Court Opinion

ID: 4061083
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 20:02:15.674423+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:28:08.892622
License: Public Domain

. 01-

l/» fmi dka vic 3`/§7/`:/ 5141'1‘   s

 

 

 

 

 

REcE\vEu\N
/ ,, . _ ~ couRFeFemMmALAPP£ALS____._

/?£f 7%£ 51[@1/¢’_* if /CMT'- ' \ ‘ NQ’VM 2915 `
us ' ` . ' . i=\bei Acosta£lefk*___

 

' /Zs£¢/z/’ LVM M¢[Z&/"VC;/

 

bear Z_'/a/‘/( »

 

 

`.7/)¢ record m 1%&§¢ //117 Mcc.f [;RFQY prmmi/mas SL¢w YZ¢J ' `

` fla w,e/`f alj/ed 1§;~" &115@ A/a/nécr/ 5€07;,?67 15 w/m»/ #~:,m %A¢ .
fecbrz:/ ` /Aan:` Z¢/£r'e 1§11/ {6/){£01/¢1[/@/1: 776/1 w//c/§ 1§¢/ (<{)
M£//§ L¢/{/C 1[/£;/ /7/€_¢15'¢ A£a/c{ 7%¢’. £ré@'l/e /77€0749//6 c/ ¢¢/.e/_ 72

. and 1€/¢ /1¢¢¢//7% 1‘¢.¢ y/A¢/ 1%/`:€

$/”ce/Z'/WW¢

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

/?¢&/11¢ ///m //7£ (1`1/‘0¢7’ -
/d/?§/`A/ ///7/ f

3?7?’ 572/c _/$/h/i' ?f
. /l/¢W //7¢5/,_9/1 `_7§;_(45 7:5'5:{>, ;

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

__ gz‘OzS_‘O\'OZJ)US

' RECE|VED IN

 

" ' \ _ : _ _ v _ ' 'vCOl-JRT oF chMlNA;AppEALS
1 £nu_.s.e_;s*~Nc>;.__£g olz_g,$j' " HC| l l d NUVZ'*. 2015 f
. 4 ig oizz%-H'£.l _ ' ` Abe'ACOSta,Clerk_

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

~ ' _ ‘ j_l;:L Ol;z§q~\l|£l _ 1
' - R(,L,M+_LW_M§£,.£M ‘ - §" _ L +»\¢_ wm‘d£@w -_
’\l. / -- __ gea`_”&`,\_\rcxa.._£m»\_»_{?c,f 1
T\\, 'S+,,+; bc `TU§   § ' w J_U_Q\_.:¢)_@_I_D.;e¢;d

 

B,'.€cjfi`c) .41" 1014ka &SCBp §w.o|¢'u`
A¢rj- nam/u.;/S_M_s__a[_|_éw__m:é)|nip

l To +k¢»_ HM£)].¢_.L¢¢£§_L_LL§ALL&_Q; _ ‘ , » ,
_F;*%;Cam_€__s_/_u'aw_._~k/n_¢_`_FLf/f/.QAACL_KQL_£L/;Ly/uuM_§L;l:i_/_¢A- 1

l .*__MC$L£.UF_¢¢£)Q¢//g_§uémL//_s_/)/_s__c?éd(ve£/MM_§E/D_/¢)_¢ k ` 1

;__p_;<_apgs.éa:’”_z_/./°;:/thg_s_@£§¢£;1,@/_:@17@/;1;121¢<*@/['LM _'

_ M____.~£AJQ/_[u_$u;qaa¢f_-M_mca£;wad/(/:¢€L§aecfé//o¢?/_‘{_€cgu£$_/' l ,` _ _ .

5 ' 'l'_£\_&__/ou,;Lf_'[z'>~_§>g:a/__H¢uaé£a¢/_aé;,/e_/_B_zé:/ZQ@£ L/A/u EMDL;.___.__

, k Q_ulc_ §'Q;,(L) ¢.

' .|v\c£»m_u;g_s@ ag C;d `

ll

       

 

 

 

 

 

 

_ . I_., 1 »
`g._*_____&u_k\[_uu~;*|_&,gzooq ,,_m~a_. Me.clfm/u was /')/'Aec_>/ 'f'o. ,~
__£_€,UACS:',_J/f /\'].e M cam/ec 1£,2_ ‘H}ze .£//owiwg 114/vega '
__L.JM%@;€;¢¢QQ/ /`/d,§lc.m_£ o_€_o?bo ézq;th;£cc_;/EA/&S ' 1

. M%¥FAL'_O'A,H£ZM§_¢$%&QA/%~Me¢e*uai£!@!dgclj;cw .
____;Hi_c_`@a£s¥pz.@u;)Aoé+hLMeM/_[La/e_ai[_a€/m444/___ ~
__/_€La¢ca/}.¢¢e_’ g L_AW[ilmML£/¢SNA/B_o zidia-#m_+l'l_e~§&é§;_'
__W_~E~ol_m __5__/_:4_»._60_[4._£‘0,:»:_0,,/¢¢$rbu=s§Q)é_LA_wwO/a_;_jczig{_.9_/;°»_1_______ _,

E&L§P_`_;.S_ogo;bv_ia¢.)__§_éuo!_;'m_s]oZACr`o_}.z__$/Jj_£;[e_/M_vl;hj_M¢ v '
_______‘-Ulia_{_\I_u_Q}&&_HMJ/_F_LO_.SCCLL40L_w€&£_de£¢[/lai;[u_' l

n . Ca~.écmég;cz;¢ '_44,_£_1@_/;1/_54/_',94.5€/€6 041/12 4¢)/¢/1&»»4

d - `.fm_e._l'_ ~_A_§$zl-sgm_c_'c_,_w”de.fca)§p_o /'1[. ' 7 4 ` `

\r\é_ ";§t&fe_;$c;\gs_;{z_aim_of@_s_eqcp.jm@»z/mell_d§j”'__*

U_)Q`u1 p_\?c&¢\:\;fsl~l. 104/am 540 §`.5`_\4`1'1§€0/7 itu mD/ 1441st

dL,"L¢:c;j:/_`@_M',_,_'bia1_'1"};\_5~/_)')».¢;//_£»9./_./:4*¢:¢.c'_§,~_,e=)/_\.d/'_EX£,_¢€,£CL`$_~€,l 07[ ‘

ALL¢£hoL-i:/P,_Q/j_/`ch:'/;S"EA?&¢'EAM¢Q/ lia/afb fh&f;lc‘j _ ‘ _

thei~_Hz)-e*€>Lcl®_o;w.r_eo/ja'.__l'$_£€%uzis_Lk/¢{;(Q;Al;c:cc_s/¢.e¥_/;Q__'_'__,__

.__z§_£@é/,;_l:m,QQ.S€,_QLIlm/:M,H:L/_749.5,Lll;h{"&y_£_)€£pr;;@ 1_?~?`

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

~_`

 

 

 

L,. .

` , - ` l l
/
.‘\’ \ `

 

 

011_0666/1161 01[ 07007 M1 M €[11061 004_5
_111162116/6__0/_ 1411 /;/')1_1:6_v 6/1111§16.5)_`1_000_0{_00111_01_/1_._00_616_
'1'11__6 _5191)'1_6_`3_1)6/10!1' fide/061 £/_ZO_I'¢?LFF __D€a£//' [0110/116/_
§1€01 118 1411/0/ f ja 11110/66¢:11£ ngmzzg

_/-)l/ w_A/M_ 0)616 1410/r1 0%6 514/146/§11161110/;)01_<00/6

__A»thj_ @6_5`11/#6/'_5_1_0£5_ 561/ug 1166/0/1_4_ [_’A_/_€
__fh_A/_ 1015 uof _00'£'11/016

 

 

 

 

 

 

`\`

 

 

i> I_u_ 14_ 0 H»)~L ‘<¢u {_/;a_foz. bgé\:'cl_\_i‘_dd[/;Qé/é;Q/_\];/)A)l__th£__jé@
wem_£'uo/ /"u ¢A L?{%¢¢u/_ D/}ZCCF/;QA/;w/éyd/_>Z_;/;h,;é{v.y_§_€.__-;_§i
b Lsfhr_` )Qd' 7'“/),<,11£; l ' l l ‘
` _ Ou Noucmée/z L£';°?OO¢,, /`M Dzl.aufu 1/LA_h:jr_i_t ' ` ' _
._*_m o@__g__5_.~°;m-p_l_q_~$b_ie¢/*;_J:L_e_\o_gl_\d;__wou|QLlnage_ `
:  ' 423 change fl#\e.'cjc:rlfcfr`o)`o ’f'l/\e.\|lw&.&.j}lo'/L '/‘}\1 /25 h//' '/'/1€_ 1 ,
v ' }'L&..*E.S£Qé)_)!sblld _?"LM;/'_M'_€._E_Q_[/;B_w£a mf.§/zof mt oz y q ~
_.;_~_L»A_fh&_c;/j`@:cf¢hd_Q/[_f_/LL/§/m§£_m _4112;§_/`74~/` 7 %¢zyoz.
` Ls /\./0 Q¢QX)V_H.s;cé@,;g_ca/Q ' _ _ ~ \ `
. , m_f`l'_+_ §C&LL\/_C:a_*w_r?_$_B£Zc/_/_:s_€a_/:£)_}Q/:EM/_*él/_u/jtc¢r/_£b
/)_££./`Le_._é)_c_d¢`c/_;Azb.l;&>mmj[~b_uf___¢¢/zs_£€&)gé_u;/g ~
'_._;.»Ml_zz>_A¢/,_~¢_;¢,;*A;LM/_»_/:z£mé¢/q_¢_@@l¢`@,@/ ~
lj_/Q/ %D p/Md:éa,¢`[fz;éLd`h£._Q_/;L[c/;¢C_C_A)_L/`QM€§r{_hham' ! b `
- _'._`**O*B_cz;`o;¢_<..s./k '_»Ai_@a;@_¢_/zzwlwc¢/+Me__é@f;@s 'f/?c_u
Pw;éc§g§¢f¢@é' As` ,g.plp//‘m/ %»_ f/z¢»_‘ Lf)¢}.), ` 'd
` 1 n\u; il/: l{' wake Moi'" 164 Cow~e.§e[s £.`££om`w_$

. duke MLM@G¢¢.v£LL)»u/o/uo)£ kach f/cm/ gca/aci AAIO'/

    

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lg

 

 

- y
» ¢

»` wmlchbA_~/E._»_€A?%e/L,Goy&_?':D_E/'/J/JZZLF_ML/€._/)/ls_/`/uuocmf_§¢__ k

 

 

_ _ . ' W‘ ` _ _
~ l ` T\C\_c*bt_\i§_mak¢_*@_ugah:c‘_>/_~.\_ogt:¢i_gb“é_ll_§_€.[lal§d$ 4
_ mg § /' ld,__vz;_'z_@_.éf)_é¢a/LA/L.)ée&@a_o_&_mf__*____v

5[“`£5< wc’“”’ ”/"’LC°,/.”’L OL /;'/~I/A¢*Q/mc¢f/M @)[)%¢
Hou_s_'e_ occu)_c))`c'c/ é)u /f',ud;`u/%w/_s du ‘.0% wA/£;/,»

 

;__»A_¢¢/@/M/_M/M/¢j[/L§Q¢¢»//egEJ,MAA§-A¢g    

 

LJc‘l/L€,\ 74?'/1£;/ A_/L (O/@/lu fha Q//Zea/§`d/w QE_M_€_,'_L§Q<.¢:SE..' _ l

 

_ @L/m`»d q dchc:/_/_(;_QQ/_udaa/:':@Mclz_/AZ£/_ua§w§¢¢m€&/__

*__é) 'AQé-;_/_c?a//Lc:¢q_;/_j&_wz§[y_{h.é_k¢d$.cjb,u~b@£b_$hé£%§_ l t

e/_ ;l. , »r, ' 1»4/'¢4_

     

A/:' ~ 0

 

v @[Mcr/.’)ozjz_$e._' l '- `   .’ _l
' ' v IL§$_C‘_]_€A/;l _m@,/)_da;¢¢_.s~_:,@go_$;¢cm[/,"oA/_ H_Aé,dg_%
C[&LZ:)~_?€/z)_&h.$h¢o_fs_g);/L;_¢_[i:ua/ 791/fha /A.SE rim ~`/p/‘/c `

 

_;L;p¥&/§_e_dée_ ,_&5_1)3§ Azh£££aaf}zm /wc/ fha _
k `__ ué/r‘¢ /;<;'mdé¢ flew Q_. f’hc juglz_d';zLj_yJ{ém;z€cZu{h€§ ‘ _
_*_LMMZAMQ/L£cam&Lo/_QZLM¢:_;_M@?¢_$ ’

 

 

 

M A}Oil:)i! +Z>p`fflf\_c.hC,M_/o§)_f__Ch@e£ge_/Mma_£@:aL{v ' ~ . _ _
‘W\C 570/'¢‘_5”'&1¢62_¢.¢ oil Cws"|f l`_s~wA;f_h_e,z_ l 04 ~zof
_ :S/wf_§ cpc/cci l[/?ze@/o;+'f @'4. )'/\i fha O{'Lc¢f}`¢w 0/ f/)c' '
. ' l'lou.§cl'p~`$(xcj»_ LS +h&/)fmé:A/;o//.:SSUC; >L/»/?fmcLS/é£oéa/SGJ '

 

 

 

 

._ ___11\1’ __oidQL_ 00 _1_€€.'5001/_¢ 0010_(‘01\101£01/5.¢.5&0 1_;51,1_¢:_1,.)_010_.¢€
2_____01\4(_,0'_$ §/€C£>/LJM£_S _St.¢_mm,¢ <./ua?/neu/
_0,_1)_0;1_0_001;0_~_50_ 11100_ 001¢__50_015_1,)_011_¢:_5§¢00/_ 0_0_001;_’___
~'_0:10_¢1_.5_€__ 1_<_0_A10/->/_@_/ec10/ea//00_//_¢/ a/u_'e_1_00_00_c______ `
- §/¢’/1'6'/_ [way_ 0:11¢§_010///¢/0//£0¢/(;040/_0010.5 0
'___1_111_1_0.51:[1[ A/.wz_/' /_1¢_,£0,1111€0;0/10/1/ 021 010/0 aé/M@¢is 000 ‘ ' '
1. 001`0¢¢0/_0/_11 001€. 150-005 wa/Lr_ 1[ 0¢0/ i`_S ££Qa/.$100q
N&e¢zwzg{ 100 24000/¢; /1 020/000 1/0000¢10 00¢/£01;¢¢

_____t/’Le__£€?q//)_mw£$_@/L 440 _/_ /;5_01_0_5_11100 0¢01 1000

0 61 §; 020.¢0

_____-_[01&_00‘~¢01_0’10»1&11.._§£_141¢5_0'0100 00\¢_1¢7004/¢;_£@0///€0/ _ '
.____ ' l 0_%¢5 010_0//_(/')9155£¢/ &Ma/_ Au_ 10021.¢//,4/ Ze__`__`_____'_

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

 

y/?,ée/QL&%"£:__ 7 0

;1:40_ /0¢/?//__01£_§1:£¢/_ 4a

T_ Kolo¢e_\' \_u~~ N agnew/10 01/0 0150&0u £_6001‘ §1_

0011+0¢1»0£1,!_€__?/1.10/_£0_¢£¢£/£ £c>_§_:j_ _6_’/:0?£._ A_é')_¢/C l
01_11_.5 Z¢`_:M _;m/ 10 '1"01_&,_§0/10:: 14000¢11:01 0>/

___ch 1611£1._ 000/110¥_ 1411/67/_001£_(.'0¢¢£0_ 19._1[£,€1111/:11/0,000005_____
- 0011_§ 03 a/mj_ 01[ 7\//) /embe/a, 20/5'
. l l 1 1 »` _ gave /¢01'010/11¢»€_

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Red River Cour)ty Sheritf’s Ottice orrense; 062175

5l6 Deputy Hamric and l were dispatched to #65 FM 195, Krissi Green`s

ON l l/l
residence Green Sléalled and said Robert McCarver had assaulted his wife daughter, shot
up a carin her dnl`veway and was armed with a pistol attempting to break into her home.

l arrived and we checked the area for the suspect He was unable to be found l
posted Deputy Hamric outside on a perimeter The family was scared to stay there and
asked us to escorlt them out of the area There were several small children throughout the
house The were also teenagers and two young women inside the trailer. The female on
the couch was Clliasity McCarver She was crying and looked to be in a lot ofpain Her
mother, Leona McCarver was frantic and wanted to know where the ambulance was for
her injured daughterl l told her the ambulance was refusing to come up until we had
secured the scentl'%. Using our overhead lights and spotlights, we lit up the yard area and
escorted the victims away. Some in personal cars others by ambulance . l spoke with
witness and they all said the suspect would kill them_ I determined that due to the
suspects behavior and having a gun (and using it), I asked everyone to leave to a safer
area. His wife held minor injuries from his assault and did not need treatmentl His
daughter was bldeding from her mouth and vagina from his assaultl She could not even
walk on her own', she had to be carried to the ambulance due to her injuries She was

transported by ambulance
There appeared to be several holes in the windshield that looked like bullet holes

-nw_ pul_l+ ml~dsll€l][j (Due to the lacklof officers darkness children in the area; no pictures were taken of the
§§ ,, ala .H_l”+ car that will be done at RRSO by the investigator handling the case). The kids left and the
wall ed l»N lib l_.llc_ victims came to llRRSO to fill out complaints and give statements (sge yideo from RRSO)

l first interviewed Green and one of the Suspec_ts other daughters, Lacey

McCarver. Lacey was at work at the time but felt like she needed to tell me how violent

peaked -11\1 Raui' he has been andlhow he had refused to get ajob and that they had no electricity at their
home Lacey walls at work during both assaults Green and l spoke freely for a few

00 rla a l`lou.s&
minutes while she detailed the night’ s events (Seei nterview fagg and written statement).

Green stated heihad assaulted his wife and daughter and shot up a car that was parked in
front ofher hou'se. She said that the bullets could have easily gone thm he;tr rail er and

_______-§ _~_"___._°__T__'
injured/killed her or her kids I agreed es_eciall on lass that is thick and an led like car

 

B.aiuai..mu mud

 

 

 

i0 it ronald hhd€. glass, ricochets are very likely with smaller calibers. She said the suspect was wearing at
/Lm°dllc& camojacket jeal'ns and possibly a red hat or red shirt. He had a small dark colored object
in his hands that looked to be a pistol (this_ is also, what she reported to 911) Lacey stated

that the suspect had a pistol that she knew of; it was a dark colored 22 that had wood
grips Lacey stated he carries it everywhere on him Lacey also stated that she wanted
him to remain iii jail for her mom’ s safety Green stated that during his crime at her
house he attempted to break into her back door and she thought he may have hurt her if
he could have g'otten inside. She al so said she heard the shots that he shot into Leona‘ s

car.
Next Iipoke with the mother and the other daughter after they returned from the

Clarksville ER. They stated that Chasity was kneed hard enough (t`rve times) by the
suspect that she had vaginal bleeding and blood was in her underwear l asked ifit was
not too much trouble could we save the the undergarments as evidence and they were

placed in a papbr bag and tagged. They both wrote statements and spoke with me about
1 ti t 1 56

7 - .',eeso/

both assaults (see interview tape and written stmts). The mother was adamant.about us
catching the suspeict. Both agreed with the other witness as to the camojacl/
case NUMEER amy Doa `7: '7 /$*7,9

I realize that i`t is a violation of the‘Texas Penal Code,
section 37. 08 for me to make a false report to a peace

officer, That means to report an offense knowing that the
offense did not occur or knowing that I have no knowledge

about the offense.

de d<}-t'.§.`) aid rests di©l_r\77,77 77,7 C:~a»fi
/' ith/hi Ct' dhi/L/ di l) dh/i i""\/l" di ld.¢ldn t,/t :i`&- ~dd\/' Z\C[{§id___

 

,."\.l~ iC

7_ )\L..i <”7 t -»~ih 777§:-7\§\.;-’~¥ v
7\<\~ wit 7@~7;$.>; 7/\§ /~Qt let [Y//Lu

tr 7 .. it 7 77/.,77?"-'<7 7 721 Z@i.7i71`7.7z7o.77\0¢7 ¢/ ca7
)t.h/ d \7‘/7_£'{ yicd»._dui{ 7jc/d/ (/[> &_'.?/ \/.h/'?é;d {`57'/<

-~77 C‘h:>"e-i 7':§77 7;7/‘7 wait <7 777 ii><:‘-:-/\I)\ d`hdld` Ldicldihh [’dii;(»{ dx id Li'h{d\i'; ’hd.d)(".
i‘\ di/lin\r dh\\dh/| dbt\ihd\dc\_lS/LILL ih`@dd C/K~i\ii 7/;]€!\£/')~1/[ ‘i_i‘/

l
7@7~.-'777 ama 777 \777 tie ltc-t ilt'»‘-.-e 77 7._/\__/ 7
7~.- ~;'7\'. l777777 7\7\1'€'7 limit-757 7116777!

The above statement is true end correct and to the best of
my knowledge accurately describes the events as I remember

them
56>; ML/¢ /’47€ AM”“”"

sIGNATURE INVESTIGATING' oFFICER,
DATE /y.¢yd TIME AM/PM
PAGE 7 oF z oF sTATEMENT

 

 

 

 

7..7~h?r …l’ C‘ il {"\77/ d_[,.‘/ "75 7,):‘/£ /
t

7~7777757 ftc/177 €7`7/// _7 /<777$'7_..._7 <.

wITNEss sTATEMENT

 

 

 

 

NAME - HOME PHONE
PDDRESS WORK PHONE
AGE
DL SS#
DOB

 

 

CAS-E NUMBER

I realize that it is a violation of the Te)cas Penal Code,

section 37.08 for me to make a false report to a peace
officer That means to report an offense knowing that the
offense did not occur or knowing that I have no knowledge

about the offense.

li 77 `l'~~lt-: ll'it:l title l/i\t-: ”¢!$£fji{;ii dim/7 5 rt 2775/po

7'i'»h l--ih'l\l'l'.li (ilLi.i-i !l`Ld\dh,({}lL /¢( _{/)/‘(j (j'”r"<'l 0/1/

7 7\7turr/7/\a7 Jcllt/-i(lziel 15%77- 57»42 /7/1

l__)t. l\\t 77 f/s§-~)it~//cz//// 7/)/;;7 771-157
dd¢’/<:dz,lil/ /'/?“///7 l

<7)77,/ illl'.. 77657777 md 7777 7
7777\ 7_)€77 ~Cl» il\r.~' L77»7)77~@177777/r ,/r.>e//
,,/777 [72 777,'7~ /l/i'<'l“ darrel/27 el 621 £7/7//?7¢/7

/';"d/L_i "i' .d\l_i._i;_lli jd) did y\[,('i`i J\lLl Ld 7 ii.,/\Clii"ddl-hi~'
tit ;lii J\Li “L'l" di iC-ll" llC d\C' di ti°\r di-(i lLLls /DL7Ci. 1
lllw i/"-"<7L_(C l.C dilute tti.i! /)t" il L7 h/w‘/Lc 7 057..7' Zl…t§~l' (/lftld " /le
' lllt

 

 

 

 

 

The above statement is true and correct and to the best of
my knowledge accurately describes the events as I remember

 

 

 
 
    

them. \,

.--'i~~~.t'r'~t:: '7"1\-`\ l ll i'~-(~,'\-'t-"t'.t/` %%-
sirsz INVESTIGATING orricER
DATE ~~ `)\\" 7 time m/PM

PAGE Z,_ OF 'ZOF STATEMENT

 

l©