Court Opinion

ID: 4052822
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 02:08:44.622811+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:43.394590
License: Public Domain

. 2 ?_ ’O l
ND@L ACO§-{zk C|@,;`ff\ O\Q (_OJL_{, f g /qg
‘£M'_o§_§£um_ma(_&£&él§_

’\>o Q>@$ \Q:>o‘e am +ol S{w|~en
V\u§+r¢\‘r+ ”1‘87 t\

Dc~¥e‘.£_;bmy_i.?l_)fl@ t5

RE:'\M 380"8| 43'-|~ DS-H(.

Ev\(,\o§e¢§`» §§ ¢cPPU`La¢/~X`S Rc>_cDW +D‘\’Le S\Ld-ets (LesPD/)§a ~Fc>r w¢~£¥
§§ habdéé CDFP\A5 +D ha § \P_ S+uwpe¢\~d.ojed O~V\C§ SQ./+ bQ~£Dl`P,~w\Q.
' (’.D¢)rlrp@r\l`@\n`a¢,o L.)»\’\/\ univ COMP\aI/\jr_<. CM\A Wm $\'\P, £ef¢fe/\lleu>.

ze.é?e¢,jr~£ul\ 4 Swlorw He¢[)

TdHA;H.»'UQ@~~\-:¥c¢:. ,.
- Ex PnR~rc-; _ § INTH\=. 3@“‘13151:21¢¢ cougar
mm E_ .Ross ' § 'oF comm coum~\’“rexas

f APPL:‘LLANT`$ R`E,¢BL‘P`TD sTA*r_EsJ-\Res PONSE,
Fo& WRIT@E HAeEl-\S é_o;RPu_€.

Th€' APP\ILQM § 1\0,5 H/\`\_s RP\H" +oJk|/»LSJ¢e 40 `H/\i$
\Mm`¥@~§ Lfoheas C¢>f`Pu\$ O.v\¢L 9_\0;`@1:£5 as ~@z_>klt>ws:

, l ; _ _,L _ ., .
T}\e M>P\`Lcw\]r ?\QAA G>u¥|+‘€ Dw( ~l'wc> aov/§§ §v\ch>_ iam LLP@-F&
c\/\M b°? Co/\jmd/ and &+MNPA~{M@LQA¢¢R w¥+b\ cL ch¥\¢£. de
_ \Lc_e`»\led mo 90 L?Qar §e./\Jce¢\¢e_§ »CQJ~M §v\cfeae~/\c¢€ C,\/\ar§e;
_ amf 10 “Pe@r$ $e>r ~H/\Q cablede d/\c.m`e.

Dn RPP\TQCLHQ¢\ for ww.'~¥ §§ habo_o_s CD¢PM_¢,. MPU,L@W+
&t\e$e&am `Ill<>,@l SQV\»Le./\Le_ duc>, +o cJ\ cummqu Cuw\u hutton
ohio &++@w£>+e¢l aj/\on$e.

_ 35d
T\\P. F\>_,S P©rdC\/\¥S C\f`{>uvv\ em+ ~H/\a:{' `W\O, Mp\;€.m\¥$ (`C‘>Um/\(_o, ©-F
?csr¥a:¥\l 541@¥@ \30 swz>Az>qSLTe>@. Lr.APQ ;)¢>¢>">3 is mtsP|acd
because MP\`»(;¢M+ $Q.`\Q¢l lre 9\05@;} 45 \H/\o, erromeou$
Cuv\/»w\al¢`o./\ heide \H/»L god SQ\ § 5 wr+@\©w+ mQJ`T+.

\W\Q. Reé?m¢\evx+ \/\D\LB \H\a,+`l’b\?_ A‘PP\`¢ C£wv+ &C¢J`e,ecl +2> +@\Q
\W\\FQQ_ dAQF@_§ 412 \“w\ Cm§e_w¥i \leW (A./\A \DQ;G.Q£“H\UQ ma§
&P\wbaf§a§“ Iv\ +Q/\LS Ca§e -`HY\Q ?M‘_ica?`\' l€.Gal \/\@ld€nc;s 510 v\o+
a/>P`\Q, /

Hou)e\ler\ ?ars(aijr was noJrH/\Q QMQ waH'/\ow*. 4~‘¥ M>PU am~¥ J`o,£_§@,v\~LeACQ ` `
w 5(¢}¢.1 dropqu \LL\Q_ {L\ec¢é;l §Qm+ev\ce AP?&iaa./»+ 5¥¢.}<@§ '\W\c.,+
~H\Q& md v\o 33@4“+@¢¢¢) m Cz>/\_‘>¥`\SLLLL»`QJ\@| ?n>uéj i`on§ 4a S+a.d<
&MUMML c\,\@ns@z;-.-§Q@ warn \1.5+@4€. ch?s dad 133»'7 95
(.Te+; Cr. APP¢ l'i¢il`§\an¢£ fcaf)w\ab\e E\)r.`b+ L\Qlds \¥b\a+ a./\ .`lle@@l
6@/»5(@/\02, 15 zone ~H/\ml-%§ ma+ awH/\ov?mcl» 513 law. 19prer Qc`d/\

wis L;)z¢l 5¢>@\51\.

_ 59 racg_mi.\es§ §§ 4€\@ C@/\$¢».wh\)@ issue wc¢ aged c)P@./\.
d@eé me+ V\na,LLe’T*\~ \€.£;c.l.`|/l¢\€ 54~¢,+`€ =SA}H;¢/\E~{'o UP§G,+ ~HAQ_
mw BL;YMHU»_ am ':L¢, :M@S¢:+v we ple QA;AFCSS.‘M

M’Pb€ww]cs would v\.)M\er +wz> \ w“*'H/\Dw¥ addressing &\rm¢l
@)Ao_ u,\/»Q`z,\/\ z,\/\»~H\e 64 A ww\¢\, make NS ?lbced\w`@\ bar -

CH>\-a,r_l¢ V\/\D'¢>‘\>

Pmw+ l\abe@$ <;\c£.~\s gm §\Ls v\/\€¢I~{s.
` QCSPer,wLQ.»/LW §ubN»/H€co _

TQAA- E .RD§§il;l[L§_/,QW”
§Loel F/\/z QDM Tem»u> esaa
C@{onu T>L ')6`38‘»{