Court Opinion

ID: 7159307
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-24 16:14:48.338673+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:15:19.617734
License: Public Domain

Martin, J.,

delivered the opinion of the court.
The defendants are appellants from a judgment in which the plaintiff recovered the sum of seven hundred and eighty dollars, and the appeal is taken directly to this court, without any intermediate one, to the District or Parish Court. The plaintiff and appellee has prayed an affirmance of the judgment, with damages, for a frivolous appeal, which he alleges was taken for no other purpose than delay.
The appellant has resisted his claim on the ground that this court is without jurisdiction, in the case of an appeal directly brought to it, from the presiding judge of the City Court,
Appeals from that magistrate are by the act constituting that court, directed to be taken to the District or Parish Court, at the option of the appellant. 1 Moreau's Digest, 345, section 5.
By the act of 1836, his jurisdiction was extended in a case like the present to demands of one thousand dollars, and no mention is made in the act of that year, of the mode of appealing. It is therefore clear, that the former mode is the legal one, on which the appellee has a right to insist. Whether we. may proceed on such an appeal when the appellee waives this right, is a question which we have thought unnecessary to act upon in this case, contenting ourselves with observing that the objection comes with an ill grace from the appellant.
If we have no jurisdiction, the appeal must be dismissed ; if we have, it must have the same fate, because the record *83does not contain the evidence adduced below, and we are, therefore, unable to test the correctness of the judgment.
The damages asked by the appellee cannot be granted to him, because it is clear, that by bringing the appeal directly to this court, the appellant hastened the time when the plaintiff may resort to his execution, which would have been protracted if he had taken the circuitous route to this court, through the District or Parish Court.
It is, therefore, ordered, adjudged and decreed, that the appeal be dismissed, with costs.