Court Opinion

ID: 4052185
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:56:19.195574+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:05:33.790582
License: Public Domain

£5)5155 5`/52. 533¢/'/5~’5/57 /f 85 Qg@ »()I

‘ ii /7)1275 l 5 .l',z/ 7’//5' /`ZZ ”"D D/:s?m~'? £5»5157
7 z ' 5)5” '
772/2555 ,D/m`s, 3 /7115513 foy-1171 75st
A/”z”/"g"M RE<:EWED m

couRT oF chMlNALAPr-‘EALS
GCT 01 2815

 

vm555,,`,/.47;)/52//;'5"52/55/:555E..Q¢//[L...Zij.75575;?_£[2'£25./ " 5

11 '-»:.\".‘»S?ea,@@@zk

EL»A,/?/1'[5' .DM& 14' '55~111,//“5£5)_35 /1_/‘ 7/.')5. /;/05.'1"1/5 -.;~7!1'/5/
/_)5?5155'/ 5‘/5/5/'//%:) "/%5'§ /zféu //11/1 511/11/5 A511/51/55'5€5151~/ //1.////§ /7/75§75)/§'/'__'§
057/11//;/ 1411/5 )1./51 , 14/'0/0//5/)1///16//_6;111/ //75 ZZ///M//L;//// .'

. \ ll n .

Y%€£;.£LL)@:§i;ji-, /) 16/;§€/1111"/ 15 1,//|11,111/" /,”//////1/1»"///7/116/1//1//;’1’7//{//¥" 2£’5/£/1/»7£/
if /m' //2)51777/ /'A/ 7/'/5 f/zs/ £05551‘ 5/‘/%///, .L// 7/1/’5 ZD,~['._/. ;75)1 5153‘515111_’57//5-"
51575/5{/15//)51/ iv5[551/Z:1M5’5 W/7/75 /Z`/Z w /513575`/5.'7 /'51‘5/57 // /%1//5'1/ /2'511/;/1
751/55 /5/ [//5.'_55: 11'/57. /34!5‘/5/&.1 /Wi/ 147 775;;//¢/ 1@51" 175 1475 5’/11711{5// 5//§51751//

;ZA./L'>A¢vw// 112/555 1555;51~///1'/{[:1/51/ Z:’/) /'/,f///.S /111' 7%5 %XDW![?/
£/£/'/?!/’11151/ jw)/ :[1151/. M/V ‘ _
//_
/)/0/57/5511// 5/5)/051/55 1711/5/'//5'1//£< /F//A/_§A?/f$ 1/:’.{51//`51\ /11//1!<
imm/55 !/5/15'55/55 51;<;151516 //§51/5/5;5/5’ Z/' 7775._5'/51{’.) /£'5//51/ 1¢)5_5175/7&.5:»12/¢>5/
__Z-

/?/ L’//75757/ 55555`/ 117/75555/,1 ,A///2/751/1'1'15/51 /:/75:\2//// /A;5/1?5/ /15 %55577:5’ 5]1.5/(,5'
551/7/7551_/11///" 51//5/51/55 /5;511;5)'/515:5/ /5 //5/1'///1/ ,/}/Hf7755// ////5/1 /71 752/511/11/7
51/5/1/15»1/51/ 255/71

Z’f//}/ 775 §/2///”\ /E;ZS/ /}/5`1/11/ 77 ///°5//’/1!///' Z"j//?

'7/75 57777 [,':/5’111<11'51 77’/775/7j 51'1/ 575/51 /2`5 777}5175771751 777 %1/151/5?51/ 5/1/
._“[1/5225517'1/5 51'151 /5115'5 [//} 5751555/[;7575'5151 §555/ im 1775 /57/517 75//71/151//757
1/7/5/,)/1;5111// /7'7511/5/1111/ 117/111/57 /1”775)1.5 /`11/5/5 27 /75/551/1/17/1551/ 71/511/5/
77171555715>11/1/. 7/155/'1777, 551/712 ` ' " '~ - 1 5

117/5757/151515/3 77 '15715/ .' 7/75 57117.1" 57515111 51 //7/55 //111///75//5571// 5 /,./2/55>11/5' 525/1141
571/51 7275/7175 2751/1117 1117 511 /7/517575%15 /71/1'71555 I/ 51515555;

5§17//15_/'177511/57’7751// l//5)/17/77:11/ [77197/177/7575551///27711”/ 77//51/'5 //////

7 /7101/'5 2/757_//773 jim/755 57575577.17.1/5'5 575 %775'1’5// AZ/z/// [2??551055/_/7

575'/75'/5’15'51 /7/7’5€5` 715// 77/75 IU'ZYZV//L” [)/ /7/5"/5?/5//5//_7 §7_§5? 1 ,

111 /75`5 2710/15571715151 '~" ’ /0/1711112 77/177;11/ 711/1;/ 1551/512 1771152/;155151775

5//1/5 575/5/11)///////15;<5 /1/55 575/1 ' 77 55 5///11'11. /7/57/151515555, , /1)/15111 1/
2/5'55&5§/15)1/ 111//75/57 /1;775)1,5 /11/ 1775/77 /717/517511 1515 /./1'/7115//7151/5

3/15/`11/5/ . 555 1470//5511521 /7755/5>55/51111 5751‘5/ 1 5775 227/55

25]555/ 571/5/ 2/7: ]11//15171115//51 555/55/'"’”

 
   
 

(

    

,
,57'5’1 55

       

7/71;_§//1/5 [)///'/515'1 7/75/‘/ ///'5/757//5//5// 7//5/'/ 77.5£5111/ 7/1//1155/ 7//5/ /75/1/15"'/ 717/5‘:5'5'2/ l

2751/li /FZ//M/ 7/5////? 75/57»55./14/ /7./'!/5"377717//5'15/

.,Z_ ,

.7/7/7>/75575/3/ 77<70521515 .` 7/75'15 51 /1/7/11:1 555 /5’ 5 5 "5/ 57/?577, 5,55111/ZJ 5755755’11~11._51/1/151
735/17 4:/U5;/,"51‘11// 5755;5/ j _7)/5’/5_; H /'/555/l 755 771"5557~5/571911//5//
311/1515/ /5/55_)/5551/51/ 775 5755 15515551751/55 /7“57555/55 55/5/555/ _
771/75’1/757~/1 7755.05/ ///555/5"/551/5 575/551151/ .'/515/3 //115/ 777/5/51155 /71/5’/51551/
7/5/ /7’.0 1 777/11//111/7 57//5/ 71/55'55//75515515/ 71510////717155 /5755>15555/~/

$75571; 755/ims 1 7552/ 1775;/1'1/1/1::;55/ 7 515/5’// 775/7511/ 75 //”//1/./7/1///5 r//5'5J51)1;5 051/57 55/5/
755 75./1711755551.//51“ 5/575’5.1 757/5///551: 7551;1151/

' “~ ’ v . " .. z ~ '
/'}U/H //,’5‘/1.-/7_1"\ 75£`/‘5195/;<1; 1 755 77 //755: 1 5"7'5’5y 1";' 7’5/ 737 75 ////’7/051:‘"51"5//7_15v ,775%75>17151//',5/55/

775/55 /57//1/555// 775/1577 555/55 7/75511,75/ 7755//5/ 551/5 _
/711751.\1/555751/ 7//5 575/57 71/5/11/55151 1 §>151515/ 171/5’15/5/555: 515)11/
- 7 11 l t
/`5757711;51 /1'/51»/15511571 375 571/5 177515/57€57 5?/1751157575715/
777/575"15 511 755/7 7 7795511.1§5'/ //)‘}5/55/ 77 515/553 1517/71 755
77571 1175'55'51_1577/55/5;11 17/7557'15 z'57`11/1'5/ 751111:;/./5/75/1152/ ,
1155/151551111115171;1155 515/1
1111511111.1 1711551 7715111_115115111/151 1111

  

  

 

       

751575'1/7 1777/515./'/ 1£/55/1 7551751571//.) //755/57/ 577/575/1'5515/
_ 1 , ._ ,1 7¢/
5511171 515 1

555/ 751 571/51375/5:551/ 595/7511 /7/5/5»:' //'17'5”;’/'575115/511//
7/)£77/755//5577;71’\/ 577/755511.// /1?2/5:557-')155/5’5 2@5/557575175//'1’75)
751/5 5515/ 7/757 711/ 7/5: 75_15155 51/”// 75 /5 75715.

77 ' 151 55 ,5 7 511

   

75/71'1511 7 727 7 775 75 157/7¢1/'5 //

775_§1:17 777/1751 ` 777/17 727/15 7 77755 7 775 777551'5/771/17,57¢5// /7///77

7511/17 751/57 115/517 517/155 7771/7//5771/1/ 57 755/117 5// 77/ 777/5 755/5
775 _§7[1/5 7//5// 257 /7575. 71/71'155/77_>1'//575/ ”//

757//5,<'515/75 771/1551 775/23 731/7715577/5 7' 1151 11 /11_`57:1515/7 7715[5115

/"5'1575/5 717/52 /55 715555/17 71 755/17 /71',/ 5//515/ 5/51/ 151
711/11 775/151 571/1515 721//5 757 //51/ 755 751/757/5;// _:55. “
77 77a/7 277/7 /77§L/.3/1/_'>_5 7717751/?151555 775;4§77/5 [/M/%/

577ij / 57557/ 77 757 //7/5//7/1///11’7777/17/7775/7 771
/11/7/57 1151 // 711577/71/51/775 777/1//51/ 75/5/5 7 775 _/////5”57555// '

751/7755/7/7 5/11/ 775 757 527/577 777/717 755/j '////5//` l )//1'55 //7775/55///7/5///
771/57 775/1575 17 7775/55/ 775 777/75 77 h?77/5//55///_1 175

46554 7512/1 Vj/fo//

      
    

  

13 `;`_\.1_,._1,.1_ -,5., xi ..">
/ S";: ,A/ ' .5§-_'~55 '; _';'-3:~5._?;.,;`;§, »€»‘: .';T_
/

/1/; /111/11175, 1751/7 //71% 775/71 5/5557///75 7555
715/15 151/557 ,7‘_55151/75[/5/15/ 771’/750117”//7757 /75155/715//775
775/1555 74517‘517115 771/7711/775'555 155 71"'555/7 77755’5 //

755171551/ 7753~'1/ / /711515 7 751/5 775/7 775 715/57 77117/57155_ 55151555/

715/751/)15555 171 1177 777/17757/7 5175111/ 775 7 .75//5// 755/75117715 /51/5/
_L/: /7 77/1£ 77 }//515/5/ 7 7771//5//)5 //5/ 777/ " ./55175-/ 71177517//5/

   
  
   

555 51 55 5 555 5 55555 555-1555555555; /555:'5555555 55555 5//5"5555/555/
511/2213 //515//5’5//5/ /11/22/2// 711 7////2/5//// /// A[?//L///:, 75412 ./55/

7/55;'5 //555555555/55 //, 1555/2555 /55/5/2/2/510/5555///')5552155/515 //5255557515/

7/1/51 775/1571[/ 151/55 //5/%/[7// 1711 1515 5'5 ,//7 /7/1?./ 7 777 /1112/120’/5./ 77
111551/) //5 //15 ////51/_1 715/1 ///////4/5//

1151 1555555/ 1151/5 /115155/ 775/55 715 /5//1//55///5 51 51555 //101/5
1_1’15//51;/25’ 1 775 72//22/5'5/2 [/"/7/11 /:’5)2 712 / /////' 175:1/1///_////7/5// 7121’5//7//1///5//

71 . "1/5"1/5 5// 751/51 17 /55/7/5/5/ 555 ///,1/////2/ 1 ///7 ////515//15/5: 5

35 515/01 ' gj~;/i _ 55,[~;0 //,77

5_1>25 1552/111/5/ 55 %/1/5///557[5> ////////51 n l

1175 512/1 / 1251/515 %//AA/hz)2 7/2 /I/)/z//M/ 1/155 5)1/2///25/25/1///
5555555/5555 5 555 555/555 /5555/5 1555 55 255555,/55/555557
7/173 L<5 :7//1{1

_L/5/5/555/ 55 2/2 //5’/ 775/51 555 11 575 1//55:/5555 1125;525525 /15/ //5/55/555'55//
552555/5 555/ 1225/5 512/515 51/5/55'5//7 /// 55251/2 211/1155 755/55 )5555125/52 7/55/5/
1121 715 511/251 1122272/21 72/1/5///// 71 /1 25555///1/0/ 117/5172/5"15/ 151/551
112 15 /12/0151//2// 215/2/ 722/7521 72 /1// 2512/21 //2 '2/22

h555 5/52555557 /51/?;5 55/. 5/213'5_5

7/75 55717 [7//}553 772/// /W//[/,¢// /////7///7_)//5/5////1//5/ /1/}5/&'2//2/2/
P[f§§£/Z[/‘/ 17/11/

 
    
      

5%//[1/1/ /11/ 71 L>V///M 114 7AL1 151 /A/: _5`*1?1’ /17/$ ('”//’ 515/57 //L'/'/l/7j /77A1LM2/[//M b////
?/)////555// ////1% 151 /75/2/5 2155/57 ///5525/.5 /5121 /75/5/ ////1/@2///)2/

mf/[f[//]///’) / ////////j//// //5{///1/1/[11£ 7

    
    

Y"a": w
50 ,

 

__i// 7/77,/ 277-772 277.,» 2777/77777/_/ 177/73 777/77/77/,»._// 2277/273 7/7/77/,77/§,
¥/’/77). Dm/W/ 7777//277/'77772 77/ 22777/ 222/7 227 2777 277 222/7 //27/72//// _
/`/¢/27//77/:/ /27 2177/272 77 M/A_) 72///7///2~ 227 27/// 2777/2 ///'// 2252/2
725 /07/2/77/72//2£ 2%2/'/1//2// I/2/32 //2'/_5 2//221'7/27 27'/27//%[’/2/2/ 2777/j
_ ' . \./ j 7 ., _ l w ,
//2/;177///)27 277/2 //7./////27 277 217/7/ z W7/7J2W’7/217/27777 2 2/
._5,72)/!/7 1272/2777 //7///7)2/7/ l //7/2 /27."£ 277 727}/7/‘/ /,77;/’,7./7?/ 277/2 277
’L` 1 ‘ i/ ' ' w ' j ` 77 ,.
.77/777777/ 27 27//777 777/2 27 27 27 777/7 77 77 772/77
724 2/2//2:;717”_/ ]/7j27/22///27/f22)///77}L'/2/%?/7//771/7/,`//, 225/7//2)// 217/2//22/
752/12 72/73'// 25:§£177)’[/}772_\" 2727/777 ,2;/77/)}77//0272.//§5£ l
277/7 / ///[!/7///7/////2’//7/¢7’//7//2 27'&)//?/7,// 272/5 2 2727 l
jj)U//E/u,// 2 f22///"/ 2///////‘ /27?77 .flzi’i§//.i/x// 272/52 777/7’2///7:/ /27
777,77/;77/7, / '
27 157 27//'77 ‘ /7 _/}1/)/7,»277 227 /7/'72.,- 2777/77727/77§ , 727/2777 7
777 2777-§ 77 277/2772 7777
n z . ', ' ;_ . ”
7 1777/77777/ 722/777 2777/773 2777/ 2777 2 272 2777/772
7/’//77 272 /////77 277 //5 71/7’2 75 2777777'7/// 272 272/727
277 777/777 /27_7)777./:)7)/ 7"/2:/§77 727577777'7 225 277//
/A/ 2 777/2 757/727 2777/7 777/7 //
577 /‘7 277 777/277 ,/77' a,17777 ///_;./77‘27/77>72 777 §17,/:7,»/;_;727"7777'"2
7121/7 ///7.71;7 § 777/777 /
732 272 "/57/777/7777/277772 227 2 717 77 777/52/7;1 772/mg
' 171/277 /'/77//.777: Ld777-777 /)7\/7‘7 777/277 2222/727 2721/75

.,é,,-

1l717/'1’1/1‘1./11/£//71/_’~/ /7///1£!//7/157 2113 111111)17/1/’>/ if .7)_§':`1115.7
711///1/1///1//111//11,/ 771/717 /1///11/11_11;< 171/17 717/711 7171_52¢
15 /1//1§1111/7'15"7/1/ /71/1/ /11/1715111/1/1117 /11/7111 711 7111'17
11///1/111/ j 3111/1 1771/1 711/1117 /1/71 l//'/111111//11/1/1;/
1771/1711`/1’/5/ 17 l
1511 1371[1.§\1151111.,71?1_§.11117777§_..7,1:1(.717 1511/71 1`1'/'7< .,,,////§1:1`/‘1'71/711!}' /1//1/
1157;111&/1¢1`7/111///711117_117717111111.,15:7_211§/¢15 515/11 <;§171/17/;1//;/

77 711/1717 717/117 7731'/, // [' 1///7/1/1'1 771/117 17:111/11///771/11111/
1"1//171/1’17 /711/ 1 711111771.""1/171/11 /1 771 771/7117 ///11//1/ 71////111///1/:,. y
"// 11 111/1/'/_51///11/711/111 771/1117 711 //` 7 711 /,'1:-/111/
111 /111111//1//111//;1/1 /1171111711//1111 111/1111
/LJ{/HLLW 771/771/1/ //1//7111/711/ //'
151/111 711 1121/1111 1111111.1//’71#1 `/1117,>//',_/)11;111/,,.1111-11111§12,1151/115111
/'////l 71/_1/1// 1111 ;11/,///,:31111711/111/ 1 1 'f','1;11111111;_1111111.1151
D> 711/1017 717/11 7 71//7/1)1/,//7//.'/// /?M/Zi,/ 7/3121/7‘1__§ 77 /‘//1.///
113 711/11)1/3 7//1/11 7 71//17 71 171/17 711/111 7177 7 /71/7111 7
171/1571 711 171/11/11/111,11,/7
111 711 7177111;1'1 7111//%1/;1111//1/7;111111:/771/1717151?11.1;7117,1/1/71;/711
711///1 /11//1111/ 111»/111"7,/1"1/1/77711111.'! 771 711/17 1117711/7' 712/111 v '
7711£7/ 171'5$'11111./‘ 7 /071"/1117 7 /y//,"// 777/71 771/7111111)11 .[1)1111/5»1/_'5 7[71:2//15
771/y /71171/1/;71:/ 71 171/7 711/1111//11/113 /11/7171/11711//1}11;/;/1717/1117 111
/7';\/7111/ 7 7/7/111_’ 7/7/?7[15117//11171» 7757 . 771/1711 ,/71//11`)1/1 717/1111 /7
/711/ ./11'/11 ,///.1?1/'1/1.’1111/'1’11/_:; l n '

 

   

,7,.'

l L`)//111/1/1’/1J/J 1571/757 //1§‘1/ /7' //§1/////11///§/ /111//'?// §1'1/§1/1’//,/1

ll\/§m/ )/’?1£.?2§1/11;§§/1/ /11§1/1/11} 17//1/1§1 /-/ §§1/11_1£//¢2 /11'7//§7//§
7/1’1 /1'/1&/ /l7]l/V 172/15/71{/§’§{//11//%1/

<1:;1; l/§//’["})/'//// /4//7/§7///1/ /I/z/.'[ /W// 1'\\ /7/?

511/1711 /;/;77/§//1'111// 1711/1 /¢ 7/11/ / 111/ /§//17)1/ //§§11.// //1511/ 131
§>[§1//1’_§“ 171/1§/ ,/11 /1./ //1/1

/7/ 121 //§///11111/§%1//_’/ 2///§1'/ 7/7§1/ /1/§1/§17 §//§1<1§/1/ 7/71/_/ /z/7/ //1/7/1’//17/11/1/
111/111 //7'/1:1//1/1:" §/1/// ]§1// /71, 711/111 771/111////111//1/§/ /§ 17 §/’//§11 / /7' // 1/1/11///

§§ 1711/7 §§1'1// /§11/ 7/§/ /1///111//”§ 1111/11 §1/5 /71: §1§11//// 711/§ §11§// §§
»__/UL/'/ ///:/1*/ 555 //1§};' /l” §7////,//////1//£’ ////7£1/11// 7'/'§72/

§////)§1// 77/§/ [§1/11£.»15/) LZ'[ f//§§/ 71////§§////// §/§}//`//’1/§£; //1§’///{////7/§//
71/1//1'1: 1711/1/ /1/[§11///111§11/£1 /2/1/111/11 |/1/1’1/// /7111 /)1'1111 ///1/ ///11/

_1`1§111§.?1111111/111'1; /’§1111
571/§"'§/11'/§1: §1217§11§7§5 §11211111/§ §§1/ §%/1//11/11 7/?1 L511///£11"1../1_//1 151/§ 1//1/111§/

/777§//111//’) 2173/1155 5/§/)//1'/11// /7$§1'11/; 7/7/1/ 1§1//7//1//1 7/`/.1/ §117/'/)//1/1 ////1§/
511///1/11 5111§115 /7//// _Z§)//) ///1/// f \///§’/1/// /%/ / ~7/7/1/1 /)7§11
1/1‘1/1/§/511’§ 111 2111111 /1/§1 /§//1?/1/ 711/1/1§/111/ §1 7§§ 17///1/'1’1/
_21112‘11)// 7/11 _711/§71/1)1111// 11/§11/) ["/1'11////§11 1 /§/////§ 7§1/

`Z§/§/§§/ [71’11;> 11/1,1;;§*/§1/1 §§//1//11//1V 71/// /7§//1) /1'°11/
1111 1(111,/1’11/1 25 11 11

¢F/D/E///d/ /5§1:1/5> 77717//%1 j§§'. /§£5//////1/1 //§/ 171: /1/1,'//// ///3141/1117/
§§////1/§1 §/§11//17//17//§§/ § 7/7§1/§71/'/§//1//// ///1/ //1'

 

\,5’ -

7771§1§§}11' §)1'§!71`1/1‘ v71//)1'1’Z51'11~'1.- 17

_)§12§§3 £///£'/ /7§5 §§//// §/[W§ /[`//'1// §’,//`///7'/ //§l //7//1//7 /§§/f§/ 1/1; 771//§///) //./1'// ///1/// `
/§11 §§/1/§ §;’1>111/5§ 111§ 17/_§111111§11§1 1/ 111/15 §71111/11§ §11111111: 1§/1//1111/ §11§//

§1//` §§111:§ §11//111§//§11111/§ 1111/1 §11'11§ § § § /1§ §§11;1§/§1 §711/1115 §§111§ §//§1511/§ n
§1/§5/§ §§'_§§)11111 §)1112111 §1111111§§/ §§//1§ §1/1151/3 §/1 1/`11' §1§§711§711//§§/§/11 1 11 ./_'

11 /111§11111 /1 711/1 §§1 1111/11 1111/1§/11/ §§11~' 1 111 /15/’ 1711)71§

§§f/'/7/§§[]/L/Z3 Y£j/§LM§E §§£j/[!§”_§' / § //111 §51 §§ 11 §1§/// //XD%§H/:/A 1/£///§/7//71/£/////1111

/§15§11§1 [§91:5/1/ § §1// 71 §1")/1/§1§//111/§$ //11/111 ` _
§/1/1§111/§/ 1§/1/ 1/11/ 111/1111 /715 §§51§:1 §/1§1§11111§1 §§111/ §11

/§1 /11/1/1§/1111/§ §11111111

§7 §1'1111111 /§ §§1§11§§7 /§1§1§/1// /`/1/[§1§111111/§ 11§171/111/§///11///////§1
7/111§ §§11111§§1 §711/1//1/_

_:/)`Z£ l§l§§a&§_/M§é.?§///§L§LMM /§11/1/. //'r'm) /'.§7)//1§//‘///§
§§§§th§z§ 777551£]1§§§/ 1/1 52/1111 715/17/ j)/Z_LMLM 1 ///////
ixj§§i §§/M/A §§1? §17.2/:§_77/

l v Z)§__)§a§ /5 §§1/11/[/ §1/ §§§// /1/111! //1/ /§/1/11/1 /14§$§1//’1111////"11/§§1

§§117 1111 1111 §1’1/111111//§7/) 1//111/ 11 /§111 /1/ §§1//7/§ 1§ §/11111 //
§§751/§1//1/17§1 51'1::. /1 V §§1/ /77‘§ §.11/7////

§§ ,§1/1§1§1'1)11// ”71/5/ §§§/[1[|/12//§//177_§§//1 /5 §17/7/}11[/ §7 7701/11
§§ j§§§//,¢/ &’11/1//£§1’1/

mMJ§§XLZLMuLA/w 1`11111/ 171_7_11111§111/_§§/1

v__7_,

..Z) §mm/£/Z:w />U /MMZ/§!W/§/q/WA/zz/a/f§/!IAM/§/¢§/§”;Da 0
sz§£§¢M//%/J/¢’//d§§§ /§fi[§’zr//////§///.§ /7///€£§
555 212/g 222 52 S.M, &/ _

E) A/z)/¢)§MZJ §Aj v//:Z/M/.Z),,//z// m 2_;/,2*/¢/:)/¢/ §////)§/£/ §§zié
" 15 /1/0/ [’ l/‘AML// §/71'?/./5,:' M /}1/ W/M§ 21 /h/ §§ l/.,mu §/¢/////:/ v
M?/ §/// hzZ“//'/¢/ /}z/I§;,£‘//?yz/¢// `
_§1:'¢: ‘ -. ` “ my/jiu/jz/._§'/ZT , §}L/' /§1: /'1>1£)§//§2/¢:/

W//sz/L// /§)` /i/L?Vl §££wiz/ 17/ l [§w/}z/ ":5£’22»0!'§2/§% //w{y¢//

F) '|lDE/éL/[§?u/J §£)A/V/E§é// § z//`/ /§a 'I/Jm %V£l,$£z/ [§z%&s/
550/ugly //4/// §1[/ '/}1/7};/¢/£¢//7/@//1//¢/1/2 M//§/ZA z/i§/u/§,,.//.
}%,¢/z:] ¢//// ' §AZ////z///i/u '/m/ a /i/¢m.¢ my § [Lz¢/l//Z"/
A//z’A/ivll/J' §//2“//0 /A/£/l/z/£ 'A/Mz/' 'i$iz/¢§w 'M//)/M /z/Au
A§L/Lc/ /D liva §WMl//v/e:/ §Mz///_. /4/1/5/ Vi//`/{/}z;>u'/ i/J/§}£A
'?F/u/t'/.cz/ //7£' ////7[///[7//) [//)£LY§)/£ §/)//‘r/`J//LWL’/)///z/z.‘v b
v /iM/,/// f//Z;w. ll ` _ d
lie EAMA_M__&/A§_§li,mj¢/M 7§£1£§¢£ , //L/£z/'M//;j///”/j,,,
//u //}L gm // §A)z: /;{/.)) /‘ §§1//, /.':>¢:/ //L//.'¢:/i/ §'// //// 1//3/¢/ / §/:`//z’z/
lb M/M /;'0/0//22'//,// Lh/ §//,z/£ f/m//L//J A/f¢*wA/z/ § _A,¢,/ _ §
§771)? V/?/£ [LIM[/// £/L/l//£’//[)// 7§:' §//,//"l/¢/il _} ///)/ //1£ §§7'§//.§£
A/)/@//£/)A//, `/z,r:/ /1) /3 f//va/J //f_¢) D`i/éz/////, i/ézzz§¢; //z¢sz///;,/%¢
/;‘070//[//»//_3 /7/11/' if 1//// * _§/'///1/¢1>/§:2/ M027/ A’///// §//,;//,:/,{// ' f
` ‘» MZ;A/z//£X§/z§§¢/§ ' v

#/z)' _

        

._§£é

51 /72 /1;¢’_)21// §/l)£ §112/ §//221‘1/2// §222§/ 1/§%2/ / [§17/ 222

2/}211/2 §2/ 1221//_5' /721111 /1/11//1/1 //23 /§2 //12//2//22//1{725/2'21/2/7
211/1 2/ §;§ 2111//5' §21211

7 211/ 2112 1121/1122

2) /2112/5 §//1// /' 2211 112/ §/5/1/1:/ §[2§/_5§2/ /11/ §22 22 257/2221

l/k////£§ A[§/}§§/ 211/1"/ //21 /'2’1///§/ /§22) 57§/1/§'/2/&2/1252/[§//
/1/1/ 2222217 § §2/ /72 /772//211///221§ //2 /11/2/ §.'111//2

22 7/7£ 1112/2/§/11// /// /§1/1/ /1/2 257//222 /2//71/§ [)/2/11/1 »”

211/[/ 21 22// 211/21§/£[///§11/ §/>§ 111/2225 2/2/ §7217‘22/ 7
1/1/1//) 1212/117 1521/l 291/1 1///]11'1)1/2 //jj 1

/1/2/0//12117§21 121/2 //2/11/211225/ /§/1/211/ 7/711/ 172 25 [2//1//21/

27 //2§2'21_5 §2’ w §/2/ //1/ 7/7221/2 <_5/ § 272'252 171/2/ /1/2!

212 7/)1'1/ 7/;;§11/2122§ §111/%221//5 /9/§/21§'/ § 21/§2/§
§;2 //121// 25 /2////§//

1/2/1; l)owm211// §§ f \////111/22 111/2/21:/1//11/ //7/5 §I§L //11/ //1/'/§[§5

fX/')§// m //21215 §>1/11// [’11'221 1111/,[)/5/2/12 §22§/Jh22/ /11/
` 2212 221/15 /222 .'21112/

B) 7§/: _21///119§22/11///11/ / 1222 /1/2. /57/£29§

//.,

 

,_7'1/2’)2/1’5 1511./2111/ 022/1112§211/

' °7"' §7<"7 6 <~` ¢~- ‘7>/7'/11$` _1/11'11 //11 1§//21'1111/211/1/ §1’1'111 1221/y
1111[’/71/_’2111/1’1‘//`/.,/ §Z£§_§ALZA__MA§M§£§M 1`/111 1"1 /:e'j/JA'// §§ 2271/1/ §§/”11/,
* 141’11111/1'11/7 /2/17 ' §1//1/211/1’/7§11/112/./§2 //71 §21”/5 5 11/1'//1111 //11 §§2/2
14 /2/1111/11>1/ /1>1 111`/ 2/" //112111 §1""115 171/11211§ §§11//11//22/11/15' *
' 11‘/11/2/ 211/1111 211 711/1 2111/ §1111:7 2111/2///§/11/1111///111'21//11/
v //71111`1/ 211 1§1111 21// §1121'/ 1 `

_15/711/1.'/”/ 0/1/ §/)1_$ §§L° ,____LZ_____[/[`// p/} _

/

jepé. 772 15

17111`///1111: §§ 422 /211'1//

 

721/22 2 . 021/15
»2/0/2/111~111/ 172_51:
”/71157>/

[1'1>/ 211/2211 111111/
750¢/ f/m/)/ 222
511:\/1//6 1 721/21 715//£/2

'/z/

1111/1511715 115111_115

_Z` __‘~>5<’_1&2;=_1__17511;55 1/70/0/5111/ 111 751 551/5 ch3///1//

51101 15 51115 /&1?7119/"4 751/11 /5//%2 151 511 511115551.1/11/5///5111/17

7/11_ '1/ 1111// /f[].ijF f?/ 5/5 /1’/111111151 55511//11/ 51 555/51 551//}//1’
/1111|/1115 /11/ 1/51 [/11//11/5/:/5/ /1;5 /WA'// /1/1/5/ L£LLL[A]_ZA__[MA_/L)/

751 70 f j '_ZD 111/155 150 112 fgs/1171 5//115/5/111/ 5')11/1/111//15/

/D f [ 511/1 51)1/`11/ //1221/1` [0111/4/ 5/1/ 511/1/5/1’1[

511// 5111/1///111111 ,.5/1 ‘/IZ>
751 51210//1/1_>/1 //01/.5/1111/ 761/11 77505

 

/1111/ 5 711/5 111/1115

5£111/ 55 51'1111///11/5/5/11511; 5/5”151
/>[). 501 55155
55015)/ 551//1911// /[5///1/ 7[1\651 75///

§/7/u1[/ 511 7513 751 / 7 511/1 5/? 5€_¢}’ l{"~ , , Z) / ‘5/

_51;111/1111 1/ 5/511//

/;111/55 1/;)/[;/)\111
_ /_0/5'111/ 11).55
”/111$1 .
111/51121 1111'// _
VZ‘DV ./"/11/ 202 .
51111//1, 5111 711/115

 

"z:)zi,~b//A- * . 1 .- . \

Harris County Criminal Disti‘i'a". D!.‘l.’.'l’\?,‘t Sheet

 

TH_E_ STAi'E OF'T_EXAS VS. DAV|S, TORACE

Cause Nb.: 139100601010-3 Court:182nd
Offense: AGG ASSAULT-FAM|LY MEMBER

Chargin§ |nstrume`nt: Felony lndictment

Bond: $0

Next Setting:

Case Disposition: Disposed
Case Status: Comp|ete `
Defendant Status: Disposed

vLeve|: 2nd Degree Felony

 

 

 

GENERAL 0Rnr-:Rs oF THE couRT

   

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

       

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

‘ §
§
§/11/2013 _ Felony complaint Filed - ' » _' §

' ‘ - OFFENSE: AGG ASSAULT-FAM|L MEMBER 2nd Degree Felony \\\

` - Bond Amount: $0 ~ ~ . _ _ \_
6/11/2013 P_ROBA_BLE CAUSE FOUND \"\"
6/11/2013 COM|_\_MTMENT |SSUED~FELONY »-` `~*

. ' v BoND AMouNT: $o ' . - \§
6/11/2013 PREL|M|NARV ASSIGNED COURT AF'PEARANCE SET|'lNG: 6/1_2/2013 9:00 AM \ ~
6/12/2013 Defendant DAVlS, TORACE appeared without counsel §

_ . , .' ' b _ \.'\
6/12/2013 Reset Eiy Operatlon Of Law, 6/13/2013 09:00 AM Prelimlnary Asslgned `Court Appearance §\\\\` '
6/13/2013 Defendant DAV|S, TORACE appeared without counsel §
6/13/2013 The defendant filed a sworn pauper's oath, and JUDGE BARR, JEANNINE N

ordered DESAl. RlDDH| appolnted as Appointed Defense Attomey \

` 6/13_/2013 STATUTORY WARN|NG_S G|VEN TO DEFENDANT \
6/13/2013 Reset Upon Defense Request, 7/18/2013 09:00 AM Non-Trial Setting \\
7/18/2013 Defendant DAV|S, TORACE appeared with counsel DESAll RlDDH|. \S
7/18/2013 Reset Upon Defense Request, 8/19/2013 09:00 AM Non-Trla| Setting §\

. 1
7/31/2013 GRAND JURY ACT|ON: Felony indictment GJ COURT: 208 § §
. oFFENSE: AGG AssAuLT-FAMILY MEMBER 2nd Degree Felony § \i
BOND AMouNT: $0 » §
7/31/2013 Precept issued to serve copy of indictment \ \
.. . \,
8/19/2013 MOT|ON F|LED: COMPETENCY § \Q)
8/19/2013 ORDER: COMPETENCY EXAM GRANTED \ ~ §
~ s
8/19/2013 Reset_upon Defense Requesr. 9/26/2013 09:00 AM Disposmon §§
9/26/2013 Defendant DAVlS. TORACE appeared with counsel DESAl. R|DDH|. n `)\
_ ~ §
9/26/2013 Reset Upon Defense Request, 10/16/2013 09:00 AM Disposition \\\§ §
10/16/2013 Defendant DAV|S, TORACE appeared with counsel DESA|, R|DDH|. \>\§;
4 ‘ , ' ' \l
10/1,6/2013 Reset upon Defense Request. 11/22/2013 09:00 AM Disposicion )\§ §
10/23/2013 MOT|ON F|LED: PS DISMlSS A`lTORNEY \
MOT|ON F|LED: PS PROD EXC/MIT EVlD

 

11/1/2013

 

 

 

  
 

STATE’S wvi-\'
EXH|B|T

'D v

 
 
 
 

Page 1 of 2

`8/12/2015 5:11:13 PM

:‘
_1
4=
l

Harris County Crimina| District Docket Sheet

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

11/22/2013 Defendant DA_VlS, TORACE appeared with counsel DESAl, RIDDH|.
11/22/2013 ORDER: G_RNTD DlSCOVER¥ ORDER
.11/22/2013 Reset Upon _Defense Reguest 4/15/2014 09:00 AM Jury Trial
1/6/2014 : ORDER: ATTORNE¥ FEE VOUCHER
FEE AMOUNT: $175 ’ '
4/2/2014 MOTiON F|LED: MTN DlSCLOSE 'EXPERTS
4/15/2014 Defendant DAVIS, TORACE appeared with counsel DESAIl RlDDHi.
4/15/2014 l MOTlON l-'lLED: NTC lNT DESTRQY EVlD
4/15/2014 oell_ve_ry order issued _ _ '
- Location: Tex_as Department of Crimlnal Juslice . '
4/15/2014 Defendant DAVlS. TORACE appeared in person with Counsel DESAl, RlDDHl. LEW|S, JOHN appeared for the
Stale. Court Repo_rter: WA|VED Judge Presiding: BARR, JEANNINE . Defendant waived arraignment and entered
a plea of GU|LTY E. Defendant, appearing to the Court to be sane, is admonished by the Court of the ‘ “
consequences of said plea. Penalty recommendation of the State ls: WOAR The Court found the defendant guilty
and assessed punishment at 11 YEARS TDCJ Defendant sentenced to 11 YEARS in the lNSTlTUTlONAL
DiVlSlON TDCJ. Sentence to begin 4/15/14. APPEAL WA|VED. _
l 4/22/2014 ORDER: GRNTD OUT OF CRT HOURS LOG
4/22/2014 ORDER: ATTORNEY FEE VOUCHER_
FEE AMOUNT: $700
5/15/2014 ORDER: GRT OUT OF CRT HOURS LOG
5/15/2014 ORDER: A'l`l'ORNEY FEE VOUCHER _'

FEE AMOUNT: $1.300

 

 

 

Page 2 of 2
8l12/2015 5:11:_13 PM

 

/_///'/)i/ 7_'/ 5/?/%// 13

  

v `: \, n l q
THE STATE OF TEXAS D.A. LOG ER:1966681
VS. CJIS TRACKING NO.:9168876807-A001
TORACE DAVIS SPN: 02664121 BY: SG DA NO: 069(_)51500
DOB: BM/12-4-76 AGENCYZHPD
DATE PREPARED: 7/30/2013 O/R NO: 071862913
. . ARREST DATE: 6~10-13
NCIC CODEZ 1314 21 R.ELATED CASES:

FELONY CHARGE: Aggravated Assault¥ Family Member
HARRIS COUNTY DISTRICT COURT NO: 182 ' _ - ` PRIO`R CAUSE NO: v
FIRST SE-TTING DATE: ' _

 

lN THE NAME AND BY AUTHORITY` oF THE STATE oF TExAs: .

The duly organized Grand Jury of Harris County, Texas, presents in the District Court of Ham's County,' Texas, that in Harris County, Texas,
TORACE DAVIS, hereafter styled the Defendant, heretofore on or about JUNE 10, 2013, did then and there unlawtitlly, intentionally and
knowingly cause bodily£mjmiyi§to?’lw;.§z§;;¥l$§ a member of the Defendant's family , hereafter styled the Complainant, by CU”ITING OFF THE
COMPLA]NANT'S AIRWAY WITH A BAT, and the Defendant used and exhibited a deadly weapon, namely a BAT, during the commission of
the offense ` ' ` .

' It is further presented that in Harris County, Texas, TORACE DAVlS, hereafter styled the Defendant, heretofore on or about JUNE 10, 2013,
did then and there unlamey intentionally and knowingly cause " aln_p.n'ytoJAMI]DAVIS,a member of the Defendant's family, hereafter
styled the Complainant, by STRIKING THE COMPLA]NANT WITH A BAT, and the Defendant used and exhibited a deadly weapon, namely a

BAT, during the commission of the oti`ense.

     

 

 

§ d j’/)
mail §§/O
~ C- c\l

mo ~.»-4" §

D'“ `\ :\.
H.g~§ ‘°:7'<, 3
haag §/;i
$H~i

d --~»~

,r: m ,,_.'

?P

JAINST THE PEACE AND DIGNITY OF THE STATE. §§

 

 

' , _ FOREMAN 0F THE GRAND .TURY v

§ STATE S \~V\¥ . RlECORDER’S MEMORANDUM
" EXH|B|T [NDICTMENT _ 4 This instrument is ai poor quality
§ . ' - . - ` at the time of imaging

5