Court Opinion

ID: 4057435
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:37:09.211442+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:32.123682
License: Public Domain

z',M ii §

z jay f
ukiaqu CSM§;";' §§ i.,»!éf” ¢N€. ij`k%* iii ef@ QJSOQV’Q
ll n 4 _€;”§`_‘_/éib%qimi `

 

\`J`i»<é"{ Z. €Lm~l£/’€

<)\é,j `,}"{,3/\,)

w.:.>a Nwi i é;?»'f'i~

WR ii 35"’3¢ my 63 du 1

 

      

.1'{'$“
w.
' §

 

  

document contains some " ` v
' pages that are of_ poolll quaiity
at the time df' imaging

   

1141 .

 

   
 
  

  

'T iii i'io~w»z@iii /;wi€i€¢~ ”';'\7!';1£7£

x l `}?f$rl¢ HN¢:!;K:!} g
few ¢.:'§' /\/ow ‘~37£’/`¥ Z»€

 

"' :`,;,.'f?"z;?»s* “`” /v* " ¢O z
§ FJ\MM&TIZSA frij.zfit/{ 55 iv 3a /\ii,/'é?flo/\ ;, vii jul dféciv¢r/\"”‘BN?£ vZzi/,w:"
ioé»fl:»£; ’¢~J;i'€i ~.)U}/W ii ww#"/§gj)&ji"i §§ v<§ f}g( vii x `Ll id h
RB€ONMO}//€Bi €/`N cif/U;W€EI, 251 `~érzw-> wl é § n H

f"‘”"i 7

 

 

 
   

 

   
  
 

-1;"`" ,_ . . v 1 r.\

v §¢ c ,¢ :~ ., v

~ . ii - c/ » Jz\zé,-é£¢,iéw,#
§ ~ , ii PJ ""'* ' ~

,~i cpif<¢;ii£`/§ ?€:) //iww~ md wm <1’ ‘ {‘

§ ril.£f@,iiz:‘c!_ (w~@"*¢” “’*’i) `/ §§ H‘£" *'i WMW

 

   

 

ij 1 "°

 

955 <, 31111"5“1 imide 3111115£1517“¥, doug/1555 5$£575’ ELV$N §5'$*`5`
55€1175 § 151;‘_5' 511¥13/.:5' 1151\€175 1361/1453 1155{17575¢1.155~7}'5 5 511,3;' 5
6011;1\5111 755 .:£ 511/1 1161 15515’" 515 o 511[‘1\111"1€ 11111111`5'3 715/iv
115511111»111%5 1365€15/¢515& 1375 /éX@..,,éw/\u§’)/Wf’!£»i"&, 511111'505
535££~51;1,11“17,55¢¢5 "” 51115 1113 1731 11 3., Md 1111?5 1111 1111
1111.={1::55£11:1?55, (`5'£7'5\\~1€31"\1;‘>#£1£/{)1\55»:€55£311"‘\ §§ 575 `5¢1.,1/15 »3115'
1575 513 559151§“1 5517115 751/11 !5"’/’.11.~/5<511)/51115131?~1¢‘ 511 5 753
{}1\0~_‘¢’11-,5§€~.¢,`5 _ l -.
1111.11111.;111£§ 31‘...?5'15£ 1.£1 ;:1 ‘»\/'. 3553 511/1133
571@\;1\1 171 215\ 711 15\11111)111515 ~15-1 -1 W .51”5“1?"”'5/ 5751 11155€.»1)‘\1 1515 5~£55 j
~";S 7511~311:051'1~555”151)11\,5€11~1 v' 5.,<1¢/{1;*1531€1 ;'} ié»ii 117&1»~1 1375 "
5 377 1505 L. j£: ..»555 (/}”‘55525) `5':5`§ 551/515 ..1‘ :5101¥111,;1#11', 55101\1'5
11\1:{1,7 11111:15 555 5:1.14..51\1 1555&¢.1 1111/§51111 dei¢j 1955
iiiw;i¢~...£/ 1§?_/311€>5 11111,1511515<1/5¢1::!/€, 7551£ |151\1»»11.11£ .1§ §\»‘5\1);1£ 7111~>01\11/1.».1
151-1111 1<11/1§311’.`1\ 75”51€]11111£1~.11,-1£; 1215 51'1'~§1 111175 132 idi{‘£bwdiwj¥” 111.:11.3

1121 lhde 17311£111,1111,1» 1"50\1&15\£ :555
311;1‘)5311 5 V 551/11 1545/555""”117‘15 377 ("" 11 59113)

550 §;{]5§5,¢_,/4 ";':, 51‘,'2915@5 5}15,- 65?3:17"5565 75/¢5!35 713/51551’11 b 757511,)/‘\1 1111 v
‘51&~11\11)71.57 111/11 750}~1/°1~>111\1 111550/*'5'1£ 1172 11 111511311§1
1.13,1;. 15151,'}111~: 3 555‘~5‘510/11 7911 3/7‘111:1_755 5*1<1~11;, 711111`;1 1“1»3115‘515€,_.-

5£1<5 5.1»5..1 1557;`1id`569 16305. 1175 555 5`51;"£5 65 /"1 7£*/»1;_:,1;:_.117(

  

15> 5\5 5501\ 1151/511 011/€5 3311113111\1 1111755111115131 515 555)55
559 5511~.1 5591»1/5\`5-' 1111;1!€ 550 1750 dwi 17151,1755~

7 7 555/\ 1111.‘111/125 2511/5 1111/1175 051,~11111 715 51~.… 11 1153
5 ' Uf\/}FNY v - ”715;5 555 \N&‘:'§ (3./<`1’5550/;5 5 - ~~

¢¢¢¢¢¢¢

53 ')`,3 §3\{.':,3 3123 533/35 /3§¢"` 5~`§/25/}] 651/321“1;39/‘3»51;) 551 1113355,\3 511
" 33 3;;>']_¢0/\£ )£U]`§ /\&1{0;\15:53£'33¢£ :O'»§ <-01‘£1\¢31 livwa §1"3 .,;;1\1 UN5.53"

33511 3 351 51’1‘11)113 1551 133 505/3333 331~1"<35”>/31 11311331_:» 13le

3 1 WL»J NOT L/€N'It¢l"’/

 

13 > T 33 1333 3110/4 31 135€`13#3'3`3 Ui £`NJ f*€[{“éz/J!> W<,~s /'1(3,3$51.22 643
153 N'GN*~`L 5;/1/{ 153/555 5111733\ 573§ 5.3-. 653 5/335551{;3\ 553 351=1,§, 1153
53 351.)51.15553 33335 1355 355153’ 5~/}315 5355¢/¢;53 51le 3
3303 33€1 33£ S::'“ 333 IJA;A¢G¢`ANZ' 131 cMIL§Z 363¢5 513 `7351}3: 3551/ig
I;CF/~J§f`¢;{ /5511}35`,/3‘> 505 651»1155551. j 1351/555 V i7.3 d`{' VG!#£§{, grid /»153 " """30 ?£/13 63:§}~"3 1313$1 N£V€/§ 3)€£.‘\§
€53/\1»11455’“2:03 NQ/“\ 513an wéc'){fd 323 733/153 505/173 13361&,/31~5//:3/;¢ 313 .

7> 3/5'3 335 3 35/131331€31,551333" 35}113 5153>.»&€¢{ 511
/‘351/\!535113£ 115 11 3 655£ (15)353£ 5 135305.1 11/< 33 31£1;1/`~1!£;» 1555 513
\51`3/ 3155\103 f»ié;) ‘N 535¢_,,33' /`4;7;»4 3‘(55533 C‘FL§N 739 1333 /`5 333 3<.13 1313
5~5315 115511\1_5}551 C,.)(i<») ' " ' ‘

 

   

__ 5353~513"` 1555 15,}%15£ 15.;}5 55 155/13 1351 11151)3115 ;
.W5N7L 33:3 3315 733 3512?737<‘1133 1951/353 53 /33 1533~31 5/3€33‘55& 333 1

r~.

"' .:‘1
5 ' d
. "~l

 

55 »’_ 5 5 §~ n - §
.. _ ,,§¢55.,5.

‘ § . ,~+"°"’ ' '3

’r §

55 556 §§§ §§§ §§§3§~1 §§ §§1£`1$3 331€§31/§:: 9 11§~.,11€§" §§11§/0/\§
big 963/(¢§!\§

Q>`H§ 7 Dw`§`/§r£§l'(yu§%} 1393 / find FNM"?’ 7['!¢1`}

§14§0 3§3§§§/§1 1.§1\§§13»1.3§£`13§ 1139va W1'[13§3§" §1>1”1“€1\§71

§9)5§1)5 )§i£§¢ §3‘§3!§ 1133 §§i§' w§§§ 3111/1233 /§Y N_o 1)§ §‘13»»1.‘> 4

O§`§“ 1915"1~1 §o¢ )1§5 W iZ’§/l §§ ’; 1"¢§£»~§`§‘1' 931..1'§`2,~:§3“§§'§‘)1)11 o/q

`”/K§ 6§ p‘/c)'\§€§¢i*/ 1113 '““`" §;`§§1§\11~13¢]9§ 7£#3§/}31£`¥ `éw‘ §;;§§ ga *
ZVIG'§€NLL &'§r~:()§ §1;1.§`:\ ‘.1»1/1§§1§.;§€?§1;4?§§¢3§§§/5§1§ 13_§’§ 151 §§\§§,S 5
§FJ€`§ §'101~1 `"` §}IFVH\{U 131§,5, 131/171 79 §T~'M`§§; WOM§A-,;j
w¢'§ 'L¢/‘§'W'..§§“£/V §J!\§{v§w/

)/“§[eal/\{ §}1/3 L€¢Ui!\} § §§ V§'§'j N§I:§ §}V £./§ 91 961 911 V¢£A§y / ’W§_§
C:§¢§\.§di 5>;‘?€[3£&\{£)°\§{3 H€/V /¥§;~i/£` GWE)/*'r‘\[ 90 531}`19’)19(3+ C§NC~§ big 1:_3§0§ ?§§yl
£§§.)~IY§N& /<¢/3!£0/13 §§th .. . w§fl§m.) /* §w§s‘,§§

 
 

- 333 ~1§§,,§1§ .§@5..§ §§ 1111 Q§m§§ §§a/ §3/~.2 ¢§§§£ §§/§w:é:»~ §§§1§5§ 3§,§33§ 5
13€1»’,~3.;’§* * 1"0¢.§1~§§’ 1333/33~§£&¢§ §£')1§'§§£ 0~§1£§»?1 §5§ §;§{ &§1§3 §§ `
0'§" §§§€, U.D [)33~1~.)§° ?Lu'§mM 6316{"/€ §§1£ /5§§” ii 33.14\/1§/’;,§§§46§

h W§"§§L V-’ §§‘» 199 %§1‘; H‘u§?’§\/ ¢J¢»»§Zi 1913 111/16 jrl§ ”W!`}§ 51
aims 391 135191».)¢=1~3?§’1!€»4){')£3131`§ 113 131/11 17[51~‘§'?1\§`1€ 1’1@}‘1€; 913 §/11~5\"§
1315 §§11§,,'§"§3£ 1"¢)§§1§§/ wm ca1 1321 131 F§,¢§§!/§/ §§ §§1§§§1/5;§1,,§ §
i §‘ 3 §§,13§§3»3/1/ W»§§>§ §)1 1§1§§§:§3§ 553/§ 314/said § _ _
§1§§§§1& 3§§ §§3§§§15§.'§ !"” 1331 v §1§11/'1§§_,_._§_55
“ 31§@(§1§" 1§,1§!*17§5> ,
5§§§§

 

f

;:,5
33
'§_6- `~1-

 

 

5”:31‘~ ih.~ dwi\?£ 5 3/§3£333‘3/5 3£3¢*`3?{03£ (:M 1\»‘3:53353)/3

\3}@}33 3 P£i: 733 333 351 36/<€?£333/3? /xé`wéw W3

-,_. § wi.,w 333 333?(1/ W'3f3 `°N 7fe 3N3{ // 3 wciwf‘

i}€ibéy~ii€€? 303 wb’¢xv/czfijé` 3/§“3/3/¥5 563 }}mf"iio `lL/*l` 6/’¢?3,1':)3“.3}:'55¢03[

ii 373 i ;g_- i>/l)}:i 3333 333 £iY 73333{3!€£0? ii£ 3333/m /33)333»3
333/33333 335/5313 iii 333/33 iiwz:zfiv€$ 3333 i£€»/

/zi$'8 333/3333 3333 333.3¢}/;/ 331/3 33333 /3 _}3

3333/336&3¥ H.~“X§`Co»w¢éi§/Q'W¢'WJ 03 //3 f?é ill€M/_ 933 f\'?i oi'
3 _»'-;3333¢3 3 233 333 l 353 331/3333 .§55535`5'31333/~1}3"
'53£3;93!'3\¢#&&{3€ `l£/',e"` '§JME$ poNI£¢Wv'¢"-;,;UN jim fiui[ 033 {3¢\}@{
_:N film iii `}FBN dwi £Cf ’"¢'TOF$¢)F:N[/Y 135/469 !,/43!’\{¢:€1/65!}7¢¢? 5
733 3£/ 33 3333 ,3 3/"‘@3,/“?¢/ 133 3331”€¢1337£ 333 3731333£

3 33/ .’5)331!< 333

   
 

   

     

  

 

735 iii }/~JT 033/3333va ]“‘/ 33:¢“£ w¢>}f§ ii ii 33 iwi£ 793
5 CL) iii`i¢§i@!€ §i¢?`i;£§ '55555”,3'3'3 3315 i""`§ oft/333 13 »Wi ?!3¢47{33//§/
:é»/”¢;au/~id€d 331 /3?% iqm,i 3313{ ':33/ 939 163 m¢i~f»wii£oi

 

  

3hi L,QQ¢§ jig/713 pMCi N£#`?[; `Ipéf*( GN}J 133 117 is€€£!j ;`Wf‘€j,`f§>;£$ 399
373/33 Fé;}/ 333 _ é`/d/V
/33_3/¢£(;97£3/ 375 ‘JLJA:{ 363 6

' .s;;j
:,v"\. '
w
51

 

 

"’}

,l -, §§ l j

   
 

 

 

' ~r

\f:§€iv wu v§f\'i':z§ §§ § §M¢£ GNL §£.5/’>‘§§5§ ((’5)*

§ 5 5555;(‘5,§_`¢{,55,5,5 §§\55`§/£5)»£ §G/\ {,A(f iva/54 /`il
555€ §5:5555;5 §5.5/‘-255§/55'555 iy §55555“ 545 z L/ j 555.!'§55
§ viii [?H" 5~)§/555§ i/`.¢,w/§ § fl§w»o
50 iiac»>< ‘;?540
§W* 5151/’}€,5 w§§)i¢.»., , §§/0§'”“§~5‘§@'

 
   

'- y 555 §§ 555551€5 §5,55 555 535 1 5,, 555 5555,/ 555553555 555 ,
' *~~5’5¢"" 35 5 515/5 5 5 §/w §5**5 5" ' `

Wd{j“§m}\ .V 655}<.55>'._),1:’5“ § W 5““'“ 68ij 584 (`?"5:/\:, c¢c)‘#) k
§"”i‘.':§/r£ buss/klm i.555.5/i 55§ '” ,z f€/ M€d §§ jzmd 555 555 55\55…5§<“

W§‘§\g€! §§ §§§' d£/¢fo§§d C§U§`U!V éni§'" §§ §/£ j!w BWN Nmi /§5».9&"

     

Dé"`c`ibfl>£` §§ ){\65`51.55§¢5/; 555 /fv‘¢§l;f wf~!§ ~o?t Flf~":s 55 //w/)éé/é§,)
55515£`55.5 @i&%.» (55..5¢»1¢'}/?} iu£»w/% 1315 [3/55€55 565 055`§ 4

 

 

 

b?l¢>c">/ id 5,555555”55 `