Court Opinion

ID: 4056286
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:44:35.295811+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:35.582172
License: Public Domain

''
                 . ,
                                                   IllJ Tile·               · 5·,4~5-0J 1
 .          ,.          --t contains some
,. 1his docur:\CII f poor qua\lt)J
     pages that are. o .
                                                .&a p-f oF "/lllf!.th~~OURl'OF'
                                                                     t_Q ~ ~rEcEIV[J IN .
                                                                        17fJ!-'·      ~PPEALS         ,,..
     at the time of ,magmg.
                                                       FoR
                                                        ·.
                                                           171e ·
                                                                                                  iJUN 0 1 ?115
                                            e,.;~r~1Nthl   Apprlli.S tJF IBXa.S
                                                     · fflliJ/e~:
                                                       ·..... · : . ;. rn.:·. .. ,. ·· · ...   ,Q.~ A\"""~·~
                                                                                               ~-h"U~&C4,
                                                                                                               c1err\~

                       tneria.lTMrtes ~rod Ley _;O Pe·llhffleR
                                                       t),
                 7/k g+a+-e. tJ f: ~a.s .:.              (feSpo!lfde/i/1
                  ·fi1R t/,o.7t.U:)I- +II) 7/!e 1~3rd!Jisfrlc.i Gou~e+
                                flay.rfs (]oU~ -re:to.s- ilw.c../dn
                 7f.io1 (]OiiJJ atJvS -e JL) um ~ er; 1$ a~ q a7 ;_ (1 ·
                                    ·Dngi:val Bppfi_ca:fittttFOr fi}J/~<
        1o 71/e fltmOY'a hie Lrudgi! oPi?Q~J O"u 14s :                     .
          · f_ome_ T\Jous0r/e.Pia .. zr~ Bmcltog Pe+rl-/lvteP Pr:o~S!f .;zA)
        Ilk akl"ue. -S4yl~ JUuMb9r&u se (!)F fl-c.!Jfn-1andRk ~ -!ltJS 6/11] JIVtJi
       -Roo1iea-l-iOYI 8R mc:vndamus PUr~UtVn.-fk fltltte ;;, a rx .:5ee_f!tn
       ~. C. bF ~· "'"!etas We ~F t2rtm1ioaP Pr(!)~€dure Mit/IAJt1uidihow-
       ~               Chu V'+--Jtve. FO II ow 1AJ_g:             .         ,           ·
                                                             '

                                                           ::r
 Ttr1     blel'tll~ Bnulteu !Ylij 7:D,.f!.,ZAJumher/sL113?5JI/. 7711
 :IIlJr!..o.vYl e.ra +Ed i!U #Je 7kxo£ Depar+rnrwl oF eY't m1r:vttP Ili!.!J./-/AJ ·
  AA1cl is appmrfN9 P,o .,te, Who {lM1 biL ?c;ct!J-k d a-t #J£ Po/tJJOsf~
 3i7~ Ftr/ 3s-o .5ouJtt-LfUINg5~, 7&c!S1?5Si.                  ·               . ·
 ·. Ml-1/lmer has Exmu:1-ltd ffi~ };mle RemEdb- tM!d/1/IOE!. mtJ
 titP,er f.ideqJ.Jak Pe mBdy cd UJLAJ-; 77k /1d .5oughl b he Com-
 }J-Q J/ed &m/AJ1~fer toJ, AJd ~s t!.rs.f.IMam .fAJ/I)a/ure, -z-~c,P~
 Rr.J //,(}, 7r ..Sec-hem 3-e.. fectJit~e .s ~Res {J07lde»> R; fmJ?Jcd-
- ta-f~lf1 7rf!At.sm/lla !#e t5t!Jurl e;Fdr;MJ';vaf) 1/ppeafs~!l eop!f
 t!JF.the f/pp/tL£11-iaYl For Wr</f t!JF fhhBaS ee;ttp!IS, !I.U!/ /!/115Wers Jl/e:/
 lbud 1,1 a>rf-i tl (1_Q te. re~fr;9 4k CJa.J.e u ~t!Yu.vhfcV! #!tbl f/AA:tlj;5 ;t'as
made., Y.f' JIJe         t!orrULt:-l-tJtJ9 GCJUrf Df:2ctCJ~ #1a:I-IJJe~ are !Vo ts.suPS
-lob~ resolue.d, tuo C!.aPy t?J-94e rlppf/c_a-/-lo-~~ Far IAJpf!CJ!/Jai:Jea .
~v-pu~ tlMIJ /Jit)jWeY'S Fl/edtAJas tJIA1d II ~Brl/'/lcaisLf>Be..PI/Ngthe
 fJ rrk .fAP(Jy'f w lt! ;LV! #toJ RAldtio!l wa£ 111ad-e. hat..JE be.e/U frtJ)[}Smf#td
--;t:;#Je t{){Jrrfof:aJcrn tAJaP . /lpp6 eal£ t   .
                                                    Ma:J st~c.U IJ CJc.U
                                                                   .
                                                                         meJtJI- bee td+rnv-
 ~fYI~+fed 1o the (Jaur4 ?JF r!rttriJAJaJ /Jppeaf£ h!l#!e~5,PMdell.fi- /IS
 Ke~ulred bw ~+a-litk, Pe-1-r~Ov,~r L:XJc.Aidh!ire reee?ued !l)oh~-e
Ft1cnv1 +he. ~Yl+ ~ r Cr1m 11\Jd.Y fi--PP ea Ls,
                        .                :JZ.                 .                .
                         .·                             (J    IJ

  7lk /(eJ {JOI1c}e llJI-fJI2tJdPI 11AK!ef'lSt:lYl- lJ1.s .fr1Ll /!#(!; r /!/ey oF
 i.bYJnts r!:ouNf(J ~xa£ has IJ/7/lu!s-fert'a}, Dul-y lo J?ecEfllt tMJd
  File AJif)rAP£tl1f) 11 r!.r1mJidJ fJm~,.,;gM!dloiJe;r:Po/Jnt/111
~er JJuf1es \vn ptl.S e.d' GY1 He, fkS 1J'l.si--f1 1L+ lf-UC'YY'Neq I:J y LJ4LJ
.PursullM+ 78 h'ec/ 11 /JRI, &,aJtf/!Jtl:S f1~J..$pmsfbl~ t/,(Jder 7:t,6fl
IJ, (')ry, ~ec: ..3. (c.) CMwl (oj 1Y¥~ m~~ll)+e If/ 7MAJ..51J1!-iltJ lk. ~~)ot
Crii'YI~1\laJ Ap pea.Ps ~ r!,apy &F.U/!.S f/pp lie.a -liM FOr Wnl1- e~f JP beq s
C,D'l'prAS. /JAJ!f llAJ.SWer>s Hied and-lk e!erllfie.a!e. flet;lh».fi!Je
~~ llfr/Yl Whicl1     -/W    FiiJdJ~j VJas made frP/k_ tJt7YJUJLiJNj f!ou!'H
dec.1de~ 4/tai 4-h.ere.. are lllcJ tssves he fJei!,{!)/u&ikAJ
                                                to                            liPe tJ!s ..
~7Lf ~+leVY' rue_~ FOr #aJ'Yiis t!pudg, '!;he_ he stEflul!d 1-/er P1ac..-e oF
 B~uue.ss d ~~~I Pra 1\J k1fl\), Su/k tooo, lhYslrM, /@',rqS '77tJ(Jd.-11B3~
.3
     .1

E.
        C~ur-f oF Cr~MimaJ llppea.P$
                      /l()_g-/IAJ/7i)tls

      :Zlf/efl~ifvnPS&adLey do _!SUJeaf/l UJVcleP 6a4ha-/- #te ·
   ·FOe~ be_t iUgP~e.I\J.fly /)JatJrc.era+ed/,o 7: {L {_, J:deeJare
              0

   urod~r Pe.Na.f-ly oF {JerJury #tal ac.tor-dJ~g-hay bEul!.P-Vhe
  Fac_JJ ~+a+-e:J /){)-!IJ£abe;ue /Jpp//whm /iJr 14J11/?foFI!laAJdt!hl/!.S
  Cl~ 7i'>uE cvndC6rrec_+-
                                            -51gJVed cm~:a~                 :Jal£

                                             ~f~~/
                          CQr+rfiaah. o£3etLltte
     :r_ hEre ~ (l_~ffl-(y-Mttl fJ 7fioe &31!1 of/IJe ahoue RPP 1/iea-HOYJ f.6r WR N
 6P~MU.S-Wt\Sg~~ued&bm///t>               .Sh:He txP 7£;ras buplac..t}f)gn LaP!:J
 iAJ#1B.. U,~, Mat( oJ.Jy,eSSfo ~e_ ffarrrS 6tll)1}/g!Jt~-fr>JLt C!fErk tJ rg.o 1 ·
 FraJVkliro.t:rk R{), t2ox   1f(pt:f~ /ltXtsi-rrM; ~a.s '77!J.JO- 'lfC.,S/6/1.1 m~
.... a. f}   !J0/5'
                    e.tJse mumber J3U~'J.=c.
                  Ca~Pi t1F er?m,IJo.JJ 1/ppea/.S
                  .. aP zeJ:as - 8tJ~.8tULc                   •

               =z;v 7/le /nat flsf,.t~-1 f1t1Cirl e;F
                 · IICIN'ls (JocuU-Ijt.J ~              __.
                                   CJ

                              meJ?Ifl. ~e.S    IJfladLey
                                          u,
                               5izr.le   "F ~qs

  /Jbel Ae.6S+a 7eras          &Jurd-e;FCr~/10rJJ/fppectf.5
 elet'JI<--.::zAJII/s &J+JcfaJ Capac1'i<j .
                               I

                                   ORDE{(
   6Y1Jfl~day eam-e.    trn    h be fleardlhe!or~g~/J;g!ltJIJ!tca.f/l:M
Fdr W\'lr+ oF' mLWdaWltA~ cvnd # 1/IJ()B:lfl~/t;I!Je ~4/kHIIre~
3hruldbe                  . ·            8sirM1fed
   :z./,_5 !ltef1efof?e. t1tder> .fha.)#te t!IEPf .1nai/Mrnedlaklu1taAJ-
5Mf.f. 4o ~ [JtJUr4 a.f (] r,rn{'f\9d} !fPPecl~ £11J-!Jt1AJC fl &-1?!1 J'
#te. AOP liM-111h1 F.:11"' Wrft c£'1J1Mtda f111S lfJJtl/IAJ.5Nt!P.S f'f!ed
tAtvd ll ~'1:1 ~..f-jfi e2a+e reet+/lv_g /he dare IIPM 1ii11Lh 1/ud+ra!J.5-
 mT++a.P was rna d-e,                              ·              ·
  ~igNed C!Yl.fi!ts           devj t!J£                QtUS
                                                       -

                    ~/f5e JJt~m!Jer 13~l?~a'Z-C
                 r3ot~M- op C!.rimiNLP /Jppec~/s
                    "F zexas - £111-Bt1A1~·
             U711e tt~cd!Jf's./pjcl- &.ur-I eF
                 /JaPrLS 0/!Jtuu./.IJ, ~kas  - ·
             ·
                                                                -
                 mFPkul;,es Q,rud Le~
                               v, '
                  s+ak    o 1= 7eYq >s
                                             G                      .
. OKder fega rdlvg f(e ~ues-.f. fCr llwf?UWJaiU .Wt/ oF/11tnda1VJUS,
tJAJI6i.s clO)J o£ma;;t :Jols- /Jppe!!a-k lfjlles-1 f0r4 hmr-
11lJJ av~ hi5 ffpp/}iea-1-clrY! FiJr Wr>ff tJf'C7!1Mtda YJ1US Mal was
Pre.sm+e.d k #te e6uflf, (Juf had !l)CJ/- be-eN f(u If erYJ hy 4-J, r_s
&xi1z:t is &rd12red. !l)iudj_&J and /Jec.rud ~lk tf<Wri-llla:l
 #1~   1ippr2 Jland-~ re.CfJuesf'-Por /l Jk4f'/#g ~hoi/ be:
 ~------Gr~                                                      &J~