Court Opinion

ID: 4048424
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:38:58.637934+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:26.892510
License: Public Domain

..   ;......--:-·-   .            IJJ ThL.
                              3' Wt t\ u\ 0\ s\-'(\c.\- t ou r.\-v-P-
                                       A-~Pea.\_)
                                A-u~~\(\ 1Tt?ti~S

                             oN ~SL A\0lL~            Pt..o SE
                         ~BT-r:\ron Fo((. 'J\J (.TI c:>f JV\~NfH4-1ttt~
                         F{:.oM T\\5 2io5)__lD\~~\(J-Cuuf+-
                         Tr\a\ tour~ tuuse_JJo FlD-731\0-R.

                                 \(~on  "\Nut\ CJ.te!_
                                L ~ 't,\~\-ur Prc seJ.
                                           vs
                               3 & JJcJJtF-[~ f!JENJJITT
                              } ud.~~ 9-tas-+-l OLS\-rtcl (wr t-
                                    I~ (~S\0otd e11 ~"]

                                                            REC·EIVED lN
                                                          IOOU\\t rJF CRIM1NAt AP~A\.S
                                                                  MAY 2i t01S
                                                             A~®i~~,Ci@i1k
  R~Cl "\J\JCt llDLe__
. [ Re..\cAo r Prose1                                                                                      L.r'\ T\,\e..
           vs.                                                                                              C:our~ ottJ\M.It¥t{
   3" e.(\"\ t.er ~ei\()P\+                                                                                 AP~e_c<l.s
    D.to5+k 0 ist-rlc...\-t.oui\- ·                                                                         tCLPi~P\ s-\4\-iol\
                                                                                                            Au~~~/\ ~TtiC6   .

                                                                     P··eJi \-Lon ror '\1\Jf\t-   or 111\al!doMU~
-To ·.,-\t1 L \-\ov1 ~rnb1e.- J ud&e~~
            toM eS l) ow , R:vCL!l '\.1\Xin ett e 1 s~'/-\eel \ru:fe_\ 11 cc{:\-~ If' Q5~ Re\edor ''
Pru se.. if\ \-'t4e.. et&1oye_ e_n~,\-\ed of\d f\ufv1btfed tetuse_, a_I)A res.feG\4UUY
~(e&en\-s +\tiS P~~1 \-\ufl ~ur wf\\-0f fVtCt11dcuVluS. IllSLti>Por\-oC~LS
Pe\-\~\on 1 Re\£J~-of' wt\\ el1ow ~6 \\oV1orob\e_trur.\- ~\e ~l\Ck.VVt~~
                                                                     0 tcJe.JVlitt+- ~ l.CL s.~
     o/1   t=eb ~, c9-ot5" ~"'e ~e_\cJor ~~\eA                                    Ct   Mol-\ on     For 0-esi~l'd-ed
tr\c.\ fec_o(J~,·\ n ~e 2.l.o5.\-k 0\~tr\c\- t(J.J.f.\-                 .               .                ·
 . L 1'1 APr i\ o-C.iu 15" L Sel\~ c._ \ e.t \ en-'o ~e J_f.,.J l-1.-D is \i ic\-C.VUr\- ~.1:. i 119 I+'
\\t't V\&-vt. ru\ eJ oft \\c {Y\u~ \on,
           to de\-~, Qe_\et\-o/nuSJ\o~ (e_e_e_i.veJal\\1 tovreSPotlde.ti.e.. frotvL ·
  Qes~ondeJ\\- vr \k.. tftu\ c.uuf\- ftelCtfchn~ hiS (cq,rue* \-ose\ ~e...(Y!ottol\.. ·
  )\tfu'\11\!1 L:.Lt t0 r ~~ 0wl0e.- \-0 MtJ£.~ ru\t"~ , \V\ ~ s 00\on
                     ·                 8-\Ct\-eMen+- C)~Juftsd\L~gn
   under Ti+\e_:J.. t ustA- Set.\\of\ \.65\ Lu.l~ 11w\\ef\ ~ wrt\-oCVV!DI\da{ILus
·i-S SDU~~l-\- ~(oM. Clf\ CtfJ~e_l\Ct\e.. t.ru'f~ \-o c_oi\.QI\e_, CtJ-f(Ct\ ~t~ \-0 C{
\Ctw~u.\ ~-tr tise.- C'>f h-s. ~(6Lfl1ed Qu~rtW -1\.c::..twl\-'2,\.tou)J. \ssve              1

t\e wr\\- odfv\osi-~ct~
                   . ·..,,,. \ .I
                                  a N1cA+ef' ckt:_ou1Se..'                              0

           >            \~\~'\'                 f '
                                ·,      ~\          I
                            •   ~ ~'I   •'   ;.!.       '   I

                                 ~~~.~-;· ~.'~ ' .
                                        . ' ·.• .               ·t
      L: t1 ctt:-ords \tJ\~ \~G-ovetV\fV!61t Lod~ 8eG~toll ¢2·11\lbJct.J '
I ir1 Per\.:lfl{_fl\- ~cutJ: e:u& tour-\- e* I+PPec.\ .s, Lco4l.\2ur &d\&triG-\-(liJci/
                            1

 i~su~ wf\t- ~ mcd~e\ttMu.S CL_L'jc:J()St- et 0ud5e..~CA d\ks\-1\L\--&ur-i-tl)
~"e__ toq c\istrtc\- 1' J-n re__ ~Mi\lll Y;fVttjJan\d, Jucl£je_, whel\ et
 ~e_-\-\Hon ~or wd+- vf fVl~nd~m~ \.5> C; \eJ ~C{l"~\- ~e~Ltcl8E:D~a
 Ats~r\ L~ twJ \- ~( ~-e_\-\ \.\un s\OLt\cl be ~\~elltee\ ~rs\- \-o ~C.OOU'lleSS
+V\ere.- iS ~     L_ofVIQel\Ln~ ftCtSo/1 flu\-~ clu8o ~r                 :Lc\ \l'lSw&:l )S-a~(1D(
 tr ~~~ ],
    C.-1iVf/\   t~e_se_ f.d\c...\-S   I   t\e_ f\llCcYlclu{\,{L£~ fdie__t b~.l()?) S,~eJkt-~0Q(Il~t­
-\--h( ~uct9t o~ ~\~ 2J~5~0is\-r\c1twv-\-, \ies~\t-h\/\~~G.PPe)lctk
 ~·u-r\&d\c}\uV) ·c* ~S Li.Ltr~- n~ \t\\rc\ ·0\S.\-r{[\.-tLJ!t\-~
                                          ·M\1e~~~~Aff80
 ~e.\o1-6r seeKs fYlu11dcal!JUS (e\\e_~ tlo~ ~~ \\uf\Ofet6}~&-ur+- t-D
 toM ~d \-{._e._ \:\ OJ\dcbk J e.nrl\-{! ~~ ee()fle__WJ ~~e.s. ic\·, !)_").)Lid& e.oC 4-~
 n-l/5--\.L 0\Str\L\ l.Lur\- \-o se~ fur h'€.CtrCrJ£1 D.£ ftA~ Dl) W~Pendt{)j ;

 \. L. Y\ avt r-ete_ \ved ll o t Afurtv1 Ot~ iVI\ sk \-ci.11 :J ~cJ.- +'ke (k0 ·\-lu .1\ \1\ ~5 6 L'ell
-C~\e& \n ~L 0\.S\r\L\- t\efl(J ~Le.
 9-. rvto~\oJ\ 'v\.ttS bet1\ Q-ef)c\\ '1~ e;ver Ct{e..COortublen.V\1outtt~& .\-\{}1 e_
 ~. ~~~''oovi\- nlJ-f~ bee11 Se11l c\-uSct~ud- b-f- JIU~Y1dcfttli5
                                          · (tr~u~ei\.\-
    Wi"'\~ v\t~ Cif~uf\1tf\~' Re.\G-\-or o.velS ~eLS e_f\\-i-\--\ed \-Dda4\-iv'\..
.,,fV\DtY\d£1A{)1US ·fe\\ e-C ~oM ~t S [oCt 'o®USe..ke \IL~S ~kt_us\---ed ef.Corf--5
     \-o Q-ef~ur ~~ef fY\;IJ[S\-'tr\u\ Au~'/ \-o ru\-G u~o114 se_+ 'vlecdUII~ ~f'    ·
    .Qti)A~J\lb f\t1o~\on Sec 1:Aft- ~ {D!tJ.S t~l S"Wsd ~ ~) LT~ fffi?- ~'1 A-rt.NnD&.
                                    1
             ·1Ju~ \-o ~e1)0ondel\t S Qi\ure_ \-o Cte..\--, Re\ck.>rt:U\ no~SeeK
OJ\      CiP~eet\ O.l\d ~ere rore.. Y\c6 flO o\--\((' nde.CtUcte_ (@_Med'/ Gt\- \etw~ e_~
 MetAdGffluS re\tef'b {ts ru\eJ \ f\ _1\ecuJ\ t o~l-tr Pcaeot-ui~ltte.S ore
                                                         1

me__\- ~or Se_e\(i~ fY\tif\c1~MUS {t,\ltt: \-o(ectuire.. \-r\u\ tour\- \-d(u\e.c:>ll
~-e.nd\11~ fi\D~~OJ)S, 1\e. ~ \'\CtS ~urt~cl \d-'loA l\-u di (efr ~ \.<\Q\
tour~ \-o totlS\d<V' ~/\& rule., on Pt:ndtll.c, Met.~~erS i \ .Lol T.n re sJai~ ·.
     fclq ~oull~ 1 D\~t A-t-tYv (o).Ltolf.~ lo ~w8d ~oi1J. \ol.T~~r fipp);
 e!J..
· stu\-~ ed..fe._\ ~~\ v B'~l to~ ~L\ swBd ~L{, D(d-1 Lr~ tr ~Pf<i
                     g

        -~s \s ~\eM ~ruM. ~e \u~or~ \6-\.e.rs i-3 ~ \-4tol C!.wr \-(;(rJ
~sectuef\+- Jfvlotiol\ \-o tuv'li!PeJ 1 \\e. ~Ct5 re9ec.~ed\V Pu-\-ee.sPOtdt'Af,
l!ltl (lo~\Le., ~\Ct~ "'e Set'Cs ~c 2b5 tltuL<r-t 's ud-\u"'J(c\c.t-ovhcD
wtll~ ~loltll r-e.CftU\reMe'1~S e>rch )i8Jet.\-~oVI \~VtA.Ded u.Pu~ Vt\~Y-11~
\ tL-P D.t ~ i e.-\~ L/·L ol lCJ.-\ J ., L1 to.rt\ic6~ \-u Re \u~o \[ ~ ~far b t+ke.-
K.f~cideA~ V\Ct5 \JJ"'ol\'1 ~\ed \-c l.JDI'V!P)'f/ \1\J\~ ~\(~Peerttde.f
 ~Lt . o3 al\d (olf. dt (LL\es &l)d t scAt~ \"bet& ~ci~~bY Fo{'ltltJ t-o
~a-c\ Re\cAor ~e. frufeSS\oral Cv\J LDIL1fhu/\ euur~eS"' c.fetllVuJal-ktt
res ~oi\Se. ~c.:>hiS tf.:>( f6fondett~ Ctil& f.tCflu~s~ ~d! QtG\-\L\1\      I

     Lf\ ~CLDfdultte_,w\~l ~ T~ e_ukct-3uo\\m\ to11d~e~,
taADI1 3L6 j   Ll 011cl q I I\ n Per t;nt.fl\- Pw 8; i\.~uc\9-e_shct\\~eOf'
c.t-1cl Aet\d~ cAl ~uu\icic.t\ MCt\-k!S CtSs\.9rte& \-u ~e.-~'-tct9Jeo.lld rule
                            \   ~                   •\

d~~o~c: ck ~eM PfoftlP~\Y' e:CC\utl)\-1'/, etnd ~r\eY                           ·'t
                           Lll'1S'Wo(UJ l£Lll4~\~\Idi
                                                 '   .

    L\~e_, bo~ ~~«o\ Lu\ULc?-~Ll.S·L~l£4lo)af'cl ~\ckL.u'W
Lv.T .L.. f+ l,\v\\ Proc~(:6 ?teiY\cedl€~ tudG~ \32~w)-t3~~cLB)
~n&tcs iAtllfL~ttk& \t1 ·rt(e/~ VvtJ'-lf uSe., a-L UllS\UOfY\ d~ru~tbr\ ·
                       r
U /\J ~r P.t~ \\-'f at f fJ uflf l fl r\Otte_. c.t 0t \JlJ(\ \-\et1 deL~ CvcJ[O IlL 1
vlfi~t&~~ul\ , t.er~i~tLCJ LoA ~ru~~ l!/rc£+ ~Jov(~ b\UOfll bekl"e Aio·k!/
f-tQub\~L

            T'lBCLil\JJCt\lue..., l t3543>X, be\m PreSeflULf tllffiQ:e.ttkJ in
 0 &\ Yl ~· ton~ll~ LlA(~,;" Ketrvt~S tu..u1~Y ,(foC&~dedetrcu;def'
 ~.P 1\e.~ ~\( ~r d Pr.i':Mt'f t-l.c.l-- ~ ~(t1ut~ \ s \-ft{e ~e_c,Jied-.
   ·'

     '\f\lhefe ~ore.. Pf ~Y'v\\S~ ton~idctfeJ , Qeb\-or PreY~ ~~ titis
ttonorob\e twr \- l:r rec/t\- ~ _s t We\\- & Met ndcavus 1ct:tl\cl e:>rder
 ~ \<.esrondefl~ \-o set- \or \Leetri~ {2/r rulee>'l \,.(s 9e;10\~11:1
 Mo~\uV) ~or ..-.rrietl fe.L.ords
         T\t ~lckor ·QCe StJt\s Uas \JJ r\\- \f) ~le., \llt€f eS\-ck~L.O)-ic_e..,
O.t\cl~r no \2&SM of de\c,Y o~er ~ ~LLS\-tLt: 'Dci~cdMillicJtrd<
o.Acl ~or ~G~ trur~ \-0 oo\-\orze...c.t/l CL~\on +t'oiVl ·~!l~o~\0~f\c.r
 tour\- Mel \ts ~ur\9ej r fl ~~_s (Y\Ct{-1-er

   \tesPed-~UY Su.bn1 it 'red r

 ~DMS(cJkrJ2_,
  ~e_\ator~TOu~-\ l53543K
   tonnr.~\ \\f UA\\-
        ~q~   FM fa~;)_
  \~e!lt&Y, T~ -z%n~