Court Opinion

ID: 2969904
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2015-09-22 16:00:02.970568+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T11:43:26.906606
License: Public Domain

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21
             3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

     (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU
                 )LOH 1DPH DS

81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6
               )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7
                 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

 '(55,&. 48,17(52                ;
         3HWLWLRQHU$SSHOOHH      
                                   
                                     1R
            Y                     
                                    !
                                   
 5,&.< %(//:DUGHQ               
         5HVSRQGHQW$SSHOODQW 
                                  1
       $SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW
    IRUWKH:HVWHUQ'LVWULFWRI.HQWXFN\DW/RXLVYLOOH
    1Rn7KRPDV%5XVVHOO'LVWULFWsXGJH
                6XEPLWWHG0DUFK
             'HFLGHGDQG)LOHGsXQH
  %HIRUH.(,7+1255,6DQG'$8*+75(<&LUFXLW
                      sXGJHV
                   BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
                        &2816(/
21 %5,()  5LFNLH / 3HDUVRQ 2)),&( 2) 7+(
$77251(< *(1(5$/ )UDQNIRUW .HQWXFN\ IRU
$SSHOODQW  3DXO / :KDOHQ )W 7KRPDV .HQWXFN\ IRU
$SSHOOHH

                             
     4XLQWHURY%HOO                               1R       1R                                 4XLQWHURY%HOO      

                     BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB                                     +RZHYHU DV LV WKH FDVH ZLWK DOO VWUXFWXUDO HUURUV WKH
                                                                       WDLQWHGFRPSRVLWLRQRI4XLQWHURjVWULDOXQGHUPLQHG4XLQWHURjV
                         23,1,21                                       HQWLUHWULDO7KHRQO\DSSURSULDWHUHPHG\LVWRJUDQW4XLQWHUR
                     BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB                                 DQHZWULDO
  $/$1 ( 1255,6 &LUFXLW sXGJH :DUGHQ 5LFN\ %HOO                                              ,,,
DSSHDOV IURP WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV MXGJPHQW JUDQWLQJ D
FRQGLWLRQDO ZULW RI KDEHDV FRUSXV WR 'HUULFN 4XLQWHUR             )RU WKH IRUHJRLQJ UHDVRQV WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV JUDQW RI D
SXUVXDQWWR86&:H$)),50                              FRQGLWLRQDOZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXVLV$)),50('
                                ,
  4XLQWHUR DQG RWKHU LQPDWHV HVFDSHG IURP WKH .HQWXFN\
6WDWH3HQLWHQWLDU\LQsXQH,QVXEVHTXHQWWRKLV
UHFDSWXUHDMXU\FRQYLFWHG4XLQWHURRIVHFRQGGHJUHHHVFDSH
DQGILUVWGHJUHHSHUVLVWHQWIHORQ\RIIHQGHU7KHMXU\LQFOXGHG
VHYHQMXURUVZKRKDGSUHYLRXVO\VHUYHGRQDMXU\ WKDW KDG
FRQYLFWHG4XLQWHURjVFRHVFDSHHV
  $WWULDO4XLQWHURDGPLWWHGWRKDYLQJHVFDSHGEXWDUJXHGD
mFKRLFH RI HYLOVl GHIHQVH SXUVXDQW WR .HQWXFN\ 5HYLVHG
6WDWXWHZKLFKH[FXVHVDGHIHQGDQWjVFRQGXFWLILW
ZDV QHFHVVLWDWHG E\ D VSHFLILF DQG LPPHGLDWH WKUHDW RI
SHUVRQDOLQMXU\+RZHYHUWKHWULDOFRXUWGLGQRWLQVWUXFWWKH
MXU\ RQ WKLV DIILUPDWLYH GHIHQVH VLQFH LW FRQFOXGHG WKDW
4XLQWHURKDGIDLOHGWRRIIHUSURRIRIDQLPPHGLDWHWKUHDWRI
SHUVRQDO LQMXU\  $IWHU LW FRQYLFWHG 4XLQWHUR WKH MXU\ ZDV
LQVWUXFWHGWRVHQWHQFHKLPWREHWZHHQWHQDQGWZHQW\\HDUVRI
LPSULVRQPHQW  7KH MXU\ WKHQ VHQWHQFHG 4XLQWHUR WR WKH
PD[LPXP WHUP RI WZHQW\ \HDUV RI LPSULVRQPHQW WR UXQ
FRQVHFXWLYHO\ZLWKWKHVHQWHQFHKHZDVVHUYLQJDWWKHWLPHRI
WKHHVFDSH
  'HIHQVHFRXQVHOGLGQRWREMHFWWRWKHFRPSRVLWLRQRIWKH
MXU\ EDVHG RQ WKH SULRU LQYROYHPHQW RI WKH VHYHQ MXURUV
$OWKRXJK WKH MXGJH SURVHFXWRU DQG GHIHQVH DWWRUQH\ KDG
SDUWLFLSDWHGLQWKHSUHYLRXVWULDORI4XLQWHURjVFRHVFDSHHV
QRQHRIWKHPVSHFLILFDOO\TXHVWLRQHGWKHVHYHQMXURUVDERXW
ZKHWKHUWKHLULQYROYHPHQWLQWKHSULRUWULDOZRXOGDIIHFWWKHLU
LPSDUWLDOLW\,QVWHDGWKHSURVHFXWRUDQGWKHGHIHQVHDWWRUQH\
JHQHUDOO\ LQTXLUHG RI DOO WKH MXURUV ZKHWKHU DQ\WKLQJ WKH\
    4XLQWHURY%HOO                                    1R        1R                                4XLQWHURY%HOO       

4XLQWHURjV GHIHQVH DWWRUQH\DFNQRZOHGJHG PXFK OHVV                     NQHZRUKDGKHDUGDERXWWKHFDVHZRXOGDIIHFWWKHLUDELOLW\WR
H[SUHVVHGDQ\FRQFHUQWKDWVHYHQRIWKHMXURUVKDGSUHYLRXVO\               UHQGHUDIDLUDQGLPSDUWLDOYHUGLFW$OORIWKHMXURUVLQGLFDWHG
VHUYHGRQDMXU\WKDWKDGFRQYLFWHG4XLQWHURjVFRHVFDSHHV                  WKDWWKH\FRXOGUHQGHUDIDLUDQGLPSDUWLDOYHUGLFW
7KH SUHVHQFH RI WKHVH MXURUV DQG WKH XWWHU IDLOXUH E\
4XLQWHURjVWULDOFRXQVHOWRFRQWHVWWKHLUSUHVHQFHXQGHUPLQHG                  7KH .HQWXFN\ 6XSUHPH &RXUW DIILUPHG 4XLQWHURjV
WKH HQWLUH WULDO SURFHVV VXFK WKDW LW ORVW mLWV FKDUDFWHU DV D   FRQYLFWLRQRQGLUHFWDSSHDO:LWKUHVSHFWWR4XLQWHURjVFODLP
FRQIURQWDWLRQEHWZHHQDGYHUVDULHVl&URQLF86DW                WKDWKHGLGQRWUHFHLYHDIDLUDQGLPSDUWLDOMXU\WKH.HQWXFN\
VHH DOVR $UL]RQD Y )XOPLQDQWH  86               6XSUHPH&RXUWGHFOLQHGWRDGGUHVVLWVPHULWVRQWKHJURXQG
GHILQLQJ VWUXFWXUDO HUURUV DV WKRVH HUURUV WKDW DIIHFW WKH          WKDW4XLQWHURKDGIDLOHGWRSUHVHUYHWKHLVVXHIRUUHYLHZ
mHQWLUH FRQGXFW RI WKH WULDO IURP EHJLQQLQJ WR HQGl DV
RSSRVHGWRWULDOHUURUVZKLFKRFFXUGXULQJWKHSUHVHQWDWLRQRI                 2Q$XJXVWWKHWULDOFRXUWGHQLHG4XLQWHURjVSUR
WKHFDVHWRWKHMXU\ 8QLWHG6WDWHVY0F)HUURQ)G                  VHPRWLRQWRYDFDWHVHWDVLGHRUFRUUHFWKLVVHQWHQFH7KH
WK&LUKROGLQJWKDWWKHHUURQHRXVGHQLDORI               .HQWXFN\ &RXUW RI $SSHDOV DIILUPHG WKH GHQLDO ZLWKRXW
DSHUHPSWRU\FKDOOHQJHFRQVWLWXWHGmVWUXFWXUDOHUURUlXQGHU                  GLUHFWO\ DGGUHVVLQJ 4XLQWHURjV FRQWHQWLRQ WKDW KH GLG QRW
WKH)XOPLQDQWHDQDO\VLV:HWKHUHIRUHDJUHHZLWKWKHGLVWULFW              UHFHLYHDQLPSDUWLDOMXU\LWQRWHGWKDWWKH.HQWXFN\6XSUHPH
FRXUWjVFRQFOXVLRQWKDW&URQLFDSSOLHVREYLDWLQJWKHQHHGIRU               &RXUWKDGUHIXVHGWRDGGUHVVWKHLVVXHRQGLUHFWDSSHDOVLQFH
4XLQWHUR WR GHPRQVWUDWH WKDW KLV FRXQVHOjV LQHIIHFWLYH                 LW ZDV QRW SUHVHUYHG  4XLQWHUR WKHQ ILOHG D PRWLRQ IRU
UHSUHVHQWDWLRQ DFWXDOO\ SUHMXGLFHG KLP IRU SXUSRVHV RI                 GLVFUHWLRQDU\ UHYLHZ ZKLFK WKH .HQWXFN\ 6XSUHPH &RXUW
VDWLVI\LQJWKHSUHMXGLFHSURQJRI6WULFNODQG                              UHMHFWHG

  7KXVZLWK4XLQWHURKDYLQJVDWLVILHGWKHSHUIRUPDQFHDQG                      4XLQWHURILOHGKLVSHWLWLRQVHHNLQJDZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXV
SUHMXGLFH SURQJV RI 6WULFNODQG WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW FRUUHFWO\          %DVHG RQ LWV FRQFOXVLRQ WKDW 4XLQWHURjV 6L[WK $PHQGPHQW
FRQFOXGHGWKDWFDXVHIRUWKHGHIDXOWHGFRQVWLWXWLRQDOFODLP                  ULJKW WR DQ LPSDUWLDO MXU\ ZDV YLRODWHG WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW
H[LVWHG LQ WKH IRUP RI LQHIIHFWLYH DVVLVWDQFH RI FRXQVHO            JUDQWHGDFRQGLWLRQDOZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXVUHTXLULQJDQHZ
)XUWKHUPRUH VLQFH WKH VWUXFWXUDO QDWXUH RI WKH WDLQWHG MXU\         WULDO7KRXJK4XLQWHURKDGSURFHGXUDOO\GHIDXOWHGKLV6L[WK
HUURUZDUUDQWVDSUHVXPSWLRQRISUHMXGLFHWKDWLVH[HPSWIURP                $PHQGPHQWLPSDUWLDOMXU\FODLPWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWGHWHUPLQHG
KDUPOHVVHUURUDQDO\VLVVXIILFLHQWFDXVHDQGSUHMXGLFHH[LVWHG              WKDW KH KDG UHFHLYHG LQHIIHFWLYH DVVLVWDQFH RI FRXQVHO WKDW
IRU WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW WR UHDFK WKH PHULWV RI 4XLQWHURjV            VXIILFLHQW FDXVH DQG SUHMXGLFH IRU WKH GHIDXOW WKHUHIRUH
SURFHGXUDOO\GHIDXOWHG6L[WK$PHQGPHQWFODLP                              H[LVWHGDQGWKDWLWFRXOGUHDFKWKHPHULWVRIKLVFODLP

  '6FRSHRI/LPLWHG:ULW                                                                                  ,,

   %HOODVVHUWVWKDWLIDFRQGLWLRQDOZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXVLV                 $6WDQGDUGRI5HYLHZ
SURSHULWVKRXOGRQO\UHVXOWLQDQHZVHQWHQFLQJKHDULQJDV
RSSRVHGWRWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVPDQGDWHWKDW4XLQWHURUHFHLYH                   :HUHYLHZDGLVWULFWFRXUWjVOHJDOFRQFOXVLRQVLQDKDEHDV
DQHZWULDOWRGHWHUPLQHWKHTXHVWLRQRIKLVJXLOWRULQQRFHQFH             SURFHHGLQJGHQRYRDQGLWVIDFWXDOILQGLQJVIRUFOHDUHUURU
%HOOEDVHVKLVDVVHUWLRQRQKLVLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIWKHGLVWULFW               /XFDVY2j'HD)GWK&LU%HFDXVH
FRXUWjVRSLQLRQZKRVHGLVFXVVLRQRISUHMXGLFH%HOORSLQHV                 4XLQWHUR ILOHG KLV KDEHDV SHWLWLRQ RQ sXO\   WKH
FRQFHUQVRQO\WKHVHQWHQFHLPSRVHGRQ4XLQWHURE\WKHMXU\                  VWDQGDUGVVHWIRUWKLQWKH$QWLWHUURULVPDQG(IIHFWLYH'HDWK
                                                                             3HQDOW\ $FW RI  JRYHUQ UHYLHZ RI WKH VWDWH FRXUWjV
                                                                             GHFLVLRQ6HH/LQGKY0XUSK\86
        4XLQWHURY%HOO                                 1R        1R                                    4XLQWHURY%HOO            

+DUSVWHU Y 2KLR  )G   WK &LU   $V            SUHMXGLFH6RDUHYDULRXVNLQGVRIVWDWHLQWHUIHUHQFHZLWK
DPHQGHG86&GSURYLGHV                                        FRXQVHOjVDVVLVWDQFH3UHMXGLFHLQWKHVHFLUFXPVWDQFHVLV
                                                                               VROLNHO\WKDWFDVHE\FDVHLQTXLU\LQWRSUHMXGLFHLVQRW
    G$QDSSOLFDWLRQIRUDZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXVRQEHKDOI                   ZRUWKWKHFRVW0RUHRYHUVXFKFLUFXPVWDQFHVLQYROYH
    RIDSHUVRQLQFXVWRG\SXUVXDQWWRWKHMXGJPHQWRID6WDWH                 LPSDLUPHQWVRIWKH6L[WK$PHQGPHQWULJKWWKDWDUHHDV\
    FRXUWVKDOOQRWEHJUDQWHGZLWKUHVSHFWWRDQ\FODLPWKDW                  WR LGHQWLI\ DQG IRU WKDW UHDVRQ DQG EHFDXVH WKH
    ZDVDGMXGLFDWHGRQWKHPHULWVLQ6WDWHFRXUWXQOHVVWKH                    SURVHFXWLRQ LV GLUHFWO\ UHVSRQVLEOH HDV\ IRU WKH
    DGMXGLFDWLRQRIWKHFODLP                                               JRYHUQPHQWWRSUHYHQW
       UHVXOWHG LQ D GHFLVLRQ WKDW ZDV FRQWUDU\ WR RU           6WULFNODQG86DWFLWDWLRQVRPLWWHG&URQLFWKH
      LQYROYHG DQ XQUHDVRQDEOH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI FOHDUO\                  FRPSDQLRQFDVHWR6WULFNODQGDOVRGLVFXVVHVFRQWH[WVZKHUH
      HVWDEOLVKHG )HGHUDO ODZ DV GHWHUPLQHG E\ WKH                    SUHMXGLFHLVWREHSUHVXPHG
      6XSUHPH&RXUWRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVRU
                                                                               >W@KHUH DUH    FLUFXPVWDQFHV WKDW DUH VR OLNHO\ WR
       UHVXOWHG LQ D GHFLVLRQ WKDW ZDV EDVHG XSRQ DQ               SUHMXGLFH WKH DFFXVHG WKDW WKH FRVW RI OLWLJDWLQJ WKHLU
      XQUHDVRQDEOHGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIWKHIDFWVLQOLJKWRI                      HIIHFW LQ D SDUWLFXODU FDVH LV XQMXVWLILHG    >,Q WKHVH
      WKHHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHGLQWKH6WDWHFRXUWSURFHHGLQJ                    FLUFXPVWDQFHV@ WKH OLNHOLKRRG WKDW DQ\ ODZ\HU HYHQ D
                                                                               IXOO\FRPSHWHQWRQHFRXOGSURYLGHHIIHFWLYHDVVLVWDQFHLV
86&G                                                           VRVPDOOWKDWDSUHVXPSWLRQRISUHMXGLFHLVDSSURSULDWH
                                                                               ZLWKRXWLQTXLU\LQWRWKHDFWXDOFRQGXFWRIWKHWULDO
  :LWKUHVSHFWWRWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjV ILQGLQJWKDW4XLQWHUR
UHFHLYHGLQHIIHFWLYHDVVLVWDQFHRIWULDOFRXQVHOZHUHYLHZGH               &URQLF86DW  ,Q5LFNPDQY%HOO
QRYR WKH SHUIRUPDQFH DQG SUHMXGLFH SURQJV RI WKH WHVW                )GWK&LUZHDSSOLHGWKH&URQLFH[FHSWLRQ
DQQRXQFHGLQ6WULFNODQGY:DVKLQJWRQ86                     WR H[FXVH D GHDWK URZ SHWLWLRQHUjV QHHG WR VKRZ DFWXDO
6LPVY/LYHVD\)GWK&LU                SUHMXGLFHZKHUHKLVFRXQVHORSHQO\GLVSOD\HGFRQWHPSWIRU
FLWLQJ6WULFNODQG86DW                                        KLP HIIHFWLYHO\ SURYLGLQJ WKH SHWLWLRQHU mQRW ZLWK GHIHQVH
                                                                             FRXQVHO EXW ZLWK D VHFRQG SURVHFXWRUl  ,G DW   ,Q
    %6L[WK$PHQGPHQW9LRODWLRQ                                           GHFLGLQJ ZKHWKHU &URQLF DSSOLHG ZH QRWHG WKDW WKH
                                                                             IXQGDPHQWDOTXHVWLRQmLVZKHWKHUWKHWULDOµSURFHVV>KDVORVW@
   &ULPLQDOGHIHQGDQWVKDYHD6L[WK$PHQGPHQWULJKWWREH                    LWVFKDUDFWHUDVDFRQIURQWDWLRQEHWZHHQDGYHUVDULHVjLIVR
WULHGE\LPSDUWLDODQGXQELDVHGMXURUV8QLWHG6WDWHVY)URVW             WKHQµWKHFRQVWLWXWLRQDOJXDUDQWHHLVYLRODWHGj$QGWKHQLWLV
)GWK&LUFLWLQJ5RVVY2NODKRPD                  QRWQHFHVVDU\WRGHPRQVWUDWHDFWXDOSUHMXGLFHl,GDW
                                                                             TXRWLQJ&URQLF86DW
                                                                               4XLQWHURjVFDVHPHULWVDSUHVXPSWLRQRISUHMXGLFHEHFDXVH
      :H ILUVW DGGUHVV WKH PHULWV RI 4XLQWHURjV FRQVWLWXWLRQDO FODLP HYHQ
WKRXJK WKH WKUHVKROG LVVXH LV ZKHWKHU WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW SURSHUO\ UHDFKHG    WKHSUHVHQFHRIWKHVHYHQMXURUVDQGWULDOFRXQVHOjVGHIDFWR
WKH PHULWV RI WKH FODLP $ GLVFXVVLRQ RI WKH PHULWV LOOXPLQDWHV WKH LVVXH    DFFHSWDQFHRIWKHMXU\FRPSRVLWLRQDPRXQWHGWRDVWUXFWXUDO
RI SUHMXGLFH DQ HOHPHQW WKDW 4XLQWHUR PXVW GHPRQVWUDWH IRU XV WR FRQVLGHU   HUURUZKLFKZHH[HPSWIURPKDUPOHVVHUURUDQDO\VLV7KH
KLV SURFHGXUDOO\ GHIDXOWHG FODLP 6HH 5HHG Y )DUOH\  86  
 UHTXLULQJ WKDW FDXVH IRU DQG SUHMXGLFH UHVXOWLQJ IURP D
                                                                             VDPHMXGJHSURVHFXWRUDQGGHIHQVHDWWRUQH\ZKRSDUWLFLSDWHG
SURFHGXUDOO\ GHIDXOWHG FODLP EH GHPRQVWUDWHG EHIRUH WKH PHULWV RI WKH
                                                                             LQWKHSULRUWULDOGLVFXVVHGWKHHIIHFWRISUHWULDOSXEOLFLW\ZLWK
FODLP PD\ EH DGGUHVVHG                                                     WKHVH MXURUV  +RZHYHU QRQH RI WKHPPRVW LPSRUWDQWO\
      4XLQWHURY%HOO                                 1R     1R                                 4XLQWHURY%HOO       

    WULDOSXEOLFLW\WKHYRLUGLUHVWRSSHGVKRUWRI UHYHDOLQJ          86,QHYDOXDWLQJZKHWKHU4XLQWHURjV
    WKDW VHYHUDO SRWHQWLDO MXURUV KDG VHUYHG RQ WKH MXU\ RI    ULJKWWRDQLPSDUWLDOMXU\ZDVYLRODWHGZHQRWHWKDWWKHSDUWLHV
    3HWLWLRQHUjVFRHVFDSHHVDIHZPRQWKVSULRU*LYHQWKDW            GR QRW FLWH WR QRU FDQ ZH ILQG DQ\ IHGHUDO FDVHV ZKHUH
    3HWLWLRQHUjVFRXQVHOUHSUHVHQWHGWKHFRHVFDSHHVLQWKH             PHPEHUVRIDMXU\VHUYHGLQDSULRUWULDORIDFRFRQVSLUDWRU
    HDUOLHUWULDOKHVKRXOGKDYHEHHQDZDUHRIWKHSRWHQWLDO           +RZHYHUDFDVHIURPWKH7HQWK&LUFXLWLVLQVWUXFWLYH
    WKDWVRPHRIWKHVDPHMXURUVZRXOGEHRQ 3HWLWLRQHUjV
    YRLUGLUHSDQHO                                                      ,Q 8QLWHG 6WDWHV Y *LOOLV  )G   WK &LU
                                                                         WKH &RXUW RI $SSHDOV UHYHUVHG D FRQYLFWLRQ ZKHUH
'LVW &W 2S 'HF   DW   :LWK UHVSHFW WR WKH   PHPEHUV RI WKH MXU\ KDG VDW RQ D YRLU GLUH SDQHO IURP DQ
SUHMXGLFH SURQJ RI 6WULFNODQG WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW SUHVXPHG       HDUOLHU FDVH LQ ZKLFK WKH VDPH GHIHQGDQW ZDV WULHG RQ
SUHMXGLFHKROGLQJWKDW4XLQWHURGLGQRWKDYHWRVKRZDFWXDO            GLIIHUHQW FKDUJHV  ,G DW   7KH 7HQWK &LUFXLW IRXQG D
SUHMXGLFHEDVHGRQDQH[FHSWLRQVHWIRUWKLQ8QLWHG6WDWHVY           VLJQLILFDQWULVNWKDWWKHMXU\ZDVELDVHGGXHWRVRPHRIWKH
&URQLF86VWDWLQJWKDWm>W@KHUHDUH       MXURUVjH[SRVXUHWRYRLUGLUHTXHVWLRQVLQWKHHDUOLHUFDVH,G
FLUFXPVWDQFHVWKDWDUHVROLNHO\WRSUHMXGLFHWKHDFFXVHGWKDW          $FFRUGLQJWRWKHFRXUWm>S@RWHQWLDOMXURUVSUHVHQWDWERWKYRLU
WKH FRVW RI OLWLJDWLQJ WKHLU HIIHFW LQ D SDUWLFXODU FDVH LV   GLUHH[DPLQDWLRQVFRXOGHDVLO\KDYHEHHQLQIOXHQFHGE\WKH
XQMXVWLILHGl                                                        SULRU TXHVWLRQLQJ VXFK WKDW WKH\ ZRXOG QRW EH µZLOOLQJ WR
                                                                        GHFLGH WKH FDVH VROHO\ RQ WKH HYLGHQFH EHIRUHj WKHPl  ,G
  7KHSDUWLHVGRQRWGLVSXWHWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVILQGLQJWKDW          TXRWLQJ 6PLWK Y 3KLOOLSV  86   
4XLQWHUR VDWLVILHV WKH SHUIRUPDQFH SURQJ RI 6WULFNODQG           $OWKRXJK*LOOLVLQYROYHGWZRWULDOVRIWKHVDPHGHIHQGDQWZH
+RZHYHU%HOODVVHUWVWKDWWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWLQLWVHIIRUWWR         EHOLHYHWKDWWKHORJLFRIWKDWGHFLVLRQDSSOLHVZLWKHTXDOIRUFH
UHDFKWKHPHULWVRI4XLQWHURjVSURFHGXUDOO\GHIDXOWHGFODLP            WR 4XLQWHURjV WULDO EHIRUH VHYHQ MXURUV ZKR KDG SUHYLRXVO\
HUURQHRXVO\FRQFOXGHGWKDW4XLQWHURVDWLVILHGWKHSUHMXGLFH             FRQYLFWHGKLVFRHVFDSHHV6HH8QLWHG6WDWHVY0DOLV]HZVNL
SURQJRI6WULFNODQG%HOODUJXHVWKDWWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWVKRXOG         )G   WK &LU  REVHUYLQJ WKDW D
KDYH IROORZHG WKH .HQWXFN\ &RXUW RI $SSHDOV ZKLFK LQ          GHIHQGDQW LV SUHMXGLFHG ZKHUH D FRXUW LQIRUPV D MXU\ WKDW
DIILUPLQJ WKH GHQLDO RI 4XLQWHURjV PRWLRQ WR YDFDWH KLV         LQGLFWHGFRGHIHQGDQWVKDYHSOHDGHGJXLOW\
VHQWHQFHKHOGWKDW4XLQWHURFRXOGQRWVKRZSUHMXGLFHEHFDXVH
KHKDGFRQIHVVHGXQGHURDWKWKDWKHZDVJXLOW\RIHVFDSH                  :H WKXV DJUHH ZLWK WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV FRQFOXVLRQ WKDW
                                                                        4XLQWHURjV6L[WK$PHQGPHQWULJKWWRDQLPSDUWLDOMXU\ZDV
   :KLOHZHDJUHHZLWK%HOOWKDW4XLQWHURjVDGPLVVLRQDWWULDO          YLRODWHG  ,I D MXURUjV PHUH H[SRVXUH WR D SULRU YRLU GLUH
VWURQJO\XQGHUPLQHVDILQGLQJRIDFWXDOSUHMXGLFHZHEHOLHYH           SUHMXGLFHVDGHIHQGDQWWKHQWKHFLUFXPVWDQFHVRI4XLQWHURjV
WKHPRUHDSSURSULDWHLQTXLU\LQWKLVFDVHLVZKHWKHUWKHMXU\           WULDOFHUWDLQO\YLRODWHWKH6L[WK$PHQGPHQWVLQFHVHYHQRIWKH
FRPSRVLWLRQ DQG WKH ODFN RI DQ\ REMHFWLRQ WKHUHWR E\            MXURUVZKRFRQYLFWHGKLPKDGVHUYHGRQDMXU\WZRPRQWKV
4XLQWHURjV WULDO FRXQVHO FRQVWLWXWHG DQ HUURU IURP ZKLFK         HDUOLHUDQGKDGGHWHUPLQHGEH\RQGDUHDVRQDEOHGRXEWWKDWKLV
SUHMXGLFHVKRXOGEHSUHVXPHG                                           FRHVFDSHHVZHUHJXLOW\RIWKHVDPHRIIHQVH
  7KH6WULFNODQG&RXUWDFNQRZOHGJHGWKHQHHGWRSUHVXPH                   %HOODUJXHVWKDWWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWDSSOLHGFDVHODZWKDWSRVW
SUHMXGLFHLQFHUWDLQVLWXDWLRQV                                        GDWHV4XLQWHURjVFRQYLFWLRQDQGWKXVLQDSSURSULDWHO\DSSOLHG
                                                                        FRQVWLWXWLRQDOSULQFLSOHVRIODZWKDWGLGQRWH[LVWZKHQWKH
    ,Q FHUWDLQ 6L[WK $PHQGPHQW FRQWH[WV SUHMXGLFH LV             FRQYLFWLRQEHFDPHILQDO6HH7HDJXHY/DQH86
    SUHVXPHG$FWXDORUFRQVWUXFWLYHGHQLDORIWKHDVVLVWDQFH          m>1@HZFRQVWLWXWLRQDOUXOHVRIFULPLQDOSURFHGXUH
    RI FRXQVHO DOWRJHWKHU LV OHJDOO\ SUHVXPHG WR UHVXOW LQ
     4XLQWHURY%HOO                                1R       1R                                    4XLQWHURY%HOO          

ZLOOQRWEHDSSOLFDEOHWRWKRVHFDVHVZKLFKKDYHEHFRPHILQDO             &3URFHGXUDO'HIDXOW
EHIRUH WKH QHZ UXOHV DUH DQQRXQFHGl  +RZHYHU WKH
SULQFLSOHRISUHVXPLQJSUHMXGLFHLQH[WUHPHFDVHVRIMXU\ELDV            :H QRZ WXUQ WR ZKHWKHU WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW DSSURSULDWHO\
SUHGDWHV4XLQWHURjVFRQYLFWLRQ6HHHJ0F'RQRXJK              UHDFKHGWKHPHULWVRIWKHSURFHGXUDOO\GHIDXOWHGFODLP$
3RZHU (TXLS ,QF Y *UHHQZRRG  86             IHGHUDO FRXUW PD\ QRW UHDFK WKH PHULWV RI D SURFHGXUDOO\
 %ODFNPXQ s FRQFXUULQJ DFNQRZOHGJLQJ WKH               GHIDXOWHG FRQVWLWXWLRQDO FODLP XQOHVV WKH SHWLWLRQHU
SRVVLELOLW\ RI IDFWV IURP ZKLFK mELDV LV WR EH LQIHUUHGl     GHPRQVWUDWHVERWKWKDWWKHUHZDVFDXVHIRUWKHGHIDXOWDQGWKDW
5HPPHUY8QLWHG6WDWHV86QRWLQJ               WKHFRQVWLWXWLRQDOYLRODWLRQSUHMXGLFHGKLP5HHGY)DUOH\
WKDWLQFULPLQDOFDVHVmDQ\SULYDWHFRPPXQLFDWLRQFRQWDFW             86     ,Q UHDFKLQJ WKH PHULWV RI
RU WDPSHULQJ GLUHFWO\ RU LQGLUHFWO\ ZLWK D MXURU DERXW WKH   4XLQWHURjVFRQVWLWXWLRQDOFODLPWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWGHWHUPLQHG
PDWWHU SHQGLQJ EHIRUH WKH MXU\ LV IRU REYLRXV UHDVRQV         WKDW KH KDG HVWDEOLVKHG FDXVH DQG SUHMXGLFH IRU WKH
GHHPHGSUHVXPSWLYHO\SUHMXGLFLDOl0RUHRYHUWKHGLVWULFW             SURFHGXUDOO\GHIDXOWHGFODLPEDVHGRQLQHIIHFWLYHDVVLVWDQFH
FRXUWGLGQRWUHO\RQUHFHQWFDVHVVXFKDV*LOOLVRU)URVWWR         RIWULDOFRXQVHO
DQQRXQFH D QHZ FRQWUROOLQJ UXOH LQVWHDG DV LQ RXU RZQ
DQDO\VLV WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV GLVFXVVLRQ RI WKHVH FDVHV ZDV       &RXQVHOjVSHUIRUPDQFHDWWULDOLVFRQVWLWXWLRQDOO\LQHIIHFWLYH
VLPSO\SDUWRILWVUHDVRQLQJE\DQDORJ\WRGHWHUPLQHWKDWWKH           ZKHQ KLV RU KHU UHSUHVHQWDWLRQ LV ERWK REMHFWLYHO\
IDFWVRIWKLVFDVHZDUUDQWHGDFRQFOXVLRQWKDW4XLQWHURjV6L[WK         XQUHDVRQDEOHDQGSUHMXGLFLDOWRWKHGHIHQGDQW6HH6WULFNODQG
$PHQGPHQW ULJKW WR EH WULHG E\ DQ LPSDUWLDO MXU\ ZDV           Y:DVKLQJWRQ86
YLRODWHG
                                                                          7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWGHWHUPLQHGWKDW4XLQWHURjVFRXQVHOIDLOHG
  )LQDOO\WKHMXURUVjDWWHVWDWLRQRIWKHLULPSDUWLDOLW\GRHVQRW      WKHSHUIRUPDQFHSURQJRI6WULFNODQG
XQGHUWKHFLUFXPVWDQFHVRIWKLVFDVHRYHUFRPHDSUHVXPSWLRQ
RI ELDV  $IWHU EHLQJ TXHVWLRQHG E\ WKH SURVHFXWRU DQG WKH      :KLOHFRXQVHOFRQGXFWHGDWKRURXJKYRLUGLUHUHJDUGLQJ
GHIHQVHDWWRUQH\UHJDUGLQJWKHLUJHQHUDOH[SRVXUHWRWKHFDVH            ZKDWWKHSRWHQWLDOMXURUVNQHZRIWKHFDVHEDVHGRQSUH
HYHU\MXURULQGLFDWHGWKDWKHRUVKHFRXOGUHQGHUDIDLUDQG
LPSDUWLDOYHUGLFW+RZHYHUDOWKRXJKWKHMXGJHSURVHFXWRU
                                                                            
DQGGHIHQVHDWWRUQH\KDGSDUWLFLSDWHGLQWKHWULDORI4XLQWHURjV             7KH SDUWLHV GR QRW GLVSXWH WKDW 4XLQWHURjV FRXQVHO E\ IDLOLQJ WR

FRHVFDSHHVQRQHRIWKHPTXHVWLRQHGWKHVHYHQMXURUVDERXW             REMHFW WR WKH LPSDQHOLQJ RI WKH VHYHQ MXURUV ZKR KDG SUHYLRXVO\ VHUYHG RQ

WKHLULQYROYHPHQWLQWKDWWULDO6XFKDFDWFKDOOFROORTX\ZDV         WKH MXU\ WKDW FRQYLFWHG 4XLQWHURjV FRHVFDSHHV SURFHGXUDOO\ GHIDXOWHG

LQDGHTXDWHWRZLSHDZD\WKHWDLQWRIELDVZKLFKDWWDFKHGWRD           4XLQWHURjV 6L[WK $PHQGPHQW FODLP WKDW KH ZDV GHQLHG DQ LPSDUWLDO MXU\
                                                                        6HH *LOEHUW Y 3DUN    )G   WK &LU 
MXU\ WKDW LQFOXGHG VHYHQ PHPEHUV ZKR KDG SUHYLRXVO\
GHWHUPLQHGEH\RQGDUHDVRQDEOHGRXEWWKDWWKHRWKHUVZKR                    
                                                                              7KHUH DUH WZR SUHMXGLFH LQTXLULHV DW LVVXH LQ WKLV FDVH )LUVW WKHUH
HVFDSHGZHUHJXLOW\8QGHUWKHVHFLUFXPVWDQFHVELDVPXVWEH           LV WKH SUHMXGLFH UHVXOWLQJ IURP WKH WDLQWHG MXU\ ZKLFK 4XLQWHUR PXVW
SUHVXPHG                                                             GHPRQVWUDWH DORQJ ZLWK FDXVH WR UHDFK WKH SURFHGXUDOO\ GHIDXOWHG WDLQWHG
                                                                        MXU\ FODLP    6HFRQG ZLWKLQ WKH mFDXVHl LQTXLU\ IRU UHDFKLQJ WKH
                                                                        SURFHGXUDOO\ GHIDXOWHG WDLQWHG MXU\ FODLP LV DQ LQTXLU\ UHJDUGLQJ WKH
                                                                        SUHMXGLFH UHVXOWLQJ IURP LQHIIHFWLYH DVVLVWDQFH RI FRXQVHO 6LQFH WKH WZR
                                                                        SUHMXGLFH LQTXLULHV DUH VR FORVHO\ OLQNHG LQ WKLV FDVH ZH GLVFXVV WKHP
                                                                        WRJHWKHU 4XLQWHURjV DGPLVVLRQ RI HVFDSH DOVR VXJJHVWV WKDW KDUPOHVV
                                                                        HUURU DQDO\VLV VKRXOG DSSO\ +RZHYHU IRU UHDVRQV GLVFXVVHG LQIUD ZH
                                                                        FRQFOXGH WKDW WKH MXU\ ZDV VR WDLQWHG DV WR FRQVWLWXWH VWUXFWXUDO HUURU
                                                                        6WUXFWXUDO HUURUV DUH RI FRXUVH H[HPSW IURP KDUPOHVV HUURU DQDO\VLV