Court Opinion

ID: 4038168
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 21:50:28.227525+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:28:12.385359
License: Public Domain

-----
       ~ Ll a. f\ ~.\\\()RE N D
                                     -
                                                            IN\~ E         \JTS\Rrc3 Cnu\{\·
      \}.
                                                            3~ q\\\ 1u\J1-U.l\\_\\r.$\~
'-

                                                            BEXi\~ LDL\t{\YTEXI\S

            /D. THE Ho t\\oR~~lt -=s\1t\Gt B~ lR-rM-rN 1\L~?~EA~
      C..o"'E \\\D~ -\hE \SE tE ~ ·6-0.f\-\- \'n -\-he_ e1\:n\Je. S-\Y \ ~J b~d
      D \J rn bQ_:\~ t..G..u'Se_ ~ \\ ~- -\-\t·, ~ tDm \J\ \o. h G..~Q.\.n S-\- -\-\t \S
     C.'t.rk 'DO\\f\t\.. \<,J\'Y 1\Jf \{\nV\~Y B~. :'J.u..C" LDL~n.-t-YtJ.\s\\k\cl,G\~r\<
   l D \ ~ \\\1 ~\/k~u-rt-e. ~\ ~ S f\N 1\Nt() ~ i D ~~o..s. 7 8 'lD'S ·
          ~b\J to ~t. \\ e_.f-e.-h.d CAY\:~-- -\-D ShDLo ~Dod Cfr\1 Se toR
   -\-\n\g \f'f\o._\\-~r: 1 L'r~~e__nct.cH'\-\· WQS Yo~hd \n~ \ ~~nt Q 'r\ d
   \e.Yfe..Se.,n\~ 'oY CDv..\~- a.P?D\ f\\~ C.Du-f\S~ o'\\\-r\CA \ 0 t\d
  Q \-:JP~o. \ s. 1 ~ ih-e...'\J£A.SS' L\·~~\ ~ ~<L -t~h<ic.t\-\- 'LDrote.. mol"\ DN
 On~ l~\\~, ~D Yh·e.. 'Gi_'i<Ar LDLn~-\Y ~is"'r\C..t· c.\~rK \-:Jon0<2...
 -\\~ VY\c K\~h'fl~y L~h \ l.Jh G. r-e.. f e.C.or-d-e..ci \h the..\ {J__LL) l\ -n~ ~y                  a
  Lb<.1~ .\'() Q\ Xl\e_ C.onn&Un\-t \l ri SDn. re__(..ord. n.o~ \J~tenknf
     S\u.h~~ ~- M~~ S&.nCJt ~\n- t1.n Q \t.o_rn?::t x~ ~ B_rruk1
'V()S\-- Lo\1 lc:Xton ~~--~-t n~ 'lno.be..CLS LorPLks:rn Q F.Q\ol"'l V Co..se...
-=it~· C. D l'£ lR'J]V\. 1-'RoC...I\t-!N. n.r-.\:- \ \.n 'l C6l we s-1- S u l:lfllo 1').):,
 1::\~ i' end" n± be..\n'3- 0..<;\z\n s ~'R '\rc. 11 <:; e. f'; \).\- ('e._(~AJrd ();.\_\._
                         a,
  Lo.!'l\\1 u \ S~ry s. C.n v~- y e.\) I A"-.n t..e.. .I 1\1 S\:n_\'1' VoS.Se..Si bn l\rt"3-G. 111
   ~ I S CD\I·e.d (\ tH:J fl., f4-·\': ~'l 'S '!<~\a..h.d \-o ~- \ v·iT i f i c__ ~f. \c e_\ \D0.'?:.
 ,~ P,.\'J A.11 c.Y !<-e-\\o ",1:3, Q ~e), \~\: f\ c... \on w\\-\;- \-ke. ~x 1'\\ \111..rS\ \-V' D~ 1~'1. o. s.
  n ~o..\ ¥n. ~Q.. \~c..~ c:.~Vl\--~_.~r a~ SuN t\ \\\-t\\\ \ D·                                         .
                                              1 ~-\
   ,, '\\ D~..,
           \::l '<..M ~o."\: Q.<;K \-h~ \\ (') 1-1 D~J\~lt: ~ v.b~? t () '\- .
    (_ R\M\ n o_L 1'\? Pe.o.\ s \-\ s l'fl e_'( d ~ 'n~ 9 \n :\h1s fi\a-1:\e.r-
   '\ \\ es \-\..-;1 s                "\%~n Dr-~...,                   'fY\t->\1 \:>f'\ \D R,e_v                l"'-:l \ - \ /
                                              Re, CD~~ D" P\'\J?Q.A\ .s 'Re.q \.A e :*
                                                            ·
                               L..J
 ~ ~ s \ ~ f\ c..\\ Df\ n ~                                    r'                                                            0A

  f\ ?~~\\~\e. ~e-w,ci, Vv.r Sua.~\ m\<u \e.. ?:,L\. b (bj Dt -\-h~
  \~"'..a.s 'RLl\~s ot ~~?'e..\\cz\-~ VfDC...e_du(e.,Qnd 'R\:.~u'bs-\~ \ho.~·
-\-he._ U ~'~ D\- ~ ~\ s \-\D r\b~Qb\-e c_ t'\u "\ YY\~ \:e- A~cl \ fe_ PQ •~
a.~ \:Jo."'\ b; \'ne_~~Lord \n Q~\)-eo-.\~ D~ -\-~\~ tA\.\.Se. \\ue QY\cl
L.D rfe...c\- LD~ \ e..S. o-t fo.\ \ D ll_;\ f\S YY\ C\..\t-e...r-~ -, h \-h\ ~ C'_o.. uS-e-, Y\
~YJ'/ '\)'(e_tle.t.~S?or- C~u S{?_<;.~. \jQ_~Q_r\dQ\'\~ 'Re~u:::>rA \ s 'f\<?_~d~ \-~
 de.-L_\cle. \-~~ l SSlAeS ?re.~Q.n\{>_d in \'h~CA. \)?\.\c_~~\()r< tDQ Lt'l\\~·
a~ ho.be.a ~ t.ar- \\~ ~ ~ c;e..e \.).r\\ kd S~o.\e \1. \(Y\L\.C.t")Y\ on L\ ~J.Io lJ ...'; c1 \ ~j
 3J..5-cl\o Cl9.1\-j LJe._.~~1\~aY\i-; S        £..¥\\-\\-\-e__A \b h~\Je_ 'nlo\~VY\nt\m
        'vl~cxrci Q,_"'d. \u\~~ Dh 'b'J. \~e. \-r\C3_ \ u)ut-\ L_f<e-e__\ ~\X 5\..0.
  'd..& Ck~ L\ \o ; G(o..Y I~ b su.~. ')...d Q-\ '\"'lg ~'l.tJ~~-\- '('u..\'\'f\<::i \.s mod~
          -an \'h. e. m D \\on \ s. \;..:)\ \"'\"' \'h~ \-r\Q \ C'--Du AJs. d\ SC:..( (L~\~1"\
   S ~e ~ r~"/ 7 'l ~ S<-o. Qd CA\ \ ~ ) ~"\ \~ ·\oL\ D Stu .. ~d ~-\ sq 3- q L\
         :LtJ RI t_~r\ . s\-e.n SU'l 3~ St.u. 3d ~So (--fz.X. J\?P- f\'Y~u{\\\n
 ' dDooJ '?uh~~Y-r\-Q_y·<~\o.\ f~~u;'te.h'"\~v<\ o* '0\..u:_ Vtoc__~~~
      .      'ff\GJ\ ~CA \~ Qd' D ~'\\~)r\-u "'\ \- )' itb ~-e. ~ea \"cl~ L.\~Q...,\ \J ·
  ~\~1-r,·c__t 1\n\f, ~·bR m~\f\o.._tnu_~\-~ ~\~ S.LU'ld.L\S.Jl\b
 , (I .tt..~. \ 0 o, I J \h u·s o. ~ '\-~\r\ c:_-\- LtJurt '<Y'tc.\j 'h-e Lx::rn\\_,j\ \~Ai
  '\J \ CL 'f\\ Cl 'f\ ci._ Q XY\ U S ~D ~-t>\l S \ cl ~ G.Y\cl '(' u \e.. 0\\ Q ~iL1l C\_\ f\S
    \('l\Dt\ol\ Vf-t..S.Q..n\~~ \c \-'ne Wu\""'\ .. S€-e S\-a__\e... 1L'I... 'Q.\. e.JJ.\\\J
     S \·~\-e- LQ, R J\'i) 1 ;).lo s lo. 'J..c\ \ 'J. ~, \ r:l2? ( -f&....'t.. ex:, r-r.. t\?? \~ ~'1)
         ~~~-U'\~o Y\ \ - QS \<._ o.\\ c\ -, SLD\J-QJY e..\J icleY\u_[,j\:nn.nt;:c_r-\1,\--1·
   l~) 1\.N V Ah c\ 1\t.l ?(')\ \ t,e_ \<:e.~\?b,\-s. (jj t.0n rfa..v\:\ 5 ( 4J ~ hY S\c..pL~\1\ d~nc.e..
    Cc:.~ ~N ~ ~"\-aR~ns\cs ll,)C'(\h->,1{\~\ Ro_c..'K Gf'ou'r\dS D~ a.\\ e:..)\\ne.ss.e_~
   Ci "J TAm R1(. q LA es-\ \n~ U) \J \ e::~' o~ a.\.L IR.JC.. Lev c."'-\- ..,'1'\~I>Crno-\\ o'f\ \)f. ri--A'( n\~
     toM Y L.a.s.e.. S e.c:..\ \oY\ \. Qy-\-{ Ut- 'Sq.\L\ t~-~:)~€_o.Q t.r\m;Y'\o-.\ WbL.e-dt.\f~ 1
        t\"'-\-'"3£\.\L\ ~\s.\_o\1--e_'f'Y S~_:-'\.'f\\,~dbSUfe..'\SV 5-\-~te.[o..) ~rt~C1.\'5
      (J) (An \1 Q..,\J'\ ~ ('_V) t_e_ ('~\ -t..- \JQh-\_- \-o \-he_ ~e f'~f\ do.h·\<3. ~C:\ \-\- tYr ~u r\\ s'hh\M\-\;
       C'd.j o..r-.'I W\ -\1-e_n bf' f-t..C-ot ~~ ~\~\{LVY\~V\.\ . . (Ar-, Y \ D--LO e..h~or r...e-~i\\-·
                           0

                               \

         a~+\ Le. 'Jan"' a-Y-'h~:r \:J~\ SoY\ \'ho.. -\-\ s. f'e..\oJ-~ \-o \-'he. t.a.s~ ~o.:r S~cl j
         r. €. ~ () r-1-s ~ ~      lc... (;.,: :) Q__(\~l,\C..c;?..J'Y""Ie_,Y\ -\· Dr n rh~.t- ~() vef'n Vhe.-r---\--.
                                                              \~'l.
                                                                                                                         I
                                                                          \

.._    '.j   ·•

           L:J~-Q_,~";·D{<-e.. l\)f~rrt \s~s ~_n'\S\~~{-u\ ~e_\:Je_ \€-V\Ac~
      R€-S\\:l_c:_~~ ~\\ Y ?,~")( +~o.._\- ~~' ~ () r ~- \Q__\ \-\\€.. C'_\u- \<                            J

       \..2)R \ ~-\T\ D '\2.\j ~Q. ffi c~'t\D~\ *~tl~ l._.e_a..\1-e_ +D ~ \\-e_ \·~                         -.Q_

        q '(:< \ S -,\\ o.L r\\)? C1 c.o.. \ ~ D f'- ~D'R 'L0 f'\ ~ fl:s;. 'fY\0:1'\ 21 D. YY> Ll s
          b'~~{Qr\-\-~_                    DR\\.ER                 ·.-            '
      o.~c\ f -e_ s~ \\-- \ _s \- \)_ f \ \--x€S t'J' c\ e__'\ ~ -\~C).\-· Q. L.o '? Y f)+'
      -\-\,\ s DI~<U' S~o..\\b-e.. s~ ~n:o(\J II\\ T\-1 ED i E:,--\r:\ C_.-+ C:ou IT
       3 '1 q \h S u.\', \ c__\ De U:-, \ S \x-\ e__\ Q\ .•_x-\:.. ~D'!\ f\ ct ):(r..'l. N\( I( i \"\ n...Y'
        \n\ ~ ~-~- ~\ l .~~~-f)~~~~ oS-
      (_')_)CJ\~),_~ ~. ~~ ~~)'..\f'L"--\ ~~~t\~-t~-t
       ~ ~Ob ~~~~ ~o~~ b~ ~D ;1\£
        1 ~ ;)_ D ~ -3 a 1 \J .           . .. .               ,     ·
                                . C'_E R-rr t\C Q 1\Tc D~ ~S'R.V:fCE'
                                                                                             .                     '

          I) c~x-\-·~~y ~\~\ 0-. \rLA-e_ Qr\~- LD\f€_e--+' r')+ 4-he-~DR-e._So·l~
                  ~,~\ -tt~n c.Jfd.~,. '\no\\ o" ~o" Lwv~ -\o \\\~-the.. br\~;Y\Ot\
                  Q ??\ \ ~o__\ \on \=o\. Lor·\~ Glf· ff\o.f\de>.\v\U s ~ WCLS r¥\o\\~
                  1-t) Clh~ lli~ ~ ~\- ~. ~~~t-- Q_\)~J\­
                  ~.~l\)b, ~o'l\·'d_3o~ \\us~\Y\)\x1-g/}/
                         -=L\~ 1\J\f\)B )s· \\t t.\J\'RJ~ ~:toN ..
               f·J·-sucd\ k.mD~~o~\::).(4-s: ND.\ lo~~~3~~~~\h~ ?r.e.son\IV ·
                \f'tC~rLzf'Q...\~x._~ \'r\ me_ LofV{\-e_\\ u\\\~ 3Db \ ·s. ·s~,\Y ~\\v~
              . ~-e..e_ \1'1 \ \ e_; Y'f..- 'l~ \ 0 'JJ d,e_c..\o. (e... u \"'\ ~--e_r· _\\::_'f\a.\ \ '/. o-\. V't-\..\urV

              -\-- ~ ~\- \ ~ '<-- \; t) '\:-L~ D J\ Y\ ~ \ ~ \ \u. -e_ 8... ~\ ~ ~~Dr 'f~c___-\-

                   't, ."\.- \                 . ~1\JL ~ aJ~--t-
                      ~~ ~CD\\}WL~ \~ 'lo\5 .....____.:~~~LLL.-1-..ll::L!~~--
             L~.~                             \~3