Court Opinion

ID: 4042077
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:59:28.187066+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:57:10.574763
License: Public Domain

~~MbE.r
                                       C.. A-USE
                                      8'1-03--DO~ 8lo-C..R~ ~
         -'\

                                                                                     :JI,Id? -D~
                                                                             L'u.T~iE. ~~l s·t-.
C..:\~rks
"'-ti::\h:~ ('                                                               d ~\ci J \L) \s\0;·  cct-
                                                                              C.o\A..f'.+ o .Q f'J\Q;;~e.r~
                                                                              C..c w.~ J Tt.x AS

ItuRE: boul.\-\!_lJ~y·u~ ~d6U13~+

                 . Wr--\   + o\ MA:M.b~ M LtS          ?u.rSUAWJ+ +-o ~ na. 'l
                   5s:e1eN 3~~ ( E)<.~\·brt \'/J.."(5EN.J*: +- Q.c_Pr)

       To \ot. .\; \~ wl\~ c__\£,~ Bp.,c\n~u-P. (b~J\~~C\1 ~&~lie__\<.
                                                   i

         ~ ·~Q.\ ~-;)~\c:.~~\ ~t:s~,e:\ e_ov.-~ o~ \\J\D~~\Me{'y C!.n~
        lt.xf\5 ~~ el\'Cr-K > {\~~ \_ ~eo$-\f\ 1 c.o~-\- a-C¢ G._~~'""·,~ \\~\YE~\~
         P.Dt Box \~3'0'2) ~~-( io\ S+A-\ioN, J\-u..s"''M ~&:NS, -?<g111-
                  RECE\\IEOJL
                 00\)ro"OfCRIM-
                      MAR 09 2.01S

                    JW8l~.c•                                          <l                    .
                                     S\~1'3.~Th~s               .!)__ ~     s=&~'\J~JMM'C~ ==-.Q.O\S
                                     '0'1 Dro-~~~~-1- -ff:sst:!'to~
                                                                                       ,,

                                                           , M \~~Pte.\ lNi\+~ ~-())a-' :dlo~L! FGV\JoSY
                                                             T ~ \\J ~J'to\oN-~ ~ 152'2 ~
                      I#d ~E ~UJ{'t o~ &~~~~~ ~f>?r:f\\s
                      'G~ ' \EXf\'5 , f.\~\1 f\.\ T ~x~S- \)\0,-so N.
 Do~~~w~~~ e:,~~\t&-
*s.3\~ \o:S \:t\A\-~r .

     \J.S.
L\~r\<, B~~fr\{'P\ C:::,\~~1\( ~Ml~
   \'f\~~O~E f:'/ \e.D\J..N;\'7~ F-:"1-1+5

         ~~-J.~~f"r~~. Or-i5\oN.~\ (.\~~\\Q_P.\\o~ ~\' W f" \-+ b~ M~~MV..'S
          Pw--su.~rJJ\ +o S3 l \ .D 1 ~ ~c . 3 (t,_~
                                            ·::

        ·\o T""fi \-\oN.af'~~~ ~~~ 0~ S~\& Lo~~
          ~'D~~ ~Qf"'ES,. \.:JuNI.~\&_ W~~~ b,~~\& \~~\~\c_~~
         ~Sif- \~ 'Th65. ~~0~ '5-\:)\u:.&_ ~~ ~\..W\~~r-~Q.~~
           aQ ~e.,;\\0\tJ ~& .Q\ \\t.S ~\"S o~~\U~\ ~\)\)\t(":A-\\CU ·.VCr.
           l~~\\ t:W ~~~&~'M~"S)\J~C'SU.~~ ·ta (4("'-\-tJE U;D~
          -:5\EQ.;\\ 0 lM 3 (~j '0-Q.- ~~ 'EX~"'S <:..a&~ Q~ C:.t-t tJ\ ~ f\A~
           \)rce_u=_&ur~__) ~~ llJo~&--:5~\.D -\-~~ ~o~\ +~e
            ~o\\ovd\.~ '.
EIRs\~~ \0\~          _      .        ~~- ~-               ..   ·           _.       .   _   ·
 Da~~\&w~ut;C:,cc&u~S\~ 53\~lo.J                  \5       \~Q,~~c\Pi\~\\'u ·-\-~e:.,
 \'<\\~J\-~\ ~~-t) ~N.~\E~u ~~~ ~.:.r~.~sa~1 ~B\)~l\5oQ
.\eN~'\3.'"5"'5£_~ ~~ct ,\ EXJ~S,                      .            ·            ·           .

}·D~. Rc\{;-\EU' ~~~-~...x~~\k$~~ \\\.e> \'c('l\~\~s ~~ hPr5 ~.:a"'\EU'.
                          (:\~E~u...~\-e. R.E{'r\(?-~ ~~ ~Po-W          I

bX)~). Thr- (:\~\- ~~\.d:- -\-a ~\E. G:e,~~toM~E.\\E&\-s \\'1\\fi\S~r-~\
         klit- b\-s~>iE. \.t~~"Y .1.~ C\ \8"", J_ \.O'l "SEC 3lC..~ PI~
      <TCJ'_\?. :2.D.. \ =? ~~\r~s \<tspo~&i::~ -\-o -:I:~l'J\.~\~-\-li:.\~
      ~C\~M.\·\- -b -fu~- en\\JT ~ ~t't""'\'1\i~ t\W~r.+\c:; \\-. e_ot>Y 'CJ~ -%\E
        ~f'\>\\e_A\\o "--\. ~""· Wr-\~ G\ ~~~~J\S Q_or~u..s J -\~(C ~\\::~ 'f>~ L\--
       ~V-:(V\\~)f_~~ \~\\ J ~25J ~~~\ ~\C 3.~-~t{\\t:J~~\N.&\JJS'I\ \~~t>fFM
       Wrt\i~U ~\s A:p,~\\e~to~) (tl\ Ex.~t~\\sl ~c~of'A~&N&Lurv\ D.Q-lAw
       \~ 5LL~Po\r---\- o~   "'' 5.   '3; ll.O'/ PT~~\~('_~~~o0\1.> t\-\N~ s cU~:so ·n+\~t ~21
        ~ Pro~o~ b-t 'DO!'ill\I\E~ rE:'b\}&..,;~ ~o~\o.u~, ~\.j 1\t.~SvJ<EPS
        -\\\~ lt,y -\-\.-E.. C.ID~;r-\) Ae..H·h~~e.~ RB!..\+."'21_~~ ~ L~oJ
        'vJ~~~ -t-~ ~\- ~\·~~\~Cj \.d ~$ ~A&£ 1 \-Q ~E. (;Gt-J..\J t C.t\. \t\.\S1 C..0 ~
        ckc_~~s -\-~f\\ ~cf\:. f:\\IE ru.o \ss~ -\-o ~E. \E.so\\JE~·
             ,,              .           .

\ Ex.l+i br± A,~             ·_ <~P\r'a{.:\,p. C~~QS-t\J.. f\~\d<=;>
 DoC!uMElL~ ~&( ocd- d-."2-+V\10\L{ A~ [)~ 3cYh~\q t:\-\E. \Dot~$~\~
.~\s~\~ \\*sc-\\J..\£'1~ t.._'--1~\f\ Q_\~~~N StY1 ~E.s\- kwts-s~.~~ro'S
 I EX.I\-S '1'7.3Dl A-s !'rsk-\e Al \oc<-'.S'/5 l<l\lflwl~~J t<G:\J:-t.- s\E.A- ~\~ S,\\P'l
\-ffi-\n£A5 G\'ftrs. MEIIV\Dc~&wM ~ ~ ·+v ~~ CD~()\~\\K: c~u.As ~d 1\lD
 ~ \f.SPoM"S£"5 ~IE. bEEU 5o:;.~. ~V ~NDtch \\.9..Q c..ou.A, Cnu.kClE~~
  D~iCE ~or c.o~-\ o4- G\(\1\0V\~w,_~ f-\.W~~\-s o4 ""f'EXJ+5\ /\~~ \ ~ens+~·
U.O \A~ioN o~ Ar-ti.J~\ \.D'l        of -\-.~f. ~~A5 Crv-~ rr. D~ Cslr.V\luJ Pc-o(1_~\t:U'E...
3.0\; T\-\-t Rt--s?ou~~~ Uto\~k-s ~rt.l\.D/ SrEC1~o~ 3(~\ o-\2-~c
·wA-s L-G&tr:.a\) C.f~\1\A~~~\ ~~IE. ~iAl~\~i_\i\l_3 +o·~fbuiJ.~ A
 Co-~l·0~ ~\1::- A-:p~\\~A-~to~ ~~ lJf'\+ oil ~\oEp,:S C.0<~l\.S)V\io~
 0~ ~w \~ <S~~t) P\V\1~ A~~ A-ll tx~l~l"t-s or ~rsi (AN."J A~sLJc.rs
~\ \t=&, l'A ~~~\~c_~\-.e. ~~\\i\MS -\~ &.A~~~ w~\~~\\\~l"'-l~
 Wt\S N\~~ ·-\-o ~E c_ous-f o,·~ C..r-t~MtN\4 \ A-ppEPt~S ~· LJ~~·ll'-l +~rr: 4-iME-
 Prr.:::Lrt~~ \D~ L~ w·l~\hl-~ r-~~SJUU.&b\~ i1ME-\)rolf"\ 1-\Ae~~t:.oM
 ~~\c.-~ fue.. &c.DW\~vUJs          GJtffi   f-E~l\1~s-\-~ -\-o ~&3. ·-\-rA\US\Y\ttr~ .

.()ol'l~~W~Vf\\~ ~\a.~-\- (\r\~t J\\.\e.e~Dhl-5. ~~~t\.U ~\<5 ~\.D~(c:\-­
 ffic{'()o\'~N&UP"l (DQ, k~ F--\N.~~e_~\'1\C£~ ~\tU& ProsEc.u..to\\' ~\1\A& C\*-
. Of't\ltt:'I ~~u:s E ~vv.& s \"\DGJS_.) "\ F-X.A-S ~Ot )'E.('~ D~ . ~\ Q.~ ~ N'Y s ~5 l\1 ~ lhl) "
\f\~y ~Ot3. Stt:-~~\-c. ~\\\s llo\ \. 2~5 \~ ~-Wa&- \)ul:. -\a ?ros£Ee.~£rs -
&'oo:sruo.. ~Elf' Pos.~~~"-lS. \lo\\- Tk ~tc.ln~ ~o\hl\.\ Ptd~Q~'S-f'rD­
_SE~r' ~ttowu.k~l\i-\-y f=\d_-. Ell0occ_,N__9l,~~\ M~ s:<i? \Nla E~d-
. t>u._t:   .-\n ?ffi\-,~,._\ &i-s~£ o~ it.e>th~c.E r-t~~O\"'!;JF>I'l\~ ~ f'lfh>~~
 t)~r ~P~~~\_va:o;M~~~~t:\.~ 5~ ~\se_\o:;W\t., 6~'f\\J. f\\~r~ tPrhlaL --
 3{~ LLS gs l19to3), R£_ctu.\N=-S prosF-C-~~orS -6 A-~~ow~~E ~ec\~\ ful62
 .3;<6 SPEe.ir-Y\ R~$;f;;o~s·\ bi( l~cS o~ t1-rxs~e_~r ~N..&. 5.~, g~ pfE6tt.c.~r
  ~ c.e..o__~-\t\~rt-~ bt \ r~y Ad-·                                    .
  3. Q!}. ~Eii,l.LIZSt ~ r ~12. +rAI\i5Mt \:tr>\ a~ ~c. \.\\1,?\i c rJ.-w.."} -\'o..- GJ"<+ o ~-
   H-A-'Dc.Prs Lo\~USJ ff\Ernor14\I\J&VJJV\ D~ lr\w thl S~~c{"-\-J (\ilU'(tf+~~\_\ Ex.-
   ji;~\i-sJ \..:.~\+r-rs, ~Y fW.:sLJEtrs ~c\ec\. tt~&.. ~ CJ~~r--tl~\Q_~ ~\~ ~~ ~\E~
   ~~ w~t~~ ~~~\~(!U~ w~:s m~Qi_. ·                                     .
   3.0~ To~~' N=_\p,~-" ~Pr-s NJ)+ ~Q_~~e& ~y ~~~N--5E -Qmrr\ ·-
   B~~~f'R- eo~~ M~\<l<.. \ t:U~uli· dtB.M<l ~t~\)(\A ~~Y-u~X~j\:J\s\NJ­
  (4-\--\Dr~IP-4\ ~"&\f\ e.\~~~~J50Y ~~-t-- -~w\.:s-si-.~t::>urot~Y-P--5
  -V'J'13'D t-~ f\lar c_GUJ\T oQ. tr\\\'1'\tt-J.~ ~~~~A\s Cle.<'\(J \+~\ (:\c_os\--~,
30~                                                                                 .
'"' I=\; tl~\~\-t '~P,.:~ OEP<c-\'1 S~oW5 ~E ~w-+ of ~\\M~N.J t+~~Js -
   Q_\ ~\~ ;   A'Ge\ Ae_~ \-A- ' t\P-\ ~-Yk<r \EO~+~ 'i ?d- ri£-Spo~ E:d          <9M   1\1~\'~E.
    by le.ttrzrs,' .~d.oJ.~ r-~diOO~ ~v,~~;AsJ4, By N:.st:o~s
   Ai\k& +his lS      L.t\s-T   l?.EAC'.   ~l4 ~~,       -r+ iS 1\lot(J ~b ~~~Dl5.
   As D ~ Thts \Y\o\-'t ON c~=t~      \o1tt}o \s w -s\\ u    NJj f'ESt:oMS fi2S   by Nrwa:.
   \1-:nX>\lE l\s-\r-& ~    . , .                                                . . .
   ~\ ,_\rs ~!T5 Gtli\\E W f\~ b~E.'fCI~ l>.-1\1.L{ ~tJi I' ~i'll~ DdJo\l:JA.Wt>.&S
   t\N\?a"S>~~ l>DDN ~\M \n'-'. fu\E \ cx~S ~G2.. ~ er~'MlvuM -\)f'D~~u.r-c_ ,
   LN c~~-\r-~ to ru:.\~115 ~.wo\l+sJ ~5~~~ ~p,-s W~o\\\J ~A\\~ +-o
    c:_~~\v wt~ fu£ \~Prs LJ)&!E. o~ ~~\fV\~IN.,j . ~E~\C l~-\ It\ 01\ SeC..
   3 (c.~ A-N-&. \s ~ \t\la_ 1~ B~-Q-~'t ~ 1 t\~ 'nPts r-iSJ -9~\ \ {2_~· +o A%r& -
    f~.r4\~~\\3 ~e. Pru ~s\01\-tr-:Y\ !+N..&_ CnP'Mo~ ·c.JJu.r\-c:sv o-\1 AN.\.J Wf't~U\1
    to his to<'\€:"5~~&Nett:. ~.~ (tq~T P.~s+-1~.x.'n\ \o\ts ,, All a~s (<)~.,.,
    ~-}~'8l~ ~\Lti Dd-30~~olL\ f\N~(c_c_A t\\oUAoltt),              r

 ~.DS. A-rt\c.\E \ l.D/ Sn:_dto~ 3(_~\ CifE-P\('\'--1 -s-tJ-Es ~~) \-Q ~n. c__e~­
     G~d\M2> 0__o\U"'"-t\ ( \\1(')-\- f1 or-osac.~o~ 0 9-~\Q£ JJ ~~-5(~~ ThJ- ~\Ef!C: ~\E.
     hlo «=S~,Tss~s:' TV\tt: PlE\\'~ ">~A-U (CnrJc.&.il4+c\virPN-=)~~-t)
     +o +~E tou.r-+ D ~ C_\tl\"\ti\J.J. ~WIP:~-s 1\ ~ 0-\) ~€: f.\\)p\\~p,)n'o~ 1 \'f\tf<\0--
     \'Pr~t\\JJ!'<\ D-Q ~w.
    AII Ex l't\rbi-k l"*"-rs , P...u. ~ ~w £6:5 -Q. t~JJ ~~ fT ~~;~,~"'*~:. r-ed:\-(""~
      fu"'- A~ ~~. ~~~~ ~J- .\\'~t~ u'lt6 ~e.. \!~+i ~w-oo. ~4 t"'-~
   ;, en~+ -\-a ~ w~~uu. -t~c ~\owatE.:9DJ ~~~~\ ~0\N.S~-\-k
    s~ ~ ~~~{\hl.~,~E'i-A-S ~&~ o.Q.- Ci~~t~~ ~roc__t~\C ~-t\drc.l\.01 J
    slE_~otU (3 lc..J ~ &(E:-s~~~ ts t\M \J~o~r+~o~ o4-t~i5 ~roe~
     6'<\li\J\ster-i~\ ~u:11t.S ~~~ ~U$         *'\t3:. ~~s    o.q_-\-~\s ~\~E..
     ..              <   PrAyEc    fer    Ri:\1d' 7
 .     LJh~rr-+6\lE) ~,£ffii~~5 c.o~ic\E:n&> rE\P~~e:r-) ~o(U.~~w~y-1\\E
   C::,ooch.l 'aht Vt- s.:W2L,S ~\bSIE. l rG::s PE.df~y r o:q,U£-:s -t~ 1+ .(11 ~'"8
  +~r:Jt- t~E. 0\ES?o~u&€.~ ~C\\c\ MO±TN&.~ill~- DQC-~M~5) \\0'7
 t-\-o.~E.A6 C.OrPu:S) (hl\.IEI!Y\DC"'t\~ufv\ E)~ \,__~w) {\. \\ 'Exfu h\-h j lE-~rs A~
·n-\-h~. :J~ usc_ ~ J.Q..So ~m&ud-i·ou oCV ~~cds Mohc~ to-\:~£
 L.cus-t o~ ut~~\U.~\       \\:~Pe;~\~ w\~\\1\). \\. f'ERr.Sel\1~\t ~\~lM~
                                                                      +\IJ\.\6.
Q~-h~r %E ~~ ~£.Y h)~U\E r-~O_u.E-s\-a\ Pr~ fu~ rE\~~P bmug"+
f\\\s \ \4-\cai\\ioN. l~Cj~ -\)A-,-t~ Aiti& ~P(S ~vlJ~J.\-u\-\AA\y ~ue\\ \~.
  R!:l~-\-E~\~(PcA~ ~\' ~) ~ ~0-~(E.~· ;~\{'~l\U&::' ~~~~~
                 1

·to t\P..NSM-\+_ t:.oQ'"=s a+~~ G\~U£. \\s~ ~Q_u_~~5 ~ ~~y
1\\\l:S~~ i\~E~) Pt4 A- ~\Q\ePr-\~ ~£~~~·\hl9 ~~ ~~ ~\U
LJ~~c.~ -\.;~~ ~\~&\~Q w~-s ~~t. ~\a~~ 0..Du..~-t               o4 C.\f'~M~IM~ f-\Q\)~5
A{:>~EA\s Ac5 &i\~~ t~ \\,-\-. lL.01 5tE.C- 3LC..\ D.Q- \v\_~L·~· f\5
\£au.t5k! ~u rF-\A-\-E:us \\:.~s ~& \\l:{1.li\MD~s e_~t\AS.
   I   ~~E~V ~\Tt~)' -\-~Jt ~ ~\g~Lour.J. ~~ Pt ~oPy
 t.J~s stt:.tu:\ ~y ~~ llJ\.dtE& ~~ ~\ ~'P~" 1--o
   C,\tcr-~, A~c\ Ac_o-s-\-A, Lou.~ of ~M\V\l~ f\\)Pfr_~s e?.a Box)
   t-~30'2 c_~p.tt,\ ~.Jnof\t_s ~~~hl TEXt+Sy ft~'ll \ ~clErk>
. OP~\''aar~ r-::>,~\CI}J ~~~\ek Qn~\.'1\t~ .D\0\s<t<D~ (j.<i"Z~ tr:O"\B'Ox)
c_a"-U"''tt:.Tt:XP:5   -'l.'/3VS- 3'0\ \\.L   \\1\~l\JU 5ttE~-\-- ~ts~~c-\- &~
 EJ\_~~

             <:   WcL\ o£ \N\1\N~PtiY\LL:S )             .

       Trus (          di'l&    >&>.y o~       E   ffi12~
                                  By    \){'OS~

                                   c   t'>Dh~Al\~wMe C40JiJ\q\J;.    ,P   ~S\<61o'.),

                                   P1
     ...   ,,.   .

Do\\1~\& ~£\VAllE. ~oo~ tut c;\d                                    ~ ~ 6. .J d. \_st-};
~b3\~la5 \teE\~('                                                   .J~\~~ ~ b\~-\r\~
       V,·                                                          t.oLLA- 6)-Q ~~OO~c\'y
t_~Ef'k \ 5N"br-~ lb\~~IM                                              C...O~~-=-)l~s
    MANt'Q.;~

                                      ~·   OcAre:tC ,, 7
   Ovu     t\t\-s c\~1 ~~ (..)~
                            .
                                -b~ "'tc~,& ~~ \blf~qo~~q r-~\~~
                                            .

   ~.p~\\~\to~ ~f'\ : \ ~h,~t o9= M £7\,~,h?-M\>--5·~
      Aru&. "l.t f;W\)~1\\'5       +o   -\--~\£. C..~~~~-\-\!\~~~ -:s~J.JL \nE

   I+ \s +"'r-f'~\'o,u=_) 0 r&s£~ '~ ~~ts.•i\- ~~IE: &los~~ c._;-\ C!l€f'\<.. ("S'e sJ\ ~
   _L'AN\.~Afu \y 4-r-~1\A\-\- fo Th\£ (1~ 0-Q_ c__{'\M\M~ ~l?c.Pt\5 Pt-c_o~y
    o-9 ~E ~rP\\c~ho~ ~or ~,t-\- £A \n~~trA-"'S c_ou-fuS, \N\~~<'~--
   ~ ~,Pt.\.\ f:x_~\\D\-\:s ~~~ ~ {\\-\~ 6.2 Lt:S~"5.22.so ~c\~ou
   8~ ~Q..u.fV\r;u-t~ M_Qttc~, -~Y ~w~rs ~~ ~ C:\li:f·+~+-~cn-~ ~4+\w;
  dP.t-e-            llibu.i. w~\c:_~ 1-h~-\- \\'~iUM-ctT~\ w~~ N\.~£.

                                        S\5~ -\-\_\s                     d...y o~ _ __
                                  ~             lo.'l ?~'d~\'j 3~\:...
                                                           X
                                                               ------~----------·