Court Opinion

ID: 4043769
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:27:17.046085+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:47:17.282822
License: Public Domain

..
                                                                                                                '?Oik\D~~-
                              This.document.contains some

:~
     •
     -
         ~----
                              pages ~hat are of poor quality
                              at-the time of imaging.
                                     ~-------·--
              · .£~~--~Do_M__/IM_-/b_QIY.¥--/1C¥YA.L&..
                                                         .
                                                                               --------~~---,--'~~----'---~~-
                                                                                            ·   llt-/!.__,.1 z· ,:) a>_y_.-_ __
         ----~__.-r~CL~A!:o_._Lfll"f_6J._7

                               c.,_ r:__ ~_//~/lt~_L:____·--~------------·
         _ _ _ _ __c____l3_tlo_Em_6_-.r_s:______ _ _ __
                                _K.o_s_~G:4--o~~-lii_~tf:.t fz_~s-fl,S_
                  _                                                                                   RECEIVED IN
         ~----~ -------------------------.----;------cotJRi-oF-eRtMINAi--APPE~

                  7D :__ /!h£_ (_~d_ce~l~/--c_f.£JL__~--- --, · ·                                      APR-1-4-2D-15 .·      ... ·
                        ____C_eG.',[_,t:_~_f'!..~C.i;'M_;,u/'l/                     .                       .     ,,                 ·.
         _ _:____ __IJ,;pe_d-__t._s__ t!)_/!__ __f£Jf tkf- . .
                    ·/1.a_~c.liax~t;;3_0__8_:_ ____-_.:______
                          '           ,.'         '                <   .            \   ~

                         . C~_~__f_Clt._ ___ ~/l:-.LLo~_l/mt;/V k ~ ____
                  . .         ?_eJ   ?/L .                     .               ..                       .

     •           ------ . . .o ______ -,-----~------'-------.--------.-'--------------------

                 · f£_:_wM.h_~_.()_ ?__fl1~~d-./h2:1~_.r_____~---_·____·-~_:
                                              '           '•               '

                        --~u~c_l~~-A/o_,_lft_6_f:L8_lLO __· - - - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - -
                 ------~--------·-~------
                                                      '

                                     ----~-------~---------------                                     -----·-:-··-----'------
                                                                                                                            ''
                                                                                                                             ·~" '
•   --~---- -----~--~-'-----..-'--------------------------------·-------
               . . -/ /          /._      t..£.L j, c -. /A ~ • ./ G                .    '
    --=W""-/!l.d_or~~J"J:2--~'7/i._ _C._ ---~---~-':/k;£_~-~-1!1:_ _ _(9"U&..L_o_r£__ _ _ _ __
                    - r__L£y__&oudM.. 12£_fA._1JJ~__fAa£k&~~/rJ691/%.""'-=-=-{)---'~
                        ___ ______ u;N_}::___o t 111_/b'r/_~w~     .          . ----'-----
                                                   --                           .·.        •
      _ _ _··_

      ~----------                                            ~- -~-i
             ___.~--~----~~-------~~~~~~- _______1
                      --.-----------------

      _ _.f1,1J'__ ,4LikP-#-~---c-8_ou&&.-.___ r_oG_:;r_Uet_____LBL£6J_Z ':.;_t/z_£~~'_.SC--_l_. __L _ --~---~-~-p-fJ~-
                                                                             fl2
                                                                                                                ----
    -----------------~---                  ----·---,-------·-----------------c-------------

•   - - - - - - - - - ' - - - - - - - · - - .- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --.---c'-----~~------

    __    . . . 2_ t.=~,. . - =-=_- LUi.. __ 9_?:__'-L_S_,~Y-J 4d _ b_B_a_:__~--~.-----c-=·---:;-~-~-PPr-~-.s;_:__·- - -
    -----'-------------"~"--" ~-----'-----------------------------------'--

    _ _____,s_4_{£r_7~t_t.M-M.. __v_!.._ __(~A?<-c;,:,.         ?¥r     s_, Cdzd.       a~ 8..--~-p~-S:--------,------'-
    --------------~-------·--·----~-----·--------~-------

    ---,-----'-----------~------------""'--.:----'------------'--------
                                       -                                  -
    ~--~L£s . -~-5.:J. (__/' ___S_JL_;J_,-_:____:>- J , 3 _j:--L~-=-==7--==--==---:=--=--f....§-·'1, Z..._____ _
    --~--'-------'--~----·--,-------------------~------'--------'-----

                                                                                ~----~~prj·                 to ..

•   ----'--'-·-------.--·---------------------------------------~-----

                                -              .                                 . : ~-· r~ ,"i- -
    ----'--------------------------'----~----,-.- - -.. -----------,----'-...;..__;_:_'-----'-+~--
                                             .                                     ~.- _r:_l· ;.~f;·f-'_'
                                                                                                                      ~'- ____;...,. __
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 1_____.___________________________---,----:...____,_·b.-,_~=-:-'=.--,;:-----c-'--i
                                                                                                           _: _ :·,·1:YJlG)\:/

                                  ____ _:______}._ .1 ~                       -----~- .--------'-~-----",·\_·-_·__
               '.
                                                                    •f            •

-   •       -·-------,--~.~·-~~ML.SJ£._/J/o_L_Id-bJZLf)_{, O~~-·_ _ _ _ __:__ _ _ ____.__

                                        .                      .
            ____,·'I,v· u_·'_f}_OM                                 ·~~&_~h_y_flo~MM__/                                     Pli 4rt7&.
            --------'----'=-"rv.~~·l-- .•       f
                                                                                                     '0 /             &L/lrlc_'d~-f'._________

_ :-e·.·       · Nat.U--~as:~:-fJQ~- ~lfo~ .8oN"#M. /-LL~Z.il-<--/~1!.~..,...'--,..-'--'=-:....r.-=-=~,._ __
              .. SL£L~y.-·rb .!'hft>]Lt£.~-i-4'.!_ C~"-·L- jkL~_SCL_~L· lc fi'M£._· _
                               '                                                              -./.       •.       .           .             .

            _ _,!Lui&.£ . o/. ~fl-e.C/d"L<. . f!_~udu.;i£s .:~~ ..t'tl~L/- $';;. 3                                                                                                                                          .
            --~£J-~~ ...s ~-·ULLIL shot..V M~t                                                                             Co.v"'-r .' ~~-~&u;~~L;y~_:.___
                                                                             _ $1/t[/i...pvtkft eC ~c4S£                                                            ..~: . . /6 ~\                  ·
                     . ,   .       .                                     .        I       .          ,        .   .:   .                        .               ~       •: ,, .              11:~

             -~-_---"lt"""""&_roL<., · IJo¥ /-hv_Mo~_~o~u/.A.. ~f,U~~Co.&Vlcr/id. _ __,__
             · · hy_/!1- Yu~~~4__j_ o/ MA- /d.L'a&-y_' o4tVs.;£ ()_£~u:.- · / ~~~~
           . ~hLtuiss_~tss~~ G)£~~~~ 6_7- /1 ·M/o/V,__,·"'--'...._·_ _
                .       .                 . . .   .   - . .                                .                                      \.                    '                                           .

             _·_~A_,~~· ·S/ZA/'L~4Lct£~~ .¥e:L_yL~ . /A/' :~L£ _ 1;}(~ f?~)gl-_~."---;-.-'-._
                      .      '     ...
             _ ol , ~h--1;/U/.4-'1 .J(6fuc.a...        ( "7'/J C.~)~-~
                                                                        ..   --           ).,

                                                                         f/7£ ¥3_r2._;::JCL-
                                                                       ...
                                                                                                                                       .':.~·               '

                                            '   .   .      (      . .                 . .---

            ----=-cl' c~~L 'DI..sZ~e-7' Cau~'<--L /;)·~ ~T ·C~,s.d'y~~·~-=-~-__,
            ___ £f.:/&~,_ /J.p,A44L__·th/J Co_~v;~i_~1L_ ~_(}Ai /Je.~.6£L.            '
                                                                                           _ __;__;                                    .            .                                .

            --~ '11 · ~ oL3      7J;,z C!"' ~,4&./!zs ., -?-/i_C!..~ fJ, s~r..Ufr__
                                                    4> •

    .•          _ EJ{ 1Ji. 'I·~. IJ/'h~ f4h. c~M-~L~n~~Afo~J. -I:A ~~~o S3L
            . L /L_/3_(1M~E/c.. \l' s r~a_c_e                                   .J l. ···-, '-
                                                                                                                                                                            ,. \··       -    ';·-:::; ' t   :   /t.';·."
            --~---------------~~----~----~'~--~--
         .                                                                                                  '
         '•
                                                                   ..
                                                                                                                                                                    -

-·       OA./_S£,a~6M.._L~ ZO/~
                               '

         ol' 'O..x_~~C_at9_Uo_~--<:;a. ~ t~- eOS:?_'l ·- c /1.~·fl£bkt?~-~4- d j ·-
                .                                       ..._               . .  .
                                                                                    7J;LCt!ZtLA.L

                                                                                    ...
                                                                                                            a£ eu~~¥!L.tlp(J£!1lt

        Cu£/za
          --.-    '
                 ~~-         f/iJI~.(d
                               ______lu.,~ llt~~~~~~
                                         --. -.. . . - - - .-.-~

     .    1At.hL-£ih
     _JJ¢__    '    -- .,__'~ ~ {d)_      1,_                           -                  '

                   /? fatt._. £JL4~s;~z;,;;7~hil_:_tt~-~.€ dM__o/IJ {)_,~r__~L
              U~tM.._h/:hr_.S.v~mLik~ SL.~L /1-faT~/Vs ~;__EML
              e_~k_Cl2)0;u                             t:>/ ._@&_·Ctau~r i'.£caddr                                       ~...,.~~~~£.
                                                                                                        •
                                                                                                                    -~
     ~c_a_~d.c_-b:b_ll-IEA-~r A_p~b"b~                                                                                   a./A.-iI   1-       o ~ C£,_floM-ILt'

              .b_~£ · {/_PZL~~~_Sc.,_~£-·
                                        . C~vt..L A-·~. £_~d___p£__b_:/,_~~ ..                     IL
                                                                                                                                                          -
                  SL~c£- ____Y:it_~y~-&~To&_ _c_hM _&~d s~ ~I                                                                        hfofrQJ-i/

     ~------=-(ffy_~-~~-- ~~--~~ k/-VI Cau~r--1!1-r¥/J. Ca..u4r.                                                                    ~-

    -_____~~Tli~--~--S££b~7---/3~1i&__Z£_c~~-z.h_~{)__&_A-L
    .--·--r~s-~~h~__ LiJ_____(J-4__d/U.~__ rlo___fl~~~L_.L-1____w~l-
    . __:___·-,ttf    C.u_ha~-:--f.C_'-Mk. ___{/h;~d' __:s_Litl)£:LCQ..i.?~L-~ ,C
                                                                                                         .,.,-       ,·.

                                                                                                                                                                                          ..
                                                                                                                                                    ..
                                                                                                                            ...                '~

                 !letJ£p:y_f_s_~o__tu_&__t:_ __o_LI~~h4:1' ·c<9~_
                                                               U- ['__j/.J..(

      ______,s- rJ£ ____~t.J~£E:d~VtA,{____Cf!UL4T..r;_~_f£ tvt:CL/!._                          ._£__    l__"/dt~ __-_ _
                    --·-!dtl-4~ dtL_o_[__~.L____(J..th_frg_t---------------_:____                                                                                 _   _ _ _ _ __
                            ' ' ·&u:..__'EdJ.Ltu~-'-~i- ao_(_J:~~A..-~I£~/41_£iZ/_o~---
                    __k_fh,(o/ :__4___ _A~~~~-?---~--f£!u1LrZ .£-'!-_:E__I'f./CL_fg.______
                                                                                                f                                        •

                    _ _po~LL£.1!-S__ Ziz-.t.'«L-~'L~.s~/-!-P"____(.__~~ Ce2/llfi_Sl ·~,_,..,~,____ __
                    -,___~  . l2£c
                         f~LL~L-   _ ___l!!1~~
                                             ____  Zlt~'
                                                  _L_          &__Q&L__~w~
                                                      .Li___ ~_.  '
                                                                  j ____
                                                                           h~cL -~ ___(26£...:__· _ __

                           . IU&ch__L'i/-ZatJ- ~Xl--      . . M_Uc/_/1£~L.£cL . . SL~k."-----'-.___:__···_ _ __

                            · l?-i_&;__6_; f _[.l)_l__~~it£o/ riO -±ft~b~o(L)c~o_£ ·-----'--
                    --~--=--~tj__ IJ£bk~~~-' ___
                                              · _____:__-'-,-.
                           - - - - -----~-~----------------~___(,£} )
                                                                                                     ~
                                                                  /]
                                                              H4(/t'/4r~SFd,u;~8-A&__,__ll~.---,---
                                                                             I

    ----'-=~'-so(v:/N:g.-~_j_f-_j:s_·__ mt~;s_Tiue:.L~u;____.ZM"'KL_Lh_f_4Y.£""'-'.z....__.. ---'---;-'---
    _ _____:{~-~.:__S.: LU_$d_.___i}_QS/_c_aJ__8~___-_:Tk?_~Yh.d_ta_·_co,v_s~~:_clh.A. /)y_o/"""-_--
                 .           .                -.    '   -~           .   .           ,         If                                       .

    -~ ilu{l:, __ _._vp..o_y_~/4__/1/!o_li..o~-~LS__N..or /!!l_c/ts_CA:I[. li D.M~~'--=-=1'-_--.---
    _ ____.,_l)e_'C_ s£k_--, __4:~_@-__ &ru_·_~:,_s-__slc.wJcL_l3 .3---~~'-------c-:._____ __

• . _ ----'--'·~i..tUil ____t:z__'Z_~ __s.~_w :;_tt~.__ ~;Iifl_C r£~ ~/l~_l9?flJ~.l~.16~__c_A~----'---
    ----'- 610.~-t;w_:__L~~ ----A~fJ-/iAL7----oh'ad'. ~~-,4~d£~__:kftli~.L__r___
                 El{.·CatV-~Ldti-u~?--~~-.a__ ~t:!Lv:..(.Y_.p_)_Li_.i .nt/u_/sZii;_;.Pil.t&:.L-1___ _
    ___
     . __      - -~4-~_~-h--~-~~L__ c_{!~~z IJ" ~--~ut:-4~ lo Ca,usdk_ _
          -_. __
      -~- ~~---~a_ _____ ufl()i.E:__~It__R!ft;:ft_f:?A.L_ tvii/t.Lf'...L_J9,~_1l£A.SoNAb~ ·
     _--.----~L-t-,SA.~-~7_;::_k_[b£u_ C~- v · b~c;_~_U__$_, 't~ ~""-e~
     ______________.~1)1~d_~_f¥J ___-L_$S_q_L.S__ejpl__
                                                     -k- C'o--~~ A: ---'---'---''----
                                     -                           '       ~       .                                                          .

                cu~~~ .4.tJus£ __p,C_@.seAft.._zz~~~a_&...; ..f-lt1i' · V/(JtA-r~
                                               '             -
     ___· et_~~~.-~ L¥--~IJ_(J~g_c£__6_y--'-~-Lv_6_,€u_~~ ~r"[,__·- -
     -~---~(fJ___Q{A~_____ B~~~Uff-'iZ_~~~L£.-dy~h ·~-{A_~._.S~,___,__~--
     ___·, Jo~iY..SotL1L__ EtS!:O~#,___C_~~~~L~-~- ~a£~ 7tJtJ5; w ;Jd__ __
     __--.____51b -r---TLZ _(1£_x_L1t!/l~_l_'l_B_f').~-~-ol_l_k_f2A-LI:5//y.~£~'f:__· _ _
              o{_gj_~cL_~-~J__:__~;£$_ufL__~f\./~-:-~--C(n~lJ~l~_~
                · ~·                      o·l' · ; 's_.. !U~J - · ·                  -- ~7«'--_-----;
              -P-~'-- ___ -~M..Cii..., _ _ -'-8--1"1JJ.-Mf'--_l£_ ____l~k::.~L-CJA.._,~-=-:r~="'""'-,.,.---,,--,---
                 -      . -        .     'ft.     . .     ·'           - . . ' -.~ \ -:oJ2t ;y '/ \
              0.(!__~-a,~__v_l<..L A:/(~ ___La:_g__s_ . . w zr/._t!J2~                --. ·>: :~::::~ . ,-. >··
                                         .                       .                                  .-.y,_,   ~·d      ~
                                                                                                                    •• •   ;/;·J   ~.

                                     ____________:_-;-_·--.----~($-)
-~~-
      - - .~f£f&roA..-_-:-Cof..L[£iJ_t::d_:__j~~-t:J---jja/;_;~l:f~aCL·L__~f±l-                                      ~L.c__·---------.,--
      __- ilM__;zivV__Q~/a_c/ __~_7€::fft:f~-ILM__M.:s_~_o ,£-~CtSL~"-'L 4-r-..Q_ .

      _ _______;fkR£ ~~;_---~~s_-~---~--f£_1P-
                      .
                                               ___4~~ -~ '1. 'ci1cc) uJ ~Ll--~
                                                                        . .                               .

      --~ur ___~(J___ ~d.£_c&vu.. ____ hlf._Lj_.~u..dL~~L-~A
      _·-._,-.   _/2~&--~-lll__:__c~-~~-'L-fJA¥---CP..S r_~f:tJ~~______:t:_6f.---~~L
      -~----:__c~~r__s__ ~_#{)____c~A.-r 4#~rc~--.peq;u_flL~-----
                         ..   ~            '..                        .   '

          _     _____:.,·~0-~   I ~S-~fJ-J:r__#_____________-;----                             ·

      _-___--_-&-~ob_.__co.l'd.r~d..J.______;,_£___(,~~_€~c,_iil£oLri:o_c..~k----
      _ _ fL£S~~~4-P-"-£~1.{:__~~_£)____ f.kl~~~!S-~~-&t£g __7J~--·_·- - -
       , . -~~ou_'M._cL__deL~~~rr___ ~__J!&i2~--~c~...r._--------'----
                 -n, . .~_~r_~~-T~s.~j)if.__LlM-_£~~/V"r;~;                                                       k~_- --------'-
•     - -_
         . _· .•...   ~-Yr()A,___f-o_    R£S€ALC6 .           ~;_;_· IJ~lLL;_J------'--

•   ..- ______·--~1_fo__~ C L-:__/:..b <2-~~-.o___ .tiu~_s
      _ ·_ · .   ____   · . ------------~:___-:-------. - - - -
                   · ____                                         .
                                                                              _,__It_:__.   __.0=---::...L-/,io__2!!: S c /. Ill:,' C/

                                          .            (
                       ____:__ ___________________ _____
                                                           &)._
 ..

••                                                     --             -------·------

          ----,··./2£~CfM..~I:.;_i'Jd-l,_~----lkr-qM--:.e~--~t-·Ht)-u~L,L '__/t;,_~4;{M_ __ bLt:f~~-'Lld£oL __Lj__tt.SI!_ /.bf.S rio~----
          __· -=:r_~/d4~--·~~ 7lti£ __7J. ;x~___(}_ft/)~'T~~L ~-l!._C_ · Qu ~,..tV'-=·.-='4:.. . :.____
                                                                                                   1    _
          _ __.·"J(L4...'L.~clf._A:r_rM.__ rc_~-~-ll~t/Rt/f_.,. lb£-C..tv~_-.----'-------,--
              ~~ . 'fJL_·_~_l:6~~---s~l'k<~v_i£a~ A~_/&._~Ld....~ -                     _
          __-pLL.o_v_L dJL~ . --C~fJLU,__ ,{;,~__it£(ArtM-~--J!£.&r-ziu<.._·~~~
          _ _ c-b__e~g-~_·j,~_/:_J__ __.;T&oiJ...p~L..·_~_-c/o£:£ .N.oZ:__bAY-h..~--
      .        · '?."· ?J,t~d . .../l~z-r-___4&:L.C#4:6E_:_tkt__/9-Lq__. Ce.xplU_,(;_,c_jli~--
          --~-~M4.._·_[c__b)_~_· -r---'---·-                                                              .           ·               .    .   . _··.-;--._ _ _ __

          ---~-                         ------------

          - - -~n._i/,iS_L____ /!£MOMS . _,_jJ/I.k.S£~JLd..,_,4uLJ_k_-rAL1JYdi_ __
          _   ___,Q /'~:Zt_~n~L __~Io-f1U~L-~£~.fl~ ,. R£1Aw~ ..(J£hl·£c~J'=-·-~­

          --:-.JhiJ, CQUI!kr~~::o___c_~u.:s~d~__'flt.ll ,4Lb.k...~AL-~9~L_r_·~-
              .. I   I/             . '          17-   ,       . §)., /,'   /'.          ,.         . .                            ' .
          _ _"t:h..fk.._/l£.~uP-S..t:£a--~ll..kJ_-_o-.-:-::---·                                                                  -~-----------,-----
          --,--.-,----·W · lo · (!)/l.du_'~An.. · ~~/ ·c-~~7 1-o oA.d'OA..___._·..f-6..=!.~£.______ _
          ____,___·. Di£rA.d~LCU4~~-·;72t_Q_m_tH_ A. _h;(d~ __dbe.a_·.·--,---.--'-----~
          --~-··_.__..Lt9-u~Z" Rk/)..trM,Z:u___g~ 9-;~)(hLd._fu_·~~~V£~~'.>1-·                                                                                                             __

          ----,-------=&=J.4]D/L _w_i_f:A- ·___ F/f/££ ___fl..t!t(J~__CoP-;/ZS.. o~ ·+4 £. . ·.
          _ _ _··_..:.__~A--l___Ct91J~~r . _e_u;_L~~_t:l2floA-l'/i.A-s ··Ike~...._-_ _
                                        •    '         •   •          •          •            'II                 '         ••

          ---"----1!17Y....o_:__TM.kL_'~··.s ~.~J.At ·
           _ _·(_J__)_ _[)~---~.~~~--*hfi.___L/L 4 TlLA_ __~_Ciapy~ ~-·44                                                                                           ·~-~~/,_____
. • :· ___                ,. bc._~k..~I±T~xL
                                      d_ •
                                             __apo..~TiiA..s_fl/I._co_Ad_..{_eo~--_(~}.
                                               -/ /_ ,      .        ,
                                                                     .        ,     ''./(' \.• 1 'fif.(.-_ ·:.
                                                                                                      JV/. ,                                        ·.·7,'"·.        1.       '··C'        ~
                                                                                                                                                                              ·'JI"-':...::_.;l,      ,
          - - - - . . -y-$1J.N __j__tY_y.__J:PTl;...__~ 1M. CoA..d~                                                       ,1-:o___C_dA.,L__....:...O            • ~ ,;-:~::, •· , ·.                      .
                           ·~ .                                                                                                                                 ~   .,. ·_ r::.·. --:'·if; , ,. ~ ·
                                  ~-----------------                        ' . -l:_q~                                           ,,.('\'
                                                                                                                                                                                 . \'
                                    '   ·,
                                                                             --
                                -----~------._:_.-~----------------------

                                                                                                                 .
          ~_Lr;,_.r~~LL_j,/n;£_,1/_c:c_c£s.1., rbr:>-C~~ S,/fJ.M ,, f..f.---=~=-:_'-------'--'----,
    ~~~-tA~d~~-:i~M_-;~-Al:_ _L:foa F~ 6~-~ld_~,v ~ .
          . 7769.3
                                                                                                             '       '

    --~-~tu.
           _ _ _'h~1iA.L'--=. -~-;-~!_~~~-e.g ~~cea:S)_d~M&Lr fL ~JO.,<_-=--_·-~--
-. ,__-P~'.s_ ~'fdt~l-                 4l-L_~_!Ptf7i_~_/2~:f.ih~~                     _/:s:   -9~ uoL_. ---;----------'-
           ..s   0   if.iJ /2~~d~----~-----· _·_- ·.                                              . ·-'---
                      .                   .        ·  - · r/_ .-. . ..- / ' / / J; / r1L,. I
                     ----------·----------.,-~----.------------~--~·.n~/--~EL~--v-U~I~'-----
                            .    .                              -            r·· _. ,         ,      '·,         .

                                        .,        . . .
                            ~-~-------------------------·---
                                                                LiL._d~
                                                                '   -                                        -       -       -- ...

                                     · ·___. ____:___~__:_·---~-- __/)o~~C:ZIV'~--:-~O_MM~U'-=--~-
                                . _____
       · ---------------~-----~------~-~~--_c_ _ _IfJ_c_-s.~Mo_..__LB_I
    ____                                                                                                ?_~d_Z _ _ _ __

•                                                                                         =

    _..       1;~__11Q&£ ~our__/dQuM~~~cr_do_6~-Y--i:LILn.4--tJ_g_£/J-'-.- -
    ----~.~-£---~~443 U.S.   307 (1979)             ~taMdard

prohibit a reviewing appellate court from re-evaluating the weight and credi-

bility of the· evidence presented at a cr:iminal defendant 1 s                                    jury trial· upon

considering an        insufficien~y              of the evidence point of error." In                        a~,       the

Texas Seco~d Couit of Appeals ~uled that their court of appeal~ can not re-

evaluate the weight and credibility of the evidence and substitute the                                                  judg-

ment for that of the factfinder.                        See Tex.       2nd COA Opinion at Page                  6~7,    Bonner

v.   State,    Appeal No.         02-12-00534-CR (Tex. App.- Fort Worth,                           Dec.     27,       2013).

                                                              IV.

           Defendant is urgently in need of his trial court clerk 1 s                                   and reporter 1 s

records to aid him in preparing and filing his pro se petition for writ of

certiorari,       and to further argue his preserved insufficiency of the evidence

ground for review and to amend/supplement on the claim that the State wholly

failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he                                    possessed a firearm after

conviction and before the fifth                        anniversary of his release from confinement

following      conviction of the felony                    and/or release from parole.                  Thus,         without

the trial court clerk 1 s                 and reporters 1 s records he will be precluded from

meritoriously arguing this insufficiency of the evidence claim to the Supreme

Court of the United States in his pro se petition for writ of certiorari.

                                                              -2-
   ,.   '
                                ·. ..__

                                                       v.
            The defendant's    questions and       arguments to the Supreme Court of the

United States are not frivolous,                and also the defendant has been already de-

clared indigent prior to trial,                at trial and on appellate review to the Texas

Second Court of Appeals           and the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals.                  Therefore,

he should be provided with a free                copy or loan a         copy of his   trial court

clerk's and reporter's records,                and in order so he can adequately,                effectively

and meaningfully present the substantial question to the Supreme Court of the

United States in his pro se petition for writ of certiorari.

                                                   VI.

            The best ends of    justice will be served by this honorable Court and by

granting this motion and ordering the District Clerk,                        Thomas A.    Wilder,     of

this Court to furnish          the defendant with: ·a free          copy of the trial court clerk 1 s

and reporter's records or loan the                defendant a         copy of the trial court clerk's

and reporter's records          for       forty-five      (45)   days by sending the records to the

defendant's       TDCJ-CID Charles T.          Terrell Unit's         Access to Courts Supervisor

Yolanda James,       1300 FM 655 -          Terrell Unit,        Rosharon,   Texas 77583.

            WHEREFORE,   PREMISES CONSIDERED,             Defendant    prays that this motion is

granted.

                                                                        Respectfully submitted,

                                                                      a4vlldtlk~
                                                                          8[;
                                                                        DON ANTHONY         ;R
                                                                        Defendant -- Pro se
                                                                        TDt:J # 1819637
                                                                        1300 FM 655 -     Terrell Unit
                                                                        Rosharon,   Texas
                                                                                        77583

                                                       _-:;,:_
,· ' ,, .                                                      c·
                                 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

            I certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing pleading was

placed in my TDCJ-CID C.T. Terrell Unit Mailbox for processing through the

TDCJ Mailing System, and for forwarding by U.S. Mail to the District Attorney,

Joe Shannon Jr., of Tarrant County,       Texas, 401    W.   Belknap Street,   Fort Worth,

Texas 76196-0402, on this 4th day of October,          2014.

                                                  ~      -~er

                                          -4-
                                        CAUSE NO. 1269186D

THE STATE OF TEXAS                                                  IN THE 432ND JUDICIAL

vs.                                                                 DISTRICT     COURT        OF

DON ANTHONY BONNER                                                  TARRANT     COUNTV,TEXAS

                                               ORDER

         On this         day    of
                                     -------------- ,   2014,   came to be heard Defendant's

Post-Conviction Motion         Rsquesting for      Free Copy of Trial Court Clerk's and

Reporter's    Records and To Aid In         Filing a Pro se Petition for          Writ 0 of

Certiorari to the Supreme Court of the United States                 11   and it appears to this

Court that this said motion has merit,              and so it is ORDERED that the District

Clerk,    Thomas A.   Wilder,    of Tarrant County,        Texas,   to provide    the Defendant

with a free    copy of the trial court clerk's and reporter's records and by

forwardLng    the trial court's records by U.S.             Mail immediate as possible to

the Defendant Don Anthony Bonner -- TDCJ # 1819637, 1300 FM 655- Terrell Unit,

Rosharon,    Texas 77583/loan the entire trial court's records to the Defendant

by forwarding      the records to his TDCJ-CID C.T.             Terrell Unit Access to Courts

Supervisor Yolanda James at 1300 FM 655 -                Terrell Unit,      Rosharon,   Texas 77583

and for    forty-five   (45)    days.

                                                                  Judge    Presid~ng

                                                                  432nd Dist,ict Court of
                                                                  Tarrant County, Texas
,I

     ,   I
                                                                                                                                                                            '
                                                                                                          ~
                                                                                                         /,epee'- (r                                             '

                                                                                                                                                                c:~·:
                                                                                                                                                                          )~i   • 1   "
                                                                                                                                                                                      • '

                                                                                                                                                                          ·!

                                                                                                            II.   Ol

    ---------~------------------------------------------------------

    --------T--~n~~=~~C~~~~£~~~--~o~f~~~~~~'l~~~~-+----------------------------l
                               5v-dtJM..d ~~)£__ -h:Vc/ 061/i (~Py £?d, o/. !}czy
    ------j------!11L.··L~·,/I.L!.j,J.A;~· /JcwzvtkL 1/zh/,(;tV/iA 's· iJuL-..sa. II% fZoA/
    ------l------'lu~/;~-¥r--tJ'JI'(.d/'(/£_~_/~.A./9 /Joc.£L.h4&<.~/t /lzw-q h.c&~h, ~.0
                                     AA~ v/1-             o / ' 4ALLJ6i// ly /0 ,LJ~           C(J1ted(     C&6l- ·                                                  __
                                     &v~~:J_ hU..r . 7Ju Ji.,tlj£.. & / . {~tlV/1. /.,.. 6/J:i' 91 vttv-1¢-                                                               .
1- _- - - - - + - - - .               l_l-tf2Af~~-;21£a.4-rli-';;iiuA[_k-4-fl£4:L._I'.lYA~-/Ji;_/n/uM ___ ___                        H   __________________          _

    ----+~li                                        M9M ··h hU              /l-   lJ.;A,/f   ol he£rtJ{~.~··._____
    -------+-----1-J/-t 5£/AALl   1-o 17z-l-;ct£ 1/. ti '/_ o/· 7lta. f&.xAf Cot:/£
    ------~----=oi_~~L~-1 //{..~) C/itdr/{,t. ~ ;:Jtz,f.r'll hU ./tt£.1/£
                /JAJ!tE.f.J' /k-dJ 6-u;,9 1-o .fit? C&t//Z~--""'U""'-'1F.~r:~V1L_{_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ,
               /9-i4tV Ito·;,__/- .:f do c;&t.&70~a:.(~'d?- r~vc___                                                   _______
                                     -f..t,/~li   ;hvrJ   /HJ't~fA-&'C£   dl/     -.14/J ll?/f.:/~--~-.:.::;'X4'-'-------------
                              I
       ---+-----------------------------'--·-----------------

             ~....                                                                                  "•
                                                                                                                  .   ~:.   ··:-- .•~.. • ;:!}. ;, ''· ;••• -
                     .. ~ .... :··                                                             "•

I
                 ..

      •
                                                         I

                                                   ...
                                                ,..-

                                                                                                                                         .IJ.v/ih,/,                                      I

~.(~-~.~~~/~------~-
_.,  .    '/
                   ..--~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~----------------~------------~----~---------
                                                                                                                  ,. ......... _. •. ~   .::......,;,.;;:.;~   ·----~-...oc:-:-...:   .... -'<~   ·:..:-- • • • •   -·   i'-":·, ......., . ..;._

                              .   'k

           ..•

      J
                      ,..-.

                                       '   ~-                R,o,,'                     ·'·f.. ..

                                                                                             ''.... ,   .~-   .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ., .

                                                                      .   :   ..   ~.

                                                                                                                                                                           .   ;, ; ~    ··. ::                          .. . . . .
     •

                         _..,..·   .. }"J
                                   )'

11~:~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~--
J;                  .-    •

.         ..
     ~·~-·:

                                            '   (/.)

                                                (3
                                                                                              1
                                                                                              .,~··
                                                                                         (;
              '•,

                                                       -.,·   .......
                                                                        . ',   ' ... ·
                                                                        !

               .                        ~

     •                                                            ( .ZJ. .1t·clt~ rnA?hr../r
                                                                  (¥;                          ("
                                                                                               ~lf;4/LC .             -:6.   WA/'~/....,r /9-.-v a                                                             /1- f'Ca/.4 t/, f.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ..

                                                                  (S)                          CcOiJLJ                c C CoIV(//c 7/r~.I                                                   /J.;.;./       o      7~a'YHM://
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           . ..  ~·
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         "
                                                    ('-1)           lr.:.l-r' h                     (I /Vb._                    w;!/l;t£.                              · li~ Jv~-4c~                                              /~ ~/~r; 1.-o
                                                                  fJAAkcr                                           tt_,, lt.~ I? r rt£.rL '
                                                                                                                ~/..!            A-:iJJJ/£,4-/                                    $W-S'/G.
                                                                   /[,{:;(CJ;(d'f /-17¥/l r C/C/~-t-f?" Oo c..£Y ,-J;?~/S.. A;»-; .a d.,wN:/
                                                                                  ,.
                                                                   A r~n,£/J/../1/'_;,.;
                                                                                     , ~/
                                                                                             k;/.),.t,4"( LJ/f.&a..J..(' ;

                                                    CSJ                 fo/l                    f.-ht[f/;_                   /lf. .;?-:{(},-<./                     /Y"/.I~;V"J/ P/V                                  h_ f-t'h tJ/;_,M                                    I'1!..4-(-_,  ~i-     l

                                                                   dA--'J                           ./4)/                    roc.,..-tr                             tu;(/                             QA--4/../·T              -./-41'1                      /M'ltf1/Mr
                                                                            //V.
                                                                                    '
                                                                                                 /II/ .£4,/:./~1 ,
                                                                                                                                                                     ,.-;
                                                                                                                                                                     ~'> () /               I'·
                                                                                                                                                                                             '/(                 .1/d••A-v/£//,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ..                           '

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ..

                                                                                                                                                                                                           .kHc. r4~, .£i~;&A
~•;                                                                                                                                                                         .... .           /Sl·.···l·~·
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ........ ! . ..                                    'r•"·-..---··"

 --                                                                                                                                                  ·-··                                                                 '   .                                                "

                                                                                                                                         -'                                                                                                                         ...

                                                                                                                -                                                                                 '
                                                                                                                                                                                                            '4)(.-- -.~1-AC?~
                                                                                                                                                                                            ,-                  rLL     //(./              //              f/r L lfM,l
                                                      .J!l&i.f                   t':);(,j           --../-t/r                '•.:.<·J---=·'- dr~                                                      0    l' ..{'Lf'T.                  .2vlt/ 11//~(
                                                                                                           ..                                  .,.. ...
                                            .       /''.k         ~~
                                                                  . tkJsA4~Jv -~-1-A..>Vf/
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        \,,

                                                                                                                                              !'lJ                                                                            ./...... 7~.            ,..-
'·
     ·~   ·.                                                                                                                                                .
                                                                                                                                                            ....'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ..                   ......   ,,;.-
 •

          \
        .j

   '.:~I
··";               ,, .

  .....

       ....... .

                     1-" ' ,'
                                                                                                         .,.
                                                                                                         J..AI
                                                                                                                 >/77~
                                                                                                                 '11•   >

     1/.S.         )

             • T         l

        /l ~l·fQ6J~~'.$                                                                      t\-'.;;.          ~~;;v/ '1~~-;~                 ·, 7_~'----,-----
         lh/.J~~ y           bf.#(.JA/ $'C/I;.;{pZ1                  U            teglfl..t . r IJI/f                       /JoCt:.rP"VV(i&~'S.· J;v      ·· -

                                      .   \   .. ·               '                               .   ~

       .v, ·~; t); r''?t{;Ji: _?&t;;..} ·-~~:.1' . *!~~4:4 ~i/~,. ~~~;A.;.,s~,dZl~­
       .i!V o!tcTWV~A4'F·'·irt~A:.i ·\a~t6ivc.-.. t_~f/,/fi: -~~~;.;_.~b~:ts~;·~Ji14jj4··· . .
       /k:J(/,oh.HL4. /IJJ£~V\_,~z~~· /l ;_~~f:.·til'6ifi'··;4,. \~~ ~d&. ~.;[;·;
       ~ ·-M/r /k;,,:,.J,. 1,/v ·s-,>,~~~i~ ~/ ~1.4P7';;_._ ·lit);
       st 0 Lt./ . ~Aiu'! W!o~,r.)L~it~>~. ~· .-·'---------,----.:.:....._~---
                                                             c--
                                                             .. .!!._>
                                                                    ·· •• -       .-· __:>._·_ ·-.·_ ·

                                                       ,,.
·--------~~~··----·--~--
    . tll·. ·-b.~-ltll'~, r:IA~tJiA" 'd.6YI/i.~:,;:::
    · .· '· I.e . 'Mit ..C' ff ul!. m. C~ FTr . .· /llt;/(,':1/A. :f:_--:~-.:::._.:. . ··• . -..
                              '       •                      '                '   '          •                              •   •   ·-   ·~   j.

                                                     ...                              {l.)                                                             . .-   \

                       ...
 :   :·-----,-----;--'---'--------;----~-----­
        ' +64. · /Jr.;AA,;.::.r r;t_;r · ok i&i; rN~Io 1/oA/;
                           ~     .,       .
                (     .·   ·•
                                                                                                                      1

          ·· (;/).'~tv;~/ ...1A.-- s·~;?M"'"'-;r ·oL'· Ho lrt.~/.._~

                                                                                          f.·-                  . ,...
            .
            f.:
                     . .        ~-- ...                     '·   .

             /J..p;i;~&. 6 64Tf£ . lt~if..c · ..J1                             liAr' t-/.H /A·~ lc teA- /M J~..t 67.-/~.6ttA4
 ,....-. 'C~;;I.r. i~IJ;i:. ;f .:~~i'~~~4J· ··#A'fn~:J1~4-~-- --iJ/i. ,L'£f#~:.(iJlf'..c!! dv~~­
         rtf\.,fr:J · ~a- · ./lJi.c.C?,. 611/ · .dA. sc.~ Ri4d/'. Jp:/o~d ~- #'$$~,._//;4/
         ~ ,6,~·- 4., :~4d/4c4:. ·~4~ .6/tk~~~f;- .Mille,-~·: .:1~! .v/~ I                              .       '         ...      .

                    {Q . ·-.?t~-              ·._     i¢./wA//&. .·.$:J::,jAt(J.. -t:>"~:!;if.f'/( 'I· -··; :·,·.: ... _·,.                           .· .

                -#JA'i\.,.:s ~Aftf ·~ · -" vt:hri.·l -k -~J!..~iy : -11~;!2·t~~9~ .A'J3#J!-;.~ / b;r~
                     1 .              ·             /J"·     :' ' / · _ . · • II          ··      l .       .                                 P ''l
                    ··fJ14bti-4& ~ 4/f.r,/ .:cw t'fl1-~£1' f                                   .. /&,s"JAJ; . .!i£.--f'tJ~tt/4·. -.~Hn~ALtffA.
                                                                                                                    e.:         ... · _   .
                                                                                                                                                                 .
            . /!A yUrt~-·                           Aiy'J> .t4~~L~ fJ , ·(J(I
                                                                    / . ;;;f4k' ...        t. 2lJ .         (!OMSU 'rabtJ~A
            ·.tv ill Ott, Vu;/n,tM-~;9 -~'-1eiald: /k~~vfl~r Ar~- i~".:: __·
      •
             ·AI"- stdlvj ''Ai!.r · ~y.· of !/J64fft ·. -C:~lt4 >~ ·;a;;,~(i: ;; .
                     . i , ,_ , , . ·-: . , ·Le:J              < ~ . .., ;· : .                    r ,·: . , ,                                               I       • ..   .

l .                                                                                                                                             ·t:
.·;,_.--'.-'   - - - - - - - - - ' - - - - - -

                           46.s €_;vet£ c £ /J£ C:t!JCL~ T /It.~.!Jfir
               r..;;W~t' ·4::> +fr~t                             .         f.i_.c?tt&Lf __
               d£su/6tt/ ~-/k:;_vA:. s~~ ·./€~.:!fi:!;~ ~L·,~:-.!:~it::if·q~'.~.~?l~{~( ·

                . ~f._.:£_·:~~-~·-.~~~~.~~-·~~~:~~~~~~~~­
                          .:.·~t,f:?~"(~ .· .·.: :··~c{r4/~,-c.                                                    ,SJ~~f:?J :·~tk~f ~!. &tffu(.i.~t?A/.. ·

              t$;,,v -~lr~        z C't:",,··.r ·~.~·-· ~dc.Tik~- Jf;.~:. ··.~:. JJ,:. ~~~c A~.,-~~                                                   . .:: :'::\:· . ~-:: : '\,·'>:<- .:--                                ... ·..
                                                                                                                                                                                                        ···.
                                                                                                                                           '        '   ....   ~~   ..                                         \
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              :   ~         "' .

                                                                                                      ·.· ..                                                                         -:-----
 '   '

         - - - - ; - - - - ' - - ; : - .------:-;-.--~---___:__:_-,--                      _ _---:--_ _ _ _- ; - -_______ _
           t:,· /Jo;r IJ, Aa~,./;4:4 ,1:/.., · ~ _/;~ . c.,e;-e,'l~ IIA-1-· /l,t.
           ~~1A_f-eJ;;I;,9 ·/~f ·.k.~t£- -~~:-'A ·cl~~~r _n:~4 WM. sr~.v-~tt'
          ··Jy "i)~CJ-;.../5' . ....,J%~ SAR?lYA.;l~N·. n) '· t/;. f) .·.l)(il.r~t~:l !lox . ..

                                   ...
~------'--_.:____c:_S_-·.                      _. "'-:··--"· ···-;_-·-·
            ·. (f~~~i>
           ..
                     ··- ~4:      --~,d'·.
                          ·~ llR~·t.r.~:,:                                . ·· · .

                                                                                                                      . .   .   ..

                                         . t                                                 .       '·

                                                        ~   ./   ...
                                                                              ' ...... ..- .f~:M.tl -fJI/ii_f.:'
                                                                             . ri·.t
                                                                                  .   ',     .   .        '  . :; .
                                                                                                              .   .              .               .      .

                                                                                                                                     ~·   .' •       \,., ~ i~   ,:.r _; ;
                                                                   (Y}
                                                                                           "')_   ,   .

                                                                                                            \,

    . lllih~   ~·~ ~. . )'• · .     :'   'l.ti4·<'~~(~   ,.· 'v ,t4:   .. -~: ~ ~-·· -1/.yfljJif.l.~ ·. i.u__!L__
    :Zct Sv,4dtvt7'             ,(;4I_ :~M;j · ·;j;afPt1: ' - / ·:h.~ ./i~),.y J,,-/,)t..r
                 At"-L...
           _ _._L·_.                           ~oAL-n / ~Ay9,€.v4J.                                                                                          <            tuh'M -..r~uuxiAA~+TA.d. ·
                                                                              --'-~,.---'-'-----~--.,---c-'----":c--"--,-~-c'--                                                                      _ _ _~----

          . __:~~--------:£ cl£~c/A& <" ~-4/4, -q~/J ' ~'vd.y: ~ -..J4..L_ ., .
                      . ~ ?81"& 9 )• /.a i£ ~I£ _·_ ·A:by4 c~~r. . ,F;.Il,dund ·- ·.
          _~. ______1l1V~..T1tiJ..                                                                                 . ·~·
                                                                                           ----6 ot~ Q£ . /lf~~~r=.<                                                                                        ·-1---.'.       --'----·

                                                                                                                                                                     ··_· -· t1   fJ. ·_ · . ·.A. ·_-CJ .. . .
                                                                                                                ·-:... t.fd.YtnU··:CA:•~
                                                                              ~---.;.;..-'--·_. ~-'-----~~-~-:-'---;--_,·I>J.D-""o~-'"AL-L,-_ -~-··.7h~A-LY • AD~_·· ·                -,!-c•I}&LL·

    \.
                                                                              .'--""--'-'----'---"-~----:-'------:-..,......:.....~~--"--t::---=IJ"--"C~::J~-·--"-.:~M~--
                                                                                                                                                                       ..(;,                         4 ·.   01 81'lK5 7
                                                                                                                                     .       : :.·.
                                                                                   _,·,'   ..·

           ·---·- .':---:-.---.-·

                                                                                                                   .·,_:·,

           - - ·- - - - - ·

                                                                       .-      '   ..                          .
                 .... ... ..............................._ ...........-------"---------~----.--c-----------~--'---,-:-'~•c·c·---'--'c-·--cc·~·.c .... -,-....·,,~--,c.....___ , _______~------,----;---"~c:..___...:.;i2;;;,::::.;,_.c...,~..-.,-

                                                                .                                .    .                      :   .           .
                          . -··-   ........ -~---·--- ... ________________:.,.:.......____ ·--~--::.: ..:· ._ _______~ ___;_:.~--··
                                                    : .... ,,                                             __                             _            ........   ~   ... -: ··-                                     .   .      ' . .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ·-·---·----·            ..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           --------·--~-·--------------   ....... .
                                           ·-···:··           ----·---.:.....~-~-·

                                                                                                                                              . '·

                  ...
                            . .·   '                                                                                                -..,...
                                                                                                                                    ·-
                                                                                                                                  .. -                               .·.1
                                                                                                                                                                            ··,   '

                                                      X
                                                      f-        ---G.!.
                                                                 ~

                                                      z
             ..                                       Ci         ~
                                                      ~          '.
                                                      !L1J
                                                         '       ~
                                                      -
                                                      a
                                                      -.L..
                                                      ~
                                                                 c:;
                                                                 

                                                                                                                                                     .. i