Court Opinion

ID: 4067516
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 23:21:43.578723+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:39.584983
License: Public Domain

%?Jz%|w'@\

'A.Jjus-.{L ¢QD, §015' RECE|VED lN

CG\ "?T OF CR|M|NAL APPEALS
/4&,<\ ll\ao>»m clerk whch x
l ‘> 2
cduf‘\~ _c£ Crtn;:~g: |QN€JS of T€“.c`) SEPO 2.15
Su Nr~€ amf z cla-5
F.o(_ 43¢,,< /513¢3\/ 501,4°\ Séc_&,w _ _ Abe\Acosta,Clerk

Au$“~t~\, T€¢r~s VY?H‘ 330.<§

 
 
 

223 A?P\lu~.d-.s pm 5a L¢$|Dm~:<¢ é~> SE‘-*`u ANS~`F§'E©E§VED "

C@~u¢e l\§o. F' Mll» QSI&-' C NHC 15 @OUWQFEQ‘M|NA[ ;'&?
ANAF¢~ Lc-’~ v. ’H-¢ 554-g ¢l'-’ Te.f):) cc th md d¢,¢.,N,J-‘» p¢r 6'\¢

Nu~bereJ mud Sl-DL¢J CAQ$»Q all ac#rw_ please Ql‘{ 0.5 Q~f{’f°f’f""~k

f 0\~<£ br‘ruj icc ftc 0~"(-€~4~:¢~ of €L< Co\)r+.

Tk»--L 30\) per nw p{§,~»\lo¢l p`;s:sl-Mce .‘,~s (:L:s imf¢ré¢-+ IWJ+€F.

3»`)\)¢2¢-@. l

43
/s/ Z/%%;\_
ANO!NN /VL‘/~r~ P. C|e/v\e~#>, 511 le'

9(20{ 5 ar §W
/»\rvwl l<\, Te,<_€

T'o TH£ HON02NBL£ Tubé.£ of $/HD CQ\)RT

COM£$ mw, A+Nl>a€w /!/II,KA<¢, L.¢¥Nz, iz@mr,;~+ fm se , mud
ifég)ecl-Fv L(» §xée.s fki_s h`i.s Pn> se /`esp¢)\)se €6 {;L\e S&n+d amf
§vo€r i/\) éhe above 5-1~;\,|¢¢{ a_,\,J pv,v\bered C&vs-e. Ir\) Su;)par§-
fTHer'eo{, _App|»`en»+ wov.»lc( SL\o\/o &he p¢(£owcwjl

ll.

Applimm+ (e¢'e¢`v€d ¢ ccpa c>é the 5£~+€`5 A`Nswe,r wci {Vl`€i
/Wor’a~¢(v~ o('¥ (4\» nu §uppoe*c 010 (3§\330${ ch.,ZOb/Uhis response
w.-H= be umw fatal if placed w eha u~w mm gbsre.m 0,0
01 bet-lone ..@`vjvs£ £/, 10'5_ See l-_{o\)s£ol~) v, ;gcg, ‘/97 6'/j¢-e 06 ngpa r.s .c.o~s.‘dere-Jp fw be
p,‘/eJ op =U~@ da~J-e H\¢l' lap"sor~)er~ de€wers €L\¢ /u\o{-\`ce (:¢> pf/.$o¢\)
Kawéhor;h‘es car mccm¢‘w$."),

. fc'

T}\roojl\w¥ dye Sb¢\\e'$ 5 \~)ase answer, 6Ae $.»L~<\+e Mer~el§ Nc¢p_¢'
Cbe {w'(a( }Z/roceed¢`pjs 46 bar A~~J fcfe~a'¢cgl~j §6¢(?¢.$ 6'})€"(`
op,\»ro». gmc A{,»p¢.~m~,£g ér.~( Y»Qe!\‘e€ `JVC\L ami .¢L.¢(»e€o¢\l»g am! tj?roh?er /'/\~N€£€/"
;¢)&{6\"<>/\) 06 U»,c /azw$ e\,wc(* pub 06 fh6 ease {awé, as a i’-C'
golé, repderec{ 0 fr.‘wol¢vs mr+»‘§\.Le|~

1/"9€/0( &5 "{ ‘M`S b&$e‘é \7?0/`\).l /M‘)`.S{Cao(¢`)`)j I`r\hca)r’/m+)`OM 04

_' érm\ Cw~se6, B<>+L ¢F wage m\ej¢&comgcw opu) b,< .So./\)i\c§ due 66
\/0/0/\~)6@(3 1‘1\)~(7>>¢¢`-(&6;`0/\) d@Fe/o.s€. w"@p H"e CF"€¢"Y‘L was .F°"'°(`¢J
006 bj él»e S£o.l.c/ gou/v_se(.'s fespo/o$e 60 é¢\e JV¢{SQ wa_g ”I
c{?»`J /006 @v€&> 661:)`~/4' (:Ll`.s won/ll be \a.N /`ssu¢s,'n R.|Z_ Vol 5/ flag
'XO, ZN 5/9/ /é/.. A:jm`r\)/ w"»@/O fee v€_SL,‘,~)S a Jvr;.) (;L,,,rge be »`,`),
é’./vde/J w 6Ae /‘ssue, 61~€ €r¢‘c\l C’°vr+ .A@/-u`e¢(‘ ‘H£¢ M<>+,‘o,.) mo
Hwe jfro\)wc(_s 906 he fan/d (.~o »es/~c\l,|.*g|n 1765 c{~Q{cA).se. new
\'~?.GS ’°O €XFW+ 6656"~"»°~{3 60 6)6¢|11\) €)\# <.`c@&¢`o,\) w_u=}?""r<- fh¢ ér'¢`¢'( €ou)r+'s '€><[9(4~.06.`0~' 06 660-6 €a&‘,
£¢..‘¢L .Czoo;»se! ashs,~" '.D"¢\ we 504 .~é?" /ZR¢ \/,lg,/ 193 \33-30.»
So#, of fl{e. claim h¢
{ecle.‘u.e¢( @a~s+»‘+vL;o~¢ 113 .'M¢\¢|e%ua£: represe,oé&+c@.\) are well
_§'-€¥Heé(.. [),¢ !A`??Q¢`u»o/¢ é‘lm`m»"/~>$ "Ne#£d'.\ue féprese,u€a¥»`ou
bears 6‘\€ b»rA\e‘lO» 06 g'/\ou'mg, 105 ch /)A~ep`o~de nwce op éhc e.u.",

Je»)ce/ ibew (:L) é$,¢\-l Cou~~sel'_s jeer§@m/\.¢w¢e mag 6666¢‘¢;`@-6/
,`.e,./ H'»a£ €|»~e repne'sc~é061*0'0 1cell below 000 lob`rec+/\)e S}'a~d\,.>db£¢ f//oba»-
b,,`€.‘Lt) €'ha{/ 506 »For 60\)»~5¢|‘5 ulc)'}?aa.-/Fe;r$,‘o¢/~éa( errory/ €6\'<'

6 f€su(& would have bee/o nme/c favorable (,~o &h¢ 4466¢~)¢(4/% -
/`~ 066er worng q y¢7.¢¢0:12`¢1b¢`(¢`~kj 5\/€,€€,`€¢`€~6 {.~o u~defm»/`~e Co/O»
£`Jemce /`A) 660 w\+c@,~e, §{rg;k(qu \/. rw)c\sk.‘~§§p_io_/ ’/é(p U.S,
<(0-98,1686/ 67‘/-(/76’5/)-_ 666 666 §aw\e: él`ma/ a de)~£w¢'(dué has
H,e r,fjA-{' 4.-¢ 6a 661£€¢},\»,»¢ &s§isfmoc¢ 06 @€ovA)-se( 146 ir,"d(, fewJ
H~s 64 l'€»(;l(e¢/‘ 60 \6¢.¢ rekso~'¢\blj commka ct~$s¢`séw\)¢e e€

a,,o d#'of/vet) clcl/‘Mj 45 h¢‘_§ §%‘/¢`3€,0"{: Am! fol/~Jcr<.@{,~/'ous

4\(
Gé(uoéa.é€-

iTJ/»e U/o"¥eé( .5£¢¥€.» Svlprem¢ Cou¢-\- /4¢!_5 ¢/Q¢L}`,ug¢( 6:° 6/66€060.66
$P€c¢"FFC _§v\`¢‘€@l\>€$ -.Q>@ A_@FFoPric$¢ 4660¢-'@3 \Co~¢h);+ wH-L\ fe-
s"pe¢% +° 611 guesl¢:o,\) 06 wharf cowsé.'iu'(-€a /a~ k 10535¢¢£¢‘\)~€
S(¢LNJMJ d( f€a‘$o»uabke/UCS$. lt r~l: 64¢\5 )‘,`)»s&ec( 6mplnq$¢`ae§
éha+ él».e `lipxolfer men su//\e, 06 /a€€;rk~"'e:) pe?¢arma`~ce /(erv\cu`/u`s
S,‘M'p(g r€¢sm)e\l,le»ess umch greva;f¢‘~_§ pfoz[¢s$l`o~q( Mqrv~\s.“
W"`vggl.£d V. 51 '1`69,\_¢ 533.1/.5.5/°(}1°°5). /H(Cor@(,`,uj(‘:)/ "ibefo'/e
€ouuae( upder+a/~0( amf /‘A) ormc\£ Ae¢c/`s»‘o/\)Vo») 56¢'0¢4<_33 \cx~¢(
_ &0¢'¢6)`05 600~)~0'(€(e pmo§e;y`o~a| as'
§>s&wce/"£ov~¢se('s alle`gd émc+rcaé (¢(c<-_{‘_<,.‘¢WS /u\)s+ s+¢‘lé /p@
SV\}?Je‘c~M {~o "Mea)umg)cv( Sdfu€"'wj" ale f\/lv${ be '(iMFv/\Me&"
'$0 606"0"€ b€¢d/\c dou,u=se€ dc+.¢, hrc 0;’ S}~c x wr`(( /v\a&e »Fome¢€ d.ec.‘;.;m) o/u $ér¢\+ew amf {-A.§.. 108-si 701 (100.2>._

 

fm 66\6 Cc\.sc .¢.-‘< z\z&f, AW\;LANL (ka19e5 60`@<( Covuo\seé NJ`H,
l'/~>e#edwe ass¢`s{mce 06 aau~$e( due 60 H\c Fnd- 66»04~ Qowo.se{
WQ$ woe%@((») mud obm‘ovs[_j ig»wnw-Jc o6 {:~\'\c lyef'£'/`/u€/\)('F pawl-
(M,¢l V»oc.edureg teeréc\m.‘p§-('o £I»\¢ m,‘%.‘$¢\¢.‘p§ defense 0616¢/€¢/
d6£er A{)p(.`cew("_g guile vF(¢:xcL. Tn`c\( Cou~. 1`1\.) s.e\,`)¢‘{,g doe &~o wo\o.ué\r.$ /‘/~>-6¢1)1`66`4`&1‘¢1.\11, é\~d cbs/my
631 J\)rg, .\ps+ru¢+?o»s w Ur\e tSCLMe ev-'eu\ (€& ~`\LS€'€ WG-! 660 ;_ywd ud -oi‘ me #e¢}ruc ramada/wee 06
1.)1'..410“\ mud ,‘va,llu~£ar:). 149 12ch
v.`@us(»`\ daij é'he *{-c.;+ sc+ é¢% w 1111erakqu [{nwia@; 4
-f'pmmeworl< 60 lé’{de\fmr,oe whe#)€f 1801/weld ach mud A/~'e`g)?(e¢% 50
€omp»om*i$e¢! U\e frb\pe-t’ 10\)1)¢61§»`»)11`.1\)3 ap Une ,ddv€r$an`a\ Froces§
66\¢6 666 Fe.su.('€ 06 66\'¢__- 6,1"1`¢( @auuo,£be Sa\`di 60 f¢\av~¢ p»fe£uced
la wre(?'di!)!c re$s)(%, Tho.m¢.<§.\) v‘ ,4_»§ i¢/. ‘} `.S.w\. 3¢( 6’0¢°, 311»¢3

' ~ ( 76,€. Cr'm. /¢pp. 6999)( 'c"£'"N§

 

"82‘{, 393 (TCX.CFFM¢ I4|0p l" FU/"6h€/M@r_¢ él've éI-)ij?wu‘:> 665+

ewaer w Se.~,~C/¢`Re'{v__:§_[_;¢.-les 901 51 (.6_ l{c(-(,§ (/470)\ 1113 "cr\ware-

mess“ was 1c(0r:61e¢( 60 1\100~;£0 de 16 410 u,\);c!iers&m{@ mg 06 re'
leva/~)’< 60¢+5 010/06 600)‘~" (Z.§. 01 g?`v;_;, /11 S.C&-j¢v’$<>@o¢z),
S{d{'c& 061`662:'€¢0663. dampe»$e»=€‘ /£.0_010~.;06 mvs6, 161`.r~c6 06061/ be
¢E.w‘mre 06 616'¢’({'€!0\/4106 6c\c64 01101-¢( /qw)a é\s 6%'€3 Fe(¢¥cc 60 H\e
) §0¢6\ 06 wrc\% 6606 éhe
1’¢{».€6¢0:¢{.0106 1_"1 db(c 60 wld kc fZI/o /`/\)60¢#4€0( 146@0/‘=¢1`01\) CLS 60

,.lemH\er 60 ?62006 131/1663 ar 1006 I! 1000/usaf 64`/'/.!\ 1/`/\9 66~`3

166065 6|'\.€10 66\0`6 assuémce;_ [¢))\(?(5 ‘SL¢r-\'-~ 06 él€e 860,01<£@\1¢6 06
001~1.100»4 0508+@¢€ jg~ar&péé¢,¢c' ,_'\ 1¢1.@¢¢,\,¢141,; 103 ,@e;,§@.\w-
6?0~0(~_/ame1udme1\/:6;s avoid 6400). /Vlorewer/ guclé\» 1`/\‘>\¢66€¢61\0@ 615-
,§#sén/o‘ce 1/'~/\05. 1661/der cL guz."(%-PL€.¢\ 1‘1\)\/06010:60/3 ewe( h;e/\MC
,‘,0.\/0{.‘& b’eé@us»e rif a 40601'007006 robede 301‘|\~3 based 00 eF»
(0,\1~900)3 510¢60»`$1: 06 100049.$€///, 666 p{cq 1\;1 1006 101-006€ 4/061/1/06»~6:|
flra-elva v .. wa 1'1owr.\

k+_, 050 F.,z.! 1033/1037 ( 50 c)r, /¢?3/)]~

 
 

   

649 903 5..0. 20 704 (Te»<. 1411,» rem/1000 /szxa),

65 19r€0,‘003£5 310ij ék:e r'e`6; .1,0¢\1210 /Ma~léwé/`O»> be
p/‘G»e/\){~ ¢'éw €xger+ to \e><'p'"éa_::`{\'> er £PM~)‘€ H'~e po,‘,u{'-J wl ('é\~-)‘
‘ fe£u,‘re¢¢ 59 gm d§_é¢,.).;e o¢€ene¢¢/ ;Z}Wl,`,¢q/o{» puele M
..M\ue ;'QLé¢{ 50;1¥\$\ gn)"c{:',¢/oou/J ,‘»\)s»lend have 1-‘/\1’5~"-~1»€¢"@ “"° 4
lopez é\»,\¢yl éo C)\)e.) (c\jclr`ws+ ['v,"w\N

E,r (TLe abav-’E req\;w,o\_.g/ HW(>cA/w'~¥'s @m>u,od' ..%Q,-V ¢ch¢`€{~` .'SL~aoY'J
/\'l'o+` be #`€.sod~)e¢¢ faul_s M¢»\+erral -(vo H»»€ leja£»",'~i)) 049 }1)(»
P(Mewpé fcb~¢~z_~€w(em{ 4_0 he fese[v»ed)" §tgeci¢rca U§Z

C_ZZ)" w)aj /1 €l.\¢a»£ gle~;ed ~!#echue ag§,`sLa/uc€
0{ C¢,u,w_cel wAere én,‘¢c.| Cw~u.s\e.d paile‘)qu/o€ 1»515,5,‘€5( y616£’ch`ue Clsf/`.séH/uc@

06 cFUA}~S€-l M)h€r*€ A‘~/yl¢`CGM €»-{e{e¢{/d/s/ /A)UOL-

0~€."5 91¢4 me

3011145 haled O/U 6101UOCC?deM

£wu,uael who was UA/Qw.ré'rar wi% {~L~e felo-
\/c\ml 1€55+_; amf é/aws comer/o//ugll/)¢J ',g_vec/-

§z amuqu

fwse¢(u/€s/-&k‘~g /_/QNCMM€ hew/15 wm nude F,\Nc(,\,o%;r of (M,.f

mud foude )a/v`r oF 1445 Rc.a,M1M5,\)¢/,\,.,3 é;,,dl {_.h/¢ 1149/(,~5,4¢1/>@,\) ,56)>..¢5[

619~2»1"»`1 01 HAbE¢£»J é°@rp~u» be jra»oéfo(’~

111

Rm:(ecl¥vl 1 fS\__> b“’\"“e°"')

 
 
   

'NJR¢¢» M?lcae( (,A.A)Z
maj €I@ # 0/830007
w>"a"“~\ F memis Jr. U`A‘>L‘*
%o' sp»r 511

Iqwunl(o Tc)w._; 79/07,?1@0@
A{)fl/‘ca/o{ 956 se