Court Opinion

ID: 4042382
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:04:37.013668+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:28:38.702072
License: Public Domain

c.nt~Jf 11   '/613-B
   <5DJ.f. C/J 11/1 ?Pf
                                                 f,},t//11(1 t.'IU(,.,!J-1fr"f
                                                                                           Ct>ull.l   or C!!,/IJI#/JI /1/'/'&1/J
   ' 1'1 "l't/1111" r'                                                                                 /t-X/15
           v.                                    ·rrluleJ)£1(. C/14/fJ'i.                              l.PO J     t(3LJ -03 ,6lf
                                                 lfo Jf"ll sf.,..~Jf;.i~l
                                                                                                        RECEIVED !N
                                    Pe.nrlotJ rP!l })E.ft?ulr Yu.hScPJt:.JiOORTOFCRIMINALAPPEALS
                                    ~/J ('7017olll ;;~;r;cA~"c:J /?~US£
                                    t17 'K :SUc/tcml l> iS/.(.JeT {?tP-U.-(1
                                                                                MAR 26 2015or
                                             7-/otJtPuh/t /IJ(J-::4/t.:., Le;./fz.
                                                    ·                                                  Abe~ Acosta, Cler~
            :t 1 J"o.H C11v/ljoS II' l153f.?YJ DAR tJ/ &1fi.M /l-j'12.1/ f"K 17S"? c~'?77Li>¢ft( /1t.s·
     71,;?;/IM./Jb/r. c~uA-r();= C/l.//1'/i~,g/I'TiflVIU- 7'£Y/I./ /lrv/ Ak/?Jb~ ASK ~/ ~.J h7/J-'/k;t_
    t~ IL141~tr. ~dte,1/ /JisJ/i/c.T L'pu/l/ !Ff;;t- SI'£-rn.J To Aqvlf
   rc.        /1/I'IUCK t"rJ h11~.r/~~ !._/!;~~7~ 1 I?Jp;7i.rJJ c/c. ~/ "s t?hv/~Hlt11m6lu,   .         . ·
                                                 f>/c"r<    S~< ~Ac-/c Slc::t'f
          t: .4-:5/C i£J       7/oNI?/Z.UbA COwz./ 'h     m,~(     fr /lt.t):t-    ~F ;{£l€r ~__,/
/lfi!~ >-'~~(<./ K~?;~'"f!:"'4/f'J
  0   f  /rllj'c.ut.-!1- /? v/ .5/Ar; /?Je!J /1'/t.-<\. Ut.t.:;. ArrP! Ct?/l.A-{C/ 70-- ~~fr_ t?~           --?1djf1r/
   Kr~Wh~< f .Jo A"-tj:J -m~ Go.L5 •. f" /Jflc .;;,lL L,-~1 ~r;ttf_sc,.v;t;i7/o#.                       >t-/4.e./y'i-
   o/L /Vtf.w ·~.lr/ /5 f/l,v/f(/ r;tl.. ~£nt/l"'A~/ J""ck )";- tt5 . .:s;Ji;cT C'bu/l.f ;/;c ,
 tJptll'lfictlorJ t?f '/n/A-ojJ/Uf-1ii.s of /1 5.t:te/l£.J t?t?tM-·~t?P Lfi-w1 "F ;',..}"-ff;J£JJ .,''
 f!LfjiM/tle< of- CIILI'J'IJlt/ l'o/tC{ :/;J~ft/ljlltli'JJJ w/,1d cr~//t/ fo~ -4-- J7M.t/7r/ J/'fA~Ikr~rA~f"'l/j;/
/C£4-f'u ;/.J 'JYJI;vd /tt.t/£ 9t?2. ~ G;'t'4-trl~( . f1Cr i.J S£/f-//w/;(f,.;J/c,-,7 •

                                                                        ~(5(1-;et'f:flj_       - (/ko- SL.)
                                                                   ::r;;s-r av,z.Os            .:iT //S.38fY
                                                                   c.r /f~-£//-/301) r/?J~S".s-
                                                                   JCe.s:/Z,p;J J 7
         Jo5 '[          c J'W/1-:2.4?5'
                                                                 :            r
                                                                           I 7¥              J   ull.lC.J /1 L .Di 5 r.R. I c.r C~ttT
                                                                 J{
                                                                 q
                              ·(J1oJ7o/ll ro!? /T 1.3/LL oi REV!EL:tJ IIE/IIC!NG/P£o(:£Eb!NG5

           Comes Now rile l>EFEHl>/INr; Io5£ 'C'/-IV4z.os rflli"!J PteoSE) Wht" 5'1't.!:f5 r; rhiJ
    Ce~A.~tT '' lo.._'~I?/1/;J ;111-{/f/JU £"1t!JJ£STIJ"'ffpAJ5 /1-/t.£ slt~f?£~ £; wi,.,r h£~~;?~efr;t w,,VJ3 70_ ,
   b£/i£V£; £5f~CMII_y ,/V /,(Ji jJ£Pilk C'45£J oF .>mn/1 r/7-tffiti:J Ct?mmUA~)Iil_s Wh£,.; W&~k'::J                     I

  /!- C115l~ .3~ h~£. -r;; j;V(Nt£ ~0.17/(_ :J~                             w'!
                                                                 e~f- L-tf' w/~4 ~,eo5;e£s~l/.., :_.
  GM-,.,b ~u-:; 4       J>is/2Jc/Ccu.q-..e'j_JEc!t#.VOTiJq17{;~/',cpc£Edt'JS. r~ ": ~/1J'V'1/1S~c h:s£12
                             ,_,<
  £vrd;ll;;;.J ;::P,c_ Jn/lkT. idif.Vf. ,, ~1//d~NC£..,) o7 A- ;nq,tU/c_,c. ~> /.7- Ct>..N~I' ~~ ~ /);5 7~c.r
 /1-~AJ's E:J~rlef- > /fx/15- tt/J':f£1't.5 A:4''£A/I-I'.!r.~ oF ~vH/:jA-C"'s, wtii/J~ (lP-U"'!J S4~/7;
                                                         1

  />;.f/1/t-7/iJfNr.. v , I'J"N'&//1-        ;2..:0,~/ CurJS,P1 ilncJ wAw dAUt ,£Zfott.7>f                  77?   ~/l-~'i:~ 7-f'_.g       7' -~
 C(UC,q) or             £Yil::&,vct:. /i?61()ci1/i;;/   r;; f'.lt-Hflt-V£- A-# rrj1,P£/hv;#t!C. tS>,C 11\lf;,-/hiiZ!J                .by IJ/.s~c./
 ['~~~        A#d 4_;re..vf>         /1//JPI£4 .t?JtrP£. •                    .

       ./;) Prl-ikul_ ro Ob5'i/Lf/f... :' cl'i.mvvwy Ct~::pJoN' S£.-vS£ /'N ;ow£.su/'::1, i'M,Pn,e~/ ~;-TieL                                            ~I
 . ;J-c7/j w;~f/~ ff ~eel o~scd~#J//J?/:o/1/ ~ /rCCf_tPK/ ~r.f;;e £ ~lur. ,_/n.f~l o.C
               /tl-ttt11~P«5 /fllry_;JJf'P;Jf /f?v:P( u:bJ~;v!'vtl/wiV'cor~sl"i7Ht70N/7/ /P'I/'/llf~;./d?Oo/1 . 6_y
 14.di'Jm/ll/-:f    J

~lllwi-i /)d t-)tf;&;·--Lc-yH/ H1C/J;t.l5, ~~5;1_ G crJ·c/VJ/ 4~r~£s;;;;, .:JW,/I!r??/1~ rZcltT.P /)",/
l~f-/f_c;c/L) Cow/}/&l!f ;J-N',//ue£~/iN:;J 4ci11PN) 6!:1 /l~p/l17Y'J /;'ft.K /rc~,.[5 t.?/1/ /<.t-trnP'L...f
! /1-/l ffx-,.,s. 4'Pd C!PU~77iJ,
           . fAj\1/PA.:~/.JIJ-Ii/y TI'/V'-511J,CA_s ~~ Jf.l?/ -;;; iJJU>.>~ f;l{:;.r //vi/o/vt-) A--1'11//1/U 6~h/l.£ · ~ (Y~~/JJ W£.4-..J
                                17

  I'J .5oe/r(j /llf.'iP/' /i £;¥fJ&.f( l/ WAfri'Cvt/t a.;.r/ wir:Juru. ,j PCCU/l.f. 171f_ ./)r.f(p~N/d.y,u.. - ·
   >r~-~"ff :tP I£~ C'OPU,a- -M4-r hl$.. C.11.I'i- IJ J~-tsr....>ud 4;V £~ /1-~lc. c;f- wJ'i,..~ /h5£.cwJW4/
     /'PfAIU ls /1/I~PW£/ ,;; ,(.14"' /Jmuck. /k brk.,.14,_,7 /"'~,f. ~jJ/l.£5[d/_5 76 1/:i~ C'~

   {). %~Z.- Cii,:'YJitvq/ J/f.",z'5,. k,..-"vJ/1)            /J-S /J     &ill 8   f   .ttff//'fw    ;0£.o~f:£/:y /5 dEs(f/lltvl /o
   f',('l-Vf-r.rl   t:l    hJ/Jitlr:f£J/ .H-jus·11ccc. .{5rc;,:           kr0r t%o£.£- v.          Alodf€/?5r; Lf:Z.t. s.w. ;;._d s-ri)
  :2..) j)f../f,.,ct;~; CI/JI,.,.s           );_s   a./11/?I~M#       W/J.S   Pb/,i/l'lf./ iy            "74/ /v.J/J..5 d-e- /'£pc/ut/PP
      ffi    574-l[.J t-<5~ of ~X"fd.t/11SI'C! FM-ub .                                               .      .
  3}1>£-h;.,.~,v/ d's:.h/V~f Cr7lf.1~oJJI~ F/l/Jupj ,q.;;r ~Mu/J wJ~/vli>wi£5 // ~/1-11.!} Mt
     oppu~t~(J /i £u(l_j Ll/lj/tR-- o/P~'~ /J- /lit',.-~ 11-11 teJ,jAB /)~ ~z./ir~J£.f ~r
    -Ji< fJ/)·ruy I} E-nr/i'/1{;/ r; ,t-S5r/L/,                    ·
    'f.). /t                         ~ ,'),&.Pi-C-u'F~
                Co,.JfjJI£/J'c-y f>'t;1iJ£r:,J                                         /t/kllP!j'        mrP/ tJrh,J.S!. ~.,.r':Y~ -r;
      /.o' jwfd# l'tC<7iP~_; ft/t'l tNI'Pllvl V!JJ-f-~'~'~"ii/y                        J;FI/uf.rJC.f-..     fif...   t?vtl{i;:,mc t:>f- n C!l'l-!f..J
      woe.tlv/' tJ ffi.-'[/i; /.1 !.:f     t:?un I i"Y /1-    fx 7iihv5/trd.A utJ .
                                                        .(   ~~3 f- ;_ 1 ~ f i )
    . Jlf.). oiVeL t'f i5 PouJ.Jb L!KE/J ~r;;. g;;; PF IC&Yi£w f'Jf7//7t?,.~(/L ,"_5 SqFr£/<.!NG
     uw£u Wtt.c':'Jf'u'!J t>J,M_1/tlr/ fidyfmf#r (;r£: CP/VVicrio;V) -K:rr-;5 w;.~su/potllfd
     IJ.J ~ Wt'jhr of £1/idt,vc€; f"-/t.-ttj iJ .S/7-175/:"Ee/ ~,v-p( L'P«tf./ Sh~P«Ic/ G/Z/JN/
     ~ b'rqlff- ££7ufSTf~ /(.£/rrf, {.5££.' Sr;tn_ v. 7/i/.fl;: 7?[( S/w. 2c/ ¥~3)
   /~) 'fti. _!dr,.;d'n"'r llf--jJ~f.Jf~'! ~rfif-               {/'/C..CJS<£C"!~e -:' J/Jf/£51/jJJ~5J eced) .
                                                                                     S74JC
          e/ld -I--/III£NTifl!V/I/I)I 111/S/Eil/) -/t,::_r t'P--W~~ Ar5 eo/111/l'ellr;tv SA4X-tld ./,g
          s£r /1-Si'cl~ • (sr[: o 'tfv:;k v. B£w/, 2s-t ~: u s-ot) (;)/(_ t1-l v~ lr.11-sr h/.>
          5ud:jf-mV>~r dpt~/q 6f.- £rcpf-/ll[vl., Noli•' £r /r /1/Pr 4- Ottt/?Jf.. ; ; ,/tiJYL fo.s5osul
         /1 rtd.£/hVI? r!-.J eF ShPIC C.r~/J-Jvt.                           t!)/l.   /jlf.- /1-.S u.se.d I~    /YlulliJ£/(.     /1-tVd d£t..L .,;;-
        /5ull£r /'IZ-C-f-S -f-~#A/~ C/12#/~ /f/P/                           /,nv[      6Hw   /11/frd-w/-r-:;   /11N'f h~d3w111 d.lf/;'J
        .)!JILroilf.S       £1/f# ;-/,.                  Anlo/PI:J'-'/-/.hnf/ 6'ir;J   /IV//1-/,£/c   , /lmr    dttV€6 /J. ~t?/i'u... tJI'TiPJl/.~
   /C..) /11( l>tMcht,.;/ rt..)Ptt€5£r.~ZS r; f,(j-5 L'P-Uif-r~r If!.-. SJ?f!& k~rrr- /'PA-J'
    cw1K £;rcu~;;/J~"J          J4vf~"'17i"') /Jw~ T/ln'YI ~IL eiU(.-er;-- {sE£: .T!VeE y. f)/~ s-¥'
     .s:w. 3cllf/?), /VoJL, fwtl r£:'11/£-J' IN Cn/l. w/,tk /f-1/!MjJ/17 /o JPCI'l~ /?t!Co';f/1'C-f_
    w1hr!t'S dWLIYj 7/'hiC r~Eftvl#"c/PW ~ /1tUJt/:;.[,e :JLrt:>rtJ!J, p_N£ /£J f7fit~ ;2#~ -h"m11i
    c,vDu/~{ 1111/C l'l'tCr~f;Jtcr:/ 1sT /if'tl,/tf' VUS/o,.J. th#£. .St;i-/L '-!/Ilk&/ /ci 'fu£Srh# J:"";Vi/14/J
    t?.rl Xllt'k            sc.y;,c.J£4{! -/ztu.tNc/ On/              ;11"£/l.JU Vi'c/1/11. 4://!L     m    Wh/d      iy /1Ct'.PJ4f/'hcL t-~;/AJ£.0
  //111/nls /!! .57/itt 5UJ1fiUH~ l(',yr/1--c~~(''&c t:..J//;;;u-s, J11o!£U- w~tNrt/ Att..£ ~,.,~£-;;.; L
   &~Mivrd 7; ct,A~ hiJ 5/P~ .9/1.... &r ft15 &ryfolf;J(//' hA-c/ eh/lfC/ /1-C'C"o//tcc WIT/1/!.[J
 diU/N .;(r_ /11(~ v:lft' /1- Smlf/1 en/. h11Ndy14F/ /11o!V~ /1/ir4... /1/ud.r/VL. /._tVPIL /P 7/[//J-/.
   11 vu.j ;t'oo/l.... itVII£577j/ff%rl Ctn~4um;;1 w;/{ £;rcuJ;;,.?otty ktJ lr~r IIUfr~ ...

 17.) ~           IJ£/(,.rc4,.,-r ~~;t.C.ff,Jt:f ro 1M t?IP'W(..r ft;,r/f' •i C£;Lr;:;iJ t>/]~1ii- .s 11 {rJ (ILL J#~v!
1'f.sji.4'Jt1;J;A-/ i 1Mr~..Jn-c1io,.;l'!/ :;:/HP~wtt~!J .61 tl/s ~Q«~ :SUsr·f'j(./tJ,(_ 1P f/it!L N~P7
{/i 1/VfJiv/ 11rY) /1!7tiKJ /'lliJ/(_J ~~~~~t.v!.fu""5 J_j M<- S711R. r;; )}qv{. /}- dw~L 1b J/iF11jJf:L
wl/{ /(c,_m) /r lniJ"55tYE FMuh Wtw~k/ 4£ £,r/~s£d.
 I~) :1lit           I tJ   1Zudo.tcf/P.<~ pI r.,t;tle/11[,/ EYi~N~C
 CPU~t7 dtH-ttvt 6~. UJil/1-j[~ /J-£1/Hlr-d:s ~e>l.rdVtc7 by_
                                                                                          ,
                                                                                              iY /'i(AU/)
                                                                                                       1--4.
                                                                                                            p,.t   If(;
                                                                                                               s"Ar£ M
                                                                                                                          a-.:          t.
                                                                                                                                                t~
                                                                                                                                             /Jt "'     l}lllr

 J<./      /"'5n: · ::Jw.derr _,.. rr t:fFli!- ~
        ' l..;   I                             74~ 'Ft'3£VJIVXi 1'0 S'i.~ £;r'U£m£ Vtjl/,-,N':'£ t)~frtt?!Yip-
  77fue/t;_, /ff /J Ct1Jifc/l/i£',.; of fXUCi:Sf.. (? r /1- /(:Jhlcf 1/jutt&i /'t:;i.;i/,J. { .Srl i ;1/£/fi,.;
  v.           31/S.W.US,i)
          fY/1/kLJ                                    .
?vi.) -rh~ /til/1/ CtuAa7£AI'Jo;J5 Wfb£ bt5Cit£77oN {fA! /J~/~u/11 :r:;tl/el~~-.:So 70
 5 ")) ,';.! ~5 m"'~) /JI.rPI lf 15 ~1J dr,ci51'c1N ft1-rwM-t/d j&j__ Sui_; £e1"r-;:;>
 llfpdM;.~r R--cvl£~t {.5£c' t.in/12 v ZA-jt11'11M-) S"'t?o r; u &.2%)
?-2 .)      10 _!}li!l 1(;5 C(U(tL/,__ 1/isf[ oF vJin-7 ~ l:>i-~rlc!tu.~r &r~ jJIUJCrJl/II f/55
 1-kt~lll;..,-1 ) J wt:Wttv/ /U.-rtt_IA-l 11-fpori-'/mt;:#rtlf {~lf/5c/ ~~~-t:Ak;-~t:&l'tlrnrrf6~ 16/c ,.J~-~
 hnV£      '"7iU'1/ C:ttUW5f/ /1-T /ffii/U:J !- f>4VI~5 .l>,/1 w~ hilS .Jo,Nt£.- /J-S7iU(/                         • • ,. · lf5sr.~
 C.l4$1iivu eh"l"' 6bAJ11 • ~ ~I v             (                    )
                                                ~ f'II.!J t ] - ·'f                  eb
                                                                              (CIJ/117/r!uf?tJ .. )
                    2.3 .) /f//1Ji".               ;::;,                             \. :           .        .   I                           ·.
                         .            . ..., -'l     /1-Cl] NEE-11 10             .B'i    f:?rii-J?Ji/11£1> rJ-//J //[R,{,/J'V''f.         (.src: /llrtcA 1/. e./.L, 33
            J5, S?f·                   ~ S.'/4 )                                                                                     -/     .            .
        \/~1./:)                    £-cStt/1]      ·~;,d /,., !?tPtdA./t?65ritvH'l/i;J·/y. d~E· CtUt/t77C.aH!v/, ft:Jt:rl/'//,,,. Ke ·. C/1-/l:f;,~. ·
            _ ~(U(/LJ5 ef .!Jvrull4j 'f?/toC£/..cbr:_;$.1 /-'ett..C. Ci!. r'tWe, 5,:Z,.O/ (;- - ann( /,J :ruc,f,~ C/}I[_
            · ·/fi¥ ~;r;/LN.:J ;1,(c. ~ Wi// c/f/i~t/!(J _tr._ ,.nfffdr/.           · ... · : , . . . . . . . ·. ·\
            ~s:-;J. :thtf 1/'f'lltU7 1-s en/Is:/ ~tt. ~u/l.S:l'MN/[7# lfc                                                         ffx-,;f. SM-/?             LtN"5/i'/W;l;;.;v~, /J"/lT~
             _·.f/~.(>rt::Ct_-rd~:JoJ_v..s14R. 1 .J!35.'w.3ciL/-o~)                                                                          . ···                       .\··      ··. · .
                             ;, · ·                                                       /ftf...Gum£/1/T                                                                                     .
                .         /T!}o ·~.:... R/Jtiul(.oP 7'11£.;,t>N171'/';lo5Eeu~~~/i/'/J1£dl/1/;·!j {~n,vA"!jd
                             !}£11-j{.j
        Guflt/l/l) £f.su/iw 1'r! /-he; /ltJi/£P/Ji:JJ5          11fE .IJE~£A!j)IJ#T; ;1/ovJ /f Fmnt/y SY,;//JJ
                                                                                                         or
        .~,(.A) /Jl'4-_ttr b.J -nJ t:'VUzvr/.ouJ .. //!e>5£Cq~ ~· 'fr/t/CS17)'~'~-~f who-m 6f:A(r,?.--r/ .
         -rt,v;srw/ r; ·e/U/1-/(. /J/V Pu77F£9YitCv·lllpt,.j /oS/C'tM/J//t'77t?~ .zdr£.>7ij'177i/t:: E/h.A-73
       W ;// ,Uo-w ~ ·n1iS t.'l!-M.I/t::) L t?;: -::IZtsf7e £ /£, T 'An I' o cc~;tc/·/iti.,l f.: t .4-N A-j//t>i;vl-. ,
       mf.#'rl?;:· /111/ 7-fllt/U'Ii)i?7o,t .,; fJILGS{:I/r 7o lA.,., 6/c ~&X-~1"!../- ;1/f:w Cv/d'i,vec)
       W£l{cc77V{ ~JJSr/. e-re. , sud 4-5 f/IJLo. .                                                              ,rJ!Zo·lt:cT7oiJ   5'~Jil/ic£..5)         £','1)(1, -   ;£/)./)/[_    '
         r/UI_I.JI(ui)/J) f1t<.rstdf,.ij/~i/;f;-;)'lil;~- '/2Jo~Lf!.:Jf==!(_£[WIIj j SutA 330.) /Jq-jl#.:f a-~ 7. s-..z '1'1
      (2{'{) ,38' -t/3 'IS t/F,t:=,c( , {2.1'{) b'3?6:Z2/ ~1'1)" · J-ut/oprofecCoh.servt'ces, ~ . .                            ·
       Wk-o {5 StFJ'YI'fvlh~t-_ -h,/11,/lmc. Wt/ii                                  .rf.:J'
                                                                  C'nS~ £#_~/q ~'ifilj /£11/VC. fl/lf C.vuifW/p                                                                    47 ';
        d~Xt6t                tlr
                         f7t..+ub ~ ht~>W ,t;-.r~urrJ~;;TJ;;JJ (u'r!bt/Jf£.1) /J.ILC e"#du~/E~ " 5 At /s 4N'                     ·
     · '-£?<;- jJo/rcx. c&t-F -. .£-;r .t:#/i/t.v/J/1-F,£;,,,·-e.r ·;:;.tvfJ/)".·/0t: !_/ '!?V:~tL 4!f.t. -~~-ru_s n!t~(IJ~y{/
 .    ~btrM.f.f~f:#/l(f-Aitl_j ~MS t-/114--S'£4                                    P;/     ~~5           h?"'!}'UJ·        wl~ .->711/ tf/;,;,~~(J~ ~K.c/_/~t?)(_                      /. .
.. -If~. J:Jk7lf0~~A-Jf.~~,Fdo'L- . ·if"~f"JjJfi4J. ,z" >ft/fd-/1/_m~~~f· /llull.t., /JCCPP1f/lct.W//;Jf..:.fJ~:S ~o/lfLS
      ~y/~/ vtll'f /Jift1 /;ttA-er_r LPA,f/!'6ull;''f:L5, ~~. /tYIIf .4..11rlj/pf.JJIS, ·
   /(rJ.(lWkdJ··t. /Ira/ 4~1t£.f., .. .                . · -. ·· ·
      - .           . ..         ·1£-)(~cr-tn~.. r;(l) 8' f>·/Jy. .oF ,.O.cTO.gu.1.. ~~.      ~ yz
                                                                                               K  ,.     . ......                            ?-;> -~
                                                                                                                                                  ...
                                                                          .        . ' '.                .                                 dy     j,   -                           .

                                                                    (J t'IJ'l.- 'foP .'f                     . ., . . . . . ..:       . -.>· , .           .d;f~. [:'n;.ii/ZI?.J
r.ERTiFIED COPY
                                                   (

         ~·-·.' .. ~- '7/t£?J/0Je-tL ~                                                     .

                             £             ~t-4~ .f;~t- n J-urr·~~c 4-t-k-~~tic ~ /~;;/ m#-~.
                                                                                    ;Jtto - s£_                      / /)
                                                                                   s/;vef/t£1-- ~~­
                                                                                 :];s.38" ~
                                                                                 e. r      /[;vt(l/ _ /sc?o M c.n-
                                                                              .· 'j('o:/'Ydtcpj ~ ·-rG4f 77ITY:
            1 '- \~~\~
                   ~.~ \\)~~ ~~.
                     rr)tfro> ·
                .·_ l:"r;:•.J' 1·
                    I      I   j_
                                    9 ?015 ..
                                      '-

                                                                 _I-, TRUE COPY OFT c OR.lG.iNAL
                                                          I ~TiiFY, THIS         _             ,.,DAYPf
                                                                 -----.:E - o               _, .'b .·
                                                                                               2n
                                                                                                                 .r
                                                                GILB~_
                                                                   ~ 'I LOzANC), DiSTRICT CLEBK             .    T

                                                               · ,.   ~·
                                                                      .._COUNTYT~XAS                        .
                                                          BY     .    -   ·
                                                                                               ...:;..D!
                                                                                               fl'£ru,
                                                                                                           ITY
                                                                                                                          C4-it it   '1~/3-8
                                                                                                                          . /17¥ Stdc~41./);sfPcf'~

-·---·---~.    L.a,#q_ _ _·------·--·-··----- ·--··- . . ------ .. -·---
-·--·---fl~lf.f(_ m"l"- c_~il5.__ ,v.,_;UA                                        ,; 4Jsfi;c_rd-~i orht'L                                   ~·7-/o,.;.-:ht1fq
___C~~~h¢~(Zc__Q~~~ ()/t.(J'!!~I f,r_ /n"" s7.1y!/ /:d/ $/'
__· __&.5/6/c .&Afi_ c~_L/W!t.il~ _ (i m_~ _,-io w/hM ~,-:;;~~ ;,., //-
    - ~·:J~"Jr er.~_Aut/ -~fc~_,;p:"'"""6k L,,:r.?&Zr-
---------~                      --------·--·---·---- .. -..........                              -·- ....................

                                  ·--------·------- ·-·---·--- .... - ....                             .

___J!Jdi2_~r(Jt; ;Zr;:!_/________________ ----·--·· · · ~y(cd:/1/--
                                             ·------ __                      _ ____                ~;wJ                                /kvSf /I)/S3'&'YJI
      ------                                                 --------------·~··:.                                                       -      ...

                                ·-------·--~--·------               . -----··-.-·-- - V- -.(1,.. -/1. -..   ..
                                                                                                 / . ·~Rf//-IJ00 /fr 6.> -~-

                      ---                            ------~-----------                        - - ·J?:.;-- /?-~~, ;-;:;;.~ 7 ?5'"~3
       ----------·----------------·---·---··--                                                        .....   _ .......

                                 ----··-"-···--             ...------------·     ·-    .

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - · - - - - ....... --·-

               --------------·····"

\

                   --       ------·---------·--·-----··--------·-·· .....   _. __ -·       .

·-···-···--·--·------·---------··--··cER1lF~ED                                                    COPY
<"'
                                                61--u>'L   H     '1"13 -B
         -a;_    SV1n Of= /iiJf/1S
                                                            ~      f/IJ   17/£ b/571{ ICT CIPute/             or
                                                            .f            u}/1/tfl';J Cl?ttAir.j        ffX4.J
                       }'5.                                l                                   J~                ~'~
              0s€        Ct~V11:zo5                        J        117'~              Ju.hJct4L .D;511UercDU.e~nlL[g[Q)
                                                           {
                                                           J                                                                      OCT 2 02014
                     ;no/toN roe. B I)._ I-              Or fi£;.V/£UI           /IE17~//IJC/r'"'oC££PIN~O,DJ~.Ciert<,~l
                                                                                                         11J~~8p1

               Com~:5     iJow rll£ .lJtE(&Il>/1/Vr; :50S& (}A.V/fZ0..5 FltlAIG r£0 SE. 1                                vvht::>   S4:JJ      To
     f{:; s   C<>-«.t.l " "To ttlnM.J    (>1 utM    f1v YE.rn_Jn71D ;V.> M<-               shn-1'e./6'I w J,.r;, u'M"- Vli...z.
  wn 4J /o .b£/Jrl/£) qecM/I_j !AJ                     fuy~_,.!J#h/'i..           or .Smdl/ r/Jh1!/~ ComJ'I!.u;.;if7tJ,
                                                                              ['IJSG)
  fi)HW
         1
               w•"'l'hc~ w;@ESJ S?#IEmdfii,cr ~7/i?.<,N':fJ of{;-,<- J ~;rAJ PJ':'juf fPY£S17_pt770NSJ
 Wtl!/l~'f       C€#.v!J $X'£PIH i>'l!111l:J;i;<,v?"; ~.          4-~,        ;2.f..rt/   C'oi\ISfl/~4:/._ wAtr.,J :f_cPtf ~£./'p;t./
 /f 1o ptte'f(L /1-_JvvJf_ ~f. nU CPu~ pf £1/1df;JCf -/ni~/e/17£;/ ~ j'/l£Jf/!~'i..
 /rfj1fAdm"C< pf i"' j;,;;,J,/i!f               ":!
                                          b I) 1.(.1"' r CP«d.J5 ,_,.,.,( AJ £r' 7J /V,.r>1' , ( ,-?JP't)'i.- ,
         i.) r;~ihP[ .,; 085fA.. (/f.. "E/E.r?!E,.IU!l_j Ctlfl1;11f?~ Sr;#Sf. t'r./ ;tJ£1l.Sui~ iirlftJ,t.r;;; I
    yur; r.c<- '' ncT'>y wrltf-7 If s                    ~,,,.;
                                                       cF s ,.;,,-;;:;,.,r,"' t:.w ''4"'>1 11- cc 'I' r.1
   1
   ti             ,.~.1
                                              or?i&1 -Icy.,/ mVJ#J. lf17PA#f~AfO< J 1!••-""'.//y ,.,.,,1                f~" will .sn.£s£f"CCN1!j Jtm/1#/ ~        ;~JusT ,{t?W ;:v
                                                                                                        /(,vPCAI
      ltE /.«k -IAI.s         J.Af'f""'5 iN U.S:If' .,-.;xd5 mv.l Wtii":X e-..                     !i
                                                                                  5 c /7t.syu""1J wl/i'
       /inml't1Ciif-£... tu61t'e    f;)w.~t£$   WhC7"1 h11v'i. -t:?J:"r;.,;    /llv'   P,;;/ /i     3£-L   ii'II/A.it/'1/11   .)~u>Tir:t..
        Wil(h';J e,..,-lj "-""",J 5fCAk.S .;:," if.ulf" wi/1( ,;.,-1.,uJ<.. syu,./,/,"J /,JSM.I -f"
        ,;.,,_, .,.>h,.r;s         "'•""I!J
                                  t!cA.I< W£- ff.J /f .5<>1!i t.'v ,Ju•/cl/';;,J WIIJ o /, -r:fi,v£,/ iy n d wnJ ~ J?,.,J.er
        .() f f{rt_ St4-1£J vt> ~ f/ f'r £X·17< INS I~ r,en ub ,
           '3) j)LkiJdt"'/ ,;td;.;u £xr;t..#Sit- rut -r.J ,C,U,ui> WAlch dWJ/1"
             ~t.. ,bl17ttl) i;· £rt~1irf£j) ~ /fSS{tl/.
                                            (/)!It;£ I ofY                                )
'
    •.   .;;) rttmu:/ 1/lfl,i-(i_;            'i-Vr;J   1M--N.f/1'~/To;V "/4/ivfi_d by tl; 'itrf~ ~c(jffl?£#/i:.S). {SU j
           J>Le/uift 11 j)£-Cfu;ltJ ~IJ .S.W, U                         ?771 J·!JP-U~ V- 7£;r'£/J1,1'--;IJ~rs.w, :2._t:1
          Ss-IJJ j iJucl~ Vr kwl£.l. 1 'It~ S./,-V, ;;..4 Ito)
          /t?.)li'Jlseo,vhcT of ~q/l.y P/L eG?4f/IIS£1ts f:X~/V51'"e.. A.rrtdJ. 1;4 i>£/'rnl~,.,;;-­
          t(';N/:5 !j£- o/ r'~WVU£14/ ''6'/lc/c IC.otM1 ./JOJ/.J 'r C/T6tM1r h/.J .t/£-) chh;v-.1/ty ·
          JC'l/'1/~£s~r.r13 ;ro ~:J aa-u/Lid,/ h~ WA-.f /~vt:,vl£}J I'~ .44Y/"J'
            . "k&t., i~fttttlU/t'r.lv'uf/j~!k;~ t9"- /lr:f/1{/2_ e/cs"L /P ~fSC,!SI/~ /J- Nit(. J;U/Ir
            ~~ot£ .,;; fX'f/[/1'1/S;c F~uJJ (.>n...: 7/c£ t/. L!/!J- 1 7'- 7 S:W. 2cl' ?CJ())          ·
           /~.) /J-      &/II oF £EVt£w(/lf/1/l/~) ~,&t:£Ec!t/_2 r; ..n:.rm-/dt: ~ .::;J;:tc(j-c~£#/
            ..;-l;r i:5 NP Lu~r:~ #,t)/f:/J~£1£.. 15 /7 V/1/rC/ /1-V'C#U&- /.J'/;I11iJ ~C. • [f£C p;,,.,5 _
            wc;..e./d v. ~tCJ5cor_, ?72 s.w. 2.e/ Yo?)
          13)     /ti-.s c~ h/ls St.~.6'.Twr m4 7T&e .:rutt.iSl>Jc.TioAI .h£..t~. Cst£ .mt!-4//Nir./Y.
              /l.t?!t.) 8'8'3 S./A). 2/ ts2)                                        ·
           Jtf) ~~~~~~          if is Fo-uNt>           l..t'kr!J   K/1-r,.., t5 il/ o;:: .erV/tw    /£T/a#!~ /5            f"fh.qry
           ~~,t. Wd/?JVG,Fuii!:J {()1514-J/.Ilc/-:rt:r})BE/JJ£.NT{I£; Colllt//e!7;p;t~) ~l/.5 WI-'.5Uj/MliJ
           (jJ    w~ltr ~r £Vtdr~c(. I ff"f'ly /.5 SIJ'11ih£//}J.rt/ eP«/trSA~Id :J~AWf-hf-£
                   Kt
           r<.£ruul£« tf.£-tc~ Ut.L s14a v 7Z"lll, 77? s/w :Lei '763)
           IS:)      "!"& /) f/r_,~c//7/Jr£fjJ~t£s~,.;f.f
                                                -ff:,-r ~ 51/i!£ l t1~tcsr.CI.(/ud.; Dv£517.Jd~5) er.:l!)
            d;d ,~vtf,.v17P/II/IIj ml:r!tn-d fttif ~~//1rr,/ A;'.J t'NtiJ//cC~;V UPttlc/ b£ S£/..?-.5/~~
           (5-;:.'f..: o~ryk v t!cvt/1 2s-7 r. :J..c/sot.)~/(_ 4 /Vt:I!_.J /c,..fr lu'f .:Ttid_j£ntvv/fAtPH/~
           IS!: l-£t:>ft#lJ NoTE.·    I            rr /..5       /'lOT /f C,{.i/YJ£. TV /IIIli( /o5FE5.$£/) /1 F//t[A,(.#
           fr5 of 54m£ C11/ibce 4?/f..                   ~.F U5£./J IN /11utU>€£. (.>£f. ~:J~alj'rmf.,.,T oF FE& 20oi_
                                                        ljt£
          ;?.) tK~ i>E-(c,..~c/n,..~r l'lf.!tt.E-5f-#15 7P ft{:J Ctx£/l.T ~r -/U 57/i/f. k-f.__,;r ,-r /n-t<:J
           (wil-l f)f'CKft/IJR':} ~!M..MI'JJ'Tu,.; -1vV'!.j -humt t3uur. {sec f#cE. v &c£, s-rr s.w.
          3d /$'7. NoT!: 2;; rf,.,/}A /,..J C/J·/l. dt,(,f.l~ W/iV/PW r/tnm£/r;n,'f r.tt.nmt IPF /11ut2.JU
          u.Jh;/f. /cob:; ..frJA... b/Uv'ilL/11-cctnr~;hc£. w;f1VES'.5, Kyr c (} .r 1'17/J,.J~,I;,.c;;:Ut/~ 5 /£17id. r;;
          (Jbsf.cutiLJ         p!fc ~   ~/ln?'l Ccu,t.r; k~l .(;,f!.r /-~{;,; /{r~;h_ ~-u,re>/ a?N /1lqtt~CA.. /,//CJI/11
          J1,.t/ /,v;/7/J/        L/11 "i:r'_/MV!~/.SC~/JfiZ.e/ PH_?;" /~.v~/t n-.Nc;( H~C~~'""'/'/I·cc ~//V'i-JJ bro:~
         u.m/N!/r./ 11;7      ;;t7ssiilc 7/r~"'1 r,..~;K Cl/i~r/eC ~rVL /1-/1 /Jcc~fi·er                                   W/l7vC.J"f"
                 . ruvrA4 U,P /jt/ /)/r/M5 11-.Lr/7 //~;{ /J~cl tP )r: ~z@E'I/rc/ By 1"£;:-4} ;&1"2u.
          1;r(       SIA ~tt.(f.f[if yt:,.r /fCC "'ffiC(. W~/#(JJ / /llP/YIS /.Jvyfd:l(,.,,; W/Jf /hU.ur,_;:/ Wty.{
                                                          6

              .5mH-!1 (}!;,-/uL iJ.fflt/v(:;wnJ wJ,./r_ .-t"',.;,..;.-7__ /tfttll /feteom;l'ec N,fNHJ d~.N .;,{{_
         /)"           /YJON!l'_t /1-fff/L mwt./J(/L jJ/1-/P,t. ~ 7/l/11'~ t/£,tJ 1/U(J /'ooi( Pv't..J7')1117P~
          trll~                                           .                                      'l                          ~
              ·7. ) ~c ~'i.h,vch.;V/ ~t;Ptt£.JD-v/J ~ ;14. fYQ-#/Lr ~r,-f: C'uv;:;# ,tJ4.47o
             1
               ~Vt-f... :_,.//£./ 71.-;t::'.nt?/'J/t? 1 f -;;u,.~..~~r,'oAJ,./ J/'11/1;u.N/Ij 6't ;11(;.,~ t3z.,.-~,-tr.. jusr
             ltUoA- ~ ft{.IA.. fi,s'JT/'1P'Y { r,; /If/old 4'::) h11,.;j(l.f""'*/ $-1'/J~/I.Vly-Wt/..> hy ~. 1                       .
           rf/i-/L .-,;;,      hAv'L      n- e/lmo/~fl.. 7P Umjf'~..t.. (,~!< .,rt"t;..M) n   /11/J.f:JtiiC   FtV!utJ   WP-f-f/4

            {3    ~ f..J(jJoS"f~.iL                ( j}11JA""/rr /Pt?.5~ #f:c. h!A;~/'A-6w-;Jv£f ~,L
                                                      /1?U~d'U_.>. ~ A)~/[: 7f.)01) ,47'!fC;{__ _::r-;f7(./rMif4 k.IJ/t~7-t..I/;..A.
                                                                       111~/1fuu/F W//t /l-f%JV/!j 4VP{                   ~t/f.Jq/f~.

                    10Jt~l14
                    tc ~(.Wia.WS                                                     {],-1//'fZe?J 1 j)~ f£ q-//s-.Jf"7V
                                                                                ofl. r
                                                                             (1./: 1[-«.cf/ -/J'Po NJ!t:-5>-
                                                                             /(c~~Mrl) & 7?s-8'J

                   wJ.S,Wf9,(..rl )>r.c/n/l./1-liPIJ .'
                               J:" J .::)o; r_   {}rf/q zof II //S3BY(         I~Ct1A.CU4 7£~ I";./ /lJ t:J7-CI.0 • {!, r.
                 7uUf!ft.&1r ir'         ~Uf2.Pk/J t'tx<"''Y J 7f}rl7) -.;JrchLL                 u,.r,,.',t   ,.t,v_./~    of'
              l'o<}""'-j f!Y,.r-;{£ 51/i/f;nfri/.J ,,./ ;H.'t! uf,...7/'P/J mm/c /hLu/o/ ~                                 !1/PilPM
             fMC ~ rJv,( {i.vtcer;t; 4               £r:J/Pf' '7 )',.._phe-6£ ,;,-/6~/;J
                            (?ff.Cufl'J          TAi5 8" If      /)"J'    oF    OC/P~r£ J 2.a?ltf
                                                                                    .Sy_ _::.._w.~~-·
                                                                                      Xr c LJ,r/I'Z..e?J

                                                 ( f//1J(   s- of   ~)

                                                  CERT~F~ED                      COPY
. -.   ~ .Sf/111
                                  e
                             or /£x;~s       '!r   Z.N   71it. hJS77etcr Cou-t./OF
                     ·vs-.                   ~             tc))II4:J c:'tl/t.iNT)I, 7£X"'s·
         :::Jc:,s/   c>nv, ZPf               ~     i 17 'ft( :Jiltl.i>JCI/1L bi.ST,(JcT C'outfr
                                         I
     GILBERT LOZANO, DISTRICT ctERK
         Wtlt{~COUNTY T~XAS
BY     J'l4o-u04l.              DliPUTY