Court Opinion

ID: 4072150
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 02:43:08.88381+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:34:32.093808
License: Public Domain

7&/ %lofiéx `C'/é’/L/<` 17 ('Oa//z/
6@£!/£)407[@/;¢7/)1$/ /4//€€[)’ ' _
/?O»éa)( /5< 305 C¢]o/`”;é;/ f)§¢r)¢am

/! ,5/,>. 73< 7@‘>~7// RECENED

61 / 1 couRToF cR!MrNAL,i'§PE/\LS

194/f :*..ZQQ.Q:_Q@U OCT 29 2015
Abe£Acosia,Glerk '

/?€.‘ FV@é§-?~A

%95/ €I‘Mé$'€ad/'j 0 lid/7 O////// €/€' AQ{M~" /?e/’_‘“"/` /d"' YF¢/
}%He Z'/e-z/@»-,o ~¢/édé a/%/ fe/%&/< j¢é/h,»;.»'@“ w/r% fhwa ,¢>;,

W@/€ dea/ 74254/19¢4 ?/€Jfl,
li
h d ' /(/3@`(?777»

@,ép,z//z 24¢@/ fzé/¢/ 94//;/3; 777
556 / /M ?a$¢/
7€:/7/4.@;(€@ (¢9/@»»/ 751 73`6> 9 7

 

uM,'W?`~C/R

CAusE No.FHobSQ-A

E)L ¢>ARTE gm me coumaF mm APPEm$
ROBERTMICMELSTORY A'T f
APPLI¢ANT 4 5 AusTIN T.ExAs

APPL];c.ANT`s a>E>:vEC_TIoN`s 'mm=_ ass Po»u:em`s Answea
AND THE'TRIAL c.omzr's zEcoA/\MENQATION ‘ro DE_N‘{ HIS
HABEAS c_LM;N\s `

T@THE l-\eNoRABLE couRT :

we MP\:LM+ Pw.»_/\&s +o +t\:s aw+ H_@ QL;U+:Q“$ hwe_ aon
HHQ_ amd w`\ l\ SMQW \’\¢\<>_ C.o\,ur¥ 0.5 $\>Uou.»$',

JuKI_SDIc_TIQN
_ 'i'h{s -C.our+ has misd.‘¢;~l-¥on ?\~o |\Q.Gr +L\‘¢s Pi€od}nt;' Pwmaw¥‘\~o
+w>_ c;.c.P. win ibm ss,z.'.Te,i`r_qul. w+ \€s l AL\€EQA

b`? +@\a C).PP\§r,cm-¥&nd ~H'\L -\»v“ia\ (‘_Dur~\' \‘SS\_\Q¢& order -\~0 dey\\\) en ‘HN'S,
l1’\?_5(>¢'~:r\ée\r\~\s Av\éwe,r“. ' `

wm MP\;¢~_N\¥ mcm$+g $1¢¢~\ wes umw 40 @P,.@,Va\w&e_ +»\L wm
C¢\"c>mé\s for review ¥or '\¥\/\0_ ¥o'l\ou)¥ns reasons: '
l. The_ habeas claims mem no‘l' Ae.¥erw\'ma¢\ b\? ~\A/\Q. \am +Q~H\Q.
glad-5 '\>Q’.Szw}aA in `H/\e, a++ome`e‘$ a$$¥c\av¥-\»wzl fn N’P\ic_awlr§ mem-
rcmdom uao~ins+?m¥essiena\ norms wwab\ e¢»¥léne_s (wmc»b\@_

' \
T…\M’M-LQSMA§\QA \o¢ls.c_T. m+ 305`5\305 ‘o.n. .

.'T\\a. a~\+d‘na:l:$ 0.£~¢‘\¢\0.\|§+ c\€orl‘( 5\\0\»$ `\'\na:\' \'\0. pok\ed \*o inve¢<\~iaq'\’e N’?\§con‘\'$
~ mo.r\{'a\ \m'§’ro¢*) Pr€e¢~ wound o¥ Gevemmm+ ¢wds amd swing ¢.Avtcz +o ?\e.¢x borsm¢\.

|¢

A. M>P\:m.¢\+‘s armada an =m_c,- habeas p.c>¢>\'.r_al:m\ was nw
mesa b‘?¢v\@ lmra com 56 w? +v\e_ S+oie`$ W¢:Hev\ _ mi
‘BQonS@_ efdev\ka.\ meacan ~\»\,\is Par¥tc_a\ar issue mashudth
0¥\ `U/\e, meo~f\'s . ` `

`H\Q._ MP\\CL».A+ \`)J.Oa.\c\ ‘f\ \€e; ‘\“o mawh©/\ ‘H\L§ C_Dw"\'.§ S~`-o.}evv\ev\¥
m Ek{’cw\~e RQMW 3`1| Sw?>A(QQQ S+a+fnc; ~W\ai+hz $tnda‘hss 0-(: ~H/\@_
~l'na\ Cow\‘\' do no‘\'bincl ~Hms Co¢..w‘~\~ m habeas P¢*D(.€Ec\{v\t;$ DA/\A ~\Mcs
CDW~+ mal? make clqu ${m\.iv\e,s when ~H/\e_ record mm nai-saPPd+
`H'\?__ '\’u"\al C,our\s $-‘\I\Aimss. Ic\.cd’ 1931 UDQGJ

CE>J`EC.TIONS

’\we, S+a}a 05 walk as UAQ H`\o.\ C.our\'%ssaes ~\l'\a,+ liow\so,\ CN\¢~.
N'\asor\`s) 0.¥¥§ dav¢# adam Ce_¥a#\'za a\\ M>P\` um*rs .c\atms 919 me£(é¢l.\/e',
0.‘55 xs{'o¢\£@_ ap CQLN\§@l\SQL C R€s?. Av\s‘?. '._’>) \Ir\ $0mmor"?\ AP\°\{LM+
wages H\M- his aau»,@’mnc.e_ wc+hc SJ:a+e§ 9~5 ‘?w P\e_a barga\v\ was
:\\\lc\u£\'\*as"\? Aua_ ‘\'\D his ‘\'r`\a\ C.ounse,\`s $c»{\u»re. '\~o 0 ?msa.v\{'o§£§rmo.~hvc.
c\€,£w§§a B$ msar\{¥‘i) (_<>A- ~\'\/\e, \~`\w\e_ e$' e$$e»/\Se_§ 50 lm\lesjr`\t;a_-\-e. mmiLo.\
hec».\~\'\-\ regards 33 admsed APP\¥c_owi'-\-c> '?\e,a¢:\ Cw. \We\¢e¢\~M/\_£>as\~ \ne,
Kn@'.a_> \~\e. was mw+o\\\“€ \\\ Ll\ w\-¥U`\hew yo‘\?.v\'\~\a,\ ua\-\'v\€,$$ \:E>I`_ m\jr\C-§O\°
¥{ev\ emAe.»r\cQ. and 50??0;~¥ Sror msan`i \'“? c§e_£@/\S@ 53 emma b"€-av\
?s‘?c\/\}ajrr?a eiPe/-\' ~Y'Br §v\§cw\€\"\’ 0,\- -Hw\e. 0$ sLFG/\se. and (n) fewes-\'
mec\{t`.a.\ €`}~Po.s`¥ 5\,»?(>0¢‘\' c‘l\)~sr`\r\@ p\v_a Pfouz,$$ Know‘.v\c; APP\\`Law\' wa.$

¥c\).§°m@ Se,\luhl ?5‘€0\~0~\£0 med`\c;a;\"»ev\?> od' ~\-¥mv, e$ P\e,o..

GnQ__ oS-H\e. mos+ im(’odm\\' dui-tss open ca4-40an szmsmlriv\'cs a

¥\\`s d¥eM-~'¢`_S advising ~\`»\AQ dJénAo»\-\' aboa+ whsz he skoald Ple,~a
sucu~z . u.s-\l. umw ma F.?>A§'n 530 Cs‘“"¢u~, ages . ibm a++m\¢?
£0.\§\”\\5 ~H\\`.s eb\¥¢;a¥§ev\ b'~? ¥wFom/\\`ns L\¢‘s altev\\»o.\nou.+¢m ,(`e_\e.\l Qv;‘\-

3`\

Ctrcam$}once_s md ~Dne. \i\~l’ ma\£.a_ am §ndz{’enden¥an¢\\in¥a\l£ Gm+ weeks abou} \_ul'\z+¢/\ev\ '\~0
uaw a»»¢.>`\ea Q§-C\>.rw\l¢ss. _»\e`¥a\w 'umde¢~slmé.s irm w:_sl< §§
Prbw_zd:n@ Jn>'+rta\,.see. a\_<,o EM>T+¢_ umw 3~<395\0 35~\%1\500 wequ

17/\ discussing ~\/.b\ese Pre¥es_<%c>m,\ henw\s.,~l»?/\e_,$,wprew\a_ C_D_w~-\'
541:\.{'€£\ (- ihj~¥l`f C\c,r l¢§soc.¢a,Hon
%jroudams lamb \\»L\~L \¥las. wit kbe S{'ov\Awd,s ¥Dr CMM:MJ Sas+¢‘¢a 4
+1,\ +.D ~1~9.19 ca4 m wm irm s&»:¢\<\am alma/ma dea holt
es+ab\\`s\\ mu\'\m\§ cal ra\e,s-1Tl'\z u\¥tvv\ak goals .¢s¥ iv\&a§r»\’ WWL$¥
bo_ on ~W\@_ QQB\Aavv\Q»»¥c-;\ ¥¢.‘wm,ss e-$ ~U/\Q, P¢‘euzedh'\ss when \S¢S'at+
16 b&d\@ clinallev\&;eA-.SH.\;,\<\¢»A \0‘4 $1CT0\,+30514>_. . ‘ ‘

Followir_\s `WQ. SuPrew\L (`_ow~¥s dfw-drive \Tc~l~as C¢§u»»¥s -F¢,»rv\"\~o_ ~H/\o, __
?erl¢ v\Q.v\-\~ Pra\l¢`s.on s£\l'll\a, proge$s¢ono.\ Ra\es ap Com§zar_¢\' Cle\mu;/\ZLG,\L m
l 193 . ~ " ' ~ 1 .
Cb) 00 \aw`f£\”é\'\at\ e,$»Pla¢v\ annan ‘\"D ~\'@/\Q. P.Mev»+ fmsona\ou

necessath ?e:w\:+ c.Uavx-l-s +¢> ma\rorw\ed decisions mswa.‘nc.'
re,?re.se¢~\ahm. _ ,A

f\'\SDH/\LT€MS Ra\e,s arc Pf`b£zs§c`e/\o.,\ (‘.ov\¢\_ac|’ \'Zu.\e \_¢S\ (\o)
O,>) I“ m>w_§@,\\mg a c.\:a+.a \Wee¢~~:,mu N;>+»

\. necle¢,+ a\usa\ eman whas&ed +o W\e \aw*?cr»
3 FWW\»WX~¢_¥\ +D carr‘\’ oak comPle+e\‘r’l»/\ne, abl\£c¢\s`on 4{'\¢}~|+\0_

laa)~€er owes +10¢. dfw
CC) ks azcl u\_‘~\'\Ms d`ule- nesslu.+ ?>\Ev\¥~fies \\\c\~\»+e,w\')\lev\e$$\¢`v»\/olm‘v\cz
tx tmsc_§ous dtsr_ezssw~d-\"sl"¥ke. raspu\$'. br\c+\e.§ owed 40 a clie\~-\~.

C;Bud\§e,\ was `\¢\va\e¢¥ b‘t° P(PP\.¢_AML ~\»b\a_,+ k'a. ¥-\¢1¢\ adm 54er o~f» model
\\»\r\e_§s am§ Aw_ ‘\*o \'#\‘\w\ no~l~»~\m\, (BPP-mm°.p.ib*"\.

731

"“\e,\\a\oe`as <‘L`C~.erz\ s\r\‘@ws ~\»@i\a:\' CQ\)?\$Q,\ a\tlc\"-v\©~)r£'bQ,\¥CWLAPPULa/¢\~
b&(.ause. \\ c never inves¥fc§c;¥ed M>?\,¥Loy»¥s Pr§or"me.v'»l~d mm~&s'.siae
CM&>\.‘men/\o. 955 L’i'l»£&“é.\'; M+;AFP. Q~._*._ ‘)"¢‘Uv`\c\er Paksepv'b,{~mses)

'¢‘ ¥ ¥W\As +<> SMDQ,'M Coa`:\s"e,l ?vb cured sevemw\ev\+ -fa¢\¢'\_s $a~ md e,)tPe,~jrv

w emma A.;>z>\rua+ m warwg.g +im+ Mc>\.\.»_¢w+ wm wang mmr
tllr\ess sea C¢W . AFP. P. .1. * B.N@vwb~¢\'éss 1 a¥+b\e ~:MW._PN¢>}~ 116 ~`\ws

'e_valaa+.‘o/\\ Camse.l npr Dr`.l=LLléL_ wm Lm£emd aboa>'k M\Le,sjrf@&n~g
N>P\&`co.~\~s 9mm marych P\’\‘s+p.r‘\’ am saw t'_mC.QrV\QL{' 419 male_¥er\.)an&
\:>"3 M§M¥¥ms A\°P\.‘cav»¥-s 'F'Y\aM-aJ dimmosis. CD\»$@\ base¢h hhs
1ang rcd»}ar\o;\ {'D ho`} Quwsu~a am ~?v\§av»;\[§"cia,$ense_ base¢\ ov\` \'\§s
PF€.CD\!\¢@NQA CaW}L;¥?&/\. '3@_€, CM+~ M"F' p'_`>.-.. )¥

“` Q\!\L`z C@¢)n$el~d¢`d CI'(\A ~Ur\a:¥ QSBWCM*L».G& Tnc§eac\'mer\\*c\;l\"l lille
a maaes¥ bQ 06 me+o ma MP\¢`Laa-\~ wanda aka M\A"Pcss{\>'\~!
rhosp¥lra\}'?_ecl ( A++.W.p.i \,(Losnse,\ slrt\\ ¥sv\em& Pef-\r“\r\e.~'¥ P.,\n%AQnCrL
0¥ wev\¥c.,\ V\¥s+vr‘¥oy\¢k mevv¥al ¥W\ess ana ProuLeAeA 4-0 P»f`€§ew»\' A»PP\"LQM~
ama P\a f§¢ma:.\~ ac mea-115 nasa U\++. \Arcc.'¢>s_?»_ x`,am§e.@x“
ms $a:-\¢A:v\ ms vo\@_~ §§ gavo'@e. sums arm m`k:§ rar@smhm ’
§e,\l' B<»_lou> ow\ j®\o;\'e¢_¥t\le s+m¢lanc§ §§ reasonableness

1445 we\\ \\,\t\§¥-\s ~\»wz_ l w
(`.u\\lid-{on_o£,a Qersd\ l».\'»o \`s »mev\Jro.\\‘€ ¥v\r.-omPe;\-evv\' C \`h_.‘\».fa\\\’av-\A
aH:~\; §§ @¢§@As@\.' fszsm€\l.a.s. ?>50_ a.s.%\\ 1111 s .cr. q»lo. 100 Lm.
'5‘1.>$£\‘1 SLQ Tk¥s Cov\s+;-lw|~\‘snai v§cav~\- cav§v\o*\' ha waived b¥? ~H/\e_
¥nw?@+e¢\+ b~? cw. \W P\ea ar s+b\@r ames wasn v,l>_se,+o Lm F ad\&l»§.

"L\,\L»¥\Q a&a.\W P\L>_a may 10th be ak+ac;\.\\""\) P\€,u LL-c'§'€r 5¢.>»'§?1\(.\¢\65 DT\ \W('_

&>mm\d ~l»§\c._§l¢\§$ lc».u.).\?er p.§_‘@\\§c\ed him §¢\e;§§er_-§§\/z ass §_s§cw\u'_ §\e_ mud
clamms§m.;§e m Cc>u_v\§als aAv§ Le. was no§ m§~H/\§ n ~\/§/\Q. mnc;e, .~.§ r_m\Pa,§e§/\Ce.

c§e_§v\a§-§M 9§ a+§crne~€`s m utM.NA Caseé. c~v\c\(:n §§\e§"e_.s a msa/mbh
Pfe\oab.\§§“¥ ¥\'§/\a§ \Lm,§£>r Ceo:~s@\s G\th‘ \r\c_ wmAA c>§ ne§ have O\Qr.¢le_c§
C<>u§\§‘\) ami moul& have____ §n$§s§e:zl 91\ Goi..#\¢§ §o §r§c.,\. Mt\\\l LJ>¢.\Lkw-§ LIW\_.\

§3,5£.»5¢§ §lebs.¢fzu>b\z>¢°qmo[ms,s).€ee,axso w:\\:@~\s \/.53@+¢
aqss‘w.a¢§‘zzsco§qo;»> LT+,Ap§>_.w@¢Q mm Pe,§.§¢§z\>.

' Ir\ §>+m~ MQFAS§ +irw. 9\ pw§ Q§¢Nxmt\$§~m s§r:._\<\aml Lu»¢°u.s.
L>L»‘Z\ 1014 5 .LTQ`QSQ. (1‘§ 843 c»\OP\§e,s §o` a `c.o§\a §zm_\ 0¢\»§¢;§< on ~U/\a
\Iolw\~\~ar`mess name @§¢~ GJ\,»TH»‘€ P\?.a en l§'"`cwv\e¢\dv»\e»»+ Csou~>\s. no
§§ Lm$§clerec\ \¢.no¢..o§v\c; ~or\lo\uv\’§£-rq§\`»§»ma¢)o_ \L\‘? §v\e.§§CL-§§\le. &55§5'\`0\(\(_9¢
9§£@0./\5@,§ .5@¢ €)~ Pw~§e, 15an loe\ swaé 510`3’19. C\€RDB. SU abc
€§L Pc»§~§c §§Lw:¢;§m mo 5§.»3¢\~53§~158 tamm

T\\¢L \5+ §)FQ\£>“ e§ H¥l\\l Loz.lé\r\c..r§ \‘SOJA \`v\&u£;¢'~"{ §vy§.o w§\M/\A`ev" Couv\$els
QAM§ce_ §‘c.\\ below cm objec.§¥\la m`§v\§Mum ~§W‘e_<.§\\/\o\¢l`o_§ Cm-P@/'§w\¢e_,
W"M u§sc.,+ 57.5@_¢»\30 w:\\§a§“s 61~15“+ ews¢»m\ lé.>b@,.r QQQ swaA
95:>»33;\ L're..~,~.cr.'APP. \qqqd'. Q-,e_c¢MSQ, `§b\e_re,go§~d c>_s§uh\\s\\e.s »§§`/\a;§
C§ULQ'§o ('_c>uv\$_<. . E§§or§$
'\'D.§G.\\laé’& §§/\Q, §`\~u~cz,§§oi\ bl€ €,\c`c:§i§/\c§ `§'\/`§a,\ C¢D¢)AS@,LS fw§C:/\Ae_c\
O.A.\L\`r_c_ \l\'a amda.>z§§ C_¢mna'\’ e,\§~`.v\c~+c_~\/§/\e_ Pr‘¢:w:§\`c.§a\ Aa§§dev\d\).

'_T.C a(>P\§u§\~L§\e_ Qro‘¥ess§m@\ nd\_ms &\m»d~l €\?e,ai§ c>.Ga§ns+ C_oun$e.\`s
(`€P\"Lbe_v\¥\~c._,§\‘or\. ‘A~Q)P< (_`Q\.».§c§\fr\@,$ §>RQSC.N\)Q, (LOon$e/\ Cx.c\u,§\) +O l`r\\l?_$§`§€a:§€

PW§\QF\U§sA¢§~? exists F¢c;c.n:\\ess 0§~`\/\¢\@. mcm$e¢\s adv~\:ss:ov\s

oc‘ deem §@ ?\ec.c§ amt\h’. l~l*Li.l Du+~€+@ D»~¢esH z;¢`i<’_.’mese, @:dltne s
also A§c.§cc§a ~\»§\a,§ Cow\£al %§ww_SA'NQT`P_v\Sc\£e_ §v\`(>\eo` d§_scus§cns
m§§§/\ ~\-\/\e_ Pf‘c>se_w_§'§m\ 0.§-\-9¢§\@\2` under no c_§m_uvv\§§ov\"m.s ~l~o (`e_wmmenc§
‘\`c:> ade,§ev\c_\cm§ G`LLMD‘§C»/\u_ Q§c» p\€a L>.Me_$$ &PP!DPF\m§L `w\\lcs'\w‘c§o:§§m
m s§u¢\§~€ §>§~H'\@, casa was `hee§\ Cz>w~§>\@§eA. wm E;W\Ab,\:»u> »\-LD.\
du§°€ +0 `?,#~P\c>m -cl~`§?©£§§§m w¥§b\ow+ '\`v§c.l.(§).

Iv\ C,§~§w»§v\al \§§§5¢¢§§90\0§5 ‘m o~`H/\€§~ m§~§ers -\ §v\§e§m@§to¢\ §§ ~H\e \§\o §`5 \`EY§D/uw§ e§
`\'§A€, paris Cwno§ SQNQ_ ~L('/\e_ d§ev\§ e-§-§`e._¢§§del\c). § w '\/‘§L»o w§ C\AQ,QMQ§:§C
§§\\!cs§\§¢.,§{v\¢;\‘K/\Q, \aw`lper §§ m>~§§`na §c>§§§§o\r\~§o make -\*l/\e, he§§
L\_‘)& §§ Sur.§\ med/mm §S'f\n$ C»§ Cev\¢§uc,-§§v\£; mch cli§LuS§O\/\S C~v\o\£)\`
~§v\`a,\ 5'\'¢`¢.:§2(5“3 e,_£§eL,-§Ne\\\) §T\n€. law‘~€e¢` has a Subj§cm~§§a.\ cw_§ l`mPor-§o»¢§
wh ‘§o ?Qr§bm\ §`r\ ra§s§¢\c: m§§§_cm,-Hng _§w.+ors bb~k¢\ ~§z> %\c ‘P§/`c>$c),w§§m\
§v\§§§c§.\\"§) N\c§'§m>`§§/W_ Co¢)r§ c»¢§ §Qv\+@/\L§I\S.'Iv\§orwv.,§§o/\ Cov\L€."v\§d\G
`§'§'/\O_ de§e/\An,w§'s bwc$mwd§e&uc,a;§§w\ § mva c\u\¢§ mo §§0/\§:.1
f>§abz§r§‘(av\¢§ §c.MW r@\p,§§ms\/\“§Pb -w‘s ll be r@'\e,\_ca~»§. as wz'\\ MI§IC»:@§RM
C,§v~wms§w\c¢_s jurrw¢\¢§.v\g §€/\e, (`_m\~\t§§§m 9§~'\§\€. @§§e./\s¢ §¥se,\§.
Iu\uef>§`\cm.:§§ng‘ 15 ei§@~§§c.,\ ‘\"D ‘§;JCTllMQ§/v‘l'e§%esq §7\5\/§§\`0\!\5.
S§r.d<§amct \@»\ § LT@§&D$L~.\S§>§:.D

PREPONDERAN¢E QF E\l:coence
FQF en§§§\emev~+,§§-.x§/\Qbea_s Gz,\§e:§ b“\)\o\ f`€,\lp`@c..)§v\¢; Ceu~v-\- APP\§`¢_a»/»*\'
mus§?ro\le §\{s CLa§Ms/bQ c\ PR,§’o/\A®I`o»/\La'. @§~H/\e, QM§A@¢\C_Q,.\A¢\§Q‘\§\I-
agnew-m com . com m. u. m>P. emma swank w \\awv§_,s\ comm 3@\.
§.05(9\1.05:? (,9~0¢>\3 .

‘\'§\e, habeas Fuo¢z§ § b\§ a §§er demmm e§ e,\x§c\mr\ce, 3\,\0§,)5 ~\»?/\q/§

§§

Due. ‘\'D CD§)¢\$Q,\‘S dec§$§`o§\ '\'e Wemc,§'\ure.\‘§) e§)ncd§/\c\®§\ §\§S `§t\\/eS-\~§ c;e..-\-§‘or\'
§-_§£ §=§PP\§§-_m§l§s m@c§§w §§§_=§§§>§<§> cp.§-§. mfg §>§2\_ §§ cQQ§§SQ,'§ §§§§§5 §§,§§§§§'\§
~§D ‘§:u§\¥rl\ §§§5 rem e$ advoac§.§~c cw\¢§§ F¢§‘§'\u§ §-§o:
\.pm£§e§\\- c».AL$e§\C§L 941 §n&o§v\§§'~§’ o~NK/\e, §§w§e, 9¥9$$€\/\5€,. Lbr§b§.\/§AS,
e§§e,mw§l>§§>§>lzw§£s mm§~¢.§§aum &§§§§\§§:§s -§-e,§a» w §>§§»,.§»,§§§5+§§§¢;
med§cn.\ §\§5-§§>§~'~? o$ §\§5 §§\ne$$e.s § med§cd§§m c;.nr_=\, Pc§§~c.lL 54§\'5§,§\03§0§\5
110 §`ew\a§`§/\ 9§/\ mds ~\?§w~o§.§¢;\§\ mw~§c.§ hm\~§*\/\ WM§/§+.

§§m@w\-al S+aA-Q, AQ,QML maJ-€ hach bean o§ P\Q§Js§b la cle,§:wxse_ £o§r
§§<§>§>§:§§-,§§§. a§§§§§§,m J‘A,W+ M>§>\:L¢§§§+ §§QA amax wang §Y§§»_A'.w\§§,§\
LP_'>§’L§§§>+§\§>P~L A§.§E§>§c§§~.a saw r§»,\QP¢Q. §>S;§§\§~_s §>§M§§>§A s¢§§‘.~§e - `
P`\\fe)\§a § hew w§“`H/\ A§§`Q§..>/\§ hair \§.§§m`; r§§\§~+ £r§>§~\ wre§\§ among

_ haul Cev\$u§v\(_n_z£ c».Iuv~“{ e‘\" §\'§6 vv\`§§r\¢§ F§/`ww__ &/§'-L§ ML §9-§: Hx~@, 9‘;£€§~»92.
'§§Q__ WS\M,§)§\§§`{ €1~§6‘\'_'> '\’\na:§’§‘§: MP\\CSW§' w€w“§'\'o'-&v`§`a.\ \M/§§.S wc>§.§_§§c&
0€ bQQ)/\ ~§»§,§v_ o§,§)§'co§»~L\-§v\ §_.,\/\:d§~ §§§°P\§§_c§§,§-§ wou.§A §'\c§m»_ §Fe_?edr@¢!§

_ P\ec§ o§v\Awo§,§.\¢§§\c§xe_ we§~+ §o -\'v»~§c,\. '

3. §\c§ye. APP`§§L¢>§A\» e_.\§c..\uw'§ed#§’-e§~ `§v\$a§/§TW a_:\' §§~§w\a. ®-\;
§_».¥~C§§§§Q, §_W§ §_~.c§§.'$@¢§ §\:M+Q ?\§,§A §§>§§.~§w@§§.§ ¢§MG§A $@+S
§§vswe_c§ a§- §§§-L e¥-§o£¥e¢\€a §\§;c'L§ clv§'~§ \ r§ 15\\§» §§/).ow~ §.J/z§.\E
L§§PPJY§W. E§§§'.\D§§ »§-a\ <.0§/§¢\ \.}d . woods +§»m 0§\6 gm

(`.OU§\S§:\ § \>ecc§u 51 \\L A§`Av\§=-\' beher §¥PP\§`L§:§M' cJDQ§§§/'\' -\\§\e_/\-\'QJ\

§\¥5‘\`0#\’ &bov~§§o§r\Q/.\ `§'§/\Q_ §A§aw?§“{AQ.-Cc§/\Se,. C A'H pc-€"§:`§Ao.u§“+ ®_2`» §§

5 §\9§-§ `@§7 L§.>§§v\§zs§e$’ §...)'¥§o udava ~\-O ~\'€5-\-§;“? Q§/\ A'PP\§`LM|CS
bdr\c§l§€a§\d §§ §es§*§¥ §>¥ \APF\§‘ ww§s me§§r§c.,\ QP sams Lme./»§
4 E~L§§§§>§ §§ \ Q~B. § (al\.s)§m¢§ $`-ou§\
"§§ Qe§iz§,§,es§- §>_LP§’.§-\’\'D c§_’)§§$§' m P\C£§ ¥\e,BD'\‘§c.. -§§;on§/ §€v\D§,§)`§v\(§ -
`\’§M/+ pcPP\§CA§/v‘§' wa$ 9|‘\ c.>O/\IU`G..\ l\/\€c\\(_a:§\D/\§: LPS°§>c,\/§c>~\»§c_\ ?_\L€v\
T§'\DM“L\'\Q,§ (,§Y\Q¢v\ E~I~§ 5§. (_Brouv\c§ Lp§
D§)§L§§> M>\>\§ cwa s\§§~§§>§§~§w¢` § §\§\es$§§c§rwo§¢\ ov§¢§- \H/§L §v§u,\~‘§c.a.§§‘or\
§,§5§:.¢£ +D exam L§:M\J§§\e§§ wm new §§ §>6§2§,\§:¢.§§.1 §§§§>§§:+§§§§§§§;

"7§

‘\*o LlI/»?Ld \Aéur¢ ~H'\A>P B~W\\`co~¥£, 'P\ec._ L...)a¢ lC~\»@\o_,@.u Aev\ce_\ NPP\\`¢M~\~ has SL\Q.»'¢\
H/\aj'\\/buz ~LN@,\ (`_euvd's \I`e_r.o~\me.»\¢\)e¢.\ wme ov\ D\C ~H/\¥.s Cws~e
as na+ wave haw gm m raw ana MP\:M r@wb¥§ ms
C®L)M's Q\ev\e:\‘? Fe.\ll`e_\..o @r\ \L»?/\Q, mar‘{’;¥s.

L`{§U.b al'\'e£l
-LF£ v\~

    
 

CER.TJ: PI¢A:rE -_@Fserw_~cce
:\; -.a@bwv m¢m'\ \ S+DH\ do ML.~M¢M¢ @+M.ww 9mm
&bw€ P(€a¢\`w\zs \r\c.:$ b€zr\ delle b‘»? 1°05`\&,\ Mc»'{l `|’D A’\I>Q/\
M@b’m c,\em¢ el C@Lm)r 9€ C\Nr»~`m¢.,\ D(PP@.?n$ inez

w\`*‘a\ S+a_~i-\`W\ A»uS'Hv\ _|_\I~ `7'8"[ l\ @[\~\»\M>_, iii/dog &_CM

3\9\§.'
ez@»M#W_jl/M?

1#133"1'1'1
RQ\>Q»¥§+N¢€ tLHWcrr~Pr_

Q~Lol.o\ FVY\ Qc>b`"l
T¢v\m§su C@\'DM TL") §%Q»/