Court Opinion

ID: 4039091
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:06:28.843927+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:46:37.552369
License: Public Domain

4111’4\4 4440.4~‘1\0~04\%3-“5(\>`3 77/ 133 »QL/

\=_4\ ` 14 1__'

P mt ' m TH\=_ CRlMW/XL_

, 33144031’3 \44314333310 1 \>\371\\37 comm 333
VED M ‘ DA\LAS 301,\1<174/. '73;3145

@R§§=§R\M\NAL APPEN§>U (‘,141\\`\'“_5 %F_EPUA&E,W'D 3"1'1°4'\'€.3 NSH)MS\=.
344 29 2315 Fc>& wm oF 1433€1% 30111>1~43 ' -
433 S 0 m3341\4`41\4,\€,3443 3\/\013 343330\103 3@4\34 %34\1434< 443144§34~304/1 m

44\\ MM?S "044 \1\3 304\441\14\35 43 mm ‘Emw\ 33333 100 1=10»044@55

41437014{ 34= THE 3333

4\`>3\\(53\4\§1 3333 4\\’€,¢1¢1441{ CBV\\) 1<4€& 0\1\/\<5~ 313¥\‘4'@\'\€£€41 341\ 42/ 17/2.040 FD(’

41101-3\\3?> MS€’JM)) 33£4~`01~13<11133 b\{ 0 31\1`45 1413 applin 3103 nem€t`
04/14:0 04333405 ,1\3>43§ 03413 331\3`43305 314/151 3@49; 0333 934¥4¢4,@54 m day
\?`44~34 343443141\31\1{4'1\44'41’34)04930\101/\(‘.€3,.\:4>1 434/113 1030 013-13 43 144";334 b 143
"14'€><3.31030 339/1414 1517@,353(;@111\\>4433,7'413\3 110 303\3`\<3{4: y
1’\0 QQSQC>X)\Q 304&39 64&&€1¥\@/5' 4;44\;4€\ 140 31001‘1\ 044\4`9%4 3% 0\414' 304 wisg
103 \¢10»0418:3, ©44. 4\429./2010 33333 434433 034)34 449 30333\1;1§
335 344 44421013010,€4>40:\3£§§§ 6 640413 RD‘:\O @4' 465€\ 4\/\€ mcch

z 3343 414 3440@4 1104\3 343 1333@ 334141 144334001< lace

V11131/201014\3 94501§31435 1113 391qu 34~133141;3113451111' 43
gwc)§@n(§ii@ ()L\\`q€Y\C€ 04’4 34`(’&4-11\€{ prp`l(C_QN CALM?/)cf> W€Hkn 441
gm C3544\13545>;\1113 3333 3\1)0113 7413 13134-1>104@4314< 343 015433 603/554

543 44133 133530.<{301\ 3111934 wm USN\SSED 340 N\SHONQX§ '
331 374>1470424334/, 1351 14§"00\14541~33¢>\>3\“¢4 444<@€£ 4@£3)0`144@)1 3301

5&03'\4\<51\310` 33330304135 1

2 1\1>4>11314147‘3 11334>04\433;034155'3 113331\153 ' id
- ‘ 1”4€34 41(-`-,143()\1 4414431\0”1 434 042 303 334:01330 04`.
004 w H\€A 43 0. 33330(445€£0411££ 0‘4" 443

©\‘4\§®‘|:@44 4 0459? 443 433 340331535 1044\3 3034
`14444 4444,444 3333 §344§€443 444 21 433 3141141121
4)5<43 14141341-;0 44 §444\14341\ 5 2011 4413401\30 3003334 §3113313343
o 434441414 4 1344 ’1>4§104 443€4>41£1@ 430

§5{$0` 03~1\3§% 34\ \=94034431\1,1 2044 5 34\3 had

1`3304<\ 3440 3\1\34430 431>1\ M+;>W`\§§ 443&\1¢4[>34433;4&\4©4:\® \;7§/?73/4£419$]§§}4 1535

` 3014411 3
SBNTE‘> 3“5;4§¥(§;4:§31\+§;9 'T 44:£4{)144 4\433\ 500111\11\,31\4 41033\\31` 33311\

P&Q€ 44 434011\
4 4\1\ 6902404€4140<4343{ 43{354414( 0394130\15 11 313 14464441413
?§%5\§::&;5§03054\3 3¢4/\\:431\33/ 344 593¢44435135 0 034K,:W133010 1131%413
? clq€ \ 693

4\\\<\ \0`\9 loew 101)&. 0. 1<95:`
14\1\1“9€\€ 0)4@`: pmcec\upg\§\\{ 11;§?1"§§€%€ AQDD*AM£V QMA,\;\£§ one M"°“?l"
$"1\9€>010& 31qf\ 09:\ 1N\9vv1¢‘v'1<>1\400 09949`101001217/201§¥51\0~\ 03;“3%0:1§1%%0"%
~ 9\\¢011\1911 43 1131\1`1910 11\¢. '5 '101(6361 963 m 433
0010`93 03 0 91<>4933101/1 1993 1199/1391 3140¢ 091/ 149911911\¥ 1103 41 951 00
many 0\;§401\3 104143 \94495?5 010 399554101'13 4943013 wyij <\ 1183-1109 1498
iz\wd, 441\8 61wa 433 Uwf<§ 918%\3®\181`1/, 949 949 ..... 3 441/113 d§)w!\
0004404119<\ 40 1q101>1\9 4109 44901`1&1 1101A 9><011\@€ 43013 md <1/11€14418
C€>\x\:€ 043 &111011101§ 3 ca1/1 18@91<“40<11\8 (‘,941\0`1 043}9 9015 43143£
(}Om\`\ \y¥@cprpp\ 03 and \ 1101“ §`V\U 1/1%\)0 441€@4 81`1( 'H\S Pe@©¥c§p 1335 )OQS§`>

003\19 014 if \41()§>\;€01\4%1:01<1'#141`193 404 UQY\ 0999:1&40¢§;\¢`1901§%1/
b b\\ 5 5 9<101'1
mg feb mg \-;;Q/XW§\§S § ‘1'1\;§3:0011? o%{_?] WS wakan

75?12(>11!, 0\43494 39\1@01 3
4119®13441@4(`111;¥;019194\/101/\ 4:1;1<388§£€ QGXQY€MSSLOX:QAU 404119
\ ' 011\ 141 b"> \ 091 01191\30.
UUKSU®®'B,\OM \.'991:§1119119 119 001@/) 41\99@10 431<1111><136£41\11&0
14&114 4118 C,om`\'

bSQS€/mc><§\€b 8 1
U\ gm“omj 5;0_£], AW {M 416.(\ 710 \)~Ui/ 09 1405an US:MC€Z AMC\ `AQS wm EA

90 3\'039@_\“T ALC§ I\O'\' PU\@/ Ol’\ '3.441'1.1

*Pf\&`§ 01 eggs ` )E>/Tk €mde
` ` 0 001<9& 3 1,2011(3403€556@>; 9
4)51`1\'1€)/\ \(\CS\’G§\O; 4:)5~€(§ C>°(’\ MN\SV\O\M OV\ gm MV 15121>'91 GN\AXOWM
\/\\QA mom 15 Q>`Q,O¢`\\V \'€C.(\b\€ QO(\ UMQ.\O r,.

3 v93pvv139 39.'“')‘1\13 rec§:wc`> 31001133 41190;111\4'

\>¢¢(@ 2 0¥3

606\"1 1115va 106/w 909 1103 m¥\-O 0
6100\116€1 1:\§`1)`“€§®1`€1 10 1\01\11\€[ 1110111 \/\0£ §§®§;;W“n:d:ho:.z;q C‘?ud
3 "3 n31r1635>1/13€ 0
1111 0101{11411\<) 110<1%00\61101\ 309 W\ GUHE§§W§ \13%\0)1\0§14:§9
1119 pble 51wa 1161 111\1§ 1Y10\~10V1 1100,% @66:1? 1$6111 111€6161` 15 <1<131`€>
310109 §0003 ‘0"01\000y 5 2010 001 1601 13 001611 2011 11000101‘ bo+h
(100111\6)161&¥1<>111 111\6€1>11\`1/316116111 511 &f>, 1003 1311 951 AMA d&@gq(011101 3
6011\610¢161\@¥\£1\04\\16)“1 1101 1166 on 11113,“§01/¥115>,@¥\9 <11;1 }1/1140116
001)1166\111 13 6\1`011613 0 1013 10101 000/10 0\\@€0011\,\05;7% Um@s,m
1`31`&11)1\0»310101 03\600149 %1\3\03`111<)1 11 13 6066<1 6&61\17613,7165/416'3
\;>< 0 10 90031` 6103 1115 memo -011101~`00 10?¢11 0103@6110)161> 00 ;,20/)
HMQ£ 000;00&11€¢ 13 1116$13119;“ 116 0001¢101:111`00 11\€<”€® ;€b 143
1\1\0&\1 1/10& 1101 011\66 O\f\ ‘\1/\61¥\0\'10/1. /19¢;[1;@1\1( oeun 1116 510<1'6 L{1€> 5311111111
1010 Mc>wkw 1116/6001 01 601`\1\1`11011190 0099\/\6+116 n1|:§<1¥13001\01 011116
1\600111€( 110/\61611/6%11116 611qu 010¥\1"116€\
900 000 101011>\01\610\03\ 106 ongme

° \U
m 11011\1(1 599%\,\>06%6131\\10\\ 61111111\016?(§`@13
FCCJ>N\fY\€V\A C<`*QSX\€W, 01\/{\;\6 (>1`&9,\<` éQj`M/\W 11531\“€£§>\ §©01661/\1100}’ 1‘1€!1¥1:1\5{ …
1€265966\ 3 11101111

@=_V\TW\U>(TE 31> 366\110:

/1\/ 1101 010 501/10 20 2013, 1116 1006901`
1/1¢0%1066?!1'1116;0?00101`1601131600\/ E1z31m/Y106v;y01`.3 ackka 1313 0{1>1€1)\1§§11111/11~
1010¢1,\~1@>12,0011113,“1>1‘/321>7 111 15010131 60111)11\016<11$111)11 P.@ 601<123 ,

111/1310 71< 76111

///
§LNMQ[leL/(EK§OM 6 n .1

qu€'§o£‘z-

».`k

'~~0.33 `; ’ ~` ' .` (\_m&__ 1405 F\O-Q`\S"3 83 ¢\0'-011%~1

. " .- 1 ': NQ ?>
-5:_101>310< \30\0\0:,0000 " 4 000/18 001¢'>/,”1:3<31¢

11\0r1€>10 40 REQF__\v,; m\wzm‘:; 011§:1_13\ ~“
'I'O N\\Ck-\P€l._ N\C>RT'C>RN P\CT 031=’:201`?> l

'1’0 "RE.MD& %LS`~; 8000-limit 818\0 80018:1" ~' ' *' '
_ , 0011\551\10€4:`0“ 3810\;&’\1)4\1\<8150/) 818 834 4101/10"»111 +11.0\00\11. 1134va
4`\4°:3 311104101/1 40 10881\/8 +~\:3`9 § /3)1.0111 001111€11114§/)111`>1181144@ 1441 all/133 4401-1011 1914
37 §§ 23 .\.¢»3_,{3/\ F§B‘QH@>?> 'U\'~'{ p€`_ Ovm Q by CL 7 ga FIQ"'QH@Y SQXLA@J‘ MAH 337
\ ‘r;: 1388 010 ;h@§€cmc\z~, ' '
'5; Z T bmw<'m 8 §
3 1108 001:§0\ 40104 84108\~0813\‘4\8 " ~ " ~
H__` T4'18,0»-» 8 ~1:5&840;488’18§/140 » 13 __ 1.
. S”h@ 010011"1 01‘1\834 0(??\14011140
0 TW£ 043%.11<8 1831;004$>
‘7 '1'1\8 0110103\11/\0\3\4 :1/\18843, _ . _
8 1119 3 c 1 nel\`mfna:\ 111?4`104 00081101108 284/080 M\
'C{, ‘W\@ 0\00114 811\4»3-\>1\03( 1084`831 0&§40\/<4848\11)8 8000584@0411111 0.1 000/1300 211\<4400
-~ 738@43{¥\0338¢, 3133310`1`110 004301\1@.1<311~1€13\4&, mere 00011424.
OA 1022/3010 m\\u€> 10\1<.8 303 . 334 £`3\€3;\3;33333@ 3333¢3, 3100\18_,03,3:14 33333373 md 33/2_33/&,0
Pr~%u§xo€\r»;@{§&& 01011~»~/~<00 '_. 4148310)333; 3@33}3 ,/3@{3 fm 33,330/@33,33 33\@ 573 , 7<5>77£`
M4Q CC\$\C\UC-\H`(\LS+ U~x‘tp(\(W-GC¢ Al\c:(_q@\ 4\4’&:142.@440_) 0843\& C,~'\Qé(£') &`S(\Mc§c; ` C;Lu )Q fogg J;,_.(G__U §§
010(31:10~011§3')`"&11§ 041\QLQJ 188 1311`1`€%4 0480‘3 dec 25 2010 Tl/\Q, Tuc.\xctc` IWQm/;O},@w 3§,
C0\1\0{1\00\44‘S409y (»4\9001`<_4 34~`1~031/100 /1 0119;~. 000va 041100\;) 011/1 010@\4~21 140 23<,, 12//7/@030
11 3> 013411`;4 80004'~537 1011-133 ‘)\/\33<¢1<>432\4@13°\33]3333 4@4`4`3\¢3/33334 5330033 33@0 I%EL 37077€7\ was
01’\\`1::4854 11'138{34@111\4081`0 €<`-`>10 603813031(”8\1 00<,.=5,<:3 g 333 33 3;333_;,, 5 __
\1~01100;818;08, 8081\1\8:3 0§3§3108& U40 <:)/11,1~74q 050 Yfmw` 804 410 8000 1040 1144 44111€8(35

°"W€<"`J' >°4{§° MM` LBM,' ama d"€` {NE~D… 413 C£>~LU\`4 40 401`\1.’10\{0;4 !%:41` 1011-1@/‘
4\\8»‘» 3888 8888‘8~*88 \“488 48881 888 "‘ 1810100 , 10 1100 310733¢033

"‘7`,)_.~";3~' 3 ..,-0,

8501{\€}§13:131.10 ’33333\3 .,3- 1 '
001=1/\/165'8 ‘735“~" g {7'3'“
445:1133¢01/1,`7“>§77583 ‘

 

   

 

 

  

  
 

  
  

' - - 0100¥\0041~ 00 30000:. »

1 1310\~840 0001\@373 1184 3>3\ 3333/030 37, 3013 1110 E>rm>m 000\111014 1013 1800 130
1\1\110&3140 (;1011\\/18§ ay 11'\1'1'101\5 0\<541\0;1 du ’1,8 3 10 14\\180411\1\`41§402\ 1812 0044€15 71071333_7
l_01>03*<3.~,4€ 03103§0\1130€30\3 110 80112508 13084\1\1011§7011 \L .
0 3 :,3'47___,-: 3 3-_.;~;3_-_ . `.' l t _7 7 ¢>£MQ\Q\/\ L,`ML_}\E |QSQM

    

C,O\>~\`§< 651 CM(¥\\'\&\» mw 27 235
120 §§19\2999 wake

1519\ %5<>51`19\
- §913591\ ’©99%

19 919 1\3§9199 1595 11199§\9:5 +19 599 39991/ D§§ld\L Cler’é’$ 399

55ku 099§5'05\ C111111\1\05 155()@315& -
1\/\9119,\099\11 Fd\§v\q 1\/\9\19113 19 919199> 9311111/ 13`1<11.11`111 Cj@,\/<'S §§§§
599 §°9\11\ 911 991911919 1191910115 /vQ)IQI` wmch &991>31 1399 13319/)1111`111
\`91` 919€9115~\§ 19199\951119191113193913<{999 ;1113 915 10
1199 99 \991\9£91 F§é§>?~§ pmsz 1511 @11113 9 131119
§\\31/95< 919:991,¢11/95 1951 6 ;w€m®/)©§Q& B 10/91/19991‘ 1199
1193119119 1”9¢ 11199>11&’5 599:5\(@ ()Qfowmy\CQ/CX§ 2199 -0 1193 %9)`91)95 9391151§9111
WMLS 01;_11\51/:€¢ 1 1963 mQ,(U <11/\£5!\9\9@£ <`€Spav\AS wm 590 an(P/@/

1 13999<>911\1:59©1\ 591 Cm¢‘v 95 Ir\ §13511\1€\~ C\€)\\K`_s o 999\>915\51\91\€1` c€§lxy;<\, 1 391\

Q`\Q, {\M.i 5;® 2255-3 MC\' §§ §§§\lfidg worm/§ 1119 55{\@ C,UU/(\% `5'3§¢::59‘5

1999 919<:191\<9 99191<1“:199{99111119995319§ 11919)(3191999€11;

995 119 wv\p\ALnM 31<99~911\53,99 micable 9111129 09 1>1>§, 1995
1\@§99@11\<13, 91195 119 9mm 999931911¥991) 139 999 1911~911 193 11

99911<9199 09 2)1:10~911&:199%119199111>‘1911 amva

§§ §\€:51<$\<,51 C)@§Y\S &5\<;€,9§3!1§)1\11€§51® \1)1§1959 399/w
991§:5§:1\9<3 599%3959955`1‘@>@9 099\&`1\119>59 WHQ§Q 1119

551`\'<\§ 919 W%Wlhme§w:\w®\ 1315[13
§§11§;;\(\ 915~§0195¢ “§Cl®§ 5 135519'0=1 1=10~&11 &¥l©~d\€¢{ 7
\“5(©@ C(~m\`LV\G.l SUBUX CM§COMQSSY\ YLWQ,}JEQV\:A iam

5§1`1§5§?91“5§\9&1199130®050€€@£155“& '5'553°53\&5

m §§\5§“% 1‘\<:>§6 MU_) ze>c_cmm€’>' 53/19§<'1_11)0$ I¥\QMG\` 01\9€,911~{\9§{9§5 (1@\@(\

MD*( §§W§€d :1; 1199 999 999 5'5; 1111(.'11111313
GM‘MM Mp\ 119197, 9919§5\9§5 xii/999 959551\§\ 9991111§9

\N&§::`§$/ ;%\>\`\ 'j__&\n\ :(\ pviiw\b "\e?

§1\’19§?1\

' 5991>~91<\119‘11`1<9)@3911 IXSSWS

CA\)SE t\\C>S. \?m 'O\\%?> 82 FLQ'Q,\\&L{
EAPARTE . ':r\:» me comm grew/unuer

, . v , APP€AL% .
C‘D`\RU D\M 140 AUSWM.,')"EM§

PE:\TL@NERS men mr MMQUMMS
,rc>-rHE-HGUAM BSLSW §FCR!MML A\§H§; us`£€l©§e/l~n+mq M€M¢@M M,wmbem§
§\;L\ed causes $A€S MS mi‘c c¢` Ma/w P W&CUN'NC
wUdERba§hg(`mMy Dls{+l`c;\'w@)z~l< Q)z~l<+mpwuw:l`d C§M\QKMU@M

w Moww\q dwv\ €wv\ F\omc&>=_>> sexual w mmce\@y <1 `cl 29 Flc>w@
'Semm\usgc\n)§c am ch .

` `"““' C°M‘* 5
174'\€ pm cause

. "> ”U\/\€ S)ADN\ c\n‘e§r a{ll}r§ou)€'

‘i The 595 formed rds,

5 “\"N& bCO\/\- m %\\

e, m wman S'?\E>§iS

'l T-We R¢S“r Fv€lw\\`~mx\\/ R\€‘\~zo`\u{> pma/me SWQE}°>

S. 'W\e 3`\:§/\@:\%£<$@¥\ em“by ww»`QKw\V€rsw/\ omclh/Zw@ b€(%>we he W

w\&¥\ Fc€>>€\:€l 5 pma%hx&\w &Fzzz/%@@p»mi@ dl pm

q w\?,¥mmscmpl' bGM\QQrQ)/d?mc hw€v\qs,' beiwe£n \/'\lZZ/ZC"O "/27/2010})

LC> mw § *r\/\Q Wwi pio{~` hemci/)$,Qcm inz/zc>lo,c` n Dcahlci“Cour’c NCB
AME:@~ LQw`LS ()C`z>ur{'

“ MMUS CJ\@A Mu/ AQSe»/\SQCA\»"\ o wm

\z (W\ pizzle

- \% {¥  \/0P P\\%z'& Mdevkwwnuez%€> §hmo[)r\ meswé, ma

\\00 me:§d\b\zg 7¢-;~2:177'
QF_Q<<\HUTE oF S€Rv@` am \’1“”°"\177~'7"‘59>3

'I_ 14\€»€§0\{ C.ev$c\ ~\'Mc\:§'ev\ `S'¢Mv\umy 2"/ 1551 H\Q/%"€?Ch\? Mmd'hqg ?°9@/\ 1115
l\/\AOEA irc 'C\>UY\\’ SQ'QC":/\`\`W\`\ A()(s$:a.\§ 0 BQYJ?~?)G@ C¢ép€¥ol S“)Q>\'f@n, A(LS`\L;) 7§$@& 737/[
§
$€MQ¢¢K¢Q¢L.@QSON

 

 

001 121 6 mmym ~ » 33““3“11 1412@"4
Ff€% 0240 636 02 HXQ% 20434\30%

000 C.o/wm&f`c€ 54100_31 3000 200

9633650>1`/’0>20,2 7 5 202

C/O 43 41>4»\3< 02 &44`1\4103331)1)0265
F..O 001 `\’?.'508

"3(0‘\ .
44€§4211,'1">2~16711 ' '

210 0020 00 141-0002>~7~00 / 000;10-0&
17102>140=5 0 210- 011011

014 10 0`61\51 1€$101/0 40044\111` 43 1341 33544®3 114 436.013 4331 034 4114114 24111
621»;42 33164§3`041400421~:0204440040\4’\2 2006 014400444:341124110 q1333040003:n 3
4?01~000'€1104 0101’>6\9. 696 100 011:§11111211\1/ 0 2 114\`00110` \011103122§4111
0640200,014_1£+144016}011 11101144113%21131 1/10 01104041l 1110 9."4@
4014)4)004<01`14 010212§4040 4311000111d? 600 1103312411011V211
'01\`1\20104401/1 01\000'4\1\044011€333101\3@10°4?1 1005>(§~1€ 111/4110 4/0111142111_1[2111_1/111`113€3§1111;p

0120,43‘01~`0 1000 110 0106 0160)1\10 40 4401 4:0431 4011/130:3 20

m§§mw€ 01110>01141<10 11001 _ 1‘11110341'1. ' 441100 002023 '1; 1011)32§(§&§@4413103
UUM 131\1&3,@@_1~3@€%>1\ ’ 1011 09434€030&411¥09103€3483@<3 10
0334211\<6401\2§? 1406/1 0111<341014 601/410‘£13&14\*:013 334€3134`4`?3\313¢13}0>11100,0/0 010 @2113- 2

140\01113441020 03024 00111110410/12 41002111~$2 z 24111£4_14®/\113143 4§:649 11<1*3€1~3:::11

§ 1\ 01 2 am 000 1210ny 1030%1 0311101/
011111’0 1104/1110011134124210 6000 0 001211,1<0§0\ 2114/4 44%015:200151 044`11‘01\2
000)33€15 3044<& 0011:1103=11\33&1/\3; 313'\01& 1010 111111\ 102100112‘6%» 10101/1 03"1\11/ 1351112>> 2
1131 1001)40 4)03301 2134 1160 111 011<,0»1 4000011€&3 1114§0111\21104434310 0301~4144'01112_ 1011
2\_ 2111 %041&01®112021401202 01 Mu§/E@;\@&€M n 210§42§!@ " w '
, 0 333
001\\1\0 1 504 Cr\"`@$ 3*°3 m 2:3304§)121€ BEW 1100

33 ex 142;®&“§(33\&:340%§ 333 m 301\§333\03 011 010.15 10300,3` 3::~1§1§10[}/ ~2§>,\ 01;11111;@
v L10440€4~{1~11\M 44140‘;10 13 §§ cg111\1\.\)16141:1/1'\ 410\4@\ 104214410 1146 1114 1011
hew 410\110100110 43110 01>€> 61119,234 \PU200016:3033)010 014\€ 434:0 0014111)401114 2030$~061):2

1000 010 441101>1040§030 11211130 04040111044'3 10400010 44021101\11 1110-954 2142 1
` 1`11 0014\3‘§)1 001,/3€1111_15

' 0104310 11111011 2410042 2111¢4 1001 1120 111 001
3330\§02> 81 0001%€0110 110110"13000440'€ 1016 64014’\ 1101401)114111110,10, 54111113
p10<\110141:00€101\%311\03 4 .

 

 
  

 

 

   
 

~~i <> ' Febmqr\¢ \8.&0\\|
~§\v\m N\u\\_ R£mw\\

- R‘\EI;E,\\>T RE,qo-ou&\{ &Fw@ugs
mg m_X\Z~lOB`I"N ', Co,S€, N>OS, O‘S“-t\l-OOOG`I~'QR &, 05-¢‘~{ -00003 ._<;g

Emos@ we w'\w +{~Ls lew mem aka +v\@ %meg \:\wm;;@n+ M@d§ 4ain
ma tls¥€,;d»;¢s -\Me. "Y:\\cwmq Q:Q)nw 4`<>(~ AM@ ME,$ Gw\,e: ) _.
\.'W\e c, ` 9 owes mmc/x y C\z>\€»w\\$s€n m Mc>-m>w ap wmq ¢mmmy ,

2. 'W\e_ Q;Q\;/\a\ r@wc,v\'\mv\ce bo'vd$ '»s'\c¢r\e<:l bi Tuclqe Gm¢,¢e L,ew¢s gm ta/z/zo¢o‘»¢w@ z
moved mm wong ms\'oc\y G’<>r» ~W\e%;e MSQS/d?&,n§e,si _ ~
=Q.WQ \e%er €mw\ m 03qu Coovwo&oqd<.\&e;\ m., 3,€.@1¢,~ -

“- l‘€*€f.c"°”\ WCYW€ Wd/\“fl 5 M¢MW .c\o:hed Aquz¥ 21,2./.)12;
;,T';"MEQ qu\`c.m\ 'Iv\¥c_rw\$§i\dv\ c§oww\ev\i'$; mg ~
é>. 'W\e mae {'O" wwss,€>+ ecause v~\<:r=,». \=\<>~ous

2. x. r»=w-oues/ adm lz/zolzo¢@;
_ ”'¢. TV»Q_ Pml. wagmsz wuc&@~UQSM we com me c¢w\@l A-pp@x
A§Nv\eq `W\ ¥Qui&m. _

5 §¥c:§" m. \%B 514/a

¥4@\&1 U,mi+ _» l
?.% rank-cls m~fh ezm'~/o
b&uv\\»svil\@,, “I"xx?“??)zo