Court Opinion

ID: 3554579
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-07-05 23:06:03.240268+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:46:02.525743
License: Public Domain

"There is and everywhere must be a marked difference between the price allowed by a contractor for mere muscular force, and that which he may claim to be allowed for the labor of the same men when their strength is controlled and rendered effective by the exercise of his own skill, judgment, and capacity for business, and aided by his machinery and capital." Bell, J., in Currier v. Railroad, 31 N.H. 209, 224. The evidence of the customary charge made by the plaintiffs in their business had some tendency to prove the usual market or reasonable price or value of labor so furnished. Upon the question of the cost of goods, evidence of their value is competent as having some tendency to show their cost. Watts v. Sawyer,55 N.H. 38, 41. It cannot be said that evidence of the value or market price of such labor compared with the price or value of labor employed in other excavation, as shown by its market or usual price or value, or by other evidence, would not have some tendency to show the probable increased expense occasioned to the plaintiffs by the necessary drilling or blasting. The expense to the plaintiffs in procuring, directing, and paying the muscular force employed was as much a part of the expense of drilling and blasting as the actual payments made for the manual performance of the work. If it should be considered that the charge included a profit above the actual expenditure for the laborers employed and the other items of expense understood to be included therein, the evidence, so far as it related to the profit usually charged, was merely immaterial upon the issue tried. The jury were instructed not to allow any profit. It does not appear that the instructions have been disregarded, or that the evidence was used for any purpose for which it was incompetent.
Exception overruled.
CHASE, J., did not sit: the others concurred. *Page 210