Court Opinion

ID: 4279020
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2018-05-29 15:50:59.83802+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:34:33.872720
License: Public Domain

1

 1                     REPORTER'S RECORD
                     VOLUME 1 OF 3 VOLUMES
 2    TRIAL COURT CAUSE NOS. 1321493, 1321487, & 1321486
           COA NOS. 02-18-00061-CR, 02-18-00062-CR,
 3                       02-18-00063-CR            FILED IN
                                                2nd COURT OF APPEALS
 4                                               FORT WORTH, TEXAS
                                                5/24/2018 6:40:43 AM
 5   THE STATE OF TEXAS          ) IN THE DISTRICT DEBRA
                                                      COURTSPISAK
                                 )                      Clerk
 6   vs.                         ) TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS
                                 )
 7   MICHAEL HONGPATHOUM         ) 371ST JUDICIAL DISTRICT

 8

 9

10         _____________________________________________

11                         MASTER INDEX
           _____________________________________________
12

13

14

15

16          On the 1st day of February, 2018, the following

17   proceedings came on to be held in the above-titled

18   and numbered cause before the Honorable

19   Mollee Westfall, Judge Presiding, held in Fort

20   Worth, Tarrant County, Texas.

21          Proceedings reported by computerized stenotype

22   machine.

23

24

25

                               Norma Rico
                    Certified Shorthand Reporter
                                                 2

 1                  A P P E A R A N C E S

 2

 3   MS. ALLYSON KUCERA
     SBOT NO. 24081858
 4   MS. HANNAH BELL
     SBOT NO. 24068993
 5   TARRANT COUNTY CRIMINAL DISTRICT ATTORNEY
     401 W. Belknap
 6   Fort Worth, Texas 76196
     Telephone: (817) 814-1400
 7   COUNSEL FOR THE STATE

 8

 9
     MR. BLAKE BURNS
10   SBOT NO. 24066989
     ATTORNEY AT LAW
11   115 N. Henderson St.
     Telephone: (817) 870-1544
12   COUNSEL FOR THE DEFENSE

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

                             Norma Rico
                  Certified Shorthand Reporter
                                                                  3

 1                MASTER CHRONOLOGICAL INDEX

 2                  VOLUME 1 OF 3 VOLUMES
                        (MASTER INDEX)
 3

 4                  VOLUME 2 OF 3 VOLUMES
                   (MOTION TO ADJUDICATE)
 5

 6   FEBRUARY 1, 2018                              PAGE    VOL.

 7   Caption.................................         1      2

 8   Appearances.............................         2      2

 9   Proceedings.............................         5      2

10   Motion to Adjudicate....................         5      2

11   Pleas of True...........................         9      2

12   Motion to Suppress......................         5      2

13   State's Witnesses         Direct      Cross     VD    Vol.
     Jason Macha                   12         42     38      2
14   Bradley Cantu                 49         --     --      2
     Steven Graves                 64         75     --      2
15   Robert SanFilippo             76         87     --      2
     Mark Rath                     90         --     --      2
16   Brian Lukens                  98        106     --      2

17   State Rests..............................       107     2

18   Motion to Suppress Denied...............        108     2

19   Both sides Close........................        108     2

20   Closing Argument by Ms. Kucera..........        109     2

21   Court's Ruling..........................        109     2

22   Punishment Phase........................        110     2

23   State Resubmits Adjudication Evidence...        110     2

24   State Rests.............................        110     2

25   Defense's Witness                  Direct     Cross   Vol.
     Susan Thorbrue                        111        --     2

                             Norma Rico
                  Certified Shorthand Reporter
                                                                   4

 1   Defense Rests...........................         114     2

 2   Both sides Close........................         114     2

 3   Closing Argument By Mr. Burns...........         114     2

 4   Closing Argument by Ms. Kucera..........         115     2

 5   Court's Ruling..........................         116     2

 6   Proceedings Concluded...................         118     2

 7   Court Reporter's Certificate............         119     2

 8   ----------------------------------------------------

 9                ALPHABETICAL WITNESS INDEX

10
     State's Witnesses            Direct    Cross    VD     Vol.
11   Bradley Cantu                    49       --    --       2
     Steven Graves                    64       75    --       2
12   Brian Lukens                     98      106    --       2
     Jason Macha                      12       42    38       2
13   Mark Rath                        90       --    --       2
     Robert San Filippo               76       87    --       2
14

15   Defense Witness               Direct   Cross    VD     Vol.
     Susan Thorbrue                   111      --    --       2
16
     ----------------------------------------------------
17                      EXHIBITS INDEX

18   STATE'S       DESCRIPTION               OFFD   ADMT    VOL.
     NO.
19   SX-1          Evading Arrest Map          20     21      2

20   SX-2          BODY CAM DVD             38,61 39,61       2
                                               73    73       2
21   SX-3          BODY/DASH CAM DVD           83    83       2

22   SX-4          BODY CAM DVD                94     95      2

23   SX-5          DASH CAM DVD               104    105      2

24

25

                             Norma Rico
                  Certified Shorthand Reporter
                                                             5

 1               VOLUME 3 OF 3 VOLUMES
                    (EXHIBITS INDEX)
 2

 3   STATE'S    DESCRIPTION           OFFD     ADMT   VOL.
     NO.
 4   SX-1       Evading Arrest Map        20     21     2

 5   SX-2       BODY CAM DVD         38,61 39,61        2
                                        73    73        2
 6   SX-3       BODY/DASH CAM DVD       83    83        2

 7   SX-4       BODY CAM DVD              94     95     2

 8   SX-5       DASH CAM DVD             104    105     2

 9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

                          Norma Rico
               Certified Shorthand Reporter
                                                             6

 1   STATE OF TEXAS

 2   COUNTY OF TARRANT

 3

 4        I, Norma Rico, Deputy Court Reporter in and for

 5   the 371st District Court of Tarrant, State of Texas,

 6   do hereby certify that the above and foregoing

 7   contains a true and correct transcription of all

 8   portions of evidence and other proceedings requested

 9   in writing by counsel for the parties to be included

10   in this volume of the Reporter's Record in the

11   above-styled and numbered cause, all of which

12   occurred in open court or in chambers and were

13   reported by me.

14        I further certify that this Reporter's Record

15   of the proceedings truly and correctly reflects the

16   exhibits, if any, offered by the respective parties.

17        WITNESS MY OFFICIAL HAND on this, the 21st day

18   of May 2018.

19

20

21
                                Norma Rico, Texas CSR 8579
22                              Deputy Court Reporter
                                371st District Court
23                              Tarrant County, Texas
                                PO Box 331883
24                              Fort Worth, Texas 76163
                                Telephone: (682) 701-3739
25                              Expiration: 12/31/2018

                               Norma Rico
                    Certified Shorthand Reporter