Court Opinion

ID: 6143522
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-02-05 14:47:17.066642+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:54:45.341018
License: Public Domain

Daly,> J. —
The argumento! a demurrer on wbicb a judgment is rendered, wbicb is a final disposition of tbe action, is a trial. w. trial is a judicial examination of tbe issues between tbe parties, whether of law or fact. § 252. A demurrer involves an examination and decision of tbe issues, and where it is followed by a judgment, wbicb disposes of tbe case, tbe argument must be regarded as a trial. An argument upon a demurrer, noticed as frivolous, is not a trial, because if tbe judge does not see that the demurrer is frivolous, he makes no decision upon tbe issues. Rochester Bank v. Rapelje, 12 How. 26. It is merely a motion to get rid of a frivolous pleading. Gould v. Carpenter, 7 ibid. 97. Put a demurrer not frivolous raises an issue of law, and tbe argument of it is tbe trial of an issue of law. Hendricks v. Buck, 2 Abbott, 360. There may be some doubt, perhaps, whether it may be regarded as a trial, where liberty is given to amend. But in this case tbe plaintiff did not avail himself of that liberty, but appealed to tbe general term, and tbe defendant bad judgment. It must, therefore, be regarded as a trial, and tbe case was one entitling tbe defendant to an extra allowance.
Order Appealed from reversed, and an extra allowance granted.