Court Opinion

ID: 8125336
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-09-09 15:05:33.997141+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:39:12.076709
License: Public Domain

Nixon, J.
The commissioner has found due to the libelants as follows : To Thomas W. White, for wages, $19.50; to Peter Karney, for wages, $2.76; to James Cahill, for wages, $37.87; to Matthew Keefe, for wages, $17.88; to Thomas Dunn, for wages, $16.12; tb John Cahill, for wages, $509.24. The New York Emery Company, a subsequent libelant, excepts to the allowance of anything to John Cahill, upon the ground that his claim has become stale, and must be deemed as abandoned by lapse of time. His statement, under oath, is that he went on board of the Bloomfield in March, 1880, and left her in December, 1883, there being due to him for wages at the time of leaving $450. The commissioner has found due this sum, with interest to the date of his report. The libelant gives no excuse for his long delay in enforcing his lien. The testimony shows that he has been in the neighborhood of the vessel and her owner during all the time, and has made no attempt to collect the debt. Public policy requires that such liens should not be enforced to the detriment of other bona fide lienors, after such a lapse of time, and without the assignment of any reason why they should have lain dorment so long. This exception is therefore sustained.
Let a decree be entered in favor of the other libelants for the sums found due to them respectively, and let the claim of the New York Emery Company be referred to a commissioner to ascertain and report the facts to the court.