Court Opinion

ID: 5846630
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-01-12 23:47:48.000292+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:43:56.549220
License: Public Domain

Mikoll, J.,
dissents and votes to affirm in the following memorandum. Mikoll, J. (dissenting). I respectfully dissent. In my view, there is substantial evidence in the record as a whole to support the decision of the board finding claimant to be an alcoholic and his termination to be caused by sickness, misconduct being a deliberate act. In a memorandum dated April 18, 1979 sent by his supervisor, Marilyn R. Stapleton, to the Director of the New York City Human Resources Administration, the supervisor stated: “Mr. Francis has had an alcoholism problem for quite some time from which he has been slowly deteriorating ***. Chauncey knowing his problem has voluntarily entered the hospital a number of times in order to try to curb his drinking problem * * *. Chauncey is a very sick and disturb [sic.] man, because of this I do not recommend termination. I do however suggest it be made mandatory for him to attend Alcoholics Anonymous and to receive extensive counselling to see if it will help.” Claimant testified that he received 28 days of treatment for alcoholism in “Smithers” in May, 1977. The Administrative Law Judge asked if he drank every day and claimant responded: “No, that’s the problem. I don’t realize if I am an alcoholic or not.” He also said he could have been admitted to Cumberland Hospital for *962“peace of mind” but came to the hearing instead. He had attended numerous AA meetings. Claimant also stated he had a blackout on April 17, 1978 and did not know he had been sent home for having passed out at work. Claimant further stated that he had plans to go to Alcoholics Anonymous, that he needed and wanted counseling, but that the woman with whom he was living would not go. The board, as an administrative agency, had the power to treat alcoholism as an illness and to find that claimant’s conduct did not constitute misconduct (cf. Matter of James [Levine], 34 NY2d 491).