Court Opinion

ID: 4067490
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 23:21:10.716389+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:17:47.444051
License: Public Domain

111 THE_

'11:¥143 C,oua_T 01= UL;LW\;N_AL 11990_011_3
0 Do'l“éc.,$ Tf::x\('\'$

m P r" 49@102>'@*>
`E ~ '
1311:2)12_§:1;:|_1@2111),011|11Aw\_3`_§1& 3 1\1£1_. \UO(B ®3§131..111\\

§ 1 1\101,\)\02:)2:)`1$?>\~~1,111“<\
3 ' aclu ~DJ`Z:TQIL_T l"_O\.zv’L_T C>\-

°"S @EIVED 111
113101“2>1?_‘5 _Pe__.TJ:T_\:@11 FC)Q wm 2313 MAND0_1\@@SRT@ECRNMAPPEALS
1101\1011111&121 131_11\01€ 2311 314:13 60003

SEP 0%1@1`5
_£`_01v112 1\10123 Cm;c>rzc:\'€_ 1_ 1301\1;1:111\13:§0. 17_31011012, @§A.
MELLTDLLEQ 231_13@ 3ee1Lx113 12011~_31' 141113 20me 01 ~
3001J1v 1303 131311_:1_1 c;LQ£\L 1100@.0_ THE 1'\/\;11_1:3113<;11_ DQTH
m +@<7_1002:1_0_-¢1 1115 12.3121100_‘_3 1_012;:T oF 112113>€213 601219013 1
1>012_31131111 10 1131 2_2100_ 2;_1210/1 Pc>_m_ 110'1 To THE TF_'\(¢A-S
L_oL.\Q_T 01 C_,(Z_U\/\iuhl_. 1~\159€0115 1109 1015:\:1_,1_51100_) IM 511?1>2)2_:1__
_ 111130_0_2314' 1143 1-`01_101»_11.1.16.

9331010<2 1=111313 1~113 1__112;3' oF 11011’>00;_ 62121>113 .1;111 'THE 121:111,‘
_ 620sz 011 1361 10 zz)M THE 5114`113;1'3

13110011~21_ \3 00\1310
1133?01113 333 1/\/012_1:11 \/.111111/'1`111_1 §§ 5- 00 321 ‘11$'3 (113><

c,\z:.m/\ 1411=@ 2532>\ TEX, __C_'ADE_ C_Q_;Wv\ PILQ( 11 0`1 1511>)

‘\1,1?011 RQ_(_,Q,;PF 01~ ms 1§?1~`-1:1;20'1101\1 1~`00_ 12qu 01”- 1101(.5@_11_3

_ »C.c)lz 1113 THF_ 1431012_1\11=:1 129 PP_Q.5<311“1:131'C3 TH,E 51`14113. 15 111_1001_1131:3
_1$ DQ\LS 10 606_5\"’2.\1`1(3 "

  
 

 

1113 'rcz_mL 2_0110_1 13 1111131\1 151112_13 11:1'_3 323 1311*1§ 1311 101111111~1 m
DQTQQM11113 mm 120250101-:_ 0211\11120\/@211313 922__13 mr¥'rEQ.DM_
w TME 1_~£1_11011_:TL1 01~ THE 11131>1__1:0011`1‘5 2_0111~1:111 1;-`112\3111_`1' 111<1(_5
12@ 112>31> `3&51211

~`T'HE 13101011` 01_33<€ 1013 111111 THE 111er 221021 1~`0111_131’3 10
DQ5IG111\1-11E `11-1E321155\31€5 _`1_1_\1 151 `1:1:1/\/\1?_1_\1 MA:¢M‘Q_O_ Ll£JT ‘
1101\21:21@ 1301113 __ 511=11135 1312_23 1>03131> 0121_:\30 Damk@w111£11(3
_§_\Ll`€.§ (:‘f;\' Qq 3§()1"`1 :ISSU;Q$ HCLV& \‘1\; l-S&X,M

103301_01313,_ `\'1~11: CLQ 1_01_100 65331'133 TH1\T 1113 `112;1111 121012:1*
1300_3 1131 11111'13 `1141€ 1111`\1100_:`1»1 123 3311~131\11> THE 1170/113 _
1_:.11/13~1-111_1;0113 03 11./_1'3 1100 15 133_~030\ 130,013 0_1_111:110
1322)1/3:£)1~1'_` Cm 0161\/('11\\'1`£1€1& `1`(`) `1`1~11; QJ£TP_TC:T 11`1`_`1'612_.1\11:`}~1 a5
11101_1_ 111_`\_ 112__1131__ Coum‘ 11111_\ 1§1°9€/1120‘1£ Cow\\§>Q/L mm ‘1111;

_`353111£5 1395_11\1~1€1`11':1) 539 1\/1140_`1311 \/ 112111\;111\1 313 3111\5$
1"1\23 1T_'1:TL C,P_I/\/\. 11913'31(3213\

PHCS\§ 1

"1»\1¢: 3141-rum 0@@ Mz,-T- 331 PMT'H 011-w 10 we 1121:¢\*¢_7
comm .Tz> E)L'TEM{> T.r/\/\E \_-\:.v\/\:TATMMS .1:1/\/\§>@;€<\ B“( 1143
.S'TH'mTF_, GTME¢>_ “TH\W Tn'v\.z)_\.~\ infer off wl claim '
Um\ui%tm@ 1331>33“ - v

`THE hamm 613:@_3 TH'HT 11 15 1011 \>\uc\ 'Q’\ .QO\S, M_O
{A'F\:XDC&\).IT§ LE`Y Q_x.szL HGQ,D.`C;<:»':\) i\loD, QP@Q_QL. Px`\”¥. DP)I~/C\ p.l?%€,
@Q_ § uPPLE,mEm` ‘Qf;\i>o r\l$~<<: '\?:`( 013'“2;1:£]` IX`\"TC\L ME“i, i\lo
i`\/TDQCVIHQ~`* H €-L\»O~I/\\C€L~\ ms 1331 625 Ha\/E. (E><»_e_,c'\L iego\\/E.L\_,
sz:m@g. ‘THE~;. 01\1¢21:::\' c_\.£w_~ m _r<:`z\_v>a.@¢l `re~\¢;
n?/:IL\L§; 1915 gm YR&BC,\QTMQ 'THE mm v\/\Q._;T" mw@A
\ Q/ Q~`\S Pr\€..u& P L_m:;rte)u §QQ 0<>,`\_1>1:11\ \! 013ch
CA-QJUL L;\'\r\LL.l Cc)um"i `\CPFW 3 . L .` ` "* , ' ~
N>@!lc,mo\_ 5 11 31 \C£)\_\ LTL:¢ c,M\/\
'THE C__L€,ul,. Ha; A \Mu\.\\;meal, '\QCN m m \>_Q,Locma>_

`Hc\ BP.U& £;¢c>_`.Pw_\, THE,. 'E_Q,L(;.*r@p___ 355 Q.Az:¥§ TNM` \~'\13_ DJMU\
`\D 'SQQ_.\L Q>Q \I$.,'F § RQ.ULC\_ C)&STD$J c/TFI.\ ., T HE S'THTES
D.\Q wsm T¢>@11€:(5\ PQ.Q;KQ%` SHE 0 FFE
z\/§cb@,,\,\c.@ 111 Fw, ZX.;TQ,:_/\t 511 w-FF§.\§&~, wm a Ltc.;\:‘n~:;>
, P~U__z:;u¢m`r 10 mm m 084¢;>;118 10 313¢€§:¥ 'T HE 2>@1@110 e__
MHQ§. H.§ <11<2_1'_`.'¥ Tc (?>Q `\~€~9110_¢;\. L°>QR€>_E, `T HE‘C.Q\)(U` 0 F
c.\i?,wv\\u,\%l_. NPQ.@L,S 0¥' `H~:Wc§., |ZQL@T@Q_ YYBSE>,US <"YH\°&T
'THEILE 25 M?\ CUQ_®LAC¢TE KQr\/\Q;\,'~\ c)»s? |_Clw TO C.Qv\/\PQL`
T\-\I§ V\/\\NL~XTE.?;CLL DU.TL( O`THQD, THA\\X `I'\'\IS L,l-m;l:`l“ ,C)F
'v\/\\AM 00\\;\/\~\1_.& ,, B\e;\e._.'a betwle V D:;§`rr_\;c;'¥‘ C_LQ£JL‘ , Da\ (a~;
@11.11»_ 131 331..31_1@3¢_11¢ Q¥Q "rO CLLL_aw "TH 151 `I'(ZI`N. '3`;1¢0@\£ TC)
QQmP L€>:r'e.. am z;\r;c©eu‘r_rmb\ .1:)\\\1 Q§TI£\QT;L@ r\\~ ama am cea

-Frm©:u`\\é\ csx`~' FOLC'F amd CQ)MC,LME\'EC¢MC,\Q/ _
11»~\T:L\,"F'HE"\“1ZA:WL won \~'La,§ E»e§o\`vi@_ THE ~\~`Q;I I¢SSQQ§`
ma 1533 §Hrm 3 Q,QF
TH!§ GILOEFD. H'LH) 913le <§<`4\;§0\5\ \‘\ B\JEPLer\/\~w“m\,
Tizo\\csc,\z;@T aamo:\:m:m@\ <1\,1, AF~FJ:DHV:\:: omb
1:}\\15¢€@0\&1021;3 <>Qf'r\~ve mezc,z.:@TEM @F'THE
cloud \?_Q,P@qz:r@,@§ mT'r~;§ F'wm,\@\_u\\ HQQQ.:NC» 00,
0@. PA§::U:)¢¢, mma 1111114 `mi \:"`YUAL goods
éu,€@ L,Q,v\/\Q,¢MQL. F”J:N©m\m ev Fc@' cwa c,@wcl_u$£@c\t_§
m m…. smsu. @Q, %QMQAQ_A T<) T\»n-§ CQUQ;
1111qu \ZO 01an @F T\»\z: 0¢1\1: 01 TN:: @Q,.,Q\EQ_,,
N\N ingEMBJ:@\\\§ ma T:w\E 13410.1 (SE oQ>”rr-\;l\\e.r>
F`QQN\ `T\\L`L§ CL)L)Q:F ,

310 YZJQ,SP@LI QP `T\~lE §_l€t\ST 01:3 Q,ICJ» (_1)\)\>3` _
Z\( PM,TE C:ti)m\i mka v…Ifll,.§b°\\¢\c\§ tia -ij\~la& wal“r€.© \0 .
W'MTH$ Tz) C_S'\o, ZYQC_,T »P()L'T\\\E C_QUQ.T_S "\~o Cl,)(-FQLT

THO_ILQ, §§LJD'@_EMQ,\»T 1 \Gn\l\¥ W\OLQ, 'T;);/\/v§ 15 lB~Q..L¢\.(G\
0 BST \7,11£§(' EO,

`W\E (.A)L)QJ' C>F CJZ¢N\IM,A|__,"QP@QQLS[ u,`u;l_L CAQ.QMT
Y\/\oM0ow\/\ug (71€\`\;§1-¥ \/LsHBt\l Pr Q,Q,LQTQQ, §HOL»_SC\`U
"\"_t~\PsT `TME CA£,T » §du&\~\l` C__GPE\_LEO _`L§H~’v\/\J:MIST (Lp.al_,
mm '(_Q\ TH~P;T `TH€U£; 53 MC) HCIQQMQTE Q.QW\Q@N
\Q§T LL,LLQ `T'\»\E Q\O\\“ C)I§T(L_EC/T C_L)L)!z_T HAS, NoT
r_mv\ PL.:;:-.Q 1_111:1'14 ~…E c_¢)we:r emma .:r\/)\OC)SEOF

- _ P iam a Q, F@@_, 113 1_1:5_1: ,
l/`,_BH€JL€ FZ)V/€, (D(Z£.W\;\'SE \\Lv\\),n\\(>- ' CSQQM C.QLLS:L®\Q,Q___.Q¢[§ THE
/?,©,\_Q°m@, \‘lum'f?>&:f \OQQ.~L% 'TO\'¥\T `T\\\_J‘:S Hot\lc) M%LE goosz
51me .{\/\&mdt>sm\)§ (ZQL_\:;&:F Ym() <;Qr\/\@&l_.,\ THE v
_01\_!13 mm 'MT`V\ 013'@11;!“ ci;l~EM, m v?') 211 m_d
TNE the/LQTGQ;§ ~RP@ er`r:\:@\\l \>@L wa,:\:T @F HNB@_U_;
gamsz 11_.11:“(\4 W\Q,w\@w,r§r\\®dm club 231 H:C\lTS ;\:\\\

31@>@@@-1 ve ~~r\\m;§ cwer c…© CA@Q¢JF mm ewell
Y_QL:,;F 119 w\~\;¢H §§ 13 zu‘n`m§© 9

@QQ\E; 3