Court Opinion

ID: 3190795
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-04-01 17:01:19.816749+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:35:36.254117
License: Public Domain

&+5212/2*<

-DQXDU\             3HQUHJLVWHURQ$QWKRQ\6XJJV¶FHOOSKRQHVVWDUWHG

-DQXDU\           &RQWUROOHGSXUFKDVHIURP-DPHV3DUNHU7KHFRRSHUDWRUSDLG
                           DQGUHFHLYHGLQH[FKDQJHDQHLJKWRXQFHERWWOHWKDWODWHUWHVWHG
                           SRVLWLYHIRU3&3'XULQJWKHLUPHHWLQJZKLFKZDVWDSHG3DUNHUWROG
                           WKHFRRSHUDWRUWKDWKHQHHGHGWRPDNHDFDOO3HQUHJLVWHUHYLGHQFH
                           HVWDEOLVKHGWKDWWKHFDOOZDVWR6XJJV

-DQXDU\          %HJLQQLQJRIZLUHWDSRQ6XJJV¶FHOOSKRQH³6XJJV:LUHWDS´

-DQXDU\      &DOOVUHFRUGHGE\6XJJV:LUHWDS

  'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ    2WKHU     ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                        7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
             1XPEHU        3DUW\                                                      %HYLQJWRQ
                 +HOHU\    3ULFH³,QHHGWRKROODDW\RXWDONWR\RX´   ,GHQWLILHGRWKHUSDUW\DV
  SP                     3ULFH                                                      3ULFHDP7UDW
                                                                                        
     8QNQRZQ       -DPHV     'LVFXVVLRQDERXW³JHWWLQJWRJHWKHU´           'HIHQVHFRXQVHODVNHG
                            3DUNHU    %DVHGRQWULDOWHVWLPRQ\WUDQVFULSWIURP      ZKHWKHUWKH\FRXOGKDYH
                                       DFWLYDWLRQQRWLQUHFRUG                      EHHQJHWWLQJWRJHWKHUWR
                                                                                        ³SODFHEHWVRUJDPEOH´
                                                                                        %HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDW
                                                                                        ³EDVHGRQRXULQYHVWLJDWLRQ
                                                                                        DOORIWKHFDOOV,EHOLHYHLW
                                                                                        ZRXOGEHDERXWVRPHWKLQJ
                                                                                        GLIIHUHQW´DP7U
                                                                                        DW
                 -XOLDQ  -RKQVRQ³<RXGHDGQRZ"                           %HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDWWKH
  SP                  -RKQVRQ 6XJJV³<HDK´                                    LQTXLU\³ZKHQKH6DLG\RX
                                                                                  GHDGQRZKHPHDQWGRHV
                                     -RKQVRQ³,ZDQQDJRKHDY\,DLQ¶W       WKDWPHDQ\RXGRQ¶WKDYH
                                     JRWQRVWRUDJHELQ´                              DQ\3&3´SP7U
                                                                                        DW
                                                                                        
                                                                                        %HYLQJWRQDOVRWHVWLILHGWKDW
                                                                                        ZKHQ-RKQVRQVDLGKH
                                                                                        ZDQWHGWR³JRKHDY\´KH
                                                                                        PHDQWKHZDQWHGDODUJH
                                                                                        TXDQWLW\SPDW
    'DWH        $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU    ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                       7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
                 1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                    %HYLQJWRQ
                   (UQHVW   6XJJV³:HOOFDOOPHDVVRRQDV\RX            1RQH
    SP                   *ORYHU   OHDYLQJWKHUH,FDQMXVWVKRRWULJKWWRWKH
                                         KRXVHDQGZHFDQSXOOXSDWWKHVDPHWLPH
                                         RUZKDWHYHU´
                                         
                                         *ORYHU³<HDK,QHHG\RX<HDK<HDK,
                                         QHHG\RXWRPHHWPHFDXVH,JRWWRVHH
                                         VRPHERG\DW\RXNQRZ´
                   (UQHVW   6XJJV³,JRWZKDW\RXZDQWHGWKHVDPH       1RQH
    SP                   *ORYHU   SRFNH\ERRN\RXJRW6XHGRZQDW8,´
                                         
                                         *ORYHU³<HDK<HDKWKHVDPH<HDKWKH
                                         VDPHSRFNH\ERRN%DE\´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³2N\RXDWWKHKRXVH"´
                                         
                                         *ORYHU³,¶OOEHWKHUHLQERXWXKERXW
                                         PLQXWHVLQPLQXWHV´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³2N,¶OOPHHW\RXWKHUH´
                   (UQHVW   6XJJV³,¶PHQURXWHEDE\,¶PHQURXWH     1RQH
    SP                   *ORYHU   &RPLQJWKURXJK,¶PFRPLQJWKURXJK´
                                         
                                         *ORYHU³,¶OOVHH\RXZKHQ,JHWWKHUH´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³2.,¶PULJKWEHKLQG\RX´
                   (UQHVW   6XJJV³:KHUH\RXDW6OLP"´              1RQH
    SP                 *ORYHU   
                                         *ORYHU³5LJKWKHUHE\WKH.HQWXFN\)ULHG
                                         &KLFNHQERXWWRPDNHWKHWXUQ1RUWK
                                         &DSLWRO´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³2K,¶PLQIURQWRI\RXUKRXVH´
                                         
                                         *ORYHU³$OULJKWKHUH,FRPH´

                                                    

    'DWH       $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU    ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                     7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
                1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                  %HYLQJWRQ
                  -XOLDQ  -RKQVRQ³:KDW¶VJRLQJRQZLWK\RX"´          %HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDW
    SP                  -RKQVRQ 6XJJV1RWKLQJMXVWPRYLQJDURXQGIRUD      -RKQVRQZDV³ORRNLQJWREH
                                       PLQXWH:KDW¶VKDSSHQLQJ"´                   VXSSOLHGZLWK3&3´
                                       -RKQVRQ³$LQ¶WQRWKLQJ:DLWLQJRQ\RX      SP7UDW
                                       WRVOLGHEDFNWKURXJK,ZLVK\RXFRXOG¶YH
                                       OLNH\RXMXVWGLG´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³2KPDQ\RXWHUULEOH+RZPXFK
                                       \RXXVHDOORIXVJRLQJWKHZKROHQLQH
                                       \DUGV"´
                                       
                                       -RKQVRQ³,DP%REEXWV

\RXWDONLQ¶
                                       ERXW\RXPRYLQJDURXQG6

,WKRXJKW
                                       \RXZRXOGKDYHP\OLWWOHOXJJDJHZLWK\RX
                                       RUVRPHWKLQJ´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³2KQDKHOOQDK*LYHPHDERXW
                                       PLQXWHV´
                  (UQHVW   *ORYHUWDONLQJDERXW³%URWKHU´³0DQ       %HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDW
    SP                  *ORYHU   GRQ¶WZDQWWRZRUNDMREPDQGRQ¶WZDQW     ³%URWKHU´ZDVDUHIHUHQFHWR
                                        WRGRQRWKLQJ$SS+HMXVWZDQWWRZDON     3ULFHDQGWKDWZKDW6XJJV
                                        DURXQGORRNVOLFNWDONVOLFNDQGJDPEOH    ZDVVD\LQJDERXWKLPZDV
                                        \RXNQRZ7KDWPDQDLQ¶WWU\LQJWRGR        WKDW³3ULFHQHHGVWRKDYHD
                                        QRWKLQJFRQFUHWHDQGVHULRXV´               MREVRKHDSSHDUVWREH
                                                                                     JHWWLQJPRQH\OHJLWLPDWHO\´
                                        6XJJV³+HJRWWDJHWVRPHWKLQJWRFRYHU      DP7UDW
                                        KLPXSWKRXJKPDQ´
                  -XOLDQ  6XJJV³2QP\ZD\WREULQJ\RXWKLVKDLU      %HYLQJWRQZDVDVNHGWR
    SP                  -RKQVRQ GU\HU:KDW\RXZDQWWKHKDLUGU\HUWKDW    GHVFULEH-RKQVRQ¶VKDLU
                                       \RXDVNHGPHERXWHDUOLHU´                   VW\OHDQGKHWHVWLILHGWKDW
                                                                                     -RKQVRQ¶V³KDLUZDVFXW
                                       -RKQVRQ³:KDW\RXVD\"´                      YHU\VKRUWRUYHU\FORVH´
                                                                                     SP7UDW
                                       6XJJV³,VD\\RXZDQWPHWREULQJ\RX
                                       WKHKDLUGU\HUWKDW\RXDVNHGPHERXW
                                       HDUOLHU"´
                                       
                                       -RKQVRQ³<HDK´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³$OULJKW,¶PRQP\ZD\´
                  -DPHV    9RLFHPDLOPHVVDJHIURP3DUNHU³*LYHPH 1RQH
    SP                 3DUNHU   DFDOOEDFNPDQVR,FDQXP,GHILQLWHO\
                                        \RXNQRZZDQWP\RUGHUWRJHWRII<RX
                                        NQRZZKDW,¶PVD\LQJ"´

                                                   

    'DWH       $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU    ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                       7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
                1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                    %HYLQJWRQ
                 (UQHVW   *ORYHU³5HPHPEHUODVWQLJKWZHJRW          6HH$FWLYDWLRQEHORZ
    DP                 *ORYHU   WRJHWKHU´
                                       
                                        6XJJV³<HDK´
                                        
                                        *ORYHU³<HDK<HDK,EXPSHGLQWRD
                                        OLWWOHEXGG\RIPLQHULJKWZHZDVJHWWLQJ
                                        WRJHWKHUPDQDQGXKKHFDOOHGPHEDFN
                                        WRGD\VDLGKHDLQ¶WKHDLQ¶WFDUHIRUWKDW
                                        PDQ´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³+HDLQ¶WFDUHIRULW"´
                                        
                                        *ORYHU³<HDK\HDK\HDK´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³6

,GRQ¶WNQRZZK\$LQ¶W
                                        QRERG\HOVH´
                                        
                                        *ORYHU³\RXNQRZWKLVWKHILUVW,
                                        KHDUGRIWKLV
                                        
                                        6XJJV³(YHU\WKLQJZDVSURSHU\RX
                                        NQRZ´
                  (UQHVW   3DUNHU³,JRWWRZDLWIRUWKHSHRSOHWKRXJK 6HH$FWLYDWLRQEHORZ
    DP                 *ORYHU   \RXNQRZEXW,¶PUHDG\WRVHH\RX
                              -DPHV    WKRXJK<RXNQRZZKDW,¶PVD\LQJ´
                              3DUNHU   
                                        6XJJV³2ND\,¶OOFDOO\RXZKHQ,FRPH
                                        RXWRIWKHEDUEHUVKRS´
                                        
                                        6XJJVVZLWFKHVWRFDOOZLWK(UQHVW*ORYHU
                                        
                                        *ORYHU³³HYHU\RQHJRWGLIIHUHQWRSLQLRQV´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³ZKHQ,KLWKHU\RXNQRZ
                                        \HVWHUGD\LWDLQ¶WKDYHQRVPHOOWRLWRU
                                        QRWKLQJ´

                                                    

    'DWH       $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU    ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                        7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
                1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                     %HYLQJWRQ
                  +HOHU\   3ULFH,QHHGWRKROODUDW\RXZKHQ\RXJHW 1RQH
    DP                 3ULFH    DFKDQFH´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³,¶PJRQQDFRPHWKURXJKWKHUH
                                        (YHU\WKLQJFRRO"´
                                        
                                        3ULFH³<HDKHYHU\WKLQJ¶VFRRO$QG
                                        JLYHPHDVDPSOHRIWKDWERRNPDQ,JRW
                                        DVRPHERG\ZDQWDPRWKHUIXFNHUPLJKW
                                        ZDQWWRKROOHUDQGORRNDWWKHERRNPDQ´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³,¶PJRQQDMXVWKLW\RXDVVRRQDV,
                                        JHWRII´
                  +HOHU\   6XJJV³,¶PVWLOODWZRUN,¶PJRQQD       1RQH
    SP                  3ULFH    FDOO\RXDQGZH¶OOJRIURPWKHUHPDQ´
                                        
                                        3ULFH³2ND\EULQJWKDWXKPZKDW
                                        XFDOOHP´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³,JRW\RX´
                                        
                                        3ULFH³$OULJKW´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³<HDKWKDW6LVWHU6LVWHU0DJD]LQH
                                        \RXZDQWPHWRORRNDWULJKW"´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³2ND\,¶OOFDOO\RXZKHQ,¶PRQ
                                        P\ZD\´
                  +HOHU\   6XJJV³$OULJKW\RXDLQ¶WQRWI

WKDWWU\    1RQH
    SP                  3ULFH    XSDOUHDG\RQWKH8,GLG\RX)RRO"´
                                        
                                        3ULFH³1DZ,¶PDKROGLQJEDE\
                                        $QGDQRWKHUWUH\ZLOOFRPHLQ\RXNQRZ
                                        IXFNWKDWVKLW´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³2K\HDK\HDKZHJRQQDEH
                                        DOULJKW,¶PZDLWLQJRQ\RXWKRXJK)RRO
                                        ,¶PDOULJKWZHOO,¶P,¶PMXVWZDLWLQJRQ
                                        \RXPDQ,¶PDKLW\RXXSVKRUWO\PDQ
                                        ,MXVWFDPHWKURXJK´

                                                    

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ    2WKHU    ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                       7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU        3DUW\                                                    %HYLQJWRQ
                  (UQHVW   *ORYHU³,WROGWKHPPDQ,²,¶PMXVW            %HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDW
    SP                  *ORYHU   JRLQJWRJRDKHDGPDQDQGXKDQGXKXK       ³ZKDWZDVJRLQJRQ´LQWKH
                                        ,WROGWKHPWRPDNHVXUH,¶PSURSHU´   VHULHVRIFDOOVEHWZHHQ
                                                                                 6XJJVDQG(UQHVW*ORYHURQ
                                                                                       -DQXDU\
                                        6XJJV³/LNHWHOO\RXWKLVKHKLWWKH        $FWLYDWLRQV
                                        FRXVLQDQG\RXNQRZDQGWKHFRXVLQ          ZDVWKDW³0U6XJJVVROG
                                        DLQ¶WFRPSODLQ´                               0U(UQHVW*ORYHUDTXDQWLW\
                                                                                       RI3&3ZKLFK0U(UQHVW
                                                                                        *ORYHUWKHQUHVROGWR
                                                                                        DQRWKHUFXVWRPHUZHOO
                                                                                        DFWXDOO\WZRFXVWRPHUV
                                                                                        2QHRIWKHFXVWRPHUVKDG
                                                                                        FRPSODLQWVDERXWWKHTXDOLW\
                                                                                        RIWKH3&3DQGWKHRWKHURQH
                                                                                        GLGQRW´+HDOVRWHVWLILHG
                                                                                        WKDW6XJJV¶UHVSRQVHWR
                                                                                        *ORYHUZDVWKDW³IURP
                                                                                        HYHU\WKLQJKHKDGKHDUG
                                                                                        IURPKLVRWKHUFXVWRPHUV
                                                                                        HYHU\WKLQJZDVILQHDQG
                                                                                        SURSHU´


-DQXDU\            9LGHRWDSHGPHHWLQJEHWZHHQ/RQQHOO*ORYHUDQG&RUQHOO*ORYHUDW
                             ZKLFK/RQQHOOJDYH&RUQHOODERWWOHFRQWDLQLQJOLTXLG

-DQXDU\        &DOOVUHFRUGHGE\6XJJV:LUHWDS

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU     ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                         7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                       %HYLQJWRQ
                 (UQHVW    6XJJV³:KDW¶VWKHGHDOZLWK\RX´               1RQH
    SP                 *ORYHU    
                                        *ORYHU$LQ¶WWRRPXFKPDQ,¶PKROODDW
                                        OLWWOH\RXQJQ

WRGD\PDQ+HVDLGKLV
                                        EURWKHUVD\KHJRLQJWRNHHSKLVWKRXJK´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³/LNH,WROG\RX,DLQ¶W,DLQ¶WJRWQR
                                        SUREOHP\RXNQRZVROLNH´
                                        
                                        ³,WROG\RXHYHU\WKLQJSURSHURQP\HQG´

                                                   

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU      ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                      7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                     %HYLQJWRQ
                 +HOHU\     3ULFH³,ZDQW\RXNQRZZKDW,DVNHG    1RQH
    SP                 3ULFH      \RXXKPWKHRWKHUGD\´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³<HVWHUGD\"´
                                         
                                         3ULFH³<HDK\HDK´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³,¶PJRQQDWU\WRJHWDW\RX>DV@
                                         VRRQDVWKHJDPH´
                                         
                                         3ULFH³1DZQDZPD\EHWRPRUURZIRUVXUH
                                         7RPRUURZWKRXJKFRPHFRPHDQGVHHPH
                                         WRPRUURZ´
                                         
                                         3ULFH³+LWPHWRPRUURZFDXVHWKHPSHRSOHV
                                         EHHQSUHVVLQJPHIRUUHDO´
                 (UQHVW     *ORYHU³RNMXVWKLWPHLQWKHPRUQLQJRU     1RQH
                       *ORYHU     VRPHWKLQJ\RXNQRZ´
    SP                                  
                                         6XJJV³,¶PZRUNLQJWRPRUURZ:KHQ,JHW
                                         RII,¶OOKLW\RXZHJRIURPWKHUH´
                 *OHQGDOH                                                 1RQH
    SP                 /HH

                                                    

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU      ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                         7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                        %HYLQJWRQ
                 +HOHU\     3ULFH³<RXJRWWKDWLQIRUPDWLRQ,ZDQWHG        $JHQW%HYLQJWRQ
    SP                 3ULFH      \RXXK,ZDQWHGVRPHERG\WRORRNDW"´           WHVWLILHGDVWRWKLV
                                                                                          H[FKDQJHWKDW³,EHOLHYH
                                         6XJJV³<HDK,KDYHLWIRU\RXODWHURQ)RRO   WKDW>3ULFH@ZDQWVWR
                                         ,¶PMXVWGRLQJVRPHPRYLQJDURXQG<HD         NQRZLI0U6XJJVKDV
                                         EXW\HDK,DOUHDG\SXWWKDWWRWKHVLGH          WKHGUXJVKHZDVORRNLQJ
                                         WKRXJK´                                         IRU´DP7UDW
                                                                                          
                                         3ULFH³2ND\RND\´                             +HH[SODLQHGWKDWKH
                                                                                    FDPHWRWKLVRSLQLRQ
                                         6XJJV³,¶OOKLW\RXVRRQDV,FDQ´             EHFDXVH
                                                                                           ³)RUVHYHUDOGD\VWKH\¶YH
                                                                                           EHHQWDONLQJEDFNDQG
                                                                                           IRUWK$QGRULJLQDOO\
                                                                                           0U3ULFHKDGDVNHGIRUD
                                                                                           VDPSOHRIWKDWERRN
                                                                                           7KHQZKHQ0U6XJJV
                                                                                           FDOOHGKLPEDFNODWHUKH
                                                                                           PDGHUHIHUHQFHVWRD
                                                                                           6LVWHU6LVWHUPDJD]LQH
                                                                                           $QGQRZLW¶V
                                                                                           LQIRUPDWLRQDQGLW¶VLQ
                                                                                           WKDWVHULHVRI
                                                                                           FRQYHUVDWLRQV7KH\¶YH
                                                                                           FKDQJHGWKHFRGH
                                                                                           PXOWLSOHWLPHV%XW
                                                                                           WKH\¶UHFOHDUO\QRW
                                                                                           WDONLQJDERXWRUXVLQJWKH
                                                                                           VDPHZRUGVWRWDONDERXW
                                                                                           ZKDWWKH\¶UHWDONLQJ
                                                                                           DERXW´DP7U
                                                                                           DW
                 *OHQGDOH   6XJJV³<HDKZKDW¶VWKHGHDOZKDW¶VXS"´       1RQH
    SP                 /HH        
                                         /HH³$WZRRQHIRU'RFDQGRQHIRUPH´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³2KRND\ZKHUH\RXDW"´
                                         
                                         /HH³,¶PLQWKHKRXVHJHWWLQJUHDG\WRSXW
                                         P\FORWKHVRQ´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³$OULJKW,¶PRQP\ZD\´

                                                    

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU    ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                          7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                       %HYLQJWRQ
                 +HOHU\   3ULFH³/HWPHKROODDW\RXPDQZKHQ\RX          1RQH
    SP                 3ULFH    JHWDFKDQFH´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³,¶OOFDOO\RXZKHQ,¶PRQP\
                                       ZD\LQWRZQ´
                 +HOHU\   3ULFH³-XVWZDLWLQJRQ\RX´                     1RQH
    SP                 3ULFH    
                                       6XJJV2ND\JLYHPHDERXWPLQXWHV,¶OO
                                       KLW\RXULJKWEDFNWKHQ´
                 +HOHU\   3ULFH³2KHYHU\WKLQJ¶VVWLOODOOJRRG,¶P      1RQH
    SP                 3ULFH    MXVWZDLWLQJIRUXKPP\OLWWOHODG\
                                       IULHQGDFRPHDQGJHWKHUGDXJKWHUPDQ
                                       $QGWKHQ,,¶OOEH,¶OOEHULJKWWKHUHZLWK
                                       \RX´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³2ND\MXVWKLWPHWKHQ,¶PZDLWLQJ
                                       RQ\RX´
                 +HOHU\   6XJJV\RXRQWKHFOXEULJKW"´              1RQH
    SP                 3ULFH    
                                       3ULFH³1DZ,DLQ¶WHYHQ,DLQ¶WHYHQ,DLQ¶W
                                       HYHQLQWKHFOXE,FDQ,FDQPHHW\RXGRZQ
                                       WKHUHWKRXJK,¶OOPHHW\RXGRZQWKHUH
                                       WKRXJK´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³$OULJKW,¶PULJKWKHUH´
                 3ULFH    6XJJV³,¶PDOUHDG\DWWKHOLJKW:KHUH\RX      /DZHQIRUFHPHQWZDV
    SP                           DW)RRO"´                                         OLVWHQLQJWRWKHVHULHVRI
                                                                                         FDOOVEHWZHHQ6XJJVDQG
                                       3ULFH³2KRND\,¶PDW,¶PDWXPE\WKHD        3ULFHRQDQG
                                       WHOO´                                            WULHGWRVHWXS
                                                                                          VXUYHLOODQFH6HH
                                                                                          SP7UDW

                                                  

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU    ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                              7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                           %HYLQJWRQ
                 +HOHU\   6XJJV³1RZWKDWRWKHUFDUMXVWSXOOHGEDFN           $JHQW%HYLQJWRQ
    SP                 3ULFH    XSPDQ<RXEHWWHUEHFDUHIXOGRZQWKHUHDW          WHVWLILHGWKDWKHKHDUG
                                       WKDWVSRWPDQ´                                      IURPWKH³ZLUHWDSURRP´
                                                                                             WKDW³0U6XJJVDQG0U
                                       3ULFH³:KDWRWKHUFDU"´                              3ULFHZHUHWDONLQJDERXW
                                                                                             RXUFDUHVDQGZH
                                       6XJJV³7KHRWKHUFDUH,WROG\RXDERXW7KH         GHFLGHGWRGLVFRQWLQXH
                                       EURZQFDU´                                           WKHVXUYHLOODQFHDWWKDW
                                                                                             WLPH´DP7UDW
                                       3ULFH³:KHUHDW"7KHVDPHVSRW"´                    
                                       
                                       6XJJV³<HDK,WMXVWSXOOHGEDFNDURXQG
                                       ZKHQ,ZDVSXOOLQJRII´
                                       
                                       3ULFH³2KZHOOWKDWFDUDLQ¶WQRWKLQJWKRXJK
                                       ´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³'LG\RXORRNDWWKHDQWHQQDRQWKH
                                       EDFNRIWKHMRLQW"´³,MXVWGRQ¶WOLNHWKDW
                                       ORRNGRZQWKHUHPDQ´³:KHQ,ZDV
                                       OHDYLQJ,VHHQWKDWRWKHUMRLQWSXOOLQJEDFN
                                       DURXQG´
                                       
                                       3ULFH³$OULJKW)RRO0LJKWJRWWRJHW
                                       DQRWKHUYHQXHWKHQ´

                                                  

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU      ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                           7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                          %HYLQJWRQ
                 *OHQGDOH   /HH³,¶PZDLWLQJIRUWKLVOLWWOHGXGHWR 1RQH
                       /HH        KLWPHEDFN´
    SP                                  
                                         6XJJV³$OULJKW,MXVWVHH\RXWRPRUURZ
                                         ZKHQ,JHWRII´
                                         
                                         /HH³%XW,JRWWKDWRWKHUOLWWOHMXVWMXVW
                                         I

LW,¶PMXVWJRQQDWHOOKLPWRMXVWZDLW
                                         WLOWRPRUURZWKHQ´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³:K\ZKDW¶VZURQJ":KDWKHQHHG
                                         ´
                                         /HH³&DXVH,JRWOLWWOHGXGHPDPWU\LQJKH
                                         WU\LQJWRGR\RXNQRZZKDW,¶PVD\LQJ"
                                         %XWKHFRXQWLQJKHFRXQWLQJKLVVFUDWFK´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³2K´
                                         
                                         /HH³+HVDLGKHZDVJRLQJWRFDOOPHEDFN
                                         LQPLQXWHV´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³2KDOULJKWZHOOMXVW,PHDQMXVWWHOO
                                         KLPWRZDLWWLOWRPRUURZ,DLQ¶WHYHQ
                                         FRPLQJEDFNRXWWRQLJKW´
                 -DPHV      3DUNHU³,WROG\RX,QHHGWRKROOHU´             1RQH
    SP                 3DUNHU     
                                         6XJJV³,NQRZLW,DLQ¶WJRQQDEHDEOHWR
                                         JHWWR\RXXQWLOODWHURQWRQLJKWWKRXJK´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³+H\ZK\WKHSKRQHNHHSFOLFNLQJ
                                         OLNHWKDW"´
                                         
                                         3DUNHU³6KHFOLFNLQJ"´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³<RXGRQ¶WKHDUOLNHFOLFN"+H\
                                         ORRNKDQGXSDQG,¶PJRQQDFDOO\RXULJKW
                                         EDFN´
                 *OHQGDOH   /HH³,QHHG\RXWREULQJRQHWRR´         1RQH
    SP                 /HH        
                                         6XJJV³$OULJKW,¶PDFDOO\RXODWHURQ´
                                         
                                         /HH³2ND\,JRWDOULJKWDOULJKW,OHWKLP
                                         NQRZ,ZLOOPHHWKLPODWHURQWKHQ´

                                                    

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU     ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                         7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                       %HYLQJWRQ
                 /RQQHOO    7UDQVFULSWRIFDOOPLVVLQJIURPUHFRUG          $JHQW%HYLQJWRQ
    SP                 *ORYHU                                                      WHVWLILHGWKDW³>I@URPWKLV
                                                                                          FDOOZHNQHZWKH\ZHUH
                                                                                          JRLQJWRPHHW´
                                                                                          SP7UDW
                 +HOHU\    6XJJV³,MXVWDLQ¶WOLNHWKDWORRNWKHRWKHU     1RQH
    SP                 3ULFH     GD\WKRXJK\RXNQRZ´
                                        
                                        ,VD\ZHMXVWJRWWRUDSPDNHVXUH
                                        HYHU\WKLQJFRRO,MXVWDLQ¶WOLNHWKDWORRNWKH
                                        RWKHUGD\GRZQWKHUH\RXNQRZ´
                                        
                                        3ULFH³,WKLQN,WKLQN,WKLQNLWVDOULJKW
                                        WKRXJK,,,GLGQ¶W\RXNQRZ,GLGQ¶WJHW
                                        QREDGYLEHV´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³2KRND\$OULJKW´
                                        
                                        3ULFH³,WKLQNHYHU\WKLQJJRRG´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³,¶PJRQQDPDNHDUXQ´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³<RXFRPLQJEDFNRXWWRQLJKW"´
                                        
                                        3ULFH³6

,DLQ¶WJRWQRFKRLFHWRFRPH
                                        RXW,DLQ¶WJRWQRFKRLFH+HJRLQJWRFDOO
                                        PHEDFNLQPLQXWHV´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³,¶PVD\LQJJLYHPHDERXWDQKRXU
                                        )RRODQG,¶OOKLW\RXULJKWEDFNOHWPHVHH
                                        ZKDW¶VKDSSHQLQJ´
                 +HOHU\    7UDQVFULSWRIFDOOPLVVLQJIURPUHFRUG        1RQHSeeSP
    SP                 3ULFH                                                       7UDW


-DQXDU\           6XUYHLOODQFHRIPHHWLQJEHWZHHQ6XJJVDQG/RQQHOO*ORYHU
                             SP7UDW

                               

                                                  

-DQXDU\        &DOOVUHFRUGHGE\6XJJV:LUHWDS

    'DWH       $FWLYDWLRQ    2WKHU     ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                                                   7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
                1XPEHU        3DUW\                                                                                 %HYLQJWRQ
                   +HOHU\    6XJJV³,¶PZDLWLQJEDE\,DLQ¶WIRUJRW                                  $JHQW%HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHG
    SP                   3ULFH     DERXW\RX´                                                                WKDWZKHQ6XJJV¶VDLG
                                                                                                                ³,¶POD\LQJ´LW³UHIHUVWR
                                          3ULFH³&DXVHWKH\NHHSFDOOLQJPH                              ZDLWLQJ´SP7U
                                          ´                                                                         DW
                                          
                                          6XJJV³<HDK,NQRZLW,¶POD\LQJRQ\RX
                                          NQRZ,¶PMXVWZDLWLQJRQDFDOO´
                                          
                                          3ULFH³2KRND\%XWLIXP´
                                           
                                          3ULFH³%XWLWVXSSRVHWREHDOOJRRGWKRXJK
                                          KXK´
                                          
                                          6XJJV³<HDK7KH\JRQQDKLWPHWRQLJKW
                                          ,¶PMXVWZDLWLQJRQP\FDOO´
                                          
                                          3ULFH³2ND\´
                                          
                                          ³<HDKVRDVVRRQDVKHKLWVPH,JRQQDKLW
                                          \RX´
                   /RQQHOO   7UDQVFULSWRIFDOOPLVVLQJIURPUHFRUG                                   $JHQW%HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHG
    DP                  *ORYHU                                                                                WKDWGXULQJWKLVFDOO6XJJV
                                                                                                                      DQG/RQQHOO*ORYHU
                                                                                                                      GLVFXVVHGPHHWLQJDW
                                                                                                                      +RPH'HSRWSP
                                                                                                                      7UDW


-DQXDU\             9LGHRWDSHGVXUYHLOODQFHRIPHHWLQJEHWZHHQ6XJJVDQG/RQQHOO
                              *ORYHUDW+RPH'HSRWSeeSP7UDW/DWHUWKDWGD\D
                              FRRSHUDWLQJZLWQHVVPDGHDFRQWUROOHGSXUFKDVHIURP6XJJV6HH
                              SP7UDW

                                

                                                          

-DQ0DUFK      &DOOVUHFRUGHGE\6XJJVZLUHWDS 

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU     ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                       7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                     %HYLQJWRQ
                -XOLDQ    -RKQVRQ³:KDWFKDORRNLQOLNHRYHUWKHUH"     $JHQW%HYLQJWRQ
    SP                 -RKQVRQ                                                  WHVWLILHGWKDWWKH
                                        6XJJV³8KZKDWFKDPHDQRQXKV

RQ        UHIHUHQFHVWRWK6WUHHW
                                        WKHVWRUHWLS"´                                DQGQG6WUHHWZHUH
                                                                                       VLJQLILFDQWEHFDXVH³3&3
                                        -RKQVRQ³<HDK´                               LVFRPPRQO\VROGLQ
                                                                                       TXDQWLWLHVRIRXQFHV
                                        6XJJV³6

XKZKDW¶VWKDWVL[WHHQWKXK       DQGRXQFHV´DQGWKDW
                                        RYHUWKHUHE\XKZKDW¶VWKDWVRXWKHDVWWKDW   ZKDWWKLVH[FKDQJH
                                        LWXVHWREHDW"´                              PHDQWZDVWKDW³0U
                                                                                       6XJJVLVLQGLFDWLQJKH
                                        -RKQVRQ³<HDK´                               KDVRXQFHVDQG0U
                                                                                       -RKQVRQFRPPHQWVWKDW
                                        6XJJV³<HDKVL[WHHQWKVWUHHW\HDKRYHU        \RXSUHYLRXVO\VXSSOLHG
                                        WKHUHVL[WHHQWKSODFH\RXNQRZZKHUHWKH       PHZLWKRXQFHV´
                                        VWRUHDWRYHUWKHUH´                          SP7UDW
                                        
                                        -RKQVRQ³2KRN´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³8P8P\HDKJRGGDPQER\\RX
                                        PXVWEHPRYLQJDORWRIIXUQLWXUHDURXQGLQ
                                        WKHEDVHPHQWKXK"´
                                        
                                        -RKQVRQ³6

,PHDQ\RXDLQ¶WSXWPHRQ
                                        QXWWLQEXWQGVWUHHWWKDW¶VJRQH´
                                        
                                        ³,PLJKWQHHGWRFRPHVHH\RXWKRXJK´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³2N+RZORQJ\RXJRQQDEH
                                        EHIRUH\RXFRPHRYHUKHUH"´

                                                 

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU    ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                      7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                   %HYLQJWRQ
                +HOHU\   3ULFH³0DQPRWK>@HUI

SUHVVLQJPH       1RQH
    SP                 3ULFH    EDE\´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³<HDK7KH\VWLOOJRWXVDWDVWDQG
                                       VWLOOWKRXJKFKDPS\RXNQRZ´
                                       
                                       3ULFH³2K\HDK´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³<RXNQRZZKHQVRPHWKLQJOLIWXS
                                       ,¶PJRQQDOHW\RXNQRZ´
                                       
                                       3ULFH³2ND\,WKRXJKWPD\EH\RXJRW
                                       VSRRNHGRUVRPHWKLQJ\RXNQRZ´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³1DZKHOOQDZPDQ,¶PMXVW
                                       KROGLQJRQPDQ´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³<HDKEXWVRRQDV,JHWDFDOO)RRO
                                       ,¶PJRQQDKLW\RXXSEDE\´
                                       
                                       3ULFH³<HDKWKHPQLJJDVSUHVVLQ<RX
                                       KHDUPHPDQ"´
                (UQHVW   6XJJV³$KDLQ¶WQRWKLQJLQWKHKRXVH        1RQH
    SP                 *ORYHU   :KDW¶VJRLQJRQ":DLWLQJRQFX]WRKLWPH
                                       EDFN,KDGMXVWFDOOHGKLP´
                                       
                                       *ORYHU³<RXGLG´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³<HDK,¶PMXVWZDLWLQJRQKLPWR
                                       JHWEDFNLQWRXFKZLWKPH´
                                       
                                       *ORYHU³MXVWFKHFNLQJZLWK\RX´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³<HDK,¶PMXVWOD\LQJRQKLP+H
                                       VDLGKHZDVJRQQDFRPHKROOHUDWPH´

                                                

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU      ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                     7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                    %HYLQJWRQ
                *OHQGDOH   6XJJV³:KDW¶VKDSSHQLQJ"                    1RQH
    SP                 /HH        
                                         /HH³:KDW\RXLQWKHKRXVH"´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³1DK,¶PPRYLQJDURXQG´
                                         
                                         /HH³,QHHGWRJHWRQH´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³:KHUH\RXDW"´
                                         
                                         /HH³,¶PVLWWLQJXSDW7DNRPD6WDWLRQULJKW
                                         QRZ´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³$OULJKWFDXVH,ZKDW¶VXSLV
                                         HYHU\WKLQJWKHUHRUZKDW"´
                *OHQGDOH   6XJJV³,¶PDERXWWRULGHXSWKHUH\RXLQ   1RQH
    SP                 /HH        WKHVWDWLRQQRZ"´
                                         
                                         ³,VD\,¶PJRQQDULGHXSWKHUH<RXQHHG
                                         PHWRULGHXSWKHUH"´
                                         
                                         /HH³<HDKLI\RXZDQWWR´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³$OULJKW,EHXSWKHUH´
                *OHQGDOH   6XJJV³,¶PRXWVLGH´                 1RQH
    SP                 /HH        
                                         /HH³$OULJKW´

                                                   

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU      ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                        7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                       %HYLQJWRQ
                -XOLDQ     6XJJV³<HDKPDQEXWDVXSSRVHWRVRPH        $JHQW%HYLQJWRQ
    SP                 -RKQVRQ    PRUHRIWKHUHDOHVWDWHVXSSRVHGO\EDFNLQ      WHVWLILHGWKDW6XJJVDQG
                                         WKHZHHNHQGPDQ,ZDLWHGRQ\RX,VHHQ       -RKQVRQZHUHWDONLQJ
                                         \RXDLQ¶WFDOOHGPHV

\RXNQRZ"´            DERXW/HHDQGDQRWKHU
                                                                                   DVVRFLDWH-RKQDQGWKDW
                                         ³,FDQ¶WKHDU\RXZKDWKDSSHQ"´                ³0U6XJJVLVFRQFHUQHG
                                                                                         WKDW*OHQGDOH/HHLV
                                         -RKQVRQ³'LG\RXKROGWKHPWKUHHGRZQ"´        WHOOLQJ-RKQHYHU\WKLQJ
                                                                                         WKDWWKH\¶UHGRLQJDQGLI
                                         6XJJV³1DK,¶PVD\LQJ,¶PJRLQJWRJLYH      -RKQLVDUUHVWHGIRU
                                         LWWR\RXDOODWRQH,JRW\RX´               VRPHWKLQJKHZLOOWHVWLI\
                                                                                   DJDLQVWWKHP´
                                         ³+HGRQ¶WZDQWQRWKLQJLQOLIHWKHQHYHU\      SP7UDW
                                         WKLQJKHGRKHJRWWRGLVFXVVZLWK%LJ
                                         -RKQWKDW¶VDQRWKHULVVXH,JRWZLWKKLP,
                                         GRQ¶WZDQW-RKQLQP\EXVLQHVVGRQ¶W
                                         NQRZ-RKQIHHLQJ\RXHYHU\WKLQJ\RXZLQG
                                         PHXS
                                         
                                         ³<HDK-RKQJRQQDEHWKHILUVW
                                         PRWKHUI

WRJHWRQWKDWVWDQGRQXVLI
                                         LIWKH\VQDWFKKLPXSDERXWVRPHWKLQJ´
                                         
                                         ³8KKXK\HDKDQGWKHQJRQQDUXQWRWKH
                                         QH[WFUHZDQGWHOOWKHPZKDW¶VJRLQJRQ
                                         ZLWKXV´
                *OHQGDOH   9RLFHPDLOPHVVDJH³&X]JLYHPHDFDOO,        1RQH
    SP                 /HH        QHHGWZRRIWKRVHWLFNHWV´
                *OHQGDOH   6XJJV³,¶PZLWKP\SDUWQHUQRZ,¶P           1RQH
    SP                 /HH        JRQQDFDOO\RXEDFNLQDQKRXU´
                                         
                                         /HH³,JRWDIHZSHRSOHZDLWLQJ´

                                                  

    'DWH       $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU      ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                            7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
                1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                           %HYLQJWRQ
                 *OHQGDOH   6XJJV³<HDKPDQWKHWKHSHRSOHVKDVJRW           %HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDW
    SP                  /HH        PHZDLWLQJWKDW¶VZK\,GLGQ¶WKLW\RXEDFN         ZKHQ6XJJVVD\VWKDW
                                          \HWFDXVH,VWLOOOD\LQJPDQ,PHDQZH            KH¶V³VWLOOOD\LQJ´ZKDW
                                          WRJHWKHUEXW,¶PMXVWZDLWLQJRQKLPWR           WKDWPHDQVLVWKDW6XJJV
                                          \RXNQRZ´                                          LV³VWLOOZDLWLQJRQKLV
                                                                                              VRXUFHRIVXSSO\´
                                          /HH³2KRND\´                                     SPDW
                                          
                                          6XJJV³7KDW¶VZK\,GLGQ¶WFDOO\RXEDFN
                                          \HW:KHUH\RXLQWKHKRXVH"´
                                          
                                          /HH³1R,¶PVLWWLQJRQWKHEORFN,¶P
                                          MXVWJRLQJWRWHOOWKHPSHRSOHVWKH\JRWWR
                                          ZDLW´
                                          
                                          6XJJV³<HDKMXVWWHOOWKH>P@WRKROGRQ
                                          WKDW¶VDOO,¶PMXVWZDLWLQJRQKLPWR\RX
                                          NQRZWDNHFDUHZKDWKHJRWWRGR´
                 *OHQGDOH   /HH³:KDW¶VJRLQJRQ"´                             1RQH
    SP                  /HH        
                                          6XJJV³<HDKLWLVVXSSRVHWREHVRPHWLPH
                                          ODWHUWKLVHYHQLQJPDQ´
                                          
                                          /HH³$OULJKW´
                                          
                                          6XJJV³,¶OOFDOO\RXDVVRRQDV,¶PDEOH
                                          WRJHWLQWRXFKZLWKKLP´
                 -DPHV      6XJJV³:KDW¶VJRLQJRQZLWK\RX"´          1RQH
    SP                  3DUNHU     
                                          3DUNHU³,¶OOEHXSWKHUHODWHURQDKROOHU
                                          DW\RXDOLWWOHODWHURQWKRXJK´
                 -XOLDQ     6XJJV³:KDW¶VXS-RH"´                            1RQH
    SP                 -RKQVRQ    
                                          -RKQVRQ³,¶PULJKWKHUHZDLWLQJRQ\RX,
                                          JRWWKDWWKLQJIRU\RX´
                                          
                                          6XJJV³:KDWWKLQJ%RE"´
                                          -RKQVRQ³7KDWOLWWOHEDODQFH,RZH\RX´

                                                    

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU    ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                       7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                    %HYLQJWRQ
                (UQHVW   *ORYHU³&X]DLQ¶WFDOO\RXEDFN\HW´        1RQH
    SP                 *ORYHU   
                                       6XJJV³1DZPDQV

,¶PVWLOOOD\LQJ
                                       ´
                                       
                                       ³0RWKHUI

JRWPHIUXVWUDWHGDVD
                                       PRWKHUI

´
                                       
                                       *ORYHU³+LVV

VKRXOGEHLQPRWLRQ
                                       LQDPLQXWH\RXNQRZ"´
                                       
                                       ³<HDKKHVD\ZDLWLQJRQWKHPWRFDOOKLP
                                       +HJRWDOOKHJRWDOOSDSHUUHDG\WRJR\RX
                                       NQRZ"´
                 (UQHVW   6XJJV³<HDK\RXWDONWRROH+HOHU\3ULFH    1RQH
    SP                 *ORYHU   PDQ"´
                                       
                                       *ORYHU³:KR"´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³7DONWR%UR"´
                                       
                                       *ORYHU³1DKDLQ¶WWDONWRKLPPDQ,DLQ¶W
                                       WDONWR%URWKHULQDZKLOHPDQ´
                                       
                                       6XJJV,KHDUGWKDWFUHHSDVVFDOOHGDQG
                                       FKHFNHGRQKLP,MXVWDLQ¶WKHDUGIURPKLP
                                       \RXNQRZ´
                                       
                                       *ORYHU%URWKHUDLQ¶WKLWWLQJRQQRWKLQJ
                                       %URWKHUGRQ¶WZDQWQRWKLQJPDQ7KDW
                                       MRNHUGRQ¶WZDQWQRWKLQJ-DFN´
                                       
                                       6XJJV<HDKPDQ´
                                       
                                       *ORYHU³2QO\WKLQN%URWKHUGRZDON
                                       DURXQGORRNVOLFNDQGWDONVOLFN\RXNQRZ´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³2OG%URWKHU3ULFH´

                                                

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU    ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                         7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                      %HYLQJWRQ
                 +HOHU\   6XJJV³PDQZHVKRXOGXPKDYHWKDWD       %HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDW
    SP                 3ULFH    DSDUWPHQWFOHDQHGRXWRQHGD\WKLVZHHN          6XJJV¶UHIHUHQFHWRDQ
                                       \RXNQRZ´                                       ³DSDUWPHQW´ZDVKLP
                                                                                        ³OHWWLQJ0U3ULFHNQRZ
                                       3ULFH³+XK"´                                    WKDWKHVKRXOGKDYH3&3
                                                                                        IRUVDOHWKHIROORZLQJ
                                       6XJJV³ZHVKRXOGKDYHWKDWDSDUWPHQW      ZHHN´SP7U
                                       FOHDQHGRXWRQHGD\WKLVZHHNWKHQ\RXFDQ       DW
                                       PRYHLQWKHUH\RXNQRZ"´                         
                                       
                                       3ULFH³2K\HDK´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³<HDKEXWRWKHUWKDQWKDWDLQ¶W
                                       QRWKLQJJRLQJRQ´
                 (UQHVW   *ORYHUWDONLQJDERXW*UHJ%XWOHU³KH         %HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDW
    SP                 *ORYHU   RZHGPHDWUD\+HJLYHPHDGHXFH´   WKHZRUG³WUD\´ZDVD
                                                                                        ³FRGHZRUG´IRU³WKUHH
                                       6XJJV³2KRN´                                  WKUHHKXQGUHGWKUHH
                                                                                        WKRXVDQG,QWKLV
                                       *ORYHU³>+@HJDYHPHDSLDQRWKRXJK´     SDUWLFXODUFRQWH[W,
                                                                                        ZRXOGVD\WKUHHWKRXVDQG
                                       6XJJV³,WROG\RX*UHJZDQWWREHLQWKH        EHFDXVHKHWDONVDERXWD
                                       JDPHVREDG´                                    G>H@XFHDQGWKHQDSLDQR´
                                                                                        DQG³>D@SLDQRLVDFRGH
                                       *ORYHU³<HDKKHVXUHGR´               IRUD³WKRXVDQGGROODUV
                                                                                         OLNHDJUDQGSLDQRD
                                                                                         JUDQG´SP7UDW
                                                                                         
                (UQHVW   *ORYHU³>&>RXVLQWKRXJKDLQ¶WJRWEDFNDW 1RQH
    SP                 *ORYHU   \RX":KDW¶VXSZLWKROGFX]WKRXJKPDQ"´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³0RWKHUI

MXVWJRWXV
                                       OD\LQJ´
                +HOHU\   3ULFHEDFNJURXQGFRQYHUVDWLRQSLFNHGXS      1RQH
    SP                 3ULFH    RQYRLFHPDLO³,NQRZKHDLQ¶WJRWQRWKLQJ
                                       +H¶GDEHHQFDOOHG7KHZD\ZHZDV
                                       PRYLQJWKDWVKLW´

                                                

    'DWH       $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU     ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                            7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
                1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                          %HYLQJWRQ
                 -RH-RH   -RH-RH³,WDONVWR(UQLHDERXWDERXW 1RQH
    DP                            WHQVRPHWKLQJULJKW´
                                         
                                         ³,VDLGORRNPDQ,¶PWU\LQJWRKROODDW\RX
                                         UHDOEULHI´
                                         
                                         6XJJV³<HDKKHPLJKWQRWZDQW\RXWRVHH
                                         KLPRUVRPHWKLQJ+H¶VSUREDEO\WZLVWHG
                                         PDQNQRZLQJKLP\RXNQRZ´
                 (UQHVW    *ORYHU³,MXVWVHHQ\RXUPDQ-R-R´               1RQH
    SP                  *ORYHU    6XJJV³<HDKKHMXVWFDOOHGPHVD\LQJKH
                                         ZDVWU\LQJWRFRQWDFW\RX,¶PRXWRIWRZQ
                                         ´
                                         
                                         ³:KDW¶VJRLQJRQZLWKROGWRXJKDVV-R
                                         -R"´
                                         *ORYHU³>+@HFDOOHGPHWRJHWPHWRJRDOO
                                         WKHZD\XSWR(GJHZRRGPDQ,¶PWRWLQJ
                                         HYHU\WKLQJDQGWKHPPRWKHUI

DLQ¶W
                                         JRWWKHLUPRQH\UHDG\RUQRWKLQJ´
                                         
                                         ³+HFDOOHGPHWKLVPRUQLQJWRFRPHE\DQG
                                         VHHKLPZHWDONHG6R,VDLGZHOO-R-R\RX
                                         NQRZDK5LJKWQRZ,DLQ¶WJRWP\KRXVH
                                         UHDG\\HWEXWZKHQ,JHWP\KRXVHUHDG\
                                         ,JLYHKLPDFDOO,JHWVXSWKHUH,¶P
                                         VLWWLQJDURXQGDERXWPLQXWHVLQWKHFDU
                                         ZDLWLQJIRUKLPWRFRPHRXWRIWKHEXLOGLQJ
                                         DQGKHFRPHVRXWRIWKHEXLOGLQJPDQKH
                                         DLQ¶WJRWQRQRPRWKHUIXFNLQJ1V´
                 +HOHU\    9RLFHPDLO³$SSOHJLYHPHDFDOOPDQ,           1RQH
    SP                  3ULFH     QHHGWRKHDUIURP\RXPDQ,W¶VXUJHQW
                                         PDQ<RXNQRZZKDW¶VJRLQJRQPDQ
                                         *LYHPHDFDOOPDQ,QHHGWRKHDUIURP
                                         \RX´

                                                   

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ    2WKHU      ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                       7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU        3DUW\                                                      %HYLQJWRQ
                 +HOHU\     6XJJV³&DQ,VSHDNWR%URWKHU"´          1RQH
    SP                  3ULFH      
                                          3ULFH³'DPQ)RRO´
                                          
                                          ³0DQ,WHOO\RXPDQ\RXQHHGWRFRPHKROOD
                                          DWPHPDQ´
                                          
                                          6XJJV³,¶PRQP\ZD\)RRO´
                                          
                                          3ULFH³%XWMXVWFRPHRQPDQFDXVH,QHHG
                                          \RXDWRJRWDNHFDUHRIVRPHWKLQJUHDO
                                          TXLFN´
                                          
                                          6XJJV³$OULJKW,¶PDFRPHWDONWR\RX´
                 +HOHU\     6XJJV³%HULJKWWKHUHLQPLQXWHV´         1RQH
    SP                  3ULFH
                 +HOHU\     3ULFH³,VKRXOGEHKLWWLQJ\RXDLQDGD\   1RQH
    DP                  3ULFH      RUVR´
                 +HOHU\     9RLFHPDLOPHVVDJH³)RRODQVZHU\RXU           1RQH
    SP                  3ULFH      SKRQHPDQI

\RXGRQ¶WOLNHPRRODRU
                                          ZKDW"´


0DUFK              7UXFNEXJLQVWDOOHG

0DUFK             6HDUFKRI6XJJV¶KRPHLWHPVVHL]HGLQFOXGHGVHYHQERWWOHVRI3&3
                             EXFNHWVWKDWVPHOOHGRI3&3DQGKDG3&3UHVLGXHDLUIUHVKHQHUD
                             PHDVXULQJFXSIXQQHOILQJHUSULQWRQEXFNHWLQFDVKDOOIURP
                             EDVHPHQWDQGVHYHQRXQFHERWWOHVRI3&3LQDWWLF

0DUFK             7UXFN%XJ$FWLYDWLRQ/RQQHOO*ORYHUDQG&KULVWLDQ'RQDOGVRQ
                             'LGQRWLQFULPLQDWH+HOHU\3ULFHRU(UQHVW*ORYHU

0DUFK$SU &DOOVUHFRUGHGE\6XJJVZLUHWDS

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ    2WKHU      ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                       7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
               1XPEHU        3DUW\                                                      %HYLQJWRQ
                  *OHQGDOH   /HH³+H\&X]EULQJPHDGHXFH´               1RQH
    SP                  /HH        
                                          6XJJV³$OULJKWRND\,VHH\RXZKHQ,JHW
                                          WKHUH´

                                                     

    'DWH       $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU    ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                         7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW
                1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                      %HYLQJWRQ
                  +HOHU\   6XJJV³:KDW¶VKDSSHQLQJZLWK\RXEDE\"´         1RQH
    SP                 3ULFH    
                                        3ULFH³,ZDQW\RXMXVWWRFRPHKROOHUDWPH
                                        ZKHQ\RXJHWDFKDQFH´
                                        
                                        6XJJV2ND\,¶OOFDOO\RXDVVRRQDV,JHWWR
                                        WKH\DUGWRP\FDU*LYHPHDERXW
                                        PLQXWHV´
                  +HOHU\   6XJJV³,¶POHDYLQJRXWWKHGRRUQRZ´    1RQH
    SP                  3ULFH
                  +HOHU\   3ULFH³<HDKZKDW¶VXS"´                         1RQH
    SP                  3ULFH    
                                        6XJJV³,¶PLQURXWH,EHWKHUHLQDERXW
                                        PLQXWHV%HORRNLQJRXWIRUPH´
                  +HOHU\   6XJJV³&RPHRQRXWVLGH´                        1RQH
    SP                  3ULFH    
                                        3ULFH³0DQ\RXEHHQKDYLQJPHVLWVWLOOIRU
                                        KRXUVPDQ´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³0\EDG,¶PSXOOLQJXS*LYHPH
                                        PLQXWHV,¶PFRPLQJDURXQGWKHFRUQHU
                                        ´
                  +HOHU\   3ULFH³,XPKDYHVRPHVRPHERG\ZDQWD         1RQH
    SP                  3ULFH    WRKROOHU,QHHGWRKROOHUDW\RXWKRXJK
                                        PDQ´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³$OULJKW,¶OOULGHGRZQWKHUHFDXVH,
                                        JRWWRFRPHEDFNWKDWZD\DQ\ZD\´
                  +HOHU\   3ULFH³<HDKPDQLWVRQVFKHGXOHEDE\,¶P      1RQH
    SP                  3ULFH    ZDLWLQJRQ\RXPDQ´
                                        
                                        6XJJV³+H\ORRN,GRQ¶WOLNH,¶PVD\LQJ
                                        ,¶PDMXVWFRPHWR\RXUDXQW¶VMRLQWPDQ
                                        ZKHUH,VHHQ\RXDWHDUOLHUDQGOHDYH\RX
                                        WKHPLQYLWDWLRQV´
                                        
                                        ³,UDWKHUFRPHEDFNWR\RXDXQWMRLQWPDQ
                                        DQGVHH\RX´
                                        
                                        ³,¶PJRLQJEHLQURXWHVREHORRNLQJRXWIRU
                                        PH´
                                        
                                        3ULFH³$OULJKW)RRO´


                                                  

$SULO               7UXFN%XJ/RQQHOO*ORYHUDQG6XJJV,QFULPLQDWHG+HOHU\
                             3ULFH

$SULO              &DOOVUHFRUGHGE\6XJJVZLUHWDS

    'DWH      $FWLYDWLRQ   2WKHU    ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW                              7HVWLPRQ\IURP
               1XPEHU       3DUW\                                                           $JHQW%HYLQJWRQ
                 -DPHV    3DUNHU³,¶PDWU\WRKROODDW\RX´         1RQH
                             3DUNHU   
                                       6XJJV³$OULJKW:KHQ\RXFRPLQJEDFN"´
                                       
                                       3DUNHU³,¶PDJRDKHDGDQG,FRPLQJEDFN
                                       WRPRUURZ´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³2K\HDK\HD,¶PMXVWVD\LQJ,,DLQ¶W
                                       NQRZZKDWZDVJRLQJRQPDQ:HJRWRJHWRQ
                                       SDJHWRJHWKHU\RXNQRZ"´
                                       
                                       3DUNHU³<HDK,ZDVFDOOLQJ\RX,ZDV
                                       ORRNLQJIRU\RXUDVV´6XJJV³>:@KDW\RXZDQWPH
                                       WRGR"'R\RXZDQWPHWRKROOHUDW\RXUURRPPDWH
                                       ODWHURQRURUKRZGR\RXZDQWWRGRLW´
                                       
                                       3DUNHU³<HDKPDQXPP,¶PD,¶PDFDOOKLPXS
                                       QRZULJKW$QGWHOOKLPWKDW\RXNQRZVD\
                                       HYHU\WKLQJJRRGZLWKKLPWKRXJK´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³2ND\´
                                       
                                       3DUNHU³+HKHKHKHNQRZVZKDWWRVD\WR\RX´
                                       
                                       6XJJV³$OULJKW´
                                       
                                       3DUNHU³$QGKHNQRZWRFDUU\LWVR\RXMXVW\RX
                                       NQRZ´
                 -DPHV    3DUNHU³P\URRPPDWHKH¶VZDLWLQJRQ\RX´      1RQH
    SP                 3DUNHU   
                                       6XJJV³>7@HOOKLP,¶OOULGHRXWWKHUHDERXWQLQH´


$SULO          6XJJVZLUHWDSHQGV$JHQW%HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDWWKHZLUHWDSZDVWDNHQ
                        GRZQEHFDXVHWKHIRFXVRIWKHLQYHVWLJDWLRQZDVVKLIWLQJWRKLVVXSSOLHU
                        /RQQHOO*ORYHUDQGLGHQWLI\LQJKLVRWKHUFXVWRPHUVDQGKLVVRXUFHRI
                        VXSSO\SeeSP7UDW

$SULO         7UXFN%XJ/RQQHOO*ORYHUDQG6XJJV,QFULPLQDWHG(UQHVW*ORYHU


                                                  

0D\     7UXFN%XJ/RQQHOO*ORYHUDQG6XJJV,QFULPLQDWHG+HOHU\3ULFH
                
0D\    7UXFN%XJ/RQQHOO*ORYHUDQG&RUQHOO*ORYHU,QFULPLQDWHG
                 (UQHVW*ORYHU
                
0D\    6HDUFKRI-DPHV3DUNHU¶VDSDUWPHQW)URPWKHNLWFKHQWKHLWHPVVHL]HG
                 LQFOXGHGWZRERWWOHVFRQWDLQLQJ3&3UHVLGXHDSODWHZLWK3&3UHVLGXHD
                 ER[KROGLQJTXDUWHURXQFHJODVVERWWOHVDIXQQHODVFDOHDQGDFLJDUHWWH
                 OLNHLWHPXVHGIRUVPRNLQJ3&3SP7UDWIURP
                 3DUNHU¶VEHGURRPWKHLWHPVVHL]HGLQFOXGHGVHYHUDOJODVVERWWOHVWKDW
                 VPHOOHGOLNH3&3DQGVHYHUDOVPDOOHUYLDOVSP7UDW

-XQH   7UXFNEXJWHUPLQDWHG

                6HDUFKRI(UQHVW*ORYHU¶VKRXVH,WHPVVHL]HGLQFOXGHGGLJLWDOVFDOH
                 ELOOZLWKKHURLQRQLWOLWWOHEDJJLHVRQHZLWKKHURLQLQLWWZRVKRHER[HV
                 ILOOHGZLWKVPDOOJODVVERWWOHVDQGWRSVWZRWXUNH\EDVWHUVWZRH\H
                 GURSSHUVMXLFHERWWOHZLWKJUDPV3&3&RUQHOO*ORYHU¶VILQJHUSULQWV
                 ZHUHRQWKHVKRHER[YDQLOODH[WUDFWERWWOHVZLWKJUDPV3&3WZR
                 IXQQHOVWXUNH\EDVWHUVKRWJXQULIOHER[HVRIDPPXQLWLRQ

                $UUHVWRI6XJJV,WHPVVHL]HGLQFOXGHGLQFDVKDQGWZRFHOOSKRQHV
                 RQHZDVWKHRQHWKDWKDGEHHQZLUHWDSSHG&HOOSKRQH³FRQWDFWV´
                 PDWFKHG+HOHU\3ULFH¶VQXPEHUZLWKWKHQDPH³%URWKHU´

                






                                           
