Court Opinion

ID: 4052571
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 02:04:05.226832+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:14.092728
License: Public Domain

a//) f/a-s-UtxAf    706-/S

                                                              ORIGINAL

  yfr/72>y//& l&A772fy?JZ>y/'

 7PJT S7s4rjr 6F 7Z~X/3S

^^y^rz/^A/rS T^ir/Ty&sS yr&%> AyjcZ&rry&sSyfxy' yVyv/sTti/

        /a/ yly^T&yZs:   yj/&. Gf-/3-0o</7&
                                                                FILED IN
                                                        COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
           <?&<^7- 0/C y47>y&yf/.S
                                                               SEP 2 3 2315
      /?&x tW^ y^/y?7?/ tA:y2>y£yy?z Ayc/sTf/cr
                                                            Abel Acosta, Clerk

                                          Jg?? sy-Anr s/wy 92

                                               @0yHT OF CBMINAL AH
                                                     SEP 111015
                                                  Ate!Ae@sta,C»
                         /yj^zj" a/? aoA/r^Wrs

    Z/<ST (Df ^Tyttr/zr^                           Pyterjr £
   Sa/Zxtx #/= AVTS/dyT/TyjTJ                      /><***• ^
 $7y47*7i<&r«/T £/" rs/£~ <£*$£"                  r/tatr Y
S7y^V2t-/^f^"A/T £/= 7W /"ACTS                    B*5* s* <°
s<7?&ysy^dryS7r                                    /KG* 7,S
y^&AYjfy?                                         7M&£- 9
C£7<77Sry'Cj*72~ tD/^ SZTZiZ/C/T                 7MG/T ?

                                                         7m&f
                             Z/sr &y T&zTvyir

 A7=y^£/jLAA/y
 Ayy72>yyy£> y^ryyAZS'd^/

Ayyysypjfisty ~y>j^y^^
Aaizzaj czvkfry 7><ysz/<? &v*W2>/y?j> &AA7cyr
/JJ a/, ^'(yy^ttay/r y^ziyZ), zs £
I>AZZAJ>/ yyxAJ     7S207 - <&9?
&7A7&'s Ar?z>y7'A/yry ytr 77?/y?z

z>AZZA£ ^06/a7tY Z>AJ77?ycy A77&p?A/y~ys G/7?ycs'
ZJJ a/. yryiyyrx/ZRtMjy &Ziy& ZB'- /?
Awzza^ t^tas       7S2&7- <&??
A7>7>y'Zy^yy7'^ Aryz^^yzY Z>yJ yt77>y??Z
AAr/iTfyy/z- A. y^Tty-ny
AfZyAS <COt/yy7-y y»y05Z7£* £xy-~yyyz>y&j> ^77-ycry
/^APA/yr ttowzsy eot/xyj 23z//Z2>yyXZ
7JS yy, '7?;iyyy?y?>oyy7' &yiyz>. y&-2
Z\4yyy?Sy TZxAJ* 7?2£><7 -<%???
J7?i7y-s Ar7&?u&y &aj yr7>7zry?z
CTM/c; *yy?7X7«/s y~ &z? y//j 2>z~<ry6A/yir<r2> >rz7>^szWrAyyiyy.7
Z^fyyAJ' C£*/A7r* &7S77?yey y^yy-y^^rys ^yy-ycy
<*Xx!<yyr eyzo^ys-y ^cyxrs m/yz2>yxJ&
/JJ aY. ^/iyyy?y^cjy7y ^yy2>. yjg -/?
Z>y?y£y?j> TZacAS 73T2& 7-VS59

                                                        y>A&y 2.
                   7A/2>yy &/? Az/rz/<2K/7yz~f
    i

Mo7?<£y/0   \/ STATZ'      7SS S,U 2cf 8&6?C7&x.^jm. at>t>. /9SB)
AzyiyyfAA/ZA V   C&<?   &. W.   £c/ AT /7Z

                                                  TK&tr ^
                    STAry-Mzysr &a taz~ <?aszt

   y^y^z'Zzyryyy tyyts ^y/Ayray7> y3v 7A7z>y&7ywyyyT ^yyyyT
y?<*c£A?yiiyA72-z> y?oy^23y~7cy yyy lyy&yytTy&yy z?x Tzrxry%s<yAZ-
C&Z>Z-   29.03. £7?//2J. y4y^y-yyy7yiy7- y>yy-y> SA07 Gz/yyTy
TV 777/f aAAyWcTZT. CyT7?<A<g, 26-27) A? ^S7>y y^yy^y^y^
An^7yyzzAA/r CZyyyyrY Aa7Z> SyZy3<sy~&ZTZx/TZ A AkSSysSy-y^
y^zzyy/cSyZyv/yy/r At zzAZ" YAS7^.JS6yyyi<?Zyv'7~.(c7r7 &£ y&p
Y#Y •>&?&; 3 727.J c7l7&<5/^ZAy7' l^AS ZaYTA^Z'T) axY
//ZfXc/S 26, 207S C£7?7 7oYj Xttv'ZZAa/T AyZZlZ 777WZ>'Z>/
a/tt/c*- oa y^TTPzyrz. C<^7/7/2j

                                                            7A6£</.
                     S7A777MZA/T Z)A   7&A AACTS

  ytfy Y.-2& y./v. Z>aJ /*A8X6YAZy 27 £67Z>           zVy^ZAS Az7?zr-
 AZ&yYTZCAS ^Y'CZ-y^yyT^ AyY AZyTfryy?           CTG>yYa^-^yJyAY<^   A
 lYZTyYyeZA T^TTk'Z-. 7?KS;7Y.       /l//77Y7A7 yVf/A7d772S A/7Z6AZ&7Y7&ZS
 ZoaAYZ~7>    A /5£7y<:yy7AY&      /ot^ Zz3-<z<yxj- z/aYz>&z a ^tz2><sa
 AT S^ZxD '~7<yl/Z7TZAZ^ C.A. /YAiy/yY Y^zZTia/AY; 77YA lYzTA/CZ-f
 U/AS Ak/ZYY 7A7AOL YA2> 7a/ AZA/Vft'S ''OKXJ7 7Y 7? %> .J zz7zr
A77?>yA/<ZyY72rAT ZT7CTzyYcZc7ZSzYzrz> zzYZ~ A/72T Aa/2> St/S&rcvYyryJ-
rzY Y>ZZ>^a^AA?Z?> A Y^Z^oA yyY TlYzr TXtZA/Zr W7YO *ZAS
ZA7A7Z J^ZrA7T77r7yy> AX           yiAyZZ/AzA AzT/S.Cy?ZS 7<L 79J.
HtYyzzr MY^zz^z^ Ia/AS jttzz AZ/yy y/z' ia/as zyyjeoyyjoyous
Z7yJ7>£S7>OAJJ>/V7- y?A/Z> aV&T &7?Z-A77Y7aY£        AZ>Z'^UXt7-yryy &6ZT
 yxATTYzr^ yyrytyy/yi/G    y7?iA/y?7?Z> yTZ"S7yA^ATZ)7?rY sAZ&trsy. "
C7r7?sr/ 7Z, 77: )    l*yyZZ7A/W     HZAS Z7ZT7A7A7yzy Z^'7Zyrzv7ZA/Az>
 y& T/AYZ" 72J£7?A>       ZV^^TT ^y^A7S Z>aY ^&77/ AXyAS y&7Z>
Yz~&S    A    <ZyyzYjyYz>r /47&67yY7> 7Z> yYYS y£7<$y/7- YA& AaYZs y?yj
 7yYc7£7&Y Z>7? 77Zy?ysZA 7Z> yYYS yYZA25. (^*> y> 72 &<S'7tzjr.' 79y
      ^z3y<CAUSZr ZAAttG/TAYCY Y3rS7=>GyJZ>Z7?S 7>/Z) aYoT
 TFAZyyrYA 7AAY yt/yZZYAzA /a706/Y2> StY7?\7ztAZ- 2^AZZAJ
 Z^GZWZCADZ:' '2^r7Z12'7'/lYZ- IaYAAZT 7aY7T7AZZA ZTciy7TAlCZ7^-^ .
Y7T7?S,-g2 &3) PtY^Z/ZA H/yZ6ZAZW 2>ZZ> S^Z7Z\7zyy yYZ' i^yUfS
 YaJ 777A Y7Z>jsA7TAZ Aaz2> A l*&77A&7Z77Ayyy>s<y AA^YZyyY y^>7Z
 szyzyw yisoAYy-yzs. (y<y?Y.3s YY &a S9 92j. zY/s zyYJzzxzzs
 M7ZTXA SyAAZA ZTAYOtYcZ/Z 72? AYzrCZ'SSYrATZ' 77/Z- yVyvfAZTzTTy^yj
 cy z>a/a &y y/zs zzrczj'. zyr^v ss ys S& 9z J. W/zzyyrytz?
TVyVAYTAZA/ZTz; 7y7<r A&ZZY7Y rz> 7?Zy?7> z^yr ^yy> ^
ZoaJ<^ l^yrA ZXYS- y* ^r ZXAyyY Z>s7yufy?as ftZZAZytt
Azozw jt^oaz' zAyAAzAAzoA/.CTTTtY <Y? 87X //a z/AYz>z7:&t7yyjy
7«y77rz7>zz- SACyy7 C^yrrs.y^Y 90j Ms A^y u*X
  ASSSSAZ ZZA AS A 7?y^7z7 *A *Oy*A *A Y/7S 7yr>AArz^yYr
vA/ TWA yVZ&AzzxZ.(y?7?Y#7-e3) A& yyYy-Tyysy Ayr ^^z y^
i«za*3 <?T77Z <<>7Zzyc$G,zzaYg r& jyytzYr, Cttyyy-yr S7J.
         Jl^zzzyjyAJ' yA/yzz7?zy<5 z'Azwy Ag&yx y?2 ttyz"A^z'&yzx &y=
 ttzyYAT 777S AYz?yy7yz?     Y>ys<zx7&yz> As A      "2>x?tza Z>yxzz <5&y7z-
&xL&''' y?7c></'*7£j. Zz^^yX7t/Z>iA7yZ5'7~ 72? ZYZcJ y^ATcZAYTS^ YlYzZYzytZiY
 Y7AA &yyyY <^AZZZ^Y^ ySA7?yyy7AAY/4          JtZZTW 77Yy X&'ZT* Z)X A
Yyx-yZy<Y2> AAz \YyyJ z37te>&X£. Cxiz V-' <Y7 <^S/ &"V, S9y Z> ol Y^yszxxtJ
YYzZ7>y'7> Ydtzcyytyw ytSAxy CToy/AAaxyy>AYcr pyyxA yZyZXZies,
 7A/azyy2)ysycS A7c7 Z7yY<2Zy      zAtfyfAS' ^yx-AZAX7> Cc?ZZ7a/S, yfA-A
  czUywys z3zyTAZAJ7i2) AY^x?i><J.CzVy^Y/ £& Z>3 7V7.). C^zzyyJS
 Sgzz> cxy?ayr (ZogyPyy/y.^yTxY yAs YZ/J, /& yYaz> astysJ
 Ay^Tt&xk-yYz'Z)      TSY   zHT/ZYyAytA AzYT)   A%x>cJsy A&otZT ^AZZZaY^
 7^^7tzyz/y7y7Ay Yl/yzzzy?ys GAYA yyyy^r a "/=zyy <yAx-fx>yy '.
Cx>xv yA7 y&2-&3 y^<srj. H/yZZzy?yy xisxr C&zzzsYS zz? YYy
 AAZy/A7 Z>xt7za? Ay&yyy fiYz/& /yAyY7y7) 70 yzzyy y^zyrxz^zzyWA
y?sYZ> AJAcyZ) AZ>7? AyYZyyYZ' yL/Z7yi7<gy-y?£? yjy AyZTZZ" 7Z> axtZZ
As -A&TZ-AyyyAZ 7SyAzl^st X^r/ jrs-ziJ. _j£j <2<z>zy/^jc? 'z>y>?,J/&yJ^
 /Py'zzyypy^ /syyu ^TyzcyyJc^ CZ&&Z> yury^xz^yytyJA "c?y7zy?7> "s4aYZ>
 z*z#cj a7z>t ^ryzzyy ^ayyY " x^v /y?-7&?J. tfrtzzzy?yzy AZ>y^ry7xz2i
 Air frZA*c? xY&T yyyr>y yX7>X7ZyyyYaZ?> y^Z TWy 7>7?i/& ttTSyyYySS.
YlyTXY    <ST9~6oJt

          £a/ AYj573ZYAa?Y £7 207& ^ZZZTfyA Pi/Aa/T 7D <~OZJ.zAcS '
 y^T^yrxy^Z-AYT 777 Zy?^T Z$y&zx?<5 72> 3ZZZ AYZ^f <SZ>a7A ySyfXZiX^y/A,
CAzy ^-^ZJtejtJ XX5 29 AS V&7 yy\yy>x 72? A7?X>yiyyA7& Ax
 Cy>ZZ7yJs A7^A7^y>UyYx /^yZZzyeyiA y?yJ7> ChzyyyJZ* cTA&yz- &sY xMT
 7W^styZ'.£yr7?y- Z*g y<5-s-~y*-<zj,   Afy zxzcf A^/aZX yT&^YyVz^ 777<r
 lZ*7?Sy&yy ZiX yizZ-A/TcT Yz?&>?aYcZ Zy7> 72? ATVZ? yyY<?Z£Y3yyY&
 Yzzr y?oy?&z7?y S77y?c?7-ysy<z, y?A/z> yyxy ^^-^?y^ry^s sy^AYyAYd -
 AaYxzY dyyAyy&yAYy 7SzyyiYyZy<Y ^hzz^YcT Aa72> PtYyzzyyfyvf.

                                                               Tfi<Z£ <o.
                          Y?Y?<&27ZWZAY7

      T^tzTZ' TyYz" AYAXYY £o^Z7Y7 Z>A Az^AZAZS Y>72> c?&Xfs*y7-y
      A<$x?y&ya£7S ATiTTOA? 7aY TWyyy? yTtYZYA/e?        OX 7WY
     a^x^zzA7Z~ JSTTyyA

     77yz~ AyTzTz#yyyx ayz>77 at:0^yas 7?/y ArxxyzzAyYT eoizTrri?
7Y£YKZ3Zy? STAZ*T7aYcZ yYyy?Y CZAzM           Z)X "7?/Z~ ZrYZ2yA/Cy pAAS
YASzZAXACZAAt 72? St/y^TVXT AT7>yZZAy/x'<5 CtWYzCTZ&yY SSZTZAz/Sy
7/7Z' 7Zf2ST/ylOyjy 07 TAT A<2d.<?7ATZYCy iaYA<5 AY<?T y&X7?c>&07?7l7Z~Z>.
AkYfr 7Z/y 77^/XZ C6>LZ7?T XlB<7Syz> Zr'J Z>ySCZ?£'TY0AY 23Y Ary72ZSyA<2
 X£> <?oyz>i7CT x? 7Yyy?7Z/A/c5 at?/oat tz? AZ>z-fZ7xyyA% 7ysyyywy>sYY
y&yYdZ7?A7ysyCr, 7MT 7AZTzC7?7yAiy7ATZOA7 OA AXT'Z'ZyXAYTS CyZZtZZAZ
7>ZZ6A/y AZ2zo7?2)S 7?aYZ> 77/XT yS &/V/a7c?> T/7Z~ JTX7y y4 23XAZZAZT
T0   MYA/<7A    ZT AS   A/OX   Xa7TZTZX7>   72?.
     Y/zaZT 7/7 XAT AASA AT SXX ZT YS AZX/VZY AZ*Zyz2>y2) ZsY 7Z7X-
AZyco^Y) yyzAT TAX yz<zy/y* yoyryxTYoAzzyzxay z>A xyfyzyUMYY
M4S A7?£>yyyY 7Z? yyxvy S77Z*i/yY xAAz TA/y Aziryyy&y.Yyx' zs
7AZA/z?CyAT 75yy*?yJ7> A yZt~y1Sa*7y?2jyx- A&yyxx.
  7y7y 270c7XT        Z>X yZTyz-AZf S7YZ>£7Z?j ZYOT AZT AS A? 7SyyY. yy/XOZ
Zfy7T yzxsrzTZOAZ yxsyzx AS A AZaZXZ Z>iYy 7&X&CZ&S SXXy&tZXXZ)
72? zwjyx^r xyyy 7?Atzz>azaz/ty z>x Tzzy yzzxys Z)xcyj'y&yX
 XAayjyyY^      Y S77J7y     7SS S.hY 2cY. &Z*6* y?x>r Cx/as. yp7> 79£&^
    Ad>A Tyzy Att?\7y ltyy7<so?y yytyyyyztyyyx yA?<T STY&m/a/ tzYAt
YrYATA A7XZAZS ZZoc?7?T yozyzXZTXyz? AOTeyGZCuZS yyT7?o7? aaY
7?yzY7? A17ZZA/&S AZsUAAaYzA Z>0& &jy. 2c/ Ax Y72.
    7y7y VAAy yZ>yy?Z 7?7 XA7ZS Tjy yyVZT <Sy?7Z? <Z£>tyy?y yS
yc$7?y<£z&£Ys zTkxoaY 7A A/xtnyxr AaYZ? yyyjy oaYZY ycsy?yay<?/ASzY
YYAxMy<YZ 7V xyYZ' AyTyyyvAYtT? 73*7t x& S&ZYATy xlf x pyyT&ZZ,
  A( ZOA/& xzyrfx 7?yyyy yyj Txxx S ylxxyZZAZ' 7%vcyzxyxxS>
AAS &XyxY Oa/ 2>ZXZC7 AtxXyyfZj 7XV ytyc^TZZy y^y /rJy^yr CyPAY
«YZ>7 ZST A?Z>Z>A^Z> 72? AAZyVAXtP^y TWA A7xtz/ Z^cyxx &Xy?7>Xyx?ZS
yo SZZ&csyST 777ZS ATtTZctX.
     y4j xaa Cozz^t <oy CxzajaaYAi Atx^AzS yYoTyyj Oyy*? xi
CyyYTtzxY AGO 'Sly 77AS ZoaYG ZsyyAY A TKyAYCAXZA yyY <?67X?
y7ZYXZSAX2YAyA/Czr TWyy ZiYAZy^" AaY 7SSyy xY A ' <^AT7XfyA7A7Z.
Z&sy yj- yyyy yyz 2>&yYAy 7SY XAA zryzz>Z>YCyy AS xaY AyYA^ASZ
AT T^ATT?     yyZZ'   Z>o^7y3X SyYJiZZZs AZnZytyj J5y yTXSozyAZ? X<Y
Ax-ya^      ox 7zYy Ac?<2c7<syz**

                                                                   ?/&£ 7,