Court Opinion

ID: 4055609
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:15:49.571551+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:02.486825
License: Public Domain

16/!1~   c w/Ik/r?J ttg f?~t:J~                                                            Yl, .re ·~ -w
/'0 50·· (.JI   le7M(nli-fC~                                                  · fh c,'j   .2. ~/ 2otS
 /3;owV'\vi:J~ rey / 7bf?ot .

_rJ ear CLe1~ .                            .                                   Abet~Acosta;{Jier·b\l;y-_"_ __
____ fl_/earL.f/-t~d-    e(} ~oJ.&l,_-tbLaL1i~tJ-c-(J-e_..f/fr-~~-f?LL a_{;}_r-_i LaLCer:.for:ar:c,~----_:__.,~-_ _
_ }:::f-ld-1:-J_o[Jr:._f-~ yo ~-t:(-Lf-~ /b!ddec_rcl_tktL... yo.ur- Cau.ef_{::_~-.locL~_'f-:kL._
-~-i~~-±~u#~~~~f-JOULC04~----------------------
--~-ll.Lj-<a<--{;u_c_~v.r-f-/r-v:tg_{l-A-L-£..ejt>-WJtl..__-f-:£._k_ IJ1c;_f-/eL,"--------
    --.,-.---------____,=--_:__) tee£p~(;.(_~~--¥or.£P-,,------                                             --
----------13.~-Cr-W~-·- - -

~
                                   :cl\J   THE. C.DURT OF CRJ:rr1.IN~L APPE.QLS
                                                   CF IE:XAS

.E~-e.El-RJ:E.--.,-----~------------------
---------------------------------CAUS£_~o~·------------------
.BrLL~_C.ttF-tRLESJP.ILITU..2                   _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

-LD~TJ:iE..Jd.QbJ_Q&Q.._Ij.Lt5u_O_G_E_QF"' Si\I_Q_C_D.UR.r,
                                                         __ 4\_~·                            - - - - - : - - - - - - - -

_CQIDES_No.w,_B.L}~_Cba..de.s_l.JtJ./,,~s1&:b::ho_de.r.,;:o._fhe-abo_V-e_e~:±lecLo.l\_d_nu.01_J,er-eJ_
_c_aQ£.e_C/.n.cLme{_\L.eS_f-be,..Gu.c\-_-b_bo_l_d_a_e¥:deqfuf_'j-hea.~.~-3--b-~e_a_cJ,~puk-:-+-.ha±_·_
_p_ex_k_~(\$'_f-o_a_m_cd±ec.o£i.cw.J_a_(\_df_e+:±tkt1e_C~:.tJ..sho.w_un.fCJ_the__Co_l.Ld_+he_f'o_/loJ.I.d.L~J-~---
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ffi.CI5_BBD.UT-Tif.E.J¥'SeUI£,___ _ _·_ _ _ _ __
_ &_J,±;ol\e:tj-O-'~.Jbe...i2.4 " da '=j-o.:.t-__:rc_f.l~-l_c{/_5ru2aLtmv.ef,~_eas+ o_c.-bwj.,.-~.7-lar-poss-:.n.,_·
_+-bv:_Q_t.l3 b-~~->-,-~to.s_w:h.Q.ol,.e._f.Mls_sJopfled.-_b~I~·as_RaoJ~B.o_b_h-::1_Gr:uJ,hs_a_(\_J.,                                _
~k.et_fsc~:O:ie>_e(..ls±o~-o-IJ,~fh .~n-<f-8_bo_<.l_ys_o.f-_feL.the....O.Cf-es+-p-e.:i .•'H.o.\'le.LI:to_d:_J1o-fna:r-~:s±ra.te.._
_(-U.a-~tl.lr..~-',..-+-     '
                    n_~_t..e.:M:l.   rtt
                                   Wc~_/J            '      L.
                                           o 1Yl..Qg_~.s±co:rc_6f-:_                                         '
                                                                     fbe.....cou··::d:'j..-wa.S_Jle_V_e_r< l.t.Lii::v.m_ai- +-het5L__
_we....ce._g_r, accys_g_:h'o()._ma Je..~o.g_ar~s.:f-kLrn. or ±bet:e. wer~_a.fJj_aff-c.'daJ.tt/-_.f,~leJ,_o_n-+-he-.­
_I.J*' da-J_of~~&-,-f_9_'6_,_t be.._d,s_k/c,.±.atf:o.ct~e-~:j_t~r:r-a_a..l\1..d/c+m~+-cha..c<j-~-peii.--b!o.rJ~c___
_c<D.rn rn_::b.fed.-_6u_r:~Jg_r~_of~_b_g_ 6,'-l:a±/Q__~_c../a./m. .• ~~-p.e±a/.Qoe.._cc.fJ_m_mJ~-*b.~+-~--_.
_a__V~rs~d_IJ_,'1al s ~l~~te_c.ec.e..'\Cer O.ltd- -3-uo2,_N~_a_c_ca1"'ooefJJ-_{I{).:±e.o.tiev.LWa'!J_J~le/.d._b.y­
_f:b.fl..-k{Ct-.\-eo_u r-:.·h_Ef-p.'(..€.-- t_r_,~a._L,~o.±ecv./.e..0 wos_b_eLJ_b..;_.f.k.e_-lx_(~Cf,_(           Co ll_•~-' ·~_('eq.o_cJ>_-&_

_a,_JThzbQ.n ~ ""_1:)_~_5_cOV:..e;r~_QOJ:k.JA.:,£f-e.cJ/!2_~_.£/ leA_~'j-Sc2'/f_S_+e_e/! fhe.. defen~e. C?tfomej,_l?e:.b~
_.f:_ltlnej~6a.tLno+_bee·~Lp.co_v/ded ao~_d/iCc:2.\te9_m_cd.eo~~L£ro ~ S~_Sfee..l.e_._$f-C1~/_Ll{_'f~_
-i-'L9..1o ,-aJ.u-~_.fo.und_p_e±dJo,er qu f l.f.~-r-ll-r-c~LL~7_L9f~-f).ej~I.{_CJ_s~oiel'lce pei~_o_~"er-
    •       ,           f               •    r              +,
_·t._o_o_, n_:bj.::...o' t1e.. ~-eg.rs_un_prr SO{}_fY} e.t'l l'---------~--------
_f?e+-;.-k,'o.ce..:L,~~-l?tv~_usd=_)_OOCJ_L'J_r:e.f:cJe.sk. J.h.r-Cltl_:;;.k Tf!XC<.5_/2u bj,c__rr£Qaxv:#!..o~~-lde:J-_
_vLa..s--g_,_ven._co.p.L-5.
           r                   Ir -/4.
                            tO..-r-_ _
                                             '       .J ( -1;'                    __L...... -~ j I        ('  .,.d    ± I1C L -          I (    ".J.....
                                      , e...._;_o..Y_es:1l9.a_(_c::t'f:l_re..p.o..o.:>=--.D.L....'U:\e..i.c_C!_ _efl:._ -~-r-r-r-:ttx_r-eo..ad~_t:L_

_and_.f,~v:\ci{rtj_o_o_fac±:: o£ p.e.:-l)h'c.ne.r~b.a_v_,~~~-beR.D._t~o.-\LoJV-ed.-_t'c, a four:J}a_~_cl_ Cross_·_
_ CC;.{J_n)ta.>_u.la.sP..-u.~:o.us_abo.ukbo_w_[be.-_dt_'ttr-~bt:-Q:/to.cne')_m.o.n.0-8£,~-J~_c..h.ox_9_e___·
-
    :/:1   -f..h
              ~j (      II    r
     _#:\_~_ e. _:r_iLL_Lbe_;_n~
                                   d(_c_u/::-m.e.tJ.+            .,_("_ ·,rj(                         j __      ~--     }
                                                    __ ,. Th.etc.:r-r::HL.pe.f.:t:tc.ol)er_co_rn.r:fl_efJC~~-r£1-'~J.IJp:f-~     .r
                                                                                                                             oc.a:httj-
_Q_~frlf-lafn±y--;:£aa)-'~£kcuJ~Iea.s.;ve_seo.fcb1_-fh_e.._R.ubtj~Lee-Sm.,~+-k-manli.qe__-/c;_obtafa _
_q__ca ~!.(-of_a_cQrr:,.p.La.(/_0:1-__m:a__La_cr.y_D.a.fe-_Sr.r:,_t':fb.._w_~_baLbe&:\_Q_(@:fetj_atl.d-'--c.ba.r:__~
_&.) /±b.J:be..Jou.cq_l(J_"'~-~-Reb~-h.'o.oeLd /s_t_Q_v__ereJ       I M t:2o.Jlv-3_us±_)_s,. L9_9~_-fk;_a_dc~_eaf-_
_k,.ad bee.,...    d.t's..~.!:rr_ed.- ;~n-therf--'-cas_t-_L31 _~z],_~_fha±_oorrJpJa./J):t:ped·:/llQ(Je.r d-IJ~~J                 c::L_

_c_omp.l~ci:. 6ad b~~_.fljg.J_{a_f_b~_:;r:(Jtf_ce._Cou rf- c&~&.oo11/eJ~!~t(J~~~-,~ne.e_tho_f:.cfafe.__pe.ftY/OA.
_e_r ha .s lea_co~-1= +b_e..._p_roseat.:l:r~r¥)-a:tkxneJ.j..lra.d- oo_ca_use--.fa Y"edu_ce._o_cQfrtp.la:r-r~:.lo~wc!f:,.
_JLri-2..c D'::f7 _V-/Ji.C,_C,e,_g_t;_ d £,:/_e. {L4Lifh fLma1_,_)_..frale_tf .fJ.e-COI!rmy-,-fl.,._..f:,_i_o_$.1 Y..P-..,_CL-,_J?,_
7TKl_-!:b.,:s_/f-I.VeSdr~a:flo~-.,:e.po.f~_c)_f4DuJ'j_.s_b_er:if.f: V.o.ace_/J,~lf_.set,~d-~,---------­
__Th!l.._CP..cn.f-la/r-. a.o!--_Samoo_&_Go.b~_c_w.e.JJf_-l:a_he:r_res_,~clet\ce.._a±.L1.~3o_etrt,_rt, 'S- ,:s __
_ _(J_{J_U Sl..l a. ( £or Ot'!:;j 0 >Je_;_~ loe._a,f_i,h.e..;_res~l~~-e_..fh .. ~ :tc'~~o.£xla~r_Wb €.1\ ±he_eamt1)_a_t:~-=- -- ~

_--=:=4.D±-wAS_d.o~v..~~OfJ-U.fL.J:o_f:b.~r_esJcLen. ce.._s~..s_a_w_+-61!2_-fca.~+-d.oo.v:..u.!as_apeA-o-ff.s-Sh. ~e.__
--g ~-c/_Q$e._t~-be.~bo.c..1.S_~S.he--.S.O_GJ_a_fJ_Qd(ji-p/ckuf-;-1£a.~_/-r---CD!otJ-Pa-cl.ce.J._{~_.fCoo-i:
--":f_f:hkiq_Qu s-e ,_,5_he_6_ocLneve_r:__s ee.t:Ltke v.ebJ~c.le_Jo~·.fo_v:.e.._*~e._fb~o-sa W_a_~~~~=--_ _
_ _ nz_c,./e._w.a.llc/.og_{Y:J_£r-a~-lr af-he.J)a d_~ p.lckvJl_W. ~.fi_$:. o rne_lat1_9-Jlla.5:..1~t:\-b.c5_ha.t:tAS_, _ _
_ _:rbe_<Mb;_!eJna_/e_u.;_c':/:hJ::.Io~Je....ha}t:..d.~oiJreJ-+b.Ltj(lnf_/rf::LtCo,IJ+~o£.-tk.~_D.a.d~e.-p.~-·'--
    lf   '.1           f r    L     •(     '-               1
_ _ pe_t~:~.ellj.u~~-~-r:~to-V--b~e_ver:.s_s_e.o-_+_o_f.l~a:'-r:&Law.ct_1_,:__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
_ Tf,_{J_{c.S-.u:.ma:b'f:l~_ho_r_d)-'j_i_'dectb.'fle.()_f_kaJ_-f-l:,e_wb(~~-tno!t-w.(.tk.._~_/o.t?d._e_~a.t~LuL~~­
_{j o11     es     buJ_c_e.ck1-~1~_d_o..r.a±.p re.retJ...f:.a~_:_fa~+-+-~ fLe_J,..; b/~ male_JJJ/l.Lbl{]nd.-e_h({_,~c.­
-h.aclca.m·Lo_ur_()_f_-/:b~r:e>_Ldea~~-&la_fa_c:).._f.J,_crL.J4t..io_o_,_j-u.lls-:-c_Qrne_uo rn,,..[os.t.de._ib.Lv:.er,'____::_

_d~n~L~---'------------------------------------------------------------­
_£u_r_tbe.L{f':\_f_he_r-epo.d-_\lao.ce_/l{(_L~a_,~~L~,-----------------
_ __!_Th..L.!.!!:e..:_·,d.~.'.r±ucb.ed._lJJ.eQ.poi:>!_rL.V_Q_n_cl_h.ou£e.._Q~_weLLo_>_{h,e_s:Ot.{d._£o_af~cfn1--.wer..~--­

·--f-hoJ52. 9"-(4.f-h.e.&-_b-'1-0_e.(Ju~_Af_8:.o.l._N.ta_J~dwt~.f/a_6Le._p.vJak Wft£(L_f-o.c_et_-te.<i""-------
__ Jj_g_oln_t).o_.fa_t:d-_-f-b~;;J-J,L'tiLMPI.lt_Mth..Io.lt7•1cJ'e_bo.,_'c had bet0. f n~/de_+-be_r_es,~r1c~~~­
_Lof_i ~_Q_q/eStrJ,-~-~~ w h,_/.f:e,_(j_/lJ haf_b)oaJLb a/c, Eve~!j.ft/rtj. Q ~uf- .flt.Lr:efJo_{:f_p-Q_~cJs_~_
_ L.o_v_"7_f:Jo/LSroff11.,·------·- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
--'-I___,.-U=-r__{h_e.c_{c._.fl-,_Lle;:>12cl: \La.rxe._s.-1-aied.!.__________________
_ _Th ~_Wrof-J.aJ~_a_o::i-'_p.U_l:sCJ-~_dt_+._~_sur..peofs..._n~                WLffLq_ffBa-r-ed__jg_b~+-1~ on&-P e. don~---
                                                         .           I               •

_ _ /.n_+.bt..cp1~1 _11:£-_co mp)cz,~r:~a.t~~fJA.cf-e.A- i.he...S:V.!"~_s:o..t.J.:fb_on Jj,_~_.;l. 79_-f.o :+l:,e_ _
--~G_c-os-_v_e._o o c. a (e4_o_nd_obwtLSa~C..oJJ a~_c:oa_d_s_~_Tl:ttLp_ur:.s.ulf:.-la sleJ                         r::e.\Lea:t[_ __
_ _fYlltl..u_kJ_o.n J. f¥_s.u1.pev-Lwas_los-k._;_~_-l:be-_sou_fbeas±e~'-Lpo_r.:f,_~c>-oP-folePIO/.I-CO!.!.n:I!::J-"c..__­
_·Sf,~LLn..o_p.tX" ,r +~~ve_/de&.f:l£~_'ca t{o,... o/oouf_:_u.i-,o f),e_W.ht1e.!mle_w..llb._k;joa:Je_ha;r.:._was._ _
_ -:U,_o,J--;J~"-"-~P-u_/LI1:o_.ff...Lp.s~JLa..AJ-"-d...rov:.e_cu./>Jf!!:j.,. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
   ·               ·    Ll                                                                                             r
---1-Ls:.har.:f-_r-,.~-iai~./ "fe'>d.a:~-Ron9ei-t3oJ:)by_Gl(..c.t_b.bs_f-oc.a~-ibe-J:.U~~ V-e.ke.Ue_Jlea.r'----
_/3_atJf-S-rUJdaS,_rbe.._der;u,:k~s.urpecf_:_W_as_cl,;_;;~vt.4-~e-IC.el:../c.{&~'_/3.-!d wbofYI ancLhQ~.Lw_Cl£._/                   .c----

_-khLp_ecsun_d.r_.~v{t:tfj_fkf::-V.eblcle. QLibaL.f,:m_e_w_ar_c:i_e_r._cr,'keJ_i!Lb~~tJ,~ S~ped:..:...W.hl..~-'='--­
_(rUJ.le   w t'f_b.._f"'_/oacl_~bot.'c_,l_bf2f_o_pos_H/y_e__[ded:J_j; f..ai:Lo_a...~S:et11cuJ +b~Gs2 be£ 11e.ve-<.!._r_ _
_a vr i'veJ.&t:. ±t...e_CJ_t'l'e:>f_    .rc&~e_-k_     (J.Of {b~</e. ~L/d&rh_~~-P-e;_i(~6hi'J€.£_-k_&e~the         o...f..N-e:..11!o:~-
-~-~Sfl..._hlfOndL bo_,'L_(/'}_ ho_ck.ove_b£/~fk-vebl<;Jeq._______________
    '-"' J I     r  I j     (      I f -~('
_ _ LuCtbe'j_.!_o_-p:.i._i.V).Yesn.9c.oLo.t:\.-lfe.f!o..f_'I Va           il ,,, Si <
                                                          ..,=._ _ .OY!._If.,_rr__Q...L
                                                                                         d-( . - - - - - - - - - - - - -
--=w=-6-~_LcJ,' Ll_t:tlLwa.s_a_~r:_e>-kJ--_o_-Ef-_fc_er:5_d,tJ ~(Le_c_p,_v_cL,_al)_d_et._d,~.,-;k_~ti_~"-
           '             r     \\
__sy:S_r..e~_~Lec.ej~e.'~---------------------------
__rher.e..._oce_o..o_..fc_c.t_o_£w.hf(;)_..JJ,e__r!)_ff,_'cec..war_ldx:if_)aca/_eJ lh..e_,~..f_emr_o.~ eveLi_W.hl!/P_ik_
_{{~~S-~~~-bca~r-------------------------------­
_ _The,-_-e._s_,~l>:l p)f_no_fads_{c:,_fbt~~-~~c-Y-es-f-/9cd{o.c:L'f_f!.fJ-o_"-~-+-l:u?l.~p-ei:.c~a.t:Jf!X_Carnm,:..tl..ecL=---
-._f- )_, ~f o_-c. h u.c.~_ler.~1-~a_h_o. b, 'kl:r!o_~_fo,.- tb_e.._p.co.secYdinj-cd:to.v:Y2~-to-euec,_m~&__
_o.__{Am~ Lo.,_,~tJ±._f)_L +h_~_b,_j)_s_r' ~j_gLJt-_D_~_'s_.fxct-i=!l!:to.~~.:~t'1-·Crat3_1JJJ.Ll~-~m-d-"-~'--.s_a"'---_
_ CLf?J-W..a_~_,. /ou_.f <2 v_ea_~_.tbLCC2tn.r.!aie~d=i~defe.cJLv_e__f_U)l,_,~[e._fb_e._Cv mp Lcu:r:tf_/Yl.~_b_aCL.e_-f:he__
_s±a:l:ulo:r-:J--'Le£{-t!j'~'e.,oo etY.f;_foLP-r oced_u.r_o./~vo L{d/fs:Jr/J_fqtPf._·fJe.._YJ_eeesLo..~-~~YJ.dlc/q_of:_
_ cela 1.::. i_/;~_d_e.ro a.o sj_(:A-tJ?d_b'1_.fa~..f.-s. .s h_o_LJ_j~v:J~-fJ-'-o bo_bLLCo ure._..(;;.~_i~-~-fYJO-j-Js:f-cQ-1£__&
_het.V-t_f!?. atk_a_p.v:ofg,r_ev.aiuof£av:._-fi2L_f.'v..i_aLle'J.a_ffons-b.&fo.,e l).iUc~q-f-k.e_Cd;..t:.C(A.at~:c~
  ,r I       ±I
              r.... -C a     rae         L
                                      .L r.            _/ ~       r£ ck.l/;/.-. ._.;, __ be r
-t-S-'-A- -~.e.-~cm_~-- _c.~a-1 _ _tJoJ_I.(___r_ttpp.or::rL ]-CLr-r-t- __ L_J__   ~  _ ·
                                                                                                 \,;:;7
                                                                                           t~_IJ_ -;;r-(}xxuov..tG,_,
                                                                                                                             I-,,
                                 7
_CflJLsLss;;J-~.£rf.{_J.~-~W.l'4p-La./4d:,_-kh_e_g_cd£-i:. of-pe..J:,~ft~o.r:er_W.Ok_{/{£9_a.L - - - -
             .             (                 .                                  .                  .

_-rt_e_camplca.,J1d-_fr_(!A.cked l:be_~Ja_f-u_f-o_~~Lq_ng_uOt.tje.-S +ec±f:J-~·-·-._____
_ g E;t:QiCEIJ2t;_1J..e._ul!dec£,:~1!1eLLCl¥dbr:u:)~_per-I<2Q_o,i~_opp.eo.LerL                                 j
--Vao~e Hi-l~----------------~------------------------------------
 l.,ho _g·:t_:i~.
-w.~               b I ,
      7 _ _"1-!ff-_ e'-Y-1!)-IOY-rne-
                                        cJ."              . .
                                         _u...._'j_stvo.c...o_a..r:J._o_ o:i.h ~I                 d         1"-rt.     { h.. r;s-:ff-o~r-e.ctso.r.::t-~-
                                                                          _ __r:J,ep.o.r...es-o.a___<J_Cl:J·~-~-CJCJf-ne...         _I

_be..l,~e_\le-_aacLd.oe.r_be),_e_ve,;_f.hat_ker:eio_~_:_..J,o~tv.lJ.7-oCJ-o.~abot.el-.f-k.e_L~-fh Ja.'1_e£..r:V-r.J.e,·----
_j_99.~-a.f)cJ_be£~-ik_to.o.k/r.g_ocrL£r~/,.~-eC-f-J.k_co_mf)a.!h:l-7/n_f:he_Gzl.lf.\+"1-<£ B.r:.owPJ.._(i./).k_ _
_1LL~te_of__~~as~--------------------------------------------~--------
_8.ltl1_tbo.__r:_fe,_I.J./~_C,s.1J::tere/oa:fkr            sJy-/e.-1_CJ_e..£efldo.aJ          ________________________
                                                                                          7
_ dkL+-k,ec....a.o.<:l fh~'"-ird·errh~o.,..-,Qj/'jrw.~~fbo.~ kb.e-e.P-fuf.SL.e__catJ.s_et:rf= e?£ Sqma;:t-Jhc..._GoJo_ec., ___
-~ e;_o_u)(l_e_r"   th ere_f!f>fTeCJ.feLQ_bo...hLfo.J/.o~CJTO.f).cLcftJ           a:tfe.tYJ-jJf_fp_c.Q./2ltr:ld OtJ.cLcoMfYI.t-!f-li.~o*--

-p.t:o_pe.c.~TOCl.l!?ely-!_a._\L[~_(LSo:te/tr..'i.~-Y-ec.e£vtl.rTO~-d-tj-VOS_LJ,Y:~f-f-h~ fitr:uJt.VLCt-20~--
__Q:f ±he.- Ob.l!J.ec. oP.s.a.,~Lp.-:.opeel-~rl)omei~.!-_Soh1a~Jht:(_Go.be'7--------------------­
_fd_9_Q.,~od_tbe-_f!eo.c.e_of'Ja~tJ~~-n''*J-t:>-LI:I:.e__5_fa_-/:e_~·-----------------------

_:f-b.er-e..~·S-'-' o gf.{e4a--b.'ot:\ a bau-1- b.a.w_f.h-t_p.e.i:/_/:r.~_(le._[_C_o../!2./!J• 'li..eL.j),efl-_o_'C-bow-~-- _
_ CI_f±.,~or:rLca_me_/:.:J_I:.'-~ve_s_u~_kn.a.w..le_d_9e_~_S.ia.fe-lL_,_If?-a.c.-b -~_i33_i_U1~.3J-L,;L97 _
_ L~_t_[_rex_.._Cr.c'.M-·-f-JPPt_Lcttf'-)~                                                                                       .

____ .8_\LaX.t      o(l£.e   be.../-w eer.       ..J.k/A   fQL/!1 rxh 'c110_Qt1d..    f:b_e_C.o IXIP-la_,~ Q.t:l_VJj,_C)_t~f-t--'-C._ _
__bar.eJ Q_c;_.)o_f-b:e.~.-i:he£/-__co mm;~#ed._;~-Fa:l-a.c/--fo_:__f-i..L~&)/ct-, ~-~~~{o_.ff2·£____ _
         f-'Q f 1 - r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - - - - - -
____ /]1g_t
   ·-r-l. .'     -I '     I I         .1           b· V:
                                                   I J 'II I I ~ ..
-LKJ.fl- I CLI/.eS:t:.LjO:tl oc,_x_e.(J-0~-ga;(!_ /::t.Lf_f_.S_Ta.teS'-"..·--------------------------

_L!J_bfU\.lJ.I1kf.nLu.J.a.r__O r~es-fe.J of£~etr. /slm-te.J a._v_c_~;_otldc>_d.,_~_,iaLsad£/&.'if:....s-ysie~YJ _
_    c_ec_e_Lv.e.c:~l:low.-e~cno-fack_a/::pr&t__u.J_f:er..e.~_th.~-:-1-ef(JL            we.ct-kcodecL.._/3.Yi:_u~-+h.e..,_
              1 (      r     /'UC_f    l •j/'J    r  c_         ~    f'l            L 1\
                                                                                      r   /_  f      .L ~
                                                                                                     1      r
_Co_f-b.p_I~.Lo+-::_Lr.:.)_~r::p_c_eL_f3L(.{.;)~J1J_7S:li:IJZ.ah OQ_p_S.( I'itallr-__· I.J.Lf.::Y-f-l~T....;r-JZLU.CK)e.y
                                                                                                                          Cro..t j----
                                                                                                                                 (
_LJ__u_fl( ',.n.~tr)._Cl/tlta<!.--_-/:~:£--i.!:JfoCI!1ait-Oo_fo~_cao_cL_t:1~-
          1    I.               I ·I _ r                 r             J ·            1      _I J. rc _±b_
                                                                                    L_ .ac.rx:re_;                         i_ (
                                                                                                                _ e__\L_e_ oJ.'cJe,.--
1
_w_a).._o... vc R.7_a~_d._o_d:,~_'JoJL.sodel.l/i::e_s_J:fs:M-Cece.,,~ue.c.,._lLf-r-o_~c.u.H~_c;r.tf-oc~-­
-1~~-rJo.f_a.£.~-+-h.a.c,_z&_k [c,.s..--lt~p.c.as.,e.c.ui~ro/Jf:__t~C.t::>_~~-C.t:J_LYi_upo.-o_b,.~[_,c,~fJ­
_e,tvJ~ac..+_t>r qf_k,_J-_(;_~~-v_o_f,~--6'<2~       0 ne..~m~_pef_ 1:..~ h(J_-th_ihe__aCLur~a-Ad­
_-f-:_be,_Fl?-r.:Qe-~-for:_r~l)..-£e.lo.'j-Ca.f.es_1_2ee:,._f_~-ft.c~Q~_\J_/_s._b:Lie..~Z2r S _bJ ~ 6d~9- 3 :;__
-9-3-'1- -35 L~.-C.:rn,_j1RC-;-L9-~-~-t~---'--------------­
_&e_couslk ibe_p-t:.ose.C!tJ:l'-~-atfc2f~l1eJ~s_ti_f-~b-~-P-lead{a-9-'~a_:t:be__ ~~at:td.c~.!.u.C!.j-_­
-lru:ld_~eof_troc,keJ_-l.be_s_~~')-lal!J.ua~e.,_.fdv_ro ±be_c_,o_mj2Let[etf_and.-~f:1ve-"-p.r:..e»-~~.'---
                                                                                                      .
 u/:; ~~_ct:tf:oo2e:J_'K::ei~~-f::be_ce cc.u_r_er · .fo.L-{be_p.leaJ~5.j-tLf1o~_f::f:,e-"-CQrnplcl"..af_c;:ePt.ie!.--
_o.._f'u_o..dCAfr.l_errtal-''1-d~e.-[rJ_c!lvf~n±/-ti.Lic/a}_cow.J-dllrJ~kve-;;J;_l.lofd/ctlo.a_
-f?      od.--iv_4_t~ (EI-t'l/ot£LJ_.Jui/_+_a&_2P.ah_'lee_h.t~ k 0f_r-earr ~~~[f_(:~_txJetth_ __

____u}Hf.R.EFDR.ErP-eH:b.'otler pco.!:j_r;_-thM. :tb/s- Co_u_r::~ 5-ca'!:f.-_o.ad_/ss.ue..._-J:htLW.c'-t.e_Qf_(e~ar:t ~:____­
_e_eso lve. -1-he_~d__lj_P-~r-e:r:.~a/o_(ry_f-o_p.e.t;[.h'oogc'r-c_{/le9aLa r,resLaa_d l/.k;a.Lc_coyH/L.Cir:a,_,_n_,____
__ b_e..c_o_y re__Q}'-_:_Q_£f.1~1!:1etJbll _d_e.fed&E!_/fJd,~e:imeaf;.:___ ____________
                                           1
_ 5o mo_\Le-A_a_o.,Lp.(a;e.J._oC~_.f:h/Lfbe 2.5 cLa7_rt:{_· frla y -.2-0/5.. - - - - - - - - - -
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ /l.es..pec-h[r..t/17-Sufomd/ed/'--------

_ _ _ _ _ _ _UM.Sf~bf?J0_0.£_CL./J((AfJ:Q.f:::!,L_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
    x;    !31fll-'r-LJl//(las _hei~-pr-_eS{!f}_f!ty-~~n-Ca.ccecafed_c:t:.f:_/:.be_l3_c<M.b_(o.u.nry-'f-Q.tf_LfX_a_
                                7
_ w.,_c~m".!:.'texc..e_[Sx.r2Wo.~d.--i_n~-Zb!60/-declace.r-undeL. i:h.-.e-pe4t::t-1-f;-o-f- -,.oe"] ((,(lf_j_:_f-M--
~+-J.~~&r-e.rpl~-f-eJ/lto~_f'ov_(;J_r:,~-~-·[er-_~ar / {s_f_r_c.Le-:cw.d.-..:.co_c~~f-:g__·_fk~b.e-~_:f-_-~-
-fllj-./rJlo.w_f_e_c1LJ-~ •
---------~-C~--