Court Opinion

ID: 4041114
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:43:42.840913+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:28:31.118562
License: Public Domain

\2r i£~-bODW<-£~

                                                     T    c—-——1l

CA^Jcny, Q£3&ax£F

                ^L£DOT5FS 0\n.GuiALAWlCA06K\ To^^eET CF MA^WU^
3D iiC^CJ^Si£^A0GGC3F^AID QX&X -

r_CA^eC3F AaXOtA Ak5DFUl£SIVES C£I£I^AL AP^O-CATAC^ Fo£coRHOF mMOAWlUS ^
\teuAtJTiaJ£OLUL UjCSI S£OI£kS3>(c^ AjJ0uX3^Stto^ltt£Qx)^^^
  3h^. C-J&clTA^Tt^W: l^2Q2kIS Art QFt£^£ljO>CA^Wd^l^^^
QFOgOTMAi .^SC\(T AjJOIS AP<&A£\^G W&,Se (OVto CA*i ft£ L£Dfr£b AT fcCCb OJOill
J2aLBDd35i%freisiO£S5>£^ cc^j^TTns&mG^ QoAiba has ecoAusreD vase&fi&sKs
^SCl HAS m C#k£Q~7^£QuAie ££M£D4 AT UuifrTfte Aj: ^JG^Tlb ?X G*n&Jjl£ft IS
flllx&SEmUMSt CC)CeeXr£i^^.X\i NUTUi^^CTaALtoaG IS uHTffl^ ^mCKILDki
TOJ?£>QdjOD unVtt^ a^TO^S m^T^ttVL AW ILCS1 A^^PA^mOj[3Aib grano
31£ COLXMXAJ AC CcaOC Of AP&A<-S, £€£^"06^ U/& TAli^m^ ^X> :£>.
                        ACT llJCft-Oflffl

:uux_Oi£fi£^a«£ nx^ issuer io &e ees^ujc^.
  Mb Cc£4 OFW-^oSt CDa\Gai&vJ> U3QH WJCSI, Ai^Ai08oO£.e^FTJ^^AkSO
Autesmxxzi&c.geotx^gt^^cu^ \^v3oa^avfijv^jo>g oja^ wa^ vu^jc
^e^ki"I^^WTKG.^TO"THC Cea£I OF C€Xn\T*Mju APPALS-UA& &ACH fcOOJflOfcAJl-S-

*$&£AUb»

£oa>Ji\|~ra(As w& Am^EsregiAL dj^mio £££glm£. a^fxu^ ao~ £a9££2>t^ a opxitcdjal

lOX^O^J^XT-.Zl, Ai^CiXS e£5^^6X.^u^u^Oe(^TCC^ iLo>T sec 3>(crno Xmcv^dAlaM
TeA^fi(TqD:^^luec^^a of awgaiS a cd?\( oftug u^ecr of tv^eA^ a^a^ iL&Ty^M
r^SweeS"EIL£O(A^0 AC££aFI£At£Jt.O AT HCR

xis3Tye4o2.Ni^ ^qs^Useskzici Coosa or u^bc^a^x3MTeYAS v

QfilAttfcS Qe^aeSl "Fce"^A)isatnnALC3F ACoCM bFTtfGGJKCXyAjOS AviS>wees,TH^D
AMOA CG£TIFI£AT£ 0£OTX^GTtte OAlCU^ uftilUATWAr F£^XtO>GluA^ rYlAOC

 ASXbHMI-Cl£A&T&X&Q£LA[&b> L£J[e^.££LAT6& UAS PJI ££SP^D£joTO^ k&OXLC
tuat ££u^d^sgq^t^3^^                      c>F-me A99dxaud>^ -F^^enroF

 JAAGGAS^C^Pj^ ,Ak>\1 AjoSu£jES-R1£^/Aj^.A C€£Xtt=ICAlG £eOXIOGrTft£ QAT£
 Ufb*A uMLOATUATFXKiOljOG WAS WAO0D£»5t HAS COOLLY FAH£b
TO tott\OU( i^U~rVCT£USCc&£<3FaZTj(^                            ilcOl ^Cc)A^XS
rApa^ax^(^bTATT^ Ak)0 MASTAtLGOTO AfFc£& EOAtmTtiG ftCSf€SSIOiJALAvJfo
 ODttvncxi ccacxe^j OFAkxj vajCXUGj^ R£SfokJS£sTo HIS CoW££5&>^Q£vioe AkSO ££o$Q£sr.

                         ^GS.
 T*MGC£ta£G ?£LAto& "W^STB^XT e>£t£££e£D ftHTVtESQyJ^X Foe £&ATc£S UKET
.C&. UA^ASeaaOJlS Aei U-ST ^G^CASmraeDlOTM^Ccu^OFC^XntLvi^ APP€AlS\T^:
tofbo^Qs: has MDTHGSAi^u^tr^i^cGc^c^Aecixr &'&-i4 A^£> RAS^SV
T^^crcO^XT TO~mGtt*xgX 0T02xmixiALAf^t3 AS6£T0oTXAT-C*Cp U-OLotd

                   C££TXfTCAtG CSF S6£jrC£

  thes xs to cemu^i mjxvg. tit& &m9iXG0 wxrH £ulgot A99a^T£ Ppxmige
 CLS §v/ 5£&tdo>g. Acopy oFTUG AGoJe piotx>*a "uyearsF wMQAmas oj&Ki
 ^SSPOn^jsST t5ISn^lCaJ&e^^€>KSICAlU^J^^ 40Z.^^^<5iaALQISVC2XCT
jCoass;oFJoOodba>x>siH-?.0. to( n01 C?vxiVkw\"uVtsti>1>                ___
 t^mAtLo^ a-&4-is

                                           T£tfv^s&e£*cDuc»a|xx ivgrgo