Court Opinion

ID: 4056817
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:10:41.49581+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:06:25.541884
License: Public Domain

oc..\-, 2, ~s-
Lc,ur\- ~ L Q.J:W\r<VAL A-PPE:ALS
P. v. Bir>)t. l2 3 o S, C. AP.rrot. S"tJnlUtJ
Aus.-b n , T~~ ., e7tl

 R £ ~ S u PP\e-~en~ ...\.v Wr\.\. o~ lkh~ C,n~~.JS.
'Tt-ia.l do_~e \\Jo• \ \C. c.,£; CL.\                                         RECEIVED IN
                                                                    COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
Wl-"\l   t\Jo. \..UQ..- ~ g,   L.:.P-.\-o b
                                                                              OCT 05 2015

 De.a_r l!_letk.. Ab.a..l Ac.~-\a.,                                    ~bet Acosta, Cl·srk

            Pl~~e -C~ \-e          .\hi)   5uPol~eJ Supo\e""eJ i'n --i-his
 ~~t unr)·er -\-h~ a.bc::ve \AJf;\ lJcJ. s.

                                                       thea. l\t.   "'0   J

                                                  ~'dw~.
                                                    APoh~~ Pro-Se
                                    C. A u~.s;. tJ p, ~ \Q L:.5 (c)
                                     W R.-'39 ;bBl- o.S

  ~e-\~fe\1· L, \Vcu0 Jfra Se
                                                1                'In The       Court·
                                                ?
            v-s,                                ~                         OF
                                                7
 lh e Sta\-~ DF"
                                                                                  /

                        Te)(QS .                            ·cR:IMiuAL ~PP6AL.S
                                                -~

                   S Urtl Lf.~M   avr 7p A fPLlCAMS \V R;tT PE
                                   . HABE-AS CtJ~Pu5.                 .

          APPltcavtt co',npta:ns .... h;~ a_pp_la~ahor\ f~r \lnhem; Cc:>r4JVS.I~
  ~ E' ·A-dvQ\ rn r'lcu.ra ce- gro ~h"' cJs :l'ho-t ~l1~ £v.·Je:i'\+u C\.ttt He(\r:')_g,t~cd ·.
  W~S. heaf'd b~ JVd].~~ BQSCbc"l\J.~.6ent \ey Iii. .·on. ":JJ.j ~ JCiq3j \A.QS. not G\ .
 .fot\ and .fair hean~.)4 f~iQI Hea.ntu;r'!-The ev',Jel\c.e ~enrd a~4e-\-,"~e
  wa~ in r~qucu~~ ·tc> tk,~ Wifne-cc!s R~dhot\ ,ffiah't\g. she \;eJ J-b-.Q(
   becduse ofiberc..ti•.,,b-1-th reo-is. ~ Cldtt it, her a'r\J .her rno-\he( ~om
 f~GI dher allegeJ v~~N6 ·M~e-r       . 1anJ· "~" mc;\n~"N~ wket .u·n ~~nownst ·
                                                                          .

 ·to Tab&~ BC()wV\ ~4kcA-t;~,ul~ cnp-J,le of rncHiJel Qrt) rfo.pe. rro'w'c~s
  rhb~ his Ccflvlchon'al-ft~ 5cu'l\e ~:Sev~ral '/€J)..(.S af.kr ik\e
 C(Cj50.0 \ts rePc>f."-b.:J 1\/tabJk.t,Wh ete~e sf'a{edjS'e. o~ heY ~~e
 slo4J~ed ac.c.v-CXa~--th0'~ +aces· . b,~. -AL Ct. A-~ l~~-~u+s;·Je the. Coorf
 C'"DoYr\ do,HS duf;ng lJarJ'sfria/. .
            APPltean\- asseri:s;lkz1 ke.hd5; a '\et\e.r ~t>~ h{? s&Skt ,:;, h~s
  ~P-lis:s,e.s~'·on 1 wJ,.~~ ~es~·lhere ~~- ~v~~e ·.sta~t·n_g··~tlcibrltq 8row.i\
  wa.s a'-.4\\e b lls offiC:e·-\-o reca.rrl her+esh·~Mo-~v•. HO\JJevetj~·t.,e LL'ClS_.
  ~~GltV.ed OJJ:i~-the hal\ P·r,t,rfD enfer\~. -tkt lUep. aft~~ lr,o"y,'g~ lcJ£15
•.-obseiveJthJ he;'tather'' s\ClfpeJ he( llfwss-the-race fofccx;rse she
  c.r.;·eJ J~'as ~)),0fco~e ·-th(s w~ ~ he.r-f-ctfkribv\ t'~ 'tla.s Al Ct~ -~
                       1

 Tab \+ha~ ..fkfher wa~ ~ c..;TeXas a--t- -"'e-\-1~ oll-·tr·i~ h

                                                 . I.
                                                                             -
        APPl t"ca.n\- would also Pbi·n\--1-h'~ Ct?urls cd\e.n~~n..b~ ft~\             ·
   reeord. A+ -\hetn~ak; o.Penii:\9a AslahJ.~~ b~~ ihe\f·r.s+ \11·~~~ -4-o
   en-\-e.(fhe CBvt4-roo«'hlmme.Jia+el'"J ~C" her 'aHeseJ ·o.Sso.ot+
   in ~e ~aiLTabi+het en{er.s-the {hu,;\-00m b~·~·lifeitl\lydf"Q~
  la'/ her t<lotbe.r wlJos'· t~ -h~nr~J ~'\e"19bt\-hq ts sc.-~,:~ a+ +he·
 1l>PJ he.t Jung'.S .(ryi-rl rel~{lesd'f· 1 ahd 9rqkb.~. oMo a~~:·
 she c.!C'vil:L ~hcua ,d-. e. d ic> read. t\k.e ·witness si-anJ(sh~ rdvsq}--k, J·o1
 a~'1-~.s\i~~~l,. Was Wft~ng~\\'t f'i'O()o(JnceJ U ncu".t~l·qble ~~ w~~
  b.V:H'c slc:rte J~u\e SOo\ 1:R.E.Jt·a~v~9H~rCrvl€ cbse:..+c:lftl'f ~~·Q
 w;t+l\es.s·f.S be.~· +hro:rte.ne.J. APPkcan\:s ~.-e Afpe.e.l C:eJns~sbl ~
  ~\e· Rule Bo4 ,·sst.el bvt ~·ti.~e·the ~ JaclnJallow~e ~~\ th>r\-\o· ·
   \JI ew_~E! Ev;JeMr\1 Heari_r>q1:atnsci~. b        eawse: "*.  4e; noi -{l h~
   a .l'Y.htre.m·-fo r leA~e fe1 -ft It? -tile· 8J ~4;W;e +raNi£A.~ ,J~d f reve.n+ ·
  ·the tl-rk CAx.t J ~},~Is-fro~: a>nc·aJe.ring-"'e a~~H ~ wiffleSSL.~>
  a.\. \Va.rJ~+r;al., VA oUow&ng1\la+ Co"rl-io. Co"c.ic>~tb~-· ~(it.) 1ss.u ~ ,.·
          ·/Jcpp\,·cants Aflorne.~;cJ;J cA:Uec+ q\Tab\th~s e~i~ ·~e
  <:-~~room. M'•~""'~l ws;s, ~oJes!ed1)a"J Je~~.~ 0'e a~~~>SJ'
 Tethi,f\1a ~l\'1 _and,~e~ i:hal she ~· asscw \.\ed Jv·s\- fn<:.>r to-her
   e..J.e.ri'I"'Q tl,e Coo~.(oom ..£her\-ttJ: depJ·{es -tes\-i\i~ed;"thcr\ ~b"-\kc
·.had fePea\eJ\'1--\-o~4heft\fl..a\- g~( \-ove.J~HanJdiJ no\-\t.UI\4-
                        so
    nim -\t> go ·to._ictoi L ·4-k.J wov\J \~cNccJ~·Tab A\,C( \NaSh+ ~Q(eU 0~ ..
  ih ~ Afp\ ,~CCtrJ I \e<Xvan_g on \yt\ae ~ rJe.r;~!j- r,~p•sl-,0>oTQ:b,fJ~ s~{es
               »-
   cl~J o.Ssnu ~er QJ\d her l\10-+he1QS-the Oi\ ly \ik:ely CtJ\pit\--~ . ·
          . APPh~M 1'nsisk -H1at -lb~'·pqrftctt'' hectrit\9 \i·;o\<JeJ ~froc.e~
   whereTab~ never. ~i\v ~eel              ·-or CLAm       assa"' H-f15-+here.utet~ ·
   11\"\Q nY, ~ r~eshOns {o be ~I!eel J cone• ;-,..., ~ i~is 1Ssv.e. ~· lUcre -'\he~~ .
  o-\-~et .S \vl10 SiuJ Y.oV .b~n9- Sl~ppeclrrabr~hq~ M""'ei J,d 1'\J;~s{iWt ·
  no-\- oUOW1.:".9, ne.'r -to +el.l ocP dhef.s ~.vho wrtnesseJ ""'"'~s even-\ :U't ·
  QbvsG- of di.Scle+ioo' ~'1~cJ9e 6e"H~v ID 1 ,~ec)off ova& bb\-e
                                  1                                      \
                                                                                 ev,c)._.
at~J:--\,·~,..fo -~~8' l:it{~~ Than n6f,to be lost for"evei'- ..:J~~~~
·s~kou\d r\ot ha"e P~f to tJte.v~ OJirleJ\" +'rQ-n ~·"!J hen..-.d a\- at\ ·
 6uid-e..-,tUllr\l H-tla.~h~; e.v~~e.f\d uA-la'c.h Pr"oves -tk(t aGQ:w I+~ ~.J -\he)·
 COt!fC.lO~ of w~tne~~~ ot a +rial h~ "aJ Ctlt'\cl~J-eJ ,1-J(\W'"A'\to "'""~
 Jfpct,io.tt\ war, dvnl_,b-1 -ike 1'vckJe-5 Prevte..,..~;~ e.videN::e -~ ~.:
  teJng pre seAted ~;-\her\- mofe \\k-il\--1 thaV\ no\--, ~\J e.r.uJt:ae AJV~f'(
 ~it ·~~ 'W-eft..~ hear'-\t.i~\~hlL'W 6J,~ce·;', ~J -~ ~J "'"'e fW. \~-t !"'"~ ~

                          1. Nlna+es · bee.\ a·r a-\-. Gon
. I J &tre"'l. W'Civd I am the APP·\tC.ant be~ng- prescm\y .
   i ncarce.r ateJ •'·n -fhe. H~ntcvilfe ~ W\/nne \J~i~ dCJ ~c\arie
 .urJe.r Pe.~a\-t'l o~ Peci vrv thai aa:.ordt.l\9\o M"/ bel\et1 -:\he
  -fCtct5 ·s+al-eJ inihe SuP.P.leraef\i\. Preserrk~J now h~re
 t~~s CwrlJa.nJ· (, cnnj\J·nc_ii~n wi+h -J-he ·\ilerJ Habea:!Ia· Corrus)
  \AIR.--3~Jlo.9t-OS.I Arl·. H ,07 o.re +~ve ov0 Cortec±~ .. ·
             CE.R\1f1C.AT£ o~ S~Q.viLt

-~'1 m'i ha~ I· do suAea.r -\-ha\ o -hrve n~ CotYed
coP--1 ~ -\-\\e ~·re ~cJ;'"'g doc.v Men~ wa.~_IV'"la~\-e~
+o +he ~.\e<l e-t -\-he l"'J ~udioG\t D,~-\i\d Ct.>vrr ~.
 0\eio\lee ~-n~, a~ R.v.sk. J T}t... fY\.s. Jatld- Gcr\-es1
                                        D

 D,-5-\y,'c\ ~\ev~ t ~S"' s. rna;"' tf\+· 1 'l."J ~oor, R.-'J~\( 1
t ~)((lS 1 519.5 w~t\, -\he Pro(Je.t Pe>SJcqe a. t\ctc),ecJ;.
C:>Y\ -\-h ·, ~ d~~ ·the l.."'J ·~ E?c*·; l..l>' 5:"