Court Opinion

ID: 3646915
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-07-06 06:02:49.759031+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:08:22.055802
License: Public Domain

The estate claimed in this case descended to Thomas Pritchard, Jr., from his mother, Mary, and from him to his niece of the whole blood, Elizabeth P. Clary, under whom the defendant claims. The plaintiff claims in right of his wife, who is sister of the half blood to Thomas Pritchard, Jr., on the paternal side. Had the question arisen between the plaintiff and Elizabeth, the wife of Clary, it would then have presented the same point with Pipkinv. Coor, 4 N.C. 14, which was a controversy between the brothers and sisters of the whole blood on the part of the acquiring ancestor on the one side and the half blood on the other; but it depends on the very same principles and is governed by the two provisos to the third clause of the act of 1784 — the first giving preference, where intestate dies without *Page 225 
issue, to the brothers and sisters of the half blood, on the side of the acquiring ancestor, in exclusion of the brothers and sisters of the half blood on the other side. The act, by preferring one set of half blood to the other, must necessarily prefer the whole blood of the ancestor, from whom the estate descended, to the half blood of the one from whom it did not descend. This construction is unavoidable; otherwise, we must suppose that the Legislature meant to put the half blood in a better situation than the whole blood. The other proviso to the clause gives the same right to the issue of a brother or sister of the intestate   (425) dying in the lifetime of the intestate, which their ancestor would have had if he had lived. Therefore, as Elizabeth Clary died in the lifetime of Thomas Pritchard, Jr., Elizabeth P. Clary stands in the place of her mother and represents her, and is entitled to the land, in exclusion of her aunt of the half blood on the paternal side. The motion for a new trial must be overruled and a judgment entered up for the defendant.