Court Opinion

ID: 4056720
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:06:46.020328+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:06.049390
License: Public Domain

. NoiC- 396- -oiasi'z).- 1109395- A
¢_LAR-¢Y.To§ moxGA_iv ' iiv 'ri_i§ 396 Tii `SubiciAL '
» V. DiS‘Titic."T C.ouizT oF

/' 57AT& CF TE.XAS TA&-RAN‘T cso.uivT)’ 7 EXAJ

931 1131'@'35*

RECEJ J`VED tN
cQURT oF cR.'.s,/HNAL APPEALS

/i SEP .2 9 2915

 
  
 

   

 
 

?OBT§c‘I'ioiv 70 Di.sTizicT AT'Toi\iv§Y.‘s Pkc>i‘?.ts‘.$'/E;ldg 0,7._5457§4)445~4>0771,
SF'iivbiNt.-'»S oF Fisc.7 AND CONCLuS/aivs oFL`A\i\/.

linlRY oiv PR§c:ée/ivs bacum§~TsiA~o moTiaiv.¢ mA/L§_a 76
CLER!< .Siivc£ A.S$E&Tioiv oF H/5 /li07i LUIToF/MB§A: 6okPuSi

 

 

 

 

"'Tci 7HE 7770.sT Ho~oieisiu§ Tuoe§ oF .Sisio CauirT. , .
LisizRY 564 moiz6isiv, il§iz§iivisrr§ie 6is4`4`§.6 P4i1iiv7'iFi=, misk§.s /<'iv¢i..iiv

' T-o TH& 60"¢.)¢.7 771/17 H§ 15 /44§6A44Y R§5T4isiiv§a iiv 405 4/6§§7'¥ BY
371771§$ Ai 4Yivisi.i6/-7 u~iT,isiva Tii'§ 7§xis5 l.>£PAizT/n§ivf oF`
coAr'cécTioiv is7' FoiéT jToctc‘ra~ "T§i¢is: 564§4¥ uivaeie' i_sivA BY
ViATu§ oF is Tuo6m§iv7,isiva 5§~7§~¢:§ 6is'i.~is§ ivumB§/?
I14I93950 STYLEL> Th'§ STisT§ oF 7§xis: V, 4.isieizY .To§ Moizsisiv
Sisio Tuoc»m§iv'?'.

4 6 ames ivow, 'Lisizf`izi‘r' '3’¢§ Maéca~, P4i1i~7'iFF Pieo_$§ iiv ‘rii§ ABov§
ivi.imB£R£D 6isu5§, is"iva iiv~- oPi>osi‘)?oiv oF 7_'//§ Di`. M§Maici¢ivoi.im Fiivoiivcs$ oF FA¢Y,ANA

` 60`~6465ioiv5 div 4isi£i idisT-§i> .S`§PT§mB§ie /'7, 2,0_/_5": P4i¢iiv7'iFF
.SPéciFicALLY OBB'§c.T Foie Ti¢is Fol.`4awiiv6 K£A.So_iv:

 

° PLAi~TiFF misiL§o is moriaiv 063'§¢77~§ iiv Pisi.i: oF 5741'§:
EESPo~_S§ 76 /’4isiiv7iFF_ APPucisT/aiv Fot¢. weil oF /Ma§is.$ 602905 div air
si¢-is-,.‘z_ois" wire iviil k§/'4Y ,
’ in 47 33 aoix'" PLisi~'riFF misil.§a Tuvo md't'ioivs oiv§ i€§qu§.sTii~ic 70
`_;_R£$o¢.v§. besieivn‘riiv6 /550§$ Aivo i_4_ maTioivy Foie B§~¢H WAA&AN'T
wlTH ivd tZ§PLVi ,. __ :§ - s:» 4. .. 4 4,1, 5
1 ‘ 0~ 5- ?~‘-i lois" PLisiivTiFF misi/.§i> is 7i~ iiv oPPosiiioi\Q"§
741 B vvisL/c§& AFFioisviT wiTH iva Acitivai.v¢.§¢_>c»m§~TiGY Tis'§’ ST'Z§ `

__LELLERGE~ R $coTT v\/ALIT.S bocume~Ts, STATé-

ME~T$,PHoToGRAPl-IS AFTER F11vAL. £a~vam~,u/rr/-/ 1410 AcK~ou.)-
LEbC,me~T Flzom ‘TH& STAT£, on Tl-/€ toun.T _

‘ 0N é° 17»~ °2.015" PLAi~TnFF mmL&o 14 14170710~ To B£ ££LEAS£ /3Y
PE&$Q~AL. E£(.oemzA~cé 11.)1T1-l 1~10 A;.é:wo¢,).Ls¢§G»mé/~/T hamm TH&
$T_AT& ow. TH& 601.112.7.

° 011 ‘? f/- 1015 P¢.'./w~T/FF mmL£/a 14 1°/11:1'101\1 7’¢ 1°£131°05.513
_ F`1~r;>11\16 QF FA¢.T.S A~¢.> 60~61.,1.1510)~1.$ oF /_Au) 111/1711 141¢. Ac¢r~o.w‘»
Lzbc»me~f F)aom TH& 5714 re 011 7'1115 ca11/473 ‘

» 6267'11~1214~4£ A&£aazr;é.u_z:a_aa_e_.&gz’

01 60¢1~.$&¢. FA/{,we.é 713 Pze.$é~'f ’7"146 L`)L»Féa/s£- oF $éLFoéFe~'sé,
b. éQuNSEL FAILuF'.& '/"c> 50/"1"06/114 TH£- Q/.' £ALL&K.’;

c cou~.seL le.wu;= 7b 5661>0£~14 714£ A/¢Kz.s'n~z: QFF14e1c ;

d fdu~$é£. FA1Lu1:E To Pfc'e$£~/ Plt,'/'unss DuRlNG 774th THAT
woul..b 600~7'&£ .STATE‘.S' Vlc.'f/M 765T1mo~Y,-"

6 601/~56£. _P'A/Lu/Lé 7`0 A/,dm/T 7'/-/£ 0/£/61~14£.190!.1¢& KEPCR.T
_A~13 11..>11“1~1&53 57‘117'£1»4&~7: /1\17'¢:> Evme~ce Ta 111/11>411411 vv17'-
N§S.SE.S 1

'F. __C'm./~ 515/__ FA/L='.)RE “7’0 /M&~T/QN 01)1:11\11;. 7`,<:114¢, 774/147 -TH~'?
ST14'TE.'5 \/1¢.7`1111: 1.1/14$ ¢uT 14¢.&05$ TH£ /307'7'0)»1 oF }/15 SHMA¢N,

g COLW.S£~L FAll_. u»?.& 7?3 SL»BPQENA 6141~16 1.)~17 Q_FFM.EE,
$ALAZAI?. TQ .SEE Wl'/Y Hé /BKOK§ PRO'TQ CO( BY N13T 601/416

DNA TE;$TIA¢'& ET£ 011 ETr all
h.' cau~se¢. FA1L1.,11,c- _‘_'ro aequesT wHY 7'14~1;1BL& £\111.>¢'~41:

Lll1$61\11¢3&0,‘
1. dau~.scz. »4~1: /-/1.¢ /~vesms,a'ra)¢ 1./1¢6&13 PL1111~17’1FF ~oT

"11.> f&.s‘T1FY u.)rrHa'uT Abw.s/~s 1-/11111 7’1/1\7' 145 wouz.o L,ase
H1s 5&¢F»¢56Fe~se lhéFe~se 1F /41.c /.>113~‘7" T&sT/FY,‘
J c.m)~s¢l. Asswze-o PLA/~'nFF 711117' 1 F 116 1310 ~4'1' T&:WFY

__HE. u..:ouLL\ 136 Fou~l> NbT GulL.‘FY" t
k Cc;')u~$él. FA1Lu1c& 'To 1~v£3776n76 '7'1'-/£’ o/-'F&~sé P.!cw/€ To ` »
TMAL.‘
gEmEz"6Z/T1_Z¢ 3101/ou isn 411ng Moaba~ lt F'¢S¢ §

  

   
  

      

 

 

 

l Zou~.sez. F'A/szs 7a //_de~T/FY 'TH& c7// cause ~ero_ue/-/
H&R P/'/o/v& NUME_>E»€ P/€lO/Z. T_¢> T/e/§L' _

m. cou~$EL FA/Lun£ ‘To /NTERVIEW 'T/-/E ‘7// CAZ.LEK'

Na LauNSEL F'AcLuz& °'To .C)BTAH\/ PLA)NTH:F Ll$T OF &o~`FAcT.S'

A~o -51M CA.e/> F/aom 'PLA/~T/FF'$ P/a/oz cawv$é¢ Ho/v. U'Amé$

$HAuJ' AND
0. dou~séL FA/Luze 70 cALL cHA/eA¢Te/z W/T~ess£-._S 0/v

P_Lm~'T/FF'.$ /Z>EHALF.
lf/No/~c=s ol-' FA¢T /.Z>Y 57’.4')'5 lmc.Lu¢>/~c, SPecm/..

_ ‘T/cA\/E;&SE /SY P£A/~T/FF
1.'5£`& PAC-.E ‘0~& 'F`ok lI’uoC»mE/v'/' cF HE£E./A) Mo"/"/o~ .

'l. "/`H£ S£~\/ENT/-/ Cou/?,T oF APPéA/..S A`FF//tm£o PLA/~T/FF$'
CaNVlcT/o~ oN juu`& ‘/ 20/'~/¢ Fu/zTH&/ZMQ)¢E,THE 6001¢.7, /A/L\
NQT ama cawPL&-re F/./.'as vye/zermze,/~>Am-r/FF cou./_/.~> ~a~r
ida AN EFF&¢T/ve A~/.>e)es B&/&F PLA/~T/FF /<£Ce)veo o~£.\`r
F_/Les 7c 1455/57 7H& dou~TY. PLA/~T/FF P/ac~se~reo 70 714£»
APPEA£_$ Coue'_'/' u_)o)zos u_)As m.ssn\.c= A~z> ALT€£ w,T/-/ ~o
Ac.k~¢wce_oeme~r.s /3Y 7’1/£ coweT of A/>»>en¢s.

[NEFF§¢T/-vé A.Ss/.STA~_¢_& oF T/zml_ Cou~$éLo/zx

31 HQN.IZ Sc.07 7 WALI<£-L AND //o~//Bz/A~ /(. WAL/<&/c IZEP£E"
55~7&0 PLA/~T/FF own/va THE 7/z1n1_ P/coceeo/~es 555 Sch-.ME~T;
R u_)AL/Av/T P. l; 13 WAL/ce/z_ AFF,koT P .1.,° A/_so
.SE& PLA:~TIFF TKAvezse$ moT/o~s ,A~/> '7,cA\/e/c.ses AFF/onv/T.s,
DAT`&§ 5»2'-1- zo/s", é- 2.'-/ --zo/s",`(, / zo/$`, map 6-/0-'2.0/:"7‘14»7
PLm~T1FF mA/L&/>` ~ro ")'HE C/~e. 17'.5 W,TN&.<.$L-s AB<>QT Q`ue>T,o»\/: 7/-/)¢7’ /.>o A/¢>'r flu/17
71~/&1:1 C,L/e~‘r.s' cnses Be'cAuse 7'#5‘1’ /.§o N£~¢710~5 SEE /5 lA/AL/<_e/a
AFF//>AWT P ll' R \A/AL/<é& /_4FF115AV)T P.'?' Fu/zT/-/E£mo)a£ lF'
"/`Hé D&Fe~se `oF SELF oeFe~s€, ‘7'11£ Le»u:>/A,¢ C`puz.=s.‘r/o~s wouz./A
HAve Hw¢T 'THe$TATe's cns.r.-_, ALso 01336¢_71~@ wound move
'P/ze§ek.v£- 141_1. 57a-rats £o~F¢_/¢r/~c, 7257»10~/§5 Al.so S£-é
PLA/~T/FF: TKAVE£S&: mo770~$, A/wd AFF//_d`)¢v)7: T/-/AT $//oul_a 136

o ~ F 1 LE T/-/A rs L>~A Te s //£ze//_u . w

E'mé-»Z:Ge~cY_ 'Mor/o-u Fo__)< A~Amzv mo»e.c,A~ _ - past ;_

 

  

5 PLAW'T:FF Nevea 701.1> //0~ /5 \1\/141../<€1: 711/17 //E //Ao
7`;,,1\16\/1:-/< me'f 14~>' oF Th'é W/T/ve:se.s. SEE B WAL/Av1'F*,/»_Ev
P 7./1\1 R&_§Polv$E PLA/~T/FF fif$&/cT 7'/-/)17' H& dou/_Z> 1\1_07'
7211. 15 waL/ 70'
TA/<é THE 5714~1> 3 V\/A(.KE/?. /-/Ao ALRCADY H/SANDON PLA/~WFF’.$
'c;As&,' $E'E PLA-1~71FF3' T/€Avées£ MoT/o/v,/\M.) T/eA\/eks& AFF-'

IDnvlT, o~ F//.E. , »’ ‘
§ Ho~. R .Sc.orf WALK&K wA5 A/>Po/~TE¢> 0~ or'< A/$ouT //'2/-
‘9`012_ 515£ 12 WALI<&& AFF//>Am‘r, P.l,' 556 141.$0 PLA/~T/FF
`Tznver¢~5:_ 70 /Z wAL/an.
7./401~11/215¢077 1510 1\107' P/ZE.SC‘~T 14 SGLF~ L‘.\é/‘é~sé fime
Becnusc- 1~/& Ca~c.z.uoeo 711/117 511¢1'/14 DeFé~.se WA$ co~7/er‘f
`7'0 TF/£ PHYS/cAL E‘WDe/vcé 5£~£/€ WA/.K&£ AFF/onv/T,P.l //\/
E&$Po~sz': `To ‘# 7 HL¢O/a/.>/~c 70 7//£ 7121/m 1€&'¢¢><1>5 141\1'1> PL»/~T/FF
5 ~ov'es '1'/»/5 A£sove 5711_7€11415~7 /.s 14 domf>;er£ FAA.:£ Hom>.
Fu/;TH&/cmoce:,$£é PA.H/~’r/FF T/z/?ve/€$E /7407/01\1 A~o 7/214\/&£.$£
. AFF//>nw.'l]o~`F/LE /1\1 /e&.s/>¢>~s¢ 70 121 1;1/14/_1€&/2 AFF/oAW‘/".
§. Ho»\/./?1.Sco7'7' WAL/<,£'£ Co~¢£u¢£o T//AT PLA/~DFF’.S VéRSlou
~ oF THE Eve~T: '7//117.1¢/5 us£.o 7//£ 5//££7 ,€ock k~/F£ 7a
1NFL.1/_T THE /Nj`u/zl£.$ WA$ //vco~.$lsT£A/T W/‘TH 71-/£ Evu>&`uc&
"THAT 71-/£ l~`.`)"ua"/és‘ weac 1~/-'1.1`¢7£1> BY 14 mac/1 Ln/¢GER
' 1<~1FE L/ke 14 /1//14¢1/& 76 555 /2. WA¢/te/e AFF11>1»\11712 / 2_;
['41<1& 117-1837 //v zes/>Q~se' 101111~7117 14:5&111 711/1175

` FALSE- Hooz> 5 55 P£A/~T/FFZ$ ‘7'/<11\/&1:$5 11707'10~ A~/'> WcAve/ese
rAFF1bAv/T o~ F1LE .

61 Ho~./€ ScoTT WAL/ ma 102» 11_'1 11\1;1€&51><>~5& seg.PzA/~T/FF newest
mar/o~,A/vo ///s AFF/oAv/T o~ F/LE. F'u/z.TH&/zmo/zé 111171¢/¢

007 'D~A '7&571~6 /-/011,1 cou'z_/> '/a,s.wAL/<é/z cows 711 71117'
l 401\1511.15101\1,14~1> $AY THAT.s 711/141. 57‘/:117’156‘1’

10 /-/o/u,R. .Sc.a‘/’T WAL/(£/a 14/.>\/1.$£/.> PLA11\177FF /\107 7a T&sl/FY
A~c> D&v&LoP 14 SéLF DéFe/vs_é béF&~.<:'= /.3€-¢14¢15.§ 71/£ ‘Té§/-
mo~Y woul_l.'> N£E>AT£ ALL 77/£ TésT/mo~Y `T/-/AT PLA/~T/F/-'

,_Inv17 P 2.;FL111.71/ee_mozc- 555 1°1_1111\17'171="5

 

EM&_'&G&~€Y mono~ Fo,a 414ng Mo)¢c,n~ ` Page, 9

`7'£1‘\ VEKSE /)707'/0/~1,141\11> .AFF//.>nv/‘/’ O/v F/[.E //\1 /€é:$Po/v.SE-7`o:,.;,,:.
R,ScoTT WAL/’ beFe~se.T//AT cowan /3€ usaa $u¢ce-
ss Fu¢.l.‘r_ 115 THE E\//o£-~c& STo'o'o.

111 /-/o~./Z..S¢_aTT WALI<é/z's ld£c/.s/o~ To /\107’ P£E$&~T T/-/E

SELF-/JEFENSE DeF'e~_sE WA: 7/-/£ /ZESuz_T 0F'/Z£-/450~A5Lé
‘T£/AL 571:`14 TEGY,’IN RESPQ~SE 7a 711/5 STA 7Eme~T` PLA/~T/ FF 15 /1\1
OPPoslwo~,T/-/£ o~LY‘.Succ.e.S_SFuL 051-’51\155 was SELF-bE/?»~se
As 7`1/£ £\/10£~¢5 570¢1.> 1 F'uRTHé/amo/a£, //\1 PLA/NT/FF3 1115/lema
-o~ /-/15 moT/o/v Fo/a 14 A/£W 'T&/AL /C».S¢QTT v\/AL/c£-P_'s lNV&$-
T/GATQ/e. 75571/-`/£/> 514/6 010 1107 /.>o 141\1\/ /1\1\/5.57/:114711\15 a~
P/.m~‘r/FF'_$ Be//A¢.F, 514; 571751> _$He cnva _sPo/s,/‘|LSQ ///.S Ow~ 1€&£01€0.$,
A~b /-/1..5 AFF/onv/‘T. 141.50 _$Eé P¢A/NT/FF': TMVE/ /-/15 AFP//_>AWT o~ F1Le //\1 .SuPPme.T oF 1"1.1111\1711»'1¢3f /1\1-
EFF£-c.T/v£ A$S/_S7'AA1£E C(_A/n/h £oN$TITuT/oA/AL FL¢:)o)z E§TMBL/s-
_l'/ED /3Y /.du£ PZOCC-.S$ CLAQ$E oF F`ou/aTééNT// AW)END/MENT
R&Quuae:>~ FA//c 710/m 11\1_/1'1411& 7`1€113111\1111. /3£-/=¢1¢,§ 311/see 111/711
No A¢TuAL_ /31AS'A_GA-11v57 DEFe~/:A~T,a/c 11\17£1:£-57._-/1\1 0117»
come oF 1115 10141271¢111.141¢ CAse. U,S,C,/a.co/vsT, Ame~A./_¢/.

C>N fs$c.oTT wALKé/Z.‘.S AFFIDAWT, NOT a/\/E T/m& /.311>' /-/E
l’Y)é~TloN A~V //\'1\/&57'/6147101\/17'/-/6 /_doc_Toz.s 57147£11451\175'111145
/N TH& PoL/c.e s R&Pom's.$éé ZSo~es \/. £YAN 535 F.S/>- ézé/
é¢/é, ~-4/7 .(_4 711 c//;. zoo 4) .Ccou~sez_’.s FA/sze 7'@'1~\/._¢.<,71511’§,
A~c> PRE S£~f m/r/c-.'AT//vc, Evme~ce v\/As P/€é)'w>/c_~u. /3&6»1155
IT GAv£- S&~Te~c,//vc-. ‘.)`¢.mee 11\11\¢<.¢1&147:- V)ew oF /beF.e~/>n~‘ri
Ll-FE). 1 . '
ll. 7141€.1<& 1.s 1\10 E.\///.>e~¢é_ 711/n 7 7/-/1.€ au'rcom£ oF 711£ P/€o#
cé_éohvé wouLL> HAve /3££/\1 D/FFe/ee1\17’ //1)1.> cauN-s_££. P££-'
5£1\'17151> 14 $eLF»oeF¢~se`A`£Fémse, 555 14/>/>1_1¢117?¢1\1';/%511)0-
RAND¢JM. /A1 /€E.S/>a)~/$& 7'0 7"//£ 57/47'&'_5 5774 T£/MEA/T; PLmNT?/"F
ASSE/Z,T 566 P_¢A/~T/Ff's `7'£/4\/1$1€$£ /1407/0~,14~0 /-/1_s 7’1€14\/6,€5£
14FF11>AWT 714/1473 o~ /~'1;5 1~ /ze.sPo~sé 70 1€,$, WALkem/I~A 1
|3. u/ALI,~z AFF/L>Av/ 751 Fu/aTA/é&mo/ A womm\/ -?// LALLe/c DuQ//\,e.‘/'/:/AL~
s`AY/~c,, P/.A/_~v'/FF wm /_>>eé~ ATTAc./ wh/A?’ T//£ A'rrn¢re/c w/ss
wEAa//vc».», /?>éFo/¢E .SHE SA/o L£T F/é,e 6&7`/1£0¢)~¢> 7'/1/& 602/vera
50 TH&Y 6/4~'7 565 //EK, B&Fo/t& 7’//£ /)/Sc. wA.s duToF/.
#?~,THE STHTE_S Vl(_T/w\ 7'0/.0 T/-//d&£-_ b/FFE / TooK 7’/-/£ .57°,4~0 SELF-/.B£_'Fe/vse wouL.o
HA»> Bee~ o~ T/-/£ TA/BL€, A~o /-//5 c@eD//:/L/TY wou¢.o /3/:-
AT STA/<&,
‘”’3 HAD TH& Plc_TuR.& wouL/:» H))ve /.`Seé~ /3/2£$£~7£0 oFT//E
CUT Ac/co$.$ `7"//£ 507'7’0_/)’) oF $7'/97'6$ V/cT/m STomAc_//, /T
wouL/> /-/nve P/€ovE/> w)L/AT PLA/~T/F`F 511/o bmw/va /-//s fe~“/'e~¢-
»I~c, PHA$E ,7'//£ 5707'£‘5 \//c.T/m was ove& /-//m STomPP/Aré
H/w\,'T/-/A/$ wHe~ 771'6 CuTs Acc/Z.ueo. sz.T/-/e/a)v\oze, ///5 514/ce
mcmle Pllov& »T ‘Tc>o_.
tt"/ EA,¢_H oF `/'HE 57»47'&5 w/T~es_ses ‘7’0!.0 Co~/-’z./c_'r/NG .sTm<-
les oF ,wHAT TH&Y SAW. ,
,#S', T/-/E STAT£'_$ ‘\//`c,T/m G/KLFz/s~¢> L/éo,'A/vo sma 5//£ was
SlTT/NC;'Nev'T.To H/m '7/.-/€~ / cnn/15 01/£/€ /_?~/.> 607 /-//m.‘£ATé'/e
lLL)£: HéA/ao /-/&./,¢ `As O/vé "oF 7’/~/£ ?// CAL/.Eé.s' .SAY//ve. $f/€//m.\
TLJST 607 THE/€& Fk`-’.DVM ago/Z.K¢ /€/5¢0'77' L.L//}LKé/Z [a/\/F!';)§;M
'7'///$ 0~.-/-//$ AFF//$Av/T a~ PAC->E"S #S" L/A/é /9~20.
#é,PLA/NT/FF Ass£/¢Ts w/-/Y ibm 7'/-/€ 57'/47"&5 \//.:_T/m c//A~eeo \
SH// A/o CuT.S am 1
/7', - `
C>As£ o~ AL/_ ~r/»/.E /4/50\/£- 7/4~6/5¢_£- fv//Je/vce /vo 2fqu //v 4
‘THEnz l?_:C>HT W\/Na_b wou¢,_lb HA\/e Foo)~/¢> PLA:NT¢FF Gw¢.?"f,
PLA/~T/FF Asse/c?'s 734/rf ,¢/El HA§ dep/es of ///s S/M £A/ea a/v
H/S £Ez.z_. P/-/o/ve,A/vjo F/)q,€/.> Az/\/£- ALSO AL/sf 0/-'/‘//5 aw?`h¢f§,
A~'/b GK:e/~AL /MC~/.>/c_ML ,/€éPo)LTs. 555 Tow~$é~n Vs.Sn/)\/
371 L)S 295 3/‘i %’3 5167 7¢/$" `7'/-/£ $u/"'/CEME fawcT AFF//€_meo
7an /°57'/770~&@5 mu.sT /3£ G/ve~ 7`/1'£ oP/>o/eTu~/TY 'fo '
P/Zé$&~T~ QTHEP_ Tc~s"i’¢rv\o~/AL` A~A ldccume~'TA/z¥ Ev/D&~c&
`R&LE\/A~T Ta ldcs )>uTe¢> lssues 566 /lz.sc> //\/ A/>o/T/Q~ /N HAmss
\/5. / 734/5 /J/s'r/a/¢r 5
.Cc:>u)z_‘f IBEC.lSlo/q ANL> AFF//am£/> 7`/-//47' P/CO .SE PéT/T/oN&/€.S_ l

 

EmE/ZG£~¢Y /’MoT/O/u Fo/¢ ¢.A/az\¥u»vqip,¢g,q~ . ,_.'>a$e G,

ARE. EN T/TLec» 7'<) A~ oPPoRTu~/TY 7°0 oF/-'£’R PRooF” .‘To " _
» SuPPoRT ok I>Ev£» LOP& ALLE c;A‘r¢o~.s' RAISEL> iN ‘THAT HAB£A$-
CORPU$ CLA/m$,

F‘/~ALLY A.s nssa/z'rez> m $A/~ 372. u,s. 316 TH£ .SuP/zem£
..coua’r AFF/Rmeo THAT /F Ev/z>é~ce CRuc/m.. To ‘rHe-ADE-
OuA`TE Ca~$/oé/~:AT/o~ OF TH& Ca~$T/~TuT/o~AL. CLA/m wm
Nc>'r D&vELo`PEo AT TH£ STAT£ /-/EA/z//ve A F'&z>§»eAL. ‘H£A/z`/~c,
rs C.omPELLEA- 'THE W/<:T oF HABEA$ Cc)zP¢/$ is 'rHé
FuNI>AME.NTAL lN.sT/zuma~?' FQR. 5A'Fe' GuA/zb/NC~, m D/v'iz)uAL
F/eeeoom A-eA/~s'r AR/s/r/m/z‘r A~z:» AAw./.ess .STATE Acvm~s.
Dl$cov'éRY IS ES§E~T/AL. To A F'AIR -PRQCéeD/Na. THEA£'$ /vo
HlC-.»HER DuTY oF A Coul<.T ¢J~oE/Z OUK Co/vs°T/TuT/o~nt. 5YST£M
THA~ TH& cAeeFuL P/coc&s.s/~e A~o AB;Tu:>/LAT/a~ oF/°Er/Wo~
3 Fo¢z wm`r oF HA/.`S£-As dom°u$ T//E.SE A$;EAT')o/v A/z& weL¢.
557/13¢./.5/4£0 AY T/-/E U~rr£-z> STATé .Su/-‘REM& couR.T //v /-/Alzm.c
V$ N&L$o~ 394 U,$ 226 F/~ALLY l 5080217"7'5/.> _l_Dlscc>\/&£'Y.r
0~ T/-//$ MoT/o/\/ A$ F'o¢.Low 7'0 T/-/E $TA 75 CQu/a'T ANA
Feo£/z_AL masz /T_/.< A W£LL EsrABL/;H£o FA¢r me
THE u/w're¢> 57’,¢)7¢65' .SuP/zeme could P£Ec§oe~,‘f 'mnr

PRO SE PéT/T/o~€£$ m`u'_$?_’ 55 CS/v£~ THE‘GPPERTuA//Tl£.s’
'To oFF&/e P/aooF 'ro $uPPo'R,T oz bev¢=. Lo'PE '-7’/-/£/2 HA)$F;A:
¢.".LA)m`S /F TF/é .STAT_E 0/£) No‘/" C=lvE TH£ PET/T/oN£/¥. AA/ '

ADQ¢MTE oPPoeTuu/TY l.)'u&//ve .STATE P£O£EEo//vz§ .EsP£c/Au.Y
lFTH& PK.o Sé Pé?’/TzoNE/a E¥E£c/.&¢T¢:-¢> />u_la»e~¢é
ER.A)QN' 5 AA/A/."r£_§____AS RULE.$ EVJD¢

(a) AL./_ ‘7/1 £ALLS oF` T/-/£ Eve~‘/'°.s T/IAT 70a/t PLM¢:E o)v /He'

AFTER A~/> Ev&~/~G oF 9 '~/» zo//. .SPE_c/F/cA/_LY W/E wo-§
mA~ wHoS& DE$c/ cou~'fE`/z THE

STATe'$ W/T~ess£s. 1

(b) Plc‘l'uraés oF $TATES V/c.T/m A~o PLu/~T/FF oF T//e DAY oF
'I’H& Eve~’fs Took PLA¢&. ~

(C) ALL CQNFLI¢’.TINC= 'Té$T/MDN`I&S DuR_/Né» PLH/'NT/FF 7'/{/&£,.-
Cd) ALL_ P/¢Tu)z_&s oF TH& C/a/m§ S`¢;§~e o~ 'F‘He /AAV oF ‘r'/-/E~ Eve~?.s.
£e)_ /‘\l_.l.. `"mm_¢_ Ev/Ae~cé._ ~
(+") AZI PLA/NT/FF ME¢>/¢.AL keco/ao f"k,c>m ZYPS HosP/T'AL..
(gd IP noe/cass QF ‘7//¢»=:.1._.5,0¢ 'ry§ even/73

 

 

 

 

 

L 7 E/}?&Ké£¢ch MaT/o~ FZ)R LA/¢RY"MO¢GAN `; » Fag<, 7

wlTH DEF&Nl)A/~/T WHIT& \/, C-L»o::/N&z.. 30/ F’,ISD 7‘ié‘j PLA/~`TlFF
'C.c)u/~:SEL DIL> /\/oT HHV& C)/ué»lNAL PoL./c& /€ePo)z_T //vv&_$T/-` §
6AT€¢> L/, ‘Z_l.`.) S`S'Z_.f PLA/NT¢FF CouNS£L /)l¢\

ZMEZG€'~C Y Wor/o~ Fa)< /_m<\r mo/Z<> A~

`

-13. # IS’ Tl~/u 73 oF S/A Tz~:'s PRo/>o_seo memo/camoum,
Fl~ol~é,$ oF FAc,T A~o Co~cLus/o/v.s oF Lmu, PLm/~,TJFF
~013>5&¢75.. A$ ‘THr= sTATe' E>E/~c9 Bms A~o Fu/LTHe/cmmLou$ EX£L/Sé$ THE/Zé /5 _
No uJA`l' ARD\.)N!> 'THE: WAL.K£-KS Jo/vsT/TUT/QNAL \//oLAT/I)N,
(5LAC.|< L/Fé_s mATT&/zs).we w/LL. come TQ TH€ DAY 7'//,47’
ch=.H o,FF¢c.:ALs Q_HLL_ B& He/..A Acou~TA/.zl_e Fo/e. T//e//e./)¢'/`/o~.s.
.PLEA.SE _.Séé PLA/~T/FF 'T/ZAvé/z$£: Vv\oT»c~.s ANL> AFF/AAWT.S '
o~ F/LE went THE cLe/e.z<, ma QPPQS:'r/o~ To ~r/-/s .s‘mre’s
F/~m~c-,¢A~c> 'T¢ WAL.)<&¢L A~o wAz.Iée.s As$/é~£/.> THE cwa AFr¢:-r<`
165777~6 APP/zovAL. F/com 7’.¢/¢= '/~/T/‘AT/~s Tu:>eL-:,

 

PLA/~TIFF Cou~$F_LS A&ma)vsfa.nfeo C'a¢.z_u:/a~ u.)lTH THE P/iOCu
SE`c.uTloN bancqu 'T/zm¢_- . 555 Co/v.sP//cnc‘r .C//c£um>‘f»~T/Az_

Evl/>e~c.s. C,A,.s`°('fax'.) 12.¢>:>'7. _D/£e¢'r Ev/oe./vc& of Ca~sP//cA¢Y‘
us um~&c&'ssne‘/,’ EA¢_/-/ ELEme~T m/)Y 86 /~Fe/me/> F/com C/Kcum»

STA~TlAL Evl/Aé~c& U.S. \/,` /‘VI/T¢HE¢.L. 9?4/ F',`BA 76?., °£oA/_sP//m¢.¥`
lLEAC/-I£$ P/ G)z_cw/> CaN/>uc;.T colvsT/TuT/~c_, /N-
cl»/¢AT& c)FFe~JE:. C.F//Lz>eess \/..SFATE (hF/->. 701$7’./‘79/) 207 .s.w.
2`.0‘¢7."~/; PL.A,~T/FF 'T.'€£.
l$ /N DEN/AL 565 \/,Tc. 14 éove/z~me~/ done T/7`/_E z _Su/_'>'

Tl/Lé_ 6 APP./ART. /O §? /€ul.£$ oF P»eoF» Co/vbuc_T /€uLE 909

Ca)(_?>),' dou~.se£. was /zeas;@.~ 7’¢ />¢»,,»~r/FF ns ///_<, /lrvz>/e~s\r
o_~ l» /9¢2,0/3 “rH/s 'wAs

7er o~LY`/_>AY He \//3/7' Pz.~~T/FF
LJN¢TH_ Z>»~#l$§-zolz’, 556 /NADEQ¢)A 7'..=_. 77me $/’e~?' Co)v$uLT//vé

 

Pq§c. S’

 

 

WNQT bo H/$ o¢_u~ /NoePe.~oe~T INVESTlGATm~ lN.$TéAc> AS
No~r'eo@’#aouc-,H ou‘T /-//5 AFF/oAv/T Hé /€EL/eo o~ 7'//6 P/sécu‘ro)a’$ F/LES FE/.c. sNo/aT aF vuan A
R&Aso/\/ABLY ComP& T¢':~T A7Toz€/ve`l' woul..o }-/Av& AoA/E,' 556
AL$<> u~n'&o sTATes \/,/JE/.’>A~c,o 780 F'z.z> ?/,? S" AT A m/~-»
|mum C_owv.S&!. /-/As THE DuTY Ta /NT&/zV/éw PoT&/vT/AL v\hT»
NE.SS£S,A~£> Tc> mAl<é A~ /NDE/->EA/DE_~T lNVEST/c,ATm/v oF TH€
FA¢TS A~c> cmcumsTA/vce oF ‘m£ cnse,' CK/sP \/.Du¢_lcwo/LTH
743 F.zo 590 555 (')TH c//z,/qs*‘_/) 964 u..s /2.14, /os s.¢~r. /zz/
39 L,E ,/3. 113 36/,’ /’LA/~T/FF /-Mve //vs¢57' TH'/£)a ~HéA/~e 50¢}/ As HFF/bAv/'/'k /5 /N
;.\/I,O»~‘L'A_’Tlo~ ‘To `TH& UN»TEL> $TATE.s CoA'sT/TuTl`o/\¢ $/x`n¢/ A)vr>

_ FS'Q`ET§£E~TH Hme~ome~vs,', _A HA/Be/as />er/m~e/< /> E~T/TLE¢> 70
AN ‘€Vm£~‘f/A/e.‘f HéA/e./Nc'=. li-' /-/6 (.2) A`LZ.EC»E$ FAc.‘/'S WH/¢:,N /F
_PkovE~ wc>¢_»z_l> _E~T/Tz.eo mm 'ro RéL/eF,° A~o (2_) silows 'nm‘r
/-/é mm Na7' Kec.e/ve A FuL.L. A~o FA//a /»/£-A/z/N¢ /N S/A rs
cou/LT E/TH&/z /47' We/AL ma /N A éoLLA'fa/em.. ,O/zo¢£souve. ‘
7\% q.s,C.A.§ Lzs'¢/,’ T//E 5701’5 Smo o~ Pm$£  # /Z oF /7’5
Mo'r/o~ 'THA`T `/3<>7/-/ v)‘>»¢\/»U"/é$ ST/PuLATeo T/~/AT TH£ 911€»¢/_&2
wAs_THe s/sTen ¢>F 714/5 $`T/)T§Ls \//cT/m'.s énzLF/a/,e~¢>;‘mn§
com PL&T& F’AL_$&»`/-/oop PLA/~T¢FF SA//> `a~e o/~' 774/5 F?smn¢s
‘i// cm_¢.ea.s wAs d)"/-u; sm res 1//¢T/-m §§//zLF,,A~o
`THAT WléM/S S/-Ié Llc 15 u~(>é/Z. OAT/-/,’ louA/T.S oF Ca~sP/KA¢Y
Ci) 7Hé Ex/$T&~c,e o_F n dam/mow é.onz..' (2.) 77/5 NATu/c£ oF
‘THE .S¢:. //&m'e A~o (‘5) "/'HE ove/cL.AP/>//va, oF 7'//€ szT/c/PA~T:

IN T/-/é \/Aruou.<. DEAL/~c;; ._u S \/./€/c»¢/é»eso~ 933 F z.o ll'-n,

1153 (57'// cna /¢27),',7'/!5» success o/»’ f///s `c@~s/>//en¢\r /A`el>e~-
bald on T/-Ié £o/\/T/~ue¢> L,L,uL.L./N(=»/vés$£s oF EAc./-I M&M&.€/z
725 P£/?.`Fo)e.m H/$ Fu~cT/o~_‘,` .£!¢H&/<$oh' 933+’.2.£> AT //s'L/;
/»/oweve/a sz.'a‘¢es wHo »K-~ow/~¢LY PA»zT»c:PA're cum-o cone
CoN$P/KATQKS `T¢ AcH/évé A <;omma~ GoAL mAY bc- memB£ms

oF A~ Qv£/zALL co~SP//cnc.Y' ch.#&/a$o~ 533 F-'T»Z.o A‘f //S“‘l-/' IN
PLAI~T|FF ~oT TAl~G TH& STA~Q LEA/_~. D/)aEcTLY 'Ta T//&Jun,‘f

éc.»:z,‘TY Ve¢c.b»cT )4~0 Co¢._.»L/b /_\/¢.7' /-/m/e /?>Ec-N £ensr.>MAB¢/.£

T/UAL. ST/?.AT&&»V,' //v HA/:;en.¢. P/coceeo//vc; cost/TUT/o~m/. _~
E/a&o)v. ls /vo~r /-/m¢mz._e`ss /F /T mm $uBsTA~T/AL. -.4~¢> l~§'u;mum

 

 
   
  
    

 

 

Eméraée~c`f mona/v Fb¢a LA¢€Y /Vlo/cc.n~ Pase. q " '

 

  

'~?.`E'FF£¢Y orr /1v FLuE~cE /1\1 be 75121441~11\16 T/~l£ Ju&`l$ V&K¢)ic.T
33 usc 14 §zzs'v.. 041\1¢1; v.fc;¢me.m.+zmn~ 5‘-1/ Fz-L> 329;
117 s,c.‘r. l‘-?s'S'/' 173 .L.&l.\. 115 `/'o` 3¢1,' 565 .G,ALvA~ W5ockk£4¢.
193 F.zo 760; 525 BR.E¢;HT3 \/. AB&AHAM.$¢)~ 507 u.s, 617
515 ns 113 5,¢7. 171`0;(71-/£§1:0~111 u~/Fo¢mz.`r /414,> /36&~
C-zw¢>e/> 13‘/~:'*115 P/o.wT/o~ 7‘111))' '/115 wa/T 511@¢,1.1) /3&
AvAu.Acs_LE 70 AFFo_/<_o ge ueF 10 714015 P£/¢.so~s wyo/w 50¢'
I&TY Hn.s GR¢E\/ou.$c‘f wm~eeo /~ L/c»h'?‘ oF lido¢>&»cm
501\11.:1:-./@7'5 01-' jusn¢;§.); F14‘1` v, No/A 501>1(14,372.§0'5,,141' qq‘o'#"
‘1¢11,25 s;.<.r 147 a’:>~o; 555 11§§1..~:¢ 7111.= />1@.1~¢11>1.6 ¢»F moo~¢\r v.
HoLon~ 15 ~oT Pu~1s14m1:~‘7' oF 50¢1&7"/ Fon 144151051:1>5 oF

A P.'Z.<‘.>${=c;u'l"o& l:.’>u’l' A\/ocba~c.& QF AN uN Fm& 'VrcmL Tc°fHé
AC¢uS&/>. 5051£ T`/ W‘)~s No'r o~/..Y u.)HE~ Tl-l£ GusLT‘/ Am=a
y4../.,¢)1\1\/15‘7"1.'=1§ I.?>¢.)T ¢.:..)HE»N 61\’,1m1~4!... 714/an A£é FA/)a Uulc
5\{57`&1€111\ oF '7’1-4& AQm1N/sT/z147'1o~ o'F ‘JUST/cé .S’uFFe/a's

' wHe~ ANY Accuser> 15 7'12547"&1> w\/FMR,L\(,

WH&IZE. Fo/¢é, PLAm-T/FFi P/€AY$. 7`/-/147' ?‘/-/E 6001€1 Z.oo/c
.UPol~g Az._¢_ 7'115 51111;>5~¢& PLA/~T/FF Pze$€~feo 141\__11> /Z&coc»;,mz_e
‘T'HRT lT Mu`$‘¢' 435 Molzé, AN\S C:£A~T 3~>LA1~T¢FF AN Ewoe~'h'mw

HéAu~c; lF 7’1-1& maer De¢.¢or=$ ~oT “ro em~r 1-11$ 1/,07 wa/T
OF HA¢ISEAS 601`<.!)1)$ »'

 

. ii 4'
§§
VE£:F)£AT/o~

/, LA»zzY .Toe mo&c» 14~1 T¢>c.'s -.~ 1014 ly‘/?z¢z. Béma Plzes£~n.‘l

INCZARc;&LATe¢> 147 'SAm&$ 141 £.Y~Auejé4 u~rr oFTD¢‘I D&cLA/ze u~o&et P£~ALT¥
CF PE£§\JKY THAT T`HE' Fo&&ém~é FA¢T'$ A£E T&Ué A~o Col?.r<&<'T.

 

. loq&‘ SlewY, 2037 '
_.,;,.:..~.4~'FT510'<_`K__'r¢/~.1 Tx 7.97.3$" . "

 
 

515/2715 g -r_e §

7'/41.$ 15 To cexT/F‘I 1'14191' bA1i'SEP1’1-'m/3.cx z.s" m 3@1<' 14 'r/cu:.
AN¢> 501111¢¢,7' cit/61an 601-’¥ qF _T/-lé 1480\1£ 141/b F’o/z&éom;a Emépre~¢.‘f
moWoN oF OBZS'£cT/o~ 70 0157'21¢?’ Amz~s¥s P£oPosé/.d Mémo/enu/Jum,/$~m~qs

oF F'14¢.T 14~1.\ cia~c¢.us:o~s oi~' Lm~‘ /Nq>uuav am 1312&¢€01~6 boams~'r.r wns
m/\ll..éo T¢» Ho.v. 0151'121¢1’ ca6/ek mr 4101 wesT/S&¢x.~m> Frwale-/ n 73141..»¢)~¢2

’ AN|> T/-/£ dower oF 6/€1_141'1~11¢, APP£»L.$ PO»BQ! /2.30£' Au.sT/~ T£¥A.S 737 1/,

z 1 SQJW m‘:""" pgo's' a , b

,, ,, Ems.ea.g~c '~/:~~Moné~ i»"o¢ anm}'/)naeen~ hg¢., my