Court Opinion

ID: 9411683
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2023-07-27 17:01:02.62666+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:41:08.865668
License: Public Domain

012ÿ4567686029 ÿ
                                          ÿ
                     09268ÿ2 26 ÿ71 52ÿ1ÿ446 ÿ
                           15ÿ26ÿ2958ÿ7957 92ÿ
                                  ÿ
                                          ÿ
                                   0ÿÿ
                                          ÿ
                                  ÿ
                                          ÿ
                            7029ÿÿ41 97ÿ
                                   ÿÿÿÿÿÿ
                                          ÿ
                                         !ÿ
                                          ÿ
        659ÿ" 5ÿ"7 0856#$ÿ715415 ÿ655ÿ"7 %$ÿÿ
                       715415 ÿ&5608 ÿ%11 6ÿ
                                  ÿ
                                          ÿ
                  1ÿÿ'()ÿ*ÿ+,ÿ -ÿ8+-(+.ÿ7/(ÿÿ
                      '(ÿ*ÿ"+,,ÿ8+-(+.ÿ'ÿ4-0!+ÿÿ
                            187ÿ0ÿ23.!334ÿ
                   8+-(+.ÿ5/,67ÿ(8ÿ58(ÿ8ÿ"(++ÿ
                                  ÿ
                                          ÿ
                  /8)+,ÿ4/(-/ÿÿ2*+(,ÿ7+(./+ÿ5ÿ2914ÿ
                                  5/ÿ:ÿ32ÿ
                                          ÿ
           &'(7ÿÿ415265ÿ566" 0ÿ,ÿ965ÿ;<=>?<@ÿB?CDEFÿ
                                          ÿ
                              1+,7ÿÿ5/0ÿGÿ324ÿ
                                  ÿ
                                          ÿ H
                                     1490910ÿ
                                  ÿ
ÿ
965ÿ;<=>?<@ÿB?CDEÿ

     Hÿ
                        ÿ
      2*+-ÿ,+--++ÿ+-ÿÿÿ++ÿ'ÿ*ÿ'/ÿ7/(ÿ,ÿ/(-/ÿÿ914ÿ:Gÿ
,-ÿÿ.-+/ÿ8+,+6ÿ(.,ÿ
ÿ
        2345678ÿ9 7 ÿÿ8 88448ÿ2 453ÿ67ÿ8ÿ 4ÿ2 8ÿ
3ÿ 6ÿ84ÿ53ÿ48ÿ 3ÿ4ÿ!1ÿ"##2#ÿ$ÿ%&'(#%ÿÿ)845ÿ5ÿ567ÿ
88ÿ6ÿ8ÿ56ÿ4845ÿ)785ÿ6ÿ*75ÿ+4+45ÿ765ÿ5ÿ8 ÿ56ÿ
   5ÿ,3ÿ8774ÿ5ÿ57+3ÿ)ÿ ÿ4ÿ6ÿ584ÿ6,84ÿ74ÿ8ÿ585ÿ8574#ÿ
9 7 ÿ8ÿ8ÿ56ÿ83ÿ74ÿ)7ÿ8+ 45ÿ5ÿ5878574ÿ74ÿ)78574ÿÿ56ÿ*75ÿ
+4+45-6ÿ68ÿ)73ÿ45ÿ8ÿ745ÿ74ÿ8ÿ75ÿ88745ÿ 4ÿ84ÿ
ÿ5ÿ5ÿ67ÿ84783ÿÿ67#ÿ.6ÿ7575ÿ2 5ÿ7+7ÿ6ÿ +8745ÿ
   4 74ÿ9 7 ÿ87ÿ5ÿ585ÿ8ÿ87+ÿ84ÿ)4ÿ7ÿ6ÿ68ÿ56ÿ4845ÿÿ
4575ÿ5ÿ/877ÿ7++4753#ÿ0ÿ8ÿ5685ÿ9 7 ÿ87ÿ5ÿ585ÿ8ÿ87+ÿÿÿ7ÿ
87+ÿ7565ÿ8674ÿ/877ÿ7++4753#1ÿ
        064ÿ)88574ÿ8ÿ+ 574ÿ5ÿ7+7ÿÿ87ÿ5ÿ585ÿ8ÿ87+ÿÿ1%2ÿ85785ÿ
56ÿ+45ÿÿ56ÿ87+3ÿ112ÿ)7ÿ56ÿ +8745ÿ7874ÿ+87ÿ758574ÿÿ
56ÿ+45ÿ8ÿ 4 74ÿ84ÿ568,8ÿÿ857)ÿ885743ÿ84ÿ
1(2ÿ5+74ÿ656ÿ56ÿ4ÿ88574ÿ87,3ÿ8ÿ8ÿ87+ÿ,3ÿ8774ÿ8ÿ
848,ÿ558574ÿ56ÿ7ÿ,ÿ)74ÿÿ8ÿ+45ÿÿ56ÿ87+#(ÿÿ
        67897:;<ÿ>:7?ÿ@ABB:CDEFÿCB8:Gÿ7?87ÿ?H9ÿ9:<?7ÿ7Aÿ8CCHFFÿ7?HÿCAI97Fÿ>8FÿJ:AB87HKÿI;KH9ÿ
        %ÿ
                              ÿ
          9 7 ÿÿ 4ÿ74ÿ,56ÿ67ÿ778ÿ84ÿ747)78ÿ88757#ÿ6ÿÿ
 16ÿ84ÿ 3ÿ74ÿ567ÿ747)78ÿ88757#ÿÿ
         ÿ.6ÿ7575ÿ2 5ÿ68ÿL77574ÿ4ÿ1'ÿ"##2#ÿ$ÿ%((%ÿ18ÿ/5742#ÿ
.67ÿ2 5ÿ68ÿL77574ÿ4ÿ1'ÿ"##2#ÿ$ÿ%1&%ÿ1748ÿ774ÿÿ7575ÿ 52#ÿ0ÿ
)7ÿÿ4)ÿ56ÿ845ÿÿ8ÿ+ 574ÿ5ÿ7+7#ÿMNOÿQRÿSTUQRÿNVÿWXUYRÿ&Z%ÿ*#(ÿ1[(ÿ1['ÿ
1(ÿ27(#ÿ1[1[2#ÿ
         ÿ\]^_ÿQRÿ̀Na^VNbUNÿcOXNQOadÿeYYNXYRfÿ\\gÿ!&ÿ*#!56ÿ(1(ÿ(1hi1'ÿ1(ÿ27#ÿ1[112#ÿ
                                                ÿ
                                               1ÿ
ÿ
234ÿ56782ÿ9 4 42ÿ834ÿ68ÿ834ÿ8ÿ74424ÿ7 ÿ766ÿÿ8224ÿ72ÿ862ÿ
484ÿ234ÿ44 28ÿ64ÿ2ÿ442ÿ84764ÿ6ÿ232ÿ862ÿ6ÿ82ÿ4ÿÿÿ
 !"!#$%&"'"()*ÿ"$ÿ,$-(,.'/ÿ(!0/$'1%!-ÿ2',%3*4ÿ,!0ÿ567ÿ!"ÿ$/3/01ÿ89,8ÿ3,1ÿ./ÿ,:,$0/0ÿ
,)ÿ$/2"3;/!)/*ÿ2347ÿ23ÿ6ÿÿ46ÿÿ488ÿ862<ÿ=34ÿ682762ÿ>72ÿ ÿ6ÿ
 '")8*ÿ!"89%!-?ÿ,!0?ÿ89/$/#"$/?ÿ0%0ÿ!"8ÿ4ÿÿ2ÿ6@7ABÿC/ÿ,-$//BÿD"''%2EF8ÿ8224ÿ
72ÿ862ÿ68ÿ64 ÿ ÿ234ÿ4ÿ44 2ÿ38ÿ44ÿ8474ÿÿ
       6ÿ6328ÿ2368ÿ86ÿAÿ76ÿ84764ÿ8ÿ4ÿÿ347ÿ48274ÿ
38 ÿAÿ247ÿ834ÿ662624ÿ347ÿGÿHI1ÿ26ÿ=38ÿ8ÿ834ÿ248ÿ62ÿ234ÿ44 28ÿ
2Aÿ6@74ÿ347ÿAÿ74426ÿ347ÿ7 ÿ786ÿ347ÿ8224ÿ72ÿ862ÿ26ÿ834ÿ84ÿ
234 ÿ2ÿ442ÿ84764ÿAÿ86ÿ234 ÿJ447ÿ6ÿ7Aÿ88 48ÿ232ÿ34ÿ834ÿ
64ÿ347ÿGÿHI1ÿ 62ÿ234ÿ44 28ÿ3ÿ74Aÿ424ÿ6ÿ8476ÿ347ÿ48274ÿ
38 ÿ=34Aÿ3ÿ2ÿÿ
       K!ÿD/!!)1'&,!%,?ÿ)/$&%2/ÿ3()8ÿ./ÿ3,0/ÿ:%89%!ÿLMÿ0,1)ÿ,#8/$ÿ89/ÿ%))(,!2/ÿ"#ÿ89/ÿ
:$%8ÿ"$ÿ89/ÿ#%'%!-ÿ"#ÿ89/ÿ2"3;',%!8B*NÿOÿ$/%))(/0?ÿ$/%!)8,8/0?ÿ"$ÿ)(.)8%8(8/0ÿ:$%8ÿ"$ÿ
 62ÿ83ÿ4ÿ8474ÿ6236ÿ1PÿA8ÿ247ÿ746884ÿ7468224 42ÿ7ÿ8826226Qÿ
6ÿ64ÿ347ÿ6782ÿ7464ÿÿ982ÿRNÿRPRPÿS ÿT424 47ÿPÿRPRPÿÿ
U,2E,:,!!,ÿV"(!81ÿW9/$%##F)ÿX##%2/ÿ0/;(81ÿ#%'/0ÿ,ÿW9/$%##F)ÿY/8($!*ÿ%!0%2,8%!-ÿ89,8ÿ9/ÿ

      <ÿ
                          ÿ
       Z[\]^_`a[b\ÿdeÿfg\hi\jÿN1QÿkTÿ<P1ÿ<NlQÿRPPRÿ
      Nÿ
       R1ÿÿ>4ÿGÿ<Pÿÿ
      Qÿ
       R1ÿÿ>4ÿGÿ<P<ÿ
                                         ÿ
                                         1ÿ
ÿ
2345ÿ6789ÿ8 8 5 68ÿ352ÿ3ÿ595ÿ759ÿ5ÿ979ÿ55ÿÿ1ÿ ÿ
55259ÿÿ7ÿ34ÿ!ÿ7ÿ9585ÿ59ÿ9ÿ76ÿ8227 ÿÿ953954ÿ5ÿ
9"43"ÿ7ÿ679ÿ595ÿ#5ÿ43"ÿ359ÿ7ÿ55259ÿ$%ÿ%%ÿ5ÿ325454ÿ5ÿ
9ÿ8ÿ5&54'ÿ5ÿ45345ÿ7ÿ 759ÿ$%ÿ%%ÿ7ÿ5ÿ7225 54ÿÿ8ÿ
3'3 ÿ5ÿ(56543ÿ"ÿ6'ÿ59ÿ79'3ÿ723ÿ7ÿ 759ÿ$ÿ%%ÿ 4ÿ7ÿ
*+,-./0ÿ234ÿ25254ÿ,6/ÿ76/0899:;ÿ*998+/ÿ;<++/;;9<==>ÿ;/0?/@ÿA-==8+B:;ÿ/;,0CDE/@ÿ6<;.CD@ÿ
ÿ5ÿ9ÿ76ÿ8227 ÿÿ
        F5ÿ7ÿ354ÿÿ37ÿ7ÿ 759ÿ$ÿ%%ÿ5ÿ(56543ÿÿ34ÿ
8ÿ 759ÿ$%ÿ%%ÿ7ÿ5665ÿ595ÿ 4ÿ5ÿ7ÿ5ÿ534ÿ456543ÿ3ÿÿ63ÿ
 5954ÿ56795ÿ5ÿ5&937ÿ76ÿ5ÿ9"43"ÿ7ÿ7ÿ 759ÿ$ÿ%%GÿH5956795ÿ
  7ÿÿ7ÿI34ÿ3ÿ559Jÿ95554ÿ6972ÿ898'ÿ59ÿ35ÿ789ÿ32ÿ7ÿÿ
C=;-ÿK0-DEÿ,6C,ÿ;6/ÿL;6-K/@ÿ3ÿM89"ÿ 5ÿ5ÿ34ÿ7ÿ3"ÿ!ÿ7ÿ9585ÿ3ÿ9ÿ34ÿ
 784ÿ7ÿ35ÿ55ÿ67954ÿ7ÿ3"ÿ3ÿ3278ÿ5385ÿ555ÿ53"ÿ784ÿ35ÿ
;/0?/@ÿ,6/ÿ=/C@ÿ@/9/D@CD,ÿ.<,ÿ8D,/D,8-DC==>ÿ+6-;/ÿD-,ÿ,-NOÿP5"ÿÿH5ÿ(56543ÿ2345ÿ
6789ÿ352ÿ3ÿ595ÿ979ÿ7ÿ7ÿ3"'ÿ7ÿ9585ÿ5ÿ9ÿ 4ÿ87ÿÿ
9583 5ÿ5"ÿ8 55454ÿÿ59'ÿ59ÿ834ÿQ32'ÿ5ÿ(56543ÿ573"ÿ

      ÿ7 ÿ
                          ÿ
      Gÿ
              3354ÿÿ6792ÿ7ÿ59ÿ723ÿÿÿ3 8ÿÿ
       Rÿ59ÿ95"ÿ7ÿ754ÿ3ÿ574ÿ456543ÿ5ÿ348ÿ4ÿ76ÿ59ÿ593'54ÿ
834ÿ95454ÿÿ2ÿÿ5 "33ÿ34ÿ784ÿ35ÿ55ÿ5954ÿ3ÿ5ÿ325ÿ25ÿ
P5"ÿ$S1ÿT8ÿ7ÿ354ÿÿ39'825ÿÿ59ÿ-U/D8DEÿ.08/9VÿLW68;ÿ+C;/ÿ@-/;ÿD-,ÿ
453ÿÿ5ÿ595ÿ76ÿ5ÿ35'54ÿ787635ÿ495ÿ7ÿ74ÿ555ÿ5ÿ784ÿ7ÿ
C++/U,ÿ;/0?8+/ÿ-Dÿ,6/80ÿ./6C=9NOÿXUU/==CD,ÿY0NÿZ5ÿDNZNÿ
                                              ÿ
                                             1ÿ
ÿ
23456ÿ748ÿ84ÿ699628ÿ56 26ÿ5ÿ 6256ÿ836ÿ548ÿ49ÿ8366ÿ6847ÿ2485ÿ56ÿ
367ÿ687ÿÿ4847ÿ84ÿ555ÿ35ÿ42ÿ35ÿ66ÿ74ÿ7ÿÿ
        ÿ"#$ÿ%#&&'()*ÿ4836ÿ+ 58ÿ,67678ÿ2ÿ536ÿ665ÿ838ÿ836ÿ-6967785ÿ
96ÿ84ÿ699628ÿ56 26ÿ84ÿ6886ÿ758ÿ36ÿ94ÿ3 7ÿ6 656786ÿÿ7899ÿ7ÿÿ 4ÿ
58ÿ758ÿ476ÿ49ÿ836ÿ-6967785ÿ.2,76ÿ7ÿ94ÿ36ÿ23426ÿ748ÿ84ÿ5 48ÿ3ÿ7ÿ
35ÿÿ94ÿ/3699ÿ4ÿ 7ÿÿ68847ÿ2ÿ42ÿ58ÿ60ÿ1234ÿ247588847ÿ
  486286ÿ24728ÿ254ÿ6884ÿ2847ÿ5992678ÿ84ÿ686ÿÿ6547ÿ49ÿ47ÿ97655ÿ
94ÿ666257ÿ35ÿ74ÿ368ÿ385ÿ7ÿ294ÿÿ25ÿ7ÿ68667ÿ836ÿ247588847ÿ
  486286ÿ24728ÿ7ÿ836ÿ6884ÿ2847:3;ÿ36ÿ958ÿ6< 6678ÿ5ÿ58596ÿ7549ÿ
5ÿ42ÿ35ÿ836ÿ+ 58ÿ,67678ÿ38ÿ84ÿ697ÿ94ÿ482ÿ5542847533ÿ8ÿ8ÿ5ÿ
748ÿ26ÿ9ÿ42ÿ27ÿ2ÿ+ 58ÿ,67678ÿ 4862847ÿ47ÿ36ÿ47ÿ639ÿ94ÿ
 6 656787ÿÿ267835ÿ,5ÿ84ÿ836ÿ56247ÿ6< 6678ÿ42ÿ665ÿ836ÿ-6967785ÿ
 6956ÿ84ÿ66ÿ836ÿ 8ÿ49ÿ5475ÿ7ÿ838ÿ66ÿ698ÿ7ÿ56 26ÿ5ÿÿ
 6884ÿ28ÿ8ÿ5ÿ6676ÿ46ÿ836ÿ-6967785ÿ58ÿ3ÿ46ÿ84ÿ665ÿ84ÿ699628ÿ
56 26ÿ367ÿ42ÿ96ÿ36ÿ=ÿ3>9ÿ2ÿ/4ÿ8ÿ5ÿ844ÿ6ÿ84ÿ5ÿ836ÿ6956ÿ84ÿ

      ÿ
                          ÿ
        ?@ABCÿEÿ+E83ÿ8ÿ95FG5>ÿ
      3;ÿ
      33ÿ
         HIJKLMÿNOÿPQRSTOÿHUTOÿEV9ÿ+9ÿ5>1ÿ5Vÿ29ÿW ÿ5;;V4ÿ
         X@ALQÿNOÿXST@YZ[\LQÿ]L^A_ÿJÿ̀PZZOÿEFÿa/ÿV5ÿFVÿ23;4ÿ238ÿ84ÿ554286ÿ
'b(&cde35ÿ$'fghÿh#ÿ1b#hÿi #('ihe:4ÿ
         ÿjSSÿSOkOCÿlJNJMSZMm_ÿNOÿn^JUQÿ>55ÿ+9ÿ9E5ÿ911ÿ2F83ÿW ÿ5;3V4ÿ238ÿ668675ÿ
84ÿ836ÿ878ÿ748ÿ35ÿ247564oÿpSB[YJNÿNOÿqZZSQÿE33ÿ+9ÿF35ÿF5;G53ÿ2V83ÿW 5;;14ÿ
rb#ÿ$e(#fb'h'#bÿ#"ÿibÿihh#$bes*ÿt'$hÿuebduebhÿ$'fghÿ'bdevebdebhÿ#"ÿg'ÿ(&'ebh*ÿ'bÿhgeÿ
2478668ÿ49ÿÿ2ÿ 426674ÿÿ
                                             ÿ
                                             1ÿ
ÿ
2345637ÿ893ÿ758ÿ ÿ ÿ2ÿ89ÿ5 543ÿ 7ÿ893ÿ8ÿ963ÿ58832ÿ893ÿ44332ÿ
7384587ÿ8ÿ2ÿ363ÿ5ÿ853ÿ8ÿ3763ÿ92ÿ35732ÿ58ÿÿ9724ÿ3ÿ52ÿ898ÿ893ÿ
!ÿ234ÿ5ÿ3765ÿÿ78ÿ5ÿ3ÿ58ÿ 42ÿ23837ÿÿ37 ÿ ÿ7257ÿ573 ÿ
 7ÿ33755ÿ937ÿ7598ÿ ÿ3 ÿ8ÿ893ÿ78ÿ7ÿ937ÿ7598ÿ8ÿ 583ÿ458544"#ÿ
7254ÿ$445%ÿ5432ÿ8ÿ883ÿÿ&578ÿ3238ÿ7384585ÿ45ÿÿÿ
       &7ÿ8933ÿ73 ÿ3ÿ544ÿ 57ÿÿ

      "#ÿ
                           ÿ
        '43ÿ ÿ454ÿ44332ÿ7384585ÿ5423ÿÿ55458ÿ5 5ÿ
()**+,-ÿ,*/ÿ0*0)ÿ0123,40*5ÿ*ÿ,ÿ/6207!ÿ,38*49ÿ:;<=>?@ABCÿEFÿGHIFÿJKÿ
L?MFÿ#NOÿ&#2ÿPQRÿPQQÿS#2ÿT57ÿPUURVWÿÿ3437ÿ325ÿÿ3433ÿ 7ÿÿ
&3 %ÿ 8ÿ785ÿ45854ÿ25283ÿX;YAZ<JÿEFÿ[JZJB\=ÿJKÿ]^Fÿ_@A;ZÿO""ÿ&ÿ
`ÿ#2ÿOROÿOO"aOPÿSbcÿ$ÿPUP"VWÿ2ÿÿ8 95ÿ3d44ÿ3 75ÿe5ÿ
73485ÿ58ÿÿ63738ÿ8787ÿ*ÿ70*ÿ40ÿ4ÿ0f*!ÿ7+ÿ8ÿÿ58ÿ
54ÿ3385ÿ];gg>ZgJ?ÿEFÿhACC;A?>@@;ÿN1Oÿ&ÿ̀ÿP2ÿONiÿOiOai1ÿScjkÿPU"PVÿ
3232ÿi#Pÿ&ÿ̀ÿP2ÿ1P1ÿScjkÿPU"#Vÿÿ
                                             ÿ
                                            1ÿ