Court Opinion

ID: 4064409
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 21:27:41.951695+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:41.957150
License: Public Domain

--    ·"'·.·-                                  ..
                                                        . 1·o
-                   -~:::~...;-;"".-...,....----    -

                                                                 J...-1:>       ·/tfb'1   'yy!c.J ChP £-scvtA,.v'J. itJ 'yYIA- /4-c ~}'~t-dfY& l.~t)/r;-,._.r;/6 t.-IJ           .
                                                                .                                 .tu £) f,.( ~J v J ~ s f ~J>;-& "W1-<. n berS I l < f~v1J t p Jt n-rn I I'~' 7m
                                                                13,b) n'J ~               sr'y\Ao c .                                                 .   ·(09, :8.5Qi"'~
                                                                                .                 .                                          . RECEIVED IN
         •                     __ . .                                                          _ .                      .                  COURTOF;~MtrOl.~i~                         .
                               L
                           71'JJ~ ~-Jn_j)_b.:ef A Lo_IIJl· Lc {; ~ .es 10 JUL <29J~'-=L-1fi[?JS'-'--._ ·_ _
               _NfMgLo_~eJ c~~ -cL_[:Il J, S/1/udt+rlu_ ~}'1~~~·::-J~ '
            :;:'o-&J.L~~ s (' f- v r_ JJ e.g u_S.L!::_IJ2. r CO M ~ c J®__i_u C 11 ~1 o                    .                           d

           . f~_umt1 IJ:IJ_v?~ t" ::m 1 Clfl_:J:.L_~ ~(_5~~ bra !J_L/ u ! 11 ;u Ll)!l__
               !U>_~ f:- u lT o_ll_/)uJ/1 r ·i io ( D ~ . M .[e f Jv~ Je.J 'C AJ U Jv o-_J
                P'(!p '{I <-l                                   tv(__
                                        lib e_J~j-~ f(.s .:6r IJ J iLl b i t.vc s () ;u 0 "'" 6>-<- .
         • fi., e.s () '-t.JVS'-f /1 S' tic ~ $1Y-l (>:9. ~([}J rr-1 '/Y-) f}~ t' J<. s-'7.1 b-t: y 7 lb .                                                                    IJ(_

            ·Cj11/eryt; ('u '(1./~ucx~_[~v ov 7-u<- }yt-1 !/;. tDj.l} f)-s-e- /-VL£~ Lo YJ .J¥YJ~~­
         . 'Je-s c~_le t1 '0 Co.YJ11 7.-() iJ . ·m / tj' . ftwd L/!d ~( r:r~ ')/YJ y.:J IV ) /) d 0
            fl EsfP_J_[~_tJ_~ {1U_V. eseJ · eI Jrcrt )tYLl ~rtin in /J1VJ,~J2J _                                                                               )t)

            Poy- r o.s 10 ~-~ ·Lrrr:n Vv! fr·-cl /1 f frr-0 J-e Cur. !V e-1 u JUl '[Yvt-t lJJ:xi A.-)r1
          (t;J.J_(fdyn lAJ 8 (o lixn$ /b .t~! Je WY1 u {_cu. J4;vJu / / t5_!,_~/l w fi-·1!6
          (I rn ~ s·           AJ j'n do . (~ y.jV i}? !o ':)_j I l,q 'friAi_~ b /l; 11 &-5'_ p--~7/tv •
         .ru{_
                                                        VY!·6               t                                                                    l)        0                              I

                     [l »:>. II : 0 ;,.,_ iJfr_,_ (I f- lJ,'k~ Y;_ £s CiJ rL ~ 1--w-<                  ~II} yo ?J_
                                                                                                            1/t                                                      Yy1 )1

           f4 V )J St' (J~i l1_~/3::Qj~r-rl /J /'a fJ JC'v L;. (oJ· fo f_f_ VYu·> e£ Cu/~ JL-1 V . ..
                                                                                                  )'"In                                                                       D

             c(,w p J" [!_ LoJ 1- ·~~§ e~_r I ·m_; ~Y0 14 b 1L~ Re y2o m co 1--'-.frJ_._ _                          o       f>                                  }v

         . 'Y'Yl_L~ O~JV                                               f:                                   m ..e
                                                            f-v }1}J w;JJ_ )'?"'~ J'S fjJ )2 t:! t::J L~k-1-"-/l...€.-'----·
                                                                            (Jf     [-vt _r_/r:J fjtf(
             - jJ e·ckzJJY:t:l Li:J..YFJ ~-:g)<,'__/)~ 6 li~vr;# v ~· j/_, j '(~ r ) t' l1 c yy, v t:))                                0

         • rL£1 rmi_id /hb~                                                                             \""Z.s !YJ-mu: ~~tJfur i n-:t J"si'J.-v/6                                 /
                                                                                                        (
             . l_" &. fY£j ()~ /}/ .(;) ~-'f. fl:?'L. Je ) IJ yr·n $1rft n' (j A) { u }4 tv! I> .:~ bt cho VJ.fl)$ o. J~L_-yy)::f~ // Je> 4 u l ,u _Lu l'.:f Jo L) ej_f__~ tJ~' i:~o ·
                                                                                                             . •.. :·     '.   .. :   ,..

e s~~ FJ.(_~J) __ e_( iCf2L. . C.v.~d~-·~____£_Q/_~~~-~~~~-t_L_fk.?.~o:_W~~----- (
_/ lt!)L_(}___ ~-~--(-_o_ ___ [sJ]J__ k_~1S'Y1__b_YJ_J_11.1!_d_~ ____ fs)_!_S_:-__)1 fl}o-~_1_b __f)_yrc s.l£_~)
L_l_ce i-_0__~__d_c_}YJ__t9-tt! f JrJ v_r;IJ 0 s:1e iJ ·-z;x_~t )A rn J 1Y_ tJ-il f.j) '}yt.L J e-<; f/J ·
de__flLs~-J e_~b. ch o J e L 1 iJ" J f V-Jln- tL d c l 2 co'- £'u e. v N
j-/ a'yy,~ rl. __llmfrvvrbY-Jio (cL_'L!P J es !'y:! ~ 11 j e7f).)f_~'L)_rt-.l! c;_uc Po r ;v<- -
16 A-~ ~W            ~b YJ4do     -(( P'!1J b-e(h~d__LCf_~~ . . _iLL_r_/_€£}__)!):_ M-~                    _

Lb. cf,· eYf) -e L J1·b uS () J._ V J I AY-rt I? ~- f/ /fo {,1 r'YYI FJ"r f~_-:Jt.o -r I
               JU                        t\                                                 ~' uC.. Yo _
                                                                                                    LJ
7
 Y?A..S;O~ (J r-·vc eYJ{) ef-t f!~-( cha f_-ervo C'fl1 J~ .te}.-·f(;_c; J4 .b u
                            )J                                                                 r/ 1.-oo~J.._
                                                                                                     {ii?O

~e l ~I bj_e_CJ)__i:!_f.Lie ll_Jtrc v- Pf> ' e s o /1_f;_&v:r!--_ 19- u~ Z j_'/1 du "")Jr1 e ¥I rfl M . _
                                                                                    (,j

?fvr ~e )/IJ)xUJ_(!/;pt ~Ar·1f/Jc:i r/~t:_f?-c..s-t~ i/1 {o.,1L f};yv . _
:.L!)V let ) t n II u j 'IJY"fYY-A- ~ E_s@ 6t1 {3_5_ us ·mtJcl £~ -~ u t I o ~!YJ __
ru_{~,'~ll>           fb~ _'l_p_IJpoJ foYj_ c() ttL fj-l}_es_Jltb_t)_-§JLdo_1' u r I l) s )~11 f h___/) ~~J 'y rf..) ji) ([U ( p J p J t //af \

:r   I t' 13__1v I o ~v c ·re _/l ~ f. c-'tr a. ~J{).J;_~-J.) ) ' ~ \--V f!I1Y'rl _f) IIJJ ·f_tLLL·T_r;__
 -1 v_i_'[}j_j_~_Lo __J~,(_!?tli" _{72            P~dew _jA_dtLc/JJ~~"-j~_j_~_bd_ ~~-
~---------~
  ·- ---~ .. ~-- .
    ./"'
                                  -        --

           •       f~_/_ o_[;_yt_/ )_I_    M_u_:__ij, 1~ } -rJ L.. u o~-IJ f{-y· J_'. ut-_ /-o            /LU     .Q:e_:____

        r~k l ~s j r-Jr ~--- _U~)./14-:$ d-e h -, s l! {Jl+ s t~ eI/ ;4-f C/; )'Vl-D                          -

  - -eI I~~ v 1.1 C11J YJl!_tfi·~ d.trl, ~tf e.-¥11-:S e~ b,, e~ ;1--5 - ;W=t J/ Jw-v ;..; /LO ~I!fl _
     ftJ 0 S_;;'\l1Yl [; tLo 'fu_L,~vY<-b J flp/ JA,_ eJJ f}-~ f./ VW' tU r/_ :/.__'t/tJ ILAI /-/u-r:          _
     N •q-j."          LiL(;YVJ Es rJliJ        h
                                            -e-t eJ u JJ o'h l J ~ d." u JU J1 iiJ t 111- m itJ
_ Cj' v y_/) tJJ~ hVJ '17; l Y' I ·'I]_ eVVI_}Q o Co tJ ~ j 5_()_1!/ )J_/ 11 ~ 1-/ 'VVY' /-JV(/6
      cl e~e I I tJ L& i!-S u I 1b f!-'J f- r!__{_c/_r YJ J=_d e_[t_2 H yC) J-e 1 oo7' f I I rJ ·
- . j'v e~l VJ u lt-Vj 5_yJ P- r£[J_ J _fj y f-1) r i 1-e.J ' (om,_ ~f} by;
                                                                          I}                         rn
                                                                                           cie /) r:/JpJ
               I
           ruLU~ !._LC=.pd.e u ~ '() 17 YVdll-- f tA £ f I I fJ'YV> ,)_ l ;1 OfB J -L .
_ -m r ~ e so GcJ r_fL_-l_yy-e.:r__c__'l,__J~J-r 6·)-t/yt)~ ~1--'- o~~r ~~y-; J /) __ _
    L (,) _S-~YVJ-11-1/11 /U )/J/)              _/lvJ}
                                                  v? /?_o .r -q:_ u ~ l_ o fU L nJb lrh: · [ ( htJ )JJ4--1.y£

                P
          -e_/_Yf] Rt2-f'u /J}J ~-11£--~_rLvJ cr M J · nv ·2 ~ JLAJ Oh-t /11 '"Vv1 ~- i
- •                                                                            r
          /LJI c bL_L » n ;10 Ltd_~ IJ 1~- u t-rYJ (v JV u }\) ~ 1.1 (/~ /J c h 0 f. v(_ --

       ·-/o ( ')-LO -e yVJ r:I /U {) bi b ·e-5 6 { yg_ {v e Co'yy(O -e I '-.... o 7- J t [t:.6_ rt 0 _ _ _ ·_ _
    C u ~__d;j_, ~'- .J• [/,_ _) I '10 7'- vL /-< [ o W> )'1 ;--< Lo J S )1 JO- ll-'JO S Le_                __ _
      ru_c"~-f rl_IJ.~S e'r II/ f-!P-l_t>-_-(; if(_e;o J 1> _ fvc ( o'VYl o L(-} m f.VM--fJ o S ~ r1- .
_ · 'YvJ)__ [/lJ YJ _l_{)_m r:J- n-fJ-- :Je. m 1 tu / r 7i1 -Cu 11-Jt/ j v It? '&} /" Co IV .e I
_ :, fLb.biLf:1· f'~-eyYJ;-· Je l JJ.J:.;g_--Jp · J {)- ·C ~ S tJSPf'C h~ · j,~-n lj o fDr ._
·              1 ''/'~ j "-S_ rlA_'Ylii          ;t: / r- \IYJ   J e s 11__f)_     6   Y'(}   1Y-J I) d -c~   ~ jt)   ••       _

               Lilb o rn76 no 1- /.-e. _eg
                                      fp              6 bIn /U ;a-c/ fJ- AJ rtJ ·Y' I ·J rrJ-- 7 V{_
                                                          M       5_ J4
            ~f I Je_j ij-rr> Ad)~ f ll l6 rTL c II t (u e_j_ e Ld flt' LS~ Jl-- rY: :J~
           "YYi fir z.. J l__l}rb It Po ) f! l~. • ·. .. •.
              c;rvc M d ~£ ~> ~~ _llct~·~u ~lu 'cio_i-~cfJ_~yO _v.l)r-JtPj·i-:A/
              c;p't- e.-n_:~ {!trL~~j/ b__f}_ iJ d e.-'ll' c// br ~VL_f-rl~-s 'C 7 vL .-e/ 'i -
(-1 Lj
   A C6Ht: S,,_,ht_j} }-l!Jt1 __)'1~--~--Jo.>:r: __£,L~t~---~~~--c:..~--~--~f1 ___ b_ trr~-~ (
  .Fl- _t~u \Z]. m uv:4c£T>~ ,t;b_Cr 'T'c"'?.:i.~ M _d_,_1f;.IJ~ .frr -!f u:r: .5'.~~ ')) .
 -tj-~"f IL:1L __ e s.____ £LtLr.D_V I_ J Tc c_17 b~~ -e c.1 / 6 C u r ~fYJ J e S tJ i c{) yYt-C _
                                                     e:_                                                             G

_f-_a_ ui1Y tr1_6 ~--4· J '( ( u (. yI tJ ba s~r;r_ d~a !J £~ s e./r'YYU                            ¥-o ~,. v _          r-vt
~~rl ~ (J(;r Lc 5 'io n~J tl () L-r d/_J-e uee. M ('I 'yY1 A 6(J f!_.e                     r          f-·vG -                   ytJ

_<_;_J AA ~___L__&J l u) t1 ~f) ~ t S:.JJL1JEYIJ f fo fJ- j"'__E_-yr·-p.-g fJ-- U /J-1 o ~.ya--d;, _                     Jt./

  d f PtO 5-/A: / Lu- r So l tit: j'_ o '( I j e 1t c11' be A t o Jl/S t- 1 o )}_ -yn fh-1 A 2rJ / / / J ~
~_§ ll l vi (:'u i' n'J fJ C uS'~ dt Lo f}ls fJ Ja 1' if( (-} I { 1J 3u lo/Y1 c /J /b VJ1V _
 Jl_J1eJ_D v· YJ Ju c J a i ra- 'YY1 f A..v -vn_ t J-l ,' 611 Ji) p- j t' J 11 r /) n t I wY I ~ J / -
 [u e       [}I J 1 yYL-( Es Tv; {e,-o ~ fo ""' J t ~ J Cill SoJ J e (;_) e- -c I l__i_i_) ~
                                                                                      iJ

Cj'-Y ( ( ~u rf u L: de_ S I M b~7 VL ~ £ S171 b~ )1/) () ) IJ Jvl -~ 'tj· u I ;f-n
          6

Im~fj_ J't' L_t.,_y_~ L · c f r< Lrce)_Lf££- y_ ~I 17' t 1 J o rJYY3 b }4 J r1 b J-? t'-JU _
"£___/__[_- t lv'L'CD. J u v ttvl L r JJ LYJ CY-J r-z ( c L, / c 14 J t )fL.LJ b v r~5            (
 j__ __Cu_triJ£ _i_ o 8_J_f1 yrc ~ s r rrrYJ sv;-d v eI I cz_ tLIQ ~~7- u r LJ / ~ ;11- _
nc /It_G:_yJg tJ de )9:_:_[ _[d- w ~- u Cd.rJ'U bi •t-ro ch c ~ v (_ a-tJ d() m.
     G                                /1
                                           1
                                                                                                                                        II

 rle _Car LJ- v !' M_d_Lb i ~vrJ uVkf1 YLJ n- LU_S- J1 Ji_o_(fl_ cftp LI t!J 'c                                                       v -,
 _e_l) ~ eJ &&-tJ YK ·e 5 (' rL'(]1 6 n j \) 6 m- ce. LJ L.v. 'yy,__,.f ;D / c f}J 11- LLi___-c IU
              tJ                                                                                     j
 r L. /1 c~~12_u ~ o y~r;JJ r'5_!!_£:___i d ~yt) J.e I L11~g oYrJ 7J. h'b }2_ /}_[ 14-c.
 J_i;_~_clt:J n_£ ).) R. 1 ¢~ ·-rLE ~ f tLe c (' ;1/!L. I e I._E__~ u c ·1( !1 ch!! (fJ )l _
  J}:__ f}_ l1J W /LC f. S·/}a Q_(;_ t' tv j /) J1 [ Gl ]: u r 17 rILL u MJ J /3_ o J ( S" o J -~-0J
  :5L'S fl_oS/.sos S6JV J-<- E~#-WfJ ~-Y'YI /J jLo Chc, Cj v~/VJ )ltb D Lr; l"t/lrL/J _
  rl -_L_&..b ·/) yy.r i/7J 'hi() LD r;;-_Q_(_j_ /s_-( [ tr_Lv I JtlW EJ )OJ_ JV'[] w / }1 ! I /     J    (!

 Je-'b -eJ--l-e_}.1_1,_(k___c_:sffi_f?yu t_~               1,)   s     ::Jd'l_/1 .s        5 -r-3-v rn n1 c£_ / ~ ]_y_L_J_!_ J "_ -eI         _j
 It LLtl__b_(J     y7)   1h_ r-J b   Q~        ·1 fJ
                                                \l               I)   er- / fJ   Jljj_ blli_c_)J_j~_ b_e}J_ Y)? j e Jjtl~J /          c!'0~   -!
 '}GO_~{( J'J /} b fH) "yv) I\.--! s~l_SLbL'i:.rn_c;.vtw __Jj VJ:~~lLOltU 'v}1_j_5_ e JIJ k                _J
                                                        n                                                    I
 ~ 5 p_/ J t. b_~ula__b..-1 vi. 'vy,.L 13 ._,_f (~, IJ [r).X.(/.YLfb~ )e1"'fYl)~_Q_M St_ X1:1 JJYC k;      -~
 'I_Cre_~k_~t_[J_b ey S'J .. L E).t'j,' t Jv) e l__rD~__tYJV /) y j:]_2 J ;)__~:! ~t lv _n l9__    0 b 5 r _j
 )_r_y_J_~LLYll&__ r_(}_~_L?._L__j_s~J.!__'tJ:J. !1s_£JY._fu_J-)LL&--r-e z.___j_~=.y_e._b-' ~7J' -~ r Lo·f
                                                            h e""'J { :l r1           /HTb ~Lc-s