Court Opinion

ID: 4065285
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 21:56:02.599349+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:18:00.600388
License: Public Domain

gwm_: _04,+4/_/1. £ £¢44444/

§§,(g|§~()/

jM/Z/4 a/Q‘/ 207/f
7`0 05 . %._ég ??é(g

` RECE§VEBFN ' x
M//__//L/,,¢ _ vCGURT oF CR!P.MNALAPPEA`|$

/3 m /z/W é.r"f'

' JuL 312015
4444442,,, 744/44 7 434

1445 A@Gs§&, CS@§’§<

7`_ /.”YJ¢/ 4445/4/_£16££/¢

c:@w,/ 4/ c,,M,/Wz 444/44
p 0 ¢{a_)c_ /£,3;9_6__ C‘=)?_Q/_/v[ 5/4f/4;Q

 

655 C4s4 A[@. cwa ~34,_@/1'~4/

 

)c///\,;?__ 0_ l @p£§¢o_<-£`f`_~__'/:(,_<;KMI/C `/7'1\/.0 16£./14¢» 444

~4___#____;£ _,44;¢./;"`£. 04-444_`4_/ /Q4,444.4/ C¢,/ W Fa/L, 3,,444"

1

 

'JMJ 7`¢44_0:/_"7/_\4_7 CCS'~/C 041 oLL¢;')// CM»r/'/ 449

 

AwMo_//‘ ___1_€779%446414~»@_4¢/0 5€1";/_@/\/ 44

 

 

co~/l.HL‘ é)'(q /M/C¢):{__ CW'l/(° ¢'O M[J €¢Q»€/¢{//

 

4794[¢4,,_,“,/._ /z.@cv€/\//a/ 147 4€4!_‘/'7’14|¢ A»0--4\4 _€./414_
0¢€/ ,QM )c,/A., *ZU/ ZF/J, 3/0*7;~¢ ¢4(/74¢.
`/407£,@¢¢5;4 $£44,4-114‘/ A¢P/om/f/@U 1444»4_ 444/-

 

 

4%:_./ /166/1/¢16 616 516/602 263/1 AMQ£`/m//_’
42€1¢\/£ d n a//L//v; £M¢/__Qz¢f¢._`)_¢/§ /Z/_ _Za/f
1916 7°€!/ a//z»§ /yp&.M/Ww é'. //}07 fda/6 f
{/}/AX/H" C¢s\»'~q/¢¢,/. A/ff é//¢v A/M Faf/ 4,’/,"/`/¢!¢/.-
317/17 257/6 w/f.

/€L,op/¢;,,;,,/ w/¢ ¢¢M/ 162 cLM/c 666 ¢6/)
QA»¢_¢//_~.;;/ _ cr Auop[cc,¢;,w?`x @M§/M/)»/’ /MVW£
11266/116/ 16_ _§i`»»f%- dew/2661 /5‘~6’1¢/11. 471/6
546/166 16 462 /W,,!- /¢/1¢~116,6 615 fda
‘:)6616¢1 61 566/6 44 1166 566 6°6/61_6»;>6',6/

_Z` MQM§MZMFLQ Ay/MC¢_M/_ 6/¢26¢/1 ¢rw `
/%~A Affszwp;_ /,V ~,Léc/ M;/h§é/c

 

 

 

-,\ / ' . ', `
,O),’H._/ /,Q( /(¢c/M/¢@é/' '

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

' l
n
\

 

 

 

 

 

évp$’»@fl¢fm..' “ § '~.?./'v€" zz’;£ §£/ 34 ¢é '[)1,§}";€,.¢ /’
1994/1991 3 1969/1912 § €906?” ¢>/ .
!£¢‘M€£/CA»,/f' §§ /MI F’:¢Z..a_'.¢'/q,/;/’:?; 71/::[/7"{

 

/~;235;;/1§ 1192/151 120 ¢:;//j/r-/' / 991\19¢99.{ 96 5950/¢5§/ 159
l §?;»1'1,7/ &' d/L/ 9,.,,_9,;;'9 915 1511 \~S`l`_'".,_j

 

 

, 4 ,.,....,:.6.."
`-‘ ~ 1_

 

73 1519 1%1./0996 595 _~j:/M§;/£ 915 _.‘3’1'~1»01 '5‘99~999 ;»;

A¢"-$’M 699 lf:" 911»¢/§! 999/1091 .T}"'.'r, sigm¢;?;m»#g/¢ f ~1=?`31¢;1/§2¢§;1:;9997$" /"2¢.9 199
399 1562 -,96919; A!;zm#; ‘9€1116:1.~:12 912 ~ 9 911 129/1911 69 999-1912 1199

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

l /£1?95,4/ CY`£,;»>, 19 {,45£-? '2961111'1$`/¢,.$.»¢9 , 1900 M»§;.//?%/ 599
. § ?`11<'//4,1€ ‘ find ¢9:1»1\9_-949! 1139_@,~,919.,1% 4 1151 999 9 ~/_./ ..`S*ém,¢z 1916 -
" " 996 . 1 “““ "
2 §§ » , _
_ 1599/9£/4996.9/"_ /J C`m; 1151/91! §¢19<.41,/»919? 1433 1151 619 § ~¢»
‘.`.. ' mém;,~ ,_@Ng `§,;M/,.;N@,¢;” 95 ~;.é,¢;;,/,M 931/§§ 995 /1/.£ 1119/91 1900
ll 65 559sz 159/919 `_1,9 g‘?"/` ;~,1.1¢-1£” ` 491 6;°<996 1215 /*w?,/W/»§/€l.-'¢.

 

13 "»1'1"61153~ . /?5/99126¢;.69,,1' 15[191¢191596/ 9191///59 159 999 111/911
95 506 999/if 1999 1951/119 L/f)'.( `P';mw JM/ww,,§¢_ 1229
Jf.¢,¢ 1121me /‘/: /‘?_‘?9 991/156 14111/ 1‘_"90/1.71" AW€»’ 991/912 `
sof/A,f/_‘i¢)l'!"lé’»c.f f 151/65 1119/04 1519 1224/156 MMAM. é//;m¢ 16
C`oM\//c.//¢;M 194 irm/1916 /\/11 /¢? ) ‘=_»/1:6/9§, 591 ~»1 ‘

 

 

 

 

 

 

` _ >LM/§M,»¢Mr 111 {7’.1)19`, )

 

 

 

-." ‘ _ 9 2

370 1111/11 71 2115/3 499¢/€11»1-/' 11011\/1:'@/ `1'7§1£ wa/.'/ ~`
1206/9011 / 1911_11.,1,911, 1199 /1"4111/ 1141<’,6.11,1;1/£' 1151 91561,/
'f?/h"i~`~,/ 1799/164 1914 /1111./£,// 1/¢»;1£9 731 w3111@»,/11, £//6/
1")!:3` 1361 9/111121/ 1771/$1,;1//€11, 1191/1111,/1<911.~7' 1£2;1 779 919/191

`F’WC» C@i»’/¢£~ //'1`99_'7 13111<.1",`9, 1 1191 AFAL{K~NN H,_ ;;M
b LZ}’L"?" €3": /`/:/~1‘*:114'/11'1' § 13»“€919’1;/1 '11:11@,1/5/ 969 Mx;;¢/MMAME
d '£"" C"%“f 41 11/‘ 151 1199 131 1919/111 111 1119/999 1915 11919119*
15 1119 Y)_£§Mg 11 1119 911 1111 11; / 111 69~,94,,,,99,9,_9% ,9 1/-_ 1 t

1115 91911/131.%111/1 515 1571/9 141 91/1191€1; =',11*'§1111 11191'€”.`

.‘.`

 

 

 

w v . iMH/{J;E\ ‘1';//(:,. M#.,J/’ n .Q_ fw M/.£. 1 ‘{F€;’A v` £FW»! w ~';L'i[§. Li' *Q,M;V
y CMQ&f/?*E¢\v!‘/ a'"/""‘/l`f,/?""(777 %d;;£ ‘=S"f/`r 515 § ' é{»§/?WAVM“M'£X
1711"911£ 611¢149,1'!5 1141 l 11 15 131/1155 1,4.19_/9’"1"1.;/ ‘»/ /1€: s

`94’111;-.`1/1' 191111 “"SMMK 1169/§191 199 111 1131£(1111~9»/11

 

 

C'i"-`»£?J\/`)Z"@`H;,'?"§ 1111 91 991/1511 111/1111 1191
7 ll @H@M,x/Mf/» ‘ 111/190 1110 1"* *1/1)` 601/11191/19
539 1311/6 1416/151va L€JAZ.’ /"'1111~§&5'10/ ‘;'?»~S’ 1512
` ‘ ' 1411 121/191969191917 1199 3 619 §1@6,911]
1917¢¢;11/9/£_ 151 /oML/, F' 111191/1:/ 1919 911/1 1111?1
'|’f" 1911 ulc,fo1f di " 4"

'”T"~ ,5;1;;4@11`/70;1{ /L/?A[JLMMVT“ L¢€/r/// .J)/Q~M \J/Ai€..

. . 150/701§§

 

'¢ ‘ ,.
.. ` v v .I
. ` 4 g _ " ;
. 9 1 d 16 , 1

 

 

 

 

 

530 ~J!We;./M"~; 41 /?§’~3 637/z €@6/)\./.~.$£.6 /f/v’/.s/£

441/44 464 _ 544/4

444/44 W//;/A/¢) 442 1444/94 544/6211
4 1244.41’ 404/444 , 1494 466/44 1542 744-441 1144<4 141/441
643 MMA 44(1£. .S>)£C`a:vgraf§ FMJ;MMCAMWZ“ AELMA 154/261
/*M’I:L §‘»`-#1//,64‘4§ 129/191..1.¢’41‘ 6546"'-.\/'»:1 464 1962 1§`»¢44/»4,».»41.,
96 1411 LL,»‘¢’{A£. 621414¢14/;.214"‘/ § 441 /494§./¢; 1 WF- 4444"’}46:;» 662

, 644 41 144/44/ 446 1"”1§2-4444/ MJEC.AF,JF‘ "'{"é’l§~ IEA»~~§I?». 199 /F¢.h'{x’fé§/,»»fwwé\¢/ ,»€',6;5<,,1

 

4 `£A§Pé_ § !;i"/;x

 

f?/';'*»@,»§ 456 §§ £.?4;~,,_/'4">!'/ ;fg;//"@/¢‘,{M#§ "',4»/*'
` 436 ¢?/ /§'¢/'0'..4.44# 644/1441 '94“16'/. 1144/961 1§;£;.1,»? 527 144/441
§§ 6 66 1 ;.41.;1

 

446 »~ - _-.=F 9 ZALMF~‘?L/J";~"// ~ 344 113 \//é¢. Mfra..' /?°' iv w§z 66 451 ,¢rf

 

646 644 11 1619\4“_ 1444‘»444 4 144 414 544.»4,4:,»111,41

 

JI’\,.A 415/t § f?‘~” §#f,(,r<’l/d § £_,A"kw§'¢{

444 644 444;1;£`1” 11;§
`~ 441
.Y?.M’ /1£`4! ngch `Cuz:qw /Mc

621 644 14 411 ~;:»4)4:
. ~e"/$§;_

6’/4¢44 44 /619 1442'4../4 /" 4¢4,¢= 415 41,,/,(1 411/fw .~
§1%/:1 05 444/4 CQA:.r/A<./y€’..»i/é. 454

/<14!9~»441<,1'/£6 466 @/’16619 444»1.14 1961

=<"_#_), 744 444,41 41 141/1144144» 4444144441@
Y"?§"{ £%'4&4§/~ »

/£zm{¢z., 344/11 461(15; 454 414/41

.g 4.

544 144/444 644/udqu ~1/6;4' 141/461,1, ¢;.6¢.4,4” 444 644€/»,.

'1

64

gca/cnw §6_¢494'4‘" _

 

 

 

1 11

_._ 113/1311 §§ 1515 552 éij 1445 1 f §”`{,¢,\4,4_, ,5;1_,, _\1{1/,; 14441,/,,¢,{§

§,1__1;\1/¢/11’ 1‘/ 151/513 /1¢1,,/ 1512/l 576 wci/1441 1514 511 ~/1/1! f`521:11¢17" 114

')`5_111155141411/ UA/Z¢,.s.§ 454 11/5/141.,4/11111/ 4//4141111)7}1114/1.
`»Séow?~(`_ +511_5 1514 4411414 Mo% 1441/16414.; 1654/4 561<.1

111411111:;1¢14 o[ 1511 191/1411 1414 41511»14 514 1111111.4 4411 41441:
..ii/&AMM /§?M :/"‘¢;¢‘€11 NM'M¢QA/A§AAW/'A»f Of 315/%1€.

016€14/1 11 §1441 §1<11411111111‘ 11' 114/442 _ 6?/§1‘$`1’11!?@/. 433

141/1114 1441 511¢111,;1 111 1441 141-114- ~51;*:1’ 141/111 1311/1314 7[7_?1/1?,>)
'41"’.`111’ 141/11 14421..11611.»1`1111 11 1<:1':11§1"4 441;<'"§ 151114 11'1" 471/4 41
1+1’@§61441 ¢1:11111,1""'" 514 1131 14 155/1411 1’1<( 411/114 15 455!§ "`1/111'/('

641 41111.:4 114 1’1_~11114;,1 1114 1411 1' 1414 15 1441’»511».€ C;UAA,£LW
‘§52¢1€11/4 441¢'§:§.14115 iva te_,_l15)4’111114_ 1111 4552/ 1554 441 2141>'1" 14141'!1‘41~1'?
f?~€m& c 411 , !S' 1144 1455/1314

§37[ /jN/-}l+' (’.'1.£3//\}? _ f'?(fi'z$."'£!" Wq.` ~ '.

 

` .-.4.,111<1114151"' 14?115£11:41’

 

_ M)$M¢ ‘4! 15 14 1414/iff 14441»11 ` 14 41~1.1414. 41441”#‘4?”~\11€54(
441 14!'1“/1,11',1£111 14511!*/£1 514 1">"’,€4.1~14'1411'1541;/‘1..1 724 /41~1.1

_/\4.`1611;1 514/fws 415/4 41)114/” 4455~'» fw/Fé}wl._,/*/ 4’1411,11:4:‘1/4
1514/111 _ 454/14 ./_`15;111~ 1414 pf,»?A/(A 511 /?1§>/ WJ/ /4311,1,6 1111/54de
4111~11£11;,411,¢ 1411 164-1641 155/1145 1;111;‘1',»111.111411111 ’14‘~111)_": 1':4111~
_ 14414?1,114 415/11 1?1111111 141111 11115'. 1514 %'1’.§4 4&
"1??¢1“" 161',111@46¢61!1§ 1115 1551 f/c.,/e_ 131@1/? /11.1411 1564 914/414
\_'_3551411- 161114¢1._1 4"01<11141/7`//»14~¢1_11¢~4/11. \//°151/ )WM
`;'1!*"'1\11'7'44-14.9/ 1=31.11_'1 /9€421414¢31541/ _ d - d g
` fpl/1111 414/5 515/44*£’1?41!”! A@"£t;~'c/D?' @Mf/)LL¢/WZ‘L¢%
'14.11.111 1114111141 11/ 14 151/1111 1411 ._1_1411111._..
55111141:1_ 114 1441 1114 ‘1/0 511111 7“’"1414.1/<.1 ' 41117:1:1‘_"14 ,/‘

 

`F£.r\.
\1.5

 

 

 

544 +/445,4: gser ,Mz.s 411 of mar/1414 44W _ '
'MQALLLMM.~/ §`/:/z'./C Ai fc~/’/_ &¢/iM/x/;»A.q,. /-/_WMM¢ 40 7
¢:P*'¢-.» {"U\//M..»¢, ;‘QQ¢§@'LFM /¢5»¢¢3(:` 4941’/‘*'»~.5 95""5!?31{ 53».‘€»£/4.~5;§
l/Wwow/£¢; 1111//.4~/?’ /‘?~,»B* 555¢5¢\//5 955 ,14/1"¢2//4/.»%;£

__€:.`{A i!_ 4554414/0/\/ 395 ,.,/’Jz`;‘/," 4__,

 

 

- .

 

';,?`, §,"3>»:\»/;¢,".,5 .;3. 5-/4,;33.4145/ 453 éMAé4 5`~/£,433”;34,/' ELXSN;L
53 ~5"3~4,//~. Mmfl F§»M»€ -"‘~) 9"‘! -` .. ' - 5?7`3'/§/£/5.,!£' 433/1 1315
,34@,1/:4;~@/1,¢,?Z.,M,,,zz»s/J 5 .. 43 194 35 134 121 §§ -, -_;1.

59