Court Opinion

ID: 4063825
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 21:03:07.301+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:49.118879
License: Public Domain

FILED IN
                          14th COURT OF APPEALS
                              HOUSTON, TEXAS

                              APR 13 201!
                          CHRISTOPHER A. PRINE
   ifau t*M4'l4-MllM-&i          CLERK

    d£zju no gnt^

^mJL d /Ml typM+dr
   Oust G\ww»9)                   fa 9

                                                                  4
  CtotMhtr&aaihp lm &»&&&&&/&$) r                                 4
d M \/k6^du6tf^r^HVbllui^^x^^7^(i^ tew)                           &
r WrM & jmm&JJJi a? Ssasktot *&/ *r                               u
6* Gortv is $/M &&'S*#J fai &b            •T&cJitr'               4

ft f/fme// 6 S/a/wm* $WSlo&                                       (,
   HtototaJ & t&h fwbr Gb. msc^f7tW J9M                           \

   titicrte tf/fcM JtdstoW syy Cftt2x> )                     J, b

to DoonAt vf&nlkv Jfi/ao&?rf              fl&MfD*Jkr tfru)    b

  W^M^m^f ******                                                  q
  HmuJ±LlUi l/dliunu3 ftJlJ-A3 tout* ftis-jpj (toe .tos'-xfcn
  w**r&3b *>.£&$               tilmrt letter Qgt&rx &)jc/Mjq
   ^CbnuOL LuaUmo iD^4/Mm V

     /mad mii&> Mm 3 dU ft 3?
                                  «   1

                           Pago /"/
                            I/ml IU N-N-DDtLHi/

                                     /faawt&.Awtr 77-s?-?^

                                                       #77*27*

ft/yj/ffist /0&£a/ Afpr^/4ecfrsjPMJA*y^jA/j^^^^*/j^/te«f/fita**/.
tifato^/i^la^p/A^y./m^/^ Ik*#&/ 00*/** >£*r * ZGfay'/%#j&0

                                            rr~ „   At dr;7j£0A7J2?f-
                                                     ***'/P/^SfAaittuT*

   ^/2%%^/jfjy &^^s0&Zs/s?*z/&8i)
                     fimj^ Jj/L/fes
f*&

                                                                    A&U,n , /%$As KM;* sA»a>S j#^^S Ad. S. , /yyjfJf^A /JSfsW/^   . dh7/Psm.jJ
>4hl 0toc & aZ/J&U'
                                                                      Ayc^

                     f/&SeJfJrTiMs f/p&M7°J.5 /MeS7/-<2S

Ta/at/A                           Mi±s fe*^/zAu/J/7/MhJ^                           ft'
ad /kdiXeAtMJS' &0k^/^
 MtA, Mm 3 M>/^ /9w. /9<&& w**j /&/»*/f&hirjj?
 /MmJ &/fcf^7*\r, tf&ss ^                    fefa/j/ Aeo&l^
to at*st»t bf "Atk />t*l b the imdtJ- J My AfaUs €J>da*e,
iS IDcrt SifoMlTv £>r £U£f&0*o brfw 4&ak uhcb //&r of iM toed rut tWh
&fM77p/z?2A^ &A>wctm/A/aa&v *rt»6*AMf&htir
 jtt*'a6r a>a-
&/^A&f/7/&7A%zfrA?rf AZ7sA3 JsfAA&t//* /2u?/'j&Mrf /kattfat&t*?',
A?AWA?A>7&sVA6 J7sj&&&& JB>4y&/j&o* s/j^37/^^ 4&g& j£M$A
 Jff-JZ,*/ &7AJ3/%yS7As3% JkAtmJ^J^^AS!t/3l^-
 Ayf^AfrA?/Z~S7AA^A7s&s4^^/&&/^A&&A:M//„

 J6^/faA$6^Af&&&A/A&^7^                                    dZ%&6tter
 ^ &fe£j, a *&s^*6 A0ae6r aaa^^Aii^^a^^ ^ J^^A^a^
 AfAc/A%7<7'*fioh&& A0BA*4e/^j:^b-^^^^x^^^^^^^^>^^^-

 Sr J7*f/f6J8~/&£r A?' j&AJfa&to&JfrA&&^

 AW&&& /Jtgt&itstit ^AT^aAm^^T^^A^y^^^^
 &^/?s2&&Ma /^a^^y&^kAC7*S^A^^^A^/i^y^a^^A^x
  &Mtkte/M/7AA^077^Ate £AX/s/2& J&sA£^4?.JSi460r'

&!fcc6f*3&     a ^aJ&Ae£#AO%£A&A> A0W&?6># A&"04%^/!k4^?s^

 &Ztj£ TX&f/fifcfoafr* ///wd/^Jvy>%5f/' /$^4/^/A7^ AfAs£7&.

 /7SE"7zjrz, r, 77T"r~ ^^%4&*&^rdS^^bsi?^^

 Mmj&77fi/AfrJfAJdU^                                  "**"*"'~w
7k Jp/cr ef frrJ dm'j/(/#u) rcQ&TZtfjtfJJi /%vm£s /7)o/jAte/xiw jfot    T0

1/J/xL;&fc«f 77/fa-'jfa, fai&i/fajfti 7?MQh7tfj/Mat #^a7/h#7/fetk Jtie/^&fdw a/^A? d/277fo/z 7g Ab e^/JeJA/ t£>\J^'/yfaJ^A
/tfa/f/A/hw/k JcsAA /fa/A7ofJ/c7<:>rA 4 Jt&ptAA ^^^thtA&rJ* 7/a $**/ ,
Jtfm/j&i/A? -» i^//W^///^^# /S *3&/A$//wfr&cf
7fajf77?£ &?A?$/&//t7& ^m^M ///*/'%b JKTZ-vh* //7%t &&* S&hLS;
  &» &*bk&*7& fffiftib- Vfoo&MeUf 7%}77/&^£d/efr£c/f4to}M*//0t£*W^/
 //k. &Ja7 &,+/'/7?aai &m?A7/7 /ak7,7j?t 'dLtf&jt^'S^J,, fo/'M*
&WA-&tySAM*JWy// AvaW&**JJ/x. A^fw^fi/j?/W7th&£
 ^M>t&7jhh7^AA/fo
^ Abt #A#f/A/jm?A S. erAfr aJ%^0A7?74j^//J,^/%^77&/to^
7/7 a /ZatifaSA^ /A/%/AA?&fA%?*7L7£ ^^s>™AAf /^A/re^7/A?3j>rtks$ ?b?
~fif>6 /&/&. <$L jty&fr'*?/AV&f/^6 Abrt&ijAhtAa Afcrt^AA/iA^aA'dA7?//fe&
•TfedsSfoA70yAZtyk?j&^ /bt /vt^s. AbzT^T^/Ti^AT^A ^^/^^^?^7^/JhA/Y
/7? W/7l%As^^A^^                                                        /jA^

AKsfS/W 0/7 SAA^/&£/A&yA7A&AAs77&
            77l7c' A%t07/£sie/s^ A7A?A/A/A?/*A ^SfisA&cJ&f'£srvs<.
      ?#/£ /Psa^c?/? •sT&ea&Jy* efjdae, sSA%Av&A/^/A%$AA&7f&Ji^/
Shk/JtML Mtdj' j!tb 7fr/M7/0Az?AA^/®A&^/7r/74f^^
/*£& ty&eeO'/fcc.*j^^7J//7z/fcJ^<5A7je/??6 tfdhrtAMM*,
/7e77&m. /^C^cTTc^^d^^AA/f? /AJ&& £> &trbfijfaf^>.fiS7t0k
  „'''&7%bi/&f//Z&7& ^/stAPAAPt/A-A'S/frieA A&//faf/%//,, „,

 /^M^a ^^^/Ml^Zl^ImU^^fj^sA^ ^t Jn7/*7- &aU?a
 &//& JA^/A72#cAer?//£ A?A&sAaifr/AtA7 /fa/j77J*fi/??/+/fav >r j&7%h
 AAA/ A*S^ZS4u#& &A*A&AyA7^Afr?A£v V/AS^&£/&M^ AZA
  <7 /&r Aw/7~££s ~/MAkv A^fA^A^sMfatJ**
 #/6l^s&jksV72AAAb&\>yfo Afr7tfJ?m&^^^^/!35ei^^^s^Wyy^^4f
 d&»* &^7^A^^%7&*Ay*/7?^
 & ^}k^teffi^AP/^77^
 #A&fi7Sj7#///^#wtf/J^&/nzi/ /? .I0t^&;/fau&£>*4r
jtfy2&?& OBAA/&6 A/^/7A/zA&a7ArjifA/77A'/»7SA&t, Attn ,3?£W*A&A jfearaS
 *•• "'••                    4%£L ,/Jl AAzj.
  tf79Mbt/X£A7/f A&7• Ji£4jzs;A£ A0aa&&*/tA> A&& «5^j^^ ty#o^
  A7yAbtf/y^7£jtf/&&j/$AAk7'^MrATt^ATTA^ 37VJ^jy^^^/ik/
  J/P JAXViAfo 7*&)a /?/&%fa'J M$7y ^ / A ^ A ^ y ^ /5fe T^Y
 AAAb/M/f^A Y^'JTs/MsYY/t ^y^^*^^^^^^^^/^>5^/
 AZT^AtgAsA*'d^ArfM/y/sc&AASA%#A&l /7&Yt&A/J7ife/'&AXTistAAjtySiYY*?
 J&SMAfcAh/jfa*/ &7Jk <£/A/*r *&rt Y^zL/*u^ .^ ~~~                  ,^
 •f*> A&J7 YfafaYV&xYJZTj 77% AHMfar a^tohJfaitAi*, ^e^AdS
 >?/ 74?/A?AA£ Afr/7 *f/SAut*r< l£ &SSd*H*fc*j AtsA^yfefr 7//$,#,.
 Mm/^/teMm /&&***./*/ A/^^at&M/bi £YAkY* #A»7b*J/?
  7A70Wf&cr 7£<^&A^y4/Y YA /Ip&T^Tter^* /s&Yjfr ed**/*
 *74x <*/4&^/&M^/J&^.J9J&r<&> f?A?S7iy'/7l3%A7s&j#&t A%<77&/stez //?7f27.
 7& A&7/>/SAr T&jfoyJA)4t^4Arf yp/vAT^J^
 3sb»9t;6/JteA AtAatofYji JtYatodpTl* Y^ttiAA Atit006&/0/7&&A6tWW
 Jbyt(./tototer A%7y/zYYJYk4*^+Ate^Y9&^Z+VA9 AS '7&2?fM$
 ~&y<£&7 Jew #/ Af^jAT^^szv/t^jjfr?33 M iGfafWfhfci

  4/JAft.

J0TS&Wy4Ss/fMAAAA7J£AY

                                      ^&€fA^/ku7^7/&(2Si0£ >£-<*&&&> AAj^^Ay^A^/^e
tJUvWa/ZA A& A7±A£'j&*Afa'A7AhAJ>/ YA &&/'*Y#?/7 ^y%4&A
 /&**, />/**/chC£K A7%?A>Aa& a^-aaJa ffyj&b/&/&AjHr*A&

YYlijt/mAS >&Sr's7^S^M/A^AA/yjsf                             Jt7a'£> cYY
                            /%//$ ,;J// A*Af
MMffiuM' £M mMvu7$u&/wl & AudL&i //m*fJfeY'-j* A^JmJ&A

MA> Jm^ YMdod^ dmyyY\                       .. /7^jrjte&A$AO'JA(3
                                                          lY/**?
                          .    ^                            __„ 7&&.J*
                   MMr^Y\ /M^//m, ^jJkdc.MSii/yu't
                   ?J~Y^/ZT&^d&Lsat? j^YaI^&t^ JUYbmkY

 ^7^^YY^YyA7y&Ay^Y; i^J/A^Y^'"**? f/^JA Y%?/^Y^YP yk&r&lfe, JL jL&>/?72&A#
 Y720oY Je     -    ' -            ^    -    *        -     '   »'•"     -
 ~Yytf%8%A:.
                                                  iYyfc&a. 1*&,A!f&eY&£
MtAtodrtu Y*Yu *A*A0 A / d &" 4 \&Mcfc M?A^^qm*iJs4k Y^Ctot^J&M* ^^MY/MYliAA
YZto^tok? AY" 7dteY-A?Y% 7^/^uy >4wZ&*/^e, Y^TS^^jaSa^A^
*SyZkYA?yj>'OrfdgtfYY) y^AA^J7$L, ^2^5^ A/0&&6 /27^fyi^&J
 AsTt^tL^; Y^&YAfc. sP&A&z**/ A^^c <$A?A#A7Jb#£AA/YvaJS
                 . >reJ-7°A'JA,teA7*e7^S^/f7%>&SSZ^S&J-
 y%t^        A2&3JU#luY J0£^J&7&Y&ZjLf*. A&6&6^J%S!®i!A£^jA?L^07 x
 Ttedr 7a7, SYtLs. /MM&a$4%/#\a&. Mu de^A47 AY&*#JA&J^A%Y7A2ff JA/AcA, 77tfe/*&/&£
 7/AYm*3 YfAJanYAt AfYAtfTW&mYteYdm/^
 ?-? Y?t7c77/c 77Y/J^YY77 m^a/Y/^^tUta/fo/vY/^c^^
lYA/Mety /*^JS^AA,3fj?*AfoJY/%//ei7f?77fSWs^#W
 VMM*f 7*73/~3A

 T^O            taA/YJL
  && PA^tet, AA JYyYA-47777t A*?J7- SJ M^f^^^A^J^
     ^7fA)Sd, M£ M&Y'aZai^'^^^^i^t/ JL* Y^JdyQim,

 7Jf7m& YA&MMAA^Y&rtmthfiMh 4fiY0f4 AA&/77#77747<&m>>
                                  zli/jL/ixf
 (fypiJM/Mm Md£ £ /f7%aA/M7%^Y70M/^^ ,'
            ' (?YY) ^um Ymt£< ^/^y&tyM&aj A/dJJ)

                          >/VMm
                                               ^

 u           .       (knYMwMAiA
Jaw imiATtiity^     of (kau /^Mo/TtU /TtdMeYlM^ ^J
'""* ' ^     TlmkdeA^ Jhbtki&y,^^
       A A&Y tfmtdY&i; yfa& ' '        - -

yYyiAfc&d          ^       XT                   ^

                                  ,          Y%&2&04[^777f A&YA
 ^^^^^^^SV^^^/*
                                      Ma,J,J*3o(y/£6.
                                  JYe a/in/1J* L YY YY
                                      •Jtsb* JITunit
                                      3JZsi7^/f&kY

                     PMiJL JJL 4m.
                                                                  A,
                                  TBfer-AJYY) Adz0&$L*>A

                                          4A^S

^ 7Jm&ALY7UA>                                            OAUS

                                    YfMMtYb y AY7/ iti&tH/i/A
                                    *7£fYrsL AtL 4CvjA

                           >-'\
                      .)

                fajiJO. JJL (fas
                   £7       A§f                       *

jYfrZAUZsrfdYt ^t^^^at^ ^7?z/&Y&&k!>. y^2ey^tAA^j^AiXi^
M^^^^o yM J&
7% yMa^l. T^Ls Ja 7M/Y&M&^

                                  TfYAAAAYYrYLYTtYY

                   Y^/Y'^j£jk*
                                   7f'A&'-'?'c
                                                  JL

 4
M>YmL>
                   ZAA&A^*                       ^A%A7AA*?AAaW&
              f^AkeA&* <&s ^A26*??^<3aA*^a aa^ <&&&, A0Ls sTVAAi&AL^

 JA^^^y^^A^^^              ^ &3<^?AtAu^
  ^ y&j&Ai&w ^A^^Y&Y A7^a^s^^a4a^
 Y /2A2A?aY&skY^ JA%&e£*Y ^£aa$& ^Z%0>z^ AZA<3AZ2s^>^ <£<£4&*a '

                                                         -~~j*r^^JA7£. jA%A/
                                                         r60Ts.
 7&A>y^A?^yA*£^7y*<^7^YA2S%f

                                                    WzAm^^'ZYM
  ^y&^LeA^y^y^YAA.AU^ ^2aLa%                              1*7b/S3j)
4£sAa?jJ.   A^kY^Mjyi^yTAU^YAfy&zAcYj
                    'A&Z A£ApAA7*^&/L A& 2%o
£/Z6tA?0Ag'&
A#£7^A^A?A&%p'i
    j7JhMt4, ~
Af?d %%&Y^>

  •Jpfai h->^\YkAjb y2y^4jfe V ll^d^u^A^
  YimMLYiM^i^                             m md       '    Id

            (MKYtlMy 6MJJtal ^^/^^ ^m^A^^^
                                           ^kht/4rMUt „
                                           Hennthh i/t/Jt HfhuY
ft/I-

                                            C.UJU
                                        VLfifj

          £01 ?AU*uY,yAjkY»
            YjMdiAy7£i&L> <77dP6>»

           A,* yJm&-rg 6L/7'y'/-yv-0J&*-£*/
              7)S0A (jPrtY 67€mA                 yn
                      7%gAc v^vaA 7&- YfAjre AtAxA* Ah* /7£tifc> SAa^A ^j^Y
        AfoATpY/At-S (&4.s^     YfeA?eAY0»Yj Y£Aa&a/ y& ^A«Y YfeAu770s7j£ YlAA**9 A a&Y,* y%*j9rA>w sA^A&y?*/'
        #/ Y&c caA&«~ Y2?AfreAy?sA

             A?^Y7£Y7jY-~ZA**^
             AfAApyje-YA Y AAYA
            y^Aj'-d'70^YAA4A>