Court Opinion

ID: 2970737
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2015-09-22 16:20:55.49858+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T11:43:31.792225
License: Public Domain

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21
             3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH                      :LWWVWRFNY0DUN$9DQ6LOH,QF           1R
     (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU
                 )LOH 1DPH DS
                                                              $662&,$7,21 *URVVH 3RLQWH )DUPV 0LFKLJDQ IRU
                                                              $SSHOOHH
81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6                                                     BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
               )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7                                                   23,1,21
                 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB                                                 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
                                                                 .(11('< &LUFXLW sXGJH  sRVHSK $ :LWWVWRFN ,,,
 s2(63+ $ :,77672&. ,,,       ;                            3ODLQWLII DSSHDOV WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV GLVPLVVDO RI KLV
           3ODLQWLII$SSHOODQW                              FRPSODLQWIRUODFNRIVXEMHFWPDWWHUMXULVGLFWLRQDQGIDLOXUHWR
                                                             VWDWH D FODLP XSRQ ZKLFK UHOLHI FDQ EH JUDQWHG  )RU WKH
                                    1R              IRUHJRLQJUHDVRQVZH$)),50WKHMXGJPHQWRIWKHGLVWULFW
          Y                                                 FRXUW
                                   !
                                                                                             ,
 0$5. $ 9$1 6,/( ,1&          
         'HIHQGDQW$SSHOOHH                                   sRVHSK $ :LWWVWRFN sU DQG 'RULV $ :LWWVWRFN
                                 1                            :LWWVWRFNV RZQHUV RI UHVLGHQWLDO SURSHUW\ ORFDWHG LQ
     $SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW             5RVHYLOOH0LFKLJDQIDLOHGWRSD\WD[HVRZHGRQWKDWSURSHUW\
    IRUWKH(DVWHUQ'LVWULFWRI0LFKLJDQDW'HWURLW          EHJLQQLQJLQ'HIHQGDQW0DUN$9DQ6LOH,QF9DQ
  1Rn1DQF\*(GPXQGV'LVWULFWsXGJH              6LOHDFTXLUHGWKHULJKWVRIDWD[VDOHSXUFKDVHULQ0D\
                                                              DQGREWDLQHGDWD[GHHGLQsXQH,Q$XJXVW9DQ
                   $UJXHG0D\                       6LOHLQLWLDWHGDTXLHWWLWOHDFWLRQLQ0DFRPE&RXQW\&LUFXLW
                                                              &RXUW$GHIDXOWMXGJPHQWLQIDYRURI9DQ6LOHZDVHQWHUHG
             'HFLGHGDQG)LOHGsXQH                 LQ6HSWHPEHUDIWHUWKH:LWWVWRFNVIDLOHGWRDQVZHUWKH
                                                              FRPSODLQW,Q3ODLQWLIIZDVDSSRLQWHGFRFRQVHUYDWRURI
   %HIRUH.(11('<6,/(5DQG*,/0$1&LUFXLW               KLVIDWKHUsRVHSK$:LWWVWRFNsU3ODLQWLIIWKHQDFWLQJLQD
                     sXGJHV                                  UHSUHVHQWDWLYH FDSDFLW\ VRXJKW XQVXFFHVVIXOO\ WR KDYH WKH
                                                              GHIDXOWMXGJPHQWVHWDVLGHDOWHUHGRUDPHQGHG
                   BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
                                                                 3ODLQWLIILQKLVLQGLYLGXDOFDSDFLW\WKHQEURXJKWWKLVDFWLRQ
                        &2816(/                               DOOHJLQJWKDWKHZDVmGHQLHGGXHSURFHVVRIODZE\YLUWXHRI
                                                              >9DQ6LOHjV@IDLOXUHWRSURYLGH3ODLQWLIIQRWLFHDQGRSSRUWXQLW\
$5*8('  ( 'RQDOG *RRGPDQ  sRKQ 3 :LOOLDPV        WREHKHDUGUHODWLYHWR3ODLQWLIIjVSURSHUW\ULJKWVl3ODLQWLII
:,//,$06 	 :,//,$06 5R\DO 2DN 0LFKLJDQ IRU           FRQWHQGVWKDWEHIRUHWLWOHFRXOGEHTXLHWHGLQ9DQ6LOH9DQ
$SSHOODQW  7KRPDV + .HDWLQJ 7+ .($7,1*             6LOHPXVWJLYH3ODLQWLIIQRWLFHXQGHUWKH*HQHUDO3URSHUW\7D[
$662&,$7,21 *URVVH 3RLQWH )DUPV 0LFKLJDQ IRU          $FW,QUHOHYDQWSDUWWKHVWDWXWHVWDWHV
$SSHOOHH  21 %5,()  ( 'RQDOG *RRGPDQ  sRKQ 3
:LOOLDPV:,//,$06	:,//,$065R\DO2DN0LFKLJDQ                $ ZULW RI DVVLVWDQFH RU RWKHU SURFHVV IRU WKH
IRU $SSHOODQW  7KRPDV + .HDWLQJ 7+ .($7,1*            SRVVHVVLRQRIODQGWKHWLWOHWRZKLFKZDVREWDLQHGE\RU

                             
1R            :LWWVWRFNY0DUN$9DQ6LOH,QF                   :LWWVWRFNY0DUN$9DQ6LOH,QF               1R

  WKURXJKDWD[VDOHH[FHSWLIWLWOHLVREWDLQHGXQGHUVHFWLRQ         UHTXHVWIRUFRVWVDQGDWWRUQH\VIHHV*LYHQWKDWVXFKUHOLHILV
  VKDOOQRWEHLVVXHGXQWLOPRQWKVDIWHUWKHUHLVILOHG          DYDLODEOHWRSODLQWLIIV86&EEXWQRW
  ZLWKWKHFRXQW\WUHDVXUHURIWKHFRXQW\ZKHUHWKHODQGLV             SODLQWLIIV EULQJLQJ VXLW GLUHFWO\ XQGHU WKH &RQVWLWXWLRQ WKH
  VLWXDWHGDUHWXUQE\WKHVKHULIIRIWKDWFRXQW\VKRZLQJ              GLVWULFWFRXUWIDLUO\UHDGWKH&RPSODLQWDVVHHNLQJWRVWDWHD
  VHUYLFHRIWKHQRWLFHSUHVFULEHGLQVXEVHFWLRQ7KH              FDXVHRIDFWLRQXQGHU
  UHWXUQVKDOOLQGLFDWHWKDWWKHVKHULIIKDVPDGHSHUVRQDORU
  VXEVWLWXWHG VHUYLFH RI WKH QRWLFH XSRQ WKH IROORZLQJ              7RDYRLGGLVPLVVDOXQGHU5XOHEDFRPSODLQWPXVW
  SHUVRQVZKRZHUHDVRIWKHGDWHWKHQRWLFHZDVGHOLYHUHG             FRQWDLQHLWKHUGLUHFWRULQIHUHQWLDODOOHJDWLRQVZLWKUHVSHFWWR
  WRWKHVKHULIIIRUVHUYLFH                                           DOOWKHPDWHULDOHOHPHQWVRIWKHFODLP7DKIVY3URFWRU
  D7KHODVWJUDQWHHRUJUDQWHHVLQWKHUHJXODUFKDLQRI              )GWK&LU$FODLPPXVWSUHVHQW
  WLWOHRIWKHODQGRURIDQLQWHUHVWLQWKHODQGDFFRUGLQJWR        WZR HOHPHQWV  WKDW WKHUH ZDV WKH GHSULYDWLRQ RI D ULJKW
  WKHUHFRUGVRIWKHFRXQW\UHJLVWHURIGHHGV                          VHFXUHGE\WKH&RQVWLWXWLRQDQGWKDWWKHGHSULYDWLRQZDV
  E7KHSHUVRQRUSHUVRQVLQWKHDFWXDORSHQSRVVHVVLRQ               FDXVHGE\DSHUVRQDFWLQJXQGHUFRORURIVWDWHODZ,G$
  RIWKHODQG                                                          SULYDWHDFWRUPD\EHFRQVLGHUHGDSHUVRQDFWLQJXQGHUFRORU
                                                                        RIVWDWHODZDVWDWHDFWRULImWKHGHSULYDWLRQFRPSODLQHG
0&/$:HVW3ODLQWLIIFODLPVWKDWKH               RI ZDV µFDXVHG E\ WKH H[HUFLVH RI VRPH ULJKW RU SULYLOHJH
ZDVHQWLWOHGWRQRWLFHDVDmSHUVRQLQDFWXDORSHQSRVVHVVLRQl          FUHDWHG E\ WKH VWDWHj DQG  WKH RIIHQGLQJ SDUW\ µDFWHG
EHFDXVHKHOLYHGDWWKHVXEMHFWSURSHUW\ZLWKKLVSDUHQWVDWWKH        WRJHWKHU ZLWK RU KDV REWDLQHG VLJQLILFDQW DLG IURP VWDWH
WLPHWKDWWKHQRWLFHZDVGXH7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWGLVPLVVHGWKH         RIILFLDOVRUEHFDXVHKLVFRQGXFWLVRWKHUZLVHFKDUJHDEOHWRWKH
&RPSODLQWIRUIDLOXUHWRVWDWHDFODLPXQGHU5XOHERQ           6WDWHjl,GDWTXRWLQJ/XJDUY(GPRQGVRQ2LO&R
WKHJURXQGWKDW3ODLQWLIIKDGmIDLOHGWRSURSHUO\FRQQHFWWKH           86
DFWLRQVRI'HIHQGDQWWRWKHUHTXLVLWHOHYHORIVWDWHDFWLRQWR
VXVWDLQDGXHSURFHVVFODLPlDQGLQWKHDOWHUQDWLYHODFNRI             7KH 6L[WK &LUFXLW DSSOLHV WKUHH WHVWV IRU GHWHUPLQLQJ
VXEMHFWPDWWHUMXULVGLFWLRQXQGHU5XOHE                        ZKHWKHUSULYDWHDFWLRQLVIDLUO\DWWULEXWDEOHWRWKHVWDWHWKH
                                                                        QH[XVWHVWWKHSXEOLFIXQFWLRQWHVWDQGWKHVWDWHFRPSXOVLRQ
                                 ,,                                    WHVW,GDW7KHQH[XVWHVWUHTXLUHVWKDWDVXIILFLHQWO\
                                                                        FORVHUHODWLRQVKLSH[LVWEHWZHHQWKHVWDWHDQGWKHSULYDWHDFWRU
   :HUHYLHZGHQRYRDGLVWULFWFRXUWjVGLVPLVVDOIRUIDLOXUHWR        WKURXJKUHJXODWLRQRUE\FRQWUDFWVRWKDWSULYDWHDFWLRQPD\
VWDWHDFODLPXQGHU)HGHUDO5XOHRI&LYLO3URFHGXUHE            EH DWWULEXWDEOH WR WKH VWDWH  ,G  7KH SXEOLF IXQFWLRQ WHVW
DQGIRUODFNRIVXEMHFWPDWWHUMXULVGLFWLRQXQGHU)HGHUDO5XOH          UHTXLUHV WKDW WKH SULYDWH DFWRU H[HUFLVH SRZHUV WKDW DUH
RI &LYLO 3URFHGXUH E  5RVVERURXJK 0IJ &R Y           WUDGLWLRQDOO\ UHVHUYHG WR WKH VWDWH  ,G  $QG WKH VWDWH
7ULPEOH  )G   WK &LU  $V DQ LQLWLDO     FRPSXOVLRQ WHVW UHTXLUHV SURRI WKDW WKH VWDWH VLJQLILFDQWO\
PDWWHUZHQRWHWKDWWKH&RPSODLQWGRHVQRWDOOHJHDEDVLVIRU          HQFRXUDJHG RU FRHUFHG WKH SULYDWH DFWRU HLWKHU RYHUWO\ RU
IHGHUDOMXULVGLFWLRQRWKHUWKDQUHFLWLQJWKDWm>W@KLVDFWLRQDULVHV     FRYHUWO\ WR WDNH D SDUWLFXODU DFWLRQ VR WKDW WKH FKRLFH LV
XQGHU WKH GXH SURFHVV FODXVH RI WKH )LIWK DQG )RXUWHHQWK       DFWXDOO\WKDWRIWKHVWDWH,G
$PHQGPHQWVWRWKH&RQVWLWXWLRQRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVl7KH
GLVWULFWFRXUWREVHUYHGWKDWWKH&RPSODLQWSXUSRUWVWRVWDWHD            3ODLQWLIIDUJXHVWKDW9DQ6LOHLVmDPHUHLQVWUXPHQWDOLW\RI
FDXVHRIDFWLRQGLUHFWO\XQGHU86&EXWZHQWRQ            WKH 6WDWH RI 0LFKLJDQ LQ FDUU\LQJ RXW LWV IXQGDPHQWDO WD[
WRFRQVWUXHWKH&RPSODLQWDVDOOHJLQJDFDXVHRIDFWLRQXQGHU           FROOHFWLRQ SRZHUVl DQG WKDW 9DQ 6LOH FRPPLWWHG mDQ DFW
 86&    3ODLQWLIIjV SUD\HU IRU UHOLHI LQFOXGHV D   JHQHUDOO\ DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK D SRZHU H[HUFLVHG E\ WKH
1R             :LWWVWRFNY0DUN$9DQ6LOH,QF                     :LWWVWRFNY0DUN$9DQ6LOH,QF               1R

VWDWHnHQIRUFHPHQWRIDWD[OLHQnDQGWKHVWDWHDLGHVLQWKDW                SURSHUW\ LV QRW RFFXSLHG WKH VDPH QRWLFH PXVW EH SRVWHG
HIIRUWl3ODLQWLIIjVDUJXPHQWVVXJJHVWWKDWZHVKRXOGILQG9DQ            FRQVSLFXRXVO\RQWKHSURSHUW\0&/$F
6LOH D VWDWH DFWRU XQGHU WKH SXEOLF IXQFWLRQ WHVW  2QO\ D
QDUURZUDQJHRISULYDWHDFWLRQKRZHYHUKDVEHHQGHHPHG                      3ODLQWLIIjVFRQWHQWLRQWKDWVWDWHRIILFLDOVDLGHG9DQ6LOHLQ
VWDWHDFWLRQXQGHUWKLVWHVW([DPSOHVLQFOXGHSULYDWHDFWRUV             HQIRUFLQJDVWDWHWD[OLHQVXJJHVWVWKDWLQWKHDOWHUQDWLYH9DQ
H[HUFLVLQJWKHSRZHURIHPLQHQWGRPDLQsDFNVRQY0HWUR                  6LOHjV FRQGXFW VKRXOG EH DWWULEXWHG WR WKH VWDWH XQGHU WKH
(GLVRQ &R  86    DQG FRQGXFWLQJ            QH[XVWHVW%XWDVZHVWDWHGLQ1RUWKULSY)HGHUDO1DWLRQDO
HOHFWLRQV )ODJJ %URV Y %URRNV  86               0RUWJDJH $VVRFLDWLRQ m>V@WDWH DFWLRQ GRHV QRW QHFHVVDULO\
:KHQFRQVLGHULQJZKHWKHUSULYDWHDFWLRQVKRXOGEH                 UHVXOWZKHQHYHUDVWDWHUHQGHUVDQ\VRUWRIEHQHILWRUVHUYLFH
DWWULEXWHGWRWKHVWDWHXQGHUWKHSXEOLFIXQFWLRQWHVWWKHFRXUW          WRDSULYDWHHQWLW\RUVHHNVWRUHJXODWHSULYDWHDFWLYLW\LQDQ\
FRQGXFWVDKLVWRULFDODQDO\VLVWRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUWKHSDUW\              GHJUHHl   )G   WK &LU   ,Q 1RUWKULS
KDVHQJDJHGLQDQDFWLRQWUDGLWLRQDOO\UHVHUYHGWRWKHVWDWH              SODLQWLII DUJXHG WKDW WKH )HGHUDO 1DWLRQDO 0RUWJDJH
DQG WKHSODLQWLIIEHDUVWKHEXUGHQRIPDNLQJWKDWVKRZLQJ                $VVRFLDWLRQ )10$ ZDV D VWDWH DFWRU EHFDXVH WKH FRXQW\
7DKIV)GDW                                                  VKHULIIFRQGXFWHGDIRUHFORVXUHVDOHRQEHKDOIRI)10$DQG
                                                                           WKHFRXQW\UHJLVWHURIGHHGVWUDQVIHUUHGWLWOHWRWKHIRUHFORVHG
   3ODLQWLIIDGYDQFHVQRKLVWRULFDODUJXPHQWLQVXSSRUWRIKLV             SURSHUW\  :H IRXQG WKH FRXQW\ VKHULIIjV UROH LQ WKH
DOOHJDWLRQV5DWKHU3ODLQWLIIDVVHUWVWKDWDWD[VDOHSXUFKDVHU          IRUHFORVXUHVDOHWREHLQFLGHQWDOUDWKHUWKDQHVVHQWLDOWRWKH
LVDVWDWHDFWRUEHFDXVHWKHSXUFKDVHUHQIRUFHVWKHVWDWHjV            UHPHG\ VRXJKW E\ WKH PRUWJDJHH EHFDXVH 0LFKLJDQ ODZ
WD[OLHQDJDLQVWWKHSURSHUW\DQGGRHVVRZLWKWKHDLGRIWKH              SHUPLWV D PRUWJDJHH DQG PRUWJDJRU WR DJUHH WKDW DQRWKHU
FRXQW\ VKHULII DQG FRXQW\ WUHDVXUHU DQG  WKH SXUFKDVHU         SHUVRQPD\FRQGXFWDIRUHFORVXUHVDOH,G:LWKUHVSHFWWR
FDUULHVRXWDVSHFWVRIWKHVWDWHjVWD[FROOHFWLRQIXQFWLRQWKDW            WKH FRXQW\ UHJLVWHU RI GHHGV ZH IRXQG WKDW mWKHUH LV OLWWOH
WKHVWDWHLWVHOIZRXOGKDYHKDGWRXQGHUWDNHLIWKHVWDWHZHUH            VLJQLILFDQFH LQ WKH IDFW WKDW D FOHUN PD\ SHUIRUP WKH
WR KDYH WDNHQ WLWOH WR WKH SURSHUW\  $V WR 3ODLQWLIIjV ILUVW   PLQLVWHULDODFWRIUHFRUGLQJWKHGHHGl,G+HUHZHDOVRILQG
DVVHUWLRQDWD[GHHGKROGHUGRHVQRWHQIRUFHDVWDWHWD[OLHQ             WKDW WKH FRXQW\ VKHULIIjV IXQFWLRQ LQ UHJDUG WR D WD[ GHHG
WKURXJKDTXLHWWLWOHDFWLRQ$WD[OLHQLVHQIRUFHGZKHQWKH             KROGHUjVTXLHWWLWOHDFWLRQLVLQFLGHQWDO7KHFRXQW\VKHULIIjV
VWDWHUHFHLYHVDIRUHFORVXUHMXGJPHQWDXWKRUL]LQJWKHVDOHRI              UROHLQVHUYLQJWKHUHTXLUHGQRWLFHVLVWRSUHVHUYHWKHSXEOLF
WKHSURSHUW\IRUIDLOXUHWRSD\GHOLQTXHQWWD[HV0&/$                SHDFHQRWWRDVVLVWWKHWD[GHHGKROGHUWDNHSRVVHVVLRQRIWKH
%\LQLWLDWLQJDTXLHWWLWOHDFWLRQDWD[GHHGKROGHU           IRUHFORVHGSURSHUW\$QGWKHFRXQW\WUHDVXUHUjVUROHLQILOLQJ
VHHNVDMXGJPHQWWKDWWKHKROGHUjVLQWHUHVWLQWKHVXEMHFWODQG            D UHWXUQ VKRZLQJ SURRI RI VHUYLFH E\ WKH FRXQW\ VKHULII LV
LVVXSHULRUWRWKDWRIDQ\RWKHUSHUVRQFODLPLQJDQLQWHUHVWLQ            SXUHO\PLQLVWHULDO&RQVHTXHQWO\WKHUHLVQRWDVXIILFLHQWO\
WKHVDPHODQG0&/$:HVW                        FORVHUHJXODWRU\UHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQDWD[GHHGKROGHUDQG
                                                                           WKHVWDWHWRZDUUDQWDWWULEXWLQJDWD[GHHGKROGHUjVDFWLRQRU
  $VWR3ODLQWLIIjVVHFRQGDVVHUWLRQWKHVWDWHLVQRWUHTXLUHG            LQDFWLRQDVLQWKLVFDVHWRWKHVWDWH
WR VHUYH QRWLFH WR WKH SHUVRQV LGHQWLILHG LQ   LI LW
WDNHVWLWOHWRWD[IRUHFORVHGSURSHUW\,QVWHDGLIDIRUHFORVHG            )LQDOO\ ZH ILQG WKDW 3ODLQWLII KDV QRW DOOHJHG WKH
SURSHUW\LVRFFXSLHGWKHVWDWHPXVWJLYHSHUVRQDOQRWLFHWRWKH           GHSULYDWLRQ RI D ULJKW JXDUDQWHHG E\ WKH &RQVWLWXWLRQ
RFFXSDQWWKDWWKHSURSHUW\KDVEHHQGHHGHGWRWKHVWDWHDQG               3ODLQWLIIFODLPVWKDW9DQ6LOHjVIDLOXUHWRSURYLGHKLPQRWLFH
XQOHVVUHGHHPHGZLOOEHVROGWRWKHKLJKHVWELGGHUGHHGHGWR             GHSULYHG KLP RI SURSHUW\ DQG SURSHUW\ ULJKWV ZLWKRXW GXH
WKHORFDOXQLWRIJRYHUQPHQWRUUHWDLQHGE\WKHVWDWHRULIWKH          SURFHVV3ODLQWLIIKRZHYHUKDVQRWDOOHJHGDQ\SURSHUW\ULJKW
                                                                           RULQWHUHVWLQKLVSDUHQWVjUHDOHVWDWH+HLVQRWDQRZQHURI
1R             :LWWVWRFNY0DUN$9DQ6LOH,QF             

WKHSURSHUW\QRULVKHDKROGHURIDPRUWJDJHRUOLHQLQWHUHVW
$W RUDO DUJXPHQW 3ODLQWLIIjV FRXQVHO FRQWHQGHG WKDW
3ODLQWLIIjV VWDWXV LV WKDW RI D WHQDQWDWZLOO EHFDXVH KH KDV
DVVLVWHGILQDQFLDOO\ZLWKWKHPDLQWHQDQFHRIWKHSURSHUW\LQ
H[FKDQJH IRU KLV WHQDQF\  'HIHQVH FRXQVHO FRXQWHUHG WKDW
3ODLQWLIIjV VWDWXV LV WKDW RI D JUDWXLWRXV OLFHQVHH  ,Q HLWKHU
FDVH 3ODLQWLIIjV LQWHUHVW LQ KLV SDUHQWVj UHDO HVWDWH GHULYHV
VROHO\IURPKLVSDUHQWVjRZQHUVKLSRIWKHSURSHUW\DQGWKHLU
ULJKWWRSRVVHVVLW%HFDXVHWKH&RPSODLQWGRHVQRWDOOHJH
WKDW3ODLQWLIIKDVDQLQGHSHQGHQWOHJDOLQWHUHVWLQWKHSURSHUW\
3ODLQWLIIKDVIDLOHGWRSOHDGDPDWHULDOHOHPHQWRIKLV
FODLP
                                  ,,,
   ,QVXPZH$)),50WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVGLVPLVVDORIWKH
&RPSODLQWIRUIDLOXUHWRVWDWHDFODLP)XUWKHUEHFDXVHZH
ILQGWKDW3ODLQWLIIjV&RPSODLQWZDVSURSHUO\GLVPLVVHGXQGHU
5XOHEZHQHHGQRWFRQVLGHUZKHWKHUWKH&RPSODLQW
ZDVVXEMHFWWRGLVPLVVDOXQGHU5XOHE