Court Opinion

ID: 4053052
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 03:02:43.971458+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:26.715128
License: Public Domain

' z,qg<@-/§//s{

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

. n ` .~ , 3-~"7- /5
l:%M`ZSé._-M nn /)
027 _x /23€)§ :‘:M/M
/z//@ egv//
PW DFMLI l~¢`¢ §LQ/W
‘¢/\€»3 9§¢`/3
¢M~S 284 "/
]/”
J’;L ¢M
WZ{, umw

3651 /.;1’/

 

lam laws/dp Sem C>~¢M:

Q/m£,< /\‘vw 745$#£¢‘7/‘¢/1,¢§7 Donmc ,(¢L §w/M. /15¢£))¢#?‘7£//<
O)QLL£D fi'?)‘f).edi>/L /4~1) I`)L£s Zlé- 74901'£ $`r\/),)$D )9¢»19 /\(umr?£/KSL’)
B»?)EF fill ZJ[, nuc»h/;T.j: KEM:IOH[ 7~,‘|4/17‘

'+/.

l \ %h$ H°WM£LL £w¢`7 /)[)9»5' quO)CWvN Q»€Junu7 Z> 7_€’(,/,/4,7

. 105 gwen 7;}£ now 7);‘197 ZJ£S (;m€`f lL_]IK J"¢g<\§mc;non Ol)»¢
14421,_/]4;7_/‘1!££444 (` 0 -/1,/>»2 r /4/\.01.:0¢41»0"5

_ 2 f ar l

'_ _'-_Sj_ua ,eljé_Q/;_"Z¢BS-€;C&_‘Mé/_/\Lw /§)f/r£§ Dé¢€n/l; nOL/?

C?f: 7 g€m-( 712¢14(_, gem-1 C)Au~f£ ('/°r Ac?'/D/"\`/ 640
¢£LMU_YZ£)LM_ /\1»_7_£/&12£_€21.¢5 _ 11 rowan 7 A¢-/ 7#£

l _ML£€»£[:£_ 531%&/12#7 £L\/ :7~ h/m,/,/ AF?XE£,/ 97;` Z`r /f' ZS//é
_f/vnva:; 621/17 Wi] 4:‘¢12¢4 _7,4_1/5 7;Hc , 7 if)( j `Z 0 L/mv
Po‘»|mjuliu mf ]\ Mnfk/?._`~¢6'/ >71/ 3
/771 7/1»:1M)U Zl AH»UV /M! Sum( VQL,]E/Fl pen YD“¢I AIL K¢/F‘U£/@ 3
76 /V)M1.2W FM..,W §7',11/ 7&:16~3 “ ‘ ` `
6611366606.;13 19 16/65@{166 .:'Z'M 722 3971:_1'
,D/g»z/m`"f 6~16`72 g-Mr~iww@ mwa 764/145 CL;!L '7¢3>
/a/O ,VW°MTHS famer fmb ?&)H¢C Z»/m¢’”’@ 17
WAS. El/wv\ 571*”“9% fdc/0 807 }}6/ 10157/¢6€7 33 _
147'70¢44{;`/ 505{:3?/~{ /D B#;wn{ lD?D N¢‘;` i/(/Pu7 370 \
AL{OM/ l/y)i; 7 /'79”£ M\/ €st/ /`!14‘44-/'~/) 47 7/41?7
` .Fr'» Z/é_, 0»732€1¢/7 A377WW£\/~3S JFF./Lé fbi /1/
Mv~'/_ C/Sé M»ll (5>;1,666)64,, 7/36)0)12 6~6167/~0)\13$3’
70 6901.,\£&»1-7~3- U/L- FO¢U>/l/+~Sé. mi 351/1774 70 2
33[£”/¢~¢€ /Q gwwew\m 0~17 @F'~ m@ H‘M S/M€é'_
7;46 0)5-7¢16,7 /4770/¢4£73 66le /79¢13 ll

.,_;).__

.01@07 1/11~116, 70 796 D1s71c1c7 Clé/»<_Ks Or~hcg 17
1016 111 flaum 20 /4111»11 776 1>11=711111~' cz;mh
566/1714 0017 710! 1706 4\/)311110\ OM lh/h /1/1@27 440119
510 71 91116 71 1101 017116 77 001 117 011 /)116 _
win/4 6\¢""‘3` (44“57~410%‘,7 1 1414va 1407 FW\/ /4‘
_4)€€9~ (41»111107)\1»7 /06M 7»1 709 5‘7)479 UF' 7¢0‘1`45 ) 1
441011 W‘j 74£ D).W,aw CL€ML 7& 776 bV/flb7 U)\¢g' L’F
7/)% /45;¥/57/71117 D/wm? /4770~W€V5 .Z u/¢m~/

 

AI:L…LLLD_Z£:B& WM`] @MD 447 777 017 » 4
» 44§7 d¢:uwcvmw //cliwh . @N.D E‘/<£//N 7141&` W)H N'/T,
4000 540\4<’41. 4;;/)¢7 2 5771/L /5/)9~0 441/71 /B”E`/€N
ij|'L7F,D1UEK W444 l.4""7 7/~/€ GN)y b 43'47¢1£7 fmj

 

.;7‘-1 6‘/‘4}`/$’\“4 F@»H"{"l;f Z Wv"b 447745)7-1_197/1¢¢ /0 717/iv-
/4 /4001;/11\ @'11/0~113 447°10.011/071011 /q'w 1 477&$ 405/0 Zi77“7 '

 

7 ]5!,£, A //,07 Ag7~()0n11/\C7)vw l¢/{*\l7 4%')¢61£147/111~1 ~71,_,,
776 554 D157/1107 501171 _Z 195010 DWY¢ 4/1’~175
411 /’11 7001 011 1111 0111,111_111 711/011
1417 510 6111111_, `-6 7116 ' 111/117 471>1177117
601 776 5 75 Dlsw€ln 511 107 7#£ 01§71<\07 CLé/zl<
57£»17 77 Awg)¢u< 7714.71101» 714#77/1‘/>¢& 23 /\/0
lum/1 1911111.. l~` 711~1;1¢ 547-44 1907/107 60071 7
6130€»/6 440#)~ j /4#£) 7 po1w7 747 7)4#7 Z/£
@1116<7101§1 `~Z`, _7,116 4007 fw 75) “who WA_€
 7111 £1116 71117 5°61171111611 711/017 11/6//
7701/1071 Imb£ 511st 721/2- CiF/&L 73£0 m§§
,.. 777 Z lc/ou{) TQ&nz" 7/'&§ OHF 7""'#65 747
576 111/0071/ 44$`51¢66067 576£ - 714/77 }ML/

._'),
3"»

  

. 1/1/,/1475 K/_SK.'£ KM£/-wl /:/l/é/O. 7 0919)/1(’ 1949’7;&,1
2141¢21¢; 1211!<1»33 @1 fm %111 ;::u< 59/193101;5
MAS_ 3101@1111 191/1111 1013217 7/1317 -
Z‘/£; 397"} D)r~/_1ch7 5911437 910 Lme¢/L /'~¢)¢4)

7 M/ow/ 1¢371>_~17 /`1[514£1»1 71/11"14/¢1,7' )4;1) 2111 /CA¢V
7//*)97 Nw 713/a 0)$7/~1£/7 47711311£34 [¢;v¢U KWLA 01/7
911 MHI:¢‘/ /1’7£. how 9 934/17 101/1119 61` §0)»[3
1111 111/3117//1 1/§£ 01¢171¢1&1,7 /1 251 714
653 jbl)¢c@)%, 319/117531313 (/11¢41-§_) ¢¢drv §M)')MW?
70 CW\( Mt AN Aw%a_W/A"H{ ZH“:Z`:' 351/79'4¢'/5_1%£
OL¢R'_/ '7m~1 1 w~l/wv BE/';r’/)c£ 11 311/1171sz
~7~~4115'47 Eu'-/ ~7 /YXAV 7/`¢£ _DJFWCUZ/) /4~7’2¢/)9»¢¢~*/

.l¢/P~s 19311:7 1317 %1£ 5211\/~1 11 7111 63111/~19
_9w0__‘>`é~/Na1é¢v7 p)}AA>F know '7)1117 l AM/vzlo\/
1994/0 53\1/18 1914/3 711/5 AM‘FWM/c)¢/% 917 Mé"
/waw//) éQ//"£/% 2 L'/U\o`/p/ nic/7 AF“/‘ML»O 7 1947
,7);/'/( /¢1171'79/)19¢»// A()A/M 914/11 6363'7 414 Au?¢)wf'?'¢(' ,C,nté
Sfmf~we»¢ ; F"Z Z¢é/ 145`3’1!`714»¢7 01371¢1_07 /¢W¢/MAV

5)9'31/ 517 2 11/,)1;,2_1?%3 01)_1§: /-1121;.%7 2 _ZzL/,’)

 

 

 

 

19wa1/xi ' /W)E `,/ é~,/'M 1411 Zé_é 9%17
/M~»( /9[1: &Z/ Wl\,/ OZ’H®;/,Ml/ 1574:7 7}7 ;w»\/ HF
7111 `@1./71¢31€7 §»L /1741‘713¢ On_/ 712 1”¢1111:/¢7/$3

 

M/a.¢bb~w 1 ~3/9331) 2 5391: 7 715/m3 Tu/nfé
. 14 9/><4’77%/ 5/111€1/ €1»11%55/01\/ 1101/§ 719£ 7
/wa l 1910 9 1911/11 7 791/3 /'V)é CLEM
. 0\:1'7` 7)9£ 3 931/779)»41/1/11171ZA ]OM;QMW`/ /'VD%L
@Z 310 79~11»/)11£5 Z 715 ‘ 6%°'7`3"< 2\`:

l_,

' .WM97 711/il /7//1'¢11) 119/o 191>¢21'1)1/0ry ¥7`
WA»S %0 719/074 /c )‘1im /<17>¢13 1 Z)_v/Q 17`7'
CH’O‘W /1/m3\1l/`p `7'5 /10117 WuH v 711¢;_1§¢&111¢

W/M‘QQ__ML 191 -‘" * @£l@_'_7
jv'¢ _é/Mlalléljzzéé 1447er , 1»in 10 'W)F_e’ j 110/nj ~

611-17 714/il 1100)¢,7 11/)4£1\/ 7111l 791/ii - -. `

)9'11€!0//€/) AND j W)<|'_§ 571/1 olv?+l)ym Z'l/IH’11 _'
AWD QN’7Y'M1M_147¢ /)M&ltdv (1)~'1. 114/771 7MLL7
32 Clk.»Mi»l/En L/o 117~119_ 5110¢3117 BV-LJ<..
' 377 Ha,l wm 1 Amj. 010 1940/ii .'
110 amc 993ij 70~/%410 ;Zv j 111/40 /Y’\/ ~'~~

. pHvu/zl Av»n M//:; 570¢,€»»1 7/4¢+7 19/$;/`

1 ,ql‘/BO

 

  
   

 

 

 

 

110wa 1 11 520/3 716 1415 01,<,,07’
J;'/MWNJ h)¢FFH/M lngi/n` YWI., 'DvXWHl¢/v/
/Od?vy ern SCléerf-Mcl\' 7410 1616\-¢?4:7"
F:dif- /1£42 501 ome/g 711#7 5 719/plo /Mwé 016
)M \1 1394/imm 411 11{1% E£l 1941007971§0 11/1711
111117 2a 113 1077 010 2 mi 1519le
/701~ /zcii Al»zllln 717/l mile ii /6~/5/
19~0 7)7‘#7 Dwel Z 71‘»,77 . 2 Mi,/:/ ._Yé' b
-Z».i g.7/!,¢’/\4£?2£. %//’771 SOC/E?\/ rim 70%7 7?@]-7 `
§/’ /71”1/<111, 7/1#57 617/11 /?i Mé
/:¢l_ z /11)1/£ 5’7’5+17 di .\’é. :o,
-- -:Z¢r> 19 cM?F/) '~ midJ’/”'~" 7/%‘ w '
pig-7 ._JB) y,zis, ‘ y :, “
"Q§i*i' '

 

 
 

   

 

. j 2d1/149 /g%r~?/ Ml_ 70 GLJ7 144
(°UP\/// U~_F/ 7/4%'/ F?%:? /MM 2 Z/A ,'/16 ‘
C 90 )90 2000 ‘ 00 4000/0 00/!§00,0-/0/0~,0 `j
-07. VA CU/\m 12 500/400000 7m0s `
%"3 7 ‘f€7 " 0‘/77 ban ',/ynv» know
. SMW' 7/~}£ le/E{LMJZF_! max/§§ ~AMV W}¢V
_7[{1&, Dssmé’? 4770)40400¢/\/ /7[)<\/;)0100//1=7 7(;
ZNFvK/_)M/§LWQM 1447/ncr Bt;::, j.-)/Zm,, ._Zv _
0/0027 4/0 ` Oé"f’&;lz~)f 3 2701 10000000
|` 7 §0000:0 :zT 1000-0 700 000007~0)100;0000~
547&/1,010.0 /fl~ bu0(:¢'/.4 /)Lé/ll firm 7,"/_404.7 20
l 4 M/l"'}°l 7/~0£010/ ~Z\- /31 Lt/.`¢Ll?_ N¢/ QQ W§J9`B
. ~.>/0 §00', 000 00== 7000/0 wm 3 7001,-/3 _ 2000 l
" 1007 03¢74424`1/1,¢1 A- paid 5000000:70»2 u/M? ,'Z‘T `
lA/),¥S 01 pf$ lumam»n-l»nv %/k,i"7 /Q`F/'L/M?'Wl/H/
MMQ_NM£HA@#M ~'
_…/7/030 0 703 = FAF? 701,;4(;/< 74,1,£
-71}'00) M/Ki"-r_r 137/1000 700 39?"_.;.0§ /4.0/0 704
U'~¢$' F/u`wt 7#£ 55`£; /du, 57 @Mé/¢§ "N;?-’
791me /Y)g: 140/00 7101 2 I"IL£ A` I€LP;FW\`@: F).Uwz
`HM\/ ffc 7//§}1/| B\/ )L)L¢H/lnr 7/££ '7400'7 EhD/ne{'
§'<’rwr 10/1`7,',1} iA/' L?LC//m/Y 74/"7¢'7 7#£ 714*
v 6 AJ;MU Z)'“i{) ]cl_.é Fr)r¢j___` A'M §<>1'75>,,»/~)/0/1¢/-
0 r 702 :2, 00000,00 75 200 _ 0
. §7)_4~74, 000 /.)4;0 A §2 /0 007/0/ //0~’7-',§;;1*_
/1/,@/'7 AHJL.¢H¢w//»., (/1/1,7}¢' _/n/ O*VZ ,[/F
_/0

 

 

  

 

757 /M/Wow£’ )Z"“Do 1417 11/)4017.`70

FM loaw/`/< A§7/~170 1 1444 r),/== 7,/,4,¢2/\* '

§7.>1,1~17444 :,17114*' :7 0/114104 0ages
I/… BF (°¢4~14-4_;0£/) [4/_1714~

3@41£4/; /h/L: ~ 'Z ,Zg[;¢z) /1/17?%)41 71
dba h//TH [4/14147 701/2"10‘-/5{€5 )" §'O_
49)/~&5'§4‘ _ /X) 514/7 A»S`/C s f"'l`/rt_ l A`)n 7\ g

 

'é/@AM§"§)M, 14 19).171140/7 ,`\`441;)/1-£. #,,,0

"`.-0:=-»1.1`;~~. ~.-_`»~'v-HW\:.~"\

 

440 11111(114,0.0 011;)0_4011__70 1100
4147_1¢410_/414:400414_~_744 1047

 

56 \71'1:§. -47 725% /41<104`4/»¢4_,131££<:14».#7:}

._.y . /)14}4071»/ 1444/1 31119`)/11!~"!§01_»7-l
"7 14774044~ 2¢44 4441¢£

04044@141; 20,_0`7»19144¢ VFM,,

 

 

 

*M/M%Zg££é, 20 05 5 211 1444 4/4144 -j%¢f)

541/s , 2 750 §~2140 14 14411»40 511/1444

a 851£1107 14qu 504 /%4 444 $`»2)11~19 1710
52))»27/10`. 214 744/1 &@'714<41 1404 %144/ 1441 ‘

im<_§/;m£-/L 61\1@ L/,§ @.40\~71»7<47/1_14./` , 2 gm §7)7/(.

 

 

pawn 70 3: ,{/%404~1 500_ 77;540¢,144£04§ _{L¢%éé;:z`

__)AL)% _ _ _0@¢1,-‘,0§ ¢1/ 144/na /L/ 7 Mf 7411/1
4<>£421 M § = -' -

. aj /1£0¢4?00?`170<1_00:7 fm 714/77

 

7,,5100,@4/04,1¢_ 2 &0\10447;0,

 

3.4_

 

 

 

.B€ §'1<+\1475-/[) 745 %Al /'77.1& §§de IA)<’r/Q/M-)»LP
7/!)177 7117;\/ 054/115 /1`777_,,.717)74, 7,1/¢4 7 4
M@L_£/// MLZL;/ /)717 d,)@ W7 477<;
`.7¢¢06/7¢,/% 747 j A/FLM 7 677 1947/§

‘ J QA¢VL LVLM`_[V_¢_’Z#Z_ WA’W:~Z--~/g¢é¢/l_ %‘HQMM&__*
145 _XM cnw §g£, /c`.{, YW 701/k ;7_1)/.,419 /4¢\//47
m m ~Z,)€Z;))(,,pq‘zmm A-Lwn ,Pu¢`? 7#¢£ S'()\/A.:Y
Bn@/L O~ nm 7 §»U»,,W/ baum/ap w 1414/vw
136>_914'4&§‘)@£\11&6»<£¢_< Flh/M C/¢,( lv¢ 6»»£. '

' 27 1117 @A/£,~D\J p _¢[,_ W;Mbn t»(B

.4 mh 7/%5 gov/n _w:?o/_‘ /c¢/rLOz/;u M¢.‘_j
_élw@$)&_m w_/é¢@_é/#S,_ Z¢M_M@%Q .é£
7,<`¢/< jam/07 7 @¢P)_~¢/Dn 711£> SHME_ m Z/)k
661/_¢€1¢;;;6_ /WL_¢Z/$’N' 7 759me /1/<1¢
D;éém. 717 jim/7 »4~`/) /MB:A

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

/ \ /\)éwzébm¢m//
/\/@WMUL
__ l)oh»ml lm SLe/)&N x pile §§
Lf‘z$]_bl /)V/V'”¢_¥~L‘,¢M 411’7" ~`

v 35>7;1 /°1»4 3505¢1,-19;
71.|_1/¢»,€(`74\.. 764 F):)?J`/ v

 

 

 

 

_ 637

 

`.'_ , D.£C<'/A /55'7/05/ V_ ,
j /_)o)ml~z l SLe/M Dd §1\ 5'7)9/7£

 

     
 
 

 

 

 

 

 

1755-75 . l
, FA£VJ $7,975//) 255 ,Z`,./ d WJ
7/%{f B)€_/,(/// v. @1<4¢¢'7
~ Q'N 7;15/5
.Qe//(’

 

 

 

C//\M,£/L 7114 pb¢/¢L/W UF. }/ML/W) 5

 

 

 

;/,/€\ ) WéMMWML/%
_-574 A}ZQMM

 

 

 

 

g 1 '_ D:WQ 5 g59)57 ‘- //59»/5’5_

' 4 4 ' 4007373 dol 1)0 /unj/W ch?/. 4 l
3375 F/m 3§0 S’W?A _ '
1411/¢5/5575¢»5 7a 71 77395’/

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

pr/>MJ£ A,FFM )91/)27

ZJDd)»m£ 1- SLQ/XWI\ D@ go 3724’7£_ .
7122 :Z 622 1222an 2412-2 722222
'7;4 lang 5)0)10 _I/c//m /<££ U)/L /qw\/ (’\/,7%11>/(
§)'§~7 "422262247242) 2/27)4 &4#2?_£/\/ 2 142 3 ‘2};»_/2~1`2__
DM:_@/K 372;-\)4 me §2402/' 9mm/77 '

 

 

.M 021/_24222)__/<125@___24 ‘>”1< 22 192 ,42;/22¢2224

M%é@_%wm_7 -_7/_42‘-/ §222_!;2_»22€ f@/L

 

 

2£\2~_7/20),§£:7__2£¢;@ ow 24 9 50 572£22/ 724127

 

722< §121222»1 22 7422 222 622227.' 7;
722 927 2/:2227_/;_€22___ 222 2622 7,;21//

 

 

724£_ 7 D27 OF . /M% 2222/§
[//wé,/L /)S¢m_/.~/i?_ 626 /¢)&ADW ' 2

 

 

/‘) /;?2:2222271} 2472 '

(/\k

 

 

1 0~0~¢&,. 1,f S'L£/l_‘h"{ ` Piw{é_
""f§$] 221 § '. ` /z/wny'£y'%M/j
387;_ _F'm\ 535’?) §0~227/2¢
lIV/Mj>.m/w/. 222 ' 7,735`/