Court Opinion

ID: 4042676
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:09:11.600041+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:28:40.311654
License: Public Domain

.''/ /:r'·.                                      A~ /_;6r>. ().(!)" { l J. 3 ~ "l / C4 p rt'ot :s ---t1r/oJiJJ ;4° --t'JNJ {@~
                       I[ ifl {( • I                -$ ~",-d 7}J/.5 3_i!Z!!. {)A.y Jf 'J1N~
                                    ' f3 ~ f~oh6 ~IS"":'                                -
                                                       ~/~~ tf-e/.A/c/(
                                                        -rt- .{3t;)__ l ( t:;-
          {op y (;611.17 7o;
                                                                  0    .          'I)                        .

                                                            /lll. rC t-lJ1e L UJ..ff6 ~ ~.6 o>< <.t:S.() 0
          -Bot&( cl- 6-1{~5 (::J 'I                           /'l?htlle.55-ee ColcAy_..... /c~s
           U.N ft6D .574£&-5 ;M/L                                ~~g~.                           .
              ~.51eJJ\.
                                              RECEiVED IN
                                        COURT OF CRII\Illi\IAL APPEAlS

                                              ·FEB 06 2015
 I
     •.

/ThJyMy Jo.IJ 6-S                                                              ~N
                                                                                ~
                                                                                    7HE
                                                                                     <::. •
                                                                                    c1      .
                                                                                              ryo7tl
                                                                                                u       ·a
          IDe# t3lJ 115                                                        ::fuD/01!6 £) JS/~!CT
                       RcLA70~                                                 &c7t}lf Cou,~,
     ·lJS,                                                                      ODC:SSA/76~
:Y4AJ Ls' .ft1 ot.G-Arv                                                         CAt.\-5~ A-3~69q
                                                                           '
 C.OUNly               c WI( c..LCA?l{                                 ;

Of EC7o;f, COitArf/// ODt¥.5/1
/6~ -~CSpaJD6JUT.                          ·
                                                           . " v
                 j>LA /f.!TjfF-> o/Cr'GI'LNA L /1- PplJCit 71dN {01( N KrT
                  of jlAAAl8AJ.tu6,
                                                                                         ..•

               7iJ 7!1£ /;loA! o~jjlc ::1LU)Ge' t)f$/1-lD c otuf-r ~
                }JIJV)  {0/vt~,- /ZJJ-ly Mt; '-::;S()rJ6:;/ Je6LA70~ P£~.
              t /J "1l1-c- A8Dlle -5L'I(i6D A).} o .AJ UMI!J&fc:-1) cAWe elf
              Ac!;o~ A10D f?Lc~ /{1/5 otfi:Jtiti'Al ,/f-fp2.t~$,J fir
               tv/.rr tffoVlJ}iJAMtt~J fJuvf~4~.Af7 70 Atf-1/c« !fo7
              .5cct/orJ       3 ©    of 7'1716 /6t4-.5 coP6 oF c_,ff~'IJ%JAZ ptf()-
               Le.DuR.~fitJD        lJD4tb ..SUotAJ 7!k-co~7lft;fi!(od~:
                                                   :::r:
          f61/l~tf            .                '
           } 1{) /.   ·-zajJy&fy:fo tJc~ ·1/) C#-/3/J. (/£' t!5 .If.,A) off6tJ                 D 6/f

 . lfJcA-;fe£tf/17eJJ 1/J 7bf& 7C~.s DcfA£7/!1GNT ~.fr
  C/tA/l.l.kL :;JLA.b{/c(£.., fi/llcH.AEL UAJ!r/ AJUD&eso»
.CtJuJJty 7 6«-~ P~ a,fJ~< ~otJv 7c.NtJGSSC6 c.aLIJ.vy, ?64s:
     7.S~86,                                       .               .                               "/
          /,0~~ /(6LA7otf 11-As· &IIAt676lJ lli5 ~G~vJcsAAJiliiA-5
A}0   I.J1//6.1f JtiV6QU fi 1'6 ~6 ~JJI( !J{ 1/f-w
J, ()3) (tit Act" _:5o,r; til         ~ 136 (jJA1P61Ied /s ,/0/l.;t~/6t\/JIL,
 ,AJb'f Dr~/?6/;~tJA~, t:c,c.p.A-Jf'/. /I.IY7 S€.d/otJ 3 Cc:J[/JN])
,A-l 6o ·t.c, c~ p, ;;). •;A r-:1 R6 Q u l:£6 I(t? f>tJ;Jt:J&vr 70 Jfo1 f£1t'D~
                                                6f
 i A'16ly --z;&1~fr "/6 7,W6 C1Jwf7 c.-f//z.ul!JIL /rPPcA/6 A
 LtJfy ~f /&16 AfPLiG4/ItJ# -(;If IAl ~rr ofII.A&45 c tJ.tfPt/0 /#e
s     6AJ/r1e-· B/JI ;VL1 /Ill t!3e R +F / 6 /J i 8';1 .S: ./1/1 fJ .DeL Ru L£ 3, 8
  /116./ll)aA'A-.AJDtAM tJf /AtJ 1 ~ Suee ~!f7'J ::S~DG-6" 761fJey·/A;Ve
   L c//'ftf &'KUff31r_x~ /fJJ.D 7/?Lc ;2 8 u~c f5 :Z:JSo £1f~­
     Dut-1JOI1 £ PtJc.WVt6!Vl'~· /<6l2U657' _AA19' Ailiw6eS                        F>
                                                                                   lGJJ 1
    A..u.D ACG.Rt/Ri:A7'c Rc;ci7i~e- :_-fbf-6 D.A76' upM toUlaj,
                 /'J.                          ~c----?i
                            wAS /UAD s 11 1 #6 CtJcJ v,c7J~q CtJt1,_/
    ..fl,j                                                  ll        ,J  -a      '"
    r tfi-11-:t rt»DiA2!3
                    (I

     t>6Cr~65-//tfltl ·/~6 A;.
   [ rJtrf A p;f~t..rti~ /tl7ttf#6f- A "7it71tt: C:t;WfL :J:L<.JJ~G':].
 A~ l1G ::SA,Ju#y 307l-t ~oi~ IJO C!Jfy                      LJf !1Jte /tffLtCATI'iJJl
 -ft1A    &JRrr   f/-A~A5 LdAf~A£vftAJy IL1c/1-1ot4AJlJufo1 tFUw
                   &T
  ::t:;u S4fPo!f/ l...r~-160 A/3tJil6 5,8,~ 161/1 g:J.~/1lvfo!bP6L
   ~uL6 3.~ f/-Ab g66A) /'?led_,. .A¢w&e5J .11- L:6!('(/f/Y47e
    t ec!rik:J 7"l-i 6 D.A-7'c tAf>tJrJ /11 uich /H-A7 -Ft~ n l/t!3 WtA:S
    Ml!iJ6 #?tV6 f365v. ·-tM-Jt.LS/11tlr76D /o 7t~e· eoth df'c;f/1'1-
      ~                                         '

   r~kL !+PP6-4-LS ~ !A-AD ·.SIAL"I/ DatuM&N!-.5 Bc-6.1\J ~N.5-
  /Vtff/61J 70 7#1-6 CIJUf7 tJ! tX;AM//It ./tfjpu~ 6f K'G5- ·
   P~N' /)6fi// A.S t€6~UJ~GD §; :5~ 7u£J te6i~7&f 1-Uo~A.t.D
    ·t1Av6 ;e6alvt.D »117/ce f-lftJA                 /#6 CoWf7        oFm~I:V/11.
  /f-fPULS·
 . ·f?.i"Z!, 17JJ! ) }5'· 1[.o1 / fiA ~/tA ~MNO ll1 JLt. of- frw /  -:J ~J 1 ~
    l+)Jt:- Lt 7 '7&f N~ /J-Vf'L6b {D -:JA..A~'~ M;ZJIGA~ cL~K-~
                          I
    5 };:-f\16-0) I).._/I q UJ IT ;V.D (W4 I Z6 .D     ofF   (.IJJI/"" I d.. I().. ;1 !It;
     E)y MkbiA~LlAAJil L.c~AL b&5k ;YJ4/L RooM: fl -S_«o}JJ:::,
    C /.,6/~J
         Dc.OA/IIt6NB tJGAC                                          -z;e1Af514~()
,)

                                          /.(:;&Li.65T@ /,) &

      . ~.o:J.f?6QIJ.65'f.5 -('&e/Pie           ~~~ tJ{ 7JIC LJnpL!/-""""           4

        ~0(\
                                                                                        .

                   . .,    ...C.                         .  /fr•  v-r£/Diij                     .
        -JY! ~·01.&r ~~- caep~ /t16MtJMAJ!Jufot oFlAw$6MA?Z-
               1

       . ~I &I l6t0    M I!D6L /!ul£ '3, ~1 e~CM[f:>i'T ')q li lA57761f
                            ':ods-,
        ~ ::Juom6 7~ I.Arve U $6N/ W rt'ti fi,vy A Al5CMs;;                                 ·
        fi LGp ,AJJD A Unt'tJc:Are 1?6c'f-1'l~:J /lf&· DA/6 LAPd;j
        fNJircH /l1A/ {JNfY~ WAS ,u4})6 ~~ /J-1/f/Jc tsy
         (V~bf-C
                                                           J

         C!Lt;Vt"fr-,           l/1,1V'rr({D5U/i:5_/h/1/L 5if'S'7C:.A-t cJ;; L
         'D6~6&e I q/M d.D ll.f '5ir7N fM/e/]Jil.D /h4/l£h tJfr
              /Vtic!JA-el u;vrl- b(:;~ ;)._~ ~oil{ &; LG(;AL '
     ·, ,. De.Sb< ;nAIL Ro&.t1-1_;p~"-'\AN/ /a Alf7/2LC) /, 017 56c·7/~N 3
             (u t:Jf//;16- c:?!JD6     ar  df~;J;;?t p,foCGDuJ'C. lieu6 ,/fAJlJ
             ,~L}-CCU~76 CtJpte5 ~tf7u-e>1~~llc_/1J.Jb l!twLr&t~A~ c~o~ v
            ,/lA c cj!A1-'/ftJD /1IIA Jl /'lJo?l L&{;:.-1-L D C5k 70 I d ;ee lA?()If
          !/(5 Lec;.A-L bu ol?t< l;Jvt5 /IA4/'Ub 1.) / ;;;..J.. ) ~<1· Ftt'o ~'-'~ / /!A/llfl<.
        w.      Mt'Ct4AeL IA/Jfr Le:r;.AL D65k /o cfc,paM:: .fr~JA-.. f<_t,Sf MfJG.rr f({k-;1fl>I2J ~7tJAi k &U6S/
        'Q,t,r@) -:::iAN~ /tali a. a!§: tf>v61€ 3~ fu,tt DAib) f~ -z,(J4tJ5-
          .A'\/rt-tL ~A copy &ftb16/fffLrC17tMl-fi;te w;e; oF
         /4A66k> Lo,€pt6 #6,Mfl.e.WDL(}1 :of )AW 5!:6v/rT6'61 II «-16 tl~
          8:1~ /f-t.DD6L              3,<(5 AMEtt;Mit':JfT /1" lc 7761' ~ ::ru~
                                   /uL£
         76;~ lA-tJ~A.Jy .;t,.u5(,.]6,-e5 f!,'tcd 6{Zi;JiJ(L1/~ ~1
         C () Vt If,/     -::fuDG£ (_ fJ rJ7'   A peo56'i_ «./W'f ) ./1.V~ II, L¢. / KA/e:
         {(6D1i}jg /#-6 /)1/6' ilpNJ Jvtit4/7i41/-./loibk!J WM
        /}ti!tl>ti (o /tJ-6 ~~"~ OJIA/'"7lff 6f';/IA/Yifi fipp6/f'l.5,

                                                                          ,-   .
., ..,1
..
,,..
                  (CR-t/ficA-7E o-:f 5 ~~ vtee·

          ::::1 Ub.fGBy C61?t/Fy 7';-/rlt/1AJ      aifr~;~tJM- A-~o CJf/6     CtJfly
       WAS 5~.-vr /o C {) 11.1?"1 CL£..R,t<) :;J:4Air5 ~ute~AN_; 3 o 0           ,t\L

       ti~ftJ7 5t&G// ~De-5~~ /&M5'.~ 'IC276/ /fM cL6;el)
       LotAls~ P6A&DAJ_~ p.L\6oy l~o~. cAPiftJL 5t/f7;~.N./
       Au~lrAJ//6-~.5;11 rt 6v /we- wlr.rrm ..5PI-?~MtL
       5 16
          'P ~ +~ Wtf!t ctf/J/lANMM~ ·/ftetf veue-
       A.t--~D C a~~               __.-,--:- ~ --~ __.....-:. D ·
         -. .     - (';             7t??t:/l~~ ·76/rs 3 ·/fkfi'cg;/~
                                    Re 1.-!l~tfY APPt/LAnbtJ f6!f l!v;f/r t1£/!A/-J~JJ/tfrlii.S fi-11d
.... ;, ..~   :~   ).·'         ;::1(      ftfP6A£5 /lJ /U6 ·cbu~'-7 7d17                                                                 /ile .5?Mc52-f04 icJ
                                66 .                                                                            .                                    . .
                                                     G-/A)d6b
                            ---
                                    -:::('/is/il6;eef;l?£ (}(2UX?GD /M-r                                                             7t-fc /)[)~lc7
                           C [BK 5/;/lftl i/v1.MEDt~7'~/.y 7(}1~(r 7D 7)-fc· Loif?
                            Of t:/1~//JAi .A-PfcA/6 ,A- c-opt fIt!~- A-PPii?t1r!J,AJ fi:
                            b.Jtfir o;F fiA66A5 C!J/fJ4S...; . M~Mt~I:AtJDti~ tJf JA-w .56vli7e
                            .fJi U :t~.- ItL/ ./  A C&/2-drlcA/c df /bfe-· {)17'~ Uj)~AJ ·
                           /NM:cu -;'U;rt -t/:A4..5AI/-ut. W/15/W4D~
                                           ..........----: t   /17'\    ·-7'1 I'!.,....- ,. ~'       "' -ii . \1) A' /   .,r. '--~i·· :   .. ·.. , •',(,, ... :'. " . .
                                       .   ~        tGJJ tA/             FiT'/:)        -?": \ : / 7     f ~ OJ                 ~--~~- ;-:;· ,~ .. ·: ·'... >   . . /':   I