Court Opinion

ID: 8657294
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-11-24 21:17:15.449171+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:56:47.327916
License: Public Domain

PER CURIAM.
The defendant was convicted of murder in the first degree without a recommendation by the jury, was sentenced to be executed, and appeals.
It is conceded that in charging the jury the district court inadvertently omitted to charge them as provided in Comp. Laws Utah 1917, § 8026, which reads as follows :
“Every person guilty of murder in the first degree shall suffer death, or, upon the recommendation of the jury, may he imprisoned at hard labor in the state prison for life, in the discretion of the court.”
It his been held, both by the Supreme Court of the United States (Calton v. People, 130 U. S. 83, 9 Sup. Ct. 435, 32 L. Ed. 870) and by this court (State v. Thorn, 39 Utah, 208, 117 Pac. 58, and State v. Thorn, 41 Utah, 414, 126 Pac. 286, Ann. Cas. 1915D, 90) that a failure to charge the jury that they may recommend imprisonment for life invades a substantial right to the defendant, and constitutes fatal error. In this case the omission to charge the jury as afore*172said was not discovered until the motion for a new trial filed in-the district court had been denied and the case had been appealed to this court. There is therefore no alternative save to reverse the judgment of conviction and to remand the ease to the district court of Salt Lake county, with directions to grant the defendant-a new trial. Such is the order.