Court Opinion

ID: 4058013
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:55:10.569747+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:27:39.097638
License: Public Domain

_                 - _                               -                               1&1!~-IL{
I   ,   ,    ,                                  C:.Ausz._ AlfJ:IF   II ct~ ;a} 3 3            o )·I q t-'t-'ifj, 11   9~·Lf-0d-
            ~~~ ~ \ l.U~~\e.- Z. L                                               "-              I J ~ Nohot-J 1.6 5tcotJJ urJd w/fAJl.SS bY -1-ht.
            X- ?JMalhvn 94'?~         :::fo.ua.~o.J .j •MvJ·~:.~ ·a.JJ tol<.. \u...\LlM'LK. .surreJzf- 'I wJI{ BhouJ t-V! i-s
                j.,no~Mn Ti ~ ('-t'l.            r                   1                .
            hE0tJ~\.t.. ti.\'#1.\.t-.lQ.\ ~uli.c\-0 ck o??r'H~               +V!t rollowi,J~)
                                                                   I
            '\U:~.Suo~ \-D""f'tx:AU Zllt-s
                                                                                                                      1
                                                    c1 AP?zlla-h. . ?tzoa&l!u12z 2JJI£ 1L I, A 'Jtlo/-,c,IIJ Mz.. Lu1J'i fo flh'>
            v~.~\- C\.~oMW\!11'1 ft-rJ          ~~~\ ct Ml-\~dAMU.J
                                                                   E.
            U     wQ..\.\- o( MA-rudArJt.l.S r L.Jt'll shot.AJ A PilZ.Sz~-1- /JNJ fu-!u122. M1:S CJI-(.f ia6t tJ( Ju5-l-ic1.
         'ih Sheu.JirJ6 -\-r\1o l t.W\\\ 'G"L toot;.NO,                 toe-
                                                                     +11z. l'.oul-ts to rvft\-\1_7.. ~SoutJJ Jud6fJtll5Jtft n.AJal
          ~'il\\~\. '\Ul\'i.( £...'L&U£.&\tl 'o"/ M'i.. iJ ~tu.o1.Ja, \0~-\: .\="ou.. t.o.JQ_\:- tJot ft) VI1.A:(..~·l:s.
          Nl\.\\'i...~ \:::. 1\ u\1)\t\\\~ 10~ 1~'1 G,(;)J &iJt..J 'ZiG~-h arJd Mv turJdaM~,;~d Co0G+ih.~.:ho~al2i6ht.s_
           %'UU..\ oiZ.1... ~ 6 +M ltJ a 1\1 Dfi utJ D~ J ucrh cL +ln. to u ll-4- ~ irJ ou IcJ Gi7....P1~ fV1 o-l-iaJ

                                                                                                   ~{)v/!e?&
                   £\\8-...1 l) lO lS                                                           ~a ~. uJh/-h. -zLJMrJo,e,~0 AMtR..ir:lfvJ
                                                                                                     'Fiibu.sorJ WflUhousL
                                                                                                      % ruzo     5!hJ#bl.            DR-
                                                                                                      M idwR{             'J£xf.!s    '1SB S'L

                 ,, - ~ ,, 1 0     75
                                         C.f\uSi AJo tt= I Iq tf>o'6 o o l\ q 11~ 'rJ o II        97'1-h-1 1J
    '
        J~\\uQ              D. w~~-e. -ZL
'
                                                                                        TtJ \\AL           L.ouus of
                      \1~                                                                C:IU~V\\wc.\ ~mA-ls Dt              1ixt15
        7hz 5/AJl!JF'JfY!to                                                                AuotiiJ J{y/15
                                                     \\\\txt    D\     Mt\Nd Avt-f!AS
        ·~ ·.fh'i..   hDf\Je>wbl'i. tau e..\:-   o~ tbM\~a\ 1.\~fttkl:
             ffi-ML 1\lcw~""L\.\o~\nuo.. f) ·~rre..-l.L~~oo~s\A ~M'tt-iMJl 1 .I.0 Pw'PJ2.1A- ?rz..c~ze.A                              fJ-
        ~~      CL\nD\)l.    6.~'1\iJ Ct~d UU&t NUI\/1\J'i-iL b~ t'lt.hl)~ ~\\'L ~\~ uJixt fk                 f..)ArJdP.I'1At.JS   ?uiZJU~
        \D o.:e..-\\~\t. "1.04 ck ~-L, Wk-5 CDdt cl ~UWiiJ~\ ?RouJutl-'L 6/\lo.l                         +o :)uPPoe+ U1,;s w{L\t
        L w\\\.s~DW \\!\.~(::. \i\.D~Ovt\\b1\i. t~u \L~ \\!\. 'L fo\\ow iJ6 j
                                                         I
        \ .\J\. ,l.j,:~OJ""'ull. t0.os~~~-tl)~oo.u~~ fwltl.\r.u.J.~ ·-:r:s i·JtA-etiL~hdl o.t- a. Wtt~ JJZ?A-12-t-
        u~\ & t.a.:w\\~\ ~U;)~u.filXSJeo~o~~ utldt~ 0.~ ocwutJ-t ,Ju;V~bill.~rJt.JJI.fbzw liDI.oo .&.t.oc.,)'-/:rOWA'f,lzx'A-5)'75'3JZ
                                                      JL.
        Z...D\ M'l ~~ 5\~\\~ ro(J\.~1..\                       M."L   ~ 'i\w.YL LMih.tJ -\\ML-.D~~~\.t"l 1cJd ~a.!.i...
        \~ \1\t.\, tv\."L ~'L?~~"L ~o~ ~r-) ('1\t_i\~L.<\ {\~M1t0t~

                                                      :ill:
         ~.0\. ~ .J \IJI qj W\'5 \-\4\'XSU.~ tcu~\-{ 'Ux~\.~ t\.s.~X-.. \Zlb.i~ic\ &t.\~               \\\J     u~d J/.01 \N~,\       o\:
        ~'ti't~ ~ ~~ ~ ~'i~\-\o~'- t.eu.dic-ht,~N bY-Hn ST!trt eJ~ -thU:ou~5
        3.()(), lnu.«.-~"!·~11\-\'L Al'\.\d ;h i-i?f-..'i.SS,J-ttll'i.S t..JI\~ ~i~~~U. eDr.\~ir!t\ jut-\Jdictfo.-J JWd w\1<1J
        5-il~tJC:..\. 'ottorlll..~ Pr Q.Y\f'l:t-<\t.-\:/,tJ -.I!YA5

         -/
                                                U{ LAw/ MfrdAv,.+                 h   SJ??oU 'N'tr\: D( MatJdAtv1u:5.                       ·

                                                       '               .
        -::L \L\DS\'\ua O.w~;\e..- tL ''LJifl1 C.ltA;J #A~J~) to0-\uJds ~oJ .a difws 2. o( LAcJ1
                                            l                                                                                 IOt
        ju\C-.Jtlit.\\~· Du~(_ \\1\L .Sub.ltt+ NfililL NA-1 bt TGAi5rJ u-f--4rJ'I },'VIAl. futAi nrJ tJ'iP!A/.,/tr'/1 JD?
         £.lt.0t\uQO~ >J:) \h.\idA'i ?c~'L ot~\c.£ Cotz'\' i.f1'1> 5o').) Jhfi.ih~t.z. JSJJOdtsterc+iOJ+o
         i{jl\lflf-.'7.. litt.'L D( Jut~~Ji th·o.J ).ln'l t'L \1 :':-! Ll. s.)'-/ 1-~ ..5d 2../s- \ 4-~L LrAW ?1Wwd~ -U, a+- tJrJN.
         S7A-Tl3 Juri:didroJ !JA6 btirl thilll7tJb£J, /~ Mus+ bt nz6ui,J .Nul~ ~S.1hlboufo~7/00J; c.+
          'JSD2-. lfJz, buK£J1tJ -i+JsrJ ShJta h -1.-~t toud-:> tu ftlout Juei~ehc.J,d;J 'ZuszMorJd liS, MtYJblic-1-
           '-/ttJ. q F.;Z} '/J!P .. Bu'AJv~ .J.M. lAw t:.lo.u/a,    P£vti           ~ ~ud5drtJ,o~ to fJ.?f't#f- (!)N t-Vll- TZfCotZJ
          ef:: \-\1\t. o.lM\~is~-h~ QG1tJtv a,vJ A-ll rtd!llliAJ/5-lz~ivt 'P7ue.crz)/NG, I~A&AJS vs LAulwt.. '-liS fJJ.s--13.
          %oufoK.t whtJJ JuiisdictioJ 8~ .4c1JL11Nt&·h:·,th v2.. A62tJC:IttrJd i-l- 'PZocnliwC:, Wf/6 thAIIrtlh t
        "tJY Mi. Qt0cl .JO'Jl Wit'!> ?tvuuJ ~£ (ou,t,b +n5,J biJ'tz Jhi UU.J. r_f lfUltf.s t.\·100Sl.. +o j{.ffi? .5iltrJC[
         Dr-} \.\.-\L ciJAlkNl!:il o(JuersJic.-f.t·aJJ 1\Atuh bY IIAl, cJd MAtltJG 6iJrtJCC. ·fl- thf'ltEMAn: tNowitJG +hAt-
          sd~rJtf tohl.Shht~~ 'Mfi;JJ £.2f'JU51Al-ltJ,& of tn'i f.:yi~~-AtJC0 ~G (At-\- j,J &uul·io.JJ {AfC.IVIINL uS
          fu.JHJ /1) 'fA 932..,\'Wi..~ G.~'/ \u.~L\:\{\~,-lh~i. \\t\cA·             w-A"&   i\\l.GiAIIv' 6i\J'i,J,

                                                            A\Wt\ui'l
         I ):)~'\\lAo. ~~\D\r\ke. -iL;)MoD~\~"' t\-Cv\'Z-Qlt.v\~, \~ 9\l.U?a~l\- ~t.e-~l-1& JUtJdr~\fi,Ju} atJJ of SourJd
         ~\1\.\d.. M~1- ~\S ~\dM'l\: wi\.\J~\~_hf\-J ~i\~t ~~c\. -~~rc.1c.D! .fa·\~) 'oi\SiJ orJ M'-1 fzll{.oAf a I .
         ~~\'tlc::-i o10o\ 1vYLh'i~ ~a.\- L~ a\I+V!irJW hnuiJ is-l-wz. ar~d come+ Dt0d ~?abv dfPtJSf otJJJAvj
          lvn~ oJCd.A0\-\: ~"M\\ \u.0.;\J\"~ t.o\lc;,\ooRc.:h. ltw~ su??oz...~ M'-/ \.Ji.t-\: o~ t\-P\\_-,tro Co~t..tli //.o1
          o.uJW~i-\: ·of MAJdAMW.,&.NJ wiU)J (u£-U,'liL-SfrtL+ha+ I( r.oud-6 ·~aiJ SiltrJ~ orJ o/1 issul.J
          "'OU t.):.}&Xt'.- atJd ~Ui wi-\~ t~\itZ/-!.ArJ\f f11cJ ~ ~i-Atw~rlts cr~ AdY~>?i55iOtJ~ wl1id1ae.LtJOf
           d£.~iiA w\~ suWoe4;~ lutdrrJct 011.1d ·?ArAltu J,qtih' ?aiJ-\-- tDe. ~lrlt DR- 't-Zhu-lhJ tJrJdze 'itJ4/H
          D~ ?l~\1~'-i wlt~irJ }£) dA) .Shall 1-iAtr.tfoe..£ totJ.SUu-h. otJ o)Mis5JoJ~ -i-o .f-1!7L. +eu+t.llfultJf55
         &~ stA-ti.tMVJ.\- of totJtlu::it.~·J et) V.&t.i't~U rut)w1tJ~ to fiJ ,fu/.~,·v,?ia ~/d).
         ·1_ d'l.ciAU. utJd~il- ?{r..~d-N ot '\l~lJu~'{ \-\tc+- -\-\n.. 5h\+-UM~,J} rrJ +~is A(Fl'clflu.if,.ft.e:l-5 Mkh bY Mt.
           f\.-v_ -hwt otJd wtl-lt+ ~1\)J COMPI5-k In HH btst ~f MY obi/A'! oNtilNouJI'iJGE 1'v.l acwd-..AtJ-\- QA -\-ill'L Ct~d toWL-t tuN &+vll_, fo'lhOiN6 i{') S~fUolAz.Jt wfb5 ilJArJ~J
     +o +ht tOJ(..\- cl L.(u,-ti~o.l A-?fl5Ab a? 7ixtA--:J) f,O,B0Y Jl3uB .,CtWifoL 5711/:totJ )AU5TI:tJ, Jl/il5
     '1'£>'111- cl)r.\ \-\A.L    'l-""' ~ DA'-1 of NutJiVI/lYi£.. ZJJ), the ?~tZ:>SitJ6 11Jtir-1d\,/ ~;-li1JL1 b'/
      ch. . te~i\\~6 ~~ML wi~VI ~~ thl. -:r~hua/ niii,JS 5'15ttM5 MA-il bov tJ. J:Pt s 1-i~C-Jt [/AS) ~s-1-/16[
                                                                                                       J

        ,, - &      \)

                                                                        --
                                                                        'rtffiu.)o;J WAei~ou 5 ~
                                                                       c,l,j-7_\1..Cl 5A 1.l -p.(:, l. fJJZ.
                                                                             Midwff-'1) /i)frJj. '7SZ55Z