Court Opinion

ID: 4055334
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 06:58:34.141626+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:27:25.842220
License: Public Domain

~e ~     PU-G+(--~
                                                 M~hl'cM. k Wf't+- ct- fi1tU\J~~
 \ko-t t.;\u\Lo~ ~t ,
      b \(\ c1 ~~~ \s          1/\A.'i   ~ fU ~-e.   rt-4-- J#~{{3 (   W'-ff ~to-n   ~
v.s \ ~ ~ c~ AcM\lo--w-t~\           ,   ~~Q__(Ltf'-~ r-e.( i e-lL ~ o         rcVUJ v'ctJ'c¥)

~" ~~ \tt~i1"-<;~{L(('c< ~~tcW CCM.K't r aJ~ /vLs b~en
~ t\ W-u-t~ ~ ~\k_€ [Uf\.1 ~(aj coR'f b-t u.s.P, ~,
         \>\~~<;e ~ )c_uJ CL\t'-J ~roce~~ ~f- J!w at- dec2~DI\J
  ~ e,ofu.£     J- !-- f Je.t'-'f o.. 1\ ~ M t-e_s/bnsz 1-d
 f¥v~ ~~,    l( ~ N\ olue-4\U                                         W     l{cJ&vV

 ~\~te_ ~1 (g(\<;~-vo)-~ . '
  · ··                                                ··. ··-----~;nuuJ1,            ·._ .

                                                                 J~!f1
           RECE\         .   D \N     RECEIVED IN                _.,-
                                                                      ~  f2
         I)O\ll'lt OF C IIIIAt ~ COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS        ( fNA(    ~
                    111
                          ~
                              15
               lA                             MAY 20 2015              ~Jbse.J
                                            Abet Acosta, Clerk
                            Cn.u.._~-e         /UCJ :     l d--l~- 60Ll6 ~ ._c_((_
                            -rr'o...~ LOLL~~ AJo ~ t=LLl'tCD d-d-oe>1

              ~tJ ~~ u~M~CJ1 b~ a~ Mr-ecJ~
                                     o   t- ~StM                   \f.)la.<)

  . . . v-
s~~a~-r~s
  (i~s~~\:-)                                              ~
                                                          ~
              Qe-v~~e_,s Aa~~ ~ w,~t 4'~ ~~s
       V5 ~ ~d\LAAL'E :fu...Q&fL$) ,_'
·r~-~         AI ow   ,   -rr- ~ex       ~ ~ "~- 6~-*- L~ :s (.Q'b ;;-Lf .,           C»()   'lll'\ cu.x-   c/Lt'?J..-~)
c)~~u             (.\_\ )    s+~~·v; Q't\~t               r) ..   36t_W fM 35{Lt        r Becu.Ltv'\~\ n.
'1.'"116b"-/{p35      c    P~~~4, \.\~~., ~~e o~ ~~~                                                    . {t,     he
Mti\~S~~ ~\\. ~~be_ ~                                     ~           (f-)-e;   u~r r-e.\1'1'-J..c(_~ ~t'-
 lcfu~e      -\-a ~ ~M ,                                                                         ··

             ?t~0~< ,c:;.ttlLs q\f~~u ~J_ r~\0& -C-\Z1W\ hts
-h-rJ. Ceu.xb ~,\·~C\lj DJ;-             0..   Al \Uf'L    ~ \o ~c.. ~ &A 1~-1<;;-07,
}A(--~~\,~ ,          wes:,M-\:- ~"-~~-e! ~ M~tCoe_) 8 f ~e Prnce.JJA-9;
N ~ tDllc, \\.(<; Coo-\-\- 0-.?Pd ~j aJtM C\ e'f , AC Ct e(l{ cJjwe.) I;· AI()'f

\).lcl!l, \ ~ ~<; btll<K~~+ o~ U l t(llt'tj "3~-~S .f-a-c-t - {( fccr);: /1v fs r?lrV ;
                                                    -l)
. \}.__~~\ S'-t-e.av,:> Q~w ,-tk                        W          -~" \le__ceJ'"'o~ ;~ld- vJh.:lf
 &<\ ·      ~ fo.cLDl\,~{_t\                 t ~ f'- ~~~ u~ Lle tl¥= ( l CAA- whu'-c- ~ Pa~h+
                                       /\A\t\·J

 t.....    \-~Q._     "'-'Ls   \1\ ~ t. · \.-:\~ / re Csi!J.:;       G~"l.J C s ee
                                                                            (_,li)__c,

  ~~\N\..~ ~(\'L ~ ''-(-"~.e -S\\:~s 't                      :J   11       r~~~+-OM.~, ., ~                      t()'cJ

   a~ MOL~\~\ t \\..~~~ ; \) ~ /[ cD1 be_CQ.A.L(. L dt ~~<;
   \)~~~ akl~ o---J. ) d-)~ 'fl-CJ-s-4 ~~ -/-tN'-e ba-rreJ_
                                     ~e s ?(}'{J QE N <TS
          -svJ ~e_(fl.~ be_\\ Co'\_1L ; t4-s#'c;v.-P4 O'o< :rulj'et_"(),J c~
          tot w ~ f"\c,._o'\\ s {- . ,~ a-9-o , Af o.w«3M~ ,~ 7rrr b l .,
           M\. k\L 1k\e.r--~~CJ-D;v-~c-i-ov-

                                    \=' ~TS         ~ Lk76

          ~~~~~tN .__~~-- ~~~cxJ,G?t3"--e} ~ \)\~ \>D..I\1"'-~ s-d--o"7,
     -, ~    ~ ~., ~ ~0v\. CDU-\ \- ~ ~.                      f' Uo--\ft\~ o.)-J-tf\f'\                 o.JN~ a<;(~5-
      ~~ o-~ ~U--Dt/;kM-vtJ+- ~ ~<tf'cAVol-e.J ~bbu-t' ~ ~ ~.wve_
     9-0     't tJM·.:;   CO!\~'1-t~tv\~ ~" TD CJ" - Gew- a                              .C trs .f- o( ~, tre.    (}__    /an'-!.
    /f\.t, (h~ \~~ ~~ ~ ~ <?»BJ-oJ~ o-~ ~ ~klr-e. ~
  ~tts           WQ..-\f       g   ~~ /lA~ 1rJ          I   9-oo(      r    U-e    {J..Ja....)   Q_fl}-e-r-ecA \1\_/-e;
  ~c'5 ~ '3'~t, ?-oe>1                      (J    A-+   wl~ -\-~-e ~~ b-t_~uY' ~~> r'n-
     ~~~                   ttsa.\   f.Q_s~ci..- VJ\~ul- JJo.\-~d~ ~ -1-t-L~J
      c_ov.-{~ "~~\.~ .\-o ~~""' ~~~\) ~ h~~ iAl&,v~ )·a~ f/t.e
                                                   ~)
. N.~t          \>(o    ~ \>i'e>c_~~J...~~ ~ \o-\~-07., 1\)C-:J-~~s
 ~a_s~'~ ('~~ ~\-~t t;"'-\tcur~ Q~                                  ll\ o~t~·            t\r-e._w
 (}o{d- t.. <;e_( \o\~ Ct:\.e_; - \_'\\T\1--e. -S\~P4 J A\t . . b~~) ~'t           I                                  w
 U\.kr-e. ~e\~e,~                OJ'         ~ \l"~\-e.J. ~~s ~ocW C:Q.nJJt~~
  -\-e)     ~\\1\ ~ u_){\_ cc~e..    f.>.J   ~~ .~~ c:_,          *'"- ~~    Coo--("     t.    H-e   w-os,   N   a+
  a_C(o~·~ b)~~ cJ\ ~-t ~\e1-e_ ~ AJtL~s~-t dotlU.-~
   o..S Qoc       ~~~, ,~~-ts ~ \\..e --tt~·ol                                   COt-t.rt- ~~~-c.J set<~
   dow..e..N\.~ (A!. Gt.            \f\1\-u...dA   \o.-kc          l ~\~~ ~-.t Pu~~4~~ ~;::-AI\
  \t &-~\.z ~'\::'5 ~~~ls~~ tMJ~~l~\t: ~L~<)<.~: P~f-lt~
                 A\t.,o ,   Mr\, ~Sb~" k.~ be~~ \(""'-~ kJ 0-f\..J r-e.sfr :d-e_/
  ~ \€.%J.. \ts~~ w~0~ <-                           l'f'.       H-~'ih S~tJrJk /AJW'--L'N-~fnJ-Jv.e.
  S~t~~~{iM-,
          l~ ~Q_C, LJ~O{"\ r}VV\, Gn~~~ f 1 ~\r-s+                            .C\hi\.lj       6'~  hJ-s' ~pp/~tc.ltcn
  ~~~ ~· ~ hl~~               CO\ \)v.-S     ~ (\\.o 1      1 \r.-.~c;   i-t-~         c.-c'-4 t o\ ~ Cou--er (j h'"~
  tJt~-el\.,~ o>Mc+l-.J o.~"' o.-~<- vl.~A~~ w~Q.(\ ~vN.
 ""\t....-c_ tt 0J CCV-.-\t- t\s'eX\ .C ~ \ ~ 0. IU \JJJ\-L PY1J ~ ~tArl
  e__~'\~ ~~s ~'~""-~ c_;~-e_s ~ Ndt ~9~~ h~ r-Of\1e
  c~ ~~'6h~~+-- ~~ c.fh.l_s@_& hcs trJ~~ curJ N~ Pll)
  ~«-- aJ\o+~ ~ k uodQ~\{, w~~h tke +rvevl LouJt Jj
   j)C)\:    ~ )'J...\cc;}UC-~~ ~~~f..-i +e )u So .
                                         .AL-t-- r; ~ t4-\ ~ 6'w' s
           \) ~ ~ev\ ~o....x\-      \s       }~ ~'w-                 tA-S(flB ct       JeJ.~ in)..d-vNtd-
                                                     (~)
.       ~.e.:e_~C\:~   0-     CCN'\      u ~d-tlo><\ ~         CJ\'i\ ~4   J    ~ ¥'N>s+ e.-s4ed-4J ef QMJ
    .   ~ · ~ .:;~~~                          ~~ o~ lf!Lft ~~ CoJ -e ~ dL{.. o1. 7k
                                           \>fCJ\)

        ~{\f\.\:_S4?~ \C,          o..   ~~~cto\ ~~C~ teN\ ~ IJ'o.\- 0-- ct~~~ ecJ e.~t·ro\~
         d.\ ~ ~~ CO~~ tS t'f'.. t t \0\ \Jb~ f\9 o..                                  .JJ UJ!\. L   prn ~c..        oJ.tr
        ~ ~~ 0... ~~~~~\ ~(j\( j
          ·~)    k<   ~~ c_~\- r~ \~                 -u-\D<"        k       ~~~cr ~                        t.Utu\c   PU1
        k_~ \>\Cl~~ D-~~~ o~ ~ ~~sen~t ~ wf~                                                                     t1vt-
        \'~tJLSm.~~ a~ ~w 1
          ~\ ~~ ~c)~w~~-\{ ts ~ ~ ~· ~'-~
        ~---~\\~ ~~C:, ~ \                   U-      ~ k        b..)~~t>J~ ~ h t~ uu:, e.
         'S)     ~~A                ~ ~ ~ ~\( ~ 0\" al t'1 P((}N~tYLS Mia
                              ('o.,u(

    ~ ~"'-'-~c:,                   c~~ Qhl-f\- \t-t'> Ut'M~ ck.Re. ~ ~
    ~. ~ ~~                        c\      ru\:.:el\:~ . ~d-     3C-:J)     aM       ~e ·it:;        +o   c;er(Fe_ Ne
        \~sl, ~ <;;6~6 ~~ ~~ c;QX\.~Ge ~
          fJ.}~ (J (Ou,(.\- wO-S <J l\J-t" ~~t cz,~ oPPor~J+-'-1 +o
    t-ee*-~ ~'-t ~ l Q_,CjcJ \\.Jf\1\.Q.cll( 11\ 0--(Cord.CLAc.e k /-€_AA Grfltlk'A}
    Cii&_{_ ~ ~loLeJ.u__re_ L--c-: (_ e__ f ! lJ . OlJ s-kf£-Lkal- /t~!ktlrrwc.
    \~~~ ~ b·~ ~fQ_(,~w                                        UJ   rfi~ ~v~ (~Jf- tLIJ\J.. UlJcff--
        oJ.l. .«w~~,CL\1 .C~:uQ_ 'l{l~< ~ ~ ,Ak ot~ &MkvLi<;sk:NJ
        of-fu o.C-~e_ \ A-)~~ /rvhk1( ·~~e_fert_j fu-#-cJ
        ~<~ ~s              vCJo   ~~~~~a~ ~ \~JJtxl- r~i-J~ ~ ~(uxe_
        ~ ~uctc,~ ~+\~                       ~ZW

                                         ~A-ets      .It-NO     ~CL~~(t'U/ ~                         G/hJ
        ~~ \ Ll~ s~ ~ "3~~~ Cou..\~                                        L:}f{'\!-4--J   /'A ~ Jeq;tc'NtNt
                                                        (4)
  ~~<3~~"' D~~e.. ~~~~~tLk ~~"~s-t.« cv \,'e__'Lk\br~tt
   ()~ o._ d.~~<{\).)~(}(\ 1"-"'v~ ~ ~dw\-~ J)(f,ol(,lhl( oJ
. c\e.~c\:.M. •"4=-\- O'l\\ '1 LeX\ ~tl\.S ~ ~ ,;,.~ ~ Jl; ~
  cA U\Lt\ ~~ Mt. ~~hu-<.{ l a_ ~ dt]O ol~f'U'_i
  . , \'--~~. ~J_ ~~ ~ ~ JJ()\~ l'1\ ~- (~ ~+- ('af\{fA'-
 ~t~"\v\ ~4 e*· ~~e.-r~ ~ w:~ lv\.~                  1-e   O'b~   cKM._a..h\-
 ~~ OX\~\ ~.c c;o-..t~ <?~-k, ~~*-~~l'l               1    ~w.\\0f~JM-
 ~dLl~C;G~1. c._C\.U-~ ~~~~ ~\v-..t"{    tt-t   t/            •

        ~~e_ ~0-~\      LchS\-    ~~c_ove__«.J ~~ ~Qkduve_\'\~~
 ~~ \>'(.~:,R.~i t~\\r'-'1         ot   ~'-5 ~~~ ~(L()l cAf;f(c-~~ ~
 ~L()..,s ~~~s ~ 4CJlkP,t J¢, ~£. -rle +r~aJ couff--tJ!eJ
 0.. l\.~ Q1u ~t ()\~~<:       /0-) c;-o7 0~~ k1 t_ ~Jc; ~
 ~~ CDu..f~--~ffb~\-u} cub~iS 1 ·fre~e_ 1~ll~ 5fa.:k.
 S'Yl ~.LO -~ ~~{, YJ1b ~ k( V1 V~ s,f-eJ--e_ l {g_g(g 9,fJJ.dJ ~7~~~
 JL~~~~ u _~..L'1ks i 70~ S~Lv. ;;J 41~. tl-e or®,)\cJ~-J9-
Q~\. UHtJ; ct Julbt}l\_\ dkes~~ <U:\t £A cJJL\['/(A/ eJffC){I·
::f6\."'~ \l,~~~ d-~~ SeW. ?Jd L{J.o~ ?~4-~1 dae£ Nof
~u._Q_ ~\.       Ovf\~~~~ J_~~'f uJ~I\ f~~'R~ WO-S3 JJJ
~ "'-~ c~AurA~U\te. ~~ ~ *'e 4-T J<J Cot4-l- r.etz,CA/Yrel ..J~JdutJ
~Cl~~'i ~ ~~~'N\ol~ {-e, 0~-(_ \rU-5 C('~~t C,~t
~ ~,. ~~~. -k ~~~--1 w ~~ ~~;'r\1 ~\5 rni\~ t J.
 ~:~\~~ ()J.,. ·~ ~ ~J~q,e_. e_ 0~ tk. 0~~-e. ~~-Cf?
~ l~, -~ d u~Ot- Q~ Cab e CLDJ ;;_., d-eJ '-tf~~ v-r-t A- ft)1cul (J e~
cg \~?:>~ ~~ G ~ rtl'!ui!i'-~           o*0wl1t-\~t w C!5se_g       m
~~~~ ~\: ~ <;Qj\~~ ~-tO--\~-
                                 (s).
                                  ~ C-L--lA-S ( orJ
     -~~ k ~ol cms-t-                        ·w     10-o    ~~~ ~s ~td-c·d'0J ~ Jh
 ..\-6    U--SL    tt   vo~~~t '"'~t~~t                       {e COAvJ'cJ-        1   Ar,~~~.,--or
  ~ ~hu "'-.~ ~                   Q('   (~~ ..\- ~ ~ \ ~ b-<3et.X\         th> f ()-(\_I-tt ro7~     bY
 o~(.~~ ~ ~\{_~~a-t~ dc__~\'f ~ovpe4\ ~J ~. +r ro)
 ~\- "-<l \0c .J~~'fc;~td-~ ~ ~o\.~ <l_ t\~t. Pro ~ N~
 *a~~· ex ~~~ocJoi ~~1'-or, Ar, ~~ket\'\r;w~~ jjr}t {A~J
  ~ ~~~~~ ~~ Q ~\~ ~0-{)"!\                                   \*
                                                  ~e Tc; e:ri'u--LV\.. ~
  \f'<\-~1\U.l.V'l' ~~ --6 <?u \)-{_ 'lt\ rcnr.~\fJ\. en* o~ ~c=r k
  df) '\ ~\,-.( L? .

                              Qrcv{Q-(         o.-vJ ~t{ Ce__ ~
         ~~z~~ ;CJL~k-~ ~ ~\0-14 ~ ~\~e_.f. .;~~
 C' od \:       ~~iR c; l1J ~C~ c;c;o..\i ~            rtV~Jfs e... · ().,if\~   {'{W..AcuJ        k_ lJS
 Se-(\~-e.. c~0 ~{-~ bo..cJL:.. i6 tM C)(~ ~h.J 4t-~ctJ. ~f­
  ~v-      D.     t-.Q_~Q.t\.k\\.LL(tq    "-tD-1 ~_1    ~ CA.ttt-j dt~~-
                                                                 {e       U'CA.£.o.-k
  ~c; s~1<u\ce. btla.AJJ; e_ tke_ c:.c.e,..,U-e e>~ \ c~~ ~ ( Nt:J
  ~~~~ ~ ~ rL~~t--\-tJ -re,cp ird.<-tJf ~
                           Cer +- t +-o c_ct--k crt ~uJ c'e --e
     A-    ~£ ~~ ~ct:- C&i ot-~0 N!otibv\ Jex                                           w   r.a- a.{l
N\~ -\\'-t           D~ ~ ~\-J ~~~~ r6~fcJ S.~l\ht JLS j
                         \)._st

·~', ~ ~~b-v~e_~ ~ ~'{ 14~ Sufu}« -:twlciuJ ~f-)
tD \ L}\ • ~~ s{ ~ ~IN'- ifJ-6 J u{) cAL~ocJ~.e > I'& , [ ~ Cet ~. h  1

~ u~~ol ~ *- 25~· ~(jk_oJ s ) ;Je 1 v, t lf1VI ~~~ J ~. o~~
                              (Co) .                              ----
{d-?6<i5 c_~~~ 0W-~           I   ~~ J T~ . [t:g7 O/"

        f~ecLL+.-eJ {;ll(\J   r.ec;Pe.c+.-k/1 '{ GuhM r.Ud bi   fV..--C'

(j(\   ~ '<S   .      JGV1    o~   AA tvt   1   J-ots-.

                                    J»1~A~