Court Opinion

ID: 4048971
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:49:11.144257+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:05:13.643019
License: Public Domain

ORIGINAL
                 AJft, pA-mffS-lS

  Z&LJTHE_JLQUaiZSL^^JIDiAffiL
              7pyF^7<rorTFyA^
 Tm^nypp^g                       ArpPJMc°S^;
                                            JUL 0 2 2015
                    VS
                                             Acosta.'Gterk
 T^p     -S-f-^-ff of i-e-ms, A^^/Lee
                                 i/
       fePHrtoA/ For P^cfCTio*/Q/y '^tsJkiiJ.
Df OpiAfto/v/ a/O. 05-1^0011.3 -£fr
                                          fILEDJfcL

                         "   ^           JuN 18 2015

j5fl/tt*H*V    -35"5 D^lric.l CfloH~   Abel Acosta. Clerk
       Hood CjooNhfj Iexas
   Jhal^^MT^WJSJMM
t ftENTlT 1E5     Of FK&Tl Es AmcI PouMCef
 Hou. PdpK (j, IdanofiJf
 0udge.^335 Disfnct Gourf
Uoo3 Q-QutJhi Josfice. C<a/fV        Dtsirbf JtrJce
 1360(Jtl%r[£4,
CorAAt^y.T/ 7ko4fl

8&Leri T_j2rbnsi:W
P'lsjrigi- AflofiUet/
load CotWw 3"jStl'(V.e de/vikr    •'Di'^-icj-   kWocue
 £00LJ;~fWI £4-                                       t
 flWLcJ* 7fa<yf-&.

m/vffAPu)4. m/i/5
Aug e Hut, sirsAjm                HrkLAifcc/^
                                                -;-

H5/A (WI .^vfe./ob                A4/-fc)fMPyfef l\ppelWL
£AA/lk7oo£870

                        1^5e 2-
 Oo^ Cw ro-tWjnlci
 TD(L# 1°! 091^5               -• .AppeJlfr/irf
                                   £co,i>_e_
                                           7~

 16 9) 'ArKl^d Or

Tenfie -L'lvtAjgs-j-OA/              •5eCjQ*/e/' D/s-fneT

Brf UoffkTa 74/9.^

Le£,_A;^iy_Iko^(y„6±
 4ol tj\ fWkivtftp ^i-k 9060           /lurf Arp/oeg/^
fotyUorWiT* 7Wfo
j ee^ GAbneJ
T\«v\ £ Uf                                 i^G^dJkSL
401 (J.                                   £k«±_Appeais
Forf, (Jar+k T^ 7U</6,

                          Page 3
   IftVil*. of. (LoAflo/k
 A, ^JJinl^i of rTocJQg^;f^f4ies;^AJe/ Comf.ge.f-^.3-3
 61 lAlole. ,of QaiWs                           Pq//_
 CT/udex <of AulWi-VieS.                       4^
 q. Sfa^tnoe/vti Regardi^ £Wl ArgotfneArl-     u^jk.
 E.S-fg-ffMeMf af 4/ke Case.                   ^M
 f. £fg(e meA<4 df PhjCjgdmm] v-m-Wr*          ¥3
 G. Groom fl <> Tor fte:i/leuJ               ^M
 tj Ar^omeAf1                                 Pc, /3--/fc

1'.' Braver fee Qel)e£                        ^il
-J, AppeAiolix                                &J£

                       Aieetf
    Tm^px. ftf AuHxort-kes
   1Zi^>- AArnJiin iftinal Amerv-1 me.i>+
   0.5. dons[-. AmeA^l, ~SL                 E^Jt3^J£
   llSJ^jMskAneiAjM.                    fs^Jl^ftjr

        m^
 ff^ te.l y/v^U, 8^H^L,Ofe> %RJ3,/y,;r

       ^£erflfUlPS
.JiJssbJkiasJfti^fisE^^

 UksHJ^fesJDioad: <?^Crjfflii^L,LAJ_^L_[L7/.,_L(S
    \pnfWu or prejiklicej affluent aiJDiLflgk       '£
                                                  W€A

         I

                         PctOfC- 5~
        SrafflnrygA/f Regardbaa (0fa 1 JWg o<weMf
    IT .doNF b&lieae Fhcrf oral afeoftW"

tjj\ll fae. befuft'cal -for mu pelrfiaN
a" FkuS ffme;
                                                                                                                                   '       '

                                  '       '                                              •                   .

                                                                                1            '       '   '                     •       '

                                                                     . ' . "        •'

                                                                                                                 •>•   .

                            - '                                 '         -'                     i               ' .

                                                                         •' '                                                                           •           s

    '

                       .'                         .                  '                                                     "                                        .•
              ' >                                     ' •                                                •

                                      ,                                  ''.•<'-                                                               ' ' •            •

                                              1                     ••'-..

                                                            '       '•''•'

                    '''."•'•

>                                                                                                . ,.:                                           -:.-•':
                                                                                !                                                                  V*       i i :

                                              Pa^e (p
   S-ttAemeA/1 Of Tke dasc

MjM^a/ ^u •rW/^r I ./*?<?/ for rfeilotfy of
JL^e^lfiilkJ^
flaM (SkmeAfT -(of 4Inc6 &fTCA/Se _OJQi^^^
u gars, Ior life .

ML,<f1^d ^aJ(J ^uJb(T/0; five Ugl ^MiAfji_UAM

 c(hJo\ cio\\W*r 0^ ^Mottfw Ho £Q14 4k<? /AJ^(di^&^
                     fci^l
bOgg/vf. OA) ^Moafif \yt'&6ts '-Z^e jury flss'esseo
filMtekme/ifl gf 40 u^oirs ^'^fi'Ner^^A iai TQ (LJ -
      OA/ februa^ ^.^?6/^ /VppdLjl 4(WL
r~,
Afresf ^f jgjgfweA/^ uiifcJv uxti \neafcl_a^A
/>kn<tcl &kI tycLKUa) 3lOM. A ndkc &f Appeal
uoas W^y fikal OM rV)arck^OOW .
      Okl f<\afck &C> jSjQIS Zec^iA ^\^d^L^£
&£_ll\ pp^AJ ^ Fnf-V UWfU . Ju3xe Lee An/A/ Ucpk/W
QaoML ia^q^vg^l ' affinwW "foaf tourf's jucfomgafiL

                      Paqe S
    SymeAtf' a ^coc&Aunl •H-fstory
            r%rrk a^glOfS S^omcI tthkidr GdoA
of App^c. k Fc>r4' U)orfk gadre. Jod^m<la/4- <*w
M0,aa-fM-0Ofl3-(Lft.

        c3, ApfteiktAn- -prQ.se,.' mfffftW far QN„_gJ<r^/3jQA/_

IS^i^^
ey--e.rd^c] 4t>               Ooat^ QL,£0)5,

             ''                    •                                ^       •

    •   •            .         '                    ,   •       -       •

                                                •                                              •

                                                                                 •   • •'

                                       ".

                         i.                                 —

                              •;•'.-

                                                                            ,-

•
                                                                                            •'•••'';

                                       P?L$rf
     (WauaicLs. For RevrecJ
 X/\| tbe dQ^tAia qrgumen-fe of pfOSffiU^QA)
 ftf d^psp. Afa, QQ-\3LWft \{ ^4-afe5 a6u4 Cj60
 kfefeyJ_jjik*^^
^M-ueaf seflfp/pcp.j rtgk4?"Tk hosti'-f gue^
Served 4gjq vjaar'oP go 5o^ac) r^KF•?•
Ije UqS rUne. -Big. a<arij ^mzih^Q^tiijibe.
 yJPfM ^g/ne r.ommuA/4y; Our l/pwrncW-fy
•JL-f.V--- Tils- a/if flffer>£ 4W Aeeck-fc) /ke_
 ar\5u)pfeJ for. j£teT~U'g Aeg.<Js 4o S&TVerHie,
 •fny^. *fko-f ki ujqs stHrwaettT^fo .a/ /gaST
 fOj £Q ^(u^s-a^\fM\/h %inm£)JIk^
 OjfQonAs arc, ike. Olsfoci- A4JMn£u_^^W-
rft _3^
     OO

                   Page /#-
 CloSMCi arac;fYtenrh> 4"0 QSeSS Ofd G^rfldlfal
 puVViSKwfcrv-l -fo fl\Q. £arUeC paniskme/vf
a^stseA and sea/ed, qac! -fAus multiple
C)x)ft\<>\\rnQnh -foC 4~ke OfiQC dRfcrtieS^
  IagW -iUe U,S, (W>s4, Arn^cf IT gfjaraA4-eglng
 qymsV Double, Jg^pareL enfefftecl -/^ru
ID^.^miA-r^m^^J JA\I pfO^OLh QMl'u&fiS of
 /^M Qa^iri4 mdl^ple punrHkno^^_d[ocJJ^^
 Sqaip, offe/i^,

                     Pcige /i
 X 3o^C^W[c-b6<\Gil\J hpiteue. 4ke On()r4
of AppeaU a-f TextArS neeck io f&ureuJ./Wy
Appeal bg^gd upOtTi rhe. fuLc, ^-fA^ers
\A Lunqugk ia fke £J»S, Cnofi oCJ\ppep(k
TsY 5th flUfauft] Hfffy Tke. argomeA4 cY,
 Ike fllslrid- ArBflffle^ (A K^~GloSfAfQ ^a^c/me^-f
-fo"-Fke. jure, OqA)'/)nf Qf .sKojlj Ad4 O^e,
"The juru ^6 ^)S3es Q.f\ aASAlcAeS pufelwenf
•io a C/Wig {koj kos al/rarL UeA asSdSed
fi/ldMd, Af4cr fefrj.kj &gg/5 !/<; /e,nac^k;
B^ FJJ k)^ Q/\c\ tompojclric, k) uJiW7
,U)aA 4k*4eJ (A -fW lo<>4 c2aoja of pn^ Paw.
-gim/lgf, J.M ^U^4l^ Teflte Di^qs4 /Xd Crmm I
  flia "7^3 i 1^ Appeal* 4t) <?Cj(Y)pai'L of
 pfejud?(Le ^_La CjeAe(ul; Aqqq^ \fs LyAQQgh   7-

By&f&cl.loOk) (L SfoW. ClommH+ed Qanskrftdlottg'/

dfjfiAj J&|ilen(tiW phg5€ ok kfial by asSer-Un*
 ikrf prior offenses gm\<\ CUtfoA robbery
 Offence uJefe &qck C{ owik ^4 bask to ym^ j
.^•fqlc, (aj^s f\ejL:e^CiclL QQiAjj- jofy ko-assess
Hfy><? pun6kno<V)f /A ^d</r6n^Q_ggidi^^
^j_ikis_^^                           -£>r each &f_

rim\zk. Jeopardy. [J,S£A/Sk Amao^L^
                    Pa<£e /3
   AISo |A IQesfe ~JeiAs bicfd M P/Mal
  _J^jJ \\1kl CO A^umeak aaA (iQcAucicfc
   O/XinSfk^Tjpp^aU -fo £u*Y)pS\« aC pfejodi'cej

  ^ffof 1A OfesrA^ ar^cJfYv&Yf ko jory qu^Aj
                                  CxJklck Quaffed

0 (ilkpQ prASe^cikr 4py jcjifo kkaf eadk of ^/eg.
  prtof ^>kfen^eA anJ OufCeni- fabbery offeoie.
  /i)aS rVabrkk;-<af .feasf /O £jgar5 '• k/vereky
  (JRfog 'Jury k^ QSSfiSS mufk;pfei_/Qual5k/A€AJi
  jgkLgo^ "fif "kkreg. prior .<r>fifert&.S ujffs
  ftdJoaavvl^^
   6Tfc}eA&e. <^f lAarmfoi efediiivj^dLJ^g^
  Froio amnAfl tks (v\aAa              <7 OpkoA^
              -* '   ' v   * in
Juf^l s-decke^ v/ery 4o yars prison 4crm
daglv-Jortekc/ bcj 4ke 5-krk q4 4kg'ugry
4iW i4- |Y\.<agl^. fe ar^uirva^

^tffl F.<3J 4Q&J From ouKa4 X mds£skkdl
uJkiA L^no read kke -exGerp-f kr^Ao fke

JodkiMQ Sp^c/tff'colL ok n^Lj kke.Qlims^k_
_^kWtj'f>y pkfdces kusargumwf<> 4o kke_jur_y_^
Xk t± apparent kmT kg i>u4^ Uf^CLLJ^L
jtjry kfl dasesS .aa•.a<4rJikioxxa! puAi^kmeriL
ffi m<y &frs£ k^r a CoAv/^korv in l^/^X
XfJJlbiia^^
        e
ground*; ulken 4~kc fo^knok AkW(Atey S-fa/cs
 And he needs Fq ^eriR, 4ke kWie XhaF
he. uoas seirrf^AC^ol 4o o3r~\eQ^ 10}20
Ueois ago" Xk Is- obu/Qu<> ke a*inFs_klvC-
•jory jc> QtJ&S a neu; punfckme/vf -for- kke
ISiLjIfiQizkJb^^
ftnAisUw/rf 4cr £a/y)e okfe/ise,

                   Paqe Ik