Court Opinion

ID: 4052023
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:52:59.561903+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:37.721306
License: Public Domain

J
                                                                                                                                                  '

                                                                                                                     '   /

          PAv\.6JfUl$ l f~~frf .
          r,o.c.J ~I _o. ~             c7   sot 12..                                                       RE.CENEO\N
                                                                                                   ~nl ~~T Ol= C~\M\~Al tl.?PEALS

          8tO Fm "l s 1. t                                                                                     SEP 18 7.\l1S

          H\JN1SVti...Lf.,l t MS                     773'1G .. 000t                                          ~.be\ A.costa,Cletl<

•,.-;''    IV~'! If\·'..$ ,~ tiJ,~ l   0 t' ~
           orSi a: rcr      c:t ~- ((i(. ·· r il;r r.!\.t.~.,p;L

             Of-1 .,.i1f. ~l'M r.lf.i<..!       or..J-~i:, 1.0 ~~        ?    en ····LJA.h·c.. ~i'LS
D

    l.trS T'eA\i tttSf. T!\ltO                                                  h:\tz: R..tJt)f0 r·"                     ll·\J~ A                                                                roPY TO           THE Cf ..L'Y\l \JAL OfSUt.\f'f

     P£"11:r-rn~ft f.!:.¥(.._"Y/( !-\f. n.b5f.S.u.J:t"St.\'iS T~\Ar \./ocJ.tl''\~ ·~dn.. Of"t
     A;\JD "tOtHt Srf.t rF I, T ~ l\;>,t fl \.{ {)\) II f="at. T l-1. f T:r '1'\ <-'- s Of "J"r X d ·n-\r s

     T.tY\ P~fi'~ANT f!\4 T 'ly ((J f'.:l~ T                                                f"(\   A ~.u A :'H-;..     ~ \N:J J,,~ Dlf f~S1.A),f 0 fV'if"t'i'NfS
     Tt"" ·'"ft ,-; ·r <;:
         ,.   .   ftoo.       ••   .-.it~
                                            \'wI [1l
                                                 ' .....
                                                        .I'J!.\
                                                            I
                                                                {l1·
                                                                .:/
                                                                       'f
                                                                       ...,_.
                                                                                 ·-r ' ..     • ...
                                                                                 ·' ,_,/'I ~I -
                                                                                                       :   J
                                                                                                       'i 0U ,
                                                                                                               .   1

    c. c          -~      o        1:-l     f -rat l. OtAJrvc.,. :

     T~) tt-f'i               t-\o,\JO(Afilf' JuOta{ LVI'~Nf Stllulll-JT

     r        rt..Ttv\ 1 t\Jnl~nr-st                           un r-~..10 ar                  ~o. 7wo ( z.J

     TIH'lflf\!\ff (CU:'·-.llr, Tti !l.A S

      OT $i             ~T.{T ATTCDI\Jflf JO~1 ~Hll~\II'J{).j
                                                        .
                                                              Jf).
     -r-rr"Y\          ruet "( J'J :S1' :tC't ( ~.\J~ ~it.
                                                                                   !
       YO\                tl.j.     f.1'CL K.NPPt            q i H fLQ.,tL
                                                                      '
         ,~1·. ujOih 1-\'                           r ~ f.. A :5 1 b; l; ~ · i.:/L o c
  v.
                                                              1" 11\ ~tt.J\ M 1' .["'t.l 1\.\ T\f   I   ;    '   )(   ll ~

          MoTTO).) Fo(l l(((();)J S~O~ti:.A"rl'o," lJI NUN(. 'P~                               TvtiJC... t.lfl.Of~
          CollQ ~l'T:n.JtO ('(ITIIJUff.S Cf T'f~ {Oti!JiCAJ 1·i-\~ t".NQ!\.1(, Of .,-.._L

                                DvADl\f vJ'tAPDt>J 1\fO'f"fc£.
 lt)   Tl"\{   1-\ar-Ja(.AP,:,l{.. o uO"{. Of SAHl Coutf:

 'I Plh.rLCu2..'t'!S L£..(.,fDf:lT,cAJ.il1..!~ DAr< o'1 fOu~,~~ l OtJ DG · i 3- '2 0 t'l. ,1"Htt1 tr\~ t>~AQl"f W~ A POM C'-\..ql.lbl.
 WOutO f!>{ Dfl.ofJD£0 Pa;:,vt.€A

  ~E(t\\fNT P.ltfWf(,JT\'4~ S1A~t /ANO lYl~ l(Gt;,fTT.:TuOTH~ICWOI'lO<;,.A

  CO.\I'f(ACTtJAl ftqrz.q~~rt\f~'J fD~SiJil'\1'\'ifO &~'ft\J~(hJ'f..\f S.iA1"t. A~O                                           I:,
  Wt.iJC~ "T~~ (OtU't S.Til,-.YO       :r-r   .c1(("~P1£f!:)Al\JO At~O m~~ 'ITS ~r~CI\1"0..

 l!'t.f$ PlfA AGl~fW\q.v7, TJ.\US, 11t< corJl~N'"T Of Tr\{. 'PlfA AfB({~fr..11'll.ff
  t.uAS Tt4fflf.Af"Tflt B.l\l01~~u1H't 'PAell'i'S. 5f€; f?,!TT~ftfnAJiJ \/. S1Ai~.•
  I 10   S.w. '2 it 3q. '"' t-1.11. (n x.c2rm. A~O. "l.oos). ~rv. (~) CJ;~"t                                Tt-\'f>f.fAf t ft
  0;40'1-t'1~tOt1.,.,1"'11f\i:. S1A7' ~tl~ACH'f01HT$ 6J\JOS~""                                  Pl((f..' A~ff'"MfAJT'·
  OFJ l~t. SfA1£          f'.rlt'OTtit.,l\hJNC Ptm1vN('' t<.~aursr_nv" TW&.                                 ruttLroufi'f             ro
  Al.T fl. n\4£.    ott! Cor~ At.. :fvo~m f     MT' fQofl\ Trtf oflitD.T NP.L                  Pt ~A             '@,qf2(t:A..ru

  ~G>li£.Mff\17 Of ll-\1 ~TilffS wR1\Iftl cJ ·nu: Oc;>AOl \1 (:\H:~tll)i\1 r:"r!'JOT.~{,                                               t'fY

  0"1 .. lq·1.0\1. Oil Wt-\~Ht4f(l TM (. T~.rf.tl CDufif OA.I                  .rrs DulrJ Al Tfl.tt.D                    "rt-\(    Wb·
   l'MAl:JuQ&>mfM1 r.-ttOt.J6~ A                r• 1\JVI'J(     Pt!> "fu~(.'', (.Tn\c(fl. W~V T,_.i T(f/.JL
 · Cout f <;tA N'T t~to iH{ ~ttl1¢~ ., NUNC Ploft~rJC~' oa..Ovl Ofl.. 1J.\ ( tfrtH fOvt!l
   OM    Il~ ow.tiJ tAl~ 1"1t1111l-1'~tt       uJHfM !1'       Al1~tl.t.O 1:~oH:           OUtDtf\JAL JufJ6fnfAJr,
                  .· ..;·'-·:. ..:;:.·•'.·,·:   ·.              •   ... ·..       .·.   ~··

L--   I                                                                                                                .. -

           'T~us, utlllA"" ~HST~ANSPr:<J

                Th~ ~.r~r,'-IAL Paoc~. '2.ot1.t fl'\rs vrd.A't~S Pfr.rrrDtJ.;L.s ou£ Pf/<:t:fss
                cf 1-HCC:             fouQ\{f""TH__ (                          l"tltl}~ :V) ~NOM~Mi To 1tt't Uun'fO S1A'f'fS
            co.uslrrutTb~, A !\JD Aerr cl ~I 1 s "icT.1 t)N ~ THrtZ1'f'i~ ( 1?J 1\1\JO NT,.JfT A (0.\IHMT                I   Ql\)('(   C'::DtH   ,A~U{'S
           1-lAv~ ~u1tfll.fO I(.NOf.!f,'-lblV A,\10-VulVN'tflULI./ TNTO ~ Pl'lA b'\~.1\IV,Tt{ft.,­
           ~ttt.       P:>ru.uO                      ~'1 ti-t{ -t-ttlhlS o(                   tr\ th AfiJJ. ffM fu1                o/JC~   :n TS A CC~P1'f0           13"'   lH£
            Svo~£.Pl.~A                                    A~t;lt\J~Ll'i: ~~'tAl~,

              H~       s .w. '%J , SB ( 1 {1(. AP/l..- 'P'fhi Aljt}J,                                J   '(f );         a~,est«.n.L ~"'AT It - 5 s s ·~"'' ~tJ
              4'4')( f {. V _A~.· (\J!'lf.l\l~r \-\tl.f'Si 1                      1.-Ci,l. "~              P~t·)~          TOrtQ.. i:'l \f. $"iA1 ~ ,'-"t!$ $ vJ .'2,d'3M 1

              (Ttl(, RPP. ·(:.J4T W0l1t4 '.'14ta                         .:N:J (.)f; J.
              t.lftt, 't.\S- TH.f$ CA~4l. o~\!. Ll) 01 1tt<£. At;Q.ffMf'N~.S t~JAS T't>l~ $M'f't \JJt>ut..O

             0 'i:.tJRl"~ T1i~ f1!fl)j~b C-! ,__ Qf,~LLt.; t\I~~A.,.~~ F.r"-l~'Yft-..\(.., .l~£ {»JlV                                                                         P«OP'it
              !ld.~      'Of r"i~ ·r!lrA t                 codrtr; TiW -r >1.r~             Pt It' t~ ~~ P. ~0~1.:1\,j 9~urrs:s ;.vf'l~                             -r ;5    ?\ ovt sf.

             · Pf•-r··r-r:")~-Ht. t~m~~~·-"'fR. .,..!'\'£ ·"(fi;~At.·r·e~ir                                       .,    rou..o....J CHt.            ~(.~.l'fr'l"'''in'L OL~.tJ
               f){.'-.fl ~~" ;_J      ~Y1't".l f 9 Al'l.H(' ~1 M'£:                 ft{-...J•;:;}   01 TTfrf,)l!J'{ tt. '            s lf: E ! i-ii' )(£!1.$ rt-)0~- rl".:ttr"IJV!l'.f,..
               y,?O(If'Ou(l( AriT.(l~ ~i_(t,~l:a{i!>)(<.). ilc\( TlJ",~l. t~:Jc;Ji/.'T O!;.:J ir'f"'-J AdC ''h<"t(t.

               l~((' {or 'f I-\~ (.l!(,q             A ~ G1. 'f. f. v1't \f ,.....,. I   ,-,.,   ~ 11{ f\fr {: t<         1   1 H~     S.'l ~i~ . c i.?ul 0                 ~~T t.U,T"l';..f ..

               Dllr.hN        Ft ..,~vt   ·r1·\.iS Cf.ftt.~. Sf~~ ~..rr~tf~mn"-.1 \J, Sl~•-r, i '~O ;;;,w. ':l)J t "l~ ~i~i'l

              (ff.X.(~:'<:t1Jx"f11.~1oS) ( (f·ir,~t~ t1t?i'!t.                                            \! $.1/H't          .it33 5t
               Ctt.:'tH?(~ S.H!1t\JS                      f..TnH"fl rwr S1l'l'i4£                   c-~ ,;n-c t t.f"AL.C::>u!l.·!- C;.JO, ,.,..\1.~...1 A~ A

               fYif-ll''i'f~. O( -~t1~•~n~                    !'   ~J.lllll        f!.~ ('!f.;.l.O't't. 1 J,t.1AL      rcvrrr
               t.~llCf' lhJ'i· SoCtl ~t/;~{{mf!J1,T»( Q~.ftf.•JO'l"-.11" SHACL gf Ci'ffNi"fif'ffJ

                h) v._l!'i'>J. CIJih.N 11:fS ft,t.VflY4..1 Pl'f.A"),                                O~t.ll;\4      hH"' ?.!-!"!1{.        t:..   1r-~. !lt   it.:'l-t:-1{0 ,._, :-,U-t;&:,

               Dfl..    t\.ifTHO~!\W            A Ptffl t2_/!Q{~tJ..:,!J.

                f-.!~ ft~ • fi f] 11,1: 51 "'1'{ fj l fCp-.,,~ '·. 1\J~.V~0(*"

                I\J0l'1 ( 4           ~ tt: ;- t l:r f.lt.J{ R ()( 'r-~ :r { l. @..p, ...    ~If P VMON'f I C\ tf5,                  f.J\J   Pf7r.') ( fK.Qcfl Crf Li((~(}                 "\1,1\>\fr.J    (~'' 1 {
              TKTAl (()Ut1*t] 'J' ;.,} £ f"f142 0 4 0 .O:t T fOMAL , NON- N ~ (~(,")T I'A f'f rJ 1' ~ f' rl\ S

              :1,\jlO T\i(: N({(oOf1ilT'f 0 :P(.t~ ~f'il.l~Ar~ i6                                                    f\;'.J((fAJ "r\-\'f:       S.L~r"f. !\~<.).0

               APP f( l L~ "'f. f~ o\JO 1 t\ ~ l>..,l            t''f1 P.   (')£ A (("f.        (JfA   N (I(         •.~;(.   q ~..J ~ t' 'f :r- ~ ~~·   r::f. $. FI'J {)

               A.. cr.4'!   ~:;f.W. G--CJY !...\ fD~ "''T \.It~ '7 "-' 1          c::o.\.\    i~J!!ct: r i-\ f R..   ;w       "-'t"i "or>ftto,v, COtv1 1>-

                l!ft:O t;-,,n·"i,..4     <:;f.fjtJ A!J017Tf!NAl.                             ~~.,~N-~ti~Of.TAr,ft.) "f'fiM~").

                 r r:'i'-J 't! :V u,     f)(?fl-l'S~ s-Olrtt; \.J.t~w L.J"tt!lf 1\'\f PrMS·
                   i.CvfT{}h.t ~flfA!tS 1n< f)(~A ,t\iPQ~(:f'Af'Nr A·'i,) T~ Qov(~MDAI\/'f S'f'f!{t
                   TO       \/Fl(f.\f~ ~rs /i.-;rJI.li'l 'Pl.~A fCA'tl-\~t t.-\nv                                             TO    t;~.(,~Qc"-r' 'tf.\f ~EA
                    ~llfGAikLir1{ lt.'YL:! <;.f SwcJ6f.H $<•;~ TlY tt o \J. NvttJ \lufllt JttDtl                                  u~s. zs7,GJ1             S.CT .!.f:~J.;·~                                                            vitA'/.S lr1L 1tt.Ir.H...

 COu 1 rl(                               ff}A1 fUAt.     fAt: rs 5 u PPDRt!'!(c '~!S A~bVfErV\f.vf
 '1'~r-\A>1' ·p-\~ ~~t:-:r'JAl P\.~~ P.lAitC..#1.TN
                               ·: ~   .      -                        .
                                                                             \AJP.$
                                                                             .
                                                                                       fbft{A(~~£),1!··\oS,~NNvtll'!oJ~t\i"
                                                                                                             '   .

  J \J~1T! C£ C\tOCCI~ fOU \l.S HttC-f rotJ~ "f      ·nuo (. t)
                                                          'T A ll~ tH ltif: H.rt.H.. fDtJtt"f O~l}<,:1t -r~   T'T"\£   :rvt'ffS::sf'"   ~F ·:Su~r:r't:£
1•-JAi Cc;.,JQi~ A-PCb.f:-..(lf'0·1:UAL· ('Ddl\J$£L         'f'171: fTD~Jfla.. Pt!~WA!\Jf l!)

 A~liCl{ ),O${d)(t);f'l:'f.•\;S ((.H)~. C!i..r 1tH\fiH. €>00·CU:>v1~-
       ~'it{·•rr-r;:l~if.t\·-~-- }~rr;~~'~":Tit~.;-·:~~~; --l~fr~·~_:!47,~-r~At;t~-4,;,r 1"~1 ~- NY~'                                                                                                                                      ?,?i,   T~~(.;.
 ·-       C!!~n~'Jir(';t,7!f:fc·It~'~ v1~J~rhl-h';t5v-t)t~¥'~~-~,                                                                                                                                          fJJ:I.f   t~1f_rbv:fir ~-;.·..,r~·\£ Fr"&t\ib
· >-·6€·rH-~~-O\\$;!.~Jb ~'~·A)~c;;J~\iHt :!;d~~'fk~~J}~S :t"t; fil{ c~~tlhtVAL {~.. ~:A _ _
  --$~~~"~£-~~ .1 :VO -~~n~Yri~l~1' tl?f !w¢::- ¥:4~1;_~~~; tA.~ 1t fy'- (~ u) t.;'1\\f)i Af'r ;ct ' , ,
    ~/i(~.:r-r'r>~~•,-1 i~1..-S''\:~itf:.1.\ 5
                        P.o. 1'6ox 1'L:~.og, CP!PJToL srAr:rot--1
                        Av 5 n. i\1 • P~ )( A s 7 B 7 11
                    -   t'IOhl'D\(Af\ lf CPrHA !'".;.111.1 A 1-l A't' N ¥ S    Cfo    L'1 L£. w. C~.'-1 c 'E., Cl 'fl?. K..
                        L!Nir f() S1P.rf<; CoUR.'f o(~ ,O.Pc>~nLS Porz·Hlt. Frr::'r 1-1 C'TCC..Ci.JII'
                        on>cc€ Of--rri'L Cl'ZRK-1 F. f0VJMO.I-fre6EJ...'fi3,_n:LOCI\l6
                        fL,t')O SJYl fl c.SI RT PL A C 0- :1\.1 OS
                -- SDLTD'ru!C. (:?'fN1rlALO(HI