Court Opinion

ID: 4039371
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:12:27.775416+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:50:29.880391
License: Public Domain

_\/\w\x\;. LA Y>\EDSBE ‘“°' O"’°"“"OD\B'CR kl\\s TW€. sum mgmth
_' l A?PE\W%§ECENED m

_ S`i§;`{‘\?§i;{’:-§§eals Q_mp\`\“ @(" A`P'P E»A-l__c
\LS, JAN 1 n 2015 T F"-ED 'N
~ ‘" ~ _ Qf pé
T\ML Sr/\T\~, m Te)L\NEIM Au‘ar€y, C*@FK @.AN ]] 5 2015

/><\>P;L\Am§ mch m E>».SE ?\@S@>c>r\<&

‘B me ofv'@nsz§¢ m AP?&AL Q_u_MEL

 

A"P'\>e\\c).v\&_`.k£ml£_&£-I-;B\ED;A& \”€_AUQ§M %}\ak ~&\NL (LD\M~
a><§<;v\x ¥IN\L w Q:\.a_ ha @m~$i Em¢£,

v L._xgw\'\@ \:€L K\\;DSBL 13 M\L AP~\>¢\\QM . T\q& S.~&cm»_ M
'_\FQ'P¢\\e_e_,

;,z. \\\Q wm \;w\;&$ x\m MW_ \;\‘\Mn …\\‘.~dn 3m >?;\€_
+&\as mbm>r\ &\\. c)<&@(\;. chx.'R./\'P@,?, ZQ,L>('A).

‘2>. AP'_PQ\\QM vc&uc;h wm clAAi+ior\aI £\m`wm CZO) Q\cw\s
\:D £.‘.\€_ AP'\><>_\\&~\£§ bvl¢>_§. €X+em\.:n: H\¢L vam ice Felgm/W

\5 ~ 30\5, m S§mm 3m AQ}L~ w m;\¢@/C §§ v\/\oH@n.'

B §/\Y§'u\‘<\a\'\); ON\A /~\u)r\r\ov\\~i¢s
mm De_c_mm Qz, Q.Q\w Av\>e_@\ Awmmw 1a v

A?\>¢\\@M¢ \1\\¢; g \N\,v&m\ S;m emng w wm J®
Q\\e_ “r\<\@ /\”P©€,\\M R\¢ia£‘

4 \\is flva (f_¢>xam:_?_m_) HM_ v\/\C>’u`m\ flwk \:_-)(&en.;k

'0\\3 '\m\uww 5&§\ Qm§; /\"\>©e_\\w\x `v&c"\@,~e_k CL view
dam D.:¢\_LM\M__;;\_L_Q_QM, />\r\m a mM-r@r\ md w(wmw
a_s /¢\'P'P\i_u_»\\\n*§ /\TTQME\\, /\QQ@\»\"\>M wa+‘\r\ cl Anme@:
`P>\¢‘\ dc ¥\(\M; mm Q`\\e;k \c;\\ /\`PPU\ /\T¥b\' m Ev\.

 

 

?@5¢ \

/H_§b /°\'~PPERL /~\T’Tbvm)w _S@'r\¢\` Co_ `Eé>\(‘ Q`O(\Mlml
»W<&\}\ X~_\M L\@M RP_L@\/LL id Qwv& Re’?ov&e/\ R¢L@.¢A,..
/‘>C\>PP_\\&~\&; ¥\\)ial`, O¢\Xi&iom.( § m \;B YC\/Iw H\p_
‘CLL®¢\`. `L\\ Q\»LQA log _Sea_v` (Jur\u FPQS§/`b(g F_Nm\<
las QYL;@NLL Lr\ \\lg `F\>YQ~S€_ `Re§!>om£¢_ `K\'i¢€.

L¥\ "'\`\NL Q_D\M ¥Y\Clu €»<~\€n¢\ L;¢\M_ im Q{\»\¢\'L CLU&&\D¢;N me T<)€ /\'PP€I\(W_`PUAU~
28. loca\. ' '
S.A?P¢\.\M\ bmc ag cme/hem ama nn __\@M)W ;)K/c¢
Q €`)\S .

LQ¢A?©Q_LK&M: mm \(’C,€Lu<_§éj (M\ CL&L`\+;N\¢(' )L\\\»>N C?®W

davis *v;r>l Q`\\¢_ A~PP&&\G/M ‘P\~o“$€ R¢$?m.¢\ T§\~a¢§ , C)(+Er\¢\ins
\;`\w\o_ ¥:Q F`dnwau¢ &QH\ QG\.S.

""\.rp\c`\ov zi>£&©n$\`or\ wm lile §§ ~!\Wea( /XT'NJ/rum
th Q`\\L A\;\(\Q /\‘\>@c.`\\um,b `RRZ¢_£.

&. hamm QLL&@\ l\®©e_x\m& vu:w¢<& ATTGWML V\/u_>+ror\
want wm ELM/ tm C~@\.\owP¢l.mmi

ACLomGa/w w€+\r\ Ammwi
mcmann Em LLM`H/\ AJ\W¢

q`. A®€_-\\am¢ \*Q ‘_`&\scs&s ®AA\X\U\(L.\ ~¥`\\N\o_ ¥Q 3;"\\¢ \m“;r?vo~
_S‘C` \»:¢_{ €>c\ M\¢ €c>\\w>’\ru j‘¢cw\&$'.

LG_\ /~\@©L\\_C)~\& \“LL`L&H¢='\` \;‘¢\L \N\Q`m ‘Cd>l:)v&o\`¢ VCL@>A (‘>'F\
`m-Lm…£_ Clm,L +:'\M_`C>\@\ w w _'\/13,-+ +'LL nw
wth cz\ A\ fm &_\W<_ v@,;m£, /\1>@€__\.\@“¢ ages ‘v\\¢ amy
w 3\»0~\&»_ am amen§em M ama w €.‘\<». m war
Lr\ &_\<\‘\3 C_Cwse_ th 933me §Qgéh Q(B\§ , CJ/M \Cbc/ »£wc/h
mm w §uv&m _Y<;\ie}¢ ’cm which w mca/1 be M,“H@(

'RF_S.@EFH`UN SJL)VM¢H&(\ '
__lG/V\L{L LQL S\E,L.Soc@

_ G_Q.Yx\€am¢ §§ gamch
:. __L(\N\'\p \nj 'K\{’LM ¢*\.4& Hr\o_ W\O&(U\
\`m§. hew 'Pm\/;.LLL th DF_B?\P\,\<./H)TRE\H C_l,e/\K AT Tk@_

'__"BI' sTFm; _iu_<.£<¢¢ E\)\\L\nq \'m NQU&\ STFWE L`\m /\vE¢/\;ué;#_z@
§\:xAR\( alwa 'mrj
TQ§&QM "QCL;L em\,'e\e@&\ `”\>m;.;@ Ldu mm hmw In;;aw

A£;>w§ww& macdch c>r\ k\m LUW/UE Un/`L.M=lQnM/QL¢A
0)_'. ' .

 

/\ v ‘ l{`M/\/\,l§/ 111 H/.¢_l we