Court Opinion

ID: 4052340
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:59:15.960019+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:42.467389
License: Public Domain

L/`hj mgio])
,LO(>_$~""`*\€/ HD/lO/‘abfc judge £>4: SQ:A Cour+
Cz>mes I\>O.,L>, B¢>bby £>rew£m&ry,_ §Y pM+€/j pm 564

W R%v~€$+ &M‘-\@Sw mo+;w\ /n> _B@ /~)¢zcved rowe
Ha/b€a;x Record 1911 F)bo¢/e I\)umk)efe@° LOFH; /95 ,¢m LLuJ
@med is -€FQ.¢+§ wz)‘z‘~as~bm~ ’r'(n) 143 mm /1-5;¢:~1 J)<>@.<.
h)DSV<§SW?>'M[/¢Ij. )QH C¢w.£€l Hew`d 171 §§ng Hecu}>
ing In Cr;m;r\c.,i B;,c+/\>¢,+ (;‘>\w+ #3 bn D,MSL 13, 300¢1»
R¢\>#, Pages 1025 am /C;)[, mm
Qn\/ Z>+Ker Pa@es Ll/¢w¥er’l”%cse, C_¢W_.hby b]~»:+ry 17011<¢6
` couRToFchMlNALAPPEALs mCCDn,/\@,L\ L{,n,»+
FEB 262015 3001 5‘- ém,ly bf.

Be@/;h@fn. 7310<9’
Abel Acosta, Clerk »

 

 

75 733 H¢nom,ble ng@,(>.; bd 93

C.ome.$ haw Bc>b by§mo 955+ry5 E¢ 90¢'+1’>, 930 331 land

350 4 535511\3 '045555~555 .0554+ 73555 5005 355
v Rea¢on Tc> Grm+»@b¢>ue, 304d 330-isiah

 

3355-:50:3+;55 955- 1155 930 \»xwr/\3 155 115:7.5 <;,555.
Dl~.§.m..,+e:» 9mm U¢m~r\e'.\ Ds+r\¢c.,+ C.a¢~€'\‘ M¢>. 3..

7%3¢"3-?@03, "T`h¢$ Hpnc>ra»‘o|e,% Ho..§ TM».S¢\»¢+»@A 0 531/633
7`¥13 .qu,ec,+ mw+fer D~€ Th.‘_s ‘.'D\_s+wv mohan

 

movan+ 301de 535054) 'Thm' H 5 \,0,54.)\./3¢ web3 l\)¢>+
Prc>w£e¢£’ F¢;>r' "`The 950~11+3€`!`£>»5€0 E$M%ve D3041¢\ 930-'
3-"'*"5'3/ 333 751»`5 004533"7@ v0513/3¢¢’>»'\_¢13“"`1'355»., IQE D:PQ,.-
393'139»'39" 339 9 93 ’39‘9 395 `

pg|

 

 

`. j:ol‘~:l.~»l.*."l;¢;s~‘i\"`¢"_i»f"l. . . . .

11€,® I_<, 195 Ev,dwl,e,“l’o Sm¢lpor+' 9/\\/ '4‘\/}>€/ O$T€V°
4‘\5~4~»<. T/p5 09 951 Cf 9¢'_41'.5 be‘l`h@ mop/cull . .
745 wal I’.s 435/owl 0Filan554»lrll>»lll Gl' l/ll,~'i
+;m glwlm€n~ls w:+`n+ Callvlc:l¢vfl wmwa 944¢'~¢4< `Tb€' 435»4" b
blm ol- hwl 55 ab ill5 13555~55/4+15 lllle.gll; ll~l ‘
PF¢>U€, .$l.l.@`lu€¢\l’ Fo..¢.:l£» wl~c,\n 'I'ic ‘TT\.»€., 490le El\

4144-5 Hlm"l?> R54l5:9 556,,- v .
_El,i,@olw_mwlllbnaab, 585 5 lo acl llll ill (‘lllolm. app 1555

9 445:?5;¢ ollm+ /4`15¢54 P4god 9n54 Prbu~e, Fol¢:l§ 44345?€54¢\
544 445 L\im"'l"¢;> Re,lic;€ ibm/l 443 mo.:>+ ibmv3 4-44; (`,\o..lm
34 ll Mlmblel~ww 05 1555.~5555 555;

1.»€*._;_4°,»:~ l @w'll 555 5 lb aa ll'll 65 cl m llpp 15753

945045_¥,__430~¢'45._9¢45¢“5, "44>@ S 44.>_¢9¢4 2484) 387588 dell C.,r;m ¢W- lU)

il De»l`em\:m+ mall sllw>, 05 lb4 Lea:l 944535,"'1“4\5 wl
4'¢5.`.4~554 Pa»c.+`$ \,<_»,}4\454¢\ C;¢We 945€, "4"¢>, 945ch CDM}§€J 1
459/354 Cmolw€»lon Tl\b.,+ 5544455 444jl/4l~‘"" 40 4?54=54`

55 llb..¢~ib,j_l\l>~_,;_icm 555 540 354 359(154 C).m ilpp 1577)

 

 

 

     

 

   

 
 

f`*'\c)v§§+ 935§1'+5"'5`7\§+(§.» R§c.c>f‘§s F\¢m§+§\y
§¥\ou;) Th§ 9|$¢§§1¥1095 999 arr§r.§ 56‘-\' FD#`+L\ I"\"W\
' t " 1 ,_j»' . 11 pad 1. 31(,4,{’“+ R€LD£.}
, _ ~ ~ ,.:4 , ¢,, §m,\_i&_é:>* va’ér C,§ws§ lUD 51
FO.%”&~S°§F!“ FD~BJ§S"?:B*Q,:. 919 1393 95 7114 L,L,M>§J
1005 ~9§“95'7»7‘(.~) 11)<>§¢1_.1""73»;11@) aon 11§3… 95_77¢1~»§(»1). _

   

 

 

 

 

   

011 Qpril ~73,510@‘»1 Pk§ He§rmjm§~. H§\d 9m771§

'mov§n‘!" LO§S Pe,rgu§d§d ‘T"§ P\§§§\ (’,1§. t+y 999 w§n/E.
jury ‘I`ri§\.- C§§A~-\- z1_,,_1,, £§1,11\.5§\ ms 743 L£n§ 711
Com§¢ m§¢~§|y £n+~ered 9 99 F'z>€‘m§ 9¢9@!§11¢§.
a pro gbme Qpp€o$@.r\¢,~g, O'@ C¢M§@\ .0€.'.$ }\>D+` Am" \_
é>w‘\+ ‘T°;o -" 9§15+§1¢@ `-DSF f 1387 “’ 81 ”D§§ 910¢:§$1
O(W" C,a§n_<,§i 9511/'.1@¢9 b§~€en&§m`\* P§rk/ 5§§»
Ev?`}€,_.;g;,¢\$ S'"?é 500 139 3953('7`§11.(`,.1,”1 990 tq&'£>)

Invc> un~’cwy 9\1311. D§§`T'@ me 329 §€F§§+» 1/§ 955"'
~ ‘~"~+“111. @1»@1>1~1§ 119151911111 '

To .$¢1§ ;~;‘-`, why 955§€'”§' 'Tk§v* `T".w§l COM§§! '5 F§¢iwf€
T§ Ob,¢§d» 9__+§») 711 D§%‘e§+¢/§ 9~5515'7 §§ 9
D§~£Wm+ mud 5710§> ‘T'k¢~.>&-

n c 3 T/"¢cl..‘ 374an L\}O°
ibid 5"1§11’§ wmde §rrof m DV§N`§lmj 501§%9»1
Oq)ec>h§n jean ' l _.

 

 

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

0

 

Fe§¥~§.m.,§ 050640>0~0044$§1'$ 0/11>0§1,0€§0 when *0601~»0 Irw\o~ _
c»‘-'@""‘\`” P€f`$or§ .L;B IAWW ca.;_§ef“<,\ '130&:}\ `T`f'~€'(`,€>¢§*l'"§' §`0“'\@l '
0»0§,0§0 T§~§§~§ “0'00?§ _/~_:`0§,001€5 0,0).000§+\0\600 °l"`\'\€ 0{54€§16§)§»00+§§6609

 

P§'€) C,u.q\‘cj; Q¢' Mo+". l `
§§ 00§160§~0'1§0§1_ 015>¢1 5 010 §§0 3000 C,~r~§§. <;1~_:10_0 §§§.31>1>§3

`T\"€. Cowr`+ €,x~hw\e§§ "0`004 F§vc§¢§m..b \` 4\/; O_‘£ /44+'~4¢-»0 _
Inf\oc.znc€. C.\c§§vv\$ 0> .:611~0 \"0‘/ P\ec§ 50”§01.0.6§11>01$ `Tl'\ €.xpa/\O§&p 'Th€, C¢.>\,a,¢"§§ yQ(,-§¢M;,\ j:y.noc,ence I"M~»
0590'\».¢30§>:104€ 045 592+ ()w“§"'Im ' » .~ w

E¥§ M"\€§.\\ZQAC§C> qw’] 151,¢6.0 3`¢§ 3001 CT@‘» Q[:m_.~ 0(4§0§§1 \€iqé§

"I.'\ Ca¢<;_§_,. '.J:/\§/o_lv050)

101 §/¢z,/`Mc>¢), `T£'\<;, §3€~(:€/\0%.0'04' 040\€53¢§ 'Thc¢:r 044 l_/.351 7101 (‘166 600 660 600-11 l

175€ COM*}' (71‘66/\‘4'6,61 R€ls,€:@ 110 9 5141.5.05‘;»5¢'>~5¢1 10561`6
l `1"1\@, De§ev\cdm~.~§' 3003 1004 1146;>_0»1`€., 94 "11~\€, "1”;/06 1~116 €fl"’
461/601 1415 131;,666 411-401 71'\€5(:616\@1¢61`¢\061'1.‘15 14001 12660"\+€`?1
'1`1~611‘ 5¢6»60¢6410»6 000 1006610 1004 Ha_ve ‘16$41\@¢`;.66\
936'6~0§'1* 14 m 1014"‘1'11661 ' »

1116 1364`61065\00‘1' 1460 1.»€€6¢»'\€¢1 04 7116 136¢;0.1~+.5
564¥6'05 94461 ’°1“1»56 <;041y 04 1415 43ng 1314/4 v?>¢wr€,

 

 

 

' 51 101'~\6§01‘1000<:6, 95 .S 1565 30 61651 (:"161~ 3105 5119 393
`7'1'\6 156-1600¢60*1 M)’»v€' 90111,6¢11666‘16<:1 34614"~/ 04 56.;1¢*
,1)56..\ “‘;5,,<,$¢6561+ 366661 304=1`6\\/ 101500 14651;§ 661661 "Df\»‘ W‘@“Y
116 1460 131 1364~116“0 321 Habm£, 36516?,€.!64/51‘§
145 Q.@\€q,§€, 10 1366'1:~651`1`€01 196116~64 C¢$r.,;1'co"‘»‘\ w&$ §£4/0;6€'61
4 10144\0666 566 131066 6 s 056 15¢666)
7716 w"1°'/\CS_.S€;”.S 1936¢5105 71`\@ 1065&’4’\&16/\'1' 8111\€{/` R@“
~_,_Cw\+€c.b "'1'\'6651‘.;`,§'§_6.‘>441/!/»¢31"\/ D0 ‘T’ha,pr B.Q,g QVW| L`,e,,"j
116601 B€€.n £)cpi)_§ed 4.;; : _A _~ . -':-"

    
  

I'e` TMC‘S 11 C-"H’YW\¢~\ 1565 4004~ 333 §041‘+\60 ` ;`
n 7 R"MGAMW LW*?~@Y'\/l` tq Qt€@e/\G?wn+ 9'\6»$ Re"

C,e;,`t\)¢J Le@ec.4¢ve stts+anee 09 CDw/\s€\ C,Qu.¢+$ shown

hhse We&an<>hwd .Se+ For4h~ I/\,' '

549¢9<\999\ 9 99995999 999 u 5 999’(_19999

‘T'\e Ca;r+ 09£,9\9\.9\9,\ tF-\ppeats 999¢)4€¢9 ‘Ttne 549
ick\ow\c\> 540»¢\04¢»"¢9 I"\ ‘ '

H€I’I\C¢/\de?.. V $’\'CC\`€ 751!> $,L¢.)- 3d §§ (`T€;L C¢/,~m gpp \€lg(‘>)
` 799 movm+ (‘,99\4@95‘1'9\99 t-te ms 93th "`“e
599¢9_>9¢ 955¢54¢99\¢9 09 Cot..w\se| 5we Tb H -‘» H~Hc>mc\,
\>er.sw.¢tw 5 t~léné '72> m ve 995 995\¢»+ 70va TF"““
(~9_¢109" .L,r\ "Th\ 3 Co»££, ;:"'9@"0 959€0»69 "'H'Y) 'S€’€" ' ' ` 7
gl,\darl&e bwbw, 550 s w 99 SaS'CTex 999 999 99939 ' '
9 699-9 999999 9¢¢€9+ 9 9919, 999 999 99 '
Inct vidml "T'\/\cd~ I$ j' j‘ jf~~:\\\/ In€©mp@+€n+‘ 9-'0~¢9- ”'
mg `11*0 I\ve.s4 jack C,Ompe+€/\c.\/ Is Predu.o\\e\ce\
. 3.9 `r*h\@€,- 325 99 Rm~/\¢vb\€, 9599\3@,93; t 47 "Th\¢¢/+ ‘TV\€¥ '
5e9erd99\‘9' 599 b§45` .Se\/€Je 0499\49,\ 990909<9/15"$&
mft..“.<..t<.e v 999,94+ 337 t:` 39 \\93 t\)
950 TOI~¢/€.$+¢jcde, men'}‘ce\ $‘1&..‘9€ I‘°md "'The, _. : ..
Posslbi\ 47 09 939 t'Y\aMzJ tDeV€rue- '

 

   

 

     

 

=».»~~~ yck~cc\’nc_, D`§€>rd€i$ 5€€’>, il '

` BM+;_ \M~*Mv 333 F 33 557 (7“~3 r 3005) _

333 335 umw 31;,‘§_+35 v H»m.m 330 s?:. 33 373 (Q“r‘\<;.r 300¢)§

t In Howa..rc,\ `fke Couf~{' Remcmc,\€d Fm? \~\ecq/‘m TO` ¢Q€“
S'e»\v3 w\'\3+&33r CDM\¢e\ w33» Ine@€ec.+me C-`Qr pllw)¢`mj
De¥`em)an+ who u~>35 433/3333 Tke, Im€l»c/~¢€ 04 {%»oe/Q.L|
(\>¢'M'CO+¢§S, TO D\€c».a\ SW\+\/ 7 - '

Ir\ ‘THS_ Ls~lcw\+ C,a~se movem+ wm L%¢>\@f`l'l"€~ I’\'*
~Flw€./\ce §-C pow'€f'€w\ PS\./LL'\G’WOMC, m'€d¢€rci'¢c>>'\$ ‘5(`@3'
3u umw 33 733 Da:¢»\*\$ FOV` /ka\ mMy

   

 

  
 
 

_ _ Comse,4 " 3333 r\>@ 3333-b wv<,...+.s¢>ever" +‘>CO'"
mvm.c¢.,+€, uo€+b\ Cpmp\wmn+ who R‘a=,c..cw\_h ‘;,_;1_~,"7713%` id
3>_¢~\3 \~\3\/€ Te¢+'¢€»ti* 3 ¢53€:‘,~3/\{- ida/339 A>Q+' C.¢>"~‘

`|5'33)13$_11v. im\+v\ 3% F 33 “°‘\rgo£>§"),

C¢Obw'\$€,\ m\&$+b .fO\\V\Cw’*\\\' MV€_S+`S¢¢{€;

PK"'

 

 

 

   

966 mem g 666
w\+v\e,sses‘"` 566 1 ‘ . . .
ch>+s v. ¢3“6\6¢~66\< 786 F 696 \a;¢§\' laal(q-mbr \qgé)',

77\666 0666666@ F6,.\66v 1'6> goodwi- 0.6\/‘3;6¢66+366666

§A+ iam I'i'\'iO mbt/anb P~Sydf\\a:im(, H\.S“\‘Or\/ 9»'6<>¥'['1€/`€*

y -por€, f\>@`j\€o\'€¢j "|"c`.~) \J)f,urdw~€, 9 \b¢>'\'€n+¢cv\\y SMLG.SS'F¢»L(_

D€‘F€/\b€ §e,€, . .
'5¢\6)6\ v mm\@. 1146 6 »“1€":6*6 76~6~£'€‘”~<:61¢6¢66°)

lt Cowr\.§el W\o..c\e i\)O"T'a,¢-}"»ca»\ D€,c,¢.$¢c)r\ i\>o+'f"c>

,. I" V€~‘»`i\$@i€, L"i'i\€ movan+)j poss¢ bia /Y\e¢\&~c.,\ beao~.r~

nme/4 H€' `S'mp"/ .~é:"~.`&:i@oi 'F¢> D¢> 50 6€€,¢ ”

Dm+€f v LO$\‘H€N, 88"| pga \\.S'él ||SQ éc>(q'rhcr \qg€g
6 De,@\c,¢€'\? performance u>c'~S l\.)¢>+€o\\ Wi’\€"`€

" Mo¢`r\e\/ F:c\,\\ed `Tb .\\J€c>\' 'TZ> goim¢$.§¢c>r\ 99 CDV\‘
~F€.§Su>r\ `§_/ i\>€>n T€$`i¢ y¢¢’\j D€§:-Yc,iw+ 5€,€,

, 364 6 166 665+6..466 313 636 6'1§('7“~¢.6 6;)<>62)

».;,

pm»…c) ‘P(\Q sec»§.¢¢`-Q‘Y\'

 

 

    

 

R€?.wi¢`€mer\+ Is iq 654 ’¥w¥¢ch/| C,\o..uY\ C>‘F

i?/R~“evh us Q_ms-¥Mc,€, €>-€ C.ow\~$e| where PIW)€W `Iv\v€s~';'
_636,4.666 06 066J66+666 w<>-w 6\6,6@ 966666./66@ 766 _
-6§¢.¢@;~ Qnoi `T’i\e¢e .I's !\>e \QP,__. Eea..sc>r\ why C,Ow"'
6661 w 064 66+ 566 " ' "

E#W@Mw 3\0 s w 36 m m -:,:CFMQWQUD)

 

 

   

 

 

.C,666666611 '6 )`366`\666,'1*6"”"111666_ 1366 60;4466166,,61
1343 PD1261. 1311 "`1'116`”1`?¢113.""`113 121-de 5+¢6:4€¢& "N\@\/ i-~iqd’
MQ £1"611@"13*@36(€3161'1 §31;016! 5\306 \/6>1. '24*3‘£> P¢Lg@» 195
Q“"A mb 03 7@@5`15 309"1)§¢51"\ p{`¢€.€, 316~.3€¢11

"_i\)z>vxe, ;616.1 l~lonor " 2236'16_1,._>,44\@.$535 Qecc».m“€o! 1311¢21
_ W\wr\+¢~...»\ 466666~ Tv\ey w.r¢>+c. mo b"w+w~€v\vs Prqm/u'(»
713 5€,~(~’€/\56&6'125‘ 1_ _314666.6.6\ 01 Con $4~`1+¢».,469, W\a..\¢ 61 c>w.$

31166€¢6~64106\ 5€3,' _
111116‘36“6 111 .1= 661 166 1623 06 mm 66661))66

W.WJ)`SW@.S v. ,H\Vax€z Taw\'\mec }é>D §636)$7§(13’16.(;.,. 1993)
QLSO CO~M\$€,!$ 1_16¢»@@¢2;.+¢6'€,6\€~§3 Qlw€£.. 1

533~16'\51.!6 156611661€ "'51.> (.61/\6»1\3613€2.'“"511€.5»6.@¥<_.€/\¢\/
O“c`* ne €,Af¢"/?€.r/`\C“;' T‘\ n"i"$/"\\€_.- `TV`5CL` \,OV*»€“"' far/1155 am

prm\ 1066 216613‘\'€<:661€ 13566'146.6"66_ 1634/1666 3666.4»66 663
1935 L.c»:fg;e\\/ 111/2066 ‘~4~»"66\~6660.4 Se€,; ` ' '
116in v 566.'46. 333 43 364 101-1\ 1161‘1”2\¢,.6 11637"`)

114 TZ'\'S CCl-¢$€»¢ In O/\€ HCM)/\j, bd1 'Hn |'V\F€€» CF~"
1662 I\)Wbe.rs 1564€61 ¢44666#€ “Tp,qe m_; 106 §6.161€/\6@

k¢\€>m‘€éb§€. .~c 573/le .S"'G¢j'€. bid MO+' `C;(A,,\I " mg M

9 gm C.l§.-`£L COA‘(€,S`S¢¢)Y\ l Tah€» 5"1'€¢»-+€ iLB\/ AV\Q¥ T}"\{`(>L'Ljh
ém/\ Drlcé, 5+664€¢3 wang `~Jow’ P\ov'\.z>/‘. 66

   

  113

 

 

1 1 151%>~'4€~7 15 'Fo.,; 116166,;,1"¢> m`“é>"iy€, P“iju»ppfess»c>n
06 wm 3661¥6_>-6\ "4"6\6..,+ 4,6.>666 4311-»;64/~66\/ €6/6¢4266466 032-
Cur\§"i' 1.`)€65~€¢\0}1_9»¢\`1' 516\.»‘1€€¢3 C,161.44m 04 Ir\ €5{`1?.6€:111/€1
95515246.,6\6€. 5»<<";€,7 . 6 _ _

511'7\1211_~\ 11 wa.mwn 1474, 777 F': 93 503 mmc 7 793¢)

3 1 ` ,
246 06666666666 4666 61 366436.6664 36 416 614 -

11ch 196er »mu.s‘+ 1612/2636 406 Qwe.sHm 1513/663 "Fl»\.'~e ~

&64666.666 043 366 3:66666666.64464 456 966 566';

1_\)7114 \/.$‘1¢¢1€»(,~65.” )6bU. 361 1:$121‘ (sé)X('i'€iv (`4{4~ 995 QDL>!}

 

161 1646 566,6€64 646 43`”6>4 466;>41 `-

51 3'14.015€44€6\~1 043 Cor\\/¢¢,+mn Fof 431€,4‘.§1`4'_1€, I$ Vc>id 1491\€1’1
0)_‘1'1\€, DD(.W¥\€A'P PMP¢J(-%w\cj"¥'o 13)€, 591 C,L»\qu;< I;\_JTFW@J\-{-
51 €:.» 1331 Q+m€“+ jn€>f`mc»+¢m C>r C¢>mp\o,.m) QO@S !\4\0‘1"
§6..'»’1‘1$51\/ 551,4€, Q._,,r\>~¥ 1'\.¢'1*1€>1’\€1\ 1€'@/1`1 "5`1466.,:» 111-1465 `_55`116<\ Cczm.¢" *§~' 1516'¢.§ 41\,\@:§:4.0‘ L_J 1~16¢>4

C\/ef 716 De,~Fe/~ 616/154
@ `T"h€, "7"¢16‘1 1 (`,01.6.4‘-14- L,.m,\<.$ Swm@ck 411"406-.‘6461~ 3466§121\1<_~16

654/er Th€. D€¥`@m S€j U»\MB@¢A 6 .
5we Q€C.OM C¢1~€?.¢-4’1\/ 1<`€»1:1€,<.»`15 `:5164 161/163 115 1343 €,Wd“’

€1\¢~€.. 'T`D $wppof+ `51\€. CGHV‘C11W4 l ,

l@211 1314 :1:/\6113~@61”\‘12 1335€64¢161\1“ 15 563 9{67,;;¢7/\ `1`_'0 3663
1113 14411\1¢64 `1."1`1~§*¢‘6.4 1310€.@63.;16455 bu641,6¢>16$1" 4._-41,414)¢_.>674~1@65

 

'Cowse\ when ..ch»i~ P\.."?-‘> "">@"i E>m Wc";"”e°i" I"
Vfé> w+€\m 36 Qrdw\»' “>1»'~:.\.3‘~>1’3*~+
3033:33 303 H‘e,a:~i¢&e, ‘To 3.3.3\ Tws 93 3‘§,3¢»¢!\3 ~
3¥»1'~‘¢_ 343-313 §§ 55`$ \/€1\/'1\3\€¢~¢\\1 353 ?Ed 13+ 338
Tl\e, ‘C<;>W*‘r 06 Cr;m`\v'\m\ 33\3\3\3<=3:3 'H33,5 !,»\e',\c:i
'The~”i' `.'E~F `€'1'3€; f)f.@@ wci 'Tu<:ic¢€m/‘~€w i'~.T" r/\p@`gm€j
idmv;,<§¢h¢»\ 3 133 \/3..33 '~1*1333,3 ~1‘33'"1"3333¢ 3;3,,3_,33»33- 333ch
i'mM€ 3’\)1'3 iqwi\»,@v vi-~/ T‘> Q¢W">K€'l Drobmiim\ S¢`Ac€, _
333-33 303 333\3333333 :1:;33¢>3.3 33 333 3333.333 333333
I"i’ If> lci N¢.A..\i wi\‘{, €l€ 155 f\§§»~i$,3,p¢) ~‘m») QKV©£LN .

303 31 we 35 § 33 333 333 (511~331`§

 

1133/3333 33333 m3 1333 333<;33~33 333:3333/ 93
gewich §+cz.:ir~z,. .`_3~}¢3:33€3;! C>r\"!`i'\»e, J\f§’ €3<>1’"0\ `Tl'z¢¢i `*[idfs»..\f

i-\c..@? l\>o ém:£€m<~
mofm'\"\’ FI.M"+$¢\‘~?..V HS§‘@F%$ m'\Q/"i` ij/»IK\W\¢,{ .`;¢'.3.~4\

Hm.i~i\,\ 932me D+"'"” gi`m#?, G$ 9\3~:¢:3 mm ;R.@& 353 ,'»1’35
f 3333~303+1\3 3:>»333~333 a 1333 3333 03 §3333,3333<. mae
C"\'-~(#’*~'"i\£»’\§ '

m3 333 + 1b sues ”13».? 3 3333'\03:3333€ 003~3"3? ‘*i?;~ é~:.fw+
Ti\¥ .S ma>+.@n 113¢\33 0 3"""°"£> I-.»') yes+;§@+@ ”f“v\e,. @He\{jm+,c>n;

::f\ 539 nff\;!;') 993 §/33‘23/`3.3 T’I`{` 3_,3~3',¢:3,(` 'Tz»\€i QP ;M`c§ (,">»3 g__v,‘:;’£',zf§,

5 33 11 1

3 .2:20.3.> _Tn 3/033/€:<:2\

 

 
  

~Temcmm mp .3¢:3105 QCW bob ibew 47
W€'/:}+M€, bid \/2{.`>2 2`¢3;2€2 3@#"¢*-¢\-‘13

833 230?22=> 3>)*"2$322>2’\, QQ'\"§ 223 363 C‘? _9,3, 514 §"<“*2@9 G~;M {xH~ 227 20%>}
€'¥ p“'M€ IMMMA 395‘2 53 W 362 §2,>2.2 (j”T=‘P.\¢ 3;;_2`2\"\ VQM?. @6}€>¢1)
2 233056€226‘2'01~¢62_.\ 3¥\3'5212)¢\6`\6¢.-"3’ "~ 3253/\€23 6 W€’,
326me §263.2622162\23 3we 626»32\3¢¢~2~3'322\/ 8036\€2126,

C:viv6m 2229-362 2336-46 3£22\62 h)D D‘GJ€<-"f*»m .- `
B"c~o\\; v mw~{la.nd 373 2225 83 (3€2(;~2'3)

by 2`2,.,2”26 toda:»/rw, 76§ § w 626-2 6233 (36)< fund 25 93932. 2@&¢!`}

52’6263 303.61 6562\ Cm 3.~@635 2 cs/\ \'30.6’2 {\50` 3\5<>~2033`2{

23,)21626 "3’3»\_6226 2065 23 _S@.:,~\r`¢¢sr\ 2»2`2: 5666. 9
`*nm`S 332"\(>;,>~365 _\/9205 ma jw‘( icb-2 C.D”'\‘Q€,)j cmi

213/322 "'2;'232 2 ;6~2 3026 2 '>2~.>2~ 3>‘162602 023 1236 666-2623 wl 26
' 203/562/'\+ Wc.¢/JS PF€§<~;/L 22 1231 "`“'h@' CV\L{U_P+ 326;92\323/1 "

5 [~:221.2' 3216 mc'* ma*’ ._1,2`_`2 V’s-"¢"i‘ 2;`22@73 Q“~§°'Q
md 2022 5»;2222 2222+23 23 2 23 2233 32\2\0~ 3'\’\"‘2‘2"‘~'2 33’“
362222~ 222 ;2;~2`22322 326 622 222 222 220,2.2; 2 3322.22..~322»12.

‘n\ , 636632\ 526 05 3392,2...6\<,2; 2321¢>3 §§.22,32

  

 

Wh~u€,`£¢>r€,, 1312 111 du1128 1111'“‘”1'5»1"€1€"`€@1 11110"""~"\`1'
131.1. 1113 "1'111, 1~10111110.1\1>, C~m~.v\m 1\1.§~1»1»11+€¢1»14`+"&3"
:€111,11+ 11.11111.111 1111 1211 11111~1 111 31 1311 €1\+\1'"
214\{ 1111-111 191~1"~31‘1 1€»:111~ 7111/2541`30:1€ §‘1`1:»"1‘€1>\ 11111€.‘
351.~1»\1:11'\$ I'n de ncaa 11;?2\/`1€,11.> C>'(;`T¥'\,r$ C»~S€..

1311¢1 jLG 31111-11’\1;1/1/) {;`1\11"€?~/1¢1:111»'1§ 11111,`€" T$‘
S&’A’ 1151 1‘1€£~(`¢1/\"1 TO 1:<;".`1;{`1'€,<;'1" 1911 £fv@;!`§ 1&1\21 ~1.2)/`1"\3
1111 111>`11;11;1;1\/ 111 1111>11,111 11111111~1. 1 "'"'1 11~»~€1\/

_1}1€,\1>1\33_,, "1`1> ~T%1 <& Q_,v\¢ 1\/ 1111
1121 11 "111 71111151

 

 

 

 

54me C,o_n;§»`¢)€l€:.\ 1"`1\1=;, 1110va 5 /Y'\<>`r' 1:‘>'1
j

% wd\/\C)[(MD; P,€C¢,,, l+ I$ Oc ¢n’\§.',_ 0{)<11\107"1 .'$
TV\¢§ C,DM+'TWW,» "1551¢\€ fno~')»;‘£{)v'~' .:.1?1’1::1..~\:2 1316-1

< 3 (;"'¢"'5`1`2“¢3 W'M’\ 1131 2%”~*" 055»335 Tr:; 1’1/'11,,1’~'1'/\+ 159'?`
6 1612<111..13 1%@11>111 '

() B.e.n§eci~;; 11>1111\ 1101 111@»1'1 011/111 119 1`1191111111 1111~1'
T15116 1311)[}1€,5) L,€,\e>u.,».

 

 

7 ._.\<>1>1> 1111-111 11911%
z"`-D’\"Cx:>rme\\ (jm.+
"-)`OO‘ §2_'1&,111'1“\1;]1:] ,£>F_',.
1111.11111.111,,1“1 1111/9

¢<1';,111’11:19, 31.,1.11111,19111,

 

 

Ia 930953959 9§5€:».) 953555:9~5~'59, 059-5 ""F.l»\ca mo ucwa%9" I/\

1759 5.~§?, 9+9.505/€, 5`5 30 95¢9r‘a hnc Q$<,aa/.-\; 9>5“£>€5/3'995/;[:¢\1\5£¢55”&.37'

.£3~“'9"*?_»;»9 I._u:\ "~'9"'.9:>, C¢;I. 939_"9'95§~'1:{'('3©5’*/9“:° 9 9/`£»9’\ "9” fn

§9229/; 99€£. , A"9'“@2`>C':l\;§.; 956 f W'\é-¢i`€`;, €;;;/\_ 555'€25' ~p@¢a:?\¢:e_,;,+\}l Z::)~\,C '9G‘Qy.1 f".=
Tya.c.,z£» ""95»€, 5§595,,.;53 535;55;~ j _3533»~< '§1:;»'~5'55;\ m _;,~§5‘ ~w, ;0m
795 52»£, 555 553 f..@/r f"~?,¢ '9' 70 '59'“»5'=:v 593€53~5 <2>55 /‘5’\~.\{ 5<55:>52;)9€_5:33.(_,

F’"` 35 999 QCLS”

ij t

 

 

 

§

 

. 5a 5:.-;335, 5>5: 5335‘ »

 

    

Il, Bz>bby 935€,53.3 505,5+5\/, Y\m/¢:m+, _
rey '9'9»15;.:~9' 533 T w£.>.,; 595/wl 91in €°£2‘9' 5_,.3‘.>9,>\! ?`\C' `T.£'\{c H.N/€l
con vs 5 d Qra ’-‘9\€, 5555~3+5¢,'\~ 1523 elk O~?Ti'»@
C,ram,a~ca ®55.53.5,5 c5ac55» 993 915 - 1555-535 50 955/993 9
51¢393 §@3.~\@77§5 :@;KG.S~ v':9.'¢.")'7<;»96>73 ` 7 9

 

 

 

`B@dbv hmo 95<»¢:55'

- ~9`9\55;;>315\@1\
311-59 ha §235'\39‘~{ L.¥ _
95&€»/ 9€. , T% 73 "'1'1::95”/`09