Court Opinion

ID: 4049045
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:50:33.964707+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:28.360073
License: Public Domain

' . ' ` _ l ga qa\’oQiOB\OqIO§/M

T\"J`Z C,Q\L'(X C,»c Q)f\`\`\"\§\’\°s.\ &PV€°~\§ `B\.Jv\e_ ?,g; 10\$

?.o_ ?>ox \'J.?>o%

[\\>e,~`\~n, T'~r`. "|'~`¢`l\\

\2€.'~ ch\ov\<§ O.'dz,-r; O\>:\ec:"<{on \'c ‘~’>¥c\‘§€\& proposed Q»i~r\c.\§v\r`>>S
E>` P¢.`,‘, \'Lz»\‘\C\\-\-A; \'LS§%?,\»A', \'1.2,\%?>€~¢\; \'Lz§€¢%\'A

c.Q_‘t>~ O`¢¢.Ov<&e. as \\`\c>. \NQ%?,~UQ.\-Q')_,-Oz` ~e\\ \ -o§ w\<~.\, 'c>c¢

O‘n Fc\oruo.\'\{ 1§+\')'.10\5, w\§% 00qu o`\oq*c@c\ w\\l \'\c\\oec\,s proc¢¢<-).;m§s Jro ~¥\ne
WiA\ Qc>\>v_i‘, \3\>\~'>\.>¢,\\'\\ -‘co -\-\r\`\%, ~¥\r\e SXC>:\€ made o` spw>‘_,°$ec\ QN¢\@(. \ o`W` unawcx¢
§§ J;\'\e_ ¥Y-zc\\ cycon SR%v\ec\ &\’\is .o~r, `\$ \r\e cS.\`C\ o`v\\\-\wn% e\g€ am m\\ \,\,“\4( _ ;u{
\D`\e.`s \;N~°pc,s¢¢\ maker \o@¢<>~\>s¢
\\oe,'\`\e.\/e m \”z*\xc>c\c,%\`v\`\-\{ c\\no;\\{$\`s \'\‘c \oe condockec\ \0@<;¢\\>;~‘».. *v\e \o¢~_ro\e.

¢L\:\»>
w{»gv~mg-\-;¢~=+ \\\\5\\'\¥0r\v\o`¥~~;ov\ was 0~\’\ essen\iq\ pc\v\ o& n\\\ p\e_o_ O\¢§re<>_me,n+ 'Qo\r

m\\ -\3\'\\1<';¢ \`\Q»e, %enXe~nc<,s, . To \'\'N\ Co§\cu\o&\` ¢v_\ , 5 \.~\-»\e_ 95 , ’lc>\§ `\5 '\"(\ e c\ ox%e. -\-\r\e, ze.ce\'é
SY\§\)\A be 3e1va \Qo_`c,\¢ \-0 ~¥\r\e, C.C, .b. , QDQ.c_o.\,>Se_ \ \¢\c~\/c r1 o \c.v\ ow\<&%¢ Q~¢r\d '\`\ne_
'\'\K iO\\ C`O\>‘(* \'\G~S ’(\0'\ SC'<\\ (\'\€, '\5< 3 L>\NY\ 9 § Y`\<,\<\’\ cbs O§ §§ch 0\' C_->\f\c_\\>$io‘ns §§ \G`W , \

3@\\<) +\f\i§ \-0 \\ou m ~‘<‘ne e-¢z,\/v\ `\-\ does adm ~W\e E>XC\X€; Q§ -¥‘<"\'\§ <,\c>`\.`, \/\u§ -*c\ne C,\d\>\'*\ c£ C.v \`mw\o_\ l\\c\azabs Fec.€_i\rec\ q S\>pp\e,w\c~nl.c\\

-\»Y&v\go,\(`\o-\ my(g\_,o;“-\ w `\~\`5 §>~Q<"\? \Q\Qc\s,e,. `\n$wr\eose. \'\o*&<-»\ me ~\Y\oé\ \\o¢ vaccich -‘<'\ne, -¢¢\\¢Wm% ew¢'\@;€¢\ g;\w\?y

§§ \"\ Cere_\\,\ l

REcElvEmN _ . @DMW w m &_
©QUH\` OFCRlMlNAL APPEALS l
JUN 29 2015

\J`_c)d~ne,\.,\ \¢ev\`»n \N§'\\\`ckw\$ S\’.
T`o.c_>. vi \e%§&z*l
'\:\'<¢\nc\/\ (N\. \Qc\oe~(-\son \)\r\\'*<

 

\10~\\ c.\v\. 3§?_2,
A\»'\\en<, mm 'c¢uom\

‘ Cw§e‘,*‘* \'L'L\F\q')_~A, \'),unc\»\'o., \1$§%1,\~», \B\C\?>S »A. \'Lz€c»¢e>\» A

E`/~ `Qeu"c€, ' ' \Y\ 'W\e CO\)Y‘\'
C>; .QY\`\\/\{v\o\\

Qc>c\\'\e»‘ \[\/;\\{(uv\§ l A‘PQ€O~\S¢ b\\\">""\an\‘

 

5\0`5€_¢&\00 \0 '\'Y\e 3\'03<€.`3 Q(bpeseé '\:`\\/\¢\m%s 09 \:ch-¥ cwwc\
Cc>v\c,\\>${on$ O¥ \_c\\~ ex\c\ C§\’c\e.\r l\C.-\'z\( Qeri\onc\ \o\\ '\'\'\&

Cc-\>Y\ op C_.r\`nn\`no.\ kppec\\$

 

I. \n~\'voc\§c¥€¢'n

.?\Q-Xe.v \”Q\v\ox\c\ gram ~\-\<\e, C_(`,.A., -\'\'\e, %\’0.-\-&, in `\X'S
§vc>p<>sed\ order §§nc\s C\pp\ic_o.v\-¥'s C/\O;\w\ +Y\QX \<\e, \Nc>\)\c\ ‘{\o`\re,
`\v\s\s§ed cv\ %\>m%' ~‘*\ ¥Qv Q:o\mae-\‘§ wis a¢\\;§c@ on
'pc\v<>\€, C'l'\`\c\>>§‘oi\\"\\(v Qrc&lb\e° |\S. Q¥- ~‘<\n§s dog-kai \/\e, is u_v\o§\:cxré
`\§ ~\\\e *\vi\>{X c\c:\\>p‘ce@\ -\»\<\e 3’§0:\€.`5 Q§\r\c\<\no_>%, \¢>QX €\'\es
_-\~\r\`\§ o\o§€.c»-A<€QW c\oe_ *\‘e -‘v\ne 6~\<:\~&€ ov%'w\% -\`\ne ¥Y\MX
ox\a\ +\<\e CD\>eo\s Jro condch 05 ra*&c,¥§v\'¥\l
cma\\\s'\s, “\"Y\e §c£v%e J<\r\e Cm><\ o(-
Q,~¢'\w\ma\ P\\)veq\g ‘co %ee whe\\nex e.\!\o\>sso,za <\e\(\ `I§_ BQ,\

 

S\I\¢`?>A (o“E>\'\ CTes<. Qr\m. !>\pp. 20\2) `\s Ve‘<~(oc\c,&R\/C ‘\'0 Co.%e§
OCC\>\'YW\B XS€,§O(§ VQ.\OY\)CLX\.\ \S, 10\”2_. l>\\=<¥\o§\g\c\ ov\&<>,< ‘W\€,
(\`cb\@’v Q,`wc\>m§~¥ox\<,e% q re¥rocx¢¥\\/i&q cw\&\\\s\>\¢\ \oe
pexm\s%`\\o\e,. -W\e issue `\5 `\Y\a\')x)\\`c,a\o\e because C-»Qp\`\cgm°< -m€c

`¥\(\e Skai\c\oxé\ \>Y\<;\ex ls\(\o\>ssqiozcle\n T§_ ioL\ %.\$\».?>¢X M\ou\ L\`ev`\

 

(`x\w\. D\\Qp. Lmo\d -kc> c>\o~\c_o§\\"(\ <`Q;\Ke’? \>~0<3\<>_‘( cm\ ®\\veqc§~q

QSX&\Q\KSY\§A precede<\-’v becauge ©cwc>\e. Q,\{c§`\\o`\\§~\\\

m`\sin$ormcx°<~ \Q`\; o\ec\~ cx<§e,emem‘.

\v\ \{%"<\‘< c;>€_ Ex @¢\YXQ §\~e~p\ne~r\&ovw 711 %~\)\»&_1& \A"L(¢ C’\ex‘ Cx\`m.

 

Aop. \_Quv“‘c .Y\eec\s -¥0 33<`\’\\ v(l\>v\\<\e\f deve\oo
+`\ne recorc\ '+0 make Speci@ic ~C&c*c §§\~€\Rn%s ve%avding “W\e
`\m\o\\`c:i+ +evm§ -\-`\r\o@\ \O\{ S`\%Y\\\(\C}) £o~r m \i§e Sex\¥e>r\ce\ raw
COY\Q\>W@)(\* C<>r Cx\\ C)n&v'%e$ `\Y\ a `b\eq ba<%acn, \<\e \NQ\>\G\
be @on\e, e\{g§\o\'&.

`11. E%Sero°vio\\. QOJX 09 \3\&0` L%re,eme~v\‘\'
é\!\r. \N§\\i`\\X\\ w 0.\\ c_'>€ \ms crimes »QQ¢ §\§Q@.
SQWXGV\C€ <'.C>~\(\ QO\\ C,\>\r‘<'e_\(\>< ~Qor &\\ Q\(\qu\€_.">.' `\'Y\€_ \\ €c=_-
5@0%@\\<;@§ ram wv-\u>w@(\k was pm°\ c>§ a ~\o\eq \Dc\v%o.l\n\
N\\’. \|\\'\\\\`Cm\”\'$ Y\&S O\ Co\o\\ c:>€ “\'\0\`§ p\ea &%reemem~¥ amd
\(\<>¢Q§ we C,\ex\¢ Q\\.. m Q@\O\\ @S)mre>zmev\*< as \\\1@\\. \X? ‘<\03<, |`;‘<\e \N'\\\ i§\>\m\`§\\ R\ `\’€
<`Qc>\\>e,§?a-\@
`\\(\ vesc>\vmg *v\(\`\> w\e§?ec§vi\/e &ss§§*a\r\ce Q\cl'\m, ix ~¥`Y\cfv {°r
made §_0_ 52ch Ae%e\rm'mo€\(\ 0300\>’¥
pmc>\a was am essewv\c\\ pad <>‘€ \‘v\r\e \p\eo. agreemem*.
15\\-\'\00\>%\/\ -\-\(\e '\Qo.ro\€ `\v\$o\ecL u%rce‘m€)r\§x '\‘r§e,`\"~?, `\\’ \c\\o§ `\w\@\ic\"k\\‘
`\m;)\`\ec§. T\'r\exe `\5 Y\o r&%\onq\ ways 00 \N\n\)\ &op\`\'umk _
\No\>'\d p\mc\ c§\>`\\‘v\\ \'0 ‘<\(\\fez_ \i§e %e.\<\%e\r\c;e& mm
Qc>v\cov rex\‘< jm \(\<5 \:>\e& \QO.(Q>QM\, `\§; \<\e \\\)o\>\ck<\`>\ \o\>,
@\e e_\`\§\\o\e.. T\s -qQQ\Rco.v\X c\\"‘vcxc;\(\ed Cx’> cm E~p<\`\\oi% Jkc>
\®\S hcx\)e&s emma ~ ms *<~<{s Q§~Qidwi-\ `\Y\

2

<`e‘>p¢mse +<> 0. SXC\XQ. \om grievance em+o;\\€d %\r\§§ \NO~S +\r\e
<>v\\w\ reason \\e_ was \p\e.uémc§. Q§\>R\\-\{.
TY\€, S\'ok€_ -pr‘o@oscc§\ Qov\a\\.ss\` was Q>Q \Qw cmc\ 9ch ~Cmg\in§

are `\v\u;§eqm-"v€>,. -l\$ &‘n\'ql\ed `m \\(\c>\>ssc\zqcke\n XI, `\d . / Qv\

 

e&§evv‘riq\ md 0€ a p\ec\ 0`%\'&¢-0/\@\"\"< mo_s'\ \o`e ?<>\.)\(\d L>pcm *\0¢
€~‘A~oress Jvexms 0% W\e \s\wi¢\°vev\ @\eo` ug@@me:»m §J\se\? , ~'€v\e

-Pmma\ wacoch ed *r\r\c p\e& V\€c>x'\<\%, cv J¢\ne \:\m°c‘ce,v\ or

 

+e§r"\\\\on\`a\' Q\l'{ cheer S\>\O\. Tv\¢\qs’< prong `\s

 

~W\e. K&.">\)e \(\Q\(Q. “\`Y\@ &~cic\\ C‘Do<% needs \”0 o\c\cX(css `\£
§>cm c>\e €,\`\%§\;>L\ {"c\' WCLS 000 QBS€‘I\\'§G\\ &\©mer\‘\ 0{' “\Y\e p\eq
Q<§>vezme'x\* w\'\'\r\ o.v'\ Q\:i'c\e>c\*se, C\\\\'\o\>%‘r\
~W\e, p\eq \om%c\in papers ¢\o OQX \OC\LAQ pa<<>\e \QCQ\)S€ 09 3¢\’\&5 C&S.€, , cup Q\§QQ~(\% -`\5 e\(\‘v'\¥\ec\
icc re\ie(l\ T\ne; record _`m 'W\\% Y\cx\oeo.s promdm§ v\e>zc\s
-\D be expanded `\v\ \K%\(\X 09 E\ ‘Oc\(%e, S*vep\n@(\g.c>(\ , "\c\\
II.. `Fov°<\\€_f` beve\c>(.>w\e.v\*< 09 ~¥\r§@ 'Q.~ac,c>»rd
\N\»\eQEc»'<>Qe @r),em\;€s cows\oe\zc_~o, A~Qp\c¢cm'\ pm`~\§ -w\e_ >‘(\c§\\.\<;~*< cm Qv \`c\e<\~\-%ox\\ \/\eo¢r\`r\c\>> cmc§
expand -\-\(\e_ reco(é\ 3m de~‘‘<" wis §>\QC\

'@`o§x'eeAWKW wm a

Qoame~‘ \z_@¢m- \N;\\caw\§ S¢\
T`@.Q.‘¢. v \\°3§%27
\?{e,\n¢\n N\. \2¢\0¢\/\5¢»~ ow&
\20'1\ \f.vv\. %Szz

b\\o§\ev\;\ T~i~` TC\\QO\'

‘ - Ch\`>§e =FF. \LZLHQ?.-A',,\'z'?.\\'\qu-A\ \1€§@'),&»¢\,' \Lz\Q%S-A; \'Lz§c°\r“\'

YO$ Cr\`m\’v\cx\

Qs:é\\ne\( \N§\\\`<>W\S A\Q\oea\$, b.\)S'\\`n\Ti\.

\)nS\NU\'\ DQC\Q\<'<>§¢§OU/ /\‘€Q\`c)»c>`\l`\*v per \~\o\\oea$ C¢\~,rous

ch\>se“* \7,?,\)<‘1<11~A; \zzquu-A; \v_§§‘ez,\ »A‘, \1%\Q%S~ A~, \zzs@Q\-A

\, ro\ne_q \x\i§\\icw\/\S, &§Q'ww\ \ ‘&%cee.¢\ w p\ead %u{\*c\\
-Qc>v a\\ 0% mg 0‘<€@0§€5 m above So\id ch\)$e. v\\>w\\oex~s $o\r
0~ \\`(»`€_ %e‘<\°ve\f\c£, YQ~(\ w\(\c:\>we,~r\°r ~@w' u\\ @V\o.r%es because,
' \o\{ Yc>\\¢`w\g ‘v\n\& p\ecx \Om'%o£\v\ , mg OG<'\OW\QH Jvo\d me -‘:`\r\e
€%SQW‘H&\ Q(,\drc>( ¥o ii ‘\I\\Qo\d \0@ -‘<\(\c€r .\ \Nou\d \oe e,`\`\%`§`\@\e
_Qr,c @d<'c>\e C>‘(\Q &&q¢"\"(\c>, @\e& barg@£\\r\ \ €f\m\'e'{€(,\ `\\’\'¥05
`W\`\Q\e w\@s‘0\/_ \N\X\J\ 0 \'\§e, Sex\‘ve\nc:e \:\M\/\ no mv<>\e,
\ mmqu gova ow\ \(\\\\N *v\l\`\s Qx>\>\<\ m‘v \oe_ o.v\ Q§Q>c\*q:'o\\ @c\<’v §
mg \'>\ea &%'ce@r\*» Ccm\<\\q QQ~\. \ €QQ\ -\\r\`\g C¢v\\» \`c,_"v€c~(\
§§ uv\ wn§c;`\@\r_\&\o\\)\ \m©c\>w `§\»e\'\c,i<)~\ 5\\§<@1\0¢ `
©\>vs\)c\<\°f w presex\*r\\\ \Oe_`w\<\)) incwc£,\<"€v\"\ev\k §§ Q'< \\m'\v\e\\ \\\>S*<&Q,e, \ 0&@`\¢ m J<\<\e
0&1»\1€, `\S \’v\)\#; &Y\;X _mee€;\ w ~¥\/\Q \oes‘\ 0‘& _