Court Opinion

ID: 4045138
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:46:51.222271+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:29:45.407160
License: Public Domain

§

5 A_g@

~;'5’4;'1` 5

3)§-<{

256 35de

"*‘1<< `/J-é\éffb;‘f¥»n 60

901 5 §§55>$~1<¥.£/\,+5'"

9¢1;-1»~ 113 \ ¢<; w

$.'z“\ @C -\'b£‘j¢< -])

 

` &sp@ wsi ,1/0

,f|q :f)S-Ljff 58361 L|D,'»{) qZ/L/z

B “{L[) L/S)

`i'-," aid A-A»»~. 4 .7)» , v
‘1$)"»¢§~\ A'kr} u\.')7 " jul g 65 ¢-f -/5’5' LHV )uj' 418

b \/.S~ QM¢¢. ,\/os'» ' _
51¢»¢¢ ns ‘rms, m'oq~»aq“v<,z> ”Dioh»~¢¥ of
» OY‘OQ~IZW€§D- LOQ»\\&£. Q,owml't’

'7'6 j‘h't Ql;$&k ag /7\?5 qu¢.‘¢'o v v `

` ` § f‘/Dw O:Srv\éS w H'A'n'l Ahce¢e© mlw €&.3§ CF,'{'¢J ,{,¢)A¢"f
§§ llab`éas Cb£ous m fD&Q_¢=mLM <99. 90¢¢4, ..¢ KéC€;a¢¢r_.O ¢I¢q¢
/Vo~/Sci cg lUQ\"} o-§`(jnlwr$ Qa¢gu.s 5 08 09»/29’?&$ -@Yi 093/69th
jlowc Jo$ was 7b §':‘(§;m$\ 54 wg'\? C§MA¢:\'("'K f'ffha.fbrblmc|’

md /Ms view (l)a~m- wh was ’i'?kc |S'$"--
~DISJQ.¢LRG¢L“ l-,év\oRAU&_ LSM;; f/;&§_\\M¢ /)1'$ W£){ d(//AA¢;
Qo£"":5 l:;n§ No{ 623-n A¢}cp£.\e$$`¢o$ 6)) Si"#§/L '-"77:;®15 /d/¢' Qau& _
6a /O\_¢ C’,a’r\¢.n<:.f ~\3 O_¢ma.+e ‘ ., mem/J l
Ml¢_s¢o:s on ¢f§fd~qs 'TO QM[JIJF~ flf&z? UQ£?<=Z;“§ §§'54

5 4 _, 6"‘/3 h I¢"
%»;§`f% #4. §hw})`,;,¢ ?°30;3 935 31 AW+ 554 £s/»AM-
DJ@¢', 7b .'f/)!¥ 60»¢¢.~1 op elim»`rm( Appeo'$?j»~d'h g,(¢`a,_~( 36 510/3 £‘SWJ"" cp""+
[?écg'w¢-& wind was &£qa.e¢bej A~s 0 3~pp \emsm+n‘ wa$f d')\ 7771'~ f

‘ "x`pm\q-g anen. 1e.-Hm by Q;é`la%)z‘ 69 q|.., 3 510/3 K¢€¢>J"d “

&5¢9“17\* pplwzen'\' W¢¢('fz)i Céua.'l pcp Q£smmn»' 5»

gg~yv\ e.\"h\

 
 

        
     

    
  
     

ASC¢M)E w <'E\)¢Jo~\c. '}‘/05 /vé ¢°"’\ f ,;E‘ -1;$. '
. Omm’:n,` App€n ,: 5 h Uld|,d,o..,~ of \/§MG'V\MA'MA TX¥A 5 QJZ
§§ Ql\-\mm¢( puetc§~w.z 4 5a y ' \

, AA'¢; %l$ 5”71$ wL/+:_. /~/hs ,:/J/ g!‘.n '£;(w,qq¢/ 73 73£ /SYZZ '
fb¢°o"fL\C-»'\ O§u.a"‘ . v . , . ' 4

A.s.sa.¢v why A m § n a
, Azl?z z$£ -r ssa m ss
'_: Au f cg §fc,'l~' vl § é¢/ /~m
Md_` wiga A46¢:_.@9~¢»»\1("/ -'(“'/ F"’ 215 dung z mm wk,azs "“ : = C./'Al /¢/L:' , f

I~A»~CF€ 9 believes }/n.<.: SZ¢BM»~H¢J 9 f{$ /;{,(_;

  

   

     

:a
. *e*?i

.~;é. -

    

i Awd ’fhg _<"."é,x.k S}MH .A$§}`qu"')?t#t-.

§?;ém§n¢| Apps§-/s“ A}z¢&/
.As€& j:h U»o//.y//¢'rv\ 0-§' \/!‘;3’?""3"": 'F/‘)~*=‘\`F-Tz)m$' é §§ C‘£»}?'h.im)
lUro;J~m.r» /]/L/f<‘/§ //.c"“`/. 3 ~'3, »
App('.c»ha~.` fcc waif' a§+/»L`.ens‘ QaTs H,o‘) 544~),'»-» 3b
gaylch F)S:{!A O,G`/\\)'¢C_»ll'cr-,mv¢.‘$‘{ "b& gll¢ .wj-*)Z QIE¢L of 73£_ C@“g,‘,"
"J;). I,OL')<;\ "'4`7\1 Q=S'wo'u:.~")§~»~ b£"’"z CMH¢¢»%¢¢) .\,on$ ow'w\*ic>g=,',
l y v A ‘-',m.l,g.,.` ”To '\'b¢+'* Cou#.+"
“-16\4 i}»)m)& 'No":", H_§$)L¢]'s\¢c& `T-H’»§` g;p\»‘) gill [.vi;_..:,. `

 
 

k c z v l w- 'M‘ WW'" ""'""‘""""~"~:.»< ,~..,,_.__ ,. i.,-.» ~.»,,. .,. .
i : ,.¢.,,..,._. - d z
l w `l§w>`j‘v:/" / . \ !! ;: : gbs § 2 h ’ _
` .,\..;~.~.. ..,.... du ,
- 'w~\i- v y

rg>¢..§:»C¢,J§...Y ms viz ,/ wm o§,,,§s».i/iq adm , -.

l v d 4 m ¢»M!' ._" " '.»' ' ' ‘
Qj,¢irélrfci,}z" §§ ' ';§§.éuic z ' '

jw.l-).M-A».;A'z;lb Q/)M 062/ig 72»+ F 5""'°/ "'"°' ‘

'j¢.¥¥ "/éx"$'_c" '_C:}eu;`rz.~/ C/!,dk gm `5-/;',¢J W;/;'i§ 575 °77¥'§5 '*)’Z\t, ` ` _
,/ ';»Z>A», pf £;.b,a~ m/ av/'S’ we A¢.§lm, s+ "»"w<+€' mcfij
/.7}*':' Q_Qm/i."/ gmc (z£'»m\n`m“ -DW€H"S 67¢‘ 6§)< }l?><>`_$'{ Qf>\pl“hl "

` §‘¢F)*hm\ }4»'-¢51¢~'¢\'7;§>'.4`5 “7%")/[` ',Q, QDW OO_F-~/f(ém§§,`“j 723 _,p\-t

.)~§'3'1“ "U‘;'§//z,'<,:_+', Ol-“.&. _ _
¢;}reew-»/so' ’3¢15’€ 713-ril // '.`Z>.o~?; afg!&m/mj 3@7(:_'

":’I uj`»//_,A~,v\< :Q’u¢o.¢.zm'. A//'é"\ `£¢mc/er.'_ _Mh ~ *)'}IA‘}~_ j'gz, §/6»7(£/7/¢'"/,5' 1

//w m. nw md 1112/vigil 73 714 4<""»"‘“‘""",‘/ /"“/’O@“'
troova iv,,-/¢/./? of W,?j“/,»V,, , _. . --k :, . __