Court Opinion

ID: 4069280
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 00:31:52.75881+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:34:52.488913
License: Public Domain

1002\1§){§ 2532 023 c>| 1

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

2 _:)<_,00¢_00 2 , » v >< ' .;M ‘T‘H€~ '
..»   1  X 1
]ZOEQ,W'" FA(`(_`@A_>_/;Q\`J( j_<.‘___C/OuR(OFCKLMr/OH'/_.
__._@.QM_EQQ mr _ >< /" FFE”L~5 2. '
` ' ` ` >< _<§,q_,§_'C,~o_c/\ CT‘;, SEP 3
“ A©@%A©@§€@, ©f!@f@<

 

*~#__;_ /\`)_.j:[:\_€,_ _/V\od":*‘:€.§`_@p E)( I£)a(_"_f'e /?Db€.§"{’ Foi(`(`e./\ l
'_;)/0_ S`_/_< $Q\_¢_&_ D*e,£Q,/\Aom:i:_w_@ul¢§_o\si< i:L\_Q_,_ Co.c»fv/
` _Q)QVK,_ijQ/QMS_Q#§;/ l_Q_‘/:lc\g._§o_QM/_»o; eri~l-'S %O
_H_;\Q.._ F_>l:010 pe~_C;OuC~S_/f\_ C_O\u,$_€ ,MO ,'JLIXB"H'/.. _
nwa <;,C,A_ /\)®. \»)K“Sl’)) )OQ’O) I/.ul§ O¢,S/< `
wm fm 700$05/5/\22,2»1» b€; no+,s;,€,¢\ 990 +AQ
_Q<:> mcnih$__upo/\_§`_<,C,-¢_@# 01 “I’F\Q, C,c)u?-n `
TMO\/\// \)/O_ w Z;E_MS§X;.QN<,_'EWQ~C.OFLQ,_SJ

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

f ~ _ 2 R€,§£_€,Cf\"?u\b(.\//.
" '.er; 5002.1'/1§;_@)'§ ' _ '* / _- ..N _-
/?QL)Q.C+ F_c\§`(`e,r\_ Mo(//
YQ_C,U/TD#¢(>177@/?_7c/
Hur¢‘\'_§o\[(@u¢\11”.
' ~ 5 S\S‘ /.;2'72.2§1', ~
. " Hur\TS\)lHQ _[VL ~
' " ~ 7_7;_1/3

QB\\M“O\ 1 `
Y " 1\\1)|\16R 23 inq O| ‘ `
`EX PAR’FE ' _ X I/\)7HE' s _ .

- ` ` Y Q_ou_gil:_ oF CRJ:mI;/OHL /+FP5AL5

4 36351<7 7116115/6 Y6R1< >_<_5_7/_175 65 75);11; '
A_PPLI<;A/o"l” 7 >( . /

 

 

1 /Vlo7q;0,\> 1263_£_53/\6;_5§;/_\)_76_1:&:_1_.5_3 C11_5.5’_ v
56M1v\1131__5_11557_/16p 150/113 __R5_P637;1:,6 ~
C/Au.<5 /\\0 |& 1123’11 ` 1 1

 

.. `f

 

76 7115 116661131_5 766_65 65_511:11) ;665/52

 

 

y . C_61v\55 166\_6_,_'368_€37__1:11331/\>__)/6RK,_H,DPLJ:QA/\)I_,_
` :1:/6 7115 113665 <7>_/_150_111\‘10__/\161_6353_50 c;/wse: '
1511_\\_12__13€$£5_€;_1:5-:61,1;_>/ /\/\_6\)5$ 7115 C,_c_u_'L/_€LE<’>_&_ 361
_ORD\?R GRA/L):FIA)G_IH_L§ /’V\QTIC>A_) JFI\) §uPFo/R'//

7115 6665_7__11§ 56116666:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

7115 61155_566\/6141>/§1155:7:_7`16 C116§_1;/_\>_612‘/5’5~11_#
66661,0 31166) 7111,‘7 12555__/6011/_\!7;§; 117765165)/ 36931/
' 1351;_.12/_/_\3 1?_\)_5_ 3,'_ EJ; 1_ ___ED 1\3_6§1:@/_\>_5_' mellon 63_03€75‘ <;1”50
_ . , FD_ L\Bc)_-'I:__Q/;>_E;):/:/J;/_\)_C Du£IAS(-; /\l:/E APPR@XJ:/wm?j
, .Ly___ ___35_(,,11211 Y_§ DEL/M__QAA)I__M_S 661.6_1> 311:5.
11 550,_0555/0016175 147/312165_%_36331` 355/§
366 LD` 1111__6_5__ 126$5:1;_ 3__1~_/__ 3 5 1._<_5_12__1§_61<53_3 5755,<______

/.

 

 

 

 

.  DEAL 7333 0333333,1)7 E\)ek Gw7 330 6333133333 l
HN)E 9633733)/3336@3333 730 73:333 331>_ H_&D,q 1

_C__H333<.3330+:33<.131:377;3@33733_!?@55:3131:7;/ 07 33 ,
3®14:7333 03 3 33773:3 53373`3<.3’ 143053_

 

 

7 Es7I/v\on>y 127733,§73735 3333/30 131733'53 153
33<’.@/)319333;_/303_37;3_7:3:35 Q3_SE 3<;14/v\/v) 33>/ 13014’L0 _
35%3) 73/€ 601437 73!37 DEFEA)D3375 37_:703331/»

3§73/\>6_1: 07 <_03143/ 333 F<>3 307 Fi:31/1)C 335/7
1336 153 93_733)30337‘5 333337,,

 

 

_ 21 ` ` 1
733 033 _333@373313@3130 33;@ 57373 7337

 

3331 0 <’_H:LL 0 7 3533 333 3 307 QF_ 017)13'3337

DEFI3:7:Q35 0334313@30333333:§31) Sc>m€ _

Q___QM\MD 56/,_/3;;3€,334§330 531/301 }>_33031)3€3'_1_9_.3 515/33

- \»30_1430_ 53>/ THA_?’ 1301439_3€_ ®343571:03383[ B§_
70313\.+.0_7333’_&3:73/33 313533_123:/?33/\)3 033/07 35330 _/@

b 533 3 033,_,3 3330331:303 531)5333 0<,€3$10_3.3 330
3133353 3;:1)_33_ 533/3333 33>/ 1137::3 SomE 3'/2 3)_/33335_ ___
' 3333 11>3':74:,1)6 7<>33 377@333>/_7@33331;333€ mls/07
37703>33 3>/3£:333_333 7333:1:4)@ 0333330337'§ 3703_~
13>33’3>3’3 Bc>BB>/- R_EEI) 771€37~ 33733033'7 13301430_ 63:7

._ 7 33 <:3_1;33,_1):7 3777>33€3>/_33535:;537;3,\)@ pROG__ » 4
' EA3M3~33;/3\53\)3c>_ 3_13_3_ D,, l v iv

 

 

 

 

 

35

.______p~`RH)/ER Iio'R f?L~’L‘]j_/E"ll:

 

\ALH c R \? Fn R ‘€, Dv’€_'m , g_e_»$___<’._o_o_s/~ deve,<\_\,__O\,QplrcMT

 

_ch Vs ‘H\¢n' 'fhe_ couv»r wl |\ issue c>/\ c`>vc\e.v fo *
_(2\“_0_00 N\oj:/cm F»m; 'Pevm/SS)°@A_"VO Y*/I€_ c,_ C,Q_S~o
1'_§0\_1“/*\¢\\`\/ 5¢\@@:}“ <>J_\A__C>\ D,/\\H R_Q.»Oo\"|'° lf\('_o_u$e
NO _)9_1_ '1’_'23‘%) +o $kc>u) ~}”kg. Q_c>u<`~i’ "H»wd” .D@‘r`ené»anirs
_Bf):'(o_____ /___\/_~§_o~$_ IQ_€_§F_PL+_/__L)Q___‘\lo_\`_ Q_o‘f’ ‘P/ l)/)c,
' _o\r\>/_/v\o~r/@n_<>_m D@S€Qna_m+_s_be_m\&`- HLS® ¥@P .

_Q\()>/ l.SL»'\C_:)#\ va\\@¥ +'}\C*`"/V\O\_>l_b_€§€q¢{)j:@ l

 

 

 

 

 

 

.__ _EX_€;_QMT A_cz/_\_j'_kj 5

R, Q_S_ P_»z.;j:_¥'_\l\ l Iy_<§_u b ML:H?_A_

 

 

l’\P--/-L-_- _<\c\)/__O£:-

Sszr_ 0177027
Huro‘r’$\>`}|le',_(_\m“r ' -

815 1217'7 $T 1 `

Hu A)_T_”S_\)_c_ l I_e_,_“]/_ _._7 73 “/X______

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

' ._§__§.___§ § 1\1 m 1;1§§_§ s 13 §Q L 13_12.1§1_§§@_;\)

 

` <§ ;1; gog§g; FA@QE,_Q YD@K,__B§IA)_§ PR§$§/orl.v`

 

;31_1_\1 QQA<,E Rm’ §0_:1;10 TH§ TEXA$§§DEPHATm§/L)T

 

_0_ F_QQ/g@ §c¢‘r.»; ¢A)_S_,_HMJSMJ;MM me A~,n_:@

 

110 _\&eLL§§LL_Q_.mmJ:y, I/o_/P£§_Sm‘r§_og[§><&s,

D§cL/>,/{§:§\A>DER 1911er )/ 01= P§Ra”ug,v 1'/1/17; /
f/)c<:@;zo;,o@ 70 /1/),)/“ 5§§:§11 7741; PM T<~ my;F/)

 

 

_I/\_> TH§ APPL;<.AUO,\)_/¢)/e§_f)F ;§§prmg§,€ '
‘ j ;2_¢>_15¢ _ ' '

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

77TH DISTRICT CoURT

CASE SUMMARY
CASE No. 12483-A

. "y'\

State of Texas vs. Robert York

im¢m€mm

Judicial Offlcer:

Location: 77th District Court
Simmons, Patrick H.
Filed on: 03/23/2011

 

CASE INI"()RMATI()N

Offense Deg Date
Jurisdiction: Limestone '
l. PROH SEXUAL CONDUCT F3 02/14/2006
TRN: 9112914207 TRS: AOOl ACN: 00506-2011
Arrest: 04/11/2011

Statistical Closures
01/03/2012 Convictions - Guilty Plea 0r Nolo Contendere

Warrants
` Capias - York, Robert Farren (Judicial Off`lcer: Eva.ns, Deborah Oakes )

Case Type: Adult Felony

 

 

 

 

 

 

04/12/2011 6:56 AM Served By Arrest b
04/07/2011 3:46 PM New/Active Warrant
04/07/2011 3:43 PM Issued
Fine: $0 Bond: $10000
Notes: 04/13/2011 wmt ret to dc office
Bonds '
Surety Bond #00332-11 $10,000.00
4/11/2011 Posted
Counts: l
`DA,TE CASE ASSIGNMENT
Current Case Assignment
Case Number 12483-A
Court 77th District Court
Date Assigned 03/23/2011
Judicial Off`lcer Simmons, Patrick H.
' ‘. \`,///
PARTY lNFORMATl()N
Lead Attorneys
` State State of Texas Defriend, Roy
254-729-3 046(W)
Defendam .York Robert Farren Bobby Reed
' _ Retained
254-729-2720(W)
Bondsman Reed, Bobby
DATE EVF.NTS & ORDERS OF TH_E COUR'I‘ ,lNDEX
<)3/23/2011 §3 mdactmem

04/13/201 l

04/19/201 1

04/19/2011

04/19/201 l

06/01/2011

06/01/2011

07/14/201 1

08/08/201 1

08/08/201 1

09/12/2011

09/12/201 1

11/04/2011

11/04/2011

01/03/2012

01/03/2012

01/03/2012

01/03/2012

01/03/2012

01/03/2012

01/03/2012

01/03/2012

 

77TH DIsTRIcT COURT

CASE SUMMARY
CAS_E NO. 12483-A

§J Bond , .

Arraignment Hearing (9:00 AM) (Judicial Offlcer: Simmons, Patrick H.)

§ Notice

Pre Trial 6/]/11, Status 7/14/]1, Trial 8/8/1]

§ Capias Retumed

Pre-Trial Hearing (9:00 AM)

§ Discovery Order
status nearing (9;00 AM) (Judicial Offlcer; Simmons, Patrick H.)

Jury Trial (9:00 AM) (Judicial Oft`lcer: Simmons, Patrick H.)

§ Notice

trial 9/12/] 1

Jury Tria| (9:00 AM) (Judicial Offlcer: Simmons, Patrick H.)

§§ Notice OfHeaIing
Trl'al set 1 1/14/1 ]

§ Motion For Continuance
filed by atty Bobby Reed

aj Order.

Order Granting Motion for Countinuan_ce and reset trial to 01/09/12

Plea Hearing (9:00 AM) (Judicial Offlcer: Simmons, Patrick H.)
1:30 P.M. `

Plea Hea_ring (9:00 AM) `(_Judicial Off'lcer: Simmons, Patrick H.)
1:30 P.M.

§ Waiver Of Jury Trial n v
Stipulation ovaidence and Judicial Confession Felony Plea of Guilty

§] Other (Specify in Comments)
Disclosure of Plea Recommendation

§§ Other (Specify in Comments)
Admonishments and Acknowledgments Sex Oj?ender Registration

§ Trial Court's Certif`lcation Of Defendant's Right To Appea1 (Judicial Off)cer: Simmons,
Patrick H. )

§ Waiver of Appeal (Judicial Off`lcer: Simmons, Patrick H. )

§§ Judgment of Conviction by Court - Waiver of Jury Trial (Judicial Offlcer: Simmons, Patrick

H.)

PAGE 2 OF 3

 

Printed on 07/]5/2013 at 4.' 02 PM

01/03/2012

01/03/2012

01/03/2012

01/09/2012

06/24/2013

06/24/2013

 

77TH literch CoUliT
CASE SUMMARY
CASE NO. 12483-A 4

Plea (Judicial Off`lcer: Simmons, Patrick H.)
l. PROH SEXUAL CONDUCT
Guilty

Disposition (Judicial Off`lcer: Simmons, Patrick H.)
1, PROH SEXUAL CONDUCT
Convicted

Sentence (Judicial Oft`lcer: Simmons, Patrick H.)
1. PROH SEXUAL CONDUCT
Sentenced - Prison
Conflnement to Commence 01/04/2012
10 Years , Texas Dept Corrections, Department of Corrections

Jail Credit l Days
No court cost and no flne

CANCELED Jury Trjal (9:00 AM) (Judicial Offlcer: Simmons, Patrick H.)
Other
Reset to 01/03/12 at 1:30 P.M. for plea

§ Motion

Letter/ Motion to Obtain Documents and Trial Records in Forma Pauperis- filed by defendant

§§ Letter

Letter to defendant enclosing requested documents that were available from the courts file

 

 

DATE

FINANCIAL INFORMA'I`[ON

Defendant York, Robert Farren
Registry Balance as of 7/15/2013

PAGE 3 OF 3

0.00

v Printed on 07/15/2013 at 4.' 02 PM

. ». ~ _ _ ° /’1)-<1, 0073~83;, 1009-01
'E>; 13131376 _ . X . 1:107146
' ` >( 6003701»'€13~01012101307130513LS
303637 1013133610 Y03_1<_ >_( 37 1376 <>676)<115
/133112<.13107 ~_ >_< » - 1

\

 

§01\1\101313>/ 5146_67__;3100_3_1> 10 131 13610.0_ 37710

 

 

 

 

 

70_7_31?_ H0100333L6 700§6 06 5137.0 c00137@ ,

 

` . . Com6s 10000 303637 613/33610 1033 AP10L7 013/07 710 736

1330076 51%.60__131_00_1\¥0_1\_/31361060 CAL,\$F 131/00

_ 1 R65P6<,760LLY /1/10063 736<;<>017_37 F03_310'013063

i, 03131071100 711;$ 1007:_0_1) 710 50310037711030@6. ‘
_1_’1137377<;1110_7 0000170 514000 0\107_0 7 716 00037 135

,§FoLLO_QS. » » - - --

 

 

 

4 " 71_46 c/30:6 5_01011\13_3_)/_ 371/667 7_/_0 C130\S6 100 3123/533
_000_0 0_51101.0 711/17 136 11 6101;1310:7_§_3_7_“7_6_31062,78_0330/
REED 106\)_6/3 PJ:LED_ 1007 0106/1/1@77_<910 103 013- , .
1763276_0 70 /007@_1_06* 7/_41;10@ 130113710£ 7/46 1319/913 .

.~13@><;/1\1>,767)/ 370 703>/`5 061:61011>13/07"0133
1007 010 1313-70 ,3750,_1>61»6100/310:1:$ 1177>131_06)7
BDBE>Y 7366_1> 620077) 14306 100357 BLY 351<60

11

 

 

 

 

.~51:_03_73 3677613 06116 71413157_1366610_013107 61163 -

GOT 1310D Cc.)u 700 741306 POSSI_BL}/ 730/06 70 737116
_.`__1_3107)_74119 41 ;1_41_41_\1_0_65©6 66171;10<; 7146_ 66361:_3;61:1;/
_©F 1310_ 9®6\11:476&_€273 13_36776/3 5610 7610 <;6_70 176 __
736 43055~;1;_31;677>/ 06 100 60606_10<,6 56 611116|7/

` ' 765771\`/31>10)/ 156 7_146 §7/376:5 7\/713710 0>'1:71065_3
_©73_ <,<>1\/\0£3_6117_/_0_7 13107 7/475 621356511111111133,)/
10@072 01_5101>00 7146 6001/37 714117 136 661013131073
3770.3106/ BQBB>_/ /_3_6_673_, 00115 16713110/ 710666»~
717/706 3'$$7§71310¢6 06 660/056_6 603 1007 1 _
_£7_|;71\_>§0_1310_/_7447/_0§__;@_10 7366610 031075 BFH_HLF., '

.1» 7146 111/073 136106_37 000017,7) 43755_ 57,376. 74/117
7_476 66661)1)11107 73 736 41176661) 631/1163 06
511;6_1)_¢_77_671> 7/4,636133611 656 06 9766633
607 061:61077;601>5 66714_600'¢>30 3666660.

50/116 00@01.'_7) 541>/ 47<;<,10560 1307/007
___ERO_\_)_E/Oe §0/\/\7; \AOULD SA>/TH_B:I:,H\/O®LALD
__ 56 Qu6577o10133_1`6,_135__70 710_7:70 736 F/471463
_ _1;.5_066610613,107_1153605705566_3_01036363037
` 010561)6337\ 0664157_@10_14101:) 0)135 106063
__§_7:*/_000/\)_ 4770)7[__(¢\7_\7_'{:,'11_1.,"5_1>_1\36__3Zz,_)_/EB@S_,_H/\)…_D
00R7;7I,1\)G ,`i') 4)",770_/{/\)€}/7'0 /?1.-`<,76_1}_6 CLIEMT`
3770_3106>/ 717 L6 47101) 7667706 066610913107;'5‘
* ._ _43_77_-@3106_>_/, 60_813>; 3661> 7141_37 066610111011)70)1101_0
C>67 71/6 CL7610 \ 'QTTDRA)EY 14531571311)¢6
&30_63@ 710_0@Ll)_61> ' '

21

 

 

 

 

 

. ? `  Pw;:_g I:DR R'EL:E_F~_ _

 

v_.___\)b_ H E_ RE' “Q<~DR\Y:. DC_€,IV\| 5_’_€_§ C.c‘>_/_\5/ é.Q.\`_€._c\,/._prl/ C.q/LT'

 

 

5}2§`9\>.’5_`/_7_7{&€\_”_._'/_'_ g._ C.o;a_<`:l’_m;l H_~/_55_ug, cm O§’&g,\` il’@

' _O\\/\ov<)_ /V\o'i“/On Po_? pevml$S»OL._fO_$`:r/€ _&LM§Q

 

 

. §L&mmo&§`_y”.§_bz€:‘:”&n&_c\ D/_\\A E@p¢=) V“l’ ._l/l C@L»SE,___

y ~ NQ, )9. _“/_33_:'4 +o SbO_u) '+E__Q, _C,O.u C`|f_‘/:):) a`/_’_D_€;Rnd./_'_w o»$_ /Dg,l@jzgt/_ U_ Q,_QO \` /) o'f” act ) fn ca '
0»'11\7_/3)0_“/;/_0/_\*0 E_Q¢Q,Q.Q.ng, nj:.S`_b_ Q,_l:\c\\ ;%.5/€/_5'0 42 0 (`
- 500_7_5;4_€.1\__§:¢2,.|__1_€$ ~'l’./\a* fmc >/ ha 31 §`¢¢h+éf) _~ ‘

 

 

 

 

\ ‘ ._;Ex_e,_<;c_x_§d_@;o:}:'b;f_$

 

j?~lS/,;

. , 7€
/QO'b_<>,_cL_Eqix:c@/_\_>loff/-<.
/4¢)/;).1_,¢0_/)~,1» /°r) f>¥`n$@ `_'
TDQ.J'~_ID mo 0\770:,171/
Hun+§\)cll€. Um~i/ '
215 I;LT’" 577 '

 

 

» HQ»/_\:;:sl}`_:l»¢ /'F( “773,1,/g

 

 

 

 

 

 

v . * ` " IA)MHTE5 DE<:L`H,Qm/;m\) _ 'i`

1 4 vH_l,_1?.n3_21J’__haal.<’..l=¢xl_,%cze)s~,_15191/0C P/QFLAR_;EEAIED_ILO_*[HE__IE;/ FHALT

F}cc@RDI/o@ 7'0 my BEL"J:EF THE' FA<:TS ` -

`j SI£IE_D 1N “I”H_E HPPLI<_HTJ:OA)~_ARC/f/Que' A/\)D
_§;QE_QECT. ' ~ '

 

 

 

 

 

 

_5._5.1:5/_0 59 @1\> T/q¢»'z_lf’7 on y OF_ SFp)/Emggk,
Q~O/§ ,, ,

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

    

UvaERslTY of NoRm.TEXAs
HEALTH SclENcE CENTER ar Forc Wonh
*

Educatjon, Research,
Patient Cafe and Service

February 25, 2011

Accession Number: 11-0180 t - /
Agency Case Number: C10-02-0596

To the Attention of:

Roy Defriend ~
Limestone County District Attorney’s Office '
200 West State Suite 110

Groesbeck, Texas 76642

FoRENslc DN`A REPoRT

n lTEMs réEcEivEDQ
Received from FedEx (#843215526382) on January 27, 2011:

11-0180.1 Envelope labeled “Dakota York B1" containing swab box containing
swab packet containing one swab

11-0180.2 Envelope labeled “Cassandra l\/lonthey BZ” containing swab box
_ containing swab packet containing one swab

1'1-0180.3 ` En\}elope labeled “Robert` York B3"" containing swab box containing
swab packet containing one sWab

RESULTS:

Human DNA extracted from items 11-0180.1, 11-0180.2 and 11-0180.3 Was

analyzed for fifteen (15) genetic loci using the App|ied Biosystems AmthSTR
ldentifller system. The results from this testing are detailed in the following table.

Page 1 of 3

Texas College of Osceopathic Medicine l Graduare School of Bio'medical Sciences o School of Public Healch 0 School ofHealch Professions o Heal£h lnsu`mces of Texas 0 UNT Health
3500 Camp Bowie Boulevard, Fort Worrh, Texas 76107~2699 o 817-735»2000

February 25, 2011

Accession Number: 11-0180

Agency Case Number: C10=02-0596

Forensic DNA Report
y

 

Locus

 

Reference ltem
D881179 D21S11 D78820 CSF1PO D3S1358 TH01 D13S317 D16$539

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

11-0180.2 l
.Cassandra Monlhey 13'15 28’30 l 9‘1° . 11’13 1511-l 717 8112 12’12
"'°18°~1 13,14 28,30 9,10 10,11 15,11 1,9.3 8,12 11,12
n Dakota York .
11-0180-3 13,14 23,30 3,9 . 10,12 15,15 9.3,9.3 8,12 11,11
Robert York
Locus 4
Reference ltem
0231338 0193433 va TPox D1ass1 Dssa1s FGA Amel
11'°18°~2 24,25 14,15 16,18 a,a 12,13 11,12 21,21 X.X
Cassandra Monthey 4
11-0180.1
Dakota ¥ork 20124 14,14 15118 919 18118 12’12 21’21 X’Y
11'°18°~3 19,20 14,14.2 15,18 8,9 14,18 12,12 21 ,23 x,Y

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Robert York

 

CONC USIONSZ

he alle ed father, Robert Yorkz represented by item 11-0180.3, cannot be excluded
as the biological father of the child, Dakota York, represented by item 11-0180.1.

Based on the DNA analysis conducted, at least 99.9998% of the male population is
excluded from the possibility of being the biological father of the child, Dakota York,

The o.bser‘-./ed genetic results are 3,484.'000 times more lil-<-sl‘~,..' tender the scenario_that -
Robert York is the true biological father of the child Dakota York than if the father is
an untested, unrelated random man from the Caucasian population.

The probability of paternity is 99.99997% (Prior Probability of 0.50) as compared to
an untested, randomly chosen person of the Caucasian population. '

The observed genetic results are 4,685,000 times more likely under the scenario that
Robert York is the true biological father of the child Dakota York than if the father is '
an untested, unrelated random man from the African American population.

The probability of paternity is 99.99997% (Prior Probability of 0.50) as compared to
an untested, randomly chosen person of the African American p.opulation. .

Page 2 of 3

 

February 25, 2011

Ac'cession Number: 11-0180

Agency Case Number: C10-02-0596

Forensic DNA Report
W_____-__.

The observed genetic results are 82,020,000 times more likely under the scenario

that Robert York-is the true biological father of the child Dakota York than if the

father is an untested, unrelated random man from the Southwestern Hispanic

population.

The probability of paternity is 99.999998% (Prior Probability of 0.50) as compared to
an untested, randomly chosen person of the Southwe_stern Hispanic population.

Statistical calculations are'based on allele frequency data for the_ relevant populations
.as -p_;:'as.ented»-,irl. Budowle B,,~ l\/lorettiTR.,-Baumstark; AL', Defenbaugh --DA,-=Keys Kl\/l. 7
Population Data 'on the~Thirteen COD|S Co`re S'hort Tandem Repeat Loci in African
Americans, U.S. Caucasians, Hispanics, Bahamians, Jamaicans, and Trinidadians.

J Forensic Sci 1999;44(6):1277-1286. Alle|e frequency data for D281338 and
D198433 was obtained from Budowle B, Collins PJ, Dimsoski P, Ganong CK et a|.
Population Data on the STR Loci D281338 and D198433. FSC 2001 ;3(3).

The data obtained for this case will be submitted to the Texas Department of Public
Safety for review and possible entry into COD|S.

All evidence _will be returned to the submitting agency unless otherwise instructed

ln the event that you have any further questions, please feel free to contact the
laboratory at (817) 735-2143.

. The above is the opinion of the undersigned, and this report shall not be reproduced
without written or verbal permission.

Sincerelyl _

' Rachel Sutton ' Farah P opper y
Forensic Analyst Forensic Analyst/Technical Reviewer
UNT Center for Human identification UNT Center for Human identification

End of Report

Page 3 of 3

. ' l -
._'_»_._'_._._____ d 7 d - -_.-'_ l ' f
. ' l

_ , _ <:Aqs;,\ro,_ra:lss»/l__i_*
` <;c¢r c,¢r¢> wR's_s;roq.»<>r '

 

 

.Ex_ PARTE' ><4 ' ' I,)\r 1HF
` ` ' X cooK1c>F<;R1:m:mnl_ HPiOg/)',LS `
R.,Br:/zr Fnrv<\:,o Yom< .>( . ,. ‘

APPL‘_LQ_A/o“l_ _ X ST/M”l? c>§TEX/XS

 

DEPL;)\) D_B_N_TS_A_ME_&_CO ALL_

 

 

` ____E;;i\>r>:i\>es c>§ F/ac_n~’s A,\)D cr>_,o_c\_us'\;m\)s '

orr l_nrx)

 

 

___B_T_H.r_éiomr;as_\_§lu_r>_e_€_o£se:o_cw 513 . '

 

__C_¢_N_\E_§___r\rq\r)_,_r?_§;@_E/rf_r§,a_r!r>/__rzc_c_ia¢r):r__);n)_mz;___

4_A,Bct\)_i€_s:r;/_i_E__Q_/MD_/_\>_u_w_\£@?_€_p_c;_&gsE} mm RESPEJPMLLV ,

Mr¢\)e_<; 1145 couRT fe g_¢ri_\\_or_?ir_@,_o
_EQB_D;:;EE_A)DA/o'i's.mm1 o§ Hnsr;us <;oi_lo_>/__ngb S_,_/n_e__¥_¥_e»c,:t/_ r)_`€, oss_l`$j’atn_c.g__@§_ C,.o_ ur_\_$’__e,]
”cO\` rt~`c\rll/\TQ “l/c) §Q_.@l<*c\rS'/"»/SSql_OF_‘li\:<:_mdr£jMe.n`l"_
_P(_`e}rol$_e_é 01\_'/:}_\_<,_5_1:0\'_1:€)$__ _ax_lu (`Q 10 comm a nc 0
_]Ojb$e_€,_b\:l; / on \x) r "l`_hi_ r_\_fl_\e__‘l:r_mg,_€?_a mrQ___PCQ_SCS_ r_be§\j)/__ ' §
la\\,s_ _l_H_L<`_oD_E ©§ CRI_/_Y_\:r:_/\\¢r\___ EA_ c_c_€DuRF`, _

 

 

 

 

 

_ ._ AKTlf-C_L_l:__/Q~“Ql _Cz>_) t)\ll\er_/_>_V_o\lrdr J____/Lt`_e_€_y€or€§

 

.$ lbrv\_ 'l__l\€,_<§\o_\‘l:€_,` C)'S"`_ CO/v\/V_\ /§S 19/\_©_¥__“\:"\€_~@ $¥ Q»’\S @_ e 1

_`J’

 

4 . ~ A L_Lx OT__HER FE L Qr\\:r: E`S.:£Z _p/_£c_<;/_r:r;w_o\.$__c`_|_\b;\i§;&_“_~ ~
' _@_;_4:1__;@,»~,»;++:,45 +r\@ ns car C;FA> &¢g;r_e_e__&@,)_¢_ny _~ x
_Q’F_Ee,n$_rz 043 PA_<>'H$_£SJ;TED__;S`_EX\AA_L___C_Q/_\`> Du`_c:r' inn
_;>_a@lq:,:@zr_@F__§_@_;ii@@_Q_§__<>_;_,_o£_f_/ie_f):zc@_$_?_a_\_w;. ~
,_CoD@_oLw P\_§_C,L\_/_S_§_o_r)_<>_\`_/_Le.:d_b)/__/QBII<; L_&' _)ZL', 0 _l(j)/
; _Q¥L_Q__Q_OAQ._Q:E_C_S_L'/_v_r,_,:r_a§_\_}ovoC,-Q.b_.u§`€. ¢' ' \ l

_ . Q°' »» v , .
b v Q_e,¥'€./\C\_o§¢\_`fj__!\>_a»_$;o_uj{j orr bo_\;`r_\ 136 Y" Cr_pfl[`o)(_/_'ma‘fe_§/___
_BSQ_A_st'. I ¥ DEFrE__/\)_D/a`/o 13 '/}17:0 RN rzjg_B_oBB>/ `
_E§ED-/;~bo~é>- 1 1 1<,¢§ ‘o\(\>/ K_l°@é._©¥ mo+/fo/\,‘ @/\ c~)r¢-\:` "
_._Q'_r_\_é\@_r_\_'r:`$__b_e_l;\_orl ¥/.. '0§` Ob~_) Q{C»+€A 1@ CAL\_)/_Q_r)lérzzac§;_,__
_Q\`_Ce/:/_E\C;.\:QA_Q\A/V de¥'zngo w 11 h L>_S‘S’$ 0 .r` `
.‘_;q_ULSi;_O_D_Q_A__W_\y__§_~‘r_orfg_‘_s w ?+n_¢s;f:,__@_v_com,e}gzm+_`<’__

_ _@Si/_`/L¢L_>/,__S_cir&_l.)_:¢_£@_z\_@_ n`_ ~+ m ,`5. m-* `Hc, \5_-@_ C‘¢j:,@+_

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

j_€_/\_Q\_n__cx_¢;_@\.u_r`_'}:¢_\\__@_\j'_?;'€_rfar_\_z>j_o__ng_b_@_j:&(’ '
» A@_\*Q__\Q\_\_j\j&@_.&\ Q_'“Q en Sr_d\ {\`I,_' 3 01 g . De,-\: AOAMML. _)go.§'__
l _SL:_U:}_/,_L€_QO\\AS_Q.. Q‘\: QF’I'Q?/W&/Y' 1’\€_ 130\(3_(:,' obl'))/ l ll
`_/_?_€_e_§>.>fo_l_d__l!e_;_‘€;,/_\brb.(_\j:_ic;,_`b_<>__c_@u_$_@ }/\ -Q. r_l@_g'
' _/_)_¢?_`/'__j£\`_<;£_@_f:<_b_f)_c?_§_® 7"© 117 Cr\ § /`SH" /'/r\c/r /`/r f'/”}\Q
_`:_ _V_)f`_b_\_ 1110 €.(’QC\' ;0/1_ CC>_O_/_\Q_&_C_§`_O,SS_¢:B_O_ /i/@_l l '@ (`0/'1` _
_C_,_O_u 1`+ celoqu De§*p€{l&¢»n`i' u)_§\_§_&\$@ 7"®\<§~ by ` / ~
_br§_/Q:]_/TQKYOE_>_§_BQB_BV_}_Q_Q,__;,z id
`_r/_\@_~r~`_l>_.e_ am j’//,C m r° + ne 33__§:/:@»,0_&__/1&?`_<`_<1\¢]_¢§
,_)/_\_c>__b.go_e___o.\r:\_>f_w_r_#hl:)_<¢$$_c_§__@>_Q_j:_l_`x_e~__$_‘_)_’q_v:)_&,_£l_l_ .
_ ®_£M\_[_C’_h_/_§_O_\__\)_r_@_'_a\if:)_©_f\ @ 1: D@Q€>,r\;\@\ n""t§° 1

 

 

 

 

 

 

` ._Q_Qn$_fii_utrba_Ql 133 k"r§ <)»MQ»\` U_»§» -f_;q;u_)_s:*tr';r7&,¢¢;_11"'¢>__/§y

 

_(2\_“_5__”1:£\_€,__7/£)_(`£)§__§;©.r_\$_"};/`;fmj;¢p(lh » TH 15 ' l"_§ -O\'
¢ ~_ , 32 a ' ‘ y ` ' ,

 

.__ _Ul_c)iod`mn O¥ 0_1 0112»'5\1€,1’10__011:\+5 ?1<¢1|/1‘1’ gquqn_te,e_(§__b_}/_________
_\/_001_}’_0_51?__7:);~1__2_____§1)_(_7#/ /+r\>lf) /:oudRTEEA>TH Hme_nA/ne_n“h$ _` y
_@_&_'15_11___ 0_5__<‘_@/151,71111"@111 msc (”11>\1\1 11 1\ 110
_01_”1_""‘)’0(`11 Q_V ¥1;7(‘ 11'17; 0.2_51`~2_1\00117`_1:_/)0_”1*_010510_€_0
_"H\e ln&P-Pec_hvwk)€__ C_155 S+a_/\C.Q 1041 COu/\_S’o_,l
_0_1£__€_£_1 5 0;_‘\:10_ /_\S_I_/_\__ ):\1 S_QI;\_L>_Q, 1091\ §¢_H_00 _\')0_ `f\ _€, [`_ _¢2,_1$___,
_h_: .§__O\_§_§ M§\Q\\\ 11‘}`__4:0_&\&§__€/\&\01 r_\:?:$'_ C_\_Q,L_u SQ_ § _._®0 S

 

 

 

 

_ 3, _ _
EHS/EX_~ \) Sj_’o\‘\'e__l_m 1_31_7_1’_}’\01\1@_@€,1\ m1$+a1_+’e15_m

"§_'_L\_\S_ Pa_(`_“}:LC_&A\Q'_§`_ C__015_Q__,_b_mj`__ /:“/” 15 7£¢\12_ 511an /n+hr< `

5_115_@__17’1_5_ 1117@11+_+_<_.011_0@0175@_15 ~F1711_11`11:Q__75_ `

_&1$/7\1$_§_11\]_0¥‘ “H'\z_ lV)§1C+MQ_/\+ !:)Y (A)c"/ 1959 O\_ PFQ.-"
.-‘_`,;§`1_01_\_ m0_":10/_\¢ AL_§_`,O /l') E)( 001\"\'0 ER§T___C____ [HJ_;_C_-_H_EA.E
w_’/j_h_§_vq?il<_u'a€ Ca$€» 1<, 01b17u‘1" J‘GLM,OQ?_,'/)¢;
_ _ _\0_1_~1:1_\_0_@_@_1)0&`_1_\_/_11§1:\:1_@_(__Q__ Q.Q_a€c)\ ,_3;_71’_051>03 01 (` q 01 €_ l
` 5+0\+14+€,_€2§1:_[_1¢'\1_‘1:01“1'10050_\¥\0~ l:)( lp@§“f" QQC+'O C,`_lg&_\._$_e._¢
` @f)/,>/ 7"|»12_ /<)_0115_’_<21'\`1,1§`~?__&011\ \)10/01`&‘€,_.@|+//1€,(` ’H\Q_

' '\/\_1\_1_‘1`€_01_ S_+o\+€,"\d O\` T?_XQ< E)C Pos“i` Fo<;_`_‘}`@»_*#_ C_’.iqg$_:z,}_ b_Q,-'

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_ _01:103@_ 171-1111 112_2__0\ 1_1_1»_¢_+2&_<131_7&11_2__1@_,_5 1111_1‘12.,_11115 11_1~1:_
» . 1727“__0_¢>_11_1;1:5,_19@_¥2.113\<11115 C_QSQ»,/`_S _..01171;1_1:1_'_+1_10____
'_ _C_QS_€__ O_\`; _M \S_\)_Q\_u$k_mc,i”c)/\) C/j_%)__
___'.D_ z. “\:L_ r_\_ 01 qr_\j’_f_\_ € __\) Q_._ \`_r£\_Q\ _01~_0\_(`__}\011\ C_Q__ _`}:0_§,_\)__~‘2_&13£_,_
1 '.__\`Q_<;_o_ _'L\j_;e_<§_ 1/\ €_~_@15._(`+ 1\012_ +O ‘1'}72_ _(2_("(’01\10\4,$’
`_Q_B;_\S_ 1_€_€__0_4`;/:\ _,_§__Q_Ou n_$`_e_l_ . _-@_/\5 J;JW 1113/___
310 _;1_@_)_;1_ _02_111>_112111117»111151_;>/_1»_11_53021-_7;1/ -
. ”)”0 PVOL\? h +e_d_$<>_)(b\ql__€_@/\c\u€_§r:_wl/\1c_h4$

 

 

'vL°§`-`

_0\ §Q;)§ny 1;7§`- "H/\p_ 4’1\_1_(`01_&€_3 _F_Q€; 000 \15115
_ _, 3[

~.'3@_/»+@¢@ w m wm @x: ~r@\ U,o)_.;¢-.g;s~;/\ .+A¢;~ '

- V”EXA'< D¢po& +_rv\@.r\_+ 0 "F LVS;W:I~C*Q__.M_/_Q|.S,_v':bls__

_ wm$;.c)>~fl/_e_o»_bo».\`g.o\fc.\,_“/:é_q_‘c‘v,*\¢\),_o,$wo\ q Pee§\ ’YQ' b n {'/_”/ie 5 `

' _O\_S;qmgi:f_o/\_,"):[/_\.qj*_‘?iwg,.lle,~\? z n Xq_n 1- _\A)_oul& de

_ ' _7.:<¢&@®_TOM_Q¢\_U_Q,_Q£);)L@.G»S’_S ,/"h /DV 1 `§ on q m\

f _\Ac>;»_\_é_~_b_Q,_LQ._\,Q,QASQ,}&_@_~L\_§._C,_o_u_l_d_'$:\:|`_(_]*b.@,~&b)é. +0 ' , ,
_\`€_\)_Q,`c\ 15_@_»/\'@ w wg\;*‘ Ae.c,_@n:r_/_,;@@_L$» k¢_ LL)_UL<:§ ` `
33gl¢_z\@;a@\_@A:_MQ_j/§)_I_&@_\>_:_C,;LW@¢@ h 23 ;n Q#

. §§ Q_.C_»‘H \)§Q_ .q$§ 1` S_'\?c\y$§€_»€-_~C?£-_C;Qum’.$;\g@.o@)/_B_€*;é§_%

  w _;¥ILO_TE\_Q,~C__/_Q\`S_e, .@ § "j"//\z, D 10 /) quj';€:§_éifci`A§)/_%
_` __i\_a$,_b_\'_`®_u§hj;S<\`:)O:/“i/_\_z,_\le,'_$_¢§:o_u;|Aé\_'[£\'_`o_\`_\)_€..' b Q,`Q.f\ cz, r\_ 4 `
.»__/_`/_q_<>@;;f)@; c>;”m_/;A_O:_c;/wna v,*@l DNA ama +@ ma KQ_ -
  gmc +1~?,AQQ_@@_A_C§_/_\_Jr_/f$i/@+m@b,‘@)¢>§,icql , 4 -
, _£Q:rlq`,\~ 09 §_.R:A c;\_/\_\ \<5_-.,,3;_/*_\5:#@5.+)\@, p,/o,/:),~
` _f€.n~_d§wib@,-&\_e,;£€g§q_m’ /"5 +//»`@ HLLE 65 D f _ 7
,F_ATHER <'>&l QA,`;;\“THE \,;_Q.c§\_£.;;.;@£_l):_,` `
_b_>/`_bi®+$r:/_\_;_%_):0_@;__1’;0;$,_/1\.u`.l:):;.}QL/\-lg,y __/Vle.a/\ \° no.~S O% '

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

w_h§_ L\, on e, 1`$' /¢)C.C,LJ__S_€,<\/,` Bw!' m>#///Q(bc) gpi 7%/\'€(‘€, `

' ,_ ;'/`_§M@,ib_@*@_@_c;&;&g_@§_tbnang`., Fu r‘+heY- '

' move/ga gr\v fn c\).e;P“}Fl/\ 05’___/1\_.`_<§_0»€,V\QL\A_C(_`@¢{__D, /\) » 19 _ '» .
\. ' 4/`\,q_,:'€,B.S_’VO_}:);Q/.Mé~cz1£'1..€,~_‘}:0_5`,.Q.i€;\`.m)`;maj:L\_Q,\_7';&;¢.~1___. ' \

  `("@,su'|'l’_$, - ;' " , ’ " ` _

 

 

 

 

 

 

' . ' " CERT:F§: <_:ME» <>P 55&\>3:¢,;~ z

 

. 1 _I _gGBERT_ F/}MQ\_)__YOR l_<_ _€M> ¥\QX`Q,LS>/' DQ _C,la(`<> 1
_ 7“*\0\§_®/\;52|'\@, &Q’\”<,~_md\hcod‘€»é\ b_@_loy> __,_ _QXY;\/&_

l 5<.§~£\€\_€/0(`(`€,.0'{" C,_'op/V O~§`H'\Q. *§oTQchomo ' ;

wL/')Sj;§`_c,¢_/;\;\_Qe,,q“I’ \S_o_:.S/_ SQ,A+ +'O “H/\€_ LIMQ.SIQ[\Q
C’/. D/.S+C.<;+ /)‘H’o\`ne.\/S O~§~,-P):C,L,.cm& “\`//)Q
TEXAS CoqRT OF <;R;m:)':/\)/QL APPE,¢) 1~51 517

__DATE ;LBEM_LU_ _;_z_o/{

 

 

 

 

 

 

‘ . ' _ 4 ` ` 1 Rohq,_v+ Po\w‘en YgV/<_ ~
TD_C,_J»:):D # 01770 274
7 HQ\:SIS_\)_¢_UQ (/\/,\1’|"

' 315 );F” S~rr»ee~/»
Hmis\>;\_{;n?.
4 7735/§; 1