Court Opinion

ID: 4070336
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 01:09:54.177129+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:06:13.049864
License: Public Domain

zow ez' / AS'?7

 A^'^Z/Aoj^ Do^^a^x                                                                        ^ jB
                                                      2015 DEC 28 AM 7:37
 SeA/£/^'c^J/. f£^                                                  /          ,
ZZ7s ^/fCC£rs^es /oa^£> fAssts^Sj                          JC vi P /Ldf^
                                                          ><-''^'"HE^Kf?TTLf:.Ci.r3|<
                      ahot/d/^           sr^y jpr /^*t*/o^<T^ /77/?.V»A
                                           jSet'ty^JZKJ

   7Z> 'TWt //€>Ji/^aj(^^ <T24Sr/^£S
           //i>/^ zToh^ £ x^/P?}itrc     Mfr',/zrrj///iiti'^y/ytK^/^tj^A^,iy/
 P^i>f^j/\ f£/?sD/i/^ *A>a/ 7^Lc /Ui-Z ^  A^cT.£ru4fiX,           ^S>w<v^y2s:r
htuz^MhSJUtr n:iw T/zr /(^SotJc ^ryosc                                  A/uA(i6&tiO c^l^t/L /iGr^e>/i/^ ^g^d/
 O^^iC SH£>c^ 7V<f
                 O'A ^SC€.M4t^O?j 2J?tJ^ T^c /}hgdZ>*^'^A ^f^SZi'Cc P^r^/Ct^ /Px
ACt/Afi£Z^ 7:i,£:At Ma, /Auflcftsiea                                      y/y*Gf/^/SaM^/rcgi f^d,'c'/Ae 7z>
7iL£ ^"^o/iP-A-                                                 PdMo sSd^aik^^Ar/yx
   ,      /lA/>££jAHtr J^aHfrffSAx KSCStUt^sn pa^nu STAV Of-                                               TAHZ
PiCtMA> oy d/ upfitr /3»A                                       »
     Afi/>e//A/£r 0p^AKfrgSAx.7ce/s r?^A7-                                 pad^aA^/s
AiAAcAiji, /zy /^fs/rtiss/UA Tf/y                                               7SzAcy//y<S aJu£ /^z^sSSs
tO fhociay} Ts^jUL yyy yp/^y/sL^ •s.HacyiW/ TAA/z ^'Vc
    ///^e-fo £,^j //^dyr<7'£/P/!^<)/cpypa^yAyi.M TO ysst/i PaayyA,
                                   y^PPa/ZiirS                                                     yd^adv se^Zz/Ayi,
PiAO                      APP^y/jgedr^z, Pi/diSai/KAT^ TO Srdmzrs sy=* y/tuf/?^^9As
y>y potd/i AddO Tu^ yy4^a-t^yfs                             /huyyct yz/                 yiOdas                    .*//Zsg^^
C/>ftpx/y, /y>xOT>'z^,/y^c>3sr'f'Oidt TZf y//e y>yiTt am y3y:yz>iU^'^j2i?'y
(5a.d9t/nd4i OP AyP£/Z,e£s -* SctOd/OuTzy                                                        ya/t^3^z/y''y*^A'y
                        Af yaci/i-r- z^c/kdeyi •yr//y/syi/€T^/z>A/*/Okt' jz> y^y y/i/n/p
^PTB e>y /loTdt^Ay /Sy y^ppy//^ y^P yfiAPidzy 3/j zo/c>*                                                 TZAjs
 /lAdUddOdS P Pytyjz>u^<rAy'Q£.6pp£fyr                                                       y<pfi^y/M^''
 JCAyTrzadTidTpyiiy                     y^Tja^ ^ cyyzpy/^y                                       y/cA/yjA/Z'
 nPP€/Zsyj ^^^tAZz>ayTg>Ayjrdiy PtAfp^ 5.V7 zaaV
 Avo Z>a/ /!iy^d/yr-ZP-j 2Z>/TL ^ £r£. AJ/c/dPiOh/                                                TJOzr?<jo
  ZOi/ ppz/tZZP^O-y / Fayicz> ysx yy)do/>ic,^^u^P PaC/c^ Azpt.
 ZOH             iJ       i/Se-SL'Z^
       •pc'^/f                              A/e>^^£A'VO
       Zoucy)         A'<?'f fidpy/or    /i/Ku .cy/ /j dffPy
        C?^ TdifS          fOcci^A-f^T^^ Or

                                                           /.
                                                           rs          u 8S 035

                                                                                 .        ;c-N   i

                                               ;

                                                       •a. . .

              •i '^^•\
                                                                                                                                                                                                 <•        . ^          f.
                                                                                                                                                                        'j A sS                  .           ^K*'        •., ' V • \

                                                                                                        ..._;,          ...:v                            •     ,-            .

    '         'i- ' -"X         • ' •'             -VV-,              ^              •-          ..          .'\- '                            •.-.•.v                   •-.•• •-•-                   ^^                           ' ••^•
                                                                           ^                                                                    'W.                 ^
                                                                                                                                                                                     \                ; .V,. A\                   .'^ X.;
                                                                                                                                                                                             \
                                                                                                                                                                             •.

                                                                                                                   •.••••,-.               ,          . V               • ';•                    . •'•• • .
                                                                                                             3-;•-•,~v                   --rs.                                                        '•                                '"•
                                         -<•
                                                                                                               /•••.•          -•        -/v..               V:. . '                                        . ••.\
\   VI..
                                                                                                                                                                         M                                              \—• 'W-'VC i

                           ''T.           • •- -                 •    ^ .• • • • ••• •           -               •• ..                                                                   . .r'.•
                          \               •" "•'•                    - .'.•                                  V • V . •',                       •• •            ••                        >                                       ^.v.! •
                  V-           <1'                 a
                   V .          • <;      »i           \                                               ^•W - .„.
                                  - \                  \\r                                                   •.;                        -r- . • r. ••    ..         •: X..                             .         .. •

                  -- r    —                ,                                                          •••,                                     . c       • •                     •       -            sV                 .''v w/''
           i,>\            \      . . v^-.                 ^ ^       . »V,V-.A                                     ••               ^                                   ••'v t •                                    .        •    • •

                                                                                                                                               .-3-.:                             \          _-A • A                                A
•)06<OT€is /^T'0A/ ffiA SZt</ Ofi
       l^OuL^   £ki>iV^
                          Ajfi^rt^^iAT/SDd^^S^^ A                rTO <it/t' /^AcU^ j^/rr
(ft f'ixitrr^ ^^i//f7v^-^            ^ £ > ^ £^yy/f^
•S'^A
       &y THc fi>,»rm£.,^ ae- jUfMU

^/Ico Afrtd^. Ady JtA/zofATc ^Mz»rtZ zz^/o/iTd                                 -7-x^>,       jLyft^-j
C/i/i/ P/>Ar'4'ntfif7*            fZZ.dO/L TikP^              oz-                 /^ ^3^Lc
HA/£ix>e4j /teOfu/APM^in.
            ^>ec64^4r>t^ 'i'/it>^
                           u. T Zc^dtcO
                                        f'"'^'i'? T^J,
                                                   j£,
                                                       x<i>vaW S<4^
TzJt             Sy /H /i/^>i/--zs^'^fT^r c^wzpy                     yjyp^.
Azy/><yMr7r ^yArzS'i.                         ^       /fz=-yy/Dd„        ^
uyi^ /^Jiz A//^y£-y zay- y^/^/>e^                       /J    ^Ac^no                     ^       yip£'yyp>yy
•P/Lfi/^s f^i2>/y*' A Pd9cy^ptys y./'s?^ifZt^                  7>^ ^iA^Af^yr
y^ATt^jT/CiAiSS / /fA(pcyMyrd£*^A^                           Sy/yyyt/^A/Tyuu/=>'//w£
U^f/              /^^Oiyic£f ^ALs Pi/i^ju^t/iyf TO *7T'J?.x'-/i
^Aya^^c Siy^STAdTydjac^ aa/^ Suyy/cy£Ayy. -7'£>s-f3>£>Ly ywt
                    GA-              ^    aryyOy^A/Ci/ ydj^ yptt /^t'dy/^ptyy
 J^/^K/£>S y^s O^CAOaT^ f6y y^/y /^^uyjTA/ y^Auyrr- <3^ ^yy>^yAy
    Tifftnt^ijSyT^f Tffuiy/y/ ^lyfT £^ d^Ay&dC: C/yyT/mfO^ ^ ^MOs pZ~^
^y p/i/^           ^/y9A. /y /^r- 3c /£sLt, to 3e^            ^^y6.yyr
'd^ff^^CC^SOST^ilP^       /£>P. y^A/O^Cip /^AAijCy>TJ£>nZ OT  d>'t(>d:
£>f^                oy^ iry/yQ^Coycy^ /HZkci F'oxl a <^ry^£s>^H/c£
^yyi^^ci/ /w jTA/zA'jfTp ^A/ ^             //0A/                     y^y-^s^n^d
(TjoLyiZfPfj & ^£i^iA/sT Af-yC'? f'ti^W-AOPA/dAS, /^oua/o jtz                                   7~£>^
A4/0         y^/j(ZT3,V/             J^/£ztysx TPi^y/^^t ^uaaa^a^ -zfuscaj fi^/
f73£^ fyit£>tX-/!^€ZLt&A2>A/£i yoiAKAAD TiV zo^P"
Z/y /C^f^ccr iP/c>ZyfT/Pj/^ yo yftyhyiAAttK/y                                                   3fylfACs
1-^ yy7^£^CA/7l/ f%zjt'4/TtOj^yz z>Ay /^^yyyOj^'^ /p./aO ^pi^yrr^
"p^krSAfiC y^^sM/&646 Sy TM ^u/zrw
iuLo A^A/y ^/yp^/yAttP ^ue /zfi^pccz 5""^»       / ^ AAAty^o .
\S. (^PST^ rf4/ y^yy^y^i^ ^I'A/yA yc? y^y^y fOAzzF-
7^ fyJj Ti'H.Z // usc^I^zz.^yP*'£yrr TO /zby^^^'^Ojyo^^'^yy
iyrf/yffzAO^jc>c/y7:^L^C4>d^AfA4-inyyyi£^'^       /   *\j c-c^a:^ / A^af»\ycre.€^''^t
           /upyti> /ScTpclg /&?cyyiC^yi^ /^aoa/tzs                                       ^oyy*y P^
yuA^jy /OjZorp.               ^                                                              -7-w ThijJiTyy
  :3rT ^     nrm'i-rr -^d>A;A^i>x. je^tyk^rTi^/7>ifyy' '7?ve ^p^pi/cy: ^                     7l£^(> /2fV'^
                y^A^Zs AiAZyD j6)£naAj:^P'j,A7t/ F^jsmA^AT'
ypE Z/kS^ .SPPdCc/sytr £^>o/Tr/L^jTAC-Ty^F jp^ycc yiPP£/yd^£ y^ert^juix
'PaPT^AC yt/o.^D/O-'^/^ZSTX y^A/ti                                       oy^/^oO^TT^ep .
A/a On<./^i&sAC^<?£A/y'£Z, yfPP£/yiPT.,yf'^;^ y2yoyzT TP Zfy-r yTp/»ff^^
           tT£ccf& T£> 'yy7y.£yp>siAi/£Ay d'sjA/Pp t^/a L-jy^yjAfifpPts ^
 tCDiMyty /py-'/Z0i//^-y-Q                                          ^y^SiyPp<^
                                                                   V- - ^
                                                                            r

                                                                                                                                                             S       \       ..          iS.       •

                                                                                                                                                                                         " .-.t*

                                                                                                                                                    .\           '   ,            —' •      .\

                                                                                                                                                          A •* - >        • '     .   _ •

                                                            -V"-
                  J •

                                                                                                         •   ••     V

                                                                   V

                                                   * •• •. -i

                                                  V V             ^              A

                                                   « -          *• *

                                                                                                                         .........          ^   .

•.,    ..

      N^     . -AV
            - •                     .     .._                                                                                     r-., _
                                                                                             .   •   N
                                                                                                                        A.. •         "•• iT • ••
                                                                                             \N»

                                —       w—-r*-.
                                                                                                                  •-:- -vvv'v

                        \- ^,
                                                                                                                                                             V

                                                                                                                                                         >c-.             =-:v            -

                                                                                      •. V
                                V-.'
                                                                       .r\-\ -•••'   i.

                                                                                                                                                                         . .;         -Vv ,

                                                                                                                           .   . v-
                                                                                                                                                                         •                  •\ •
            nUD.

-vl OKj"*                     ^ V <?Ia
IttSOECZB WT-3''f|>S^°Si

            : - Mnme.eLtr'v

            f1^1"
            V.
            ia->l ^ ^

                 u

            ItH
                     I
                     r
                                 <?'•"   is

                         J.^-'           I
               ^       rr
                                ^
                                ***
                             ^            ^
           ar 5 ^ « O
           U/ K S       -
                            o       <0
                                      "
       1
       %     ^ C^ h~
       4
            "Ti (j O
   a.       ^ U.
   u.       •i o ;:             .
   o
            .' i'" c            •
                            ;-
  U;,              .        ;-
                Ui
 uj:            O  f-
 "j ..

a: «C
   X Q^ ^O ^S