Court Opinion

ID: 4048027
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:32:16.639845+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:39.699803
License: Public Domain

33 d LQSM‘ 01 )0;{{03 l OL‘E
REC`EIVE
couRT oF chMmAEZ ;§PEALS

_JUN 08 2015

Ab@!Ac 4 g \
'~TD w Cuzm/. wl mg coua,vof &m»unv.aL Mnmw mt !@§'k

’\2€~: Q€Gl;\€sw'?oa G>\)Fa(lvum~sow oF D€leE/Lu mr A~?VLH\,+T.MJJ Frm wmroF
umw comm

\\.\c\Pon&Src\
Cu'ee,;\wrhgs `> €nc,\bsee\ phase."€`nci a (efpe,c:'\'p\»\ e,,\oeph madz,"\) m \A)GLL @wmly
”D\swmf\' O_LE\{L\< . ‘
"\’LEA)'E Assn£\’\\lem 'mu MM'TE/z.

\leua nw mo e=FForzT u c,rz mch wallecrm-:o .

anlbscc}‘. ?E®\,u-ZS_;\' (chjs§>
\Ex\n`\\§\\"(?, pgs) _ . n n
Qes\,>w¥$nq Ju-LM.`M} ima .S"B’ Zolf'
(~‘¢akn`éj Car§lon:' llI'LlLN/;?z
Al\ add Un\"}
.QlOl F‘H.Z[eq N.
ma ~

    

 

l:c>o\(l"ul; lltiw\. Appen.l> no w Q'( unkn®b~“'\}

&‘?&(~lc`.@\nlme/l l_l:\rc,lo¢\c¢ b ~ § l’n THE L\C`l“‘ $uocoAL
®\3W\&T UMLT
§ UEGB COUNT\! fl’f:'~`\(M

§
R\;®u£sr ma cumv\a\chT\um oz DEu\)EQ\l_oF ADDUCATIONS

o ml wm u; HMSEGS C.uvli>u&‘ c
\\Xuou l\_uw\e,s l:lc)luc`\ul l\_`ucclu¢aa,ccppl`ceemlpru so `\\¢\ ll/\e ~Hlkmn£,od
males ll/\'\s (Qc\ues‘l ol/ Qun _"fmcal§c\n up ’Del`coec\\ up {l\>plimlio:?§ ructh
aj \»\aloec\s lun\us,m\d ¥`Qsp€c.l'l;..llq would slow ~H\p @0uA-as ~ul/ows.'

\.
\ (Qal>¢{ul llxcolum luéinq um;wl\q 'w\o_cneeml’e_al in l’\aTe,ms 'DQpcch/\.lu{
Cu`cm;“al luslio€, uc\(§o( "\mv\a,l& "\fl. v\umloo( lLlllLll:?Z/. Cem Coml:p€+€nl' la Mak&
l\m ~l\lluw{~ng alal€wwv\l_\ \u¢\dor pemllq up Pec§ur\{j' l>e`mgm owl cw@.¢+:
l va\ llch uppl;ouv\-l iv L\ walz u€ llal)eas G)cpw' ll\al-wem fi/er/ on 4'~{.30./.\"
`m ll\cc\lql""§`\§l~dcl llucl.b.>€l>l> ll ' nl\¢ laredo .`\'€Xm. /lr\ `mclc)uul ll'llhg\ will
‘m pmcénd l\m{¢\_ac“€x\.\c' cl \'f pro u lms dulo. t lncwe, wl roomte cc cast>mse,_
lmmll\o.'\)ls-l'riel' Ql€(lL wyl{ mg wL sl' ll\e. Cicc"‘\valu' ur cloliucco{u@+f\u L)vc`lcs or
- ll'v\x\/ll\£\\ l\cw¢ loew clul\.\ cloc,lwl€cl owl »l`\`lecl. l `lllr-llwc' SQ/\.jr 0 l€.l“l€rlv llnz (‘,l€rl£
\”Qquas¥li\g such concacwwlw`w\ l\> m cw¢;c?l. l mcelqu a "BMM QQspu/\ru la A~ppl\ca `w»“
la mcl/\ \uc{l' llle.cl ll_):l' wcll\w.l’ loebch Slcl\m‘>ecl ax“'\:\LEO q l)\\'ll\a/(llerlc . ll*uoos
-/\ul mle of Mc\)€cl lxq llw@l@(l(.cewl Il' cll`cl v\o»l aunl'Ccin ll\a, mcll' numlw r.
Squ/\ (Qsptsme daley llaq Z?_iZBlS'. l luer l§locl7 0 l\lamum¢\olum }n ceplc/
ll> l\\u Blcles c€swn§es uc\ ll\`u Zv\al claq 09 luna ?.uif.-
l l.

5cmcl pml§'lior\§ cu\Ll overall lll\~/{g,§ deem mcc`\le£l via O€c"lw"llecl W\ac` l g (E€r`l..
md l>@\`ccg “lmL\ ~\zrw» u:u\~zuuz'qm ,. exceeded delan dale Ll/lzuhs» we;gl.+
alj 05 Llus 330 oz.[$€~e index Q>r lll\hgc\ .le\ull\or wrl\` coal C`.liv\c] was made v"cc\

Cecl\`£iz¢.l mail cu\§ulw§g of cm ac(»zolum‘l' of §ch 64 sup[»xl»m£ ‘L»n`lz' § (`e(~l~.~ uu.lueiug
wm »m.u~ uc'u\-/zuuq-szqs mm empl inqwa .&l£\ ce»l;[~ed mail pack m
were ulasl£eé lb mello llqu li.vl\'oe (‘e¢\‘l?r .'D;sln`ol (llpAo\ u€~€‘c@ f ESH\Q/ 02qu a
Clo,'cl£ ,c\.tll\ u<~Hr-w op ll\b Violun£z sl. &lc.ao_"),. laredo ‘.\`~ex.cu 'M’DLJO <>¢ ’lxollL

welng ula second llui§cwa_\ up u Llos. 2510 01 .(See facial

 

 

 

lll

\n ac@ucclac\w cull\,\ llr‘l\"clo \l¢Gl el`lloz.`\'»?.xccs Q‘uclesu€ Qc'{'ML/ml choeduces,~llno
C\u"\¢ ul l\~e_ Cnm\"cl\`ng Cm(l* Sl\qll process . l.`le.wvl woch all lll¢`v\g& l~O all pccd)`es
l¢\\)~clua;l. `Fou'lluz¢. wl\w\ `l'l\¢; Slal€ -le:l-Tl~`mer. Suul\ is no~l line cme cu”.> f +l/\i`§
Sf“" cla\\ al luna 20\§, `

\u\lea€cuczo .’Prlmcses mmmr~:/¢eo. +M._. a ~ harm c'“+hu alma alc/M amf
humbecaul wch , ogqu ~ll\ql» `l'ch 0011\+ L‘Dn l")rms lluz cle/¢'m€rqa/ all pedzr`nem£
Q.M,l dul\{ lllc@p male lui llL€Crpp/fco»l,oqcl weil numbers ,

’EQSPECH:L¢(\L( Yu_.lumi*l‘l€L/» JU(nc/S£’ ' ZGIS_

Q@,Lc:@l GQAM/-quuwz
AL\.. ME,O clsz
ézibl F_M 310°( IU¢

iowa rl¢¢`\'¥' 7103(0`1

 
   

 

 

 

 

-K/
§ \

 

 

' " Exkl amc 1 leg armor-of wear "
flde D 4 l:'l my
Tr`\ccl Quu`._Z,_uuS films \o'su 'u\(A§_
*\l.\}l lr\)cll' u,Q l'l&\>€£\$ Qc>rCN\CluW\ ucc l._Cu.» \`n &L\p{l>l'l'_ul: L)\dcc'-l/
~ @r¥\'_lucl/\mml-l\) l\l_\€xwu.ul: lam~{leclc,xo~lccl ro\l+\cs§’\m L,‘(:)S/.O;\`
- llul'\uc\ lur (;uiclenl`occ\{ l/leur'mq . -

Tnul Cweou Qucuw \l.\)'?

o llUv\D~ cl l,&\.\> l\/\ Su§>pu('l' \>lz l,\)<`cl' d __ @v?v. "F

- `\/e&l§w\uml ul: Ql/\<”\:§lw'\o l_uz£mu (.L`Y\ &\)\ pu(lu? pulkl al Gc rdwn»llCl/v’&hsc/dplu'l

f l\)ch\\\ cl\`sou\mc€ ul Luc{u l/elez O,

" Q&\olu chnzele,s ?chv_
':ddlmg¥bl\\l(l('lw r\€.’L (
" bth ll\Of ®Url` '10\;'('|0\
'“ O,lr\c`\_&~lw`c\o l,.‘>ma\o mp '
rlCu\e/l l)CY\G_£\lC]

~ Mulau¢\ ldc molev\l'ocq l'lauc'cvq

~T_<\_eoc§ eucuu\.s ll¢u'l

~/ \l.l@,'\N\D L`>C low lv\_§upp>(~l"ol l)bccl
' TJ¢S_l-;w\u\q ull Ql\("c`$l\‘¢\o l,o?_uc\o a¢\c;\ Dcw€d l\AlL¢ C`e,;ezu ["` ‘°‘“SC("?W _
v loclr\e,s& S-lc.lch.Q/\l":i ' o - ;, f _
§\m\\)'\) ul: Iv\l€m`w\_»s ul`~ Qa.lm`r\u lull/ma lai w l leaman_q all l,uciu Ue/Fz U.
" (POLl:lo Q\or\?£\l£_l
~ mad llcccliv\ev. C\mzu
~/ lum Aq>ull?\ac ®u`.ougu @occ`cl'e
’ ’ ®(\\x`\§l\ho l_c>mnD
‘ llu’l\l>r\ loc l§uiclw\l\` uc\{ lleo\<'mg c
` ~' E»x¢:o_rp¢l‘§ ul f (TLEL l:acl€ml Mm'l€me. run Conwcrml.l
" fl)l€,€t %orgo`w\ llqr?£.w\l)n'l'
-' budqw\ml' ul: Col\ l(;_l§Q/l .
» udicial ®uc.l£ul cl lelch cca,\)\sz§\`ug c'>cq)p£llu~le l?m¢\se/l

lam

 

‘l'o{al Cuu(l come nu ‘. 100&>€\0,¢\) 01§>’?70 m /A-) ~

¢-\l.b'l L¢c?~l' ul:' l’lCclch\S Cl><

z \lf\en\u . ul l_Q¢w {v\ suppu<§::l: b$rl_l

~* l\lul`w/\ l~w Euirla¢\l\' C\cq l'lQm<'inL§ _

_ ~ lim.erp'l'§ ul". ('V~€‘. cmlzml §in-€./\c.<)_“l\s mn CanUrs~€/»l')

~' ?laoe ‘l$curqula l\qc'mvwrcl
-/ §u£l%w.¢\l@f' Qonu~~fc,l\`w\ ,
f dud€c`c'u\ Buclull oct holmle ol;l?€rélp,.l"enclonll
- judicial O¢¢lccl €C. le;ll`\l;\l\l»| ali C',lcl`c"wu wl Exl\il»#z' (r€`»"‘J“Sl
v l\lulio/\ luc loec/\rl\ mccool wl E¢,ls`¢lzc'l§

l ` Malouu£ was c,e,clllecl unuch 001 swle package
cull-lied me “\um mo ouul wm ms
'Dul`cuecy dole_‘. ¢lpdl 30»20|'4 ' .
’Dzsl\`ncrlimi ®Rsldcl Ql€(% Eslea’ Dequ'"aalo _

\\\u v lol>ccu al `;la, 103
_ L(lr€clo.T\L "(‘KGLl'L

wecq\\l: 3 L\»s . Sno uz.

\1?9&&'Qllclaui‘lul &\ula~ lv\ @aner_n/ mer 3
Cucl§lae_pl -r\b~_“?u\q mo mul wm Sz,qz 12¢+\,~\ czm=g+ few
'Dal`c\l€£\{ OlG-l€,: wl l~l(l\{ Ll_ c ZOlS
‘Da-$'l\hccliun ‘. ®i$~l‘r'ccl- `(lle(ilc E.S-ler [)ngllaclo
c \\lo\tielm>c\c`c sic Sle.U)S
l.o_ceclu ,`\'K "[X’DLIL

 

l,OQ'ql\-l`. 5 l_lus. Z._“lO u‘L,, _

lleqw,sl' -ll;( l:c)ccoe,lw'm al v€(§urcl lilecl “' l/la ";§,ZD|§
" Al§b lequ£g€tl C'l€(l,'l\ N>`l~:fq di l).>‘f'\;l'\“ prl?.(i' A>N;vcll\

‘~l l\)\ew~umv\l)lxcns 13\ Qaplq `l\ glule; ‘leeS?v/\se.s ~l`¢lecl via C€(li€*