Court Opinion

ID: 4075288
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 05:57:39.759761+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:51:40.061835
License: Public Domain

§   rrJ THE IJL/tH             :JMI)~L
Tl:tJ-Ti) ~.Q 1qj6qt"]q                      RECEIVED IN ·
                                                                         ~
                    fl. fLATa{(_      GODR, OF CRIMINAL APPEALs

                                             CEC 18 2015                 ~
                                                                         §
V.                                      Abel Acosta. Crern               ! DnTrtr.cT     LOlA tt1    o I=
                                                                         ~       This document contains some
                                                                                 pages that are of poor quality
 &mrr H eLl LA tJTY iJ.cst aIff LltfU(                                  ~        crt the time of imaging.
LJ tii2_R./ l+LS t>FFiti£41 ~~PAe,ITY                                   §
                        fZF.sP~rJD £ruT                                 A SmrrH

                       PLfiLJTI Ff's       ofLIGLJAL Af PL!LATin~ Fott w~ CJF mArJDAnAl!S

      TO TH£ Hort/\b12Jtl3LI:.          _Jt.AlJG-£ 0 F 514rD LcJlAILT:

                CDv'VlF..S NOW, .DEmEmrus Ksl UAW1 Qilirof..._, Pao 5L rJ TlfiL V-H3av£
           ST\)I£d tAtJd tJtAmbE!Qf..cl L~utSE- o~ YlCiiavJ AJd Fil£s Tl-fis 6r'LiGitJtttL
        f.\ PPLi64TioJ FoiL LLltLi t oF mYitJd~VVJvl6, PV~tsv1ArJT To Aa.+ic{ E 5 1 :sEt tio,J S
       OF THft T£~.5 CiJrJsTi futiorJ J'\-rJ-3 Attr 1./ .. ot.( oF Tlf£ CIJDE DF CLiNli~V1 L
       PtWL£ D!Jil£, ArJd vJotA ld s l-louJ nf~ CJJUVLI Ttl I~ FrJJ!awtrtlG-;

                                                             I .

       DEmETfJJAs K£1 LtAWJ      -, TOCv-      v>l3laqCJqrn#. o  :r.s A~ aFFEtflt.IL · -
     LJc~EtuqrF-Ll r:,J Tlf£ TEXvkS Dt.PAl(rn8JI 0F GfJ.LMirJftL :JUlST,cE ;qrJd rs ttPPFfiR.it\IS
     PRo${_, wrtC) C£4,J b£ Loc~TEd ~T                     w. a,
                                                mCUJI\IIJEll t.AArir :tnl tMihJ Dif;J
     l3tJ..villt~' lttXJ4s f?.Bio2.-8~fll REittlatCiiAS £xh£41AsTEd His r2Rvvll:.cliE5 AtJd
     HvlS   t\.kJ    0TI~,:;_vt   Ad ELltAA rFv   (!Et'\t1tdy PI Lflv.J ..

                                                              (1.)
  rrJFoRiY!AIIDJ WAS r'2tThfUJt.d To ritE               IIY.rh      UI5.TILLLT CDtAt?.T oF 5.Mrr1+
  C..ClAruTY, T1:XIItS   L.J·h~f..&:uJ&   IH£ r2£LATDt2. w.LTtt   nh~ DFFErJ£.~           CJF    (jGCr
 r3§ALAIT/t&lfiHd84dlyWMPaJ CJ/\1 THF- QjQ.YOF NOVr 1.5-tb             ~CJ    13      j    f<.E.LVJtTDIZ.,r uruiO
Lii(E TO sHow PR.oo~• ...
o J NQI/En'!b£(( IS"tV1    ; 'ltJ 13        n~~ 5 TrtT~ ~CLU1s E.~ 11-lflT w 1+1' I f. 14P-I-r~ IL
A t ItAb ~~liEd ' _TH£ l3ArJ YiJft TfZ.f~t.'' TH tiT m,;_ t4PPf.l IAI\JT WA::5 u/5£1 wj +t,
                     1

A--liF..&Ed vicTiWl vJi,Jd£11 williflVVlS F~OM bt£i,J& l:olle_F-d To LEVI\/£ TI-l£ Clvtb
WHF-rJ All ~b~RTV's c,~W1£ l(!\1 TH£ SV1VVII~ JF-ltliclt:.[Id,AitaE) STAT£ f-lCCII1SfS
THAT AFTEI'~ AJ ~fZGtArVl&J/ ;~ T/11:. \Ji:JuciF... Tit£ SlAV t:¥lt/VI1E TO A STtJf fll A
/JF-f\£ by SToP SIGtJl THffi bCJTH Wll2rJ :ltAvVIP£d LJIAI AJd J4 Llld Y4 ,:;.siFiGrrl
{TeL AT ft/1-'72/15-'7'7} STATf. ACCucSF~ THttT ~PfitllfoJI STAbb~ w;JJ£1/
 WilliAmS \I\Jifl1 A rDocKE.T IZ.I'JiFE MIAif-iPJf I;M,?_.$, T'l4£4r williAvv15 l~l'd{TwD
 PltJf_TR.«ri•\lG-)wot.Wd6 TO -t4io (jbJi'r·J AtJd ~tbdoMJ:rJ(rcL,qT3Di.t"J/1-80 STATi~
 Ex..4~). 1\laf VVllA~;PIE STA-b~ IAJ()wJcL~ tts (-JIIEGELl, HoWE\/£t£ 1}/E siV+I£
 All EGE.d LJi rJd f// uJit/,·v-tfVl..S .S1APt£((td dt~imAs J3odi ly INJLA~y, AFTi-:JL ~H
 YYlW R~TJAirJfd TtJ IIi£ \lth,'c lF- AAid LDrJTirJut~d CJtJ To vt,OPE.-IIMJ~ l~Nit~
 wi,Jd~ll witl,·tAvt'16 Ex.itf:d THr.. llEhicll~ f\GvtitJ2 To STfllfZT ~rJil1fi'--' PfhjSI.Ct4}
CcrJF.2orJ+tAtiDJ, AT AfPE:J/,~trJis HCJVV11:_, .s 14owi,JG 1\ltJ siarJs li£ wAS
St11 FF t.v'(iAI G- t='r?l!Wl VV'\IA I tiP}£ s TA bb WOU1rJdst tJO~ J Sf~ iotAS 13odi/y rJ:ru.l yo
oJ. 1\.XJVfV!'lbCte tSH1                 1.CJ 11   I II.JIEV2 SVVIif'n CLJLArJI1 PoJtct~ arftcr.tt':.S
f\,Qr(F~ T~d ArJd -ldwJcl A ~F~ PouiC£T I<.NiiE ,'J POS.S£SS(DJJ oF APPt~ lfr+tJt~
 Pa:1~ET/ oPfiC£vts TodJC Tl+is /4J i ~[ i~t[) [\lldt.tJCE tA ,Jd 14CcusF.d m s
oF sTAbbitJG wirJdt.ll witliv-JWLS wi·H1 THi.s KN;f£lid,AT3lf-.J&);
wiJdt:-1/ uJrUiAWtS 1\JEv,;.~ wt-~s bf,/J& lt'lJ:v.rn:d FtJrt srflbh wotAI\Jck irJ                       }14£
Emtlbt~itJEd T l~i2ol!1bH DrJPr TfsrirJG-, 14rJd II·IE f2£GME..sT FOIL
TH t_ Pa.oPo~Ed DI'JR TEsTIAIG is rm rf)Ad£ TLJ LAI\.Jr<.E.vtsotJ~ b}y cl£ lb4-V
THE EXffAA1io~ DF S~I\JiE.rJCE. art              AdvVIi JtlisTt2rtTiotJ CJF 3v1STic£.

~(r £l!JEAI.. ~F-i o/tTH TlttttT T/t£ Ftflc[s AM AllfGATiD.JS irJ Tt+E_
  AbDll£ j,J cSI!lPPo~T CJF Tt+is mo1iorJ tAll£ Ttlvlf. ArJd. CfJR..!LEL-1.

:STGI\IEO tAtJdftLOATH fJE..Fotlf_ YVlEd'JtJTI.fiSdfty"              /Oft1   DF. D(CiwJhZrL
 2.0        l/5       ..

                                                (J.)
~ Ks Po,Jd &JI

fLF-s.PorJd£tJr1 La is. r2oGErtS                       l   i.J   14fJLI ~/s c~P~iTY ~~ fJ isT~icT c_ 1,:_{{t(
Ot= .SrvtLTti             ~OUltJTY 'Tt:.XAS HI'+S v1 llllllruiSII~1AI          dvrTY Tb    fL£C-Eiv£   r4tJd
 Fil~ All Pt1P1:J..s 1\J A c~tiM;JA-1 Pfl~c.F-.fdiJG-, ArJd P1:t<.F-oll-W1 ~tl 1-lrul dufffs
  iw1PcsEd otJ TltE c..IE.6tK by IAlAJ PtARSu~rJT 10 TtcP fiR~ z.2..1 ~rJd I~s
· fZ.ESf.lol\lsib/E iAI\Jdf_tt ~~T[c{F- 5 Sft.lio,J 10 itft1WlJ~diAt£1y TI(ArJSMif- IO
·n4i2 ~ CDPy c;F THf. moTioJJ AiJy Al\lswF~a..s Fii1Z:d, AtJd A C£t'L-I-iF,~cAT£
 R..EcitirJG- THE dAtE uPoJJ wJ-IicAI Tl-lvt--T. Lni.s. RaGfr25     . Dis~,·c+ ClEVLJc
 _" SfYliTtf            MLArJTY MtAy        bE .sE.~\fF_d AT tiER.. PitLJeE oF 8u.sirJt.s~ f\1
     J 00     f\1, Bt2.oeDuJAY      1   rt4TJ4 TliVtT THE f=t4CT'.S AtJd vtl'lEGff-TiotJS iJ TH£                 ~bDtll~
    ftA'JliclqrioN    l:ofL vJ~IT     DF Y\1tAI\JOAWllll& 14r2£ Tt2111E A-tJd CflfliLf.J:..T.

    ~m,J ED lArJOFJl.      OATI-l 8.1(1-ofLF...   rn£, D~ IH is TH1~           IO±b       d~yllF D(CfrvJ b&t         I

    20       IS        o

                                                                      ;JQTMLV Pv1b/ic ItJ ttrJd FofL Tlt£ STAit    oP
                                                                      TI:XAS,

                                                                      PtiJJTED    CJfL   TyPtd   rJfliYJE
                                                                      rf\y eomm i&sioN     £x.0/f(F-E:.. qf:J/1~
tffi1I FICATE.. tJF Sfrt\/iCE_
I    H-EJ£by     tfJLT; Fy Til AT A Tt1JA1:. CiJPV of THE. About AA'JiicATiatJ Fofl.    CJ~           wt.rr
mAl'.! Df.lrYIIA5 vJtts ~EilJJEd CJtJ THtA!JsdAy           by PIACinJG A eri{ .TAl rH E u.s.
ri\IA j L Add fll:_<;s Ed /o; CotJRr 0 FCI-Imwtll.. APP£A LS                 D,J TH rs THE

          /Otil            dPryoF     DLCilvJV~i                 >20     IS        ,

                                                                              fZfLA10fL

                                                          (/o.)
 D£wH:UtiAS KtJWWJ                                         ~ 1:1\J THE_'   II Y+ H
Ti'tJ-.LD 0 jqJ09?9                                        §
           {)._,-=_   Lv-rro Vl
                                                          §

Lois RoGEts             CotANry Di.:srp_;e,TC lmiZ
IrJ f4,:_f2. d~ficird_ C(JrfJAtiTV
           R.r:.s fJLJ 1\J 0 ErJT                         ~    SMITH

  0/\l THIS Drtyj Clqm£ 01\1               To L3E. l~Elll~D Tl+E r=ottE.GoirJ& f            . &JVtrJTy DisT~;c/Cl~
 IOo rd . L3Q6ADWr9~ 12rVl ?oJ
           TYII~t                  ,T£x~s IJ6'10l

~!:: ______~----------~
   tAIIlSf t\\0. ~--------

                   £JCI6sFLI PIJ;tttsE F(rJd vVlovAJJT0 moT;aJ foiL APPoi~Jimt,Ji
          DP CDlArJSE-1. o~D~ AAJcl f-1F;:LdAJi I -e~ r,Jd [G&JCy L~ TdE l4bov~
          31yl£d AAid JIAmbfr2kd C.villlSE; Pl£tt~L FilE. Tlt/5, ttrJcl bf2.;,J& IT
          10 IHE A1TEtJfiotJ DF TI-t!:_           eoua.J.
                       \)61At!L ~55{ sTArJCC      i,J THi5     rvl~-rTE~       is      G~EY-\T1y ·
                       rlPPR-1:.ei ATtd

                                                        rllov ArJI PR.a IL~i..L..l- - . L111\.lff
                                                                  . .300 I EvVJ j hi ])(L

                                               (J)
 \},
 DfrV\ETIZIJAS KE..I i111m
-rDc:J #.      Iqc30179

              QAtl)')f- o,J Tl~rs DAV FoiL CaNsiDI~~TmtJ, THE DEFl~rJdANT~ RfGLA~I
            Fout APPor,JTM~rJT GF CDIArJSEL 10 AssrsT HrvVJ LJ oln-A;,J.LJG- Dr-S14
            'Ti:.~T1:~& PlllutsVJtArJT To At1-TicLi lolf.Dlfl!) ccJDE CJI= t~eL-ttvrr~A-L
            PR6cEOtA~:___, ·rHt: covt,rr ~Ah R£viJ~_wf.d T11t r'2.1~£s1 A-AL.f _ _
            AFFIDAVIT oF .L~IGbJty rrJ T1tL.S rYIATit:,~ tAtJd .rl IS
            H£f2Ebv
                      oQDI:Qf..D THiAT r-ttJ fl1TofWt\/ _s l-1~ 11 BE..,   APPoiJTW TL)
            t2_EI-Y<.ESI~T Dt-j:tr_JJdA.JT P11112SU1t41\ll ro
                                                           vttR2TuLE tot/,oJl.CL P.         cc
            ACCO~LrJGIY, -, H1:. FollouJr::,JG Mfofl.rJEy LS HE({E.bV fifJPrJr.JJT1~
            ArJd rJ&I(U1C;rfLJ TD eo,Jiv1cT H.rs tlr wT REGL4r2dDJG- T/;-/r.s
            mATfEIL                                                                       A:idRE.&S
            --------------------------------------~

         IT .IS FIAI2.THEil.. oRDf/2£D ·rtf AI A       toPy oF Tl·b:s      EJt?d £.t S lfA IJ    ltJE
            5Ef\J-r   ro rl4£ o£ FErJd.AJr bv TH£       c-1 E.1PJZ. ~,: Tli u CLJU1UZT. ·

                                             (2.)
                                                EX ~:r BD! .1''~
                                                             1

                       'DI~GlA~V-lTIDJ o~ IN~Br:LJTY TO                   p,qy CosT
( Titt.. rot(ow;,.JG D&lt4~tATioJ   i..J WJMI~ PL!1~£AY-ltJT rD TIAE TExv-1-S Ru{Fc:s, 6,:
  c.iui L Paoc,:dLAttE: ;q,Jd TitlE fo GH£LlPTfVL 132.- oF THE. c_,rviL PtI r.rJ Tl+rs c__lui I f-lctiD,J tAtJcf
  l2E&lAE~Is. Lf.iWf_ at:- TH~ Prwc.E..fLJ IrJ Faf2n!lv:~ Pl~I!IPEfiLS LJ TtiLS ACCDmf14TJyirJ;-
  ciuiL AcTforJ 1\tJd iAJDu!ld SHot-J THE COLA.eT THE riJllowrtJG:
 [I) T       P!LF-SENtly ;JCJlt2L£t2J1tW IJTH£. w.G.mCCoNr·Jt.J/ LAtJiiDF' TI~E
           ANI
    TEJ\1-K iJ RJ),q {J[IY'l&JT o F Ctrr VV1I:AIA L Jvtrri CE w Ht-~£ .L ~ N1 td[J( fJE.JRmj T7'£c:l
    TD ELAtUJ c:; ()_ 1-l AJd./ £ MDrJE'{·

 [2 J j_ HAU £ f\/0 .SOIJ1ib~ CJ F LJt..otvJ f ofl._         s PoU£14 L ItJCCJME

  ~l\ D/,1\/(;rJ&      my .L~Cv1u'KE/Z.ATiotJ
                                          i,J 1H£ I~Xu1~ DE.OAI