Court Opinion

ID: 6992486
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-24 03:27:23.400095+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:09:39.659962
License: Public Domain

Wall, J. This was a proceeding by mandamus to compel the mayor and the city council of Bloomington to remove certain alleged obstructions from Beecher street, and the question was whether the strip of ground in dispute twenty-six feet in width was a part of said street. The judgment was for defendants. The court trying the case held several propositions of law asked by the respective parties, and then of its own motion prepared and marked as held the following, showing its view of the law and the facts. “ The court holds as á matter of law that if there was a dedication of the twenty-six feet south of Beecher street, and that the same was accepted by the city, so that it became clearly and undeniably a part of said Beecher street, then that said street was sixty-six feet wide, and in such case it would be the duty of the city council to remove any obstruction placed in the street. But the court does not find as a matter of fact that the evidence shows clearly that there was a dedication, or that the city clearly accepted such dedication. The court finds from the oral and record evidence that interested parties might honestly believe, from an examination of the record of plats, and the appearance of the width of the street, that there was no such dedication or acceptance by the city, and purchase said disputed twenty-six feet in good faith, according to the plat and record description of Phoenix homestead. Therefore, the right not being clear to the writ, which, if granted, would affect the interest of persons bona -fide claiming ownership in the disputed property, and who, before what they honestly claim as their land should he taken from them, should be heard, the writ is refused.” After carefully considering the evidence we are disposed to agree with the court in this finding of the facts, and the judgment will therefore he affirmed. Judgment affirmed.