Court Opinion

ID: 4067523
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 23:21:56.622439+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:34:07.845461
License: Public Domain

UT-,^-46 ' 10
                CfiUSt Wo,

REbPZS //0UT7&AJ               COUZl Of #PP£^

PftV   USELESS. JUh&6             COURTOFCR^ALAPPEAIS
3uth bzsr/?zcrc*u£7                     — tW
                                       AUG 20

                                     AbelAcosta,Clerk

T& Ttt£ //*/V0e#£6G J U£&£ S/?J2U> ceLtM

by ©lvno| tKr^U^k K:S pro SQ a f record £{\#s
cewnpfe/n/ng a"f Pay Ci//te/esr/ J^^e, fies/z&deht,
UJcLi\d ph&uj ^hc Ceurt k,he filial*In9:    RECEIVED iir
                                     COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

                                          SEP 022015 Of
                                       Abel Acosta, Clerk

i^d^e *f sum Dzsy&zcr couxt *t ecu**
CoMntV/ 7€*AS <5tvW reu'd nlntC in-Oa^utfQ
?u-fmj~oh ?±ytemi Ttt&sr&re of
7~&X#j u-r; PBbMcS #4UfT0N *ntgrec/^> r&per a^r&l€r t^ ~ u-f/V:
    SP*Tve«lev\*> denied befenctantV IMqU&\
Terjrzw* f®^ teelfe-P T&%a$ c®dt o^

fl/l/p 0TH-&R Represent;* &**; ^di^fusU
to Set c\ kOO^frv^ x Sou'd MaVs\*Y\.
£esp©v\den^& defied be-fewoloiyvVx reouex^
*~a J-bQ^e] ReF00>*vP« aW /W refuted fcd
 '-6t ^\   KQQw.T\ng OY\ S<^fd ma-&/>)>

 tp f£ b   <3l   ka «tr ; >>g o>v> j^a Id m* b>'6»>St

^e$f®r\€i@\s\ d^vv;ed t>e-fc>vola.fc*;V £*K-Jbjfr
kar i-e-fWed Ld ret a, k^ir^ by\ s*t

 Gm<$ bW-^^ XiTtTixcr AT7a*my
               Cftltft wo,

fceHDZB                             C0HB7 Of frPPmu
U

    vs,                            C&97QL S7&TT/M
                                   ®US rzivt 7&M 79?n
JM7H b2S7/£2C7

      Oh tktf      d«vy ®£             52«?XJJ C*cmff
oh to b€ kese»./ i>ePe>yoL
(a) $ c&hWcteJ petg&n r>nc^ submit ho -fcke »n-
WctiVvy court c\ mnahidYi f#r fer&hffc 2>W t^fbftiy
of .evidence CentAMnff lotdojiccA tv\oteir) TKe ha^t^n m*XN/ re^ueri .ftrensfc- 5FUW feeing
OY\\y c^T evidence d$fcr\lb€d Wy SultfCCteVon (a) feVvsA
^^s s«cAJor*d iv\ re\<\t\*a* -*U ^Vc oflW.x< feWwb Is
   € °"S*V c-f tW oWUe^ed cp^v^w^ c^d

   Clj Uoas Hoi previously to 1)1VW beffttfng:
      (ft) become t)iv)(q tes^inq ujas;
         (I) not- ocV*»\flA>l«j or
         (tfJiaveJIabU, but vv>t technologically ca?a^
         0^ pTondvVg proW^'vC results; OT
      (BifcWou^h ho fault *f tU co^vvc^Jper^
      f$r r€A5$H? t"K^ Oor-e d/*Oi n^urC jackt^
      u\ve {*fcere*tr */ juxfa'ce re^Ve M/« ^^*^

    heiA^er bee Wpuef %Wfe pravide ^ v-€a,^na,fe^e
    Kkelihood of result* bWt, owve more «cc-
    UxA-fee *Vv\d pv*bB^soy\ §£ ebkAV-jboeir^ori {^
^^^obKow U,woler bWs Gkeupber{ b:W Court ffvxols re-
tkg CoU.>r4c ^ebQrvv^lV\es, bUt bW T^rjfcn tfS ic/i^enfe*
Counsel vv\ust be ixppofofc&l ureter t:Ws JUbjrecW^
not lovke.v %Vaw bW V5i.k oUky cx-Pt^r Vk 4\e
t Ve tout b fivds r€<\sov\a..ble OrouvvAf o-v bW
^l^t^'tki Court d-cbevm/nCJ' kVt kU per^n is
indigew^/ uJkCcV*eA/<^ ^ 'o^sCr. dtfrnpensd-fciVh of ccmux-
Se^\ \S provided Jvx bhc S^vvve Inaajn*nev <^r i5 r^£u*f|
fey;
   CI) nr£\cle 11011 -fa* tke v-epreye%vba,fci'ovi
 • £\ pebfbtaY&v CoVNVCcbQol «s»^a, capita,! /eltfhyj
   Q) CW*\P'!?c*- oU» ^v- bWe representor* >k ov
   Kafeeas corpus Manvg o-T a^ i\rtfb'&&*'±-def-
   <3>nd&r\±* C&ftVi'chGet &f <% /e/&toy ateh&v fckan A
   d^p(fca\ felony..
        ftz-r, 4ll, Oil. £u*«.i>;rftN* **& OTtfe*

vfc) Xv% tWs cYtopfee*, 4^^,^reli^,Va^ ^ caywi'cfceol per.
San   meotnS A per/** uoKd /? t;kg te%a\ gU^¥«U<\v\ d£
tVe carwvcbed pevs^n, L'Ok&bkcr bWe leoaj reUb^.
SV{p between bW Q^oi^di^wowyusI 4#*>yrcbed pecf-
oy\ exists Weccxu^e of tkc cxge of tit covtwctaf
p^v-yov^ or because or tke ^Vyf/ccLl qv me^fe*.)

r^{\ mob^nS for fcW* eavwvebed perte* ureter
tV\is cAvcxpb&r o^^A Is ev%b\%J,ed bo Cou\vS*A cbW
•fivuM^e firovid^d -to .e-yea^ tiWboi^W. pen'od, Uccmai€
*i A# r wfc/ej?.ce && tk& e&turt>)
     along U//tr'A of c/eJl&^iphfan of 'ttrAx a©*d

     Stabe cannot otelfrer tU* e^j\fdenca h& bke
    cowtrb.                                               ,

ftrtfcte 4%&S afler fe-K* response p^^d dwfr
&f Uj/iehher t kg ^b &* ney M^D ireTevi fcr*5 fc** I
\L.CSbiV)Q Uv\der tk^S dkocptev- o*v*fy iA
  £1) bke Court find* tKottt
     W)tW evidence;
      Ci) 5btU exwts o^*| if in coYsdrUan r^ecfevwg JbiUfc
     .b£sbo$r»ftlejowv>d
     Cii) Haf be.Cn Suleyecbcd "bo fc?x o>r is cxn isyiue in tkc coje;

           Convicted person es tAb Itf^V by o prepaid
    e^^wce &4 bke evidence bWxv.
     (ft ) b K6 •f*£ r>"^*» ujouid Kob kc^e )>£&>*
      ;/ eKctdp^^ory r-esulks had been obtained
      bVrouoi* D«/^ hen/^;and
     t&) 4?te rm^est fir tkc p+*jw&d b^H ten              ,!3

                        uj A e ff*€J* be'&*>€ dr a fb&y

tffjb* fh -tU care /%^ s^&^/t e/,,r /
une/er tb»'r ch^Pte^ ain^f i?ke Con^fct/*^5          Court
if pr®h>%/beJ frfwi finJinf that fJent/kzy UW
not Cth *&*-** /* tA^ m/>e s*/etp ah tke
apptic#Me*
Cc) £f tVt C0*v\'ctin«i c*uvfc finds ih i'kt aftiVm-
abiVe bk£ /Vruey Arta^ /'a, fujject/'*h fe)Ci) and fete
can V)'cheat perron meets bKe re^Wremente of
 uJsect/an C&)Q)/ the c&Litrt St*M oyeter fck^t trkg
r   equested fWenft'c &w$ bestmg be conducted*
The c&y*t m&iy prefer the -test *bo be, co>i-
    ( 2-J £:ir &epetj>tr>?ejjt a/ P&t&h'c Jhfhtyj
    t*t) d laboratory Operating U*der a, Cars-
     bra>cte uoibK tKe deport ^ev*b; ov
    (3) o* ^V* reouesb of tk e^^cfc^^
     S'av\* AViob'Ko^ 7oibovctfr** V^X @2afj ^t^mevit,
    Cent**
(J) Xf the eanw'cts/nf ctf-wb vder,f h 'k ab kk
 farenS/c 0/U# besbfnj &* C&na/uchCci by q
l#karal0Y/ obke? tk^h €\ j)ey?c*r bto&ht of
Pubh'C S*ifry oy c* MJ?ar£ory und
er Cohbr«ci -av/VA tk* clep**-bme*t>t tko.
ftcihe of 7eJ^$ is /9#t //^i/e fa fck« c&ft
&f hesbixn$ 'u ftete* t k,'t fi4bsectt'oh UHte-er
*    /^^   ^   *le c*rt o/ ^"*
u*ser t-A/j- ftr&seetJ&n, ref^rJless &r
eU^ cost W         h€€n yW Z-f tKc wvt
ox (rlerJ fcWvb bM belong be coviducted by c*
lcvV>orc\boxy oleSCviWd by bWf Sub TecWon, tke
CoxA^vb SKa\\ include m      tke order veoUiVcme-
^b.s tlkAbl-                             y
  O) tVe I)WW te*tfog fee conducted /n a tiV^eJy
  a^ efwc-ienh vv\^Ysne.r uvxdex Veo^ov* r iwsto,v>ce tWt tVe bwift bests cKvcvtlouW
°tb vve bfwxe <»£ K;s br*o>c co^>©A>te o+
PVoV8drw9 p^^b'vt Y7€* CnK vw 2^eyj
5/k.h u, Sb&tc, J£T X W.3el S^X CleJc. Cr^
Qpp. 2ooS) thxi°\ juAge*s jud.'cTal wb'ccofbU
brrctl recorrol com ItVcd loi\sV t^£<^eno/aht X /vio/ti^
and dffid^vit suffi'a'ewh: fee ju/b^y bert%
C&ul&l /iodise   beer* bcs-keof or l*j?<*-/ 5fe/I/
•6C £?/? 6/'6te4g/ L& pazSk-C&>'*et,C±i'*>>i l^X^'v^, #*•*
/'i^m r^txy 'he ees^ /f <^7 ^e^^ ^^
<^A/£ ^^"fc^od of khJA bMbfwaj nofe be.ck~
m&loflc&lly &%p<**ht af providi^ p^^b^btVc
results, ^f Diy$ evidence ^r^ fcef4c<^/t
$h&l*J th4& J\e US &eS6/*if beckntyu-ZS Lua>ul*4
accurate c%-^<\ t>to\><\\,\\/*. tVeo/\ "pvewoMS results,

it. Support? ^wae •i55qcs; ( 2j fcA«fc wet Stereo/
•\tV^;«U*WVy O^ fcfcC p*rp€rV-raAfcY...U«JQ.*

ev/v«=le.*»c* .|»j^e-v» t£-$te©lj o>v©i v^Ve v»'KVg n ^i/^r|ab/e
prvbatUe that.tU /?*rs*.» ^*u/J »„t AM '
"•eeji   c&mj/rct.ed,

                            JftZftt £ou«tt 14 ur thtizry
£^j)ber &H aubkari-ter tU eotwi'ctf^ court
b© <3vde* bW^ tWblVg eww@l ^© More* tkl
 tn'ctl- j^d^C Kar >o oubVori'by t» ^A? ^y^v
f]\v^i>tQf t/v^t results Cu<*rQ VcKvaraXK or n<*t

( 7€& Cr,m, »^>, £La?J£),
                       #r^T* ^v. or. mp^>w&\s
$n ^tppeo.\ u.vvr\ vnn^v\o,\ Wv.a^bbe^ €J£C€p% bW
i£ V.K* acrn^\ecb^dl ^yttyy% uj*k$ co***A'c&e ^^
Cc^ptbaJ ecv^e ^n^ uj«*s r^v*b£.vc£ bo deOCU^
b^a c\ppec*l >J a dhvccb cKpp^&f bo bk^ edurt
Of dr;% cou^r-el ow k,T i^\ob{flv\ 6* D^M be?fs/n? .
S^cotuXe tke cosjLtks o-f cvppcej/ ^^ ^^erojiy
k?k& -£frS*£ nir€eif rir&rn tz^e
e/rS turret d**/ u»by  **" SA~«1*t
4 peb/t'i'*h Atr e=c OeJr/t: c?^ <^^r?r Jaunty
Csjur$ Js^e py-ese*\&d -first bo trie c^u^af
^CftScP+i J'm t    &e> c*/&.S*e>t pa^cJtll^ \s, Wc P*n/e/y