Court Opinion

ID: 4070771
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 01:31:02.219034+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:08.734579
License: Public Domain

M/?}@?@J
%` 444* ~ 4

%&/'1¢ £ME¢¢¢/%'Q€ v
za/ A/, /%"/.¢>2;55 474/az
r f » y na

 

a .~,_
fl

””é § ” ¢,/ 4 444
4::;:%:44/4{ 4MQM

z § /”4@4%»¢4
4 %”"L/&”£ M”Y MQ:/Mf/:,z 44444
` AW/M:M JW M
A% M/M%WJ jj

‘¢W M»~ ”4

 

 

14 7//£ amf of cum/444 114/545

 

. %L\ 13 l 'O‘
v ' 194 414.3744!45 mm '

144071\/4, 4 _

nom 571/01 ZQLZ;€£:ZL‘LQ_‘£.L_

f ) In/ 7//£-' 441 Z€/L7 goa/127
ix ”M.Y 5 /¢/01____/5'47112>/£/4£ A)Jze/¢?’
mla/1752 1{’¢11)/ 5[£'6`51< 9 ,/_»
/7)9/°1/£41\/7_¢`

 

/}147/0/\/ 1€£6!11£§7’//¢0§' ./°£Nb/A/£-` 1£’£[`01/17/'011/
of 2414/717 //4£[/21” 514/41 4/’/’2/¢4741¢/ 195 4;4£
M/ /7&"’ 7114/ci mv 71?/41 C’¢u/aéff £wb£'/v?"/IA/ £l//IMf/V&;`£_

/
6£~“1"01¢.’£ 11 7%'£ danvme £02471:/’-` w "/'°£"‘(5 ‘T“°§f} b£c"m"‘/’

44421¢1»47 ama/452 mmi 5£5¢51< //4.\‘ 4/.§47 75 4774M' z/4Z/0/71'/51C

CO/vV/£ 710/v 4/\/ 6’1€0¢¢11/[) UF A[N/AZ 4/?0¢/£'1040££§_.§ /A/ 019/51/11/11£ A/AJ[A_|"

604/w 704 7//4710¢{4/945£ 411on .1, 3475[@,444/743) 365 5h1/2d 35 7
174 454_( 514/45 457 414£571¢/4, 777.

 

/5 ’“ !.,21)/_§J

/f/‘/»<’/m~ 7//454 17/_\' 40577111 714 1141701‘/%4474_( 514/w 0 1v //£174/’/..(/64'/\/7 641\/£71€4

/.~'_¢ 7///5 Af/%/ 74711\/ 416 5 45 360ch
clMALZA/Ef 194 41/ 51//5£417141€/

4/’/»(1;117 A’£AM;WZ“A 41744’£4 4_r 4744/44 /941&§441¢/7 / 447/aff
//,//4 A/L) //, 3/) i/£~’/EMM/_f 411/1111 6 51/3 zu///c/>’ A//El~'czf 717f J` ///~'1€//"1‘ 415 559/1943
alan/77 72 4411/41 /21€74/1!/44/441.17/1¢1 4405'4; 71

5044.(5` 7//£ 641/47 7 1644/541 7//4’
155/711// of 4//1'(/£4111%{ 057£'4///44/. 75

1111 51~5441411.1 447/145 4 f..z ij 7;:;\,,” @,/M-
415/417 caAi § 5//, 42/ 0) 644/143 24/5

135453 ~1~; 45454244

{//. 47/’2 1241/74 4/4177 71 454€5`45.174 7114 47 ca11/wa 14 1~7/5 /Md%f
614/41 441)¢554111/4, 447¢4`5 / 15/ mm 1144/142 444 c,c./z,'

62)1 414.<'1¢4~7 451/751'751¢44/ ¢¢1171=114} 4 1447¢5~14~/4¢7 A£/'EA/Jé' //\/ I/Af
£Z/?//'l 7///77 fl/Hé' /4£ /7¢4££-’1\’1€11€ mff47£_f 745 145/49 165/f 1111=£5!)”41€7/4/€ /?
421/177 rf/aA/c7 1 1\/ 3£541.14 4411/0 51//0£/1/€£ 417/67 w/U 75//€’>’/"7 775 573'
154/1450 % /1€¢7£ 715/5 /1\//,(/¢ 7/41\/ 44 840 7 /4/741¢'7' 1417/07 d 41\/£!54@7 d/"
,;55,,,,¢7, //471¢44_’¢ z/,g 3 ,;,\,U 37. 49§ 2 1441/144 411/114 c c />.

4//1/441\/7 cu,\/7z'1vol /'/'f /!40' /"£NA//u@ 4 m/JA£»¢£AUo/< ¢4.(£ 417/cbi w4f
D/-%LCFM /1/¢111117)/ 411/47{2) 47 ;an~'//M 1644/4452,

 

,_ 444 41 7 441/544 y '- 451/4744 444517 Mf_f 14 éJJY/< /A/cAM£A a/‘/Evff`

41471/44441111751) 14@41¢7 441 427/55 4///'151<. 54 744 11 d%v/¢,f [ 541 4/_/1 /f` 772
57!$¢1/1 2 15 5 91 711/231£741£1\// 4411.1 vZ,<"/1F41€’1¢»1 4/1141 16574/45/1¢"/4 1 /5`9 LZ) 1

. l
‘ 44411¢4417 4~75443 744 7"57,’ 474_¢ 744715 4411/01<44'4£ XM’¢¢§/"

411/6 H/A// 141154411“7<115‘.!' 4 51271174; 72"445 1€114£_?~4/55145116£ /f’azf /93 /?”A"/M
1 011/ 5'1//51!111££, " `

_ A//’//MA/f MMZ‘A/A./F 5 115/504ij 41757/1£(.¢/%&011\//44! 5/%//1'-'/) %
/’ W/@£'”/\/ // 44in 717de ~1//5445 44471»5445115 444/1541 442 741r

[‘111451.15£ /,4‘:£47£4 137 77[5717[.’41\115 745 44/51\14411//$ cfc/140 454 1/1 574‘7£

.[4//, 13 444 ..244;3_) 133 544/sd 153 /p,€,g[;qgw 444/754 ,@;,/W¢z /13 51 141/sd

575 /%’7629¢1 69sz 44/04~.€¢9 .2w 4 412 712 z 471 66/1»11 444 1\‘”4715/6£(/1@1 ?i§é€/ U.

44’///[441/ com 75421~/1`:11//2-2!41\/7:¢ a114/J5'Z 01£41014£4 775 7`”‘411470/-'
A///Az_f 1)7£/»21/£41\/41»1 4//41/101/ 41\115 J,A 5/;951// 1051€[ d//A//d/»/J 7%1'7451"1//150
4//»<1144174 174/4 44/1441.117‘/ 74 454/441), 751/46 4//, /;€m, 161 72/, 4

4445443; 141 ix 44.<7£ 1951€4<5,9 .21.5`.§, 11131° '//.?:, .571122 1275 72151€44,¢1) 1.r 451/a /b a/"
£.1/0£1\1741¢7_$‘¢14/4¢714'11< 17 awv/LZW\/

141\/51//4£1\/714/<,7
1/1141 741'= /)'///AZ'/Z.(` 417/€/{/.§ » &1\1¢11571441 411/y g J-M¢zf_;/,;é/::}:;/£,;:Zl;`;?;vw/ZJA: i, gaf
IA/ 5;{0'¢¢11/¢) J///l/fl{;/£/£/f/\/7fy/A[,y£f g ' 1 //zd&tf ' 4r

l 1314/5 01./41.,141 &,1141;194%373 ,<,11, 7512
4 560/1511%'1()[££~24 _

§4474%¢3€/14/414£ 1///19?[_§ 11 11/47“.6’4'1111/0v 157/140/11/1¢J 0/%(/4[ 631/147 /11/ 1¢ 154/&¢5`

514/4r /’1€’46£2§014154114 1447 441<$ 54474'447/711414/1£! /£1~/ 3440 1144 114 7511/1917
774/42 511/471 5441414;¢, 54 7444'1¢41414141 714/444 /91 7745,1.112¢/54 4,

, 4 _ 601ch 111/441
444451%'15 4414115; 5441145€54, 4///114~ 744/ir 1411444114/4£ @4<7¢/"_
541/414141 4/454£: 7417¢£( 474/17 ”1¢//1 1417/441 11.1 747/511;€14145€£(7147414£

444 41'74447/1@5141£5 /_£>’115 444 51€.05,€ z 74r7e1;d 1144/17 /1"414 4~ 541451117/1?1€1'" `
/7611€/1¢/5 75 1/£/5614/1115 77/1.r 144?41!/ 4f 1!/1;'{/0,@417_? camwc%M//

 

 

;5"/1¢11/55*4411) 4476€£4 4,./ ' ` FlK/Z.Z/T‘//{?::Z”Mg /7:':"?/
///1: 42 1)4741» 457 211/51 4/42144~1 444-s

/)7/1:1/41[ 1014)/ J££`§£z
726wa
1344/45452 3744!-' 474/4
5 35 6`//1¢'11/411/ 1040
~¢171./41\1%)11//4/ 76(’¢{ )¢PHL

» 1141_§4114110£444174\157
_;*1)11¢44251€44155€45€ ,wccfzow, 4944445611111'4411)451) 1471/5011»/4/1¢462
5747£ 541/7/1\/.¢`411/41\%4110/ 753|4{ 11 145[/171@ 411/1256 191914¢07"0/1`»/£§€74 167 7447%//_'; ppzw\/
15 7415445 54444¢4 ‘
' '“N»/ ,_¢‘ ' 1 154 /7>’)1,;/~0.@0'72»»& v
.5’/54154 141 745_1£._ 4 422/414 f M%MU/ pizza

1 way