Court Opinion

ID: 4050506
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:16:29.802776+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:27:21.355496
License: Public Domain

I(

.......   '

                                                                                                                       RECEIVI:D IN
                                                                                                                COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

                                                                                                                        P.UG 17 2015

                                                                                                                    Abe! Acosta, Cler~(
                                                                                                                                                   ,:   •11 •   ...~ ..

              C   ,£.\. f?~:f.I;A,:, ~-· !Z·£i.Ft.d3/S '::.ftf57t{;£" · ,(_ C:.'lv 7t;: ·{i!.
              ~·o_ · ··[)6/o .ro St.;'~.·;, : 15~;..fe_· :rz~·:o            ..                                                                ..
                                                                                                                                             . ~,,~····

              $Ail       '/k1, .f~        ,.7y;... . -7$/i..:tJ -; ..;. )0 3 7                                                              %,~~1ib'ff:~
               .                  ".· I        '       . ' . I     ;   ·"

                                                                                 f<ot:;pr-( ;t/fAn. /~'Nf' i.....
                                                                                  ~D'- .;:t· ·· ; 0 . t~./a ~      /7 }I.Y''/7
                                                                       ··:,      ·.-=-~~p;.~1_··   · S-l?i fe ·'. $,' /

                                             ..       .

                        Glee 1,;\))5;~
                                                                              1·                              J.             ·    .   l "'      i
                                                                                                                                               r·       ·       L
  · :! ·"""'' pr~ (':\:' t , N"/ SeU e<~ \ c ~« :l.eM1~s ill my .·UIJ C.OtJVt ql{f)15                                                     AtJ ~ •.
t.\t'Jj vV1l\ 5eel'- l(eQ(fS> ·h/ VH\ltt~'\1\S ot fY'·y ~CV\~1-i~-h.ervllt.( 'rfC.t~·

.:E.-. lt\A:ve              -eY\_ c.c·uv\Y\-kv-- .· · re   p<'c~~J ?-4?n-~u1 acces5 ~b                                                    Cou r+      'v,oi4~·0AJ,;.
Of\J~. dJe.                  rrotf"SS       v·r~\a-htrt~s
             :t.. "'~J<a. {e.1 Jt?s~J                  1N      b6() d Fu; H" -h~ S-tJ-eet-hi... JocurY'e.-~b
 (\e<,.e •;hllf~)fV c ~ve. bey<n1 J·>.~· pr"e p{fylr)e.;r6.NCE' . o { eut\dfftl<..Q trJ
                             1-v

 ..;, 1 a+kV\, ~ ~ -(; Ie ad·~· iJy,& I )Nf. f of & ~,._, ~,pus
                                                               " .. 1i.                               .                 ..            .

             J_    h~                IJOi    (it2E" 1  .ved -(he                   !Je.<.essc•r:j dllc.urvle~-& or ~
 <me              s\l111e:        (f~-rsr'~~e. .+;.(,~ "-th~.                               D'*'<..+              (1-flrK's csf{;·<4. :/A)
 t~           \ uc,t        d, +c, h e-f..fo r f .:t. t"Y\(i ~                                        f\)6 ..fi ~ -\-n A fi . fbte q b6.~e :
 c r ·h0"' J
      Cl.·             (!          Co u rf· c t~ ( ks              .
                   :L . .. ~e~<. ptt0'(s ..J.                             ~ 1-eJ.            ,_JJ               -1 ~e            a.b6lle. c&pt~W~~J
      C6S<0)                       5po'~;-h~c...ll'1,        :!.          YVIO•        l~d ~r :~/,·Jv,J c.pprox 1 ~~~y~·
   C20 ) h0eM -h-1                      pi us ~)<1\f' ~o .J~ N uIf- De k~1 Ge,; +.-- '(!)c~l'                                                                             .

      6k p \ 1 Gr:·, e vNV ce_5 AAJd                                   -\h t?      ·   5ubse~ ve. ~d~                             .A to ~lJ:{ s. ·. · lh.;s~ ~:,
      0{ 1e u ArJCQ 5 o dd ressPJ                            1\Ml             I'Y\~ doe                         (\)o h<.Q          o-f       fit e }fE'(l?<•.J..{'        ~
                            +o · Ceo v-f        V1 oIo. ~ S                                                                                                     t:, ( (   1
       NU?<>'>                                                            .        :JNd ud, YlJ -1 bl e '                                 \j( ADL       !'Y'l

       hAtud(\ rv&..·J -+he                 G. (   bi -lr-6 l~_1       "rv.J :c        Ct
                                                                                            r • "._
                                                                                            !0
                                                                                             · ,· ,       ~   ( ' \ )   c.
                                                                                                                             cr.~ P"' c tru/ ~ .cl...,/( ·
                                                                                                                                           7
       ~\·N1 ,_( cloWMeM+?, -\~~                                              tru.!\11\111f.S>                               \A;1J    librA•) IJJ;,f ·
   '(()t.      M       0.. C ( 671           lo s.f ~1\JJ mtSSIA!]                                    .pt. f:CrSJ tpv•.St111\                        of(;c,,J)
    l·wxJ lw( o-1 I e1 uI pqw r.s 1 t'Y\ uJ ( . ~ ~ urvr<~ . 1 II~~ cc.Fv,, M d"' r
 f'\'ll.S

 ANd\ 'Qt1•So ( ( t~ y (Jf)'
                         ,      ·'
                             ·e vC.-'\1\ I1b .c__-f- I' ·m""'
                                                        'LJ? ,..
                                                                 ~X-.l'\ .f w i Ht -coo tJSP.(
                                                                         ::;,>                 1 VU
                                                                                                   lA    ...- llf"Vl-fo (.
                                                                                                         ....

. uf\l~ 6\~~( vt()l_(t ~).
 . -fl'le ~1 p<>r.s                       ::+-       ~ i.,J . weve vJ 0rf baih                                                   tAl    Coy: M
  ~a ~~- cp..- "'~'18 , 18b~ f8.-·l<-<• r C1u ~ , .1 be li PLI2., vvlfti' tJ
  Y'f-.Y Y'A~~,-.l -~( NQ....J lr<o.(. AJJ,-hv-~>117 f?"pi>C.S ~l.,cl
  \tJ ( t\~e                (\.)o .· 3o712..'")
                                                            1
                                                                  Uu        1J+7     Cou r ~- /\J?}           5   1
                                                                                                                         ~)(4 r          G,o rJ~ .
              :r        />(1(\1\        \ rJ       tJ.e eJ         o-F           rhe s~            '.(]7(.{ ( d0 (,. () merv\-fr                .-ri r
 ~1 I "'-'/    r..y ~ kPu s          G," p;s pu 1.SUA,A -k 1\r> (;c le II                                                         cf    --(w, ~~
 GJe _q(             'cr,n~\1\.k\. ~ P(o(.Qdur<?. 11-l1\ ret-fUt'')~- ·,..,                                                        -\lvvla.     ~/1\~1.-hu<?
 v.ii H\      ~·tt-k          A.,Nd            teJ   9   r'u_ \     -\-o ll1 ";~              ~~tuc:-s,
                    rhy ~~~~1            {! ...-   Is        6 tJ    (( -\.:'i H               -h \( ..,c)      5<lc I (c    I    S<>c u r   rfy bevle f+
    \IJCuvn~. She                        1.')      ">1 yeus oiJ.                              :L        h A.-<Je b.>e!'l «cJ~c,,.J S~E?
    hA;         PJ rdw;eJ .{;, v- ~ 50                                      vJrf-h rr-y 4 f p-e<J (Ju po (.5
                                                                            A.       C. 0
  '{          ·t\.w. J_. C(L~-f' No                           2Dt)- <rf2.-&.b7~.

               J." .~.vt           c\          C:+~ -2..~ rJ oi ~( kt :J4.!e. of. ·-;iJ:As ,. . =\. hAV2-
  ~;!eJ ve'vJ,e~ -IN~~' It~ -h                                                        fA'f              -h~           LDsi-            u·ff; dtu:+r.
  :1       ~ kJe YY\·4, \.eJ (e1 Jo~ tt+.l.ev·                                                           (e'f     Vc>s~           :r hA.Ve ·
. IV\ill \:e J ')e\-" . Gt dd (<'') yj . s-Ir.. pe j                                 1/1.'1                  e 7'J i)e ( () '(J@5 A,t\kJ            ~.
  b tJ R        {   (? 'S   prl' &e +::~~---                      -:ll~            Di s fi~(t c·l 'f' r ks                        o--((.)· (0            "J,_
  ~~ ~ ... {vN4./e -{haJ -\ltQ C'eo.u~ C/..,rl . hAs pn~1ckJ
     S llYn Q_        ptl ~ rs                     bu4 N~ ~. ( ( .                                        ''""',,

                                                      '~ 3 oft                                                     .
  :1. h, heue 4~\Jl ~">hb+lli),                            vJOS        fr().llfu~;; ~ Stve e<tud c.Ccess .t,
+k. u,u~-h                  ~UI?JVI' \NJ·, ~~t1t' 1Nd 1 v·, du4ls                       a.5 ~y sel-f',                    ~
re\V"P \ .-\o ~ riHd e. 4-~t)Q A~<:( ess 1 G .-l P" f'VJS UM hNJe                        (,j

 -6 ·~ fi'P£'"~ rt--y ~~AI f,' li1~Y,
      ::1. nA~te f\Jo-hc.e {o ·-(l'\Q .f;v'~'~ &v vt· oJ Aep.ec\(s ArJ~
-Itt t tbor atole, au rt of App«/s 6+ ·c~ ><As, cIe r/(; .
      ~. _.·. -.l
 A.·. !!Jt:           1\_c."'~{"l\         l-~s,. 1N ,-; Y-As.                  "7' ~ 1        _J\                         .I ·h
                                                                                        ,\Jeed · \ n~e_                A-.f'tl a-,h~y
                                                                                             \
                      f'\1 u "         1                                        --·

 ')rc' I \, L                   Ooc. u W\eJV\.(s \,.<.<k;G (, :J h"'-'e                 vel     !)? ')   .j.,.J I    A-;,~ j -hr
 {k p.>Y'5d'(• ::e. pr •Lil. I i'V\l., I.e J .q tJJe lo {JeS 1\NJ hl'QN M>( ~ .
  (i,I.J\e +o rllc:i tJe. 6r 6(kVI· U(-! C<.rvvl ~UP L C....~ I ~rl'h ~
 ~6'fflb~ 'fA':>h·,c.f (!., d 1 Dm114 l&.y rvt"-i(mn"y 1 ~~or
 C,ww~.               ·. .    .                            .
                1-· 06          ~r      L>), ·; k    "' y t~ ~ s             h cex {;we.                  ·f~       jJr6-+roc-i
 ·A<,e l ~ "'~                        W1 ':> h   ~    c. do ( t?'>S   -{.l>\Q    'Y ~rv nd<,         .:1 ke(i- r 1..1<? J:
   (Xrv\            QAv~ +- \ e ~ Ao .
               .:JJ.      -~~ ~rve.l ( A
 . AMJ              11-..(i . \~ l?.' II.;,,
   A'\r-.o u            u '(.   {s.
                                                           ':(        {2Jli\J\ A I ;v          ~l
                                                                                 -r · ·
                                                                                 __,..J N .
                                                                                                    oc
                                                                                                    ·.
                                                                                                                     ·...        •-:;:
             '"· t '..                           ... ·,:. ·.
                                              ~" ~             •i5'"'   .. '

                                                                                                                                         ·•

        ·i        1            12619-Q.r~ /L\u ,.fiNn                               t    Dc 3 tb      t-Jo   I~ 3"13'1]
                                                                                1
. be~,· N 'J . f>U.)Vv\ -\- (y                                          -l JJ u r CW1 tt{eJ         ;N ·{1,\2 ' fo.,xAS
  ,1). ~ , of ._ Cu.Jm; N<LI                                                   1u., t u    J ·   Lo i1P2- ~ *" J:; ~
        ~~ dcc \1 0 f~r<JY\-tr 1[ ; 'lA_ )                  da c. /ctr -e L) ,uc]e r
       . p-e,\Ac,l).                o.f       ~q(jurt-) ~h..J -the ,a6DVe A~J

 ' .tor ~CIA!")          -f'              IN ';)+r-u rn~/V-1                        I~    -h-ue . A 1\.d urw cf .· ...
  •     ~1) -41~· ~"~                                   cr4               n--
                                                                                1 4ta. I,~ · .··

  ,.
  \.

                                                                                                               ...          ..