Court Opinion

ID: 4059766
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 19:41:46.846686+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:54.536880
License: Public Domain

wng 03

¢Jd. am » 19,357~0'6

E)c were § - - l~ TA¢`. mafzncr Cwa‘r

§§ _'.`!LN 0~\0 J`uol<‘_mL DlsTQ)c`l`
K.€~~»'STA ..wm`f><o.\‘\ § l m:D-Ln NO Cdu/uTP 0 Tcixvs~§
FW©TH©N GDENHED

DATE. 230 § §§

F\PPLlCANT'S o&_§£r_`[`w/\) \0 0_-¢4£ "D)STR)C|`\|¢¢…
Su&&£®w>_r\-T Pos¢`€am/LCT-w/O wQ»T ¢¢P im%&n_s CoRPu§/)?LL@..Q~
\I\)C"a F_)N\Qu\}fw'b 991-&¢\ 0 C,oNCLMe¢o/.\) cl\{` Lm)~\ Pu\/O Rcaom~
W\.£MDF\\ wl\l$ ..

P\OPL»¢:ANT» K€NNE_\~H wmst FnL¢`&. T)-Hs oE>_~T¢Q`I`¢aN 729 ~7`H¢:"

WED HN
B\SW\CF 30055 5 R°?O‘L‘ j C§§Q§\M\NALAPPEALS

1:_ - OCT 14 2015

HPPL¢¢ANT'$ w\aT-wrd T`O 26Cwa£ TR)AL §£@@M@Q@I.ég§ F'/J~LW\
H£A»Q/H\!@ '\\ 0"0

 

'\. `me ”\`¢20»<\0_ \mo€~,a le..wru; `ch R€c-w<_.¢\_»o u»m&.¢~,\u: -I»/U
-\*¥€+\m~€w APP/L\mk;.\"g \\..`o‘» eé@memr\)@) T»EM.R. (iw. P.

1|~@ a\ C.-EJ 4 '

3. HPPL¢@A¢\)T wa% 40_Le€4.4u_‘( mun uNLA»JF-wu.é/ 041_¢@“3..¢‘_0 \`-c) 56
sam 40 ramp , N ma 4\:1.040, sums 00\0 744»¢; I`/vmomem`
”Dm /\/¢>T °>€T Vc>R)` `ri 04 ¢"043£ 04205\¢\16-’4 UJN¢)EL \-éyv‘£s PE_/\ml,
CoD-_ " 04`r T-H»c`. i./mc`_ c>{` H)s ARRLST` Av\/D 5-£/\#~0£0\1¢\/\1@0 / 000
P\ ..vom P\BRE<>'\` Ar\)n O,¢`TE/_\)`r¢o,~l D.oc,um/€~’T

3. ma ve..¢\¢_ \mm;e 1LLee04U_v r\wwu@_@ c»40 `m+.: umwa
\/SRch\ D.IAE `Fo \44'€ ll_¢_c~:SHu/s/ Aefl€$?` 14/\/0 ®.c: Té_l\)T 100/\)
T-l/+€ HZ\¢H, COu/L\ \Bm& 04¢`\`5 640 aml’>§w~§ 040\/.0 Cde/S~
51@0~0' m_e&m,\_¥ 50:.~74;0\4¢€ AWLm/mm `“m_¢__ f/€¢\/L
m T-Dc:r. 745 TP_m¢_ ew,@d woman L&&n¢, Ju/L¢S/o/c;,s\w/u,

WLE,'F\PPMCAMT CAN 0\)0/ kevin/050 04 F'm,-L hmo 4`0401. il @")
R€VL€\,J \E>‘/ T?Q)AL. Cc)u)°~:" 0

U)

ll ,
A-LLE~_G,ATw N% op TH£ MJPL» en Nz`

`. i __ ` ` _' \ ,,_. |.\
~“mf_ HPP£ c Cm~/T’ wv¢\&. "’ n-QR.€_$T,.~:Q FC>R lH:¢~, (HLQ:&:D ' oFf» ~ =

E,N-f=£~ cfc \No,::c'r:-Nc‘\/ _C»=(\ n_,,»,.CH\\_o bmw ¢x herald .l/\Jem>.¢~\) |N

OQT@P>¢\»L 15,\¢1¢1\. HPPL\¢MT was cu¢m@,eo 513 was l.mo¢crme~r

#%@ %A\o oFFeNSE uNp,e,L m ramp P&NAL CODE§ A…/ m
C"WSE' N‘g‘ CM` |'e>' 357. "?"Hc`,\ \NO\CFM€J\)T" '“D.m WOT" S€T FORTH
Pr CA">& ARlS-|M(w .UNBE& T'b“r€ P~&\J\w¢\, Coa£~; AT .TH¢‘, q~,,m§ ap 7,74_5
'*Pp\‘/\C#\~T{S MRE§F m\)o gEvT.e/\\c.»w\+(w , " mm rue /uth ...(,NJ §(7
T`H>‘E "n'_é¥v&§ P&NNL COJDE "l.DlO NeT` 60 f I_M]\o `CjFF;-§_CT T|L_/ Sb\me/be/L
\/ \C¢¢)L\ » S,.=;e: 1465 mw 6apr ¢-LNO 5705 § _\_ ,.3 §§
LB\ ) ,AND 2 11le LRE/PC\‘A~(_ c>-`(\ `FM.E, Q:\,@,§~A,LH\}@ STV<W\.MJ£ ,,LLM<}$
"\_¢`> `lTN¢E E`FF€U` S.EPTEME>e\L 11 |‘i‘i'€> / /,uH/)eH =H "}‘> mo ‘F<)Rcc~:
OR .€’FF€¢`(` / (N l/iOLM`/w-/\) o\“O &7Am/\d£§j AN() Cch>]`;)//,{//\w/\m;_
*‘Y\AND¢‘\T€§ 1 ~S€€"» l`£')rr&€> Co/\rs`r)T¢/LTw/\@ 'AA/\. 5 § "5(,, ," lC/.e»g
R*mv G'€Nf=>w¢c,m© 1 c¢mpm~:/a »quj?:> 1 ,
T)L: Q€Pem» 09 wm mwa -P@\/\w, cope "`3 w.'u`bz;&’£¢w.~:o W,¢:

C¢)¢ml` Tumsa)m\\om ./ TNu¢¢ LT` 13 314 m 'h\)l A G’».e/\)c~>e¢w_ §¢~N;¢;

`FHA\\ %MNSC¢ rv\m.\`veLCS-umsmc,r\o/\\ R&;~F@L$ `17`0 ~7`»4€ Pau$.S/)_
199 C@MT Ta ~A£AK. A¢\)o ®ec\o£ n -Q.As¢¢:.` APPQ¢.AW‘AQ¢Q¢$ "
"'\'-HA‘T BSFZ°¢L€ A Can~T i$ A¢/LT'H@R\'LSD .W H€AL .)o, c,@,,m,__;/. j_-HS,Q€
sms-v F¢sz B¢-; A m<,m. L»<\~Q / mm )<FA fian 1a fm /,»<\¢,,0
"T'?+a¢c L$_ M) ee¢me; 115 TH@A€ 155 fda C-e¢me T)¢ep.e 15 /\)O
§M>$t;c`|` mr+TT€/a, \`-\`u’/>_l_<.£)'.cc`rwv\? . 33 €¢>/apu€> \.Tams Schumban/s 1
"Cflam~l/\Mi_ H‘\\D)" § 157 / P- l`é"’l,‘ jum£>p¢c,T-¢e/\J 13 BBwu@#/`
TS A 1waqu B\j ,i/\))W ct{\A Cc)m/’LMN/`/ .}/\)+/O£/MH\¢¢)/~J..OA \}»Nch/Wl:c`-NT',
+\No l1)-/ Tm~;g£ .|=,\)@mwm,¢/\»,\ -Fw" Ta c-#/<),Q@§ 19 C-A/m¢~:/ 77¢¢~£,;
é’/AN Bé MO ~‘L\,<'JB_TECT MH#"*FS!L J'u,Q/'SD¢U`)@/\) 344/va M/Y#dLL/`__/A»
P/<>Rmm_ mm S¢¢FWCIENT /No¢¢me/\)T cwa l/\/~i»’c>@m)<)rm/\> / )zL

50¢¢¢_7` D&e& /\wv_ Hcé)wa€ ‘Su-¢B\`\`¢~d 1100me \`.Tu/az'sz)/.crw/\>

AN,Q T\`¢m§ +\r/\) Acc_ue¢e/; ‘m»)°r\/ M_vr‘ Er~: Pa/u/s¢+.<~:/b,

C,¢m.eT?;> rule Cc)¢\»§¢\»mreo: 317 Awr_'h‘o@ cW' ~A-No THU/ CANN<»/`
@Lo E>€\{owm THAT Po@\)e.& ®€'LSSAFQQ `Ta wam.

(a)

'H’/ W`%&`f //*\C/`\` 'BE ‘~/QN'Q T-FIM` AMTNG£V("/JA NO -CEI?.TH\NU/
m ad maw.e~m@/<) 043 nw TA@.¢< J:M‘D@M¢:N\r q…o @Q.Q.,m aaa

Peé%AmeD Ae> ‘c\?eu,LiT>¢e§;TA»e‘(_.ArL¢ ./\MW w 1014de ,~ bar
.‘S:mP/l/‘(' .Ué>m . .

 

Ti-¥_.ERE. l-S A I\BL£CE%‘> x`I`Y/ ‘F'c>l& ‘AN ¢-;c/ch:NTLMlC‘/ .H,&:AKING
Becm&..e `FH=€!LE Ae€ +/Ac,v§ l.v\J asg.v\e WH.:<:H mm 355 Hec¢/L-
‘I’.A\N€Q F/ww\ l\-b\€ R€Co@a wm+ BSA§¢WAE>LE Ce/aTA\NT‘(-.

Tm-:u£ 13 No_ D.Lsce€r\w/O 7`0 /C%.No& ¢-L.n.c'r\ os() 5.¢¢153@¢:\~
m»wre@. §r-um§mcvw/\) , T~HE ~B.aRAQ-M §H.\Pr€> T~¢>/wh~; comer
Tb Wlo-c/E \Tu[u%m€,`r 10/\7,’- "HE Cc>oc/l`l" l/V\LLZY' P,meg _`o./\» /7`~;4€
Rz:"€@¢o , f»u, \mg\z,o¢mw/~J VA@§ '/zeum\;o w wis Cm/u<>._
muw¢~> eas».»ymsm. 17`#€ nw mbm/355 TH»<M\.a/\)ce smz`\<~:
-N\so FI:`®:&KZ»<&L~ \"i'ums>,@¢¢T¢c>/\? H¢\S Be.ct~/\| CH»<LLL.@>N(§€»O /‘/7.`

mu§~r B¢: moth }-\mebmcrw~ ,- 0/\»¢€ CHM/`.éw&ec> 1
C;'AN:\\<>T be Aseumem .m\m mw¢r be 0@<;1&@¢;.

l-’zkmm€% mo FY\CC; dwm,(’,c.ué¢_,o¢\? -0-~0 ll,»<wQ won /PéQoMM:LQ¢J

1. TLL:`. Sl\m\£i~ »CO<,LILT Ac/.E‘R`¥` i\H»<LT 'APP/t,cC-n w`{"_,uh°r~% PP¢ULc)uSJ_/S/

Co@.,u.LcT/¢:Q \¢J C'¢Luc,€, Mww\a&e. G-)<B )¢4,&>7¢/ |\»_J rmi QJGHL
n»¢J/a\¢h` ew.u, O@ mom/va wlww”/ mAg o/\J_ 'n/é wm
AM <»@ m…¢z , 1%3 .¢\0 we &:/_@MJ ,-MF,Q~;~%€ .d\_ wu-
AMTAC)RVL:Q usa c>@ A -moNa 1/,€1+:¢:1,£ A¢§rr¢ S<>"~H`<~;/\s-cec>
va 36 .,‘{e»\&% ll\) »me/\J, Lms.waz,e .MP¢¢@M:` lung
cf@u.\/rc':\'~m 'l.N-»c:»<xus$ NMMB@L C:/l_B- -H / 7-@€> ?-M ~T~`Hc` 3'?>’3
?H "®STrlx/QT Cc>‘u¢l`r ch IY\¢ObAr\)D Coum`\j/ 729/ms mo T' c; 17 m
nw ~.<»\quwa,- lq% 010 wm ~sz/\M UFFM\IS<~: RLBBE/u/
mom %¢_\)`r¢:~cf_b Ta 36 »‘/EN&S l/\J P/Z'¢SO/\) fled 7`%&- S-/\\/»\e
DA*/.$ memo no FAJ MPL¢@;+M\ ama mcneasz /4/\ me
`T»'»`rv\c`,, G~Q 4TH¢L_5&. l~c\ D.e>/\)TS>. w HE;\) `|"M-is 'C¢,<>a/QT” S.MSR¢MS'I\D
AN@NEK A' P@c_>u"w/\J up T*RMST Ar\,u) com~'zz)z~;/\réc` /'H)S FT¢H- .
L\)P_€ `1`0 Bls-LL-O%E FAC\`% `i-”H»<+T 1~/»€ Hv+s 04 DL¢T£/ 7`¢9 D/&‘#
cL<>:@>e 1a A,s saw 14 F):AV»Q 195 A/\) ncmlq¢_ _m/$)Qéo>/a€-g¢¢.wm`

`Fl` a (\J .
CB)

 

'7'¥|£ T£\¢),L »Coa/IT` .Lmel¢c>\b §ru/ltbblc?\.o/Q "I`a -l>'te;m& Cnus£'
wm PQQ§.QNT wqu To ?wé Qru,z‘./ ma -S,e`r :'Fo& hilan

MIPL-\‘c»\z\»`\ ~Av+_vzs T-¢\M" .T+LE |A»o¢'~cT.meMY ”b)a /\wv~ §»¢:"r VO@¥H
A (°Asé. samsuma uN/J@/L `T\`/b°»& W.TSJA_$ ?ex\ma_ cde ’»AT WTH~¢-;

`Hm¢~: .U=Q mahsz ,m\o -&<~;/\W)=Q~)QW& /.AN¢> TH»¢T-NL¢ me
T,e:&\°v% Pc~_\c\\)°vL '€@De: ibm .N@Y~ l 60 /NTa .<i f-'F.€c$r_ T/L’ galan 1592
-l/ quLl. 565 l-?€e> Te;ws 6°¢~:1\’€\@4¢ L¢wO 34706 3 /. 16 (»D
C\I, AND md cm\.\s@e fm T>¢e /Lm;d m,m¢~: 649 WMT run/cue
A£P/L~¢L€.g <>NU(/ To -..oF‘FLN':L<:`S Cc/v)m ¢.T`l:c~:b 'o/\J "..-UE (1/<})€7`-££’ W€
eFF.@~;cm\/£_ mrs / sep-¢\.e/v\ aaa -"l , mqu / gear / //., ¢/@ mm
umuésL"- l.'l€ C@ /.A/\M) 3 l»llo (R€P¢;AL oper REP'€`AL'/A)G
\“'>`warz, wm w mae er¢<~;cr §§€>rm€>@\e, 41 least .wr/l<;)+ sms
Mo .Foc<¢¢: ala aF/`»’»c-:Q~ , m ummri.a~/\_') -o¢Q<STATz->p_v/ »A'r\)o CowsT/)»
Tammdm, M»Av\)wtef>. 536 T`eomg_ coMS-T)'mhcw AATT 5 55
301 1965 T&:mg GSMSK,AL LA.B ,' cHwT¢s\/)_ 1467 ~‘€ f . A~D
T»'bH"> l/O¢D-"> THE A»FPL'¢<:A~T/s Cow Uzd`»lo»$ / -'P<.~S/ Ar\m ALL_
EWD»SMC,E ®<,w: )\@ ware mwu_ Ccsu/IT Nav_me//Lw€-] aggqu
d`u£ll§pctT.Lo/\J 0\//&`?& I)\P§?(,\C.-AN“F' |N ‘T’Ml% "M!§TAN\r C‘A.D‘>z:"..'
`-FHE TR\»M, comm HA$ F'mz,oL/Lc~; w nebuch fhwa Poze‘~
§umc>¢\w-M, nwf o¢\w( T¢Mv/ .E>U»T:SX,P.LA.M ww€ TH¢£'(\A C\” \€¢75,
m r<c\. U=@¢,_cu.. am %. E>. ..u@_ s3>¢)/ .eFF. JM\». 1.., 1qu ’ mms
»'1\.¢\) ALT Rc:§>€kmu\)~& 'TM& FP&\\)AL l,m& i-t>/\J.A c`r'n\>&` e‘\ Mcu$ P@\).*\L
dower '%».>TT\MC» our €v<~;.~se»am_ 'Planwc.:pu~;$/ d).£i`¢m…@ OF~
-'F¢/\s%&“> § F¢><\NS Pumce.%me~`r% ,FMAK.¢U& be»£$">v\f’\?_ C¢N"
'Fo#-Mu\)€) i\m’c:womem-% `l`o sur§-)Dé LMOL vla,¢s`lP¢¢:'_`M.~mr(*, ll€`

,l/

P'Lv\¢n\)€» Lmsi '»<\NQ De'c;l,m¢_)/u& AM,Q/ne~a('~%e>/\)as/ , 30
`4"¢4& 'Pe~m_ .c@pa~: :Bc~;u\>€z RESFEM. *F?’&. 30 /‘{~#:A& \ , ,

`T"H€ T|Zm,h~ Cwa`)\ TWL'(zMF-) w ATT.HCH~ l°rP,/JL»/CAN_T” 193 é>em{v
.»As »A ‘nu\<w"" m P¢;~AL cope § ~.:l..@v ca La\ ".n@<@r¢”imew A

®

Pev_€w\o ,lluHc)“o£ (;Rl-Ml.l\»al_ {L€.~€>Pc>--<`>~z.B/u_l.-T‘/ 115 //o ll%s¢¢é"lhd

l\ CL\w\\.l\)A-c_ Ac,\~wlo. w\+§>wewf:ll `l~v&<~: l`+:gvv\ “ ~€>.ual>.ec..`r " .l§

ibew m T»\\-¢: sane l lif~-fma_\ame "`llc\~@la`." P@Naa come §

L'§S\"?@_so§" M.eavo .l\N '.\.Nl)\(ull)uAL l we Polal\\\wld 1 ala ..A-ss¢sa,~
' iA`\"uS/\) 661 .-AQ»¢:NT; Wé, \\11\¢\¢ C@u,l£r .»/`¢`> hl\J-I`H)QOM,`F /Vle/L\ T` .

(Lohg_C_,§Ag§=LQ-L>_)
A.l>‘D/l_l@»\arl wmng T-l\m~ Tvu> Lr;€lm_ l>.m-? ewers div
`t~\\vv\ B"{ 7`+¥€ lD.c;F,SNDl\N`l /v/¢ Tlllv%L .Cc)a/Ll\ s»é)<lST w l`rh"mj M¢Z
T€,)wb C%<l.lalawmf\/W conf -?> {,\1.19~1 CA\“cb\_/WHM£ F/L-llag
Cwla`r musv~ il\sl\ (R@Asw\>'l®uf ./l\l\'l\\l\wlg lautc§ »'UP¢~\J TN¢;
wlaLT oa@ /'b\l\bfl\g colal>as l\lwl> aman/uss 7`%15“€"¥@¢`) '15-¢`-`"
C°A\l§é, Tv‘r\s Co¢m,\` .l,l»cl¢ @Q %ub§c:a`r mmTc~/Yg fnl/alan 1g'7`¢ll»\> )

-AND \T‘s wl`rt*d>u~l` mE‘le\\%.

Cctltvl Fl€;&\\é 010 §c§lz.\/l ¢`f:`
Tl\m l\pl>uc.»\m / -i¢,a_\l\~..l\»ervl lwm*>ol\\ / 00 EUL¢SBV .a.fvarl/F‘l/ TN»M\
~P< TRuE mold C~.c>l?.f&€la`r COP~‘./ cap m F@ll€(\°mm(% w l"c~& -\Q~@WT `V‘Z>

Col,w)"rl mo C.lll_vv\l.l\ML Mc>~a\M_ w mmle 11`»&:)<%; l .A» -z:o/>‘/

wl\e> .¢_>l¢>l\)`r~_.-\`\-`l)' D.¢l‘>.?mcr' feesHK Cl.fsar\ »Z'o%% Bugll low *rslé:
la\lw b\swa\'cr wng w@ mll>L»/ul> muer 7>5)1/+3 / B*/ lwlO
_Tl\flocl€'°)\»\ =`W¢E_ ./\)E:A~\- u./ul`r mmc. E>§X .U.%. VDBTAL Mm(_,

 
   

 

`\°:X.E,`€u,`(`t§N c>~l\i> S.l£p`r£\!`/\E>(:§(¢ § / B\O`l% - _ /\ ~...`
cc/l<u?. ” l .* ~ m~;/D,
C@./ waan 09 CIZ¢M;\~*M_. APP&>AL., _ l . -~a .» ~ ,/l~

c:,,<;/ DleT-lalcr caflag RO:">s Bual-l_ l<.¢,\~,\»e‘rll war-zo~

.c\)/L~;~M;.. o..l\L LT‘
Qo_">% %PM./a zell

Avv\Ar<L Lw/ l\é)m£ `-'?E¢.¢_d7

®