Court Opinion

ID: 4056120
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:39:54.332632+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:03.994828
License: Public Domain

Xm 1V)6 (WV C^ffijsAU oflexAS
                          HQ.WW3
                J^3i^TL^udm\M^Al^^
                   I),t^^^X^Uh5W)j£X^S
            iS^ita^^VkA^
                                                           ILEOIN
                                                   tgrnntim- o f appeals
                                                      HOUSTON, TEXAS

Vhafo f\\&er\                                       -JtIN—3-Z&15-
   ^                                              CHHIsfftPtlER^A^PRlNE-

Ja^^fe^Tau^_                                     CLERK'

                                                     ^)S£Ffe\W^\|WyA
                                                 bxcfec^q
                                 ^\k^A^^(E^s^
                                MSUcaiJ^
                                _Wecl\^n^

            ^uest^Q^^^

       l^to^t^jy^^^
 jkbt^i^Jr_^
Ubk D?(j^bA<;

U$>Vt& KuTWvVfek

 ^^Mi.oiCj^e'

 ^fe_^E^Vc^kA-s

 SfoWs vAH^feC
 ^cfeeJM^B^^

 ^mpANfijd

JsSv\eS^ttka.J

G&ciusW
                                                    5

  _CASE5-^

  Jtfde^i^Wi*^
  S«8&^&te$a£A^^
  CAai^l^^^H^^^^^11"^^^^^!181^)
  XiJ^l^^A^^^
  \^i\).H.W-\|Bl^,S^Z-,Wa)^S.L^t)Dl,U\LEd.^lc)^^^

  iikSWKtSlbSjMiS^
,, JWte&lIi^^^

  X\W^M.MUtffl\!>.S-3^,3g>-^
liy»\\|. footertfasxs,ti a^avrifodtyr-hftft WteftA.te$)
    il_iS^i23^J^.^.M,m(Tel.(^L
    ^^^^^Oi^A^Vi^^D^^ffib.
lia^lM^^^Mill^l^^IvkcZee^^M^
M^ue^^lf^aua^D^^mO-
M^_s>^\i.wv»i^™^^d)_
XIc^Mm^JWImos.

JkXra&WUAlb

 Trt.Cttt&/Vfe\UiD

 AiLik&.WLJt^l

 VlSXot^H^N*'
  US, CtaasV )W«;>oA 5+h
                      Ah
 AkSJj^ka^
                     \tH* f»F1 Ck\°\V* Of"!W* PAgPflE
                                                                 WeWo^ ^\?%^r of
        ^e ^tefi=sW| pA^YteS   o

    JSJkli^M^!                            VkA^Xk
                                          G^\li^
                                          wwmai
                                                                        iL
    4)^^^E^feCs^>E\:S_; ^_J^a|kL^fe&^                                             (Bafc^

                                          yavA\,
                                              4- it3i^W^sL /yfetaTi.Hta
    J ) j~a        Eft

    J^xJd^i^vWt      0

                                    _ \     \   k n \   \\r\0.   \ r»   o    i.   o,   ^.   .   -^
^                                                                                 ^La^^L'
                                                                                        hy
                                                                                  £&SS               ^
                                   5>pcjneg TkA
    5)a_j^^AMtk3Si
       _Guv^e\ I                           S^\iiCm^^I4£5^(^A
                                                                                            m~Q~i&-
    J^J9\^^^S^„(WiS^

                                     SlA^Ej^dz=
    :i>^^\^Ii)^^^E                           £>MS
        JSEjj.
                                     d»
    SW^etfofCASE-0
                     skAim{k   isa^tO^
%                                         ^

m
                    m               *S(&£~

          CI    m
.... 
          i£J»fc^

                        JStfcfe

                                  !&4^10

 JdSihS)^
                                                                                      s

vApteV&c wee: s^hj ofCotefcSM6*if. U&Y; Diofg: mmje XV k>(W>YVtt>\

Avn ^vui \M)ut^ 4^ujto tJwv^ ouitfrl Hrpp^^\JUM«vHJfnwuiwcKAJfeu t?K-yMtaJMall ^w**

^\re t£y&^tea&a&S .TiaftSpA ^Ajfa^ cV^^iA [w^K)os h\so<^As
\to\y$m$                                    M>fe hafe yjfeaba ^Qeo^ (Jiji^W
^Ja^be^^^

«L

                                    ^Me%£tV^
                   (yat^^^^^

                       M^sbs&bdm

     fc33D&
                                                 m
wkiJ          Mr    MMU^WiAtt^Ste              $&&&-
                                                                                                   \t>

    ^ hAttoytm^ ^H^^sdfeaat                                     _
         ;     i.      ;        Jfe^i^^
%
      CkeJ4&tt£(\:
                Q.__                        Mm
                                            Jl\DtlbN\              uAlm
                                                                _„_U4\VK^          Sigjto
                                                                                   DieOUQU               ,
                       ft3\ NflmrtfefaJ^ffict^A\^^32^^*? Co^^^Wfa^
                       M^SjiIIdGwm
                       CW.WJM—IV_V-V«K-W *—t V^ftJ|_WJtSi

    ^2°L                   A&>5M\)£
    jpJAb.                                              to

                                               J
    jpjtz    Jbdta4_                                                 vt^JbeKAg-j
                                      i#Mo£                         paoagk S-*
      Ab     M^k&ltK
     HI                                                                                     MM
    ^m^j^                                                                      J-"wOHJ.Mjy3&44MVUsf _

                                              'm

    ^a^M&^                                                  -    -
    JM2d&iS^^                                       j.Vri£ali
                                                               H

                 3)i
*»W&^^
                            MD^kj
                                                      i^Wijy^4«E

6VcbcoUAg
TWelWUi.            _ ...                t                     __

ftHCA'rifr La^^AJQB^WSikJSfe(bmL«fe\
                                       ^&^famte/^t^        o   .«

             itA^Xc^Mi.        ^Qai^l
                               ^J^JeJfdw^^^
_3^M-\)^
                               JSee&__u)E£j^^k3_j
fc4^tWl±i££^^
                                                                                                                            \1-

stoXlVte SJB^jfit W>frftl *3bAi_s w>S AtWtte § fc te^ecl AmA^fen (mho^s m
%bd&&Lr\,2W\
 vw    y—--vt^1 —Lt:—   •   j      -—^-       j~-—•—^^
                                                                                                                     ^\e55l^

                                          •^^a^m-..wlw    A]u&j faVvWrtWte
                                                           r—t.. |in»g^: ib^| ....T-j—=i^_»—i—.-     •_:—»   •-—z^   =—:—^»^L--. . -w — —-._-.

                                            r            L/>           \o. \                  o     \ ii l tt                  lr>
jftia&l ^fe^^v^U

                                                                                      __           iDKghgyA
                            ^^k(fvA^Bi^                                                                                           9!
     J> S

                                J&r&EL

            n^QiretftAte6^sgch      M££   g:X>4v>V-

                     lUByosfciJ^^

S-W^^g^JL     k(K£5t^\W>^k0p^^

                       jfL&i&ii§^
      LVioWk^fek^
                     J*!

                         iVtaf
                                         \fc

                                   iiKAafes^^
_          6                   Lte^csEiiAms_

yy^ykagl

J|$Btt^^       ___•   4|pJl«A3^^
                                                                           M

    (\Aey^ Wi Q^/frfcgMEKlk\Al& [k\V/i OtOtT Vd Upp Atecffifi^SJ£$>£kCOptVset£(faeA

                                                                               Ckk

                                      ^IMkeJk^
     L^SaAeu^
                                                                           3kj&u

•

             [EikVtri&i&S                             i                   — ^p—

                              tite ftWVoW \°h MAfoti t& oeW^wefcoc
                                          \7
 S Wa^VeS^ote I

              .QJlsiiusklBEl^^    ck3^^iifeg:l&

\5h^&\GmV_^_                     _^____
               ;4^i6~«^

(WLj
   _Stt^\^i&s3fi&5

ttv\kJ&4o^dli^i^
                                                        «

TtfeV\$MmviA?k\, 6)> f^f^\W)A^iAd \px teoAjj iMte^aa^          £

                                                              ©—

%;Xt^&teL                                                     A>
                                                            ABEL
J>iftuiBJia£^^

U^tMg Mte^^Cgi^W^W                     l^eqWdl iA\0*l

\gtos vito-^.t>E,l "% (Wr%Imk \m   d^of^k^^^.

                                         O I'M

                           SfVN
                                                26

                                           kdritikM
                                            saAeMi

\QyJM

fep^»ilUto.1ftt^tea wW*k) i^we&ybjyid)teg^jSSgg^i^r

M^idffi^vMa}; fe^^kjMt SaAzA \Kj\M7 tfeO^^bttfjcA

 mm
         V

Xai^k$

)•
o
            32.

\U^l&dtt^
                                                                      "O

Ivj Ibm&Iii* sfa^bif OmtfE&p/^^

                                                                           Juie

fe* uwAw 1iS CoieViBOei^nfuM weiM>lfe help) fiooftUa htfakMcidedw

_Sem .(lri^).lOhi( teamed maDea^ |Wj&6uv/y S^JfiDffi^j^
jMt»^•l|«b)od Sfetelife Wftfc flbefJJ2^t&^

feM|MiaiZ^ilB^i^»^u£^li>4h^^rfM%USE t&P^sca\cbsM^3

            ^eX\l, f&Wl fW liUS.M i2Srs.Ci.2a>7.)bl lU.U^Z
     to>Guwi4tteX\)t
                 ;ei

^ikso^iu^Cellos;«..%te^SU.3d )^fe%rAs^&)Ib^e^fN
     ^ ,^_                                         l^M^j5
4fes:oa^&.^teus^ o?^fctie$>1^ fet detoS.isidlfek^ g>ia^ A\ussi

2S?^lT^M^W^-                               ..   _._..._

Xd^DD^e^ABLI_pjSi^^%^0Stid^Bcl^MlllO^vS^                  ..._
                                                                  *Zk>

 ^u^J^V^i^^^v) &UA^%om%iM
 d^JtbjyiJhs_cprAM\Aiv)i\u (^We<\£,-fine^^x o^ui^lsa4 a^feo^Wik

  ^UAei^i^di^u^M tayi^Aftto^?iv\ f^Y$k; fe^W?«yt.&tJi>J^
l^Jr^iVUwSiSen^S^IrO X^tdi, ft ii oofely ppssMn: MJm^tail) m\
  Mi^Mg_d£sSbv«oi!J^.^eofy\_Affcfie: .«ccx%s^|, £sLu$ty ^cmsmaajjao^)fe
  ^JM*M$mz&z&h$ mty£$s°s>& dm^AMQ Mfetyfiiod^s t£J
  C^^A^V^^^ s^tu$.butt 9D&ty\VtfWw£^ ?>oW^ix>^^Mje:^

 ^ w ,ss \iuw,M^)WtM viWiftiq w^m^U%

 \lmWV-wMslmfo m

  1^eflite'^eVW.a.(a^V^^                           op^vw^) ft^UrtcUs
k&V                           _,                       _
     t>« />irr- ° \ \° . to. L» * aA° voU\ \ V. *» lL*>AV 4- U^a\o^c -

          Sf&ia^^^
    SW\A be -&ftve*L \>sw?ss o£. few^gA tafe hS^) \w\

                        '

                                                        •

-

                                                            ' „ .'-' ';-:->-;- -'•'