Court Opinion

ID: 4565015
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2020-09-12 05:06:35.626122+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:35:28.176822
License: Public Domain

Cite as 2020 Ark. 263
                  SUPREME COURT OF ARKANSAS
                                      No.   CV-20-470

ARKANSAS WINS IN 2020, INC.                     Opinion Delivered:   July 31, 2020
                      PETITIONER

V.

JOHN THURSTON, IN HIS OFFICIAL                  AN ORIGINAL ACTION
CAPACITY AS SECRETARY OF STATE
                   RESPONDENT

PROTECT ARKANSAS
COMMUNITIES, A BALLOT
QUESTION COMMITTEE, AND
ALLISON WHITE, INDIVIDUALLY
AND ON BEHALF OF PROTECT
ARKANSAS COMMUNITIES

                          INTERVENORS

                                      PER CURIAM

       At issue in this original action is a statewide initiative petition (the Additional

Casinos Petition), proposing an amendment to the Arkansas Constitution. On July 24,

2020, petitioner Arkansas Wins In 2020, Inc., a ballot question committee, filed its

original petition for expedited review and declaratory judgment and for writ of mandamus

against John Thurston in his official capacity as the Secretary of State. On July 24, 2020,

petitioner also filed a motion for expedited consideration, temporary injunction, and

immediate appointment of a master. Petitioner challenges respondent’s decision declaring

its initiative petition insufficient to qualify for the November 3, 2020 general election
ballot. Pending is petitioner’s motion to expedite and for preliminary injunction. Also

pending is a motion to intervene filed by Protect Arkansas Communities, a ballot question

committee, and Allison White, individually and on behalf of Protect Arkansas

Communities. We grant the motion to intervene.

       We grant expedited consideration and appoint the Honorable Kathleen Bell as

special master to resolve the factual disputes raised in the petition. The special master’s

report shall be filed no later than August 17, 2020. The briefing schedule is set as follows:

petitioner’s brief due August 24, 2020; respondent’s and intervenors’ briefs due August 31,

2020; and petitioner’s reply brief due September 4, 2020.

       The motion for temporary injunctive relief is granted as follows. Respondent is

directed to continue facial review of the petition and to begin verifying signatures on the

initiative petition. Petitioner is granted a thirty-day cure period to commence on the date

of this order. This cure period is provisional, and counting the signatures collected during

the cure period depends on whether the petitioner is ultimately determined to be entitled

to a cure period.

       Petitioner has also requested that the court order the Secretary to certify the

petition for inclusion on the November 2020 ballot. We grant provisional certification of

the initiative pending review of the merits of the certification by the court.

       Further, this court has routinely required parties to post a bond in original actions

brought under amendment 7 when a master is appointed. See Lange v. Martin, 2016 Ark.
302 (per curiam). Respondent is not subject to the payment of costs because of sovereign

                                               2
immunity. See id. Therefore, petitioner and intervenors are directed to file a bond to be

approved by our clerk in the amount of $5,000 to secure payment of costs adjudged against

them in taking and transcribing proof, including the master’s fee.

       It is so ordered.

       KEMP, C.J., and WOMACK, J., would deny certification.

       WOOD, J., would deny certification and further expedite the matter; not

participating in the motion to intervene.

       SHAWN A. WOMACK, Justice, concurring in part and dissenting in part. While I

concur with most of the majority’s opinion, I respectfully dissent from the part of the

opinion ordering preemptive certification of the issue to the ballot. Because I dissent from

the certification order, I would propose an alternate briefing schedule.

       First, by granting the request for certification at this point we are short circuiting

the statutory process that exists for review by the Secretary of State and the Board of

Election Commissioners, as well as our own process that has been adopted for similar

cases. See, e.g., Ark. Code Ann. §§ 7-9-101–126 (Supp. 2019). Second, there have been no

facts established by a special master and no legal determinations made by this court that

would warrant a preemptive certification order more than three weeks before the statutory

deadline; there is plenty of time for a thorough and proper expedited review process to take

place. Third, this particular injunctive relief is premature given that the petitioner has

made no showing of likelihood of success on the merits, as required under this court’s

longstanding precedent. See, e.g., Baptist Health v. Murphy, 365 Ark. 115, 121, 226 S.W.3d
3
800, 806 (2006) (discussing requisite showings for preliminary injunctive relief). Fourth,

by stepping over the normal process, this court is inviting premature litigation from future

ballot initiative groups, setting a dangerous precedent of ignoring both the statutory

requirements and the work of other state officials in the process. Finally, by preemptively

ordering ballot certification, while simultaneously setting a briefing schedule that

necessarily puts any final opinion by this court after the statutory deadline for certification,

this decision will appear to have been quite illogical if the facts and law ultimately require

us to prohibit the counting of votes for an issue that we ordered to be placed on the ballot.

       Accordingly, I would deny the request for certification and set an accelerated

schedule consistent with that recently ordered by this court in a separate ballot certification

matter, allowing submission of this case prior to the statutory certification deadline. See

Miller v. Thurston, No. CV-20-454 (Order, July 28, 2020). Therefore, I concur in part and

dissent in part.

       WOOD, J., joins.

                                               4