Court Opinion

ID: 4058078
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:55:57.50642+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:38.382721
License: Public Domain

%3, UQL/I 'O\ »DQ/OB/

@‘-!

\

lot 'L_M Cw-e al Cm»~cw.\ Ap\o¢¢.ls
@,ap¢'+o\ S+a_)<(@w

‘ l./-\L¢\ A¢os+a’» Q\U\<
Qc>. 31 -1130€

Aué&zv\ ,'T)_<' ‘72;'7¢_4

I‘\ :Cq&`<)(\¢\ Co.n$ o\.\q_ (Bx)c¥ (‘1“(“\277_

\cxas Dp+ C`.riwc\`\»\a.\ loé'+ac¢z.
laws v A\\r¢é u»\: +
'Lke>\ va 3e‘( M

iowa \Oa<`l< ,T>( 7693(07

ch Wl@ A`a¢| AL¢S*¢ /C[¢rl< ,

A'\M poéwarélmj a AH)[JM\`+ \'v\ §¢Ma@r+ of B§l¢\¢r/" mg (o¢`/\¢_\Q 00
Tbc§ iv\\MQ+¢ GAL)F»'¢\ Qc\m:$ov\a. CTM#NLHQ??). mrcarcgou\a lm\\`¢v di fame
02 \1\`5 \Ma.\`\mg_s `\/\Au¢ 30~1\¢ \Mcss~`wj \`v\ pm+ cr en+a`ve\~/¢

C_m%w
\M:U@\y[

REcEl_vED m
CDURT OF CRIM|NAL APPEALS

5 é>ajes ewelo§ezs
JUN 22 2015

Abe!Acosta,Ciers< `

 

4\4\¢ 4\’\'>€4 44@0§-40\ v Q.\a¢LeQ 44&05¢(4¢4 Qc`\mi\no4 A”()\)aab'

@E‘.'ZQ@\;\€§T; th Qc\\>e¢r

M\‘ACGS‘\U. 4 ,

§v\€losa,¢\ p4€c€se. '4'-4`1\0\ m \~0.£\\)&54 4 1444€(40/\' Dlo.[S. |Y » 42400:4 4/;(\00> {£ v{(.?u
UMA i)(\ \U,xa m Q\-\Q wm N'.mm(\»c> m>( memo p.~@d~.@u§\q\
4 S\’m\g\\.\ 4)€4`\€1,\9 44\9, 4.)¢404)(4&1\4\{ Dl:$"k 4 )(4‘4‘4'01¢\£»| aAde_ DH'}Y~»"d’/@/d/l¢
am Ci\ou$l}\g \v\>.\ 44¢(}.4 r'\(§\\§r§ .Tam‘)e n\ng w444\ w\.\{ 21‘4\\/`)§§.

4 wm Am`\e¢\ ,v\\§4m'\m4w\ 40\,\4’ vi\ w¢§14\vz;\ wm (\Z(-l~(%cw\fo/\ of 4412
\>m>e ¢4'\\:\>.\ Q`»\w`\gs g 'WL Mm\\a'>w\ \!\®.>£ ,<
x \4m/4\M ma 0,42'@¢>(4_* is gveeA/\H~ Olp\)m€\'c§€{j.

\\M>TE". `YNS v€)/\{`c4£. 5<\ 4\~¢) Q!\\)e,\z>§)é`s ‘QLAL€. 44 4)€(11'(13`£ 4¥\ Q\/\Suni'\_q 441.2£“~€
44\\}\¢§ ~ »\4\<43\,\9\/\ 44\2 'W\a\\ mow/n 4. 40041\0»!€'44/\0 mdan 45 014.5'0 pur'PDJP »~
~Qu\\\g~ :\ crt§;tn\{\g u¢\=\'4\ w\>.\ Mcxi4`\n35.
' mm \ §QQQ`\\>.M} `3>(¥\\»@,\ ¢\541'®$ csc ~F\\¢L harris 45qu v@e]uw@.
'LML <;/%M?M» cl - received 1104”"€

$’$A?~'L( 'o~z, mcqon vw ‘ce,
83 Mv( wm - renewal mdma

\ 444Q(4 \~4 442\3\3¢) wi4*s\ 'B\`c4 054- \~€c@i\,»~l 4 4924&\»\€ 373 H’LU~ 0‘/ 7 jjqquz/
Qesp%W\q, (»“ra,l:m`el [bm/&'\Q
AH led Ll.nil'

5 41 m F. uqu U.

 
     

EM401’49"44 l

AFPm/+u )T no supporz‘ro)¢ DELA\I

Ex QAw>r §
wv¢ XL.WL\A-o\

~ 01 §
4 03

§ .
_ 944}`¢40115)4

41 Q>l&\:(_\`€/\ QCXC(§\U\C\» Q.\$'.Yh> '\ M€_.\`r\ pv€.§€n)c\{ `\v\CClr(!£_l`C\\?d \`~/\ 441\€ 1444 42604
4;4¢\44/\ uu\t\sc‘ TD Q_,.§S it \HMHU7L, cmc/4 4w\c§ C'ow\p€4én'4' §~46¢-4€ 05 42044¢»_\3‘-

\.
4 am~~\“\u app4i`em4 i/\ 44\2 C14ol:\.xt)W Q¢/\~4~I~4»4€1;4 (°ciuSQ,_S 02ij 040 4)€4~6401{
34&4144\0\4 on 0\1.4$.\$' , 4 9\'\€04 m Q.E®\,\€ST 1501 sTA\/ br&muomnm./
hamm %( walk w i§z.v\zu-cl. 23,1|1¢)¢01, &z,uw'oz. and lmu,s+
assumo_i/Z.QU('DLI . l 4¥4¢64 '~4 mad-45 . \ reques¥ed S+@Lq because docum'
o,./Am$e_r 4a \>mduca, such eu;d\mm %rwgl\ £e§+b
4\€£4 vm`\4 a m¥ 44\0. 4444 441!4 44“4-4/ 44404444.mw 4\04_! 40£0\ U/M`€CLSo/\cz.l)h m
k 634qu `\\\ \<3<1>€29,33 ~`/\ 441 ver_£ dune. Ha.\/\a..no+ ve(;q;md an any
war . 4 \r\cmsL 4442£4 Q @cr"»e\:zmca {c¢w)p}q{n+\ , A$'£t;m m +keq me PQHS`.
4<"@£4 4\»>{44 Q<`BEX\MEQ Sud/\ pmm£»ep W\)J\ 42.41‘695,

443 ¢>@ 364/§§ \S?Vv\ daq~¢4 luna 4 how \~Q,Cé\uM D(`Len'>\ avowed
, or v€>`pw£, gnma 402,\04') ("l_nv\‘\#\l.- (3\'(.`4\0,( er amf W\a~4»4'€r~f Pe,fMinlc`/\j
4v mg 4136435 4 ma`\444f{\_x 44\\'1:\\»0}\ ~\4\\$ veh\`c\a 40 emma 04,9410€rq,

YMWU 344;`¢1»/\4' Scs_\{€,u'\ ub4.

Tc\m. ul\A vauX maher pre/ong 04 \)Qqur\|. Msp.w\rcd\q mbww
Qa`\m;@|, Qa.-AM'“NH»MZ
4444 deal Unhl'
91 \.\F.uczb,.°{ h)*
40 ¢§ a ,T)L '74113[/‘7

  

 

 

4:£&_»'\'4>.4' Q.C\m'\r\ca\ 4\'\)12044 \~`>b‘,\».>`“* 33qu 54 101 »DP> will
4\¢\ ~4?4\2`4'€\<05 (§bw\»

EXVC\A?_ 4144140“0.\4)§@40¢\0 §
a F
§ Cmmmm 1140 VCALY
§

 

QE®\AE§T ?-04& smu am Alm\,'\u\<:¢>rv\o\\) DF umw 4
434 44444’>€{45 COYLQUS`, 444 l$SHUC\ ®b£UlUE/UTS

Cow\eb new Cl&4onv_4 0&\"€404\0 4 099440&4\-4" \drc`) SQ, \§/\~44\9 044:¢>4)£ 604§~44204~€1\/\£4 numb~
exe,c4 4!314$&§\0.0(4 4“4`4€$ ~4'4/\'\& 4€£44)4@5-4 ‘4\'>‘4'4\0_ 440.,2¢'4’¢>42 crim(\r\a4 44 Qea43 44)( 3464\{ 4¢\ Ccc4"\u~~
dica\`m\ 04 40€‘1:4/ 04 ~4?4014>20\$ Cov\)uhOm'\ 425\)42€‘441`;144»{ 54\¢.\..\ 441\€. 4§\»440,\»4¢\5§

 

 

 

 

\ ."_04\2,. \0<{-4/ 424140:'

44\@_ 4\1>\)\'~®..¢\4 §§ wuw_ 454 44\1. B<\awcl\<_; (Lu\e cmi 400,4`\2,\)23 ~44\¢44 44\Ls m\c,'\§ 412an u41>4c~ ,
-42.;\ \»\.\ 44\0 4')\341-\'<;4 A’¥%rn.e\\$ ¢>4`4\°¢‘2.4 cma\ m 44\3, 94347§\`€.4' Q\e.c\L _Rc webb 4".@.4¢\~4\§.4_0¢0¢4¢
T€y£x$ .`44\4.\8.~44\1 4~404\0((\\3\¢ 4)L4A\oe7. m ` ge 'Y£Sidw`\£_` . 'm 044 bod-45 ~Q`4ac4 pm Se 04 40€4\\144/¢4
44\2 \'\Qc\n-\' 4 Camw4 make 0 proper 04 . cm(vw inn ; QSSQ,SS 44\2 411€:45 44\€040.®44\1£44€64£ im

44\¢, \).4¢1' 'y-. C¢>v\$e£iuen“\{. 441 444\>\)4'\0044\4~ \..§\44 4)@, 94€\\1¢.~4€00€4 \'é\ \\"u' &4>`44¢=414 40 W¥S\AQ.. habeas c£4`w~4`.

`T4\m. ucc \v\§;s'mg ¢:.m/w; . '

`\4. \\44;544\9 wmw\`\¥

44. `44\0 449944¢9\4\-4 c4u4\\ 4142£4 n Mwomv~c}\um 04 haw 44>¢ mc»ln 40~1\`4 npp4icu'4iu/\"44\e_ APPMCA~
¢\4 4Z4Q£4 0 redaebd 0004€&$'\¢:\ 4\:»¢ C&we,f\of‘w>§ C(LL> 40’.'>0 454 043 , 'm suppo(-\ 04 414:' pbfn~4 ne c¢!-
an\¢ 1441 App\`\con¥ 9:4¢¢4 wi§messe,s‘ s+cc\'aw\enks Pb{ cause v\o`s.~z.oo$ Cim\s QYL DWD rank

Cm~) L414\ \`)\(B).°t\¢\o_ Avp\icav\4 444@_:4 nev~>\v\ &iscm.4{¢¢:;“4 §4&4 04
qmec4;\¢42\';\ EY~4n4oi-45 QM S\AcL\ c'M4m{,T4\Q. 449§;4(¢2“\-\' a\.§\v pmu'aAzA ~44,\@ 34~5440_'( 5144£'4)§4
40,\¢\1 gm Cc.usws;: w>s cum ma 4>4 am wm am qua m.a“d exp\a`\m| 4®4.> 44\@ LUA\&\S
o¢\ `\4¢“¢\ 43 45 `£;4’_(04\10\)`$\4’4\»;~» CUJ\NC4 444\\/\¢\4~&1.\ 0:)\'4€@:4@L4 44\£. 0§}¢<42¥\)42/\-4' 018 4‘4/ Qe(-4a4v\s 45444¢1 4`w:4-
omc-4 m`\sso.c\ ~4)4\¢.'\42“~ \'.S wovd\'¢\g .(\)<\m@ ~44\¢\-4 Cmv\sv.\c\\`¢l no4 ev\)\m`r\ 04\\444¢\$4/\3 rci Q¢jseem4.4\> app

44¢0\,\5¢0.4 444€\\ P\Qu uaw en‘\'eceé ‘4’4\0\ om\ ~4'4'\¢€€. l
”44\2, a\>wo. was 4\4u4 mdma Sm;\¢ gauge w44'4\ 5 S€o»l~4>4` s bow 434 47_ pages ¢`44\11 Qppkcmn¥ G4Sa sen-40 ‘L page

zi§\€mo§\Tm 40 4’\\1; C\Qr\k 04 S\AC')/\ R"`\\\`ng§ . 43\)€£644\ anal rewch ¥4’4\0. C\»Qc\& *4<> mk$\i ~\'\\L
4\\§§\4?:§“4 424 dd\`u£<\\~ 641\(.4 44l cm\l dow~\o 645 \\§\SS`\(\%. 4\@.4)(4/\¢¢' A{a\ ‘4'4\0_ C\er\/\4 l

T\v\».u\rmv. wm £:42¢4 w\émr cl s{;\540 pcm)mc.m w'\¥\\ QdArass ocl\,u¥`ce `4?60`41( "Dis§\-
\¢;L'¥ (‘,\u\(s 64'“€`§€. 4~4'<)666 '\~r\d\\c& \;\c. Cecm~le,d Mci\\ .~`\”o\n\ m]g\\»\_ A:-ZF|O m. ’De.\{vez\; c464"e
\;¢“\g (>S .0LL\T »~4'4~:1.4 is 446 'S~44\ daq¢>4' 446\{.204! 1 '42@4\10\ \~€ce{())r r‘€€\ueslegi was s'u_;}z\e¢;\.
s\¢w\m-;.w@\ rees-wa \>q w A§p\\<;m&. (‘M¥. nn +Q»( lms pumq¢ is void mo com Zoqq
§?943.

\\\.”\Aa><§m<»s

4c §§p\\`cw\\ waves 441a reqm,s¥ \»Lmus@,\n.e_ \~Qo€\\wd 0 4~e44w ~4¢\>§~4\45 Lm-\\,\er wis
Ceu-el\m\c\ .L.>\w 06\42¢4 44\¢. \/\M\vm\»\e'; x£c U “\,_->Qco_ vtc:<>_'\\£d .`4\¢\1 OL(`:\>4‘\(‘0¢\¥;\ \c\m%er \v\qu'\coc4
u\oo.>.\ Néemc\c) 40,44€( . QQ_X"&`QA \0/\041»05 nu\~‘\(\'ej M 44 weis unc-4 received

1.. ’4\\9,44\>`94'\<:6¢\4 mm 44\'\5 cequm4 \)eeause. 4\0, \»0,44'@.\)¢$ ‘Y\~ead}ud'imkan eQ-»~sudr\ m¢{45
43 lns4 4\'\3 hhc-mh `\.2¢(\2¢\`\€¢;4 . anc,'\ 4)@.4`\@.\,-&3 944\¢44 445 suckjs\\ne CO\S€ 4.0.042.»\¢`64
414/45 chu$& 04 -\»4\1) m`\s$`\¢\q dbmmenH. \).>4\§&\ mm (T.ém$\ni£d 4{4)Qm44q _. cr us ‘4‘4/\9,

_ 0)(>'941@“\' €\~.\4¢2£4 \r\'\S §e,\-\\\`ol\§ . `G/\ ~\’4/\@ wmu\a*\~`.u£ amsc (2&\€2\0-4'. 64u4)4454\&5 412. C4`E4 n6~4
_ mum, w \u\ow&g. mmqu am .;\4@44;5@“4 adm\.\:.~\ 64'¢36:\4.

\v. QQQ>\€ ov- wmku
‘4'4\2 4¥[> 4\'('04“\ 4/\6_\ 440 §2041`1945 'Q~(bw\ M\o, Oc>s\ O“icg omo\ 00,\'4\` 4241£4 v€(!tz.`~\§h .44/\(:4.ue4iv~g
(\XL\\K\ BAQL{§\/ ceqms‘bd ‘g`w'uv\s m §m>£ -44\¢2»\/4\0.~\£\'\4@4 ~4'4\1246\$62 5464@04 cmc4 Mi_;;i`v\q A¢~
wm¢\¥§ ¢`\\\o A§p\{ec-.v\4 wi\\ mqv\e_ 44\9;1\'\ avc\`\\c'\\o\e m bush 03 ~4'4\9, r\s\m\`za¥dv\ who p\aw.
4\’\»4\\ \0€ mcc44€(4 'V4C\ 02'('\\'43£<4 ‘N\a`\\. Ql>r$`\\>\\, ‘4\¢\L 4?'4’4¢\ '~'4°4`4'4\ 04"4'4\1$ N\l)z\'H/\ 69 )wI\-€ .
\/. ' ' ~' .

\»>'\l€a‘ecou€l ’MEM.\§EA~ Cmu woman ,Hw_'app\imnjr paqu 44/)'\5 Cm(+b¥ Onm.hd Apym/J
4b 's\~'c\q fm 664§\.\04`\004~»'0\ 04 “\4\»\;>\~4~4: mm \>24/\6\¥¢4¥\41 A¢p4iw*4' § §QAA{N ve 4`4\`€¢¢4\`~\ 04
(\‘.54' ‘\ Sb>(\\O\\' Prpp4\(oe\3r \.».{\44 (\S\’\>€. \By-€it.z.b\`\tid)`\-Qc PmMAuFANV 04 '4`120444€ z 14 4"4(. SLl(T‘€.SSib€4y
§\\es em><\¢..r w¢§¥ici:\c$l<\\>¥\oz, c"x§\>}icon~\:r
\zm¥€\\{`s \.g\»\»€( (Q`.?\\v\z Q_o\\\‘\m *\’wz."\\\dc\e'_\ Scea~e.~\oc\}". l -0 §
O\\`C\ V€[‘_@;t\,\i |(`

`L.;.. Dr\>w¥ -\*na_ (‘_ev)¢ic.§c] pod\ccq¢§ ‘)I\.\q¥qm jm\c§ w\mv\ ‘\'

hud m\\{ ')'5 pages '\’\\oA/qsu. sever 'Y\\L O.Q.Ai§u( \el~\/ler -HW 01€`& ms+

<~ecmw\ {\»» w package was vecdc>k\.\ed on M\LS’\L\»\ dmi ¢€»\\!\cw

cé( 3 ‘\>cm. ch\ ‘\'\¥\Q_ m%£.§ M\‘,t-c\nc»[ "\\AMC_"'V\A*“`\*\'\L \D.A Olf€&£l\/ l

(U>Pmdu,\ a.)\d%\q¥ ¥\/\sL (lum\/'\'\QS._ Cl monM/\ '~i\s mom Cl.¢iec`l_sil,\,n fund

§ \.J\\§\'\\d\ G.,W\w\\'\»\\~\é\\¢x\' §§ `Y\\n_ §~\"\'\ dog J’ :\uaq.,'»*\'\u.\{ Am'~\ def:`td& ~“.M

d\’\1\9,1[\»(\\ su)o~\€s< ¢"-\/‘kb ’\’\\Q Su.\)x~€m£.. (§111¥4“' C_Cw(+og (_‘n`miv\a/ Ap‘pemm.

m&-zs u\\ \qu %\\d“.. ..;BM~\S` \

(Qq"€)fqm\§c¥bm\&f\ d/\\
Tr\)w.. acwmh. mohr pena\¥»| o@~q>er`\wq` $L&\>m\¥\¢d v.\s;\$'
Trcu\s\q\m;} bq mi QQ\)r;e/\ Ql\_'cima*£L/WMZ
A-ll aid U\h'l`~}' `

gun Fllu¢$(pq )U.
_ park '.T¥ 7[¢?(!7