Court Opinion

ID: 4056289
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:44:38.425693+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:35.667614
License: Public Domain

, y3110 51’13 03

 

` " ` QM§Q: 05 %@1 00115 1111
3_;1.'1.@\!%15/3111€15 C‘\SQ#TJQ
§TATP_ '- ` '- ' _ 3 @‘\(W §`V`:%Qm
36;€ §111'1€. ' v l
x 1`:'_.\£\/`11\%.\:§?'5_ 1-

CEIVES 1N
Q ufd- ELLV 15=(\\0:'1~\ @R§E RHWNM PPEA
RQQ:§U§`SOS;€ 1‘_@1\9_. \\11\11, SQ_Q 31&1®1 O$C :Q®S_§S x

…11:_111\01°\(\1/\&\11/1/1 1131%11 091 §§@1*7§@:?@©1@”’1‘
\\ 1301 \)\§1333 373 \1\31:§`(1%‘“150:§%\

7 _l_N T\m§. l\f\xcwm)€ C)§ `\11$‘1310;& muvr\aq\) O_mrrlew _% C‘1'
» O\L\ C\_GMY 111 O_. 1§>1\1191/ r_ 1131 `\1'1’115
QR\v\/\lv‘\¢<§l '\.Q:M v.&\& CXNC§ 31110?31`1`1331/11£; 1\.1\€3€1;10§:11/1&11”11/‘1/1 g 11/1
gm 0 0 \\Q_(X\'\ QV\C\|V\ 1113 g
1 111 >11611?1311 3 1111§§131 3 33 3 3
C§ QQMM_ ®1_1' 1101\11¢ \)1111; 111111&<1 11\110_ §mo_u s 10`1\" 011/111

111“""1)111/161/1@\ 111113; @mv_e.ss Cpm§Hu‘11G1/1011 1331'131/1315
ALAQSLSG rs SQMQAU_G Gc>'r \ ©1\1\\

QV ~ r…<; us mm \11)\1;01/\51`1‘111`1101/\011
111\\10}\/\“‘1 1313

/\111»_11111_\1.~ \1. 3 1533 ,,1113115
CSM 1315 §\/103113510@» 11311111;11;. Qd'v`o%\<115 a ap 1111133703716¢
1111:\ \\/111/1 \1111111 ,’,11111\1>1¢11`\1><11§110,311(1@ 3111311;1
511/163 "‘\<\ QW\H\D\I_L% /13§1111;$&11/1§§`151/1@ :uv
116;16:11<1111\ 1111 © "’

Rose<‘_n‘(@r; Q mgn/\QN“H? ..
361 MUR§QM\ \110111\.
.`M ` \33%11116\1_§1\?

&nc\ S@. @.1
"I\IE`.N ru`[e QQ§YDAM‘N;D 1~';&_1.1'1‘1¢0§1\`;11~ mr 5
113 11111311.11~%1111$1\1110111 § @1~1@_ sLm%L 3@112 111 5<11 1011111,
leg OVQV'QDMQ.\h©P`( SQ_C`_ '+"l?>b\\~j,

 

 

 

 

 

 

-SQ_Q_' ` ,.

, ~_§»A)@:;/;X»\-\\Mm_ 1 ' C¢\SQ,:<:§~%Q»@@¢\M
` _ ~ C&SQT\§QQ .O\'\/cav A\f uc;_\)
» Qc;sgss§o\/\ -

' BA@§UQ)/TELA&_; é,\/wam§ \s,u§<\/\e}w~l& Qoud§r _G<'\ S~Dq~\q_<éof ~, _
nh&g\\;<§ov~@_. ©V` C\mr`\v\<§:\w )`-c\€>l°\hwm%{c)\/\ AUHW} _
\ m ‘\>M<- w ' >' fmi am ,
_ /’\>\e_e)!\ C>m\'(e§?
UOV\,§~\M°\AC\A \r\z:s§v`\§m¥€@v\`\ \\\v\é\\-Avq)umw`§\"j?r©
_ 3,<\#\~°~ l\lY\-§ \`\U\<\~w ¥\/LR: `\*QX. Q©(§)Q GQ Q,\>\°L;Z\A\QRO§_,, Q~M\J{¢ 5 97an 2 4 <((WYE
Q&.\Ac§ O.Sl/\Qc\ 5K'\Ile.`$_\smj`51'¢> %.§`UL W\€_. OL` \_'L(:€_ SQ\/\'\`Q»\C§
:\:’,M mck 5qu z§)\m\% lam ~JX+PL§.~`(>\DSQ@§¢QA’ h H\<»£v ‘.

. Smc._\h (\>mo\,e, Kv\§vmck§ov\” E%M&MM"
- &&vu§ 503¥’, Sw.jwzu<‘_€>__ \)`AQL,S/TS €XQ.QSS°\VQ_ .(.\V\c§\
M%lm§_&m\ ‘\:es$v\ `m°u§)v’ Qg MQS
l mm im \~\m. C;m§`e, ©‘€; (1\!\¢\3\€<,\‘1%‘1\
~ ` - *L w 7733¢@),&¢§49| ~
' 40 qrs» F<:>vj g 0<\9. (Y\°\\\"\ow€:\ns O‘; CLQ§R¢AW\,

>)ETWS\O\\M\". C©u§}ro; C“.s¥\`.m\\.l Q~(:¢(SQAA; QQ\)QYS@A Gm\ QQW\Q/a¢§\;§
` SV\`\;:\\§C§:¢&>¢ (L` N g;]g;° § &°3;;_\;\\: ©J\<§"Qe“.\'§jv?om@wb€ QG\SQ_.' @
\\aptw g `» §\Mm W\¢; adamer §§ Iusf}fc.e;’ CL\so,

WAEM (T m ,A x §§
'H& M¥Q.\¥'.S+A+a ' "75{ S‘u).ld.g?ggqq€_)( m Nll\q 4 d

_ ”`\§><_, .R§s:\jl /\DR:/-\S\'\NS§Y \'\/\`.-3 \;KOV\©JQ\B\L
'-&cud C§wv€v \/\*:; \\..0”7 -\m~°€r ©$ H,v.\\;>m$)

" in ¥\rlL"Kv\XQv<:s\' C>\: I`L)\SHO_Q.y OLS jv\n`i§ \/m\/\.
D_©mljr c\\é\ °m `H/l£__) C&SGL©F § 4 ~ l
_ - , "` Af\/+\/lov\\j Llo§§©\f\ \/\/\‘i\\o,\r \/.Q=\~M`& '77§ _ ‘
g,w.;,\€\ 491., am WL‘::NWQS% §§

' uSJL`TCQ_) '.,

`\'0\,\3\/1°1@§/\ [§Ojiov\ PQ`H~HQMJ\ wa@(s+; ..

 

_ 5`§ 7./6 ` , , 515;@6@:@@§5@77%
. /
r. .~~ Q\&Ll Q/F GK¢\VC!`QA

< pw+@. %m\\\\ 7%¢ stw\;a<\ <3 3<@ _.pw$uw J¢-O \\.0'7'
, E.'>< Pw”f°» M