Court Opinion

ID: 4062095
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 20:23:36.650785+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:07:11.280907
License: Public Domain

muse no. GJ~CK~WO€“"/ 66 3551’@<7/

E>< PA&TE at ` _

“@§e?®z 1613€$1A\>e' ’…Q’€'ouow‘m%`.
. LMIS D:.QT:C@N
M.Qowljc~{;ndd.; , _ 3 .,' A , ,
WDMM 5 ' h »S-l=mdc c,o¢u~JcS have ov\%‘\s'\e»\dm\`sci¢c,{m\\ gm habq,;g
3 w m aHé?ckS @re mem utpo~ +he. v@l\'QLEH of 3 m,gd€_
mwn°`r C/owllld'i¢,n ~ . ,
OLQ,`m(m f \' \0 and _pe”+`“h_oh@r$ have a T‘SM' h afFQ%\'From irrde
3 § be ' il 931ch ?\ne\g_>od‘ L(BB ’SM>.?,& 323
@ STM€MENT or me C,Age _
Axaw Z°°Z>. v
` 16 ¢355@~¥$ ?t~\'\a¥ ~€\/‘»€ CDW)C\( @°‘H EY\‘H‘@ 3\°°"`€ mg \(\33 _ ` .~
\\m% an evadenld@l hearing m+o_ ike P€!€\JUW-’~"$
\MSQG[ '\)(5 'm\irvg on 3 €!\rbnmu$ conci<;$iow'o ,

_, j `W\ Q,ou . C,OwH
(\La\\: :;f' has fdde on Q\Q,QY¢\{ QF`FZ>OQOL,LS §&c~('*pinding|_ M
AH\{- CvEM. ma \~’\El "4'<15 1-'.'30\ 355 (C_A co zOOS),

 

 

 

,WL-Q:\@u$¥ widean o‘€ an oh vec>_oro( pre.+r~¢@[ beam/13 (%w`e#&i- ,,
470 dc;{@nd@nf$ ecm?zn+@,nc;\( fe 3 v.d/Lio[ wgwev tr12 aounn€l 111 Kwr`[)
§I/\OU[C[ bg wojd_ d 9 QonWCJ~HOn

~I“ e,'\¥`wmsjr@nce$ Hm{v skou a de€€,d@ml§ n
{-`»é'or\q {/Y`OJCQC'Y€Q§ w;'U/\»O<-ff Cowns'd ,…Q da€
CDNV'&'Q;&{O`\\L Q,Qm 01C P'@hn$\cl t mb
3c1 213,1<)0 L“€Cl lie
/3`\1€\'~@*1*‘§5“"*$ ha \__“§3 `"`j@" V"S “§“°Fd‘”" b»\ showxng, m amc /+LM
v17\,\12'aloo\l€jC»c’~l~JU\SQ,Au)&$ 1\1€.33{$»1-¢45@@1 1a tam/ge normch l \( 1 1 '
15 51\.11 SML,J%€,+ -l~o Mwm co £[Q\l@@( QMSC§UM€ 10 4~15»$»1\ 1311 4§\/\€,£ bg
pmin m@@{;y\g ~ch; Y€S+raingaf 01 1115 11501.1 ve _S L( UBG".O‘L'H“S Uf?Cou/zse//'e_o[
5'1&1€ v_ QD[(HZO QéH' $.ca.fs`@l l&l--t&¢,t¢z»)' \f %`m`em‘m¢" T€~l"@'¢). `
TN va Ki 1\' AFJ¢.I\»OQ 01£ ihQTBQ$.CNG(& '0+` C`¢“m;’\&‘ procedure a{o~r~' ,"h
._\_éx 115 Qom+;b+w+im A~€¥. 5 § lé> B.Y\& VT.C.-A ngv&*“m€h{ COAQ, § 35 ro?@'); 1:)
csava Qo`.-`m-f\( Qou€}($ gsu/isd`c-C{"\G*r\ 'cY\ \'\Q\OQ£AS fr§€£e_c\’\h%§ whex`& on€
15 n,$\mwp\neé \)»Li~ rQ'-S)cra\’ne,(le o{" hc`§ l~\>zrng J~LL& 1‘~» a.lla'§all@;»\$
¢} <;m~\¢`i<»_h¢z n a m\’$_ deme®nov.r@ A¥LQC)LS mt %\L\e, \/a.l€cli+\( of a m‘sd.w h@\ wo- ¢`S $ubj@£'fa M+W @l,|e£e¢~d,l @n§e,l€_$' ills<;, prov¢rl€ a P%jt§l({'on€p SQV@-@l
av&,\u€$ 10 aH@/CK A 171on o»m`ecf.om H\g£ holds de+Ymeia/l wm$e@qehce§
‘\'R@ C(S .<§u-Pf€m€ C,wr% h&$_helc}. i/’\@{YJL&§"§Q$ Sl/wu'{cl £v\ciglaa @_WX`_( z
PCBSDAEN'C FPC€u/AP‘»{'NFY\ 33&1`1\$>+_(»3:\/',@(` 0`€ *Fu)’\OlA.m€-.`/T{Q,l Coi’l<.>"‘l\‘#l-c{*§o)'}&{ /\¢Sh+S
_YN ,1}\',5‘1¢€<;~01) i¥' is 4116 §{2?[€ fil/\@:l: has {)’1;® burde 0163%@5(;5}\\`113 61 chlic(
\U'¢?W€f` O‘{" Comn$'e.l_ 001;11)‘{$ mu,$‘f be Y€$~§[‘/CC] ih 'FELYOY Q‘F f'!`l)'{e€{.i 03 “{1’1€
gm-¢L',J`Cw+;ml @[@;m_ Mz¢h:;§w V. CXCJ§§ON %75"115~. 133 ,z L id 2d c,zz, 1015_@4_
1110/q 113:§_§_)__,. J;MMSON V. zepr 301 u.s. 159 ssi 511 sued )vc,/ mm `
/S;;‘d:¢lrcll&d ’F?)Fm‘ir\ Com'PhanCQ w»;{h~$%f€{%€ PUQ£MN:) rl?)h“b `h’ YCFNSU{R”
+;U b( <:-_mn§&\ h be reed P.N>l <~>'W\€Cl 311 a defenda/rl- are /'m.L alone
+zm+amoun{ 1b va(,`cp waiver mo Qour)§e\` Vrm M.@H}<€ v. G[HQ$ 333 U- 5.
31 q,;g-z'»¢,¢,<¢ 501 3331 N.'ll;amsv. SMQ sz§ 5.wzc/ a')z_ ~
" am ewm$€[\@d f,\,.[m,~$ used /PO¢~ ehh§n(§,m€/H' purpose 31`6 "n’\ \/iol%:{i.@g\/ c'Fél
91€:€&“013%1‘\$ S'Q<.m Am€,f)m@/H 113 h+-& chole when Y€SLLI+I`nj m ami
wl 41111€.`[._\/1'£3 1‘13H'N@d5 15 ml:$dw_'e&“‘?” CZ>"W`C+\"<)NS_ (`; ;QLQ,<)N ~1 mm -
W(~',Q\`h+ ’S"IQ (,L`g _’3%§11§ Avj@€§ihg@r V. HA'M|`\'N c{0'7 U‘$Q§,'J’Z.CIZ 3`.©€. Z@Oé

31111§;0,10@ 1101 l/\&»ve be€N
1 ces,$ Q,QSQ ;Wye.|.`cl.a.£es his
van.&exfe|f_ l-l@rm@u v.. CLMJ»\{ 350 u.$. i(L, l`\S 170

_W."l€, @h¢oMSQL1eol friOY`- m"'§cie'm€,anor aonvic1\'on 01 §§qu
MS° Y‘W"`M` ameng Eno(odtC-UL€@) m Ob~mn‘,
mi clim:t$‘$’A Wé$ Mg‘mcq data &'F\°£"@Yb was m+ weFr@S€»/)+ce( b\i QM\§@|
_U)a‘$ "‘M€‘CJU%¢ and had "NL mEZdG E’,- /v\ owing amf infe[(fjen+wé.‘[vey~ ~h, Qo¢,m$.€|` ll
E')< 133/1916 WQOO(L,.)UO) §‘11 5`.\_3_0. Z_Dl 1371 E>< 1>2¢~{@ \/»/5}331.@,,~ L(qr'; §_U_Zd 305
fifplicev¢c asse_w_{s |f\e, as ~.'hol\'§m+ and ,~§__W,&/O/@ 110 .,corwahcl a mw 01 _.H/\G
1035300¥~»3 m/H¢ion 81~£1\€ p-Ye§en{+¢m€ 10 oppoy,-g'j V@,r[q_ ,A.Fpliwn{ MA{T
355?_1»3¢3 1133;11/“€ DA\|"@"L U':H'1 in wh*»C)/\ he \`S preg@,q.-M incarcer;{;@l
is QW¢Y€~A+M( zm aclzmi/\.S1YS10\/€ (oq)0~`0\3 011 Q,Lg€
T@AP 1010 2. . § 0
’[)u_@ 510 app 10@@1§ mol.igemla~t gnd mazza/wes 1)€>{01\61 111 §Qon1ro1 he. vegq53{
01 Cour1 Su$FQ/)$£ID'N Nx(€, regarding 'g/~Mil:)é'd""f) 51 Wd‘ "1°'\/ ‘ll?> 010(>0$.,,`3 p@,d>t`
all 01 UUSC @N( improch Ce/>h`w’\ o/‘ /?@€Ol"`"j 35 FEZ“UY€O' 1011 Cl'>\/~/‘1 PLL/C$ end
`(qum 01 QPpQ\/ia,qte regarding mcr{>i-on$ wdr€-SS@O\ 10 ~H\c Co¢u~{~ owe ~}b AFFL¢Q@N¢[Q;
.m&lo;"[{.f»/ -{, q,$e, 1@(»<) abrer 750¢ {>FDFQ_’{‘ ‘1:0\//7\¢11\
` ` C<>w~_____“_§;_@'_\\
W?Q C'°“"`J“ §1‘°`-\¢1 10£100) 1116 LL-$-S“P‘f`€"’?@ va“1s mli 503 41001 00.>{100001
€Nzclence 01 an @ecwd mb a ole&ndam‘§ compr cci-fo V&(l‘cl wiva @1'

Q°"m$d 11\201:£0 \(l`CHo‘/\)SP\ 1011)Q_\lo£c1 TH€ Q
_ "‘ °LL -. , h l, |,| `_
me md his bmw 31 fed®cnd mg m mw ;wr% 5 000!0{ 1001 AP,>I 951

l d ` _ 111 rezu£mm 1 ' "
b@@®@~ he 5 510 11 $ubgd+v ‘FWLWQ dol'l#@f`@l ®"$CLM:ACQ:;F re 1310 `S
_me,' ma §)‘“°L¢H 6a QFSMQOL
. E'ff:'\
WHEW°FU?E, ?KMIS€_H§IDERED)/%c AEFllc§/H' (FPO 5€-) PFQ\¢$ 11\€11 11\1§
MD+-ion be Sr,rq{€¢;l find ’117'?'11’111€ _COW"1.` y
®q)r@\(§ 1110`§ Cow% Y€men}>@ 1116 Qe¢u§€ 105 ith FNQ€CJ¢` ¢~Kj§
@ CP(@,\C$ >[~Li$' C.Dvu~} ~{‘QZLJFQ <'?f\ ev¢`c>{€n‘l‘l'@l 1’\€20~\` ?~fld /olr` j
Q,»P@n$"w_w 01 J¢%w@¢rew~d` 110 41\€.~ 9100\/5 <,00,§@

l M H\e above
mg 11an 1€1000\1 RS‘SSMH m ceu.§€.

@ w +A w a~»mf aff mw mgt-dmi ed mcf
umw b am @+w.~r@l‘~@€ wier @g%;+( ve wm ‘
@fpe\t$ 1915 Co'»w?" \/01`01 {}\6 CJNV¢C{?WN -

?\Q€FQC{FR,J/~j S@/>m[ He@@ l

`… w ,Ap,>|§‘<@ml~L 1% se
g€ss@ £w$ #1<3£2§§‘(
©A\h@@l calif
fl‘l§c) +'Mm

p ` % ‘ uNSWO`P\N O€QLAQ/:,~}/q as /z.-¢zL€;Qlar`€ under P@@H\{ mc p@a;§“nf ,Hqg% ,H?G Hi /e`f’ %`l)
~f‘r"w% @'1€{ C.oY`F ~

EXCM am +%1‘3 -H)@ [Sjc de\{ 06 Dé€£mb€r ZO(§`_
` §MKLL¢@ '_ ,A{‘F; Q/]'}[

 

’lt;ir`€do}»p§ is

v CLUMQAYE o¥ SGM'CE
j . 3/€5$~’5 gm l hereby cer+~i¥\\f */]1€+ +}1€ ‘F‘or€‘;§oir»§ mo+\` m l/\@‘S
b€€>’\ mai iad -Vde ~p[.`rS-L cle$$ m@t'/ 1403  
Q,@,,K me &MM\QM+ 0+: Aee@\$
Aba\ ACOSJ@ , ,
P. o, @-Oy 123 o@ ’ZWH 1
@QLC~L)&¢! oh ~l;-l\,`\s ’H\e. l“s+ cta>{ of D€.Qem§>€r 1319 n

 

. §§in

©N +L\'\S -U”\e '“G:_,__,____,_,-~\ game on Jr'o b€~

v\C-SY`Ol /L\F\°L‘QBV\/+S wxo+ior\) /A\P€`\Q"@/ {VZ'DY"\ ORCIU U€'N`{‘Y\D AV]L H eci
AFF\'QQJ¢'<»J ~Fb/L{ wahl of

 

 

[”/ALJ€.AS CO/?~va$¢' and S`&icl mo~/»io)\/i S hCC€&L{o
< >@§MT{@ §§ DENIED
€‘.3.-'1@0\ +\”\is' ;O(ST if

 

,.______¢-
_____-__

(

>( /
514 S£ CFES{JZ@S

, flat CAUS€_n.o _0& ~ N<)'Y , ( /A\OP\»¢€R`\W far ll»<>"l A)QH of HAEQ:;
@E.M Q¢U:< 010 QM+ 010 cyim;~»l AW»@\S ’*1~ 01 § rs
Wm-_ A\DQ,\ AC,o-S‘(@)

E_V\Q,L'o 'SQ<;b `Ole_Q,SQ 16ch VYI\( mo+c»o}~/ @V£r{/QD( AEEUL[ i'/H.om‘
O§Q§LQEMJMQMLMLWV
if !SIQBSQ '{;i{@ avco Pr€$en+ ‘FO *H\(~‘, Co»wé 355 '\[ou,» @r[l,©,g_{?
QQr\\/(/\'MC_€;. AS &Mow‘€d)jw€n“} +D KQC£Z\/£~ng g_.m{ _F‘;
mo'\ti<>n `DlQ_QSQ $~{‘Qmp Ol&?é€ ‘ll.`)/\l`§ Co`vev /€,ltl£€r and
inU\P/‘L€l\{ +ZL m\( f€cod‘,{$'\ '

/'[+‘é>ési$ CoVLPM; _

 

(-a'f)§ ‘H'NS
‘F€,`(.`-‘(.w}q »I)~O fnve

`\tdw ass%$l~e,~nqg, 'm *H\/?S vf\”@¢#19;{€€1.
KQS¢M@LM .
-J/€SSE Q;OS’H*IS/L§Sq

DAU'\Q\H; (,mi§r

1 l‘i$o FM ‘I‘?  354 fz