Court Opinion

ID: 7135396
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-24 15:23:23.345807+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:14:35.650786
License: Public Domain

Opinion of the court by
JUDGE PAYNTER
Reversing..
The appellant is a corporation organized under- the laws-of this Commonwealth, and is engaged in the retail grocery business. Its residence and principal place of business is Covington, Kenton county, Ky. It also has retail grocery-stores in various places 'of the State, including one in Owen-ton, Owen county, Ky. Supposing it was its duty to do so, it listed all its property in Covington for taxation. The trustees of the common school district assessed the property in Owenton for taxation. The question here is whether the stock of goods in Owenton should have been assessed there or. in Covington. From the averments of the petition, this is not an effort upon the part of the appellant to evade the payment of taxes, but to prevent its property from being assessed in two places, thus being subjected to the burden of double taxation. The law requires that the articles of incorporation should designate the principal place of business of the corporation. It was held in Newport & Cincinnati Bridge Co. v. Woolley, 78 Ky., 523, that a corporation can not have two domiciles at the same time, and that it obtains a residence not by its'own act, but by legal authority. From theaverments of the petition, we conclude that its residence is in-the city of Covington. This is not a corporation which,is* required to make a report to the Auditor of Public Accounts for the purpose of being assessed. Sections 4077, 4078, Kentucky Statutes, 1899; Louisville Tobacco Warehouse Coi. v.. Commonwealth, 20 R., 1047, 48 S. W., 420. Section 4085, Kentucky Statutes, 1899, provides that: “The property of all corporations, except where herein differently provided, shall be assessed in the name of the corporation in the same manner-*565as that of a natural person, except that, when legally called on, the chief officer shall report a full statement of the property of such corporation for taxation, and for failure shall be subject to the penalties by this.article provided; and so long as said corporation pays the taxes on all its property of every kind, the individual stockholders shall not be required to list their shares in said corporation.” As this corporation is not required to report to the auditor its property for assessment and taxation, it is assessed “in the same manner as that of a natural person.” The property sought to be taxed is personal property, and this court in Wren v. Boske, 25 R., 1780, 72 S. W., 279, held that personal property of a taxpayer should be assessed in the county of his residence, although it was kept in another county pf the State. The court went into details, pointing out various sections of the statute upon which it based its conclusion that the situs of personal property for the purpose of taxation was in the county of the taxpayer’s residence; the court holding that there was a legislative declaration to that effect. As appellant corporation has a legal residence, and not being in the class of corporations which are required to report to the auditor, it must be assessed in the same manner as that of a natural person. It seems to us that there is no escape from this conclusion. The Legislature'has the unquestioned authority to fix the situs of property for the purpose of taxation.. 'This conclusion is not in conflict with case of Lou. v. Tatum, Embry & Co., 111 Ky., 747, 23 R., 1014, 64 S. W., 836. In that case the effort was to tax partnership property, and the court held that a partnership is a distinct entity, and its property is subject to taxation at the place where it conducts its business. In that case some o'f the members of the firm lived in and some outside of the municipality which sought to impose the. tax. The case of Wren v. Boske is made to turn *566upon the legislative intent, and this case is likewise made to turn.
The judgment is reversed for proceedings consistent with this opinion.