Court Opinion

ID: 4071688
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 02:20:16.736568+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:17:49.022622
License: Public Domain

f~ Th-E           'Jik-4<5    &;vp/         d/          t,€/MIN4L              ~tu ~fhO~-D/

J;i;Q't/~:.s ~vN#                                                   This document contains some
                                                                    pages that are of poor quality
                                                                    at the time of imaging.

                                                                               ofHie J/qbeAS W~l/­
                                                                               e19t/JE   tJtJ. /I~/IS7-4-
                              .   .    /1                     .            .       .       ~ECEWEf.HN
                          Mt.flfiN    h·~ L&lh/6'- /tJ HIE ,1-~ COUFtTOFCRIMJNALAPPEALS
             #,t;/'iv-~'I    4fPilC:4h~tV            l'u(..   ;v.Ril- 11/' P!.tJAicJutfJtr 22 2015

/tJ; 711 F #JV";e,&-/7/r Wfe<> / r5Aicf tJc~&,€:t" : . Abe!Acosta,Cierk
        ,£.€/rh:~ J 7.€/J-vlJ fkv.;I.£ ' hdu- ;;4-/11# ~~1/·c/r //. 7 £1!'1'cl~. ~.~()-         (7

'78/f..s Ctc/6- of (!£JMJA/.t~·l r,R.e-Cedt/~t-, / E', 4~ "f,Y'Iic4;het;V k
                                                                       j       w,e,.·l-
 ttf' ~liB-~ ec'1P'V'U tA/ 7116 /76-r~ c/vc/IC;';f/ 1},-o~;'(/,f CCJ# Q,c ~~~:s
 C.uNfJ     od Vl,.tue ttY"~ //, 19;e/lc/r 1/. • 7., hi''" rs 11-                    'f'"AI         ckJ
     f/Jo o/I)'Z~ ~f' //,r /;€.,'1/ eo,.;e/- jz, /'-?Mlf<:h//e-lf~IJA/U'M•f. h /'fie
     to.~. ~f f!;t,M;N.rl 'fjl~IJ -Tht:~r-c<£c/ i£,M t!Jr fu6uu &,LNJ
      IIJJft; C:l'?'tt. \./. .771 . /) · /  . ,      _                                 .r
        r1 . . ~ ·.              tr- .-srRlC/-6/M/~ hills #tJ /lt//A~/2r-~ /Ci e~,vfoAJC/f?
      .-fo h(/lcl ~e/gh~re. 's FJ-R)/J/)cM~· / /:,e        ~/ /' / ./1                    ;'
                                         '\! · ~
      -        ,
     Is I.~Jvch>~     .
                               rr
                         . . h.. ,.       , . · vv-~; ,- e~r-. ndoe4"J. 8'12A./J'
                                                                           r
                                                                                  . /JIVe

           . . . ;r 1/J,/J, a · LY<' 4 /           c!v;t
                                              -7'• 'M L?~'llof: ;;~"'Mel .r~r
                                                                                                          J

     11/f/Jc//,"x.l, ltA.Jd£&1/&c/hCeo£c-IJ .                                          1
     Mhif      fhe-J                  ilfyod s,~cU n4k ;:_/~
                         16 PI•!V/'Ju h11.s
fo,:.S hllN""4d Cc~if"J w~:.f a/6.&1; hdJ Ndf- kw /'..w-~M -/D
·f>h, J (J~t£1--   tr   ff,e //.e-ycNcl~.

       M4'1     df/jf"'N.j- lf#GM//:f wBer M~               t
                                                          .£Ek,{,,.e /t.r ;-r/-
  1-'IJ,r //.erq~/gv./- :M .<10.;£- 4CeMc-4.?_~ . Jq ~r fl-eroc.,e;k/
  ohrlvr iU~;e--h PtlvA/c!J h;A/J ·k  "./loNrcl M !"hrslll/r -/d . /
    ~?{!, cle·.J"~Nd ~~J t17() /JJde.:J 0 /-' ~110-/ ·fo .Je/2t""Jelvco "
    /J/L/. I/, o 7' f 3 ( {Y
                                 f   y::::-
        h,<- otl~e Ito Me- 1v/fls ~6/:,-h~ :r h~~/J
  M Vud-o..tl AG/t.,v .fo!-tt6'AI, TPr,J ,;·ve_~ /T,;~ d~ sfl(trf
  1AI #!;i_&Af 1/.S. l!tJu/;;J,~ s"f/L#./                     rn6'    5/~/trF ~e:s ~v(.r-1-JJ M r/JF /lEMit/~ ~C/;/t4GJJ/s ·fh~ElA.~ ··titJ
                         j

    Ct'-t2>f shw!d M4 ILF JJ-A./ c"t'tcl~ fc 61VJ/rl f-f1e-:- ;2~~~"cl(i}.£1-
    /o l]c-/ tJ~ riJe fN/,/;.,~1 l?f ;;~.._4rld~ , 1- /-.r ~Y J 1-./ tv~,oh ~AT sf,(/F              £ey--.<~d.;     M"Y
    l'hiF ntoh-J e_c:;Lfc.J ~;2;-f 1~ evA,c/i /~i;r/ f!tf~.;el Mtf
Je:lt~ZM/7VlF tUh~?/,{/(., v.u~eMI;;I"C/ iose_ sr                  '7J
                                   '"'Ale&// ;:A/. mrh~bti&! .
        (ot2/(J.<:   ~tf,f.      .rA/   ~c) r-ed /r~        1'/MI-,       /J£ "~cA>e          1/IJ.r~­
        b~/J ~scJvtFJ she,/k/ l'v~·/ Pe ec#-s/;et.6f?/                                 lfd 4tv   ;~~
        Sk/?,Xp          r_l;~ Ck~~           htcA4    h'J M'/v1<-~hi'Jei'4·/' clc.~(r~ ~ 6t~f
         tN;/i;      dJ2-Ic# //, (17.
                     , ThF IJtpic/JlnAI             M      tv/£,')   ~f'M,;.;Jc/,Mtd            Mull- ,   .
            .br iJSi!rc/.                                                       ~taffl./hlf s..i1-1./kr/
                                                                               -~lfl J h~l'lit
                                                                              fi)CT 4P-/617 'tfa. &
                                                                              8.-i/ eltft,vtevh ~0'1,'·1
                                                                              96tJ/ ~tt _s--q I
                                                                              IIM4/b   i/c . .l?;t.4J
                                                                                          I

                                                                                              '791~   7
Lefllt.f'rc~ 1/i# -f&~Nr~ ,.f:_-../ /o T,:JcTCEMd~& ~cry-~~ ~a:! .-_/p;Mr~r~~~---­
·~-----~~&Lce cbE~~~ s;r~~ef ~c- o~~~£~_~~~~~~u&~7~//~----­
•------r-'-"1'-"'-'I/Bv=.;_ "'-_.~-'-~--~&(hvv-r!?! cy;t" ,/'¢£: J/Jtcl.~/lfc4c,/t;c.-.:.'~~··-,- - - -
                       '.'2-le- r#& r/~6.J-£6:C.~,v~c!AI-' ,4!~~,vUtr-~· ·-
 --                  '/VJ li7&

•------'----t-L.:.4-_/1£J
                                  h2~tt;__L_ Cet..ft· ~;J~.tf._C~.. e:;l;a/~~cr e~/<
                                 ~Ltd. a-_h/ ~ /;_a4-a~£ (»-r/r_ (/ /' l'~tT                c #J &-
                                                                                                   ..
                                                                                                         I. ·---
                    ."' /Jc-;?£c/t~ tCALJ~MeJit_tf~U-& ,A~L~c/vr ·
·------r_:_~...=t:""""._&"--"J:....::J'~~_;_/,o.4·~d' • 77J,J rJ ?v~r h-yrz~trcl /tL-r
·------v-'&41, .&/velwh.!l-' . ON.,/pi=· //,G 7 ~ 7'.:.£.--'ckLL!c:u.:tv=&--~----
·------r-t}~Q LMAI ?'                       5rb/£J     M     ·,~. ('~,ME    L.d.L&cf--       &MP~L_ _ __
 _____,tJMf' d£./.gt,tf'r;