Court Opinion

ID: 1082180
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2013-10-09 20:56:34.409419+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:49:00.772623
License: Public Domain

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF TENNESSEE
                         WESTERN SECTION AT JACKSON
                _______________________________________________

BLAKE WEBER,

       Plaintiff-Appellant,
                                                      Shelby Chancery No. 103274-3
Vs.                                                   C.A. No. 02A01-9407-CH-00173

JACK MOSES, Individually
and JEFFERSON PILOT LIFE
INS. CO.,
                                                                        FILED
      Defendants-Appellees.                             January 17, 1996
_________________________________________________________________________
                                                       Cecil Crowson, Jr.
                                                                        Ap pellate Co urt C lerk
                           DISSENTING OPINION
_________________________________________________________________________

CRAWFORD, J.

       I must respectfully dissent. Plaintiff was employed as defendant's sales manager pursuant

to a written contract which, with respect to termination, provides:

               (a) This contract may be terminated on written notice by either
               party, or at any time in the event the sales manager becomes
               disabled as determined by the company. Disability for this
               purpose is the inability of the sales manager due to sickness or
               injury to perform all of the duties of the sales manager as
               described in the contract. This contract shall terminate
               immediately upon the death of the sales manager, upon
               discontinuance of the company's operation, either by withdrawal
               or otherwise, and the territory assigned to the sales manager, or
               by mutual consent of the parties in writing, and shall, in any case,
               terminate on the effective date of the sales manager's retirement.

       Weber was verbally informed on August 5, 1992, that his sales manager contract would

be terminated at the end of August, 1992. Weber was unsuccessful in his efforts to persuade the

defendants to change the termination decision, and he subsequently received written notification

of his termination after August 31, 1992. The majority, relying upon the decision of the Middle

Section of this Court in Webster v. Tennessee Bd. of Regents, 902 S.W.2d 412 (Tenn. App.

1995) affirmed the dismissal of Weber's suit which was filed on August 31, 1993; the filing was

within one year of August 31, 1992, the date Weber's employment terminated. I have no quarrel

with the holding in Webster that the cause of action accrues on the date notice of termination is

received. In Webster there was no specific definition of what constitutes notice. However, in
the case at bar the parties agreed by contract that notice meant written notice. Under this

contractual agreement, it is my opinion that until written notice was given there was no notice

as required by the contract. Certainly Weber was informed and had knowledge that the

defendant intended to terminate his employment as of August 31, 1992, but there was no notice

to that effect. Apparently, on August 31, 1992, Weber acquiesced in his termination and later

received written notification of his termination, perhaps as an effort on the part of defendant to

comply with the contract. Suit was filed within one year of the agreed termination date of

August 31, 1992, and within one year from the date of written notice of termination as required

by the contract.

       Under these circumstances, suit was filed within one year from the date of the accrual of

the cause of action, and the order of the trial court dismissing the case as barred by the statute

of limitations should be reversed.

                                               ____________________________________
                                               W. FRANK CRAWFORD,
                                               PRESIDING JUDGE, W.S.

                                                2