Court Opinion

ID: 4054999
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 06:21:04.240421+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:00:27.573809
License: Public Domain

~his d~cum~ntcontains so~e-COU/?1 °               _f._   C. RII'Jl.LNA I,.._EJeE£8_1.. 5           RfG~~lp -D(.,
    _I -ges .that ar~ of P?or quality              _ll.u_S'_[U\L1_fa_tLS__                       COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS ,
    · at the time of 1magmg.            __c...ttu.~ c
                                                    _-__ -N_o,_L/___
                                                                 119oo~r:______                          MAY 04 2015          rJ'-

     1~H«u:ro.e.J:I-6..B_B.8.ff_f:lf_/\l
     _ j~                               R:IC;for-
                                                                  ·§        _5-M_fJ-J €
                                                                                   OF_
                                                                                             _:f-:3~-D~~I\!00~~&-r               j
     1.H!JBB.t~_c:_o_v.M.LtJ)J_s_rJ.?.Lc,._[ __ ~- ·                  §            i-1 A.Rfo_s__c_tJJJ.A.LcY_, {..c_ :?!~   _s__J
     l c l~i? t, (_ tiBlS_D 8_N I (;£ L . '                          f:.       .       -                                         I
      I                                 tt-e.~ pbhdtlf\~'       \_ '!'$    .                                                     I
     ;.-__P-Lll.IN5..!_£f_!_s_()_e_ J_ G::IAIA L fl e_ f1LC_B T/ I).N_ _F oJ?_~R'II_ _Of_ fJJ_B/IJ DBlrl uS_"-
     .~:fo_: __ f_t/.G_N_DJVD_R.BJ3b_&:__s_~ D& ~ D f S IH _Q__ r:_o_u_(?-'--1'-

.   ----~-<~J!tc-5_/Y_e>y.J C.hrJs-fo.pne.r _ BCirte..·V) 1 f?e.l4ho.~~-:··-P-<'D-S~---•D_tke. i
    _:.f/_b_ov e._s 1- r-fe..d_--~nd_r1 ~Jt~:tb e.- ~ee.it_~_cv~s e.. _o_t_q_c)) e>.Ja~~-~;,_J_£ae:s_f:bi.sJ ·.
    -1~-0·~Jgtne,J Cipp/l'e,~}(on__ f'o~- wr)J· of Man_d_a_fny_s·--J-f-u>PSv.OJJ_LLo_J
    _-_r.:td:.Lc_/e_iL. D 7_3(c..J ..0 e. fhe.. {~)(a $ C, o~ 0 f~C:. -r ir:'1i.>Jet I Prt:!Cced v ..-.~1i
     ,:_O!ld We>u/d __Sh_t'-w. l:k_('.d?>_v_v::Lth~_E..oJJ.~w 1 Y1J-~-                                        __
     ::___R~Le,tor ,~c_hf"i.r fop.her B.as:le-YJ _Jt. i.S-7D6!i l __ ;_,s_ QVl__O f.f'e.v:'lde._r-_Lo_j
    -~ the. [~_4s_SH..p.o.d·~ ~ "'} o£ LV' im_j!J qf .J'._,s} lc. L C/ nn-Y+---(~_X-05. _]_S:$.8'6 .. Re/4/Di::-.. bo_s-c-e:D~C:!IdSh:d        I
     ~. hi~ rerv~ed/es an.d..hc,sJIO ofha ttd 1~ c.o rn p e ue.d is f(1 in is f ri 111 i _n ~ _ __ __ ~
    ::. di. scr-e.f /0 neuy: ,~n_ no.ll.2v:e...... ..                . ·- --       .. --.. .           -. ---! .
     .:_ .. _i?e,spD·ndetr1.f__1 C.h ~\s _DCirJ/eJ-1 1-lo r·r)s County _])fJtrl~td· ___c_}_~ck._-Lj
     ~..i.n__ -),;,L a(i't_;_{:.iCf/ ~.C!p&r:.ly    qs  o,·sJ.rjc.i Clerk _of rlorci_s__CDuY\hy__,__ j
       :.f~)(Q"S_ .has k M;nls}:d~_l_dllfy io. r~-~;-~_ve.. __ and .. F\L~_g_U_p.ctf--e_c.~ I
    __-_,~n-4_Cc)..rn_i YJaJ_P- f" o.c...e.~e.._di?J_1 __qn_d _p ~~-~ Q.~J~__[cj]_IJ_~tbe r duG e,_s_ _J
      .::_l:l'Y.\pos.u:J_cn fbP... . c..ler t by Itt~ f-Y .r5 uc,.,l_k,_~L.C._"f--o.rl. _2.." ],.,J__j
      ~~-nd_iLr.~.pQn~t~.i.e_uY'I clec._f' (.._c.._e. _aJ:L _lLP-:l__.s_e__c_.,._?,_(_c:,.,-:J_.fey        ·_J
     i-'·YY1 m-e,dl fl:re._l_f- frQn.S_m:~_t__fo_the.. (oJ.L'cLof. C_~_,·_~_;_o~d__llpp.e..l!ILs_gJ_~e~-r-Y-~
                                                                  I                                                  .
                                                             .                                                                             I
    ~-Q£ }~e c,pp fl'c..ad-ion _f_o_'C _{;;)_~~_+_eLf_ L, tJ_b_e._c,S _C~-~ftaJ1 _Q.n_y_e,_n,L~l e..Y-S__ j
     iJ~_,1tt.L Q v.~. d _Q . t. er ~I Fir:_ c,k ve t..i ~i ~.         I '1'?.._ dq k~r-.o 'l)_ -~ t,J_0_~_tk ('J . ___j
    -;tl~n d'1 w cts __ M gde_ __ j_f_f-k _L.. l'Y) v; c.f/y C.o ~d_de_c..i.des_!'b_e-_rl!._CLce._YJ o J
    t-L~.Sue...S_Lo_b~-~· oI v·~cL._t:.h "')_r_b_anieJ__ c cro_be__:_r_estc.. b_e..!l_~,LL.b_~is__j
    .
    L_b_a_v..ti_,~.J1 _1/_a r t:.is_e..ouY-liy__ Q)~St-rlr.:.i __i:/.e.rt .oLH_a_ r r·, _s- C.DL! ~-tV;_ f e 7< QS.
                                                                                                                       I
    !                      .                                                                              .            I
    1-&. ~._'B_o~--Y6-~L1_ J/_o_tLs_kn )f ?~_g5_1 ")_2,J0__ ~4._6_.r_J__._..                                           l

    ~---'Lhe_ Rupc>n_dCI.nf                             vi6}e,}e.d -Arlic.le 'L_,...2.J of }he.    -f-e..)(~s. ~d_e.J
    ~_Qf___C~\_YY"\ i_nqL Pmce..d:u_\f'.e.. __by.__ F~~ h"o/ _I.e_ _ p.co_v,f1e.__ i_'b_e__f(e1~1(!Jv::-               I
    .! ~ h· · L . i                                            ~ ,··t.\
                                                         ·{}J _vv         "·     t:::).j CJ~" ~ 1 '·k            •r I
    --~...__..r.)S[Df-Y!~'C _0
                            _u {J .rft:,l'J.
                                     L       . R }_~ 7_06.1
                                                 iJ     ,;
                                                                   llt"l .Y~'--0-,- y _ _rcOTCI.C-_ _ _r_\_\..>_7..26_~~
                                                                                     f"'
                                                                                                   T
                                                                                                                        rJ)

    Lta~.,~d o,.-& red_ rt££ida vi:f_ _Vp0Y) rec_je, vi Yj S cr i~ aff} dtl vi f pv'('Syq ..-J. I
    ~ te> Ge>_u,rt 0 fde -c_2,jx>e.d_m" _r~b__ }:/1_'2.- ~ l LJ ~ _____                                                                   l
    L mr ~J3_4:Jlt·n__h 95 s~"t __!:t_le)ltAS_1_ ic,_J._o_'fJC_dab:L_mtca:,b_Z._s;_Z£21.l_j
    I          . -           .                                              .                                                             I
    ~-4od ~keel __ }he. _:;.J~~rls                fe> _;,oY't'lfPiV- _c.rJttb_tk~-c           "1>.:.~t_Qrder ._ __ ~r).c___c/e...-k
                                                                                                                                  1
    l_t.o:n}inL?eJ k_ r-wpond ..w~}\... ... ~ n(;/c..e:... a_f_ ..Se_c..b. .on 552. .. t)2K_ ____ __l
    l &"I'JV e. . Yltfl_e-...+ . c. <>dR._C/I'!.d_r:'l.plL;;,~ fo ~v:r4hCJ se__ S_l"i_i_d, _cJ {)_<.:- u vne-.\':1ts_, I
    ~-C.h tl s   j) tt _n   i~J       _I $_ -~1 __d1 f:e.._cf__v_i_o./QttO.~_oLt...c_ c.._P--11d . _?- .. 2_1_ _q ~ d _ ;~            ..
                                                                                                                                       1

    __\i1~ ed-icn·~ D F Cc~..Ld__r)_'C_de c_.S:,iJ_n_e.-sl__ tYl CJJ'C...b~ 14_1 ~ Jlj_c_ CliO c:-e·-r~v~:uj-                         J1

    '       ·                                                 r        1 ~ I ~L •' '' ~ 11 'I H
    ~~_avs.~JtJJLL'f_of2_- c_                  . . _f.l.efJS~ ~ee.. e~o'b.'rs A:J __B__ ._c.. _______----;,

                                                                                                                                      I
l            -~-            _. ~--f>RF-lY               c-fi f'ot_ RS:LIG' (               . ___ __ ~                                 i

l           W.ite...c.e...foJ::..e. _p_r-ce_b'\_i_s_e_s_C,C>Vl_kd!!- r~_tce/ fllo./'_1 _ c.J, .r:iflopb ~r-                           I
 Ls~trf..e_YJ -P-~ v~ -Hll]tth___ ~J ~ ~- of mfAY/dam u s_b_e,._J:ss_l.L~d_J· n_tb)_r_j_
                                                  t{_

 l_m.r. fLecLo .£cn·c'i?..~}Jte._tLt<.d.~oE...JltJ rc:i S~_CQul'l/_»_,~r~ ()5_j Cl p.IDrnt*~
lf-!-...':" !bn21 hIs.-~ l.nl.d!'ierl _dvkc~ > pvrfu C1~ f f:r) cu.f, 2. .L-J t1 h ,J.__ l

/..:.1!1r~~ 2zb (                 g   ff_;_&_vJ_f__ c.._o_ Y1 ce r-.nJ.o/-- _C_fi:':! S"e__ t;i_J.}l/J/_00 - c:_.,___..-._    --=-
,
I

I                                                                 2...
                                                          __Eg__s_ Oe_t:JJvJfy . SV   bfl1~ 1-/e.d- ---- -.r--
                                                             ~f~                       ..          ·--.

                                                          ___C.b r \_~}e_p_l'J_e_c_B.fl_de.,:-.1_#.Lr_7 66_'/J_
                                                          .___ J!l l~cJ~:er~Lu_njl_
                                                                                  1 _2._6 6 '::/_f_'fYJ_ZJU'/1
                                                           ..:Le.on ~.i1e.:..e.._c.o kit1,_¥,_L.exgs_7..£ ~«>6. .

 __cev:l_i_eic..~-1(_ of s~,. vic__e._:
__J._lt_e dy_s_erl;_r_y_&,J)Lt/_f_c.v ~-CA.P)j- o£ ~~ i r ap.p ifc:._~_b_u-~ib~loof__
..,_t-:xb~l.bfr5.-&,_~_)_c.,_l\.l/:.o.c._6~J__f0_c,_.s_r.tul11Jed_by-u.s~-Yfi fJ.JJ_iD.---"!,_____.
_,_C.Jr~LLD_o. y,)e.l;_Hcu::c.i.._\_C_ou:v:.\ ~ y_f:lJslr:~:cLc.Je.-:r-k-----------..---~
~e_e_Box_zt6_r_z    ___ -------
__ /l@_slo.a1_L.eD,_g_,_s_______
                 J
__7.-.:J_(l_./_()_::_-,_6_~-'-------
            li
                                                                                                 t;~

_Q_t')_th"ts 2.9/..ll d_a_V- £3 f_li.p.:r~.d 1 _ZCJIS',

                                                            c ~ )-•..Sfophe.r B tirk.n
                                                            #   )S7D6ft J

                                                    3
                                                                                    rn o r c.. "' -z_ '-1 ~ ·z_u, 15
     _0 e. 4 v' C. I e.. r f.;. o P f ~ e (. o u r +1 _:( Jr., c. ve p r e. v '·o ~... . s ) y 5 e l/Yt yD u
 q Covple. 1-eJ-j.r,..~.; 'Crj'k~~~J f:·u /-o 5-c..vld Me.. a ~G?J oP_ Pc-fn~c.k.
  J',f<,_.~z:z.,(':J'S aPt\dc,v;J. ,q,,Jc,t (...)[;) Oy·J~J-ed i)v th~ C-()vf'·f Por
                                                      1
 C.uL>Se_ /r/C-. !11/qoa, _£.f):; Purrhc.-r 0\~cJe-l~ed n f/tlq-1- fk. c/e_.tk. of
 f-loe_ Cov."l i ~ lr:J Sz.VId Cl ::.opt oF St:~id Ll r·p;J Ct vi j fo !-),,.,_ 4 p?)! (c,,,l J
·cJ1,-)s Burl"'"::../'1 tJ /.f7Dt;t'fJ .. (ot._,J s~'"}~ t/J·~ a no~;ce. of vc:.Pwsol
 bQ~ed O)'l fL::_ Puh/l.C.. (.'(c.o:~d--:;. /)c-:-f l?ule.  d o .-de ··eel _c; f·Y ()( -' q,d cd/,'cl av' f by fof rH-k
. Rvz.Z-0 0)1 :au')~--14 jJI/9oO-C. rte.. l}·~d.9?.. oF' H;c. .-:___)l.)>f S;jn.d fhe_
 · Cb ~"d~ ,- o t·l _ /Ylo ,-(.Ji I Y; '2--:) J 'I . :r {,v ~ l/ b?... Qdd l)y f·l~;~ }- /e.lf~~ ,-- o1'1d r~­
   /-we; p ('ev /Uv~ h. He r5 1-o Q l!_,J 1.--j ~ c r ' tVJ 0 v1J 0 VVIL/~ 0 \ :(;;<,'/,)- bi ~ A,) e.,~ ~'

                                                                      '
                                                                  5   '_n c e ;'e yJ

                                                                   Chv. .·l~ Sc,~~fe.Y)        #tS'706Cf/

   ._;,,
        '•'

                                                                                             ..,.     s57              2
                                     ·,   '

-       .•. --~.-Di Ox·~f2LSJ ._:_i__\..L _c_j~_1"'k__l ·.. ·_ _ _ _ _ _ _ ____:__-----'-'--------"~~-
              _           __.l·r~ r.:;._~s..g~C>.'~).s_rc.__to_tVJV---'L~1;;v-~(} Fcrr            .'·he :.c;p._y_ ··or _rv?,,
                  Ptt I rr G 1 i          c.: L_::_._o L>Ll_i)LcLLt::ec.J    Ct I!   cl',J c v; /- )   .-(   r-t' I L;Jlc.d,__a_...L......__~_
                  AJ  o;,·c e.. o [ __s_e._clL~cx~·~----s:.,_;;" 1._~_-z i? &-_o__uL__!:___u_d~l~'tlSleJLct · ~/' /)')1!-~-
                dur .. c_ 6P-V ,, o l !~e.. 6 Ff} d_ av·: +. flu_.s~S'-te ·;.h~!f;l.,e_.0,1_ _ __
                Cth d · d_ Ci) e d                i?
                                             r.d e v 11 o_L!lJ a r Lk£L,_ L. ~ 1 LJ )1--c ~-WJ~_)J_:__~)e.o IC_L)!_
            _ fee. 'tbn~·__tb_:~ ;:._L~k~_,2L_/h~_C.frD.rJ I s~fr_b_6_1(}__GJ:)__fD S_~d___                             . __
             _ 0 .C.0p~_Q_f_tb}_~2:c de r fo_t\--,:~pl ic_ ; ~~"I; ~ J1 ;·J ,-J.ap_b. "-- 'e
                                                              1      1

                                                                                                                                   ,.__r·_·_

             _,·8 (A f' fe Y) j::/ )S~20 61J .., {'J')_t.lurl_e__cL~ \f\ t\) i \" 0 tde_£_.IL& v-k.h.!........Y._/'_ __    1

          ·__ · s}c4lu... J\,~J__- W~t'h ·/he af£1~L~~~l Df PcJ{~)e:.L~-·
                  .          '                    l    .        .                                  .
                                                                                                                                               --c-----
                                                                                                                                               1

             __ r-e ·:: <-l·,"""J_rj)JL__ cl-e ; k_U~.OJCJ)_G:_fS__eti_b_j~~-.:t..vx;LtLr.- 6p_y~J.J.__-8_·_
              _..i.hl~ ft; dCd~JJ fo ___fbe_:_4f?3-p !J~L.&.t·' -f a Y\J -LC~-p-)1-1-cL.JJ,·L~f a~'----
-•          -~ mI(' ....Jf\x7... '?.- ~- /t, Q d_cn'JLJL~3...6.~d£LY' r Jo f, '! C, s Ct ~ d a£fJ CJ J~ f. ~~~-
           - cz.r .· of /YJ (J r· ~"b-~12_0_Llj_\~(f ·1 .~ · 1 J_D Q·. , ru Vl_i:_/_6_r2~ lj ··-~-
           _-__Eie C!~e. ~ :f?._\.~~b.L- C._OtJv-t as:de ~y-,-l}~Ci/ . S u f-·e r S_ed-:-e_<;;.,~~­
           - .S e c_·fJ ilh ,£5-~~~~.g- (6_o'v). C. t~d_e.._,'- . . fl;,cn'-~ls. )0 L,.;

                                                                                ,SJ~·)~-e.re ;Y---~--
            ------,----~·                 _·      ~\J.      ·   ·        _   . · C /i r.I)~Cirfe.. ~-, Ji J.C'2f.S!_6 t?'--'-1--,------~
                                 C/-~y-K Q\ · o'a.t ·
                                  f·vf'ie. ,o,.!l.~-.~-~.--_·--~i/(· .~
              --~-                                ·---'·         .       ·-            ~~-=o=li~~,_=...._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
                      _      ____:_ _ _ _·            y:_,~\ ~----'--~--------c------------
                                       tf -~\p\

            _ _ _ _____ic..f                               ------

-   ,
        ·- --------·~.,...--,.                -

                      -~-------------------.,-------                                                                           ·-~----=-·---·

                                                                                                                                        '
                                                                                                                                                   ----
     -------:---- __ -· C en.) ~ ~- # j iii C) o o - c_                     .f{)C,)j._l- o_, z._o 1:,_J~... _ _
·---.b~£1-~'-'-~-c./;._) ____________ --· ·- ----- ---       ----- --,---·
         -~ f.~{'_ &o_\_;~~~~~g_c__e_p¥-o_t_thc__CD:vd 0 -rder fD f_tA flu1.' ~
                                                                     1      11
    ·
_p-te>\rn -KD.u-r ()_ffi c~_~ 0~ r  F!>-!' t\:>£.-_r:.Je. rk__[o_s~I-YJ.d_~c_(J_,Ji__j)_~ S:c..\_d_a.Q'da_~__!_~_i'-'-6. ._
                                                                                                       . __
_ -fu_~-~p\.U-.caLC?-~J:.e.._JJ~t~~ler~-te.CLLv,eL_S ~f lt'~U:L_Lb.,._e,____~
__Q_u\er     iJ OS.~L,9-'I'l1,d_J:Y1tJ r ~l').:._l_Y_)_ZD-L9_h~_i__)tg_lfJh"Jf-P ~
                                                                   tiJP-. /{_\.;7.:7-~
  ·so daY- f-2--~'le>ri_ hll£_/.fLr-Sr~.o, -e/e o~S_e_lJ_a__ttYJe_i-b~.c.._o}jl-o.~l-
_m"', ft~tE?r-u;;?. ~ ti_iErdc, 1/) f 4~"--d(? ~d___Q._Lk_~~v dr~,                                         ·
---i.b.&-Yl.L'f.DI..L__fM' fD l/ r b_'l'fk_._QhL£_/~Y b 1;._[~~-u.-~q'----,.-=-d_ ____,
_/Q__,_o_i2_v l~S:Pffi-JS..7     :J/;_j_S'/C>6'Ll,_ _ __

_ _ _ _ _ /0~·-·- - -

                                                                                                      ;'
                                                                                                  ;~
                                                                                                  '