Court Opinion

ID: 4054645
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 05:45:50.768711+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:24.628347
License: Public Domain

-·

                                                                                   l l ,.CT3~ ~ol.l
•
                                   .                               .                     .

    _ _ _ _ _____.~_o.sbAIUl6Lj_1i~dd_'l_?..t:£J_~-------Abei-Acosta~Gierk----

               ·ro_:._-d.M._t_&QS?/1/ c~=L-'---
                           -u:~-~-c~z:J!_/_~~-'~~/ #tJ.4Mtt_____ ~·-____·____-_
                           I?    11
                            _.a_.oax_·              ' •           "
                                       Ltlst28__~Djl~·&_ L__;£fdli"AL--___
                                                                                .
                                                                         - _·_. _ _ _ _ _ __

•   --------'--

    _ _ _1<'-----""'e£_:
                           /brS_~d.,_'li.~¥ 78_7//

                            E~~-tU£~ /-/JIM~         c Co.!!r~J_Ait..U1!_7_U,L(L__
                                                                                       ________

     _ _ ______.u                                   c.
                               c-1. .;Vo_.__ /1- I~ /Jc · o7~~·o ¥12€.8 -
                _ _121_o·~<!:!~_b_~~9-Lu/h.~J~Z.L6 )_ _

       ----/J=~=---_Lft_t_,_kCJ.f_['~l----------------
    ---~f!'N_~Ia_s~;/_fCi~A. /:v~_dpft&~~~rs IML&.o~-~d___
                                                         · .-'-~
    ________&_/!l._v:h..__b~~   Sul'fi-~~L-k_/¥FI~bc-~1Yf---
     ---~~~i ~V'IS<.~.f__-~_,(J__Rh..-,-!Juf&_/ hbhfl~ ___-ha_ __
    __ ___sz~rL.s_&"-L'r;.,.:.v~ / Ousw.i£&..-~_L;)_.~L__cf9URLZS -:-.__
              _ _·.        ~~~L~7_t!J£' ka_~-<>_R.J.,_~~~~Ac.b.aM w,-;,t,___
    --=-----_ _ _ /lcc_~~~~L'-~9                 /J'Io ko~ B~IJ £.fj,_,!J_,·y_(/}J -(lSJ_j_ __

·---·~fl~L f~-1-~M~-~--::- ~-~A.£Lo~9_·~
                      ~~ ~-~-~AL.....LoM'_o_Y::'h_,___:___ .J fLpr__?L_...('____!!__   _Si'VIJ_ _ _ __
    _ _ _ _C~.d-r._lf_y~CD~y s~ 4./J - LoJtM- U_~ -J _ _ __
          _ _____,_hiJV'.IL_£__/C.dALM._a__      4    Co.Jd--y~L~iLM h~;~ '1-o~-.__,__._
                                                --ft-)--------
  .,rlj   ~'   I            ~­
   •           '""--~-   7)

.. . . : ~.        r'>-~r

•.             ,

               _ _+/,h__~_j;_L~L~L_fl,.s TN"c_f /J~~-~-lh.€o 'Te:ulJ~~~-
               --~M_··.%N c/,cr,~~-f£_c;L /N ~r/k_c~lL~bL It ..s4 ,_ v1~ k.. "--~•-'-----
               ----.1-do_~~d&~~·· ~/J/u._v_~Ztf.                                    VdUA-    ~IL-~-a,.,.··_ __
               _ _ _ ,(MSL.SfL'hJ_c.L_LY~~j__ /?l~t/b__.t!!hy_<J_·A                         e/~· ku~__A.~_·_.---:---
               __     .. ~~/d
                 · M}c_                                    rr-~--"-fkc~~~-1!1!1/i._/I_C!atJ-y-oL~Lj_~~~~-
                                 A   .   .   ·U   .il~..
               ---~0-V:.M-~ __ l«L.-'-~-~/i..._ae:.
                                                             • :,-/.   1/   / f'~    .1' '/•/ .   /·
                                                                                    12_&1~-~-~~'---~~-
                                                                                                          .
               ----,----,-__,f.fl.c_ad_f_._·_'7hLb.LL__~a.U_L~_,g_;L_v~CU.---------~

·-~-'----
    --·     - . ~·
                                                                     -                         ~(Q)l~©!Nl [Q)~INJ~~[Q)
.,                                   ·.                                      . .          ~    o~1rre:       \o ---(5 -(S
           _____                  4~_Th4.__C€1.U4 o~£ C~-_;A>£/l"'v~j[).t_____· ______-
          --------------------~e~ ZL~~~------
                                                                                      '                 t

             __.~-JUJ&IL
          ___£_                       .           .·   .                 ·   4/v Zlt,t._/)ls_:L~e..I Coua.tc__~~-----

          ------------------------ _.-·-~"'..l__c~~4--'ll~~n-:i'=-=-------
                                                  -t                                                              ~-         ---
          ~.Appu~7~:___/11o_~o~-~~-uAvL ~                                                     £a        S'v~JfJ-~2-               __
          --~--dpAt.~~r:r--~~~r.tL '!I'(Av_~_ ~<J_f.L_ 6~/krL~~---
•         _ _,/J._i,_b_ o~____sf.o --~7J'Yl!L$_{)u_:;_L~~/ ~.SC<LM-_&:Y4__&~L'-----­
          _ _Lo...u_~[;r            £'~1?1'//~9-             s /     k_r..r         A7-.a_JU. comA?~ e:/.~12~-·_

            _______· 'To_._-/lt& /~&Lo;1...4:_~lL                    '.Jv4-L.r o£'            S-4-//J       C~~r
          ____y 00__Co,.,~- /11___Mul C&ll&~.t: Alu.hQ-~-k.IY                                       i/;A.. &,ll~~r,_______
          _ ·__ fMA ~~ salt .Lo                            /'WI ov.A._'i:6;_j_c~4_,7            fJ-uA..-:S_CL~           ..L..o-=:
                                                                                                                                 '-------

          ___n~_lbf__tU,/IU' o£                            t/pA,,{,{[..g..fL__· 1!__/UL~~~                   ~!£._('~------
    . ______2J_2_ ~~- -5~-·2lA) 1-o_S~.IJ/l~~/ b~J-4·~-'--l'::l'~--
           t!),u~L~4-/ ~A-6M4 ~v/iA..S£ &.sj}.~&SA.. ~ L£6ufht.f ___
          ---~_s_z~us. t1u~;~_L:£L4.L.Su..tLA.._rb. 2/~n_ -~--a_ __
                /M.s~T ~ o~~·ha;_,wf. ~-c2·:r-~.-c.._c~·~r- /J/~~-'-'_/£'-=-----
              . Ceu-t4--T~_b_M_~~7_·0_1' ~-J:.f-~1() U c~-nt~~_d/fdLo~_.:_
•         _ _ _At'----"-'---=~_a___01'Ldkt    4

          c---;------=-Th~iJ'---m~oh,__o~_i_c_l sw~Mi.lkL · ~~[___'j!_ao_d. ~-/'---'-J.,._t,_,_______
                                                                                                            ~~

          _ _ _ &~.Q_uo_L.. cLa,;v._/t.._io_A.M.M...! tJ.<. VM.ui. s.s~ /_'4-
          ___ c/ll.L~~~-~~J-1Y~~-~~-6M/~~LL.,;_d&__ w~/-''~.,_·______
                     -   ---- _.. :__.. _______ --- ----- ·-- --- -- ---f-1-)----
•
'

    __c___b.u'-Lc/o)..L£_-~iw__..jJ_A.,__.7bLL.~Z -D fiY Ju..s -rt ~~--~LV51_ __
    ---_&_;_ui£~-·--                    .
                                             ,   .   (
                                                             -                   .        '
                                                                                                             .
                                                                                                             ~

    ~----------=~--=-/;iAL_~--p~t:Mis_u_~o&:__S_LdALr.LcL_~~~--
                       •            .                    .                                                                            .   L

    ~-/kpiJ-~-~z -jJ~                        ~ad__·l:4_i_j_ C(!)~A--7'                                           ~~T dLJJ_·_ ___:_______
    _ _ /!!to-ka~ . ;~- efi..Jt~~?f-~~-----!7-~7                                                                     ../A,4_ tU./L£'-=---/-~- -
     _ _'f/,iJ        c(J)_vA-r__ c/~_.r_· ~~A~t.re-~                                                            -                .
    ______________ · S: o_l_Li__L_/!~,(d

                                                                 1?4 spur(,4_
                                                                            _S'uh~;Mrlfu_
                                                                 M~~r             .--
•                                                ----~M~~~cL/ ~ll/MJ_AfM7-WW~---
                                                                 roc::; No. ISCZ,J:JJS

    _____:r__c;lp__~___!J_-y~~/z..-fl~~/4                           9   L ~IUJ_dt.~~--4~ - - -
    ------~A. ~9-{2_;~9- /J ~15._./9?.-A_~z: ~- L-o._____
    ____$.~v/(c/ h~_- /!__ku_M_ -.dll. _~~£ ,./:._, /!}- t/, r. m~---''------
       -~-=-o~__()_/Y 'Jh/{_ /~// Vh,~~ A//,us1' k -/4;{.. C/.rf/_,.;,~_-_____
          'It       ""                 I~--
    ____ht_o_t_u__.J_y,_l.u.Uiili!L .t4'J 1L ·d~_o L' ~;i:il ;1_Q 1-:[_-_-__
                                                                     • •

                                                                           - _ _ __
                                                                                                                      t-

                V)   1h '- .·
    --------''----l.oSA-                                                a 4«:
                                                                  z'.,f?:B·
                         __ lf-()___"'l71M.-LJi_ _ _ _ _______:___~~~~~~~~-~~~~-
        ''Dt~fM~l ~~___l[t,_~                                           MMc.IT.J                                 Co/1//.../J      Uw4f(_«Lu--_
•    ___fto_Bo~. l?'fS                                                  1M.!Lk..ll fJhif;_                                     TPc,rtJo. Ar93~3S
    _ _tk.sr;~r_,:f£¥ r-rf ~8_/Jb-7_ _ _ _ _                                           ____- - - - '- -
                                                                                  _b_~_s-
                                                                        ________:13"'-----'o=------=o=---r'--------,_-/11._.

            -~------------------=------------
                                                                        ~.shM.-cAJ OIL~~ :?IJ.58J
    -------·---- -~--------------- ------- ------~ __(*1. J~--       ____elL()_ - sli