Court Opinion

ID: 9386346
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2023-04-12 14:02:09.039398+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T17:18:05.321985
License: Public Domain

Cite as 2023 Ark. App. 222
                     ARKANSAS COURT OF APPEALS
                                       DIVISION III
                                       No. CR-22-653

                                               Opinion Delivered   April 12, 2023

 DARRYL WILLIAMS                          APPEAL FROM THE JEFFERSON
                                APPELLANT COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT
                                          [NO. 35CR-19-282]
 V.
                                               HONORABLE ALEX GUYNN, JUDGE
 STATE OF ARKANSAS
                                  APPELLEE
                                               AFFIRMED

                              WAYMOND M. BROWN, Judge

       Appellant Darryl Williams was convicted by a Jefferson County jury of aggravated

assault and possession of a firearm by certain persons. After a firearm enhancement, he was

sentenced to an aggregate term of thirty years’ imprisonment. He argues on appeal that the

circuit court erred by denying his directed-verdict motions. We affirm.

       Appellant was employed by Hixson Lumber Company and was subsequently fired

when it was discovered that he had been stealing time during his scheduled night shifts. On

April 26, 2019, appellant went into Joseph Green’s1 office to sign his termination paperwork

and get his final check. Appellant looked at his paycheck as he was leaving and came back

into Joseph’s office complaining about the amount of the check. Appellant was agitated and

       1
           Joseph was the yard foreman at Hixson Lumber.
was warned that he had to leave the premises before the police were called. Appellant left

out the office, picked up a crossout, which is a six-by-six piece of lumber, and threw it. The

crossout hit Chris, Joseph’s brother who was standing at the door, in the knee. After hitting

Chris, appellant began walking backwards so that he was facing the men. Joseph pushed

Chris out of the way and started reaching for a crossout sitting on a bundle of plywood

located outside the office. As he reached for the crossout, appellant pulled out a chrome-

colored revolver, causing Joseph to raise his hands in the air. Chris also raised his hands.

Appellant then turned around and took off running. Appellant left in what looked to be a

white older-model minivan being driven by someone else. The police were called, and

appellant was subsequently arrested.

       Appellant’s jury trial took place on December 13, 2021. Joseph testified about the

events of April 26, 2019. During Joseph’s testimony, a security video from the date in

question was played. Joseph indicated that the video did not show when appellant threw

the crossout due to the position of some of the lumber. Joseph identified a point in the

video where he said appellant pulled a gun from his left pocket and pointed it at Joseph,

causing him to raise his hands. However, the weapon was not captured by the security system

because a pole blocked its view. Appellant was shown walking and then running from the

property. Joseph admitted that appellant never said anything after he pulled the gun and he

stated that he did not know why appellant backed off after doing so. However, he said that

the look on appellant’s face indicated that maybe appellant did not mean to pull the gun

and was overreacting. Chris’s testimony about that day mirrored Joseph’s testimony in many

                                              2
aspects. However, Chris stated that appellant was waving the gun around. Chris testified

that he also raised his hands when the gun was pulled.

       At the conclusion of the State’s case, appellant made two directed-verdict motions

premised on the State’s failure to prove that he had or possessed a firearm. The circuit court

denied the motion. The defense rested without putting on a case and renewed its directed-

verdict motions on the same basis. Again, the motions were denied. The jury found

appellant guilty of the charges against him and sentenced him to thirty years in the Arkansas

Department of Correction. Although appellant’s jury trial took place in December 2021,

the sentencing order was not filed until March 17, 2022. Appellant timely filed his notice

of appeal.

       Appellant argues on appeal that the circuit court erred by denying his directed-verdict

motions. A directed-verdict motion is a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence and

requires the movant to apprise the circuit court of the specific basis on which the motion is

made.2 Arguments not raised at trial will not be addressed for the first time on appeal, and

parties cannot change the grounds for an objection on appeal but are bound by the scope

and nature of the objections and arguments presented at trial. 3 Here, appellant contends

that the circuit court erred by denying his directed-verdict motions because there is no

evidence that appellant “pointed his pistol at the Green brothers. Having a gun on him,

       2
           Jones v. State, 2015 Ark. App. 495.

       3
           Id.

                                                 3
pulling out a gun from his left pocket, and waving it around does not rise to the level of

proof required to constitute aggravated assault.” Appellant admits that he was in possession

of a firearm on the day in question by virtue of this argument. Possession was the sole basis

of appellant’s directed-verdict challenges at trial, which he now concedes.4 The argument

appellant now raises is not preserved for our review. Accordingly, we affirm.

       Affirmed.

       VIRDEN and GRUBER, JJ., agree.

       Potts Law Office, by: Gary W. Potts, for appellant.

       Tim Griffin, Att’y Gen., by: Rebecca Kane, Ass’t Att’y Gen., for appellee.

       4
        Appellant also abandons any challenge to his possession-of-a-firearm-by-certain-
persons conviction because his argument on appeal is directly related to his aggravated-assault
conviction.

                                               4