Court Opinion

ID: 9308620
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-12-02 17:20:43.923018+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T17:14:02.544657
License: Public Domain

BONSAL, Judge,
concurring and dissenting:
I concur that Champlin’s motion to dismiss the appeal of DOE for lack of subject matter jurisdiction should be denied for the reasons stated in the majority opinion. However, I would not retain jurisdiction in TECA but would remand the case to the district court to reconsider its holding denying DOE’s motion that it be dismissed as a party, in light of Dyke v. Gulf Oil Corp., 601 F.2d 557 (Em.App.1979), decided subsequent to the district court’s order.
*1249DECISIONS WITHOUT PUBLISHED OPINIONS 1249 UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS Fifth Circuit UNIT B DECISIONS WITHOUT PUBLISHED OPINIONS The following cases have been decided without formal opinion prepared for publication in the permanent law reports: Docket Title Number * Rowland v. Schweiker .....80-5666 * Goulden v. Davis..........80-9042 * Cain v. Smith.............81-7138 * U. S. v. Smith ............80-5620 Aldersgate Foundation, Inc., Matter of...............80-5697 McCallum v. City of Macon, Ga.....................80-7354, 80-7629 U. S. A. v. McCoy.........80-7395 Sunnyland Refining Co., Inc. v. N. L. R. B............80-7795 * Denaburg v. Post Welding Supply Co., Inc..........80-9037 * Watson v. Busbee.........81-7204 Hollowell v. Jove..........78-2479 * Meggett v. Wainwright .... 80-5436 * Compania v. Parts Express International ...........80-5526 * Parts Express International v. Yale Industrial Trucks-Gulf/Atlantic ...........80-5526 * U. S. v. Castro............80-5603 f U. S. v. Adler.............80-5733 * U. S. v. Sanchez ..........80-5766 t Boire v. SAS Ambulance Service, Inc................80-5911 Tenn-Tom Towing, Inc. v. Inland Towing Co.........80-7622 * Fed.R.App.P. 34(a); 5th Cir.R. 18. t Local Rule 21 case. Date of Decision 9/ 2/81 9/ 2/81 9/ 2/81 9/ 4/81 Disposition AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED 9/ 4/81 AFFIRMED 9/ 4/81 9/ 4/81 9/ 4/81 9/ 4/81 9/ 4/81 9/10/81 9/10/81 AFFIRMED IN PART; REVERSED IN PART AND REMANDED AFFIRMED PETITION DENIED; ORDER ENFORCED AFFIRMED IN PART; REVERSED IN PART AND REMANDED AFFIRMED REMANDED AFFIRMED 9/10/81 AFFIRMED 9/10/81 AFFIRMED 9/10/81 AFFIRMED 9/10/81 AFFIRMED 9/10/81 AFFIRMED 9/10/81 AFFIRMED 9/10/81 AFFIRMED Appeal from and Citation fif reported) S.D.Fla. S.D.Ala. N.D.Ga. S.D.Fla. M.D.Fla. M.D.Ga. N.D.Ga. N.L.R.B. N.D.Ala. N.D.Ga. N.D.Ga. S.D.Fla. S.D.Fla. S.D.Fla. N.D.Fla. S.D.Fla. S.D.Fla. M.D.Fla. S.D.Ala.
*12501250 657 FEDERAL REPORTER, 2d SERIES DECISIONS WITHOUT PUBLISHED OPINIONS — Continued Docket Title Number * Joseph v. Huguley & Son Coal Co., Inc............80-7722 * Minton v. Secretary of Health & Human Services ......80-7984 *t Firsten v. Weiss .........80-9027 * Blevins v. State of Alabama...............80-9056 * Stephens v. Lowery .......80-9061 * Butler v. Harrington.......81-5042 U. S. v. Richie ............81-7049 * Fed.R.App.P. 34(a); 5th Cir.R. 18. t Local Rule 21 case. Date of Decision Disposition 9/10/81 AFFIRMED 9/10/81 REVERSED AND REMANDED 9/10/81 AFFIRMED 9/10/81 AFFIRMED 9/10/81 AFFIRMED 9/10/81 AFFIRMED 9/10/81 AFFIRMED Appeal from and Citation (if reported) N.D.Ala. S.D.Ga. N.D.Ga. N.D.Ala. N.D.Ga. M. D.Fla. N. D.Ala.
*1251DENIALS OF REHEARING EN BANC 1251 UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS Fifth Circuit UNIT B DENIALS OF REHEARING EN BANC (Rule 35 Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure; Local Fifth Circuit Rule 12) Group 1 — Denials where no member of the panel nor Judge in regular active service on the Court requested that the Court be polled on rehearing en banc. Group 2 — Denials after a poll requested by a member of the panel or a Circuit Judge in regular active service. Group 3 — Denials on the Court’s own motion after a poll requested by a member of the panel or a Circuit Judge in regular active service. Title Docket Number GROUP 1 Chatham Ventures, Inc. v. Federal Deposit Insurance Corp......................80-7599 Huffman v. Wainwright................80-5237 Meason v. Popular Bank and Trust Co., Ltd................................79-3106 U. S. v. Harrison .....................80-7416 U. S. v. White........................80-7949 Whitfield v. Termplan, Inc..............80-7249 GROUP 2 Fenner v. General Motors Corp..........79-2518 Date of Denial 9/11/81 9/ 9/81 9/ 9/81 9/11/81 9/11/81 9/11/81 9/ 9/81 Citation of Panel Decision S.D.Ga., 651 F.2d 355 M.D.Fla., 651 F.2d 347 S.D.Fla., 654 F.2d 722 N.D.Ga., 651 F.2d 353 N.D.Ga., 651 F.2d 777 N.D.Ga., 651 F.2d 383 M.D.Fla., 657 F.2d 647