Court Opinion

ID: 4056038
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:34:21.058719+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:05.280168
License: Public Domain

.,..                '   -

fu-~~~ ~\W\~\rillJ«
-~~~~-~'U ~ \s.'\\o_\\'-\
~~JfL.~ '\f • '\\~\\mrwa Df
~\t~~:V't\1'' ~~s.b~on~Tk~nnclt~                                         ()F-
~s ,()mri ~f\~ln(\ !')~ ~.~ ~~~V6._~m~~ tit\.dl~~f'Vrd
~'\)\~~a>\,~\~\ ~\tlL\\\D\ ~.~LU \'b~t::J1,,\\)~D2S~~
CLM~D~~.
             -\~ ~'\..s..~\.~t'M-~ur\~~ u'-~~ ~~~
~.H& -~ ~\.,~ -'c:"-o__ \\_~~ \~~\)"'-1 ~LL) ~r~ ~ LDL\:'){\~dv.
~ \~l'd.\L~,d_q~~~~m~~r_.~\h,.r-~L~\\,~
~.\..O.~~s-d..L\..n.~'-~·-~·~\~).\'rutl:~~~~Cx..r\.~L~~
\~~ \:.~~~w..r:.\.~cs'~~"c"M..~\.l.M-~r l:t-LMl~ ~~~r ~
~~&~~~-
             --c~~~~\.1..~'--~~&Q~~~~~~~
   ~~lliV\~\\ U\~\\'1\~ \/~L~'E~                        l~ \Yt~ \~'\.~~\).~~t.'"ilih.t~~\
       \~t__~- ~D. \Sl.\ lo'/ \l\                       ~~
              ~~'                                       \\~~~~~ ttJ~~\.~ ,\ti~<:;.
"\/.                                                                       RECE~VED ~N
                                                                         COURT OF CRHVlll\fAl APPEALS
       ~\\~~ ~~~~\:..L ~\\ostl~~~~\n.~\~~
       ~ ~ ~~~\1'\o\ ~,M._~~                                                    AUG 17 2015
                        ~~                                                  £\bel Acos~a, C~erk

       \\ ~\_\\.~\"li~ \)~""\.._~~\\\_ \\~~l~U\.\lli~t~~\b~"""S.._\ \Jt
           \\\\~~\\~
          \\) \\\t__ \-\.D\'-SD~~ "2\\l~bE D~ ~Th ffi~\ :
                  ~~~ ~\D, ~~~ ~h.e_ V'cJJ.x~r, Wn~', ~ ~ Ln -th.L
       ~\Je.d-~\ ~ ~1~erl ~ n ,,~() "D~ ~3:~f\ ~ ~ i..~ ~ D,~ru1
       \\~~~~'~'\.."\. D~"'OJ\c\.~u_~, ~~ t:e (4,-\:\.th.. \t. be ~H~f\ ~(c.)
       ~~ \:.~~to~\)t(=~~\~~-~LUI"\ulrl~~tk.tourt t\u_
       \~fu~~~~·
       ~ . ~~\_\\~~
           \\ ~\ ~~~ ~~~\\'c..~'li"' ,\ ~\_'""S.-~n ,\S'-\.\nl \4 L~D.i"\ D~~ L(\~.£U~de.cl.
                   L(\. 't.~~~ ~~t'\~-\:.~ ~~ ~L~~ ~tL ~\.~c.~~\) ,.., r.-~
                       ~~\ ~ ~ ~\.n~ o:l:. ~ \J. (:\;tl_tt_d \l.fu..t           dl_\)   fh ~~.
                       -s....o~c:.... ~cAt~~~ 1\o:fu,'\ •
          ·\.t)d....   ~t"~~'k~~ \\i.~~dl~~~f\.0 D~\uu- adoq,,ok_
                       ~~\~.
          \ ..~~ \'ru_~~~~~~~\'~~;~r\\.-c~:wu-~Lci,~~c\i~illh~Lt\~ ..
                 \\L~ \\~.\'tt>\ ~~ ~~\ ~~~ ~~~ ~ Ltf\mui~
                 ~~ O..N'U'i'l__\:_ \:D ~~~uri \)~ ~\..~~    \\w
                                                          cl ~ Q.. to~~~ lc~ ~ud{~~!("\
                       ~~ ~~L-\ ~~ ~ to"'~~'-~ CU'\.~trS.. ~~~I~ C>.. ~t\. ~~.n:k.
                       ~U...\:\..~ leo~~~"-~~\:.~~\-~w~ ~~ L~ -t'M..
                       ~~\.tt\.~ tnw-t fu.t ~ \::.~ \:.~ose_ ~ L~~-~-~ ~\ved. ~~
                       ~~c~\:~o.~'¥\ "~f\ ~~ ,\.Q,"'\.:~ o~~~tn'~' ~ e..J\..~ers..
                       ~\iA:.~ ~ ~ ULr '\:L'\(~ ~ti...~J"i\.f\ \:.'M_ ~~t\. ~~ili \::_~ hM.lit\tt
                       ~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~~.:\.~ \'6 ~~utt~~ ~l~~ \\~ ~~c'
                       ~~~~~~~~~~\n-\:.~~~~~\.~~
                       ~~~ ~~os.~~n.s._~ ~~t~~woWA Nu,e__
                       ~~eA. ~'t. \.ll_~n t'ta ~~ b~ lt-tl"\l..~ \\~~ .
                                                   \
(
\.\\~··~~\.'C.~~ \.c~s
 ~\..),.__~"""-~ ~~   \\w--,\s..

       \\~~\..~

        ~ ~~' ~ ~cD:-"'- .~e.~"\::~ ~S:.M.ci. ~tnrS. L.n
~\)~ ~~\..,~\:)"" ~' Q~-\: ~~ ~ ~-~~ ~\tt.d:               I

                                   ~~\5\W~\~.W'<\LVfkqr~
                                       ~'
  ~~~~~~~~ \:.\Us._\:...~\~\:.."~D~ ~ ,~\~.

            ~-\L~\~ \J~ ~\J~

       ~ ~€.-~~~~\::~c._~.&..CC~~\~~ t:'M__c.~\J-e_~'S\
~' ~,\.-\ ~'\- ~- ~~u..~ ~ b\Al: ~-~ ~~~~
~ b~ ~~~ \.L--~l ~D~J) ~\)LtJL~ '6.JL~~ on. ~
 ~~ ~~*-' b ~ ~t;-\ tv\L~ ~S. brt= ~~ ~, '{) ~~ \~3D~
                                             l

~~\ ~~~ ~\\,'U_'i._~~ 1%1\\ Dt\-t:'hl5..t'nn_r~'n~D~ ~~J)
\S:~ ~\.L\'1\~\f&.u-                  -s...\S\tlt. \~~~u.~~\\h.
       '~L~-~\ \~~\\4                 ~~S.\,~'"S._t_\ ~\>S~ ~~

          ~'                          \\c,s,t~ ~~~t-eo_~
\f.

      ~\\~~~~~\...._ ~:tt,~~fur~-.,
  ~~.~ ~~~ lr..~t-.~ \~
            ~~

                        ~~~
          \)" ~'hl_~~\~l)~~k \u._cs-c\-th.L~~                \_ ..
  ~"'S- ~~"-'l-. 'm- \..:>..-\_\\)If~~ c.ru,\ ~~~~~{'~
      ~ ~ lnvs-\- ~ -t.~ ~ ~~\ ~:                           -\\~
- - - . C:,M\.~\~~ '
        ..

     fu '~~~ ~M~k\\'ili~
           \s<\~~.\~- . ·· . ·.. ·.
     . \~~~-~·D.
     ~tA~'"s_ \J ' ~\)..s~~- \.Lt'\i_~
     ~')\ ~\'-'\.. ~~(\ \~...             "·'

     ~'~k
      .......-.........
             ,   ..,...
                        ~,r,;~\~
                          '~'.   ,.~
                                ..;,..~

         ~<.,~\':)~,:~\~

,i
I
r   ~;~~\At<\(~ \..u.~~'M_\fcJler
    \~~-~l\S'\~l\q
    ~w-\i.~ v. ~\lr~ Ufu'\
     ~\   1=\'\ ~q. \\\'.
     ~\.Oc. ~cu~ 1\'L.I~~
        ~~'~\S                                                                   RECEIVED IN
                                                                         COURT OF CRIMI

                 ~~~
         ~~h~rl.. ~~ ~ ~ \:.'NL ~~~r)~Df\
    ~ '~~~ cx~~~h~\~a~\~,~~~~b"~C()~~
     ~~~.

                 \.'-.J-A-.~"- """'' c.~'\.. o.\1 (;_~s&- e.J\tl-\1-..   \:,\,U,<;_   ~'
                                            \
          '   '

 ~~ .\\-\E t_~u~~ \)~ l~"l\\-s._~\\\_ \\~~Et\~ \JY \~Pt~

~~~\l\\\~\\ lliMu_~~\\ \f\\\_\._'t~
      .       \\\4.~~

\f.

\\~~\..~\..\\~\\~ \J~~t.t~l.~~ \D \\-\.E. ~\~\E~ r1..~\\"l~b
 \J'" \\\~\ ~, \\~~ C~J:J~tw~--s._.t)~ ()~ \Ji.~

                                      \
\          , ....

                                                        CHRIS DANIEL
                                            HARRIS COUNTY DISTRICT CLERK

    June 25, 2015

    NKRUMAN LUMUMMBA VALlER
    #1546714 DALHART UNIT
    11950 FM 998
    DALHART, TEXAS 79022

To Whom It May Concern:

    Pursuant to Article 11.07 ofthe Texas Code of Criminal Procedure, please find enclosed
    copies of the documents indicated below concerning the Post Conviction Writ filed in
    cause number 1030025-D in the 184th District Court.

    D      State's Original Answer Filed

    D      Affidavit

    D      Court Order Dated

    D      Respondent's Proposed Order Designating Issues and Order For Filing Affidavit.

    IZ] Respondent's Proposed Findings ofFact and Order June 24,2015

    D      Other

    Enclosure(s)- STATE'S PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT AND ORDER

                    120 I   FRANKLIN   •   P.O.   BOX   4651   •   HOUSTON, TEXAS   77210-4651   •   (888) 545-5577

    PAGE   I OF I                                                                                                REV: 01-02-04
                                 Cause No. 1030025-D

EX PARTE                                    §

                                            §
NKRUMAN LUMUMBA VALlER,
 Applicant

      The Court has considered the application for writ of habeas corpus, the State's

Original Answer, and official trial court records in the above-captioned cause and in the

applicant's previous habeas proceeding. The Court finds that there are no contro-

verted, previously unresolved facts material to the legality of the applicant's

confinement which require an evidentiary hearing and recommends that the instant

habeas application, cause number 1030025-D, be dismissed because the applicant has

failed to include sufficient specific facts establishing that the current claims could not

have been presented previously because the factual or legal basis for the claims was

unavailable; or that, by a preponderance of the evidence, no rational juror could have

found the applicant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. TEX. CODE CRIM. PROC. art.

11.07 § 4(a) (West 2013).

      THE CLERI< is ORDERED to prepare a transcript of all papers filed in cause

number 1030025-D and transmit same to the Court of Criminal Appeals as provided by
       ·-··

TEX. CODE CRIM. PROC. art. 11.07 (West 2013). The transcript shall include certified

copies of the following documents:

      1.      The application for writ of habeas corpus (with all attachments);

      2.      The State's Original Answer,

      3:      The Court's order;

      4.      The indictment, judgment and sentence, and docket sheets in cause
              number 1030025 (unless they have been sent to the Texas Court of
              Criminal Appeals pursuant to a post-conviction writ of habeas
              corpus order);

      5.      The Court's Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law; and

      6.      The State's and Applicant's Proposed Findings of Fact and
              Conclusions of Law (if any).

      THE CLERI< is further ORDERED to send a copy of this order to the

applicant, Nkruman Lumumba Valier, TDCJ #1546714- Dalhart Unit, 11950 FM 998,

Dalhart, Texas 79022; and to counsel for the State, Linda Garcia, 1201 Franklin, Suite

600, Houston, Texas 77002.

 By the following signature, the Court adopts the State's Proposed Findings of
          Fact, Conclusions ofLaw and Order in cause no. 1030025-D.

      SIGNED this     gB:;;;f~+---+-=U:..,__·~-------:
                           ~J<~.c?.

                                             2
                                                                                                             Cause No. 1030025-D

EX PARTE                                                                                                             §       IN THE 184TH DISTRICT COURT

                                                                                                                     §     OF
NKRUMAN LUMUMBA VALlER,
 Applicant              §                                                                                                HARRIS COUNTY, TEXAS

                                                                                 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

          The undersigned counsel certifies that I have served a copy of the State's

Proposed Findings                               of Fact,                    Conclusions                         of Law and Order,   in cause number 1030025-D, to

the applicant on June 16,2015, as follows:

                                                              Nkruman Lumumba Valier
                                                              TDCJ #1546714- Dalhart Unit
                                                              11950 FM 998
                                                              Dalhart, Texas 79022

                                            FILED
                                             Chris Daniel
                                                       District Clerk

                                                        JUN \7 2015                                                       ·Linda Garcia
                       T\me:_                                 Harrl&        county, Texas                                  Assistant District Attorney
                            BY-                                             Deputy                                         Harris County, Texas
                                                                                                                           1201 Franklin, Suite 600
                                                                                                                           Houston, Texas 77002
                                                                                                                           (713) 755-6657
                                                                                                                           (713) 755-5240 (fax)
      I    .
                                                                                                                           Texas Bar ID #00787163
                                                                                                                           garcia_linda@dao.hctx.net
               ''"11 ,·: .
                   .·: . ,
                     ... ,.          '.
                .   "\.~.       \ ' .. J   '1                  l   ~i. ·,    ;   J   •   J • •         \..
                      \_    ~   •I   •          ..   .,1 l,                      t          l)   i..
                                                                                                                                                                                  ..,.

                                                                                                                                                                      Qc~\o~o~
                                                                                                                                                                          1/~o·

 I/
                                                           co:uRroF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF 'rf;XA:s
                                                       APPLICATION FQ.R AWRIT O'F QAilE.-AS·CQRPU$
                                                     SEEKING RELIEF FROM FlNALFELONYCONVlCTJON
                                                    UNDER CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDCRE~ AR,TICLE :1·:1.07
                                                                                                                   INSTRUCTIONS:

                                1.    You must:use· the complete:form, which. begins on the following pag¢, to file an
                                      appliCation :tor a writ of habeas corpus seeking relief from': a finalfeJQri)'conyjctioll
                                      under Article)l~Q!'t of the C~de·of.Cflminal ~rpced.ur~. (:This·form·is •wt·for: d~atb..:
                                      penalty ca~es, probated sentenceswhichihave.·not been revoked,,or misdemeal1ots.)

                                2.     The di~tr:ict'clerk of the C()UI}ty in which you w¢re c()nvi~~ed. wilf~ake !hi~ form.
                                       available to you, on req~est,. without charge.

                                3.     Yotl must file: the entire yvri~ apptf~atlon fortilig.the groull~ shall
                                      bemo longer: than. the tWo pages .provided for tb~ claiJ11Jn'th~ forrm                  '

                                7.;    Legal ~~tatlons and arguments may be mafl¢ill a sep·arate.meooor:anduih tluit
                                       COiflplies with Texas Rule of Appellate 'Procedure 73 a.nd does not ~~.;e~d lS,~O.~
                                       words if computer-generated or pages ifnot.                         ·    :;       so
                                8.      'You must verify the: application by·signi9g either the Oath Before Notary Public or
                                         the.lnmate's DeClaration, whiCh are at the end.ofthis.formon;.pag~s 11 and12. You·
                                        ·may be·pro~ec.uted a net c.onvicted f()r aggtavat~d perjury ifjrou make any false
                                      : statement ofa . material facf.in. this·application~     ··                       ·
                                                                                                                                                                                         :\

                                9~     When the application is fully completect; mail.the original to. tlle:district Clerk ofthe
                                       county ofconviction. Keep copy· of the appl~cation f()r your
                                                                                                 '
                                                                                                            a
                                                                                                         recor.as~
                                                                                                              .

                                10.    You··must J!Otify the distriCt clerk oftJie c()1n1ty of.con:victi()n of.ariychart'gein
                                       address after you have filed your ·application.                           _>·      '

                                                                                                .. :.:.

                   ~.    ·.                   .•,
                                          ··.: ..
                                                                                                                                •
                                                                                                                                     ...
                                                                                                                                    ·.f" . • ::~~ ~    •

                                                                                                                                                                                         Rev. Ol/14/14:
---~.._.,......   __   .._...
                                                          .....!·,   .:;:   I   _.··   "-1,   ~ :~ •il.~-   . _ . .,_.

                                                                                                                          -.,..:.                     ..   r-
                                                                                                                                                                ..·
                                   Case N~\:.~~\\~~
        (B) What was the case number?"

        (C) Were YO.!! r~pre~ented by c~.UJJ~~l'on a~Re~l'.Ofye~, provicf~the attorney's
            name:

                    ~W>~~\s;:e]\q~\[os~ ~ \\~~~~(\.                                                                       .w

        (D) Whatwasthe·decision and the;($ate ofthe ~~(!i~i~nl?              ,_,.,..~~~.J,.J.&.;.l._·.. ---------..,---..,.-----"-
(13).   Did you tile a petition for di~cretfon.tacy~w In the Co11rt Qf-Cri~inal Appeals?:

        0     Y~~     .                          ~U)                                      '

        UY,o.ii did. file a petition fot disctetiollaiyreview, answer the following questions:

        (A) What. wa.s th~ ca-,~·nurnber?

(14)    .haye ym,a preyiouslyflled an applica.tion.for a writofhabeas>corpus under Article
        U~07 ofthe Texas Code-of Crimina.I PrQ¢edure chaQ_ertgi;aig [hi~ C.Q!J_vic;tU1nJ
        ~es.                                     tJ'   no             .. .                '

        lfyou answered     yes, ·answerthe following questions:

                                                                                                       Rev. Ol/14/14.
       (B)   What was' the decision and:the. date of.the;decision?        bt\).R t\ hl- :19 -l S "

       (~) Please id_¢ptify th~ re~s~n that th~.c.urrent ¢l,"jms:were I)otpres.e•lt~~ ~ntd' co11J~
             ·not ha:V:e been.preserited on your previous "pplication~

               ~~'S.),=o·1,IL~c\')$~~ 4X(' u\p~~snp\ttlcl L~rtvcl:~n LMCl>ktto<\

               ~'t ll~ .\\os~~ 1':>j \ \t~.&:)$7.8?:?~.C \-.. \\9l{D,I Dk,.:Ed ,;M,[lqQ).

               \\\% \oo~clJD? D~ \~ U~t~ ~:l4J.a
(1$)   Do you.:c11rrentty-h~ve: a·gy jietition. or:apP,eal :p_ending in ,any other state on federal
       court?

       If you· answered yes, please•,provide the: n~p~e ofth~· ~o.u.rt ~ll~b~'>Th>.\u;t.""k~%~1w:.k.h-vlt;\:IM~~tr.()\9~~"k]}w }\~
    ~tt.~~~~~~~~~~\..rut~ \\C'\c\ ~~'cUr\. \Jlblcl:e-f\ \'ruL ~W\('J'Ao-\:'s
    ~~~~b, \.'ru..\\~~~~ ~.r:>t~L:h¢DQ o                                       .

    F'ACtl'SSliPPORTING GROUND ONE: \WL ~~~\ ~ ~~ ~~-h:l
    3£k.~~~s:.~~~n8"Nt..o.r\.~-\Jl~ ~C~) ~c:&k.\~Mililc«cu~~bvik.Jnx.u~~
    ~~ -~ \ ~ ~u.~k2..-~~~D~ \ Lf\ ~~~M.~ 1 OS\_('\ 'no. ue.. ~tt':il.trun'' ~
                                             1

    ~n~~\$ll>t~~ .\\~\~;;\9~~£>~ it:lliS\\1\~ paS~ oo.\t>~DdS ~~s\\~· !>{\~ucy,l\,ltoo7,
     \\~D..~~D"t~~3.~M\t~\hi;\~~O..~~Q~~\_\.Dn~ll,d£lDln
    ~~~.l-WieA~~4\W~Sn\\n.ml£l~St'~RJ,1 UQnCo~ ~. \) .J'AA_~\@.\"r:Jru;\. ~d)sr\p?R-~M.\l'51)bl5"
    "d_~, ~ '<.!UU'~\:.\n_~c~ ~~ ~ ¥'\.~~~1.')~ ~~~II ,:;LDc,lo_, '3.t:. l.t                  L.)CQ   f\bt
    ~\:·w\t;qo~ t\~W,~<:o r\ \\'\ .\N._~\N~~ ~s.~.b.) tq=lk_ fu~Iru::k~S\ ~n.~ •-
    \:.\s..~~\..n~~.\\S'D\o~,\~\\~~~~tbN:l~~D{'\~\\~~~rtiL

    \.\m~c\.wl.nAAiwM>\M\t)S\S>Tt.'N..~~c.rtb.\.LM-\et!~CC>C§1l.-h#oo ~~~tS
    ~\..~\:.~~~~D'f~tm.\t)~;bt:>J.S.l~~.\So\.liL~\\~8/~ Ln -i:rt'cl~ltD.ItsefoZ)).
    ~~~ ~~\:.~~~~ ~\n \:~ \~~"·~"~~ilur\._~~\:6..tr-vl~or
    ',~~ ~,\\~ \a'dS~ ~ dld ~ \.s~c..~ Dt"dor lu.fu.\ ~ llotd.oo;S'-fhntr\r.l.l\ tho. A~l$
·    ~\\~~$c\*.~~~c~~\\~-b md&¥r~so ()nrlt:Wgrhl~~hl;,rt\\I!I!Lt.~
     ~£:'0:.\:t\xo..~          ;;:;;;:J;~~t.b~ f'l\l.Sb)ruL.~.d b.t.\e"~~At.rfHr~Le.hhin~_\
                                  'c                  1\   \                .-~        1"\   M.bi::kr-
                                  N:.   ~w       ~ ~c.S. ~ t\Wtr l.chrd:L~ ~ 1"\!L Cl.n.d l.l~ t.M-

    ~\tl.~?{ru~~~~~~~"\*.~ ~ct:.~~~.u\~mw-~La.MmM·
    ~~u-~~~\nr~\.\~~t'\AI\~1 ~\l~\.l-\,~~r.ct-sl.;t4).\~~~"usru:iec.~~5o

    ~~tl~\)~ \.t~.~~~Sbt>,J:rlcA ~ U\t;ttn.<:& -~~ -\:b~~'i~~~JMB;.t.hd:
    \.~ \\~ ~c.s,o._\1\,b~ ~lr.\ ~. ~) '1~ AWltru\i ~~ ~ ~\:.\U.~b. DLUrutd
     C>%W~'a~r\nod~M~ t>~~u')o \)1).\\SDblS o~&oshlsJ.l~\U}Cr)n~w~· _
     ~~~~\.~lli~D'\=t~~~eJ"(\~-\:.k~~~·cttt-bs.ur-ten.d~ob.,~o.,
    ~~ 1Qru>Jiwckb!SD)~u.bu~sdSgoEdubi-t' 1tl 11 ~\cuJ~~dAbG-hllA-He.Sasa.te.3!.&
     \)~ \:~~~~~·\t_~(\~,~~~~l.Y\~fi..D.Ib3b~'\.~n.dtk.A~LGJU-wJ1

    ~~:\b~ fu.ttJ~tb~W.t\tg:~~lluiUutdw=@oa. of~ WGf~ bti.~t.n
 ~l}\c~e1±.no.~\)e.t!\M&Oi ()nA "l'>'WS\ ~r t.~L:ili~ ~l.n ~~ ll5D<&02S.. . . .
 ·\'M...~~t\r.«'\ ~~t)n.-\:.\uu:i.d.}.~:~o~hl~cMD~~~w~-~n~+ultr;ruJ
 ~w~oss\>~ ~\ .\\ot\~~Yww~vl-cpuso \\t).\~St?~g&s:M.d..t.AA-
 ·fLi-~ ~~D..1\c\ ~ hl t~~m\ \rlo\-\n ~L~'N&. ~~v.)D~ 1\l)t                                     h.a.u'e..
 ~C>.~Qtx tW ~~Q.nci L1\~\s\u\ 05\~~\:b t-dd.).~\\l:ltlo£-t'no..~(\~\.-~nn~l
 .ttrm'~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ t'Nt. (:\~~ ir en± wol)w.A f\.l')t 'nAtre.. ~- ~11:~
·. _<>.t\~~~Al'n~~-X.~~ragtl~~~rrriftwou\dkle\oonc\J.rw~·Ji:.~t.~~U)L~.
 ~~~-\:.~~w,~..cre.~~c&-...\\)Jc~""()rr.,,SQ_,D~\lS\~t'\~"~"t>~~Rcl:Lv-e..
 ~~'=*~t>"i~'>A~~ \)~~'1~>.~~t."rul.\..~,~o1\w~'=v>\cl-LYt.;;~
 \A.~ \:o tutt,~ t~ ~~ Vl\:l.c:~ D~ ~\\,~t>S .l'n_o_ ~~ m\A~~WeJ
 ~l>'u~\~~\~Y$>t~5\~()~DW·~~3r-\dt\w~S)h\~:¥-.
 "fun.~";l.D'C'~~~·~~~~~tt.-~\~~Ll\Xc,~o'l'\ ..l)ThL~~""~hl\.oAm

 lt'M.\w~~~~\\u.tl~CJJswkM\3>'t'nn.~~~a"-5eiliof:
 '\:.~~~~~\.~~Lnxb\~L~\:'wuwCA\.u.s.o.d_~DSre..ll~k_~~~l'etrl:u.\Lth•
 ~\~t.wJ\-;.Uv4~r\-tt,~~rl-\t:.~ror.cl-~~~b~()t"'kkricl\~ts_t-£ieMsOftho.\.oM~I)j~
 \:.~\~ \.'f\~\M.Cd:lM\ -t\ro: tn~ue..~ t'M..~to.J\L.~ ~~ -t~~~\r~l- o..c..c.u.s.~~
 ~\u:,.,.,~~~~-'t~~,~~~t»4~~~'i):lhto"")<\
 ~-~\.~e..~~~~ ~~~ ~":!&..(.~,~Df\~\Jt~-\x) c,syt~ 1"\Q.. ~l\\l~U\4-k..
 ~ t~\tztw\n.t\~?gute_.~\.~'") t\\>..\\.~hc.rttl ~~k\'"\S.I\@wlJ J\\\.c.n \.Oc..t:ft.(\ aM \'twll\ Cc~
\~Y\~t.tlW\.~ w:,..\nA ~ ~ D~~-\:k. ~\ L~t-(•\cl-h">Y\ ~~'rut.~ L-\ L.)oS_ 1\.b'C t~
 \,~t!Nb\4>(\.o.M. ~Aduk y..f>lj)r\J» l>.ne.~~\:t\\on~\ 1 ~o;;r ~DFF1w~~E.RPhu-t~. ~a\lti.UJ.
 t.~ ~..:\:D th~\\utl..-tt:. ~ D 'iO..t.l..de.. -\..k ~~~\ten± Dl\ -t.W WSCLLn.fon"ld-iM .l).Th1L~ tr.J..lul b:>
 D~m ~~~~\cio.tre 'o'nos\nst.'tx®.u1-k~""AAM\ wi*htb.R f&~.Mu:..oi}JwLI Apr~l Pff5. ~) ~lDr~
 ~L~\:.~~~tk~l.U\Sl!l-tt>\rit.~\\~~~\\~\)iMorrdl~~~t'W\
 .CA~~n~~•-»>NH'~~~S\o>-'uw>~ictk~-~\k~iiJ\~~1r>~ctJ\.pdqquddw~M\~~
 VlDu\A   ~~~~(\ o" e.c.u.':I.Q..t\O,\\St>la2.S' ~ ~ b\:dl~IA)lt~-'c.h~.\t)):-rm..~~veroi ~llinu..
 1.\!lS.N>\wM Mlli.~u*\~¥i&ll4 ~~ .~~?eJWcll\ills~du~b 011 ~Of tivl.\Rcitt.nr1Il·H-t3-3dS7
 o~~~~~~~~bt-.~,~~\1t~hl~'"k~n~\MES1c.b\1~
"1~~ s,')~+~ iL\tJ.~ \:1\C'Cl.PO •l\'>.\\51>~. \\)1\u.c.ounlRh. 0-tl\.t>C\~\ .Wtt ip!ulh'o ne,l
~~~'-~ \D ~ud: ~ ~~'\D~ IV\L'da-W L\h\t-M.l'AIM\{t.'bn r\ }st\tYliJ.d th-tb_Q,~t \$-. iQ"
 ~.~'MA'NL~~i.\~~~.\\r.uri.s.~~\ci'M\n~~lil~tk~cbtP~.
 c\.hll~~~~':A:~t'ill\ill~~ ~~~~~~.\\\\.~' u~rt\.\.'ttlr(.)hrutu~~c\.td-tt, 1 La..t+nu ~
~~~~61&~~~-\r,·~.....He.rl.i~~:S..              7                °                       ~              ·

                                                                                    Rev. 01/14/14
                "''   . ,..,   ~.   "

    ,   ·. l'

8

                      Rev. 01/14114
                                               Rev. OI/14114
---,.~....;,;,.,.......:..--~   ········---·
GROUND THREE:

FACTS Sl.JPPO.RTING
  -·'   • .....  ,,.
                  •'
                     GROtJ'Nfi
                      .,. ...
                       /      ..
                           ··•·.·THREE:·-
                                    .   .   . '   .-   ..

                                                            Jd

                                                                 Rev: o'tli41l4
lJ

     Rev. Ol/14/14
GROUND FOUR::

                12

                     Rev. OlllMl4:
                    13

-----------··--~·
14

     Rev. Olh4/14
..

     15.

           Rev; 01/14/14
    \\'llEJUiF()RE~ APPL.ICANT P~YS tlt\t TUE COURT GRANT APPLICANT:
        RELIEF TO WHICH I:IE 1\1AY BE ENJltL.P:DJN ']"H(S~PRQ~~I:tilNG!

                                             VERIFICATION

              This application must be v~rified orit will be di?rnisse.d f()r n()n:-tQII1plil.'tnce, For
:verification pUI])bs¢'s, . an •appiicailt is a,persoh filiriRthe.application on his ot ~er own behalf. A
petitioner is a persqn filing ~he. appti_c_a.~h:>n:onhe)la:lf ofaJ1isreptesented
by a: h9C~lsed.. ~ttomey,,the attorney may sign the ''Oath Before a.Nbtary·Public'' as p~tifjgl)_er and
ihen.complete "Petiti(rper'~~·rnfotm,ati()n/'' A Qon-iiHJlatq a,pplicant mustsign.the "Oath Before . a
Nptacy Public"'before a notary: public unless he is repr:~~~nted.by a,li_c.en.§e4 ~ttQrn.ey, in whiCh
c~st; ih.~ fittom¢yrnay sUtn the verification as .petiti'oner,                             ·

              A:noh.;.inmatc non-attorney pctitiof}(!r tl11JS.t ~ign the' ''Q(lth a.~fore. a:N.otacy Pubiicr;
p~fore !l·notary_puolfc.aiid must also:complete !~Petitioner;s Informatio_J), ·~ .An' inmat~·petjtjQ!J.~t;
'.must: sign eitherth<;: ''Gath 'B.~fow~'a .N9tary })ubH~·; befm:e a:n6Jacy public' at the ''Irimate:'s·
 'b¢clarati6n" ·wlthouta notary·public. and•ro.ust:~lso ¢9tl1rii~ty:the .apptijpriilte. ''I'etidoner's
 Infon:nation;"'                                                ·           · ,          ·

              OATH BEFORE ANOT.ARY P'OBLIG

              STATE OF      TEXA$
              COUNTY OF        ~------

              ----,--c:c--:---:--------:-"---:,..,.-:-------''   being duly sw. o o • ~~ ~ h.\·-s •

                    '·
                                f

                         ~- \-~,~ ~    ••         '   0   0   0       ~'~~ ~-1 .
                         ~. "l:'f\9. .\J:)m\N.).i%\'-\iSt-ON\~~-t:tDr 1~ A.~~n_\et.\ to~.J_n~Q_\ lirJJ.i'ai\~ T~Fir~
                              \\~~l~~fl\~~t·~ ~~~ ~)_\.r~~-f\\.~t~ ~>~r'l..D.1ha:Fost-~nvlt:tiM\
                                    ~'~~~6.>..~~- ~~~'\- ~        0                              0                      ..

                          ~ '~-~~ ~o' ~\l~.r-,                                o •••    ~ \t>.
                          ~~~~~ ~o.s~~\,~<\ ~                                         '!   '!9   ~-~~It:
                              ~s~\.~~l,~~ .\J~ ~\}L.~. ~~.                                       o    ~\\ •
                              \\~~·~d.~\.\;. c~\.\c.s1~Ji)
                              t_\l'IA.!U"\~ hi\.,~\"~' ( (';.\.~\'\,h\n~l\w~~DI'\; b~~,,~\~Ab,,SP.d),

                                                                                                 .,
                                                                                                 • \•
 ~~.():t\~\!.t\~'-"ji~J\1£.~T~ \J.~~~S.Ii)~.EA ad ;.us!8~ S.\.t.\\~~(\~to~). ~~- 4 anA\{).
 ~~~£~~ t~}a·A'- ~\\~ ~.\0. ~<\ 591 (J~)(.~;r~~.\\~~*cl.D\~) ~ ~~ca~.Jp ~                    ·
 ·~,¥:i·\£,..\~ut. ~ ''-\\.~\10~.~-~\~~ ~·\t)• ~"\ liSOl. ( ·1-o.~ ot1~if.;1.1l~. d01D)~ ~~s-o
  Y:wz~~~!fei~-~-\Y~l.\ ~-W.dA.f~~1!·~s~(1QX.trlM.,A~.\1~1) ~~-~Lt.                    tl

  1;.'!\~~~-~~\T~~"'l ~~~ ~·W·~Q 51~ (~.tr~. ~~~.:li)\~). ~0·~~~· •

 ~~,\-1::\"'la};; '-\2.'l \)·';,."iDJ, "/Jl(!'m,) li)S;i$), ~,!!.dO • .
    .               UL£?·*OEISW

  ~\.$~·~~~~L\~ G.~~~·\Y' ~\ t?l~.~ t~l,l)(to~ .(J-i.p·l.A~.l9t?~) ~ p.~~-- [o',
· · ~~.t~~nr-Aj.:.\l.~~1~\.hi!,'-\~~u.~~· ~P~~-~1· It'{\ ~.tt,.~)~~~·\a!)tp,s~ ~~o.t--·Ed . acl ~ 7'-1 ·i t)7lf
  l \(''\ ~·.~') "~;-. ~ .               .                                                    .·     .           ..

  \ ~"'. tlS~~~ ~~~:~~~.\)C.,.·: ~~-. \\ ,()l ~ r);) (~_) l~~\~\~~-~ wi~. ~\). 'f'~~~~                       f

  \~~;• \j)~~ t~"l\'-\~~~~""'J:{~~. ~rt_.\\.lY1 ~~\~. •.~\'.\\ •~tt. '2>~.d ~ (c~ . ~t,~\'..., l"p •
    \ ~ \~:s.·c._-~ ~ dl\d...~~~ ,{) ..

                                             •••
                                             \\\
                                                                        .   ·•   .   . ":··; :.. ·., :·.   '·   .....

  .        /
 :/
.....
  ~.

               ..,.tQJt:U!!P.JWJt::;=:;a; Q   n.

       '
                                              ; . > ._;..   ·'··- .·'
       l,

r-··
  .• ~.~~._:----·!'-"
.. ·. ,,
                                                               •.'   ,,,·   ...-

                                                                         \\I
                ..
                      ~£}Jj,X~ '~' ~~\) Lt.\J.) ·=•
                     "' 1 ~e.:;::z   ... ;«.   tA.   Kzt>)Aq         u;:;z so:z:p:::;w;;;;a;;c;:u   cp;;;e; :z.   ·
           , \\l~ '\\·L(~1\.Ad,~-~. ~~~t!.:.l)\\stj\~~ ~r.M'~t r:~~~~ ~~ ~~ ~r~
  ~\~~. \\\\~1)\J~~\J\)S ~J~\JS\~ \:~~ '-~\1\'~ry~.l;.~ fw._i:~ ~l~) ~~
. ~~ ~'\J...\~~_\\_c\ Dn~~~\h~ \\W)h.Q..f\t;~~~~ w~~-~\\xtO~~~P~~-G.M~
                                                  .                            \)~\J,~ti)\\~\.~~~\,1)~~WJ~t.~~i~
                                                                              \J~ ~"'-D~~~.~ )~~~ Co"A.n~}s. f4.,11A1e- --c)~                                    Rf'\
                                                                              ~'-~~ ~~-\;x~ -s..~~~ll,\-V>I'\ ~.ll;\.n£!1-n
                                                                              \\ ~ ~ ~~ ~--~~ ~~-;t. n_. CM~tt>ch;A~
                                                                               '~~~l..n~~.o~ ().M ~~~~~ ~·~lt.&~ lnR..A~\Ae@\t'~
                                                                                                                                           1.. : .
                                                                                                                                                 __·

                                                                              \).~\"' \\~~~_1\:r Dr 1hR.. \ltl!-if.d ~J~,~ ~:Onst:+~~t {9 ,, ,

_                     _            \\\,A,,~-\-~ ~s\~ ~~}}\~~v~~-l).,~"~~ Gti}~ /Jfl.Jl~
.. ._,.....-~~---         :se.a~q'"'cwc;a;::w   !lCOSikC@;...'"#.W*..o&:ta::u:is..e..u   ::rmca::a:;:mc:;:;a::   ZU.iibb'CH!S:...,.'-~:a:wlif;W!L:i~~-:o;::a,.._ml:l,::a=i:i:=i=
     '··\
'.
..'I· . .   ...   ~"""' ~   .....   ·'   -· ......   ·..:
       .   ·; ', ~· ''.
            .             \   ..-·   '   .,   ..   )   '

,··.

                                                           r:f '.
                                                               --·~
     (               ...: .
     ,.                                                         : ~ ·-,_ ·.   ,•   ~ .,._   .             '   .
     ~(~'-'"         .                        . ,.
     ··~

 .    ~~                                                                                                                                                         ..•·
      'f'
..    ~~ ...
      ?
       ·'
      ~<

           &

                                                            ~\~·~\)'.·~~~
            /'·

            ~.. ·.                    . \..~\-\t.:~~'r~\\~ ~~~='\~~i~~.~\\~\c~R~«.\~.t~\\W_\~~ir~~ .
            1                      ~ ~ ~\;'- Vo~ \\,~: \&~ ~?\'\.,~-\,~\,t>~l-)lri'u:>" ~:,~&;;~ ~ An.d
                                   ~~\\6.~.1..\;\()t>}lo\,~\~ ~;;,c~')ul"-\;; ~ • !>X, liT>~, ~n,d (.'t',v,{alik. ·
               ..                                                                                                                                                 \     ...

                                   -~~.)).\WDI)·.~~~IIC                                         . ~~~~twL ••
                                                                                                                                                                           •,
               I'
               'l:

                                          ·          ·. ·                                       '1fln..
                                                                                                 '  .,
                                                                                                     ~-
                                                                                                        'fl1lruJ.rrtb'hd1Jmuft1&/%a.Ph
                                                                                                           .    . ~   ....
                                                                                                                      .    ...
                                                                                                                          ~-~- .~.. ·: '
                                                                                                                                    •::·   ~   '   '   ~   .~·

                              '.   ·.·.
.
,~;:;~~?·~~~. ~~~·~·   ..
    ,,'·'

                                  ~\~~u.~~)\~~x~~\f'~-~~~s ,\~l~-~o.lSl.llo1'Y ~t.hp__
.·. '. ·~~~~~~~~~~stl~~~~;:~~~~:~
                  ~~-e.\tA,.~ ~~,(" ~ ~J\l'A\~ Cr ~~ \;.~\ t~ ~~~L~~~
                  C'!J\~ t,.c,~.                  f       •        •

                       ~ ~...'tJl,.r.._l_~t,~A \)(\ ~••   wcmm,..a•n==-·

                                                              \\
"   ,.   ....

                                                .......
                                                .

                                     .   ....
                .r .·.. . -·
                ~   ~· -~
                               :'~
. '(                                                                   ;,.·....   ..;.~
                                                         ·- ~
                                                        ~~;,c
                                                                 :::
                                                                . -     -~~·
       -. .,   .   .   ·;,.   . ,. .   :~.'   . ,   .