Court Opinion

ID: 4056692
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:04:31.96517+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:15.682079
License: Public Domain

§
,.'.~‘_4_.$__'-

.._....~.4.4..__._ _ _._4_4»_ 4 445

4 _ -.` 4_..4....44..5...4.._5...

 

» This do::umon‘t contains Some
pages.»t?l zr#~are Gf-po_or quality¢~~ ;
at the tim:z of nmagihg.

.4.4'444_..__.» -. .4,4 ... .‘_...44._.._“ . 44

. RECEl\/ED|N _ 4
C’€)UR'T OF CR|F!HNAL AF’PEALS § m

 

`EOV\AS `*'

{.<3§344`1<3 .4.4
343 15 667 533

KT. 355 4

44.4.,;-.._...‘5145,.. ,._.

14 -_44 ~¢"_ .Lr.-x-:

 

 

… ., 96 3144 Q>@©@:>H 11,1_0521154 44 4…44
444444_4...44 DAL)._)‘\_§ l >4 7\":1@64_4444 44 44 4.44, 44 4_ 44._44444_444 _.44444__
z _ y __ A"~emco 4a, Cer w ;_ ___,
A`TTI;J ; /A\B'S\_ A`:o §TA)_(":§.FQ\<' ` 44… 4_ .'4.4 4444_4

c ` `_’ v \

4’1)§Qun_:r_'_401344(.;£1;;1:3:441344£34€§344;;\45_44§344|434>444'?»4§_43,4 1

.¢~..-..~¢_...1._4_._.....44..».»,. 457 4_... ..._...__.¢.. »4._ 45_- ».~=_._-..~_-4

               

 

 

 

 

44444_4444_44 3244 M;rss;r~e mg 35 :444 434§¢1._4 440_344€¢14¢24444@: 4:<>3_544
4444444 . 1 NVV\@§(L n w 4444..444 444 44__ 4444444 4;)44 44 ,_4~'_444. 4.44 444 444..44444
3 M{L AOOS~A ~‘-~ »~ ~'-~ .~*~~=~‘"‘“‘*4*_‘.‘“"~~"“~“~*»-~:

 

 

 

_.,.4.__.._.\_ . ........_4. .._4¢._..

__ ~...»<~1_.`... ..__>¢. __;. 14__5.

4l:N

_4444@;05_\;)4_44.§444 lS\S"~r~* 644PA 645 4:3:@4.. 337 P"H*U or_>)4_444_.
3@4:14343@". 333©3 FQQMGI:;:M /4!\31<11>1)3133 303 3333
r\)_O 4

.»»4 4m5.(_ 1~`- »- 4.=..4»¢..

.....{41_ ..._4.__.__.... - _.4.. .4.4_.._....4_4. .4.___..._..

 

: 144A4)4\133;\:34§T 57 F03165~3 T'n Rh” ”mm' PA6§44::;4\1.

443 333:44!§»1\01§41§44443~\4340>/4§@5§£464+.:1: 4_4.44.4444 4 41444 44 44444 444
\4454\\\< vw 303 475\)4?4 555:1:54&440§4;44\43:314`1'344444
mm§@ ` " ’ ~ ‘

4.. _..._ - 4..~.5..44 .45,4_.44. _4.-4_4._1. .».;~._ -~4:¢4534 m»4434/&4§44

....».~4 ' 4:~4 ~ r4`_~ »»,-4-.

 

_,. _r . __.
. .`..1.,¢>1,.~,1.,».+.:..~§/__¢»;».,@:\' _@:~;-..C fm m;r.,‘.\\.._r\.-.‘__A_e>.@.\=._m`:~,“; n.~a- .,E_~QE_.WLE_>.<_»<_».\§

~,` w.~ .__ ._..

 

 

.....`... .....`,. ,

»_~,LMB..~=._SQC'»°_Lli‘;p..§;\/,..Qo_u.&l@_u;.>_“\§ c/1
W’:kf§~.. _~_

.._,- “,.,.~__...r`.~__._v-g§.$_€". "’¢~\ 75 Y\ A.\.':'.,H_o:£>aj;;;l§-»_§m.;:.~_l_*§..¢.£e:. .QIT~.,Q.EM|F_`{¢LJ~T F)F v .…..
P¢Lo_aa'.ib;i¢r 'io-\l., \`/\ ;\"-l_o rs 1=

 

, \
,_mL>Imj;.Of_~.. M-Aw)./§;E_._\l~<__:i,,p.aja~,o.FM§.a`.~,\/.'r.-.,H_:.;JMWM,,
, ,…H.A»LDAM.»);&__._M A'~/._B&. _u,;»_r;.;) T_o._sal/45:D'i,...f’.\,A...;L.¢..'.r;l__§w;\-c>,o,v..mlm¢za.D;E:\Z\.J;M.m,.;$.~v_.¢$
_ _Ww\_N.=L-_B;c»_er§§.,_m'.....'e><,c.e§usmn:ar_._<.o.um;‘_s.vhms.u:.sa:¢~..\}_..SI.A:\.§“E>:.,..'.'.<)“;.L..~-M:g,_sa @M_v._.l.¢.?.»,y~;b_..lvm:hl§,_
….~_,<,_;o.“¢_~;1:.§>¢.)'_9.§_.)`:1.»\19..1)1§:1\_)__<.M€?_&o._<,er..u:._'_~»c¢$_,:r~w:._._~._e@\.~._¢_..`f._~¢.g`:_;>,._`f._H,»__<\..s;,._.s.amwe,.;r;;mE-.s-.Br\;.@.r_~»*_v§.§m'o-_uz~;;,_c,.a.\z_@.:<._
4_,,_,_40.@§'&5.~,:“.»L.b:\'&f~:`sw.#,\:.A\._\,MQ_\):\;:-,:oa__:r,+.+:=._DIc.~nAw;E>-,_o,&,.sm:;.n;>;r.o,»@,,_..o&~oasg:`s;o.¢~)&\\,_.-\.A_»`L,..E;~!_E.'>).*-~..__.
, _ . moved .._IH,@;~!.”.!:1_1:\.‘..1...H.m-s,,_‘.@ze.v>\,.“H;T.d:cmdm.X;H.c-.,_M:F:o,:.~t_c».¢_.>.-.“,o.r,a..'..u,x=.mcQQ.Q~T;._:.<>..MA\<13“\-§,):,E_...E><”.PA-`(:[.'§:>\)_Q¢€.$,»E/,\:c_\_u.c~;-'WT,Q__*_
_._._ ,-A`M_Eo»a..\,ov-`\ L,A»,~\ .&_A:'H@§’>rr'_u f>..~~,\ .\o~\.....c¢um';;...,LA~c,.\_<..c;.“.is_u:s:p ¢,r;:n~:z_~:m_tim;&.&.ae>o.§&_;_~l:z.._€/:QC.CEH§_H\:UA ,.<)_`LE\._.
...SH..../Lp €),.`.`I.l_,(o."..`|;’>._(`TEx.AW\ B»g/wr!om’ .\_°¥K.l,.N§_..An.:r_:;)..-.,_v,:c_<);~.m:zo,_\).-_OE,_L¢>E),Q;._S:/;\.N.o:».~)g,.~.C)§ngLA.¢>t.._~_
g .n..`H_§LD..--r:o -BE.\.AU‘..E><<,E§<):A€ .<.ousm“.s . dy. -;LS . i?&z§:xs\;\_~?r..j;uri,_:r.$~fv E._ .. .ELATo,C\J$.,.?.~AISE,‘>\_Q- §'~L',.U;HI_S. ,-5 ;LIE-E`._D,E£<;.S§.¢N AL., B< C_Q :»\§F:rn'.mfa:oua;~_.,
_ _. ___,L n w~.&xsgu:r»i~&$. _/.\,_ _ourz\;_ry, AL._.DI; FKNDA-m.;?>&_e_m~.n;§p.-_ _4.E,;)__.,&'E.,~g:»~z:_-\).L,`_».~\.H~r<.;-,~`.>..“T..H.£&§...NM,MB.&LN,~A.M\?`
A&s &€sa~_.,:ro.,)¢.,,o§,. .r.<:.e.m;s ; r.l».4::§...~o,<,_,',»r_w.~r§;~>~.£:’1./§\_~/M..L`»_,')_.<),J._E‘),,

 

 

 

 

 

 

,.-

__~Wl’_>( :T;_s).r;..PM.s».EB_-m:;z.<)z>l._\\,s.-..\:\~ili“_€c;a£§.&,,.\/_E,H:z.€<;,_&..lé,,_.€.f_‘\§:!;_§‘.~\? ..._/~\.,\:_`u‘);v:t?,~&,.,,A.mi~;M;mD.H.;Jé

 

...... .. . .. v ~ ..~..,_..,._... _._,_-_....-{........_....M._.._...-_'m....L...A_mc¢:_(§.......

 

,. ,,,B._»; \,mo_r\H_A.:; H.ol_g: D. live CQ ') 931 _~:i,z».,,._i>:_:,m;c§§..` .c..¢;u.-.,) s.§_L“_K/;J;§_q_.~),_s_§:\;§Qwu.§*_svg~;”\';i:\__._.
.,Ru:)\‘vov.' 3_ c»s:_ me r.wv;_v, lew~'~§$ Tv. D.Ism§\E.LI \~Iri...<‘AY:’..A:r.~*jl”_m15\f§»$i\t..z.'§<.&f,)z\¢.\”»_h _* ~_, .,.
._ VM,N:&TJ¢A__AS ,Pa,o\?§w` &f.m&,D_>/,_T.o. .P;a`§_\l'_§fr>b'_.c,o_!.am:&slo.,\l o,F,,.F\n'y!L§, )s\c,*r ,am;NEK;'N;.=~> fm ~ ~D o 1

.M.._._-.AQ.T__AL/rz,§£\\)jz...£.r; a r.-‘Q r>.t:l s‘»)__ ,_ S:e\:;.§_,_ E><_R§'~.. N: ~:s..$s€m_;,¢__,Lo ha nw .1,§‘-’1»$\¢~\£147 311 `Q__),,§f.$;l=.£i:>\_”.!§m("€a:u_~¢.
.M-~A er_\£i§$.‘§, -|?.@,o;u cs::r¢§¢.<)~_¢\.s_@`1:_».».\10)_.7.,_&.~/...._»,1.hchsa.,suenf§o,&,_oo.o;rm's~ e.’:~_e:v_§;i>ix~.§_'§_$_§_r_~'a“o:\;r_<:ci°>u~ ~@..\¢.~S_.,~___~
...,',,,,,\.o'é\=.tc,§ 9$~,.&..€.‘\5;,0... 5_ .,F&an...usu_?£lr§§... of?\.~£s<.§c_o;c.sm\.;¢;...._u;u.._ ;>Ql",<‘;:r~__ ;.M ,§_)¢ .__,__ . .§..5¢ _- _.

~ _____,,.Lg_§l.A;~‘_c,:_y__<-`;; sj__@.QS. .‘S-\:.~`_l_o”§§i¥.*\.,_.%_l:\"§~(.C¢?>:L)\\~;\_~A.F;j€..._\_c_\§;>_,_~S.TA:\:!jr;>;::;§::§/);r::;_:c§?iw®opw

__W_W__~é~f.(g§_,$,\d:)_.p.,l..é9, 193VQCQ,:\€>¢._AFA?M.,.@._°\`A`.`!¢\._)...,.,. n ~w“

.W,.,»..._q.,.....`_.. ...._._.,.~- M~.. ... . `

_ _ ,n_m .. …_. _...` ~__M___~ _~._,_ ._ w _,mh ., M~_,.* w..~_.,._~.__

 

_, __l.ms_.. Qov.n:i:___l:|.m)*-/:.\...H:r§;§:§.&l)§;_ D~rr~/ T _R,§,L,x,§:_;,»= C.€w.<\'>`~§.L A'\Z.acr:.¢~\;v Qr~\q?.:\.e.:...,._.\~_;e=_:,w~x.<,M._.'E.zs§;,Lg.:,;§.._."Nm`-Mm“_~._. ,...._W.W~
.. ._ _ .D::s.;,&\z`T;o;»J ..oz»\ Ujuue§§~'\§\~`li’,.. .- ~ ,_~M.,-- -.-m_-~ '

 

A¢~\ ACU .o_\;\,v_‘fs.,pco:»~\_s:r_\.`).'éf~’_xb,. wv~.4;r r,~n:&`.f,c;¢»?\::.)§L,v_~) H§»,:>l _‘:1.\~_\ §....,LA'!>\ ~_oL.EA&L>/._»s'&&.L.;§M_ou§;_,):\.D,~.»I;~/_;COAG.E.,

. _ ..? E,&F.QQ\MeD_My.~\;T_.Hl_S,.v_c/H_.K;E&TT,AIM.TH.-F'H.)_\T. ,v>io:!ilz>!_§.,.;§_ .LEH,J;Q_..E,>,<'E;r?\€:c.s.t~‘,“.b:.r.-s~.cerx;;o.xJ__~Qoz\”~ _
, -..ot;zo,es_m§.m‘§'{z>ws wD~$.P.T <>,F ..C<>\.=~n`§¢.mo..~.;s,,.,E,._~\_,-..»/..,.Da_¢.cé..\m§.\.Q»;LL,_§_`»>\IL>SLD.,H_L_ W(_C_a.zn.._)§r_r_(fii§‘D.
… _»'_M_e\._w_¢_\sz\__.\);.,,,.m__ _.Ae,sr;~_a§.¢.~¢:m:g__».§.u n.~.§~,~o.»l».>,._oi¢_a~y_a`o:§.)9_\_-ogo.@&“m.a:z_..%_§wri~:£&§`»DN.,_»SJ;L\-.r;§.“r;>gmg§.__
H<>L,M_e§ v D&“»~\:\ o.;'\.,`£>_`,,`l_| 5.\¢~\ 1203 q 6~)39».°\`..(@.¢'<1¢:;./§£? \3%‘#{).. … W.__.
-:L'.`\ zu¢§ .cv\:;.&. _A-_r_ Bm\:r~m- mg *.»)a,a.~»,,
~. _ s NO‘.).L 01 ..HAVE ..B.E; §r..~\~`d:m\#.\:s\$§o‘._;!z€ mv:o?.~_. F:'~,&D.L. .A.~M..o::mgpm;».m;s;s,_~§_oup_s_g.¢~a;£:;lz\:\;ug_CQ-Ja;r.
_ ABE r/;lz\:~) 65 ,, m v,:~_\ ,s._§;L_ _c,om,£u§:;.ril_»wb.§ ~..`AE;D~)§: .,¢_\:;O‘.@`,¢ g:;\§_..~§/<>~. s'.“v::r_u~».:r¢.>,v.s\.;._.\l:'_é;.w:r; _.Tomé€§:,\i$:r;§;~¥c;gw~
~,,....,..c)`&»_(`&u.~.ls§ \,..-Mfl '\ mv q.~a‘\';g§..,.¢\¢.»_oy?§§)... ‘r;)s\;s§¢.);~:m& ~.c,l§-:.\;c.._l’>.&~-_;uSr;p~;?.¢z,.§~ adc,z:_.,£~£;»r§lo.f;,)~E.AJS_ED~TL~
_ .. .-_-.;E»__u.u_.;§.~ I.Z§u=.=:<).a\s,. S_~,:m_\nio:pm. K:ce,m:§.....m;.,G.p_/.¢`».\.D.,.;):'_ed~/_,...m:_\¢_e‘» ~,-_¢.__.a.l.\._.z__w..o_~a,o,¢>\_s*_&/.\:¢_»_&:Q._::Q,~my.-§".
W.-,.---.\Z¢Lo -»er;~ H.cn'r Qf~>,f_~\ HE-AQ._D., ,.oNL>/M§f:&'r§§..\?»c§13,-£\.._6*@.~&&\:1€~;s>\:\,'_,_‘$.r;:.e;;,._Ts,z,.a::.;orz`,”_
~_”~&§.53¢>»,9*0____1¢- . P>Q.L.Aii', Q;{.)`s_hmmz.\)>§i o:ai.$_;?.?::...m §s:T.'_~NI:&..,£E:-.);\:v;oj?`_Qr.L~_i-:ma;u‘_‘:r,)_