Court Opinion

ID: 4071826
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 02:24:18.088549+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:20.192999
License: Public Domain

U0l~/g        "TVie Coun
                                                                                                                 ts C^'vlAM0*- \
                            "V
              %
   V

                                                             ^•g,\\a-T*A\of> q^ *^.o<\s<^AiV^V CWAv^'y-''
                                                    >Vt^ocar'^^T>^: \<«.v>>r K-e^^^T' -^t)^ ^IsocCTvpr^W
                                                  .•^veA)\^\;;.'
                                                                                               COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
          V\\\                   ^&^oj-a\\c jjo\a6(, oR S^v\ CoO-f A                                   OCT 19 2015

                       Ci OTACS      ^o^ WWvr^ \~\A(\vor t^ frv'K cWXVeHs.e Vd \o\\\\cA ^X bA>y.A WAVcv-^r^uVvKl
•Vt> •Vv^g-       \>r\       VCOur\ ^eftXyesVi^A ck ^^Cfg-Vy^^gv-rM < $ ZAP V^> T^VA ^oVvCeOfCy \^'OPc>r
                                                                      .1

                                                  jA<^g-tAofar1 q^OvA ^A \ix\a) /foMTicA \vif U(A(C\\ or^
              _0£      -^
                             XS-V'b ">i. \mxX ix \ e
 *SYAlS Vg.<: g-^VMiiVt
                     •M 'vNvOoSeX
                         \^       fx>»><£-tA \o opc-T^At/^ \\\(.y^\\){\sV'> i\\,-a^ V>^ c\tv
                                                                                          vtMt^viJu <*\ Vm *.s e- \VV,^A \\t^oV o^ AW VKo^s tAA'vq^ «wX\\es\\ «.N v:c^cX^o\. g^V \\e.^^0\V\c
                                                                                V
                                                                                        .<-r
                                                 ^          3
^(MAC VA                    S£                               \ Ospve^ \o cko VWa \ §JfPv\) VIVA "TvvA ^Qfr-S Wl
                                         *
         A
 tA-E. CV»-^\i                   ^V^i \s>a-Vv,^(jA't\'-j e^.H-e.cAuA\s g-X-V^axAs rAl\fo|A VVvi •C/oor'V 5 C&CPocOi
r.(N^CvV-j
       A-t * k_A»»Ces                               tA o^ Wc \A.o^'^. Nt<\A4- , ^vl^W -s
                                             tsNc \)'                                                                SosR*~e^'\y*>

*Wt               •Pg-O'O    ,9,) VV\A\ vce,-sOe.cV -VV-e. Xnk.g-^Ag-r'ce cfc i^-t o\\cc so^cfc\»^ ^AAaA^0^2-).,.
(^Q^\ -Ac - ^Q^ceiAg-CtKiA . "TVic <;^iAe \s S^'vA \h vW^)-o Coi^VA 0V t>r> F-r VS
 SecX                V)' Vxl pVA^j -c& CAVyi-C^^vvP Ks o^ KoQ't^V ^yMLc"iC<^ ~\ \vcMt "X.(AtAO^'iT-l
\ \\>0^. ^-<0<"C^A tOt^S Jl 0 \o$<, ^tcoAtiAcxA'^^ o\ XW tAXiA. £looe>rt>>Jvg.As Xo i^A eT^VA \t* y\Ao<"<-A^&rA's'(^

   AVe-^i rai^ otV-J e>c\s\ aiS eo\yA"vC<\ 'ytA'v^S,. /V~~) fcyje-^r-AVnt^ JKoHC v^Xe-v- AY^ \yj>f"\<;A/Vc\iV
AVt-f^ <»\ >s VQ^C O^POW OoViA^cA\vi.f\sV-'vA>^.A^<,V)A<-V-\|o'^'C O.'C.G. °)'1)DS ftrA^'blt)
"A ^t* AVo^ogk.Vo \^>\V -vloOv xjAmA \y)-t\sVv AiOgA (k.^(K Nig-t^O^ A-^ QP-C^A!AyiJc\ \f^.
      VMAi A A
rx <*<••&<•-
 ^
                 Ao NcX         AYc ^\cA\x>t^ , *^\\«»oyy A- t^^M yj^ ;>A \W A11A*. <£ fw*• AA Vo At<-(. \\\-t OrAtV A°°\ Vv>A
ma-^ CA vf* K OM»Aood vAWtY *S&\r*huK V*H QoVvA'vor^Vve. \>yeX^^AV vtS yW^X^ A ^X^ Kg-Me<-V\\o "S-         (N>fA     ^yr>V A^^^rA^t \ovV>« \-V>\sW
       V\^ ctxse- S^oC '\)Wv>k>c\:vOf>Ke^,g..r^iJccK \^p\ 1- o*\ \\\c k^pA^-m- *s \T^ifr< iXWn'b .AVv5 w^s fk'.-(K^Ce,^\\-^-g\->| \^QoSg, frS vjJg-W . \)A\vu,o\\<, r^j <^&,(\ ,^mA& iocce \. <^Ar*T
 qNsHkV^ -YVva^ flofVyot* oK \\\e, ftcorkwA \- ) ^o<- ce^So^S SA^&l \f> VW V«-s \
  g»ec    v.
                                                            2.
                      _\A?,IL(A.O ^imAnjwn &^" \c^3 / 0^vO\e-c\ rVAAev QvifVi^cVoM CWwU^Cye-

  A=^_jA«c^cJ^ ^eAcy-yvv^iAvu^ V^c, Npa.e ^j ^jyixdvC- te-^V^c, yM 6V^\Lt A friA''2_l/f^Viy>
      VA-c \j3 ^vV^X^y^ ^ \VA ^)VA-c. A" ^WnTt(\
           ^. ^  >X^\e-(A VKAVcat 'Aso-»t\^V,yA\°'p c^v\<.iJ<\o Vo \V-t- XA C^f \ ^ pv^^As
      \Avt An X^ e^H g,<-co^e,^osVi ^^^V
    TV £i_GA± \2.^2>         oY YW sYA^ e\ec\ \W X^AAA^\-q \o r,CeAeAYe\Wa^_
         V^e,   (M~     Ao \boA Y\\1\~e.\mgfS
     A, loWitM-Aet^ Yq cK^AyY Xix^S .
  (K^i

         \ Ve. YfvK<,s q\ \o^\^^ MxAXe.^ X^, e.er^ t^o\lAAYA
  C^^vSa-'sS V<^nC Ye>oAAwt onYw-r'A^i t(K^V Q.-TC ^\Wr fAo^QiH^

          :&! se, r,ox^\K\A\e^S Cdt^Asa q\ W^vvtA-Y^sr ^ \o^^
                                                            0
                                                              \ <^\K^j j^vT^
                                                                  \OCN6\o
                                                                   ^i
            Jfctfk

            YYe.

   \K^ S€io v*V o^se/A" vor* oY YV^  O^vx^vkcA flioWor'xV-i ,*SA cccxfsrX^ vvvXAfN
    A           j^    f,\Kqvi,yO(.-e, ^wA YY\i XeoAsXA-^-e. ^ W t , QsKY Vq Kr\
     \      diSs    \e,i^6^ \'-, •c^'OiaVSWA^ ^o-r XYve-v^
M^oy> \ooXSY^o^ \)o YV\S Wva> \*> Y>qAV Vvac Xe^A O^dve, Y
          \mk^ (x.v> ^tJ^t/cwie^Y A&vKp..

                                                                  A X'yrg/6A 6<:-i oA oYV-ikAo^vj ^Afcss \Y Y-g, o<^AAA

                        AW^A> ^ fO^AvA A              \oS As Vtf"-, priAA ^nI .0 oYAt^vXeA ^X |x/yAc
                        &yL

Y>ooYv A^«4 YYvA p-f-ofAvAiA
                        *f
                             v°^ nfC^T*? AVt ei->kt\ it-><^
                                                        ^
                                                            Au qAAA "vt> \VA AA^T^YonV^ Aov^ A\Y\»vPT.

   AY <,     fc^g   icA\^t\
                         ^
                            A(\o<,^vy\oA W ft',AYi .iWiYXg. m-> \\\c^>v<.^ o^ \Vt, AAA* s'^M
      Aa £&K h fk-o^A V<- oYYe-r-,
    Tg-^Q't^,$         PC NpOoX^^ Vt> C,g-<- v1^ O^e- -a-TcAsY •> ,

             AV IxA^oCg,         YYe \^o^ A yAV^-g-rX V^AY^ \yo NiVXYAY^'Yo-rcc\oyH<^ YAn frAAo^><" AX^ f AAV c^*- »-c-o Nov^\£-v-oOS,
              XV
         •.ffs-^VMh.     AA<> c'AeX . vYe xjAAi. i-VAieny, y^^fows jVaYqAw A \.r^o nU\ 2,
         io^_C \fy^Ac <-r         V\ g.\^(v^ ^^

                                              A ~\ttO-< ^ \A ^A c Vv&tJUiUOfa r.QO-rY           yX^AV V^rvx"1-? A) A   >lX ^'U I 1
         m               UibX ^ LFl 77f CuvT) )
           M |J\>I \ Ck'T-AY ex. ^0\c, X\e.Av^*\ A- dAA Yo ?>ee We.Qu'TvH^O^Ylcetf-^
    jpAV               b£i   X YX\i Coo-r\ s \>Ac^A'v^^o^. ftyAW-oAWOf Xt^r ^ V\ ,\J /XytWsoh1 Yed
                                                                                                    AA
                                                                                        A

           (XN   X           .X wv^> Yg- X sYo^ vac XsAVn >0kA A^° YoxdxtA^, YYA A. X •cg-c^sie                                            stc<.A-
            V                >^sA ixhX (k vXqXws V^/'yi-i^. <)xY>-5£A'oe.oX YYl^V- A oVs^e^V Arc -Wcx*
          lfrCv,«.»y -X, Y?e.cny.OSC oY We, pCg-SuOp^-bA Nsp^oToXa'xYvV^ c>Y ^Y fc CoQtY, SeX-P^CNW Vvy
          XV X tAt AAA ^At. torAs»^,\ tJv^i Ax)<»(A Y^ X>e, \Ae-X \v-f °^AAA
       (>x>A                 S_A    (V^^Ora-Ox SO XV\C Q^>T AVyeWv-Aw Wom^VsV \^flv<. Yne-itY -A f oA^A «-N

      \eA\
        *y\ xfl i-£L '.g>^
                                 XY«- OcX'tCC- C<^PoA S^MIIOIX ViSL «S<^V)J XA^Pdv&HA ^yP^-fOyO^ A?, £\
                A t.tA p\ f,o&x>g-r xjj'x-f  (xr^fx, e^Ao%eA Y>S "VAg-Hd^
     Y'DV-'^t/X SA-f
  A Yep Vc                       >-|-s Ywa yy                e_   -opy-r-e,    \>j(nS       t^-
                                                                                                  Y4 foOfvAcX   YAoyA Y^*- SoAX\x»->eA *->A\
 XxXcY
Vi           v^O-S          )As ViA'xA M^A^y, poxA \q\n\An \s t-ioA w ^H -g-r-A^sA GoC^~pofT s<^\A A ^^$ yp A ISY^A
  i       \Ax<- C,           \b xJH^"W^( <*<-<£, '^o\^ OV^X- x[\AAi-Jv hYv>A^\Aa-AA AAY ~XtAg-^XxjAg-\^s-e>                      Xgy, (s-AA-c^-cAm oi   \a\a\^ \W o^x'vC^'\-Q-Qor\ \^ V\N ooAfrSStpf^

          Ks«         c-?    Aa^A xpAYv^ Wi^eQ-Ar V\\g- A\r-e- V^w x^X A X^c ^°Pe^W
   V^S- X^\
 VAVSQyYxC^                          \V\g-           Ax'M'K'L XxYAe<^ X^ cor^v YV\i ct'x YdCy HutAOevr oA
 YXnc .£,\jxX       r>C4, Y<\M(>W^ \nJ Yo  ^A g^ YY\i(h-£, (X^AxeA \>CCCK^<^ \\-'0 PvAs
    So^-eT A YY\g vPx-& . At tU/s
         £
     yyv^,        ^•rot      ^oA vA.Qs.Xg. /> A>S'l ttfy^. XL YveYeoc 0 >   A-pyYvixjJ XLx^vA'tiSiA, YYxg- fV^g\ Y*-SeA of* YYy<- vStAo-e. \SS.oC ty^X
^  3
   or   XV L.          pAA-vA^A \tjAA\Y Xf^oA^ poypV . Y)oY \VvA xjjAhA AWAAsA
  VyftM "V X Xpe^yJ Xpy^^X. v--t ftYxiKq VA^'A A6*"*" ) Vx ,0 ^luqinJ A^fL
   v\^ - oUu< o-A Vx«-4 fH
                                                         *r
                                                              'OxX)\>f^| AAq AV\

               1.    A ions *A YV-e, A vfxA (Ao A. ,

                                                                 Vs^s p«•A a" m\X v. AAd k AYA
                                                                 YKA*\+i\WiW>r \ h\
  A-   r\Avi\ A \AxYcvT". T\\ fAW* A UyeseAA>Jt fAg\xjt r>A 1AcW<~
qAQ^AO YAt^ y^SeAX-) ~xYr.sx.rs l>rAA \. r> \W As (A>^~W
AAxX XcA^^, xjyiXor AYc le-AX'S o\ R^ yrs YYA YW A.of Coxoc t^A
\^ A<0^- \^                      ^^^X^"A

                                          \AA\,AWccaA2
                                                        c^o3
                                          fXAoyAnAAv

                                          -fboAoi-1 TA71oo^