Court Opinion

ID: 4054927
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 06:18:13.667316+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:31.272394
License: Public Domain

. \.\~\r-..\®£\§m§mm\m\?ck\m
M;~\§§.\S\\\;\\\\

» `\\1;&& \_\.\\`)_X~_

\\°\SR ?\\,.§§X

M\\m \Te>u~§l T%aa s

§§§\.\ \\ AL\S“

"\Jd 00 M_QI`X\
ibm BY Q_\"\_\‘\`m\t\\ \\
§ §sk \s:w< \, w%§d\ Mw\

    

` f couRTOFC» ‘ ` ¢AL
“<\.\.SR\X\\_(.Q.\D\%_`\X~H\ , ;; ,~' ME s
M»_ eo.&, M¢bz®;>,s»c_ ‘ §§ ’ °
ei Acosia, Clerk
mme\€\~
Y\QM\:L§AMMMA§\L §§ '\\"l°

m»_m WMA §WH wl mt wmm§m §§
_ §vr\§r

`§M§Y¢m§w mg Mw § mww§ cm\ m Wmi

c_;_"w Am\§ \uc.s' wm t \AL\N§ wtc\mm_\¢c§
;:%L mm:v\§n& *:\\eé;m mg ug …§m§‘\§\~§ ;LDL>S’ m wgg_w
\\'§§s;§ m mcmame wng §§ \~_\ML §§ wm m mm mem

Y\oL§LM§ Mn_m\; at shawch months
~ :\\L\ WN\\N;:K?‘\§AM(>\\ R§Wm c>‘€ -\~_\\_m_ §‘.A\.\r& \JM-_\ms_ mc;Hex`

`\\N;~R{\ \f::\»~‘?vv °*“._,:_"§C~“A Ol\ hamm t\m& **\L$r*§a§§§\¥§\l‘€_?\\??
-§xam §mxx aame limx

§§ alumax \>§`s\mxa§ ‘\B -'Y§a § §NE'Q§B§D§E§
§ x§\“\\\i§x §§ ‘?§U\ Q.B§ Q\_\A%‘m§x U L §\A\

§§§d \B‘€\§"LY\

‘%\\ §‘\m&\a\aa\§ 3 M\Am¥ar `a\ am \%L\ th
\x%§v\.ri \_b\x:*c §§ \Xax'<`\§ Qm m mmM beam w
\aa. a`mxv<\`>$aa .`\\\;\_ §§$;s_a:a amab§€\&mi w &\°~ l

\.`\\<\a§ ` `»x .Qm\§‘\ma wa;a.h> a
UUMMWMQ aaa am X;_a\¢ani wax
'\\\\db\{\m§x ‘:\\9_§§\> `»§_`L&§N\ DF A\~\~_`\.\\_X&_ \\.D"{

\3? &_\\x`wa§ §§ §§ hwkx\a§ `€mm§mxa .

~\\\§. \§wx\;§\\§r_a\)evw§daham. max wax maA.o_ mcl\_\a\a\n_

a am mama aaa§m\\ aaa §;;§M 14th
ercl§\a\>§§\\` \\:s&\x .`X\\ \§m_ Q\lxxbmlsni §§L§\m\‘£
V\.b&.`\'n\\ "§bv § \m\`d\_m §Y`\_&E bath
`xm R\)`»\ §x§\a\\ \\Ya .\~¥\ ~ 957 an \Q. Q_Stc.h\jx¥m;\
X\\Li_§\.._é\§§:§a.\x\€\srm¥,\oy `L\\ t\\n_ \E.L\i\'\ ` ` '\_Qi Qnar‘c DF
\va\x §J>ma\:§wax max m ada B\AAEQ. La wl ao,
\\Sb\QDS . `Ym §as§f\um§c Lx ama xn:\)i.at.:r§ mswa i"_¢\ W-Esaa
0\\ mm.\\§b\a;;§ aaa wm §&aie.‘s__ Faj.\we_hb cz\iscln:o_

lab §\-\_»_ §a$ma§_' ` maxw\\\§o\o&§ Lx~,\~ w eha $aa
mm `\.\\ \¢_\<\L §r`xv\o`r&&o&s. §:r\ ‘c_\\s)_§&a§:h€bn§:imm\“§‘:

a amana \;\\ls m§>wa£\aa w aa§\:\§;m dar" twa
\;Lvs§¥`a;x\(ga; caa§».c\».\oz\>a&$~§ aa-Baka\m~'ii&m:u
§ma;:§\\.v\mc\§ma\z~a ax.xx\x~z.» xgx.a+_. \\°rLe .)a

\

\`\F_A . §§ (_\G\\n°_\.\ ..`\\\o. %§$x\as\\; `\x MM w \a_cmx m
wavwa \FOX\R\>axM\ a\\ m g,a\»ermmn&‘x \r`u>\a_¥\a<\
'\~N X_\\v_ Y;m:§x§w\s_\ \x\\`>§§n Wv€x t\u_<\£:\ser\\v\sm§a\x\

\ai`m\'\ emma
`\;`x m ma K `\x\C\\§_c§ "?`\,\`S~X_\*<.\\s\. " SS.U.SLQ\'\ magic
\\nn?_ YD:>. w wax _"Q.u`\c§a\x\t;x‘?c\navc§§§_w an amm$§ac~l“
X.\\xx§c `\J%_\~e§.x\:u\a w%_\§i a\` mm _\\\L R§§.\_`\§m\\;

m a\é\<\a&\\a»aw haw `» bast
miwa m wb\,\l§,§.ea:ld§mxlxiu§:\\ o~&\~`\a\\mxa \\))_ ‘

. \{\mm ‘éaca mixm\\\$blp’&$ max §n.\\h`n§§oYa°& \\lm.`¥ha
Maaa &\a axxm`w§@.aaaam§ \/\ma § *.\M>_WA mack
`\x\\`§ &r>oS `\,\\Qa»§x\\)».\\$bb?$ Q_§L\\K<_\\mm\x\m¥\ r>\: ‘
&.\aa ` \\>,a¥a`§m§.>q>é;»srlmv\¢\aénelmea&u` '
a aa xxa;wa .mexax@x‘\aa§mrx mmaaaa
Y€_M `\x\ k\\s\_ A§E\\xm\x\& §:Q_"zm\§; §‘.m\>_\`\xi`\b\\ L\\ wx§.$_

\\s>\\\§ b\a§§ ama X\\x§:\.v\a wax wxxxm`\b”>abag max
\>xa;§; `\.\\ >a\\v. W'\\`>.%.\s\m& W §§ £\"\DX w Qx\\\ax\s;o. JM>\.\A"\ ‘r§m.\\\(l£&%_ki
. a\acama ma m §a\m ama 1a M<\».\ mg
aaa am x\\a_ maem»\a_$ x\¢\s_`\axx Ms_ `u\ dam
m\\§>"_>md&§ , T\\a§a`>.aac\ `\m>a\\a&`u>x\ c>\-' \-.\m>.
\}:u,§ \,\x\r§&£‘ “<'\"\L\.d_ B%\D:§_(Q\ \l\b\.b`§\\\£§\"\(x§¥bar*c\(\ “W\U\A.\V\M\'k
‘ .“\\<\».%va@‘»x ` § \~\`m;a-@a:é; ' m
l\ \X'\A\~o&\>`u\£§. `\.\\ §\l:§).;&\\“ \`C`du\'k§ mm m\w?\:§:§r“§\,\i
abc x. udva t>v \.»`. ` wiémr_a_ 0\~ visa\ix Pn>m€\m
C.\_&\)a~\. C;\.\\ °>`>a&. `\\\§_ g toni mux\xnl 'Su_m§ ' cows `
S 3_® E_MSS\I\`\E \\9_ \,§c\§_§c\:\b_\la\-§r\§x‘ 0\: Q:;§L\A &b§.\§ \`.\\&bo$',
'§_L `N>`a>ax<§m\s\_ca ’c\/\a.xams),\_a\x. Q,¢\~Aa\la?\byx`»x rehired
\<:b _U.R'~ §_ `\.Y\ Qoau§sz_, (\D\ \ \§b\ol§ D.,M;\ t g
WX aid \R>;mx%a (`.ar\.a am ` €,r\ guam ma 1 o’>oal$
w %mmw\ma ca ma ama max aaa
\W\x\¢\ M.xdm\ Ya\i.u»_ \Lg§w\& cammz\\aa v\/a ` \g
\m\ m view w `aax\ ' b m \~_\\L want wear
`\1\\¢\\». an 4 masa\\a\\m 595 .\a\\m. am m %#ra§a_ m
wax gw\ama> ma \<_a `a\\ `aa§éam§ aa max am \c>'zmx§?

l

xa_\m\»\ x .\a. 5a 5 \a &w-\ via . aaa . QDaB'.
aaa § \@_\Xa\;\ax\°>°\°; x\\»;>.°wa `\Rr> Lw` Qr`m. aax,aa\z\.

"K\a ~ ‘ ama aa\a\aa w“M,m w`a\\ £\\9_
wax`a~a';\!eraxxxa nw `\\\ %\S . »Yx£c ‘c.\\x`uxakwax§§
`\_\\ mea_\\)>\\\)°>baas 4 adaan »`\.*_L asaAA ‘m>_

%K.`>.U\\S;X&`\QLX\.\.; `\, 7 "zx`x\x\x§ ‘F\>v t\\x wer w \;`\N§\§n\!\§i. `\r;aair$

mm in a vaxo_ “\§;m\s\._ va ¥‘\m‘c\\ Q,’:.\ELAAS' . \b\r\xu\ \\s. M\:\§€
`\,\\>c\> bdva \o:i\ \,x`a\\ \JQPM.§HAX exam \.u\*§_‘~\.\_

_Q\ §§ ’Bu>b$‘. -\\u&x'\b \im%xcm%§mz:aeg\ &\\a_§a\iu_ \-.\\a§r

l`\§§\_\mc§t\\`axxir ‘c.\\s_ \nSLX` ’<,\a_a& _§\(-x\.awd \.a\\b vacde cér §th

\w\zc>x' 'x\m:‘§ \\§J\B<. é\m\“ ‘U~»A\;A

<>._S.W\&Q,S` v\n_ \><\ Y‘\r~x‘\:§t\ 93_1\’§1) t>S" . `\\w`)§. "\5_\>&;£.1.»"§2_ \-_\¢\_\_ S&a_§&

`\, v\am.\"?_ aci<\».ru:\ w\<\m\;c_v._ ‘m ?c§x§mi( `\_\\U imak` ' X\asz.
` '»zv,< vw§x \).x‘>)\¢§<\¢\n_ `\\§a§§\»>_o\aa`xmr\ \\R% w`\¢\um_

QDBS' .

_'},, `\\\a, A§§h`\x&l\ hou.<\\ma max\x\x§¥€):k`\.\)& \Sc\u\\\s_ aB)J`\S_QL\
X\m§. ` kv ` `u\ awan m `\\3`3053_5` \,>\mu\
\\L\§\x\a,\b br ">.\\m\;§\\)*z_ \&\x\x\m\ a‘<' \AM_U% Q»\A§M§_\.`\.\\`i\i

ma sam w M\\»`\\§\>\MS L\\xxa@xb§ . ~v\a wax emma

\\x wo~%_ c§?$b YQ$Q_KM\§=\. \\`m\ b<\ mm \\SGIDQJS av \;\¢\a¥ dc
\,>0&_ W w`a\(\~\¢\,\x §§:?\o\r§(\,a&&_\on\\§\\oaré \o:\_§v.c\éo;.&m.
\{\mx\»,e‘m x\::§\w\~<\\ \`»av\a way-mm am mmiama“
\J\\§gz\'-u§:\\m\b\m\\\x%lx\m§ w 0\5§13; wav\a¥\w w§~xvaxx alma
Q_n\;§m\m_ n\>§m`xx\'dr\ `\x\\\\b\a§<`\w\ b'€ *<_\,\s_\_a.m“ w\AM' Rv+.`\t\& '§3\9~3(.€~\.
"\\\c.k \)`\.\>\1:3&1§\ \'.\\9_ C,§$\mm\§€& "‘\£\\ $oax`\,m_§§€d`\\\€. \A\\w\\xa,r§»`\‘;~a§ waxx\xcardc \-,\\a§r \u.‘x \N\\ c_\a_axer
\a`m dc ada 25 saw assault max m aci£h\si him wa\¢\ »\M ad
C,a&§_ ~_\\\9_¥§`\€§ tom%n§.`wa$_§,<\x¥¥€£§=`\\m_ a)\(\m\ \\9_\`1..\\§_& w chD.
aa meam.\\sams max war\»&§a\?bm de MAMWA mm
&\L§§w\aar \\\ §m>\a \.\`\,X\l\`m\ \;\\s_ §x~‘\w\ar\:§ea§a, .\3'¢ amc '?av 9mm wux\@\g
marx a\_m_ u%§xmm\-_ wa\a¢\ m¥\\nm'xw fm\*s_\,;cu\A \,amao\
\\£\>AL `\..\\‘.`\`>.&XU\ d\\§\:\\§£® XY"\A. %S).L\X\\\\I»\~DRUE \L‘\`l"\ \l\&
51 W‘°AS\ °>M\ 3“` \m\A-\f \\Aax\mawa \L\\°\n \_\x.\o\n‘& \\L%`\»,
\x\\ x&x. musa \m\¢\ 3a \\»E.A. ila \;\v\ \ \M’> &\C\x~x\ .

Mmmaaa\:h\»\~\s* ~ -\ 4 ' WWMJ:WLM\

Q_m»SL\\Y,c>A \BBDB;LS'C, _

-EMWv.\\c&`&,.\\we, muQAOLQb
§§ R§$`>:m& R\u§;£\bnTnT\\L wes ‘?vr>§h%su;\ \:`u\c\.`; 5

B‘F ivch \QD“A;L%Lm‘\K d'i" \,`um\$|S\ \m<.:\m.&l\

o:’> '\=b\\n\h"> `»

M`€\ _
Q;m\§§ §§ RR'.;<\RWYRQU\&
9 .Y> R>n\ \Q€>mx \U>&:< m %U~r'm§ .
%\l§\”\*~\§ \~'KEM\ "m \\ v

WY\A\§_;%.\RV\DS&A\
` \§Y\Y\m&r\ mv\\;u\l?.\`;tf'
T\R~B“WB .\S"\\o_l\\-\
mm Xw %9.
\c§.\\cs¥ \X.\\`>}\; "
\\Q\® \1\~\ °\°\‘&
\A\\m& \`\)¢m§ W‘U>Q~;