Court Opinion

ID: 4056675
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:04:06.588614+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:36.310975
License: Public Domain

KZ.LW‘°\ 103103/0`"~|

RECE|VED l
couRT oF chrmNALA§PE/us

_JUN 08 2015

, AbelAc@s ,Q
'~n> w new com ma comm= arlmw.aL ,4/»¢)54:_)~ 23 ’e”<

A%EL dq'QDSTA
1261 Qé®u€sT‘r’oQ G'>\.)F:QMAToow oF b€l_w€/L\/ of A-r’¢'l.u\,+‘nmuf iran wrl\¢`oF
Hmms coramg »
\\\c \ RQQ&‘\Q`

Qu'w,;\(hgs `; En¢\bsee\ p\mse.\q`n¢i a cespe¢c:'\-€w\ ceqw¢s+- \\,¢mld like +\.
£\Q wm 441 cwa am QMM.@H a MSQM_\\M.\M,\ Wu,+`» m mm @wniy
barech QLE»IL\< , ` '

‘\’Lm)'e Asmm\ew mm wmnzn.

\lm nw mac §FFOQT u @,rz mer M)/z€cmeo .

§f\leSch(. :QEUES`:\' (ch)s§)
EX\¢\`\\S\\' (?, PQS) _

Qes?w¥£»l|q suLM.'»lJeJ Jum, .S`£’ ZGIJ'

gabriel C@¢lon§t unliqva
, Al\ aid Un;jr
` 3101 F;U.zleq A).

 

 

 

- I:>L.\(*'é" Qtiw\. Appea\> no w Q'( unlimith

E>L;'Pa(§e`_.(l\a\me/\ eurde ~ § \n TH€ HC¥*" dumc\AL
"D\ST(Z\Q,T U§LW~T
§ DEQ>U COU|\S`N iTE_\(A'S

§

R\;_®uesc ‘v`mcom\a\v\/m@w oz v€u\)Ea\coF ADDUCATI<)N£
' , ml wm oz HMSEQS Covl'\>ux‘ ;

\\B¢>L,$ wa\cs (;`40\1><§@,\ ch(c\o¢&a,@pp\leon\rpro sv_ `w\ 5('\/\@, '(:ul}ovoir\£,ond_
ma\LCx 5(\/\7\§ (Qc\ues¥ ap (:‘¢>n _`fmm¥dr\ op ’De\`\o€v\\¢>c )Drpp\imko?`$ rlAr!{~
§§ Ma\oec\s an\us,omd r~es()A-M\\q wald show ~pr @ouA-cas ~w)/ou)s:

\

\ (La\)¢§e.\ Q&rdm \zQTinq Qm;eh\r\q '\v\cmeem)¢éo\ in Me.Texm 'J)QparW»/\,lu{
Qm\{m\ §us\ace under '\nmak "\d@ num\mr \L\\\L\LJ?Z. com Com¢pde"n¥ k rmke.

\'\m~c»\\w{v\g Shkwv\lr_\\u¢\dor pmqu op miami béc§\g +vv¢. c.»¢( c.>\¢r@.¢+.-‘
\ mm -Ww. G\>p\`\o.uv\)c §~\ ‘~\ book cc \~la\neas G)rpw' H'\a¥~wm \£l/er/ m .‘~l.ZD.I£"
`m ‘\\\m\\qb"'§`\s‘\~n`cjc Gml.b.>€,\ob “ mL\¢ laredo .`\'€\ »A~ppl\ca `IM`
gm m¢\/\ 1001 %\e.c\ burt w\.%\w\\' \)e}\ng S*Qm\>ed as“'\:\\,ED n L\\'\\¢\a/C\Erk. `i`\~ooos
vw§r_w\al\£(\ of cwde \>'q -W,LQ[€(K.Q\A {L did v\M c¢>r\xrcdr\ -5<'\`/\0,1&><1¥ number r.
Sue\/\ (€s`>®nse daley Ua\,g Z?_iZD'\S'. \ fuer 4§\@§i ch \\Ao,m.>m¢\o\uim }n vep\c/
¥b 3¢\\1 33<€<\€5 wst m\ 5&\1; ?,MY clqu o€' june, Zz>\c. '

\\.

iad pa¥‘\§or\s and overu\\ ¥{\w\`g¥ mem w\cz`\\e(j \)`10\ Oer`\'?(`ieal W\a\`\ y (F€r`j(.

vw. \><>_\`~rlg "\B\L\ ~\$’1.0' GLD\~‘ZQ 'q?,£’.(_' ».€\pe_c>\eci delivery C[ak Ll/§Oh$» 'i&)e¢`gl»+‘
op 05 L\Qs 330 01.[5€~€_ index per n`.|¢hgx\ Av\.>“\of MH~} £zc\ man w Mado_ vT<:\
Cet¥\`l\.`ac\ mdi\ c.,~\\s`\x\\§w_‘ be Om ac¢lé\am‘¥ b~£ &\Q+S \`u Supp>(¥ete L»Q"E ¢ (`€ (~1-: ho-`oeing
101\\ »\m>~ c>m\-wmdszqz mm (lw..-p+ 214wa &»l|,\ ce¢l;f~ed' mail pad 15

were AQ;%.R¢A -\b memo 00.»¥\1 juva ("`e¢\‘l?_`( .’D;'Hn`c}r (‘.`\ML\ c€f\?e. f ESH\Q./ 02qu a-
Clma ,L\.:¥\\ @d&w op '\\\b vidvnz@ 54¢ &k.z,o_z. lmedo .T~ew.\ m>LIO m ’lxouz,

\L)eig\n\ 09 sw Huig\wa$ o@ 0 L\os. Z:lo 01.(3€@ \`J\AQ¢\

 

 

\\L

\n QQBNA&“CQ w`\§<\:\ Qr"\'dt \\¢Qb\ OGW.T£XCLS varies ¢,€ (.`c'{ml)/m\ Q¥\>Qec\uv€ir\“\')@

(l'\ajr'\¢ ¢@ \Y\~o_ Cw\\>\`c\{<\g Cm(\* 5\1\¢\\\ process , L`le.cw§ \Moi\\ o\,\ -p\'\.`v\gs §~0 all 'pa(+;es
;WAWA. nmb wm w s).@&e £\u a `CPM. w cw¢.A'T‘\\`Mer.» :Suc\/\ is no+ +l'\e t[.`ue mcf 'H/\i§

§d" dmi cs`$’ duvw, ZO\S. , '

\\>\A€a€reac~: .PrLe’M\ses Comso oz:/c€o. +'m a P|io:m+ {» w akwe ;+\/M amf
hum\)ecao} w>£$. . v¢quesk ~H\Q¥ ~H\L 0011\+ Cen `rms now de/¢'u"erq cf all perM€mL
QJ\¢§ d`u.\\.| p¢’MSA W\€cle L>-\ HL€C¥ppL`cOn'l,unc\ wri\' numbers .

’2239€0¥[:11[\\{ ¥uLm/L|€c/. Jdl,éna/SB ZOIS'
G@Ln'd helm I'L)Llumz

ALL (£50 mun’
62\0\ F.M, 310<¥ cu4

     

 

 

 

` " Ex§| 1qu 1 lc\»sa,\wm'of wear "
V\CXQ_?&,- 0 ` gm \`(1(3,§
T(\u\ Q»\,\<& v\d_‘._;_<>c>$ cms ms n\§£\)__
~¢\\.\>1 b\>c'\\( QQ \9\&\0203 Q¢>Q LO.L~.> \`Y\ ` &\_Lp{j>('\'.uc L}b¥ 1-\/
~ QHud/mm¥lm ‘€\)\€W\D.¢>C~ \Qu<>*Qec\uc,-\cd\ Qov\$€s§\un L‘®S/.OS`

~ U§(\m lay Emden{uc\j Hmr'mq _

Tn@\ Cmcl< N>: m wm LM/ ):>__) 991
' \mé¥u@ \/\Q\>QQA Ql>cpus \1.0'2
»=» \)\Uv\o. of mm §\n Suppr>(¥o@ mdl( ` _ bow of `
- T@_;X§mun\{ ac Q\/\<"t‘§%%'\c£ LLXZCM\\`> (.CY\ S\)\ pb(\»u? peg/3 ap Gf uWM)CWO‘“§C/“:\PR)
f `\)Qm\\\ C§\;‘\Co\m€& MCM\QQ ~`\'Q.s~\~. `rw>_m|'o' 3 md @inedo\ AQ;RLQ\ 'lvwm€ence C/a_»'m>
v maness Slvulcma.v\¥x ; t (`-""““C""“‘) _
Q%`\§Mp$\a cf m\'zm`)u,oé ~D(;*@tc_:\ol`v\¢> Ur\cmm _\r. w\ l€!am`\vl<:> op Lucio \/dez O,
" Q&\D\o Qu>nze\es ?em,
'?Omg¥;\\km¥ net (
" uCu\ \`\nGr Gu'¢ qarc`¢c\
~/ O&\<\s¥z\o kaon men '
"~\Cu\e;\r' QL"M.¢AO\
~ Mo\ao¢\ ~Q\>( mc'\:zv\¥c>cq ch\vq
~T<`\ul Cau<¥ emma ny zoo;_g;w\) 952/01 {L)\
-» h)<~§¥ 0`: \Y\cL\vQQ§ Qo.f\u,\s \\¢(S”) ~
~’ MQSN\D DC \_Dw §w\`§upp§(~\"o'e \)bn`~\/
' TJLS\-;mu\q op Q\I\("LS‘\~.`¢\Q \,o?_ur\o a¢\¢\ Dcw'd M‘\'l-. fhon [,`T (°‘“@C""?s“$)`
~» \Déme,s& SMMQA¥;‘Z '» , l l _
S`\v\d‘n'\é D(: Iv\x€!U`\Q\»S ap~ QQ.\D¢}\!> Cl/\£IMKL 3§1 wl learning me Luci¢> U£/Pz d
’ (\7€£10\0 Q\o/\’Z£\.\€_§
~ 'D:w{d \XCM\`~/\ez CQM z.o
~/ juan Apc>\\\?war ®u`.wgu @arcln
' " ®(\\x\$§\ho LQZQnD
‘ \ln*\`w\ ¥\>r Ewidm\¥ ur\{ Hm<‘mg 1
f mi mg § (TLEI FQC[UQ( §2¢/1"!€0€@. am @anrrfv\l.)
" (p\€,€x %ofga`w\ pcq¥?£.w\l)n‘\'
“ bu§qme~\\’op Cc>¢\ §(;¥m ,
~ &\Lcllc~'iu\ 'D>LXLQ,~\ vi \.oA/k( rcqu\sz;£{ng vae\\ale (?w¢\se/\

\.,£z

 

fried C.M¥ ma no z lamb c\woama m /;4> '
¢-\\..(§') l.»_\r?~\' 59 HOL\G€CA` Cb mn (bn£Urs~€/rl)
' (P‘eu garqc\;:\ {\q\"QD.MQA~)r
/ §udqme./\\“oc» (‘1>¢\\)'{"€§\`¢»\ ,
f dud€'ci'u\ "Bsduz‘r \-c'. QQF`LQ\QA o@€r Av,fendon+)
v judicial OU.\L¢¥' CC. \€;\/ler (Lqu!.¥\\`¢q .uppa."nl€. (kunw/

in‘@lmgg\ § 'dlg\;§` S"\§(; g;g§§ ngg,fz FDQES ‘ _* l
' Qaque_>¥£¢ aim Qw}§`\\§\\\h| o(:'@\c{cms wl Exki\».#:' (r@‘»delaq 5'\ @"“"\5 ‘°""*5)
' Mr>\`\on (T\N bel/dm warranjr wl E»L¢\`al)(h

'Mo.\owsz wo; cec\§e¢§ w\o\u mc s\\nQ\e package
wkde ms nom mo com wm qzs§
”Y)Q}Luery dale_‘. Qpci\ ZQ»ZDW ` `
’\)Q'>\{na%`m§'"\)\_s\w{c\ Q\em €'shr Deq¢s"acjo, .
'\\\0 vi@+.>r»;ci s+. 546/103
Lacerlo.T~/_ 'IS/oLl'L '

4“)€1@\\-\". 3 \_\)s . S“)O 02.

\1‘,9&{3¢(\:@0'\‘¢1\)§"¥¢(2' rack \v\ (‘:Qn€m, gle f
C¢L;\»`Qe_pj M~.'v<>\q mo own zaqu Sz,qz flew izw.~y+ war
mmng eight w uaw 1\_.20\§
"Da-s\w`nc$un `. ®is~\r'\c;+ 'Cler`\c E.Sler Oegonado
` \\\O\Il€'\vné B:L 516/503
lovele ,T)C '(X’qu,

@Qquex-\ -pv( (§L(re@¥'mo£ \"C(‘orcl meal “ MO. `-;§»ZD|§_
" A\Sb \Qq\££&\€oi C\(>.(L*\ |\.b`l~»i\{ op wr\i'\" {T{€(i' A»rYa`va{\

L\ ,Mewmrqné\ums \5\ Qe.o\q k gain ‘Q.€$Qmse.s ~meai ,u£c\ C€(+i{;*