Court Opinion

ID: 2653227
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2014-02-14 01:01:12.248376+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:11:11.360339
License: Public Domain

OPINION
 

  PER CURIAM.
 

  Petitioner Beatriz Herrera seeks asylum or, in the alternative, withholding of removal on behalf of herself and her daughter, Victoria Isabel Perez. Petitioner was born in Colombia and is also a citizen of Spain where she resided before coming to the United States with her daughter. The crux of her claim is that she suffered domestic abuse at the hands of her husband while the family lived in Spain and that the government was unable or unwilling to protect her. Both the immigration judge and the Board of Immigration Appeals (“the Board”) denied relief.
 

  As with virtually all applicants for asylum, one may sympathize with petitioner’s desire to continue her residence in the United States. Based upon the administrative record, it appears that petitioner has suffered domestic abuse. However, as the Board recognized, that sad fact does not end our inquiry. Even if we were to assume, as did the Board, that domestic violence “may in some cases be a basis for asylum,” (A.R. 4) petitioner has not established that the Spanish government could
   
   *491
   
  or would not protect her. Absent this vital element, her application for asylum or, in the alternative, withholding of removal, fails. In reaching this conclusion, we acknowledge the exemplary advocacy petitioner received below and in her appeal to this court. Nevertheless, after our own independent review of the administrative record, we adopt the reasoning set forth in the Board’s decision dated January 29, 2013.
 

  Accordingly, the petition for review is denied.