Court Opinion

ID: 4070248
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 01:08:12.702525+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:03:59.186258
License: Public Domain

....: '-

            BLISIL"hJ C.D.UilLQ£ Cll£m~>o.L_/.tJll!t:lt4s.                   Abel~Siti, CISrk
           _e o_J_IJ.o>LL~3_o~8~----------------~
           _i.lu.s..t:.w .7:~~-'J.s_~lJ.    _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
                        1

           _/lE ,· fJI.IJ_i.Y.fiL D.lJ..!Li.J_'LJ:llzSJJ)!l..fll'Lr:2&17i£cr:a;w~-ro_ar:.~J:Ek..Er»:R.k!JG
           _ra /3.E_&EUJ:E_Aj_fd.Y..dl&~E-11i:Eli>/i~I~B-r!:i.IGI:!J_eEE...&IlLSi.Tmit£ Er,o~
            UJZrtJ&ur.&B.5B!icJ:lLJ:JS.. £/J:QZ:S ''-------------~

            j)ii!fli.}~Cl..J:JB.K. 1                                                     Cf-l8_-!i.DJ!L,____
                                                                                          I   .                          /
            ~iDJ!ll3fJSE_ED:Ji2.!J:I!lllrc:RJ.JX>_OOT.EcLr&M5..LD_&~:c8~&-

           ~o~ll£g/..LB.'I.. 721.1:s_C/JJ.#$Z..i3B&:a~u~E-7Jiil ~~                                         it:B:S'_
           IIL!!.ll IE 7.1tJ;_Ce.u&L.LRJ%L.L.<9.hlky_71fi!J1llt.B_~-'-D-Iili.U.C~L~/.ZJJ
           _lli.E..fltlo.V_ii 8LY.Li:128.brl21JluJzzll)::}'l ~e-..~1~/LEJ;JE: Z'!J:l:& C28~
           i1ECIJ;f)b)__Bhll2 etR12J.G_l:J_l12 TilE hrra,;.u:._e»_({)./!.. /J.lE-~L<.&'--~
                                                                              ~-
           _z __l{_/(/2_/ll.7.l£L..f.J~Ct2e.Y..Lb_ (}JET/lici...CeUt?:T_8gL!Ifi!E_O:MlJiiFJ1£IceJ:V.£_
           Jl2Y_e_I3_5JZcJ:LQ~/:te_ /:IRlZ /l1fl._liPJI2y_G.l:_Gbl BELelzL~~~/J.b/l()S§_EJ:UfJ.;;vr;

           .e.E..~f.IJL!)__CJ2/JlCLIAJ:k.eJJJ!).E_/.d1;w_, .. L,.fit2J=-&lJ~_kE]J1:J;S.,~LUl_);Jk
           _f!!ll?f2t;);...jJ_E_~~IJ...§IYJBJJ...Il EJ.JZ:12EJ:JI~.'LLt~?Jt£mG 71/:J:S_Cf:MI)J . utl:JL
           4£ZW~cQ.l!.t..4:..fll27_~~lliE~lJJJI1Jf.,_SJ-JoU:.l,il,I_/3JZJiE!J..V_~ft_(;l;l?,g_===-=
           .EEll~c&=J:l.!si__,8_Eca:J~?li~m~-kll.~-Y.~~-&l1te.,.$);JJ£ 'l:JJ:o:rldm&tff=
           _e.MeCJ:.,J!i.EJ!7sg_f!llES}:)J;'l:__llr.Js=:ro~CR-~~l!_, ..._                         '*- "'·""'""   ,__ •

           --~{lll.lhl.l;._. Y12,u./1.:.'Eflg__'/t9.YE._7J:l:n:~ $~ ?:J:JJ:S../1:!~ ~:-.,....._..........,.~--­
                                                                                     1

           .£.&~=ltll//Jl...jJ)Ai2.Gil..tyl)£!1);8?;(;gCJ:L__ @l!IJI!i»R =5X!JJ~~t~_,_,..
                                                                                     '            I
           _.EL&E ~gg_I}£J;Tn-:C}_-);f£121{ZIJ,G_ilo.Ll3- i.-8:..           fd-~-~'!!1.:.·~--=-,__

           ~~OU~L~~-e~~-~~3~~L·~----------------=-~--~------
                                                                                     '.....       .             .•

 ~--~~GiltJsE JUfl,~2.tJol>- q.;:;.,f>_9_..-!g=:O:-B~--=----=-

..-:-_{)J:13-'bR];CL_C~)(-..,-...,~·, .. .                  -~""~-.c-==-=- =-="==... _,_,_,,. __ •
                                                                                               d -

·=~{ti?.,_Bfl.IS-.8 S.l)"QS£!.:- ··~·:·· _,. ..,....,=~='""·''" •. •.· ... ,.,.. "..,, .._,.,._.,..___ ,~---~==-··;~=co=-:-.~----,~-,.
 _fl.dD.fh=li)$...,;_C/:JUJ)Xl4JJJ-is/E:=-==""""""""·-·"'"""-·""""'•-,:=·~~=====-=-===><=-·~=-c-                                                                                       ....

,.,e~.eJ,_(j()'X,_j_D.So"'~"'=-c-""=-o ..'C'====-· · ;,."'-~·- = = =...                                                                                ....   __ .._,       ----.::::::::::J

~u~eo~~rexb3_~~~8~~~~~~~~-=~====~

                                         .   .
                                                                         ======·=-~=~~«======~-
                                                                           •.
                                                                                            ~- ======~~=====·===
                                                                                                        I
                                                                                                                ..
.B.R;l~l'£LI-08iY7-:cS""l1!2MJ:=:J:::J:~JJ..S-=:l:Q=$I8Tii19..-EI~.l:2.4lJJ/9-=-t!J~~.
~ElJ:cl:BJ:JO-=-Cf;>.AJC).J.Jcfii.0AJ2-c;2£LdJ.w_e;y-=--~&JJ:J;EJ;ic£.,=--= ·" "'_ .

 "{)g_J:f~-CL.:f?Jl.):.-),... .. . .. . ..                                                    .   h    ••••••    --        · -   ·"   .l28-rE C~-~.tf5~:t.DJ~.. --,~
                                                                                                                                                                        I
 "...... .ElJcL&SW~l!).l.~5/3..~~EPJl28111!aCB;_~T~-013sJECJ:ZILj,J$~Q""""
 . SIHTES /2-1:J.){):DJG. &F Fos:;.LEtJJ.O~CPJJ'""ClddS.L0~-<:7E:/.,!Jk/.:..c:l.I!J-=
 c.S&4).'(Jj)J~Ce1~"JdMJJ.i£,_8[?JWj~_e_S;J:}t~fLJ~O=-IJJ.u.P:lB~.==-r:-8Ys.f£.~"-·-,-:-c:.·~
 ,f1Li:JJ;}s;_£&£XlE-7J):Ji$_..f!J.8;lt::kl:LEM1b.&tJ=8.£I))£LLl:.D--!2tEJlJL-_
 ~EJJ]:Zz>N-<:2Ll1ifi__CJ:)p~Z.r:~                                 .. --=-
 ___/3.1J1CW..s:.&_J:s__tJ=&XI!Jf.LC!)Il.'L~E7JtJ2iJ~&riiC~IcLlLJ3..JJg
 J2.7:F.JIJ:J.flBJ,_/2fr(BJZlJ:hll2~X.b.=~~~IN"'"&£@.~_£--­
 ...Sl3LK Ltdldldl.~E)t)QfilfJt4LilJIL!!Z't-12ii""~';/!LE!J§:.E~Sm.ug
..B=-Ce/1'l ~£Tlt~IJ2E!.'l:Z:£Ul)._Lb-=[);t~-=ilif~);'grcJ:. fl.U:&!l!QB~~'-=-== ..
                                                                                                                                                                   I
'"'·=='['_JlJL)Ji<.=ttau~lfe~=~{},f.lg<>-~4$XilJJ~.,-W"'Z:kU:~~mB:U~,,= .

-       . .. .             ··=. =-· == =·=                                        =-= .           =j].&$,l!llc.r£..U2L~8Jde.az...1ZD1/2"'"===-
                                                         .                                             ~              .•          /ll).      #.
_.,""-~--'.      ,.,_,._   •   _   ---       ..   "'''-'-----   ~   _   ~,_,_~ -'--~ ~-~C.C ~- ~~~~'1l..~""'"""'La8..Ql).J$:'-'=----- --,--=-·
"""""""-"""'"''"--=·.~='- :::::.oc.....,.;,..,.=J r:::-·-:.:"'" ·-.,.~~"'---"-x~r .. - -·-   -· __.,.,. -,.~T,J-trftm   ,..U1J.l;_l;_,_c::j2,._-:_Q_~r~~=....,.
...,____             -···~=-------"'··-""                    .... . ..      _ ..........              . 2:b.kS--:l!.£Irf~T.F;>.-u~UAl.Q~G                                                                                                             c£ -~
  .aalQ·.~~z;~fi.~~~.kau.J! Q~·rS-~v~J....... i.;~.,.......,..,~~

 ~7J:J.J~};;l~i~~)lJlJ~:o.(;;t:JJJiil:r:~,~(~~!<.ftl!@l4.;-~ . . I(:·:~
 ~j· JJ).[J/Jl..C;jt).llJi5/ii21JAP~..U.W.tl:;kl&l~'fb~Jt:<, ~t.J:b4.~ .• .
 ..812attQ; a~\~8~.  . .. .   . .  .. I
                                        Qll#:£liP(~EU&'?,
                                           I ·. . . . . .     ..J)i:.,'i-~7;:2i.g. ,_ ,••
 ~~~¢A4.:~.~g.r:/£~~.FJ£.~··.·.­
 Jit?JX2l:JJ.~ff4;~/4J:/4J..!~~~~-8~{4JJ~fJ.l.f/JJ,vj@n:~~·
 .~~C:Z:IiJ~)3Jt~l~~~l;/bJ~(liJJi{ ~~ZJi[!. BP!:t§2JM.i$..
  ~~ w,nr~~r: KJcu1~~ ~-ll•t?.-2 ~~[=~rri/2.
 at~~~~~~~~-~ SF?-~~.<7.~?.P~PY0f4!Aif.z:;pyq~~-·
                                                           .
                                                                                                                                                                       ..       .
 ,,;,:i;i~~~~~~~~OI:;#i~~;.* ..~:•·~~~ ··"#"~•:l;,tr·:                   l'l."'ii(IYo'l.a   1':ru1· .   irl.   ·_~~;,.;· *li'iM·.,;,·.,wnl~ iti~
     ·.~;~ltllJ,, ~~~~liE-.~~4. .~~~~
     .i£. .IJJ;F;. /J.t;,,':J.,,j;i~~'(:.~~. -~ ~ ~-~J~ MJ.iCA~£ J1/JatllS ·Q;IJ/?t.JS,
     . lat.W..:I:L,_~£./JJ~:a~J... ~1J:JtJI~ttllf~r;aqur~~~~-
     ..11..~1:>.okl2w~tJ)ti4~~.~JP.·f4.z;t:;.IP!iJ#l:tJ;;~4~ ..•....
     -11~ (;6J~'I;jtWJ4.&Ao.. 'J:J4.~G$.4~·4--) ~U.f)/.tk .. . ..6~~·
     .o~IJJf/i.             . _7;,7; ~~.!4i:s; a.l:t?-~ We~.--~-iiltJ.~t;4J;Afl:tlhr&kiJI:k..fi<...,
     £l.t(@~~Z:,..~_fiJ,~L,..a,~~ . S/l.V2.$.~r7)?Jini;@~4i.~.
     JJJ~tJ41J..lU:()..,G81JJJi4,W~.·f.fl/iJ~~IiJ.;/.£~c.~W.X.lU~l:Q..f,~pjiR~

                                                                     P.2-
'..c:;,.!,,lJ:iii.,:~~&~,..w
                 ·i'  w"'"i'~;.,<,irl-'>r·.,.~i·;oo-.,                                              '*riilld,;,._, ...., ,., ..,

~.~~~~.~~.~~J~.~ ll/JI?£~~4~~~

~.Ge)/).£ C!J.~:a.ct(?. .•-,,                            '"   tr?:J   f   . . . . . . . .;   ••   g~·~- -.~~;,;,i",~"'-~·.~~.:·.·~'!"'#-!'-,''l"""
                                                                                                            f

-~~~-7:iii.;~-/))/iL~41;~~~14~/i:4/:J,~~
.fi.£Qriabd ~~C?~-~2~~~ ':1.'!/,,.r;.~~. ~ iCJ,a~ ~ tt~Y. (££~ -~K;
.IfJ..O.~Ja.tlllJl£l?J%tl@tz::oJ.e..JJJ~l'JJ).T~.~dll~
     .    .                .   .   ~-                '                    .                            .          .    .    '

.~ lQ ~~'ix~{)P.I;E.fdJJ.wJ;tk,~~~.~~
~~~~J¥,~~@~~~
"'~~J:Jsiili.2~1'P~o·~""~iili' &)~~Mil' ~~~~~~~·!i.i.\ -s~.;\J' L·~· ;.··r::,vlkl•.r· ,ioii~~~
   . n      - . v :l)'\. ;q~ bL¢ 1rrr::. . o. c r-u r:a.l) S>;o; .l~q ~ t::~~ f.JRJ.tc;·
     ~·Q"T:.·Q.t·iJ24·/$i'iJ.~,~~~-~~~JtltC~~~~~--.'.~-~~~~J}~P~~~~~~ J'
."iq_·n

.{i.b~ 'itl~ (Oazt;.1A)t2a2~~~2.CcuMt;Mlz:~,tJZ ~{t~¥1!~
~~~~~. ~. ·,_,. ,..E . ·:·.: · ··.: -~~oi;\'-~r:t•••oioi•. ·".~~~~~'<\1%\~il~~~'i<~~~..,.
,,-.:.., D£tb.P      tt:l.~n.t:n '£Yl2 . ,
··e.,, .. ~~~~~·-···'·....
               '-r"r<::                                                          .· .· _. .·. ·.·.· ·, . · ·, . . . ·"'· ~
                                                                                                                         l ._>:;
                                                                                                                             ,' _ 1· .·.,· ~'
                                                                                                                                     c-
                                                                                                                                   •:¥.2_
                                                                                                                                      ..    ;:s,··
                                                                                                                                               .•.•   . ;:.,_;·"···... ,· .... : ..• ·,.

~~~];l;G~-4CJ~~&~~1f.~~tfA~~!W~tf#>iic~~~~
.~~~··r~·
        ... ~-·.~-.Aj·~·-·--~~~4-~~~e.XIJJI!(

_.,(i),].Ji£ ~J.J~JJ.Ja,~,~.~Lt.mill~~~7i/MJ
JJJJ~:a1~ra,. ~~E/28-.WJJ.rr:J:ti~ B!fllfj.t21rJ2.:m.~~~;'*'
·lJu:l.S Cf;UJ;JQ;J4~~1J;Jti~~i~JJ:ie~4~/i.:,.:~. :-.
' ~i,~j-);t~,l)J~J(~llJ.~t~ltJli..Q~ ·~·'·

{~~~~~~~e~~~4~·~-~~~~~
JJeF.;mJ]. ~e c;etl;J,4lJ.W~.{i-,~();&c~J .~J#'tt.p:)4lltE."~4l~~
jJJJ)i;l]l;k~,.: ..         -.•.'·.···.······•·'1'                            '.········'                                                                    -~
~~~iJJ.~                           .                                          . . E.&E/4lJ. 'i.CIUl1.f!l. ({/},f22;, ..~~
.r~J'i,~aE.ft&QJ. t£!0o.J.UJJiLC}:.CJ:i;l~~~~"'~·
                                                                         :'''.                                                                                                                                                                               ...
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ~·

                                                                                    ~·>, ....
                                                                                                     ...    .,· .··....

                 ·. ~·-· ,' 'o;r~ i3fiEI$:le&VDJlG~lit~fit>IJ.Uo.bJ--fZ~JJ:fE~~/;:QJJJJ;J-L.Cttllt~J;:il&S:e»
                -~ ~.- . ..-.. ,:::/wiJs,,..$.~:TBY:~··~&.:fitE,./!..41Ji~V:~~~.~QfJ~.Q~l:JJ»A/-e>-f?.~~; ..,~~·~··~~·~w""""~~.~,,i~ •·
                ·. . .#.<.::>·-.· ;~~:CP.d~.47i£.fJ.~~(:{hlW..YJX:i:LZJ.JEJ?.J:iO$:o.W-b;ll21il.Pl:.R!2$1£tJ~.l:Mti.~tt~'t., .
,,~.:,,r~-~p:::·' .· ·:~r~k~Elli&.Wl:IJ;.CJ;i.1JtE~f!;s;gsl?lJ_w.O£..Ct».iUiP:JW-r:>-8~J;~n!&JiS.QhJl£2M
                                                     :r.

·~-·
         4
                                        ....•    ,,,,7Jlii,;{d~£.l!I_t{f)S,.,.C;f>-I.Jli}.LC:.~~1:/,ih):f2....x~"'"~"·'..,". ··~'~"'.~;_,M·•·~~; __.;_~~L:, . -.-.. :~,.-..;~'"'-~::
                                   ··. · .. •. . .~G3)~...ZJil~~f!~o».,.I;I:;~...IJ);t:i;;.~g@..C{JIJ)~ULC!i~2. o£.t14J-.CJI.£~/£..lJ~De -                                                                                                                                                    .t

;·
        -··-·                                                  -4e.CiliaA>;_'-4r:t,,l>..lt1"ft9,R,t>,~.!t:t~..IJi~?fJ~'i'1,~';4.~. .L42!a.~l~l~.~'t..'l.dt~~-~ . .·~~~~ ..•.r:.p.lia.,. .......:.lll.ttl;~~~zi:CJJi...witJi.E,. ,.l:brJ:t:;x.;r;cor.a1
                                                                                                                                                    .. -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ·. ··c; _· . q
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     · ·

            .
                                                           j,.J).Z,.l:H.W-.~t1-7i~"'c:t£.7JiE-Wie~LI)O;J:~..U.h!-12JiB..Cik.!l3.lJ..rL!M.~ll-M(!)~ ·,< ·
                                                                                                                              .                                     .                                                                                                                    ~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               -.i
't !,;·~        .. _.,· •. ·.. ;· ·.                    "'(g}J).fi;/IJ5];5_,.~,/:!_~U$.,2~_,.~,,~~~~··~~'v<..~·~"'"'"''nw~~~;.*'''"'""¥~· .....~ ..<,.~<·::' . ,:-'~~;:"C":'";.~,_,,_.:.• :                                                                             ·'. ·•            .    ~-:·~- ':;
         - .... .:       .~   .
                                                   .·.. ....,,.~.,.~.J;~~-f!&»lJL·...CP1l~~f:l:..c:t,.a,.9,lE2'"0<72t~JlrEJldt?.J!~:J;?2~. &'-E.~-··~·
                                                           .         .                                 ..                 .                ' ·,   ,.,                          .     ~   .   ., J             ~    .         ,/'~'   .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ·;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            . •.

                                                     .'.• ~~,_,6};Q;J;,fd.l:~"~{)J:;;"""f3/);J)ii,..,/]Jill.ll;~.t,~/)f~~/l£,XJ;Ii!Y?4i!i~,..!l>~~l1t£,"'"'W'"~·,..··                                                                                                                                '·. ··i
i." ... . . ·                                                  ll~X£J:.CE:~!J)-~£..liJ1WI...d£E~.£t::!&ll.ld.l1ldf>S£.~~e.£..CI!tB-I?GWb.                                                                                                                                                                     (
 ·-· ... ·'.· .·                                               "'ViE~C2.£~tiP£:g,,lb£~J£-.:tlJtl:?l~lt~i?E.l.~~A)/l..~~.t1-U::t!Sf2W.&~.~-~-.~~"···~""·-·· . .                                                                                                                                     ·_ .. - · -~
                                                        .;~p~~.iJf!.£UGB.~rJ~~Cf;A>))~~A2~.E.fi~,)J/~~/;:,~t.;tltlf:~~£"~~1i.l~&s.~.-~,.:.
                                                    ·:· ::~EkB~~t?ltJ!ilii~!.ltU;)~IlJ~~~,B;.I.t;!L:l:tkWi~~~~Ja~~..G.i;~l2tG.--..
                                                   · .· >1!7££~Eg~~~l1t~#lJJJ5J:O:J;,l7;_CPG._~il~~~~:r.ttJS...CAi~/C-TitmEEP!!!4
                                                               ~T.:HE~t!dlii-J~....Cf:J.I})J(~JM{}r,£;_~(:>~~r~l:~Ji~:/l..J.)s5;£_U);Jl2.1$.]Jl:E.~.~-: . . -~ ...· -. . . _. _·- . ~'
                                       .... : ·~,5Jk[t,.flE~YdU../;;73EI.:;;1;::Lf±7:..WJ::.-:.7:If..lJ~e>_E~i-12£"/!4#JlltiXl.f.~ll!JY.cJEIJ)G . .-~ ·...... · . ·. ·                                                                                                               ,... ·

                                            . · •· -·:. ··~]}IJ).,JJlE~ti'IJ:!IJ~);IJC.'i.~~-~
                                                               . .       .   :~·"
                                                                                              ..lite~c;a~l;..~Ttl»li!5.~.R;..'i . U&:~G-711£.~)
                                                                                                ..                 ~                   .   .,      · ·                                              .                                             .,;

                                                  ·· ::(5J{i:J::..UrE.1,.8-,l.l!Mf2b)))l2fYi.8._~>::s"".e£.T):JE.,.~:tVI{)~ce1.LLl!.J.~dJ ...
                                       -· - .-.lJ£(i.JJirll¥:d~l2.u.)J)rsjj/)J.&~w.x.l.~J4z:..if...X.b.Jl:J;7gJ!.l!IJ.-w..G....et>~vr.~rrt»J.,"' .
                                                  :. ·.~:-~Ql!f!i.k~:&/lk$o~Ct>iU.~<)>lltitJ:8.'1_J:JJ)Ilbel:CIMG~QI!I!~JtJ~.~ . .
     j, •. '         .                 .           ~· Ell.J;}~~Y.J2i.!l~!*LJJ$~J2..;,0}Ec..l:.tlQ.&Jl&f)._,r5.IttJ:JJlE~.L-t4Xe,;./J8Jf)ti,.~~£.~--
                                                      .

                                       :... ·.··. ·. . · -'                                                               ... 'i'       ·.>.,..:_ '.··.'                                                     ...       ,:_     '.·. SJ2/E:J;f:k~~ ~;. .
. ·'.   .Sr/l~~.1Ji.Ji,:fJ~~g~()i[£.,JJJR$i. CQ/Ji;.~~' ~ 8./UrtJ.~. (;fv..s~!r.
        :~~tJi~~.£WilrS, .                                                      . --:- .... f(lJ..I~,~'t.iill~ ~~·-~·
        ,.,I&ElJI);r:.G..:lJ!I:li...Co~J.)..&CU:t:>IJ)S~udiili:.f!       E:W.t!J:i=A V/IE., ~~
        .~WS!!J£.~e?...k.~t«td.~li~:l·l9J~.Ii$(;;fi~·
        .,Tll:E:..IJ&~fi.ED:JBN:£lz1Jlf2~EJ;)J:.E.J'Ba,..~.~J.
            _s;.~?:.t.lJ:E•.~E:tYF£h)12if/2.)Jiill?jf(12l!!~fhlM5..BU/2iJ, ~~~~
        .,~~z:B~~-fJffili.. .ClCGLJI?I!ttll.fli?.l]Jg_tJI'..-,
        .l!klitt.G:~ki.'i.(!.~~~~-~:~~4~.~
        A:I!P-~~ J:tBJltt. ~iL:m Ml. ,':LtJ£lJ~l..~ :Eil;;f2Li~c;LtsfAll2~·ii
        i!k t:.cr.i:..k'WJ.UJJ:IJ;.f2JJJ. fi-E TJZli..~ tlm> iU22J ,e£.1J:t:J1!iJ/Q:/,iTE,
        .B.f!e2 W6 ~ ..~1JJJ£JJ2..liUl::J..tt~~~~r
        Ll2/J~ l~a~-~z-~a;g£ /fi.J.~ ~ £1J$Z:.etto:r.a.ll.:ll!kf.r#7P.MJ

            . .-.-·----·-·-·. . . ..._._,..--ai~_IIti~IWit!'. o=~r:te~- ·-~·  ........ .   ;_,~,   ....

        J~X../.j:ff£./J::lJ£:.)J:!l/S.l3..U~..E~
        .                .    .. , ;··· -:< ......... ,._ . . . . •.. , ·.

        fi~atJ.)f:I~)JiZJ.W$/t(Ji!J_~~r:;dJi.i;J;Jl,.!J$..\t.tt,®~5...~~~··
        ~Gft8~.J!tJsRE,~,/3.:}l~tf.Jlt:U.~~,f:!!:t4,£21JJ~/J:£1!£JLI.JilllJ;tt'f22~~J.~,

        .,,..,..-012Cli-.f±Gft'!A2., ~~:I.~~J.J.A1f/j,~.~~!L.11!1i.IJ/I'ij..
        . . O.!f~.r;;rJ;~~i~LJ~z.JJ:e~~~£.~H.IJi}.JifiteJ~.. ~ ..~
        .,C;4lt~ZJ~"Q;J.~~~~$~l4~~ . ,01·
        . :f.JJlS.TIWii.Dl~.
                .~. .. .
                     . .   . . , ·.
                           ..   .   ..... ,
                                        .   . .         ~w~A);f):~
         "~IJWJ2~'U:lE.~ ~Js/35lftp~liM:f.~-~~-~J. ........ ' .
     ·~'dTkl-'C:/}o'T"C"'-o~~sc
      . , ·.
       -..... . .
                  ., ,       'I,;J.;;;j,.;J~~ , . . . . .
                      . • . . . . . ·-·:· . -_ .. , ,. . . . . -··
                                                                                     - ··. ...,                                   ·· ~~%~~
                                                                                                                  ,I.H.:. -'~ ·,-C:.,, .. . . k . .
                                                                   .·· .'t(.- . . ,. . . . , .. ,., .. ·.. ~ .... ~~J.N.~~~~~~P+t:i!·._...
                                                                                                                                                    C' ..

      -,~~~,i)~~~.~~~IJ;I.'i.-)
      -~~~~i)J;~L,J;f,a/J~~,,.~UJJJ~J.Ii2l~'Oi(tfie·1)\l•.. . ·;w;,•
      ...&.4.d~~4U~~-~..l.MI
                         .. ~-···'-i;~A)J(4Q~.J~~A$~
,JiJ:i.(iJJ£liftli.tP~;;..c:t£-i.!lJJ./LW.I;i;~~.Jill.tu~Cil~Tfi2 ::· .
_c;t£/l~r;-J2~r-!2WL~E~~([)~/.1£&k...Jr;J.;~.JJJ%.JJ/-DJ:~~
,(Lr.i).f)£7,)1,e,L?,9.¢._CfJ~'=-r.Zl;{)b}~~~~~~JJJ.a;••llJ~
. .-~S/l§.t?iJJ"<';Q.J:£./iS.S.~lltMZ::,./.i'!T~~~(...;,{;j~./llDll~lJJ.k$;;.ri:~T~.:-
                                              .                ..  .                                                ·.

-.. fP.IJ?!l?:..I$ . .fJE..c;JtlJ/ili-~.Z1/1[J;[q~..7;Y.£r,.o..~'I...W..I.t':t.....'WJ?IIJ/!...l11~ .
~=£Br:;TlJ~QJ.tt);t?l..lt;Nl2~Ym.&~t?.:!rJ.j,g/J~c;!JJ&llr~rJI)L25,~~
 J"l. \ '!VQf}t ''~-IF)-.,_ F,P };!J.J · r A_L;n:_r::._,()_JhD.J1. l.C:. CIJ-.>;f; _TL l;.~n-C: ?T,
,_.,.,fl:rtJI~:¥.¥.~.~,~~~;.~·~#.·~~..,-~_:~~~~~.~~--~~~~~~~~- ~-.... '··                   ~~

,~~W..fls:i...p_·l)~~{iU.J..J;/C.ffJZJ)ii}J~!";:.,.~
                 .                            .
                                                     ..;,;~~-.«<'#~l'-'i!!'"'~:~~-'*7.*~·~jro
                                                                                                                                              /

;{j'J~tJ4:~.?JJ~P"Ii.Jitt;?f7JJ.~J;},l,~J7;Ji.rp;r~fP~l;;lJ~~i!.ltJ.ll$f.~~
~~~~WM,.;i;L~.M}DlJ)._ . ·... ·-~· ......... -... ·....~ . -~~~.f~Jlj. .i"
JJJPq~QJ;i:.&JitgW£JillJJ:II¥;~~~liJltr.:fi;-£~~~W,~~~,~
 ..,S:i~~~.dii!li~o~fJ/-11:NfiJ..t;.r<..J2/i:MQ'tf;Jiili~.U~.~:~-:2..2~~
.,(9li~Z:~~~Wtt4"'tt:ef.lii:k_,~.fll:l¥1~ii..?M.I!i~~q.~~tJ~~~
...wJ.l.t.:IJJ;I;s_i:ii~-P.t?.PlZliJ:.,ft~Afl.~~&J.AJ~;ca~
.-Tl<...§:J:o.:e..t:/JJlt!ldfJ..~~Eili;,~lill!tW~jj;g~.e(pxff~JJ;I:~,{;!j.J}-~~,
~f:J;4Jl:2iiit.Ji?..J:);t.E.11:1¥:~9Jil%&.iJ4t.2$• 1iio,t"'i.li:"'f\'~i'"~},<#.4~----~-.:i~i;>'~~~l"i'":Jl!'>M(....il"?'""'i',~JOK\i~~~
~f4J4tiJ/ll!).J;J;H».:l;~Q.;Wdt@~~~11i:~Ztlr.~7::IJ)JI~.:._.
~Jd})J12~..,f~;}t,~/i(t~~~JittS••JJtJi.,,
~~~.1:;1)~[~4J,£;{).Ltef£f;IJ»J;~k:J;.~.~
~.JJfi~~l:t).~t.JtiJJ:t::li:{I~J:.t).,,/~~Li..~~~~·:tif#?~..,~"~"~·"'~~""!·~~'*'~.....,.~<···-oi!" ...,~.
-~CJ/.i:lli:L.fi/!RJJ;~ZAC.tU.;)rtJ:i:'-~~I:!J~J;,:J;~.LVDI.Uit~
. .Iltli-&Wl~:&[:D184CfJfiR~4k.~i:2tt/JA~JJ~~~~\'~ . ,
,..~JA~k-cL:t~.~~~,.c;a..£.l/jf;)j;;.,...fJ£-~~~~~~~~.. ~:.:-
...,r~~~~.z:.~~b:t~~~.~~*~~
           '       •                               '       •               •   ...   '   :-,.   ••   •   •   ....        ~<   "'..   •   •   •'   ".   '   .,   • '     •

.1J:ttlJ:.;/:ll£..~~Q),fiA;J·&A:{1.;;;,~~
.J.tJ-.ii.4JtJili!..~~~tt#/2~~~F.~~f;ii-.W
}i~./.JJL7Jil:l.4~~.lJ$liliJiJJI:11itQJ[#/i,i~ftlditl..JJ~~~
                                                                                                                                                                      <..
                                                                                                                                                                      .' .. .
 .                                            '

~~CM~ ~9.,.a,.9=CE2;.Illo.LWI)S-JS.r.r1J____ Il.JJi~££EkL DJ....BMGJ:!sr
 3. '2; ioeSwJlEJJ_4i!.P.u;s:a:lJ.LG1)L/:tllS;_q:t;i£.~..fliWSii.~flo£2.11:14%Jl2
;Jl..J.S...IdJ-L~;J)_.S~, 3cld;.;5:;LU&.,.Bb3..Ef}lv_f}lU.7.l~IJd.l12 ~ooo21J:tl:Jlo-t_o.~ ·
Jl..J5IIJ.IE.:.~'JJ.. c5 ;uL /J. d, ':i 9:2 Cre-x, CRU!n ..BI!~L95~iJ.;:rr l2ill-21iD Ltme
.9-.eeLJ:.WJM.T /.9:l-Js.£flil2 Y.aJ_ft~Q12E..!L1J1tLC£)_w-JJ:~i£ 1:;.r._
§..TOit.;;.'i.,.,£)-J:.:I.).lJ u-:rr:JJ;J)hLl.ml.Y-ld~;::...;..L!.S~b_E.t1fL.IE.Idll~ eE£2J..::_
_i;}-Jj;)J).J;;i3Ll77:W_LUihliL$. L l.1:JS-r:i~U8lJ~0.1l=E2J..ll:tthlcEblL~N.:L. U>.Jl2aJ.
..fiUJ3_Cl:Jftf!n:!E..{J))_CJ3fl1>J2RJ..2.r8-ii.L. blttr_ UlJ().J£,._8o:lJ:f_ZltLS._·_
£EvTJ:f¥2 fl)J{) 8UBC).:lBi211:l51.J2 nt..z;s:..J.J.ltf~7!~1JJ SC!?T~
                                                                              -
~e£/J           ur Wf(S /'n7>JJILllltXW..I72P-ElJAL Ct21J.§_i.f3JJ)_9_[G)_1d/i;'£J:::}}
~~~LL~eEE8CL·----~~-=~~--~----------
(!:/)1_71t£_()}lS.L"&:J:Idr..&i.Ie.JZIJ)E!(s_fl8J2J.J!J:Il£Ei.~CillBlJ.CJE_ro lib5-Cld$.li
_V:lfJLY:J9:&Ll;lJ)J:EIJJ.f)i!IJ_7.:b_~g_]}j;§_~j_tlUJ:&-~?JJUtLclZ!1li}_Ll>...&.Ef.£ME
_'llL.W:J£~J_f2EG£/3lS_£EJ_()1Jl!{. l):bl[)_~lilJ-LD_8./IS.~-ZX-8.fta.ca.Jv..L
_Cb!J:J./llfU:.>-_'W:K/li.O..'mJJ:.cL. ll.J:flLRJJL&~g l:t&.J:Sllt»X..frJitJJ!.!JJ:/S;LG~EWtL
                                '      J
.,}:,Q-=SiibJf.J.. it!l:l!Jc~Jie..r:J!?i,'(_~fJ/lLCfl&:L?:llit'L'b'LWll§~.lJJJ:l&.lJlJU:C[i:.-=.f)l.J@1:PG
..c;;.&££'£)jJ_OJ:9.J:J~F-ei..J.9:.t1JJI~]1:t.E    £X.f2.zys_L. Ells::::.Th1,8:hiO-LD~tf00:/1. ~
.il&u&L~C!W.B.~'i. 9:1.0_9. CE);IIJ!J:LW:..&s_'JdJli§EEEI::L/itU.G:LIS.J:...i:..t-;..;~~f)(;(5~
,=73.1:B~flttY_e:£../H!RJdc.CB:lJJS__Wr;mif.l,__,_,__=------
                                 ''                ~
~W_)3{tT__CEJUSl£l~:LL.l/J:OO-WilS~8JI~.JJJ:oLititlat.J!JlW.G~Cill.,.,
..il1.J£~l:B W!Jll:IC ~~8JEJ:;£,.~7:..7.11J;!YLLtl~J:V:.tx:t,8_'i:JJl'(2..,.~.U~JdJ..6...
 .D:u:JJJJJr:Ll!J2J_SJ.dlllllA!JIW_7:_b__,.l29:.~Cb..~L=/!;..:I.Jd)J:!N§L:JL.JUrr'L c9:8~
_(J:gQ.t:;r;J;J;,GcLY:ftS_f&&ItJ.I).J;~El££l.J;.OR.W:~r&&O:.I3.1:~r,,lJJ:.[}LI3.m>_G--=-
                    .,
.,me2i:PAIJ:I15_ fJ~/li£.4CDMJ:d~C!Ll.JS~L~C!tfii§_-Mlf:>YM
 )1JJJ!~T8~B=IJJ:z5:fllE/l:l~e.!l-fiS=-~I?tyS§.]:t3_J9;. P~,~,_ft$o-=L~ ..:.
_/3.EEIJ)"'"/21?(~Q~c~B~'ij9:J4>__~1E)Jg;!_'t()c-_;JJE_-o~fl:Nc;£,"fl::>__ p_piJ:a2?8;-c
.JJJ.EJJJ)_f2~=~mt:~e.~£&- MEB.~b/3.:J/2;JJJ_!,C#J.           _ . . _· _ __ __. ___ ~ __ ""
~~=-8-=~7JtE=fi6S:vs:'l'tr._ltlZ-fl'[JlJ/UJr~-lf-J:;ts/Yl:::J?D1l..tt)]JJ1fl'lZrrll!f£:;J:.JlJJ1>~
..J::t::>lKJmi"[)J;JJlG__7Y/:L:5_,..&~'D.CJJI£2.~L-fJ/SE!jU!)J:_J~EuYJJ{_llJ-t1R~!P4iB.JiflW~
~e-IZ.j!~/L8.uLL.ii&St.Jl.J5-,Ih)_UIDict.ra:Dh:J.,t:J,~7}9'lr:j!§Y.J.I!.~/9!1:or~/
                                                                                                  ..•,,. ..,.::.,...

 :$4/r EXJG.A {Qi;;._~ Tim$wc:»J): 1J;.l>14J,~ lJg;gJ,Q- faU.FS.~~~i:-;h> -.~ ·:. :. >
 .JJ2~~1Jlf) fi!W fie;SiJ).~ ·,PY lJfQ I;D;r:IJJM QE888U±:?J2&~
 ~~1¥J,J.ri4.t&~~~J=.J:Jlli£:fd?lt2fi0:2.UJ:];;..~~
 .Jli£t2.Yli:'lif...§:£~:a.iltl_;:J.tg~rJl;E-X-EW-;ED!:lJJfiJJ.'i2~;;;
 TCJWZ ltm~lj4o:£~J:J;JYill:!A2"'.~E~f?:h).:J;;T.IJ.'J- ·
  .fiV&iJ]jS GEOil7~1~13iilf42~.ltl;£)i£tr.lilJ~JJ:?-i9;1;§._,l1J!l~&
 ~:k~~f.2~,l),tfl?fi(J/~.]2ft~fJ~1)Q)JJ;,.Gl5.1i.Jf&J[&.ZlkUJI--·

 ~..G:JJlll~.f)l{eJ:.Ri£..Ll.t.J:JBJJ£l~q>~~E-'i.J~4
 . . L~U!.l~l)~la,Q:j;):2'::J:.S.~..c:;;;~.tR:t)~Qt;t;..!tJ.ttef..UgJ.JJJ:../J1it.¥U~Z:~.
  ,_EQ/LflbJ...f2iY)..l;;B..,~~)JJ;)JJJ6.]]jji.,fif%lar.a.LrJ7);J,_jj~.7"0 77t.1i -~
 .}a.J:O:L.C!L~ TD.~/!~r:.JiffJ~ti£JiJ.J-;~nm.­
 ,~Y.XllJ~-t-ftf!P.U.J;JlJJL./2et:y1J:i$S:U..~tl.~fJ~J::l:D'.£:f..,~

 ,. . ~.,. . ~GllJ,~. 'EalL~~.bl.lJtf#...T&m~.~.CA~. "'~---
 . .,.. . .e<"·~·nCi1.&1Qfii. . IJ..8.r;:L.o....lllOla~"~....;,,."""'...-"'.•;. . . .;...w..•......~....- -..- -
 ···--·~~l.!bJ.JJJ.lfEE~~~~ii..§).J;:]J?$n~,CJ:t.~         •. -
 ~---~G11~fis:;.I~b.'""l4lbl~J;;a.,id~-SSi,N.)JJ~l£,Jl~m wdi

 -~Vt1:4. ,~S.,~~~~--fjJJ~/};/?ff.­
 ,..,1!2~..ctJlJ~.id. .Cf...ZJi:a~11tE~.!J.!ill.l~.of);)~~.~
 ~~.~e.?~JJ.. .rJ,tft:l:;::ar~llvllcrre:~~r:ur:r~JJ£./))~-~ .
 .. f.iif.f~~-~&JZJJJ:~,ttfl/i~rt;JJ;;"fZt!AJ.~CUf~
                                                 ..
                                                    ..nEllU&J...~.      .
                                                                                         '

 ~e.o;tro.£lt!;;;a)~Y;I.t:/AJf-W.J;?J;~jk~l:§;~.•e£.                                                                          .....
 ~,,CaLl2uEJ:ilrfi);Jllf}f:%J).J:J~J;,I)JlJ)IJ.~,.r;Ji.;~~lJlJJ1~'1_.~'£r­
 _I:tfl..RIX.._Cif&rts~B_;;,a£iuc&r.);J2_JJ~Illlc&-YJ..j£_E/lQL.UBL.Ji3Lle_t:IS~Bt.R_
 _rl.l-E-GUr..1ZlJ.&.Ul.~&U&L&tJl.E__
                                    ~r.,V..tJ:Lt;J;mi£=-/i;££llXB:i.J7'
                                     tl
                                                                                                    e.?2-P:
 _11);;5 B.- !YJI!a.cn:rzou~_lt.DLJ..lWJ=R1Il~&:».'!E.;.DJml1:~rt..Jl~- TJ:/tt.r__
 _EJs;S;E£r.Lt>.N;1l'tiE0i,Z:.s..:Z:D--fiE.Ii&JUJ:r£ -THE~li2UE~/31.Ts__es=eE81!Racw»rs
                                                            &I                                 II
 _C1.£1Ims_f3_1/_Jii.TJI2L't1-'iT.M.G~r;:;E_f1J:IgftSES~Li1l4Ji:_lt.5.£.iifi8-II&J~-1hL.O.--
                                                      .                 II
 &I                          V
 ._EiiJ!;;J:.UBL._88.BE.s5_8.JYIJ_f2&Qc:e&os_ll>~CalJJ:E2tl.tLlll8~-rL-lE &lcJ. i!rftL_
 l2fflE8._£Qfi_8/JP..acBJ~);S~DiliEE~G~~£olLfii1LI:E.£U,J2~1-72i~-_.
 J]iiGf:!lliJ_JIVJ:f18lJ..c.E_8;M_f.1/!£J..XC!l.&d_fldlB..Jlil;J.JS_C/a:J2J_~oL_li.J5.Tb11YJ
                                                                     I .
 wPJJ?E_/J.IJ!f.ILIJiJlE_fl:r.. 72tB..T:rn:lE. 8.P£&rx::LtNl:S-13.-!1:e£a.C!J:.rz___ebL~!tS
                I)               .         .                                    '"
 .EIJ...ElJ-J.....rltE_.SIIJ:l:J;; s.: fZBS.I?J:>_~g1 0Eil.):Z)_f3.~LV/.t.'LeE-.S.M'9.-£&,.;£11,o~.
  ~                                            I   ~
 elXi/!ll CBh)0TCTL'JJ..G_Q)J.di££5_E.D.J.I}LJ,)__G_eE. ED.c;)_S-;_C/JltlCLL5._~-
 fJ.E /.AU1J.8:Nil IJE.DDlllo:J.&U.._il!f~_ra.rJ.t.E_CJ:>.{.djj£_ eE_C/li/.P.'J:J:JtiLB:/!1!&~--
                         ,                                                           .'   ..                 II

 tuJL13P.ell.CD.lJIS_/l/lL_L};.{)_)_8f!I!L.LCll!ZI)J:J_£DILL1.1/lt;T o..£ lJ:&.llJ!l9§_C/)J]J2~
            )        .
  SEPJ!S· TD.1~"'&5..UbJJ.iJ_TLfE....IlllB.LG(}/.dlL LD_8./2.of!.l- EIJ.JO.IJJ.GS_6E eJs;r.
 .bJ.b.L. IJ.JJJ.iiS.Q:.Gfl.7m_ B.'LTJJ.&_L_~rtB~_CtJ.L!d.IJ:htO_TNEIJE£t:JilEJveuMl.l.utX£:
 .EiL/lao"ft8J,L~LEE£E.crx_ue E~IJ~WZ~C{)f.,g2Ji..fl.c.cee.~c.~,.Elfi!2:J:.o!:l»._r
 _/i.E_(JutE£L..V:liS---G8.ldl.Ll])__O.zs=l2e.GIJ'IW~~B:I2Q.E);:e%LED.212WG=B»-L..
  ~f!l2acP-H2..-W_;,rJtE~Bls:;_rs=~-71tetll&wB.J,_£JJJ~J:J)/UlJ==-==---···                          ·-*'"""""'

       ==BOl£§_()j_J)_]J:Ii~~=D.Il~7;Lt>}t1...lliJ;-=-Uhl£l"&£72tl:15=£uP/.?EPJ8
 ..Co~r- t:J8St!J<..UW-~7Jl8:'"[.~=-- __ ~,._r,...,...:==n=-·--=-=--==>00!=-=.-==-=-====::::=oo
  =~W_Ii., fUZE fJ:S}4~J='C~IJ.lEP!JES13l:tf=CltrSE..-=ro_,.J~t.~'/J=7J:tg_IJs:;;t_ctnL
 rihJI))__Q~CENcE=£>?.cBe_~~~=/!ll.Q_QJ9){/__fV}b--=l2a£/ffuLJ:_~£ ~'fi.(JJ:...
 I~--Q~BL_ CtBDnS-.:::.CNRLL8JJ.GDVG.cltJDJJ C11tJ!~TffL __ SSNT~_cj)r)__~j~&~~ •
 . . UJE=Ii/1~~~7:Q./lJMSWH~-.,._7Jle-~~l1:tW~W=7J:I§=P..t:J:5.1Yllff~C'!2Lllf.ls
 .:-Cb5#-&JJJ)-~7:ellO-"k/;_f>J..tLDfO_Lfl_£e/28£tL_Cty.)_&'£~-=blJ;,J:JI=
. ,.B:l_LgGO:tl:O.J.J.-~F-eBJ:;.rw.L='EN.hlo..;.CE:blcE==-WHEJJi'l3f.._f!?2£7J:1E-=~EltJlLW~
 ~ef!::_ 6l/LViS-_Cf1timi~CliD4.GJJl11,/J:J).d6::LEUJ&Ll}:lif1~~-!J!U.~IJJ,t)!LflEJ!flU1JI7iiJ
 nCl..fl"ll!J.5~=C))m_f111~/J:81E=BEkJE£,_8h)flj~TJJ8JJ.=C?g~)J)I)~~IE_~o§ ..

                                                   P.IO
'   .

                                                                                      II

        J:I8~_WH8JUI..f..V.E_&efl.N3SW_CbiJ)_PIIJEhlce_vttri;_£1)/:L.'Lttlf masJ IJ1Jg~ . .

        ':_u_z_c.T.J:Jn.S_er£ 11 E.~.J~hl{).flm.t~:J:J:L8LJ11Ji5.CEk5Ml..TllG.£_o.EJ.uo~LJ;.cE_Lt1I1L-
              .      .                                                      1/        I

        ~L7:r:l:E~Cftl!se; - 8JYJ)_- f:!/1i£Jj,Y)}:CE.=S:JlJ)r).Qfi&l2~=-'i:-2..?=lb~,-tTL !'=7&:,/126I
        9LL~:~,3d.~d9.21Jbb.&_:.o}j .9..k3..::.9.--.{~ut;J_;r.IJJG: .Eir)G~V,..Z:Slr_Hc1='1:i5i:>--..
        =U,B~"'Lb_?j=l.3.c.21 2LLd?i!2."U'=~?lJ..--.~}D.2._~:..CJ;,_I.$~'8=Ct:'l~~~)_,_OOI(~Ci=>~J- ..
        ,.£d2JIJJcE.-Wf15-8DL5-T~eD B'i_rliE B.Utt£L&l1IJ_:£r-'i_eE_DJE£EEciiuE---.
        ~fi-$£J;;;,_"f?~c;;£ , a~- .C_t?..f.!J))SiJL :.CUt0?;~=-:;;ez;_r__Jta<=-l-18.."2fl-..Gil12Y!!-!0-:._IP:te_ -=-.
        '"G&us£.-.a£.=fts=f1~f,l?.l§iSIBNOZIJJG=C).Br;m==Eef!.,,./J.i~_,;,x~:LO-~tt;;-:J;;;:
        .U,UBIJI2..1J:.GB:LI.l!>Ll)ll;5;Cli;/Yi,_Lf.tGES~)~,JillsU..GR,.JJ:.t£~J;S;J;~?,J_~
        tJ£Su.cJL£B:£E_GlJlttBll5'1,W~<9l3_,_qi?f1.(}J:~2;::0:Zll~f&.!).I}~'LDJl!-{Jgf&.
                               1                                                           II

        .ILV-=llf~8~~-C,l:EtL~.F lJt)2 _ltflBez.;s~CI:JLdliJ:8.=/;fq>_,.yp-­
        ..8:!JULfl1:8..D..£iiU!2JJL4L.l;II:L~il8/!E~LD,.,f/1.ll..CI5!J.tJ..Jl!Jll)l_fleE./tuL
                     ,J
                                                                                              TEO
        .G1.e..rm.s_!~CI.f.rfj.g:r_H!J.=S:L.fi2Bti37 ~El'L'-L't6.1=9.LLd~J1;1_ftd,=3~9=?1)jJj;;!~Shcr;im
        =(/)Jl_D1~-f?--=/?v§J;f}J~If-~-R~-Itf..~-U.SJJ1=9:;=~2"'L~;2:(2,=!2.cL-l,~)a_t}_S.,"cz"~'it:!l
        _,B8~l,'----~------~~--------~-------------
        -==IhLY.B.lE~~.l:llE~£E.2J;Il:/J..;~)£-=(ll:!E-S.IP-J:E)~GDJ:J..cmH!J_Lf.Ld~L
                                                                                                          .&~

        _flilG.u.meu.L7J:/B:[.J1.iE BESdlatJ.IJeJJLlfol2f7_u:z:e.o..J.E_lL},)f2                             s 'J:..G'~l;:    .
                         II

        ...f:LCEI:hl'LJ:JV.SE~E£C:U:UE~c:2E-.Ct2ubJ£SL=CJJtr!?:1~·-D::t£CtJ.~~r..l.iGtlEPi)
         ~WZ:[/l_71iE<:f}):!J:Il:l!JJjJ1J:ifi_§):I)J:lNG     n-W.."S ~ T}J;J.::JirJC5
                                                                           1
                                                                                         I H ..lYJY- rrr .....,._
                                                                                           j('   f.t...
                                                    ---. ..._ .:-;~~ "4J~-./:l~C.-e.~~A -\-'=~~ .-=.Cl~ ..~UL
        .'.                                                                                                             I/       .

        E,J;,J:JRb!b,/J:~.G&b:?.t:?!:!!.'- &..E. .LJJ./¥;f$CI..e.J.!.g_Qss~Q.rlj;JJ~C9:E...C4~'=.JV£g,, .
                                                           ~(

        _Tl:f.E._C.O_t..l/lJLcil.6.81i..I):S:LD:IJJ:.J:;_&u..CCd-SS-e.bL7:1:1!I..lb.~.&.b.TS..                  wcuw .
        _G.WE"<>IJE5/loJJJll.BJ.t..I.J:lL.c9.&.1J:i:E_Be.L7:.ffLltE_s.g&Jts.~:..r.,§.,,_!l!$~.
        .E.aJI&:lc.W_G*1..,}:;,.r._W.t>JL.Ll2...8:1..5o.../2/lQJ2.1;1J~(;,O;_uo§=W e)LCf-PS~=:= _.
        -.lli!f..J~Ro~Ct;"12.4ll!l..~=!JE)~J:t.U.),.~r.-~~j;;l;_~_,&dr_EF
                                       /J
                                                                          L..c;r:.!Ihl_.C}l_eF.
                                                                           .
                                                                                                LH~;i,
        _gux&EJJcfi_.~CWJ;tn..,,=--=--··~·~·~-~-=,~... -... ··· -----'. -~
        ~ ._                                ./l/]J:t~YJ3le.,.,_~.,~ ..    ·-a,,•
                                                                          RMt.   -·

        ~..B..&Lr._c;tJ..!JJ;,T ·- e&f!- Y rJ.:tiS_,__Co.~rt:LGw~r.,lJI!ea.C!lJ,J;LI]J.i~~
~-BlU_CIIl/i&._/]J~.mBNB.IdllG~V.t:l~- B:.llEf-IS;J):JZf2_N_B.I)J;K_"LD_ =
 V9E T&IUL Cilt.ei]J;_ro_CJ>I?£i?.CJ- fL/!R-DCl.I.OJd&~l:ll Tltt=.
                            ·.                      I
. !lLW&.Na..rzu&-; Bf!EUceJMLs                          fl£.c~Lud~s.r:_wg_ttJ.J__ JW£f2&2JlrM~/
  HFB.R.Z.JJG'
~--------------------~&seecrLWLY_s~e~2T~~-
                             , # .'
----------------------·fL~~-2~bU~~----
-----------h?l:t£LH:IJ:ll:J. UJ:J:L~rl2~~-
                       ' I. L s AI(, • • JJcJJil
----------------------~·~~ ~~~~--------
--~------------------La~ELdD~-~-?-~~1.~·~~

_ _ _ _C&J:IELLD.&                                  a£ S.lJE.Jt:t:.cE_ _ _ _ _ __

__jC.-J}_Q_j]_Jfll&.B_'LCEll. T.LEt.J...:lJ!IfJ::.J:£u.E 8J;J.O_C/Y111i2&::T-Cb_£L
 <9 F VtF:. Et2111i..Gt2DJG f2LBJ11)I)t)G W..BS_6.&2.UCIJ_8~'LI!J.EJ::-_W..G~
 Jlh2 ll9iE r)JJE~L Wm&J.BLJ11BJ;)..D.J.t;_&.!JE_[~­
_/l.O£'f.fJE.};;:.~f!lli3/2&WJMl TCit:, 2._3 t:h. .lf28_ Y 6LS:l:!iliE!.ltBL:TS7 .~
_&fl_(l~ 'Et:.Lt2I£7.:~L. CLEB,K llM/2 B_Exilll/J_Ct>:£lf_Et1/LEJJ:£ ...
_rl1LcL CLI:!PJ:~.-'l:.D 5l:!J];_u._it Tf2...ll-J.if {)_JEigicLll:..rTt111JJJ_~'{,_ _

-~.u[2".J.JI5:.6.l.tL.t..JY1.:.\....r~.c,:.!.r_~ca-l~~c..------=--=..,._,f2BSt'EC~Y...Eui3m&W1J_
                                                          P-.      I       o     t;t
_88E~E&L5U~~~--~--~-~~~~8~li~--~--
_fl_r).JJOJ Lb..5_J_GfJ~I.dQtt/;tD_usi~.                  £Bs;.rlillJ:lJ-Uhl'LLJ,.2.::..a.~-==-. . . . . . -
1...tl,_B_t:JX_Los..a_6                                   lkb.5....£f6b£()}))_/bJ_/!..L:.--_ __
J..u8.BJ2.CL;-l!;&J5_!;3_L};f)ff_                         Lb.I.IE.)J1:12~-~-?_Q.'8:_.f2.L._ __

                                 ·=ra   -   = .

                                                  P.l2.
                                                                                                        29
       '   .                                         JH1MY ISABELL - DIRECT

                1                   l'1S.   STANEI-<:;    Your l-lonor, ma'l I approach the

                2   witness?

                3                   THE COURT:           You may.

                4                   MS. STANEK:           Your Honor, at this time the State

                5   would offer State's 4 and 5 into evidence, after tendering to

                6   Defense Counsel.
"-9,
"\J'            7                   MR. CHAMBERS:           May I have just a second, Your
·~

~\              8   Honor?

                9                   THE COURT:           You 'may.

               10                    (Pause.)

               11                   MR. CHAMBERS:           Your Honor, I'm going to object

               12   to t.he introduction of State's 4 and 5, basically on the same

               13   grounds that I made yesterday morning, prior to impaneling the

               14   jury.    Those appear to be certified copies of judgments· in

               15   excess of ten years old, and prior .to September 1 of last

               16   year, 2005, -- this offense was August 27th, 2005.                 Prior
                                                                                       __. . . . , _ _to
                                                                                                       ---

               17

               18   judgments in excess of ten years old to be used to get

               19   jurisdiction, to raise, basically, a DWI to a felony.

               20                   The Legislature, in 49.09 of the Penal Code, has

               21   amended that.     But we're objecting, Your Honor, on the grounds
                     ·~
               22   that to amend that and make it retroactive              to   allow these

               23   judgments in excess of ten years old violates the

               24   constitutional provisions against Ex Post Facto laws.                    And on

               25   those grounds we do object, again, strenuously to the

                               BECKY CLEVELAND * CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTER
,,   '

                                                                                  Dlfmrr (;)
                                                                                                     30
                                                       JH1MY ISABELL - DIRECT

                 1   admission of those judgments in excess of ten years old.

                 2                      THE COURT:      All     righf~     Your objection is

                 3   overruled.

                 4                      MR. CHAMBERS:          Yes, Your Honor.

                 5                      THE COURT:       State's 4 and 5 are admitted.

         '~~'    6                      (State's Exhibits 4 and 5 admitted into

         ~...   '7                      evidence and shown in Exhibit Volume.)
         (J
                                                                                               '

         ~
                 8       Q       (By Ms. Stanek:)         Jimmy,    if I    can have you look a,t

                 9   State's Exhibit No. 4.

                10                      If you can read, who is that particular judgment

                11   against?

                12       A      Danny Villa.

                13       Q      And what is the cause number on that judgment?

                14       A      It's 92-490,392.

                15       Q      And what court?

                16       A      County Court at Law No. 2,               Lubbock County,   Texas.'

                17       Q      Okay.     And what:.    W2,S   the offense in which he was

                18   convicted of?

                19       A      DWI.     Driving while intoxicated.

                20       Q      And what was the offense date in that particular

                21   case?

                22       A      May the 24th of 1992.

                23       Q      Okay.     And turning to the second page of State's

                24   Exhibit No. 4,      is -- where -- is the particular print that you

                25   compared; is that correct?

                                BECKY CLEVELAND * CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTER