Court Opinion

ID: 4134227
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2017-02-18 01:47:42.095876+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:36:53.627637
License: Public Domain

Honorable Robert R. Barton
District Attorney
Second Judicial District
Kerrville, Texas 78028
                             Opinion No. M-440

                             RE:    Whether a conditional
                                    sale contract consti-
                                    tutes a "security in-
                                    terest in writing"
                                    under 4 V.T.C.A., Bus.
Dear Mr. Barton:                    & C., Sec. 25.02.

        Your opinion request to this office asks "whether
a conditional sale contract or a retail installment con-
tract, under the terms of which the seller retains title
to personal property, constitutes a 'security interest in
writing' so that, should the purchaser of the property
remove or fraudulently dispose of same, there is a vio-
lation of Section 25.02, Business and Commerce Code."
Since your question refers to the Business and Commerce
Code, we will assume for the purpose of this opinion that
the conditional sale contract or retail installment con-
tract to which you referred was executed after the effec-
tive date of the Code and is otherwise in compliance with
the provisions thereof.

        Section 25.02, Business and Commerce Code, which
became effective on September 1, 1967, provides that

           "(a) A person who has given a
           security interest in writing on
           personal property or a growing
           crop of farm produce may not,
           with intent to defraud the se-
           cured party,
                 (1) remove the property
           or crop from the county in which
           the property or crop was located
           when the security interest at-
           tached:
                 (2) sell the property or
           crop; or
                 (3) otherwise dispose of

                         - 2185 -
Honorable Robert R. Barton, page 2, (M-440 )

            of the property or crop.”

          The Business and Commerce Code superseded existing
legislation dealing with such security devices as chattel
mortgages,   conditional sales, trust receipts, and factor's
liens. Gone are the definitional difficulties and trans-
actional fictions of the chattel mortgage,   the conditional
sale, the trust receipt.    In their stead is a general set
of rules for the creation   of a security interest in the se-
cured party. Therefore, to answer your question, the pro-
visions of the Code that are pertinent to your question
must be examined.

        Texas Business and Commerce Code, Sec. 1.201 (37),
states that:

            "'Security interest' means an in-
            terest in personal property or
            fixtures which secures payment
            or performance of an obligation.
            The retention or reservation of
            title by a seller of goods not-
            withstanding shipment or de-
            livery to the buyer (Section 2.401)
            is limited in effect to a reser-
            vation of a 'security interest.'"

          Texas Business and Commerce Code, Section 9.202
states:

            "Each provision of this chapter
            with regard to rights, obliga-
            tions and remedies applies whether
            title to collateral is in the se-
            cured party or in the debtor."

        Therefore, it is the opinion of this office that a
conditional sale contract or retail installment contract,
under the terms of which the seller retains title to per-
sonal property, constitites a "security interest in writing",
so that, should the purchaser of the property remove or
fraudulently dispose of same, there is a violation of Section
25.02, Business and Commerce Code.

                          -   2186 -
  ,   I

Honorable Robert R. Barton, page 3, (M-440 )

                             SUMMARY

             A conditional sale contract or a re-
          tail installment contract, under the
          terms of which the seller retains title
          to personal property, constitutes a 'se-
          curity interest in writing' so that,
          should the purchaser of the property re-
          move or fraudulently dispose of same,
          there is a violation of Section 25.02,
          Business and Commerce Code.

                               Verfiruly   yours,

Prepared by Dunklin Sullivan
Assistant Attorney General

APPROVED:

OPINION COMMITTEE:
Kerns Taylor, Chairman
George M. Kelton, Vice-Chairman

Roy W. Mouer
Ed Esguival
Malcolm Quick
Harold Kennedy

W. V. GEPPERT
Staff Legal Assistant

HAWTHORNE PHILLIPS
Executive Assistant

                          - 2187 -