Court Opinion

ID: 4073914
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 04:28:39.445988+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:58.614687
License: Public Domain

FILED IN
                                                                                  'STCOURT OF APPEALS
                                f_ ftV*c\ c£ W^Pr\fi "W AW                             HOUSTON. TEXAS

                        W^ l^\s,\c'\f.\ c£ "\>*(v* fl\ \WsVfrf\                    NOV 2 0 2015
                                                                                 CHRISTOPHER^,^
                                                                               CLERK

           \kl¥vVTOW 90f^9MA?vfr Tfr VAKY\rV AcAeA \W™Wr V^amS8

      To\f\\ rAVir^: \Slik3lisWi: (WA: d \W\s C.Qim\\j

 ^VAu^s, 0uAfc5it6c/if»ftg. iflu> •k.^kftio 4-LlV 4Ws £WfV W jnWidrion auer -rims appeal.
                                 is rliifl. hVilbiV (Mfl'p flrTfie bt jfle. fla-fie*..

Ort Hflr/^ ^OftK^app^/UI-Ry/? fatWThfMnthtl^
 police repots aaA &4rU^ rg-Uv//}ft-\- Qtid<A££ -App^i</?n-f-P. 1^/1 w faabgas odkt ^ U\e, 167 -Ha
"DivlrMe.-rfftii<4h9 JWrts ftomftii y^kif^ relief irAiyi tmmluhWij rtnd Illegal rffvfftftn-l- AT Ills

 \V± WiiS tS^W'Al*^ AftA^l/mA.l /^WaIaVr 4W. difeii tesul-t- ftf x/afcl ju/Hginfl&ivh U\>n\$

                                                                                                      \t£l»
(jfl Kprtl llpilffl-.'nuft Lau.p1 issued an apinioA nffiprti^Tn^Vft^Jud^....,^^--.^.^^^^-
by W\£. llLyHn "bis^fici CauA i&itiftoirir deAcrmmma, °if -r^e. \1U 4h bu-rricT CbuA in fact
|f\&A suV^e-cfr~W(AW^\v<vsAicAvo<\ 6(\A sWiAl% T& aiij'uAaoig, Tfle £flsi.» Th£rg.Qf£ NJ6
miAs and em/W/ tn 4"h& rtcbrd sWumoq 4Wi& \Ww\$ u>a> v»\a4e.% Tlv/dWe^tn^ tokAb
fo Lsitict £.r>nf4 fi/>JbgA t^ttiiftiA jSukajkeirjfHaM^g uiria/iift-HiNtt \t\.enr)n &tJfaeS£ gfiiitefl.

                                                                                               te£_

\& M6\A ?)                                       J

o\isV\ \waoA v^QA f.tt<t\wv\WeA SckeW&tf ^cye. ^syr^pse. 6\ flWewoWv^ \& procure, sub-

TrcvuA mas^uAWtfeA Wife, CcaiA's 6p\mpr\ mSkWogAe mbCpjme^WtteA moxA
JuAynfofrfe-

 l\ppe\\a<\V sV&\e£ ftflftMX \V\q\ V&\ft\ fta^gjcAr \^Wy«^ CASfcAa^, .
\M\V\ <vp*or be. OjinA gtxf^iA W %(nq\ jS We. (Leu A Xoc.WA SQ^\gjcv\ -ffyqWf^^uvvs-

Cci(\ <mA AiiftV^y AS Vtr>q\- p&<s,V /yvr>MveJE\BOS vi \W.^uAo^pote genderA V>\i \V>e^
VMfA ^t&Vr\'gA r^vA.<V Q.oA \\t\g, QSXVftywiV^ rs^yf\v^A bX WW d&u«>\ U^e*^ Cf\\f^_V \|QV<\-

H^pf»UAr>V t<\ ca\<3>v<v^ W>vq> \^^>u£, ar>A rr\f> <>dV W. prg.c\uAgA ^rom A&\c\^ ^t>.

                                                                                             SAL
 CvAl/> 4dftr^4r^ hb\A -f^fl-t" steady QS /l nj>n\pr><*(\\: oft ^iKj'gd--tY^grjucisA\rAit>n)pr4r\ ncfr
t>fc \jJ£Hue/{ ir\ -^is tasp Ar a/w a-fW fllsg. /?n/j may he. cvuse/1 w 4-Ug. ws-i- 4nm^_ ftn appeaJ
by -Wpp pflc4lM fir ky-U)P &&dvjLLl£*as EmpUymgrvl- f/smm'ft \j. Xfyfrfrnfl-horml Llniftn rif
f jgr.j ftft/JlftftfvJ MAdfl.W6rkgys,Uc./ll Uman No. 183 , [{/.STp*. (35" A<T3 S^\.&A 35a,&T^
Cw/XSakjegj fnf,fkr juasAichofr <S an tssue tiici nruy be CAiaeJi tq^ -Wit Tir.sl Time. ftA Appeal/
iVfflfly^.ki uWmrAky-Hip patAigsJi Sgg /?Uft RfSUTg^.KlT^eA^t>)ftr«TUtyirHrilK fill,
&on»*ier\t £ G«iaa).ld.                                               ^_

  ByopeiWfc lhas tyus ri^lnV /esinW i»4 Ihe. peiri^&A tW uMJt o£ Uctas corpus sgekudg Sfelttf
 ^ri)tA •Hx^&f- V/fa\A ^uAa^aV Qg, \Vg fe/LP>cA W\A\ ftV\ma

  iQQclWA
   ff     sbAdS T^/il.'Hftk l^m4 ^mro'i-rl^ll /i4urvAQ.w\^f\\a|^y^f |^lv./x if re/vie
  ftp'tft<r>r> afflr/niAg 4iy V/m/A jud^rmrti of 4lr)P_ \1L 46 *hkfade4 £aa<4: This ^oiirf dt/Ji yipf
 i-ftflutV/. dr>/4 frm*^ -fUe, ite/ior/1 aa<\ (AeAzdHMne. tak&AtC stihitsJt -MA^tor^\ueisA\cAt*/\ WGS

/if^ifiyii^ -Hog. Opi/4 ju^ivkfa!" afi'kg. iQL4i\ 7^i^fr^4 ^au«4 rTtM<; tlauftfr A\A ryvV injury. <Lt\A

  UiSif&ni: AhToiAss'o o? bus. V.Tex. K\c CbrvVrsl fcA, ^pr&AKdn c>f*pian \s%ixfcA id a cn&e

 Se^ E4W vj.Vv\o^-V,A(o% U.S. 1^,151,10*4 S^^B^Sj^AM*^ LJ^LlA 55(,-(.W^.TgxQa

                                                                                             2>£L>
 WrtWifr V>inAvix$ %e, pa.Aves.XA.)

vV>iW«>\W-<gfftCf\ oS^cm^i^eiy arA fwrKvVusweAy aWsvAS 4WA frW CL6u<4 rg.rsAg-f^3 frV><

ra rycA«»A A<^ •Va(NAoLHv>c\froA.) 5a/L also NlLJ V//»fIc Iinde.ft.Aflift's C.Q. V. S^g^Tl,, 333 S.L\.^j(
                            Uift<^4y>fl-f laak a4? AppallA^ju<i^>H'r>A *a fWiflroeax-al grrnc n»\ii^a
 In^rau.w infrgriYte/ii/iiy. flourf I/ft»kMyirt«i\cfr'»ftft. \K)tHv iumAygfrvcvviy *WftSo<4 Tu^Aa-

•tdc cxicx* u>'i^r>&u.\ ca^Avx^-v^ a, <y o\<? ca> \e>< Wfon ex<-o \9 -Woe cfto^ \?> oc& ftfese/v/eAJ

m<H^A AW^/>£\\VwV UiftSVyllA ii^AVifrW. V*v\A gpuAlASl V\\"^v&V\'<l>V Cf^A <£ lU*vtS

 csW>\a ,AWm\c^ AW frWAvcvy qcnA r^^&^r esi\&*s\Cf, ^eAvrvpjA AW ^vic\^A\cA^a\ iflfiyry
-VVyA frW SenWrAr^ (*ft^\ eR \W, Wlg&^\sW.A(W<A- ^ Wa<y\«x CWvAy <\MpA vaMWA
  SuV^^-tM^r j^<v*Aiickvofv f\(\A ^WA^vaiva f\oA g^V/^WWA AW-f^f- ^<nr\e^uy^i/f>iA
^u^yxmfrs To iaWcVa AV>\<; £y<^V C&ix<\ A t^ypeids g\\\<vyy-a ^\r> &hse,f>r.l CX\

 \ W U\iAy.^Kr»fAv|\&\ftDn e£AYvl V^lfrWfrv^AncA tou<\ C&waiSreA ^ur>Aarr>eriVo\ €{
QC\A aWs^oH Aft-V-fcWo V>^ x^ofr VftbW^-VpfrW yoWAvr^s $\ kppe.yA&.^Vs VyfJoeas claims
"W AeAe^Xtt\cviV&fs c£\ftr**ui<u>Ai> *&£ " sJc^OLh <vsa.^c<?.^ A^A SXVsV Vj^'vVVx Yc%pgr3 Ao-Wc
 VuA^vpAs- xW^vvA^ft. svm^Vvj ^g^vxwfcA Vy\rxV VW ^M^re^y \j.^i^\{<ng\ aoA ^c»V ^v^ \1U*V>

          S\X£>ACu\Co>Av<\%. VVw^ Cj>>uj\ AvA A^(\€,\lgy^ fit^tf^. VWsa. ^v\n(\/^ ^W-rsp\(N\r>A<ft^
           \\&.^V<> ^AAc^\gj>\<^ v^^fg-V\t\o\ V->Qsg^V orv'A!s opvmor^ ^tU^fi^vj^n u\ V^^^

                           ,                                                                    A£U
  IVAS   bpvnvLvrA \x>&% tss udA   K(                   Ilits £Wj fx)& Ttuiei^ teas &
 \b se/. rP Apoellfinfs hfilagfi-s clow> raises -M& (Ssusg df suiajpxf m*^ jurrsrficl/ft^,
 U 4 i A £53ifa T^sfrn.,1 IW                                  Altai Kfaf cu\a GhiAicd. lis

This LWi" rifls akx tigW&nfr Ajjy Ifr teuieu) 4le- /£g£di (jphg/Q jviMsdiif.frio^lI issues
&r£<uU&LThd CpuA rvxu&fr frlxaik w&k^^/ippeJlflAt's pdMij>a and c^^^cuc
 it trx ^ppglUrAfr's W/q^ Ceo>e.u^ -H\e. rta><d. C&\\\<vVi^arA fro Agfr^Mn^g tr Am.{ &naWK£
ftupjysffrg frKg--^ar-frs, sAle^p/j bu kp^-HgioA. TSll \J_ SUfrg. ^W,<^\ P)lAl afA'Jf"^Co-,

 04 voWfcV> kpp&i\&nY ts> he\c^ \\\e$&\Ay &^A^Wv.ft\>A\\| {efrWxniA act v/biA AvxcVo
Vack o\ SuV^qfllr >m<-iVtfjir VAj^UAycAtg.A 6r q \iyb\nVvr»rN <W*-<•_(>*v^p. ^ V6LafrV\fifr Ap-yp^vj^

 ^^pp\V&.rvV Wg> ypcDMvA^ SvA^vcyfioV ^rt>c& Vo cneAfr Cjon^AlXoAxfrO &£ Ws> cA&\ms.
ep\'A\g W«nV&^£\ve^."\W^Vf*r»AACc\ c£ x?<ht&VS Wj a ypo(>,f\.A*s-woofc oQAW-£^iAa-{\cg-.
KxyXWA Ws. tf\g_V Wvv^ WvcApxn r£ xpcr^ ft^frVy (£Ci>>cA uS\X\ Qyx\yrt\&Wie,\N| &6jAQ*&~
ArnAg- XC\ <e.K\\e\Z> •<&, t^>A\dfW xpgVAtr>f\^ArAmc\Vr?T'g^u<> OrsA V^vln ^.i^^VTV^id-

_^ftpg\\p.(A S>VcA&s frWA AW> CLkuA W^i/x^AvcAxkn "Vcs yA.y\\ \V\i &li&£ fxautsfrM

                                                                                       SoP lo
 WUL\\u^^ >^ppp_\\fl(\fr frffii^ -iWfr Uxis Laik4 i.\M\ ac.fr in its ntV^diS/^pi^Vkru,
(niiibfr^Qai CAp&cifry and :

    SEAUf.ia tlfyg- ejt\V\<t <e.tb<& OJ\d, woki. aV\rvW% AWfr ^-jiiifla)Mfervfri4ce. uoirl W
    acV rf siJpj€gA^>nafrVg<-jun^A^iioKs;
a. feratx'V'H^ r<J<cj ^ucsfrgd in KppelUnVs habeas e^puaJ
 A- Aov ?,VA.cAf\ cyfA Viv<^cW* <y\\A as\\{\&.c\flkvA.c<^ t&\W f<ivA_y_ cv\fs.vj rimurg..

                                                                                 VX%^

                                                           Xv^y^cyycjA

                      C.e.A'yVco,^ cR %       ejc'Myc.g,

T W<e\a^ Gg.cV^vj \WA CL V<vvg_ <VO>A (LcCtegfr CfNyOvj ^^W^brgflpie^ \M\tHrft

  2>0\ ^cvjt\OXf\ ^y-t£e\
   VA&va.^ct><v^g^ c^ Tlftc^- ar^to U

                                                                                 z

                                                               &p^u**^\;ve*** wo*"
                                                                 ^ppe.XXo^ivX-

                                                                                        /* tff LP
     ?^e
S           3,
            a

'A

I           (A

     G> x
     o