Court Opinion

ID: 1044034
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2013-10-08 02:04:55.864334+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:48:22.444686
License: Public Domain

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE
                               AT JACKSON
                                    April 7, 2011 Session

 WILLIAM B. PENN v. BOARD OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY

                Direct Appeal from the Circuit Court for Shelby County
                 No. CT-004970-08     Donald P. Harris, Senior Judge

                   No. W2010-01250-SC-R3-BP - Filed April 25, 2011

                                            ORDER

       On June 9, 2008, a Hearing Panel of the Board of Professional Responsibility
suspended Mr. Penn’s license to practice law for three years, with all time suspended except
twelve months, upon the condition that prior to reinstatement Mr. Penn pay restitution in the
total amount of $36,040 and also pay the costs of the disciplinary proceeding. On December
1, 2009, the Chancery Court for Shelby County affirmed the punishment imposed by the
Hearing Panel. Mr. Penn appealed to this Court from the trial court’s order, and the parties
argued this matter before the Court in Jackson on April 7, 2011.

       Mr. Penn asked the trial court to review the Hearing Panel’s decision pursuant to
Tennessee Supreme Court Rule 9, section 1.3, which provides that a party dissatisfied with
the decision of a hearing panel may obtain judicial review by filing a petition for a writ of
certiorari in accordance with Tennessee Code Annotated sections 27-9-101 through -114
(2000 & Supp. 2010). Tennessee Code Annotated section 27-8-106 (2000) requires that a
petition for a writ of certiorari be “sworn to” and state that “it is the first application for the
writ.” Recently, this Court held that a petitioner’s failure to satisfy these requirements
deprives trial courts of jurisdiction to review a hearing panel’s decision. Bd. of Prof’l
Responsibility v. Cawood, 330 S.W.3d 608, 609 (Tenn. 2010).

       On February 9, 2011, the Board, citing Cawood, filed a motion to dismiss Mr. Penn’s
appeal for lack of subject matter jurisdiction because Mr. Penn’s petition for writ of certiorari
filed on October 8, 2008 was neither sworn to nor contained a statement that it was the first
application for the writ. On February 15, 2011, this Court entered an order taking the
Board’s motion under advisement. On March 8, 2011, the Board filed a motion seeking a
reconsideration of the Court’s February 15 order. Mr. Penn filed a reply in opposition to that
motion on March 30, 2011.
       On March 31, 2011, this Court granted Mr. Penn’s request for additional time to file
a supplemental brief addressing materials in the supplemental record and ordered him to file
such brief, or a notice that no supplemental brief will be filed, on or before April 22, 2011.

        We have reviewed the record to determine whether Mr. Penn’s petition for writ of
certiorari satisfied the requirements identified in Cawood as necessary to confer subject
matter jurisdiction upon the trial court. Because Mr. Penn’s petition failed to conform to
Tennessee Code Annotated section 27-8-106, in that it was neither “sworn to” nor included
language assuring that “it is the first application for the writ,” the trial court lacked
jurisdiction to hear and decide his petition.

       For these reasons, the Board’s motion to dismiss Mr. Penn’s appeal is hereby granted,
and the trial court’s December 1, 2009 order is vacated. This Court’s March 31, 2011 order
allowing supplemental briefing is also vacated. Because the sanction imposed by the Hearing
Panel exceeds a three-month suspension and because no appeal was properly perfected, the
Board is directed to file a copy of the Hearing Panel’s order for review by this Court in
accordance with Tennessee Supreme Court Rule 9, section 8.4.

        The costs of this appeal are taxed to William J. Bryan Penn, for which execution may
issue if necessary.

       It is so ORDERED.

                                                         PER CURIAM

                                             -2-