Court Opinion

ID: 3497386
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-07-05 22:04:59.580725+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:15:34.406073
License: Public Domain

Plaintiff was the guest or gratuitous passenger of her daughter Alice J. Cook, who was driving the car of her husband, the other defendant, Ray G. Cook. The mother sat in the back seat and the daughter in the front seat of the coupé. The mother and daughter had been working, moving household goods, and were on their way to the home of a friend for dinner. Driving south on Union avenue in Grand Rapids and coming to the intersection with Fulton street, the daughter brought the car to a stop, or almost to a stop, and then pushed the control into second. The car crossed the intersection, collided with a pole on the side of the street, and plaintiff was injured. The daughter was "tired," "rather tired," "tired and worn out." When she started to cross the intersection, she lost consciousness, or fainted, and recovered at the moment of the impact. Plaintiff had verdict and judgment. Defendants bring error.
There can be no recovery, no negligence of defendants being shown. Verdict for defendants ought to have been directed as requested. *Page 182 
If the daughter did not bring the car to a full stop at the intersection, if it continued to "move a little," it makes no difference, for this has no causal relation to the accident. The sole proximate cause of the accident was the daughter's fainting, or losing consciousness, which is not actionable negligence.
Reversed without new trial. Costs to defendants.
WIEST, C.J., and BUTZEL, POTTER, SHARPE, NORTH, and FEAD, JJ., concurred. McDONALD, J., did not sit.