Court Opinion

ID: 4235488
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2018-01-10 05:26:25.675916+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:42:37.221004
License: Public Domain

03-18-00001-CV

m ax
   bVw DHcUb                                     TD\bU\L-T
                                                    P • \ V. \ 1
.     » „K       1                -.             jVAmhW biwritT
%D^^) l\pf\\(,ftrvt .                             ^ \ . ft Aa ^
                       ; .:::: 0 2 n j   A(\f\^35, tPLftW^l

                             FDf^ M90)n\mM\ of ldhm&el
         nimm TD nmiolef.4 tou of tr3Wi\^ e.\
             ^YoOEdUTt',                                 Janurary 2, 2018

  tt)lVvt WoWOAxW ^VAht C/ftoPNi^ tDA\\(
  FoTA eb K!o\Oi lAx l\\)it\\ Mi)W"Yr
  ?^tQm^\a!i (\i??oirAN\iAV cFOou'A^jtl \o f\e)bib\ W'yYV
  \N            &(A dyiAc FC'Y bi\lf\ F-eaVVi!!! Frf-tfl Wii FTV/iYib
 lo33r\Vl>               toufV Pi3r5iiftyi\ "Yfo ^vVvck M.(71
 ff) loAi A tntt\iw\ IFD[e}iw\6. -enOKF^A e'd bfyiEU
 foiM              k^\\\ ^)0-od]. T{\c>lDrf\\ [Allilm \p
 OiF [\F^'\t)M^\; of                     3YAb^irc^^Vf^ her^f/i
^ (Xb FFFIdAM (.0 pfFz-b ^)F lhb AAoTRtJ

 KiAtll N-^hi'YllY, vJftb 0-i/mit\etl Ftr W ^Wiht dVM^u-
                l\bb(\v\\'F bf IFAAij^c/f. cn rnM
 dM^ Vj?                                     [mk.[ t\M fcuwi
 NiV A3Ai\Ul\^tA^ 9F)\Vl hi \d W ithhlM flnrt
IAIViHW!)                              VH PrDbetMVffv VhtTuv-l
!\b!?      V\b 9vn/ii^Vimi'(]V CiV iMWiic/lfTUfl^ (h\ A rnivi
                 D\ VfM of \f'i'f)0>
 kLOtdift^-fo Vk rfEtrdbii^ {\WNi Uv^bo, A\/W\\ NfVi/iiV
 G)Ui)\\',V"ifi f^Y \)c>Ai ^^\uik ftriA ViA^r bi^/kSifcAk D/v/A
              ffWovoi^ km uriAef !)V/:^nAQYii ^eV
  \il cW\ey . -tfU ,CdAe Df       . AtJtJ Ay\. M <01
 lA").    An A      .0^ ^ AHO Ai i U 5)iT)LA^ 0              OVfrW^

  tW Yti4)Vi&bTe£!i iVomi tDnbik of fW. KWeSfA Niitrim
  (M5l MC-AiiOv^CAtYibtrnnlooifi reOwkA w\\y '^TfafE> ii\l kfL
            oyiEi "kt f\imiALNvib), RnA W)V\tm sfe \-eo\-fti
   PobAiHt fof'^ckVaMik'' snuftl Tf ftwsmkk bibtmk
      -(imm          hiautvV^ ik ^\D,x5e. wA coYiWif^
   BVodId t£e>\ fvc'TA yW M\)\b.\/Oi^\iJOL'i (T\f)Vi\f imAevWM^^i
                             HL,
  At fMktYit'B Li/nVft'itlitifi VVt kD\DS\LA\ bAo\aU\\OC6
  \s\{h "T-eMiu!) W(NS K!D^               %tv\lVi t4o faiA
 OV lhi             bh^^UcVl \b Vitt-Cb'bl^'j Vpf {t[i'^/l'5
'iVw' DCft PfIX N(\Wi W»e.\ W- mWffA TlA^ViLti
 \b ?TO(TlDVc(i'
                        IL
"TVlt tM'^dfnCt l(r^Wn\'(^ VVt\)^b\55\tP>l lYlhWiftl I'd
5V\\\ m-cU\b\c\fiCi f^Y                \)Hf\ T€6ViY\j
Hi \\dib \^m                     Vo a t\\6i;v?    tiA^ci^ii 6i/iff-
itH-nV \o mm \Kf\ v\ Ws -nA \^m
oY               Rwi H\AwiOv\ m<>€tVcA           Vw.
 Vrt)te5'D.
                            ^(\(lWc.\ lWviD(Le»i{^^.   >

i:€>6MTiri 15 (\ ^YA\e                iVi iVi'\5 tASt,\\- \b a
              9YofoA\)i\i\i \\\A \V\l AAfYYA AnV WlDuU wA
V\pvil b-cY-n ^YDSec-uVf^ or tY/n^icVfd d9                 0i55ftnlr
 i^r f^tliWADTi Y-tbUlVs VOwfi ObVtXMA-e^ \hYC>vA?iV\ DW/l
TtbTir^, bS iW. AliA^nc^ uYlTfS^fA aV W T\ir\e,
Of 'Aii'TfiAl. A SeYVfi A5 tArrebaraW e>i\Atn(l
 Vd 9ef5unt>M5 VcbVi-monA-
iVit               fcK              vb f^p\ M()i(\'£.V& mmA-

 VAiVwtWt VrMi50 Ui\h\^m^^ Mrf\\Af-\U{'Vfn-3r ftdi
 '^pN' ^\b, UuA M'Vi/tn\'b lii'nl D\V1             fir^-Wle
  V\/ff?Obe cf-oyl\       , Kdii'ViD/loAlii Nt\5>M'5 9x^1b
  9vr ()\Yi^ ftiVW reV\^ Oib            jfy^MonV Abz?
 ^              Miin^ (?f             /l£?n6^115^00 of \aA^)
  n fApVun \f, -dfrii-fA,
            9cr)
           -n
                                                  nfk^Xr
                                     l\r^-el\ (v!t\!>waSr
                                            Nd^
                                    'bcoX     €na't\i DR
                                     fteeMUk -ma-:>nuz

                            1
xtoViVj                                 a m(\"Xvx ih'hwt \u Kv^^^WVitW'Svi Tvm\
                  kmWotxiVs LW\t'f kCDf^^b         1'V0\
          k\i) btxbL     \ht^k\ dV N?9t\\ftnV ftfo% ^vf%m ^\mj
            btti\u\ uAc^tV VO\\V Vi               \M'\iAfbb v^i&A
% moCTM kAVLOiYAd V Vfb\\ft\Dni D? cc.v^aVbe^e^ W
 K^ft-WavA l(\\^-t\VA?\tlY\Xk L65\^tD\ V.\k W ^" cV\LAmA^ia'^ bi                 b.

AV, /\?-P\Mftk i h^fW HeAbotUk SWfffb                                   W- VA)&b
WW ftfbfttA for                                         Xronsm'kcA Axbm^e,
            N-Nef kiftVA fib avxA b\bA%b\o V)e Crud
()\X\d \lMbWA\ ^v\y^\sV^{UiXAV, \b boAi'x
 Ni^\ft\b(.A         VtJ?Xxv^mA, ftrxAUtAlfAfA bVm
 V)t\\A3     \ftftoD^nV. Of 9\fti£ V\\s mDc&nftc \& Am
                                                 5
tMvUflJTurl, -imtW m\A4 KtmA'i am frmsb tej
 lDY\binuVfAd
                "oVODiN                          "^(aV \\fvt fNl\AtAC.£
 bV\\\           ftnA \b iti (\ (!OAAtV\DVi              \)Ut\ If5\w?^
 ?&{)5))\)\§,             [\?Pt]\M\ W (X |j>T\M\c)rfA i^€tXfA'^A\u tDyA'('\P(YmrYg\M')vW6S'TefXiipncn^i'^
   \VvtA MH\Ur\\V\RA ?\mYiV\\5"5rfiW(>\           inViev(6fmt>l
 Of^pms pmi\ l^^iAb);'
         tpixA fcSveA   \^ KvM\ixA WAyncA            '\AenV\^-
"! teXwi\ V3to \A PiAeeuhV \\i V\f«\ \\l Al)^! of
V() VW \c\eY^VifUA\iA PyKfAiiveW©) KPPfWwAV foiWyu-c, to
Mfi3r Vvyi t&w\'5 atWiA vDiYtb M'                 \\ti\ (x \^dV (x ^
 taA\T(W\^; voo^b                    Vttb&NcA Klt> ixxoVb Fortoieu).
uf^Air fM w ^0                     on Ws
 H A FreF/>nAfrancf oF        NxAfnti.^ AFfA n\i ttiA
CoufibiX Tt^u^-fnV^un FcF W\oub iVit           5 n
avhb DF FYotooNA                        6e/         n)
U^b.UbSAO? \dA                          L.EA-ZA          IW

                              (f
                  ^\(A touYi^lor CoiaAA ViPvN-e WU^sVA C)Wf\
              D'v^W K'eM\&r\\ dui\r\!i Vk\.
  0 ]\V?hU'y\\ vj\W        W WtfOnAtvemce. of i/ii eJiA-
  tt\t.e Va£ tx'UT^^tVi            vdei-b
  dtf^LUiflV. V(f\Cv\ W V\p\ t(Mff^e\c!c\^)^b N6\"vO«^^1?vl
  Tdn^e D^ CoffiV^WYMfe Atrnd'n^fA of KVfort^db
Q             Z()ihWi/\ Une)VXvA\mcA\d
                     \\\b diW^3e---o^riA V\tYmbcv\i)iV\e, ?*'oWU\-
'i VS          t-DUn^Vi U\\'9n'ftSS\l3\\Cj\ tYYwbrW         WAi\cI
           bef^
                      pF 'i(\t tC'n^Xv\\pt/lp\\ ^toaVeYfieA pF
        F'fVeoVbb          \5\c> ■mbiAYt (x fC\\v\c\e^.
                    kAitk b\m ?yb^\hib
                      ^ NVoVcii tlFcY
  ^m\ bVk'.
  \)%p^bU W.                  bWibwiVbd Vt bVt^e \M^
            oF -hi moVoA aT\i             \. \\ \ \
 1) Ttavwt^                        WT^bWl\\tA ^
 (,(\') (^ktMW                             tCuY^ \\ \\U   Vuwt \t) SWd C>var\a£.~^CT
 Vvw (ittt/nA(HYiVVOdwA^ n1 c\V\Kif.\>eer\       K\\(nH-olfioxiiii
         -^laxxw^wii!) W.rA'iV\\\5 of \f^\Aflun\tr
 \\\e. fovwii        tDiAvV «iW\\.                                    fmA^nq
     Vo vA\l\WkVic\Ai \cvt Ttsi^^s\5«n                                \jvl
          VOt/vXiX               tt/A^^cAfl««»

                           KfflPAMrt
"1, Kv£\t\lHt\bLA'lY'^^9?l?i AxA Oltr W CiW   e\A W^'%t
 f^'e\^.: -1          \aaAw W Wih\V\ cf HfSrtH iVvpV W
  f-cfeaci-nj \5 Vfwt. aaA t(KY«\                WA(>^\tAie,
(ftA.\-C\>j) t'L%\\,bt'?m\e MpXt WvO                t.pv^ Xl)3-.o&\
  ■Ui^ C\n1 . 9^d, (xmA 9^m^\ib tbA'\'^^,v^>b
                t WD\Kf,f
     AttXew UTiAef                    pf VerJuifi V»okV\t fof^ci^Ad
                Ai) OALi c^^(){^A                       "1. am ?r-0S6^
 a1AtOiftCfIxVeA a\ Vaxj tAtloAXUAWttxA ^fl£>\ S.B-dri^VlAR—

                     OA -1V\xb
lL&ifV\ Pkvtltll                     1dciV\5 PrtsenH^                      AV
 Mitinrtui'W UyIA-, G)te\!i\\« -msipz, X AYvi un^iVjU \o      itjCmiU
     ^vi)bO-t&!7 Wi\ViU VVt \$i1)V MtYlVW N/cr 0\i.b«irki Nov clMb
 Oldom (MfnA on rd.
 dAS. ^3pin9 bWftnwA I'bVfWt vin^kflf^                          of PerSud,
  fwbwftnV ^ft) ^1% li-t-f? P)% 5-VlVTtVcw^ V>               \i2>'c^l, ff,X
  t-N ?mViU) A\m\                    ta^-\-i2L Ol^h)

V)W<,W. fr^T0\M6 CDyi6)^-trei! Kff                       frdS Wi. fx.ufV
                         -Xtbd'd^ K^eX                     0^ CciAASe\'\ft
               VjWX bViC/vi      PiVc^t t-Oiv\bd                    KtvjA
f^O'AKWXt^lM of ftYl Xv^Nciii/A'                 ..»
                                                   'V\€-5>Pft)cV4l\VJ Sl/\\iM'i'^fcl
                                               , htr\-f\\ npAsrAN-X^
                                               Kr^ii-iW Y\{/\'5i4
                                              l^ltDYW{'\\ uaA
                                              3po\ s>fwd| OlA
                                              fce£M'A\£ Mmo2

   (,tL CYT-                     1
                                          /;

                           eublT'l
                        5U)0RiM ArriDKMlT
 WClA?i(\\\DH pF-BiAblLlti tD PM WST
 NOW t()inn«b, l\V(icl\ Ndbfl/llr,* 0\r>a dfcdcwe. W\f.\: 1 ftrA
 unpible \o fM tcuA                tOb^ fer DNftTe^ViM, wof \v eUa'iAffli'd
            in Vlii5 bsf, ftnri refiWfS^ Imt of lk tiurp +d fwtefd
              f OuPtrii C-LFP) Id d\i')5 DMA mh of 1fi,-3 PftSe UMi\
 SW'.
liVw- fNidwiM De-tlourAivn 15 mUt furiwftinP \o \V\t
 Of brv\ botdwvt omtl         c, c-vv^pW of ifi-e t\i\\ mtXiaJ'
 M ftomeiite Code),
 Wovn) ffbPttVfJH tof(Ub JyrAsMl^^iAlr                     .■fe'Tbtd'-(\l0 4?^l^
 ftnrf dedavY.5 V\iA -ipim MnftUt Vio PoH tc>5\ iVi PViii                     At^i     iv\
 OlV^d f£llui6-\ !\PfbiVAiMfi\t\ii ^o.pn
Cf) tOkPEl —BdLe__R5 iviib/tViiAt
(<\) /^i Mi/tl-l-W'l fU^btb art-Affri^ximftW/N ^ib
 i-             ^r     rfl^fci UD{t MF^lFa*  ]r)i>ini^]ffc^A^\^ infois^
       in JifcklMMjlii           -rtu-ffUcb M4'ArVmwV oFCfWlfisl
  c^\i\'^(/t \yi ?>ee-     IV/t/iriVi. -in os
          a^i)            wnk (%iMVl of                                       \b6 FmJoira
  '^Wctrnks m b-iit ftnd awieb

                                                                   l.'iMjf
                                                AvfltW          Nt'l'>(vi'5r
                                                I - 'n-j' I >1 11/ vv   vim   \

                                                bpol 5. grvvvM D(^
                                                fceeMAV -ix ll\H-

      q.r\A\
            m
                               ll
^fifiMvbi CCwn\"| kv\t^iv\T\X

 Ma^u' is 3V^A\i^|
                     Myet/i/Af^o
                                              'oiViUr&U
                                           kvAfW^ i4p,V7w\~yv
                                          M/J'VftvA
                                               Wt|_4|20^
                                     •■                       ^uw'A
                                      hoo[ ti.EiintVl PC.

       pVI   r,i«
                            M-