Court Opinion

ID: 4070683
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 01:24:44.547223+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:34:24.734119
License: Public Domain

^3W5
                      Court 6f dnmiAja,! /I pf)^ah
                                                                     ORIGINAL

                                 Pt.h,-k to *j

                               /veu;/j "JohAjS6/u
       FILED IN
COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS         FtM ibAMPJ

                                       vS -
     Abel Acosta, Clerk
                              oicj-e. Or 1-^xaSj             RECEIV£D4N
                                                        COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
                                 F~&sf>o
                                      2oaJcL>aJT               SEP 30 2015

                                                                        ,u

                                Out of ru
                            Court Of dpfecxls

                                                    (by ', Pro .5e

                                                    ?id F/iv x^X\
                                                    j-i\J/u-t6\fl/Uj T^tCc£
                       'Ublc Of CoAjtt^ts                  A</€   ff-

                        Coua/6-cI Far hffi/J6t

                     Procj-z/c^ Ai LctfnJiiro^J

                    Ho-rns Cou/uty- . T~c%&3
                     7&a/ 00^-88 (* ?£
                    /AO/ Ffo<jF//Jsy JZthtFlr,
                    Hcustom j Tvy-aj ^002^

                        PnU/u5Z,l Fof Stc^U.

                   ft SSista^j-f &l<5 trlC / /HFsr^jJUH'
                   rXbj Frwkli^j J^/Ve (pOO
                   l4oo5tbAjj T^XclS ft002^

                  Fouftx r*A)r\ C»ort OF flpf>tc\te A*W
/Perth «<_ 141 II Tec mi s c?n)
              .    ft cfolly
                    Qusbw
                                 C(X&-€ KCuaJ

PV)o.rt)^t± i/, Sfcxkj A(p8- S,0J,3ei W LTcufrim, 4p[>< X066)              3
Millar V; Sic^kj 3(* <S, CO, 3J So3 CTr±i Pr>m, fi-pp, ZOO 0             / ^
 2*val^ v>SUtt} *iOls,uJ,&di 191 CToiJfp, -f/ous^j
 Dt-Ho. httJ^b/Zj pel A£fy,J                                               ^
                             !

                                                                               1
 r ovrttt K>fh f) /yieAJcl /newt

flrticl*.      3D 1bZL                                                     I

du\t        S-03                                                     tj 3j #

                         T?..Yaf> /LiJJp Of ApfullrM Prop.^cJAAOi.

fiofe   LL >2>

                                           1   1

                                          If
     ftfifior^r (^^6 charcj^ol oj'iik P>vrf/ary nf c^ //cvt/P^F/fxJj
 7> v, Pi C. i <3Q i/)2 •Se&o^rd <P<? y/utt. Fc/c,Ajyj a^d oJcl^5_£aiAjsljl^cL by
 <k_ XifJtjU panxcyryAj TrK, PC, i iZ^Zfti)^ First beOAjit, FtJ^y
 OLllecj//^a Pz-TiTivfiM-r- -fv /] aiM- AetJ p^ i/ zoos ly aoaj u/op-^J of
Ay* ra>\rr\.ird Aelnbf.^yj Trt.P' C> 4- £1tfc\ F/rst P^jsuie Fcf&^y }
LCIlr, oct id), P-efiFoAftr erJTtrviLcl ex pi-to. or A/of RuilPy /Aj //(            XJL-

pr\fr\a.ry Qpfc/<jS<Zj amJ -frixjL To Pks> e/j/iaAJCt/r^/irryDa.rcK.eir<xy)/> J
CC,d> cd- /3°l) A,£. Ill ojP Wj 13%), ft jury of F^Pi FoAJeri peers
-Pouvcf him Qut/tyj fU tr^ul Court PoUkj^ Fj^ t/oha/dfLenwuT
 'tr^'j PtjAJiaFltrj PefjFoAMC l^olS s^A/FcA/c^d A Forty (1^
 y-een.CS COAjti tKj^/KJKvlF Jf^ Tbddj CC.il, cdr /S'tjj P.Pi lH clF /£C[
 /(?!?)> P iUfifit^ AJoTtCZ. of Ppp-ca,! (sJCLS T/rrJLiy filtdj CC>
 Pi gjF lts>2- I/sHJ i TU l'0 urpz e*sPP Court of Appals *PP> r-

    JFj OLCcorda^c-e- uo/fk F°l^ (»(p ,?> (^ T/ZftPJ PzdiFo/^r
 CDfjtvrjcLs ti\JL PcxjrPceAjff Court Of Pppe&I^Sy noosto/O^ TtytKS hous
cUc^dzd arJ importarot ao^st/o/U of SFF kcuuJ fhoJ- ka6 ajoP
b-^z/Jj but slnoOick htj Sc+tFd by PPz. Court Of Cnm/sOtx) App-eaJs.
   PPf^j Further anJO<z , Tk£ Court most F-^-cp //j W)jAjd, -PF>- Court
of Pi pp~cc^l<s h,G~^> mi^s Coi^>5FriM-d tkjL Azh i/awr Pc^cit& of PFl ca-6<l
OrO Ff rf subject ma~lte.rj pkniviivaj?j -/Fz Fppeufe Pour! m&wora/J--
cFum arvd ep/Ai/o/U is /a) CdajFIict £aj/-PJ\ Fks.6-z. /ie.lt.\/anJT /Laps
<XS Suck      h<xd Such /ljf/tAJLt\Jot^ Ojfiof MSu/tcd //J 6a, CofOpJict
Fkod cU,^1^ tkji Ax/ier P^FFioKxr ^oopft PLskvldaJ,

                     PI-5S tjjb„ <   FoT P 0A/-ir,a \ —.

  I of <\
     / Ll. Sduk., afftrdfsc/o^uAA to F^ dsfcA/sc FPcxP ft/xj^
vit~\'\'rr\ CsChrn/fcv (aJ-ho. IF) ho.d Aice/^-d rx £&.// From ftjtr
vHoo-xn Se Ct/rrfy Corr\pa*jy' C^bTj ftp at-a, /77a//a^y P)e ftcto r
i/Jifkj/J Per /us fdjsuctt hud 6>e-e/^ aopi JuFd by /yj0*rt/y^aj/
cxpftr p/\t_. CkJ(xrm System ko-d bce/J ac 11 ira Itol cotter ttsu<
b^a.k/Aj &J- fo/OQ dt/Ytt OhJ t/\*. /ndrAJ/^q o f ft^JJ}t/i <da » of
              (0 —-         >                        /•       >       ~ /j
Playy &Q/3, /FewtzFftry PHs- hJfjuM /mrr\.edtc<F/y aJcP/ Fed
fissh D>sf{Fct 0tForAM.y; ffl&, SftxPcj oJlir'ch PPIs. lAJ-yafttj
ttJ Per p/yjescAJC-t S^AJSt//npr\£9S/c>Aj or^XC'rttd/jffe/'aA/c-e j
C/ppaSScd fktxr som&o/v^ cucu5 ^/n-£cx/C/V\jd out dt ttxsi. 7)0rJ&-z-
l/J<stcoud of br^o.F//^Cj jpj -ohsKjld b&>M. otfaJ clFo iam0/ Fa) by
/4cartay Pu/e S-03 ii) pr(h)y t/^t^tbyy tAx- Court OP ftpyoecc/e
kcxS mcupLjL fkiir op/AJ/osO ojke.iv. fkiy haiM. mi<s COaJSpread am hi/-
*Kjt ftxch oP H\jl cols*, ptrtaifiJ'tvc 7k A*. aPoiA* mp/u-p/e^ed
SOJoj-ectmc^ltcry fh^Lbyj ha.**. cUctded a,J important Gj^eSp-
Fqaj of Sfc^k Z^cuaJ thixf ha€ a/oF b^e^j                 but skou/cl btj
Stifled by/ ft 16 Coi/rt,          r    .   '    j                           ,
   7/Le. £-/<xk- P,/td (x /DoP/G/J /aJ kim/^t oaJ /Ae. do-y tAx-tr/c^7
Com CNLUtz-d , CoA/%¥//3J CSfa.k& JTlo PFaj *9) to r>/^todc- °-
bamer F> Fzep tkn cUFa/<5c rronn pof{k.ri^c, /dc^jl /AjFerrncx-FoAj
Prow M£i OJ*<xlt oixjfpfs subjtcf irv^aFtr Po expand t/uL
AjLcord Supperfirjc, fk*. cUPtnJSoS tPiory ttuP ftzAJL ouo>S Sorna.-
            ff        I i'       "i       '   /   '/ /     >        ' 1
Giw<L /aj PYls, IaJaxo^Hs  /icoideAjcz prior to ptPiPiP/vers cirri<sal
G> w fhsi <5e€ASt. oP ca- httpa/ary /aj ppoOri 5Sj p/\(/Sy Pol tuas aJ&P
{\asl fo}a.ck /Ylo-b uJto lAjra/oj PPhr vUm,^ lt\9 doorbell^ PPjiajlafter
b^txF/AJc out /Fl^s- CaJ-uuU'S bed rvvrrn oo/^dooj cxajcJ e/^>rer/Ajj

                      Arcj l> rmtFt r^/xipl AAh on tics
     TPsl (J/u 1tzd Stocks Co iJ 5ft/ fu ft/ 6/0 e^J SUAJL^S fh(xt Cnm 1-
/Oa| cxjlPcaj daAjFs u~> 111 h^v^L ' C*-~ pr£ cxaj ij^a Fu> I/ oppo^FuAJrF
 to poJL&CAjt O^ XCOfnphtz- cUAa/ScP PYljFr- if1AtaAij 3 b