Court Opinion

ID: 4055073
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 06:38:03.851051+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:24.690060
License: Public Domain

‘ ' “~,,-?“~\,`,,W ur d
_-`_ -» __,
M,`) 7 _ . ,
~,`,.,-_. :\` ,`
' ¢~ ' ,_,_;_._ .
`_
, :"

u.»,,~ ,
' *‘»-`, ____.¢"n..
~~\.~-;,. ...`

'_‘»`,_<" ~4~

§ .. Q'g| .02., oz,m

DENL CLE¢L\< ; -

‘__`>:\<<, 1 v\1<»4\<_\_ _\n;j\\'\,% C'AW(U.EL _ _
ls; \{Qu \»loq\d__"~-Q\€LQ§L §)"/LSQ;“_E_ z ‘.7\
~E> {;\'\Q/¢'JC 3c1 AS*O~.

C`Bo(\ \£j \'\\§\"\\/ O\?()YL;JQT'EQ.A f\'\Q-LL -\/`OU,.` l.

OU`/ }<\<'\&.(\L@j

S_._Cpr,/L§<) 00 AIUCL

-\/OU_V C\\>§>/LL;

Hw~£m.u. /1
/ -/Qr~r\ 50” ab v .
j: Y\G\\[ sL.. c;\ :,(\.'u{ 7 Ouk khl’\'\€i(\;_l,`)('{£; y
' ) j Y\°‘(\A 6103 Wq° g mj both

1. 05 E> \"\C<\/L agurij

'TT\@K ~7/014 \.(…C\_\\{ l

b lum C.Q)’ d \j .
l _
LQAM¢&? RECE,NED\N
'”" - couRT 0\= cR\M\NAL APPEALS
MA¥ 1 4 2015

Abe\ P.sosta, Q\exk

 

L.D\.Jo'_\\ ®U\GC;\»` G'(Q_Qx\ A\(0\ Fm 2051`7”

TQ/\"\QQ,SSQ_Q Co\'om\/'l T>(l']§<@@z,b

QQ_'_ T¢_ QJ~_. !\)0. 2_0\2'“1¢\0-€_7_ \,\J£- Q>Z/q%|_OZ

'\T) “['\'\]5 Ho/\JOQQ€)LE £oq_m” <)F CRl/v\lNAL_ APPEAL.S

Loma.? 'OOW/ AQ_()\\'CQQ!; ),@\,Jg_\| (3\\4\'0¢\/ 63er in f;\*vLC\\oo\/Q.
ma:r\l:.\gnq_é LQ\J\§Q, nume,./M. fo_§?@a¥£u\l\/ (JYO\\/ ~Hno-)';
‘L\m% l~\o\Y>LQS°CA¢(MS \/~l\r`\{c\\ +_\m'§ \Aonomb\ncouv£ A‘bg,r ‘Ioubjzcé`"§>r'
+_\°\\5 Lour_£ tag \FOT\/\~%\q \AQAQ»/ (30€>£ Com\/]c£¢'on \'\q\muq%
'&Q¢Q\A€> juv\b<§\c~_{:\oq.

/\F()\‘,°CQQJ; ccngw& 1aqu \M §{WWQH; b é\m 64+\q ‘Di@ér'/C£
(`»,Y°\m\r\<;\\ C»C)\.\r& HOQO\/C\\O\UG<§ {Yus` \JOQ\A Q/r`\-l:;j<\o. clep\\£o.nlc im
(` \ ,

A?Q\'\gc\n£ 16 unqb\b £:> Ffo\/[§\¢L 1_5\\]5 Hon<>mb\@ <;OW£ wl:{-,`h
QAAMOQQ\ Cx>p\{'é 0¥ J;}w -l:>/Qn@w\()i emg uh{b¢€e./\()ph¢€_»nt

@

()YQ7' J;\n"\‘“o \~\s>r\o»/o\\o\\\C_in; €rc,\\i .);\~\'\5 l~\»Onorc\b\L COM/{: Q\lO'\J ClQp\l~C.C»nl-_L¢ _
?mcu,@é MQ\ nnvo\\ 4:\> mQ)Cv/lc¢\ Qac!c.,.l,:hc.t §§
F-ro\/w\~‘\\\ wLH<»\» h\'m yQ,\KJ». :l€ zoy\\CC\G{: Clom\o\&;n op pro%sz_c.u&w m`,§gonc\ud:
who./Q,q€s, opp\{£ont \'J°"@ C\//R%Q~A “CW {1\'\’- 0§-$<'1\99~ Ajjrq\/q£u§
Ks\obu\, w'\~‘=\n a A.w<\\\, \~\LOPOG, On march 24, zozz,howa/(
'HWUL \'JC\§ no wmngon fun-du QJC JC\'WL 99ka o$ Q/KQ,S{',.

00 m@\,(<`.\'\ 2.(1>, 2_0\?_ O\‘>€\;C\nl; b ‘\r\ pnin \.on "D_oJ-_°~C'L:\\IQ_ /V\Qnu\u,{ CHO\\IQ,'Z. qn 2 66 han<§zun . (`RR \/0\. 5{ ijLL/Z, Ll.nc_ ’1-2'5),_4
(R(< \/0\. 61 Pq¢)L Hi,LInL 1-25),(@@ \/<>\¢ 5, PQJUH, L{nLl-z§)(

(RR \/°\. lz/ qulq¢z/ A},L':-‘$); S¢_Q_ (Exu\e»\-r's #2,3,4,5).

`AP{)\\'QQ(\L, g\)z_<\ O\ mo-\:\"on £Y bite-pccva O\rc\w\/ On Jul\j 561/2012

m 90<>$'1%11}\ fwbua%¥:;nj 'l~_hg SEQEYQ\, in 'H'\o. BL'I'HW CW"Y\§
\nq\ bl§é_le{ Cour£ `\r~[lL\r\C/‘\ [Rq\m§:\prem \Aon.[m€l{'i-~)O\`\n§@n¢'

mc\\/ |5/ 20|5 A()\o\\:<.urrh proc»v¢\. L:b 15er 191 -/~_r;w 0¥ §qdc~
[Jwr\/] prOSLCuHOm . ;n\(;)rm§ +-¥T°~_)“Nj 'HF\GHQ \G\\)J Sl»n~§wc.;\-

@

;an°"‘ . _ ,
mbn¥;’ ` (O_CD\/W 0\ \,J on but \f`\o__ \ -E\no`. 0¥'$¢-°»¥ ~l:QKlvnj 11-“}\°~ S'ECM\A'/ ho\dQ~\/°-(, ‘c<`¢C-J'~'j
f.°~»(:\.v:§£' 'l;\no\lz £-_\mL \Oro§s)`c:. J=nr Qd:`(~/»_\~/ of mz.v 9~\/\<§°»0¢9~ 'v~l\f‘\§c.\n mq\/ bs>_ mata/fci h)é}nb
4r Q_`c?,BB HAN€D‘
Gw\’;§ \~m'§ m €Q\w_mc\! hmqu mr, +\nc\% [C<> ’2_ 66 HA~oGu~j \Am§ N°T
[_ le<'-Lo@ef) £hql<, mmn§_ J¢he [`C€>'_z 35 HA#O 6~4~3 wo§["vu??££%].
.THEQEE>KE/J=hl zqv+h b'.%r.z+ uon,,m@)=e wman QM Rns.'nz is
m Q,/mr, Ap()\\mn£- 9(0\[',¢\@,1;_ CDQ\L@ o$ I;FACT'jJ`m £\m, FSLI~*h <.`ou@+. .
' _\_F\L bégjm_ Q\\LSQ>/ (0/16 "THL @Ourl: ObE)Q-’\/\:'_A L\'\Qf OnQ.» CO~¥\ hw¢ll\j bR_
Concl<§_\ ;0:\0_‘_3, -}_-_O gon<§qct 0 §DYM\
¢\`i@c.o\/Q-»r\/ O$ Jc\m, I; ungl@¢\o§gaj mqe»/\Q\ 9_\1 ;AUCQ,.
'T\'\Q~ QfOS-‘LC-\_" L;Dr\ l;Q/n<§@/Q_<§ [\»<;m\o)z»/\~/ E);{éé.e/mqq') 15me
'hD\MQ.VQ,\// L`\HQ, SL‘.Q£:)_,.mm-I; \,Jq§ \'n \:FACTj SMfY\O~na/l:'°
- ` ' ' ~' .A {:\> Qo <§uc’[f`@l
HWL [Co 2 63 HA'\)Q@W\)§, ’Y°r\q\ boune»,o.\ R\¢\_<>. w n
.Q>rm€\\ fmon<>b, \<()\<.“4\°‘»\@_<§ 06 O\ rQ,qeonc\\o/\(Q/ %~l:v'ccl:
Q*S“Q C\°~C‘\€)i‘sn,_ but rq.§\o_d¢§ Q " SJ:Q/£\\'nj fjnorc»nC'-°/ UVl-Qv/,;,
G:"<; P\O\Cv_.$ Y\v\§ (,oqc\ud: 0\44;5°\<§1. 0$ 'l;\no~
5'0“@\\ norm@¢ 5£¢\'¢|<\0¢\<§ \f¢ `~*1‘35\";"5£°“/ 449 U~

\\WL %uPrsz_mL/Couré ConC\.uAQ¢§

9 vrs).\/»’cj.\\ ;nj ?ro;$b§’
5 .  C\nq\.\mg@ b`iqz \/m»
\rn.\o@<@on (Re. \/0\. 11 Fqu 1351 L\`m, lo, rqu¢Q,
A\f'l:.¢ 7.76.\((> \/‘Wnonr§ [Ann_TQ_X“UW Q(-OC_. [H:\, pfO%.LC-LH:OV,
;::?"/{‘::BPOQSL ( RR \/0\¢ Z/ quq, l%|(_ Lino. '2_,0» 2_5>-“[¥"\‘1.~[~!.1<1[
(- ' n ¢ 0 . _ a If n
O\C€ {:\ne\mj \5 \n U/'@r. 141 \6 C\ ):FAQ'T§ courqq\ \,r\,..
“E»NL (LC<>r<§ ..
_GROU'\}'O Eu(ll Tf\€\\ CQ‘\,\QE»Q " ' o '£ `
l?_e_<§ \/Uc\°\C:E Om<§ \/0°<§ _) Q\\ §&\\LABD Ob')_LC Eo on u°dqqéhor
\ \* 31mv_rrb., AnA'J:bQ-»'unc\ul¢)»\cm(z¢<=\~

@m_km QL _\MQ€)H§_ `,4¢ v
pa q.’ L. ‘éZQC-KQ..A Of\ '£;QF ~O,Q g P,{~‘m/ COGV{CHOHCRR \/.0[._5
?)°~ ' ""°~ "»~16>/.£?@3°~ %,AM /- 253. "

A()p|¢cqnt~ win ehow f FACTSJ 19th .h»~ \Am§ Am'ws Q £`q;r will

Lf.

 

qq‘§ »J_»)nd_ Va{rc§§c%:_ ‘15 Uno\u£\no/\ZQM T\ng, 4;-__¢{0\\ aguch
_1(~`6\(_+_ -F‘\rj<§o\nj 6103 600£\\46“\00 15 in 2»\/(0(. /-\F?\'\chn)¢
?m‘/` 4-'-\?\@\£ Jf-\\'\% \Ao~o¢m@l/E £oqm’ 1155 17 PO\A)E@T@
ADM¢N\§'TER Ju€>~'r\c£ :r;~ Acco@o¢wc£ \~n-ru THE LAv\/..=.

Ano\)/S\E)

LVAC.T] CDL,\H; C.\’\Gw'j noJ-_ Q-XPWLSS pff°\Un prior€on\zim-
\_®"\5 \r\ J:\mL En\ncm€°\mo,qt A\\¢,`¢)ql<{@~qg, Q(\A phyle Al~\o.j‘:"&'

‘°(` w b°~ L-NQ~""\'H_E duz~/ mo ¢Jo'r E{Fr<£§e> A Fmow€> 00
/\»Oé/*DL' \AlE/*» ~ \.&_/' 2…” ' ' ' ~

   

5

 

f FA'CTI JU?@m€n'r <)F THE Jurz\/ ', Qm\{`nj 00 ,;,,Q.A\Y WWM
__,,:/_L/>`// \\O\A}'Q_.\/SLY,‘£:\'\;S mLWSl/NON_APpMCABL_E:/ `

`TY`\Q_ l:.f\@\\ élour'& <§'\<§ mcf o\$érz_%$ '£;\n)~§s)~ C\\\Q,gql:°l`ong
bS>~C'~Q\J.‘st. 4:}12.59_ Q\\Q.jc.k{on§ o\m,fF/\C`T‘b'] ‘\:ur]c. C»errw. J:U »l;\n.o. conc\u§io»\) "`DPN”EP“ HQ}M'QF
'(QM€? \3€\69`<§ 00 BF\L L=v\o,() C»our'k'§ §Q.QEE> c'm<§‘n‘j%'

AWNCO`“£ l: FAUS§ MLLTR“€B cm<\ emma w w-E\Qu§ `
{33 ]:QEME};: vAcA“'rE JuOGmc»¢\VF 'Dle~\l§¢zz_=p Wl.-VH p,r {»hg, O§§USL OI%
AC)(JYG\IQJ<;L§ R.Q\pbsu\/ \0\[ \/\.€)L Qq<§ »°~x\‘;\‘>I-'H“On 0»§ q §Q_qg\% w@pon/
h@\'\!°~\l°~f hS-.\MC\S €)un<§. zu;L{:\j b\i £h)\_jur~./@ N\o\\&onq¢\o COm/'
P\'\°M’W~A 0§§ €\"'M<§v~@a<*-l:¥%wrw`,c. ,Q/-/of ;mp./vPQ/\\j in e-éruc~_é.e. C<>\\q£wd` Ym'»f. Ho\»:w@r, LhQ, CWA L ‘SLL. O£hw' 5;§91
loo`

\/Jl£\n QALBMQ]=L fQ.QSOr\In_c)~, Orjumm'lc Qn<\_ /:Lf)é'\:mpr\‘\@,()
\ Qr\.A YQA<;@O LYICJ` `

'A?‘?\\CC\(\]C, COG£U\A_ ‘£;\`\Q,-"`k \']L Y-\QS PU.E mo(°`ré':`ho`n -(-_-_Y\Q,

C‘O'ur£ 05\<,@‘§ ‘Y\O\\éono.éq jan m,?\m,é, \~lhn.rm‘), Q,QQH.C)M\J<»

_ C.O\§s` at bw ,ZD\"L' "YOC\"C"" hC\S Pfo.€)m£s\.é r%TA'T€m€n/r

CF FA;T%B '\'° <\-»`I‘RGE§ `TO ‘FHE Ju(<`~lj, f T_NOI.CTMC/~T} O.n<§
}; \f££@¢c‘rj . '

,\-/-9 AFF\f\/m<»€\a.\/L -;\'n<§;nj L>(pm§§ §§ fn gm 3…\5 manic/hugh
L\jvf/ (*F'P\|‘Lc~n£ '\~lq§ €)WLA guilb\\ 0@ C\§§ro\/qtq.<\-ro\@bR/j
l-O\°A:§'Qf\§m_<>°~,;m€o§».~f bL-¥‘_’M/ bLC°mi€‘j
U.\jlb\o. .§_`Ur _PQ N\L Cm@',¢|,va/Ho»)/ embch on q§.F\°,/qu-¢`\/Q,-
m+,,J/;h\'e nojc \231§),0&€§\1@'1(11<,9»”1@,

'c\.n¢\'\r_\§ Q~r\jc""'k

v.r b LC,QMS_>L` \nAle"

c\

Q\\L§LCJ&,\(~Q' P°L_ mm 5

,L)(()(°_."of)q_$ N/A . A mun g Pm hung \Ao§ §Drép . \
.. mv`\£ Q`\\‘lec\(jun;. \»J\‘\ULQS`, m\{ ‘_T_(\A:C%mm'k q[[L§q]:F\er/m or
66 hcinéju.¢\):§ b 'NuN'C. P(O -TUNL{ Cm no»§j'.bh USb\&r"\’ '!:_¥`\‘\q\(, §\’\oulé hq\[g, ho QQQN in lamb (){UQQ.L;\N$§.-

_ (, ~:{a§¢\)