Court Opinion

ID: 4063427
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 20:54:29.235106+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:58.024844
License: Public Domain

§ 4 z "7/)%/'1'_`: 
\

0 C\CQ\K Q)C QQ\XL§\ co QQ\M)M\\ A§p©;;@\'zl
E‘?'EIW
@@LM ms mm wm APPEAL§

lUL. Y;BZUS

Ab@m@@@§a,©iev@<

 

Yf\ Q\QSQ,®~`_`
A @ - . " ‘ ' " ' ‘
,B`CL\`L w 77’7‘1 UQ\U 'Q\mm V\,o\\om w L@\uQ 7 f ,

I?'§-L\-m Qom §~\ _(
§§ sa Q\@.@>\ CW‘<>K wm w%),® ,V,\_L\J\._

`\\w\k Vw\_

YSvW\ d( \-\»\\ !K \€>%1®?0'

E\\l 3 \) fur\~

w run `¥m wm
7'\\)(\\3V\7)z/ Tq\~§ j7§q37 7

 

 

l

‘ _3 7 _ t ` w?\ g-;P)"`\O\“_Q\/ -
pv/M\'\ ‘¢\ D,.\'B\»“_N,:-. 7\7\7¥§0‘\ ; X\n 757\€/ \'e:y,,b%/ (`/GwQ/§r

~'~',` _ ' G_ v -
C""§'h\"\$ DA<\\€,\ ~ \'\APJL\S C bon/77 y
z 7 > C Rxmx wm 7

b\s\u\<,\ C_,\,:c\dk A p pm\$

'-vs

§§

9 '.‘\:r~ Vwe§\¥ 70 >(\\e, <>m\§e»g Rm.~q'momn +Q
7;@\\)€_7>$ 77\% C<>\)‘L\»~ m UAXXCP~ SBL\Q\~c>\

 

, :'v\ 7703 vw+\¥c<>)?\ 7<>€¥\3€® \BQ.W\ b .\~\\\\ mc\)\\oq mc)`

. C\ -
_ Q\\(L\s b»;m§\( B\sm;§ §§ ~»c\\@ CQULX \w\c»§
.\.“ \)(`§ C)QQ<\S{OO'YOQNclq/\L C,\ML\S b.¢\me,\ Q`€S(Jc)¢\c}em\r‘*' \\.C>‘] Q\QLOK<:`A, S\xb'm\X A<\\-e-Q).:§ ccp\i 077 A 7\\'\€,\`\3 sme®
_, 0"§©@\1 ~\7\¢<'\ \€573 \r\ Rep\\`/> 7® 77¢\@ C@QRXS c>Qc§QZ 771¢€: 71&~\'7>€,'(>¥0\)1©7@® y
\MM A Co§>\i 677 A\\ Q\.Qs\>i) 9\§@`u@37 \71)~\\ \P 77a w\z\\ o@\v\‘>ww l
C®Q\?\l§ APP\L\O\\\c>/\ M-é-'A,_\A%%&'M,»\X 3\)9@7eme.<\7 md &`n@? @PM&M"
SCKYQ>Q\A)NLQ:$ 70 7\1& Co\)a\ v<>7: C>`m_u\)¢\\ A\)pu\\§ 77\77 55 /*7709~07@/0`7' -‘
QK 7§§» 771& 6990<1`»7\)0\7\/ 7a A\\b\/d 77k .9&>877\ d\SXE\QB\,`-~C,C>\>f&'- 763
do .A vazc>r\)¢\`:\gm<§ Ximz\§> §§dd\v:c§ OQQA§@ mck cgnc\uszm\>$° " -\
. 973 7;\\,§ /\m~d \7\\'\ be \:§)\\)\ v§>Q)A\\ 3_'\1;71 77°<3\.033 N\G
co mcmanus §§ 77\4\\ 7\@ mg c>E>Qe@\` § 177"'1\€.€€35/\£\} /\C§:®:\m __
7<> 779/775 777€3 °Q CR\MWM 9?/_9_gcv7u£i \\`.`0*) md»`YQW 77\/7€3 a@,é%>pg%\g
7§'@€€;.6\)1{ `)B.LJ v `7'5:‘1.5 . \7__,\77 \0\7\1\7\V 77\\'@<7 7\1'3 mm mQ_\}; ~
l ’\QS>B"GQ~WA S/?>l/\CS md m M%M <59\\51!\9@\'7 deg13w7w.y UQ;>gg-\¢@

l wka 93d S\Sr\ed ®§7 7:\1 75qu bmw C¢77\<13`_§\)m§, b1 / él®l§ A/\Q 777€€7 0
- y Cf> J€z - ' ' - l

 

 

L

!7 l ' wm,@\@\@\ "
. , _ v y

>' .
` ` . 3
7\@3>\§; 7<> 771@ C’>\&13 Com\>. d\§qmc\ Q\QO<_ @¢w

77 77 7/\7€<1 mm\cd A~c\ SW@\@N@333137,40€€

07 Qc>\)n%€% 13
A_S %\\CMSS 7 70\% \W\® Qs~€>c>\ QAC\§@ gou(o

R€Q€ocd 539 ,.B Lowc>¢o
memowwdum A~L
77\\\ 3 3999\em<93 exams 3\39 cwm%ec\ 093 mem%~adum 07
q @&95\75 \3\\\ 737 37\,\\ @s%é»~® 71)3 399@7€»0<07 =QRQO'ZJ
70z \¢\U\;§ ~@\725\ 75\’9`7,337\ w &\37@&;7 Cv>\)Q\ /'3“1&7\ Cc>\>tl`\\ 373

 

 

‘*`T'+£ ¢J..r(

"‘.L r-.;
¢_=,
v i£a`»;
\‘ " ' .‘ ' ..
7 ..
, 1
" '~ ’s‘. _,9. tv-
` ‘»“ * 7" '~»r 7,‘ . »_-~*:-`;-9` - § 1."'.»
¢ _ .r. M;`

 
   

""'; z‘ "'~,"1;'~:§5 77““7 7""7-`1"1_7 17 ‘-"-' /'" E\'\` § 0 1 _

,»» MH» 3 f“?»z, 7;.'113.""3, _“:`z "'~;`}j_, 717f §“'}` z'jw _:'z'_ '9 § \)dqj ‘§:N q&@
\7\)1173`\/,772,) 7cxf\3

T-")ZL)!E

 

§§17`770\71 673 3 ea\))'.r~ a
vir¥ ?e\g~‘<
2' 03 b

 

 

m 7 _ wR~‘€s/L\O\~@\
__ , 79

A 7‘
LQ\A)\\‘ 70 QL§€L§U"\( n¢>¥\oa) 76 L€A\JQ\ >

C 693 7\77 0\71 073 g QQ\MQ,

 

 

`l %R\Pm d@\`@lm 777\\ 70 \\Qe!>y 3\)3€,3\1 77)37 3 7-2\)¢,
md c,mth}\ Qc>py 073 771\3 dcawmen,& 77e977 7a 01¢)@1770<~\
_ ¥%>mdm} wm Yammm ~179\»379@ `

Tdm 7'7959\ 7/\7./\§ 57 p\¢\mn§ Suc~,\‘\ d/o'€\)mcn“r U\ 773

mm\ `7 /\‘\ /\,5.

3\$0@.<7 va/@,)/¢M "'/"°7/”5

hamm d \31\\ 3 xas)c))z\

7*:.\\\3 ‘\7"(7 '
wm `Fm 93°\_' ..
\3\>({33\/,77@) \QXAS 79373

30{`3