Court Opinion

ID: 4039110
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:07:02.285554+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:03:51.087655
License: Public Domain

Y/, 7©{/©¢
j/A_f!ua_nj 95,3;0/5' /

{¢>;MLHDnomé/c £LUK af~/*l/»¢,{o[am/s:

:l:n fL:A.¢>’plaLm/)¢S Amm¢le_c{ /£}'pP/IA¢L lon par L£)n"£ap Ha£)w,§
Ca/{ALL$ jl§l-LJ'SI_L¢L)'\‘)*-}0 Ar-»l'\'//~073\{&\€0JL£/)m.pfo€m
' Quéx,A/o\ ;(OQ"/ "40552’+3 ’I//

éfu:}mjas CLL/Lh£/LML[OS€L/ L)LULL u))'[/ F/LA_S£, )Dmcl/
/)/0 //a,m%`s Ol)/e,dmns 150 *b’/a./ cow/5 gmc/mas 0;1£41_!
Mfcondmznns mo /au) m /:ALLSL/)O. 3004“‘/05§343';?
)O/Mse, p;/a, mud Dé) afm-ns mfa/fmb m'f#,¢mr,{
/o/ese,n$'suc,//) 143 »L/mo/A, /L{Cow$ an /¢5 gaf ¢{A¢j{ ap
bas/ans.. 05 LL)Ll/, hcfa Ulcjc)su! Lfau_ u_)/"l// {A/LASL ,B¢r)cl
` calz)._j DF'H¢/s /z:}’-l’e/ )D/w`se, )0)'/¢/ $vLA/w,o par /L£,o/¢{ §L)ou)mg
D/ofu_}u;ms -).[D é)e,/U_£L\/L¢{i F//Lcl) Mcl/A/£$L!)'/?_cl 7€) C(_'JLL/~/‘
)D/me/ /L:Lum SAJC{ mpL/ ¢n me,m 511/f A.¢M/L£${/¢[
5//¢1/2/)/0¢¢[ wJL/opa, mr_/asw[. .L/; `7/1/)004& 4}0¢.¢ par your
}m/)L ¢ma/ Au.)¢u‘/' L}az_u/ 070/aj
ilwu/bill

mML\.z/S/,
alw/JLL¢J/Mm£/;z§z‘)z:z

KQé¢/fson /Z'T'?/

/20`7/ T//M 3522
nbi/m ,,, nw mm UY§GC;§M.;EM§LS
- jAN 29 2015

_Noe% Acosta, O\erk

aims e., l\/Q.Q\OD"'“"/'OS,Z)L/`z" F

ExP¢)»He § IMTHE lm'“z>/smm“ comm
§ op
gwMJmMM%n¢L § uch comm 175/ms

/)PPum/dfs nimmo/05 m me mm cows
~f/mo/,o@s op mcf mm mucws/o,\)§ DF mm w me mzo\/€
601/fmb omni

’)/D 77-}5 HOAID/LHUZ COLLU OFCHJMl/OHL, HPPEHL$;

H]b/)/zc,/.\_/r{’ p,/LS “H/u$ /’)).S D§¢M:hms '&n ‘H'\c,-é/m,/ coa/vt`§
¢lnAm§S ap Fo.f.,‘lb Mc) COHC,IUSIO/)S D`)C La_u) H’l ‘H’)L A/é)O\/L m’
»'HH¢.J ZAES*:}`l/h)s 15 novL;[$ `l/lq:z!m: L._)ri!z);l')/Lé)mj cjg>u-s\

`7/€, Lb/U) amc LS ’i is¢m"'mL/l -L Qé“
/mAJL¢o)/) opm Ll)r»‘% op Ha.[)w`$ Co/;n_u.$ lj>LLf$LLA.J/V)Lvln L“Qc]i//L 07;:>,1
7ax./.1.s CD¢/e, ap Cnmm¢/ )D/oc,l¢{u/L.)D/ULSL¢A:/*/’Ml/\LJ F} A:f’#é».

{l')a, clam/as Pn_sm»ha/ m LL)/»"f EAu$¢,n,o.JOO‘l/L/GS,Z‘{€)“F
gould L\/_Q]/ //)Ne/ blm p/Gm%ul m a_/h?¢ fJ/UIOLLS a)m¢ )a»/
/q/j lQ'/)/o/Iaa_n% EU’_ALLSLHL LL)LL$ fl-GJ’ U.A~}l/ OC;/'oé>£/ a'.sabuunt u,)r."f'as mn:}rue¢/ é)Lf +l?z,
fr/A,/ coLL)/“A QppllCAA/f has m€,{i al/ ‘H/)e_rubw/Lm¢nr/S ap

/})4. //- 073.
F))Apllc_¢m% psz H»ns Cour$ ¢)FC/.m.m./ 473/aids jmn$

fnl/ap mci f con AH £aa)’@{) q¢/ou_m:/s é)e£,m$cxl%cqr!a /;LN
umw ~/./Ex.aoAEaM./%oc/m/\Lm11.01§4¢ MA //`073

l

CEKF'H’/ICME OF SELVICE

I, EL_{L,JM¢Z [u,MaJ%/m.z,, healy Su)w cudd penal-hi op
/>wJLL/y #H/)A}a, copy ap 099/mallis Oé>!a:)L/ows 153 -E/m] co¢,u’-/s
Hmlmq.§ op ¢Mj mal £o/)c,/u§lon:s op La.a) was mdu/ul VLO ‘//hc,
£Le/KJDFH?¢/f¢xas Cou/¢DpC/)mma] #ppm/$ C/Jo/)`[ows¢/
)Dcafson////on‘ nbc/ /}cos~h_)'orl '/’l/)IS §[a+/”clal./ ofjmuug

201 S`

0¢»}¢.~. ¥a.uw.y 526) 520/5 v €MLW(' XQ?’W /Mjlmz)

111 w nw gaf QAA/,MJ,O,, Por A nw ,,F mm corpus M,
jua/I’f -/'D _A`/?L/cjz, //» 073 .‘TLX_\C£)chc/)/Mv )O/DL.,

NO. 2004-405,843-F 137‘h DISTRICT COURT
EX PARTE _ OF
EDWARD LEE MARTINEZ 1 LUBBOCK COUNTY, TEXAS
Volume I of I
INDEX
PAGE
l. CAPTION ........................................................................................................................................ 1
2. APPLICATION FOR A WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS SEEKING RELIEF FROM FINAL
FELONY CONVICTION UNDER CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE, ARTICLE 11.07 ..... 3
3. EXHIBITS (A through Z2) ............................................................................................................ 21

4. STATE’S PROPOSED CONVICTING COURT’S FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF
LAW, AND RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS ON
APPLICANT’S ART. 11.07 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ................... 50

5. FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ......... . .................................................... 5 5

6. APPLICANT’S OBJECTION TO FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW, AND
RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS ON APPLICANT’S
ART. 11.073 AMENDED APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS, T.C.C.Pn

ARTICLE 11.073 ........................................................................................................................... 58
7. CERTIFICATION ......... 59

lofl

.jMLla-1»‘1j SZB, 31ij

.. 1 nn ~ .. . f _' 14 A
“,7.1.:;'1111.. 1~11:11'101111111 Ll£..l;/'K 113 '1"1/)1;37€.><113 1331,1.1"~1:' 1121 61511':-'11/1131 311111_.1./3;:

w

§

.z_r'z.~“’€..: /1;?1{.”>1111.`.111/17/5 /EW?M£1¢Q/ 1511_1;?111£211~'!11:)/1 1321’ 1_1.31"1 /0_,£ 1“111 13120.15
Cl:)r,~lm§ pll= 5..1.111\/~/1;» /1¢1 11 013 '1/.¢_;€0&@1111. hall
531:.1:51 1110 13013’1 /"1(3353 35

3 .
/’1’11111111‘1§ 1.:131!/1 1551”1; €1”?l1115€341 llli.dl3 l 3111 ,u/lll»_Sll 1’11‘11:1

l

h»*'1{,3!/31/1.¢1/113 531,/1.,£:1’1\,11!,.» 1@1;`.”)1&'[ §§ 1113/1/1/?1'1 5131€ 1'1&11"_3
1113 1511111,1.111311<) 0.1" 111133 114 ll1l/. §12 1413 31531_3"1 "1`1’3§?) 51‘1 5 F_'
103 1532 3 /’:,~112 531._:'/1_311;£/~1}/1.1111~, 133 131 113113,(3151"! 1 l’,”’\1.‘i.1
/:.1/2§2 121/11 513 213 511:) 11-113~/.,;11112 (/321€3.;' 51 D/i 311/53 111 1;;1;161£:{‘ ll`f!g:
bus/r1 lia 1513 llj‘l?-11. 1:?£.1."_ 5/7(;_11_)$€13' ljll/ll 11,3111/113,@1 1111an
l:\;ln,;§,j 131 '11’1/$ 11,11£1;111311‘; 1’)1€’ 5"',:`11 2'1'1,1{11 515 1/€£1_1`.\"¢£1 §1}01,.:)1';".='.§
33}1\;§€¢' lam 153 132/111*1@3\/£,¢1 1:1,1€1/£ a 111/1151 /3)1;:3€_ l_l?~l';;l`/ '/l» (}l)i,£l"i‘. t
1911?31.5£; )l./¢l.!./z/'/` :'1311'£1 l"cl`);£}l;;,z;) ‘[D /-..3"1€, 115 fill/11 11.:1111'1_:1‘1’ '

’51111”1')/:12.;: U)\/€1ch12. llHl/O:»<;c./. ll 71/)/31*1/1:;.11’3£.1 301 l,/l/lllr

'1'1'1’1/3€. 11,1’161 1313/3m ' 17101_! Yl’./i\/Lb¢

£l:§/l) CC:! fix/11 5a11/M1515/'lc1]:

fit/abu 151/2131 /l//li11/:1112.’] /lj j‘/T`l.j`?) Y/
kohl/1530 1'1' 1 "“ 31

/Ll./)"/_'/ 151/11 352._1 ,

1353 /llr) 137/1331 791’§»(`)1

hull 1110 2004 1105 1113 15

E)l./%¢)lle § 1111 THE 13 5 1)/51/1.11;:1 could
§ l).'¢
£05./131.1'0113_¢,.15/1011111¢1 , § LUBBGU<.. £O£lm 51 353(1535

HPPLiM/\jl”'$ 191373?1;1’10,*1‘5 723 7' 135 l"l?lll}l. CULLIL'?“§

1’/111£/)113€,5 01¢ r"/"`lil;l' 1511\1’/,3 C,OA}lll,Uj'/l')/\)S 1315 ./.-131.1_3 113 ’)'HE 9601/6
1;1&1'1'1'1;..€»:1) ali 1156
~’f`l) 1110 11011"1)1.'1‘11£12 lou lll' 13“1'11’;.@1’11111;)1110 11911121112~».

[1/3/:>!11:&1‘)*1 1’112,3 1146 1/31§1_/231;}2&1/01’15 101.1’11_'111/131 6.0131"'15'5
anguij 111 1""111;51 mmi Cc/)c,1lf$101'51 103 L'.clw` m ~11/112 1313£)»1_ 301
213 111_11 l',lLLLSl 333151/513031115&1')5££)'“£3£/)1 11311'/¢1/ 1)&@£0.5 l;£iril>uf)~

11--/11~11,111'1;1'1 l_;nll.l/e;:’> 11111¢1 11 13 1111 31/1“1 mle 1511)¢:11
1111,11.31) 501 13311101' 1111)1.115 (.01/)1.13 151,1,15/111111'-111 M111l1l 11 1373

/l.zl.l»s 1312 051310111111.1;1/3/ 121/1011 15111151; 51l/1~11‘5111.111~l.:11’?11:155&1

11’1£`- C.¢{é';£!)’if‘» Plc.:¢i"“/€_lj 1133 l,z;`*ilf L"ALL§`, 013~¢‘£;(3‘1£1@52‘53 F
l:./:)M.//j 1\1"13”_' 1101/l hell/3 p)l.$lnl[lc1 m 0111‘1£111)1)1;)135 1121:/ 1 1112
vii ;/)[.}/)/,Q!,'J. nl hc{:.£i~.u~$e 15 1,.1.;&`)1!}.51'?£ €...5~1/3°1! 113..(15(;3¥"€/ 6“1{..;5/! il

~--"M _.MM

’11»/ ~5511€£ 1515/111 1112/1113&1'51’/3?17/ l`);'~ln 361€3"3(1£1£:3 1’£/£&.$&’,,.£1 115 1“1110111'1?‘

112110113111:1; 15 i\;l'l)f 13 31.1.1"1<11’1\11£11/1.11111/:> 1101‘13'111.11201’11.1,¢ '1 1/1&
1111011,00115\ 51)1)1/1@1/ 1115 /1)11: 1121 1511/11 /11;:;11111/1/'11111 113

13Ml1 07;. 4
}“3/3/"31: 1501:11‘ 31121?5 1111;'1'11?31,11131 1111”1111“31;111;§£111.'!‘ 1:’,11:2_1’)1, §
1111111,1 031/10 1111€, 1211 1311 mm 1511 1011/mds 1311/llc <' 511/711.3 51311'1.11,
/31‘1`-/“1111"?/ 1512 1535 Cf ft 1_7/11’{/1 .5),5]!:3(: 151111*\1 331 11 133 § 1(_11.`)13\1"101 _1__1_1:§2._,;),
' 14 l_<)l)ll'i'i’ll!,z_/ `51,1"1"_3.’)/11‘45‘11"1 131
31111.41.1)11311,1133‘ 5111)1.,1 _ 150 /3/11?{1. 1317

 

~xn.

camp/mfg of tsmvzcri

__. ‘ , 1 - ~
.Z..l E¢{l.d 414 l.a,¢.. !1//&/1"/)1/..2,, 174/agri S;D£a./ .;mr/r_./ po’?.@./ 11 0 §
PQ,!:}`LUL/ 711/wall LL 613/du op _&Aj§;!CLL/?°I"S ig[’_`d£(.',}'l¢,‘))"'i$ 120 1111 011 (.".OUL/"/§
, . f /, f .} *1 v , l sr - , '
Hm}mqs or //¢La:l M»c/ £cJ/)c,/u§,'<)r;:s 91 L¢Lu_'i was ;~’VM~.//L¢\/ 10 7°%€.

, J ' 1 , . x .
['Lz/k. 01 1174',,"'//£.><43' fmc/1 01 (_::’; :»3/)¢./,':1/v ,Qpp£,!'~/$ fl-/c/I\AOM/:M..-
Pc¢u'soy)/ Hom r%c./ h'c<)$n¢a) ';)z/i ""/'1'2/5. <~'ZL:»`/L'c/a¢j 01 J;u/)u my

SZD/ S` z

1:),0.11-'_ ¥A/UL£LU[J 353 gO/`.:`v 656/b H/(-(j (/3/'(}£. b?/)/!') £Zl/LZ:/;’LL:>/

T.I'i l/ZI~L [11"}’?£.,"“'?../(“.¢/ npl§/'/C¢L'{."U!'? foy .Q. i’='"'l]” ap /'/déf.a;f§ CQ/!;\UZ§ ’~/'?u'.l.}'“’
§_u.a`/H' -/z) f[)[{j;lc,/e_ /"l'. 073 ":/N¢)