Court Opinion

ID: 4061746
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 20:14:39.936605+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:39.761929
License: Public Domain

gu, 10? »Oz_

 

 

 

 

 

 

IN THF
C€)(ART Ol'-‘ CRI_M::NAI }QPBEHLS
gunn nme RECElvEDlN
T/u'dFiT UF CR|M|NAL APPEA|_S

5
Ex PHLZTP 5

53 ,.A/o. szoa;<-QCL- §-;112 Nnvgg 2915
F)uGaLYTI/v T'IMENEZ 's'

 

 

F\ULLQH'~/T' s QNJWER To ymle ’,< 15 ¢.
F|MENQI»/c anouo,¢ QN)) BrLIEF/ME/v\orzn./\/DMM

 

 

 

 

'i'o TH`E HoNleHIZLE :ruDGEF oF snID Courz‘l;'

 

NOW <éOMES;' gus u.<'-H‘n‘e. Tj";me/Ve?.¢. Qp¢'nil'cqn-)- pro.S¢ )>\l/
k Qm) -H-»r-oug% k)‘m_§el~l~\' irs -H)'e. above -H~)»-\L mmi Cap-i~»¢§r\ed
C_ao\.\"¢: w»+`h -H»e. H'o¢)h'<:an+i< nnfwer To _§-Fq-}a'§ -f-}'h_»ow ~i»})c (_’.ourJ-' ~-‘Hn=_ ‘Pc$ilowfn`g b&-Po're 'H\‘e Couf*~~}
reac'ave and make. “;-i"l v\‘uclgwgpn')~ per#ic.'\n\'\ng¢ +0 -l»he.

pp'ol)c~.¢mi~?_s‘ \/v/r'\+ o-F Mo.be.od` €,or~pus mpp|i.£.o.-L[D'n ;'

I¢

 

nppi¢'cqn~)-i; \n/r\}+ vi i-labea.f Cprpu$ 9+0?}1`€¢:~3»,£»n/
Moia'on For` Ev.'derH-¢'gru l-leo\r"iyaa. Mt>+i'¢zn F('>r' npo`n`)n-')'°
» men-} op Cour).$e) and Gr~¢)e >r’ Dc:;zgng-hnn .Lf.!'c/aa wa§
g ~F;i¢cl w')+i) -qu Dss+ric+ Coz¢r~-}; Cler»)<.. on Oc,-}ob¢r‘ ¢25’)
Qo|$ »

 

I':»’

 

"wr~H~ o-I-` blake aj (’or~,ou; noph'ca-hbn bags e¢mr.’,) 40
Dz.S-l~rlc)- F)+}or~nen nn Movembe er 9 2015 ¢x.f well al +/}»'e
/V\o-}roo')} Gum'.j (’)r\ale'r‘» "

 

 

 

 

 

 

.]JI*

 

ST/HT#E` ‘F\'i&_\,_+-§J.D.LML_B_&'__TO_;&'E€- 'npp]i.£c.-n'p.¥ np"o||`LQ-,*l;an

an /Vo`\/embe~r" 0|,.§203.\’ a-l IZS'SPM i,v")~j*h +}HL D"a_S-}~r\fc.+ C.ier"h
ap MCLP.nnqh CoMn-i»>), T¢=d 651

.II,.

"Tr‘s'c»l Cour~~)- piled a-\--Y -Fan&»r)o e-l`~£qc.l- and (;onclu.£n>nj

n~P law. fedemmehAq-hnn . nnr\ dawn-lar m~n Novgm`ber' °Y)

_Bo|$ Q£~ glorith w.-H\ +La Di_H»r-§a+ Cl»r-k. c>~P)V\e'Lcnmqn
C ou.»r~+'\,/v\ Té>,'xaj ,

ZT..

n 7 _' _-
The S+a-h>_'_¥ nnswer qn¢) ~(.cc,u‘_
De-i~o Un}+ -mou') Clegq]_) p_~$e.'r\v;ce,»

nix

an)a'can-)» -c'le 61 re_(’pon_re -)»D +}1¢ §-}-cd»e’j cantu/er- and

{`-'nur-)-J -F)ncl)nm.f and Oraer* _. )o‘;/ Qmenasn@ +}\13 Gr‘t>u‘nCL(

 

G»R H=e BLLr._q..n_é_M__m_w_Ak_m_n__v_p_mr$ G\Y)A man
-H»e dcaamen+_$° +o -H-»e, DsJ+/wc_+ Cl¢>.r~)¢. o-P J\/)aL¢zn-han
Ce>mn+\,/‘. T@d.c\_$ »+_o be ~r(e_):Ve*r'en) *+O +)1€, S-;~Q+‘e canl0
-i~he four-linn +b£. IS+)\ cle 010 A/ovemjl'>e-r;gol'$'- by
U,J`, Mc.§l fn 'lH-)e Be-{-n Un")"}~ poJ-)- booL.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

CEIZTIFICBTF OF §ERVICE

 

 

I do her€-|?J/_C.drill§l%ih_£j'_(a_‘);£.b;c._jné {'oprec-L toy"v’? h-P

 

 

'Hze. ~Pore_gn'z'n\c} documcn~}' ~ Ap'.!)l l'c;n~n-i"J' 43 Y\Jw'c'y~ ’To 543~4~2.55'

 

Qn.fwer Hme.vé»§ng Grom')¢l_f pmi Rr‘§e~P/Mernoran¢\um coal

 

f¢»"`vec’, upon Da'j¢l~r‘l'£`_+ ’n-}-}or'r) €}l 1 Qiq /\/or‘-}}x Co+)\ 547'€€+,1
.S'b{-'}-§_» UJQC O.~ TQ§CC¢S °7&’)0)/' 'l`q+'}\ Tb\cji`c.)l¢.z] Dzr..(-)»r\\‘£.‘~"~ COLU‘-?~j

 

cm w&.s%.‘nghn nv¢.d, flaum zerz; wa¢.~_,; TQ¢,L@_: °')cnc>z 'f

 

 

`J’o~‘n )2£ Gaimlo)el.`])l._§»}~r\;c+ ("1er~'kj po’, USX §"l$); Wn£c,_;

 

'l'ex_a£ 760ij by (Jl/J`.N\¢iu nn -H\U ~Hn_> IS+)\ clay nc
/Vovember~,,£?c>i$.

 

 

 

A / //"

 

/
‘Q owing U’i)m en c ’2_

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

,Co/vc L u_SIc;\/y ’QA/D PRF\\/E R

 

’ e£.-l-p H

   

 

+)'me +u rear-omni +b »H-.r 54er arLB Col/ar+_$
Flnéw»a_.< NF Fa¢'.-} er.1 Conc)u_§¢o'n ¢`P L&Ld ELBM)"£. ‘)'})e
Ce>m~-} recpw,_~z an make ,-H \uAgme.n~}-_ norm -l~'he.
npp)acan}; wm+ null )~]q'b¢q£ (`.nr~pm Dp'p))c.a-}-¢`m >

 

R€._SD€-C“'-pkn\/ .£U}m_l++e[`,

{%M//M
F) uac,¢féz jnmen;.~z_

Toc:r -J;D£ 332055£’
BFTDJM/z"r

1391 F/V\ '?;".=25”

Te-n.ri e_$`fe e é°_oi ontT)/_ll"§l 15220

/¢