Court Opinion

ID: 5126499
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2021-11-16 23:08:10.013988+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:15:52.393349
License: Public Domain

OR1P AL                                              11/16/2021

            IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF MONTANA
                                                                                       Case Number: OP 21-0544

                                        OP 21-0544
                                                                         FILED
 MATTHEW L. MONTGOMERY,                                                   NOV 1 6 2021
                                                                       Bowen Greenwood
             Petitioner,                                             Clerk of Supremp Court
                                                                         State of Monta na

       v.
                                                                     ORDER
 JIM SALMONSEN, Warden,
 Montana State Prison,

              Respondent.

       Matthew Montgomery has filed a "Habeas Relief Petition" with the Clerk of this
Court. Montgomery contends that, pursuant to State v. Hansen, his sentence is illegal
because he entered a no contest plea to sexual assault in violation of § 46-12-204(4), MCA.
2017 MT 280, 389 Mont. 299, 495 P.3d 625. He requests that this Court vacate his illegal
sentence and rernand for trial. Montgomery refers to Cause Nos. DC 03-98 and DC 06-83
from the Ravalli County District Court in his pleading.
       Montgomery is not entitled to habeas corpus relief. First, in 2016 this Court issued
an Opinion and Order that required Montgomery to seek leave of court "prior to any
pleading or original petition with this Court regarding his prior convictions or sentences as
imposed in the Ravalli County District Court in 2004 and 2007[.]" Montgomery v. State,
2016 MT 169, ¶ 15, 384 Mont. 120, 375 P.3d 403. His Petition in this case relates to those
convictions and sentences, but Montgomery did not seek or obtain leave of this Court to
file it. The clerk nonetheless inadvertently filed his pleading.
       Be that as it rnay, this Court overruled Hansen earlier this year. Gardipee v.
Salmonsen, 2021 MT 115, ¶ 10, 404 Mont. 144, 486 P.3d 689. We held that "[a] claim
that a plea is invalid because § 46-12-204(4), MCA, prohibits a court from accepting a no
contest plea in a case involving a sexual offense, is a claim challenging the conviction."
Gardipee, ¶ 9. Such a claim is barred if, like Montgomery, the defendant did not object.
Gardipee, ¶ 9. Gardipee forecloses Montgomery's claim.
      IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Montgomery's Habeas Relief Petition is
DENIED and DISMISSED with prejudice.
      The Clerk is directed to provide a copy of this Order to counsel of record and to
Matthew Montgomery personally.
      DATED this I-1, day of November, 2021.

                                                            ChiefJusticc

                                                    e9--i            4:UL.
                                                   ( #4/-1-‘44
                                                              Justices