Court Opinion

ID: 4054343
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 05:06:21.27736+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:45.367970
License: Public Domain

C@O.£§SB> ~z)g v

QOM: C>ww|@§ ’D ¢Bw/H?)v\ REcElvED m
1041 f ed MML(TD oil l %1,,, \ couRT oF cRuwNAL APPEALs
w z law ma N¢>f\“A APR 1 0 2015
YOWmMz/\TX’HP)C€W
Abe| Acosta, Cler§k
Aj>rl| Lel/Lvt§ `

/\'bi' Cg\/W't’ opcft;/WM A’Ml-&J€ V€’{:€X@/€ ,
` P¢D‘Yo>( l/L@OB l,Cg\/) 1{70) §`WH)'/)
_ A\»~Yw '(Tew ~1%1"1
_ @E; m p/WCQ; CAAW.L;§%UNTAM ND,'Dv[/DC/O’L“QOC%L{Z*Q,
'Dg@u/ Cle/((L{ . l _ l
§/V\(/[@ggg{ pb( ghi/d 59 “M)ph'mvv¥"$ OlU@c/"Honz 1=b Fw'\'o@ bo+k H\e /L_”WM ®¢§HLOL@W)L '
@p'H`AA/l$ C@M’}j§oVMVAL»p(z}/L ;DLS+VHC(@V{<})“F'@WC CDV:HL‘?/`M O\/ »
» mad-4b `v[*g+vw@e»{~@u) @»?"WU CW~' w 1 \M; f
CSY"] WA/j ~ " ' sri/l @}YOVB._,§-} M A/W{¢ca]$')o|/)
W m'Q,`H/w @1/\0105@0{ SRUWM>U ““ 9 g V) x y or
V - _ . _ ' mw>\§§wlw w
-Pz>f po€“} Com/i<'/“l'lf>‘/)_ W‘" 1+‘”@ W&°S C°(p"}r '
g ¥ _. , CSM%JQC@;WM) /)»Mws @»@‘WG'
m V)M( ' . ' “' f -, " ~H/»},§ ij“L€f'
m lme (@M W »<~W¢… m
§@ C:@f \
CY|:\A)£,W` MAW>“
qu,@llc\)ezm%\)mm) § APPEM§ 99 'r€z
'G~m~c/ls QF- FAc/T,fz€coww@uv.o:now , /)eoWM'\¢ D§leé sz Po\‘ow;nj 0§@£;110{/1§ :

O*BJ¢>;UHON Tl> FWV\M&% SF FA_C/T`
~ !>}>\(cM/ML Q'eo?‘z bacwze 1b1/le lnv{(d”vm@wf wm gma'd»~ +'h@"(@/v@(
ap Pelov;g 09\£?'09@ c_{'¢>r"degrewc Pdo@ 0(5(2@'¢15@" W{L§ gler @5 @UHLM
agean ' dow wa/l@ &mv\rlm€l$ @F F/)M) Qowcw.snow§ OP uaw 3, @d'i.
Appl\cw/\T @b)'wk here bmwe fth §§ vuhm a cr]-h£¢j 'ow §§ 162/f
t OMS‘¢‘(/h,e MMM@L@<,@MZTl/IQTM 240ij @w§ff/s ~Hne. degree
viz m@§@ 15 F/>,

A[)Pil€aN @b);wf§ beam ne{’ one op 1416 PrMol/v$ (£.Mpl[mj'léw€
°’coml’W+thH€ ed ead/1 " ‘

game ' _e w 0 App 9 wmc/10 ~?Mrvv\ecl 1116
app\lw/WL‘§ ConVlUNoY):"Tl/v{§ 1961/19 01:&(11>&¢¢1)/11“ lwn?v:j mcth dep(w>
o~E/F-@/lm»\} 19 WMAJM( 1'1 “H'w, d'v\dyv»w/TGP§@WJFM 55 nl>_i_~{-l/\~e §§qu
‘I/M/ 1991/w (féu‘\/he Cm,vdL 616 Drppe@J/§ v\Jr'on 1 w%(.w\ecl W(l}mjr?
1111on d'./Kjwze 10@19113 ems/101le when err a?)%rvm/ &.§'f¢}@dw/ 79@/[,%1/

, , 1 , . , , `, _
Conv[ohov),{'l'l'\¢em ts vw @“H/w( umw bagle \HM; OV,@,

O’BJVCWM 1b Flwvsu@§oFF!>vC/T
AND wmau)§\o\\|§' orr LAW h ML 3»
ApplWTL 0 )`¢j§ h C@NC'¢USIQN§ S'F U‘<'\N b M`Z beam/156 `H\`e_ i;»s+an]L
M{,\LM£>~/) is m%dj W‘d’h imp/idb 191/1115 %l@ ground M&Arhll¢ i/L(>’I
§@c, 4(01)(1)@“111 while H.U’l , §ec;%@) allow +WS FW?/);eq nwf H.o') @/,/<(,;7¢(5”
4b ovvo')c/Z m §ed'j/SV)L{ lmr by e§h/v'li¢\f@ 'TMM£¢LM‘WS?§ now welsh
M’_wa//S WMI@/(Ol:€ ‘h>'H/l@ awhsz when ha ‘meJ 171;5'11/1.'¢?11/'\/ fmng
00 111/l dhov) 'WH`JL %p[¢mhow, §@e M@M 1240ng aj l -"7, -
jlxlg@, W\mw’f o%'gj§ low +Ws %f¢ issue 211 +ke 1110'7¢1(}p ;@j\o;,,j¢.,
hOI/:; h'Q§/EW b@@V) lt+|$$j"'@d 50 dt(`e£j:a,/y/;&\} W&Fpll;wj')oo‘h.{z DM _H/w;{_
mi$ 1391/119 WDM:{L{ mir @»p/M M/m/+ll @H&f OI/:r£jl@{;pedj Wa/§ over 0.,(/1€€
m WM@, MJ, 01 dwi 111911, mpp)zcm 1114 01%@1;,1¢“7
W”\'? WTLO\)%W\BJ `“ ”\ 51/“118€]'0\/1/100£911 Wa/S M;Mec) amf H/l.@ 515/mahan
fm `H/L~€ ,§

» ~1'/1/11\1 WTVM1; C@{m+j 'DL;HLZ]L 011/14 Pmpam 011101 110»1/15111111'11@
C/wm| denno 11011311/\@11112@¢0115 1011911/\14'/1@ 1111111 `D£.dr<'d Ce:ml G>Md
01 '\/oLuM/€ l’Z»ON / PAGI€ §{’L 011/wl 111@ JVD@M€W AM'.D §€HTIEM cz)
100va 011 V©LUM‘§ 1“101“111)14@€7;17/ '17> 111@/@)11(1'*€ Crcv;/uv{o/{

/\»M),DM/y 50 ‘1'1/\0/1 Q/11:610 Feé|m€/SEJ 114 peva\/n\j 11¢0’1 cm be QMUTED,
sea 111wa LMv 11‘7» '

120/speij ~\ 31/1/11/1»111€¢1 ,
1 C/1/w'1f1@4 Buv\1'01/1 /AWIL;M’(

/111@1-1 1111/1,.1#11%'1'11
2101 c/\A'§wq 1\/@1¥1)
1011/1?&{\¢11&<@5’)(/5€1“)

c¢/rz'n F[cm"§ @F €€2\/10§

f C/'mrle§ 1511/11'1>",-@¢)/1>11¢01111§1119114 umw ()111111111 <):Pp'ij 1111 w
mmr copd, 09 1111 />(Ppu@ww owch “rz> @~vmae DF er,
WCDMMMMW, Am> QMBTMNS;M HAW¢S cw\)§ cc€c@@ CP°»$T: _
com/mmi WMTA+P»¢@(TL<)N) Wm/, 1101/led DWA)L;M@)J(T bo+k 11qu W. 101
COv\/P1 UQTYM/l$ C©Mjf\j (10V61V&.L¢p(:w@{b1§1r101C(@f[/,;]TJ\A/L§ C@M`hq 1 (’¢0 1 '{?)0$(`
m @ 1>0%,/11)¢111» @1211437117-¢ fm W( 1b Dt;¢nH/MNW mm COM+%
1101 1914 14%,1\1)§~1111 (T>w 91 m w 1125 1111 1111 ,,FAW;/ amf

VGF%