Court Opinion

ID: 3879003
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-07-06 09:11:08.473864+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:24:13.820841
License: Public Domain

March 11, 1926. The opinion of the Court was delivered by
"The plaintiff entered suit against the Krey Packing Company of St. Louis, Mo., upon five separate causes of action. The first cause of action alleged that the defendant had been employed by the plaintiff to assist its auditor or agent in making sales and collections, and to go to Charleston to assist in unloading a carload of meat, and had agreed to pay the defendant $77.23 for his services, etc. It then alleged in four causes of action that the defendant, through its agent and representative, obtained the plaintiff to cash four checks for the said defendant; that the checks were presented and were worthless; and that demand had been made upon the defendant for payment; and that payment had been refused.
"The defendant made motion for a nonsuit and for the direction of a verdict upon the grounds that there had been *Page 190 
no confirmation of the alleged authority of H.P. Pumphrey to cash checks; that an agent has no authority to bind his principal except within the scope of his authority. If he goes outside the scope of this authority, and commits a fraudulent act, the principal is not bound; that there was no testimony to show that the Krey Packing Company received the benefit of the checks. Both motions were overruled, the case submitted to the jury and a verdict for the plaintiff for the full amount claimed, except as to one check, upon which a verdict in favor of the defendant was directed."
There are nine exceptions alleging error. Exceptions 1 and 4 impute error in refusing to grant the nonsuit and the motion of the defendant for the direction of a verdict. The testimony shows that Pumphrey was employed by the defendant to sell their output and to collect checks from the customers for cash. His actual instructions from the defendant in regard to cashing of checks was:
"And where checks were given to him I gave him a rubber stamp with the following indorsement to be used on such checks: `Pay to the order of ourselves in cashier's check. Krey Packing Co.' I instructed him further that checks received from customers were to be indorsed with this stamp, and a cashier's check obtained, and the same remitted to our company with proper letter of advice as to what it would cover."
The checks that the plaintiff cashed for Pumphrey were not made payable to the appellant, nor did Pumphrey indorse them Krey Packing Company by himself as agent. They were made payable to "H.P. Pumphrey, or order." One was made payable to "Cash", and all were simply indorsed on the back "H.P. Pumphrey." The defendant's name nowhere appears on them, and the undisputed evidence shows that the appellant never received one cent and knew nothing about them. *Page 191 
The plaintiff testified that Pumphrey told him that he received them from customers. The evidence shows no such names were on the books of the appellant as its customers and parties who purchased from it. No other inference can be drawn from the whole evidence than that Pumphrey was employed by the appellant to sell its output, and, when checks were given, the rubber stamp given was to be used, and the check deposited and the cashier's check obtained and forwarded to the appellant. The checks cashed by the plaintiff were drawn in the name of Pumphrey, and not as agent. They were not accepted by the appellant; it knew nothing of them until attention was called to them; and it promptly denied liability.
These exceptions must be sustained, as Pumphrey in cashing the checks was not the agent of the appellant and was not acting within the scope of his employment. His Honor was in error in not directing a verdict as asked for by the appellant.
The judgment is reversed and remanded, with directions that the Clerk of Court enter up judgment in favor of the defendant under Rule 27 of this Court.
MR. CHIEF JUSTICE GARY and MESSRS. JUSTICES COTHRAN, BLEASE and STABLER concur.