Court Opinion

ID: 4056830
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:11:11.983097+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:06:25.804303
License: Public Domain

j£0« (5 Mb:]l-W'00IB6-Cft
                     IN THE"
             court or appals                     OCT 02 2015

      ^For TJ-ib FIFTH DWTftl&T OF               elAcoste.Cterk
ORIGINAL          at Dallas
              TDMMIF WILLI AMsS-APPOLANT

             -me cSTfrrr of TexaS - APP£LL£F

            taU^MUMfi^ll-14-00(86- OR
                                                     "FILED"
     Da/ AfVfl^ F/k)M CamMM&u: F'/l-UM3comofmm^appeals
              2^2/^ bi^TRlCT GMKT                   ccto;oz:;5
      OF DfcUJU CDlWTV. TFXAvT
                                                  Abel Acosta, Clerk

       Permo^ *&a Mc/Lgri d^/y«Y fieviw to^F

                                          -TDHMiZ HILL IMAS

                                       FpttSCM fo&BflTfotl WIT
                                       noil pm k-h,

    Pu/WMT TO 16& fU, P. P.    A3^?9
       T^t 0)b\(tf

       1&ZMD        (dicwKicT cm/rr
      bkiLhs cousrri, rzxAS

        PaRT/^5
    Tommie Minims
                                                    APPeLLMT
  T^dTAT£"OFTtXAS
                                                     FACTS'

ASSISTANT ftkfflMCT A7lfrU/£>/                  fcnbojjfr/ TodTifc state
133, M< IMVlfcfiXJtfr Boui^VAfcO
OfHWKf/Texas .75^7

AS5iJTAMT OUTftiCT FOToMBi
                                                f\TTb(l^ fuiT^staTZ
 OaLW.Texm 75^?7
 M. ft?5££CA £TT
                                                m>u$&t fitcmtfrpcre

                               fa(tf is of 6f
 ML kkttWDttf £IUW0
 m Pnnboui mm, suma

II 3b a/. tifflMmkiSQ
                                   OeFfr/JOftArr

2J/ N6PTU PSCDlUb

                    Ptffl 3 dF6^
                  TaQ>LF OF COhSTZhJTS

  ioewrrtf DP T&E PwflBS                           2
  "ThHJc oF CorffetfTS                             0.
 woe* bF AinUoMTiES                                ,
(SfftreMetiT of tm(test                            |
STffwmrr of Fqgts                                  u,
PounopF/iMfL Numerous
1M &/U>e/JC6 if IridUFFlM&tT TO
Pum £A/Tfi4 iA)miMTTriF jfajffik
Effective (M&t                                a2
<svm*M of Mavtfffrp                           ^

PoittrfF £m(L> A/Mf/L> W
-7W TMkU CdvllFF FMiFO #9 MbkuUM
MPFlM/tf"S OUClBC^JO/s} 72 WADMWlDhl
 OF A <SbMtfM7f6l*t TFl£M/)hf£ OM, flfyCSO
 bf rue omorm of ~we twee                    %
  u\AM/nvd of amom/tfT                       ^
  fa&oM&rr                                   4h

                     hd£4i)Fffl
    Po/hft OF £MuOiu MmFk rpf/^
  -7/fe twku cm*r stmt) W fjvua/a
  ro limit rue offm/tdmis of I/ftf/JT/ipJai^/
  MQ M&tii^bl TO Ttie RFlFMkhFF CDhlmT
  FLFMFAFTt DFTHf-lMfALdlMfr OfFFKlSe              SI
  <SUMm/ti $F AflhVMBhtF                          cT/

                                                  57/

~W:TMU, £oh/iFT kbcfr&o \/tiAttfO/crnod
re 4ffl, T& /fikffittT £Wt /TAJb fl£WF(L
a ^MMemrr Beamr rtf^e m^a/^t                            ,/•

7M*trftiim. To m m&mt
dl//y>/h/r/zV OFAA&VMFtiT

Pwieiu
c&ftFictfr&dF co^/a^C/^

                                           (Ft.

             Pmsor w
               mm dp hoTuoktms

  <Mes

:„,MMktlZA V- dTA7Fs H6 S.H Id AT7
  (TOC,CAltf.AP0/<?<?4)                         J5

  wiwk i/, FiAiHiMhT^ *hi vs. zn°i cm)          lTo
 m%<STWE 11)0 SHid I^
 fTfX, APPr DMUt IW)                       63, (XT

(T®LC4iirt> APP< mtf)

 emure sfidrl, zq^w 3m ii/l                     67
(Te&Cm.APP.lDDl)

(TtrL APP- 4bu<nbH Cl HlH hiST.! IWf)
 HhfWJ V^MTF. 1W JIM Id fr&b
(~Wt.CMM.AM<ffl)                          (5D

iTe%w\4<mmi)

UufFMAU \Z07tiTF 2_£7 vT, W $*Jb fyV     (5V-
fTea CAM, AfP, U>d0 )

 (TB*«CHM.A0,lW)

                    fati h Of <ff
  MAWkj \l. SVKV5. %S\ <S.til- 2 0 Z7S              50

 (Tec. CWM- jrf!P, l<V&)
  HiOiiMWahi >/ inft-s?, 000 d,KJ. 2-0 02^         (TV
 (fM QylH- *PP< IW)
 jHfityAJ'/ auGffl/r rmnrrV. $pf                  4$

itbms \j, Cobb, 53i m a>2> (zooi)                 ¥$
•fikMfidofi \t <S7kT6. ^8(f.M 7^0 lip             4Q

    domr/7hr/&Aj<s
TfX., Cj>mtmkt. VMorn/J /z (a)               s%>

•ret Coot CMtA. PMO. AJkI Hmnrjx $\,.        yj
IB*. PFML Cnpg AkIaL MCm^l frM               <&
-ret- cm com, mcuhto. fwriNE iw u            ^

                  Pirfe'1't>F<5~q
 Tgy.,PfoifritjcoeAM.m&noti soot                    U^

  'M, Pem/CMZ Mk,rvyparfiryi- a0.02,-ft) ft)        <n

 lELSMe cm. Hub. h^mmT'sn.n                         ^

Rule

                                               to
                                               4^

               A$f # ^     <?"f•
                    INdBX OF AoTtiOAiT/^S

IkMktJZA n/,vSTaTE: my vftj.id JLSV
fm.cflM.APP,w<M                                &r

 m v. <m& m<t<SM Mi
(It*. APP. - omuiX* jW }                    J3, y£T
600K V vTTATF;
      <SFFhT£Mttfr OF THF CMF

  in muhMfrKjt MttlFAmd/uW&T^ifT/MfjFTM/kr: T%F

M*»*,«»/art*, mwJZm^^i%&%&Ftn
™*#>M0g, camrr nJo wmpr to cm*rr Affawr
Aw/an ^Tftoie MtoufawrnJMW,

U-fl/ji/Mi, wt

TX^a^, ^ cow/ww #f term-Mm, rw
 mm, 46»nr,M TUf-Loa^o OMUctttU JJntin' ajuvt
 6F djrm<f fattN, Taw m Tt# Mute tMketnu Pto"ft&l,
 oti -W ?>m ofN of mhuctr /w.

                 PMtf$ OF6*1   •^
         foA, p7l

           ttPPFUMlfT PLFAO MbT&Uilrf/tuJO TAB (Mb vJhf
           TrUBh Tb a JMi/.. CO. VbL.3. l>< W)

              IK/OfCTEO OFF&X&E. Cfc(L»FhU3, fi, !>/)

         f^fwflt ftwm<szmm atsdv^^ oB^^m^r.

KI'* -

                                                          /M^/2? 4W

               -, . ...aViii-n^aiial^JLiijJO^i. -   ... . .„. . . . .   .,..../ ...-.'-(, -..^ .Aeti.ett^£K^fiiiiii.to^;silii
               \<S&U&S PpffS&fffib.

i me ®iwu6 at itt&mmtKTb pms bisf^i Mtum t%-
6ma&j$ gFF\(X\\j& cdi4s&jtt:

U1%F7M#0 CMnFF FhMO F>J OWlM/FlM MteUUtotTiT tfUeeffod
 7o TiJF'AOtofitfi>/J op ft (^l4/tt;£pF/T/(JhJ, -mFfi/^iFF fcti;
 bifr&Fo &j 7t& Cftitmi/*i& wTm&rf 70 AttfU,toiT#m&
 oite&rtffij of Tig- fioUce.

             Qmf gbMFo

"*T<*i>m. W^iw. ^m,leriQU ^ ^
             STttFMFtfT 6FfA0fT

A0FIM/SF WPfS CtfkhyffiO v>IVi 6U/b&iAto/ dFPr BOiWlAfti &J &tf
 IKi 01 CrTM&srr W4i CM Z&AQS. IU 'TUtF MIfrMF KUD ®lTUF
Portions*/OF Trie (TFhTifoTTFXfr^, TUir&Miua duo/ dp qmaaq

 io-w o£ of o?ce«m, A.0.W3 *iv*£^¥o$$%?
 ztsfBh/tt mm rrirfiod wntMT -pb~ efmmvircMSetrr <fF ^r^c/te'^ww

 wsmur Kwitiff nkM6MM4&'flucrrTMume' *m Fu&mf)l

OF^^l^^^g^^*^
 tawrum SF ^r ***//^^sf^w/ffiaF**^
•••™^ft*sd>*v&          /^. I*TUTCMMMK;Stover
  *<*>* mo rmr fi^/i n mr as^^Z^Tntr

  Ml* ilaT0aFAimfTi/&l$ CO,/I, pj)                           'i
                    PMf/2'6F(&