Court Opinion

ID: 4039925
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:21:35.44831+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:08.524387
License: Public Domain

§>/,Q§~@/Q

§§

 

 

 

 

 

oFcn\M\N§~L APPEM jaw /A/ l
1 v 6
M law ;0/7/35005 ;‘;]’Z:;_i
60 F b
AEe\Ac f fn 5
93 a,£l*_ B¢Z@_M 7:):¢ M;U;/%/G
115 705

 

 

 

 

v)_a/Q_u "
a/;/¢/ "7,, 3~0 /§

 

)F &' ’ '
/4 ¢ ~//'7//7@/_
`W:‘:;o/&épél/'/L C/C’f/:;ffm/j
,,,,,,, 0 ._C;/_/o-$` l
gea@'-H cA,). 43 w/o 551
1 1242 1 11~/ (A)

 

_/._):Q//_ _£_/€/_/¢°
v » k 0¢¢//_ acl
j/./_%707%0/7“ /z pA/_`O_;i/:/;:§C 566 Md “
//`/ `//%{ MH% /):;' 0511_';/71/<)/)
z /@ 1111
1',¢ //7£/1€§

 

 

 

 

 

fé/:zc 105 M/~eg,

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

lou/71 Lj{` L/»m/na_/ /qp)oea/_§ [jF `7"5)(01_<
0)11/+ /u@ 1010 591@31@1-/-04)
wrl+ /Uo a_)/o- 6?0@?3 HCA)

é)( )%f%€_ 1111 ih€ £/`/mma/
5 5 p/` ' igf+/‘)`/' CDM/ 111
L?) //7__
M//Zi/D;;/Za n`/~ (

ija //14_<; (oz,m-i'\/ l )exaj

A /O///a/`)71_)\"L)éjé`£71mn d761 JL/C/¢Z /'zoéze_fi' /_gL.l/`/`)$)
/:l/L:)a///)é_$ L)Fj Fac_% A/t/D g:ac/Lz_/)

/)70)1/'0/) I/‘) 777£ [//7/7165/ 571€¢`)1€_5
gic/1 £§/sz//Z §§ D/;zoé£’_r+ /3¢.1//)3 F;`nc///) adp H/FQL‘/`
Z/,O 50 C’_ 73/©5£/

/1;0 w ial/1 ami C/jcrom
c)r) / ¢Qz;a')»-,£:g/~
C>f! 14,0,0//¢0111%

3110/cp _SQ.QVE¢/
a f L_/:n:_l/~C¢;_ /£?r) A`/:)/ ma;/KB+ 0_571//£$ f/(:<;/) L,lr?l`/“
l ,(,4 ._¢‘ f[;` <_SE 71’€`) '//7¢;’_ f‘/ + £/GI‘K
an Ae l gr/( F %Q/, ‘
daly/0 Dbjecjil.on 0 1_11~/~ L)F £r/m/r)a/ 13ng

1011 '_3 b /e(/ PQH /_$ 0~¢ 72de
/ 6
L:>u/‘+ goal/bg 0{0 ,L.`ML+ An[/ /ngn£?? /LJ_S /~JL/r_c,e. 1111¢¢'/'
l"l¢`<=>r/`e¢+ 11 P//Z¢m+ ha_<.'Om/L£ pm cf in /,,,`~/15 77?£ [°'*”`+ '“S

15 man 71'0L/ hila/ _€.€L!ES :/)L/u¢/l/Aj
~)D£& GMO/ .SC./w`/JZD 111 é/"HX, 5 y+:./»)o 1a moa /)'mj.o» ca regé.on
cm //.;zuj/ :F:r/ //m;[i wiman/wang VLB»)

c)/ fe e dcfs

///`e/ [0¢/’/)£€/ 5~/~0+@_ AHz)r/)e'/
Ap/.)//ca/l?‘ Lz_)as /r) a jfk/bush fagg 1:..++1
111th

on a [)F L [/) é£.€_ [.d €_°Z A/j 5711,>€)1£_$ 909
71;“/:1)£ §n;;;; c//XS/OZ_S//m /4¢)::“)/@(?5:(1)/)@.€) 61

par-201 i_<. p§ycho~i'/c_
hF_/`

_ hLo/‘r€_c_+\ £.'/a/ua+e_.< +Ae aaa/nd a 1_< g,

£a?cr;ah €-/`011\ and -F aug/1715 amf make§ /'_h{orwerf therencne§

aba Eyf'€_rna/ f€cz /1‘1 EVCn

c_w¢~:mce. 7'/»¢ +

/'/') '/'/12 Faz_c_ 011 LQA-H~ar~ r~/
arm ps/>/L,h©)¢/c,_:] clara /')Q+ apply +o /hi___r\____
6//5710¢')1/0)’1.<. of fi€_¢i//?1 7""/70111 //)t/o/i/e_ mm*/+er§. 016 /`€./6;‘/'1\/£
JU‘/§i/”MMH 77762 712-fm 11059/£/10711;_] 1"$5071;7€/1)@_ ap H~.']r¢)/_;i_h)/~m;+é
wiman /3@1_<@.'1»$ behavior 15 so amiss/le isom 1111@.1
€L /".Q¢:..$Qné/Q. 1`/)-{'£'./'/)6£_,£.<1,/) £,e_ de .Hw!}» fea/dry ./.C_S+/ng /_S
/Y)Afk£(//l 5//571 l`é>£ %I(j. l¥ 61 LZ')(`¢Z/)£/Lm’i` ]',»m[_)a_',/~g_[/ his
pErLE_/o 11'//0/) L.“ rawl/1 11y _SL/L.//) ~/-'7‘/)1:, F¢acé’_ mm-/-/~m~! g./(;¢/a,»,[_@ hl ,_'5
QL/e$I/naé,/€.. [A) 61//70711¢1'11111/ ,7,<“/3;¢1/£/5737 Insmf

2/ prp/3d Juz.a/ by
a 1/1'¢1/@/)’/'£)(£;/71'€/)7€/)+ of »-,L/,e gmc ns or pmss/ ns -rh a+ r£n§un;nj
'{0¢`11/71’1’1° '/ /`Fm”"/’° gri/mp pmi/a j M 1155/ems -/1/)1111 -F`
/OE//o'cl [fEa is iam/3 /Q,

, ar
c/E,rar)g¢). rha/141 @1‘ In+a//e¢_'f@

pd@é /UFE

ljirh/h/`_s/werj La.p¢;/+l/» 21 mcf/anal Ir)sam`%y bo+h are. LQ:L'~

sz.o /))'2.13 )'/) 'ZEML /, '_S 7¢;/7, 1 , ,. /.| 1 ` :
f/M M +@ .¢~~mma/‘€QY'Z;HZ,-é;@ ,;; aim ‘/;” f ;j:j£;“@j;'*y
.j?‘n_“_?i€.$ 369 SMUJ 3 13¢9. ° ._).

L?f‘? /ez/F€)rc_/ 0,01'/)2¢/ 7"'/)01% m/‘. L£)€_/'S./)E.F H,l{{`er¢¢/ {rom '/>7£/)+01/

hem/+/') /S.SL/ES 645 //'.<+Qd Aéol/Q_ and /m_§ m dcf/'r.'/+ `1’1 f ii+
ideas RRQ¢ /)1'11:04 /3>,<9\€.` / ga y

,4»211

/€€-9611`¢//'/)§ ‘/%£_ oL.//aga%10n -)L/’)a~/ -}~r~/'a/ L'oL//d_ése/ dca/ied "/'o Gb)£¢;~)£
+G Pé’f_jl-'://» Ap,o/,zan-/~ /m$ no+ _5/')@11_>1') %ha+ amy fzrjum/
dace/fre . 5 ' ' F' C/m [){` Fa(.`_+ 4lLr`/'/ foz,i/`%
/f/\_}:P ////§z;: :;§~/,Lc;/:;u::/ ;i?;:/\:_¢QU p/:ip/Ji/f')mn M§ ¢/é,, ,' CJ{~{E[_+'.M£
61 /_S /-//1/1;¢ O-F Lo¢znsz;/ when munéa/ 1911/ied 7"¢ Obj £c;+ `/'o
Fj/`M//M%él/ /JBQLW`/.¢Qmm/+*Qd by ‘/'/ve L)/_€+r/c:/ av"~#orne,}/

-7;/21/ [0¢10_<1/_/ fes/uon_:fe:'. Dafensz LDL/n_se/ /5 meja/.Q_ eric .a.a¥_
perjury zommh‘%)e é,y -f/)e c//'sv‘/Ic:/' a%%ornp_%

171 1101/nd 13 a 1001/5a 31‘0.~%121%@/17‘ éma¢@z +r}m/ ioa£§é/ capo/1553
Grc>¢m¢/ 1031/en maj /je%’en£e 1390/131:/ was pro via/ed- o-Ha»_

" /)F égfar)@df.€ 0151[£175€£ 119/ ,l'O/` “/?3 “/'/`/'@/» DE`FQ/>é€. £é.)zm_<'e/
u_)e{')~! C)z/Qf a.// %£51; 3c1 1£)<'7‘7‘61/1£01_11$ 07@(1`€/)£€;~ 03/+/1 A/J/D//Zan¢

i p/@'Of +o baby prc .$en+e¢/ _fc> ~f'/)Q 30¢%~ ije.)"ézn§a £a¢m£e../ made
06}@¢7‘1<`1/15; /"/JL/L/Mp_:/g /`eM@%e/o 555 @1,7¢/ /Q[_/K 5,¢’ Pra;§a£,/g_
gauge 479 _bz//'£i/£ /'va pan as 413 flo»é>}//e(./ a//,; a.,c,'cm_<_»,
“/771:> 57%1.7‘£ agr€er/., _,1//`@/@1/10€. cf ,;//7£1¢1_/}1;1£//';.£1';+1§¢/ effie/1555
,LL)@/£ .Sz/é>jec_ ~/~e¢/ 143 £ro$$ 1€,1;@/171'1001_+20/1 cmc/a urz'
/T).S_%rz/L+/`,@n -/'/1¢17‘ 79{6: jury musv‘ bd 1'€.%:; exh ana/ja 0/1' ¢a_+ea/
Q#FM ,@c‘cL/r;c/ éy_}/Q/) ‘ 51 /ea§mé/e c/d.1év‘ was indus/aj
m +/)¢: /n.s%ryz;f/&n,_§ _ jwv..£¢@_ms¢/ aaa a// .»_»¢/ he
.c//Z/ 51 /'fh/£_S‘/'/ja.?“/O//. .__()<3 ‘ kan +/)@_ _§-/nfe_< F?H¢»mn:g` madg
pg;juf}/ _£`7‘017¢£/9:12/17¢5 /2> a jury L¢é_~u% /4;:1,13/1¢"/,>/1 has bean
/DA//»/}m//y 5//£/ 6040'1¢/0.051//1 ca.é>a_s‘/r/c', vL///}77/.'1/1"<;>/£/1~,§ an 1 .

` a 31”£_<51'1/(;. _5%/'¢/)7/£>£/ £@mp/am@/)-% w/v¢h a L/O.se¢/ ~F/;%:
F§Or£ea/ [Qmp/a/'nma~/- %0 have S~e.)<_ 5/§1 ped)' graébeci, and
5/10 Vg;/ l<_)mp/a/}M/)'%; /_Dc///€¢/ com /am an 140 hair and

/»rou_)n
"` 1 ` "L a U->@»// ” “/' 5 01”1¢12/).<. “ @,30,
fog/§§ n/Z;:J Wpi)'i/¢M + ¢1¢3@1 no X££¢£OZQ+M/m 131/1 11/1 +11

' 0'1' H. /%é~» L€L?Cd$/m 199/l was /é>_;/R} 0/€.1' 110 164/ag
1 ,_/_j/?§/ /“e}_l§/+Z¢/le f+c have be@n'w')+h A'Pp//m/rf g/n¢£_ 5/4@ ‘_,_;Q;
/X §/`1? 0~1" ag£. J@g: /<’PO§ D/rc;c':f,

1065€-»‘1#5

In +/x; mims paper ar+/L/¢; used as £x/>/é,/`A< 3 F'@/ é@n%
£a_€e.,§. //)/`. f?osémer§y éa`/[/ b_)a/g/)Q/» was Up$e% abf/mn /’)/'§_
On* agd/53 0_'101¢»091?/) fE/a:/'/an_)/P w/"f/) /-//'// En¢/co/ 54,151‘@/`

/5 years.
A - g

Juc@e_ /Qoézfv¢ /§um$ /m_€ /.)F_m'@¢/ AF/)//'¢Zm% I)F DL/a F?~oce$$
/Zy /khL 7%,///41»//')§ IOL/ML of l/~//w//'M/ /9',9 Qa/s pf 7Exas OrD/@r;

JW/Qe R<>b@f* @UMS aims arden 72 do w F;r.»z/h 5 ,4 d
£O/:’£/¢/$/@”§ .D’[ L“‘#-J» 75 dafewm/be. whe.%/)e_/\ /;E}ZQ /‘g;_§onéé@
/oéMé///)Ly +/»a% /mc/ camse/ pfae/)+e¢/ m /%SM/"v‘j/

l6'£`)€/£/)_/"£,. 75§€ b_/(,//‘/(/ oba/d /’M/€.’ "/<;me/ /4 //Z¢m% /]c`)‘/L 6{/'/,7£/
by f£a£c)/) 015 /'n§d/?/f'}/n I,q M/,,M /7£ z:: mO_/, d©/)~z' /
A'I
_juc/aa -iQabc/NL /Z’>_uF/? mfg a EzS/;Cf)as /};/)_7[¢;;;/2>/)@// ~%an¢/
~/»\//7/ /'/) //' CE.' /~,71//_’/ `//Zz;'/ 0 CO/).S /‘ /'ca/)a'. ‘
édr`;lfo??/h‘a ms ff€ h,:§ nov‘ answ;c£ez/ finlsz [/‘JZr//_`~]
O[) /c}P,D//L'vaé L/Ufnj 525 AI@¢S/Z¢I_S. __Ln a// q g/o¢,{/;¢/;¢
JL/£/§e BL¢/WS De,/)/e/ H~pp//Z,m~)¢ 5‘*’§ é*/j /4**' Amgm/mm/;
015 ~7¢/1»£ U/)/%e£/ 57£'@17% ' [d”).S%/'%Gl 74/'<)/7,_ §/?,~f he 5~1¢/'// /)A$
l m+ M/;'§J_,oa/’e¢/ "1Lo any O~/" '~//)€ ¢i//e/a ez/ 'F}`A¢:!S_

fmc/uS/o/J

§pp//chn% cé//'e_cj/'o/)S 7% M.,// dodge i-?a/;e/~?‘ L’>L;./m:">)

_/hc//`/)g_<` DF` F`QLJL '~)4/16/ foa£/(.JS/"or)$ [_31( [.qu_‘_>, Q/PC/ ' l
/"M`_S pmc/52 5/)0;.¢/)19 675 7€@¢7‘_§ ~/'hzzf /47‘+0/~/)@5/ pau/ RO$E”WF}/\J
/_> /)<>v¢ cmc//é/@; md nw w@»+/)/ 576 5a //@f.

l_ '61/ . / am vL/)e /‘)pp//ia/q+ and /oe_/'/)H pfe$e/)`/‘/y

§ /hmr£crm.%eo/ fn mark al _C,-/~//c_¢, [,/r)}f dec/ara me/e‘/‘ pena/fy

L>')[ per'u/‘/l/ ’/+)ol~/ GrccOr£//hj ¢-c :’Zj/ bg_/,£{ ../,¢,£ fac/ig
_S+A¢’e. /'/) '/26@ above mcf/bn §m?_ /*LM_ g/,»[/ £O,~,~@;-/-.

/'e_m/#zr/ ‘§Ca,q¢)g,g,qe@ JAWMU dam 73qu

 

 

,W§e_ 3 Of-B