Court Opinion

ID: 4053066
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 03:03:25.276133+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:43.359405
License: Public Domain

_'!-§\wc !QM Grr§zd¢d ¢/1{3@@“’
§\-Z\€s \)\Y\A`XF Ug.,€/U?OH)O$)UO

mm wm 55\»\
YZ)QM\\\¢><\¥ \T`L‘ 77'?65"

;v`\ c)~»\ / j\'\o»( Arbel /Lcosl-¢m 191302 ,Cap€+z»\ .SHL\~\

MAR 122015
A@r><\f'\’x` 71571\ )

AbelAcosra, clerk

Ez\clo¢.,~eol Vm will §wl w\ m;-.A~W\/- cd/’V' mt W\>’
"`RQ~>W," 46 m +…l @Wc@/C/L/;*“§q¢@~w 012+.>
0\->&< §§ <§w\~f wc{*\' \\c»\oeu§ Covws §//.07,

I<€ `fm/\ irm Qn\/ Twés$'\‘o/\§ w Con\_/\U/lv'}§mr

1~;\@\~¢@¥0¢¥\§ -@mw\ W:; ‘<\oa/Ci down/25

S/`/) C'€ Y` Q//‘//

W QVM»

T§cw~[ Qa>j Gz¢}>&,m/

jim /\¥¥16 CN`\ w\b-_/\o\\ C@ux€\v oil APM@L\$
‘:\:N =x'&e C/~rém mr Av\s v\__‘EXJ¢X*S.l

 

"\`Uc~\ \lw Cd\\z,wo¢\\m@w 3 CUM NG@):

mm \:N\ 55va 4 'Flb{‘i&o<;&~$lcv')» D
Q:>M>~\N\B(\<\’\TK. 77705. § FLL{?(O`_B`3007_, 4
(v D& C`r\mzm\ :W,&;Qe
SM\¢L @§ ’TQ§\@§ -
Qc§`\¥< \€ more Q\Qé?¢n${ 40 Tv §\ex

§U\\|`\D”A A?Q\"\Loér\\oc\ fQG~€ w¢l\~ ©Sv \{\ck\>€ab COS 031- _,`r »/(`F_SN)
did '-\&\"\ZLQB&'~B mfvex\<\'\'~t `\r\ ”\“(/\L cu§‘¥m£\i ov\'i’¥\e Sln`\€§
\ky:.;¥\ 5000 \;W\ 735/q \ ¥>@MWY\P\T§ 77705.: "l` now
§§e#.»@r\$< \<> J<\\L \r\o\r\ovq\:»\\ Qow<'\ 0§< C<\m§n§)_ 'APP€Q!{)»M‘/
?\eesw\¢_,e” 4a '<\x\e ‘WSH` S\~\>Qx:¢v_ D:§w:& Q.@Wo¥ 0£ /Ud.co€)-

<§ocx\w (`Jou~n¥~t> c,§‘v`( o& /\)Qc»i><\m)~<€‘ ov<>\Q-x %<> ¢\@,v\%
c\??\`\c<»§v§m\ lex m(>< 032 \¢\@\>@.aé cos?% §§ //.07.

Q\

 

§§ \ %*§'0\3\\1 Cr§f CP§%€

`Al<\ o\QCO~§S\o;\/\ ca §§ __\/‘U\C»é> (;<`\w\D/\c§\ Q()é\ C cu\& §>§c>c£\\>~§&
AQX, 9.’1»._‘®;1[%> Q§,\vl$§\§¢\\§§ es<\¥@rez\ \(\X@ e~. §>\zc\ 0§
"5\\'\\¥`\ X§> "(\NL' CX`\N\`§<\¢\\- C,\(\c».\§‘§‘¥.`) io‘$§ \¥\T~ g A PQ,\I`CL\ @Q
Q,Q-°\`O’b I\“\‘?S§c\,\s<$c{d Q\o\>`bm§i wl"§j\\& “\'§/\/>\ §m\%§ chi ?\m`\é`
\§m»m¥ vf`\`-C\><.§\;z.b;l 5`°!¢1 view§ » ll§§;‘§ c§@i’)§ee »
le\¢m‘( JQCCW¥€» a ?\m bw§gq?m £o§ 020 \feo~§§ 0»§\$ Q¢Qw\o®~
`\b\e\ \§>`\ `\’\M \W§W §v\?@"\€>< ®`\§5§§ rex Q§O~C*v 1\(\0§\0§0»\)\< ".)o\)§€.
CAM\&\\ CBX `K »Q<\¢Lg`~é\`u\">`» <,_,`\`§`\f\ C@LL§¥»QP%ZM€J Ql/e§!\€¥»
N\§. Q\oim Qc\§\@§\\ q 00 N\w¢ 3'°91310<>7, N\§\ Q~\l\>‘> wq§
U\\-u~ §§ ".¥§®<\0»\ \D\\u LS?O~¢`) 06 0§ `JL)~\(\Q \ 9~€>0'7. -

N\§- C:§`\Xb§c§>> S~l\?§ \’\55 §§§e'¥ 5~\0§\¢ w§`§¥ ©-~C

\!\o§<)ws cos?v=~b 3 L\\O`T €uc>w\@§v`~~'\`e -\>Q;§w€aA :S\»\§\e \9007)
-‘d> A'\’~‘>v~¢}\.€~®c?} on §\\\'e "3§¢¢»\0\6 osi \) S\e QQQ§§~FL

`\c\§§é§ §\\Q)N‘§ 35 in QX~QMA¢ZJQ ags?s\w\¢e os§ Co§u\§ry~<\ "\\\ O§.\\Q,W\P¥ Xo dmecl- *H\€
AQ§&CX§N’\ h\§\c§ qm*<\\e,< c<>»\\‘:>c
052 %x\`~s\w~e,§\*< ~\f\‘I`.C=A-§ /<§2.53 SND 31'&‘3§<€ j;Q.\oc\`/
443 @u\sm ve \Qw H\m 3 ~1€¢~§> c»wj ./\)o\L 40 vich
\N\Q N\@\\ciw\wv\~\ 0§< 90 4@»§§. “§\:\e mw ¥v§ol cm;§+
m§*h< move L;'\\%§ 0~{\ @C/LOQDL~C \§+M/ <§l€><>'la /4/§0 ‘H\€
~NQQO\ c_,¢cw@§ §L\Q<§ \`&’é> §§ce§v ov§\e§ S&<\M\a QPP`(-
Cc»<\R-é 5§<<>»\@ w§`\¥ 01 M\ow§ Co<&>»§€> 5\\.07» T}\e H§¢J
Coc»zév §§ N)¥ §mmw& §§`5 \>oz&\cov\oe¢¥w\ co<»§\`L m)e§
Jv<> /\?\§~Q\`§\x>s<~\h \¢\13 CQ\»o\\\c§ O\L\O§M\¢ 3 crc JL\‘>@/\+o
¢§>\s\e `\`§C`S\ Q\&cos§$ é`\`\\\ ;s§<§<\_ `\M\¥§\ (5> -er ;3@1<9-

./V\§ ~\ Q»)\l\az<»\\> ) ww» Co\\¥u& /~\ S)Lm~'e founse)
?@< (`>£L@<\S\ué j¥?‘?§\\¢)§\c }§&\e>§\\~§~#’ 3 »/V\§§. l\
wm \n;§\@w~<`\r\§ “`<\a ?§§w~\€ CO<\S;*L§-Q,o;e/M§§.
'E\woc‘dr\ > q§§\sl'~zm\ we `\N\&r ~»\/\~L §§§Q\\ Cou»§lv dinsz a¢\
`\§\Q§WQ~< §Qr_sc\\§§\&`) .\)M\c. ?§c> \¥w<\c,_ if qs/ §Qs?cn<§ §

"3; \)Q’y\x\ ‘\§o §QQQ`\\> c ?<»§6\{ \\§\\v&§\)l€w_<.. @C>QS\~&§

(33

, ®Q:,S\§w§§ \>MW m;a\wx%m§ … pm\€.
a\‘\¢>z\)\\\§< m\ mc@¢ém\<,e `ém \F-T`C`A~ ésv@./q‘i. /l'w
Qa<~z>\{ `\<\\(§<\\,\{u>s owe accm§h\ml~r .' Qc\v\\)§o.w ,@-’1015 3
\_~Q\>mc~<`\ 390\‘>\ “) ?Q\©§v\c»§`§ QZ)IS`, @QLw-LQ.Y\ O’ZO/Z»O?J/S`
J\§\C.Qq\"\pjo\b) Q;\,;(\QB ?\m\\b§<\c><\§ \\¢.\ §Q£u.<`»¥`§ C\é¢§§ §Q\QGS¢`:»§
\}\§n\ X'§ow\ }5§$\ (S€S §Xr~\-w$ \'c Cv\~"\ §¢\€_<\`w§\- cus¥eo\\i
mi\’\\ \\`»~’> \.~`\\\& C\<\es \.

§§ \¢\)©\w ins <§\; ;»\&\"§

"\'.\\1 CO§`§¥`&¥PO\<\¥€¢% 'O\\Xo§ i\&`f j N\§. Q‘l€,v\e U\\ ()cJopu)-Ld)
' U\N> Nww< §w\ewc§ `V\\§ §N§§c§§\w\e,w°§ \ `\ O\\\o\o§<\”_'§ »J\!\?- Q\»k>$o~d 3 H QD\-O§

' `\ <\\<<> O\ ’\>\Lo\ ~\)>.§°>¢®<\ 0\\\`\<§§_¢\\\%&“9§"\ `f O<' \)~>{\\L\!\mo 506 l `f &>Q€€O@
O\(\ a §Q:-\»o\\ev\§§~ j/\§`\ QS\:\O§@N , q/l’@@§ `H/\C
%§`\c»\ 69\>~§§ §§ \>IL `t\)\ “§\\Q §Jo\\om€¥“§ Q)<§G\S_ 3

\\ Q~`\\QB "§\~€ `\§'\P<`OPL( ‘\`©<\\€¢q“{ 3 A)§)J\c Pf`o \~me’»
_ §§ d ' \\C§\ \ w \\`
`\*\§\O\ CO~X\ CS\\\\\ C,O§vU/X§ l§\(,c.\\ QX§Q\`S cong Nd'{‘\i»k ~
\c

`\Q§¢§\ QXWFS § @\\§w %\,\L \’§o\>@( §Qw\e<§§ 1)¢)<>\1\¢1 \r\wc been
lee §§\\(\S\§c§§ -\ ~(\‘\§. Q:\l\>§@\\)-

Q.. ' XC`\.OX CCBu-\°~\ \¢\/,\X R>\`OP‘L< m&§`u§`§€”&¢t‘a€>¢\ (U\A \'P ()OQS
Q§§§b§§\&§@\\x ¥§ow:\\/\§ *vo `\\"z M\u\&§@n(§ H(c>v) 01 H\P
AQ¥§<§¢`\\)L \10§§\0§®\‘1 d\gfc,¥m\bn¥ `ir\;<§?<‘)z>‘l.

 

Q\\

' ' 5. %K\Q\ QG\§'§\€§ §§ C.`~<\\vé§~ 0§3§(@<\\@>{ J N\<~ C¢\\\A us§\\ , `Y@C;`S,~ D\Qc<>¢$$ ©h)\`s§`<\B~\ N\§~Q§'§\DSGO\ §§;\(\Xv §\ %€QQ“\\?QX )§O\Q > w\/\§`,¢\\ boa$
Y¢`~M \\Qc»€i> QQ¥CV °§“\l~e gac/dr T@CI~ Q\Q¢o\<§~z` D\)§.-§\`c>v‘)
<5\\0¢)~>® v€LQ,\\¥ \\`TN\\<~S\`\\’$“ \)YAOL§N\S\~ .N\Y~ Q’\`§!>$:»WS) )

\€@c§\ é¥w\vv§s ;®< ?<¢`§\§¥`{,

‘3\\ ~¥s`§<§\ Co§.<¥ >L\AceeS/Qg\ 965 gm I>J§cxl\>¥m¢§)
<\>ousb<:‘> <>x\)\ Cw§¥’\\e re}m§`§cl\\{ §o.,\v-L O:v §T\x\€ CO\N\\N\YSS\`(N\ 0~\: W€ O“P'Q/UW%€;
645 `N\QC¥ 9§~ V\D\q\oec\/_

§§ ~\/\\e \j\`§`o.\ C.c>§§§'¥$ qc§v`»m\é, A>veaoe\eoo “~H/\C

Q\Qo§-'\oo~‘€€>€§w 619 cwa \~<\€x\-\ M \s\C§f> ("_€w§se_o( `(-\Cul\o°ame(\*~al
§»W», mm {>»@L§M § wm
§»\ wm ~§x.@>.c(,k, w m \»\‘(“ /A»M§\AL

f\Z@_\E§> / PQMEA

QQ,X¢`§A¢\\G\\QN '\ )`)\\" Ql\`§\§>f:v\l}) SQQ`\¢-S `\/\\Q \`Q,\`\{`\‘b< QQ< MKLC& Q\\§Q`§s§\`\év\m\ \>‘\ `H\t CC §m§`hc§( Qo§d‘

o§< }‘RW<>~\S §§ smu-w o§?cl Y&… \r\`=> Co<\)\r£`c)¥&c)v\
5)

~\0&<,\& \<<, \\\€> A<~»v`§o¥ Cr)§»x¥ \ \"\S`"`§§»§§§<§c>f bd$kz>#
C__c§x?\' » N@C,@%Ao&\€é Céwc\&v”( » c_`\¥\{ §§ Nacozc\oc/\~¢S ,5+@§`~€
GS< "T‘bm§ TS°lLQ\ . ~'U\C\ C¢\lb§o§), £-(H\»§w v‘¢‘I/w€§\% <>M
0~¥\\§( \)~x\wa *Y\N>§\< vol\\ &Yex\¥amd\<>§ \\J¢MN\°.\ d\ \\Y§ %<§o§§ CA§>§(¥£

j’:;§mo;&§ §§¢\MQ§XM /fe<¥;£;m¥e 09 Semace

T\_ -\ _\_\<<§<»1 Q\O»`t ij;bzm.\ %’NB@&§@\\( \ ofac/dm M\JU F€n~
c§\\-“\ 0(\¢ ‘?UB\)~C'( ~\"N/§X' ql{ H/\L ~C@f@c)§(\§ (’¢/\.»LG.és 'cma/

`\/\XOw u¥`§\`\;?<\§ “~Y\¢\< Un{¥ 63 SP§\LQS H>S{v:§/ §€w§`e)§
o§ \~v\)»€ ‘L\Lc~£§¢ C<$P\f \`é '¥)QUL‘J (Y\c\§(leo( +6 f Cf\`m¢"rm/?

QO\»§C"§F O& JL\`W{O§Q_S) ()O Eo/Q /0'25€)% Ca/D¢"/¥a/ 5'1[¢0[¢'>1¥!/ /¢uSILJ\>

,T)< 7671! Qr\& cl Covw(>lir\/\QAP»H COFY \5 /)€¢h? mal/ff
\_0 /L{SH\ SLLFU§` of D§Sjrr 01 Cw(+ f /O/ w /WQ¢Y\ 5¢
row\ /3@ » /(/aco:')oqo / S'ND'@/O'/“/ c)'p/%frc-//>\
’ 520/5 -
' lomas/ga YAQ})$<)(§/ Z~~él/$_

./an\t’

MDKQM/&RM 63 51 /_§_

§lf$"ld§~(~§§

(c`p\