Court Opinion

ID: 9808732
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2023-08-31 20:48:27.032195+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:17:54.730601
License: Public Domain

*405Stacy, C. J.,
dissenting: I think the question of jurisdiction over the subject of the action is properly presented by the defendant’s demurrer and should be decided, even though it challenges the validity of the statute which confers civil jurisdiction on the General County Court of Buncombe County. Williams v. Williams, 188 N. C., 728, 125 S. E., 482; Provision Co. v. Daves, 190 N. C., 7, 128 S. E., 593; McIntosh’s N. C. P. & P., pp. 56 and 448; Clark on Code Pleading, 358. See, also, Motor Co. v. Reaves, 184 N. C., 260, 114 S. E., 175. But in deference to the contrary view of the majority, I withhold any opinion on the validity of said statute.