Court Opinion

ID: 4057351
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:33:21.258025+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:28.246428
License: Public Domain

-?©3 -IS
  s^ptrz- ^{&smr <£AAX-K                             NOV 03 205

                                  ORIGINAL *******

                                                               NOV 03 2015

                   r                                         Abel Acosta, Cierk

   fc£tf£Ytf&*f<5- APA?2-LA*n)S ASTpZAkSAS, CUT-6f -7^*1^/ P£7T?T?Ofi/

         f%£7l5£ M>7ZZ7^y ^^'*A= T&^r &G/jeLTlJi &V£J*/&- <*rf *?

         A/-So &ACLoS£T> A££  oF; Atevz /^otz&/A J

UMOV&l ^ tnjev&J PBT$ (c/s ?-7-/ir) ; AMP, AneW1**
Ovr-or-T^jfcr. l>r«, R*\T. j VOX** ^^ ****"*» ***
A^r "uktABu; To Fo(L<*JM&K , TH£ ^>IS /*"** of cooer
-T*>ez> Pot ffrvxpe. Ats At>^uat^ Airpejs^. p^trASS R.ouT£
-TtteS&cxATOfK *

"7fM*/£- ¥&J fttL YoUR. ASS*ST7W<^ 3*f Tft£*£ MATTERS,

Zll—J-         •                    ??73L /=^. ?&>?G' Or*-)
       In Ttt€ dougT &F ciA&KWAL APPe**-* *? T^**s
                                 Ak. Pt>-0£LQ3-/5                                                                                               _
  ^JJt^JL^S^A/j^M.                                     _                                ^JJ^&^^sezuZAL^AV*^.

   T7&r $rm& aATZ&Fs                                                                            "TZitt&^r ga 7&X4S

                  AWo-rz&AA                              AS*                        fretf&tX&AAg-

 -~~        &>/ne^ Ate&A,« ^^^'faLj.^fei^^
  ^A&>re- S?Y*jeZ> A&*» .AAsTMAeXEfr 4AV&4T A/V& A?&&°£ziTtev^-y

       <2)*?0&~o£p£zp *sf *£-£-/! f
          *re>&-Q ^/ ^/i-fl
       9
       c) ^OS^O*}^  ~p3.fr W2» Fjxey _w HH^-i^ \
       •W             i-iiiiiii-biih-jii—i^i-imb ii iwiummini.nii, iii'iiih—i hip ii iiin mi-i i. ...T••.. 1 1 ii   •„ i.».iJ..ii,.,——•,.,•„•   . .. •„••   .— .. ...   ,   1^.„.   _,-nm,|U

     J^LMp&turt Pp-ezcZ'/s- Repo^a oat fo-tV-/6rf
     ^^mmg^&jaM Ab~oa-o?••/$ A5z-gt> £/A_AA>^=£r/^

   Af? or tw& ^efpezTZiv:
A^*?73t7fe* OAAPfitrLt^TZ? SjPt/A&eZ-; 3W  APA^A+a^^d^us^ «7& /=&-* AAjtS
 hb>/}«j>6£ ATrrsyi^Ar at- A                        PA\Qp£fiL P&rzrrxvA/ Az>& '7>^d&£-73zw#eV
  #&Aft?W{ 1>ag /Q~*&~lAYs fferpoizgri-fric
  T>>>.k, WAS GMe+J "frOS, -3V4.gr> A^TZba/ S/A?ujs TMgr d&cs/zr**

                                                                                                                                                                                               /,
                             Af&r h>-&*0?~{<
 _fe3#.„:Z^„J^^^^
-2to&33S^jr^33^^^

 Tfre: "nrm.e *p? T>£P^^>awt^ £M&usr&vcy 9 // g*__- Abe AAA

 AhH> Sxr&AATFxiLMJT 3L£X>I> Z-oSS aaO> BfZAsm/ 2>M4^_&z^y>M^c_r /wc <7Xjx*t. apcfj*rS4r*. /5 Y A/3rS 3r*7Sr AMr0£#S;

(k) t ^^^H 7>e5ffttfC APAjS^UAA/T^ lbJZPAXV*r73&A/ OA?
 <&An??*rrv*73iMSjn- fizr*S amp AteaA£L£z*era? A? A OAaran> 3r#7&5
 ^TzrmcV -7Wse0vg&7' -7^0r^ £*A7X3aAr .Sg^^gfZ,
   TZitt ^Att> <£s>ir£*i^oA _zrs /"u>/>gg AualY £~Xf£A&*/<£X> JTa/
APP4&u**rAs &TAMC& P&r< T&sc, &&sf aatj> jts a          sz^^7?W7sm^
^£Afr£*i\/&MT*/& tZzriLtx/A+s-rwGe _ AcPperz^Arfr P/zAV^ Tfcrs £av&r-

  AAP&Mi+ASr PAAIA3 T7AZ5 tauter ACC&Tr SAz~I>              37XLUCM.
  Penr*1>irset &ev, (p>-.oio3^/5; A ^            As Mars Sas^P
  W 7%Sg^^g-e^^APA. Aal*^,j &/££ *7&f.
  Amp 7*k, &< APA, P/&*-,/'•&"* -2*r.Axs* ^Assmc &AArz&L&S7-
       ^£g?fr_ £e&/u£*x- AtoJAZ^J Ah*z&At& *T& Pk£&-£W7~A

 fA&AxCATXDfi/ AtS£> AATSdeATPOCT T^ A43r5£: A /e&WS€>A/A}£l*e
  7&O0T 7&9M 7Z& 61 U&5-TZVA/ AurAV P&0A* "7&*r tn/Ay A*V>
 -pePfrZVirt, VettMPAiST *A Ar P*Z& Tlbxat , Al09££±S XAAA2>€XkUA7e:

                                                                        z.*
„* .Az#&*A*Ar ^???^g? r^aj-tgza^:^ £3&***/£rt&{.t
fVi-Uf ao&l> pTterrtf / AA& J£^^                                /fafiAFSTY
-A3^_AAQ^J&£^3>£Z*!£y *                                              ,

                            ^§I^^J3^^..JmAiUXm^v                         ,...-.
                                  .A&S&g&A^mAZL.

                             J7p,ct^r #> fi/^rfsSL
                             3f"7-2. AZMr3&>**, AhtVATSKY C/a^t
                             ,^?^^^7v^.2^fc^, *77l£&U-

         A?A&rrttrzA~ri£   csfc    .^ng t/3*_r

   A   A^A^ <3&vyfyjFy, A££^&:akZ^~£gJg%^^

3nf$A5, ~3*> ,H&£B«%. £gg3-ae&..:Otor^^
^g££JA,t #F XfWA JkSA>T^AL^A^-J^^mS3B^A^, ,AA£jg2^Aa!&l£,
 PeTPAAWAAf 0tsr-&F-TZM£\ Pe^rrxoA/ A*? ~Z2txasaAY

 ._^_.__»-" aovAjr 0A? &zx*wml AA>A>rz-*y Ate,£*x fel3c$
 .AaffiEafyZfr/i Kllr7S.4--J5EugL-Z2lm. aaggi^-^e^z^--LJ5^agC

   AVoz&Ss &xvw =*A TV/gr T&c, Pr A?A. Pjz*<£&   AT MT& '?>&eA&Tzz>Al&           .,., ,, ,•.. ,.

                                  ^_^_aL_£_J_fe_^_C
                                  Z2>^/^

                                                                                  2^
    UN3VORH ^-f™^, ^ ^e

pefiTvfiX THi tone*"
                          ^^2-2   ^y of _Z£J.   --

ftHHO Vol****   —-

                       *z** ">v£i?t.
       ' ^ *XW&^X #ZY„*A^ ^ *
                                                "••'-•-   .   , _frt ?.?P$                         ^*-i
                                                                                        7^.^' '-S^X-H ** *AW^S
            sf-fg.
                                                                                                       _ -A*       
            ---at- -a- ?.jy    'y~A. t* \?J :X ^                   -j*.^
                                               li>il<|fl'l|'i||>|l['li||i|»l|ili|i|<'lptH|tiliiiH!l|||i|-]it:{itll'          Ki-/   ?$r*vj
                                          0fr-80-T4040-££4ZJf                               Z40SS8T5E44               IDS       t
                                                                                                                              i ... ,*f> . in a
     S-^/i A*^        'M "3- T.A                                d^VMilO- OX                  3 1SVNH
                                    \Afort~,              aassaaaav sv                 aiavysAnao ion
                                                                                                                             .*i„ £.W^&A
                                                                                     -t'-'^> '' '4,8 4,          3 JX IN
      jn e )/?••& &-&aa         1                                                                                           _j ' r* ? r a ^ fy
      Zw* £JL        •£&      A>&£$ A* 9- £.A 3 V V AffCLO^^ S^xAf ^ %i J^^ \/ 3$, o&g <>£>?.£-
                                                                    M jj r j\- -?4V           A »"t/A"» '* J. '>?-»5 «"?^
                                                                            *W /* *#<£ 3> */                 J» "» ^ a? "-i- ^i4/ -jr-i-
                                                                                                                       A
                                                                                                      '•
                        s? t   -.

        . S- T*f€ •&******* *<>* P?tIA/& T#£ **P&Wj G*f1-Ot-Ts**€

           f# AfttlLJ**                                      t2*ApAV*f A>*}L,

t//-*    7^.j.**/. cot/*7 erf r*i* ^°~      ti*.y *rf ^<-*

 e   g.A2Sn?&Ai As*S*
                                                                  ts<*   - 7y/-*«
                                    ,TTZ*f* Mf»"7'o A*<*' *<« ^^r"^

              if A&fit***'' #i.cci«*P t4*~***»t£ SW ^ ***•"*
                                                 fA                        -A

                                                                                    ?,
                                               P$a, ..<,-._ i,                               „„,,,.
                 13* 7s'f't /V-V 'f 3 A£-£Z/f& UA&At A^ %A*&t*J *£&&£> AA&SA" Ao*Z
  TH£.         ptt&V**5'*'1* t ST*-****™* AA* , AS ?#t.ie<#s :
                  / \                                            t    ijttK    *s ?,** ** *A* +•&     &V A&tt-#T-~

  7^ ***** * wm : ?-.**' sv, ****** »>" >*,*'<*"»***
 An£&£** A*m*<$ / f **•**p " A *• "•' J "•
  S¥ a. ^UV^S US***, A«r> LrxS-rm, *A< £ r* >£ 3o*AH ** *n *'
      ft) T//_>-5 ^/*5         t j Mj£.-7AMo 7*2 Al Cover tfice**** /S
                 fj) AA?<*-
        KA)      ,^cS „,-,«* PASCAL XJSASliyrV.
  Iff***,**,****"""- ;*•     7^- A^^rt^>/^
                  *AtU#* to** * %^3SA**LA*n/

   ^w5f Tts. ^^/^" ,^^'^ ^1J/^^ Af*V**•*«** JOSS.

                                                                     jRi Sf£ ci f yt. t- V Sue ^> ? - e~x>t

                                                                     APfi £ *AiAf ?/A/y4 1<
SzpTmsgn n, -2-© rff
                                                                     Aft £ •% ttfrf/f/^^ iS,
               ~Pat-€~&

                                                                     3$j£ / „**<~5!>& 5*w? // - fipi.ita*SPY ONJ T

                                                                              7?3Si

                                                                                                                     f*
                                                                           /&._

              u,.^lo..*J-i».J-,«...^ii .H—mum ff»i n.J"a   »W"•-•—>••   • —•• i W«>m*ii''y* • •'.   • ••"—»'•••   -•   •'••   —

                      A1tfn 3 r?tA T£ Of S*- AVatE
—r   —   -i

                                        _r //«-**•• *?v e ^ ^ y -r'**r * t#v€ amp e^^^cr

                 A«*TTt>*f Pa* £*1 *N$™#i or Tua**. t^ rait,                                                                                                  rr            ,
                 COT -Of »T3^ T P€l 3 '. T»M /«V* ^3 SCA eTZttfA** A& ¥J ^'VsA
                f,(AS &££*' ?#S?r> VJA %)**>- fi*A3L Tc 1HG #f PJC/# •SmTA             of ~/^vs/A^ ^r-tf^V7

  To 7**€' H3*>*uAAZ*-e Coo?* of                             €£3»*-jt**L AA^t'A c1> .
          (3*1*. £<£• *A* l>At Alex &A?*&£*, z*
T/t4r A3&VA- "$>'"'•*/**" p Al*& tfvA«&£ *e& A^tuSe A--S& Ast&S 7//> 3
P$a$& ft*** ?J--»^*- -X * •'                ~                                   _       ,   -vT-a»rf/
(t&fOPItS +•<&•                f£7S-m>"e« -> 'rc'^                  '

 ^ *,_* //« _v*«~«" ^                                        ^ ,           ^er, ,,^^ *.

          ,    -    //».i# *-. Thin**J >_. "'£        'wU'

                                    /            -.    .../v > «. •*tsA&J 6*»lT ****** "?* To"**
              f.   A APt * £AAS 7 A"'t '' -" 'J'"*'*** -                                        .
                         »"i      .- - ^   <.   A**&*f
                                                          /-..^ •A/>S fc/i&CWt^ a*-»7a/*V.
                                                          AS&*^

   fj'^                             ,,...,,„,»,               •iAffA2rA?*A'*3'4>*f?A'1*fe           t***^
                   U7 <• **<• 4** st At. ?J5l7fr./V«5S Tc ^                         AK6?o CoAY

   ,^t^ 0/C /t^/^TT ^*

                                                                                                            7,
                        A& •_ _                ~__„^ -.              .,„

        Y- AftP'tiAtff ^imse^S TTASAT AS/4" **VAT^ JM 7W& 2AAtoKW

       jj, W a«<,«t &>******* -r„*Ai ^^^fi ^ '
#W^S        pvfi*u#e*T T#              let.**-- •'
       \H.Hk'£fr0ZG, f>At**JS£ S AoAfsn>r&e'f>4 a*??***-***7/
f&r?7*-GAA*r# /^W5TS T#*7 rAf>S tetA*>«vt<4£€ touAr Aee**>r
^tte o*j&T#At. <*?y*m*V Pe.®AA^, eur.^-TjMi ftirrj**
f9iz tuzePi'r&MtAAY *tV?c»tj ***?# apa?*'** St*"**e ?* *#*
Stat* frx-st'*?4**& A*<™<*«* Y, *"***•'><** *'* "'^ "to*****'**-

                                   &t SP*. Clr #* tV 5"o«3 A* J * 7 6"fc

                               AASC**• AAA"t AtJA~f ? 7jT&/tS£ A
                                .• 44 f_ M ><*• «' '*? •' **AA^ JE

                           3S7_i /i-./i-« - 55 =- Scuj *v                  *-tw».j
                           / _• \A2A*C» $71ifyJ, "7 AX<* ?/77 3'5 /

        ***/• 073: AJf si TA     £>r         $A A SA'x *r €

      X f4At~.*V AA<-*7fY ?M< * 7****' "•<*& f&*P**r ***** ** T"*
#&*V* *-"» P»*>€ &>•*-*>/& PAOSC P£-mcAf&*'S A"*-(u4«/ 7 0

if* T>fiA-b/A, &OT -Of • "flA'^£ Pils 77W fa,?, !>J5eAA7jAfJA*~y Pi VJCtA/

OP 1V-4Z Sr-ATT: fa*S*c*J73M& A;7i>AAt&Y, A.*.<>qk /A¥®£, AAAJ^J

                                                   Ai..€.k AaajV&s s~

                                                                                     ?.
                       A/o     f*P-OSLO'S- JS
    Xti TH£ CtCOfCi OF C&3A\?tJAi.                 APPEALS of T^XvtS
                         /4 US t -r a/f T grx A-%

                                                            /'-•

    Ai~ex £p.A*!At &               APWll-AtiT; A A                    'Ait 13 r^oAJtrR

         \A<

 Tf/A 3rni-£ &f Te*A%

                                                 _9_&
                                                            4-
       A(PP£I.LAa/7"a>                  /^/ ' Pei 3 7to aJ
                                       & A>*4&&
                                          v^

                                       C^^
    At/rPoA-zx&v £'

                                        ^> j 7^7/t/. 6A-o5£ AA>.&007-AP-fof&1
COOAT of AfP£AL^>
                                               3*A 7M& ^Z2~7 V-< O'u 7>.tc jAI-
                                               T^Z~5 rP 2.&<£:
CTo £2 c i (A u 1>TS'f A. j: <7
                                               Phs 13. PA ,'teAZ.t Hj 3 R, ,

     OPA L       4 # a u /vi £. fv/T    -I 3     V\M I V-r T2>

                                          Pc/~ U/V3/< Y Oa/2 T (l I-)
                                          3^7X r,AA\, 3SO South
                                                                              A

                                                                                                   - ( —«
                  A&W€Z oF Pa&Txsts
 /' A%-nA0AAA>*& T(S£>o<£ A$A?*-TA A* PAz^AAf JA. J2j2 *Y ^^AAJ:c.xAd~^'S^A3sc T
  (Gf U/> A/tA^YA f%T£,-3i.nf SAaaAaat#a,t*^Kf?$X®5 f $%&~JZ:'5^e
«?# B&xaia CavtAAtyPxsTF&jzcr A•vTv&Af&y 'S'tA^AA/A^AA^ •$&& j&.&&.giA&sA
 .SaavAMrPMTVs -A*>- jJFJi &•?*('** e) 33S *•-* 2/ i .
 3, S-rA-r< pAo3€CW>y^AG- A?7&4A,v4: A« P.O*•&&*. t£*f0?> AAP3T&1 SmAZ&Afy
   Acszttaa, T*, ~7&7A/: - .              . '
  ?,?>AW3£4. A*A/!>A^jP^A€>x WSjf&fApOsT*., 7$261;.{***}*$*~53t&.
  5. 7kfft,AS&/A'm'^^£'/ S*/3& A&&ftfr/lJ:>iA &.>*£!t£_t $*A>fA^AATVfiAWf. T* *?$& a f ,
. &AP&0OAAP /*?*,, fSTAArPAAroA. St., Ag.4ty>AA*PA*rtlr,VA J2 M-3&H,
  7, /iA^^i-A AQe&Aft /&/ tVfM&A'YA Jv,y SnT. Jm/ $AA? Aas^a'-tq-/ Ay: . TTZOS.
 &> Ioi?3 04.a A/jntK Ac®ax.u' -z- ^jacck. {? fv) 3"7i - Y&M*/.
     A&A £ &4,4./\AJCf<£ ® <*Ane>\ /< <-&+>\ '** *?OG<3 /S&*,

 fa.   A*-** •*"' AA^t/Ay-" f AAA&*-<-f\A/r        3^7^ a. A*. >3soSAl'SAw<
    t* -             (        - £&utn "s JMAAJr'tli PiwyAte. &A a*-*&7j~0a/ T& HAJFVA&eAfo/,,
    <£ *          &- ~€.QU£i'3> OY&y.AUl.3A/& G&0£<£720A/ / PvOHLC 0'£ OpAAPY,
    3, —          -> "" £CU£ 1's A&US£ Of PTSAfi>im~dt*/ ', £.)ATf9A A&.QVS VfA'e'TVSA .
   HjS"          ^5iaM' t>t F2C~j £AT 7A1AL COUMSLAL j FAJ£_/*'£ 7& £&VJA,
    &flr         S             ' P£-FJ€.T&\AT A#oM3££ '. Pa'J J-ufi£ "As, So£rtf3AA A*07**AA~
   £ /""St A&A/A'*"AZ *
    i£?r -       7            ~Vc?2C.z-b'?7TAAA'ei.cATre tou/vsd.-i._S* 'pATi.UA£ 7_» G£t&£?7'-tyz7ftPA*\*J.
  Mij*<2'~'~~ % ~7s£.f-tcj6Wl'Al?P"*.l'AT£ ^oy/5t-S /JfifefAt-'-CTfVtTAtZJAiAvtjtvsiZJ.,
  \3*            i ~ p£f--3C-j OV'7 ArPClCA r 7^-^a/ of />j? \A<$t~oos> &&*•*•'F*
_XOX,~                        PAAVCA &f Alt:x S, ApAiAfA,*-,
 ,y.lV' > "                    APP£'A/1>TX ~      AP^P7l~oi\A AY R&A£A^A^A,
JEST,        ~                 £.?-r~J fj-cs•, ,
-K-Tll .                 ""     3 A//*A 7 £ '-s   _£>_. c t. A ,£A s-J'&aA*
 xn7* 4*,,

                                                                                                 zzr.
                          JL ajx>£A      O€     A u'f /• to -? J t jr £. s

     J5               -     y.?\,/1, AGfticviiuiie €#&£-l76'-'M^ * 7.
    ^>f        ~          -XAA&zti^cA/T =* yaf3$P3/9S -            ,^'/3,
%&>°{          ~          A*07JVAf -AP WJ 7AA&AAW                    ~        to*f {(,,(*., 131
  3/£f         "-         At*4>75F&sj/ JT/if Az Ai*»-?AA£~         *~~         ^'/^

   _&      ~~             A*<£Z-?*vtA "?& &3rstTsi/ £ \/2-A<£~Af 3>s$/^y sjs AAAc>-AAr-£T> A^^AV^e J. ~ /, . /^,. Z.2,,
    ^     ~~           A?PP£ *"*'•*'•zZ'tY ~?i, J?"y&Ai<&&/K/A Km: taA(t 55 &5 — ^A
 /, o      "              Ai^,f?-p-.p}p/A A*A aYa h/ ~?A^">f ~    "                 /"**,(*-1
 7^       ~            AWerrfcS/V *? &> S uAA£&~~m&:-NT f^ilc&fZb — /_?, /_•.
  7/S     ~           A2-P/iGe £&-7A<£7<: ~Ae AAaao-AaitttArrsAAAAV— /*? **-*,
 7f$f jO ~            Acoat of AAA*x&sy &P?a/ioa/ {AA&t* a) -                           Y*»t/ f£./ /S~,
   tO          ~      A&>OA?T     Cf Atj>A4.ti&?* OA?/VTOAJ (r>/t<&k- V J> ~                 x /^
    7       ~ JOO'l- CA- \0£i(ael - WJ /*<£• to&RAS*]>VM                     (ffr&£ //i(c)j" {^<
  /o
 1 s c &a 7 x da// ^ V r' £ v 1 *r W

 To -f'HC Moh/&AA8lt.                      COVKT Of            C(Z2 aa 1 a/AL APPeA£&\

             Appal 1 a*vt A&s'aa^ta^ t.y ^v&mjts t^/js P& ?* tsoa/
.Pop,    T>2/SeA&TTQNA&Y                       Pzvztrt         /wi>    a^$v& s      7'n S

f-(®ts/&f< S    t ht     Fc< a o w rw <& 7 n         s upPop ~
•r fi&A&of              \

 SATA1E fA&NT                          R£GA:A\Xa±N&                   O^AL         A£GUM£f\/T

          A PP& /.A- At iVT AfiJZt./iy                   ixAA2V£i>       AiAf &AA4~
Al.AGop»ikt\!T                  &lca.uS€        f-U    2^      PftysucALi-y 2^3 sabl

AHO         %'S A/oT               St-OQUiNT           __ ,y     SP££rCi~\, AAQtiC         AAa*>'i t.-V      SlO\jJ - Of- - 5 Pi-. € f H     A*, rxfp   A* AY h&

 £qM SX |>fc K&1>                 /Vi3/W^- /?£ 3/;^/V S 3 V£ / A pr f0 ^ ceS£> Po
AfAS$*SPte                  A     O.U& S? J-OA/        A*A0P£ O 'J/ C te 1.^ ,

                                                                                                 Jfr
                      SrAiem€Hr of thk ca..%m
  S& Pre-•#*&&•& l%A*N<>'p0**2:-*iT 2vol- - A4A6Z*. St €aaAfAt&
        AAAa $?&'$> ~ ArT*v*Pr ^oac^-a ** a/aA $y&*?6>
  S&Pr 0Af t &&%> A&-ST M-T& So.$j£. ,
  ~2>(,A£-v>\&k:A. 13.t J..oo~7 ~ J &t-j c} ** &. mt ^ \/*Pf £S P 3 ff^ *

  .AAAAAl-i */, 2o&ci - AAA* ru»s €t>v*•?•**   OH-iiH ~Q€>f£ *t/*/ Aci/*rar Aa/",i mas j.&6x^r.
AltJ&OST /%j.atr- £JeL/t7H a^ua-* >,f /%?ii s MAM&A7A ,
AAAAAA %f 2o/j. - APPttCAfiTt fleets \/t.^ A»44Y3>*T£ Al^g> 'Q?Jt i+Xk* fit,
Apaj i, t2taora. - A$r7 m*, Ay5_v»* n?&*/*#y a*a»a*am/ f'»&-03H 1 -/2.),
A*AY ,?3, .2&tZ - ATT&AAAl-Y SfizAVAA/ces PU£TU SVAtT* aA<< .
duty 2\f ao/7. - /iAar^O'Y Ao& J~t/~pjcj-rt.& At&'tnLe &?; %r&,
Z&cmG* # Z^zotz - ///t©fc>i5 CGAPOS Pulc i> ( if,«*l) .
AAAAAtt /A, 2*M3 - //A 3cAS Pirrj.7T0Af6fi.y3 A'>j>7 svAf Al'A &J Sfat/n-ftY*
Z7AltYtA*trA/&% ,* V2> foAAi-VSjr*** cf £* uj ,

                                                                                XT.
               Si ATO\ fc/VT Op            ftc qc £1>IJKA U H2ST oA^I
          @i\f S-i.pT cw&irA fi j AivMapasMi A/r Ao&j vaa?g.A "^"/VM *?*/£*/&
Arrrvifm-v aao^d^A, AlPP£tlA><.VT/p£.:Ty7:r^tA-k~: s* jw& J~4iAe>7-istrKiTfWAS
APPoiNitr* AlTQAMt>t 'PamiblP^^p^'p/ *//& u/A -> CAAUrt* Ta -po'iY -^'V
^PA^ /IM& $£P&A a*/ 3'2H-^^l unPin*."0jLO0"7~eA~H>%h-f
                                 f        t                                        * A,

 AAu£J>*4 A,t3 4.Tf>AtkA**e*ifr#. >coh i> J^y's A^^^Y
•VcHT>Xcr JA Of^A/ ecu*? A*lt*^r«& si /Y*r-<£>***',*- Se*.A-p«A£WS£
 Pl*A> ApA£-1£,iaA7 A/AAA/U.^t> Tt/tr At*tAscrjrvtfy<£**•>?#*(; - AlPptiA. AI77VAf*sA*A' 7>L3eAAri le-T*, WHO
  G-U77 //^A 3cB Jfi/p AtfAAAi^ i^jrsY *04*7 O, AOi>*X <^CAA 2Z.
   ( AA&tsS '**-&/*£.& At) «•
         -TAc /fist/Of-iA Sir 'B^ Y'&o^J- of ApA£TU«> AAo-Uep <*•' £>*S-lA -1- CA.
 *A2l-<\ A^ J5SUA-D *«KA;vi>A2_> A/& ,
           jAfy/Zz&flstST At fd7^; i>. /> A&AA* 'I*!: ,-/,?lj A s\/p> C&fi?tmA',*                Ptt4>%/'t*0AA£LUP&-S
  -r/AcTeC UsA-5 AAV A~pfio# j ,v nH£ D'uS>&^ tVT ^, Af^A t-LAMT rA4-W
  Asi.€~r-. /As. Pe--75?TLh\f Aeg Pises?*, TjrjfitAAY .A&sst&da/ &m y-/2-/x
 & PP-OSm-l*. ; AIA/& S/JX 377t;-a A/A&em* AoAAts-s
  **•      -2-CO-7 - A C , _2 -D , 2. &/ .2. ,
                                                         A

          ~A/A<£~ /A>/iAo,'iA &"7l~Gl ' O/sf AU\AHCA-i 2^7..<>iS
  AiU7iloA7 7Lj::ixf&       "Ta/jS    OUT'- Of ~Ti~^ e       P& -> xTjvtf A^oA
        lAl SAP <£ 7 XO/VA (4 Y A&. V2 t"W ,
          "7"//e~&,££ U/AS AAe ft,-t&-t .j~0/V AVt< At. t/t~AkAs.iY
                   (The Clerk of the convicting court will fill this line in.)

                IN THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS

               APPLICATION FOR A WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS
             SEEKING RELIEF FROM FLNAL FELONY CONVICTION
            UNDER CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE, ARTICLE 11.07

NAME: y^MEY ,,,(^/?A^K- 3fc                                     ____
DATE OF BIRTH; ^/^T ^Z-y                     Afp"** P**** *$               10P .

PLACE.OF CONFINEMENT:; T7>' C»3", P&Ll)N**KV QfSJTt _{Tt\                             :r*-

                      __&
                                                                        _^.^^/^£3
TDCJ-CID NUMBER: '0S5~.&f&..qff&6>& ,

(I).   This application concerns (check all thatapply):

       D    a conviction                    D       parole

       D    a sentence                      •.      niahdato^'supeirvision'.

       •    time credit                    Jp-      out-of-time appeal or petition for
                                                    discretional^ review

(2)    What districtcourt entered the judgment ofthe conviction you want relieffrom?
       (Include the court number and county.)

(3)    What was the case number in the trial court?

           £lqq~7 -.&-! og^s

(4);   What was the name of the trial judge?

       AtrnwA®tr£ Ph i- > r P /f, ftA'Z£Mt ,7>,,

Effective: January 1,2014

                                                                                    Rev. 01/14/14

                                                                                             jzzjt
(5)      Were you represented by counsel? Ifyes, provide the attorney'sname:

        ££AOa/i> ~d£f*f£?i$QM PtnAffiAO^€ 'Ma AeB&tMPY. %% 2®0$_f

(6|)     What was the date that the judgment was entered?

          FhrfiAUA-A-Y ~&3 ^o^T* Ai//A/&y> e-A .-•      *? **" Y£/iP-5,              .              _

(8)      If you were sentenced on more than one count of an indictment in the same court at
         the same time, what counts were you convicted of and what was the sentence in each
         count?

                  UApA/diA/sY,

(?)      What was the plea you entered? (Check one.)

             •    guilty-open plea              D guilty-plea bargain
             *^- not guilty                     D nolocoriiehdereltio contest

         If you entered different pleas to counts in a multi-count indict

(1.0)    What kind of trial did you have?

             • no jury                      ^     juryfor guilt and punishment
                                             D jury for guilt, judge for punishment

                                                                                 Rev. 01/14/14;
(11)   Did you testify at trial? If yes, at what phase of the trial did you testify?

(12)   Did you appeal from the judgment of convittiph?

       itt yes                              .• no

       Ifypu did appeai,answer the following questipns^^ ^^ lMttSP0t/k0> To
       (A) What court ofAppeals didypu appeal to? ****7H C-WfrT of A*P*r*<£^
                                               Qfy-Q f - Q&7S 7- e & ~~ *** A* c H / * ° ° *» -
       (B) What was the case number?          Q*'CA' «a/of-p< VE*^ **•**» ***** 47PU.
       (C) Were ypu represented by counsel on agpcal? Ifyes, provide the attorney's;
              tiame:?&.£_y'MH T>> ui2 / A<**4t.A /*< *^-*" /'£*/** £?&*£&• Ai&iYf-cK
                 AOl>A7;&U&&.(wzLLtri^A) d,CH*-Y£A LXQCfsA,:                            ...... ....
                                                                  ''tj*.A.C£. ATA V<-3>&,'.«L,\jA~ %-/*?-' \.
       (D) What was the decision and the date of the decision?"^ ***** *iactopowmt ~3-5W*.
(13)   Did ypu file a petitiontor .discretionary review-in the Gourtof CriminalAppeals?

       «$D. yes                              D no

        If you did file a petition for discretionary review, answer the following questions:
                                                  Pn -
                                                   p-<33*n.-         i.a-
        (A) What was the case number?                                          ___
                                                                      Af'tHi*. (8,2.04 3.
        (B) Whatwas the decision aiid the date of the decision? ^g ac^Y 7Ai*<*a/ ,

(14)    Have you previouslytiled ah application for a writ of habeas corpus under Article
        11.0.7 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure' challenging this conviction?

       -f_i: yes                             .•; .no

        Ifyou answered yes* answer the following questions:

        (A) What was the Court of Criminal Appeals' writ number? —_                 _i

                                                                                       Rev. 01/14/14
                                                                  p£&, H't 2.01 & A><
                                                                   £At^-0f--TA-l^€:
       #) •Whatrwas the .decision and the date ofthedecisibn? .P®r.,.*®x$c. P^Ar . ..:
       (C) Please identify the reason that the current claims were not presented and could
            not have been presented on your previous application.
             APAaAAAAAT Al~rT-i>AAs£V toJ&t/Ais, A&t j?-fSA4.vm ?AAeAA£*.'?AA£:
                 Assaf-^m A/C (A'SA "7A/A~\ tosA&T &A

                 /MSa~%S £o£P   A'£A/~/y\ 3

                 [?£.£ pft^A .3 . A'"-€-megA   \AAA,A .-~   w*z, Z"2- , (ofAQl ,

(15)   jF>p ypu currjen% have anypetition of appeal pehdihg in any otherstate of federal
       court?

       O. yes                             W- 'iw*

       If you answered yes, please provide the;name of the court; and the case numbef:

                     Afe-V AP&*: ? "*&*& '                               -. ••••.,,   ::...

(16)   If you are presenting a claim for time credit, have you exhausted your
       administrative remedies by presenting your claim to the time credit resolution
       system of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice? (This requirement applies to
       any final felony conviction, including state jail felonies)

       •   yes                             D no
                                                              /Ye-r A fAiXZA BC£ >
       If ypu answered yes, answer the following questions:

       (A): What date did you present the Claim?             aAat a a a * ,?-aA&l£ ,

       (B) Did you receive a decision and, if yesiwhat was the date of the decision?

                                -ajAav A&a*- +'Ai2o^«f'r,r??7>0A/e^s 5"*,/***,• $««.«*aces«j, a^ai,
ftorrcciiAQAi! J&& AAtcHpA\icm,.. Yx<&a-> T» AAa&c-tzsA A^w.s&a @¥ /AcijiijrA/iS
 A&<7A r !s jr>i aa aAem 2> st>/A f <77 &•>&£>&&'*   /?«_?- r^r * 4.
/Wmj&A T* *Y>rAtMi4iV 62-Tj->Yt5, At<.,VA'£.T6T--<3£~-7*/'rf~A.A::Tf

FACTS SUPPORTING GROUND ONE: 7>£SArm A^stj-a^s ri ; ua3tni>*aU,
"Pj$v*3S$ AaA&wt&p A*s#st.-% a//j> Aftwf tJbwerfr ytt«nt.e*o / r//c (•/^n a?**j£>

AeVAT X*s%&£/..AAr...Aj&:TA.J~T A6tA$A3> Ws$ ^^eaerss>N AA/2> kg;ft

•ft/A .A T//.S f/AP&fVt. letYpy****. UfoN A VVAV Ti> 3>£.4?A#€K

Ae.(Y..PtA!xW<£i PA^/VCSA^j £V2P£Wr TAAqo&Awt THE l/A/£0Af37JTttrjy#tA£

"TPJrA.L* &£Pojl£ AA3 t> P/A-A&TfYG 0M Pe&&\)i^Y'$fAiYA/0'bsA2tA3 %Q&jf

~TA£ t>£fm/l>AAsr U/AS Srizxes&HRtKlfP AAVt-japi-e. Tjrtwe9? At pas*?

0f< WltrcH H?S (JE&AL A/aT£S AVE? A*OTXotf£• frAgftg AY>A/AZ'fA'A7'„

AtA,Mooa£ $7rtr&T> T'9 TH£ C&Q&r THAT t-l& l»/A5 Aqa/C&1A(^£1^ ABa

 His o&fA PaF&iY, Aa/& A/e An aoa^t^s, To &a Aot3AXai>... &P

 t>tF£'APA-*jAs.. A£L£AS£* T(/£ &W&£ '&4t(l£'X> TH& . T>A.f£rtiPAAff ,

 J/*.-** t>9.QK,          Al/g, J, AdoofLm pA3£.<£}> 7* AA,orG~Ar pgf4t^pAAAs_

                                           •Ai

                                                                               Rev. 01/14/14
 GROUND:TWO;:Vfe^A/i7^^ oA A*rx 73we*>a. S, ^            '#'~s <*>«* Aapcs *s ,
 F&VAL fiAortcCTtQAt [ B^A AM.tNJHHAWr A3~6f(A 7b P*Y&L£. Xm&AAPY
 P/"or£*r3VA/ B>Y 7Atac Cgvali '*        o\/£H.A(4£rA£r a/apa iW^'s
 0&Qe.C*3&A/ T& StW/A^S £?Gs>/fiSA/CT3\/£          ^aa&zcjmaAt.

 .FACTS;STJPPORTTNG'GROUN&:TWQ:; TAxac Jug**, P. ^ 2 eM, X*~ -
 AAi2gA>. &f aao'a: fi?Ui.3-*/&. oaA ~frc£&AfP**rA3 Afe* $m, P/za.-t/ix~a4- /n.orjrvfit

 J>rAr&A   3A/.'t>ZcrmeWT s1il&G2*i/4S' 2>?f/tn*-j?v€•   AAArtAs.pis -z/4£. Ap£^£lTA/€r A«2"S goawfegx         OF oAf£W5£5         Aa/P

 Aev/fr //AIS£ Aa-cM A^.T&rb BY A&A£J7Y'& 7//A" ^TTATlC To A 40 £7

 "7AA PAfiAGaZAAtt UAa*\A ^r7> 3r U*jrt.L P&octreTy              cA &Y             ,

 A7i£auarA£Y Ah7>#£'$S3~Af£r £c£$(?K. Cu8JT%Vi£ ....A<£~AS*x$ar P&.&^ TAt € "t>UFt.relTY o-f TAtA

*~£>iAA£7*1*16 Memoes eysjTtrui : J:a/ WAxcH THa SA/ia€

 ..A04Y2Mfer Xs     PuAfJSHtTQ Ivs/TCC , ^A£             £ouA7s$ ~1)AATAL

 To t>.1$3(JA/&73V£~t.y A PA*.        3rfi'PTcTM£Wr AT>V£lzA£Ly

 AfAASTAlA.TAAA X.UA,y. .7A/:*TAi4C7TdAt$ ASA WAtVl P. AA&SL£Ab?tY g

                                         AT

                                                                         Rev, 01/14/14
                                                                                          -2_,
 GROUND'T-tREEiV.e./iT?.*/ *f fie*s••>•-**-**   S^a**/*- AwttoMtrr
 P2&HTS 7> "PU£ P&ces.S. AtfbtQvAl PdcrrtrctToN OF rA#. IA\kj    SY TAxAC
 IJtSSx&tA C^lfW/'V- T>^F£Mis£ GSQet-r-swS 7*° St a. re*s             OS£
 Of AA OYetl~J£N~Ye)Mi -Lt\P3£T>        EXA&A/VeoyiS fiAXSt>GMCA#o&

  FACTS. SUPPORtING GROUND THREE:
 T>/t F£lYl>AA/T ///?_» /> ffstA&^WoMf tl&A/Y Ae/V Vz         A/OfY~P££*! Y

  OfrFPNSe fat*. S.itecfcsrtG A f£t?Ac. D'oG-• .mitiChT£WtN& .rV-TS

 S7£f~$0A/j AHfiPusxffaMAS StFAtu-AS _w fkxYAreApefp£~nry•,.

TH£ !>£f£t/PA/YT p£AT>7 4V AJ>t*7 tt*'D TA/f. AfAYX*TXG/Y "t~i

 77/£ tAtJA Y UAttc At &U£S7TQ/Y£~> fAf"?#£ AAt.eaccurxQM,

 A££2£Y/At& T/fc Syyf74t ~TQ Aa*#*£. X 2>£rA/TX7y /A£~Y£7>,TH£££**

• ~?y/a   PAosetorsvA*    Pa.& s/xooscy s&r OP A A?*&ttJ?/&^JM£.

 TA&L£       IAX7A/ A Px>V<££7i'fAXAtTjA& P-YP£^7.f 2AA 7//A

  XTiY(Z3-Sl>x-4TT»fi/ OF 7a^A~,..cA(aPY AAA PAP£AA€:pCS> To XAaA

  JAAli &F Dl'FA~n/23s!A/7'js- T~(TA/    P^rfl/£&~A PAaA/7 3   A(tft> A££

 TAYstr £ A/Tart, s, Saxz> (YAAazaa */?<&> Pa cures* A/t/4*-ut.3 siT£f>

                                     -43—

                                                                  Rev;0l/14/14
                                                                                 ?