Court Opinion

ID: 4060630
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 19:53:23.437495+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:02.021621
License: Public Domain

§§ T»v\\; ”"\ E»\m\ M@::. C,Pb€, 1\30 \L'>\\Q\ LQ,[CE…N

C,A§C_ ?\.1`) \O BWW“ Qf Apppals
~ ' aj we wm T'“"D'S""Ct
f~\€?\\h'):<\ \\\0\1\\ BY-_Camwd 5\3\)¢\'>®€'»~'0¢\.""-

,_,} .S

Y \ .,
N’P*L\\M"\' IL\XT\\\L ¢><\®\u>_ E)H\e}_ md '\\x\§v»\loe»/Q,A Uli_.o_ 315:@@\-£3\(`!
v\\a§ \~1\\; umw mk_ \R\;r\\& r><€p\\@:u@_»§ ?\Mm w ma w

¢)>m_ \W» MMA\M“\;> w M m\\\’ce_\\_ EMAQS L<>M_<_~,Mm;\& A,Aa m
ZJ\\€€NKT §§ `_\'\{\\:> />‘€?\\ULUA ~EN_ HPQQ,\\M§T mo\é. §_)\a\,g P§ `¥IQHM;S

7 ‘ TX\)(’\S;O?CU:£\ v
R.'\P\?(’\%\\P§.A>c S\\&\)\$é; H\'l\§t *\:\¢\\:> '\(\m\§db\
may T\\»_ r\\\f><\\w m;w>.»_ w M\\m§'r
”ILM,\`E\;E:\GAL _ \§>Q© \zi><\eL md §§qu F_)AMU §A\\§ , {Lo_g_lU § ©’€ §P& R_TQ& &\§ (°\_\§ A_\LTG r\§ ©\XEF' `H>L. CDL§L.

 
  

11 C_;.>L>H;T \/\Ae> BB('\`°\§ <\;I@U
\,,g§ ®m\l\a~\&c\_ m TP\D_
Qm¢ mmT{/TE>LA; m

w §m§~\@§\i m maf§
~~:\~;_ M’PA\M wm LQ.\\_\LMLR §§ w ©Ym§eg §§ WJC &@

m\&m‘@~& \A§LM @£ away H> Lo,r)o§°" mi mm §»lOO amf

¢>g;>_ Cf\(:.r\`lm).\_ Md\.‘;» U‘§\e_¥ A`\_§, wall wm §§ 61 `_Uzrr»\_®&
:x_\~/\\P@\\m§m>c §§ \& Yeawz_ m:'Th:¢\x TP\L cE)LA> DSHQQ+M
@€ €_M° " v . §

\m\§ `LNQA TY\L P\€\P@_\\Q_.\\T `F\\LL

@_Tu\:>_\v" I\DTLC_L §§ AFF€M
C»\§ (QSTY\_ Ul§,c>_<.>

L\\

/%334333”4 ’4@@ 4)3§44:43443:444 43 44€4>344 g

' 443 4443\\34:4 43334343\\4 4334343 3344_`4334\3433 M\
`4>434‘3444>44§’ 433 444%33\43, 144 434 434 Tm/U 3333 434 Cw/NM®L

433343 433 44334:4 43 433 433 333 44433 3333-mw 43
TWM€M/&®:\<€b 3333434334334\\

"”443 444413434:4 343433 334 43 433 333 434\33 43 M
4_3€>4343 334 4;344444 443”44\3 43,33 443\3 443 33443/444>¢34» 4334343
_\4443 \4®4334333343 Ce>@czj 4!44: ¢443\4 343 /433 /3r Pme_, M

N.€,uz%&>%)f\j _ n
"44\43 44€4>3443334‘ 3434443 4334 433 433 4334433 435‘?>5<34\9%4 3
mv*\‘§bmk "4"343373¢;____"15‘¢%4@ ___ 44 9333 34 §__T>

 

 

(@343 33334\3334\34: FQ%Q. 44 '41\4:3444 333435 mr 633 4444334
L;>`U~Q, L©MMUMT(

` UN/ WQ/\-\M <:>\4®445”3 39 EEBA,O 45 >4&<\: UTFQ, NY\QM
34 4)\%433§’ 44/4~ 443/4 44433343 444 4343433434344_ 43¢443

443©334\»~333; 44\\3 /><4»334\44 3333§3 UMMD\\/ 4:4\434443_`44\4>_
4>4(‘>4*€33\\4>4§3 APPER(M /433 34443, P>Q¢@€m 333341€4"/443304:

‘_44\3 344>3\\4><43~4 3443433 334 14 343 /><4>4>334 433434\_%43
344333433 443 3 4§433"433 43 33434°44443 \4334344 443443444-
\4343 3 333 433 4433'>43 4444_334; 333_\®4»433» ”&3343~3

` \4\3,4>44)4>€4\34§4 344434443 4434~ 443 3333 333\44¢433 434 43
4\43443 \4434334 343/343 333 443 33 434 44333 44
33\4\44:33 433 "`43_.£43434»34343`4"4\[

423

"""i\\Q, PC am /¢F \f\\;»»u\. milk

vwagva mg MAH`LS

`"T\\Q_.`N<>-a\\m\' wm 53 lmwa M,@+ 09 T)~L”TM

©€>}\;L ©¥ <;mmmm_ M>Mue_§; m\u,L UPR\U.. A zimmde
Mméd_m wm m» N\Lc@/ her
. `\)D L\_. ?U é/M“ev /%F`P€i)l

`Y\Q_, Ml€x\§-JLH P@;U§ w TS\L €>MNPMAE
§>'\:ZG¢\>_:; wm;$§>;\v‘§;>&
(ZJA\\_ mr EJ\U§\\JL

w m_ ©w\§ MFEA\ \:> B\§u%hz§

~W us T%\L m§‘.w
\m\\o& z‘\Me,§ m P¢>m §m;§§\w
VCL\.Q_ bmw NU; m RQ&QWLR

_”\&\L \H\~ »/>§ C.LQA;SL )w&_
&R\>N\` @mW/J®m C_b&@<;de_

§§ \QU~R; \\1 50 h &M§
`Qéw\®\&§\/um\ \5\\\®¢:0§&¢
MD\@€,\\QMT

(3\

<`_\§S\`:i\>€\@>€€§ §§ m\&\c.\§

`;`_ `Defgrmm©u \M@>QQ& ’~D® M&v S>>DML
AM» am @ A”\`me, A>L wm wm w Tm Ab>Q
md @A>C\;Q_md MP\MU,\\ mm m\a§_ ma w 3a C\,;\;/ §§

P<\§:\\s§; 3®® tc> `(k»; C_LD_M\L §§ < \\\L TQ»LMNMA C@Um?
©§ l/)\@O\Q,A\sg AJ¢ /'\N>_ l@)'\ SRM,L <\u§'\\u)_ VB\él A#
\\_<>© Y\x  TM

`?Tab®l
" %\Q@e,e§u\\`( §MNW.L'

k wm®@§v»m{\®océ§
/>§€PUM

{4\_