Court Opinion

ID: 185592
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2011-02-05 02:33:46+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:42:53.777272
License: Public Domain

United States Court of Appeals
              for the district of columbia circuit

No. 00-5195                                  September Term, 2001
                                                      99cv00042

                                        Filed On: December 28, 2001 [647940]
                                                               
American Bankers Association,
               Appellant
               
v.

National Credit Union Administration, et al.,
               Appellees
               

     BEFORE: Randolph, Rogers and Tatel, Circuit Judges.

                              ORDER

     It is ORDERED, by the Court on its own motion, that the following revisions shall be
made to the opinion decided November 9, 2001, in this case:

     At page 3 of the slip opinion, lines 10-11 from the top, replace the words "overruled the
Supreme Court, amending," with the word "amended."

     At pages 16-17 of the slip opinion, beginning at line 9 of the first full paragraph of
section VI, replace the sentence "In support of this proposition . . . than would ordinarily apply,
63 Fed. Reg. at 72,013, 72,037 38," with the following: 

          In support of this proposition, the ABA cites two provisions of the rule: the
     criteria for determining whether a community qualifies for a charter, see 63 Fed.
     Reg. at 72,038, and the new "presumptive community" standard applicable to a
     recognized political jurisdiction with no more than 300,000 residents, or multiple
     contiguous political jurisdictions with no more than 200,000 residents, see 63 Fed.
     Reg. at 72,013, 72,037 38.  The ABA contends that the community credit union
     criteria are substantially unchanged.  Compare 63 Fed. Reg. at 72,038 (new rule
     listing political jurisdictions, major trade areas, shared/common facilities,
     organizations/clubs, newspapers/other periodicals, maps designating community
     to be served, common characteristics and background of residents, and other
     documentation demonstrating common interests or interaction) with 59 Fed. Reg.
     at 29,077 (former rule listing political jurisdictions, major trade areas,
     shared/common facilities, organizations/clubs, newspapers/other periodicals,
     census tracts, common characteristics and background of residents, history of
     area, and other evidence of what distinguishes chosen area and its residents).  The 
     the ABA also points out that an area benefitting from the "presumptive
     community" standard is subject to less demanding documentation requirements
     than ordinarily apply to an area seeking a credit union charter.  See 63 Fed. Reg. at
     72,013, 72,037 38. 

     At page 17 of the slip opinion, line 12 from the top, replace "we have little difficulty
rejecting this argument" with "we have little difficulty rejecting these arguments." 

FOR THE COURT:
Mark J. Langer, Clerk

BY:
                                        Michael C. McGrail
Deputy Clerk