Court Opinion

ID: 4053572
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 04:00:18.342115+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:46.611183
License: Public Domain

•-A~LQ_c._~{~1~K.--~----------'--·::~Uill~n~fe@                                                           ,,")____
                                                                                                              __ '1~J~_______ _
                                                                                                                     ~:)

        TeJtc.. c-   U::t~>r-~    u'""'"..-u:. LilP-~e.. ~ -;')_______!!m~:._~'=·c.~·~~~~~-
        £· 0 -Eo_:>t_L~-3-~-~p-1 :ct_t-Sh1:b "11
        -~-H ~ -~c;,.L,_2_'lf:_7j_j _ _                            Co~l~~-----.BECEI\fED ~J16_ __
                                                                                              -   COURTOFCRIMINALAPP~       · .
                                                                                                       ·MAitzrr2D~-.'-~----;---
        -~ ~-k· ~_a£_-tkwlr:±-_t

        _et~JC_-6~L        _lV\   Llo~'b--~-m~•l¥1_~1-p<±Ji{~_Cl:l ~ rc.s~r -o£_Gri~V~~-)~.t.r~P-'l~fffi~----
        _t()_O;..ki£Lt.uJ,J_u_~£~~-JS"_£ilo \lft__w fl=-1':-;J..J_'f~l~- o J_~e_iL~~~--YeJiesP~ _l___~q- lf..-'-.+~J.__________ _

        :-~_CQ(L~_!:;e_::h2~~ c.d_ __,hc.L.IL ~nt.._-lhc_~~ t ~\ • ~~ • A"J:___:_}lL_tkta~:.~~_o£_-fk_ ~__}__ __________

        _hL_clcl~~ ;J-~'--J:bhL'}'?w O::f_/j__c£    -f[-"11-l&w:   M.-. Wt.J-_L_.{_k__S}-c:.:~_t:_f(' ~1-.!i.pp~ L   __________ _

                                                    _______$U\ced.,\\--~-----------------------· __

·---                                                        ___£¥u~ ~'=o/--111f!l~-----:---~·___· -----
                                                    -------'-------

                                                                                              ·----~-------------
\   '

        --~-----

                                                                                                                     ' --------
                                                                                                                     -

•---
                                                                                              -----------------------

                                                                                  ..   ~
                                                  C.o.\A.Se... NO: 05JFOS"~-~oaA

  •·
                                                               w~-~a} B,f~o l-

        _,Su.j_~V\.~\s_~ouete.J--1ll~---- _                                       S1M_te_~Qf_-rt:X:~--· _· _____-_ _
                                                         ___ ·_ _[.o.&rj.:_of__et • W\i ·~~Lt±Vl)O__f.tl...l£._ ____ _
        _qu,\_o~~-~jY._m~__ fJ.tl~on __-,---- ·                            --~h-e_\ ___~5-\-g,__G\u~--------- _

                                                                    --R~;_:RU,~~-.Q£_C2tt'3_t.vGV~£._t_________ ~-------

                                                          ----~1_~j__j)d /ti.~J~~-L-RuLSJJ' fll~l!:L_Sec.A- ;J_t_.____·_____

        _Th~(.._v.-A_c.\_ed'.S~t\.-eA._p..L\-.1 _\ ·, ~:n:f.A"__re£,..4 ~-no.:.\_cce___.:fra ~         -¥o \A,L_oc.f.£,_j.._e______ -:-c--
        _tk,_k_d__tt:_bv. rc;..;r ~--a~-)-cSlO-~-~---hh~:\-_:__W_et§"~\'eCJ'-e__~__b~--:\:be.__pc;.._~.L\_i~~ut-u"_~----------
        ~~~-'6~~~ ;tQ_\LC.._t_J~.~-b.poo_,_\1-.~±_LS_, _p__ff.£~L:\-Q ~L__Q. bp~--· ________
                     •                                                                                                       I

 ·-                                                       --.~---
                                                                                           -----------.- - ; - - - - - · - - - - - - - - - - -

        _Pe:.,.\ ~\ '.o"--e__t~.tY.S__canv_(.~\<.l__b~__o._\)w~~-O-f-~~~:f_c;,._Vc._kJ__~~1Y ~~-W-l:\ l.t______· __:_
        _a,   Ae.c.A\~ p.n"+-1-o n---:nc..~o_'o__ea-_\_s.\-'l--a9.a_~-)-a-n_LSfL\Jt,~-:~,_e.__\:Q_Q__~-~----_:_
        d~f_of.6J-·1}-e_wrS"___l.n_.\-k_T~-~s_De..p.~.f m_~t_oLc...r:.L~'~-'-~~\- !_C ~--------------
        ~\n_s1;.\v..\I.DI\.~l \)~\)\~\ 0/)   '   -~e..\-\ \,~1\U   l,JJC.t'S'   0't?--P~LU_!'~he. S\'i-th_!.ts~_( ;c..±_____
        -~~\.._   _Q__:L&p_pec.lS" ..1_!1        C.c'\lA~_o~~hfd~o_k_o_.8_::.o o ex~~)___!? n_.___}_he..--:-L o}_b cl~~---­
        _o,_.f_M:ll,~u ;)~o~-0---\-:he. &pf-eJto.k__cCMr+,Lq·~~~e,.l __Lt_o.f2i"\ o-" c.ff;,M,~--
                                 ~       .                                                         .     -

        -~~~!]~+~~ ~~~+_fl_y,2pJ~£±__:_~----,----

       . Qn_~QlAC4V'\J-~.)-aoJ_S"_>-~f'~~ \ \ t"tte/ _£_. _\e_A. uJ L'J:__o£J:tt;i_~S_(Q~y,21.t S_,_,n_\_bL_· _
        fu__l\ulctJJV) Co~.A.r :\-""fln-\3£>-~ iL~CO-AY\.~_(e.li~-C__cl_j~              m __ a9~_n~_\-s:\V.; ct~.d:,____ _

,. ..tA('
 ·

-· "
        _an~bw.l"'~___a~_\~ ') a~\ s               no \,te ~AXt~_de.\ ~ :\-..Q_pe..._-\-\ \'ot:\er _s-\-c:....\.\~~~.bhA-_~,,_.13~--
               ·,1:__of__j1_~b~e_§.__~1f'~~_____w41f~ A~e..c__)_on___w hlt--.h~CAiL~---te..w~~-b~ __fr\4'1 \ic! ______
       ~ J~~__!-\-L_id.~·~ ll~c.-i't!'\1\..v&.\- __~_CxL~I-~ (~4.-ti:.~~-s-mc..._t __\_ _fo~ ~ &-~~                    ffio,,vL h_ S _11 __ _

         Qo\S .                                                                               ---------------------------
                                                              .'
•     -'~1'+.\e.t:, i\o~VJc-b""J-CO...t:..L-C ..,a,,.,~o£__~~i_w..,- nok -I~ #f.-++_--'--~-
     . -~ t\0}               ~fU"t:\____:pl.A:(\·•i..>[le.£:3"_(..(.!1\ \-~)-~h~t_s::     Me;     '-"-J-P-~J~hce__)-~-Lb-~.L<(c!;:_____ __
      -~@_I'\_(H\,~}hcOo)-t1.!ce-:12::t~-\-k l'V\c.~~L1__~-~~--pre~_\cc!_~ :To Succ..~u..~~~:.e..&l-C--
      --W-•~Jt_l_Ot_p~~-·~~u. _O\.-\.-t~.J--_Ql-=.-J:Ot::>l=-+-'c.-Ue...~.c-~b~-d.,.e.,.~\-l-e.d-£Lk~-~-"'-c),---@ilie.Jr_,_·_ _
      ·-:-t.ts.:~_\:o_1 _~l\l_Lo~pC.:.f         ~ I~ c..t· Co'\Ct~5:LU!!_t~A--'-4--ttJ-t~h1~-_N_teJ~.tx__ __

!.    -pc..t:.te. _l\:oy.~~£~6_s~-W~cL3:~J.._L.TX..:.:&•·nc~_llp_p_._lj_)_z)_f?eJt \. vl'lf.._f!.!d ~~-~......~~-\--o"'------
      J:k_~j- C.~EI'i_-\ut_IUM-L(:;l"-"""-H'W C.-h d:J-~-fja/ w.,~..__'___._.fk=--'-::..:..-1-_ _ __
      -~--._uJ_Mil"'_.Se.eAk\.n~-telte.:f_h,:u"' uoW---c-Ct_--k,_lkd_h__iJ_,Y,_w~ cl~ ;- ~, ;,~4--=.:-rc___-__.1--'-'k.....____ _ __
      _tM·l~c...1M~i_:_~~t\.~_of~b)5_~~~"\,c..\ p-ro~j"---\"Q l.t,;)~                         \ ,n_G_(M bl'i c ~eA-_\:~~~)-kJ -----'----
      ~'                 -                                                       '        .                       .                 .

    _ _.-;~nlc..w_-t~J __Si2-M:£l?£..)_lL&del\t:a,pJ· ~-j~L ~ V~LJ}-o 1""1                ~D lle..-_'\2lL1.CL. \-9 · c..-~Q-\:-'-'.kr"'-'---_'_ - - - -
      _b1_..fi.'-!".C"Loi__:\l\!..~c.,L_-\:~k!~~~~4\-c. V~_:_Q;c...,.,._.b_ou--r _v_~ tY_. C. 4Y.'j.4_L~,_.._~.f"~.____:.__ _

           -~c\., u~. ,1 t~~ ·4:t\d ~~tk-.f~d~b--:am~J-~___Ij--~d~l~-e.skbt_!_~h..lk~Llle___­
      _facJll.ts o.f_..tk__~~pte_-+-o_k__s~-x~_:\:he,cL..~~s-.l_bo~!\Li_P'"'~t-~"""'"--~--,---
      _ef~·-~~)-t:t..~' ~.L~~"-~b\~-~~QI.I'\-~-'--S:e...cz...~$~-S~LL...a!: bf.._U,-'-'~=\;._.:..__,_,kd,..,-..,_,,.__~·_ _ __
      _Lt-_\~_~\~-~-.ti.L.\:b~}__t~L"e~-~~-h..vL£af\llL\e.1__~i~.r~<-'--_--"'o~£-----;----
    . -~CO l\liJ.ltr;!:\f.2lL..bA~ed-~ji_-~.h014 LaJ.c:. ~ I'M;) a-~~.U-~§_tl ~' ~,,~rL_Je-/h,t_)_)_c.n:t_.fr.&"l~M.&\~1, _ __;___
      _Aefec...i.---~-~o_\""t'\l)~~___r_~l~~.-jkhtlli1 ~_o_.t~_n~n ~~-, ~ ..."''"'"" a.~ · "o-+~i{,Af' !"I.e
              _e_~~)-w ~~ __t,.lD A_tt'_ll\~~-':\t ~-~-reJI e.l'-r-'·H~S-_ucv:\,.\-_.-b-1~~" LQ/'_1-i--a ~L&t.'f'                         _

              fur(luf-)-MC-~..(i,L_~tj~~JLb~~~--=·-------·

             ~-~~·\-L\~ -~~-wh'lj~c\-_(lM-tr_~c._fll.._~.,", .!&_ ~c.t ~ Sk~ wh.)J~--­

:,
             , ~r'!J'i \-.·. .Me,r - C••.r'!_\_R~~Mc.)_tt:r__{. £c";iJL~J.vnt< • _5 ~..,.d   Lc.lcia-_t"loJ:.   ~rar~NL~a.~_dtAn_J:he,'-'-,-----

         , . .~L~~pe-ck}-~~teAsc-tM ~v-me,.·:t- ~t-h'\          &.\l___Q£   11~~~ ·~'':'"' \~)_!_t___$~\e. ~~            C       #c.beg~     C.C:"fZ.=W"--f_ _ __

              JS_~     wn\<. d       N~M~ 1 3-~.A s~H .,.,eve,.r he,. s~-sr-~J~u)_at1~L--\-kec}_the l_e~i'~lc..+:•"''? sl-tc:. \t
                   .                                                 .          -

              enac.t~k,o~J-·~-
                                     •   I                               I                                                ~

             of ~Q_:~k-~_ijvkt_~_S'e,c..~W\ l8 of -tk__:re~::~ ·~'":l-\\~~·'-"" ·~\\.\.. o..f g,~'\)_'S.t..::k=•t«::_:__··- - -
             ~,.\- l\Q__~~ S~\1_\;.e_pt&,u.A..;" a                   IM ¢l§'011 Meri} ,.{k G\    ~t--ki_\kl\\~l rn_~~ ~, _ _ __

             .S~:k-_Jor:!:l§...J..~v_it_t.t&l-1_~(..   prt:>td(f W4'S". V~.ol~kod_t.ll.\_!u_~~~~1_o.f~ B1 \l of                            ''~-"1------
         -    -~1\d..-'-·\k_J~:tJi~A~~d:~l--~ ~U~~L-~1~-\-<..-\.M ... ~.ktki1_p:o~e-d~~nt>~"-'-"---'--
              5;~k-:~-~~Q:...,Jy_be.rhJ-~~~~~L&. ~s~:}-~_be.f2~ w·-"ho44- ~Mf-,____ _

             ··t.t,~AA.t "~~~\-~W'\6u .-\'IL~~c.JS: Co-l~-h\v-1-J~., ·se.e.-_1.5,_~-s ~ro-•-~_2]~~ ~~~~.!..!-
                                                                                                            =·---

     •
              .SkL~_h·_~J_ ~
                                        ~'\e.J~~~t~~1_b_j_--bu~~~-C:~"C- ~ ~~. w\..4~~                                        \JGoiA,te_ Sec.,._3Q         c:f.   }_k_JS•\l·-o-{J:~~It,k._'_ _
                                                                         ·~
         •              Sk&._~__g ~ .-1-;7_ alLil.«~..M~J-I..._,~c.~oH-rlg_to "'*'4ia.H~Ll>i' a1LUM1c_··_ __

                ·       r~A~~ '\-\C\~L ~~f~M~-Y/          Q./Y_.      M~___$1A bj~ n.V.:rJCLt .                           ·____
                        -~MA-t~~ ~-V.o_ck.....:.HL_pL~J.c.b-~_wl-~h.-~lil_r:tdc.~ t:11.._&1'!\4:f:;.sn · Q~L-tit._c.,"vtuJ\!1.., , _ _ __

                        S~±_~~rJ~pr\"SO'I ~-J ~tL_~a.L_~~~·=----.,------'---------_.:_-

                        . ~k..,O'f-T~r f\~ (!!Q!.(~ h\~~-o..r_~ ~k__ pek~ &;l~kcLG ~~------,--
1   '

                        ~~ ~s~k...of ~~ J, ~J. ~---\o~~ -k, &_h+h ~t:J-~if_-fk___c_._ ___::.____:____:___
                                             1                                                                                   •

                        Jk ftc.iti.(_K. -t:" .~le:i.. &__s~M._go_.t.W_peA-.::'•.:t•\YLU· &-.lA_ ~~~ 4IL~Jec._lo~_'·_ _ __
                        ±v-+le    S+Gk ~\-:A-~~±..)~-\-·\'$' 50. p:;:!24Ahl                      tl1         -tk. ~(\.t ~- (2_,~~er 'Se.L~~ ·~~--

                        _[-.__V\ \_($~M~ ·. WCLr     c.._~#-L-~-tk. ir!C:L18roiN'-t. ·~¥-w-~_.\9_&_uJl.LL_JJ_~~
        · .         ,   -~ ol't--   So       eo"-&-\::lkbu~l_,,~ t.w~Jq. &__~ ~-f\-l,.hoYl a I{U, ~!-€... prokf:=.h=~'---'--,-.- - - - - - , - -

        •               OCJ'Ie_   (~J,k a£ &~peA-f};"-.,./> J~ .&.it Q                      \~<>'\ _,._,,i ~W,/_pro k=4-=-::...I·LVI=-=------
                                                                                    \_s"""~cw- L~~J_CA9u~_~ur;~ ~s~ _kw_b_b~t~_wc:~ ~-~ 1 _o:e_ _ _ _ __

                        __b_j_w-~M~1\--i-.--t\e.,. s~c.\L.· ~- ~~"''e.- wW                      l(       S2......:t:1'~~~ I~J-'7-i-~.L\__:~-t--'k..=------
                                                 ,                                                           .
                        ~p_te~~ D-~- :tke-_J~· \l_~_fJJ-sh':hs--pD:>VI kL-tbM-_Jiu4o~_~Ls-o_w e n : i h ) - - - - -

                        . ~-'L-~k~~~\LJ\o}_be-_~,)-4Cl-aJ_:'-~~~--la~·'·'v-~ ..~~_.:.\:k                                                 A~~v-----'---­
                        af:·t~s~~c__c.on_~A~I.-1 ~i~_f}e__S~b.tL:~t~J"ll)_bo~-)-J:-\ h4,                                        p\o. ~=-'~_.:....,         _ _ ___;_____ _

                         a---l~Lol' -~u~~\-~~·flltS_k/>'\Lf~a~--~-,.:_\).\1~ _tl~~-,-PV\)"'h-.t~:__~: ·                                                                                 .
            •           ~~ SkMt_6e...,~ ~.\0 ~\tti.U'i-,-~~-1-~_c\o.-....g-~9-J.lc:k:-~:lt:J--'-~-D=I---f1ut..J_~,r /4~~~~-c--.<....,-;~---
                                                          ,~                                                                                                        1\"'"~\ • .~    1 , ;   L/
                        ..ww__, '{
                                         •            "        '         '     '    1 '
                                                                                                        .. _--,--
                                     ~ C-\t-~~of-~?S. "-~_1 _& ~~-•~.hu.~M ~k~A---:-e:>J' G: h~n'\bi:befi-
                                                                                                         '       '           '           .            •   • -   '    r-'    ·;   ·t• ~ . •
                        _Q..~~ ~L~n~l_,.~. :JeY-oo ~-n; e.,_i ~t ~:\~_A~~1:-_·_·_ _

                                                                               4
•-•-fl-D~LilC.Lt.a~p-~t-n.~-er- g,~ ....e..-~:L.J:k_s~~'-·+< _ l~-~ ~.s-~-o~_bo"'""              Jj__~E:Lp£t;.>p~:t~)-:-:---­
   _C-ollVI~_-tk_pe_.f:iti ~-J-1:)-~_I_a.W~Lmt=.c~:S:_rH!_ ~ris1:~ ~~.~ tU"''_~___f_-iL~o_+_~_+-k_pP>4L_l'-~------:-­
   of..tk" £lt...Lrktetr;_w_b}t.-h~~h~t}"-~der_t1L~ -~rt lll5_'Qf__:_fb'1~_61~_(.~.)-c.-7')~ ~~--~-------
   ~;_~,Jc.. ..f-Q & s~.-k. .fk._ ~1-:>_w_~,.:.-k .,'"\ pt:o-~Acu-1 u~er_-t,~__Td4tr 8i 1LQ:£ ~-•';5!\.J~ --._______

   Set:.-h~ \~-:-w~\e-~_l_±c.k. '~~ r4 .±t..~~~-_rz.~v-.s b~l.!.~be._{i~-~"~-D~p>'\OL~_r-_Q'£_ _____· ___ _

   J.a.v!l. LtL~-~~~ ''1--ttfj~.n;~.:.fu.+_~-\:h•~ ~.Her be. o~ ~~~-)~-~L~r~-~~l:~_b_e.____________
   ckLI\-\.1~-'-~-~'/-~ &;n}~_i_i_ber-l-j     k     ~~··· ~bc:.tL_C'lkYL~.~t::_~ -~------. ___ _
   ~~-h~ 1o_)lw~-~-t~:ll~LS'~t~~L~_£.)l_~r~f::h~~n J5Lh_$LW..!_~_ 3S4_ _______.

   ~tfJ>e!-1-\-'"'"" M- ~~ mo~ re-lc.~q-J- ~':)_lc..~f...t ~eul &f ~.\-\.\.....-\--·'-"' -th.~±=-J:~iwtr___.___ _
   /)'l'\t..}kr   b<- .!J"rl.m u_l~u   rek~e#: 1\~~ M~r-~,l-4.:_~~~-~~f'j"(::.l>YI~----------·' - -

:·~·---~
   _1-.)_Q\.N\ ~ \-~\AU'~~I.M\~ 4'-c_See.J:"""' L.)_a?f .-4-k.... b·. L,q:f~(~k:\--')_Qn___:_-\:h.-\t\ __ ,]_______

   ck~-N\~~cb_~o.\'S'~_cl~~bolo~~-s~ ::\:bivL~-~-'-'-'--U>~t..~Lop_Y~-IlM_:__he.,__ ___
                                                                                      ~ ·--
                                                                                                        ----------

                                               ----~'~-~~n______
   -------------------'-----!P~~l\_J)c\_~ - - -

                                                  -----~~~~~~~~ ~~~.---
                                                               ~ ~~}~------­
                                                  ---~\=·~~'~~0~~v~~~~U~~---­
                                                  ·~----'.f\\c....=..:\=-~-~-~-w_(dj_J