Court Opinion

ID: 4062759
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 20:36:56.978957+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:07.387549
License: Public Domain

g§`,??é’ -»OB

7 ' ‘ » \,r ¢;_LDLS" A 7 ` ' HECEIV ` '
Dé+p~ " Dec@"m`b@.r_\ ) ;_ COuRToFcRH\/)HE\E\:_NAPPEALS

.-\/\l}l|'\dm Ha ward \j_reelnam,§n ._

'T.,`D.C,B'.~C|?) r\)es§©£ . aim O:E§§`§\NAL A_PEEALS
'AUS‘Y\N,TC);SS ’\8’|'\\ `

-' ---~-~ 1 59182015
D€au~ f\A'r» l\_be\<_ACO_Sj_a). _ » g _~ ,

QM \.'l /OC\/\§~.'; redievec\, umw eeg-rci _ 43+‘,\; 4 qoa
\'\Sc{ \‘€'Q"i€.'\)€e\ 'mq/appli\€_i&+;_®!\l $OrDU\O_b_§E_BiZ&§_ @::}` »_
1 k l 15» Af\/\ wm IN 'E(‘,e,us- . _ w _
§grgl')“zg;":“§%`§“ IAO*‘* Q~d»€»r$\;»d,a¢dd%@ 55 wm
.Cér\)~\+»€. wur~+ maK€_&c/ecj€).jo;d w;+\n@U_\_NW COUH_
HPPQ`.~~¥_QA &\+@m@q`, Mr;ThO,/Y\as A,,;,\{\@,,+;¢);) D,NJA _C;@)[SL ‘
bag€¥ m`\-R+v rc-‘Wi@f?£€jaiz_o.'\i-_ \N v£%+‘\ gaqu M § v
` D`\A+"\e/ C.OU\"\'§ C-OM(£UC-{_a ,’]@&}~h\jcl UEDN D`M`A‘ 04 n 4
l+e%+‘i{\}¢\ `QO\’ . eV'lA€NC,E/? .I`? 50 CCU lCl LLOLL {M$©`AN\ M& 7 . d
“Pv\€,'ir Y\€%u\~¥§?’nnou_€\\n`.l udaf'*> A.ppo'm!:‘r€_d a,`>¢';j»\~or/\g§b,§q
`“/\e, C¢@UY’\`S'?D\""H'\‘\S QUYPDSE \’\€.w'\)@ NO'+ Y`QS~E_DN`S€(J _):O
\'1\~)\ \€;\+Qv NDbU anJ O'p N\ 'éam:\('q [\Aem$o@rs_/_\_ wm W_m%
W'M a‘€M |\/\0¢\) 311,3¢») I-w\\\ also 5@5)4 U|U 3 wqu _
.Waw\<$¥or qou,'\" ~F\M&~)p\€'a$@&,\g$w@rb 4 _

3 `\!\)'Q~@relq .

\ O¥ 5 DGACS b

<\\{5 1335 6 5\1\. , 33 ag\{_ 553 3 563 3'_\,'"€%<§ 5;/5,125.513' ,,1..,:{"'11”5
901 .quez|_<\,/ 5),55\5,'"55 .C>.C;.:$~ 1011 1373'1?.».15
L`\ 515 suqSHJanFF`5 3 1

1
_.~.' /

.zA~t-»ijc%)\")e*}§ 351 1\_`;._';5;`55* 1 y N@v.,.riq,.,l©i§'
5373>'5'(91&\"535' A`i§\/\E;)\"JUNF~V ~ ` 33

506 Prgs%'om__$%. 5555.51556'55)0 _`
\~"5~@-5)135}'_`1’0555",'-¥1;»5~*55‘€» 1 ."/_71'0 0‘;)_‘1 v ‘|\ 1 ~

1311 155-515~5:555\/5¢+\@5> 5:).-55.,15.5555;55555 5555 555
' 613 12ij "5385161 \/ Y."v.'e~@;i,-y~.é?b\`l 375 19.,'23`5~;.<3;"55)(35€,`5<93 U`)S‘Y'v}d Cou5+ 03
_ H<':?\‘”V"b‘.:, Qo`u_g'\'i 11 ;'FM<,
/’DQ,@X`;N\Y, N\@ §~5`.\ ida ! 5b ',' j '. .
1 ‘”‘€'=5"~(‘11'“5&€{ H@',JY 19'13`€'5 <3€\"1‘1<1 1\/50/,20.15 oppqu /(QMO;
1‘1"`@`3€“1:1111’1111'1'1'111'11‘111¢51€1151‘ +555:1 555 535555 5 555;5‘.515 51555;55
5 C,OU\.'"" CJ'$’~ \‘\'<§55~5'5‘-`.;, CO5,)A)‘3V)'T€Z'!@% 35\¢‘£!.$ Sp[JCiU\`é;d LQQM J\-@ 5
re tag-win Me* ` 1""1"'”‘# 1`9'»051‘1"-‘1`-"2 1*1\’5 1 C=“L" D"'\" D‘$\\§ ~.A~._.?r:'r:i:z¥. 5;-5<§~5
' I \1\>\.35\..3 \;.5305'\¢-.5)555‘\‘“35 5505)\ 353;".-£§.5\)\/5"\53&.5\`~3'\5_1_&3”§_ \/\5\5<3\47\5~555_€703..

_\ _ _5\5'\ +hec)rq`oi}"m% 953..55;.,_"£5€555/5 `55~55\50<;,53;,5,5_@)@_“,£5 ®Q%
G"ON\)"C"+€C§ 911 "3 'C'w;?‘(;t"€* l C!\"A‘-">{C"£ 'C»O;r\:\`m'}+°. ( P\va\€ 153.5"€>§>@€0‘3`05~ .
K'""Gw"""f‘°!'1161><1"15'\%@. 1955-55 5515-1@5551555 §55.<;5"~.55-55555555 '

' 336 ad ‘\ '1"+`11'1"' "’@'1'+" 1‘ €1»\1'.~\ 951 55 555-55 5555":¢5555 ' `_5,555 555`»'.451~5-»55'5;
`C Om!\>\a"»!":`°°“’% @“"31+€)"3'('B)m`~'/€'<.C§_GN‘553»'€5§5\5@~'+ 16533'€5»1>51}€1 F555é'
,\(Y>Rg,?~§)&*\'f;`§§"€`\'3>5€€3 5\55€-3\<1% t~.)Q-`FQC:O\\~`.€C ;CN,O¥ @.Vei~!q§u‘m)q
QNV\ C»Bl\-'\\JQFS':§.""%`GN LL"»+!§ O'¥`§`\c.,€r JO~S',\"Z? ‘S)SM c,$~, 525 .‘S`¥\€:E_I,SD _
'$§a';r@é;' 511 1‘-1@"1111' 11'~1€~.15>* '*@1‘3"¥5(¢. 15055>'5+91}‘(,£>`5'55€6105;).5+,35\5@' l
`a:\\O\-M'Ed 53 M `)\aY '+e%`""' N‘O"F’U\ 1(`:‘€1`1`"'"" 13¥;~`5<;55' §,\`52,15\>1@:555 §41<'15555‘0»£
1503’\0 &'ui “‘Hq.€ '~{5\~@_\\5055)¢~~5`,){) g ,\5 @_§S,T;k; 1555 j*~@$€ <`;_`JQWV-Mé.€?-}T€P@r+ 7 - °
_'UU 353`5;\'\. L_DSS §5`3'3&'>€ )SQ 30‘€‘,5~ \"€.§DG~'+\LM 31 _l">@;¥;§_,\g@ L]§$@;  .
,(155252155;545§3 1555 1559 5555>\5`:5'»'5_5555»_~,_<5'5;¢555\5 055,1.\.~‘_"5¢} \,`&PQM,C..ZJMG_MM .
hap`p.er\>ecl`,`w.f>~.if\_}z\>ql\¢f\a.\:f)e,\\.§€d)@q@._l',,(\j _(.A{~Rg;;g§.-"`§,q;, __];515“'- C___ QDN`P_M,MM+
51"‘1‘>“’°* 1"*11' 1115>51@\15 5 '\1'@115-~51~»5)555 555#55~;€» 55~5555»5555:;-
653 ( 552 52 ,:2,1~5,',133 555 55 QFC»MP! 5 555555+ 555;,`,5,5. 59 555 65 b ecin M
w here M\r-kr€€ mw-§ \~’~1&»"> ""_’ 1312 fig 3'¢»1<5 351<`@¢5" _1»5"5/5/`5:5'.5`.:?:`5+ wem% 3

‘OK@L{_&O WQ,+¢L,T._\L é\.m\c‘. 55315€5\1 : qo+ 3551,|:><_~:.<:1 vivva 1\1./\'\,'+15&4}
ezz.~z( 33¥‘555__555)1\€5@ 550-55 would _,33\<`@.15` <1'5»»1¢1 ?:)@l\'\@'w, bGCéuS€. m€.
355ij harv 655'53:».55<1 5’5/50-}-455:.'¢1 him 135‘§€.¢5'.') 1?~)’11\3.‘1` 12>€<11@11 11""@1"1\11/\19'
(F)‘TL.}% 5555)€: also q@e:.¢s '15')#5555.5~`5 5.5'515°.w 113 C@r1>‘1"\/5€>5{ 1*3@1"»
110 amend \Q.:>_z\;~i'a;) mi_¢vé)+iQ/u,' 1163 w§»\-e,~}¥\éf 11 111?»"""»1 P@CKH%'E"J
l\5`\3 “'1“1/\<.?. "53:5'5’\€: Ll_(§ N('\.‘S 5 :\3€.¥` 1415 61th 531@'5<'1`61 31 1 1031 < \"\1> a`$o ing 1
'5&255)~1"51,~\~ 3541;:5 '55'_1@'5\54<1%“"5¢_»;5¢3~55:)5\3 ' P\,‘\av§!;§b bu¥- £'5")€5-5`/\1/5.5 ‘1_5:) ~\~e$+»'fq
553‘55€.§»5»5=?:5~ ©5~ 555<5"5' »\155_@. C.@N\F355`5551¢35\A‘1‘ 5,5)@€-5 “H$e. §J€f.<;ow ‘.Sma¥:) e~<\
555 555 5'3..51. 51 5 €»5’)'5-: ¢-_`51»'5@;»5 . . -' ' 1 5 'l
re;r§~_e':$,"§"€.d_;H/\€~“\*W~a 355¢""¢\3'&,5\/5€.0$ '\.`)a.-'¥éa\:~§$@ U 5@‘¢1,> ‘111_1€ f'~’<"l""‘e
051- 05255555) m 5>¢~‘°3591@3 650`55\)@5 @»N<>* ~1 ~1`~&1\ '5)`11"1\ 1\\€"1€%1 .>31'$0
`5/55=¢ cia-165 355 d.-~"n§ we “1"5~\-€: 1169 13 €€511\/,,&5\16. 1'1“€*11¢‘/\@ 'H~€ 193
` 55);,5_<_;3-‘;-1`_.~`5<, \‘5.'§;1,_§'}_;\5¢'5 ~-5-\;5@ mcgqu )5~?.55.3 cl Q¥`€ C.€A/i§’@c§e sine -5\¢\`553`15-\/5_¢@
55\5\'&553’-*.‘€'\‘~35"1051_.'5)"©'1'0.<;015- 4 ~. ' . 1 ' 3
_ ,_‘I :£51»'5 <‘.'ail}¢\)q:'%©l).r'- 954"1?€15\)1©5\1 "“1_0"1,1\& NO`\~"C@" 1311 111 1331 91 01
55.13555‘; 11)5~5-55555@.5:555555>~ 0.5).1. `5\1\?'5 51555€- `5»\5~1.€¥ 5>1€1'&111@1#1~»
'W)B 1~1-£55.¥3‘5 CO-5JF3\J`1'“\ ©1‘.'~31’5*3"€~1 13\'1'1@1*‘\’ e"~i')t<"_" 0113¢;.€'.'1/"_‘¢'” T14€1,‘€.~.,€';'>;`§"[113
5_»ea.w@d 635 d~a\~;\chs'+`o 'DJ\H\'.. 1\'1\`1`»_<-*1'51\“€ W 11'"‘~'1"591’@ '1111"~0“’ 'P‘m`¥@®k
55555» 5¢5555 155-555 25 55555555.\ ,555555-5 555 651'55\’~5.>55 55555. ‘"5*55€».*’
C\na»\)£ij:€e: `55\) 5'-‘>1'561*0€50_1‘5_ \’\9..\/& @CC'» "~§"~’1€1310'\31`~. 117 1131 1$‘9`1`€"`“" 915
(Eab;@r~§r§uo ‘r,.}e'§ 53J"54+H».»u '11¢3@~{~",.&‘55 “1\"\'33 1'~?3&"€' ww 16 UNY`:""ZHEJ
155 555 555:»:5.1'». 515>¢1151@1‘"~3~`1`11 \5":?15<>1.~>1:54~§5,-55 3161-1115\.<;'"~'~:»,'1\"~€ 1111/1
C`__Qm@.' ~\jz> _13;[55¥ w'\ne¢\) ‘H\e `5‘13+1‘5'1~`\€,31,5 ""~’- @a`e‘~\\@`¥"Q-NS U~)€*@
53655\33:\!<5 uaw T@szr-i~i>`,"'110*“»1\-\..1_{0€‘€@ 13`€~'%“""~"3€‘“~1“1‘§ \A'E‘V.i591('>"-"€`/';°3“51‘1
05501.-»5>.»`5 555-554 5_~,5‘555-55)5-`51,' 5@;3551+5 5'-'_`\5): aged 'o~ ,¢-\C¥ 5>1`1>*;°1`@“1" 1151 111 `
\,_E,S\)\`,§¢-="_ \jq-j','\`\?_~`( MC` j\\'\e`\v C.'\_)‘("Féa¢~>'jr '}35"€)¥0€»@1%)@\~’€ 10"\_‘€1¢?‘$
.555555-5+55-555 c.5555>¢5`~ ~‘65 “1'1\€5»~’ `1 111 ¢1'5>1<1+1111"<1~ 5>'1’0`1@<1@‘~1»`
-a~d xve:.\a+\ec§- \>5@€»€60\*€‘»--031 1155 ic 119-11 01 /.@"p"r'»~ “H’"€'
LebDra`_hvri 955 C’,L) 5'r”€..5\)3‘ M=' 111‘31`@ §91"."-"1”‘3" 3~@15 'm?\w 1‘¢€!<~!` '..1"~9
.__613:1`~1"`&5":'5\>"1"\"€ Su 113 _ 17 Y~ow‘\"'_i\"e`x$ is 1:¢3?‘€~1 6 v_:.~Cr>"&`-Y'\;1"‘»‘?»~‘ C~C'/"’ " ~
m ‘ SS,`QM 53 "_,\J.Q;,,-,~l M"‘Nc` q 05,_§€'(/5,5_:¢;+ -`D` M.`f°’ ~' Lab <"_1¥|._9,‘,5'05"¢3`/3"5 655
NU.-} 5.\.3‘\,@ P_r‘@pe»y[-" q\_\`)eu `_a{,c;@'g,r:@,+e re Su\+S` 5"5\\) /\/\5§ §aS€.-

§ 051 §.~ mqu

.,T$né.\”»~' ~`%\na `m)a c';cwy.@j_€ \,QSW\ *S alpa ‘RRGM CW
b&'(;d u'gé abc 'H"€ }lV\/O'}V€Nie.w+ 04 €_»c> cai.\ed "!\r»¢v»\+i §9‘(€.
Qm\}+r`ghdr‘c’%”\:>""i¢;`>@“)"" dw~€mi+\')€L‘_+<:~ +~\{,'¢_ E,C_;_ MW* _Hn€ :[_)”JU. A. pv€%em_+€d i~'mq
C&$e was pro ne Si¢.;e.d m ‘Qfa$c¢'uia¢_o+e_¢_l @,p+&v ;qqq_,_%%€

l acule be €§;SCW'FP"R'“~‘C';@‘~"" `W. ;4€» -§"Ndi'wv;'s». l")ue. ~lU ~+-1-,.€'
`TN€?U:S:FO`\'"BNS;C Sc`\e.:\s CQ C“.o wm ;S:\i@f\/ ’C;u¥r`er~.r.Hc.; ‘¥f\J ~Hm€.
D"`<»“»‘él»€-°»SZ‘S_:>¢P @SBQM\D'\M a »-¢:)a.~e,\ .§da\»e`§z,smq ~#»,@ c.;~.@\\£.`_,¢q;~q

AT€‘ a §§ D'N-A‘~ F\J\`\"f~'.¥ure lr\.\-'Ler,;@'ré~‘rzl):¥\o/J.

j`b\€',- §§'C\"r€~?.:a\r%;e{ _Efv\ §)&c.“)' q;,~$`- +\.»1€`§;@ {,\).€,W pro,{oco 165 ,©N
C,s*};\,~'.lu&`.% ¢/’;&Sa&"\~"» %4`4§~§. Um<`wowé\`!}; ch>;}.)@w;r,-')+ has _
U».'\J<£@rs%!@¢l)d§b{% vé~s'¢$ea' 'c:<“)¢\_s_.:,§;.r,\,',+b:_r~‘,.bdo+in.%C'_\€NMHS;, l
SNA mm views U"""H"‘;"j ` vii Cr~}§\_;!s`é su:a_§ ."'3‘¢¢.1§44$’<;€.S~v;<.>~&e?h»j Fg_-r al

de+a:!' `€ §§ ey?\am 5+'@"3 O"'? `4'\/`\"\“`->' 13 ‘ON;":P\'€\»< 's"'SSu €, e +ol-&. 4 ,_

_ _ ` L)SJ(: f/{)€‘iid+éé.'-
help <'DL_)+ ?c>‘-j Sl/\@y~`,,\(q wing j .;,m_b,@ `E_&M)€ ») 9,€8`§€ §€+&_
tma KNGWJ `Hr"&+ HOW \”E.<.`.`:‘€l\f€d;~¥'i~`¢$ ‘€~H€zr (,)J/H\ L»§@W`?_

I:~r r\)"c>€~ 1:&~~r-~.1;~Y~l@ be_ am 214-toma )'O.u-%_

, L...J.¢-»

vL/W:£MMUG Jy¢{"%"@€.~igf‘.!§¢)mw»%&,

.' ;) ` " l

DRA\/EP

THEREFORF_ PRE¥\/\\SES CONS\DER
ADDE \_\_ANT p\"aq \”Q5peg-\'1Cu|ly re~ZUes+Wq -/»L,J)-
H\e, wur+ 039 l\ppea\ w`-.\\\ €)Lc M§+ -H/\`»% \e~I-&Qr` nw Ord€r

Por. mg ai¢+or\\) (Cm¢»+ N\\`T\¢\o a A M H~`N
'\'O'@u\\~\`-\\\ H\<:HCLU‘{~\€,%+KYEU)&S |N§W§f:l \mM a “¥O'cl:>

bq -Hr\e, \Y;lwd D\S+\~`\c~;l' Q©u\c+ O-Y- Ha,e~f¢`ls C@um€/, T€Xa$, a_¢\§e¥€>,¢\)daw\' l\'\)\l ham Ha ward \:\e,emard S\,
dod €C;\ are urode\ -H\e §>QMQH q +OVL$Jrejurq H\a+ +h@

550\’€ \%"N~ue amd Q,©\'\~e>,c.+, dui -\-lna¥ +L~\e[ ACQ5‘\B d.+ P 9 Box \130_52 Au§+\!\l, l
'Tex&<; 7€7|\ Exec;u+ed 010 H\e\ l+b daq @’[: D§Qemf)er/»
£>LO\S&+-qu A\\e.w E> po\u~<$|