Court Opinion

ID: 4124966
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2017-02-10 02:11:52.516401+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:37:36.615032
License: Public Domain

KEN PAXTON
                                           ATTORNEY GENERAL OF TEXAS

                                                   June 27, 2016

The Honorable Carlos Omar Garcia                               Opinion No. KP-0098
79th Judicial District Attorney
Jim Wells and Brooks Counties                                  Re: Requirements for a municipality's
Post Office Drawer 3157                                        posting of notice regarding the carrying of
Alice, Texas 78333                                             handguns (RQ-0087-KP)

Dear Mr. Garcia:

       You request an opinion on behalf of the City of Alice asking multiple questions concerning
the requirements a city must follow in posting notice about the carrying of handguns at open and
closed meetings of a city council. 1 Subsection 46.035(c) of the Penal Code makes it a criminal
offense to carry a handgun in rooms where a meeting of a governmental entity is held under certain
circumstances:

                  A license holder commits an offense if the license holder
                  intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly carries a handgun under the
                  authority of Subchapter H, Chapter 411, Government Code,
                  regardless of whether the handgun is concealed or carried in a
                  shoulder or belt holster, in the room or rooms where a meeting of a
                  governmental entity is held and if the meeting is an open meeting·
                  subject to Chapter 551, Government Code, and the entity provided
                  notice as required by that chapter.

TEX."PENAL CODE§ 46.035(c). Sections 30.06 and 30.07 of the Penal Code provide the language
to be used in a notice to prohibit entry with a concealed handgun and entry with a handgun that is
carried openly. See id.§§ 30.06(c)(3)(A), .07(c)(3)(A). Your questions relate to where and when
a governmental entity may post those notices to exclude the carrying of handguns at meetings. See
Request Letter Attachment at 2.

        Each of your five questions assumes that a governmental entity is authorized to prohibit
the carrying of handguns in closed meetings. See id Subsection 46.035(c) makes it a criminal
offense to carry a handgun only in instances when "the meeting is an open meeting subject to
Chapter 551, Government Code." TEX. PENAL CODE§ 46.035( c). "Open" for purposes of chapter

         'See Letter from Honorable Carlos Omar Garcia, 79th Judicial Dist. Att'y, to Honorable Ken Paxton, Tex.
Att'y Gen. at 1 (Dec. 28, 2015); Letter from David D. Towler, City Att'y, City of Alice, to Office of the Att'y Gen. at
2 (Dec. 21, 2015) ("Request Letter Attachment"), https://www.texasattomeygeneral.gov/opinions/request-for-
opinion-rqs.
The Honorable Carlos Omar Garcia - Page 2                   (KP-0098)

551 of the Government Code is defined as "open to the public." TEX. Gov'T CODE§ 551.001(5).
"Closed meeting" is defined as "a meeting to which the public does not have access." Id.
§ 551.001 (1 ). Because subsection 46.035(c) is expressly limited to open meetings and there is no
reference to closed meetings in either sections 46.03 or 46.035, it is not a criminal offense for
individuals authorized to attend the closed meeting to carry handguns into that meeting unless the
closed meeting is held in a location where handguns can be prohibited through some other
provision of sections 46.03 or 46.035. See TEX. PENAL CODE§§ 30.06(e) ("It is an exception to
the application of this section that the property on which the license holder carries a handgun is
owned or leased by a governmental entity and is not a premises or other place on which the license
holder is prohibited from carrying the handgun under Section 46.03 or 46.035."), .07(e) (same).
Section 4 l I .209 of the Government Code prohibits a state agency or political subdivision from
posting notice prohibiting the carrying of a handgun "unless license holders are prohibited from
carrying a handgun on the premises or other place by Section 46.03 or 46.035, Penal Code." TEX.
Gov'T CODE § 411.209( a). Thus, a city may be liable for a civil penalty if it posts notice under
section 30.06 of the Penal Code prohibiting entry into a closed meeting with a handgun unless the
closed meeting is held in a location where handguns can otherwise be prohibited. See id.
§ 4I l.209(b). 2 Given this conclusion, we answer each of your questions only with regard to
notices prohibiting the carrying of handguns in open meetings of a governmental entity.

        Your first three questions ask whether the open carry notice and the concealed carry notice
should be posted at the entrance to the building or the entrance to the meeting room, and whether
a city may "prohibit entry to the entire City Hall, or just to the" meeting room by a person carrying
a handgun. Request Letter Attachment at 2. Subsection 46.035(c) creates an offense for the
carrying of handguns only "in the room or rooms where a meeting of a governmental entity is held
...." TEX. PENAL CODE§ 46.035(c). In construing a statute, our objective is to determine and
give effect to the Legislature's intent, which we do by first looking to the "plain and common
meaning of the statute's words." City of San Antonio v. City of Boerne, I I I S.W.3d 22, 25 (Tex.
2003). By specifically limiting the offense to carrying a handgun in "the room or rooms," the plain
language of the statute makes it clear that the Legislature did not intend this provision to prohibit
the carrying of handguns throughout an entire building but instead only in the specific room or
rooms where an open meeting of a governmental entity is held. See TEX. PENAL CODE§ 46.035.

        You note that sections 30.06 and 30.07 of the Penal Code provide language for the notice
that states a licensee "may not enter this property." Request Letter Attachment at 2. The only
property where entry with a handgun is forbidden under subsection 46.035( c) is the meeting room
or rooms, and a governmental entity may not prohibit the carrying of a handgun from a location

         2
          The Open Meetings Act authorizes governmental bodies to meet in closed session to discuss certain topics,
and the public does not have access to such meetings. See TEX. GOV'T CODE§§ 551.071-.090 (authorizing closed
meetings in specific circumstances), .001(1) (defining a closed meeting as one "to which the public does not have
access"). Thus, while section 46.035 does not authorize a governmental body to exclude the carrying of handguns
from closed meetings, only the members of the governmental body and those individuals invited by the governmental
body have a right to attend a closed meeting. See Tex. Att'y Gen. Op. No. JM-6 (1983) at 1-2 (explaining that only
the members of the governmental body have a right to convene in executive session).
The Honorable Carlos Omar Garcia - Page 3                   (KP-0098)

other than those listed under sections 46.03 and 46.035 of the Penal Code. If a governmental entity
posts notice at the entrance to a building, it could suggest that a license holder is prohibited from
carrying a handgun throughout the building when in fact the law provides otherwise.
Governmental entities should therefore place their notices under sections 30.06 and 30.07 of the
Penal Code at the entrance to the room or rooms where an open meeting is held when excluding
the carrying of handguns under subsection 46.035(c). 3 If a governmental entity posts a 30.06
notice indicating that a license holder is prohibited from entering a portion of a building other than
those areas listed in sections 46.03 and 46.035 of the Penal Code, the governmental entity may be
liable for a civil penalty under section 411.209 of the Government Code. See TEX. Gov'T CODE
§ 411.209(a)-(b).

       You also ask whether the concealed carry and open carry notices may remain posted at
times when the governmental entity is not meeting. Request Letter Attachment at 2. Section
46.035(c) prohibits the carrying of handguns in the room or rooms where a meeting of a
governmental entity is held only "if the meeting is an open meeting subject to Chapter 551,
Government Code." TEX. PENAL CODE§ 46.035(c). If a room is used for open meetings and for
other purposes, a governmental entity may not provide notice under section 30.06 or 30.07
excluding the carrying of handguns when the room is used for purposes other than an open
meeting.

        Assuming that the notices must be posted temporarily, you ask "how long in advance of,
and after, the actual time of the Meeting ... may the Notices be given?" Request Letter Attachment
at 2. The statutory scheme does not establish specific times at which such notices may be posted
and must be removed. It would seem reasonable to conclude, however, that a governmental entity
could post the 30.06 and 30.07 notices at the time the room or rooms are opened to the public for
the open meeting, and the notices should be removed when the open meeting is adjourned.

        You also ask whether the timing requirements would be different for notice given in a "card
or other document," as that phrase is used in subsections 30.06(c)(3)(A) and 30.07(c)(3)(A). Id.
Sections 30.06 and 30.07 authorize notice to be given by written communication in two ways,
either by a posted sign, as discussed above, or by "a card or other document on which is written"
the prescribed notice language. TEX. PENAL CODE §§ 30.06(c)(3), .07(c)(3). While you are
concerned with the timing of the notice, the more important inquiry is the message that is conveyed
when these cards or documents are distributed. If using cards or documents to provide notice that
the carrying of handguns is prohibited pursuant to subsection 46.035(c) of the Penal Code, a
governmental entity should make it clear that the prohibition applies only to the meeting room or
rooms and only when the governmental entity is holding an open meeting. Subsections 30.06(c)(3)
and 30.07(c)(3) would allow a governmental entity to pass out cards at the entrance to a meeting
room where an open meeting is held to provide notice that entry with handguns is forbidden, or a

        3
          Because your fourth question is premised on a conclusion that section 30.06 and 30.07 notices should be
posted at the entrance to a building that includes a room or rooms where a meeting of a governmental entity is held,
we do not address it further. See Request Letter Attachment at 2.
The Honorable Carlos Omar Garcia - Page 4                 (KP-0098)

governmental entity could include as part of its open meeting notice that the carrying of handguns
will not be allowed in the open meeting. 4

          4
           Section 551.041 of the Government Code requires a governmental body to provide "written notice of the
date, hour, place, and subject of each meeting." TEX. Gov'T CODE § 551.041. A city posting such notice must do so
at least 72 hours before the scheduled meeting. Id. § 551.043.
The Honorable Carlos Omar Garcia - Page 5         (KP-0098)

                                      SUMMARY

                      Subsection 46.035(c) of the Penal Code makes it an offense
              to carry a handgun "in the room or rooms where a meeting of a
              governmental entity is held and if the meeting is an open meeting
              subject to Chapter 551, Government Code" and the entity provided
              the requisite notice. By specifically limiting the offense to carrying
              a handgun in "the room or rooms," the Legislature made it clear that
              it did not intend to prohibit the carrying of handguns throughout an
              entire building but instead only in the specific room or rooms where
              an open meeting of a governmental entity is held.

                     Governmental entities should place their notices that entry
              with a handgun is prohibited at the entrance to the room or rooms
              where an open meeting is held. A governmental entity may not
              provide notice that excludes the carrying of handguns when the
              room or rooms are used for purposes other than an open meeting.

                                             Very truly yours,

                                            ~?~
                                             KEN PAXTON
                                             Attorney General of Texas

JEFFREY C. MATEER
First Assistant Attorney General

BRANTLEY STARR
Deputy First Assistant Attorney General

VIRGINIA K. HOELSCHER
Chair, Opinion Committee