Court Opinion

ID: 9965288
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2024-05-02 03:10:35.245244+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:24:51.119138
License: Public Domain

May 1, 2024

The Honorable Dee Hobbs
Williamson County Attorney
405 M.L.K. Street, #7
Georgetown, Texas 78626

         Opinion No. KP-0463

         Re: Whether a member of the public may obtain copies of spoiled ballots on the 61st day
         following election day (RQ-0520-KP)

Dear Mr. Hobbs:

        On behalf of the Williamson County Elections Department, you ask “whether physical
copies of spoiled ballots in ballot box 4 can be made available to the public” sixty-one days after
election day. 1 We begin by examining the handling of spoiled ballots at the polling place, the
distribution of spoiled ballots at the close of the election, and the preservation of spoiled ballots
following the election.

         The Election Code dictates the handling of spoiled ballots at the polling place, the
         distribution of spoiled ballots at the close of the election, and the preservation of
         spoiled ballots following the election.

        Election Code section 64.007 is titled “Spoiled Ballot.” TEX. ELEC. CODE § 64.007. It
provides that “[i]f a voter mismarks, damages, or otherwise spoils the ballot in the process of
voting, the voter is entitled to receive a new ballot by returning the spoiled ballot to an election
officer.” 2 Id. § 64.007(a). A spoiled ballot returned by a voter to an election officer is accounted
for on a register maintained by the officer at the polling place. 3 Id. § 64.007(c) (requiring an
election officer to “enter on the register the name of each voter who returns a spoiled ballot and

         Letter from Honorable Dee Hobbs, Williamson Cnty. Att’y, to the Off. of the Att’y Gen., Op. Comm. at 1,
         1

4 (Nov. 3, 2023), https://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/sites/default/files/request-files/request/2023/RQ0520KP
(“Request Letter”).
         A poster with instructions about “securing an additional ballot if the voter’s original ballot is spoiled” must
         2

be posted at each voting station and polling place. TEX. ELEC. CODE § 62.011(a), (c)(4); see TEX. SEC’Y OF STATE,
VOTER INFORMATION POSTER, available at https://www.sos.state.tx.us/elections/forms/pol-sub/7-36f.pdf; see also
TEX. ELEC. CODE § 62.0115(b)(3) (requiring notice of voters’ rights, including information about spoiled ballots).
         The Secretary of State is charged with creating the register form. See TEX. ELEC. CODE § 64.007(c); TEX.
         3

SEC’Y OF STATE, REGISTER OF SPOILED BALLOTS, available at https://www.sos.state.tx.us/elections/forms/pol-sub/7-
93f.pdf.
The Honorable Dee Hobbs- Page 2

the spoiled ballot’s number”). After entering the required information about the spoiled ballot on
the register, the election officer deposits the spoiled ballot in ballot box no. 4. 4 Id. § 64.007(d); see
also id. § 51.033(a), (c)–(e) (requiring four ballot boxes, each for a different purpose, be used at
each polling location in an election).

        The disposition of records and supplies at the close of the election is generally governed
by Election Code chapter 66. Id. §§ 66.001‒.062. Subsection 66.021(a) instructs the presiding
judge, upon completing the election returns for the precinct, to “assemble the precinct election
records and place them in the appropriate envelopes and ballot boxes for distribution.” Id.
§ 66.021(a). The term “precinct election records” is defined to mean “the precinct election returns,
voted ballots, and other records of an election that are assembled and distributed under” chapter
66. Id. § 66.002 (emphasis added). Spoiled ballots are assembled and distributed under chapter 66;
thus, they are precinct election records. Specifically, chapter 66 directs that the spoiled ballots
along with the spoiled ballot register be placed in ballot box no. 4 and delivered by the presiding
judge to the general custodian of election records. Id. §§ 66.021(b) (requiring the judge to lock
ballot box no. 4 when it is ready for distribution), 66.026(2), (3) (providing that “[b]allot box no.
4 must contain” among other things, the register of spoiled ballots and any spoiled ballots),
66.051(b) (requiring the presiding judge to deliver “ballot box no. 4 and its key in person to the
general custodian of election records”); see also id. § 127.067(c) (relating to disposition of precinct
election records in election using electronic voting system instead of paper ballots).

         Once delivered to the custodian, “[t]he records in ballot box no. 4 may be preserved in that
box or by any other method chosen by the custodian.” 5 Id. § 66.058(f). As precinct election
records, spoiled ballots must be preserved by the custodian “for at least 22 months after election
day.” 6 Id. § 66.058(a); see also 13 TEX. ADMIN. CODE § 7.125(a)(10) (2020) (Tex. State Libr. &
Archives Comm’n, Records Retention Schedules) (setting out “Local Schedule EL: Records of
Elections and Voter Registration, 4th Edition” which requires that spoiled ballots be retained
“[e]lection day + 22 months”).

        You suggest that spoiled ballots may be subject to the preservation period in subsection
66.058(b). See Request Letter at 3‒4. Subsection 66.058(b) directs that “[f]or a period of at least
60 days after the date of the election, the voted ballots shall be preserved securely in a locked room
in the locked ballot box in which they are delivered to the general custodian of election records.”
TEX. ELEC. CODE § 66.058(b) (emphasis added); see also id. § 1.012(f)–(h) (addressing the
availability of voted ballots for public inspection). But spoiled ballots are not voted ballots as
exemplified by the fact that spoiled ballots are delivered to the custodian in ballot box no. 4 while
voted ballots are delivered to the custodian in ballot box no. 3. Id. §§ 51.033(d) (providing “[b]allot

         4
           The Secretary of State prescribes the use of an envelope to keep spoiled ballots separate from other ballots
that are returned in ballot box no. 4. See TEX. ELEC. CODE § 51.033(e) (specifying that “[b]allot box no. 4 is used for
delivering defectively printed, spoiled, and unused ballots to their custodian after the election”); TEX. SEC’Y OF STATE,
ENVELOPE FOR SPOILED BALLOTS, available at https://www.sos.state.tx.us/elections/forms/pol-sub/7-77f.pdf.
         5
          If removed from ballot box no. 4, the records “may not be commingled with any other election records kept
by the custodian.” TEX. ELEC. CODE § 66.058(f).
         6
          With some exceptions, the records may be destroyed or otherwise disposed of after the preservation period.
Id. § 1.013.
The Honorable Dee Hobbs- Page 3

box no. 3 is used for delivering the voted ballots to their custodian”), 66.025(a)(1) (providing
“[b]allot box no. 3 must contain . . . the voted ballots”). As a result, subsection 66.058(b) is not
relevant to your question.

       With that background and clarification, we consider whether copies of spoiled ballots
preserved in ballot box no. 4 are available to the public during the 22-month preservation period.

         The Election Code designates spoiled ballots preserved in ballot box no. 4 as public
         information subject to disclosure.

        Section 1.012 of the Election Code generally requires the custodian to make election
records available to the public unless the records are expressly excepted by the Public Information
Act or the Election Code. Id. § 1.012(c) (“Except as otherwise provided by [the Election Code] or
Chapter 552, Government Code [the Public Information Act], all election records are public
information.”); Tex. Att’y Gen. Op. No. KP-0411 (2022) at 3. “Election records” include anything
distributed or received by government under the Election Code or required by law to be kept by
others for information of government under the Election Code, as well as any document or paper
issued or received by government under the Election Code. TEX. ELEC. CODE § 1.012(d). Thus,
spoiled ballots are not only “precinct election records” that must be preserved under subsection
66.058(a) but also “election records” available to the public under Election Code subsection
1.012(c). We must then examine whether spoiled ballots are expressly excepted from disclosure
to the public by the Public Information Act or the Election Code.

        Subchapter C of the Public Information Act establishes the exceptions to the general rule
that public information shall be made available to the public. See TEX. GOV’T CODE §§ 552.101–
.163 (“Information Excepted from Required Disclosure”). No section within that subchapter
expressly addresses spoiled ballots or excepts them from disclosure. 7 See id. Likewise, no
provision in the Election Code designates spoiled ballots as confidential or otherwise prohibits
their disclosure to the public. A court would likely conclude that, by requiring that the public have
access to election records, the Legislature thereby authorizes the election records custodian’s entry
to ballot box no. 4 to respond to a public information request for copies of spoiled ballots. This
entry must be made in accordance with the time and manner requirements prescribed by statute,
the Secretary of State, and the custodian. See, e.g., TEX. ELEC. CODE §§ 1.012(a), (b) (requiring
that an election record that is public information “be made available to the public during the regular
business hours of the record’s custodian” and allowing the custodian to adopt reasonable rules
regarding access to the records), 66.058(h) (authorizing the Secretary of State to instruct elections
administrators on compliance with section 66.058 for elections involving federal office), 66.057(b)
(requiring the general custodian of election records or the custodian’s designee be present at all
times when the records in ballot box no. 4 are inspected).

         7
          For instance, as you note, previous open records letter rulings issued by this office conclude that spoiled and
unused ballots may not be withheld under Government Code section 552.101. See Request Letter at 3 (citing Tex.
Att’y Gen. OR2001-2842); see also Tex. Att’y Gen. OR2009-10257 (concluding unused ballots were not confidential
by law); Tex. Att’y Gen. OR2001-3228 (concluding spoiled and unused ballots were not confidential by law).
The Honorable Dee Hobbs- Page 4

         Any personally identifiable information contained in election records that could tie a
         voter’s identity to their specific voting selections must be redacted for purposes of
         disclosure to protect the constitutional right to a secret ballot in Texas.

        That copies of spoiled ballots preserved in ballot box no. 4 are available to the public during
the 22-month preservation period does not mean some information on an individual ballot may not
be confidential. 8 A recent opinion of this office explained that “the right to a secret ballot has been
held to protect personally identifiable information contained in election records that could tie a
voter’s identity to their specific voting selections.” Tex. Att’y Gen. Op. No. KP-0411 (2022) at 4
(citing Wood v. State ex rel. Lee, 126 S.W.2d 4, 9 (Tex. 1939) and Carroll v. State, 61 S.W.2d
1005, 1008 (Tex. Crim. App. 1933)); see also TEX. CONST. art. VI, § 4. Therefore, a court would
likely find that personally identifiable information contained in an election record, including a
spoiled ballot, that could tie a voter’s identity to their specific voting selections is excepted from
public disclosure. As a result, the election records custodian must redact any such personally
identifiable information to protect the constitutional right to a secret ballot in Texas. See TEX.
GOV’T CODE §§ 552.007 (providing that a governmental body has no discretion to release
information deemed confidential by law), 552.301‒.310 (setting out the procedure for a decision
from the attorney general regarding whether information may be withheld).

         Briefing received by our office suggests that spoiled ballots, either alone or in combination with other
         8

information (e.g., the register of spoiled ballots), “can contain information identifying a voter’s selections . . . .” Brief
from Jennifer Doinoff, Pres., Tex. Assoc. of Elections Administrators at 1 (rec’d Dec. 19, 2023) (on file with the Op.
Comm.).
The Honorable Dee Hobbs- Page 5

                                      S U M M A R Y

                     The Legislature has established procedures aimed at both
              preserving spoiled ballots and granting public access to them.
                      Section 66.058 of the Election Code requires spoiled ballots
              be preserved in ballot box no. 4 or by any other method chosen by
              the election records custodian during a 22-month preservation
              period. Section 1.012 establishes spoiled ballots as public
              information and requires the custodian to make the ballots available
              to the public. By expressly requiring the custodian to provide public
              access to such records, the Legislature authorized entry into ballot
              box no. 4 for such purpose during the 22-month period. Thus,
              members of the public may obtain copies of spoiled ballots
              preserved in ballot box no. 4 during the 22-month preservation
              period.
                      Personally identifiable information contained in election
              records that could tie a voter’s identity to their specific voting
              selections is confidential and excepted from public disclosure. Thus,
              any confidential information on a spoiled ballot must be redacted for
              purposes of disclosure in order to protect the constitutional right to
              a secret ballot.

                                             Very truly yours,

                                             KEN PAXTON
                                             Attorney General of Texas

BRENT WEBSTER
First Assistant Attorney General
LESLEY FRENCH
Chief of Staff
D. FORREST BRUMBAUGH
Deputy Attorney General for Legal Counsel

AUSTIN KINGHORN
Chair, Opinion Committee

CHRISTY DRAKE-ADAMS
Assistant Attorney General, Opinion Committee