Court Opinion

ID: 4040826
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:38:23.681932+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:03:01.925689
License: Public Domain

DATE: li(p^//-S^   ¥ Ofafait <¥fi^
     DECEIVED fM            BY- P(/ 7        " ^V£fc/ ^^^
C0URT0FCRifw,WAL;pPE4LS       '—               A^^sfe&ts'ir)//
      JAW 20                     Wfl-1*,*W-o«:
  Abel Acosta- Clerk       ^^ tf6.f)-/-066f--%>M?-C*

flfet&e esi</eir a rv/fhy tZntferhfrtj &toi/-ti*e a.6c^ <lfj£/ec/' One/y<fcr-6efcd

^W gn^r /V a <%?-eeJf /r^t/ ^ /-he jdo\A^<&//-e<J &n/WriterJ
&IIT&ZS ^^?e/ Sk -zsflparvt- ^//^/^ fisitfffm stff/feas?'/1- Sti&uu*?:
                                      X

/fa /6*f /fe/~' 6rtAr£ a/y^pec/ /r fau/f/z&mf ^<^*i/5A/^i
/* Off/fcariJ- k'f a cAm/ #fftJf&/r<3)S) - •&**?£ f<$ f>aS- WflPa~r4 fa/A*
ff 0* /£• cfhfi////,^^/ cs/frfi /As Ar////.*%^~?<$?2/&</ fr <r<^ 3 &X-.
,rtT /W <&£ *f, <?*'sc<r/& fay Jfef &</& fn AfS &gg?f£<rf At*/ //j#
WYr/- 6y?fi/fOnf£>rt (sscl<? c/rieUr /frfoZ/J^I/fJcS?, sZrtc/ (/rubr/hc /*//<»
ujf*# /M^ asic/ /&MS *. tt~2J, T8*ZZ? Ifr^, £*/**/,<£),%f./?, &.nP<3&0),
                                     3T
  /?Jpr^£«a/ fi/ /Pr&pee/P^ iAri*** Me yrf^A 6$c/rA £e/Peir<es /a^.
o/fet^fffa/ Pf urffaoi/A 'yfreJtf</fct, <fa*e p&rAP& (sforftA'Acu*c <Pr«fAjP-£fea6<A
& <%k<xr>x yszty?'?6i<pAtvtn J&£0j*-etA /& /tap/fA^^* AA-e Pi**ii*iUrtf/2-' £c0r<r>e& -
jwgrtA- i/j/h /?*€ /mtfJ' A#(SrA AaviAtjH wo rtmP Pyn/z/^r^estA p^ ^Pr&v^
/A# ^r&z/^^siA* yry: <f&£ti z^-^ A-t cAwe^ -Afar*- AfetA&p*'*'AaAA*™ r*#Airt-r
 rto -gengX'. jA&c/irgif&ry y/iS ¥££?>*w^^^s~ A&ri^AcrrP&tn, <P^/ne <cArt>A/&rtr<ryyc^
(Jfrr^&T A A^ a/f/P^^iP APr a usr>A app/Pk^AP^^ pf /rtyfcfef&i/--
£?gp//~i#rsA'r &ntA c/ar^A fc0?f<r<ry fa /pTfi^PSSW, hcfr^g'TacsrytPkAr &/
&rr&<rr *><pyAuf JPsP^P^c/^ &tn<A /he <£r*xsyidr of/&& typ/PA&ykA, extent
/Asr^ Pr Ahf-orff/^PenA #<pf<rw^?iAr *>f/Ae i/PrA"<pcrcrrA P& JPf^tPrrfaA^e
a/pfAPte-rtA a.'.vi/apA- 4flpyPaa/&"'

  fe /revcifA vpasi Ay?c^^6$rt(sfcP!o>n cssr// #<f fodpetcr /&rp?<rs^ ^ypcmA
h&c&T /A-e pHSreUn <?/flr<n/Pyi$, A/- a ff&fiMe/e/ZwT^ d>^y&e tf\rP^^r^/^<e
/mz/r /AaP- c^fo^AA &//P/A? AP^ /<y rePPe^- sPfptyPowP »<i<srA ^a/Prfpp a
yAr-€>-e-^<fcyij4t/ y&rAj aflpAZ&W- /*</?A ^pPrrA <fA#css /taA/h*. <?Azt/& <3r<s*^
jfaffeA /& cAfr<rA<r£e ^\rfj^yk^^ r^^rAA^rr ^ /&# /r5?e&sPP?rir g>&&dA&r-
htiJ fafM/ A^^siirfA /tt^rt ^AocM yA^A /&* [////ifa&AA ^pPeA^t^e- frfawr
rccAAt /& aflpA&wA, ^V f6# a0A?A*£*nA r^^^Aoo^ /Aa^/te, fA^A^
A&(*KA ei/P°AztnpZ AT ^t/e-rP^A ff # ff&&£rA*'rrT jbcA+trry*- ^p^-r £ Afasi
^OLcAA<y^i/ PwivWc/yiPA/ ttfimZfi^ie^A <fe%A/£ eAc&r ^4?/w/£s^ Aprpa^r-or- /<r
Jfr/^Prr, an*f prpa/ A*jrA app^iMA Pr tc Afr^'MApr/^ i/^an ^//^M^y;
<pA-en y^/ClA AhiSrA aff^^-A Pan & ^Ze^APo^ /Psi/fA ,%:/6& /ffkA&VrA-
pr dZuWr^e p^iA /%£ ^/P^asIPrm/ pf A<<&&<yAj?ari an Pmr*tmfA%-'•<z&he.-e/*Z£t*A«
                                       V
  fPrtdPPjAs P? i*rf>t?^ //i&v-z /Ai^tA /&* eAArA/p£Ks<ry <peO>--*s*-r+encAs /&
cAPr^Prr [ffeAa/**P aA&o /?rA/%2*/Z,fi}ppO,p^,&^£rP^-A>rGa»/#^
CAi(f£z t/szAh ytvt <r&6T^fy?<L/itAr y<r (/Pr^Zrr p^ Pn$uZfp£A^'?£ dnrp<rr«***A*r~'
4<s?J!sMZ€,r~ /haA Ahe s^pAA&sbA €&#us Pr /^la/erp^tAy ytistA Pr, /frer^ft
Pi ret&crncti&Pe fliTcsA^cA^AA/^ /AaS Asic/ //<e gi/PcA?<^Ze< A^r? /&&A*Z£tA>
AA& &oA6rr*& tP//Ac /vPk/ lM&er//p,4Hs>t £e*!rt eA^^^eyTp. faj^ p%K9Apy<S'
AfontiA A&<<^? & /<re f<lfe6<z?T 6&Pn, 0<p jpePA/yVL /* t/frtAo-PZ dX&AyaL -
y*f¥ &i/fJem>ef *P£p*sh*f a fProvspnj} //haA Afo^ ?&& PovyP XafeA A*
- e/PrZ7Po£& &\zAeA&*i£&5> y^&fiAA&fr ^ AAe flr&£^<rAP^'? goc^ ^^^
 /aAAAy /A-e iam/A^AiA ev&z"^* P^p^v^<reAAe fa y$# apfAA^^t stnc/- &/~

A)rs^/}^nry tMcA a ^/eepAy /rAaA rfaAAr, £#£P ^'^e rep^Py^fZe^P^ra/Potn
0^yAi4'' peZAGc^/Ay./Zzs/op?^ aP/Aoc/sA /Z^P ar^ nop &X<?AvrP^:<p?A/At /t^p^1
&//Ai^ JeAatPpdh/A** ftzas&^f /?«^/A* *k£jp//1?s/fre^pAZZstnA'tZf&vr-
Afa<* &<p A&€ vr&A/p ztnAPZpy //>e fn&/»S&<e /<r Az?s <r0?z?yP<&*-^ r&r<r/ZPrgf-
/<fcrt /A-e tPg-Aa,^ '2^ /?^pP/?-/Z,^^/art<APzZ5o p2tyy-/ben*4>/- y-'&a/Zy

   £A frj&r- AZ&^e <re*tzro^r /Zi^A fApfr AtonovzA/e pp?c/*A ^fo^A^
iZtoAtzr- /-& & -g-tfte-ecAy <roPPyip) <*s? /Z>e ZYp^C^ "?$/&</ tfnA n*A*re<tZ^(/^€y
#&J /& a&zepy /APf /^oAfen y<? •fvyp?*y&rf~ <net&wr^&McPr /& JPr^Prr
 tizfAPt? sA zZt/r/Zier- <PeAa/.

                           <£fn&&<r€AjAr

                      <0PcZia^P cZn/Z

                     </fr,si ZeZo/*& fx ??$%p:

                                   -?•