Court Opinion

ID: 4039194
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:08:44.720107+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:06:34.006276
License: Public Domain

77, 6'17-!Jd
                                                                 11.1'\ if~ . '-tt(
                              \N T~E
            COURT OF C.R\M\NAL A??~AL5                           v~      .)(> \'\

                         Or T~XA>.                                   RECEIVED 11\9
                                                               COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
                         WR-77;577-0 2                              JAN 0 5 2015
                                                               Abel Acosta, Clerk
HA~\G Ct\-ANt>e,
A.Pr/i t-tlwf
                                 Se.ik\V\~ t\A'oeo...s      Corpu.> Re.\\.e.f
                                 UV\ i (l.(    Art\ c \ ~ \ \ ~ o7

"·T\fE   STA\E OF TEXA-.S

           017 c~llaferd I /(~vje,v.) froh1 fqlit Pi5/lt'cf Courf
                Or MvL.t'-nna. n Coaf[/y 1€-Xt:R.>
                                              1

                [tttl>tt No. 2tJI.2- 33B- C f C.

    APPL\CANT 15 ·MOT\DN t=OR lt-AVE \0 F\L'E-
    SEC:ONt>   SUPPL~M~·f'tTAL OSJ:C.CTlOl'lS                  \N
    VlEW 01= THE UNt\E.l> STATES SUPRt.ME-
    COU~"T15 OP\ N\ ON \N !<!LeY·~ CA/-/FO!<.N/.4-)
                  t?73   u.s._ (lo \4)
                                ?ouYJ.s·e/ for Afrlie--tJ.nf:
                                ttAM\ s G.\-\ANb'E
                                lb:\'bl.'3!>\7
                                })AL\-\A R.\U ~ \T
                                \\qso Ff\A "lq<Z>
                                bAL\-\ART1 'Tt::>< A-S 7t:to 21-7{; 24
                                (s·of,) 2.4~- <Ob \55

                                Ap,? //c d Mf      frD >~
To ~+\-'E ,ttONDRA-BL''E              couRT OF-_ C.R\~\NA-\-.. AP?t=A-LS·.

           Now c.oM~Z..~ -HAM\S. A'T+\-DN\A-N              CH-A~h'eA~-\'\i"\.LO..V\l.LJ
                                                                         i
prt>t~~,~~ pro ~e./ o..~~ re.spe.t.,:\-fv-\\y re.V-.t2S\-.s \.e..~VQ. +of\\~ .see..oV\J
.su-pp\e..n.t~L-vt+oJ t'>k>~~c..-\-~o\1\.S +o ~<t t~\tA.\ c.ou.c--\-~ re.GoVV\~~\\~t~..~\oV\
i V\ Yi e. w DE -\hQ..' ti V\1:\- ~& ~ td- e..s . 5u. ~'(ll.,V\1\Q.. Co u..d- ~~ 0 p\ V\' () V\ \ \-\ I
f!i/r;_y   Y-   CahforYlttt;'Ei73 u.s~- (J..Dilf.).
li~

      2
 £a,(.l(c,h WoJrtt~t)       J\ ~ ¥\.ot o..u"*'or\ ZCL -~c \ Se..-o.£ t:-Vt -fulL ~\o5e..J_
0 1' D.\~ _c:o ~-\- ,_, iA.~ w \, uu, t< / / ~._ e.v' ,9_._ \'1£e- , of A f \'\ <. LA.~ f
c.o~\1·~+\o\t\ w~~(e. fou.\1\_~. Affh~_"'\- fet:o5V\~?,-e...s ~4' ~u."'R,e_( ~e.
fr\.ut t>f ~Q.. po\SOV\oL\..$ ,+rQ.Cl- At>t:--+c\~12.1 tA\\ -€..vl»<LV\Ce. ~Q..,r,vei. f?\'\1\
~il.. fL"~lo,tLtt\b\1\ ~A\.\ \l\a.5A.\ Sl2-ML\A-- whe.re./o.__s ~e.(e..-.- V\1\V..rt
 ~Q... su.~-pca..sse.-~-J~~Q_ tl.~. v. P#-k1 l~lp. F. 3& 24\ 1 ~bG(5~ C\r. ,
 ~o \D)( l:>~ N N_\51 J.1 _J\sS~\1\.\,V\.~~- cui.. }llvzt~ I~\ _5'~ ct. G2D1 17<6 L, '£~. ~R
 4-~ (?...DtD);...s€€ a/.t)c !f:S. V•.J!a/e111fi(Je1 S~l t:- 5upy_. 'J.R ~3~1 ~Vta.(t.J).
 N.. Y. PlLG. ?--Lt1~DDg (t.d·~\V\.~, WDVJj .>ull/ V. t/n/fd >1-drzs1 '11\ U,.S. Lf-1(/
 it<l.lf- ~!? L I~ G3))-: As ~Q.. s~pre\IV\Q. Ccw--\- \t\t.\...s -~\ s.-\-t) r\ L-tt\\v.               ·
 re.C-o,£\~\:2.-e..J     *'-k
                           -fhQ.. wlk.((~":-\ \<L~U.\(fl.WVL\1\.-\ \.S ~ A\1\ \ M.f.bct:·t~..V\1
 _WD( \(IV\_j-_ fP-.f-\-. ~ ov..r V\1\t'--C...~\ V\IL(y' of jt~V.eAV\ VV\12.!"-t ~/ ~t)V. ~~t:<l.\y' '' t\V\
IV\~\1\VQ,V\\fl:Y\f~ t-'o };£ ..scV\1\a..hcW 'w.JL\1t;\~~ A.~tl.\~t th<L L\"-.~Vv\.'5 of
~Ol\ CQ.. eff I G! \1\t.y. /t.lle(.~ 57 3 U~ s. tt.T- (sh.r ef• td: ?.5-~")C c,t:, V\j
                          (l

Coo/i/fta- v. New lftawp.>h~re 1 4-o3 u.s~ H-Lt~1 4czsl (t'i7t)).
      gtJSQ.J. 0\\ ~It- f.o(~jO\ V\~1 Apv\\<:.Anf M~U.eS "ffiiL .cLV\~c<..V\02. of ~~.s.
C~\1\~\~t\oV\. v-!A.~ \H~o..~\y o~+A.~.V\~J .~Y ~<L ~1>\\ca.. \V\ v\c\~\-\c\1\ ~
\-\\ $ (\~ \A."t 5 U..\11. /)., « 1\.\Q.. fc. v..-f~ A-\'\A.a..VLk VV\0...~, tt ~ · Ceo~.>\. ~ !"\IL \IL~ \\f.. \-\ e_        l

t"'-ua.ft>...,a. u~u.(L.> ~tl\- -\krL,. -\-"\v-.\ CA>v..-ct e..rc(LU \V\ £e.iAj\V\.) \""'f\\'c\-\-\y
 h\s. LJL(",UV\11-e,~           OV\    Q.>(L.\U.$\bV\t'·X)'        \\A.\ot.                                      ·

                                                  I"Ll.
            Co.NSTITU.TlD N 1\AA~DA\'E                              _j\.Al>&-!'AE·NT OF
                                           AC&lJ.\TTAL..
        T   ~~ T        tt)(c?-.5Co u-ri- _of. Cri. M\ V\~ Af~ o.A.\.5 '-".o....s st'>< ~\A.~ V\e.£ *-' tl.\. \\ .S
 JQ.L-\S\oV\ CA~Y\ot Aft:e..L-t -\ttQ.., o...V~~\o..\o\\\-\-l of \a..~dv\. bA.SCL.$
 tti·t"i C..'-'\a.,-\-e_~ \\1\ f~~eitt\_ G\")LL(-t t>f.\ V\\ o \1\.S .. ~tl.- Ex: e_ar:f~ flo f)~ ?J \ S. W.
 3~ 7~~77liLTrL)(. tx\_N .. AY,~- 2o..~,?)(a.Yvi.~~V!~s A.tk~J).A-~ .S\.u:.~\A 1
 ApfA\a \/\,-\- ~seAt> 1\\A- ~Q.. ~f' f\~ Q <~u."~ r> . o f\ ~\ tl V\ , "V\ tf: s.< v..
.)fZ;j/J.S"btJ Lfb~ f=.. :.?,~ J,t\~ (s"*' C:~c. ~t>C,~) \S \V\stfi.AL:\yve._ \V\ -\"~'.5 t_o....SQ.., \V\
~A!-:. ~Q..1 il ~?a..\\ tLV\-\- ~~e.A\e~ ~(L .. ~Q.~\ A\ ~-f ~\.s vn-o\-\ 'D'f\ ·\-o S0..p~re..s..s
 ~\1\~<LV\C~ o....> I).. (Q.SlA.\¥- cf V\c\~t:\o~ trf \t\,s ·fou.C~ A~e.\-\.~Y\1\.CL\'\.t
 r\")~t./d. A 4-~~L ·r_~a.. f\f~- ~~fc..\A\t CoLA.J(\ <Lxp~tL\V\eR ~~ ,lo.f2.LOJA.5!2.
 lAV\A:U    ~ f\.A.\1-              of it:~   ~~ \SoV\oU..S. ·\-[Q..CL A~ L--\-(~ V\Q.. /'' o..\\         .:f!-Y\        ~J;_;~C€;
 ~cL.(\ veA f<c\1\/\ ~CL. ~. i ~\12..~l.l\             S(Ltu c...~~·, VV\U..St           ~.e. sv.pf~es,.se.P1 11 ;}, ~+
Lto1>   25<:_ V\ ..   \'~- o..V\~ ~Q..({L~l       fQ..VU'Se.&          o..~vo..\\tl"'\t_s L.-c:.V\V\L\\~V\. tA_I(\~
 r""':'"V\ke.& ~\ M~ t..r r;_"'-'\ry of                                       ~IAN~ M<LV\+ <>f                   ~ "''t+,,L .S11e iJ.
                                                                                                                                               1

                                                                        A                               tJ...'
a.+ 'fuq(~\1\Av~.$,~ .t.J!~d).                                                          .                            Y                     ,   1

-       A-p v' \UA ~     V\     t: \ ~ \ M5   ~ e,f~ \ s \ V\ e.s: LA f ~\o\e. \ejo..\ \o L\$ Q.S ~~ ~ "'-'-~tJ                        L

-\V\ Jen.5t.SIJ)       \.N~UQ.J       p..S \,Ull..:   f\\5-\-1   \oa.c.A..\k~Q..   -\-\..\CL   e..v\1!LV\(.JL            of       "''..>

                                                         3
    ':~r~'v\,\: te. a..."~   .f<"«.' >'   -\-c f ~ \"'
          R~~ ~a.L+ ~ \\y             Sv-\oM\tte~1

            H-~m\.s
            \b~  \1S !U~2.\7
                               c"'   ~V\
             t> oJ hAft ~VI.\t
             1\£\S o FN\ 4i\ct>'
             })~\~lLf\-1 \)( 74o?.!L--76'lit
            .,4-?f7/iCAflf fr1> Jib .
            p~ LL \"v\\o ~ ·~.A 1 ~D \ tt
4