Court Opinion

ID: 4073174
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 03:29:42.998098+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:42.241021
License: Public Domain

PD-1440-15
RECEIVED
   OCT 2 9 2015
  CAROL ANNE HARLEY            /AJ THf T^XAs                  RECEIVED \N
  CLERK OF THE COURT                                        COURT OFCRIMINAL APPEALS
NINTH COURT OF APPEALS
                         dOU&T DP d/Z/AdlAJAL APP£-JU2>
                                                                 NOV 09 2015
   hK\L\\AEL WAV/LIE l4/4AJ0AtLK.*
                         re,4i±tcne,r*                       Abel Acosta, Cleft

   VS.                                           A/Z). _                     —

  77/f STflTJ? 0F T£-XJ4^j>

                P£T/T/d/J JZ>/z di$cz£T/daia&3 /Z£v/£z^r

                                              mrmL3z

                                            F£f/7/DAJ AS F/&OB£A/Ai£, /^kar

  P£T/7?D/J JZEOU&ST /)frffL A/Z&L/tff£AtT
InJet aP Au4llonb&s>                                 4

Slaknilnr Rtt^arAmL- DraJ Ar&urriejvf                 S

tlhthtfM / 0 f +ht Zks<L                                 -5"

aU-kniBffJ £>t Procedural HlsbrX                    E~Lo

&r/>utiJ& tor Pk\//eMf                                   k>

(\r6i/ni&f~t                                           7-/Z

         /     ft riunt Pr& -/una slt&luk has net/e^ Jjdirkd j>n
               MPP^llnnl 's n&ftJ- la Munz Pro lund. J#d&/r7£/j/.

               A.      Ink/ dear/- ermreA /h £r?ArMZr y^£ huncL
                       Fho -hinc order uSt*tftovt JfPlordiriJL fe/?tr/MUr
                      An /DP/brk/rr/lx Id Le^Pre^e^f^ £>r -jdio^
                      hearing rtPresan led bd dDuns&f1 Pr&jta^d
                      Frt> 5e,j in ard^r -fc> /bf&rJ hirvi due~ Pfuess
                      dp kid,

         i, Trial dDurr d\d /tor hatfe, Aulltoniz -io Froltlbif
               ftMhoner Promt rtPPejA-fiiiLrj jts, <a~ ^rtxsnd exran d*e~
                tOUrPs exi-hrS £>/'<* /li/r?<L Pre 4zjrt(L Jlid^sr/estA

               A.      77?£ LliriJ-jf /our4 Dt HfP^s /h JEetzt/trto*/^
                      dismissed /zJiboner's j£iPP€a/ of -/liz /7i/r?c Pnz
                      -Lime. JudLtrtdnJ vf-f-he. JriaJ /*ruri -tor uJa/ildf
                      dunsdiednor} jilkr CDndudmL -flud ffldrhdner
                      tttilaJ 4> P'k a. -htveh tJ/i-hhe rd jtPPtju/.
                                        2
                  B.   ft rfUHCPr&lunc JudLrSyresir' /s ^.n 4/¥k*l*Lk*
                       Z>rdex Under Hade- r>f)£rirrt/ri**J Pr&oediMnz*
                       Ar4ic.lt H-.D2 t iP^PPk&l is liirt&h JZLd.

         A   ~fht AoSenee, £>1fib*better's -fltitrnhfintrt trnm -J-he.
             flUrtC Pro June Judtsrie*t/s t A<> reuluired J=>3 HoJj&
             6p CriirJiyUkf Prot-edart. jkrAole 4l.Dl 1/Cj^C^oJ^h
             2tJ/z<> r< cleril**J error noi j£uhJju>-h-k> lu>r/* ^n/su/jsis.

             A.        bJt vf&iniJri/tf Proejiduft, Jirlidt ¥X,D L
                       en-Piltd "^uA&mmij" rtauir&s ilAal the djduntour
                       &DHT/iiii,/?ji1£}1£r n-fher ikiH^s , Ml? Porters -flwmhflri/d
                       -falter? j'a nr/Arda/ze, jjiM drlide 3%.?& of diis
                        tude,,

                  8.    mt Idtlufe, Ar *~4r/jid(Lourr 4z> do 3orytadff/n&-
                       -trial is /nanddory has be&rt de&rned a~ aJerjirJ
                       err&r jls opposed ~/d <art error vfdudicitd rea&wiiZ.

?r*3er lor teltif                         IX

LtriiliLtJt, d Lowtp/jnrtrz,              /3

dpP&tolix.                                 f¥-/s~