Court Opinion

ID: 2969896
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2015-09-22 15:59:48.644107+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T11:43:11.941195
License: Public Domain

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21
             3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

     (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU
                 )LOH 1DPH DS

81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6
               )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7
                 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

 7,1$s2 0$< 0&*5$:                ;
         3HWLWLRQHU$SSHOODQW      
                                    
                                      1R
            Y                      
                                     !
                                    
 s2< +2//$1'                       
         5HVSRQGHQW$SSHOOHH 
                                   1
       $SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW
      IRUWKH(DVWHUQ'LVWULFWRI0LFKLJDQDW'HWURLW
   1Rn%HUQDUG$)ULHGPDQ'LVWULFWsXGJH
                 $UJXHG0DUFK
             'HFLGHGDQG)LOHGsXO\
  %HIRUH0(55,771(/621DQG68+5+(,15,&+
                   &LUFXLWsXGJHV
                   BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
                        &2816(/
$5*8('  ) 0DUWLQ 7LHEHU 67$7( $33(//$7(
'()(1'(5 2)),&( /DQVLQJ 0LFKLJDQ IRU $SSHOODQW
5DLQD , .RUEDNLV 2)),&( 2) 7+( $77251(<
*(1(5$//DQVLQJ0LFKLJDQIRU$SSHOOHH21%5,()
) 0DUWLQ 7LHEHU 67$7( $33(//$7( '()(1'(5
2)),&( /DQVLQJ 0LFKLJDQ IRU $SSHOODQW  9LQFHQW s

                             
     0F*UDZY+ROODQG                                1R

/HRQH2)),&(2)7+($77251(<*(1(5$//DQVLQJ
0LFKLJDQIRU$SSHOOHH
                      BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
                          23,1,21
                      BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
   '$9,' $ 1(/621 &LUFXLW sXGJH  7KLV LV DQ DSSHDO
IURPDMXGJPHQWGHQ\LQJKDEHDVFRUSXVUHOLHIWRD\HDUROG
JLUOZKRZDVFRQYLFWHGE\D0LFKLJDQMXU\RQDFKDUJHDULVLQJ
RXWRIKHUDVVLVWDQFHLQWKHSHUSHWUDWLRQRIDJDQJUDSH7KH
WULDOHYLGHQFHLQFOXGHGDFRQIHVVLRQJLYHQE\WKHSHWLWLRQHU
GXULQJ D FXVWRGLDO LQWHUURJDWLRQ FRQGXFWHG E\ D SROLFH
GHWHFWLYHLQWKHSUHVHQFHRIWKHSHWLWLRQHUjVPRWKHU%HIRUH
VKH LQFULPLQDWHG KHUVHOI WKH SHWLWLRQHU UHSHDWHGO\ WROG WKH
GHWHFWLYHVKHGLGQRWZDQWWRWDONDERXWWKHUDSH%RWKWKH
GHWHFWLYHDQGWKHPRWKHUWROGWKHSHWLWLRQHUWKDWVKHKDGWR
WDONDERXWLWZKLFKVKHXOWLPDWHO\GLG
   ,Q FRQFOXGLQJ WKDW WKH FRQIHVVLRQ ZDV DGPLVVLEOH LQ
HYLGHQFHWKHVWDWHWULDOFRXUWGHFLGHGWKDWWKHSHWLWLRQHUKDG
QRW HIIHFWLYHO\ LQYRNHG KHU FRQVWLWXWLRQDO ULJKW WR UHPDLQ
VLOHQW  $ FKDOOHQJH WR WKDW GHFLVLRQ RQ GLUHFW DSSHDO ZDV
XQVXFFHVVIXO  7KH GLVSRVLWLYH TXHVWLRQ LQ WKH KDEHDV
SURFHHGLQJLVZKHWKHUWKHVWDWHFRXUWjVGHFLVLRQmZDVFRQWUDU\
WR RU LQYROYHG DQ XQUHDVRQDEOH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI FOHDUO\
HVWDEOLVKHG)HGHUDOODZDVGHWHUPLQHGE\WKH6XSUHPH&RXUW
RIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVl6HH86&GDVDPHQGHG
E\WKH $QWLWHUURULVPDQG(IIHFWLYH'HDWK3HQDOW\$FW
6WDW
  7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWFRQFOXGHGWKDWWKHGHFLVLRQUHDFKHGE\
WKH0LFKLJDQFRXUWZDVDSHUPLVVLEOHRQHXQGHUWKHVWDQGDUG
SUHVFULEHGE\WKHVWDWXWH:HGLVDJUHH7KHMXGJPHQWHQWHUHG
E\ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW ZLOO EH UHYHUVHG DQG WKH FDVH ZLOO EH
UHPDQGHG ZLWK LQVWUXFWLRQV WR JUDQW WKH ZULW XQOHVV WKH
SHWLWLRQHULVJLYHQDQHZWULDO
1R                           0F*UDZY+ROODQG          

                                 ,
                                $
   2QWKHQLJKWRI)HEUXDU\WKHSHWLWLRQHU7LQDMR
7LQD0D\0F*UDZZDVRQHRIDJURXSRIHLJKWRUVRSHRSOH
ZKR ZHUH mSDUW\LQJl DW D KRXVH LQ 6DJLQDZ 0LFKLJDQ
$OWKRXJK7LQDZDVQRW\HW\HDUVROGVKHGLGQRWDWWHQG
VFKRRODQGZDVDOUHDG\WKHPRWKHURID\RXQJVRQWKHER\
ZDV QRW ZLWK KHU RQ WKH QLJKW LQ TXHVWLRQ DOWKRXJK DQ
XQUHODWHG FKLOG ZDV LQ WKH URRP ZKHQ WKH UDSH RFFXUUHG
'XULQJWKHHDUO\PRUQLQJKRXUVRI6DWXUGD\)HEUXDU\RQH
RIWKHSDUW\JRHUVD\HDUROGZRPDQZKRDOOHJHGO\mNHSW
WDONLQjDERXWVRPHFUDFNlDQGZLWKZKRP7LQDKDGHQJDJHG
LQDILVWILJKWHDUOLHULQWKHHYHQLQJZDVEHDWHQDQGUDSHGE\
VHYHUDORIWKHPDOHJXHVWV7KHSROLFHZHUHFDOOHGDWDERXW
DP:KHQSROLFHRIILFHUVDUULYHGDWWKHKRXVHWKHYLFWLP
WROG WKHP WKDW VKH KDG EHHQ KHOG GRZQ GXULQJ WKH UDSH E\
7LQDDQGWKHODWWHUjVIULHQG&DURO\Q6LPRQV
   7LQDZDVDUUHVWHGDWWKHVFHQHDQGWDNHQLQWRFXVWRG\7KH
SROLFHVXPPRQHG7LQDjVPRWKHUWRWKHSROLFHVWDWLRQDQGD
GHWHFWLYH7DPLH5HLQNHWRRN7LQDDQGKHUPRWKHULQWRDQ
LQWHUYLHZURRPDWDERXWDP7KHUH7LQDZDVDGYLVHGRI
KHU0LUDQGDULJKWVERWKRUDOO\DQGLQZULWLQJDQGVKHVLJQHG
D ZULWWHQ ZDLYHU IRUP DV GLG WKH PRWKHU HYLGHQFLQJ KHU
XQGHUVWDQGLQJRIKHUULJKWWRUHPDLQVLOHQWDQGKHUULJKWWRDQ
DWWRUQH\
  'HWHFWLYH 5HLQNH EHJDQ D IRUPDO LQWHUURJDWLRQ DW
DSSUR[LPDWHO\  DP 7KH LQWHUYLHZ ZKLFK ZDV WDSH
UHFRUGHGHQGHGDWDERXWDP
   $WUDQVFULSWRIWKHWDSHGLVFORVHVWKDW7LQDZDVUHOXFWDQWWR
WDONDERXWWKHGHWDLOVRIWKHUDSH$FNQRZOHGJLQJWKDWmEDG
WKLQJV WKDW KDSSHQ DUH DOZD\V KDUG WR WDON DERXWl WKH
GHWHFWLYH WROG 7LQD WKDW m\RX QHHG WR WHOO PH ZKDW ZDV
KDSSHQLQJ DWWKHKRXVHl7LQDWKHQDVNHGLIWKHLQWHUYLHZ
FRXOGEHSRVWSRQHGm&DQZHMXVWWDONDERXWWKLVODWHUlVKH
DVNHG7LQDjVPRWKHUDQGWKHGHWHFWLYHERWKUHSOLHGLQWKH
QHJDWLYHWKHGHWHFWLYHH[SODLQLQJWKDWmZHQHHGWRWDONDERXW
     0F*UDZY+ROODQG                                1R        1R                                 0F*UDZY+ROODQG             

LWQRZEHFDXVH

,QHHGWRLQYHVWLJDWHLWWRGHFLGHZKDWjV              QRW ZKHWKHU WKH FRXUWjV GHFLVLRQ LQYROYHG DQ XQUHDVRQDEOH
JRQQDKDSSHQZLWKSHRSOHl                                              DSSOLFDWLRQ RI WKH &RQVWLWXWLRQ DV ZULWWHQ  7KH TXHVWLRQ
                                                                          EHIRUHXVUDWKHULVWKLV'LGWKHWULDOFRXUWjVGHFLVLRQLQYROYH
   7LQDLQLWLDOO\GHQLHGKDYLQJUHVWUDLQHGWKHYLFWLPGXULQJWKH          DQXQUHDVRQDEOHDSSOLFDWLRQRIFOHDUO\HVWDEOLVKHGIHGHUDOODZ
UDSH  m, GLGQjW WRXFK WKH JLUOl VKH UHSHDWHGO\ GHFODUHG m,   DVGHWHUPLQHGLQ0LUDQGDDQGLWV6XSUHPH&RXUWSURJHQ\"
WULHGWRKHOSKHUl7KHGHWHFWLYHHYHQWXDOO\VDLGWKDWVKHGLG           7KHDQVZHUWRWKDWTXHVWLRQDVZHKDYHH[SODLQHGLVm\HVl
QRWWKLQN7LQDZDVEHLQJKRQHVWDERXWZKDWKDGKDSSHQHG
SHUKDSVEHFDXVHVKHZDVDIUDLGRIZKDW&DURO\QDQGWKHRWKHU                 $FFRUGLQJO\DQGEHFDXVHWKHVWDWHGRHVQRWFRQWHQGDQG
SDUWLFLSDQWVZRXOGGRWRKHULIVKHWROGWKHWUXWK                       FRXOGQRWUHDVRQDEO\FRQWHQGWKDWWKHKDUPOHVVHUURUUXOHKDV
                                                                          DQ\ UROH WR SOD\ LQ WKLV FDVH WKH MXGJPHQW HQWHUHG E\ WKH
  $IWHUDVKRUWEUHDNWKHGHWHFWLYHUHQHZHGKHUUHTXHVWIRUDQ           GLVWULFW FRXUW LV 5(9(56('  7KH FDVH LV 5(0$1'('
KRQHVW DFFRXQW RI ZKDW KDG WUDQVSLUHG  7LQD PXPEOHG              ZLWKLQVWUXFWLRQVWRLVVXHDZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXVXQOHVV7LQD
VRPHWKLQJ WKDW ZDV QRW IXOO\ DXGLEOH DQG WKHQ WROG WKH          LVJUDQWHGDQHZWULDOZLWKLQDWLPHWREHIL[HGE\WKHGLVWULFW
GHWHFWLYHWKLVm,GRQjWZDQWWRWDONDERXWLW,GRQjWZDQWWR         FRXUW
UHPHPEHULWlsXVWmGRZKDW\RXKDYHWRGRZLWKPHl
7LQDFRQWLQXHGm,GLGQjWZDQWWRWDONDERXWl
  7KHGHWHFWLYHDFNQRZOHGJHGDJDLQWKDWGLVFORVXUHZRXOGEH
GLIILFXOWEXWDVNHGLI7LQDZDQWHGRWKHUSHRSOHWRJHWDZD\
ZLWK ZKDW WKH\ KDG GRQH E\ EODPLQJ HYHU\WKLQJ RQ KHU
7LQDjV PRWKHU OLNHZLVH XUJHG WKH JLUO WR WHOO ZKDW KDG
KDSSHQHG  7LQD KRZHYHU PDGH NQRZQ KHU ODFN RI
HQWKXVLDVPIRUmPHWU\LQjWRZDONWKHVWUHHWVDQGJHWWLQjVKRW
DQGNLOOHGIRUWHOOLQjl7KLVWKHPHUHFXUUHGDWVHYHUDO
SRLQWVLQWKHHQVXLQJGLVFXVVLRQDVGLGDVVXUDQFHVWKDWWKH
RWKHUVZRXOGEHORFNHGXSDQGWKDW7LQDFRXOGKHOSKHUVHOIE\
FRRSHUDWLQJ
  6WLOO7LQDUHVLVWHGm,FDQjWWKLQNDERXWLWlVKHVDLGm,
GRQjW ZDQWl VKH FRQWLQXHG DW ZKLFK SRLQW WKH GHWHFWLYH
LQWHUUXSWHG WR WDNH 7LQDjV KDQG ZKLOH KHU PRWKHU VSRNH RI
PRYLQJWRDQRWKHUWRZQZKHUHQRRQHZRXOGWKLQNWRORRNIRU               6HH   'LFNHUVRQ  86 DW  6FDOLD s GLVVHQWLQJ
KHU                                                                          
                                                                                %HFDXVH   'LFNHUVRQ   ZDV QRW GHFLGHG XQWLO VHYHUDO \HDUV DIWHU 7LQDjV
                                                                          FRQIHVVLRQ ZDV XVHG DJDLQVW KHU DW WULDO WKH VWDWH PLJKW FRQFHLYDEO\ KDYH
  $IWHUDGLVFXVVLRQRIKRZ7LQDKDGEHHQSLVWROZKLSSHGD                                                                   0LUDQGD
                                                                          DUJXHG WKDW DW WKH WLPH RI WULDO WKH DSSOLFDELOLW\ RI         DQG LWV SURJHQ\
PRQWKHDUOLHUDQGKDGH[DFWHGUHYHQJHZLWK&DURO\QjVKHOS                WR VWDWH FRXUW SURFHHGLQJV KDG QRW EHHQ mFOHDUO\l HVWDEOLVKHG E\ WKH
WKHGHWHFWLYHVWHHUHGWKHFRQYHUVDWLRQEDFNWRWKHHYHQWVRI              8QLWHG 6WDWHV 6XSUHPH &RXUW 1R VXFK DUJXPHQW KDV EHHQ SUHVHQWHG WR
WKDWPRUQLQJm+RZPDQ\JX\VGLG\RXVHHUDSHKHUlWKH                  XV KRZHYHU SHUKDSV EHFDXVH        0LUDQGD      LWVHOI LQYROYHG VWDWH FRXUW
GHWHFWLYHDVNHGm+RZPDQ\RIjHP"l                                     SURFHHGLQJV DQG EHFDXVH WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW DV WKH PDMRULW\ RSLQLRQ LQ
                                                                          'LFNHUVRQ   QRWHV  86 DW  KDV mFRQVLVWHQWO\ DSSOLHG    0LUDQGD   jV
                                                                          UXOH WR SURVHFXWLRQV DULVLQJ LQ VWDWH FRXUWVl 7KH LVVXH QRW KDYLQJ EHHQ
                                                                          UDLVHG LQ DQ\ HYHQW ZH QHHG QRW XQGHUWDNH WR GHFLGH LW
       0F*UDZY+ROODQG                                 1R        1R                           0F*UDZY+ROODQG           

ZKLFKWKHGHWHFWLYHKDGLQVLVWHGLQUHVSRQVHWR7LQDjVVD\LQJ                   m,GRQjWZDQQDWDONDERXWLWl7LQDUHSOLHGm:HKDYHWR
m,GRQjWZDQQDWDONDERXWLWlWKDWm>Z@HKDYHWRWDONDERXWLW              WDONDERXWLWlWKHGHWHFWLYHLQVLVWHGm:HKDYHWRJHWWKLV
:HKDYHWRJHWWKLVFOHDUHGXS7KHKHDULQJjVDWRQHWKLUW\l                FOHDUHGXS7KHKHDULQJjVDWRQHWKLUW\l
7KH WLPLQJ RI WKLV H[SOLFLW UHMHFWLRQ RI DQ XQDPELJXRXV
UHTXHVWWRUHPDLQVLOHQWFOHDUO\UHIXWHVWKHVWDWHjVSURIIHUHG                   7LQDWKHQVXJJHVWHGWKDWVKHZRXOGMXVWJRDKHDGDQGWDNH
UHDVRQIRUWKHUHMHFWLRQ                                                     DOOWKHEODPH'HWHFWLYH5HLQNHZRXOGQRWDFFHSWWKDWDVNLQJ
                                                                              mGLG\RXDQG&DURO\QKROGWKHJLUOjV>VLF@GRZQEHFDXVHWKH
   :HQRWHILQDOO\WKDWLQGHQ\LQJWKHPRWLRQWRVXSSUHVVWKH               JX\VWROG\RXWR"l7KHPRWKHUUHSHDWHGWKHTXHVWLRQDQGWKH
FRQIHVVLRQ WKH VWDWH WULDO FRXUW WRRN LQWR DFFRXQW QRW RQO\         GHWHFWLYHVDLGm7LQD,NQRZ\RXWRXFKHGWKHJLUOl
7LQDjV GHPHDQRU DV UHIOHFWHG LQ WKH WDSH UHFRUGLQJ EXW
'HWHFWLYH5HLQNHjVGHPHDQRUDQGDWWLWXGHWRZDUG7LQDDIWHU                       2QFHDJDLQ7LQDUHVSRQGHGZLWKWKHZRUGVm,GRQjWZDQW
WKH ODWWHUjV VWDWHPHQWV DERXW QRW ZDQWLQJ WR WDON  7KH              WRWDONDERXWLWl+HUPRWKHUWROGKHUVKHKDGWRWDONDERXWLW
PDJLVWUDWH MXGJH ZKR DOVR OLVWHQHG WR WKH WDSH UHFRUGLQJ            DQGFRXOGQRWWDNHWKHUDSIRUDmKH>D@WK>H@QlOLNH&DURO\Qm,
IRXQGQRWKLQJWRDOWHUWKHFRQFOXVLRQWRZKLFKDUHDGLQJRIWKH               GRQjWZDQQDWDONDERXWLWl7LQDUHSHDWHGm,MXVWGRQjWZDQQD
WUDQVFULSWZRXOGSRLQW1HLWKHUGRZH                                       WDONDERXWLWlVKHVDLGIRUWKHHLJKWKRUQLQWKWLPH
  ,W LV WUXH WR EH VXUH WKDW WKH GHWHFWLYHjV DWWLWXGH WRZDUG         5HIXVLQJWRWDNHQRIRUDQDQVZHUWKHGHWHFWLYHNHSWXUJLQJ
7LQDZDVYHU\V\PSDWKHWLF7KHGHWHFWLYHREYLRXVO\EHOLHYHG                  IXOOGLVFORVXUH7LQDZDVROGHQRXJKWREHWULHGDVDQDGXOW
WKDWVKHFRXOGFDWFKPRUHIOLHVZLWKKRQH\WKDQZLWKYLQHJDU                 WKHGHWHFWLYHWROGKHUDQGZDVIDFLQJDOLIHVHQWHQFHLQSULVRQ
1RWKLQJ UHVHPEOLQJ WKH UDFN DQG WKH WKXPEVFUHZ ZDV                     m,I,WHOO\RXZKDWKDSSHQHGl7LQDILQDOO\UHVSRQGHGm,jOOJR
HPSOR\HGLQWKLVFDVH7LQDjVZLOOGRHVQRWVHHPWRKDYHEHHQ                IUHH ULJKW"l  7KH GHWHFWLYH UHSOLHG WKDW VKH FRXOG SURPLVH
RYHUERUQHDQGoDVVXPLQJWKDWKHUVZDVQRWmDFRQIHVVLRQ                     QRWKLQJmULJKWQRZlDQGZHQWRQWRVD\WKDWm\RXKDYHWREH
IRUFHGIURPWKHPLQGE\WKHIODWWHU\ RIKRSHlVHH.LQJY                   KRQHVWZLWKPHILUVWDQGWKHQZHFDQWDONDERXWZKDWZHjUH
3DUUDWW&DU	3(QJ5HS13DV                   JRQQDGRZLWK\RXl
TXRWHGLQ'LFNHUVRQ86DWoWKHFRQIHVVLRQDSSHDUV
WREHWUXVWZRUWK\                                                              6XFFXPELQJDWODVW7LQDWKHQJDYHDGHWDLOHGFRQIHVVLRQ
                                                                              6KHH[SODLQHGWKDWVKHKDGKHOGRQHRIWKHYLFWLPjVDUPVDQG
  3HUKDSVWKHWULDOFRXUWjVGHFLVLRQWRDGPLWWKHFRQIHVVLRQLQ               &DURO\QKDGKHOGWKHRWKHUZKLOHmWKHJX\VlDSSDUHQWO\WKUHH
HYLGHQFH ZDV QRW DQ XQUHDVRQDEOH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI WKH                   LQQXPEHUHQJDJHGLQRUDODQGYDJLQDOVH[ZLWKWKHYLFWLP
&RQVWLWXWLRQDVZULWWHQ %XWWKHTXHVWLRQEHIRUHXVKHUHLV                 DQGKLWDQGNLFNHGKHU$FKLOGZKRZDVDERXWHLJKW\HDUVROG
                                                                              ZDWFKHGDOOWKLVm+HZDVMXVWVLWWLQjWKHUHODXJKLQjl7LQD
                                                                              VDLG
     
      :KDW WKH &RQVWLWXWLRQ LWVHOI H[FOXGHV IURP WULDO DV sXVWLFH 6FDOLD
QRWHG  86 DW  LQ GLVVHQWLQJ IURP WKH PDMRULW\ RSLQLRQ LQ
                                                                                                               %
'LFNHUVRQ   LV mFRPSHOOHG FRQIHVVLRQVl o ZKLFK 7LQDjV FRQIHVVLRQ RQH
                                                                                ,WZDVGHFLGHGWKDW7LQDVKRXOGEHWULHGDVDQDGXOW$IWHU
FRXOG UHDVRQDEO\ FRQFOXGH ZDVQjW <HW XQGHU WKH     0LUDQGD  UXOH DV WKH
'LFNHUVRQ   PDMRULW\ H[SODLQHG mVWDWHPHQWV ZKLFK PD\ EH E\ QR PHDQV          DQHYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJWKHVWDWHWULDOFRXUWWRZKLFKWKHFDVH
LQYROXQWDU\ PDGH E\ D GHIHQGDQW ZKR LV DZDUH RI KLV µULJKWVj PD\            ZDVDVVLJQHGGHQLHGDPRWLRQLQOLPLQHLQZKLFKWKHGHIHQVH
QRQHWKHOHVV EH H[FOXGHG DQG D JXLOW\ GHIHQGDQW JR IUHH DV D UHVXOWl       KDG VRXJKW WR KDYH WKH FRQIHVVLRQ VXSSUHVVHG  7KH WULDO
86 DW  sDPHV 0DGLVRQ DQG KLV FRQWHPSRUDULHV ZRXOG SUREDEO\ KDYH
IRXQG VXFK D UHVXOW SHUSOH[LQJ XQOHVV WKH )LIWK $PHQGPHQW ZDV LQ IDFW
                                                                              FRXUWjVNH\ILQGLQJZDVWKLV
DLPHG DW m>S@UHYHQWLQJ IRROLVK UDWKHU WKDQ FRPSHOOHG FRQIHVVLRQV    l
      0F*UDZY+ROODQG                            1R       1R                              0F*UDZY+ROODQG          

    m,DPDEVROXWHO\FRQYLQFHGWKDWZKHQWKHGHIHQGDQWVDLG           FLUFXPVWDQFHVWKHUHDVRQDEOHQHVVRI0LFKLJDQjVDSSOLFDWLRQ
    µ,GRQjWZDQWWRWDONDERXWLWjVKHGLGQRWPHDQWKDWVKH         RI 0LUDQGD LV WR VWDQG RU IDOO RQ WKH UHDVRQLQJ RI WKH WULDO
    ZDQWHGWRVWRSWKHLQWHUYLHZ6KHQHYHUGHPDQGHGRU              FRXUWLWREYLRXVO\IDOOV
    UHTXHVWHGWRWHUPLQDWHWKHLQWHUYLHZl
                                                                         7KHVWDWHWULDOFRXUWGLGQRWSURIHVVWRILQGDVWKHIHGHUDO
   3RUWLRQVRIWKHWDSHUHFRUGLQJZHUHSOD\HGWRWKHMXU\DW          GLVWULFWFRXUWGLGWKDW7LQDZDVEHLQJXQFOHDUZKHQVKHVDLG
WULDO DQG WKH SURVHFXWRU KLJKOLJKWHG WKH FRQIHVVLRQ GXULQJ    WKDWVKHGLGQRWZDQWWRWDONDERXWWKHUDSH1HLWKHUGLGWKH
FORVLQJDUJXPHQW,QWKHFRXUVHRILWVGHOLEHUDWLRQVWKHMXU\        VWDWHWULDOFRXUWFRQFOXGHDVWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWVHHPVWRKDYH
DVNHGHLWKHUWRVHHDWUDQVFULSWRIWKHFRQIHVVLRQRUWRKHDUWKH     GRQHWKDWDQLQYRFDWLRQRIWKHULJKWWRVLOHQFHLVXQFOHDUDQG
UHFRUGLQJDJDLQ7KHMXGJHDOORZHGWKHWDSHWREHUHSOD\HG          WKXVLQHIIHFWLYHLILWVWHPVIURPDIHDURIUHWDOLDWLRQ%XWKDG
6KRUWO\WKHUHDIWHUWKHMXU\UHWXUQHGDYHUGLFWRIJXLOW\RQRQH       WKHVWDWHFRXUWWDNHQHLWKHUWDFNZHEHOLHYHWKDWLWZRXOGKDYH
FRXQW RI ILUVWGHJUHH FULPLQDO VH[XDO FRQGXFW  7LQD ZDV      EHHQREMHFWLYHO\XQUHDVRQDEOHLQGRLQJVR
VHQWHQFHGWRLPSULVRQPHQWIRUDWHUPRIWR\HDUV
                                                                         ,QFRQQHFWLRQZLWKUHTXHVWVIRUFRXQVHOWKH6XSUHPH&RXUW
  2Q DSSHDO WR WKH 0LFKLJDQ &RXUW RI $SSHDOV 7LQDjV          KDVWROGXVWKDWWKHUHTXHVWPXVWEHPDGHmXQDPELJXRXVO\l
FRXQVHO PDLQWDLQHG WKDW WKH FRQIHVVLRQ VKRXOG KDYH EHHQ        6HH'DYLVY8QLWHG6WDWHV867LQDjV
VXSSUHVVHG ERWK EHFDXVH LW ZDV mFRHUFHG E\ SURPLVHV RI        ODZ\HUGRHVQRWGHQ\WKDWDQLQYRFDWLRQRIWKHULJKWWRVLOHQFH
OHQLHQF\l DQG EHFDXVH LW ZDV mH[WUDFWHG LQ GLVUHJDUG RI       LILWLVWREHHIIHFWLYHPXVWEHXQDPELJXRXVDVZHOO$VIDU
FRQWLQXHGUHTXHVWVWRVWRSWKHLQWHUYLHZl7KHFRXUWRI       DVZHFDQVHHKRZHYHUWKHUHZDVQRWKLQJDPELJXRXVDERXW
DSSHDOV DIILUPHG WKH FRQYLFWLRQ FRQFOXGLQJ WKDW WKH            7LQDjVUHSHDWHGLQVLVWHQFHVKHGLGQRWZDQWWRWDONDERXWWKH
FRQIHVVLRQKDGEHHQJLYHQYROXQWDULO\7KHFRXUWQRWHGWKDW          UDSH:KHQ7LQDNHSWVD\LQJZLWKRXWTXDOLILFDWLRQWKDWVKH
7LQD DQG KHU PRWKHU KDG mERWK VLJQHG D IRUP ZDLYLQJ          MXVW GLG QRW ZDQW WR WDON DERXW WKH VXEMHFW o PDNLQJ WKHVH
GHIHQGDQWjV0LUDQGDULJKWVlDQGKDGWROGWKHGHWHFWLYHWKDW           GHFODUDWLRQVDIWHUVKHKDGEHHQIRUPDOO\DGYLVHGRIKHUULJKW
WKH\NQRZLQJO\ZDLYHGWKHVHULJKWVDQGZLVKHGWRWDON7KH           RI VLOHQFH o LW ZRXOG VLPSO\ QRW EH UHDVRQDEOH WR WDNH KHU
FRXUWGLGQRWDGYHUWWR7LQDjVUHSHDWHGGHFODUDWLRQVGXULQJ          ZRUGV DW OHVV WKDQ IDFH YDOXH  $QG LI KHU UHDVRQ IRU QRW
WKHILUVWSDUWRIWKHLQWHUURJDWLRQWKDWVKHGLGQRWZDQWWRWDON    ZDQWLQJWRWDONDERXWWKHUDSHZDVDIHDUWKDWVKHZRXOGEH
DERXWWKHUDSH                                                      VKRWDQGNLOOHGLIVKHGLGWKHH[LVWHQFHRIVXFKDIHDUZRXOG
                                                                      QRWPDNHLWDQ\OHVVFOHDUWKDWVKHPHDQWZKDWVKHZDVVD\LQJ
   7KH 0LFKLJDQ 6XSUHPH &RXUW GHQLHG DQ DSSOLFDWLRQ IRU        ,IDQ\WKLQJLWZRXOGPDNHLWHYHQPRUHFOHDUWKDWVKHUHDOO\
OHDYHWRDSSHDO7KHUHDIWHULQ'HFHPEHURIWKHSUHVHQW        GLG QRW ZDQW WR WDON DERXW WKH UDSH  :H DUH DZDUH RI QR
KDEHDVSURFHHGLQJZDVLQLWLDWHGLQWKHIHGHUDOGLVWULFWFRXUW        VXSSRUWHLWKHULQORJLFRULQODZIRUWKHSURSRVLWLRQWKDWDQ
7KHFDVHZDVUHIHUUHGWRDPDJLVWUDWHMXGJHZKRLVVXHGD            RWKHUZLVHXQDPELJXRXVH[SUHVVLRQRIDGHVLUHWRUHPDLQVLOHQW
UHSRUWDQGUHFRPPHQGDWLRQLQZKLFKKHFRQFOXGHGWKDWDZULW           FDQVRPHKRZEHFRPHDPELJXRXVLI SURPSWHGE\DIHDURI
VKRXOG LVVXH  7KH GLVWULFW MXGJH GLVDJUHHG ILQGLQJ 7LQDjV   UHWDOLDWLRQ
VWDWHPHQWV WKDW VKH GLG QRW ZDQW WR WDON DERXW WKH UDSH
mXQFOHDU DQG DPELJXRXVl  ,Q FRQWH[W WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW        7KHVWDWHDUJXHVWKDWZKHQ'HWHFWLYH5HLQNHUHMHFWHG7LQDjV
VXJJHVWHG D UHDVRQDEOH SROLFH RIILFHU FRXOG KDYH EHOLHYHG     UHTXHVWV WR UHPDLQ VLOHQW RQ WKH VXEMHFW RI WKH UDSH WKH
WKDW7LQDZDVPHUHO\LQGLFDWLQJmDKHVLWDQF\GXHWRDIHDURI         GHWHFWLYH ZDV PHUHO\ GHFOLQLQJ WR OHW 7LQD WDNH VROH
UHWDOLDWLRQIURPWKHRWKHUVXVSHFWVl                                UHVSRQVLELOLW\IRUWKHFULPH%XW7LQDjVVXJJHVWLRQWKDWm,jOO
                                                                      MXVWJRDKHDGDQGWDNH>DOO@WKHEODPHlFDPHDIWHUWKHSRLQWDW
       0F*UDZY+ROODQG                              1R       1R                             0F*UDZY+ROODQG           

   ,IWKHUHZDVHYHUDQ\GRXEWWKDW0LUDQGDJLYHVDVXVSHFWWKH              ,QGLVPLVVLQJ7LQDjVKDEHDVFDVHWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWLVVXHG
ULJKWWRFRQWUROWKHVXEMHFWVGLVFXVVHGDWDSROLFHLQWHUYLHZDV         DFHUWLILFDWHRIDSSHDODELOLW\SXUVXDQWWR86&F
ZHOO DV WKH ULJKW WR GHWHUPLQH ZKHWKHU WKH LQWHUYLHZ ZLOO        7KH FHUWLILFDWH ZDV OLPLWHG WR WKH DGPLVVLELOLW\ RI WKH
SURFHHG DW DOO WKDW GRXEW ZDV UHPRYHG DV ZH VHH LW E\       FRQIHVVLRQLQOLJKWRIWKHFODLPmWKDWSHWLWLRQHUjVVWDWHPHQW
0LFKLJDQY0RVOH\m7KURXJKWKHH[HUFLVHRIKLVRSWLRQWR               ZDVH[WUDFWHGLQGLVUHJDUGRIFRQWLQXHGUHTXHVWVWRVWRS
WHUPLQDWHTXHVWLRQLQJlWKH6XSUHPH&RXUWGHFODUHGLQWKDW                WKH LQWHUYLHZ DQG FRHUFHG E\ SURPLVHV RI OHQLHQF\l  2XU
FDVHWKHVXVSHFWmFDQFRQWUROWKHWLPHDWZKLFKTXHVWLRQLQJ              SDQHOKDVMXULVGLFWLRQWRGHFLGHERWKEUDQFKHVRIWKLVFODLPD
RFFXUV WKH VXEMHFWV GLVFXVVHG DQG WKH GXUDWLRQ RI WKH           WLPHO\ QRWLFH RI DSSHDO KDYLQJ EHHQ ILOHG EXW ZH ILQG LW
LQWHUURJDWLRQl  0RVOH\  86 DW  HPSKDVLV              XQQHFHVVDU\WRUHDFKWKHFRQWHQWLRQWKDWWKHFRQIHVVLRQZDV
VXSSOLHG                                                               mFRHUFHGE\SURPLVHVRIOHQLHQF\l
   ,WLVWUXHWKDW7LQDGLGQRWVD\WRWKHGHWHFWLYHLQVRPDQ\                                            ,,
ZRUGV m, ZDQW WR H[HUFLVH P\ RSWLRQ WR WHUPLQDWH WKLV
LQWHUYLHZDOWRJHWKHULI,ZLOORWKHUZLVHKDYHWRWDONDERXWWKH             7KH$QWLWHUURULVPDQG(IIHFWLYH'HDWK3HQDOW\$FWRI
UDSHl  %XW WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW KDV ORQJ KHOG WKDW mQR            SURYLGHVDPRQJRWKHUWKLQJVDVIROORZV
ULWXDOLVWLFIRUPXODRUWDOLVPDQLFSKUDVHLVHVVHQWLDOLQRUGHUWR
LQYRNHWKHSULYLOHJHDJDLQVWVHOILQFULPLQDWLRQl6HH(PVSDN               m$QDSSOLFDWLRQIRUDZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXVRQEHKDOIRI
Y8QLWHG6WDWHV86$Q\UHDVRQDEOH                 DSHUVRQLQFXVWRG\SXUVXDQWWRWKHMXGJPHQWRID6WDWH
SROLFHRIILFHUNQRZLQJWKDWH[HUFLVHRIWKHULJKWWRVLOHQFH               FRXUWVKDOOQRWEHJUDQWHGZLWKUHVSHFWWRDQ\FODLPWKDW
PXVWEHmVFUXSXORXVO\KRQRUHGlZRXOGKDYHXQGHUVWRRGWKDW                  ZDVDGMXGLFDWHGRQWKHPHULWVLQ6WDWHFRXUWSURFHHGLQJV
ZKHQ7LQDUHSHDWHGO\VDLGVKHGLGQRWZDQWWRWDONDERXWWKH                XQOHVVWKHDGMXGLFDWLRQRIWKHFODLPo
UDSHVKHVKRXOGQRWKDYHEHHQWROGWKDWVKHKDGWRWDONDERXW
LW)RUWKHVWDWHWULDOFRXUWWRKROGRWKHUZLVHZHEHOLHYHZDV               UHVXOWHG LQ D GHFLVLRQ WKDW ZDV FRQWUDU\ WR RU
REMHFWLYHO\XQUHDVRQDEOH                                                      LQYROYHG DQ XQUHDVRQDEOH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI FOHDUO\
                                                                               HVWDEOLVKHG )HGHUDO ODZ DV GHWHUPLQHG E\ WKH
   8QOLNHWKHVWDWHWULDOFRXUWWKH0LFKLJDQ&RXUWRI$SSHDOV                 6XSUHPH&RXUWRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVRU
FRQILQHGLWVHOIWRWKHLVVXHRIZKHWKHUWKHFRQIHVVLRQKDGEHHQ
JLYHQYROXQWDULO\7KHDSSHOODWHFRXUWVLPSO\GLGQRWDGGUHVV                 UHVXOWHG LQ D GHFLVLRQ WKDW ZDV EDVHG RQ DQ
WKH TXHVWLRQ ZKHWKHU WKH FRQIHVVLRQ ZDV LQDGPLVVLEOH E\                 XQUHDVRQDEOHGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIWKHIDFWVLQOLJKWRI
UHDVRQRILWVKDYLQJEHHQJLYHQDIWHU7LQDLQYRNHGKHUULJKWRI                WKH HYLGHQFH SUHVHQWHG LQ WKH 6WDWH FRXUW
VLOHQFH ZLWK UHVSHFW WR WKH UDSH  7KDW EHLQJ VR DQG WKH           SURFHHGLQJl86&G
0LFKLJDQ6XSUHPH&RXUWQRWKDYLQJVSRNHQWRWKHTXHVWLRQ
HLWKHU WKH UDWLRQDOH JLYHQ E\ WKH WULDO FRXUW UHSUHVHQWV WKH      7LQD0F*UDZFODLPVWKDWKHUFRQIHVVLRQZDVLQDGPLVVLEOH
VWDWHjV ILQDO ZRUG RQ WKH VXEMHFW  ,I XQGHU WKHVH              XQGHU 0LUDQGD Y $UL]RQD  86   DQG LWV
                                                                          SURJHQ\7KLVFODLPZDVDGMXGLFDWHGRQWKHPHULWVLQWKHVWDWH
                                                                          FRXUWSURFHHGLQJV8QOHVVRQHRIWKHVWDWXWRU\FRQGLWLRQVZDV
     
                                                                          PHWWKHUHIRUHWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWDFWHGFRUUHFWO\LQGHQ\LQJWKH
      ,W ZLOO EH UHFDOOHG WKDW 7LQD DVNHG WKH GHWHFWLYH QHDU WKH RXWVHW   DSSOLFDWLRQIRUDZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXV
ZKHWKHU WKH LQWHUYLHZ FRXOG EH SRVWSRQHG 7KH VLJQLILFDQFH RI WKLV
TXHVWLRQ QHHG QRW FRQFHUQ XV KHUH JLYHQ RXU FRQFOXVLRQ WKDW 7LQD           7LQDGRHVQRWFRQWHQGWKDWWKHVWDWHFRXUWjVGHFLVLRQZDV
HIIHFWLYHO\ LQYRNHG KHU ULJKW WR VLOHQFH RQ WKH VXEMHFW RI WKH UDSH E\
VD\LQJ WKDW VKH GLG QRW ZDQW WR WDON DERXW LW
                                                                          EDVHG RQ DQ XQUHDVRQDEOH GHWHUPLQDWLRQ RI WKH IDFWV  6KH
      0F*UDZY+ROODQG                             1R    1R                           0F*UDZY+ROODQG              

GRHV FRQWHQG KRZHYHU WKDW WKH GHFLVLRQ WR DGPLW WKH         7KH 0LUDQGD &RXUW PDGH LW FU\VWDO FOHDU WKDW JLYLQJ WKH
FRQIHVVLRQFDPHZLWKLQ86&GDVmDGHFLVLRQ        SUHVFULEHGZDUQLQJVEHIRUHWKHFRPPHQFHPHQWRITXHVWLRQLQJ
WKDWZDVFRQWUDU\WRRULQYROYHGDQXQUHDVRQDEOHDSSOLFDWLRQ       GRHV QRW SUHFOXGH LQYRFDWLRQ RI WKH ULJKW WR VLOHQFH GXULQJ
RI FOHDUO\ HVWDEOLVKHG )HGHUDO /DZ DV GHWHUPLQHG E\ WKH   TXHVWLRQLQJ
6XSUHPH&RXUWRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVl
                                                                      m2QFH ZDUQLQJV KDYH EHHQ JLYHQ WKH VXEVHTXHQW
   :H DUH SHUVXDGHG WKDW WKH VWDWH FRXUW DSSOLHG FOHDUO\      SURFHGXUH LV FOHDU  ,I WKH LQGLYLGXDO LQGLFDWHV LQ DQ\
HVWDEOLVKHGHOHPHQWVRIWKH0LUDQGDUXOHWRWKHIDFWVRI7LQDjV       PDQQHUDWDQ\WLPHSULRUWRRUGXULQJTXHVWLRQLQJWKDW
FDVHmXQUHDVRQDEO\l,IZHDUHFRUUHFWLQWKLVZHDUHIUHHWR       KHZLVKHVWRUHPDLQVLOHQWWKHLQWHUURJDWLRQPXVWFHDVHl
FRQFOXGHDVZHGRWKDWWKHVWDWHFRXUWGHFLVLRQIDOOVZLWKLQ        ,GDWHPSKDVLVVXSSOLHG
 86&  G DQG WKDW WKH JHQHUDO SURKLELWLRQ
DJDLQVW JUDQWLQJ KDEHDV UHOLHI ZLWK UHVSHFW WR FODLPV        $VWKH6XSUHPH&RXUWVXEVHTXHQWO\H[SODLQHGLQ0LFKLJDQY
DGMXGLFDWHGRQWKHPHULWVE\DVWDWHFRXUWKDVQRDSSOLFDWLRQ       0RVOH\86m>D@UHDVRQDEOHDQGIDLWKIXO
KHUH  6HH :LOOLDPV Y 7D\ORU  86      LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ RI WKH 0LUDQGD RSLQLRQ PXVW UHVW RQ WKH
KROGLQJ WKDW mZKHQ D VWDWHFRXUW GHFLVLRQ XQUHDVRQDEO\       LQWHQWLRQRIWKH&RXUWLQWKDWFDVHWRDGRSWµIXOO\HIIHFWLYH
DSSOLHVWKHODZRIWKLV&RXUWWRWKHIDFWVRIDSULVRQHUjVFDVH    PHDQVWRQRWLI\WKHSHUVRQRIKLVULJKWWRVLOHQFHDQGWR
DIHGHUDOFRXUWDSSO\LQJGPD\FRQFOXGHWKDWWKH         DVVXUH WKDW WKH H[HUFLVH RI WKH ULJKW ZLOO EH VFUXSXORXVO\
VWDWHFRXUWGHFLVLRQIDOOVZLWKLQWKDWSURYLVLRQjVµXQUHDVRQDEOH    KRQRUHG    jl  4XRWLQJ 0LUDQGD  86 DW 
DSSOLFDWLRQjFODXVHl6HHDOVR)ORULGDY7KRPDV6&W       (PSKDVLVVXSSOLHG
DQG'RDQY%ULJDQR)GWK
&LU                                                           7KH6XSUHPH&RXUWKDVUHFHQWO\GHFOLQHGWRRYHUUXOHWKH
                                                                    0LUDQGDGHFLVLRQ6HH'LFNHUVRQY8QLWHG6WDWHV86
  ,Q WKH 0LUDQGD GHFLVLRQ LWVHOI WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW          &KDUDFWHUL]LQJ0LUDQGDDVDmFRQVWLWXWLRQDO
H[SODLQHGLWVKROGLQJLQWKHIROORZLQJWHUPVmWKHSURVHFXWLRQ     GHFLVLRQl PRUHRYHU WKH &RXUW KHOG LQ 'LFNHUVRQ WKDW
PD\ QRW XVH VWDWHPHQWV    VWHPPLQJ IURP FXVWRGLDO       0LUDQGD DQG LWV 6XSUHPH &RXUW SURJHQ\ mJRYHUQ WKH
LQWHUURJDWLRQRIWKHGHIHQGDQWXQOHVVLWGHPRQVWUDWHVWKHXVH       DGPLVVLELOLW\ RI VWDWHPHQWV PDGH GXULQJ FXVWRGLDO
RI SURFHGXUDO VDIHJXDUGV HIIHFWLYH WR VHFXUH WKH SULYLOHJH   LQWHUURJDWLRQLQERWKVWDWHDQGIHGHUDOFRXUWVl,GHPSKDVLV
DJDLQVW VHOILQFULPLQDWLRQl  0LUDQGD  86 DW       VXSSOLHG
$PRQJ WKH SURFHGXUDO VDIHJXDUGV WKDW WKH 0LUDQGD &RXUW
ZHQWRQWRHQXPHUDWHZDVWKHIROORZLQJ                                ,QWKHFULPLQDOSURFHHGLQJDJDLQVW7LQD0F*UDZWKHVWDWH
                                                                    WULDOFRXUWGHFOLQHGWRKROGWKHFRQIHVVLRQLQDGPLVVLEOHXQGHU
    m>,@IWKHLQGLYLGXDOLVDORQH>LHZLWKRXWDQDWWRUQH\@DQG    0LUDQGD VLQFH 7LQD mQHYHU GHPDQGHG RU UHTXHVWHG WR
    LQGLFDWHV LQ DQ\ PDQQHU WKDW KH GRHV QRW ZLVK WR EH   WHUPLQDWHWKHLQWHUYLHZl$OWKRXJK7LQDVDLGWKDWVKHGLGQRW
    LQWHUURJDWHGWKHSROLFHPD\QRWTXHVWLRQKLP7KHPHUH        ZDQW WR WDON DERXW WKH UDSH LWVHOI LQ RWKHU ZRUGV KHU
    IDFW WKDW KH PD\ KDYH DQVZHUHG VRPH TXHVWLRQV RU        FRQIHVVLRQ WKDW VKH DVVLVWHG LQ WKH UDSH ZDV KHOG WR EH
    YROXQWHHUHGVRPHVWDWHPHQWVRQKLVRZQGRHVQRWGHSULYH         DGPLVVLEOHXQGHU0LUDQGDEHFDXVHVKHQHYHUVDLGWKDWVKHGLG
    KLPRIWKHULJKWWRUHIUDLQIURP DQVZHULQJDQ\IXUWKHU         QRWZDQWWRWDONDERXWVXEMHFWVRWKHUWKDQWKHUDSH7KLVLQ
    LQTXLULHV XQWLO KH KDV FRQVXOWHG ZLWK DQ DWWRUQH\ DQG   RXUYLHZZDVDQXQUHDVRQDEOHDSSOLFDWLRQRI0LUDQGDDQGLWV
    WKHUHDIWHU FRQVHQWV WR EH TXHVWLRQHGl  ,G DW       SURJHQ\
    HPSKDVLVVXSSOLHG