Court Opinion

ID: 4039042
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:04:12.810127+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:02:00.771864
License: Public Domain

I                 o                         ­
                              CauSe. NO: 22../53 - 2o/<}

    .5+a~(l   of It'XQS                 x         'To   ,tie: VO~ Nd
                                                                          ",

       -- V,j­                                   JudI cie6thLCOURT
                                                               FILED IN
                                                              DiSffllC.t   cc.c..uc+
                                                                   OF APPEALS
                                                             TEXARKANA, TEXAS
ChR./0foph~R LyNft.I f/CI{fZSll                  Woo D CouNt       Y "T(lxaS
                                                       1/5/2015 1:37:15
                                                                      I
                                                                        PM
                                                             DEBBIE AUTREY
                                                                Clerk

      !Yeti ce of         8ppeQ L
                                           ~ohLe          of lippe-at
                                                                                                                            Il
                                                                                                                            1

 A) .I I\fVti L datu!            cit,·{'ec 1, Vf;? ~ Nc/I 'ctlVl e fI(   +                                                  I
                                                                                                                            t
             1l-t1i Np.t-/le I      W(JS   INdle.. +ed ulYdell .IS CHfl..;:s-fuf/(PIl tYN/V IfA tf Sf2
                          ,
 ANt::)   fV!V   ("i me JS        Cfltzislofltt!'((. Lyl'} n H" 1£ Np.f-         -5fl...   NoR. #Ils.s:-+ eW!rL Bt::dl'n.

       Aioll J/pvf:Z 'i!V-en. BeeN coLl./lc/ Sfl- j\1l1 60f)1~ Nat'Yle:t:s Cltfl.i5\-cJptten                                I
                                                                                                                 .
NO r\I*,~ f..1lt Ni\Y\.1.e CAN ..b~ -" cl7rr:.t.s{op Het2 Ltf fAIN HAI~ -5 ~ So -+He -INdl<.::tMerrt
                                                                                             <

.::r:: WAS.I rc+ed LlflIdf"Q..             ZS IN VALId 1\""'0                def~c.+I·ve, :x de;      UNcfftt0{f\J\J.D      I
J:N:

-\<)
         ~ ~"Tl" Or f"FX.f\~ X-N 111-~ (.Dt)Q T 0 ~ LAw AN :r:r~d (c. +M1Z(V+ 1-\4\.S
       fle~d·t Vf?.I IVII-\cle +;~i.s poiNT 7bMf/ LAntl/en. f...1Atlk JAletJt/lfl buf vvrttt
                                                                                                                            !
l-Hs   -twE'=V0 cf/ve t}~+.sJ..At'll.Q (~oo5e Not- to (o12f2.€c-t 11Iis I\1~Hfl'It,

                                                                                                                            I
                                                                                         Q                                             \

ON -t1\-e       ' Q..d I\-t\~",\p\- ot GAl\.~"9 \-\UV'\ H-e                I\NSWt;;I2ci. .I:- If\14-olZ     ~1t.o Mn. W£t.t~rz
                       ~~rOiNiit:.o (DUNt:>\:L­ H-~ 6OI{J ,i " ti~ YVM UNAWA.e€                       0   F Tftf' F1\c-t.:r

M Y(~6f" an I 1\ flit f\. \via. \\IF nE'rt /\IE' V!'>1l -5!\owtD                  Uf   ""'¥) M~    f\ 1I.YL I\r g ""10   N+ d A~\
CON1€"   clod          i\~d    I.-\.(Ii-\\­ NO 1Ai6tO   ~vLOrvl   1'\f1. VL,   V\{~l tta..   , -So MVl.   \'\1t\-lc.~n   {ook..· \-t

                               (\,\v\u     A   ~l.-t~   c>"\N.O   dld          Not C.ONsul"T !VIE OQ.. 'V1Ct\L ME:­
A Lc·H-£ (~        0    I-b:s .p \~(\l~.   :::n   He­ -\ 00"-   ~\~ \.)~w,.\ t\i ~ ~\f                v,II\V1OU\-    M,--\
J::ru:. WIt:'dqE   Of/...   CO w:.t NT,    W 101 XJ I     N     '1\ t: 6U',re a V~K....s CQ/ ~ci 40"'3" 11. '1
                                                                                                                            CI 
                                                I
                                                                                                                                                                                I
                                                                                                                                                                                I
!     M   ~ AIZJtAJ:~            ME: NT.      DUll Ii;, it LIl5J-ec/ 30.... MW! u-iS • Itt                         ~I<.ecl ,. fCc>~" -t\\\v'lC].SA: ~ 0 ~ M" I~.·
I (qse          4Nd                  qAve J.Ji,.,." A1~ WltNf&:> fhoNC ()uMb~e~ ok> "-'\'1 ~'-Olt_                                              \         ~                     j

I P'U5eN-I~. pAppeR                                      I"IOfti:   ",..d          Leflwu -1-1111-+      6i10W+AV()It'~ M~                          bR 11 " If c    ~           I
i .;iN~O~" ·c.e                              ANd         IJ~ -s1-I>1-ed off(.4t                 'fOil NlE.j-.,        Hold Oil(     .j()   iVl'1 f"'fpe tt        liven.!::.    I
I' r
l
               SfAtFcJ '/-h"f:r INFf,yfeci                             +v           .:lee    p,-S(o"<2I1.~ .p.q.Llaf.        It<: OA.d! 'ite t"/c,()/d 130'/1119                !i
                                                                                                                                                                                [
I ;f WIIJ.I A                        i<leo of Wt 6fp,j'ElVlerv+ ~PrI"'5f                                       Me        ~ follovv\rvg 'AI-el?k·                                t
I
I
       Nfl      .VII!:I              m      did f\/(J-i-            5tlo~" +/it t:o/low,n1 w~. r                                        Col/eel bHs PNJNIZ                ON    I
                                                                                                                                                                                ,
I severaL             a ertJp-ls bL(1 Na                             ANS\t\ltl2. A1R Wt: It1:fl-,                       tiNct 1\.,' ~l-l()\J\.le£) a
I .i.
!

,
          /,\10N+t) I d--              Ltcttf?n. vu./44f()LII- Ols((N.('llc_;                     pacJ_~-I- aNc/            1\10   Vtdrzo. Hesf-tt/fl'dfHAl

I!. r.                                                                 .:5J~P-I£' fvtvN i:                                              ;"'+   Mil. WeI k:~

I·   f!.A-{J
               cou£dAi

                'Fi:i.il:u . +0
                                     dee    fife II/cieo

                                            f\'IA-tt AWC{            A~f~NlP+ -to
                                                                                                      {tl\lP

                                                                                                   (O",.J-f+(,t
                                                                                                                  A+ -tHiS f
                                                                                                                      AtvV o·¥'
                                                                                                                                    O

                                                                                                                                   '\1~    1tV/+",qs.s    OIlU:   Jl1l1
                                                                                                                                                                                I
!
I heHAlh .t:t
                             i
~                            i                       I                 .......-.     •

                                      tH..t:j !tf\1& 1\.1y             +AMt/y                Made 5e'veral                  AHernfi5        to CONf.Acl-
I    Mfl WEIIt£i/.. MID ",,;.).Ne6S. Mit. weltell. 5-k1hd                                                  1\~'1       Mothel/      ~VI\5,. ~e lIe",c
                                                                                                                                                           "
                                                                                                                                                                          A

      'bt+CH      t-otL              AII;N~ Hil'V) l~lT,( '''19                A          M&s:)a.q~ ·.f.£If 11\1 ""UM r. F HE dldJJf do \-..\)~

      JOb 1\$        "lll.           {o14flf!!:l!L       .;sUtz WAS          q()f\lf'lA         CALc.. -Hre '"&OOf'd               eN   \41""', -1\+ '\"i\\~   (\I\'f!e- H"'9
      MVl \JUtlcell.                 ca"'ltZ hiH#            A      ~{eA TR-otv\ '~e [).A. eVeN AJ'-k-fl Si~+e"\iq beR £A2 

                                                                                                                                                           '
     ~A~ I 
                     .    NC)t     Mt\~U\l'9 "N~                       p/EFU. HP a.qO'hY               5~t-'ed         PtS I{.e     did ~+-+t\-t
                                                                                                                                                                                I
      Ll\St      (vree+ N9 He 'v"dulc/ f2':e~(trJ ~tt~e f\iVjl.. t                                        i/..If'(?   t ,

                                                                                                                                                                                I
                             I
CpfW-\ 't#              Z1f;of   c)                                                                                               I!
 Cc)                   ,WtJII<Ftl      NfeVett R6tv(l.flUlc/ A.VVd           T d,dNt HeAl?.             -t1l()f'\I\ HiM   o+-
 f\LL    UN#L          :r   MAde c( plea                 .Jo   J"Z,dqq Doswell ab6U+ 1'111l.\i\lfltetc
                                                                                                                                  iI
:t:;J~'f.(e(,hv(lnes5, J:N th~l5e                      NU:>l\th.s "'1rt 'v\#!/K:ea r/t'cI N(".ll     Aru'5Wef{   (\fl~ photJ~
                                                                                                                                  t
Cqlls tJOtL            \(1 ~~ CAli AW,          of VV1~ t\ltttJe~, La.Jle- dlCl r                  tN()W /\1 fl. Welkef(

 w~ Not-               wonbvJ         ON rv1..~ CA~~           A-i- A\l tl2cause         ::c.   \eA~rJed 1\.1rt We lk'ee          I
                                                                                                                                  I
 \A/ft!> Wort 1t-J'9 dN           ticS'    ON    p~bl€1Vt5        0+    br::t~9 f\i.J1tsted ~t CAtll~ ~hu6e

V\Ji(~    \M\-l.         ~elJ asblcl            b\.{    fV1~-+O   1'-11t.lt\mlt:'erL    WelLe -HA\f€ <-t0c) be~",     p,.,rltct
                                                                                                                                  I
                                                                              ~
                                                                                                                                  r.

VVII-'i
    .
          "",+.i.t          ,\\lLl bel! /J C+-l ho.j           "''1 W'{N e             IIrt S+p..-te cI I<hz r-i Ad Ht:Atl,j      (
                                                                                                                                  t
                   ~                   ~                                                                                          I
    1S5~~ W ic t+             H.e L, Pel.
                                                                                                                                  f
                                                                                                                                  ~

                                                                                                                                  tf
                                                                                                                                  I
                                                                                                                                  1

                                                                                                                                  I
                                                                                                                                  I
                                                                                                                                  I
                                                                                                                                  I
                                                                                                                                  f
                                                                                                                                  I
                                                                                                                                  I
                                                                                                                                  i
                                                                                                                                  l

                                                                                                                                  I
                                                                          \   .
                                                                                                                                                       I
                     eNlaL of~f(iC+IVf AssistANce of (oul,-,seL

         AaoQdlNy             -fo     ffle !5 f11 il"}oi loT'! ANitro/l1fl(Jn+                      ""'/> Ou~               f(l.oa sS C LflUSl:        I
:t::   Ht'Wl    I   Il   ~(QHt f6 ~4+Cd-ive Ilssis+I\IIfCt oF CouNSeL                                         iN      M~       tAl/Oft.      f\Nd      I
~'l~. v..lFlu        W-P6,     No~      'N     q::-~fjvt   OlL   c1 id C:Mu, +\bout f\-t~ \Nf!LL bQ.''''9 at I h rz                                    ,.'
CAVl£ct A:          0\ W~S ~Nq O~.+ 6+ ur\k:tett "'1.~ C.'~s-e :It.l ~l"s-e                                                   1iw       I\1ol\.:\tks     .

                                                                                                                                                       t
                                                                                                                                                       i
(00\2+-6 lc>i 1ptA iNlt'9 4\\)6v.r ~.I\ Q - WE lke~ Awo '1: dlCAtf ((4.-/ "-t'ly n..eSPON012
                                                      (;
                                                                                                                                                       il
p&vf 1'-1~ .2-g:ZtJU&J- of fil~P(Nf                          (\It   (L   !J~l iet2. flNal<t wtfit                M     ~ LAs-t AttelY\r~               I

                                                                                                                                                       {

(vll-   welt IZ          Non. tlA\ffl WE'              wOllkRd            ON:     ('1"\'1 C<t6e ~AtH~~                      HA\l;f.l9     NO.f­
                                                                                                                                                       !
qoN~ 6V-e£ 71fe              {(lise    <:fer    ptlE p(fte       M"f      dmN6.e ·X ""er.c/- b&fJft-E"- trtt Stldgl

                     ~wElL                MAk./n9 MLf (l)Mrt"~tJ+ ~r rvl~, \t\.f.f/Un. .

                     6\J..1eLL '+Qurd +ooNd                  ~t\. ~               l::>-e:s-t- j'f\(tru.s+ 0   f -tht:         ('Clovt+S

                    'f'I'   CV\01"t'i IM.t-eod ~Q.QS~V\-+1 "'-5 M~ wr+l~ p fCfEl1 t?'~c>:}'v.R

                     IN lVz.i       +=AVOrt ftfV..ett %                  pifRt. (OMplo.I\'b 0+                t-,.-{yt ..   weliuft
                         Ffi cl /vrz N ~.:5:S         6   F Co U N (j fl.. L
         ON             . (L ..5<ZCONd werz! ()F Jcrill :5-/';LL NO! h()'V/f)'Cl QWr             CON+UCt­
    "JIM        (VI      .    v\le Iterz I    hNQ//Lj ~ e:tZ hiA-1, wheN 1'-1Q ltiN:! fAt:
    qlfeMp               fo       h   iuzlNJ hifJ,1-/0 JUdge 71f1-1ofh y i30u \lV£ I I, ...I N
   fhe. iNf\1{//es holdoveR!.. /l.11l Welkell sfcr!rzd .;hoI he WOCtld
j 61Z -1-0 rd ON MIf CC/$e vvifh Me Qf flit: wood (Ou.N/~ ;:XtiL
I 0111 -5 Mll day 12                  tJ;   qNd jUlvc/d ~ t3fr .     Iw 0 dOlfS /:Jrz./l; fl rz +he
1   -hz.ia{ h w CoN +h':s                     be. QftflCtl've   ((55'I~J-Qi\Jce ot Cou~<&eL?
!   Mit. WeL                 e   ~ho'rVecl ow     .jQttAllda:-; /\/1911+     qt ChNNrtYl +ifVI€..
       .JZJty /         I:t      o/l/d .slaLf~d      ON     houfl-. YVL d(dN+ ft'Ni.sh ~OIN9 oveR.
  ..QviderJ(   a~q/NS+ f\.~~. NOrL did we ctl65cU5e f'fl~ ::ide of deFeAlce.
,    M +h     pOlivi Mil. Wdk~1Z u-l-iU hIlS;'! Jfo~erv to AI\l~of M~                                       I
I   WtfNt&5. I q~O shared 40 Mil.. Wrt/K-a -rhlZ/1.<L Wh~ E "t'deNa ON
I pnoiVfZ ne onc!lIV!p "'hI></- help                      IN My fQvote. Cirve! he said IF fheu
                                                          Mil
I WP<&         iI~        Ol//d p05-i-fON~ coun.t- dq-kd MIL WF Uf:/Z (\Iel/eR It&t£: /'I
, 10    phONq            12t:con.d tivg.::..) M fl We l/tell. -Yild! He W()u Id ON .5uNdQ ~ l~
Ito     '('l   N(.::.      10 I Nj oVett ([v id e/\fee f/rt d, 'd Nof f2du lUll of' (pURSe:,
!       Ht'       ft         ..5fAW fhilt- He W(J5 9o'N9'i<J srttz M~ SON -/.fJ
I IN-kn. vi ~               h,"ltl) a+ "Boy..) hOMe ctNd he. NtlVCL(2 dId <fha~. r
    dldll/-!- h         i:(e- f'eoM w({lka 090/'" L/{Y//L{ CO!)rd- c/ak i'1oll/da~ rtf of .AII~
                                      N.,e Dt Appea L 

    j   (P) L         eFFrzcf,'VeNflss of cO(jf\lsrzL
                                                                                                 .
                AC fLd INg -+0            +he (RfH Af'-'ifiNC/MrtNr i>"gh4 I    hove +ne J<...\ljht
f       -to obfon el/;dervc.e IN MVFAvOfl. DN MONdAlf t(tthot0a]~ ZOitl
I       +he ciatl o f /Illy courz+ Me QI\lcI MIL· WeL/U(l IAilU jftZClhN9 IN
I+h~        JUl2l1 IlCO/Vl
                        <pI"':) oVeR- his ffloct:Sl of" h6W +he JUll" IS pll:ked
i    I cI.sk cJ hif\1 rf Itt, Looled a-f +he phoNe: flfl.(Onc/5 FflDf\1. 'the:
1 Yo iL Ic.f rt icJ .' No! .L Q<5 ked IIVh(;/ 1-1e .sale/ I Decaus e: he VlIQ5
I bL/':' Y                 IZhNJ     ON   My   case. L q/so o6ke-d          (r He::   had   My
1 50IN ~u                 p0fJ:.Na    he sa/d.' 'No ~ well. I a:s/ul.d vvlzy? Qrvd he.
I       qClve    SCi 'It' (ltZ.5po/VUQ:        os btZ70R.e, he   I/'IOj .hU5Lj Vlfoe/:.INl) ON

IIVI~       CAse. So he I/IIQ:5 dOt'N!) -HIe pOfPtZlZ //IIod fhaf h<'L
I /j(ld       hf/ JUdge -/ho.I fie ha d ClONtZ a/rc.f!"Clollj ~fZ +he:
                -fo   i

i NflSSc/1l f p.eo ce6J Tofl. ((;uR:/. fVln welk~12 +heAl erzp)yed WiLL
I fh€: 0, . I.:5N+ 90 / N J -to U.:5e 1h~ phoNe f2€            buf hDW
I does +h f                   apply -10 havINg        +h~   rzvideNoz       +nai-   V'/Q.5 ON   the
I
~
        p~l\Ies iN 1Vl~ +(ivOtl. Q'Nd NtJ.f                 {)se'N9   If?
I
    i

    t (el) IrJ((fFec 1illtZNe5$                 of (OUN~tl L
I             Pr~co   ed lIiJ9 fa -Me           (p-ih AMeNdM(ZJllf RKjhl- Al11d              9~~eaNfeedh'j
l 1.'/ +h       AM    /II d Mfl!I/f   1219hi-   .r   have !h rz IZlghf of ,drt-fa(N J nJ!) VII I+N~
I IN MV                I/Orl.   ON    A1oN d a LJ, /C/# of-  JU~Cf f2cafltl
                                                                JuLV c<>ILI         IN     --the
I 7.. 1t5k.e: /-1«. weIkeR. IF,he Made' eollifod W,'I-h a List ot: t'1'1
I Wf+/IIe6:5. HIZ skrkd lie dtdN'J- Have ,HI'H? becaux He was IIJoTlkirl9
I ON My ~. ,H£ (iJ/led Ny ,,'/OIIIe/? IN +M JZI/zy t<WJVI .ON Hi-J a./I­
I pho"'~ +h . r{!; IN MV i5!ce asJ<iiIlJ, MJ Mofhrtn +0 <Je. +- a ptc..+Ufle of
I Ne aNd {/ {oftf Of ·:fclCtZ &ot. 6+ tVly                        /N~+(LLdecl
                                                                        Q[((/CIZ fl. • ANd
I Y Mofh +0 q<J1h aI/ 'th hIifN a/lid .tNII/J -fhe-M -10 hi
        ,,1            /l..             rlR          q           1?.55                                     N1

I ~ h~ C uld speak. -fD theM.lhlS (s iN rJo WC/4 e.f'.(ec+lVeNeJS of            ~

I Cool\l5e L. I\~ d (rv hiJ fn.U&tR.a.+tOItI of fvlV C!5k'1ll9 11'''"1/ he Vtl05rJ f
j

I d01rv<] £ /\1 fhe insj( --Ihit\(fJ ON JV14 fQVOtl. -H~ sfdrllc/ tl doesN'-I
I        HCI-trefl r f C(OU hdlle Wtf rJe05 SQ l                   i1tJ9       YOUR- a      gwd ~uL\ C'(Nd
I ~ClVe' ch N9 rld CjO~'R. 1'-[(
                              arouNd. ANd I :said "EvtN if fhe(1
I \AlW€, S fe .oITkid{5. OR rzVI?N -the WifNe'$ aT +he +illsf Lfly
lout ot'-the- Of(lej'NaL daie of ClLcu:;,eIN<j ·I\IOR. Cl weLL Nowe Paste R
I
        of +h({       0 /Ill M U'" if'i . AI\{d Cl WI? LL AlON(/ J-iq/llc! up C ih            it: 11/ 0 {' -/he
I COMflI/u ify o::t /'l!Ni?ola. OJllell-he -Du6lNess OWrcNrLIZ oP
I E-1-- e u-lefl. -t-IJal...L WC>YLke-c/ iOll 3:rt               ClJ1/d 'Nat.. Y!?OIl..5
I iNVu!ye 1# Ml( +Cwli/~. Wha-.fs               3     kIds who
                                                            /l101l.l;     Lt                   orze.
I be~-ft(LJetVds Of -+he aC            Des.f.iN1 LiIC-/ol2ict HQle +ha.J. WorJ/cj be
                                                C({..5etz
I 0(1 'II! Mi 'F(iV~fl.   Wdee/Z dId (I/O! qitle Mil' +his fZtcfhf 0{'
                                     /-1Q.
 defQ/AJIN . v-..ltfNeS5 AI\JdIhAVe IiI/ellS noM Each WrffJR~ who
I 1Akls. fJo£.q lied -ht{ M V Jow vrzlZ H 12.. Wrcl k(L f....
I        \><1I~bC ~\
                               *+/ce          or ApFeaL      fa 

(fl) :ENe; FtZc+JV~N~:SS            or CouNseL 

    ON        uNe i eJ..{p 120ft; fle.; wIFe Rosirz Lee HclLtZ
 pQs-f 0'/1' (ft;. itve we're' Le'JCiIIJ A 10K eiLC/ feJl( 1711= VIZORS IN h.fR..
 pa5-5iNg -Fouvvd;1- hoed -Iv deqL w;fIJ. BRac/ hlllt::JON witt. f-5 ".I{ t(
C;viL (Oll eLl COA/{IZ -fO se€         A1rz WIll; RQchrzLf&ce (OF. p. 5)
-Sholf+ qPf R 1'-1y VvIP.eS dt2t1/1j Sf0(j99L(~~ +c hold Q coAJV~Rsa+IOI\I
 wi+h ea+h ONe. /\1/L MLe/soN ON h~ depard-ctf?f? he ~ested '+o-the
 :S+AP,f:     lje'Nf fhal r NQ:'(£cl COLI,sttLIN9 bellQ-ved .I WQ...S 9iteF-sfi:ictfCtJ .
   -rile h {br2(£ +R.;aL.I hq cI cr c.ps. c ,\,i L (DUll-+- daft:. 5-I-R ugg L'N5
+0 -.sP((CI    CINd /v1Q/Il/·!-oil../ "11(. lAlli/SON f(eCfJue:.5+ed +6 +hi'
                                        IN   (OUR-I--

(ill i L JUc f/ if hq: {ould htfp Me Wifh CI wall oP CDl./5Q'L'-W9 -IOn My
qQI€f'v~rtJck(£tJ. Sudg 0+akd Le-ls /-flQVe ..fha f uf +0 'fh l :)heR i+~
aNd, -the . a+.(. I WOj /ql/e'R pIQ;t'd ON Q deprrtssioNflLL wier. ,.s
Q 61ckpiL          ~(c(l/S(l I c.ouldr\t-t MQINtairJ Wl-~ N\~ w,~ dea1h."t
(ouldri-l      iNk. iZl9h{ OR 01.eep aNd ~Q+, I fV\ c.UK.(Lt:t",..J/L, ON ft Cou..se L;N~
Ctts(t /00    . :.fOR. r.fhi5 cau..~e. ow !Ql~ lel, <Dill ...I pResen+ecf -+hi~ ~-f

40 "An.. \AI I t~n. as~if\J9 40rL hes    he Ip qV\d 0eeiNCj f F hfL if hf: (ould
 gflf fhl     GUlf clof( pos+" poNd Ht 0fa-/-fld hi COLtIdlit 9<1..+ (OdtZt da+e
                                                        I(

p:>sf"P"N      fl/OYl (ou fd he htlp Il/ll, fit: said: L/O()n. No-t h-RQl'il)9 VO\te~ 

 OR cpNN       ki It onq bod~ ~ '10. l\ 'oe f('rUl. tvl ~ W<d tel{ c\idrJ + wall t­
 +0 hi lp i      ~I{y :fO.V01L iN ONl-l C\5fec+. 

                                                                                            I
     ON      tiLl( /tl 20/l-/ O/ll dltl(   o.:r flef/tVJ   Jcill. L/ bel-odt   LuNCh­       !
 6r~Clt                    waS. c50ylf'l9 ifs cJlisf Bt case ONte'
             J1{t. Wr= Ltt'fL                                                  NOtzef
 ClqQliJsf CI   lJoIh~fl aNd -fhefle !/IICld No Pf(OV(fIIJ evide.Nce                        I
 oFth<z qCCll5~(L.5 6td<7. ArvdoN-fhts I\AO/lJVINg of JuL~ ILf, 'c6/f-l
 p/c~/'N9 lIrv c.CJNc{ic/a-!es 1--1(1.., VI~/tel2 clldN'i- INc/;Co-fe ANti
 JHt+eM nis O+h~1l yVise 01Z. i\/l"-/ chances. Wrt Wl.N+ to
 LuNch ,f-/ 06kec/,' Who! Was I\I/({ choice of JIldg(L o~ JUlLll
+0deci M~ COoF ONe/ f\.fC;-5 fZNfeNCtlIAtJ ' I .sI~cI -Iv                                   1
 Mfl- iN J/atll </Iwl q ]urLI NO JI,.rc. ti io N. I-/Y<.XIid ( .r be //e ve                 I
6peciol qNdI CO(J/cltvl hqve .ff}q.f hq!..r (2'lQ6Urec!
 1l1fi. Wei f"12 Ihtrf IWaJ lIt/ZV C/WQRe of~
                                                                                 '-ff-afs

                                                           the Jurv1Noflt-PC/cfu3J\/
                                                                                            I
                                                                                            "
                                                                                            ~.

 CINd +0 I    o{' ~17~ FOci --by Of\/fl        Allr/.. JCtWppl/Ho!1Vl5 Cl
                                                                5.J-crf~d
 veil <J IN tC, hvtJ WN LA vvljete. "11l. Weli::.I2'L ;X;ON Q,c/€
-the} Do . f/ftS oPPeevci q oP.{'rzlZ oF C).5YUllS, (heN
  Mil. W, tell -s'h~Ylkc/ S,fQMiV9 We WelLe f..co tJN9 clt1wiI/ V-wcJ
                  r
 J:xAreeelJ fhcl Nrt lA/CIS :scC/(2(tc/ fhffl/ N 0rkdedif woW! Cl
 fV1on~~ ~ '~N9' -rn~ lA/OJ ~he f\IIOSf ([XC';'feM~Nf af +hrz holt:
 +-h (N~ , a+he uhoWfci. theN He weN! aN +eL!I;vj 1\1 e Qbour the. 

 W-SCt Ot- a ~1{l. iJue oNe/ how Hrz 90f two Itk ,5~II//~Alce:.s~ 

  ll",dI W(Z'CI fh~IL~S NO /frpL rzV/c/-ell/ce C/9rilwsI Mfl. 

     MIL   ~/tffL oJ-Mfld +hftf he Could ovJ/~ (1St wtfllV~ AV1ld fJ/YJN~ ­
R£'coaols ~ ~ rLl/idiNCrt ON tV1L/ behol-P c((tideq ON 4le sfAJe~(jts 

--ft"xlt+h~D.A. fV'Qdf OlL j-f<l cou/d/tll LtS( If. 1++ '+hi~ POINt / bR99ClIN ,.
4u C\iLI .b CQu.se I      khlflW "112, 'vtle-Ik ~f2. WftsrJ -\: gOtNC) '-\0 do
  ~g (Z.*O.r ,l(~                                                                           .
                                                                                          I
(..:r:-') t:M rhcllveN(/05   of   CouNseL
    AWl{ h/N9 <5/N M If be   h." FCit -fr i6 I   Q "Ie(   IN   ({(lLf   o-fh rZ /l WCIY
Cfwd I elf I /lad (l(tJ of/Uil. chot'ce 'Iholt/ fVloKe                   0   p/~o... 

01e.s5tol./ I;LI /+11 OJ A () t 2 51fQar~ 

                                      _oflc~'      of     AF)pe4
b) r   f\./e       tec+illeNe'5S       0   ~   (OUN0eL

                   ve     t\1C/d~ COf'v1pIQ'lvfs +0 s(Cve!<.aL petJpLe
abDLtf tIC              WeIkeR CINe! hl:S i'NeFFecflveN€:SS of couNs<zL.
   Judg C:r Ti~(\'1ofhlj i3osvveLL, CiviL- LAVVYfl,1l 81'Cid willsON,
PRoLe 6 Ft~t:.1f. A.IIf(.j· HoWCIRd, LO'llvLj£12 .5c.JCOpPC; f-Iollvles,
TflXQS   il2 Dtl'FrzMSe Pl2oJ~cf, IrLXCI.5 :;:a,r<. D~feNc,je CGMpdJrv .
:)+C\+e:    D ard o,ud -+0 !vt¥ FofVJi/V ~ C(Nd CJOu CO", nrL/fl Me             (V}ClK-INj
               I

CDMplol            'fs   (}ix::u+   A1f2 vtle / f'e-12 oN pnONtL' ee cOlLc/e cl 5ysfefl-1.
     ~1(l           ~'kfZ(( 15 FOt? FROM a er.rf2"TIVe a.s5i~QtJce of
(ouN5eL ~ ftNd I kNO v\j +hq-f                     I'M   NO+   +h~ F/R6+   +0 MakrL
(,o/vlpla ~/fo Obou-l /t1R.. Welke/Z 1~~r.f'fZ£hvelll~s5 of aS51t:r/-C1tVc.e. 0+'
  (OUN             L.

                                                                                             t
                                                                                             II
                                 Tim·:- _~~:O-=O;.......:..P_·.... .~
                                                                ' ___

Dl>.~ x1>r 7 - I~( 

      i ­

                                                                          \
                                                                          l
                                                                          \

                                                                          I
                       .trine.                      \T,'\i_~ilS
            ---~-                --~---                           ----­
                          o                                         o

                             402 nd Judicial District Court
                                     Wood County
                                     P.O. Box 1707
                               Quitman, Texas 75783
                                    (903) 763-2332
G.. Ti othy Boswell                                                 Joy Parker, Court Coordinator
Distri t Judge                                                       Una Garland, Court Reporter

                                         71712014

CH ISTOPHER HALE, Sr..      ~:~ ... ~\ \/;.
206 CR 2840       .    ' \ ')~:v
MEOLA TX 75773    ~\     )
               -{,\~       RE: THE STATE OF TEXAS vs.
                 ~               CHRISTOPHER HALE, Sr.
                               # 22,153-2014

De    CHRISTOPHER HALE, Sr.:

The above referenced case is being called for Attorney Review on 07/09/2014 at 9:00
AM, You are ordered to be in the District Courtroom at the Wood County Courthouse,
Qui man, Texas, at that time. Failure to appear will result in your bond being forfeited
and a warrant being issued for your arrest.

                                                      Very truly yours,

                                                       ~~~                                          

                                                      G. Timothy Boswell
                                                      District Judge
GT Ibjp

CC   MARK L L WELKER
     PO BOX 1150
QUITMAN TX 75783

         Unknown
                                  o
          - X
         () ~ t'~ WARRANT OF ARREST
          ~~~~: ~    Cause#.l>H-03..-:'13
                  "\~        ~                The State Of Tcxfts 

                                   --,              ~--~   ..   ~.-~
                                                                    Vs. 
                          ,

                                         Christopher Lynn Hale
                            W/M - O.O.B. l1l1311973 - Tx. D.L. 07661390 

                    ,    Addl'ess: 206 County Road 2840. Mineola, Texas 75773 

                    '---------------------_/ 

TO ANY PEACE OFFI,CJ.:R OF THE STATE OF T:EXAS, GREETING:

         You are hereby commanded to an'est Christopher Lynn Hale$ if to be found in                                                                   ,

                                                                                                                                                       ~
you county and bring said person before me. a Justice of the Peace, Wood County,
Te:x 05, at my office: located at Hawkins, Texas, in said county, immediately, then and
ther to answer the State of Texas for an offense agajnst the laws of said State, to wit:                                                               f
                                                                                                                                                       t
Co tinuous Sexual Abuse of a Young Child, Felony 1
                                                                                                                                                       \
        hich offense he, Christopher Lynn Hale, is accused by the written complaint, undC.':r 

        alh of Kyle Henson, t1Ied before me. 

           Herein faH not. but of this writ made due return. showing how you have executed
                                                                                                                                                       I
                                                                                                                                                       t
                                                                                                                                                       f
                                                                                                                                                       i

           Witnesst:u my official signature, this 15 th day ofNovembcr 2013.

Rec ...mmended          bond:~7s;=a()e\~.9,,~Q..:~, ... '"
  ~
        t~
         .I"t.
                  e¢i\.ct:4,CJ.c.(.-.L- ,"!\J~~\,p..)Gq' '-" ~~~~I.;,Jqt...L)"l~~-::::!!!.L-
                                      .---
                                           y.... ....
                                              '\
                                             ~'~
                                               ..
                                                     ,          ,,-,.       4,      " ' , ~J
                                                                                 ..:.1   : ustlce 0 e
  1=,    '-'                                 ~.                             ~    .....1

                                         .~'fr /'
                                         -.
                                                           "'~0
                                                                I               ~
                                                                                    '\..  'rood County, 

                                                                                               ­
                                         ~S~EruF"'~REjj)_RN
                                           :'~~ :.\                     ~            " ~-:1~
                                         ...-.  '. ".                            ...'rY.~
        Carne to hand on the ~ (fi}tp~; ~~..,. .        .2013, at              o'clock
    M. t and executed on the ~ daybl:;r"il'l'?~           20'3 at ;.:.2 0 ' o'clock                    $

£-  M., by arresting (he within named ~t/I'flr':sf~ "''(t-N ~
at       W t...J 0                        in      ~I)          '__ ", County. Texas
and placing him I her in jail at w ~() l~ 1}a..",,­

                                                                                           ~~
                                                                                           ~oU:V7: ~,w-,;,>
This ollcnse occurred in J.P. Pel. 1#2
                                                                                           D~                             F

                 910818££:06:01                            b9b££:9L£:06                                    lI~r   0)   aOOM:WO~~   1£:01 £102-61-nON
                                                                                o

      14t     i~ f~f\dC\l1t -+Fnd~6.S +Hi-5 notice                Of(   4ixidcnc£ a {:       His

 dESicf     +0         Ap pEA L"t11t (onv/C.1IOn          If1    CaUSE No.     LL, l5.3...- 20 ltd

                                                                    ~G~ Ec,-H\.4 LL~        uu bfY' '\"\tE d t
                                                                        Chti,o,lofrux jyvm HcJj> Uti€:

        ~~~""-f"'-'~!o-....l..--lf-L-U-L-~~        _Tbcs f\      \QL\300Q    \::)c·\n~   f'a.t6( n-\-' '-\
                                                                                                                       I
                                                                                                                       It
me C\ (' c..e~Cl              ::r..f\ Tn (J NlrrJ\aEi UnIt In Hunts\lr' l"€ 7E;sQ ')
                                                                                                                       I
                       R.   p"Eno I-\-y 6f""' pEQ.}UQ..l\ ~at +t\~ tDCU)oifKj \-0 -\-rUt       C\f\cI (0 (l.R€c.:t .
                                                                                                                       I
                                                                                                                       t
                                                                                                                       (
                                                                                                                       I

     on -h\r5      ·ffit           (   f
                                                      OQck I'L

                                            c\c.\L\ ~t ,AI#t/,    ~Ol L\ c.c\~ to b~
                                                                                                                       I
                                                                                                                       f
                                                                                                                       t

 -to tl"tt:> Ik-oN :s\-loulcJ DE': I).~ f (J               r
  ~aQd bL) ME +r\€ b~f'£ndQut\J Nofice C)f AppRtL otjd if app.:rCIRS                                                   I
                                                                                                                       I

                                                                                                                       I
                                                                                                                       I
                                                                                                                       I,
                                                                                                                       (
                                                                                                                        I
                                                                                                                       f
                                                                                                                       I
                                                                                                                       ,
                                                                                                                       !

  pg 2 of'!H       I