Court Opinion

ID: 4061026
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 20:01:18.898382+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:04.491969
License: Public Domain

@\///17¢/ 020 5

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

' 2 - ', _ ?11/1{44 e . » /
. ___.._°Z_€/#a’_€’.ez”z~4c 5'4447 02_244.121¢¢¥’ ' l l ~ 1 ' ` l y l @
____21`171!¢5_1_7¢/11:~¢47411:22¢~/ ' _ §§ y ___ l
16 ¢1. 642 /530,!’ ('5/’_¢744 civ47441~/ @@URT OFCHFMINM A_BPEALS
_~_/7¢/.1771<.1,_71715__/2£2//__4 ¢9_0 , l ij -' 'JUL 09 2015
l §§@@M©@Sf?§ ;@i#@vk

_ 41_€€_;_@/_1¢_7_@, _2£5,': 112_15¢4245 443_@14244.4)_/ 2421/_7414_1/4/245/45

_(’_4¢_147_¢'___,~/1@44_1__42241~_1 ,_21.1’_7_"0_’2*41" o_¢’£¢zz;z,gzc W/f‘é‘?fdéa¢//'¢=’ @£/‘//

 

_/F/_Moé&__/_;£(J_LZ/__éc5z5¢1_~l__/_QQ/£/lc&cac_é`/zz41~/€011¢;’ /511474/ 5’1¢/117'

_5/_' 557/111 117/2421 7_4 245474474414"4_144444414_2§ 527 45'-/74/111'

 

_7’5145_(1'5_1?17/_¢57\/_ 241_74_/4'_ 7~»74:4¢27__ 55 51"`_1147_:444; 41\1¢>_ ,¢744,_4_~4%1,

 

\

. ' 1 \ ' /2751451~_;4/_ _/24/_/5!.04-_¢/#///441»//1¢4//7 /@_/_.5114$€,_

 

 

_d:_}/¢)_¢_/` /).2¢:4_/_¢__ €55¢1¢41¢' (_’0/~/ V_{_~/__e~c,_e; _.Z;_" a/v 0644/.,//434_ _/1-44~1,¢“4_~¢»’._'“°`~_""/‘ ”"~
_/,\/,5,,1,114//4,~/ 244'4/ 41/¢1/144411¢41 4/1 /4/1/ /4741/446 5¢-/4- --/5'/ _,2/4,¢@_

, _ _6.1?_162&;/41~) é/‘/€/' W//L 1/¢//)/_'4///;{_-£_¢/544_¢/_44/15442_ 602/14441/4@~

 

/445/1§_(_225/_ 26_2,0,¢€45&'_@¢2215/_;_{)/2/¢_//_;/;~40_ /M_,€J€MMJ'_@UL_

740_¢@’5’5?/;5@_/_€_/1'2/_2_2/,4145 445/16 /1//2441~41/¢14,/-5

 

/‘3_2.14_1_ 5_124__7 42 5441:1_<5£5_¢_"55_-_ 4444:5,’54_ 4;1€,11_1144¢¢¢ _52.1.4714/5_¢,
_64_§’_/1/%/ 1747/491_,_4/1/2// 413 4'/41"1 111111 441_4_14_1¢;44,14~ j _
1954414¢44¢/,_411 45_ 4_411¢,_§2112;1_// 54_14:;_/4_541 421_114_ 244/42 ,_&¢11479_
_4"_14._111_1»/5 /5_/_1?1/.14/;/_/£_21/_1'1_¢; 21/_4554/1 4444,_.‘444€ 541/444 ¢_~
_454411//44¢4_1¢/4,_21444 _4_14/_4€4_41<1_515144244/44_ 442414_441_ /_'-/.544_
_2/,&5_ 5,5_&4141:. 42/¢_ 16_/24.1444/_%4~_ 5'11_1.1-€ /_w. 4?444~44 -//51 /1-/

 

 

. _€'1'65_1€_1'_5 1 _A/~_ /1‘_£¢1/__/5}5 2/4’# _5/‘ _ _ _J_M_ -m¢//o_/A_o_/e»_/¢\e¢/e&
_425 4_4'~?17 _///4¢. _5//!1,./_ /_1_/_ 54415_11,' 42144€__@12/_ 44111_1_5,241’11¢,€4____

___€00"/-¢€’¢-' _¢_ ,9)_~:;\`£_ Op¢`_/_C_/€ //___¢32___'_ 161@7:/‘.¢»/1_~/_ 4%//)7__¢¢//¢///¢411`2% .,_Z_ va/_/VQ
(’j@,¢¢.' A//';;i% /0/¢>1.¢74/ f¢////¢/ &'/~/40/' A'c//`¢J.¢ f ,656/¢'/.¢12?/ 625/6/41~/ _ o '

 

 

 

11\ .~'l ` . . . @
1 ': ' ` ~ ‘ ' .
0 \
. _ , 1 0 . ' \

. 663/:€,64//6%/;66£50”06_¢20£/6&¢@¢&165%6%6€4§,5;0£0;»¢$“6
" - d¢/-/a -/5' /JA/€ __“_/@¢/_z/;"_/, 750/3 lawn/kc 02/2».0_¢’_ 4640 662¢2'1_99.¢0;)

_.,/'a¢_/// /@/2¢¢6¢¢:£/6;3?.; /.f 0¢/0/ Monce far/00 05 000 050/200 ”52'660,0/¢2-_ 659¢=660¢¢62¢-;:6
_/6€_0'6_;;¢_?,6£/:~£_0;0¢¢6;_466’¢06/¢06&6 /600002¢00¢ 666/006 /'00>0‘4400_-

" 6.6£6('/,¢/_,~/ M¢/e¢//¢¢Am»-¢€°- 66¢_/0~_/0;¢_10~ /Ae //V//va¢a¢z¢~\,_/ 420/',¢

      

 

 

_061.6/¢,//_00 660_0_0¢`;_¢6 00 000/a 600000_¢ ///00/000¢/` //A'£ 646,2_06¢€, _o_v/;r_,e)6
/6"¢/_6 ¢d¢J//¢»A/Ad_c¢6//»v/ gM)_ 406»/_06’/_¢£2).¢_¢060/_;' &_¢/Af_o¢%r;¢ed’ /IM/,z“oc _// ~
_W//a-/ /A/ _//‘¢//_A_» 6//' JA¢://né‘i 455/2 4,_,,.0 ap/MM f,(?;p@.nqg}°

662 e_,_é' /_~_/A`Qw'_ wife /46/¢6 @¢0_0¢ /Zr¢_/_///_ def/606 060/606 0.9?¢/_-.¢¢~00/29:0¢

_ 6501/mea / /02¢/¢/6 500/004 @/~ zma¢¢£fé;%_g;é/,¢_AM
_4{%6{(&62?6.£¢6¢/_/..?65_2~02 mw ‘ ` ' ~ . '

 

 

_ . .' __o/’,`a¢¢//¢ a,//§/,_dA/6 dc 120/236 46¢/_6‘_’4/} 06, ZQ day iva-206 000 444 ¢;p'¢,::g;¢.€_ ‘ `
2 _/’00/,[¢4¢2€6@/0/“0¢'0#¢4/ 4/0¢6 556/20 y,../a-.‘¢er ~c¢),.,,¢/e,ga_d¢/wd» 010-006 -'-~-- ~
€M,¢?/z>¢nl _(_’06/¢/¢)60~//_@/ /9@6 4~40'~/¢.‘¢2_ 40~_/.4.0¢~;£6.0/¢- /o FZ'@/ /zve»%/
_j(_`e#/c>'?6 / 646/6,/_id_ /n/,ara¢¢~/M»~/’ fA/ /Y/ 460/4 ,/Z/,;’J df'?é6 436 //VAC
6/100¢€0¢26¢_5/0@06 97;0060»¢/00/ . /_.'¢60// mp¢g,¢_'g>//a/v /0000 23 '
62026’4@/2¢06';2¢/12264_0»:2’0_¢66502/_0,§_5093204»¢65/00:0.6/£2_$:¢6/6/;/_,0~/0/ ~ _.

0 °.
_90,60¢¢6 646 000 6/,_0;6»66 ,oa/_¢/,aa 4000/0600¢»/,&00 002 o w %0;/ /60~3»

_6/_?_/6/66/46/66_¢/67¢€6@¢£_¢6 5!6660(0“ 5_6_¢66~¢6;6)_ 356 //’c/_///;a/ aP/.a/€ feesz
6/@20”'_’6¢°60,_£¢0 00 656766002¢¢06 /t//»a¢'a~nvaf_'»¢ 06/6 /o//fa»/nq~ea ¢/00,5020
_[6’0;¢1'[[;,476;6 ,/60~/ J)3_/ _50_~._///_ 464€~_6 5<6/070/0%\/ /¢/g/a’c/e &,,

/»¢/ /O/v 4 6//6»2_.¢_)_ 6100_¢¢‘»_¢¢30 006/506 ¢?0.000,./6 460/06 AL_

 

 

_00,40¢¢2/ 440266626/_// ,€¢:a_ama aep04<'_ya/0M 4/’_@!°4/¢64¢///0 0//0:/,: 6
6540-/6/_00////0/6;;/ /1////0.0¢00¢7°" /Ff///M/ 406<1/6('060~6///6»/¢:06/0_<§£’¢_6_.¢/”?/7_6
. 60/,/,0~ 6{?7/¢/_ ,»¢~0/ //rr,¢/ /2/0/'/ 4000~060004‘ /:/00/6'/¢¢6/@¢,6 6292_6
_764_/464;06664 /_'¢0/06 a/c64_ 64465_/'[06/006/¢2.6_ ¢" 46//¢/16/6§€64_0/ _/_;:d1.,__

 

 

@

. _;___Az¢a ~p¢3m3_ QMM¢.O/ __9€1”3/:1;§3;'1.6319* 1_'¢/1¢-0%_/ z_- 3_@33;22_3;
/3__091¢/33 /¢’/¢;1¢¢1.32 /%»M M;,¢z/_¢Zx_ GJL 0
~____.,43¢1~.'13'¢/170 (”0»~//3/.,9¢ _3?1\/37 /‘/31~@>.£1/* M,L¢MPWFYRWD@%€/@¢ -
303 1313 ,W/: ,;-/- ,{,/_ é,/£L;Q:_ o ju\_ 09 ZB%

' o ca

/¢// /d,e ("331,.1_,¢ /7'/1’ 119/y 6’ 1\,@\ ‘

 

 

  

__é;<_:A//¢)A¢? '7?’.\/€(% /n//;¢J //»»37 1@’@)¢? /k>" 33 /fm/'e A'_¢e.»./` 313/3313/11//
_/1=¢,@/?13»/¢3,€_7¢3/ /¢é 597/l id 4//41‘,_ 3+7/€ fe 43fo ( 331/16/ @A*) ¢;’A»`¢z136
_éiwz/_ &/1»,0/114,_¢91¢/_2//1_9'[1:1_;:@ 01’/11/& --,7,3¢@,;¢¢3€ /'¢1111\1.-3¢/_ _&/,1,;32¢;@
,(,_91_13111,__ _/.4_1>3/ ,13/1/12@ 3»/ ZFT,/ //, 2'111 /,»¢Mw 3?1119-13»//13331£
` 77 23 3_1;/_ /1:1111_3/1;`/3_1{¢11_2,4;73~1711 1311/3 ,; 411/3101
`. ~_1_¢_¢9’/_»1/1~113;/3/13_/ /7/€ ,£///5/ /Za/J/€ 0/ /L// /j//$'A///o,~//)C J»f//>_€¢’ (’3¢1/#

-/i////a///Q¢»€ 0/ //%'09 _/¢”1;3¢?»/£¢5 1191/077%/_1’_¢’/4;:1_/3/¢37 37-¢’¢/0¢3/
. /73/1/101»/3‘ /5/~ 631ch 3¢/19//>)1~//’ 70 zz’éc.z/.j/~,*_Z_Aoé/_ _'A_u~/ d¢»,-o;¢»@ '/`Z§c'e§rj_ 770 vw/`z'v._¢__/{€A fj'_¢d-€f,rc_%

 

l _/Z(J;_/¢¢;/;,:C_'_A¢-/_d’_ ,&/3€-9€¢;/’3?/_‘¢»7£_/_/23~// /1?¢/ €» 15;¢¢/-/ Ar‘¢>¢<:`»@
).4_£0’1¢¢1_1//7/€/ /9// /3'//@..17 d'/d/¢/ ,/¢¢,¢113/ (°3¢1/7" 16‘3¢33¢//~,/’<9 `

' d»/-/ 1_9 //,¢?¢/1~1€3¢¢7 77 177 /.1‘01\/- ¢Y'¢r/M W/1~»3/o¢~} c'e// /€a/ /z_,

 

__g,g._/_@_&>’/` 1947wawa A=j% 135 dyer /Zd qu_/q/e.r.:-` /£/z@ /3¢11,’7'1€¢'¢31:3€¢'-»
,%/ /,=1,¥,1.§1;13 1717/1¢1/,33 /;f 3?!3¢;_»¢¢__ 1933/331';¢32/ _..
~ _1£¢£,33¢»¢;3;1/{¢/:<3&>’51_¢11//€ 37// di ' ' L//"..f’ 1535/1676 ('0¢/3'7’ l/,‘ 19/19(#(31
. 33€;:&2;§_ ‘ 1 ~ -. , ._ ¢Z/{é 97233 .3/¢ 106
__’76?:/1939...1€£2"3;1»/;1@ ' “` '
__1¢ __/5_/.93:11/_19;20_/3115@/