Court Opinion

ID: 4031140
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-05 07:08:54.33934+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:46:53.793874
License: Public Domain

Order                                                    Michigan Supreme Court
                                                               Lansing, Michigan

  September 6, 2016                                             Robert P. Young, Jr.,
                                                                           Chief Justice

  153265-79                                                      Stephen J. Markman
                                                                      Brian K. Zahra
                                                              Bridget M. McCormack
                                                                    David F. Viviano
                                                                Richard H. Bernstein
  SAPA EXTRUSIONS, INC., formerly                                     Joan L. Larsen,
  known as ALCOA EXTRUSIONS, INC.,                                              Justices
             Plaintiff-Appellant,
  v                                       SC: 153265
                                          COA: 326414
                                          Court of Claims: 14-000068-MT
  DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
          Defendant-Appellee.

  ____________________________________/

  BALL CORPORATION,
           Plaintiff-Appellant,
  v                                       SC: 153266
                                          COA: 326415
                                          Court of Claims: 14-000069-MT
  DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
          Defendant-Appellee.

  ____________________________________/

  FAMILY DOLLAR STORES, INC.,
           Plaintiff-Appellant,
  v                                       SC: 153267
                                          COA: 326512
                                          Court of Claims: 13-000044-MT
  DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
          Defendant-Appellee.

  ____________________________________/

  FAMILY DOLLAR STORES, INC.,
           Plaintiff-Appellant,
  v                                       SC: 153268
                                          COA: 326513
                                          Court of Claims: 14-000088-MT
  DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
          Defendant-Appellee.

  ____________________________________/

  GOODYEAR TIRE AND
  RUBBER COMPANY,
                                                                    2

           Plaintiff-Appellant,
v                                       SC: 153269
                                        COA: 326585
                                        Court of Claims: 15-000013-MT
DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
        Defendant-Appellee.

____________________________________/

FAMILY DOLLAR STORES, INC.,
         Plaintiff-Appellant,
v                                       SC: 153270
                                        COA: 326586
                                        Court of Claims: 14-000029-MT
DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
        Defendant-Appellee.

____________________________________/

WEBLOYALTY HOLDINGS, INC.
& SUBSIDIARIES,
          Plaintiff-Appellant,
v                                       SC: 153271
                                        COA: 326732
                                        Court of Claims: 15-000057-MT
DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
        Defendant-Appellee.

____________________________________/

AFFINION GROUP HOLDINGS, INC.
& SUBSIDIARIES,
          Plaintiff-Appellant,
v                                       SC: 153272
                                        COA: 326733
                                        Court of Claims: 15-000056-MT
DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
        Defendant-Appellee.

____________________________________/

EMC CORPORATION,
         Plaintiff-Appellant,
v                                       SC: 153273
                                        COA: 326818
                                        Court of Claims: 14-000145-MT
                                                                    3

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
        Defendant-Appellee.

____________________________________/

EMC CORPORATION,
         Plaintiff-Appellant,
v                                       SC: 153274
                                        COA: 326819
                                        Court of Claims: 13-000119-MT
DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
        Defendant-Appellee.

____________________________________/

DELUXE FINANCIAL SERVICES, LLC,
          Plaintiff-Appellant,
v                                       SC: 153275
                                        COA: 327725
                                        Court of Claims: 14-000287-MT
DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
        Defendant-Appellee.

____________________________________/

SCHWAN’S HOME SERVICE, INC.,
         Plaintiff-Appellant,
v                                       SC: 153276
                                        COA: 327880
                                        Court of Claims: 15-000096-MT
DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
        Defendant-Appellee.

____________________________________/

MONSTER BEVERAGE CORPORATION,
         Plaintiff-Appellant,
v                                       SC:                    153277
                                                                                                              4

                                                                 COA: 327962
                                                                 Court of Claims: 12-000083-MT
DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
        Defendant-Appellee.

____________________________________/

MONSTER BEVERAGE CORPORATION,
         Plaintiff-Appellant,
v                                                                SC: 153278
                                                                 COA: 327963
                                                                 Court of Claims: 12-000122-MT
DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
        Defendant-Appellee.

____________________________________/

SCHWAN’S HOME SERVICE, INC.,
         Plaintiff-Appellant,
v                                                                SC: 153279
                                                                 COA: 328231
                                                                 Court of Claims: 15-000134-MT
DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,
        Defendant-Appellee.

____________________________________/

      On order of the Court, the application for leave to appeal the January 21, 2016
judgment of the Court of Appeals is considered, and it is DENIED, because we are not
persuaded that the questions presented should be reviewed by this Court.

       MARKMAN, J. I would grant leave to appeal for the reasons set forth in my
dissenting statement in Gillette Commercial Operations North America v Dep’t of
Treasury, 499 Mich. 960, 961-962 (2016).

      VIVIANO, J., joins the statement of MARKMAN, J.

                        I, Larry S. Royster, Clerk of the Michigan Supreme Court, certify that the
                  foregoing is a true and complete copy of the order entered at the direction of the Court.
                        September 6, 2016
       a0829
                                                                            Clerk