Court Opinion

ID: 4058789
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 09:19:33.265268+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:41.422744
License: Public Domain

Cm.\¥»\ e¥ \\.k'\m`m€/\\ &\)`>eu\j Ne`. M(L E?'biq?*q"°;] §§ `p u§qm

Tv'm\ Qw¥ mims CRN mo m /A') ,
. , RECE|V
&00<-\€ @1¢3\)€\@\ (}K(EIBM § , \V\ Ma.“q&'bm@|: chMmEADL|ANpFEALS
'\>\s'm.'\¢:r Ceu (l-Y
§ mean (x:m\)'m. T)e\e&>meu FOQ \l-D`l wfl\T

\\)ew e.>mu (~`»1(1\>¢'\0.\ emanuel .~ a()`>\`\é(m\' pm~se and max -'“{u \»\L>\»\emn¢\um iv\ re\>\\[ Jn>~“w 'S\oi'e§ res?_mse.,
‘\¥*“AD_ app\'a€(¥`\'un ne w<\"\ cc -\'\a\)m$ on puts .G¢\c\ CQSOBL':\'RJ“\[ S\\eu.. '“'\¢L.pow'"o.¥ penowa

\‘ j-:ALTS.
'Wm. S¥ale md a m e \\M.Awkwa¥k \u<~&¥ef»\*\a\oeas @eq>u$ on ‘\{/\o. ZZAJ o\a.q ec Maq 1015 »,`i'fhe»'
wi\;m¢»\ ¥M \\.3 ap,,\'.w‘;: \X\b»¥h day o m 9¢96\ w\§', Ce(‘\-\"Q\QL\ Mu¥\ wCU Ae|iu€r€c\'\)~¥\m‘\§ls*dejrmwk. ,
\v\ i\'x ws\)mse We qu.\e (°)a{ms WuL"Opp\lea\-\'s 'Duu,\,\e..\eapa ' cl `\w\ is Mer'\\?\e;s ." v
'“\e 5¥!€1 a\.w `wwo\c€d ¥‘g\a, \ae\n\l$ ym)f.e`\'m“ a_\ a \nc¥\r\'\ne \;{`\ea‘§on.Am\w \'\ ~“\IL S'\a"\'e Ci]¢cs wse.r|aw
`i\A ' §§ b \'x'§ pem\ ‘“\al \'\\e S\n'\env\url ne)r \MQ\LQ..GN\ pa<¥ieu\ u<`\~cec\ §/\ee.>ii\q csc pce`\u.¢:\'\re_ .'\"\¢\£ S`)rE\‘\f _
wm , aim Me$ §\ mma-cal pre\un\'\ea"in §\\' dunhqu 1`¢`\\) qo\?, ay\rj \>.ep rea decade ~}v¥¥|; Appl;on,£a,:'
A\\e¢n¢,i\bnl_\;;;fl\e €\1\¥£ \>a».\`s We,@euv¥%\ mqude \L£AQQ\\U¢\¥ ~\o sa¥.s(q me .>Z` m ~k> climb
over as cu’r`\£n x
Tiw_ $Gl€ £u(‘\z\/\U duiw\! “\Qz\/M\L A'P?`iem\)t srd\\\ *d ‘€Y\QQ)¢ '\"\.v \\¢b'\ §\'[in(;(.ifd$ usl'“\  o gac\'ual
1504`\5`. CM\C\ ¥u.c‘\:) m.-` \)C\\r\§ Y\€£\ +v CELMO\\S;\`¢'Rl-€ “.S"'ri(,\d.l&\\£l Po€'{uc|i(’¢.\.‘ , _ ,
Las-\'\ owe S-\ale \>.'e.\eh)fs am QQQAUWA s"\gmzd \>\\ flqu Nrwam‘\_ .dzw\n\ oc.\o( tying ably swemc,:\,-
wax maj A;XMH'LA,M tim§ '\m£.~. Cu.w\$€,\ s~`\n'\'£$ '\'Y\o_¢~ewo.$ N>'\s'.£ue f'€gur&u`)_g benjamde . t bmug(-\\/'
'i“»eegd\vAxve §M=\-x .' m _W._l -d@,

\»\ac!‘ mcmann .`

\I..[§LYAM£A>_'

"l\?\e ?\'\u§§ n(' ~¥Ma_ ‘5~\'¢'£\’€4 rvq>o/\S£. `\s w\ \w\a\q -.\¢\ amoraane€. \..>`\'\N\ Pnr\\de \\.07 ¢.(3 ¥MQ.TQ\<.QS pool
09'(§11\»\`\\\:.\@meeé)ums .5&» S\ole has \T'd '5& me u'\es‘>mse..@m\"¢.(¢§e\lwq Aa'.\u Lllbo)|$’ greg-1513 'eJ
ma;\ w~no\\+ mo mm zone Qm.%w,\s Q_SML dmi ¢€ Apa\ wmth §¢des rey-mm ¥:\.agé¢ia
`\x\v,ci,£eci_ m.u\ex\w ex`mtd m or a\\n.'\ -“\€ \\2-“\ G'\nq mt \»\m.\ 'I.Dl§'.

Dw_l\o\€ las fo\\\‘~ m ' \LCO\'\\ S¢"».\QAG \,\Cmom“£§um pa law,;n_ mmier'\'ec \\l.\;_ Ho&!?&j par 113 Applil’~
e§c'\e:\ g_.\\a.~;eiu\ §xumm'x\ \r\e c\ \1.3\ S\ » me Qeu<‘¥ Pyeced£w\ . \‘¢\e\u¢hr`g "\e`m.r Qaw.\aw weeden .Su“)or{?§
\;s B>¢\\L)W Claiw\ (SQQ,QMQW\\> c;ETm/v\ ..'¥\¢\e S\c.la.c)oes m\re»lf a\\q emde in suppeg¥oc k rm‘bn¥u»\
`“\o.. S\t{\'€:`s \'w\a)¥exio\\\\{ v\-QT`uAiee£,\ \u\\“\o.é\ah\| \`v'\ x\\m‘¢_` l\'\\a \\.e') }\W\Im\»`m aul`\\'$ nol
9=€\“¢§1¢2¢§\ "`u\ ‘¢¥x a\é¢\‘¢w\v°\\\¢e$\‘$a\i a~& pre\:c\&ua'\e§=m "rv'\\ne £\pe\{ee.\w`o;\“: \\'I$\e 54¢.4\1 ij fn possessed d 4412
o€(e“!e saved F\'\\e lamb Qb\`\ce. be <_-\MN \\m '\¥w.. “‘~e npc<¥c\$ well w\m` k §\\oes'~\~;gdi$r ”2¢\)2(% C.qrclci rml
ike %qe:zu \¢\Cwe\a»\ q"\\»`w\g -\X~n.w\e \`a moe c\qm‘.z\'¥'¥\o Yec§£m\ C&.> mmH ' 1011 0"`¥'¢~¢§\)@.{ Aei" `».\¢Llel'm»¥

12 ‘l\s~\ c°¢_§ece\c§m\c 1 esm §va\a-_s .e¢\¢;\ op?\icw\)r. eo\\¢"r.\\ is s~\-;“efz:lq“\{ ppm md §nuc\w_l `M`.§'Cafe as pari
riggs va&exeox'ux§ L\uw\xr`¢ §§ ‘duz 54¢\"2 and -\‘\NLVQ.Mm\ Q\wamw\£l\'\' kaun,\nm G‘.rb$.r €ng.g`¢ncj '\'\\.2\`( L..`A\\ QSSQS,
mcea \'\\n, \:>a\em bc meam-var`, L\\T\/\n.. c€z££m,\ gmcm\weM \\cu‘ J€cucf(\ m firm Sses,

'\ of 3

sr\'\ rue tomvcm

ease mc'\ C\r)ulse£;§ apr\`.' enh-\ Ceeeeve\[nq\q\ and.'\"\/\Q¥"Ggp\\eu\i‘\': Ne ~H/\.eon/

Q.S\A£at§_.;am\. \€é\§v\\m\, wm vo\\u€/~\'\\n S\m\e w\c\ \/\m\m c'@no'\ucled ca paye.r`i‘nuea~kgajfm}aui 33 i\ia!l'
§M\)s<-\uy\§¢\\\¢\.oav\€es\ao `\’ou'c\(.u Cc dl~(:?a\dan"md a“€gea\ \s\m~APr. 11 *m G.u.'s"-`cci\{ md 4"¢\0, 5~!€¢~1€ beneng

M ’ vS' q£\_L `\`war was .cw).d\»\ -“\L.S\cd€ a.:\d..\:ec\e¢a\ Cé`u_>u€m mail md earlui~\\\.{ ~\'w_ S\Q~h tx ¢>\ a mucj\ marc ¢mmr
(1 O..?bs 0(\4 l `

£\ ‘>\`\cov\§r a`§b mall o QECIJ\ES‘\' Fc>(LDUE`_ CEEOlBanV of CUHMS“ w\\areiw c:\)p\(‘o_un-\ §§u_e.s'a@%m\§l\
MQ\Q¢\LXS or\ ‘Q‘vf 5\>.6/\ d()_`a.\\ ,\"€\ mug f\£\n_ éw\\l!a\\`cr_\ »' S\Jd/\ Zi(.p |av\cd`$b/\ Sl'\d,dd .S'cduf\"i\'\\£" \u.(~’-¢ paup
M“ §§ " ~ sc&>\c \¢`§\-" rm,£\sile.[§u !-¥p\>_\ n\; war rov..mc aama)urv".. . chluJ‘./g
\'\'S Q§’~\¢lc.\mwu\ .-&~" Ev'.\\rp\__°§»i “ ms prime soc inch cl(),c§\|\

¥\e\%\cep_ campme.a'\x ~\ML S¥q~\e `\`w\\m kes.AoEch ~.

`w\z}\\{ \)¢\w.¢,.\o.e§no.$ Q§¢M}d`w\ S\\eldd $c)\`\\
FAAuAL mg BM M- §§ gm|gg: `

&'W\lmn‘\' >§q\€c\ \r\'\s pdi"`or\ 5\ kna"@undc\\"mé M“ §u.$\r\'\w\ raw -\\}u.¢\ ~\"'\no.‘;$i¢j\e amaral T"\cz‘>\»;`$r“m~"'
`\'\\C Mmulu¥\w €cc€l‘:\’o£ , flam%\j cth v€\lm\d`£d `\'w\. `m “\Cd &?t'\ioem'\' did ¢\¢s\' (Cai|d v\.c"\“\\¢w@) `MGW. (l-Qa“¢/
{\\§»rmac\ omni Cov\s \" , C\\v'\eo, '\.Q-‘ d\+o'.§iqm)r dawqu ‘Wm$ uz.\m\w`\\., odmls§o/\ op gd\\¥;’\'i\e.. S~luTé
up‘ms€$ f“\n Q\qi\m E\ `\F ` (% {§A‘\’\\Q,"h\_c\"\vi(dud mmr “ ur“sd\g\o_. em>r “(\u~\;\)/\ . 141 6 U'¢$» §uve.m@.[\cun("
\:\M \/\0.`d ~\»\?\a;\ '\‘\\L Qr£`udiii`d\ fled be ew$d} é.m>rS ww_s\'\n mms`\du£d wmu\u}\’u_£\\/ ra“\§r'\'\'vm “\`v\di\g"i`c:\un"~{.
gm w\\raw\s v.~raq\o¢. m 1/1,5.".>'\,11i \z¢> _<..c\,¥. \qqs.\s~\s. m 'Ltw.zd 354 haw .11\@. Cm#.~,£c“l:m;m~.(
AP‘>L£\\$ \/\GS G\§v r€CBq¢\\lid Cw\d N\Ed m '“Aa" Q.dl\W 4 S-Q.L &3¢ EX pG(lQ‘LOC/\Lo W\."’S/.\' §de §ql(?;€){.wczi`na.
l\?pi \§(<\c\ D¢T\lca»\\" >4\\\€(1\\13' Qe;\‘\\;l`mr\`q ~“`\.~Qr‘\\ac.\’ C‘u:msz\ dano:`a.\l )rkz>.a\mue'_` md adude a |. bad
accor¢\ln \\{ . f ‘ b rmwm\§_¢:\\‘) cmcludL¥k§\/~“\c;~e_ud¥s c\ mmb\£ w\>a\»".\¢ ~\'t\q¥ ma wix,a\Mone
p\ep.d `- \>..1\» FH>C‘QQI§D.A \\\) \~ncz\ ¢ 3€0 Q.q¢?€xmré \'.\L\J. qua ladngqu odd ¢?. Z$Old)(m"mcumau?
p¢o\aa\§<'i`\q" '\.va pmba§.i|i"\‘ su¥$“ue.¢\\r ~\» u,.'\é_£rw\(~\e, cone)`dmm N\ a.\)g>,\{d ~H}\e,\/-W¢ fawl[cmjr] would \\awz
edest c ?\md '(L(>p\icm-\'wm\d adp res \>QQ,XR\`\\§ v€MMAV`\'M,»Cm¥ ‘W\a~\'~\r\¢\a.\,\`§. Sup.~e)hw_. Cc:uA \/\a §
\\_AA ~\r§)\a¥ paz~sa many s\nm§\& \w._ cnm~\MlA' I(\)eml\\+..“\\\n `r¢r\zrcs¥\_-r.=r enc\s o¥`ius~k‘cesq require.r.
§oo_ Q.;q. H(l\T/\¢S v\\(Q(V\CF aL\(dL\ M»S.S\ q lS"ZD l.$b L€dld hqu??).npp|¢`mn\' \"S mda bwq@r.
app\sm\¥ fs QMQQQA§\§ pmm c.\.?\\¢\ m\/\c.¥ \\L\ms \esm\u£ Wn:a._zgk~khmnr ago ‘H\\`s#HeS \bdj\\werllw|w
m Mw.\>es¥ v_@o(\»'\~u \¢»La$ precise as pos.\`\\»la . .[\'W\icm¥ meal a.,\ A-R;`dma‘l ar Ezeb ucs weil wl»ere:h
\\Ll; `w\s “\\ N enu:\' \\c\..s\\a_wu.£ Ocec¥.d'ed Omd \\>\\\.\ \'uz dead u'¢ .C§Q£_ Amd(wd’ z it FZ£L"|F L¢ (:¢en€m,,
`\\§5_ 4\1¢'\9)" “s¥\md \{}>em\\y"` m L~\\ veaé\;\.§ W.po.¥¥`m cas s¥jad a 'u¢.. i¢`\-\Y/\L"mmu\u\`m em`emepp¥
es¥&\:\\`s\\;i 5¥\¢\&\' awp\{cm\§ c\\`a\ \\v\’ma\¢€, am m{iniryd . \La\ov.>\`“g- md udqu ac\w\`\.s>`.m d qm\¥» `)\'~e`\u¢liw¢l
\¢,.\\ sam 3 erro(`s'. _`

Coux\sol Pc\ arms a.@`da\£\-\ \`s_ cqu-\\d)i\q `\`¢\ sewera\ xesyee\:r .(\ouv\sel s~\n\e_\ \v\L~\¥/\pmug}\ '
'~\v\\,o,&¥igd¥'a\ \M_ 4 ` §Y/¢\Mcme ami minimal o \{e`cwl' awm\\`»gk[t‘. \'\me»ew}\c}udrda\ chch
§o(-\\'xqua§€ dnuv\o\'v,eg\w\'a m:§\ion gm dlswmq tef}:f§’f!€ou¢l¢dar\wdg V-»ic£j .-,Cmv\se\ aka £'|Qi'é'd %)!~H_\e. .
\Qf‘.m‘& ‘~\'Ka\/'\"\L 5¥\€\'0, \\a nu\"pm.)`\d¢;r;\ vc-\'QPQ“/\\> \\RM\ fm '\_ mary lLZD\l`| ' C\Q¢trl\‘ (_\o_m=$£} ,\*.\ d£p€m(m"'
dr ~\"\\a, S¥ale ami Me. " pmvz-\\\q~\' QM\M.\ dial md m cad"%wmgl\ " ')`v`\uw_')rgalad -£lu) pack
a§/Wm§l¢`\’m\'\m/\M. (:mmd S'Src{\'@§ \'M@_\/M\a»€v;us no 'iss\,w. vzqamh&_q \m\o\e,~.\eo rdl(.__How ~er,
\/\\n»~e.. Q¢`¢.v\;_s 3\1`),0\1. Q¢A eve.eu)m\' m\\ as "\"€m$ \>:QM_d_im-¥regam\‘€\<) bouh`\e£;§>arcly%\}i» dim
carl Q\e,a_$ (.@.Q,$P_. cup§ Q§}Hd {4\_ y\`(cm " \\mmm-mo\wm ¢Y»l_aw .)'¥\'\u‘!l dr 9mm +ing\r (.tm,md way
&\em\dd“e»\' 9 ‘ m)r\.v\ow +\\L. 6an \I\`§l m\c¢\\`v)/\ R \Ns che G;A¢,\ could haw sw\» adol(uj ap L`mn¢,"
acem\c»\g\\§. \"\m» m apphum\§£r' \\\m \Q@.av\ im\z\\`igen\ @Jm`¢ss`\w\? Lazd\ .Qu.mse] dch£‘§\o\~e way
w'w Q\_o.\\ H\)£ §M`S C‘ar¢`\ .dl.e)()end ur\ -\'\\LS~\Q`\'€, gendch md rcu`\€u> Qpp|icM a\a`\iv\

1935

 

(br £Qc,)rs ¢. $~\M aug M mci answer mecm-é\(é\¢"\\{ l [_`w¢\£@\ meade/5 k Ql\ ¢>~\Lur clm\u& .

'\\\. M¢q»c¥dzmw\_
!5<`>9\`\¢0.\¥ res'\>QA-Q\d\q rem.'..\AS ~\h, marx -W\er\' a¢;`odzqua`\'e, reveal ¥_'< lmpem'\§m_~\-\ powqu

wa\uu\'zc; LM`E¥\J~£, ass'\$\w\ca. 119 Ca,w\m,\ dd\"mf¢“$ee. o.q.l\jaHlQ./ml v..amlqr)ov\ :Z_FSKFJJ 3
a»\u\\t> ;&'“tg U.S-w®mvu. los md lsax/. 1333~/~)+140;¢,1?97)-,41\¢|&`.p¢H,`@@r 13 enin

  
 

   
   

~\t> cm aside a \\wr`\¢\ ‘;\. an order ~\r'\`r\_M/\~Q m§g\\-¥ be layman b\>§c>(~\w\i'xq ~\<:0@(`€.’ ew`ola'\w..
-\>\= dana\a\) H\.¢:\kdc}\m,\ 515 6¥"'\{\&`.1 (‘,\L\lw\ .`\i`d a.~\» \6\'| . ' "'~:.~'~ ---‘,~ ~ 14 »

Ap\`\uom\' Q~\\ad a Mo`\\`im¥d( Eufdw\\s`d HQQ<` "u,cpr\\¢\`\$& ’p\\`i!ar\'ii!v\.
P _ “1 n ~e v

' W` \` + mv m L 4a J
mumvc>\\u,\,\ app\?cwv\af)w\aq \oe,@uf§ed . ` h

1 Mcd col 1

‘Kes ed'gJ/(qm|m;@ duv\¢ chl. ’lo\f
gla.tml€'/| mdma l"MUWZ.
AUM }m:+ ,

 

_Car~\~`¢ cvcec`€¢>( §ém§¢;_ b
kqu § <“\I_\ dsem~\m)r wm w\u`\\e¢;\ ~H\wug\¢\ %"cd~ Q\G\Ss N\a`d (sx\_ `\’\»L?,ud c\cu/
O§>Lq.za\s“ \\» ~\M-. O'\d~rcc}r M+bmm; 0€€1~¢2-\3\ wasn va\>~r\l .LMm>:vaM ,L\-,‘¢H\»

@d<\§ll:us §§ l\\%\££o}mc‘ia SXQ.U<>! 150 Cccl£ ' ' "p'wwl“ l\ng A-N\- LI-€d\ae/
’\B\.L ' mich

      

15sz

BJECT: State briefly the problem on which you desire assistance

moi,i1011kp 115

\ NO.

.` l
i€CiCi

. ap

mar .\:;z _1 parkng 7L/1mC/f//1

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

60 r"~1~11102 'imn¢111~e/1¢er herai[# rerui€$irr/ 1114 lrLjLJ 111/mrp
1 1 ` " he
" ‘ -¢C '1//)1¢’01§€/ DQ.~/€!'/MM€ 71
Ciww wind p;`diiir) -Hi¢) ncciiagid
q §
_vi)i‘>§ l U€. l
v ry . ` -. w Unit: kw
e flra ne- chirdmcr MEZQZL;N _

 

 

 

 

-vi_ng Quarters: n 1¢1( K "Z//U_Q

 

~\!\/ork Assignment:
\

 

|SPOSlT|ON: (lnmate Wili not Write in this space)

 

§131 1117(215\10`

\`,Qui@
L/Q$Ci p0 51 %)/W

we

§ \@/

 

 

 

  

   

_;, . .
Posiég`gf' ,~` `

- l Completeltems1 2, and3. A|so complete

' l Print your name and address on the reverse

 
 

1:| Agent
U¢Addressee
C. Date o_f De|ivery

item 4 if Fiestricted De|ivery' is desired.

 
 
 
 

  
    

so that we can return the card to you. .
l Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,
or on the front if space permits.

B. Received by (Pn'nted Narne)

 

 

 

l
Certified Fee "

   
    
  
  

Retum Fiecel Fee
(Endorseme`nt Required)

Restrict

(E ed De|ivery E_ee

ndorsement Hequireq)
__ \
~Tota| Postage & Fees

. >ent To

; PS Form 3811, July 2013

5 1. Article Addressed to:

D. ls delivery address different from item 17 L_.l YeS
" lf YES, enter delivery'address below: -El No

§§H\Qr ®ng\\cdi> C1€r\<
\\\o \/1211>1&¢\ vt ($i< 1035
LQrQClO i`\`)<_ /1?0|`124 1

 

 

 

3. we Type
Certified Mail° Ei Priority Mail Express"‘
l:i Registered El Return Receipt for Merchandise
El insured Mai| l.'J Co|lect on De|ivery

4. Rest`ricted Deiivery? (E)ara Fee) |:i Yes

 

2. Article Nur`nber
(Transfer from service labeD

 

, ?DLB DL\UD _Ei|:|[]|] 5]151= B\+E?

Domestic Return Receipt

REcEi"-““ “-‘
COURT DF C'~"

101122‘"'7

 

Ab€\AC_CiSidia aim