Court Opinion

ID: 4066726
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 22:45:34.425558+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:02:49.631289
License: Public Domain

/
                                     I
                                     V
         20I5SEP28 PHI"32
                                     «
                                     "t
                                                      K              r
                                                          i          ^
                                          \
                                     •i
                                          ?
                                     *
                                                          9    «
                                                          K    \             >
    I    t
               u
                   %
                            I
                            *,

                                     k    I
                                          «
                                                          C
                                                          JL

                                                               %
                                                               "a    >       I
                                                                     I
                                                               \
               >
               ^            a        s"
                                          y
                                                               Ji            i
                                                               %i
    'i   V
                •i                        I           s.
                                 t            ?           V
                                                                     n»                                           s
                       <1
                                          j                          •j
                                                                                                             «.
                I                                                    s                                       <•
                                     %                ?
                                                                         i
                                                                         X
                                                                             ^5;
                                                                                            !?
                                                                                                             I
                                     H.
                                                                                        V                    t
                                     I
                                                                                            \                s
                                                                                                    V        V
                                                                                                    1        «
                                                                                        X   w
                                                                                                    ft       (5
                                                                                   V.   S
                                     I                                                                       X
                                                                                   I >                       !
                                                                                                X
                                                                                   I I      fJ      ($       I
                                     d
                                                  (                                                      (
         fl./'^4C//''M''

         ^75/^^•v

                                  y                    , _

         / jrv 2. Si'y^f tfL.s^

        ^t^o/f.,/^ T

                         .A /:^<)A^^'^*^.

          C fi "L                           j?*   Z-''"*'?^

          /l.t/Ji-}/f,       ?^7^/
(   ;

          -'Z>y»^ /<•                     ^Ac^ /.f-,        £ji»Ar-yy.

                                 .A^.^-!<^.f-^

           y i cj* j>-?9r-t~ / ^ ' r y 7 7 ^

                                      7 &iu>3
            7yT/£

           /^'t--v**>     ^/if*' -O-v                                                                              '

           /~/i^/L. ^^vbTZ/"^                                                                                      *'

                               <» /         y^y<-^^.t*r£/^n                                                        //'

           y/^S/c- ^ ^                     ^
           y. /^/fcJif o y /-w^                                                                                        /

                                                                                                                       t

                              tfV* /"/'/•jT /f/l.^^^e•^^' /te.c^/' oy ^••^^e.s^                                        X

      0^ ^/t^CAy%vO C>/^c<.>y ^g'tAAAA                  ^
    t/ /i/i.^vA^'CMr^ Oty                                                                                                  ^

           y^'^tfA^^/^-y e^ y^»' ^/t.^•»'**««'»'»"- "Ti* •f£A»ycA^          ^aao^/^

                    f/Cy1V,^yS                                                                                         &

    l/'i'' ^yvCytz/XJ/^                                                                                                '

<1^/        ^/cyty^i.                                                                                                  y

                                                                                                                       y
e           lytA.f /yo^yf"^

                                                                       /'
//'
        CfiSv                                                                                              fl/tXx

  /.                                     ^         yitjji/                                                     y

 Z.                               t/'/^^A^cM^ xryj-^S"               c^jrcw                                        3

 3, Ctry fi/ ^yfyx^cytsfcyt-^                            ,   rvj           c-r-i/^Cj-? Crcj,                       4

                     W          ^c a., y3i. ^iy 3^ 307 Crci^ Ao7^J                                                 y, 3-

 37 /Vi//vOVtfiy{4. CSS> iA ^AliAx^ A.C i               3A 3ZA C/- A^ rJ                       /

                                                                                                                        6
 C           Ajl yiavj•>-Ti*/ 3/ A»*" (^VX*) ^/r''                xaj>-*-3                y

 f.                      y///f^^AtroA^ 3 Z,/ yt^yy^ yOA OiTi              y/a^ry*^A«r*y                                 7

^ o. J'/»r5'Ttf<'^fc/O      ^.v/iAif^ iA y'/ttAy/' AA        / "3^ 3 Ju/Zy C3 C         '4>4t7A^S' ZayAj           3

,(. yt^yfyf tA ^y///*-f / fff^ yvQ^<^>                                        3

/ Z. yy/AyX/Sys-Xr^ (y ye,y^,yvtAd ^ i ShySX y i'7                     Zaoo^

A? /"^*X/»j              Ay/Otty /AxA, C<,A A i,yr ^rx/ , 3 jr7 Juy 3<^
                                                                                                                •A
                C/WTe /9/r'~ y«^f e^»y\,rAy Z*-'*)

//.               iA//^y^xAA^, A yiyyZ*                  73* C/'eA' A/*'' /U-t^X.'*'^ / f Zf Z                      y

  yyAAOyA s

      TVs:*. ext4-. z^/jz ¥-/C*^ zu>d^          f/o/.txA                                                           i 7

      /-••Of Cf^^. AiUtc y-yZi^ eoiAe.         i /A/-roC C.*>                                              'A. r,           7

     T}cy>               ^ d£i^ itxxa         f /77./'i* C <'-7                                                             7

     y^Ao Cr*'/AyAX.f y44^ Ao9t.             f /3AxaA(,A3                                                   s" O 7

      rAA ASfOtAA d^-z-c                     ^ 3^*-a-z 3 OiCsr)

      '^/^CAC.J      dyKu- "Tt'C.-io^^t.t^

                                                             1*7
                                                         \   /V/v/.t t*46iwO^^ •Ji/Cc^o'-^r

             A-^fy ~                   ^f^V. fr»

             *p//?ey^

                                A^y^CZ/'jufrt

  r'v                                   ^yt

                           ^oy^ tf-iT ^o f^f             Ay0^-^<9*^*-,               /^yta St.,        y^ArS
 /"yf'S ^yCsCry /^vC.                              y^ 71^^ y^Sf'^f'C. ^yp'S^ts^                       ^5rt>irc.^
 /^yy^ a->                          oy^ :7yrASt,/*yyiJ' /t^ Z2:£yy:<:»                                Zf/Lyc.y. Z^A.
  /tf fhfCJtpy    yyy/i S ^yc. /-^ /fZf^Z/fy^s                       Z» /£'>t        yvZss zyZc Z^yyo

  4y/>V^Jlyj Ci'^ tHZ^.tS) (z.'^ • 6^t.l}^ dy y'VVlS^
  ^, j/~yt,tcy: CVey-Z: AaT? rZZrJ^ Z^U'JS^aZ ys yy.rZA,o-c0 T-yy ZZt- zyAjt»C^}                           y*z^'^*-~
 yi/i Zy                             tZ'Z^'A°> ^C. ztcy^yytAy^^ZS y9^'9 ,y2yhy^ Zty? y^y y yyZyW-C^yZft

 7~zz< ZCCcyZytZ'f      ^ty/yyZ /iw/cSi ZZ^Z          ~tyy» Ct.) yiyyZr **/«-<-•. oye yyy ryZyr            yty^t

 Z^^Ay\      yZZ^cZiifyyz /—^ y^Z^ ySyy /4yyyfCy%y7<               Z^ytyC^. ZZo o>yt^ty~^ Z~ZZ^ zC*.4yy*,*tyy.-.'f
                                                                                                                   (//
                    /                                                                                       **
                                                                 ^ C^A>ci»//e.^^e.^ ;r7#fiv-'

         cA /tS'-^'ity^^ /0/vD                                                              U^/*^ ^y/<^ o *y j-f/^t^              2x>^/,

                                    ZOf/^ '^Oyt-<^f/^/7 / ^yij ir-y£.^ O^                                   vHV^ ^ ^yf^y                /ty/tc-^

         ^/9J-                   ^/cyty<                           y~//-£ y:',ye.y*~            ^     a / yZynry^ S'i/*y Cz./t,            Sl/ ).

         /-//''C Syy^''^-^                               ~/Z^ fr-yyy!f-r f^'<-^ D*                  /7>^<            r»j,yyj- y»yt^ ^'fi'bAucyyr,
         /9MH /'.^SCJ''                          oyy       /f^'VyyT                  ^ry^y^'Z. y7yt.*- yyvy^yS^O y^ ^C-

         ZluJO          S'.^/^4/tyty<- JCryyy.         £^y yy ^y^• y£ytj^77«yy                          A-iyy/<~x>^^ yi/^•tVyyty^'rr ^y^y^y,/-
         Ayy^ yyr yv y^—^g-yy"^ ^-y^fC ^^w-«Vv4-

                                            ^/^yWyfhyy                   ^yt.o j"«_ yfyy^ ryy'C ^<£yt:a,y^J' eyygyj^ "ioyc- /^a»-"v/>i

          y^y^S^Ajr- /Tt/co          f" y^y*':i ytyy^ yryyVfyycy^/tt,y- ^yry iyys/yf'Syt. y-".                       yy-yyyu gyy T'^y<

                        /--f yAfCj^yi/tc^cjr'^     ^Ar~'CytyJ'Ccy^yyy7^y't-.

           J'^yyx y^ y»y%yy         •yV^'C y^''*y>y^''y**               y 2>*xeZ^sjyoyy^ /fytg'e                 ySS*y*~y

           /JytiLS'yryyy^o : y) ^^y*'y*/'^ yyyyC                                          /ty%^otyi*y         y^yye. y^oyt,

          /t     /Z^yt-muyyutyt. ^/"/iy^yrt-                            r/^ ^yy*^yy ey>y^£yy~ ^f/ifi»»/"?TS-t. Xi^ /^ey? y.fy

          ^yxyi-              Cyc»»(-^ y?j- yZtjc-ryoy^ y^Xy^o^^yy^'^ /7gVi:-y!4.»yyy
                                                                 t yS'y~J

                                                                                                                                             t'>j
      .jVJ' r~9 /5U-»««-vS> /~//<. ^^,i*jj-^^ir.

/2t                                     y^^rriiA.

                                    fy/-c   /~A<-f/t-y                     JZ/<3jy^/-u>'erjr,o,^_^ ^^5

      O-Z^/^/AtA-rr                  yi/tx. ^<.«r-    (SyytAcxj!}

       ^UA*A.yy         ^ y    y-yy-c. ytyyfv^A^^y-

                                   /l/^£-//At.A^r' y/ytiA\y yyy/>t.   yy^t           Cy'«e'         e>/' yy^*- j>>»j-«..

       ^fpy y y 4fy               ly y/t^.'-'AncAy, -2- vy Suf yy s <£,              ztuf^J i^j yyyyK ^ y^yic^rty

        uj/^          /tcy<'0     tuA^yr/^r' ^y-ry«-«_^tfjo«yv'''T«>v#'                           <✓ /v»7- y    yyt,"

                      /'/yy j'/'/try yyi^y Sovyx.ef^AA                                          ^Z?            j^yy<^A^yyS'

       fi ^^C/t aaaa                      y    /^y y^A yyos

       •Dm/Z^jt ^oa>3J           y/yyAu,A /j- ^          yA>yAAf,^^,ry ^ oy7ZrxcAJ'-/rA'A aaa J>AX'^AyxA fy yyyAC yS-*-.— yi-i.

      Cyy^yz. x/" jZ/£f y*^'yyy yT-AA^        <^y-yo

                                                                                                                                 I 3J
             «*-^   T/^< y^^c.^5.*'/»'o»'r

                             i/f<^C/<. /V*/»-r                        /f/'rf^y.re~        ^oe'Oyyyc^vtf*^
     ^                                         /***/»/pA*y<^yi>y*'*-^                             ^A:: Ay-foy^r /*^

A C.y A               y/^X /S.At^/'yeycA. yt £.^s->sr>      y/yx^ J^aaa. / ^ A ^ j v ^ A a ue^-x.^

yyz^ Si*-'3*^ 30 C^9c Zoy/*^^ /l/y^/iffyy y7/y^'Cj                      /\/V*t~ fy^<

S^siAi- c* /-v' /iA*}i tturr-Tit- -rAA. C-t^. Cc.a. C, z*J

                                             ry-^ ^^/V«» >"<_»_         yy Ayy,y?ytyy^^ ^y A^-ryyAt^

//vsi»*aOi^A'^/"•* A. c SA'caA'^X £A^^CA tt/V~ CyAi£A> Za>o ir) Se-'Cytay y^y A-^C^ jSAk'eyioy *>y yA-*—<.                        ^ Sc-cy>ofi^ yvyyAC
 /^y X'yy Sw^Tin—XAoyy                    yytt**.ir AAlAyy T't*     ^At t^Xyyrrr         ^yy-*y yyA.        yXy-Ae^

 /i'/'A*A-yy S ^ ^ y f y ^ A ' ' " y ^ X'c-'a XcAcyt a^-y ya*. yyxC*^) aa-c* yoy.yaX(yj
                XTSOy      •^yvA'JZ-Ay-

                          U/^iay /^A/yyX j?/Z ^           SIaj^                      yt       .

  /~//c SiA'r /lyy^AyAyfy:rt(^f        TS'CA^yA'y       r-» SiyVzz" »a-«. yCA-cJitACAyy H ^                             ^Ayt-ynAA' A^ta^yAy
  /~^-£. ^A'tAeAyAtCAfyAA        lAA^fy- yZA^/fAtJOiAA^        Sa* a%a<~ ' X-ASyi-cy-yyA ytcA. JZatry-a-eyyo-y ^

  ScA* .            Z^/"- y yt-UA-Ai , C-'.X»^*'-^-JV-»^ a-py^

                                                                                                                               7-y¥^

     •^•'®- -f««-»«' 2 .c> t'.ri^

                .'«5v/v^«~»6-v/- »               er^/:ry^y

     y}.^f^     «^/      vy
                                                                                                 tyri*ta  o-              f y-c/y-f^^ 7ff,
    - ^-7 ^ ^~y-t-tf /R-X'^yy. /T:^. yy/^-ix*.'' r^'itisL r/fxt yyy^y yj ty<,/ yy-<                               /«^

     ijjiHtt^ r^^f JS^                                             yx4Z./^y .ji *yL. f /•ix. y^az"C^J.
      OA      F£^     ✓/#«<'-
                                             ,           yfyxyx- £xy^*y>- f/ax.xac (4J xfy-9                   */♦tx/,j^,

.                         ^     fiCJ^^-> y^ <•          -          OyiZ^tX Cayncxxii-'J-                t^ZiXXM't't. yixy^Ce.^.

                         I^vr ''                                       ' -HtSO*^'" '

               k1^'             U
                                                       C^A^c^ry    '/#•''^^yinj-e^ ^/t^t^/'ir y£j/ytA/tyy^g-o

        ^             y                                           o^y a <"t /t f^e-o            C f/^e.ft / /^^t/'^^rv

        C^ry py ^^^cje«r- tX £ /<»>*- yJCoy^^

                                               ^'•*y~'*-tCe'   ^Vit-wX /lArS ^^%//%.r- lyy/r-tyy/c. r1> /tM-AvcXr"                       Ty*jr^/ej^,'

                              y/j^cyiL,        /'y^'9»^C*SL 4Ct^t/-/7/TV*^-' /9cy^'O ///gfyt^/y.

        —»'<^                         /7/^X^r^cyr^

                                               /"TS^                                        /-y r~>                       ^yr.^tjrreu      f-*t

                     ^Ir^< ^eoy/t-ei^c oy" y//^ A^cya                            yjsi^e^ fyuvl ry y><^iytA                   /tJL.
    ~                             y. ytyf-y/tt>\,yyy'^ C f y :t,j-,-J Zto * X                                 /?*-t_«^<-y y^„yy

        y^yJLCffyeyy'y                                                                                    yAf£ jyi.at                   Q.MfyT'f
         CattJ'^ jL^z- juj S^ e yy.

                                                                  yyty^^        AAt^yC y^yr-r? yyy-£       ^^yw y yvr-ey.Cyy9y-a)

                          ^y>%y/yyjni/ A^t. A^tytyy y^iy*-^A^C>     yy Dytyy* *y^y^. Jfiyyrn

            A'AA^AA'y /ZcyA^yy^eyti-^yeys.^o''^, yjry^ y/t-yo ,y lyy^nA y^y^f^c^ ^/eyt- y* AyA*- J^ytjiAyc^oy

            uyA^f 'i^ytyytyfryA^ yjAyrt jy^e^y Tyi-yy^-xa            /-yft. /Ltyetney^y— y»^Aay>. '^'yCAoJvytA. y>y y ^yyyyyo

         ySczy y-'yAc'^ yis /J yr'i^^ATi'^ ^ 2>'/C«.«*w'*/7»,r ^
        C ^.d-            _j~>C<«''»/" y^yt-f a A' yVy^y ^^xo^e-s»<>««. "Tjp yyoy~^y<~                    yyyy 1>tS'y-y%.»-cy ^Aiy.*e

^              y                                                                            _
        y/Ao- /7Mr?                                    ^
                                                                                 «. /l^my-         /=?/>--/•

   ^ z** ^ /»•/> •» -•'

                                          r/^^   7-^.^ £»fcv-»«- /r^i           fr-y

  ^e»*             TV^             riP' ^* •"^ ^ ^/»J't-0 C/V ^1        *»«-c

                          /9yi-ii>"^yy''^ A^//✓77'Ai/'/'—
                              '                         yv Mt, ~~J fX/^ f                            ^ ^ yifTtXfi^ po

      Ay*r yMfi-                                                  /Ot.^ ryyc,-*.                                     y^

                   /-.                                                                  .✓ ^/-A-                   "'-

                 ...                                                                   ^W,. 4....^.^^ -^1^-
       3 1./ y.u J. ..y r ^ ' " '-"-^ -'•'•''''

  '     '                                                                                      ^^        «fc r t-< - i'-y'"'-' Z"-^'

            .^rtA-n.^v"^                                                           ^ . o." —-                             "      ,
                                                   rj r/,6U.1^- , y""

                           /f'                          ^ U*""
                ,v"'                              "••              ,.y.
                  fie^                                                                                  /i/'o*^e. -iXl>,,o-.

                                          ;^.i- //ity^a./\^jf^c.               o^y// Cjay^Jf=><^ /i^y/U ^xt-

                                    y/fi ^                                     yPtacA»~itfje'S.

J
/ 5--     .j^y>y -       sy

                >-iyyy

                                                     tycy^ 1^ d^         --'

                                ^                                                    yx^yr. ^ Cf^oe^                   «»<*'

                ^cy/^X                        yyyy xyy                              yytf*-         ^&->. t^eu--

                                ^^eAyrcjo            ,r»w                               y Z' ^fcywy^^'-ys«j».-*-

                                      Zi.>u^Ze'trx^ t'lZ      -y^->. ✓y' e—<_

                              jT" a**y y^i*                    X^-yy y y     yyy<

  //yx ^ccy XZy/' X//i ^'^'' Z/yxv               X           oy r/Xx /"y^                    a y-f x>X .

 y* r

X" '^/s/y/y^X            X'/^yi' y*yfi^yityy                iXi-Zy,             X/^^^y-xyj Zy^xfyt^-sx^ ^
    Z^ypucxy             X'yy''<- Z/ox ^ yy^xty^^y , o*® ^»yx

                                                                                                                               CirJ