Court Opinion

ID: 4132859
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2017-02-18 01:31:14.182136+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:37:38.812070
License: Public Domain

February                  7.    1975

The       Honorable           Alton       R.      Griffin                                        Opinion          No.         H-     519
Criminal          District           Attorney
Lubbock          County           Courthouse                                                     Re:       Construction                  of article
Lubbock,           Texas           79401                                                         1899a,        V. T. C. S.,                witch
                                                                                                 reference              to particular                pro-
                                                                                                 blems         in microfilming
                                                                                                 public        records.

Dear       Mr.     Griffin:

             You      have         rrqu,ested            our        opinion           concerning              the       operation              of
ar:icie      1899a,          V. T. C.S.,            insofar               as it may              authorize             the     microfilming
of sealed         files,          surh    as adoptions,                        juvenil,e       proceedings,                   and        inquests.

             Article          1899a,           sec:I:,on       1,    V. T. C. S.,                provides:

                                     The        Distri~ct           Clerk          may,        pursuant            to this         duty
                             to keep           a fai,r      record              of acts        and        proceedings,                   p’ro-
                             vidt:       a plan      for       the        reproduction                 by microfilm                  or
                             other        p’rocess          which              correctly            and     legibly           reproduces.
                             or     which        fcwms          a medium                   of copying             or     reproducing
                             all     records,            act:s,       proceedings                   held,      minut,es             of t,he
                             court        or     courts,            and         i.nc:luding         all     registers,              records,
                             and instruments                        for        whj,ch      the    Di~stri,ct           Clerk        is    or
                             may         become          responsi,ble                   by law.             The     plan       shall        be
                             in writing            and        shall~ i~nc!ude                provisjons                for    maintenance,
                              rtt enl.ion.          s ec:uri,ty,               and      retrieval           of all       records            so
                             m~c~roi:.imrd               or     otherwise                  duplicatzed.

             Secl.!,on        1I. 17 ib) ,        Texas         Family               Code,        provides              for    the       transfer       of
the    complelx~           file    of an adoption                   proceeding                 to the        St:at,e Department:                    of Public
Welfare          up03      en1 ry        oi a dxrcc                 01’adopi:ion.                 Sectj,on        4 of article                 1899a
allows       dcst ru,<~:tion of instruments                               and        records           pertaining             to a hearing,

                                                                          p.     2343
The     Honorable                 Alton          R.     Griffin              page            2      (H-519)

proceeding,                 or     trials       only     aft.er       one        year             following             the t-me          at which
the judgment                has       become             final       and        the         time         for      an appeal           has       elapsed
or    a mandate              which          is      finally         decisivelas                     &n         issw.xl.Attorney               General
Opinion          H-466            (1974)         construed              section              11.17(b)             of the        Family          Code         to
allow       retention              of the adoption                    file      for         only         a reasonable                time,           which
would        seldom              exceed          ten     days.            Therefore                      the District              Clerk        is    not
authorized            to destroy                 the     original             file          in an adoption                     proceeding,              and,
were       he    to microfilm                     such        a file,          the          copy         so obtained               must      be      sent         to
the     Department                 of Public             Welfare.                   Since            the       District           Clerk      has       only
temporary                 custody           of the       original             file          and is         not auhorized                   to retain              a
copy       of it,     it is        our       opinion           that     article                  1899a         does      not authorize                 the
microfilming                 of adoption                 records.

                Concerni.ng                 files      and       records                of juvenile                proceedings,                   section
51.14(<.),          Texas          Family              Code,         requi,res                   a separate              filing      system            from
i:hat reiating              to adults             and        provides               that         the     fil,es        and     records          be
maintained                only      on a local               basis.            Section                 51.14(a)          restricts           inspection
of these         files       and         records             to certain                 specified               persons.             Section           51.16(a)
prov-ides           for     the     sealjng             of these             fi,les         and        records            upon      the      order          of a
juvenile         court.             Upon          such        an order                all        files     and         records        pertaining                  to
the juvenile               proceeding                  involved           are           to be transferred                         to the      court
Issuing         the       order.          all       index       references                       to the        files      and      records            are      to
be deleted,               and      ail      fu,ture         ,requests            concerning                     the juvenile              are        t.o be
proptriy            answe-ed                by stating              that      no record                    exists.             Section        51.16(e).

                The        clerk         has      permanent                  custody               o,f these           files       and    records             and
they     ace      thereiore               ” . .         . records               .       .    . for        which          the      District           Clerk         is
or    may       be-corn?           re~sponsible                 by law.             ”       Arti,cle           1899a.           Consequently,                     the
clc rk may            microfilm                  piles       and      records                pertai,ni,ng               to juvenile             proceedings,
but. the        system            adopted             under         article             189Ya            must         conform            to the       coniiden-
tial!!~y     requirements                       of the        Family            Code              which         are       discussed             above.

                Article           49. 22,             Code      oi Crimj~nal                      Procedure,                   provides         for      the
rctenjon            by the dj sf:,r;c.l, c,lt,rk                     of a sealed                     envelope             ront:aining           all     papers
perta!n