Court Opinion

ID: 8055445
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-09-09 04:32:17.547602+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:37:49.790377
License: Public Domain

Pennington, J.
The action before the justice was brought by Finley v. Smith, for an account arising on *559simple contract. It is stated in the justices’ docket, [*] to be an action on the case. By the act of Assembly, it ought to have been an action of debt; and this is objected as error. Without looking into this case, I should have thought that this error did not tend to the substantial injury of the plaintiff in certiorari, and thereby the judgment protected by a late statute. But on looking into the case, I find that it not only tended to his injury, but that it actually did him a very material injury. This action was commenced the 27th of November, 1811. On the return day of the summons, [733] the defendant, Smith, appeared before the justice and alleged in writing by way of defense, that this same matter had been tried before another justice, viz.: Justice Craven, a few days before, in an action brought Smith against Finley, and produced the record of the justice, with the state of the demand, and judgment in favor of Smith, which fully verified the fact. But it further appeared, that the action tried before the other justice, was styled, and that properly, an action of debt. From a rule taken on the justice, to certify whether he did not overrule this plea of former recovery, in his answer he admits the fact, and assigns as a reason, that the action before Justice Craven, was an action of debt, and that the action before him was an action of trespass on the case. It is true, this was a shameful quibble, and is, of itself, assigned as error, and rightly. I am of opinion, that the judgment be reversed.
Crane, for plaintiff.
Kirkpatrick, C. J.
After stating the case, observed, that the merits had been well tried before Justice Craven; and the law is too eagle-eyed to be deceived by such refined craftiness.
Rossell, J.
Of the same opinion.
Judgment reversed.