Court Opinion

ID: 4075790
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 06:29:48.816698+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:05:09.546081
License: Public Domain

TfoU   Coor* U*<**- mo. hibC-Ci- Z.og'Z-oCa

        \A              NOV 302015   *   "TUlri   btiUV-V
   vt*«Me^.          v^bEMaj«i£X     7   JL>^     \\os\v^   ley ^^
                                                            November 30, 2015

          ?JEte^\0(i" oJ      6-LfcfcfcS RECofrk
To Tte vW>ofUt'vSL£ ^OVT\U^> ©£ S>A\X> Coo (IX\
     £o«l£S JOoO. &v\xTjfk iWu^Y / A£feH*Wt "pro *»fc- ^ "ft—
frboOC'^VflcA, *«**- uo**lae-r<sl £-A^S^- <£> V A<-4vo^ A***. &L» iX^
WVr>r*o> For IU.Ue^rf^H a>J Clewlf-*S £<*ior<i~     TU— iv.^l 6*ur-V-

 f\py>. ^. 3H»<> O li) ^ Wu p*«(u^^\ ^ ^-*- -VtiVV toor^ cUrk-.

-ffcX. £. (W."?.   3H-Slk) g>g^0gST Tog-        M>b tT\(o^<vL j:Tg>HS

    l*) d-to.

                                     a5
  ^iloevJr ^^JaI kd**\*^T <*> o^i^tW^ 4o ire*- -W*~s.c/"vfT-$
   ^4 ^rvor \>r© uulAwv> oV«~~ -VWx -Vvs^cAbr \> v«*1^4. U ^
  eftcAvL LW«_ „/*neJ .^rrV m to^frAi^ +*f 0^Uv*-7

 r} ^_ aIoov^ ^ly'" fi^^ tJo^W^ C#«*±*-. os> Appeal ci ^hJuJU

  ftW\fttu iwiori. V'LW ot -iU SUC 0*«Lr TeX«VS l**>
 Aro ^rt^a-JT lv\ V.««>V O(0ce_ fir Cowv&UjU_ £«-v/vjh2. <&t aII kv> '

                                     HL.

Ur tiO.S. Co^rt UA>1l^ felt, Rv App»?» 2tfS{±\) T^ JLirfc. M4v Unt^el^
u»i K* "W-«- ^>wj-\U/* (LovNtA«;>or*vQ TV-*. Lox,vl<avc«r oT Tt-_ di^J*^l> &-<*>€ L v
X P*-Cuu*^.
  pe-dfexX >>p
            Pl& f£.Vbe*>.S&. -GrW VC-lv*
                f<LyeoA>.Sc -WW   \)<-lv«v ^U.
                                           -friOc . "b,skjA"
                                                     DiSt/u*" Co^A
                                                              Lo-wX c\&A~
                                                                    d £-*•£-.
_»> "IV^ \«_\W* / fcs-*£C»*h. X- v»roti. *p fUaOiA \^ ,2JOV5" A«vl isieb-t^lot^

•to "Tg»> Rs^>?» 3^>(d.HA x4 k e*l«*/i*-vT I-U^ Uas U**> owiv4ci
 •CfovK ^t\**_ C_V«-rV-> ri-oorl t 'A^A^. -\rAo-L /loo A . "iV* ^peU A^ Coo^X^
^r ^       £><vAy ^^^ t^ l^^Lr itrd^t -TU -Vr^t doo^ clev^

•13-«- -WvaA. C©csrT cU^-l^ toTlUe^ IS i^v-$. o\r C^-CuvC^ 1^5

                                       *Uo   4^
                                  -SSL.

V Kyle. o4-1V-.6Do.r-V ^rs.o^A 4~ Tg^A^.fr 3>^9 Q\ ^^ftf

 fU. 4rT*vl C*urf cLrl^ oV ITU- <L.4-<dr of ^MJ-Of^C^ l^Ul-

 ^c^ ^-c        -WvuvL (joorV cJje^tV- v»Aooll *JoT" £*-v^©vv 1 4o

                                 3T.

X^iUK. jOOr \J(\t>LuL \* "\V-e_ CoO<4!l- vAolcJkv^-e^ Ce^*>rl Sua^CT Ao AfcpJLvX"
e>^ CVo^osV 3>, Zol>. Ibc.E. %,?. 3d,CfeM?.\ s-U^ ^ cr^,vl

 ^ou^^A     iv^vl (S> (Ao^^ 4e> CtZaJT PtCCt3><> TO C£>cKrT> "tA^Uc^r^-/

Of J^?6IHU tL.I 0J 3Uy Zl.Zo^ o^Lr X« ^ iAX^r fiU
 ct |>ro 3€_ flJlcTlW TD ']b(S<tfl^5 <V^ouTEb> r^j^gL ^^ -tU_
 u>Wt L>>fr> 0*-^™^ jV 1l<- Cocr-V cl*/^ o*ktT TkK. &Apo .?< 'S^feA

                                        T7T-   .

 _ Till 4tT*C <u>^f ^t ^rv^\ A- Tc*. g-k?r >. M^^^l

C©orV        f^^^yr -fro*    MoTvo^ "FoP> feeyk^^fe- r^F ci-EttL*? gccoe^
cL>4- Are*    fr^clVA^^'^   <io-e_ «Lt\ C<XC^c-t_- \o W.'v. £. HjaWT   4to   OS>tT<dc "tU*_

^V>C CcHt\       tjrt^ frCCofivCloi     ^      "CU.   ^la-fr Av»l S.Wo-11        A>e"V (s-C-
liZA^v^l 'lAooT \       ^pcil^wt M*YS- ^La-1 "^U^ ^our"V Ui«_-i\^_
-W\*l Go^rr cJe^-fc- Dclo 1«- *v|>|>^((aws.4vS. "pro e-4_ vvup-4\L*wG) ^ 1S*-
 fc*x<pcA oAevva oTW o.U o+La-r fc^uML^Li «'-W*^S. 0J "(V
 (vto«. S-^fLi A^A ^fwwW t^o><^> a^I 4^1 -K^4 -iUc-
a V~ Tew* ^aA«~J^ ^ Crr-w-l ^uv-Ut. a| -^ ^w^oc^
O^V t^ ~&£W Lu^ T<£Xn>, OcL^-Cy A-vl is-cUrx- UkL/ j>e~*U v~

                                 ^ui^       •6U>>v4.

                                 ^«ll
                                  'eel ATA~v-
                                                       =*•

                      ofc^efc.

                                   vJo>K<-t. ^/c>1l^*

                         5" .^5"
         '^jUrfJJL Sft*y ^ KyL                                     -iOD-Oe^^ ZP^- Tj&iS'

                                               ££       e£>- ii"- oohio <- c£*.

   *fo^ lOrfNL\*G- ^ f!.£**-'> teCQg-V x                             ^W^ XL._

     (jZ>l>r*V\

         fervor <vV=t— \C^S«-M^K^ L^-k«^v W^-A          ."p^-Ht-b?          Cs>   t> »*.

                                                                                           H
jJ^fcS

                                                                               4 'l^-

                                                              V

                                                                           1   Ajwt
            ^                RECEIVED
                             NOV 3 0 2015
                                                 ^bfcwvv«S   CI (J 4-^Z-
                                                             &
                           THJRDCOURTOMPPaLs
                             jiKggvaKttf                                   -* ,       U-
4

0)

      r
 I
M
in

•si
      i    Or*
                 r
                     r3-
•si

      $
                           71
      -J

                 ^   (7
                 ^   7^

      V              r
      ^A
      <<