Court Opinion

ID: 4055072
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 06:38:02.321581+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:26:45.324264
License: Public Domain

;_. ~r_.~\ ._Av._
"`I\M
"'1""»-

\"~`..-
»-.
‘/'*~ \~.,~`
~v---’_-'-¢--»"*`.
'*\,~-. __,\1}»-~`/ . .`_
/ _~»» ~ ..
-__..,` .. _¢ _

* gg_\ qg| .@'21¢03,0+

   
   
 
 
 
 
  

1 DEM_L CL&:L\<;

6;`\@‘ 1 \/~("OU\A \'\\j\'\\\( CA`>?'(LQ"Q‘\:L 7/
P\‘LQSL Q_/¢L,j¢“']€ \BQAB°"

\/ou_»/ Q\J?¢LL;QE\\)(\‘\"J \'\\`5\\\7 Q()()YL;JQ%Q,A £\,\qe `/ _
. ~ - ¢>U_,.

OU " \<\¢\Anv~%§

C.D/_/L“§Qon A,U\C.L.

1451qu-j gm
: Y\G\\j/ bn 50»/1/7 q\ooq& 'k\(`Q/_hqm;w ,, g-
_ hot \'n)ufj ¥`\CW\A Cln§ wc\ol,gn§ go \(:\S`Oj bqt
C‘\/Q, ‘_'jLJ/’jL/'
"3,

'TF“""“K ~#W \<…<\.\\{ ,

. / ,
RECENED \N
CUURT OF CR\M\NAL APPEALS

MA¥ 14 2015

,l" l

Abe\ Asosta, Q\€¥k

 

LD\J¢_\'\ twiqu Gm… A\S_QU'\QQH gm;n
\[.O¥*\"\Q_$ U`(\\‘&

?_(p(z>\ -Fm 206"`7/3

TQ/UQLSSLQ~ C<)h>f\\{, T><.T§%%¢f

RL~_ T.,_ QL_ ,\)o. zolz>'?‘w»§z \~"<~ Q>Z,q§

T?) '|'\'\]5 Ho~<>Qm€)L£ £oq_a~T OF CRl/v\mm_ APPE/-\L§

£»00"\<2,'? ‘G<>\A)/ A(JQ\\'QQQ&; L,@\,\/S,_\| G…\'nc\?/ 6¢@1,(\ in {;Mquo\/QJ
ma:n£\§nq_c\ C_Qué'e, nvmbUQBQQ-¢L. rQ_SP,-Lc_lr§u\|\/ (gr@\\/ .anl_k
‘L¥`\\"O l~\Of`\O’\/O\$\C C»Oufjc '\/J\'\\ F\°~D\SL 9¢0\(\{; lfQ,\/l.<>_\,`i~ 0(-` AQP)|CQQJC
'!~}>'l HO‘\>LQ@°C<>¢QQ§ Wh(¢\\ +_\w\'e» mmmblo\@wlc An€b 0~$ QFP\\CCmJg.
C_\C\`\m§ \r\l\r`\*\('.\\ '\S €)umAJ_AQJ:YML \»\lou\<§ jWC§n{ folm;.
A.Qp\iccmlc C»On-{:,an£\‘on ;-5 O\' gi C\r\<§ F-foi)°z/ zubjgc£.fof.
‘l;\(\\§ @Our_£ ici (Q‘_\{\‘}\'\( b\r\¢\ )\)w\ec§\c.l;\oq.

/§F()\‘;CC\(\E COF`\&Q/\"\A- "l|;_\r`\ql; \"\L gori/dana bn £\_`Q' Bq+\" Dl~§ér.[a£
C/Y\<~`n\\jcq\ C,C>\.\r£ H'Ono»/C\\O\.n [m@\)€b(l.q\
100€&5_3 Q)QQ{J.O r{~_;nj_ QP-€\"\c.cmt C\Q‘\m@ C\\vo05 W`\`;___\n {.un$ jcyus_ \¢Jou\'é O/Y\JZ:;]<;\L G€P\\C.Q,n£ ltv
WleC.

A?Q\'\c,P)l¢C.~n'b

@

PFC/\\f 4;¥\’.\5 \~\Qr\<>ro\\o\<>, Cour‘t \O\[ ‘*'-5 P»°\JW GW=Q\‘n %u;\r\ Ar>~/qb\o,
mal-gc Jo\me,on, \w;h c.\\ c;w, (K@QWCE,.

A?P\;C.oml; Pm\i _);\n;e Honwc.\o`\¢_ COu/{: c\\lo'\.f C¢pp\l.cc~nl~_£o _
?rgcsz,©é ' leCQ/lc¢\ ché_,.£hqt 'hc
Ffo\/Qn\m\\ sL'n£_H<,\L \m'm {L\§L.\`~. '_T.¥ 60 jmn+,LA, Qp\o\fom£
,\\I;“ P(OCM‘,A m C_¥\ rone\{oj\cq\\\/ oy¢§w.

(\jRGL/\QO 009_,; AFP\\CC\GJC Com\o\Q;n op Pfo%sz_c.u&w m'l§gongud:
WHMUS, opp\{Cont \'J¢\€> C\f/Q,§J;Q_A @r {;\w»` 0;£%59~/\33¢<1\/¢.£“§
Ko\)b<).{\l \,d'\‘=\-\ q ¢§,Q_,q.§\\[ \.JQ__C~QOO, 00 mck/dm 24" ?.olZ,hovJo.»/Q/(
»i:)n<_z_r»_ \.\m§ no wa,o§)on rum/w QJ< fc\ru. ,2_01?_ O\?€\;Cc\nl; t .\r\;v]a,nl ,(_RR \/°l‘ 5/ pc‘jlq‘{,Ll‘na_.l-?.B)(

(KR \/`o\. 15/}9<39¢_¢{5/14'0¢|-"!)} E)Q_Q_ (EX“\B\T'$ #2,3,4,5).

`A{)()\\°Y 'D;'@C<>\/wy Ov-AW on Jul~jZO/.Zv/z
m 900$ §ml}\ fQ€SALS£;n§ *Un@ 9&<;,1:@ fo 'Eu/r§ ovw Om\/) Cm=l\ cdi
mqjc,O.)/{C\\ Q\/‘\<\MQL 1110 £hL Q\°'p°/\%&. How.°.\/w, ~/;\qL SJ=‘JH"L~ l~urm_A
O\/Lv C\Ff>\iaom£ j;r\£v\ml K°\m\o_w\~i G:H\AIL~IQJ, J=\m.L fbi-_q£°~ 1[`€4`\\ 153 -l:-_o l:~$\oec_|o§,m_l é\'w` 1140 7- 935

hw<¥gv_~`] in C\~,mp\'\¢m@»` with w Oi’bco\wj O-W~ ”TF\U "9
no mol:_\\dn erqL;nj J;}»w_ §-é_q{& [9“??(1_55‘3{\¢19_ [Co 2 66 hQnAJUHB.
:W\UL 36 _ no l SQQ‘P/¢w§i`\mj ho`o\f\.nj 00 rq;;°»,» '£`-\’\9~)“4¢3 "'1\’\€\](. \G\\)\J' 9~4~\¥;)¢€.‘;\"

@

§af\°"' , ,
mm)c' " fosva 0\ \,J'm»gon but \'m_ \,(pq§m IE»%/ L».mq. lo), '

'\'Y\\"z \,Jc,r, 0` C\LC¢_,?L-_l'on op }:_\m`_ bur\/ . [FACT] lC\\AJ M$orc_o_r_n-f

Q,n\l; ro`€@\zwu§ 0\ l:Co z 55 \Un&j\m] @`[SOSW\] fe not o c\m(O¢m;ns>_f \A}:£\'\ -l:\'\o., AMS£;¢'\ FO\.\C_Q` DQ»(){:.

['_FAQ.“T'I Pf)|im.. fv.»€ork'e o\/ »L\nL OYQC-Q»r ~EQK\”G§ J-'-\”\°~ SLQnA-, how Q.\/e.f, -f:<:,g£’j
0(:~?:°::4:<\_'::<'43: v-/=\'\s¢ PfoSLQ:» l:mf 0\£1'::~1:`\\/ or HQ.¢j\\°§M-l-_\\) 5:4(>?{2,“5521~
A§L`c<:]\‘§@_ v <§_\5@\0?9`, o_d\. meQXLG/Q£OEHQ,
&. \% (9~\1 u§\b\L whom ‘~>°-°' (~)w€.\< Ac§)) €).’?_ 55 HA>\D 6\4~:§ wQSI:SHPPKESS:).
‘WE@EF)KE/ 4:\'10.# 54+¥1 D]SJ;r;c'\’ I»\on.` mo)c£ ~)O‘NWSOO %Q£ gm§\'n§ 1`5
m wmc /\pp\\wx: pr@\/'.M win Q~C EPA 1=`*»-‘54*\<¢»\@+-

_\T`\L EJ&CH~Q__ C\\\Lj<;§ ‘J=\"IQ_ ffc-52 63 H'ANO Gu'\); in ibt Go\l£.rnmo.r~ib
[:cnon<-rme~{§ lhw»_~%m/ lam CC<>z.B€>/M~o@u~j was mqlc \/. 'Dmel<@/ 640

M.‘”a‘ §p(o%, (0’1‘5 "”I'ho_ Courl':‘ obesw\/Q_A Lh<;\*c OHL Cc~n hw&|\?l be_
C,on£`\<§ <§Q»n{<).é alma Frq(,v.e$j.
Af?\{£on-`k re.q\\mj<). onc\ incorpka {-j»m_ FAQT A@WE:Q

@

6(<0!&|¢\\£)."¥:»\}0; T({Ch\ [LOunE)sz.\ ;Q:\;,_A 4}_-__0 COQ<§MC{: 0 §D_(m\
Av\~°»’C-C>\/‘L"(\/ 0; £\'w_ \: unc§~\ec_\@.§s>.éj mqtg/`\q\ Q_.\J{AUCL_
WL ()fOS.Q_C.\.\ J:,;Or\ l;°~r\<§QJ/.Q.A [\<\mb)l)/\~/ @;éé,m/mqn'j%£qbz,/;:mt
""\D\~Io_.\/Q,f/ t\F\Q,. SI::Q£L,mQ,nJ: \:JQ§ \'n [`_F/§C“|.”] 552/menu tx n
HWL ):C_O ’Z. 63 HAND&M¢\):§° ’\"r\q\ CJDun€)Q.\ Hm\'sz.§ 1';\><‘<.00<§;;¢ C\
£GHY\Q\ A.\SC@\/o./\/ \,JQS C\o.g<'.\°./mm‘*‘*'» \ "mm- mon
'\/. mowj@on/ mm u.e. ?>o><;,"'T\n_Q_ S_v¢pf»-mQ/C‘wrg conclan
h°\*\|Q-‘\{Slf) J:HC\{: 0{:[:0¢09_.\/ ’5 ~FQ'\\u,/Q,”};O O\O'£"C‘J\"‘ C\'%C'°\/°";`/ inch
H'\Q- Q_\l;<=\.Q/nc»_ Cc)u\é no+. bs»~ R.X(J\C\\.QQ.A`Q'B O\‘ fLQ%On:§/(°;¥ law-
Q~z`\@ Al<‘\@:w, but r@¢\w¢§ Q " @#=Q/Hms '~J“‘°f:*j ‘
md P\QQLA \J\@ women OQJ'C%’\<§»~ §§ w PWQ\\"§
5'*0 nc\\ mo(m%¢ %("C_K\Cmé V»¢ \Alq§\'\\nj£°f\, LHLp U.€) » (a%(lq@ll/),

€~(o;!b§'

°GKOW\¥O "'\"HRE]`::THQ\ Co\m@@.\ §;I\Q_Q\ he C¥~\q¥\@/@on (Re \/0\. 11 quL 1351 ),{m/ 10, ;e,.~s \/Wnonr§ Ann`¢[i@,(_ gm Qm<;. 561 , pro%g.¢.u%:of
fb?' YQ'BPOGSL < RR \/0\¢ ’Z/ quq, (%|(_ L;nL 7..0» Q.‘z>-"TF\Q.-|:;f~\<;[

CCWFJ< cadc $m<§}nj '\5 'm u/'@_r. T+_ '\6 m ):'FAQ~T`B §°U"’°\(m“
-l;\u ro_Cor<§.

`GRQW\!'Q YB\°AQ'_ '”['-r'\al Co`\m@e\ §¢`I\L<\»b.> O\c)jo~CJ<» ¢=O Om unqwéhor
l?.Q_<§ '\/ UA\C:E Qn<§ \/O\<§ ._)\,\Q\c') L.m<;,(~r&,, AnA'.[;\/\o`_,unqu_é}-\O»(;,z,a.<=\»

bw& _ ll . ,4( w b ¢
P QX\Q~L: \,\\C\© 5{-_<;\€.\(0`_$ Or\ 1339 O.c Q QHQ`/ Con\[\,t~\'\.€>n(l€@ \/0[».5
q§xz, OFI' Llno._ l(o- 25)/_Lij‘L q%, L;no, I~ 2.5)¢ d

A()Pl man \,\|‘¢H S\no\,\{ [ FACTS`:§ £hc\'l: \'M. \M_, 4:_»/;0\\ C;§u-r¥:
pack p\n'<§omj Om& C.onC\\AS“XOn 45 in Q»\/ror. /-\P?\'\cc..n£
\9“<\\/ 4;\('\0\£ Jc_\r\'\z \Ao~o¢m@)/E £o»\m' uSE:C*T FO\»JERTO
ADN\!N\S`TEK JuS'TlCE I¢\I ACCC>@OANC£ \m~rH THE LAV`/»¢.

Ano\)/E)l§

[VA¢.TJ court L\»\WL: m am I;JM\`/J (M.\/o\-z, qu»
'|W'l, L.;DL [p-’Z_W)( QO¢§Q. lz‘b, L{na, \‘25)»
[ mch SLQ’¢Q A»fjumm-l~. : <`Rf< \/<>\~ 3/ VQJ°- ‘5"/ LF"°~"*'")
(qua. l"')'q, L‘\na, ll"l`o\).“"l'hc. pro sgq_cu£§r @FLC.`\$FCQ\\)/ expoqu
Of\ Q F\.(Q_<‘wrf\.”
]: FA('.T] \)ur\/ \/UC§`\QL; (`RK \/<>l~ '5/ FQJ_Q. 111>3, Lin@ 6-9_1»)`

`-r"lQ_-» ju(\/ \/UA.\C_E_ 30 no_l:_ ,Q_X?(R_SS p\’{LQ{m D( bb gun/.
\'\O\~lv_\/u, \#&: w‘ou\¢\ bo__r\or\§m€;\u<'w_$ l:o bz_ {Fu.Q/¢
5

 

f FA-QT§ Ju%mwr oF me wm z Qnafnj on AM.A\Y WWM
__l,,\/./»-A/ / »`\o\r~l' ¢L.\/SLY, Lh;f:) mwn§"l\/o/\/'AFFMCA@LE il

`T`GQ_ ‘):.W\C\\ Lourt $'\<§ 004: c\éérz,‘b§ %;\1)1.59~ c\\\ugq£:o\,on§
bQ-CC\\'\€?Q- "'=}11.59~ Q\\L§Qjc:ion§ our¢_./IF/\C"Fc.vj ‘€Guna "\n th€/

[ %TA’FEMENT OF FAQ-»r§j.g,umporlc by l Ex‘H\.€)lT"§j ton/`

U~.e Lvlq\ CDWJC Q,b¢m kohn COQC\M€,{O,¢ ""Dp/\m;p" IJQbm§
'(°~A`l€§: bo§s>`$ 00 BF\L L:y\sz_<§ On '(Q,q‘_`po\n`\f`lfj
C‘U"‘ é. 5°“"\<\ <\L£Ur\’\'mr l;h¢, O(I§USL Os`;
A(§C}YQ\/QJCL§ R.o\on.\/\/ \`O\/ \/\€JSL, Qq§ F~>(Y;\`>;-‘élbon 0»§ q §Q_q§\\j wo_;.\Oon/
hO\'\¥L\l°~Y \f`\s>`..\l~lq§ »€>unw\vl Inevéruc.é_o»m 0$€'<111€>9`.01¢¥\¢¢/ J:Y\_c\é Gn<\ E`)Uon'rJC -\\r\€, C\\\o.l»°S C‘°'”'

AQ?V\CO*\J(, O\ l:EQLh 9.<1 f po \|C,i RE PO(ZT§J l' E\A;[j.;;,;r::~'fj [

['T(Q AL_ Q\AA R 625 70 cme Ju@-zj, E MD|.QT mL/~TJ 6103
]; \/~'£@Otc“fj . `

"_/9 AFF\frmo/E\‘.\m, ~Q'nc\\unj Mpm§§ 14 fn é\w<>~» BLAS mmjc,'h°.\*_"_
°"W/ Qg>p\f¢m£ mg was gum-q Oc szc,m\/mambb@
'-C"°A:§Q»n¥< 149‘1?1§ 5_5/ s
J:¥`];% 15 §'Q'M,.: Un,<;°n§jc°`qu‘or\a_@ Q\u§ P(O<;L§§/\,Jhg/Q,QS/c¢f’ph
CQG£ mule S»J\¢'L 50 C<»\su\é. Oojc \RS"S)QG\\!L ‘m€»‘_mt/
p°l\\£\£° 5£€»€,1_" ‘,-..,A(?p,|l'ao.n{ C»¢n&m& pa mun 0 P

C§(flggt,_)")g§Lud Omléél,o¢.)"

or )MA].<;IQO ;umw" J:h 1“5 mt O~
C\W"L€QQQW:Q¢/qr"? m nqlcwrb. %»_L Poe \/¢ §',LQE,L/ fn POQ_, ffc
Q\\°-§LC§)'\»\(\;| Pom_. \Aqg -(»`\3\,\(\§ gulley I\’\Q\chz,r, ,_L_\qg_,, jq<\§. mq.~n‘Y
.9`)( fmb€w_§ N/A . A opm g Pm gunc, \~|Q§ Propw bLQQuS_::` \nc\lc&"\
.. m°$r\jc Q'l\°~jq<\(junj. \d\wum§)_ 'm\{ ;T,nArc%mch ql[m§L]:F,(Lm/m 0(

65 hcm<§ju,,\):§ ` NuNC, ()(O .TUNL CCM,` OO»&'..bL, u§o.c\ é¢§(>u'lc \/J)naj’
‘l:h.°~ Cr>\»br"\' ~1:,¥\‘\0\-('_. 5\’\0ulé hq\/Q,. ha QPUV' m jc.xrw~» () (°Q‘U` \"`)(35¢

‘ ____ ~:¢CC’-;\)‘{`.¢E /W
KEQN €S'T€p RELLC/F AS @/E®u~'<;>`T ~1,~) /JAFSGAS C°@FU$ ~H~’ RE F°

CA%€- 20 ¢?,» 70°1-'»€‘2' wl<~>@é?~l%v&-~ '

\\