Court Opinion

ID: 6958354
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-24 01:41:15.69164+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:08:21.128726
License: Public Domain

Mr. Chief Justice Scott delivered the opinion of the Court: This action was brought by plaintiff, to recover of defendant the value of goods sold and delivered to defendant’s wife and minor daughter. So far as the goods sold to defendant’s wife are concerned, we see no reason why he should not pay for them. The evidence shows he is a man of considerable wealth ; that the goods purchased were necessary and suitable to his wife’s position in life, and under the circumstances proven the jury were justified in their finding, that she was his agent to make the purchases. It is with great reluctance, however, that we reverse the judgment as.to the articles sold to defendant’s minor daughter. The goods bought by her were of little value—were such as she needed, and without which the evidence shows she had not enough to make herself comfortable. But defendant has a technical defense to the action, so far as it is sought to recover for goods sold to his daughter, of which he is willing to avail. When she made the purchases, she was living away from his home, was working for wages, and was receiving the benefit of her own labor. No reason is shown why she did not live at her father’s house, and had she done so, the presumption will be indulged, whether well founded or not, he would have supplied her with necessaries suitable to her station in life. At all events, the circumstances proven will not justify the inference she had authority to buy the goods on the credit of defendant. An express promise, or circumstances from which a promise may be inferred, must be proven before a father can be charged for goods sold and delivered to his minor child, by a third party. Neither has been proven in this case. Hunt v. Thompson, 3 Scam. 179. Appellant has printed in full the transcript of the record. Of course he will be allowed no costs for it, but only for the abstracts, which are quite full enough to present all the points in the case. The judgment will be reversed and the cause remanded. Judgment reversed.