Court Opinion

ID: 4067031
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 22:59:37.547404+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:40.914494
License: Public Domain

A\>(in-\f`\'\s loua& \\\zf \»Ja' .2;1»5\7- 261 2 501 93
Ta\a\maax 1155 ozom.w~»m_ 2 1

AQ$\ \ C_A\~\\'

, ' " " _ RECE.\VED\N ,
-' ' ”`17‘ \ couaToFcR»wNALA'>P'-=ALS
k EX /\>RV\\E. _ _, \ _`_S;_\A \‘@§_OU\R\ _
SX\=_\[E, \[\ c'._ QRY§"“'":§_P\. : §§ C_,R WQ\&AWAQ\)E;¢\\S
` ~P\\ 319\~\1-;5 A\\K°>\!\IE_R.
?&uag\>w>< 590 ¢\a&. \\ m C_ c. 9.., ma A\cm\?¢~_¢\»¢\‘g

aquaSX-' Sc>v` "\’\z,.\ gage _QA ’&50\&\ @uagum¥ 595 Aa¥
" \_\ L,5 C_ c.- 9

__° `YQ,"\111‘-_ \9\1>\~\1>&91\0\?_'§\>51\¢£5 c>\: 311\‘15 &>R\A C;c>ua1". v

LD\¥\€§ MD\/\! Ap §§\\<;99\`\1, ED\N€,\,¢:QRK\d,’
"\a\ 1111 A\oc>\/a 51>/\¢¢§@ Aa\@\ \Aum\o¢az¢§ Ha\ouag 913an Ar_\\o¢
Q\xa§\,\w\\¥ 590 Aa& \\ m C. c, 9 , AAA 1111 A;)\)\:¢a.¢&g 511\0~
w\\»115 1115 ¥0\\0\/\[\\1£ RCSpC>\ASc_ 10 111L 51199€.5 Aa\sv\f€_a.;

”Yae._ l\\> v{)..\ \1\*_;§ wmgl;¥;\`\[ §D_Lg&naagea A»xa \__A__ag SEMEA

\5€0'1(3\ 1\/\|€)$<¥ YP_RK SL)A\'CACE_ \\L Fu\\ 'D\‘»\_'Y “?QV\ Q\\y *_(ALXL\R\ G_R\
uléea\\meh L\\¢Ac‘,a C;Ausc_ 1165 Z>‘i,D%l. A»§\c\ undea&h\gx_ 0 a\c>?*
Sc\c>mc> $oa >mg a\aw\g 'Saaay \,J\\g~>a

Al\\A AC.C_DRA\\X310 591'\&.§`19\591_, Av\cl XMCJT.O.¢.'B.C,.'LD. Class.~»
\¥\CA\-\€>\A$ P~AA 17\¢£_.9?\<§5 De$(&@cmh~\\' A\AWDK`\RA by S\MDY\\£

99959\¢\91\/91$ 59a1>_w\ Qac>gaam sup ca9 nsoa`_ ‘SIS_ C_1\aa\ey \/A\¢\¢z__,

59¢;`\3§{¢9\\\}/ lex¥\$}'{c.s A\AA \Icv\'\¥{e.s ‘\>m=\>c >Ar\e. A\)p\ls C¢Zo) Mm\y
yeaa su\\>cmc_c_ wou\é\ E°\schmge, 0\~\ 05» \"!'JD\@ mims 453 days
* 0¥ ig;__;$m%e,;<~_e_ :'>“'\\ mea‘\>¢§ ma US cAU_<-.<. Q‘MJ
`K\m_ A‘QQ\.'S (P'ZO\ >cWeA\cy W/\\\
0'1 ~' 04 - .QD\S , cmmoz*s<\.oa¢ . '
(2>»\"1-,20\1, mims 353 w»smx.z“’\\ CK¢A§¥S 7- 4-;20)5}

‘~A\s@ maa`“§g>m w 9¢\\><¢_ wa +om.¢:;.¢.:.n. c,\»§.§\s:w\w$
ma ?\e_m\z¢\$ Des;m&¥mu:\¥, C.e;¢<¥&`\eé by E>\/\Im\& »A¥?¥AA\IA ¥w>m >¢he_
same, pr§\mm susmanme C:h\>\rz\ey_ ‘\/A\AL-z_.' vc.a‘\?v`ies >m% >¢h¢,
A\op\ is w we muu>v f'nwm~ ym mw>rw<. smw® mud w
gm on '1*4'°20\5. ,¥BKMS musa m?€,z;>\o-¢m-,a\ . . ' _

[Q\M see '. wbm mama c_ause_ w 40\0-44»1*@_\@

A\sc> wl E`>Wmm A¥$IAN§'&$ Lx-\u$e_ §§‘1\25‘1.1>34~:§;59,030.-\<;59,084~1_
~ Z>GI,DQQ‘\T! AM 5‘?,08.2'!~[

(>\/E\O\`S_AURC_E_RAMC> k\ ,WR&@&\\\`MQR@AWUX d

/\s 0¥ Xc>c\¢\y§ c\Mc Q$ XY\'§s»`-\L App\.’s Ke.§pm&se'¥o \%\@.SXA\¢& A»a»
gwea \>c\e_ lA:pp\ , hug 1-?1.; §uma$$e¢\ his maximum 'DRY $c>aDny
w SJKSGn.ARg&. OM¢ S§¢>Y< his (£0\ +we»s¥y WM sc>$emf_ maza

cause w’€"s°n.oe>a .,~vowm¢_\n \AAS m '1- 4-,,20|5 .
, AMA \¢\s ¢>£ &¢>A¢\ys AMe_~W\¢ A\wp\. \-\A gaf E>F_EA ”R£'Qr cows w)s@m: wm ammme
»\P_\Ac_-e_ \_\\Ac\ €_?\ \\n`\s C”_x<§\.\sed Mc>?*' ¢?0|0» LN“I»C.\ . "Tov~\\q':r.\n was '\-e.» \o€§`\`»$

e>»`\ "I~ *~P 410 15 . ` ~
MG AC§Y\\/ E_SEM¥E)~\LF_

jim l\p\d\§cx\\\)c'\s ;s¢:.)`\\l\y b€»v§;'l_\\i ~A\\y @\r;§m>fimd §r~\"¥§n.<;,;§.
1,0“\`\/~1§% \_A<_>_ Ac_~§§\zf.. S~_£>A§\€.)AL€_ A)r A_Q__S'Y\\L, Ap¥)\. `\S 73\>§-`¥ Y>€\Y
ga_é ~:_A\;L' §A‘T.D.c,,:x. fm \§_qwm\s.

 

 

 

Jl.

C_o\&c_\u$\"cm

B\Lc_`e_ P\§m¥mce.\‘\\\% 'D'“\§c\wa\§\eé \Lgexz¢'\s _\Lc>__ \’§m>¢\n¢xz, Cbmm.~»
°'\\ch;v¢¥ Qr>§\b\e_ am ’rh¢\’r C_BSQ ., A\&A 5`\$&£.€,>¢\1€.,)%¥)\ z v_§;&_;_\§_¢i A_»~\A
\€\"Ag \\\0\< ibew QRE_--ng£g;_c._é . `.'\'.'13.0,_.:;.:_.1)a \#\As A\cm\ule\,y
\A___G. .. £M~€x¥y \~\®YL §§\x;}<`\§}’§c.\\>v"xm\ Xc> Cc)\£¥{»\\ue,¥m Re,s~>v\‘<‘t>&\\x‘>rhe
A\)p\.. `°ul CD.S.XQAY; ' ., .. ‘

QYAR)[r-:K

*m>_ l:;€p\ .. q?mys A\\\A ’Re:>p;¢~_>&u\\y Ask +\n¢ \>\c>mmb\e_ Cwa¥ §

v Lt>uv& ' CKWNA\ AQ\OU\S »\c Ci\ke}?u\\y ...Re~f\’ebw F\\\ X\\m$€\@\c.?v§ AAA J¢\~e.,
§\M¢>R\A mid (Wprs `M X\ne_ CD\A\%\-s, RCLQRAS . Auc\ A\`~\c\z We,jus¥i’cc.s
CD\AC\uAes X\?\Te_& Re;!fe_m , >r\nL App\`\cpru)r Re¢`uc$¥ ‘\W¥¥ M'\L ,Cnu@¢
mm&s am mm wqung m Re~\<;w. m &>DM,UM wig
mu@:v_s “Res.z.\\/QA \oy'% H\`\s \\z;>x&o\u\b\{. Couré< D$- Appems .»

 

E§Xc\ le°\‘r T.D.a.r§.
am m 5%'¢8»
~Ruu¥sv{\\@j§(.??&£®_ _

UI<\*\¥{<;ML csx SCK\/:ce,

`L p\`\u>(\~\&, \(\AL€\D)/ C£!Q€`\¥y A\§A So\emm\y` Swe¢\& umwa pem\»
3c1 §§ QV\`\M¥ _ 3\»3¢\\><\ A mb A\lc\ C@R?\Qc?v Qc§py §§ »\=he A\@<>\i; AAAM
.S=m;gc>`\\§g AQQL’M Ar&é &que.s¥ §§ gekease.c>»l E>o ,
\\\>\§\om §§:Nec\ am 3th m§_\_mmm (’.&>m\-y B\s>v?\\c.¥ A>;Xowey 5
`~ U£‘\¢_e.,,by p\a€\¢g A Copy §§ §wne, \MMQ_ az\@\;<_um:? u.T.s-..
mol`\\ sve?vew\, AAAK¢$.§,¢¢\ .\~O 1\0\ \Ao¢\>¢\. 1331 S><. 5\£;,2@0. O,;_hc> ;3;<
wmo\, w@um& >¢o` ila u.$.c,. §e¢. mth , on >¢w:» \~w ___:, y

033 Och\oc)P~ 67915 ' ' Lb£, mb
_ Ap\`)\\CB\A

LQ_Z£OJL