Court Opinion

ID: 4229223
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2017-12-15 11:26:04.320174+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:43:05.980082
License: Public Domain

MYa i. ad / ?

XM THE. NjWW courT of ffPP£ft^s

                61-J ?'d&321~£.fl
                                                 LED
          /)/iTMo&y J&iAJ Summits             dec . g2Q1
                                            CAROLANNFHARL^y
              J7t£. SXtfk. of JkxAs         CLERKOFTHncoG^T
                                           NINTHCGUHTOrAFpr?/L3

 wMjea/ Mr w/6r*f /MmJ)ao7/js was f/M Thu/ul.
 vi/aa jtd Cou/SlT Caa/v"jcJjdaJ I £   W&s AMd £          AM
 fipihf/^ hej/ip:/\ j/iY U.S. CoMsl?Ja JToajft I Rj'/sHT
£&Pi£A of -$D/njLfH/7j£> J

                           -# *US/3?l        , _
                           c J~ T&ftf/J /Ja/j J

RoAoZsT Tb 3& vte* h)£A/£j) M>u/. u/JS)££ il.S.C^
                                           iMMmiis
 OJ COME /{O'\V f)/rr//o/\r>LEoMSlirr?/r)£f5 b?EW77/jL
       bEFEA'AAAf/W f//£ SISOYE A'OAVBEE IN/lFlEJ)CWSE
      Md W/J'MOVE f/fefo Sfaf fillf/YE AVfcdA'^dcf
      df OKE/Y6E. c^dA'TycfcATjA' T/itrfE foj/ffhA's cf
      Ua';7£.1) s,Mj£s C6Ar5fifijJj£//*8? fJJc/i£teii/Ak cf
      Ttid LmLAlMMf, LLl^OAl/ .Jui£Ea xm£j>Axh£6M
      Y/a/"JC

 LZ.) AHCooM ££/#7kj) fisO^AfiE D£A//J:P bef&vQ?tAfil&
      /fZtEJS/l/V/hAMtL fa SiAYjZ aIcTAss 72 T#£\ '^amT
     JjJteMf aa//> r* mx fA/>A/i;r-2££., h^Jh&Ls,i22^
     .(rXM^rty/ty 7Z*AKr if7? ,£1L$jaH&£as£ , Hr>ip:Ul
 r -teA&^AjJ oA ftZf-tlAbZ . ,7a7/ fas ajpK , A// w;77/a<^_
 1   ^l&ft^MA/^ ifi&finTMhll/. at VrtA/A-A/J) /)£ T?/u./T
^-y Af/7/£ JJ:£MJ-
       W/L jl.LOY/*'DliJkuf'CotiATof DKBrA'&/£- fcxtts , /Mi
      AWM hj/) /}B/Ct&6r£ .M/ U,$ . CeMsfjTcjf/bA/A^ RfAjtfc
     j J9S 1,6 j ?,#,£->

      T/i£. A'&Hr Tb f//?iL Afruf/ff. Avj) 6>Aie.vfi JlA/D
      A/>R£Si to#*r HjL JJaj D*M£- />}£- A/U/) ffi-fcE /S/2?
      off Aiy ofci^i 0 )JZ /)J) /fof /Hie ft,A. ft/AlAetK.
      Af Ue VD)£v f/tijv 37h/ Th CooflT/fart/L-!

Lb) I btfjUi&At/T#&s A?££A/E>£/Vf£/) HA U.S. C^fff-
      OJ/oMfik Rj"6Ef,-
-        .    U-ofLs:.     _.

    -J1J11EJZLR-.        . Pa r- f

     ficTEo/i/      /V     vhe.      FILED
    /V/Wr//     PzARL sL*33c          m'lm
Be/} u/V/j./v/ , fx       777AJJ     n~S^^atls

fl/f//fo/\ry Aega/ Snm.VEfts
       STz/Jf.      ^T     Texas

en use Mo #L£j. ?oo ?*-/?
             CfM//6£ R //AVA^jg
                                           -2

                  /& f/kA A*/risks'        Z    • =
                  AAA) SJJ&as CfiESJ^ s I "
     CAUSE# DJ?0O?jt                T^ 5   OS

J" fa7%oA? A£bA' SlW/XZZS     Y//// Ah'a 14/ fj/fif
J am ££/>&' eusaEee^ -yE// /ny as, CMsr/jTof-
 IoaJ fi'f?Hf<"ff/A)E£a>EE X,i)/f£ AAA//// a-a'E)
 AawytyE JZ/)ah/-> SS /)£aeaA af ElLLjEjeaEaA'
jCeM "ja/ 77/jl AE/j/e cacIsE aVE'/ESaa TfExf
 CA/V AA/Jb WjJ/ 3//du/ /7\7£A'AV££ArcE J T//A
. SrAYiE     A//A h/tW/ER. AS vs/L// J). A. „Fff, e
 A/AS OA>'AS U<£/) 77/A£aA£A-^ *7k W£* />//)
^/YlA/tE, TM+T Tjs S/Z/c AA/Jh MdT A//a ^EEAAA/E^
TfrrffiAll C««/fM ,' TT/Af'WAS aaF HeTa1/
 rt,SA /H///)/-*<, PY /// AAA/) /Ws l,£//A//E
 AsM foE CEf/ks af J// AEY//)AAEfJ) A/lAl)
 Af?Eiun) rfiAE Asrr^iS , fEEf TaP/± s , A//
.jjZiu&i . a;y \pj£Zs,j// TAEAj.^yrnr
 £    HaAA Ej/CAE) *Afiwy£/L-3L. ^AWi " fiof
 A/0 oiA£ eft// &Ef' T7/S AEfo f/A£E£ H&*D
 7H«r Z E/D A/df E/Ef' /),W.£. IS DfAjvoT^
  Ha\t&. a    Va// J 77/fif£ /j#/J Efdsf Eo i oa/
  of /°a?/5daj A/y_a£?As A/yy) was aeaTeaeesje^
  EhA A h>W,JE J coo/iT ZdsT'Za/A/£T£/> ,
             PaE>£ X. of

           C. A) \/EE?         PA/rf
                                                          ; FILE!
                                                          ;• .         AUG If 2017
                                                      -   >..      CAROLANNEHAF1LEY

          C—// LJ <£>/.—   U   /   / / / f /   SAi               NINTH COURT OFAPPEALS

    p.£f£A/f)£Ai r~        s.ipy

       ReTaekee /4,5.EE

J
             fAES^JAE^tEIET

 za/7 . X //AYA J/2us Sj/AX' Aj&sAoJ/aP yt/j77/jw *
 W EE^ A*J<- AM/) jQ*T.Sz>ajA)Aa/E^ /^^/£At
• wte CaJA^E AfAEX fAEiS- AS w*a> aoSWE efXEA^
 '• toAj'tT E/fs BY So oEA AaxE c*tYJ> M^SaaXA
 ' AvS H/AAA ytz/SA AvTMAAt' Aj?AX^X?oA£ A
 fir^S „r >,a«sMf/te&y AXE aEESu£EVY Jam*
,&E A/^ySof/E
                   S&A4

                 DAAXA^ 7x f?E3A ~A7AIJ^

 A y,-,E/A:< EysSES />'J
                      EC & LLL

 C^SEExt       fEA-x/EL
            sjaAa:

CMJ&&JU2&3.
                      C-A6-*
CAASELJE-     'AESix2i±Z3_2.

 AY/ASA A/sm/cr
                    ^E!L                            p^..
                                             eastUe|-nd

                                                   JUL

                                        S.
                                        DEPUTV
  EAjfEcAjy / soAiAi£jtK                          'PS"' ^
  ^E*E^ oJ- ^XAS                       F^~~^
                           hl^AA7&A!
  * Aa/AmA A£CXSv^77AAi *y-au +» •-
  ^ "' dAA aa'A) bn- Ee/u'^b AAA Asa ^StE r
 j*AaA aE/ASa^,) r * lV -, SSr      <«*SAo)-
 ™* AJ IPS ^ Xm^TAAA h,SAsUA

*» *^S EfE^7        ~ **A*l *r
nee*,. EEeJE AAAf •fx^* **"
^«iAe1ee^e:zaE^       **"* •mA
*"><* .i- ^ XBSyEEfEEESAi "Kj^-
»#>>
.4aA r„ E7A^ X.
               r^^^SEE£^xAA,^
                      /       -•       A^AaY Suaptej
                                                JEEoPjiC
   Cd

                                  ORANGE COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE
                                          CORRECTIONS DIVISION
                                            INMATE GRIEVANCE

        TO: GRIEVANCE OFFICER

                        NAME OF INMATE
                                                         YL_A.
                                                         CELL/BLOCK                      SO NUMBER

                       DATE FILED
                                                        DATE CONFINED

       SIR:

       LUdge a„di:SnCe' 'Cer% th3t ^ Statement iS trUe ™d <»™» to ** bes, ofmy
                                                STATEMENT

      S^^^TO^"* °" **^                                             ™,nes crpersons invoived, iBeludiBg
Ef ^^E^^SA^                                                                                  AT'*i*Y,*a)

.*7**UL»uM «l A.A^AT^ Af^^ S" ""^^

    Seal this completed form in an envelope and it will be dehv"
    Officer the same day or the next norma! business day.
                                          vNGE COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE
                                            CORRECTIONS DIVISION
                                             INMATE GRIEVANCE

           TO: GRIEVANCE OFFICER

           FROM: AtflftMty A vaw/^\                          -d             A.
                           NAME OF INMATE                    CELL/BLOCK                       SONUMBER

                           DATE FILED                        DATE CONFINED

           SIR:

           I wish to file a grievance. ] certify that my statement is trueand correct to the bestof my
           knowledge and belief.J A)M T/K£J) of SrlV /MA ft, jfefrtfr J>U>f/j£j) A.Uj B&J/fr

          (Please print or write legibly. Include all dates, times, and names ofpersons involved, including
          witnesses ifnecessary.) X 4/11 Ja^Aa PSJ) R/6HTJ~c CjjLL^f,!EjAa"uaAA-/ J?/&ftf±
    -5aE£ J, YiSTi L /j^MUtAdE^UAL^L / J7yEcA-S<>jS . JS AA" ASfSs/kh Ad/) l)EAAf/P/Sj)
PoS<>        A/or ffilopEL Urj AA.J) /a¥yy M-&££££jtJs+/?/£. S>iEJ~^SJ/jf^
A$S C£'.r APaPa'/F- AxjP'x?£Yf,tA JI-,            /£/>/ /),/C ri#y& ) aT tfis/ss' CSAC u'Acfe/)
of /frjy cr£/j?A£ J

          Seal this completed form in an envelope and itwill be delivered unopened, to the Grievance
          Officer the same dayor the next normal business day.
                                  INMATE REQUEST FOR
                                                                               s.o.*JE?A y
To: rT/jJ>6£ Ha Hi/                                   Vmm: AaYAm/y A. J.j/yi./y/^A <.
                                                                 (Last, First, MI)

 Date: fr? -.2 %~J f                         Time:.          Block:       A          Cell:   A

 Message or request: /fly XA'/AaEk fetidzS/oAms n/Z• &AlE VA/ACES nA
AAtf EaSA Effry A> A/ret? AT ASLfiAiAf c^-i^S XX,/ *VA>
 cFEEl/ft r7A,/1ff<, A//) mE A-A'A All IA'AIaSi 'EaS rFl]£AocK A
JlA-VAAi YoEA?1T/,A? Mn A/AAAIAEel feAntxT'A,*/** ' Hz A< *r*/:
 hAiv AEStft-fiy Mo via A/?#-tfAe rou/Efv SE/A AaJ VXIaE-.j *A
Jama aajA) ef U.A. CpxSPePjEE/aA. ! sa^SEE^a r,»xf
YA//Y BmY v/ufc. £?*S nA PIE P a/^ A
Receiving Officer:                                    Inmate Signature:     io/\J\

Disposition: (DO NOT WRITE BELOW THIS LINE):

  yytyy Ay tmmcA iL\,^ cmUiw>a

FILL OUT THIS REQUEST FORM COMPLETELY WITHALL YOUR INFORMATIONAND
PLACE ITIN THE MAIL BOXSO ITCANBE PICKED UPBYTHEMAIL OFFICER
YOUR REQUEST WILL BE DELIVERED TO THE INDIVIDUAL RESPONSIBLE FOR YOUR
PARTICULAR REQUESTAND A RESPONSE WILL BEMADE BACK TO YOU.

Y\EZPRINT\SHEB.1FRJAIL\INMATE REQUEST 4/99
            fJ'ZAAB
            —_
                    ASAP
                      .—
                         Cofv
                          Y—A
                              P>foi

                                  INMATE REQUEST FORM
                                                                               s.o.# .SEAS
 To:SAP Sc                                                 ?™™S/i/YEAnAjy i <;,jMsnAX5
                                                                 (Last, First/Ml)

 Date: ? - S ~<>S                            T™e:   f   FA7   Block:       A        Cell:   A

 Message or request: /fefcfgl fay nA C.aAA E/hE^TAJ . Pr>'YW *j*_/L-
a/a-saP^ tee .a^aaa wA//s*sa* ~a^ y i
aaaaa^ fo Etaep fy/oA& c,a// ssEk^ ^,e s/epSjaj, m*aj
 T P/E ay/Up aa\AEaAExa^ AE> Sp/Ea a&i AJ r aCa-a k- *
\S/Eh Fa^eX'/                                           pyyxsE Xo^JL
Receiving Officer:

Individual

FILL OUT THIS REQUEST FORM COMPLETELY WITH AtL YOUR INFORMA TWNAND
PLACE ITINTHE MAIL BOXSO IT CANBE PICKED UP BYffl^MAIL OFFICER
YOUR REQUEST WILL BE DELIVERED TO THE INDIVIDUAL RESj^NSlBLE FOR YOUR
PARTICULAR REQUESTAND ARESPONSE WILL BE MADE BACK TO YOU.

Y•£ZPRINT\SHF.RlFPJA:iAINMATE REQUEST 4/99
                               / Copy Jo ^^ -
                 INMATE REQUEST FORM
                                                  so# 47#y
 To: Offi^*
      
                                         From:A/^;  jSSa Jr SEi/ntf'/gyf?C
                                             (last nameyfirst, middle)

 Date: ^//-/^Time: J PEE Block: /f                     Cell:   /f
 Message or request:      ,.                                            _
 Iff? D(>f7o*Z s/l//) f           C4/P A'A/. St/*/ 7?/a MJ?,L
AfetfolTFn/? 77/S A^AY>,/r/A, sn*^r//*7~Xaa/A
~h-ift&&//£/&/ /^>0k JyS^ yylj* Sa^/al^ 17J^/~A' /Aa
 HnyPlT+A^*^ Mm/A #&*<>*?< a-ajJ) fx^lTj/S/^ xKa.Pah/^D
tfvAyy A /)/>£/: 0Ask J*#A£s*A6 14/d/ A/&&."
-aVqh/ 7//ft J/^/) Acki *££ 1/jjdY £A0AA/J) W^ /&,'*>

Receiving officer: Xl>7 ^      Inmate Signature Jn/V
Disposition: (DO NOT WRITE BELOW THIS LINE):

                       (eLo-cJZ^l Ju^sf-,      f J*'ou ^      . .
              _pb> ^wk.       ^^^yr .^-^"^p- ^ ^/U Plztz.
                                                   A7 -i—~

Date' "? ( IP             Time/,{f-2a
FILL OUT THIS REQUEST FORM COMPLETELY WITH&LI^OUR
INFORMATION AND PLACE IT IN THE MAIL BOX SO IT CAN BE PICKED UP BY
THE MAIL OFFICER. YOURREQUEST WILL BE DELIVERED TO THE
INDIVIDUAL RESPONSIBLE FOR YOUR PARTICULAR REQUEST AND A
RESPONSE WILL BE MADE BACK TO YOU.
         ^^            PeT/jAM A COPY U AAA / A,S~ A - ^
  {\U
^t^V:\ NMATE REQUEST FORM                                                               RECEIVED)
                                                                                         JUL 21 201/
xf.AsPK .PP                                                  sou
                                                                      _„ ,
                                                                     5 72/
S^      --EE
                   v£^?l                            From: /U/7P/,Ajy ( <,)AimA.A<.
                                                          (last naree, first, middle)

        Date: ?-Jjf)-/?T\™s.:              Block:    /f            Cell:    £_
        Message or request:            ^
        X AAv£^ WAe>f£ &£)£ VAA/CA AAA ,AaA/)7AT£- ft.£&)£sl
        AAAA) E A£\/£A y-,£.ETHM BACA a*/A A< „»,j*»,JZjI *mD
        A/i/c/u/^j/E/TAaYaA t\e£M/s~ rxAfkAA^i ama*«^ n**A
        EAAAA< , PEvaJj^MaiAIEaA: , AAA AaA„a£ Ana* a//, j a ATAy ft/Anax/"7aa/a<, / r                                     ^a*,>A
        EATA£&fiA Stiffly, ak FaEA-'A a. aa£JS»aa?»PP*A
         EAVoIpA /^jA'0™
                                   INMATE REQUEST FORM

     ^•Cfi/ftA AM'/A*                                  —       From: ^^T~
                                                                     (Last. First. Ml)
                                                                                       V.,,,„, fC/"/L Ai~

    Date: ?-tf-/7                               Time;_^                 Block:    A           Cell:     XE
    Message or request: jf /^/g/? SEE <.A- AY{/aA.A?AA,£ /EoA.
    £#£J^-A2.o*#.- Ta?SaA                                                    ^        ^

   sl—AaZJ7a7aA A,aaA Aha WaaaPaEjx&y_aviEA
   A// A7A>/a7kaP Aaa/a/) /VP,AAA^AAXyE,YA7Ay<
    Zf>E< SAAh7AA7*A7^ PE/)a* & U&Aa^ AtK/1?.^
    McnAz/Pi                                    —LTaaxaE >e^ !
    Receiving Officer:                       V^—-V f   p*     Inmate Signature:   y/7yt/
    Disposition: (DO NOT WRITE BELOW THISLINE):
                                                                                          0?l tyrwD cY^uyZoO/y^
                 LP 6A<. /gg pjy^ pjxg__ -^rYUjahht ^jLCUttj gS                                  -»J-

    Date:                                      Time:             By:.
    Individual

   f!ILL OUT THIS REQUEST FORM COMPLETEL YWITH ALL YOUR INFORMA TIONAND
   PLA CE ITIN THE MAIL BOX SO IT CAN BEPICKED UP BY THE MAIL OFFICER
   YOUR REQUEST WILL BE DELIVERED TO THE INDIVIDUAL RESPONSIBLE FOR YOUR
   PARTICULAR REQUEST AND A RESPONSE WILL BE MADE BACK TO YOU.

   Y:^£ZPRI^T^SHERIF^JAn.y^\1ATTI^E0UEST4«                jfj / //7^ *7/f u A^
                                                              J

                      MATE                   UESTFORM
                                                  sou XPJZY

1o:$jJ@<>£ ,y JXc/t/C                    From: AayTJ^a/a A S,s4fJ>fJr/€£
                                               (last nameffirst, middle)

Date: ?-J/-f? Time: f fyfl Block: A                     Cell: A
Message or request:                                     L,                 ^—
J". TXAE Ao           DudoA      A ^U .jz//t>UAi£A AAS
S,E<, ffo>/?. Aaj,As,AA" TaVaTS.^A AqXA
 SnK Ay .AAA)AA AaEsX ^ TAaA ,A XAA
 P 'fA/PE'A-A ,+a'A ^/yYaj^EAJ So Pa, aEac-/
 A.A, AvnEAA/hytX^ Ce,'/>'7~A-AXA) Aau/vax uAX<.
 c.fi// P/AA Pr>rt,' PPP ,/t/vS 6r~E~~ypAA/s/hE
   s
Receiving of:                   ate Signature S fi/\/ iX

Disposition: (DO NOT WRITE BELOW THIS LIN£):

  (J]A^i °-^ ^~^- aI^aPAat^ ae^pt—aCf*-                            77
  cr^-AXA-^     &^—t^.   )c y\^^y9^   A~>~   r^/t-TZ.

Date:   l/nfn            Time: /¥*»               By:

FILL OUT THIS REQUEST FORM COMPLETELY WITH A]
INFORMATION AND PLACE IT IN THE MAIL BOX SO IT dsAN-SE PICKED UP BY
THE MAIL OFFICER. YOUR REQUEST WILL BE DELIVERED TO THE
INDIVIDUAL RESPONSIBLE FOR YOUR PARTICULAR REQUEST AND A
RESPONSE WILL BE MADE BACK TO YOU.
                          ^                               W&*£ RAaAA
                                 INMATE REwEST FORM
/ las-
                                                                               so.# JT7J? 
 ^••Phj[)(^                tffrfrs'? "fib ^/?                         Time:-               Block:   ^          Cell:     s4

 Message or request:JtJ/y&& />1y ^^/M^5 Im^/^^Vi,^., A$?^. rdZ^/jy ?/J*a& f*ss^<
/£kdtP-\lA\>/i.t^ t/i/M.. iaSa~> svxs• ^A,h^//y^/hjy/> yCsx/<^/) ! *~Ts s-

Wfa "l€Wr CcJ&Tp^T^ Ah/d />)/> Yt^TTlv aA hzTyyiyP
 Receiving Officer:                        (^ j^L^\_ Inmate Signature: /&AlA)X
 Disposition: (DO NOT WRITE BELOW THIS LINE):

£>ate;                                     Time:           By:
Individual

FILL OUT THIS REQUEST FORM COMPLETELY WITHALL YOUR INFORMATIONAND
PLACE ITIN THE MAIL BOX SO IT CAN BE PICKED UP BYTHE MAIL OFFICER
YOUR REQUEST WILL REDELIVERED TO THE INDIVIDUAL RESPONSIBLE FOR YOUR
PARTICULAR REQUEST ANDA RESPONSE WILL BE MADE BACK TO YOU

Y .F.ZPRINT.SIILRIFFJAjmNMATE REQUEST 4m
                                 INMATE REQUEST FORM
                                                                                                       S.O. # sT?j<¥
  To: CA^y).                                  %S^CAyA_               &AL ?™^-£pT2L^    , J^Jri£k^yJTO^^^f^
                                                                              <\£sPpfo/X\)  ^

  Date: ?*~& -/ ?                                  Time:-T ASS                      ujf rf-                     Cell: A
  Message or request:            aUax+- yn^T Z~ JLaA*. Apy*ctJ\A 0. /a
            /A /A/i  CCAlp'
               /E/<> ccAipA/uf aaA aEEPPaiaaAAs.
TEaaAA AAA /<»&- AAA) otAAAS

S -AD.s/2.

                   AfAJp/Ai                  AYzy
                             3 oEp

 FoA. Aj J)aVA L~ Ttf/hTL t)v MoTKAfAfr AM/TM'tAffr
  Mz^AtfD I~M&f&Mte bfiit/&- An/ V#//a*$
 0/t /£ Ucfc- rP &*& W-A//Q/U6- A3 ±l&aAa$ Z A/yhpd &>Ai A/Jd iWfig/£/Z C-ZT

  £/£*//£& ^e&ji/h/ CAfej AyL}A£d) A^P^y/hy X&jfaf/ 4//tf£k2*                   T
^P Aa%£a//>a¥&/u7~~

,4xJj U> j/eFoF tfA/yP £/y5y%JaZ &f'7^Kfip> 6yt7?-Ay(P£ CccwTy JP
 k/4p* A^fro/feJ>A-/vJ>h/te *//3<*jl/])'tffg. FoM^J^y??.^
jf-.0'2> A&tCsjs£A /OAS (A/feJ) opJEyZ A^>J) opyZfLl' ya?JA a3a?APJ> )V/k>
 JEEtptP// yvjJ/f 0(7/ SA£ aKaVOUAEA^ 1 %Y^ P'vXjZ/P JaVaZ ScJiY/C/
 PaIIa Xx'AA xpteSiP- iYS> ., ///jZ S?C7 OOO* */&/,>£- W£*/T/& £/*£&
zoopy JoJttPjz. jr^/j) ytS J>yJ>/JcT^A<£,FYsoo/d^h /^ PyhL
TiJ/yAJy^ SoA/S&fty/ J>2> MoTJ$e>aU}> 4a/V/^V Ji^A^ Sia/^/CO/^^
7 /rA/AA'ftsiAA'T^
^T/A/xZ fit&H-rfi ficJyyty TttfiJi , stAYY CocaaT^AP /tet//£j>
 TjtArtsaFT
   a
            s**jc TM£ H&Aj1uC> Jjl HW£-r a/oTj £*&/
 6iY£A/ A// F.4c£ 4Ph /#/ FA/J)£J^^ //^ 77f/^i de<
             A)£AAY^PPEa,)a,^ ^//
              S3 An/ flXf
             AALaaA^. Jx    77s^/ -;?XX

E EAA//-^ Prn/A/AA «A_P_{
                             ^
           \

                             ^
           >s
                                 ^

     ^     g^
     <£!                     ^1
      ^
     e5
                        TV
n1

               1
                   1$
     vi2                                 ^
     v

     <:            1                     ^
                                         ^

     H         X

                                     3
               ^
                     qraa'6£- Ccu/vTy DijsT/titT' cojpCT
                       PA(a/L £L a>A m
                              6 of ^

ATE FuB6£ MnM/A                                &?-/? V ?

                 /DoTjcA     fo/L   ttEfiAjy/As
                To F//LB     l,fi}v/£sZ
               AAr/J S/JaaiV czAusi^
    CRUS/Z- fr      I) /'2An?$y
                                                   ,i __
 X MftfoAjy A^Yb'SJ/AyAyzAs ypy/y sAa>a TAaJ , -J-         AsW
  fi£/A6> MzytJjgA kxAjj A/y a. s, coausF/FTjA &&tfF"j$)t
  DAATfftrFTnOfrr. HfiHF As/A Aflnyyyjp T Ka^y, "y\0
  /)£///Ak of M £P//0£/^£jy' jyiA Af?1A- AFzpA- cAils/Z
  /Jt>'A/MA FAaF~*wy£jL AS Wd// A.J, ^AAysA AA$ syyVj/
   Us£h FAsLtPFAyils' Fe> FPss> AyyA M/hASj FJiATFt SjcX A^'J)
 . AJff T /%£ A/MM&Al Fa.y.FAAJ/ Aai/jaA^ aP/aT YV'A<>
  keT$n/jffl Th/.o Jf/yAfAA Ey/f, Aa/A $aA< I X HAAzP
  ASK FaaPL cZd/yFs *F AJFAVyJ)aA}aAI) AaE/S A-AAaS/)
  TTiUf tifryrfh, , jjJL&fc* , A//PAsTTja** , A/A ip/Aaa<
  M F£Aa/ jjcT~/fA\y£-
 A fox/ J T/ffiTX- Jf/b diisT&^r^ijT^#F FAlStVO A^YiS
 Jo)3 AjUl) L.-:.-:A--S$m
                                       In The

                                Court ofAppeals

                    Ninth District of Texas at Beaumont

                               NO. 09-17-00292-CR

                     IN RE ANTHONY LEON SUMMERS

                              Original Proceeding
                 260th District Court of Orange County, Texas
                           Trial Cause No. D170078-R

                          MEMORANDUM OPINION

      Anthony Leon Summers filed a pro se petition for writ of mandamus in this

Court. See Tex. Gov't Code Ann. § 22.221 (West 2004); see also Tex. R. App. P.

52. Summers complains that the trial court has not addressed pro se motions filed in

a criminal case in which Summers is represented by counsel. "[A] trial court is free

to disregard any pro se motions presented by a defendant who is represented by

counsel." Robinson v. State, 240 S.W.3d 919, 922 (Tex. Crim. App. 2007). A trial

court does not abuse its discretion by failing to rule on pro se motions in a criminal

proceeding in which the defendant is represented by counsel. In re Kellum, 307
S.W.3d 336, 336 (Tex. App.—San Antonio 2009, orig. proceeding). Accordingly,

the petition for writ of mandamus is denied.

      PETITION DENIED.

                                                         PER CURIAM

Submitted on August 29, 2017
Opinion Delivered August 30, 2017
Do Not Publish

Before McKeithen, C.J., Horton and Johnson, JJ.
                                       In The

                                 Court ofAppeals

                     Ninth District of Texas at Beaumont

                               NO. G9-17-00389-CR

                   ANTHONY LEON SUMMERS, Appellant

                                          V.

                       THE STATE OF TEXAS, Appellee

                    On Appeal from the 260th District Court
                           Orange County, Texas
                            Trial Cause No. D170078-R

                           MEMORANDUM OPINION

      On August 10, 2017, the trial court sentenced Anthony Leon Summers on a

conviction for driving while intoxicated. Summers filed a notice of appeal on

October 17, 2017. The trial court signed a certification in which the court certified

that this is a plea-bargain case and the defendant has no right of appeal. See Tex. R.

App. P. 25.2(a)(2). The district clerk has provided the trial court's certification to

the Court of Appeals. On October 17, 2017, we notified the parties that we would

dismiss the appeal unless the appellant established grounds for continuing the
appeal. No response has been filed. Because the trial court's certification shows the

defendant does not have the right of appeal, we must dismiss the appeal. See Tex. R.

App. P. 25.2(d). Accordingly, we dismiss the appeal.

      APPEAL DISMISSED.

                                                       HOLLIS HORTON
                                                            Justice

Submitted on November 21,2017
Opinion Delivered November 22, 2017
Do Not Publish

Before McKeithen, C.J., Kreger and Horton, JJ.
CHIEF JUSTICE
STEVE MCKEITHEN                          Court of Appeals                                        CLERK
                                                                                       CAROL ANNE HARLEY

JUSTICES                                     State of Texas                                      OFFICE
                                                                                                SUITE 330
CHARLES KREGER
                                                                                             1001 PEARL ST.
HOLLIS HORTON                                 Ninth District                            BEAUMONT, TEXAS 77701
LEANNE JOHNSON                                                                        409/835-8402   FAX 409/835-8497
                                                                                    WWW.TXCOURTS.GOV/9THCOA.ASPX

                                           November 22, 2017

           Anthony Leon Summers                       Michael S. Marion
           #02151376                                  Assistant District Attorney
           Terrell Unit                               801 W. Division
           1300 FM 655                                Orange, TX 77630
           Rosharon, TX 77583                         * DELIVERED VIA E-MAIL *

           RE:     Case Number:             09-17-00389-CR
                   Trial Court Case         D170078-R
                   Number:

           Style: Anthony Leon Summers
                   v.

                   The State of Texas

                  Enclosed are copies of the Court's Opinion and Judgment in the above
           styled and numbered cause entered this date. The appeal is DISMISSED.

                    Tex. R. App. Proc. 48.4. Opinion Sent to Criminal Defendant
                   In criminal cases, the attorney representing the defendant on appeal shall,
           within five days after the opinion is handed down, send his client a copy of the
           opinion and judgment, along with notification of the defendant's right to file a pro
           se petition for discretionary review under Rule 68. This notification shall be sent
           certified mail, return receipt requested, to the defendant at his last known address.
           The attorney shall also send the court of appeals a letter certifying his
           compliance with this rule and attaching a copy of the return receipt within the
           time for filing a motion for rehearing. The court of appeals shall file this letter
           in its record of the appeal.

                                                               Sincerely,

                                                               CAROL ANNE HARLEY
                                                               CLERK OF THE COURT
cc:   Judge Buddie J Hahn (DELIVERED VIA E-MAIL)
      Vickie Edgerly (DELIVERED VIA E-MAIL)
      Kellie Derouen (DELIVERED VIA E-MAIL)
      Judson Daws (DELIVERED VIA E-MAIL)
                  IN THE NINTH COURT OF APPEALS

                                  09-17-00389-CR

                              Anthony Leon Summers
                                         v.

                                 The State of Texas

                                On Appeal from the
                   260th District Court of Orange County, Texas
                            Trial Cause No. Dl 70078-R

                                   JUDGMENT

      THE NINTH COURT OF APPEALS, having considered this cause on
appeal, concludes that the appeal should be dismissed. IT IS THEREFORE
ORDERED, in accordance with the Court's opinion, that the appeal is
dismissed.

              Opinion of the Court delivered by Justice Hollis Horton
                               November 22, 2017
                             APPEAL DISMISSED
                                   **********

     Copies of this judgment and the Court's opinion are certified for
observance.

                                              Carol Anne Harley
                                              Clerk of the Court