Court Opinion

ID: 2758688
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2014-12-09 18:05:40.414906+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T11:26:10.328207
License: Public Domain

;- awn 

   
   

‘  STwmmm

 

Phillip  , '  ' mglasa am: Jamifm

       
  

ﬁwgiaé Budéy Wﬁbﬁ and

SW? E9 wgﬁﬁm

  

 

‘  W  Fatwa {if 

" Emir l ‘ wﬁéﬁ‘ﬁi’gbk #W} in 
 #3?) iii 19336; am ﬁx: Emma
‘ #15 ﬁg ngm mad. a   ' ‘

       
 
 
 
 

a;

 

 

   

  
  

a mat wag than kﬁﬁWﬂ
- ’ Tram  QM
r  mi mm aimseg

 2i? ‘fzmgg ﬁrm amid

     
   
    

 

 

 

  
  

 7 #459 gﬁmg in a
   Wham 
m .  °’ ‘ M

  
 
    
  
 

     
      
    
  
   
 
 
  
 
 
  
 
 
 
 
  
 
 
 
   
  
  
 
 
  

ﬁg; ﬂaw am
in 1 g;

   

my  @mﬂﬁnmusﬁy
; 
V  ’Wﬁhbﬁl
' was 1m
‘. : Emmi ﬂf'Wghﬁ
I \ .1 2mm
   [ﬂag magi} far

and   .
@mvm? Mammy
 ngh meﬂm Wm};

   

 

.7 ‘1   ma: mgam mg
9
'ngb #1 in 1%??? 
 " whﬁmhse and, his
ﬂ? that ii; amwmﬁy in, a
in it: cams
aim; _  gem; rapiéad; “Tim? 
    that a  bug

 

 

  

githgi @mi mfﬁhig @pi‘miﬁ‘ t m
r ts QM Nmmﬂg  Emil;

 

mug—ELAmMmz—MW _'.A-.11x M.AKWW\‘WMW“£$§%..M 7

 

 

 

 

 

 

22K; ans. 7, _ . :
k‘wi’w-Agu. Mu»: ('1‘,- . , Tgrpﬁ v \; ’

<

    
    
  
 
   

 

    
 
 

 

‘ ,, u ‘ _ a m ﬂaw   ‘
mmmmf a,”  -- r ' z
Egymﬁgisé «mm; Mk6 iii  '
mag whim  " 

1%:  at“; abﬁmmg Emﬁamm m
@6395 4% Ham Ct App» mam 
" jg  gwwggﬁ 553653  {in Amy

 

  

   
 
 

 

' as a whim
V : 'pgamantgw

  
   
    

 

 9&3 36W 
awning a ‘7 ' I . ’
13m  " '  at: 
aﬂwﬁammmy mdeme'Wghkg mustghm
   m an ﬁﬁﬁmﬁﬂﬁ may
' _ ‘.   i: .WEQIIaQTZZTﬁﬁaEQAaEE-a
 sup 9f  
t;  . fig  359 Smﬁh gmﬁﬁ GK”
_ k   261.1%WL 5mm 3: 
 W; ‘~?i;§§ at; % ﬁTﬁmﬁ Ct“ Awe
‘* 1    fﬁhaswwmhy
ﬁf  mm; big
7 ,  gm
ig [£39m Wm mt

  
     

’ ﬂag? Wm

 

           

        
    
   
 

  

  
      
     
   
  
 
     
  
    
    
  

    
       

     

   

  mt ﬁmﬁ‘ w 532%»: m @351  ﬁg;

'  ,   Althmgh Wﬁfﬂfﬁb @1’
' ngk than:  
@gi that mem  is
. Wg‘bb #2; “Webb  gm
ﬁiﬁ mm?  mi? way

   
Wm: @35va Whmﬂﬁ ﬁfﬁﬁ‘ﬁﬁﬁ  ﬁf
 whiia W'ng t9 dam
 ' 2 ma: thaw i3 m magi

   
 
 
 

    

 

 

 

 

 

    
   
  

  
 
  
   
  
         
 
       
 
       
   

 magi;  may
2mg WED éﬁﬁﬁﬁi}? a:

 i," _‘        
g ﬁlm gram! mad “Mime: i1};
_ m aim  

' i ii : 
‘7 : ﬁle Wag

   

   
 

  
315%“ ‘ wilt M Kim: ‘Bmgiaggggv
, w  7  
mm mar Wﬁﬁhg mum

 

    

 m @‘M@ mg

g mﬁ

‘ m: 11mm may at? , 1 ‘53s”

kgir mﬁifﬁfﬁgﬁg m 653% mi:

 ,_ Emsgﬁg mag  @mse- 

 ﬁmgmi @f‘ 7. . gﬁﬁ ﬁrm Wghhs
ﬁﬁg

     

 
 
 

  

  
 

  
 
  

 _*uti¢;m in waxing m
mtg}: aim m ma? mval mad
mimfﬁmarmn Gm 

 
      

    
   .
am 3 mg]? ‘   

   

     
 
 
 
 
 

 

  
      
     

. w 
, g  r grim :3 mg times: whm
 mat. mat: lama ~' . .. ‘
'mvﬂamimﬂg $313: if mg;
mgﬁi m?  wmm
" mi in, 91:31:43 Way it wags

 

 

 
 

 

 

 

 

 

   
 
 
  
   

‘ m?de ma Wﬁbbﬁ fm

m: Bmglagﬁs gig mt mm ‘
'    award ﬁfﬁiﬁﬁﬂ

the diminuﬁm   mm?
m Em Wah   .

 

 

 

    
   

     

hue
¢

 may“: .

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

  
 
  
  
   

' I ’ mg in mammmﬁng and m aim? mg 

,  Wﬁizab  that
  up  31$ @awﬁ

the maﬁa ‘Whﬁﬂ 32ml
* ‘ ﬂag Mama is; am:

am And they
 mmgi mng
am has :3 

rb

      

22%; ‘ ,   . , ,5 H 

 

@kgy. wag  a magi

  
 
 
  

A:  ﬁll 333 a  ﬂ;   '

1g: wag a 
" ‘ " gm:

 

 

 

  
 
   
       
    
 
 

ﬂag jﬁlﬂmg girl?
, kw maid; g6 1:»,an

 

s: m Maﬁa
  3%; WM?

   

   

  ,  . 
#E‘fmd  £3 _' V
 m‘trang " ma:

.le

 

~  a map at“ Emim
 ma mfgmd m 33%

  gﬁiia mad 
m mung)? mwﬁuﬁim
 “ Had almg
 by plmiiffg Wabb

 

 @xpmmi that may

    

:3 4E
'ﬂE

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

      
     

lmdgmgmwh , 1:1 mat  Wﬁbfb mum mmﬁ a

  

 

  
 
  
  
 
 
    

mm? ma
Emﬁﬂwmm
53%me
@me gm“; .,

3mm   aim“
" 91m if ma

   

, . mgr Wm? Wﬁﬂlﬁ
id 6 5 é 6} ‘

 

a 11%  ﬂag gm- rib? his
 ,.  fwd ti? ﬂmﬁw may

,   ’
f m at:  ,.gimga-

3am '

 
   

 

   
 
     
  
 
  
 
  
 
 
   
   
  
 

<

 

 

«  ﬂaw
m 'thgir

   
   
 

‘ @%%g 13%;:
{3'  @ff ﬂf‘thﬁ
ii {a   53am
tha that

it:

 

 £2 ., , 3f .95 Mm ﬁﬂmgiaﬁé
 Wifﬁ w mg mg grgml mm 

 ‘  aﬁvﬁmymﬁhg
.. m  Wahbgz  My.

533 me an ﬂag  331%

Wﬁsﬁ m . K
ﬁmﬁﬁaﬁ ha dim mm; Wﬂﬁt _
   
mimic} whmiki a; V  , s'
Sagas twig ﬂag 

 

 

 

   

‘3‘.

 

     

   
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
   

Wm mgr than the

 

Wﬁéﬁ. Em Wﬁﬁbﬁg Imk and: pﬁaﬁaﬁ a

 m dam-W ting  w makg it
whma it; mmwﬁﬂ hi5 ymwmg jgimimg;
aﬁmﬁﬁi  mad 3% am;  a

 

V mﬁﬁn mat the? yams/E; mad.
mt m 11.52%: mg glam: mad
imgimgﬁm beg;- ‘ f’ ' the

“ '  : iﬂjimmim
 mags? m 

    
  
   
   

 

 

   
  
  
     
 
 
 
  

 .'  . ahﬁﬁawsmﬁ
' ‘   wm’hiwghigla ngsb
” » gimamapﬁaﬂﬁ mat hﬁ‘WﬁS mmbm

H  r. _ , 11% mm; maﬁa

 8mm that  mmk mg:
 iﬂm 

immﬁﬁmﬂyp m
aha ﬁlm madmdﬁﬁﬁi "

iaﬂiﬁéﬁ his
*  m °‘

    

; ‘ itmmg ._   4
mkamtm ‘ ‘

 

 

 fmiasia iii:  2m
 a? “ that Em .  
 maﬁa $3 amguﬁ at” 
‘ ,_.   @f glam: 
  Eighb gmvidgﬁ

 

     

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
  
  
  

‘93 I? $1,:

'5;

 

    

ﬁg 
. 7 , @iﬁi 
» i8 E55? a Wbiiw

, g,

 

 .‘ a ,   1% Ear Mapumia
@ﬁta a??? ma.  land;
 a; grimg maﬁ far

 

 
  

" a  mm}?
ﬁmirgpmdaeagmm
mama thaﬁgm

a,“

“ ‘iﬁ'makmhgm 
 ' ﬁg '

W

   

     
     

  

’  Wabbmai
mg  WC:
'" 5} 
far  mg},
 'ﬂfﬂng%

 
 
 

   

 
 

£9

9’

‘  and pﬂmt mag: gimp.  mm

 
   
  
  
 

 

     

‘sasu

 

9, MW H   m  said,
 ._ ‘aﬁiﬁW  m  ma

    

 Es '  ‘ 5 j ‘7'    m'ihgimwnpmmmi

   

 
 
   
   
 
 
     

" . :é‘awwﬁaﬁ ajudgmﬁm
1  ﬁlm ma magma cf

 lei wﬁmﬁw iﬂgﬁéﬂﬁ 

 

   

       
 
  

, , g I Q
mﬂ 1 ‘ ’ a  m " amt? 
'   mm at ma  a gawk

"  the  mm mm
‘ alga gamma ﬂag; :tﬁiﬁi mum

,,  m mm: m mad fm
 m Whﬂﬁﬁ maﬁa?
 m 121% ﬁfthﬁ mam,

   
    
   

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

 

   
  
  
  
  
  
 
   
   
  
      
  
   
   
     
   
     
  
 

Maimm  4 , 
maﬁﬂmt 

32%  at; W; ‘
     '  

 @f’ft’éﬁm  mama ammﬁmg ma
 mmin
. mammagemm LC?!
,  g Swﬁg‘ my 12%} i 4);; ﬁgiiﬁimfﬁ Em. ﬁg». v;
 2  ﬁfqmﬁim @1an £365 mmg wiﬁh
‘ ‘  Eeigﬁg 2914 WL 443 573’6‘713

    

 

       
       
 
 
 
 
   
 
  
     
 
 
 

 
 

“ " g mat mas 
a Hﬁwavm {my
 if a @uﬁl‘ia
   

. g 1159 3 (Qitﬁﬁm  ggitgﬁ mm
P  7' 1%‘71‘ﬁggeg ﬁﬂﬁfﬁﬁfﬁ v.
' ' ﬂfpﬁhliﬁ aﬁﬁsﬁalg in
has hm, um by 
,  , ,_ . abighway' ﬁg

   Wham ﬁrst ‘th'ing
  ﬂwwgm ﬁﬂmt mpﬂaiﬁgﬁg

$335, 412%,   ‘
ﬁg?» 

  
 

  
  
  
 
 

    

»  gum:
 g  by 32mm m
w mm: mm fig; 

1

 

5" ,, ‘
521A ,.

  
 

' , W by WEEK:
WWW 313% 113%;

  

In mg ame mf ﬂaridganm m

   
  
 

  
 ﬁg Wiigiﬂy magma ﬁg

   
   

5mg, a: g;

WEEKS  " r    I  

1% mg gavgl maﬁ vaﬁmgiy as 
" 5’9 am an ﬁmmmed wail? m
t   Wm mmdigw‘m 

 
     

  

 

 

 

 

 

     

 
  

r :7 '  gatam
  ﬁm mad.
‘ ' 5 ‘ ‘ a]; mad m pink.
 mde m w:

 
  
 
  
      
 
   
 
    
 
   
 
   

Ky  mama  
 ﬂ '  ad m magh

  
 

 ..
 :15? S
 33, 2&3ij

   
  

mam

 Em

 mm m @Vidﬁﬂﬁﬁ  mt

' ‘ $1 mad  mm a pubiia

«Em-mx am mi in awsiiim
Ybﬁitym

 

_‘  . 
 @«f  
g  haiieeved