Court Opinion

ID: 4056457
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:58:14.797628+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:11.831374
License: Public Domain

I f))d:JO'/a// Wq/jo f€’/"j` 7%€ O//`j/'/Vf// 0 7////¢//-/7" C`a,;//~/)/'lb ;qu£/@LFO/:f?

7/)€ L//v/f ¢>\/af /05/{€/ ¢/aw//~/ /7_ W€/\/f da?" aff?/ fh€ c>/\/¢‘/afz#/¢/c/f/ .
b){ fhp 691//7',¢\/£// /`ff%FQ/, /(/07_ /(/vaW/f\j f?/) 7/'/7(" C/F//( 7:/¢7/~/[//'7/(` /}LF/
)47)/ 7//9g~ff7é`0/v @Uip /(`7(@7§’{ a/rifM/rij/ /5’746(7: ff/\/CF 7%;’/? 4//€

,§7(// C¢//a???/@/ /ffupf /§/€¢/,f€ M¢z/ §w/F 7`%() Cw?“ C,-///” /§)//

%j€ff T/)/f /"’ff/o//#€/zf 6§@%€:7~]/://
7\7@2~€3”/5 ' ///
%` ~/ l/\/o¢/jo

 

 

6 53 “ @/0’33~§ 333 032333¢33¥§ '

fix i?¢,/»Y"@, ` §§ J~/J //')@ {://`3/”’7/<7“~‘1"/ @/5/
_ " ~ 333 ;(;.»:/'3,333'7' /U@,, 3 07[ ' '
"de/VFAG 635ij 533/avc § 73':?7"7/5""“7£9 ) /FX¢'-"f

 

deJ/M¢m/Y MQP,/>m»;(y 7a 575/723 <
F?@fj 737 }/abpw (`€33,93.3.3 L¢/,»,j~/%/@

70 f%() /¢jg"'"V‘:‘;`“l‘/"~‘?,l/’//¢"l jwo/Sf’ GJ[ fa(y/ C`¢. w/ 7’
HECEWEMN

!` '::€`W;” A/@;pv’ V?wwo/ / 6€@3’:5@1 A/w(/;u;::;i;;);gf:~ 15@.<..3)
§f€rfv €’ /~...3 /" w ,
q inn §7}7,/0 § Q' d FFQ?”’K Aeost@€r@rk `
‘ _/££'f"(:f"(.f'7¢3’¢1`/~’€9‘/t f /L/3~
.§M!.?[€>/* C§'?//&V/LF/&// CC>/*vjé?’ M¢""/~./(t¢f~’" j`/. "&`f//"/f 376/47 6/#1/ l `. v
33333.3’6/33337“@'3'“)/ 333/3333’€/3>_: 7@/3739/`333¢/ // 333/wi 6%%¢/{33¢;3 ‘ ' `
.,.U:
3§€¢1 ff‘=”//”<"/ had /"é’c>€/VF:/ 6? /?7&'3\30/¢:/7'?//¢ ...S" é’/`z//; /0/~)
V€/€HJ€ a/J/?L€ /é¢¢~/c?c/<°K` ?L’A€ @//j/';év 717/y if ¢7 356/p7:5,/¢v/;(/"
/€3//’)€/£"/;>3"6" fed/foam 3}7 70 664/73 660/69 JUE' /‘7'/7 (,é) f'jm?
Jjgp’(;/@ ¢,?'/v€/ €;¢:w/ H’MA/F g Q/p 7:@3';07,/\7@/7£/ 03~.) 7'}\,;,7" 0/‘@/,,} Pf
l 396"37 736/336/` 7’>’3<7.33/6&3/¢/33'”/3/ r’~€/<’~*w`cé’ 3,3//?6/~/ /"7“)/7?3_¢//¥’6’ 713/dd
5(° Mr“¢?'/?¢F 7[//\/0/3/\6 ;~l//) /,L@ /3\/3’3’).3;3%37 63'¢33.:'/3/6%7<;3;0/ f€/vcé/c?""
iii/330 3< /\/337` 3:/3<3 6€3¢,/ ?'&7"3 m;f/@/?‘/aw ¢-.._7' 37"}/,@ 3,3»/3»3,7*& faj;>,\/Tk//
few 3"6’/"3¢:3/'31/‘/7;"5/7}0/»/ //,£H“}@]a,¢a/ (;’~)l§ 377 363 3/‘»373'}¢;/7?"'! 3:¢"/63/(3$3. `
wpa/j €/v¢>/G’/Y€V“ YA€WM/¢/?//C/ /"9[$’¢7 %}:_3' §@/ff€//H;/v§/¢/QN /<`

31ij 5¢3!)}; /~"`€7L 7'/ 40/3'7’?3/3")7;3§//¢3/6 6/3*'\/333¢/3£`,3¢///633//‘°/1/(!0')

 

// 3

 

Z»€//’) @?f;»“:»(cw@) 5:5';\4¢¢_ F*i»@ HS¢M¢!{»»_V W,!@,/ "MMN» mcf/fy 73/’,€,(
wave M#M»/ 333-w -A¢W/,% § M Q§.W»@@,W
256/f /W/ f/f-¢"/<’.’"/"’f€~”€" few 333 z"`é*€w“c:/ Fx€¢¢ f 17"!7€ g¢;j‘/¢,\/

'5,,~%/ mar/36 §c"/’#:j A@#’€fzv' jw -M“)‘ psc fff/’"¢>Mr" 57";// §M)§§;:f
v€f€»'/"‘ ”i’h 6 <:`/a'mc/j€ ca //¢:/ Y'r'"”/'c//)j/ ;¢;»W;<¢ ;%,? m'/}{W~f » /9/1/6!:

~z*!/P;>W,% fha c@,j., ¢/.:r/?i Ww §§ -s~» )/M/§~ Qj.y) ,:Y,M¢/) m-
`FMAWZ'<°W` 0/2¢//?! .5/7£ fw’d"w»»r€ "60°7(£) .Sf’/;¢Q¢/A,£ V~W¢/’€ j%!/f~/ /67)/€/,3’_":/3)¢3'{ (:?/WW"-WJ 5-’3""“"=‘¢ 3%!°‘?
4 duff my /‘“M‘ m/'~/¢/¢’<"?’£"?"?f~'»~,¢f` 3¢"'/"7£ ?"M V€/””!P /'f”'"”’"”* .‘:“‘““""'
?F?/»'@ Mf'/~/?* §m ¢jw/° 5)¢'»€»3'/¢/ 33 €j`// MJ“Y'QJMHM£/F. /9/‘5/ fva

@-?:M/@»; y §;~MI»Q 3//3 SKW-»f,:»§"»/ 6/3;`/`@/ 5?'@><>/%€ "'M~%@

l f, -.° ~ l ` ._ - ) ,
Q*MWF 5 §e’.w€-r'¢/// , [f];z‘ ;j§gvf“€“z cisz w¢`;;i?"}"§;j,,>,f Q,)"@ ,‘}M,;/M,,;;a,_é/€
b F¢ ¢1'¢/5 co w 51 f/@J¢m¢p 2513/v ¢W_[ cfs/§ '?','~" c"¢/ gL/e> . ¢z»?£ /f@,`/w£/’/",f/z,)?"/"”c¢w

`<:?»Q_of flu/f /7,’; c’/’l.c#/'¢:/¢fff§j*¢¢`"£i'é§F/:_}”F£vfm¢/ 04/€='¢* ¢;;¢ few/2d Q/` /¢a¢,¢/
dé/,*¢A’;~'j C¢:;wo¢'d;¢» f,%}/S¢)[Y?LVV’/$ 'V, §7";;,7"€} 67 .S'.£»c/, §,’¢j "//Q
F'»I*IP I~C€W./é°;/€V/ C¢:<,z/’°?P' W;`//&z:w/ft?f~)¢a;>\/ NgQg»/MSC §§“6;9§#)

c/M/ ¢»/:@ 3 949 ‘F*//~/€ C 5”’ /‘/Y'?:, 341/f wa// f/@f~//?

 

uhl ,»,~‘

 

WH@YFW b 57
W'})é"`*"z‘°?£w”€ 113/111!@[ c;“;.¢/'J;c/€K/w/ C,,V¢/ ;//~/ce ` -
py?‘"ff/OWPF 175 95701¢1/¢/ //1//¢10€19/»»7' 1.>7[ 737/19 /7&_71 /"f//`
1591>“1?“11"/~11°11'” frey ,<~_ five 1:"01,11/7` ,;~,/1,5”_1/1~1 611/0/ )“/€ ~S//"@i‘f’f
£ijP//f ¢;//».M/ 33‘1/_@ 3207 )L/c/v€°r 1"€’/119///6/%` 77l/ga _
1:»

‘/(? !"/df/'¢"€ f’§;‘éf_,f'€ gy/~r(// §§/\/é//c*/ ff/€'l M/\j/{/ /Sé%/‘

110-1111 511 1111,1@@/.5
' 53;(<5”0/£///€? Ww/jc/

P€)Lé+{f/“' P/ pc;¢~/M/a///C/; //;/@,/:7¢9) %FF€£/ dpg/;;,/€ M/._,o/€f
WFWM /7!/ yffgfj M/’/x/ f'H/”’ 0/}01119 ¢'1’/=¢¢/ )[¢>f€jwwj 701 §é?
507/1 191/1112 111~1§/ 600/1110 '

fYP‘FC'I/f¢f?@/ cpc/ //]”€f/V 1969/5 v %¢w 147ng

 

_ 6531/71 1001/19 c//[ 552/bn €&

77 776/6 fof/v of 71§§':.1'(*’4 1'4§01,-/€ hal §191%/ 1/?’1¢1//19’0/
961 7’£11? 601/111 01`37 /77'//1/ 01/ /111/1’6//117` C¢W»ff/ 7`//
As;'/’, /§LW//P@ Jq¢~M/QI ¢101/ 111`»11131~'1‘/%11?6’ 77 W<'/?‘“A' /