Court Opinion

ID: 4042024
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:59:03.988342+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:38:45.379022
License: Public Domain

~:'

                                                                    • .Iu ~t.              Loud      J Lc:M~~o.\ ot Affeo.\~ of .Te.x:u-:.
                                                                    • f.o. ~c.1-      lZ.~o~ Co.~~\~\ '"'Yht\\(.,t-\
                                                                    o   f\u~t·.r..\, Tel(~S l~ll\

                           No±;< e.          MJ.d   Se.c.u:u_    J AH\~c.a.f:.li~ fc. -\:: tc.u                        This document contains some
                              Ft>r \A.h a     A~ MaN An Mll ~                                                          pages ~hat are of poor qualitlf
                                                                                                                       at the t1me of imaging.
         ""t, The.. l-\c~ofa.\,le..      .JuJ. ~e_(")) o-\- fut.. o.bo\lf.         ~a;c!   Lotilt:   t-.....\oi:~Li.   ON.(\    ~~\"~ce..
 ('.) hdt.~'l      ~~\lt.u aucl. MaAL- -\-~c.Lt -t\tu__ o.-t-\:o.t.hl.d ~\,a                 c\   N\.o.t>idoo.mus tlr-ld (\J\o+~o~
 Fo, Lc.a.~t.    ·\-o   E \.t..   hos be..~i\1. .\-;\t.A ~u tht.. Ccu,{ o~ L\~\~lt.i.~\               A. ff~.a.\<:.    0.   ~ 0.~1\.\."l-t
 'Stl~d' Au.-thor~ti           tcH
                          -C-14\~N- ~ -\:o f~, ~c< M M•~:~-t<..t ~c..\ Du.t:<.s uud.( c 1\..(=\: ._\(.__ \\ .() 1
. ~CL. ~ t.t-~·e}\ .. f-..u\c 2ol U.').c'\.wt 1tx.. ~->Jf E.y:ckw.<.!. nut\ ( odt..ot 'Jud~L~a.\
 Lo~ciu£..-t LO.N.o~ ~-CJ· (8) o.\uu\. w>t~--.                                                           .
         '\tc (\.u.\.<..''~ et Lo~ut'"::. \loL _\_. ~ ~\-n-\-e.. ~ .. . R.u.\~-::. e>\ A.\f<:..llo.te.. f{cc..eJur<. /RECE~\/f[)JWJ
 .f.\ Q, Loud: ~~o.\\ (t~:::.c\\lL dill~ l~~U<-"') ·-\he~.t L.c::.u\-\ ~                   na.
      +~md-1 de:-:'11\lu:t.e.J to( (t.":.t>\.u:\:~ol>.i. A-Mi. Mot~ol\1 tee t.'Lte.\-\~ic.~ c~ +~ML Mu<:.t ~e_
      -f~lt.ci ~M tht. Lc~.Ht u\. Lt~N\it..~.o.\ 1\ffc.ab ~<..~o((_ +~L <.i.~~\0.-\:~oN cf fuL. l~O An.i
       eu~ed.

                          0
        M.a:l td ou       0
                                         /           I
            ·i.
•·   ..      'i   '

                                                I~ l"C Leur+ of Lc:m:~ .. \ ~~fco.h
                                                               ~+- \c..x.o.~

                                                       We~*         ....\o. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _..;...

                                                     MIL h<\.t. \ \.Jho.lc..Y "* bt\~~~ ~
                                                       ~L\o:\:o(     o     1\t'f\~L.tu.L-\:-

                                                                    \1.

                                                 Jua'\~. ~.D.f:Jo~ \2.00~ La.e~t-cl ~to.t~c\.1, {\...u~~:t-i.k~u~ lt)7l\
                                                     Luul-\-   ot    L\~MI.N.o.\ ot 1\.U.:.o..\s of- \e..ti.S

           ~L~t.rl. 4:-:. Ce:.uct lr-\ a M.ct~cM tor Le.a.\k. to ElL Q /o.M De~ ':\IMC1l 1\ff'Lc..o.t~uJ
           .C.oc \k)t:t ct 1\l\llt-.lda.MU":. tn.M The.. Louvt c.\ Lc-.N\~t.ul\ c.+ 1\ffe. Lo.e~hl "S,-tc.l-\~ct-1, f\\l~t; ...L Te..to.-> 1~1l\
              Wr~-t est \-\o.bu':i Lc.l Pu."l Lo.u.se. 1--\u..mbu :

          ·-r. Lt. 1--lo. Wct\-tt"~6tt\·~ (G). w(Z.-')t3~~,2~
           Tt.    Lt. ~o. W ~l.- 'jlo~\17 ·· s (_f). ~\ R..- '3l\. ~1\'S- 2.. '-1
                      '    '
           Tr. Lt.             ~o.   W '\~- ul'l'b~·~ (_f).               w~- -~'\. ::> P(cLt.<.di~-L'L K.u.\.e... 1.ol CD] K.<...\ll~Us o.. Lt>ur+
           '1\tnll -\-a.k.L 'Jud~L~d.\ 1-.\ot\U. I~ rt.tu.tshci ~i o.. Ftl(t-( d.N..d ~uH\~td w\~ t\te_
           1-lU.:.t.'Y:.Cld 1&-L{C>\'N\a.+:llt!."Tn.~~ \~ 6.. M.n~Jutud c\u.ti ot fuL tou\t. lol (c..'] C.t-.Lt~-\\(.~
           D.. VcK\:1 -'\::"' he htl.Lc-A uQeu -t~Me.l-1 H. 'tu    fe o.""::CII-lCl~lt..
  l~~fu.h_ w~~'-h l~ ~o.lHo.\\1 k~owu (\.\~-\h~b-1 ~t -1-di.,h,~o.\ iur~~ ~~L\-:~~ o~
  1-hf-. +r~nl L. (\urt wk~:.~ (}.({ Ln.fo. b\e "-\- ( tnAi o.~A 0.<-<.ur().t<-. dLte. fN\.I:~crt~~t-1                                                        bi
   \t.'::lor+ h ~QLHle.') w\\o~t o..ccuco.c'l Cat-1 \.le.t bL ,\euS.Mlo.\o\.'1 'l.IJ.< ~\-~ eHILt.e..c\~M~ \ 0.'-ld Kt:.-:.eouc\.~t-\:-\ 1uc\.~t. \\Q~                                        ~(._tu:~{d. +(>
     e..cu:tuta.<.t-.1 ~ll-~d Md~o\..L                  rue
                                                \\le').(_ \(~~61-.\.'S.. 0..\\1\.C>~~-::.-t t~~'S.<- e:,-\-~~\'S>
                                                                                              I

      'M.t.t..\+~~t.!.tJ 1.~ -t\te £.i-\-·hu_hed Mo~do.M.u'S f<..-t-~-\-:6~.

( j_) Whe.~.~ 0M-e.. \ ~ hdA ~"" Lu~-\c.d '( Ut>lc\.t.r L~P\u~\.1-\- llt.l~ ~{_~l~ re.\e.c.~t_ \:d ha. \o-uts
      Leduc:.,~\- \.-:. \~ C.uM \-.>e.\1-\ d.fo\.1 -"'.t.. ""'l:.-\~-t<- -h. l.t.rt.;c AulL 0.. ~atu ~t ~~M. lie\ e._(
        Su{tL~t.~-\              e.\l~c\c.tC:l\ ~.w. U ?:,'to. ~'\1 (\n.Lt. ~H. l\~G~.
         fleaS<. su. ~tJ.dt.r 'J. ~\a-k. '1':J'D ~-W. 'l~ 'L 18. (T-u... L\. P..~t l\~~ ).
         fiLIISe 'Se.<. D.o.-.t~~ \1. ~\-~-\:<., 11~ ~-W.'Ld <\.o'-\.~Mo l\e'&..f\n.·~L.r-\:Wcct~ l~~'\.ec.i:. ~raM-hd)
        flttt'J{ sec               El-.l~dl.~l\\~ \J.. ~tah."l~o~.w.U u3                                      (1-~:'l.Lt.l\n \'\b~)

. \L\.) kc ~lAe.5 1\H. f1cc. ~u\es 'So (4): Bm~\<-w \~                                              t.N.   o.te(_t\a.~-\ -\--o "S.tL -+~u+
    ~u.-\.t~L~u1-\ ft.Cutd l">. er-t..~iJ.-\--td -\-u ~UuW -f.Hc.(                           (-e_   '\U~t~~~ (NH5G.\.
        Je~. hu\-e~ A.u. frK. t..u.\.e...:~ ~{) (J), e.-.)~ ll<-.):. t\(k\\o.~-\                                     \\11":>   do.H *u ~\t.-t<.c\- (<.l<>rcl
    nt..tc\ br~N.~ ·1.-\- -\crwnn\ ~M ( ou.t\- .e\- i\ee{C-\.\-:. \e.\l~e.w.
    \/t.nle;~\ f\..t.l~.·\-e;... C.L.t Cld:-s.. jh.zz..,"J~.l'L §(o \Lull<>.;s.I\.N.t-..\.·-:ru.. C..et.l~:\-.
    1\d·.\ § \o~ U.~.l:. 1\. l.c»~±. 1\rn-~:-N.d':::. . "2l. kd4: t\<--\:-t.UV\lN.o.t.:Q.\1                                    h-t \na.t.iuc\.~t. o~
    \l<>\u~\a\~t-ltS~ cJ QLLU<:.e.c\.'s ( ()1\.ltc_'S~\()t-..\ ~t~l)( h ~\~ o.c\M~-:-":.~6~ \.~-\-1:> e'IL~de.~lt
    l":\ both           lot-l-:::.-\::tut~o..W.\ nt-id. ~-hx\u:\:()Ci        H..'\U.~~t:..Mud· O.M.d rf\u"'::t\ot..Mil.t-!~~e.~-\:
     0~ (Ltof£L t"-t.. lt.\a:\o<                    N\b\.1.!':.   .fu~~ t.Du~-\: ~(o..\-.1.\- ~~'S. ("(\<:iTtt.\U. ~c( .Ltn.\lt:.. +o
     ~~le.     CalA      ~~~ll(.   (\   W(-~-\   cJ Mc.u..~do.MI.l~.
          \v.l~-t_((.t6rt. uPc~ C\.\.\              \'SSU.:tS      r(t~e.-.1-\:-ed
                                                                  C.ou~l.c.\u~~ -\-\t(. t(.\o.tc{ (u).--1 ~oA­
                                                                                     Cb.ld
   t"-~-:- Lou~-\ ~{ ~+ --\\\~~ M.c-\~ ()~ O.t-ld. \.N.~ttud -\\t... L\ul. h c.\<~oL~t.t -tht. c ~~<-
   £1.-.!A cuhx ~(. ~~()\ld.u.L-\ h. t~ \.{.. f\ I A~ O.t..\. ~\IJU ·h) fuc.. w~~\ o\- 1\1\a.N.d..a.mu:.
   ~th-\:-~oU.
                                                                   "-fcu<<:.      Re"'.f~ct+\l\l-t ,
                                                                   AuwJid~

  ~t. it   re.ri\t.n'\bt..(el +ho..+    oll.l -\-he. bt.\cw j~\lc.~ d.n.tc +ht. t.do.h./., Mc-,-\-~L'>~
 ~()( Lel.UR.    +I>   ElL   4.L a.tto.c..hul    W\~\- c' Mo.-..l.d.ll.rou<.. wo.<::.          bu>.ut<..!.
 T\\L dc.:dk     ct ..fu:s   U..ur-\- ~ouctt.t.l.+
                                                                               ()\>1.   1\tL
 Iu-::.·hULti.u.'\ 'rt~nl /~o' ·h, ~-.l<- {\ /Ai.i o.N.~WC..v w~th~~ 'LG \o\1~~1..\.tS<:, da.'l-:,.
 ~ft~l'\'\ ..fut £ktL c~ -fu~":)       L6Utt\   c;;.{c\.c..{.

  DatL! · - - - - - - - - - - - -
                             ----·
                             .ll\l            l\\e_ Cell{+ ct (_c~M~t\.\ut AHe._a\"J
                                                 c.t    ~$..(). s

                               V.-h~t "-\ (). - - - - - - - - - -

                             f\A~~_~a.~l!A.\ha.lcf ~ (o~~ ~ '3 3
                                 klo.-tc.c

                                                        v.

 ~Ltt.tt.. +h•s L()Q{t llo.l {\ w{~-\: (>t 1\J\.o.uJ.o.mQ-:,            ttc..\\1\.   +~e.. Lc.utt cJ Lt~m~..t1H.
 W{;tc~ l-\r.tbtlL!> Lc<~Ll~ fcoLt.e..d.~t-~.'\ Lllu.s~ \\lo.Tc.c"\. &J~'I.l--2A. t-.\o.\t.l-\..M.o.'\:S-Oll\.UC-~ (f),
 w(l- -~'\ .lct~- z.s .

                         far-\-~t.':>      +o -th~<:.   ftv cu.d~u. ~     cu-ld
                             Jf•c:..~c;.~ L_/t{.'}t.N,iA-\'~pr.l

( t.) le..lator ! M ~'- ha.d Who.ld -'" bl\~ ~ ~ ~
                 3Sll.1 '.::!·L Hw'l ~ tb
                 t-.hw ~u")tt:.~-i..l~ lJJ1b
                    ~-1.u.

(I.) ~g~foud.t.t.d JLlci.5<..: l-\.ouofu~lt.. 'TuJ.'!t.(-;,) of Cuud o~ Lt~N\.~IIlo.\ o~ 1\(Pc.o.h c\ l·nt.l:S
                                      f.o.6o'i.l'L.j(.)~        Lo.fihl         ~tel'"\-~~~~
                                        1\~t~~. lu.u.-:.     L 'blll

                                                               M ~ u-\       ( ~i. ...,..__....5""----
       ( ~-) ~toh.Mt....\+ o·\ Ju\~~A~'--\:~c~ ". Clt (~. (o
        (toJ -~ta·h:.me. . .\+ c\- Ca.":~<.·., u-t f~. {o
        (1J I ~~u.~ c;, ~r c~u\t-t.d : u.-t f ~. (o
        (B.) ~to.h.Me..M+ o\. t="a.c.:h ktof fof~te.c\ w~-\-h J\( ~U.W\tMf-                      ClMJ
                                                                                                                                  ]-q_
                                                                                                        e\.Ll+hc.\>\-~e.S :at~~---'----~
        (t) fred c..( tQ( MauAa.l\'\u~ ~e.\~S: o.+ f~. _q..l--_
       ( \().) \/e..ci~~Lc..-\-:c"l<:.: '1.\t (~.       \ ()
        ( \1.} Le d-1~~ t    Ci\t<..   o~ ~e.~ \1 *'<-<- •• u-\ ~~ . to

                                                                    J[.
                                               ---LJ.u ot A.utb<:>(~±;t.~
      ( \,J ~e.Udt{          \J. ~hc\:t., 1:;~ ~-W-1...d 2.78
       (f..) DbWJ.cl~ \1.       ~mah. ctI ~-Lt. (\(_ \\ at ll\. 'l~
       ('3.) Lcdt.. ot- Jud:c:...1.o.l Co~-.~ dud C.ut.le:.t-1 ~- 6-l~)
      ( '\..) Da.\1~<;. \l. ~-tu.-t-L.. ll-~ ~-W. LJ ll(A, t{o (G.
      ('S.)[j,l~(._lL""-~ \l. ~to.-tf-, '1~0 ~-W.td tl~
      (£D.) [ 1-. ~e~.t-\:~ W~l\la.M":>, £:.::,.'-\..01! o.N   Lc.~J.\l:L-tetl ..Lt-1              Di:-:.h~d
                                                                  Lcud- Dol..\.a..-:. LuuM.\i; Tcxa":l Z..Bl.Md.
                                                              lkc._
         ·ju.J.~uo.\ ~:~~c~L-t, fc.r Ln.u.<:.e.. t-lo. \l-ll":J<>Ll\, 6...\o. '\.1_- ~lol\.1'7. t-l.,L '\.2..-~lo'\.~l,
          ~().'\~-CJt't~,~- ~e..~+                     f<.ffi.<.M\:H.\ed       .tho:\: ot-1 ~L   <\:t\-t. c.\-   1ul\l.<.., i\.O.l\~~
          -the..   CJ.\o~\l.e. e...t-.t:t~tld cu..ul UUMbHt'cl               Lru.l...)L   Co.M<.. c~   tO(       ~Ul{~\-l ~ \o~-CofL -t~L
          \-\.~;~'fo.blt. kM Pr~LC_, Juc}.~e_ o~ -t\H. 1..~LMIL Juc!:L~a\ U~-:>-t~Lt..-\- Lour+ ot Gnlli'A":>
           Cc.ul\1-\:i,\-tus \J.j~-t\\.~.~u.-t tA ~Q('(. lHJ.d e\oU. td~u~'\ WC..\(. 't\e..\cla.~ ~()l\ow'c:

        br'>± L-su.<. P('<.~e.l-o.\.hd: ·r\\at ~-dator ~~l-ee\. o. 'f\A()t~o~ to( Tuc\~(..~o.\ N.~\:~Le. o~
        L\tl~ucl:ul--\::~\1<... Fdt.b atuc\. befot"-\-u.~~\:i -1-u be.. \u.a:rd w~-\h. ~L c..lo..~M et'
        "!-...\~> E\l~d.t.t-lLt ·~ o.r \ul~J. ~ \l~o\.o:-\:~u~ c~ \lt.o..\bhl."\ 1\~~.\tc (..(.f. 0.~-\. l.lj.

       :)t.Lo!J.d        I   ":-;SU.t.   L'!.) ect.";)t..~ted ~   'T \.i t..tte.<..t~\le.
                                                                     f\~~~-::..-\a.~LC. 0~ Lt>Ut..~~d \c>'i wo.--l <)~                  '

       ~rt..~U.d\c..<. w~\L\t l~ c.. \l~o~-t~c\..1 o~ ~<.. lo~. L"';)~l--t~J A.\'\J\t.t-LClMel.lt e\- ~L
       LoM st: tu.-t~()l.l c+ 4.L UJU.~ h~d. ~\~-t-t-:. o\- C\N\u ~<..a. • \() \o~~l-1 ~ .\-Clu.\-\:\t -t~c...
        tu.e..~t~ol\11\lGI..~ff- wh-t +l"LL lLlo...-\:cr Lcul\l~t..\o( 1'-lt..\1.-t( d~c\ <1\ ~~e. To ~(t..~f..l\\.t -th:~
       ,, W..o E\J~dH1C.t." c....\a~I\A du\LIU. ~ *"L tc~a.\ r,Dr +\-uuu1n -t-\tt. 1\.H~a.\ e(cU.'S~ 1
....
                                                                              -~.

          ~±n---\~e_t.\..-!C:. c\- ta.ct-:. lw.Lot ~cfa-\:e.d w'i.th f\{~umu.1t\. o~d t\u.+hcr~t~c')
        fro~~ fi,'-'+ al-l& ~aoi\Lci I"!l~ut.s €H-::.'-t..\td :

            1h'- kla+o<"' .tiled               CA.   Mc>tt..tJ     to(
                                                              ""Ju&~t.~o.\ ~~\:~u. e\ l\a.1ud.~<-ct\.~\.\t. to.c\-'5
        llUJ.    offot-\:ut-.(,1:-/ ·to ~e,. \\e.O..t'd ~U.(~Llo.u4- h lu\.c. 'til\ Rt fue.. \u. !l.'> (u\(_";, o±
        E\l~d.<..~lt.. -tht... le.lo.·h~' Cotl-.l-\S h fuc.. ~\:o.-\:c..mt.N.·h ot ~~<...1:-s ~c\ ·Tr~o.\ +fo.~c:.u~qt-:,.
                         1

        of LCill':lc.. ~uM.~t..(~ wh~o:..h VlL wo.~ (otJ-\l~dt:d. c__\.t.a.rli t_~f\a~u~:     1
                                                                   .                                                            _,.-             .

          ~f..  Le.cL\: c..a.te.. ot tl.~c(\:-t_( I \rJ(>.·( tJ~ \-\.. D\M-:.-td. (_(_ t I 1. ~ LucL l~ u,t(_~£1.\
         "b\~\-t~'"t Couc-l- / tr<1~\.. 'c_\uw\t.-1 Lc:.uth llu~\J~t.~. '\ i D u.\.lo.c:., Tt..~Cl. s /T<.\d 'tta..t_<. ~
           l.lll {in~~-'S~'S) / Lu\-·.tc:e~.\:c. ~c.. i.'l31D J £~\li(~-\':uu Otlh.: i2. /)l Itt~
           e~.~~ t:Qv~ *H.~l'L.{\:l'?l                                 ~a.-~~.
            '':I. t.LC-t\tt.c           --\-k* ~~"!~ -ha.u":.U~fh't.u o~ ~c... ~tot.H.J.~I-l~S -\-,u.l-1 0.."-lcl
                                       Ctd::.\i
            LoHt.t.-t\.1 re..~\u.-\:~ ~<. tlC.\\~~~\-:5, ;~Au'"/, ~At.ut:-kd. tt~d lo.r adM~**"ed ~-1
             ~ e. ~~~:·he s ."
                         ~L\a:\:o< Mc.-J.ed to( ~c.. lZ.t~l~:>\1..1. c\t\.l-\ ,\u.J.k -\-.., ta.~t. ~u.c\.~~~c:\.\ ~ 6-h: t.-e..
                    "Kt...
                 ~a-t 1:-\\.L "S.h1~L'\\\t~t o\ t~l'h l1t-~-c\. h~o.\. ·hc:u.i<:.U~C'·h n..tL 1-l~t ~u.~~t.d -t"c
             H_Q)e.IJ.o.~le. d~~~u~L O.t-l.A \.":. C..~fo.\J~L \-o C\.t.l.u.(c."tt_ B.t-.td \fdd'i de-\:eiM~...Iut~c.ll..l a.l\icl
                ·~ ·h:d.\ -\tc:nJ.":L\~I2b o.t-.ld ~\u:\:tMta-.L.-t e~ ~o.ct"S. · o.                        ')uu.ccc..   w~t.'l<- u.tC:ur o.L i ( autJ.d
                tta.sc.uo.~~-"1       b{..    C\U e'Shc:,l\.\fd .. lhe.. tt~ft.l..t clt.u.-\ T"'-J..~L         H. \u. 'i(."" ku t'a. "-.t. J....d~u'o..\ 1'\1~">-\-:u~.

                bLLa.u"'l.t.. ~~ ~t":>CM.i.t~Le. that ~\e...
             Teta'> Cod(             C_c\iv\.        ~{CL.lll-k. 'L6.lct, Z.O.t.o. tu.to.tL a.ud to . .z.:l._Ltecrtcs ~{~-t~:.ch!
           \1k\\d ll-.l.telt.'.:>h i--o ~n.~L ~llll(~ ().1a.~t.l\:\- f.l"\t\ltJ.
           \tt~~£>\l.At.\1.1.-\- JU£\~(. -\-e~ to..\.t. J\Ul~c~ul Ulit~t.t. o~ .fut. .\-c.\lc.w\1-1 \ ( ::) :
       ( \J \\tul.:\: l_0.l3. ot +hL Ttt. ( c.Ac Ct:oo. rf{)L. frc.\l~dO -fuc.d: ,, A+tu al\ -'ciAt. -te -::,-t~~'\OIJ.i
           w~\L~ \"' t.H.LtS'S,~Ic\.L t .. *'"L Gftlt..~.d JLltL ~\\11~\ ~t.. to.lt..t o.~ h ~L P1e ~Ku\:1\\etJ.-t               cuJ.             c.t
           \t-ic\.~L-\ 'i\\t.ioi..-\. C\.t-J.d I.~ U~l'\lc... Mt.M 'ot.r~ Lcll\.\lUr ~u .\-i.Nd~N. ~ -\\tc LJ ~ \\, +~t.
           FMt.ffillM        ":::.~o.l\ 1\'\a.~e.    C\.   MUII\O(O.tJ.ALln\ ot -\-~c... ~O.ffiL wah ~u~:..'-". duta. 0.~                    wH\
                                                                                                                                                       11
            t.Ua ~lt    -\~e. a:\:\oo.l.d whc                    {dH. \t.u-\ ':. +'ne.. ~ro.·h +b \1.:)\~·h. ~t.. tt-1c:\:Lt ffi.u.l*,
                                        h
            ''1\lu b.Hd<.•-HL                vJO..)        frt"::luJ..ttA~ -\-hu-\ wo.~ a.<..(C..J:)~~A<.. +u ~e. ~n:uuci ""fur-<.
           l.M -\\t~') LCi":lL ~~ lt.c..crA ~'ttc.w                      4-\-.o.-t   u:~..~.e.. McM~tC':.I (>~ Gra.t-~~ ,ku-1   a.-J     1-lut       (.or-L(Vl(

            itJ. ~ltJ.t\.\~ ~ t\\L       tJ: l\.
,,..,

        (z.) ~c.d 1._0.1D o.f: Te1t. Led<. Cr~m.fco<.. frc.\I~J.{.':l ~o.+!
                    " -n:.L A--tton~d IZ.-c..ft"t '\c.w:\~~~ ~ -t\te__ ~·\:a.'\::e_ ~"o.l\ ef(_\)O.H.. o.\l ll\.\d~Ltf~\£t..\+:::.
              wh\~h ho..\L{. be..c..t..l +.ou1.1t1 w~H\ ll"=> kt-tk. ddo.-1 11 '::> fo~S~IolL, £1'-l.d c\t.\~\!u +~t.ro.
              +o -1.-~t... Fct"e.N\.o.IJ, whL, 'S.h6.ll -:-:,~~M +\\e.__ ~o.M.t. off~t.',a\l~, lli.iA ~a\c\ a.Hc.n.H.i ~\\a.\\
              {.t.lcl.::.r~e. -f-h-utcl.l -+h.t. 1-lo.Mt...":: c~ fut- WH~t':>~~ S U~ot..l. w~c +-{.";:.\'~n\e:.u-1 WO. ~ ~OllMO _''-
                tJut 4a:t .fut. lucre\ l.to.~. -fu~s <..o.~t. ~ht>W +ha:t ~e.. D~~h~d· 1\1-t-bo.lt.~ -\--t ~-c.d u.r o.
                ~lfL~ o~ P11?t.c llt-ld lo.\Atd ;t o.l.i l.uc\..~dl'l\.<..t.~.t ~~ tctctl o.'.?~t.l\lt.L ot o. •.d o~ ofuo~C.
                 Q(oL·d.u.reo;. ll.l. 1.0.ll\ .. \1~<>\a:ho\J ef VuN,c.t.,,!> 1\w.».. ""'G:~.. L.Cf. !1(-\.\,\~.

        ( 6Jlhat lo.1.l                      fto\l;d.<.<:> :
                    "lUhlt.~ 4L l~cb"tMw-\- :-:. (fadi                       +()    bt.    frt~tu+-eA, ~L GratJrl Jur-I ~~aH +\uou~l.t
               +\tte..;l'" f"(LN\.a.t..~., D<-\~\lt.r        fuL lt..~.A~LtMui.{ to fit. Tud.'l.t
                                                                                              c_\uk e~ -lliL C.ou.r-\.
                                                                                                                    cr
               (\-\- le.A~t ~:o.lc Grc.11.\.~ Ju.\'l ffie.l\'\btJ<;. Mu~t be. Pe-t ~e.N..t ol\\ ~u<:.h . "- 1tiat ;t-~ -this
               L.o.H. (~) -4-hL \\.u.o(d ~hew -\h(.. Gra.ll..lJ Ju1'< M!M~as IA.Hl.':> fa~u.o.d(.. \o-1 fH. . .il.:ld.~c.e.

               -h,    Cle.L.t.ft   -\\t~!> ''Uofv'.Ac..Ul.t....'' ~uc.\"-.t411\o.l.:b,M               +\to:t       \~c    tDI(..M.O.o..i    ai-le\. ..t~l\lt_
                Mt..M\,u~ c\..c...\:c..\J.ttcd         4L l.~d.~ctV'<\u..l.f +o .fuc.. 7\uc:\..~<.           o-r   dul ot +~L <..ou.r+ .
                                                                                                                                                                  .'
         (':{ . )   ·~u.+     ?. O.'Ll.   ffo\I.~Je.) ! ·I~         fHt:t..\MOJ.-t fCLc+ . . lliL FuL+ of Col fft ~e.~h\ile.lll+ ot
             a~ l~ll~d:M.ru--t ~-1 o. Gul.l\id Jud ~\txull \oe.. C...t-.~.h.reJ u.(c,~ 4-ht. ;'V\.11\lu:h. -:. of th(_
            Lcur-t :\~u.-\: -the1.t tl>.l. ~~-:. c. oSL A. IP...tJ. ~ tl-£.. ~ct.l , l<.'\14.\ froL-edu.tt wu. ~ (c~ Auc...tt..d
            ·\.\ti.... ~Hod ~cue:.+ ~ ~uw -\hu-\ d Gro..tJ.d J'ud th.H~U. ':!h. -t\\~{ fu~-t.Ma.Jo.l c.\.d~t.ll-£..itd
             ~Ltllld~du\\uit w~-\-~\ o.-:\: leus.k r..i~l\.l.e. MeM~HS -t~e~t..·w~-.fu.
               ~e...::.fotoldu.l.~ . Ju.d.~e. ha.~ Cl.. M) r-l~"':>h\·~~l d.u..-li ut-~.d..e.r L~tl(_ of Judzdul c. <:.wcluvt l'....a.l\.lot-1
             ~·~·lt) h" ~-· ~t.<-o,-J: t'~:> e.\lt.r'I~U">ou \.U\\o \\u~ cdt.~tll ~~~ottULS-\- 1M d. ~fouc..J<.J.~~- . .
              \~~ (~~\\.~ -6 \IL \\et1.~ ClC.Cc:.t-t\~u 1\ +o lti.\. .J .......... ''

              -~~ ((..la.-1-o\"     (on'\elo.:l-l">     O\   0.\~Ue.~   4-l;..u-t   0-(-\-~~\t...   ll-01    e.4-. 'Se.~ O.t-.i~l f'-uk               'l. vl5e+-;

                                                  C....C.du...";) ft~oC..t..t.d~~~ • +o hL ~e.a.cc.\ ~u-\- ~~<, \~~\H· +<> ~~
          ~u-\ h\:~o 1!..~':1\\h ~~ o.. ~o.~·t£L":.
           ~-l'ilrd t..l.o~ ouli \L~ch.-te.~ ht-:. ('~~1.\..tc; utJ.dL\ \LOJ aud k..ule t..c-1 e..t . . ~d.. \out
           '             'l                    -
            ~~~-\:-uL1 ~ \<...L.~~cuA.u.1..-\- J~~t. ~c;, ~U '-l~c\o.-t~o\.1 cA L U.\.lc.\..1 ~· ~- (~) o.\ -1-\tt. L6~C":. _c.{
             Ju.d.~cio.\ u.udlli±,_ kle1.tol"" / ~H\ktu.£..+ af 1u<..S 1-\t.a.t thL ~u(rc..ffi{. Lc.uc-\ c.-t
             +ht. llu~{fd -:.\tn.h"i hdd fuo.t A. I AoJ ef~~61-\.H hl1<.:. £1\cl;;lc-ll..ltf... f;, ,,\.f tc
           ''tU.t..\Ut~.i::C (t.-\-u.:\~\le... o.ucl Mco.vJ.~M~~u\ D.CU~j ko                     t'ac.. Lou.\'\") -\-., Lino..l\e~-t~c..
              1\(...:c L.bu\l.'ct~o!J.":." 'luct~i-l ~. f)outJ.ci~                   \L.   S>roLf\tt, <(,] "d.c:.t. liH dl liD o.t.J.ci -t~o.t
             i't..~'-sta.oo\:t. ( Cll\uJ c-\: \'d:aL Cl:\'L a'~u~ i\.1 ~+ ~ \~ ~c\...lt\S              \.M    H:t..~ C...~'::.~N.. ':1   -\:'n L   C.. cU.~-\:~ \-u.t ~ (ltJ..O.. \
             ~~~h-\- tCl Q.(.(..t_~j      -\--.,   -t\H. Loo\-\') ,, '\.U.~>{i.IU"l •. ~Cl\-\-\x. Lo.sc,\~N.O.. \I. et.Q.\C.t, ~15 ~
            1ll. 7t.S._
           -~'- ~da·h-.r· Ccmfla.~~-. -tha.t -&c..                          t .-:.ect.lclt.tu+\ a.c.f.t>t.i<. ht--~a.Lt:ol\1~          L.:.m.fla;N.d
       e\ \iiolc.d:c; h~s \=i~"::.t ( btJ o.tud te:.u.( -\:u.u.~h ( \.l\.1:kl ~mc..r-~t\.Mt_t-~--\- ~~'.1\\:\::s o.(:                             fu<-
       Ut.l~ttc\ ~tu.·hs Lo~"::.f,·h~-\:~e:.l\1 o.\.id -tho.-t lt..";)e<:>~o~..d..urt c..\o.~l\'\d o~ i~o.~ach"c.tJ.') o.(~
       \   L-t-o..\to..t~oi'J /l.~o.l"l"::.+ 'n~M ~~>( f.MXC"2:.~ 1-l~ \\~~ U\.i.C,.\~tut~ ~l>l9-\ (·~ ~"-\- c.~                     C\(le_")')   +o
       --h.    c_   ou.d· . l"- L lt~ (o,-l£iul.t           u.>   ~Ll t ~~t~l.lU..<- t<..~u.:l>.:-IJ.~ -h. ~-t< ~fM V\1. '5.

    f\A.it-.l~~t   ~6\\.(oWl~ ':! ~
           Wh.c..Ct.Jctt.r U~o\l all {H_ (\\~';)(. ";) Coi\.\C.:.LJei d. :
            Trli f\ulo nU~~th \lol I..- "::>tct\{.. .... _w~ o__t_,A.frc..l\u.·\:c.               _                          fcKec\u\t.      (f(<>(te.d~N. ~ s
    .iu +nc. ( we\ d- ( t~ffi.\1\).ql 1\.Ht.cU') h.llle.. T~.') lZmc r(O.Q\( tO(                                              ~{_ "'.:\r,lu+~c.\'.\-
    c!tf da~j\'\> lo.~~(_J ~~~ f\Cf\: .:.o.\~t>~ w\--\:\-.~1..\ \ <6D do.-I<;. tr~M ~L do:\:L                                     o~
    rt..lt.~d           c.t --llie.    a.Cf\;La.-t~c.~ ~i     --th<.. ~--te1.-\:e... l="il<-d ?_olt\ J~t-lt__ l\ • ~M ~:o7
   _~Q.C:{ FI±'Z. S\1'\j\I'Jlu~      D~s\-\~L-\- L \e.\ k. / C\o.llu<:> C..uLh-1--1-'f, l~'i.U. ";) .
                                             0"--l

    1--kc.. tcw\l:d,~u~ luuct ""::1\\o.H Ct_<::.oht(. C11\l'f \~"::1111:~ 4cd- --\-~t_ tuud---\\G.'\ +~Mt_\'/
     de.<:.i.':IMcrt<.d +cc (t~c.lut~ol>.\. 1\1>1.:-/ Mc--1-~C>I\I t~>t" (.'1..----tt.~'::.lo\..\ c~ -\-~M(. Mu"::.--t ~L~~ltd. \~
       -t-\--\t_ Leur+ o{-. (_~~Ml"N.~\ Mfc.tl\<:. b-e.\Cl(C.. -\~L t'k\\r~·\\'ot-.l o~ -\-h<.. \'tO do.-((--!>)
       Pu~cd           clo..-t-tcl.:     N\_a.f<:." (c, 'l...ul~- L-om--\ c~ Cc~M\~o.l t>--t 1\~f<..o..\')e-\-- '1--t!C..~~,
       B~-\-"'~:) c:\. G. -1 clu:\<-0-:              -z /uJ)
                                                     /t.clt\ (_·"fllli l.to.t.clLIJ --\---~e..oJCl;'-o.t~c~ .\-o(" \.\...o1
       Wf~--\-- u+ \-\.o.'bu'> Lc.b(c.U.~n-\- cu--t                \1-l
            --fu~-:. W~\--\-.
c~.) T\\o.-\- 1\ -t\1.~_ t(."':,~()t.l,<.\{.t.~.--\ ~iA;.l to:.        ( c.mel'{ oJ\t\       ~~":>llO.t..I.L<.   ct    (l   Wt;-\- o-\---1\llo.ud.aMU "::1
              lo-1 -fu~s c-.u(--\; -~o.---\: ~'\~"'> Luud- h~u--t.. Ck Wt\~ ct t\.G.~t.~t-S l.11\ ~u.S +u --\-~e.. 0~\ e.t.\1)\
              ot l . \) _ (_."J.--ltl ~d ---fuL&oo.\dct ~Md~l-l':. dl\ld~O..\c,\t__ ~u-:.-hu.L--\-~1-1"' ~Uo\ to
       'tmme.A C...uur--\: Gte1.1\l-\- -\--\\.L lL\o.--tl':lr / f\~~\~t..o.\.l--\ o.\.\ ct\\H le_\~e~-:. .fuo.-t \\e.'-::.
               .Lo.w\lll\.-1 <:..i-.l"\~iec\. to .

                                                                                   f~.      q 0~--
.
.:..   '
             >·

                                                                                Re;)fu.-t\ull-1           ~u~N\I·He.d,

                                                                                ~~"df'47-'dfj"
                                                                                M~c.:_hcu.l ~ (D't')~;,;j
                                                                                                   Who.ld
                                                                                                                              - - -

                                                                                 :~t~ '\ ~-t. ~wi -:\tq_~
                                                                                 U-tw ~o~h~.l'k "1'S"')1c
                                                                                      b.l.U.

           lh;-:.   (.,to \lui~i -t\-uli l\..,\u.-tor /A.erl~u.~~-t                   S.w!O.f       ~'/ f(l\lCl\-\-~ts ~(\(
           Pt.fjuo'· -fue14     -t\H..         lc ..li:(..ut-:. te-l +~~~ Ma~-.~do.mu.') ~t...·h·-\~c,~ l ~ +n.\.(._ CAtJ.d
           LO(H_d·.

                               3 /( D /~o;s
                                           I               /
                                                                                   M~.:..l-lo.d. W~kt ~ lo'-l.":) ~~ 3
                                                                                   j B\ f\Ut      C.di c.\ -t~L 1\l\.~->-\-~ot.l ~c.t .ltu.\le.. ft.~ tl.lL         thL
           Mo.tJ.6.a.mu<:. ~t:\:~1:-o\..\        Ull.).d   -~t. rf\a.l.ldo.CI'11l~ ee..-t~'\'~o~ -\-~o ofut. ~(."':.e~.:>1~de.1o1.t ~i
           P~a.<.~u.'1 ·fut.. ~o.rot.. l.t-.~. fu<... ll.S. ffi.o.~~~c.'( h-tH. .          i.IJ.   ~(~O:.eiJ. ~l\-~ eo~-\:o.':lt.. fo.•c\ Mo.~l-t.c.\
           ou ticth.d. : _ 3 I I o I 1...vt5
                                                r              1

                                                                                f~.     lO          cL___
                                                 I
                                                 I

3     a   tr~t    ao