Court Opinion

ID: 1079525
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2013-10-09 20:33:15.316301+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:06:20.074957
License: Public Domain

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF TENNESSEE

                               AT KNOXVILLE                 FILED
                                                              April 29, 1998

                                                            Cecil Crowson, Jr.
                                                            Appellate C ourt Clerk

IN RE:       THE ESTATE OF   )                  WASHINGTON PROBATE
             HENRY M. SWANAY )
                             )                  NO. 03A01-9712-PB-00542
                             )
                             )                  REVERSED

Judith Fain, Johnson City, for the Appellant.

John S. Taylor, Johnson City, for the Appellee.

                                  OPINION

                                                INMAN, Senior Judge

      The last will and testament of Henry M. Swanay, who died September 28,

1995, was propounded for probate on February 23, 1996. He devised and

bequeathed his entire estate to his daughter, Carrie Swanay, whom he named

Executrix.

      The decedent owned a life estate in his residence. The remainder interest

in fee simple was owned by his daughter, Carrie.

      Six weeks before he died, Henry Swanay married Catherine Teresa

Swanay, the appellee herein, who filed a dissent to the will and a petition “to set

aside exempt property, year’s support, elective share and homestead.”

      In course, the Probate Court, inter alia, ordered that “the widow shall

have a $5,000.00 homestead exemption from the life estate of the deceased

which shall operate as a lien against the fee simple estate owned by Carrie Beth

Swanay.”
      Carrie, being much aggrieved, appeals and presents for our review the

propriety of the assessment of a lien against her fee simple interest to secure the

payment of the homestead. By necessary implication, she also questions the

propriety of the allotment of homestead.

      Our review is de novo on the record with no presumption of correctness

as to questions of law. Owens v. Truckstops of America, 915 S.W.2d 420, 424

(Tenn. 1996).

      It is provided by statute that “an individual . . . shall be entitled to a

homestead exemption upon real property which is owned by the individual

[emphasis added] and used by him, his spouse, or a dependent, as a principal

place of residence,” and that “upon the death of an individual who is head of a

family, any such exemption shall inure to the benefit of the surviving spouse . . .

for a long as the spouse . . . use such property as a principal place of residence.”

      If the right of homestead exists, the statutory scheme requires that

commissioners be appointed to lay off the homestead from the lands of the

decedent, but if the real estate is so situated that homestead cannot be set apart,

the realty must be sold and $5,000.00 of the proceeds will be invested in real

estate for the benefit of the applicant or paid directly to the surviving spouse.

T.C.A. § 30-2-201, et seq. Aside from the fact that homestead was not assigned

in accordance with the statutory requirements, the allotment can be made only

from property in which the decedent owned a transferable interest. Bell v.

Hackler, 365 S.W.2d 900 (Tenn. 1963). Mr. Swanay owned a life estate only,

and upon his death, his ownership and occupancy died with him. Thus there

                                          2
was no estate from which the homestead allotment could be made. This seems

obvious, and the point need not be belabored.

      The judgment awarding homestead and impressing a lien on the

appellant’s fee simple title to secure its payment is reversed. Costs are assessed

to Catherine Teresa Swanay.

                                       ________________________________
                                       William H. Inman, Senior Judge

CONCUR:

_______________________________
Houston M. Goddard, Presiding Judge

_______________________________
Charles D. Susano, Jr., Judge

                                        3