Court Opinion

ID: 4065922
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 22:18:51.367303+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:27.722808
License: Public Domain

^3,077-0'
                                                                                      wm

                     IN       THE   COURT    OF    CRIMINAL      APPEALS           AUG 0? 2015
                         WR   83,127-01       Ca.No.lO-CR-2388A
EX   PARTA                                        §
                                                       IN THE    28th   DISTRI
RANDY    J.KAIZER                                 §
                                                       COURT    OF   NUECES
Applicant
                                                       COUNTY,TEXAS           MOTOOINI DEEDED
                                                  §                           DATE: ounsel or State failed
to aknowledge this claim thereby ,failing to deveople all the
facts order by this court.
                                 XII

    The Habeas court in their "Supplemental Findings,Conclusion,
and Recommendation",has adopted the Starts findings without con
ducting it's own hearing.lt is well known that the practice of
the Habeas Court is to adopt the State's findings,as it did here.
Without a proper hearing the Applicant is not afforded a fair
hearing in accords with the Texas and United States Constitution.
Applicant's right of due process of law have been violated in the
 coarse of the hearing at the habeas court level.
    This Court once order the habeas court that additional facts
 were needed.Though the habeas court adopted the State's findings
 and trial counsel's affidavit,these Statements were inadequate to
 comply with this court instructions,and the habeas court recomme
 ndation should not be considered.Applicant suggest for tjis.Court
 to take it's own initiative and order an evidentiary hearing be
 held to develope the facts needed so this Court could decide that

                                  (.8)
...the Applicant be recommended for a new trial.

                             CONCLUSION    AND   PRAYER

    For the foregoing reason,the Applicant respectfully suggest
to this Court to findrthe habeas court did not complywith this                    -n
Court's instructions;2$further expansion of the record ,by an
evidentiary hearing,is needed to afford the Applicant with a full
and fair hearing,3)the summeries of trial counsel and the State
are inadequate to develope           the facts needed to fullfill a proper
record    that    would be sufficient     to let   this   Court   make a   fair
decision.

   Therefore the Applicant suggest that this Court deny the
habeas    court    recommendation.

                                                 Respectfully Submitted,

RAWDY J.KAIZER       #1730604

C.T.TERRELL       UNIT

1300~FM   655

ROSHARON,TEXAS       77583

                                        (9)
                               Unsworn   Declaration

     I,RANDY J.KAIZER,DO       HEREBY DECLARE     UNDER   THE   PENALTY     OF   PERJURY
THAT THE FOREGOING SUGGESTION TO DENY TRIAL COURTS RECOMMONDATION
IS   TRUE   AND    CORRECT.

EXCUTED ON:(J)Y^r/^                         RANDY         KAIZER

                              CERTIFICATE   OF    SERVICE
 I,RANDY J. KAIZER DO CERTIFY THAT A TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE
FOREGOING SUGGESTION TO DENY TRIAL COURTS RECOMMONDATION WAS
PLACED IN THE PRISON MAIL BOX WITH PRE PAID POSTAGE ON THIS
DAY OF      JULY,2015-

EXCUTED      ON   :Ot/\iS«Al                RAN                 R    #1730604
                                            C.T.Terrell     Unit
                                            1300 FM 655
                                            Rosharon,Texas          77583

                                         (10)
EXHIBIT   A.
                        Gregory-Portland Independent School District
                                       Gregory-Portland Junior High School

Marye Lou Landrum                                    Xavier Barrera                                  Ross A. Wilmeth
Assistant Principal                                     Principal                                 Assistant Principal

      Wednesday, February 2, 2011

     Luis P. Garcia, ESQ.
     500 N. Water St., Suite 510
     Corpus Christi, Texas 78401

     Dear Mr. Garcia:

     As an item of information, Victoria Medrano is no longer a student at Gregory-Portland Junior High
     School. She is now in grade 9 and all of her records were transferred from this campus to Gregory-
     Portland High School at the end of the school year last year. What is enclosed is what we have available
     at this time. Please feel free to contact me should you have any questions.

     Thank you.

        rer Barrera
     XaYier
     'Principal

                  4600 Wildcat Drive    Portland,Texas78374 • 361/643-2552 'Fax361/643-3187
                                         "An Equal Opportunity Employer"
  State of Texas
  County of San Patricio

  My name is Xavier Barrera. I am the Principal of Gregory-Portland Junior High School in the
  Gregory-Portland Independent School District, and am the official custodian of student records
  at that school campus. On this the 2nd day ofFebruary, 2011,1 hereby certify the attached
  documents are t^ue, exact, complete, and unaltered photocopies of the studentrecords of Victoria
  MedrsuioiTareyB.: 08/24/96).

                       sy$0tf—
  Xavier Barrera
           /

  Sworn to and subscribed before me onthe cZ.            day of February, 2011.

                                            Notary Public, State of Texas

  (SEAL)

         sss^^^ssssssss^ssss
                                            PrintName: M Child List

                                                       Children

                                                       Modify Existing

[        Print Child's Registration Form       ]

     Required Fields                                                                                   Last Modified by:

                          Personal Info    Site Info   Tuition Info   Pick-Up Info and Special Needs

    Personal Information

    * Date of Birth                        :08/24/1996

    * Sex                                   Female     -

 * Child's First Name                      Victoria

 * Child's Last Name                       ; Medrano

    Parent/Guardian                        Maria Medrano

                                           Currently (5)! 5
 * Grade
                                               or

 * School                                  ". Wilson

 *Child"s Physician                        Attending physician

 *Physician Address                        3435 S. Alameda

 *Physician City                           Corpus Christi

*Physician State                            Texas

*Physician Phone                           361-694-5000

 Latchkey After School Information
City of Corpus Christi - Park apA Recreation Department - Latchkey                                Page 2 of4

 * Latchkey Site                      Wilson
                                                               -

 Is child currently attending?        \ Yes       ?       No

 Last Day Attended

 Vacation Station Information
                                                  .•:"'
Vacation Station Site

 Days Attending
  •   November 23         •   December 20                          EH December 28

  •   November 24         •   December 21                          •   December 29

  Ej December 18          •   December 22                          E3 January 01

 •    December 19         H December 27                            •   January 02

Summer Latchkey Information

Summer Site

Weeks Attending
 •    June 14                     •     July 05                                     •   July 26

 •    June 21                     m July 12                                         0 August 02

 •    June 28                     ED July 19

Off Campus Field Trips            O Yes         (?) No

Off Campus Water Activities       O Yes         (?)       No

Field Trip Transportation               v
                                                          No
(Bus)                                     Yes

Tuition Information

* Tuition Type                     Full
                                                           -

Caseworker                        Select                                   or

TWC amount                        0.0000
(Use "0" for "npf)
City of Corpus Christi - Park zpa Recreation Department - Latchkey   Page 3 of4

 TWC Auth/Term #

 TWC Notified Date

 TWC Original Begin Date

 TWC Begin Date

 TWC End Date

 Days Authorized                   Select                  or

 TWC Termination Number

 TWC Comments

 Delmar Begin Date

 Delmar End Date

 Scholarship Number

 Pick-up List

 Pickup Names                     Phone

 Maria Medrano                    361-980-0365

Special Needs
City of Corpus Christi - Park arJ Recreation Department - Latchkey       Page 4 of 4
                             (                                       (

                                   \ Modify Child |
City of Corpus Christi - Park ar J Recreation Department - Latchkey     Page 1 of2

                                                                      Loa-Out
      Main Menu
                                     City of Corpus Christi
     Account Search
                              Parks and Recreation Department
                                         Latchkey

                                         Transactions

                                                Listing

                      Parent's Name           Maria Medrano (1141)

                      Child's Name            School Attending
                      Victoria Medrano       Wilson

                      Account Balance:        $0.00

                      Transaction History (all)

                       Date              Amount

                       04/30/2007        ($89.00)

                       04/25/2007          $89.00

                       04/02/2007        ($89.00)

                       03/25/2007          $89.00

                       03/01/2007        ($89.00)

                       02/25/2007          $89.00

                       02/02/2007        ($89.00)

                       01/25/2007          $89.00

                       01/09/2007        ($77.00)

                       01/03/2007          $77.00

                       11/30/2006        ($77.00)

                       11/25/2006          $77.00

                       11/02/2006        ($77.00)

                       10/25/2006          $77.00

                       09/29/2006        ($89.00)

                       09/25/2006          $89.00
City of Corpus Christi - Park zrA RecreationDepartment - Latchkey       Page 2 of 2
   . i f !                                                          (

                       09/01/2006      ($116.00)

                       08/25/2006        $89.00

                       08/14/2006       ($50.00)

                       08/14/2006        $77.00

                       04/27/2006       ($50.00)

                       04/25/2006        $50.00

                       04/03/2006       ($50.00)

                       03/25/2006        $50.00

                       03/02/2006       ($50.00)

                       02/25/2006        $50.00

                       02/07/2006       ($70.00)

                       02/06/2006        $20.00

                      01/25/2006         $50.00

                      01/09/2006        ($50.00)

                       12/25/2005        $50.00

                       12/05/2005       ($50.00)

                      11/28/2005         $50.00

                      11/01/2005        ($50.00)

                      10/24/2005         $50.00

                      10/03/2005        ($50.00)

                      09/27/2005         $50.00

                      09/02/2005        ($50.00)

                      08/30/2005         $50.00

                      08/18/2005        ($50.00)

                      08/18/2005         $50.00
EXHIBIT   B.

           .s~
                   Usf-W t'^f f
           0 rib, ,v «,                    2       DEPARTMENT COMPONENT AND BRANCH                                          3 SOCIAL SECURITY NO
      KAI4ER-, RANDY,JOHN JOSEPH                                                          USN-NAVY                                                                     43£s |%? \tf3H
4 a    GRADE. RATE OR RANK                           4.b "PAY^GRADE                                    5 DATE OF BIRTH (YYMMDD)                         6 RESERVE OBJ            TEB       DATE
      HM3 r          :        >' '    '              . -          E4                                   LbAPtfUL                                                          Mont1in          Day'
7 a     PLACE OF ENTRY INTO ACTIVE DUTY                                                                7 b HOME OF RECORD AT TIME OF ENTRY (City and state or complete
                                                                                                              address if known) T^-,7              SYCAMORE               PINES           !<]>
-      ilEPS     NEul    ORLEANS
                                                                                                                                  CARRIERE                     ("IS    Bltbt,
8 a     LAST DUTY ASSIGNMENT AND MAJOR COMMAND                                                         8 b    STATION WHERE SEPARATED

       NAVAL       HOSPITAL                GUAM                                                        PEKSUPP           J>ET NAVAL                STATION
9     COMMAND TO WHICH TRANSFERRED                                                                                                                          10 SGLI COVERAGE   IL I None
       NAVAL       RESERVE                PERSONNEL CENTER N£U ORLEANS LA                                                                                     Amount sLUU-ilJLljir.ULj
11 PRIMARY SPECIALTY (Lot number, title and years and months in                                        12 RECORD OF SERVICE                                  Year(s)      Month(s)          Day(s)
       specialty Listadditional specialty numbers and titles involving                                  a    Date Entered AD This Period                     6lar-       TTOT              TJ5
       periods of one or mat* years)                                                                                                                                                       ITT
                                                                                                        b Separation Date This Period                                    TTAir
       Hfl   -   GDrjO/QDDD                                                                                                                                 TJ5-         TJS-              TJtT"
                                                                                                        c    Net Active Service This Period
       X,                             X,                                    XX,                                                                             -onr         -tjtx             irtr
                                                                                                        d    Total Prior Active Service
                                           X,                                       vx,                                                                     tjit         TJX
                                                                                                        e    Total Prior Inactive Service
                                                X                                                       f Foreign Service                                   TJir         Titr              "tTLT
                                                     %                                                  g Sea Service                                       "inr         TJD-              iiur
                                                                                                        h Effective Date of Pay Grade                       "7JT         -JTJN"
                         vx
    13 DECORATIONS MEDALS. BADGES. CITATIONS AND CAMPAIGN RIBBONS AWARDED OR AUTHORIZED1 (All perods of service)
       COOD CONDUCT SERVICE ilEDAL (1ST)-, NATIONAL DEFENSE SERVICE I.CDAL UST)-.
       OVERSEAS SERVICE RIBtON (1ST)-. IIAKKSflAN HlbAE RIBBON (1ST).
       X,
14 MILITARY EDUCATION (Course title, number of weeks and month and year completed)
       HI!           SCHOOL-,              1QWKS-,                i)7riAR-
                      X„                        Xu                   X,                       %                                                  'x,X.

                                                                                                                                       Yes
                                                                                                                                                            16 DAYS ACCRUED LEAVE PAID
                                                                                              15 D HICH SCHOOL GRAOUflE OR
    IS a MEMBER CONTRIBUTED TO POST VICTNAM ERA
                                                                                    XX            EQUIVALENT                       XX
         VETERANS EOUCATIOUAL
                  EDUCATIOMAL ASSISTANCE PRUliKAM
                                         PROGRAM                                    ""    |       "•                              I          I          i                          .
    „ •JCU«.IM,« -OWtte, C^mnt DENTAL EXAM.NAnON AND ALL APPROPRIATE DENTAL SERVICES AND TREATMENT WITHIN ,0 DAVS PRIOR TO SEPARATION!                                                     E3
'"eS^TME^T'OR^-CTWE SERVICE'" TERM EXTENDED FROM m NONTH^ON^U N0V;0^
    ' IXT^NSiIn OF SERVICERS At THE REflUEST AND FOR JrlE CONVENIENCE Or THE<
        GOVERNMENT-                        , '                                  -                 „                                     y                                    x
        v
                                                                                                                                                                                            X,
                                                                        X'
                                                                                                                       ..- X„                     - ,         ', -      *v
                                     *x                                          *XX
                                                                                                             19b NEAREST RELATIVE (Name and'address%- inc/ude.Zip.Code)
    "19 a MAILING.ADDRESS AFTER SEPARATION (Include Zip Code)
                                                                                                             RICHARD L- KAIZER
        3M3 JOHNSON ^RD-                              |                •-       - '-                        ' lODDfl ADAMS ST BAY ST LOUIS MS 3^57b
        ASAtrfA HTS'^UAfl ^b^                                                                                                         RTSED TO^SIGN (Typed name grade.'tttle and
       j^wrBEBg&BKfesTscgrr                                        DIR. OFVFT AFFAIRS K

    'JiTsT                                                                                                                                              [^HILPlRSAjPVBYD£R'
                                                    SPtaALrADDITIONAL-'INFORMATION (For, use by.authomed agencies onlyVx
                                                                                                            24 CHARACTER OF SERVICE (Include;upgrades)
     23 TYPE OF KM«MWM<4 LE"A'jS EV' I- K0 PI/ AL I 1 y L
     DUTY A!ND ^R'AN'St&RRED TO NAVAL^RESERVE                                                                  HONORABLE
                                                                                                            26 SEPARATION CODE
     25 SEPARATIOBAUTHOMTV " ' H
     ' MILRERSfflAN 3fc.gD15Dl.ie                                                                              lb'k
    f SOTS?, "tm*klW?™^- ««*• *H» T.ANSr-F. TO NAVAL RESER.VE
     29.DATES    OF TB*E LOST^DURWG ,T](«S' PtWOU, <.
                                                                            't l«,
                 N,0NE**..^--'^«                          ^   -                                                                                                                            ERV1CE
    baFormi214,,texasbar.com
EXHIBIT   D.
                                 CAUSE NO:   10-CR-2388 A

EX PARTE        RANDY   KAIZER               V    IN THE 28th JUDICIAL DISTRICT
APPLICANT
                                             V
V.
                                             £               COURT   OF
                                             c
THE     STATE   OF   TEXAS                   c      NUECES     COUNTY,    TEXAS

                     CONTROVERTED/ PREVIOUSLY UNR:ESOVLVED FACTS:
                  INTERROGATORY QUESTION TO ATTORNEY LUES- GRACIA

I. WHETHER TRIAL COUNSEL, LUIS GARCIA MADE AN ADEQUATE INVESTIGATION
       OF THE FACTS AND CIRCUMSTANCE OF THE CASE.

       1. MR. GARCIA/ IN YOUR INVESTIGATION/ OR INTERVIEW OF THE STATE
          WITNESSES/ WHAT DID YOU DISCOVER? YOU INFERRED THAT DETECTIVE
          MOSS DID WOT ADEQUATELY INVESTIGATE THIS CASE.(SEE 2 RR 34-55,
          61-62) DID YOU INVESTIGATE/ MARIA MEDRANO'S WORK HISTORY/ VICTORIA
          MEDRANO'S SCHOOL RECORDS/ MEDICAL RECORDS/ INTERVIEW HER FRIENDS
          AND SCHOOL TEACHERS AND COUNSELORS? IF SO, WHAT DID YOU DISCOVER?
          IF NOT,    WHY?

       2- WHAT WAS YOUR TRIAL STRATEGY FOR NOT PRESENTING THE EVIDENCE OF
         MAIRA MEDRANO'S WORK HISTORY/ RANDY KAIZER'S WORK HISTORY'A.ANDvTHE
         SCHOOL RECORDS TO THE JURY TO SUPPORT YOUR THEORY THAT NO WINDOW
         OF OPPORTUNITY EXISTED FOR A CONTINUOUS SEXUAL ABUSE?             IN RETRO
         SPECT, SO YOU THINK/ THAT CREATING A TIME LINE CHART FOR THE JURY,
         WITH THE USE OF MARIA'S WORK SCHEDULE SHEETS AND RANDY'S WORK
         HISTORY AND SCHOOL RECORDS AS A VISIUAL GRAPH TO CHALLENGE THE
         STATE'S        "ON OR ABOUT" ELEMENT OF COUNTS 1/2,3,4/ OF THE INDICT
         MENT COULD HAVE CASTED DOUBT ON THE STATES CASE/ AND WOULD IT NOT
         HAVE SUPPORTED YOUR TRIAL STRATEGY BY PRESENTING EVIDENCE TO THE
         JURY TO CAST DOUBT ON THE VICTIMS UNCORROBORATED TESTIMONY.
     3. MR. GRACIA/ IN YOUR INVESTIGATION HOW MANY TIMES DID YOU CONSULT
 •-.     WITH YOUR- CLIENT? IN THAT CONSULTATION WITH YOUR CLIENT HE PROVIDE
           YOU WITH AN ALIBI STATEMENT.(SEE AFFIDAVIT)                                              IN WHICH HE NAMED

           JOHN    MEDRANO          AS    THE       ACTUAL       PERPETRATOR..

      4.   MR.GSRCIA,          WHAT       INVESTIGATION                   DID    YOU    DO    AS    TO    YOUR    CLIENT'S

           VERSION       OF    EVENTS?          DID       YOU    INTERVIEW JOHN                MEDRANO.          IF    N^T, : WHY?

           WHAT    WAS    YOUR       TRIAL          STRATEGY          FOR       NOT    INTRODUCING          A    THIRD          PARTY

           PERPETRATOR?             IN    RETROSPECT/                DO    YOU       THINK    YOU    SHOULD       HAVE          CALLED

           JOHN    MEDRANO          AS    A    WITNESS          TO    CONFRONT          HIM    WITH       YOUR    CLIENT'S

           STATEMENT?          IF    NOT,       WHY?

      5.   MR.    OSRCIA,       WHAT          WAS    YOUR       TRIAL       STRATEGY FOR             VIOR       DIRING          POTENTIAL

           JURORS AS TO YOUR CLIENT NOT TESTIFYING?(SEE 1 RR 62-198)                                                             YOUR

           CLIENT       STATED       HE       DTD    WiANT      TO .TESTIFY            AND    PRESENT       HIS       ALIBI       STATE

           MENT    AND    HIS       VERSION          OF    EVENTS.          WHAT       WAS    YOUR       TRIAL    STRATEGY          FOR

           PROCEEDING          WITH       THE       TRIAL       WITHOUT          THE    DEFENDANTS          TESTIMONY?             WHY?

      6.   MR    GSRCIA,       DID       YOU    INTERVIEW THE                   CHARACTER          WITNESSES          YOUR       CLIENT

           PROVIDED YOU?( SEE EXHIBITS) OF HIS EX-WIFE VICtfl NORMA)^ JOE
           GONZALES/          JAMES       FINNAGAN?             IF    NOT,       WHY?       WHAT    WAS    YOUR       TRIAL       STRATEGY

           FOR    NOT    CALLING          THEM       AS    CHARACTER             WITNESSES?          IN.RETROSPECT,                DO

           YOU    THINK       THAT       HAVING       THESE          CHARACTER          WITNESSES          TESTIFY          ON    BEHALF

           OF    YOUR    CLIENT          COULD       HAVE       GIVEN       THE       JURY    PROBATIVE          EVIDENCE          IN

           THEIR ASSESSMENT OF GUILT/INNOCENCE AND OR AT PUNISHMENT?

II.        WHETHER       TRIAL.COUNSEL,                   LUIS       G&RCIA,          MADE    AN    UNSOUND       TRIAL          STRATEGY

           BY    FAILING       TO    PRESENT          A    THIRD          PARTY PERPETRATOR,                AND       FAILING       TO

           CALL    THE    DEFENDANT. TO TESTIFY TO PRESENT                                    HIS    VERSION OF             THE    EVENTS

           TO    SHOW HIS       INNOCENCE.

      1.   MR.    GSRCIA,       WHAT WAS             YOUR       REASONING             FOR    NOT    DEVELOPING             YOUR    CLIENT

           VERSION       OF    EVENTS          BY    CALLING          HIM       TO    TESTIFY?       WHAT       WAS    YOUR       REASON

           ING    FOR    NOT    DEVELOPING                THIS       STRATEGY?

      2.   WHAT    WAS    YOUR       REASONING             FOR       NOT    CALLING          JOHN    MEDRANO          AS    A    WITNESS

           TO CONFRONT HIM WITH YOUR CLIENT'S ALIBI STATEMENT?

                                                                 2.
   3. WHAT WAS YOUR REASONING FOR NOT CALLING VIC§(l NORMA(/AS A CHARACTER
        WITNESS?        WHAT      WAS    YOUR    STRATEGY       ?

   4    WHAT     WAS    YOUR      RESONING       FOR    NOT    CALLING     JOE   GONZALES       AS    A   CHARACTER

        WITNESS?        WHAT      WAS    YOUR    STRATEGY?

   5.   WHAT     WAS    YOUR      RESONING       FOR    NOT    CALLING     JAMES   FINNAGAN          AS   A     CHARA

        CTER     WITNESS?         WHAT     WAS   YOUR    STRATEGY?

   6.    IN RETROSPECT/            DO YOU THINK          THE    PRESENTATION OF          YOUR    CLIENT'S

         VERSION       OF   EVENTS       WOULD    HAVE    BEEN REASONABLE          FOR    THE JURY'S

         DETERMINATION OF YOUR CLIENTS GUIr-T/INNOCENE ?

   7.    IN   RETROSPECT,          DO    YOU THINK       THE    PRESENTATION       OF    JOHN    MEDRANO'.

         BEING    THE ACTUAL            PERPETRATOR       WOULD     HAVE    BEEN REASONABLE               FOR       THE

         JURY'S DETERMINATION OF YOUR CLIENTS GUILT/INNOCENCE?

   8-    IN RETROSPECT/             DO YOU THINK,         THE PRESENTATION OF THE THREE

         CHARACTER          WITNESS      WOULD     HAVE BEEN REASONABLE            FOR    THE JURY'S

         DETERMINATION OF YOUR CLIENTS GUILT/INNOCENCE OR AT THE PUNISHMENT

         PHASE    OF    THE       TRIAL?
                                                                                                                y   .

III.    WHETHER TRIAL COUNSEL/                   LUIS GARCIA FAILED TO SUBJECT THE STATE'S

        WITNESS/       TO AN ADVERSARILY CROSS-EXAMINATION AND PRESENT EVIDENCE

        TO    SUPPORT       HIS    TRIAL    STRATEGY?

   1.    WHAT EVIDENCE DID YOU DISCOVER AFTER YOUR INVESTIGATION AND                                                INTER

         VIEW OF       VICTORIA         MEDRANO?       IF YOU DID     NOT    INVESTIGATE OR               INTERVIEW

        HER,     WHY    NOT?

   2.    WHAT REASONING DID YOU EMPLOY IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF YOUR TRIAL

         STRATEGY FOR THE CROSS-EXAMINATION OF THE VICTIMS                                 INCONSISTANT

         STATEMENT GIVEN TO DETECTIVE                     MOSS,     RICARDO JIMENEZ         AS       TO THE

         ALLEGED       SEXUAL       ABUSE    AND    HER   TRIAL     TESTIMONY?

   3.    WHAT WAS YOUR REASONING FOR                      NOT CROSS-EXAMINING THE VICTIM AS TO

         THE DEFENDANTS VERSION OF EVENTS NAMING JOHN MEDRANO AS THE ACTUAL

                                                         3.
            PERPETRATOR?

  4.        WHAT    WAS   YOUR        REASONING       FOR    NOT       CROSS-EXAMINANING          VICTORIA       MEDRANO

            AS TO THE ALLEGATION (SEE AFFIDAVIT)                            THAT SHE WOULD DISPLACE THE

            BLAME,       IF THE DEFENDANT TOLD                   HER    MOTHER,    MARIA       MEDRANO?

      5-    IN RETROSPECT,             DO YOU THINK,             YOUR    CROSS-EXAMINATION OF             THE    SOLE

            EYE    WITNESS       AS    TO    THE    ALLEGE       SEXUAL    ASSAULT       THAT.OCCURED          ONCE   A

            WEEK FOR 53 WEEKS(SEE 2RR 37)                         WAS SUPPORTED WITH EVIDENCE THAT

            WAS    AVAIABLE       TO YOU SUCH AS             WORK       SCHDULES    AND SCHOOL       RECORDS,

            AND    MEDICAL       RECORDS       TO    SHOW    A    TIME    LINE    THAT    NO    WINDOW    OF

            OPPORTUNITY          EXISTED?

      6.    WHAT REASONING             DID    YOU EMPLOY IN THE             CROSS-EXAMINATION OF                THE

            STATE    WITNESS          TO DEMONSTRATE             THE    VICTIMS    UNCORROBORATED          TESTIMONY

            LACKED       EVIDENCE       OF    PHYSICAL       AND       EMOTIONAL    TRAMA?       IN RETROSPECT

            DO YOU THINK,             THAT DR.       GARCIA TESTIMONY WAS                SUFFICIENT TO SUPPORT *.

            YOUR    TRIAL    STRATEGY?

      THE    COURT ORDERS             THAT ATTORNEY          LUIS: GARCIA         SHOULD GIVE       ANSWER       TO   ,

BY AFFIDAVIT OR             AT AN EVIDENTIARY HEARING                      TO THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS

TO RESOVLE APPICANT'S                   CONTROVERT,          PREVIOUSLY UNRESOVLVED                FACTS,       AND

THE    RESOVLATION          OF    THE       DESIGNATED       ISSUES.

      SIGNED       ON:

                                                                 PRESIDING       JUDGE
4F-        /CJ I $~&-OZU- (styes i - i p j _; - c                      it u    i c e - ' r r i *&
                                                                       A
                                                             ^prtified^S^TExpr^^lSiT
                                                              D Registered          I Return Receipt for Merchandise
                                                              D Insured Mail      • C.O.D,
                                                           4. Restricted Delivery? (Beta Fee)          D Yes
2. Article Number
   (Transfer from service label)
                                         7Q13 Eb3D DDD1 1^53 DUO                                   | J _
PS Form 3811, February 2004                  Domestic Return Receipt             '_—•