Court Opinion

ID: 4047523
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:25:41.046216+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:38.782354
License: Public Domain

~',¢Y\M wm ` 33 353/01

RECE|VED IN
Coum C\F wam>_¢ Acs COURT OF chMlNALAppEALS
/5<44¢»1110»\:9\@¢,\, /st»m<., Cz/M¢a Ov/Tm/ flaum JUN 02 2035 v

P.D.E)o\c l?_Z)O ‘B) Cb_;mo¢; §1.1)¢110\1
!XM 14 Fw 7 l\ Ab@mcosza, seem

P\v_,: EXV&ceum¢‘s ON mm>¢ kem/mma Fomjrm OP P(#m Cc)ams
wm Fn,€,o tow TML,OFr/u m DP TmuD\sM m wm Po& 170 ma Cou'm~¢,i’we<<
Dc~l bime 1(0,7,015, L\v/vaw»n’rm/:)'rm/% Ome»\u/KL AM¢,M,F\ wm
PP\me\w Vn~u)uw/ DP F/km A_'i'[ms, \'u MMLH
'\Z RW@AQTQTMJBA\GMM /écmer/r\ ks Mm /@<¢,Tm$'imn/s PMFM\M>
F\umum 0¢ Flwr.

/Xs %u C!w SMJ \"N>m \M,CDKMPDMMMMTM/Awuwm Reu,wm) (.`)H
IY\m 7,7 2015 Vw< LMM. VY\ML Fv\om wm Omm OPT&@ PouaCoumq '
D\s'mm Cbm\_ , fm (Y\M |B, ZGIS ”l'\&v, La,w¢, Rmv\s MM, FMMDU>
TBTM/Coum 0¢ mmmw., §MaL/>:m.

BLLM)‘,L’FM,AWMM'L k\a_ Couc,w¢,mn<; DPLW,’\'\)¢L AF@Lm/am _
Rm>,mo'f\xm'\'ms Coum LJ\LL- Pw.w) D+\'T\A\L DN mm J@cwuL/mwu.

‘\'m,bmm% Tm',
As>?uc/AM\L |(¢>,ZO!S, ’FMJ‘D\<,’) mm acme lumw_dm>
T\m \v |\\o De~mz,m \)<¢,'¥ub?v_zmmn wound BLFOMMMD

’Yon/C@UM OP C‘Nmm)xc. AQ(>ML$ Vopfw ’\'\&L\Xoé~me`eucmmn Cmm`mw-', bm. Pé\mm: lo ’|\?,x¢xs Com/ 0¢ 6qu \uALVRoc,m-L)M/ AF§TMJ Cwm la kim Rmmm)'lb hamm
wmame Rm/(>M\@m,d\\m Ruuvu> mm .@s Sur:»mmma Coum bow Aslu,
Dum 70 B.e/ been/am Tw@,%aw@w flaum firms Bv,w lP@o\/¢ow Auf\"ecm ’Vm/
APPW/A Son, wm W¢, €upm¢zm' |Mmeuwm "To Mm,
"\”mz/m \uw>mv,o Am> 3091 Dv,ca€lm~l [HLu)mHCr 'PF`@\/sm 1140 UHD\)L AA~M\M~{
Cwsw E)\¢ Tmr, szl,\c,.hmcvme¢H Rm,»¢ 'Vm/ mm l‘f/\lem Czlvn;/lm/ /§qvmc/.AMM~QTD A.?osé\esw/ 510\?1 P\a/»PMU

lA)M\/y@)sm Rr,/w\vs,
Km~mw/ Bo~zo B,QMM"Y' IZS % 83

Dmou. C@mmloml>\lu hunt/rr Pm_vl Ceuurv,Tcms

APPL\ clam 's RLPW TD 511/lam Oaie l ma Auswaa

iu SLUHBMI bFTwc/§TMUS Dmc»<@1.2_`),'111£
Fiasr wiretap wid`Rr-/ve.@1§5 (:£)or\'t ANr) Emurcouau¥ LMLLT\Jr,m As dual Dur, lssue 11a .
1156 bremr’lilc iowa /10 Auoar/sq ldu\cie<. /érccoimm&`l/é "Tu Paur,'/ dr'lwa umaun_,%l>l_marnu,
waicaTae,§rme C\rps~,’li> Fiun’lius Assmrmlou O\¢ Fa`m, Nm
brule/wm mm keim/MMQ limine 16 bn ul 1uAno\110u`Vc»Tue
Nuumue Cnuuuocs 111

§rmuroa~r l,l\rio ms `b‘~l Tm/TMAS Rm.cs dr 1100ch c
Paecanuar. ileer Cobc(lr> Cr\\ m\u,/>rl. Pan cecil r\a ,’lixvfl'em Aooar/,s ibew OPTM/sr, ` .
(_r,l,/mmme L\,»ams W\l>_a>r, 511 T\<\r, heron/mr 111 1104 Oa\cmm_
barwick/imm 1209\1111§14 OF liner/ike CORPus.

111 lem .Tvre Cci<\ms Or Vu)cmious dr Tmc§rA/m `Baa'o _

D\acu>emur>¢t Ruucs \;or»\ VF\n~vessmNni_ Cuuoucrf lie llu\cu
lar 5

“1'111¢,’11»,>11>13 51191>\1,11\11, Cnum 511411,§ Aae% Bc‘Rm;e1>¢1 111 111111)1>11/, le 71a \/er¢r wm Cu>am mine E)v Twr.
barn mm . “(m '|'1111. ONL§{‘ 111,11<1111 Ar>oacs11_ Auswra.

’1'11€,5'11<1€.'3 lmst Csoes 011 10 §11><12/=`\”|'11€, ch\cz1 131%121’<1 "1”111>;1 TMN, 11111¢1>\1. Aoo 11101~1111. 1661)11/» kessnd
Couuau. §111>11~1,1> L\er_,Rl>asm , 1311-1 1310 1101,'111»11 1111:>1)1.0 111/ave
Nusumco 111 1113 Cbuvumm~\ 1501111;' @rr,muamn. ”‘ TM/Aa°ucam
116\1111\1<1~11111) 11111<11<1 111/ec 09\111'11111¢ 166 ups 1111/milk lhme blm
erswrm.

T\xa Awu cum 1111 1u,1z1%1>tc1f1)1_1_1’ 1706@‘1'1:11‘1 ®uamlou ’lb '1'11£/
hunmsm Coum :" Cou to 93 have 1111111)11);11)1>\1$»1 licasoulgew
Couccu\>e’HiM ivan Arpcttkrc Armwm, kramequ OlaNm,
lummus 1161<.£\%1.1.1»11,15@\11,1, 11)11111111,11“1”1111, wade harry 111
Rch-~r. 1111111111,1,0/1111, AP@r,LcA/rc CouP<111,0 111 15111~1 1111111 1111111 11%61,11,111, Orm’l'uauTM/etc
111111"'111»<»1' 16'1'111/ 1510 019'1'11115 1,11111,151)1’\ Am/M,e lu'ir,w< s,"'|iim 136/musa
T\)¢cm 11me 110 110116111.¢1>;11011 001101/1\1111111 Fams OFTHcCMa/, NO
Cousummlou Coucmcuum» linen/um P@oceouai11 Couccm 11a F/z.<111,0”11"3 131<11/“11111<1 1HMFJM1D1I,
1\10 Comummmu 0)1101/1\1111111 F/>rms Ru_i 10 C<:)uoucr OF 1111
Euroacmw/f, 1\10 Cou€uc/W 1011 CoHc/camua/ F/xml, M'l?\w< 1, ,
Cououm 011)@¢11,1161, Cc)uu sec @P\'lire Cuuouc1 01>1111/ Couw, 1\1(1
110116111,11><11011 font/mmc PDM `TR\A
Noalu 111305111011 16 14110111 111111>1< 111<'1 /1111,©`1\11.“/ lssua Tum 13 wa ls'li>m 111,
1113 hew Dcr>r>\\\rcn Dr> 1113 17\111111 /11> Mma /5<111> 1111/1111111111¢1)1.

201¢5

1511>1>1,1>_11. 01'» R\&M ?"

'1”111,!§11>1>1.1 1,1111‘1 C11111111 1511111>1 11111_1,111110111 111111)110111@‘1?> 1111
511/111 15111!§11>~11, 511 1111/111111~1 6112>111111111111/0 F»;ms 1111 ARL
1"11111\1_1 151101111@1/0 111 '1'\111§111)111>, 01111> l'151=,0111111,”11111J 611<11/
17\1/111%6’0 /111..1@111311)L1J1>1111,"1111, 011<11116 CLe/m:( 0111,0 111 1112
01111111111_ /111>@1_101<111)11 \"1>1\1111111 01 11151,1215 Comz' 1‘) 01 5011111>
111011;11111>11 T1>11,’511111, 01111111)1 Co1111111v1111, '.1111,6@ F/ézme-, 1511/1101
'111111211,1111>11 1111/1 1111/md 1\11>1 Aoo&e%m.

'1'\111/31111/1111,111 1111)110 011 17111,1 011'111,0111111111.>11, 11111611111."1'111.
AW1101111 1116 F11111510 511<11119;< ‘)'111;111/11,111 6111/11"1111>11 11)01)1.1)
1;111111@ 1311111 'To Rwu, me/om‘|Tm 1191)1,111111’6 0101111 o 1901
Rwe,» 51111>1)1.0 '1731,01/1111/1> .”

11 11111€/)11<11/"1 1111,1111 111/71 011,1,11111011 1de 11 (5?\11111101,1/,§,
0110 1,1¢11\¢1 0;1>1,11111<111, 0111:116¢; 1011 01>/1111/ 05191>11¢11111"1 0,1111116 '|B 15b
11011¢111>11>\115 1511 ”1'111/ 11)1)111,131111) 11 131111,11\1{111111,61 Fo&fm/M,Nwd.
09 RLL\n/F "1'1111/1 0/11131 1?)1/ 1)1%111111111/13c

1111111)12/\1'1,1>\,111 115’1111_,§1/><11/‘1 1\11/1101661/&12111011 '1111211 Re/omF\F/> b

qu. 0011‘>11>1,1\11111911 /5<111> 51111>111.1> 31/'1110111)1115111:1 1/1>11111 11111>
15\1,1;1>11111,%11111> 011171>1111/>’2_ 11111:>§’1 01‘1'111,01’1111111111. 011161111/1>\,
"111& 511\1'@ 13 11111>1131_1.10 R@Fm&, 1115 />1111611110111
1111111 />1191>121_1111& 0011111111>113 1101 111111111)1111,1111”5
M1`TOWE APPL\CA\\\T. 010\/15@ 1110/1 01 1113 R\ 151)1T5 0R

191>\1)\111)1, 111111 1111111 11 601>1 01 1111 11191)11111113131’\151¢.”

FACAUA@ 110 FUKMLR
151.<<,1~3 111 0111>1/1>`1'/011111_/ 11011011<1>11, Coum'l'o 1511/1111 ’1’111, 1311)1>1,11;1<111
~ 0111,1{1111@ 1111/1111/111,0', 0111 UMulmwa 31111111 11)111 111170 1111,$6
EM,\& 0F 1111/111 01,1111111€.

<\'1111/ §1111/. 6111¢1, \1 1115 1\10 011/1111%’11>1111,0?111@1111’5

KoF:’S

\Xnmm Assr,mmmm¢, 09 er. \AA$’IZ? 'Rn/eom 13 ®wpmmn Tv f/L/A\m_ bmcwa L\Dwam 361.7\2>_<¥ kim 0ng is \5<\¢1 [,L,»<\m Cm)\e?u;,, `Bm
\Xe/Smu\_\> E)€, (Bmmw>w Foa \5<\'> ComPLmuw’lBTuL, 5st
T\m)w \1 la Bw\km, \p Mm mgm uum, Feum»€ Umm, onwz,.

k mm Dm,»e Tim>uc<\‘<\ /§s Gm:» w fowa Cvzmwms
wm wm I>m@mmmcf\'o DMWM\ O\¢Famom'e Lm'\'nmm@
Lusm, ®ue,e/rmns mAsTum, Mqu mach Aw/>mmub¢§¢w,@v \/mu. /§sw( Rmx Tww{
W\\mm C§ow, . D\sw/L<)zTmLR§qu rm 10wa Rwu@ Am> (§N<\\H
Tm/ M\,\wxm bap `Rr\,\,\M RL®M/nm Aw;> @mwwn fm ks Uw_
P<¢, bow Fupdmvv\ F\wu Tm, Loum W\M Dm;m He,wf;“~m~¢ OR
AW¢.\ e,/a< e»w/. Rm <> am Puu.\l~‘)ue.m\~nm,

Rnuum, Bc>\n> B)xamv;w

Tm,:\ *12.5%@3

D\esou. CORP\LUH@MP\PJL 111’1111 1111111 511\11111\1.11 11111111,-1
_ 1_1311&./1 1111 _
RD111~1111P>0\_11) 13)1<1111111'1 19111_11 111”311 11 11 ,»'11’111'/1*'1
_ AWLN.,MH '

111,1)<111:11;111 11 111 §1111111111

“111\‘1 16/111 111/€<111'~1 "11111:1 1 1 RDHMw/P.)D~m 311<1.¢11 1111 1101/1 a |ZS 81393),
1111/11 13111»11'1111111.1 T~o 1111/111111;1, DF 1111 11011111111<1_ 131611~1101 /5<11'111111191 111
1301_1§ 11011111~1’1')1%1 11\11_ 1111me 1111/1 151011 \/11>_< 1_1 6 111/112<11.,511101

1111/11 111111,511%1,1 §1)111¢11¢17 1,11/1111151011 ,’\'111¢111 77 351,1/31/1111111/3<110
1101-~111/1,1 1101)~1 111'11111 1117111; 1111 6 11111711~1 T@ §11<111;'6 1111 11111 111111111,11
1111/1 111.11¢, D111v111,0 111 1311111 V1/1< 111,1;1111111411<11.” 1111/1111 °11111)1111)1
1111»1 ,201;§, 13111> down 11111¢1111111§/11114`\ 11121?\111/11111/111111' ")'1/1’\1/11,111'"" 1311 ,
‘T1111"T1'11, 1711 1311 111 1111111. `2015.

111111~1§11111>7.1/><11\111,11@”@§ 115 31 215

Dam>u, 1101¢1111 111111111_<1. 1111111 1111
1110'11 3011/111 11&61 61
91311111,,'111)¢1<5 '75‘1“1\

501¢5