Court Opinion

ID: 4051895
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:49:25.870581+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:55:34.892157
License: Public Domain

/7§/ 08@’©/}

WEC§WED Ei\§

©QUHT OF CR|M|NAl APPEALS
` ‘ 2015

Ab@i@@@§ta,©t@tk
J\\,JQ\. 93 QD/ld/

This document contains some
pages that are of poor quality
at the time of imaging.

gear Q_|~€r'i<'i

p[£ér.§e DI'IL/ €.nr,/Dse¢:/ /f.//e pen/cm-/f$ ;APP/llajw /-D" DU‘/'Dp 77”7£» A/)f¢">/
wi `~H'\ /\/l£m£lon’ll,l$ 7[0/3 @_)é‘/zc/ cm¢/ /)/e$en>/e//;{D 7[/7£ young

E>»/'[)/`v/ /) /'5|&/:51> enc/a.s,_»_o/ 05 wL//

//
/3/£0_££. S~en¢/ mp__ a ,[) /r//`S~/¢,M/ [/a/_$/¢¢w//Zi L¢JAe/F //LuasA//‘: /

WLM/é \bl,,_,,/»'/

l y ’ f\/oL/r_; 7;14/%
AL‘ ` WM K, EMM

  

\/3

_ MLQQUMM£B
AQP€.|\Qn

`Ir\ C-`\m\nql 13 :§r\/.§ onur'§
11)1>,1'1¢, atf

\`\(;1¥\’\§ Cc,\Lm§\|l`_\-_&\(n~\
\"T~.M (’.1.1.,11 MD.,O\%?J\@

\r\BR- 131 1\,%<\ nL\

¢.,_

MLDLMAP_QW___`
JMIQALQMMLA»@A¢LLMAAJHLQHL

lb T)'\€. l~\l'>h€>t~c»\.\§~e:(,tf_\£<\e llc SL\SA ti»1)v§;MQL _
/Uom C¢>me..\.…l mrng C»r\r\ [\Y~Co,r m§(> B.\m.\enr.o_ cm [_In\ml'\ Ur> th\ln§\|@\ 1\\>111§&1 C\saclms§ .C_r_um\ 111,51:§11¢.§_( \ W
»\Blr-!`-L§-LHMM \~L>'v C\€x\\\iv\& A'P\>e\\;nn¥ bBQb£nh.Cm:£u§_§_\»Dl\ r ra\`\e§' and
C\u\umi~\ §\\`1; MMMM\£E.LQALL

,_Z_QSL_M and t~e,ji"ecl oath mr,\w.s ~\»\ni§ Ci:u,~\ §o %rcm§ \Qa\'m \-1\, \\e. §\r\'\b Dt:ih\ns=l_[luiu§:f.m&_,-

amum@wmm mgmm,@w£mk»i\_g\_£rmma__

“\'_() \m>. ~§€_r\¢;l rec§ (‘_1>\"\~§€. por`hhe_i;u§\\| `1 \§\'1 ~\'\\E‘_\ me mm ~§\n`\$
DQ>_§B@QLA§M Wm;»,> m$_,m

. .. Mm§ln€x§.\§u §\m_i§‘,swl_n_, \"\€4\1`\¥\°1
~M:|U`£‘Il; C~N_L\\ TP\11:11)13 th 11 named m 11 \;1@.»1
(A\" 4§\9-§,313)£\1’\31` MQ§ ‘(\'}:1\.§ I(:\(:~L;Dh Cmcl CH)P||:£P§\;I/l v

(~‘|l°*§“e§ pl |L““ E""” " C°\ bd¢.\\ (.)_s Rnr,\mnmlo,\ t¥~r~or pmm ~H'\o_ record um_\u
1 (,'\nrj m 514 19901~1 hal 31st L.m\\ v~e‘~.PQc.W\;\,\N 5511¢\,>-§¥\`\: bomb (1¢\.11~1- §\'w, Qc>\\c.\u>`m£\°

"

1 5 6 35 1 1 1
5 mm ‘\ m 13 ec mm Q%cun>..
311-hawn

 

(;'r‘l>l.\r\r.l ana ¢~~A£')&\M,\S_AAU&L\_LLD.QDLELL£M(J£ _B_\,\_QWQQC.!~__
1' f MQ_M:_EM_Q_MLEMA 11@@111@1_1>£_1\:11;1_%_ in

R\r:>@

\§\'

Cvrn;.mi TLDL~,‘; 111 ' _ QMEEMAUM 111111§1111_;1111111/111111111§
_~Six$b_l§mmmen J.L.SL@AA_AQQ§\M‘>FQ% ' w `~‘~\1§\ _

_T"\e- lJnr]!.\\\iv)§ prut`*£.e/_\_'m§ '\W~L~lw_g ram MbM~F_§\Gr§'\v\Q\`X_nS'\’*UW'¢`-/ \Il>;t-“ 1“£\4"[“‘*\“`€"“~\`
p' \\cm~\ wme his Mi>|\§~-f° ° 51 `m_g\ \/l>`lb `.'anli¢.§men~y was \'\1:§ rv.§ur‘r\_e.al h &.
he u.\ §\_Y‘_Cmcl dur`\ duva_ §D -‘\'A e..‘§ff§“§»\\na§ §MYHA DE\TE. 15 mif>§`m_fg which its fl \l\'\:\c.»-\-u>r\ 03
MUMLM§D(£ __F brem\;r¢_ L\_>\§\'\\=u\¢ -\-he_ 95'\'£»1¢\ §u¢*\‘§T?¢gY\-DN\'E.
L1>c\~\ §\n-e.\-e. °m carl cm\\ S§'rcm<,\ .\u\»\\ e_ -Dcm. ed bn ¢:1,\\\1 given r_.\¢:»,\\ `\Y\ \-\G¥"`\`£‘ C‘>*~“"\*" ’ \‘€“Te~"m ‘5
Q>'rr_\nr.\ lur\| L\l(lb D¥Y\W\`\\§¢cL ;t\ §\19_ `\\nc\`\l; me 30 1155 MD\C\C\\Q§\§>

 

 

 

/§L §¥\ . 195 MD ()P\IGIMAL 'FI`L.E STP\MP 1>\?§\~1, dis§r`\b§ 1‘.\11\<‘5 1:>?{`~111>,111111¢
'i’_?> f) rbn;r e;\ti' lenr.. -\-§\a§ C\ r~§§ mut }Y\Ait,§mw§ 1_1.>01£> 'r\b§ Prehv\§u§ `\‘> >'\“°' wu")' "*""5'*“""'
~\»\'\Q, 'm'PJ;mih£‘; 0 ° ‘ h `

      

  

» :[§» &151> \QL\<§ §\\1. DX\S§N¢§ r_z\\§¢>me\\..t>r com vs \r\f.§/ kir»_(d,§§\§§c\r\§‘£) gi§"\€\'\tw`@~

C"kép€(:§ `\Y\ $u\n;§(mce. sz.\ FG\~m-\|\` 1>\€1§`\1:.\/1 139 Ar~§. 331(33-,5. 4r§a11,éc@
\»\(_\_\ Gu§hc>w*\~\`\“ §b ibvr\`i.sd_/A (`_'\/\r»r£;`m§> \ns§ruwwn§; WI¥¥\ pRE§xumI-C‘E gov C\ deee`i¥
g Fc>rm c>r _ ub§§am£. "?

_TL@. "§r~iol. 111~>11»§ ha cl md 5311\1311,§ '1>\~ 139 guinn §111~1;1111.41,£\ rf>\wrk§)'>t)€\ <:m»-l amd

11.\»€-1~»¢.| d.e;&h\.»_\ 1111 111 , h AA! 13 1;~ '_ v1_»1}\1>"11\1
_..\.L>BC\C hva Gr§\\t juridft_ 31 hir~ln~\'h`\;nl?o$u%\nu§%1&3\-01;561,\ _§\'_T\$ SREI‘:\B`I£.'E_

fig “\'ha C>n\\l remain
_T\"\\°» `l,""‘f~l "-",>\1\>;'€ M\:Ltd§un_'~\ric\,\ §§m§e.%\§ 1\_\z `\'v\cc>m\)elrém-_<»_ `\v\ 1114 am

031:§“- lion @\H_ ` \v\~levc‘\§ -\-M’LA was 111\11`151)1.\»1¢¢1 (L\P_\\-\"L"en§ \Q\\ § `~\\uvL ~1:>. umt\i»`.z‘
' 1m$`\1€r.1 L.\>\~§\n ~\-\/11`_{1\\10)`1¢\. `.Ihd`\`t:§ n-§ flange Cvc\C\LQ?_j\lo\ £’.Dun \ `1\ §\> r_\.\>§er.i‘c`:
1;‘;11“;;‘:1;"15 ‘M'“~I w EAM 191 ' my 1114 91 …
'€‘>H“BL\ S\.EE 131 c»r.\<\l._§ 31`§\1':§§"\1§;'§`11;§51> F“z_§~“ §§ §§.>.Q\§§§\§)°"°e' be

./_{
3?£&\_\_&_\;___

 
 

' m

         

:E>:{§PQPBHOH¢ pra\l_\ ~\~§'\0~§ ~\')\i§ \'\Dm>r~ab\§ [‘_w,.~l Q`n;ml_ \C(_Ng ‘m \;h;§ .-,. ,~ 1 ` 1 v 1
_lie`m 93 :L`I_LLE(\JAD-Q'\\` §§ \?r_r¥>_ci.><:§l `m ~\-¥\¢` j fbri£j§;‘\g;.\ng£\pa>\ic,@~§\&n me §§m\)\?&r_\l`. >\I°
)'1£ nam‘& be °S`L,\\`;l\,]_¢f¢,` cm§lm_ R-z'-IHLE» m;.`:\n meal b\\ ho,Cx ~e.& ~|r_\a_ ¢.» \`r\

O.(l‘i

\RD\S°~M¥"\' ¥1;:.{3(;\7%3 i):`\n£\ |)rr,.£,en-i\\| \:\v\jn~€w ~`ui¢¢i m ~\-\'\@_…limit

(%\ -\~h a e.\mx MDePa (§.~;m,m,,\"' ALL LL§€,(::,M iiji.__£mc;wvc_\`m§s i~o m\\

p, \`\eji- Oiel;i_are_ unde.\)v~ Dmui¥l L~>i"- Der.iur~\ im viuied`m H;.;, mD~\`.<>n weim¢ cmi torrez-it
LJn r £r .

_ /( ‘#3/1781
»`ew |<.I&MMMHHHA

'\

:*i ubb€*`i M BC>\»\ASH/ZIHB| aim hirel)\! ££\i»\i}‘l ~i‘ha~\ O~\-r‘ue_ mmi torrac.~i- LCp\\

C ~`i`:\£.> C`§i¢\r>\\é. (Y\l\}¢\`l.m i"\a acidth ' i-bv-b.)r,wcie;_i i;\\\ ~i'he, l iniie£i eddi&`r€.§ Mcwi fd\\$‘i-NY\
05 13a ‘ ¢3~re mud in ibt \\<>m`m.¢s C\r:\rire$>b€»>‘é

i"iC 59 r\~\\iq D)'SS\-i aieri/\
¢T\'\Q_ omni aid C\t`.m`m¢,j Appeal_g wr`i>%l>‘ m 100\1\,
1 pll§\ &D`( icggdl)% CQ\)JMB\ gigli\`bn ‘ \;)D\ rfc‘nk{:i m "“ ,°'

Au.gi»m,-'\§~,f'\%v\\\ i-\¢;L,\..&i\>n»`¥$c._*\*\§\l)

 

£C‘;

QKDPB

 

1-1(\\1£`1_;¢~1 1<19 Q1AL‘\I 1)¢\hg-1m

       

mun1\11 T_)([`\(w___
Re.spr>nd 001

v 1:1(1¥~1"\§

DDMLAQMLM@LMMM
MNMNAPMAMALLLMMM LLS&S

_1_1\1.§ 13 ibm Exih»§r\ir\g¢~‘{ 11\1¢~11- 1515 Mcmdomu_% (`i>m1)1cI§`m~1 flu)rkbr.Le.A 1311 `1-1\`.5

UY"\C\'\WLJ QDL|QMUS pm `r§[_,\(;,n.\, K`{S(` 1311

 

2 l&¥¢.Ln£|L-C-NDQ..PCGL§ Ahr.u. Ap1~1.1“1 1351 13 fmc-1119 “1-0 13031 i',n.\m 1`.4

 

  
    

 

>_‘>~1 f`\ r1 ih\1-1a_1 1:1111“1.3
1126 i‘) ~1~r~u Cmrl fbc~r~if;1- under ~1-1¢\9. l)e_rv.\\»1~“| 1012 pad ‘h .£\E.E- » £1-11‘:1-10__

."\LAL\¢ . ib b £n 1\0¥\{.`. (_\ya[ .:E.X._ ~ `:1_1¢:15\- wrv\» 01:1\» Sc1ir~1»'oc_ n \.mcle.r l
`;1§§£101 ' § ° S`W§Y:@JHAM&`&“E§ ”“`LM "'"
.._- . > z _0,___ __

r\ Y`€.‘U.\P..S r tx m ignc‘li\le, re_1ie'3 10 \-c mm\zl C\EE Ix.. ' `Ulwm§;{mgr;:
~ ».t.!:t>.!'....__. Cm1;1 \~ 1-€\¢*1\\-g

 

_1,111_§ Ex~1mb\~¢15nar`| Wri1» 511 [Y\r,m\¢:.mug ,_5 cm tdr~d¢_r c1\’ref1»`\v\£s 0 9111\1.0 i\[:fij`\a_\ 10
‘D\M~p rm C‘>. (1\..\'1`/ 1’.¥' 1 \\\1 10\,;_~,[\‘\ 41 \\5\11 '\'\1-_;1. §§5[,\£~1-0“~ rig C1\x'1-\1 ~1- »-11£;, iv\ 0 \1 `€‘§l"r_e,
601311131\19-5 -§1:‘1£_\, 431 QNMY£ 0 \.LF[§/\r 1119wa ‘Q(L\E,Q\Mé;

111 1 l P, l 013-

l RQ\£_HLEX imur.chm¢i Ma=iiu~.
~V\Q\B\`v~`\\» (>c MC\V\/i(xmi,¢$ l 3 fm F\r\fj€r\~\» fbmm¢m lioup: E\i¥\e£\‘\’Un l'§¥‘\.‘.\m Ll.w~\ik

 

F§;A E) ll.i\
i‘.&\\?r ms zimml`u w:$:f)ed%) \>lx}?.\`( OU|'"i~ "m(` pm` ""'_\U ’H`[
iat§l¢h\(i`§ &`(ll:`c`€:\'; EAT(‘&:` »`L\n\_: he lpcu_" 443 \1_}»\ m &\:qz. l\.§»¥\\~\~ \§'r (`. \¥`Ql€i@£-H Er: m Q'
havana §§ mi)ob_i \\16 ti \Q.j\£ M¢’. \~N\\`¢\`rt wm C\nm“\ SDFY\¢ C\"

:i:.§§m 6-,.191:6 wri:i~ _*,.

ge \eci_ up mi _~i-i\a;i N`Lcdl£\_is°_&____:`
gardwiici§L`fh:/`§[LB -C\£-C-LQ----_

§

hug

 

QLA@ 4_-&£}?1¢;;w
~i~i\@ Bfi:;::l'§ m‘Qli-Ul| ('.\ ll>x\\'\»_;`:&u~i§|élil€.n_

. _ ,\,_ §~i-h ~\-)i»acm.wn.q.]_ .$,,`mi;j LAD-:K” ink .\:1§[;;_¥‘__[;}§\:\£ qq;.\;:|). ) 53 ai_‘ii:[`

fl ( J~é’ Gr\_ - \6>.'r ‘.¢\. i~P"\-i~%b \[_p (Y\ , sgk ,\ la e Dn

fl&§:\'\%i " l §§n§`: v~/I"\li\~ l "'xb .»`§`m$\‘i 'f§'¥i\i"' ~°é¢¢v» immian
U"'E.

-<,¥1£.'_ A`\ meSM, 0 “r\.\`- \.1§¢| '~\\ nn L/\»_\`d `1,€6£\»-\`\ medahr\ rca
31 j‘L‘L“ R{"`w"“\‘”i|` 5"‘¢>'\'1$'»~\`-'> Y!€ Uh&q?\,l\\|nfr:i“€m\‘.l:v\%i\ ;\L:`c.hv-l abel pre,\cn~\) \f) Cs. use scm
di l`?- \i.\Y\w '

 
  
 

 

idle C“A`. M`L§L`l§'v\li.u §,~iAC.-_i \\`|_S SU. _\CA' ltd E¥`imhr~[!mn&` RE£|QE l,»;‘.i~ n{ ko_ i(\.u\_,\ (‘\euri‘\ .‘T_)E\l:k|;e' ml,`_

 
 
  

    

 
    

\)el;.i<;\r¢£;r,\'¥\\:\\ \l\rd (`hd § 590 \(' r\ n_\l¢.\\r\\(kl §§ WVJR:_\/ m;: §"\jkiil
f\(\°m PME'I\ L\> n¥ \W.E£‘_¢`&§ n ‘“.\q_~\,\¢\p¢ L qq'\\¢_~\ Y‘l’\\r\é3 ‘\\ 0 ama 6 w\r.l
j ;;§\e§& Seu&~\¢£\ \S C\m\v\i'\.\p_v~\¢\ \¢;`;\ \\ nw 165 wq\`pw\, (\g¢_~pi>o§q` ~¥b C\ \SL`\¢ zongr~`i '
W‘Q“‘\¢\ mu$ vii Q\\w,\\>`Ym~\s¢\ul\oh 61 c\{’,;~ .s~ns>`i; \:lioF./:|' re @. .
“Y(;\.Q#m€r\» €h\h`rli \»\, v -w_\`r m i\`\,.{ ~ _\_\ .,`,._p_§%u `Y‘\aa 'm:.i gee ‘
\ m\\ 3¢\\.¢ '\_\ 1~`¢@'\5\\ "`\'W'> u_r,i`c_;\¢ i\fr>nduL Lymr h§ rc`\ 6 (`.m

:;,‘u@.\ _cm un§u \

  
         
    

     
       

vw_§‘_ ?'Mis&c=rrm§e£>`l
B\` v\a¢*| '66,`\+. \'S

' \\Cc..`r£`\~\%m_c»._\ C\ P \0§;"@
"\y-\ . \u 9_~1- \'L \'\` di (‘_mni>\m\'\
15 C\i~\ol'_\¢\em l.¢;\.\ ..\.\.\ `___._> l§'Q\' hig`m£¢§ \'\L\u ea\ fder Av. l\. D§,

UH\LL\M AW€LJ_S(§& X§¥\ 666 \~\‘ g .§uw'\cl\ci\oh in mmin i\\v. \<>\cmr Cnu »-i ibpqu

 

r i-\\e, arm-wi

l‘\"'> \!Y\`\m&`\ini¢

. \ `
N§)i'\? Y\? i\'J\"i- pi"bmi 56`3 MC\/if:» §ei/.)i¢:»r pm\l§ ~\»\~L\i i\¢\\\ \\m\\\sv~a\s\¢. Qr,~.uni Q\rcmi 5\-\,-`\<_s
C!`UP

u_§ \\')PC»mDP
\h \n `““` nh"-`ive'i-i¥,_§i:.\;:: baby-effects rm A'\h\-e'_\ W\\|’\\Si{rir,.j _\Cm~i‘i \\'\ ii\\`§ C(i¢r\`mu.l iam mailer

n;me

…om_l.lm__,__

:1 j>\<=~]mv~\f>r~ RD[)~PY\~\ KL FBD\J\CLS$LIK\FR| \_)L"m.€s ~P»~e\.:n~u`l ncavc;~zvu~\e¢\ »n~\»kem\nm.§_[_l¢mm{§

_‘-&Te.\¢c\§ DQR,rlmvh‘l 00 'r~am, L,j `Yu.S-L\ I.k'a.'_`._ Cl any
~"r~ m`l \‘.\€\\`SP P\tdnw~l@; hhle ge- &r`\\u§llc}`@_ EQL~\- ~\-_g gigan `w\ ~\\n`\s A\)\>l\`r,c linn or:£lm::\g

c\v\r\ whom

_.

.¢Zég>l<>_z.<;

L.l-\T L:

“E@Q£&LMQLLQAA¢_MBL

R¢;~l)ev~i I( Bou|r_l_x 11 IBH'IBI

 

Ci’dc§tLLl~CC.a-LL.DQ_”§£LMM_._¢

é_; p\m`>ev~\\< gla,\\(~b¢ii/’>W€I aim he, e|>\a CP»li‘ll 1in o lmv.u~\ formal mm
P

p "'x\£ C)\ \(>.\\ € P°\\`L(\ hon \{\(_'\\ \'P(:r\ '\‘¥‘\_\5¢ v~f.\e_¢\ ‘D\\ ‘\~\'\i\_ Uh`\l*€! C\"Ule~$ mc“\ ‘!\\`S‘J‘e-°" p‘°'§""€‘qf‘m
rt~\`)(u`~c\ ¥\\ 5¢.\\¥ o\ w:-H\S\ C\(§<\\-¢~¢`»Se-§¢

_T\“‘°¢ (E'DU'"\ OD C'\~lm`ma,\ /-\PP€¢J$ Hc\rr~\`h 'Cwn--\~l hig~\.@\e.-l(
0 'D' Bf>\l 1330?> ' m 1501 moir/51 '
EA$~HM g~\ul`con n );)L\.-i Frc:r’\khn ~Q`T»
Au R_\m"`r;` ~_-)%r-lu *"\[)U_§‘lml`n.‘-]F]Q,D

,Augl 23 £ol.i
DAT§
. k d
` §% mri lZ. %n§:i§gQ/.zm£§/

p. 13> t.\(:" 3