Court Opinion

ID: 4074650
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 05:18:13.900911+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:09.380192
License: Public Domain

al~ · t Y iJiriJ- ·                                         tv~rt<Jo                  .                          ;::JJ.t Tf(E al 9.:1 -,..,0
1.
-    .
         ..
         .   !f                                             W07-'I!Ird/-l;{A)                                  ~iJIOA L OIST/UCT
                                                                                                               <'!.P-t£--7

•
  ' . _Jg££~/AI! D_._/)fllt.LiPS                                            '7SJ     1Jif                      Dfltt_~~TX

         RECEIVED IN                       20l50EC -3 PH t.: 13
cou~G~~~~NALAe~A~~~~~~·~~~~--~~~~~~F=E~LIC~lA'PiffiE
         -~_:__~-~~~-Mo7itJI-/__ £d tcAf/13. /C? RtE          o2L~1f~·~ _Lr~R~S-:-._ _
            ··IOE€ 17·2@15. Wl-fT oF /!dltNOAfif~S  . ...:.-·-·-··---·---,- '\.. uTv
         --""'==--=--.:<..-==--=--='-----~~-                                          ·       This documeni contains some _, _ _ __
         ~--~--- "                                                                            pages that are of ~oor g __ lit)f-"---~~~-
                                                                                                                       ua__

         ~~f-Ac~afG;~r6~~L£                                 -:ltrtxrE OF Z2:1cat 8~~_vt ilo~"&i.m$AL"-------~
         -._/}f!j}£f1[,s_,·                                            .                       '    .
         _ _ _c__}jt::>W Ct:>14£s_$R-P-ft/1!14fi D~/211tGt.JI'S 7J1Q_;Jo:                                            /S/cJ.5;?C1' - - - - -
         _Pm_ S_e_SE£155__j...&Allc_IAI                                012J£"t:. . 7Q         lJE~B:LLDCJ:i?fJ__~_;_ D Rc.E_ __
       -__ll/s____[)£/&tY!4~ w~11 c;;r ~ANQAfrfuJ_. LN 7:1::11£ 4&'-=o-'-vz=-=·~-----
     , _Afg_;tt.,JJ£/L6D_AN0_57"tLEf)_{!Au.J£· A-..NiJ 0D4LU Sltow ZlJ...o=t£~--------=----'---
                                                                                          '

         _!i()Ni)/::4~_££' CDt-te:r                    WE £(;t;..LlJW/Al~tM 04~ 'Z!fF-eE ~----
    _ _ I!ES!!l£C7l~---~LL.t:__ _ _ _ _ _ _~-------,--~------
         -~~~~~~~~--~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~---
         _ _ _//d_o)-rpe,gf5_££~EEitCI~-li1~.-CtE;LIC_a!..=-77-1£ AtSoVt==--------
         _· t1Lh11A (Jff"Lb_IJ_·· ZJ;s~r                  {!J)fr~Tj~LS:_7_7fE £~~No.ENJ l~~t7f'----'-H----'-/..-=o_ _ __
         _        4/_:__(l._ I r   6£ 1'1iyy_r2_M14_5_t__ M 0 (/11!liT R851?Es;JRrU.J~,_.A_1_o_..!C~.:.=C<__,"5:"-----~~~~-,---­
         _To                /-fAVc_l7!(s_CP/YStl1£tzF-c)_(}4M_u_t__;;_Z7J{£L Y" L!tr TffE .M.fV\IN~~---'--­
         ~IZ£:5:E~t_"Eu__ ,_L_l-f;5_/S_LJ4 E Z0 ttfo l/A~n_:_lt<ltlL(£-F-ftT J71!Tl-6"-----------'
           A-ND IN11(3!L!7Y-_ 7D O/l!21uV. CD£!!_ES_ANO_TJ{_~ F-'C.oAfo.M{!__ _ _ __
                  bFLHc__ C04Lt~·~~~~~~------~~~~~--~~~~~---
         ------------~-·--~--------~---~~~---
         _ _ M_bV/lAIT WB_~f..E/llE"S£;.J7E;J_{J__~ C,qLVIN U_PI/{VSoN .4T.___~---~-
                   TPAt             AHIJ_12L4_&NF       kATtt;~u-t JixN~             df.l      APenJL(j;~ftc7;),'--------
                            ' __jf}(jtltT~ To PAy Co41?..r cos._rs_!!!·ND f:/U~·-·-=-6-_ _ _ _ __
                  fo1Dl/Af/To
     •-F~S_ft_A--s_                         (!.kAt--tGEQ_A.~r()~tJiY          ;(to   Co.&~ e,__l)__E_S'"o · - - - - - - -

                                                           '.1/l
                                                            .v     •

                                                                 I
                                                                       I

        ___________________ :CNfo~lE_D£an~Apo&-~_------------------~--
        .__r "'C~FtY._tiC!I::f._iJ. PH~~c;/2_r_ :tt::"rs;;; s-~o fk_b_S£ IJEr~G,__·--'------------~
        -..(!__i--tlt-tt.£"'1JrL<c_IH &:+-LC£/!A-TF-.0 I M_fEx~S_/)r-/!L._~---=&=--'1'1=--·-"-tiV---'-11--=-C______________

        _ -;]lis71CE /1-tiCHA£"L wvrr i<fe_fe{/- Fl'-l i(OS'</_fr;JtJ~SSE[ CoLoH'I:_,.~-:::x'---'---------,­
        _'75~         .   L.   pO ft;:;-,.LJre/3,(./ .5_L4.1;;.-..q,e_ &tNOF-~ ZftE_t?F-tVALT'r'_o_,c:
                                                                                                    _ _~--­
        _.f!£eJl1~Y,_Tt-~~T /lf-E FACTS                  St/4_"[]£0 11130(/£                Jtl-££ TI!:.U£.
                                                                                        -                                         .
        _ _ht'ID Co!V2!CC-T        ·-ro
                                                                     ·
                                          71'€ ll12-:>r or==- k(: /.)5U€£
                                                                                                     ~   . /JI'·n    _. _ _ __
                                                                                                                    :rr;st-zS3o
                                                                                    9
                                                                                    --~~~'? ~dl¢"£.

            ~L[CL~~~L~ lif5~/cr-~d.S~~---------~~---------------
          :;211/J !lcc:L r-:fA_NK C{ipwLGy____::C~o_t..!._tf<T2.___~:&-=-'L=D~G-____________________
        _ LLL,&. RtvE~ ;=-eo,AfT B~L=-V::.....:D=-·...........::::L::.,.:_ts=-'~·;J."------'---------------.,----
          D14Lut~ 7X. 7 5_J_o .r;.__
                                   -__:_lf_l_tt__::.9_ _ _ _ _ _ __,_________~-----.,-

    .                                                                        _,__                        .           /51'J5.? 6
•        ---------------~-------'--------'-----~J~~~~H aP#~(IPj_ _ _, ___
                                                                           - :Jc.&L/ Fttt ~osq l4tUIA!EL ?r.N;r
                                                                                    '        '
                   Now C 0 /tt.c5_ JB£m /14 1-r /J£5JI,EAJ\LJ?iffLL/~S/~,b-dA_L....,:::.4C--=:-_--
_·PJ!o .5E7 , r 1-1          771£ A6Q(R£_.5_'£_t./t.EO_A,yL)_Al_tdujj~E<l t!!!£6j_"--F-_ _ __
        . 0~ ~~L2~ AM<a HL--E'$;___Lifrs 010{5-_rMqc_ · #//Lru;7oN
____&?~ ~IL-L"L- oF fo/__~NL}_4tltuS_ ~tt~l.-FAN/ Z!;> PF- /kSt-CrY!HlF[J_~~
___;;z:ssitb'S D~E££0_3_y J];tJ_G.E Cdi.e~.-:_'-' /Z1LZZ8fi:~L /+At()_ _~'-­
              it.»fll/fL£ !fSSLSJZl}-IT V;~CT A-ZLQUIE~ or-'-------------
_____(__l/f!S77)1£
_b/{l[[) co&~ OfY_QIL AtftJttr AIOUF-/tf6:E~ ;zt;/ co,/t..__V_-4________,__;-..r._v
                                                                                 _ _ _ __
  wc>~U) ~i!cJtcJ l"ll£ t"o~/LL_ rrl£ kJL.(d)tviN(i_ _ _·_ _ _                                      -c--- _ _

--------~-~-----------------
_12,;:_t..-@:_Li>tZ;-'2£LEjM_/A_fd__·'D.. /!/llut&_ -#L_~~/.--'':2=---5=-c$=---O_.-----'----/5=--------
_jw_ Ou£A!OFL /#04:~--4-/.J rE!)~LN_l]f£ /GYP5_[)_r;Jz:_· _ _ __
        6/- Q!./f"lt/;(}/-IL   :Yttszzc£ 14t<JO_/tf,f'/J~£rA/G- gzo:S:C Ac....o.·_N_o_ _ _ _ __
-~£ LOC4·rB.J               .fflmE J11/_C/L4._cL &,v/T ~&& 1/Ffll :ltJ5Lf__ _ _ __
    _ j_N Zff£ .7£AJAJ;:::-S~Ec {!_oto_)(j,_Ut?f               -7SRg'-'::..__..______.:.___ __
    -~-------~:zt=                          _________________
I        :i?F-Z.Aro/L f/-Es_1£ELV      ~/4/Tl;ttG
                                              /#AL ltd.S._'--='tu.=6=----;e.:____-r_v
                                                      /-.::>Jt..                  _ _ _ _ __
f-._·JZ!E DES /erjLJ/1~{) ::;L5su-es- Fu/e_. 0/E/e' 5 ~ .}t-E',q.,es_1- ' - - - - - - - - - - - - ' -
1~uS /#~ C ~dT 0/-L..U.Mt'/l.Jt/_L 4/J?GALS fL/Is_.5Z4lP!.::tJ'------'------,-----
'              .                                           '
I       A-(L J:lC 7/e>NS.      ,/fJV()_gi-I'L/~(iS_ ON T.H£ Rc-td;l/b&~l!- 0!7...,---_ _ _ __
I-A~I'VC477oM tv/171a~/. l2t!S I55_lf_£~· RcuZ<X-                            C.b.-'-'w.=--w-----'-'lJ"---'_
                                                                                                          -T _ _ __
: :·    f?Lt:?C£"~{)
                   !/'lTC> Ill£ NF'X'T S7E/J c:F /1/'_/lE4L_:_Z!-Ac_____::C=--- ------.-----
1
I .
      {]bugz_ O.J!.LJO.£-LJ /?Y Ug~~ /U;~C.
                                                  77-/4/ ~.-~_·oe--=---s=---£_ __;___ _ __
                                                                                  ,

_:· _J2)£s/a.A-Ar;c-O ~~£rE. Jl€ ~~AIT 70 -T?I£ 4ef:'?/C!!l~AI_/;_____._ _ _ __
'     ]JiC kS..Sit'E-3 £i/j;l2~ PLEu o# IJOUE/1-taee. c:IC/;_-=.:c2:__0._V_O _ _ _ __
     ·7ft£s-£ /-/H()/#G-5 r4cr5 4t<IO CcY1/C,.{.bs/£J.Ns· /I-#U£AJ(Jr             '--------"~-----

_:_7J£Tt~.l SIEMr... /fl ll 77NELY H!s-/lteN wflcLr-. A!J/'L/C4JV/
i    Couw 6/lll£cl 6~.· FleE /-lis cJJS(J, SEE ~l8;r @.) ----~
    I                                    Ilb     '                   '          •
    __7}113 Col41LT&ttP!J ·p-lAT i9/C#               t/1= ZR_',£- ALL£.._6-A"----'T.'-r.-~_(5_ _ __
                                           CD
-~,9~ r~-1 /N T'"#£ ££U:??Oe ,!/. D'7 /1//'£/CA-/?ZJ.AI tuBE
  {!__oJJr;t!..O 1/E~~() A_i1t!_./)_ t,',.u L£TS6Lt/,E;) MCTC..-f!I_C~/.=0S~Lr..:.....~~s~_ _:___ _ _ __
                    ~.£"1J&IL£-O /lvo/77aAJ4L- El//Oft»CF- ~t-f..:>~·~z;~A:__a=-:~:._=:_---.....:.--~-­
          /,vlf;c,.Li
         /i?s:TlfittJ)JY' ro /?£ ·£.6'.;--oLuF-o,
                                               - zv·
         'I/I__;q ~£L1-1r~/!- 777£-attO/!         ,(L, o/7 /,l/£%/C477C/# LLA....:....r_:_·---,-------.--
                                                          /1/.5
_____,..-=-oll_z;~LY_& 77/E {?ot-,./2T TN>4 r u,v/e.Q..aLt/£""~ ,c:.qc7k4L
        ISSU/£S / t)v kX/ST; 771£ Co~.e..T tPp-C£//'If//1.//1(__ 4-Ao£//L
       ALE' J2.r=qLiiKE0_7L> .L'£V/EW £U£;-,4!!.y _,4/l..GtUJifp/Vf
       f2A-;s£[)
          '           .
                        .8Y ,4 J!?IJ;eTy
                               -         '
                                           77-tAT ./s )J£C£.sSA:Ly 7V/<'~--------
                                                                          .7;¥£.
_. /2f's/!_~SiT/~J..J tJ? Z71;? T /-l/P.E71L L;Mr li-S7/l!ZAS.t.A.J.
_3..11 /0':/.._,_Los (TE,J{ C/1_/F~A l!t/1 ..7ao~_ _ _ _:.....__-:-------~
    -            · .          Co~f~SLO&.                                  ·-------'----
_ _ '!2f;:S:t1o)lf~ 4/J~-/11-E /-h:>~o~/1 ;Sc.£" Ufpetc_/ /'1!TZ/IELL t~IV...::.___ _ _ _ _ __
_____l;tLS_ CPI-/'&_CITY . /!1-S ,L)/~T,e/c.--T .~t.Jcs£ Dr.;: 0-4LLFf-:S: _ _ __:__ __~--
      t!.oltfliiV 7fl.J15 Jlt:~S -4 ZJtt?:v To tJ,ezJ~L- .A /-r£.4,£.-//V(f
        D·fl- r,C. 1/o (:;K) c A N rr 8£ sA-tO                    ?H4T                                         __:_Lc_:_t2-:.~/3~-------'--~
                                                                                LL..ft!.....'...I=:'==-;_-C=o_··

__/_-+ELD /1              Fi.<L.L AJ...t£>. FAt!!- /I£At:.tNG IN iZF-ACt(d'J(;. T~T-=-~-----'----
        A IYD!IJC-S       o,:- FACT  Cdfl(/.~)45_ IbN<;
                                              ,t:I).)L)                       or
                                                          L/1 w w/T,({_o_r.._fT_·_ _ _ _ __
_        A_Ll-otu;NG- AfJf>L-!CFINT To ·pA,2_r;c;fJrtT6 IN 7/rE 1--tEA?/.tlt(r_?- - - - - -
        Jiffi A,/r/Cf,UT          C4-NNoT G-o lfi-IF-.4/) i4LTff 1/(s.__~.=.......::-::l~S~t/_·_ _ _ _ __
_       l]gAt.tSF.: Itt£ C-LEJLic oF {If?; Ci:x,g( IJ._AS Y._o(· :5£N~·~----~---
        -r7fr-s£ -:LSSfd_E.S--;-fo.e.H-16/Z.£ ll-?,//t.-/f114/41~r--=a.A~f/"_,___L~_..:_~-=u:.:::::-::._.!._C/I._'/s=-·'_ _.:..____~--­
_;:1 JS CfF-FFt=,e_TtV!L.l:;_,~,.:..___------------~------'--­
_lf{_E' ~CL/-ITO,e_ Ji/lS ;:} Fct/-/QMMGJJIAL Rt&IIT 7D Dt-/C
-~c.C:SS tl;-/0 HIS L(!),NS'TiTti/lcJNAL ;2!6-HT /0
   _/ZFE.ccrJ..t/£" Cot.tN<Sct- ~AS {doLAffo, 77-tl£ 5-'~-IJ AfiD~-------'---'-­
   _J-LI--~'11 Afoi&VQ,(Ij_eJ\Jf Stt_Z:S_ c_pt,tiLT C14-~;Jo/ 0£/'..erl/F-
 -.. ·_gU/6/L o;::- L1F£/_Lt8££T'r;_ o;e ,P£o;?J,e.er,v tv!Tl-fot<-T
_-··_e~YZ.u.=/)1{~5               o,.t!-   .Dt<,E />..eo,.CE$5      A-JJO      ANI) ·ilk:._                        /l:L-.:7-/,:...:...::..:..'_
                                                                                                                                              G: _ _ _ _ __

W11DC-r£ Ll:LU.4j) Cou/2../ /!Au!JJG- A/i>T !IlESE ZJ£SIGIJ"'TED"'------
  7;5sucsJ /!ESoLf/E-D 71/rS LS A t/;ot-ATtoiJ or- ;t~Y'
  Co ;..rST; lit Jl oA.J 4 ~ ~- {(;-/-fr 7 2> i)erF- / J!.oc€55 .
----------------~~~£~-=i_______________________~----------------
_ _ f1Lii£t..£ ro.e.£, /2£(ff[tJtL                   ~tf"S~ECThtLCf--'/~'--'-~-/7---'----'Jf'-----'-m---'-A_tS=-·_.. - - - - - - - - - - - - -
                                                       I

    /lpNo£A-/3L~ eo?t;e_j                          G-~A-NT /11~/-ID/f/Ut..cS 1!-FL!k'~
_·_Af-IQ oi_;::g-,e_c /lt-E t!JC.tPT 1/J/Jt- D 6r,f!.;cr (!_e)~.er ~t.~ 10
~~ ~eOIA~L_L__ll_/1N(51U rr. 7111£                                    WAR/T            /l~/t.'---"Z.:::..:...f-=-(j--'...C.-177_oAI-,-
                                                                                                                                __s-~70_'-----------:------
     J7rtS
      ~
                  CvL./2...1. !M
                         .    --
                                 A-Cf!ogj)9_j\Jc;.C
                                       -            l,vff/-r TH-IE ,euL.E,
   /+LTc-JUfA l1_ti£L.)j/
                ---'----1
                          12-Eurd:-- /JM/3 ;:::JJL-/IJ.lf' O//fF-,e_
                                                            .      '
                                                                      /!£u£~
_. fiE fl-14Y
         .    BE
              .
                  £,;(l77TLEn 70 ;l'l t-/f tv c?L & c;u1T'r!
                                                        .        1
                                                                     Rk"~c~ar:
                                             .                           .             .                                           '

                                        ~( M A/~ iJ£CU?,R_;:tJ1i>JJ                                 ·      ·            ·.
-------~----.- - .- - - - / J                      "      ~I'S t2S !JO
                                                           '                     .0                            .
    'd_       ·Jr.;-£EAA !Ai-l      v    I   .,-'J-1/LLtP~ I                 r"f!.L>   f:c     /.2~LNG: c.L{ft!R.£Af1l..);/
_--z::;y_· O.A-£cG.R--A16.J                  IN :z~~              UF-/!.Z:__or t:!.le~t/JA.L-'--Jf{Zlo--'=c=-t;;:--------
      /ttAtcH4£L 01'-f/r_ :< ''- l/ F~ .16$<1 fE.t!.H~5SF-G" C..VtoNY 7X_ _ __:___
                                                                                                1
      rzsg~Cc.       I       .lJ6       ~~~~~-M~ S'_iuEtlte.. utv{)'3""1:!.. Lfl~ p;.:;-,.VAL-ry
                                                                                              _________
      Of[:'   1/ZIQlo~-Y;_ TIM( -{fiG F,At!.73 c57A-'TF-D__!t&_oUc At!-E -n.u£
     ·Al-l!) cP~cr                      70 7f+t-::::           !JEsT o,c /11 Y /)G"C!E;::-                     . · ·. _JIJLt·
                                                                                                                   ~

                     .              ~(-evF;_c rf7£fi oF SF-~ V/c£.
                                                                             .
                                                                                  .
                                                                                                               11
                                                                                                               ~< (p'-f"C"/~
                                                                                                                             .
                                                                                                                   -~---'---------

                                                                                                                        .
__ll_y           Mk_ S;Gj.I/4-·TutZE £)62-cuJ 14/V() 11S/Jt2E55 f;sff-O t:?b"L-DW 1
   -£Do IIE1!-t£;;3Y CE~T/Fy ?r~/lr 1'4. Tl:k£ '*1:-'0 · Ct>~eT
   (]_jp;Jy_ /ffe: /fli_oV£ h!'-11) Fo~O/)YG- OuCL:t~G?JT &Pr.5.~S3"'-'-r---=-:.-}.I._'T_·--~---­
[_8/' ~IZGtt~,e '/1.tAIL. 70 /716" Us715D A D»I2C~_o_!f.I'--'-----'7J_;_(..(r.-'-3_~------~
____I'HE .Q 3 D,q Y oF f-/ovJF14/S£,t_ Olo/S

~~~'
        FEL>a~ -f'l_r_ec fJoz_,lf!/c,r ~L£,e-/c        ~~~~~----------------------------

    . d J.JD nootL ;:-ILA!/K c~tJLEY &>~~.:r ~LD6-                     =-~~=------------------------

          /13 . H. lf-tt/c-/f.F~L!__{ B~l-~VD=-----=LB~I:l.:c:::.___ _ _ _ _ _ _____,__ __
,_ _··-'LI·V A LLJ4 s1 7}t 7 ScJo '7 -l.f3z--'-c; _ __c______-=-_ _- - - - = : - - : - - - , - - - , - - - - - - -
r-·----------c---------------·--_n~d f'L/ttL J
~--------------,---------'-----------=-JE~ tA-14 il.:_f7ffl~ 1/3:_/._51=--/t7_5._3_~______
- : - - - - - - - - - - ; - - - - - - - - - - · d . G [ p f / F!'< 205"t.f /f{!UI/1-.-='GZ-~tt~'--·:. . _IT_ _ __
'-----------~----~-----                                                !E-i:_tN~££ C!.£,{,oN7j_zg_ 'ZS=.Y.~i,o_~:__-._____
                                                                   ·- -·---····--·----··-· · ·-· ··~· -·~~·- . . . .,. . .751!? Yr(EJ·-

                                                                        I
                                                                                                         F\LED
                                            \VRlT NO. \V0?-48) 64- V(A)                          ZOI5·DEC -3 PH ~: 13
                        \, , t .   o"
                                   \ \l
                                          ?·
                                          --.   ~l;
                                                .._.
                7.~\QH!0 ~ c'-+
 EX PARTE                                                      §                               .. · .@Il.l•.A~TRE
                                                                               IN THE 292nd JUffi
                                                                                                        D\S1R\CT ~RK
                                                                                                        '· LL J·"\'' S cr...-.t-I S

                                                                               ::::::~:~~:~T~~
                                                                                                        1--\

                                                                                                                          cp ,
                                                               §
                     '-
                    STATE'S PROPOSED ORDER DESIGNATING ISSUES

        Having considered Applicant's Application for Writ of Habeas Corpus and the State's

Response, the Court finds that controverted, previously unresolved facts material to the legalit.)'

of Applicant's confinement exist The Court tJ.nds that each of the aiiegations set forth in the

application are controverted, unresolved factual issues, which require additional evidence and/or

testimony to be resolved.

        Th~   Court appoints Bruce Anton to                 res~lve   the issues and prepare findings of fact and

conclusions of law for the Court.                      The issues may be resolved by affidavits, depositions,

interrogatories, or by hearings as deemed necessary by the person appointed herein.

       Above appointed attorney does not represent the Applicant. Applicant is not entitled to

counsel at this time.

       The Clerk of the Court is ORDERED to send a copy of this order to Applicant, or

Applicant's counsel (if so represented) and to counsel for the State by depositing the same in the

United States mail.

       Signed---·---------------' 2011J.

                                                                                                 Judge Larry Mitchell
                                                                                          292nd Judicial District Court
                                                                                                 Dallas County, Texas
",       r   '.

                                                                               Respectfully submitted,

                  Craig Watkins                                                Christme Womble
                  Criminal District Attorney                                   Assistant District Attorney
                  Dallas County, Texas                                         State Bar No. 24035991
                                                                               Frank Crowley Courts Building
                                                                               I 33 N. Riverfront Blvd., LB-19
                                                                               Dallas, Texas 75207-4399
                                                                               (214)   653-:~625
                                                                               (214) 653-3643 (fax)

                                                   CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

                          I hereby certify that a true copy of the foregoing response was served on Applicant,

                  Jeremiah Deshean Phillips, #15 I 2530, Beto Unit, P 0. Box 128, Tennessee Colony,

                  Texas, 75880, by depositing same in the United States mail, postage prepaid, on November 24,

     )            2010.

                          I further certify that a true copy of the foregoing was served on Bruce Anton, writ master,

                  Sorrels, Udashen & Anton, 23 I 1 Cedar Springs Road, Suite 250, Dallas, Texas, 75201, by_..

                  and United States mail, postage prepaid, on November 24, 2010.

                                                                              Christine Womble

                                                                  2