Court Opinion

ID: 4056721
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:06:47.22391+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:06.039501
License: Public Domain

- /
, .
." \ -
§ ' ‘ l ‘ y

 

 

 

 

 

. ». ~SZ¢SW" @3 ,
_2?2;_12222122221 72/2~22// §§§§§§§ §§ . 3
§ § ’£_LAA/D§ ,{ l §K_ 83§§2 M§_A / § , ' § C©uRToF chmNALAPPE/ALS
7121£_1)22 /‘292 //O /.:%7721~2 SEP 292:115§ '
H,f§§ § § § §§ 05 §§d§_ §§ § 22@;2@@9§9,@§@32
H_.Q__ l ,

 

 

'» ` 2 1721/_’@¢22'75/)2¢ //?’>'M )9/<142?/`/*7?“ /);/‘Z A/HF,F/§ /‘23/),417“/ ¥/F,YH§`
` IFIL_Ci£A/f' ,OL`§H/f% 1%7" fig 71//;9 121/1 {791 §791/'¢" '

l " /))F/ 9/` 2/2/ AA/GL) 119 025 7%1 WF/L)?SP //0 7 1412/26 CDKPUJ
1/22122012/)2/%5219 Mz: 232176€/2/1 /JF/,oz%a€ 2221- ~
1£11£2[1@1_@€211£2ngAKM1121[11:11!11M£L?

, 12111_1 222 222/111129 1212222212121/./_

.
721221_§211222:1222 1212/12211212222121
@MM;LM/ (`~/L/)f/ A-dA/JS’F 211 /'a)Ff/?F PDF¢£/? /§7/2?/7
4 1:112221';/222 211/1111 2212221@1111222_1
" ' /9,5 611 197//// A/t///)%~F //Foff/A/ML[_Q&LQ£MCM£E,_
. g'my_% z &¢AQ§)QEM Z'[Q §122%_51£&2£2_.[2&§1£.5;£¢£4£__
_ /O/&¢T////Ae_ Fo/P 059/741 §(`0/ r/A///p% _/Yr//€ 9/0){1)/4&??€ 1421 _\ '
` 2112)12/212211122/ 112/1121 21 22 2211/3 22/4'@2‘2

Zf%»e 7 d/¢'ed.;

  

ll

  

"`i%zwz;/A/_A/pl,f/pt 102€_/05£2~2‘202/11_£/111_{1211
, ' _$25-'21:22/112 121 1111>:12%2¢22122121211@_22_1
.1£1-21$_1£/¢ 1911 2121 121£1;2/_!%12?211122/1{;9

 

.....

M///'? z§p /1§` /0,// iv 7511 /?¢»%//z`b//¢:;€ Cjaw»), ‘. 5

/'~`

 

l
l

 

- 222/2266226[21_2.31£32/_22226 1062/92
%E/ _0,6¢@;62:26666_7_ §M&(M_Q!id//_ 6 4 .' 4 "
__322.236}_?/_5'2'23 626_92226622/272)2/_<24,;_<.626 666 662/6 /2/’2/ -
' ,62262622)_/62062/2 6122_2¢:222 622@2/66666622 2 12 226
,2/ 62?_6262262 0226[__67 22622/2202262@22225>2_
`- /?6/0»€ 60(60[._/1€§> 60 66#1014 LUI)EX[ 6/¢£6£_ maj/110 3622$¢£.26 6m/+'

v 1 j 02 /z//'v_? 06 225 7 60022 66662222_6156<;_3222226656 0226[£2/_
` 222/ 222 22622/€2322/ 62 112/re /)/2626‘5`22? 62 62/266/€¢/26 2

'_ j26022;;6'&26 612/67 6226)26 222/ 6252[._ 6256§ 02 -
_`_6122/26/_ 6226222/226 22626626/2_ 22922262226262_____62__
,216660:63_6_ 6022§:26'_6626'_6£60, 66602<'/5_’2626 60 666 062 /{/0_6`

§ 622§'222§22/ 227 67/2 2/»' 2/2622226_ 26_22022 222 616/21222-~_
. 622/020(/069 60 6%2 6222620/'/7 569 662'26 6221/_/626_§’600&2/

_weu 2 /%»03,€2/, 026/226 221/222 222 /”/2¢////2 62 252 641
6202621_26222602/67 6220222621262226_/2_626 66

-. 666§2§0%06¢2¢ §/221/}42262[_ 012/w 2662/229 ye/%e$g,@w

1 il 226 2 922;’,<`/6 222/2226226226_622 622 2262 662 66 2

' v MZQ£)Z:E_M@,_ 76626 6202§262566662_<12262227’2266¢2__

_EQ/f_ 6[6_?262626225722122-_ 222/22662%&%6° 622266/_2262;22
\ _Mj//e 227 2720`22 2/( 622 222 2226 02/222222'// /

7 _/22_2/2662/22__ 626/j 62_926_ 66026222§'6//;2///212_¢ . ~
026222//2/22{20e6262,222226e222222022e2 222

 

 

626622/”260226220266062661666222/22622__6
 ._ M_EBMQSMM_ZAMMI 62662_ 6066_6222` 226 \
022%2_6€6/226$?6262222$6602222 ’ i° - " `
§6762/2665`_228,6/22£@1256£626¢02/ 22/ 677 /PY‘/

 
 

 

2 ._Q4’454_ 52/744£_£54’44[4_&5 5522’4@42%51/12544544254/__4
_ZV¢_._// H_A/_/{/¢f `£/ch[.£g;}z_? foia M.§£,¢/Z" 521 ”/47444&22:
¢_ _545454/244_ 7244§414:;_5/€ 522/`5¢7451:44 5461.'§2§1/)/4 4
_`4)444/42“12’51` <’1>5/ 553 514/5 14 57 5//44/ /41,)74/
l . 41%52:5 5445 _5//222:_§4'2”554_@”/%54_445245/544 §44:£4_
" » , 51444{242‘41/4§.£§4§{54464 544£454/_§242/5415_&'/4412€2‘_
. _{2/12£_@//2=354.._%252. 1522 M_Z%ZEM/HDJJLMLEL
' _52545/4/544244454145/14£44 424/2557 /‘/SL./ 541 7 545/1 t
1 4454244_ 441‘111;_45_ 4244 4 1445 124 544 545 1151y 1044
` _ Q_ 5542 fazio/44 555 %22: 5411£3&1§’42@5/_ 5141&412[4251£111515/52?5/4
505 5 /5»;;4/;_1/02/5454/ 545/54 515 414/95 755 5
2545‘5451]242455 444/515 507 /?4444 45 2/4/=454/ 424 `

._4544.4'451% 514311'11141/2€ 504/ //41'1'11'44/,

 

 

 

 

, 1554/{3¢51/55/ ' l
_ . __/24224@2441445%4‘1:_4247;2%45/2;4454455&524224
`_ -` 5_5444_,~_94251_2?:522425£4»/4544/_ …£54452€5£24?4
y ' 45444244_4542»_722_ 555¢€4542§4£44244444£554£4244415!_4
" 554541*54/444_ )%2 2514>’1245’445(5/5/_9_ 445%45424112£_2%445/52‘4_
. _CMMJ54425554444545444242024£@445221545_
~ ;9115_/522244_/5645544£245/57455{24444514414/444544544
2 514251/_‘9_44 542041/)155£142'54£ 224 511/522 55 £mA/c’. 7§_12£2§?3`442
4%552_4_/5_544[41424/144/2 5524/ {/m[inQ/5L[4£L£ZQL22£ALL£QL`
915’ é’faMz.'s 455’1{4'154€5/ 2£/152" 652 fém/ _§’e:/_' 25 /$44_4 5155 7 F/w¢
._ _1242141112 72424/¢4»€2 5244§’44;5/2114444441415:42114?§'_1)454_4
' ~ _ 4-55:?44445 514/42 1 . 1 ,..,. ,

 

 

 

 

 

 

_9999999;9 9:999199_ 99999999£491/99_94994
_ 9/991192:‘4199_.1?97 994 99999<_9_9_ 999/9999_;9/94
991/999 999 Mzé@_/_/ 4199¢99;‘99;99999€9494
',` ` /9/€9199:/4£99’9£99:/ 9499<:££9_91£91999£99299.9_
‘ ' " 0999€7/9£9(/}4999£;99 9992.%9:{/9_£99@£544
/1/9[9991£99//7% __5‘99974199/¢/.' MQC; 4999£9£;59§1§!’

99 199999999{ 9/:999999999?_19 99919999€

199_ 99999999:9_§4999799_;£999999/99999919£€9/

' 9/£/99/99;9999’9919999 9 9'9991. '

7 x9rj!z199 999/999099;9:9/4?99!4¢9_§9)_99£€499/4/@_4
9;/%/¢/5'9 915 999[9,€7 999/19/ 19 MMMZZ//z_ 999199994

_9/: 999/999 399 1999 9)_ 999,¢9:91€999!991€9599 99'9199:

._F999499919/999_7299;/9_F91991999;9949999/0V49C£4

[2)]1:_5’9/§¢£9} MJJ%AMMQBJH &M_MQ);L@_

b £?E_z‘z/ 196/919 9)999/9991:.9¢:492/'5:9€9£_997 5499¢99.€1:[_4

/a€/E@MML£'J&€_.. i/ ., _

19999'999 9999;' 992 /925:9,£..295:2949@9;9£9:@944

' 40_049,