Court Opinion

ID: 4054563
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 05:29:04.219765+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:37.667950
License: Public Domain

I.
{)u 4=· 1 · i~ A/NJ/,·cAJr 1\t:e_;e:L-tsd ~ tu0-1--tt!__s of P.t\J ~fAdAvl~
.Ctle:d b~ h,~ ol\L9;AJA-I ~AJeY. ou 3·                          "''s:
                                                          Ths Mh c.fr'Jn/,-f IIJPO
?,Jed       'AJ   +hs      Z-&3   to   1t.s~.c.J Lou!\+- tJ        Tt::;){n-.s /-/n,;._i\ u LhUtJf'l>.
1\.ll ol +he: A-PPlrc..rKJh f~VIOU:::. (Jrr{Jcf.... woAk.. hAS                         ~V.J fllt::.--e.f IV
-1-f)e l)'ltb ~.S~1U trut-..t- oP 1-1-tt-MIS. t~ T~w.s.
                                                  --rr.
ANJI1UA1U~ ~ ...PhA-+ luO DN:.ft::Jt of- ~A1JJkk tuftS~
uu be:h"'IPD~ .:SA-aLL erutf-sA-baue. A6110"-tl.ug to lrw -1-he.. _Ld,~(
~~~~L+            1\CJ-of IC,~Q .Pl\ouidd lo~ +he -1-AJtt<Jslx... 61- f'/He:S A.vrJ
c:xc__fl ruSE      of b:::.~ be~o ../-h,;z. d ts- k 'L.t tn:.J A. -1--.£. bl- VM-..1 ous
toc.A.rl-ll:S.      s~ .. '~ou                i4.3Cl3 .. of --tl-1~   v. 7. L. ~- Govt:JJJ               lf?t::.V-1-   Cocf6.
fhb:.J\f.    ftf...f:_   ..St::Pb(A-ft; dtS-\-k.1U ~.OJf..,f.s.,. 1d~~~W !J~ ~/)6-kfl-k NU~t:d.SJ
:5UGh        h PrtJI f\1!1 I k    C)UJA)   ~Udjf:,   Mvd   ?t'J() 11. A-Oh   l(e.J "Jcii-.,f;cf   1L~DJJ;~ _!_A) .A-
Win~~ nP ~e"fr'S! +k 3~..11.A..Ohtc..A-I .Jui-..:!d,e.J,ou of,4-u..o{z) ot.                              tnd6

 dD~td            CCD\ts 15 oua /r:t(J(J;f\J!3 1U .J:>mc          ~u.J-,e:S, Eveu                 tr.S     S/Jec..,fu££
!Jy ~h~ :-1-he:. ca+h ~ud             rni=JJ\.s  fa -l--hr: Uu1 t-ezj .5~4-e-:J Gu.s-1-J·~tJ-I;oJ +h~
Att.o~d t.s. e:u.-t.+lcd -k -k.,ll-1 t.u1--t-h •'w --ihe dt.s+K-·iU -1-hs CL;/hG LuM
f.\.,llt:.SeLi -l-6 hl'rl.£., !Jt:::B.J to-inmd-1-ed ~ iUh,Lf. tit:JkteJ- .sht:J II hm..e bee«
fl\t).JJ'aJS{ Y 1\-Std'k..~ti\J IJy fi\VJ. A. fc9~fnl'r'i 07-clbh. I.S IJezd~d fu II t/ec_+ +'h2.
-k-_AAD~ aJ C!r313S trc;-lwt::EU -1-wb (L) dt.S.kiL-1 [6cA~5 IAJ &;u.u-/,as w1./A
 1-wo 09.... nfb~~ d,sk ,cJ- (AJLA.:is_, ho~evc:;,;... IUD ;sud ~'t. t.S ;u~-d 4,(
 t:JcUJANjG oE ~udle:s . k .. A..b~v-k>u 11.54-A--£, q1~ ).w. uJ z.s (_J~. A/f. 14-ih
  d JS+ 1'1Cf~ ). lhJ I~ {J,e ~ oil Au-1-lwx_Jfl( o1 1r CaJt,-/- .la !4LGiol...m A
Cou-lc m.fJ IM-at ~ t2..A~ .!Jb ~ 'o\J -IJJ,; &u.S-\-' M ou o1- -1--t, ~~ S-M-It;") .
 o 1\ +he f~otus. du A-Lkr.l +hut_/Z, uudtd.,. +/, w+ mu(..t~ ;s wJA 6 c.rl- suiJ~
  M~.Ju"'sd,dtw . .h.. d-A-1+, z_ 1/. .5~ c, 17 :s. vf. zd 9.~ CTu. {J... /LfJ;J,nfd.
                                                                  a

 ~ , -/-he., //U.S~ ~6 +Ae; oefcNst. tvtr.5 A-//o5d -1-o htiv6 a~d w,Jh,AJ
  _m_f-h .Jud, t..iA-1 hts"""-'d o t tfrt.M1~ /o.NfY" /0{/d. fha p-f_t, drw, ~ tv!() Loudu616:f
  110 .f-It.. 'Z.Co3NJ   d,5k,Lf ~+ (\ucf A-6.Se:~-f                  J_j   A   -1-A!tUS:k bt.db-£.
  1..u ~"    J   hou ld .!Je      vo 1ck.-d .

                                                  /iedt;;_{.
    A.PP J, c_rrv~   fh f'W.) -1---/, A-+   +h '-S · tno+, ou bt5 ::!~W Aud sA rei t+f'/, dfrvJ !-
     ~~~-                                                                                     l
                                                  u.J ,   +·h LoYft--IW   TotAJ M...M +h~ ..!::.~ SIJ rtV
                                                   o-P +h ,_s [ouL+.
                                                      ~~-:JPt:L-+tu II~ sui:Jm, fle-d
                                                          ~1~
  ~~:       4-·tS· tK
                               [a_-J_, t~ tA-bG   tJ   t 5:i_   VI CJ3

-,--..                 -/(opkf kJ.S . -=tt/o/34)¥,. hatS6Y r~+J.:r +lt'jt+-1-fi1J.J
             SAfl'lLk?:J

 rno+tDAJ          6! -ht:sMutA-1 wtt:S. m ~~ /eel ..tR .f;/,.5, P5. +a _'
  {')yl.     L\\.rnw.:r,l ~ ou 4-· IS· 1S

         \