Court Opinion

ID: 4069996
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 00:57:51.489649+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:44:01.729052
License: Public Domain

'U)Ll,u'?|~©&

f>

 

' ;THQS_Q°¢{_¥_Q§._C,M\”Q?¢M\$ C\eé¢>

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_Abe,l |l\cos_i@
P.o. €)_r:x \9;308
lL\\)s%`n;m ’18:11! ` _ k
. ' ' ~?’CPWM 9`{»3‘°‘5,/ ` ,RE@§i\/&IW
_Q,_Ef_€x_'€¢fl£ v ~ . d ' CGURTCFCR!M|NNAD_D§ALS
`_Amlm~)*é¢_w:zé\es ~ 559 3 9 zng
Nc`- \N¢;(o bl',_ q:ULO_Q'
~ Ab@mc@$i@,@@ez?<
. &dm@d;.is~_o._pwm_,j_» _\@¢_£\A_w,;w_¢w_{&_c¢~_%@é@v_o!¢
.__COD$L*MQM\;M. ' ' ~
3\; win
"\ _ _
4 "MDMH&QM@iW~WD
ZM\L_\)AI+ `

 

;__R\€F
'wm¥.+monpew mowerst wm
` mm comes warm emma a,,,,\;» , saw m
sopp\zmw¥a\ w`w£ MM cour~¥‘s cm§)dem¥wn
I.

\. Appilcm} sowa re.\ie(¢ ve M'J~'\imw Afpw\ 49 ¢v\@d'l'§- sP€£¢M pucwmanc£
'. a(»` a 94<\+& breach o$;\ dombrde agreemen+ nde mg MM {n
§§ aan com on woqu '\0, mo 500 Tr`\~a.\ twa €zcor& @& p\ezx aqrwne/Q.

3. anacin ve a pha agrezme:vk c\zlvns are c,M¢gpmj ana €ng+s whlc,h con
rw\' be, m`wzd or Por£¥\ed e,n¥i\»\§n% hon-'brca£h§“§ pm’¢g 4a e,`A\r\U 99me
'Perpo\'m&nu ar w`\\'\vdmw\ ¢£ pm a@mm_erv\ (Z>\TTERN\L\~\ v. 3~1?¥16,
¢80 5\»3¢\ \39,\‘-\3 &x.me-App Qm$>

3. 151 am wm w W\a¢axzm__ mud be dasm`\_ss¢d $’°¢ 42@;\\;,,9 40 gale
nasorr> why mm 99 breach w)\d m mbm pms,m&e¢\ `\n pm\’ws
Wr&-i' wh`\ch 3009'¥\+ ¢]`1> c)m\\eng¢ Cm\)\c,\»€°n, TE\(‘. (`.DDE CPAN\. ?ROC». N`-\. 4

\\.0'7 5 ‘\@.) ; S'rprr€'g, vRoPoséD \=\ubme oF FN::YE>, (‘,onc,w$\o\.\ op
LN, 09€» 51~3.

L|. Con¥m\»g 41> 4\\@ wh& wn»kr`\¥i`on,' app\;¢m), -(?‘\\`Q`A"w'&k \N, J¢r§a.\ coor+ .(i) A
"'e»rid? ¥n Svpp¢r+ Q€Wr`»+'v€ Ha.bem wva "an<\§ CSL) APP\"`QM"S respen'se .
'~+o Sm\e':s Gri`g\`na\ Arv~M, b'.»¥\~ §§ \,.)\\»ch soCi¥w¥\q clemons¥m¥e» ‘ y

Pwls mdma by m `\'\.1)'1§ L\@> rex.Coo\aC:`m \>m¢»- ~6@.@, 5\-_;¢? \“ , _
sum wwm ¢>F mens coms, wa _u/'z¢/Qo\.s,p» 995 g's; A,>p\;canx»g

\ wm~n'§h&so§:gml bmw,£»\ed '1/@/90»$' pgz,

5. Whelhu 35 a own § deric,a.\ amf 9_¢ \\w\% Q¢u~b\ ®'sm'c,+ C,\er\\wo\€nq and brw,£, w

Rs wm `O¢W W@R» g__ ear’r sc (‘.on§`\d€r&»\"\of\ se A*\e, A»vio~\ cour~)'
Pmar »\-o z\'S vu_\mg and cpn¢h)$wn op Ju\q 30 905
'Pr\or P\@.a¢\\'ng$ and brie?s ¥`\\Qd w'\-“n %\avrr`vz Cm:\¥q béswc-& Ceef+
wh also m\egmg w breach hm\o¢w\ \gnomd er.no~\ £\\€Q\ ’\m-W~
'~_+`+w,' J»r€o»\ covf-‘r',¢ d§§p\aqif\g a£wmie, appumcz, @£ o. c,\er\'c;~\ mt
. Bez, A-\\o¢bmexi% ap lnqu§/s, daw,\ A`€ 95,;0\$ ,‘ Sq,_.’ 3\,.;0__»$'-
w. .‘F"Qr evid minors abew» app\icam aez\<»°» -'\\ne, er-\"s- considera~\~\‘m »\<,

mm rd}€¥ @£00§"6( <\-\“\Q,W\ or remind vM\\» bach -\0 ..\.da\ @qf-\- for
dmlopm»» J w wavqu xava

hwé?~\'¢r m we md cs>~w\ eo\)§es,J-

1 Qe,wecwuw/. .S.\>e>v`/\\~rva\>J

% 4 ‘7¢24»20'5`

Au@ezw emm\e§,. "Pw 3a ~
£F\asq?>¢€>

' 884€“@ ~un`\‘\' .

904 m 34'1€&!

. m»§v\\\e., v “1’1390

m QF C\Z.\m\u&\

 

Ae¢>w\$ § iam
a ?m+@ “o_v\\&~ U+, fm ~oa
Anim)o @mw.\es,
AYTACAN\EHFS
whom C°g:¢$ §

\nqu`\f@$ owe 40 l»\t.rrls €»\m¥% 6\3>¢¢`\0\' Q\@rk;
Yv.@md\-nj pmiws ¥~\Q& pmm$g/ g,q@£s_

3@@5

. €§H»§z ¢£??Mi§§ '
~§¢~»’i'i`§ §§w~§§ §§>'i§'ih\,§ §§@f§;»;

 

 

 

 

§O‘ §§w“ €§§.S’ ' , v §~-M'€'i§ §Lw?§?§:\;"£ f§"“§§~§“§£¥
i§w§§ - “"F i?§§ _ ‘ , i%§§ §§ iii
4 A§§i,i §§ JW iii»‘i m 3"¢/" ii §§ _
365 §’»i_)m):§§§'»o\.' §"’m§£wx ij 7 " l §»§i;w?‘§£§f§:§¢;vi , ”’?'F' '?"73;@

f/éi §§ £7!'.@-¢?§§£-‘?:;,?$‘»
§ f§@,§ §§ 9 /@§zj z /§'i §§ i'z,§,§ j

 

li;i¢:»“z§€ §§,¢-ié:v`

 

§§ fz¢i"¢?¢'?§ ii»?§§§§$ § j;h~¢;'/ §§'€ B€§Qw . F§M::¢:’§§?F';w é,v) §§
-¢?_»;w' §§//4'”¢? v SFFF;¢""’ §§ BMWFS -f§?¢'$e /J'§M" /"§ K§a<”ifnr’zm*i§,z, §MH>'M?:
_ §§ ~§»:W) i§»§@:/: §!-»§§ rz§§ §§MS»~ §§§§f#§ §§ §§ we
'¢’§f$j/§§ »'..Z}L?§»~'z §§ `~é§‘i? §1».’~ p,;;gf§- i»»'f»:) ¢»,3.§}¢ !¢§2 §§ -IA?AMHM??~$?.

 

 

 

 

 

 

M§"F"m»~i/ i*?i§q¢~im§ - 7 §:`»i} §§5»€` .Y»~f.z~fr’m¢’fi)" 631 FB§§'$ - é@v§ 257!!§"
3 )§'Mr§ w ,§M§w M-“" WMF w x!/i§»:-‘”»?j ¢,“§€ wis §§ £f>/ 1‘

 

@§L§a: :i`§?; swan/rag m"§l §§ 523 fi¢fci ?/ici /m.*;§);v§fvi /.;»1 +"rf»'f\_¥ (z;:.w4§
/¢'>'vzi,:¢ r:)'s¢'§ ¢'"Q)»'!F§iS/§/* off tim/§§ §h» 7793// J}, I§' 5¢§;@”?5 -.;..h.~`§
z.?/z/’.¢;r§irw; am 5 M?§ :zf€f’sé/r»!mi m Hi€ him €Quf';i §vr I`€i*/~P§} ri?)~"r`cv‘
lis §.§»/" ¢“=:/>(§s/§m /,:,~.d i’@¢-'<.Wi//) §zi»~z §§ viui§ 5;'1051 §@/.F. j

525 /.r;/:/ 4 l - `

 

-,i§m/£?Az'£~""é’?ii €"?i;ms?"f§ -M_~, il 6

 

 

'Chr'~s 5?355'56"5

34956%5 '€¥6»6*335-5 4339534" ~€.~\65\6.

655 655 43 35

955565565.5 353 2126 363\

4 §epwmber 34 2075
Q€ Prev£o§s £`.\5£.\ 963¢35~35,355¢\
eammamgv with CWM 956/467 94 "?j£wf
__ €6656.5\\¢ 64493\\ §

- ‘-€J€?N{ Uefk 6
__ 4 ""W\é's 53 659 ..6£66<\ 9446555935 69 59695¢65 496 3404\)39¢ 966»9639§
._-.§\\96 94623€€\7\3:> 665{3 40 dia€€.m 9mm 9`965¢ 944\5`-.95, 994 999\")\5` 995.\39 C,-N¢4
996 655 669 555 65066 3 339 555 4,/56; 3553 54 996 695

poihMps 355 mm 959 555 5936<2 §§ 651554\5'\9 663\.665*6@5.6 565 955 6565'4

6¢50.5 535 `"7} wig 6653 jw¥er_p%aa% 596 955\;526 9( 629 ¢\65555146_5501

(7) ` 676 6556._65'53636 996 5957..-9:\~.'9~55 \~565'~35 455 3559{5\56 9355)5 3565
‘ 9666\655 56 9055€3€\, 3666566, `2351*~2265955€;€... 696 3[ 66;65>¢3 999 555 34-085{-§-,,
'»‘565556 356 5565655656 3663 495 5/¢5716\$; 959 9565<>555
463 €)£56§ w wWMG§ 63376 393€93{96553 696 9[33}2§3 63536 9534‘403"@
fws 55 3§5~65 3555963€397} 96355§ 953565536¢4.;,956 959 999 996 655 999 of '5/2_.5)/2»'1)

(2} L@‘§Lq 496 49de 963 §§54556345> L.`M 964 644 méel 34 \’1¥5`~44.\

655553¢3- ._€95¢3, 355-674 6‘7/;66/_2073,555 6365§;6 556 .67665\»65

. o ‘»
cc: znd hqu 3`“'_'»"”‘ 9__"7”'4 mi €mMM/l 3

res\)\ied .'.¢~Y&m$" w ‘$\,WQ¢.* o( “Mas'coé;'§ . nw wave bwU%M
be-{`m~€ ~4!\@ £wf~'_¥' pr'\or 34?,~' "I/ 201 JQ¢§` Cvde¢'p ¢-,o.\_._{`q 341 em@m‘mq
-p"alr-S~e§ 4545>€$} €,\e,¢ii,¢.a\ ¢.¢mi_,

~7&&1'1,€3 (/J.)

 

ppg gym érloz~a@'€$ H/?¢?‘i§' VO
5316/§ ' l/n# _ v "'
3:,¢/: rm 343 w

`_ /;,_/;,,»,é~z??)‘}€».,--'W ;/‘3»@.“,: _

>tc'i' led I.l..*qwl~f f&¢§f jjo §7@‘”,' §H¢'/ Fé`l»"£( MJ q?ag/l‘£