Court Opinion

ID: 4061802
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 20:17:42.77037+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:51.401498
License: Public Domain

$££os/j> C#o,*7 07 ^7/Jr7>7s
                             o7
   rEceN£0
             T0UVS                              wfigSEff/^
                                                    °ISTRic\
                                                             ,,
                                                            «.j

                     U/97/ / fJ7J 7?              "f^
                                                    °ossoJ                  77Zz^J7Z// 777£S7
& /??*/*/ ,                        CJC s7t,^777 7 S^
toMW U/7                            ?/ )7fs7' 4ejU~/40
                                   7h/7 Wtu77 77- 7777A
//a/77/ fl 7*0/

                         /
               776/7 07 £^77,77J

107/S7J77 07 7#7 f7/777s            /
                                   X *

X//77X of 7c7//07J777J             u/CW
S7A/7M777 07 7%7 £7S7              70

 0.fZ7jr7JC777 07 S7X7JC7           //
 £MM/7S /)j 6                      /I /j
 C£/f/Y7c*r7 07 r/c7rf             if

                     //
            3/Z7/7 Of /?C77fQJ-7 TZT'S
CA^Ad/j*/ 7e//£0S/-fszr J/e/ i/.            7
v//W/S3, 7J SO 24 3**<, s^s SZ&./Z/7J
 ~5o/JJSa*/ i/. 7ouS77 CacsX a7 7/9^?/-/    7
 7oo S u*al 7/7s 7/7 S777. /7fs7

 M    C7/f7./y77J
 0 'Ct>J7o/ I/. 7//S7 £acs7 #7 777/^77     C
 ??>7 sozj ?7>77 czsy./rrzJ
Jj/c Mjcez., £2 sou jm-yns                 £_
C77X.777 -7M7////0 -200/, os/j, 7/pf.)
 1Aa*az i/. 77-77^/Soyy p-7f S*/ zdyf;     £_
Z/f C77X./m)
J J Me Sm//// / ^/J x U 3 J ?3,7S
 t/fX. 777-//ocsftJ 7/s7^/s^J^c?4
 od/3 7/0 ceedsxJ3).
S/o7ff 0>. StarJet JTSJ. ?/7SUiJ2tZ -£—
 2M C77X./?f7J

7/.C7J o* f/^7                             -£—
 -5/i^/i/ 7. 7A//SSSa~/srJf SozJS/f,           r>
  3// 7-Z   C7CX./?73y                     —?—
 77//A77 C7/. 7*£. /     3.0/ £77>          7"
  £•//£ t /J/ . 00/ ^v                     J_

                    (V/9
Cf. 7//0a~/9S i/. 777 ft? SD2cJZJ771t        ?
C 77X. /??/J
\//A/7f/, /3S Sl)3 J 77 774/                9
7 J f£ I////A//777, ?/ ScJJj 7otj 770 ~
 7// £ 3c/>. £oJ76£X
C77oJ Z£7/??'J t£7s;y/ff                  / »f

                     (3SJ
            S777J'yVi7/77' 07 Z7J &9S7F

fiel/lht 7//ed A M0//0J foz #y/9 /es//y3 ay
AeCCMte/ 27, 2o/l /y 703/Jr/?s 7a tese */*„&**
"J'i'ff   **JM/*3/k/c
/X,2o/<77y/>77s       ^ *******
                l^JC 7/,^^//    *s a*>*
                             fcAc/t
fotf&j y//7 ?//£ s/a/c /?yy /?y 0//?^ ^s?j
 3/0/7 /a 7c// ///£ /Mcy/oy see 7XA/A/A /9 ''
AY/70//, oy MA/07 7,20/s, Ae/j/o* 7//td #Ss/Atk>\
fo* y/y of majjamaj see7/yj /#/} Cocs*y 70
0/00Z ///£ ///A/. 7ols7 70 7c/£ oy 77s Mo/7*y
M frt£ Xecosjs. S00 /e/io>£ y 7/te ys/7 s9s**S S0&, 7//9/zm
leA0£ Ao 7//0 MAJdAMCS 01^A0/7/7&y/O. PWe.
S/7/C 7XM//fy 7-// 77/70// 7o 770/y 7es/b^*
7XM/X 7" S/ttJs 77A/ 770/z /?sa E7 ya/±~ej
07/70 0»WyA/ /)o//:/>/ S700>/ /}y# 7f u^j £m,\&^
07 M/lf0///K20/X 77AA /s yy^^y 7#9/7/^ /&Z2cl
/AAf ///fr£/S Jo 0/70/ 4/ 77c: -3c
CAM fttfAUC Me UAtAVA M/0£ 70/A//^ey7
                      W)
/o A7st)0/ #7 07o 0/00/0y 770^ 70 /0ys7saX
7/1 c^/00700 /y y/s CAS0., 6Ase y^/0*. /07777sA
As ye//As //yy£ /7/e dcs/o*,/?^/ 07 /00O/&S
 fa/ UA/A^JA 7o//0£ 7C7A^/^077 U70/:7 Je&X
/J/> ^7/001
0?eAA//M0J/ 7yy Met; S0//T     ycs/™//!'/?
ei//00j0£ /J 7AJ 77,77' W/770c7 //*7/7/>^j>
fte/7h/ 77y ybT //yye/s/y 7 J js^y^u 7/
 ms. y//soJ 07 ^c.yj£ 77/90//. /0//9/o<*. s7?h^
//As A00J 01/0*. C30) 77/S. Sfc? "J777S/7 X? "
7/770// 3/0*0*7 C/)/7>. tyyyy: Jm/z/t't:
CoJ/>c,0T dA^^S To/ 3cyjxtr /ys 7^0/0
7c/T To 7a£ 0/* 7) M0//W 7/^y 74l et/Zsy^z
S//ocJs /7/7 3±7j£ //7ts0* 77j 7>sS/y0?0:y7c/~7.
 oty/ts yd/ M/0A 7 /t/;y?.

                     (s/
      JSStl fiC/S/fJ/fJ       WJ/X/ 7/7*jc^eyy

7s J7 yy A06,se< o7 y/s/irc/yo^/ 7cy yyj£ t*yA0s 3cy>Sc/AZ 0oyyt,c7 7yyys
  3ouJ7 Coye 7yyy/77yy. Cyyoy s c/x/yy
 y/ 7) 7UC 0/7 AW 77my/7 Mo7/s0£ 0/ 00s/S/yy& /i*/?7£.
 S00. 3/00y 0A/y 7XA/0// 7'' 7A/A07 te/V/7/h^
y^00/ 7o/7 2/2 o 000/ ?//7 yrjzy 7/y
Seyf/Ae Ma/Soys To 3^Je? yZ/Sz^yy/// 70y?yy
A77 /O 7/0jC da^7 C^a/t/y^T&xi 7o Je 7/Az^yo
07 XX/0 Aa0/0/ 7ay A 7cAA/yj, ^77 L)y?j /rsfjyb
3//A//Ay/ Co/.y/y 7/ts?7S /€0os~,   ay Ayy70/S,2Ly
of /0do/0J o7 7/a7es77 y/cy/ S/?A>7 To T&r/s&y
A//00 C(//y0y0e /^ S/y?y00S .
0yyAo/yy ye//0y0S , 7e>o
 s. u. id ?// y y/y yyyy. /S/s) 7 oy/j. Sy^^y,^
J^y oyjfx. To 0y T0 707/yy^ yy/<~
Xe/A/ay. mls/ SAa^ TXc 7p//oy/^3 - 0 77
A A0JA7 Jc/7 To /eyyoy^ J 72/ /? ye^y>yy
7a/. A0rAo/MAy0d J AyJ 03) A/ /0>7*.sy?0 To
70/. S0y. s/o-A0A (A. A*yssy/ j ssA scJ^y
 M.S77      0y07.77Z/y                "

      Xt/A/o/S 707///dy SAa^yy 70 J/yy/yy
 £0>CA*S0: /e/A/oy. //AS SAocjy y?yy y0^a^S/y^y
777/A//s A*jyy To
X/e A/AsJAaJ 07 7/7 yy7y/ 0*^7.
 70X7X0/ 7/770// 'fJX///7/7 7 '' dyy77y>y^ J>y/z~\
CA/7 77AX 77/07177 0acy/y S/y^A^y a^77
Xoom /CC0/i/yyp /7 0^ 777/0/3, 2o7s // Oys
 $07/70 3cyjy7070/X 7/yy X/yy docy^y
doa/X/A/ty. S/7 Mo S7oys 77s Ay^y ac//rjg_
Go)AA/sA77X//£ J,yjz //AS yo/ a«aJ%^
                        (7/
A//0^AX Xz> /*/£. ay e//yy* A*a/7*J S£ .
trst/J/0* jj T77. Joey7 £*<*£ a^ ^T-70-
    J//s J/// sc//X0d /yy/y /y/yy docyy 7s
yc//0?oy0j x^ caJs/y^ a MaA/ojyy^^
;/AS/Xo/600y 7/0S0J70A U/XA/ SA/d Aia/soy*
 O'CoJJa/ yA/ys/ docy/ o7 777yyys/ fir soiy
 ?777 C777J//2J                                   ~~
 t " AaaJJAmas w/// Xssl0 v/yeJ///yyg 7s y?
 10JA0 dc/T /o 70y7a-yy« 7 /7oJ- yXs £yc 7r&-A*J(
Ad/ A J £a*aJX 7o* 70/7oy^y}y00. y9yy y9
Xe/LSAA 7') J SC0t A/So 7,7 70 07a yyz , Xsl
 SO2J 22S, 22f. CX/X. AAA. A^A/y/o Zo*/2.
  00dL~£y/s Ay0 do~/s/dcs/?d 77/0y \^y^y TT/yy
X0A0A /Ae 00/./7. 3/9a«/9a 0. yy/Tyysoy s fAs- s,cj .
2d S/S, 3/S a 70X. /A/s/ j jfv re SA^y// , ^ j SiCj~
Sd XS?S 070X .A/7-yocS/a~/ y/s/ y,jT. J yciyTT
Qy/v A/J{
yys; ?//so.zd 24z 2/y 0yyA.y/7Aj s j—-yr.
 y .     —-,                    . C- AIS?S7^/1
d adc~ c.y/ Ao 7y»y^ docyT yjyy^ss 0o~s7y*^
O(/0y //AAo/yj dos-yfsry 0ol^7 y/syyss0^yyy>77ty/).
 Xy77yj "
Udd/. 7Xc    7/07s ypy 77l 7/Ays J - g^>^^
(/ X>A/X0ASoy '_£££. so:Ld 3/^J 3/J> ^'^ Sa/z7JSSJ\A
X>o/X/oA XA/A/o/S M0//0J //AT 7^7 d0y//y/cAT0i
 OX CoJAe/0y00     \JA0j //c S0J/ 77c Aa oA/o^a
 Ce///7/y^ Aaa/X. Syy. /A/AA/jy d7/. Toy- K.
 l>*t 06)              r~nT\
\////0J X Ao0i~s>JT Xs mA/AcJ \JXXA 7yy 0oyyd>£T
Add/ASS 0J<0 AsoAfy Aas/yJ^ ; /Were 7s A>y£ Sc~SAl~
/X/A///VAS /00£/i/0A>- A7. 7//o~y>S c/./yy

 %/teJ 0A/J . 7o Ayau/e 7/T/JJ />X desT/yJyy /us?//,
X0//L/y70 C0/7T AAftes/yJ, A? 7A/T/A*y7 //Tyac/t^t?
///0 if3/00J 0AyA" A0/t.*/ Tfe 7A^ 0oJ^d s U/XA?
AJy J/yy^A /ojTa/ 0000,7*7 4s7s_ a„~^s If££_ j 3&y
 S0£ . WA/J0J. yjs Su.3d. A/Sty 0' AyoS0 /J^/yS
doCUr-0/A A/A00y 7J AAnA^yyy AJJsyjjs? d sf-sy
S/Ar-A0d £//0Aa70 /s J 00~0d Av/yJ )JA/?y A^SoJ
Ac/Aoy/A/AS A000/y0 do0L^£yy 7o 70 A~A/7y* <00 Ate 3

T//0 Ac/A0J Xs oJ /0/ATay. To sXa u 77A/ T/7f, 7/0-777 0: 70-7. A97^~
7^>a////0 2003J
 X0/A/0A C//ys AJA,17 Zyx. doyy . 3la?. Cgyy^y
 CJJoJl fyr/y/ AdAy/y/yy J J         777. Joo"7
 Co07 AJJ 7/72                            •
       ^//S /ToA Ar/' oXs0yy//o^ *ToT To Ac/c. ~7
XI McX/oJ /XS ///£ 3cyj£ A/&//0S T0 At/01 /71
/M At// XU0 //d/7d 7/0XA707^J
770/0 0l>J At/A - 0.707. 0oyc jc,y. dc^Jd^y
0ajoJ3 //////yy7//J7yy> J j tax. Joc/yy 0*y>0?
AJsX T/7 y-
 Xa/A/oa 7as AA0 Xe 7 yJ/y//yJ To A/T/hy-
               i.AXAXAA7AA7 7 7 7
WA/S A*aJaAa«£S is s70/ A«ooT Ac /Af^sT/AsS          ,
 tow/ Xo JoT 3X2 A/~ As 770 SA^J>
 0/ 0/077 7J ///SoJyy dyJ 0y77 Lf&> /&-
 7os7A7 SA/y/00t XT C0yT/7/yJ a«a//.
             daj0its70j A?yy 7/A/yfy
 UJA0/. 70X.do/?0 3/.A 0aJd/*z7 0Aty<>-/ 3 0/7/22
 Xe7//XX0y J-J TAX. 3oy'7 0&y0 A?y^A TyT J-. A/yy^yA
 SAtfdS 7/s T7l 3lAJ0 3^a/0/a7 7*7/ To y^yy *^
 AX/ A/ioX/oJs T/a/ JuT dAJ7 At/0 o>^A yyy,

   7A//0A Ad 707 j?aTa?T0/ //7/s 7?a 70//yy
  //yy^ 3ls/ 77// a/a/s 7/a/ Xe 3/ye a/ yMA^y^.
  70 60 X/7AAA2.                       S/yc&et/

                                       s y / -yo/s

                     ^0)
 VlMX£/v/7'', /x7a*JS7s CoJS^yPTAy^y.
 Rd/A/oy 7/A/S T7A Cocy7 W/A/ 3/7^7
Ta/A/oas 70Ai/0 T& a9/£   wa/7 07 AAyyy&^t-s
                             7es/y0/7^/7/
                              suA^/TTyy j

                               70/A/aA /Jo:S01
                                 s yy- zo/s

          dj/TJAJcA/y o7 j/y-yjey
AXala* 0oA7 07 77y AAo/y/Z LeAiye 70 7/702
V/A/ZOA AAJAA^S OAs y^y/Xyy 7> T&. y/yyJ:
07 7A 2-** doty/ 07 A/A/ty/s *7 7^7 £3**7*
77/AS. 7/m cisy/ c//M,y*A Scs//0e ceJAyy:
 To/ )J, At/Aryyy sy/0 ?ooo 7r. Oay// /7- ^AyyA

    C7/777XCA77' #7 y/c7//_
X. X^CdJA/C /JAAA /0r2AAT/ 07 /0yjod7<»-
CO
                / '//   y

           fi/ybt £/7

{[) J/ddJ CA77? / C0yiA/7/yy> S<~4e*
   7*0X7 ZX2o   000/ 7/7/      ?*/>>

                07)
                                                             CAA/2
                                7)/a/0 xs/ Zo/s

 SENDER: COMPLETETHISSECTION                                 COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY
    £fm?«?,items     1' z'Delivery
    rtem 4 ifRestricted    and 3- isM5° complete
                                     desired
                                                             A. Signature

    Pnnt your name and address onthereverse                  X / _^^                                      ° Agent
    so that we can return thecard toyou                         rV       ,jft>                            D Addressee
    nrttnChthhitfaHtothe
    or on the front if space back of the tailpiece,
                             permits.
                                                               ^byfPri^teWa,
                                                             B. Recei
                                                                                                     C. Date of Delivery

 1, ArticleAddressed to:                                     D. Is deliver ^ressdiffererAn item 1? D Yes
                                                                If YES, enter delivery agj&ss below:      D No
   U,zx9£t/J f*/}cAf
    0* Q0U47 Cgd/Ls^A?//^
   07 CI/a^^X?7. AXCfxtfy^
   C^aT a/u~4£c j sMfc**                                    3. Service Type           "                " ~~~-^~-
                                                               SB-Certified Mail    D Express Mali
                                                               • Registered        D Return Receipt for Merchandise
                                                               D Insured Mail      n C.O.D.
                                                            4. Restricted Delivery? (Extra Fee)
2. Article Number               -7 ..        !!       •—'           —              ——SZ                  "D Yes
                                                                                                            Tes

                                                                                                       10259&O2-M-1540
                         dou/7 of 7777AXS
      received           ^ J* A7s//yey 07 yj7AS
       MAY 262015        ^   £c/yy £f/„;^JS ^LS/C/A^
    ., COURT OFAPPEALS
   "ggSaSKSS-            4/°/ ^ 70/7yA/>, Su//y Tooo
                         / / Uoy/TX fX. 77/yy
                           C S-Xf-^o/fJ

M/.7X/0ad/s0hASoJ                      1^
#X/?oroT                               ^
AoJJA/77 U/T
f?f 7m 73Z
KtJ0f7 7X 7/777
tfAAl dXerXs-j
 7/AAsa {//£ A*X Taa/a: To 77/0° V/a/T #y
 MAr/AA/^U A.           /y/A/jy /oc- /y JyX/3
 MA/7CZ •V/r*X/ xMte* /fXX/XA/7ds.              ^^y
               Coc/cx Ta/Tcc                    <^£_
                                                s-yy-yy