Court Opinion

ID: 4040340
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:29:54.990877+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:10.918923
License: Public Domain

.   '

    ~-

                                                          .:0: '
         6tbiJAJ_D 8 :A t6/JIJ&Jr7ZJ 1:E AtiJeD TIJ .4Piflt:AAI13 Mi:AitJfl.AAJMAit -rN &uKIY ~eord!J ~_veillide IIOUJ; ii/JWetJel6af-tridl bf&er ~ TvrMV
          COiirJJideL! &1~ -letti~ h¥ pta~ Cdd1e -lo seard1 ~~ 11eltuL:Je .. bLf f86+:hft~
          11"'-or ~ d.S Cl expqf wfbless .-GJr .1-tJe, Stale liil!d -fl'a~ K..-9 hsvJiu LM fkt, 6cevte.;~
          ~ltJ(-'1 :biD NI>T ALYJ:r To 6We tu//MAIJ PRiJA4f!ECAtJiSIJVJtl.6·-tree ht!CiJf/Je, if tW1J Ji~Lhrii11 vVJreiJ.~
         ~eizure ·.tJ~ ~s hl6fll'll!' fl:J &~fpre65.Jhe. ev~ sJaiA·hM!.he&t~, fi.J~ ~
         ~ -frldl t.ovFf ht~JrJ ev~ ~ IN~fesl:iiMdWtf .Jt' svppr~awia~rJe.tliivq ~~~ iA.B6
          -ldl_te ~~ lsve t:orrt!Of81 her rdi~ ib.r ~ Cdllie .;J ~ frfdl ~ evitle~ newlq
          dLb£/Jvert!~v •
                                                     .:nr.
C,.WAIO   ?,~ 5114UMR.D f£1/tE.MJ/APPUCAIJE l.AVJJ.
            :4 wifM6S 'k6fitrji~ 1/V'Jef ~ CIJ~ltt$ (Jf!{jvrq if! ~IJr tltte~e:s~ fe~
L.atlt:dN".§ md4erial. m-dih:r.s w'*" w~l ;~h;,p!d'vrJe.f~ .Jrg~; Tb ~rk.{lel'fortt .
if i!J I"Offlid ~ ptove~ 1/J~ {.J),IAJiifiJ ;i1fevtj-~~ille c:JJI1d (.2.),~tfftt~ tsf .:5~
n1eU.U1JtJ l31 mM8 ~.sfare~ ilrrhr o~ C!J) •..Jiai-IID4 1!1fil'elt:Jr~i2tJ.b..f I~
                                                w*'
itJ .ht:,. M3Jlz 1/htk; ilJI/ts L5J. ;1;1, u,YII'JeC:I-;i.vt ofFtdd p!bCed~ W. fk; )i~6tfe ~~
Lf...t06 ~kli;
 4 R:fiC LE IItI1 , IIGA~AV ; /JutE <60l, .DefiVlih'M •
           {d),   U(f}roaq ,,."#eorti9q '\-s   -s~ t.:iltw'+havt tMe ~ b'l ~kl~
                                               01
whi~ ..fe.JJb.ilq~ .Bf-.Htle -f~'liJI ~ ~;lfJ ~bfferd fVJ. ev~ 1D (VtJJe:fue +ruft.t sf ftte
 Mafkl'.s a.sser~.
              C.~tihblldf Law (JV6Vide..JIIJI-; ACi:MA!Id-IM SeaJrd bq-Hte 1/fie,af ~e~
 heiw'.saq eit~ JYJusf!Mvllldu Live~5~i Where~ Cflld'~s ~~
 ~ ev;J~ --ib.!JD vnt:brrede& ~ if J.Pf&'t"s, IV~ & ret~iliftt of ~ivevt
 Jvifvle~ m:l.f JVeti he,~m!vJ~ at fjtJI'if or~;~ CiAJfh-a f&ldi~C-~rt:: of evitlevta
a.frecfiV!J crt!L/;bilift.~J"V6fi'Fie6 a. neu.J+rit3lar~~ vvJu-h tlue,(Jvot..e"is~,
 frr~dlue pf t:LKJFI-6 ~-fdiHJ v ~.ftJiKI, 'Catwi6fiit!g~ ~ h>& CiXJr6-
-ib.he. prtjJrel is~~ tE Llue (JAJtes:s. ~              #EREAPraL ~11111184 v6ed 6ke ~
 ~ fetJf~ tf ~"'t3[ iiM~ W Olf'IJ~5' Co1VicJ11i.1~ hsJ IJ~ ~ ~
 .fr;aL ·;ru4ge v Cb.Jr+. ~ if~ ..Jt,e VUif ~ V""~ w~ cuMvdtJ ..f1tte heM-~_
  ftJr evl~q iW'J       ;{JJif!S6!M,
                            The            .Tvt!Je
                                        iPlDl IIOn-&d'di"IO ordtv, t:sla:fi~; Tlle~r..f' ·
 -h'Nk ..Jmf../he V~ f:1Jze/J6ar /wid~ cau~ -Je. ~~ ~ V~1PV1 G.J~
 +er:fliM~f! ~ ~ ~ Nku- ~ Tvmer..fVJe J(_q ~ ddvii5h£ /Jr -k:JJ hivu -~ ~9
  .;>(~ j +hi~ -/et;tliYJaAq JU)S Martikf" '11le 1?~ :r~ wl1a-u ~~ -./l1e 1/t:fl{- ~ :r~
  hecrd umf~· evit!BvdJ lmw. Mlr t:JV're, fJi.JTTIAJIJ ~ w~,. {j) .8¥i/f~
· ~ ~ lvrht!r --~he fl'a~Nd K--9 ~fer tn .#Je ~~~mid b~ --lklf--lk 1(-'!J
  DtD 1JtifAll!llr Tb 6tlllJ tdUM.IJ IJIr vmi&-itU /Jd:s lin-~ G;l{)~ dS .J WldlkY ofSov~n-h(
 -lb~t»t ;~+iJI!q aAf whose. irrkreff' ,;, CL Ui/Yii;Q{ -lrdl b .s~~ i$ d~.uedaAJ
  Cl -:fair -/riM U86 ti¥Judd.~ ·~prior 6-ia:ie~ ~ .;;2 rteSolf bf VJt¥jl~geVJL.e. or
 L/es~; +he f'le-{~~ihil/1~ -h> tArredftse .fdtse ~ of ~'/Pidf ldW ...
           Ll Gx- 'lade .Brel d6 d. .
  m~ afde/Yilli"J(J Cl~l'lfof1iherlrfabr 11/)r 15 dve p.ttx:e!i5 .sah~~d ~ ~rf-lails fr>
  an-&:i' ~~~~ i ~ire2- v,60fe. ~ St~», 3d ere~ ...fp~A~.;?a)2)~ -
          :L. U.Svs IJ"rfdll t99~F:3tLICJ?JL:GhJCi"r1999);TJreU:vrf'pf~ heltf-/Wtfk
 G:m(J-ifdiiM W36 v~ wl?a4 -MeJ/eJrwlilM ~ ~ itte void~~ rt4ful f~Dp.
 4Jd- ~ -~ bt.t fJvr~ a£-- eutieVIilal''f           diiJ..
                                          SJ~~iiM iuJa:ii!J; /he uur~ erred ~14l~
 if'P~ tnd/m? +o w~ ev~ sei2d '""' 11ldlatuM of h/s tf,Ji.l A~~~.,
                                                      2,
, :   TV15h~er7U5~-~59q(:r~,.~ •. Cor(MlG1rtrif'i ;t:y((g)/kCa.JfftRIJp~
       ,
reveu:sdap~s C41U!iciU:Mihll~;flh*'·l/>e --lria.l wtf iw'tfr~ ~ -Jhe5f;;de -lo
 WrtradLt:e.~eu~~~Jv/l.f~ wwr:.-fclrwt-nvenffhe.~17.JLecw.&
                       lhi6 U5e .befbl'e ../-he CCtJF!- Aete .a./lavd vVI5w£VVL art--
liVLSWPrtl M--Df-CL¥/rf ,.j0(.1/'Z:e5.
Jtf-caJrf' ~~ 4r ~ aw.se&f evid&tf~O/q a.v!d ~(Jfh!SSI~ 1u:9r;lll{} -ID d~~V~
d(J~ fDr frial ,awl~ d(J(J~ ~ 1v cSCJ,qie$ ev/id&r:.e, -lhlt- ~ sei~~riWJ
.dV\ vnl'~ ~IM -lhH--Ie.L-/z; M 11frtp/8e¥dtt avJ ~~              Bl{ ;"-Pe/'ell1£e~
~'r*J~61&:e N-hEC4.11f- setel4ll8fltl's we/e rlZeWal ;~ e~f&'evlt:61iv- (VO~
                                       4

dt $~ he¥;'(/,~M d:f-rr_i11"': iiEAt.&Al/ YIOLArlbJJOtx:.f)f2£{)': 1/ws ev~a6-lo--Hle
                                            1

 pvt~rr of ihli»-wsfib/1 teeeifid· hq-.HJe w~ t>r-fet;f~·IJf..fW!, re&llf 4f ~~ ~
At~6/flrer per~/ lli&-da; fJfZ¥:tF aC-#Je.fild.s ~ an- 6F cawf',AeG fl"~ dil.s.s~.
¥ HG4~tl : .MdbrYJ~itt-. !l1 £vitleJ,t::e, ~~ .2 qq .p. ·7.35'LelefVl(Rev.,6d l:d /084)
  .            ~ ~{Per; !Jihw S~ovlrt.s+est"~ f~Jb>.rmd -lheJun{-lho:f tJfur Sealf -lb~
 him..JhttdfJplldd-' Jf.86 VJOt at1 ihfil.rMt:Ur~-; a.Jvrtf ~ Ybf likefq-lz> ~ ~ ~0>1.hdweel4
cil. tht-bvf VJM"r~ (&~&+ad Wl,e~d(JpeliMI- i6 ¥U:t-c9H- itiir~ )~                                        .
            . :fvt -fne catJe .be~Dte us . . v~ l:Jv~ ..Jeit111a44 JttfdVJ'H!d .JI,ejurq. ~ IJ{6zu
 wrner-frJ/d ht~<#sf--Hte KJJdlerh!:J        -li>eue    M f.JI7JIIJ3/Iiee6V~fotiear&ti¥Jp~; Vehtae:;
   ~dtl.( Is_ U6Y !lKefLt -k> ~I~ .di£-Ft~ befiuf?sA ~EM--at- hd«dfive {/vrnu folii H4e
 -H1e t.-'lJr-e:fed1D!file~ pnMJie ~ _--0 f!:AYdf., ~ ~ J lhe .pil(.{bdfku how
    ever 5bmltt !W& pe/JIA/flid 1o rdMe hisl3rica.l ~ecb Df-Hte. ~, replde wikt ~~
  ~~in -~he ..fiJilM of ~~d141 r~ "" yb!Jntis -JI,a:!;-- he -41e IU36 sJiltc:J -Ia Jd{
 Jhe  ""fl.# -Hie ~rW9fiM ~JAJhidtl he-sk!! ,f).c;;f-&D .::z:-.,_ -~he,~ d:/-/sr; ovf-ttf"...c.tvrritMplial
  {:.~1118~ u$6 ~"r ~irvin :Md14.9$ flrw-~ ~,. f"'l/&lvcl'i6i tEfhe hedr~ Ai#5 .
 d~ ~ 5ullSTAIJriAL PJ611r~c1fpl~ ~At/ reve/.Sdlbf hi5 Lo?vtd11Mffe£ ,{l_.
 CriiM .&,-J~ la3 [.a.) •

                                                         A.
                AfJf~ ~ f~ fh11--Htis Caltf ~ cit 6rat/ld IJine .be/tette he 1&:1 jMJftfitl.e CAJ(;f£ tv J$1"~4 O!JPii@Ut/:5 vehi;;le, aA£1 c:J[ltJwe.J ~-eoureJ
 -festliMDVIi{ -ib!Jb Wi&:Juf cor~ if.                          »"            ··        .
               ;   ~JJlJ./JR.J) ()f tl.EVL/:JJJ/:APILI£AI!JI£ LAIAJ TO .4DD 6WI1D JJifiJG, AND ALI..EA.bll-h'ted
  Met«tJI"~ ~Su(J/br:fof Wr:foF ~                      Clr(¥15";
                   A wrlz,ess fed:if'q.,"!1 vVItief o~ COMM~'f-s peqvfl/    if he- h ..five ld!s -les~

                                                    3.
.       .   ~

eow:u~•lt1j ~iol ~s with wiLlfv{ inl:evlf-rn (Jt311el~e ~I
            An(cl£ vut. H~AI.f: l!.vL£  well CL6 ~~ ev~ ~ &reLidiJilifq
6ta g;vt!14 tv~ maq wtdl he ~ial-ive tE guilfv'~.. Irrespeclive cR
pro:secufttvti!Jird.fJ;th or W -~~ ~fofM(j~MA1t( KvuJwvt -k> ~ lbbe
prejured iS ~ r£- tfue (YtX:.eSS. +ler~ 6JrMM l6&i prt;jurtJfa.lle.:le&?;~ zF
4#dferlai fMIJO~ce -fD a(JIJII~ U!nVk.+i61~ ~ k be ~ -fD fVM<:cottiPI hecai!$€..
he ~#)e.~. ~u /A/Jan~~ tye-friat irfentiews 4f ~JL #vee~ .
wift1e.!setu IJ1ele;;y ~ wilrtwss ~l.f. Til/lifer~ fr~ K-9 hdwller6f- -ftte. Sceste
wfn,n +ea-ti-;~t:.£ af +!i3l .fmt- f/Je 1<..-9 JiJ AJdr.Al.£1(:1-fl> Jive IPAJ~Ut:tvt (Y~ ~ -h:>
5W&z atJpll~ veWde,, ~td&'del ali 6JrVJ.W(5 .f.e.tii~ fOrpv~ ~i Cltt£4Ue.
 verq ~ (J~r wku-1 afiJLltideJ -#Je dtfec;f- ~14af'-tM tJf-/Ue5e lA/ilt1e~dfiriaJ.
  tf: W:M hi6 t:iii(Ja:iitJII DVJCe he.. he~.e ~e -#8f--lne fe!ll•ftl/ iF~ kel,t wi!lzes5 ~1l16f-"
+rue" d.5 a, ~ df 6/JVfYe/glthf fDga/&-vt imp3A--ia/IJ{ dVJJ.. w.itJa:e intr:res+- i~ ..2 ur~dl .
 pflJ6ecutibiJ 6hav/J nofle -ID,)'udr wfi.J; .bvf-k> rrec;f.Jne.Jitfer~-fesit'"~
t1 ~vi~ Uu; . .:r:v, & ~v+e 8rdVI.Lietf 7al S,IAJe2d ff$Ye(:re~.&-;i4t.Appl9'l.9) ·
-rne Ctx!t+ o? Crt~ Appedlf hfid fhJ:i'; The due {J/IXef.t dour1e of--/he FUP+een-1-k
 A ~tM.d~ t'f/ rs M' tfil:f-is+iol whetrJ. Sfale COt&flive6 a.. COtWiaia11·&-~ &pr~ J
a frW. whiG£? M. ~/eifelprevr'f ~re-z.. v. Sfilte ~ s.,wt 34" 3a(gC:T~,IJpp.. 4Vf:f&U~2)
                                     j

              Lt Sc~-lfer -zu :s.w. M S9t.f(,'f~#A(111CtJr~ Ovr6+i /No) The CatJ4- t>F
 Appeds reve/Se& dJfJ(Je~ cow~ -F'WMt~ ~111e +rw CocJrf im(VOfJedtt ~t:c:f
..fhe ~ -ftJ ibrlr?JdJJa:, Ue.or6:k1 ev~ b~re iheJurq, Mil'* drco¢4va1fitte
 l1e0r6aq riM tMJ t.M~ ovf-oF-avtf5a:Jr~. Ca.&e*J:sr,:Jf-ev~~ dvtd'
 ~ vppr~iOVZ ~~ & §fate jJilJfJ«-ti/J/1 SIJ/.icif;e£ UV~f5Un!M o~-of--ovrf' .sfaie~ /Dr
fhe de11W l>f a,fJhl.t#tf~ mdlM fu&flfJ!Ye.S:54/1e S~eH!' of -~He ev~             J

           API'~ clferJ ~ le~1.fJ~uiQ;d'fiB1 .at~ ~(){ tLI} as ,J18ra:fii>4..for ~
ct;n&;ftJtes heor~ik(; a·f/EAIJ9tl/'\[s a ~~di1u"~ maz:Jebflhe-~~
wwte+e:s+'~ ar-tr0ltJr ~i'Y ,ollfy4:[(n ev~ tiJfVt>Ve-/ne-frlll« oF~~
d.S:l~~    · Aq tnfe.retA£1!/rdfJ(i~ j"P4i4e resvlfj tE ~esl:if!:'att UQ/e .hf deter fJ~ JifereJ as p~~~tue
faot-.5 a.ssert-si cvr-'* -avr-1-, :A~ ~T
                                                          T6UAJG5~·16ms        7Sn'tf

                               , C£~ FtcA:re-,
     .        I-~ C&Rnr:<:t lflkli--J. CIJ{XI oF&~~ fOr~ hK ba::vtJMai/ed
    .Jo#;e l;~~a.v;~ &tfs w/M fJtlfiiye .ad~ :£6¥ed-CJwi~~ 161 lue ~
    .5bfe:· mJl/. ICAT~Y CUr~OAl Jbfk.Ca.tvti'I_,~OI W.Mtl/Sh 5011-e 2/r;,, L,v,1:Js~_,.~~ 713SI'""
    323~.r . ABeL IJC()5IA;CtJu.rf--bfu:iMI'W.~/s .. ~Od!x.Yx: t236~,WtJ.iol5~fiM.
    -Au_~t£4, T~~ 787// ~·                                  ·

                                                 r2/)JS         StiAce/elt.f
                                                             5V~C&q CAta!C~
                                                              AfritcMi- &      ~