Court Opinion

ID: 4040117
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:25:50.753386+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:04:19.618998
License: Public Domain

"   ~,]   '
                                                                            3~)b-i3- 37
               fler&Lflb_eiJt-ca~Chk                                              Q2_~t2,QLS'__
                   Qt:)_j_/:<o~/5-tA_U)_e.:_~ S8]_::_JJ_y~m                              o,      -tMd~
                      .,-/ ,r t__
               l-It La_~a-      w_.o_Lof   _ t-or:a_c.t,_r i,_a.£J; _eeL/_C:ecQ
                                       _ cecf/                                .-t!uB:J O.LlcL-;o-celktteet
                                                                                                       _ .
               ·b::>_ihg_CQL<~ir_f\lc:J £r!c_,-wh a.f~CJ'-f ~r-rR-J.£!!1t£?1 b -fh.e.      Co'-< d- VI.)_Q r q
                     _~'c!J~4a.Q_r./R_..f:f2 £:J~-1:i-p_e.+Li-/irl~ £or a Wee c.?-of Ced-loror/e-
               Biea.r{!_ fr nd-etJC/aJrJd id-t_e      or/9 /t>~Q(~;b!t:;_c/1, fOr Q.__u)£_~C'eL±lar-a.~
              ~ ~'Lt
              r~      . dl    ~- -~~tbati:
                                     a_       .
                                         -'j-0'-A_c__ £   re t-k .S:~~-~     _ . CuJ_
                                                                            aLltL6 !' ~LJa:::d/e
                                                                                       _ _ . L..
               ~hLritte~tr:£.~~()_~
                   mr. £k_ar.lo.,_,_~e._rf?:z_;_t:Y;Q~':!M                     r:'t2t"l aotczl.~
               llf±B.c:b.___g_ooPl~~_Jj,_e__Sf. -e--L/'~ lor/#; ~R~d--b.vai~-
              ~ ~~,_r_~~dt{.-_02JLibocf= £dl~jl(2/Llxlf~rcDL!~ r a_u)['c ¥-::_
              'P£/JQ~_e.as_factJ-C~S~rhM:y~P4~~.fo6fe~~~
               Cof(_o£ :lbc£__tQ~~~4-~~~o_Ul~~ ~.i:-2-kr~
              · r-o¢/a~1!1£ q c.e.d-cJ2~t-e. o lr~ Q~(!l~~-ta?-~rz-.
               O.tL. rrlfl-114
                           •  l...

                  :r::ho-a/L~~~.-llr-x.tl-GJ4L_~~t;;J /£-i                              --t-hd IV!er:ikt-
                                                  -
                                                               t2g~
                                                              ~u_,.·

                                                                      JJCEIVED    IN ·
                                                                         OlfCAfMINA(~
                                         ..
                                                                            FEB 04 2015
                                                                        Abllt--   ...    ~. .1
                                                                                        .. ---nl
                                          .. CAUSE f\.{Q,_                                        ____ .....

                        .. ___ . C.OU.RT.OF. c:J~ff'II.d.IJL-.A.f.~E!JU. Q.P...~A.5". _

~------IN&E~8lLL~~KAR~S~KLU5______________________
-------~W:;.;;;..R...--3~83                                   72[v_(LJ1lo_r/3/f~7-2.. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
                                                          7

-------~--                             r a A' r::l"'l f5 .a i.UR r-r-
                               p FIL-W~-llLJ;:_j_)-A-L(-                oc C .... o-r- ~ o.
                                                                   _, _ _[.__ .t:..~J...LO.f-\.a~-·-----------

---------"a               n:~LHQIM(L~LE_CZ:V_DG E..O..!::_..f£a;D. CQ..U ltT-_,_:- - - - - - - - - - -
,_;.______CQ.Jnt;.~OtU,_8J.L~-cJ-Lcttdes)l)LLki,U;-Rgfa..kcb.ael~adf~-& le 8,,lb_e_qbo~ eo+~
--------"a.ll4.nu.ll1~.Use..aac[ t!:uWJi:.rJ.he....G>_y_~rJ.e..c a W.tr~i:a.£ CecHe,:a.d.~..J:h:q_.f~~S.-
             ,L.. J _ t ~ _ 1 til" - · ' .L __ r rtt "      tlf /                   t' d/ +r, ~---L                  rd"          cJ,
~---~-.s:rza<:tl~:n.-~-~t:tct'I;OL.Lt:Jt-'- _..f:r:o.tn.E.~-l lBJ;.J.. ctf:r:f:!Sf--r'll ..6~/YI.t::t.n_a~Cc?.a~c--LQ•:'l,....<lt.1.=..--

_____r:e.f~cwt£Ls:b.o.w_-.Lrt±o_~~-(tl-ur:.•bl±LLfolLa~~l'-'1{'-"'------------

_ _ _ _ _ _ _-+-~     tf           11""           \.      ~.    r-_J~r
              Lb.t5:..o.2.c.O.r:..aate...L0.Y.c.\-..,.r.:lAS'z;f-U-Ct~               dd
                                                                       ..OJ:).f:l...YJ.            ~  ' ·           "~JL       ~
                                                                                   .f. O ..~....,_!l~t.>'~_r::;q_c~~qe_r:,Q.t!:)_p€(..S:CL.-
                         ~
_ _ _ ___,cJrJ:k _o_Ar-hc.L'1.~Q ~-\l<-B,..~r:_,_f:.Q.:.....----~~~-~~~-,.---~---
                                     !·

-----------------------------lL~~--~~--~-----------------------
- - - - - - - - - - ·"""""-~l!L..r:,m=£Clfi..=~g&l,~E ··- ---··" '"=·-··----- ....'" ____ , ··--·-·-                                   - s

~';.!.ou..r--l:Lo.f::l.Or,-tb.€....ZsT.u.es~ca..ts_d.&.ec.e}i.,_~4.r.~_b.4S.ed.....£~1..,'J.l!W.c¥"1d~;a~~~~"oc.~.fnh./_&tp.ecfa.rll~-h,.d.t~~
_af~!-.aJ..axas.,,j/.e.J.aLt:O.JJJ.dr.nen±al:xLl.lleg.aL~l2.,rt..'([c..:fiaa..l2q_tb,~t_:z:'!}}_)..~-!J~o£&r.t~L9..f-$rce.lafo.~ .War~
_a_cr.esk.cLo..'i'3.S..4£p-ec..f:W.Q.~~"-.t~-t;,Q.t:f)fr.;).~&q,}~~-fjla.:r;.'j,.,~£r;~,~h~kait;~l)~•Jl....~Jqig~W,4S...4~'J¥~bis.,.,r_lgk:f~b=
_l,.a.v.e....a.Q_e;raroJ~~t.lJ-:hLoJ.£-r::~e£._we.re__,_pp_QcCJJ,cj./)..m.e.a-±...b;eJ~ by~dl~.,J.!1Cl7-'s~o£..f!:e~co.urltj­
_a_cL\[_ls/Y.l1-r.:el~r:.J:~tl..J...1ee.r.:,_a_c_c_us.~ ~~o_f.nP..ll-+.&~5-o._o_~s.e.. a.5a ta~.ejQoJ) o.f'_+.b_€..J.t<tte_.._
_(2n.-=fb_~t.c&l~~-of-.'J74c.rl~rQ/J_t_~dc~+.m.e.t.:\~V!.ClS-.£:k-cLclt~J~9-~t:t&-celp.lv.c..~n~tLko.b.dohdc._CJQL_
-~-~_k_CQ~.r:ct-*-'o.al_caro.ro.jj._iq_e+-J-_~a-\{c.t~,rr:z_d!J_t~fa.Llcde.l.lr.'k.S~s--km-Lecr:..[v.er:_atJ1-Ju.n£__
_w./J.lo..C!J.u.f.-f.k.e....e...efed[v~~~aulo.J¥_[J.am.el'j..:_St:t.a:J4q.U,~-Ga.Ler:-,.Jl\e-kb.it.co.r:Q.1k,J.3:1-).tt>±.Cada.1
-fn~acLdf>f-OL~-CI#e>.r-n.e.,_()Q.AQ....Sca.d:h_-&.r: d:he-defe,~~.k-Aio.~he.c,-IJJ!J.S,-fficr-£'M./JA_br-aujltf_o.ver_
 fp_-fh~o,;( o..a..Lp.r::e.s-~_c-2l.o:io.Y-a:-t~Vi~sd:f3.cc&ol!l-~~rJ.~-~L'-t.f;.~er-V,z.ac.e.)i/f!ro.tJA.(.)._~.~'-1-
_&_r: clc tr co ~-f-~~leJ.b::JJl·~ff.1, z::~. ibis:ro.oflo.,+Jiir..L~r:.ere-J-Jo.r=. :.fk.e_Co...v_d-_lb_¢_cd.ec...l:bLO.L~c.c.(d-.~.--_
                                                                  l, .
----------~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~1-~-bt
                    rl -   .    r r{ f-..
                  £Ct·re ret;JL.StTe_ ·T'iKJ   a         r    ,.. -L - - J   ll   r }
                                                   Ct?Ulr'etht::OL t:!STO·Qrltr«J ; ll-
                                                                                        •   r.

                          2,
                                               '\

               · ({.JI4j by ..fl.. e afBtzn+- re{a-f.or Cof"'/M~tfeJSo/11 ~ ~
                                fO                              -     ,.   r:

                                                                    be:focea

          ·o.foc/s of tht)· ..f&.e uaoJie ..Joprov:de +be coud:a CotJy-
rS'   cornp/a/n+aff!da!((+desertked h) /1r-+:.:l,o'£ V,fl_-Cr<~. R,.z;:,_
      •       · u.H·,~ of haheqt   cor.pur pr€!eMed   -h:J--J-'l-u.cc.C:J.~

                         3r
                                                                                                 .•

                                        JJL~·
                          :r:=A!148Il£_{JSCLCJB..AT;C'Qfi_/
          I,-~tl~_c_ixl..ded.Jt[tft1>t-foe!4J-PteS£Liil'j-r1!a:JI:I:er-a:{:aL£:CLB.cowtLCau~_J:Q_:_f_
    IJec_[aces_uodf!Lp.etJal~-of. p.etJ~uf3j-.t:b_'rbllt~f-'o~a!-(jJ~~-~,. ~--
    It1    ~Cech'
          .r.: j _          r ~ ~
               _ _ _o.rat:Lt_S'_                 ~
                                        af_C.o.-"D_
                                 _ _e__CJ.!j                 -~
                             '
    s.y_ced-_o.r-.~b/s .· :2"d-   c/.~_a£ £eJ..ru 9 C.JJ                  .:2-0../5.-
                                                   Res:.pecf$:dJ/_suforz~J:.ed,
                                                  ~L,JJ)~·

                        C..E~.:rxr:;:cefLLf._Q£5-E&.JCC-C£

.         B::;-af#.rp./J~-~-.sfJ-Ila.lcu:e__qJ.,_Q.I£e_j:s
                                                     -lo ced:~~-ihctf a k_q_e_a~d
    /'·Qc.c.eoJ-_fl2Pj_of'...d-:b.L~J-o:_'-1-&-~=t_'floo£a_c. ccWr-/1::. DP-G!d:lococLof-1_
    /4.J.')_JQc:f~-was_pJac.aLtc.J.o_..J:b...42...J~1ands_~_dbe_&i.oWd_(]uY-I~-:la?LAd-
    lfX>./.q!jf-mila~~+o-k_e_m_cUfes:L_f-o-fkl_/c_A_Qe{_ty)_uC!C3j_3_S~            OrY::c.( 'cd-_;;)tf-~
     f!2r'/J_e!j-f-~Of>(lf:~_add1esed_.Jc;_.z,r:x:L.S..,.J3r-cr;c:EL_wa<j-Bc.QWflu)CJt2i ':f¥,_
     7-~-& 0(,.

                                             $