Court Opinion

ID: 4034838
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-19 09:17:39.52353+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:09:10.022279
License: Public Domain

~ \ck4.,_4 t) Dlf'f 11 .S d
            "' rr et\ 4,
                       Oc,r\

   v.

                     • d fftVID~ V/1                              df      PRiV/tJtJS FILLAI&j'JI'J/ANLONG~CLERK~o
                       J,pv&     C. ( ' , ' , , ' /   .fl/'eu.fiCt)<   .a¥1~ ~.:-u &>eohQ C' /'.ode;     }'f,tJ(}(/

    ~~~ll~f\.+/ {?tc.h.wd                   BaN'esot              ha_s.    rr-e.vfouslv     fd-eJ       -t-lw   c_u()Wt/t(j ~
   ...!) A~r~Hc.f\t-, lY\. k\'>                    ce o..l le.do...lc, "-l~5 atrud de.spl2f'cx.{Q. ..J2r
                                             ljYlOI'ttf\                                                                 6V~Y'.SjJd
"'8"'"~ t    llt<>l• {, ~"s by                 51M¥i-/lk.iNt'f uF 7/Jc:J/ ANIJ fe-I'SM" e/                              "'tf-l'iu/
t\A,\5 ~y -ftll~                +k','
                               (Jj                                                                 /
            U" $, Dts1f\fc.t (O-uV'4
            ~"V'f- h.o.-1'- It ~ t $ Jill cJ ;,..p 7~ Ci-S
               Mo~~               lOJVIS/0/f)                                           (t LV      ZSCl· 5'""5'00
             fC9,6a~ (,to tO
             tiuu~~ 11~ Q_5 t l z.C)Z>
   AN    ATTei11P7eD fhJ~JNOJ (J-11/ ~G &: A<- n fi-1£/Jc 7o
   A-SilL ft-CdStA /YJ /{ RJ~/11 r (t ~c P I /.tJ7) t-e f ~ 1 rtj "-<, eoN 11 t eft Nj
   CtJCJIJ-Yy     "'"J
                     deiiiIJY                               ~· 4 f7 -r£'1?..   Pct{Je For       T~t'P Jld7      t='.PFP'l-.J

     ~h~s-(klb..s. ~f-ed w..t-1-~ 3~{~ o-f 7-e~s a.~ Pe.PE' 11 cldt~-,_J
      CLVL       ~c:.A to"-. hvfll1h~v- H . . 13- 6 6 ( I
      'J ~A9 e t._ ~ ~ H ~ R".s -ef\. 'f.-"-ct.. (
      !;lts M lS 5eJ        14 ~"'< h I ( 1 '2._0 llj fi I111J he Re fur,~ J
                                   Prev 1 co u.-~     F, {t "'-[JJ f ~ 2.
   \k S'U.(;~          lv.l-o.s    "'"~        JI..SMtS5-eo( t:l.S       ..Pt..tVd     li!V;3       or   ~cc..(l crdcJ~

2)    Fd~J D€          c_   ~""" br-       $',   ?..i' I 'f
       (21 ~·"~~ ~ : f<, ~1\of B<'tl'l'dSO
       O-e{!~~+ ·. I "-e. $711-7/i. CJP 7/V:Jt-8 Q_t I                                   0..

        l N 71/-£. vN-trl!tJ s l/1-7~5 1}/STj;tcr c.ovllf
         <3 ~u -rtfIJ /:! N .(JIS7It~
         f/c:Jv S 7 (} A::J /J I f/ IS I O/()
          p..o. \3n 6ttJto                                                         (11~            2Sd- ss;-dcJ
         1-/-ou S 7tJA.J r 7Q..Xa..s                -r7       ·z.o ~
       C'tVll.       lk7oJIIJ         #    L(:/Jf-cv-o3S'IZ
       "TuJ8~ Na11 cy                     r.
                                     Ai /as.
     (h,ts case tu-a.t;. {r-a/1-.sfe~J ~o ·--1~ U. .J, /Jcs{ Gu,__{
      }Joll'ii\QN\. Ott.>ittlct ~ 7-o.-x ~~ t:t-11 ..,_~ e.P-1 e.Jtcy lnjf/11cltW'
Gfdel' to~ +iu. Covr--f 1u <1~"d e_r- ~~ s.Ja:_{~ af 7~,//7s /J-6;~c}'
'LIJCJ/ PQt~nll~l i--Attr~~ -l-o ceu.se. ,is cxc-ltcNLs {a olesiflet ~ 1-                     +.
        ~~ 1 "-~ ~flo~ ns ~~ ~ { ~s ltd'f-- d ts fllll t ss eel a. s f,... vo Iou--1 q.._,.                              fl'1...; f,  I 7 <#(._'6-Cf_S l 'i I d I
       C\\J·tL a_e._{(ClW           #      2! l/..i"       ~v ..... ~ "2. 5(0
       ·--r o. J.s ~ fVto..,...y   1-o u        R(7 ~ 11'1 so"
        Wts~usse.d w(+t,_av~                               fi'~JvJcc.P feht1vcv'''l
         fc,r     Rt /vf'-ll          io       C.. ~ o..vJ.et' ~ hct.l -f /,.Q    law                         lin &tty
    ~et~~ol pr"dpQf\- y 6~ ~f'Q_.S:f2t"li"€_J at-Lei 11.1-'~ cl.Qs}roy4>d1 y.J
    o\ ~ 1a Jl s ct ~ ·' ,~. ~ J I (! I r c v f/1;(_ s --\-«.rtc er ~ ~ttte ~J tere
   'V'rolOv~Co..A ~ Jl DlMis o-f S71f7!L 11-IJIJ F£;:J/f!21t-L t A-.u" 57R..cf) t(
                                                                                                                     1'\_

  ~ /'le~l1( ~ f'€..S('cntS~~ ftlo/                     back ve./ 1           'fft.t<;   Wd~    d(s #'IISS;J
  ( k~ qLlowt""] +~ s-k~~                               f.et'.SdYJIIEl.-( (   cf.,s.p ,4p jM[y>Uf ~/'{;
   ~~ f[at~ft'ff 1 ~lAe.-1-1 cr-ecL-W clacv~ ~ Qfl{~,.. evtdencf
    t4o cou./'--t r.J<~.Sonllef VJ_()._{. hell b.e.flJ Q":v} o/e_~Jf'd--y'lllJ
   't ht ~ f f-o p-ef\-1 y ca..c r ~ J IA 7d !l
                                          -Q.,                t
                                                .YI1 e a.s (/ ~ 'P !" c/J-r -e 'G .e_ ('-c I s I A_)
   1/'lij ~l-5 I ~o-v..e.lll11 ~ ct"cv JM.O-,Jr vJ- e f'{> {1_ {s 1 fc -eel ~
   fl'df~,4 7 o!<2.s.~"O-f~d )l}ltQltLtous~,
        --rk~.s C"-"-f ~s ~ ~" l/ he.1":5 J~f~J) 1 y~ ~ c i 1 s ~"Y
C'm.,; S d JII'Uh tty II- 1o {,_Jrt_.J a_;v,/ Ye r /- w I 11 .,,} <'ff It ~(,<4> ~
                                                                               J/t

o--1 {0-IJI 'I f Q.I"Sdl?ne-1 a_ I'7'!1, "-'-•'~ ~ rIIX/,.J PI's J I s I, I u,.., q J
                                                                                  J             0-                  11.

tfVI- ~" ,,__,        ,.:/-..s .fl,." 3 J.,._~ a.d ru er- ~ I tfd.o ,J,I r,la:t.. ~
                   Q.-w,:

 Jl.7 .r

 ali~bi~J peK::cm cac..ses tf)1.'jo/~ r1-eql~./ ~ /;J.,,.I,f'"l.rsf..t
 beL'3 p~d edJlnJ a-llo~cQ_ ~ k.t rui~c~ o~Ctl   h~A,..i1    7eKG..5         -z- ~ 1/1(/£/J /VtJ77C£ f!Jr CI//IAI~ C dF' Al)t)R.€S 3                              UJd
                                                                                                      Rt.s.ronse)
       i)ece.,.,~~f' &,,24,~ ~ecrvQs.i tJ,spo.siiFf//1/ of' e~~:lt:lrnl (A/t1 RQ.£j?otY:fe)
      Oece.1-11bu" 't, Ad/!:,-. Re1ve.s.f SCIYH..( Jl)o--/ic.e tr{ fee ,.~f (}Ptl K~l'dftse}
        IJJE-1)~/2. K-e (!etveo) Cl'l-s:F Jt(tJP'I/J_,/1                        .
         ~ v.d1 e (3Q_'i A W1 t1tP A e
           Ax!) l?.fi~fC>IiJ.S €. ?a Dl17e:::: CI/JJfl'"CMt:G/J NtAttH I-11Jfl1/ltt157Ril71VF
        1:""f),JQ I C Lvt L LCe.5 tt:Ji'\, 14-JV td S ?lr-7€ COJ11 fYI t S S I'd A) 01{} T uiJ I e f/}1._
         ~ cfY\l f)   u c-r.
                                                        t>re.v C f'd 1119 s               fl y
                                                           Co~-k!.4"" tr)         /
        "'it~ ~\l~~ ~u~k+ til i hv~ W.O-> -flf' 4ktt' pQV'.Srh~ 1
   t t\Vf. .r                   ~ 3 2 /7              _I.
                     'fuol~ ~      Ed     (..(J   IY\        D~n. VV\.-0\. If)
                T k l~ ca..$-~             IA..k:L.S          r-eYV?-- q     ~J          ..rfl-~     s   f.-6<.-r~ (c~e"- ('-i          hy 7~ ~q.....s
         tA-Mor()ey {%,e_~-ze~cvU cfAc~ w-k~ -JvJ ~e.                                                         D.enl14tth              fo.uiLJ ~f\1, f
          AN ~ S iLI              ~ ect.f' t      "--5 ICl '1\ -t (              o-N '.::[)J "(    uvc:-r f' d'fl}       A--M/)        w 14-:5.
           t?~ve.D        Ul\t~fQ.J s~~es, Pt-s{ttte--~
                                 TD                                                                            Cou-(-"1 fk,(j.f;lun /)/1/IS,on
           CrN C?c..~bel' 2..~ r 2..<9 I£'                                                                                I'

             "l L ~ tr~.P ~a~ h-i tva£ v-tg(~/-cc:Nt.s                                                       a-/ A-iJ A ~~¥ lth- ~
  tkce~ , /IJ.e,_ r< tti/17s 7 " 1# et. v1J IZ. .tf-CLLJy77hcttJ /'17/ctNs rt(/
 ffg~lf7 /A.-I mo.57 ~~p_ /~7/C/;0/l/'/()p 1/IOt 7M I-r:" Ttrre
/A.JCJJti.IJ yJROC$£.Sd,e. cJ-1)_ 7 $ L-//c£ 7/IK£ JkLo-~.~~toJJ/1-7/~
/klNII.J                             UM.s,-derc£.£~I ~s}Mc £r1>0 h l'i."' i,'#/
 ...Q~QI"CI...S(~ itlJ Y'tfl/.._fr tA f"lStnV"'
        -rkr-fl ~~nrk ,.Vo f'HEclr.anl.r P"-1 .J1, 'fl.,s /.V                                                                         /r/(f/o.-kCJ?t    o-/
   ·~fh Lf2.. VS'e.S ~ !S'tJCJI / /5't7tJc)
      Sj€c\ f!,c~( fy ~&~t'QJ '!Jo 'i~f f {utA Vt PJ' J/Ylay ~~j      *"
      ..J!v!ly         fotJJe r ral~                    liLt.      f('o.~~~ I'                     j€1'v'/ces;       u~ achpt/,-ed
      /eJ     J/lie/t?/o/"           .12.,   ¥- e r c 1 s , J   /1_           a/
                                                                    i /y-.. -fttJ~c~- frlflt ~
                                                                                        it_, s     rtJ,.
        f~--'~ fl.Q;( olo no:~ know llUJJ--S 't~'I-JtJ~i'~ ca 1111.o / ~s,~
     ut     )...[~ +k"" ~!" rre""'Nl +k ~10 fal'!J ;.; 'f/JJ>M. 'Pt-.. ,"(ef
         tiJ. 7/0t:J /taN po-~5. ecJ old'-~ A,           tye./le ~frcArt k 7 e/lera.lt.rfrt
       wt'flwa / ~~e/''F'j tA(l tAt.f~ J~f'sla-Y:.cYn ~~cctvs..:: ~H
       t ~ !}!:!_ 011-ettsrfJ h__"i. tiU yf.D f'v .rem sv6feP/f cllJl '( 1--a (ai-eJ                                 p

        o{ (t{fe_~S ~.)._ •
    -dus t !" "'-' fru1 'T IJ C. J p.e_ r--so-n~AJe.- I ~ u c h.. cx_s a! k 1-1..d-tl n{ s I /V                 'Q

  .1 1.              f1 b~ { t ~~ -+"'-a. v aa. h a, Q_+ c:v-w CA.Y wr fIt                   v Y' d ~r1                        yf-t
. .,..-vtt~ "'-PP~                          r 1         o       (
    cwii\J ~ n. e vcx.-l \I + ~ y do L.,i-e.ro ul' J.
              q_                                                        4                             I

 :J} fcJe_J :5a. rt.u.otr 1 l L( t 2.o I6
        Plo.udt--Pf    J< cebtJ () afltoso
        ~~~ /I}or t~e( t.., Att~ta (j  he ~ ._, ol L~ 1111 f ~-e.._J                                         U.U YIt    f f eJ u of  1
                                                                                                                             C -f     tl-eJ r :1-t« J\11'-l
                                               ~~VtD,!, h J,llj~ Pd b
         ~ LOV"tfly tv-~~ h ch.Q.,~'€r l y ~ -r~'tar e,;;if Pt-cuit c~s a"-J
         \2-Q.~tes Co.~                      o-e £J,IL6              C t o-Q $~ e f 1I ~ f' I e (}Q iU. ~ ,
     ~e.{ rtf~ ~OYl.SLJe.f\ed CA-N ~4 JIVLQI4j VJ()f~~vltd)'LS ~'/                                                           S TA-7£
   trf    TQ. ~t!<.> /      J7 f        A 3IC ttey 7 (} CS /                fer .s m   ne    /      t-he ~      o-P ·1/J h, < h Aa Y..P
    h.ttt.ek...,J r '"' ,,._L, W ...t,, J, ~ ~                                (!Up<      .
                                                                                      p 1y
          #I !f...J flu> /aw jru /.e                                          a-/      d"f kr     bee" rsf,.J  fL(
   II\     ally         ~vva/            tJV    'fA,         /tuJ        ltJI'-Cl/lj o.-r f1!!osJ te«-Sc:J'Yto-h /y
    ~tl 4--~ s-1~ p :IT J Nevta /7<>e                                    lIs e-IP tl6 si-QL-1~ f(J f( /ltui'1
   J.cia..-~""'.s f~ 'lfJ C j 8 fu.._ [( ..c2.1L.Su~ IN/Ma.fcs oN
    CL(JJ-0..~ I r I Cttll j, '{lf wa vI J n& i ha.ve -k W-at rl vwL I
   f/v 4 f2 th /JIS 7/d/('l Cdf/!2T IJ.I~(}i!J?t/£/Y J:f-tm
                                                                !
         -rt 2.. l!rLL B u1 f) 0 tJF 71/d-s~ PRev lou;fS ri It nJ _;
   AI2Ji' I.J,/,9 enf CJL--1-kl?hpls hQ ljoflJ 1//dlo-iQ'"yl-s &...c-L

         s L~   hs> j       +h     (!    '3 {/ -r~   ~I         o1 All-~         vs   J   1.JJ     I~
                                                                                          12LC/t~ ~cruf
      R~cJu.J            BAr- ('()-SO¥, '-/52 '2. 4>
      \(,t\.-IM. Se((    l   U IH 1
       t/(}0   FM         ftJ~~
       Rf7-.SJ-/AR6N 1 7~YM 17 s-~~

      C.LiiR k VIVIIlJV Lt:rvc;..
      [t91.1{(1 t!J F           A- fPe~L5
       <5 ilVBIJ11J             nLS?l?.LCT             fJF 7 B'L A-:J                               SEVENTH COURT Of APPEALS
                                                                                                        ViViAI\! LOi\G, CLEiiK
        IR.o   t   ~ 'i s-4 0
        ttifl1.tu' ,·L{a l 7 ~Ct..~                 L. '1 {C9$', CJ.S4o

         (([~ [<.La.~arcl ~41"1"05o v.. A/orvel                                  L·     J<\ r'"fi"JJ ~{ c,.,J
                        c._ &LS~ N C!J'   I - Ih
                                              ()               -   (p   D   3 t1 -      or-r CA-$1£              /J.fJf       f...[Cf/1   H
           PliAR Cl~/2 k V( Vt4N l.ONf;, I

               Ftr-s-f- ,p yov                 e/iiJ    Mo-rt aN Avsvs1 2 <:j #.'JL!Jl G                  d.~d         JAito7toJtJ
           to           C.~ u ~7      -t o 1Z- ¥- -r bW IJ "71 nt e ~/,AIt:J LoJ.../6.11 /( # JZctrt ~ 11/?.V '"\
              1\-S      ~     CtO 'N.crf f3UJ rzuli -;r couLD                                 f()-5' H 7Hildf/t%.tl 7#.E
               PfiJA.I -za C071fPL/i1£ C/Y0/2-rlf /2£~u-£s7 BJ117J- -ztHtk:."'
                                  .                                            (
               nu1 ::]. l--\ f\ v ti.
                        t:LLflriS£    f::tJ..ftJ liiJCLesc tJ                AFrt.bi£.\Vl1 M:- l N DI&.PNtlZ 1 AFFI /)fllJll
             M" f' R~\/tt>llS                 Fl LJ JJ &.s 1   Poc:Jt/271N 6              St '117 fl_lt1 GJ..rt I   e. f2t-71 F 1£0
             etll-P'-f ~12 tAIIY'14t!i                 7/i!.U"-S7FU-AI() /1-eC...."f           A-s -p;./1£ Ct9ue:-r ~EQutR£!)
             G'i     FRlOI4-I.{ Sl2f>7ei11~~R.. o< 1 --u>ib.                            t>t..I£-AS/2 BKIN~ '7H€s!; 7d 7/f!Z.
            v't'"116AJ"1t07tJ             0   r    71f li: CoU-t<1 J4N .0 FtJ-£' J4-MOIV4. -t:Ht:'                        P.,!J.,f!'£)2S
           fYF 7#-!Z Co-u-12. '7 14.--N f) ~J;EJf.is J4 R TZ.. 4 RtZJ47 L. y ~ £s pn.L 7 6b .4--~11 IJ'i'rRE£.1Pf71£lJ I

.i.
l )

I
I
I