Court Opinion

ID: 4050228
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:11:32.137738+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:17.183112
License: Public Domain

%3, U¢Qq 'O\ 102/03/
m

\

tot T¢.xo.s C¢v¢t oil Cn‘w.:%\ A{a\v¢a_\$
£»p.‘+o\ S+a.w'@»\

§/'\'\o¢\ /~\cos+a’” Q\@-~rk -
QO. B* jimmy '
Aos{`.v\ ,“-T; `78“7(_¢

A_KRL'. Q\&\Qr.`¢\ CN£.-.ML Ap¢$i‘m~\mz
'T€)fo_’> 09'\~~ C.¢`(~AL\`\AQ` `\w$'h’cz
Jau¢¢$ v` A\m».¢§ u».:+
’MQ\ F\M BQ‘< M

:ow¢¢ `oa<`k `_T'>¢ 7@3(0`7

Dmc Wl¥`~ ALM‘ AL¢>H¢\ /C[¢rl»< )

A'\M ‘Cofwar§'mj it Al\:pfjav\`+ (v\ §~WH or B¢l¢.¢/" ev\ lo¢kw.\c op
TD¢A iv\w\a»+¢ €ac\`or.`¢\ QAWJQWL CTM#H'~HQ??). mr Car¢gou\a L\Q\\‘¢ve$ U\a~l-
\;\@_ 15 exp¢v'\ev~o{wg Je,\m/s , Vw\`ss+¢p$, cw\¢§ oks&¢ad¢$ le \/\\'§ §¢etu‘v\j ')u<h`¢\`@.|
‘f`e.\ieQ ‘HA¢.’€ are \n.s>+ c}u¢_ 40 mejl\`j¢uce, or ijv\omv\¢e ov\ \/\\`5 \oe(/\a.|(') au¢$

&pproa¢b.ec§ "W\o_ é&u.¢§ aske<£ »l`\p' l waul¢) QG<`¢»)M`A “H»\\$ iMO+¢'°‘/\ ’€"‘ \’\"F¢j ;{'
w{\\ arrive Sa:()c\\} aug \`v\ '€{z$ CV\"'E:\`C‘\'V Cv\o \M.c`$$\`v\j pazej> di Som¢ `
02 \A-`§ \Ma.\`\i~cg_s \!\o.v¢ 30~/~¢ \Miss\`wj \`v\ par+ er eve+¢`\r¢z\~/i

C:`_>_.__`

\\,\a~.k q %ou

\§‘“‘@;£;@;,

RECE|_VED lN
couRT oF chMmAL APPEALs

5 63an e»\d¢.seé
JUN 22 2015

Abe!Acosta,Clerk `

 

M\¢ \M)€l AQOS'\G ~' C.\(/le\v.ecr ¢“0\0,011,\(‘\'¢_\,[' Qdmi\¢\a\ A’()\)CD|J`

QE‘.'&Q@\,\€§T; th Qa\>@¢r

M‘.AQGS"€\. 4 , `
Ev\cl,>s@¢\ p\ewe. P»'nd 01 mc\\m¥ l ¥L\ed m Dl».[S. |Y , Gm`l anou> be L{Uur
mcel\ml i¥\ \ \Qs:u\c§ \‘i\u R\'\ed wl“\ ~\M WM€€U (\‘D my\' v wedch pwukoas\q\
\ S\'m\g\q \)€X`\Um M \.30.50\)(§&1\~\\*{ DI-`_S‘)mbjf Q~\‘\'on\.£q Cw\(H)/_ Dl`f}n`C~/~/@/&/l¢
am a\»us\$\g \v\\\ \\¢M r'\q\\\-s'.Tam{)enmg w`n\¥\ m\{ Y;\lv`)g§.

\ mm A.M\QA l\f\\§¥:»r'vcm¥\i\/\ \00:\’ Cow\ w,c;\f\\lng ®r\ (‘Z(HH%(;Q'\\`M al ~'WQ

\>¥m>e oe'w\).,\ %»\u`\gi . '“~L \\MAT\ (I'>B\\ \(\(S.§’ \OU/\ um~€c€.$lma\g‘€, U\le}i\\q “\/`/10_
ee('¥qQ\Q\A Q<\>M<S. D(_< wm w H'i» o\me, _\`\\ w\cd\ ¥Y\Q, \)n>.>§ .`

\}Lm\/\\M. md Q.QQD(¥_ is gm\/\\.'\ App¢.~eo.`\'cr¥c£j.

\\B¢>T'E". "(Y\§S v€§/\i`c\£\ \\`<\¥\\Q. anv,\§`>él ‘p£,\£€. is b€(l¢;i(l.§€, IY; Q\/|S`ura[r\g "‘H'\,QI`-€
Q\\h¢§ -¥\'\)\<'wg\»\ '“\a Ma“mmv\~. \¢ ba\"lw'\}$m wmale is abc purpon »»
~Qu\\\y :\ Q€l§§tn\}g L).>G\'\\ w\>.\ i\i£'\i\`m&s.
' Mo`n;: \ §QQQ"\\>&£\ 3@\\~?&\ adiqu csc N 53er \)ekv\q f€(ie`a\u;d.

'\_n‘{l/ YSI"\'U'\“ 0 l ~ \~e,c@_io@d no'}\`(€
¥’SA’L"( lot recegued vw `ce;
83 )"\'L"‘( "0'3 “ \'CC€|U-£UI VLD',\?L

\ mth q wasn Lr.»`ri§m\ 'B\`c§ my\~ \~QCC\\R \ \oe\\@u€ 872 ¢'-lUJ~ 0‘/ 7 g»/'.qquw?/
QEp%W\q, aaLm;€/| {bn:[LY/\C¢
AH led Um}L
;QH)| V. M.S[a€l U,
»" buck load(.T)L"/@$('o')

,.\7)\

 
     

E\dqn:)“n]' l

AFF/'Dm) )T 1:\) sm¢p<>m'/)F DELA\I

Ex OA<LTE C(me\€e waber §
w(L~ X?,.vm/\»o\
~ C>’L §
" 03 §
_, D/M`daml

\. Qlta\me\ Q(M`>\mu. Q.\S'.${h) -\ \oe.\`r\ pvc_<en)<\q `\ncar@e rc\\zc\ \I/\ M\e All DM‘
U¢\{\/\ under `\'Q Q,.S ‘¢\: \L\U\i\\n')?,, cmcS`\ `w\c§ C'c>\v\p€\én'\' §$Cl-\€ 05 palm ‘-

\.
\ am"\\\& C_L\>p\icon)r i/\ `H\a album Qn~\~l~\»\ed (_°CMSQ_._S Qv\el de L)€Pdn/
s\c:h)<m¥ on C\`Lo.l$.\§. l Q{\eo\ ca Q.E®M€sT Foesm\/ er,¢)muomnm/
é¢\d,,wd¥ br walk ma K`z.l\zll-ol. 33 .'1)1¢4'01, &z,L/zL/'oz. and |mu.s+
aa$ume??.‘i?.\l'@'~l . l (z)\ed '~l wr¢`~\€ . l (qu),s]red S+qu because 'C~lo(lum'
m\< leo\\`m&\ uce\v\d’féd'a,\ ave,.MIss§v\g. l \)msen receip-\'S , evidence ~H\o~)/l

M Q»'\QL\ S‘a.{c\ mi's_s\\¢\c`)} documa.nk.

l \ ,c)xv\ `w\ Gu\ a\/\emp¥ §§ \Pmc\uce web euic'kmne+|\mugk EQHS/
(\`\e.¢l vm`\\\ a \0'\;\¥ *'W\L M\ Qw\ Uv\i.~\/ \\Aa“ 9mm \'\0\.§ blm U/\PECLm/\abl£ m
k da\cx\} `\\\ gus@ess J\ °rb.e oer<\\`@o.d \~€Ge§pjm . \;ev\*r C¢, v€que§+w\ H\e.
\S\/\'\ md \'H'b swan `\Am¥b of Ju¢\e. Ha,v~e.no+ received an ans~
wes . \ \r\a\m. mail 01 &r`ce\xzmca (Cmv»p}q\`n+\ ., AS'£LJY\ m Hw,q me [’Q{+S`-
=Y<'m§> \\,Q{\\ pmc)\ueo Sucb puyallup ww\ H~‘ng§.

us ¢.‘(: M§.s \%Pv\ 0\0¢\4`¢>‘§` Aw\e \ bow \~ec,e`\\mA msz amu»er$

_ br vespme &r\>w\ webb @cm\\q, DWM,( er amf maWd ver+mm¢`a_g

Jw w\\‘l wri"\'s. \ w\d\\)<b`\_\ ~\Jé\ru\»q\` ~\'\f\\s veb\`c\e bn €nsue'e dejio£rq.

"¥L¢\w/ cLH}Qn¥ saqu mb
Tc\m. 01\£\ Q.>cv<;)/ \.\/\A£¢- pom\l\{ op pmm\,]. Vqspw+m\q mbwua‘
Qalm|, dew.@"‘muwmz
ml deal Um`¢'

Jl x\l:.u¢g_la,°( U'
lo 421 a ,T)L '7[113(/7

     

 

 

C\>m\'¢>.§<‘ Q,c\m`ma\ b(\>peo~\c \$\><.\..>*{l~ XS.\\ZL{ 6\ .07,.03 foil]

EXQCLAL Q\de\on`e\_ chde § \v\ ~\Y\¢\Q`T€\<QS Q¢>w\'
BF
§ Co.\w.mM Mve»ru
§

 

-QE®\AE§T ?~0(& sTQ\\ m Am\;\m\e¢¥v\()\\) OF umw
C>Y- w>(%€r'>¢§ COQPMS‘, umw BI>£L/ME/UTS

Co\xv\e§ v\e\)o Ql&\one\ O&rclmu -. G\§\z\icm\-\" \)\`f) SQ. \`v\~\"\r\o above €~¢\§_~}~Heo" Cmcj numb~
end Ms\€md Qi\es ~\"b'\s §que§l '\\‘“\a. ch\»\"c>€ crimm\ A peo\\s gx S¥c\q {¢\ Czc§iu»
dica\\"m\ op wn:\/ be Ma\av_n$ Co\rpuh(hm:\ (QS(>Q&\-Q'.i\\q `S\\r,m )d/\e §»\\cw'mgf

\ :`_Br\e \).)<{~\/ "\zu\a,“

T\\e A\)p\`~ew\¥ §§ wave pp 3<\\1. C<\e.uocl\i; (Lu\e and \)e\‘\e.ue.s ~\r\r\a§c ~Y\n`\_\ m\e`\s_ being mwa 4
425 b\_\ X\\o \d\s¥v{e¥ P¢‘¥>ru;'n,e\'\$ 0%"¢"2,‘ w\o\ or 5(\'\2. ’ORHT\`GA' O\e<\e F§r webb Ou.w\xq.\,awdo
T€>;m.ms.¥w_ Mm\omb\a. belo\m, m “ ge 'Y_ce>’ic)w`\g . `m a\\ wr\'¥_'\ $loc\ pm se m beba\f»¢e
‘3¢\\2 bech \ comm-ir make 0 proper 0\ cm;vw icm = 615sz ¥\r\)z \"ue¥¢ §ben%@.c¢\'\udlco\e im

"rba. \m\' y.. C¢“sec\uen“q. M A\>\>\'\com¥ w`\\\ be pce'\\xdica& \'¢\ \\'\s eb`\\ 1344 b Qm~suc_. habeas ce\'\o§.
T\\Q:e age \v\`\§s}nq riome .

`\\. `\\A`.s§{hq anv\ev\`\I

\). "(\r\o L\pg\lce“r\-\ Au\\\ ;\'\QA o M(Dzv\arw\c}\um D‘(" lam ¥\>c web wv{\/ Dpp\Ica'\io/\.~Tbe A\>p\ica~

\r\'\r ¥E\Qd o vedo\ei@A mm£e;s'\m $oc mmenb;w>§(:<w who m md ,~.\n suppbd DP \m~ pain n€ m-
an\n 'W\n. Arpp\`\c_¢m¥ 9:\£¢§ wi%&§u` .S'\'cc\'emenh €i>{ mae no`s‘.~?.oo$' C'ruc» QS'L DHA) 120011

333 L\\-\\ 0\(?;).`¥»\0. \°<\)p\icm\¥ mmi ne»§\\/\ Ai$€u»e.<cd evidence or nem\q avo_€\ab\e evidence les-
'»\~\`mm§ ¥r\:w ~\C\MA' QKMAQ amd C`¢\r{s‘\\rb Low“o.§t>r cause no‘.'Zi:oLp (*,M `lell 01 (A)/M suppor/\’
.~L emch Z. cmd @mu\c$z \b . A'c‘.\w>\\ innocence Clca§`w\.v Hp~\>\icm\¥ ~F)`led @lb:¢,rpk oil Ooclcd-,
Suc\ng\w\¢ and ?\ea \\c_»,caewmn¥ \‘¢\ suppm+ o? \r\"\S C_\mm r~e_‘; 'Fe¢_§wml Sedence.. A \y]>\;cun¢\ md o
qeq\ecc;\ veqm-¥ Y»r du (_`_'v¢d¢\»i`\\~¥q o¥ (‘,\a`\v\)\§ w_\\e,(ei¢\ \\e pr\a'w\s \\\`_\ de\a\i and masons %>\' such
Aa).uq .» ¢\-'W\`\cm\¥ §cvu\&nd €v~\¢\'\b’r'\:$ Pm §w:b 6\9.\0\\{.`¥¥\1. A\>p\ice“\¥ a\ao pmmch “\w 5~\~¢¢¢'¥ Evb€\)F)-
\ 0.-\0\1 %f CC\L\SL \10`3‘. 1045 C‘,`YLA) (.o'.'>¢> bi and Zi.'l§lc C¥LN HLI| DA.Gmd exp|a`\n¢zl bow '“(\Q_ Lmvz§\}\g
cv\ `\\uv\ \'5 §§ `€,`\“{nv\eou`$ ¢\’\v\.`> CQM\IL\ mw\arcd. Gsvc€e'\i>£\' ~\<\\L. o£}chm./\~¥ 018 l"\/ pe(~\a`w\s k -\ba emr\'
cmi m`\s$u\ W'\§-em \'5 L.>o\"(\\'ng Qmo" ~¥\m)r Cmv\se\c)\`ci my`¥ e`\¢\>\a\"\ av\\\-“Aiv\§ rci Q@<€MA¥.¥\> app
hcw\¥o_\ 3\&\€\\ P\m wm e\\‘\e<eci ‘\"V\e»\ um'\ ~We<e.
’iw. am was Uu\ uner suv§\¢ manage w¥¥\\ 5 §eo\b¢\ envdopu.'¥beqme<e m\¢\;»essed+v
“We ‘b"\s)w`\c§< C\e¢\c Es-\"Ae( 'Dagc)\\uclo umw Cerl`mu°\\ _("@,r\\'~\;er\v\o‘. 1014 l`XZU,Ow,l ZO'~IY qZY§ wl‘lb
b ’c\>\o\\ we\qb¥ 09 3 Lbs S.'|o oz. .'De\'\vec\\ obie bemg:(‘)u|$el\§ Flbe 30 +b dam op Aprrl Zo}$'.

7). '\\M yn()¢q)p\'\€s::\t\\ \\*\\QA O\ m'\'e. \Q\’¥€f mb'\cf»\ Cc>v\lro\'_e\€£\ Px\op\`\ca¢\¥.§ P\W\`o\u\){)c 0¢'¥0£`}1`§
App\'\('cw\\» elp\a\}\ed \/\`\s re\a "o¢\sbip w\`\b \ou-¥\/\ (§w\\se\$ ."BC\\»\`€X va\_acc\'l amd Fau$+o
3550\, prp\i`€mv\\€s o\ecl.$`\or\ "h) \ead QL\'\]~L\/ /\M$ b\v\o\@r$'§nnc')i"ng ¢~)c~ H/\e Oc::re_i' Om>f pml‘»
mdqu .. Sm"d M{'ciau.'l L&'(Co\cts bow we \’l_ pages dba (A»pp\icun+- G\sv sen¥c¢ ‘L page

Q__¥.p\Cu\cI\\Tor\ 3m \'\¢\L C\Qr\k orr S\AC'N\ g`\\\`ng( . ®Mra\\\ caw\c;\ dituch *\'\\0_ C'.\.€c\& <\Q m\~.`g»\{ ~\'\\2,
Y\\s§\§`ca“\ C!\`" do,\\`ue<\\~ é\\c\ ic mg dowmo n”b m'\ss`m.o§. `Y\e`\\’\¢\ar c\\`¢\ “\1\0. C\er\k. 4
mm was £:\eA twin ci s{¢\r:\\c 'pc\rlcac& w`\-V\\ odo\rm oclus\»`co ('.‘€v\`&iz;( "D'is-.\-
r;t}< Q,\u\£'§ 6%`£€. \'\r'¢~>€\$ mci\\c€§ \>\c. Cv§c¥`{\~}ed Mc{\\ .-`\”b¥n\ mé\g\¢\»\_u@»lfll> m.'be.\ivesq ddt
\3¢\“<5 (:S .cl\,.\')' .%n-¥ is *\\\a S~\jn da>.}¢>r' Mc»\{¢"£olf , rlzejum xice(())r F€C\uesle_ei was S'\q/\ec\.
§\M\>¢A.c»mc& weaka \»q 3m ng\z<;a“&. (‘.m+. ne M laws my 13 '“)olLl mo com ZOUq

§1013.
\\\‘3_€_“_§~_;\92

\. Qp~p\\"cw\\ waves X>v\ls' requis¥ \>Q.wusc)..¥w_ \-ch‘\w)d c. \e¥lw ~vaw\\is LmX\/\er'\,uis

Cavé\m\a§ .L.>\“> cm\\ecl M. \»\mvru\»\e's s€x:<£¥mq cw\c\ was wc>\»\(;ed J(\r\cc¥qn\q ~\/\'\e.
mdl pages (p\~cmm\o\\\\"vs u"\»e<@_ vec¢\\ec\ .‘¥\AQ. a()p\&m¢\¥;\ \m%e.r \v\qu\md
u\m:\>§< ’\\'§o_<§e£c§r\c) \e.¥\e{ . QQXEM .OAo\ was mz)n€\eci M \\» mills m)-\ reve’m{d.
'L ’I\\J),A\>p\\\ce\nx mayes 5(\¢\\5 magma/34 \)emu$e. \r\a, `oa,\(eve$ `Y\@ac\`\udicajw/\ c.Q~»suc'\r\ wr§\~j
§§ ;ns\' \\'\\ \`n`-€m,§“\{\ `\`.V_‘(\£n`\eo\ . and \r)e)`\&.\z@$ -‘Y`r\cr¥ \'{> sbxc,'\/\'is\\r\£ _CC\SC `\.(?.d€nia‘
' C\' rs eccs.u&£’_ op ~\»\\o m`\s$`\rq dbwm€nk.w\§& m\r\w\ (T.z§n$\~ru£d \{`\)Qm\\q .c,'r &S “\'\/\L
op‘p\\'cw\\' _€\q\a';\ \r\'\s `\»L¥§\\“m§ . Cv\ Vka, wmu\cd§\.~e. arm (':a\ce\o-L esj¢c&)\i$)\a \\e AZ\ nel‘
» make em \u\ow\`n§. V\>\m\\ou{ md 12\\1\\{30:\\' adm`\.\)'\m a-pqu{ \¥.

\v. (Pcmv o'\'~ QEL\vEeu

'T\\a pr \\‘em“§r \/\as MNL geeci\plrs -Q(bw\ Y»\n Q¢>§< O%§Ice,.a{\o\ (‘o.r\\`e\'o.r\ v€QQ."\\)*x .iv\c\\uai:vg
QLM“HQQL{Q¥ reques“\'ed ‘g`mms m gmc -\¥vzr\/\\Q,W\'\\a;} ~\'\\n. am sk+ed and Mi_;s`iv\g c§¢-
&M;\¥§¢`\\\n P\q>p\{ecm)r wi\\ mq\ko~ +'NM avc\'\\c'\\)\e m mm us ¢\'\\o_. did-mn +Q\¢u p\aw.
\\/\»‘\`\\ \DQ. ma\\€d 'V`\CA Mf'\~\£\d\ 'Mo`\\. Qbr$`\\>\\., ’\\r\e. \X’~H/\ °"\ci`\"\\ op "\r\"\j Mvz\‘\'l/\ 59 lane .

v. §§.'m}, , 5.,-30

\»>`\-'\Ea'€zo&€l ’W.\;mssy Co»\)smm§o ,Hw_ app\i<m# pnch W\s fmth Cfrim\?\u)hppm/J
\N_ {£'\`C£A\"M at

'\\ '3\-004 f\\'\ C\O'\iu£;'\€c\*s`m o~"' “\’\\n\x)P;-"S \ bn \)Q§na\£o("\\)\n_ A`pp\\`(n.¥ g §an\i _

-<\:>\`r ~\ &X‘m»¥ p\‘\cm\¥ w’\\\ <\v¥\(\>e. pyejw\`imcl»`¢.eip<nmdumilq cl »Fqull;?¢ ,` ha Sua=c.s§iue,y
~ \e,s am><\`n.r bo ` ;G)\c§l<\\>¥\oa cir§cr} m'»\j,\ M)L,\<e.o? mci-¥.`Tl/mjr_¢`)¢ `\Tj~\w. odl`udi¢crkm `1_§
aqm\`¢\a\' CX)`Q\>\`\U\\~\"; d\`\'€¥e.$*$ `\J;¢C\m`\€.d . Pw\c§ \\> £u(¥\\w !~€\(Cc its \.§ni(\r\ \¢\2 W\c\.\}.\o@ Pn“)\~`ul)z:).

Q€§Q€L')f§l\\\{ 5\1\0`\\/\\`~“€¢;\\ (Qr\\S‘\S (Ov§qim\_(u\m\u(us
(A(_A“;@\ OQ(AM\W\.\W’L

A\\ fled \XMX

" lot \-’\\\x.“?~w.€i w\

CNQ<UX wm

  
  
 

  

Ev\,€\\,)¥ \?\ SUWMF ozan
. § .

§
`Y\~L Qv\\\>\» \`v\c§ ls cA`<‘\>L ond churcI\'e, `Yrox\$\cr\~rm 0("43¥\1 Pr
\>m¥`€\\f`s \Q,\»\C( fQ`. ?\\mz Qo\\*\m M.`i\udc\e'_\ Seeq~c\or\{“' _
. . . 4 , 0 _‘ 0 ` ¢f
`L¢._ D¢\;o.é(-\MQ_ Qe<l~i@\§d puo\Lc\cj¢§ ~’\\,o¥gm %\d w\mv\ \<\W).{ d\`d \~€0_0§\\,\2 11
\ou€r'or\\\{ ’)"5 pages '\’\\a¥qm.$m)r .`T\\L (_‘.Q¢A~i€\`cd \-Q'-\/§c( ~H\Q,g did r\o'+
<'o_eo_'.w\ {\/ ` 'Y\/w. poologe was ve_@c>\wd on MS'H/» dog 0(:»\\1\<1,11
cd( 3 th\. de V¥\o_ §\.Ld§,u.§ odd-drug dam M*\Md"“\m \D.A.~ already `
(mpmdzd md_)<'\'\a-\» \30\1 work/hog a mo/\MA '?i\s mem deec`oiop ¢'n»a)"
§ o>`\\jv\\é\ &.,Mon\'\¢\\~¥\\¢x\- §§ w §~\'L dog J’ due\q_;»f\'\\n.\' dw'l dedd@. ~“~z»/\
mi\»i\\ smoch rl( id m Su_pm_. two ch(+¢? Gnmm/ Ap‘pwh].
'¥m¥-zs u\\ \L.>as i\\d“.~ ~-M_lo!_v\$` , ‘
(Qq`€`\m\§¢xbm\&f\ drs

TF\ML. Cl(‘_wro\£. Lmdw.( peno\¥g oc"§>€("\urg`» Sg\>m'.l~\w\ v.\s`.\$'

. c , g.__
TUM\AM \og k\/uz‘. Q¢Q\me\ Ql\jdwm will/bn
A\\| aid blle '
gun l:l\u¢?>[vq IU.
.perK ]`)5 `1[.4?(17

`>‘\> k Cmd:f