Court Opinion

ID: 4048401
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:38:25.734522+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:26.750344
License: Public Domain

§§ wO'Y'O/
‘ §UL¢;, e~,-z@zs '

` HE@EWED BN
tim QAQL ll),~_,¢§‘[§ CL‘Q_VK coqu ne= cmmNALAPPEALS
` . l / jul 09 ZU§
963 B€~>x 41‘1.3€2% ` . `
D‘°°SH"‘ rT':' 1 P>" ll \n@mc@§ia,©€@r&¢

i?@_ s Rw»./»@M P\~ulem cia ’T,B»C;:\=' CIR idame 731311/
rimch n~¢" Ea)\~'#- m~@ Ma,¢uo(d.mu_`s/ -
jjle |71'{71\£§+\¢~¢`(‘:1 C©U\r-"" / /¥A_\r-Y~l:! @BQI\!E ;Qxé..$
, /
T§~¢`LL Cz\.u_$e. Numls~e_\» q‘-I`LL{®l-A.
nw A~<;c>§'i§_§ '
EM¢LQS<>.¢(/ lsLQS.se_-C.‘¢\ml .iqpp‘L£`ca_m~{-;~s ZQ~¢_‘B¢°M¢L .JL->:s.-_m.mé_e evil
mm\r`i¢mug. /IZ`L€. / Z\H‘Nj f'?"'=`/E‘fl.e>_ affem+¢é.:\£ e>-(l '/`kc>_ C:@,u\~{’.
Q-pp L.“Ld.\c~l~ :l`¢\.n "Hns pLLA.¢:L‘Mj fs a ix\~c>-..S¢>_ I(Ncl_.`ge~¥ :NMci`l`L
},§:?L`eu{- fi&., medium @-\O UCAane_ izi> page ~G¢.s_ 1"¢\~@_ -+€,L-‘/)\Q_ e-¢’

`H\Q;Lejaf_ r`us`/;»NMQM{¥ a_N/\Ie.)c dual Pmej.ff 'fb éz hL[sa.)c/_ 755 ,m~®- d
fiscal ;cu£@\ma [Rup€.h;s, '

_ Fd»#i\er/ ham`c~lj ue memus' eng PM¢`¢L"MB Cep.fes amf PLe_o.cLs'
`n»e, lion ilath C‘Le\/K 13
Ui\`€d log L.b.u_) ®V~ @\’"d~(’_j`¢\'f,é_b
MMV( gen P~®q- QIQQ\~ `h"me_,/ KIN~ pm¢¢a. ( v .;z:~ "ri»e. 4747¢. llz'fh‘¢,é
Ram@.-N R~mi@\lci§ t’_mn~‘\~ c»+" `
_ (f-)-ppL€c.a_N+] l-l~*a wis Cowu`§[ labs

l:x_s'cJANUL DC D.)%~H“ OC n\§NJnmLBS
i')')‘n`lc;md 75 @emfdel.. ?>.N.Cl C©WlpL_l{

E» Ti\e_~l-ic¢uwv-z>kLe lodge op TI"L<¢ C@civ#* of (’.\~i¢~n¢` NAL llpp€b»[.,$:

(’.om¢.>.$ N§us/ I}Bmc.>ru' phuclemé.lo" i iad L.¢.;L” Cld l\lum key 13232.1 (/JPPP

L:c'e.NH mud $~;Le.s 145 w\~t+@£`ma.wdamus a.~d shaw 7¢;<)_. BQLL.<»¢)¢N_§_

~\l supp®\v~l¢ of P._s issumu¢é.. q
\d- D.ML;WH ll LQ¢L§ Haa@a_¢, M,~H&M m umw Cw~l§,* L;AS ame,

dowd (’l\a\LLe,cw/»!g `H\e_ Lg§ol_¢°:g of ink C@N.Cudr'\e.\h(? due_°/b aty)e[_a.`/Z.. q;.
Om¢~.a.~spl_s Qa-.Lm-e.`fo advise kim o@ /'\£S v~j /nt' ib £T'.-Le. a pc{v~ sh"#o~v[ />.'5 --_

c\jvf:.a:" nppr kdi them LLP.NRA
'l\-`T\~e. amusec\ 1025 'H~.e_. végk%’i“o -('~`£i_.e_ a p¢;l\- (_9~¢~0»$€.,\ L;_M

 

=`?`\"' 13 "WL bpt\el_l.§ba. QEB<\.ESQ,L +B.ZLS 175 Z\Alié.§e¢`#»e_, a_cL&YBJ §§ I’\\;§
wig\& TbC€LQ_ a_ PA,\» CPm'Se.\ `N`e, Pv¢>{sex~ veL€_Q 15 4a §`~" L.Q. am au#-» @'(~`;

l \ _-
,, -11~§ ' -i ‘~ '

 
 

 

¢'/:)- ilPPL;Lka iM-& ec uaw @@»~PLS c`T.cc;A A»¢+ ¢c.m) ~P¢\» md 901-@41
,\ `h`MQ_ pd‘\- wm keepiqu /-F’:Le,cl am ol»-SS`»-LS" x l
5)° (I)M ‘z_*s»o\~l..$‘ ‘H\e, ("ou\-J'_sjg/~¢ed nn c»w.\e.v~ das;`gu§‘fu:l§ &PIM_LLS'{L, G,Q- §
. ume,L-ih C:Le, am dmicl'em~\‘ wZ{-Ku\£ 4\\`\’€~‘\3 (,Bb’\ day of“"¢l»<»»_ 3.-"3/\¢/‘~3
,_ DC suc,[\ m~ML’_LUS.-‘ew e>C Lz>w‘ mild has -@a¢|_e_cl +e
d germth `H\e uaw 40 `Huz.. C.@m-l 943 @.»~‘m¢“~al_ /-Hm€.hl.$; 55 of ‘H=.e._ 5'¢'-
gmmg o~C"H\£§ m‘a.u&amwsy
films wath 0.5&°`§“@»\&';5 |-Lemav~a.\nl.e., Ceuv{~ '."<'> :;npe>,$?_ ;é B.J'va-¢E/
ANA S>\'~Ae_\r~ `“r\e_, _di$`f'-¢`c_+ C.\>u\-+ 10 -Qm~u.>t>_\-A. I\ES' l-d~h.lne.h§ f%j?/'F¢{:»al ,

QM@/;@
Rambm 'MQMC§@ '°" 73231{`
C¢>T’¢`QLJ, UMFJ¢-
%(o( l:/VI Z&S`q
~ENM€SS€€. Cs£srgg/`/): 753@‘1'"56@0

Eie_u»`{?u!. //'S§ Me.:{_ @»¢\L `LLB [D~ZOlS

pm - sat DH»L¢;~;~#L