Court Opinion

ID: 4072588
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 03:06:01.995138+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:05:57.558978
License: Public Domain

314 ,Qur'di

`7'5?.0¢¢3\/`4'0¢ C.MVM‘MA[ 44444&34£
UWK
9.0.444014308/

031 9 4:4'0 4 34§>4'44§1/\
444 74443 7 47 14

43€ 56 /)3444
I§¢¢se. Lw:s mddzmadb

F\/lW\/\ LL'?HM` D\`34v\`t:4' 4\32>:3/4 il/l 40¥4 43414\44 tom/1444 :_4€)443
_n\al own/4 44 iQ-M- 441844 \4<‘.\
M)R~Z‘I.Sl‘/I~ol

64944<:
44049@ 4\4/4¢4 441 dwle 040:4)04'0:1/\5 4534.\4@_‘9 4?@34>0443£»_
4§)\' 441 4\1%4 034/44 /\/o memed 44;>1)4/4. ‘

 

443 44344§43@,5” 443 wmw¢b M,M 433/4
4b 441 flaw/4 mg M/\m/»m@/ 1419)417443’. `

'744444/(' ‘131,1. ‘711..\/ 434 1344/ma /L< _41@4)4/7 444434:43414 .

 

 

` 434 ,
n RECE\%§§>ALNAWEALS ' 44 ' g wm
oFCP\ : ' ` - '
CQURT ' ' osa'lhi§ `RAWWWL\WMM\AB
. . 15 2®<“§ _ z `. '[` ` _TDC:§ /4/6 - '
_ DEC 4 DtiM/\A/\$ML 34z4& 334
(aSZS ['A& `MiSM ?r,(.

Ab@a Acosta, ©\SFK _ ' `_\a/»\ 444/444 `4`@ 443 13 l.§l

 

;V. *m aoM G¢LW:ML

nom m mm mm ' '
CUVH' /Uz.wK`S"/' g*q/`OI C`T¢ be W§S)°B'MED
TY,@L _/uA_ n'g~na?~o@lqu Hc\ '

Z;X p&~¢& § Fvcm"n»\LLBLI+/b` D ixjmtl' cnw/j(

 

 

':¢MLL.-- maids J , § of

4¢¢:.~¢%¢'°5¢),@-@@,"3 6 § z 1 fhwacwm mm
IAPPliM/M§ QlQ='_)eJ-)'Am
To 3@1€'3 kell 919/196

 

 

l"Tc> 'Tl/u. HzmovaUe, Kwd_@§e, 0£&1`~_¢1 @.'wv]r f
Com@_§l /UM_\ W IAWHA/A/w|'.~ jose Luu:s ll\*'\A\Amon.’-JM
Ve$z@ec)r\:u\\\'l NQQ \/\is “Dbjeczlm/\ Hjla}el _Pe§fmyei'.“Tl/m |[1-\”\9\\`¢'/<&»01
ml dwewa malum msw>(>m# B\D b\.:§ mizell

checme 'To 313/123 '\;inz}`\v\_u§\°\ W\Qv\\wm@i{
"Z\YAUW\JS va 0103@£:,"'\!\& wis `\¥Q,'V\/\ -

"£lQ/m_g ` ./l/@s.&%\wsh H`_i`aw. loud w QAW\AV\BMMM
oil mmeqw€v\cns `m Jrlm @W|icwl's (’\ea QM M\JL APP\iaax/Jr wi\\
domm§)rm§l<», MH`\A,\ dam/jr QW@A ami abt/wi `\L'> d'é>_££wo.~lq”@v\ b`\1
hs'\iv\_@» h mla 9\1>\9@\/\‘1 'm`a-B Mvv\om`;s\n\m/UJ: mt M MO'\`\GAML§
Com£e@memcm in ~Hw_ Fo\§h>wm_&: ' l
\_/ovmm‘g ihm.c‘_¢a-{). #Y'L 21(@.13 C@)G) ()m-`sde£:(£)\ pvilw jm ’&MQC¥M§;  

 

eb'

 

24 4)4€44 04 54444}4441 m/ 34 945 04 444045 4`_4:44/44»€44(404/¢. 444/444 ham/4 5444144

34444/\04”44544 44&_ 02464544444441@44`44/4444>44¢4 414/444 44 44/4.4. 4424€/4/444&444 45
44454 154 4:4,4‘441@/45 04 414/43 Mm§4e¢4 §4@4€5 0-4_444/424/`44_.4. 21 4’4@44 04 G1u444‘1
54 /4/4545. &5»4444544@444_ 445 444/44 bue/455 0444454.44 4444~:444 4'254444 444
444’_4>54431414;4'44‘4“440_ &de§hsh 4>415`4/4/\ 3444444554145 444 44/4`4'5 05454444"44 mf
\4/45444404/4§4 454 4454444464424444`454\ 4144/444444 44/45444 434/454404€/4'. 444545:

4'4(144>4/45424444@454445 540 clume 54 34414444 4444444_ 44444444/@<4 402.4¢44/@

644>_4`4444344444 pmca44444/4545 c>C/:wv; 444444444444 549 454 44/4554/44445 L¢D4/44444€44/49444
4°5 ;4 4)4¢45?@44 3444014€€4 4`5v 4441404>354 4'_4444/44445. EX 454-44 44)454414>44/

(a\»»m 4444> 4444»4 554 544)444 1514
93 CMLXLQUE€\AMQ ma O4U’v"4`4/&44'4`tm 04' <'l 4)V44/44Q§42, ‘4*4> €,*441<44 41244445 4/\\)4444/\

4)444\'4344’_ 44:44.._>3/
3)£@445€"44/4@¥4€0_9 04 449&(4'44/4£4§ 414 24 4/134(4 imbde 4>4/4 3 444444>4H 041

455 5wa4 054/455 445 44 004~4>444544. m_54544 44445 .;4 44544

444/444 45 445/4 445 44454444 55544444 444444 444./444;4>5 4.44.444_.4>.
434/464@444;0_ 4'4@4/@.4/ 445;15 4’4'294444@4 4`44 opa/m 44_5445/4» 4444/454¥.444449 “4-44444'

4444. 544>4>|4`4/44~444 05444444`.444244 3554444/444€4 '4?544440@4441. 444444444/44454/5\
500|44444445 444444444444/444 45 4`4444444444/\44444\44 434>444:454/4>, 04444 444 4544444/5 45

644424% 444454 4454 wm 444044`€444444 444541244 144444/4 415 (404244444445 4444.<444’4 4`4@41444'

4445.`§ 44444\ .4444444’. 554444444)554 44 54444 444 444 44454444 544

ad 415
c44 4444 aca/ased 45 ev44444@44 444 344444144@_5455454;44/414>_ 04 644444/45444 444/4444/45'>4

Z\L 44444 40545344444/4£4 9444455 54 4544€ 4444444@_4 841 5L.Ad 444 432):..€41444.
' 4). 4(4"44)

P£»'> '

 

._» E_X aware \U§l§m/\»"? QW SU.Q~J “)O\C-Bc. C,w`vv\.iqi’p.l°l¥'])}`Tmi§mlvv\:e/w"
x \0‘1 Gnv\d `lXuNH {)\»nlec)lf$ La"iz,e'v\.$ MAW\X} Q’rb`\jrv\d\fv &c<',md~i‘om
b‘1 H\a §mve.v’v\n/\Qmjr.`\/e/vmv\§ B@nw."l`oxz\. S.w.'o\duae_ em£m&
madle %~l LAL.\$ 0§- TQU.`TLQ `\v\d§dj’W\Q/vgi b_\%i bo`ed Q\/\A
`U)`i lr\§él (\_Am'l' V\Ql/PY had ~:A\A'v‘i$ &§C.§m/\ jrz> Q‘l/\\~QNL\M ~\LLL’A \/.iA.(‘..c",»P; rE_l {)é)vle L‘_MM\¢,
Cc,v. m wm) 511 s.w.;d Q@o_. umw AMD\M¥ w zuA-m}v\,\wr as
twa , flow/jr afl C/w'wv\`\v\&j \a??eal§ \(\&_m&s’m\ @¥ ge)c\~img\
?nb£mv\ am\ ma mww adm/\was¥\e_d» §§ Hmse_ Qwu)_mzw
wm§e°\u@m ,TM._S\A€, \#\Rs B'~\ed jm (’vwe_ (§H/\Wh>¥§e,, Wwa Qm“e.
M~L &? 9\`\0_&\/\:1€ 'vQ\`\aQ am ~uu \/\0\(\“\§\3 0{' put gm>ve/WL Cc,\/M' \v\
PAA"\\A v`. \u" pole/mmi Fov de?avh:l\`o\~§£ (_`sv\seo\mém££ o{»\

adm wm QW,YA wm m miam.w\mz m m M\MW.

1955-3

 

".,LHM 1115 11£ 1113131€1 limdm 150 Fap} 1361 Fv"\vz>\om llc/111

131-1111 Mghle views 1111 aee\l`c@/M} wax 31111\11.111311@11 111 1111
01111151€, 013“1113111\1 & 1161\`.111". 1111111111|‘1 we ewiin wax 191/1111:*1€11
1\11~/ 355 1301)1)1>!1/‘1.."|"1/\1 &PN|M/l/\l Cm/\lwd&‘l'l/\A)LH\LS 13 1101~11/10_
1151 1411\1~111¢ 3\2\1£ eWS. 11111:1111£1111&§ ave 1b1 233le iv\ enmewev\w
1111 emr>’ 06 111\@ 11/\11211\`11-11110. ."°H/w_ aeP\iw/MJL emclai'vm 1115
YQ.\ieC 31\'\111.1)£1 beezm\\*e11 311101;~11/\1.§1'.;1¢ 1>\1`(1 191111>5111;111{9<1 a »
hmal°a“;$fci¥?§lé`hdev\M 31151;)21\/ 10 1411 esm/133 mdnr 1531/1111
111 §11\11& .11>15.*1111_31@9 wm 1111de 31)<110[312 1111 1111 1111
Ce>¥\/\P\‘i will/1 1111 Dle~r)'cl' awle 'D\rzlev,-: 1:0\11:¢1"1111'13 115 3113£1/£1/_
1111 /1/11111111111 1190151 fm see/mw 171/111 1115 1111'51). 1111111:1\
111 3111/231 `IMJBM/)ev\l a/a,e la lLLe 813/leg 111/lwe 1b £¢)11111/"/
1111 1111 011/11 'Mvp§re 1911 011111¢'/@1)1 11251>11;1111‘1 1011/11315

1113/1 ~H)\e /E)r;u few/1 131 CJ/l`m/\imhdeeealj gmi/115 1115 m\€ ap

_90£431111;[“££@31172)/1£1 Me§)lélle£ frle llome 211/111 A\fl 11110;'17)
eM/zf’/'{ LJ)HA 1141 031/111 few/ls Drde/r.
011 ilems /1/11§. 01 l*h)w§h§e), '1%2 llale mere/9 a11£3e£

111de lml owl found Maee//"cwl'r 9111)1111 wdiL/e Mer

v 111111111131 1115 31111111111 111/111 1111 1111 1111 111/111 1113 111111 1111/1111 v
41/1131 911/12 ou1aa>1/M_0. 01 111/115 we would have been di\'lYM/hl, l

- "me 3199111131\1 vaa§om\dH 1115$1).1113. how.ew/r.

119

 

_1:11@@99\1&&“1 1133 di§£l/Lx§ea/ his 211/wle im 1/11`;,.§ 111@1711`1%11`1)1\,
va\ 1119\111111/1§1/11111111/\3 51,1190611»`11191 \/11.§ alPPlid/Mw'w ,;111111 1011/111 191111 111

`Il€/W\ 110 L/§L 010 Hd§é;lex pma/fw 0£1'/1>11111119&1' 1“11.@1‘1"3/1 £01111*1'

Lu&£ well @w&ve of 1115 01313111114 dwa' 1111 1111 wax 131011_6 11/1@1111"1 me
1/@1/11111111@3: 1111 11111 1111111/1 1111 1111 3111/1¢/;1111‘: 311/2111101 911 1111/111111

1b deeille whdh/101 1111 81011Mw1 luAS dmi/11 1Q1?.1111, 111 1115 5131~!; 1111l 1111`111£1,
113 3131/111 11\"11 01 make emleszmv\s.. lll/so ilwu/1 11/11 i/=Z elerm§ ~1'1/1111

1112 8111\(\,£11\101 1113/2 [!11111/11`121~£/11'1 lllsetl am 1111 wuv1»§ 619§@)1/111,1\1)11”,_ ;11101
9mm 1111 imm 1111 301 1111§1.11¢ e/Jum 111111“£11¢1/ 111111 1111 mal/he

£11:151£1¢11/1`1 1111 1111/12 1:61/19” , 7`1/117 1419/lead 11111€£ 111/leal 1111 114leU1/1' 1/11'51/
1111 911 1111/11 1111 111/11111111111 11 111111. 111111111111>3 1111 1111 1111/1111le

wmeele/wc,v
"111 1111.1111111111111111111111111 111111111 111 1131111 111111111

1119_ 13 VQW well 91A1'11'1€11 111 1/911121:. 111/1011_911111:1_~1’1/1131’1)1~£ 1";1`1&@1 113 £1>11\191‘1

L.Ji`ll/\ 111/ul 05111@1'|£@11/11-§“£)10101 l)essigmkma "".L:ssue§" &uV/M/ wf~`Hn 1111
1:1111;111>1113 311&13111113 1"11 `;/lwm A/z>.$ 1115 1115 5h1/mw 511 1301 1412
311111e now §1/1111111 he pvecedud/H loan/ul 211/111 /1§ 31112§11111)11_0 Meled-

Lm/u.l 1/151`111/\
w1/1191111.10,1 11@1115&01>11§1:11/112_111 ~\M 2101911111/111 1111°13 11111:< 1111/10161:10_

CDU.A' 1/1/1&1@3 1111/\(1“/\£1$ i"l/l 1/1“$ 111ro 611/1111 001/10111)1€1€, ‘14/\¢1 `~1'11.1. 3131‘€3

CnnJusrzsm 01 Lm held 1111 11/11>1\/11111111 1b 311 11£@11111131/1;1 Ve.xche ;11/101
1;1\11>1111,1_& 311€6_\&1113113 `l`|/\QveM‘e\f 111111311/111 1111 0111011111/11,19 d@w\ 110911 1b
1111 `111111.1 01111111111111 111 1‘111111\;11111‘:311111111~ 1111111111\111111 131\113111\_

OE>-'S

 

G\QWLM 1111 ~"1&\1>.4312. ap gri/111 |A}Wl\M/\AJL 014\1)€1§$ anLQEE 120_11`€1")
DAM:___/__ /__ ' i?e_s.'>eJ 1111‘13111»_111`1111»11.»

 

:§oze 111 is Pa.miwz W\&$olam.b
_(D(°,`_§ 11!1>.
1301/mmst 1111/171
(DS?>S 1451/wm PA . _
891 1111/1111.1\“>`:\`@1112 “l§l§).

UV\KLM 1/1 Dacl;v/&L\v\ t

 

t‘"`l ,`:1111@11/111 121111`.1/11, 11411,111,111 111111141‘1 1111va 111
ML"IQKM 001’§11111/111111 111 (`_1\1“111/11\111 §1/1£111“1_¢-11415111\'1\/11.>11;11 §\;1111 `;Sa`¢\
111 111/11 1111\\-11@>1 gun/v 114/1111 "Tam~@é¥§;'1Ave. 1111/111111/ 11de
111 11113111‘1 1111/1111 414 111/mama 11 _1`1/1111 1111 MWM"

041£.12_/._3_/__15__- j _ %11111‘1 §1,11:11'1/\` `1‘111211

§&se_Lucs ?aA/MWQL W\ema, 11&111>

`TDL: /111.
Dcw\av\_maz, 111/111
gun \1\1\1\'\1\1“1>_,_1`€%21£ TXJ-§')_

 

1561