Court Opinion

ID: 4046229
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:04:43.343912+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:29:53.947905
License: Public Domain

4-e t.t ll'f a-f' (!a, 1'11/ll¥1    A,p ~Is
                                                                          (}(j (!)0~ /2.~61
         "'                                                               9:f;1.d}~~llt!
5~:1-e_ 6~ f. ~tcd-Cs£     &"-n~. ::l toAS llzd- ~cP~e:?J                              (TA/    t3f--6Y-1<..9z7~
 ~ -fh6p ·:hJJ,'c-/m~--h R&441 ~£. &/unJ Jul-f ~ ?ht. 6"'1'1~ oFJJhrllee.
 linJ ··fht- 5h.rk 4£' ·7£~/JtS, 4"41f :5J~e..-h~ ~IYifP/J'riC./f,.:/1 S (.{)(}44) ~ NA~J,
 Jhj tJ 1-:JIWI-; 2.2-J AS ..S:ucJ. Aj --Ji $- J'-'~l. "j;.ll411 1 JJ_P, ~8 <~J&' -{}1 E..
 165'2 ·\i}uj:i:; <:...JA-1   'V/-sfe,c.t          &u.~t.:l- 8cf' S'tJ1.J             CbLL-n J-v 1 1          H.!tJ~ h~
   rj\~ C)~(l_~n'\~ ~ cQA.i/..!~ '{h 1: :n.L$7~ AIUK-f J "7].~ (f~,~
  \hAtta 1 ~ .S~~Iflhel!.... I ~08~ "f4t 4-st /11l.171J~ ·;;:::;,._ ~'¥+clllb6L
 '/JIL J.:5""~Z?I~.IC(~ /--:;J;s/£,-;; / ~u/l-/ UJ~ f 77J ~~-~~E ~1.1.--n'hto
:Z UJh~ ~{M«) /JJ~ IJJ/r5 d~l- /J~usi-J tun!:! s't;pfh'lis.e 
 d()CJ~o :z Wl-l-5 ~ii!al {k;U416d Uvn ;,. . I SE{/-k-#1~ }~ ooog :J2J1.
 Wk-,01h ~         Wlr5       A/t5d ~J,~ft:J ~2- $4-m~ ~A<.j.o                                       .S~p-fb11b6f?_
 1g. ~r           Af' ll>:J-1 frrrl) ~              IIJ cj{ll!e.cj--'-8~ /t)~J/6<. (k~~ 1)jJ
 I'I()J 1-/fiU~ '1l1~ ~~1<.\ &,·c~lcir-- o.9 Th ~ I E;s--:D.1J'z,J~~--c~ ~""J--
 &l ~'epfL~n b6R- 1% . d<16'? !hd /Jid Nd-1 1/AVF cJLtds&tdfl~
 ~ :Sep-1-~ hu 'f ~a~ ~ + t: m 'b 61 cr· Al/Vtl~'f (J~~rlvfl-1 ~l/1·6 ~-· ~1 1 ,f)~ t!)Oi~           ~ ~~~ p_yi,A .2C
            16&/Jw-;.cl    tv-iJ-5    ~wnd -z;;,~~tc/rd--.·~ 4D"n1 rYUf · ~~c                         J:      HAVe
             £/~J 0          tO~i~-> erP ffir/;68$       Cla~/16, ~E ~~r/- T?Vd                  tv6I.L      ~tb<'""j-­
             /')E.WI~ --p,·s~u~~~           6o~c.eo l,Uh.er-~ ~'Aj~            at'flSm~-l.k~ ;.J~ ·;tc hf m           ·n /71 ~ &tv4:f 0 2&~.~ j
             dJ~~~Ls lis ~l~-/so -fhE                                   ]A-b:,,e145 /imt IS ~E>Jy
                                                                        1
                                                              t:mJ'-(

              Ct.e~-I.!J 47 ...J,J?I'- )11c.(!A'fj· 1/3 J-f' ~~ ~~~JJ,,,~f rt}.'rdi!JiJ
              J-/AJ r/60£A~I$~tcA,~ ~ c.S--t~)-s~~<:J, ~ (l.t:Yn 1\laJ & \J~s~
            '-r-6 ~f IS1J~&,-B.\}~J,c,:,- (/);~JIZ,~ /-.. ~~ ).,qs I l?m{. Y ~ ny
                 Chlorn 6.w!i ~ lOirs 11f',R1 ( -='3 dl>JD . . ~ NMt #6.-1 ~
             ~ 6£--/
      JfJJ/o~ ?a_ &xCP-11f 7b ~ /!7~4 ~~ /lpp~~J-1. c;l( l#uJ rlfteL
     -'47/(/ mdlct?sl lis~/ a{jt~lYl ~lr. Ar~. f(l¢~-v~ w~ f\lbtiJ T~~~l
C'»•' ..

  . . /!Jhcl ~/Ld Jf, s -::J;, -4de:9~4'1~ 4ppell/ />n.i£.( W~/JcfA f hltj ~6/JJ/~JISR-
             .Qnc:l   {j;,-11.alirf·~      Gn1co.-Ao     ·d4t t~ktG csP              (!6/GIJ!J.I&C:A-j,-cM     9.(_
             f+pp$<&{ ~25 1'/C>rl            lhwc /JUj       S:.gnA!uL~        d?7      ~~       /UR.7/ ~
             o~~o<1-IZ'i1Gz1> -ocg-ac;-tcct~~ TJ ;/~      !Iori: ~ 4S¢ltt..Jelz~d &y
             eifle_.. -f7.er--oskz;c/ ~,e_,~.s o$-c--; Zf'e 4 {.YS -k, d cfw~.
            /A4--f ~;-( t'o/1"5 111Ar/~ I 6-n ·-:iJE:t!e57YJbe",{ ~e.. t701'f~ ~ . Jf/PR;(
            d'l oo/5 .::£'           £(k    IUJ.i( ....:z4y~-)297~ -8CfCsz..Q~s A1l.~ ~4 ~+-1\'11'1 J~~~~ ~·. . ·~. ,
            odet.· D.A1).!ol ern />l!'IYl 7J t.Ja,cP Rtskc.tt. \J ~ ~~ SSJ~ .c~ lhfhtvt--
                                                         j

           rurs~-. (i>l I)\ (-o
   7   Aw?.    71Lu£1Lf            So~ ~~ ~~s n1~ss, :J?-/s pJ/ 6ee446£- ~ ~
    fJ.J-.f.orvn~ d~r/11'm GPr/lffl~, £~cf;~                                  JZ)      Pt£~1 &.J5d.P4tc'fr..., cG,;,JJUr£1
    r]h.tp}- WtJS Sl..bps~/11-+.eJ                    ./th.CI /\livE-< f!U-s~-/zc/ -m 77r -s &v~J 61l..
   -Jl,1. .Jt--t~,               JUr-h~s-s~-5 &.aJ W~"F-                      d6V6/L       $e.. bfu~/lkd ~ /Yiult.D~J-s:fid­
   ~ Hcrf                      CJec_~. kJl.       "Jb '7ft     7        ~u a..+    g    6u;cl..o-n..c ""i.. -:fi4-'l ~
   "'m~~~i~l A-nc::l v;l-tt r                     -ta hl'i o.46L                  -~        j/Jrlh 1,~1/     ~'~ riA~ 0J;sJil,~l
    /Jd-1-olfAL (j         9    ~ ~ lnCj ~W)\..sd10                      7 ~ -;:h,;~od ~ -:h~c.~ -f "?-c9-IZ.9-?·1- -4'16-ec_
   ~     r/4:1•,
                           dJu2'

   E>hua      v s~t_ ern 6h2J .St9~                            :;;:;, Q£iw11n4/            Cn-:;e:~ I AS Of~~ C."iu'd
   O~s ULtrL,~,c_4,~                      C'/dn   1\o-+ b~         S'-'b   +kl\ f11~.. \ l~ ::;;., vobc.~ ; ·:r-r €. 1-f!,u ANAJ.s-
    O't.-,f cJD~5 ,Jcif, ·~ lik~ ·~ Q.Jt-ad C..A~ wh~g!, (9b~4-l Autt~~1c~l~
   cvu        A    (y.t:l~L~ m~ t:>eh~ m~ R~l1                              b'-110A+ o>~/l.~/£-s f+pp.!AR.~ma IJ--£~L£­
  /~l    &i.i/L.fl              !2vt!~   i2tJ   '\I~AM6Y\S ~1\ T~X/15 ~~t;S CJ~                     Q_-;vd   V'~~f..f..,,&d,,;,J
   J4(i~,clr~ ooca..·"'Th~ ~~ C!.A-nlloi Y,c ~~~$J1 U.f~!n ·n~ (})1-s-1-~<:)
    0.01;\e_-\-- acl~l'f ~'-/ 7n~ lk.~~s~Js                                t\Q1?

   ~\llSIL ~~~ ~06s ~-f h AQ~tc~A~~ o9 ·Jh ~ ID"S't]ld<.t~•c,41 i);&h_~c;[ C!.ouR.t {;.JJJ--n t- c
    Ues·-kd 10 ~E..-+k Ck,UA'l~ ~~-TJ
     ·   J~~ ~(\ ·1i.x·AS Gt>v~~m~J Ck.~~                                          ().--, ~~       JS's-'2 JtiJ,~~.+f
     'P;·$~1cl (Ai")Jm,~t'f-k, ~& Wl\-lh:ll ~.J.-1~.
                                                                      ·';. '''h'

(C?t')·-Jh·f-·n.lhf'ls ~~-fh ~ I~ -----p/~-hvc.t tle>c-uz#- l:Jc$7'1 ~
Q) J;, IJt,ts-/m ~GtAJ~        ll71      '/hf   ,g,:si     (Y70YLJ~    ·Pn           lluJ~r) /1nCI tVo6&mhcR ':!
~"A~ £-fk.              Lk4 671 ·1JJ l f1~t 1(}6)1c\,. "'11\ .fih R"1A(l.tfi!J1td                         ~ ~c.L '&
($j '51n tu~>rlletL    -
 EA~ &ac..az.-1. l 1 l.;.f~J ~ -fh1s. S'-thc:J,Pcrn.. <1".53
"SAl !>at ·P
,4-1/       J1brf   &-sq ~ fiz d/skcf &1!--h-.. /1~ .5az ~oe/bnnW-?z1 &Je:..
~                                         llof3 d~Q 12.¢?

-1Af_ -r~           tkm~./::k.ko7- lf!L.f.,c_ft S, 5jG A'S 4-m~cl~e/                                  f;_,F?ttsotcl~~ !
f'   o ,,   ---Jh£. fJM-~f~-/- o-P A?1 ~c/;c./-m.P-71./* C>L _hl~.tJ../;tfX.                                 ·7a A- C!J4JJ.{

 :JJh t).t.sfs ~£ ~L.f- c.v//1 <::..ftt/l/Uo£~-1-. a+-~'! (1AU6-E..o
     \l~t6'ns ~/\~~~ Gc:,u~.-,e-y,~-1 OcJ~ d·i oiG '}}~ /htcl 5~~s~s
 ~~~.sk,C-1" f'P"d C~vm,t\n-{-;;,:-s-kz,C/ Ck~ll/- ho/Js                                      Il-l   l/#Sf    .re'Ud '76tt:ms
 ~- ~~+ ~13aA ~gfd-, :;4, ~ tleJ~*f ~                                                'if,l'   dJ>kt~ft.

 ~\l;!(_ ~-\r NW~f't.. l~t+efJ ~t.J<;&(c.-~io-n                                     c_Q fYJL          /~g;-"t!t 7frsfll~C'r
     ~do
 · + ';JdNt;-1 ~      AWt     #& ./-   A-    J~1-,e. ;£ do /f/p-/-- kJaJ zu-A~-              -;I;,   cJi'dq.
  ·r dd     i<'~oa.J ·-1Jt .,_.j sd Jl.\n~     16 d-o I D     YYltt Af.1~~'1 CA-Ium ~i 6 I
  IWiDJLme.. 761/~ lrlc -p,4-f ~ J.Da1.1/c# -w,f71dutD ~ /11-lj ~~~~~
 ::r.f ::r ltJ~cltt Jlc:_ 11->hc/ "7E I :tAl/ toff11#cl ;. /fwl /.15 #f~.e?~~-­
 mi /J:SnW~/2.. 2-..,. ~1r~.J -rP.lo ·~~S 1 ~f.kte, 14 d'Jc/ /10·1-'
  ·v.rr:l1td;eJtUJ 11-r I I ,lt/6-l a. u I r tv., j, I J j-1
 --Jh-? e~s '11SC/,3
                          Gsvc{;"\cA-+~                (5~ s~r6~
  ~ 20)//,;;w; /hd~ kl~                                    Gut./~~ '-114-J   en-, fi-,'5    ---1/l ~
  J('T!l ~ ~ /Yl~ ~IS:             -1IYJ7z s-rn ~ J~ ~ A- (1,Pi o-.!2-
                                                    :]:.
  -~7~ 6~1 --;o SOL- ~~lAJ,c;lt (}),s~cf OewJ
   A\ ~~t rn f(\q cA-'1) J~. ~"'J~ <660 ~fV\\{{ SJ-. g~., r~ $~7
- ~tsW~ 7'7Cfc/s- 4-nc/ 76 "/J,·'l_ &~/J-l ~(J4~"h~.>l
  ~.M(-s 1d-&':>7            @c ~'X..       ~-{-~J ~}~~,;_,*¥\       ibJ,y.£?t     f2xAs 1~71)

                                                     ~.~·~
                                            ~·~