Court Opinion

ID: 9704386
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2023-08-26 00:33:55.296126+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T18:22:01.714664
License: Public Domain

Reheaeing on Petition to Transfee
Givan, J.
I dissent from the majority opinion for the following reasons: I have carefully examined the appellants’ brief which was filed in the Appellate Court and have studied Judge Faulconer’s opinion.
Upon examining the brief, I fail to find any mention of or even a summary of one of the two affidavits filed by the appellee in support of its motion for summary judgment. I find no mention of or any summary of the content of four exhibits which were filed with appellee’s motion for summary judgment.
I do not find any mention of or any summary of the content of two additional affidavits filed by the appellee after the appellant had filed his reply to the motion for summary judgment.
I, therefore, agree with the opinion written by Judge Faulconer. I do not see how the Appellate Court or this Court could pass upon the Trial Court’s decision on the motion on summary judgment without having examined the foregoing items which are totally absent in appellants’ brief.
I would, therefore, deny transfer.
DeBruler, C. J., concurs in dissent.
Note. — Reported in 247 N. E. 2d 90.