Court Opinion

ID: 4050502
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:16:27.34234+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:08.449233
License: Public Domain

•.                                                                      _, RECEIVED IN       @b,q{O(?-tt-\
                                                                  COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

                                   ~hat
                          This document contains some
                          pages       are of poor quality                     AUG 17 2015              ->-

                          at the t1me of imagingo
                                                                            Abe\ Atosia, Clefk
                          Q\\l \-~~s f{\CV\~~vtS Ovv~

        \J (e_ S ~A,\-     \\- \<:, -\:- \-Q_ GoVII .

        L     CA\ So    re_lv\~st- (\0\-) Cl_ ~"' \ ~0-vt
          ( (L lQ_\ V e_ \ \- ~b. ~ \.t...l I \- , • '( f'\_tvvlL't '-"'

     ~ ~b   Q_ ( \-- \-- (\)   ~    r<\. f(_,(_\_)..A. ( fL

     1\. \ '\ d-~'\ S I

      d.- \:,b S pr ~so"' (U ~ ~
        \ ()\.)(_ \"' ~t _) i'f-!513 51
                                                              f   ~ •   •
                                                                                                                       \   .
•

             l~ \\\~ (.,0\)R\                            C>\r CR'"'L~L.r-.)~\ \-\pp~Pt'-.S
                                                  ~\                   (\\)S\L~

                         ""I_~ Rt_"., ~~~\_\l...\              \       Q"''\ r{\~ C..o ""'-'-\:to, ~ L\1.-d-a<>S" -d.-"?>'\- 'c)
                               Lv ""'""- ~ ""~i J •                ·               ..

                         t>·~\"L\"La~ ~\)\l ~R:~·\
                                     0~      rY\(\~t)~~~s

    \ CJ \\-\ ~                    (_\)\)\l\      o~ c:...,\L~~~rl~\.. ~PP"~-~s
                                                                                        '

    r\J \) ~             c'J      rr-. \:..:S J f \:l iYLr\- rr-.. tt...\..-'-' f !L v-1 b   'oe..\ /\~ {) r~:>:'>t~
    ~~\J,(L-s ·\--"vJ\"!J --~JL~\~~ .... ~r :V\t\Q_ ~\\\::>~\"~
     re.-   Ct :,\> "'   ~ ~~ .
                                                           -e
                \1 '-..                                     I
   t \..V <;;; \''                                                                     '1 '.
   <;'~'""'\. ->,J ro') \'1~ 1\S '-<;) "\"'0 '/IJO\'J \ t\s '.~ ~~ <::--W) '\">"" <:\j
  ~fl\"'Jflf)J"YJJ "\ "d~~ o ~~ --s. s J"'Go ~. ~o ~ o'\~ J ~ ~v.>'\\ '\"' \i
        . o"J VO)~ '-1'-1     \_.   \r-v:J ""\J'O    "" " ~S"> ~          s;; ~ -\ '_     \'"VJ"'-.-\ \) ~~) S'.~
  ~~~ h""~                          ""1. • "<1'::\\\;IIQ S"JJC\""'-\      hu.. ~\          'o)cw J?t..\-\J''!1j
                  - v ""';\"'...,., \,."". " \)  J s ';."\ .l
                                                          ' S Y\. dJ ~t)        S'YJ~'Xl'\ ~\.AJ ~ Q               \J ('\~'J
       ~ \.) ~~ \J\'Oj 0~-\                  c; \ ( ~ "'-"" -\) <'~IJ    \'J ~ )\c:; \ ~ Q~~              -\q. \J ~~Y)
  s"'o ~'lJ \ ~\\'             ""'13\ -JC 'S'c:;oJOJd' 0 4 ~~ ~.w"'OS \-$;"'~:> J ~
 0 f'~'-\ -s_ oS"'~~. . \\ Cg; 5 o~\' J"'O \1 G ~··\-v'""~ ~\S \1 O] <;;x~f'j..~l
~ -\_~Y\SJY'-0 '-'G'.,..~()\~S'.,)Y'': Jod\0)Q -\""0 "'-\~'-~ c:; ~ "\J"C)
 ~'"1~J,s~~ a'\"' ""\":i'\-\- r 0 ~"--""''"?                SYl\"'       s~6J~j s~~ ~'--' ~a
  'd\Jv:_'\   o~-\ ~"0 ~v:_~-...rod <;Y)~· -\'YJ~-\ ~\J:_J~ 'J\n~~s-1.~ J~
      \JQ\:\_<::lu.J                    \.
                           ~\.N ~ \)C\~J S'~-\ ~~~~"<) ~\v'y                                      -:1            , -\)C\~j
       s-:~\ ~~ ~u)~\J<\;;\ .~ ~                        cs o"'"~-\~ \\"") ""O':\";\{)(} <;"Y>o<\'))\\ """
      ~ '-1.<:"' <>.l,. s '? "{'>\""\'0J h\\JoJ \~ s \ .>,_'11~ ~'"'~ "<>1 ~ '."'-' \'() '." \J~O
               c::;~)0.0)'\'1~!\S'.'l o~~ ~~ "0-\~\d'--N~'J ~oo(\ ~q,\"J c:;'Vl'-\
  "\J~'J      u"' ~             ·es'd~-\ ~)()"~ ""'\) ~"':\\Q1~'\J~'J \J~o s~J"-~'J o'\-\
      ~~ ~-\') ~ '\-\_V'C() ~ j (\~ J               vvJ-z>) d(;' S   ~S    r \('.   ~   '_"2__
                                                                                             \._.'-J<:;;(y')aj   ~~ 'J ~ (\
       JoJJ-o -o~-..o \.)--1. <;Y>'-\ -\J 0 ~'1 s'-~.l.                         ·oJ~'\c; V\C: .:JC -u(;~~Jj"DJ
 -c:;;;w      VJ          <;<;uJy~: ~S\ \J0'..""\'.\7JQ. S'>-\"\                     Jo -v=;C\dY<'O ~l
                                                                                                                               ~-
                                     ~<:;\:l'J -3s 0  "    ~'c. \ "-
           ~ ~r\"~ o~~ o.\\. ~ro'V"~s. ~r re..~e..-0., '3:..~ (A~~\\:-,\:>"
           ~\~CA.\. ·\~~S l,~\) (~ Q\CAl~                      U..   \-\e_c.,,;~ ~ \c"-,) r~~ vf\)1\. ~.t-:
           'oi    re.v'r'·"~          !"C'\Q_   ~ ~ f~\l'...&_       CA..   \((.c~r~ ~ r (e..'\l~eW.
                  \\\~;>r\ A\-c..c"- \ "~ (""~,\)A \p ~ \;"'t_ \) \ S \ II v\ C:.\UV...
           D.i\~ 'oe.:~"~ \" ~(:..s\)1\. L. ~\J~ (\~ m.tt.0../'.S ~ L~A\-IAv~ V~trl\.
           L~\i CA~'V\SQ...~ \~,,S> l~\)fT {)~ \-~\ <::> Q0\.Li\- (A \\\1\~·~\~ \\- wQ,((.J      "L      ~'.)!"~    S\.':>   ~L 0"Q... ~ p~~ ~r           CA.   Cop~
           o~ ""''l \ ri>. ~r"'"' \'nt. s \-c...~ \ e>,.u:. \ , 'o fl\f} \ "
          (\o\}.     \\-\\:::, \~ ~q_ ~ ~\.\.. \ ~Q.. ~" ~~ t~"'~~"tb~ .,G) ·\"&.~~~ ~f ~\)"~s ~r (e_\\~~-                             Qr()~\k~ ~\t..
                                                                                 1"-
          ~CLM."'"'~\c,J'\ Q.,)\~liL               CAS     0-~""~U-..'5;>J (A. 51::1 r~~e._
         N\l..~orCM._~""'"' \)~ \~w C''¥\."~         u. :>, fJvf (t.""'\""'tr ~r~\- ~'""' ~
         G..L\-'""'~ '" f"~~t{,_ 1.- ~ ~~~"...~~ ~ fe...t~r~ \\)Lc..\.\~"' ~
         '""'~\. Qr~>JL \S~        CA.\\ t,\U:\N"S Or-..6. -s_              Qf '\:)\)\~~ \"'-l. ('e._~rters
         '\e..c\)r~ ~ \-\.\\ ~ c~\)(\-..              'i{_'.,~ \-~,s c~\)f\- re..~s. ~
          ( J\      ~Q        """   \)F~\l, ""l c..,\.cl'\""::..
 ~\j\.~ \-~\s c~\.) r-\- (_()" \\.""'q_s ~ 'o~ ~-G ~~ 'c\,"~ ~
     m ~ \Jv...~ c..J",Q..s 'U~ \I\ ~~f.i:>YZliL.
         \Y\,5 \ s, '""" Q.rl(.Q.... ~'b.\\"\)'"~\.\~\" \-\~"'""5~"
  "orLCAA.~ 'n ~ ~v--'o\:zc.:.~ l
          1\ ~ ~r i(.O...; '"'""'\ Q£                o ~ o-£>~<1.1 o.., ~vlL&\\'0" ~"' c.._
Stv..-u~              'ii)\.AJ    ~-so         C..c:.\:>r\- "'"'   ~sR_                o.Q-   d-e.c~L>j J
\\    ~:,q_ ~G L\i '(_                                                                                           .
:s~
         ~ ~-\-""-'" v....._ .~-""
                                \  r.\-
                                   ~ '(.)..-
                                             (         ~     \Q\.A
                                                           \.J         \_"\'
                                                                        l...)L\.,e_~e_
                                                                                         ~\ .\_l ' U '
                                                                                                  L
                                                                                                          (A_
                                                                                                                   \
                                                                                                                5\(-\,\e.._
         j     'pQ.. 10"-~    rQ_ ~(Of.l..\.J~ \ ·~\A~ [A.(L ~V\. ~)'LS ~ b~ (
\\re_ ~~           ('.o\-   S>'v-\::,~~l.:~u. ~ h\)~~ e-~-v ~~·"' . \ ~\ .
Lt. au. 6::.. s "'~ ~ s         "'fL. D"""-        of "'- e_~\'ll            UN:- o'~' \c\ \o\CA"'\."        CA..   \Nf~"~\v.;\ c...o".:0~c:~~\u" u.,'\\ D'""'\- uf'
      (e...\-(11.\~ ~\\\)1'\ 0~ f(.(Jo (\.""\"~ \\J ~~(L \~.:i-~s \0-.A.~Q_(S, c"~~\
       \~~'¥\\ \)·,~:\Ct\\~"'S ~~;~r \\) N\.~ ~r~~\ ..,"'-~\- \e..v..~ vf ~"'
      CA" \"-J~~ ~C\.\\ol"'"\ \ "- ~ ·\-\-.. C<::>'l.>r T      ~"'"'>    CA.   S.~S.IL "~ ~~\-"'.\                           ""'1. Clvv-.
                                                                                             . '\ 1-..cw-
     (ASV,~"'~ li.to0 ~ ~r~~ ('e..~\~~, \~ CS,\le_                                         t"V"'.~C..Q.... . '"'Nlre_) '1 0v.. 'IN~\\ \e~r" \"'-(A,~ ~\)\A h..u-~ e.. be.Q.A.

     ''~'C ~ 'pi \\--..L ~\s\r\t-\- G~\)f"\-~'\A~~l, ·\~Q..(t../1~'""" w~\\
     \I \r \A.S\-.J- ~wr 6\-;"~ ~c.C\~ WIA.~ \)\~ \u.\-tl~
      b) ~' ~ ~\ ~\1\~\- :)v-..·~:J, ~-
         Lc<..,\- ·\A.S ·-..1\)\)f"'-. ~~~\ ,~,J'e ~6 ~\S \~ ~~SfUJ~                                                          ·
      'Qr~-Jt. f'f\t. ~be.         C\   ~ y1~ ~\"" ~~v,                        '!__.    ~-

           ~~~ y...._..,':: ¥.-.\s . L             \-.CJ.."<:..   \-..-""t>""''- """} st.\:Q tr ~ ~. . ,.,\
      \CA.~ '" \~Q_ \ ~ '{a....USs ~ 'v~ 'ot~ \1\. C1J.J (,QJ~\e..'¢:,. --s_ V.J\o..,o
      W~\- ~" S\\~'A-\L~ .~'e_,~lA-\ -.J\\:}\~\no"s o~ \-\--..CL C...0"S~h\\\l" .
                                                                                                                                  '
      ~       "">'\ N._\)Q..c-.., CM f 1A 'S              ~ f 1:'>\ll. ~ in~   \"       "-0(~ Ct. ,         l.-<> \ItA S \ il "
     \oL\.~UA \"J,:'t!. \-~L (e_~l.:)rttr.s re..Cc(O w\\\ be...
   -e.i.. \-r~,z,\~ ;,- r "v..\\, "~~ '-~"'-' . \\ 'S\1, 'Ic.v..r Sf(.\~ 0 "e... ~t....i'::>"'"· (
   1..~ ~,.., c... \\!A.( \-i-..~ v:;-,._ ~ 'lv..\1 t ~ ,....e...vif \:,Q_e,... 1> ro\J v- ~ b~ o~e.. .
   \\,:s·                         .\
        '    Co\) f ~     ~ S tt vJ "'-1 S S \          ""f\~ -\'!::/"~ (~'c    1'("\Q_ .

            \0 \)Q_~'") f'l"\~~~v..~\.1\.~ (e_\\ ~¢, \:,"j \~ • \\ ~l>.},d..) \-"'-L CA'o ~U-- 0~ CA. C\(!JJ...( 6.1'-~
 (A~f....'\"'CA.\t._ (Q.....,.,~ o-,\- \c..W v--1 tA. \IJ-_Q_f \J p(-tL\J..Q.(S 1 \?J ;)..1 S.W.
                                                    v

  ~~ \()?:, ~ 1 l2,?;,0\.- l\D (_\e_ ~.\'\ 1\~) lDr\~~.Qr ~ t h (e._ c.b\'""'Mb\CA.
  YY\t..b.. .. L"'r. ~ \Ct~ Go\~1\tA~ J J._q{) s~·v;).3>d ~C)'\) d-.or ( tt{.. d..t.u"')

l Dr\ ~. . \)r\) C..e.v\.6)N \)~~ \-\...w\ 'r...CL \:)..(" S'" ~ (.-'::> ""fQ..\ ·CA. N'\\,... \s.W\cJ\ ru_;\--
· s lrc..\-t. -eA.., \.0. .'-\ "\)'""!:::> \J .   S'- "f..~ ~0 ~z. .:. u.\         ~-:;.. b \-.     G<:>\l r t-   ot ·
   (AQ~Sl~\s [A"\- \Q..:i,CA.~\(~CA. l ~~ b Su·~ .. 1~                                      d._o1   1J.\ \>. L\e.~, -
   ~f '"",to..~~. ;)..o;:,l) (_ 0 r\~, {)[otQ.R...~~"~ , \\1\. CAL\- \ s ~'~"''..,lsW"\u. \
    ,.{! \"'" Lx> "s~, \"'"~s e,. 6. . . .\1 C-~I'>J"\1 {" \ te.l o.....~ r{Lq,"'"' ~~~
     'n i \ c-.v:> • S\ "'\e__ e.'k I     1\J...IQ    (\ck(_r ;..... , \\!>P- \ ~ \l1} (or;!:)·~ M.®...~1"_'))

                                                           6
J..)      \ NL     \)\ 'S\<'\t-~ Go-vf~               J \-'f-.L   M~ ~"'-~\<.,.,\""-\ D; s-\("t~t
       w'\-t\-.. \" c~f'C".'""'\ c\)\l"~ \~ vS\~ b"'"\ .pr(l{)(l.f ~~ r\s6\L-\\\)-'"·
       \ha... c\\s\-r\~ t,o-v(~ \ s 6' 5
           \- f\S\-..J
       o·~ ~~ c\- \ " t....CA"' -::,~ "~ , C..R.- d--.~ C) 5 - ~::, '-\ - d.... ~ '~~r\-ct..~ QC\.\.~ct..~u...\..,~S ~"'C/\;\- 'or~""~~\- o.b~"'\
       ~ M, "b C..-eJ,_rr\CJ\.~~ ~~ ~'"" ~~ t~.

           Sr~ s 'J f> s_.,.~U ·
         3 ~d.. C\e.)k U\ ~~ \C\··""\'1)
                                   N'\.      \

           '~' r~)        ·1._    'o~S ~ \-'r\l (e..f~rw..s
       {!Lt.:,(~. ""~              (<1..Q<>(\V       r~...\v~ ~~ be.-;."~'""        \)f\'i,l)" . 't   (_a.r_

                        'v\:, "" o r \  ""'-"'"'" s .Q, r
       ""'\ C\) 1\.\c.- t-\-
       \ f~X..f" o\             -       ·- \ l\. \               \...                             .
       . ~       'r s ~ ~ \~:>''\"~ r'U::i. '"'. f\a '""~e... ~v L -t_ be..~"
        ~~~
              CA. Ce ~ i 0 r M(Q.. S ~ o.Q \-)...Q... f-t.(Ja r -\efs rcz...co r~ .
                                                                        .    .

                                                          l
··~)               t~( \-~o~                              1
                                              [e_CA..'i:>o" 5    o~ 6e.J·\~\ u-G CA.C..( c~rf'v"-s, l:.. (\\.u
           CA c....\-.~~\ sv:,\      \"         c..~~[A,\_t'U'01'\"\ c~\)r\- ~ \[N...J                \\- ~ 1
           LO\.v.S C:J ~ o ~ '(;,~ .) ( \) b e.F\- r<\. C..C...\ v.J e..        \[ s
       . C..O ~o..\c~0"~~               J      Cv~CA'\ C.:o\)"\-~ ~\S\.f\(k G\~.Jv... J ~~ Ca~
           l100r-.\-~ ~-, s\{\G\-              C<0~r~ ~ \-~~d-..~"~~"'" 6-:..L\CA,\ ~~" s\r~"'-t ·
                  ~ s~v..~\...~ ~ \"·~~"c\;0", ~w(L\)~                                    \)"   v. ."ow,..., ~     r-NL

        CA..~ \"-!L. \;. "'Q... C>~           ""'\   \\'>..;, ~"'~u "'   \~\- \""L {> re.&~ ~\"-~ ~ 0 ..~tJQ.
        ~~':f- r\u~(Af'6_ ':>'0" \                        S     CA.   \)"- \),..._~ \..\~ ~ \l\~?> c.;,~'\\ f~h;T
           c~~~\CA\"\.. \ ~s "'\~ '"'~-\- ~\ACL. ~C. "L W()\.S 0°~ o...\\~we...,6.
           ~ G\..f{>-,...:\- 6~~ "~\-k~"[)•

                 I..~          ~-v
                                                ~1 D~\ S\~v..\
        \)r,S~"· ~r
       &. C0          t- ~v..lA~\- "'<(..\~ \" ~·n (o f c\ -C:'r"' "" \-y..e..,, 5
                                                                                                            \A

       \                                                                                  \-ex \ o..W \\lor tv'} .
       -          ~o\'bJ       1\c\Je.rv-..'dlf          'L ~v~c         0-   ~:>\'-\    L     ('.z..c.e.·, \leA v..   Lop ~
       o~ ~~Q_ re..c~r ~ ~

                                                                  8
b)    . \ l\Q... r~co(~ ( GOA. ~~c.-\- t>"                          rf\Cv\1

     \e,\)fL\S. ·-s... C.AJ"c.,\\)\.~~ L    ""(1\.\J~ (S~) ~\0\.)"-~ ~'kCA-\- \~~~
      U~\\e.. N\ c"0 r\-
      ~~~ 1:'0\- ('\A.\Q_ er c~"s'~ \--h,~ r-1'~\-\\l". \~s ,._,oV\\'l"
     ~~(~5~~" ~ \-"'CL ~\s\r\.c\- l~'-lf\ ~~~tJfL
     \s ~~~o'-N~ Q(o~~v..r~:>~.\~~o".

         \e.,~ o..s ~ SV\\""\;~ u.r\.\6\L S ~ ~\ v~\-~~:
                                                                     )

         No ~\A~!:)Q_ s \\CN\'\ (z>-\ \ ""' W'\         (..C-\., sCL ~-~e. 'r-.e.. e r s \--.e...

         tnCA.~ 'olL \~W~"E>\~b...
                                                     1
                                           -~ \.A.6'JfLS S~CA.\\ 6:""\sq;~\\.~
         \-~e..l""'t\ se).\l{7_S ' " CA.\\ Qr'U (-<~-e._~\"~ s \,.... ~'r:,c\t\. \~~ ~\1~
         ~" '"~~(\- \~ \-".~~~                                \<:,"'CAS   C.,~AS\\~\;\l"
          OS~L\ct. 5 ~ \\.
                  \ "'-\-r:..c..,'\- ~\.A.~~~         S\6.1'..&/"e_~ r-n\.( - 5L
          L""CAvCL Qr~~~ \-'<\Q... 'o\~~\- v\~ \£A.~~"'s ct. C-'r\) SLC.\...\.~r ~~ ~\ s \r~~ 1"'"~~~ \ L 'r--CA.\,)~
                                                   J                        r·   f'\           ~ a-\)o s- d-.14-
           ·\H\J-JCU\ \-~CA.\- \~fL. \ "\\;"-\ Q_\"- ~"'-" ~S \)'t" T~C.\-              \ "-       -
          ~ w         'fO\J~ /"('\.'!                   \." "o LeA.CfL.        l

            ~\)~\:)~ N'\~ Set\~         1"'<"'\Q.. 1 ~\..(L \)(e._\)\)1\GclfO-rlL \)~ \-~Q... ~v\~~t~o-r\-s ~L \.s\f.\J\
          ~v..~~s (~ Lt:> rl'\~~r-.~\-5..\:)" ., ~~~w\~· J.-.~~~)                                        ··
                                      ~..._~tr- ~ \-{:,~ C.i"'"·'r\- ......._o,;J,q_s \'-,__"~'"~s
               \=v_r\-Wtr ........;)ft::_
          0
            ~ ~CA.I...\- w \ \~ C)'""\- CA. ..._w..r\~ ~ . "' "'- s C.S>\.) r\- \"6~\~
          W ~ ~v..~i ~ f'r.L ~ 6~\\-S'                SQ..     (:\e.,i.,C.J\"'. ~IPP· V\"\5)
    G\)          \   ~Q... CAJtn~~\- \)L~~\)" ~( ~tA be.AS G~rp'"""s;                         C(L-ct D()5'-
             ~-:, '-\- ~ WCA.CS ~\\~~       \J "-   ~ c~i)~·\.41\.\   \ " "o C. 'u s. c\-. d-\::,~ q l \C'\ '&b)
            T~~SCL Ctl"\-r-u\\\1\~ ~v..~o(~\-;~.S \{'_  ~ r (Q_\J-, ~ .. 'S:_ ~ f \)v ~ ~ IL~ ffi-
            5\J ~~~"- /"(\Q_~oro..r-..~u.~ \).Q \u..w <2-.s\-CA-~\\tt>"-\,.._~ ""'1
            \..:\\\\"s ·
                                   L
             e~CAL~ \~Lc~\-\.~r-S. \~~\- {)f~-Jt. C\.\' l'?:>~) ~f\)\l,_1S Q,
             (~\~~-

\ \:>)           T.. ~   fee~-,~-;."~ \-\-."- "'-Dv'o(_o-.s c,c r\'"' s .(\, "6\ "ss
           0~ QCA,C\.J   ~~ \Q..(;oM i"V\·~fA ~~" L.\- co-\ 6..i"tt.S ~ C\.i\-
                                                            •

           ""1 C~~)   ~r~\)~6.s ~\,)~ CA.\rll..eu~ or(.~ ~r~s~~ or-
           Go\.A\~ "a\~L. ~£A~;.;~
          .es\~\>\\~\..~"~ \""CA.\-~ CA. Qfe..~~rl~~fnf'lL ~~ \-"e.. ~-v\ ~~.)
          'ov..~ ~~CA. ,,-,()\ 1 ·t
c\\A\i ~6re.s~~o"
~) \-(\U ~" ~\~fA~u" S r\~ \\<;::,~ \ " \-'<\(L \ " ~,c,\ r-l'tA\-
\>:>)     f'.oe~\~ULJ ~~ \)6\~L ~ \.;~ "~~\:- \ Q..         w \-V"'- -~ \'¥\(A,\- ~ r ~'J Q...   c..~~ c...~"-~\- (Y"cv~ 0 p CA.. ~ o\~
w~~~ .. CAS       \~ .,U rAS S~W~ ~ ~t. c,.,..t:_ ......., b\u~~ W«-S
\e.t-\- c..,\- ...._'\ "'" ""IL ~1:> ,..._ ,... '\ \ "--:y r\ e._::, , \) •~ · v..S(L~
Qllf~(~ \e_::=.\;...M>.... '1 >:>~ \-\.'l., (.l\>rv-. \>\~e.... s ~ h~ f e.CLM-\-.S
\--"(A,~ \) r\ b r O..Cl\J\ s~\; 0 "" s ~1. sc,.._~ is "'t_l_s "o\- Stt~\" ~
L ~c0 \\.,.~ ~~\\~\"5
      ~\- :re1-,"t-w6 ~Lh n~ ~'t---.c-~ w~             ''~\e..~\" _:"'-\.(\.A..C\- \"L\~- ~ \-~..,Js
      w~Q]~ \~e... '(D\\te_ %~\}' -\"c\.Q.... ~\\)\)~ s ~IV'\~\~. ~\- \-"-L 6-r\~e..
      ~~ ~.. L. \t..\--\-- \" ~'\ C..o. .r ?::>)                 GJ \:)v ,._~s.    \'T-. ro~""- -~...
        (Q... ~<>r\Qfs (Q...l.,f6, L              ~r~\JfA.           N-.)      '\~:.Lru-.LL,                1:.. ch"'
        V...."-u~ ~-u~ ~v.t.l~ ~~\!2... C}.t.~ 'L. t.~ bCL. l2.e..~ '""'-'}
        "-c..\,(_ W rp"' s rne_.,.-v<>fo.,..C'v\'"" oQ- \p.,J ar;t:. Vlf 'f~ I 1-
        \J\~ ((\-~ ~~ ~""'d.~~ 0 ~~c..""\~.                                    '(...1-,     ~\')\.)'' Li)~ \_~)) \..\ ~5.        \)d-.5'   j \...\ ct "-    ,~ o~ \._£A) l'~) .          "'L {'   .\-~s
        c~\) r \- \-..."'" :s    "v \\\. w~ c\.           ~e.e\" ~ s ~ ·wwd.. s "'t. II\ eJ\
        (~Co~"'<-\"~                ""''\ f    ~ ~"-\: ~ 'oe.- ~ J.                    D \-_;:,.   ...,\~   be. 4-(Cef-\-ll.d ·
            \Li.. ~S (R)" ~~\V\.\\\ll\.              ~(~\c,\e_              '\__   ~   \D.

                                                      \3>
   \   ~        '   \ \-.. \)< \-            o~ C.(i. "'\ "CA.\ c.-_~ qes...\ s   h."'S \"<=>v&l \'I)
             IL~ W-\- c.\" o n j.""'-\ :~~ r; .s 0, L-~ \)"" D\1 u- ""'~ ~"~60 ~o rp~s
             C.,~ ~0~5- ~::,"\- ~- \ "'L (._~\.>(\- w\\\. ~u,"'-..Q_ 5V'0~ ~u.( ,sP-\L\;01\
             ~" e.1-..~riA~r~\f\o...r, c_~'s; \\s w~e..r{, \-~e_ {'roc.Q....e..'b"~~ s
                                                        1
              \? \)\)\~ ~~CA.~~~\ \N~~ !\.\)\- 'c~ OJ\. ~ecvV\0\,~ re...c:Q...~i
              Or w~Q.fQ... \-"'-CL ~~\;\\o"Q.r ~S 'o. \'1.\S)

l '-I)        '~L ~(>f~~ ~~~('"' ~""? ~~~r~~b. ~~~ f'(\.~~\A-5
           w\ \\ \ ~ S:n""-Q_ \ " C2_.~c.RR ~\),.._D\)\ (._\ ((.,\A."" s\-~(.Q...S ~c \.)"~" ~
           ~ 0\. ~\A6~\.Ac..v\ '-"C::>~r{'U('V-.D" 0 ~ p~wQ..(._ ~"- re..."~ v o\V...SwC-t_)~
           0~ CA~QS~C,O..." J'"!.._"L.5'-\ 5 ~-a~~\-~~~ :,~~J ·~~q) 9;L-\O~"~
           G~e..o-1~ "'~ -v.s .. C>~ ":>~. (...\- J 5L\l.. \.A.S . 3 ~~ J :,e,o 1 \~'-\ S .. L\-.
           d.-,5 I b I\6 '\     L-~~. ~~- '-\ 5~               (__J.roo ~

               \ "\::, CA'>f\-     CWIL~ rv-, \..\'"11 \J\, ~~ \ro\o ~\'\ afo1~ l V\ ~\.;) \ hCL ~t'w\
            L\)\.)f~ \ ~ \ " 'J~\~~\)" · a-\2- ~"Q_ '\e..~~~ ~" ~~-\\.N~U"
           CA.l.~\ ~  s- \\ \.       \\"6. \'-'~s \J\~\ O-l2> u..s. ;}.\:A                        1
                                                                   d..l:, 1'-\1 S.c..~ ~55 1II C.. .~

           lv:0.<'\ C..\."\~'.)              .               y\U>-.'\E.~
                      Gr~\ re_\J\e..~      ~~ c~"~c~ \""~Q_PtA,~~'
             le..-~-_a_-.,~ ()~ ""'\ ~ tt~A-~ uc-a."'s -d-~u.- ~
                       \Le_~ ~(( c\-t.,._\\.'\
                        ~\oeJ-\- ~~~'v\]\.(L
                              \ '-\.   ~>:> '-\ 5   1
                                  ~                                l'-1
                                                                                                                 -.."-'':.

                           /

                     /;-
                                                                                                                               . : '. ..   ,.
                               iriarcil~rt Cause No. CR2005-234
                                                                                                                         -~_
                                                                                                                     s

EX PARTE
                                  ,;~.r~['~   ,_-    .,'

                                                                  §            IN THE TEXAS COU
                                                                                                       CZl
                                                                                                       -<
                                                                                                                  (/)
                                                                                                                  -1
                                                                                                                  :::0
                                                                                                                 ("")~
                                                                                                                -i)>
                                                                                                                ()-I
                                                                                                                ~:z:
                                                                                                                                      -
                                                                                                                                      ~
                                                                                                                                      (_
                                                                                                                                      c::
                                                                                                                                                     .,
                                                                                                                                                     r
                                                                                                                                                     m
                                                                                                                                                     0
                                                                                                               ;-.,-<                 r-
                                                                                                               ::u .......            w              'l
ROBERT TROY• MCCLURE                                              §            OF CRIMINAL APP         '"
                                                                                                            LS7~
                                                                                                               ~,-,;:.
                                                                                                                                   C)               '~
                                                                                                                                                    .::~J
                                                                                                              oc::                 .::0.                   ...
                                                                                                              :r:-                ::r ·-
                                                                                                                                                    -~,.

                                                                                                                                                    -v
                                                                                                              :>:X
                                                                                                                ,.,.,
                                                                                                             r-:Z::
                                                                                                             g:u                  -..           ·'l
                                                                                                                                                J:-:,
                                                                                                                                                ~--:::,
                                                                                                                                                ... -_.
          ORDER ON POST CONVICTION APPLICATION.FOR W                                                         c::
                                                                                                             :.z::
                                                                                                                                  0
                                                                                                                                                    __ _,-
                                                                                                             .....                              ,

                  OF HABEAS CORPUS, ARTICLE 11.07                                                            -<

       On the · )t:il-£..;       day of             ;;-.A/:;;?           , 2014 came on to be heard Applicant

ROBERT TR9Y MCCLURE's Application for Writ of Habeas Corpus. The Court

having reviewed the Application and the Court's file is of the opinion that the

Application for Writ of Habeas Corpus is                              a subsequent writ pursuant to Texas Code
of Criminal Procedure. article 11.07 Section 4. The 'information contained herein has

-or could have been presented in Applicant's earlier writs·, and the Application does

not contain sufficient specific facts establishing that by a preponderance of the
                                                                                             ·';

evidence, but for a violation of the United States Constitution, no rational juror

could h~ve found Applicant guilty beyond.a reasonable doubt. ApRl_ic.ant is not

entitled to any further relief. Therefor~, relief should be denied. Furthermore, this
                                                           :;'.

Court notes that Applicant ROBERT TROY MCCLURE has filed several writs of

habeas corpus, and has been declared a vexati~us litigant in the 1ih Judicial Di§trict

Court of Walker County, Texas in Cause Number 26040. McClure v. Texas Dep'tof

Criminal Justice, No. 10-12-00481-CV, 2014 WL 813753 (Tex. App.-Waco Feb. 27, 2014,pet.

filed) (mem. op.).
      The Court therefore recommends that ROBERT TROY MCCLURE's

Application for Writ of Habeas Corpus   der article 11.07 be DENIED.

               DGE PRESIDING