Court Opinion

ID: 4057725
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:46:47.139622+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:14.635055
License: Public Domain

QQ\>:@./\/o. mci zl-o\
. ._ ';
\';>< …Tzz %WSD 0

' RECE|VED |N
CC)URT OF CR|M|NAL APPEALS

}LET H m\/:ec, LEE /\/\<;QART’E"\°§ NOV 23 2015

,»" '~
»"'

CGO P\T GF C.Rl/\/\:/\/ MlAQQSta,C\erk
¢\QPEAL; w /TF:H\§

RE§P<>/\/§e l/\/ <>PODSITIOI\/
Tf> TH~E >W\TE'§ MGP{>§ED

Fl/\/GI/\/G>g 'L§€ FA<;T§ 6a Cc>)\/c_w&lc))\/
C>F L~A \/U -

APPHCM+ wm &\m>w 1';\\@ H~cr\c>m\&\€, Cc>uf+ +)w<>,
F@l\cm)m§ Fc:rcjr£ m §u(>@oc£ 0!\: @\i§ »§€_.J[>\\{ bp`lep'

r_-

j_d
A»P(>l(<;&n+ 0105€.<;+& ~EC> ~`rficb\ C_ouv\$€_l/S (€S{)GY\SQ, Fc>r '
(\M c>k;§ec_~¥m% +O §+c\;¥@.'$ /V\{SC\_Q§>|(€,Q..+{N\ 0\? +%C
I;LUQ §§ F&c+ieg m C_`\@smg chume.n.+ cum Q§;@H§
wm wm QMSQA alanv ms §@i\c@cx +@ adams
b'-\Wliwn+'$ Qlcqm MM +he 5+0&€, “n/\\'s a.,§){>l.'ed +h@

\@Lu,) mg Q@Jl\`a§, +O ~+h@ Q&SQ. EX omle We,l\oorr\/

185 S,W; ad 3@\1~3% S+cw+e§/" Tm@\ Q@@m@,\ mu:+
howe c~; firm Cc>m MY\M& 0€ MW. goue…'m
`\C\L@ \Q~Q_ ?C>f€, l: 4')@&\@.\,1) 9

\/€C! C.lc:@n\\mo@§

f 5

Q.PECC_+\\)Q, &§Si&%o\x\ac "’ T\~\'cp\ Cczon§e,\ S%O\J\~Q._-S §\/\
5\\'3 @,YP\'&cn/i+ +hcdv, "lr\' +ha _$+a}e m€v\“r, 5'5\@ %+cdce;
gm ; 5kch ix ms m*cem? 50 '&Q+ 503@<'\/\€.¢' W|/\,\'C\q
1 uNYQ§ Slm>c>c§ 553 vY\eeL_r\. "<'\f\Q, B+CEFQ E€H: H\Q_
\c»,u) 0§ 9&€4`\€_§ umwa '{\05 G\M>mc?-'m`cdre_ m 5\\`\3
CC\S€.‘" §A@?l\'a@w+ O\SSQH£ J<'>wc,dt +hB OW\\`§,§{C>/\ b\/
555ch 'CC>U\SQ,\ §mc>u\>$ H\Q H~cmo¢&\&\e Q<:>u FJC +h&i"“_
)Ffi&/\ C_c>uw$€,l C<>_\)\OX 5\05 l/\a\'\)€, been ko@$£{bl\/ \
pfdif\g-QH+U\+(@Y\_ +c; MQ S+Od'c€’§ C_\o;&r\j Qr§@m@n+
beacwge. +hQ, 350-dca m amw+ +c>\d H\Q dow +hcdr
15 £\fe(\ "\¥ ~°c\\@,y 'k>€.'\{£u»e& Jv`hadr 1/5_€9\{@&\/\.'+@00~£~_-
Chasim§ &€+U H\Q mbh\ev MU\ 5\€_ was S+[l\
Cjui\+j uY\é\ev VY)Q, l&u) 051 par+\'_e§ 50€,&@05@ ha way

m P@;;Q.Ss\`<>(\ §§ /\J\S. /mc\,c+m Pr@\>w/'f Th@ $+cdre>.-
w€n'lv M§)…` mm ~Me. Sor\! C?\\65 H\Q, Sur\/,€( H\Nd 53\/ 5\'\§ §56¢\(, 159 5\)&+ S€€>_ +')5»\`$
QL)\/ 665 §§ 00 u_)`r\'€€&, mm Oq v him mud 5th

hQ pm¥\`€_lp@jr€£ IV\ ..+5\($ 1051 Ol@?r\`w`@ /\/\S»/l/\cwjv(/\~¢
05 `Y\QF CQ\\, her M&.K& QJ¢B.»Q.G_SQ, |qgr Q&gh QJ\C\

C_Q_,l\ phOnQ_w 80 hQ:S 3(.)\,14’)// (_")`J/`\\] wO\-’\/ \/C)U 3 [t.é€:‘l_
(JQ l QOD+:`Y\U€, Q')/\ `L/)QH 506 ‘ v

 

550 5 0005'5550@
\5¢

“ ( `5/05 5.5 536 53& \&3> 5555(5 §0§_5 5>€_101@ 551@31>1\( 5151€155
555 50 0055510.1005<; 55\Q, 35005€, 5055`5 55\0 §511~\[ “ WQ__

150555 5\0511. 50 5510\1€, 0\1€1\[/\5551§ 55'5005 55&1@€151@5 551005

155%555 WQ §0§5 55&\1€_ 50 95051& 551€05 55€. C55.C555 051`
550 510003 05_ 9055\/ 50 \5: (_ \10\ .5,. PC;>. 5&8>. 30 515510\

C051553@,5/ 1655>0115@_ 5501155 550 50055`1511€5 5550 &50,5@,
105 5550 50500 055 90155`1,_; 51003 1505 00111"005‘1015€,
555 55\5`§ COM, 53 0050801<5 0055 1,…555@555 155015-5**-"
5001@\55$@ 5550 §50050 050§05 505€.55/ 1055 1505 500 50511'
01 9015505 51000$ 0,5>5>105>150_050 50 555<2, C,QSQ 0000115`0
55501` 0015551\\5@@5 50 §51€€,$ 55 &0€5 5551§1£ 5:)€€,051§€1
55\@5 55155§0011>55@15 510 5000 05 500155€3 50 55510 Co\,&@,~
.`51)555055 50~5155€(5 55\& 0511`\/_§ 5500'58505”5 115005(5159,¢,

15 CC5 1111 311'~5 1510 01 11515@§1 10151€; 1101
000 13 1501 00 1015/ 50 0015 051€11$€_ 005501 5550
00151\15\5385015 01 5551 011€555@_ 500 1111)&5 51155 -
5005\ 05 551 C\51C51115§5c01\c@5 00<;0151555 511101@,/-_,

550~55159 010l 010 1510 001151155'0;5'015 01 5551, 051015§0,

 

 

506 5 <;01551051€.
fm 15055 95

5>(;>. 5 C0155`515\1€. 5 '

. \5/' l 0 '
1551155‘10155 0015511\0_% 555005 5551 5000§500§€» 51&@0 515
1051 3500051 §§ 510 0011\5053005 000 05101. 15-~
055@503 1501 1551 001 5555‘3@0111)55‘@0 5551 50001
_5)0155'15 50 55512. C&SQ, 50110030 51 5551 §-5515 y _ 5
511\5"`1\1115 555005 1555>5>55'001155 wm Qh&&;'ng CLW_`V 1550
10505>11 1510 551111 53 150 5003§5`505&01001 115<;15“-1111155@151”
100555 5\0511 \0€1,5”5 050 53015\1 10 5551/ 10515)-11\/ l:;::j
E\/51511510 1150&5 05500) 55100'5 005 551 5515111051 55\1
05505$€. 5501 50555€.5 50€1@ 050+5513 5001.55\11, 1001/5

C®m+F55)O55[53 30515’5@ 15)@(5 »5-0®®§(5$ `55552_ -`Q»X`€.El£)'5`('©nv
05 55115`1 00515155505\ 90150§1 1 300 T>(. 0.0.5.015.?)5’5‘5

 

 

 

701 01€050 <:51'15 1505 010\1€. 5515105 /51)5>55'001155 0011@5 -j
555@, 105053€1 5\0515 0\_ Qc)mmmf\ 53015960@» @@CCW$Q/ `
511`005 000\0£15 00\50\1010 5551 351/050 50 5Y51‘S5C0055
151 1155 131 555001)115'159 1551 1050 01 15551511 m
551 §'511\/ 1550§531/. 1415>15`1,05155 5000 0310§5'051555/ 55011151;5
50\1 515'005 1000015'3“ 50155`€_5'," 555<11 1551 555:051515@5515
01€1€ 5505 515\0105)01 5501 1550 5511\1 U¢'@|CbeQS ®W`/ 1
§1005515€, 01 000515'5;505@, 15@55) 1@@11 55@15/515 105105511

Q/C,C,L)SS€(§" 55 551`5/050513 &5555 01555501_15»1'55€115 506(.05113@
93 5 C0155’51151@015 150<5~5'6-5

 

PC»>.\ Cl>n¥»{\\)@_\

\)/ ‘ .

ThQ_ &lrc~:“ejg m+ `Q\)i§mce, imc/dr " ADP\ i CQ\M
A;+@,m@ m mm…'§ way wm \NQ,… pr@,mga£@~l
bea&&>§@, ¥mzr@, wm mo -A\)tOM\QO~ Hvu“ Apv\£c&\/H* w€\$
ever m 9033@,&3‘\00 ,@% \r\@.r ws@. TY\-i; …’ver&@Q+-»'ov\ --
gmn@d ¥h.,@ mfva @§ +\/m 5\»4 w b@\ce,@m\§ Ag)p`\i &>W©Y*v iii 606 M\Q, §0{€,30\“3 .FUJSO\\S.

1 0103@@3¢ jre +`Y\f¢ -+~v\‘od Coun§@\/; AH\'¢\@_\)£+.

 

@C»,., Q 4\0@316\3{
¢\o<>\\wvf <>m<»_@+g w wm Q<>L><\S@_\i@ MW\SQ~ F@“

"‘ m:>% c>b§ec¥m_<) w Pr\xz,§\)r\[ Q,\m&<%& mW@C€/%L)QSMY\ O;.
\e,;sev m<;'\u(§jr. Q,.@Fr@bmodr@ +f\`@\ 4600¥\£@\:§ Q`.,-l\e§vo;+n`on
.j(-'hcdf /in§>l.'war @L)\\\/ `\Mex\c\,m£
m WS 9053@35{0/\ 40 M O@|{Q'€,. -

.. H@,;) C@n¢m\)»@ c>\m.es(+(?€>~

 

g£>c/).a ;§mm@

1+ was wis m¥\\ c\Mev 4th QH\`Q€F &5\& 6&0\
MQ\@<;KQNS, did.\fm>\f)`\iW@C%S 'Hm H\QOF\/ @E‘ TMH m+ A\o\)@v\/ 16 Vm §\)r\{ -m\.ie\)ed H\..§mg wm irm mbh-er md APPMQM+ P.'QK€(;\ UO
H\Q ‘{¥€nq$ HW€ (`@§Jb@(` (M“@QQQ(` L/L)\n_@y\ MP\D\K:O»HWL maj
QUFS m§_ Y\WY\. Tr\`a,\ c:c;»on$e\/$ \Pcese\w+€d 00 €,\)\AQU\QQ/H)

jim 5\”\) \3\>"¢ O~ 'S\f\if+ uman w +h€, MQ!\`QM_*Y.IJF
m&o\d howe been Jvr\`<@\ SHC\+Q%\(\ J¢<> @\@g@@,+ )F-@

H\.Q, S\)N <;hoq.%€, amd mY\ §er @\_ag.§e,r mclu&ecl

Q>EMV\SQ, 05 +heH am QL_ A~Q, w/)SQ_ irc +h@fA@§. (l@\@be¢\(,
"NPI»'QQA»% -Lle@rl\/' wc>u`\& wm &CQQ,P¥@A 1000 ""'
§¢~)1')¥§/ §§ /U\€,H FC-\.¥\AQ€ H”)O)\r\ *Hl`&l C.`oul/Ue,l-

{Mrh"n€)' @_,\l hf§d\[é)§ gm Pr\€. +C\BD\Q Q>Y\\\(SL,\)(U--
ibm \\)- ,+m @\s>+r@n +@ @;AA @Q;@@\»;m+ 9@£1+~/@1¢
m>% gm“… 06 543<3‘ QCMJQ(\/, AQP\\'Q@M @35@€+$

jrhodv» § L)_§+ beacx\)sq irr{al CQw/\.SQ.\ SC¢/S H w&$
+rrc\~\ S+r@j€,§\[ 40 nmb @Lz>§ec.+ 40 +M SQM dwij

C\‘Q c@n+moe,@m me)<+@@_

 

 

i.m:W-i

GM\' €§'r(ib§@,c_% @PC> +r\`.&l C@ov\£@\/§ AFG\AQ,vLJc._

 

f

J/

!\?©\\`cm+ ®SQ¢&S Hm+ -H% ¥c\'c\,\ QQQV\SQ,\ WQ_S $v© 1
mi§ \€m§ A/h€, 'l¢rc¥\©f&}©\€, Couf¥ b\( §M¥m§ M')C>d'
AO©\'\Q@M mag ~R&QWHHQA Odr ¥Y\»Q SQ€,v\~Q b\j M\Q_'“‘

‘C@m©l@'\\® WMJ'~ TNS Comlrmc\cdr; his @u)v\ C@v§&-

€XCM\’\ §r\O$r[e\cxMo\/\~ '©9 L‘n/\- 8403¢\"0§ . ll § hva ©\F Ul`cq€®.
9mm ¥he. ¥lm€, M¥ h<)»@©er)edi H)Q¢`@ ix Y)

M\@Se \)iA€@; ar m irth MPQS'-é$

 

 

 

 

 

OWMV ©V\

\/Gk> \' AQM§ Fy' in

nom a, 1000 * - was H\Q $v;p,@¢+,
H&C§ i+ ho»\ haw §Qr `lrf(&,\ QQ>QV\SQ\’§ dQ&L'Q[Q\/\+,
QQV §OFMM\QQ, m §QU`\U{Q +O @L§§QC~P“A© HPD)(Cm/\+
Cl@dm$ ‘H\Q HLN`OJ '@fOC€€Oli\/\§j wowld howe logan

diFLEe<“Qn+_ l

__4;

 

 

Pé,@ ch+{n\)€, <3/\_ M\(;v @G\\

-`

w@<;.z acem*.m)@_j x

fir-ia wirtch C@w\m\`ggiév\ . +c> m\)en”v a%vce`v@§§fc,
V€_QLS@Q 3 of ; &CQQ\§>+ a\\\l S+rojve,§}\{ Qc>u\r\&@\ C.@u\d hcx\j&
F(_\,\\@M~z\ :.w_ga~~_
MCMSM\/. ice Q_\en‘§x_\/ cmi 5@@4>?@@%0+ +h@_ x
Fmémg

EOF H\Qld\`cbl&©m+"_\ cwa ~H\& CQ>UF+
C}\CL'P&;;AF€F\`Z€S i+SelF 635

i:im§€f" &m\ +Y_\‘U\ L§Ud
T/m(§€r,,. .’ me C_c)Y\ &\)C
@>G w reward md W)\+ \`E +hQ imm §@d§e§
Hr\é>m§<; ma mir §u§>@crléed> 134 %Q f€C®r\d, W€_
h[l\)€, Jr¥\Q, O»UW\OFH'\/ #1»@ gwyng QQn-\m_p\[ @\C OV\JFUMMQ
de§$ md C@Y\Q\u$s‘o'ng_. `
N(:»><+P@c \”M\\IEM Q&RT`I FICATE"CFSEWICE
, \<;;,‘HC»C}\ L/Y\ Q.M~l

  

 

// +_M-.u…mc&& Facj<-
e 03 +hQ @vi§\`l/\G\J F&<;+
am indewm§cm+ 061/tew v

 

 

666 '\
En§\

666/66

£/\6@)\`£664 66&\/3 -¥\\Cdv 466 )-\ 06©66§6\€ Cc>m`+ CO>V\(§LUF

`\¥S emma 66le Gindm%§ 606 QQY\<;\\)6&66 666 6666;+
3dch Cc>m+’$ HM§£\’\§ 666 +r\`o\,\ C@o\/\SQ\S 666(6\6\!& 67
f€§?cm$@_ 60 669\\`¢6666 \\ 01 wri+@§h&be@$`_
C`_NQ)§ 666\’\+ 666{\<;66+ €6\1‘@§ 66 66 666/66-
§of.

6©666€6\\4 5666:666,
66666§66366@6,
mgm/616 L):E AAQQW~ER
T'. 66 6 6 )666;)9<@
36@\ 3 é,m((\/ pp
@€Q_u{\ \.\<),, T>( 76/6&

CCIIFI F:Q6TE 'GF 315 666:@ E
f h€f&b\? C€f+¢`?\/ 660er M)@_ 666 C_OWQC."F<’.@Wv
66 66 666 mm

3 666 YY\&\IQ£§ 60 666
L666T 66 <16:66:6/ /\/6L 666€6'66 66 TE><66
66 666 7 664 649 6/66@6\\@6 320/5

\YQN‘W§QQ_ W\QCOU\U/L,
Lz:THA\/:EL_ LE); /\/\ \66666§6

 

 

 

d d z\/cu. m &01§
<>@_ 53 z 1 .

®-€cw ®i§+m'f;+ CKQrI/\,

l fe%u@&+ “H`) \/00 FOFL@CM\ 'IIY\'\l \VQ@H bf`l‘€§ w Wl&

QF HH);>€@L§ C_@r¢>u§ C@w$ m@.l\cr&:,\l@&~&;§~l
WR~ w cg@~c>\

R€§,@e<;+wl\#' §L)\Qm[H€d, _

§NMMQ §QLMQ@§LS