Court Opinion

ID: 4056496
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:59:35.689783+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:35.882079
License: Public Domain

R'EGEMED m
, ‘ , GOURT GF CFWM|NA’[ A‘PPEA,LS
v _ , .…_’._`\l.l§]l~_&_& JQN 112015
v c.®Mz@S¥@,C!@H<

GF ¢_

l

D‘,UA'N P\.DELQADO `
v.

` E>`T,ATE OF'TEXAS __ , C,RI.MINALAPPEAL"Q `

UU\W`»’UU(U?W
/

 

,_ A PP`LI CANT'§ RESP@NSE ,TAo_sI.A-cr-.‘§, PRQ~P¢>$ED. VIND: M e _s_____

 

O\`- F.A C_`,‘_¥_ _AN_D_CQN.CL.U_SI_C).N §-O.F__L..Aw ,,,.A_N.D.T H-E,,S`T_ R"\`,_E§_- . ~ ,_ _ _
_A _~__ _ ' ` ORI.(`:IN ALAN§\/$ER
- Tc> T\-\E \*LE:Svde-E op SAIDc.ouM. _

._(`,_O.,'i\§_'d_ _S\\_L>w, J'uo~vx il ~ b e\¢§w'$e \o.p p\acc.n‘\'\\> fe 5¢,%\\\1`»¢3‘\\.\`¢, `v\`\> cce\>c>v\$e
_ 'i\v\_?k_\»;¢;o~!>_c_\£e.=cqqs.¥§ooec\_c,o~o :'>L.,N_\v,~\l.\_v.\s§ b _c,cv_\, _S¢aye,&,w`_\¥»~ <'r_'\<\e, {71.-¢.§¢§ P_ce».p ¢>:>¢A -
F\},\A.\'.o.¢§§_o§_\?_c~¢:`\~__auA_C,av.\c_'\.u.>.\`om:»_o§_\,.ow.)_-\_c),~o_c\ '¥Mc, b:\w¥ e,:§,(>_e§`\§'w.\;~\_ A/A§`,\_s¢£`-

._"\';Q_Q_~p,p_\:l_€c~/\'.\S C\PQ\¢\‘L,¢<} l`(>f\ Y."o€` wr'\\' O‘¥ \}\6~\0.¢:¢~5 thorch Wovla..©\'\O¢/Q *\‘\hL -

~

_,_§_<>\\Q»__L~_A_, ; . _ v l
, .__», 4¢ _ . __T_.
. lhc-¢xg>p\\`cc~r»\~_ co v\ ¢s.)_.~__§ \,J_\.-¥h _~.`\.\o_e._‘v.§ ¢»<\r."\ n _i.¥`: §{¢\A\‘mj '\\Aa:\ p v c § uw;'.\ _~W-o n
--`¥_\¢_\e,§pd_%e,me.¢:r.\r_o».~¢\<§_ee_q-.\.e.n.c.e__q-_¥__+_\A¢._\.2.7.!‘_‘,’_¢\x's¥r.w`*c,:\‘_<;¢>w>§_o§_\:_\o.\~.e.L§.Covn'.\'_~`§.'\.v:.¥o»j,
` §n_€>.o=u,ie»_u.w.o_._'\l?>_$;`l_?_.2-\_\.».\¢\ e,~r:c__-:h\,.\¢._czd.p+l`s_cqw_<\;p_\ ¢,<3..<:5.\3.\_\_ _ __`“\;¢>__:¥L\.<,§.<_loa,>(. -
_ <>§§.e,.n_§e._o£_E.rA:\-:i.u_;r_\3_0~_€/_'\;4_\3_._P_u.cba@A*\_¥u_o>pp.\.{lmo*_'é_\>_\_e,q`_b.osn%chi\_o.g.c£c ~.
_m ehé\_\;¥_\n¢.:¥.t{a;\_cc_v¢r;\_$ am\ ¢:\ c.e,<§ ~\\~e..e_~§y\`\_¢a.d¥.,:\.U§).,v_\'¢me.._\\ _ec.~r_z_co n_§».n¢,.m<,»cf\*;
_`LZ\_;+.V\<,I§-Fo~\‘> D_¢l?.ac¥,mcx\.o§_ f/_i`:i;¢!\_\:<\o;\.§.u §§ pa flv\$\`\‘\'u¥\o~=~\ D\V"S\L>v\ . N o A.;rc¢+.
'_o~gpea\ w¢~;`> '\¢~\'~ev\. _ _ v
` `.i`_\r.\e._$:`.fo»;\<. \xa-S,<\¢e.r{\ec§ .~‘X\nc, §0»¢~`:§0~\.&\\:3¢....`\0@)\5> _mc»<\e, '\'v.\ .G~Qp\\`c_o.¢»¥§
. \ mb§a.s_\_\'_o_..?_§>§\:\.a_c\é\~_{eA_\_c~,¢ ge pi_€rfv:.~.c>b§»_$;vp.par_"\¢é ,b>\_o ~.Q.:°r.`\`_¢».`\ m§_£..c_u.r§_\:c,c_.o.eé b
_ ex»\.c'\,\_i§_&§mék§;\"`_`e>¢e,/>,_`§_é*wa:f.\_\.o:\p.§>_\_\"_cé.¢€.\ls_o.\\.c,»%¢~.§_`wg_\>.¢m.c._`v.o_:>_v£_€€c_r\`_e,,\¥*
. +\1\ e._s:¥.a»ic:>_c§m:\.w_\$_\_Q»_¢_\A_“§;w_&.hc¢r_m;>.ce_\_~\h¢mgpl\x_`¢¢~¢¢._v_\_\r\q;>_§:é~_\_\_¢c\_;\:u;vv\¢c\.
_ \m§b_\o_u._<;ée,./_\_o.§_c_\\,ec$\v.\g_c.,-/_»_'é.<_\>_r_o_§r_`\.».$_b.\\.0`_()_.¢_¢.Q.oA'A/.ar.cw_\¢e,~cs£_§c_\/.\a_g,.\l§Aenc_/€,
j o...~;§;>_w.\&`\.a_\r_\_.\_\`§_~\:\:o-_c_`_e,_n.¥_\¥\e.~h.§méco_\'>a;\o;¢_»~;b_’\;¢_\`;\.e§°_¢_l§(_\§_c»*c§$_<,_cl»§ ~\»'\/~e?&
¥\oe,_'\.`¢,\£>§r.c»r_\\',.cz.gp\`\c¢~\‘§v¢j. `£ f>.w§§\/\o»..r\ m c c~`\X o~/\ <\ ‘o\/\¢>J§\,:¥\'\¢e¢:‘./c¥¢_ be <\ej\.»_¢§ ,

iL.

 

f App.\.\`cc~m)€_c~r_,<§ue.b ‘¥\pc~§ :‘\~'\¢\cfa\r¢i~.’xcb §\`v\&_!\%§_ 08 §0~¢:\ c)~r\§ \<,§50.\ w¢\¢;\os`wn¢c>~vc
_C- r\> §X.§o»v.\\.m¢.\c\_un:\y>;`\f¢é}c"\oba~*ca .,P<,pp\`\_¢go~ :\\ \D c§§'i ¢»\:`> \/\:ib oh$u> ¢`<`¢ §o>\ §¢,c\ A~\‘§@
" _C>‘s.,“\* "}\/\o..‘\. `~_-\_\¢-E. cs~.\f)\'b\c\' C;ov‘s~-\' 'M '\N.> A(\€>\;nc¥\w\ \oc\‘u-\c,e¢\ ~'\".\¢\e, o¢;%< Aa,.\ ; .
_-ap`z\\ge.:\-:x,ez\_¥z$v w\'-"»'\' ¢»$. \'\o.`\oco~b aim vu.’> o.¢\é\ o-Qp'\'\¢a.,<\"i>,cw\ ¢,AA<,A`__¢§_-§_§\_,\¢\ _` ,
`C\~"\d§\\`c-,a:\<\`z>v\-_l¥ “\"\ae,. b“\ra‘\c`_\b Mo»\<`w\§ o~v\$v.\¢r Xz\,:\_\~e, O.\£\q;;no`\_.&g.§\\.ca§,\on -¥Mea 7
-»¥`\/\¢,\(_u$,\l\_oln\% §»\`v-\A_ clam c.\~v:$c> r\\ 6~\\ d¢»>r$\ov~é §.-<>un&<§ 0 v\ o»?p\\¢a.\§.s'wmcw_
_ _ of ~.\,-\n¢ §o»¢\f> 1 o`\¢>¢\<.§ ll.` >\-`v~¢&\aé\.c,l_{b W\iw\¢§ c\r\ €>\M¢_c :-\'r> Av\e.am¢:>£\_s.é _
.0\\) §)\\ Lo,§;\lz.a\_,j_»_»@§i¥ .'\:)_v_\.\ 69_:\:¢_\)_€,¢§§0¢»§_@@;>_\1¢_0~.m§v_c,o V.\ A_moS;Q\/_\.¢e,;§_v§;o '\o,vré¢n.
, O»Y'c»\\c.i£v.vn!:>_cxm'§1¢,¢~_¢.,~/-\`v\_¢§> cer_‘\'¢i._\y.\ .<','\.o.\.`\`sv>£> b.&cau§e,_¢.\;€o :\i\;\_<‘_ o_ug\§-c\w¢,¢\'f\.\.€$aaw

 

_M_;L Cc>'\/\c§ _V\.<:'\'- O»LC\\$\YC C,e '.~§5:\~'\ ev;(l'¢&§& "’¢'O \>e,¢: gaf/4 \ry§$_c;\,a:} -‘~i'> w~\v\_`\_¢!\_c.v:\\~`\_-
,&§ :¢\I; 3 €/A'\'\.€~¢`\{f\ncaf` ;¢~"¢3 Cchn ¢C'/\.`/“`<°-'». " A §¢L\\u nc '§T<>.Sebe,'\op_¢& ;o~¢:'\.u¢.\joz~§'f`\¢’> §O!`
__ a_ c\o.;'m "»e, m3 ce~¥¢;b\§§kc¢'\.un\c§.:)_£\gqe¢_ib_.o,~,do»_»o_\< QS_A`\\\g@qce_\.c>;r_s,um¢,§m.lcr
' _ ch~v_\f\' \`_o.~§\::\_\:`\'}dv_&o_»,\ol§__¥¢e_v,e,;¥_`i-_\»_§_c,¢_»c.v_o e.\>,¢?\»,`\;\v"v. v.\¢-.~Z cour\:ze,\,f,' .\Q 1\1§@_~¢§ ;y; . Ia:\o§',.

_ 1 10 S,‘!.'.:i', t'-_{ `l_‘| \@'oob), A \'\ o"v\\c,s_' ,c,',\o$,m§. arco §\“.r_w\\v\' q)co w\`o\_¢A § v\_’v.`\¢\¢.-~r:cw `~A,-
,, § ;A¢va§;_¢né' b*é§¥e;\@ 4\_~3¢\/_~¢ O~N»c/\Aieé\‘ c§g p\\c,x\;\o¢\ amy §§ W\cmc) <`cwduw\ 04 \ow)¢ -
. g?p\\z¢" o§`,_(;o_.bb¢’,flré "\'\r\¢\~.)( q c').'\`:`>¥`\r~.c\\;>¢\ W\w:_'z\'\/O€, WAC b\'\ '\;~\¢\c, c\\o¥c:p\ C,c_vrl ` _
. _ §.c’~'> \-z> w.\"vz¢.'_\'.\_o.-§.p\`;\c,¢c:\:\`c¢\_wo»b_b_e.jx.m\`c$x,e.y_\`eu).ec\~.. ALA.\.\/\¢n o=?_?,\_\`c¢»'.~:\’ x_c,€»\_ ¢ve.é. “\'\'\4’_ 1
_'_ OP§?\'c c?~'»'é _v'¥§> g co ;>`ob¢é\ §.”»`/,\A_Qv.\¢¢_‘>_o§-§mo*\ max - `
'- <'-¢<=- "~'\ c»,.\.`»,.s_§.Q.Ab.._o§_\a»`..>.`;»§t_\..._»Q~.é_cz.é_é,r.¢,b>e_ri._Je-.r.> app L\ ¢o~'.~`\‘¢: !X FW--‘§\\'~ 1416 \`*\ J'¢> __
__ wh\!/\'\__b_¢“'b:o~é_ bix¢.?\,tcb`\&e<.§-o;\'._$,{o,_¢€<.N_Ov.cmbc,c~ _o.¥ L£>\?.. ~\ b\)_&{_?:y?¢_\_[_~€@x& GU`ISO` _
~, § c.‘: p',v\£,. <,LAA rcb$ damages bw§>m°r\-\¢_.l ¢\-z> ‘\:\¢\¢. c'\\;&§cf`lc."\': c,'\_e,¢:)s,v§/\,.c`;-`\"'_\M¢L{
>_ vv\M-_l>_o_\`___c\%._i»'k~_il.féc»:\ cc\ b-\ §`._\Q_'A`_\,¢:\ka,v..é_§ro_m~,oxq,p\lw_».'\‘\-§a~._é\§§€\'r.§.c,k_co_¢_$;\_a `T\/\\`§
_ \€Q\é.\_f>_av>e, "\‘o_p ccb.u_w\; A_\¢\¢>.-.\'_ ,~`¥.\o.¢, ‘Skw§c,__\m::s~c\ ¢>.v_\'§_">o___\ i_\k_\_c-_~\ug_c\a;\.v.\~:$.:`\§\m¢:..;\_\`}f_c\;¢.\oL¥_§;/.ca_§§.ncw_wb_¢£¢_kq ‘Sem`& ,`\\c'$
`._0~/\ 5.\»_¢_<;6~¢§.pl\&¢__§_\{ Qpp.~
_\ zac~_/\":‘L`.o§.cu_l:c_¢m%_c:,-5B..Qe.ab_c§\/_\o_~/.»%e:‘>_~_T_i\"_v_~,lf>_¢>__\;¢z~c;\.:>_cz__g.p;\:\,can§<;¥e>_\o_<§\§eve .
_-»LV\¢»‘\' .L`_jc_.i_‘~z_.~`& \n.¢_ ,<> ;:`\ 3 \.;`g\_a Q._?\l` Lo\,-¥{c> /_\ amin/cjc "'t\n er amend ¢é\, C:P.p\'\ _¢¢¢X\`éx\ .-
_»"» \- is __ma~,\$__'\y\§ J\ n$we,? `-\-:> \o <. cows ¢ j\-'\~¢.C¢v /~ ¢\-e.\\ Uf\'~ \' s~é~<& r¢’¢._.’> was vince.
,Q_e,'§j'£";_\;q£\_€:.f bomb i.y_\Cu§\/b<§-\ cdc f"\"\¢vc,. C\\\ Lxc,)-o; '.\'V\€. O\".\\¢j\`/\a;\ 61\)?\_`\(‘»0¢\?;@-/\.- .
- '_.Qc.\>.">;\_\\`¢a\.¢\\' §~\S¢.> o~§§e,r~‘¥b .'\'\(\c~';\’ '\`/\' `\§ `¥\'»¢ Q~M¢mé_e<.\-o~Q.Q§.¥.eo~¥.s" `i§< "~\ b obvou 06 ¢c') Tv\_-.\`\,\¢ craig ré_®_& _c<=m@\»€b
" _ b~; '\-X\'\_,"\`- c;<'c\>, Rv/\_¢:b_o:":`_€§.v~\`_\_P_r,oc.ev¢\_v';_r.e_.,1.'\§»)¢. €'¢LL. , b '3.i `C¢ "`* ;_ 644 .i:».§' s‘~¢>.v.\f_em 113
g`O‘~m.`¢;.'_\éA;¢.<-§L.P_o¥\i\';»`m.\§ \.wab.-;‘>,u_\>.v;.\§<§_¢cxO-¢>B_-Q"\\¢A "‘:\`\}v\¢'\-t»\.o»:.\é c§:\c\ v.\,c'?`\' ‘ _
- on;.s~.<>».-\c_~c:\_s_o\_‘§gcp_si\s~<__~_X::.>_:¥.v.\.¢_c>_p_.`p c>_b \';\c_=_\ _p.c~.cé<>\_f\`\:\; ~<>\`~/.~'\.c,m A.¢¢§,_o_`\>p_\_\ ¢¢_‘\cl§.m, l ` `
_31¢\_§,\'.\c..r_¥,_`\;=_W~_o_p.e:_age\_`\_¢~__>v;\r;<.__\,?r~§¢cc_$§< <>S: du 53 \`¢e._ 4 , .- `_

Z..

 

1\ 99\\cc~1\“'1 va~kv\r.)r owcy<:> *\/\¢.:\ ~\'\/\¢:5\§)¢<~\`¢~,\' gov 1-\ w~5 3¢'\/\¢_ 6‘\¢:.:\-¢,
`\/;.A vvw.<§e_ 'm> §ac,-\_\.> »v\ ~\\,\<,ovc.¢ - 2`/2,€\{¢2-;5
_"m,nc.e, 0199\\<;»~-'\51 ¥\\¢5 '1\1~¢_.¢>5`\¢§¢\<»\ 0-99\1¢¢51`¢'>/\ 095 §r\,c\¢ \1\1:.1_\` bo¢\c) e¢\\~\\ L.v\

W\ow\_ 2,£>_1_2_6_\5.\;\_\/.\€_ v&.r~\_-\'_bé:#!\; 501>\__11\._`\5_(;0vr'1__§_b_\2_€5_1'1">__9¢r_(,v'v_\a,¢v\.
jaich 1\~<»_ ©\2_.¥¢.'31.»¥>1~1§\¥> \_\ a 9 rc> 9<;:)1:5¢_ ¥_L:_\A;?~¢os_o § ¥o_ck_\_<'_<>..~cf\,v.,:» o-S
$_1<;.»`; cw»é 511»~¢¥¢:) L¢\{~,.u_s¢_,n I:¥ \:= \vw§>oeb\b\e gov ~1\~€,_ '?)¥.;.,~\¢, \3, _\,m
mo;<\_¢. Ow_\>_9 ro~.“\:\ov\o~\_§_ adv-65 §§le_\§§-<>v \<..:>c~\ Lo/\ c,\vb_\w,\.`: 010@)_ gmc
C_G.,\_s;;\_{'»\ v:\'61\<1_\ \/{@_\a~-\riov~:z +\~;-A w¢_vc. c\em.~_\\` 52111\€5 ¢»9\¢§\13»65 565
'1\'\€¢-\_.:\055\ £\\e5 `O\l 51¢-.5¢,0\//\5 ;¢5¢1~6~110\~_\ 0_~A5 <`,6~$&_1,6-\/.>‘ 0~/\5 w€v<-
¢,\___w\`\ 5\,9()¢,;\1¢¢5 b\\ ~1'\~¢,{'¢¢0¢~.5 in \€_‘§>;`) -1'\¢~0».;\ C>v\€. 501\_\ f\-;'> 02991_\¢;¢;,,~.‘1
- has 01,5%¢\'1-¢@1 --\-¢> ~\\Mé 11va § ace¢»\\-\ ‘,'1\1\¢€<’,. \`5 no.`\> v¢:'>vm\>'\'»o.n_c§

 

C,o _l*"c,¢‘/'.'\¥\C$f? \‘1'¢60/1 6=.\01)-\€.? C-Cu 1;‘\’ “1\/§0¢';1'_1/;10.¢~5\`1\5:1€.\\( wo\§_~\'c& ;'1;_\£\4»¢ 11/\
wv-»:'>\éc'~w\c> _¥\ne. Mo<>"v wv~.~Qo\~Xd/A'\' 0\,.»\,5 §uv\¢-§a.w»c,x\m\ v\g\¢\'~‘> 0~5_ 01\:’.5 2
1110¢:-5>\~\..~1\5__¥1`¢¢50»/\ Sr':<>w\/cw\ o»<'b_`\:\-€¢~z~\` c,¢»*v\c}»ov\_`_w\o~va¢o x_e'.<>¢~\
cov\r.\ub\¢>»\é_w\~\\/\m;\' ww~\ vm\ Q§ §Q§\!`. mves-\-\c_§a¢\\¢.»'\ w_\\~b 5991\¢2.,<\\.~)
§o»_c,§_wa.\_¢l~,\l¢cbo£t ,\c~'>_:.'> 0~/\5 -¥\/.\¢n.,p copr-ascs 43 4\~@_ 319 51¢5-€,,0_‘1` _$ot~`\.é,.»_\o.)o@§.

. C;o.v_r~.‘\f~;~\:¢.z_350.9_1-_:\~\.~`<:.{>.<._i¢_§_v_o'\,<>.\,zé_§,§o_é_~l\%£)_e~/.\5_€¢<2.0_¢.\“\?-5,1`§¢>6_$:0,¢_o- d
9\'%_1‘\¢€0_~1;`¢_1\% ‘C`v\ L..¢¥\;c,\'~ '1;\91:»’1\\`§»_6_\¢;_€, 515 vxc>'_\;@ \`6_1&>151.;<’...k E>'ewe.;;v.'@uo~r:\c'~
‘~1°1_`1 E 3¢1110_2. 113 $. (._~t 1051 G\o_(>\'~cbum§>;1\on o _¢v<~r¢¢*nw§>_,_MQM

`°125_1-`_21_5.`_7_ Z°l §QQ~_&\»&\L_M,A.Q%Q¢¥ Y\"o&>\< 5¢\¢-1) `T.\A€S_(__'A_¢._C;»z\_`<);\$;_\o\` _A_

1 _ ~¥\1\¢5}¢¢1.-_\;<,_¢~./_»5 +\¢»¢._é._`\:.~»:¥¢~<,\' gov 1111 o~r; "_ob§e_c)cwe,\~\_u.v_\_mc.o>s_¢)_d¢~§ale`l . -
L~_L.SM_LAM.-L> 32 wb..,ce.;z. 1155 c+ ama . _ 7
_ Tv\_\;¢§c>c¢\c.e~\b‘\\z€;orwy“a.\ 0\99_\\¢5.:\‘\01:\_509 w.v\\ o . C\(\.o~\oec\->Cc" 9\)' .') 17

.1»`\\_¢_<‘> ov.\ _S¢Q§-¢»&>'er 2.2_\Lo_\;?.,_ _-\.\n.e,_‘b¥¢~.l\c,f.;\~».<\ q <§>`QS_\_€\/\¢.Roy_\ ¢£_\351. ¢.
1\’\0',1»0!\ ¥<)\" \/v\c,;:c€,o*:\.v_¢ C»‘.’>b \S‘\c»v_\o_€. 0:?__¢€>.\)/\4>_§\ O\_S- ah _\SSS-L_¢ _\'g_\o`_\'¢$pc\vcé
.01,\5_;\»_\/_\_ _C',ovr“\' 50 695:»¢.~<5 !lXXc,r 7-\‘\€_¢:~.:5 m\~\\~ v\o -;\`v~<\w\&b e,`;.__,('o~o"\
o\ Co:\c`\\)b\cn=b ex 1€'--‘> 0\¢\5 \v’\ §0.4>:1 ~\_\Ae_ 61¢`.-\,<_5. `_\5_\/_\¢,_ _¢,_\/_¢:,/_\ Q,Cqu&r@

__.G~f\_c_§§¢.c§\_a\..\:_\§x_§_m_v>z\_cq_c;,\\m\\a o§<¥<>r¢\¢~\\ T\/~.a:v\¢,\_~_;> bc W\a..r-¥W\, \-¢ vc>.c_\\_/c, , ,

` am _\`,3.5.012¢>_.-,0~9 9\.11¢§~/.\£‘< 9 co 9 ¢r_\:`_RM¢¢~A¢;~> :`%\n c, `\1\¢§&¢¢;¥\`~/¢ (,ow~»$¢\ c\¢». w

. w\~)cv\_{>v:§lé.er\"r\§§~\ &\\e%a.é\€k>né 625 5¢\~06§/ \v.\ -\\~.¢.c mow/125 2\99\\¢¢‘5'11>/\.,_
\\/.\<_.5_5;¢'>5C\_\ w \)€f>_.£\,/\A_>_v_\¢?_~_;_;o»v\ ca, .'_\c">__€,o /_\ c\ us\ 9/\_5 _G § _\c_a.`,`.> _~1<..1.¢/\5
“C\<\s,=§c __~_\'_\/\;¢_\'A-_o¢\:c._x\o_ C() n:\~_`*@v_c~~\<',¢§ \9:~ <,V 1 cub\~j uv.\_<`_€b.o\..v 65 ’16-4-»3¥5-(“¢~1”
<’_r\gv.\ _“\-L> _»-1\¢~¢._1:¢9505 \4\( o§`- 4\»\1>6,9~9\\¢1¢1/~"\§ Cor\¥\;r\¢v\c:v\§‘ 3565 C_€-_€\!~'_»£c crm

. e,v _;5&¢:5.~0~1::`_¢` \:\,c,au,~ w\o> \\ov\- '\'\'\e, 5~\0»‘\¢ \` /\ \‘\'§ owv\ mc-\-.¢>¢\ \ §ovn¢'\ 1165

___ -\>$uc *1\¢~65 Y\¢c5¢5 ‘\"<.> 10 <. \:c_§o\ve5,w1\\g\/1

\. Al¢>\L§N_c_r_5,\5.\_$_Cz.-\¢U~%Q~\,\/.\._\.:\'.O-_MC»\S_€, CL/\\\ ;\1/\5\~/,\€3 5”.\'\0¢5” "1\/\€,¢:_¢. \5 \’\Or`

   

                          

31

\

_C_u_~_r_\~_"\i_-_c_v_¢_\i_¥_<_;v_ o . Q 1~¢\/ \ov_§\\\ uv\ \i<.‘>o\v¢¢\ ¥¢_c,-¥s> -.-\~0`3\- eve ¢\,<>v v¢¢_~\¢__l.<~¢_¢_v\ 2
6\)_\_ cv m-\~w-r»` law v )\o> \"'o O\'>¢\c_.c;\~w c,\\` uv\ xir,o\,$o M\o\e L£_;L:`_E_'MM
5 v g> .'ia..
__T\/_\_c` Sv¢¢v¢i_ c,u»A i\"\r~n:,v§\r\ _\~e,_ ri____q_§a_\‘§é_ _\Ao_§_ dc'\_x_€_fv_o~?p\\c.¢__:\°;_c~.h~t
` ._O~c_'..e:':€>_j~\_\/_~row$\\ c\__ve,é_;‘\_\_\%en ce:_\_\_-¢>_ \'_\cv_c._Z_Q_C_?>_ Q_¢._\_vc€» vic@ov‘v_a»&_%co.mv__ __ .
a\\c,/_»`_ §_\v_v_\g_ ee»€/___\~ iy_\e/\v. o § \¢»¢/'i 'i_c\_\_v_ c,¢§<_ 0_`\,.\ c,_%oc‘n-_€>_~\_S_C_€>__ _fr_\~¢- c>_€i_ x _¢3\ v_\_e»\
. Lv‘\__\/_v_\__¢c’»_»u_§_¢_n_o_.$.__\l»~_$_§ 7 l 3 3_1_7,_%_5_`2_2_§_1~\_»_\¢,\\_\_\oi¥_<)_£;cog;v;§\v.')
di v\'.e_ §§_¢Qv__{_)_=:»_nc_€z&__-` c»_p_?_'.\_’\an_\/.>_¢>_\_\_;\,_\r_\:>_v_e_p_c_oc_ee¢\ c¢v_ £\':>_%_v_`\av_ `_c_\;_\_ em_<\__\,~_ _Sal\_v_\___%_ 3_5__¢_%__"1:\__\5 1121 _L_a)_,_+_h___ a. _`\s¥_ 1- _1`_¢_& ¢_<>_ Q_r~_\-__m_\>svi
_c\\:,-\c_rm_ mo §§ o~n ev_\`£v¢z\§r'\aci\\_ .\f_\_co~c_ _\v\u> _\b_ ve¢_\v \1;~ ceaA_ O_vz_m:_\\ §oz¢ivu)¢:_\ \$S\)cb

 

ip '~ c':¢_rv,\»<,cv_ _b\\a¢_ppv€ocmv (1>\/‘)£ hotv a,

' _\7 cic:,¢_e$_~‘>__c‘_'_\\_~¥\/1_?`__(__0_\) . ~v"> -@_ 1031ng `;\_v\%_ »v-`\A{/ _ .
C,`Ovv'\'_ o_§___C_C \:v_~_~_\r\Q~.\_ De_Q§_ &m\S_K\/\.vbv\’_€§~¢"v!;CM\./_\_e._c§__:v_\r.\c\»\r/L¥c,_v®_.°y_'\'¢»v _v'»"__\é\_

_/

_ ivsz A'_\va’_€_\_ox-C/Dv$`bf$ -;W\A¥‘A&&$é< .

` _\ ~\1:\_€, __T_€_.._);§_\b_Cu\/_¢i_:v__ 0_§_€_¢_3.»¢~1,_\`;1\¢>.\ .l}cp\>eo~\$ _C_ _v\_¢\oi\ §v:_\ v\_\\ A<_&e,rmw\€_ \v=- - _

. __`\ <_.' L. _`_P_ Pc:i_'\_ _\\ C>"?_ SQL ._3(¢\)____¢\@9`\_`1¢_5_1.;v_\'_~v_\_\_ia_¢z__vv.c,_$c>_v_'v_¢§_v_v.»C.Cu_ €`_5__ _\v_\_O. \'.`A¢r :\To _C,on..$_\l'\¢(`_ o~\_\ _ivi__\/_\_<_-_¢_c__\__ovo»/_»_ __Od£,n_v_»_v~.__z_, iro_~c/_v$ w_\_€vvamg

'__ ~v-\/_\_o_‘.'>_ c__ d c__v_ c_\ o_ pecv_b>\_i\:lv_~c.<§~\é§_¢i_€ov .C<,>Q-Pé _O_ 1'.\ _v_\.\_vi_\¢\c_/_\_co_~_o_ivi_\¢_\c.'_\i)<\ 5 \,_C,Ov- ':v_
_ d_t__ cf\A_ z_..'§`§_o,/x ~\_Q_\i_¢b_u mp_¥_vo- v_\_o_v`i_c,o.- -_r r_¢_o:\'. ga e&§_@?_p_\ _\_e.i_v'_o__v_\¢_\c_r_\.; S¥,~_ QC_v_

 

. C`_L)V_ 1~_~v_’:>_1.\ _¢\_ CC v\v mg\m,)\~‘_"€-buv-KA j
_ i'rv/_\cz.i_\i_@_§i_€,é__um(>~v'le.'\. . ___
D_o'_¢_:'> _ivhge.__‘p zi_o ceb> cM\cv va:svan¢e 09 k~v»e_. c\\:>v n<_~\- c_¢,\,:»\~$ ?1~\8\,~3_5 C‘1~\\ ?r.»(i v
`l __0~<\&_ _\i\\o/\a_\_ \¢\,W`W`$§ \@ ecM_b¢-.*»_:\'_vn_<_ _é\\§:v_\:\_c§r_ C<:~v vivi___c_ \v.<_av _~\:0 _§_<.;v_l`v` vi_\jv'!'v_\:
_ b¢»___s__¢é _o_.g__ -vv_\_¢_$_l_@_»o_vs Q_/\A_<_'/_\)Aencc. p_z~_c _5__¢¢\-\¢6 _‘0\\ _<>»9_ p\\co./\)v_~\'\wvv c~.v_§_/ _
Q\ ca,;~_\_\`_€,_u_p_ gowvec;\_ _\Q~l j_i\~_c,_ r¢._c_-o_¢:_e._c_¢_ l.r_\_a»ev_ _¢¢\_,W¥_<»_\_\`_A_<_V doch \o\l_
_ iv \r_\_¢?__c\__ '\.>Iv'_xi_\_.»_v__ Co_c/_ i`__iv;:_\/_\@beas_§?_f.:o_¢,e_’>f;_ oi\~__c ?$_ zz$_iL(_`)L)_\_B e_AA_-.;L‘v_v__\il@__é___‘v _\1"_?§_-\
- vv 5a uzg: 123(`°@°“ "i‘r 2535>-1-- 2 ‘v~\‘-‘i'-“ ~V ,»LL_ L_°__E 3c1 1502 \52_\_1'_\_.1_"2_,_

_ (wwcc-.~ \_q_¢n)_; mcn¢>,m;a __.,;_1\11¢_% ,_13¢112 3¢'1_1__0521__@;“_(_11~_1<_=1‘32) .
_ _B_=_Y@v__ca/_\iv (`_c_§_p_¢;__y\i¥v_\_\_\`_<`_e.e\_u_¢é_~:v§ _~_v_\/.v_.:\_ :\'_\r_\_\_s_v~v_vco_o_s:a.b_\'-_c____ C<>~_r'v_? ccvz¢\¢
. (:__M_dc).,/_\_s_o£)_~§'_l._2 _O_~_.'_\A_ C_c_»r¢§_v§_a.l\o._\-\$\j_ivz> _\r_\\ 5 e-><:v_me_ r¢v__\(_\c»._\(-c_o»§e_ o\/\' i\;
. i\i\/\\,$ O~.r\a.v~\ 515 \,`_‘1\\.\ cv~<:_vvvo'~'\év’\i_c~:\'€._ \f_\l_c_'\$_<‘::_\“vi_\_:\-_v£é _i_v'o v~. c¢~CV\ c~$ \/\\‘§> % b¢ccw><’_”. _ _ _ ._

‘-l._

 

. .(.\.)c.q P.§Uc.c»r\)t"§ O~m¢!\6.e6 o.\> Q\~\Co.-\ 100 0~~'1~6 évbb¢qv_ea‘_\._ob»_lc>u_mcm\b Q\_¢_c~r\~i _
6..<1`\\¢~5¢ ¥¢`¢¥\"a 41~<»"¥\ §?$rc>vc’~n, ¢9._~\`\61\¢_‘> \/\Km,~`\»c> vc'\¥e,$. \j\`\\\ v.\..o ` `_ _ -'» ,_
_____"-\.`1#1 u.s_. s~:_, Lc<> 06135).""1°;§_»:6§__@_~_;¥\~____$!6\6, 3"12~ usc-ev 312_. . ~ _

L2_)_ ]'_\nc,_'_\"_¢bc/_'\ \oc\>'e.6_ <;\_.cb_»_w>$_ _\0\1 ou\>y_ \\`co.b_* ccc€,§_u§ p o r~\'¢6 ___\o;\_~\:\<»_e,
- § ¢Cc C<`_ Q.¢\6 '\'\'\,€,r ¢;Dr_€_). Q~__¥`€._'n/_O_ dr___.\>o~\pa~.h\\.`_\/n¢ t¢c>_\ _`0_\_6_\_“.1'.€:\ va\ 1.6)J,

; _ 0_1~ \`-.»._\3.¢_ B\cs<,\<1cc1@c_v_._}\‘\1\sog>,_1:131_0_;_¢¢3@51:13)_}_@¢0_13§£666_61~ 1 1
_ _ 511\2 F 26 cc'\~ 1201 CS+“¢;¢~ 1<\¢\_0)

 

6_(3), gen 1`.<.»_¢~201\:>_.\9_¢._\1_¢>1\6_-\'_\/_1_¢_0>_ r\“\'.c~<>§_o § 0613.1>\`\<'.¢~:\'\ "¥\\'e_§e_ c,`,\o;z ms
' ) w <>‘,é z,' 1106 6yb")c._¢¢~\:zc§_~'¥¢>_m_§uc\\_‘_§vbj\_r\, ,o_~ 96_<:66_ cq uw'\~¢ \/» cow`\ 1.\11) § vs
r‘\'\¢\g c>»`\ 651’(`.\_¢" C<~>v_€"\'f>_.\\§¢_v_\o_¢_¢_\_$__?_\?`_¢z.§€$zb lcxn<\ 616 _V\O'_\' \"_C_€?c`>l ut,__¢_§\\ ‘\'\/L '
. 60 n¥ro\\{v\§ 04` \`¢\cvo~¢\'>t ¥o~u;\'oo~\ ;6:>0 55 "' %6~1- gee \L\._EL ` 2.3\1"`36
_ _ . 10 Ls` LU“~ 61 n ch>Q) ‘,_\QMLA bupm. _é_ z_zs__§;,‘___u ga _ `
- :YGWQ:>, 172_ 1131'1,3&1, 361 €5*_“11_:1», 1‘1¢1<1> . -

, `__"\_`_\'_\<’,- habeas cou:` 45 9\»}\6:1»\§>§ 0\\:¢. uv\c_cc~.§ov\¢>.\o\e.__ base.6 ov\ ¥\116 cnm<,~&¢<\ ,
_c\`\»p‘»\` 6¢\'1£>1\ obAA 4*\1»¢._ raw 1~6‘, s ee, \_Q_Q__\g§_xb_;§b&.~>.,_§oiq_c.>_.. 51-3_3'_17_1_3_¢ 71_-35¥~1 __
661¢\:1`) 113 s ¢-1.33§_,'11»15 c¢w~+ ncc;\ noia cr.cr +b b&.~.__l,ccs 165 cbsvsw€c- `
b€cc_o»vb<,-\"\'\c~\¢~r¢~ ¢\¢6~4`\'~\ Cov.v\'rcur~\ 616 ~\\1~¢6\'1'.00 \~6__ c~.AA,_ W_\_~\ §-M§~,s),»~\ s

_ 3111-661»\15§ \_oc_ \e,cb¢,\ 00. nc,\@_sw,r,\_§ Ob<‘e_._ b_\c._~_\:o~~\`\~\ c v va 1\ ¢o\;_$_ ;Y‘_>L=o.$ c>»\ v

-_LCL.£§%..)_ 2.2_\’;¢-3.6_{23_ “°l_ _(cB_‘:\,_U+“ 61 ry \‘LW:\>_ \_W\/_\\ 560 rch L C(,;.‘p 0~/\ _\,\n61_ 69 .eA<;\O~Jv
_c`\¢.m~. 1963 cv_»cs¢ ,_g_.s_y__;bbng_b_,_\ _'1_;_1331_ 3_3._1_,_38¢'1_£§*“ sav 15:\:\)____ , - _
,_C_cu_c_-\;¢ _C<`_\.w\ \/\_66\ A-p v ¢6\5_\_6~11\,5:`1'_.\36._0¢.6_ b:\ _\1_\6».\0¢¢: ;>_566¢3¢0_£10¢\1'15$

_ _C,c n<,\-_b\c. mb\_§;v`__§`_¢¢',.o_mme_ q¢;l,a~_~\'_»g.;\j w\'\¢n +\A~<.\\ O~'\ <’,. v\ 06~_66_0_ Q_ 0<`“\’§-6 \o\.{

7Js-»\c_r_:,1'__1».»__1;11_,__€6_,69_1111¢17,{_3¢_1\¢»:, 3_>¢_<»3&¢<\ 111 _1\19 am csa _ca_hsc\o_cs~$_. . _

' b _ C\_\O\\vx§,§_\.w\'\\cb\'\__\»\.c,cvt\\¢b_.¢ v_\_\ -\»_\1.\¢,_ 6656’$'_\¢)( 600_ _“\’_§ ¥\166 _\1_\3.‘>__¢6_€!: -

c 601/16 tob_'~_=\_`<‘t> _6\/\¢__? ~E,£.c». \\_6_ _QMMMEL]_G _2_1:,_7_6 ._ '
q 3 '.">_,_5;\3 q (Ji~" C 1 P 11512?.)..1-¢1» ~6._60_0‘:\';00.\_\.\ v.\§_\..ow`_>_ 6_".,_§;6\\ \, van_‘ .
` 7_7` _`?>.E._Z _"*'\_ 61 ::___\_ 328 31 __3 _a/\(>._\`_¢Q_ ¥_ ¢_5 616»¥_5_<;0.'_\_¢>_\>_\/_1_¢1\.>.3_€666'¢_£\_66'
\'D._CDJA (._€_¢3`,___~\’\¢;__¢_ €..\e..;~/.os 667 §Q~_;\;§_.~¥:¥_ \'.\L_c_,bc:,~ v_\:\’_'a`_o\\_ \'_~/_\f>_ \:;r_§ob\_\>_r_\ A£c;¥\<.§

7 . amf§_.`w_\_'\_ 5_1`_¢_{3_€:€, s_z'.cn;\~ “\¢Me_ __p_\c§_v_\r_\ \_ocn S.\)'_Gu>\e , M\`\/FV__A___€,/\`Lc\'\_`_ _530
- 1,_1 5_".5_?.1&'1_311\_,_\2.0 s__ctz._z:;_¢-\¢s_ (;c~,¢~.b) _ _
_` .A@p\\c,amf\'_.1`0_1§).\.<,¢»¢.\1-/'15_;,¢\~3<3/\_;\;\~¢.-&0_\)_¥`_'\'__-\'.:. 0§>6€;1 v_\_o\ C_o p\t 9§ 6$\€_;

l §70\ \:\oww\g 0n6.c_r T_ L C_ '\). ,Pw¥ \\ O`( SC_C,,?>Q-'_l) \_Sc»_ 6\¢\¢:\ 1'\5 Cov\c_\_ub- _

1`1;»_`1\:, W'~\\\ 19 39 \@o»scc\_ 1>_¢\ ~1`\9& §0.<,-’<$ o_b cc\» ccs\e'c\__\>\\_~`\_~_v\c_ 1 1aer °

 

   

 

5.

 

(\) 1002 Po\\c_¢ i.’¢pcc~"\ or B€`¢~»'_\<\f\` !X\\es~s imp ea.¢\¢\w\j C.os\\p\o\.;v\'\~ <>\ f
\vvl~¢."r\c¥ -b-YQ»\\CW\~‘:> b\ O~\>{)\\<;v».»\'\r

(2..) _\,-\0~,€"€`\3 C,Ou rv`r~` $/\/\C$ \¥"¥`5 O~§¥‘:VDFD€~\ 1(,\16/\‘4. '\/\6'\4‘»’~§\'\:(`.>*’\ \.¢B Q0_¥`
VV\,o\vc,¥\ 'Z>"Z.` 7_0\\. ,

(?’) `\.(`o\nsc_(`\\>)€' 59?%£>“6_¢0¢\,\/¢1:50:\'»0¢\ be:\'u.> 660 c».,\d Q\\C.Q»’\Sr»\.)\q\\,e,
____\,_¢\ _\_\¢>,¢,~(\\§ _C.fs_bn‘+~‘ `\`5~‘\\-.~ w\~\»\¢\ §§\;'\\/\6( $`¢%Gr¢xw\c$ \£`L>\\'\_9@ cv.\. C><;)¥?>bcr. \3 ?-<'-".\\ 4 _ _ ~ __ _ `

Q'\) bep¢$r\x¢m c,)52 \\'\\c,\»\c.\e. _"D¢~J-'\~ <¥c.¢d¢_',cc\`w\c> ::>5¢-¢.--\6ma\,\~é> w,¢;~r\'¢-
__‘\’3 Vc\\vc\:\c_lvwe:b*`c\$¢»+vi` E>e.'\\\»¢.bac$»<¢ o~TW\\¢,W;W\_ ;.‘>~M_¢_W:g;
6§<\¢\¢>¢\ 6¢0\:\~`»»'\:3 §\~o`:\-¢.Mo/\"§.§ 0~\0<>/04 O~Qp\‘\c¢v/\\* to -\g\~¢ w~;_¢$§'¢g\,f\4

Q$¥e/n§>c’, 0 ~L E~!\~\~\L,w\§ C'~ C/\'\\\c\. , _ _

la 0.65\\105 D`,v\ ‘~¥'; ama +ke, w¢,\\ A(n$“\~`-,'\-\)A=`Lov\ T\vw,o`?¥`\\_\_co.w\ via»\se.-S quc§'\'\ov\.§ e‘§ _
X_mw ow>é ¥e`c-;\'. w_\m\c\r\ mand_\o§.-._\:e§o\vc¢\ b\{_+.»\e. _er_'l;@§_erlmma\ "
LPQUL’> \o.\i 'R'M fe{o¢é, a\.bn¢ kav\~ rc¢\'uw~c, %omc, Mco~n w_»§ _¥v\. L~n<`uu~~|

cou\>_is\:om:\- w§_\:\\ o~n 6\/.\&6~\'\¢.,»\1.\¢\¢¢»¢\¢\5.
__ m . .

564:\`/_)¢6 \'w»b b¢¢¢\ G`c<,<>w\p\'\swcé b\\ se¢\<\»mao`cop\\ 0~.[' 4\'\\5 iv\$~\~¢~uw»o-\» {'v

"‘c\/\c. §v\\__ow`ms oc<&é\`csz>' C,\/\_¢‘_\b Dc~o_\e,\ - - _` _~__w .__`.

- \*\oq~r`\:> Cou~\~~\ D\S‘r§‘;c*§;\e.c\<,__-_ . ` , _ __ ' -
A++n: mw D\'<,+~'¢+ cov»?<. ,, _- ,_ , __,_, ,_ ___' ` .

P'O. %.o¥ HL»S\ . ` _ `. _ ___
_ \&D¢$:\.-'é>.v.\ ?r> +\/\e,__l c\o-\ o'§ __:_._______W‘L 10)$`. _ _ ,_
, ,` _ _ Rcbpec.‘\'$\.\_\ éub?v\\:\'\‘¢é,

  
     

 

_ - P\\ Lo\.A'\~ \P!`O §§
~ v VLA¢`,\,\\\§) vu\\"
"' ` ‘ "' " “ j " “' chq F N U%L “'