Court Opinion

ID: 4061149
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 20:03:08.524819+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:06.155713
License: Public Domain

A éei/ #c(oe+¢\
f ~ ' C{/€/‘lé d '
COM\+ O§ C{‘\`IM;¢\)OJ /MP€DJ$ PC(OM

QO'BO><
_ '9\305' C'r‘} )\')T\l "`
AUS§M(T£X,. ?_I%}P’ SJNIW\)

L/,L+ -- ` l
) €,'r/UU\/€/w\\§ep 5-?:';‘ ,9\0)§-

RZ § wR_~‘ ¢/L/j ;L)C/ ..,_Oa

‘/@5, wc@§e¢é fs FQWAS gov -‘fv.\ 04 under QNL E>WD\§I\A (‘Fcu\ufe. 40 pursue 00
' `\0500¥4‘\" 99¥2052.\115 uncomth and des'\¢;§nad 409€011‘1\014'90¢1 \mnc\er redress
€5¢'1`1\`0¢ ?0£1`1¢_9\04~1`£1590.5 04 fne¥$ee+€v¢ 955}$40.¢1¢.2. 91 comse\ ad¢re§.se§
10 1110 hnbens 999\1¢.01 1011 0¢1¢1 memnrmum.g,¢¢, ( A¢,.} AFF ?,\ 1

TNL Subs'kmce. 045 APP\\LN'\4S 11009.95 C.on4eA4\DA 13 10050¢\ 90 91\
¢.?:0~1\4`€ p\€c». 41'££\' u.\9.5 mod¥, 1911010040;1\‘1' bn§ee§ 001{\1°?\1¢,9045 man/1401
A?sd‘dex~ 001‘0__ 91 1110 1.~10. 01 P\e_9 95 we.\\ 95 c.\u.¢mcs 1100 cwmssmn 01
crime ond1th \190095 1r1c0~1?e1e¢1c,1es 01 1001 000/159

000 01 1410 mo_s+ 10190;4¢01+ 991‘105 01 90 9140~\0-? veP:e$e,/\Mns 9
011~1100100101¢\0011590)1.5.05 \1_'.5 c.\ cv\+ 991101%10 ke_ 51109\.:1 Plend ve._n_:\H.
0.90192.421\4' 001.>0`50,'\ 419$ 9991‘1) -\1> _(mdar 1115 bas+ 399¢3¢0¢»1' 40 015
011011 90091 9091 909 10 011er.9v1c1 1991 39¢10~\0/11 51191.1¢1 be
1010rmer.1 b¢? 90 9¢1§®.991@_ and 1000?2119¢1114'101051 0912. 0411}10 430 ¢;15
01005@. when amsex's ve?re_$e¢11n11 00'1§ 00051.1111{00¢1\\\) 1001124.1‘.\/¢.

 

§§I'SZ§*E%` §1`\§& 5‘§‘£@£§131"£§\§‘§’ Y'P.N!§Q€“S L\.h"(_\ f 9151.\§ §§1'\1'.‘5 &13`1 § *‘1’ P§Q.¢.\ §1\§iuiur1‘§w‘13 .
131 11 131-1113 11 ~1" "33511..~.213 11131$@¢ 13 »'1»~- 331‘1 '

111?¢1'1 1113 313>112, 111131111§;01131 13911'11_.33§~1135 331 111-111 ~‘!r\¢~d" §m':s §1~.’<11
CDUSQ§.S ’£'<'..9313`~.&$3 §‘c»:e§£!`\. §'c',.§§ b&.§cu.x 631'\ 1.121€1:§11/1¢_ ix§ar§aé`z;§ &§' f`:,c\$:>h»
0.\:§&1135$ b'»r ‘f.;>u\éa&`_‘:, ‘1'1:1§§11;113 -.111..‘>3"'133 §‘1’113§13'15¢3§~~\§1113 o§
1:1§§ w\£e, (3\ 11\\1,$\§11§.1 .c. 1\".@1. §.z.\ .'11€.,1“`!*`;4}. §\§S§';:>I""e C\n:§ 1`1.£:.3..3., 1111 1'1'1§ §§§c~_§'¢;_:f\
9311‘0§1:5-- §`.1:): cam 1~1!'1011;11_3~1.¢, and P¢-,~nvi's§\r\'\z»\‘\' P‘r;a£e_ a¥-$r‘\¢d(j¢>\`c\¢,\\.e.-'s.‘ng;
111?1‘1¢3.1'1§~11 91133 313 11~»+=1_1,1111»1 1531/13 1113+$.»_1 -§¢> Pr-e,\!o.. m 3111.1‘+1<,131
\“[1 £1‘1~:§' §»"1::»:-1\ 13111:.1!5 13§ §"'.¢1\~.~, 121-§1:1§§'1:11$:.{”1`3 §‘1=.111:#5-§1.:;¢;:§~3. 111§'§0135`:11;1 am '§¢11
513*:,~ ?1‘.@:1::1 ~§:1:1“§:§:1§1'5`.) \'11:=§ €1101\1'1.111¢§ ‘:.1~1"" .W\11'1v11’1. e\.s°€r~§ 1°@ 1"~2131,1&5"1~ a f C`)§‘ .
Pz".u»_ §u“ 905£~`1\;1§¢.3. 1101?113111¢1§131\ 5112_ 41>1~11.1\-‘~¢…1 1115 § 0113‘(_{11§‘§3?|1»{£
1 ‘§`O 1391,111`11, :1‘~1€11"1¢:~.~».§ §\1:3-‘1§§1. e\z?~'zr§~ §1-;' crs/1151 1191 113311§» §§\Jom; §\ P§€;»a
13113‘313 Fr~@cz:‘;é 31~1§.+1!5 313:\1@,~ 31 1~;1111$. 1 f , _ 1

- § ‘ '. `_` , . . " ,, l » § § ` . n '\'. v t 1 ,
Bo+vo 431/mfa w\€ viewed 1.01\111‘>\.‘3`~12¢1 §§sue:$ 11311”1’1§€.1:11»\+ €e¢?mesl.s a
1` 1"1.£1`?_-. m§e. 1311-1311 a\n.-§u-.».a §§111\ 1211 1113 §ac¥!» 18.\1;'1'¢§::.311,€. Cw~z.§ §§§u` 1§¢»93`} 1013.1

. §Q»N.§Cnb§e ~§'c> ~§»!/19, P€e.~‘.§'.>.-n-§-wse .

M.Corti§n€§ §o Cwns'a§§ c».'§§§éc»v¥+ 1‘11>, U.SP.A 110131~§~' &r¢m§e¢& funds
+1>.522,1< 111¢12&1\<1¢11~§1‘119.¢1»§31 11231+'1\ u?er~§ md 1111 11111£1 o ~Swen §le!'¢ae
who 111'>01\ §\"1§5 "'»1 11101.11` e,§lc\.§ua§\d\ cz-§ AF?§§<.c\v\-i~ 1131/1314 1111 was §eh'sn`m§
m@§¢.,\ §\\nesé t_.wns@.,\ §§51)¢¢1 35 €1§1`§1¥1 A ~Lhe, 511 o-§ ~wa. usa Q'F
®1111'1:111¢1,3/11 w\d\.s.bw§ 111§119 1_:§ 1131 §\-1 .)1,1‘.1-.11~1’1 § 11 €¢Per§s 2;\1¢111¢§101\
§cr 1141 Cc»-.,xz"§;.1 1”13,\1`1'21.~.)'? P‘.\\ 1313 §'wo.ve.-rer 3111:1111\.(12.'1$ 1123~‘311\5 Cm dushr‘~(
s§a&me»\§ §§31,1- "Dr §11»,\€£ 5313 .£113‘1 1131 1113 C§W¢:¢c§ 11031> ‘~§/Jeilor.s
§¢~r '~1 §1.::1.~ 15 \\1_111.-§ 1110 2113'11,1¢1§1‘1.;131=1?\@"~1;1§

§§.?P§§(,c\1r~f§. 13331'\§£. -~§c> 1~§9~§-1: \§1/16':§ b€:w<; C~:)u!\$a.§ §'1§'{1=.¢§ §§L\!c$e 1§'\9. d§c§ 1‘-\'5§'

3.

 

irw}:\e 4421\60/\44"€ 5224§ opc-4 PR€.~QV.¥H‘.D£? (Qcords 94 APPUc,cm 4'$ mem4a4 il 41\£§{
!~.\0'4'€\49_¢\ D.f 44€\€§% C.€Y\‘SM?I`QA 44/\£>€9 pre ~€\L‘\ 544¢\¢:_ fe Cr>rA€ 430ng ha G'o.\/@
4\.4§ pfo‘§e<€;m¢a.\_ gammon 44~¢.4 APP\»`¢_ML\.L\::.$ 4"\’{¢\¢'; 04000,4 mev\4¢0.4 1‘|4/\@$§.

Qm.w\.$e_l did 004 432.\4¢.\!2 44'\<:\_~.4 4\\°4’\4 c_...o.¢\‘4 \ncA 40004.:04 9m4>4ew\5 . Dmg
42 cm4a¢4_e¢4 00 Dr.`¥k`\¢~».ve/\ czc~c\cw\ who mu?€o_ci C.o¢)/\SFJ \4/4¢~¢.4 &FP\‘.(,QM
&Wor0A44‘{ 41\0¢4 been 4rm.40¢4 114 441\2`\¢* 4360¢`;444‘\) 40¢` fsd»\‘\o.¢. Prev\‘m disordgr,
Qarmokc\ ama anger~ Ca.\P\eA 20444\ 4\46 oncier$wl¢v\c§lns 04` 4e¢aai 4v\5'c.v\{4~),
Cov\c\,uder,\ 440.4~\~\/\212 wm no timms 401`&1\ 40500\\4‘~¢' c\e§ev\§a, 004 44/~¢2
04`¢>(40\¢,0, md -Cor_use_& oh Ptese¢\44na Dv<¢ Tkir¢,\vem§c\dom 430~1` m¥446c.+4m
<».~\:Am¢ 444 ?Q,\z.‘.»\mew¢. ama see t AH. AFr-. ¢. 33»

7 ;r+ 45 dear b'\’ counsels own a£CeA¢vH 44\¢4 m did m+ mem¢+¢\~?
‘ir\\405445¢~4e. 442 441¢.45 04 4449_ Co§v. Per 404¢\`[¢\?; 40 &PP44L0045 m\/\’ra\
4640€. nor d{d Cw¢\se,\ 4\0.\10. ch 4 rm aommrm¢\ 04 490 4000 40 ode&uc404'4
646-‘.\'\&)’62 4\45 c4‘.¢4`\es 40 4\4£ died C.c>uhsc>\ 4\0¢41\`~4 043444¢\0¢4 4499\4¢_0¢\4§
fY\Q:\?n:»\ awards 004 \4¢\4¢\¢;; his m€n4c..‘\ \44¢\2,5$€.$ cind- disorcb.)\s be4ore_ 4\e__
L-l£ec'\ C-»ovemmag\4 44)/\¢45 40 40454‘\"€.\1¢.4\..\0.4¢44 9444’44£,0¢\‘4 C\nc4 Q\r\\“\’ fe4uc4dv\44\4
discouere.¢\ 44\€ 40.044/\ 04 4/\45 c440¢\4'5 men4¢0\ 4\4nes£.

'44'\2 habeas (`e,¢_.ordecl 204¢420(€.. c\$§trmhve\‘-? derv\m£v4'm.4e.s md 44 ver*c’
dear ~44¢04 A?P'\kcav\+ Su¥4ue¢4 "Prm\ da?re.ssim~onser~ b‘.PniarwAmg§4 94`
0\\ %hc.4'z,o44re.n4¢.~ P¢\mr\o:¢. 5044\ 24 44\2 440\¢ 04 ~4/4\€ 0440/\5€ and 044/42
~kme. 04`6>4%¢\¢_; his P4ea. 520 (me.~\cmnduw\ im 40’49 l'€.\a` \ 4444 AFF. 4’ 3 and
AP?.memor.?ao` 3 .

4-40£'\ maj §§w%er 44\40544<5¢04@¢4 \"'-no_ mm\é\. 04 44th 44\¢4' duv`ro AF?‘\I r..md's
C4Nov\4€. O~t\A §§can\f`\mv\\» men4u.4 gtohiems 4’1`\M.erec\ 4§4m in 4\4$ doi\V'444a» and
d¢\:\\’ fun¢Lzm:ns. £\PP‘\;¢M+ was 4000 ewm\e,\~€ walkamw¢\\ cm&‘\¢\ w\\~€

51

 

~3:`2£:¢5 533~¢:;3' 033\.‘?.¢‘5 a~%.”‘ e »,U.~.; 38 sms 3¢.38\ C\.e`vd 3'\¢?.@`>.{3¢...»`»1‘3’3\ ' Pe)s:»" Z`A§S§f;~l\"»“
xb\ic) h.i‘£ EW;)$r'i£Y\o,3 W§:V.\jcr»'\:'$ Y§p\z` L&v\3§ 33'\0»¢33 35 Cd`r».¢?. écw\m.&,"32t13 31'\'1) &
,.3¢2.\.5.~2€"1,‘353 3553 53£\'§:¢%§5 Ci' 3»\ \zL iv\&‘, 683 3333`\.€;$.’) {.53--§ La?"e”ania\ find .3‘ 3£~.'*3'3~\`5
disdfc\:).\ ~3£:~§:3-3‘.&..4 3»~,~3;§ end 833 ida 313?3"33:.6“3`.$ ~3£38».161@~3» Prc ws$ ~Cuf'~¥hq_
:’“.\.(1`3:>:¥3%" c;-'*;--L~\{.s 333-8 amd 3\3;5 Pz's:..\x.‘¢')ee:.-* x‘._.e“§m§e al aids ¢..uoi`e. 032¢.¢!‘1
f.'.‘)r`v\.w.§.'%‘§“`t!é !».43.~._‘\33; 't»r\-.e§€i` ‘-3»3'\‘2. 3'3/\8'.»\€5,3~3 1133 5'3¢>“~3»3¢~.&; 8£3:1;`3-$ 83 €€3\{'!_0-'
`e'*= »\\c\.`! were .~'mr=: d 13 (.3¢_.'._»,§.-391'\5 339{’33"_.'.,\».‘3!\'“\1:\¢;\2. e.,-».b\‘¢\e 935 3d s. marks
S\»\c.»¢,\\é. inr.\md i>e\l?e¢.ue¢_l des ~33»@_§ de.d.s\ov\s 83 an i(resPs/\$§b`\a»mreas';)/\~
d\§e_ mg ;-“DE;¢¢J m, tied¢ mej~.»\¢;». §`;.d.;‘v§ 341 \d*_~,, , c a>-%d

'1?.85"x db\t~?_ TE\.» tss-35 3¥~,\\\.'0 _ Cm»'\,mc»¢\ ~1)3\\¥_ \*35.\..\@.:£ 831 53@35~ >33!€¢\¢:»,.
353/nic due 30_ 338 declare 83 338 disorder one can 650 3380\16\¢\ maid and
601~¢\3)@3€»\'3' \n3€!va\§\ us SPF’&:">¢A ~34> 8,3>§':5<>¢3,¢$ 93¢'\;»3-~,3>-%\5; am dodd-ods
£30.-€.?. hC» Lu.é.= .'\ \'\€. (‘.£» .*.:\03 308 magee-395 `31:.\ €.\lerd£g_ '~‘.‘;'uA¢:~.sv‘w»,-§»d‘ hasn_m!nr
`Yh¢;‘-f`c~ \<..'>. Cz:\.!\./\u.r_\..e ~b'm.*r ~3~3~..9 exis-\w\/..¢.>,. ¢_\¥Q men r\ f§e>\:erc P§‘< cMA".‘r..
6323¢<+ <_ hair dimer o??c`r¢».§.\_-\»~\,~r~ 3<)aner\ mm ~LL\€, e§'§§o¢'.`uz.$ d-\
f\\w\\»\s‘~\v'#d C.c».por`3H) 1’\8-‘3 \ he£?‘\jd.l` 331 l~. 3.\-1¢`:,>\)5 3')"1 5083». . `."L-‘:LE". i'j`.~\i\lf,?.{`v‘_.

&'53@..\\@ :Sz»i¢.-.» P.ad ze.zs\zo.s'<‘» C.`s*'c,:r \Q.’)a\f me need ¢\.~+m m+ew:¢~

\“c>~v:mz~: ¢S>\' gr£)%;¥!"§ \'3’€1> 3'.`»8. 3€.¢.1".`»,3\=`?'3'1/\ n-\e"md' _,88.(1.\5£> e»G. LD_\<;D._S 1935 _ `

iad 858 iam {. S‘*ckr \=’»8,®.

basedw ~‘e\»\e iam awards Cds.~s@& needed Mf’% mss - mdd.§,i'!,~.i;s-§orv
(€.€.C§AS 358-3612‘¢. ».`ent§ (”:>s~x&';'¢\a\.'\aw$' 381~¢3».$ »3~9".`>¢‘ f 5\’_.€’.!‘38`\#\ 3~\3$ 833¢.‘§\.'35 '-’"v'\f*¢’\‘"m \_
128?&¢!3'5<:»~¢¥3 3::5\:\`£* 318 £3@.£`,$¢:39¢3 33~§, '3 ‘E,\¢\:cc<':~ Pr:¢\.a ram\3n_\¢i¢$ude
mailed r\r;>"‘*' ‘_’:M»°PDH am fnSoMW zia-QzMQ. a'¥\\wz, ~33 me 835 £>$3€4\58. QounSeJ,
had d ward dd+‘~r' and p\n\'\gd¥\w 38 ew\orz. 0.\\ \feod‘.\*? c\\!c.‘.\ab\e.
530;_1; gaps m _,"uld€'nca, 331\0.5-3' h~§ 1\.+ hem-333 '3-§ §§ £33:31.»\~‘3~."_'££` C£>..\¢\.S~z,\ {§\.\io'j»i£",-
Cc.-c-Aez\ 613@-"&»¢3¢\"€ amd -a~§e*§'§' &.»0~3'¢£» ¢\2.13 3\333:`33£03»\€~.'£ tween-313 585ch 3\€
@.Du.3c3 3'\6.3{2. _£3"0\‘\8. cm 3¥~..'23?}3 3\’\"¢8£ °aC=L»‘\"~.Cn n‘\'3~04 '\€, '3\’ b‘,')‘l&>)¢&:i \'Nn`3d

q,

l * ` f`
B..N‘.J EC; §\$1:\;¢\'?' !.'53'?£.% Cx'\ §U\{‘¢. 10 »;~ a‘i) ..;'I‘¢`...> 1¢'.5~ §\5 JJ\.-\L.Jl..~.i £li"» v\J.J\-» "\ ‘z{€

.`§.':"‘.‘ '£)§\¢3';.11`£34 é>~§ ' \?.¢'.'.‘.'.£.'» "‘\"_"6:*.\‘\&_2\‘423,‘.>.

1444 44 _ _ , s , l `_ 4 \ _
\'%'\')"-.i;?.~._‘..>`»";s")cd ?3~;¢41‘)'65;=£\3€.1¢3§\4.§ 1‘1‘\&.15‘\‘ 94 m ` -.*'é.'. \i\'\*a)fe=.. \;§;>Q. 396 fm R:f"€-;!M+

,~ 1 . ` - 1 `l ._ _ , . 4_ l _ _ n
!\.',;».~},-1.§'3 §§ 916 <3__ ‘: :_ 62 €’-:4\1.-§3.;...-.3 1331~.11~3€3,

f 7 ` 1 ‘ - .`3 - », ~ .,~» 3‘»' ’¢r`. ¢ ls¢
‘9.:>:'»40.\1".4=.1§<:6\6. 9313;1~1¢;1~4-\§¢ ~'cz:..¢.. cc___<. 511 »:4~.»>66.“-»2€\ 6*¢~41°-1»4»-144.»\ 34\…! §§1>1\

Ca_`
n £. z
;‘i‘ \...L‘\' lms 191\4\. ‘.'.`1\.!"\¢?"1'!"'"»"""75`\(.`;.§ 531 ‘3’.\1.:_~_,~

Cf`v§¢ ll ngu‘u..d;vm:: .....x\\a.m..\ C-Ja'
P\L'.‘£6\: ¢6§¢§.'41“ .m;L 4)..4-§.¢_~ 64 ¥`: H`cic‘\aé,‘:`,~e_c 06 'F_ 16 \,\q;.,.;~;; :;§&4§4, 344 i~q; 44\3¢
' _»:11»¢5¢64 ..\f»`f` 6 and -9?.."1€. -:"§£».1~"6~?‘2‘§ \'-4"`.‘§`"\ :f; .‘E. defam§cu»\:\v$ m 1996\“|)&1~2§

gcr:¢'\'i$ €’.-¥<;.'.}" Ka._fK ¥\¢zf;i§)¢)ii; fz,+r:\!w`¥/l~e 61:?1:_‘. €)1` 7§9§'6.\ §"“f` ¢'wgm~f\a~{'~ .~`€i\ in
~:"~'cwc,:. ix 1a ,44..46§ 4"‘;1443, §,€~4»;’6; 616,~»-.4~5>.<6-1~:636~. '2~';1,._14'..1.6?¢196 ~°+n..r%

"J"»n.’v~.l.~a f“.“";’\z¢,\‘P\ ir\!: ;“r-'\9 § cl i"¢.‘ ‘°‘1"; ii f*z'*i‘l}_ (_..1‘!~2. 9::' :va?»§c~t
.~\z',‘\%~ P\‘S.c».‘rls mman r~-U/~.Q mos+\mPer‘mcv\+$wrces ns 3~ ~Pc»~+~?

§ ¥`
m ':1~3\'653§61'~, 316 1011"_‘)1`4¢ 055615¢116§.,~.654`§.

i!”'\.='£ FO§QA§\G.\ ifr\`\¢r' CC¢:\.-(J>. v'\'z')£u‘\ \1‘.56 .1'\‘11""~1639 §‘Gr»§&z.\ §§ P§‘I’-L 9\°;¢.1¢‘$€. ¢~.`94';;<:£¥\5
‘§\4124~»:’\' P£"» 9»¢;'60~:*.2. \-`\z€. u¥:§e/\ 30_ has bean f\zu>.'.s~m”u'_é w eMw;~ cwa 1902 assfem§
E .E. us.mw¢~\.‘\3“1¢`1-13:%0 L$`"‘Lh" t 1566 r_.>r mcwier
\I`\:e_ “»<"'l~m 1132 ~!~e.£ 4111\ ;,x~c`", max CD».MA hamm 665 "1\0.\13"'3661`\ 1096 c»,¢c»;.v§

in brmcc¥ion ‘¥d 956¢¥~?¢14¢.`¢. emm€n?nt§\ §W, H\PP\€LM\+ 1'1\ Ce>nnea~lim
iu.\N\/\%\Q, QECM¢?_ va\A H/\Q,-*~F,m?s,u\¥ c`l€!`ec,-+ adefe/\dm\+s a..Home\’
-‘.~6;> §`*"¢.11...41_4\ mr cx*?er§£~ crm-lim 34 ».‘ '~H\ I...‘\§en§s. \r~.§$'§r~,e"-? :4~.46§'\§.~‘~» »'\1\.1£6*5154+ ban

. i"`
51‘.-_\_\.1)\-‘-,; 141_,;~_,4» ,:1,{_-\`.\!9{"?21/. 441a c.\%" ..117.116173 94 line 9'7 69».4 r:?'/~¢:n».~;). AM\ 1199
`;Y\"`° v\"` \.4”7\\ 1701an ?\(16\$31/\1_' (-; 4;€;;(`

471-¢r?1‘.~'." L'w\ 4 54\.#~1417~,~‘4' 1 U)!/~!lf;/; !'1 ‘-'\(-;_ 549 449 €.-. ibm/f
072/701 \.619 ’..r.1.;»»261.\€, 055%¢\1:4

ch `47¢4 4-.»= P.-. S._)€ ”Y\.-.a -5'"~15:19 419 ¢.. 4 4L1r:..4'

C.wMM mc.¢\e_f c:me. 944}:."747 t\e‘ 751 n04 de$eo,¥ cwa 107949744¢ V@ 0..<‘ ‘;¢’~54
C`Si"‘.(.€’ mr 5.(>£»1’\’39_4 C\£") \_|".Y\¢

9744*4:\€3.\£41 C.c>.;¢\‘)o.4 .»:41:4 ('7,54111€.54~4\4’?44009\‘4 4a 47)9_ amici \1.'».¢:4~¢..»:4 4401` L©.\rv\~--

417..4€4\1'.‘-1' 419 341;1\.¢‘1 14¢1¢1_4 1419 '41:1.‘14¢¢;4 423 f 72._1231.11»§4-' 409 @1-11171»11771¢3343-9¢\ 00
31.7411944717.¢" 914‘43\4¢-51\47 L).A£\$ 41 Sw\£, 1004 --4’1'\7_4 4-§!1'\17_ 734 441-71 fM§ .94:4`9»~15@»"-4\°_
CDN 4"€»’4€0\ €,,"\9 €`Ldm:na~hm 42\':‘\> 0%"1 4:¥'1¢.., "‘ f).¢`€, N`)"k§' 151443$'4~1’41,;'48. 1 SCL¢AH"~¢’
r;-..*§'\§»»‘;’ 19 4§177217 94`~4119 1:~ 449*1<9 0.'9:‘ 171 mmP».-_’ 471\.¢_.-. 4<:‘$7§~1:9\¢4 -4»~1'.':...{ o.. 41.»1.>
71714!1794.\-3_¢4!4`474‘1-.1+ @19@14:1:¥\§1 wm\<<>.r\/.m?@me.\.i 581 7’..$1.1{91°. \'~121§3.‘
431$¢‘~\!1|.1)1171\\"71‘ .Q.$§L§MQ§A._..._~. . LW\UE‘~¢;'»_, m 14947;11»~241¢1¢1 isn 04`(€>~15941»¢»13.“)
'i;~ .':r011.4 417€£14\ w¥~»;‘.- 4~£)~.1.\$03$ 'SJJ\ cdu'm 747-14 054971;. 4¢)4` 4{/19_ 4\'<'-`[>41(07'14 S

4'1'.77 414 wee/1404 Ccv\r§\; ‘0.7`§ fm 47\@1.‘17\11'"7-.4~ 49.'.>£§2?4)41,>. \c~ c.\< 04 (:171¢»1¥¢\¢\.

~C(S?c>h>f\z\34'1'\¢`144117 4301¢3 9+‘44»?. ®Qr€vn£€;w\'\/z:{\,'e$ ..7~. C..:\ 7>1'\»14?.47!` E.-\./::\.~~
1,1.§::14313¢\ 9>\:1'&\.5 4704-214 73'¢2!51»'\¢.1\!~1‘~!.6.¢~44217-§1:~4'~2\9 1\{.)£~4:\715@. 14 Fe»_<.-zu‘!e§
44/=¢7..:41\\4-&, z?§§%£§° ¢F;'s.¥hr4 nc~.;~q_a.. 1;1. 771,1‘.'~;!~24::11/~14¥1:1\. mt»*’§"-;-.»r~`v-;>/\.§~¥‘&} "47':> mb _‘:~Qr\’£‘,
44‘\€ d‘&~:\"~'€»*-.111415\A4 C\..*m:`\ 4\4`,§; 'N\Er\'\'c`\ PJ`D.€.€ S‘._"> .`Til _1»`7., 1 ’~'~_Q,ca.. 614er §..12>\!.9..\4¢1).3
5*1\5 :=. supp 534 bm- 1909.>.

1 . 4 ` .1 g ,
41`1;='~6¢34 17"\_1:».»_'9\. 6-»1\.. 3;7..'4’9:;7474-1,».1114‘\" ~1*-:: \._..\_';;_ 444.° ~;3‘11§£4311_;»> 94 4/ ~'1."-" \..' ,\;'p,\

12`2"23':4 42 r` 2572-3 §'~-.7‘7'~7\ {_`.-\?2. 4'7,1"9,9 13.1’4"\0_
i;L'.')!..‘/\:" ;‘.,4 4 ».~\.‘M’“l'\-.J "4`~2(` @‘4 ‘.-.H-* `:*»‘4'2 7\?!‘?\;£,£»?\`4' ;Y‘\`;i`f¥‘».’x “J`“\.\¥“‘/\ V;C\ `H/\E.

L"UC!` *;`*{5 { -4£`€9' ba'l¢‘.'>€~é {,>l\ .»’:.'1 95 "\K'\!\(‘ 454’) api ;¢E`__J{~r_)_

-'-§"§1

`2,!“'1374,11‘~7‘1\.°._77 35`7`\)‘1'1"4\1..¢:~\77 4".\\9.'"'1"

1.1._.£ /~.;,{ `,~n 43ch .¢» V.." 1§12;4
CE‘~4C6,4 l".??"#!'€\§s'\’*'“f` 44!'»1'1.'4"'.4')\»‘99\. £f\-.~.4 ' \\L\S !"~'\.7’/7--4¢1 §4‘~?' 1' 44!'\1‘11¥-¢4 417 1'_1."1,1..',=7_2\'4.f'r7'1 ~44/4::\¢\

 

:`2 253 6223.‘£;> "5;':\_2‘1;2‘..1,)3"3.. 1355 \22`\‘.`:`... 52`?(.3`..1'(.".1\ 531.€‘€;23"3<'§’, ."3"¢;»1,).=¢\~'.2?1\€ 133 fci.'M<: -'1»1"01\
~2~'1¢2'1:1,~2--'51\.€,£3`\£2. \;.3_`;,.¢"‘1:;~1;:1¢;_2 2213-122 13"':-3;;:§-`523.. 2235"\1'£031121.1..)»3£102002 1~;13.,~1 532 2 14
2*11¢ i‘-;‘\%;\iv.l‘ ""‘ 213-1151 93 .~?.\¢' 012 '1111/\‘.-‘..0:1 "`1~~-:'.'0* 2'~"~'2'1*11:; §`1;..,:7.~"1..:1,*:". 3':332-"210§131_2.3'2~\-€1€) =:"3*123;2{1’_010\'25
52`2'21,\`.1;3'1’,31\1£1300\03 €.-L201'52T12'2"fs 23 ";1!`\1‘;1.3 5".|;:»1'\.2"150\~“-1 12'\0*1.1.‘2' 1122€;,‘13..`) i'..Z.T>L.`>¢"~ §€'._2 VV`J.»F?
2011'31\0€_. 25221"1'~..2;`\.~‘1¢~ w 2213-n 0\\:~;1;1321 2.~11212.'1 `.1,.1\'>13‘\5~1 " 001 1330.1`1;.'21:> Ke£c?
‘221'3.15003 -" 1,‘)01“.> 2100 00 ~2’\\$2 5.`13~:' 21 13~\€~0» 223;:~.1 521 2:51'13>‘~'5 230"25»\ 53. ?.‘ ....2.
10.'1‘132'10.01“ 212 -2~0€»2~`12.*~0 912 2310-1051 39211032~..1»121111~1/221`15 1\0101=1223 22»\§2203 1 1 -12~~1=3‘11
232‘123 01,,22'121\211_,1 2a <3‘-011;11.1:2 2: ;`12 2"( \¥\1‘§; ~0'\11.‘ _.__2\/\§3/1,1:-,, 3212`;;1~1 ;\,\!\1»1~¢~1~01_1¢

1515 (.`.1.5.53.1/§ 562 0

1'-‘ ` . 3 ~ . '
L<.':=..<."J:..2 .‘) 11115'¥\07 "152.'\9. 2312 151 1'2<\0'\~2 .;11;/* -‘50\0221'1~‘0\‘1 15 1 '1..\6. £\c.,\ fm 21“3_$10£\

111-122 23201`1\1£10 132 05`1;$12~12'$ 20 521 1555>91:15- 2-:.) \{2;2.. 2520.20,. 215-15 02 915250012'115}`10:\ 1 Se_c L'.

C..¢

A~H 210 § 22 “*`_" 3 1>\.3»1_\ 0 1':1"13050 "~ ~2~0.» 3'12>§\~;1.'2000.54 ...:12~~2211-.‘143,‘2~2»\5‘$ 25 2’2._2*2'
001:~€31.00.1~1~1<212')5@ 2.2>1:'00§21'"..1"0;-12_ 0130'~531;>53 5110‘111»1;¢\112 23"?311°§"0_2 .,'\-; "'\ F 010_`;`;._12€
"11.~153"-0 !€->C\, Z`>'€».'! 1305 1153 52 2000-33 32122.; 322~.»32‘ 0 v\ 2111/12 02113+ man 11311¢

5121‘?6.212 ('s` 5 ‘2‘»0 201 1131“=‘.0;“~ ....~5 11;’_035,>0‘.$1.~€5102"5€'31 55 ‘_6;:> ,€' 2c,»1m*' ~ \c~§~-

’22‘1‘3;. 012§@§2 2113 021-31/\‘16.‘2 ~~2…¢.21 2100;=1-“'“ `“1102/\€ 1'5~"3’.`1\‘* '1021'\¢,2. '1"1.»?.. '2'*0"11:.,2, (_£>0'~"“2 \.3:1!2
~-3`1*(10¢’-5"2~5»‘1/\“ 532?.0:.~1 1;‘205<‘ ' 32;0€£111.‘~‘.'.¥’ 1::`»@.0 :1.51./ >'2:-3.2231 +1013\'2'121,1"" L?;/\(:zt?.l\:ns
22 131‘1‘~.' 52.~‘13.1311§ €:3?,»'~31*32-'0.00001.2323"- 220 22’1912103 3122 mr \ 2~ 2`2<2¢3 \.3,)0.2@ CDE.¢G)#> 00
22!\2?.2~ 0.~1( Cii:»c»"`lh"~,'vi{"> ‘1'"`\`:.2’1`0£¢202"~*2'¢.\1:2`\500'\.

11 ,2 ,1, . ‘\ 001 _3 0 _ 1 1 .»~ , _ ~ 1

3.‘:\.1.';31 ' 2.510.. 5".;3. 1~51...1.1'..1'\`; 1.(`10€. 121-3 5 151.2\302 0 123 2-‘ 030, .. .156_ 1', ii~'i `.‘-',~‘2 :'11.1“11',;? 503 !5"!1'¢_'\.

.» l ', _ ¢f‘ _ \` . ,»_ -‘ . .,'

z mi "~0\“2` 35203-1'="'“.`_`.`3.’02 ‘.32'-.@-'.@'\31£.`,3-1§`J.L..’l.!z\\u;n{:"\?i>’h
.. -1 2 1 r~

!‘{£DL vii § il)a¢§) L§\~‘o : §SLI v.)`V-.s`,\ §§ L ici 'BLz~di ..,.¢'\:’ \ F`btv"¢ 01(5"":'\¥~)2.9':£1::(»&`2€”4;“‘5

&é=.e<.s:€`\ 110-112 \ZJU\ §32"1€3 1..2;3~“ 221`10.` \E 1211\.. ` .-.."15153.’>,.1.'“~ 12~..»5'.3‘~221'5: 0 `.0-:_‘~12_1~. 2~.;~ 0_1:5-`?0<,°2 t"‘.:z-:!...£

¢1

~ 1 _r ‘ .
Y>"‘T C""z 62 52 2031:*0’11~“" 53.. 3 `22\"` 1 "2.\53(;1"1_'.):_’_»'+1'.2~.0.(0 2~¢@§(@{193 g C£-`,~..;_M§Q,§ 1' 551 fin

L)d .‘.':;¢;\c)‘\ g (:2:>.{3’1#»~1§‘11»"¢"},
Q`Dw':`£\ /3

g 3
, 1
0
d.
\~_"1
91
...b~
ga
{,b
LJ\

5 1{':`.» *-1 r` 31 \ "' .
llv\ww (.AL;:J€£¢',‘:“‘.W\.§. `.~.1'¢<1 €1£5

551

J

7:~'L‘:. §3[ :. '.i§é" §;f’§¢ 2.9’§.‘:§\'2. "`-", “".2;£""5§.~ §£§»..r'n;'~ §”.",¢.;¢.,;--1-.‘.~`.;1‘;‘5§3"¢,~§0 »"\,§4.1_9,;/\¢,'_§ §§Jb¢;;-.{ 9*’§,~

w'»'.`\ri'§~ -.{A" »,'¢ ., fl;_',"~ '-3 l` ,_¢»33{ ,
:'.-..:.»,‘.9~,;.-9\~?.~§{"3':_ 9~.~~.‘.~.~;.-_. ~§.)’§:. '\.'»9:.--.->.:':'9~:§::.¢‘\£.5;_ §..c>»~\ >¢c\ e»"\'v`§l~ €:.\\ `~3’\--.!&,' LN`§ §Jrv\j+czv\w§

‘ \ 3 ¢~ `~ k .- »,~. -~ P
°_s\'¢§\c.§<§§C~-A:'\. \.F>\-§ C§"§' 312 SS»T§\.- h?\ 59321`€"§\'$§~7 §~‘§" §..,;‘ ..;1'.»¢:&1,:'¢:!\6§ Lav\"§ L,.i£¢a/v§. 0'3"

. » § . {. .3 . §
\ ." §" '\ ~. , " 3 . . f l _ ._ ', 1 ._ ." -` ~ " ' .._ ,_‘.1 ‘ ~‘. _~" 9 ', ...+
\¥\'\’ w~'-\-=.c.. §.§.?9§: f.\ '»f;~a .¥*!_.~..~'»-.i'..:.. f>-'. L.¢'.'~f.~"=.f;,e..=, s“~§~._.'\';: 3 #..‘.‘$;. L-».”‘ .:\,- -,€' ~¢'t'\ -Wl`{ 'f. `~.§1`~. z+.\’\ .~ '.'=.`»~'-"¢‘.‘;3.\.,§.‘,'

§ c ~ . 9 114
-- , ,.~-1*`* 3 . \ ‘“' -, ` :\. _" ,‘ 9 ~. v 1..` . , ` . _.» . _-\
§'=_ `;."3'€:.§ ,”' .;_"'».Z'_ \,»v`§y"\ ‘.',;-. -;~,r'§ §§\3;,`.. xi`“.,‘,.%'d.z`"‘\'." .n.\% 'g\.i 1;.~ i..."" v `X m

. . '\ 3~ l § .‘9
‘-~§,_~ ;_ 1>~¢`.;'_"‘. 9;1{` .‘»~- i:".;»/.jq‘; "5' 1",‘.'.,

 

-~

~¢ -' 9- . ,,_ .. 9 , " *
"s.'{/».‘§';.. §;3¢"!3:.;..>_§.!,§§§;‘.{:. ?) L.é_v\."~.";‘.a'i"
...»§' £3£3 f;" "3§

_ ;. _ ¢.` _ _ _ gh,\ \. la m ._`, [\‘ , _ ‘§ . 9 *
92 w.;».. \»_.:¢3- .¢..§;\ <.'4 §:, muej.§.§l»w\.w --\V `f“- ""5\1 1 5‘ id

~4"`, ._`_ \,_ §, §.3"§ “ c \_
film ‘:“;§L:"§C$=;,\€`;_'z. ‘.':3€:'*.‘ ".'§‘,.`.'.' ~3#\. x§" E>"§"; .§‘~§(lz"x \‘ f`:.l`-, ~'Z-:¢§_ ': 1201

v...~

s§...., '\* 33 l_""|~.c \ . e, »'.M"‘ o .S_ §
3- § 333 .‘ ~-»{3-"»3"»’?"'~`?§'"'-'-'--`§ 1151 "3"- 33~3‘!13£'2M`*L'3-1 3~3 343 §'» 31 "'¥ €“‘€" .‘) ¢*z.. 3' 3 fe -9'.`-'\ “§' 3' `{‘. .`"`»‘? '3‘3. fm l ,o`A."§'-'

~’,`,_1;9',9'§.:5;§\ rm.\_43~ 331"§§1 m m§~ §§ -_c .‘3; ‘.""§'~ ?3:"1§9;2§!'§'.."£ z €'.9;§\.-,9 34€§§.'"§'~;-‘:3'3’ -;.z-§~ "§_n“§'
9 .`.§z;_~,§`§.§';r 3m 3~»'1< 3wz\ ¢.’\~"~;§ §:»::n.\ \!§.é a§!§-,<;.§-?§;;»~» '.'c, .»`32'»:~‘§"§§‘ 333€§‘~'1'~3'¢.§§ lfli.-{F§~,§;zs
§ §" 24 §§ :;~».. 5;~~§;§_.(.. ':"'”* 9#4"§.":-"\,» ~ ~-'~ -- ,,

13 -",§ :3§3.'{§:~\1::.“ .3"(~ ¢`.>i’;)§;` §§C» ~§`\r_,§r\ §§;~ 3"§ §=\.‘§,(’e_ gdf'§‘w?

§ §

§¢if\.t:wn ne‘v§ GL\-JL `.~.cJ)\.:., .1.`.>“§ L.di ~r*»§»' 44 z’/' W'§‘..¢‘.m."§-.:`Jiv\

 

’-;" §§»L‘~§ ‘\3~`4`..\ (a.‘z.§§\"'.§; '~‘§’.`C §Y'§';»"',)Q 3'¢€'§5§` §'..\9§3=-."»§"§"§

. _ , ly '_ a »l\‘ ’ _
E~.*§§`¢ ¢'J:-u,§c`§' C\:" §-»’.)`+3'\§. §§=:33§3§\ L"_::.;;'\'I‘$ §.~$‘:1?'!5§,4§ ;'"§\i..`\' 9 :’;`_'»I§ .»\ §3*.,2 l§\.':"~§& ‘-; ~,§L’.§\‘. 3.:¢"?€$

\.

3 ' \ .
5'3:§'5 §lc:¢)i\Sc-'.§§ c§r.);i~‘i' §0 m,v§§.é §.r.°€.c§:§?. '(€ L~`>`M`¢X§e.$$ c~ fw 5 €.!§Q§ \§E. !‘,\?.§5 W'¢z ... . §3.'.’~

¢\313)§`3§€3:>¢;§}‘9; 31\1§£)3“3"‘*§_ § A§L§‘ ‘.C.‘= -.\'\\,,\’3 _'T~§o‘§(!. §§4"§(‘§ -’:‘.'3;‘._` !\$f§§ §§.§..§.€f;§ §\:2.5.6\,

q
` _. 3 3 i \ ' ` ' \ - \» _ 1 -
‘,)¢9§>?.§3'€§.\¢. '3~ \r. § cl §r~.§.'\ \~.§\§P§?-N§">.'.`§* §' ..C§ :'€*,. ' ': §§'Zf` S,T;-!‘;;\~. §=“- ""c 4:3`§.§9"..§2§ 1"§§'» '3-.31~9~' .'§§-§~'992§§
r",` § ~ ' ` 3
. , , § . _',_\ , .\~
5i'§‘I.-) !. § !'f".=.‘ §`£.‘- `§§"\Q.. ‘§)f<) `:“‘~"£~. -§ f""\ \T' §§3` \’=9£; §§ "1`, !'§§'\_5_3- °§D J\'V'E {.':.i};} f`"§t _/,§_“1 '_`,~‘:'A ¢;‘. L\;`»i_§‘§,

-“’“'-‘ § .f. ,, b '¢ ‘ 3 3 ' \
-s.§~z§z§:s-@;§;.§:{§'§€'= §f»' <-6’§9¢\3,?¢:\\ +c§~ ~3.+'...'~*.~3. `_§.3:%.9`,§-§_§:§ E~. “~4~3 ».2 4a *:31>.§ f:§- mé <29

1~`

§3\{5;‘-\ §§uir,'\.&§§he£» §:Dl~ C.d"`s`c»~`md T\J»'>§\` w ¢»\ Ll! Ccm\r»~w\'§~»r..r? 9.'*\*53)`»
1§1¢{4§€'* »*. s‘»'ar,g',~\§ .’.. :§S 25 ¢..‘;‘ !-.-'9 'e.$\~§e:-§?v§z. 945€5,"!»'§€9\:‘9 ~';§.,~C C,.: ;§.-9593 -,\§!r'.§.-‘.. !`C.C.€;§“;,:§
(D‘>Q~§‘z:\ 1 <‘§¢Z)P..‘) nr.:”r C cv.§'»'§z~. (..3£1.4'§.‘§' '_.3‘§.'\ r:§*-£§ '§"‘!§ ‘§`”3`§)§*~3~3-`§§?.. §§"§." "».§-I'§=»‘“§§':” -3§"3‘3`§
<§33§§1:991~...-3 §941'9§ \FI§r..- .-§>G,w’ `§*. 33;".§.'~:»*3'€,:;.’92 f.¢-?.f'\“§C-\§§\~‘~l§ M"~ ‘;‘~"§33"§5'353"‘3`3£\3 533“°““3'\
§§ §aci£ `§§n¢»:§ C.m>v\f»e_\ §§&§§er_§ §/\ !'j°"`x‘\nf\ fw §'.‘,~)-"‘ "~! n“~'~' w"¥f.*“' '-\~’4? £h‘

»-4

`44’\& C’,.~!?¢`€»r~\zfrz. W`C.“r %“‘\K\ ’¢`~J\ -:_\. .r'§'f'?‘!?.‘

'\.e

f-

"’C§\, 4'.`:'»"'1~. ,".`,"‘:’ ',"~\ {_`."-;'Elf 4.:'\. "§ "1‘_‘":4.,"*;1`§\’;')1»;{`4} .‘§51¢§
e'§‘,[_ (’< .-’."`Y\[ L!‘. `1“{ ‘Z`N_Q€_( $"T»g§rpv ii ppi\` L,,; '\Y`§
11.\.044§¢1 @5`¢1,.,4@/\4 -\m 444‘-.`:4.'1_,%4\;¢4+».'5¥¢.-.,33\9( -' 441a-l fp-">_"h\<»~»q f T"‘ (-4»"19’?4 '°$OQW

§-

‘r~:'.~\c"\ Cr:»¢)r.‘)'@.“\ f&§§» ..¢4 mla-4 Pé`¢:€m# 485 ’:'a.‘\.~

~-:mli‘r i`:‘.,é»<;€'=' h 4 §*‘~-r.il

"‘¢/¢/leze

 

C,EATJ;‘K».».-:.'x*ff 44:;‘4% €F_fz>m: 4:;.¢€w
1; R»;»\)¢z,~i. Pn`.¢mz`\ s+we\ , wri.;i;q `;W,

~ \~ ' 4 ..
4 -4_--':»4,4<‘.. (-4>.'4"1’ 54~€%4~:; mf<$~,.:§n»:s’
?r‘\’ ""’4¢‘ =:;‘_:,‘_ ` €,U»m 40"‘" 443~)4 .4 `s`\vn .44 "`-*’4:.-~4’9=.1<’. ‘£‘l.\ ..93 Cs:‘ 154'=‘-‘4»`-’.'§' (.C\#,!§"’¢" §.':f‘€‘
~»!. § __ - . . . /
_3[;4;,1\_¢\)_¢,5:,\ »{`_G;.Y\\‘\"{ `4 `_‘. \4\'-'£‘ {,)4¢}4!`4/'4‘\ ‘(~[g :-Mc;' {,) `_M",,,,. L_|;.`_FS' L§é',:, rha
`r""!` -v,~ . va |, §~B "'" ob&€f` '
4 =' m 124 .»._?: am 4\»4. .,,,. A.~__

3 "C »:‘3'4” »u..,. .3¢:§. 4

`.

"'?'¢‘ i=i'§¥\e ¢*QZM ~L:M

'\2.4:»4>2»'44~\'¥\‘\(,\/¢.2\ 541>{‘-¢’ \¢-l 39§‘?“7"1
QLSM Fm 905 ’*'.
'T¢z'.'\.rie€‘.~.&; (',..4;§£4:4.»\~." `T#» "'?'_Z?*$¢Z~."§`-“'§

041