Court Opinion

ID: 3407841
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-07-05 19:24:24.844913+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:34:34.344715
License: Public Domain

I respectfully concur only in the principles of law enumerated in the majority opinion and in the voluntary act of withdrawal of Mr. Justice Ingram M. Stainback from participation in the hearing of this matter. *Page 286 
I am of the opinion, upon the entire record before us, the exhibits, the subject matter of the respective affidavits and the arguments of all counsel thereon:
First, that it is incumbent upon Mr. Justice Philip L. Rice as in the case of Mr. Justice Ingram M. Stainback, in order to avoid and dissolve any question whatsoever as to the propriety of Mr. Justice Philip L. Rice sitting as a member of the court upon the hearing of this cause; and
Second, that it is likewise incumbent upon Mr. Justice Philip L. Rice, as in the case of Mr. Justice Ingram M. Stainback, to the end that the fullest measure of dispassionate consideration and impartiality by this court may be insured upon said hearing, rather than chance even the slightest taint, however obscure, which would or could cast shadow or divert the fullest, fairest, and impartial hearing to which the respondent herein and any other respondent or litigant is entitled in accordance with the fundamental tenets and highest ideals of traditional concepts of fairness and justice,
That Mr. Justice Philip L. Rice should forthwith, as in the case of Mr. Justice Ingram M. Stainback, voluntarily recuse himself sua sponte for the compelling reasons that become apparent upon examination and consideration of said record. *Page 287