Court Opinion

ID: 2660326
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2014-04-03 04:27:26.73603+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:58:54.863720
License: Public Domain

Fr LEo
JUL 24 2013

ur\'z'r`;'; r» S'I'A'r)<;s l_)l.s'r‘lew "r c'/)z.=za'l' Clerk, U.S. Disfricf_& Bankruptcy
F<)R 'rrrz: r)r_.\rzzzr'l' mr C<)x_r':\uzz,a C°""S *°f me D'Sffwf of Columbla

REDACTED

Crin\illal N(). 10-'2 `75 <\".h`§x"

"' `" " "l

UNI ."""` .‘>"i/'\{".""S Ol~` A »`\'7§"7".1(.`/»‘\,
v.\~.

s'rz,z" `-';'= v" vv)~i'r<:" ¢_iis<'.lcu:»wu'<: of national C:~‘I`r::se `nmf<~':~.w:‘-inn in vic)'~.-‘».f  .‘ 18 U.S.(',`. § " ?E\'_ci), ":"
0:~.': count :\f"nal<.inr‘ {`;-xl~~.¢r Sta!:*\‘x ".r'?<~.v»'. 'l`o "\':. c"=:!"' ‘ :"."rr:.".="‘”':  .i ~‘<~§c- 'v:z‘.. '?~':

r-

Cm'."‘ .""p;‘?"'::: .J'.»" I?‘.': x'1.'#..~s011i:*.ga set 10:‘!?. in "‘Fs I\'fcxrn:'."=:‘~r?’f:i: (`)_;:i'aic-x\. in 1¥`” '=“.cz‘.‘.o.'rznd\:z'r
-'-'~inion r.'::so1vi11g ‘l:r (,`vc)\-'L:rn'~.u:'nt"s m pczrlc' :v';'\tions for a ;":‘"~‘~<‘.li\'e ordcr. "x ':.c~.‘.'.‘z'::!l\', ?",c
f_‘o\n'l uc‘.chc:‘=:"= the ‘ »`;I`uxxdanl’s and the (}0\"::1:.mc11l’s ‘r‘»~'»li"z:l; :r't;v"';:‘-.:§y, but th~ '}'?»*is.`r'.‘_:r

r'~'»;:r=.'!islg ca-,;.‘» ]')zu*»‘,"s rs j.'>a;‘li\>c motions arc c ~‘.'._=‘stc.:~,l.

`i“.ze Cc)=.:*! :»\ddrr~s."~cs 1hc I‘:r"':ndznzt’s }~".r.-"~€, Scr'<))'xd, and Fo\zw?z Mnlif)xzs 10 C‘<»x=.~.~;.':~l
u:: "`“1' sc;~.’:"nt<: coven
2 ` " "` ""' " ° v . ` _ \ ~r~¢
D¢f ’s I~arsz Mol.. sec » No. [98»3]; C)ov’i°s Omn:bus (.`*;._; n (‘ <~¢z’t’s Oyp n"), B< F

NO §"}‘"; Y?:'?"s G"."r"‘nxs Y~`.<:'*_\,'( "`,‘<:f_`s Rcp}y"), YY\ ;" .\30. [10} j.

.
'\

REDACTED l CLEARED FOR PUBL|C RELEASE

l. ii./\.f`NGR()L‘N})

/!_ /"""/zw)l` /’.zzr:.""'>'r=und

3 ?-`or px_:rn..~»:c:‘ uf this :r\olinn. the Co\n1 cites 10 thc Go\'crnmmxt`s factual background
fr.z' rc'.¢“\':\n! ‘1!:! um‘.is]‘)utcd background iF‘F€="Y`,`.HIiON»

2
§ Rer)AcTEo /cLEAREo ron Pusuc RELeAsE

 

A! or about 3:16 PM that sams day, James Rns:cn. a Fox `Ncws rc;~nm~:~ working oz)t of
the S‘\:.‘,: Dcpartx~aciit hcadquartc's, published an az'!ic]e entitled "Noz‘th l§<)rca !rstcnd,¢ 10 M.",tch
U.N. Rcsolution w:`rlv Ncw Nuclcar 'i`cs! " Gov’t’s Opp‘n at 8; Def.’s l?"?:'st Mc»:.. F,x 2 (l?=')..zf‘rial l’roccci=.ire< l()(tl)(i), which ;=t‘:l:.~.
ei\""*rv'i'/zitiorz iincl<:.x' section 4 ol the (,`lz==~il`i<::i lnio»z-aiitin Pi'c)<;c'?'~a":~." Act ("(Y?"` ‘\"), 18 l.l.S.C,`.
.A,'>P. .'l § /l_ m'l l"`t:der:zl ltulc~ c)i` C.'iii)in;ii l’)'i_)r.<-.clti!'t' ll')(d){]) for 1`.'1:‘ i'l:-“'~.::ti::n\‘_ sul‘:rii'.‘.)ii:):'~.a.
and witlili<)ldinv,:. timing clisco'»‘~".*\/. .‘)`cc Lgunc.'ra!/_p Gov’i’s  'z iii .Pu)'lc~ Mnt , l~`,"’i` No. ;"~‘ `;],
`i`fic C<)i:r‘ y)'.-=':iitt»;».i‘ ;)riatc_, liis zinticipiiierl cf'~':'.ii\;c.~; :’ lii;"‘ for '!~,..~, Cn~-~~‘g,
<;c~'*'idcl.:‘§».')zz in i'~:"-'~'~ii;z“.t’s rt'w?ion ‘.r:
c" "»‘.:‘,t~.l.

¥I. LIBGAL .S`T.ANDARD
i’or.'=iz:irit to Fcdr~~sal Rulc of Criminal Prc»cr'iiirc ]6(<:), "{u]poii a oci ami to c¢r~y" ".".y it<~ir: t‘. .'zf is 'txitliin the

(io'v.'::‘s'.~‘r.<‘r"`s "`;»z).~::=cssioiz_ c.'. "i-dfy, ~"f t:ontrol," zu'.~¢l is "iii:itoi‘izil to g')"v‘.;v:o'i:i;, flra ilcfeii$':." F:'fl_

 

l{. (`r. l’. ?o(t~). "ii<~ (jo\'criiiiioi~.t :~:iist disclose iiiforisialion ~’ gin im.irr tl"ris mile "<_)uly if`s'.zcli
evidence cnal)!:=~. ‘_"-c .*.:»{`<:nd:z'~.t significantly to alter the quun'-.i'==f) <~"~,~,rc‘~')j’ in his f“.'=.‘.'c..~ " U~:.~`,r.~d

Slale.s‘ v. /l»fa);t'/uzl'!, !32 F_Bd of)`, 67 "? C. Cir. }995’»}(¢:3!2)150:: <~=:‘zitied).

4
REDACTED l CLEARED FOR PUBL|C RELEASE

/\ ~~'~<‘v‘~ su't:x;‘“'"~‘. three-pan test applic‘s. whc)c tlu: l)<:fc:»cf.~:~' :"rr'l<:, clztsssi't<~cl inl'<\'~':“ft\it):»

ltc-m ‘.l'»<‘ l'f'~ "  ::»t  ‘-.l~.t~ I)ct"::rldz*.tzt ':“»:st :=_ltt~vt` tlt:;t tl'tt: i:t."~ , elt'.'~.n :zt_)tt;~_‘ ~ ‘:~“.'~.~:::lc,\'j tl.»t:
l.'»w l)t=':l’:' ul rt_'lc.v:zx)t_‘.u.” Urzz'lcd f.~')‘ul¢‘.v v. )’un)s, Xt)'/' l".§d <)l'/`, 1323 (l`? (` l`:'. l‘??»'§?). .‘-`-"f‘-'t"'l.
tltc‘ (,`nu;'l ":»'lt<)uld dcl¢~."r"nt: `.”‘l"»~: as `~:m` <)f`})rlvilc;_»c by t.‘~,f: sz\)v.'~rrtxr "w? i:» at least 1a <§¢" ~r:z!~’¢-
nnc." id l"izz.'tlly, the l>ei`t.:xz`~'9, .‘~»‘»A (l).(,`. Cir. ?.(l()“)) (citirts; l/':"`.“ ‘r,.' $`_'zx.'e'.\' ‘.~ ,/\’r.';:.-‘.-r/_ l'l'l l` °»Cl l l?.l,

,-.

143  C. (`.ir. lQQS),l.
'l`l:r l‘t`l~;n.‘lwr~.l fx::"l:cr moves to ct):n;~.cl ;»)uz~:'.tr:x~.‘. t.t) B)‘ad\»' v. /l»u' '~"".":.J. ".’B)~/zdy znfl ‘.’:

v
t

.~c_l tlz"».' cltu: :>:'~

  

gt,“'~v_~“x~_'»' ‘ '> ~.r»”..< requires t':a~" disc.l:).~<='~": of itt"\rn~."‘fott €l:;;t is "";r'nri:l)lc ‘.:» ".::'
a<~r‘.‘.).‘:t-d. either lr.:t:zxnsc it is c:):"~‘_t);)ttu'y. <~:' because 11 is ?:~~.;)Q~.zt:hixtt!` :culnutory' iul`c'~“r":ztit)n under Bmdy is w::bsu:ned within the Cn.zr"s ::r_,z‘y.\'is t_,», wl:c'.'&'t<:~
r€¢‘-!"-'~’  1'=` "'t"zr'ati<)n would ltv tl.tr.~,'itl to the '?.'.‘.’c.r.e=<~.
l}¥. I)!S(`I'SS}ON
"a`?’t~, Dr».¢cl ~".1:‘~1 is rci;'z) .':.'~.tiun md (4) tl‘.'t thc dt:!`-."'z.“tz'=‘ \\'illt`ttll_\'
c'.t\it‘.xxitxtt:'~':‘.~€l, dcli‘~‘r'~*c:l. or trziii.-.tt.ittcrl such iiifoi‘.iv:\."`:~.it to ii ])~.'z=>:; ~ v z':'.‘.itlecl
to t‘u<'.::ivc: it_

(/nz'icd.S`/rz.'r.s‘ v. (im, XUC  S::~~.~~ 2d 44, :‘»"» (l) l).(." I£Gl l}. 'l`l'tc l`)€f`.'"'~riz\r~.t`.'~: ":tz)ti<)ii tn :'r~=.~,‘,~"
 '1'::.~"_<; t`!tt: ~ ~>;);:tl and third c.`
' ‘ tt!c'.:;‘;;:cl liy tltr: " t:l`:tt‘i".:‘;i in !ifS ru()i'loll.

d

_»i "/.')f¢).~."rr/r)`¢);z /1’0/`1:11')2;; 20 the N.'//z`¢)nz)/ ."»‘¢jfc';.~.t'e "

  

litt:~.rg=""’ivtt'_  ;‘;:"‘:.'~r \"c"":')n uf the li ;.‘.~ic~nztgt: /"\t'l, in l‘)"’-l !li<; .“l\';"" t (Yutzrt
Cxplair"‘ tli:it "iiati»"vf..il dt.v"c:)~;:?" as used in this ct‘-".‘.e;~;? "is at “r'~:‘_“?c c  nl ":~\:_»'l
='r':'::c)l;~itioits. i~r~f`;ri'zng t:‘~ ,*li<: .*.i‘.lit:~.ij; and naval c=t.'zl.“.»'islt:~.'.¢ii?‘i )zr-' rli:»<~ln'<<~rl t: Mr_ lln.~~“' vt=;t_< "`nzttictiiz=.l dctt~r 1 ~`~"'=vr“.:~.ttoiz". tl] t‘. ‘ ".1; "citsclt' =‘='1~

»-t"'ltt~ ~ttti."~~:tt§/».=t ~'»~t.'»t)tt.'thiy c,~c=.tlttrt .'~.""111"<~.'/

" :‘ "'J"tiii.""‘crit "'.‘t"‘.ics t`<)i'pi:'*,“'\,.~;t=:< Gt'?‘r,".x t“.~~~rlti<)tt.

_l_‘()dt~:.'?.‘iztll§;_l§,'t*rigging t__Q fl‘.;j_l~lllift:rl_,.°tt?':s "‘. :t_);"".zl ‘,0 ':‘ §7,1'.“1‘,“}' t'=l lll'
L.?riitgd__.“}tat<:s

l ~f trial . '~urt in Muri.sur) d “."`::t.'-<.l the tc:'m "'titxtional dr"':i't¢c"  “ tl‘zc.  j'_ 12.° ."llt)ws:

` ""?:c tenn ti:ttit'~'v:tl d;‘t'“i'.scl] lnclu:lt".<‘ till trtz'_f<~‘- flint direc:tlv ctr ".1 " " ‘::.=")';.:
l)-< c;\')ti:~.'~~‘:~rl with the dcf":z~:.".c‘: of thc l.’:".~‘.t.c,t‘l St»'.tc" against “‘:j»' \ to the :ztilil-'_»u}' and itzz\"~l cstal:»l§*‘:'~r‘*i"." and thc “r"t"_" zt~~"~"ltic:s wl it;tt"~"‘.'*l
pzt~j.).tzc'.li)tz.<.\:_ 'l`u prove "` tt thc [c’».""»rt;t'.
two tlzirt.t)s that thc  '~'::r~~.':~.~'“'>t z*:."st m
r)rt ;;) ; ' z~sti"r ; " )lt~.t t<:tt
|"ir::t f\m ' '!;m;ttt z'tctiv£ty.

'. -.… ,»»t-,~»

‘QH'J],'- ¢lA ~, 

.l'{u.<.'li)/,<;,r ~/_ ,.-'z/t/zz~)'¢z." ff `.'))'1 i.')'e)“)c:e t)_/' U..\`, 829 |".?.zi 9}, 305 ,’l`?,t`. (`it

" :t`t:ttt’  }§}:z)`.~.' =";:rltt~:r` \';-. ".zi:rtc.<:$ t'.lt.':llt:tlgr_:. tim (Y<)Lt.'“t t‘ilcd lt) ?" ~ /t/f" "~t<;=r ‘.(L\' t~` l~`.'.tz);~. 153 :tt 

t`<`i!f):s> ,t.;/()):..'.'»)), 9-'1-1 |‘.'lr! 211 !074`;; )`zf. at  (s.'t:`.:'.‘t. /\"~'~"zt'. zm_\’ t;tntsti's.nxt)z);.~l ,' ~~

(`t)'.:"' is lmunrt ivy ‘?' i,)t<,»ztt"‘~* dt;i`)¢;*§'>" <)t"‘nzxtit‘:’."’ tlt‘._'"r't':;c" plu`»'i';ictl ‘"" ‘."'7. .\"z;  '\"Zt)url in

()`<)".’>'

.S'.~r~c~r)¢l', tht; :"~xu""r"\“.f"'-f that the di$clos\'r'.~ €"f"xxz?"\.“":~.zati<*»': ‘~." l ¢:~"»'§rttiy tl'.";'t;l?:t<* " the
t_tnitt;tl .“Y'~‘tt~s. " "':tt 11 :m<.zht be .'./.»'¢,'_,»'z// .'0 cm c)acr)?y ¢‘/f!.’tc* t`!)vznzr/.'»'!tx;¢'.v, )t»ft)r:\'-.»:.=_ é~`A/l |~` Ilu` .t‘
!()'7!-"` ts lu'_'t)t‘: '.<=".tz: vt'i"". `:S tl.S.(_f.  '.793(<1), Wttl) 'rCS_r`;‘:/‘t tv thc t`." ' tr'i:tst":»  t')!`tz”;."»'i.
t`§~:‘ :.*'.':~;

"'C.c)tlttt` `m~ t.tsct"t ;t) thc iniurv t.»!”t‘t: Unitcd Statt:s t)r to ‘.t';r ¢t .

 

t\\»..

li.$.(`f. § '."'~`»(ti') (=*:j,)h;tsis a""’-d). /\.S the Suprc.::',c Court .'»i-_';‘.L':ixzt;ti in t_»"~"")¢_ "‘-; s""'.tt' is nut
I"""_:‘=‘i 10 i‘.\_to-~~~~rt"f m that nti;'.*:t aid “~r‘. cra<'r.':j'ofthc Unit<“d .“`-t:'.'c.=;:

T,`tc' .\~tz-ttzttc is cxpiicit in t')llra:ri:'.',': Th<' crime cvt` c\:;`§ons.;t~  am :s~.:t o;` t»tw‘:z';n`t;.:
int`<'~:~z~z  ~~'.'~.tittgz tc) thc r~.zttfc'-'tzt! dci`c:r»:‘ "to be :):e:~‘ . . , m  adv:tnt:~.;:<: of
amv l"t.=tt:i :xzttimt." Nc» distinction is minds t'»;tz=.':~f~:: i`ric:irt tv t:'.~:~~::‘r_ `.'z'.!.:\;)'.‘»'z‘.y
thc :stz:tu.~: ” a :’-""c.i_x;ct ut)\'<*.':tencz1t may ::}z.'tz:ge. 'F?;c evil v\fr"‘=. 1.’1'; .<€.‘t'::f".
i‘.sh?‘<¥§§ .'“."""zs guarded izzt"' :::"‘fit)l), c.".`»"' 10 mr

j‘=ttt‘ttstxt':; `s '?2:~ -t~ialltir:u ~".' ft::';
htu"t car .'. X'I\""’.~; :~'1§::.

C}r,)r)rz, 312 U.H_ z\t 199 30 (cllinse>: in cri;zinal). lt would be ilit)gi<;at  z'~"'.\ir<` :t~t~ "=:v'»dv:tt“'z:t'. w

.='.t=‘w that thc "~i`tw':;'~t::‘_iotz might be t.’.:t:fu] to an e:t#:s:~,~,» of the t‘~:i::~d Stat':\‘ \,vt\<::' the ':v`;. ‘=‘:~

'.

"'.~'\ttirvrr'~ " ‘ ort>'.t~dl_y z v':~'~e' to iuft:rv.~ation tt:.'t‘. :<".xld be u~“.'~" to ‘.?.~“ a;*'~'".'=tz'_:"' \.  tc:~rs§t"z :):=‘i' z~._

s
rzeoAcren / cuzARzu FoR Puauc RELEAsE

4

r"` ‘r:'/. :.'1 t:.:,t':. lil:t this wlti'.:l'» Z'~'.'t»l\/L‘ tltt- ztll€.f_,’.€.-:tt:t: 01 c§'" ‘l"" t

\

`zxz_"\.~~r:~:' ""intt t“tt"~~utctjly <.lts:;lu:;cd to t\# ix Rt»'~"~ m '."*.

ss

<'as:t‘ was t:itt:=.~:il'»t:ti :~.s; 'l`;tp Secr'tzt//`Sct‘.:;ttt\'c Ct»tttpattn)~‘rt'.<:cl ltif-.\:'.'"“'-.itr¢tz tt c|:=‘~':‘i`~:'::‘- 'l l»;‘~.""

tlx:tt 'i:;i ""»l  m ;~" \rtit;~itir»zt_ `tht: uti:ttttl~.zt'€.'/_ccl disclost)i'c:  v/lticli ~-t»;;~~)i:zi`!ill\' <:_"»§<`  't.'.»‘,. us z-.tttc:,.'lt~,d by l'l>;c<:. <"'~‘. ~" l\lt\,, l't.f"t'?.. .'t t`.l".tt.
~t` =‘3(1('.’(’("5"-. -"1',"-"""//'/?" "»t`.~.' » .‘t.<:trtt: ’*'~v‘. t)l`llte

),r‘.

to cl<:‘¢: :~:1.?:‘.':

 

;:lt".'tzt: "jixt` !~" the llr"‘ ":l
."":t‘~~': r=' :nipttt l)t: useful 10 '=.rz encmv of the Y'ztitc:d St:.":s," <‘.rtt'k, tltc Court w:z$ unable to ltv<;:»‘ .: a sizi_:"t <.:t_ ': 0::1 ada
tltt: l~`<»ttt'tlt t`iz'cttit t ::z:~?o_‘.""~.g this ::t:tt: "~.~~.;t_ Morc::)\=<=.v_ it is not clt:;z'~ 1}~,;~_‘._ ,{~Z_¢';f<-,i C¢,;,,-v_¢ Wjg}~j»j
.

 ~:rtui‘”:"t`: tl‘-~

thc l*`c)ttt'tli t.`itctxit F_"?"_Y ./l~inri.w"" itt t’.:" WHY the l)ct't~ndaz:t 1:";“<`°~ -i`*.r;r is.

9
REDACTED / CLEARED FOR PUBL|C RELEASE

ti<_\v<:~ '; »;ttt ‘“ ::'t'.r)\»v tlt:;t tl)c "t`t '*t":' tt~.lutrxt;ttit:tt :1'. i>..\~tic would !)t‘~ pt)tcztti.'alljy rl::rr\.ftvirtsv tci t!tt:

!lt'titt;tl Stzttt~;_ ,\z ;’c:t.<;t  \, t;¢tttrl:~ ~‘tziv€ tz.~tctz).'ctt:tl ,l»;f./))'i,\zu~) tt> i't:<,tuist~ tl:c (_i" "r:'»t  tt) ' t '1.1
tltztt thc tttt`<\z'tit:ttzt)tt "`.< tltt‘ !t.';)c uf it "c="r':tt»t)i) tltztt. il tliscl<)s<:cl', c`tu‘.u::."
(/’):J!!:(~" .S`It'/ic'.t` )1_ .";`.').s‘t'-.').', 4-'3“ l-'. _'>jtr'~)' 3d t'.'>}. t;)l¢‘>' (l;`.l). V.'i. './",UU(.'») -’~.::,;‘»F~.'z"`g :tr§}_-~:'|; c;c'cryrd
(1’)'.'11;'¢/'.\'t’rz/r;_e' ;' !-.'zzvur'.'t'z@ ."~.'t)_ _"?.’t~rlf’: .’.'l.'t',`.'. Wl, 32.638."~"1, ;.t "<'1 t’l‘...’). \"st /tttj.>_ 3, Zill'.’). "'¢/
.‘('/’ }.'.'/'tzzkz)zt. l’.i`ll§ \‘.»'l, `5.""()3<‘?.'3¢, :tt "(), n.§ l\"t`.ll't:t)ur:st‘g at trial llzc‘ (.it)'~':‘.‘z‘.' ‘.“ri‘ ::'tt_s‘t prove that
tlzt~ 

!"`*.',»’~ :tnti lit'tt‘.ll_v, thc <`,`.r)tti't w:»u; =.tx\:il)lc tt) find any =?¢»'.trt ot'.*r:`t;lc the l~`otu'tlt (":';":it t";»et
t~:~.tyt‘f)yt:t‘. t`t)is c:cntstrttct’ ~ 0_1 "n:~.!iw;xztl tl;-.t`ctzsc,"  t`nt: cortti:_=‘_'»', ':1 l'~_t .'  court lms util"'-'~:*
the Ga)'i): l "'rtittt»ti  "rt:ttitutztl <' ;""'ttsu." l)`nz'.’c'<." .\’tulc.s‘ v. AI»=/-tt’r'lza" "t Ff"") *` St:,~‘-_ 2d .“)(32.

'~)t‘,'§ "`> (lt'."" ".tl.'\‘»`) 't'f'.'./, G'§(l l",,lti l‘.!). (f`/.ti t"i;'. '.’.(ll@§;  Uniled’ .'\'Fr.'.';'.'c \'_ z')‘<.'_t'c'c'_ 5"'5 v .7.t’l

 

?'  d~."= ..’.)tt wl

l/.

134"‘, '”'§l ` t‘?tlt C`§" i¥/`T"l} t’t"$.lcctiii\_' tltt~ dcft-iiv.’.'t:"‘,’s ztt‘g!utt'\;~r‘.' tlt:' tlrt‘ t

"'*':'i')t»'.tl tlcl`:': ;t" sltt»‘..ltl ltc l~":'itt~.ti m itt.‘"<`\':"."‘f'gtt <'r_zn:crx~.i:!i?, lltc "t‘.‘ii?.‘.;tt"»' cs'.»‘ 'i:;l="',c:tt" :t\ttf

":~*ili‘~js yr:~~~":" "v` ‘.~:.'< l*: 'lt~*`:t'rii:iu the t"~t¢"i!"ry c)t"the l}tzi‘t¢”l S! .¢""’).
I"C.\:' rltt~~'~ :  the t_`,<:)t:tt dcclirc~~ to construe s<:t:".ntt '.7"`“»’§1) Z~ i'e<;_z;‘.:'z '.‘~='

(Zt)"~':'r.".w‘;‘."'t tt) :;ltc)v»' tl‘.ttt the di",-§’c~"i“:', mr tlic ittl".":':it:at§r\: :zt ‘frz;t.." '\v“=i,tlcl "" ;10*~:"*15':!`1_\.'

d:~tttxz'tt:iitt'. 10 "‘;;~ tlmtt;ti f~itzttt:s ur tuf{zh‘. be \)<".~’t)l to an ~,z~.ttz=\' :it" ti:<“ ’~._!:*.Zf'~r" .‘¢t:‘_"_< in nt.'f:: t

z\

s:ttisl`y tim s‘.'~’.'-ttt)ry z'<‘<;ti*-".'~tttcnt tl't:tt the ‘:":)rtttztti<)tt t'clatt-‘ t<) t‘:it: "'“.:ttit“n'tl cl<».t"`:\=vc:`tz.'ri<‘t#t. "`i`.»'ir; r"crz_ui:t \‘r':ztt """< i:`::lt

in lht' fv!¢.»ri.t'w~t ¢: :;z:€',fz"»"""* of inform .'1»:~ but .<::!"z‘.':.';\.»;':'lj.'

\>c‘f""""'.\' f':"'~:~ of those rc~.qucsts." f_>us!y tln~:~: raz'.v.acsls v main ‘r)<.»nu`ilwg, ‘~"~":` *Y:t: (`>".11:

(l).'*:z~vz;;.~<: ns:;<::~:.~:~ .'»»,'.s conc<““.izxg "h'; alleged disclosure 10 Mr. Rc '»:;'.; {i) c'“:~':;zz~: ’: z“!a‘Y'”-z

_az~..-' (3) all 'x"r)x) Secr;~,t inlc~ilz`_z':~t~c<; reports acce".~\'d by Mr`  ."`~on: A;\f§ 1, 12009,

?‘:r;»‘;_:'h june §§, 2009.
!. ?`>n"va_xyq /\sses.-'~.:,c:.‘__~j

Tniti:lliy, ‘Y "; l)ef¢~.l);§~.::‘, r:r/,]':-~”»‘*~ "an}' `.'i"x":~.\.‘-‘ a»i'~.:"'~¢=.n:_""" or c ‘!‘-'~.' <~r=_.‘f "r  :a\_?-»=.:""`~"',xz§?

"~' .'z":", v‘=, ii'zuw, oi`ihc zcllL-.;,';~:i disc,’< F‘\re cm ‘ 1;"'< '~':‘ .‘»czzur§=.y f‘i‘»';‘," .~"?.< " D'_"` "s M:€ ,1‘ 5. ."`izc

¥)r:f`<::'..inn*. 2:;;\1:"' T{¢‘l ",'ajny =";'~¢111)'.1'11! Lcu<§§".s', fu S?rr‘./ 1‘"..'\.‘. .<~:v=~ #::': in :`~"~»” }i,'?".'\’s _r'*.=‘f‘.f.".':

""'\s'_>:;.'z"f)' c~;v.z]d have bc`lieve~." lh.\‘ thc d`..~"".<;»s".r: of "': ir‘.f<)z~.:: .‘.'».:~‘: v~+'~'uld _1;~=‘ !:F'rm U.S.

1~.;11'=:;;11 security im;‘r,~,.-:r- "w aid a fc-rc‘s',n is c)_uulpaw.rj‘."` bcr:r.zc :=._z:~¥' df-.:'.):x'..).z:!~ "iv~:`x!] m

}"`f`-‘\'€'. that the §:;F~":;‘.:xli<)n at issue v':'.:‘ not ‘rxaf.ic>;~.::l c‘~;'i`c::<=" ir.,rr""zz'~xlix)lu."' ."J':."s M<)i. m 6

 

(z;.'a)uhasis in uriginal), T}~.is .=a.'gzusx:=~‘ cnnfu:.:": two scp;‘;ft‘c ir):u)irir~<' the qu;’;
:‘w; Dc,"c'zzci:zxz! had rca. w 10 bc!icve t!:z=.€ f!'.»" ixuf~'\s‘szs:_xli"~:‘ could !~." vs :_‘. 10 !.‘:: iniz;r~: n;” +_};¢ 1};~_;'1;_~1

Sini<:s '=r m 1!:<: aj"~ wage cfa foreign x‘.;zf.iex) is a .".<:;-;+.raic -';;;\'~".Li<)x'. F'..~ `=’ v\~'!".:"‘.."" ‘!:z~ "1‘ "c:»";:'»e.li<)n

c . ¢ - . ._ .
I‘.\<: (,Lmz‘. refers to the Defcr,dnnt s request for ~.!»»¢1)1~0¢;~.1:< cox;:<:vrw".g
mi 3 .‘;zn_x'_?c rcqc<:§!.

.S`c€ ."`:v;t;.»sccl (`?)»."f;:r ‘E"i_| 3~4.

12
f-.'F.oncreo .'cLEAREo F0R Pueuc RELEAS€

;illt;_;j_t~.d|_',» tli.‘;r'lt).‘;u<.l tclutu:'§ tn thc ttz»'.t:t'r~.:~.l dcft:xi:':t' 'l`lil_' l)i:"<.~z:f vt t»f":’r' no c;\pl:tnu'.i"': ns trt

li':»\-\' dz~.in;-zt;t- - :<_t :.~~:its wt)ttlti ha l'tcli?'tzl tt» tltt. tlt:t"t>zzst~ 111 sl)t)vvilt;»» thm l" iut"t‘ : 's?‘<)i:
. l

p. " '*.v‘dly .'lisclnsr:»

tht; c<:sit\:x:*-', t‘v' |>t:lt:ri:~d in thc :":~¢,~r'.
li;itl `:-':¢n :<:_r-t='"tt‘:¥ in ‘it‘:.'tm<".ti‘."  Y, ;uiv *"'z»‘:lt.’.‘f l* '~ '.\'it>i't. 1 "';tt).l)’~ t~l' t:v<;:-V al:=.# ki‘<:»x','x‘. tci

r ..
132

Mt'. K`Ym 211 thc ti:i*..*: <)t' thc alleged ciiscl= ftrc, such itif`c‘.':z~.:;!?:\:~ vvt)uld l)c :,’i=c.'z"t‘t':‘.bl':" in.~'-".
:.:= they would tz'~':\'ist the jury in tl<:tt~::'»'ir~.ixtg \". ~'l " thc Dc:l"~vz"`"int tt:;-::'<»."iztl')ly ‘.wf:llc\'c~.'* f‘i:it

(li"-:‘?t)s':"~ ~'\'xl:l be t’:.'t~.agirig." l)<;f.`s Rc;)ly at 175  " tio»-~':~~" ' ":';*‘tt=‘:= that .'.“;: tlz“ l:-.:t

n<‘zz"..".,';': zt.~;s<~.<. ~'?:<~.':‘_s' by definition :z"" not relevant to this inquiry ‘~~::»iusc thc rt"‘.>~itizzl)l»::i:.~r ~‘"

the D,-_f::zir? ':it’s ‘-::‘ie:"if based on thc t'::~'s iint in his inotiort or ,':‘:"v br?~'tltics the l)c"cr
v.tottlci 't)c laul;“‘"'ll 10 :‘:: f :fcn'*.":‘.‘ in ~"‘ "x\l.’iug tl‘»" *‘1. r :"`c»x; v.. ~" nut "clo.<<".y~ E~<~!d."

 

l 'l
REDACTED/CLEARED FOR PUBLIC RELEASE

t';:\"t`$ (); ;' n at ')‘)_; id {" ?"~.t.' dz;lrtztg€ ;ts$t""tit:;tt,~. Wcrc -t 'stc~.rl m t~ “'.j"ilt;t‘. ."ct tl\t' z‘.llct't~.tl
t»_'! " ‘:t~.\; '.‘.'t:;t~ c zv‘"=ltt~cl W'rtat, if un_v, future cl:.~ tl;t‘ t)c:c:‘ --»'l '~".t'.i tl:.~'t‘§t»::t~~‘-~ \t':».<' ;it)t
l;g~,tivt "~!r; ’n_,t ‘h' :t<'t~ti:~‘ f dut‘itztz_ ‘i’ ‘ time pt:ri:)cl uf the t.liztt;.=c.~.l t""",:n.‘~.t'..~..") (ttttt)titis! U);/l .'
.S`./..'.'¢'.t.~ ~.~ /t'.-‘¢:)nzz)~/_»:, .‘)`lit). t)p, at ~”»~“1 {`tl..%` A"~‘~}»' `i.'.'i twmtl.'.l l;.)<’~
l`.'.t~,t:: known t)xi'>z‘ m t"f‘ tlisclt')surc‘. 'l`litls t"t)t t:xu)nr)lt':_ il` "n Jtmt‘. l?.. I)()()Q, :': it  :‘\"r t)li that
int<;lli'x‘)tcc cr»:: :11.'::'¢'[‘».)' /‘l.*?.l`t:f’ n tian'):t,;ist»~", <~.riulc;` pott~r:'.ially l":
rci<:v'~".' tt) rla )w ~.x-"~.~thw r)?:#`rzc~f)`vcl_s¢ thc l)t'fczidasit :‘liot;lcl have l't."'l :‘c" "‘»t\ to l»¢licve ?‘i.'~;l:'»?.)";:

~" t"\; i.",f`\~~~~.utit)ti cr:'.z‘.d bc tr."':'i to tht‘ injury of the l_l.".""‘-*, Stz'.!"z' or to ‘.it: ;e;l'.':+\zt;‘.;'_" f. a

\:.

neu/men / cLEAREt) Fon Puattc RELeAsE

l~~~~`;;_»;; z _"'):x. "*`.-t; (`st)“»':"t"""‘)’.`$ :~:=.;'::."." Ol` l "."‘il`l.,”: is based on 21 "~ ~z'»?"' t:l` :'c;" ="'i~.< t`t‘_;

l):.:l`»"'~.f*.'!'tt ~'J`~)t‘..\` n-;\t .'lcl\" 
l‘~lt~.\=;;i'tl‘.u"":, thc (I~.)url ti<)!'.~._<; ll :,‘ tht: i")":l='ii.'i"l\ 'h‘:

tila '  ~'~‘)ility ri:l, ’h:‘. l)¢‘."c~':_»r!:atzl strt:lts all Clocutr':;‘.‘-.s "rt:latin;z tt_) tl-»~ 
h" tnci»z~.»t;t. 3 (t`\/'i l/’t>‘)_c.'naill, the l.` ”C:ndaiit 'z':';zttic)tl is .~-_»lt:\".~:;'. 'i:'.i l::l‘pf’ttl ‘_~i»
tl'r.‘ l`)ct`t'ttclacit `~~.;~r~::t::su “it is far ""“::~. cl’x'tr that thc _rc;`/":“.‘, c=“, ?r§~'.r:l :?"ti:'.l
ititcllirt'¢z\t:c "'?l`:))'ti=::tii)ti that Mr. Kim z'.:.asr)ii".¥~‘y cr»'tlcl lmvc lv~;li“‘»/@.t'l vt~:.s [:z.':‘_ir"‘.'zl ».l;~-

l` "’.~; lvlc)t. at ll. "c l)cl'e:'tt‘~altt stt_tztzcsts that il' lltff _ ~"l'sz:v“\ v~.=?."

|))

izi.";."zi'z.'tti:)‘ .

hzi‘zr~:l on "‘i l`<‘s'i,lrrl spe,ctllatit)ii’ h'r~m  pul)licall}'-'tvailal‘ic

_~=:ri-s<)‘.)rc,» ."~'~‘.criztl:;." ‘."'t: rif/mt would not qualify ns ttatiotial t‘.»':.‘r x'c i:"..‘c);‘ti~.atiz:t ,’d. `i`l:€

i?:fctz=*-;t:)t t'~=i.-'~ i'no\'»zs to cozi'.;".:'l thc di.<~:'.~.<:;'f of "a/')y ii`ilo."x~“.nt‘t)x) '"!atcr* tt;~_
_ "="Oftl wl fhc i““=llttf»i`"”’-“ @t“"="='~‘“"v'$

»,_,

t" "I'i;»:)rting." Id. ztt ll (t~i~;;=:»liasis adtletl‘». ','i.e l`)e',":*.:rlan. r.“,c:> ag,t. .

' s
Rtzoltcrso /cLEAnl:r) FoR Puauc RetEAsE

Lt::it'l'.ztt~.s t\.\=t» di  cu ~=<~:~:~‘1;: u"t;c‘.`ti~'“  is :1 :,'~j~‘t: .‘ i""'t' 

\»" "h<:i' " .- trilt~."'"‘.~t:"\r‘ ~.».':ts t~,t.\"\lit'ly'~zl\'=ttl:ti)lt~ `s`:,c C<\ttrt '.‘.d:‘.' ":.~:t~:: l~ ~".i  ':i:z= in th<~ c'~"t:\:t

til `t»< 1,`- .‘ ;~ ":t:;tit)r\z:l 'l:§t~n':c" and "t";  to l)eli<"~»'=_~t" i"~f]utri  tmtlt~.z' .\:t~.t;tic)x't ‘/‘)f,tl":zl '. "l~.- j><>i`v:.".;».»‘.

   
   
 

    

Suc»' l)cl`.`s "'rst lvt¢_)t., i`  l _rcpoxt) at 3

  

,'\_t»;_~;~.~~~l`ti~t;;lyt__ t`:`=‘ (`iovté;~~i;v;::;it 1 `z:;“ prod=.t"¢ any d<)c~.‘.::~.‘.v:‘.':' ~=~~lzt'.itu<_» 1..~ wl ':t’_'.."‘ "ftt' in?t :~~:'.;fi<~~:

t~t.:"t.":' f.; t"t>r<:':,»j'z~ 11:;"911. `i'l:t‘. "~""'

 .f.tizt~zzt 1‘,.~"_'~'11~.~‘
dt~=~z`=-\t¢ "="11 ittf‘<»~v-ati<»n »~@i».-.rdi=»g;=~t the  =~..v~\~»=~ of

the intctlit',<:t-.:: mav be r@levart to this inctul-.",', Rzt'.‘:~.t~r the t;`t)~»><~:'~.iii~.»'z~.'. -l~_i':z:.- ‘»¢» thc

l ti
REDACYED ICLEARED FOR PUBL|C RELEASE

...t ,

I)~-‘"'--H.'z=:t`s  1 ‘>1 on thc grounds ‘,§r't thc dncurt":r)!.\: Sot:;_!f';‘. am not d‘. ;f;»v;'z'.'s¥.".-In' `t""':ztxsc
:'}c"~~'t;zxtt t;:xttttt)t Dru\'c: that l'.r: had at:t;css tt‘!_”"""~":""i `i`~‘! :"\(' “<‘V\' ~""°‘-11~"» 331

rH:cc.t-.\~':j;_" "lt)v't`.‘~' (.".?_t‘)p`t! 211 65.

/<.:; lht: I),(T, (_`,`irt‘xti? rr:~: v_.'ziv.cd in Yu.'v)`.,\' that "l])c deft‘-,nd:sttt z.:“.¢i h§.~; r_,t_~ttr'~¢'~§ j;z 
t::u'z " tire h'z‘"'\""r'i t't'\_' t‘~'~ f`:tt'.t that thc ittft`v'"r.al}'.)sz "~"',/ """`1' j:» not '\"~.tl:ti)lu tc= zh;~; tt,~'ii fn
::h<)wint: t)l`})t‘};)j`tt]) '<;] i.=. tr..'tdc." )"u»'lis, 867 ti§’_rl ztt t')').";. lit)tvt:\»t~- ;t; ~ f`lzx\=v in thc "».'1’=:“ !':r."s
mqut;z;t is not that h<~ fails 20 )~."tz‘z)tif`_y '»‘i~f:t;)`!`)t; tit)t:t:r)»cuts that ha ""'§L~.»»'c:d r<::~:~' i'.ns= this "ftt!"»~‘t.

21 f);trtf= -" )’urult' Iii-:<=.])' §It\c.s not in'ttt»"»:.;' 500 )'tz'. (IF.`»’FF;= i`n't? ii ,1“‘7' ‘"‘"" 01 "thr `="'n'.s' to twin ?* .'t

vt-'?’.:'.<',<:s mnv tc‘.<"§{`y, :~":] the r:~’c\':t:tt'c of t'hr,»s“, events 10 the F'tl#"" <‘.h:‘“,"."” 1~.=:"»' \\"."!

dt-rr».~n:t.r.\:“ cith:~' the ;~s'=~=czz~.‘c or z\_§»~\:~w:c t)fthe rc~quirt"'l tna':~~"‘zttity) tuu<»'. fz,»"z U=~."':t! S!azvs tx

":Ic')zzuelrr-li-'~::al. 453 U.S. 858, 871 (JS‘-¢`t)t ”."-te l)c"s»vv.<_?;~‘-.t’s r»r';tt'cz=t, as c.~“r=~.t\tly F:‘t"'"'i,

  rc:_c':;'~:‘".c.::s of wh'~’hcr the D "_`::v~.r‘.e't' `ttz'.~.i zst~.t_:<::f:< !»'~ tl\t"r* t!t)t't‘x‘:»:;‘.‘?\".

»

“‘--'_‘:'.-a'~" 13;

‘;’»'=)pt»<~‘<'! l)rdc.t' 1§'|] _`~-4 T"vr Gc)vurnz't'-:~:wfs tlt`)tcs, \\“~t`nt)ttt "")ultt:! ¥`\.'t~tu\ the I_`.
".t"".='¢‘.'¥"r)t c¢:."xtt>‘t ;`-t't"'c. f.‘~.:‘.' h': had act ~; ‘.“- _;‘.i.'f~':»"ir.! ‘~.Ta ‘.t l*.'c :',  ;‘€""Q "
' :»c Couri cannot say that all d;,~:=nvzt~t".s r@,t)‘:="{i:txz _

 ‘3"~*‘“‘“"~‘~’~ ‘1"@'1`*““=`=‘~" 1116

t'»=~f»:'z;rlztzut had 110 authority or ca,;~:~.:it_\_' tc- :~=.:cc~“,:= ~--would bc `nv 3":'.! tt)  ‘im’t"~=::c "'<':1.}1¢1':'.;"».111.

 

("~"","t’s ()3~;~`11 .'~.t ()$.

articulated by the [)c."-“r.r!.'t‘*.l.
5. Q‘l:cr .`<>;7 Sf.`rv"_ei Itltg:`l_ltgg;_tt_;g _}_{g)<)_tt_sj`;<;:~:'.c': :":,"».')rt:, <.L. .

by Mt'. Kim from Apr`tl l, '2009, through june 1 1, 2009, which were clz=_":‘i!`)t~,d f s`:;‘ .

 

I‘:"".‘r‘.”»€d Ordc~r 1} '7. 'Ysc rc:ctu?.<;‘ is rmi limited 10 ?.ny ;~.~t.t cm ii singh cht:.‘.' `Fzd ct:tizt?" " t`iuv`t`:, ();;,'e tt :tt tt‘).
1149 /\..\:z.;tx:ztitt¢' t_ht; ;\;»;t~~~,%:-;t '~,'it-»vcd j::'~.t tt~: " );) .,S`t"":‘ rc;.»t)zts t:».‘h  "~»1`.,¢ _~,? \vt`-z't:
c*.;i_y;.: cn;:t)tnn; ‘~.~tl h_y t`ttt- "‘,;ti:ttdurtt`_¢, z`c~.quc.st, thc l)cf¢t‘f"t~:’.’.<; rc',: 1;="'. '»\tt>tttd include <»v';: 500
`I`t~p  t-I<:]~ '“':_

`» ~ ` ` - t 113 »‘ ' :zt_z§\=- '~ that the rt~,qztt;stc.ct 1.'"~'»:‘1.<: wt)ttltt *"` at tt~.zte;t h-.~t;,' 1] '.<.~ tht~ t".z"i~).~.<:
.`\ .:A

fm l'.~.''

this r':‘”,l:<~»~.f i.\'. s;‘r'*~:\A/t“.:~tt ':“.v»rc d`.‘.`t'tcult in ii:l'h'_ of thc t`rt)v't‘z'.“-,::tctt‘_`s "i',:zzr' 1‘;‘ ‘\‘n': ": -u c~f`

\)atxctl~.'_»~~ it jntt-~~_tz; m t "i"t ' c\-"t'it':\t:'.: of th: Dc{`<'t“."t:z:‘.'.’s in(\f§'.~'c. If` the (: “.-'< ~"-:~_‘:‘;t‘. §,'t'"" ‘.».“ m

;t""~t c\/tt.t"=  ct "‘ ~ D<:i"'~~'t.'txtt"s motive at triul. thc Gt»\/e:r:\::~r'nt :r~.:"t r)t)t§f`j‘ "!*'z l.>c"`-.:  :‘.»')

." tt) t'.t§<)\»\' t""' t);'z"cttc!" *’ s'.""":i“:‘tf t":z: to .~~"c’< ciisct~\'t";"' at least `;;c<};"t`~tt tt» tt;:` ~’  itt

z'cht I'.f.'z§; thc \'tt~\~. ':vz;u,rit’:: :~v:'-"` ::" ;~ ctt"trxoti\'t~_
 c (`r.‘\/ct':;'z.~~€`:» ‘1‘ 'tfti:~:' t”.:~.~'.::~t.~s' on thc ine:-_‘t:z»,issi':)ilitv :‘,' evidcrt<.:c of a c':~"f'"- t't“xt`s
1 .
"gt»t»<§ :=<;ts" t.=n ' "n.-r »_ ~.~::ztsiu:i¢ in ."'C‘cx~ to negnt.': c:‘i::)it:.'».t §nt':nt. Gc)v’t`s (`__\~_~>;~`n ,t‘ 'It»"` 't`,`:;‘

'1 xv

` .‘E'c' i~:,":-“\.~“f»::t'. d<». t‘-"T

Cut~‘ ur»§t 'tmis 'zr 1 Dct":nctz‘vtt tt) ¥~': making a dft"!`r:r,.‘::‘ :tr,'zt:.':’.ct't'.

c.<~'~.""t~;t tt\.zzt he is‘. cnt_i‘-_lt.~ti tn t')th.-r' 'I`;)p Sccr~t :'cj\<)rts in t`;'?r.~ to .'t:"*.'.')*..:'! .  10 t`*~r~ jury 1..?'“.‘

!~“"t\t."' h~.‘ did :-)<»t tti.:'!°. he '~'~'tst '.tr? have ctisc t:F».-r* .'t~.<‘_'rt~'=":" 10
Mr. t{¢¥f~r n R;xth;~i thc t)et`exxtt:tr:‘ argues that if thc Govc:'t:rtt:‘z'.“ suv_g.~'¢:st.s tca "': 'itt'.'j,' hit ne
disclosed "`5`~ 1 ~..=.ti.":'» 10 Mr_ Rc:‘,:z: in grdr~.r to c‘z::~ry i`ztvot' with Fu>; t\!;~.~»z~a ‘.t,c t')ctt;'\l~’t icr ;)‘/

l\~"* tl:utt ' '~':l;:» r:~:)t~tt.~: tl'.:at :J.»:l-; ;m\' a,“;~,:tt;t'n¢ <;<)zttt;;t ’itm ‘tt) this <1:1<‘ 'l`hc' l.,\c"':, 'l".'\f`s rc~.f`t:‘. to t"t"

;\'_-f`»;;~qi.-~ ‘ in _m~z;;z~.rins) t`<~,r his t'»"""xtoxzy, such ns other intclli;'z:»¢;e "_~y,~:'!=‘ c:r)n.".>:“:~.i11;'z l\‘““‘t"“

.».i-

`;` . "‘u, 'l`ht: l)t:.t`uztcl”‘,‘.’s sup ir.-'fti ': {luit `t"‘ nt':‘tls evt'.*jv 'l"'tp Sc" r'*t :~~j~'>~‘ F:: ":'.lf~r ") ',~t.'~;a:w':: ’~'>“

iti$ ?'"?‘l:"'\zt'\/ is t".".."i';ularlv 't:‘j\'.“"rt::."§'\'e in light ot` '.l" :t:t't.»')\  of di~"“v'\v'~.'~j) ":.':t lms bf.~_~»

provicl.';;‘ 10 the l`t:"""'~'l"-~:? z¢_;."'."ltng his work at ‘l.c l_‘.<"j*,:z'f:‘"cttt <=t` .‘lz..'<:. 'l `;t~ ;‘=z:".l» : ’ di.“c'~'.'»i~".'

crs';-.‘z';":\:~;l;‘"':t.~ ittt'lic:ttt‘.~: thc t`)t)\’t;n“"“‘:.":t l\,"' t":‘cititre:tl a "j,»:'"att.’."l“.‘;’f" .“-‘.` "'t'.‘ l".* ". ` .'l"ttit`x

_.:'~*?\"'.' un luis ll, ?.OO$), as vault us t""f.::?:t tr‘:.

rt»".'f':‘i‘»"* "»_:'~ r-'€=" f~’.‘t‘tz~te;lt::'.c‘.tl '~‘:"  .t ‘f.'~' t). - \~: l`f.::fl"nr’rz!'?’s
l)~»'§,t~:¢'ft"~.:"'tt ut` S‘t-".‘:: "t"§"~'=". Ne.t" ‘.vorl'_r‘.,t~‘.tion ¢<,r_-,p:;‘st' :;'::1 111‘;¢:1<‘~‘. ;t;‘j"§‘~.j’ ;`~~tv~ -'t_u_p_ugi 24,
2009 t‘::;t=~.tf~t: ()ctt)‘~'~.' l, 2009, and an irrxat;c of thc unc;l:».;:~it`tud t"'.':‘.“ri:xl C:: tl':‘ l`:t”;t'td.".','.‘.`s
l` ;"‘."»‘"cttt t)f l",ttcrgy l,zxn§'~:~ ll./l§:'l() l,h'_ t'j. I~`j'tr~».»c.y to )"t. l:~~.:)::lli l)./Z(l/ltl ',tr. G_ "l.'~_:'\.";y
fn A. I,t)\vcll. ln "fs coutc);t., the l":""‘t'lzttit falls to clcrrt_c\tt"tr.§t': "v:'tt ev  'T~s“ .'~`t :r:.‘! z _.'t;>i't

uc,t;c:.sc)n.~;, the C<)::"’ '~:"ix*."'~“ 10 z_\I?-'_r)l '.‘.:' f‘\~*lczz‘..'c>n 111 "xlalll<,»n:) "~»."cz»~

n ~1
l

1 :" |u_vc:cl l)j\' llu: l~~'.\=_z" ’\."~"~':l!. . n.~ (`.u\lx'i auili'z.c‘.s; Z‘“": \’.» '."\ni\§:>u ¢)3 1`:'\:\€ 1\:~‘~~ j~=-v:'.' 'l»'- ~ u.li:s,z`:""
ilml the '.~»:!`<~.:»rl::n! " '='a: ": '."')z) 10 l)cl§c~.vc ;"' "".~’?s.*."'*f?

_~ r' ‘ .

:<: cl‘..<=cuvcr:)bili\y of the broad ca‘.eg"~rics of docum:'xwls suu='_lz‘. 'l`z»'  =~ z .:‘ ".".ilc.al m
¢Z<~¢:‘)r.~*:=;';~ ll»:=.z rl'~~'r:z:*" :~;.' =;=:~~r~‘€ us a ":~'~.»‘r>zl f'»rcv_c)ry z~"';‘ r“’c~.  '\'=.:l ""‘ 1"" 10 " :
;_§-_:,"c:l.‘c with n  " m rlw clcn:~‘f~' c'r'\curr‘.ins‘ \.vhc~‘.l*.cr ’.‘=~ 'i':i"".“::‘..~‘»?~;)n “"":lazal 10 "':<‘ 1'» "»*/`"'~:
z "":n:~‘.<:. `l`l`»<~ !)k-"-,.-:i;xx'll xr'.';‘ l~r able 10 show that 'J~~“"_;_ ru'“=‘ ~§ »11.\; ha ~:F c»z) "1" :~"::zi~

l¢ nm:c|"»“~'r? :'."s mmi/rr sr_~r~l's clu<:‘.nncnts thin l')y dci'lr.‘f;<)x“. 1120 l)¢:‘"¢:'~.'l . ‘ could x:_"»‘.
acc‘.css` :xuc| (l\:‘r.~i"r):".~ _=:llull l)c dcnia:d_ T".xally_ ussf;zt“.;"" '."'<{uc'z').',.='::' 'l 711 the ‘ :l ~' '?'  <;¢)L\ld
" vw lhz~.l "l"t"aiz: 'l`np Sc~.¢‘"'~‘ v\"t">r$.~; rc\~ic\vccl by €‘1=»" l)efc\z'f`:z"xl ‘~  ~1 ,\.;~“i‘ l ¢z';d lime ll,
I`~'(‘)l>»l_ rlw ."=~ ’l~naizlnt`;: 1'<~,:]\1¢:);1. 36 l\~~:»""::'l_\’ Siz\r#rl ix nut limited €<) cl*~ ~`/.\v¢ ~z~"~lc r:.".fc:v*:;=l_ and is

‘ ,. .

 . ': dcné<:/\s<':‘ m 1)1~:!~!""* 1 m

Au a;n):'<>pri::ic (`:"_z':r rlc:co:w~~wa~l%es this Mc~z~.r)raxuluzn ();)"~::`r~~z.

. .,w./-\'/ . l - . ._
('I()I,lll' ?`:`\' K(!l.l,.»\l{ I~l(l'l`l`l ,l'.\’

wz~<"*:‘i= .'<'1‘_» " 533 zj~=.   11 :~'='l=

121

REDACTED l CLEARED FOR PUBL\C RELEASE