Court Opinion

ID: 4059582
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 19:36:09.302442+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:54.222530
License: Public Domain

_ " `~ QQ©~©/
!\)_0@& {¥LDSMV C,\Q)»\Q §§ '
` ?.r: .® c>~l~ Xh~“bc>% Cap¥¥u\ S'\z\RD¢/\

 

Aae¥?“ 111 31 M'

"…S ` W§@ m
Dcu¥c d 5 n @ou;\§{'r§§§m NAL aPPEALS
. ' 0 2015

RE:I?\PO\'|Q~*[DS` [)CT 2
Abe\Acosia,C¥erk

\r')e§\ imlobe& ¥5 APP\.`L(M\_<, Cw\ wiring ami Uojedn`on_> b> be \:. LpA
M¢A da}c&Ol/\A So)\' $o\!` §\A,bv\/~ b’>sD/\ w ~\'lA\\/{,(m CDJw/+ w°\~\be habeas
\le,\ne...> 9 graham Cu»§e hamm Cb.»»*€ove P\,em Se)\' bow CDJn/+ owl m

ha\)ea§ §\,e \»~“eour \)’>\MA Lae\/“o¢\ PLec/)& F`e}ru.w\ c&owv-e/\>B §§ 4.~‘¢.)1 Cowv(’

hO~$ V\D`\' §€,\/v\' bCJ/>U$¥\\€_S `\‘O `W\§ C,O\)\/l:h
'/ho~»\§‘~gu~\

L;§M¢“_%"_

C`c§~ua C;>fwr{§';7 {'7 §/153
94»5\ Fw\ 91>5»\ _
T@/\Nss»za C@§.MT+") 55 84

CAU\$E\\\O°, iaFOl“lD~“ IOS\

E'L PKK'\`F_ z INT\~\E DI .§TKICF eo em:r'
-5;. li)&n/,'\ C\“aBCc,:AL__B_IsTR:\:c_T‘ e.(-`~

Jbsmwcgaem _Q)@\N:F.' umw mme.¢\¢[a¥%ons. CTr. c_T. Recm\.d.

APP'\}¢QM raised .__G~.room\g 0'§¥ ineqed& ve ass is +am,€ §§ counsel 0/\
h;f>‘l'r§o.\ CD¢)M&\

md +\vee mci er\sel 9a \aA ¥o Plese,\+ m&ea\‘\a.\ m¥¥t¢§a,+\`cv\ ev\‘¢lem_o,
Aus`°m$ \L(:\e E`.ev\er/\L`U\ZS P\°héo_ a H"T\`¢:J . (__Tr. +- RU.O\M. PCLEG__%:§EW)€

MP\`\LQN\ &Uec%s+-o +./~`\a\ CDQMe\s f`es?onbe and \\?\/\e ~\'r¥a\ 69qu Ae\`mc.;\
M\SCEJ\>.)N§ bascckod\ (‘_©ov\§e,\s &~\:~§`dau¢~l QSSQF ¥\O¢l\st '

‘| `\1`\0,\ CQO¢\$Q,\; fb§PDv%e‘}o`\'\m_$ G:sPDu/\¢L does nb'\' C.DMPDH \70 MP\\¢LC»)/\‘\"S
habeas con&ev\lrtons waged s$ wonse;\s $a'.~\@fe MIX’/tzs@/\jr mcder`\@\ mibaajc‘.m
@,v:¢\ence du.r`.nz; ~H/\e Qm\¥eA/Ww Pbc.se.§ee. CAPP\‘\;¢.Mo/\ P.\O-S mmmmdm\
'?.’\'5 ‘l'z?\ . _ 1 m

Cne QY~H\e S+c&e.s mt‘¥v\eése.s \{e.¢l- CLZ>L§@'\&'A\'+&M¢‘a/\o\ abow¥d}d he /
hear P\PP\¥L<>M express umwa bar aw?on:'. e\sa owes Um./\ him Sc>,\¥ c\dv\§/)e;
&Poh`csz_ §M\UL \\eA c\,bDu:\'.Th\s \\Q_ £‘.V\w\é,'e,s' 441
mh®\#e QM}ABAAL`¢O.A"'€_ Fiu¥ol`e'~l/im;¥ \\*'\Ae `SM BLLW dol"u\rs '\’Nc\.\»‘k~\eea {Jr
%n~pcre$' '~H/\:J G.\\ \H/~M> §a,u> aj ¥r`\o~\ \,\xu$ N)+ ‘\’W\,\Q. which Cé>d/\Se\ Sh£mld sp

CQI`RLC,]¢€L(/ .§vQ/\ §\’r>a adams Sugses¥§ “H/\a,j( "SD/\»Q. cmrs' w¥ \\ ha,vo_
ha¢§ a pervas\ve e$€ed~on %\Q.w&\mv\@.§, ~\-b bo_ Amu)/\ $v~ovv\ ~U;o_
QN¥A¢»_ALQ_\ a\+e€`\m; \H\o. ev\&t re e,v\AQ./\\»\ar\¥.?€¢.¥are..(as. .¢\ ~\/\A‘c 5 ease§$ee
agc Sh:@\\\m( %w.sic°b%\ @¢‘¢5%3 inv sqa@§a\.a¢>w#bi
CQ¢)M'LA 0.\-\@@§¢\/:: Wis Qabv$ \ov\ '\1) s+cw\A ms ab?ee+\`o/\abl‘+) uv\~
feaso~nab\e‘€)ewso, M\e ¥./~‘\a\ eoov\se\ as we\\- 65 Jr\,\e_ \/ma,\ LDQH ¢i¢cl
na\~ac!&d`eé_l, H\e QJbPen.\‘x) exhws\-c¢@ ngow\¢\ ~@or J`e\\a~\: ~Hs $-c~'\er,\ jr‘o b€\v\s
QAEQ&¢(,@PC¢S\ h
_ C>.rm\¢x Qboe~`\‘».\¢i a,:».»s@l ¢a:\&\ 40 9 see+L> leaaw\g M»o_ wih\ess
4 ga w¥¥`.¢c~l ?.‘)Sue..s' b»‘€\l/L\o_ €>~P@e+e.-CT.F‘. C+. Recow~ . P. "\~_~ HB).
!&DP`\.LQML amiss w¥%\~¥'b\e cist \C\n¢lm Es(\¥hc.,+ wm counsel agrees
‘\'o ism¥m§ AQ,£ELIOJ\¥ {)Qf&;ofw\ov\(.© buc¥ Dbf)`e¢,¥b -\-D~H/C, Ce\)l“\'s fef'zz>lu~l-'\‘M\

/beh\` aj CD\)r'\c he\¢\ \H/\ca\' becaub€_ AOP\`\Lm/»¥`s Cv.roan¢\ cams hasec§ c>r\
o\\€a:\m>e los ebje¢+-\~I\evv\as+‘ Cb+ab\\sL`M/\¢§r¢m ¥w\d?uo\§r;wou\éew
leg ¥~¥ rev tier objeahm ~EJ~- ?or¥c.ul/§;.\é. \b o Sw‘!>ci °-Hs'\:$%(. :}`0~>*+3. we
also draws hcqu MP\‘\¢.QA¥ @bje¢.+§ \H/\c:¥ \\M, ~H~\`c.,l wol+ be\¥eva§

M §§ PP\?¢¢»W¥ ci.\¢\ no-¥ es+ab\}sk `H/\¥s QN\¢Z P((L.Suo+'wrihv\z‘ Ms
“h; Siz§e_ "4/(/\¢.} \`$co._)/\so.\ elde e¥ eb?ee~¥ez£ ~\&~e+v\`c.,\ LQQH- wmalc\ ear fn
AW\‘-?tn§q\ {5 \'\`01' emba€h APD ukoM`a\/\\' Cm eb+a$o\¥shv\n@w+ B¥ `M,\§s Sh~/\ACWL
50 5\'€\`¢\<@\¢° %U\p-D:» PJ'E,POS€_./> `Mncu\' ¥;\ \0`\) `H/\Q. PTUQDAC)R)\BM,O_ ®":`H/~Q_
mama wm Mw+.¢, a Prbw=\we was ms wmc @m@ae¢v dme
Wbcsm§h`ns M».\A §§ bQQv\ &¥L£Qr@,x’r . é\QQ.-r¥e. `u.x t \\tovm£>(g§ SLJ ?>¢;\ fos`lc
6958 CB~DD\D) ~\»Y/`\\"s is hOxD ‘\/bc’, ‘Qb¥ab\§shec'\ SWU§A §§ pfo&uwc).

mvan ma w _/, @_@OM&( MM> w m \MWA wékluLB“u\\v
`clef¢`c_{c./\+ Per$orw\w\ee ay~A‘\U/\e mer w§‘\wv\s \`+. LT¢. L+. Qeenm?.'~\\
T\\e_ hQ.AA/\v\/\QML £orGMG,E./\s~ Cu/\\_-B L\a`m/\'D~"/ \`u\e£(cc\-¥ve.ass?s MACQ"_ is
mbev&\@\ cams»;\`s .coe\&ae+ 50 uv\¢\w\a"m¢£ ~W\e`- P-roPer wm
$ov\¢¥??@\\ng @£»+Lo. ar§\/Q,\sm_:@\» Prc>‘ee§s M viz ~'Mcy\ c_cu)»v\;)¥ be
fel¥el .U/Pu\.o~§ ham‘v\a' QI`BM 'c'>.JU.s-¥ feb¢\'¥.~§jf.r?dx\mc§ ‘~\l§bu.§. l;>B(/_»
/`|h@)\&. TSV'\O %Jfrcére@?c.€e!§m"hn 0)~\0\,0 \\/ho. S\'c~ie_ ‘\'D'v\'es¥?¥‘¥ Cmc§ \aaA `V¥\e

C;o~»?\€».`\m¢\)r ev\ u~u~c_‘\cb\ ahA'CM¥%aAe ’\550@5 o¥`\\w_ wm $Qw\ . MP-\icow+‘

b'#? 0\ \>J`@Pm§uom 129sz Q.\RAW\<.Q_\SQPPDFM b~? \\/L¢L rem cwa \'rr€d manse\s
cl§§erhw\$ es+c~xo\ add M\'~lr'\/\e Wo\/xdo.\‘ W e+\`§lr-_s emmsb\% uv\duw\§'/\o_
~PW; $Q.\\m\u>, a~\»W\z,\l)z!z§tc¥ ix '\>or¥c, w\/\°.\€ \loD 5\_.)5¢\0¢\/53> §CLCP¢PP\ {Y\QW\
;d` SQPPDF¥) ‘

 

C`ereM/£We' $a`\\um.¥o ebszd+b work denial a¥ac\w\¥ ~\/Jr<.w\(_e, S$&v¢`c)evm

~\’b ?Fem. b§c\snes$ Gv\c\ W\O~¥Kve (_'w. L¥.P~Q,ca:v\. P§- H*G-
M>P\¥cou\~¥ 9\0?'¢¢¥5 ha ‘%\Q, Caur#s f`<’_ww~v\/\'M¥.D/\£U` adm

_ faa sons ‘Fins’n C)>\).ns@\ d &A n@+ m&o°es_<. v\\s mims -@m~'~\'\~¥s c,'\a'£ M mw
§iro&h\§ MT\L §§ c.\. vv\o¢\"lrer 9$ faced mel‘ Pu§\\QA ‘H/\Q. (`e$?D/\S'; br \\\"\’

01\ ‘HN)_ h d Co\)H §<>.Lz>'nd ) ljrs 41»¢@ ~Um}&&\eam`\§ was hud on ~VH;_
b\c;scu/\A wmth e,\x¥¢\e./\u, ama 4b1 zurich m\QA ~H\QM Y\D+adm.ss.* b\Q
SQQ,CP`&:H 1 ?@se,uo\ \v\ \»\~353 . umwa Cwn§@\ A§c§ nb¥e\s§`e¢+ 4-0

` `¥_6 denial O~v\A' Pfe§ef\le. ?,WDJ` %a" O~Wo.\\a)ce_ (le,\l¥éw . Av\ ebj'cc.+\`m >{br

P._d@w wma+ ba€>{>uj¥:¢_ O~ccom‘*.ms irc TM.P. ?>?>.\ .’Iu§}
wadan Sv\ ~\/\,Jz. '\I`Q,¢':Dr¢\ §§ no¥ cm obje¢}r`\ or\.Qena\l.§+¢)\Q, a§§:`>wz>d. °|57},- ‘H>'~l
CT>L cr {>.a;~. cwa v\'~‘o-¥Nc Q,\u`rlw¥;€
§'@\Q\lan% owl \r\'b\A§ ~H\Q ~\'M¢l LQ '\,JL-¥ \v\ ‘c'dwse 93¥€)`¢5(_{@¥§0¢\ Q\>r m¥ atmoth
‘.¥ -SUL Smeu §41.§<»_ Q\q_ew>¢'\sw,§#\q~$\ mm M>P l¢m\d; %r\c 5+@¥».
\\q§£.>?,>¢i SS<>.§ tol:b%CT+ APP \400.1‘-{""-’}009- Qe,+ Fe,+‘d)¢

c§<~@w~<§ sw~ far wm 49 W@w;\¢ §>,\ +wo' m ¥m!l‘ issues .CW.<_+.Q€QQM .€@j
' M?\i'cm\+ C@`r\u)rs w"`\“\,\\\¢o, Q¢¢~Luc`k wer ~H/\d\\/¥ALM<> cea/v¥$ -' ' '
feec\né E>M @éscw\¥ ma two CQEU\AM 955$0.\1¢,)&€@\ § wm C\z>§a»k\'
9\>3@¢,+5 =\?> ~H/Q ~\'.mc.l Cmr¥$ §‘\m`\`mrz \W\c¢\' AP?\}M_'>\NEMW H/\a)\'a
com ¥".A\MD S¥imkes'~? wWAA»hm/L c,S/\c.,/\Eed\ ow¥c;m»¢ was YY\QMH.->Qs(e_ss.

M>P\rww+ mach wax wdne»@\‘dmeab` \,\x_¢, Jwv\~\§>\a`\r\oyv]r$ 4€5¥¥\~\0/\*? b'~P her fnLe\/\S»“bl-€/\ YSMmQ/w\j
~\W;¥ hU` 'M\Q/:i‘c.c~\ dow €)lrcw`\a\) \.._)`\/\Qv\ 5\/\@ was §v\ i/\€/` Qwe$l/wv~cv» `?Qaz\ ‘{@,~l'

‘w\ wm SL\Q sw}e& div 5\\0»~\4¢\ wm am W¢.§ ~3¢'¢4>_./2:#1.?.5%.\" H~z>, 40
@v\\"e C_\m,\\e»\§§n; 5 QC~~U/\Q, M§w@va,¥cd c§\Aufc)‘¢>; ¢‘v\§jrcacl @$W . pr“\'

\\“\/\©\x£$\i\ C,DUY\$Ql %c”£€¢l'¥\l£.\“\) `\v\/~PQAL\AP_¢% M/\L LB/v\ip\c»`\v\cw\/§"@r\ §9‘{;

\\jv\e. QL;W¢M C'\/\m&e_s `v\e. `rv\\'-.»\§MK'LQA M,o, wi*Ae/\ce_ mich also
av\(.ovv\ Pa$§e¢§~\»€\a, 194wa \»wo CQL)A)\*S a~\:&§r; r¢\x¢\,§ea\ a§éw,»»l+ C§em¢,\\
CLLL¢>rc&-Im; 40 hQr S¥akme/\¥S \H/Ydr mo SLM P\~»€§\‘¢¢J abuse S+M)I+:J unl€ l
u)\/\ed\ "JW webb `i§£>»l`llo . l)~)r?‘\' €z~`\b”.sr 15 Lov\jro`mé `H& SMMQAA ,

“l\\QN)_ Cm\b-Q. v\o 6\1`@>¥@5¥; r.\no§(_Q. +oa)ocmdon m~c\,JPmLoN Q,\l\`cl€nce_ QI\W
bwe<»_£@w»sd cm\&~`-¥ (’ro?v»\~? ‘.~\P@m/\ er%\e,gs.r'_RRtZ>-§'R 104 I/\a~O-§§;
?.195 in \~¢5; ms 2 m. m \=). P. m \v\ l~t@ ~: P‘ 53\ \v\ $"i).m also SMM
fu\e§ wl 13‘ SeL-L‘zc)>\ GR'l~lo\(i£’<) C\\Z»\(Yb} [\NO BQwV¥-(+ \"V\ w.'~\'l,\\@\ci\`v\r,’ -Q.y~L\,\\P(/J'L')N
ev`.¢§e,\u; cum G\)W tJv~\`p\A is \'o c'\<>_Jrem\\\/\e, os\“¥<>w\e.*€g ¢\\`QA\' C;>u,:"\%*( cf Inn D¢e/\~'B.-

_ \4@1Ain5 Cpuv\ép.\ defeated ~!v\ \iab\¥ §§ sor¢\ wker \`5 m¥ SPQLW\@+\'DA because
»W decided PQr$DN\/\GML f s Cm§”\mw'\ tv\ \\4); \Fw>/~¢D..`\| csaw_z.% ?>z>§¢.)a¢\ ‘Hz’s’)q§`l

C`\+- U`, APP¢\€€})¢

G!ouv\& %<»_W\~ £;¥LQ;L` irc PmPeM~/? chW\: + m ¥\‘@J §v\,\z°ew,\~w¥ e.\x.‘de./\<.Q .CTr.u.
`Qc;<,om~ P.'D‘

APP\:¢¢.W+ @\Dsa.+§. uni comm mm\»? MMA@A&@.~L@\€J m wage m
mma/3 .Q\C no¥\na¢\ ¢1\\ \M Y\/\r_/> MQ,M c»».+'LQMN_/> 49 :MPQQL),\ w
COVWP\CC\MW*Y.C (LR`.LL p. l(l$\ \n\q$~‘\‘i§)¢ E,\lG/\ C`Dd¥\§e,\‘$ cr§~£?écm?¥§\/®wj ln€.
is 5+:\\' nw+ Sure, §§ %Q,Pfo?es; weMADA 91 M\»M»m/»¥\`@¥`»o/\ Pfo\n`du§ b# ML
'f\`e+v (l.z\l ‘ §eo_ §Te.c+.o »'5»\.5

1¥5 bumbe, eg~~\&~!$ M~\»Lo_`\'\/`?¢J CD\)er \\Q,\P ~LLQ, &L;QV\SQ. b~? a&\bc..)`.n§
\\‘w\d@ uh\m im €>M mm 441bon ma amams¢:b\e_ 40 wa$,»@s»\
mew\@~# Cw+§r¢\@. w Pr¢s@n& @L@ur%`).€@c_aat»l P. '\q.¢;-\qa ; Qa§~h m a\-a$

9.;)55 \`2§; 99519 \\n \~\53.€@¢“5@,1‘5£&:1¢&£@:\@_¢& +.0 mw mw am

Ci`Dw\¢§ ~\'ul.() NDPQ.\\Q&Q CD.):\SQ.\ w\e~c~£cc_¢`\\lc>_@erm>¥d`cu§`mcs lei’$al SL.LH¢¢\@\N_Q.
CTi\ l.+. iZQ.co\/»~ P“\ H'i\

him m.~+ wax mg¢dw¢i mm ‘¢muw@e¢i cam/ims §
0»~&4 u,\m¢,\r\ aim m ~W\ SM assowi+ .;~,L@ cbi ici ’ha§@, coming dm\+
Ux\%\ ©v\\‘-e P@/\z-:\»ih}c'\©i\o '
“in@ Q,\i AQ.AL¢>_ culAumAi asi &r\c»\ SMQLQ¢A \\im>ir \HQ diem aci-5 ~
\\C»W€AQL§L m\\?/\\W\L CDMP\D¢\¢W~\' was e.i~\/i,\i>} |L\ cr l'*l.C"i‘.[LRKP\Li‘i).
"'\`c> be_ am Ses~u¢l G.ééc\mi o(~@ C\M\A \\»LQ Cin hug in bQ,éDMJm>

OL (`,\/\i\.CS/UMSU\. l_l f\D+ l`-lG.r\c\Uv\ébl/\ &CCDI`¢Q:‘Y\B‘L: 51'@.>1\17`€, P€/\Gl CDC\.Q,
%Q~»D\\ ‘_B~éC/)(Ab '

"\NL Siwiz Ca`(iez§ 413 i>/\NQ_ b<»,‘)m¢i LL fw§mc»b\z &ow+cy§i@ LJM\ 41€
aim§ez§ Qme}rrwi\w idchPQ.Ae¢i “~\~Dr TH~o bias as+iq cim.rse_ wc.S. an Se) 49 (Q\SQ amw.lrou§ c,\cfwv\ ov\ ciww.ci CcP?ec\/\i 592_ CN>P\F ¢ /V\erv»o.
\)o»giz, ’Ivib $0/` aw§urv»e~+)‘ ~
`\1~\5 va»d/u@\e§ M>P\'\` c.c~}_‘> 0\03¢(:/~.'0¢)§£
' 12 <:.>Ped~(§¢i LY §ubvw`. 4/4~‘€)

CF_RT I¢J:LME ®PSEQ_\D:¢E .
`]: 60 b\/\L)¢\ C=>fo,w\ do CQJ`)r WM/W`\' G_~\.r\)\sl_ CDP"( \nc.s beam Se,»-Ho
Nl>e,\ 6¥(,¢953@» CLQJ\K ('_.DQJ?}D‘$ C`chv\/~`\v\cp\ APP&§»\$ P D §Q)o+\?~}©§
CL¢.P ¥0\ §¥w`%le\ {\~¢Jb¥w\ T\J~/]"B'H\ \L\“e ?DS‘}¢>~\ Mc~s\ Dv\`\/Ll&_ga}{ 09

__§Q___?¢o\$

U¢_‘>m&>¢em#.. 179/763 '
9{>(>\ Fm~’&o§v\
T<:mmsm CD|DHT\Q§%¢¢