Court Opinion

ID: 4047871
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:30:33.708104+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:38.021095
License: Public Domain

' 3101/1211:/51)9<

3~“-€7- /5

 

 

w _-_-4_- FWMAJAMAA
ii

3¢§ 'j£j//

WY~Z 9?¢`/3
‘m`$ 784 if

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

~_RECZ£{VEBW 0

 

 

 

 

couRT oF chMlNAL APPEALs ~ l `
"AR 122“‘5 , ' 9292 241 /;4 11111<7 01174
'_AWWEGMK 3@71 F441 2511 511 vi

"&'”"”3”7”“ 704 7')2J /

 

 

 

 

C193/Sr /~/<9 _1_1/11 3 1193~/3
€Av{Sfc N¢O W,Q 355/5 ..)4/~

 

1“_'€

7 114

 

 

_tho»m`s /19100_3)~3)7.3~ 29141315

 

z __)%))MEZ£ Ld(r'b()r; 39'3) G>~¢/Z7 1

531/mm flow ?QESFECW‘L/Lb\j Do/m»c 1114 540/9~1_/193.2£)1~4~1"79/<
G#LL£D 557)71041411 /9~0 l:w£s zia 790014£. ST§/L)w 3€1¢¢¢_0y /vu.MA&/¢£/!)
333 113 733 1141/nj 1313131 71,<3.1,~

/

+_ ,
FHS H°MWML£: 613/17 /)91<35` vmo)cm)~ 1,113.£3419»17 Z 7661/,/4,7
. /05 191\»1_1 Z}£ )` 1937 71419~_1 HLWKT_LLL_.. J“¢£\£am;zmnjw 114 __
_QLL_/_]._U_ /‘)BB£¢.L$_ Cu_ 141/1041 r /99/*121,30131114»11 Nvg/ F/L 3511§/1414& 1961 01‘731£ 407 `
`45~,11131.1 0’1.43116131)`633 057/16 1037 711111 19 Ds-/¢w /Z'1L313~7>71/ '

' I?7)` 7M00u Z? A'LWV mi Su~m( _VQJ,’]&/F 91¢7 701/014 Ké/f;\dw l
711 W)M16;/. 17 1310)4& 141 Zf
7}111135 1494/b 759 619111660.131 6151471111 @0»33»75 741<41=5
l/l/Hlé/L£ 7}}£/ B£<)u/W F-@-m/u;, §71LL4 ]QS)GNJ '
033336113118.13 19 43/133@1‘3313 .:7,4 733 2971/l
.Dlg»z;uw 6341071;“00/'1`$131@314`111>1‘¢4 '_7£1)1//}$ C/<».\°L 7
/¢v<) WM7HS 06€111_1 713 fmb 1?41€)3-3_6 ZMWM>D 17
Wm_ 663 . 51»1»»3611 1130 837 114 01171333;7 "
147761¢¢4£>/. JUéP/-f /\j ,H#;wn{ /370 7\91‘7 1/(/191,47 '7'0 1
1931113.1 /03 7 1411/6 M§/ 611/1543 /¢4131310 /157 2131-1
71,.,314/;1!- Z/é, 0)¥74€1!/) A7711/1ME5/5 JFF/Lé 614 /1/
/\jo'/_ 6/5£ Mq (_5>;~71,31£46141, )/)11)1)16 [)1»331¢'71-0)11§_- 1
»’7.,. 19111,3,3.17 01_ 6213/me m3 11/171173 .
` l'F//LL£ 0 E'ch`%\m 037 Oi‘ m@ A#l}\ S/N»Qf_ `
714 011~71137 19771)11~£731 666/14 /19119 14 `
¢-,3 ~

.D))@W? J\NL 70 717£ D15741L»7 CH/» i)¢f_ f `
. 4 4205/11\@/110/)~10 /41‘1”!011//_171100 /q'w 1 417&540377 %‘,77“7 l
7_. _]`lLL 4 //,07 Ag-/*() 141/\11715»»/ l¢/YM'7 ADM,)C)¢?/v>q 071,_,
7/#0 ;§Séz»D?W/ll-~'07 ~Cu'w)¢?'/. _Z pii)10 DWY¢ 4/4"~17-$'
400 €/’11 711/011 011 ‘-”/1.17' 1501/011 74010 .71111 /1/)01
Nw 651/0 édw/g 4 74€ 4 ‘M/K-'l'? "A')°PM&FWI/M
5010 7/1% 5 714 D's'z¢lw 500/17 742 01571<117 CLé/zl<
§§¢¢7 1774»§)%€< 57147`10\4» %_%)1-7 7//-¢1<12 21 A/O
Ju10612 7{3)1'0\4/.,\_».<1;1 7'1~7_$ Jf:d DK%w/? few/1077 0
610€0/& x)~()#m{ j /4141)7 pohu"! 4401 77l/77 ill
610£<'71004 111 ne W'MT fw 75 "1/0/41_11 /z¢/A_\’
7142 511062/ 7+07 2 YS~-/Meén 700 "’_7 14&//
, .Z'T 111/1905 111/165 B¢w/)\/ 7)4€_- film TC[) 444/ng ,
.. Yf Z h/om[) TQ£I)Q' 714£5 Gdf m’\¢¢ 7 ~?
` 571/t Mw?i/ 74$5'111<120¢\/ §<2£ ~ 711/1507 /Vls/

.,_")v
3"-

  

 

   
  

 

. 14/{2917£ H/M;F f£“/ILM /:/"l/é'/O. 7 0014¥(’ /\44'7M_
MHM@_M<»I_ HFBQN_Z£BLEJQ§ u_:___ CM`S’__
' j W14§ ijm/£»/;l 14/1411,14 fnb/1447 74/»147 ‘
242 397“’5¢ 01§‘1_{1167 615/147 NU L)wef/L /4')¢1)
7 M/oM~/ /41171>\47 /15514411»¢ 714/1 W417 1450 2411/6457
7//*)?7 NW 714/16 D)WH£/I 477144\1&14 [;»540 %M»191 ;~7 Ww~z BE/C¢’/n£. 24 311/474 ZWH
gha/5017 Eu‘z 5~7 /7<%/ 72‘4€ 071710>120/' /4~7714»¢/$7
.Q/M 7431£'7 457 %E 52140 :Z»¢ 714/5 G~~Lu/`)A
…5555£%7 ph'-A»94 245/mw 7101-7 l AMU>JADV
_AAPO SD\//LS. AMO 7///1 14105%14//52_4/%1 an Mé._
laban éQ//`£V l L'»O\¢'/i_/ llc/7 AF/‘Mt»/) 7 4&7
,71;1'/( /47471/)5>¢~// A(H?'M 450 615/7 444 A¢¢'Zd)e/f%(’ 2611€£
5541’41¢¢9; y“7 315 145`1’7_1`7;4»¢7 O/r/me? 247¢5/4/'5»¢5’
519'»5 7)¢5*7 2 Mdé_.g%»__&/_Mé,;%&£% 315 L)

 

 

 

 

 

14wa4/d ' fmi ",/_ £~,1'1294. /411 W»_¢': 4%!7
7,;,94/¢7€991/ 1119 0494,9!4»9145999 _1/
745 [)»9'7444€,7 04 /)1417.48€ 051 7425 13¢1;14,/¢73¢

 

'14/1141)-4 9 -~/qwn 2 545/15 7 715/1414 319/mha
14 54549 5/9991 6’99%199 44 745 v
/\/Ww ;Z 1440 - 1411<@/1'\ 7 145/5 /'\')é CLAM
. 016'7` 75de j 6517777\414/11471€0 1045:1951”7`/ /5//714
@,Z#D 74011»/1,4'£[ x `7/16 ~G;"P’H~< ,
Lp 5 , ,

.0/55/500- -9_`7 7000 /L//_m/) 740/10 7422/050 327 '
l/l/A~S %n ~ 7401/177 /<6)4, lion /41.\¢0 - 70/< /7 f'
CH’UW /~!/mS\L/`,p 75 _/j;uu’? Wu»¢l01¢7~0 010 M.f 71»¢47
35 C¢»M»l£n l//o 04ij 590/40011‘7 BWL/J<.,
n BM? file/105 101/150 1 )41101 ,- Uw IQH'/-dl/é ~
' itc amc ¢Y//m‘z`£»/A /$é)m, 27 :Z 940 /W\/ .~
. P)-?am£ A-»n M//:: §70¢,€04 7/40+7 W/$\/ `
14530', . ~
fhqu j 10 320/3 706 Z/S' 0_10107
U/"V 57/£514)0/ AFF/¢}/M:. lQ/MM/n` 7WI ””_D)SWU/u/
_/04701. /)/q-’MJM S<>AWLLMLI\' 7£;100 B-#GLQ%`I"
/::;i/' /!£L./ gmai$~¢£é Z#? 57)'?`750 Mu€/é plc
)M v 6514140//00 C»..M 101/07 35 44§0¢/04150 £0/1747
4//4047 70 03 5000 010 2 070 9070000/
/0@1\ 1054 4500/101 200 1400001@/6~/4/
/300 7911»_7 010 Z. 2017 z 510/0/ 705 `
2510 71010020. ¢¢//7)0 gac/579 /‘005 700 790/7 `
§F" Wy //'1// 041’7/ (/’1/‘);
JMQ“_NM&_D 117111¢? A_7:7_M¢;13'OM€/é
»L__&z:zéw/wnj ,. 79 = FAF? 7_11,,11;/1 711,.¢

712/11 111/1171 FZAW.,._ 711 1925 /ng/) 715
045 Fm 711/5 59`£5 /4¢}11, 117 &peé ;)\1<:7
74me /Y)e #171 71\4»< Z hbé A` QPfo/£ /§'Ww
HM/\/ 57a 7,//§}1/| few ¢11141/111( 7/£{: f/V;-’T E»».D/Vze’{l
§'/<’n.¢i 711/171511\1 ' Lf'c//m/Y 741‘7&'7 7,,
- _§?Eg£¢bg£ 11/)41 Mm/rv§/M' /?u_v' l 07/) ~
6 /4+}54¢1? 5§1111) ;FL5 E»c 7 A~ §017¢”7/1/1,/ -
or 71111~-:2, * ~'

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

 

 

. §77)7”75' Awn 'O[’JO A §c;) /¢ 1117/1/ // ,
/1/,@1"7 Awummmu» (/1/1',7# /n/ Orvz _//!< 41`

 

. 7114 //}4/7/3>14£/£"&1 1417 4/111'17 .171_*
" _Ey_m %:03_3/<~/`;11713 - 141/1 K)F 7/14€321\` "
§70`17¢1613. 3/(111/ 7 £4/1)11/10 013¢€/1_1$ ~ '
ZM)#¢~ 35#€1414411(11:0 1411714 *
SMPAM<’§))M 14 jD).f71112/'7 Tq/Y)/n‘i ;#140
351/1114 /h/l: '~ 7 41441) /vah)m 173 5
36 h//`TH 115/477 701/§ )O9i6é ) §’03
7?./@3 £_`64) 1414/7 1543/21 Fm. 1 1411 713 0
110 1111§1 (1313313 3/31\ 413 711 11133_

§41_613142/411&1,20114:_211 16»37

 

 

 

 

 

 

56 \7/’;:§. 477 7 1179 -/ddm/LJ»¢-BI_A` 61me
3 '_ ., /)111}€;71/7 1414/1 ;~p)/LWW, `

 

 

'S:`/M& MWH /Q”£é_ IF' M¢/
_/M/M_ZJ£,LL 23 /4 514-011 l/wu %%1-7

511/3 3 2 Hw §7111 14 ,P1e111411 50111111
”851141117131011119;/1111131,1 1470 1141 1410 §`711»»0 1511

5?31171;15 ;1,w 743 . 16.,11,»11__,1}»13 1111 111

l__w~<_é/_ng£/L 6131£5/ 519 @.4497_17,17/111\1 1 2 1914 §`7)2/(, l
1821_310] jg_,//z%orljmlgg%/M 1141:_1…
_H_A __¢_3.~`,£ 5//`11/¢/1312/\1 7Mf 37qu ' ` l
1411 l %§51141&544331 /.1,1143__5;2_, 1111 2 714;

<>L¢LM_-’J__ 901

 

 

 

. 7333_

 

 

~ ‘~4/1£¢0/¢§ 73¢1_3;,7 fm 1177
G¢/ ’ 2 '
7

 

 

 

.B€ G‘F»HN'?bb 745 ////4 A}X 5_§<5>5`.4 IA)CvQ/M-M;P
7/!11“7 714£,4/ 4440»¢4/ @7'7,1),~ Mb 7,%¢14 7 ,
1£/4/11 /Y)I;, [H/// 714 41775¢5.__/27_7___ §§Z§_/FQ¢<£_
704/7M 747 7 A/Ié£/} 7 6¢1741?144,4’

% _.

- 43 w 4@_¢§;511 144/5@_&5,1 libng___
145 XM 644 §'£1' fla you _ 701/k ;Lp/.,M 144/147
L_W,¢__~ZLJ€Z’HMMWIM )q»vwn pvz'_) 5 ‘7#£ S()\/A:Y
Bne,/L 05 nm j §4501,5¢/ 41/0110511 441 1644/074
153 111551_§5555455 454 05

21_/;4__€/5111\114555,<\/45115 ap ,
.'_ §A@ §55/) ~ /‘115,50 445
_§57<9__5L14m WMSjWYM_MA%Q
,<11< 4]4557, @11'4.49 744 gmsz » 1114
610_1<1*1¢1_°75___§0[,5_4%714 BM_KM/IILF /I/C/L'/
D%/w. #r §§qu 1415/1 _1'?/144?£`;/£.7

 

 

 

 

 

 

/ \ /135»1547 14514/

 

 

 

41\55; 11 1 4
_ l)75'1 /‘)m 35¢1555-1§ _

3 111/1»,€(`7_4\\. 744 jj?~§/

 

 

 

. , ` . ' “ 3 . "‘
` 3 § : "~. .~ . r£ 1
_., , ,

 

 

`.6 ` D£CvA/€¢)v/w/ ,_

 

:77 L)MLA §1»1 111_,_@3_3@_3~@1@ __
§Y_AM 71¢“_/6£0¢7…;7/,§§___§

75 145 '7f 5714_7 HM MMJ
::%:7:516/){/? 7/(.144$' 1411 /) @M

____@:§ __MWL LUL__§__
311// 01@ j-%
z/\M)k/L 7_1% HM#L/-z? UF” /é/L/u/,vu/J -`

 

 

 

 

 

 

/'\
»/, 71 WB)WM%%&@MI

:~ _ ` 1111/we L Sc.w)sw * //@0(¢9£ AFFM 191/117

 

Z.`ann|£ 4 SLQLBZI_}_DIM'?E_ .
m? :_Z fha '21~,1;1102¥>04/\ 2911/n WmM/LA
’7;~4111,1 510/m 1140 000 _U»a 714/111 0,7,%,0»/(

47 4121’111@/1471§7) 0/11714 &40?£ /\/11 1142 3 ‘1_1;1_/2~12_
Qbe240 @/K 3"7>1;~2*1@ 014 5155221/ §501001'717'
'715/&0£2/!°//;0/0 ,14100') ,/40€1\ ,,4'>’10 2 /30_140/02002//4
j HQ/c_£é@_%w/M_E¢ 601 10 /.1 00 c f;wv
,)`41»0 ZNQ)(»£»¢ Pc@_@¢/ 14 v,) 50 57)4,0.¢ 7,14117
zile §7,0701211211~7 25/@]!2¢000&£ /4~11/) 43040007 7: \
~//7’ }1’7 24¢'4777 M 229/l n
240 9 014 01c 444/2471 2111/s 1 '
[//1000 401/1014 0. 2400301:7

 

 

 

 

 

 

/) /‘\A)012400'z/6 0///1141 ‘

44 52 ` r `/§ !/ 22 " J `
, ~m¢é',. Z, .SLVM 1040 {é_
4 953 421 .' _ 442/w 47 4/1`./17'

38'2,1_ f'm» 135’?1 5010/15
4,12/»§.1‘7112/. 7~02;" 7,735`/