Court Opinion

ID: 4593899
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2020-11-20 19:11:47.110644+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T07:51:08.928952
License: Public Domain

DEATH VALLEY RAILROAD COMPANY, PETITIONER, v. COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE, RESPONDENT.Death Valley R.R. v. CommissionerDocket No. 36590.United States Board of Tax Appeals23 B.T.A. 783; 1931 BTA LEXIS 1827; June 18, 1931, Promulgated 1931 BTA LEXIS 1827">*1827  Petitioner's returns for 1920 to 1923, inclusive, were filed on a calendar year basis, but were adjusted by respondent to fiscal year basis ending September 30, 1921 and 1922, by reason of affiliation with other corporations on a fiscal year basis.  In 1921 and 1922 petitioner had net losses.  Beginning October 1, 1922, petitioner elected not to file consolidated returns with other corporations.  In 1923 it had a net income.  Held, that the short period October 1 to December 31, 1922, is not a taxable year; that the calendar year 1923 is the "next succeeding taxable year with relation to the fiscal year ended September 30, 1921, and that the net loss for the 1921 fiscal year computed under section 204(d) of the 1921 Act may be carried forward to the calendar year 1923.  Albert R. Palmer, Esq., and Harry W. Stelle, Jr., Esq., for the petitioner.  J. T. Haslam, Esq., for the respondent.  ARUNDELL23 B.T.A. 783">*783  Respondent determined a deficiency in income tax for the calendar year 1923 in the amount of $4,174.47.  The deficiency arises out of the respondent's refusal to allow a deduction from 1923 gross income of a net loss sustained in 1921 when1931 BTA LEXIS 1827">*1828  petitioner was a member of an affiliated group.  The facts are set forth substantially as stipulated by the parties.  FINDINGS OF FACT.  Petitioner closed its books and accounted to the Interstate Commerce Commission, and filed its income-tax returns on the calendar year basis for the years 1920, 1921, 1922 and 1923.  Because petitioner was affiliated with other subsidiaries of Borax Consolidated, Ltd., respondent combined its net income with that of its affiliated companies for the years 1920, 1921 and 1922, and adjusted its income for these years to a fiscal year basis in order to meet the requirements of section 240 of the Revenue Acts of 1918 and 1921.  23 B.T.A. 783">*784  Petitioner's separate net income and losses were as follows: Calendar year 1920, net income$19,834.81Calendar year 1921, net loss36,161.25Calendar year 1922, net income4,715.51Period October 1 to December 31, 1922, net income1,178.88Calendar year 1923, net income (exclusive of any deduction or adjustment for any statutory net loss of prior year or years)56,142.57The incomes (or deductible losses) of subsidiaries of Borax Consolidated, Ltd., for the fiscal years ended September 30, 1921 and1931 BTA LEXIS 1827">*1829  1922 was as follows: Name of subsidiaryFiscal year ended Sept. 30, 1921Fiscal year ended Sept. 30, 1922Death Valley Railroad Co1 $22,162.231 $5,503.68Cuevitas Trading CoPacific Coast Borax Co. of NevadaPacific Coast Borax Co. of New YorkSan Bernardino Borax Mining Co1 2,168.731 1,292.02T. & S. C. White Co. of New York2 2,452.832 9,945.56T. & S. C. White Co. of New Jersey1 2,836.991 4,738.32U.S. Borax Co. of West Virginia1 68,826.831 56,800.83Applying the rule set forth in the decision of , the net losses of petitioner are $21,594.68 for the fiscal year ended September 30, 1921, and $4,702.67 for the fiscal year ended September 30, 1922.  The loss of $21,594.68 for the fiscal year ended September 30, 1921, is limited to $16,196.01 by the provisions of section 204(d), Revenue Act of 1921.  Petitioner elected not to be consolidated with any other corporation after October 1, 1922, for purposes of computation of the Federal income tax.  OPINION.  ARUNDELL: Petitioner claims that in computing1931 BTA LEXIS 1827">*1830  net income for the calendar year 1923 it is entitled to deduct either (1) the adjusted net loss of $21,594.68 for the fiscal year ended September 30, 1921, or (2) the entire loss of $36,161.25 for the calendar year 1921, subject to adjustment on account of income of its affiliated companies for 1921 and 1922 and its own net income for the calendar year 1922.  Respondent's argument against allowing any deduction in 1923 on account of the 1921 net loss has several branches.  They are, first, that because of petitioner's affiliation with companies having a fiscal year its returns for 1921 and 1922 were required to be on a fiscal 23 B.T.A. 783">*785  year basis, hence the calendar years 1921 and 1922 were not "taxable years," and, as only net losses for "taxable years" can be carried forward, petitioner's net loss for the calendar year 1921 can not be applied against net income for the calendar years 1922 and 1923.  Second, while conceding that the adjusted net loss of $16,196.01 for the fiscal year ended September 30, 1921, may be carried forward, the fact that petitioner had a net loss for the year ended September 30, 1922, requires that the entire $16,196.01 be carried forward to the "next1931 BTA LEXIS 1827">*1831  succeeding taxable year," which respondent says is the three-month period ended December 31, 1922.  Respondent further says that, as section 204 does not provide for carrying forward net losses more than two succeeding taxable years, no part of the $16,196.01 may be carried over to the calendar year 1923.  In , we had a similar situation in that there was a short period (one month) between the close of one accounting period of twelve months and the beginning of the next.  We there held that such short period did not constitute a "taxable year" and that a net loss sustained for a prior taxable year may not be deducted in computing net income for the short period.  Respondent attempts to distinguish the Strain Brothers case on the ground that in that case there was a voluntary change in the accounting period.  But in the present case, too, there was a voluntary change of accounting period.  While the petitioner kept its accounts on a calendar year basis, the respondent put it on a fiscal year basis for tax purposes.  It is stipulated that beginning October 1, 1922, petitioner "elected" not to be consolidated with any other corporation, 1931 BTA LEXIS 1827">*1832  and thereupon its accounting year for tax purposes was changed to coincide with its bookkeeping year - that is, from fiscal year to calendar year.  The stipulation that petitioner "elected" to change its status connotes a voluntary act and the change of accounting period that followed must likewise be held a voluntary change.  We are accordingly of the opinion that, following the Strain Brothers case, supra, the calendar year 1923 is the "next succeeding taxable year" with relation to the fiscal year ended September 30, 1921.  One of petitioner's arguments is that it was the principal reporting company of the affiliated group and that therefore the taxable years of the others should have been changed to coincide with its calendar year rather than having its year changed to coincide with the fiscal year of the others.  The case was submitted on a stipulation of facts and those facts are insufficient to support petitioner's claim.  And 23 B.T.A. 783">*786  we think it was proper for the respondent to adjust all returns of the affiliated group so that their taxable years correspond with the parent or principal reporting company.  Section 240(e) of the Revenue Act of 1921 provides that1931 BTA LEXIS 1827">*1833  affiliated corporations "shall make consolidated returns for any taxable year beginning prior to January 1, 1922, in the same manner and subject to the same conditions as provided by the Revenue Act of 1918." The 1918 Act (sec. 240(a)) provides that affiliated corporations shall make consolidated returns "under regulations to be prescribed by the Commissioner with the approval of the Secretary." Pursuant to this authority, the Commissioner promulgated article 638 of Regulations 45, which provides in part: Different fiscal years of affiliated corporations. - In the case of all consolidated returns, consolidated invested capital must be computed as of the beginning of the taxable year of the parent or principal reporting company and consolidated income must be computed on the basis of its taxable year.  This appears to be a reasonable regulation.  If the taxable years of affiliated companies were not brought into harmony it would be impossible to make proper computations of invested capital and income.  As shown by the stipulation, petitioner sustained a net loss of $22,162.23 in the fiscal year ended September 30, 1921.  In view of the fact that one of its affiliates had net1931 BTA LEXIS 1827">*1834  income in that year, there remains to the petitioner only a prorated portion of its net loss, $21,594.68, under the rule in . See also . The portion of this net loss that may be carried forward to succeeding years is limited, as stipulated, to $16,196.01 by section 204(d) of the 1921 Act, which prescribes that in the case of fiscal years beginning in 1920 and ending in 1921 the taxpayer shall have the benefit of the net loss sustained in that year in "the same proportion of such net loss which the portion of such fiscal year falling within the calendar year 1921 is of the entire fiscal year." It is stipulated that for the fiscal year ended September 30, 1922, petitioner had a net loss remaining after adjustment for the income of the only one of the affiliated group that had income, and as that was the "succeeding taxable year" with relation to the fiscal year ended September 30, 1921, petitioner is entitled to carry over to the "next succeeding taxable year," namely the calendar year 1923, the net loss of $16,196.01 remaining to it from the fiscal year1931 BTA LEXIS 1827">*1835  ended September 30, 1921.  Decision will be entered under Rule 50.Footnotes1. Indicates net loss.  ↩2. Indicates net income. ↩