Court Opinion

ID: 9730639
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2023-08-26 15:19:12.018141+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T15:07:57.399212
License: Public Domain

Grimes, J.,
dissenting: In my opinion, a public official is disqualified from voting on a project when either he or his partners are employed by persons who are interested in or are affected by the project, and such disqualification does not depend upon the employment being directly concerned with the project itself, or upon proof that the official was actually influenced by the relationship or what the attitude of his other “master” was regarding the project, as suggested by the court.
In taking the position that aldermen Branch and McLane were therefore, disqualified by reason of conflict of interest, I am by no means suggesting that their votes were in fact influenced by improper considerations, for in my view it is the existence of the relationship itself which disqualifies regardless of the good faith or proper motives of the official.