Court Opinion

ID: 4053583
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 04:00:57.280625+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:05:35.568416
License: Public Domain

j _, . _ 1 XZ],SIZ)/?'Oz/©q

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

RECE|VED |N
coum' 01 cmMmAL APPEALS
.§9_01.€: 3~(7 135 l 1 ' MAR 202311§06 3/;1."5`57»011110101);_03§
§@67 06 Qg\_mM_L§ 010ng Abe|Acosta, _61611107 <~1'011: 06 700 3
_$1)_0§§50),<_\2§50 § \1<
_@109000§1011010 . 701~<\65 30€6507\) .' _
,§(~10_31:1;10_7§6003, ‘7<1`17\-\ 1016 00017. 1071°1¢1©0 ~C
fA“NO O

 

 

§V`O§OTL§%<>NBD_LC§ 50©0\‘/: DF_ Td.? (701,1"
x 130_1_6661€ 1.066163 115%_%&60_%@€1%1~7§‘15 1000
§\1:00~1`10103 _90 `~lev\ 1117 030/011 01;( 010711$§(,1;£1001010"1\¢\
_:1:;06§300,06¢61>:017 §01615000_§0¢\ 3201 101 Q01051_1:0:00<1_1’__
_ §Li©ummg 1\/\0-\/ 7 307 011`-\»\»1` 016 1306 7661)<17 M\@)~f
. _003 _6061_031<_60 §01 0003 0 101 1000 11101>110560 010<6‘53§0
_@?§'1'1:15§161/0_:50100/ CU@M 610111061 0037 711/617
§@_01 0046_§09063066€0010151: 1116 1010 0~006010:>7_1"110:061§_
.§\12111501:3_1 7_07€_3012005_6:1©§ 156 1115 1671 _€100719 _11+07
§(5110(>5§©0(_ Q_CQ{J§£F§§L 1505101&61_6 03 @171`27/\1$ 0€71`1‘13 (;1761¢777
’\Ml@_d_ U1\1266 131-1106 _T_ 111/1116 03 §01)51_111):01011§)@113106¢5§
§1\10366§§§0_05_0.01005 §13§1)1§6611010_01000 _(511?1361)001_00§
§1366;10_12‘€_ 0§1<)£§(5§6:013:)_10_1~§©0€5 1031 511 <;1~1@0 120 0?011< 30m1=
§610§\6§1/3133016 0106§666 3000@61§0_\?_@01151:`1:§0~0§ 71`01+1~5,
1100 510&>1100_61_0_?£7056 76'3_06§1617§‘:?§11111 1060
1010 061101`10 106 1040 1011/10101/1\001' 10061 1116 1310
' 131 RC4106110016:7_32£5_._6_'
. (" §51110©? P\i`@'df§§“§ 1166531\)\’~' 301`@\ "` 1003 1301`1\71`/01(`/'
6000&0\,611,._(3>010\60660001 1000 1013 11 1111/10006
16101'© 010 1116 1001 103 mug-11 03 10 760€0<
111001\11010 ~~0100 167 7 1003 1361060 0 3000 I

 

 

 

_QOOL© G“€~€b§© m %QUQ§ new 1999 QUTLE\/ pc@(pef@
9 U m€@\)%Y-' ~l ')\n\/ %cr of mHO¢)m m/<+S :
_®QAMED `Wn\ CQQ%"§ ‘z` @`»C\<:>ED \ Fo( ;)\\/<»Qrs (@ mom§ `K)

 

wj€;€_ef_ T@§ IMJCWG<\J/ c),F“m< 0 mae TC @@
oc 1430 e@m»`"/“ M)O v '
w\)wv\a€c> _ »- L'OQN\FO TH(" WS(L¢&~\/ 70 __
(/_OOC\L Gr\D "'QWQY\WTE gm (‘_xe`\m:L,_\)~_\`:Q F’vr\)\'/z was z" 9~7_§1¢;6:_@§_@_\_{,&®”(§[5\; `?

 

 

g: @Sa<€§> ama o\? mrs w m~,r mm ®Apom€©

 

. _._QQQQ:_E_L oliva w€% O®u\QQSLV_d\)_CI° QFC\J\/ <`Q

4 %QC_E\ P\NSWQC€ W:'S HH_Q;F u-..H-;

_ _____\Q<)::c;<>\;<'»_¥¢_71;{1>_(‘,:&©:§~.@€,_&»@').\~.x~i\_L§§(_Wa:,o_c.>\'_C_<“).\\)§Tl\r\`g)MQ(k

 

Q~£bc'w T@ mw __ » ? il€_%olcf_,m§;ca€ own
L&w§ u'_')\‘\"c‘.>QQWE,DM

WU@_Q@J;SW§F \)€er\M/KO(
TD 61 (AUM \mc<’ cung cvv\¢\c&_\|;» @q>qyo L§<>czo§© Tb \rv\< `\0 cwa/o
@G~X" C_O\\J C&QCB\"PW) \¢)_\c;QM §§SU~‘<\`§WM) E>T\/

Zi®§_: nC\S OQ.v\A`Ff) DUF \QGQQCS¢\- <7»`\0&+\ 73

. f AAPMJ SK)N depequ m wm(c

 

1.'.

__1!5001\;1_1_)9_<_»~4?\@. 00<3` `1\403 30<`1`0»\)

wm \1\1 LMY\@NSW 01\)€ W\o%< 1w0&€m@wr

01 "\1\)\10030 60031`1`11)11*01001 1010 _1`10_ 011>@2 1b1
_5_070 6011_0;12) 732__60_1>_0_01:0;)3_1`1030033_6031: > '

13 TH\S O(Q@ QN\NCIECN_ O< 003“1.'7 <9@§_@1\)1= m\1

733me \€- 32 VY\E'S_O\)"AQ`_@~_‘<$ 7;1;1¢0-» 1\)0`?'

1910101¢0( 01 GSMEMT §{00€_\`§0330<~3,1“1'¢1¢\/1

1¢\ 03 010¢@0 003 wm_@,ow@_€c;)w 1/~1 901“\&\/

01? 0001) 010\~100 1?0<'>0<,,,0/\.1'1;91¢\1;/\10@0 ~60103@0/01'11/€
vaQ@Q@'@_LWQ@L121_w@.._w.@(;o@,@:&@c;m
__1013;9012;14)1€13@;11/11€3 H€c 142-120 m 00 we

. @€Suu' 110 0600_&00313_¢_`1;_©;<;33%03:/0 my
600011<»/ .1- 110 1)`€111<§0`1§10 1113 0:11129 01:
711‘9 DCC*>CO§NQ\I 1001,0 H( 139 _“E_S_L`~‘v_l_//_\)_`(:D@" 3

RFWV\O¥\>@ST ku/v\»%$ Hw¢ TL~M_L>S 1. cma/mers .
1611¢ 030¢\0313;%\1301)013123 1 300/0131~10001@£
MUM@_Q®J£_GQLL._:&: may 13@._90:10\_2\

F©< 01\1¥; mtw\x€ ,@,@®1 Q,OLX.:_G(;@@`g_r;av_v_\_Lg:/_ww_€a£ 01013)0:@ 1000 1/1010111 101 - ~

v _10_€>21§ *\:11:1 12__.61,1@01341)0 070_ 01 162@1@,_1`11;‘1-;1112_3__3
UWLC PMD CF?§>¢\¢‘$¢U\T¢§ (R€$OL)€C,#$ (-F\/Ou 1011&( ¢

. `1’1-1%12 911 14 7€01¢1131111131001;10.0‘03<_0_@0@7
:11v,121 6914135_ f»v<‘TH13 111/1013 \'/\000 Swor`
‘1/\/11/10141/1/\ f/W 1)31€@ Qe\/ou___

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

33999143431/ 003&1\0_`1119/_6027 1220 1001/522
1442 143 14013'14133132 09€13 09 __()141>99 15134:_3145
14 111/910 14 1903 1111941) 10110311)“351219110311)92>
734 009 64521~311\ 71 01”¢4\} 799 60031:93700\<` `
1117 09€0/059" 754 911\) \,/ @_0_0/_@5_§2025@@11_1)6(;
3331:11€353€2731;@03\83100233_7;31/969®1' 1\)_1)23.6
°Jf 904/ \1\04 9404<\2 13 16322;1'930_ 131363 71)031191
%\1<19;11\ `31:143\<7119 @0)1:13 wm 1004
1107 661040007 191 1119_ 614 1WNQQEmeN\
9\911/6 114 691911\)1_9 1 11 14 990 6 91911)03 70 9130_11293
' 1"~11\)0 5140"594 1109 0014 706 SY\QTE 151190745393191 '
. 3__362/.€6 1002)_21493 00031003©979193 1913@ 1536091)313333
175 121113391 7:5_67721`3€9116'11/0_91_43£121/`11‘912123401)
39013;4031)31_1317_1_19391403@122) 3112/92021) 1/7/1 194
1230 91653 401219\1\_/_0_ 401)1._€£§©1:'135__61/30_731293433 33
1094 116 0019»11) \/12) 900 4001 991/1114 1971/m
_7§_60230031:00~0 6.1)11, 711911\>12 400

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

, %172)3191111/
3_;1§_11/_6_1/£0 1214 rME/UZ>O 723_()1_6311/1'19 \/l/l/t/6 flqu

773 60)19415343@6MQNW jj TDC°§SW: O|‘%%GS S'EB’U

0103\\{_1312131131736@£12_176171)&)11.21%_,_3 (2911€1@ 6751.’0/\)1`44

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

EL DQ% 7 H'SOL( (~1'12/4 203
2111/4116£211:0 511/1046 1911~1<»1)_1»0\15 15&1/1119`3'1;@_1_< 915 73’/09~
. 101/1114 11214191<00~11;7 599121>@011')15 1120:
§1201©14111€§530_ 1@1£290113<121273313:7?00 16 wm 13 7
190443“1134951 7700_3 1219 %/;1,557~05 194/4001~1 ,

 

14910~3 612/21'7<610123 0991¢93