Court Opinion

ID: 4045552
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:53:53.697809+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:04:37.979223
License: Public Domain

€/7155 /z/@. 020/3 05 03%3 ».3?¢ /

§§ 1210 O@)OZ
4 /_27/ #§Cw/§r/@F§§IMD/AL §§/§7% §

@f;, 7-5;¢//4< RECE|VED |N
couRT oF chMlNALAPPEALs

 

 

E.Z/§

wm mM§MFO MAY 122‘"5

 

AbeiAcosta, Cl rk

 

 

G§A/§>Z»%, 77241/5>25’&§' / /(@70¢¢/

 

 

 

~7;/§ §4§0¢§ §47/§; 43 §\/&~A
77%§ §d§Lr//z)w/r:<’ §z'§¢,¢r m §§a é§~
A/,.¢M /)L/§ §§0 /’§§f §§ /-747;¢!12/§/

 

§§éd;§ 3 /?7/€7\45/4~72)72¢/ FL¢§§/z_»

 

'_____§Q/_;§z§,;zz§;@/_lz£éé/Lw; 745;____

m/,OM §§72M ¢3§ 517/377

 

 

45
77¢§ /%0§47'§47/7”7/7¢§ § §§0~

 

 

______ €@M Qé¢§ §§04§,;§ §I§,¢§w /:7412

/)/072'€§ §§ 77%’ EMAc/"’O/%§ j /1777§

 

§§ 777§/ /%§+§7_7\/§. 171/ 771/rs C’§§§T,

 

77&’§/7*§&£§ §§x/§Z, A§\/”L~Z? /-/M

 

W§.f§%r'. CS’§§’/§r/We/%§d ET)`(_

 

/-%21?17’ /11-; { '777§ we')wo§§z/A¢¢Ma§

 

and W¢//§ §7’7'/,1¢17<7%)3 7'2> 275 470-

 

/FLT€§’5"

 

 

§§A/A amf 0§4§,7/
“7/§¢§0¢/§7?§ 47777€//4-& m BOW¢/
§§AJ§/sz/S’ ( 277/3 0_/) 039/§§ -
_-?,Y / §’ 070/2&0022¢7§»3§¢ / )

 

'77§777@§474777/777/4§ 4)§ -
7/7'§23 § 07§777/77\/§7¢244 0§§¢)§‘2¢71/7-

 

77 70 §§ /§§)420 747/d 2445 §/7077/7\/ 727/47

 

wzvz’/ 700447 774,§71/7)4»§77)7/ / 71/024§§

 

@¢/§7€§ 57 §71/§41 071/ 77<7§ .,SM§ 4)74175”

 

77777777§/7§%27¢/§§ 730 § 704,44§_,,),

 

747/41 777/§ /%0§4'22/47¢/>-’75 §A/7_774§A

 

777 /<’§7§§7: 071/4- §§7/4§7/4744% §§

 

_M§/"'I' §§ 604:4"7)4, EZ[/ WAHF?' §¢:"_Z’ %E?\/
QZJ>J’ 4¢/.. 377 555

 

 

777§471'/47§74777/§5 4) §~

 

7/.:§3 mm 2274§:<' §§§Mr§ §§ 77/§~_§

 

/M4)7' §_27/§7/ /M/ 070§0§ 7201/m 777 /3§

 

/7§2»724} ,?’ w/+s /z/ar’§zz/§z/AA/ §7474227“"

 

772 §§0417:§§§7§§4)4/ 71//717 /7§ 47/,¢5 0§»

 

/)/zz=zo memo /7'-;“§§~7 547/1§721/:§ s,zz»\/._ ,,__

 

§§§@//%947 z // '_z"A/m/q-r§: §§ 721§7

 

71/§;?72§§§/+ §§m/Az/ ;»’ C@/Q§§cm_@/\/AL

 

§DM§A¢-'ZL/ ‘HL,Z/ L/Jf" ..z’.

 

 

72125 §9¢¢§)77/§5 /§)27 [*4§%

 

'7\/§§274§7\/ 027? 521/1377 @é@@ /1/77:47\/§
W ” 77%§ 0§72277\/ 0§ §§0 MIZ$D/§/
772§ /S’M?QA Wp'z¢ 171/7§072771/4»72@7\/ 451/§-
§§§22/§ §§ §§z §7¢§§_2:.§ §§ 4777'4§

 

 

§4§§02 0§5

 

 

- 702744~7:77744 44§§_7§ 77/§
17/777/1~7§_7§ 477/§7/4§§ §§§§¢4@7§§
§727;777¢/ 47/.774 §§ 71117417/§ §4§4§ ".

 

zz/ 4=7/7074§7§4¢71§0/4 §§
751 M341:' /7171 /7§’, 72¢7§ /077/¢,‘7'§§77§€-»
/7~7§>1 §§77»4 21§44)77/§ 77§-7§77/§7 7
7477:_77)7/777/044§' 76’,€0 C§§§` %522 44772§5 77§
3777724) 777 §71/§1/\//177¢7§§ 7§71§477 7@ -
7/77\/4§ /1/07?4'§ §§ 777/em §§Mm//=w&
§§a §77§§ 07/ 07§7/;074»77727 577§577 //I- -
7.<’_7071/

7 //§ 74%7¢477/7'7/7/7¢/4§ é§'
71/;§71 777777174777277 §7777§7 7/7:77»\/ 7717;?4
0777 § €/%47/§§ 572 §§4='§§7\/7’/7&:§

 

§§§7’§’7§47§§ ,@7€ §§7€§§§7"/4-7'-
777/4)747/4§ AMA /%'.z: §§7€7777:7§714§5
§z)é §§74§ §23474:’7§/177\/ 7 §7§7\/§§512'
/ /./_/`7§ /7511§ 7/777/§7&7 //771¢<=71 §§§O»
§47@747\/7"7¢/1771 §J§§§ §§727_77774'7?-/7:§
@/§7\/ 72%044§,/7¢ /7%' /-'277\/7§/%773 777¢73’¢
/)477§§§3 7$'7§40§7'“ 777§'€§§' 4%§§1<§’ §§0,)
777/77 §§77 4§:<7 7:§ 777/§§7{§72’727 7201/717
§§ //70,@47§41 777 §§ /§247§747§7 551/v
.,7‘ /41*1~ /7777§\/41 m§v\/r;:,, 447 § §777/§727-

 

 

 

:7'2!/ .z_ OZ/
711'4772777§720//7/¢’§; 777'%'

 

AWAJZ'§AZ//°:S' Af§%r“$’ a/A<§ %777 cA-r§§

 

577 § AQ¢J 47§5§ 771/2775 477/6071/§77-

 

7477.:7)7/7747 E§§MS§' 1777;»74@ 7/€41

 

7777§§ §§)7§@7/§ [§A§§ §§77071§

 

 

 

 

§/71§§3`“17? 5

 

 

@ée' 504£;) /77/?73£>'5 ZZ£§I_¢: Z'Z¢/OW

15 FOZ§ )‘%44/
S’Wuv ""44.21¢/ 41¢44/£;’) / ¢/A/,ngz _

44 4444@4¢‘/44 amyle 4412/4
mm 4/41) 115 521'4_273£@“427€ 455--
/4)45€ 4/\/ 444/146 44447 ,5¢/45’4 1/.;5’12)»\/
_4;1_1_¢_£§&2_;_$_@_44//€55 774 44-

55’4€£2722'4 ,C.zz/Azz/@;, 54 ,0%/~€/
4€72¢47:1:; /3§’.5.@/, 344 44

 

°'341¢44/ 44444444/¢§
443 4 44 294/;;€4542§ 4443/_27 A¢» -

 

4411/44 744 4441 441/rf 45157455;
4/\/ 444/\/;} 44'472¢/ 524/4c 4/:':5_22>1/ _z;€

 

54@4427:/4 47{/ 444/40»/5/174/_:@4/-

 

41, 440 4555 444/44 _¢ ”:s’ 4//1/44/1/5;'£

 

770 _z?)A//¢z 45 4441.:2-23 74 FZ%e-’/%A-

 

4/fc4A//za/ 1415 /’45§,

 

 

77%/ A/WIGS Mg)ée’wf

 

417/@/ 4422)72 771¢€ 444/I4444r3” //@'4»€~'

 

77a/§§ W/~%zc/¢ 44§’ 47%51’63¢¢ 445

 

%44/4€' ;5" /)471’&'4727/@ 444 1712)~

 

¢4'+523 748 444¢;/.' 444/25 4244/rs -D

 

/)¢/¢- 444 4¢=5;5:5 /./A/Aéz W%e' F`IF>%L -'?’/
,€4¢4,4 zz=E/:/V,Z¢ 444€/\/4 47wa 22/

 

'€4-'5 445&*, / 4(5<) /1/4 024/4 44 4225’5`-

 

 

344 / )
77%5’ AF€_L 510//1/4)'::€@'$

 

7/£ 440¢2' 4414" 454€27/§;3 A 474/1464

 

 

475 4444¢¢5 ;»¢ 474\4)44)724 54457€-

 

 

 

 

444@' 44 4FS

%;y y_zzJ/\/ Ad§y ¢/A/C¢M/'
57 _zy/yzz/y.,zy?)/\/Azo;/ M¢aéy 3 M/.?_zyc’_-
adds 1411/73 /_30€< /Mdf'/_@’/’/kyA¢-
Az raw/ry /%"§' 77 w/h/¢./) /Hyz)v€k fad;nz 1/.7: -

 

5_2797\/ __Z:¢_S Lz/Méan/§ 7.2'°77,77:1,/_72)¢//¢¢ 45 17"'

 

 

LMA£QZ_MM%?J d/¢;S`éy,

 

//%y M/JWF 5511@/¢-:3'

 

_7_'7\/ §006 ?SD/€e?€éy ,C?%yy)v¢ Wk€fy/v%y

 

l;< éz/',yy z§z¢.zz:) 53 dey¢_zyz:y;=y dadyw?wy

 

722 eve A/M<’;Ey deyyz¢/kr,€: éezvze\/

 

/ Q_/< Az/A Wk»~ véyrebe>\/):§ 557-y
377 W%zz§ doudry_m/ 7%§( %§e:s'

 

 

y;)ky Wm yc/wry /kw@7&

 

_;-,\/ /¥_z:sy Wp¢fc#r,wA/§ m a/dnyz?,¢y

 

/»/>¢/3€%#$` dodd/251

 

 

/<’E=S’déyczy,y¢¢c¢§/ f¢/@MI/y/?QS

 

 

0(' ZO\' \5 QE§AQ MAQ@JFO

 

0»4»)’&’ f€.f% MAd/QH/@

 

714 (,/,7. ¢/Q,§?/Z?f

 

dkdey$'a:$"'

 

 

  

.4~. ..‘y.~,`_;~; 1.‘{__3'.;."{- '~B`~

E(HI/~?>IT' /4“ cary /1/¢). .,27)/30./> a.;qyz;;§s/_ / amy
1' /$’»Tr?+d/»/ 515 m 772#)/€)2§§ _,,,>z@/,Qoooz;qsy-E__z y¢»-/ I§S¢¢;€§

IA/ 77¢5 fda/drop ;%mzy/z//k /11/‘/§4¢§ ~ di 751/25
._z`/v/ J`¢z/O/GH/<'?”U/C' `
AAALYAAV~IZQA/ Fe)z A' wA/:/yy¢v/»y/k¢@g)¢f §AA’A¢¢§

_, ' di (?/4'. //£/y.y // W
K/??E/?“/‘O@A/A wm ar 4 £M ,

'y/yo ka /e@/\/@Q/%>;,LyJZ/Ad/£:f’ JF JALIA fda/dry

 

' sr

 

 

 

 

 

cwng /)/d,¢z/j (-’é;" dd<) dev ¢/d/r‘z AL/€ dd¢?-
de-yf¢y/ 421/d /Mv»/A /ky@)zy '\sz1 Va. 547/7 7/%42“ M§/_z’€é' 722 JE»!//U
kwdc) 454-__ §.ZVES ’%»y /1’70§44 dfw/y /Z‘é' 56
//’4"47 237\/ 424 d4y 4424494 47 5741-<221/§ 542 77
13 /, d4“44y//411/2y4:'241y44y 4y `;/7: 4, 244M
51/'74’4)44' § 57)49. 247 64)

11 4 444/2 42 444/44 3’/14144

Hd/) 474 771/4 d4y4 445 4 475 44/ 271/221 41y4yy 75
221421@ 474/247 5 440€/<’4/.4 524111/ 4¢///421/ /1./2:>’
6’§44~_$ /1’9d 7"4“?214-" 104 445 244/3/ d€ddM€/j §42424)
7272147 56?4/44 2'1/25 J4W2”4274’€

 

“~,

 

//%€ §§/042' 6/77/// 41/245' §§ y
2/2413 474 447 422/444 &4/4y 44444:§5 474 -'
¢/444;54' /%4_' 4¢/45 71/42`"§22/472/ 24 2 722244'47 -
244 4/41/4’4y /7’072’44 . ’

77)‘47 `/ 4’14/1*3’:§ 5@42€43 42’25 §2%€-
A42/.s’ 77 4440 445_4_244§:4444/224 427 271/-
221/475 42/27271 2 y2721474/' 445 2644/ig /w;y.yf€£-y W
/%4y 44/y4'4 /"`4-’ §422\/¢5’22)5%6~3 k&d /?7/1'11/4/1'»727’
JZ/%é'd/zyfzw\/ /€4 4 474§’47 /'dzz%’ 74 77
447/2471/ 774/422/41 /1’4444'. '2yy//2ys 2/244 201§4 -
uzz3y 4 92427344 24/11141y4ys 2222-24 172/4 4244-
2224/42 241/17 25 .4/4-744:_§:544/ 74 44444] ///4~111
w 54/43/)122/144/4/ 7444 d44€742\/,y2y11/2:224-
/)24722374/ 474 7774 524/843 74j dc)M§zzJ47€,,.

154§5 142

 

 

 

 

- 4451?4 §22/47.7141242124) /z//
/27 4?4. §§ 4744://27/4),4721/§4414
§4724/42/ §47§2 .4'>’44'. 553

- 2 77127 2242727€472771@7 §1@§44 §4122'
§47€ 472/473 422 -/)474’. <”/f/L 424/§ 4244 4/4/ -
;’422¢/4§27 27 2 744 1 442/§44 2/4414447 547 d§//z 547 1
271 §<2449 11/4227 4477 2 §12'20427641/;77/41/4),44'
w 2//741' §4:4§4741:§ /1¢4' 472445’ 4’§2)/22'§,7
49 4/2442721'271/§ 4272 §7§/1/41§72'1§ 2 54/§474 4
4/::7.22)1\/,,b

23’444/4/4? 442/ A474272222\/§1§7 .'

//1¢.§4447 542 4/22/44474§ 77 47/4 477:1:/1/2747
42 2222/74 421/4- 24 §424_4411/ 427 2444 211/444
_4n// EZL.L §¢=`4/?"77¥€§§§§§,/4//1/4”77 7b 227
/dl/Ua/ 4/2%11~ .I_§ §§4> §275277€29 , §4752%4 ~

6’7`6:2), §§ §§294427§52\ ./

771/147 /1/0772744 :47721§44 45 /%4-7
44./.4774 547 §42 €§5474! 492\/ /1!45 §§07 547427
§474 444‘4 441 4v 422744 427 2245 242-4 4122/27
414/14 472/422741~2-4)1/ 547/47 424 §§§27__47‘€

O?§/ls”,’
2/%42/ 2% §§§424121//41/4§, 4
4?'§§4/§ 4775§4’/§ L/§ /~_4`7§ §4=7/2,742\/ 44/4»”° / -
/%472 74 2242 4'4547 §§§4 24’41277 722 §2’§1¢/24 1
737€// 45 L/FCVQMISZZB/\/¢W 0/€ /V@/’.'/
41¢’/7/4’ 6374)§'/24') 497-" §§denjy 2?

§4§4)44:>7 /14944§ 24 /%411§21\/4~ 102/4 nw
§464'3

 

 

@?>ch‘zzz 77/44/ 7774§ J’/O€LZ »
cm A/,)zr§ 774/z f/://)M»re’ /M: /5’€&7\/ /1/0/:/"-

/C:z'ezj ‘/"'/M// 745 //g%éz/)/¢L .¢¢/.z'¢¢ 744&/
41 4[2~', 77%9\/ 77&: z/l/m,¢¢)z-' /M§ Eezv\/. ,.

47.2<5’¢€23 /3¢/ 77%€ /1/¢9,:>'€§', //<’§z’ given 44/

A¢-'a. 44 pea/4 ), 471/4 A¢-szz) )7%§ 4a ¢¢,
0440£ 7’¢//1/.27';/ /%E“ a//¢€S MLA /~/€ a/Wz¢A
/%41/€ _2'4/ 044€/2 70 JZ/@/)//.zv" Hé';§MA¢/r"
_271//@4/174;22)4 72 77%5 561/1144 , ,%7.'4. 45

4@/'7'6@¢€ § 524 /44 /_/3 ),' fA/&-/J%_ ¢>,e,

575 w. 544 z 754 4
" T//g)\/ d/L/ JW/c/¢¢%/ 9 #5,
.>ZA/_s‘j 77%§ /04£0 car p/¢ln/§L d€/Mzzzj 727%§

4704/_:6/7\7~0'3' £1447' 723 4/<'0 few ¢'¢/€41 Oz/€

440£.§55' 57 /'%v¢AU/¢L 4 /MD/d. ¢Mzz-/¢
&417' /1/¢972’€¢".
7425 4a1/5 f/A)Ar’ 77%§ "/':we'

27'/#40 124-wmng /¢m ff€ ¢//0¢¢ w /h¢/é’
'72> Jz/£wz~)-'m/,cz)>Z/¢<)/;-F'w,\/ %éz¢;'//Am/,r'm
77%5  55 /%§)44/1. ;4_-
444/cg »/, éyzz¢/zym/, 522 ¢/, 51 26 z¢, 204

44€@- 4

 

 

 

 

 

 

776¢€ //"2/27 /vY/"/“'Ic'ei 7#€ /7'25’4¢2‘~
2414/222 227/223 /5022 742 /7@2/,12@/¢”_77»'%~
730/2 424 225 4/1/ v_'/`h¢/_ 52 >‘€, 242/§§ M/M’ 242\/
/4/) Mm/zsmz/,Lr 5 242/'12\/ 272&~ 212/22442“
~/3€:1-:0/2<:»"/ 277/225 /1/2)22~ ’é’ fs/ /:72@224 4-~
€0/1/(5’)'2'~/7271"3/\//712_ 022€' A£O€ES'S 5)7?7\/ »~
26an TIFE' 542¢?§ /+S /l/b A/¢J/Tc’é' /42"/§'22.
212/444¢§‘4@2224/:2;/ , /35_’5¢»/. 322 457 .
/e¢`»"é 4222./_=2\/`0 ., //z,f, daM§sz’w/\/ '
772€¢'“ WA£ZC»%/f’//#A 42 F£O ~
693 222/22 AL/é' 4206£~;§§ AZW 7‘2) 47%272
/1/07'122§' 4/: 7?%5 €/MVAWM 7'.17%€
04 W,@' /%g>;%_zv\/d., 52 2044/af /€€2'2¢47:/'~';
545 %’4£'7'€ §1//?2\/§,_ 3347, ch$a'....§$!$' '

“ ¢)¢/e' 4202€..<75’ 250 222222:3
522/71,2.21 279.!42@,/12§ /_.zme`zy /1/@222§'7176:)2
_z'z/A:)/Hz=' (/¢244¢'1'24~¢") W.'Q'¢¢¢A 225 604/523 -
5>2€29 432 2242/2422 52/4622 //zszz)»\/ /?€-
cg?;l:€ 421'29/£ 7`0 / »\ 4@/2€“/ 74222(/4.

42 425 ./ 572 2044/§ A-zz,ee)\/, 425 w 3{5'.<:?
4250 y€§'cl€:z'/¢/€ 4@ ~ ,
2’§5_§ %€2?¢22@§5 504/46 27> GZVE 171/4244?3“:

/@462' $'

 

 

 

 

72'”7 512 415 //47\/¢’€ /1/0 2702 275
77e/532 £_Q/Iem/ ;2;;€ /2€5@45€ 0‘/\_/ m/WA -L_
/-?1'7’4/£¢/ $’2?/@§'£//[5_;-@7`/) v § ,_

2 _, .,..¢.m__.m_,,.'

’ `_. ‘ ' .~»...¢..
Z Z ` -.) *- ,.'1~‘*'""'“
l ,

7”42' (oz) /z/w'.z'@é:c 27%¢/ 444¢;

642\/// £€é 512/63 42¢/ defde 52 724 za/%/ ,
445 2224424 // 24, 222/§ 425 222/2@2/;2=
garzth ¢/4-¢¢¢'¢§’ )5’ AO€J /1/02~_22/~-
5322/24 )7%¢: 42.2'€222¢/,"44'2/2/)4f'2€€~ ` 5
54€22:§ /%5' /C?¢¢¢s 5424,~ 45 m 232/42;~_
/=’7 FZ)L /hAv:/A 4»)`072¢/ 52/4¢'?2%2'§129/\/ 37 _
dw/F%~m/.f/\/F 50 4742/7 ;’/)MAO /1/5`4/;-:()
772/222' /22»~ /%)45 78 622@'_§§ 4r 224/24¢- _zz§'
yeah/1252 4r /%122.__ ?" 462627\//%02,’2'

% _zz/Mm_:s 421 2222 2/€/322¢5/24 4@\//)2
Az\/A 6042'€27::2/\/ €2)21 425<_ €2’4`L. ,
1222 4/.£ _2;9 ‘ "

 

//»462257\/€55` £AI.S’€S AL¢§"
A&) £'@TS_< C’m/é’e%/¢/!’ .I’/~" 2 ¢:=’€».2:§¢27/‘//.1@/\/
00€5’ /\/02' 420 //123€ ,¢'22222 /z/o/-Tce' §§
¢¢/,¢/24+~' rs 2522 22122€21 ,. £e'J/vzqz'd/’éz ,.
422 440 /¢.z'BJ:-/zszé , 3224225’§' 67\/2'042@'~
MEMHMW£€@MFMEIM . 574 §
/T»¢¢ 47%€7\/2147 571/iri %.5. fda/Srz'mm/\/'

‘/7/&' /z/U'/"`f`€e’ /§7/ JZ/Bs"'e’q/“M@>\/y‘~'
/€evz'e'zd d/\/ 2742/224»47 é~ 2¢‘¢’, Zd/§' ] 7/%4+’
722§ 424<‘_:~2/22//" €€2 €zyézy d/\/ 2741/2422
¢S'>"&/ ZO/_S', ¢(//2'5 2421/ /MMIMZ'SW/H:WE

F4_67/0 0 5. 004/57;77717_20,\/

 

 

 

5500/055 77/€ 71/0 71055 771¢@7
4700¢;;'¢%7/,2' /»/$75 %g€€.z-z/€A /7'>€¢7 w --
007/5,?77/7' zz>A/AL 0,_2 770-2172 /¢7705 7'
/,L5 M,O¢zz~:z) 70 72%§ 4000 2007/77 .,,L
///252 /1/0/?555 725/50 ///76’052,

747175_2:5.0005’,. 73 0€7:'€ 07 D/g 77077’2:7'
/¢77£/)75 77/§ 4004170411/77/3<5'07705 0 _77'

0 055 7/0/2 577@2 /1¢2771 77/:-2 0/»%'04 707/5

70 I&) 7105 4041~7757/ 571/0 072. 04/,%5
537/70 571/057 077 /¢.z:$’ 570/5 700 2771_ EF/M/-L
2072,0¢/1¢£17:0 740 ¢/57?55 07»¢757877¢15
_:7/ /¢/z:§ /-zzé' A£¢)//z?jé' 057-707€57 £e'~
,szz¢=)\/é@v 47/_0 17¢//-`07207/,1-»27)7/ 001/507€’-
/z/zz/¢ 0055'22;>¢<-5' 900¢0007€/\/,2 04 /¢/005 -
171/cl , 70 135 577¢€5 717/51 777/555 /1/07120§5
/77057’ /3€ G=zv/€/z/ §’L//€,¢'-.’z'd.z”EA//z;/ .71/ /7'»0 ~
1577/052 07- 7%2 m/H/A 4720725/ 5005/2 /1:57)4/
£5257/25€ Qa/z;m/ 074/772 70 7400»‘/ 777/52
zz\//)¢/.Lzz_~ 70 005/4705 72 55 0507.>:72 47/0
J¢/c’// zz/FZD)?/%/§Lm)\/, .Z"/t/ EE' _S`Aé$o/¢
57 5 vii /7¢ /75» §/20071//7¢0¢72 z_ //,
_27//)74-725'5 077 77%§ /M¢-_.B£#.§/’ 771"2;)\/.M
77@ /}7<:-’€/7//,171/.:€ ¢5’)7?~/`5_§.¢_ ¢52¢, Ir'

 

p#é’z>' 59

 

 

 

/772’¢¢¢'>¢7/ /3€ '/’/%¢< J"/??£F?JQ
01277%§“£5247 d/Q 77/5 5%~721%'7 we /,'~
55¢55 04 72%5 wDQz~A/c?-» a/L 77%5 _z'cl»/:--
727%/ O£; 77%€ /@"¢/¢-?, Ac/A’?,d d£ f?H_-"‘"
692/52 /C¢IZ’/“L .M /-`/0¢(/ c`"/¢'z/ %Fz:(
(55/9//»32-¢.27)¢75) 777/rs 5 g a/z)# /.1~
‘/z/d;zz'e-' z;z/z/; 77%¢7 572()»1 ‘77%5 /47¢7-
549/hurd ,7
, 77/21§ /1#/1/,4'¢05/ //#§ 7 ;
”);.Q£§ " " )>" 69 €0/)?90 /1/5/1/;;'§ ,. wou¢¢$
.27"/1/07" 55 /AGQE’ 72) /4» ve??§w/ W>’
dQAzA/A%¢/ 17//"62¢_2'@’52/&§'.7

_ZZZ',

7`//@“ Azdé’c_z'Z’/%/I'“é?ézfgz/€S .

_zW d'~d€5 2'1155411 y 1155@ .zz/T//F
457/few 44535.$`$ 72) 561/5 77%5 47441.1 ~
4411/rf /55/`5?3 57"41”5/11'25 571/72~)7@29
452 5745`§' 772 4741/11 47;:251/4573/_2“§22/);/
(555 574.273.274 5445,/5 452 - '
144'?=', /3.§"5 15, 356 5 745 445 115-§§ 1556
75 551/7 745 444175457;!' 452 574§5 772
4741/5 417/147 5545731/75_57\/ 1545 7115 -
41 j” 1?5/1/57.7;1/75§ ._1“115&41 4557)3411/,,~
55 °/7/5" 747 45797: 515'@/3_27?4. JZ/_s’fz€é'.
_ 77%5 444111“541¢/)_'1/4)' 1/57’
- § 471/744 4- /-74;)3 /7457447)\/5._ 5/2 4- 4457471/ -
_zvuo’"-/-“-’ 111 5445/2;’11/1/:7'7 770 35 1454/35
572541 4 1’51/5"77/”'1/7.75/1/41 1374/1113 4527¢4-'
7747 /2/5 771'5.5' '/74-:>~ 4441'_1'54»/7 4555.175:3
1145 445 5455 45 /)/5 /)/571-55(5‘) 41'411_
. 745 /4/44151?41/71545 557/1157 744 54 -
454/71517-7 75 445:.§571/7“ 114 - 75 -~ 545
.271/5`5/244471@1/ . 745 4441'7541/7154:
4551511 74 444/11 513 51/ 745 451?54 -
1151/§ 74 /445’1/5 4/57755: 45 E§'€<'iv/&zj
1574 j /1/*4/ 44571/5415>~//-::" ,z 1153 551/57-
_1-7'1./ 7.1224/ j
£/,

, 4451//1/1 511/5 I§ 4 554/577~
'7“ 1/ 271'7)>\/41 5//411 57\/6’5' 75 /7745 4451’5~
5545: 54 4517115€' 115511 135 /7/5 7574§

 

 

4455 // (

 

 

 

BWMA W/~/ A/%€A 0/\/5’ j> /’/r’»€a1/
d 521/q /'/~z?z~ di 4~ 7.”.2794§:7 /M¢)fz'd§'/%/A
/¢/’» /WE?€% Z?z/U~,Cz/¢, &FFJQ D/MIF?/ /"'D 5a
/%UMA d ¢z¢>‘ 333/533 %EZJ apQ§:' /¢

/1/0/‘2'6’€ ;? /4 375%'7\/171/6-,;“ cz¢ 3333/dm -
/1/:>~77 70 33 /WA 57 nw 3/:'27/91/

if JM 34 5`5'3,’ 171/fe _S’/{Zoo/< $"§'

C;“ w 361 444/34»/¢:'¢=" / ¢=>€_z‘c/(¢fm/ .S_.”s’L
‘ ¢/,.z; zz.pz 240 531 ,'»4 /¢/#¢ AM@/Aw¢=)\/r;<

¢/,é/' €d/\/.S"/?'?Z(/ I??/[/
ZI._

. '7`/7¢§' WA¢I€W 377€0/1/¢1¢7
U¢m//"z>z/A§ 77#)~%“ /%e~ .z:$` ./.?é'.‘zz/Ji 12¢<§6~ ~
/f`z¢l/ ,QE.SV£/;Lz'A/€Z] 57/- /%Z$ Lz'B§)Z¢/:%

/,WA /¢zz w('/»€¢’wé$-’m\/ 15 ¢/Mdaus/ z- -
) - 37)#@‘5 AL-

famA//H, 5’03 /<,¢7(/4
/9,0/,}0¢'@ 341/el ’/3/%%;, " d£de?€_ 77}‘5'@¢
AEXL:€ mr A/\/ _zn/w/zlre’ m w/v'z/A/¥-r§
J/,/Aé'é /z<$zzm/ /M/%/.=z/ CW¢é'A/A 413 / m3
¢>L¢¢s' An/V /4€€€¢/¢~73 6000 304/d /,/¢1 f" 7::7¢7¢
EO¢/Az. 77%9' 7:¢72/)1 z;?/r /74.:3 352»/ 7'5)\/¢75-:

'/ ”7'/€ m/M/A/¢+] /WJ?ZV LA¢/M//Ao’¢=’
dr /‘7¢@“37)~7;2/7@“ A @€_< 573ng /7- 413¢.~7€/7
~/ /1/7;"¢¢~3/ _./:2/ /)v/¢Wd /77~2)@ 3¢/3,§72 z/l:<,zzm/
Q&'Z 57?35' . §éé’En//%o ¢/ z /, 271/mm

3461§ /,Z

 

 

44 WE' /1/4444344 452/41
§»E_§Q/\/‘dé'crm/ §4/)74¢ 536 47'42 . 54444_

 

_444442304/3 / 414/44 432 _43 347 377-
_3_73

37777727~§ 422 maza/4742
_ § 221/47477-’ _’__/5;49:4,_{‘_ 34 4<:22§4354 272 4747\_/-
______ . 447 424 34442242522)21/ §§472/'¢=21 444-7
_______ j 444 €4_<'5 4144727'4 71/2 424 §12;/ 4 574

44424_§43;2<42,_43 3 /2/, 324 _s;s;z___`

__ 44277/2742 4144%<`<)¢4’ 444
…__ _ 21/5;3 /.;Z) 3272)"42_47227 2527/4271/§!5,_/)744€
___ O/\/L_!/ 722/7sz 2271742./ 445 27.€22_¢_",_4_§’3 4 _
_______Y___ §/1/4 72'€.§" 72 ’7%5' _‘Z`/_z_/A?A-J/‘E' §27_/.2_72/41_ 4/271_1
__ 247\/ §§444 7421/327 22 34647.27~’/?//`47"&72_-
§12772_5.,. 244 727/45 444/ri 04 442717@/41,
_ t~7`2‘252_ ".z'(;<§' §sz /774$’7'£5257734 471/
____________ ' _5/_2 "§2'3¢‘4’271//)77_{5__ 72)_47/2111/4/97
344§7<1/2322)7/ 477 4447'@“ 4472 _
_ _ /3$"'§ ¢J 364 %£__ _ _ _ _
__ _ 322/44 2774 44442447/'-/ __ _
452/471 §4’4477/¢71 4- 7727_744 444 444 1
§§e_- 35 442_2*€5’/ (34“4' 62/_1¢__2;__327:§ 4 3 ,#
__ §_Cl_ _) §27/27/§ /~2‘2777 /1‘7»/ 44§4/&/ 442 22
__§ 343/2727"472¢7’47&1771§ 2442:§ §525432-:"_
______ § §2443 421/42721/5’2 2 742 227/% 441/2279 f
/%2.'3 IZ/§’§r?€e?Q§iZ?J?\/ .2’3 ../_/.LE§§’L,
; 77%5' /21§41_2'441/#"§42€7-’<9€5’
§ §4441”///472/)7_ /31'/ 274~ 444€@7! 444-5 4
4547_1 777 447/12 272/rs 2242545“§'. 2741~/34~
444 447/51, 43625 77/@'327777&"_ (»?.) 44/<’§,».--_.

444-73 /.3

  

 

§
§
1
§
§
l
§

 

 

 

 

§4444’5’ 1721/ 27/@' 4452’,1/4 » _

7244, /442~4\ 444 711 2424 7 414…
2411::'=) 7?) 442/4 272717_ 427477315'42¢/ 772¢§
44441=7\/;’ ' /1/42 244 (€21//%;1?_?2~'4 j ,_M
pW/»I- §£§70/1¢3 15 j 1243 5¢’§44135"
744 442’21’4:' 4412 421/442/5'2”27’42727)1/-
744 1/4§415 34 7717§' 2744/_'2'4421/274§€'3
/1/44 /<21/421/ /7¢422/ 72 4744¢277/ 972 /¢’€ "~
14734",7 744 44£4144421/2~7 142-74
442/7271/457 272 434 777 347145' 4444 -
4 444/43 421/721 744 447/17 542_:422_ 2€~
117/27 72_=245 ’7/2’ 2770/342 ”’§241/’_/12//%)7-/‘“/%§'
_ 4/4=21.1 272 ‘2<::222 /

4744¢1 4/42_, 721§444/-2 ~
§47\/27_ 442/22 214/45 72 447’2:2222771 77/4-'
44444447045’ 24 7 24 4442347/4
2 74_4347_; 4 4544 772/275 4742/4 42747
254/§&72%¢327)71/%&7/2 €71/ 252€4§ 1333 ,3’
25 4445_-2-224 272/444422' 4411/2727 315
24 4444,1/ @:52%41-2\/43 44 217/25 423 1 _
572'274 f
4412 445§ 4444444445
742 7 742 442/4 421/74 /2) 444741)» _
441/27 114/2247 -1 5 /1'727 34 472pr j
4444444443 24 7' 124 /1222./4 25 ~.._
//4/£._<.' " § /3’41)474421/421/;43 744@77/47@
421/4 444 4477442744 14 45421 24 41'_-" -
21/4 £<1:-'247434 7

77%52§’ 4441:479 224/55 1?’
21/4 22245 444 2/444¢ 7 ¢_-/1/ 272 444-
¢1/ 442421/_.5"7':1_77"47'.22)2\/41, 272 772¢& 44 -

xé 4244/7 //»‘4,` 2425 44 44 /71

 

 

 

 

/'LZU/??\/F/M/%ZC’»¢ /}£.g'" v5’/,,//3 ¢~
J?;cr’ 73 V"L/A ram %ev/zzw", 021/0 7/1/§
/>le¢'.fC/?M"" would z;,z'?z@/ /73 m¢:)¢,,,,\//r/
/?' 43 Lz€ Aébc”§$$’ (Zé/%'/¢c €)1/¢€§-/ '/?) 7/%,5/
/6%3¢) Ez;-"zj ¢‘//QQ: @/5‘¢‘73 37 27/§ 369/479 0 f
57 /UMFF §é;)"/ZY QS`.M 34 553 x
__§:1/ \~5`/%00/<4 .$’4 55 ¢‘£< /¢'Mez/Am€)»/r'j§, ,4/,5’,
C’;o/\Ls'f.’z';"¢/ZZ'UA/

 

' .¢//z/Aé??, '7"//;»/ 6’¢/4%51/§" 57/¢~
722"/“£-? ,- /%\/ .271//¢74¢'€’ 15 (:“"A//’.z’/‘ZQTO 70
£F¢€/~}§é a///@\/ /z!.z'§ /"'Z//»V“ 7273,45 j /,é§
ng) r/”m¢;-' e’Q .¢S’M/O¢'-VZ' /I§Zz?f/\/, 41/_2'77/0¢¢)"
,4 A/¢%@¢é/‘/@ME»Z§ {,,2 ) JyW/¢¢;z'/z /f,_m/~/
Azn/L»w /?)1/ d/J/J¢'>A 72//»/3';/ 7& ;»S 213 -
/M.zy~ /)M+'MS ,. 77/2'-' "7"2>?/4$ é)<'z?.M@'/~
/97€>1/";/ 0/: C%l?¢?z'/)/.élf. Q/'Z/`s‘y'.’f¢’g -~ C_z;/)
_QL/§_)//<°&?§A§§ //'z/ éz.z'é_z:/?c€ f/\//>:)M
73 //'Mw/A A+P/¢v~/ZL/ \5"¢/%’£72%¢:':57£02/ .""

/?€§/Jg€f;@z¢a/ J`z./@Wz/')?_, €e,:§.sr'/

 

EHJKAROOSAAPLLN sTATE oF TEXAS 12/04/;014
` BOARD oF PARDoNs AND PAROLES PAGE'

_l
PAROLE PANEL DEClSION “#*f: ` _f¢__ __'f°__’
OF ago lai / 5

NADE: MARRUFO,CESAR

 

SID NUMBER: 07757299 TDCJ~ID NUMBER: 01953108
TDCJ-ID UNIT OF ASSIGNMENT: LINDSEY SJ
HOLEING ASSIGNMBNT: DORM G-l BED: 144

sUBJECT: Decision Not to grant Parole - sERvE ALL

After a review of/your case, the Board of Pardons and Paroles
decision is not to grant you parole and has marked your case as a

SERVE-ALL.

You have been denied parole for the reason(s) listed below:

One or more components indicated in each paragraph listed below may

appdy, but only one is required.

lD. THE RECORD INDICATES THAT THE INMATE HAS REPEATEDLY COMMITTED
CRIMINAL EPISODES OR HAS A PATTERN OF SIMILAR OFFENSES THAT
INDICATES A PREDISPOSITION TO COMMIT CRIMINAL ACTS WHEN RELEASED;
OR THE RECORD INDICATES THAT THE INMATE IS A LEADER OR ACTIVE
PARTICIPANT IN GANG OR ORGANIZED CRIMINAL ACTIVITY; OR THE RECORD
INDICATES A JUVENILE OR AN ADULT ARREST OR,INVESTIGATION FOR
FELONY AND MISDEMEANOR OFFENSES.

ZD. THE RECORD INDICATES THAT THE INMATE COMMITTED ONE OR MORE
VIOLENT CRIMINAL ACTS INDICATING A CONSCIOUS DISREGARD FOR THE
LIVES, SAFETY, OR PROPERTY OF OTHERS; OR=THE INSTANT OFFENSE OR
PATTERN OF CRIMINAL ACTIVITY HAS ELEMENTS OF BRUTALITY, VIOLENCE,
OR CONSCIOUS SELECTION OF VICTIM'S VULNERABILITY SUCH THAT THE
INMATE POSES A CONTINUING THREAT TO PUBLIC SAFETY; OR THE RECORD
INDICATES USE OF A WEAPON.

If all your convictions have offense dates prior to 09/01/1996
and you are eligible for Mandatory Supervision, you will not receive
further parole reviews and will be released on your projected release
date to Mandatory Supervision of the ParoIe Division.

 

If you have a conviction with an offense date after 08/31/1996
and you are eligible for Mandatory Supervision, the Board of Pardons
and Paroles will review your case when you are within six (6) months
of your projected release date to determine if you are to be released.
You will be notified of the Board's decision to either:

grant your release on Mandatory Supervision (RMS) and allow your
release on your projected release date
OR
deny Mandatory Supervision (DMS) and assign you a next review (NR)
date.
If released on Mandatory Supervision, you will be required to
comply with the following special conditions of mandatory release:
NONE

Should you have any questions regarding this notice you are to
contact your unit Institutional Parole Office.

CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE

/.F ”d£:§’ -N ._i*?/ /fi)’ AZFFQ€M/"
;¢¢,mA@Ma/z§' ma%g§ W:§ w 7:~1:/_:' .;¢z/z/~
€aMsrf;Z¢rzaA/Azty 1//4¢;/5'.3 .40¢52:¢ calif

LPDKAROOBAAPLLN STATE OF TEXAS 12/04/2014
BOARD OF PARDONS AND PAROLES PAGE 2

NOTICE OF PAROLE PANEL DECISION

NAME: MARRUFO,CESAR

SID NUMBER: 07757299 TDCJ-ID NUMBER: 01953108
TDCJ-ID UNIT OF ASSIGNMENT: LINDSEY SJ
HOUSING ASSIGNMENT: DORM G-l ' BED: 144

‘7"'/7¢:5 A/pzzzz”e/ d par A/w/
I?l/F'J,Qm 77;€§“ /4/)/4’;,2"£’4<4/;/@@/

/%z:§` I/QOJ'¢§'C)'/éé £ézé?¢§é' A*?ZY"Y//

M///ICA¢ MA/' AWr,-:zwa/r 4 '//z)w@’cy AA why/cg A 415
A/) dress /\/0 72'€@~ ./)/-/ /%z § m 57 ita/few
AA»V§’/ MA 15 //T'/;»¢¢¢§’ 75 /71744/37:¢1¢/¢9¢¢5’
41\/;\ //M/€m/S'/"f??/ "/’zzm/Az 723 U/z§ WAL.z/c’/§Ln/a,/“

This Notice of the Parole Panel Action is your written detailed
statement as required by Texas Government Code SECTION 508.l4l'l.
SERVE-ALL

CC: INMATE - TDCJ-ID

PDKAROOSADPLLN STATE OF TEXAS 12/30/2014
BOARD OF PARDONS AND PAROLES PAGE 1

NOTICE OF INITIAL DISCRETIONARY MANDATORY REVIEW v '\ 5 ' _
5{‘//‘/,.2 _7§17_“/{'? ‘*'

NAME: MARRUFO,CESAR

 

SID NUMBER: 07757299 TDCJ-ID NUMBER: 01953108
TDCJ-ID UNIT OF ASSIGNMENT: LINDSEY SJ
HOUSING ASSIGNMENT: DORM G-l BED: 144

SUBJECT: HB 1433 Initial Discretionary Mandatory Supervision Review

Records indicate you have a conviction with an offense date after
08/31/96 and you are eligible for Mandatory Supervision; however, your
release to Mandatory Supervision will not occur if the Board of Pardons
and Paroles determines that your accrued good conduct time is not an
accurate reflection of your potential for rehabilitation and your
release will endanger the public. (See Texas Government Code Section
508.149(b)). This determination is independent of any parole review
decisions and will occur prior to your Projected Release Date as
determined by TDCJ CID Classification and Records.' Records currently
reflect your Projected Release Date as 04/29/2015§

If you wish to submit any additional information to the Board, you
must do so in writing and deliver it to your unit~Institutional Parole
Office within 30 days from the date you receive and/or sign this notice.
The Board will review your file and all available records after the 30
day period has expired and no earlier than 60 days before your
Projected Release Date to determine if you will be released.

After the Discretionary Mandatory Supervision review is completed,
you will be notified of the Board's decision to either:

* Grant your release on Mandatory Supervision (RMS)

f`\D
v

L\

* Deny Mandatory Supervision (DMS), and assign you a next review (NR)
date for release consideration.

Should you have any questions regarding this notice you are to
contact your unit Institutional Parole Office.

Offender signature @(.’,9§‘1;/ Morff`_)¢(j gate [-@_. /:

Witness signature n Date_¢'#§§`? 5 l ["(0`2@[$

30 DAYS FROM THE DATE YOU\§BCEIVED AND/OR SIGNED THIS NOTICE IS:

.\`

H.B. 1433 NOTICE ;-D\~ZQ(§
cc: INMATE - TDcJ-ID AD409: N
TDcJ-PD iNMATE FILE REG= N

/

gil/en /1/@ ama z /Mzz/¢ ~@A/ ;%'
JAM§ 434»7 25 MA/z’a/\/;TZ;Z/z'zz))z//¢L /71~;
AWL¢~€;) 72:> /7/@-' M,@Lr@w,r',,,