Court Opinion

ID: 6315356
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-02-18 20:28:56.34737+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:01:40.675076
License: Public Domain

The opinion of the court was delivered
by
Knox, J.
In order to validate a lien for materials furnished for the credit of a building, the claim must be filed within six months from the delivery of the materials; but' where the delivery is in pursuance of an entire contract, the lien limitation does not begin to run until the contract is performed. Bartlett v. Kingan, 7 Harris, 341 ; Duncan v. Phillips, not yet reported.
A book of original entries, kept by a paper-hanger, is evidence of paper furnished and labor bestowed in putting it upon the walls, where the entry is made as soon as the quantity of paper is ascertained from its use and the amount of work done in using it, although it required several days to finish the work. Kock v. Howell, 6 W. and S. 350.
When facts have been found by an auditor and approved by the court below, the case must manifest most flagrant error in order to justify this court in interfering with the report. Per Lowrie, J., in Meaga's Appeal, 7 Harris, 222.
The principles above stated affirm this decree. We cannot say that there was no evidence — that the lumber was furnished under an entire contract, and we think that the book of original entries, corroborated as it was by the testimony of Daniel Pile, sufficiently proved Hollinbach’s claim.
Decree affirmed at appellant’s costs.