Court Opinion

ID: 6103636
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-01-14 16:11:10.735727+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:53:39.346589
License: Public Domain

PENNSYLVANIA RULES OF THE JUDICIAL ETHICS ADVISORY BOARD

Subchapter A. Preliminary Provisions
Rule 101. Title and Citation of Rules
Rule 102. Definitions
Rule 103. Authority for and Effect of Rules; Designation of Board
Rule 104. Pennsylvania Judicial Ethics Advisory Board
Rule 105. Confidentiality
Rule 106. Civil Immunity of the Board, Its Members, Employees and Agents Regarding
Advice by the Board

Subchapter B. Requests for Judicial Advisories; Actions by the Board; Rules of
Reliance
Rule 201. Standards and Timing for Requests
Rule 202. Assignment to Panel; Composition of Panel
Rule 203. Provisional Advice
Rule 204. Board Action and Publication of Opinions and Guidance
Rule 205. Informational Discussions
Rule 206. Rules of Reliance
Rule 207. Reconsideration
Rule 208. Records of Board Proceedings

Subchapter C. Miscellaneous Provisions
Rule 301. Conflict of Interest
Rule 302. Expenses and Staff
Pennsylvania Rules of the Judicial Ethics Advisory Board

Subchapter A. Preliminary Provisions

Rule 101. Title and Citation of Rules
These rules shall be known as the Pennsylvania Rules of the Judicial Ethics Advisory
Board and may be cited as “Pa.R.J.E.A.B”

Rule 102. Definitions
(a) General Rule. Subject to additional definitions contained in subsequent provisions of
these rules which are applicable to specific provisions of these rules, the following words
and phrases when used in these rules shall have, unless the context clearly indicates
otherwise, the meanings given to them in this rule:
 “Administrative Office.” The Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts.
 “Board.” The Pennsylvania Judicial Ethics Advisory Board.
“Codes.” The Code of Judicial Conduct and the Rules Governing Standards of Conduct
of Magisterial District Judges.
“Judicial Officer.” Any individual within the “Application” language of either of the Codes,
including judicial candidates.

(b) Number; Tense. In these rules the singular shall contain the plural, and the plural,
the singular; and words used in the past or present tense shall include the future.

Rule 103. Authority for and Effect of Rules; Designation of Board
(a) Authority for and Effect of Rules. Pursuant to its constitutional, statutory and
inherent authority as set forth in Section 10(c) of Article V of the Constitution of
Pennsylvania and in 42 Pa.C.S. Sections 1722 and 1723, the Supreme Court hereby
establishes a Judicial Ethics Advisory Board (“the Board”). The purpose of the Board is
to provide advice and guidance to judicial officers about ethical matters that may arise in
the ordinary course of judicial service, or in the elective or appointive process.

(b) Designation of Board. The Board is hereby designated as the approved body to
render advisory opinions regarding ethical concerns involving all judicial officers and
candidates for all judicial offices, superseding the prior designations of committees of the
Pennsylvania Conference of State Trial Judges (“PCSTJ”) and the Special Court Judges
Association of Pennsylvania (“SCJAP”). Advice provided under this subchapter shall not
be binding upon the Judicial Conduct Board, the Court of Judicial Conduct, or the
Supreme Court, but shall be entitled to such weight as provided in these rules.

Rule 104. Pennsylvania Judicial Ethics Advisory Board
(a) General Rule. The Supreme Court shall appoint a board to be known as the
“Pennsylvania Judicial Ethics Advisory Board” (“the Board”) which shall consist of nine
members: one judge of the Superior Court; one judge of the Commonwealth Court; three
judges of the courts of common pleas; one judge of the Philadelphia Municipal Court; two
magisterial district judges who must be members of the Pennsylvania bar; and one
member of the Pennsylvania bar who is not a judicial officer. A majority of the Board shall
constitute a quorum; action of the Board shall be by majority vote of members attending.
No member of the Board may be a member of the Judicial Conduct Board or the Court of
Judicial Discipline. The Supreme Court shall designate one member to serve as Chair
and another to serve as Vice-Chair.
(b) Submissions from Representative Judicial Organizations. The PCSTJ shall
submit to the Chief Justice the names of three candidates for each Board position to be
filled by a judge of a common pleas court or a judge of the Philadelphia Municipal Court.
The SCJAP shall submit to the Chief Justice the names of three candidates for each
Board position to be filled by a magisterial district judge. The Supreme Court shall select
appointees for those positions from the names submitted. In the absence of submissions,
the Supreme Court shall proceed to fill the Board positions.
(c) Terms and Vacancies. The first nine appointments to the Board shall be for staggered
terms as follows: three members appointed for nine years, three members for six years,
and three members for three years. Thereafter, a new appointment to the Board shall be
for a single nine-year term. A vacancy shall be filled from the same membership category,
or in the case of a representative judicial organization, using the same process, from
which the vacating member was appointed. Appointments to fill a vacancy shall be for
the balance of the term vacated.
(d) Powers and Duties. The Board shall have the authority to:
(1) Render advisory opinions regarding proper judicial conduct under the Codes. The
Board may not issue an advisory opinion interpreting a judicial officer’s obligations under
any provision of law that does not relate to judicial ethics.
(2) Appoint an Executive Director and such other staff and experts as may from time to
time be required to perform properly the functions prescribed by orders of the Supreme
Court and these rules.
(3) Adopt regulations pertaining to its processes, which regulations shall not be
inconsistent with these rules and shall be subject to approval by the Supreme Court.
(4) Develop a course of training in judicial ethics, which course shall be subject to approval
by the Judicial Education Board, and which must be completed by every Board member
prior to beginning service on the Board.
(5) Make recommendations to the Supreme Court regarding amendments to the Codes
and these rules.
(6) Make recommendations to the Continuing Judicial Education Board and the Minor
Judiciary Education Board regarding topics for judicial education.
(7) Undertake such other related duties as may be requested of the Board by the Supreme
Court.
(e) Duty to Report. The Board will provide a summary of its activities to the Supreme
Court on an annual basis.
Rule 105. Confidentiality
(a) General Rule. Except for publication of redacted opinions as prescribed in these
rules, or as otherwise required by law, the actions and records of the Board, including all
requests for ethics advisory opinions, Panel advice, Board opinions, circulated drafts,
records, documents, files, internal communications, deliberations and other proceedings
of the Board, any Panel thereof, and any members, agents and employees relating to the
business of the Board, shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed to or open to
inspection by the public.
(b) Limited Waiver. Notwithstanding the general rule, a judicial officer may waive
confidentiality as to the advice of the Panel and the unredacted opinion of the Board,
either by express written waiver or by invoking any rule of reliance in a disciplinary
proceeding relating to the conduct in question. Such limited waiver shall not affect the
confidentiality of all other matters protected under subsection (a) of this rule.

Rule 106. Civil Immunity of the Board, Its Members, Employees and Agents
Regarding Advice by the Board
The Board and its members, employees, and agents are immune from all civil liability for
conduct and communications occurring in the performance of Board-related duties.

Subchapter B. Requests for Judicial Advisories; Actions by the Board; Rules of
Reliance

Rule 201. Standards and Timing for Requests
Any judicial officer may request an ethics advisory opinion (“Request”). A Request must
be submitted to the Board in writing, which may include an email to an address designated
by the Board. A Request must contain a statement of the facts regarding the intended
conduct and a concise question of judicial ethics, with references to the relevant
section(s) of the Codes, case law and other authority the inquiring judicial officer has
already consulted. A Request must relate to the inquiring judicial officer’s own
prospective conduct or conduct of the inquiring judicial officer that has occurred in the
past and is ongoing. A Request may not relate to hypothetical situations or to facts that
are the subject of past or pending litigation, disciplinary investigation or disciplinary
proceedings.
A Request must be submitted at least 14 days prior to the event or action giving rise to
the question. The Board Chair or the Chair’s designee may, in his or her discretion, waive
the 14-day requirement if the Chair or the Chair’s designee determines that the
circumstances giving rise to the Request were not reasonably foreseeable and that the
inquiry can be addressed in the time available.

Rule 202. Assignment to Panel; Composition of Panel
Every Request shall be assigned an identifying number. The Chair or the Chair’s
designee will assign the Request to a three-member panel of the Board (“Panel”). At
least one member of the Panel shall be a judicial officer from the same level of the judicial
system as the inquiring judicial officer. If the inquiring judicial officer is a Justice of the
Supreme Court, at least one member of the Panel shall be a judge of the Superior Court
or Commonwealth Court.

Rule 203. Provisional Advice
The Panel shall issue its advisory opinion (“Advice”) in writing, which shall set forth the
facts upon which the Advice is based. The Panel’s Advice is provisional until acted upon
by the Board. The inquiring judicial officer shall be promptly notified of the Panel’s
decision.
If the Panel finds that the Request contains insufficient detail to enable the Panel to render
Advice, the Panel may request supplemental information from the inquiring judicial officer.
If supplemental information is not provided, or is insufficient, the Panel shall decline on
that basis to render Advice, and the inquiring judicial officer shall be so notified.
If the Panel determines that responding to the Request would not aid the judge, benefit
the judiciary as a whole, or serve the public interest, the Panel may decline to render
Advice, and the inquiring judicial officer shall be notified of the basis for the Panel’s
determination.

Rule 204. Board Action and Publication of Opinions and Guidance
(a) Review of Panel Advice. The Board shall review all Panel Advice as soon as
practicable. The Board may adopt the Panel’s Advice as the opinion of the Board
(“Opinion”), or may determine that the Advice should be modified or reversed by the
Board. The inquiring judicial officer shall be promptly notified of the Board’s decision.
(b) Publication of Board Opinions. Opinions of the Board shall be published on an area
of the Board’s web page available only to judicial officers, and shall be redacted to remove
information that might tend to identify the inquiring judicial officer or any other person.
The redacted Opinions shall be posted in searchable form, and shall be indexed by the
relevant provisions of the applicable Code. The Board may exempt an Opinion from
publication if the Board finds that the identity of the requester cannot be protected to the
Board’s satisfaction through redaction.
(c) General Ethics Guidance. The Board may, in its discretion, issue general ethics
advisory guidance (“General Guidance”) on relevant topics. Such General Guidance may
be published on a public area of the Board’s web page.

Rule 205. Informational Discussions
Board members and Board staff may engage in informal or informational discussions in
response to inquiries from judicial officers.

Rule 206. Rules of Reliance
(a) Where a judicial officer complies with Advice that is subsequently adopted as a Board
Opinion, such compliance shall be entitled to substantial weight in determining whether
discipline should be recommended or imposed.
(b) Where a judicial officer complies with Advice that is subsequently reversed or modified
by the Board, compliance prior to the time the judicial officer is notified of the Board’s
action shall be taken into account in determining whether discipline should be
recommended or imposed.
(c) Where a judicial officer complies with General Guidance, such compliance may be
taken into account in determining whether discipline should be recommended or imposed.
(d) Informal or informational discussions with Board members or Board staff shall not be
afforded consideration in determining whether discipline should be recommended or
imposed.

Rule 207. Reconsideration
The inquiring judicial officer may submit a written request for reconsideration within twenty
days of the date of the Board’s Opinion adopting, modifying or reversing the provisional
Advice. A request for reconsideration shall not alter the effect of the Board’s decision
unless the Opinion is withdrawn or modified by the Board.

Rule 208. Records of Board Proceedings
Subject to the requirement of confidentiality set forth in these rules, the Board shall retain
records of all Requests, Advice, and unredacted Opinions for an appropriate period of
time, no less than ten years, to be determined by the Board in regulations.

Subchapter C. Miscellaneous Provisions

Rule 301. Conflict of Interest
No Board member shall participate in any matter involving the Board member’s own
inquiry, or in any matter in which the Board member’s impartiality might reasonably be
questioned.

Rule 302. Expenses and Staff
(a) Board members shall not be compensated, but shall be entitled to reimbursement for
actual expenses incurred in the performance of Board duties.
(b) Administrative costs and personnel expenses deemed necessary for the Board’s
operation shall be fixed by the Court Administrator of Pennsylvania and paid out of funds
available therefor.