Court Opinion

ID: 4059351
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 19:29:22.714688+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:45.233429
License: Public Domain

YB,Q?>+~QB_

 

§ :`" " A;w¢z /15.

f/¢/ 555557557/4//4/4;,¢ 5/%%5
714 ,{wr//; 725/vw

 

/A'/¢e_' 5’550015 455 7275/5<5, 5756450,2
z/.

WM/MF;A¢ 56 §44/4//5% 7°$/¢~@/7~4
55//_7/5/ 557 415/f 055/7504/1/4¢5

 

 

%//5/1 )‘MA//£ /W£//af§//M@/M/¢¢Z ///1155%55 555
7 7/5/2/}//6/515§/¢/¢/&¢/¢5¢/ /%»4//5/¢/€ QM/ /5%55
fhwa/15 50// y/@g,y, 45 .

 

 

 

\

z /‘5//” 1055/ /1// 55%€ /~”£5¢?/5§6 555 722555 ”/5’5550¢
/%/1/54///5 /A¢ij D/§&’/¢/ f/@'aé 7`??£;’]'- /’3¢5/€'/¢//)/// \
/5/527/:/55»/§5¢%5 ¢?%M 5//4%¢¢¢5 /_?4557%,4,9/
'W/¢/'?‘ff’%//€/ 755/5 74'”"'37‘ ”5'/”? A/¢/Az@/% 752/46 77%5

y 5 555450)£

f / 5@454/¢/5755

1 77/?/7/'@//¢//5/ 5/57931<:5&¢/55
/5/57@;4/ 5///1/¢"555¢45 l

/%/1/54;¢¢5, /W//é 7525'/- 593 ’

555/paydawa . » HE©E“VED

@@UWOF ©RmmNAL APPEA§
SEP 39 ZUS

A@®“A©©Si@,©@®?k
/575/~ 151 §

77 775 //77”777545]3/»%;€ AF/‘//£ Ma/>’fafF¢/’Pézzz($ z

VEAIA/Z, /Z£a?&%‘/)€/é/v §¢/%/¢///%J /z'%%M/é% M€//w//WM/M¢M/ l %A
L/W?/% [/J//zw /D,¢,€¢>¢/z//f/M,é_/£€%{é /WA/¥/¢;z¢€ faan /D/¢s%e/¢/ [/&,€,é 3
Ir$% 2'/1//%‘/1//47¢¢6 éa///j 743/\%5/ z% /A»>”z/£//z/ "'&§’Dé'$> *ldw/a£/&Ay 7%
FG/@/z/@/¢MM 19 %é//w'/%//A¢ dp/y ////J,jv/éM//m//é,€ A/,€//A/%MM
&,qw % %6' éz/z/a/{/'¢/MS;/¢M@¢WMA 705¢. &aé’jz///z /Qé¢£., /%,€>4 922/
//z/¢//A 7 ZJ¢-'é. S(c'), ,¢A//W@z//z/J%wu %:< fpa/77 7%/‘ 147/way :

_[ __Q;¢ z/.»sz//c%/y/¢/

722 éuz/J////M%%w ¢/z/;@¢¢//w/ zS/OW/E¢ %/¢//v/ /%//1/'@¢¢%¢¢<»>'
/V/¢/A/¢%¢ ,O/§%/c/[/L%,é/ @j,~éé/¢//é¢¢/z/:/} Ma?¢¢d/€ [sz/`z!j &%¢WMZE

//r/ )%5/,€ ,€¢W¢¢*/¢a/Q¢J%,z/M, M%§//WW /¢i>§z/¢f ‘¢é§ "/,/,z/%) A/¢»'c'¢z§/>¢§ 26
éu,é,¢¢g %£/»é ¢/,e/Ja%:%'//z/. 556 745/w 6'@//'/ &@/gj; ;,7,¢‘?.¢?/6¢) Ma/Q.Q. QQ/(j),

//74/¢‘/¢/%£0//¢/¢/@/&§ %,W[¢M¢%/z/A,e MM//j{%éw Q,§¢z/J/ we //¢?'//;
,!¢) ,é%///)/.//, ,€b'//¢’///y/,lyéz¢wq%% ,Zéy ¢¢/47 /WHM/YM/ %;é 4/,£//¢//%/)%//-
ifqu //:/,4 &¢/¢%A/WMS 72//¢)’ &M///¢JM¢/Mc////:/ %/M 7/’@'4;1/@,€ 65

' /5¢”%//0/1/%¢ Me////VWMM/z/wa¢/M zé/¢/. M) 55/ //,%s' 7@’1/¢5’ [WMM/-
¢{)%A/%/m/ éa )/'/Z@Q{§j 972 ada ` `

,17:.

_;¢¢/4 725

F,'Zgé/Q¢ZX¢Z 72/%%.§ 5`/!56130 55 /¢)’//,/MQ%:/Wé% M/M/ééz%;¢¢é//,y ,4/5
7?,5;5 pLy/zW@M/&W/A//y/ ¢/J%¢¢s:. MQ//JWQ%€/WMJ¢$ nw (’MAA
zw/M%/ 75 /M//J%%¢ M//»z WM /M¢/¢M /%,é FM,/ A//¢W@ ¢z¢,

/§Wcé' 77 ~//’é

767/69 7776 3. .f¢:&//,€ 666/6666/66/6/666676%6>”666/6% :/i_/é '4,6/616
76/¢7¢/7/5//’/77¢7'§@76466 %47/§6¢6// 666/4/1/;441¢/66//15 464//;,/4,1//1,_/
`M/Z” ‘6//1¢6666/@ 1676/666- 764 646 666 666 462/772 66 566
6676/665 /7@/666/6/ 26 166/66//66§/1 7644647/,413 4/¢1 &y@/ /661111/,1/%
%//66{5 6 KW 6/ 6/6'6//667'666/6/41€ 666//6/}/666£¢’ /6;§6¢'6€ 6/(¥! 666%'6£ /¢/66{
666/6 66666766’66¢'/,6/7 676 616/6 74644/71/61¢¢6 %//5/)////%; ,¢,/44 /1741,6¢,
/7/%1 16/1/6//¢’//:?7 fyl///&/LZ£/a/¢’g$ ;%41/1%%/¢5:,% '/ng/£_-c; Zéjg££z¢/%£@/'
:_/1_/.7 767/ja 6/»666%666//6646 6/6///%663 /W/VM/ 61qu 6%6'6/665 /5'/6¢1{
//16/6 666¢/14¢6£.'£66/6/% 766 6/6£¢16%6///6///%6/%6676'76’ 6665’474@@
666/666666/1/ 676/1/0`67/6/66/6 676 é//,é//f/Z/W//Wf/WM/J. %6/516'6
6?§)£667'66/6¢’¢’///7%667/6766/6 676 §666/&/67//667 %665416 6/ 526 4~

' ,1/@/1111///6 1557/1165@/,`6/61%¢%: ?667/66 6/66/67%7666666/666/2/22666
677/6 676 §66/6/56/676166%664%;..

 

72 6§’§64/66’717/

%6/66666/\6€ 166/66 06666/1/ z/#//¢% 416667/(¢4'6£/`6/ 66 165 D/Jz¢’ez¢%
6'/6€/< 6/%/1//6665 &666/, 76265, 666 667/6/6676/6/66/5£ 666¢6/¢/666@/
)46,¢'_7;@_ '/7,§66€6 //1/6 66/66/1/6//66‘¢66676 ,66/6//66/6667~:74(_4 66766 616/666
gWJ;¢§@/y/W% /67666(} 616/66766/161#775% /M? 5€//% /96773 v %7/ 627/1 6/1/@/
76@6666/7/67166/¢6 666//,6/,6{6 6/ 767/1 66666//6 /767¢?» 677/46 72666 '
555)/ 70 767/66667¢6§§/ ~z%%/dw/¢¢ 65 66 &//6/7/£66666/,6%66666 674/y 667
/6/6“_6/6//¢’666/156 666/7//%6668’ &66609 66 666/666!15/66§ 666/6 6661¢.
/AM/EM£////y ,67/6"6/6¢6 5%6/1/6//7/¢% %7/ /'/2/6§/‘7 Ww/WM;//%é' 6661/16 -
661/j 6666/66¢"/6/¢6667/676666664_/6_ 726/5666 666660/666/. 676/66 066/64
@169£6/{/66€ /%)667466 &¢M/j/, 671§6 66 566/6%466%/61’{6 6/61/6//1/665

/§/¢7;’ 5 ,-6/' . . 1

67‘ /6//:6/1/66/¢/ 66661§ /%6/6466, 762/§ 76,?¢5‘/-66/6.

Wa g 66666766716/\6¢ 67@6@6»;§

 

  

 

766 76666/1/6/61//6/667/66//666/6//62(56¢60/)/ ¢‘3!6)// 6/676 762/75 /76476/
666/1147 77666665: 617/617 6/6//6666¢7}6/ 6766//667//61/ 46 7/6//7/ _

%7666 /7666;67//66/)6666) 664/666 cz%//r//z'//¢;gg¢/,é/y 76/66»666664/ l 7 `

667/621/6766/7¢6646666'666/666664»/646666/6/662¢666/6_ .

l 666/66/(6)6 671/616/66//6/1/4‘66656/1/66&,64;6666/1666/6666/66/67/66
`6/'76/66/6 77666766%»@/6 6676,14641,4694 z _

657/6 7/676, 6176666/6666;676661/‘/6/466¢666//76766666663
6664/66//66/6 676/567/6766%/6660646 6/6/¢//%66¢6 666/76 ¢”46}/41,¢;- -

" 66762§§,;”,}};4:66666666666676/161161./642¢666/666%w

1666/6 /67%6&66/6/ &/67//1/6/ W¢¢W/§ 666/677/6’¢/£6 66676679/66,667¢1/696/
6/(/ 676 §66//&/6/64/%6666/6% 66?6666 07 6/6//6/'6/4666$ 67,%67,

, 766/6 666/16 66//66776646/666666¢6/46 66674676W66d

666 6/676/667 767% 666&/67/66//?66¢66/11,@/1,/64/;%4§/6 366/pg is
66466, 7696666/6¢/%666666%76/6676 766/66/6767/6 637/6 WW//¢/W
//\'/6/_/”66£¢76/666; 667/6 //77, 666666§¢¢)/ /56666/6666/157//7, 666/666666

6 6//6@/66%66/766766;%//66/69666/466/6767676/)/6666/@6/;41;/\1%
766/661/6¢6/6»'666 666664666176 -

/'

677/66 //6% 666/1/56)/ 6666//6666: 676 "1/676 661/663 66617

l 667/665 767%66€6666§_6 6676/6,;116, ,%¢/g/¢!,@é M ’Z,/,,,M#@ . 746¢,16,_4
, /)7//6 -%6’/666/6/&//6//1//7/%6666/56/W/p/%/g,WQM/% jA‘/j%/M%

/7766’ 7"~6/-j 6

1566 611/6 616//6¢6¢6666/6/§ 7%666/6 ¢WJA/w//¢/ /66/'62/6'¢/1// 666
666/61 /L`Z//¢/,My/f%§ 666 6 666 616//4/66666¢/6@/¢?66,%; 5__%5_4 ’-¢',,,/_
'§/////6’ 1516/766/667/271)» /(7¢56€$ /m*£?/ 566/666 1566¢6666~€' %/66¢6// l 7,
§§¢////z/¢')’(¢Q . ? 6§6¢/1/6>6/1// /§ /6%@6///4/6/6/6/6666¢/666 /;7/,1//@/¢,%//,./
666¢0', 666/666 666sz 6/% 1266-

-1/ 666 /=:_z_/:___A§w/;f

W,qg¢£Fd/FE, 766/665 66606760, 766/06666665 666 7¢7/655663631,
6666£%§/¢ 67664;166///17 %%%in/a/¢w/¢/_M_@~ ‘M¢M;/% wax/66-
4/7{5 6 //€6//,¢/¢/&//7///16/6/766666//,6/»1//666;0//666' 6666666 666 666 '
66 666*/367¢/¢4;6~@/666/,#6/ 6/6%6666¢%6//6§674;6/`66/6/56@//;/%6
666/6656’663664¢`///0/661/6/ 6¢/ &6/66/6666 66 fm ZWD¢§H ’6¢666>6:7
F¢<§/¢/m/g/z//zé 666/166661’6§/6/6/@%66666666 M/%¢/W6M 666-4
66666466666/6666666661/666,+

616/169 666166666666/66666¢667@//66@/%, %Z/¢Q
_ //6366'//@»/136¢9 ¢//7/¢//2'/6;/?/6/6¢/66/7//66//?66)6/666

766/66 616/666
_l//t{jw/W 066§¢£,77§@/

`_ / WW£Q§ 6661/65056¢§ 617/ly /66;6¢/§/0 //1/66¢’66¢/€6///1/%/
757/6 566666661////&’//)///6(//6»766 /1/ %6/7//%4/ ///l/// /”/ 5¢///7¢5 !W”” 39
66 666 616/666//6”66/6”7”6 667 75 7
6¢666%6@///\/)76666/6 '6/6/0/////¢/1/666¢6,"666%66//71/¢/6666664

/?676 f;//-ép

\

£,YJL'¢/ £¢¢/¢w %€ /75’%@{¢/ p/(j@¢/¢/@///%M, 24/5.“

 

//ZMMEM¢» 7[7%)#/%05¢¢, @4» A¢WA W/_¢§ ,////,4 72%¢%/
f&é€é€}¢l&/W //%/Eéf/W/fj M//d//%¢/M/;l//n,g, YJZ§/y/M/M )S/¢¢ M<)”;
W/Z/fé§//¢y€/d/¢W//J/u%€y?i%a\/za 0/&°54£:»/&$6 y'?¢v;s“,'

 

%z/¢/,awz¢¢/ 79 ,‘

zé&/;,%f§§//)¢//@/Z/é _ /QA¢/jé’ W//j/,¢/J/E/%/M%M<¢y

W//¢//!£/M//z//¢/W@/),{S /p/ééz/C/%%/pwgyg IA{,,/%
/HM"C/;':‘§M /A/HéM/é/M/é,zzw,¢

405/w DAM»//£/mé - _
/72”%¢;¢¢5 /w/A/§ D/;%¢/¢»% £/g/z/< /r "~j/%%¢M
/F/ /C?Z/¢/:/£///¢/<§MZ¢% _.
/72//%4%¢/§, 2505 7¢,2¢5~/~ p§'/Q

(7/>?% {. /7'%/,¢¢!7%¢%/?@?1;
%Wé]/f//c/»/@/WW@ /0¢/¢/
/I//*-/‘?/;‘/)/M/z/M¢WL '

’%/V/ély¢/H, Hw ~»»Zé 1%7 155/§

/V#;¢' é v/' é