Court Opinion

ID: 4043825
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:27:54.609968+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:29:45.579878
License: Public Domain

P¢@W\ 5 O\/Wr\e§ 'D »/L)>w/\)m\f\
wm mt Tvc#u L&?>“m

1101 F¢~/\@LM N@~f+k o RECElvED m
/DDN(L 1001 Ll/B< /l wg (l,) , _ OURT OF CR!M|NALAPPEALS
APR 1 0 2015
Ap('jl La /Lol§ AbelAcoSta, Clerk

T`b f Cei/WJF be Cfcm[h¢l DrM)wlg quj`@;,zm_§
19 0 €Tée'>< 1»1’503, amfth §+mD)
Pr\)g+{¢\ F¢/Ms /)(0',~/)({

Qg: E>< QAME cw\M€§ Y;-Oxm»\) N@,\Dv»\'-‘D c.»O’L/Ciow'/M 141

*D¢M cf@¢\¢i _,

€M(O§ed 190-v Q;M@ LSC(WL\£M@ o)@wh;¢) n zw”r@% 0(;3@4
Am.§w¢(.i} k dam wm pb-(u\/o\ro{wl V\/\ mf»(l\ZO-MVV lb %JF|/\ \l@\vc\L¢Prl¢¢,
i)lje‘c\r/w`l OL@((¢,’WM/LS C@vm_]fw ¢w\”l 51 ®1§+¥1]JA'HB~(MV}:PFM;§ Co\/LY '\/)D’VW” lol'(/\(l O,%%l'cl/v\é@ ;v\ `H/L_LL m<<)~)llc;/l

gw;%,,zy

Obw»w\@s `va¥lw
Awl'l;owxl,

NO,D'\~'\>C~O/L'Ol@/Ll,l/Lll/L.,@
l:/>L PAWII? , § lM TH€ Coul?;\/O¢C@uvt…,¢\l,
§

§ l l
wal/G@ l\l §, />lQ/.\fl>l€ JUD@€§ OP-Q/A~l-D Col)lzl/:

cbl\l€§ l\\o\l\/ l\/\~a All~p\l'ww\l {v\ ll\<), allon numbered canal §ll//g@(
camel gl,llcl (eel)ecll`lllll' Pll@§ lll§ lr)|ll>l)lllllj ©ll)}e@lllll/l§ : '

o%J €cw>l\) 10 §Aclc@lz@l)l\®
STMV§ malele mem all l.

Al>pl\"coevll cl)‘Qc/lS lb §Acl<§@)wl® l§CM/S@ llle le,l@_ albe€ \/lc<>'l vv\eml\l>l/l
lll@ lblol llwl cl{)l)ll£oe»v\l l/\)(LS llbtl\@l gl/blllel all 0\, ll\ll`@l aller ldf/long @l\
evad(@ arrest ll le \/Ul lll/l{>ofllull lb llol€, lll.( l/\l lllol/l
Ol§l\@l/\(/l(M/ll l`/\)&~§ CO V\\/lCl§&l fllll§ d§j lee 09 OQ@./l§@ ngOl/l\/{cl](')n '\S /m;[(&p ,DQMQ;[

(>`BJECU@N "T?> ls§l)€ l>l/&ESQ\VFED
w . + »€TATE'§ @QléllMA/L AN§W€Q p\l'l. h l
Al)()llw\l @l@lew_ ll l%l)§l’be/SENTED l@mwee. lwe €lbl@'; a.llew@lle
o.llU/Y\llll@ lb avl§lol llle 'l§§ll§( wlu'oll le “l'll@ &{ll)llkowll al lle§ lllulllllle
Tllllp@bls Wfov»gll cllllfvv\@@l llle lllllol aglee.l@@lovll aoll:\/l'lll§vl
Wl\€l/\ ll dignle @. §lllej@lll las/lony cellvlclll)l>-r”

\QF’:'S

©BJ€§W>N Tz> R€§l>owe‘€ I.
eli/wee @Ql@ll\w\/L /lllew@lz @l'z.

A~'ppll'¢cz,nl cl>jé(/ls lb RESPONSE :. l lo€coul% lll@, appll@wl lwe Vl€\/~§f
. @lblll}vleel lvl all/ll 09 llle. p€lof la applllallbm$ llll)ll "lll;_\'lllwol Ceurl_ 010
AW)@/l,l; erOl/l@lll A)Ql€llflv\@ll \/lle lllllcl Ol@jlee 100/lewy cel/\\/lc/llov) wllevl ll
»&l€fmbl ll §llll@ ill l@ll)vll cen\/lolll>v)(“
Appll"cwlll aléo elléol@ loew/wee llle¢ Sllle rl/l@llll}llllll lim/l llll@ pl[llllll'lllll .
le lullcll@ lllll)rvl/lllll)l) Mol lee»llee llbl ll@ rolled ill ll'le low/lowe wlll
alll>llbcllll)lle,E/Applwl cle§l/lle§ llll>, lel llloll llle §lllle call/l ml pollll wl
@llll llll/\@ l'lll all olle cl lll@ pall ll bplll&llllbng llle @Wllwl mall/mal
lll@ leel/l@ lllll le kelly pf@§@lll@cl ill lll{e 'T+ll olp()ll§@llo'l>l
/>lpllll£olvll aléo ©l)éole‘ ll) llll>, §lal@ wlle lllo\l lll>/"ll/ll§ll/'llelprel§ llle. cll>wl/\/lQ/lls:1
l\(MY\)@l\j OWLIl §Y§C_’lll\<:o\lll lll€ \lUl>C/'ll\/l€l\ll ®f\l \)l)l/Z/'\{ \llZl/&D[CT @F QWMY_- »H/\@ §MMQ
@lllm blm §ebrll;llce,` Wllloll le lbr ll ll\'ll@l aleg lee l@@l>vll/ coll\/l@llllvll,e'.gb
'T§XI Cool@ Crl'll/ll llocl,lllll WL. §€Nl‘a\lc€ '\/Sl Cowl wl'.¢l'pp@al§ d@¢l§léw ill lll§ cols'@,
All.l)lli@enl lol))'@ol§ Olv\ol poll/llé wl ll\cl?lllle §lal@, le lllcow\e@l l/\lllell))l §oly'§
ll\al "lll@ eplllll>ll males .ll\b mdl llllorvl/wll?>v) ll\ollllmz ol{lplliemlmblll blll,'llllg
'll) llo\'\/»€»j\/bél@ll-SCOVMJ ll llloll ol:lollollvll'@ copl&§ op llle l‘vlpo'éllb)
ll\o`l lll`@ lejvvl@lll olle eell/l@vl@, le lar al l'llllcl all@l@@. cell)vu/l Ovl llll
C@wl@llbllhj §lc/le(ll\.§ C@u-l‘lc'>@ Allp&~l§ ©l>llllz>vl al l'fl/l/l§ al €lvl.\/lc?l'ed, apllch‘/\lllml ll\llcl alejl”@@ lillollll) llel/l<@

1<9?$'_

1`/ we wler 69 jr"wQ i%'w@ P(,;g@y\j@o( 1+[»/1'@ 99[@ wm ?W;Mj¢@| im .J[h'(§ OLW[,(C'ONM
&’T,Tlll$ §§§~lle las llc/vel mo \/ijll'§ljéfi Wl)@ll, §z@ Allp!imll@ il/\@ll\lv@ml) ll‘f?'§[.@'q‘l;$
Bll.ll?l)l), \?(l S-lUF)d JZ§§, we ”lw€ §'l<>l“°f@ was §l@ql@;l`@l) ill Hé R€§P@Ns€ "L,
A(,P\l"@lljl Olojéje '{7> “"Fl>( le@ %m@o'lllj lwéoll§,+w'ls @p~p[lc¢lj'?£lll §'wvlllll be/ _
ow:§ll/llé’§@l¥ pml§walef+l Arh'ofl/ 'l(.GT,,§ecll‘(a)"'lll@¢lwlge jbl/ll §Wla'e faa/slule '\6
pill/veal old @l,llt"olp Mlmow wlnt|ll +we pmc/JL§ 09 irl/lie Cob§@ Ww“l&w Cl\h \0@
llm\/l,ll ll mele All;l) §§NT§NC@ v, awmoll)"lll ‘Blllll?>l)l lz'LQSlll/.,'zd %§: Tlle.
de@w\ylltolv\w §elwbme ls lam ll H\llcl O\)yjllze` lozll)wl clll\ilcl`l'l>v) v. Hl\€/ OPlNlON,
ll) Bllllb>w\l?LlSll)l/!M Z§§/ lowe/w a lile ll él“lljle jail _l@@[l>lll collllcw?>ll§¢\-~ppll'cllld"z
C@nvioh'<)v) wol§ l/\l~fl)nj(\j Mlll/\QJ low lwe Tw\'fy ColllTolC App€llz'¥§lllp)e 0an p)cflw,
Fo/V jle p®re(jolvy) 63\)5@@")`{12>v\§fmi5 wUP[\&/clh'ow 15leij W\W/]L +wé `H/W€Swl)[o)
fillw,'
O'B»€@ml\ "lz€§(>@l\l§;fl`, '
S'"M€'s @'f&célllll\LEMT @b)'@@l§ baca/lwe `a,yl>ll@w?L wm ll<>jf war mi§led +w@' l%ll@ clc
ll llmll@ll] mc@lllle¢} cellllchbv),%ltlw col/lid we do +woj @v\ allied appell)
who/ll lwe §§le pmm/lde ll)l)l,wd nl<>jr' log all/ollia)l/e wlll-L`\$ lAMy ll/l@»lllfd@
w@él §§M@l\l{ ? Twl€/ §W@[é W/{(Slllg@ bn €>< f)ov(jf@ AC@SJM 56
mizl>lllllcl lll, r§j'el/l?l] @Wl ml‘@l@ %§WM l,@,gmww +D
MN\CMWLW? l?qlll/§JL@J fill ‘H)e Wy[lkml>w'§ Me_llllw‘ll‘lllll) adm

";<9 155/v

`@'@lll;cll@ll T?> lz%€l>l~l§§ T.EC,
%ME’S ef&lellll¢l¢ ANSW€Y& @C?F?). _
Allplll@lw?l @LU‘@<-/lts became al lllloll§'l mcgile GowllE/hl§w §l/l¢w ms pr@§elljfej-
lll +l/lis come colonel \qg@l.pe lwe ls§lle§ wm §We c,@llll)w'llls 692 Ap'p\[ca,wjf
pol`ll”l@ owfl M ll0 lw@ §l?ll@\j m¥€llllwl wis +w.‘lld de@l~w
lillin coll.\/ldh.l>v) low maelele olshlll@&jafl} Pdmlll cowl/cj` ll/llllVl@/l j §.l;lH@ lil@ @VLH@ `
ll/M@{ l §§ 'lt-l) C@ll/l,ll)wf¢e l"’l)\/o ADCll/lw@ll`»JL§ f I)W.Jldjlllell/lo»lw@ §@llJl@wca/z¢llnll,@bl
l:@l)mal»l i’{,lo©§ amy ls locQ\/T¥id fw allel{z.é O\OlQlé'l/ l}l\ V@\-ltvl\€ lLlC|`Ll of V&j'@ 321
llllil l"`ll'l$ ll.l>mll@lll lll mnd,»z>@lllll`l>ll ll$llll“@, lzll§.ll)lzd'z§§l`m llll.--Al@lillllll,
"l'wlé 512wa olllcl/llllall+ §§ ww@//e T{/le Wlllll@(ll yl@@€lll@zj coll\/lo'l`Y/)"/) ls pl<>vell.
Tw@ylw/W{ M\l“l +well ,llll'll[ H/l@ C@ler-§e@:Tl/ll;e le lll> gall/lle, App)lc'all`lts lel.lz{
d(jjl‘~ee le/il)lll al)lll/'lohlll/) ll)ll§ o\llrll-H‘/Q{lplz:ll/L]L<{ a/'ppJ{A//l€ C@wvl$@)) 613 may
»\-b g;m)p/J) (lv, giglng blvd/tt Cin/lbol‘ll;\'l 011'>@§ lych Cc>thF€lf\)`-c/l(l§c?lghol/) @v\ "Fh&jzm[
%y§@@~d

;lll,;) legally ll@ lllléll@lll m §l,lll@l@ ll fm +llzl@l dljll@,

loyl>llll /~Hlll$ `l§ l\lwll wll}l{l@&llf le ell-filled l?) Ml'@f@ll Jr\}l{§ §@)€,[gg/K@,

 

 

L`l@l¢;%'

©BJEC jLz-->N TL> P/UW`€}Z
zm*e‘§ @m@m/)¢ /W§w§rz @)H+,

APPI¢UML abrahaij 429 §+O\ZL@‘iS Vm»y@f ~}”p +M@ Q,>F vo{d¢ne§z ok/>@§ n(>'jr_r@s[>ej,
l\'¢>pl.cc;wn? énlvj §@€/{c§ W(NT H/L@ (aW reC`\/MWS Om' +|'/1@,
Fe[ckp r`e¢jwkw[ 64 +l}\'l_§ Cbé@ bpa Wm\@{v) 0\ alfred
W@J‘ _

A-pphwu+ recomva “fM/F+M€ C@W\L'@¢CM'MW) A~pp@lé grwa JH/\e fdc/610
fejmes%¢) '{\/\ ~Wl{é pi/MQ/J. Lf\»O*I &Ppllfwhbw, 646 M@.m¢GPL&i/U_ mJF/l¢

QeepedBQ/JM §m\z) v\/“\L&ec,)
U/\o\ (\eé 'BVW\+I) v)/ .A{)@)\QM

D(LW=QJ\.. l/U/\hit/|D(j¥-\ \u[:z/\ .»l )
`7;[01 FM ’S[M No…/) ~
lowo».(>or)¢,(/\Q;US ~'l lang

CEYZ/Tl F( c/W; e)¢f €H?;v\c§

': C/[`/w» v'\/es \'S@L¢\V's'c>“‘.(,‘e..r+i@\j oL\/\o( S`w~éa( wmle p‘@vw/HF/v] op p'\/vngj
Mmf 0\ wjr-rm wm S~(/l+lw APO:,\@/WT’§ eeaz:cmm% /)2> mnmzfs
02(&1)\#\1 A ®1;¥¢{}/'TMMV)Q4 ,'\"FMZ.§ me%
p.@;%<>'>< i/MB(;>N;%R@ \T>< masz w ~Wls LNM$D@/ @~{>»Aq»f.»( (2,@1§,

)

C@pv)’¥b i'\/MML»QHM {'D'\s‘m`¢+ Cle((<, fowqu DDWm.w¢ ,SM¢@QT@)<% ().o § ?>¢> ><
tm 003[ />mg+iiv» items 137 m