Court Opinion

ID: 4041802
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:54:11.836174+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:28:33.884626
License: Public Domain

/lOl |UO 5Zl3qlq0l LH l L'Z,q%[L|L'// LE/ L/(D

. . LV|, L/g` "~\
¢5¢61¢&€ m nw 09~0<:»~/2¢; 7a 6 "~ 170 7/45 '7’£):.4§ (',¢M .@+ ‘§".

or'o€~~zaq’g£o 3 §

\/5 §§ Ca,m»m»( Qp,o'g»oq»)a » UY»-c¢~)qucb, ` Y
MAR 0 2 2015 ¢`

mm ¢MHLL.. am mm hmw ,
/¢w> 0sz bj, ibm lindw.) Q/\'\Q~\ j¢?`be\ ‘g;t§;’§l:mq"¢
fm OM¢.+ 6<§’ Qp'.‘mm;\ }- D@pg.<»|s @E®é.£o

@‘%BQM‘L \? 304 -'F 5/»»1% werf` ~0 »/z 05 w
of»c)‘i-\z_¢?€cjé_ 72 7))6 /§52/554/<;<} GZ:/Jg Cl;?l< :Fb/MZ;%
95"¢°‘54;‘0 md cg.€l/JA'KJ):¢$ 13 /|AL/b;§+.€»‘€}' Q-}/J¢znc¢} ;L)q\¢}\ 7)\3l
'5'§7”3;51“'¢’ @¢°"UL» AS@§ //)\'\'s /Dm% Fd>qemw} \°» él(_/.:;//@\ a§`/l`é>ms Q@<§)a' %z /€€~Z"D;s/,e/G~/
Q@u du /D/\'¢¢ Q 1 wali §§ flaws ¢.s /'/.07. g§@€l/z<;wa .»
3§©@~/2‘/"?€>£ ca ga ?4)£,7/ d - ,£/¢)éw,;§ Qg,e?p/L§ //6‘7 §'@?JZ:!?GD
*@?“`
/J»sz /)/6/ dan yzs§¢»n/z¢/ 70 %z /5’5’/? 'D:->~/w'c quq",“

F?/K;e/

Cg'@q`/zq?(@¢ ~0€'~¢>€-12¢%6 ,@e“'»e<>r/Z_~ /2_.<;7@®\ .

wm Q?p\;m.;,~\ @€»o-/zcv@® a@?,<)qj»/z?g@@~ 153 "AM A¢¢,,,\
F}S/?Ldé,€ aj -£/',"/7£/<_ /D/§/£/é/ 4»//%2/\1£€/ "é£ %é` /$-S..L’.\.

. 61
T:Sf¢)bt @Qma'l/- 775 L<)e`/'Il 000 ,L/A/_L§;y§ QQ£@L¢§ //',67: 'P,~FQ.QUEI:Z
acc /\/£vd <§J/c/Mc.<, Yn/%`\"€oo §')'L":Dnd mwr'!" ZFCE,WAA/l gsws~\lt{'<..<.a

jj ge rf lN»Vth"?j

@'\'\_Fsb 9'~! 361§ 33 w,//,i¢-,v\ ,Qm;§ead {\))/@n fec`rauz@f) /1/5/;¢€ VZ,y/“
{Zl'% damage aj @L;rmhq/ //H'S FécZ/'ga.s"¢~j /Y"'[ l/'J? [,O£T.?L op )-//0‘)8,9‘§

' C‘Q£P‘*SA?\OO l~l'#§ @£5§97»7[?00 ’)/)La/m 73 ‘1`7\€, é?u\/L~/»Q `qug 735 h
l/)'é/q~l:~£s-r\ U§C \/6¢@1'10"\ gm "T€y`#$ @a¢p..<_¢“~~p @£_a~m);)e/! pee€§d»¢&z
,4¢{:'¢/1.//.67 3.6. 3,<'. ,,g¢,,_@l gdc ‘-.'I-n" 3771/74 wmf ?§"OCMZG?&D
“W'A<><€~‘~/2€@@ )/»s //¢/ &M,- A;,m,m 57 5,~¢7€/¢ ~/zz,
”-Dfl§hzic’ N-szmz(¢szdrs'g 7/5 @vs%%%v'vw/
0,€7¢,, 4/ \{u£;§:/l,`c!;m Mc/L=f,¢ _`_é/<;L,,Y 665 luz ¢;; ;-/ b:¢a/ £ét;'»"|

G,,,,¢Mg é;/Z'n £ ) v/T,,‘ /`, g 50an 599-1571
wn M(,\)e@ \ é£/ncm an @e>ua’)l_o<§,) Qe.m\"p.l ~£acs ~u,£,&
~f.\;z_#.`ch 1.05`, f 736_27¢5£6<;;1"2>; \Saé/?c.z.. \,(a§)[`)ci méA/)\'m%

'Z?'n )QQQGP~JMCE wr/'l{ W\z Mws §§ fli>¢‘#§¢

D§/`/ 1 M`\ '¢\|S<‘ €:|€EV_`( `nA/`{' ’lqvlj";,y‘,¢»§ agun,{ 039
Qé*mrwi _ ol- A<»,a~§ / <: C)/€.cl' §§ lO@//e/L CZQWA{ 73@»1#
\D»`Hz VX<¢)»$ <9¢ §§OB'§/mfn.=»l Qq>p£.‘-QL mé) ¢Q»<»u»»¢@@ /1;>:7`|¢ //~O;
OQOG~/ZQ‘?Q'_D 711/la QQOQ»/zq§é® 75 './?z "’D.~§¢£/k/ /Q W//:;L /m
,/_ QMJ,‘¢J/'w,' ML+-':B,\ Qm\@|¢f.'nc€ LJ,+¢\ /rkz. /5241@/\ ._ n °l?€yo»<
//.07 sb..`.za md 336 '

6 09 @z>;.nw‘m{ )OQSG.<»¢OWL&, »
‘ @,Q@Mm . ,
MMM @MM v

@/z¢."%i/M a<’

/Dégv\¢§fe~\;` /l»L dud(°j Ggmj» nw cna/M u&wm+m
/Z»r/g C.OCQ£ cf 6angpa m,,:\,y| MQEGO‘MI£ /OS// _ @

;\!Q€ 756 ll~vuv»aq»z;'

Cé-¢€~}`r.(?a€q`z cf `,§6/€4!/<,$_ '
':I' aj,//,J,,.,` /%LJ¢§.-d A'//¢n 5?/4/ /J 7/¢¢¢§ A¢<:~`I

_J`~"€ `_erz md C’J/c/Le¢# //Z> my ,K£AZ£: Ma»%»z %4/44//7 rf
W”J"""?”`

5><<@»1-144/74¢§ WF Q¢B‘VHV dfé/Z;ue:l' §§
wd\,.gm M,;£“) Qi/~Q»r» ' w®\lerc QQ>MJ

Q/OC /#`C’ L"/V"'j(?’?;/

/»

@@ae,': él QAQJ»ITMMT w Cowad., 7

Qc')rné“§ A/A£O 715 A~MY`QO gm QHS¢<>O€LHNM~, 771<'_€ Olé<; 3 !64\}3 €‘?f¢?fb

732 /\@Fr»ci A 591 736 vé."S S£.. uggu@»,q '73 Vé(X¢tS
Ogbdhr?§’ QR\;?,:\J/vl peacs//¢< 672ch Zj/ygp//§
717 /r)¢///'/éa

/1[44/;

A'Weéss\

 

 

 

I+ /s 465/344 0/27)6,@:4/ 714/f k~ C'¢;=~y d/A/r dec/44 §A§y//
56 Szn* 73 W\z' als§;w'kwl by %2 C’/é,eé afd=q 042/krc

 

\)\<\>c, a Q,_g,g div/k

R£&~)EST gsa C,wd" HPPOIN‘TED cowg¢l.»
@ugsuonf 121 Qe¥"€l& 1087 . 7”£)<4><; G,o®.£ 06 C@m';/ml pena/dug
Q_¢>usz_ /~/0., oe"<>q-/z¢%»-G?o¢z-/z¢s><,

STATE 05 'rz_>ms. nw 'r/¢é /sz'&
\/ _ """"

- ' Comd“ of _w@\_lae.

"mc'¢`ff' olé?>"\\€ib

’DA‘Z- bg §1'01171 [__p"'/§’§D

,,s¢ot,‘ 7>€ hv"~#??;{

70 7'/16 /‘!O/¢ar-,»+ w1‘|1`/>»'~/Y\ Amo@/zé»<) Q.HM,
770¢37¢ 164&3"1\€€/ / /)11¢/ ;€.¢;7¢4£§/'5 `nk/' 7772_ dea/cf AW/¢z;/»/
` 0,0¢vn.§é/ 72> 46§7_5¢ A;VV) F)\ K¢“"§é/Ui

'/ d"` C',Qm€ 5 714

711£. Alooaz,“$%)//zd Cmé_z. WWZSQ,¢)NL 72 .;£';;»ksn<;)&dé aggin
TJA/ p@a¢fa/u/c£, /4,@'~/,’¢3 /'O§~/c SAg/{S 165 \ rDécL(AK/q}licv\ % Sl»\pp¢»z+ _
§§ K¢'YH' 'R`> @56’£5-39/\`|'=\`(?0\ 10»{ (LOu/asz_l ','Du ’)'71'£ Aloovs_"-§f’;'/E,
md /~/umé)é.zscj Ql_auo£‘ @/e/%sé le jzssé G>@péki H’AQ»@ L>K¢'m?
/D\em 'R> /D\e QH»-n+)`o'*\ of 712 Qowd¢

`/ou& ASS?$'~/"W\C£ JLN'”W'\’\s {{\Q‘H's/L nrs §ng mlw-

 

 

 

 

 

01£¢5"\\€?, '
,

E'XF/I&I’T l

’SECLA~kATFM :IZ¢~I 501 PP@€T of £~YGH?‘ §§

73 faw£st/~/mf‘zm\'l §§ Coumgé| b ,
1 AQ%H; ?.OS< 'T`éms C)o'Dé. 05 C£;\Zmi;\\\AL p@€{m@&a §
. \P
//Jé£:/aw/ OéCJ/H<*¢J”>", 75 7»)~ S-»zppon'j-' of ,4¢2¢¢2>)5 7»06’/ //XH/’ b
’R> fe SSO:;>r-`}"¢"\ b~; Qownsel L». 4112 Teu'rs Q¢&z cf Cl.eimr’n»/( _"`\
@&aec£a,z.,_ » - ` ‘ ~~ ~ \\§
/(/mqfé/L/ v¢Z[Jdc)“’y'
@Fawz »/@ ':€gsA'/¢¢%,m

-@/YM me+k\Y §o¢¢)@m<é€r H/Lz AW/zowm:&/z/y &.

j w>//}F¢\m J/z£¢y M£»/ 0/.43'7[€2 557 l /éz$én"v¢/ ,%wce.'e¢k?‘z<64¢¢-/2/¢»77 72(5 %Z 0/47 doc 010/5/
ZL)`I//l/B’YY\ /Lé‘<) BQ///@"’
3/193 7)€2_