-SANTANA; CONJUGAL
  PARTNERSHIP MORALES-PEREZ; IVELISSE PEREZ-MARQUEZ; DAYNA D.
   PEREZ-ZAPATA; TOMAS MONTALVO-TORRES; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP
MONTALVO-PEREZ; IGNACIO RIOS-RIVAS; LESLIE E. CABALLERO-BELTRAN;
   CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP RIOS-CABALLERO; JOSE M. RIVERA-COLON;
   IVETTE M. PEREZ-NIEVES; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP RIVERA-PEREZ;
   IVONNE RIVERA-ORSINI; DANIEL O. VALENTIN-ARROYO; CONJUGAL
 PARTNERSHIP VALENTIN-RIVERA; MARILYN RODRIGUEZ-DIAZ; LEONARDO
   RODRIGUEZ-DIEPPA; IDALISE LAZU-LAZU; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP
RODRIGUEZ-LAZU; CARLOS J. RODRIGUEZ-HERNANDEZ; BRENDA I. COLON-
ORTIZ; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP RODRIGUEZ-COLON; MARIA D. RODRIGUEZ-
  TOLEDO; LUIS A. TORRES-VAZQUEZ; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP TORRES-
 RODRIGUEZ; GABRIEL ROSADO-DE JESUS; MARGARITA VAZQUEZ-CEDENO;
   CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP ROSADO-VAZQUEZ; ONIX ROSARIO-MORALES;
  ANGELA M. GARCIA-MUNOZ; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP ROSARIO-GARCIA;
 MIGUEL J. ROSARIO-RIVERA; AMARYLLIS L. RIVERA-REYES; CONJUGAL
PARTNERSHIP ROSARIO-RIVERA; JOSE M. ROSARIO; EDUARDO RUIZ-VELEZ;
   SAUL J. SANDOVAL-MELENDEZ; AMBAR ROSARIO-LUGARO; CONJUGAL
PARTNERSHIP SANDOVAL-ROSARIO; CARLOS M. SANTANA-VAZQUEZ; MARIBEL
    CRUZ-RIVERA; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP SANTANA-CRUZ; ANGEL L.
SANTIAGO-GALARZA; DAMARI M. SANTIAGO-TORRES; EDGAR H. RODRIGUEZ-
  ORENGO; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP RODRIGUEZ-SANTIAGO; DAMARIS E.
  SEBASTIAN-LOPEZ; MARVIN SOSA-GONZALEZ; NIDIA I. BETANCOURT-
RIVERA; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP SOSA-BETANCOURT; CELIA I. TAMARIZ-
  VARGAS; ALEXIS DELGADO-ACOSTA; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP DELGADO-
TAMARIZ; JOSE O. TORO-MARTINEZ; JESSICA APONTE-APONTE; CONJUGAL
 PARTNERSHIP TORO-APONTE; GERARDO TORRES-ORTIZ; NEREIDA TORRES-
  RODRIGUEZ; CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP TORRES-TORRES; DIXON VARGAS-
MONTALVO; JOSE A. VELEZ-ZAYAS; ROSA M. VIROLA-FIGUEROA; CONJUGAL
                    PARTNERSHIP VELEZ-VIROLA,

                    Plaintiffs, Appellants,

                              v.

  PUERTO RICO HIGHWAYS AND TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY; FRANCISCO
RODRIGUEZ-DOSAL, in his official capacity as Executive Director,

                     Defendants, Appellees.
                            ERRATA SHEET

            The opinion of the court, issued on July 12, 2023, is

amended as follows:

            On page 3, line 3: Please delete "Marco" and insert

"Marcos".