Court Opinion

ID: 4040676
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:36:08.770986+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:46:12.776680
License: Public Domain

/W/^VjZtMlA^f     i

                                          FEB 17 2015

                                           ^P, Clark

COURT OF C                          /f^f/^VhMtJfg^L
      FEB 17 2015

   AmJL                             m^Je//Wc/^

             fatty 6 M^MfoJ /U^#k/-/£As/%&&e&

                                                 ^y
-i&vrl /jiAsist Zee/'S-/ok&s l/S SivfrSk&dtJ' 3r£^
ll^YyZ^/M?6^ Af7^ folda.6 fr/eMUt,

fates* "fUs'&dO&tS&eJ Oddd/St kfafr/ZAifa).
 .   .   _..' /hJrhltou foe/Md 7^/ // yvdt

/(-/t~yl?nz^l\cy 17/7,1),.). U ^   xr,

•^NLy/AaricW f^ A4?J 7ye(a/ / s a/&U
/dd2adfdA^Jd' d&d£&d±
 4.3 dzAAAW &»*,»*

~MjA1 m^e/AyJ «yds ASTA%3ed/ddUJ
/hAT/^dAhfA ddf€A (/5 AA^. dtfAA>^A)
^ufid^/vAfrA! /dleddy dWfAe^&^/dtAd
&/WWce/ AAcf deddd^ddML7d^sdd&d
tM>Al /kAntfSdz^dddceAAd/oJtdj d^yd**/
 "iwidc%A. fleJei\teA AAxfeAjteA jdj^fe**dAs* yL

SUA Ma/_ fowjAHtsd ™ (-e^cd /A AifiaJ fcA&

yPd^A^d^f^ ^Jd! ^dAdd^a*/&/^d
&dW?fe/f-iJt, ?W oAded &e4fofeya£-~
^SlA-fid/d-^ ,Ah/potTeJ /Avffatedddd/
-fiA&loL /Id Arf/ZAtfeyiA AtfaeAl UeU ^d&yi^^dyvu
AHdd ChiAd aIo&S /WdAw^Afafl*42fl& d
<^/kAT A^/hAfcn*.) d/L/hAlA>?iJ AAsAA ^/d StdAsfc^

(dkoJ zdfnAd yWAdtd^ AfydUCGcAldd&d yf-
AttAtAd MA/y^AyVQATsVyd ^Wj,/7^/i, /
/Mfodd AAA^y* $A&J Mdy bd//%AoiiddA^ust'
6MAt Add A~-/dvJ idd Adddvdvdu^d
dAAA hxAAAtVtJJtoWvd^/dfdAkd&yA/tA
       . . . . . -. /,•-/-•-//• &Ahdkj7d*\
^^A^^^AA/dA'd'/liAA^/hed)
    (HAUAdSe/ Ah /d dji/AdAe^Sdd^A
fod^lA 7%yd) ddcd^A ^ATdAdd tddAZ £ddy)
fmAidA/v^QflyfM&dl tfteteedrsiA Ui ir^dy/M
il^fAAtoL) 6M1A6 AhAAAJ TrddW/W&Uefif-
  «     -jU/foteJ d id dojdfod AW^At^A
 ew«™r duA/d dun fteb uddyy -A*/
Addd/tfAy deA Slide/ AASc/dddfAbu/izrAtf
A6d,e^y Ao A', cUy4A6 Ado/CnedAwAhyV^cJ
dd^&a^^f^d*d^duvi'
3 V0l A ^(W f^^dwJdddAyl-,,,i*A
                                                '-^y

                                       AAr /A

 7fe /yJ-d&A /%%T<^ €?dd^'(yddA ydd/

 fo/fadj^d/>yAdd> dbxed/hS/d/flA&ote/
-fa AeAec/es'Ah drtd&v;-/%/&w7' -Ae/AZoogtidaf *U
oldeteKiJid dU/ ledd S'uddciml^ >d> AceuJ -A^u
^i/ideAce/ JyVde/ /dhtAv>sf'Ad<^/e/ d id>A
ideAb A?f rydyd d?dd'A^Sc*wdA^^vd„
 OleAm. £ Aft- h%/L M-d I/dmAjddWdA

                                 U3i.   LzB.
TdiMdMjA^                    lows
A&ffeJ'Ja>A£tSAfegdfa   ^                               'y&ttiA
                                  ' '~%A%ALy™/~>
    //A/y/P^y

fv/ly le/H#A-h file/&?, AA**) A^^y^d/yycAAj.rcdA^
          i /tdfae^/friyw-A^/ede^Tcy^^^-A^^ddd
Qrr&lJ^AA^A],9^AAd/7Y£ A^yd/?d<.c ^
   {*JHfc\(ta, Yd) JAy^d^a^A'^da^tfAides *A^z&ioeAs
^£X$dL^,dd,AA.Aa) r(U^mdm^
                                                  ^.cy/d,//,/^

                            (P          /Wd&wd^AAr%^
            (".0utd'/y dddl^w/ld APd>A/c
  'fre,': FAmPj/-£e>Ar aU>as^s 7Ta>, a, #wm6

                                    AD -A/o^t - AT

      AMfA/dd MAfcd d/J> /#kteA d, /T/rdrftei*/7
      A^ydA/Pd /M,6L»,firf /J ddrd ?/?, //

 r-    -dl^ df^dlad't:djarfs/d-/AL). x6\-01 ^J

 MmjA AeA/uesrA>A A/m/AeddbuAfed d AtdAU^y-ddA
•AC /to /yjVOCp/cey A> /^/^d^9zdd#//d&nei/c-JZ
 7^/^dc, /d/2dd//^A^yH^cddzdAdd-AtddZdd

&dMd^WSkl^±dd
                                                  ZW'-dCeA
^Adr^^,^/md<; uAyAeAsdMslgj-^.Lt
                            -/-
d PJsJAO J -- 3o.2. AA/yd AJsy^R. I§L dv /A%fpwd
issues ddTdds od£#&d /d JZjPAza.Kd
fi'AkiA'sf OwnyhyMd &d' MGuyed?> /%byr? Adass S/Ad3
 mr;38,A (d drt & d&d/cd £/&ed/d £ddz..%
de&SdvdA/ndsd 70 AfGd /*A £*kL22A£ dtus,               y

•iltidd Apu/id d fata 3®' r dA~d»e/d ddddted
/d aLIsJ XRd„ 6) ujdi d?li>/l0djd> &(7k^7Jy»ey/?/€
Attodfidr/?Afj#A /d %Jj>s/o. *//<£) dp /ton*i*fJ*rr/
iSiAtfJl#hed /d /LL,3A.y fie disdddd>&'d
    'ft Ad AH/ /ffif
t^lf,/^^ ^d^/ddtesA^^Av t/Jiict
                                                37-3 ^d
                       W2J

1^Z/£d^X£§W^d
        t £?FddAtAS- Att^dfifeddot ddy(d^A%^y
       ^l£ey Ui/ded Jdfes cCed/douAd /A^dd^A.
Z9-X #-S. titt* #3* cd/d:/?/¥•> 9 Z dd.ddd,
        :atf*Wl/W£oy>AA^/UdAA^ A^WyjL*7Ay,F^
  ,Wdhbdes Ah^Tdddd/h/h/d^-7^^y^Sdl
Afafynr ^^m^er%^/d/i^fisddWc^y^dz^sd
-.. '/dJsyP^y/9S
&U  AiJd^dm>yd yft ^46dfj
                     A^£AAA. ,„„ sKsr,,
                             wd-dyrrjdd>y/d
Aid dffwd Ate; d/AyMSA&ddA -^fiUtd-do
              Mfedjrfeyrusted j uuoh /*/'/&t7Alt«gi
              •fodfy ey Mel UTtysSeS'. A PdFoAde&AJcey '
(Agcowed eJdd^dmmd/mics-d-AA'6                                 _
&dd»j^d^^ddddd
idd'ji'/Ad**'/^e/k'0&^^d?%A%%k
LjkfofM/cJd* ^^dMZ?d^A/^£
'^^mdddriW^^
uiUaI
                        A"~   iy'*?i //\_ 0LS£yyVC&( /)CALd   l^y

                   -3                 ^Msmis
AouAJ.sd cJiXLaa. ^hd/he4ds defiedy^/^Ad/fcdy&dd
uLeA Udfmkd do JeoTdv dAeAl/sd^f/
        A/fa/jA/todt&id Bdm^&us aA&fry;
    lv(Y^ddkMAA/, kMv\edpddd^^Adcdyftdh*si
DouAleyOeod/MOd AAJy/Adrd/eddo AdJhcTAftdbsnA
ddAddldL (diAAAi'e/ hJ0wd d /ydiyV5t7dAA& dAedd/did/A^ *d
               A>/// ttd€4/ec^ &AAeyitey^ dddtfed
               ihey/ /AdiA!A<7WuiAf7(& ^ / W ^ ^ W ^ ^ ^ ^
   ,dw> A \^#^(^™ ^^*rt/tfaA^^j
   de/A^A ;A^ecfy^A?frdAWx
 1< ?™"rL dd"^ dtyft* ^"idd/s-ak&ttoe.
 td^dist M Ao Atddd d^de/mXtoeZ/sruey-
 Id dUy APAAryrfA,, I/fa*6e^dtej5wh>„
 dddd/d)'ddd'd , '^-('^jrtp ifo id-AAyA- /mm), lUySuF/i^e¥cdld
    4/icm/Cd Skcxdd/ttrdtbes /WhSudd d<^/UJdt.ydd
             dffc n*A(\;ui- M</yd do AAld&yAT&Aqddtd d^oSeA
AWtfe/lS d£ /Wyi/dv A&Atea)', /did'CbuAJ&ddtfddk.
yrdd^d^dduA^^jrdodtdLS d&^d^eyJy&diri-
d a&Aieddi4j &^isldTdfA\
S~Mfes ddfeynfAAbiiJyFAlWA/d^
M\M/'A/y^nAledddd^d)d^Awd/% AdyUf-A/y/^cf-jwd^c^ I
          ZU/'AAddl ad ApdSf&yAZTuddeAt/doF
                                             ^dd&y
         d*d&
   Leyd3.L> do £&Ae/dc/AlA/c
/FAZdkds&r#AA^
                        Atedhc

                                      dd/vdyldfarcey

u»M   y^^i-^jmAud^Add^ydA^J^
dM'courts*'AAtJdA^ 6^^%^/^
ddaL lAO«\d l/We/AyAc/iAdsrddl^A^Jy^AAkJSc^,
/auddht cfFdedAAzJ sWLdeAce/) dA^A^WJAddAwd
eMx?/V /fe>/Ufl(d feSuHzddyu'AFcAMsioAeddFosvey
(ajAS /tedz^ldL/ddtfteifce/y oeAA^WdzAeZ/dsACisy
•JUddl*K AfeF KAfDusA do AldMA
dhddyheA&Fdfa^AaJ dddylAi
eAed d^MAdy^di^e)^ddiddtLZ&/c&/> /owjT
^&/ AWdA&fd- tid&d i&iddcedoA/A&cjfe- dAUFAAyZey
/hAhlMd'AYTdtdAA^A?F,/h /fe, e/lAAAZA
                         WAZAZAteJApsU

/WAiAST A-ihiiM2diyhfe ^FddFce, -> Sec^uS^y'£AAtf
 A^Aad ddto A>-fme/wddd%$dd/dded/ddid
deAkACey/) Aid /iladda,y/AoiyJ,31ctimAeAkMrs,
day CdAAMdidddA'. ol <£& yfA^fFMedcdeVCey &o
diolAftd dfAnyisF/ld A/UedSL Ad&eSFA/dd/ddAS
FewkeA .od(o~((*,~aoo^ ^yrdA^s d&uydt&d/dt7 y?d
A£~W0c4d?QAjdadd6 4^d dkddb /m6 /ALj/o dfa4«ZAc.
              TidTheAt~y>FA/&*aAJt?d JUsde^ dc4^scy
fn/de/ dddyJiSt&J f> -            y^ddd) oF
AAA/Fw&Am <2£ AAii,
dfn die/ Addd/Addd •             oVtf&AAMAd/^aydoj
Undid did dcyi>t/ds          .               _
 ds do. dtd/dd tody /ds Apndjd/jA/TW^d&^y
/WsAdd eA^dyt yyA^iyddd AdddU d&AAZtdr
    dlddAAu-tedi ^dde/dZdAdedydAFAyfr /Li
     dd diddic/d /dAdd Artd^dAddAdl
dfdfi edf&eSSioO fF dddccd' dcdL^JdVcdd
cAkdtey AA dd2oyi, Aa?s ZdzuAed'yAdAdeZ yd
                     -s-
Codd^/f-'ddd^cdy tikdleZy^dATAdzd^dd^5
aFd^dSddr/Udde4lkdidf- ds /yvfej A#6
£/l iy&hdd%%//A%m/hdd&g^ AAi^d^A ZdZ
td^ftj, .dd Addld/ldd editedd^di^A -A&
Spdjhb ddAWdz%o$edje ___
AnA d&d AyAYiydTdddAZ da%&>dAd^A^Addd
FfeeAedd^ d fddyylddAFiAdi) 6JM A/Bu)
                        d-dAhS^iuSeAd/df /%eed
Al^teyedeJ FldA^dyZcd'> l/> ke/ld/mdAA^ZiA..„
do ddiF&drfeAdAd' dudd d/% dks&t^d^&vdwc         e uUdJd^AAKMX^d^
deyduAdL Fp,&^6d6ed/,
dl^^/KCASedMS sv&Td&A?,            ,w ,_     _,,
r£dnd **d AdAleJ dAey AeddAFj^ y^yFmkJo ddd)

 A\u-i -      -a^aZddldicAfy d dldddyfrt^ud?^
AdL -dlwAl ff teas d^d UjdAAoiAjd^yeSi
^ VMS*.

.^ <%dudt/A /yi?Ahedcc?-svdo.
a}A/yd Jdwd ^'^^/7m>KFi^/d^m&ddFy'AA^/MlAit^
                                       ^^/d^aff
       Wt Am
   q/l cy£tAiiA)ixi Hisfa&& Aff&ls /fctfoL, 1&d/jvAfitaJ AdF /Lls>d

8*1?/fy llj Id (A W /J&wfi1j.                              ~^^

                                                       ^dflt/2y^