Court Opinion

ID: 4058375
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 09:06:40.753404+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:06:39.621653
License: Public Domain

. - 3 1 - ~ ».--03,0¢¢
?N"C® §§ \(5--\'§~ AO\~S %O' 532 ' t _

‘»@\sw\@§§» m Ah\$- ` ‘

 

 
   

0§ "\>§§§m\§§§ 6\.\:,\§\3,§ .

o¥» §N\§ B'U'%€X L\ §\\Xorm§§l,s §§ch K<~r\~¢_,»§§¢> MWAAQQ@DQ:€_L

w\}\>c\\> -

 

 

Or\ b€.Ce§-&>Qr \\:AO\_$ § `S`_L\J~CX$ OFLUM bl€e.x~r~ber('\ 'A@\'S G~rA,L/'\c~§`\§\\g.§
\`/\n_ C\@rY` Xn X~ $`\€f\`€ \»M\\S ‘\Q) \M_RQ\\LQS CO>~>C\ CS€ CC\<~§\\N\\

…GQ C(\m`\c\n\ A@pe¢`\s {XQCLS.S § bd

<\o<\M!(\@@\\QN\X csc \Q~\X\>cm§ €§f \\\m $%G`w` ét»es (\0*\ K'd»§\>\‘v
c cw` cs.~¢-?\ms W C`~\\€.g A~\`\ur_\$ 5\\=\n»..> \~\m$ \>»§cam§ °\<\Je_ bQ,L<~\\)§@_ :\\~z»\a

 

\,_)e_r< wm C}r\f\\\Q/\c.>el -

~_Q 5\»\~)\$’ \>g \\-\§ QAS€ \.m @183~\® Y\D`\\Q\AK\Q `\\@`
'N>QQ¢;\ Cm\.> c\s \\r\<\\ `1_ E\L *Ar\\, §§ \.»J€\<\\ ~\\§ Q\\Q\\ch§<>_ MC~<\S €’Q\;>\P\X~ \\rw.
$\(\`\25 C\\\e¢\{$§\<)r\§ \..>\v\<_¥\`\s \J-\\§ "3.¢~¢\ \.»3\"\¢\¢_ `M w t)\)€ *\b 5\\§\.» § é:\}. r\/P\ \'\4§\/€ § C)-\LL X\§ <’e_ézv“\\` Q§\~¢\\\'mg»m\$ (`€6\.50/\5' FOY
§¢Qu€§¥\m§ id Q:u'\'\ A<~.§ Q \D
p`c\§\).e. L.) `*\\§ cero¢¢\; X\\Q.\ md §\\e%<\¥\<>c\s \\~c< X~(\Q_
`l~f\€.‘%§~¢>`c&w-§ <\55"'\§\9¢\®§ 09 G§W§>_¢¢\ ¥'bc ¥CQ}_§_`§,~;¢ XC> "\r\§"bc- me §§ ~\\r\§ 55:<.=\§\2`;§ 3
'_>&¢\€ ';@\u~ GQ€<>_( "\5 Cc>§ri\z\r§b\§ ur\>. Cz»‘v\§, oh have \>esm fa:\s§§\ '\;\m\.b‘€-\`<'s¥
-\.§§<"'\\~.G\»' 53»<~\\<=~ ~\`w§\ "\ 30 \r\€\\/Q g '.`>@/§l\<\v A§§§@Qc§\ R,§ \Q<\o`*s\<\nr
C\w(\~_\\\a_ ‘A§§\'N.`{\q§, C>\er\.o_r&s _0`%”9’\€.,@ {~\<\l ;\\\@\».\RCJ) 'bi\;\§‘imr\ \)¢ §§ §§\.S\c¢\c§ ZQ.>\)(\
5\¢_\§@> \`>£\§s C>'s§u¢\};\§ m\ bwca ¥\3~='\\\.3§\_§\§§»§ 6€ w;'\\ goa-im § w-
rv='\ §\)cc€,$s'\\r¢ "\\‘-\s O§fo\~\l § w§;\ec,r?.<=re,é \§\QL\L ~\§~, A\~L 5\<\\‘§ C§§§r\) b~e\)@; \\\A\ ‘1 Qc.zse/\\QA m Q\.\`\Xan<'_§ \0
5\.\§0>¢.$\_ }\\\¢i\‘\<\ QAL\ ""\, \MAS '¢\m\§`er \_\§\}._ C>Q~ \\r\s\ Q\QL§ GQ~Q‘Q(' &.\§_ -\\N'§\'X »€sc\\\_)

_} '_ , _____ m _,.»~¢~ ~`_ .-=-_-*`F§`_'__'_‘

"”M§%® @Q-® " ry~\z#\'§

 

have 5\,_sz>rn R\\Q,QA\\LY\S A¢~§ C;>r\€\\)$\ amf X\\A\ ¢`\§Fg v\s¥ S\)@{)¢LA<>A 3~;\ @CA_\/Q
m~\ C)\-\\’\n\s lX\\\\A>vo\\r\ ><\\A\ mg 5a -\Tm €Ne_ G\M ubmm$, \\\e`i\ Am\ YL_!’¥B

R&\AHM_`A_;_LM§\ \\~g saw ms A<\e> 3m Jw§_\us§\~¢ swan

`\\§\5 ¢-L 63 '\'\M. z? L,\~e;.%l,g;. 6€(’€?~.
m,;¥`\cs: \z>:c\,em \.s \'§s QCL»`\)e ~\\\c\% %\r\ue mm m ?\{e. \>A\'%\Q\r\ d £er 6€ 251 L§mr.'<
\>)3 3€\~; S\-A\Q .`§. §§ 50 §>~_\) m <\4\§ "-\\\” B\') 63\\ m>`_,> 'v{\\\»Rr/\s_@\..;b K€<'\R-'&VQ\\% -S.€Ac\;s§ m\\°¢&\\..‘ \ s\,&@z \\\AA- \\@.; ®

 

 

 

 

M…€s 3 ¢,\£A¢- s(€er °N \..\b\\\) \\*\\m (AC,L€Q‘<°.L'\R §§ `§ e`~<~.\
MQ§A§&J§_LQ$\¢L® \\'\Ls< mae md §\\Qe\“\mc\)' <\\\Q§0€/\
Q\)\ '\{\‘§U

S`X&\QMS b¥® `?<\Q>\§ \`\‘\\\ ~<\\\ 3m laske} €$<' a Q\/\§Q!r\'\\Ac\$ \b

§Q_Lof'>. § §g§'§dmcg~,. 6§»§;_\\0_!§\'3§§£ 3 Q&QXS~
1\\\:` SX(S\IE. Q_\,"A\w\$ `X oraxn\p_>/ r\m 'b(ol>€ `\\\1\. §wa

M… `S.mx\\ <\m/er §\r\§ \”¢.cw§s ~\\\f\\ 5~<\\~

533€$\€>'8 '~\c¢`c~ ®€~€Qr.,\\\-AX \5 ?r"\\.o\l)\)$ A<\l
CA<\ M>`\\ae, arm/eo \}¢\A\`w c\l\\~ md @\Jr>en g A.C/~\.~\> O(o\le. QAL(`~UA\,\\ m n\,w
c\\¢\°\~\s QALYNAS. \\L\\J@~ier \Y;§X fe).~>\:\\@\ w\§. R\)c<\.gn in ¥¢c ‘\~\\\ 5’§~1\\€> \Qc\\l\€w.,
3\0 name R\\ X\~. $\ec\e,\\c\s \m iv \> 5`\@\0\ bro§\)¢< §fe_u)rl(s§ SN)\_;m 1 m<.~\s‘
G£Q£r-e}. \\~_ g \Se¢z.(r \Ar\§ -\\\e\\ ‘I K`Q,Q\)s~<.»_>. \\\J§\ \$ F\ \>\Jféo.n '\\N\\ C(~\<\ \>£ Ww:\»
 WQ;.@A\ _S\JAA@. \,JA\`\€¢‘ 50'\\\\'\ §XR\€€WL
¢c;;e.rm m bank \1, 3§\<\¢. sx@.\g uaw w Q,~¢\MU \\;i\> Q\~A\Q m\\@f \m 1
Slm\e_ \:\c~\\>ea`s (v\)c\ ar \\r\k`§@x@.s Cm\)€\ /‘§ Cr\m’m(\\ ‘Amea\s \r\m'?v;\§& G\r\\k
\Q\r\;\(\b\?; sr §d\§`\~€> §§ X© \,J\'\Qj\\n.c c><` ‘(\E\ \\M= 3 \5€£;(5$@ §L\Q %\}Cr' §§U\_)Q\(A'<§,
' \ ~" z .“~be.c&\)se \\.\LY\~A\?\'¢\@\B$ ~'\~\\~Q\ \o\)r~Aey~ §§ no\ cr\q_T\;(\g\< %@\J
`\.<\ EVC)J<'Q T\r\)l)
`?O(L'\N> w~> LQ\\Q@ \oj C`;> ach ue %\N‘Qad‘gnm§ S>r’¥v\\)HQr La\)\é ‘¢\.1\\ f`;.(,. rgf\ S~.gl §/\
m §`\cs\ \..»c°Q\ beam-sq "§. §\`>, Y\L>\ @05 sess R\r\p;>\ \M\m¢\<,l¢b@ u<\X.`\\ w
<`Lw e»»~\m.¥ `.\\~ X. \\¢\} \\v \l\m\.:\§ap or Cc»\'\%€o\ ac ‘§\\A\ “\\w` CQ)J<'\! 5\\/\3\1\§, (A\\U\»
C‘\\<‘\`>*\ \r\<\ §0<‘§ \o XQ.S >(\§\~ A\ § \f\s.£>.<\m f\¢\§ \@ \\Ls;£g(>\@'\r\ X\\ose Q\JGR¥S

§§ §§ mh g\§¢g_l<\s\ <9& §§ m'\M N\>_ %\\.` S\A\Q> coma\w;\ms~m_€€€\w
‘ ' QQC\\R‘(A€S (§"\§. QKS<"CQ Y\°~$'R

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

1 \\v Qm~ (\_>fo£de§\)\e CA\:$¢ wl & sz-
\i\ L\\¢><\"N\NQ\_ ~\Q\\ ,'\`\\`a s G\(ov<\>. \ 3 Coo\r\\LAM
_ G-(c>u&,"\\feq. n

W\>~> AXX\:<¢\Q»._~, S\f\¢u\§ v\q§&- \'\1\\»'°~ Cmmge \\Q> m>`.> \»`.§\€Q 3Y\\ X€.»' ~Y\€\j C\C;\)Z\'\<\§>v \~\s~,.‘
X\\M "\?> man m 3\:<:¢~\;~<%\,> ;\1»\¢\\ “\_s § Q,WQA\¢. (~`v< N\M SA_~®L '\rw.`\£>§ ms ~\<\\\m
5-€_@\)~:4_ 'm C<)v\\§\ caf\m-\ .,(xo>¢§\,\ §~¢\"\; “\s §L`»YL:.\»§W)€QF C\g\r\$\"\,,\`m 5\'_`5('§ \13

§ *\~~cs¥\%*, w ~Q.\~> m‘~\ m , 0(\\`, §`\M ¥;m\¢ s w`\~x~< -`\m\c \Q\M§ '\ ~J%m:i\<~ ’wuai€\¢\<>\
"S, c\oc`\\- :'\"\¢\4\¢\¥` \,>\~>\\ jr )'\'\ s §{ book '\>' {mz¢)'r§az&b\§ -

C->‘€D\J~<~.§, `Fb\»\r

'(\`\\9. S%@.\~€ L\Am\s ~\N\A\ `S`. mm\\e§ m~) \'A\.J\S§; \o fe Q\>Q;‘-x\ a Y\m~ Xc`\»$\\..
A"\\r\_».c~\\ "\ s N:?v \~\s`.> m'(§>_‘.\)'m¢\\~ T_x\e.@£"zq\'\\)< A$s `1 S\¢\~r\<.»` §§ Cou.¢'\Sc-;\ §"Q\\f €A"\\-`\ r\.<

 

\'n @~`\\». w\"\ Q\z\ei\<\ a fu\`\r\&) am \\ m¥mn \z\\c § mw -`\m\\ \> m\\ A{:\\\m,¢-\ \
"\\\a. \\o<-\ 'Q~>( 4\ m_m \c\c\\ \5 J\\\.v` \AS-\ A¢~.>, €!<\\3 C\\e\c\u \¢, me\%crve eroc_‘
‘€»c va_\j\aw .~.>¢\ (\ . ~ . ` _
m »e‘?\€erx\\;<,\~\ \A>Q». o<\ SXF\UF~\A=\\» ‘€\~.\l Brcn'\c. S-\A¢\émé,s - \r\ 5»\\»~ \) §
LQCW C@`x\ "i\\@ \Qx&s Co~)<“\~ L`)Q (’C`\m\w\\ MQ 0\\~.- \w¢\s gm@;\:

CL>\.>(\$ \mm\le. f\\\\& \:\<\\\\ w\w.r~ §§ ¥\\\\rmm '?\§\\\s \Q §"\\a. 5\)/_\\ ‘A x~¢\b\\\ 00 Q'\‘\c~

 

 

 

m FQNULA\- mg\\\¢\c\¥ \\v.{\<_‘<\c§v\ » ` ' ' " § `:
b § 5».(§%£ c>§; §§9__ Qfo CQQ§~`\ \mo.< ~A<\§. \~s 43 5\»\,~.54@“3¢\\}€ Q\ o`\\\\\.. 5\)'3‘§\.<\~¢\\`\\!\€

 

 

 

 

o% gre§er\,\r\¢\ Q(ror €~n.' Aq‘.>e.¢~\ w<'>_ w X<`\A\ wm s\>\i\wsk \/<\€A‘\r 50 Cour\s¢\ ‘€_-'\`\LB '{\L>X\§\mj

j,`\/e:\ \\\m\_)@o\\ &\\\s ~ ~ ` ./ . be

 

 

`\\\ ` ;"\\\~\\` mm '\R \?> \3 SAm-w~ §`o ré
d \\9\‘&‘¢§~3
gm \`_'\M Aga;\

~ \.~.>\oY\Y\sL. \.n'\x\
\-\ w\\sv\\\@\`i";g'\'?%%‘\