Court Opinion

ID: 9930476
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2024-02-06 22:14:34.559364+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T11:18:23.249068
License: Public Domain

Filed
                                                                                       Washington State
                                                                                       Court of Appeals
                                                                                        Division Two

                                                                                        February 6, 2024

    IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

                                         DIVISION II
 STATE OF WASHINGTON,                                               No. 57456-0-II

                               Respondent,

        v.

 WILLIAM SCOTT AHRENS,                                       UNPUBLISHED OPINION

                               Appellant.

       CRUSER, J. – William Ahrens asks that we remand his case to the trial court with

instructions to strike his victim penalty assessment (VPA) and his DNA collection fee due to recent

statutory changes. The State concedes as to both issues. We accept the State’s concession and

remand for the VPA and DNA collection fee to be stricken.

                                              FACTS

       The trial court found Ahrens guilty of three crimes following a bench trial. In October

2022, it sentenced him to 8 months’ confinement and 12 months’ community custody. It waived

community custody supervision fees, having found that Ahrens was indigent. The court at

sentencing told the parties, “I’m waiving what I can” before it imposed a $500 VPA and a $100

DNA collection fee. Verbatim Rep. of Proc. at 136. It later entered an order of indigency for the

purpose of Ahrens’ appeal of his judgment and sentence.
No. 57456-0-II

                                             ANALYSIS

                                     I. DNA COLLECTION FEE

        DNA collection fees are no longer authorized by statute effective July 1, 2023. RCW

43.43.7541(2); see also LAWS OF 2023, ch. 449, § 4. Although the amendment was not in effect at

the time of his sentencing, it applies to Ahrens because this case is on direct appeal. State v.

Ramirez, 191 Wn.2d 732, 747, 426 P.3d 714 (2018). Accordingly, we remand with instructions to

strike the DNA collection fee from Ahrens’ judgment and sentence.

                                 II. VICTIM PENALTY ASSESSMENT

        Ahrens argues that we should remand for the trial court to strike his $500 VPA, and the

State concedes. A recent amendment to RCW 7.68.035 provides that the VPA shall not be imposed

against a defendant if the court finds they are indigent at the time of sentencing, effective July 1,

2023. LAWS OF 2023, ch. 449, § 1; RCW 7.68.035(4). The amended statute also requires trial courts

to waive any VPA imposed prior to the amendment’s effective date if the defendant is indigent

and moves for such relief. LAWS OF 2023, ch. 449, § 1; RCW 7.68.035(5). Because his case is on

direct appeal, Ahrens is entitled to the benefit of this statutory amendment. Ramirez, 191 Wn.2d

at 747. The State agrees that Ahrens is indigent for purposes of the imposition of the VPA, and we

therefore accept its concession and remand for the VPA to be stricken.

        We remand with instruction to strike the DNA collection fee and VPA from Ahrens’

judgment and sentence.

        A majority of the panel having determined that this opinion will not be printed in the

Washington Appellate Reports, but will be filed for public record in accordance with RCW 2.06.040,

it is so ordered.

                                                 2
No. 57456-0-II

                     CRUSER, J.
 We concur:

GLASGOW, C.J.

VELJACIC, J.

                 3