Court Opinion

ID: 5561825
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-01-11 00:52:06.161579+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:35:29.641569
License: Public Domain

Blandford, Justice.
The defendant in error brought his action upon the following instrument in writing:
“ Augusta, Ga., January 30, 1882.
“Mr. W. M. Dunbar, secretary and treasurer: You will please pay to A. N. Porter, Esq., four hundred dollars, balance due me for wages by Steamer W. T. Wheless and owners, and this shall be your receipt. (Signed) W. T. Gibson.”
Across the face was written,
“Accepted, when funds in hand. (Signed) W. M. Dunbar, Sec. and Treas.”
There was evidence submitted, going to show that the Miners’ & Planters’ Transportation Company, of which Dunbar was secretary and treasurer, owed Gibson four *35hundred, dollars for wages as captain of the steamer Wireless ; that Gibson made the draft and delivered the same to Porter, and that Porter procured the acceptance for his own convenience, and without the knowledge and consent of Gibson.
Where a draft is given, directing the drawee to pay absolutely a sum of money to the payee, it is the right of the payee to have an unconditional and' unqualified acceptance of the same; and if he chooses, without the consent of the drawer, to take a conditional, limited or qualified acceptance of the draft, he thereby releases the drawer from all liability on the draft. See 1 Daniel, Negi Ins., §510; Ohitty on Bills, 340; Byles on Bills, 316; Story, §204.
We think the non-suit moved for in this case should have been granted. When the payee took an acceptance different from the tenor of the bill, without the consent of the drawer, he could not recover against the drawer. { The drawer was merely a surety for the acceptor, he being an acceptor for value, and not an accommodation acceptor; and taking a conditional, varying or qualified acceptance by the drawee, without the consent of the drawer, was to his injury; he had a right to have notice of any change by the drawee in the tenor of the bill, and if he did not consent thereto, he is discharged.
Judgment reversed.