Court Opinion

ID: 4065840
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 22:16:38.659622+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:26.742896
License: Public Domain

'
Yo~ THE CL&.k OF,
~-OF CR IMI/\Jid_ ~"1--PPEI\L$ DF'Tet~ts
AtJsn:-J,TK.

                                                                                       AI V' -f
                                                                                                     ~   0 t"\1"~"
                                                                                                           L"d t!:l
                                                                                       f';\J\J                iJ '.,

                        -A 8buT        lt-l£ -eND or M !«       T GENt A Lbbtlret@o/f!V8f5t:::CJW~'­
             w·ifleti   r    JNCWDc:-(;); t,      A Mcmc:N Po~ MAJtAJ7XA.£tJI or-           CeJVIJ5CL

         d~'~t#LLY FtLEb IN z_q"!l:!: DfSTJelcr ~T, P:ALo PiAlTZJ,                                       co-vNl'(,
     . T-E~ ~N ~BER JlTiir Ztllttft=XitiBfiAii); Z; 17»o (z,) L£TIER6
         "                                                                    ,. h     "'       ;J                .
         ID Tt-lt 1\&N£ .NAN£J) ~T ~K£1)                           G><.ttiB'iTS (5 ."\NN    c    I

           f· ~et-ER. ·RectTVEO -N,k/'JOWLEObblvt&JT ll{AT lifm P.-4C~e tfA.D
     16' ££N RfC..£1 veD BY Y oV f( OFf=1 C£ M Wti-11 AC/l ON MI\S E-£J9V
     mk"b\.1 RaARD WG TliE MOll o-tJ ,
                l1if        ~\'f(iE   GODN6EL FOR Ol-i=END£~s 11\l ~o ME IHA-1 "fouR..
         ~- .AMJ2)\- (JR_l')ER.. Tt:tt ~OI,rJTMENI eri=-COU!J.S-EL                FOR w~ ~~ DF
         'HAB£1\~ COI<-Pvs               c;;NJ   AA'(   PAR.nwLi\1<. cAS£    ~ (E;AA~, c; lllci~s)

               I_ NV\ UNABL£ 1D                  ~TI'\1N DOLUJA.£JJT.S ID 5UtPoR..r- MY CLA/111(,
         Wlt!d-\        {S   TRUE /\f..J.6 W65TAIIA-L 1 l?fHJt; f\ \JiDL..-A1lo.tJ o-F l=DVRTH
         ·M'ltNOMEJJ-1 -PR.cllECt\ ONS PROJ!f)E:{) ISY THE. Co.NSTlllFTlON
         CF lliC UNfTt:D S~Tt:s B'JL.L DP Rl6+tl5,
                  f\i£ U.S.           SUFREM-E ~T Mt\~ RUL£f> THAT tN.Di~t)JT,!l\IC{V(cG(?-
         t\1tb          DE.fEN~          Rt:blvvRf: cov.Ns.-c:L- Fr>R wR rr rrF      f+A&A~ CDR:Pv~f

         Tt\eRE:FbR.E T                tv   N1JT' W/\NTlD PRCC££t>, PRo S£ 1 0N f\ NEW
         -~                 a«Ns. PRa::-EED\NG               B'AS£.D 6V'J NEW RULftJG:.:, MD
         Lt\'W OCCO~\~~                 Af1=1::k. .NV'{ O'Rl61fJ,Al_     ~flJCftTIDN                     FoR.,
         WRtr OF ·t-h\IS£1\:;               ~RJ;         ,
     I i-IA\It:       v..J~\TIBJ         !MNY    i\~J£Y.s .AtJD L£.6i-AL .A\~ 0R®fZ1nflJS
   AND      gt£rJ utJ E0tc£~sf=VL- OB IAt!J W6 R'-Ef'~::ENTATlDAI ON f"Ro BD.\.V
    &A~ iS     1
                    f~o PftR. NON~ HAvE t{-Ab Tltf FRDF"£SSit>tJ.PxL C.:?JVRT-£6 y TD
    2V£N           RE~PO!Ji)        lV )/JQVIRY.
            IS ll-!~R£ A Rf:CJ){<D I CAJJ D«!A:\N Ff~M YD?)R. Qi2tzt.C.C: OF AU-
     FiLl Nl1 ~ BY .Mt.. M·D Ttl E. STAW S oF 11+£/V\ , . -ALL DJ2 ;vV( Affi_tCf\110JJ .S
     RJwc: B'EEJJ'' DctJ t&t> wtTttouT w~ trreJ R£cerR. t>'' wLntiiur /'\JJY 6DR..r-
     Otcr E><Pr-At-JffOVJJ vJ H'{J 'lHA-T l /11\ t 6. hfT U>te..f<.t-CT Pn'ri&L&VLS bR.
     Et<.P.~s, ,
        It~ 11-!(6' {('lf-TN.ICE: i PAl-O PtN!D ~ 1¥ CAUr:c- 1Lf72L -A, 1
      ffkJe A         CL-f\-IM THAT l{fO ALI<EkPY                 St&J CA6e;5 CN2fC.~tJE.D t ....J
     't'oVR CDt>RT'            l), S·.   D\s*\    CT     ~ M            .D -n-i£   51)f>R8V\-~ CDt.he-T     FoR.
      \ 0£Nl1c.AL Gtr<:d)M 5\1\1\JCCS                I

           ..f     CAJJ N-OT Ul'-l!)t;R£1Mb trJttY .1 AM t-tMlNb. St) MDCli DIPF-tCLU'{

      OBTr\\".!NG R£~;                     t Gtlou..D 1\1-crr-     16t. RE-b(Ud"2tO    w    tU~t:: D5VJV6£L

      Wtif.N       nit 19\ LJtT      t:-l-E S   c-tnrt Ttf.£ bl'-:ffi:C AN I) r"ts ii-At-J DL W6. Of' .N\ t ,
       N~ C:A1..J      :r   wr=v~\) o-N£ ,

J¢: 1 \~i( 7 9, q{p(p -ofp
 ()RJ6!NM- ~Tf?,_.~c.!411o-N