Court Opinion

ID: 7193989
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-24 17:00:09.163234+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:16:15.956315
License: Public Domain

The opinion of the Court was delivered by
Bermudez, C. J.
The defendant was indicted for shooting with in-' tent to commit murder, found guilty and sentenced to two years at hard labor. He appeals.
The record contains a bill of .exception to the refusal of the judge to grant a new trial and a motion in arrest of judgment.
In the motion for a new trial complaint is made that important testimony was not given to the jury by reason of an error of the attorney for the defense, who had misunderstood the ruling of the judge touching its admission.
We deem it unnecessary to pass upon this ground of complaint, as we rest our conclusion on the other.
*388The -motion in arrest charges that the indictment is defective and illegal.
1. Because it does not contain the word “wilful.”
2. Because neither the shooting nor the intent is charged with having been done with malice aforethought.
The accused is prosecuted under Sect. 791, R. S., and charged with intent to commit, murder. The indictment expressly charges that the defendant “feloniously did shoot with a dangerous weapon with intent to commit murder”
The State claims that the case falls within the ruling in 36 Ann. 336, while counsel for the accused distinguishes between the cases to show that they do not clash.
Considering the rulings in 33 Ann. 922; 36 Ann. 100, and in 37 Ann. 776, and Sect. 1048 of the Revised Statutes, we regard that invoked by the State as merely constituting res judie,ata, and do not propose to repeat it.
We therefore conclude that the indictment is defective in not charging that the shooting was done also wilfully and with malice aforethought.
It is therefore ordered and decreed that the verdict and sentence be avoided, annulled and reversed, and that the indictment be quashed, the accused to remain in custody to await the further action of the District Court of the Parish of East Baton Rouge-