Court Opinion

ID: 4058232
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 09:01:13.360549+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:36:28.861423
License: Public Domain

'??, 0/() - D tf RECEIVEb          IN

        '
                                              !J-1   -,          COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

-·~~~~~~~~~~~~~~--
                                     {_'
---~. .L:y~TiE                                  ~;· lif-~L-     ~gzY /(1~/_ _ __
---------+~~~~~~~~-~~~~)Lc~v~e~.~~~o~;~~:~r~.___________________________

-------1-------~~·--~-----------------------------

                                                       T~is do~ument   contains some
--------rc;;:;;...~ /&.LSAV .5)C<2fl'&ZY · / ~--S____pages-tilat-are-ot-poor-qoaHty----
                                                       at the time of imaging.
-   •       -~----------------~~~-----
-•~~------------------
---------*~~~~~~M~T~O~-~c~~~<0=£C=-~5~~/~~~~~~a04~a~
------t--L-L~.u-;;~.-!::0."'-'''--t::r/(";O.b-f- b La3 ~/to-~ ~ Vehck. A;,L
                                                            Q             .   t"( .   '-..../       II                /

-------l~__p(" ,tp~- 6&,AwltP(A.. zt6e h.e ~o/                                                           ai alr-tP~-/
-----~a..:.?2?2~-tr~"r Cu./ft~/-/(#·t-2,

-··--~------~-----------
    ~ar ~s av-5eLaec. /3.5ue C~geef'll,.'15 &tz-
                        . ·" n·6'k-n...a.l C-/v/1 6/sit·f5 v/.,/allak'L                         y,.      &cac?e .4e.
---'-----f-'~7~=~~.£d&n. a_ Cc~~e,~?...L_,~A=w~h~"::.J.;'! /Is d5"Averl5                                          &r     c.:/tc.ce~~>-es
  -------T~~-~~~s~·~u~,~~~~-----------------------------------------

                                         ((                 1/
-------+-<-&.,..,.&."--'&-'<-.O=t-J<-Lt-"'-'~6"""~---'71/~-&= s-;f,,?;~-ek2lf~ce -    ?Jus               &..6 /zv~e&:l -~""-=5~-----
------PC=;;:';~!:::..!)t-1..-:..;L!~_~~ Oe!J~,._.I 4~s _~'k;/ ~ e~&.r                                    /??P#"*'     z0
--------j..L--/.4~vc~·$~e_/LJ:kce. aht-rj h.J/&.                              t..J/'/'6     c?/'~~                  a¥.,l5t?t;
                      C-../Jie4.   a          (,h){,-.._   4/c t..J/It-       A ./              r         ~   ./a-Ao         1/~--

--·
~·~~----------~------
        'YPre5.54-n Ac»elvt6 _5e:C..... ______                             ~0S            Ll~,,:L.LT
                           wCe.!'5         I> Co/e:/Mves    t0 _&.   [L/o/?1#      XC~
--------:~=-=::..:::..;.:~=~-'_.b~~=-.../Y ,J /ER¥~ /~/ 1??5'ihttL'4
-----~~·__,.JZr'---=.JC;..·'-!/ee-tce.. /1.9·/- he C£>d~&&/hs·l acct.<~~--f_/__:;··V'_·_ _ _ __
------f-t~f"-Ce.                 hH-l.-5    ~.t~/hd c~O~.,c
                                                      C7 7
                                                            ..

                 r.·o. /,1e.Mc,Lk a.5.s~s·/~v.,ce_ o·IC'ou;-1se/ /jg.r t:~
-~---l-k'a_·~7--7P/~9-r~l~                                     &-c   &-.   eavri;       &s      ·/U:L.____
______         ~'-"'...._11r-~""'~t:H-t.5 ~-r Av.5 .tz.~!e/t?tey r2l d.?r::...eR'l~--!_:.15::::.._. _ _ _ _ __
                                     v /',;.                                            r/41-

-·
-~--~~l~~~~~~~~QJ~~ ~ ~~~--------­
--~----~~~-=~v~~-=r-~~~~--~~==~1~
                                                         JZ~~~--~-~----~----~-

                                                         ' recadagp(fi?~S a~i:¥'
                                                                            . ..                       ~~----

~----+~~Ce c~~ 6-e U.~Cf51h/k6t=acc.«S.J..,..L/_.y_·_-,--_ _ _ _,.....
,.....----.-,---!'G--·~5 .l~(Y~~ Lr/Q/1 C:&eei
               ~Sec cc-//~..... qa:: ~ ~~ crf- ,.5ua t: a a/ CtS?Rt-
------J-L.~~-L-~~~UL'6:.&ta&~r0/a-ks ~=wC~:S----..:(Do=u...::e=-._ _ _ __
                 /Z?CeSS i> /1/    C".Qp-cz<.hvMQ        /~~e<( ~.;.-~1-.f; t-/~          5t.tet._

-----~'-"-"'---'C"'=·=~vd /t:r~,>tt·~~~·~_:___a_,v//.er;s~ona I 6&ncl t2C £v ~th~ ../l_~~:.vlt"'-'-1-_ _ __
                                                   ~                                   r          ·~
                                                   _~ ..                                 A      · _:;,_,/_ /1 _
----~1--'-"'-~·r..s.'-~-~-j y                                             ~ .;fzz:t7e. I£ /t'&/-- ~ .&6:
                             .                             ..,/       1           • /     /_

-·                          1t:W1
                                 1      /1
                                     r:Jr-
                                               ·             A    /         /
                                                     C-cL.&at.{~L e.~..t::J::..L
                                                                                _ _/"'-

-------!~=..!:::=="1----'tv.::..::::.L...!-0(~_'~i_~(=L.·..L)_(!......:.~--L.qit:_!J:;_ )/CJM. ~~~-~ &;:1{ /1pc_'-(J&~'-4----                  l

--------1- (k;uvcseuJ ic.~ /'!&/- s&Jal~-----
-~~--+~'?l~-t;Jfe- res~! Ike#'(_ 5d-t~$ot/~ a?&;s- tfit/..L.~-t.;lfc."'""5,____ __
----,---+~_71""-'ededf-· fl2cpl-6k/6 {JR~G~a~· &zf?fb~~-
_____,_~M .6u-f d~~~_e/_Jct£c&                                                                      ~"664~~ /,~~-                            ____
----~..:-F-_-...,_l_(_G2_) /6c,                            Cede            Co~, p?~ >-6£5 rr Z/ a M~I-
-----~-=""-~'-L.!=:..o.L.....L.~W,"'-"·'-""~.:..<...~.:Z...t=e-~#e-=-=-~-/shf h C&c/Jt5eUL/&t¢t?Se~ ofJ
-·.---t=:-~'-:!8 A 0ui/fp_a_&cpvced~~-.& C'.19v(l-_
                            >~ -li a          /5e~ rik. A~#r ol' /I.e. na.£re...                                                   &I :Ate.
   •
----f-L-'j"'---;2LP~~!J 7d> zf,~~ de dtet~-6 am/~hlf~
------lc.O......I_·....c..~-=e"-'#'----4t~·~ la-h-J;P'-. 7-/ die. &r.¥'1 ~/1:f_::..L'/ne=e5G-...:;&~a:~.-f_ _ __
                e=··~:;...oRt:...:.L...Zl'-="---'"~o/ux~L'L·'j£ &n/ /Jr-bJ1~L.J.zL4"-~~'v~M"'.."""""~~~;-----
------;...<'-''-'-.

----~"'""--,t!.~lf;flCN..d~~NL'&a.dbt~l
-----~~L.t.~:--.r..'-~~//v                 r //z :&e. dd/Cv/k:a.
                                                            . <..../ zf?Cf4't-.' t. ,)/cA..1 )/,sh<,ne/
                                                                                                   v
                                                 "      e.       ?./.                 .be 1Vt< I .tJt%'1 t>P
                                                         /t    iJ .
-------4~~~~a~·~r~m~~'-~.-------------------
------+&_6dl                       &rd s·iat.P t7-Pfiud/.:C_e_L?                   z0    ~.ldl:J-~=<---""'-v.._ _ _ _ __
-----~·~~~~.a2 Va. 5:. r.~ , ~.> «
                     1

                           ;:s                         ~        c./v.j<   &u,l/?!:.kl t.~ ~_A~PI1=_       e=-__   _ __

                        .51'1611 ~5l ,.~ ,&- t4tkl.»a~tf)c /h ~-5~:£..!<-zl:e"-'-,-k=.·"'"'·- - - - -
I--...,..-,-.,..,..---F-"'~+·e_,c.=-f~·z{,~/(,_,V5~J' u r lsdkl{ ~

-·---!-
~~----,..,.
                    t::t1L__L_/{/s Ce5e- ~ flHJ~tu~._ t..~/!ldeoer
                                          ~~
                                                                                   .be
          .. .!.....:~'-,!.~=-=b~ ..s~s5t~ Atee~'~:5 ec .a,_Y-'&dts ,Jiftt:k nPke-tA_...,t-.L~·____

1~---~~~~~a~~/.~·~~~~~~~ ~/~~-~0 -eo~~~------
    •
------rr:~.)-~~22=5 L?&?n>-/r-Yd&e<.... /~d~--;-.----
                                                               (/   .                       .

-----~~·e=c.."'--'-·-'''-"".5"'-'~'-'-"-'-·~-=5 .@/rA?-&:5.i(Jus                                         kct<....    en c. tta &ra~L·:z.d-~-t-'-'~-----
                                                                                                                                           .
------~-~~*:;/ cau/5&4;-ec.!&-L ·76 ~ rJuclsdtcl-dQee
_ __:__ _ ~~~&~·!1~,.~2e.t..A.-s:
                     1                                                                          al #e. t/a//e/ htt;~-m~tl-·---:------
                                                               . ~ &ey a-5kk, tU .56tk                                                          .2A(fi;:LL6:.L...//_ _ _ __
_____,~~~~~~~~&c~:~e~~~a~,~~                                                                            L,d!~s~~~~-------
                                               _1,.;-.·/       S'             .   f                    ILl           .t1            ljl             /!~
-----1---'-"'""'--(Z"-L!LLLe;§e.                                    t::9-r Lk1/../H."-<.1.LLT-If-~s_·_·_,.,-----
                                                                                                                                                        1
                         &·            f .,_                                                        t.J ;!fkuf
                              ll                           /
                         Or-                 · '           re~          ·m/       at1v
                                                                                                                               t      f       1/_
                                                                                                Oec50VL.., /d.L~L~b'L.'-"'=---L./.L-D...L--·_ _ _ _ __
                                                                                      7         ~                                                   ]
                         'l                                                               I /},....,,./...,.,                  ~
---=~-~~-~~c~0=#~1l'~--~~a~--~~~~~r~ ~~~)~~;~-----~-
                                   I     /          I      _j/                                                  I.         -              /         )

-•~~--------~--~-----

                         oc.lld h                   t2t?Vf"~ ./Juf- tc;../l..e.r                    reset tJ;Y6ov/ /.C~totv"lt_J.__,_'._,_,·&c~---­
---,------t-!..-r.-.L.;-'L'i:=_--=..;J-.o-=-.:..I...L{""'~ 5~/~-t.e- ~~~                              C) e_~e/                     c:;;J 5et        ~
----~..:..__t_~.LJ...t.L-2---'f.Lhkt... ~~ 1- c?CdC)·ec-1 catlec/ ,(z2 Gvt:~
-----!=I-Z~,'«/190-- ~bt=_~<~·e.-~-­
             ~.'~~-L.e..,_C..L eo~~; 74r d~tolte.r c4&y t5 ..!Oe~X- h> co~~'-------
-----+'ofL-'-.
-----t---'-'-~~_...."-'=¥-4-LM-£1- &d~~~ 5o ,Jr.facf In~./                                                                              (!cJVT'f
-----!-"~=--~ ~ d,e                                               &«¥-
                                                                4c 6:;.b/, ~d~sj cd./k./aJ
-·---t-'-...L-
          __.u~·~..l_.(_t:?-Jtk~"'--rdt'""'"·~e-~_....&~).....f2e~=lbs~
                              1

                                  ·
                                                                   -v__,G!.Pl="- /rf. . .<.'/-L-f4.!. . :.1'e." "/:. . . _ ;,~- " '-.....r/u~e..~L?""'-YeJ.._.=
-----t....:..J4~(}_L_ o/ ~ l?f&_,nt/6S /'Z.&__t.;}_,_~f- b'/V1.~v..s z%¢
                                                                                                                                                     I
                                                                                                                                                             ..u.C~e.~2S~----
                                                                                                                  ~         7
------t/t;S /-kuzra~/e 4£-ud 8rr&v.{ d"ve-h- ~!t~~""-f_______
-----;~~~~v-c tv.-CJi29~~vM4""""'uc.;....f5.Lko~----
-------;-;;:~~--=e=~=h"-'-&1 $Ls ~~~ g-ee_ a~&'-""e==--....:;;t-J>c t>·i' /d~~e,
       Pur5aau-/- ~ ~~a I / ac ~ ~~ u(~ c /71-/tP 2                  I.

-·    ancl£~k Le~~~-z; e.~, ) e!}/a_~/mcllce<
      ai21L_ · .K'e;;1 d/e.s· C3rr.&_ / J_.a ,..a..oJ-=-L3d....u?O 3 ..

      ~r?.a:kL O?c                 ~~ /a.z-~ £J4Y-t2L~~t:tt.Gec~/5C"

                                                   ~ .~A~-~~.LO           t'J/f.-Lr
                                                      -      -   ,          -;

                                              5/:yaa:ht~   CJI1 ~lteaP?~

-·
----~.~~---------~--~----------

---------+------~lt~.------------------~------------------

--------~~fd~~~d
--------~~~~~3~~~~/~5_/~~47br L1~dc~r~·-----------------------------
--------~a~~~-~~~~~~~~------------------------

-·--·~~~~--------~----

          -z;le ?1~.5t;J:;neL c:Jor.,Msel MQ_cer/-64~£ &gf<,-----~
----;-=..~~CQ2i,L_f2.1
                ··77-    tJtfr N-&.be-ll-5 &r~..s
                                              , - - I· /.?u/.SDAd·. ~ .
                  I
l-------,.-,---f'-"-4.tLLZ./FI .5ec,.27-/,e>.>l ,C=y2   ~') ?'er, ~~ Ort:,,   //0/:.,thtrKt/
                ~~          {!o!Q_/,   &/"1 &1/1. /Cff# _5ec,.Z   ,.:-c_~:6.t:.-e e~ /[C/~
l-------t'-".A--'-~_.;;:::3::......,.&J::._...:...7Ur- ~~~~~ ~&vkJ.~4"""e.""""~A
                                                                               . .S',___
                                                                                  . __
                 C9t-'1..   L?r::c~'~ /& 7r1d..:?t£.-_·----~------------
                                                                    ~~0~-

-·                                                                                             o:J,   <