Court Opinion

ID: 3372973
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-07-05 18:14:38.108911+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:47:05.592204
License: Public Domain

The defence set up a counterclaim on book of account of defendant, for goods sold and delivered to plaintiff. It was objected to, on the ground that there was no plea of set-off; and insisted on under the plea of discount.
The Court said there had never been any definite idea connected with the plea of discount in our practice. They could not give it the force or meaning of a plea of set-off, and the defendant was not at liberty under these pleadings to present his counter claim for goods sold and delivered, which would be a mere set-off; but if he could follow up his books with proof of an agreement to deduct, defalk, or discount the goods so sold by defendant to plaintiff, against this note, the court would allow of this evidence.
                                        Verdict for plaintiff $307 47.