Court Opinion

ID: 4064544
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 21:31:12.715726+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:06:46.873765
License: Public Domain

I--------~V--~--~--u~~~L-~7-~~~~CL-~~~~---~-~--co~~~~~-­
r------H'-",;,./~-~_,_-=---.,__::.·..,.~..,::;.. ...._""""~'"---n_-7?'£               __~<;J -~~-----­
                                                                          L"_L/L,b£4/?C
l------•+......,"'~"""/~'-'~~,--/--=.r£ __ C,L/6a,tPt!flL_,&!.cZ/~L'7cL.J .,~"'f/;b <>~~<
!------~~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~-~~~~~~~ ~~~~~

1-----H---~---------~----·---~----"~--                                                          ·-~~--

                                 A
                 A;7/C#£( ~- ///£72f                              C~//J?/4/#{ ~/-'JfP/$S C~.e'/

            .'
                        v.s                                       ,4t/J~     7//£l...S
------1-¥--WL SZ££ o£_~£S~---L:!~~~,:___·. :. . _-:~cJ~.2~/s- cJCJ/~~ C~"---
------++-"~Zh~"rC£_ 2LfL/-zo#_L_
                                                          0
                                                   /7'- 8Zo7C,f?
                                                                          . /z-o8-69ZS7
----H---~£7/7/0/l/                                     B/ 6'          /N,..¢'.(2_ o/-    zr
                                                                 0~   vs

                                                   '         .

---~~~---=..L..;~___::_~:.____,..~~                          /.4JZ Y/#R' /N ;?"~

-----tt"C?£7'/7'/c:)/1/L/2 s~~· /;7/C /6,/~ Co/1/t//cz;r/tJ o/
                            ·'dd{£      o / /£~4(/6'7/?J/ll /A,/~kC ~/<- ·
                       /V     /£.KS"PcJ5/£ ~ ,/U/0{/£_ · OZ'4cY ~/cL?£L7
----~~--~~~~~~~C7 ~U~;?LAJ co~~o~
                               I t            /i       .              ·

------+-1-7'~-6--L.;_/V.::.,...__kat.l7'-UL>£ I            J U,IJ :.~...S,.-d..~t'- ~7/4'd'_h;?_p~6/!/S_ 4 /1.//J
----ti~~~~-;a_rL-Ldc::z::9~C-L£4//0 ;z2e'_OL_A?//-4~c.-t;~· 7#£
                                           .                  1?1 /.)"'
                                                                                                      ___
                                                                                >       •        •

_ _ _ _,_     0L~fc__~J-~L-L-1.J~~                                              ~cc_z~£

---~~-~~~~&~av~~--C~J~ /Vu~~Ar4lf-~~--------~

                                                                           ..
----1-1£~0/f./CL_dE,@/UJ£,0                    ~~~ &"~£'£ rR'//A/AJ
----1-1c:J£ z;&'£..         vuaL__s;       ~/;?/7/0/1/d )6/8'~ £JL:_AJA<::....:..:_¥:=--,/Q~--
~----~-v---0' d4!'/'c_CZl_~7ua:if4/_4_(__,.£L~ / § ~
                        .   ----.                         .                         .            /'
----~-~· ££/L'_dkt:0._/.21:::?Af/L~4L;,                 ~4 ~~£.£'C"--S 6-4./1/~/P
-----1-v--    ~~ ~(L_4A'a_L .d~~A:O'V                         ~CL_f L!L.?L;?"/-a#/~.
------t---~C.62-~ A/6:7 /~L ~~_d__f Lf¢.7/"~/f/L~ ,,//0
----H.ha~. /Z.LA'L           L:?'df--:2. t£_-V~_-
                                                · .L'S 6/L/ d'~ cJ~~--"""----
----1-1-&-5'£/l/LJd__z::o           EP.£.~Ar~                 ~~£v.£/V;?' _;:;:::_~.L.~---
----H'-~O/,d_~..£a~_C6....-1'2~~2                                         6CJL:_~~c /?77/~~
----1-1-.2:6         16/£/-2!"£_z/?'£_L¥/4t~ A/1/~ ~~~---
------~-~-:;£?L-.SZZLC7-cau£_/O     a£.. ~/~6'Jc yo S_?ZJ~ 7~-L,____
-------IH'_-U&£L"2'27-L'CA:.(_A..A//O ~/c;£_,0 . ~8'4//~0C:# ~~
          ~

---~,-o.£ ~£7L"L'LZLA/£LL                      ~--~L_.S/.U-;7' ~ ~d~
                 '
----f+-;·     LVL.OfPCL d~LA£L4 £)//!1///J,                                                 d?t /--1//?/;ZL
       t ~L-, ·
----H~'-        ~ ~,..
          _{_,_!__~~--~  ~/7 17 r/Jr-
                        LL"d.&Y-~-~   Co~Li:5f_£)L/f./~
                                        ·              /0· ·

----IH'C~-Ll/M/&4._PLZL;ZPA./LL_,b'_62_S d/,00/A/~/0
------H-Ct2tJA.C,(C_,:_/4/ff£C_-z/J/£_CatLA/C/C / J                                         A/0;/
-----R_c_oCL&..c/c_~;;:_ act-~-ZL?-'£                L4V-;Y£L-4?£· JdLLCc~~
----H-£:~4&1~~/JO.d}_p-__4-C-;ZL/V-4-                         ~ /-;e/Lt?£ ~~--
----1'-1-;a!c:L~t 4£~/.S--~~C:::Ju/L_ 42'PL!l2/,.o~/J
                                       )
    I
    I                                   /#he J
(
    IC;ROA/a               c;~_      /./j::'/    Ju~/....r ...,q~.P.cJ/4/~,o
        YtJ ~,e~,LJ COV/R'/.LJ {/,LJ                  7.ij£ 7.,et/~     s·c;
        7'./7£}/       ,4-e.-e   /1/ci/' /£"~.5'~/,Q          ~~ c~~..-v&?C

    I    /Y,//J coA//.;JUC_?',             /7    /S   )1../.,.CCC ~{/M/-"1.///~
    i   7/7~7 ~#£                    A'R'£.      r..£..£1~~(- /Nv£Y/P4'~~o/z/
        //Y/d ~£. W~o/l/f" A:J//LI~S o / :?o/£ ~/­
        _?"t1h:P/£Y        @v.-1/-;::y JU..O~S~ -~/?/;7/CJA//_R> /S
    I /N,f/CJC£4.// o_,c 7~E <:::/?41~?£ CJ,c. ~~c'/Ai/01/
        .O.Y   7/7/Z         ~.&k/S £J.£,£//z/~MJS r./4/~ o/~~
         )/1//J£., 7~£ -C..:/#'t               ,6'£//(//EV
    \vv...or-.R" ~/c4.h'/               4-4/-U/ /3///l/4' SU//.,RE..I?'"..£,0
                    ;IJY C£OA.I/L · A~/cJ/,;V7£L:J. .?-~4'"67(. coO&c/~'J.
              . . . ,/J,£7??7CJ/1f~4' . _/)/4YS, 7~#/. 77-#J"" ~#4CC
                              .        .              /

                     CouL'-;7 J~/C[ //L/7.£45£//0 CYV ~J ~~/
. --·-----. -·-·· //A/l) ___ .SZ??.P ..    /J?~. /&//C(/~£;- ./PA?.£4'/..Jo-1/
  ..... --···· .   . /~Ci_-1':::? _ 7/P//(/fitL'~A.!e:f ./~~7.$~/4L/' _ _ ~,P/.L~

... _________ ~/~;:;o/1/£/l·· /~4Y.f"_ 7~/f ~:i-:f!C!~~f!?E CQ047
                                                              f   .   .                       .

   . _ --- ...... ---- _/7/'A.:J/A!.Z _. /5'-1! /9~/.'Z~J'· ?.~1-V'YEL /?o<:? ,?/?&/.., -~----~-d?d!!.~4tf'&___~£_4/._~.f-?'__~~7~t:L~
-----------·····------· ·__,e~Y/d/~ __&;e... ___ /L/k.£7L._L&__I(__C..£~'<{)7!zt;&~---.ZQ_..$Ll(_
  .                                                           .. /
                                                                                                  ___ --···-
------------~-----·--·· ..o& . . /?L?d'/a-v/.~---- C.-44 ~«..s: _CQ~,('£L'£~7 -~~~ -= ---·.
-··------··· -···-·····-----~~#/k,£&:...8'--1-',.0 C6lk/Y/.Z:.J.' . /?.7 £1/~!/_0_dlL.
                                                   /4~£-C:

---c----++-=oL-ft~LJ- ~_Lw/'C/_§_£d///Jf_~..:r7#1'£(!_5;)_
~--+Y:_:__ ~vN/~ A--..L_){L£cc__hl__L_dZ · r~ ?£.4/C ,E..R.&£4'. W/7'£/f/ /:7
-----t-+'~~~~7///f;JN£~ /;f'tl~, /?67/?dJN/./? I~L~
                          ~Cf/J /tJ            IA//?/7£ / # / ~LC'JU.f??"c;c- o~
-~--t+,J6/couZZ2 CM?//C~O~ 9'/~:.CQ.? ~ 4
----HCC2_U£~ /2&/£ 7':Cl ~#/? ~£-~~£ ~01./___t:~"-
~---+t'-~--'-'·~~-
                ~M'-"'-
                      _.,Z2:L"=u:;~k2=-.L__duQ{;E"            7/~Z ~/S_/l/l/;Q:/4.J · -
-...,-----t-t./?£;7/7/()A//d ~:4J"f L/VU.f27A./.f" c/U~fE ,QQU$C4J
---o---H---~c.d/2                 6h-v-fi?f/P.e'4. _· .·                WtJ    -·~/V~~~
              -::£4Cdl7cY! /~/L/1//-J ~c::Jd')~J:-~01"7 .
                      .     .
--c------t-t~~__Ll~A/f/e'J ¢?/f/,0 Sa:.o · /);::j/ J?J64CU:ce.LJ
----H-'~ ~(£Ej' . W/-7/7 h:~ ~////,) c/t./7~U/C£}/~ ·""'-.ECJ.~Y2~--
~---H"-"""~{,t//[" .$/O:J.00.CJ::J, 2f!7LL_,I?ed~.6Z'~ K/_4J'
------,.----+1"'--<-.W.=--.:/9'---'__.__~-~/1/;7£__L) · h'///~/_ic         JCL/7      (Z)_ ~CYV~f .
                          ~117        ;                                          .
                  _                   L;#~/E£'       ~-"7'o£Y-                       c / ~~~--
-----f-T-'-/-?2 aYa.d6,.                        7__./?:E~~fA..C/ .L£__ 4£/AI? ~/LJ?'L"V
----HL-~~:L-::.-..__;_.c=;'E.----"--c//-LLCJ/L/LL_L..£_t/f£;(/                4S 4     S~_L~_
----+t-P-!Lc£o_r£-.eL-LLJo.lY-'"~. ?"t7~Lf:2~_.LZ£-h/;Q/~
----H--12~l:J-z_/P.J                             /-?'oA.LJ/.#~CE
                                       cc;u,eL___L_/[L-;;rzzSLL:__/J_
     ·---~--£cr£-_,L!!_£7L:z:L!.AL£L/¥uo_o~k ~S"fL~o________
                                          /'~~:E      7
_ _ _,,£L_/U£_~~/L                        ~~,£ /"ZLi/fO£~ct
          '            '                          '       :         ,..,.,.
--~-~~~c~ou~ ~s ~ho~~~-~.________ ,_,______

-~---=--A.r~-=-__,_~..r_Z_r__L'&/V££'   ..b'A!_J c_o/I/..S~7u7/o/v4C~ ./2/-
--~---/(-~~~~~/A/f /?~~--~~~~~--·~-------
____   · .>....,.CCU."""-!i/LZ //.£7/Z/cJLVL_~ f· So/Zf /J4t:-- ?tJ1/ /-'£
_ _ _ _ /6!:4)- .iZ:__~U~ ·20;CJ/C ~.£I__.#~-~~'~"~--·_ _ __
---~_7LA.J..llf/_/J~CcLv£L                    u /...      ~£?,/?'/o~£4 S..;?;·_·~J
_ _ _,d'J_~,.(!S_______dLJL. .o,4'C/z_~~ 7 0 ~ SQ6.)_1-1---·--·-·---··--·
_ _ _ fLk'L~ Cd_A-CL~ 7Cf ~at?E d.~_L£,-e_o~--H------------­
---d~-LZ/.5 e7_CqA/f';?Z07/cz~..tJtC £~~
  _ _ _d/_~ 2/CC:::::' a/i/£J aw-v ~/f:?.&k,._.~ _/ ~d--1/~~----
_ _ _ _ _Mt !.,£/' £Y-S..4:C~ ~ ~£~ ~a~ _______________ .
---.£~{J(j(_ L~L~CYV--~~-LJ~C-4LI-CC ~---                                                      ________ _
,-------C./-vLc' C~ JuL27£___;:?P4_£k_ ~~;Z_L_4/_ ____ ~~---------'-
---/-~AL£[6r~~ ?GJ_~o?ZC~_- __ 6/"lLJ______. . _
---~:z;r--L~/fb?_a A?LC.c_/uv                                 /2::!CG6U? C:d//1/'..J(.
-------;//-&- 8 Qf!L/2 ~,eo 4!UCJ /J£.4-C,: JvAJ7L 9~ - · b ' - - -
_____S::q2 u$/Ld"L}~~ /?tlf//7£C CJ/Z"?"~Y::;.___:__;::-;-=,+---------­
-----=~:.L-~-=-Zl,O ~£/~ Z.Cf2?'/7A/~~:£/$.J?'                                       7#£
                                                                                       )

_ _ _h@fRLL&-C5_d5                      7~Y     /OLLJ _L/fY          ~d:" /Y:?~/Q -~~-c~·-_
--~L?LC~Ai~;_,A:)L ~~£~~~8.0                                          :z2_,.(//c_,£_?"a_ ·
   _ _cLPJ_bJJV/J _kJ,C~/f.J                  ~ ~/c:.e." /2_-L_~__!&>. ~--
----:?-r..LAZ1£LU/-/!/$._([L__zz;:'~ _(2'/LC/2. CCLS~L_- .             ________ _
  _ _ _ _ d£4~/Li./+_ze;__t/fL                   ~~/L2._·C/L                  ?CJ·   5-.7/~.    ------··---
     - -------~L"ZC/d:JL.YL£L.__db~/---LLZC!.5_Co&__/l_-2LLL~.7--- -1-     -----"-·---
 ·--_-------~--4~?-/LV~----,eZ£Lu,L!}!,._.· z?'L'LL__W§@_ ____ ~-~---- . .________________
··- _____ G·o.v.f~__ L;/ foR' . £«/Z      __ /7.11/~ .. A/6 SU.R-
    ... -~lf/S£. /_W4f /Z!(/7:       .SU//J ./' /?"ClX/~-P/4 76
     ... ?/;{//J CJ[./;/' 4/3007 cJ~ A-7££J/C4C            £>04~~
          W)t/Ci N'&J f:ed/7     4ct:   T,ij£ kU//:J£~ /A/4J-
          _UN~YSP/C;7//J        /-lU/ .A:-Y/0#/A/~,<:; ,//cJo A/"~Y
          .7/P~ /;/6.f/O/:?'~?f-.. ~£C.'?' C/J~~t:Y'7.#~U A)
     ..   cov/4/~ u//        /d4_ /J.R:,    /()L/ff~ _ /A.J~~#A
         .CJ/ . .LJ/S 7&!vC/A!~ . .7~£"~Sd2b/f /~ct..-t~ #~
      .. ptJ/7'///e/J/h . b/,0 /VC!/ ~/f/~/1/ .£>9//J co£//t//'~-1!
      . )1/;f_S' 50 ff//}0£ .?~~~ //if ~4-f>· . /[JU;?' ~..#~
       .7o ,/J/<77JCC;::P~J SCJ{; JOh'a /.S ./U:J"Pt/ ~~.e'­
          L£_5J/.7.~/ -~Y-.B//~ .. .6?.'~4      .6?.4£4/A! __:/"Oij~~
   . __ A?,E#CJt/?..0 ./~ ~. /'YLZJ..O         ,ou~/;u~. -~ ~/w~cr
          ~/0   CE//-J/1.1{ ;&A/J /1/u}V' /O#CY0-1.)   4   /4/i"/V
           C4/t£ £SY /7£/      S/.57~       ~/ //?&'~d/J #£./2
          4)    Y£8'~_ oc~ ~{"//~ ~£/~AI~ /4/22;
           /&C£ ~~)$.1 cYLJ . ~.~~ .a///#?.            /'~J .7/A:?~
          #"/   ~£ ~         a-c {?£)   I        .
i
\   I
    II
    ~~£~/t.IV£/( ,;9/t:JCc~                  cou.4?;;:'
        ~~ h' COu~7                h'-~,PCJ//l/?"E/()   ~/9)1/Yf/1' ~L~;{?

        7,e,f/l./ff CCJU/1/7'-/ /94.1,0 ·       ;:::g /J./Jk?/...s:J         cou.£?
        /!}r',P~/At"/'.ELJ      __,c_£JcJA:? /?:?oA-J/7.CYJ::?J,R/
                              COV-VC/c
        cLJVA/;?y JV//tt> /2£/0J£.1. · ·7Cf ,4>~/AJ<{' ~~
         7/'Y/J   ;~~l,J/;(;).£/t..C.£>   //£//7/0N,f~        -7'-J;t:'S'"   ;7(J

         /5',£' $£d0f/77 4£/0.-ef                  7~/S      h'cYVCJR#'&<:"
        CouL/ 7b             /f.£_}.-ZN/ ;;P~ /~;?'J-                4-/i/~

        .70   t7// 4/t::/£/ /~                  7/7~    /P.£/J~..Lr/b£
         /J-1./LJ /24?~.-9~/~ cz;v~c_·                  o/   ~~#1?..?/fl/
                                                                     I

        CdUIU~jV.         ~Z/'/7/(J/L//£ ~Cfa ~~J ~#ftJ
         /74,0 /f/6        .5VAJU~.P7 /N           61   )/£&'~/ JA~/0& /~
        /_/f.i#f.JM,-9/UI

         /J.Z'-:?//dJ/1/£/ S7~-zes                 ~#-/ /...C            ~/P£..r-,r/f//'
         COUA/C/L          (Cou/2_/ ~..,O~O"A.J7..C,6j //74:-- /X//.?c'/~,;?,
    ~/1'~/lft'/..fCYU        /f    A/0-:7   /?d'A:?ot/£/0 ,4N/b UN //l#f£~
         CWIVC/G           /}~/J0/)[)-7/l/:J ?~cU? 4/li.O;;:?Y/~ 1/.E/Uuij
        _couN/Y/ 7-?P/ //£7'///oA.//{J /.ij'ft'CJ /.J
                      l

        /NA/CJC/~ #V'£t /.JE ~'~.#.fey /MP..RA'"o.-v/.b
    l   /0£ 7'-W£ /£.~;::? O/ #/[ ~/// ,4/l//:J ~£
    I~U?'/7'              M/2/V/4 Su/,PE£.r.f'//.7/
    I
       /??--7/7/0&~£'                     s .#,?
                                 $7:.#.:/Z'            #~J' /1/CJ. 97///,e
     . #Jc-o~S~            ~/?JW??CC 67'/?'J4 ~#4 ~f
     . W/t/-;7 _oE £44£-#S . ~/tlf 74· _s-/cv~E ~/S
       U:J~a-u??ti/V.-&!( /!/977-f ./6 _ ;;;;cc? ~£ 7~o~
       .,8'#/? /'~.a.;A./;::7 7~£ .~u/4///t.JCE / 4;c-y

 ... ____ _'Z:/1"/L _ A!/.~- _C41!/1'~---~~   4/?~.E;(J(J. /-f_~ /l-1/;o   d£S
   . ____.R£L?I/f/'4 __r"Q _ /9?'Ct2.W. ~_,;{"?/?."/.oA./L/( __d/~ ~$~
. ____ ~----Z'd __ ,tO~£.-f'~~-7 ~4- /Ef///:Jf~c:;e A1//;l_/~/t!~CF~ ·
     --~J- .. _7/7.-eY .. //~h£. ££A:fs.;£_,() --~A;";?,/~/i/~...J­
       W/?/7 u/            d"~£14&Zf. co~/~-.S- co~,..,OcA'/1(~ S-4/~
    __ __&E'/JCI//1.1/£.0 COU/1/C/(           /d4    '7'/?"/J. 4~,.-qf#C-   /u
          h!J~
      $'         .//~;()
                     #4J /8£~£7/.J. _ rCJ. Ccf/1/Y~J/ ~£ .
      . 7£v-:P/?"_z:o ???/ 4/~~-6?/J_ cou4';7/ ??Yo_s.
      L},;£N y /N7 /?£ ;7///c::vV£.// /;?YJ C~/V£~70;::?"~~L-·
      /liV/J L:£{~(- pe/~~:7': ;;o ___ d/LI ~,/-?/?f4?C/

                              ~Ja/~~············.·