Court Opinion

ID: 4039577
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:16:01.998117+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:02:50.788564
License: Public Domain

1   •.

ihls docum'ent contains so~e
pogo& that ar~ of P?or quahty                                                                       .COURT
                                                                                                       RECEIVED     IN
                                                                                                           OF CRIMINAl~
at the time of 1magmg.                       WR- 60;lolol-IJ\
                                                                                                              FEB 05 2015
                    IN·r H          o RI
                      E [ U 0f C I M\NP-. L f\ PPEALs of 1 E. xA~
                                                      R
                  ---------------------------------~~,0~

                         Fx PARTe PERR'/ PATTERSON                             :tt   IL7 6iJJ
                                                                                                    MOTION DISMISSED
                                                                                                    DATE: 1""\ \ '"\S
                 ~DliQN       RE.QliESTING REHEARING WITH AN EN                          f~ANt PA~'(:,_--le~v_ _ __

                   Pursuani i£}. rule         ~1.1 u\- T.R.A.F\1ht- dPPe.l\an-t resPecttJ\~
            (eg_uests ar~ en          bat'\c. Pdr~el i"e~'lec:Jf.me 0'. 0. ~-' The. triJ\ C0ud f'cu.nc\ ihe Cli\':)Lder
                         1
I'

     fc bo-rh +\1e::,e 'lw?::)t"to~s to 6e ~t'~- \h.k':l honcra~J~: Loud s+ate6
     --tha+ ,+he Jpp)·l[dl'li m1~'l\'lt tJP eVlt"1ilu~ ft:. (e\le{ ·i~ ~Dltv~d tD \oe iruc'
            T.rial      Cuwt       O(r..~lexec~ dPPe\\a1e           Couv1s.e\       ·1-o     PrfSevrt C:\1"\            ci~~~d~v-it
     ·1D    uh'tLh      cc.uV\sc\ j·fafed           uV~de.,- oa1h /swCl(c           +o      ·-Thai he d·td                Y\6·\

     C.c~~l)~ul-t j_,_Jdh     -the:   JrPhC0lr'\i rJt (:)\\       a4'ter     Dl\eCt         Jrrea\        (10(        Co\'\\lf~   d

     11'\teMflo/\ t6        t1)e      3   P. O.K.   (\or   PruJ,de C\         Ct.:.fl:.J   c,\    :::,C\me      -To i~L
     ;)rPLcdt'\f.      Ever'J      Jet    cJ Jred\c}tt'          CouV"IsPl   ~·(J\\s b~IDw fe8scllab\e
     stJ"darJ~.

            1.   Th"t.s     hof\ur3ble          eourt 9fd{\te(:\ -the CIP\J\\(0{\-1;                           \eave te:.-Pde
     h~s    DL<_j(\    r. 0. R.    'PIU se      whet\ t~c: ~OU(i·                "3'\&V\-ted eru               ')C.    ex-fet\'StO(\
     -to -~-~\e Pro sc            P.O.R. C\(\d ~:-.u.sPe,f\s,(~[\ o~ \.~.A.r. C\.?JCb.)
     SflecitcrJ\b'\tb reduce Cd>ie.s ~or P(o 5c Pe·krio.1er 3r\C~ 1hu<"fNc
                                                                                                     11

     e..cred .\(\     accePi.lv'lc.J J       P. 0. R.    tr6rl\     Couv'l.sel   0(        dfl~i Per.so·n other
     -thGM -the        Jpp)·ICJVI-t d.') Text:12>          cloe~    Y1Ut     olloLu h'J~x·J                (ePresc.wraiiOY\

            ~. The.       iri]\ Cou.f-t         dtt~IV\Pted           tl)    .Jv~-t"~~~          \'\()Y\-C.oY\sul-ta-tiol\

     'o·~   Cc:.u.V\Se\'.:,      excuse       cA'    3 \eJCI\ C\ss.tsturd CLur\\(V:~,houever,
     {2_X[u~e.-:~     de, nc;i     et.cu~.. e   or Just·\{':1        L.o'1\~titu.tior\c1\ (e~U-I(C'I'Y)ft\t.s                 61
     CoY\2lu.ttc'J·(\61'\   (lfCC.r!'::f.~d{l!:. t~r    e{('L?Ci\Ve. ass\        ~feir'\CC: Jl'\~
                                                                          du.e. Proce~5.
     ch'\'::1 Cou.f\se\or -~~ re'-lu.l{cd to LDi'\Su\t dV\d .\tY~OriV\ 8 c\teV\t -fer

     {eP\e:::>e.i'ltat-1oY\ C\Aj tk1.s Cc.uci wO\~ f\6-\ he\d +o ~lv'\din:!S Ceuor\eou.~.J
                                                                                                        '  .

     CJf -the. -tria\       Col.A(-f ,see    Err     .-tJ.Jrfe     A&\fls, SS() ~:l,W.1d (Cf,At'r. l'\ll)

            fudhurmMe... :L.L~ t:the• Yl{O\J.VI~S were \e:~-t Ut~fe~c,\ved d1'\~ wJ\
     'be.. p\a·~\'\1~ exPt.scd m 11.:d P(ucedlf\55 Gd'h J \1\<..t:\'j                                     Vt'\Yidi\cl VJQc\<.

                                                                 -2-
.   .   I   •

                -lD    tkls ho;'\L.:.f3ble Loud                ds --ktJI COG.d       ~~·~\e~     to re:;;c\ue. or         adci~es -t~e
                \~S\..lt?~    0,(   e Vf' V\   S\-C\-\;e   l,__j~ethc: >f i~e iE'    WE.f e      C..c.nt'fo'Je.dPcl   l   <::,-:su.eS or

                Ylui         Per. \.Cc.P Jci. 1\.Dl ~ecl~JlcJ

                      l.(.   1he.     Jppj·ICdrli          ·~~ Cl){,-t\e6 t'b clut           'Pf6Ces.s   dl''\~ :shCAt\d
                '( ece·1 ve ClV\ ell\ bi:1ii\C.            heac.\Y\\j   -tG   el/\':::lufe    ~vel'\.

                        WHERE ~QRE.               -the arrLc.JV~-t '(l(C\'j~ ---\hiS honClrcib\c: Lcud Slfch\-t
                +~1e rectue-stec\ LY\ bane                     Rehe3r\V\C::L

                                                                                    9cn. ~ P3t~er.so\"1* )loT)\?-_\
                                                                                    Te \~'or J L\ 1"'1\-\·
                                                                                    3,2~(\ S·tafe t\w::1 '~&
                                                                                     Ne.w E.\c:-.s\a1'\J \X:. T~:)'l()

                                                                        - 3 --
'·

                                        WR- gQ;loLal-D\

             J   N ·rHE t 0URT 0F CRI MI N~ L ~ PPEALS                         CJ f    1 cx A~

                    EX PARTE            PERR~ PA 1 Tti\SON :tt IG7 ;)lJJ

         tv\DliON REQUESTING RtHEAR\NG W'\Tt\ AN EN                              l~At·H PAtJEL

             Pursuani      t~ rule_ ~1.1 o{ T.R.Fi.F~-lhe ClPPeJ\ant resPect~u.\\"1
     reg_ues-rs      ar1 en      6JI'\C. Pdr1el     rehedrinc:J cf h1s adic\e \\.Gl wftt
     G~ habeas coreus o()d                  1n   ~uPPOfi ihereui W0LJd shew -t~\:S
     ~{)fiCHabie Lourt             ib   fclilow:~;.

            On Januar~ 1~. 'lol~ ·tk\~ ~G\'\O(ah\e. LtLfi acloPied -the f';r~c\;,'\'jS
     o-f -the tr.1a.l C6Ufi C\r\J c\c:J\.ted ClPP\tc:dvr\ S L,_y(,-\ o{ h.Jbecb CurPu~)
                                                                       1

     hc.t..iH:?.ver.-lh\2> dec.t5\cJ\ 1~') Cordrch~ to Ur\.dc?·~ :~·rrdte~                       2n.tP(EI'Y\e

     Louft f(ecec\eV1-t~ dVIJ evev~ Prec~~\2v~t.s o{ -th'i21 hoi'\Drah\e Louft
     a~ ihe. i(ial         Court     dearllj        clnJ        p)a!nllj macle f·illdln':\')       in{avG'f D{

     -the   arr \'ICC1 r'\-t's d II eij(:.~-t .\M\5 a,I\J er (_i•ilc~eJ    P( 06~· em fe(ejfcl ot    c0(\S~ \-
     iUi16Y~t11 rish-ts Lliolatior\:::. o{ -\he Six-th anJ                      foudeev'\th        Al\'\enc\'\'VVY\f'S.

            \. 0(\ M(j ((: h \1/l 0 I~ 1h\ ~) ht r r?l bI e c0 u("\ .I ~~ u t' ~ dI'\ 0 ( c\ e u { 0 '(
                                                         1\(J                         <)

     -the trial Cc.uri ic L~t?tt r m'l 1\C:' ·, ~ c.H~fc \la-te cGU vi 'JC \ PufSL~ed r. 0, R.
     l.A)·,+}·wut Cu(\5Cnt cJ -the C1P~'l'i~dl'\+ a(\c\ ·i~ sa;J ~. 0. R. b\octrd
     •J~pp),cJI\1 1 s   Pi' (j   ~~e 0'. 0. ~-I The tria\ (Dud f'ouncl -\he ar~~~)L         t'V\i.lile.c\ tt:. (elle{                           \~ ~G\.tV\d           -to \:Je -true         I

         /vial             Cuwt         Ofc~el'ec~ dPPe\\aie.                         CouV\.se\                ·to       NfScVii dl'\             C\~~~d01v.,t
·10 L.Jh"ILh               CCLlV'ISf\         ~-fJfcd UV\dev                 ucl\h         l<)WCl~·c           fo -1-hd.-t          he J·,J         Y\c.·\

COI')~ul--t /..ro.~'dh             the JrPhc01rd rJt dl\ {j4ter                                   Dl\eLt             c1PPea\        Y\0(     Con\Je~          d

11'\tev~t'lo/\ tc,t,)e a                        P.o.R.        (\br        PID\i1de. J              c~P:-.J c~                sC\me         -\-o-t~e
dPPLc:;'lr\t.             Ever'J act cJ JPPc:l\dit'                           Cc.h.Ju'\Sf>l       ~·8\\s        btl\c,u fe&sonab\e
stdv'\darc~'::,..

      1. Th·,.s                  i'lof'lordh\e           Cc.wt ~L:.lf\ted                         -the         C1P\J\-,c31'\'\        \eave          te:.   ...f\le
his      Of.A)(\          P. 0. R.       Plu    sc whe1\ i~t Gou(i ~\.'6JV\-tecl                                                P(u <:;c ex-/                clue~       Ylut        o\\oL.J h~bx-J                     C<::P(escv,-f-aiion.

      ~. The -tria\                      lOU.fi         att~lVIP'ted ft) ju.J{I~':J V\()Y\-CoY\Sul-ta-tioY\
\cJ'-d Cc:.u.ti\Se\'s U(Cuse                           cA 3 \~sd\ C\S~).IstJrd q_w~\(\~lhoue,Jer,
e..xcu~e::J         de nc;i            ex.cu~-,e or             .1ustA.Cj C.oY\Stltutior\3\ \"e'lu·,(en'\f;rLs                                              o-f
CoY'I~uttc'Af-161'\              (lecce'::f.:..,(Jrl!J       +or deci1Ve. C\~5\ :dJfiCt J\'\J                                         due. Proce~s.
C\~'\~ Cuuf\sc\or -,~ re<-lul'(cJ' to                                     Cu;'\SlJt               C!V\d ·InforM 61 c\teV\t {or
{eP\e~eVItcli-10\'\                 c\flr1-tkls          Cuufi            i.;Jel.:)   Y\6-\       he\d          fD       ~-l{\6in'JS Ceuoneou.~J
         \            . I
G{ -tY\e. -ti\3\ CoLAfi ,.see                         LA'
                                                         L        -
                                                               /Jc!Jrfe
                                                                                 ;/} . .           s· r
                                                                                 n&u'\S: · _)) .),\_,'-.).
                                                                                                          ('    <    I   \   16 ( (f' Arr . \'\ll )

         fudhurmMe.. }_Lo uther                                 SUf' S   ur

Vlui            tler. \.Cc.P Jfi.                   1\.Dl -:::.ecl'_))CcJ

         l.(.    1he. ~:Jppj·,c.@n-t ·,~ er\t·,t\e6 te:.                  c\u.c: fl(6C.e5.s    civ\~ :shDu\c\
fece\ve ctV\                ell\ bC.hi\c..         hea~·,(\Cj ·rG    eV\0ufe ':)vc\'\.

   I                          •
+he             recLUhte d         t ;'\    (jEinc Rel-1cdr\V'\~L

                                                                            Peff'::~ P3tier:san* ll.DT~\A.\
                                                                            Te \{or c.\ U(\It
                                                                            s2cn     Stdfe    t\LA.) 'j '16
                                                                             ~t'w fjc-,sta,'\; IX. 7SSIC>

                                                                - '3 --
                               WR- ~D;LGl-D\
       lN ·rHE L0URT 0f CRI M\Nf\ l r\ PPEf\ LS CJ f                          1 Ex A{~

             EX PARTE_ PE.R R'I PAT T ER. SO N ~ Ilo7 6 i ]_ \

     ti\DllDN fH.:.OUES.TING f\tHEI\R\NCl           W'\1H AN EN \~ANt PAtJEL

       Pursuani t~ rule_ l.\1.1 u~ T.R.A.F~-lhe. JPPe.l\an-\ resPect~u\\~
(eg_uests an       en   bat'\c..   Pdriel    (ehe~3f.m        1
                                                                   Wi1'"\   o{ h.:1bea~        Co{PU"2l,

howt:v'er,-\hl-~    JeC.i.S-101'"1   i~'J COt'lir3f~    to lJf\-dt-J         ~;VHt~ ~uPIEI'Yk:
L6ul't Precec\ev1-t~    GYIJ eve__v~\ Prec:~~\ev'lt.:s o{ -th.i::. \'1onurah\e Loud-
as   -t h~ i ( iaI co ud c)earJ L:J cl nJ Pla·i nI:1 mac\ e f -~ nJInttrm'l(\t:'' -~~ dPfella-te LGUVI~e\ PufS\Jed r.o.R.
LJ·,+hout C(~r-,:sent cJ -ihe 8PPl'1cdrr\- 31\c:\ i { ~d·1J P. 0. R. b1 octfd
                 1
t)pp\.,cJ-1'\-\: s 'P to se P. 0. R.' The. ty--ia.\ cGu (\ f'cun c.\ --\he Ct{\ ::)L.J er
fc buth +l1e~e             clw?st'IO/\S             to      be        i.jes. \\1',_<;,  honer able- Lulid .:)+Jte6
-tha-t '+k~       JPPLcC\1"\i       m1~"1hi bP eV'Ii'!ile.r1               ft:.    (e\le{ ~~ ~D\..tV\d -to \oe i1ue'
       /ria I       Cuwt       o(del'ec~ dPPe\\a-te                     CouV\.se\ ·to Nt>Scil\i df\                   .3-\~lddV.it
·1 c   L.Jkt Lh ccu nsc \ ~-fated uV'IJ e-v uclth /swoi'c. +o ·-t ~a-t \0 e J·1 c\                                       Y\ c,·\

CJHI)~ul-t wd·h           the: JrP\1{0)(\l rJt dl\ c:A'ter                        D,\eci dPPea\           (10(   con\le~           d

11'\tel/\t'loA     tot',)e      3      P.u.R.       (\t.r        PruJ,de 6\        CoP::)     c~ :::,dme -To-t~e_
dPPLc~t'\f. Eve!':J act c.:J JPPei\Jit'                             Couv'1St>\    t~ils bele:.w (ecbc(lab\e

   1. Th.,s hof\orJb\e C:c:.ud CdL:lAted -fhE: 3P\Jl.ICol'\-t \eaue te:.-Pde.
~;s ()[.,_)(\ r. 0. R. Pru se wYlfcrc
                                                                                                                             "

f_fred \A     JccePt.,v'lC:'J J               P. 0. R.   +rt)r/\ CouvLsc( ex                 Jf\ COt'lirBf~ to Uf\.dt.?•J ;=)·rdfe~ ~uP(ei'Y"I<:::
           L6ud·      P(eU'c\eV1+~ a(\J eveJ\ Prec~~~\ev'\t.s o{ +~-i~ hoi'\Dfd'b\e Lcuut
           d~   f h~ i (i aI c() ud cl ea(I ~~ cl n J p) a n llj m acl t f JI ncyj i \'\ f~hJ o{
                                                                             .l                    .I   Y\               t,'(

           -t-he d~fl~-ICCl t'\i's       r)\\e.CJ{)i.ICW'\5     avv\   fi6'.J1clecl   rfoD~·    01\ (C(G(Cl   ot (Of\S1.1-

           iUil{)(ldJ        rish-t.s VicJatloA:::. o{ -\he: S1x-th                   dnJ    foudt-f'VIth       ~jr:\er.c.\rY1ents.

               \. Or~ March ! 1.1201~ ·th, ~) h(';fl(;rr:ibl e Cour-1 1~:.-·}u('c.\ dY\ O(c\eu -for
           ihe tria\ Cc.uri ic c.~ettrm.Hif.:', \~ JPfc::l\c.He Ce;uA~e\ 0ufS\Aed 9.0.R.
           w",+hout C'Dri5Cnt C::~ -fhe BPPl"l~drrt a(\c\ i{ jc),J ~. 0. R. b\uc~.rd
           tjpp)'\(U(\~ S
                         1
                               '{)((.)   ::~e         e.o.L'    Thetrid\ccu(\               f'cu.ncl-the      Cl{\;)L~e 'luest-, u"" s to be                                        e~. \h·,-~ h on ab\c- L ou d st- dte6
                                                                                         ':j                          o(

     -thcH '+he            3PPlit:Clt"li m1:1ht                         be C'Vli·il\e_J ft:. (e\,e{ ~~ +CJ"-wl~ to \:Je icuc-'
              };ria I           Cuud                O(rJ(<:'C~ c~PPe\laie                CouVI.s.C \ ·to PfeSeV\t C::\1'\ l:-;y\\lc\civ.it

     -1c Ljh',Lh                Cc.LtVise\                    ~-rated      Lmde.r      oa-t~ /swo~·c.        fo ·-Tha-t he cLJ nc.\
     COI')Sulf            /..,.j"dh          the Jrr\·ICdr'\l                rJt     dl\ (J~'ttr      Dl\ec.t c1PPea\            (\0(   Con\Je::\ d

     11'\-teVIt"loA            to        tiLe             3 F.'O.K. {\or Pcov.,de_ d                   Cwfl:-.J    e:.~ :::,C\me -to-t0~e..
     dPPLc;Jt'\f. Ever':J ~let                                 c.J   Jppc\\Jie Cou.'!sel ~-8\\s beiD~ feJscnab\e
     st8.1dard~.

            1. Th·,.s                   hof\or3h\e Ce:.ud 9rd"tec~ -\'~2 CIP~\·IC2ll'\-\                                           \eave te:. -Pile
     h;s     OLA) n            ·p_ 0. R. Pw                     sc     w IleA -t ~t            Gou(i     "3 x01 V\-t e d     e( o <~e        e.>:-f e~·\5\o(\

     io   t,\e Pro                      sc P.O.R. df\cl s.usPeN::~c~r\                                  o4    \.~.A_P. q_?J(lo.)
                                    1
              _ ['.       \\    \                         •                     ('                                          II      \    ,         o

     Sflt?Ci'tiCrJ             'j tb           reduce Ce.Pies                   \U       P(o 5C F'eiltio.\e'{                    df\G --1~'\ucforc

     e_cred           .I(\ accePi·, v'lc.J J                         P. 0. R.   +r6r/\ Couv'LSe( Cf               c;ln~i   (Jcr.SCY(\    othe_r

     -tMJ~" -the               ()pp)·,cJVI-t Cls                     -Texr:l~ clue~            YlUt   Dl\aL_j h~b(·\c\            (c:P(ese:wrJiim\

            ~. The -tr1a~                             Cou.c1           Jtt~IV\P·ted             fl)   .Jv~-f1~':l     l'\oYI-CoY\Sul-t2diof\

     \cJ·-(1 Cc.u.V\se\ s cx:cuse
                                        1
                                                                      cA    3 \e~d\ ass·1stC:Iili q_.--t\1\(\Cj,houeuer,

     e.xc..u::,e::j Jc r,oi ex.cu~-.e                                  or JustA'Y              tol'\~tltut\oi\3\           (ecLl(\(e    n'lfl\f.s o-f
     Co\"\:--:;)u{t,.:;d--161'\             (1t:cce'::1~f:Ar'!J         -\'ur e{('t>cttve. Jssi sfC1Y\Ct:                  ch\~ due Pfoce:'.>5,
     C\,r,\j Couf\Sc\or                          1':::>    dV\d ·HJOr\'V\ 8 c\teV\t {or
                                                              re'-lu({cd tb Co/\Su\t
     {e~\e2JeV'!tclt-1 0I'\ C\v~c\ fk1.s Couci Web f\D-\ he\d to ~\v'\6in\ -o·fatcd u.ll'de.v                oa1h /swo{c. fo ·-tha-t he cLd Y\6·~
     CcH'i~ulf L..Jdh -the:                     JPPhC0J(I-t tJt            Jl\ r.:A'tc:r D~cec.t Jrrea\ Vlor con\Je~ a
     11'\tell\t'lo/\           toti)e          P.u ..K. (\bf
                                                3                          Pruj1de 6\ Co0:-.J c;\ s8me -Tui~e.

     :JPPLc.:;}t'\f. Ever':l               Jet c.J JPeei\Jie                 Cuuv')sel   t~\\s be\c,~ feC\Sc!\,:1~\e
     stJAdarcl~.

              1. Th·,.s            l'lo(\orJh\e Cc:.ud '6rdrYred                      -fhe CIP\)\·,c:211'\"\ \eave tD ..f\le
     h;s       OG.)f\         ·P. 0. R.     P!t1se L....J\eV\ -the                Gou(-\ ]{@lf\ied Pfo ')C e..~1ev1-slol\
     \b·-~·\\{:" Pro              Sc      P.o.R.. d.r,d ~~usPev'\5.\(~l\ Q~ l.~.A.r. c~_?J(b')
                 r
     SPeci-t.tCrJI
                            '\ 'j\' tb      1               r                      " \ . "
                                         recJuLe (e.flies \ur P(o 5c Peiltio.lt'f 3i\G ~~'\ercfNc

     f_((ed           ·lA   JccePt.,v')C.'l J            P.   0. R.      +rorA CouVl.s-:1 or t91'\'6 Per.son other

     -tMJv~ -the             iJrp)·,cJrd             C1~ ·Texd~ ciDt-~ ~ut Dl\ow h~b(·\J                       (ePfescvd'C\iloYl.

              ~3...    TMe. -tr1a\ CoLHi                      Jtt~lV\Pied t1'J Jv5f,~'j               1'\oY\·CoY\sul-ta-tioY\
     bl.() Ce:.\),_V\se\ 1 ~ excuse                         G*       3   leCJd\   C\s.s.tstCI!li q_ul~\rY~,houever .

     {~X[u~e~:,             de,    YVYi    e.';(Cu~-,C        e;,(   JustA'lj C.o'i\Stltutio.'\c)\       (ecw·\(e{()f,'\t,')     o-f
     Cof\~u.tt(}f-161'\ (\f:'CCr!'::f.~d{l.!J                 +o(        e-f(eci\Ve ass\ sfdr\Ct:        dl'\c~ due    Process,

     C\,'\~      Cou.llse\or              -~~       \t''-l.ul'(cJ t6 CLd\Su\t C\V\d ·,rrfor\'V\ Cl c\ieif\-1:            -for
     {e~\e~efltc)i-,or~                  3Ac\       th'ts     Couci Wi:l:) flG"\         he\d to ~-lv'\d\(\~;s Ceuoneou.~J
                                                                                                               -·               '
     c._{ -the. -tr\&\ CoLAf-t _see                         Ex       /Jdrf~ Aa\1'\s, SSj          ::,,1..,0.'lc\ (U.Ar-r. (\ll)

               Fuc-1-hurrf\M~.                  J...L Gthe• Sio\..i.V\~S were              \c:~-t   Ui\(e::Jc,\ved    ;:h\~   w1\\

     \Jt>..   p\&\1'\k        eXPL.scd \Y\ l1.S'-\ Pcocedlf15S                        wdh     J     \lkt:\l~ ve\'Y)dt'\d bG~c.k

                                                                             -2.-
-b +k1.s hal1L:.f3ble Lou(i ds i(tJ\                COLS   or

Ylui    ()er.\.Cc.P.            Jfi,    \\.ol ~ecl'2l)Cc.J

    ll. 1he        ,jpp)-,c_dYI-t      -~~ c,1t-~tle6 t-e:. clue. flfoces.s ;}v\~ ~snou\d
fece..1ve ClV\ ell\ ba~f\c hedf.\f{::. tG ev\~i...ue ':)vc\-1.

       wHeRE j:QRE_ --t~e              arPlicJV\-t 'P(C\'jS    1hi.s honori}b\t       Lcud      ~(Gv\-f
+he recLuesied t (\ [~d(\C Re \·wan\1\C::L

                                                            Pc(f~~ P3t-le.r.5on* )loT~\?-..\
                                                            Te \{ord L\n-1t
                                                             ~2~'\ State t\w-:i -~&
                                                             N.tw t'jcy~~ui"\J IX. 7SS/C;

                                                  - 3 --
                               WR- B.O.Glal-0\
       IN 'THE toUR.T OF CRIM\NP\L                        r\PPEP\LS of 1E.xA~

               Fx PARTE_ PERR1 PAT TtRSOM                             :}t   llo7 ;)il \

     ti\DliON REQ\JES.TING Rt.HEARING W\1\-\ AN EN \~f\Nl PAtJEL

       hirsuaoi t~ rule. l.\1.1 o{ T.R.A.F!1he.. CIPPe.l\an1 re.sPecttJ\'1
(e9.ue.sts a() t:n       6c11'\t Pdt1el       rehe.c:JfinCj of h1.s a(f1c\e \\.C:)l                    w(\t

6~ habeas        CorPUS        a11d ·,(1 ~uPP!Hi -thereu{ w6L.Jd ~huW i~\~
~r.)flnrabie Court           i;):j fuilow:~;.

       oh     Ja()uar'-11~,'10\S -+h'l~ \\ono(db\e LQL(i acloP"ted -the f';r'\c\;tdS
cJ -rhe     tr.1al cnufi C\1'\J de(\.lc:d c1PP\\Covli 1 ~) w·(,-~;; o{ habea~ Co(PU'::l,·
h~wever.-lh.\2> Jec-~.s~ol"\       i:.) Cof\irdf'::'l        to Ur.. l"tc?·d .:Hdi'es             ~juP(eme
L6ud·     P(ecec\eV1-t~ CJY\J eve.V\ Prec~~\ev~+-s o{ -t~·is ~onorah\e Lcuft
3s   -t he. i ria l co u d    cl ea,- \j
                                     J        cl n   J P) aIn1':-J    m acL~      f ·~ r\ d;nc] -~ in tJ u0-'( cJ
-rh~ Jflri'ICClt'\i's dlles::~-t'ICH\5 alf\J f'16ilc~e,1 P(oc~· c.m                  (CCGrcl      ot (0(\S~·,_
iUi16Y'!t3.l   rish-t.s violatio(\~ D~ ihc: Six-th                   dnJ foul tt'l?V\th rll\'\c?V\C.\\\'H"ni·s.

     \.On Md(ch l:t~·)OI'i          ·thl7.l    hQncH~:ib\e       Coufi         ·,~;,";ue~   Cln    orc\eu {ol
-the trial Cc.ur i                     ~ d Pf'c llcHe cDU v'\ '::le \ PLifSUed 9. 0. R.
                         it L4ett r m ·,l\t''    ·,

LJ·d· hcut cu1 sent cJ -f he 8P~'l'IC_dn+ a r\c\ ·i ~ 5cr~J P. 0. R. b\ockfd
dPPLCJ\'\-\:\~ 'Pr :':le e. 0. R_ The. tl'i3\ (GU(i f'ouncl ihe .31"\~:)wer
                    L)                   I
fc bo-rh +\1e~)t' CLuesi-·IO.~S to                                   6e        \jes \h'\,'::, honcrablf' L olid state~
                                                             bf' eV1t·,-d~r1                                i~ -~~\.w\d
                                                                                                                                                                      1
-tha-t .+he        JrPlicat'\i m·l:.'lht                                                t6 (e\,e{                                      tD       VJe -true-
       Tria I Cuud orc~erec\ dPPel\ait CouV\.se \                                                      ·1-o NfSeV\\ dt\                         d-\~1cie\vlt
·1c   uh-1Lh ccun.se\ ~-rated U.V\,le.f oa1h /swui·c.                                                  fo      ·-1-hai \0e clid                      Y\6·t

C6~1)~ul-t l~dh thE                              JPPhc0M-\ Jt              dl\ a4.'ttr     DIU?L.t dPPea\                    {\0(          (o(\Vf~                d

li'\-tell1t\oA          tot',)e              3     P.O.K.      r1t>r PfD'j1de. 6\ Cof>:::;                  c~ sC\me -tu-t~e_
dPPLcJt'\f. Ever'J ;;Jc..t                         c.:J   JPPei\Jie C.\.rul\sel ~·EJI\s bt:lc,~.J fe;Jscndb\e
stdAdard-:,..

      '1. Th.t.s l'lonorJh\e C:c.:.ud '~HElr~tec\ -the CIP\A\cC\1'\-t \e8ve tt:.~Ptfe
 \n~.s OtA,n P. 0. R. fJUJ se wheV\ i~t G6oJi ~(6\lf\ied P(u '")c e.x-1et,'Siot'\
\b -~·,\e Pro sc P.o.R. dr\d ~:,usPeJ'IS.\()t\ o{ \.R.A.r. C\_~(kJ')
                                 1
        ['.       \\.        \               ,                       r-.                                               1/          \        ,           ..,
SPec\-t,c()             'j           tu reduce (6{)ies ~ur                     P(o 5c Pe-t~tlo.,er                          31\C::\        --t~lef<"f'uc
ecred         \,f\ JccePt.,v'IC.-1                J       P. 0. R.   +rtjrf\ CouVl.seJ ex c.;\fl~l f·er.sc.:.·r\ c.:.ther

-thJ~   -the ()pp)·ICc1v'H d!::l                           Text:!~ clue~            Y\Ut   ollow h:Jbi'·J                     (efl(esc.d-ailoY\ .

                                                                               ......

      ~. The iri::1\ CoLHi Cltt~MP'ted t1:J J\J5{,~lj \'\oY\-CoY\sul-tciiiof\
\cJ'{l Cc.u..V'Ise1 s excuse C:Y~ 3 \e~1(J\ Cls.s·tstcJrd q_L.u'\\r\'j, houever,
                                     1

e...xcu.s~~       Au                 f16i   ex.c.u:.,e c,r :}ust'r{l1 LoY\'Stltutior\c)\ x-ecw·~(eiY\fldS 6-f

CoA~u\tc:~·t"luV\ (\ecc.r!'::f.~!Jri!J +or e+Cect1Ve Clssi s-far~ce dY\~ due Proce~s,
dv'\~ Cou()se\or \~ re'lulkd t6 Cu:'\:)u\t dV'J lrY~Or\'V\ d dteVIt {or
{eP\e2l~,V\tclt-1 0r\ 3VId -tk1.s (c,ufi W~.:) (\0.-\ held ·tD ~',,r\din:;s Ce(foneou.~J
                                                                                                                               .                              \
                                                               -~ v 1 d ( u Af·r (\ ll )
c£ -t 1Y\ e. -tv\. d 1\ Co ~.Art :;:,ee .c.cx ~dr fe vJ. ·
                                                     n &11'\S'
                                                                                            t: '" ,.
                                                                                            :J .) )     .) •
                                                                                                               0
                                                                                                                   -                   '         ·

       fudhur[{IOfe_, J...L bt~e,. fO\J.V\~S were \e~-t Ui\(e::-Jc,\ved dVI~ wi\\

'be_ p\&,\'\1\j 2XPtl.SCd iY\ 11.S'-\ PluCL:'dlf\55 wdh a \,ke\l~ vem8i\J bS   or
      Ylui     Per.\.Cc.P Jci.            1\.Dl ~ec.l~·)CcJ

            l(. 1he c)ppj·ICchli        ·~~   e,1t'11\e6 t'o c\u.c: )')foc.es.s        3•·'\~ ~snou\d
      fece.IVe dV\ ell\        ba~f\c   hedf.lf\S     tt   eV\'::Juce   ':'Jvc\.,.

       I                   '
      +he      recLUfstec..\   t (\ bane Re heariviC::L

                                                                 Pen·~~ P3-t~ E'f.Son* ) LoT:)\ A\
                                                               Te\{ord Lh11t
                                                                 s2cri s-tate He-,) 'j         ·~16
                                                                  ~ew l\c,~')\ui"\J IX. 7SS/o

                                                      - 3 --
                              WR- go,t.o~l-D\
        l N·r}i E L0URI 0F CRI MI N~ L 1\ PPEf\ LS of                         1 E. xA~

              EX PARlE. PE.R R'/ PAT TERSO Mott IG7 oi .2. \

     t-1\DliON 11EQUESTIN8 Rt.HEARINCi W1ll\ AN EN                         \~ANt PAt-.iEL

        Pursuarli f~ rule_ .i..\1.1 o{ T.R.PI.P~ihe dPPe.llant fC:SPeci~u\\'1
                   bat'\ c. Pd r1e I (e he(J ri nr\.tca ni's ()\\e_),l·t'tM\5 avv~ ffo·.J1clecl P(oc:.{ OY\            (('C()rcl    ot Cof\st\-
                         violatlo(l~ o{ l hc Six-th anJ                                            ~11\'\endn'ICiltS.
                                                      1

 iutt6ndJ (i9h-t.s                                                        foLh i"t'eV\th

       \. 0(\ March ll.\201~ ·th1~) .htf\Crr31b\e Ccud ·~~~')uc~ Clf\ Q(c\eu {ot
 -the trial C.curi ie. Lt?ttrm.lllt:' -,~ dPPclla-te Ce.Uv\~e.\ ruiSUed 9.0.R.
 W'\thout Ce.r\Sc?nt cJ -fhe CJpp)·,~drrr Clr\c\ i~ sa,J ~. 0. R. \;~\oc\c. fd
 l)pp)·\C.[\\'\-\: s 'PI c. ~~e e. 0. R. The. tria\ (GU(i f'ouncl ihe d{\':~i...Jc?(
              1
                                      I
ft      berth +~1e:)t?               cLuest·IUIIS        to   ~<:?~.\h~-~ honorable Luud state6
                                                                 be
--that '+he     JPPhcdY\i                  YV\iC~ht be eV1i"lilcJ ft:. (e\le{ ·i~ +()\_tV\~ to \oe irue                              I

         };rial Cuu(t [)(,dCJxec\ c_~PPe\\aie Couv~.se\ ·to PfeSetfli dl'"\ .::\·\\·~,1c1v.tt
--ic    uh-1Lh CoLtV\~:.e\ 0·ratc:d u.V'de..,r oCJih /swo{c +o -thai he cLJ r\~\
COI')::,ulf I.,J'dh                 the d0Phc-al'l-t {Jt all a4'ter              Dl\t'Lt    dPPea\         {\0(     Con\Je~      d

ll'\teV1t'loA     tGti\e 3                    P.o.,K..   (\CJr   Prov·,cie 6\ Cc.fl::)      c,{    sc1me          -Toi~e.
Jppl·ll~.~t'\f. Ever':J                ZlLt   cJ   Jp'pe\\Jit' Cm.AVIsr! ~·a\\s          bc\c,w fe85c!lab\e
stJflcL~~J~.

    1. Th'f.S i!)Of\Or,;lh\e L6ud Cdfdf'lted -the cW\J\·\Cdl'\"\. L?ove te:.{\fe
h~~ DL-..)n P. D. R. 'P( or     JV\~~-    (-'·erSo't\        other
-thJv'\ -tht: ()ppj·ICuV\-t cJs -T~XL~~ Jue~ YIGt o\\oL_; h~b(·,j (eP(tSCv\tc1iioY\.

        ~. TM~ -tria\                   CoLHi        3tt~ni\Pted          t1:J   jv5-t'~~~        \'\()Y\-CoY\sul-ta-tioY\

\cJ'-(1 Ce:.\J..V\S.e\
                         1
                             _::.    excuse         cA   3     leCJa\    Jss.tsicJrd q_u\-\\(\cj,hoL.)e\JcJ,

f!...xCu~e::j   Jc nui                 e:V\   .:'.:l-\""C:I~e wk:"'the1 i~e1e we.re
Ylui ()er.\.Cc.P. Je-t. 1\.Dl-~ec.L~)CcJ

      l(,     1he ,}PPLc~l'li ·~~ t?tlt"tt\e~          t'G    clu.e      rfoCe.scs                      dv'\~ :shou\~

  I
+\r\e       recLUf'sted        t(\ (~dl\C Re\·war\v\~.

                                                                              .i'·
                                                              •
                                                                  V '· ' 1.
                                                                   1 k·_:;;
                                                                              .(....',,_ H
                                                                               i
                                                                                         ·,·;   n,. ,
                                                                                   iAJJ,r.-!nC'Jc

                                                              Pen·~~ P3t1 e csan=*' ) LoT~\ A.\
                                                              Te \{ord un·d
                                                                  7 ·'ac
                                                                  ~~ 1 \5-t cJ t f 1\·
                                                                                   r Ld ':3 ··I o
                                                                                                Q

                                                                  ~C:W bDS ~en'\ 1 \X. 7 1; S 70
                                                       ·.•.
                                WR- goJaLal-D\
        lN 'THE CoURT OF              CRIM\N~L ~PPEf\LS of 1cxAs

               Ex PARTe          PER\~1        PAT Tti\SOM              :tt    11.07 6iJJ

     ~DliON lifJ)liES.TJNG Rt.HEARiNCi W'\ll-\ AN EN \~ANl PAtjEL

        Pursuant t~ rule. l11.1 o{ T.R.A.F\-1he. ClPPeJ\an-t resPectt.J\'1
reg_ u e.:d s an en       baA C.   Pd t1e I (e    he.(3 r·~nP\'tca r'\i's a\le'='l(:lt.ICH'\5    ·aV\j ffe.J\clcJ f'(oc~ c.m                      fcJC10rcl ot Cof\Sfl-

iuit6na/ (ish-t.s violations o{ ihc: St:~.-th anJ fou, teeV\th r-\n·1enclrrwni·s.

     \.Or. M,:1a:h !l~:ZOI~ ·th~~J hcW\C;r~:1b\e Cour-1 ·~~;,·jut~ Cln occ\eu {u~
-the tria\ Cc.uri it c.~eterm.,/\c, -,~ JPPc\\cHe CouVI~e\ ~UfSl~ed 9.0.R.
w·,+}'WUt Curi.5Cnt cJ -the ClPPl'JCdn+ arv\ i~ ~a,J P. 0. R. blac\c.t'd
(jpp)\Cu\'\-\: s 'f)( 0 ~-;,(? e. 0. ~-' The il'\d\ (()U(\ f'ounc\ -the d(\;~L                 Joe~ Ylut ollow h:jb{·~ci                  ((:rresCv\rJiioY\.

        -~. The -tria\          Coi.Hi          c1tt~l:viP·ted      tD    ji.J.J·\'~~~         \'\oY\-CoY\sul-taiioY\

io'-d    Ce:.LlV'!Se\
                         1
                         .s cxcusr.:           c.A   3   le?Ja\    Cls.s.ts·tani CLu,~uY~,houf\JeJ,

tX.Cu~e.::~      du nc;i       e.Kcu~,e         c,r JustA.'::\ C.o'I\Stitutior\3\ fect.U.I(efY\i?i\tS                            o"t
CoY\~L..~.\tcif-161'\ (\ecce'::t~C:lrl!J t.)r d~ct1Ve. Clssi s-taflce dl'\d due. Pf6ce~s,
C\~'\\1 Coullsc\or -i~ re1ui'fcd to Co;'1~)u.\t 3V\d 1r.JOrYV\ 8 c\1el'lt {or
{e~\e2lentCli-IUY\ c\V\rJ fkt.s Coufi Wd:i (\u\ held                                 to    ~\,1\dil'\:]s Ce(JortV\ ,:'JtCI-\e   W~ether ihe1e we.re                                 I':J-sues or

    Ylui       Per. \.Cc.P. Jci.           1\.Dl ~ecC~)Cc'J

         l(.    1he.   ;jppj·IC@Yii       ·~~ C11f1i\e6 Tt. c\ue       'Pf6C.es.s   JV\~ shc;u\d

     I
    +he        recUJhted      tr.   e)d:\C    Reheof\1'\C:\.

                                                                  Pew1 P3t1 ef:scn:ll- )LoT'J\ A\
                                                                  Te\{ord Un.1i
                                                                  S2'1cl SfJfe t\0..)'::J 'i&
                                                                   Ne_w l\Dsto1'\, lY 7SSlO
                                                         ·.• ..
                                  WR- 60i~L1l-Ol
        IN·rHE L0URT 0F CRIM\ N~ l                        ~ PPEALS         CJ f   1 E. xA~

                   Ex PARTE. PERR'/ PATTERSOM :tt llo7 oi}_ \

     t-1\DliON REQliESTINC:i RtHEARINCl W'ITH AN                       EN \~ANt PANEL

        Pursuani t~          rule. ~1.1 cA- T.R.Ii.F\-1he JPPe.l\ant resPect~u\\'j
(e9.ueYrS          an    en bc11'\C Pdt1el n:~he.c3rin   w·i1-'i o{   hdbeJ~ Co{PU~,
h[jwt?.ver,-lh·,.') Jec·,~~ol'\ -~~') Cordraf~ to Ur,.tl:ed ·:;·rdtc:_~ ~uPfei'Y\e
Lc.ud·      P(ece.:.\ev1+~      aV\J       Prec.;c\ev'lt.s o{ +~-i:, \'lonord~J\e loud·
                                       evel/\
 d s 1ht'. i ( i aI c0 u d clea(I ~ cl n J pla\(\ ILj M acL~ f' ·, Y\ JIn(:1 ') i (\ t:hJ ~'( cJ
                                  .                >          \   I
-t- he_ Jrr I·,ca rrt's ;~\ IeSJiiC)I'\5 aV\d ff6'-.il0\ed fl(oc)~ em (c'C()n~ o~ co(\s~ -,_
                                                                           f\                i   (\

     \. 0(\ Mda:h l d-.) 201~ ·tht.") .hC;t\(;rC\b\ e Couri t~;;")ut~ Jl'\ orc\eu {or
-the tria\ Cc.urt ic determ.tf\t:', ·,~ dPPcl\cHe Cc.uv~~e\ Pursued 9.0.R.
LJ·,+hcut c sent c~ -the ClPPl'tCdrrt Ct(\c\ i ~ sa·,J 0. 0. R. b\ocled
                   Gl\

                                            1

(jpp)-\C.Jf\1 ~-;,
               1
                     {)(L)   ~':It' P.IJ.~- The tria\ (Gu(\'{ou.ncl iht ar,'~L honorablE' Loud :.)+a+e~
-tha-t ,+he JrPlicarrt m·,:.'l\1\t bt> t:'Vli.lilt'rj ft:. (e\,e-f \~ ·~DI.tvld to \oe -true'
           };rial       Cuu.it b(clel'ec\ CiPPc\\a-tt CouV\s.c\ ·1-o PffSci/\i                                          of\         d-\~lde\v.it
 ·1o L.\h',Lh           CctH\5';,t?\      s·fatc:d uVIde.v oaih /swai'c.                            fo   -tha-t     \0e ci·td Y\o·\
LCH'l'Sulf           l~d~         -the Jer)·IC0J(\l         Jt     dl\ a4'tti              D'I\C'Lt      JPrea\      {\0(       Con\Je~         d

 11"1-t'etllt'\0·/\ tG           ti)e a pu.K.             (\c:,r   PfuJ.1de d.              Cc.P~) cs\         :::.diY\e -To    i~e.
;}ppl·~c.~l'\f. Ever':J Jet L.A' JPPel\Jie                           CuuJ'Isel             t~\\s      bclt.u fe8sondb\e
 striAd3rc.t::..

      1. Th.,s i'lof\or,;~h\e Lc.ud ~fdf\i-ed -t~e JP\)\·,c:ol'\} \eoue tc-Pde
h; .s DLA) (\ P. 0. R. Pw se wheV\ -t ~C' Lour -I c:'J ( Gl V\-f e d Pr u <)c e.x-f evYsiol\
io --t'l\{:' Pro Sc                   P. O.R. a{\J susPe/\5-\(~l\ 0~~ \.R.A r.                                       C\.?-.JCb')
             r       \\ ,,               .          1                       "                                           \       .        ..
 SPeci'\.ICrJ ::1 ·tu                redut.:e   CoP-IeS lor P(o 5c Pei\tio,,e·r                                     or\d --tV\t'rt'+crc
f..(   red       ·If\ JcceP\·, vl)c.J      J    P. 0. R.       frt)r/\ Couv'Lse(                  0( .:Jf\'j    Per.so      n   othe.r

--thJl\ -the:          £)pp)·iCJVH         Cl~ ·Text:l~ clue~ VJut o\\oG.' h~b~"·,j                                  ((::PresCv\fdilon.

                                                                      ·.• ..   ·

        ~.        TMe tr1a\ Colu-t                   dtt~lY.~Pied                   ft)   J\J5·\'·~~~     \'\N\-C()Y\sul-ta-tioY\
bYl Ce:,uV\Se\               1
                                 s   cx:cuse     cA       3 \e:Jd\ c'?ls~::,·tstC\rd q_L.u-\\(\tj,houevcr .
l!..X.Cu~e~) cL~ nui e'f.cu~.. e                     or     ju.stA.(:~             to'(\Stltut\ot\C\\ fccLU·I(eMI?tlt.S                       o't
CoY\~LJ.\tcif-ICJV\              flt:cce'::LC:Hl!l   t_)r dect1Ve ass\ ::daf\ce Jfld du.e.                                          Pfoce~s.
a~'\':.J     Cou.!lsc\or I':J (t'£-lulfcd tb Cu:'\su\t                                    c1V\d    'ln+or\'V\ 6l c\lev'\t {M

{e~\e~eV\tCit-1 0Y\ 3flrJ th'1.s Couri WCl.:':l fiu(e                         ':)uc\.,.

  I                   '     .
+Vie    recLU.Este . :A   tn     f.ldt\C   Re hear\v'\C::L

                                                                 Peff':'j     P3t~ecsor,:t )loT~\A.\
                                                                 Te \{or J L\ f\.11
                                                                 7.,'ar:
                                                                  _,~  'Stdte 1·r\G.) '::\ '\··oc::,
                                                                        1 \

                                                                  Ntw beYS~ o 1'\ J ·yx:. T:O S lo
                                                        ·.•,.·

                                                     - 3 ·-