Court Opinion

ID: 4058453
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 09:10:09.328848+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:59:38.568175
License: Public Domain

~ _ v ' gb|l?jg`m 1021

.DECSMPJEE I'~f , BOLS

 

QBBL gco€;m, C,;€\ZK
_C.C\Azi_' o\'- C\z`\rv\imt, R¢>P€tLLS

Slnls o\”- Teme , %w\z_sn~s C,_o)\z'\ L’>viu)iroc{
3»0\ UO. \L(T“ %TK€€V,; Rob\\/\ \O(o n
nus‘r\w ,.TX ’l%'lD?

 

 

REE\< pump mm;c\)> Pu\;¢\)€u, L\)€`L,u'h°e ©MW©§§HMML_
_ 'voK-%q , 311_»'0| ,; TR._CLN<>. il¢i_l$§! 'R DE;CMG$S;_-_

 

 

 

 

wz-w, 371-01 /; T°¢z, C-r, No. umwa-n ABQM€§SH’_G,@F@€

 

. Demz N\sz. F\cosm?

 

EMQL,;>=>BD %o\; wic\, F\`Nb ms Pog.\,owic\>c~,?

 

l. Rsevwm_ ro Q¢\¢ilm~/\`T oF KSNMTRR [V\. Foorc. ‘

z.RerzurmL rp % P\zbvws\o F§wome\$ op F:cm, C_,owcw>iom oF bmw mm Uw@a

 

i)_¢énz§_;vvvc@mem m~r Ree\,fm'., w R¢Fiouvh o\= Ke»\\/wwzn m lio=>rr,, m mg
r_=_nc:rs op fm onsz( v €. carmsz oF Fn

.mnrzous P twime Rs>t>dcmar

 

 

 

REFEKENCE§

l. Feibv.un\z‘r 30|'~1 nrro\w@`r Disc"PL?l\)n\z`r `F\cf\`ow> .- . . . . . . . . . .EXH|B\T’A

z.i-|CDC Tue €>Tm'@ ocTems v':>. Pco¢e , l aqooqo¢ mci chzrr acq

ziean anve,zs D;sc;vu'r\)e»v) m Fese\)m>_~r nw maqu aolz . . EXHlBlT-C.

'-1. ane\z op me S»r>¢zeme Cq,rzr <>c T'em§ iv me mnne\z op . . ` -, .. EXH|P>| T»D
i. \1:-> »m'@c,

5. C.c~m Rese‘r F¢€Zn/\i Dmsb (Oxo o\z QE>QM 3-5'0"|; C,Le¢zl<§ RF£.ORD
b. DouHeer,»‘ s1 swan 5~9\\~0<£>; C.uzm<> Recmzo
7. DOCK€T €§u€€T/' €>TRMPE>D 5 ‘l”l 'O”l,' C, Letzc<§ Rec,olz\>
8.P.S. \. Pcm- F§eaeemem ane\zc»o¥z\<; C.Le,lz\mmuw\'w Swe\zvis\'om; CLER\<§ Recc>zb
1O.Os'»zicinLCoM R@x>o'\zrsvz , ao%‘“, mama P_\.r\\zwew; amen/am
To lLIT" CouET o(~ QWE¥J.L>¢` Exl-\i£bh’ \`w F\?V\`vcm`io\w Fok
U\)Riv o¢ HQBE\QB Co\z\>\)§

11.`P\Ecozb`m5 oF Fle,memem HERR`\\\)C) i lZ\'|l>'Oq/‘ H.C.?»DCU" D.C.

1')_. (V\s. aneua E. l/\)iwhe; BF\=iDn\/`sr; E)>'\r o\= \Qwucm"\ow
crow U\)¢zir op Nmszna Coavos

1'5. '|LlT“ Cou\zr oz D.P=Pem.s Memo\zmwbum Os>m'mc\)
111 U.€>. S“\ Ci\zcvi~r; R\>ve,nL;- No.\o-Ams?x; U$DC quo -CW>W\

15. Cnse No. HOOW\\’>B ?~'\3 5 [\)\)iui'~rc'$ Comm'\ss`\ow Forz
Lnuo~'W -’- -” =f -‘“' '~"-"--'

l'_"."_ \..:»~. ._.J

judgment ln two of the matters, Endicott neglected the legal matters entr._=:t:-f t;~ =“.:.‘.
--~¢~l ¢-! I`.J 1` .-`4. .~`

_. ._ ._..-_ ___ ._,.._... u..ea...e fees ln all of the matters, Endicott failed to promptly

.:1\` _¢`»`" .`4~|` \` -~` ~._.` _\` ¢`.. .._(`._»" ~l. ` .` ~.` l¢_' \.`__\ 1.` Z_

. . . _ _ _ _,.. .....,.v . ._ »_1.…._.¢`) .~3. .. ..~_,,,,,~_4~.~~.~ . -;=, _~~_., =_.uiou ~,-`~ ,~_;:; =;~..~.i wl lllei`l |eSpOnSeS to
,-__1§;‘.§3 as directed '

    

Endicott violated Ru|es 1.01(b)(1)_ 1.03(2)_ 1.14(h)_ 1.15(d)_ 8 04(a)/11 8.04(a)(7)‘ and

nll»-\lf\\

.b' ‘°~"\;:,"\'_‘_.'.

f"“ "" " "" ` " -=z':'t ';fT::'.::- -:~.:::;;ted the resignation, in lieu of
'_ES~'-~ ;. ii_"_e, of :':a "~"'~~"" .* )r. f:': §7‘2’."."2"_‘0] 63 of Fort Davis At the time of

\`.1.` …~\..'._‘__-_ _l.f_-_ ’l

.¢»¢.l-a. .- ___4.`4 `¢u.;‘.t"f
l l

   
   

 

L, ,.... _..~.._.l. !..,\.~ »l° _._L£
--ll\.' lll\.=r.m nu¢¢¢;n\,.-n :\_~u l\;_ »-».
l . .

   

violated his fiduciar j t

   

client representh s ;’~ ~‘..“: :': *%':: .':;‘;';::.’:*.::‘_.:.“: tv
Foster violated Rules1 01(b)(2), 1 04(a) 1 06(b)(2), 3. 03(a)(1) 3 03(a) 303{¢_){6),
304/h) RnA/a\/’)\ Q__h__'._/- \"_:,_ ;_~-__ _

`\.'..

`_`j: :_`:_°:".:`;;`_§.S

   

On Nov 6, 2013 Ray Galvan Jr [#075’€.-;-; ’.‘., 51 c;’ ,»C-.;£;.;;-;»“;

 
  
  
  
  
    

probated suspension effective Nov 15 20 .3 far ~;.‘
Grie\!ancp Comr\»‘_'*' F.':: ::'::".' .__::....,:_._._..:__?:..:.,..;_ A,U ‘ _ q ._ _____ ..
~'3:' ' _ '. ;~ ., ~.~ ‘ ` ' ;‘ ";.`.ants decision

`:`.:~' 3ly informed

r.`_r\\\:nn \1\"`4‘\4 qu\l\e 4 n*l /\’\\/1\ 1 nr)[rg\(’)\ 1 nQ(q\ ?r\d 1 1/1[|¢\\ ug \.laq nrdar°d fn hay
.. `__/, __'- ____, ____.__.,... _ ‘__.

~""2 ."";"; "\. '.-_ _,:'.~.. '. .. !'_~..-. .. _ ': `. ~." \ T\ H:_. .'J:~_. \ _

._ . ._.,j_,.".'_`_`,`.:~:$.

Galvan filed an appeal on Nov. 15, ZGEE.

,..-_.,..,_,.-- ,..__ ,,. ,

 

_ :;`~::.:3. l, 3333. .._e District 10 Grievance
f~'~: f}‘~“-'~-»‘~;-:;? :‘:‘;~?;*_*,:;‘ :_`:‘::i:‘_..tl*.“~ :m, failedto\nform

   

_¢-4_ _Q. .i__:.. 4 04 __l§:_\__(

l __:_;;`___ _~_:; _____“‘ § = 1\ 1 n°“\\ 1 44/'\\ "~~'~¢j“ 4¢:/{4\ Lln \_;Jas Ordered to pay

4_ .._.\

 

'. _

..___._. __,....__ .. .._._ ".""‘

____ _ __..._»__b

 

9/9/2015 ' l ' " . ` _ fhce fHarris County District Clerk - Chris Daniel
/ >< li ‘ la dr
' \ i /

HCDistrictclerk.com The MTexas vs. FOOTE, KENN[TR'A (SPN:; 9/9/2015
13§8§`9§1'5”1 ) v
Cause: 131400401010 CDI: 3 Court 209

APPEALS
No Appeals found

BON_DS
No Bonds found

PAYMENT PLAN
No Payment Plan found

RELATED CASES
No related cases found

DOCUMENTS

Proper credentials required Please lggin or contact Hanis County District Clerk's Offlce at (713) 755-
7300_

BOOKINGS
No Bookings found

HOLDS
No Holds found

WI'I`NESS
No Witness found

SUl\/ll\'lARY

§§ _ _ ET
Fi]eDate

   
      

.' DEFENDANTDETAIL

    

722sz ,

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

   

 

 

 

 

 

 

Race/Sex Height/W eight
Case (Cause) Status Act.ivc - CRIMINAL Eyes Ha-lr
Offense EXPARTE SHOW CAUSE Skin B“ild
Last lnstrument Filed EX Parte Proceedjngs DOB lo Cusmd‘. N
C“° DiSP°§ifi°” Us Unavaiiabie Place or Binh
Case Completion Date N/A _sz_en g w
Defendant grams JA]L Address 3300 LYONS STE 201 HOUST()N
TX77020
Bond Amount $0.00
Markings
Next/Last Setting Date ,g 7/26/20]] …` s k l w nn 7 l y 0 v
C@URTDETAILS _,

 

http:/Mww.hcdistrictclerk.comledocs/public/CaseDetailsPrinting.aspx?Get=ZnocTANJynlyB12Yszquptthr0Hj3lh3nSanWi4sanhogy8W6T koP1 7rYf10... 1/3

9/9/201 5

   

~ » in February and March- Houston Lega|

  

_, T50N LEGAL

11 local lawyers disciplined 1n February and March

By Mary Flood on March 13»2012 3: 45 PM

fs:rlz¢ma* ` 505

  

Whrom = Sections

General questions regarding attorney discipline should be directed to the Chief Disciplinary Counsel's Office, toll-free (877) 953-
5535 or (512) 453-5535. The Board of Disciplinary Appeals may be reached at (512) 475-1578. |nformation and copies of actual
orders are available at www.txboda.org. The State Commission on Judicial Conduct may be contacted toll-free, (877) 228-5750
or (512) 463-5533. Please note that persons disciplined by the Commission on Judicial Conduct are not necessarily licensed
attorneys.

 

RE|NSTATEMENT

J. Robert Love [#00791139], 45, of Houston, has filed a petition in the 113th District Court of Harris County for reinstatement as
a member of the State Bar of Texas.

BODA ACT|ON

On Jan. 31, the Board of Disciplinary Appeals signed a final judgment disbarring Robert Leonadis “Pete' McKinney [#13723400],
6'|, of Houston. On May 12, 2011, McKinney was sentenced to prison for four months, followed by supervised release for three
years, and ordered to pay a fine of 8250,000 and an assessment of 8100 in Cause No. 1:11CRO(]059-001 styled, United States of
America v. Robert l_. McKinney, in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohiol Eastern Division, after McKinney
pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit bribery in federally funded programs in violation of 18 U.S.C. §371 (18 U.S.C. §666), an
intentional crime as defined in the Texas Ru|es of Disciplinary Procedure. The criminal judgment is final. BODA Cause No.
48984. (Editor's Note: Robert McKinney [#00784572], of Austin, is not the attorney referred to in this action;)

On Feb. 1, the Board of Disciplinary Appeals affirmed the judgment of partially probated suspension of Kristin Diane Mlkinson
[#24037708], 48, of Houston, signed by an evidentiary panel of the District 4-E Grievance Committee on Jan. 21, 2011, in Case
No. H0080827321. Wilkinson remains on active suspension until April 30, 2013, with the remainder probated until May 1, 2015.
BODA Cause No. 48195.

RESIGNAT|ONS

On Dec. 13, the Supreme Court of Texas accepted the resignation, in lieu of discipline, of Steven A. Bearman [#90000546], 48, of
Houston. Bearman represented a client in a personal injury case, settled the case without the client's permission, and converted
the settlement funds. Bearman violated Ru|es 1.02(a)(2] and 1.14(b).

On Dec. 12, the Supreme Court of Texas accepted the resignation, in lieu of discipline, of Dan Dewitt Simmonds [#24027980], 39,
of Katy. The Court found that in connection with the settlement of two personal injury matters, Simmonds failed to hold funds
belonging in part to the clients separate from his own property, to keep the funds in a separate trust account, and to promptly
deliver all the funds that the client was entitled to receive; disbursed the funds to persons who were not entitled to receive
them; and engaged in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceitl or misrepresentation. Simmonds violated Ru|es 1.14(a), (b),
and (c) and 8.04(a)(3). He was ordered to pay 88,377.94 in attorney's fees and costs.

On Dec. 12, the Supreme Court of Texas accepted the resignation, in lieu of discipline, of Steven Jay Rozan [-#17357000], 68, of
Houston. At the time of Rozan's resignation, there were 10 disciplinary matters pending against him. |n six of those matters,
Rozan neglected the legal matters entrusted to him. |n eight matters, he failed to keep his clients reasonably informed about the
status of their legal matters and to promptly comply with reasonable requests for information. |n seven matters, he failed to
refund advance fee payments. In three of the matters, he failed to surrender papers and property to which his clients were

i'rttp://blog_chron.com/houstonlegal/?O‘lZ/O?i/11-|ocal-|awyers-discip|ined~in-february-and-march/ 1/5

9/9/2015 ' 11 local lawyers disciplined in Febri.ary and March- Ho\.ston Legal

entitled. |n four matters, he violated a disciplinary judgment and failed to comply with Section 13.01 of the Texas Ru|es of
Disciplinary Procedure relating to the notification of an attorney's cessation of practice. Rozan violated Ru|es 1.01(b)(1). 1.03(a),
1.15(d)l and 8.04(a)(7) and (a)(l 0). He was ordered to pay 812,692.53 in attorney's fees and expenses and 861,925 in restitution.

SUSPENSIONS

On Dec. 14, Richard Alan Mintz [#14198800], 60, of Houston, accepted a one-year, fully probated suspension effective Nov. 15.
An evidentiary panel of the District 4-F Grievance Committee found that Mintz. upon termination of his representation, failed to
surrender papers to which his client was entitled and failed to refund an advance payment of fee that had not been

earned. Mintz violated Rule 1.15(d). He agreed to pay 3525 in attorney's fees and 83,620 in restitution.

On Nov. 19, Robert C. Gerringer [#07826200], 56, of Houston, received a three-year, partially probated suspension effective Jan.
1, with the first year actively served and the remainder probated. An evidentiary panel of the District 4-D Grievance Committee
found that Gerringer failed to keep his client reasonably informed about the status of her legal matter, to promptly comply with
reasonable requests for information. to promptly deliver funds that third parties were entitled to receive, and, upon termination
of representation, failed to surrender property to which the client was entitled. Gerringer also failed to timely furnish to the
Office of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel a response or other information as required by the Texas Ru|es of Disciplinary
Procedure. Gerringer violated Ru|es 1.03(a), 1.14(b), 1.15(d), and 8.04(a)(8). He was ordered to pay 81,865 in attorney's fees and
expenses

On Dec.14,Arthur Eureste [#06702250], 57, of Houston, accepted a one-year fully probated suspension effective Nov.15.An
evidentiary panel of the District 4- B Grievance Committee found that Eureste was hired for representation in a bankruptcy case.
During the course of the representation the client made numerous attempts to contact Eureste to ascertain the status of her
case; however, Eureste failed to respond. Eureste violated Ru|e 1.03(a).

 
 
  
 
 
 
   

n Dec. 15, Kennitra M. Foote l#24029552], 39, of Houston. accepted a two-yearl partially probated suspension effective Dec.

15, with the first three months actively served and the remainder probated. An evidentiary panel of the District 4-A Grievance
Committee found that in connection with representation in a personal injury matter, Foote failed to explain an offer of settlement
to the extent reasonably necessary to permit the client to make an informed decision regarding the offer of settlement and to
abide by the client's decision of whether to accept the settlement offer. Upon receiving settlement funds in which the client had
an interest Foote failed to promptly notify the client of her receipt of the funds and to promptly deliver settlement funds the
client was entitled to receive. Also Foote failed to withdraw from representing the client after she had been discharged. Foote
vio Ru|es 1. 02(a)(2) 1 .03(a) and (b),1.14(b) and 1.15(a)(3). She agreed to pay 81 100 in attorney's fees and expen

   
  
   

On Jan. 27 John S. Chase, Jr. [#04149100], 59, of Houston, accepted a three- -year, partially probated suspension effective Jan.
31 with the first six months actively served and the remainder probated. An evidentiary panel of the District 4- E Grievance
Committee found that in representing a client Chase failed to maintain communication with the client. Upon Chase' s settlement
of the client's matter, Chase failed to notify the client of his receipt of settlement funds and to promptly forward any funds to
the client, Chase converted the funds for his own use, but repaid the funds prior to a scheduled disciplinary hearing. Chase
commingled his own funds with the client's settlement funds. Chase failed, upon the conclusion of a contingent fee matterl to
provide the client with a Written statement describing the outcome of the matter and showing the remittance to the client and
the method of its determination. Chase violated Ru|es 1.03(a), 1.04(c), and 1.14(a) and (b). He agreed to pay 31,384.04 in
attorney's fees and costs.

PUBLlC REPR|MANDS

On Dec. 5. Caesar Escalante [#06662090], 60, of Houston, accepted a public reprimand. The 127th District Court of Harris
County found that Escalante settled his client's case, but thereafter failed to keep his client updated as to the status of the
payment of the settlement monies. Escalante violated Ru|e 1.03(a). He agreed to pay 82,000 in attorney's fees and expenses.

Categories: General

 

Promoted stories

f

http://blog.chron.com/houstonlega|/2012/03/11-local-|awyers-disciplined-in-february-and-march/ 2/5

ii Xb“i>/\Y@

ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT OF TEXAS
MISC. DOCKET NO. 13-9166

IN THE MATTER OF KENNITRA M. FOOTE

The Court has reviewed the Motion for Acceptance of Resignation as Attorney and
Counselor at Law in Lieu of Disciplinary Action‘of-"l<§ennitrar"h/l. Foote (the Motion) and the
Response of the Off`lce of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel for the Commission for Lawyer
Discipline (the Response). The Court concludes each meets the requirements of Part X of the
Texas Rules of Disciplinary Procedure. Therefore, the Court deems the professional misconduct
detailed in the Response conclusively established for all purposes The Court further concludes
that acceptance of the resignation of Kennitra M. Foote is in the best interest of the public and
the profession

Therefore, the law license of Kennitra M. Foote of Houston, Texas, State Bar Card
Number 24029552 is canceled The Court notes that Kennitra M. Foote has already surrendered
her Texas bar card and Texas law license to the Clerk ofthis Coun. v

Consequently, Kennitra M. Foote is prohibited from practicing law in the State of Texas.
She is prohibited from holding herself out as an attorney at law, performing legal services for
others, giving legal advice to others, accepting any fee directly or indirectly for legal services,
appearing as counsel or in any representative capacity in any proceeding in any Texas court or
before any Texas administrative body (whether state, county, municipal, or other), or holding
herself out to others or using her name in any manner in conjunction with the Words “Attorney at

Law,” “Counselor at Law,” or “Lawyer_»

wK~Z‘{/¢??Z‘Ol; M-e Numr>ez‘.") HLHZ§’I nw l I'N.\Q~Z» lN contrast To me Flr~t:ionvit Ficer), ns
Pazev`ious adam or rue State/z toir¢\)ess, l cnw sheer to me rou.owi'ne ns unreus?

1.. lY\s. i rum~ buses pemoiiuo nea\nsr ms. l 010 nor ize\:use to eo to
tzlnt., l in Fnct insisreb ow it. ma Foote mace me siar\i/ oi\) matzen 5,?100‘1, ms
other asset Foizr\/i, ev nn X, cement bee wait`mo oF."l com want rue l‘S~¢z.
orrerz, I want to ec to riz`mt .“(‘E>ce= Cooizr Ressr Poetv; patco ?>~'3>-061; Cceei<’>
Recorzvl i Neveiz iranian or a P.$,l. Feom Wls. Foove/ u~tii, mr misc onte/ done R”h
100¢1/‘ winch was ser nFtEZ me assertion or %-3-0€! to Z-i'l ~Oq , indem l diem
ser/oaa me boone to se nonnor\iisuso concee~smo mind flaceoi~c re co,tzt zecoeos,
l was ser rotz taint r-oiz born me bates o\fi 1'|\1"01 crop b'M-O¢l, stemming seem
me notion Bar/oaks ms Juoosi materials on coins to riz`im.. ( Bes= Docinesr, stun/msp '£>~\1~0¢1;Cceize"> Recoei))

Tne State 050 ~or continue re oreeiz cruzer non cnaeerz sentences news case

went o\\i,' in Fncr, rice forms crestst smotcsra mm smntceiz sentences 1 30 ves. ,

to AO ‘res./ to l'; wea.(§ee'-thzr lze%t F<>Etv~i baron 3'3'0€1 ,' C_=.stze's Recoizt)l li=.fl/\s. Foote

wns"svtzs”ruut l owcp izecsive n cessna vu~isumsm seem me duces romo seen rue

Stnts/ war was me P.S,l. voirth mo noeeeD Recor\/teroomiord; war was l smc sve.>‘ecr

'ro mo now iznwete o\= wmisiimem, 6~¢1¢1 ves., wired me fumes arena was 15 ve>.~,"i~ widen

l msceivep"??? l\= fV\'). Foote was"$\»tze/'(i.<'. onmise), wwr oit>t\it l rzeceivs sess man
count rue inure oresest> ?°.?

lt th~). Foote expedition in oemi<. ms P. ir ro ms rif mci Let
stone r»iizsr, new comp sue uan Pvr nw X iv nw need mr nwticnsce nov move to `
seamen me wuixe oven oor?`?.? (E`>ee°~ Pt<~>.\. Pten‘ Uorzeemem Pnt>etzwotz\‘l; Ci-Elzté lZ€CO\Z\Dl
Mz. chmir\?,n, l'Vl,|'-oorc is paine uwttzomr‘»uu~/ ncaa tisan mobva oPeQm\)pi,

2. l F mo coaecioio ~oiz_rutzams wells mt armco me iranian r-'oz me rs memo ouiuv,
tour amoco (Yls. Fcore"`mmE€? Cov\zr stef l:c»e.m; DmED "
53 'O%' C,Le¢z\<'s llecoz\o) iF mv case was`\\aeom re Ec,"ser poe mm lssporze
we Jvoees P.S.l. anmow'\sumems, wm was ir avaem>»r ser mata TrzinL , cLea\zu<
E)\PRES§BD ‘.7?.7 (&`>Ee? Doc\<&1 %v€~er.¢ sTnn/\PED 547 ~(>q ,’ Cvestz\¢'s Qecoeol lt
-Jvo@e Coma)s owele to coam\)c_r a P.?>.l Heazla)c\ ama owen Less man lamar
mg €s\~mr, uaw on me var».'>LE , vvwr nimv'r l Racsive Less man ms léwas. ; uaw
was l war evBJEc/r fo me PvLL name oz Pvm`sum€ivr 'l°§? Qas rasse"comlznolcrm@"
Evearrs vvum~ Leo rv "n Bmzm< \'N ms smmso\=r~”e>ervveém ms E>rm"es vvimess
amc m‘rseu:".??. is wis warn ven me T'o memo Qv`\u'v ‘?7;? l)\)wr wassv'r Jvoc»c;
Coma)s' or=r-Grz maoe ao<>D (o`.e. Fva.a=iu_eo)/ i»= mv nG»le@me~Nr 10 Pus\ao emiu'v
aeerD vPo»v sam ocFer; 77?

lF fVle. F`oo~re j~avw r-em~ mm a wavw N%ver& man m~./seLF re as LBD, wm
wouu) He¢z Tesr\mmw/ svpvossl>ur nev mv B%Hau: .. m ms P.S.l H€al<'m@ 1561

i‘ \ ' . . . \' 7 "
’chz.l)\)\vawe ss a \=sLLovvek am mcmanus op \?>e\~a n \_eax>etz. ?'.’. \\'»

l sie~eo ran men ne@eem€m ovcvm€ms 'vvimom~ Hes`\rarlow, vvuzw mo
`(V\s. Fosre c-)\Puaia) mem fo ms; wualze was m~r usvm. mom)s ope\zam>l
mem seems rum mgrze, vvas m uas`\m¢iocv Bervv€<§rv ms R@c@’\v’vve mm
siemia)@ mem °?7.? lF lYls. `\iome \=.~/~vm`nveb rv mrs ns sue o'm"¢m_ 1452 chiemS/’/
wovu> l ss cowsioe\ze,b m'.sia»\=oeme'lm oz neceiver) °.??(%ee" Ferz¢zvmz~r 9mm
nrto@w€`f DisclPLlmeY Flc,riow§l

lr-l’l/ls. Foore L@r ms Ka)ovv (\`.e.plaom\'sz,) l amqu Rczcel\¢s 1a Less€¥z
semmes THmv was mv ms vague vv\`m mg STaTE f wm mccannch ro
comer chom)s l oimv'r ?.?`? lp l maer aer-'vs@,v> ms oc>ri<>w op emma ns
mmc 1 uov.) was l anomsz ~nbmvwismeo rv ge seT' ma man mims °.":?
(Se@? Dec\§¥> 2>'1’\ ~'O°l;
Cl.ez\<") Reco\z.®l (Yl‘>. Kewmir'\za, ll/l. lioer a`s memo umwquva , H€\Z vs\)m.
mobl)§ GPE>ZRNDi .

3. l‘F l’/ls. Foore "Plzomise,o” me wm me dvo@e , rmzo\)em P._%. l,, wouuo o\=r-e\z
me a_ess man vvm.rr ms %Tars mac os=r=e\z¢;o ns r-\ pl_€n, r~\c:¢zes~mev\)v , umw
vvovmw'r (Vls- Foore, PvT r1 cm> nw ms una)@s or~' Pvmsumev\)v, ravT a_e\=r
me svesecr rv ms efva names vF Pvmisum€m', mm vviru n"v>lzom`\se”
nst sve.\escx ro ever rats move moon (\`.e. r-'vu=iLst>). imava a dvoe€.,
Tuzovcm. n P.S.\./ oFFetz ms Pva)is‘lamévvr, mz"e\`\ve"ms va\`:>umsz ?7.`?
E>e,cm)ss l ms)v"r vsl=erz@o ammim. la me 16 weo. was mv ol=\=€r;,
cw\z\<'s mecom snow mm l nlmv'+c voam ms 15 ~rR, o\'-\=Ek 1 Bv‘r‘ vvmvrlsb `
TD Cvo Tb fl?.`\f-l(,»

l\= ms ov=rc,ow\s vr- me P.§.\. R@x>om wovu> german/lime \'F l umw Receive
Przoe.mlow, wm was\v% l olvsvv me owomvmiw rs asview ms P."s\_ mspsz
m am sme»e w m*r case‘??.? lF ms Svoee omvirv@ mrs ms man case
vacuum oecs'zmia)s \'F l vvov\,u> Receivs Przo¢smiovv , vvwr vvouL.u> we \)v'ome,

2.

LONT. .» PQGEZ. ;_

TEL<, me , ns som\) ns me Henz`me smmr.v, ze\=o\ze oec_v`me, mm we ncTunL cn§€¢
mm sue was mr come To oiv& me PRanTio\\) 7`?? l mo movant n RS.|. was
neou‘r Paoe>m'\ow: i r»`\u,eD our n Rerwes»r Fo\z one»mio~ (See? I`(\oTiow Focz
Commum'\r\r §uvezv'ie>ioc\> 1 C\.em<’s Kecomn)/ sic-men Fo¥z me P.$.l. / l=iu.eo ouT n
on\snriow PnceR C,ommuwiv.' Swe\zv?~siow was e\z¢zomeou:>uv FiLc.¢-:~D
our 6‘: mS.FooTe , nTTesTim mm l mm weverz seem Panev> ow C,ommu¢uir~r
Su¢>e¢zvi<>iow rea n Fe¢_c>\\)'r. E>oru f\/ls.Fmre mm donee CoLLms mass ms ro useder
mm ir was umw n P.€.l. was manor mon mms uaw \ wouc,o aeceiw> ir

(`\.e. pczo\zm`»m\)). ms. Kr-.N\\)ir\zu m. Foom vs sam umszmm=uu. , Hecz usum.
mcDus ope\zn\)Di,

u. \' oio wm waive me couRT ze\>orz'r€\z aec,oszo`me me uemz'n~>cq; l mm
nez,c)wrew mo K~ow¢,e\)os, or- Tu'\s; mm DEF'\'Nmur o'\o NoT cowzem re ir.
Tmzcwau.oor ms ou\zmiow cc me uemz`m@ l was um)ek me impke$:>'»ow wm
'\r was acme Rec,otzoeb, l mm mo season fo min muerau)'\sei Tue comm
Re¢>z>mmz <:~.m iv positiou\) fo Re<;<>w.o we Hemz{\\\@ , winn 1452 mncu'¢me im mm o\=
usa nm amendch iv (i.e.wo'\wo),' wue,m run duces wm me semcm sue row
me comm ze\>o\zre.e, "U)e{ze ccc me aeco\z®"( ma wmemiwe ¢,imm.mz `m
~mulze , nmb mem walls m maize woin 1 nw vouel\) me donee came anew sue

m.o ms cover czevoczre\z, "\)Je'\ze saw nw rub meco\zb"( ma somemiwc~ sinn\)u:\a
iw runwrza), mm me cover zeeoe:rel emmeb e>nc\< T\(P\'ma. baum ease
wouuo l, 02 owe emma uvmm\) adm rui¢\n¢ ?`??

h= \ was Pzeeem wuew me umw RBPo\zf¢:R. mm wm`v€l> nmb R&cz&&b ,
wm D`\D OGF§c-_im Cov¢z¢ Revovzree , mazda Emzww , wake re ms M“* Csu\zr
our owean , Tum"` ms. Fo\>re'/ come re 1452 1 mm sua nsKeD"ms. Fob~cs iv we
wentzin was emma w E>e R&cozoeb , nm`\(\/\s.\?bbm”snio mo mm ir wae.w'rf
mg coma zsvb\zr;,\z 010 mr mem\oau n/}a. mm?,ou§ 9 U\Siwife (€)es? GF¢ic_'mL
Coum Ke\>brzmz,' aoz"‘; mama E»mzwew; sm-rsmem m lu“‘ Coka op viems:
E>\u'\p,'n i~ ch,icnr'mu ma UURir oz Hmzsn> Co¢zws); wm 050 mroawe\< r-'o¢z
me %mr'e , J. ‘i>re\>uewsN lB\-\b -0¢1 , m mw \Qe>n'rsmem i-\emzir\)@ , rem
duces Dew'e% Co:_dm mm ue m\)D Ke\\)\\)'\v\m aetz€éb fo waive me Recol?oi¢\)&
oc-' ms uemzim: ms meesz mo wm memiow ma mmaws P. U\)imi're

(`See'~Rs<,oxzo'\wm as QBmemem Hemzi~c»; 1149 »0@|; 'l-\.C. 9\0@‘“ D.C.) ???

u)wr 1':> meza ¢\ niFFelZeroT ncaoum' as mis"wnivek”r»eom ma Kewmimn m.
Poore l W|s. mazda Bmzwe‘rv, nmb Y\H\z. J. €>rc>\>uemsow 'Z?? (¢= me RuLes
op D\>%mrs pmacher , Ruu; 13.1, en~m ms oFFicim. comsz espo\zrgz musT',
umess women law noeeenr\sm o¢= me pner\’@:>/ mm wim me ane\z>' ns Pn\zr m=' me kecoczo 1 o\z mms a'w open
comm mm QNTEQGD i`m<> me Rr>c,o\z)m nccoma‘mc\ w ms Ruues oF C,;vic,
Paoceo\)rzs 1 @uu=,. ll `?'?7. l/Om me cbs\z\¢s amoco nom i~cwc)s copies or-
mqu waiw@\\) wm've\z> ore nw mcmanus mccree ac me P.S.\. Hemziwm
ncco\zoim@ r<> me Ru\,es 06 p\p%<.\f\\'e P\zoc@bum§, Kuus ?>Ll,$ Cn)(l) ?`7.?

mm mnlzcvs 9 \)\\iLu'mz, Nevsk sieweb mm wn'\vez oF me wn§v@D 66!=0\2€ oven
cover me ee\>o\z<>Licn+ibw ma ‘u\)czh ac Hmz,en"s Co\zo\)s).
W\s. ‘\:oove’ u,u`\m mm me "armes wir~%sse:> Wszs ~oT cowen eecnuss oc

n srcz'ae'sr'\c, move oN age met 1 is '\~ comr-ocr w`\m Tu§ dunes us\k1 wu@ee n\zs ms wimesses , mo mm vacuum usa Tum` us
nom uan mm "; nw ms dunes name me Pm>sewro\z, wmr\“ mo me
wimz,%s%s uan w sam mm mm umwa uea ,"we~r sum mm me‘f nom water
fo anz, nw~rruiwc» re bo wm me mse¢. Rua.e§ op Ev`\newc€ 1 Ruuz %OUCA)
iadc'*»)c$) mrs 1 n oecumznm 55 coms'n>ek€b re as s1an nhan ns n w`moes:>
UMD€(Z WD% C\UAJW]€>TH'NCBS.

me undue n zim-w m amman nw ma Fo¢re marine mm l no\zSSD .c> ms
PS.|. i'm innsva l o'u>m` amein P\zo\§¢l\'\ow l comm _»T\Lu DES>P\)TB m‘r
sem@me 1 wm Wouuo \ umwa mw Revo!zrev.s mmsz 1 women n oe\¢emonm
ns n szm con».nimmo on nvx>sm_,~ wave nm"om_ic>miow”fo waive
Fozwmzo Reco\z® fo s\>srniw {r's com recov'\o\)s o\= emma 1 mm iF mr ooNE1
mv coM\>ua'\m come wm se uemz\D .?7 me unv\m n mem m nwcn¢, wu~r
wouuo (V\»>. liona umw m wmch m\<, \zes>¢.>\zre,\zs macozo, mwme mm
nrrore naoicnvgo re Pe\zr-sm~ibw mr ncw\zm~; Rr><;.>zoz
r»orz ¢zcsv€c;w nw nweu.ms ¢o~.,¢zvs \‘\: po`u\)rs o\= ecause mae fo aeceivs
\=r-\`\fl coms(o@\?m'iom nmb _msv zuLim:> ??? U\)m ruiz ueiz c*-h:>b-w-§~nzv
now ?'?7 D{D sue 14qu nw#rruiwcv fo uins?.?`?

flaw ms momewv l wave swva oF ruiz nu,eoe»e¢> waivez 1 unv“e
comvmmw nc \'r mm cunLLzme»eD ir¢ F\zmw_ oismicr c<>ulzr (SEe¢Reca>P.nim
oF `|Q\?)ur@m’€;s¢r i~l%urz`i 4161 \Z-l£ 'O¢i ; H.C. ?\O%T“ D.C.\} re ms NT'* Couxzc mr
Rwe¢l\::» ("De~e’¢ N“‘ Coer oF flawean memorznwoum C)Pimi<>\\)),° re lime,zm,
CQ,QT (S»>es= L).%. 5“1 Cm<»,uh~; nw@n<.; No. m -20151; USDC No, ~'mt> »
CV' F>MU; To me €:Tm@ (bmz oF Tems, wmerar,`m ‘i s={LeD n @rz`\%vnwce
nemva Hez, mm sue mem games me @vio€s\m'm”<~r pnm lH ap mg
_Smrc; E>mz Di->nzicr H.Gz'u=_mwcs C<>n/)mh~res o- 1 €l~IZ-B , nw g%;@w@p,
m dev o\= Disc}pL}me (S@si Cne\s No. MOO’|H’>'S 213 ;Cwi¢.w`rs“.l Comn/¢is:>iol\)

Ll.

comm , ppc\e> 14~_}

~.=oR an“relz Discimmz v, Kc-Nminzn m, FooTe); mem to me Cowzr op Czin/)iwnL
QPV€ML;’). ma Foote muD nn‘rs@u= Neve\z mm nw cowve\zs¥rr`\bt\) 1 moa
@mTen/xem name , won nmm'me impue\> , won nmmis\)c» Himer) comerzwim
me waisz o\< me zevo\zrezs Re>coeo op m~r ov m~r P.S.I. Hen\>_iwc» ,' Ne\’rus\z
wm ir munz \<¢wu\>w m ms Co»m ma %rmz, § N@`»m@z I>»'D me Comar
motz %Trms sewsz me mm 1 wong mr nevrziveb ms m~r Pac>re<:\"eb {s\)r'zz'>r.
by imP'Lc-n/\Q\>fme mm snr’)sr~w'mcq mg Vzoce.D\/Qm. en¢eeoam; ro ewe,vzs
mm me Q@Pozreef>. Recom> op mw P.S.|. Henzi¢uc. M>v e>s waiveo wimom'
mr Kmocue.e\oee> mg cows@m.- i o`»o Nor names m umwa ms newman
aeco\zv> op m~r P.%.|. Hemz`mo; ir was romwv , 'r=ncwmw , nw cpemzcr
wimom r\n“r KNOWLSDG»G Nolz cowsew\`. ma Foote is theme umizmu\=uc,c /
H@z weum, mo\)\):> oveznwni .......

W\o\zzova l W\s. Kewwirm (\/\. Foore wm o\zosmz\o 1 m me flouer , To F\`uz
ns\=io\¢\v'\r window ?>D mm oF, 10 -“50 --\`s; W\s. Foore’ nr~r»ionviT wm siev\»eol
\\‘7~'\5, overaqu owe m=ré\z win oe\oe\z , wimow nw enewribw op fin/nsn
vfV\'>. Foove’ aar-1310an wm r-iu§b a¢\\=re\z me Res\>owoem§ Pm>mseb F\'Noiwo op
Fnu- mm Ozo:vz wm r-'BLED l wmch wm re ss us\;\o re mm<@ r»\'moims oF 'r~ncr.
(V\'».Foor@’ amoan \`:> wm sv\>c>¢>xzf@c> m me \z@u>m> , mm mo n.cc:ionv'w
um‘>ux>vorzvex> rev ms clequ cm,moT onvioe n BF\*>'»§ coe n \=i~oimo ,

F\s ms %mres Wimess , W‘\‘>. \Coove’ cczeo`»¢=,'w'w~r mm 155 mmc\~r~°\n/\omv m=,um me wime.s->e:> zevmmic>m flora umwa n cunancrek op
-.,Nrszum\=uwess oz F>‘r r%sf'\mom ~\'N ms \@o\zm oF nw oviwiom macm- mm
curxxzn<;rmzz 'r-\st/ i\= 3145 wave comm'.rrsb n emma o;: n \=e\.ov\>~r 012 imvo\,v%r~.)c».
mozm To\zP'vTuDB , R%szbuess 0\= P\)N'\§umem} ca i> c-'Za,ic_'\reb \=\2<>¢\4 ms

wimess oz zzrmausueo ran made aecom>. Wl~>. Fobre emma rv as reumwu.

(SGG‘ F@R>(Zomz`r 3014 QrToRNBY Dibc."m,`lwuk‘c nc¢iom)($€€? HCDC Tus ccst
op szs vs. F-oore,'ls>u.Olt§q 151 ; Causs‘- \Kwoc>qmolo_; CQMJ AO°\\
(€>ee.¢ Loc¢u. an~¢ee> Disc'~vum@b m Fee,\zuma~r mm mclean S\Olb\)(€>eer Ocvx>sz@mcs Cnvtzr o\= Tems im me N\rms-xz op Kewwir\m (V\. Foors ; n/\\SC.
Do<,\5§, Rmvlse‘r 1.Uuir
F\o¢,umzow{ T¥.. '1'|51;3

5.

U)R' qu a’?‘L-Cl; w\'<`~i"l,?\’li'O?\

Cause No. | lli 1157~£\
Cause No_ H’l‘l |£f‘é'g

E)\ PL\QTE § m me ao\)TTQL T 0

Swme§ PIZDPDSEO F\MDH\)G§ C)F FFU
Cowcw%lo\\)$ QF uaw m\)D 0\?0%2

Tue, D\>x>u'cnm ms wmmez@\> me nvx>uc.m-€DN ma web op weems comm me
Smrez Oaiaiwm C\\oew@x< nmb opr-icm word Kecom>s m me move ~ cnmioweo
onus-sea T`Hs Rwdcnm' o@cmrzea ns Fiwoine op F¢\c,r mg mswbav o\= ms cases
ns ser Folzfu i'¢u ms nomicmiom r<>\z weir m= means cowur>. Tuz, Um\"`cnm
neca maez mm mm mae commc>v€:zre\> 1 mz@v€ousur umz@su,vsr> Fncvs
mmez?mc To ms Laem.\'r\r mr me modean cowc‘iwz~_:mem ww°cu cze@~.)v'rz@ nw
eviozm'\mz‘r Hzmzir\)c» muD wm umw mm me \zzl_.ie.v czecm game \ze, e»¢znmreo
Fo\z ms Fou.ouo'n\)@ tzensw\)§-'

F\ND\NC‘¢S OF FF\CT

1. Tue meme oz ms cne.cz ns ser maru §N m~r nwdcmiom \=o\z weir o\:
means corz\>u:,; sumeme-:»mev) ns ser mem SN mv Reamm re
mcdoan oc l oc Fncr, Co:oc\,u¢,iows op Lm» mw Oxzoez
wm mm)e Wimom’ nw A\=\=\"onvir mom men \ mob
D\zoel?. ron F~im\)@ F\r-\:'\Dmir, m me Couner Tue\zzr»o\ze mn\<§¢\)c» if
VO\D.

CONCLU":`IONS DF L\flU\)

1. Tue nwu'cnms Hmzeuz cunLLeme nLLee\'No mmc cum 92on is p.

~Rsco\z® umwa mm was ran`\seb m cover mvv ow nizecr nwam(€>se=
H\">Tozv o»~ me Cp.sa; ns sen Foer iv mv nmic¢mom r-ora weir ov un@@n:>

CONT.) PQGEl./`_

S.

coa\>u:> mm svt>PLsmewr)/' me RWLicmurb Raco\?o cmim i> mae nu,s@iwc»
iwe\=\=eu'¥ve> ns>i§m\)ce of c,o\)r~)seL; macomb nw mead nv\>e,m, iwn\>éouvmz
10 nev@w\>€ mo iwe\=\¢em')v% ns:'>`~smmce. amin/1 , me v€.‘\z'v \'we\=vec.viv€mss
chairman mm masva ma zeco\zb> c:\zom comni¢\)me me immammiw
wecesz>mz‘( To sv@¢>mwc'vm"e s\)cu cmim':`Du¢FY/a>©‘l S.l)\)- 30 501 S\'J~.,S\S.
me mich mecsz om>'kuv`iw ones mr czev-Lecr couwse¢§ zenso:\ns ma

Doicoe ma midwo to 00 ncr-iowso\: mmcu. me usesstan comv<,miw§;
Vuscw@z/ O S.l/O. “AD @IS|. W\o¢usoverz, mech iv w @>mz re ms
amicqu neveco\>iwc» ms maj Nec@s->ma~v re suvoo\zT ui:> po>r-cowvicn'om
unions @vzouom m me imsmm exan owes@o`\wa. Ex omer U\)i».u'nm.s,
@5 S.u).':>o be%. c\z'\m'mnb cum \c)a%.

TH@ nmicnm was oemowsr\zméb mm mm coowsex$ aemesswmrim.)
FGLL ibede nw ob.>€c”\`ive STN\)DHBD oF Kemomnm_&wes§ .. . , .. . .1 mez€wom\)r,
ns szr‘r comvum' wm ol\) nw€m, l unc nw obdom'\m\) 10 emma \=oszu)u\zv>
amend re mm'm irb,c,omre\\sfiow$ oF Be.?.o\?`, va w \)d\wc» so, ira
comvl,nimb comb mm ms usu‘M
S.l)\). ?\0 550. To $mi¥sf-Y me PRE¢\)DRCS pkow@, newmaer mu',r s\Ao\N

ms mvcprv\@ wm R€»Noe%b szsL;m>Ls , or< me Pizc» c.eel>ir\)e was
Fu¢\)DrlI\/\BNTRLU ur\)FF\iR.Jouwsom v. Sco"rv b°é F.Bb 1051 IOG|.

T“e um\mm mm oennosuzm@b mm covme; movioeb
zemesemnow mm amouwrex> co €wcpm %rm\)cs umwa P\ze,u emma
No\zms. 'Rrro\zwe,~rs suo\M) r:»s oeoicméx> r<> vs\zrecf\'bm oa= accuan
Raco\zo> Fo\a Zeview \?>~r awaan gowm§ i\~. po'\m§ OF ERRQR mg
TD RBC@i\/e FR'\{Z COM'>\'DS\zm"\oN mm 3\)31` \zuc.`\t\)c.s , `\’o\mg, q,§m\:\=o@,
rim S.vJ. Ab ’|10

Tu,e mvv/umw wm emma mm B\»T r-c>!a couw%w S\zrzv\zs mm oe\;`\c\'em
RBP\ZGSBNTMRON,~ \ wouub mr wave PL,GD eviu'\r e>\)T wouL,u> wave
sweis“rsb ON @\oiwc:) rv W`HLL. Hiu_ v. Lou'|0»7|\.

anex> md me romn.irr op me omuvv\smwc@s iw ms P\z'\mvm~( cwss,we

am`\c,nm's vLG was No+ womva mm vowmmziw moses m ms
rim or~' ms hmw-1 -PLep. RW\;LL:\NI§ memaL sbst Reere!> vv"`mm€!>
mo im¢uex>"f>¢zom§sé§" .:2001\ ms TQ\'W, Mro\z\\)e‘r nw me mine _\\)‘D@e
wm wesz mr r_uc.z`\u,@!>.

com.i Pge»s Z._;

e. THF.:. nPPLi¢nm ams ovexzcome 1416 P\ze€>\)rm>n'or\\ 04= R@-c:.u¢.mz`vw
seamen \'N me ram comm \zxz»c,o\zos, r.m\o ms o@mow~zmn@ mm
H`\:> men ama {\\)vouur\)‘m\z:r.

7. |N nr.¢., ruis\)as, me nwcicnm ms €>\-\oma\) mm ms cowvic.riow mm
s>\;\\>‘f@me wm in/\v\z)a\>eilwr o\?>m'\¢\\z\>.

Heco\zoim@Lw, \\1?€7§£\?<"1'@"»1446’\'6)\¢\$` C,o\)\zr our C,Rim(r\)m, Qs>vems wm
1446 ReQuesTeo. umz»e¥\§ nder e>e eem\\f€b.

S\GNED 1'H'\5 \?>“‘ sav 09 Decew\se\z, 940\5;

P\e¢_»%c1Fut,LY e\gBm'mED,
Ma/fme~"/Z. 71/1/19%?/€
W`\n\w)§ P. U\)icu‘\re
f\PvLi<;nm

Km\/\s€‘r 1 UN'\'<

\\oo F.W\. loss
Ros\m\zo\\> ,TX . "lr\S<£S