Court Opinion

ID: 4061524
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 20:08:58.646759+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:41:25.554329
License: Public Domain

%/3,8§§3’0|

RECE|VED iN
COURT OF CRHV||NAL APPEALS

NUV_ 13 2015

IN THE TEXAS ¢Gi¥i!i‘ §§ CRIMINAL PLP,FYMMQ ` costa, C}erk

xvii-rehirsz son wRIT _oF
assess cohens snow

3:3;6?’-‘?- aun;rc;m. =b,rsTmm conn
los sxnnxurcbuszv,frsxas

Ex ~PARTB:;

RICKY.JOE_SHUGART

abode-mm

mann `coux::_j wsz.m »#;c_a¢ 13:~:;4:1§8'»-1:
marc s sumser _s,HEs`T'
suP'PLEMENT 11
vABPL:cc':_)vu\::.z'."s NAM_B::. _RI,'CK_.Y' JQB- sHUG_A_R-'r'
oFiFE'N's“'E:= poss mm >g.ql.njs<'=.;z,op:q mst
-cAusE- .;,No»; cK-¥l,-B,'-z"¢li'l.as
sEN'rENCE= <.'1‘0_'): brian mas INSTITvaNAL bvzvxswr¢:,_ rfch
;J:RI'AL :nA';.rE:`: lanich -;16.“',_ ;20'1.4'
TRIAL. ‘€0118`_1_ JUDGE HGNLA\IRINE ;;1. aLAKE
`APPEALsNO}
- cwa'r.:!€on' "ro oézI_N-I_o»z»`._: ________
HEARlNG‘HELD: 'YES’ _ v :NQ
:rxnv:ucs a coschusrqns\srsss=..,,_ xzsf s »u¢:

RECCMMENDATIONSX

 

.Post~€onvi¢£i¢piwrif Of:H§YS§S:QQX§H§

'Fannin Cohnty'District Glerk

diAiP T f ¢zg

was swATE;oF“§EXAS §1

couNTY or FANNIN §

At_a regular term sf the 336£“ ums@riét court begun aha;holdeh
within and for she c¢unny of Fannin and.seaee of mexas, befbre the
chorable hasting elake; adage thereof presiding, which term began-on
the 1“ day of January, 2013, and which will xerminate.on\the-$lsv day

Qf Dchmber¢ QOl€» the follow;n§§¢éusé same on forlhearinq} to¢wiré

EX ?BRTE;

¢

RI'CKY€ `JOE :SHU.GAR'T NO .'?`CR'+‘-i:l?a’.-,FZ'§§?»?SB'.-.A`l

NANQy»YovNG

      

:, DBBUIY QLERK

 

 

 

 

 

§~Z>F UOQQS.

 

nwst 2a2 Q~.E-N§mm-> . , ,_.g § §§ 9,..§9§ §Es. s§§ ga

 

§§ 2 §§
m.~>§ cm §§ c IVA/.’VE.’ § /$PFULAT!DM FAR wm oF
. § HA@EH'S Cc\EDLLr F\€¢swt
/?/c/zs/ 235 snow/fr § m "‘o¢mc¢r amf

§ AF FmJNNL‘z)umv, TEXAJ

SUPPLEMEMT JI. oF WR\]'_
z/A/BL//\/DED, /v£h/ mm amf kcsz xz/B/VE£§/MQ

6 )WF //¢/IA'))?M me¢:r ame man

',¢/)%///:/§ gaf/v ZAMMFAM 542/12a #/A@//é/ Wz ‘
L’/?/M/A/A[//VAJme/M/ p/ %J“ w €7/ )‘)g/ AZ»/fe/, )w/)?:¢éj/M
key feA-))%My ;@é¢/.,Mf zfv %A')%>u)%é MN£aU/b)z

' § f di /~jéji_@/¢"?/ %€Z)'/é/£J’§vfm/é % 7!/¢¢/2)//%`/ 60135"¢”7
" j‘-’$Wj;f‘)¢(/%'%)' /emz/(/o%¢u ga.,jy), (;,\77 / nyot$w awry 551/vhf »
MG{:MJ-`e /ZW&/, :r agw/¢/¢?/z/?M M z%j
¢{’/a/.§ ‘0%~ Ma;-Jmay;a/ % MJM %¢ mm»¢/M
' . ;% %J' &M,, AQ/Z;QJ/z¢ /qég J/MW %¢'M¢/c/@@QW /h 117 ` z
W/W/v a///M M

 

 

 

' j‘ £vppL£ME)/UL PA§E z off
irl/7 HA%\W’?J’ M/t Az¢'/Ae ¢Zéoa/£' /)`ZvY b /w/Nb' aj , '

£¢IL gm 1502/ 'aa/ e. ..|{/2//£{[51/;: J`Mz é:(:c//o);;r fn L/A,JJU'
%¢JOIM¢ £6 )% % e 64], .Z`a//`/zv_¢f¢gsy &MQ.
H¢,M"M, wm my MM wm mg ms (/.¢/ wesz
k J’Mf /%!Sm@/ §0@£¢ /% g w m;»¢'ka/ w/ze. W//M_[&M
mféea/ W/Q#m Js¢é/ [Z@.. MgM»¢€v¢ro£/)j %>°¢11> M///)
/‘7 /M~é/ dhzéjwt’ /{w)%w; /3" %f_¢!£i/ %;@/ f/'a°/

)mw@/ %z. £/Mf~ /@€@»»J"/_@a¢ A: BJJJ»//w/ijm. umw
_ l #W€rj@i=f 01£'£1¢/0 lay /»%V, 60 /3'~/4)) f%g)a/ g;WL//%wm
.` £:/é)j Je@¢gz¢ y ge game/dwa c;/Mcwff % was

w//% fman zé//e@/Aij'/V ?7@?)4, fw- z% NQ¢MW%A" '
¢1# m,éJ/GEW/\/mj¢&- 67 573_;;»[&/% m %“z J¢*/¢'M'

/%2§2 2%/2£ J// 2%92? b 4 % MW %JYWZZ MM`mW/ZLL
`0!%'/; %)d:l"@v I)(/new Z/:::‘ /?) %°J \z@x€/zk /'/ guth/eff
”ZQM;??ML{Y"/'/"%/’€ /z]/ ___),Z_/E_M<`;/ZW oy’ ZS/Oo&`éz,jm”j 159 )"`7
' _ Zwes’zé z/c§ d F{’m% ¢"'”M/( ’%th/,», /wémé, mMWeJ £/m_
o/W a.v¢w%-& mm/é@/ £%é mew’ 26 z§y ja gwé amf %7
. @ésww/ 19 m amy/nw rgé%/ %M spasm/m W§/ _ _
~ r/j/i;¢ %/¢y/¢ m mw w fm%/ ~f/y Ml’@/ /ZMW M/'“¢
gm M` MA¢ Z;»~,@!fM// me m/ m z%w M~f/zy
` /W'é£, //"m¢ %,@..-/3» de 318/f cé»);: déam/ %/ef %1/0 jaw/1

/

 

» ~ _ svfnszlE//rzT/%%E 3 OF_/,'
54 /4/ 44 444 24 446 ,,? 44 W,,%%J,%
414/4 472 4244/4 244 _4(7 44 444'144
4424242244 222 22 4244 442/ly 422 - 4244 4744/224
f¢//ze,@/,_‘_/L__am/Dmy/%/m; %M JM 414 Z 4441 w'f//L
jrewéwa 44 742 74444/22 cwnW"¢z/' 444 %4¢2,;-2/23” 444/744
1444/424 4244 §§ng /4» 444412» 4444" (:_.é;¢;_ JMzc/J,/B 2 4
221/42/ M /A ¢QW/j 96 'ZM /"/,,/ {/6'¢4%¢»4¢24 /24//4224 4244/744
'4/¢24/4/ //44///:/4/ 7 7 ` ' ' '

1144 44 44/422,4/2441224 4244 444
J//W 4744 43 437/2414\40 44 444 4144£/)7@ 474 /9; jay 76%4¢144
244»\.¢/2/4 444 4447,,/»44424/), 5 c,, 04 jisz lib/mg
[& 442/44 424 z§/MW/J`M 4744/440

M‘é 1514-w %27774?/4/4 424 924/444 24/!/1>~4/2>7£/4/%

419/1402 [23)5/6[67 no'rf_°.. @_<é%*/ 34 77b llle 141er a/&AW)/A/h€d/ /h [z‘/w»_]

¢’/4¢;¢,5'@422/ 215/444 ‘?JI`{/~ 424/4244 4/221/ 442/444
7744 /1474)7 Jz/J; %gm{ /é/ ch,f/J`//",Z), /Z§]/// Z%¢ MMY¢M@ 0
w ,W,M»/§m {@J md we¢%e,¢/ /n exc@£fo/g 500 pmn¢l;r',
1774/h , F,. /5/'. 20/5' 75 A):r#l`/%mv 47 Z%M'€M 442132/\2?/2{'1224 ., j
3€/7777§ e/m`ed gm few 434 €z'v¢€£»"j`éfww‘}~’¢/YJ' //eeow/ 32/“' /”7 Frl¥fp /37.
_zg 442 244 44 444 /2241 4244 /M 243 24 44 742 444
444 123 415/244 622/79 +2'1»_~_2>_@”- 34/4.2 07 mgva 924
5 pm;' 75 44 444/2434 /]4/4224;' 44 422 21 412;>4244414
Jaw 73 /@/Jméi/_ZWJ%SF/EZE/ , J¢(/gq /€/ww a/MJWL/r /444`4 /'/ke'

é’ 434 41%§7!2 ,_ - -- '

 

 

symzm§j 'rlf m§g¢l AF 5' v

1
._
.
gaf ‘
4.

7%)€ //§pwza”¢%, 163 you fm a/é){' %51’£1/»;:/ zé a M¢M:§'
', M;uc'era/M f p/é, ap£é)}’%/§%» D¢’ /'izr ado;z=%ézé%

w,w,-.%M WM7WMM %A,HY ZW/,

/’¢ §§ M~/”"“/@~W /@m»¢ J’¢m/ //%. /¢M,§~A;,,,

% .:_%JM-F/‘HJ¢. %»& MJ’ %%J%/.,%/M/;/- {f,%ajc

% _(’%,,%c‘e 7@\“ il A,/¢m¢-e., % €WG%WJM, J/M»" /j?‘p%

%_YCW% ' fe ;¢//@Z_,¢ y/bMH/M£ A//%.': /z¢'w ¢%¢7@/

%¢fe W/% /07¢ ¢/;¢j Z,,,WA%éz// ;h¢¢/ %ze. ¢//% /2'7¢¢44@4/ Jz?'/)ze.
MMz/M%Jf »7/%%/~ m' % W§»‘ J"@// %.J%¥Aw”

Mr M/%}ae,/Zué M% 7¢”‘1 //z"-”/f /v //2¢'"%¢7 ma

699 ql%¢/M %.”mW’ %/Qr~ev?/M, e)$/,¢%¢A;/§; z

M?Zc" 511/mw M/';¢J/? /M/aé%¢//g UQM@ a§aqu/@?//Za

» oé¢/ 21%% enemy 513 kw .,4:’¢,5 /,, /;4 z{%/MM

/77¢/..2' f¢)’/M mr %f @ Z'//'¢ 761 d?/;/J;Wlé%¢¢/AJ

MM, J¢¢/' /z¢/%/;q /;'é A¢ ama MP_¢¢¢%Q; /ZV/AW/»wv; _2'

hew 65 M %\/>)v.@m/%m zw¢¢é/~%a/ %/1» 3/{%71£ /¢=¢M,/

_ 16 mcpm /<~":;ML go J@I’/£l m ,%e/)»M yém/;' /?MM ,

' ' %¢ MV<)¢;%Q" ,l¢ Me¢ ,~;¢ éyx.¢ //}¢ myo/@.A;// pwa mfm¢y

~% Jg§e¢g(//%)€f}’ /Kw %u£ % J>Ze,/.MWL§ p/c,é%€, 72’:#

/3' /z¢%/ée//)g Z!¢//% wl Az%m¢@{, %W»g Mfm¢fa/%

AM %J%"“‘MWW” ‘1Mm¢ '%yn//ww///$ mma/?@U%&

}§/ J@WM ' ` ,

v 1 M/ //%: /W %Ma¢$’cal’kj%?¢:wMQ// am/ w me

. 5 12 M. Qé¢/€ W¢% £Me'r pf ga w WM,~_ q/,:J,»;,¢é/ 04ij

{Z>_: lioé%f% /MM.@% @//‘J¢My, . \

 

, MFF@Wrz FM§J¢/Z“ '°`

/z{J/)L 152/j 0//67¢)'14¢1 a/ %1 ¢v/Jm 75@%'_2'¢)01//¢/
?Zf/ he c%aoJY/~zé §éa/ h//é/ /§§/IZW%JW»§AAW ~
1 alma/§§ va»// %w 44 ¢W§S}§%/~ZZ‘ §§ij %4»/¢/%
" A/%W 25 am § //$Mww 0 @<%¢@Mé M/?M» § §

§§

/V’->>/j» §§ /'¢;’%/ //%MQ%€ &”!@//f/`lmm . dev j'
7¢/¢£ joa/iv m,»§ zé %W §m»é al %§f % //W ém/ § <¢/§é’w%o
¢:M §§ %,é/' Jl:'"; /§)’ %§§W,Q/z"€. ¢%%j %ml %'Av/Mm,
':’Z°ex!a/SM£¢ X/)n %aj)!%¢ J¢»¢e.zuuu[¢/ whame ”M,W@,J w,\@§/kq,j;q //
.zz/, iam 2~1 , , f’z%¢ §/,)§M § §§ ,',¢W/.?/ § -f/a M¢;~' A,W
zfo\/o/We...,f/'//)@/ud W¢f`J/¢£ , ., "WW§}/ZQ§¢L{M jéf %/Awrol//n ja J/éw
' czma/§§ mmi § .D»§ze____._% w J’/»¢e, 570 wear 552, 555-53 z%mm
»~ ~§,j,/WS');;//Gh ~z/ ',§@¢e, 543 5:;¢,2¢/'5¢,5; 550 z%,;;,»@.f /qvél.=z§¢ x §§ zh../
_ z ;»@,,./;Z_e /élhec/£O %z%)éno/MMM; _/)1 7{1/<)$29¢’/"?/'1€@., /fl”¢“§/é”*
, a/l~,§t,~w,§. hij/an'a mwmn ;4» $%/>/QJ ,>1 /{,§ cage 35 ja awWMAQ.J
§§ng § § M,"MW/ §/A§, 1 anew § JM»§ /:y' zm@¢@, '

  

2%4 ¢.F/Ez(£ %2§€’ % »éwréléfl jdl/G/DW. d L"'j%%’o , - 5 /? M$” /W’l
" Vv’/MM£M?/ })na/£ m£/W wgn/1431 ;6'€2. ¢’M’l("!n_?%/S/ o/., Mm%g;gzé:&§; il

/%`M/,JJ 242 [fex¢,§f§¢!wél$ 0.»`¢,/< u. g »7/{,5;% Zd’ 4;)7) Fq (/ »' '/2@)
, mean l/,JM<:,: 512 w,_z¢l 51)4,5@1 fTU/g,@/»,/ff?), ;;>,Wd,,/ gm JM¢°/ 1a ~ '
g zumi¢/./§/l’m/m/Bm {%L/oa/fce. MHZM. /7/%`,7;5»22/ féxé;d£»/Ypye M

' . ark Wmo-//»f$sz?z& Méss-M,M§§ 0 ' 1 ¢/J')@Ac zS'SlA) JJ /é’.? /2003)15./
IW/va~¢- ` ,- /@FM->U z»"v\(zw)'); imi§§$mw z/szs' //f%€’

TMHM,@ /e,»é~w.»e ma v ,@¢W/ `77 M;A,e;'/,,§
f/Z@ d/<’ 2025" §
Ji/JWM/' 716 73”7?7

  

' l. '/ ~ ., , N,MU.W_
/a/M/ W 47 ZM"E aaaua
t § M:}Q 5 f M£a')é"¢£[é¢or¢/ §4
\l& » 1 [j¢/Z¢]/,gaoa;)nrwwd
\/ £A¢JM M§¢%§
law § \M@¢wwg, azg'l
&‘”1"// gsaw,y M
5
- '~ ~cwl¢l$ee. Jzz.
;WW%?;€//gwww
gsrw»€m§j~¢

ck/Ma;$g;k_bw ' '

   
      
  
  
 
 
 
  

  

 

 

¢,C\m aaPe)nc/Qa:gaaa

4a Sa°+a£aj§§i