Court Opinion

ID: 4050149
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:10:19.648325+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:05:05.625765
License: Public Domain

'

. Yo~ 'TiiE C.L~I< CJFr                                                             IAtVl~ 6£)C'{[),\} ; 7 'g7 so 3
                                                                                    KDBtKrs.&.!J LVJt(
CfW{-()P CR!MII\1-Al i'\-f>PE!\L$ oP7f:fAs                                          t'Lo7t F. .All. -:ss z z
Atlsn tJ, TK.                                                                AS;~ffi~{~lN .
                                                                           COURT OF CR!r.,~!~J.b:L AW!!AtS

                                                                                          AUG 10 2G\S

                        -A 8DiJT   IH£ t5ND       or MltY J   ~wl A LEltJtettrko/~pf:GJfif~'·
             WtftcH I     fNC.W()£-Cl/   1..   A MOT!c;N FV~ MPoti.J7'!U£rJI         (J-F CoV1J5£L

            6~1 ~ INA--LLY FtLEb IN z__q!!!: Dlf:>lR tcr Ce:Jl)I<,T, (-;:ALo P ji\JTZJ, covNf'(,
            TE'XP!5 &!\l ~BER ll~r 2e!lctjE:Xit1BfiA~);                   Z;        1Wo (z) L~nER6
            ..                                                            ,.   /)      . ....     ;J
            lo THE. 7'\&w£ .NA!v't.D Co-UYGT ~KED tSXtHBiT5 8 .A.-1-.tD                         C ,

          · t tJet-ER. ·RectrVE-D NktJDWLEOb£M6NT 11\A-T TffAT P4L~e tf-MJ
        16£fN R(CEi v-eD gy YoVf< Crr-f=-IC£ M Wtir-11 ACflrJN HAS 'f5f'PJ
        D1.-IC'-eN      R~D w-G       Tli·t:_ MOTl o-tJ ,
                 11fE   ~\'t'fit; COVN6EL      FO-R   ~-A9J()£~S   11\J FoRN\E)~ MS l){.A--1 "iDv~
            ~- MV5T C]Rt£R 1ttt ~ouJTMSJio-t=-c.ou~ls-EL FoR v\h~                                      tr- DF
            'RABfA-~ COI<-~s (:)HJ JA'( PAR.nwt..L\R: CAS£ ~ (£M~, s. uit:i~s)
                 I. AM Uf'Jl'\BL£ 10 0-&TAVJ DOLUM-EtSrs 1D               5atPo-R-r- MY                  CL/tflv(j

            NttiC-C-\ {S TRUE- A.f'Jt W65TNTIA-L 1 E'flN~ A \/IDL!BlcvJ OF I=DVRrn
            J\IV!fN OM8JT PR£11EG!\ ON _s P RCN pl)&D ISY TH £ CoN sn TU7l otJ
            OF TtfC UNilc D SII\-1£:-S B'IL-L OF R 16+t13.,
                  jt\£ U.S, 6\JfREMt: Co.ltR..T MA~ RUL£t> Tt\AT /N.Di~DJT,ll\lC~cGR'-
            tUtt DEFENtAN\.5 R£blVJ~ COVN$-El-
                            .
                                                             FOR   wR t\ uF ffA~~ CoR:Pvsfi

            Tt\ef<tfbR.E    T      Co tJ7Jl W~NT TD         f>R ~ 1 PRo SE 1 D-N f\ N£W
            ·~ Q/Rf:VS. PRo:B:.DING 151\5£1) (')lN NEW RULrtJG5,                                         MD
            Lf\W' occu£<\~~ A-Ai:k.              fv'\N O'Rl611JAL    ~Pi..JCI\Tlr9N                    FoR.,
            WRit"" oF ·Nt\£5£1\5 Ce!R:A:J~,
        I         tiA\Jt" v-J~\llBJ .JV\AN'Y A-~JtY.s .A~D L£G:rAL .AlP oRttw.rZAnD\lS
   ANt> g££JJ utJ EDCL£~srvt- e£ lA\~ \Al6                                                       R-EP~$0TATIDAI oJJ PRo BD.'JZJ
   &MiSt. 60 Pt\R. NON~ tfAilE:tMbTH£ FRDF£~SIDN.f\L Cf;V.Rl£6Y TV
   2V£N               RE~PotJI) 10 )A}QUIRY.

                   IS ll-i[R{ A Rt:tbR.D 1_ CAN ~A\N Ff~tv\ YD!)R Qt?P:t.C£ OF fttL.
         FiLitJG5 B'l .ME. J\N·D TtlE. STA11JS oF l1t£/V\. ALL DP JvV'/ APfLtcAikW.S
       RJ\VC: B'EEJJ'' Dt=tJtE:-b WtTt"\OUT W-R lTTEN R&:etR.D 1' W lt1iVDT 1'\N"f 6DR.\
       Off E?Q1:..f\!~A1Joj.J VJ tP(J .!HAT X M \6. L{T. u~t<tcr P{<(.~l£Nls tJR.

       ox:~~~~                       INGINJCE I                   Fl\l-0          P!Nm     ~              1'{.   CfitJOE 14'12'2._ -A,   1
         ffMf A Cl:ftiM THAT liM                                            ALk~i.( S-££N                 CA6ES      ~ TV-R..tJE.D \..~
       ......;,
            lO"!JR
                     f'"'    n-
                     1...-Vl)~'--\    ,.
                                            l) {'    ('...
                                              , ::> ·. JJ
                                                             -,~~~:1-R. \ c;-l·   /' """ tbTz
                                                                                  vuvn...-\ :>
                                                                                                 M   j)   lti£ 6t}f>{( 8V\E coveT FD~
            \ ()CNllCAL CtR(L)M 5TAI-JC£5                                     I

                  ._f CAJJ N-OT UN[)f~b                                            vJtr/   .1 AM HMtNG St' MDcti DIFFtClJU'(

            0011\\t-JtNb Rf~;                          t G·HoUJ) N-tiT 15t. RE-!QDIQC;t) W tHR-t. CW1'J6tl
          WrtfN nit                  19\ uu- t;...(-E s c-trrtt ·11f£ bl'~ M ~ rrs ii-At\l DL W~ Of' N\ ~ ~
            N~ C:At...t         1          ftFh;~t> O-NE ,

R£ ; \~i( 7 9, q(p(p -ofp
 DRl6rf'lJd_ !rfP,...~r,.~CNJ .