Court Opinion

ID: 4057032
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:22:40.849723+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:26.065455
License: Public Domain

\i      t

L<Q..~\t-         C   ~ c_ov.~\
cC   \_~~~'~a--\ ~~~~~s.
X' .(J (b c~ '~ ~'\::.~ C..~,~ <;.~~.o-Il

~~s~-"" .,~Q...'i..o...':>          \B.\.\\
                                                                                                 \RECBVED~N
                                                                                            OO)Rf Of= CRJil ~i:\!At APPEALS
R_ e.. •, \~·"I}-\           c_Q\~ c::,~     ~   t:) •       ~-   D   '&~ - '- S \                  OCT   te z:,s
                                                                                                 ~~c~~

  \_II""'\   c_\ c ~~ 0,.       '"'ov-..    ~- ~         \   ,~ ~          ('a_"'o.-._~~-e' 5>    ~~~· . _~""'\
  ~~< \~~~Q_ "o                            C·\~ ~'<·.\ o\ ~~-A,. ~o-."'""'u...S.
     ~\~o..-s~             c··_\Q_ o.."""o.. \o"-""'~ O,...~Q_""'~'~"' ~~ ~~~
     (_~->-.<~ '

                         -\~c...~\L. \o~. ~~ . . . .<
                                    .
                        0...~ ~<:Q.._c.:: ~-~~    .

                                                                          ~~'\~'Q_ ~~,\.
                                                                          ~~'-\      ~~~ ~U..\c

                                                                            ~~"'~~-\'L~~ ,, ~~()
                                                ~\
                                  c.. e...<\;:. C'                      ~
                                                                   ~"" o::-'           0...
                                                                                              '\.~<"
                                                                                                  - v...L.   o-."' 6.       (.O<"".(e._~

                                    eo-.   \o ~
                                             0       .It_      <>-"""""   0..   ~   0 .("   ~ <>) ' """'~       ~-::> ~-       ' ? '""

~""-'' ~      6-
                   Cl~ ~ G.:.- ' "\~a..
                                     \.
                                        ~0 s. \.. JQ_ ~.. ~- ~01..· ~     0..                                   ~   <;;:,
                                                                                                                            -~\..~"""" JL

(__ <>"-r\         <>   \..o   ~ ~-
                                  < ,            .,..,   c-.'\._      ~~ \(."-~               S     D"       """-'f-.<>.. 'S

 <;:.   0.    Q:,~"'-..        ,:._:,D-e,         C...o.~·\o'\ S:....~\;:.~.-...' ~"-""'':>.,;'",
."      e_~ ~":>         '"D\\ \

                                                                                'i...Q_"'""'~~ ~~~
                                                                                Q.<'    o     ~e_ Q...~"-.e-~o<:"
\;.~   ext\ R' \:...                                                                                c...D ~ R:\               c ~       c...Q., V\, N    b...\._

\(.X..~~~\\\\\~~~                                                                                   f\~~'E-.~'-'S                      ~t>~      '\\\:__

1\ ~~ \..,   c...o..V"\~                                                                             s' ~, ~                    o~ ,~ "h ~s

                                      }''\ D \       \ D ~              \= t::> ~ \_ ~ ~ '\ ~- '                         0

         f."\\._~            ~E..~'''~~                                 \=C){(_ ~Q,_\-< 0~                               ~~~~~'"\\J'S

   ~ ~~ \        .•   <.._o..~   .,    ~e_~""'q_~~                          \ \ ......."""\)        c""'""""'~-s:.                  "'~....::>   \   D

"""'-o ~L             \;"e..,          c._=-..._r\: \.-o                      ~'< ~-t)\ ~, ~                             ~~'<' ~·.., ~ ~, ~<'\ ~~

\;..' \ 'L      a_         ~ ~"-' ~: '           t.."'"\        ~   0   <          ~'(" ')~,          0        \         ~ ~ 6- a..~"'~
                                                                                                                                0..

~ ,~ "-~~                        \;_- "-\." '"""-~ ") <"e.-"' s~"'""                                      ·.
                                                  ~'       •\   L    6_         '-"' • :1.,_\.r-,    "'"'"' "-.              (_ o   "'\ '-.\, "-." , " - )

                                             ~c~·-~<"'\ ~~< '(~-c                                                  SCl..V'\\ C..,      ~-~- ~

             \:::,. "-. c_'-., "-~ ~ e-"                    "C \ .          '"'-   c.:'-~"-~\ \
              \L'\         ~~>"· "') ~"C>--.~ ~"-~ '\L_"'-~
                                                                                                                              ~c...~         ~""' ~
               ,_,_,. 0....:, "'- \,\, "- 0"-- ~\.. \,                             ....,_-;, ._ 0.. ' ...... "'\,-... "-- ~ ~ \,'\:, "''"\
               ~Q._ ·~ ~ "'::.\:.~6 ~·, ~~ ~- ~\.~<.x cz..~ ~~->~ ""'~ ~S
·-.:ss_.,       Q..~s~o...-.., ~tt..,..,._~                  ~Q...~,Q.. 6.. ~o~·~ ~-"'                             c::>"l         ~ex\
            .   ~C)')         ~C>\ ~. Q.....<L\.o.-\.o,                                <"SL-~\.)...,Q_S~~O..                 ~<=>< ~

                ~~~·-~~                    "    0    o..'(<z~'""                   c_o~.()<::,.~ ~!:l. 0..':::.~~ s\
                  '"""        ";)'-   ~, "")          o-         '\:,.    >-\. ~ \,. "- s""-                o•"'    ~~\\. ~<:>                  l

                  ~~ '~          ')    \:~ 0-~             <t-'\,_Qo,.o......._    ~0..~             ~Q_""...,~~              D--"Sc:.

                  0""            ~-..)..-\.,          ~\) ~C\~

 -s:s:s:_ , c:._o "'~'                 ~. ""'~ c_.,...._r" S
                                      c_                                           "'~~e_.             c...    ~-- "'~ ~'(L<, ~
                  6.. ~~ \. \...               ::>   C>-   \?. ~ c --~'             c..0   ~"' ~~ ~<' ~' .;._. _...:·'\ ....... ~
                  ·~:::. ~. ~- ~ ~---s'·"'~                                        >    't·~< '>'""--o.."'~ \.~                    ~~~.
                    \.s,   ~. " ' \. 2) . . ~                   ~\c....   Jt..    '~'{... C_ o.~
                                                                                              •     C>             1:>   ~

                                                                     ~C(_"::>~~c_)~ C"---~\ ~--\o~,\\L~,

                                                                                       ~~
                                                                                        \~ ~""- "'- L ~ \r--. \~-.)..'A.~
                                                                                        '~c....~     ,,oc ~'-\
                                                                                           ~\..o~   (.:'-

                                                                                           \~ u..~\. "'.:> ~-·~o_   l'
                                                                                                            ~ ~u._, '6.

                                                                                                                             'f..., , ,   ~~0