Court Opinion

ID: 4060710
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 19:55:05.825546+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:05:31.689861
License: Public Domain

/I/O.      Ufc-<H,2&2-04

     teEL acost* ant ^r\^^camtZ?mmm^t
                     p^fg:--|(j (h\n '^>... OCT 23 2015

 $OQJ         #S       FA/s           J/.Dl     fkb-e/h^ C&zfius     tJ.&l   F7ed*
 Some         Hoi>      You      rnfez'          dl*d      T)\& . Oft£ A/D. A%5 fS-U^j
 X    I old     You Add           Tke.        CovLizXi      Do   AJof /^ccePf J/*D1

GaTo&         Qwrj/J     i\       a)qT my Arro/iAje./, Fhct 7-j.i-^Dig'
fftoijT&OMe£V          Cgua/TY,

APPtek         k.s.      fan*-, chiaja/ xs                 //or /?ir drToBA/ey, //£ Lib
ajot Efahs ArnzMi of iecozj ~7-J}/'*2o/g' xy a ^ > ^ ^ /
LeuA/fti A fl/lfieUiJi &fkt DV&l Pouite-ad MX MF^s, &r
TE.l\MG~Tht*\ S*i*iThiV6>'* JE+kw FileJ CHM6-ES 0A? #££,
AA/d .ICSi trAfD/l DUfi/M. X                        fl////iAn Uti/fct EYedF OAP&HW-
/Hch/TS-ojuC^Y         CsusTy            Counts          At/Yd   Cc^ef   OF F£j/j?/a>a/
flPPlolS /l/onf!/ fcS &/9'TD£ OUaY/I/ /Ja/jO Mt/eC**' &J/lk-
fo& FoacfaY& k,s* Chtfo/e. jOua/a/ 7~o BE hJi/lC/iM <Jd>&£
ATlQUtJEy flfaiiJST- UrJ)f*>» To&eZ klfll* X hJfflfam JoSF
HAVE Filed FUSSES rf&to/AZT 77fe/n. FOA Fdzcujyt-
A ATTORNEY of d<Coed U^ Hi CletzlY UAS A/bF~
~7-JU-ao/.£r Fkd ILdi HaUk YcZPu^ t Dcd a/F Ten 1hb
 ATToMty To RU FHYs 1101 Y-JaUai C&aAus J/i////bife.f%J
         -ES AC-^sF H//n Fq<£ do//OC So,
                                                                             ocument contains some
                                                                                i are of poor quality
                                                                                  of imaging.
 ft^a± acasta. cj<^k                                   q3.^u3-CW
 ?.G. "&AX U36l_> CtoPrroL ^TATloki

D£^1^ CJ«s*K _:
    £m closer Tioasg. r:uD oug_ Ltt <DR.'_9',Kmi_ oF TA<2_ EbUouj\uc,
Pociuvxaux TW Wfts Bcfi^__SAuT 7T5 J/dU. Bk LUh\T<^b Statg^
Dcl.VeKcjiTOTAG. coujo-aP cr.ihlyflL APf£AjLS firJfou&
£aK) \esT C5Uvgju ,' ejLA a.<^ «,

frPPRe-c.i&t-LD _

                                    TAauJCuJ ___!&l_. ;u ADVAMCjQ. __,

t c , ]r;ieji
              ~TR_i_al_ Cc_u_R_r KIQ. iOna-J3,(d3>3k~C260

Ex ?A?or<__                       |   Tki T)4<_L CaLlRT 6P
                                   j C_J?imxKlftL ftPfCLALS
                                       FlusTaiki __ Tt_xn__

                              Cf_jj_mcl
"TOTWe, viovicsRiABlJE. jtust__cclgs OF 5 Ail. Court,:
   Cd1t><____ K1c_jl)__ _^_ix__.L_2Lnm LamT__£ _Jb^£__ P<srJT:0M(__fc__-
?3kfc :_£.__ lu Tke. k£„_V<<L. .Style- AUD iJUmJ__-_^_Lt) C_AS<s.__

TA}flBfe__>1=__ ?feT,'T,'_5ljGK UjILL Shaui Tk:s Vio\JOkSxB>) G. cduRt
Or C__R.\tv\\U&L IVP ?&£]__   As £Al/_jU_i-_ 1

    IDj ?<__^;t1,q\i^r'__, "meriowTD UjItAx^wU /Lo7 YlABoAS
CtfL?u__ . ikib UJlrADitaLa DTToRjjeJ./ UAme As m.y
aTTOiOAai. k.*. grtor duxiuI T_LT/T:oki^ sthtcd a
NUm%_£ or- Tim^ T/m*t~ _Sa!j^ ArraRkJ£i_ kjAs u_jt vi;<_
ToTKg. IYi_.uT^orv\fijU_ cr>ujJTJ_ D„AJ__ ofcpica. J TAc_ TJVD__

r   ^~t1CD - ^^ T/lftT R__T.r.OKJGR D'»b Uot AsK               k c
Cat** buiiuT^ r.icTk //.o-} ml:t^^S coi^uc

                               ?A9c J
?Rfc£ ! :    K-S. GnraR dlluij -is NaT /TlW OttoRn^/,, _H
             Mywsl "BGLGki T£U_;u_3 G/rroR bluiki TO Lj i'TMDRiUJ
             TA;_, /i_o1 ma Sens CoFLPus_ Auft Tk<Q,
             mo\iT_5^r^dRy c_)ujjtj_ d«,aj_s 0Ft!c£._ tAo.
             CI^KKS ' GFF,'c___._

?fiG£ _a ;   ^F?l;_uAyT__ _yp?o.s<__j> mortou T^g^u^t rb timujD
             rxPPi'.corlDu FgR LuK.'r <oF ^Ag<s_As cnRfus* ___
             Add^d G&oujjb ^_5_L_ ,'£ UdT Accg-PTg-D k-£«,
             Gato* Duiiu is Mot kj ILX'.Arn JTdbc Atta)?li/c i/n

7h&<=. 3 \   X To/J. fiAlftR -DLOlU td ^j'tAd^ALl) T/,£_ //._)7 MA fi__A__
             CaKPus. T_b)£> Vr.r^ do Udt Put U',± AJAfDo.    As. /Tii=/
             ;ATrnR_ueJ4. jitc-ID w,rY. Wt ;_s U_rr my BrroRxiGi/-

?**&£ ^ :    2- d'.d U6T As/c k.s. QraR Dux/iu to jtrj/e. /7.0*7
             vjabgas o_r_pus             ]<.£. gator buuuM :$ kiar
             my n.rnrtUGi/.. a: Am bsfakij cdlu^t op £PP<sa/s
             To Uj'.tAdRRLl) K.S. Gm&R bLLUU AkJD //0_)'7
             VjABgAs CtffcPus Aui_ X„S_ fiAT&R DLOiU LuAS AjfiT
              n-T-roR)j(SJj oP. T?ecftiLD DATc of P'Jgb /./.0 7
              PcXm.'^S.'ciU TO ?UT /C.S- £tf7bR DLUJU /s A/Or /7)_y

             vjab&as- cdlpus . x u;L/_;Arn jtde^ as my OLdu
             ATTDRUGii GKDc^.fiATto'R Duuau X/Am<? TAKou AFP
             ALL KeraiUj* AT CAUJtra£ CR'.lW.U&L. bPPOUS^
             ^1T^ >'-^ Vja6«s corpus "Ee uy/rAxiXBUJLi
             uuiiu s Udt my Lu.LL'.Ai* JXoBok ATTORLKJeif
             A*P'.DAV',T* TKAT Y4fcV£_ Kj^-r Eg^xj H^RD Ifex.
                               PA3C 3,
             Cau LtoT £y<ai VleAR TkeasL nrknrlou* llut'.l. TAl_s
             Lxxiciitv%PlcLT<s. I/.07 WAfceAs CaRPus P',l&B 1-31-
             aoil "Bitf Au •tovTc&.V£l4 TUnr ,'s UOT Lu'.LL.'ArA
             _JfcB£.'_s AttoRUGJ4 OP RgroRn

?£&&. fc :   cou_kt #p cR'.m'itittL. ftpp^ALs P/eAs<£. uj'rrlibfwid
             II.an VmBGj* QjRPus )<0js. 6mr»R bmuu is a/gt my
             AtTOUU£J4. Jit .SOmeOUG. P^CD'T^^ ttrTOJUJ<£j4
             A.9A',UST A)M LoiLL _2L .£;u_ XL WAUg. PuJ/if
              iUPfcRYACLD CDLUIT oP CJllJfc'.UAL APPgA/5     KioT T&-
              Uc^s^T 11.67 Uag^As ObRPus, xlP IT /£ TAcRg.
              liJiThl^ALii IL67 UABclAS C^RPUS_ AUD Uj'/ThDRAL£)

          Te.TjgCE^kie^'_<L Hnffl!EQUTfl fr:r£CJJBR£e.- flQLdJSsL
     "PcT.Vlnu^ i^scjcns ir Was Been UcuA TharTJic Klo.hr To
^G-IP^ K^fR^^rAT.'ob D0«^ U6T AtTA^J, LUUT,'^ ; T /4AS E^Jii
Stat<=__ 777 s.w.ad «3- 9a fr^c&APP. m<rt. tlxat^cl
iUSTAUT Cttifi. Pa.T:TlOUfiR.mAD€- \T CjokR PRfcto TA <£. T/m^
TK^-r Cbuui^L. P'JajD.ft \L61 \\x ferrW.'au&zt Eo^AiP ;U
D.SxRlcT ^AuKT UflT Mc, b\b UCfT to AUT <2>UU£GL Ufl/Wflri^
uJko 1WaVu£x> CDujjs<u.tt £i^j iu P^t.'tJouilrJs ihoTloiy
B^FAlU. TA'.s UaUGRttBte O^uJlTDP <LR;jh',liAL_ kPP<£A/.S As
UJ,LL;Ar* UJAJTGR JbB€. ,4 /fill Oluil ATTaRjj^                     X

 a?SSi7          - ^      ***** 1r ^^T ^ ^:/hlua/
c^n o. t. uot;p^ta. **** rw /r.s. a^SZ^a
                          PhscL 3
UJAsUfrT fe.TTi'Ti'OUGJR.'.S, ATToRU£i4 OP Rz&nkh _J ktLT
TfiT'.T^OU&fc ,'s St'iUl. Hgl\uQ PoRciSD TO Arrg.PT SA.'L ATToRU^f
Rs VI ,'s A-rTOfckteJd #P Reri50U^e
    To.~r;T\Chi}<ZLK AS.SQ.R_B> ThG. LLKIITclD SThT&S, ^LLp'RGJChG.
COL^iCT ftUD LUT.TSLD STATES. CAUJOTS OP &PPe_ALS )-/A<L WOJD
TJiAT ?£.Tf.T:bll4lR MAS TliCL JILSMt TO R^USG. CtiUXiSCJ^ ftUT>
KcpRes^uT V/,'jyvs<£JF<, Jftc/taskLe. k tu;5Sli/^^^^ U,s,iL2^
 \n^_ \oh s,cx. q*tM^ 9^9_ 79 Z.,fi£;U /Pa Cllifi^ II)bete
      Y^r ;t;6)j^r COUT^-kms £KLU ,'kj A;_s )TAB><lAS Q3LPLK
pRfcCj&iSXVi LiAs _, EarVKoUGK -SkoujD fJOT Ro. 7?^LoRcX> Tb
V4AVG, COUJUSGX. feRrJSLD U-POU U,TV\. SG.CL ttlld^Rs 1/
Cd)/;*x£_ 2 J^^d ^ ^ as.3 ^^n.'B. /942y_. airluJ
Ck&rv^^RJAJu K £.R,'cK£cki- 7^^/ P.2J k^2^ k2A l'S3^
C,R_ 192*0. mu^6iar_ Tfix'.TJ^GjR UAs Tk«. Rij9kr LxU£dR
Tkc. £/xTh I^UD l=OLLKr«cuTk AhnGJakmGJaT dP Tke. LULi'Tajri
States Csu<,t ;tixt'.du To PR^cxiT 1-1 ,'s PRd ££L PAsad^ Li£l<;
Aud luK'.t rjp )4AB4As CMU>U£ To The Couzzs. . As kJc/x.
Ws to TV.i u^u6fc«a/G. (Coujo- op r_R;mv.uAL_ hPPajxis^
U'.UfeUT TW ^s;£TAUCC op CGUUSU. . CAA^/l^R/AiM
V. £-R:d<5£u. 7^ T,3ii IsL k29 rg^clL / 9*</}..

Vicjd t^at Tct;t;du(^r cnu d^cJiaR^g. aju ftT7a(kki£jj at
AkiMT,m(L Uu'TA AR UJ'T^UT CAUSG. ^TcS£_JC_ h, /T)d)^^0
<aca.s.uj^J tofc_^7^8 tT^.ftfP.- UJACX) aooLOj _xJU RC
U^£Rs 5J4S. Scxvsj XUC,_, 3A S,£d^ 3__?/_. 33£ CT<^ WW*)
Jr^S^%^r^ ^^.id '* ^T ^Lx;)^ To
S,Lo,2A AT _B_2_£ -3k ..                           ^«=-*v^ _> «4^
    As Tk€_ LUilTGIb j^TAT^S £;£tAi C^KclLlIt G&uStJOP IXPF^K

                             PA^<£. ^
   •Fuja^^i^ofRc.^ tuiTK C£»uu.s<u_ P^Rc_',ju_9 tils LoiujauTod
'RG^R^sfeuTAT'.OU 6U TfexITlOUCIR^ Pct;t;0UCK VI As Mst P/ £
S.'yrk AiY\Qjj£meajT "R'^Kt to P,'/g. AiaD ViAi/e. Vl,'£ 7Ro £c_
 Upp;dav;ts aub 0U4R PteAb'.kilLs o£ U',±> TKo sc LoitiT tfr
ViaBc^s Co*J>us CDUs'.DclRfeL Bij T^£_ CgllRTs J iUcJ/xDluB
iPls VtoUtoTtoRiG. C6ujcr oF ^\rv\iUAL- &Pfc*L£ LJko UAs
niRoabk* Di5h,*,ss^ TG-r\T:o>ba£L IFhBr'.bkiSL QM OO&RgJ* P__
<^)£ EejCJQUSG. oP C^LLkiScX'A LULiUJmiTc* TtePRcmiSTBTlAul
^ ^fJ^J^o^ v. 5totc_ 2s& s,uj1c^ £^7_ ^ Ct^MPP-
r ^ ^ T"^051^ ^ c^^;bfi» w;s ?/to sc m^r^us^x
 1^?           ^ *tato_. 777 s.iu.aJ 8^<»a Z^. c*jb. APP.
    P^r.Tiou^ As^ojus PeLT'.Tiokjrj* _ AkiJ^ kler U ,'_s
LLUU^^U-feD CfcUJJSOX. OK Tk<£_ jSTAT<L_, Uj'.LL BfiftG. TA <S_
^fi^l- CjOUSCl&UCJ^CJ^ OP U\S COWlcJT.'OU LJkeXj
LxuujftuT&.n <fl£)UJLjs^_s' LxuujaljT<£X> )/oD7 Pa\L~ Tk^RoPp^Ro.^
Pc^'.r.oucjL's r_ko;ci.^ aud SlxTk fcrhfeU&mfeuT P,'_5At To
ItePR&sc^-r W.s-soJP PhUsT 1^£_ I-/DUORCD. ' FfllterrB i/.
cn./.-^cjj'.A- ^a ^s„ Xofc_3^ ^                ^lCj. a<a^ ^^^,
3£d^V_ 9^,c_T„ 1&£>7_ IcM^as L.GA.H J2S1 ^BRGJdlLikw
    TtoRcJM<L^ For T^e. ABO^ TUftsaVu LLUUALiT^ CaLOiSGL^
K.s. GtfTa* L>uxiu_ sAfcujb Be D^cJi/aR^ Abft wk'
G>u>u* PR0C_^u_Ss Ah* /W;t;ou<^ \M/ouj^ ThcTWlhf

                           1r3cl £
   . L_M-»EKE.FDfc£-_ P-R£mxJSes.G&LisaiDfiRGJ)_, pG.r,'Ti6LieP
TKfty-s Tlols )4c>ucfcft(B]e. Q>ukt of CftliWAmL APfimJ.s CttUslD£R
 Chat) GRaviT TPTs TPg. ^feri'T'.OUG&i. mOT,73U TO D',SChRn.0e
CDLuiSfcL-" Aud I^;sciI»aRJc CDuusgl. POxD A//0U3 Po%t;dju<ir
The ^;_qIit to p'.iei vks ouju PRo^fi, lor't op jlvaecbs Cdpj>u:s
i'li tPg_ /LHfeJtesT r>F Just.'cj£. .

                                        Lj ;lx', apa lja; ttssr JhB*c
                                        Pg_"T ,'T/nkJ<£R Pj^£3 _£<t

                  ca^T^ExcJxre- OP ^£Rvx£_gL

c^^ltjf^ tkwt a c_ftpj4 toF "Pcx/r/^iuej^ ir>0T,'DJU to Mschrmci^
 CDLuLiafiJ_"_ "WAS 12<££Xi S'<£4aT TO TUe. X>;STRlti_T ATTOKUGid^
OF-l=:c&. oF mcsuTQftmG.R^i C^U-uTJ* _, t£*As Rid UU'TtLb STATC^
mn'.L_ F^t-cJass., Pgsta9g.Pj?glPa;d^ OJu TUs TP<£. Z/7                 DA4
*t~~aCX%             ^o)£\ ftD^Gis o^Q'.b^Plcc Be',11.9 •
^07 03. TklJVft stk&glT-, <2)±J Plot,* _i ObuRofi- Toxfts 7736/'.
S/^^Bi, nnQ.TA^TP^ xx_ DA^ AC /V: 77.                           ^f£_

                                        LlJ »LL.', Rm^AJTo£ JJaBC

                                        fAicJvB<u_ LUJ'.T

                                                              7£lg4

                           ?Aii<* L>