Court Opinion

ID: 4041694
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:53:02.655107+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:28:32.929993
License: Public Domain

.            i~ 19~!-01
                                       Lru~\        or     LfZIM\N~L APPEALs
                                                                                         RECE!VED IN
Lo-wELL Q\..H NL "-/ bR££f.l                                                           COURT,OFCRfMINALAPPEALS
                                                                                    . fEB 25 201S
                           Y•                       tliis ~6cUmen~ c;ontains some · . . ,, ·        ~V
t:;,-     t\"T £       0' -r£ vA 5                    a§@§ thai are of poor quali~ Abel Acosta Cl~lik .
                                                    al i\li litne 0~ itnal9IBB'l9J.
                                                    P_

:..:> \   t-\              r      I'   A,                                                     '        0
                                                                                                            .

'R   \I   upp\\c..Ctn-t:'    I    hcn/o_ ~us+~
~ :"-~"'~~.....d) o-~oi \u'vk. 1-o                   r '4\u"-s.\1 '"4 \-lnu -1- -t\n._ S'-1 +\-,
                                                                m"-
 &,m,rol                        DlSktc+ Louf+- C.)~)< C..Ornp\y '-Af;,\-'n Ar~·c.\q_ \\.OI
 t.c_.P~ b~ ~y-,rJwdlnq m~ c.~) Applicu-h'onS at ~etb5 Cn('-
. pu~. +o fulL Lour+ 6~ (/l·f'n;nu\ Af~Q.Q\s · \-n Aushn 1 ~...

          \-\oJ Y'""6u; r-
      ~ \n                      Com p\ 1Q(l C..L          \J1   +h       Art.. \\.01 c_.c. P.                 :
                 Fu.r+hu 1 ~L\~e +o "? n ~                     to rnp\ i C:~ c~ 0 . :rJ ~~+ o~ fV!o1l-
          dumu~ 'na6 bQ_QJ\                              ~\ \~ on ~ 'n-f\ icanttQ ... vJ -r;+-· of· MQnJ.a r:n (O c_Q...cud_, n~ 6            •. .              " .

                                               ..   .
                                                    '

                                                                                                                                                                                   •   '       I

                                                                                                    •   i

--·-.   :tr

                                               ·,   ,t '1   .
                                         .\.            ..•.                        .   ~~ .:

                                                                                                                                          •• ! .   ~     .,. . •    '     .'

                                                                                                                          ,.              ~.   ..          t
                         .                          .. (   ~'\   w   "'\.J.    -nc;n 'i>? '--\")l:>>-o ~ "!);:)\..)'()~~..A
  \.J~ uc;)~t:l')~\d1v          \_()'\\        '-\')~       '\\"'.;~""        ~\          fl>l'w:J    D    \\~ow l             :~Gif'l         J
                             ·' -ou ~ D(.J IJLlJ ~d CD                        0-t c;c;-<))~) Y) .:-\~ '.. r< vi 8 l c:JtJ ext
CII -\JCI~.L "'     c;-6:\J     oo '~ot •..A dwc:Jd 1J                        0l{l- \~\t ~ fV\ UJcUCt o\1 J f\J()
     c;--o '.d(r)   \ t; ) -d· d'0 ~~\                          ")\ DUJ        "S')Q\d N4                \ln07        ·c;d
                1.. 1   °/o \S 1-t        q I ·· (JGJ__

                                                                                                      •. \..kl   rJ\ o W .J Y)a Cl .
                                                                        · :3-0 t· 1_1 ("\ )~ S~U\J~lrJJ ~ \ Jd \j
                                               l

                                       <:~, (; d- .X.())   c; IJ(l(~ 9-\
                                                     f133'a 9 !"'- ")~J \ 110 -nj ro-1 ·otJod X·3 :-o'j

                                                                                          \ QL   ~ L ~ S TJX"O_L        1
                                                                                                                              \JjY.j~
                                                            -cr; no'-\-:1;-" \1 OJ               j "\u n r:sJ      \J ~AJ uop\}J
                                                                                                      ~ }0\J 't'J ~ >tc; '. CI_
                                                                                                                                         .::

                                                                                    ~-~ .L\AJ
                                                                                      1
                        9 I-\, ... \                                  11""" \ t
                                                                             '- ~-\ 5

Lo~\ Q~,r-L'{'            b(tULn
         v.
S-\:cA-:a_ of      ·\€LXU s

\\._ ·. Aff\iu.hon 's Fo..-                 'vJ ,..;r J Hub 1
   \oa S.t-t.., o+ lcio3, ~uo+in9 £~ pQr--\-a_ IZoLfo\\ 1 Ill u.s. ~LII 1
  dS\ 1 b 5.t-t.l31.J 1 71/o 1 aCf L. Ed. 'blDS ( I~Sbl. Atco~J·,n9ly 1 s+o+a.
   ~v \ ~f\VS . G\v'"'IL fQ_('f\.u I -ra.cl -\-u pr~LS~ -\-h~y- fa..dexc\ c\o"lm5 ,:--o
   ~-\-o-k_ +\""a bu no Is ~'bQ_fo<{Q_ p-roc...a_dtn9 +o WvC~l hCA..~ 1 -+o
   p(o-\- o"     1   '"'

. L.\).ft-\E.Lb
  ..  .       ..
                 LAt\1\\. d-lolol  -r-:-M dO 51..1. I '"\£1\f~IESSt.£.. r!...DLo/\IYI \x.
                               . . .
  ~ 5 ~)~q 1 ~NDER,SO"! L._nu_r-JTY. # l qo3~ Y 2.CO- iz. \I ) •
                       1!:...

SCL(_: .   . '""""•.

                                l~ '-•

                                .\....,·~,: ,.J'· .   •h ·~'·I- {'"·
                                                                .
                                                                 ' • i
                                                                     - . ~c_
                                                                     • ~-

 '·   ..
       -
                                                                                                                                                                                    _._.... .       ,., ___ _
                                                                                                                                                                                                ,....;,;.
                                                                                                                                                                                                      ·......

                ~~'=._c. S            ~ r\.'i . U n S \~1 11,(~~. f i \ ~d 1 (A 0 ci. ':> o.+                                                                                                        p
                    . ._,__,d_ y_?bJi~1~1?.s:}. ~·-~-~.ss.-. ~-·-rs-~~ _2_9_'9 ___ ... W9~, ·'QJ(QS
                  5_Q\                                                                       .      • ., (o,...                                    :
                                                                                                                                                                                                            .                              ~                               ·~---~   _.   .,..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  o,.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 .. .

                                                                                                                                                                                  JIT ..
\)0       \HolAT\ot\1
           c_~\;\-~\ ~c·--
                                                                                      oF AR.T\cl£ · \ \.ol oF \\-tE
                                                                                       ric;-·z_i                            ·r;~~ R~--~,                                                 - -.   ~··-«·
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                nxAs                c_ob£
                                                                                                                                                                                                                - -·- -·· -.. ......... .... ---·----.. -- -- - .....................____ - ·
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                o'F
          ~ ..... ~ .. ··~- ... -~..,... ..... _   .. ~, .............,.;;:   _ .......... /.._ ...... ~--~-,_ ... ,_,_   ,__ ,......,_....,...... ''"'", ...:: ..... ,Jr,q::..

 3. 0\ ·~a_ Re...Spt;nJQJI+ . '/1 o\G-k~ .At".~(\Q._ \\ .ol ::>Q_c-hon 3 {()
       0 ~ -\-\,"-: leXuS Loci.«..· o~ L ,.., en 1 nw \ · Pvoc 1 ~~ "'-' CA n svJ oJ s f·, \Qj 1 G r,c:.\ . c. LH ~~ ~ 1u;h,_
       (eL, \;~ ..\-\.,._ 6u~ 10.po n "'-l'nllh 4-hcA L\ nc:.\1 ncy vJv.':> mcdL
       ~ ~Q_ Lou(-\- ~ L-<\m\rn\ AfF\ S \rJ\-\-\-\\t\ -\-~Q_ ~-,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         (Y-\(L

                  e-r Q_'J c_-c· \ b~                                                                             b~ \u \1'-1 o "~                                                                                y..j ~\-\-\-,\n u                  (Q..C,   So nub \Q._                   -\-, fY!'L
               -~'-rom                                                4--h<- ~<"anSrn··~~>-·                                                                                                                . \,YP!i~'~ , ..         ~               .            ·
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           J'

'2:, •() 2. (?.._~~.~v+~ ~ < .fu"- -\ -rc." s ~,-\\c.\ J. \~ · ex pp\.1 c u \·, ~"'
          . \'o ( \t.) ..-~ .\- o.\' 'nc. \m. S Lo ,- flu S 1 U n 'i ~ n S W  f •\ IY'I I.\-                                                                                                   <"\

          [ ern p\,c:.S\ ~ CAcbti4 J. ~. ;-\-llo_ -. Cou d: yf c;' N'MoG\ I Apf«-QI~
         CA Uf~ ~~ ·+n_o_ upp_~\ ~-C!~-h~n·, Uf\~ ~nS\JQJ('-'<-?~ u .....cl --\-\.~ ,RXS
~ 1\~ 1 0. <'\~          U       G_r-h~ 1c_u-\-«-                           1
                                                                   (fi...CJ-t-1             n~   --1-   h '=-                d.u-h U.pll ..... \.-J h u:_ 'n
                                                                                                                                                 ..   ..   .

                                                  _· •••    __ .!<..                                                                             'kF+~~ I\~__\ Su:,b01tk_d. I
                                                                                                                                                 Bt{·'~U.            Q;,;4 ~n.
                                                                                                                                                               R.£~)R.

                   -~--~   -·      ~: ~ ..        /                                               . .!<,   .•. '       ' •

              .,    ,.          :· .....                .       ... ··
                                                                                                           . P,.       •      .-,
                                                                                                                                         l,: .

                                                                                                    ~;-
                                             .•   ••.       :   .~~--- .. ~-           '·    .. ·'!·
                                                                                 -~...       .     ..

                                                                                                                                                                                ~.   .. .....   '

                                                  Jf'-1'•- - -           • -   .,. •        . -    •.      ~ •     .         . " ... ~

...... ..., .....

                                                      '. '
----
                                                                                                                              :''
                                                                                                                                ~
                                .              ,.
_LNMATE..S
      .            '       .;       ~   .•·,

I          I
               \
                       t~J\ ou.·.~ G.~
                           I            •                         '        ~
                                                                                 I   a"' .   •.
                                                                                                  +\--.,_· c.PoYiwh--\-
                                                                                                             I I.
         bcu \'C) . ptCLSQ..n+\y \nc..n f'c....9--ru-\-Q..~ ; <1. -i'.a..XC\':J ~·(~
    Gnc1 ·
 N\JUi.\- of· t(< r('\,nCA\ J\)'::lt~·c...Q_ ~ T.(\s+\-Au\-\\)'(\c~\ D\·..l;s-
                       •                            '   !   ...       .

·, Q   ~o,h\ CA.(«. L.\ nJ~ ~ !L~U\.\-- '/ ~ ?"- Y 1 +'-"~ I
       1
       1_ I                                                                                               'f'
uCCo·cJ \ ·nC) -\.o rn~ bo_\--A \~I +'n\2- fc,c-\-':> s~~~ \ '(\
                                                                                                                 1

+\1a.~ o,b\'.>\}0.,...,- 0\f\'\; r_c~\,.;\)f\ O.·(Q.. -kv.o... 0.<\l GotAS                 ~­
LGl)NT~. \Yt~- ANbffZSON

            -:L-SviQO.·< LA r'\do..x · DC\~'n --\~u\ -\-~,Q.. ~c_-\- S Qrd
                                                            rv
C\ \\ Q_~G~·o n 5 \ (\ +\\o_ a \y.)\}Q_ A L \ (_/\ ,. \ () N ·)       K \/\} IZ \T         ro
Df        1\(\Ar.J
               .
                   DAM u 5       C\ ( Q... -~\fUQ.. .c.\ \k:\    Co c (Q_ c.-+ ~
     ,\
                                                 0          \l       ~- \              ·   I

                                                t\)o lJ>)sU\ ~-u~~~e.>z3 .. \:ir\AA-:0
                                              . K£LA\OK                          .    .
S\GNLD UNbiEA OA-rH BEFoRE N"£ 1 on+~'~ -\-ho_ __
~~ u~                   _    1   etD -=---

                                                     ~Q4-r~ Q':;\, ~ i '"             CA   nJ \;, r -\-\.. q_
                                                     ~+r~-~Q_ o.\2 1Q_xc\ ~

                                                   · PY'\ ~~~               D I. . \y·f~       .. ;:0--rY~~.
                                                     N\~        Corflr<\\S':J\on     OXf\.{Q..c) _ _ __
                                    \

                                                                                                                                                                      .
                            ~SE          No. dO~-IcA-GQ
                                                                                                                                                                               '•

                                             .................. ,. ··-·..... . . r·
                                                    dDIJ, -1~\J - C:Q
                                                   ""'""·-.. ·--...           . - ............ --·1
                                                   _§\o\a--lq\-
                                                         .                .
                                                                                      sa '      J

  L_o w£. LL Qu' ~'-'c_~ GRE"t.tJ
·--r bcJ-- ·1~ D · ---------r
                    s 1·6b 2 2
                 f