Court Opinion

ID: 4052989
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 02:44:11.050213+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:05:28.968576
License: Public Domain

101 |U.O '6803€])[40:\"| , Ll'Z,q%/LJLJ/Ll§/L/(p

» "V',L/

é<@m$s Q\\¢»r~ 0§»0~/2€?¢» 6 ” j_`N THZ '7’£)¢»¢§ (',@…v¥ 5 §§
ov'@’g»oq»)z ”Th!-; lie k t ~
1 ,Q-Yy\ v . C€u~) Q’“~°/'\ ja “Sfénsi'" R
/.,p\z O;wu_+ 6 QQTm\nl\ ] D@pz.'q|g O@é£¢,

&’QBRM.A\L |? SO/SL `F ¢5;¢»,,~/ 2027 - »z O w
o?`»c)‘i-lz.¢%%c:j&. 73 7)1¢<_ 553/hidalfo 635/ff (/)J:,/`
k/D"t 66:‘*"""0 /D‘*/} $j¢)"( //A &C"é;()-€J //77'& AW/;<'A )/c;- <;;,,Q //_@7
LU€"'L 6 F/=’Jbés>¢<_. 02de //@é¢pvm€ /',0’7_ SZCI¢Qm
5®` vw  f{aTQé'_ via AN§¢U£L» c>""\~ 3909`-/297&6 ~2€~0?-/;95?¢5
F)nd mac /L usz §§ ¢{Alams %¢.s //._07. @{;0€»/2.<;7@@ »
S§~©Q~/ZGY’O.C 01 
vf@$~<$q~/Z‘i`$(g/D¢ /Mz_ Q@w¢/` @¢;~12¢?¢6 ...@@“:~e<>¢~/zq?¢€ v 0€~09"~/29§4,@.
©Z»o‘?~ 12?<¢®' _ -~ @§~o<'; ~ /z. ~_/)?’»<)9’»/2'~'/?<,,®‘ )1//)3 //<)/ A@¢»\
F}S/)wé,q z-J 67 .£/'Wz,c (D/FS/£/@/ H!/é¢m€‘/ "é£_. %é. /SS“`¢`\,
’D;'§f¢,a£ Gmm’- ')'~’< w¢z/`@’4 301/1712 szns/Dég)nd mwr+ Z)=FC;€.WF\,J \§wsl`{'<,aa

)/@€ r€ L’*"*’""‘J’?J'

mfg/b 94 365 F» w,//./;,,m /MM) m/¢»r. i¢@wz@v ,M/C£ vz,y~/"
Mz dowd pf é,¢h'»n,)»,»,{_ ///rs ¢?ée'/;@£_J rml ;/.07 w@,~_{* 09 ,_/,gg€%
' C@LPK$.A"\QO fin gmé$;@m[?¢>a 012/m "»B ‘?)`7\€ deans/3 W)rs 75 j;,.,
l/l?>/Ollé’f\ §§ \/é'efw"\ gm 'T€W?S @e<,pg,¢~p@£:m)`rm/l deQFC£»¢A'L
,4¢4,»¢/1.//.67 3.{,` 3,<’. mtd 340 :z; 7)14+ wmf 2€»0¢#/2€7¢1)
'W//f<>')¢)»d‘k»<,) @ML`/ U)L,c&?"g

771 ?¢v;,__|§§izf_D/~S:-I/zfc,\ Q@uc of w/L)/€/L @ém¢qp
514 éx'zié '//da/rz ,_ §//Y 5102<),. ?9‘/ )'/» dd @/30 _
Q@¢:?//o§ O)Q'zm'.m,l pgn}s woulr_} na‘~+ £>(a£dfsé' ’/`v/S &v$¢i¢%nm//
0,€7§/`))4/ \_(u,Q/;§cj,`c/;'m M¢/i:.,¢ 36/<,,,7 @,¢5'5 gun /¢;S '; vi b¢< Adw'n

Ww"/ Né pé!r)//Z')v ge owe canf,qm,»n?» /;ég jwo,§<§;' h/)@/ L€w/zssnn~/z/ 741 J'W/? af €¢nu:`c{w'fj Ge)w€{?»

/D<M M&éfl \ é¢n;?:nar\n OGLL€,""_O<§`) QB`\m'\"A[Wp£;CEJ-wl.&
{»\p_~liclz IH.OS*c F»’/~ `7}€ `j»v¢d££‘;;/'" 05 \Saé/?cz.. J¢¢:S)[`écz_ msA/AM
'Fn QQQG£% 006 HQOW,-,,»,; %pg@l<- Mo (§<@M) %/:# ,/.O§

0~€»0<:~/2€"1¢'_¢> ",Me» ix <>.?@<:»/2@§¢’® 73 :7»'=; »;),.§J£,~~¢/ ,Q ' M;L h

'/‘ @@¢J'CJ/'Wl' Z)a¢¢/z,+. 391 ®W\(pl¢>'i/)cg w?‘f’¢\ /i)\£. 6an __ n T§y/K
§ OQ @€-'{WV"/)Q‘ pasaeéo"»¢&&¢ //07 gb\ga md gdc

.@§é@@.;/j » _
w~‘LZGM (MWD @@@-
6/'@‘%"11<£& g `

@%<2`@

®€¢wz,£
/Dz`QM§'l/a»~ €…é‘ ./ll\L ue:!. 936 pqgfz¥n»$l"

blamij //zm ¢M¢K md 4 -'z» 411 QM,€¢ ap
@L/m/»M '/ Ayp€e/§ £’é‘/QBOY C,,D,, /a/@f¢y/'/:-»\ Awé!l‘/)') (,/;%/5'75’7//

a'r)%r§ /H¢ J<.l”’/D»:;V afééaumfy .Jo/§/'

fbi \Qe/Q\Hl
;f§ @wz md CJ/z/L&/A % my K.;A?/ Md»¢¢ %M»/@a/

W”J “"‘?/ 7
5><<<=.»1~14¢/ 717§ Wz 3¢?"/£?»)7 dfé//.¢. ~ '

7’¢/5 §r¢m: of was v y,, ~r/¢é,, j /6@'2» @,'5,€¢.‘¢,{»
` f _\/$~ " 00€42:""@9 '

w`¢\\,.‘@,.r\ MM.Q QU@»A ' w<@\]en~ QQMLLL m
OIQ%QLLQ.L .

ome \§ 1¢252>

cmc .J»f L»r/v»>‘q@j

/'

@@ae.z 9 WNNTMMT §§ Couna~d.., 4

C."°’"“/'§ /‘/5‘0 TTWS cV/a<§z\ gm O€HSIOO€LHNM, `771&0'2<§/}\<§ ./WS ` &‘/"/€#’
531 'A"'@Pof'»»+ ~m°»mL 6 'Qe>wf\$ej `To Assa’sf"l/\\‘m z,\ {€ésczl\)»'wéf
6).9»»'»§ C,\Az§¢b 1531 130 Aér)vz.'€>{o,,/io@ -Q,qusa &u£_gum,f' 72) T7`»§1><»&5
GD¢QL §§ O?~\'m,»i\/vl p£ecécoJLz_ H/Ll¢‘cls I.OS'(‘ 1715 QD“@+ }{-.45 Q“/¢6¢1@»/\+ TZ) Téu Cb<$)z_. 619 G»e‘~nm~( Pe@c,e_o('wfz@ _

 

Ale»‘c/a /,os’/. )C)ccoad)m / ,7711 <»C//M'( AL)%M 73 /é@/
v/¢llgp/M _Z/?/%< CYA¢:Z ,éj/yg@/,§
»7).7_¢ //r)M//%m.

/1//14)1¢

A'DP€_§$S\

 

z+ 7§ 462/264 @¢z@é,@ze/ 7)\”/ @~~ dam .,,/,n»z duke 5,-,;///
/96 Szn+ 7a W\z dz.@;=d/m¢ /oz/ Wv'z C'/é,e£ @f/A)-'z OAw/)L“

 

\5»<\>@ l ?e_es¢ dfwd,'

R£&ues"r .»§>a C,z>»m“ MPOMTms- ;r;~r 'r/¢é /6'.;"?-: _

\/ ' ' - ~ . Courd` o-F _:L“uqz,

mata by £>.'m. z@»/§,§o

,,s¢.oc 7>€ /¢vh#?s;/

'70 'rHé //0»/6»<¢36/;€ dub@& of S,@'»J C@ua"."
QO'Y{\£S /\/0¢¢) , 1713 JZ¢QnoQ¢>-A+ w\‘|l)’f'n’\ 41»¢'»0/1$¢<.) QH__¢_,\_
WCT¢ §;&31\€© , md ;€é?uzs'/’§ 'Fw/' 7772 Q@a@f AW/d;/
` Qownse) 72> 45§')`5¢ éi'm ¢)\ Ké'zs¢/u,~’ pwdf;\//zd Cms_z, p¢,,/zsu,¢n?‘ ;§) 733¢'#5 C@c?é gtf\@,@;m»
BA[ pee>az:¢/wci /4»2'//’¢./3 /.0`6"/€ 5/'~‘)/{5 195 ~ €é@easnn+ wm I’» fly A<§uezs/my \S\wlvcml
@@Q>Qee=¢@r ’f)'hM‘- mq )€esw|}’ Fr\ @un.zkmwf bq @m\§ms~
mw+wa;;&§£»¢§qnlz ®£Q\AzAJ¢$
ey,€é$rmw£¢flov\ cf QOLW\S€' '\'5 _/-)+¢Ac,\r\;/ md Tn@/z€¢zh'{`¢po'm+zo\ Q.ewnsé,\q 6,<<1£/<, Qw\ "Déc'_(/+K/-n‘i¢~r\ -;Pm S»\pp¢.e‘i' _
OS’ K¢'YH' }'J`Z`> QEQ°Zé-¢§PA`I'¢\`()”¢:»\ 104 Qe)wvlsz{ 7va ’th Abovs_"-§/'j/E.
md /\/umbé¢zs QLQQ».» 63206;§.
w.\|.'mr\ '€$*O ml~°#'\»

 

 

 

 

 

 

Olb?>"\\fi& '
<€|h.s L¢m'lt wa\ke,LQ@M/¢q»
"\Leq"| Frr\ C?Y<') "

 

lJmkv“»l/;, Ta>ms 7734 ?>.

E'X/~/IUT /

’bchA'kATfm :EN 514 PPO€T of £»YGHT' §§
_ 73 féffésE/~/m/”Im;5 C'»o'Dé O& 093/nazth Fg.>@{pq@z¢ §
j t \T
422 jiwa @2<:9/+/<@¢2»_ 72 72 s»,pWL+ af A@¢,z.)¢» haw »65¢/‘ q,
72> £E ssQ:;?H"D\ b~1 Q@u/nsz/l Fr\ G’hz ’l`ams O;zé}£ cf C¢imr'n»/( ."`\
@Q,ae »uz,z,v ~ ~ ` ‘ " ` ' \`§
/'/ »ro/o

@ D»nz` m Fncmce»zm[{¢m pry/1711 7§)0\3 /'D'e mehner\\~ Q§`Gg",m.'rml
"`5 44 _ P

\\uslicz.FL/no£. /2501€')05<>9 Ayf£o)c')m,¢lz,‘{ No /nd¥\£'~f p€£ WGY|"”{’I 1
las é/§/z <@M @élga'\v;:$ md ;1~.*2,`¢»$€ . .

@If/€%é/z own /v/M /)4?0¢ my Fn¢€»czsv[s 7>1 en FSA//;t/§/"a”cés, éz>zc£',
54 gmc/z Aczz@¢mé dna/j ,&c//z.

@ 17 /J/wa 6)1£_ Gepom¢f¢n%

@F¢/m vwh/ 445/z cf AW,QO>//,`:M 2&2;0 d.e/.w 0/23');§2 527 4%2$'@;/§%/ %wcéwv‘z¢l’
;, 712 5)/“%,;1¢»»2 7‘ of viz 72»¢,,5 ®2¢,@¢};,¢@,1%/,,; é~/o;mh/J z/us¢;“cz welb<
L¢/¢\\-¢l 1705/134 Ué£j:/ A/ILGQ J£C'I*YILZ u/néf’¢/L 417"7 00[)¢5§;4/ %%2'
Y¢£jo‘~é SjMz/nw|s maisz #»c/ @MA£<% 75 737 51 " d"“§*’
}X(cu~»/zc/¢-r, %v;s F)Z 6/47 a ca Ol°/’§/

ZL)"/l/l’é’r"\ /Lél-d 9[~)///%
D/zpzv)€a.