Court Opinion

ID: 4055136
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 06:40:25.57401+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:03.648284
License: Public Domain

tJ.e t-tJl.f   ao~ /'2. ~" t

$~-1-e
            " Cf...fl.911> -a~~OC:-I(R~~-:D
                       CP-l?n &~.ot~.A-       Ho.      ~~'0'1-IZ crl(p
                       cxP~rlet~              .w-.~11,~ htda$al !J,tl~-                        AbeiAcosta,Cierk
    C!I~ILk:                      .                       --At~SlP~JC-                                                         ~
      ~ ~~s{J-Mce.. -ro 0"J~ iy'\<-Ctt•s Ja.... t~tf.EA ·-rc         m'l                                yau .
    2fJJ6f feq &tc..n~                tP   ::r   ,(t/A5   l'!.d- ::h,cP/c?ol             (TA/    t3t.-c~-l<-9l7~
 ~ -rh6p ·~JJ,c-bn4-r'l~ l'61tif (-(t;,£ &/un,J Jupt ~'fit.. 6~~ t:Jf'bJ~YIIE-e.
 /inJ.:(ht- 5h.rk. .  Jt.t~l. -;i.U¥~ 1 A. . P.. d-cf:;8 ~&' -r11 E..
    Jos-2   ·\]}v_M:; c.:JA-1 'U/-s[e,c..t &ulf.-1- ~cf' StJ1d                              <1t.L-t\ kt 1 1        ;/$-tJ~ ~tJ.
    rj\t_ C)~~~n~\~           -1o   &A·t/L~ \(}, 1 ::rL.L~7A-1 AIUK-f J                                        "7]r.;   (f,e,.a_t1~
 \ltAtta 1 ~ .S~pifi~R... I ~08~ -f.lt 4-st /?1U71J~ ·~ ~¥-fclllheL
 "/liL J:r-S"Z?.duc/)c/~ I'JJ/s/£.,~ 1 C!t?Ju.~l w._a., f 7?J ~~u~ ~1.1.-'11·1-r"'
:r lU,Jt~ ~~ !JJ~ /).J/1-S ~.j /Jt:J-1 frt-r,;                 t:rn    !D Qj{~lfl.cJ~8o /,(J~i/6<. ~~*1 '1);J
  1\]~J- 1-/!iVt-'1h"'l. .J~,~ Jl,·c:-~'dr- o~ 1"h ?_ I E;s'nSm~-1-k.,i _)J~ ·tc Af m                ·n /71 ~ ~IV~ 0 2&~.~ j
        ~~~-D-ls fls ~l~-/:s                         Q      -JhE   t:m )"( :1 ~ bJ,ellf.S /!m t      "TS    ,6E,:!y
        Ct-e.P:rf.!J  47 -~J?r /l?c.CA'fj· 1/3 I f -:1A~ ~~~JJ,,,~ tf/))'J/!jiJ
          J./AJ r/6 0£.\~~$~tc::A,~ ~ c.S~lZ)-s~~e:J, ~ tlA-n f\JoJ & V~skc\
       '-r-6 fJi't OlJ!o-tll0~J,c,:-r ('[);~4~,d f.. ~.t J.As f l?mt Y ~ R1<.f
       &~ s&-{            Ch/lirn    6A1Lifi ~     /.Ofrs     f\r.Ri ( -='3 db JD. . .::t: J.//JOt    h'o.l ~
       ;:tl/(5~ ?c?J GDtah1f                 7D     At         m~e-s r£"' /lp1~1}t.               (7/{     f11uJ a{lcL
,.____... . )~itrl mtrflce-sl        l{s ~I QIJ{viYl               glr.     A,~· rn¢~;~       Wt- /1/.M T~~41
 ..    Altc/.£/J:.cJ Jf, s ·-:::J;, Ade:94 4'/~ 4 ppe/J/ /Jflit:_ ( te9~-J1c(A f /11 '1 ~61iJ/~~
        .Qn4 ~,1la~f·~ ~~Q ~t J.Jkl(., cs.P (!6/GIJ!Ac~tfif:n1 Q,c_
       f+pp$r& ( ~25 t/i'Jd lkuc /YUj 5-:'ffn A Ju L ~ d?1 -/. ~ /).) 1<7i ¢
       o~~o<:J-IZ'i1Gz'D -CJJ /31 kJA/o~ cfl~ Cf'1.SWf$~ &'d-~,
                         {rm f

 .    '\.1::+ Ad,·~~d- GvtAILf- ~1fs . csHI-i/cls ~~; cfu,u;'ct;;,k.;;4/ ~SflA(jJh;c
       Aa.EA-1 'if~\~ @~Qo~~s lm~ ~~ ~f-~fl1 of.s~;&>(. ~>~ .
                                                                                                                               .·,

       CJi..Jtt. b.A$.!ol o-n tnf.·IYI 'TJ t.Ja,dJ, . Rtske.tt. \J Oom ~·] ssJ~ .G~ ~~~
      rurs~-.6>1; )\ ( ~~ C!.ev~:.J 6R..
        -j],1__ ~~')                  kJr-/n~&!t~-5 -d'Jtvf             'WM-"t-         dM6/L       ~e.. bftJ~I'l~J.., /YiollE71- &       !Jib!£ 76 {Jft~{-·
        ;·~.fR,cJ    ( A-.~J.:n ,~('+1-L, mt.& W/\-ll~fl ~-h$,.
(~)·-n. ·~ ·-n~~ ~~..p, ~ ~~ -p/~,c.t tkJ4};} JJ~$7>1 ~
Q) :::h, ~Jt.is./r-n ~UA1frt          a-n     -Jh F.~:flJs-f rnonJ. ~      ·::i=?l   /JglllrJ IJno/ /))~b£mhc,e ':!
~:n;~£+k                    Ck4 on -tht /J.~t r(Joncl,_ ~ fZhR"ik~ ~ntd                                       ~~c.L&
($j ~ WhriiE-fL Ckl.Vr\-kr on /ht- Jfi,-sf n1~~ -:vn Joo\.\Aflit ~ dune...~
\J~s 4-nl'l "T.!.K.rr=> ~t.te-~~ a,.J~ ~, bo9                                         Jl-l6ll~~~i,J->-
 EAd         ~Ltll.J 1/sf~J        "11-.   -;h1s ~'-ibc:J,P76. t!.sc>t"fJ./'-k.,./rh h'?t_c:l l~s           ~~cls.o~ ~'1 9A~ 1~·sJ.q.-k/t£ d~li'n£ 1n1~
c-sk4lf>4         J£4/U;J,:zl~ch- ~~·41~ &s1,e. ..c_f                61.412./s,. ~ Cull~V bJ,1sc:rn.. <1".53
'S'w!>ai 3 ~1c.?-~ ~wrd-"'?J HoB hdo ;Z¢f
~£ -r~ tkms./:t...(rdr--                      lf!LJ,'c/1.   S, 5j?   ff5      4-m.s:;:::!.cl~ut          f!..,41u~cls:-~ ~
 .a   o"   -1h£.. j'}M-~f/I'UI--n+          o-P A?1 ~d/c~r o,e. .h1~4-l/trX- '-n; A-~'-~~
 ::P1t {)£Sis --?7-J£ ~L.f' ~:7/1 <:..fi.tfVUo£~-i-. a-?'-~~                                   {]/}U6£c

      \/~1-e>hs ~1\ ~~~ G-a~.u~~~l Gcele d·i o/6 ·JJ~ .&n.cl S2£S~s
  &c&.,:SkiC>i" ~d              C/l/,?'YIIt\1\-{   ~/~kr'c/ Ckt-tllJ ho/Js                   IJ./   tE#S"f     7"eVcl ·~~&
  e!S' ~~+ ~~a.A ~~trL,;?;, ~ tto~.ft ~ ~' d~k,~fo

 ~\lc~ ~~ NW6tL \~Mll ~~;;;&,c,~'ifsal -7·,£' I ~AI/ WD-1fkcl 1~/tm /K #f~.MJ~-­
 mi /JdiJtvt:/2 tu~ ;/£11 d/J.,. .J,~.J -r4Jo '7Jf.kjs 1 ~lkte,.. J.t c/Jd /l(tf'
  ·'b,;--r/11d'(~ t:}'"i/J 'J)-;d dorl A~~~ -{A7 cE:u,cl~.c. < /h,y/ ~
 640c i(rm.         lhd       --:.:hru~s/,;Jfhl(.. .SUiffl; _jfi_J /J ck Is I
                            tfs                                                              ;:JUJ         Au   rf
 . Tb     0~ r:u:s-klci .4-J:A:sam1f ~ an, ~;t;- ~£JlS)                                       :Z: aJ,·1lf>M
  ~dt~ Iii/CA.._ (J)IJ~           -rJ,.I'yl    fu"' dPf /.a-k, -7l ;~ .lnA--.f/e;z_                       l?Jta-
 :r ~        p :k/1a~l f&RG:PJ.                'J:: rL::>-;d do-l-           d/tJ   lkr-Pr·~ ·73 ~
 6;-Juzo-P ~ '7 ---tJ, ll£:; ~ds ;r bJrI I Jtlo./ u I !vJ, f, I .:r
                                               0                             a. r                          y
-fl,-? e~s
                                                     $~J21~
                                                     w~~C)QL
                                                      C>l~~/IC(6,. ~~l~s L4t;'f
                                                      Jlo-91 P;11qt()
                                                      ~o~llc· ~Wt? ']13(/:!;
           Qsvd ;Q\ c4 +~ tS£? s;~,L-$.
  ~ 20)11~ Ad~ 4-1~ CJu/;;J:f ·-tAI+J                                           m, /)1-,') --~A    c...
  1P~ ~ /Y)~ ~IS:                                  X -l~s-rn~fhei ~ (1,fi cr.!2-
 -~-;~ 6~1 --;o $b~·J!l~v.J,c~4{})~s{=,e,cf CkuJ
  A\ ~f2.t rn f(\<; cA·,~ J~. ~\.\J~ l9 ~~\fl SJ-. $'~"!c. $~7
- 1-/wn;>sW·~ 77Cf.~                               4rzc/ 7b         -/J,·l   &~/J-1- ~(14~1?~1
  ~~(5 )d-&J~