Court Opinion

ID: 4069210
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 00:28:46.791042+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:06:51.779609
License: Public Domain

""*'_'W~"”'" 59 KZ'UZ

 

5 ///( 36/ . 2162in IN
;z/géw gain/name 377¢"/8 codR'roFch.'nNALAPPEALs
grownwo<>d/ 7“§@°’ %g°‘ sEP 2321115

_Dea¢:_;]‘l'¢/T.l.j.__e/ BLca/.a -~ 1 W€M,¢G~§Ya’,gjm§©)$

 

 

ms pr[ca) )a f rcs~/>g¢}-F§Jl)_]_wr/~¢@_~£L»¢j /e#e.<_~£z_/voq_m er_j_)mjl§ h@per_ you_w/{[___

_+O.ke 'n~¢_aS/c{e/a{-raq h_u/)c/€,GS“FQ/')d~ h7~:/_-"-00;\_0~)1£¢~¢'(1\7_¢¢_)o¢,/,_/qu_amlI__é\!d$'
_al_re§:'{:'ed_w_q_\_]_l> ac/C oq__ c/n6_. /_"27 /_;‘7`1~.9~$__197 ecczc/_Y.€__I 0205_5¢¢5?/0€¢-&€&_ aF hal/1 n7_ée@¢\
_/hL/_o/ueA_/n_o._!o_u /_611;_7_9601_/101£;9&_+‘(@¢\, \/e_HJZ_édp_“F'm/b_CVCLJ_QC“E/a |_/ )Q/_?O_Cere|:'_
-r<0p _ _ <0/.@.¢:\‘~§_. b\<>w¢_\~¢\”? m£/i r\_)"k€/~§_'FQ-}€f @_¢_72*:6¢2-$`_ /~_-'L dick on€__hdr_m+`o cm 626_~)5.¢)_612_ _J QN:.
_d_o_r_\_+_é»_@¢_\/_e__¥_»ée_res_arce;’ 767_/16§0_,.@/»7 _st,_-,L_-¢@L¢m,__,.w_¢)_s_cow, c.:£e,d,_b<] a_ J 1,1¢3_“_'_
_cznc/__$_@/_~,,é;>,,\¢; _~/:0__"?'_‘2~_760:5_¢/)4 pc/_sonm_ecd-<,_TX@_<_Q r>.v£m‘jb¢\.w_ 6M#P»rme<£__l>_7_~/:l. e_
_2/€_\/.@¢141 Co_ch_gf,qf/,@/_G+£m#ml_v:€»@s _1_0_406_¢,_/€_110._ /> 0 A> f d, 210/2
_a_c< ,1>/>/¢ 'oaéo_ ~_£0661_017@1§\¢_0_1§£_§_£€§§_ C_Q/;_\¢§__ cha//@/L?¢ _-H\w ('¢0/~ 1015an 101, %g
_'1/_5:6_-0_¥_1;;§_1/_@)__¢; /re@_<;\_7_f0_@_r_ed_0/)¢_d€n¢ed 67_%€__7/0/66//@@¢¢? C'_w+; H?¢@`r;/mJ/~ jj
fe c_Qv.Y_Qd_JQ-o nn_+ALdffe//@`/&_Mfm€j_,@ €n_&oj/QJM_JJN_%ALC_O _,e_~]_cz;§_~¢/_»_e_+r/al€_ouy:k
152~/&0/@/.~0€@£_6-?_-&?<>\(';_£4_0_50§_»2€72/0+0/>/»[¢@;{-@ n_L,j_(/_re_cg;£_%_ 6 /_n_\/ei_-l:j;a¢o ,\__&'116_
_r_~@.fzo_r:}’ fj:r_`7_€c1__)40 szO_u_f d_i ;>011{6____1‘_'[6_ /me€cw€_o ,_\__-Fof__él_aja_ fL_G__f\"‘_'__/>zoeé_
_b_q_m_€¢6(0_€¢_a%_~é17~'£)46_0 0'.'1£_0_&7"_’_ CO_ udL_ C[€_(_}\/_WQ__:/&/ _a-£ra,{,r
')Cor ~l-H f en rv~~! h Jéml' ha +RE__OLISJ' _I_`_L(Zf'_-'_ €0_ u_mL__C/€f//C{/)cl,w& 6_'_7_1{9__9_ &:Z:_QL__C_`(QWV____
_O‘_F_q_Comfg[a._n¢/_/_p;@d~€_l?_~éée_/Qrcz§€;od'a m__~)!'/m.yl__ ha_c£_ /__a__r_J_ q@$/‘Yl;mL/\ /')‘ name '
_QQ_H;__SA£ mal/ed +/e/ §0/!)/@_/6~€-,4_%/.*1€,../\/¢+ urI/>ézESHLO/xdmj_/'LO /W'/ 05100~€_ 011/111 /€_
_ ___Ceang__n"/¢¢d__£en_£l_/ed_, c)_v‘d¢¢;__l_ 1;/21.%»_ ce__Co_u_:f'_P_ 136/m ¢C_LQp/Q/_Q_. _B_Q{Q ¢e_`._f____-_
_€n?.u -1 r_€._@£bu"' a.m~jwrw,ala 1222__4:}1£6,1¢,¢0_4 /ea.m¥:_%é£,.mdiofm€,)fz//aj_am%/ Z!u£..
_Lorn.j Do)p Ym_LH.\ load hew d¢;m» sSPA, on ~»LA€ .Z.S"LA _c{o,../. §§ ,Q.y/aw,H”/995; §‘/E,o/)en
__E_~/[_:f hud `i ~H`# elliotth "7 //)}\ (~‘AD acme -l'lqKoL/yk_+/v¢__dw ré’C+U[/>/)PQ/ \S`+F§/Mm F/// f
__b@came_d_ u_sl_qe_e€_+_ke_£_@<¢r+;_¢, 66706_+ a mm ali mm mm 1/)/@»14/~? / }\/ m ~H\g

_,:|'_§~}:\'1_@__£`@¢1¥:\'_0_@@0_010_16_£0,¢31;_0 921 ms:)/ mb._wl\en_"'&_¢_:€_¢_e_§\/@d_:/:A ~@ Qmplar_nt}/____

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

nf-__q_/_Q.§_§;q.p/o_c;f¥_~€_d.~%ZLMQ§_{AQ._O_Q.€FQ&CL.§am_€,.c;l§.'£l;g,.Q/;)Q.:_M@LAJJ;MEK(/ .-

__O_a/€,.é/_>:LZQ\.§ /70/"1`@»~0"\ f`p» )qlo/°//(`ajé'c>n /-3/;~ g 701/cf £h.MLWEM/LQ_&.M%A;L@._ .,./,..

_/'_qL'_/>:E.__Ea_c_&aa_€;_d;i§m/§S€J .77,¢>,1_ 5” wm+€ SCor-P&/eelo .#p. %n..(@l . a;-é/Eca;€;j_.;//éa __
-5)(/')" ...ZQ_L.L-Z_q`_.;(l'@r ry

._...(.__ .

 

 
   
 
 
  
 
 
 
  
 
 
 
 
 
  
 
  
 
 
 

 

 

 

__d_r)£w_e£_`e;§,»£)g¢§_a/_),&_%_L>.z¢§¢/.ue;£b__rf€ad - §+&+é -\/ .j /770.:}:¢_'.:._,,3;33
MC.C¢:/:v.\.,_~.A/QF_,'.LV,Z>];E€Z€QOA_L,;&Q£&;;M;l,UJlJM?Q;},CTFQX_,_CQ//§,'_49,0,0_,_/_Z~H-éo(h:rlj¢$mpn»é 5 f °Ln('_(/ 75'£»`£/\ //.Jnov@“u/p__W/¢CQW
*_4_:(@,¢»_,/_37__3_7_».2':_~§:__1;@¢0§%0/{£ /m.. %L@-~ D/Hr¢'&/? '@;u_r_-/;§C/_'€L_l;_-IU.G__BLQU,£\_S:L€_-_;__
iogd_af_galm//.»ok}__/Qp,ae¢z/;_JQJCL€,'_£_<>;'A _:».¢`a.~d.&m.lhIM£éLe,§ca.:e.;iZZ£A¢£A¢_QQ/l;/¢b§¢&
Jr>_ _u/h:'€:€,_£ha;é_~z§é'.€_€au.d_aF_.,Q£Z/r)_{a@[‘£/Qpegl§~_ie§chL/Qi,éb_difm/;ZSLMLQF~/)/¢é¢z€¥o.z
_c/'Q_Zmlo. ~%:A£wap,el¢.faa_§o@-lac;£éi¢oa€ié/fnq.¢__,§/¢`.an_e'_wau/A/.z‘é//.me_w_/»»g!;_»%.@.._
__O_r_)£;:l:éufr_»; _(,Ua57¢.Z`Eg__@_u_r}__é>§_`.&jm.o/QG,L!.D./;Q£Q.[;__/J;;u€<£,a\,c>;@l§ri;d.¢./C€§&"c)_j~..%¢,~,._
*Q/fer/Qr_\_@f;£o_-e;¢ce¢d_@.'¢.£L(/w*ny._o:é£e'c_~p.la-‘c,cé.
_Ho_v_\;d,_ oval 710 ~ f 1551/n cl - ~Zé/\z./Qaci.€,_£jec§<
_.z.O../;z.l'e)¢l¢.,.’m+A/,o?_L£)Q£/%.éZ§LQ¢M;A/z,m;):a/M¢Q*M?-Z.QLS.).co.Qv%v¢r:)/.(r_\j_
_ .e>u;a_ddf_r§en:{;u_ac{df€$$;.§ubiez_§¢;
_gn+w v»¥s_`_b_e@awe'_h\, ~H1 e r/>?u ¢'rem@M<_g_§veca¢h§;§:@;b_zeYMQ+_-_mr .£Ls 'do hD-/-"_ '

_a/qg_kj_j:.zq;c/fq{¢i),~l:baf_-£é@. ~/v'{a\ mark ,/ ad/e&j u r~/~'f» c{/'é=»%{')n' Cf/’c{i ~r///€f'/\Q‘Hi`/@§;',LZ.)',..
-")Lu+/U ml ,» ‘ L£c_¢[)./Q\‘

_;--l,`»_‘/:Q; fe _@Lm_@%*_@*qpp;%quha;i¢%md! <>/@i.iw Fa»'f‘€$ 11~ fm"H*/
-l'/w\ -;H>»a%- soh’c~F/e>:,vkél@.pco_c~.ed_w:<>.l._-cey.u.£r_@/z)_edx_so UY“-,/r) j,o@//wé/' )"@W-'éu/~

w_ji;dge,JQ._/_c_a_[a.,_._z;ev_€r_§_._pga.ama¢;az;@gqmLer~/ 3/ 872-/ /9}/ g ,Av./QA\/¢ z§z"/B’Sz§ 51:;
__l__/_EA/f]"~ CC?/?")F/-) A/[/”D;A/ HH/,/¢'ca‘+,-{q r\',.j`$-}v'/-/ -H`mg_ §/erLd_€oL@;fXé_£HQLZ€§€&Q;L;QM
4_.Uc¢io.nd’.a;o~c‘39,_%o.;_-I:L_`_~LQ::¢§£/'l5~?1‘/[»»¢17‘~'~ alamo ,. ‘ »' 1 * ». `   ‘ v ` ` ‘

3.-//¢/,,3) h:// f am_QJ/daj;_;‘s;/a/eas;c.£a/Q;a_/@ »_@f¢£h¢za/o,@[¢;¢é.b;h_énd%cea_@é_%b:€;
_;',c)_\/;~e.;:l:‘;%£@.¢*@é§m;@£€,@_ak:l/._a-m¢;%k\@,. r@m,o/m“n;k a~+!mh{>‘<\/ aj c>z¢h.'tv=#§, 7'/»1¢> _`D_',;‘D_.
__k)a,»l 40 amé/>¢L Jé§.»€;ue@»f/J'/»~Q:rge;%e;@.§i§ea$.€,__/je_£@a£dl).e::b¢k£\+_;

_7_1_-}_\,€ - arc u$€/ ancL +M_,mee¢akq»~;: 73 n@'m_u._\¢€.;h"i (`Mr_$.@¢:ll:r_om_ié\e_;,aé¢'c§{men¥ '

_iql:;b.zo_HnL;l;L)@~f-?_LH“QE€&§Q_~/:L;&_-/'r_lc\,l_céum"_/__Q~UQC\/,ju m(’ cl }e{,<"c, 4 higgsz -)Z//L ` Wg¢ f\;,._