Court Opinion

ID: 4061967
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 20:21:38.340462+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:36:21.630109
License: Public Domain

/\i5.l>H-H-Cfiy\K6

    T-NiTi-fe CduPtt cf FWsftus Teas THE
  fcumi supreme cmoic^lipsrfti&r or TtXR-s

                                                    -   •                    on

                                                    , ; \-—                  .    -

                                                        - 4,                     ^O    :••-- T\
                                                    --•        ;-                CO        .      .J—
       KVLE HXLlEfi                            -H       rw
                                                                •-».
                                                                                 CD
                                                                                           ;.-•       ''
                                                                                       —          '
                                                                                 -o

                      Hppellanl                *

                                                    : r>
                                                     - f
                                                                     i
                                                                         •
                                                                                 ^
                                                                                 ro

                                                                                  CD

\/S.                                                                              CD
                                                                 '

                      Appellee-

                CiAi^C 10)5. 2&\- CJPr 65C&

                                  6Af^ f^jTO!viXQ,TeX^o ISA)"
"XMrac of AurrttoKrraBs .      .                   .         .iih/ii
 ftMOJCCD/SUPPLeKOOTTEO AWdAHCKJT                  .         .1-9

Tke bVrW\+ disregard 4or pJlcy oni ^rc^We, a^ tuetta^ +lte - -*J
 Ab ^VEx/^usU bfv&feA/4\\e aA6, t6felhOif. (Texv?_ceo)          .        -               U
'Afifirrl V/.Phi-k.iOrrlC:.

105 5,US ^ M05,W tofe.%,-TLjWr IQ&i                                    3

iSg Ll.S. SSCvSSSfeCb)              ,         .,           ,           3

cfn. as. iSBGrid)                   .              .       .           .2-
 Ll.S.SL^.CrhCKit'i).                                                  CL

Cojq \/. Sfafe.                                                            o

     r                                                     o
S14 S.lO. 3d 351 C-tex. Qm S:^ Unbnlo^UOJ                  .           .;
Ce*\l.. Pi.r-l-m        .
 ^TrSujf>Qrici(SCLvJ.:P.Nfe\r2t;ib)            .           ,           .Si

  ^&lo^6upp.2cl^C€.t).Va.9>£)tS)              .                .        .1
 fKrkpf.W\/.l.l..s.
 U.6.Sup. (M-.ftcoo)               ..         .                .           A,S
 505 US. ctj- L5£,^, 1, ID. s.&. atttCPfiS)                    .           .1
 3ia U.S134,131, 
 1113x0. tA aW/slfa-nfe. cSv, %. aosJi                             .           . k/2

                                        ill
(Vxrnpr V S33i
665 S. 3. Sd t6C-yf>S8 a. 1&Sc. fWfw4 uW1 lc'S\3, ^ rert)             .4,, ?
495u.6.Se>qk6.c34:3X3iq%)                     .       .               -V?
(9"irWn\/» IxtolhuiririlvP
UL6.Suf.Gfc(W$> .                .            .       -               .4
 ^9rU3i.l\/9-^o\-Qia
94fc bbS-Hs^s, lot- s.cx 199434 L.-&.S. >i aflsCnaSx.                 .7

 UflMm\f.SWigR<,
 ibLm4sqq(iOP.i3:.9cS4           .            .       .               3

 folSf.ad S5%699GSttiCrcRK)                       .       .            -<§

 yggjagap \/. 5.3.3
tf(&> S.W.gd 5^5q^56&t. fljf"Ei ft»si l^                  .            -3
4ib bbs. 93^ 40 b.ex;^i pqq,itso.cs wii ftttft            .            .I
Sfffi.V^ V. l.P|i9s                                                       ,_
 s r: si ilsd,ac^Cq^Aqsm:i).                  .           .            . =>
:3w?-s3SS3
5443i0/2dlSi/i4^^.CViK, ffyttrfc}                 .       .            .3
 ^iS.L9^\c4bgCl€y;.%-fi«xM-;\Wiqq3l               .       -            .3
.UfltfBs V. Sbff.
 12990.9d MwCaflod).             .                .       .            3

 49B blS. 6&,(cflk/ft S.C3 A464, 336(Rig).                .            .3
 LimfatyriAZJ iii"ifli.mh
 afc6TThJWl5Co\SHffl)            .                .       .            .(?
 Lopez \/ c4Mp
 Lv3S4^59S(9ec. (W bW9 94iS)
J4a13i V, l-liwu-)           -
                                                                       .45
 Mf,oP-3/.3WX
 49^ 3 9d i62o taq S4gd94            .            .       .            3
jJdcJWi \/ Rr.TSnP L
 96 KId »('C3 4 1^54                 .            .           .        3
 38^ U.S.. ia&tma&s.efcs^.-aat 14 LsJL ad J-sfe (fid)             •    .i

                                         iv
9194 \i lur-lSf-r-
4 n as 493331) .                    .           .               .       As
430 r.9dii.^fc\4i mi)                ,          .               .       .%6f°
MiirrfiuV..Gyn9r_
411 U.S. 4%, 41 L. Ed. 3d 3qiy\0o S-99 9634CH&>.                         •8
Mr,f.i.tf. V feopte 3 43i 1W.3                                                   ,
4S0 Q. S. 9(4i5UE4. id P99,'14 3. 04. Iftb Qf\90                ,       .4*,5>
Akffl V- F4o.rUb.iirr.
 sqir.^i 441344 (ss CjcWM)
 Duteas, V. S3&3- __
 433. S.bJ.24 341 tex.ftpp.TS4 bQj,SU(J9499                     .       .1
Pnvb \/. gj a^  o    C

 595 33i.casC:'ft43.G3              .           .               ,       3/3 3/9
 ai'Aieod 351,5406:1!. !%6) -                   .               -       3
fesok \33vi3<,
Wl /3j3S4b>(fS444l4)                 .          .               ,       3
ftjCS \/. Pvi ;,arSrawn

jSS4r^:W, Sdxde
134 S.Ob. 2A ~m t&L FW- Car^usChm£ 2c£4)                        .       .8
SftfUS. Pi 1,111 L3d.03'393 lag &..03 2drt3(ScfiL>.                     -"\
<9f^4-4 \/l3cs /                           -N                            _.
439 S,uX 9x1 aoi frex. ftpp. isV.T^sV. OcVS)      •                     •'
^Sp.mpA^q- \/. fS-6.3
546 6. lO. 2d-icrt/idk-cnCiec. QKw. fipp 141b) .                        .3
j3sn vi.s. j&3,asaCiW)               .              -               -   .2.
 \osff V.-Skfe               N
3.9c- s.lO, ail (otf-KHsu   «                    .              .       .a
 S\bbP3>E i39 b.gd.. 31 333C M&                  .              .       ,4,5
44^r,?rfVrl V. £&£&.                                    .                    .
 944 a.S..43fo3sS-CS i25a/iaL£i. MeCn4«)                        .       .1
ikrfefl 9X4^. V A-y>.^..                                    .    N
434 U.S./ cd ICfL 1Q.- US/it 6.(1+., q+ 3941, 2tf0l-3{tot( 1449)        .3
iinlkdJSkk:-, V. P>Wti -
 1ST Jr. 3d £35, fc2fe (34a Ok. 1b\Z)               .               .   .2
 3443 33Xh\4333^.
 305t93d4inrn^3sQ                                                       n
 Ur,i43 SjafeAZ Bobt&aso                                                     .
 4S33'34l903b3TL33c9r.3xtt-)                        .               .   J
 iI i P. 3d "10S CChS 1441)              .          .               ,   .2.
4tb U.S. G48; 19-19X4. 2e:6L3b L.td.2d fcSiCiwO .
i.b-S. \/. (--a rem
(30P Supp. 2d 9SI ClX/D. KieW. 2m)
%4 bbS. 361,645,43 639.465,60 LPX ad 4fa8flcn0              ,1
(PS. U Pm/prq                                                /
364 3 3d 44 COft 6 2£&\)          .       .         •       -b
LisALSal+zac
Sc\6 33dli9C.C(l.^lD^\d)          .       .         .       .1

bsS+SSh-MlCsft 4X516)             .       ,         .       .X
11 6. \/43rii
sa +73d 231 (c.a4 \pqq9)          .       .         .       4,s35/6
Vr3n-3v V. Skjg
5S1 S. IX, 3d DlSdaXbldex-bldw.App.lQTO             .       ,3
\Sl3 /.33-^lk '      .
lOS^Sd 43-1(03 6 i4S6)            .       .         .       .(e?
(,\YdSrr3/.3P-yoel
9b>US3l 1011CCR1 W5)              .       .             -   .2,/
9>95 S. U). 2d 4piSS3-34 fe.6rW.App R18)            .       .3
LkJa^flAmdoO 9 SPSe. r-P4evo.*s
2>6&lX&4443b.SX2d 329Si S-CSiq^PiqfcS               .       .S
611.5. IS 3d 462,46%(hex. 33. App.Ofi. 3g.09> .      .    .                          .   '.5
/'OO^PXTb'aiSKifit. PqrMTSTDk^
"1^^ G^fr\+UVioo, Ar-Uc.W Xi4 ID              .         .   .5,4,8

                           \/p
UX'i+ecl 5+A+es Cais\i4v,vS^f)/ld»'mi.rl(i(Vie\3"XZ   .5,£>
l-W-Wcl 3+a-les, Cc/\5\t3+K4v A\WirW3 AZ

P-PA/P32k',MSK3 (3643 S
fe tts.c $ 3\u go

                            VI
(J,S3/(3^S
4/ob U.S. (o% 19-16X4. 2o:>X3b b.SX 3) k6nCfi&4) .
(A.-S. \/. P^rrTn
(SOP Supp 2d 2SI SCO. Kick. Ittfi)
If.66/. HW7a/1
*\CA U.S. 301/315,43 SCX.466,60 L-EX addPlXPnD
(36- \/- TWrrq
3S4 3 3d44lCVl6 2^-0           .           .     .       >
LLsALSaJ+zer
646 SSd 1110 (bfl ID *dd)     . . .                       1
 U.fi6\96W^

(cSS A3 31961 (3^9 9516)                                 .%
l.i S.\;i7ri.,
52 XT 3l 2Xn (CA 4 PPiS)       .           .     .       .1,3^6^
\/r.3S6,» \/. SP-3
531 5. UX 2d 34<:l/4cC6d(Tex.^dra.Arp.lQ13)      ,       ,3
\XIa\/333P
IDS +32d 454(0^61456) .                    .     .       ..(p
(\VdK^m\/3C-yQel
S(Xl22dl01b(0S114S3            .           .     .       .2,3
lkb^tfeo \/- Sb-4y
3S.o5 S. LO. 3d 45i,q33>~64 fe.6f>M.%,p. I4i3    .       .3
3S& U.'obPlp? LSd. 2d \c&\, S7 S.tX. Waaftfol)   .       .S
USI\r3/.Sto4e
311 ,S. IS od 462/46%(lSc. (33 App,3>63).        .       A
74-v3/blS.                             n
6m U.S. SSfl,1^4 Ufa! 2d 144,136 S3X. KHfcftoOfc")
•gMFS-
70<1\6 6uWs oVAcuXWe- Rule 263(0 .               .       3
ieyp& ^ules cT C^iSAe QWwre-44.2(c4              .       .3
3xa5 fiu3s of Acpdlc+e bae<~fS(e-44,2(bN)                    -   '

sri43bm=6
~1e>fts PnAf rC Odivviiv-d VWfrW:
 i33\c>> 31-01                     .       .                 1
 Ar-Vvck. S3.a?> .        .     .                .       '.5
 ~ ^3PPTbH69>k Iftl. PQ (MT.STn^
 l^Xa-^ Gsn-sX^+ud+on, PlrXcW X5 10        .     .       .5,0,8
1£k&6 Q,*sXS\33ryAr3eWXfl4                 .         .   . Q,

                        \/p

                              VI
(J. 3 V. (Wu-,
4(3 U.S. 04s, 1016XX 2c5X?b 1/6=1. 2d Oo iGqg4) .
iA.-s. \/. P>n.f6ii
(SOP. Supp. 2d 3SI Sen. Kieh. 2fitf0
Ub6..\/.HW7f.,n
404 U.S.- 3C1,245,43 503.466,60L.EX addOSficnD
Pi.S. \/. Pb/Wo                                                ,
264 P3 3d 44 (046 2.03)      .            .        ,       >

S46S6f3i9C(94l0^\d)          .            .        .       ,\
IbS. \96Wpv-
bS3b3Sl349(m4a(6S             .           ,        .       .2.
I \ S3)l3ru
52X7 3d 2ti (OA 4 14qS)      .            .        .       J, 3/4,5/^
Vr-.U-Un, \/. 5kk
531 5. CO. 3d 3l^4cC-0l(Tex-b93^,App.lQT0          .       ,3
\4klZ£5klk
1C^A32dq^i COfl S1456)        .           ,        .       .. ^ules dP PippeVloAe QWwre-44.2(54               .   .3
l2xo.l> Rules of PpiKilla+e. (Wt-+We-44.2(b)
3n4Tbtn=s
73fr>s PrAp r^Sduvuivd VfriT^rW:.
 FVUck 31.01                                               .1
Plr+3k ^SS.02>    .        .        .                  .    .5
3(3 VsPXxi.rrr^K ifti. Pa oMtsxd >a<>
 OK6 Gaa&UWdon, P\r-UckXi40                   .        .   .5,0,8
Im-s G^sXS'dXory ArdiC.k Xf l4                .        .    . (o
u(Pi+e4 Stages Cais\i4u\3on, A»'nWwe\3"3I .   .5,£>
lifo-ta) SM-es, ConsVrUrion, A^rWia43ZL .     . ly4;k,7
oV)\/33ktMSkYr 9r.\0ES
fe Us.C. $ sifcl GO        .     .        .   .1

                      VI
            Ahmed /a w pu^k && ftx&r PlC/^t ry jaegog.

At> AW l\n\Ad SkAts Gorv^AuAich Onl Ak ^^ee^^r^\ (^ S^(o\^j
          •,/•. i       x\ - -.
curm^f ur\K\    Arial, udwefo   a/resAi oam U..7-X                .\.-ss ^
                                            be$«e. indtoAifh^ in aiWi
rewolftaslft^                       ^neAtO&upxs, Looking of- fas.j/.
earVSa}and le^ra^/^a^vt? \///^'-U/, Si^gj(f2>\(o\(\y)/^^^W
%*jf.&l/f/sr/e,/,^^.-g^Mphzl/t^/eno//: iA ts-Gi«nd4iia4- de.Lk
rox\a\r^^o&prc^\ma omuear^and 4loo waifs, eviert 4uje^AuAiV£ WiemW
0/£. ^p^l^trlrl/elu ov^udicMal'iTT/CiS Can m aT\/a\At) 4W ^Wres.
iftfijfi or a £^T-fep(vV|case, as aiell as Imsff&Srhl/fe as^sWnce &P
 ccuroel a/^nT^^pel\aM- (ATcl moV us*? Gtfunsd ^4fial;G^fe) \JfcW~
 fUfta%, Dbkinad -Paynes WW^Y'Tfas mePfie^enefe 8y request- •& 1T^ -VoAnle/iT^n Unl7m -Xr-.r Spgggjj Eq 1,«
aid pAtliineQ .Counsel £U^ Art^ Ac perfinu lu3 Axx+ve< ftndi ^eewuhaW.
C&aeHVifi ^bU AuxAWr b^ iHolaAin^ ApplkusA-S. w€ipco] ITAy ane^jXifluruAxj Ap jpr^s^A
 a. i^e£ir^oAa\ ar\(i C£>£ v7£ru l«a(xs+ bean akle. At "pres^ni a rt^arSnttful anc\ p'lutcs^^
 deiws^ ojaA a QAbfejrAieil uJi-Wss iJb: passed cuxoxisi ilunvia
                                                         AlixlIia "AIo^
 pl^udllckl and Lmhj^anTAaarij uocaA-^.rAard b^ Appellajf4= LasHt^m
  u.ar.^ a;t\V>^^V^5^; a ^clu oT^S mo4W. ^ ^re-^^ dcrW^
  hdei
 CH-   C.UTX7f

 and uull Aricger a spcd|y-W"\al aralusAS Dn\\k owi
 f,Prodis V'toiOoA-tdo cF cicui^sosi's ra\WcA
                                         7^
                                              as Uie\l as diU e proce^s,
                                                                P              ^ ov
                                                                         \j iGloti
 dTAW CgjurA; ^?r^ Vmmek tSee. nkn //o5. //%r/./ at> Ao. deAenvime
 ujheWw A\\\s error UJQ^ w\6fe jxotatok AWi mVWwi\ess/or aJkefW T+
 diaTn Atxdt ma (^unAuyt^asbneAy/^pnve AcpelburA-oPa^r
Aria I.
    ""Tkle QSircFv^^ur4V\er faxbsW^u*!^ In cu\A^csfHVp;racA- 4WA-
AW qalsn^^^s^-ln^lueuCx^ on toeeaGno&'fo a vlotafian e£ ckAe^e^.
uv&ifcWl avYi-Q^ti-Wocl Da4V\e CcssrV, £&£& l/V*,fa/s£>*r?;

Cm&e. /s/Ah/y/ss,?/^} (^DUpWa uj"vA-h*4Aie pYp^duAor QklTmAVi-e l^taae ^
doting so/TWse vTdaAt&tts uJe^ accowiplisViecl bid ou;U\Y32^
6Vu3ferc£, (XlboJed \>nek r &/r*r/t, l/A/h/a/w/(/'y% >yrA/ 7 X* fijnd upheld
C£rfhA.57&4*z &226&Z/ /xs AAiese 3ibsWvhoA^ lOtatA" o^vjicAccVTcss. cF
is slhWdAm^ AAfc a] uk*>ce fe/Nsuijpms5T&i bu AW opsa^uA^ ^jP
evKWx^--(5.vJo\73\bk.^o ojt\ accused UupnY^au^M- LSbl&xes duue pnrVg5
ujWs A^ee\T\cW^ls^ocWla\ Ap Qj-^W" °if f^rusV^evx^ iVreaosp^rlfe
"HloA 4A)e cWQyws f^aaersA- of \ucAiMs \^eo~d, uJImclK uJcuU Ua\f<^
6l'!6ion aisci: UdiTdaAm A^IW^ a-gsaHSbn &£ re&4&mta\e Amrc>r
KmcixiWAxe c^TmmlwenA doxge^had rb nolVteen <5Ujppc^sSQ23 orsj&ft
 ted abmACK.^^                                  SWfes ^sU^Tk hivu^
(C.AWvs. Si^32^asAVfolrvftfrv\fl^isn iaJ3s f&aue&W- on/file<§A^W
36XTVus InfemrxAtoh ixA^ famesfeci G4:txf 41^^^
(SAirQ (tkjJgdiS/kjks. l/Arur^f^Ve. proper .•fAoncWci c^nrtoJr^alT4^^4%€
Undfectasad •^ildence;onJQW sbjndarcl dpfJled fca AW^-fvaljua^e. m-Uu^
(^S^CHoisf^Wy (W&naftcf Wo\x-9o.A\-riejn
 Q.nns+44i.\^Amlp^rr9r h7-s V)g»an rrmixHc-d ;n.sAA\€. i/"fc)laAibn arises-T?c#)\4fie.
gacpr»sion oP-H^ euTdenae arc! IscW 4o AV^ cfer6X:fer o->P 4Ws. eulam&,
G^XoulLa'-e pro^oe X'soAxwk Y^.cxjrdAo de^as cud ocrtr deorWeVuwi c^Ta
•ter\i\o\ ijSoen"vA cup^mi ^eccxA f'7n<,r,^ r^qij^s-W-J V?u a^^svx-^ counsel
ICP Aki6 T6 so/-AA«n umer Arle a&ema^^ovieA ^le^df^vj^p^.ajw
llv (Ns6A^in5 fd'^d cancfeiUwg difaCo\/er\j; (i^pdkxnfe ccivvj^hc^ ^KeuW\ h,
 f€\ie>rsed a-6 uoeV\/asAirvis"i^-H\€ +e^ rfix rwc^nawijclP ekriA\pA^nj
In-ftrmoiAon ixA cil-fXslcf^A +o defence bi^A:\le pTD^uAtmrTkisAiJt^.<^
 teVlX/Div} '

 \tiexe hc^u(XP2c\^xcfc\u to\ca\a^aMTv^v^AK; pra;6Ke attoc^^s
  C\ppeliaa,A-vS Ccx^&^ocx H A^nod" 0^,7^- as dfx.^a^d octo^sad^pr
  due-At) .l^WlWJfe tofcrcVs o^A (Xprdiic^ H^lW- 4W_heU^^\\s3J
 fl^TCfa la\xirru ^Tl^ uJTAV\ltola7yg cfjCtofl^ PAaAenak fea^T^mibn,
 LfcoKTn^ Oct loWV £\nder\£e uua^ ISe-^Ar ^rccm Ao^eiWrt duximcx
                                     X.
bc+h pro&eediras ac^un^-Urn,-the burden oP v^dx" cxu id hot taue.
been met iol/uchls Squired cJP -iWivs Sag, /&&&• /A, x^^^.- ^
U2&£2m. lA<7> ^X7^/3^^^^-..rTK/X IIXtV"
-nwAfoer tflAs Oy\d ^xb^anAio-KA^h'ie rtdbun* ord awv>lfm c^a ia/u^kx!
CPvaxAte-r txjtokc! ^^axflal^Cxiome.i G\4s^jAt>f «vtfeAnoJ As%u aqalr\*) 50
 as Ax. \/vw6iiq:l! a l>etter cox Tn rc^M, AL^j^ Is.fO^/^^<^x/^ Jfe
Tke. paSovufYxJo&VCmd -Wm4 bVxAayrV 2^ipre5^\on r>P ivrtfenoj d"u-six^rA
Irvioi-se-tP n\ ixis \\etfoe a*d uja^Tu%K-ficd ihddtt^t>o"m aoeovd unAViAA\e
 ///-^/}ig/1;, A::r>r>/^ 1/ /^^//^SS'X/^ ti?A~/-• LS< ^7J^JAA^/er.^n/-> 1/r^/oY^J (xsA
./s£4/*Afe- /s< <&£zk. o.$ -met) sub&hxrctiafe He^ILa\*=> pDli^^xiTcuj^xnd .,
need Ad tlA- xeWi-r LutaW uyder aAfe^k An Vus aujm bomerTfas ^dUaMIw
Ob Evidence. CDrAin^edA^.A+ie ptJL^7sb^ml^4/s0n^^c^ doase- sx^ s#vte.&P
Ai/\e S&cne Coldanee c&uia bo>je.V)eei\ ti^d+6 acun l/fcpdW4 a leaser
^\t^c^,uM(iy bs^iM r\ot\iauk proceed abcA\ (flad ^utanGeVean
albis'd oet Axi.J0^77S3^vqp^^sic:x dmrina Ounfebvnt^A-Is £\HctaArtOft.,
held valid Y^j M\€. Inoldvv^s <&JxtdZaaa (>/^ &jeik/s and (?Wg)/ &naw3£>rne errors tvfcu*de&' fturM Ojkvdusls Jj^sonTiw^yiJ
 xme erases s.m\\ pgjr_ be praVenT^rwuess beccujse AV\& harw can
 ftsvJer W d^AervvSriea due Ax> lack c-C flaxa needed fir ^apaIi .<7^2^Mfg
 CcfVfenpbded w4V«3tt- ^3^006 exTCsT^ rie_-Vu okx\uc7s bu (AormW.^eni3r^fon__
"T^iese -AWe.e cci'^1^ fcferAiAilu ScsV A\tx -4WxV>^o\ -fcr Vanxi analysis
 AVoA si^cxAd be CiTdu.eA-eA T¥ csn ri\rrrx is aileaed^These a\^o .
 d-9^rm# ^AioA- Abe lax' dees x.6V daoe Wder do ae^mQ^Aoefs'sAaWidi
 b'arrr, ixxi/sr
 \noxrp  ixxle.r IrAule..
                 V^ule. AH-^Cb)   5? +bs ItKoss
                          ^H-iOo) &        ~1exas flate
                                                   ftale^ c# ^(o^e
                                                             ^(ftte H-£02da*f«
                                                                    VamkbC^

                                                                                         *
 Qll ' •

ju^-^ed bi^ HA^ aj^pVf^^l euAance Ax^-o fvi-AVfe yd\vxA cfcefrcf.
  Ifo ^erscf had a ^aL^WrViallrAue^c^^^ 6V/a- 4lie v/a^icAr 6.s AW u.4 ctC^tA dee bud Au.x -(air 4naby-Z^S. ^
  /?3^V/ .
     •3F

                                      XL
^ /Tfe Uetltwt di.^oiflrd -for cdfcu oxd praifii'uu^as uj&UatbdAie,
^cpvld bpue. teen abided tad4W oxresttwg Sgvi GiNWio^VrAxx
Qmeete LOoodard omd MerapA not fceeft ^o tmji-fi"m4o dfcjta&t -KactA-.
TVQS U1GS aopm^ll^d bu re^rMKKxlAB ^d^c^tYicL'enAanA^ and
hberium Otov\A lunuri \%74dC3o3#5y^cYb>{d\e3Sz.^44^ pbrccse -HrxV
Lufli^ alle^7ft4fe C.d\$a^> 201/rfil ard ft.ftuduffiea<#fe,po^ IU*
as doling t^YadxA^d AW rMuretvi^ ofAW toaroun^s. Made appHcatok
Ad A^e. stores viC\ AVe C^n^^^Au^ aaalnsA f^lPwnNiTvvfAir,^./%//>/*//.
.Am&&,/ and AA*£ Mrmdw uxfrtwas to adylse uou oPtjcur rlaWHta CDunsdTs
fhaae app\\Cab\eA-o Abe ^states bu C&i&n /sS/7A/>?/:f^A^.. flhe Supreme
Court ae6£vAeci Abat /^/^/^^                          proceduralso&aurck
uiexe rcA A^msebjes n^bts, oroAc-x^i buAW Cbn^4a4^^
"\r6\ead fAec\s\xre5>4ti ms^e-tWi Abe rlaHx ciaaTnest ^W-hmU\wA-\m^
fflunputafifUf oOas OrcAec^cedTTVtQ. SiMae^fei 6od^O)jjrd^ lo^y^yxsP trended
'feinferC£^^Ab Act Abe rT^Hb aoyxmst e&tvimte&ry 6elf^7nmMiftoJte*l.^
j££e£ (/7&&*r-T Aaxlbm" uua& lAcsb offirdra AVfe mW oss oncers bfsHn
4esR-fied do net ravJuto done soTTUs amcer^, kneui -to G^bra AppdiWtb
-Wtee rights toudr u>eve AtAA v^crf and cW?s ncA At>- Oh •ftw^szoera^e.
 oeav»fctf\«> d"b%i drfed Ax g&Jcfid aj\d deaaue a^xuxVab\ bbj Usim
 faWiAxj Qor\d -fironcoronas is fcsf'WjsWAmA-W rxoxxd a^4b ^i^rorVd-Ax^           by
AW. vulTms In and c£4W Gcurts Aasrd "in ,/^g^r/S/^2^a^z^r /Japis&L IS
 AwSran*:/3/e.fefcr>/0<^£/.S«)(\&& &X&&2. /Sd(?/^sr^,4-j* &\cm UU>T+Vl Cl\\ W
 a-€>r^m£ntiDmd ok! briefed Ore ercuah dx \fa.lidad"e dWs €xxa£ &*=>
-Hie oRftoer^ \n Abas Case c\Td vtA ujpWAddA^ tab^,Merely brota^
lA AWiselues AooSdln ConuxsV\xn l\s_ SWe )xd n5 Cas^ \\xA\Acssb
A\\£xr V\e\p; SS Arp.liarA vjj{X.s defend»Vtt lu^^eVT ihWfe h^nein
 o,Cx.cxd uiltt Sb\4e Icujj ord d"d rot bjXrvk sud Iqi^C^) toucfcjm66
 as TlWatluSL^fe^ai^slTda^^ -sbcB.s TusS-ficcxAton."TWse ^AcvA^^aVs
 Cd'b re^ubeeA^f hi (L.r>- p^s Qs>»^€kuld bcoJe bxxxv ^uspx^Sbxd
 fl€> Ab^u ljuere doAcuned \v\ vl6\oJr\c^N &? "Itoa-S Qjcoe o# Oxnsuml
 Rroeeduxe. ftr^hct. ag.2&|fluviTn vil^iodiox b?4V\e lojjUy fyKfan l/Cimfa
 raid v'\daA\Ons o-Fdbte. Slydb ftjAendw^jrvt T^T^Wj do oaxrvsel o-r^Wve-
 £^pr^^f/^^svkC^ '/5c Tn ud/MCb aPUr r\gl\+ TnUoked iOj Ab^e
 PtoeKojhA- act ^e^tohim,nG Counsel provivefed aA ^uiql^xxbe Ao Qs$&
 uJiAb aJhd lv ujas eKpped do Bej^r (jjutIii AaulA bV-fei4i/3iA (!War,«e
 M- v/filume. \*&U W la6F\(b^epov4^ ftPftcerr ^Vec^l^ fcaruellis
 0?9 \s Unflunmg cuxJj37i\lr^b\i^^A^ -W rfghk
 cvd"\6 ajp^res4\n abneficned Iqij AAp2fa'ift» ^ AAv. 5c^ Hnte^o
 PoliCe \)eparAifVKvvf:See ^S. /^7^/ GSparrt a^es dfpra\Ti\y <-f fai\rArW.
                                 4
       A^ OteJiouslvA brTe&djjtYte cA^Acure. 6-P4ee\AmoY\a bu
AW Court mils uhcW a. due process U~i6\cbkc*i cxPdb^s
Qotort, ^r/^- JS/^/^w.Aho^^£- 4esAiYvuyiu €jVe\v\w\£a brDWlAbie,
bVxAxmA dt^aprd dP^W "t^Ptb Awenimerd- Ax AAAe LbMiecl StWS
pbnstvAut\Dn ami budVte "Texas C^s&AuAiomn b\A^deXs ]Q,-and
dx> providf pxaotxxd fe^^raem^ -Pbr -\V\\<=> rTabr^ oxe*/\dexe~
d^d^Mo/iu -fv-oAW a -sxixrc^. -W\ccb mYvea Uupen A^'3ps^v'iD\oAion-b.
 MS&fu "T-A-s "SborA-doiXXL'mTs CL^S GLars ^«^dudibv> ErPYueaatiAu &jfld
 CUXTUpxt ad^Cvm6b;cdprfe_r^f LOCOmAbJ C6nLMcdT6nst~Tk?. tvtyw
 OQOun^Ar Se\^TnerVmAnabion;v\\cxde mpp\ieeda\e dp d\ne _
 IcxAer, p>£.r AW bAxtVeS d&GlKAtiAibrv produced A^tae -Ae^fitooMes

Adxv

Jn&b a cped reason At>vlo\oAre Chn^AuAnonal rvjtofs Ac aid an . .
TrvJ^iLjabTon or case^aet AAflctt is Oidn 4V^. Qxse lAp^.'"t\ne bdb
 ofdxixAbdx AAy m\i^KaodTbn AbcA-, Bppdk/iA4 Cass isamaJas
 fhutd«r>A5 emadx rWerly cteasr by 4bie v'exot aoViovis -Vetisenfin
jOenoLVFcJf +he. Son ArvWio W>Uce ^pxxArn^A- as Abie umrrums.
jhstruetei rxd Ao Ve glv^n an? C^^4ut«^iailvj Quired -f^onup^
4he \H6laAion o2? ^lPi\^orTt^Hnation. fbls*Vs aAt«4ber vloWtan
eF+be Court. cxd ibf> abuse c^P AisO'eVicX) h*> re^fUsiv^ Ad\Bse
l>wAe-trejnAfe Ad toe S^jppv^s^d m Ut^adian bf Adi€ icuuJ, r^devTha
AVteM madmi^SfxUe uwW lArAAcAe^^DTA-W feaxs Cede.cF _
Qcuxxrxxl VYMeAi ^.. AaaaA™ /A SibA*; C &. pqaes 33TJ-330. -Ln
 d/C I/tAk, 1-t^ rdded AW Avxd ccucA- erv^d Cijjina allooj^d
evrofs^dAhof Dp'a (liuvtllcLA^vfe i.'Yfcbure<, ne^nved Qr-dx^b^sd (dr t\
A^rdrTaLSuda'\s-ttAe Qxse Por AppdibnV Tw 4bu^ cKHAse&sis
(Viode  ^ucn\em^Jirtmi qVie-3^ b\\dvsl ^ri^ruxl
AAKas Cflum&t be. vtocr^d c\s Atve -Qcfarh cl\&^ Wxl€ bad 7ulr>iBKT»^n 'PxptK \Spci^t or Eb^oe,
        Appel\04\U di(Urv\crF Tne^ iAr-bcle.Xfid oPAmdtexaS Qpnc.sK4\xhoft oyd Cojh loeroasai
vVTl^•dU£fdAcr> dr cb'ubW lisXf^d^T'S TSXddoS^Vvtd (Utfi IMOJ^bte. ftUSsd fe:
Ab£ wsV A^me on oflpeat'.[ S^r^r SSA^ .as AVi^claMse -Gupd Tr\ our;
(ins^A^6t)Stlfr(^ci<, a ctikaItoJ d-e^emard- Atom repeated prcflBeuJic
•fix A\\e SctfYve r~iwpxsavrd.Tl;u'
                                                            Couraei avded o
Kn£a2 Swe u^ujd/\h ju^tmCatlOM ujxlex mojiu-Q>sV ne.cx^tuj doodnne,
0baa ^Axnio^+r/\AppxJ.laiAt TYVto jffequiesV\Aoj v^sWfoA fCdJunsJi^csied ncA
 R|^£lby\-t),see aba M,^ lSAp.&r?> asAo wwufest wec^A^&r 4V\^.
CdUsnsel \u dft&rgsd umb 'Axsxde^'dR^-vd/lMlopry-Ti^ ajnd takr
 mrxbm s-f' mdTcAwe\nt by proSf.cvdor fi\e«irfieir}CR« C- v^K ^Loffc 9^™^
 u)luCbdSecYO*) sex, /^/iiArtn-l IS/yAiLiKUL. (xxinssA Continued dt)-Qd\ bdoui
 sAxxvvWdk as uviDrooflr attack ctP v\ppxl\c,Ms C\xxi'\bd\b,i Ccpes
 an pkj£ S00 ©^ Kfi, \Jo\\m pcteecudkar (\k&rtS0i\
 sAa-bd xdouJyUou ba)j£ beey\ ^pve^ixp fn^Vbe CjCiLur-Vroom -Por -Uie -eMi^t
dnaly flOjbV? Sd^ieAVurc^4^otV- no oA\xr xWs ba.s Irod A4tx.. Wv&^+cE
Ilkudp^^AW                    dodt ojed -fe bewr uuW^r o\Vi^ir -p^pk sa^3
 nojWr^^as AAm^xV^ v^^uojAt /QdfcyiAwnfe n^t-to pv^W\ 4tv<^ao >^^/^>%^7^^^ [ba^ ulolqdion
 flwvttflued as dbi sAcdi^s eksro^csc as a cWcSa aperfR.^.v/d^oftpjaT^
 duxr^d\dnland oodxr\ at ^ntercAYT^CPv^-\)oL4^^
 v^t^of^^kW^S^biA^                                 sevjefe pr^UfiAce (xid is
 proJuhi-tEd ISA//SS^AA*- >/JAA/-sSn<-' /SChr/yeA/:&ks JSj£^2£3Jb^Qj±}
 £/&&2&JS£hq£3c.f 03) ujfill as boira -ftbe 4^^\yiontu^^£g lS/&v?A* IS
 77%^/s:A AhtAfe/ASSA/f. or  fehu    LWrdora a-S. tv>od4 euldeWttoi/
     s Waxd 16 ^ it \n-ftva Sl^Ci ddOD d,(xd^.ffinfi^:L (oc*tl^VI1Abe
            ; .-  Xib 7   ii  -r—? 2

 SLicpJpmeH- ard cdreorbi -ftWd rkie-f/a/e Pr>-A\ro;viAbe Jfeggudak] (i^ide ),
*H\2. :!>2ftta^C5m pVo±>e oP 4vvd\ IS. uibere CouA'SeJ GcxvAtntA^ed do
                                      (0.
be. \r^%£\\Je. asdbisds a cSA\cr\ sUge To a. chkm^ case u_>We
due proC^S^prodeeVs a convncteA (xxoxx a^'ib doss ojh omxs^at
drial Aaxi^cAedd^TiaA-t WkS (k rlahf dx procedural s&Q^aiwtk tae.1
as rsjht Ao, Cot \t&&<~&e. S/<^S^ ISm^ iAnder ^ afe^syd^ ^
Mtp/ieze.,, Under A3g/tfe u^Vucb sentenceTs based,W reilabfe anc
acauTxd-R, TrSf/^rr/iSfit--rAr ,-fe^Monu c^P f^ixh^ Mtaadoza cdfies 'r^t
otod^btyA\u^ am ihAcre \mpbrAai^uard pvv7L\didal\u^io. adn,u-lknce
dV C)mCer boix+rd Tkrv^s. destitvoeMti QS loett as dl^phrari/i fepofT
euen ocPber tejm cbjpetaJ -ix CC^. \te&6bPb/ ^^sOandl on paa&llAW
idDPOxabbi.Vab flnesb flderruWJ s^er AV\digb wehc© b&sto fded uuAb/
Tr\ 4be CWfe £le ondl*s not to d\xs ^crxddxlal fvk, Odlfsons>Ac*ki .
en pqae 3.3 oP R.B. tot 5cfCYdWp 7-V ujas evmibd p^or4^rsd-4d uoell as ViGlaAim PwA^cie "51-01 c^F4be,
dexa-s Code oP Ldiivxnoi Ys'0(^Ai\m.7{\\s ad^mroe op yxA AAS^vpUmra
records Violated Abe adi^«p^Pdvj oyJr^nes^"1etos 1Sdle of Evfcfee
-the. UmWl S^Aes Cc..\r^ActV\6o7 as -jAus. Tixddtrrt vs veSesftA Ao7t\a
 detailed nafroAwe wj officsc-s,fxd- TueV- C^cer^rr«s,XT+Tse.Wr
 mound txova AaellfliWs v&^r^4ktt brM/i Abs StcxAe and Arlo,\ cojjpP
 UJncSerstooa 4\\e. nctture dP A\us. obve^Aicrya^ in otfervuUwj ob\xx\ 1a P^.R-VGWe GcPfcpogea Iand 2 lsP
SJo^feLVublA""7oL^tVus cm be Gs^erAt^jnod and A\va. Q^^wu3in x
Qcxuse Vudod-iov7 axP\r\x-ed as obx\d: bo \j^sujorrt/ QX/car/e o^ crp gotefhivnerd a^ploUi?es<™
  as only Qfeer "Torres G.ppe. a(TOX^C[c^
r^ord> redder lackdbe^ ^rp^»r4^ aJ^;-A^aj^a^ Ia/^a^^p^/^^^/fS
.Sy-srAfr f(xrd In-I2). v/oliume 6oF(oy page 3>S, iVTs sVv.xVi Vicuje b^ein pjur4V^r
 objecteo 4o as, uS)0cii eyArojiA^cus oA^^^eyicAencxxfi Ga^\i-ssciW^eAo
prove lde^tt\y uuWn4bie. caving GSn^^                                         ar^i
pSs Urusual as Ad act as rtete^mi^ ^IgnDck^^
 beapcor&nA AVow\ a Coupour\sojn csPAbe (Sva^^virsb^x^^'i.nbLAV. car^-Jy
 Ck&os. fSSArS^.:""T~9 KoWin^ iox-\\\ Abus c:o^<, c&^^riMcmA has
 amy one ^k5\ojt ^rcu^v^asr\ce/vn bcAV\ Cases, defenda/dr ta-vS
 clePerdirq JU\^tf)CR.1?,vol3af(q,pg.affiP>10ofHrppy^^ and pogx 3.
 of S\odes"&bibdll..'Tl/\e c:crd\\xied me^cd^g aSS'i^ou'xG.e.Ts
CoxdinteAlA Oxd also c\ uldlcdnon oF Ar-bck X 3 ID oF 4WT5«6
Cbfi^tuvAion as, dux .precox-, oP ,dd&.mm lOvbsex^sonA^^vxVcuT-^
beba^oard Cdvipslllng Atlelr afendojflCfc uuOS retv\€nATo^ed (Win
^etlrp-ffeobvc Ctxjjnsei and a Auyde^&vrWl e\^^
  IYhp Con b& h€.ld as errcr^usVai? alvAVie ad(cfeiwex>fon^ errors \n
 fcodb S-\\r-s Ond pfe\iioi\s\t^ Axled fcneToc€» IhdfASe^v/e a^si^arx^dt
  ^cuinsal and covi fcte deeded as_.Svv.ob U3 Abe boldlhas and 4be
 established AesV "in C£iSJ2c&ua -Aa /SA/i/aAAf^rAnh-A Q$\ be ddod also, as Adie sdardard Fsr
1ne$2eAlv£. toincsel ls4be SMAe tor bo\t\ Aelofluayici deoAbf^alAu
 cases. f\\\ oP Abose \Aolatbns-Could cund sliadd Roue beem axoided
 bx& cb^ect\mAo> r^pVA, see a£Aa %&z /S, Sfefe ji" a u)Vm cba$ ledde
 IOXaJTs DUcTAVmri iY\ /syr/wr ISi. SAvAr at-A /v /A?rA=> ^A-AerWA dn IiJpMcl
dAbo ^lodra durAb^c
4bot +V\fe £i>japWmerbbd (brief ecuptaA uoiAb Abe forleFalreodu redfeulal
 o^rAm record/1 dWouiab dki& Hdmratole CW+ o*\d C5u4\QesAA^ve re(7ef
 ftppellcuxf oeeKs IhHbe -Ponr) &f feypr^ ftg (Vnulebon flaad A-qurfal
 Ovltf if ncA'vn Abe xeru kcrd- TTis^T&Sftl tuT4k Ptejudtbp ;4o vbssj a
furdber ^^tesdlAuro- o\ Ax^ ddloxs as bcxs CCCovX^ci Auulce- DrEv'iGudu
and ccaucecl onli^ due to i\\ea^\vA^^av\o\ VicAcu-r- di-r^siird tovv^
latx ana pisbte as. is ^Aenrboncx^atab^^d vc£\!er\ mAocAt Bn&fs,
be MDtfvUa posdr kvsde
                                          t\especd£il ly tdubvudfeol,
                                           l^ppvllodd' Pro-Se
                                           fear CoiirrLjAcluldUdxxAn
                                           C&d-cr- l4aioTi\\l
                                           OlD Id, (Wa\
                                          5&r> A4t7\io7Te)(tc^"l8<2iT7

                                         IVpdbrd
                                          W
                                                 ffcvX    oe

                                           buk Miller

                                 T
     1J Kv)l£ MtCLL&S ^pcKoi4 Qo-Se In 4b ppkma4a1FWeF bas b^en delate^ do
4-iiP. fcay&r (XuMtj TJlstrTeb Pdtorneui GRtC£v ICl LO. OiA€^4Ab
Pbp 5ox7 Av^doido-lexas^^lCS, on, Adxsd-fe 26tU dau oP M&rch

                                                     el lord \7ro-Se
         3 V)

                      f

                          r-

     5

i«t
2
O
-9
                ••*
 a
                *r
              '•••'-   5
     \   -r        •   r   . . -, ••

^Xb;:                  X^
     ,„p^
 3
                             !-••      . • -