Court Opinion

ID: 4060451
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 19:48:46.500009+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:58.251863
License: Public Domain

FILED IN COURT OF APPEALS
                                         12th Courtof Appeals District

                                                 OCT    8 2015
              l2'/£-OOQ2.'£tf
                                               TYLER TEXAS
       -T    -V    s^/S// S       J S   ^.PAMESTES. CLERK

               /y /&%,       4*

                         u

  0<j Apfe*/' A*~ S/c //(/' b-^/iJc/(Tow./ ^/~ S<™'d
f^*j/y / /States

     C^rtA/ Al/iGune^/ A/e/ &Ou£&/lrJ
                              J2 '/±' OOOO^J -67/?

                      /J   /ySy /(y^y/yOyY S^Tou/?/ o/ Z/yldyylZ
                                                        w*
                               >y A/? , yy<

                /At        y?4A~ c/ AOttJ
                                 /f/^y/A'dT

         O/j J/^TA/ /taw //y //Z^ 2\^A</ Z^uy?/<>Z
                                    sxs/u          y^yygs

              /ipps/ZvA /fes/ia   yys.6.    ^vjj   yyyy^-yts Sx/e/*

    /3 /At /Tos/afadA: Uuj>/c£s (DZySy C^au/z/:
            COfPi£s aS&us, (V y/z/tZyzz/yy . ^/y/Zyy; y^ydy^^j/
 A/?D ^^ /}/JyJ sV/y-£ //'S, //s y^S/^oyu^y" Z> yZ' y^scd'ycs Sisly'sZ
///£c/ Ay Z:^j, y^y^y/ZZ y/yZ^y/srjy, y^dsZyy /?££~i*r ^yitX^yy.
flMfAtjey /C Appt///u>/

Aid'nJ %££ti£ JAc/cso/J
lit £. /;aJ€ , J«;/t3/d
*/£*•* ^
!
                   7£70>Z.

4AlA/ C&bJUSt//

411 S. J>£>aJa/6 Jc/y.
              i

/yjt/ty/jS.       7^>70Z~

A*J>L,s//iw/ D.UAy/ ^/Aa/uCu fS#*;/J /k.sc/yV
V' r/oy. co^*t J/a>u sy
JdQ //. Ha&aJujAu
       CV/Wowr*./ —Sy^yyA^         s^y/j s£ /ftft^y?A Z,\± <rOy/u<^/'cys -fyy/\^yZ<^
Z^ AZ o/%ryy_j*- ^Z /Z-^tr^s,^ „/0 <?Z^Z~/ZZ^&\*Ze#ce: ,yy yf A*«ts
 /-/tcy ^>yyc yc^t/r^ed yfgs&e&s/ //^ /^, &r<aer**Acy. o/ Ate-Aytryf*. - CzTcy /±g).
/Z/si. —S/e//>s<y s^yyfs, s*yc/~c:Z~<Z A^ /Z o/Z~y/J,c' , \, j£ts£T „ /^oyy^ , y, AZc'
//^y <J,ls./e;c/ Z^st/ ^Z—W/Y ^<A,// yc-y^s. C^CsC/) /^ AZ± c Za££
 Ac yyyZ'yryA yi yZy VZ Aj^A6^, Ay y?yiC/ y,fc>c<s~<-~</Cc/ Z yx/yZ Ay
yy. (T<z/(/$&). O/Ax^yA'A „ AAc yo*y /-<*// /,,^ A /<r 6>c,Ay.                  yAc Zt/yA
 c~ouk/ //c'/j j^p^>j>c:c! pL*K./'^sA*~i£ysA yAy A**~. ~/ AAA i/yyt/i-s- c^>'~'Ayy<i~<*>£~yA.
-~*Tyj/=s^c/ysc 's-jylJ ^/(Jx/Ou A/CtfA <£>ys A/ <$£c£Ta*J^Ta. <?&sSy/^d yy^>/cd: ^.f yf^O?/
 /Akj Ay/yA A<ZZ. f-^cx. /£^/^s^).
      ' y AZ>(yy yyoscr cc^^eAyy^ycAZ ZZyZ Zy Zys sty yyyr^yA
 ZZa Ayyy/ZZ- ZcccyzZ /yy ZZs yycy^y AyyAyUyZtZx/ZZ <-oyAr-X*<Arr
ZZyZyfy y yr/yyZy c*Z/j/tc^-zsy&cyyiZyad&&»ryyZZt£~ yt/co^Z
 C.O/Jw//ss y/D yy<yyxS'ZZ- <f>C/toy\ Ay/cA yyo ywUS<A/<A/oyy^/
 cZ^'ZcZ y?yz<r yyiysc-y^Z
                    _ y/ ^y-^xyxr Z y/ycZyyZc^cyysyZ <Acc/s/oyyy y//,(.              |
 ^_S/c/?X)yy fy^Ou/A AAy Z -^ &'*->>'/ ZZ" yAyAZsAs yOyy/Z y7-S <?WX3y .*
 —- AZoyZ_SyyJ/xA * Sr, '&*,ic
      C^yyjsyyy/ yt> s<yy/uA <->/" ZZr /yys/cAcryyyy yyy AZs ^yZyyc <^/y£s
 obA/'y/eZ ;/A'oy/A ZZouoA Zy/yy .yyyZAZ'cyy)Z\/y ^y^y/sZyjAAyos)
   (A/JcAfyt   /Z' A^yz/Zy//*fc~yyA*i6yyZ±>Zy A- C/'/ZZA>A/yyJ (7^>yysZZ//oyy,
  A y\>yyjyyyZ_jyy?yz.cZ <=>yy}yyZ'<Z /y.yZyyy yc>yyyyyyZ /yyyj -'yycAucyZ ^y
 <^Ac7y)// ZyAyy / ox y^/^yyyj/tys^yyZ/yy '^ (-fyyAy/lSoyvyAA. yyAr^^yZ^y:
 Ay yAcAfyyy ^cec^A, As Ay^rs^yZ^AZZc cyyyyi£y7-±>yyyi/A syyxc/, /^
  '/jAcA^s^iAA: y^s <?y-ycAryycdT y'/y y ZiSaAA>ZAZ~ y7c-<rtsj;yc/. AA^^,yi^ZA
 ,y. ZiU^\, Kioc. Zsc/cik JJZzjAa) /yy/c/^AA^, " xa> c\y'<Zyy^<r ^AAf/y/crA
Ay Ak/ a//c£yL oa. o/Z*. y>y~/uoyL/ /a/ iyy<?ZA~o/y u/yfyyy yAoy/^/oyys *->/ /Ay
 {~oa/*sA,/u A/d/j, oa Z>y^ o/ A/y -s*/y/y Zyyy&s ox o/ yAe' <^^yysAAAyy ox
 A?v~ys ^/ /AZ y/y/ZZ ^sAfZz ^Ayf^Cst/a, ^jsAy/AZi' y?<Z~>,/ZZ yyZ
 yy'Z^yycy Ay-ysyisA AZ~ y?<:<r<y^y<A sy/ yZ ZyyAA/ y/L/y csi/'/n/~///?yAyisy-
  AA/ZAZAZ'yyy^ -S^^Z, AZ yty'cZ'yyyy Sy^ey,~cA 'A S*fc. -^Ae/AyA C/U£T; aZ
  sviyiyyjuyyyy}', &/?_<£ yyyA <y.AAZ A^y/Zy^ yZr^\, -^A/ao-yy- (y3y,z /vy), AZe
 ~±cyZ~ A/j/Ia yvS) y ,t7yyy,yy A/j aa /s& ) / y>AAoc<^>- ^Ay/Z A/3 aa /s/)/ .yy^Z
 ^s/o/ccs*y A/3 AA ySJ^yyy) •S.Aou/A Aye Z~yyy ^yyycss yfyyZyy^ZuserA
 y?s <yAZ<F^ycy yy, .AA/. ^SAcA&ys Zt7.yZ
         yyA- _j>AZ Aaj AZ- AvsuAtyy cyAy^AyfyycA /^«A yAovy t/oAyAyiy-'yy*^
 cjA Cc>'j\seyyA A jyyxcA Ay cAsf't <4<*/Vjk/^^c-^ y<ydeZycy y<cWZAs<
 ZAy yy<yyA pxyyoyZ-wyy/cc' 0Ayyy<Zyyc<c. _jZy sZA' </. ^aZZa/ZAa, ?X?
 Aux Ac/ yyz ,y</3 (yZyy/y,^. yfy?p. A/W7); ^S^Z^yAZAAy yH^A^^A- v/y^s
<?/#, y/y, $3 S. yA ^oyA, yo<yj -yy 3£ y C^A AJ Ss/Ay<f7s) A^>^%cyyAyfc^AZr
y>/<jis.<*/ A Ay yosAAisy yyyc/ cyyy^u,\y<,cyAyy/A yAAyur y^u>A yyoA Z' yy>y
  Z^kcss oy c jxzytcAcyyy.             yVyAt/cAc- y. _5A SS'O ~s. j,y y<y y7/^ ypj AyZA A~<x
 Zyy A9fy)
        ysi;y}A y oax.A d~AXc~</ ocs/cW AAc y?y70±yc~c,Ao»s /AyAZ x^ y^^y?/ /ya/AA
((zxmaAA. yv7oA/oyy       **J A/^/y/cr     X£suAA/ yyc     Ayj   AAc'    /yy/oc/c/'Oy^   o/
  j//AZ'4/t''s'ji;AZ~/ yxyy^cAcyyAy xAxy/ AyA/nZ/ ct'yycA'yycy. —%yy /(A>/>zu'y£z-
 y. ^sZ AZyp. j AsA 2c>cA> $6 £>.t,y. 3J 34*.
.—'-y/£AAs~cA'<y£' A-Ss,s/y}y/c*-' V ^cc/c/j^/ XO*. Ayf/A^sC so y,A y^AAo/j yo —\jy>pA<£<£
            .Ay?- A>Ay/Ay*4 Aya/yAA*yy<ry Ar/AA A /A~ yycAyy Z -^ypj/icss AZ
(fy/cAyyyyy /aA^aAZ j&/zc<Z Zij>*~i yyys/cAcy AA' ^yys.iZyycy/ t^y,:y«yyyy',
cAass u/aA /^<;/A /yd ,y //<?/*, Ayixn /ys'// scxA A3 xa/vs)y ^AA,~y ^AcaA
 AlJ A'A /SA), Aa/<A /AcT ^>AZocsy/ A/JAA /S3, ysy}. /CAosi. tysAs AZ'ic X ***A'osy A
scpytyis /Z Ay AcaAyyAA-) a*j y^A/cA yf?^. ^sAxc/c-yA^y AsZZyA sAc-
 AA Ay/ Z'a. y&-is<t-_ss/osyAy/AA/S',y6)/' yAc ^y^y <rAy>XAyyZr Aax y/<r
 J>*yyQ~i A)yi,yy/yyy s^yAyyiss ZzzAZy*/ /Ai/ Ar , cD/%cy* yA/4ass, '— A^y^A Ayy
 Aya /}^>^^><r>s/oy/. "\ /3 AA 93 ).         Q^tyyysy/ /s./yzs ^yy/Acy,Vc A~. AvAA/ier A /A-
y Aa?<?A ^y-ypAc^s, jyy y^o/'ayy /reiser A? A?A yossA^Aw yyo c/_sc^y<ryy /
  ZZ^-y-y^ cyyv>A'C AA y'/ysA/cyy yy^/oy/ /A/ AAc ^>/xA /syys ACy,s'<C<A
 A> yCy^y oryyi yy/ ,\<sc<* fay A'<y <£~y,<Aysc<c A A/' yycA*ys<z~.               y xf^r —^-yyA
 y/'^yyycA'iiyy-sZ to/oAAyyAirz AA' yy/A A             yyA^Ayc' yssy^j/o^^c 0/ c<siuyysyA
 yxA' S^yxe'/^c ^luz-z/ Ayy AAc Ayy^Ay^Xyt/ yy.$<t'                     Ayyc/Ay/cA <'• /y-AksA/d/esA>/y
yz<y s. cA y^^y^ (/9$/)'/ ^yS A^AZ ZZ ^ZyyZx^A A ^A-A^^y^r
yAA-^Ayc' Ays.-zA?yyccT Ay.scjyy-seA, ^^/,/A y yyyioyy6 y^~J>A y A^y /y^A'
yOXoyycr/ Ate' y/ypAcyyyA*rfcsAArA^ *y AZAc~o*»yyse'A£ /cyyPsic^yyyXyrAoyy AxX
 AyyA^y yfyy o^'<rs?^//^er r>A?xyA4yrA<*/ y^yAsoyyyAyryydSSy Ay jS-Atr^/yyc^
<rAXoyC_>     cJVt   s~-// S3; 'j>yys <^>/ <r^cysc-AA yyyAe,cyAy<ry2/A^*w9syy<<r- —<222'
 ^SAti e//Ayy<A/ -*c,y/y).
            ~-~As    AAs Csto>-*syA ZAy c~y(./(3si. <OA\. ^"^is'ss/oyy y--y^>   C^"^/L/s£rA At'/xc
Xo AZ A /^"/j// yA> -J>t.y?pyty3S yy,cAy,C£' /><<<*' A cAcy%,yyc AA' -AA^yiA Js^/kcA
aZ ZZ' sl cs y<A<ryy&L-, yAy<-cA yA c Ay/AyyCc -J>AscA A/Zcy?AAyAytsA*              Atru/sZ/scZ a/a.
AiyAAyyyJ cxyc,j,.s>y/ y,oAA AA yf y^^Ayy A Soyj)x£Z± oyy y Ac ^f/^/i
XyyAo/y y_s <rycA/cy A Ay<ycscr yy/Zcry^y o/Z'yy^A Ay /A' yoA'Cf yy/ tAsk/tAxcy <*/]
 A </c~Ayy<sAyAs /<Jo/-.AAZy^yyyZ/yyA y*?Xy yy^AAy oisXcA /o A/i^cyy AAc'
 tZfZyvcZfysZA' oc/AZxAZ/xA S*y cAsi x. yAxi^yrs, yz A 3A y3sis/ A3y/
 A A^Ayi. yyfy)
                 __y /y y^css/^c yAAxtyyyys yy^Zsiyfyryycy ,^/AA yyy-yzrcA Z>
X/jr   tzAzs'syeyy y/<A A A A' A syi^/'^yy A            s<^ypAy3± /    /Ac' A><.,st/sutus.A
 cAA*.s^;yyy ,s^ZAZyc            AZy cA'yy-<./^yy ^Ats ^AyxcAAxZ xyxs^yyAAA-. -x-yy
syy}/,,jc A/x/ Z?Z't.sy/''yyxA'o/-y. siy/cij/ c-^yys. cAyt     ^yAc'AA'^     /Ax c/yx/'Aoyy
AcxsAg At' Cc>yy~sAo.xA y s, 'Acx^yyA A/xAA/xZoy/                     ' A AZ' xocyc/
 yoy/cAc/z           AAxA AA </ec/s/t±yy <yyxs> ^s/zyycc,-c. y^y^sc/o^s / Ay/Z / s-yA<<"^y<A,
 /Axyy AZ' A^yA _s> A<±"Ac/ yi±A /syAyAxy'^ /AyAyxycA&t&'c/ AAy xy/occyc/yyyy^s
 y>Ay;tujAy ty^Zrx, ^AcA cAj. y AAyrAy syy> A J<y y3o As''* yy,c, y^o?\
        As><>-       cj>^,y->xA A cAyA>o^-yy£' <s/y<r/s/£>y_y /yy-s ^•AxAcc, / y-J^yysy/
iy./o^yc/ A^yc' A<A A            <rc>yjc/ue/ y^ tAc/syXTyyAfyyA sAyy^//Gy7A:>y 's<s/o /Ah
 yA^A , cA'<-yoy^syy2'yy<r3y a<aZ A*1*** e>rZZr otser.                 A^osyscA Ax^ A c/yy
 Z     stf/Ay yAyy2sos<yxAZyyyj;s /yyyy^A'cxA^yyj              <~>/i A ^ix/y A Xyx~sc>*ysfA'/&r
cAycy/oyy AAy?A^fxAy5 yyiAAccZst- /yyyC^AcryA\yyy Cj^yyccyssyfyiy. _J>yc-~
 A>Zx/c//ysA, Acy/.S. CA cAo^z / y-Ac<s;yss y. A^/AA, yz3 _£, c/ z^zy Azoo3.)/
 /s>^y),//y y. ZJcyfstAs yzs J> ^/ ^As^y Azocy).
         Ay ^yyyys/ox/^/y         <y/cX-ZS c&yys,\s./xyc <-,/ yx^x^y/yyc AAc' ^yyyes/ayA^y
 AZ <~>A xZ~ yAj>sc<ro/yyc aAAda/./z/ ys ysy<cAAc: A.yy A± ~z^A fyyyc^sAcxA^y
 yyyAA ^s/^yt/ o/ (y^yA/ A x^erxs^yyxiAA cs>*wye'yyyyAyyA't-yycy /^yo^yA Aver cAi/^c
     $<B-y yZs~ry?y x- AA\£/AxaA, 73$ y'yy. 30 y Ag'* yx. yfA'A xxA^y xr>
Cc»yxZocA A/jy xxy -A,xA //aytSzAcxAyoyy Gyyye-yy?// <r <£>yy^.AAAA A c Ay;.c
A/soAxyycy <*A yy<rAA~cA~iyyyyyJs. —%r'X         Ac/xy/s l/-    CxvAA&Lst'&e*/, S~66 AAA yS3"
 As~ C'*. A<j>o9 ). C"ou,A-s xec^Gyyyey AAaA /yyyAAz-cAucryyy'sx '-* cyyyyyiyiAf
cAx?X /yy c^y^ZxZA/ A COy^yZ^A^' Z'A^c Z Ay^^yZ'^xA Az'cyxyoC:
(cx^/ysyA <Xy, Za/A A' syxA Z                Zxyc y*y?y?Zy A ^>AxyZ~y<- <^A^yc£ A<£yi;/ys/
XcjsiS<-«Ay/C    y     CCX/y?7sy AyXC <^/ /yyyC^/cX/t^yy ty/Ac'y/ /6' Axs yy&A yyA
<^AyypyyyxA AAz' yxc/s <-j/j /yj/c/ j>lacA y cZc/s/^yy y<^y<A y^.- ^ycAcr.
       A Z /s. cAxi           AysyA oyV ZZc X6c~>*A> AZaA AAciX Cy.yAs yyo /yyi/ZTsA^xAyy
/y/7b       AAx    scsfyc/ Oy.     Sy/^uyzC       &/ /Ac     cyAcycc' czAiAxAyycA cAst/yc AAc'

<yycyy7sc>^/XAA          y>^yyccAA AxZ A/^XXe               Ayxy./ A<y AuezTsAcxAosy,. y A. —^AcyA.
AZAzycyycy, yAA. xAxAa,/./ /^do/rf Ayi/y <A,scdx^-AccA AZA AAc y~y,cA'yyc<L
<y-./As~     o/sW/yyc'c/ . y/'cxxA            yy/Z /ZyyAZyy            ^yo^xA y/^A /y?yy A^y^y

 Ayyy<,/,x.s; /A~        Ay      / */(.     ^AcaA^A        sAh'AA
                  l$AsyA o^c/ AZ ZcZ , C/ sc<r<.< s*r^.Zyycyc t AZ' A^yj AA/Z
ArtCty ***€asA&          AX<ryyyyA'Z <^y/          yZc'sX <sAc>c.s<yAj , ^Sc^ypcy As   ZZZ r^ yyjcA
yyA^ AyyyAAcAyy.                 yy ^^oA^^y Z ^Soyyst&S^ /yA y! yCdyj^^^y /A'
pAzSx///y o/ AcsXyC                       A/x/iyjA'As    AAcXc Aycc'   AAA OctAr zytry <^>A AAc'
 ZcAaA yyyouAJ Axyy Ac-Xyy tZyy^Zc^Ay ZAAycyZ xfs ZZ- Aiy/cZ^yycy
 AaaA ^yau/A A*yc Ayyyy syyycsscA f/yy± AA' AaAs ~Z AZl
sycAcAy^yy/A              A.A/ZA AZs yiyycZ'yyCX AZ' ^Z>A~ c/yyyXyt-Ac <?Z A^Ax.
—>A~yyoys^            /yycA/cA^yAy^A, Aso.^ AZ cA~<S/cA<l ^AAAA c A^yxc' , y7s t^/£XA
A-*-       Axe' ^yyyA'y/c/yycZy^^'^A'^'^y/A AAyyt^s                    oyoc/AA yxyc Acyyy
 s., &ys, y'CXy/AA AAAyytXeA, AAu^                      /CXyyAcAsAz xAc' /yscA/c ZiyyyA <Z~Z*Ziyyy

        7
             yAL ocX^ AA' ^-v^y^^ Ays Zycx, ^,/o^yy ^ ZZxZ Z^A
/Cc C^^ ZaZac yy^AA yZA' y y^Z^y Z ^yyycss <A/Z
yy ZcA y^cyuJcc y^._sA-yCy, y^ aZ a/,.r <^o«/J A^y A^Z
*AM~*vS yZAZ^A^c-, /Z. ^AeriC y^ZyyZ Zc' ,± y^/A^A
Z XfyAcA Ay^-^ ^ AZs ^0_y ^f yy^AAty/tyy A^sZx,                                             Asycy

^ c^'-'-~x y A;AXe Xyy- „^y0,., y **#**, <*U y
 /A//, A.C        As ASiS£ "isA/6yj A".

                                                                           K£Sp\scAAAA/ Ao^ZAyZ,
                                                                         CJ A/UoKCkJ -AsAc/Ay/
                                                                           . Apy/yyZ, yyo ^y
                                                                         /.d.cAA/92AO&7.
                                                                         1391 m 2.3A8 aazZ CLZ
                                                                        sAA/</£J>SAS A^Asuy, Z 7s~220
                               ^(3/lAZa/Z A -AiSAuiar
              —-   ZxxZ c-y^ZZ ZZZcyy -*££- ^ScyZy^A^y^ <y/£y A Zoiy
    Ay/cA COAXcrcZ ccyy &A Ayy/Ay/A^Z Ayyjys<?£ Z> AAy,<Zr«l ALi/eZ iy/yfs
-   yvxj;ZZ Ay (A. s. AA^sZyAAsj; s^/AsA Z AZ yvAZycxsxy A*. AZ AAZZr,
    ytyxi.

    /•^Ac/Xiy/ --/- /Ar~z>Zy XyZsZyy ZZ^Ac/'y/AAy^cy / A^/yCAo^ COc*y ZAot-sy y AOd
    /A yjyu>yiZ/^/xyy yZx s Ax      7^aoxl.

                                                         (ZAA/yxA'tc us ^ZArZby
                                                          yypacAAyy //X° -5"t~

    . : y Ca yAyZAe,^/ -AxcAAA/y y-Ay, -A y9gA06 ^ ,- Zy/Ac yA<£^<syjZA
    yy/XXXcyxAArc/ /&   JZrZ 6/yy/Z -xy ycX/yyyssGy AZ.Ayyy yAA, x<Cyc//C Ayy<Z
    cZy<rAly?e~ <s,*yACy yyyyyAZ ^AyPAtycxy ZZZAZ' yAtcA&Cyyye ^Ay/A-y^crysZ
    AxAZ<yS AyscAy^xycxZ. xAAzyAyZcA o// xAZs xZ' =3aA*ZA?y &Z ZeyzT^ZZe^
     A^oys.

                                                             Ca Z/jJycu ^SAZZv
                                                           Al)/. A*- y92/06Z