Court Opinion

ID: 4058790
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 09:19:34.306677+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:21.230183
License: Public Domain

§ Duu.r¥ v\" Cr`\w\`\'mc¢\ A\>pea\_£ v\t>,w(b»

 

, “\'¢'.Q\ Ow“¥ n.>:w)§ am fm m (A) l v ZL,§ ,,Oq
E~mele Cm\><{€,\ cardona § \h~“\£uq%\ duo\umr 83/|,§
'D\SW.\CY C ED m
§ l WEM’ CD€]WM‘ , AL APFEALs
§ *\\ W`U\cw m z<$l§N 29 2015

 

'm_ mg m mr;uAQizA\)\>uM m miva mTHE;ST¢)M“ A@Q§¢Q,Q¢@,k
’\l€§d>w§€ TOTHE APPUCATN)\\) rim , |' 437 wan ` 1
i\sw.>c¢;»>ms O\a\n<`.e,\ nardone `G '\`cmv\i \`)r\\$e..mv§ ci\es lhl>*u€mnra\([;umjv\ rep\\,;L~\»\\a §\c\es
m\»me )ct>M Ayp\icolim c>¥ lam J‘ Hu\>em norwood res`>eo}$ul|q show M\e Owclras RUcws;

 

\.FA(‘I\'S

_________

"T\\a S}c.)rQ £\\m\ 0 respmse ~`d“\a [\pp\(cem¥ b.)n%p na\>£(n 0 void en ~\\\e izvcj a}a\j o( Mc¢\{ ZO|S'j
‘l\\a Up\>\’d;cml' fled hisapp\mo\‘\m ~‘hmuq\\ orml\’ze¢j mail .car‘|'\:h@crmz“l )Ll'l?lO~CU)l-'Z£WL‘TZX(, ancl
dallqu duk \alng- Ml'£$b\¥\ Aaq o€ Apr'\\ -iO|`$" C‘erh "ad mail was de iu€lecl lb ~Hw, Dis\\r;d' mark
T\w §§ `\vvb\\es -\>m. \a¢\nes mk,c¥ m as a Lm~\d\\z App\\écitun;l\\lhwg\'\ H\e Sble ér|e§ mm)aw
. ;‘v\:jmpbr;§; ' `\ pb;§}: 'H:\G\ lwe §'\o!-l size v\\:~k mcf (M\{ p:c}`\(‘ubi\m\ s\'\w)i`\ng al §ré\ué`\`§§ . -“ve. \S\c¢x€ nevfl;.
‘ rl§s£ c\s\,'\ m - e`\\A`\&‘@..mi ain`, "wwe§" ca `q»r code nse lny kaié'ni.'¢\' ,~
makqu \¥\\L B\ok Qccq?(lka C.>wl k requlve_“w Qpp\imn¥%sc¢\§q 333 )¢hreo componem olim w
' h wm xm~.e.r. _ l f l '
T¥\e S¥r.§e S.u-U\e( c\m'ms jrl\a\ hac up`>\(ca!rt $ai\s \v'wwe} ling l\.l),‘\ §~\¢wclarc\s wi)r§} ccsgec¥ 5a a',cqéwa\
\>BS\S" omni -%c)/x m¥ lend \Qc\ k A£MDnSH¢-\{`§-\'KL\&\G“J p(£j\'ucl((‘€.\ `H\ml app\'¢cdn;§ hawaii i'nVQS ('€QW€
ana mt \QSSen \¢\I.§ Cn\ga\?\\ ." w f .. " .
` Tka S¥c\\e §u~\?\\u s\nles Wa-\ )dw \eo agrae;uen)r a.\jl(\udqmm\ ,>\: aonvidiam (‘\@arl\{ wind 'H\a-l 1110
S¥a\e senth maxim nw concur€u\*' wi amf 'coclm~l S€n mee.. . ‘ f
, lm\\q.~v§m S¥a\q `m\»mo\uces 'a¢\_ al`-P»Aam']r L\‘ (`a,mse.l SB§Q .'Faux}\> . anew Le`\nq,eb\q wang maj nolan
`\Z£A‘ 123 \§émg ‘\MQ_'¢ (‘13\1¢\30§ $'\r§]"u,& ~“\¢:A \/\Q -“\Q`muq\n\\{ `§¢\'\'2.¢»`|€,\>.~£¢\ m`\'\'r\e§$€d‘.}vw(;$‘|\,§a+n\ '“w max st nw 4tim
anal aclu\&di 1\\> \'.ca»\`¥ "GQCL>cc\In ]\{~`“'\a‘\ `\*Nz bigch '\nv."cl@~cem\e ups ~L|e and ill aJvif€d gweme tjch
' sgtdgci )IW\~\ o‘§x>\'“\ bc m?.qb`%a'\io/\ war ayp)\canjr;\` f€al@m| sedima

oc“‘“¢\"\s t'i£\s@_1 . mi\$€k &L‘L“e

\\_A¥ wmml

T\ne c;\\é\g .~>H»\w. Ms game k \,\ \mj\( .\n QQTM fe wi)r\g Ar\ie\e I\M ¢>Y'MTe¥al coduu\:@rrlm'umd
\xe\`:ecluces,~\\w. gale has \S 0\(_11\|$ 30 wm re vm£.?n>o o deliver denies LHBM}S £og C‘eA~.-£;orj lm}) 110 |'J
\fs'LD mm 101\¥ Ql?f»§\wér i.s-\'\r\e 50~\\\d\aq c 'Apr'\\ ~.1.0\§.'“'\0.. S\a § mspov\§e_ ¥y.dg dale mM‘HrM re
eq{re m m a\nw\ -“\a \\95<\/\ c\ou§ ac blm 1013'. _

t !_c\c§/\Q§`. 'M 5\11\2 `\s, \\s¥“m&lenh“\¢ \>cqué;m<¥ \)y %q):da’r.\‘ \`n ¥i}u`v§ \\w \\.D"\ .Dpp\le¢j¢'én md 343 hal pcé'\\ucl'
`-\uzdl` fm §§ away \\> `\\\\)&er'\n pmrcla and_\q¢ “'Baezn
( 'sg¢>kes\)¢.iss.d \\a\)e \>QB\ qlv'\ng )n> ~W\u. media \¢\La gyer ;Z)`i\/\a F€chro\\ ammuwa 'c'\\o(‘!a `Ll'm\/e] Ac-¥“`mc]i "w\w*'

d_gam&\> wo\o;££o\&m¥s\ coom\!\i\ra`nri`a mci app\£cm\‘}aw\m'cl\ "i;\ S)¢€)\ eMic§a"q cpe¢\ anal f\“w>\\:»ej -“1`\;£' cal m mr} op

\»€3

. '

\‘\'S rockwqu (.lcmenl`.?)\`\l\e' 5lul€.aml l`ulaml lf\owemw\ml l\cwe,loea¢\ L\_n>s£ ,@ngoq`mg llw`( w'rl'hmc/S l coclc»avzl¢mls

w`\\'\\ mcl.“l\w,r l»v ~\>\\:L \>u\n.lijl cl mav¥§l\e ;'-“‘l\w. l`ecleml Q»wmw“\ \\azs Sewlulgo,a sucl/\ . ' m sa a `D€ 66un .Qa\kl nw wl nu> va Y{cl¢ed .C\Ssc\'\un 3

uslw \\cn 'muo£l?galf:.s on or sound ?n\’l_scorln‘w\lq.

~\'W. S\¢¢\-€ \`s fn a wit lama\)lv, gallion wl I<. n.~.l"\>re`\w.l'\ce& mal Cn*lA \\ave, concluer cr pmper '\¢\v€.s\‘gcrl§».\.

l\w\{w\ also l~\la¢l a"Qe:QuEsr mama caselaw er ch\\js“ w\`m“\ am wnlgw@ a llmm»ql\ Qq>l.
anul'm\_\ gmc suc\\ Aalu\\ 'm ¢l\f\l\'nq -;l'\w l\p\llcnl§ov\ g §m~_l/\ e_\cgl¢:m-li¢m s\/\ml& sal§.¢l:\| -llr\m_`\m'l~."l:al)la g§cnsc#"or
"axcai§cl€l:la&,£ 1\¢.§\£“, rqu\,dS\\e .(S€e_ ll\)?li@mxls QEBUEST'GGQ but Q.~€LE!)\\L\HW `.“. inclucling §l's ul-lwl\mowl cc E'~¢l\'\\ni'la"
us Pm> r ' rla o\{§\ .
7 \lm?k_lwe. ll\wppl\em\l '_ `_sl`\'es ullmsl jlwv ¢,l` llw. ll“-Q€ G>M\)wenl-> ‘l’l\a. S\c.l€'lnvu\ces .l¥wcl\hgl\[.+l'l\€
l.m§n,$ ¥rolecl{m xl)\oulcl tape l\| coil _

¥aeluul Lu'¢; fle Vro.`\ul§`tonl o\(cl wl (caulcl love.mr\\ Mc.\a a_` pmllq4
`\\\(’ecwm£r\" qu\c\ "Co¥\((\:u>u$ Cl\e.'\t',€ n `\`»€_.-"\v\‘&el\lg€v\\w\mo\hw'q\_(mc\ uolun\'u¢q raclh\`\§$\on ocr qu}ll-. '“\2 S\£A€
m`\>es M¢lmm\“ '\\x rv\>ov\se un¢lu ll\a“`inéi»iclual um“ »r“sing o e¢m“ nol%on."¥lw U..\`. S,gpremv. qu-l» lms
\\olul \l\\ul lam p scx.\uqs \\ny. mv L.EA.Uz.s¢a/zan\m (‘w¢ -Dl G,'m.'.;.a\ - \s» Mm»a\¢_.,

' cqu'\wl owl mlu\ my ~,llmr-\' concepl~&e`a¢ . €‘Ll)a(le. k)¢ll»o(m .`1_¥§ 310/id .`Hl kuan .\clq% .llp\)l`\mvrl s~lq'
lul l\i§ ?el+l\év\ `w\l<\\u:l land @u,u\$c;l Ae¢\Q`Q\l 2 alwvz“ mgle a¢l\s_"ugol cr\\pl`\(!q¢\l'omnill q. f b ecqs¢>v\clol@ -\rvc¢~_n-
C:\..\¢\o_ l\\cr\ W£(e 111th c\ f€c\§mn\>\a \>rb\nal;\l\~l\| owe mau\cl v\sl/\\M plead \ll\¢ ‘ proceeded lu'lv§ul. 5a
e.<§¢ Y@.m.'»(O v ,U .S ll§la F$ol 112 17.‘\\-\ C\"’C`mi®l$l (c;`le mloa\;€ll% "’m a wlzal¢s`lrlq su@\énevl»l\
uv¢:\mm`mo, co“l'\¢'\u\w. `\v\ o \:.z\\ol: l'\»nl< “l>\~o. [QW\%N\H L.::ulel,l\awl wheel o cch . llppl\%.cm\" wald also (€_Sp€ -
c\'§u\\\\ \l_\vimd \3\\0,"(\_0\,\<¥ ll\c\l ~ll'm. ll.§¢ &pvuwz l}a,ul l\ccs l\olcl »llml pcb 3a gillth sl\wlo\loow“(‘ms~lwll liloerc.~ll¢;",
'\'\\o. '\n`\Qres\'x sr e»w\$oc`luslhc`e Sv t€qu`wcf. §a.v, Q._q. l“\(h\'\\o_\' v»ll.@.mu .Lll)l'l U.S{Slcl 520 »31> L.~Ed.&l' l.OY’LAq?Zl
AVA‘LU¢\X is "N)la \&w\\@(¢ app\'\(\.m\`~"\r pme@ecl\`eg'\;m S~P. wl~l'l\ wl\a\'lna_\r\u.\ leam¢£l‘ ila ` “l‘l/wm& final 'll'i\£l'l€! l¢u‘l'
nmfllmle.s§ modes llm l>asl eclvr-l leland p¢e£& as vastle A ?l‘\com¥ ~l'\labl av\“ l '-l:'.¢la»&-l ¢>Y`Fc@\s l“ pump

ul" us mall w\¢\u£\n\\e. explains -\1> ll\o_ l"om~l» wl\q was l`ec€l'e§m\d w\qq lw, leacl gmllq.(;§€e"h~l`~l§clzvi-l. a(`
cu¢>l< "\¢\ Gaue,vall.l-\i§ wqu Oov\$-l~r~ue¢l lll»€ra lv 01 \u\{ w_a¢lu§\g ‘\\\a.. ?e)n'lim ar 3 old alx`>u€;. \`v\ ll\e,`l:umulflw£
e` .€§xnl\lulml -ll\u'\ aj)pl¢'tanl clicl v\ol' make an `\}\`l'€llh'g/f`nl’-.lm'bwlag.£\ncl volunth mlm`\x§’w\ o€@.j.ll.°\>r?»
';\.A;wl \\\Qmmlk mm ‘ `
_Cam__$_el;g_ll\luml;_ ,
Qoumsel §Mals cllrl~`\clo~(lv '\s wll\cl\ “ a\ Sewml respec\s. nw))\se.\sl¢lc$ l\t ll\umu§l\\\;`\dl?cd¢€wal w`\ nest
\lad \\0_ '\\Cr&o¢\r umwaqu l\>~llm 'P£lfu an¢>(~\r 'lvl\°€. appl§cml
rl{\'€e\'l\`. lb)¢_l'w w\uular ¢la.`$'lu\~\ `\\\a\' a q¢\s’ \WO/ld. L~»¢.L\' lrw.lcl au\A“crll-l'lmw:l rest/tma minimal assa`.lan'lr
s\q\ul \\m.> <\*vem¢e\ec \m\')\>cae:l&j. `@o_fmsol w;:lcl luna lmmocl~ll\al 'Da\.\`d \\Xa ha ¢§\i¢l wl m ltqu mg mr
ll\`mg a\»czul a g¢c.u\) mold nov lMu¥Hll ~llmw:` maxwell assul\aul< s\ale£l l\u» ~l'l\e Murcll)r oecurrecl.@wl il»qn$
`\o \!aln a¢~A‘V.oml\”n fn , d us\\a waco speal[m ca\=»ul -llae,_murcloi. §ee¢>ncll\{. llw.ce e’\c"u“licl a 'redsmal)\e. P’D\>Q
\d\ tl\{ :l'l\fl\ 01\\`:'£\ l\lf).¢l\lwl cll.(R"LG \:¢c\\..lc` Co\v\w\§ *PQ¢`\\M\‘ ¢\.\>ll\\.(_lr\ `\$ i».`»\€\'\' \\Q..|`_s(.lol"ng \`A F€Cl€rfll Om¢l.`“\;f£ll\/l

Zol?>

~ \
§ ' l

`/

Cu.u\.§el m:u.\c\ A\§C'.m€( *\‘wx\' \`§\ §uc,\' Dn\\` `Domic\ \Xu'()“mn.(:€'¥ p?,($m\g\

\mm\u')ge. G~.w~se\ mo\¢\\rnw.gssesse¢§ Cce§\\`>\'\'\l\~\ am~\ pew\\wnes.\»~“~o-\r \_; ic ci¢\\\ maxus \\eA an\'. l\m¢\se\ c\€¢\
' m\" `u{ku\'.&\_» w`\§mzsses us \\e C\o.`\m§ ."("\\ot`\>§\dac`\ f\r\ves.\»gc:§¢~`on£q defense \ov.\ mc,<'\\' and wu.\\o\ m\' \\c`\\\ ar§'u'&»
QA.(§QLAW\‘M¢<\$ N\Qm.->. &sz\ .Cwm.\ ¥urh\o..{ mendes \1> Q\\ e“w downsg

*T\\agca\& (‘_\m`ms M aw\~`\cun\s galesen`\'m,e.wou\o\ mm _ca;c¢.om/r\ w{L\v\ \\I\~ \`QAem\ so£\'mw,.‘“\eqme_ m>~\.
SJA,\ \x\>‘?v)'i¥i>n \»r\’\\m gale .\muppo¢¥¢\ \v\\ milw,o\$n cens¥lu\'u `\m'\mem.n¥ \;eeauso ~\’m S¥ale has a\»so,
\ule\ m M\on\'\{ bulk Y€A£m\ emma n\\\m'\. ;\r \e.¢§ci\ Mrcl\}\g -“\Q¥wm\¢` §QQ;v\ `\m\(l\ao@ u>cu\&\ua ces ~c§l\oms‘.
“Wo, 3 a ms ¥n m\\?qms\/\ ms§§clq \F 3¢\\.1 ¥co\zm\ Qlwemw¢\¥ md Qm\\ pmpos'\x~br\ u.'.\\ a\wc»\\s ¥m\ \o'mc\\)£e downwij .‘f}\z,\:»"q meal "i¥-'" \ea¢]§
ums, va\\w\ m\m\ pmw\y Le\{eve cm\o\\u\ ~\\1\¢1\‘- \\\M S\Qle \\us maw\l\u'n\\{ war Tecio¢a\ G'.\,qr"]'wc\ lee¢e°s
'r'\§.c ~\»\`»\a\ `Fec\a¢@;\\ Qwr¥ \..»`\\\ v\c\cvu\ -\’\\n, Sa¢\ dee (Yac\\ cbnm¢m\\¢\\\o re:u\`.\\\ me -\'ha, SA\.a~\~}o/\ §\'~MA opp\; ccu\~\t
w )¢»\c\ `\\¢u>\"\r\\s ;“:\me SQAKA\ $Qn`\?nce wm\& w umwn€s\_:. A‘\xp .ccm¥: soi`\`r@ees mm‘>¥ concurre~l.
4i\:\& gold Yo{v\\< ¥Cu\s . pfpp"\i!o¢\x was ml '\'v\€\ ~\\/\a-\ ~“\a M or (_\mr¥ \N)o\ m au~\\\§¢'l~`\{ wm F€A£fa\ c:us`\A C\c{m»\

QwML\ ConCQC\Q.S `\\B. y
\\\.Ad¢qga_l¢ %m\

L\)P\`Lem\\' fQ,Spe.c“u“q vuv\ino\_s ‘“\0. Q®('\“\'\N:r\ m;`GD\uq\;\rAUQQNd ;s l *~» `mpem¥.\¢€ )t> magill evaluan

`wn?_£ctt¥v{ asi\s)cey\c:g oc' Camse\ (l\c£\:m$“.§&c Ma)¢~\)vw.ne\\ m hcv§@r$m"a"l.¥$ F.$o) g'lD%. (o¢irg US. vi'Dmua_\‘. 103

Y.‘Bc§i \31.$’ \\"5’)$ (‘l*`€€r. `\O\‘K'\\.\\“¢\ u"pe:\{~\\mr gm c\‘)?\im/\~n k wm cl `\\ cm mclgv\; rml \\aar`w% . .. `.n or doc ~\Mnl~\'\q,

m`\g\\ \)€ glva s(`mzz 0\>9_¢("\.\1\§`\\ xv u§£€x Qu`\dm('@ ~\o A€\)elc>p -\\\n. ¥u£'\\m\ \b£'l{\s n(' \r\is G|a'\\v\~ '\J.a.Jr ib\-\q.

£\‘s\>\'\m¢\§c edna o '\\\o\a;}ia§\ gm Elio\adf\(\uc\| \'\@.0<'{¢\3 wl¥\'\»\ \\is uw\itzr\~im . `

\V-.._Q_Q“_C\s§\_im_

\D\\€QE`\:QQE \r\)U_E\\l\§ES (N\NDEQED€ upp\`\~f‘un<""pm\\& `“vu~\ ‘“r\o S~\Q)KS t€§pon§€ le.w_`\ee§€o\ carl puc 'Q,\r'u\@r
‘~\§ O§'c'\-CQ ca \).)Q)n\\ (}:An\q \\.Cl\€do:\'€¥£\$. '\“\ address be \\\Bvic}or{& 346-um 119 facie
name .Qec;¢;@& aug ma \x;Am\ m~.¢m:v.. .

./"

 

 

 

 

30£‘3

m ' f v _ \ NO_. 1

BJECT: State briefly the problem on which you desire assistance - \.- =\ §

/ 111§0`\,11("11_1&? 173 i’l/)CA~ 3a ll€GCi_/ i’)CZ(L./Ci€i€ 7[’51[1'.7£///51 n

 

A

60 r1 1111 '111'1111`/ 111 11111/1 verach 16111193/11/ wulf/1 1111,1 `1’)/111/117

 

 

 

 

 

 

1-1//)_/1’01§€/ DQ~»[€r/MM€ 7£51€

 

 

131)11111"(111£1 '1_1`1`111110 1111 in

 

 

'1 § 1
drums 131 v

 

 

 

me:_(/]|(`-.'L rif (:gc{rc[dnci - /UqL/&?Z Unit: D

g - n \.lV k ' en / n
y v ' ' SSlg \..

 

 

 

 

 

lsPosmoN:(1nma1ew111notwme1n1hisspace) v n v \\NUS)Q 91171` l@l%(lec;§\
1 w \@/ iii/1910 1> 51 ii”‘”

11
U

.,_.._F\

 

 

zl-60 (Rev. 11-90)

 

 

 

 
  
 
  

co/wPLETE_HTH/s' sie¢jioN` oNl DEL/\‘/E:nv" -`_f§-;

 
   
 
 
 
 
 
  
    

 

l Comp|ete items 1, 2, and 3. Also complete -

‘ item 4 if Restricted De|ivery' is desired. E| Ag€n'f

_i l Print your name and address on the reverse _ _ 4 l'_'l Addressee
so that we can return the card to you. . 5 R d b t . -

l Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, ecewe y (Pm ed Name) C` pate °'f Del|VeW

or on the front if space permits. ` ` '

 

 
   

Post§ge" ,,1" l

 

Cenified Fee

 

El
_ § 1 male Addressed t°_ , D. ls delivery address different from item 17 Yes

_ lf YES, enter delivery address below: l:| No
E`e+\y\or ’Degs\ \c:do C\@(k ' v . - 1 -

mo \1111@1.11 s1 (11<,-1@
LC\’(Qd,D \vx. {lYO L' 2_ 3. ;yléeType

Cert_ified Mail° E| Priority Mail Express"‘
l:l Registered El Retum Heceipt for Merchandise
l:l lnsured Mail l:l Co|lect on Delivery

4. Restn'cted De|ivery? (Extra Fee) EI Yes

Retum Recei Fe ‘
(Endorsement Reqpl}rred(;

Restn'cted Deiive Fee
(Endorsement Requ¥lréq)

 

 

 

 

 

2. Artic|e Number

7 (Transferfmmservice/abeo ' ?|]]|3 ['_'|[=[l[] nunn 5]151:1 lE_lL}E?
§ P§ Forrn 3811,Ju|y2013

 

1 RECE|VED lN -
:couR_roF cRmmALAPPgALs
'.lUN 29 2015

AbelAcosta,Giark