Court Opinion

ID: 4055340
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 06:58:45.174206+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:55:56.734754
License: Public Domain

' ." 4§1“0\
‘ coyle/o €Ae£%   g\'
'~ FV@Wazzw@¢¢%zm§ww@@zwanw»%jzwf
' 677 72/’/’6//, //W/c¢/£HH//&’NO@O(/ é{$ ` ‘ ~
_ ‘ fp.s’A/;¢va%/. 77.§“¢»/%/5 M@ /'/"/)/“7
f’Z/' £/7‘€)7.5’/0)7 /?/ 7"}/771€ %@ %//6 a///@ @d//d
7"%'¢7_" fa/¢Q%a/¢ /‘"_<’ 776 y€$f/‘}VU€/ 7*/¢4 >/‘
7”%/:5' C/¢:/’/? @//'%5 iba/f IZf//}v/%M/%‘/ZHEQB

.` /e£,_f£ ;_[_’//€, /“}6'_§`€, A,/ae/v_s’ z?_?&{?@ Y’/z?

- f/§<€/W ):0/ %“éc £/’;£/7 /0/7 ‘0/7“%/:§’ fay/24 d
~___. 7547‘ d/> /7€ c/k%z par //;725 £)7

/45"5/1<’/%/€;6 W/”//;/%:; 77%//€/' )/:Ae/ /‘:f’ 270 Z

/03 774/hazy Ae/o/`°¢ #A/? fo.//m¢.

' 4 72 .’ 7%@ C/e/% F/ 72%¢/"[700/~/£/5)/`//'%/~
_ 77£//4/,0 @4/_:’~ g §§ LS“W////@Z'fé' f@@/ 0 / _
5 744%/;0)7/4 usf/97 763/fw 7@”7// o

RECE|VED |N _
-counr oF chMlNAL AFP.E"ALS

MAY 2 o 2015

' v Abe| Acosla, bitn .

w>f§*

`_Z;)’?~ 776 557/ff H/ 577/~°777/77)5/%,@/935/_6’
_ 1 . ` _//z/§f/??, 7122/55 _

 

`, /D/) iia/§§ 1<%///7?/7/;6>4027 ' __ 4 _
l .y: ` ' W///’/"f 270:.MZZ '
.` ' ' §§ 3 f :'~E: 2 fn 2 gaf

A/zz/'{'; HWW¢,`/Z/”!W _
fug§j@_:&¢_@j_i Mg/zgz
L?A /€/)A//¢¢ /"A/’/o<`f/od,?? x

_ A/a{?”/J'@' §%,/4/;0/05@/

7“"0 ‘¢%@ /§/0/%/'/¢£/5 _»_¢7&¢6&¢ e, "@"//'/e, fay/ff I/f/'/%/%z/

- /l/£/@ 6@/.§, /\70¢(/ £0/)%_¢ £"//@5/)/;5 H@/)@/¢ZFW£//%/j@ 271

;¢%5 /56/¢%0/7 oz./Z@ /§: a,/@/”& ja //°/‘/ £/7%//)€£/° 5@/47%@6 /77 ` .

, ;;%@. 75)%§9 495/057?¢"?7/§77%_p%’f?':/W/?m/JAJ// Z>e ,_Z”)f¢<-’W~ ‘

_ j /0 off wig/ge p//A_e /’e/¢)®/ w/_?%c: /@ _§’pr/%a fpa/f ///z;
/<7//0 w/};'U€‘/»‘ " ` . v ~~

, @/V‘W¢/zo/@Z 5, 020/5 /c/¢ /'Qf/’€ £€/"dec£ 4 /6’ c f)/€/“/€/> `
4 4 apa/ied :/7/"¢/@%/¢&¢20/_/0/)7 )%c H%//'/ f/Z//;?)/’/%////e@é ' -
' _<.’/d/%’//S@ ¢' ` n n v - ' y y

@/2 `5’6,0)%/?74{¢/ /§, za///A/§’ fay/f ed%£/eaJM/Y &/Zz€’/ 775 f '
,_///j‘)-’(‘}y v f%c 7765/00/74@/7%: /%///a /Koa/f])% fes;dJ/M{ 70/°/%/}7
30 ¢JWF A// g/}%e/’,bf@$€/?//;Vj/ 527 0/’¢'¢./@/£5%°2/25%/}2 jr.:’//zi§
54/£/?7/>‘%/37 /%5 770/0//25)”/%,»/ 749/1 M’/Z%///¢A%J lS/;¢WJ/S )%a
‘ £_. /?, fn //g;. or é/ car )%Q/}Sz/f%¢//M ¢//a//Z%f/Zw mm /'/°/z?zd
z§` @/¢z%@ /70/7@§/§/7§’€, AL@£.A%/z/’@J@///cz ./7/// fj5f 5>/’52,/57'_5’ ffc 7b/’/'@ /6_0'5//’7‘ f? fé/)¢G
55 525 W/M/>y 775 552/7 757 557 3 75 555/557 57 75555
y /’ZS’,D 0/75{5/7 f_s’ 55 u5 770/ ['0/77///'€5¢ 5'1///% /A5 0/7 /’ 5/£%55/
1 _5 5,'6_2 )"577;£ 5/1 /0, aza/%

\"

_Z§

' . 05 753 55 75 ; 5 ~ 55 5/_5 755 ,~5/5 757 57 753 1775/757

'7"€ €6/7€¢£ //70/7:' )%5 f.- d 5/’, //0/_). 5, ZV%/)‘z: 55/’5/ ”5/5 555¢ »7~
¢Za? ~/5 //A 5/5) s 5/%5/° /%5055 552%&0/5? /%5 f /' //;/{z@/a,) .

` 7%/‘_'¢ /55¢//)?5£ /‘}7 )`%5 /’5/5/0/°%5 a/"/Y /;7§’¢/7;”/ °€/5/7/ //?7?5'

' 245 /"5/’570/5%5 5 75W0555 , 775//}, M@f_/ ‘5/2 7§/ 75555//%05 .
-5055/§/ 577 5/0,055,/0/' 5 /70%/‘2’5 5/@///055£ b ` ` '

l /"-’2//>¢/5/@ 755/75/5%5/> jaypr /’6'55/%555 55 540/f

0/ 755 7¢/"/°'5/5’05//)€<’ /’55/0 0/755,, 77/3’ 555 /4///'/%5/’ //%/

` 555/555 A/K' M/"_'//$j/ 775/35 2775/0//4905' /_:’s"s’ 053 5/75{55/54’»
5./ ‘_’5/) 915 555 02)755% 740 5 y5/’50/)75 155/§ wA//5 55/56 565 4
)7/5/ mg /l’s’ /%/¢/'0/7 55 55505 /’5 ///5 /%5 0/’/65'/° 4 5/590 ~

///.’L’ anb/072 7€9¢ M//’/V’ I/ /17£_/7%%//77#5 /'%@7‘ W%;?/€Z/Zaf/
. jj /%/f’§’ 505/if 5///7'/5) /// wf///€// 575/575 ' '

/0/’£/ 577 //5/’ f 5 /7‘5 /' y
' 7;%5 fci/55 /5/’ /@/"L/_s’ 7¢5¢// f%/:S’ faa// `/5£§"50?,¢`@/'7/
» _A/,")`W 555 0/,£57/5/?)/”/ fo 55 55//5 505 5/;5 ////5 477 z

- 590/0 eQ,//°’/? 755/5 1075 5577 555 75 /i`s /70w 55 /0/’5 7”/5;

* . Caz//’%, _ _ ~ ~ -
\§/U°@//y: M ' »

/@/’//2% 775/675 ;’ ~Q»MM@L£££ZZQL,
.» ' - . 7;7,@61<_7:775¢’;/5{73/5’7"

~ __C ,7.”__75`/’/?5//J U/?/’% _

7/3&&/%///555{ é,;§”f'

/F@§Ad//w// 75 775@”5

¢@..