Court Opinion

ID: 4066639
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 22:44:09.296892+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:54.349726
License: Public Domain

,       '

                                       1.ll 1t-\E touR...'\                 of              tR-1~11\JI~L f\~~Ef\-L\
                                                h>Q- \.+\ [          STf\.T( of \ E 'i ~ (

            . ~1L.1 oN \l E.n.J\M               \hl 1 Lll A.lv\ <;                  \
                                                                                    ~

                                    fl..rr~t'""' ~'                                 I
                                                                                    \
                                                                                    )
             'L
                                                                                        ~
             Slf\lL o~ IE'I.f\<;f                       d·   CA\                        \
                                   f\ffe \\ee (s\.                                  '   \
                                                                                        \

              coMES ~o\l'l \ {~-e\v.-\.l)rl~rre\\o-f'\-\\ tA_·,\\-o,-, \\, \U~I\~~~~ ~~ \ t~\ej
             -t-~-e C\bu\fe _c,..\-c,J~\'!p~c..\ q,"'J.. <;~c....~es -\-~"~ -\-he c..ui.Af+ 1~\u.p,J
              c\£()i~\ \t./r~~ ~r~t\.e" orJ...e(                                              o"'        ~~\i ~11, \ct£1SL                         'btJ ~:J
              "vt ~r1.~\ sA.~d ~eV\~c.\ -\-'> k\"'~or I 1\f~\~cv..~                                                      Ud\t           l f\v..j\1\c;t o t,,
              J. Dl5      '.Vh~c_h. \.t-Il)~ e7'",~-\.- J... ~f; u.\-\-er SCl~d ~Pc..~S~o 1\ '\}.)0.$ ~c..o\ P ttr\J
             \~ ~ ~~               1\o-\--    lAf\\',   ~ K~~~~            \0   I   ;2. 0      \~   \    50 rn(l   l \.l \        c}_q_   ys         ~ter
                                                                                                                                                   £X.      S£:1   ~~
              ~e.c~~icif'                       ~                  o~ C.olflt-ed>:nAe                        a.-\\etVYr+ +~ ck.Pn1 lto\ot:vr
                                                                                                         1
                                     . . ,"           ',Sao
    I         a.c.C£$.~ 1-o            LUlA/4,. ·       o.."l      f(e'\It.l\-\- \\,           d\       ~(ot?" D\.pfet-t\ '") ~c..~J t(,\lol tiu ')
              t\ec.~s;o,.,             +o       c..     fr';~ \'o-.c..'ie           C-v..Cf'            ~~" ~CA.\IcJ(            o-f 'k\C'l-\--"r 1          5c,.;~
                  &..e.-ciS ;of\       \NtA.S         re..ce\ \!e.~      ~\II ~~p~\\~"'\-  '\ C" \\                 ('     \        r   ll     l
                                                                                  R.e.Sp ec:.."'\-\ v-. ~          .:>u ~tv\ ,T\ e ~
                                                                                            IS [    1\~ ~.         3\JJ....-- ~ 3~q3J~ LooocJ
                                                                                        tv\\\-\-on \le.ro..A \\J-,l~~".w:; ~3 1Vt31S'
                                                                                        (!•"'h E. ~CA.~,\\,\"' Cu rrecho.,c..t\ C.e.."\.et
                                                                                        s--,l\io<K tv\1"er"'\ ~er'"',<; koc,J.
                                                                                         HoJ., C;)t"' 1 o~\           "'~ L\ C{ 31
                                                                                                                    (A •     .

                                                                     \                                       2
      ~~ \--ere_b~ c.eA~~1\ ~u\ c. -\-{u.P o..nA c_orfPc-\--e,\ eopll 6~
 tke .\'Cif~_j~\r.'\' ~o\\~ 0~ ~~~~\ r-i-b ~.p :Iu\'-\ ;)..'\, ~o\<;
 .d.e-t\~CA \ ~ \i~-6~         ~.P" or~fl_f' .,!", -\-he Cl.bo"!f -:,..\-'/ \f c__CA.v.s.P \
                             '\)..\r1

 '-NCJ..<; rno.~\e~   oY\ l\.\A~u.<;+-. \\, d-D\~, po&\-c.JP freplA~cA \ +hrc.uj~
  LL S~ Voc.-\-CA-\ ~er\l;c~ \ ~o -\-~e_ \Je..\o'\t-1 \~s\eJ f"'(\-~es ",

JLau.c_Lol_ c.r; "'.'"'" \ fl.~ ~;..\s
 -foi +he &\-o.\e o~ Te'>l-CA         '
  ~-\to : c\ e( L Lhlle_\ ~cu s.\-a.\
 P. o.      Box      1)..30<(
 _C~~J:IDL SIA\j()\\
 ,~U.ST:r~) Ti           ISil)

                                                                _:f!\~ ~_, ~~ ~ 3q£13J ~ ( U!DC\
                                                                         L~ ~~~(\\)
 cc.:
 iHflT£D SlllrTE5 CpurLT o t='                 11-PPEA:LS         UWTTEO ST~IE) SCiPRtME Cuut:T
_"fo~ THE. riFT~ uuun                                              KITN . cL~ f2.K ( \k\1 LLJ:A'M \L. s uTf~)
                                                                   I \d. S1R.EE1 \\1~
 leJL\2._s . M~'E. srt ~t.:r PLfrc E_ _ __
 11 I-\N o tt. u~: A1\1 s , L ~ "'~ o t 7> o - 3 go g

 uwn·t..O STATtS 'lJ:tS'TR.TC-1 C..O\Nft'T          l'OftLL~~    in \fiTS~ 2)   tJj
-~-_c~~­
\\00       c..o\\J\\"1\tR.CE. Sllt.Ef.l", ~ooW\ ~\~S;)..
 llh.ll f\ s, +- T~         I 5 ::2 ().l _. L{(~ D b

                                                                Mti\\,J ~c:..~<, ~o Po.r.\.her =
                                                                1)\~ 'L ~Vv-- •3~li 3~5 [oD oc)
                                        .2..          ot         1