Court Opinion

ID: 3864509
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-07-06 08:58:10.194998+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T07:41:30.542027
License: Public Domain

Two causes for divorce are assigned in the petition, namely, extreme cruelty, and neglect or refusal to provide necessaries, the respondent being of sufficient ability. Extreme cruelty has not been proved. The only proof of neglect to provide is that, about a year and a half before the preferring of the petition, the respondent was arrested in Albany, New York, for burglary in the third degree, so called, convicted, and imprisoned in New York for two years. He was destitute of property of any sort, and of course could not, while in prison, have the fruit of his labor. Clearly, therefore, he did not have sufficient ability to provide necessaries for his wife, and we do not see how it can be said that the statutory cause has been proved. It is urged that the lack of ability ought not to avail the respondent, because he lost the ability by his own fault. We do not think any estoppel can be applied against a respondent in a divorce case. The question of divorce is not a matter which is merely personal to the parties. The State has an interest in it, and has clearly specified the causes; one or more of which must be shown to exist to the satisfaction of the court before the divorce *Page 41 
can be granted. We cannot hold that the respondent had sufficient ability, when it is clear that he did not have it, merely because he lost it by his own fault. The fact that the fault was also a crime makes no difference, in a legal point of view; for it is not the crime which the statute makes a cause for divorce, but neglect or refusal to provide, being of sufficient ability. If the divorce were grantable in this case, notwithstanding the husband's lack of ability, we do not see why it would not be grantable for a like reason if the husband had simply disabled himself by breaking an arm or a leg by assuming an unnecessary risk, or by falling sick from a reckless exposure to contagious disease.
Petition dismissed.