Court Opinion

ID: 4055533
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:06:59.821578+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:40:46.306993
License: Public Domain

yo,&&@~@@

 

me>_. C.ch\r~"l' ec C_\r-»Em¢`NAL inpth e-CTQ__)L£LS
in:sQ.L_ Q<_¢QSM_I (’_L_el~l&

Po 1331 17__3@§3 4 HE©EW \
Q~¢os_hj’¢\l / TQT¢M 78 7// @OURTOFCRMN§YPPQ§LS
JUL 13 2015

EG§’ 1`\/.‘¢_'_`{"@\¢~ E’:¢Ain\~fe,l__ Numl&L£l$o$` Wé,
Ah@ié€@$?a,@?@rk
w\\;+ N@. w&e~é@:ss¢/~@ 033/#@5€¢5 /Pem‘

.zal»\//~

"(`;’.'l_e.s.‘l:l~pp/_¢‘c_l;r\??‘_': lee_s.p@lu_se_ /-’mel (:`_x ao_.,c)Y/¢'QAJ/
T;> _S~hl+<>_s l?e_s'p@l\/_se,

I~L§N¢ IQ~£>_Q_[_ Fl~a@.sTn_f

’E~.-¢:L@se_ri pLe»_c>.sQ__ £.‘Mi ’H\e_ a_b@ug me/\D‘/l§/ved /€@_sp@/vd,
DLeb_se$_.‘ ~Q.‘L_L had b\,~¢‘cuj H~ V/D`l%e_ n_Tf'QJ\/`[/]AM tap fAe_ Cd>ur~¥»,

TL»Q_ S`fn_/'L G_¢swuso_.L ~Q,`l_acl fit lQQJ(§QMd@N Ill/uuh\~`¢j
é>_S`- 19 /_‘§". ’ 4

mmkf_ gao '~Q®\r H@u\¢~_f¢`me_ /K¢`/\JLZAJESS /'t/\/`//\LS mojfLP/

\/c'&"l§>\r~ &.ABH'LQ_L Nu/\)P_‘Z_:ELS`C‘)§QQ£
H~;H~¢ C_@m‘C°_Lz:l_ Ll)\//"»[`

"'2_£>€°[ F~'M '2_®_/-\`£[ ,
`Temu'&_is;& ’ &>LQM¢;HT>:/ 75`8@£{ _

pm _S'Q_.S HFL¢‘cA/u"/,

M ::/_V__ JQL)/ q7- 2015

 

zu\»,‘+ N@, a,)@&,~é>g_zs"l .Q_(§)

1:/\{ z_/T& (’_.©¢4\'~‘{*'
' 0~(3,
C_M‘rm'~d_l_ ilme L_s

D~HQLFCAN{J l€e_l\ls€_

 

F`\~§om`[¢\& 263le Dc`.§‘{\=\¢`c:l~ C.qu~"{'“ '.
DA_L_LAS C_@wagfe& 7_

`n`.z\_|_€_zz_se__ N@, i=@é>~ 63354 m

 

M__ 5_¢‘_€;>/\)&£(//7'121;[¢>@/ »j).U/}’ `7~ Z@/j

l V¢'c’_`:fz>\/~ C`:.z>_'l¢e~¢'e_[_ I\ILJMQ_'L. l§`é>§`@iqé
HcH~. C_z§ m `QH. Urua"{"

”)__é[o_l l:M '2./_:>§¢!~ " 1
`lEALk/e.s:_e>_e C&L@u_g/"l_` o_ms 75834

, lam _xo_.‘ Q~Ppl_¢ c_'am+

Su_s¢\_m 1425wa ~
C.\r~¢‘m£l\.l&_{_ DLS'{`\~\'¢;_‘F R~f‘bm»\ru@__!__.{
BFEB;M 43. ~l-.-(¢`g§:r\l Ee)`_l"l,\?\§m

` QSSE_S’{.§A_I+‘ id ‘.5+\,~\‘¢~_:[~` Q:Hmwxla;t._.[ '
\BA_I_L_?~.S CAUNH/j€x&_s

F:\»£:.NH amu_; L~Q_H 649le iBL\¢'LCla'»MB
133 N. iQ\`uo_v-C\~ol\'r% BQQLQ_.\/&\,~c(_, .LB%¢.Q
haf_£_a_s /7?)¢2\._5 7526)7~ 434€£

 

H'QM. I_QNEL LQ_/\/'w~¢`@ j
o;:~h_.\;+ :UAQE_ `

Q_eLLTL`\ _D¢`S`l'w'c.+ C¢;>w»+
Da_[_l_h.$ C_c>u¢\?i_?j ,. TUB_s

QHAL.°@_t;N‘/`

\/»`C_"i‘@>\¢~ G We_L- i\lqu Q.'L:‘LL 153 §C?Qé

fla CQ`Q__LA_ l l ¢'\_n'+`

263 ccc l:/vl o_@ §L{

TQ_N/ue__:se_e>_ C$L¢>NH / 7<:)<;&5 '7 533 ‘.-/' 4

&bLe_»-@Q acreLUPm:as

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Dd&éz_

.Téxza C_Qadm SC C_»~.rmmz`~_L_ D\~c>c.<>_clu\pe_ CT.C¢(’_.D\ d
D.a¢aaa_ n,a-z * ~' 1
Cz'§_s§ {_a_u_)' -

E>aaL;Le;¢:¢ .\/¢ U»S,/ 1135 cli, 2639 9_@44 C/‘?Sé,) ’-- ~'“'“ - l
~H-a\¢da,\.,c_v\ \/. C_»~@siag /;52_/9 L? 3a 1117 CHI'R C.‘».- Z@¢~>?»\-- _ 1
mama \/, Lk.u_sau/ EQL! c:,_ai§£é,[>/Q (527\ 6_.\~1999\ - ~‘ l
maw_¢j u, aama», ma s cia 1430 zaqzzawqczqgé) --~z
wal…~\(gb\i \l suman 97 5,€_+=.15@&> 1507 09 77)- - -~z
TB.BL-E ®Q CQ nffe_w`l'_$_

60le ph__(:`f&- __" lt
aa_sL ac Dm.’a.s_ . _ _IL
Th_(a L_§B-@ Fl-¢_.\`f’L\co \¢\ H`c Q_s .:m:
?`z\_la(_e_°_@£ Cdm`fe_¢\l"(is ' IEF_
ll¢sf\ L-¢ C.AL\T.'E{ /PQ._\' P©A/.S'€_ Qluc{ Ex_£'_€tl`het\l Tc) S'lh_TE_.S QQ_§QQN§ €_
ua»~:+ Na w@@> 53354- al cB)- _ /, 2/3
C.¢s>:\.lc‘_L_usr‘o/\.l ' » _'_’>
D\~Q£]\Q_v~ ' “ `3

'Lu me char-l QC c\~.‘mia¢z,l. llppeal_._s of`]!§g§,,
_ wv.¥ ~o,~ w@a-e.szsq~@ wm ' '
E_x pa.\r'-fs»_ ` _ F~'\»-am ma 264/m judicial

q/a;v` aaaw‘aL/\/d ~a1_ _D;si\~.zi CM=+ ar
`T.mc;.~c,r.a No. 15@5~9% _ ` _ ___,
cappu¢a~+) v _ x aaa a_<. am_!_z,/ /(;_¢M

 

‘/ 7371\§ L‘a:u¢>v~&{af_£-_\_ judge e-¢Sz_~.'d" (’dm-{:

i:)»pP Licanl`l~.? Rm Pel\lse. lj-M.l E.c cep'//SM
"" `['o
_S’bem Qe.spm\/se_

comm Noau/ \/r'c_`Be-` sz>.Lw;¢>_l. Na/\l€:z_¥l`~'ih§' Wé CHH:)LJ`£QN?L] A_I\I¢l C¢‘Le_x
‘~H\¢'; -_I`+q'.: 5 »Qe;pead g i-le_ av.'LL §'Aau_; ‘H\e_ CoLLm..»¢`r\B n

l

13 ` l’-\~HALJP_AM+ MTQ.H=_J. a ;pLo_a mo Mo~/#_guil:|¢_.; 1B`H~e__ aLLaBed c’_/ni\~_go_ `a'>‘F'
Cz\_}a$laL mule_v @C p. child under lav_::}\e_m»s e>-C’ h_ge_ FN é.+F/'¢L [?_5/ _`
jqu bd~l~ L._na_< P@ue~.lcl gal.'L'lH old maj L$"~`Zéeg okl C.le@_ Nco. l1§"2'>6"£835 £f"._&..

jj 14a appe;LeA `la“rks_; arm 1531de (`:.SuFl g(~` £lppenlz all case N¢a QS-OS_~
es7l/vC/9 , MAQ, jam‘v~me£[ am L_We_ 17~2¢1>£>9» '

_’?J i`-`¢‘Leal. 2a P.D.R. A,.d was a££?\»meal am lowe 17"2130?o
‘-U F-`.`L@¢:l 'a_ klaka PQT£f?`¢aN CFCLCR ¢\_\~T'.»l(¢é7) dem'ecl¢

:n::l: , ~
STa`fe.s Rm pause €poge.l".) aLa»‘n/Ls /Q~HnL¢`c'.ou‘é 6502 op 1`1\/`&£7‘7;/9_

assi;Tamc_L>__ of mumc_p_l_' (_EA<`_\ 13 No+ CQSMJLABLQ_ dale 7‘¢> 1331

pt §§ g

'/_\L? \"as'_SQc£

_ @1\1 Lli_s O\~i_gl`maL -#abgm 1%1(1‘{1'01»/_.}1_&\11‘1\£9 awde beaij ams-auee-ea/,/ 71?3_ .
side skm§s'~ /2\1 1`7‘£ respond E.¢Ai£_,;¢_?;>a am ’a(I`.‘d_Au,'-! pmm ¢!1‘5 eduA/-
wm adea 11a am day go nasa 1913 aged SD@N_¢_, 12,0,01,\¢@_~%3
claim @C T_'.AC. 1`1\1_.#»€.§ ztssu€»_§ waist ;1\1 #\m( peif¢`h'ar\h 71§5!5?‘€.3 mini-
554 ‘l‘wo loan No`//\I/\xg‘{a,cla wifk`fke__ [)\~e.sc>_zv-Hssuep-CLA=C. Basea{é/\/ /\19-
aaag.`ci;s®va»ad\amzia¢\aawe§a wanda dasf,‘~a¥ mcfa»¢, “Pahh'a~ahs

alaim maj :#LL ée_ venide m `IL.: asLLa`fQ_\~aL pv@c;@_edwg 643 HL¢:_&M
as`fa|;l_¢‘al\ `U\e ciam:hfu hém/a(_ Q.w»m~ m H¢‘s )aLp_a c_aLLa>gu_/.] has phabaé£_,_.f

disabled zu`l'ke_ donut/6de afm/lo is a_c:{tmLL muecar\hL 338 /lhh.vjaa§

L‘M\.`\er, 1055 C:i:., ")_L>:LQ, 26'-/3- LA'¥¢/ CIQS'A)° Bsusaé#m\l U,S , 1185 ct lla£>é¢(i?
081 m_sa wa."~w¢~.c,A~/- V.Sakm, 975 1;1'_ 2505~7_5157 61<277) @Ar~#,a-l 11a

as advang 11\11`\10¢£@.~#, 1

4 FMAQ_J,, ava~` LM/\aj czwa$) ma »ama=l,'-~H\e_= nppL;aaml ma~g_paa/)'s
adam mdma aid was#.p:al_ ammaa‘_s 'c;mge'a/éz,\/aa clay 1a away
a pmpa 'rmumf;gah'aw md oUB.‘u sua/\,L’av§' za pva/mak defemse_ a_“fw`aj_ CLem--
L_zj 5/»9¢.\»1/\9 wound was m ~Cbc_+~ zue_We_Cf\\)e, TL€_ F_L§u¢_>_u"m C,'»~'aa:/¢ has
wl\ Le_ we,alo~.a~/~ \»eQ_an-P_ ‘i/nf'a_ La,..J_.:/¢>.v be h P\~¢L/a_`/L rN VeS'/qua/Br- ml
maley ‘k> ch.aur¢_u axe.vj Pass,bLe_ aVQ.NuQ.' winc.k mad /)u§-l ov- l)@_Lp‘Hwe_
~aL.'emL/ wa 119 \’~aqiliva*tkz>+ +ke_ mayer maKe am e_€€@e'£ "h'> IM\/e§T_/qa-

`I`E. "H\e. abu£@>a:s, ’J_MBLJLCVW+_J_;QSFBJ il~Z.7 CHTR `£j\». ml L%=
_M_~gg_§cg>d_);‘ §Lso #s`fv‘a`i’eaj Msecl oM am rudovaan uhder§/M`? Cn(\
`__H\Q_ L;u; e\~ :a_£‘_um_`ib ~Call_\__zj zN\/es`h‘ga+a`il»\§ ~Pe_r_is CD.N/t/m£ as d mm

WQ_`TZ\BQ ,

 

v ,CO/\IC.LS/l‘;§/\/
44 `Ti\e_ Sfalll`,pallflallell/`/kls /~lllllal»llélLe wal-/ issue zll/ owiel» des;qllo~
`h'llg ‘H»e. ls_slle_` ll~£` hcleal_ llllll>_c__ellc_.e_l zell¢[ ve_,lee.?§ _1_AC_ as /l@l+

Cl:_qlllz_zlilL¢_>_ `SO_é_ 51‘2:.'[§: Qm,o@llse_ cl__~_{- peg e>.`#\ve_&_ 63)

olp¢aLl*azl.ll~/~ km_l¢alln/_#l`_s lL/clllomla[_e_ C@al\-'f &P C\`l`mlilaL appeals
‘H'l: al_Ll_ lsscle_s lll /J~l‘_s sallasecLLllel\l{ Halaea_$ pellel\l eve l‘A/~L`zle”(

C@lll‘ mm_|ll|_el be \~e\_zxfell_"ize~fke. Nell_ll__l._{ c{_lsclglel-ed_' evl‘aleluee_€§c~

1115le lll alphme lllel\l+ ll;l zwl\l 77e Pw{l@wllwllall ll llHlLl ~

ezll\rfs ell dellal>_ rllLlae:/m`t%l‘_s #e»el€@l~e_/ "H) `-Hl>_a 1"&:\1_.1‘:]1 ll>(`+/le. Le:um /D~mell”?§a/
Pv»c_ll]le\»~

Q-Blll_l`c‘_zl_l\rl~ h._SK_s"l'Lf_S Heluev~e_bl_e_ C°_le¢l_\l/+ lea C_\l~lmll\lZlL lapp€_&(_$
clc `\:xe_g ~Co_\,_ vel_l`e_~@l 4

12 Vleal£llllll$llmlf§i
7 7 ZO/l'”

llc-_izl\~ Cl~ll|ll.‘e_\_ Nllllev_"/* 15@€<1%
H¢{'l\(`_.c)cx>\|&l_de UILI¢`{' 4

ebel cm za§4 __ ,, f
T'Q'_llllé_:»»¢0/\,/
bkooo_ mleu_/`lol\/G<~[ de+@ '

 

9 § @:W.\v~ee_ 4