Court Opinion

ID: 4073990
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 04:37:47.577272+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:58.487537
License: Public Domain

,,                             01vse 1\1°· \JJII2':J-Yio5(A) '
                                                                 1
                                                                      '\          dG} 96<f4-!Y/
 M~Rk t'J\\LL\£1~N                              X IEXf\S Cout:T of .
     "TDCj :iD      t~8'34os·

 fe..' ici~ P\+Re
                    Rei~
                DALLAs Co~ 1
                                                y.
                                                y..
                                                       c
                                                    ~If)) I rJ AL ~~fiArl s
                                                                     couRT oF cRIMINAL APPEALS

 \JLs~ict CA~k ~ he~ ·
 Otf\CIAL . CApAC\if                            '>'                          DEC 03 2015
                       Re~                      '!·
       A, ~ LAl,JJIFF'5               APPLJCfiTI6rJ Fcf( MJ&~JTc&£ chttMDA-fVH)<;
                                   Of2JG1AIAL
 To Tt4e           l4oN6~~13LE JvDG,.E J 5fol~ CouRt :
          C. OT're.S ~ow, MARK WII LLIGM f<e ~-lut~
                                                  p17D:5e OJ -/-4 Abe 5-1-y /eJ
                                                       1         1

     A!JO IJI:Irhb~ CJ4u.5e cf k:hcl.l A-tJo .ftles -+~.,; 6 D~t~jJp.\ flppll~.J
     ~ 0~< 'Wei+ ck MIWOAIV\J~ 1 ~J,e::>tJ.A,J+ -to Al:hC1e \3.03 "'' tho l~s
      Civ~\ ~12ed- 1 Ce Mo ~~j 1 ~s ecJe .. ANd WouU -sk..J 4 ~lbw1;.S·
      _15. Rel~~
      \.0\ Mf¥~ I'J\\LUbihl?DC.)~                     l~ls3~o~       IS AJ   6F~h ~~ 'J.te !eJ><A-s.
     bep~ 0~ UL~ #tiJ~~J jv·.s~ce 'A~ \:> ~~11\!5 r~o .se) lJho ~
     he I~J M: 5eo-H Vt.~i-1, loqq~ Ret«,&~e Rd 1 A-rJglefnrl 1Y 7751 '5,
     \.02 t<e\~-lot< . \!~s e.Xh ~vs-ted ;.· h'1s r<erneJ1t>s) a!lld hf'rS N? OTHERS
          R~,e.s A+                lAvJ.                                      ·      .·.     : .,/;   .
     I .os \he         ~+ ~V<jh+ ~ be. ~fBliJ 1s tnt~ls+IZI~f/vot D1~W#f)
     hJ              Tel41-s R\lles of A~IP"k ~e~v-~ 5J.. 7 !<eqv.~s ~~~~ft.
           N.jl,\.vl{e..
                               f
     ()~ t}" ~\ \e~ c(Z \ IJ ~ \ vSto,J \N .\-k {(ecdZel rnu.s+- M ·+~ s Arne ·-h ~ -
     ~t(tv-e. Vf'C·h 6~ 4~ \JM+,'eS>. Ru\e 52.1 o~ \eMs Pw· f~o(;, J.es~ibes
     A Wt<'tl o~ ~AbeAs CoRpus A5 AN Mll3i,Jf1/_,~~~cfn~~~tJ ~i/5
     extrz ocJu~tk>y R. el Jef               ·,s that.,~ ot P?o' quality           :me of amagmg.
1. OL\ ; 0 tJ :Sepl-em bet? ).LJ , ).. o 1S" +he      -f he cJ.'1 Isl- t> A-!Ills COVN ty D1 ~d
Co ud 1S5uee\.         '' f\1 Ag \~-JRP+efs PRo(llseJ F; i-1 J1~1) o~ Fkk ~ ~~~tO.S
6~ L~w '' 1tJ          A   Wei+ of ~1€J>s        CoR{hiS       Appl,~ ~hi,; t:tJdv&:t).
 ~~ \,,jss              .5~veJ               -+~ ~~~~Jf, l2e~+.vt ~-e. lhs LL"'.ss
                                                                           1
             tJCVeA:              UfbeJ
 I Nd~ AJ '' Atf:;dAti+           by
                                   \S12M.        Loi/M'',"~k ColJ~t ,~<epoaAe/ fWd
" i<epotz:l-e.<.r i?ec.,pJ ~ f\5 we I\ As         -1--k '' e.J+I«e C..OJJ~ o ~ --\.;k
  Cou~+-s -h\e 1t-1 Cf\u5e tJo.                F} \ J+lllo~~ ~df}~ hA-S t-f ()\- hPJ
  f!\..1'1 Df' +'re.se \iems ~ve), uporJ h ~~+hilS hM l"nflde 1+                      ·
 l rn-(b.sS1ble -h:l RcsF'JNJ I)~ obit+ +n +heSe . ~luJJ~5· \h ~s ~
sev:z~l Reques+ +o -tk d ':'WI'ct cl&k Re1ueD+\tJ5 --rheserl ~I iJs_s
L~xl-),bi+ 1':1.) b1 l>S rnP 1\. ~~) Re~.J5e ~:s bee.J QetieJ.d,
                            .. lf. . .
c'        l<e~patkle.rt    . ~ ...                  .·.
          R~de.J+J Fd1c1A- ~Ike~ ~o~h'c1A\ CJ1V.ACt~ As D1st,ea
 ~~~k of DI\LL!4S CoJNfY, 't.xAS hfl.s A rn'Nisti<p/ du-Jy_ -n
 R-e l' IM AtJd ti /e A/} fPpeiL S 1,J {};,~,tJ~~ ( P~~"~Y1 p.,.;J fett ~a/ltY> fl fl
othort dv-hes I~ o.J ~ de.(.k b'1 lAw pu{(~tf14Jf- -'h C~.f.                              r
 IM~ :t~ I -to (2e1urf<eJ r+ll p~s ftteJ 1rJ flrJ ~~g~~p.( ~{Jd~
 j?1Zo£"d uvs ~ fl/So fx :)e,Jf- -In €flch ·~ 1}1- -tL 5/Jrro -h p,.
JK. r<vb o~ ~peAfl-k Peoedl)lle 5),f-.                         (ei!C/p.   PWe   {YJfly   ~ ~141
 A+ I53 ;J. r<i~~MI-) L£, 12 DtJU!ls IX 15.2o1--Lf5oo ·
                                    "1-rT'                 '

 . fo dMc 1 r2e/,ml{ h'f>s ;;,it/e) /110 f<eSfbJse f-.eom ~AtJl- M
  to Re_lp.-/nci ~trsf -lv &. 5t'$.vej +iese hJ,i.J;;~ us:J h~t ~
   l'ni1GJS7((!1T£ 1r1     4 P~ h;.~c/;;5 ()~ iN:+s                       AJ)   ~dti9M,s of /A; 1'
           .                 nr
      ~lA+or<. tJouiJ .As~ k     Judr~,Jrl None£ ThAi- tk J.grs+ f4iltt5
 Ceu J~ T f( 1    ~ rS-f!? 1'c+ ~ Cw .d· 1s . N trr +~ l\ R·1 qiNI\-1 \I( 1;.I
 Co~.~,:z.t. ThAT +\,..., OfLI~itJA-\ T«lfl-\ Cou~+ Wp.S 4-\.e 31osP<I
 J0d\c 1~1 D~~~;c.k CouR+ Who ReCN.;eJ het~1~ ·Hwr>" +he
 c. ALI.sc -11 vJ \12f41o 5 .) f'-tlj ). F II).7-4 b~ 'f{,p,+- WP.S klfJ;-6{
  .

 b, ~udse ~tJ~ AJ l-4-J<. ,+~ Gufl(le.Jt- DA liAs ~'-'4 Ors-1-fz,(:+
  A++-or< rJry , l'nfl-c:i5~te , C.M. <) AIY\ 5 , 141.:1 Ju~e. ~rhA.J ,~
 rn:+c~ell h~ ot-1\7 ~e. I i,v;,+eJ) v,J ·deucio~ J~coM AJJ
  ~PV' 1 ~~ NJ AtAu~ B/l.AJ Lo\lf\(1. s ~~~u+. f->r<pj Mlt~
 CoJd hA~ 4 +R,A I +Jz~s-G<Z,fh, Cav~<T ~de 1 fepotz4.<.
 l'2e to~ A.JJ f'«t jAJ[h Not J\VP. 11 WI,., -b Rc,j 10~ (j h1Cl ik<,
       U51~ s -to ~Y ~1~\<~n.R. s d ,~., w1+\.. bl}i- r.llou.II\Js h,n,
  1+1< e
  -+~ S~e flcCe5S. 4u Je0elop +\-.e Re:COi<J ANJ his d,~s
1\fl.~rvt~ Przocduae S J..t- J4JJ 5'2.\ dep.kl't &<\lh~e A\loR
  ~ch ·pf\~ -h> b ·6cy.ve). Prf- ~ ~ -h~ .. As r<eltrlu~
. hp.s ·the burzcb.I oF r~~~ IN +ht~5. Acf,O,J he :Sh>u \J hA.N
  e-,lt~ h\J ~1 \t'~J -h '+k Cov.(.+ sercveJ -\-CI h,in -to t'llaw
  fOe<.    A,JSwut tzekv#-p(   f\Jd o'DJ~'~" uhct.e App1,,;.11e          -h ·
  $Ph~~   hl.s . ~4'\-, p,.,J lti.f\., p..~~ D~ -fk U.S.C.P.; AJJ
  -tk \eyp.s ~.Jshfu-1·\o.J ~ Te)41.5 Awe'1M<. Przoce.JJ~es.

                                           ·'"":   ..
        ~

 r~Ayeft .ro~ ~hJ       .            .
n Wh('fe~ J p~,.s~s r~s,J~ Rd~ m~k ('n,\l,~       v -. ,_ rl(o Se·
                                                               I

l<espee+ful~ 12eque5+- A ntJJ,;,5 -+-~ ~h~ ~..J~+ J,;j vJ of
~~Gnlt                  {;he   ~~d~\1(+         of        ~j ~\\AA I ·e\et()<;~ f<eCA~ 4
IZ~crah~ RceorJ ) J v~ !'Y'e.J 1- I ::Se,J~ ~ J docbf- 5 ke+s 1\,.J o+k
e.XJh,b,h A-t.JJ. evtJe.Jt-M1 Yh~~ (tl-eJ lrJ ~ ~~~ ReeoKJs
o~ Ctlose NUl\-> b~ WI 12~L/ hS"" ) p..-s rkqU 1ized ~ +k T e1<f\S
\( J e5 0~ JWe !Me Pfo0)JI'e r2J le $ r; ].1 ~AtJJ 5 ;).. JJ U t:Vh (r.~ A
~OoJf'b\e ·+! W 1 +~+ {J~ VJ«e Req uC'Skl AJd ~+                                               ·-tr'
5 ~vld be ru~P-~. T~M-- r<e!A~(( htts biOU<J~ fh)'s fd,~
'tJ CJocd ~Piih AJJ hM svbswJ,,p//-) pkVIli'hl A-s P~t~s
 CP·J5C:          hf'-) (Yler<,'f
  r'<e/ p;fm:>,        Ptzf\y s F
                               Of{      AJ   of?.d.ett.   a/~te.dtrJ'J      -J.;~ f?espN:lArJ1- -1<>
 Fort,IJ\.,wl+!- -hz~~sr» rl -f!~ ~~~ ~~ s 1rJ                         4 l.s Vp.use b4 i1-e d1s~iaf
 Co.Jrz+ +n f\ \so 6 S~vee/ otJ ((r:)f\-hs"
                                                                   . [)y ___
                                                                         nul~·-=---~~·.'"\
                                                                                ~
                                                 n                                RcA,1)1-o~
                                UN-'u biZ:rl              n"
                                                LI8Cl~M DvJ
                                                                   .

    1 Mf!«l< MILL.I&flrl -,Jr 1~[34031 1-e..:s t..Sc~ 1.1 5cut~ LlNii, 'fQ;j
                                    1

             [3ff\zofZi11 Cw~ IX deci~Re vNdo- .U.. {};J1J.~ o~ ~)d~
        1
'f. D       1
                , "'

 ~ h~ 'I' hM '{2qj 'Ill~ UFi+ N) A fA·Js Pflc --lt<ve /#;(
   ;.J     I .            ·. .        (YU~
 Co(l(Led: f:>.eWJ rh 5- W           f\11fl1" /YJ /k/&h/ fle)M P12o 5e ._
             te«-\-'\~\·C A+e   or   SetLv!'Ce

r   1-\{'a.,by eetL~ ~ -vhfl'+ ~ +r<ve Up~ o~ +1v 14bol!e ~pltCA%J
~R Weit of M~I>Nv\lls LJf\s ~ r~h(,:p, Peke D~liAs        .            )

to,JJ1 Dt.s+tzt~(- Gieck, 6~ plAd~M;... ~A~. P. C_,o·p1 oF
P..Jdr«.sseJ -\-o \"35 rJ61Znt JZ~~~ i3lvJ. liS 1'2.               D4LLA5 \EX;\)
7S2o1- o~ +his df'J oF D~b. 3, }Ol s.

                                      rnwJ~
                                     ~M K    t'VII W &AtJ 1   /Ze flAo fl
  {\1\AR I< ""'ILL' c;,A~                X
1tt' l~~3Llos C2e\~~a.                        -fems Cou RJ\ aF
    f'e;)t·c It+ Pe+lle 1 DA ll~s Co.   X
  . . D \s~·\c1 Clettk i/J J-ktl        Y.    CRHW~AL ~?PEAL~
      6 F~1ct ·A:l <!f~c,; 4--~
                  ~~                    '!
                                  ORDER
      The ~liM CovN~ 1 \)1$t«ic+ Cl~k                      1s   he{l.eb1 D£06CfD
      +o;
       ·p~ff\~ f'< ~SCR+i J f\\l ~S                  IJJ   -t4s ~LI5e   ANJ ~~~t
  +k CkJ:s Re~, 4'k ~~s ~ 1 jvJs~t-~+-, 5e.Jk.Jce 1
· docket skd-s 1 g~cl Loll~'~ AftidAvit 1 docket .sWs ~d
  <»~ exh,bin ~ euid~'7 ~+1-& Cd-ee~ hl +k· 4-<ttAI
   R-etattd s ct: +hL~ C-All5L +o MAR~ 1"111 LLIC9At.J J e~ 0~~, (Y1Ai I
    ~·.~eo-~+ utJit. loll~ Y<0121M- Rd. ,V\1 1eto.J Tx +Is,:; tr>
                                            5
    Requi0 b'1 \ Gc,.s Cock c~ ~e1Aie PRotedv~, . .
             ~~S~eJ       ftwJ.    ~-ktz..d !hi& .         dAy o~            )Ol$".
                                                                  f'.W \.: iv\ ll.LI ZA N                                                  .               -fb;     fet121 P. P1We \\51-llt'd CI<:Rk
                                                                   l "8~3-LlO-:>                              f<.. V ·                                              \ 3J          rJ.    f<?t   vtt.ttfP.oJ+ LB l 7.
                                                                           ~eh< 1r've f:J , Pi\~J/.S;;nlX ?[,5,~97 -\p6 0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         1
                                                          · lf1'1 'l
                                                                   ~'~_q;\d~!~<J''{: 17'5\$ ', ·~ ,.:,'./'i'.• :• •                                                                       •ho•              '   '

       RE. .SeR~ lee o~ •~o,(ls.:;~~-·~· ~A ~~\Je. W11 Hli~~ .(,r:) '· • \~~?~eft- !tlpw~       •!       '

                                                                                                 .~~ .. •.·       1.,. .. :,·.~ ·~.~if..

..~~>~\011. ,c1£Rk . fct, c~-~- :eifB~; Qp utl.~ ¢;,J . .tty. ~,{f. c1 fRk •·. ~"! , ·.
                                                                  . ;   '   .: \\,.\ .

f'•{; Ricif~s;: *f ''lZZ;j~ (Xr-"~ ~ttlt./)1~;_ \1-11 ~' 0,u· ~A :>k thA-~ {k fi It ~~~
L'},                      ~
       hl J 'til ' \pje t U:ho; -1. 1•H•P.b<'A                   ~f:      bt:M,-,Je',                        ~'Co~?f~u~
                                                                                                11bf-e_ to _rne, lJ h1(: h                                                        AJ~d
     L~ wli!•·· ~""4 u~ ,!i · tkM ·~v:ey ·'be :~ "';\~r t ··f'n'.;_ by · lLs. _M~j! 1f '"'·· ·· .
     ,~R \l\t; s 1-*..A~c~\ ik >p.,&~ddRe. -~3:'.+ ~ u,;~ s ie.d:~~c~ of ~ \1 flir.J'";,:i'i:l f ;l~s
  () !  ~~ !-lcftf~XO~ ./~~;~·· ~<r.t.MJ rn6:s~
                          ,                              l•.M iJNJ                                  '                                                              '511~ -h~c- 1i?~~~e ~ ~~'"
  '.. R~\c .Sll: \ 0~ gt,\e~'\)f''·' rt·n,;.
                                        0     \~-r :.f\>)·,....l ~;ll;;~c~~c\l~s·
                                                                 l.'J__.J,vl·~ '] \:., .~.:. -.,~ .~:~.~~"~'f "!-k.6,'~"                                                                                                                          ·.
' e~o~pL:~ ~~., A~ ~z ~~~!:~~~ A~I\A~<: Pkqcdj~~'':rebi'.Js _ex+-tkJ ,J~f'l ael,ef
                                         t'!/                                                                                                                                !'                                                               .

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  .
       -~~·.l~; ,:l~+hcJAro~ "~;;,bJ!,.;:;b,s. hJ·,.v~ ·",~~~iih:·s-pR;f;;,;.
 EaJi~i'l DG'' fkf ~~·:·Ltlclvi',g;J'~'(;f l~;J•·"tbes 11~·                                                                                                                             Lou!H              ·~~/' ·•
  l'~~r-~r(; '"'~~Iii '}3~¥{._~·11-lia '~,It\~~; J1~N; {.l~a·· JJY~·,.llo iot~':'M
  ··~+~~ €~+1~.; CVtl ·\ e~{!~ <Jt ~~ ~''~a~~ f1Y~ IJ' tAJ5; ·wJ:·f~'tf-11 LH. '5",
        .,                                      . )                          .                                                                        ·.            ..            "                  ...        .            , . I .•

   q,hc               ~ fer<~S' {~clv n~· ?to &;~ p,qJ J:~:;~"-i~e,.,;,{~ ·~·~1: ~~·~Pii-"W( ,e ~
       C: ,;;,.~1";1~;~). ;~· ~;<,.,;Jd,. f.\~- h,;. {;'~oJ.t>··. h/A ' t-WII 4,~<6~.:; , ·.~J~ Arn~"'
  4
                                                                   1
        ~- ":;,,t'~~~~~~;h,~ ·~J~J;:~i:V~~~~~tf&_,,~~~\,:~&\~ is :J'"gfKp·~­
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  n ··_,. .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        1

  tttlu iJ. ··4ct ~(+ ,;r: 'rcc.sft;iJ<J          'be'• ·i:l\r\-,~.J~ ·1N ·~~."''UK';* D~. WJ.:{~l~:;tS1 \\
 ~:.c, ·-~Hi ·7~;,':1 Gt~ ~+ ·'a(..• ;ej~ ';..,, ~~ I ·f.\'pp'i?fl i4./ \.f•.,         ·· .' ·~iY!:'~\
   · ·f 1er,~ ·. r<e~JJ 1J' ·'rt:~\ ~""'r~ ·.,:~:S\.;iC>ot "•· ~~·~c~f' ~,.                                                                                                                                                  ·"'•"··
   '                  .                      .. .            •.                           -                     ''(7                             ,,                      .                      •.                  ,,       ••...••

             '            \i' . ..• ·   t-          '/._,.,,~
                                                      ,. ! '·.      .        '
                                                                                 .::,:·       <., y·
                                                                                              '-.    .
                                                                                                               .,.·;:                      ·,~: ...
                                                                                                                                               .,,,
                                                                                                                                                      1,. ,_·:
                                                                                                                                                           ... .
                                                                                                                                                                         ......()'.··        ~~~ .
                                                                                                                                                                                  .t·. 'r J· \II,
                                        •                                                                         •                .. . ' i                                  .\.6. ..· 11\..!L~W'\ .
                                                                                                                                                                          ,.fY\.t>Rk !Yt, II1"'"" .1\w \, c,....-4
             l.' ·•

         \.'·                                .,:                                          ·                       ·. ·"-                    "
~!..   •   • . .:.