Court Opinion

ID: 4527015
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2020-04-20 16:00:42.49837+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:26:28.014482
License: Public Domain

Case: 19-1950   Document: 86     Page: 1   Filed: 04/20/2020

        NOTE: This disposition is nonprecedential.

   United States Court of Appeals
       for the Federal Circuit
                 ______________________

      CANON INC., CANON U.S.A., INC., CANON
                 VIRGINIA, INC.,
                    Appellants

                            v.

      INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION,
                  Appellee

  ASTER GRAPHICS, INC., JIANGXI YIBO E-TECH
      COMPANY LIMITED, ASTER GRAPHICS
    COMPANY, LTD., NINESTAR CORPORATION,
   NINESTAR IMAGE TECH LIMITED, NINESTAR
      TECHNOLOGY COMPANY, LTD., STATIC
 CONTROL COMPONENTS, INC., PRINT-RITE N.A.,
   INC., UNION TECHNOLOGY INTERNATIONAL
 (M.C.O.) CO. LTD., PRINT-RITE UNICORN IMAGE
               PRODUCTS CO. LTD.,
                     Intervenors
               ______________________

                       2019-1950
                 ______________________

    Appeal from the United States International Trade
 Commission in Investigation No. 337-TA-1106.
                 ______________________

                      JUDGMENT
                 ______________________
Case: 19-1950   Document: 86    Page: 2    Filed: 04/20/2020

    MICHAEL P. SANDONATO, Venable LLP, New York, NY,
 argued for appellants.    Also represented by SETH
 BOESHORE, DENNIS MCMAHON, ANDREW KUTAS; EDMUND
 JOHN HAUGHEY, III, Washington, DC.

     CLINT A. GERDINE, Office of the General Counsel,
 United States International Trade Commission, Washing-
 ton, DC, argued for appellee. Also represented by DOMINIC
 L. BIANCHI, WAYNE W. HERRINGTON, SIDNEY A.
 ROSENZWEIG.

     NICOLE A. SAHARSKY, Mayer Brown LLP, Washington,
 DC, argued for all intervenors. Intervenors Ninestar Cor-
 poration, Ninestar Image Tech Limited, Ninestar Technol-
 ogy Company, Ltd., Static Control Components, Inc. also
 represented by GARY HNATH, BRYAN NESE, MINH NGUYEN-
 DANG; LEI MEI, EDWARD NAIDICH, Mei & Mark LLP, Wash-
 ington, DC.

     BARBARA A. MURPHY, Foster, Murphy, Altman &
 Nickel, PC, Washington, DC, for intervenors Aster
 Graphics, Inc., Jiangxi Yibo E-Tech Company Limited, As-
 ter Graphics Company, Ltd. Also represented by SUSAN
 KOEGEL.

     STEVEN EUGENE ADKINS, McGuireWoods LLP, Wash-
 ington, DC, for intervenors Print-Rite N.A., Inc., Union
 Technology International (M.C.O.) Co. Ltd., Print-Rite
 Unicorn Image Products Co. Ltd. Also represented by
 BENJAMIN C. HSING, New York, NY.
                 ______________________

 THIS CAUSE having been heard and considered, it is

 ORDERED and ADJUDGED:
Case: 19-1950     Document: 86   Page: 3    Filed: 04/20/2020

       PER CURIAM (NEWMAN, O’MALLEY, and TARANTO, Cir-
 cuit Judges).
                AFFIRMED. See Fed. Cir. R. 36.

                      ENTERED BY ORDER OF THE COURT

         April 20, 2020          /s/ Peter R. Marksteiner
             Date                Peter R. Marksteiner
                                 Clerk of Court