Court Opinion

ID: 4066654
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 22:44:22.508852+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:51:48.418608
License: Public Domain

<1>~13~-0/                        j\
                            Th v\Jv{__              Cou-if' C,a,u& '<: N {/ ~ //4 -er; ~ - J:3
                                                                 ~
                                                                 I
                                                     This documint contains some
                                                     pages that are of poor qucUiD.f
                                                  ~1\Mhftime of imaging. f-:.N.
     Vr      v
                                                                 I

                                                                             o 5?- Cht''nt~XIA4. kPPett/v
'f1-t f S-/cJ-e.           t7   Jz-       /f1ip/..Jt,S                       JiuJfr~              1         7fAtlS

                                                                                            ~           .---- .....            .                    . 'I
                                                                                            '\_         '

                                                                                            j     ·~   £. ~·I   •:... ..
                                                                                                                                    '
                                                                                                                                    '
                                                                                                                                        ·,       \ •'
                                                                                                                                                        ~
                                                                                                                                                        \:   '

                                                                                                                                        ,, · '     '. ~,.,}
                                                                                                                                                 't.J-  €'·

  0 eaA1          C~e;Jv'A            1

                 fl..e.o.&e_ fZ-t'McL CJ.u:.losed 'rlt~ Oht/w'lu.dl.c, ~ Yi 'f! ol
               Po.._ L..-e.c~vtltL CLM-11 tt ~(J(J~t'c_~ O'nvtN')u_~
\b.- M-v-i'f-;,'-CJ1'\                                   11

MPA-~·c.cd--1 o111 ?P1.. CU h /9- o b< Ma-~tt da~~-tU& // _
        PlvQCLs e. PY\ e> eM-f- TP ~>e. C'oud ~ Yott.4.
ecu.Au, e.si--           CPIIL{J      eu l'eAL.c..·e.-
                 ~ Y Ctt( ~A Y P U1.._ VI Jk.-e. OAtu/                                             y-ho/,f/1:, J...'I! ..i
JAf ~is ?htvP/--e;,-

                                                                                ·,~~ 9-                so
                                                                          Mt "-ch-11- eL.              f...vlu1            'v--
                                                                         ~ (CG L.l     fZ-1"1 ~ C) ~ 4
                                                                        Te-NN.-        Gl..oNy                             1       ~J
                                                                                                                7 s; <O'iS £.
                                                        'i
        C." Y'A-tlG-      WeLtJoN 5A-W'7eh              t
                                                        l
                                                                     ·J:Jv 'f1t-e. CouJt_,y-
                  v...                                   I
                                                                     0   F C Y1 /111 1"/v IJ/L .4PPeALf

                                                         "'Il       - A-us 1/'N     I   nx.. AS
                                                         '
                                                         '

            IJ-f Ph l C.IJ-.NT . C n 11--lC-- UUeA 1/a 1v SAw Yeh.. , ft1o 1/e.s '11t ~
       Coun r Poit L. e-A-ve. YD r/'L·e· Yhe A-Jia_c4e_a/ A1'J.JI.lcA.n'oN.
       &;.. tun,t- 0 p 1--14.1\1 d et~ils I Pun.>UA.~ n 'Tit,                             KK.a~

       RwLes . f7 F 4-J~p -e.l. "A-n .PY.u ( e cluA.oe_ ) r< ~L 't 7 :l..- I -

              '                            '

       c;·'r' J:t.-wf ·h,t-S   M Ph't:JN       roJ...   L.. eAVe   aA.La/    G'hA-M}/-- AYJPll'cliN7/;
      'Wh I "f-     0    F Nt+N dA.~tUSS        .

:--

                                                        lriJ
                                                                                                                                    /\

                                                                                                                              . I

.I     c· hl~t"G-          w~ki/otv SluuJ-eA                                      l:N -rtr~ Couk-r .
                 V,.                                                              o F C n ,·';s,l"' d ~JPP~ -4/t.s
 '
 : YMe. s rcde..             t!Jr   H.Ktts                                         /4us77'1V        1       TexA-s.

                                    ,4P PA./c:A-Nif,~ CJ ,~y;. ,)vJP!., li-PfJl !'.anoN
 I .
 I

                                           Po A CUn If- u /<' /v1 A-AJ d7~1J1US.                    ·

                   Co Me.s          N   o{J}   c,.,., ,4./r;_   CU-e.A. t/ (J N     ,.5;'#W )' eA       I   !?elA VoA     J

       f+& -S ·e.. i'N /he A-k u ;.~ Si-Y ~ ed cuul ALa/JPbekd C ~J-Us e                                              &   F
       A-c._/1 t!J N       cu.uJ p., 'Z.es     /his         C!Jn/'C. l   ;v   u      A-I"I' AI~ATI"o~          fZoh

 : lU 'y> tt-
 I
                       0   F /Vt A-AJ.-dAJ11U8 •                                                                      '   1·

                       Re1A--rcn, ha-s             eKha.usTe.d _h/s                   R e/11 ecljes. a414' heu·
       Nt7 ' 0 tlt-eh a_cL e.tflu.ATe. R ewu~d7                          cJ-- I. A-a/~
                  · 7/ru:>. f?eiA.-toh hni"r.L~ fiJ11-~ rilt-/s :/.J-PPllCA-%VoAt
       Po;....    CV h t    '*' o F      M     A-M dA-IUW           ~ 11-J A     '/'his HoAL.P A-4-bi e
 1-
 I
        Cou,d- oF
        .
                               CYu~j'JV4i            A-PPect~            70' r;,_,~ ~~ Cun, "'r '
                                                                                                        i

                                                                                             .     .
h ~64t Vhe      k7    ~A-IV o   11   '3 5'   da..v.s /   A-PJ7lu~~ 1"5. he &Uesi-1¥u£J..
'tf1>~5 #o;uoh~6b          CO~d D~ c·n;~/'zu Jvl.... J4--p}1~ V{j                            /'ssu 'f
r/h0    WhL'f' of?. McuudCllltU£                 7d Co~fJel ~                       /I'-/ t:!Jr-
Dt'Jt~""U C.owA!T 72 h-e.._Pl-._'7            n. hu          w"~v- o~ ~-he~
C.oh Pu..& ..

           Lu he;A.-e.. ?bAt.    fn e111 ~St·~ C "Mst'd-eitw/ A-I'P_}, ,~c ~
Pn AA1 ~ r/i-is 11-o /tl.() h~ l~ ct/'{.(,~t- CJ\ l'ht-r'uaA . /v',br'ea_-(._s
                                                     0?

w,LJ Ch-aM/- \11t4~ UlhJi-- oF /Vl~us olvlf// Ohd~/"
n'l-   Jj~'/:!:2 Dvs_f . . ;cf' Coulli' ,')..,_          l}l.._e,J..   I   NK~:J"      n
~e~Po/U;,cl      In    ht~ Wh1          Y-   oil JI~J-he~L-.J          Cell~" u ... o?_
         5t7     P~ 11-yeol.

                                                                              0
r,
I
I

\

                     Vhts       t"s      lo C~t-v+lt:z~ Jh~"~vt t/1L~ b~ow ~
· 11t-ct             Gh·~-~/G--.1 N;.,;U. eA-fil-fie_c/ 't J1tt.o 'T7 f:JA.t   -PoJ.. /.. e.A..Ue.   ~ a~
                        eY"t·'~ln.LttL A-toP J..i'Lcd-t t!Ja, -Po A w h-e~ P P
                    .L
; ll /t-PP A,tc_cf/AAJ~
!

I                '

: M A-AU:ial'fJAk!.     LJ.;cv; f(a__ce cl ~~ ~~At U-S... /Vtcu k 13 o "
                                   /;J

    i   h e;J..-e       OA.t   rftr. Mt'citQ!f.l.s         U-Ailt-, Pos~               Phe.-- -Pcu~
        cuidltt-R_,~ e.cl                lP - - - - -
          '   C-(e~v·k~

        -lerx.a_s. Loud' P F C h ~/IIJ_~L.                         ~J!>lJ~(r;      ·
         P,..o,. f3o" l'.2.3o'i1} CA-PirA-L.                           S~YJN
         4u-s /tAt, n... '7 g 7                       1,
                                                                   L

                          /U..so- a          VhUA!.    ai{.U/ CohJte,y- Co/1·~s                ·C/   IZ   ~e

         A·bvv-e .cloc_a.fkred                 WeA~ ~ v~                       1/kr u.s~~~                 fjp;<.

        o~ r::A~- S~e                        hd..~v    dOf..I-P 1 a_dc/A€-stu/ . r/l - -
              L L e-~vl--r ~
         s     fvl-·l   ~      c   0     uAPf., Co UA,     r   jHJkS   e
         LJ          ~ ?Aoo;,
         / tY Cl .AI o h--~                L3 hu A-dw~A/y
          YY L€4 /               V~~ 7 5701....