Court Opinion

ID: 4072371
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 02:50:09.565328+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:27.186596
License: Public Domain

&0fr-C^_
                                          ylA    /-/?-/£

                                                   14th COURT
                                                        HOUSTONOFAPPPAic
                                                                TFVAS LS

                                                   CHRISTOPHER Z^L I
                                                         CLERK

Afifofc/'/?/Md#//W/&e &//&/ATJMH!d/**U£, 4/4*//d*7*#//76

4& 76 /&6dtf<s ///M&//<fifakf, //# &//&//#/J&£ 76 /%#& /• /4*?
                                       M//Afd.                               ,

                   /fed'*/od
        i/S.                                                      /u>c/tZe£*//*/

Cfdws J*M/eS't*£«// dd                                              /•</-€/ dd steals
                                                                                  FILED IN
                                                                         14th COURT OF APPEALS
                                                                                 HOiiesTON TFV4.S

                   /£d/esifJSss/
                                                                                 AUG 21 20
                                                                          CHRISTOPHER A. PRJNE
                                                                                      CLERK
                                       /pffiT/o*/ dh* /e*tfe /o /dk

                             fy/KZS MfuS, /C'dd<d disss/ dZcJ/f^, &/<*•/<>/? /d<>d£, /a/
 A-i /ddte/i s/t/ted; /fdpt/ts/ dd*t/£ /d> /Zdt drfsC'n/*/ rfS/O/sCf/'*<V dv/? &//€,/
  dd dKrfr/*J#7nZS, tJodld SA/occ) 7&/S /ecrdZ sdS /Z/dotJf *
      /) t//Zdfd Aldtfs ^uJ/ tt///rsad/ /S sfsZ1/ sf/3/v,*VsJ/fot7/u2 /ddW^dd^/f //fedfji/see
         Aod dee'S'd'Z jf /**£ dossed A> de/Sid d,n//r^?£/</ /*?&?<?,/ zi> /£ -od&/
        //e/t/t/'Zt' Zi>* /fdds*/ //Zndtdtr/de, /Ztf/c/*/, *f«/d j/stA'^y /ZrSd'n/66, 6£~
      ~d*ZS£ /eid/v/L/C ///<?S //£>/£*£*/ fri/ldc/td JZ /* ddde/Zid J/fcfyi<f£ /l007<e?f//£<d
       tZ/S/fe /d/Z AdJnfii/ti/krtdidp /d/df^SfS; sfnfd /dd /d7S /1/0//$*£//S£n*?f»/'S£d 76 <4
       7f/e#7 0d d,&Z&'Z&w>z/"Z * /&S*/ssZs/Atdjndj Z?/£ sd^/e^sZjr/iPsZ J&ocfddi
       A/0?* sY/?t/£ &£*/ dfisZfrff&d 76 4f J cfa&r/d/f*//'d/£rf/?/«/4> 7$ /f£Sff/d£ fd/S
       //?&/£ di>d s4d&/d/?dy /Z/Zd /rt/td/dtpcss ffsdsttAd, d/£ /s dt/fg*/dyy znsdd&zi'/dy^
       /?/Zd t//Zd0/ZS7idc/rf*/Z#dd{d sls/ZZys/f/t //Z /Z A>#4r/ //t/f/d/t^£e>l/.
     d?J ///e ddd/tedd/rf/r /t?£//,o/l 4<Z tJ/s/e/s sd /XsseAteS /**f«s/f/it/af J &***!
       diid'S/fi/t/ /<S 70 dvdf // dk/'/jsZ d^d /Z A/*/?'^ s***sZ/&f/fti7S /fdS/yZSd /^£
        dOddd.
     3j A<S &e/d/J/ZOddd fa*// /ddt/f /%££/</ 7* /?/£ <?f'd"d*//dd^d,?*/^ /Z*
       It/drf #d /KM'Zd/t/KZJ, /f#. fa/It ddf^r, /4dfid. d/Z/Z,, ^d/ 4Zf/y dj 7$Z. So/i/sT?
        ^ r; -Ad. tf*t /'& *z<, SifSi diP/faJfaj; &&. j#j frjda^ dd^ fc/J, *<&fejj
        /K S^", fSf #„/£• /«/y" /d/Ht^Jl/nsWs dd- ///d &dn7//*J <d/*/ej ^/*J7^/^
tnJ-MbUdtotE, ddS/m&s flcvsi&&d, /?t6M dS^f/dca)^, /tef/ei/dirl/*/'Sddyw&ed
 Ai/#rt>£ />/&</s /*W' -A//S dwdZ' 6d*JJ'dt4t/£    yfuJuj aPjo^ ^/vuf&i
 dHst/v 6 dk.e MA***/ A94*uM#Hfs. ^<P-/?-/£L &cAy &**/ /***&£ &</j?983 /%<>Se
                                            d)#-d£
                                          li/d// a/o. ,                               ,

   fidt</ /)te/f/Z*JdE/                                              /4/       ///£
                   M^/o/e
        /*-                                                        /&£•/&*&
  7£WS d?£//t*ddtesZd Jd                                           fad/ 6^ dt/Z&'/s
  /df/r?//Z#/(Jzs7fd£' -                                                 jH/T^SW
  JrtS**/id?awe* '/                                                         SSSSS^?^
  /hddd/zs /?*//? dte&/?s                                                  AU6 21
                  /*s/"/J£<//                                           I         <|L
                                                                            CHRISTOPHER A. PrXp
                                                                                      CLERK

                              /td///d*tJd// A dkotftdl U/A/ocJ/
                             //£A*y/9*zw/a* /ddjj /fZd'/i*4/>/Bi\

          -Z, //dd<d d)M/z' dhtJdt/e /£//#*£ /&*/ r df/v /&£ /d/^/urr /*/ /*/£
/d/to/d 6/>ddt/ /M//0/Z /d/Zd 7$/*/ J- /d/n t/*/*/?df rt> //*</ /i<d /dc/dd /as//// db'S
 /tf/sd/Z #*//? /£(p^sA /hfidt d/r /$,£ dbo>d/ /£ zffjdt&d /// d&d/w* d?/te>dbd/s /a/
 ///£ /fdd/e/^ A>c/d/z//a/ ///£ drf/d;<>z#/ ^d/d/d/f-/^/i/ /^sf &£///>/?^r^/z/tenOfj
 J~ /?/* d/Z/zAiJ //>} d^d/z/i/ r tctet/zdl J/dou; >&d dbsd/ ///£ /iddo/J/rfd :
      0) -T /?/*i ddtst^/ //Ze^dd.sd^/ed //Z zi/£ il/s/sd 3 £d/Z/dd/r fa /t&ts dsA**/-
~/r7£tf/ />f dd'/nWi/JcSs/tf, dJdtdS J /f/v //<?//fd*7///fd 70 dS*t*/** ddf/S/idd /*<?//£/.
     C&J £ MZ£ /Zd SOcJ/e?? j/r /nfdC/n£ ad Sdec/S/fd//i/dc/nd,
     d3j £ dZddfWdd d//?S£ *0 dd£d//cd /o /K£ //Z &£ /sZ#7*1& s4zs//rf///J,
    &J d)dd//i/6 /fid //Zd#dd?dsi7//>n/d/z ///f ziz'/s /dfd/ttd/nf,*// sd /d/w/i/*/ ^/zs/ei J~
 Mdd£ /d£df/i/Fd /f*dsf£>#//v&/£di/ *$-/*£* /ftt>/Z/// /?S <£'/*/? dX*/*? /f&iv/ddJ **//) d%/£rfd>s,
   (s) I //f/d/std ttJ/Z /Zed ///fc/£ *a/ /*//fd£s/M /?«/*///£*//</, S/ed/ft, /Set/as^ 0/? /5#ZdT
/4CtccJ/Z/s /t/Zd /£df/</£ a/0 //Zi4/&sj/a* d/Z/0/4/4 /sZd<r/<n£ dvfa/n /&ZVj&c#?/£t
  (t>)j~ M4i/£_/Ld£d/A/j/«//<?.
  (l)j #*/£ /*&/ d£ddS />/* /fddd00//v#d£/<Z' J^M-
  U) Z au>£_$_#j /ss/z/z/e//.
 (<?) #f<d SVCA/////? fZ/ZfA/ffs /Zd£ jd/Ae*vs»»+A//Jj/.

   X, jftidV&*ddZ>*Mt£, 7%dJ*S<dJ3r8, #!,,,,£ d/to£n>diy /**d*dd/*/?i£o //Z //,£ jfe^f
3 Mrf dd /«£ /W /Jfd/vd^fj/ddd/e,/„r«d«z'jtoke /</ d*/ed**/4 d^nW, A** *&*/
d//d 4tdd«et **fie /*<*///d* **e*«ey &*//to /&*&»/£ ^w/; ^? £t* **/<,
fadddd/. ?dded/£d d/Z ////sJl7*'/}*</ds /h/<?c/sf ^A/C

                                                                           '/ds/jfrd /Jf^/Z /VA/d^e
                                           AU6 21 2IM
          /4/         //¥£
                                       CHRISTOPHER A. p?
                                              CLERK

          rdx/di Aba////

       facd/vS Of df/P&tlS

       Ia/I'/ d/d.

       &e#*'zW'dvudte/e, /?eU/d£
                     Vs.

       Tzdds /dfAt/t/m/i//d/ ctewrfd-/
       kJi/!//C£ - /)/d/s/a/Zdf tfad/dl ad />4rfdd//j /*rd) /fa*As
                               fesAa/tie*//

&//£/*/*/ /4d9/0//ftt//d'/ dv/ u£// 4/ /zzt/Z/ls/nz'S
                                      6/A//'Afa

JMJ~ dVA39&                                                             /A/ £t
                    d!U*/<?d
        rt-                                                             fit*/**/*
AjddS £)!/*d//»£r//dd                                                  frjt./ ^ MdGr/s
d!dr/?7/Ar&/ Jcte/ce —
d)/tdfS/c>«/ dd dO/t/Zd Dd
d>/tdde/dS /f^a /dtfe/fS
                   A&S/eA'df///

                                     QdrGsfif/td' /tddZ/dd/sed dbd 6/dj/ dd /H4/Zdd/nZ£

               do ///e //on/6d#d/e c/ts£>6e ad J*/d daue/:
                             domes //otd, /ttcd<d Se/f/J dotted/ /£/#/&/?, /do Ss.,
ttf due rtda/e sdzded dcd/orf d*/d d'di A,s ddr6„z#/ /tddd/wd,**/ /** &d/d ad '
M*A/4/hr»Z£> /Jmsv**/ A S£d/,e// d-o8.*&/; **/o So&.adj, <,d ///£ A**s
Soc/edAtote*// ddd£ 4/Z/z., 4*/d &dov£d> dftocd /„£ dat#j y„e '/o,U<Jss/£ ;
                                           T.
                                    L/de##l ee//sdrizc/fo//

                  /efad* /£4>C£s/ A/J dec*/ /i> Id/tud ///s //s//dw6s //Z //£///
ad l/ded&Z ddnfj/dztfo//.

                                  Pddde/)t/d#/ tftsfod'/

              d /eMd 't Atdc/e ^yfs &zZ>dtd d£d*ds£ //s y#>d*Ad 7&£ /&£<&£
 dtfd £*jg//i*dc ad ///s ddddtt /sz ddA7rd///Z^ A /#£ddd#dd//»d/£djdd /nd/bt'/f/
 d   /#/s dtAHeaA/dd ddd£*/s£ ,
              <?) /iteded Jdt/Gt// A fisddt*/ //£#d>/«/6> Ma d£/n/s&d£ d0d>£d/>s/i>/Z
 (d*/# dd**d Z/rt /Z/£ /</t>.//{&), t/A/dfd drtf/>//*/Z*d d/*d0/»Jd*//d£J &#/&?///&
 d/ /#£ dd/dUdS dd fefcd^'S' #dS dne/Z/tid /»*Z£/ne«fd'dade/neAt/ed,*// /o/zz/d,

                                    JIT.
                               6ld<™<[

                                           -    /-
     dfsAAd, Af£d<dtff*//ddcJ/d/, 7ddJ-G9te398J /s /?,z d>/^A£A/d£d //Zd/*edsd*Ad
 /*/ ///£ Az*?S d£/dd//f7f/Zd'dd /^W\jas/e£ - /A/drtA/'O/Ztd'/'Ztf/j/d/AdJ/dJ,
 /?yd ds /4//drfd«z6> /da js / dZ/^0 /W /f£ AddAd /?/ *Jer/&es i/a/*/, 3 j/ssAd
 A/>A*d, /////sno/Zd, Az^/S 7-7<d<>4>.
     AtUAd //ds d#//dds/dd /d/S df£/*?£d/£S /t;Zd //ds s/p d///dd sdddficA^ /d/A?d{d
 /f/ /dtt/. t4/£ /fd/JoZd/r/ A> ££ /a/zr/dfs/f/? /s a^/aT/s/paW/^ A/dd d/sdd£.7/o/Z«d/
 /A/ /Vd/Cdd. dMZd dd/£ /</t.S~ d4j6Jd*Jd*)j dolt /V6. toCo.)'ddjjfyj; &te /vt •d/Ci/j
dt/tl /<£&.& ddJ//)d^JC3); Aed.goZ. dod£ jMZ., SdS*. *S>/fz/ddjj Sag.dtdJfajdaj, (cjc'c/),
#t/d £e>Xd&e#tdy Af. da/f£ ds/'fi./dad./td/ VJ./0, /VdaJJ; ddd dd j/c>a/£ /V, JO0/,
 77/ui£C>.} /.S.f dd/.dd4>y //, £00/ A*. &«/. ddiJj ddoS//n*&«/6> A?*. goc/./o6t /?/Z/Z.
 SW.JH>/C<OC4d; dn/d SaS'.^dSd'ajC^ dcj/e/j, **/*Ced ddddsc#/?d£ A> diZadf/a/ZS
 06C(/d/A/& ddded J£ddd^d£d /} jfrod), ad cf^/Z£ <d?, JJ>/£, /£dd/ad /dd#d //* /a^ydddf/
 d/o dad/ds/ /d dd/drtd/d A/ed/as? /t/A*d£ds#d<i20A'f /// doc/at/d ddZd/d//ted A/c//ndfd
 /, /*/d£sA</ AzW/^ /&//£ Ady/ndd/d dtd-A^dSY?, /*/ d&##*/&£ So** <Jda dd<dJ
 /dZA//<dul>f//f tzts/d// p/a/aAd A/£ dcddd dd dtedd&Zf /t*/j /Atdaddj A*zd£ *?J?: ds ^s/
 Od/ /a/ ///£ d£d//d/ddA dd /s/jfatfj jAA-PJ J~ J/de// /a/n/v//Add ddd£sZJ£ /*&**{£/
  A/t /dtJf dd A//S jAA dd drtd? d/z/d sAA dd* itz£ ^/d///£d JT^/dJ,
      A/d/dd'j /dda/d add/d£d d/dd/da/Zdd£//f ddae^/// dW^0d/£ doddwd/d/J 70 /a/n/Ad
J^// d// yf&as/dV, c2a/£, 6/A"fe idJ/7$^6 /£//?/<>*> /&**. da/ZdddVdVZtfSd d*£//t/ad A**/
*/ dc/tddd d£ dds/p? d/S /td/r/Ped /Mv/ay///y////^ a**/*z //dA*//A y/d/d/A/d dtdddd
/dd£ *£, JV/Zdd dd£ /dfdd Addda /hr/AA/dAed/A/d da/A*/'/i d?/Sd£/v£A*/Zdi4 ddSS. As/dAl
Mfaded A d?/ dt»*dd£A/ /t/d/ /%£ />////'/£ds&/dd£ Afed dz#s 6id<u#£ MS AnA/dd //dd
d£d£*S£d od/^a/ZL Jto; &>/$, d/Zd d/£ dtdds A/dC£d d»/d£d Jo#£JS d/ dfe Jds/'dZ J/sAsn
£>*/// 6eddc££ dd /As /dd//£&£/ //dd/st/pS. /i/d/dd, 's Addto/d ddd?d£/e, Atdd/d*Zd/&Ad,
/&d££d ia*>c/Z Atdaib* Ma/ay^ /d£dd/y6 tud/ddd d4*zA //£ de/acud /A/dd^/df ///&//>£-
jdd/d>*/ dsZd&d/>?d/s3n' AdA/P/ded d*/ Sdddd //aW^s/ Afdid/dAd dd? ///d £y/dd/Zd£ —
Ad£ /£/*/&?'J x3d*7 Aed-Addd £/S /Wc/Zs/ad dttdpt/rf/z//d/sd/j /a/6 /& d?3'//, AdI
/d/d£0£d d/f/8 df Jd/cAvAa// dddvdd/Zde.
       A/£ Ai/d/dd '£ //£***/*'& &Zdd d/£dd d<d tZd/t/d*, a*a/ /Zdde£#A/0>ZS A*^a d/Ar/)//z6s
u/dd dd/Zdve/ed di£ daddd /W#/ZsA /i A/d /dddPd /??fsir/son/£dl ddMdgg /*A/d ////i>dAid7i^A
SZ0/9?/Md, dZ///d// dZddt/ded 7^/S /£/A76d<d *3/>? /4dd-/dd// gdS /nt/Z/Ad d»az^AV£A//'/&4/A
dt/ d)#/£ ad" d?/7d0£d dddd/Zd£. A£/*Ad's Ad&Ae dt/ds /dPadtd. AfSdAtf //#/** di/dA
tdZd£# Pdd£d/a«did'd/ddZA7S/*Zd£S'j MS 6ZS£ /H«WA£ed /»ddd'ddtZddd//, dd#d 4 dd/dd/dd
 /£sA>A/s*6/6d/ A jWto/Ad/Zd //d£ *d/es/df/zes /*> As sAA's Ass^s/*//, azdi/d*dAtj/
 £i//dgA>d£ /fS 6/£/ddtS d/Zdd//n/A//tdadd; pfe 3d* Ada -/gc/d gdS /Ha/Z//adAV6 S/d/f/^ /J
 762 /M/Cd dd" /dtfdd/ds /f/Zd /d/ead£S S*ddC?£"*ed /dtdAedAd/y' /&# Jdd/^/'d. //£
 3/tfA-ed?-/#£-/?/>/ ///&//£>zd zid^/zaAs/ ^ddS A/tdssS /f/Zd dfddzdd/s ^/J/ddd/tdr/s.

                                        -<2-
      AeUAod dAf/v£ y/zdd/ 7w/s dzdf/o/rd/ddd //,ediZA7sAyd£t gs/£d/dd// /// A/£
 /3dwed& Aass&ss/a//, Aws ed£/»e/zAd/? /w/etf/A-Ad&dAJd&azd ddrzs d££/Zda/Zszdsddd,
  A> /$£ Ji/dd?d/dA// Pz/dJeA/de z/Z d£Aed/*/Ar6 /£/A/s^e^£«/A dd /fddddAtA*,///d J
 &/d /*&/*?* ddddd/s/6, dz//£d£ dz/d£*/de &/ds tepzesAd sy /CdddA* A dd sza/v/dd^
  /ndd /a/ A/£ dbdd£&/c»d dd~ A/d ddddd ad- /dddaA/d dts/d dte/ea&s /ddadAid/sarZ A&frdd-
-/n/6 6dd>d£d, df/ddd'd*n/dAlfAd, /€£/dA>d"f /**£ z??d/Zd£d/d. 7^/S Sdz //d-Adcdd g/S
 dw>*'/Ad/<zc> jVsAs* dzdzdd dd*e# etdd»/£dA>Aed t4/£ A£/d7te, ///zd j/d&A/ y^AAzs
 Ad/dAd dbadd /Pd/ dddPd y/d/dA>4 dfz/sd^, //a/? /a^z^zd/dd Tz^d /fd/£d£d &?&,&£,
/f At di/dd /ZoA/mrdnd/d* #/r4/£ jA/Ad AaddAd<ya// dct-jj-dd.Csse^sbe'.&ydzOL
     Ae/dA/e /s/zeyg t4/£ &4e<d dc/tv/d dd**yd /(-//zs/zdA/zy /aW//z^Af^ a* ztfad/dzdd)
 dd/S Ad/edA, dd/ddd tW£ ddd/td'S /&//?? 7zY/?AAd/dAzZ /edd/tde<d dd/f/fdyad^Ad^d
 ddtd/z/dg, /£/WAj ^zds ddAdrga /nzAwzi Add//*/ddd/?d//za dd7/e£//dsAeA' Szdd*'jdu>a>y
 /z/fZd/dA'z4 &*&/?$ rfc/de dl/l./d, d/Zd d£/Z/Pd dZddsz?//&/£*/ /ydSdtozdA7& /ad#d'j>
  Az/e /<£Cz7deJd3j,{6je d/Ac>d/»£y/s Aawo tf]
     AdAAe d/*/A*s 7%/dA A9s/ayde//Aj eaddzz dd dUdddA/s /**& dt&edAt d/*s /Z/Ad
 ra dv df7//zzsAdz*A dlz// /4 dda/d ddd/t/d* Adyadd/za/Z ddfdd/Ada. 7%£ zfeAdzix's ddddd*-^
~/Af6 UAS d/£d/} 4/ 0ZdzZ£/y z/zZ A4//£0*/rt,ys zd/Zd dzzZdz/Z£S dddS dz/ZdZd/f^d *f</
 dtiddd /fr/df/d/ oa/ dfsdzsA J?9, tZadJ, AddM/dA7$ Aay. Aadd zt/Zz/. SZ&.JSddvPdt),
 A /£Pddrg A* /zz/ea/e /ad zd dd/dd/Tza/Za* A?dd£ yzdddAdAd, t4/£ /dda/d Ad/dd/dd?
 Addze///d zddpy/ d/r fa /adzed /fAe/nwds /&*/** /*/£/?&£ ddds /t^y/azy/dAd
 &d zd dZ/dzzy dd/d/zss Azsvmz/Ad dJ/d/df dzz ddz?/ZA/zs7^//yd AsAdiddd /?A/d d/dd/5££//
d£y/iyd£d A /? Aztw ad AzZdZzzwdy//A/ // /?,/#/ Z/ZSdz/^Aa/d^ yA/£ dfAdddt/rt'zdTfoy
/S /ozZd/S/d?gz) A /?£ z* Ji/dTzd/f/Z/ dddd/?//Z& 7$ /d£ya/dd /4/£ Ad/€a/s. Adsd&n/Asj/
 y/a/dAd Afr/r St&AAj di/d z/dd d/sSd AZe/A/ad//^ y4 /ddya/SS AdAdz^dd z4*AlaAe
 /odPc/A/zAA <&#,£<?/A<OC"d>J, szd/ed.
    A£dd/ad <Sjf?As c^/Aac/Adddamd^A/V/zz/ Azd AddaA fadd /Zd/ dddZd /££z/Adda/gd
 AddswzA A 3Z>f.cdd'dfJJ/Jzddd /?dddc/d£ c/«zdfy ?&£ 6p&/z/d d*/e zfsyazdd ad &d*76ds
 AddaA, /A/S AVd/dSddzdAd/f 7$ // dvaddZK£*/Zad' ddddytg A*d t4z£ Ad/fAd diteS dZct/Zd
 A> ddd</£ y/e/dAd dhyd/Ad/dr ad /zAs dd m* dUetA /eA#s* #z /Z,* ^ad/2d d/dWzjA
  /W/s-*^, jgd 4Wd da/^ddd£ d/£drf/y6/u/d/Zed /dsZd/S zd//£dAAa//S A*/Zd d/^dff/^ds d/Zd
  A/. A?P,Ad£ //</*/. 30<?. #y/CfdJ,Sdddd. /dS/e/Zden// /did Ad dZ//M€s// A zfdzys/d/d,
  A///,n>/£y ad /ntd/d/ d?eddAdJs Ad&A, J££ Ad. d?od:d*d£ //AdZ. &<?, Jds /%}&/{-<//dadd
 de/^dee £Mdd /dd£d /vt.sdaJd/J, /v£. /ada/OJ, d<zd /</6,./a(c/X<JteX3d> ^d Addd/Md/a
  A /dddSad'S /dda/e.
    Ae/d/ad 'S d/d/m da/d dd£s>z/7e«A/'/A/ //,s /Ufr/i fi/j/M //£dd//za /£ /y#AA$/£
 daddd ddd/Zd/A/dd//dZJ A /£/d/d£ d//S dh/Zad£ /cdst**// AdX /ad. dUd /**//. &#,£#/
 doJOJj zzad a/zd<d znzd/ A/£ daddd/ ^d/jr&y£ A, dn/d da/daed A/£ A>y £<*/ dad£ Sd?/ydS
  zWd /3addd d>y/dddayc //So Addd/dS Sy/ts /?/ZJ /yadddd/e£SP dd/d/ZV z£d£y/dd//f£

                                      -   3-
     /add/7 dd/ztdddAds z?/Zd d/tdadts dPyo/h ddz/s A dd/ay /dd/ad*? y /W/y/s/ddd/
d)ZzV dd /Ss/a/dS/d/z/t/ zycc/AiGey/ addzZ ////nt di/,/z/zy Az£ /ddtde /f£y?/*//oy //adffS
ad A/£ /d/^d: /£A/d£ds Ae AdddAd cr /gyaddAo^d a>d ///s A*eodd A Sd /d/dd*/,
(/fZ/deddd/d/j z*Zd Z/Zdo/Zs/z'/zAa/ZAd// dZd A Az£ Saddd<S //Gsd/'s ydds/ksd/ dsZd
dddd/d/dPS dd/c/ZJ'. Ad Ad/dAd d/d/zns Ad£ Jaddd'j d&yA, d/dd/d' dazZddS//, z/zS dddbA
ddS£ dnd/Zddfd, dd/dtd /d d/zS dlrdzs/dje&d'dzdd'dn/d /dd/ayszd/d/rV z/S dy /yAzezzzedz/f/cd
dd/c^y Ae Az/zrAd yyd /4/e /tedyyad /dddayj d/zd /toyo/d A dddwy/d///£ddy#yA
 /6Zd j/dAzs&d^//ddd/e j/r da/t//Hesz/A/,a,z j*zd dzfd? fd/dsydd dd Ad y/dddd/j /cr/d
 yzd/dA/>/Zi A zdd/ade ds /€dd)Z£s4d d/ Add /ddz/dy, dd/yd/ dwAdd Ao Add AdddAdS
 3/>? /da'- AayAdf zwyzday yyaPfd/fsy/ /azy/s d>d/y, /d£j/yAd zy d ddzdz yys/s Ao
 Ad ddddsAd AdWaA ddd/df, zy /aSS£JS/*y dd dddd/ dvddd/y, Ad /fdd/od'd dbse
 /vdyd&z?, dzzd /ydz/dd/d /ad Ad /yya/d dod/ed$ yyA/dr/ /zyg^s //id dz/Zdzy&s
 zd d d/d/Zed /dfi/?d/dd,; dd/' dZddf yad /dAtz-Wz-z) dd zzZddad£d zy Add yed/edddd dztdtdte
 SZ Ad Saddd ddyed ad d^/fdzsd\/o /dddd d Jc/dd/c/tddd*zd dd/d y,*/d>/dG, /// /d£ dtezaddd/ay
 OF /d£ fedd/od's /ddodd. Td/S dddydddp A/Zd ddddzd/odJ ddd/ay d</ Ad ddztd!d's dddd/ddd
 /d&dtntd/dd/ deAeey A£ /£dd/ad dyd A£ ddddd dd /ddd*Zs dya ddda/ss yzaddAd
 Ate Aid. Soto dJodi dyy JaA. dSYd&J: Saddd dy /dddoyj zwd ddda/ds /zd£x /<*/£.fdajda)
 'A ddddaA#e /ddZzd£d r^ddd''AA ddztdA AtA/dd &yds zizdA y d&d/a/z/tddyde dy<dz/dsyd£
 /jd/dAs AdA/ Ayd/Ay *d /ddd/s dZdd y<add/ddy /y /&dez/?yz'dyd J/ddzdzddyA /dd^d /
 PzzdMe /d iz/Ay/ddld d/ dedddi /ted/, /t/ddd'daydd£/P/ A/£ dleAvAd's Azsb /ndydd&G
 zd /&£s£ss/ay dd' d*Af didCZA&z/rAe/p s*Zz3 /zAA/£ ydddd'f /dpczss/'ydfd/ZZ'dA/d dd7
 Ak AeyddtoA*// AeddddS. Azde /yt./a dodtej zA/zwyaAdd //adzzofj tAzaA y dcz//
  /yd fzdd/dzdyA////AddAa/P y£/zd>yd a/ds dsAd/zs-y/zj^dyydy Add ddddd &y^fA/A, /ff^
 /dydd£zz[ dkSdddAa/Zdd/ dddtd/ay A dm/Ad^a yoz*dddfdyAdd Ja-dArrA/odazney/d/zozd
 od £z/dfdds /A#AdzayeddA r/z£ Ae/dArf dd zfaAAA'C /? /a/zd/A/yd/d AcA? ad^ y/s
 Azdd/e AzAdti. Aw ydadd MeA^dayez) Ay. AUdAds dyy. sAA/4 zz^zd Azdd* /dadAz
 dA A/? /dddddd AdddtzZk d/zy AddaAds /vzjA dd /ft/atzdy y<zd ydzyytd A, *z//'dy
 dS Az/£ dWdp *ddd Ad daddd /azdd ddd/£ Afd^d/gd Ad Ad/dAd(f AddaA. A^dfZAy/
 A Aez. A>yAad£/yy ^^.^dddj^y, Ad AdAAyy z* dA/AA/ed A y ydyy^ct #£/**£
 A /ddaA AdWd/ dd y Adszdy/fA/ y&yAdf Af d>odd/ zzzdfd Ad Az4d AdddAdj.
 z€dAdddd£ds ay zzydA&y At /AdAtAze /yd/Zd/ A/ddyApy d/edd/yd. sd yd-/ /&£
  A£/dA/ /d jA//£AA£/ A /?/#// yydSzmd/fyAdyy/Pd/ Add/ddd> /$/ Ad dddd/f
  Ayd/psA/y/ A£ A/£fdyArAd>// did yzd AfdA JheA?d6>yy//z£ Ad /d/dd^y dyyzyse,
  /zdddAazp dd? y Addd dd /a/ZdzAd// ay zfdAdS£/ dd dAW&dayj /£ydde>y„, Az. AaA
  dhds dwy 3a#.<£s*d/eij3 3zm *
        Ad /sAdAf,y#A0yJ>Ad?c/id ya/ ydp£ d?£ydayszd£d£d A £d y JifP/d/fdAd/£dd/yz:
  A Ad/d/d Ad/tAd's Adda/d. Ad/dAy /s yzAd/dy z/zydddA/A ay jAAA /»y d7eA/A*'y*Ay

                                          -¥-
. ad /add/) dyddys/ zv/Zdzy&s A ddddd/zy/' /egyzdd//a//ay yy /yyd/£ d/zzdf/e
  dd#dd /z/dd //yd /ay. s/d/zAds Ad/'/day/y£ /£/&#?*/&/#//{ /&ddg /zd A
"yy/ did/zydd dZAz&dA-A/Ay d/ zfe dyzygydd, "/aysarzAA Ay, ^y dayg y</y, ^yt
 dt^ddhJCdddJ, dA/d dZf'.cZf'sday'dsiPCadjdeJ, Sdddyjd dd yddz/dAdyy^/j dto&,d/4*/c
  /ddsayc. /dAAd /f yydd/zzv/d/yydzzydiysAzi>Ad/Ps*//<y dayd/ygd /y y /dyiz/
  zysA/zAay. Ad/dAdd jz/ddds dddidWr yyy A/dd>dzd£ edzAd A/s /a</d/'/dddyy
 AdddA/e'd zI/a/sas dA/d fad-yAyzzz? /d/zpy A dydz/w yg z^zzyyd dy/Adgj, zyAgydd/dy
 Ad/d AdZdddAd>y dd ddS zfaddA dadddzAdy dy£ Z£dzC d^d dac/d /z/d/Z/zy AdZ/?/edS
 AdddA/'s /oy£ /yd<dady&dAWsegf zy dteAyddd And A yzd /dzz7^y//z^ ^gyAyde
 sy Jgi&yAgy Add/s zdV Ad Az*-d ay z€£ydddz?aydy dd/s Adz&A; A/&g Ad/dtd>ydy
 yyzd /d>gy dd£d/Ad /d d/zf /yda/d a/di z/aV/gyzygy dd /ssdhzdsy/, ydddwdv/ddy.
 /fd/dAe<o dteddA j/^yzd yaVyyyg ABsy/gydygy. yyd'/zz/z/gy\sdyd//0ydy y/
 /3BS/, tdzdd/e sdyyd /zde dvd. /£dyjfajdsj;ad Add. &UAd£ yyy, Jfry. jyjdzJdzM
 de-J- Addddy d/dzzAd A*d~A/gs/*ydgyAddds y A7/y/sAdd/'dcz/d'dyy zfe/ayz/dzdz//
 Addfid/y/Add. A>y./adM. z&zy dra^j^/d^d; sv<?.d2#/d*P0Jp dya S0SJ.d?d3daJddOd</XA>.
 /{ /dd/a/zr? y M/d, jc/yyyzgyA, yyd day^/AMoyy/ /yyzPdd ysdd/A/6 A Adyays
 AdddAa/'j AdTtdA. zfgAAd dyys y£y/fd y ryzy, saydzdzgyA'yzzd dy/zc/AAay^/
 eyd/PBd ddddd/yd ddddycs dk>yyy<s ydgy/6z/Aydd£d!d /d/gy*zpAy*ziojddy//zedyA
 dd/d /y/dfydd /y dd/d /^Sdd££zaydkldzrz Ad Agyadd-Aas/dyd yd/dd/aMf ddzZze/y&
 Ad/dfdS:A ddzA- Ad zfiAdAt'd 3/y //d-Apty A/J d?*z/Ayz^dPlPz&gA/A/ddAzA dd/y.
 /ydcd/nd/ay. /yy/£S£yAy. Ay/d ydPd /gyddsgd Ad Azydzyds yzzd /gzkaw/ZdAay'
 ad' Ayd ddd/pgd d/gy/zyd, yydAdsAAd/y A//d/Adyd>y yzA dy Ad Ad/wAy's
Azt/dA Mdd /y yyt/'//*/A&yA/addAy, yd/yozgy Add Addd/aze yd/vs/Ad A
Ad zW/S/dzygdydd dddgysd &y/d£ yydd/ zOyesss. AdddAd /sdy//d£d) A d dd«/yzd,
JVyy/dzgd/, yyd ydzd ygydzyc yy*j jAdd/zayr /zeddess^ zf/g dfZ ddadgsd dZddzcg.
 /zCoPzdds aw zZdAvs/Yzs/yy/Pe ydddys&e &zA jgy&e*/ /zGzz/s sgyay? /z/s /ddadg
 dddse dePa/fod.
          Addd4y dddzeZds As ddds /zzddd y ddodfd Jz/atJ/yd ad dXd/t/dd'd^zd
 d/d/zAddp' deAdAzyyadpydd dlAzA?, A^ddAd /s yyA/zdy A fayy/ay/ydydd/vzs
/ddzfA /kdd/ad /d /dd£d#//i/ yyd yyddy^/Azydeydzdy /ayysy&<7 zy d /dydd'Ads7f/c^/0yf
A/oddAyG y/d y/^dzAdy/jzMd/zAzfzddA'yad d/ze/dWdyy0*jz/bd/cA//>r//A*dydf/*/y<d<*/£d ''
ad A* ttZ'Add jAA A*ysA/(Aa/yf a<s ygdddS yzs sr^d/zd d<d/j/y/d£*dz9,gyAs
ij/d /daddgs dddydgd, AdddA*e izz// dd/zAyzs A szyygy ddyy>™ /Z/ya d%£<Ad/dgy dA/d
 Addtd'y /dZd&tyydA/d ^ydaysAAzAzayy/dy /ayd/yed /yd /gydd'/yiA/zAoy^ /y Ay
 doPdAedAd AoddAdd yy/gy/s dd ztdaAdddd/ Af df/ddz/s dyjydyddd/sns, {Tczs/'dd
 dd/zv /£S(///dy / dtzsdddd/d££, AdddAd dddzws Ad*Ayysdddddy tdzzz, jAA/ApSj
/ydzCdddd yyay/d &2 dbAdf/ds&d z#y ydpgz^ydAAzddzAtsAydd zy As d/ss #y
dc&Aee /yd d%/dA4?£S dwd AdddA,

                                    -&-
     Adddw/ /dz/Azzds AdAA/rAzdAyysJc&sd/dAoy cyd£d Add y^Add/Aay
Amd /oysAAA&y dteAeAs y;s-j ds/y's~& y/*d y^d /V^yd/g^dd^yA dy As zdyygy
cj/AAs Aay-dAAoAaA/j yd/arys ^ydeydzeyAAd)gyyy/>AAd say^Pd^ ^-^ji^c,
 AdddAd AdpadsAAzr dic/y/ A A^d/jfze u/ygAdy As dfrsyyyypgpcyA /&//&*&/

                          dfdyd/ds/os/
      A/y&dZde , Aedz»*dds AazZS/dgZ&zl, A£ddA>d, yfydV d£dydad/A/^/yaSS,
 Ads/gd/yz/dy AdflzesA/ dz/zdzda Ad/ A£tz4?yypy/ dzd yad yy/zyy ye/y^y / ysz/,
Jiyy/d/gyA dyd Ay&l/zAaydy/ ApyadyAay y/dyS/szd. yyd Ad /ayyy dd/yydays yyd
Ad^/dd yyddA/s7f/zAa/Zy//y d&dto&y Ad/dAd<f AddaA //yy d&edg/Ay yzd 'szfrgeA
  Aav£ "dd£dzAyyy //d£dAds ydd/Ayo//, dyg A yza/izAa/P^ ay /Ad£ Ay** ^y-
- g/ydid/pA /a/£ ^ArAAs, y^z dhzdd ayz4zzedd/Pc yyd dfazaAs ydddAy AVds
Aeadzdpy A Awd/p Ag Add*Ay<d zAaeaA, AzzpAzyg A$ A&AAy's Abe*A, d/e
/ya/zd-yAd AAAdz /&eaA dy y dd/y, j*y&y/gyy'zdydAysAAA^dd/yAd/-
-dddA/ty yey/zyfe. AdddAy'j> AvetA M*z/d yg Ad-/ysAA/J}//gy/ys/Ay//d/ddysdA/y,
 iP/ywp/dzyAf/ /)£dyy, yyd//gszidAAa/yjy z/yzedd^ytdZiAddyAd*£ "//gyzA
/d/ygzAdd ys y AdfZdApy Ad /h&dyAaydyAdddAe's AyzdaA za/ydysvsA'cz9j
c&/<3, //a-d? Ad yidAd py y/zyzyzsAdAdd ArAyfs A dfa&A, Ad/d^ydA/dyJdd9.

       y-/f-d£~                                   AesAddk///Ji/ddi/XAdJ,
          d7y/d
                                                  AbAi zw&a <^Anty*^-
                                                  yf/djfy/kdydv/j/g/, ysysiyzg
                                                 A/d-sd AiddzU
                                                 *XgsAdd 3 ZaZ/A
                                                 jjgsdid A**/
                                                 Addvayd /Azds 7*7rtde

                                   — 4-
                            /y/ydA? Md/yyAd/^d

         u, Ardyp ddyy yaaz/py, yg&yp ddd/ddd d/zdez dgyddyy dy ygd/ddp
 AdAf ydddddd/dd/ A y/P /dd/gy AaA Azg dZ/dA jAyzy/y Ad dd/d>y*/
 y/yd/dyAazAd^y d/d^/dyy/dyddz^ps^ yys Ay£ yzzdd /z/pgd/yydgd Ayys
 d/py y/ddAddS AdzAgd>/£S dadd y/zya/yAd, d3c2,d>ddy dd<z,/>a3,
       —d/6*' /S                                   AttA, Alea^ »^LzAL
              zOdA                                 pf'tf/yddy /2/tJd£//AdddAy

                          /ddA//ddA   jy j£/y/de

       Sy AyyAd)fdy/azcAg/j jdzyd /y/z&yAyyd z^sgyzv/dy/w/£/yAd
/y zidA-zd^ y/ A/dc/£s76d<? cA/,Ay3~JdsAdAdd, zaz dfzddPd&yy AzysTPdat.
Ac ygd&dp AepzgsAAd dti'di ddgyy ad- 7$/d/ac/y/'A /dddzyyy y pdeyd z*rd
Ay/dd/zlayydd Add yz&y? yadddb/y/: dtf&A**/ydyd/eyVzas/pzy d/yzAdy
/my/yznyy A Ad A^syayygyy yy /dA^yd Azp jryy?y ,y y?e y.s. y/dzd
AdjAdgd Adz/. diPydd? /yy Sd zf<sydddey y/ Add /adddA/Ao/d. ydddgss ;

                     AAedAAd/Ad Ady/d/ d//kf€dayr yyy Ay/dAs
                     S%d£> Jdddyd //d£dPAozdgydd/
                     ydsAy, A^jdds /Ms-/

          dJy/e.                                         A'tydd)dz?yp$yiddy//d/d/o/e
                                                                         4#AtUntedrf M-

                                           State of Texas
                        Board of Pardons and Paroles
Bettie L. Wells
General Counsel

October 16, 2012

Fowler, Ricky Dean
TDCJ-CID# 542398
Holliday Unit
295 I.H. 4.5N
Huntsville, Texas 77320

        RE:       MOTION TO REOPEN HEARING

Dear Mr. Fowler:

The Board of Pardons and Paroles is in receipt of your correspondence postmarked 10/09/2012.

Your original Motion to Reopen Hearing received on 9/06/2012 was not processed because you
waived your hearing. Your recent Motion to Reopen Hearing is considered a supplemental
request and will not be processed for the same reason your original request was not processed.
No further consideration will be given concerning your request.

Be advised that subsequent letters requesting the same relief will be placed in your TDCJ-CID
Parole Division file.

Sincerely,

 )avid M. McKinney
Assistant General Counsel

DMM/jsm

cc:     File

             8610 Shoal Creek Blvd., Austin, Texas 78757, Phone: (512) 406-5353 Fax: (512) 467-0945
                                                                                           /4774(!/J{7k£AjA&

                                                 STATE OF TEXAS
                                BOARD OF PARDONS AND PAROLES

July 29, 2013

Mr. Ricky Fowler
TDCJ-CID/SID # 00542398
Huntsville Unit
ROWD-3-11
815 12th Street
Huntsville, Texas 77342

Dear Mr. Fowler:

This is to acknowledge receipt of your correspondence dated July 09, 2013.

Special Review applies to cases reviewed during the normal review process and denied release to parole or
mandatorysupervision. A request for a Special Review shall be considered only inthe following circumstances.

   1. A parole panel member who voted with the majority on the panel desires to have the decision
      reconsidered priorto the next review date.
   2. A written request on behalf of an offender cites information not previouslyavailable to the parole
      panel. In accordance with Section 145.17 (C), Texas Administrative Code, all requests for
      special review shall be in writing and signed by the offender or their attorney.

      Information not previously available shall mean only:

           (A) responses from trial officials and victims;

           (B) a change in an offender's sentence and judgment; or

           (C) an allegation that the parole panel commits an error in law or board rule.

                  Allegation(s) must clearly show/state the error in law or board rule.

   3. Ifboth parole panel members who voted with the majority are no longer active board members
      or parole commissioners, the presiding officer (chair) or designated board member may place
      the decision in the special review process to be reconsidered priorto the next review date.

Your request does not meet one of the above criteria at this time.

                                  ^>
Denise Williams
Program Supervisor I

DW/br
cc: File

                  Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles, Central Office, 8610 Shoal Creek Blvd., Austin, Texas 78757
                          Phone (512)406-5452 Fax (512) 406-5482 Offender Status Line: 1-800-535-0283
y*   llvfS"^

                     s
                          X5
                     S

                         O; ^   »M

                                     SM

                 ^

           ^ X   I