Court Opinion

ID: 4050369
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:14:43.532029+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:32.702195
License: Public Domain

. ~ , @ _ J\»~ai$zm»,-:»
dwi le\£>.nzz?z@i\ gwing

%;M¢n WM_{)M ~ /_:,\,Q§»\£ 166 mw w
MAW\A U¥ Mamh$ Cso'mMTEXAS

' 5005-655 @\E§QM\§ET¢ Slxkz§ \>Q,;w¢se¢\
\;`\m;\»»§w€). G.Q \:Ar}r {:o\\\c\v§`\m\§ mg lamjl@EA mw 0§ $MM&M\UW 0§ m
AQO\AM 0§ gen ‘W£ §o\\ow`\m% 'A£S\>m\$€>£ bow CLENEHX\\/ ANA%OE<}\¥§¢/ Pc>`mXS
‘H\E %laiu€ m»aME§\ m\{\,;c\n L,_>`\l\ be weme hamm b§EJ.§§ \\\umbeve~\§/\B

, ._ ~ " ‘ l
54$& u&,\=A u\s 63 Q\me\)am:. couRToF cR»M¥NEA?/|\|EPEALS
, ` Aus 20 2015
- ,(\;rEMEM REE>OAMS£

 

. 6 ~ Abe!Acost , l-
/5\'{. _g~MLE §§`1\5 la ¥EXAE `1\\&5<0 wm§,¥z§);€\a§imm\\r~.¥ _50¢\>11_ zAAmse\ Mm¥a¢§§\;.k@om\e
m652 im APVHC?\M~\S \\ R‘E,S()BMSE, '\0 .R§S:~\c\&.u`\¥ SL_\.\Q rv\>.¥~\'€A Or\.) _N\am;\\ ‘?>O~.M>\B b\)
-~H?i~al mu<_»'re\ ‘{\Eoomi (BQALMIAA 62'.’01\5\3\.'>05\)4 §§le w`\\\)w 4>\\£ C,mo} 21»/\)&
?fz.c>?o§§\y geaoEA @M~Dnz 3431£, §aiA azbr>ouse Po;u+$ 0\>¥. m CLE+z»l\aw¢\')z QLCX>M>\\ rha/m EMAAEQ>\>&K.`\ES zmA mma-kij
N\'@x 5206$`\.~`\51\ \*m§ \\.90¥\' E`LQ\BR¢\J"<_\,\.M§GQ, L.)\\A¢\\ iper (:`>\'B§E may_`:’,é> MD
m v);-¢$Qomsa =.H ¥U\\ ae`\neme§ DS~%w+§oQAM-d& QES\>DMQ,E wou\¢\`b€'
Q)EA:>MAQM~¥\ mci ¢\&\0£> Dr<>i>l.ir_am& KLES?EA:QL>\\\/ £L€ODOE,S-\ “\'\\$N)¢\z Couo§c 0)6?:&0.
A~¥ sol 6 Y\J\\EQ\ ~'\'v£,v:\me¢\`\¥ 0§ 303 mdl\\)\¢\.\sal QDSM¥§ w\'ad£
be\o\.\> m QE&,<>DMQE\LD Q,OE¢A.Q;L PQOS>I>.$EA Y`\MARM@ c>§ Hx\- by ~\><\E S~U.

. _ pUl>osE¢\ \YSHAM \~\~§
' "5£5§ Flmlm€s S\w§_ um com~)€§&§i

§?fl/wobrii l:imh HS)B

“5\£_ algoma ¢\E£azwcid RESOOMSE by }\WL/\r_w¥ 40 5¢0»<31 Oo\)L:QE\S A££{¢lzwnL ?01)1146
ou-\ alma mmu§‘\e+'ewo\e§ Nb)c aw\‘amEA b\) wm mu§';\ 1402 ad'AQEsé£`\4 J@ bc‘med;\gl£' `~\' ¢\)¢\Ew\ 905 A'©Q\j\aamjc \/\S&LSb MDQL fog 3 NMAEP\@N®MA "_“E.\`?J‘O

\/\}\§ mm A);¥emg€’; fhwa 09 \\§(\'E Qm>u<£g 69 cDMQEAe\¢,M ~w emma 465 `

§§ dm \f 5\1\1550\>23»\~416 \)s '\\@7_@, n\),1 )Jo@ '\_M 0€591>»¢§£ 4<> °\XNE QE,Q>oE§’r
61\> R§§-`\AU>`H m Q\)n£ `\mS¥@\>)c \-\§o€a,% QQ»>L£EASMA Ona!\€melh\~l€z R\X/u€

E§§'€_cki\\€c\\`x';§>§ §§ \\ig Qev&o;>\mmcf> . wom$€\ €>MES ESSE\\>;\%;§N ~`\5?¢»€ c\?€oes`\+€.
`me%&\ womaw dm~\\'®\@§r MVU QM¥S GQEQGW mem mi\zueu¥am,§ \»l§
anwm maxwme wave mw mw\s~¥m‘v"ooc>¢>e,E-s we mow
Sh§emzu”r wait \n£ kohw\>¥ma; manhqu a mmse‘\\m\¢ J&\eocz>o
wm `EN~CI>P»Q~`\E“>\¢, due 40 .Sloo\i,@ul< ‘\M`X\znwcb\ow t>¥ cx>»_:\.$u£>{m@ Fax¥‘»

n.`\mq 902 m\>€,£>~\»i Qx@b`\DM-. Mwm€,‘\§¢\&mc)f&$ 6\)€.\\ 65 ~\X\£S€ §Jcaaj\z\§
cazA;b'\\_>l. QENM\(:§S o§ w\\ic>¢§ SE+ §§ wawou€>&$ ig max AQQJQQL?,,
» PQ>OGS&L\ Y:'\MX\M 30 '

/511¢ VJ;CMA Smu)\$na} \\ma§ amd COuME>E'\ SALE¢\ wis ()Qalmax W\D\Aor\\€>
'§.\LC£P-\ 01\)€ ou \’\RE Q\BM 0$} \\&>'La§- J)<\\“>A ~\>m)§~ mo~\q` fm was Mo¢r `\(\E.U)o\,
QE£\-¥aim\y a CDUMST;\ \m\>ES\'l€)ai`\Ma 6 maxim 404-65 m"\\\s_€» SOEM& '
\‘ax).A)E mmm>¢\>l, 6¥ lime ma Wec>aaahow zu\>¢\ b'\sc.<>u€;zaxo1 wk&\adieml¢
w‘m> '\me,'\§~\&iou %`\m”_> in W`m) §mmd¥\£b\.=.aml es~. wou\¢\ hang \(\m;l nran
ank\,;w mikva \\»\\z,ama&~vrm~\>¢€é.l\hmzm\ mg PM‘OMM
rv@£¢AQb\/\L¢\>% 0034>`\& GJ\/\X~. \/\_/ou$z,_ w\¢\£n£®<\£ crle oc_cu `M-:A~ wives ~&XE
mmi :=!\\E¢;_\~*;A§m 'Aoz>¥\ Q\axs m£'>`m\£\~w£\ AA.\D); emma gm m`\&,\ 3§_;&4»£
-M\EAQEA aMc\A)?_NX\ u_>\\f:m_:, '~‘mu\] mil§'z\x~\$ €\WESZ€A¥\O‘DE ;u_>u¢l‘¥>
myv\ah@mctz`am’\w§&w'€$§ Q;@§ z>§¢ w E_\\@Q% v\sm\A m \@m¢=_e_br=_

_ 19 we oz;;) AH&`EN$£I;:_ ‘C\?;\ii€q.m ag M AW`E bg Q'\\E%d 3de

\ QQ/O()Nz&l hung 5 »3`

436 §ML\.RM§S SHJ\_>AUNLDM‘E$ ‘1 wl§\)#\_il€§i?:?§r §LO"Q\'\)Z J'Mmérv\/PAL.H£
widib)&|l~<|@ O§ M),Z~a)) mou§_.p&\ 64 ‘Azw§-l/ has r),EA/QIQ. hew a:d¢lu€:§&\/,
@NA hea& .H`/ fs ~D+ 60 Muc&\ wl_{/&+L\Eo/ mb wo+'»bz/ia) cou/\)§¥J wax wage
di M_Mu@»u+g w@&~mm§" AS \MWQ Lz. aba ,~D+ dsa whom m \
AQPUM timmy iv uaw 09 \Ona)r M@%wezs'>'.

` , PQDPMCL cmi;w ‘2 A

/" ` ‘ 13 MM'E,§&L\, wm Mm§m QQDM£ §§qu 5 @LM}' M@?M` -

n/£,'LMN;HP%EQ‘WUM i>na/§¢:>L>QAM &¥\Lr»;i ' mu§€ adp 441/ml mm§&‘ié >Qf-£m\a~i+,

' "

?IZDPG£&A F}\>A.XM€) \D l v

`/5\)£§ {'Séui_ §i) umwm\*£§t&& b.\)¥?@g\)&$ \1\\.7; PDSM¥ \On@»\ iowa Cum%l 115
usx 60 Aéevb\>dz \uueg¥m£cu mlp .AQQU@AA; P%~`\\;\aaxzm;a%ou
w~-z\a;\ \ngv»\a»ai“;¢ mw mm w exam ma %m@;ms\\z.mwz

»\o‘=\kne €%SXE (Z>axz_. '

QQDQO§iA_' (;`\w=\i~€) il

/{Ll§ m kimme QQ£UI¢SV§§Q\ 505 `\M an`£. cl£“\'a.l\ }ro §§Pc>l,\c;m&$
anuioos\y> ‘_\?`¢LEA Q£.S€>ov% 40 ~\o,`<~a,\ cowge'\§ H¥Ma.u`\£%mz ouEz,
3 40¢>5 umc§&£©q®»\)

¢\)}1\>9 c>~F §M`.ib MA,MLE%&&_R>M)S') 175 N04@\'MFS
QBVD\)R(E:¢\» 309_ 00 A>E<\@\)Od . 69 609€30\5&) M §a£~\'ua§\) o `

§ _ MA@_F.MMAWQ
is m,;(m me wee,s»m.<,\-:,z] wm M<:) v V~~A€A.§MB zezu,s.
¢_ wm ..”WAJ\ MMQE)B 195 M:- §J@£.z 666 WM he@ue§hz»»
EA 1909qu (Lah`o/\)a.l|:/ com-45qu Pai wmckain comepie@£y %Eoejzw.
am a.c, edward m <=kM-,'Moo/ won§e mng SEL.F.A 59 ,¢zs>PL¢‘c,z,mL1 =H\z
'Ns\zstm 306 mon 05 Lv'\f> niemd i ll»u&§$ can ap'a>\iom,\\a `u\s&o amaxon m
amy'giJi>:-m\>iou ibma)\_v am imh‘oml\_\/ emme& oues`\’m,\ mcneal eiH»'eez.
516 ’\N§,o@££}c}\BM-¥ `\ML\ES¥\€)&J\:§QM do \CNQL¢)~\)\~`,§$ 09_ lm':u> aJ\_,,L 616 um-

‘A'§.'\ mn_§i_ll\l'dx`j \ l

;QQDQD§’E£\, ¥`\uAL\LQF \()_
/{:6_\}.5 §§ 3 `\t\\\mc. 909 %mc_'"ml>m:ew)r'\\\£ §§G§.£BPQEM$~\© \OE

mm,{m \\><\a)c wam.é€ B,P?Ucm\>-\S O,ESQDMS£€) cb\soi 9 ~\'O»`\a)

zieva m\\\&\a}~®\@&£@z \\E, was com@e~¥€\\:\-W¢>k;\aha *

fsia Bame. wom_ ax \bs¢x\"[‘\']he §Y.is ” “ ' - ‘

did _\S`MG‘\ alww§ ap `\O \UH:E. G;' EUEK) a §EUCTQ?;V$Y(.\/\B§O,LC,

' jo 519 uus¥w¥ca_gi wav@awmtz mzm`\w€¢ wmc>€§em,i\mw£w
35 am 12605 40 ble ad&z»§%€é \0@§<>0,§ wax bmeéom ivAac:Bc&¢->MS ~l)@a}
a@§\ 34 "\¢\A<> %\>€,;>dom `<>DSS‘\\>X/; B\@A¢,{ N@ 0®¢@93;~9}»1~\30 hawk
ND)¢ am f§§\)% do 1930va 664 owes %G`omv\m@, <§Qv,e\\)€ ~1@‘<1»)\.

\\ v gabszch my tug -\~3
M ¥UW\ §M<)<>D@\ 466 63 662 dm M@um¥ w m+

€6200‘\6£\ AQ?\§MLA'\¢\) §a§;k- Qv,®u"\& }»6`\:\15 QM`©Q>N ¥'\L%¢\
wong 40 wm mmsi';\s R‘§$»lc;\zw`\lrq

w wow\£a&)£®§?\ai\\y®\)~\$
\)5.€ miami anew {méwéz ~N\/ec»a w'\~\?(\¥@ ` mm §§alz A;A wolf
131

§nu@m@\\\§ 03\3`@\) AoLun/GQ§. \\oww'c
534 ZM»§OUJ\GKOL) ®33004 ap?\icav¢>§€> ‘E\L~\Em£,`\\)'€ mSM-\, do kl; injured mack :3@1\ %Cmd$ ~ wk;c§\ md wuw€\ dm,%
mm mae way we gamdw dim MSMM@ '

£Q/Z\@DS’§CL $§MEL'NQ§H' 17 7
/iS/LU {S§TES hUE @mu!a§§\)&l@ EZHU ZLRH)?ZE..SS&:]/UM °p)\f: F%€/l:)l)§ `

' %@M§ES §>‘,¢u¢\f m Q.OPL; @M: fa%))(`oué§ '§Lecl MSPON$ J@ Jm`s)
Uw¢\:é€)é §Q'dzw{+, §EPFLLé'r§/lmuc(e§ JEM€)\)&¢M%E<£
`uu -RL'B §)ES`\€N&'FQ`N¢] %o%@§

is§w: .Mvz§ow;m>w 215 walk as amf (>qu% 1+ deems

fam@pm-doz amslm $w/v\<>l)ne QEcDad.

. %mm€~U/\ V\!@)ANE zwem£”z\r€wzn§
AM&M '

(`/W\>?in\/ `\/M‘l‘\’
am FM wl
\CTW€MTO§ 7811‘1

-('_C §wwmz