Court Opinion

ID: 4051536
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:40:57.660277+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:55:47.380150
License: Public Domain

732 W?M'O'*

" . »'\ ; ',` -, , 9CO§TEC')FC§'Iu/EDI

" d ` * z - - ` `. SEp`082015 EALS
99 909 \'A°QQ°(> ` . 9 l . 1 9 ` %;@M% @Y@`Me%§
_929103 909)<9 09 95\9<\\9\69\ P900309\S x 1 . d

i~\9>3`9\9\ _9.;3:©$ '\%'\\\

 

9\9 ?\\9\439 9`(\0\'\9\09 1"9©9'99* \O\\C>A€f> \.939 \9 09 \39010‘<05 90909)5
909939 990 \?>3'10001\ _

' §90199999939 l \S`i 30\3

' .~ j . W\B 9\00\<9` 93 S`{9\99>199&9) ‘(`(\0\\'00;09\9 19<99099'9\'9\39 099909\’9\99\€0
, _*90 \_99990`0®3‘9 0093 990<\90\_ _9090900_909099\ 900:: 0990_
90 0\\9 903<9.' 9\\99 99933 99\\:0_\\)33 9900@ 909\\/99:9\0<\3 003 9900\ 099
?)U\<\, g909><\_’939 \`93§`>05 000 m3 9909\'\ \-\0;99\3_ 9009\999 \9\90\5 \93\0\\`009\00
, 909)9\‘9`9<93 `\'\»99 09300 9\<\0_9 `93 09\9090 900;3 99 909 039 ‘093 90399 930 9‘9\0;‘9:J
‘09\09\0)90 90 0 99~)9)9\0 00099\999\ 9\00\30 939\9090 9090_3$3, 9 _\9'\3_ 009@990.90£930
90\>\>3935 9,>03 .\_9990333`3 909 99\\30399\39 ‘099<\0 390\30 039 09)9_99300\09 `
, l\<\c\. 1190 9\0‘9 3099`\9\0 -‘9‘<\939 l9\9\033} 9099\993 9\\09\900°91\ ~‘9\\309 \/393\ 903 \\
` mc939 9099 1 99)39)900309 0933309 §9 9030\\199\. 999 999\<339 000 000/9 " `
03509\ 90991'\9990 000 ‘00><\3 909>093_ 909 3999939\\ 9® 9(9)3¢993 \c9 903 ` `

\90¢9999033(\_’9 09 9,9`\<`9\'\"\0_\ _99>3‘9_\93,“ ` .
`9\9\<9_ 0§309\ \C\ 9099 933>9”\0 9000999 990003031\_ 99)‘03,<\ 93 ' ’

. _ l 909 9003 93009*930 90 933 0<\9'999 \)009_`9 909 00\999 3\\09090€.) 990 09
. 993 39303,_ 90999 3030\9 909>999 90999933333 000 095‘90;\0.309919,\\\09095<,

99090 0 090_9\099 39093 1 909'33 9\99199~ \9990~\9999<9 09 9003
399 999999 999 99999 99109 099*‘93993*9993 10 903 309\)9\\\09099

 

, 09;>99`\0"9’909\ 0'9\9
0 ‘ Q

v \L`\§Qs>m\ 0010<_51(0§\03 1`(\0\\<\§`0§ _Q§\“ §,0\§3__\§0§\01_\¢0§ 10§§§\'03 ` l
'1)0_`_0.. _WLM_ 1001111 \<0§ 003 _§0\\`0 \1¢$<§00§§§;?_, \,_;\(\0 is `

01`\\\ 001 \::0©€0 \f`<\\x 1101§0‘ 0 0§_§§_00_0_ \%§§\§_ _1_0§ 101 QO>§A gc§x_s_
01 0<0‘0001'\0<`\ 1000wa ‘<\\xx\ 03 110 §x'\\r<<§ \j\0 \ix<<_xxx§x\§(§_ \>31\°§*_&_ __§Q_ 1 _§;>x_m§.

 

_`(_\‘_`<>l_‘§>§_

©

\(`\

____¢_i@¢¢_\\ 1 1005 x\‘x§ \_00_1=0§ 00 \x\ 1001 106 ixi_\:_:<§_ _x:§x_x§§§¢§__"

__x_ 1 _§ _1_0__xix Xz§§_i_ Q00 1'\§0 1(_\0§3'__1\§\ '?0<0§30<_0§ 10310€<§§ 00
0\§§\4\1 1§00\_ »x\x\\x \3x0‘x\0€xf 3>0\sx0`0 1 §\§ `

 

 

 

 

0001€>10:00§:0.1:<>§\§11 cxx\§§
1§§10;§0\103§0§0010§__ 00<:0_31§§ 10 ix\x\‘@. 0§30<\ 000§ 3000 ' 0\000\'
30 1103 §`\001\<\3 \x\ 11\<0 10<1 130\§ 1030-10 111 \o¢é§_oxx_ 0§§0_1§%§0100 `

_§0_\§§010>_01§0_§§§ §00_10__000§0\_0§\§ x> 030§'0 1 \0_0_3 ix\x\xzagix§x\

05'\1\\ xxx\xx\m%i 001030_13 _01_':§§\§§,_ 11_1§>0§ 100%>0101§§0_01_§_0§§3

0§001_10_'_§10 \0\0 _m _\0»0\; § 05301§§§\§\~0 §§ 1 _\:3§3_11\§\_
l 10\§ 06 003 000 000 10< <0' 1010 193 \§00;§3§_§ §0;;3 _C§x_\_§_ \m 000§ \000§\§
ix'\c<\f<, 00 031 `\x\ x\0 ix'\xx\ 4 lixix 00 ix`\x`\x§ x\,\§ 1 Q>i%€ 300 ix‘<\§'> 310.1<0114.§1 0_§~0£1\_§0§1)§\>3_<§§&0 ~

\0'\ xx\§x \0x0x`x0 Uxx§ xx\\`x mx\\;`\c.ix\x>§ _1\3¢0_1€00§0§:01¢0\1\_\;0 0<=;30~<10§ c§ 00
01\01_0 0\01

§x\c>s\~

 

 

` 1 _0§000 01 01\01€5> 10 ix\\‘<_ ~&\0'1`\`0\ C§§<§ S`\\L 000\0 \0\1\\ Gx\\x_§_\__'
\‘x\xx 13\' 0\1\03 0\ `§0\\0 \ix§x \\cxs\§‘<:z, me§wix\ _ix\x;§ 0§0;5§;<_'<:1\

Q
10_1'§ ;03_ 0\0§§§<‘<311\<0 \1`\§\0\` 01__§00\§00\§01 xx\\x©ix\\xx\& __
001 3<01~<\§§ 3300~¢‘0 \0§% ma 110031\005` 03¥0§ _000§ 0x033 w\cxs.§'\x\c§xm.

_10__11\§1§00§1§:,1:<§0\&_ 0§0)1_1_\5<§0;;§0<1§ 100003\§§%‘0 03§101_03\§:§1§`§§03<\0(\_ _
1 MWM**AQOS 0011§\00£.§§ :11\"\5 \110\01:<§ -1¢0§00 1\\3\<<.3 01 ' "

 

 

 

 

. ~ .
' __E§§§‘§§§_‘§_§ "\%’b T`§§:§‘€<;<<¢§ *<‘§§§§§§§\OS__ `OC>~§§_;:§§_C\§__ _

__§§§§§s._§__\§a§*<_\§§§§_c>§) §§\z§.<<\§& §§§§§§§<<§__§_§§j__

_§§.§\§\_\§\__ §§§§_§§§_§§;__§§§_§__§§ § ' q ` '\\\ § _§§§___

§§_§§§§§§§§<_§§§§1§ §§§§@____ §<<>><\§§§§§\§M§_
._ _§§_c>§§§_§§_§§§_ §f<_\`\_§__ %§§m<@§§_§§§ §§ 1 \ <>§§1§_______§§¢

' _`\>< _§§§<<§ 1 §§ \<..§ §§ §§5<_\§§§_§§§<§€§§§§)§§§§ §<‘<`\§\; §§ §’_(_

Q<€__*<\<_\Q§§s_§§§§$§§\§§§§§§§§§<§ '

 

 

 

 

 
 

_ ___ §:)__§§§_
\X§ "L\\'\%§¢;§c.<¢ _§§‘<'\<\c<§\>s '\m§ § ~\§§%’\*§\Q~_

 

 

__ v.;:>§§\§§§L\>_§_§§§§<§§_§§§?_§3§s<§§§§_§§§§ §c m Q
.~ \§§§ §§\\§ c§§ J<\§<<. ')\K§=§\ §§ \)<§Q v§‘< §§\§\¢¢ §§ §§ §<§A<§r\,

\X \\§&\\X `§<15§\ §fo<&<<&\ 30 \‘v M¢§ *€§c>i< 1§\ *<<\X\§§ "§§<§1 _H>§§§§_§§§§§§;§_§§;§§\_§§
. %§§<@<_\_0§. _§§_‘&§§§_§§_*€§¢_ \ §§ _§QQ§.
"_ __X§L,_gg_g §HU< §§3< g§§g§ §§§: -‘<§\\§§;§g§\¥ m_\§§§ ;A\§§§_..§S<:§§m§§_
\ o§_§§§_§>§§%§§§§§§§§i§g§§_§§§§§§§§&§§§§…§§&§_
1 r§b\§)§§x§§:§ §§_Q§_M§§§§_ §_m§%§…§
" wm '\§§§§<§ ,§c c§§g\;> §§ §§§ §___§\
_§§___ §\<;§§~;§s_<>§ §§§§§§§§__§o§§§c©_§§_§_§§<§`§§§§§_§§___ ,
>§\`\S ®§\&\d<\§f\ C§§§ brown §§§\\§ § Ci§§§<§b\§ c§b\§*r

 

 

 

 

\)5‘<\€§<<£3 3<‘<\<<. Q,\Lké§§\ §§ -“c\\<§ §SQ§§\§\Q §§ §>'\§\§§5<13 \m§§<\ §
_c§%§x\_‘“§\§§§ §__§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§‘<§_U§U¥ c§§>§ §§
§>Q §w§ § `\<\L§'\%‘\§‘\§\>< §\§§c\ §\§\<\ \<\U §§ ><\\<§ §§\\s §\
. §§ 4‘<\\<\'§ Q§\\G§ §§ §§ §;S§<§€§¢:§>f\§ §§`_\3<@ ~ Q'“` d b S:;_' _
1§ _Q®\K>L\%_£C>SMS§§§ \c\c.<§ 05_`

§>\§\\m§\§c\% §§§ §§\L § §<_§§ §§\"\ \&c§§§§§§§§r§§§§§\§§§§§&§ _,

 

. _ / .
_'§_l*'§_;<\i_\*w_\c>%_;,©§\w‘§; __‘§Q; icc €=L<§<£\_.:x_x§ m&,_`\w\ c>~\:\\\ ~wc»;é 1 mak §§
. \z<¢ Q\Qj\\~é<'w§v `\w_\ X§\~§@"\c _"QQ;<% k&r\ °<<\§~_ csx\d QQ<\XR\\;>R(\Q' c\\c>m ‘<\<\<¢,”Cm<\\ "S_ 5\<\®\&&?<\&\1<<."<\@&:_‘0<<2:\ ' f
_Qcmf\_ciw§ c§<., \DY\L<£§ x\§\§; '\\>S`<_`\;§; ce< z "S:\\ \Q'ggg' `*<\f\u,`-.cs;w;>;_<~_\_;>_<;<;\:5;:5m _
*_§M_LMS_FOQQ@Q_~\_ c)§;<\“~\,x`\lv. _ v   " d   v _ ` '
" P\<\c>`><\<\§;\l>__v§_c@@§%
»\AMA;KM%M§J;§§_`©:L,&;¥<0?__\><@`&££>€:>®
_M_:’;\_L'_<:<_~. "S_` \s¢; <\<@\smw ;>;~>:_*._
_Lc>`)rj§;‘€m$_ OM;MSMN§MS%®§$§_Q§QX&UK® _Q>,.\\é r~<\_<_&ésém.
_ \»\<1<\¢\% mg m W~Qc>x_mi_s_mi;)_@; U~\_x;e<__lx_\z;¢_»<_@v_\@@;§_:;\_
__`©‘_L.._.Q¢\':>L\\\~S_C;\:_CQQ\ ‘¥SC©__§`0:__\$_<35._@§j`(l\&s\_<\£§l\\_>m_;_¢mg_\z§;;>_§g;cx;>(,.
_*Ga§d_@`\\i¢xmz_g;:d_€¢&§er:_a§>o_g§\- \c\’xc> ><\<_\\s_ -mc;_\\ *, .
l _\\os_<;$_§m;_\\o_\°>o:_l©€d - /   \/r w ‘,W/(/Z_/

_;§m, ;MMMMD:QA___ _/`- / :/ v  
_ ;Q;,,\>K_M`_o,,_m<_<< @\Qo\m\' \»\#\»\z'm§&'_$@v§_m@>;g@*\g\@az?>__.
`;Q<‘\:'W Qcmf\*w\ " P\<§OQ 1 j \ - Q‘(D )(\>