Court Opinion

ID: 4044301
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:34:14.875518+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:29:50.609142
License: Public Domain

IJB“. _ gg/Q©U'OZ

E" 7’?"[°" § a:s:l¢»:: :);;>:;/.::F
;)\\\B'U'\‘S{\ /l?/\»\W\'n) RECA-M l
‘TDCD' /\)o, l‘)/%Bo \ § couRT oF chMlNALAPPEALs
§\ ' ' APR 17 2015

 

' , . , ' , , - Ab , ,
/dpthm§/S E)r\§ma\ c©b<)a@/‘Flm 110 Z//'-»pélif .e| gsé?$m kabeas
gvél-"”h?.).?“rjqané_go V/A@(d(,@)gp{, //,07 3 ¢1{,:1£,/:‘, Co/os'r".,
Ame/~)D,,. /_) /'7¢;@@/;[@[ §/}aczs§ »é) @vr{'$ BM\ H~o§l/ProW/'m

 

"To 11/1€ //o,\/OQA$LE :)’u$T,/ce;>' oF Cz)UK/‘T' oF£i€//~A//\ML A?‘?”é>¢?i,$ pFTM§ .-:
games /1/01,3>. ’:>';kna#)a/) Qu {:me¢/‘i/ 4030;- ijm /ls /\/07' A/J
' mm€?; bj¢é, wl)kw é/aas wm 710 M/@> _M,j_§ -/1¢077@»/ ,/;.~Wi/j,
C‘””"$`£TM@O/ 170 _?@Mlé/ncf /}9/0 scls` -FQ\/<>\$`,,. Se:z, ;,/'/6)//)@$ 1/ ,&n@/;
4’@4 ¢/,§,5/9, 32 5 c,,/, 5€¢/, 30 L,ez/, 2d 453 ~__,
habeas C’UU 257 a<>é/@m
471/ls /Y)pf/fcé/n€ Bkna‘n%en “?ug:l:nb£/§/’v%<§@ j CW)C'$ 1/¢
%z 248 § 3101 fcia/l ':Dl's{ricé L'm)r{; sp /'/é’rm”s ,co.,,'/ZXQ\S ¢L>/%
'#/;S j$%é~'/' habeas Qa»{v‘¢/n, came nol /3 ‘75’ 314-4 ~ 157 \@¢/
¢;, mma z@/§," wa _,LA¢ %/§m'$ ¢@, 1935/w cl@/)<» cms
‘®eni@l//@/ Fren\<\fn -’P~<'>, 34 4@5//,%1).:4%,@@§ ‘772.1@~%.<.~/,_ `

t 713 ‘57'#7'5': orueu/\/A£'Aw/Smei°; of /V`MMH zo/_s"/,@S*
ml:§cm§évued C/al'm$ ag /QHQ}{¢Q/l-é§ 5 w;#»ow‘)’ elm/wm 143
c@mw£_ M,%f/> 1/¢\@5@ YM/Jow/'W£S_; %@ Swm:
l'/)@/'Lw($~$ &wéro\)efé@@/ issues 9)"10[ 'F?WFS , wAi`@/L\ 115 0/3/'/»'\@/
143 bc aheaan C@/iél@/'G@) §§ J/A@ 577‘*75¢- 7//1<€@@\¢
dwéro\l<¢!‘{:€@[ ‘w£é<‘/‘¥§) %36 'Frzz IJ,/mz~S’O/U@o/ -pec>/ch/ b&$£s
g 133 C/@§?/£z,§y § 443 QFP)@,\J¢:< @m£'n¢m£’;,w)];% ,;,
.<~¢.@sm .L>/ a Lz)'"@,¢z;f@w' 3'13@6'@@_,kw@’ nwf.~ g `
‘ %,%/c#/\/fs 33 je:cr/@~/ '
_ _ AW/)'azné’s ‘ObJ¢¢F/%o _,é éw.élsjv¢opw@ gwin/gs op WCT’..);
5(.@`%;@( m 24 MM _zo/§, 3¢,00§;&3/ fn 77(\"53, mart bi><;w%
Qrs~{'*o\`e.<“s /f)o)+e§¢ §)@/1331'@/ fm 5%¢_&‘33 3 )'\QS nO-L~@/C/, had g
'de§@'.m“é (?Zno{zfea{ 0100»’))';, ba£;>:`z »[/A@ ['UU[LT;§ D@@g
go grme --l@ ;'€w¢%¢¢CZJM/MHL %FFNS oF 75>@¢);€_777'1¢/5,
6'3¢/5//>5 Un{:@fV`/{) mg v~@!{cfa/ {me;érr{é/l% 1[@»0211>( -#\LS
AH@ /'Cgmé ,. 57777@_ OFM~$i h€b¢€$ duffl¢<\$_ frOQ,1>\¢’ 591-113 §111:.-111111+
3'°500¢ 3 volé;én~‘agp\@’,. 5501‘11'\1'115 533 been walmeal 33
655€0)1'6315\5 :@tigin@l 0295&05/’31..-§31\05 91® ej<"; unless me
5>01»505 '001}1\£ 553 333> m331"¢§ 15@1“®31;`51'/3§ ` op _5\319@€5 mead 1'./,35>
Q~,S 311 #Nswef"»_» 5)55510 5511`5 AW/ 562/1555 O~\Q\Semgw’); 5`€¢
<`e?{)e$’é:'j#\@';§)/@{/§£ 5 " v " ° w ‘ l

7) 131/5053/13"2@ 5@3'1`1/15 ,2`)"®1'6 couerj 1/`)'€0§;5$ SDFP¢OOQ“O(L[W]
ahd'fn§femL/% expvaer 315 mikva 'i'»>/C&or{: m1'51351 `7r1'35 633-b 71“31~13'1`{>3 , 35 <55\<'>¢ £UU¢T r_¢¢ofd?$~memo's 5>'®0¢1,(,1@_.
‘~33¢3 e){o¢@v€$z 313 1/3155433?/0 05 53553/10'#\57 , e5c11... `
' _ /\/0.551//\5 5135 325£/)’17(01?3\/7 035e1’12051`/1 -551115 5)3;5e3§ 3>5?/)7,
15111),-511@£1>@5/13 M> 553 9€1>,’"€?“5' 536/1311 553 55‘@
§‘m’l€$ 031/5 311193)110€)`§55\3 i/)e§Ql¢'§ § 5`15~5 émffnemen"éj 11)5\<23
%e'gqg¥.é 313_(;, 1135 43115@1)”/, 225»/1331 20/5, 1115 \0351235
1 1131>»<1 5“'l>aiéme13@l kaye 333 " 1110 451-1133 333 OF -
5 M 1 '“"`55‘0\* “ ¢¢1@€1'1'¢3»5$‘ 5055<:05/39 3 ewers 1311)“1>11\16$* 1336

CU.\5 1031 r> 3/1'53’13'3:7 5\<;2(1`/\5 313
` »/_D[$ao\d@rj /F./@cs_z§$ § 012-55\1’0 _~//511“_5 013 55@’1'/@,\/9 _755,3-{» we,fm

1131155\¢/1/+()1,133311315 rm\05e:`e<>l 30 §>\051\1"5{1 _5_5\@(@{0,._

1

7*`/<1/+1_ wom- 1015/plugs

/?31533/13 50 %A&@U,)Q,Ar{jeale l/:.O'Y)' I// /»,;1,@¢;,< LWF“S
i553e.5 muir -I>e 1050/bed fn 553 T¢~j’a/ §,_,,r~r_) b¢.l;,{-@ PiM',/UJ
35 33 131 ha eaa/veal 315 ,e¢a»med@€a,.$ 1933 y
5:@"““°5@5 5"'" 550 1'@'<>05 50 »550’ fwva 1515 CmM)/QAL 3%%: 5
05`“'1’91”30 In. 553 #le'QQ/zé'$ i'/)>'izn,~é) no, )3'7<% 2314 ( 211/835
”Dz`sérlL+ 31.)(~5 35 kf/'grrfs @0_,)"1/@<3$>) hc@w$ wm ), gm 3m
m@"j -?@'"w@ 3091-011va maker/al -!0 553 /05011'!3 »5`
A!,o//'CQ/"é/¢S M£Emm'é »-':/_:r) 10511'051 .) %e$e; Cw),/Ya:/Ve;f{'ed
/'SSHCS need 5 be (‘e;olve@/ i`/) 45510<7’¢1'3[ Ay»r{: 1/;3 3#}’013~?£:)
050500?51'0»$,1}1/5@¢/033751/1'@, 3105 an 301'313153@ 5130€7/§; 5:>1`3
535 5 3111/5 1530 1`1'§.51‘5'. 050 7:,»'@3-35)7 %@ Mr£§..,,d,j, @’,4,
001\15'/’41141:13'1>5./)/`¢/¢_' - 1 ' 5 * ' '

 

jrflv*% ome/nme Ay\/$@oa€"`

 

‘ "Me: 553£05>01\01 hale eva‘§me~ believe;’bj /15§ pure
3@’"6511_§/"0/)') 13 145/1315 553@>530[ e/faie/)<:e'~ 05 313 ‘)Ci'nd 515/1315 ,&vmcl
was eLFmL)H/e @f 510 359 51"@@/1'5 /@05:005 015»_ 550#‘¢@”; 1'/1
.M@ 57131*5£5 0361/1//1¢ /41~151)113<, w)\€f¢ 510 §fW’E/]p/M'O\eo/
€>(#/BITS , 521 550 CUD.,lCV,.'“/#ESE &<17‘133/7: stw

l I 1`}¢§2{/71)/@¢@{)0@$ 5 577‘)‘7'63 9<'#/7¢23’/7' /4 f gm emerme
pf'°Sf/D€R:|' wman oF c@/JSTI/'MTIO»ML 2116#75) %KEM&;,T .TD

sm m/,A»re,#m> `FMD»¢i/H_ cw/F€ssi¢>~ " /\[g,z)"zs¢§§$@z ,. 77¢/5

` WA]VBK '[5 j¢¢é@#{,;*po(:¥A}g§O/LL?[@ f`|(g/\+S cC/ZWHO‘€ b@ »

wafv@r)@m w ;~w.~ MU'€; rmpz¢ m@é@b"@ 041 +¢WS@
<\\'S)\‘€S 115 004 510'500@4 3’\34 \*@emoé ha L'O@W@/ of ~14<;)¢-4-`¢’¢£@/,.
}<1<1:564\' ruich \/é §=éa‘bz.,_‘il) 5@2.»>{ /5(¢,.. me@rc; ~[/Af_$ ;FM'. 75
»M lam‘é'/J,Ji'gr\eol @-@ixk/:r, 15 \/ou) ¢m ;-‘}5'15&¢§,,. ZL)}\;,;@Q;;
~@\ ONLY cvi‘o\& Az‘sm wwgf<’] .‘5“01.’¢;@! aw.\€¢§$im’,_-~/P)¢Q.s@$@,
AC/l£'\@r¢ V, s+@%¢:,§€s 5@204 éBc,z,@/)£ S~Mz:vj ‘"'If 7!//;;;§
¢jwq,'dg{ w.`€’¢$;im" was -Mc @nlj wider/me in _,§A¢ m¢¢‘,~¢/(,
wcc would .k@\r¢ ~é@ .szL/MO(C ~é¢\él£' '[¢a: C'uide/)¢@ ¢03_<; ,’/,..
-5¢,¢-@§:10,&@4 40 514$€21!(/) c'? émI//'l‘/~é/?Y)M. g)C»L)/'LGL /Q;owc

. ,él\@ 657;97€5 oa\é]/d,¢;/L, ANSM>erL’) is 3 nq~ewm\z/){/j Qm@{'@/

4

3"\'@’“ m€”‘é<°/l 54<`>1@“'*\¢”'5 »~`4'~5; ‘SM &-»W-S Ex'l~'ib#:> ,,.clwlg 511@_»»$ -£A;é “QICF@AM
Q(,(§ZH',) )GT>'L»A@U`QA QWMJ w;l’i\ 040"@€0_048/»4 was -H\C '6.~/\<;

1040 @X@QMJCCA __.-44¢°».$. 04060\'¢1\¢04,6&)141\/@& 060 QOQSWWT[WML
R\QGPT`S, H*é(§ée’/vla$s' Tbi‘“SWM/-ME,,M CY\)\\)\Q,\AL coppeg;m,j"_~j{:$
vis a 'Qn'm\"n@l` 0¢;4 r.";//@<é’$/P@Q/{ 5000 §‘3‘37,105’/.'00|00/?7€7 4
10':44 éw\)c):mmvn~€;»l faceij '>_ 633 533 ,__"T/)/'.S §§ch w\»\.'uv§i»~;] -/@ 4rle 403 F,‘M“j'$ 3“‘4_, CO\)NS¢/é,

gei\wm 710 -50@»@~ 9~4 ”Ff°l@”(' *M‘gjc W`L”°(“+T d§kjc;[:$"

’ v\‘§k¥ 40 z&';u\)¢\.$vc/;_

\

5ij _»',@ 1;/:/\¢;6@0/2/@,, 500 140 10 115+20>;/0000%@; ,

34 9,£,[ ):3',"-/-`] %~/,)n\/._lun'/.'Q,Cj,}o;<:aa_$c 04\

i.;\@Pwa"u/c 355?540/)¢@ 04: awn$@/`,-'/
3\'\1¢ iff 543 \”\S['vk 749 2 4"4(24 ,. %l.'§ A@/nm§%rg;\-@'$_

0"~4331(‘,3'./\¢§)`0§ 1`\1,;')40 1

gov n$¢) `[5`

jn@Mi_1%$. 01_
2,@ 52 ;_*'74¢’§* Cdv\_V/”ch)M . <10/»¢\04 legally-60 _¢040~6¢@04;
.9/\04»~/%4'4$`1/ bc `0`\)®¢'74(460@0:{',__' j ` v .‘ ' \ '
'C@MCLM 510/d
zD/t@ 710 ~[/}\0$<6 .i/\$€@/\Qz$ OQ: 00 wmqu 710 sade/10
6 amufc/F{m, Co L/ man 76 C‘éux ' 5600 76 `0{~07%»0040071)01, j

jj_[@'§@l{j gm(:im’n§ 440 0\0$0/~019>\4 lusing¢‘;3¢0001.,¢.\0»\415
gm-Q@o( §od\S§ 2/\<>q . fr\Z) 5<7@040 `WQO?0 Wm\/io\@{ 40 440 '
&\T*g@@\@f\& -,"5>:)'\§~‘3® @r\cg /pro-lz:C/~('@Oe 105 440 ’F¢)C£S va"§%-.¥
-,`4,<'42'0/) .>.L{,S,['ms'%lJ/w/_'fmal /¢}70000€$. 6). H,_ 500 620 10 M,,g,)
_ 322 § 204 ‘7_‘?00- 74~0(04;0»@\204. 4303-n 9450}“-710 m3 /\{_ 110
CW"S@/> ”") 933 5“"<1" F‘§k+ 149 C<>W\Sd )ZS 501-4;¢00{~3'¢0@0404!
49 04“@~?(0€»<5$$ 44\34 134 /:5_0.10/1:9@‘60.67 upon -4{,\¢ 5.(.3.€@5 bj '~
662 V;\)Hé@e/)#) Avr’lC/)odw\mé ,_, #/\/D; #H;S' /:5 _%C
1 600 why 40 203 000 000 04 1040
’ C,du,,\lcj)”l'@)\@ l\/O‘?:] 7@)(<4,5~ STP¢‘,~€ }7@§,@€3 4
C§(»Qvl§ ~'P(O'C,P@@LS` 070/03 0%0+ 440 J;z)
000 40<¢00;000:; £\/¢~1>00/40> )40¢)@»0 000 ,7-5 `
“\>\5@0)@§3>:] alma 6 )weh’i€$ /i)romU/-/?l§». AW/fcem§ 1500 l
044@ 730/610 Cf/\)(LT ..(,00\)\0\' 004 ud?,n{' Q/[[ _.H»@, ,H@gc/,//’ 37./‘@,;,,£;

L;,,% _H\¢ mc§a\ §§ Co»\)vich'z'o,\¢ ;m{ savin/mfg egpo$@/
fn ..H@ Z¢B"§i‘/ '”D)`s%b)'c/+ @m)\"‘l: 66 §’/SN"\S wa\§j ,'I'ZXaS § 565
~§”§\¢ §)W|icen§ paz/§§ -§;m>@,&>\_.,'b@@@ \\is lam pan added
Hl@§ :)\l'\i packard 523 _“‘5'@'§ ZZS"F> 1\:));>@25 cwpr \l'q~|§\€
>.~ L,z, 5,'\>_,:5§.:§+ gm (§ §§ AL§ iéw§§§n ®r§a¢.'¢§ § TQX@S> gi-

. h§~svbg§jé 3;\\,` SH\%/QMHKMTDC;X /Jo¢. )§"I 44 80 ,/P({A‘,)§ .`M;\§
@o\>ru <§§K§/\/zmc€ @§%11)~ F»w“'<>"'@/ mr 5 wl , 6 614/07
%;§ AW),-C€,\J¢ },r§ L)‘| amf §§r gm AZQ,MMW _€m',_
` ~C@OI/°n§ wi~"’§§ mma/d Le@/{L§> vér)'@) cla/orr w%§§\j'psreuawoa&§_

7%@'@ D/STBMJ/b}l£$ `5_//'7§¢£ DQ(>L&DE,`BW+~$@\' \\'r§{.+@@{ -/9 :
}:§¢l/ end \z9'»r E\/¢'ai1`~§'§\ no ]l'm)'+@+/;HS U€U”I “/’§@

"Hoap)fc§/r§‘$ m¢lw@.§§f 5 @QDR)AE ~//£a Z‘f$ij’"D/'S¢H'c'/?£ '

CUU\U’) u€m Cwnp`}@élm §§ VWLZF¢`/\§U) 0\¢70<>5'179¢:/)5‘) amb(w[‘§r)

 

v @,\C`A gmb¢wo§§§%)r'¢§s ,~H\a§ CO/Lfl//(LT/o/\/ SMLL@EM,¢H>E
NMU, 14wa l/D"D_; c¢>\/IQK€ 0?774/$
.@m>A/v) FMHL M‘/J cM/wré€ oP :msT/@€ -AL/\)‘D c,¢)a$€ A¢c
@@>§@s; w 5<)<»~7§: Fem wm own 7@ /,z§@~,» wm

UWQKCUAMTY €>K m oil 7%¥45/ 29¢8§5®15'7)21<2’ dwsz
EMOK.S oF Febewl'¢ A)?a) MJD Com.sT/mT/o/\W_ wang .,

55wa LM/l§ /371_§
0§9/ §§ ,Qpn’| 20/5“_

 

.LIM/HES w&LAMrlo/Q
628 u§c § !‘7%)

-'-_', jc')\~n'zk\§§?i /\2»\§£'0§‘£/¢)/4/(@80 010 \f\¢"¢bjDE/CME; WW(@/` l
<;PC'nQ/\‘\j ¢>S;*'pcrf`)u§j)-H\@§ @¢rj%¢?»$ in ~#\Is Mo")’)o/J )_s Ti&vce’
/§An> Coazm}§%§b@s§ §§ mg §>@h'@§._. '

§§ijaMn_M;_-`_

%:,§MM §§M§
@(‘/5 25‘8'££‘®1`§?210;' Cdup:r 09 H,¢¢,z(; /DE@LM@ANT/SHY€H+SQ

C°~;TB)H€` `
_’_:' j>\/\na'§’f’\;°/\ ?uq;n '[DC`J//§o §9/4§)80 30 \l/\C@bg C{;`KWF§J

_Lb})@.(§ @/ /72,1,(5’ H/\JD @O£K€C' QO)DZ} ag /Ql/yp //C?/r§$ Or\§me{

053@§&/,,/, 112 L//>§'§ f §§g/§§ eha @@h""m has beam
P§\,;< 923 591§#§2 Z‘/B‘l'/”C)'S%f/v§ ['w(§ §§ §z§rm a-)\)n§j,” /@>< ¢/@5//

7L/01/S7?>/1 //`@W'§ WOZ/O 495/j §§5 §:`CS§"C/\Q$$ /1>(@»‘0204`0<)%23@
Ul'é?- g)(cSc/V) me'¢'/ buy ¢§\@)0¢>5£*§<¢0§

Xwn;M/,%,J /3@ §§ QM@H@;M

cng § §p(z| 20/5/ _ /O*“‘“’§“@~(§u§~,£n /€/%30

 

/§>¢lé ié/W\qu)( 0 5a