Court Opinion

ID: 4560288
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2020-08-26 21:01:58.566513+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:46:08.740160
License: Public Domain

FILED
                                                                                      Apr 15, 2019
                                                                                      02:42 PM(CT)
                                                                                       TENNESSEE
                                                                                 WORKERS' COMPENSATION
                                                                                     APPEALS BOARD

             7(11(66((%85($82):25.(56¶&203(16$7,21
                  :25.(56¶&203(16$7,21$33($/6%2$5'
                                                 
7KRPDV6XVWHUVLF                                  'RFNHW1R
                                                  
Y                                                
                                                  6WDWH)LOH1R
/RZH¶V+RPH&HQWHUV,QFHWDO                 
                                                  
                                                  
$SSHDOIURPWKH&RXUWRI:RUNHUV¶                 
&RPSHQVDWLRQ&ODLPV                               
$XGUH\$+HDGULFN-XGJH
      
                  $IILUPHGDQG&HUWLILHGDV)LQDO±)LOHG$SULO

7KH HPSOR\HH DQ DSSOLDQFH GHOLYHU\ GULYHU DOOHJHG VXVWDLQLQJ D KHUQLD ZKHQ KH DQG D
FRZRUNHU OLIWHG D FRRNLQJ UDQJH RQWR WKH EDFN RI D WUXFN  7KH HPSOR\HU GHQLHG WKH
FODLP DVVHUWLQJ WKH HPSOR\HH¶V KHUQLD GLG QRW PHHW WKH VWDWXWRU\ UHTXLUHPHQWV IRU D
FRPSHQVDEOHKHUQLD7KHHPSOR\HHUHTXHVWHGDQH[SHGLWHGKHDULQJDIWHUZKLFKWKHWULDO
FRXUW FRQFOXGHG WKH HPSOR\HH ZDV XQOLNHO\ WR HVWDEOLVK DW WULDO WKDW KH VXIIHUHG D
FRPSHQVDEOH KHUQLD  $IWHU DGGLWLRQDO PHGLFDO WUHDWPHQW DQG GLVFRYHU\ WKH HPSOR\HH
ZDV SODFHG DW PD[LPXP PHGLFDO LPSURYHPHQW DQG ZDV DVVLJQHG DQ LPSDLUPHQW UDWLQJ
)ROORZLQJ D WULDO WKH FRXUW IRXQG WKH HPSOR\HH KDG QRW PHW KLV EXUGHQ RI SURRI RI
HVWDEOLVKLQJWKDWKHVXIIHUHGDZRUNUHODWHGKHUQLDDQGGHFOLQHGWRDZDUGEHQHILWV7KH
HPSOR\HHKDVDSSHDOHG+DYLQJFDUHIXOO\UHYLHZHGWKHUHFRUGZHDIILUPWKHWULDOFRXUW¶V
GHFLVLRQDQGFHUWLI\WKHWULDOFRXUW¶VRUGHUDVILQDO

-XGJH'DYLG)+HQVOH\GHOLYHUHGWKHRSLQLRQRIWKH$SSHDOV%RDUGLQZKLFK3UHVLGLQJ
-XGJH0DUVKDOO/'DYLGVRQ,,,DQG-XGJH7LPRWK\:&RQQHUMRLQHG

0DWWKHZ * &ROHPDQ &OHYHODQG 7HQQHVVHH IRU WKH HPSOR\HHDSSHOODQW 7KRPDV
6XVWHUVLF

*DU\ 6 1DSROLWDQ &KDWWDQRRJD DQG &DOOLH . +LQVRQ 1DVKYLOOH 7HQQHVVHH IRU WKH
HPSOR\HUDSSHOOHH/RZH¶V+RPH&HQWHUV,QF

                             )DFWXDODQG3URFHGXUDO%DFNJURXQG
                                                 
      7KRPDV 6XVWHUVLF ³(PSOR\HH´  D VL[W\WKUHH\HDUROG UHVLGHQW RI %UDGOH\
&RXQW\ 7HQQHVVHH DOOHJHG VXIIHULQJ D KHUQLD RQ $SULO   DIWHU KH DQG D FR

                                                               

HPSOR\HHOLIWHGDFRRNLQJUDQJHZHLJKLQJDSSUR[LPDWHO\SRXQGVRQWRDIODWEHGWUXFN
LQ WKH FRXUVH RI KLV HPSOR\PHQW ZLWK /RZH¶V +RPH &HQWHUV ,QF ³(PSOR\HU´ 
(PSOR\HHWHVWLILHGKHIHOWLPPHGLDWHVWRPDFKSDLQDQGH[SHULHQFHGDIHHOLQJRIKDYLQJWR
³WKURZXS´EXWGLGQRWGRVR+HGLGKRZHYHUH[SHULHQFHSHUVLVWHQWYRPLWLQJODWHUWKDW
HYHQLQJ  (PSOR\HH GLG QRW LPPHGLDWHO\ VHHN PHGLFDO WUHDWPHQW EXW ZHQW WR 7HQQRYD
+RVSLWDO DSSUR[LPDWHO\ WZHQW\IRXU KRXUV DIWHU WKH OLIWLQJ LQFLGHQW FRPSODLQLQJ RI
DEGRPLQDOSDLQWKDWEHJDQWKHSUHYLRXVGD\

         'U-RVKXD:RUWKLQJWRQDJHQHUDOVXUJHRQH[DPLQHG(PSOR\HHDQGUHYLHZHGWKH
UHVXOWV RI D &7 VFDQ EHIRUH GLDJQRVLQJ (PSOR\HH ZLWK D YHQWUDO DEGRPLQDO ZDOO KHUQLD
DQGERZHOREVWUXFWLRQ'U:RUWKLQJWRQQRWHGWKDW(PSOR\HHUHSRUWHGKDYLQJDEGRPLQDO
SDLQ IRU  KRXUV DFFRPSDQLHG E\ QDXVHD YRPLWLQJ DQG GLDUUKHD  ,Q SUHSDUDWLRQ IRU
VXUJHU\ (PSOR\HH KDG D FDUGLDF FRQVXOW DQG KH UHSRUWHG WR WKH FDUGLRORJLVW WKDW KLV
VWRPDFKKDGEHHQJHWWLQJKDUGRYHUWKHSDVWZHHNDQGWKDWKHZDVH[SHULHQFLQJFUDPSV
ZLWK H[HUWLRQ  'U :RUWKLQJWRQ SHUIRUPHG D KHUQLD UHSDLU RQ $SULO   GXULQJ
ZKLFK KH IRXQG D VHFRQG VPDOO YHQWUDO KHUQLD DQG D 0HFNHO¶V GLYHUWLFXOXP ZKLFK KH
GHVFULEHGDVDFRQJHQLWDOFRQGLWLRQ'U:RUWKLQJWRQUHSDLUHGERWKKHUQLDVDQGUHVHFWHG
(PSOR\HH¶V ERZHO WR FRUUHFW WKH GLYHUWLFXOXP DQG (PSOR\HH ZDV UHOHDVHG IURP WKH
KRVSLWDOWZRGD\VODWHU

         2Q0D\(PSOR\HHUHWXUQHGWRWKHKRVSLWDOFRPSODLQLQJWKDWWKHVXUJLFDO
ZRXQG KDG EHHQ ³RR]LQJ TXLWH D ELW´  $ &7 VFDQ DQG D SK\VLFDO H[DPLQDWLRQ E\ 'U
:RUWKLQJWRQUHYHDOHGWKDWWKHLQLWLDOKHUQLDUHSDLUKDGIDLOHG'U:RUWKLQJWRQWHVWLILHG
WKDWWKHQDWXUHRIWKHIDLOXUHFRQVWLWXWHGDQHPHUJHQF\UHTXLULQJ(PSOR\HH³WRJREDFNWR
WKH RSHUDWLQJ URRP ULJKW WKHQ´  (PSOR\HH UHWXUQHG WR 'U :RUWKLQJWRQ LQ WKH PRQWKV
IROORZLQJ WKH VHFRQG VXUJHU\  $ VXEVHTXHQW &7 VFDQ ³FRQILUPHG >(PSOR\HH@ KDG
EDVLFDOO\UHKHUQLDWHGWKURXJK>WKH@ VHFRQGUHSDLU´$WWKDWSRLQW'U:RUWKLQJWRQ³IHOW
KHQHHGHGWRJRVHHD>KHUQLD@VSHFLDOLVW´

         (PSOR\HUGHQLHGWKHFODLPLQLWVHQWLUHW\IURPWKHRXWVHW$VDUHVXOW(PSOR\HH
ILOHG D 3HWLWLRQ IRU %HQHILW 'HWHUPLQDWLRQ  )ROORZLQJ XQVXFFHVVIXO PHGLDWLRQ DQ
H[SHGLWHGKHDULQJZDVFRQGXFWHGGXULQJZKLFK(PSOR\HHWHVWLILHGWKDWKLVVWRPDFKKDG
EHHQ³YHU\XQHDV\´DQG³KDGEHHQKXUWLQJDOOGD\´EHIRUHOLIWLQJWKHUDQJH+HGHVFULEHG
WKH OLIWLQJ LQFLGHQW DV ³WKH VWUDZ WKDW EURNH WKH FDPHO¶V EDFN´  (PSOR\HU VXEPLWWHG DQ
DIILGDYLWRI'U:RUWKLQJWRQDWWKHKHDULQJZKLFKVWDWHGWKDW(PSOR\HH³GLGQRWSURYLGH
DKLVWRU\RIDVSHFLILFZRUNLQMXU\ZKLFKFDXVHGKLVDEGRPLQDOSDLQ´'U:RUWKLQJWRQ¶V
DIILGDYLW ZHQW RQ WR VD\ WKDW ³EDVHG RQ >KLV@ H[DPLQDWLRQ RI >(PSOR\HH@ DQG LQ >KLV@
PHGLFDO RSLQLRQ LW LV PRUH OLNHO\ WKDQ QRW WKDW >(PSOR\HH¶V@ KHUQLDV H[LVWHG SULRU WR
$SULO´



 0HFNHO¶VGLYHUWLFXOXPLVDFRQJHQLWDOEXOJHLQWKHORZHUSDUWRIWKHVPDOOLQWHVWLQHWKDWLV³DOHIWRYHU´
RI WKH XPELOLFDO FRUG  KWWSVP\FOHYHODQGFOLQLFRUJKHDOWKGLVHDVHVPHFNHOVGLYHUWLFXOXP ODVW
YLVLWHG$SULO 

                                                     

         ,Q LWV H[SHGLWHG KHDULQJ RUGHU WKH WULDO FRXUW GHWHUPLQHG WKDW (PSOR\HH ZDV QRW
HQWLWOHG WR WKH UHTXHVWHG ZRUNHUV¶ FRPSHQVDWLRQ EHQHILWV FRQFOXGLQJ KH KDG QRW
HVWDEOLVKHGIRXURIWKHILYHVWDWXWRU\FULWHULDQHFHVVDU\WRSURYHDFRPSHQVDEOHKHUQLDDV
FRQWHPSODWHG E\ 7HQQHVVHH &RGH $QQRWDWHG VHFWLRQ   :KLOH WKH FRXUW IRXQG
(PSOR\HHKDGHVWDEOLVKHGKHVXIIHUHGSDLQDVDUHVXOWRIWKHKHUQLDLWGHWHUPLQHGKHKDG
QRWHVWDEOLVKHGWKDWWKHUHZDVDQDFFLGHQWUHVXOWLQJLQDKHUQLDWKDWWKHKHUQLDDSSHDUHG
VXGGHQO\WKDWWKHKHUQLDLPPHGLDWHO\IROORZHGWKHDFFLGHQWDQGWKDWWKHKHUQLDGLGQRW
H[LVWSULRUWRWKHZRUNDFFLGHQW7KDWRUGHUZDVQRWDSSHDOHG

         (PSOR\HHVXEVHTXHQWO\VRXJKWWUHDWPHQWZLWK'U9LFHQWH0HMLDZKRXOWLPDWHO\
SHUIRUPHG D VXFFHVVIXO KHUQLD UHSDLU RQ -DQXDU\    (PSOR\HH WHVWLILHG KH IHOW
³ILQH´ DIWHU WKH PRVW UHFHQW UHSDLU DQG 'U 0HMLD SODFHG KLP DW PD[LPXP PHGLFDO
LPSURYHPHQW RQ 0DUFK   ZLWK D  DQDWRPLF LPSDLUPHQW  (PSOR\HH KDV QRW
UHWXUQHGWRZRUNVLQFHWKHOLIWLQJLQFLGHQWDQG(PSOR\HUKDVQRWSURYLGHGDQ\PHGLFDORU
WHPSRUDU\GLVDELOLW\EHQHILWVWR(PSOR\HH

        )ROORZLQJDVHFRQGXQVXFFHVVIXOPHGLDWLRQWKHFDVHZDVWULHGDQG(PSOR\HHZDV
WKHRQO\ZLWQHVVWRWHVWLI\LQSHUVRQ(PSOR\HHKDGWHVWLILHGLQWKHH[SHGLWHGKHDULQJWKDW
KLV VWRPDFK IHOW ³YHU\ XQHDV\´ DQGKXUW DOO GD\ RQ WKH GD\ RI WKH DOOHJHG LQFLGHQW  +H
IXUWKHU WHVWLILHG WKDW KLV VWRPDFK SDLQV ZHUH ³VORZO\ EXLOGLQJ XS´ RYHU WKH ³ODVW ZHHN
VHYHUDOGD\V´³WRWKHSRLQWWKDW>KH@DVNHG>DPDQDJHU@LIVKHFRXOGKDYHDJX\FRPHRXW
WKHUHZLWKDIRUNOLIWWRSXW>WKHUDQJH@RQWKHEDFNRIWKHWUXFN´:KHQVSHFLILFDOO\DVNHG
LI KH WROGKLV FDUGLRORJLVW WKDW ³RYHU WKH SDVW ZHHN RU VR WKDW >KLV@ VWRPDFK ZDV JHWWLQJ
KDUGZKHQ>KH@H[HUWHG>KLPVHOI@´(PSOR\HHUHVSRQGHGLQWKHDIILUPDWLYHGHVFULELQJWKH
OLIWLQJLQFLGHQWDV³WKHVWUDZWKDWEURNHWKHFDPHO¶VEDFN´
         
         $W WULDO KRZHYHU (PSOR\HH WHVWLILHG WKDW WKH V\PSWRPV KH H[SHULHQFHG DIWHU
OLIWLQJ WKH VWRYH ZHUH ³GLIIHUHQW´ WKDQ ZKDW KH KDG SUHYLRXVO\ IHOW DV WKH\ ZHUH ³PRUH
SDLQIXO´DQG³VXGGHQ´:KHQTXHVWLRQHGIXUWKHUDVWRZKHWKHUKHKDGHYHUH[SHULHQFHG
WKDW W\SH RI SDLQ EHIRUH WKH OLIWLQJ LQFLGHQW (PSOR\HH UHVSRQGHG ³>Q@R >KH@ KDG QRW´
:KHQ VSHFLILFDOO\ DVNHG RQ FURVVH[DPLQDWLRQ WR FRUURERUDWH KLV SUHYLRXV VWDWHPHQW
PDGH WR WKH FDUGLRORJLVW FRQFHUQLQJ WKH V\PSWRPV KH H[SHULHQFHG SULRU WR WKH OLIWLQJ
LQFLGHQW(PSOR\HHVWDWHGKHGLGQRWUHFDOOPDNLQJWKDWVWDWHPHQW

        'U:RUWKLQJWRQWHVWLILHGE\GHSRVLWLRQ+HZDVTXHVWLRQHGH[WHQVLYHO\UHJDUGLQJ
ZKHWKHU (PSOR\HH¶V KHUQLD FRXOG KDYH EHHQ FDXVHG E\ KLV ZRUN DFWLYLWLHV  'U
:RUWKLQJWRQLQGLFDWHGWKDWDKHUQLDVXFKDVWKDWVXIIHUHGE\(PSOR\HHFRXOGKDYHPDQ\
FDXVHVVRPHRIZKLFKZRXOGEHZRUNUHODWHGDQGVRPHRIZKLFKZRXOGQRW+HVWDWHG

         7KHKHUQLDZKHWKHULWZDVWKHUHWZRGD\VEHIRUHRUDZHHNEHIRUHRUD\HDU
         EHIRUH , GRQ¶W NQRZ:KHWKHU WKDW KHUQLD ZDV DFXWH RU QRW>@ , GRQ¶W
         NQRZ%XWFHUWDLQO\WKHWKLQJWKDWZDVWKHGULYLQJIRUFHRIKLPFRPLQJLQ

                                                   

       ZLWKWKHQDXVHDYRPLWLQJDQGFRQWLQXHGDEGRPLQDOSDLQZDVEHFDXVHWKH
       ERZHOZDVVWXFNLQ>WKHKHUQLD@

         2Q FURVVH[DPLQDWLRQ 'U :RUWKLQJWRQ ZDV DVNHG WKH IROORZLQJ TXHVWLRQ DERXW
WKHKLVWRU\LQWKHFDUGLRORJLVW¶VUHSRUWDQGWKHFDXVHRI(PSOR\HH¶VKHUQLD³>E@DVHGRQ
WKDWKLVWRU\RI>WKH@VWRPDFKJHWWLQJKDUGDQGKDYLQJVWRPDFKFUDPSVRYHUWKHODVWZHHN
RU VR \RX FDQQRW VD\ ZLWK DQ\ GHJUHH RI PHGLFDO FHUWDLQW\ WKDW WKH OLIWLQJ LQFLGHQW RI
$SULO QG  ZDV WKH FDXVH RI >(PSOR\HH¶V@ KHUQLD"´  'U :RUWKLQJWRQUHVSRQGHG
WKDW KH ³FDQQRW VD\ RQH ZD\ RU WKH RWKHU QR´  $V WR ZKHWKHU (PSOR\HH¶V KHUQLD SUH
H[LVWHGWKHOLIWLQJLQFLGHQW'U:RUWKLQJWRQVWDWHG³WKHUH¶VDFKDQFH>LW@FRXOGKDYHEXW
WKHUH¶VDFKDQFH>LW@PLJKWQRW$QG>(PSOR\HH@DWWKDWWLPH>GLGQRW@LQGLFDWHWR
PHOLIWLQJVRPHWKLQJIHHOLQJDSRSRUVRPHWKLQJOLNHWKDW,WMXVWVRUWRIVWDUWHG´
         
         $OWKRXJK 'U :RUWKLQJWRQ KDG VLJQHG DQ DIILGDYLW LQGLFDWLQJ WKDW (PSOR\HH¶V
KHUQLD SUHH[LVWHG WKH ZRUN LQFLGHQW KH H[SODLQHG LQ KLV GHSRVLWLRQ WKDW KH LQWHQGHG WR
LQGLFDWH WKDW (PSOR\HH¶V KHUQLD SUHH[LVWHG KLV HYDOXDWLRQ DQG WUHDWPHQW RI (PSOR\HH
:KHQ SUHVHQWHG ZLWK D K\SRWKHWLFDO VFHQDULR PLUURULQJ (PSOR\HH¶V KLVWRU\ DQG DVNHG
ZKHWKHUWKHKHUQLDZDVZRUNUHODWHGWKHIROORZLQJFROORTX\RFFXUUHG

         $  , ZRXOG VD\ WKDW WKH KHUQLD DSSHDUHG V\PSWRPDWLF VXGGHQO\ ,Q RWKHU
               ZRUGVLIKHKDGERZHOVWXFNLQWRWKLVKHUQLDDQGKHZDVDV\PSWRPDWLF
               EHIRUH , WKLQN WKH DFXWH HYHQW ZKHWKHU WKH KHUQLD DSSHDUHG RXW RI
               QRZKHUH FHUWDLQO\ , WKLQN WKH ERZHO WKDW ZDV VWXFN LQ WKH KHUQLD
               KDSSHQHG DFXWHO\  $QG WKDW PLJKW KDYH KDSSHQHG GXH WR MXVW WKH
               SUHVVXUHRQWKHDUHD,WFRXOG¶YHEHHQGXHWRPD\EHWKHUHZDVDVOLJKW
               ZLGHQLQJ RI WKH KHUQLD GHIHFW DFXWHO\  ,W¶V KDUG WR UHDOO\ VD\ EXW
               FHUWDLQO\RQHRUWKHRWKHURUERWKFRXOG¶YHGHILQLWHO\KDSSHQHG
         
         4  2ND\  :LWKRXW WKDW SULRU WUHDWPHQW >RI WKH KHUQLD@ WKHUH¶V QR ZD\ WR
               WHOOWKDWLWKDG±
         
         $1R
         
         4±SUHH[LVWHGWKDWHYHQW
         
         $1R

'U:RUWKLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDW(PSOR\HH¶VV\PSWRPV³GHYHORSHGVXGGHQO\´DQGWKDWKH
KDG ³DFXWH V\PSWRPV´ FODULI\LQJ WKDW ³>W@KH V\PSWRPV WKDW >KH@ HOLFLWHG IURP
>(PSOR\HH@EHLQJWKHQDXVHDDQGYRPLWLQJDVZHOODVWKHDEGRPLQDOSDLQ>ZHUH@IRUWKH
WRKRXUV>SULRUWR(PSOR\HH¶VYLVLWWRWKHKRVSLWDO@´$OVRKHDJUHHGWKDWLWZDV
³YHU\OLNHO\´WKDW(PSOR\HHEHJDQWRH[SHULHQFHWKRVHV\PSWRPVGXULQJWKDWWLPHIUDPH
WKDWWKRVHV\PSWRPVZHUH³WKHUHVXOWRI>(PSOR\HH¶V@H[HUWLRQ´DQGWKDWWKH³>V@WRPDFK

                                                  

FUDPSLQJ DQG VWXII OLNH WKDW WKDW ZDV JRLQJ RQ IRU    D ZHHN RU VHYHUDO ZHHNV
EHIRUHKDQGPD\RUPD\QRWKDYHKDSSHQHG´

       $WWULDO(PSOR\HHWHVWLILHGWKDWZKLOHKHKDGLQGLFDWHGWRWKHFDUGLRORJLVWWKDWKH
KDG EHHQ H[SHULHQFLQJ VRPH VWRPDFK GLVFRPIRUW DQG KDUGQHVV KH EHOLHYHG WKRVH
V\PSWRPVWREHIOXUHODWHG7KLVWHVWLPRQ\ZDVLQDSSDUHQWFRQWUDGLFWLRQWR(PSOR\HH¶V
WHVWLPRQ\DWWKHH[SHGLWHGKHDULQJWKDWWKHOLIWLQJLQFLGHQWZDVWKH³VWUDZWKDWEURNHWKH
FDPHO¶VEDFN´DQGWKDWKHKDGDQ³XQHDV\´VWRPDFKWKDWGD\$WWULDO(PSOR\HHIXUWKHU
GHVFULEHGWKHSDLQIROORZLQJWKHOLIWLQJLQFLGHQWDVGLIIHUHQWVXGGHQDQGVHYHUH

       7KHWULDOFRXUWFRQFOXGHG(PSOR\HHIDLOHGWRHVWDEOLVKE\DSUHSRQGHUDQFHRIWKH
HYLGHQFH WKDW KLV KHUQLD DURVH SULPDULO\ RXW RI DQG LQ WKH FRXUVH DQG VFRSH RI KLV
HPSOR\PHQW6SHFLILFDOO\WKHFRXUWGHWHUPLQHGWKDWQHLWKHUWKHPHGLFDOHYLGHQFHQRU'U
:RUWKLQJWRQ¶VRSLQLRQRQFDXVDWLRQZDVVXIILFLHQWWRVXSSRUWDILQGLQJRIDFRPSHQVDEOH
LQMXU\KDYLQJIDLOHGWRVDWLVI\IRXURIWKHILYHFULWHULDUHTXLUHGE\VHFWLRQ D IRU
KHUQLDFODLPV(PSOR\HHKDVDSSHDOHG
                                                    
                                       6WDQGDUGRI5HYLHZ
                                                    
        7KH VWDQGDUG ZH DSSO\ LQ UHYLHZLQJ D WULDO FRXUW¶V GHFLVLRQ SUHVXPHV WKDW WKH
FRXUW¶VIDFWXDOILQGLQJVDUHFRUUHFWXQOHVVWKHSUHSRQGHUDQFHRIWKHHYLGHQFHLVRWKHUZLVH
See 7HQQ &RGH $QQ   F      :KHQ WKH WULDO MXGJH KDV KDG WKH
RSSRUWXQLW\ WR REVHUYH D ZLWQHVV¶V GHPHDQRU DQG WR KHDU LQFRXUW WHVWLPRQ\ ZH JLYH
FRQVLGHUDEOH GHIHUHQFH WR IDFWXDO ILQGLQJV PDGH E\ WKH WULDO FRXUW  Madden v. Holland
Grp. of Tenn., Inc.  6:G   7HQQ    +RZHYHU ³>Q@R VLPLODU
GHIHUHQFHQHHGEHDIIRUGHGWKHWULDOFRXUW¶VILQGLQJVEDVHGXSRQGRFXPHQWDU\HYLGHQFH´
Goodman v. Schwarz Paper Co.1R:6&5:&7HQQ/(;,6DW
   7HQQ :RUNHUV¶ &RPS 3DQHO -DQ     6LPLODUO\ WKH LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ DQG
DSSOLFDWLRQRIVWDWXWHVDQGUHJXODWLRQVDUHTXHVWLRQVRIODZWKDWDUHUHYLHZHGde novoZLWK
QR SUHVXPSWLRQ RI FRUUHFWQHVV DIIRUGHG WKH WULDO FRXUW¶V FRQFOXVLRQV  See Mansell v.
Bridgestone Firestone N. Am. Tire, LLC  6:G   7HQQ    :H DUH
DOVR PLQGIXO RI RXU REOLJDWLRQ WR FRQVWUXH WKH ZRUNHUV¶ FRPSHQVDWLRQ VWDWXWHV ³IDLUO\
LPSDUWLDOO\ DQG LQ DFFRUGDQFH ZLWK EDVLF SULQFLSOHV RI VWDWXWRU\ FRQVWUXFWLRQ´ DQG LQ D
ZD\WKDWGRHVQRWIDYRUHLWKHUWKHHPSOR\HHRUWKHHPSOR\HU7HQQ&RGH$QQ
  

                                              $QDO\VLV

        (PSOR\HH UDLVHV WKUHH LVVXHV RQ DSSHDO WKH ILUVW WZR RI ZKLFK ZH FRPELQH DQG
UHVWDWH DV ZKHWKHU WKH WULDO FRXUW HUUHG LQ GHWHUPLQLQJ WKDW (PSOR\HH GLG QRW SUHVHQW


 7KH WULDO FRXUW DOVR PDGH DOWHUQDWLYH ILQGLQJV LQ WKH HYHQW LWV GHWHUPLQDWLRQ UHJDUGLQJ FRPSHQVDELOLW\
ZDVUHYHUVHGRQDSSHDO

                                                         

VXIILFLHQWHYLGHQFHWRHVWDEOLVKKHVXIIHUHGDFRPSHQVDEOHKHUQLD(PSOR\HH¶VWKLUGLVVXH
LV ZKHWKHU WKH WULDO FRXUW HUUHG LQ LWV DOWHUQDWLYH ILQGLQJV E\ FRQFOXGLQJ LQ WKH HYHQW
(PSOR\HH¶V KHUQLD LV GHHPHG FRPSHQVDEOH (PSOR\HH LV QRW HQWLWOHG WR WHPSRUDU\
GLVDELOLW\EHQHILWV%HFDXVHZHDIILUPWKHWULDOFRXUW¶VFRQFOXVLRQWKDW(PSOR\HH¶VKHUQLD
LVQRWFRPSHQVDEOH(PSOR\HH¶VWKLUGLVVXHLVSUHWHUPLWWHG
        
        8QOLNHRWKHUW\SHVRILQMXULHVKHUQLDVDUHJRYHUQHGE\DVSHFLILFVWDWXWHDSSOLFDEOH
RQO\ WR KHUQLDV ZKLFK LGHQWLILHV ZKDW DQ LQMXUHG ZRUNHU PXVW SURYH WR HVWDEOLVK D
FRPSHQVDEOHZRUNUHODWHGKHUQLD
        
        ,QDOOFODLPVIRU FRPSHQVDWLRQIRUKHUQLDRUUXSWXUHUHVXOWLQJIURPLQMXU\
        E\ DFFLGHQW DULVLQJ SULPDULO\ RXW RI DQG LQ WKH FRXUVH DQG VFRSH RI WKH
        HPSOR\HH¶VHPSOR\PHQWLWPXVWEHGHILQLWHO\SURYHQWRWKHVDWLVIDFWLRQRI
        WKHFRXUWWKDW
        
                  7KHUHZDVDQLQMXU\UHVXOWLQJLQKHUQLDRUUXSWXUH
                  7KHKHUQLDRUUXSWXUHDSSHDUHGVXGGHQO\
                  ,WZDVDFFRPSDQLHGE\SDLQ
                  7KHKHUQLDRUUXSWXUHLPPHGLDWHO\IROORZHGWKHDFFLGHQW
                    DQG
                  7KHKHUQLDRUUXSWXUHGLGQRWH[LVWSULRUWRWKHDFFLGHQWIRU
                    ZKLFKFRPSHQVDWLRQLVFODLPHG

7HQQ&RGH$QQ D   

        7KLV VWDWXWH GLIIHUV RQO\ VOLJKWO\ IURP WKH RULJLQDO VWDWXWH ZKLFK ZDV HQDFWHG LQ
  $V RULJLQDOO\ HQDFWHG WKH VWDWXWH UHTXLUHG WKH ILYH FULWHULD WR EH ³GHILQLWHO\
SURYHQ´ WR WKH VDWLVIDFWLRQ RI WKH FRXUW LQ DOO FODLPV ³UHVXOWLQJ IURP LQMXU\ E\ DFFLGHQW
DULVLQJRXWRIDQGLQWKHFRXUVHRIWKHHPSOR\HH¶VHPSOR\PHQW´3XEOLF$FWV&K
    %\ FRQWUDVW WKH VWDWXWH DSSOLFDEOH LQ WKLV FDVH UHTXLUHV WKH ILYH FULWHULD EH
³GHILQLWHO\SURYHQ´WRWKHVDWLVIDFWLRQRIWKHFRXUWLQDOOFODLPV³UHVXOWLQJIURPLQMXU\E\
DFFLGHQW DULVLQJ primarily RXW RI DQG LQ WKH FRXUVH and scope RI WKH HPSOR\HH¶V
HPSOR\PHQW´7HQQ&RGH$QQ D    HPSKDVLVDGGHG 
        
        7KHILUVWUHSRUWHG7HQQHVVHH6XSUHPH&RXUWRSLQLRQDGGUHVVLQJWKHVWDWXWHLV
LQVWUXFWLYH,QMatthews v. Hardaway Contracting Co.6:G 7HQQ WKH
7HQQHVVHH 6XSUHPH &RXUW DGGUHVVHG WKH UHDVRQV IRU WKH SDVVDJH RI WKLV VWDWXWH DQG WKH
GLIILFXOW\SUHVHQWHGLQGHWHUPLQLQJZKHQDKHUQLDLVFDXVHGE\DQLQMXU\VWDWLQJ
        


  %\ HPSKDVL]LQJ ³DQG VFRSH´ ZH GR QRW VXJJHVW WKH SKUDVH DOWHUV WKH PDQQHU LQ ZKLFK D ZRUNHUV¶
FRPSHQVDWLRQFDVHLVWREHDQDO\]HGUDWKHULWUHSUHVHQWVODQJXDJHWKDWZDVQRWSUHVHQWXQWLODGGHGE\WKH
5HIRUP$FWRISeeNavyac v. Universal Health Servs.1R71:UN&RPS
$SS%G/(;,6DW  7HQQ:RUNHUV¶&RPS$SS%G0DU 

                                                       

        >7KHVWDWXWH@UHODWHVVROHO\DQGDORQHWRDQLQMXU\DULVLQJRXWRIDQGLQWKH
        FRXUVHRIHPSOR\PHQWZKLFKUHVXOWVLQSURGXFLQJDKHUQLD,WLVDPDWWHURI
        FRPPRQ NQRZOHGJH WR PHQ HQJDJHG LQ WKH VFLHQFH RI PHGLFLQH DQG
        VXUJHU\RIZKLFKZHPD\WDNHMXGLFLDOFRJQL]DQFHWKDWDKHUQLDRUUXSWXUH
        PD\ UHVXOW IURP PDQ\ FDXVHV ZKROO\ LQGHSHQGHQW RI DQ\ WUDXPDWLF RU
        FRPSHQVDEOH LQMXU\  ,W LV RIWHQ GXH WR FRQJHQLWDO ZHDNQHVV RI WKH
        DEGRPLQDOZDOODQGYDULRXVGLVHDVHV8QGHUVXFKFLUFXPVWDQFHVWKHKHUQLD
        RUUXSWXUHPLJKWIROORZDQ\VOLJKWH[HUWLRQVXFKDVFRXJKLQJRUVQHH]LQJ
        ,WPLJKWDSSHDUZKHQWKHZRUNPDQLVHQJDJHGLQKLVGDLO\WDVNDQGQRWEH
        GXH WR DQ\ VWUDLQ RU SK\VLFDO DFW ZKLFK FRXOG EH HYHQ WKRXJKW RI DV DQ
        LQMXU\  7KH TXHVWLRQ RI ZKHQ D KHUQLD LV FDXVHG E\ DQ LQMXU\ RU PHUHO\
        UHVXOWV IURP VRPH LQKHUHQW SK\VLFDO ZHDNQHVV RU GLVHDVH LV RQH WKDW LV
        GLIILFXOW RI VROXWLRQ E\ WKH FRXUWV  8QOHVV LW UHVXOWV IURP VRPH IRUP RI
        WUDXPDDULVLQJRXWRIDQGLQWKHFRXUVHRIWKHZRUNPDQ¶VHPSOR\PHQWKHLV
        QRWHQWLWOHGWRFRPSHQVDWLRQ7KHGLIILFXOWLHVLQILQGLQJWKHWUXWKLQVXFKD
        VLWXDWLRQ KDYH JLYHQ ULVH WR WKH HQDFWPHQW RI VWDWXWHV LQ VHYHUDO 6WDWHV
        VLPLODUWRRXURZQVWDWXWH &KDSWHU$FWVRI :HWKLQNLWZDVWKH
        REMHFW DQG SXUSRVH RI RXU RZQ /HJLVODWXUH DV ZHOO DV WKH OHJLVODWXUHV RI
        RWKHU 6WDWHV WR UHPRYH WKH LVVXH DV IDU DV SRVVLEOH IURP WKH ILHOG RI
        FRQMHFWXUHDQGVSHFXODWLRQ
        
Id.DW

       )XUWKHUWKH6XSUHPH&RXUWVWDWHGLQMatthewsWKDW³>W@KH7HQQHVVHH$FWH[SUHVVO\
SURYLGHVLQVXEVHFWLRQWKDWLWPXVWEHGHILQLWHO\SURYHQµWKDWWKHKHUQLDRUUXSWXUHGLG
QRWH[LVWSULRUWRWKHDFFLGHQWIRUZKLFKFRPSHQVDWLRQLVFODLPHG¶´Id.DW)LQDOO\
WKH &RXUW H[SUHVVHG LWV RSLQLRQ WKDW E\ HQDFWLQJ WKH  VWDWXWH WKH /HJLVODWXUH
LQWHQGHGWROLPLWWKHUHFRYHU\RIEHQHILWVIRUKHUQLDV
        
        :H WKLQN WKH /HJLVODWXUH FOHDUO\ LQWHQGHG WR SODFH FHUWDLQ OLPLWDWLRQV DQG
        UHVWULFWLRQV XSRQ WKH ULJKW WR UHFRYHU FRPSHQVDWLRQ IRU LQMXULHV FDXVLQJ D
        KHUQLDDQGDOVRWRWKHDJJUDYDWLRQRUHQODUJHPHQWRIDSUHH[LVWLQJKHUQLD
        7KH VWDWXWH XQGHUWDNHV WR SRLQW RXW DQG GLVWLQJXLVK WKH LQMXULHV WKDW DUH
        FRPSHQVDEOH DQG WKRVH WKDW DUH QRQFRPSHQVDEOH DQG IRU WKH LQMXUHG
        HPSOR\HH WR UHFRYHU KH PXVW EULQJ KLV FDVH ZLWKLQ WKH SURYLVLRQV RI WKH
        >VWDWXWH@

Id.
        
        $QLQMXUHGZRUNHUKDVWKHEXUGHQRISURRIRQHYHU\HVVHQWLDOHOHPHQWRIKLVRUKHU
FODLP  7HQQ &RGH $QQ   F      /LNHZLVH WKH EXUGHQ UHVWV RQ WKH
HPSOR\HH WR ³GHILQLWHO\´ SURYH WR WKH VDWLVIDFWLRQ RI WKH FRXUW HDFK RI WKH ILYH FULWHULD
LGHQWLILHGLQVHFWLRQ D 

                                                  

        (PSOR\HH DVVHUWV RQ DSSHDO WKDW WKH WULDO FRXUW HUUHG LQ FRQFOXGLQJ KH GLG QRW
VXIIHUDFRPSHQVDEOHKHUQLD(PSOR\HHILUVWDUJXHVWKHWULDOFRXUWHUUHGLQLWVPHWKRGRI
DQDO\]LQJ WKH VWDWXWRU\ FULWHULD QHFHVVDU\ WR HVWDEOLVK D FRPSHQVDEOH KHUQLD +H DUJXHV
WKDWZKHQGHWHUPLQLQJZKHWKHUWKHILUVWFULWHULRQZDVPHWZKHWKHUWKHUH³ZDVDQLQMXU\
UHVXOWLQJ LQ KHUQLD RU UXSWXUH´ WKH FRXUW HUURQHRXVO\ LQFOXGHG WKH UHTXLUHPHQW WKDW WKH
KHUQLD PXVW KDYH UHVXOWHG ³IURP LQMXU\ E\ DFFLGHQW DULVLQJ SULPDULO\ RXW RI DQG LQ WKH
FRXUVH DQG VFRSH RI WKH HPSOR\HH¶V HPSOR\PHQW´  (PSOR\HH DUJXHV WKLV ³HIIHFWLYHO\
GHIHDWVWKHHQWLUHSXUSRVHRIWKHILYHVWHSDQDO\VLVDQGUHQGHUVDGGUHVVLQJWKHRWKHUIRXU
VWHSVLUUHOHYDQW´(PSOR\HHFRQWHQGVWKDW³>Z@KDWWKH&RXUWGLGLVDGGUHVVWKHILUVWVWHS
DQGWKHQGHPDQGWKDWLWDORQHHVWDEOLVKWKDWWKHLQMXU\ZDVZRUNUHODWHG´:HGLVDJUHH
ZLWK(PSOR\HH¶VLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIWKHWULDOFRXUW¶VDQDO\VLVRIVHFWLRQ)RUDQ
HPSOR\HH WR UHFRYHU EHQHILWV IRU D KHUQLD RU UXSWXUH VHFWLRQ  VSHFLILFDOO\
FRQWHPSODWHVWKDWWKHHPSOR\HHPXVWSURYHDQLQMXU\E\DFFLGHQWDULVLQJSULPDULO\RXWRI
DQG LQ WKH FRXUVH DQG VFRSH RI WKH HPSOR\PHQW and PXVW ³GHILQLWHO\´ SURYH WR WKH
VDWLVIDFWLRQRIWKHFRXUWHDFKRIWKHILYHFULWHULDVHWRXWLQWKHVWDWXWH
        
        +HUHWKHUHLVQRGLVSXWHWKDW(PSOR\HHH[SHULHQFHGV\PSWRPVIROORZLQJWKH$SULO
OLIWLQJLQFLGHQWDQGWKHUHLVQRGLVSXWHWKDW(PSOR\HHVXIIHUHGYHQWUDOKHUQLDV
7KHSDUWLHVDJUHHGWKDWWKUHHVXUJHULHVZHUHUHTXLUHGWRUHSDLUWKHKHUQLDV+RZHYHUZH
DJUHHZLWKWKHWULDOFRXUW¶VFRQFOXVLRQWKDWWKHPHGLFDOSURRIIDLOHGWRHVWDEOLVKWKDWWKH
KHUQLD GLG QRW H[LVW SULRU WR WKH $SULO   OLIWLQJ LQFLGHQW  $OWKRXJK 'U
:RUWKLQJWRQ WHVWLILHG WKH KHUQLD could have GHYHORSHG DV D UHVXOW RI (PSOR\HH¶V ZRUN
DFWLYLWLHVRQ$SULOKHDOVRWHVWLILHGWKHKHUQLDFRXOGKDYHEHHQSUHVHQWSULRUWR
WKDWGDWH

        :KHQ IDFHG ZLWK D K\SRWKHWLFDO VFHQDULR PLUURULQJ WKH IDFWV VXUURXQGLQJ
(PSOR\HH¶VZRUNDQGWKHOLIWLQJLQFLGHQWDQGDVNHGZKHWKHU(PSOR\HH¶VKHUQLDDSSHDUHG
VXGGHQO\ 'U :RUWKLQJWRQ WHVWLILHG WKDW ³WKH KHUQLD DSSHDUHG V\PSWRPDWLF VXGGHQO\´
+H WHVWLILHG WKDW ³LI >(PSOR\HH@ KDG ERZHO VWXFN LQWR WKLV KHUQLD DQG KH ZDV
DV\PSWRPDWLF EHIRUH , WKLQN WKH DFXWH HYHQW ZKHWKHU WKH KHUQLD DSSHDUHG RXW RI
QRZKHUH FHUWDLQO\ , WKLQN WKH ERZHO WKDW ZDV VWXFN LQ WKH KHUQLD KDSSHQHG DFXWHO\´
+RZHYHUKHVDLG³WKDWPLJKWKDYHKDSSHQHGGXHWRMXVWSUHVVXUHRQWKLVDUHD,WFRXOG¶YH
EHHQGXHWRPD\EHWKHUHZDVDVOLJKWZLGHQLQJRIWKHKHUQLDGHIHFWDFXWHO\,W¶VKDUGWR
UHDOO\VD\EXWFHUWDLQO\RQHRUWKHRWKHURUERWKFRXOG¶YHGHILQLWHO\KDSSHQHG´
        
        ,Q KLV GHSRVLWLRQ 'U :RUWKLQJWRQ ZDV TXHVWLRQHG DW OHQJWK E\ (PSOR\HH¶V
DWWRUQH\ FRQFHUQLQJ WKH VLJQV DQG V\PSWRPV RI VRPHRQH GHDOLQJ ZLWK D KHUQLD
+RZHYHU'U:RUWKLQJWRQ¶VWHVWLPRQ\GLGQRWHVWDEOLVKWKDWWKHOLIWLQJLQFLGHQWUHVXOWHG
LQWKHKHUQLDRUWKDWWKHKHUQLDGLGQRWH[LVWSULRUWRWKHOLIWLQJLQFLGHQW'U:RUWKLQJWRQ
DFNQRZOHGJHG WKDW DQ LQGLYLGXDO ZLWK D ZHDNHQHG DEGRPLQDO ZDOO PD\ EH PRUH
VXVFHSWLEOHWRVXIIHULQJDKHUQLDDQGKHWHVWLILHGWKDWWKHV\PSWRPV(PSOR\HHH[KLELWHG
VXEVHTXHQW WR WKH LQFLGHQW ZHUH FRQVLVWHQW ZLWK VRPHRQH ZKR H[SHULHQFHG DQ DFXWH

                                                 

KHUQLD%XWKHGLGQRWWHVWLI\WKDWLWLVPRUHOLNHO\WKDQQRWWKDWWKHKHUQLDGLGQRWH[LVW
SULRUWRWKHOLIWLQJLQFLGHQWQRUGLGKHWHVWLI\WRDQ\RSLQLRQVWRWKDWHIIHFW
        
        2Q FURVVH[DPLQDWLRQ 'U :RUWKLQJWRQ LQLWLDOO\ WHVWLILHG FRQVLVWHQW ZLWK DQ
DIILGDYLWKHVLJQHGWKDWLWZDVKLVRSLQLRQ³LWZDVPRUHOLNHO\WKDQQRWWKH>(PSOR\HH¶V
KHUQLD@ H[LVWHG SULRU WR >WKH $SULO  OLIWLQJ LQFLGHQW@´  +H WHVWLILHG WKHUH ZDV QR
PHQWLRQLQHLWKHUKLVUHFRUGVRULQWKHUHFRUGRIDFDUGLRORJLVW¶VSUHVXUJHU\FRQVXOWDWLRQ
RI (PSOR\HH KDYLQJ OLIWHG D UDQJH DW ZRUN  +H DFNQRZOHGJHG WKH UHSRUW RI WKH
FDUGLRORJLVW¶V FRQVXOWDWLRQ LQGLFDWHG (PSOR\HH UHSRUWHG ³RYHU WKH SDVW ZHHN RU VR´ KH
³IHOWWKDWKLVVWRPDFKZDVJHWWLQJKDUGDQGZKHQHYHUKHZRXOGH[HUWKLPVHOIKHZRXOG
KDYHVWRPDFKFUDPSV´%DVHGXSRQWKDWKLVWRU\'U:RUWKLQJWRQZDVDVNHGZKHWKHUKH
FRXOG VD\ ³ZLWK DQ\ GHJUHH RI PHGLFDO FHUWDLQW\ WKDW WKH OLIWLQJ LQFLGHQW RI $SULO QG
ZDVWKHFDXVHRI>(PSOR\HH¶V@KHUQLD´DQGKHUHVSRQGHG³,FDQQRWVD\RQHZD\RU
WKH RWKHU´  $VNHG VSHFLILFDOO\ DERXW (PSOR\HH¶V DFXWH V\PSWRPV DQG ZKHWKHU WKH
V\PSWRPV LQGLFDWHG (PSOR\HH¶V KHUQLDV H[LVWHG SULRU WR $SULO  'U :RUWKLQJWRQ
VWDWHG³,FDQ¶WVD\RQHZD\RUWKHRWKHUZKHQWKHKHUQLDZDVIRUPHG´$VNHGZKHWKHUKH
FRXOG VD\ (PSOR\HH¶V KHUQLD ³ZDV D UHVXOW RI OLIWLQJ D UDQJH RQ $SULO   'U
:RUWKLQJWRQUHVSRQGHG³,FDQQRWVD\WKDWVSHFLILFDOO\QR´
        
        ,Q KLV UHGLUHFW WHVWLPRQ\ 'U :RUWKLQJWRQ ZDV DVNHG DERXW KLV DIILGDYLW DQG
ZKHWKHUKH³ZDVFRPIRUWDEOHZLWKWKHODQJXDJHWKDWLWLVPRUHOLNHO\WKDQQRWWKDWWKH
KHUQLDH[LVWHGSULRUWR$SULO´$OWKRXJKH[SUHVVLQJGLVFRPIRUWZLWKWKHODQJXDJH
KHDJDLQFRQFOXGHGKHGLGQRWNQRZZKHQWKHKHUQLDFDPHLQWRH[LVWHQFH
        
        ,ZRXOGVD\DWWKHWLPH>,VLJQHGWKHDIILGDYLW@P\LQWHQWZDV,PHDQWKDW,
        ZDVEDVLFDOO\VD\LQJ,GRQ¶WNQRZ,NQRZQRWKLQJRIKLPSULRUWRZKHQ,
        VDZ KLP DQG WKHKLVWRU\KHJDYH PH DERXW WKH KRXUV OHDGLQJ XS WR WKH
        HYHQW  $V IDU DV ZKHWKHU WKH KHUQLD H[LVWHG EHIRUH RU DIWHU WKDW WLPH ,
        ZRXOG VD\ WKHUH ZDV OLNHOLKRRG WKDW WKH KHUQLD H[LVWHG VRPHWLPH EHIRUH ,
        VDZKLPREYLRXVO\$QGDVIDUDVWKDWZDVEHIRUHWKHPRQWKRI$SULOZKHQ
        ,VDZKLP,VDLGLWFRXOGEHEXWUHDOO\,GRQ¶WNQRZ
        
        $OWKRXJK'U:RUWKLQJWRQWHVWLILHGLWZDV³YHU\OLNHO\´WKHV\PSWRPV(PSOR\HH
H[SHULHQFHG LQ WKH  WR  KRXUV EHIRUH KH VDZ (PSOR\HH UHVXOWHG IURP WKH OLIWLQJ
LQFLGHQW KH QHYHU WHVWLILHG WKDW WKH OLIWLQJ LQFLGHQW UHVXOWHG LQ WKH KHUQLD DQG QHYHU
WHVWLILHG WKDW WKH KHUQLD GLG QRW H[LVW SULRU WR WKH OLIWLQJ LQFLGHQW  ,W LV FOHDU IURP 'U
:RUWKLQJWRQ¶VWHVWLPRQ\WKDWKHKHOGWKHRSLQLRQWKHV\PSWRPV(PSOR\HHGHVFULEHGWR
ERWKWKHKRVSLWDODQGKLPUHVXOWHGIURPWKHOLIWLQJLQFLGHQW+RZHYHUKHQHYHUWHVWLILHG
WKDWWKHherniaitself UHVXOWHGIURPWKHOLIWLQJLQFLGHQW:KDWKHGLGFOHDUO\H[SUHVVZDV
WKDWKHFRXOGQRWVD\³RQHZD\RUWKHRWKHU´DQGWKDWWRGRVRZRXOGEH³VSHFXODWLRQ´

       0RUHRYHULQUHDFKLQJLWVGHFLVLRQWKHWULDOFRXUWFRQVLGHUHGWKHWHVWLPRQ\JLYHQ
E\ (PSOR\HH DW WKH H[SHGLWHG KHDULQJ DQG DW WULDO DQG FRQFOXGHG WKDW (PSOR\HH¶V

                                                     

³DWWHPSW WR PRGLI\ KLV WHVWLPRQ\ DW WKH FRPSHQVDWLRQ KHDULQJ >ZDV@ XQSHUVXDVLYH´
(PSOR\HHWHVWLILHGDWWKHH[SHGLWHGKHDULQJWKDWKHKDGH[SHULHQFHGVWRPDFKSDLQVLQWKH
ZHHNSULRUWRWKHOLIWLQJLQFLGHQWDQGWKDWWKHOLIWLQJLQFLGHQWRQ$SULOZDVWKH
³VWUDZ WKDW EURNH WKH FDPHO¶V EDFN´  +RZHYHU DW WULDO KH WHVWLILHG KH WKRXJKW WKRVH
V\PSWRPVZHUHSRVVLEO\UHODWHGWRWKHIOXDQGWKDWKLVV\PSWRPVDIWHUOLIWLQJWKHUDQJH
ZHUHGLIIHUHQWVXGGHQDQGVHYHUH

        :KHQ WKH WULDO MXGJH KDV VHHQ DQG KHDUG WKH ZLWQHVVHV ZH JLYH FRQVLGHUDEOH
GHIHUHQFH WR WKH FRXUW¶V FUHGLELOLW\ DQG IDFWXDO GHWHUPLQDWLRQV  See Tryon v. Saturn
Corp.6:G 7HQQ ,QDGGLWLRQ³>W@KHUHVKDOOEHDSUHVXPSWLRQ
WKDWWKHILQGLQJVDQGFRQFOXVLRQVRIWKHZRUNHUV¶FRPSHQVDWLRQMXGJHDUHFRUUHFWXQOHVV
WKH SUHSRQGHUDQFH RI WKH HYLGHQFH LV RWKHUZLVH´  7HQQ &RGH $QQ   F  
   
        
       &RQVLGHULQJ WKH WRWDOLW\ RI WKH FLUFXPVWDQFHV DQG WDNLQJ LQWR DFFRXQW LWV
DVVHVVPHQW RI (PSOR\HH¶V FUHGLELOLW\ WKH WULDO FRXUW FRQFOXGHG (PSOR\HH KDG QRW
HVWDEOLVKHGWKHKHUQLDUHVXOWHGIURPDQLQMXU\DULVLQJSULPDULO\RXWRIDQGRFFXUULQJLQWKH
FRXUVHDQGVFRSHRIWKHHPSOR\PHQW:KLOHDFNQRZOHGJLQJ(PSOR\HHH[SHULHQFHGSDLQ
DQGRWKHUV\PSWRPVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKKLVKHUQLDDQGWKHUHIRUHVDWLVILHGWKHWKLUGFULWHULRQ
RI VHFWLRQ  D  WKH FRXUW IRXQG (PSOR\HH IDLOHG WR HVWDEOLVK WKDW KLV KHUQLD
UHVXOWHGIURPOLIWLQJWKHUDQJHRQ$SULOSUHFOXGLQJDILQGLQJWKDWWKHUHZDVDQLQMXU\
UHVXOWLQJLQWKHKHUQLDDQGWKDWWKHKHUQLDGLGQRWH[LVWSULRUWRWKHDFFLGHQW

        $IWHU D WKRURXJK DQG FDUHIXO UHYLHZ RI WKH UHFRUG ZH FDQQRW FRQFOXGH WKDW WKH
HYLGHQFHSUHSRQGHUDWHVDJDLQVWWKHWULDOFRXUW¶VILQGLQJV$FFRUGLQJO\ZHDIILUPWKHWULDO
FRXUW¶V FRQFOXVLRQ WKDW (PSOR\HH GLG QRW HVWDEOLVK WKH VWDWXWRU\ IDFWRUV QHFHVVDU\ WR
SURYHDFRPSHQVDEOHKHUQLD
        
                                           &RQFOXVLRQ
                                                 
       )RUWKHIRUHJRLQJUHDVRQVZHDIILUPWKHGHFLVLRQRIWKHWULDOFRXUWDQGFHUWLI\WKH
WULDOFRXUW¶VRUGHUDVILQDO

                                                

                   7(11(66((%85($82):25.(56¶&203(16$7,21
                         :25.(56¶&203(16$7,21$33($/6%2$5'

7KRPDV6XVWHUVLF                                                 'RFNHW1R

Y                                                               6WDWH)LOH1R

/RZH¶V+RPH&HQWHUV,QFHWDO                            

$SSHDOIURPWKH&RXUWRI:RUNHUV¶                            
&RPSHQVDWLRQ&ODLPV                                          
$XGUH\$+HDGULFN-XGJH                                    

                                       &(57,),&$7(2)6(59,&(

, KHUHE\ FHUWLI\ WKDW D WUXH DQG FRUUHFW FRS\ RI WKH $SSHDOV %RDUG¶V GHFLVLRQ LQ WKH
UHIHUHQFHGFDVHZDVVHQWWRWKHIROORZLQJUHFLSLHQWVE\WKHIROORZLQJPHWKRGVRIVHUYLFH
RQWKLVWKHWKGD\RI$SULO

 1DPH                               &HUWLILHG   )LUVW   9LD   )D[      9LD     6HQWWR
                                     0DLO        &ODVV   )D[   1XPEHU   (PDLO
                                                  0DLO
 0DWWKHZ*&ROHPDQ                                                         ;      PFROHPDQ#ORJDQWKRPSVRQODZFRP
 *DU\1DSROLWDQ                                                              ;      JDU\QDSROLWDQ#OHLWQHUILUPFRP
 %HQ5HHVH                                                                          EHQUHHVH#OHLWQHUILUPFRP
 5RE&DUGHQ                                                                         UREFDUGHQ#OHLWQHUILUPFRP
 $XGUH\$+HDGULFN-XGJH                                                   ;      9LD(OHFWURQLF0DLO
 .HQQHWK06ZLW]HU&KLHI-XGJH                                            ;      9LD(OHFWURQLF0DLO
 3HQQ\6KUXP&OHUN&RXUWRI                                                ;      SHQQ\SDWWHUVRQVKUXP#WQJRY
 :RUNHUV¶&RPSHQVDWLRQ&ODLPV

--HDQHWWH%DLUG
  HDQHWWH%DLUG
 'HSXW\&OHUN:RUNHUV¶&RPSHQVDWLRQ$SSHDOV%RDUG
 )UHQFK/DQGLQJ'U6WH%
 1DVKYLOOH71
 7HOHSKRQH
 (OHFWURQLF0DLO:&$SSHDOV&OHUN#WQJRY