Court Opinion

ID: 4063673
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 21:00:14.197245+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:43.273109
License: Public Domain

% ./»:Z¢/;~
q .Xél,z~on

.__£M¥<£ __M l_. _ _ _ _ w REC_;‘__\!__§D `N -___»_~_-_ _____'
,/ ` ; 7 mw oF cR §§§§ §§§§§§§ `
_ _ _-.__~_"~.__ ___`(_`ZW_¢_€_§ ' - .

` 15 4““ “"”
__@_Q/_¢J:_/__z/fi__:zz,_~_¢w§/_,£M` /@,¢ § .§1\3\. 20 23 7

_~Mj- _ ./_;;Z~QM 7 370 / \ 7 ` / A‘@S§ §§@@Si@»»©%@z%§

%_ ,/L¢_O____Cz/y/AAAA“.€*%&J?AA/_? o%~¢~ -JW » /Z/_/Z // @7&/1;_)’1£

______ __Hd/r)~/J__//:O___.__/Za’?/OY)_ _éj):r/ IL_

 

 

  

 

z_/_ __J¢A// M_

/f 175

_ZQJVA___ j l »1_/:1»1 _JZ /?5?/’2/ ______
c:, 71 7:¢.~»¢// J/»: %

. ` 4 § _/;Zw /f/'/~ éfz.'

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

__./z/_`o_ @_Z/a_w_@_g_¢Qa_¢_Zéo_c_e_.;_/;_a 25 /_:z_zz£_/_s;___ _ _ _ _

 

ii 4 £d__;_/£P_£_Z/L/.Qz:zz/N af_/>F¢Z; ' ~ ____

J_@/v<¢ 011-fra /v__r 0 / ¢_¢QZ,_A/z,@__é,z/_’é’ Z ___

 

,5/§/‘0/££ 7//.£ aaa/275 _ ___ __
z&/»a/:_s /¢/271_) J'o,r_¢:P// j'a»z¢/d_<'@,;v J')_z A/»Q/@// WZ__ ____
_//:@_.-F’ -¢_)_¢_ /1_¢/_75)/_;_ %/_~¢ u//._/_ MW/-£_ JA/_e__¢v//_~v_h_ 7___._____
_é_'rév/_‘z§¢_'¢_ 73_<_7-20..¢_¢_¢/ /4_¢//7_@’ o_{_/;¢¢-_f/_) _d_’.»»_,»,_¢_5 ¢¢_~<._/_‘o_~n_.r _o_v_{g______
/_I/__~_Z . @»_-_»é _0_115/7 _a__¢_ gaf _M.r a»m/M/-f/w¢// 72__@»4/_____
__-__»,,,_ :5¢¢_/_»»-/_ /_a_@__ 79_2/_/_ __/_ __:/-/¢,»1____-/ _____ _r_._¢__h_ ____
______/___ //__ _ / /_____/A_ _-_1__5 _,____e__?_ 7_1__ ____ __z_/_’
/f/z/;¢M __/_‘.r_/'Z_M_/r-e_ _Zo___r_@_7_/’_/ _¢/ ¢_¢z_»z_a_-/%-£____
__ ___/_ ____/__________ ___ _____,_//_ ___»:71__1_?__ _____2’_/1__%/_

_A_ /_12»_/»_/7_{/_/“`¢_5_@_/_)_¢ ://_1_ _Ca zea>_/¢_¢/_ _M_)_¢_)»_e_ _q/a_»z(_ 7_5_`_¢¢154/;.
___/e_¢¢»:_3__?_<€;_ __/_2__3__< <7<.- 993 < / 1132_ j_,z’_______€9_£_7/_.__/;;/9/_/_4)_ _
_¢/93_9_-_£_929 6_7_1193> o ~ _9_/_7_[7______75_____9_§__7_~__._____
___25/2/9_/_)‘_9_9_»_\_7_5__7<>_59/_9_ z,_ 129 /_¢_ 995_4`_4_<99¢ 7559 __/5_9____ __

 

 

      

___50

 

 

 

`_69<_,_-_);‘9_9_75__¢ 92‘/»¢4_(-!_>_7_ _99-_7_5_7_{9:9-_ 99_»:,~ _9:___2975_ _9:2[}_ é_jq¢_Z_M/__ _

_jMJ_£:»/;?_ZM)_ M¢;/¢€_/.>w-¢*é¢/_i-_)y 999__}_9.9_9_1;992_ - _________ `
_/-1> _/'_9_519_9_7_/97/_ 957_9 1/9 /L'. 7[9)_915 /9/915 /_{_./,_ /0/, _ __.,,_ _..“¢'________
_ _.?_9(,¢.:_75_ A»’ //_¢_ 9/999<2119975->’ _9_-/_9_.¢__ ££/UZ’/zzo 7§/________
_&-/)9_9_1_7 959/9 59 _9/917717_/:9:99_:_5999 14 /7_ 99_ 75_ és 9¢_<__ ___ ______
fca/Ao»,_ _§;.S'Z _Q_219’ 9_ `_>/9_/9/9_97/9»,_/9¢9_2__999725/»99-~9 ___
;7»5/_ /_/_ Z’Z_Q,é;z:Q/i/ /7:<_75_9_ 75_9'_2_9_>/_2___6__<9 ___ 7_/>_1/49/9/_9'99_ A//___

_45) __ - ___
__ _ /9/9//_<:997_/__4/99_9 9~./.¢;¢'_ 92_/94_ _9_;7_5_ 9 157 _~_55¢9_ __ _ _______
,5/9<9__¢-_ 9__74`//;9_»7_9/_/ __4.2_7 1_5_/_2¢§)_' _/M_4 1529'__/_79_999.9_759.; 99/ /59__ __

__/3_996954' 74/@7’7_%/~9// ¢/_c_ ./_ 4 _Z£_/z_o_ % /4’__ 75/2"__/_ ' _/99_¢_<9~15/917
_-Zh_///;;_ /'2)_9>59_»7_9__7_9_7_9_[/4/9_597_1_5/_9;/_ _%9_9_7_19_ _7___9_7_)&4/

 

_/;/9/@//99/)17£ /p_'/'-€_,__r_!_»_'»_?£ 9////_702~@¢¢9~_/.¢_}9/4¢:‘99-,7///9)1

»i§~_""j_Zu,J_j_ 9_%/_`¢5'41/ j/¢/(_,1?¢'»/'4/1 - 15
v 1_ 5114/'/21 /_4/5/_» 5555/17~5/1/> 1745< .5¢75157755_’5751§/57_55‘/__1
155 576[5/5!_/)/07`.'.7 1 .615)5701515111_/:/11155_/51@5/;)111/:5_-155157£6__11_11
_12_`51/4/1¢_/577517;171511/5<)_//7;¢_ 177917115:777517171117712_455/1'7(55¢7¢_
_ 1505/¢/545<7_,/1/'¢€7)1 17557!_7§»”7_//111 15__@517'_52_£71'0155/___1111
_17101¢7);5~»:;1 _ 571-51__/2517'11 1<11152:/;£17;¢5Zj1 1571 1/)557{117_%¢_¢%§7-¢¢_5“_{/1515_
55£¢;1~11'5555/1/1515<1/.55»<_ __57_4»1-_125:.1/15_/5{5'1/5 _ZZ//€/Zfl}£ ~Z'

_11 111/1/1‘41 555<21¢1_1¢>_5_55_5¢511€2£1_11:5515 <~,/55»;_/7557&5:_7;5745591%£.__1_11
5 _Q"_§Q<__/Zr;»;ia;%££ _11<‘_ 1325145§1§51<;5/ 111§:17?151_515<__4/1@7__21210_7€ c 747 `
153_‘:1£11¢510_51<7)1/'11 ja@_¢/LV_LZZZ&?; 555/116 375 5¢-7<. é"'z/, 33 1<: 657 _
121/171~'/111(1/125§21£_»»_4:7:5,>4_11;177__,_777/_ 11517:7711_71771 771/1_5/57_7_57_4:1111_
._17117'41'711177771711)1/2__&157_7:11571%11_;75‘ y
1 11 11 1'1_11.51(/51571'/1‘15171111/5551/_'/1.77177171/7715/_'517¢17/_1/5715/_55 _r_/;r 174 r- 1

_ _c 11522¢71_5215¢1,_€’1_/;_5_21/ 51/‘:~¢15_1<_<7_77111571»515 _ 5<445;2/1/555€7_51010 / 5_)_* /A¢ 15

 

 

 

 

1 1 ,_§1'¢)¢7/_51_,1/\/:€17;¢£_1/_ /5/:_5.¢51<747- 776:y_11a1)_4/11'61/:¢;1/__!___ zg¢!l»?_;\___c@%/€ //MW

 

1777711717777 771,1/,1777'17/ 177 :757/1'17171717171151/11 _717117711117151_111
775 016 517/5554151¢§77_/55/ 7z_1151¥7»7v 1 555/15a 5/_/1"5/155_5155 55 v l
151%577_-7:5% _/5_1€51¢: 51£15_15/1 1114/_71711 5/1' 7_¢-__1‘/1171511 115611>1’71¢1144§1-3~?1111__
__ 16111?7€¢ ).> / _ ` ___ g _ __ . . _
_111115777117157717,/1111717/7_157/7141111_51571,11;51711511
_A;1151/W 557>:17_//-=-//< // 25_/%71;14_5.1/;¢1115¢15_7/_¢'5_ _)1:0:117_5557¢_/_/_`¢» n

_ ¢£571§11125/>1¢;<21 1Méwo_lg5in1d 57 n 5/ /45 '¢ 1/€ `5__‘_;~’_

5_ 7/;5/.557.55-_?7_&5@7277 ___/_(57_¢¢0__7/7%/9_/2//`_57555 7%_555_75<55.5[_/

 

 

 

 

 

 

_1 11 15517_/. 5.7:€75_/;55)5_0117£_515.¢7 1 55551551555577_?§117125_52;;1_ 1
.5 11 5721@_'.7€' 51€7£¢52'5.25_1~45175_177/. ~.<_5751<;//{.51/1\7¢15_5525/£_722<’)1`)11;<1~{@_5 511
__ _.£W 5;1<7¢155/1‘51¢_%¢7;5_55);'1517/4_/714@/_155~2`_//_¢;15§/_515_?_[5£5.5!__

 

 

@

 

.______7/%42_7[_ 564/__ 544 _54_6;4/_667 //-/z¢/ 6,_4)_\, _/‘6»)!/`0#2,4.//

____ ________ /4,79_ //44_6¢ é_d__ /6/-! _/A¢»?[_ (/_ )_M/A<, -_>:7£/_754 __6/~_6______~1'

_ &/QM/ /:5/://,65__ _4._ _.56;_66_.;_ 524///_`14 ,_.-__6_7/)/;¢_¢2,_75 _56_/:)_ 6./61_./_/_6_21__
/ /

__ _6 _7_/__/£&/142/_ _A_/na_z___d__£¢é/"_ __zéc) /`/_4_/@/,1_757 662 4_ /&__/6/2:__ /_'»;¢¢_/1_6_,£»-!’/_`0:>.6_ 46_0/_6§_//16'17///,/,6 ._
' _7___4_ //___ 64_/_ _6_,_'_6___ 4__/_/__ 6 66

 

554/_ %6__ /6/-6/6_44-6___ 46 __/__6»4_2__6_4/»_% ¢_%_»L_LM_:M-¥ /
?ZO /A¢ 56»-!6_75_/@1_/3666/__ 644 546/_»1__45 _¢_6_244__4_6__'/7___
//6 626;7//»67/4-21:7_£/?_56/_‘47___“%7_§_ __ZA< 2_';14/7 4/ _4:7[
666 ____/_ Z_z____/___ __7_4_ _Z_[__z___/__ /_¢_7‘__7_7 ___
_//e//¢//¢M/ /_f__/»_1_6__.<'_/ /_'_6_ 644.1>__/_/ ‘/¢» 666 565 '
/5_6 _56661:_72_~1’__656___46¢41_@_“/7/__/¢66475¢// 556_¢< ` 2426722 `
_7//4_6 644-<_5_/_1/_4__4_ 4 _ `

__ ____:_ _ ___66_4/_ c_L_M,z_ 617

 

__/je__ _5#6_:1_//_'_7_£_6_/_5 zf/M/n¢¢»///@/Sa/ _/;6_'446___/5¢ )"£2¢¢//

 

       

 

 

0666_J.r/6242_Er/62/ -A 2/)`//'_»»7__ 62-/7/,,¢//),- 7'7¢_/_@”‘,/(

_/____

/

 

jwM…&_Qw'¢_e€___/L@__j__g€/_A¢g/é__@;£_é/ 644/;§01»\ b /)_r“ 647 _.

 

\\ 1

§ _

___@:///,¢MJL,_AJ_ ___f_<_/ /”_____ 774 Z_n@é¢/)ZMWA__AJ

 

__O 2/_%¢/_“_<¢//0&»14¢_,/_7€_¢¢_»4_2(__/_§/£_/0_ _/4.&<4/47§_474&¢_/ /7Z a_/ %L/

 

       

__7_//4 f/A/_»f_{_4_r____f _/'a_/o _¢Lr_¢_/ Q___r‘é&/‘ ____7€_¢£/ JM_/_ _§J_Li§»_/e_//_U/é_”_
~/%:_7/_ // 07_1/)~_1_4___;'%¢2¢¢//0/ AL_¢Ze/_n_/`_¢_e/¢

 

 

________ __ ______ - v ?e_'_}e_e¢_¢A/// __?_¢¢/1;»» _>_4?;¢/)__.___
_____ ______ \ / _l.__’/S ,._/_A__l,/ _ ____

` o_r_%%_ J_QZMW, , ;,@¢._)~.- w va /_7_§~39/2/ _/¢_/,7____
fne_r_¢-n///~_ ///¢ja///_/w>é_@_»/»__¢/_ _)/)»1 _/ ZL¢Z_/_»_z//)d/¢_ >_//_Q_@__ @_z£
/5_ ¢/-_9<: _£¢M/__ .'/__% Z/___/_z_ Z_Iw__»_//_ Az»//¢ 412 /_MO /r/f .4_>::;;___
//`<»;l¢/M/_Z;_,_J 7_ z_s~g__z’_/ _aé_e__/___J __MA» /W/§_ ¢,_15__ ____

_)5 647/»¢" /- %A”“_?é»”{jav?_zf_%/-o¢ _¢_44»¢/__ 4a >»»»¢11111

1:_11111"1'111~;11 1111
111101111| 111111\',. " `

(2) \ :'1}')'1:_'111 11(1‘11;\1 1111|1‘. 11
1(11)1111°)/1\111:1)11`11-_
l 111_11.1': 151_1_|1;1'€€(

11._:111 1111111111111

111111`1:\`11;111:11’ v _
1'."'-1111111113151c1111151111'_111101"1'11;1'11'1011.
11)111\111»\111111111111111::_1.11:11'111:1