Court Opinion

ID: 4056676
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:04:09.448726+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:36.374824
License: Public Domain

53.*43‘4‘0\ )03:°3/'0'"4

RECE|VED IN
couRT oF chMmAL APPEALS

_sz 08 2015

, AbelAco.<-;i ,C .
~n> w CLEM com mg ®ua:rm= C:O.hunvm_ Arwmw a ’S”‘

MSEL .,DMSTA

’\_1.€-: Q€®L'\E;\;T 'FoQ C!>\.)FHZMAT'JD»L) oF b€Lu/E/L\/ m= A-Pru(\,+mwf Fc`:)z wrlli`o»=
Hmms corams..-

Mc \ RQQ&?\C\

Cu'w,§nthgs `> Enc\bsea\ phasedth a (Q.sp¢c:\'p\¢\ cequns+‘ \wc»ulol luke “\.~ i
“Q\'\.Q w\\)\. '\"\9, Cw.(~\' anew C\~u€m()¥r" "\) ~\'MLSCL¥\L\\D\M¢LQP“ made%\) m w&lol> UUUNLI{ §
"D'\STQ»\QT QLE{L\( , ` ` '

‘\’Lz;,+)'€ Asm’r\uew mm MM'TE/z.

\lcurz rome .41.)0 ¢=FFQQT u @,n €»+TL\/ M)/zemreo .

énelbse¢l‘. QEQ\»:$T (qu;.`)

\i\:','x\n'\\§\¥“(?, pgs) _
QA?@@¥L[|¢{ suLmilJeJ June, .\`£* Zo/f”
Qakn@] Ca¢lon@.t IL|LI%??,
Al\ aid Unn

3101 F,H.z£eq Iu.
ma '

    

 

 

 

` 7 Uw(\'ét Qi.iw\. App€nt-\ no Lo Q-( u'\ tamth
E>L 'Pc;\(~\€:.(;`\c¢\)<\e/\ thrde d ' § \‘n THE L\q“‘ ;\um¢\AL.
®\$T(Z\QT QUV~T
§ DE‘@U COU|\$T\I i'l"b'Y-M

§
R\=_®uesr ma comz\a\\/\Ar\om oF v€u\)EQ\l`oF ADPUCAT!@NS

' gYO{{ UJR\T OF \/\MS€Q§` CBO~'PUS‘ _
\5000 Qi>vv\cs Qm\m`@\ O(HC\ a ,G..pp\iam\tmo m `\v\ the tenomir\£,oncl_
ma\Lu '\\¢\"\s (Qquest ibt Qov?a(mc\t§an ct ”De\`m€§\\ ut ' ptimtio?`$ q rl»dr!t
at ¥\a\oec\; t\.brm,m\d r`es\pec-,H;J\q magid show ~H\p @ou/)l-as ~u)/ou)s.'

\

\ Qaa\me.\ Q(lrdm\ca being ch'€r\\r\\l \v\c.‘.cjreem‘t?e_o\ in ~t\aTe¥m 'DQ_pcartn/\en,lm[
Qu`\m;“at du$t'\c€_ uc\dm( '\nma\L "\d num\r)or t(“\ttL\U?Z. Cem wqu€nt ‘L make

“\’\m ‘t\t\oww\§ S`t€lt(wv\t$ sund!(` peyth op PQI`{LH\{J belth C\wt ce`eas G>q)w' lhatwef£ 1£1`/2{/ on LI.SD./S"
`m '\t\m\tqtb®`\stwiet thid.k)€,\ot) “ ' nt\( .\_m€do .T<¢Km. Ar\ `mctc)cot thian will
`m pm\§\éed \\Qm{¢\»cc§“€x\m' rt \`1 Qs 0 ' this data z \na\m.`m:t' renewed a mpmsc..
tmm“~o,’hlstriet Ql€(¥ \\0'\{ mg ma st \*v\L Cm"\va\¢ or cXC/\Lucu[ 0@1%, writs ar
- ~t\'\cc\““\£\{ buv@`owv\ o\ulq doddka clth mut l `t:urt\wr _e£t <1&“'\""\\.€0 n ta\\‘t\¢\@/C,t€rk, `\tu)os

mt 'mai\zr.\ or M¢M \0'\{ tm'(‘,lemv\ctum }n tepta'/
th 5c\ML 35<€§€'3 vespu\§es m\ twa ind ci.aq 09 june. 20\\`.» `

\\.

janet pa¥)rims m\{_\ overc\\\ ¥{tw{§r$ mem melted via (‘€r`tit\iect W\cu`\ j {.‘_€f`tg
v\¢>. b€\`~ng `\ML\ ~\S"LG' UJB\~ZQL[X'O(UI_ ». expended detw€u/ dal€ Ll/;BO}M°» lucith
atf 05 LL\§ 530 02,,($€€ index t:>f tttlhg£\ Av\ott\@f Eut§ cut citing was Madc_ 'vTa

Ce¢t\`t\.`u\ mdi\ c.,\sls\\`rg o€ Cw\ &tti§am‘t a~£ tZ\Q:tS fn Suppdtc,t£ l`_>.m`t: .» (`e(~te no_toeing
°1C>`)L\ '\<6£0~ (>DL\-’ZDL|C|~SZQK T{a,hrn (Zece¢'()t- inqwa 30th (!er“l€£ed mail .'Pad< `€_s

vera AQL¥.RQA 40 memo Um'\\q `\u~vt-.ce ("e..\'t'ér .’D;'Hn`c}r C`\ML\ 0€¥\`<@ f ESH\Qr hequ a -
C.\Q;(V» ,L\.\;'tb GMFCSS op mb Vi(‘.'.t`l)nz( S't¢ &~t€¢ZO.?>¢ laredo T=Q¥.CU 13’[)(‘]0 c>€ ’FXD‘~(Z-;

\.Uel¢)\nt et $Q.U>¢\d t\`tui§\wd$ op 0 \_\05 2410 01 .(S€e \`/\ctv,¥,\

 

 

\\\‘

\n aeeordam¢ 00`\¥\\.\ Qr'\w"c\i \\¢G\ ¢'t'w.T€xcLs roi£s 09 Qcimlm\ Qn>ee@\wes,~tm

C\C(\L 0t ¥\~Q Cm\u\`c\\`ng Cm(t 5\'\<1\\\ process . L‘le.a~§\ »\Mo\`\\ o\,\ t{t}sz to all padies
§¢\\)A\w_¢§\. `Fu(M¢ . w\¢\w\ `\"WL 'Sra\€ go a \g$pon§£. ~t\~L C`Ler\h$t\c-l\ prod cou ti /L€0 h

"Q_ESOD\\‘>S€ Cupqtvtho app\i`ccmt manor \>€t?\\`w»er.» Suc\/\£s not the ime Cu'.>/ 'H/\i`§

§M dqu st db\“@, 20\§.

wu€a€mzc: .W£'M\~se;x mmsmr:/Léo. w a Plic¢:mt {.\ w atm ;»1\/&¢/ ad
wu~.\)ewé was . egqu that +LL @wrt fan terms tim de/imerq ¢s/ all pedz r`\,emt
Q.AA d`ut\{ putang Y\r\wte b1 tt\BQpptz`cOn't,Q<\c\ writ numbers .

Qape@ttul\q Fu,t>qa,'tJ€L/. Jil.éna/S£' ZOIY
@aLn`<¥ v\>‘._Z_S C b\(A)_
~'\\.\>W wcl\( be \?\&\oeo§ Q¢>ro~nduw\ 1>@ me \`r\ supg><-\'_u(: L)\>u'-\»
~ Or¥\'uclnmv\-¥~\'o ‘€\AQW\'L>_¢(' \Cxu<>~'Qec\c,\L-\cci Qon$cs§'\m L,‘(§£/.O_\`
~ Mj:\'\m "v\\>r Euidaml§ccr\{ Hmr'mq . -

T\-‘.Ql CMX Y\D:_'w>: amc ¢M/ @(AB
' \m{)m§@ Hu\>em owns \1.07
v \\)\UV\D. 0£ wm §\r\ &\,\§)pc>(¥\>@ b\)<\`¥ ` _ @°f'v. "F `
- `\/Q_A¥W\N\\{ o(; Q\A<'{§'\v¥§o LL\?.CM\€> (C¥\ 8\)\ pb(\»¢§? po:vr\ b\£ Gf MWM>CWOH\§C/HPR)
f \\)Qm\\\ C§\`§m(&c§ QUCMAQQ~`\'QS\~» `nm>.c\\{v ` _AC`M\O} @ineda \D(G;Mz\ lnvm('e.'\c@ C/alm)
v w`?\mss B¥ol O,\ncmn Jr. w\ l€Q\m`v/lg> op Lugio \/€/ez O,
" 905le @u>nz@\e,s ?evev_
':FL)J\R¥;\\X&(R n€.’L _(
»~ uOn \hOr 61ch norma
““ O,\/\c`\_&‘\w`no \mcw\o mp
fRCu\e/`\f QL'Y\CdOl
- MD\A@¢\ ~Q\>< méev\¥c>c\{ \“\mc`\m§

-» bo<~:¥ op \’\CL\>QQ§ 0,0,!(&\$ \\.6') -
/ `MQA'MDt DC Low `\v\`§up(;m¥o§ \)bm)r
- TQ&\§~<\/\u\q op Q\r\c`l_\;¥‘¢\c\ \,u.cmo ama bound …z». C`@@zo [,"\` (O\“\W“'?W
“' \DC\`Y\C,SS g~\C¢-\-PW\Q/\'\’l: " z ' 1 l _
S~*m.?)'\$ nc ;v\l€€lj\Q\»§ oc' QG.L)¢}\I> Cl/\CWQ'L 361 wl )mm`mg al Luci¢> U£//’z [J.
" (PCQ,\¢:\\> Qlol\?(l\£j
~ mufd \md»`v\a szo
~/ lum Aps\l?\ar ®.im)gu cros¢,`a‘e
" ®(\\{\S\\hc¢ l_o?_m\£)
' \\ln'\‘\w\ $\>r Ewic\m¥ us\{ He_u<'mg 1
f E>x¢:o_rp}§ §§ § (TLEL Faclem( Sem'lEnce.'mv\ Concurrml.)
" (\7\€,€& %orgdw\ chr?£w\(){\‘\'
" 3\,@£}~1“2»\¥ op Cm\ `\C_-)n`m .
» Mlc‘lu\ wax 01 \.e§(l€r v€qw).;¥ng v°npp£l\ale (?uw\se/\

\.,€z

 

‘\'r{a\ C¢>u(¥ comm no ‘. wore C¢Llu mma m /A-) ~
» \\.,\:'l wc»?¥ 69 Habeas Co<{>us
/ \\A€mc>. o(/\D.b.> {v\ mppu(~\’o(: Mr[j\/
-* i\xo¥\m Q»< Emcla.n§§cuq HQ¢.:\<';M§ _ _
_ - Excarp\a` act (”\1€‘. Fuhm\ §ine/\c. mn &ncura~€nl)
" ?‘CCQ %Cu'qc\;a\ Aqr'QM\A.QA'\
-/ \\\Adgme./\¥/o£~ Qx>¢\u{`d\`w\ ,
-' dmdicifl\ 'badm\' vC'. Qe.`\&@~\'€d omf@£\[€ncé:n+)
`- judicial D¢-¢\Le¥ tC. \Q,~\'-\er raymqu oppdlnl€., (Yun$d

' th\ue.s¥ §§ dull (\_r€'¢`;\\\)’\\\¥h| O(:(L\CL`\`MS wl Ex|ni\:»r"x‘ (r€`»d€\€kq *"\ mmi "°'”'+5)
- \\J\r>\'\on par \oev\d¢\ mcmn¥ wl E¢‘s`c 1033

v ‘ Ma`oum was C£()t\(;\ed und.e( mt S\\rq\e package ‘.
c@r_¥\-R'QA ms mm mo com wm 611er
"Y)Q,\\lu€r}l d(kj€'. prpr"\\ 3012()|'4 l _

"Da>\\`nakm§"'\)\s\xicf\ mem ESJ'N Deqa”ado` _
` mo vlcjnr»;c; s+. 34¢’103
\,-Olr€c&o.T\L 730‘4'1, `

_\»e_lq\\¥: 3 L\,s a 330 oz.

\'LP%&DQEAA\)'§"¥¢Q FC\C)\;\' |v\ @Qn€ml gle §
CQA§C;@) m-‘.“)<>\L| mo own wm s;zqz flaum izw~.»g+ wm
milqu eight M \A L\ .zc\§
‘Da_s\whcr\iun ‘. ®i'&-\T‘\Y `Cle('k Esler Oegbl)ado
\ \\lo\iic,h>nc`¢ ;+;51¢103
l.£m!dc> ,T¥» '(X/Dql

w@qw. 0 L\o,,. mo w

’(chqw,s)r .p\>( G>('ree/\w'm of v€(‘orcl meal " Uo. ZS’ 1105
" A\Sd KQq\x£&\eci C.\Q(L\\ M~Hq op w~n$\“ £r{edl -4m`val\

L\ Mevv\omna\x{na \3\ an\\_{__"\\. S§U-\€s "Q.€Sy`)mse.s ~"¢L'ai u[d C€(+;£‘Qd mall
“\s 'US\\`\<;\' (‘,\ecv luna °2.~¢\¢1.7,0\$`€ n cal/vail tice`¢‘)\§

zc¢z`,.