Court Opinion

ID: 4052399
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 02:00:26.470128+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:13.340107
License: Public Domain

LO~ -q~O-:O(o
                                                                                                                           ' ·,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                        .
                                                                                                                                                              ''       I                            '               '

                                                                                                                                                                                                                        .     -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                             .,       '

                                                                                                                                                                                                          .   .:.            ' ~.·
                     I.                                                                                                                                                                                        '        '.        .
                     !

                           J                                                                                                      '                                        ""       '.

                     I            .   eo~_;w. L!MuJ.d!J~ fdt_.,-yfZIAW+fJbU,_~_t;{d_£; Pr'-=~w.,_,.?_ __
                     !   i ~.IJ   ,   ___ •   ~   .       )       ;::_/   •   - ,   t       - ..-- /   J   ~   . ,.       ff          ,   "/ 4        . I - /                            /-
,    •        _, v~-~-..L~llt-<-t. I__· vtW_i.!tL21/:ffl'W-'-d.t~_JMLt4'-tLJ4AM1 f£_1/f.r_L[-tcC~tN 1 t-L~-11J.Ltll?J-'U-LiQ.~"".'--·__,_
              _:-6:_·-fk ~KO.LtLfL.o.~aff-Lt_a.;~~ f:...LtJo ('; [J4&tUt.)a~sTCOi/_5_c,J/o,!f~L!CJ~Il ' .
             . _:r~L_~t!r-5-o5·~r{£~{_rr;(I_~_G.,~~u_~r§~,~[:/k:J_4_L 9.ttP2UzvJ_--<,:·· ~_. ·_ .·
         _: _·. £L~loLidkeLJ_£fYJw_~ klaJML'llvi L~v.~.~~!o~Ltflh.Lt~-~----'------~

                     !' .

                     (4 )__:k__ti'-! ~~~Lpac.uj~..;,t-tu:_{u_i_p / -t[;_dtif:fu_{';,_~c;w~lfWtL.-,----. .·
                     1

              ·-.

. _ .
 .       -    _f
                     '    /~ J. 11 I
                          )--1/tAift_ .
                                                      .       .
                                                                                -
                                                                                        .        ·                    .                      .       .,            .                        . ·                     .
. . .                I. .               I.            ~               '   ~             '

     ·.· _·:u)dkudv__v,_~Lt-ttiLfttf~~~·.-----'-----'----'-____:_-'-----:------.....;...-..,.-----'-----'---
                                                                                                     .                                                                                       --:.   ~--

      .•.. <·.
                     !                                                                                                                           .    '   .                     '
                                                                                                                                                                                          •' .
                                                                                                                                                                                         :.·

              -·~\----~----~~---L;·-----~---~--~~~~~
                                                .'
               - .
                     I

                     '
                     I
       •ifi)         .                     . •   .   ·~

                                         '(t.C.l.ill ~
                                                                          r.t                 .

                                                              oJLPxkk_~_~L~~"'d~5_.;_.,.:_~£-tk(Uo~ee dt~-;--~

       . ·JLv-15iu~~aLI
      ..... I . , ·-r.  j)faQJL,--------.,----------'-----------

                         1(6J (1-tLAII~_W._ttLfkA!a':_·. _
                                                                                                                                _

           .-;· if-f
                   ''·~I_{-{l<,
           l&ili_W.W/IL~  / iiD·-; ) th. /) ('~ l·-'/                       ~t/' ,-:---- ' ~ · - -I '
                                _..,.Yd.._ -_!jL'--.14. -c.&u/ J--P.>'ti~{)f'f_tLu];;.J&__{i;v__llfl,c;_£1J.d.&6-J1oo/1Lf .                                            ·
           .             ~   '   .   ~      '             '       .         .         .   '       .             .
                         I               - .                  '       ,         . .           :       .   , '       .   .

                _-j £&Ul~'GJ&wT£kl/-i.cft~·-~>J;;;U d..AJ(_ C>t~ltu..t-laiL£. U:._--·~
                ~ ~ttZobi tv~/Uv.t.f5of_tuL dn f:da..)_;,. ilffD"> ~dh.""1-~Ut5Uu! - · .
                _.:l.tJ_/w~_i&M_·6~u~ 1_oL6v!_Lkti_ ~lui:;:u;_~_tJlo_~lt4~t(_y_k{~t-tJ~-·.- _·:
                   l .·- .          .        I )6 .        -       o· ~ .       _.--. I.   . i;;_.
                _.6Y:JWu.~-f-(li(!£_~_j~_ts~'1fdl~ _t_c~aLj_~ ~a/illu,_t.~~ULv.iLl~, _uu.r~~ -"-~L· · . ·
:·             .__-·lo.rJ~AJ.~if(/~·~'"~{. wf!"!,-~d ~-:_,s-.tu d_.dJ~~ f~,_-                        _·
       •1~d M-~ '::fk ~WLI£.,_1,w_£k__("-4~£/u_/_(_-LlfL~.L~L!ftlf/-]': : \ ..
               -~-1~·~~-------2-~~~~-----~-·~__
                                             ::~
     ...       ·::       \
... .   .~   ' .' . .
                         . ·,      '.       '

            _:(;2_) /Af.ldtt f1-flllL-7I 1 0L//3_tS_~_U4>':~_}o_f.iL,_,r;;._-fkt~-/.ui£.Jtw;;;~                                        .·
            - ·j.         k4A-tL£tJS_fa_UL1i;~~)_W/[[~~~ a_{f~~"-~VL~-0-"-0u_·-a:;;-~
       . -[oJ ~ ,;,...;_,r_ -t.;-.,u;;:.JJLa/fl£;;.'-f'-()_~1 '1J ,                                 -                          -

            -fu ftM_w,~~~fuJtc&A"--:~~-~Ilt ht>~ aiGP-li.;._ ,_t;/Lyi-IL"i1_~ut-
                .        ./;,..,   \,                   .                      '   .        .   '                ..       .    '
            _ . I·~.Jl/LI                       .           .              '       ..   .                    .

            ·i.zJ_~hA 1 (11_(Sft>8_,_at_'!J1> ~-LUA-~~-_dp~u~r;Dc_-fhiu~_~iz ifuJJ/dye _
            ~{_jj_6J.tt; _ad -!lh ~ £% r1f1~:- 2/J(!:.v. aLIL~_d_j.M,_ ~t1Y'r-Ut<....:::.._..------'--
      ~tAt /Lto-vd;                    .          .        .      .       _        .
-· - _.JU,) t ..~ t;;;J<4ttr:k5 r;&yr {d.i&udD;_Wl_!!_C-dj_[ 1 l~V«, e>-Lult#Wti.: .· .
  __        ~~~t!Jt.!' £ V~~:bJ 1Lt;1 1l-t__a_ek!i I"'-~-lt.'-i-"£.~il_'l'-111~74iLtbLL
                    I

       .            !                   .           -                                                                     ·,

           ·_       _I     /Jt fW,ir s_~~J~~~-tk_!Ul:~-r~_ aJ]:i_u2:Al{it~~ a?6~~~~ .
           . i ~~ ~ ~--aHtf_~dii/7urdlif~J-dts.~a,/d~ltdtJJ;{o~:yJ )fqt~. . ·
            _·__! (1-W~~r!r f-'4 t;;~_l·~'(;-~uvr;;LLIA/I-LC;_t;_t_~a~_i_fu_"-flv_L~ d/MtML- ·
, _•          ~~~ad_.a"" -~ f L1&<12,_ti._ckJ~ --zo_:puf__f$&;_6_.,is_,-L0:ad,L ---t:u;.f"'; f~i< -~~.tl(1:?:,_
                                                                                                    I   H'

            . .;              j_j.
                                             .~-:: '·. ~ :'. .,
                                                                                                    i             .
                                                                                                                      '
                                                                                                                                   I
              1
            ~--~~---------~-·---~--~--~------~----
                                                                \
                                                                    \""-
                                              'r.

               ·t ~~~U, ~~ ov aJJukk. (, r;_,ku..;L~)_LI)Lu .;.,_£uu ltj)f;;.. ,_r-_ ~__t:h_·~if:'--~:-'--
                                                                I. 1              II ·                                   ·                     ·                            ·
                    .~          .       . .   l      ~
                ttt:a::r.J-":_i,f_6JtL1!2Jj_)___LI_·C!__rs..           ·   _ 11
                                                                                  4           •           ..       . •       .   •    ._           _·       •       •   •           •       .   ..

                     .   ;..~       .   tJ~_             ·   wL~ i~--~ ct~~)t.s·,.pf'&d,~Y~--~r:rc;_ofl~~~
                    ~~tu~4_M~v)'~ J1Z$ a~ ~ t£~~~-'Lflv_s_4l--'--:-
        -tL~i!~-rLu.t~_C:6u T-~;tM!-UlL -ju>-ra_Le&_fr&t_fL~f&.!ifW_[~Jat~/
     _- _J~t1jto·d~_Jd_LCJ ~JLr?dm<:_!Lty("~~r(. il.~:z Wotj-Ufll«< JliJ 6£:__
       _l~~~+~l~·~---.----------~~~---~
        'I            .
           '
                                                                                      I   .
                                                                                                  '
                                                                                                      .
                                                                                                               '                           '            '
                                                                                                                                                                .               •

                                                                                                                                                                                        .
         y}5Ji_r; d MLSei~Lof:t:._~~~-:k>riM~U.CMi~,:r(;-C/~i6': ··
     tl..t; Dl~~(A_.Jt;w'f_~ tdf.i.i.Jit if__L£/A...U;J.Lt..1:j~u'£ ~ 5vt!t;; tU.- .
     ~~~~~~~~~~~~4;~;~?
      ~(a ( -14~~-~ ort:u_fl_u./Milll;.l.& WiMtdtL~-~-·.
     {"ui;;&. ol r;m tf.u.!UJ.~A.WJLtl.yLt«<@;;_~ /1.&!!-tkh ~ t;;J;;lfwec~~r---'------
                                                   .   '       .                    .             .

     'f'.w.--ttM ~dut..t!t.t.;;_,~L fku:J.uadllr.//..117--Wt•fPLff..{a.L~JA-l~-_
         c/M,p&· _YwfA,._ !4oa{ ~tfu'r       . ,           .            .. .            .·   .,       . ·
                                                                   ,·

                             "                                                                        .,   '

           •                             I             '
                                                                           '   '.                      '

'   i.
                                                                                         r

   11 '.-r 'Z If
·i.nv                  /'    ....--· . ._:-.       .   .           ·.        .       .       .   ,
        , to II ' i   {;(jJ;t f1VIILlltJta     .           .   ·         ·       .

 I                                                                      ,·
 I
~~----~------~------~~--~------------~--~---
.;
 I
     \
; . . f2d~_/MLtd_L~-LLt_iu_/A_a:;_ ~rf-__ ttLIU_fL{_-/Jf¥-:d~£L(}1l~ •.• .·.
      _ ·tA-~(oJ,_ vk t;a~_f.t!~_t_fl_p_uJuLtd_tlr!_L;&:fd_Llo__7_{u_._f_ (L)_dtt_~~7!uw .
             (;:LfM-<.      uijMu_,:_t> fC~~-flbl.iLf.L-;t;; 6JL{Z;,.£~~KfdS : ·. . ·.
         . . k..                                  >
                             L:-fk f U/Lf~lliLkduJ_/ d~-~-61 ~ .f ~           7!- -:t;_&tt__tL{~5_~CL~5~--_
             ~    .J .J. ~ t;l£.. ' --~ ..;----.-- _,.., . ~ ·-r~      --~. -
             ~~~lL_/U~.La_~~Lhd ~':-u~L~~atLLIUJ1LLJ- .           rt.je&C~-Jti£L~--
                ~      .j    /   .. /        /'    I   '        L   l /   .     /Z       I
      --+--V--=--~~(A)~_ILU,~ty_i_rM_t()ILL?i!CLtL0_tLL_f_{J~Iilf ltL~J:i(Lczl7-f-tJ~c;-Zbl~.·_
                                                                                     ¢               _)   · ,-../'· .

             ~Xf-'1 &_rw~~j!:; ·tr~ ~ idh~tr-~;~CLu~af/ow_td_~ tt~~ · · .
             LfS_~t( 6< -rk_dfL~_ti_L~~M_~'l; -~~!% J~ctdLLt/4~
        . ~~~14-u;_y_tL~~f1LU~£il;-a~l£aLtLcd~E~u ~~&:!~L -t;=                                                              -
         . iC-Lt¢ul.~ "r~fflu;t--~~t:~~C-:Z:X_~"~r?k&_.~--. .___
      --t---_M~-La«-ituJ_f~~tiie_;_s_1~~e-L~Lf-k_ILt~ ~Ju.-~ :6:=--·_
         ,__ i~ ?C(_ ~"-~~0L(;!_I~ t~L!/tf.aLll_~_p_£~tlffllC~;-·    .
         au:;-- (A,iAJ_fd_~tt_S_{_L{':d_,_ut-')_cL_Uy_fZLt_c_h-LZ_lL~C~~L(~- -~ )a_&__~f-a_t-t                          .
         .~h~~-Ct(~~WA5-~)_L~-~/Lu£t_a.~~~IP_v_-:-~~c. ,
          ll.it it~ -~ pj{aui__td_~tL~--73_f_k/Lu_~ ~ ~'-~~f_ii_~(A_G;kk)t~_.._
      ---J---#-        k!PLatl_~~cA/t;_w_L_LL,:. ~tl/__0_{)~5. li:w~-da~_£4/1~_·.
             6u ~ touve!hJ.o/-~r~ A!fk~<~~~w--)~~s~nh.-?-t?~·-·_
              . dds'&ud "~~idO_I'_A« dv__'<.JL~/_p,W_,I ~ JiLL!_!:. k_exkbt_D;_ ..
             a.!' 7fiLdl-"'-' t;__t{_ !t!ALrfL-kf_ fa1P-ttLJJ~)_/ttJJ:.a.f~ <¥ _,c:; ey~;_, . ·
             o_£-tC l~.i,_do_dt<'1f,:~d/a,-L).>;)~ Lu,..,r1'T f"lM..-1~                                        ,
     . ~lJ_k_e,tt~+-. 't                fau.t_GL{~~L~{fdp;-t!Lk?t_ldo ~_L~drL1A_-_
 •    ~ tJ i'iJ :14 r;Yfh+!-t(t 2-U_~ ~.,~r;;__{lLiii!' rl"Lu-Dx fk[~_r_p~ "'~·----'----
              f'

  . . , ?-o ~11-7 t-~UJ.b-~0.~-£; -<._ fb""'-~Ad<¥~~lt"V ~~
t: . '             ~~ _j{nfJI'Ji:d .-t; ~.lvv_t rd_£;ha-'~-~Co-"-(l_v__}_,
                                                          . . . . . '- .' .
      .. ·llfLtJLUL~thu~ -c,~Ou~lf_u.rt&lr ,./t5_pa_~u.1_~~-{Mtp_>-t;~---
 •1.~~~~~~~~~~~(
      ~\~-----~------~-~--------~~--!',.~
         I
         \         '
                                                                                             .   '
··-''.'•'
                                                           .1'

                                                          ·'

       •    ·J·>·          .     ·. . .   (Ju $/Ahtc.   /}atp.u. r;;~ . . . · . · .·.. .   ,   · . ·. .·.. ·

       .·       ~~&-=_lltyt1%r&k.N?fii".17 b.~fi~i~-~JV.A.Qi: 'fk ~c-
.. .               ' r:-.;- ..,.-~. ~ . I .A", - , - Rw
                  ~Lut_t~r;;.Ju;;l_~6iJJs_fiu_~tt;_L6.  lt .- ' - __                  r -' £ 1 •J ' ·
                                                                  c; 7 ~Kt;_idLiill_JJ_ltc/lX2]_tt_
                                                                        f,e,.,_ q (},

           ~~"fi_d.pv~~~Lil;.,j_{;g¥'4H$v.t~·,,.
            .   ~~~~tU:;~ i ?'cJ~~~G744 rlol c .·. ... .. . ·. . .                                        ;