Court Opinion

ID: 6834818
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-23 20:02:25.345634+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:04:40.130003
License: Public Domain

BONDY, District Judge.
This is a motion to punish for contempt bankrupt’s president, who has failed to comply with an order directing him to deliver books to the receiver of his estate. In opposition to the application for that order he stated in affidavits that, through forgetfulness, the books were left by him in a cab and lost. The order states that the facts set forth in the affidavit were untrue and unworthy of belief,, and that the books were in possession and under his control.
The order was affirmed on appeal ([C. C. A.] 15 F.[2d] 614), the court stating in it3 opinion that the matter set forth in his affidavit was obviously false, in the sense of being wholly unworthy of belief, and that it formally introduced a defense, but the defense was sham; that is, one which is palpably false.
In opposition to this motion to punish him, the respondent interposes an affidavit. It does not state that there has been any change in the possession of the books since the granting of the original order. It states only inability to comply with the order by reason of the facts set forth in the affidavit in opposition to the original order, which affidavit he incorporates in this proceeding.
The order directing him to produce the hooks is at least prima facie evidence of bankrupt’s possession of the books. The answering affidavits set forth no allegations of fact other than such as were adjudged to be untrue and unworthy of belief and sham. The answering affidavits, therefore, present no issue to be tried. The motion, therefore, must be granted to enforce compliance with the order. See In re Frankel (D. C.) 184 F. 539; U. S. v. Moore (C. C. A.) 294 F. 852; In re Stavrahn (C. C. A.) 174 F. 330, 20 Ann. Cas. 888; In re Weber (C. C. A.) 200 F. 404; In re Plaza Shoe Co. (C. C. A.) 15 F.(2d) 278, and In re J. H. Small Shoe Co. (C. C. A.) 16 F.(2d) 205, decided December, 1926.