Court Opinion

ID: 4038517
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 21:56:20.052201+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:06:06.778206
License: Public Domain

* Vt/<?/</ Co /fitJfJ U«tf
  Q6>&/    f^ Jos'/
                                    pjuETIn court of appeals
                                     iPthCcurtnf Apex's D
 fit ear/„ fa/i    jef^ <?o/^/

                                          TYLER TEXAS
 TZjt/ffa tov/i/ o / Atpx^ /f        CATHY S. LUSK, CLERK
 /JV7 £*srs//y^/ sftxjf su,ft 3sy

       n*t *«*t i4Ji „,„Ua ;u ^/v_ s^
 sJya: mot* **tf{f4*ts

Atj/Z AJj toxic

              7'
                   tfv. ;i~/*f-o*3jo-£lf                  iu tN COURT OF APPEALS
                          x.   /     a       a       I   l?th Court -? ^orjfals Distr ct
                    77^ *W/ p/ Appeals

                                   / £/*s
                                                                         •     -
                                                         C^THYS.LUSK, o1\ERK
                                                 Appf/)/ from ~Tjfc J£« N
                                                 J<jJt£(4/ H/s/fi/^ dovfU
 V
                                                 AfjJefLsotf CovtJ-b / yr*^4 r
T7/&S Dff^/n^J. of
Afif£/fct

     *rz Tte Hotwire ^Jots «/ a* t^y, eM/
 AJZ-in ?/?*£,?/ J**"""" /V &*/„, d«fifa
 f'/t fl^t A^fiw fin Aey>f4/iry a**J *>/// */<,& yA€ tootf/j,e iy^rx •

 fete Mnttt,ff W J,u;          1         r         f 7 " *** Vion ,M^t^ef,/s
                                   I of
   dfsjaiej. s/ft£ /AtaesMsvQ /£ Ae& ofJ^xt <*j<<S$ /w /Zrcfiya/ of Ars
   Anchor faa fi/fu/ /0./Y// s)*sJ A/* aM^//^s Fr**/ /^^f^J^y
   &ft fjjsf/il AS-hhtAt 2Tat/ fa /s+jq JuJfCfA/ fitis/fou A*tJ /*j4a/ kt*js
   jfa J/Sy>0S/f??Af fft yArs CASf, yQM/^/fff A/so Astec/ /fta/ //*" /A/
  cf/iSi £j/)S J/s/n'/ssfJ A*tJ /A* /V)ofr<?fif -fi/1 A/*t*j~7Ar4/./i*rJ /a*
 <t6Hie<7 Sy Le/Ua tf '/A* <W*/ fak «° A****/ , ^ f*y* "*/?*€ of
 A fife*/,

 fi/+c*9 /he Mofa, frt „€ul yjm/ + ywfr W y£ *W,/^J .
 "IfffoA tH JAt AH€Mfrv<S M*fi*l, y&A fi*A*4Wg, «oA ///* /$y

 A* fart <W, *s 4tI *//««/«*/JtsA^X* *>

  *fi,Vio« fZfK Aui?«%\Tj 'oTJtt tfaifti-Itf*4/* 'fit* "**"*W^
 S*4*{ jo 4AAfihA /Y*,*. A>/^0 ZQ S/t AJH/f//f A^4/AUfl -

/iff-Ay t*i -fh* Attoy*} Jufi-wj /A* sr/ /notJ/A* pA/zcefJ/*/* /A.r e/*/£ 0lf
ijkuA ih£ sfa"* /'*• -f'feJ.                              J

<»** AlfrfiHAfa fi* /UtoAto9rA,s A//^//tr ** ""'7&*/*A

yjyyr//^f Ais a,*fa, /J/ /2^^A/Jy A%*%;Mf*/i *'"* "ofis,,,
A6o»e A*/ZAf*c/ ttse, A^J /A/fy // *,„ &^y/ff^ fl"w</ /„
/?*, fl'.Atf* a- Vi>/f/i*ic/ Ma/ A ^°fr<>« /^/? fel^J?/jL*Su*"f *°
frft jAcA<f4t/Js, Mvsf/t aftAn/eJ 4 /he ^<Po/zy * 'i ^f"*. fa/* Mo/ro*/

                                   I of
  U *>y/i4«c*r u,,/h /?KA,A/>A^. V%? on aA <ff/«Ae aTaa^
 /o, o*/ /0tcf^6f/z 3,JoaS A***//* / A

                                                      M«/r«„ A,*

   *****" **"*** '*/*/£%„'f'fr *» A~fi.„ *,,,

  **<*.»} ***»fi*Astj;„t 6,4*** "* A***/>»« A*, a*-
                                  //

ZJA,Ju*e *u"i v%/< «**w*)&&///S2<'; 4/>fii//<iZf/'
                                    *-*' °7a/>s
nn«f?»S A*4jtfiq it mtfie* fit t/fuj-Tv,,:/* , *? L
•tht Iff**/, &&*/. l/«Jte fa f,«sf mZj „„1* &**<**>)//,'„ y/*j,«
 *>W AaJ 3c J^s to tuA,*4 •*>. A///ft fo* *>* /"?" TX/4//>*/> -
/&II//OVS ftfttias A*<J At* f)nfv/ie /* yAorfJe A d££/(.ft?J ^/"l

 A* It been •*•' j^/'"// *** U"J                                                    J
 0f/,sS»°'">» fiA ttkA'l'J •
   ste jciJJ </• fiA'J'K i s-"• •>'J -w'7< 3/a C'&. /0/>f- - fl/H/ifii/A, lift) (&7
•775V Sup/tern* ^eafi-i h«s it/J' iA/tf •/hf ftf/>Sort/)iff f>if>//)H4Jrotf ia/jfy^ip -
l*k:J iy &* i",,s "A 4(ft/hft f>A*ltJut£ W£*J •Ou/y COrfi/*/ 0h 4
ptAitsll/t sMZM-eJ) of tlttumsfAUtlS toJ/cj/rsj fte'f At* rfc'
\f/l lull •!<> etuHfh to'fc tl* J&J/inf (~/>-i tf*/fye/Z. "Jt/titnqfy- SS9/Z
 il,4**b***/ T'"/' '' £**"**! ** fiffur' °f i*iJ<'*fi/4«<e£s"D,
   »,s4aIs oA /»'s*4*«A€-"**/f'i fy^sk ******r/ 0* Ass Sfete/4/tb
   "'* %fa* •/o^sAffAi /****y « ***/ J*J**£ 0/J,/,ffr/c£ /
 fYX

   ///A. 6AA*A7 /&**&*& pflA,cA,/f&*j££s fiAQAAhA/Au f£/eA A'S£ " gtAdi*
      Z*t„*k /****,«" r?V**"*cA A<t, 670 CTn?.M?) /fo^g */o*«

       At/{ctiAo /*?*/ *">/"/') (sM7"J 7** W*J' ^^ *M£A Ouo/lJs, c/* -
        A./// A*'"A f*0"7 fiftQ/'cjft/AS Ofpes*J Yo MUvAo^AfoZ J*-
        i<UArt A/fiu*, ??°^-s A t€AsonA6Se£f<vt€.zrJ
   "77/f Aoufi/ <?0t//</ tnifuf* /V<fg//q/A?/c£- je •/%# Afy>tf//A*f A*td AAoy 4
       ci*///>«A4fc OA. /A>'AS.MAo*//}//&/ A/ fao// oA ft£p/ho/y /(J fat//*/y fa
   £<"hyt/y i**tj*\~'yiis/f y*i. / of/hf A*Ms A&fe oJ Afff/A?/? AAticfJis/ije
   &A41/SC // i**AS/7/ (/**/*'/ /A/i A/tAA An£f*/70As£y fy^ y^ /eJ. £fA
   lf//<FA h/)J#cl b#££**&<?A $,$oAY j* 1^/aa/ As ^€AAAn€ A'Afoujfec/osF
    oJrwA a ftvfaTZtfif 7s A A^Ason Que/ A/ask* A> 4e, /Hf TZxfs
       bep/ltlMttfi of tM"it**4/Jy*frt* TiAi/AA QoAfiJ Aolfcy 03,*AA'SfSS /o
       Aufi/s OjfmwT pA/Sof/f/s itJ AJfYHKi/sf/lA/ii/g S£yAZ£<yA/?o«/ AlA'f
        /// rJ **/« XYfAofttJ t*f>n* *f £*2*7 tASB 11fr fa*t , fiu/tS /
        liTLu ZUuj fi/t (aAO AeM7 fao/<s A*<7 A*** To /^ouj'/U £Mc/
   &t4 Alte&tfAhi'i? c/*lys AOOf/c/^ys- /^fejAjdsJAy's - fa/c/Ay's is l/Ao/^//Hif
  Appe/faAfs A'cjhf of teas* /, eovA/s, see &e*f* ly Anct<AsA/t/ -7$? J
 f,#c/ AAit,ffjt (s-fA AtA /??£){A/j/4/ ofAccess M>//?/Vc/ 4etAuSE
 fAfsorJtiH /a AcffntttAs/AAfire SeaA*a*} frow A//ow<rJ o*L $ oa j
  toojcS fit* J*<y t*"^ u<f ^^/t fcAfa^i).
    Appt/JAti/J Ac/s aAjaAc/?o«jS c*jA?A# AA^f c/*A/teAA/g oA /*//<?r/fa//a/
  A*j fheJsfivf/* AoqaJ f°Acy 03; fA Acarss A> £oua/s aaaaia/Taa/ /W/u?rt^
  fA^syj /cfitOrtton /fit Ajt+J , Aff*ffAAf /j CuAA/tf/ffy <?oa/ ffes&c/ ^a/
  AJ^reJrs/fiA/ft/€ S€g£€j4/?ff*s o^f/A a/0 Ass/s/qaacz fko*, Ahj? Z/^u/
  L'/>AAft<4 utjJffAl /ia*AJs \/ Sm'JA VJo (/'S, 2/7, dd/~J% ( Af?/)/
  AWAS '!/ /AS/tUfSAf LA, 5. JYJ. JS~0 -S/f/f^&J',
  /L Mas, AfftflA*/ It/iei/es Ax rh£*fs fit fiwsoAA/iMs fr/cuse er/ifv
              a           A        ^TIZZ         '
   AfiAyfA. foAl faAff
 &Art* fit*, fittM'sfs, Apf'faffftoufsf /a*/ /At eoy/tf Sa^a f/s
fl*/fAQ 1*i 6M«b*<) A/S ^<3f^0f/ fbAtZwf y, f>/€ ^fr /»*/*>*/**
Affaitiitj) °^'
/, Uj ti£fa£A AAS T^O A+ofarSs A* 6*/£ fsAcJ AV*/?o*S A^A A/f^rTo'^ A*        A
  u«J-*i-7T«. A. Apf</>- ItmaVcYm), to.s a>a 9tr/                     7
j. frAr/AfA. Ah SSCOAtJ AAA/of /AJA /uso AAA/ y^ A           £* fir/

   j*/,***!*. u»t J£/;J/./                   ** »ww A**, „„«,/
  hlk ftnAfwilf/l. 9% c/o/y
  fl&ffcffiA/tj soA»t, ~/fcj
 *?V/<?A?    t'/fAf/et (/„/
  <36&y     f^j   do$ y
   /rZA^ctsee JoA*** i/*X4S lr*W

                                     sr oA   b
                      ctea^ ficAk of SirAv"?

t«py of /AS AOoA^ -foA lAAUAc f> f(ff fy fa /Vjcfa^ fbA teUjMfJ*
<~*t f(*x*J AaJ fyf fifi/SotJ AyJAftAo^Av^sf a/ass yQos/4a£ A*l4r//*jy /,J
AAA AffaJtAtfi]
                        /•/**> (ZAA-cfvAu /)A6o/-A
                           / ??4J AlAA&ifi/tfcf <£'?AAfA4 f
                         d°<A l*ss/ ///A, 'sfjtfef
                         f<Q/ fay AJS ft
                         Afrifrr* rr^AAs JsyAA-ps-rs-

                              A of" 6