Court Opinion

ID: 2970008
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2015-09-22 16:02:05.936536+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:40:40.298152
License: Public Domain

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21
             3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

     (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU
                 )LOH 1DPH DS

81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6
               )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7
                 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

 &211,( ' *5$<                 ;
           3ODLQWLII$SSHOOHH   
                                  
                                     1R
            Y                    
                                   !
                                  
 726+,%$ $0(5,&$                  
 &21680(5 352'8&76 ,1&         
          'HIHQGDQW$SSHOODQW 
                                  
                                 1
      $SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW
    IRUWKH0LGGOH'LVWULFWRI7HQQHVVHHDW1DVKYLOOH
      1RVn5REHUW/(FKROV
                  &KLHI'LVWULFWsXGJH
                  $UJXHG0DUFK
           'HFLGHGDQG)LOHG$XJXVW
 %HIRUH.583$16.<%2**6DQG%$7&+(/'(5
                 &LUFXLWsXGJHV
                   BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
                        &2816(/
$5*8('  .DUHQ /& (OOLV %$66 %(55< 	 6,06
1DVKYLOOH7HQQHVVHHIRU$SSHOODQW0LFKDHO5D\sHQQLQJV
/HEDQRQ7HQQHVVHHIRU$SSHOOHH21%5,().DUHQ/&
(OOLV s 'DYLGVRQ )UHQFK %$66 %(55< 	 6,06

                             
     *UD\Y7RVKLED$P                             1R
      &RQVXPHU3URGXFWV

1DVKYLOOH7HQQHVVHHIRU$SSHOODQW0LFKDHO5D\sHQQLQJV
/HEDQRQ7HQQHVVHHIRU$SSHOOHH
                      BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
                          23,1,21
                      BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
   $/,&( 0 %$7&+(/'(5 &LUFXLW sXGJH  7RVKLED
$PHULFD&RQVXPHU3URGXFWV,QFDSSHDOVWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjV
GHQLDORILWVPRWLRQIRUMXGJPHQWDVDPDWWHURIODZRULQWKH
DOWHUQDWLYHIRUDQHZWULDOIROORZLQJDMXU\YHUGLFWDZDUGLQJ
WKH SODLQWLII EDFN SD\ DQG FRPSHQVDWRU\ DQG SXQLWLYH
GDPDJHV RQ KHU FODLP WKDW 7RVKLED KDG WHUPLQDWHG KHU
HPSOR\PHQWLQYLRODWLRQRI86&H%HFDXVHZH
KROGWKDWWKHSODLQWLIIIDLOHGWRDGGXFHHYLGHQFHVXIILFLHQWWR
VXSSRUWWKHYHUGLFWZHUHYHUVHDQGUHPDQGZLWKLQVWUXFWLRQV
WRHQWHUMXGJPHQWIRU7RVKLED
                  ,3URFHGXUDO%DFNJURXQG
   3ODLQWLII &RQQLH *UD\ ILOHG D FRPSODLQW DJDLQVW 7RVKLED
$PHULFD&RQVXPHU3URGXFWV,QFm7RVKLEDlRQ$XJXVW
DOOHJLQJWKDW7RVKLEDGLVFULPLQDWHGDJDLQVWKHUEDVHG
RQ KHU JHQGHU ZKHQ LW WHUPLQDWHG KHU HPSOR\PHQW  *UD\
DOOHJHG  VH[ GLVFULPLQDWLRQ LQ YLRODWLRQ RI  86&
Hm7LWOH9,,lYLRODWLRQRI86&DDQG
 DQG D 7HQQHVVHH FLYLO ULJKWV VWDWXWH DQG  D FODLP
XQGHU VWDWH FRPPRQ ODZ IRU DOOHJHG EUHDFK RI WKH GXW\ RI
JRRG IDLWK DQG IDLU GHDOLQJ  *UD\ DOVR ILOHG D FRPSODLQW
DJDLQVWWKH,QWHUQDWLRQDO%URWKHUKRRGRI(OHFWULFDO:RUNHUV
/RFDO1RDOOHJLQJEUHDFKRIIDLUUHSUHVHQWDWLRQZKLFK
ZDVFRQVROLGDWHGZLWKKHUFODLPVDJDLQVW7RVKLED
  7RVKLED ILOHG D PRWLRQ IRU VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW WKDW WKH
GLVWULFW FRXUW JUDQWHG LQ SDUW GLVPLVVLQJ 3ODLQWLIIjV  
FODLPDQGWKHVWDWHFODLPVDJDLQVW7RVKLED7KHUHPDLQLQJ
FODLPVZHUHWULHGWRDMXU\LQsDQXDU\RI$WWKHFORVHRI
WKH SODLQWLIIjV HYLGHQFH 7RVKLED PRYHG IRU MXGJPHQW DV D
PDWWHURIODZSXUVXDQWWR)HGHUDO5XOHRI&LYLO3URFHGXUH
1R                           *UD\Y7RVKLED$P         
                                      &RQVXPHU3URGXFWV

FODLPLQJ WKDW WKH SODLQWLII KDG IDLOHG WR SUHVHQW VXIILFLHQW
HYLGHQFH IURP ZKLFK D MXU\ FRXOG ILQG WKDW WKH QRQ
GLVFULPLQDWRU\UHDVRQSURPXOJDWHGE\7RVKLEDZDVDSUHWH[W
IRUGLVFULPLQDWLRQ7KHFRXUWGHQLHGWKHPRWLRQ7RVKLED
UHQHZHGWKHPRWLRQDWWKHFRQFOXVLRQRIWKHWULDODQGLWZDV
DJDLQGHQLHG
  7KHMXU\UHWXUQHGDYHUGLFWDJDLQVW7RVKLEDRQWKH7LWOH9,,
DQGDFODLPVDQGDZDUGHG*UD\ LQEDFN
SD\  IRU HPRWLRQDO SDLQ DQG VXIIHULQJ DQG
LQSXQLWLYHGDPDJHV7KHMXU\DOVRIRXQGWKDW
/RFDOEUHDFKHGLWVGXW\RIIDLUUHSUHVHQWDWLRQLQKDQGOLQJ
*UD\jVJULHYDQFHDQGDZDUGHG*UD\LQEDFNSD\
DJDLQVWWKHXQLRQ
   7RVKLED ILOHG SRVWWULDO PRWLRQV UHLWHUDWLQJ WKH 5XOH 
PRWLRQLQUHJDUGWRSUHWH[WDQGFODLPLQJWKDWWKHUHZDVQRW
VXIILFLHQWHYLGHQFHWRVXSSRUWWKHDZDUGRISXQLWLYHGDPDJHV
,QWKHDOWHUQDWLYH7RVKLEDVRXJKWDQHZWULDOFODLPLQJWKDW
WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW KDG HUUHG LQ VHYHUDO UHVSHFWV GXULQJ WKH
FRXUVHRIWKHWULDO7KHVHPRWLRQVZHUHGHQLHG7RVKLEDILOHG
DWLPHO\DSSHDORQWKHVHLVVXHV7KH8QLRQKDVQRWDSSHDOHG
                   ,,)DFWXDO%DFNJURXQG
  3ODLQWLII$SSHOOHH&RQQLH*UD\ZDVHPSOR\HGLQ7RVKLEDjV
/HEDQRQ 7HQQHVVHHSODQWIURPXQWLOsXQH
(DUO\LQsXQHRI*UD\DQGD7RVKLEDHPSOR\HHQDPHG
7DPP\/\QFKEHFDPHHPEURLOHGLQDQDUJXPHQWLQYROYLQJ
DQRWKHUHPSOR\HH3DP&KDSPDQDQGWKHFRPSDQ\jVSROLF\
RQDSSURSULDWHDWWLUHLQWKHZRUNSODFH7KHFRQIOLFWEHWZHHQ
*UD\ DQG /\QFK HVFDODWHG ZKHQ &KDSPDQ YROXQWHHUHG WR
*UD\WKDW/\QFKKDGEHHQFDOOLQJ*UD\DELWFK$FFRUGLQJWR
&KDSPDQ*UD\VWDWHGWKDWVKHZRXOGFRQIURQW/\QFKDQGLI
WKH DOOHJDWLRQV ZHUH WUXH VKH ZRXOG KLW KHU  &KDSPDQ
DGYLVHG*UD\WROHWWKHPDWWHUOLH
  7KHQH[WGD\DQRWKHUHPSOR\HHWROG*UD\WKDW/\QFKKDG
FDOOHGKHUDELWFK*UD\LQIRUPHGKHUDVVLVWDQWVXSHUYLVRU
sDFNLH+DUULVDERXW/\QFKjVGHURJDWRU\VWDWHPHQWVDQGDVNHG
     *UD\Y7RVKLED$P                            1R       1R                        *UD\Y7RVKLED$P       
      &RQVXPHU3URGXFWV                                                                                   &RQVXPHU3URGXFWV

ZKDW ZRXOG KDSSHQ WR KHU LI VKH KLW /\QFK  0V +DUULV                                    9
DGYLVHGDJDLQVWWKDWFRXUVHRIDFWLRQDQGVXJJHVWHGWKDW*UD\
VLPSO\LJQRUH/\QFK*UD\VRXJKWDVHFRQGRSLQLRQIURPsRH              )RUWKHIRUHJRLQJUHDVRQVZH5(9(56(WKHMXGJPHQWRI
&ROOLQV WKH 3ODQW 0DQDJHU  &ROOLQV DOVR DGYLVHG DJDLQVW      WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW DQG 5(0$1' WKH FDVH ZLWK LQVWUXFWLRQV
DWWDFNLQJ/\QFKDQGZDUQHG*UD\WKDWVKHFRXOGEHILUHGIRU           WKDWLWHQWHUs8'*0(17)25726+,%$
VXFKDQDFW
   %\PLGPRUQLQJKRZHYHU*UD\KDGGHFLGHGWRFRQIURQW
/\QFK UHJDUGLQJ KHU DOOHJHG FRPPHQWV  *UD\ WROG IHOORZ
HPSOR\HH$XGUH\'XNHWKDW/\QFKZRXOGQRWJHWDZD\ZLWK
FDOOLQJKHUDELWFK$FFRUGLQJWR'XNH*UD\WKHQUHPRYHG
KHUKDLUFOLSDQGHDUULQJVDQGSXWKHUKDLULQDSRQ\WDLODQG
OHIWKHUZRUNVWDWLRQ2QKHUZD\WRVHH/\QFK*UD\SDVVHG
sR\FH 0LWFKHOO 3HUVRQQHO 0DQDJHU DW 7RVKLED  *UD\
UHFRXQWHGWKHVWDWHPHQWVDOOHJHGO\PDGHE\/\QFKDQGDJDLQ
DVNHG ZKDW ZRXOG KDSSHQ LI VKH KLW /\QFK LQ UHWDOLDWLRQ
0LWFKHOOUHSHDWHGWKHFRPSDQ\OLQHLQUHJDUGWRKLWWLQJIHOORZ
HPSOR\HHVZDUQLQJ*UD\WKDWVKHFRXOGEHILUHGLIVKHKLW
/\QFK*UD\WROG0LWFKHOOWKDWVKHZDVMXVWJRLQJWRWDONWR
/\QFKWRGHWHUPLQHLIVKHKDGLQIDFWFDOOHGKHUDELWFK
   'XULQJWKHPLGPRUQLQJEUHDN*UD\DSSURDFKHG/\QFK
DQGDVNHGLIVKHKDGFDOOHGKHUDGHURJDWRU\QDPHDQGLIVR
LI/\QFKZDQWHGWRUHSHDWLWWRKHUIDFH$FFRUGLQJWR*UD\
ZKHQ/\QFKDFFHSWHGWKHLQYLWDWLRQ*UD\SXQFKHG/\QFKLQ
WKH IDFH EUHDNLQJ KHU JODVVHV DQG JLYLQJ KHU D EODFN H\H
7KXVYLQGLFDWHG*UD\UHWXUQHGWRKHUZRUNVWDWLRQDQGVDLG
WR&KDSPDQm,WROG\RX,ZRXOGKLWWKDWELWFKLIVKHDGPLWWHG
LWl$FFRUGLQJWRVXSHUYLVRU+DUULVZKHQDVNHGZKHWKHUVKH
KLW /\QFK *UD\ DGPLWWHG WR WKH DVVDXOW VD\LQJ m<HV ,
NQRFNHGWKH FUDSRXWRIKHUl*UD\ZDVGLVPLVVHGIRUWKH
UHPDLQGHURIWKHGD\
  7KHIROORZLQJGD\*UD\PHWZLWK/HRQDUG7\UHH9LFH
3UHVLGHQWRI*HQHUDO$IIDLUV0V0LWFKHOOIURPSHUVRQQHO
DQG 0DUJDUHW 0D\QDUG D XQLRQ VWHZDUG WR GLVFXVV WKH
LQFLGHQW$FFRUGLQJWR0LWFKHOODOWKRXJKWKHSODLQWLIIZDV
VRUU\WKHLQFLGHQWKDGKDSSHQHGDW7RVKLEDVKHZDVQRWVRUU\
VKH KLW /\QFK  0LWFKHOO UHFRPPHQGHG WKDW *UD\ EH
    *UD\Y7RVKLED$P                               1R       1R                            *UD\Y7RVKLED$P          
      &RQVXPHU3URGXFWV                                                                                          &RQVXPHU3URGXFWV

,G  2XU KROGLQJ LV EROVWHUHG E\ WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUWjV             WHUPLQDWHG EHFDXVH WKH DVVDXOW ZDV SUHPHGLWDWHG DQG WZR
FRQFOXVLRQ LQ 5HHYHV WKDW mD SODLQWLIIjV SULPD IDFLH FDVH        PDQDJHUVKDGZDUQHGKHUWKDWVKHFRXOGEHILUHGIRUKLWWLQJD
FRPELQHGZLWKVXIILFLHQWHYLGHQFHWRILQGWKDWWKHHPSOR\HUjV             FRZRUNHU7\UHHGLVFKDUJHG*UD\SXUVXDQWWR5XOH%RI
DVVHUWHGMXVWLILFDWLRQLVIDOVHPD\SHUPLWWKHWULHURIIDFWWR          WKH 3ODQW 5XOHV ZKLFK SURKLELWV mILJKWLQJ RQ FRPSDQ\
FRQFOXGH WKDW WKH HPSOR\HU XQODZIXOO\ GLVFULPLQDWHGl                SURSHUW\ ZKHUH WKH HPSOR\HH LV GHWHUPLQHG WR EH WKH
5HHYHV86DW                                                  LQVWLJDWRURUDJJUHVVRUl5XOH%SURYLGHVWKDW7RVKLEDPD\
                                                                          GLVFKDUJHRUVXVSHQGWKHHPSOR\HHIRUDYLRODWLRQ
  *UD\KDVQRWSURYLGHGDQ\HYLGHQFHWRVXSSRUWDFODLPWKDW
7RVKLEDjV SURIIHUHG UHDVRQ IRU KHU GLVFKDUJH ZDV QRW WKH             *UD\EDVHGKHUJHQGHUGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLPRQWKHIDFWWKDW
FRPSDQ\jV DFWXDO PRWLYDWLRQ IRU GLVFKDUJLQJ KHU  7KH              WKUHH \HDUV SULRU WR KHU PHOHH ZLWK /\QFK WZR ZRUNSODFH
HYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHGLQWKLVFDVHGLGQRWHYHQVXSSRUWDSULPD              DOWHUFDWLRQV LQYROYLQJ PDOH HPSOR\HHV KDG RFFXUUHG DW WKH
IDFLHVKRZLQJRIJHQGHUGLVFULPLQDWLRQDQG*UD\SRLQWVWR                7RVKLEDSODQW,QERWKWKRVHLQVWDQFHVPDQDJHPHQWHOHFWHG
QRWKLQJEH\RQGWKDWHYLGHQFHWRVXSSRUWDFODLPWKDW7RVKLED              WRVXVSHQGUDWKHUWKDQGLVFKDUJHWKHSDUWLFLSDQWV
UHDOO\GLVFKDUJHGKHUEHFDXVHRIKHUJHQGHUDQGQRWEHFDXVH
VKHGHOLEHUDWHO\SURYRNHGDILJKWZLWKDQRWKHUHPSOR\HH                                            ,,,$QDO\VLV
   $OWKRXJKZHDUHDOZD\VKHVLWDQWWRRYHUWXUQDMXU\YHUGLFW              $QDSSHDOVFRXUWUHYLHZVDGHQLDORID5XOHEPRWLRQ
ZH KROG WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW HUUHG DV D PDWWHU RI ODZ LQ   GH QRYR DSSO\LQJ WKH VDPH WHVW DV WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW PXVW
GHQ\LQJ 7RVKLEDjV 5XOH  PRWLRQ  7KH HYLGHQFH LQ WKLV          DSSO\.	7(QWHUV,QFY=XULFK,QV&R)G
UHFRUG LV VLPSO\ LQVXIILFLHQW WR SHUPLW WKH MXU\ HYHQ LI LW    WK&LU7KHPRWLRQPD\EHJUDQWHGRQO\LILQ
FKRVH WR GLVEHOLHYH 7RVKLEDjV DUWLFXODWHG UHDVRQ IRU                YLHZLQJWKHHYLGHQFHLQWKHOLJKWPRVWIDYRUDEOHWRWKHQRQ
GLVFKDUJLQJ*UD\WRFRQFOXGHWKDWWKHWUXHUHDVRQIRU*UD\jV             PRYLQJSDUW\WKHUHLVQRJHQXLQHLVVXHRIPDWHULDOIDFWIRUWKH
GLVFKDUJHZDVGLVFULPLQDWRU\7RDOORZDQHPSOR\HHZKRKDV               MXU\DQGUHDVRQDEOHPLQGVFRXOGFRPHWREXWRQHFRQFOXVLRQ
FRPPLWWHG DQ LQWHQWLRQDO SUHPHGLWDWHG DVVDXOW RQ DQRWKHU           LQIDYRURIWKHPRYLQJSDUW\,GDW
HPSOR\HHWRDYRLGGLVPLVVDORQWKHHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHGKHUH
LV WR VKLIW WKH EXUGHQ RI SURRI IURP WKH HPSOR\HH WR WKH          :H QRWH DW WKH RXWVHW WKDW DOWKRXJK *UD\ SURGXFHG
HPSOR\HU  $FFRUGLQJO\ ZH UHYHUVH WKH MXGJPHQW RI WKH            HYLGHQFHWRVXSSRUWDILQGLQJWKDWVKHZDVDPHPEHURID
GLVWULFWFRXUW                                                           SURWHFWHG FODVV  VKH VXIIHUHG DQ DGYHUVH HPSOR\PHQW
                                                                          DFWLRQ DQG  VKH ZDV TXDOLILHG IRU WKH SRVLWLRQ ORVW VKH
                                 ,9                                      IDLOHG WR SURGXFH HYLGHQFH WKDW D VLPLODUO\ VLWXDWHG SHUVRQ
                                                                          RXWVLGH RI WKH SURWHFWHG FODVV UHFHLYHG PRUH IDYRUDEOH
  %HFDXVHZHKROGWKDWWKHHYLGHQFHLVZKROO\LQVXIILFLHQWWR             WUHDWPHQWWKHIRXUWKHOHPHQWQHFHVVDU\WRHVWDEOLVKDSULPD
VXSSRUW*UD\jVFODLPRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQWKHLVVXHRISXQLWLYH             IDFLHFDVHRIJHQGHUGLVFULPLQDWLRQ6HH0DQ]HUY'LDPRQG
GDPDJHVLVPRRWDVDUHWKHGHIHQGDQWjVFODLPVUHODWLQJWRWKH            6KDPURFN &KHP &R  )G   WK &LU 
PRWLRQIRUDQHZWULDO                                                   FLWLQJ0F'RQQHOO'RXJODV&RUSY *UHHQ86
                                                                          7KHPDOHHPSOR\HHV*UD\FODLPVUHFHLYHGPRUH
                                                                          IDYRUDEOHWUHDWPHQWLQWKLVFDVHPRUHOHQLHQWGLVFLSOLQHZHUH
                                                                          QRWVLPLODUO\VLWXDWHGWRKHU7KLVFLUFXLWKDVKHOGWKDW
       *UD\Y7RVKLED$P                               1R     1R                           *UD\Y7RVKLED$P         
        &RQVXPHU3URGXFWV                                                                                       &RQVXPHU3URGXFWV

    WKH SODLQWLII PXVW VKRZ WKDW WKH mFRPSDUDEOHVl DUH             DILJKW)ROORZLQJWKRVHDOWHUFDWLRQVDQGSULRUWR*UD\jVILJKW
    VXEVWDQWLDOO\ VLPLODU LQ DOO UHVSHFWV     7KXV WR EH   ZLWK/\QFK7RVKLEDLQVWLWXWHGDVWULFWHUSROLF\WKDWSHUPLWWHG
    GHHPHGmVLPLODUO\VLWXDWHGlWKHLQGLYLGXDOVZLWKZKRP                WKHFRPSDQ\WRWHUPLQDWHDQHPSOR\HHLIWKDWHPSOR\HHZDV
    WKH SODLQWLII VHHNV WR FRPSDUH KLVKHU WUHDWPHQW PXVW          IRXQGWREHWKHLQVWLJDWRURIWKHILJKW*UD\UHVSRQGVWKDWWKH
    KDYHGHDOWZLWKWKHVDPHVXSHUYLVRUKDYHEHHQVXEMHFWWR             VHFWLRQV RI WKH UXOHV ZHUH PHUHO\ UHQXPEHUHG DQG QR
    WKH VDPH VWDQGDUGV DQG HQJDJHG LQ WKH VDPH FRQGXFW           VLJQLILFDQWFKDQJHLQSROLF\RFFXUUHG(YHQLIWKLVZHUHWKH
    ZLWKRXWVXFKGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJRUPLWLJDWLQJFLUFXPVWDQFHV              FDVHWKHUXOHVDVWKH\ZHUHZULWWHQDWWKHWLPHRIWKH*UD\
    WKDWZRXOGGLVWLQJXLVKWKHLUFRQGXFWRUWKHHPSOR\HUjV                /\QFKLQFLGHQWSHUPLWWHGWKHHPSOR\HUWRILUHDQHPSOR\HH
    WUHDWPHQWRIWKHPIRULW                                             ZKR LQVWLJDWHG D ILJKW  7KHUH LV QR GLVSXWH WKDW DOWKRXJK
                                                                          YHUEDOO\SURYRNHGE\/\QFK*UD\WKUHZWKHILUVWDQGRQO\
0LWFKHOOY7ROHGR+RVS)GWK&LU               SXQFK7KLVNLQGRIRIIHQVLYHFRQGXFWDSSHDUVWREHH[DFWO\
HPSKDVLVLQRULJLQDOLQWHUQDOFLWDWLRQRPLWWHG                       WKHW\SHRIDFWLYLW\WKH7RVKLEDUXOHVZHUHGHVLJQHGWRGHWHU
   +RZHYHUWKLVFLUFXLWKDVKHOGWKDWIROORZLQJDWULDORQWKH             *UD\ SUHVHQWHG QR HYLGHQFH ZKDWVRHYHU WKDW DQ\ RWKHU
PHULWV LQ D 7LWOH 9,, DFWLRQ mD UHYLHZLQJ FRXUW VKRXOG QRW     HPSOR\HHRI7RVKLEDHYHULQVWLJDWHGDILJKWDV*UD\GLGDQG
IRFXV RQ WKH HOHPHQWV RI WKH SULPD IDFLH FDVH EXW VKRXOG        UHFHLYHG OHVV VHYHUH SXQLVKPHQW  1HLWKHU LV WKHUH DQ\
DVVHVVWKHXOWLPDWHTXHVWLRQRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQl.RYDFHYLFK              HYLGHQFHWKDW*UD\ZDVGLVFLSOLQHGFRQWUDU\WRWKHHVWDEOLVKHG
Y.HQW6WDWH8QLY)GWK&LUFLWLQJ            UXOHVRI7RVKLEDDQGLQGHHGWKHHYLGHQFHGHPRQVWUDWHVWKDW
((2&Y$YHU\'HQQLVRQ&RUS)GWK&LU                 *UD\DQGRWKHUHPSOR\HHVZKRPVKHFRQVXOWHGDERXWKHUSODQ
  )RU WKDW UHDVRQ ZH FDQQRW VLPSO\ KROG WKDW WKH        WR KLW /\QFK ZHUH ZHOO DZDUH WKDW LQVWLJDWLQJ D ILJKW ZDV
SODLQWLIIjVIDLOXUHWRSURYLGHHYLGHQFHRIDQHVVHQWLDOHOHPHQW           JURXQGVIRUWHUPLQDWLRQ,QWKHDEVHQFHRIHYLGHQFHWKDWWKH
RIKHUSULPDIDFLHFDVHLVGLVSRVLWLYHKHUH5DWKHUZHPXVW             SURIIHUHG UHDVRQ KDG QR EDVLV LQ IDFW RU WKDW LW ZDV QRW
ORRN WR WKH XOWLPDWH TXHVWLRQnZKHWKHU WKH SODLQWLII KDV            VXIILFLHQW WR ZDUUDQW GLVPLVVDO WKHUH LV QR HYLGHQFH IURP
SURYHQWKDWKHUGLVFKDUJHZDVLQWHQWLRQDOO\GLVFULPLQDWRU\               ZKLFKWKHMXU\FRXOGEDVHDVXVSLFLRQRIPHQGDFLW\RQWKHSDUW
                                                                          RI7RVKLEDDQGQRHYLGHQFHIURPZKLFKWKHMXU\FRXOGLQIHU
   7KLV GRHV QRW PHDQ KRZHYHU WKDW SODLQWLIIjV IDLOXUH WR       LQWHQWLRQDOGLVFULPLQDWLRQ
SUHVHQWHYLGHQFHVXIILFLHQWWRPDNHRXWDSULPDIDFLHFDVHLV
QRW UHOHYDQW WR RXU UHYLHZ RI WKDW XOWLPDWH TXHVWLRQ  ,Q         7KDW OHDYHV RQO\ WKH VHFRQG 0DQ]HU RSWLRQnWKDW WKH
HPSOR\PHQW GLVFULPLQDWLRQ FDVHV LI WKH SODLQWLII SUHVHQWV          HPSOR\HUjVDUWLFXODWHGUHDVRQGLGQRWDFWXDOO\PRWLYDWHWKH
VXIILFLHQWHYLGHQFHWRPDNHRXWDSULPDIDFLHFDVHWKHEXUGHQ            GLVFKDUJH$VWRWKDWW\SHRIUHEXWWDOZHKHOG
VKLIWVWRWKHHPSOR\HUWRSURGXFHHYLGHQFHRIDOHJLWLPDWH
QRQGLVFULPLQDWRU\UHDVRQIRUWKHDFWLRQWDNHQWKLVEXUGHQLV              >L@I WKH EDUH ERQHV HOHPHQWV RI SODLQWLIIjV SULPD IDFLH
RQHRISURGXFWLRQRQO\QRWRISHUVXDVLRQ7H[DV'HSjWRI                  FDVHZHUHVXIILFLHQWWRPDNHWKLVVKRZLQJWKHHQWLUH
&PW\$IIDLUVY%XUGLQH86,IWKH                 µEXUGHQVKLIWLQJjDQDO\VLVRI0F'RQQHOO'RXJODVDQGLWV
HPSOR\HUGRHVVRWKHEXUGHQUHWXUQVWRWKHSODLQWLIIWRSURYH              VXFFHVVRUVZRXOGEHLOOXVRU\$FFRUGLQJO\ZHKROG
WKDWWKHHPSOR\HUjVVWDWHGUHDVRQLVSUHWH[WXDO,GDW,Q           WKDWLQRUGHUWRPDNHWKLVW\SHRIUHEXWWDOVKRZLQJWKH
6W0DU\jV+RQRU&WUY+LFNV86                    SODLQWLII PD\ QRW UHO\ VLPSO\ XSRQ KLV SULPD IDFLH
ILUVWLWDOLFVDGGHGWKH6XSUHPH&RXUWDIWHUUHYLHZLQJWKH               HYLGHQFH EXW PXVW LQVWHDG LQWURGXFH DGGLWLRQDO
%XUGLQHIUDPHZRUNGLVFXVVHGWKHIDFWILQGHUjVWDVNRQFHWKH                 HYLGHQFHRI>JHQGHU@GLVFULPLQDWLRQ
    *UD\Y7RVKLED$P                           1R       1R                         *UD\Y7RVKLED$P          
      &RQVXPHU3URGXFWV                                                                                   &RQVXPHU3URGXFWV

LQGLFDWHVWKDWWKHSULRULQFLGHQWVLQYROYLQJPDOHHPSOR\HHV           GHIHQGDQWKDVDUWLFXODWHGLWVQRQGLVFULPLQDWRU\UHDVRQIRUWKH
HUXSWHG VSRQWDQHRXVO\  ,Q RQH RI WKH SULRU LQFLGHQWV RQH   DGYHUVHHPSOR\PHQWDFWLRQ
HPSOR\HHKLWDQRWKHULQWKHNQHHZLWKDKDPPHUDVDQDFWRI
ZRUNSODFHKRUVHSOD\7KHHPSOR\HHZKRKDGEHHQVWUXFNGLG              7KHIDFWILQGHUjVGLVEHOLHIRIWKHUHDVRQVSXWIRUZDUGE\
QRW VHH WKH KXPRU DQG JUDEEHG KLV FRZRUNHU E\ WKH VKLUW     WKHGHIHQGDQWSDUWLFXODUO\LIGLVEHOLHILVDFFRPSDQLHGE\
$IWHURWKHUZRUNHUVLQWHUYHQHGWKHWZRFHDVHGKRVWLOLWLHVDQG          D VXVSLFLRQ RI PHQGDFLW\ PD\ WRJHWKHU ZLWK WKH
VKRRNKDQGV%RWKHPSOR\HHVZHUHVXVSHQGHGZLWKRXWSD\                 HOHPHQWV RI WKH SULPD IDFLH FDVH VXIILFH WR VKRZ
IRUWKUHHGD\VRQDFFRXQWRIWKHLQFLGHQW7KHRWKHULQFLGHQW          LQWHQWLRQDO GLVFULPLQDWLRQ  7KXV UHMHFWLRQ RI WKH
LQYROYLQJWZRPDOHHPSOR\HHVDOVRRFFXUUHGVSRQWDQHRXVO\               GHIHQGDQWjVSURIIHUHGUHDVRQVZLOOSHUPLWWKHWULHURIIDFW
ZLWKQRFOHDUDJJUHVVRU6RPHZLWQHVVHVFODLPWKDWDFWXDO              WRLQIHUWKHXOWLPDWHIDFWRILQWHQWLRQDOGLVFULPLQDWLRQ
SXQFKHV ZHUH WKURZQ ZKLOH RWKHU ZLWQHVVHV GLVSXWH WKLV          DQGWKH&RXUWRI$SSHDOVZDVFRUUHFWZKHQLWQRWHGWKDW
DFFRXQW                                                                XSRQ VXFK UHMHFWLRQ m>Q@R DGGLWLRQDO SURRI RI
                                                                        GLVFULPLQDWLRQLVUHTXLUHGlHPSKDVLVDGGHG%XWWKH
   *UD\ RQ WKH RWKHU KDQG DQQRXQFHG KHU LQWHQWLRQV WR         &RXUW RI $SSHDOVj KROGLQJ WKDW UHMHFWLRQ RI WKH
VHYHUDOFRZRUNHUV6KHDVNHGPDQDJHPHQWOHYHOHPSOR\HHV               GHIHQGDQWjVSURIIHUHGUHDVRQVFRPSHOVMXGJPHQWIRUWKH
LI VKH ZRXOG EH VXEMHFW WR GLVFLSOLQH IRU KLWWLQJ /\QFK       SODLQWLIIGLVUHJDUGVWKHIXQGDPHQWDOSULQFLSOHRI5XOH
$FFRUGLQJWRRQHFRZRUNHUVKHUHPRYHGKHUHDUULQJVDQG                WKDWDSUHVXPSWLRQGRHVQRWVKLIWWKHEXUGHQRISURRIDQG
SXWKHUKDLUEDFNLQDQWLFLSDWLRQRIDEUDZO7KLVLQWHQWLRQDO         LJQRUHV RXU UHSHDWHG DGPRQLWLRQ WKDW WKH 7LWOH 9,,
DQGSUHPHGLWDWHGFRQGXFWLVPRUHVHYHUHDQGMXVWLI\LQJRI             SODLQWLII DW DOO WLPHV EHDUV WKH mXOWLPDWH EXUGHQ RI
KDUVKHU GLVFLSOLQH WKDQ WKH FRQGXFW RI WKH PDOH 7RVKLED         SHUVXDVLRQl
FRPEDWDQWV
                                                                      7KH&RXUWZHQWRQWRKROGm,WLVQRWHQRXJKLQRWKHUZRUGV
   6HFRQGWKHUHFRUGGHPRQVWUDWHVWKDWVHYHUDOPDQDJHPHQW            WR GLVEHOLHYH WKH HPSOR\HU WKH IDFWILQGHU PXVWEHOLHYH WKH
OHYHO HPSOR\HHV KDG SXW *UD\ RQ QRWLFH WKDW VKH FRXOG EH    SODLQWLIIjVH[SODQDWLRQRILQWHQWLRQDOGLVFULPLQDWLRQl,GDW
WHUPLQDWHG IRU DWWDFNLQJ D FRZRUNHU  $OWKRXJK WKH PDOH      
HPSOR\HHVZHUHRQFRQVWUXFWLYHQRWLFHWKURXJKWKHFRPSDQ\
UXOHVnDQG FRPPRQ VHQVHnWKDW ILJKWLQJ RQ FRPSDQ\                    7KH6XSUHPH&RXUWKDVUHFHQWO\UHYLVLWHGWKHTXHVWLRQRI
SUHPLVHVZDVIRUELGGHQWKH\KDGQRWUHFHLYHGWKHVSHFLILF            ZKDWLVWKHSODLQWLIIjVHYLGHQWLDU\EXUGHQLQDQHPSOR\PHQW
ZDUQLQJV WKDW *UD\ KDG  0RUHRYHU WKH ZDUQLQJV *UD\          GLVFULPLQDWLRQ FDVH  ,Q 5HHYHV Y 6DQGHUVRQ 3OXPELQJ
UHFHLYHGFDPHRQO\KRXUVDQGILQDOO\PRPHQWVEHIRUHVKH             3URGXFWV,QF86WKH&RXUWUHIHUULQJ
SXQFKHG/\QFK                                                        WRLWVKROGLQJLQ6W0DU\jV+RQRU&HQWHU n WKDWLWLVQRW
                                                                      HQRXJKWRGLVEHOLHYHWKHHPSOR\HUUDWKHUWKHIDFWILQGHUPXVW
   7KLUGZHQRWHWKDW*UD\DQGWKHPDOHHPSOR\HHVDUHQRW            EHOLHYHWKHSODLQWLIIjVH[SODQDWLRQRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQnVDLG
VLPLODUO\VLWXDWHGLQUHJDUGWRWKHFRPSDQ\UXOHVLQSODFHDW         m,QUHDFKLQJWKLVFRQFOXVLRQKRZHYHUZHUHDVRQHGWKDWLWLV
WKHWLPHRIWKHUHVSHFWLYHLQFLGHQWVRUWKHUXOHXQGHUZKLFK         SHUPLVVLEOHIRUWKHWULHURIIDFWWRLQIHUWKHXOWLPDWHIDFWRI
HDFKZDVGLVFLSOLQHG7KHPHQLQYROYHGLQDOWHUFDWLRQVZHUH          GLVFULPLQDWLRQ IURP WKH IDOVLW\ RI WKH HPSOR\HUjV
VXVSHQGHG IRU YLRODWLRQ RI 5XOH & ZKLFK SURKLELWV          H[SODQDWLRQl7KH&RXUWZHQWRQWRH[SODLQWKDW
ILJKWLQJDQGDOORZVIRUGLVPLVVDOEXWGRHVQRWGLIIHUHQWLDWHDQ
HPSOR\HHZKRLVLQYROYHGLQDILJKWIURPRQHZKRLQVWLJDWHV
      *UD\Y7RVKLED$P                             1R    1R                           *UD\Y7RVKLED$P          
       &RQVXPHU3URGXFWV                                                                                    &RQVXPHU3URGXFWV

    3URRI WKDW WKH GHIHQGDQWjV H[SODQDWLRQ LV XQZRUWK\ RI      HPSOR\HHVSDUWLFXODUO\HPSOR\HHVQRWLQWKHSURWHFWHGFODVV
    FUHGHQFHLVVLPSO\RQHIRUPRIFLUFXPVWDQWLDOHYLGHQFH            ZHUH QRW ILUHG HYHQ WKRXJK WKH\ HQJDJHG LQ VXEVWDQWLDOO\
    WKDWLVSUREDWLYHRILQWHQWLRQDOGLVFULPLQDWLRQDQGLWPD\       LGHQWLFDO FRQGXFW WR WKDW ZKLFK WKH HPSOR\HU FRQWHQGV
    EH TXLWH SHUVXDVLYH 6HH >6W 0DU\jV +RQRU &WU      PRWLYDWHGLWVGLVFKDUJHRIWKHSODLQWLIIl,G7KHILUVWDQG
    86@ DW  m>3@URYLQJ WKH HPSOR\HUjV UHDVRQ IDOVH       WKLUGW\SHV RI UHEXWWDOVZHKHOGmDUHGLUHFWDWWDFNVRQWKH
    EHFRPHV SDUW RI DQG RIWHQ FRQVLGHUDEO\ DVVLVWV WKH       FUHGLELOLW\RIWKHHPSOR\HUjVSURIIHUHGPRWLYDWLRQIRUILULQJ
    JUHDWHU HQWHUSULVH RI SURYLQJ WKDW WKH UHDO UHDVRQ ZDV    WKHSODLQWLIIDQGLIVKRZQSURYLGHDQHYLGHQWLDU\EDVLVIRU
    LQWHQWLRQDOGLVFULPLQDWLRQl7KXVDSODLQWLIIjVSULPD     ZKDW WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW KDV WHUPHG D µVXVSLFLRQ RI
    IDFLHFDVHFRPELQHGZLWKVXIILFLHQWHYLGHQFHWRILQGWKDW        PHQGDFLW\jl,G,WLVWKXVFOHDULQOLJKWRI5HHYHVDQG6W
    WKHHPSOR\HUjVDVVHUWHGMXVWLILFDWLRQLVIDOVHPD\SHUPLW        0DU\jV+RQRU&HQWHUDVZHOODVRXURSLQLRQLQ0DQ]HUWKDW
    WKHWULHURIIDFWWRFRQFOXGHWKDWWKHHPSOR\HUXQODZIXOO\        ZKHWKHUWKHSODLQWLIIKDVLQIDFWSUHVHQWHGHYLGHQFHVXSSRUWLQJ
    GLVFULPLQDWHG                                                    HDFK HOHPHQW RI KHU SULPD IDFLH FDVH LV PDWHULDO WR WKH
                                                                      GHWHUPLQDWLRQ RI ZKHWKHU VKH KDV GHPRQVWUDWHG WKDW WKH
,GDWODVWLWDOLFVDGGHG                                   HPSOR\HUjVDUWLFXODWHGUHDVRQIRUWKHGLVFKDUJHLVQRWFUHGLEOH
                                                                      6HH5RKY/DNHVKRUH(VWDWHV,QF)GWK
   )LQDOO\WKH5HHYHV&RXUWH[SOLFLWO\KHOGWKDWLQHQWHUWDLQLQJ     &LU
D5XOHPRWLRQIRUMXGJPHQWDVDPDWWHURIODZWKHGLVWULFW
FRXUWLVUHTXLUHGWRUHYLHZDOORIWKHHYLGHQFHLQWKHUHFRUG           +HUH7RVKLEDDUWLFXODWHGDQRQGLVFULPLQDWRU\UHDVRQIRU
GUDZLQJDOOUHDVRQDEOHLQIHUHQFHVLQIDYRURIWKHQRQPRYLQJ           ILULQJ *UD\ QDPHO\ WKDW VKH FRPPLWWHG DQ LQWHQWLRQDO
SDUW\PDNLQJQRFUHGLELOLW\GHWHUPLQDWLRQVDQGZHLJKLQJQR           SUHPHGLWDWHGDVVDXOWRQDIHOORZHPSOR\HHDIWHUEHLQJZDUQHG
HYLGHQFH,GDW7KHUHYLHZLQJFRXUWPXVWXVHWKHVDPH         E\ VHYHUDO VXSHULRUV QRW WR GR VR  *UD\ KRZHYHU KDV
VWDQGDUG6HHJHQHUDOO\LGDW                                  SURGXFHGQRHYLGHQFHFDVWLQJGRXEWRQWKHFUHGLELOLW\RIWKLV
                                                                      DUWLFXODWHGUHDVRQ)LUVWWKHUHLVQRHYLGHQFHLQWKHUHFRUG
  7KLVFLUFXLWUHYLHZLQJWKH%XUGLQHUHTXLUHPHQWVLQOLJKWRI        WKDW*UD\GLGQRWFRPPLWDVVDXOWRUWKDWVKHZDVQRWZDUQHG
6W0DU\jV+RQRU&HQWHUKDVKHOGWKDWm>W@KHMXU\PD\QRW            QRWWRFRPPLWLW+HQFHWKHUHLVQRHYLGHQFHWKDW7RVKLEDjV
UHMHFW DQ HPSOR\HUjV H[SODQDWLRQ    XQOHVV WKHUH LV D    DUWLFXODWHGUHDVRQKDVQREDVLVLQIDFW6HFRQGWKHUHLVQR
VXIILFLHQWEDVLVLQWKHHYLGHQFHIRUGRLQJVRl0DQ]HU           HYLGHQFH LQ WKH UHFRUG WKDW FRPPLWWLQJ DQ LQWHQWLRQDO
)GDWHPSKDVLVLQRULJLQDO                                  SUHPHGLWDWHG DVVDXOW RQ DQRWKHU HPSOR\HH KDYLQJ EHHQ
                                                                      ZDUQHG QRW WR GR VR LV QRW VXIILFLHQW WR ZDUUDQW GLVFKDUJH
    7R PDNH D VXEPLVVLEOH FDVH RQ WKH FUHGLELOLW\ RI KLV     XQGHU7RVKLEDjVUXOHV*UD\FODLPVWKDWVKHSUHVHQWHGWKLV
    HPSOR\HUjVH[SODQDWLRQWKHSODLQWLIILVUHTXLUHGWRVKRZ         HYLGHQFHnWKDW LV HYLGHQFH WKDW VLPLODUO\ VLWXDWHG PDOH
    E\ D SUHSRQGHUDQFH RI WKH HYLGHQFH HLWKHU  WKDW WKH   HPSOR\HHVZHUHQRWGLVFLSOLQHGDVVHYHUHO\DVVKHZDVnDV
    SURIIHUHG UHDVRQV KDG QR EDVLV LQ IDFW  WKDW WKH     WKHIRXUWKSURQJRIKHUSULPDIDFLHFDVHEXWLWLVFOHDUIURP
    SURIIHUHGUHDVRQVGLGQRWDFWXDOO\PRWLYDWHKLVGLVFKDUJH        WKHUHFRUGWKDWVKHGLGQRW
    RUWKDWWKH\ZHUHLQVXIILFLHQWWRPRWLYDWHGLVFKDUJH
                                                                        7KH HPSOR\HHV *UD\ VHHNV WR FDVW DV VLPLODUO\ VLWXDWHG
,GDWLQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQVDQGHPSKDVLVRPLWWHG7KH          GLIIHU IURP KHU LQ VHYHUDO LPSRUWDQW ZD\V  )LUVW WKH PDOH
ILUVWW\SHRIUHEXWWDOZHVDLGFRQVLVWVRIHYLGHQFHWKDWWKH        HPSOR\HHVjFRQGXFWZDVGLIIHUHQW0RVWVLJQLILFDQWO\*UD\jV
UHDVRQVJLYHQE\WKHHPSOR\HUVLPSO\GLGQRWKDSSHQ,G             DVVDXOW RQ /\QFK ZDV SUHPHGLWDWHG ZKHUHDV WKH UHFRUG
7KH WKLUG W\SH mRUGLQDULO\ FRQVLVWV RI HYLGHQFH WKDW RWKHU