Court Opinion

ID: 4067593
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 23:24:19.91203+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:07:08.089497
License: Public Domain

Z‘()U"/€T OF £%’//)7//1//}[ AP,O£:}M£’ l§>nLFS/@

ClF/r’%: f//E>FL A COSr/¢} " 1 r
/°.O. Bm/ /<§23£>5? @U…YM§@DA[EMALS
C,/-\/°/TDL S7?47/¢7A/ ' AU@ 2»? 2315
Au§‘r/A/, 7’£)64§ 7?7// ~0?30£/

A®@U©@§i?®,©{?@?k

A 1160 5707£, § 0/5'
Nf: [A>FQ ¢/Fzr 70 F/¢F m‘r "A/O/<>z/m 7‘/@/ fws a//e/r
_0/:' m/)A/z);)m¢/.S //\/ ['/)usz A/cz ,/355/0 40 -,4 '),

 

135/m CL mm -
' /°Z FASF /'~“/A/D £A/€L 05 50 T//F JA’/G//¢/Az 0 F
M‘»r 'Z)FFFA/ZJA/vr /S a/P/G/A//)¢ A/W /Mr/p/\/ fZ/e a//_\> /7'

c>F` mA/\/D/-)mu§” Pz r€/)$F F/zf’ /~’OA /?€€o/d> /IA/
B/?//\/`G /7’ '7`0 T//F /w?/W”/@/z/ UF 7//£ F/Yof££ Oc/A>’/T

//\/ CLc)S/A/é`, I a//aa /?f/”A’F£/A?Z' ‘fau/e
/%55/$7’/)7\/€£” /A/ 7`/7//$` /)7#77?7€,

/?€5,0€€ frazij

M!<\daaaw

ii

/W/c///}»a q F?/#/c’/mz/
70 cf A/@. /Z/S %5

Z/}/)’/?‘f§/Sf c//\//7; F_Z-S.Dd_
'3;296 fm 35/"% `

B€/w/WMT, '7?')(¢/$ 7'7705

CAL/gg/ A/'O /39"3’04‘0“'/4

m/M/)a dr@sgp/J FU/m/WA/ ,' //\/-~r//F /777/L ;n/o/m¢
713 cairo A/a. /2’/5/%5,

/?FLAF@R
\/. z)/_ABLE ;mz) 65 oF S/)/z) you/971
cry/mfg /\/@M/, m/c//AEL :)“05;/@/,/ Fw/;€w/W /i’foM

Pr¢> _/¢€;> /IA/D /\/¢/w£zmez) c/ws;

UF /)cr/m/ /7‘/\/£) F?LFS 7’///§ o/P/G//\/A¢ AF/@z/cAr/QA/

/»’@/a L.J/e// QF /)M)\/zmw¢/: /°u/§>s¢/A/\/r 72> A/?T)€¢F // 07,

S`Fc'f/M/ 3 _(c) or '7'//z' 7;¢)(45‘ mcf or c/v/m//¢/A; P/€oczfz)u/€E
AA/D wound 5'/7/044/ T//F £0¢%7' 7/)‘£ Fozzou//A/é`:
_l.,
/?z:’LAT@/€

m/c///)FL J?)SH@// H////mm/, TZ)£J' A/U /S/X“%S, /5 A/\/
UFFn/DF/€ //\/ 777? 7’£/\’/9£` 2>€1@/9;\07'/)7§7\/7’ L)F` €/P/w/A//?z J’USW€§
AA/D /5 //,@/OFA/)/A/€ fm S@_, w//o MA/ BF zoc/)/FD ,47'
L/m/w G/sr Sm/Q/ TA/z 32195 F/w 375/4 EFA¢/mm/r

/L`>CH§ `7`770_5
7“/%£’ /}c/ 5006/!7’ 7`0 Bf' €0/97/’€¢£€1) /§ M/A//STF/P/AL

/\/0/ Z)/SC/»’FT/o/\/A/f"/ /A/ /\/A?' u//’é_' WFLAT@/e w/z_ L s'//o w.:
/\’FLAro/a /}7/1'/£€0 70 7'///§ (’0¢/07` /7’/5 ,A/@)"[/€/¢?“/a/l/ Fo/r’
w/m' oF /»JABF/)d< famous W/)/€// w/l§ /PFc€n/Eo AA/A
F/LED /-’M reno/m 0/\/ JuA/Fz§'/»;)o/$ OA/ J/\/Fd??"

due/5 A/\/ o/»’DF,Q DFS/_€A/_/) 77/\/6` /Ss_ufs w/,\S S/GA/FD 2?`)/

'T//¢ ;ruo GF OF T//F / 77 n D/Sm/cf 600/fr ar /M/F/P/§

cowvr~/ rams
/)7' 7'/¢/5 7’/07£’ / 7’ ///;'S BE€/\/` will 0 a/z-'/Q ”(:? 03 `/’///A’?"f

WoRN/MG DA‘/_§ S/A/Ce’ 7’//£" COU/\>/ /S’SWFD 7"/1£’

551)

l

l

f

_ f

€/7//,’/5 `D/M//£z ; .{
l

c

f

l

/%A/\’A’/S’ £0¢)/\/7‘/, 7’€/\//»"$

"OA>DF/€ 1355/6/\//47//1/6 /SSUE;S H/\/D 70 007£ 777
/\’Fz/+TM /MS W€cF/v€z: A/o /)Aa§¢./£)€ 0/\> 0>1=:/@0/\/$£-',

_`U: 0
/?F 510 OA/DFA/T“

HFSPUA/DF/\/Z €///Q/S Dm//H / /\/ /7//5 600/1077
0F 7/%' Z>/57/)’/07 c z£iP/€ UF //AA'/r’/d§ £0¢//1/77, 753-'/\/,'45`
//)?5 A m/A//SW/Q//H 1307 7 70 HF€F///F A/\/D /:‘/l.€

/-\ z L )OA/Om$ //\/ A 0/€’//)7//¢//41 /@P00€FD/A/€ ///\/0 /UHPH)/rw

ALL 07//@€ 007/03 //)QP0S‘FA _0/\/ 7'/%£’ CL£)P/e BYZ/m/
/Ou/PSUAA/z' 70 7//F 72`»‘/\/05 001-70 07 C/P/W/A/M /07’00§00%5
A/i' 7/0 LF 02 .Q /d C///»’/S DAW/f;, D/S?W/c?’ ALF/P,/ /W/)‘/ BF $F/\)vz-'D/Loc/W£o 07 /7//5 /OMF€ @F

L/Z:us/A/zs.$ /+'/j )0. 0, 507 405/, 7/00$70/\/, 7£-'/#3 7'73/0~
' 5/..

/?F 5 /°0A/Z)i-A/7' HAS W//o££ 7 54/0:-’0 /0 €0/77/00 7 M//7A¢
7//7 701/05 comr 07 c/e/w//\/AL /OA’0C,_CZ) u/P,s; /?/Pm‘¢€ //07
spar/m 3 (@/) /)A/z> 550770,\/~7 /5 Ac7//\/0, //\/ 300 /»74/7//
A/\/D 1705 /I¢so /-’0/¢' 00 70 /lFF0/P0 /r’FLATZ)A 7/%£'

/°/)’07 FSS/o/\/AL 0/¢/0 Comm@/\/ C00/.> /F$ 7 0,=' AA/‘/ L¢//r’/'/?'é\/
/1>05,<>0/\/5€3 0/\> 000/55 07 700 5779775 AA/ds’w€ 0707/0/\//$)
0/€ 077/079 />L 500/mas /P,§m/”z-'¢J 70 7//£' G/P'/JH% /,1 5
W)F/\/T/om:® //Bov¢e.

/?E$,OoA/Z)EA/v' /S //\/ I//azA7/0/l/ 0F 7//£' 77('.€,/€ ».
/M’T/CLF // 07, 5'€(:7/0/\/5 3[0/3 § 7 M/A//S?"EW/AA DUf/ES
AA/D 7/7'05‘ 7/7¢£7 ; 014/5 07 7///5 57747€ 7'00470/6 /1 10905
7//47 /7; /S KF//\/G' /7’€/;0 /A 156/410 7 /A/ 1//0¢ 777/wu 0/-
7//7' 7 775 57/}70 007/57/7¢/770/\/ /7§0/2¢2¢ /73 7//F 0/0//7?0
5 /97€5 60/\/5‘7// 07/0/\/

 

“\//omm/\/ 07 fhwch //,07 OF 7/%¢’ 707 0007 07 (sz ,OH@."
` 7/#/ /QFs/OM/zm/T \//0047;0 007/af //, 0 7 5,_¢¢7/@/1//5)

3500 6 7 05 FozLoa/d§z /A/'sfc7/0/1/ 3(0/) /7' 57/17€33
“07702 707 cOA/v/cm/G 00007 m/M/z-:§ F'//z/D/A/€S 0/»'

FAU~ 0/€ /-)FP/ro¢/§ 7//£' /»’//\/0//1/6`$ 07 7/%1-’ FF/?Sw\/
D€$/G/\/HF;D 70 MAK€ 7 /%Fm, '7//7’ mem/071 7#¢='

00

` ll00/\/\//¢’7/,1/5 000/07 5///;1¢ //)707€0/07€;7 7/$’0/1/5`07/7

70 707 00007 07 AFFHL§ 01\/0£7€ 011/7 €01/0€ o …-
707 0001/@/)7/0/\/, AW 7 /fMSw§/?S F/z¢~'z), A/\/>' 0507/0/1/5

7/¢€0 TA’/+NSCA>/)Q / 5 0/-' 711 0£~‘)00 S/ 7/0/1/5 011/0 0?/0//1/63;
077/00\//7_§ /+A/D /l/\/‘f 07/7€3-7€ 07/7707?5’ 500/7 03
07 F/c/AL //’500005 05€0 B '7 7//€ 600/97 //v A)ES<)‘A v/A/G‘
/S§UF_§ 0/: F'Acr ”

FD/P?'/%WZ, //\/ 55€7/0/\/ 7 /7 577¢7£¢$:“

“ w/¢;z/ 7//7 0770/?/:/§2/ /-“0/< 707 57075 /-’/LFS /;1/\/
A/\/$ wF)Q, 0707/0/1/, 00 070¢0€ 90 700 //1/0 A’Fm 77/\/6 70
AA/ /I/”PL/€A770/\/ /»’0/< 0 h//f’/r 0/-'\//03¢=;43 €00>/<’05 0/¢
7/%¢' 000/1177 /SSL/?S AA/ UH’DH€ /r)FL/#T' /A/€` 70 /4/\/ 9

AMOz/c/<)T/m/ 170/3 /} w/%/Z’ 07 0648€;95 €0/9/°0$ 7"//£
L'LQ€/€ 07 77/0' (’007>7 SMAL /77____/?__//, 0/`€ Z?Fz/z/¢=?€ 70

7'/7‘£" /}/O/C[/L’/¥M" /4 CO/OY UF 779£" /4/1/5&/257€ /WO7'/d/\/
/OLF%'Z)/A/G', 0/? 0£’?0£7? ”

PMYF,Q
W/»/FA>FFM£ »O/,’F/)v/ 575 00,1/$/0;2?70 071/1700 /% 50
P/? /+s/S F0/\’ /)/\/ D/\>DH€ D/A’FC?'/A/€ /PFS/O0A/Z) /\/7 7`0
/wA/L 00 071/1079 70 /QFz/¢m/<' 5000004/\/7 50
C 0,<>~,/ 0/-' 70/€ 5707? ’S AA/S¢/£)€ /7707/0/1/, 101 FA 001/6
00 Q/PDP)€- 70/\)7/>'70 /)’H mm /°/FA vs 700 mg 074-§-
7/?007 /Lz FGAL €0/\/7//1/7070\/7

/PF$/@€c7F1//; L‘»/ guam/709
WZCAQL€,Q 010/mw

/Q~FL/q'T`d/€ %H’U 50

 

<3>

PurPSu/-)A//" 70 77sz (p, TFX/f§ C/z//L /0/r’A€7‘/€F /7/\/2) _
/?FmFD/ES COD£; C///WTD€ /3¢;1 5`€€7'/0/\/ /3@7.004

217 S'z=_>cl.

I, m/cH/)FL FoSF»O/»I Fu/+¢Pm/h\/, TDCJZIA /\/0:

/ X/Z 4[¢>5, E,§/A/G’ /06’€557\/22 w /A/CM€€/MH~Z) //1/
7//; n=x'/?S’ DF,OA)PTM£/\/?` of (’/f°/w//\/A¢z fus?'/c€-
//\/Sr/ rum/wm 2)/ 1//!/@/\/, fm cJ:.z"z)) Ar 7/¢€

LF}f\’/\)L/ 8/$7 S”f/W?’ J/}/L /A/ BF//uw@/\/T JZ’FF‘??SOA/

Cow\/ / s/, TE>¢)L§ D,_Cc L/WF uA/DF)€ ,OE/\/A L 7'3= c)/-’
)°F/\’Jwe~/ / /M-r 7'//; F°a/e€O/A/G /S 7790§';‘ CO/P/chr

E)LF/Q j
THF Fa/eGo/A/c w/\>/f oF m/H\/Z>A/)W$ /S /A:m-'Q Y;'
<§/m/\//T§Q
BEA//EZJ

 

PA’FS/D//\/G J¢/Z) 6`§ '

09

§F/,>/’/mez/
UF
5`£:`/\) , l// C F

 

'7’///5 /5 7b CF/<>'r/FY 7’/%/47” A C'OFY OF 7‘/7‘;‘
/~)Boa/€ E/\/r/TLH> AA/z) A/umgf)?z-z> "_Q_/;’_/_@L/_/ZL
/')/Q¢>L/c/)r/m/ Fo/Q a//P/z’ of MAMJAM//§ “’ /7'/+5
BEFA/ 599 1/€13 o/\/ /r’FS/°oA/DFA/T’_Y C f//?/§ D/M//FL
)4/)/\>/»>/5 Cow\///Y Z)/Sr/r‘/U’ CzF/r>/€, PG B`O)C %§/
i~lo¢)STo/\/ 7?§)(/)5 ‘7`7..~?/0 %S/ AA/Z> T//F le/Q/\./ or
717/g Cw/er ar A/OPFALS AZSH ACOSTA />,0 501

/51305?, CAP/TUL 57,¢)770/\/,/‘)1/57//\/ 7;¢%/?:€ 787//~
2202 B‘/ DEL/VH?Y OF A 7'/`?¢/£’ COf"v/ 729 H/A?
E/T//H€ //\/ ,OF/P.S@AL OR \//A M 5 /77,<1/1 ZDFM$/??D

L/A/D€K T/%,_¢’ C/r/€F /M/D CMS?’OD“/ 0/' 7/92“ MS': /00$774;
SERV/c£-' 0/\/ 7'/7/£'¢1;)/\/13 Z)f/¢/ GF AVGUS); ;20/5.

M,§ MW
/\°EL/NZ/c‘ /b/o ge

(5>