Court Opinion

ID: 4070385
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 01:12:23.78577+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:06:13.155714
License: Public Domain

July 23, 2015

                              aJo,oz-N'oa^^-CR

                    TttilQ Stcp^M/ JX/1)0^ }f?TWi
                                        AT An.SC/1), tliXAS
      >m mimi_n*mi************mmiji iuiiui   ii.hikju iiinniiii, iwH^gwM^—wwp—k»        >*n«>wwn>MM!W

                                                                                   '/

                                 TM£- STfl-IL of W5>,
                                                       A-PKUAL
        mnmomm*im*mim**mmmmKmfa

                          £^-/Wi5 Rilf
                                                                                             H 111 iumvj\ i'.«.".. • n i y

-RECEIVED

                                                                      AJA#S07/9, 7£M5 "77^
OMsJtt PAc/k UPfi
Zto UfUtil PK* Ad,
/J/WAidfA, 7CXA5 773a

nd.bmr^ Wl \/Atf 5iu2<foM<tl

^MOT/ilXAS 786/1

7ft M Cctutttt fee ^t'luftt

lloliJbU 57., 5^^

$|| K^dM ST.

                               •II
iMiX\Ti onHt BUS..
fhfiLL Of CoUfttJfr
"\hkt of- fr\6Wmi\f3       -
Sft^mfiotiHfLQa
 i5%jl<? m*?tiM
 9rfr)VLM\wrof- fm ftejs            *

 PWtl        _ -

CMdHCM OP CdixPU/WC£

                               di
                       lAfti. of Mamas
Ca^:

        J8G US7^/ 57^cf7fW£, /$<,& U Y?i</#7.

          lid 5/d;-2W#Zcod)__

         itf^ya^&w              _     _   _   _

           ^ftll llVC^O/LCwur/m)^

           M f.W&Cidoy),

               ^frfjy iJB/WSlw-^A
5fAT(JUK5 •'

    ai)ii€> sMs CMzmVou
               k^kUrf 8

                                TSL
PULitU1?) M OuilW A»A PtocltMMb «/t/At W JUn UIjC JU^M Cedent)
Mfttofof//to/ft W S/to*/ rjitiW K^i^Js H/S Pdofif\t\l>f\ ffi Qtt, AfftciAif, lM)

iHi SIH4. (UOtt-ftSTto TU Afci/W^ Our o'r THK \U)'rlf\Ul)Af,J Han^c^ of //-K-

/uDlcTMifijT.T'MjL K^.'K C^ci^Rm 7M< UlAL OjuM toiuA v-IM TM£

                                 X
60 MV lSilO/S JKftN hWilSkfr Ldf6 HllJtfJt H«a oU<& Uq( p flfi, //^^ //J
TIN it tofiild ALIA, /K <z*) M> U)lf( Uio vtti Uvi^Am^MCA-i fouLtj) ^.O^i/t
Or 7/-U1 OT1/ U*iffi Of UMd&^oOhlChluM7t, i-'-M'(Mi (uf&o A CoQ-Culo^QC^
f/ZATSMfti/O* c^iR. Ufc hst&tl&oof-f'M Ac*V i''Mi [Jf.HltU 4(S^ )W1ti\ turtle tyih.
 MP:. h((Z(biST^f 0(Ui\ ?// 72) /U/W />/£ \)M£ll. %-^AKi ojtftl UtJri&Jt'lHir.ACALtfAU&C*
 ktfotiih 'M Cats \m\\cu 1) <ti).
   (M\Ul kbiO kah fr ~\WL U/ruO ficllCL kfW^Cjr tfopfa) VIA. \ltf-ULu M frj M#~
 %C\\ob /J pk)0,yit- afK/l uo\\cO Hlfl S^/ac of AtCortxic teu&LAQ' And A*>Md
 Mi, Pai/WA fo 5/CP ^itT 61- HXL CML. ^J/i£j ///T M,t* A, ft)&Ayii) as^/3 A7 AM 6W a>
  ^l£cO fk unj/.THi OMC&ACtO %$MZ\ Mil. toLLMh U)l<> ULO'^Mi(htC'Au6l M ou °
   fydcQtf I Chit 6Mv-i riu^/JoT AuTichW/u; C67/U cxtf 0>- 7% C/a\ T^ooPl/i i/MliA
  CtifrMfcte klco MfUUf) AtrhCofo T) kWxDK* 7U*. hfta ^O'Upil Y' ffZSfS, /teeMifJtj
  ll&< U)UC V0T JRmid&tM UOtc^fc h\£ Criidb UJi fell fan* man(fyLCfo<& Of ///S
   \\kiMkti HL Nltfolsl U)k<> A-flik'^m fofi UuMA wMlL/f /ijiOXiai£,)t7iU OfHCUS /))P
    0(T\ Oh^tflijC ]\h\&:i( fifcTOCGL^Afiit ^*L/\L$<.tf.iri''tM4'^M l)iff?iL'tf ?*''7b
   tea /^O iV) St* ^ iWro? ?'' //J frKf, /W C'::-fliU{*> CcMM.) *)/';•? Y* klfo) /f;?:y'Vi
   /¥,Hn Ci; lT'///^ )W* Po\l(Ju/'J> Hc>\d(6( . VUJ (JOiiL) /j/?,,; 7/(^:7 /•/////7
   A tl&JPuki. - un\ for- A h(-AAUohl6l J4<i- i\uT A "hUifa • S/V"            7u /W ///' >
  hwh<,usii:?yf.LaOv //ja. U//^ u^(..\ Ma^/ 9-fcv/; 7-M-r ^^ A)/^ ^v//y^ >f
 *'h\i\te:\t tout*, dor i\t))-M£i)/at ^mok^c^U^ ?chm>> r> AOk^rn
   hfo'-ifK "A-u\\ o\-\h) 'his voT iJnfJ&j VhW fcaf f-M-jnJ faJ f?U#^~ 11CH ~Usrf/Ut
  YmW u(c. Puilm* hii) ml f\<r,j7 jo v4£ btt&) ?);iAvj-7>t.rcVky 7&^ it fai-
  Ui'-l V-ti t>icjj{)Auo>l0L T^ n-m? %AC'X Alour r:-o\crL -jf-k UMW. t<Muf n vonti)
   lit: foJiulrt hffCkuSi of jul.PoUMhfc D/A^rir rr\oD)d\J,

  UMU ikHOilCWh. hu.il/-tjC) J/vV fidi.M-lfiW.iJF Pslfct* liiff Sf/n?/ )vl«ofoUnfiy\UtJC{
  Cyr firi.)6\Ur J)uM , uJ\UC<\ QC (afitii oOMIui AtfuCfitf UAlOjjfotJb.TM Sffit
   Ai^o ixSth AO ILitCk h-MiMuiOT or A \)0to C<xJTufi*i!Lt''(H.4A- fAa*\ iWl

   v\l f-mt^ Of m)\r cu(,\hki C/Jthxa-Mii Poul^ujas m.^ cm^\* fascist
f\<) 5W|0> Ik] ^h\L\/'Ptit<iuLH V><i%M i^nsi^i) /)U I kwh raJAM^AffuJ
h lV*7l3R LVl/i^A-KtiJUflC hU(((j(LOC am}* LA^JlrJUSMJ. rX, PuhJiAiihiCM
tilQtMS-TUttMs AT ?>/K(.tfi CoafM o itlltciui - dom^ toifH Lfo» usfrAou&ur, S^-vi
AihUMkx. ACifajCiteVO roXircSUOW i PfUJKXol l<Z<&JL$'A<flAL&7tftfV<4iL faryji)A\rau
T<iS7 Ust& CcU7foA)uft-%7\ fatkuM *ikuii* mjMKIML Ant Ciutd R<i f\tef &i'fa4?$
h PAvAtSi*? VMhlA-Tfi. 7A//M M) lOMfri/OL CtA foa Uca) \JOtUAl <C>f TO fcdtOatA <••
L^llltk'S hiM f\iAu)<A ad ftf.hd&.cr Uks faM Uttej) A- tc/fxitCu Suter/to£< l-O 7M/5
Cfo£,SAUui K Ui/ah U\?A hico'i), l!\i J/uKutlTY Of Mi ^KCIWbJ AS Cot-'PWi'ri)

                IhlltfiClU A<£>l37foU Cf h)Vl 7,1/fit Au) AflMAt Couiml
U-CAuM foTM *iT*Ur'^ uhtA 7AJ<c S/h*rf M/bU, tilL /)/)) UTTul TO CHhwIotS
M/<> LUlu\*> Ckuc^-\MMfc\ TOtr) TAIK. JUft* /7/A-T /J/S CUiOjr iOA< A "Ofti*"*^
i)Mc,ic" /bu) W/fr Mrfiiii n<)7 liAutu&AiO aigjMic u^kGt , ///<; CvtxX

VM7 KliS CttibuSVuoLo fiUA" r,iift.\\ nor U& dsca )u A-fjs rarjiujM r,K£.

 fityjvli^ /W u hxy CrjjLtjTV < PucuUc* Ai/n* tu M~S£c -5ou7ftM Gxu^nMUiojr-
 (vk K UWdUL ^Ikk -OjmiOu A/J 6-/A-A4tuATIaUfu)nuOiLT * LoT Of- £_tffoJitj>W-'M)
 VW S:aT£>> POUCH Tb fu\C< "yjHHfO?*! lU SdUiAii^ /s T///V" f/^ ///K To /3^
 ^yiA^AsfcM 1//6C^;.;7" /I '^/y/J -(J-frAt) on Hl,T\(iPk'jT't 0f> /!• A)''£^CA-Pk. fid SK.'
  MO.. PflLU-fth /S <^/i/ Cr 7///V , h6 Air> A^Olli/LI LthT hi/t-r "V) (loT " iM'/
  1\\&k£. /OSKr. L)W\(>\. YcM MiCtil /jO\£ , L)\\i' ) ihf u>A--> 7'?/H//,/.R/l) To 7/11
  ^NctLlfT /ti M/7*ji«,i//Lli? , A/; MAktuM\')u<>t-l0uJt\ ilfi MA*) P^/j9/HtP5 10% ul
  lifS i^U^b a/^rMiuC A)K ^(?friu ' IS )T /L/OH 77 7/? VA ^^'J WAfe/^ 0 IS
  AM ComvLteK or- T/M PAcOUMLCS.'-A A/^^ IfUhtfAH TO tlCuU&UltL*-
  hitioUki 4Lt<*jL-*t.>> ui'^T.t.'S**" feirc Aox/Lh n> \-Ur~> M&Vte 76 PfowoTii

                                         >t.
iJML^lMMl^ 1 7>o AJofOlfrTO #6>//7- WI&L/^ ^u P^/ft Wo" AiJ) 7^/AjJ

you. £/rO a7A:6>( fafnta?) ^i^kufr uM.\) fod tom&i^M /H foA. 7mt.

ri^tofa hx\Jia?i^m£lHlo, lOiilfaxi opAuULoCaf\U)hk^L DtfAlfrpof
 ftTWftfkX /ki Ce.i\uiuH pa/XA£9/uCS.7H/^ /$ )&rf 7D 7/-/£ A.-kt Wi "A axr;
ft^M 1^ /JOT ArHVCTfcJd /K>iAK*/*J 7MAT 7AK. POAi)ftA Ce>*A*4rf*ft A ££jm* ' lUWhi),
n n a STAr^aiCkjT^r-'^ji.xa/uiL/^ to <^tv?s7 7>i£ GmcL /bS\ acou^aul^ o*
dauKM^Afl. SM/WViiHA feu* IdofM lb\(&akM>2<j!A pkWLJ^-^AtuV <f^7
ft AW* .^/6^<4/fira.r-Xo/0

CdU&fs /ItxuMMfvT Wfc 7A.ArbSPWrrAT/oO 6^V 1AMVT AvjlbUZtO k Ka% MWjfficitui,)
 7MW A^M OUfr.. ftlfoo 6„>fK /H/^Jt-Y j-te/u?, 7^&V 6JAS A SfcaA [//KwiK &«^r> f^ frt^
 AT kooVA-LCotfoL U^l /o $tcteo\ ,o%% U-lfc 7/f^ A/i/b£7 bXMvT TA.it ia* VAtoA^i
 IhlUd 5/VWt TftlAL, /bO fC/^^7 TX-CMOhj 57ttiX) TUfrTLklQuXth IfJuj DILL &U \\l
Gooi) fcfcrt/uft UV of- /h.J i .1/..'

W/VollwduoLO PaAVv? A>.Guu£l<) flf <LAi7 toi faMhSSMM oi- fafflJ/JCCu^UtcTl'pJ.

                                        A.
           O-MimiLsLSUMm

/*» cwm* tarn WL <^C4)of w. W* *u« eM****
           G

Is

 I

-^1
      \A