Court Opinion

ID: 4055537
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:07:32.979334+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:40:46.416830
License: Public Domain

. 7 J/zo~/_S"’

_5_¢5_ 55 /;__¢_/ :_'55'§ j_%/_»». /@é .________@Qumg¢=.gmMW/qtAPPEALS555 __
_555247_7_ _ 475 ?_ 370/ ` _ J_UL. 10 2015~~~» __ __

 

 

 

 

 

_,Z'_ )-_~<,._v_ 570/05_7-/\_<_2;/_?¢/_<;_:%4_¢;@_¢7`/>,__5;1u_;_<__/_go: /Z'$ //0£‘:;.5_

 

___Z>__Y5 55_5§ ___ ____
_/'¢>_/4_¢5_ _ _55_4_=.5,£_ _ _74/%__ __i _ _ _./Z/..¢_
_5‘2»5_74_ »é::///M ~5_.5» 55:55,_/;2_ 5555/5/__/ :5/5_ _
_577 )»¢».//5)7.~#¢/ 5 .,2:74 555/554/_'5)/»%_%_%545_
.__5175__ _ _;/_2/5_54@ 775 _ 5/55_574_ _
555 55 /55_5_555 755 5 555___
;ZE /z.e_<.z<.¢»e %5/?€»<5 Z_S_é___ __ __ _Q_/75455¢_
:%_M¢_ _¢»_5<,_<415_% /_5_¢¢-<»@-¢7151‘“ /%_M_@¢ZZ¢ __ ____
54_` _5%___%5_45_
_%_ 545:%:¢ ___ ____ _________ _ _
,? _54__;5%/

§n!l A/z§o/ad/¢ _
_j;'_;.»_// _J_?/,,_¢_W,__J_}._ /_'7__ s'o:’zz/_
5 7 z_;__¢// 541 74 '
4500 /7/. 5_;"§"

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

. 4 `. k - 4 ' ‘Z@_:/¢_M__?'E: ~7')‘_§'3.3 7

 

 

 

q ~ _CO¢UQZ"@'F c/ZIM¢')z/Az. /_,.¢£/u_s;_~Z;ZQ__ _4/1,1_72____`--__

_a¢¢;%_%z.<_,é: ./_¢_/_¢_r_é/.-_%A<_._/:HL_Z{<_»____/z._$"_`£é¢£»{_)

 

 

 

 

 

_ jg_f_/p%_Qd_,_x;v_f{f_/Q_a_/_n_?g_!'_go_%ze_<;!¢a.»;__/:%_a_c.c¢M.a_¢./;¢¢*____

 

_ 0 ,/’ /A_¢ J/;€;/_'<_/,_Q ;,g_¢_/_A‘M_MV 72 4@/%;

J_"/_`,/o*_/
To _______ , ______

~_710_“7_%_*¢ z_~ez_£:_`_)_/z_e._ __~_/_`/Zej_o.///»___f_¢,¢,:_;¢¢¢n_z£_~:'£o ` _ ,
_A.~_jé¢!,g_Mn_?L_Mc/_J~e_/)q_£¢_m_¢<__,Q_LZZ_L.AZ_Z:L
_£/‘_:/_ r/’/'¢- 7¢ faber-74 )/f /:'A;L<_JJA_M$_~*_/_Z_~.?_Z_/_'d_éo_/_Z_Z/_G/_¢_____
_._£Zé'¢¢i¢ %4 ~J' /¢3/:/€,¢/ 7;/¢? _K.’a_z/_~<,_ZA¢_L/__/%_ _ _Z/;c___é_///l_%______..-
_ / //” . .
_.4/£&;_,&¢42,_¢')_A:/;/.o_<`f¢>_“¢?é_j__o_;_/)__~MQ_¢€¢M_Z$» 02 7/. @Z.O.Z//',v
_/Zo_¢¢j_%`-j_w_*_-Z¢_L;_c_¢_¢_r 7!<) ego 0»~7£ ZA /§/.¢L»-»» j ~; 511 éa.~ § y __
741/j ‘ /J j ¢/ 14 z,le @,//_7_¢ ___/o_/Ld..__a_p<:j_a./:zé__¢¢_é_d;_-___ _-
"<»//¢7¢// 749 A¢.//L,é*<,_e._a“__@_%e<¢_¢_¢?
` Z,é&- a -'/’/¢" /‘.e_»l*a;/ éQa¢/_/_é?_§
__/2.,1_ 444/4_4/7;/_ 44441_4 4444 4 43 4 4 444 /441
_57_5_% ~?_/ _40 4145447/‘0_¢¢_24 o / /a/w [55_/{->" A)’/£.£X/ j
///_‘4>_/4»/2/¢5/ 44 4»_ 444 %,g/_' /_< ¢5_ _:7_5445<¢:4_( ¢447.>'“_557__5¢? 7//__6511
voa/4r 444:_4 /5 75 755 /'_é)/j__z:/_§¢~5/,

/

5_1__1___25)__424_14/_¢54/7_/./¢.7__0_1/7 755¢__ _Z:¢’W 127-f (W_r//_ 75427_/ 7{‘/2/1», . 32'//

_4%’ 274/7 _4’4,/._1/_~/_2 z‘ / /7. /244 344444_ 4 54444_____
557/05 4_ :.277_75_5/ 45_4~_///'j5z5_ /~54_£44_<_ /:0_<2 424_<:3_ 075,4_¢444_

_ _274 1£_/4 4_ __7_4;7_ _44~4/ /_ zz,_ 4444.__ 441 /f/.$:j
572¢2:@22 4554 ___We_a!_`l/»;.r 4_;%_ _'5:3_0_ ¢¢45_ _';1!_66/ _/.20 _C <:7¢ 234/29
_CZM)_ /4/ 475 4245/wpa /_/222¢_¢_5?4_24¢4,,_ 252/2275 c 444 45 __<',7_5___ 72__?_/_5_<.4_ ____‘

795@_»’¢¢¢¢/`//014__//@/£14 __/_52/ éL/M~¢ /Q/-e/ce_f‘_x’ (_¢/é:~._d ______
_44_,4,/¢ 753 /~.'z_¢é’ 3:/ Cf*‘ 424 <7“4> /zzz))_@ 444 _

275/¢»-/»174415/5__45@ 4444»1_¢».~ _/____‘.._; _4»__4/2. /)4<475 444/2 22 /_________
_)*2111 <>54¢4'_ ._2'4,4_-5444 ¢_<._u 212225_ 424 _/442~ __5_<_/"2¢»4€ 45 475 k _
_4¢_:_/1/_%_-4244_._64’;47_1/. __>/44_/47__3 _/<__~_/f___
_»£14_;>:_`7_¢!27__1;»_ _1_1__24_1__¢__»_5_£_4!@1¢;_»__1_€&_»-__1_'77_¢>~2_@1[_@_____
_4?»_//1_<;_44»~/ 1_'_4 ¢¢J_¢,o/ go f/M¢_/_ é¢:/_‘_/ __ ___A;_,¢_j@_M____

_ _é'/_:¢;?_zl/__Z"/;[.V__AM¢_QML/`”_;_/AJ__A&~.£>Z¢@¢e__¢ __&14_! __ 14/____

 

 

 

 

 

 

_ '_gJa/_<. _4_7;%__1/££/_ _c_e)_x_~z\_¢.,/V_;_Z__¢..<./_?_Z_. 0__ 74 45/ ){¢4-_/_7417_ .7¢.,:-_@_&_/!)’_4_~¢¢;: ___ _ __
cé¢)_£-_é¢_M_&¢fl_L/:-€__ 4~/_)_{/_:/¢1_ __A_é_/_"h; ____ _J/_L ef_/¢~e._r_w/>_£_/_j?_ . Z_%r_é:zmy_ ___ 4

_ _Zz/‘_¢ __.¢_-_~/_.KA_¢u__L_¢_'é;»_»é_.z'_/%A_/u>_1.~_¢>_.):€__¢»_:4_2_£/.6_4_7:@_4:,,./_ '_ _ _ _______ _

_A/Al¢,_¢//)_@_é_t/e:/_h_/_zé_z_a//__a<);;¢.¢/_,;__2_¢¢_4_14 _,_Z_/p;¢_z__(,w{__y/Lj_/¢Z_Aé_éém_&_d,zzém._a;£/A¢____
__Al?géc&¢£__aézé%é_w_A_Mh.A/__F_fZ/i/_€__A? 117 of j/_r .

 

 

 

 

, @

_ dry 144/ /d/_/_ //O___Z_ 44_1£__//_! zj__//c__ _4-_4 .1_41¢ add

_//7 14¢4¢¢£1/ 4¢1_',_/¢’_-__42~4¢¢_./45/4_/7§ _¢-_a _12_/.»/4_ );1'11_1¢ /
_ /)/¢1//5_,» _/2¢4¢41:_1¢_‘/_ 4451:/_;£_4_)4_54_/¢1/17_:_ ¢1_ _/9_41_&1»

1 1/2?-{11_‘4.‘.’.'1__e-_Wj 1£_/_/_
//M
_6/4' h 0/4_ 744 4)1_1/4_44/ <_¢4_£_/@_¢/_~_/_4_¢1_»_4)//"1%€6{__&1/7/40//”_

 

___/_%1<_-£’¢_4.7_4/'~ J/é/e¢//&/_ A__£_a//Jm11{f_1@éad/%/%r_<7¢¢4//Ic1c1__

 

___ _ j 1 ____ 1_1/1 1141 1414 __
1 .. 1 .___.1 .1-11 _-_.._1111__ 1111_ ‘ 14 l _’£71' _1.144 _¢_4_! ___ ._
______ _ __ _'____ _ _____________ ¢Q;§§/_qj l_c/%n'w» f‘ /_7¢$"5’/7/ ___
1 1 1 _1.1`11111111 157 74/4¢// %/14/2¢111__11_111
__ __ _ ' _ 734:)_-44_1/_15:1¢ 6
_ ___________211_411_/11,/. 774 7 7_:"1€3

   

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

__ _ 511/54267_80__5£4£1¢_&¢7.£'012

 

J'Jz//o/ :;_Aw-J_¢H_ \/"’} _ZO(¢,, 19753/7/. 542/ng _/0/'€,.{41¢__/ 7

 

 

////`¢"// /¢¢-f' 1/4/>1¢¢/0/ /'.__/J_'_é_.q'_ /;_/£/_l-L_j;/p €' "7

5 z;_ /;11/1// 55,,,5_ /5_5_'11/_1/ 515/_>:4_/// 4 615; 1€,_1%11111/

 

1 .Z&>/‘é_/"_ 717_5:£5_/_/_7_z£_¢_Zo_/:./'_&_£anj_)_o/¢c/Aw-¢_¢ 245¢1_¢/¢/"
_ jo_@/w-/&__ 127_€_/~;:_61~_7_¢_/¢47/_7%_%/;¢_ _<>_/_7_/_4¢_ _,5_1-¢_<__44_-1/_

 

__C_O_Z`/‘_'e_ _¢'

 

 

;1;17:£_172__;;@:<: , /JUAsz/LLL_Q_QM§Q/;LQJ____

5,/_<_41__1 1

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

____ _________ J‘