Court Opinion

ID: 213311
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2011-03-26 00:00:48+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T17:28:15.012986
License: Public Domain

NOT RECOMMENDED FOR FULL-TEXT PUBLICATION
                             File Name: 11a0180n.06

                                           No. 09-4115                                   FILED
                                                                                     Mar 25, 2011
                           UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS                       LEONARD GREEN, Clerk
                                FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT

SUSHILL VIDIA TOTA-MAHARAJ,                              )
                                                         )
          Petitioner,                                    )
                                                         )
V.                                                       )   ON PETITION FOR REVIEW
                                                         )   FROM A FINAL ORDER OF
ERIC H. HOLDER, JR., UNITED STATES                       )   THE BOARD OF
ATTORNEY GENERAL,                                        )   IMMIGRATION APPEALS
                                                         )
          Respondent.                                    )

Before:          GUY, BOGGS, and GIBBONS, Circuit Judges.

                 BOGGS, Circuit Judge. In this immigration case, Sushill Vidia Tota-Maharaj, a

native and citizen of Trinidad & Tobago, appeals the decision of the Board of Immigration Appeals

(the “Board”) denying his claims for withholding of removal under § 241(b)(3) of the Immigration

and Nationality Act (“INA”), 8 U.S.C. § 1231(b)(3), and protection under the United Nations

Convention Against Torture (“CAT”), 8 C.F.R. §§ 1208.16–1208.18. Because Tota-Maharaj is

subject to removal on grounds that this court lacks jurisdiction to review, we deny his petition.

          Tota-Maharaj entered the United States in 1993 without being admitted or paroled. He

became well acquainted with the United States criminal court system, and his record includes three

felony convictions: receipt of stolen property (March 2008); possession of a controlled substance

(February 2007); and embezzlement (November 2006). On October 1, 2008, the Department of
No. 09-4115
Tota-Maharaj v. Holder

Homeland Security served Tota-Maharaj with a Notice to Appear (“NTA”) and placed him in

removal proceedings.

       The NTA alleged Tota-Maharaj was subject to removal on three separate grounds: 1) entering

the United States without inspection; 2) having a controlled substance conviction; and 3) having

committed a crime of moral turpitude (embezzlement and/or receipt of stolen property). Tota-

Maharaj did not and does not challenge these charges. Instead, he filed applications requesting

asylum and withholding of removal under § 241(b)(3) of the INA, and protection under CAT. The

immigration judge (“IJ”) denied all three applications. She found that “all charges of removability

are sustained in this matter by clear and convincing evidence,” and ordered that Tota-Maharaj be

deported “on the charges contained in the Notice to Appear.”

       Tota-Maharaj appealed the denial of withholding of removal and CAT protection to the

Board. The Board dismissed the appeal, affirming the IJ. Tota-Maharaj then timely filed a petition

for review with this court, arguing that the Board should be reversed because its factual

determinations were not supported by substantial evidence.

       Congress provides this court with exclusive jurisdiction to review a final order of removal.

INA §§ 242(a)(1) and (a)(5), 8 U.S.C. §§ 1252(a)(1) and (a)(5). However, Congress has restricted

the review of removal orders against criminal aliens. The INA provides: “No court shall have

jurisdiction to review any final order of removal against an alien who is removable by reason of

having committed a criminal offense covered” under certain sections of the INA.            INA §

242(a)(2)(C), 8 U.S.C. § 1252(a)(2)(C). Criminal offenses so designated include crimes of moral

                                               -2-
No. 09-4115
Tota-Maharaj v. Holder

turpitude, INA § 212(a)(2)(A)(i)(I), 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(2)(A)(1), and violation of any law or

regulations related to a controlled substance. INA § 212(a)(2)(A)(i)(II), 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(2)(A)(2).

       Notwithstanding the jurisdictional limits imposed by Congress, courts of appeals retain

jurisdiction to review “constitutional claims or questions of law raised upon a petition for review,”

even in cases where removal is ordered based on crimes of moral turpitude or violations involving

controlled substances. INA § 242(a)(2)(D), 8 U.S.C. § 1252(a)(2)(D); see Nwagbo v. Holder, 571

F.3d 508, 510 (6th Cir. 2009) (“[W]e retain jurisdiction to consider the limited question of whether

the petitioner is removable as a matter of law.”) (quoting Patel v. Ashcroft, 401 F.3d 400, 406 (6th

Cir. 2005)).

       The United States argues that this court lacks jurisdiction over Tota-Maharaj’s petition for

review on two of his three counts of removability—conviction of a crime involving moral turpitude

and violation of a controlled substance law. INA § 242(a)(2)(C), 8 U.S.C. § 1252(a)(2)(C). Tota-

Maharaj does not challenge his underlying criminal convictions, nor does he raise any constitutional

claims for relief. He makes no arguments that this court has jurisdiction over those two counts, and

no case law has been found to support such a proposition. Absent an exception, this court lacks

jurisdiction to review the order of removal based on these two charges of removability.

       Although we do retain jurisdiction to review removal orders based on a charge that an alien

is present in the United States without being admitted or paroled, INA § 212(a)(6)(A)(I), we need

not reach the merits of this charge, because Tota-Maharaj must be removed from the United States

on the other two counts, which we lack jurisdiction to reverse or remand. The petition for review

is therefore DENIED.

                                                -3-