Court Opinion

ID: 9425512
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2023-08-02 23:14:55.94875+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T17:22:56.028237
License: Public Domain

Mr. Justice Blackmun,
with whom The Chief Justice joins, concurring in the result.
I join Mr. Justice Stewart’s opinion and thus I, too, concur in the result. Against the possibility that the Court’s judgment may be interpreted too broadly, I *572stress the fact that the children with whom we are concerned here number about 1,800. This is a very substantial group that is being deprived of any meaningful schooling because the children cannot understand the language of the classroom. We may only guess as to why they have had no exposure to English in their preschool years. Earlier generations of American ethnic groups have overcome the language barrier by earnest parental endeavor or by the hard fact of being pushed out of the family or community nest and into the realities of broader experience.
I merely wish to make plain that when, in another case, we are concerned with a very few youngsters, or with just a single child who speaks only German or Polish or Spanish or any language other than English, I would not regard today's decision, or the separate concurrence, as conclusive upon the issue whether the statute and the guidelines require the funded school district to provide special instruction. For me, numbers are at the heart of this case and my concurrence is to be understood accordingly.