Court Opinion

ID: 9407408
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2023-07-06 20:09:37.366349+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T17:20:37.572552
License: Public Domain

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
                          WESTERN DISTRICT

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,      :   No. 343 WAL 2021
                                   :
                Respondent         :
                                   :   Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                   :   from the Unpublished
          v.                       :   Memorandum and Order of the
                                   :   Superior Court at No. 92 WDA 2020
                                   :   entered on August 13, 2021,
GARRETT WILLIAM LUCAS,             :   affirming the Judgment of Sentence
                                   :   of the Allegheny County Court of
                Petitioner         :   Common Pleas at No. CP-02-CR-
                                   :   0001672-2013 entered on
                                       December 18, 2019

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,      :   No. 344 WAL 2021
                                   :
                Respondent         :
                                   :   Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                   :   from the Unpublished
          v.                       :   Memorandum and Order of the
                                   :   Superior Court at No. 93 WDA 2020
                                   :   entered on August 13, 2021,
GARRETT WILLIAM LUCAS,             :   affirming the Judgment of Sentence
                                   :   of the Allegheny County Court of
                Petitioner         :   Common Pleas at No. CP-02-CR-
                                   :   0014400-2012 entered on
                                   :   December 18, 2019

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,      :   No. 345 WAL 2021
                                   :
                Respondent         :
                                   :   Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                   :   from the Unpublished
          v.                       :   Memorandum and Order of the
                                   :   Superior Court at No. 94 WDA 2020
                                   :   entered on August 13, 2021,
GARRETT WILLIAM LUCAS,             :   affirming the Judgment of Sentence
                                   :   of the Allegheny County Court of
                Petitioner         :   Common Pleas at No. CP-02-CR-
                                   :   0001167-2013 entered on
                                   :   December 18, 2019
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,           :   No. 346 WAL 2021
                                        :
                 Respondent             :
                                        :   Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                        :   from the Unpublished
           v.                           :   Memorandum and Order of the
                                        :   Superior Court at No. 95 WDA 2020
                                        :   entered on August 13, 2021,
GARRETT WILLIAM LUCAS,                  :   affirming the Judgment of Sentence
                                        :   of the Allegheny County Court of
                 Petitioner             :   Common Pleas at No. CP-02-CR-
                                        :   0001457-2013 entered on
                                        :   December 18, 2019

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,           :   No. 347 WAL 2021
                                        :
                 Respondent             :
                                        :   Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                        :   from the Unpublished
           v.                           :   Memorandum and Order of the
                                        :   Superior Court at No. 96 WDA 2020
                                        :   entered on August 13, 2021,
GARRETT WILLIAM LUCAS,                  :   affirming the Judgment of Sentence
                                        :   of the Allegheny County Court of
                 Petitioner             :   Common Pleas at No. CP-02-CR-
                                        :   0001168-2013 entered on
                                        :   December 18, 2019

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,           :   No. 348 WAL 2021
                                        :
                 Respondent             :
                                        :   Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                        :   from the Unpublished
           v.                           :   Memorandum and Order of the
                                        :   Superior Court at No. 97 WDA 2020
                                        :   entered on August 13, 2021,
GARRETT WILLIAM LUCAS,                  :   affirming the Judgment of Sentence
                                        :   of the Allegheny County Court of
                 Petitioner             :   Common Pleas at No. CP-02-CR-
                                        :   0002432-2013 entered on
                                        :   December 18, 2019

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,           : No. 349 WAL 2021
                                        :
                 Respondent             :
                                        :
[343 WAL 2021, 344 WAL 2021, 345 WAL 2021, 346 WAL 2021, 347 WAL 2021, 348
WAL 2021, 349 WAL 2021, 350 WAL 2021, 351 WAL 2021, 352 WAL 2021, 353 WAL
                        2021 and 354 WAL 2021] - 2
                                        :   Petition for Allowance of Appeal
           v.                           :   from the Unpublished
                                        :   Memorandum and Order of the
                                        :   Superior Court at No. 98 WDA 2020
GARRETT WILLIAM LUCAS,                  :   entered on August 13, 2021,
                                        :   affirming the Judgment of Sentence
                 Petitioner             :   of the Allegheny County Court of
                                        :   Common Pleas at No. CP-02-CR-
                                        :   0002467-2013 entered on
                                            December 18, 2019

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,           :   No. 350 WAL 2021
                                        :
                 Respondent             :
                                        :   Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                        :   from the Unpublished
           v.                           :   Memorandum and Order of the
                                        :   Superior Court at No. 99 WDA 2020
                                        :   entered on August 13, 2021,
GARRETT WILLIAM LUCAS,                  :   affirming the Judgment of Sentence
                                        :   of the Allegheny County Court of
                 Petitioner             :   Common Pleas at No. CP-02-CR-
                                        :   0010861-2017 entered on
                                        :   December 18, 2019

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,           :   No. 351 WAL 2021
                                        :
                 Respondent             :
                                        :   Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                        :   from the Unpublished
           v.                           :   Memorandum and Order of the
                                        :   Superior Court at No. 100 WDA
                                        :   2020 entered on August 13, 2021,
GARRETT WILLIAM LUCAS,                  :   affirming the Judgment of Sentence
                                        :   of the Allegheny County Court of
                 Petitioner             :   Common Pleas at No. CP-02-CR-
                                        :   0013632-2018 entered on
                                        :   December 18, 2019

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,           :   No. 352 WAL 2021
                                        :
                 Respondent             :
                                        :   Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                        :   from the Unpublished
           v.                           :   Memorandum and Order of the
                                        :   Superior Court at No. 101 WDA
[343 WAL 2021, 344 WAL 2021, 345 WAL 2021, 346 WAL 2021, 347 WAL 2021, 348
WAL 2021, 349 WAL 2021, 350 WAL 2021, 351 WAL 2021, 352 WAL 2021, 353 WAL
                        2021 and 354 WAL 2021] - 3
                                           :   2020 entered on August 13, 2021,
GARRETT WILLIAM LUCAS,                     :   affirming the Judgment of Sentence
                                           :   of the Allegheny County Court of
                  Petitioner               :   Common Pleas at No. CP-02-CR-
                                           :   0001670-2013 entered on
                                           :   December 18, 2019

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,              :   No. 353 WAL 2021
                                           :
                  Respondent               :
                                           :   Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                           :   from the Unpublished
             v.                            :   Memorandum and Order of the
                                           :   Superior Court at No. 102 WDA
                                           :   2020 entered on August 13, 2021,
GARRETT WILLIAM LUCAS,                     :   affirming the Judgment of Sentence
                                           :   of the Allegheny County Court of
                  Petitioner               :   Common Pleas at No. CP-02-CR-
                                           :   0001471-2013 entered on
                                           :   December 18, 2019

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,              :   No. 354 WAL 2021
                                           :
                  Respondent               :
                                           :   Petition for Allowance of Appeal
                                           :   from the Unpublished
             v.                            :   Memorandum and Order of the
                                           :   Superior Court at No. 103 WDA
                                           :   2020 entered on August 13, 2021,
GARRETT WILLIAM LUCAS,                     :   affirming the Judgment of Sentence
                                           :   of the Allegheny County Court of
                  Petitioner               :   Common Pleas at No. CP-02-CR-
                                           :   0001623-2013 entered on
                                           :   December 18, 2019

                                    ORDER

PER CURIAM

     AND NOW, this 6th day of July, 2023, the Petition for Allowance of Appeal is

GRANTED, the Superior Court’s order is VACATED, and this matter is REMANDED to

[343 WAL 2021, 344 WAL 2021, 345 WAL 2021, 346 WAL 2021, 347 WAL 2021, 348
WAL 2021, 349 WAL 2021, 350 WAL 2021, 351 WAL 2021, 352 WAL 2021, 353 WAL
                        2021 and 354 WAL 2021] - 4
the Superior Court for further proceedings consistent with Commonwealth v. Rosario, 294

A.3d 338 2023 WL 3470869 (Pa. filed May 16, 2023).

 [343 WAL 2021, 344 WAL 2021, 345 WAL 2021, 346 WAL 2021, 347 WAL 2021, 348
 WAL 2021, 349 WAL 2021, 350 WAL 2021, 351 WAL 2021, 352 WAL 2021, 353 WAL
                         2021 and 354 WAL 2021] - 5