Court Opinion

ID: 4055966
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:28:02.002103+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:04.644446
License: Public Domain

'
. fO~ TtfE C.L~k tfF'r                                                             IA'Yl~ 6£)(T&v i 7 g7 SD 3
                                                                                   F'DBEKIS&.!J cv~rr
~-OF CR!Mif'Jid_ iJ\PPEM_$                OF'Tf::#\;5'                            t2-o71 P.lv\. ·g 5 2 z
AUsn ..J, TK .                                                                    A.s;~tfi~t~U~
                                                                                COURT OF CR!r.,w·J~1 A~At.S

                                                                                           AUG 10 20\5

                      A 8oU( .lt-i£ CAIO OF"' M ltV J ~wl A LEtv-t6t&tlo/~p£J:JJWk
          Witf61   r      INCL.LJ0ctl; L,       A Mtmcr--J PO~     MPDtAfi'M£1\J! CtF C.OVt.J5£L

         6PviGL'\W\.-LLY FtL£b IN z__q !1:!: Dts-netc:r ~T i ~ALo P iAlTZJ t                        covNH,
         ltXfl"$ &1\l ~BER llllir Zlllc:fj&:Xttt8'fi"'At); Z; two (z) L£ThSR6
         ·ro   THE. ~.NAME".D CDVKI MNZKED GXtiiB'iT5 '8~~-Nt;>"'c                            ;J'

               f hlet-ER. RCCEIVED fr(f;J\JavJL£0b£M&JT 11\A-T 1iflff P.4Ck11-be t(TtD
     16£8\1           R(C£i VeD gy YoVR 01-f=-IC£ 6fZ WHr-11 ACJ70N HI\·S Ef!VJ
     T¥\-1(-Ef\l      R~DW6               ·niE MOllo.tJ       <

               l1i£    '€,\'t\"i'E   C.OUN6EL     FtiR    ~-i=BJbS~S   IN A*N\CD MS 'lH-A-1 "four<.
         ~ .MOST ()RJ;:£1<. Tttt ~Of,0"fM8J\ o-t==-CC!lJN.SfL                     Ft:1R.    w~ t l oF

    · HABEA:~ ~~s                      ()IN) JA'(        PAR.nwt.At< cAS£ ~ (fNl~,s llTcives}
            r. AM         UNf\13L£ 1D 0-&Ti\iN 00LUM£tJIS 1V 5utPo-R-r- MY                            CLA/Ivf)

         Nt\iU-i   {S    TRUE 1\tJ!J WB6TifTIAL 1 EflN~                 -A \llDLIBlD.iJ OF l=DVRrH
         A/VtfNOMeJT .PRffft.G-iiOAlS PRCAJtD&D                        ISY THE CD.NSnTI.J710N
         OF Tt1C UNfiED SlrtlES fSIL-t... DF RtGtfr:,,
               Jlif      U.$, 60fREfv\t c.ov-R-T MAS RUL£D THAT fN.DI~[1JT,JNCIY(cGK-

         t\1tt D£FEi\ltWJ\5             R£61~1<£ COUNS-El- FoR         wR t\ llF liA~~ CoRF-vs.,
         TMtREFOR.E           r      eo   NrJr wA.NTlD P'R~, PRo s£,o.N f\ ./'JEw
         -~ Cet(j~)~ PR.a::fe.D\NG B'A5£.D                             64\1   t-l£W RULfNGS           MD
         LI\W occuR.tlJb Afl=Ck. M'f O"Rt61tJAL ~Pi..JCf\TlDN                                       Fo~
         WR.q:- OF ·N-t\:15£1\:; QIR:R:Js,
        I     i-IA\IC     vv~fTTttJ !v'IAN'Y I\~~£'(S AtJD L£QAL .Att> oR@.fZ-fntJJS
     Mf.J      g££tJ utJwrcE~srvL- o€r-At'\l 1Al6 R'-rP~$-JTAne.\1 oAl PRo gcxvz;
      iSA-siS      1    6o    PA-R. NO:-Jf           t/Ail£ t\-Ab THE FRDF~SSiDN.A_L CbURT£6 y TO
      ~                RE.s"Po,~t) 10              INOVIR\f.
                IS     l11ER£ A RELbRD I C:AtJ D1nAIN                             Ff'-f)lv\ YD?JR, OfP:t.C£ OF AU-

        FiLi Nb 5 BY               .Mt. M·D THE. S!AllJ S {)F 11+£/V\. -ALL DP ;.N'{                        1\ffi_teftrl£9JJ 5
       RJ\Vt::     BEE.,J'' DctJtE-b W1TrtouT W-R. lTTtN R£c:bR.b'                       1
                                                                                             w ln,-wur rvJ"t       6DR.!
       Ofi- EKFL...At\lf\ll&l-.1 vJ H'fJ 'lHAI J M l b.J{T Cvvet<.£:-Ct PR:oi~~S                                      bR.
       EY<.~s.
         IN Tt-!!5 frJGTMCt                    i      PALO PiN'ro      ~ 1Y-- CAv-:c-               14l2'2. -A,            1
       fikJE A CLftiM IHAT HM ALI<Ekf.JY S-esN CA6ES CNf3f?-TlJR.'-JE_D t ......l
      YoVR Cl:n>RT'                l). S·.   D \s\'R \ CT ~ M .D l-H£ St)f'Rf:N\-5 CDL)f2,T Fv'R
        \ D£Nl1CAL Gtr<(.i)MSU\!JC£5;
             ..f       CAJJ N-OT U\'JI)ERST1Wb trJttY .t. AM NMlN(; ££' MvLLi D1r=P:tC.lJU'{

        0611\V.JlNb R£Lfi£W',.                     _J._   G-HDLLD 1\l-tFI f6t.   RE-~UIQttl ID tt-/R.c CP51JJV6£L

       WrtfN THe t9\ uw- 1:.-i-E s CtJ1Ttf 11f£ tS-r+ITC                         Mb   lTS fi-At\! ()L w6.    or   .M t:,
        N~ CAN 1 ffP~t) 0~£ I

                                                                            £f~~
~ ~ \,~'1( 7 9/i (pw -c0
                                                                      JM\Es      ~               !5/z/ls-
 {)Rlf,f,J~f- AfPJ...tC.:tH'lo.N