Court Opinion

ID: 4050689
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:21:36.032862+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:18.459168
License: Public Domain

'. " , vi gglqa\~’bziozxoqu§/M

"\T)'i C,c>\,\,f\ C»€ CX\`\\"\\(IQ.\ D~'PP€°~\S 3\)\'\9_ ?,gi 1¢-`»\$

Q.C). %ox \').30%

A\_>Q>v\\’\ , _\_`r~ . '_l%"l \\

Qe'~ Qe_m¢,v\é crsz j Cb`¢edcic\n '\'o '\’>Xc\\e`§> puspr Q.inc\iv\¢bs
E>` P¢.`M` \NQ- ‘E>'L°'"'\L\-O'l,-O%‘ vb\x ` -»0§ und, -'c>¢¢

OY\ Fe,\gr\,\c>.r\\ 'lS-\-\q', 10\5, -\-‘v\i% C'¢uv‘\ m\oa*£c\ \'Y\\| \'\c.\oe.c\.& px"oc¢¢é.€n%s ‘\'o ~\'\ne,
-\'via\ cowvi o P\>rs\_>cw\'\ “\c> ~‘<\r\`\%‘ \"v\e S~Xc>;>\e made c` \pvop¢>sec\ Q.vc\¢\r . \ o.w~ unawc~\'¢
§§ -\"ne ¥v'<¢\\ anova ek%v\ec\ &\’\§s. ,or, `\$ \r\e. cX\`C\ o`v\\\-\\niv\% e_\se >»reb‘ \ Ci"\e, -‘<\(\\`s e\Q`;e_cA\‘or\ ‘X'b X\r\e &Xoéo`c,¥€v\`*r\{ c\\no;\\;$\`s \'\€.cc,\ odd \oe conc,\\_zdmc’\ \ozc,o`use, -\v\e ©oxo\e..

¢L\C\)..\
`\-n(»ovmee\-e¢,~=» \\'\`\5`\\%0\'\\(\0`&-;¢\'\ was em essen\iq\ pc\(°\ ¢& n\\\ p\ec\. &c§¢eenwen+ ~?er

m\\ -\-\'we;e \`\Qe, %en'\enccs. `\'0 \w/\~\ Qc\'\cu\o:¥\`¢\r_\, bowe '2$, 10\§ `\`b '\'Y\e c\cv`kc, -\-\/\e, ~\’e.ce\'<§

S\(\§\>\A \oe %€,\/T’\ \Qo_`c,\/_ \'C> X\'\e, C`,.C,.L. QDQ_co.\>Se \ vamc no \¢v\o\~\eé\%& amd ~\\<~\e

-\vio\ 00on \‘\o`$ 'm>‘\ Se,'\/\X <\'\c '\'\S c>\~~n @C\n¢\%io`ns §§ \cw`s; \

S€\\c). "\~\f\i§ \'0 \\0\)\ \\’\ '\\(\€_ C‘~.\z,\’\‘\ `\°¥ § ~¥"<“\i§ <;\<>`\.`, \f\us +\r\z C,\>\>'<-\ c£ Cw\`o»\w\a\ l\vp@g\$ (ec'e,"\\rec\ q S\>pp\e,w\en~\c\\
+mv\sc\'\o‘< vovs.uo;\<\*x \'o `\\‘s ¢¢<-\? \'>\<¢~g@. \n$wm me ex ~\\m‘; mha

\>\@ose. no*‘\<»»; me ~¥Y\cc\ \lc>o receich ~‘c'\ne 90\\0\~\\»\<3 ev`\¢\cr>ech Q'\\w\%.

S`\ r\<`_z\’e_\\.\ l

QDIN . -QD\\ W\N”M;`W&.
@;‘§§&§L‘,.(EUM ‘Mé _
.|UN 29 2015 _ \é-odne\..\ \<-ev\`n \}\\§'\\\`omv\$ Sv.

`<.o.c..>` k `\b%§%?,'l

Ab@m©©§?@,©g@?§< '\?Y<)_m\/\ my \Q¢\@¢{\gm wm
\7,0*\\ c .w\. 3§7_1. l
b\`\»)'\\e~n<, `\\` '(q!oo\

' C,wé,e‘.*' \’L'L\»\“\Ql~A, \'),1\41¢\\,\'1>.. \15§~31,\~¢, \B\c\?,$ -A. \'2,1$¢£\~ A

E`/` \Do\.\"c€, 7 ' \¥\ ~\'\r\e, Co\_)\'\'
O\: .QY\`\Y\{r\o`\

Qc>c\ne,\,` \'\/;\\\`0:0/\5 A\PQ€C>~\S. b\\\S\"\n¢T\-

 

CWS&CX\OO “\O `\`Y\€, S“\'C>\X€,`S pfbpb$ed Pl\'\¢\§\'\%g o§' ¢‘o.c-\< anc\
Cc>v\c,\\>${ons 04 L&W c\\'\c\ C`B\'c\e~r AC.-\Q\r Q€r\'\omc\ \0\; \"Ge.

CC\>Y\ op- C_.\'\`\'Y~\\`\”\Q\ uppec\\&

 

T,. \n~\-voc\uc¥\`o-n

,l\C»\ev Q‘Q\Y\GM\C\ gram ~\'Y\e, C.C,.l\., -\»\¢\e, %‘ro:\-e, K\'\ `\-\'3
§vopoae¢& evé\cr §§\'\c\s app\\`c_o.~<\~¥`s Q\o;\w\ +\/\oéc \c\e, \NQ\)\¢°\ ‘<\o`\re
`\‘ns\s§eé\ o\r\ %\>m%’ wl °v<»i'o\\ Bu‘\ £\>r w\m<;~,e,\`§ misu¢\\»§ce_ en
*pc\vo\€, €.‘\`\%§\oi\\"\\(l Q{Qc\`\\<>\e,., l\S 0,¥ “‘<\n{s dc>:\`e..,. \/\e, is u_YlC\;No.c-e
`\$ +\(\e JmQ\ C@m ¢\C\Qp\=v @;\¢s
'+\r\`\s c>\o`be.<,lcic\n C\\_>e_ J\-Q -k\(\@ S~Xc\-\~€ \)Y%'\\(\% -\`\<\Q ¢\-‘\'\`cx\ floqu
O~\r\¢\ ~\'\(\e fleva 09- Cx'w\\‘\\'\c\\ (>\ppeo\s “¥O Qp_>\<\<\\><;.‘< a fa¥vo&g¥iv\'¥\\
cm<.\\qs`\s., “Y\r\e §m‘<€\s \3(0005€<\ -$in¢\mc§ \>\'o§ 'W\e C\w<‘< 0(-

C,'<"\w\ma\ P\\aveq\g ‘vc> ace \1\:\(\€\\0@( (N\o\>s$<)_~za dam ’XX§, 35\

 

S\I\:\?>c\ (o%¥\ C'\"es<. Q\'im. l\\op. 20\2) `\‘;~, Ve:\voc\g¥i\/C *vo Co$.€%
occurring wg§@c¢ \;2\0¥\>0`>(\4 \S, _lc>\'.)_. I>\\><\<\o§>g\c\ ov\c>\<>,< ‘v\ne,
(\`%\w>< Q\vc\>m&»~\ox\\>\¢}\ \oe
pexm\$%`\\o\€,\ +\(\Q :\SS\>€, `\5 `\‘<\Cx\zp\\`c;q\o\e because C`»Qp\`\ CQ\'\°< °m€&

'Jr`\r\e 3‘<<£\<§\0&6\ \>w\c\¢>x N\oussqicxc\eh 'X: ‘0¥\ %.\S\».%¢X \\ov\,CT€‘f~~

 

Cv"\w\. D\p@. 100\5 ‘cc> c>\o°ro\*f\ VQ`,\`_\?.Q oné@( cw\ Cx\veo`d\\,\

es*<&\@\\g\\e`;\ pm@¢@… became @m¢\e_ Q,\;<§;\Oa\;><\\

m\@in$ormw< <>N»o\<"‘r .\’\eec,\s ~¥o 33<`\\\ 'C\>v\\\e_~c deve,\oc>
+\ne ve;c>rc\ '+0 move Spec`&i<; ~Co`dc 9~§\~¢\`\0%3 ve%avd\in% ~‘<‘ne
`\~mp`\\‘ci+ +evm§ +\r\cd\ \O\{ SK%Y\\\(\% ¥’o\f m \i&e Sen>§€>nce\ YO~Y\
Qc-Y\Q\>vrex\’< for c\\\ QB(\on\e$ `\Y\ a §Q\eo\ bax%&:v\, \<\e \N\>\>\e\
be @on\€>, €.\§<5`\\0\'€,.

`D.`_. E%Servv\'(cx\. @cm°x 09 \3\&0` L%(e,en?\e(\‘\'
é\!\r. \N§\\i`\\X\\ w Q\\ <;>€ his Q\fimeg ch §\\`Q@_
zen°cev\€>e (c»r\ Qo\\ <:\>\r re\r\>< -Qc>v a\\ Q\<\a\'%e.s. `T‘ne, `\\ €e,.
5€0><@\\0€§ mm wv\c,\>w@(\'\ wang pmi o§ a p\ec\ \oc»r%(- ~W\\`§ ‘Q\ea &%reemem+ o.'r\d
\(\0§;>@5 we C\G,W. Q\\‘<, he \N'\\\ ¥\gvn\`§\n l\ `\?
<`Q_c\\>e§a¢:c\ order `\5 `\<\oc\eq\>a-\Q
`m \\/mg ‘rv\`\s me$&`ec;&i\/€ ussi§m\r\ee Q,\o¢\m , §§ ~‘€Y\c\* {‘v
made §§ §§ch c§e&e\rmmo©\€\ woods
pmc>\e wm icm essen¥\c\\ pad e’§ °c`\(\e \g>\e@ ng>\ree>w\€x\"v-
A\J<\no\>%\/\ +\(\<>, paro\e `\v\f¢c*r §v\¢c>r\c>@m\¥ec\ `\n\c>
+\r\e uc‘voq\ \;>\e& agreem©r\% `\"\o\ p\eq,c\ ;3\>`\\’<\\ \'c> ‘v\mez \i$e %ev\XQv\céS mm
Q®v\cov rex\*< *\\f\ \r\\c&<\`§ \o\e
@cm>\e e\`\c§\\o\e.. T\s ~c\op\`\coof\*< cx*€vacv\ec& &S cur\ E~¢S<\`\\oi)x Jvc>
\\\S hubech w ms ~ ms ~"vr a &‘v\\\\ ramon \\e. was \Q\UA`\‘Q% Q§\>i\\-\l.
TY\E',. S\'OXQ prc»©o$c& Qov\c\\>$\`®r\§ <>Q \A\u cmc\ 'Qo\c‘c -Cmg\§m_;)

are `\v\cx;§eqoo:\-e. '¢\$ @n¥ul\ec\ 'm W\c>\>ssc\zqc\e\n XI, `\c\ . , Qv\

 

Q&Bevv\iq\ md c€ a p\ec\ u%re@mew\ vosz \o'e ?Qo\(\d L>pon ~\\n¢
expvess +e>r~m§ 0% ‘r‘(\e, \Nvi&%ev\ p\eu cu§cee mem §Xse\$j ~W\e

*Qovmq\ reqmi ed ‘<\m: \Q\ecL V\ec)x`\m§, o~r ~‘v\r\e ww\°<)ce,v\ cr

 

+e§v~`\\\\ow"\\`o~\' Q\I\` c\®(\ce So\omiXXed \o\\ \0¢*<\(\ -\\ne_ wg;@w%i@(\
Qv\d `\\r\e &\JQ\`\CM\)\ `\v\'& V\&\Oéa$ \)mc<@dmo\. Tv\e,`\o\s*< prong `\s

 

~W\€_ "\&S\)e hewe. T\<\e *\>\e e_\§§\\@`\\ \“c\{ was 000 eage\r\¥io\\ e\ew\en*i di- ~`v\ne \Q\e&
Q>\\\ 3§\\@`\\0\»/ \-<> q\>p\icor\*X N\c_\uc\e. @Q.\ 1Q\»e\r\'\@r\-\ `\v\ #{Xs \1\\"\¥‘<€\& 59me - "\X \Nc\§ go
"`\\\'\Q\`\Ci‘<“ “vevw\ ~ %QCQ\>S€ Q$ -W\\s ease , up p\§‘cm\*< "\s en‘v'\‘c\ec\
Jvc> \rQ\ieQ\ T\ne record fm °r\ms \(\q\oeus Qw@c,=zo\mg neec\s
~kr> be expam§ed `W\ \K%Y\‘< 012 E>\ ©C\v\ , ~`\Q\`
m.. `F»>YJ<\'\QX` D@v@\c\:>me,f\*’€ 09 'X\r\'e/ "ch,c>~r&
\Nuemar_»<>cze mm\s_€s c;m_\s\oeaeo, A<*r be munc\o@c€c\ *‘(\c\\.\d< c\v\ €.\x \`c\ewc\`cuq V\em'\`r\c\>> om<§
expand +\r\e reco(& w de%exmw\e `\Q \m\`§ Qo¢cc>\c
¥ wis Q\QG\

»Q`O§eeme,v\°< .

Q,e$pec\*@o \\\,\ 3 o\om \' \'°rcc\,

Sc%m¢\ ¢<\(\\s 2§+\5 dam 09 5\,¥\@

’lO\S`

 

Q.>Am@,\ \z_e,\,m» \N;\\caw\§ S¢\
10.¢;.;>. “¢ \\,3§<;§;7
F~ce,\nc\n N\. Q<>\ocw\s¢m Umlv
\2¢'1\ <;.w\. BS'L?_

¥x\@;\w; . ‘w. '1<>\\00\`

- Qh\$§e 445 \'L?_LHQ'L-A‘,_\'L'L\\'v>\\.\-e\k \l€§'au~l\,‘ \1,3\<-‘<%§-/>» ', \'Lz§cpe\»i/>~

EY~ Qa<"ce. n \Y\ +\r\e Co\>v‘\'

_O$ C~r\`mmq\

Qcé\\ne\( \N{\\\`ow\§ A\Q\oea\$, bmi$‘v\`n, Tk.

UHS\NN‘(\ Bec;\oxo§c§c\"\/ N€Q\`c)»o\\l`\¥ Q@( \-\¢\\oeas C.crous

Cu\>se_**` \zzwlqz_l>,', \zzmqu-A; \v_§§~ez,\ ~A; \z?,\<\z,§~A~, \zz§@Q\-A

 

\, Q<><,\\'\e_q \1\!§\\&<»1\/\5, C\§wa\ \ 'a%€eec,\ w \Q\ead %u{\%\\
Qow a\\ cfr wm 0%‘€@0§€5 ‘\v\ woch So\w\\oex»s ¥ov
O~ \\`(»'e %e‘(\"ccmc€, \fox\ C,<>v\c\>we,v\*r ~@o\' u\\ @V\av%QS because,
l b\{ °fc>\\¢`\v\g ~\'\m& \c>\eq \Dm'%c\`\v\ , m\{ O&Xc>w\eq ‘Vo\d me ~‘:\r\e
egsen'¥{a\ @c\c‘¢<>( ¥o i‘v \NQ\>\c\ be :\:\(\cé \ \Nou\d \oe e`\`\%`§`\o\e
,QD< @¢L<’c>\e one é\&q¢'TY\@ p\ec\ `\ocm%cs.’\r\ \ e.\n>ve(€c\ `m*os
§N‘(\c>\e 30\05*<&\/\¢€ was m(c>\e e\`\%'\\@'\\§%\/\ q T\\\g is ¥\ne 0<\\\4
MS¢`Y\ and wm{de‘(a‘<`\o\(\ \0\4 ‘v‘ne 5¥03<€ 3<\\0@¥ \N'Q\\*c `\\\¥0 '\&

ibaco.\>se \ mm 5\\>0\./_ \s\s\%\(\ 0 \\§e Se)(\‘ve\noe w\&\/\ no mve\e,
\ Qm\b‘v QCA\(\ sw\ \(\\w\s *v\r\`\s Qx>\>\c\ mX \oe cxv\ me>r\‘x`\o\\ pad Q€
m\\ §)\ea a%~ceeme>r\*. Ccm\<\\q @Ly\, \ €QQ\ -&\r\`\g cm\\z€c,§v%cv\
is wv\co>v\s§;`\<>\r_\¢\\o\\\ §w\©mmlss`\\o\e, S\ Qc§i¥\r\ in
001 `Q\>c\'\c,io£\ §\\§Xe)m.

©\>vs\>c:\<\°< w presex\*<\\{ bei\\r\% KY\QMQQ,\<&X ed §v\ “Y\(\e
`\'~@au$ Depo<~‘§v\®ev\‘< §§ Q'< \m\v\&\ \\\>S'Xice \ o&-Q`w w\ J<\(\Q
05<1>\)@ `\& hug om_c\ 9mmch w ~’r\¢\e `\oes‘r Q¥ wm q\@\\\‘¥\q

bo?ce<§ and &\%Y\ed *r\/`\\S Q\c,\\\\‘k\(\e 'Z§'Y\’\ o‘€ \\\)v\e. 10\§