Court Opinion

ID: 4065235
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 21:54:39.741342+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:47.024586
License: Public Domain

wqu '<>/

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Eu\q 28 20\5 § ' _ _ y ' DF©E% \\W//[§D %N
/\_’\\;Ab.e_\_/§\co;w ' @QM QF QR\M\NALAPPEALS
C_[_@.LL$ 0(:\ J(\’\C __COUY`_{’__ 01(: CVlm\/_\o\_( AW@Q\,(_$ OQ T€)(q§ mfg 032015
99 @QX mw Av@m@@§ia,©i@zk___
` AVS)&m','-D< 78.1\`

 

 

}Q€: gx pavlc@ Ben;\am¢"n ~E'|\`c\§;.-
CM_SC No. OHODHZBZ'Q`{B'Q(

 

~ 0€/\1/€ CL€KV\

pl€d§e, gmi QV\C(OSQC£Q }\/0!0`<@ Jco {ovnt 0\@ C[/lcmc,@ 0)[ AO/o/re§§

Q`USC Q\l@ llc 000\/00(1`0$€€(1/
§\40<10( \Jou L\o\v€mw owes%i>nx ornp<’__qa{af:bom( inform/zahn w/@a@@ `

010 m_c)lf \WS(W& er (0#1('0\€+ Wl@ (l+ {'LLQ OIC{)C)W/$`$ LQ(OW WIOW\L< \/0u |`1/\

md\/£MCQ R)F\[mur hm@ UV\U{ COV!SI`GFWOL\(WQM 016 €LUS WIMHW.

tQ€Mch(p\/H\/ '

_g?/v“)Of/W QZM;

g€mmmm HIOIS`

§O 4+‘1071757 ` `
UPQ§<) Co\mh/ We whom Fac/‘/¢ §§ Awne)<

\YSO( (/\/\on\%cmo\ _

lift VG{SO/ T>C.W%@ 1

 

 

 

cp. `- X;`\Q

 

 

 

_ 111 THE
- 001/111 011 0211/1111/11 1222/111
` AusnM,T_E)_rs '
§>< 0002@ genv`\mmm gm

 

11105@_1>10. <170011202_2<13 -01
T 1011 CM», .1/0.@1'10011232
g FQSO 600/127 ,T€XOU

 

1101.10_€ 10 ` 001/01 00 cHA.N@_E_QE__/.\.MES§

 

' 70 THt' HO|\/OM@C€ JW)GFS OP THF COK/KT OF CK(/\/H/\/AL _/41”£1:731££ .`

 

CONFS }\/Ol/\/ §0`1010110111 6210111` pe%)jooner 0002 212202\/£ Q/KP 221/§( A/#/Tce%o
€1010¥€20_0,10 02 /1021110:; IN §020021 1111:1<1;00 222/10102 1011/1010 2110
2201/12 2210 QHOWMQ

 

I,

 

p@212101/10,F:§ 'OWWOQJ 0122112r0,§§ WQA` QS'QQ)HOW$ f

 

_ g€n}amm gm
TY)C’F'IW NO.'YI‘WYY
W(||Ulc\'/ 2/2111'2< l

227q5 § @1/22;120 222
2201\111101102\/122€/_2 TX 785?0

 

222121000¢ 110 on@er render 012 §011`02 002621‘@§§_

 

 

11 010

11

 

\D€Jd’m>naf :1 Cuwe/\'}€ 0101011’€_1_5___~15 1151 121119;/\1_8 ~`

 

 

gemom’\m 1:11<1&
SO 11‘1011757
g 1001§0€0~11114 W€1111111o/1 510111%\1 /11111€)<
12501 /\1\0111'011101 ' `
11 11130"1>< 1101

 

/111@ 011121/11' 001<11*€§1 ' 1`.$ €11;€11`1/@» 1`mmec11`01101\{/.

."4-.
,1;_,

Q(ON_€W

 

 

1/\1111(?1:1(€ pam/1136 CO/\L§W)EQ£W pa1/110n€r1111/m101~// 01’01\11'
111/11 1115 1110110001121@ 1)01101 0101<110w120100 1112 0116111012 0110010111>5& 011/101

 

 

J
1111€11_\101£€1__011.1_\{__11011£?011101/15 0101€f& Of 1601/3515 150 11111»1 011 1115 CUf)/€M' -
011111@§§ ` ` - '

 

 

Qec,00011\v1_1v jT

‘é gemm/mm an
16€11`1011111\11 gle
301 11 101/757

 

 

v 1'1 1111$0 1131/1111 11€1€111101/1 01C1111'\[1 /1111’121<

 

12501/111111111101
01 2111/11 1112

 

 

 

 

 

 

21131

CE T\F|CATF O` §€Q C

 

 

if @€vf\ownm E1ias,_€e_1)_"1)oner 112¢@17~[/ Cer1'¢`1:1 111011'@ 113/6 011/101 CO_G:ec{-

 

CO\M 01C 1115 1117__Q\(_@_ OL\(_\O1___1~`0F?_QO¢\/)O) 1\101¢`(€ 10 Co\/H" 0101€1'1011/&_ 010 AO_UV€S&____________

 

 

 

 

\/\01§ been PoFWMvJeJ 1)\/ 113 /\1101.1 wee _po&_&@ e__pw@1,_10rs1__c1a§§_mou1,_10_._._______

 

TOW\ 1101\%0101,@1 Va:o_ CO_c/nlr\/ 91$1\0¢1 AHOme\/s 011;¢€ A}OF@ 11_1/1_1_€ U¢`\/)s_¢`_v__w
§11)€45`0@01/111\/ Co_(QS___H Pa§o Co\,in_lw COL/r{“1_qod$e §OO E. gm Av\10m10 1':1 1142£0 T)( '
'1‘11101 0v1 ¥111$11/1@ 2311/1 01%\4 01 11v 2015

 

g€A/~\d/ww&\ UO\@

 

 

 

\Qe…mmm E\my

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

\;@Ml