Court Opinion

ID: 4058788
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 09:19:30.572359+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:41.371340
License: Public Domain

Cour§c own `na\ \(\ aa\s n .' q¢\'§{;;,gzg..a;zz] `
v T¢“.a\ Cw<¥wv\\;._ 1535 gao ;;'\?o b\(A\ , BZM/Lq/Ag'

  

§§ ch-\£ Q\a\oc`\éx QO\m § \v\ '¥\m,`-\Q“` Aub\t\AL
‘ ’ ;z~»=--;e'¢:~~. m
§ . ‘¢ ~' `MAPPEALS
JUN 2 9 2015

§
§ ' . nova zwi€%g€£g,i§lem
L\WL\QW\§ ugmom\m\m\_®_§&_\;€mlmgg §»,m§
(RESP\>\\)§E Te T\A\;- MQL\CAT\D\\) ma \\.m umw

mo cows Qa\me\ omé\>m\ cap hocm)r paz-se md £.'\Q.S )r\\ls i\]emummjum in rep\q

453<\'\¢ S\n\€'§ (Qspc~nse,"h “/m App\ica§m se b.\>n'-\- ne \~\o\>ms Cmpus.anci vQ&$e:-\c»)\q show

¥\w @m¥ us 'Q»\\ea»s:
\‘\Eag§_

`\\ne. Qu\-o £~\JL\ a re must *\\ J<\¢\a \q“>\`\€uw\s L)<`r\' of \-\a\)e&_§ Cb<`>us on hulan Jaq of Mo.y
106511\2 l\p \`\ea»-\ marx \\'\')» ¢\-py\iw`\w #\\~m' ,n ocr\i£ec\- =MC.‘\\ . verde n.>‘. 'II>~N IK'ZL‘> db\ ZN|`S’
CW$:(\S`“ 11 usi doS\\s€N c§lc\\€ \)€`.\v~q'“\a E»C)'“/\ Aa\`"og\: dupc'\` 10'\§. Cec~L`-C¢ed Mcx`\\ waco de\{ue(?d k ~“\B
‘D'\§ `c¥ Q<\L
`“NL §-\c\\€ `\mb\&s ~\Mlxm.\nu p(dl£t‘\io“ as 0 \oc\r \v -“'\o_ £\§\>\`\eczaiom .[\"\“mugl\ ¥\`no. §*alo_ cil£&
caselaw w swpw_-\ § i\:s wlv\)¢ )r\\a\ JM¢),S\Q\Q mead \M>\ make cm work w|mhaA s\/»maiq cc p(e`\uc\im .
-¥\\L 5\1:¢\€ v\evec~“\a,\a;s §\c.\zs l)r S\A%raé d~¢`\uc’\ico“"m .{\'S Q\§a\ll\ `\\» `m\»es§iga-\e cmi magma a desense
'\\:\ `\"AQ A'pp\`\\:d\im“. A\k!na`\\\&\\| ~“na. S‘\\\‘.A‘€ \-,m\\£ ‘\,Nl (}G`\fu* \v t€q\)'\(€ ‘\\\D. b(\‘p\)\i(‘onl '\'b 5€2‘\"?\`$1 one ac
‘“'\ceQ, cbm¢bnux'x xv Cllw\\n bv{r nat \.L§C§/\u \n':<¢\'§e(., v
T’i/\¢ S\Q\e ‘Q“)¢\\e¢ dalw\§ “/u\'\$\e opp\‘\cc“\)s pc\\\$ \1> mee/ir 'Hw. \\¢C`J a¥mc\c\cck wl\"\'\ respaml¥\»§%' *

kw \m“ ms A:NAX .\..4 mag ,,\@A x., AMM»,.M§\“~¢\GA pre;.,¢uai' ,
T\m\- ~'\`w AW\`.Q_U\ owns ml<$“}\g mom-mw speculation Y¢>r \'\{¥ H>nm¢?} ¢_`stFn`F€¢ml dam _

.`T\\¢ 35¢1-\@ Wer' s~\n\e$ »Pna\ ¥\M p\w a 'ue.wn-\' anci weigh/1244 e¥ comi<:'\~:cn`c”\eawlq “sel»-a.d #nl'

*\'\ML B\Q\L sw‘\?;ce_ would mn wncmru\¥ wit mg rlec\lia\\. napier Le¢&\g Au)q swm\€c~l

md nn~\q¢¢iec@ a>_ \Je§o ~\-mQ . Counse,\ 61:;$¢1 S\o\e.s -\Mn)r \\e, ~\r\/mroug\»\\ iK\’Uuiemed ~)r¥'\e w'r`nes£e.t fmve§-\'
lgct\-QA ~\`*NL ~E¢x\=:\~x o MQGJQ, ad advised app\`¢¢anjr acci>rci§ng\q.‘)lgm\€.\ -h\e cv.“cga'\iov\ +La+ \\C yalec»
XQA “\o. C§zmg\\l€r apa §>uv\er Q_!`m\‘\' “'Q'mm \"\w,, viger§ cl QfD'SS ~me\;no`}iw\ and adm\)w\e[!g€.( 44'\¢\¥&
{n\`<\\' o‘» v\ego¥\a\~§m was c\\>\)\lco\~‘\\'s ¢`npu\'“ mc_\§m\\§\g \\(A Y€c\e(c\\ jetwer ..

\\. Ar§yivgan¥

T¥\e £.‘\~§q o$' MSM€§ respoqu is um\\;me\\|‘\n accordance w€¥\/\ £\r¥\;c.\¢. \\.b’l AF+M `Te\¢w O¢Je
\s(" Cr`\w\\`¢\o.\ ammc\\m$ \\\\e_ §\'u\-e.\\m \S amf }h> gmc a wqu ?mu(/ el dol{ue(\( claim L”30’ HS'
in QQA\'R~QA md ma~lo\\l- \i\~ zoqsv‘m'§¢ +ka& \`>' Mw“:>,c>)¢\\ Aaq. ¢~¥ l\\y\ 1013-mw sales
msp§“sv. mms AG¢\O_ hamm \>a e¥.\\`\cq§ on or a\=w.-\ im \U-\M c;,\aq op Maq .Za'\S'.

 

\°F‘J

"'LG(°)XCS`. `“Nz_ julc is ¥w\um£\\-édu“\[ `Qrc\\u§`\€€£l \:)q%vl G\z\u\) \'v\ C`\\mg '“Ao“.m A\pp`\`\ca|iav\ ana
il is wl \p<€'\uc\iced "'m i~\s a\¢;\`¢=\\¢ \v `\`x\\) is`\ic§o~\€ Cw§\ qro_po(e a de(`lv\§> %¥\\a,hq?\i(n\im‘:) \\`IL¢_
S\c.\e is §¢\ msus§im sc¢\’m ran-live hamm m\u><+ ."f\\o.\ma§v ?o\\`c¢ D_pAr-\mqv* '\ms §\/\e,e¢\‘\)“¢e_.
r@\>¢>r\os w\oer'\c> C\as$ engaging -\V\e{r w¥¥
masses \ co¢la£a\c'\cm\»s.w{-\N\ eac\\ e¥\\er \e ~\(\~n.,\)one,£‘l op one.mu>-\\r\u § L\\‘t¥\e F‘é¢§e.m\ (`~w\)€c'n Men-\
\\Qs §ecuca_c\‘ \»`\-\ms>e.s .eutc\m\c,a. cu\c\ \cs.~\\`mm\\ ". §`\w_ m'r¥msm 5¢\/\&, S¥Qle\\nA a-¥ -H\e ~\'§,w .-.~.?
(\pp\{ean¥s ¥m\ `Qnu\‘§c\§s¢> .v§\.\> makes \a‘>"-'> ec ¥\\L S~kxk.`s“ case .(s s\{\\ \`,\ Fedem\ (`uch\ us
14 C>Qvewn'\wawu)}' L\:{\ma$$} C\r\r`is‘\\'\'r\.@ 151-emc ':\S (¢\ t\b ma é¢’ \€s.\'c>‘: ¢;\{S?v,$i~\~`.un Q€o_wv\\\n,¥}ne ve hyp-
\";cm\\zs Ha\`¢ \o\‘“m S¥Q\Q W\q \\c\ve '\Mcj,'aAAcA bwacil op or ibm Aurz>m 324 %¢\;que.w\\o
um§\A\)e"mc\imc§ \\> G.SS`\S\ Vi\£ S~\n\e .~Cev`ccw\q “ML 5~\0.;€ is \“v\ a vw>c€ £L'L\)om)o\e, P¢>S'A§m amc
¥s m.\' pre.`\uéwec\ m\c'\ cm+\»?\ have (_‘o/\c@ uc.¢\»€cl a vaa lnues\'iga¥¢>n. ”

Ap\x\lcag\" a\$b ¥I\o.c\ Q\`QQGL\EST FD¥L'DUE (‘.CEDHZ)LJT\/ 617 CLAHU;S n w\\ece..ih app\fcun~l gives
cn \j\¢\m> €$p\ancf\-'\m gm SL\£\¢\ é\e\a\' in K.\\¢`_\cA xiv 61 \`\cq'\»'u¢\ ' akin €§.Q\clv\ot\`m csme _Scr\~?`s£{
\'N§\u.,s ` ‘a\o\l e'\<.uu¢“ a(“d(msa\»\€ '\\e§\e.c_:\ requi\;§e L&Sw... {-\ phcon\: QE(§ uE§T "FD{Z 'DLH§
1'~'1'"""`"'"1"-"'1""'1 --¢ 'Lr\<;`u&w`\g r\'! G¥‘\B\E)va\m~\ of ` EX\\`\\¢{L`QS X>m'>£‘{:>( SL\C~L L‘t)jll\l.\

\Ke¢e)c\;.s c§¥\ms§ m§o( ~\'w_ 5¢\\<¢@ éc'mgmen¥s ~‘\3¢\@, S%Ae invo-
Mas. C\Qeufél§\g\\,. '\\/\£\_aC\/\QS \>n>§ee¥m <§\'\m\& VGYQ.@\~M\q ¥c\¥\
Fca.@.kn\ \305'[_\ md \>\~e`\udfce‘.

app\`\cm\~\' S\'\\\ec\ \'\i$` \Je:`~;'\ibn {¢\ \*\\n.`;`(‘.umu`cr\'iv€ um;“ ‘czl~$\{\o~\ ra-`Ma{"’i\on \'A "'\ne. .Si.m_)\\€ eQ\\C[mx Al`a he.‘" (Céuu \\a\.)o..v\e:-\\ NG\&Q &“cu“\' `u\‘\:l>(¥¥\€(i_“_al\c`f`{©“$£'~
`1\0\_9.; dm§\ec>,“ `\JL '\K\e\\`{°g@\* d\LJu.-\>.n`ng a y vo\uv\\rm\l ac\Ml;sKm op gu`\\\»c`\'\\e. S\u-\{ m`\s(“ u\;+`s'\x\g,\o embr“ no'\\`m\ .`Y\Ao,\l¢l`. 34‘Jve!wa(.\u4r)r \\cw.$ \/\eu
‘\\\o.\ -\3\\1 M?re"urhd&\ epi{€.@:\"¢c C`ounw.\l £\m>ea\S \r\us a\§\> recoqn`\m;i unit m\vc\ md ~\vbv).\-' czmacp+. hal e.-g E_Scpc.r-le
\x‘)A\oow\ \"lK\' 3‘\/£>.1(1\ BQ\ (T€¢`Q_¢¢AW» lq¢\b) !\'p‘)\¢(!nm'\ $¥q\€£l \\'u permian \L\ `“\LL{' 11|&£| alde dana
“a\l -\*'\\n,a,\m\)c“ cmi aAuiséwzi ccp'p\`\coc\ aocord\`eq\q a (~\- ls remow\)\e \\\> conclude M¥Lei€ ev.\`d-s o rea~
SD¢\QX§`¢ v\’\>\)o\;f\\l'x\{` eu\Chm.ulA rw'} \¢1\»2, p\€c\A gw“q \ou-\' proceeded "\>'\'r'\a\. S€€.. Q‘q¢ FQs'rz\rc)l v. U.S.
L\su ma me agu(\\*€cr. ama C"c camden w\m\,;\\l " icc wc\mk;\r\\, swan m¥ 41 umcmlm
Qm\@\&w,\`¢\ c. \;a\.&.c had »\’b\efapp\;mv\¥] muu\d \\aue auxqu q \m@ Ap\»\§cewr\ walla also vespec.
\'{\4\\\4 cem?\d \\w, C`mcjr ~\YA¢\\»~:~\N\LU.S, Su$vcw\e, O>url \\@cs \/\a\c\ :\mc\ pro fe £‘)ar°qs a\'\w\c\ \>Q`E:cm~
\'\'\)~£c$l \\\)€a\\\\“. ““'\.0 In>fltes'\'$ v( £v\c\&` o ' Au.s'\`lz so \(c-on'l `c`s l\_p¥a lau,\,er, appl`ccan~l \`s pmcoe¢l¢` ‘ prc¢e, . w M) what
\r\o_.\\o$ \I;G. )x.clj
fpceel‘w,u> ss\`\\e._ l\r\>p\i.(‘.on\ §»i\u\ an A££`»Am£l 69 ¥c\c;\:` \¢\ G¢e.v\c.m\ "as men my\\c.sein he
up\au\$ \\> QGW\' \u>u \A!Lwo\§ mae @M cmr,\ w\m{ \uz \>\aacj qwn\{ (_Sec A'm ciam"h("'+'ae'h

Zo€q

   

:» v ‘\` ' . ' ' ' l , v .
N\Gwivzn.\ \l \'l£s gaan C‘D¢\Sl'mu)~ \\lw.mll\{ »oc la\_| rmo\n'\g ~ll\£ velwl\m cas §`l'alecl clva .`\r\ ~\-\m..
`C:um\ul:`we g,<"r\cq>l \ es\c\\g\€s\n@§ -l'\'\alrop?\leonl c>\{`e\ hc:\' make Gm `v<\le\liqen~l-» \¢¢\¢m.hq¢
and vo\wn\m\\ Qc\cv{\es'\w\_ c>‘f"" quill» .‘pse'\ud€'m\ \:\\ ecu\\§el§ erlisl\al ipc l%‘l~?cmr o\emmslml€£
~\Vm\ am am\..a\ ccc\ll\icl- ole im'l'exe$l l\ac\ a“"c“\'\v\e¢' .e,o`\dme_e“ ll\a\r c>.é_(‘.brcl&\g '}\) l\'\£§é£p\>(l» w‘\~.u.kl (\,cvm\mrc\l-€~R\Q
Acr_om?l'\eo_ \L>`c\“o.ss ~Esl\`m>m{. gm `e`\v\g i¢'\`\`@.m`\ewwk} ,\_cnam>. counsel was padded ‘£\n>vv\ wul¢{ncj
a pmpa assessmen\ cl-l>u fm :€¥\.2 ease .\nsl-ecd. flowed was wpm:\i\\$ under a w\\'secv\ce `n/~
l'\\cé¢ i_mum;\ slnl€wenl"s were walecm\ le llue lul\e.rl er\=ev\l~ md seemed la give up m\ l'\\e. Oaw.lol\on
»\\\ a@,lceé.
Cc“saqvanll\\. Cow\ze\ weld m>l move '\u mp\>w_s; ~wc>e slc¢\em.qlx umw ¥m\ll*l\ D-¢»Mmml'.
Q:.u.\\s-Ql Cl(el mrl' tl?_m\ \'1\('4\&¢\5 *\’lr\o$€ (‘_cw\m.rml's ‘lb l..v’Zcu\c» Cmt.l msllw(f“\mcm`€.`ll\b&€ CDMW:\*\ &\\m\(l $lu\( aucCl\i
ljme aq;)l'\ccm\-.. (§oc). flwl‘(coml'§ Memt>randmv\ ¢£\;r ware chselu\.~> Cl~lmg anal puer arguwnl.`)
Do\m§€l»`& ll(l~`lcl_&u\l' 2 “ _ _ '
enamel :lnlels l\e.“\d\'€<\»`\ewmm> .Cwmu\ wild leach ~l\u\' Lawno was
vo_v\n\\q»a¢\cl Mw\lc.llq kanqu ;“\'Lus laee`l\md lvln vv\cl¢.`~\v\g l\¢\nse slal=er\u¢\\x. \-\a\>'\`v\g donna .(:\'>¢4»/\v
5e1 cm\& \nave w\wed'| le uc\\_\c§w_. \/\Qr. ll woulcli lmva \e»cl ~\'\\¢_L S'\Czlel w`\“\ul ,(`:.>vrr>\co_w&lm lvl'\ne.
llecom`>\`me_. la);lv\e£$“,¥\ov'\v\q dmeSeCmcl (lclui§e!ll O\p?licunl’ &Qé_cvcla`n€ll[ .¢..)l'\o would plead
q_.,\\l\§ \Um,s\`ma ll\a~l'?. \‘lwl`\m`\l mw.l(ln/l.'\'l\mecocullilu)€ lwzn a mmolv>le Pn>l:nlcllrlq dca(qu'_\lln\.
'LA’ l:ew\sel lov&>me reason §§ch `§n`l’am`\um€q \Maw. @>uns¢| @rl¥\.o r' amcw,c{ul» a|lcll\.er'e\a`wn§.

'Tl\a blcle c\almi ll\ecl &p?\lca¢\lc gale walch wu.\cl M\ cmcm\-cwl 1.>¢'\'\\ \/\`\c FQA£\*a\ 521\"\?¢¢0,
Tku\`ce m¥. S\.u=)» p®p>;`\l=.m `\nq lim S\nh . uhsuq>brlezl \m{ caselaw.»a\sv coml»`wzs_ Incluc@,men+ l?ec~a~
u.Sv. ~\’l\n Slqlel\m Ql:sblul€l \\\:>1 an¥Merqu will,\ ur cum M¥ederal C¢e\)emwnl. A- \egalw>rdu`»q ~l\'\c.l~
we‘\.\lcl Se€m '¢fdhc,la¢l mml£\._ law l`\)l\m¢`\glm Slal£  \mAuEQ. ClD.l:(’:t\LlanlS .`“\.£.\o{q uo¢')fcl" ic“ lQO~ClS G(\\I fbmwmn Se¢/\S§C.al person 'ld
\>e\d\i).ve cw\cl \u\nw hulth S-\tcl=e W m culme over '\:edera\ ew,(l}ond d lleace'$ risk l'Mal Feclerc.\
empl c\§\\\v\\l( w lr\m, sw‘\\'a\ce. cohe,\srrenl ('FQA\ im cml\`l\{ o€ lwe siluc\~l»`m is ~l~\\a\ aplech was ladd
\\'\¢:elj \\`\S l`u~.l\ue. :QAaral .(Qn‘l'ence, wall mv\ Ovnmwe¢\ln (l¢ lim¢\l`\ se;\'l;zv\ce§ om.,.v\.»lr dcncun~ml.'“\a
glale§ qu='\\'\‘l' cuj\.‘». ll-¢F\a\'\canl was hal lvlcl ~l'\ml* l'l/\L blege ar Couvl' l\acl m wl\¢\ocil\f cum federal
m.swx\\.-“q xv¢\-QMA mead le

\\\ .Ac\ ala 31er `
ll?pl`\@an`l' respecl~€\“q \w§y\d's llw. (‘ourl- ‘~l%cll av\"o¢lequule recuch is `\mpemli ve lv pa .sl\, exclude inop-
Yee\we msislmu el O.cumd claims".- 542 vol+hene\{ w Ancle_rsw .753 md al 1018 gilhg L(.S. v. j)cav,
QS .'\O?:. Vc`i’)ol ' \323 1\3‘33` (’T‘“‘C'i¥ a \q(nll, ll\cl 0 gel;‘l'o”mef fe ro‘>pl\`oa=\l] 1&“ &l~`¢lle(l l‘b cm €u\clav\‘l`\ m etsi~
v`\` M 3 adea l:yiuxl)\o, m`\qln»\ \)e-g'\w'a\ Moppo¢lun`\l\\;l\> espch mdm\€o, le clevelop l\,`\o. ¥C\c:lunl L§\I
e" 13 mmc 1 .a \l>'~\‘l

pbgc-q

 

tr

apv\\£unl ‘&lQA G mc>‘lion gene Eu\dm+m unafch willa\ \\`\S ap`)\ic(l'l§ dn. ,
'\\/`. CDY\QLL.S'\L

. w\`>\ERF_F_oRE_ \”\’QE‘M\§E§ C€>m\\BEQEb ieapp\\om\l( p(c\\,\sl¥\¢l 411 S~\ulej response
lm \’€;\€C\€c§a \ 0.\:\¢§\ q~m' q\\.\'l))\£r cel@_c la \...">l\`\`r_)/\ apvlid;w\ w\a\{ 4)0 Qr\¥lr\€c§' ,

@Ap€&l;\e\\\{ auh“'\-\le.l .Lm.o._’(,.o .d__ _Z_z' ' \A’
©mwa Om\m *“\uqu¢m ~
' m\ aaa max
a\om\\x.$\@q co.

\`o' `C\c\L\`\'vk 1(_0 gag
` """ `“;>»/~

 

CQI`l’l llcth (>l: §_€I\)'\(‘_Q
¥\ flqu se ll/\'\\ Abc,wv\m'\' u.\CnS W\adml 44\(1>\13\¢\ $-r\Slr QloS.S M£\il on `l'\\e _zx\.d_Aay og_al.u.n£_

Q'ID\§ ) 4'D441'D\S‘l~n`f:\ Ml'c(ne\{_§ Bl"'c'\CQ 'W\ \1&@\)\» (\an`l‘\|. L&r€£\o \T€V£l! f\.).§ rl'l/\ 6104'04¥€$$` dc
mm umwa §\€¢L\e,\ 119 CDAL “180\40,,’\2@.<:;@1@\¥ \o<»;\»q A»\ ~\ ux wm wh'\em'\¢e .

   
    

/ `

ad arde_>v\o

‘~io('~l

BJECT: State briefly the problem on which you desire`assistance.

l 11\171,14€4 _l1k§ ?lD had

\ NO_.

‘~‘-`4;.

l 311 é1061/ lnc“(k€m€ 75/1{:?1,////"1

 

 

 

 

€0' rl- haw ‘

'107611`/ 1 nelum i~€r'a1191L 161111.1?$1{_/ l/)u[fl 1111 r)/@r¢r€

L/

 

 

 

"'va_'and pi`rikuo -Hiz) pc¢r.

 

7 0.[1’01$12/ De~kmd/de ~/Z/€
/ ~

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

pf)$l ga
n d rig l v 111; 374
e ila ne Uc1rclmc1 !L_/L/¢i/WZ /di y

ving Quarters: H( K 'Z/U_i_?

~\!\/ork Assignment:
1

 

 

 

 

 

 

|SPOS|T|ON: (|nmate will not write in this space)

 

11-60 (Fiev. 11-90) ` v x

  

   

l Cornp|ete items 1, 2, and 3. Also complete
item 4 if Restricted Delivery' ls desired.
` l Print your name and address on the reverse
so that we can return the card to you. .
l Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,
or on the front if space permits.

w(s\(~`>`

Wl?5 '
\\/ediw
;6:191<> l l Jllw)

\@/

 

 

 

 

 

EI Agent
' l:! Addressee

G. lDate Qf Delivery

 
 
 
 

  
    

B. necelved by (Prinred Nar`ne)`

 

 

 

1
cemned' Fee

 
  
  
 

 

> - Retum Fiecel Fe
(Endorsement Reqp;l§red(`)!

Restn'cted Del|ve Eee
[Endorsement Reqri¥lréd)

  

 

11 1. Articie Addressed to:

é::Sll\Qr ®ng\lcicli> -C\e(k
\\\0 \/}<;‘ln>nc\ s\- Cgi,< 105)
"Lcivede inc 'lCrOLIZ '

2. Artic|e Number --_
(Transfer from service labe0

g PS Forml 3811, Ju|y 2013
Dall. 15 delivery address different fidm item 1? El Yes
lf YES, enter delivery address beiow: ~L'.| No

 

 

 

3. §y§e Type.
Certitied Mail° E| Priority Mail Express“‘
['] Registered EI Return F|eceipt for Merchandise
l:l Insured Mail |'_'l Co|lect on Delivery

4. Restricted Delivery? (Extra Fee) lII Yes

 

_ ?CILB Di=|][_l DD|JU ELBid BHE?

Domestic Return Receipt

RE@EW'"` _`
@©uRTOFCP""“' jill-3

1111 29 xiii

eni`eeeee, diem 5