Court Opinion

ID: 4047373
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:23:25.427724+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:38.351024
License: Public Domain

_\)\M \§LY>\\K§L 004\14~-00\33~<;€< §§ THE L§.\R \1\<0€
LQ>_~_Q>"] 14')< ?e.an ;1,, fmi
”\w§~"~ -» "’E§’:§‘;z wm ~ . /m>€ \AL§OSQQWM

`F€.-" Y 0 7 2015
4 _ § \\€\0'€ 40\\\ U> X_\\\.T\;wem& ' "11111 2111
T`3xnr£-: sma, '%'exas \ 1

"4§@1“4’\‘€41;‘14\€1€\"$®>&5@ Q_\\ moa 0€ 334 L’ HJIYY"‘Z'E,Y§;,R
4\§\_°1_\§ L,GW\§;_ ”\`_\~k\`_ /$Y?e\\am& :U\z "Ur\a A'be\}€_
Cmv\a Nuw\mj\m; QAMQ¢¢ Ax\m €\e lam Ps\b£lom£h

1\\3 `L\EK\: F__NC 41

/1(§1?\:_14_0~\& u>m\x Q\c\n… Tk\;< Lo\)v£ mpo\\o<,o`w\:\

.A,
m C\0\14 331 §0\14 L\\L ”1\1 \U¢L.Lm\ QMM 104 fm
1;&\\¢00_<>,1<\_\ t\n_o_ /-'\SS+_ DL$&ML)C /U'tum&q AL,U_;¢, L£`s
A,‘_<¢ve_¢_.or\ wm m ¢mPr/>pe/Li_v Cz,Pp/,¢ 410 L_a/w
O_.CF\LQJ\Y\RM ¥jr\_L U£C. §§ Q_(Pm()v €N\\<\UMCLW\M/ul' G>f\_»
Lcm_§_sp_ v\)0 432 mm QL gun iam QL\@… %v\;smb(<),

w mm \"; 35 cm w emmm, am£\w/\ _SM _&Q 4 £`eu>m(
"Puv\\$\r\nlg\a \M\MA \R ?>S §Cx\ °CD HM_ W\&X\vv\w\/\Rm`u\\mg,
I\& Q\_ _SP_Lm\A A_Q.£\ru QU;QY\M.

' ' go
Sm;\x i/1\$_.;0 `D‘st gi hummw max FY\;& U\ _\__0&1'<‘_‘0¢\
\\30&;@_ <_\.<\ 01 \\<\4:31£10\{\ 904 \\AU,Q `T,Via_,,( Jc\c\)\wu ¥€_Peu£¢£
mg\)m¢~\)¢; O__@c\w\m\.,g B{\L .`Lu_e.qa,\ usa 0€ mae 400

@g'.m'*mx \:0\ O_nM£umL 10 Oldl `Lr\ \ch\ §CLLM\ Om¢\_
O_mr\hmu"e_ 110va CA_ \Q\lr\k €_ML lam L¥_L \&_Lcsa\ €__@€edh.

.f>'~c'.L. "K-’P~_ \/ L.,c>g"') ’\>_<4 ;)¢Q L_lm, ac>.as ' ‘\>519.~+
` Q’_ -
L\NSU_M> §§ PLQ‘QW LB_A_Q\».. £\u_ L¢_c €Jr\ amcme 01€
\_g.m wm w 3000 0\; Wmm ama _§mc.m \;11»95(9
1441\¢4\4\ _%"\>@_C\C\Cm\q &uke. llam\\u C.m\;\/`\¢Le/A 04 two der\i&
film ¥X\DJ»I\ O_ S‘ch,UL _§u\\ @€,\45¥\.\4 \u\\i$`/\ab\@__ L)r\M/\ L€.L'}.Icr\
\’A. ISCCL\ \M_ ex\uLLA \<\\_\. €_Ymr\eous \r¢rs;@(\ 04 ah Umm¢¢

D&WMUM

_‘»e.e_z`cz\/ 4_,0€°\ 1333 \_;M__C&iof\ 4;1: wa mar §8`.0\`|1)§

` ¢\;_m`\<\g BM_ M¢Mwm& Y\'\P<$L §§ Ec€a,\, -
5,¢2_ R_-R v. 509'1'9_3.~»‘1 l_m_ w>-. vs

AD@QLLMU_, r?\v;ai~. wm `Cx<_xe_ i:_u ('-_§ML_ L&l,e,&a.§ €J/\hlal_r\`co.w».o,d~
5£@_ ~Y§#R\f. E`M>W 'P_‘l.: lay \__`\r\¢r ‘{,-.-H

4 E]
_Dw;mv m ”Yum;hm& YHML m />\_vmw
\N\ul_o_ mem _Q£alemm& th th `(L)mv$ H\M w €V\‘Am»;@~'

pung gm £Mui m +wc> "Pre,\)fcu_s C.onu£a&ion§ wax 9mqu-
.Q+\MN +&\n/.A QMQ&[LL/ \Q;( ~C).(n¢@, samm,c)zs:om>< .

__<,~@_ R“R_\/. §e>m ?_‘r-3')\¢) a/MLH/m
\ru_ acme £\M_ w cms v@ewdml m £ Tc>£ Qim @/Vwi.

._Se_a_ ?&9¢_ LL e£ \8. ®l}:.&fdcmw; A(l\.r§u BV£L€

C,.
)°L'POL\LD_M_ '¥_\<\_\\n_.,o K\)cl_l¢\ gmi/d P_§Qon& Y<_Sewxdu/l O_(J.L€. LD,Q_)

‘\'_D \m_U> 041 \t\§g fl§imvu¢u (\_i&`\ng. __C_Aa}£ \/. wh£éa Q$`q 5.\,¢1.3£.
375‘ f_TL)<. Ao(>- For£ wovH/\, \QQ£, P@£. r¢£’JJ', webb \//.$+Mg., la
5.w. 3a §03 L_T¢)<. g»;m. /-kPP.Qooo] Wc\its\/. _<+a£¢_,- go 5.\0,34
5L, LT¢>, AP.O.-- ram wmm, QDD\, QMLH\¢_ Q_HW\W( w 94
woman \<\B\x¢.r.\@ im C_mwv&>¢u \/L sum q@<.s.w.z.._\¢.ims,
C>~n.\u_ 133 \r\;w\ w town cl L\\;r\§, e_\m QLWL mae amc
am_ o,n.§£_ \_gw, i_r\$m \NL%& wm mm acude
\_y{\ wu&, _‘§~@_,a_._ fPL\_@L \\a r`»&l§? (dMA.QA_\ BV`Ie,c~. d _l:(/l£d`
~` ` ' apa C_\o_m\u- SL\»<)L¢)
\\_1\_1_§.1, O_CL$~L. LUA,L.S\;“\JU\::&:S`\“\; a mac GK;D\FWX cbg a*
\'__\r\_n_ _§‘cCLi. €_‘\'\J\.D~r O_Dr\ui(iion to a c".lwé

A:?\§:,)D:M»le(:mll UJ\/\,L _§&Ai_{J/lc.£_ \\cm ’l`;b (SO\ UE_(LL:.

_ '\\` . v
~ mm &&wl;m \»@@_Mq 05\¢, +_\m acme § w\/\wn
` BM_ m\.¢.qc&LO/\; $ek w `u\ ‘c&\;_\ vv\.,o&iu/\ w .\.\u’ce/\\/M.Q¢
do CL rpm@e,g$;omw\ €_V&\Uai[©r\ U HM_ Lll/§A)J _S€l:_‘®u&
`L<\, >;\\o, ”Pe)<\us com _§&wwe<, \;,L@s_v:) am am Lcw_` U»ar
15 CL(>£>\IQQ,.M@_ +Z) j¥n,tc _la¢`/ 106/cnw %/).aj 61/\;. FZ_)/)r;sl/.e¢é& u/z.{_@!
/2,35 am“ in which !h£§ Acmé wi// cleo/ng _§u 1bth emma
UX': 0/’)7)< .L$ cl _S.+aie. __\a,`/ §c/on PUY)BM/€ whim /é?.l$§;d/ amf
O_<:»'L,\k v\)oé 102 F€,LL§¢J H) €!\Wm@ U/V)OJ'/w _CM/f/:,._{a// \Q/On‘{
Ur\¢L/m 125 35»(@} 193 CL jccc)n¢! clara

T_&\L _S+wt/_ U(/n.nm‘ make £L Uf\Q/afz L¢'/ /¥l' u_l€ :“\k\-o \u\‘uJ\ (\_cm)v+_ €J\)\Dv » Cl/\/\A 0vast its Ai_scm,b[on wham
L§-_ Lw\ \>r<>(>P\'\H §/_\\a, Lcu,¢)~, ~\~c th 'CCL£}.`. "L'_r\ whith
ma_qm:mm, m guam m kemp/ul cl dam-scm w W%

C_.€><\SEAQAL_A `\_\(\ C_¢owcd~ , LF\ l_E-`SM §§ 'vacu`l[n$ _ L£u,.,¢ f)\'l
B¢\o_ _\ce_\/;e,wl~j auemr?d(. . '

' __\)X`Uul M,
L§\mu, \-\m; (\\emu\ hamm nmu H\ing `c_r\, TCX[A L,w,.,» find-
rP\re,uu\;ke_L C)w\,u (\_mwé wi&\r\_ `\Lsr\`séicl:tm\ Q\JQA a ulm‘nw\
c\__u_se_ §§va me+.‘c;lr\_¢z 0~\¢& a.ew@c,e.'m_°¢ Cc-,v\ liL.e`q¢I SQM
5a_ ‘N\`n_¢_u_ \/l sw,te_. \\q S.w.$; 804 C m .ce. A<>r>,¢;)o@l).

. ` '\`/‘€Mc:§. ' .
\)\_\A<:» mr Q<>\`ma §§w m qua C@\J\+

CLN\L *c\¢\n~ CLQ©DL(\SL<\\@,M; \=J(~ CiQ@em fl_€:&t§ra)e,q/ QMA m,L/p,

~'k§¢\o_ 03va ‘CL>\IV\Q Q,®r\w\/r\m$ Jc,\\a L`_LLL‘)Q,\ S€mi\%u_/ atm/l
CNY\M €3\:\/\»_/\' ‘(£,\l¢,§ ¢§LQ./rv\ %R€A

` 'P\ Q§.QMW m mw
L.\CJJ\/vu`_e_ \_JLL B`£,&c>¢ \/;&
L_)t'\Uch ~C‘cu££; \AAaI\ \Z.(¢\ls _ma.£/ MA__QQLS'

4§ .§ gm