Court Opinion

ID: 4046232
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:04:45.533104+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:57.665073
License: Public Domain

~ 4-llf a-f' (!,t, rt1 /l)lt4
                                                                                 (i cr...JZ..91'D -ar~a:;-,i!R~";JJ~~ 1:8 2ll1fl»
                                Ctz_l?n    &IA.A.-+ Ho.       e>~'oc:ii-12 9'7(p
                                cxP.t~+J!:.         ~·:11,8-tn Aula~ !J,tl~· ~beiAcosta,Cierk
    (!j~ILk:                                              .                                      ·--A,:;Sl.P~Jg- ~
       :::h-t t<~sf... .;;4., %'/- G~cJ~ilnt~--1 r!A<:f i)
    ~~~uJ' Atl C!V->~75                     $$. -'1hc    -6.s:2?t~rshJcl                -n, "1Jt6 SObZ34>            L     /IML

' r/6 ~61~ b.iih ~.%'l --JJ,~ (j'J.tJ 6/a.-m                              T'S"     -?71AI 6'?1 . s~g:xf.smb6~ )~ ~oof
r     :W/1-s   --:::hc:J.ci~J ~ /b &"-'nls                    tl   ::;   wAS #of- ;::77,dJ/ckol'            (TA/   6f'r5~-l-2.9l7.
 ~ -rh8p ·~cP,c-bn4Ji'l-4r t'&tl~ f;J,~: &~J Ju~ ~ ?ht ~U-?1~ e::>FbJJYIIe.e..
 lfflJ ··fh t- ShJk. .c ·7£ A--.4$, 41.4/i ::;.dl!'e:h~ ~A1VJPnelf,o!, S toa/UJ ~ cJALg-J/
                                
:£ LU~Jh~ /hJ{lk) /JJ~ /Ptrs ,n/~.t /Jt<.~IJ tun!:/ S'~pfhl1j¢se 
 ;JtrS":O "lJZ>f~/cl ~~.<.~
   ~'epfUr-. b6K!- 1S .dafJ~ fht-d /)Jd t/~J- 1/AV-F UL(;tUscRtiJJc-?-
    6'Yl
 ~ :s~ty~&w,; hu 'f f5Dar> ~ + t: m ~ & cr· AK~U ~ f
      .As :/;    hAV\ ~'ZfArc;J (1\~ g1l'STh.ft I           £/,~            z.U'ELC.       r,48m    "1JJ£ ::7?r:7~c:l~
                                                                                       '
      ,g<;;"./h1 /J.tfi!Jtvn4f' dtt-lvivl ~IR'6 ~- ~1 1 ,~~ ai>l~                            ~ ~~~ uriJA 2?
      16&1/w'$- cl    w_,s-s ~~ -z;,~~tc. /r~·.::s-              4'0-n1 rYUf · fhJ/r)Vn ~ ~ ;z; HIW~
      ~/~J 0           t0~1-f-> erf:' ffir/;6RS           Cbifu:S, ~E t/rsrf- T?Vd                      tA.J6U   lfbctvd~
       /')E.WI~ '}>;rs'1\em~-l.k~ )d~ ·:to Af m                             ·"7.3 /71 ~ ~4V4f o2 &~.~            j
       ~@6>~./}ls     FJs    ~l~-ls4J -thE                    cSn Jvr !1 ~ b.eL6             7im t --rs ~E"iy
       Ct.e~-I~J 47 -~J??- /f)c.(!A'fj· 1/3 :Tf -:1A~ Jo--o7?'JJ,(',~I0)'JI!JiJ
       J-/Ad r/e;     JLA~/z;~ic-1,~ ~ rl      )/-me /iUj         ff:gn A ..fu L ~          071    -1   ~ tu to i :d:
      o~~oct-R.'i1~:D -CJ(. J;p\J . :~ .,.
     CJi..Jtt.. b~.tol ern tnf.·IYl 7J tJa/dJ 1 . Rtskt:.tt. \J C1m.rva·iss)(s-).. ..C~ /-.!JUh{!IL
     r:Drs~-, @II n(~
             7    AYn'    ·-r~Lu.d1          So~ -:k~ \/'14,rs #/~s-s .. Y?..fs JJI/ 6ee-146£- r:r-P ~
               I+J:krvn~ ()4rlvm 6rtfi.§1~, £~~~                                     I()    Pi.t~i &;5d.P4lc~ _ &;,JfJ.4le1
              r]h~ W'IJS :SI.bps£/1/.tt-.a.:::l ·lt'h.CI 1\/tu~~ ftU-ser~fzJ -n> ~'$ t!.eu/(.,J 6/l...
             -j7,1_ ~~~                 JUrh~s~r:-s -dlt~ w~~                        dM6rL      ~t.. tfa~/1,(j-d ~ /Ylult$11-~?AJ­
             ~ HDt c::h.-~·hJJ.                           "'(b   ~ '7 ~urL{,                   bt.ficl~c~ -fo,:y/ ~
             ·-~,y}.5~'~t~-f          A71c/ tJiltt( -76                hl'-(    01}6'L   -~ wrh/,~// ~i rj1~r;J;S..Jil.lcl
               /kf,f.r;Jf./11 d' 9      ~ ~ tn'-{ ~~sd~                              T   A?n    ~rl<)·hua V S"M-t CfiAI'-~/6-$   f+pp.!AI/./rYIC£   ()'$~~
            /'1h1 det-1/i.f1            /Jvtf~   i2.tJ   'VG~(S({S        lml\ T£xl15      ~Jf:S e~ Q-;v·,f ~~u!.£ 1 &di,;,J
             ~t\~,clrd\--.. ooca..·1/l~ ~~ Q.tm"~i ~c am~~$Jl ~PIP\ ·YA"f:. Q7-s-l~c.t
              ~~e.+ ~~~~'f ~'-1 7Yt'f.. Ll~~s~Js htd(pe~471CEJ h'-41 1!-kJ~'e.~:;:S -r;,~d~c..
             l.:s:ki/Yl ()g'

            v;J          rlc:.'f     f/P$5c_   .Jui,~&,d:J~~ .cu~ lh~ J$"s-Lh "j);JLe.,ct ~ue.f-'!
              /h, du~6~tc~A~~ e;.P Jh ~ ID'~~ Jt.{~,c.41 v~&k~cl ~uR.t iVJl.-1\ t- r
               Ue~-~J              10    ~c.A~ Ckl.vv'\~ 7€-JMS-?>
  .    J~~ ~f\                    'iixAS      ~~fo-rtme-,..J (kJ~              (}.'t~ 'd~         /6'6"''221 JL(J,~,.+f

   'Pi·~~~e-l         ( A."')Jm ,~t!-rh:_, mtcP W/\-ll~ll ~.J-.1~.
(~)·--th ·f.. ·n~s ~-fh f /~ ---p/~-;uc_J- tkJc.e};j.                           l:Jc$711   ~
Q) ::t:n JJt..s./r-n ~UAJ"'t          l$"Y)   -% f   ./lis-! fY7ond fk1 -~ tfuJilf} /1JLo/ /))ob£mhcR ':1
~~~~..fk                       e14 on·fhl rfk~t rt76>lcl~ "1l\ .fi.hRvtAp.y ~ntd                       ~~6L.'&
{$:J ~         /).}hr/}E.tL   (ki.VY\-kt on '/h1- Jt~.'J-sf n1~lj -:Yn         Joo\.\Aflit        ~ dune..~
v~ ~~ J.!X-r.ts ~IJe~~ Q,.d~ ~, bo9                                               Jvt!l~t~tcf->-
 EAd &at.t1z.J 1/sf~J ~ -Jh1s ~'-i bcJ,P&rn ~d){ S uJ U                              G;IJC( 1 &12 1 (1;~

 C!ln~~ ~ 1q9/) AaJic.)~ S" §''if o~ -1J. z -!i..vtS ~sl~/rA 4-nd k~c/E
 l.j.CY) cF '171c, ti.xAs W.t csP0-InvAA'f
           D                                                     f1aa~uRL       VJI4c.t        Jurl;sd,~.e:cft-:-. ~-P
AJ)        J1brf       &-sq :::M. '1Az d/skcf &/!--Is ... II~ ~ ~oeibnfflP.?Zl &Jc..
b-/;:b.£4-r-- lfP-J,c_ft S, 5j?                        A'S   .4-m~cffo..e/           f!_,4Jvccl~~ !
 .• e ,,   -/h~ /)fij-~f/J"l.P71+             bp   A71    ~d/c~/' o.e. PndtYl/n~.J/d'X- 7C                    A   Cel~..tll}
 ~ v.t-~ls f'JJ£ ~L~                      t:.v/h cfi.,/1/Wrci~~         =+ -~ t            ClAU6·E-Q

  \l~tlsns P.,../\·-r~~ <:b-c>ulf~~~l OcJE. d·i o/6 -r;~ ,(Jnc/ 5~£S~s
 CAC&.'::-ott:.f-l<.,o,l" fr"\d C~nmn ll-{---;:J/~kre/ Ckt.tll)- ho/Js                     ll-/   lE#S'f /e'Ucl ·76~&

  ~· ~t--+ t;~a_A ~t;fYL 1 ~ Md tLJ(v,I'J*f ~ 'VA' drs·hu~ft.

 ~\l;!(_. ~~                       NWb-it..     I~AJ/ ~~;;&tc.-~io-n            a_Q fnt-           ~~~·tJr 7Jrs-lli~C'(
   ~do
                                                                          ~ L       ~
    . + ·~..,;-~- ~ AWl NtJ 1- A- A~~!(_..       :r do der-1- ~,'J()tV ZUI~I¥r ;P;, ua·'d. .
                                      J                        d\

     ·-r dd /11ow --11.,_-i sd Jl-\n~ Ia dOlO YYLlt AiJc~"'t 6.-lum ~6 /
     IWIAJJLme,. 761/~ 111c. Jh41 1-k JP4'-1/t/ .w,f1dut.LJ ~ flU-J ~.tK41
    :r-f ::r llJ~cl.. Jlc_ IJ->hc/ "7E X ~AI/ tot»t#cl ;. /i7r! /15 #f.i;U~~--
    mi /J.S/JAJE/'2 W~ ;/£// /lkJ ... ~'r~.j -r4.Jo '7)~5 lt+-f.k,e, 14 c/Jd /ld·r
     lbir:lltdt.~ ~'i/J 'J);d dorl n~pl-71-l -rA·~ &/cl-"':tc. { ·~,y/ ...:£
    b40 e J/t);Y]. Jhd tf-~ -:::h.,u~s/,;ifhi(.. .5'u1ffl; ../fl_J /J J: Is I ;:1j;{;J4U rf
    7b ·'fll!. r:u:s-k;cf gj):sllm'ti ~ L1-rr ~<5- ~L~s; .:z:- ~V/It~
    ~dt~ Ill!~ Jed~ ::z: i0~S csn/y /£y;.;·f /2                                            .,({'$~ -IJt? C)/d?sl-
    a/2,
     I Az.v/Jej ~ 1J -rh4 blc QJ iJ'[E~ ,k.JieJ b.J;IJS                                            A-   'Jj,eu[ dG~Jf(jR,..
                                                          #~121~
                                                              /~~~~
                                                              CJt7
                       J"(\q
-    ~;>siu~ 7·7q« 47zc/ /6 ~-'l &~/J-1- J(J4~,'a/
     ~.M(~ 1d-3D7