Court Opinion

ID: 4042894
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:12:42.567103+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:26:59.289003
License: Public Domain

31,¢-!00 03

 

 

 

 

.._"€_ ___C_.@\>$Q 1105 303 143ng
' po\/%Q . §T/\¢ /HC <§>33` 3\0_.0:“1£1`/§1_0__

 

v ~ ,___` §W>:S"r/QI_TQ C@u_,€ToE
gobe;@@£o@@ /11_`_ § 'w_T_LcLJ,A/\;)§ 0_/\1_&><)/\))\/ //K

 

'A A '_ 7@.©13§@§11§@? LS
l w3!`\:>i0£»_’1_j;0w1§ 3091/10 §;QUW§EA

 

 

V:NMNC; 00 VAC‘FS AM\\AWW§@§£RUU©N

 

 

 

©r'~ L A \AL Om>@ll

 

 

. ACC@r§m\/> 10 pev.:110 v ;‘"""/w§m 73 1:'331¢{,1¢1(111%,
(5:` C¢°’ 1130?1:3 {%Q 160-61 1:,,0€1¢)'\0 Df0000`10!0(']p@£>€\r
1\1&0\1'~\§ >_ 1`/11)§“1` 192 030000\‘10 for fP(AC%,/\o fC{z§\c)/)AW»€
C®rre'c‘?é 00§1)1~1_0 ,`U»<>n §;\) /Ué$&é… \/(`/3/1)/)3 11 §71@1<><
§§ nd°\m< bc§'@§ §01010\1 010 §§ 13013€( 10002;01 000 001 fl@(e§0>0 gill`1/10/)01? 1i.1`/)0¢~).1Q(1H’ 1001
112 11/\0\1, SQQ, 3001§0_ 110+120€ m?m.o \< 00010@~
00 10\\,;>31/\0( nce/01 13 001an \§ 000 S\)DD0Y1001 10\11(~0
FQC@rd 351/10010101 190 0304;)1001. Th@m 0€'\`00(»1?00
.{0 G>< pg\r%a `1) &;M73050031306[100® (AP
` 1: nd 102 00,&1 (`0,)_01€' C0r)01\)§§cz)n§ C~\/Q 001 ."§000@.¢~1@1 3

 

b\_-\ ~1L@ rq>_g©rd

 

 

Al;;el‘ A'COS~}C~_ClQ'(-l§` 7 ~ v 3;3!@" lZi .
- 160_\_1€>1>1 1951>'& * ' ‘
A12_31:1»1\’1>< 73_111

 

 

lQQ l/\)l? 7l5l(1>@ 355 C~>< ld&r+§ 51)>'\¢01,$1)*
dps/11 1111 Ac,o$%@`

 

 

Cem \JDQ Ol,§0156 5il l§ 1\/\11 033£§151'0¢\3 15b 1156 ,

. _‘50 SL\;5 L@Q®li (,_\( §90155+@00_\301>_1911066
5 l§ 5`\,11% 3 omme 519 51L@A 519 151€11 dow
MCA\MU§ ee\06005110_1 lt l§© 1131/01/‘1((-“1(/1<2
\11>1> 11 1391)111>111 1 mm 319 1111> 10111~111115 _
15 .5\\§<530\%0 'I 111 13100`1¢1`1)113 \101>1112 51 31 SA.SC_
, 51 1195 1111 11111 1 1§111111111 115 519 1111 513111 11
161/1311>551.030 \)\1>1> f§L\/cl_ 51351l§cl 531W§S§1\9§Ql i\5'53

5L6 Q31>Y53 1311pr l/)Q.ng l

 

 

 

 

§ 11 Y\ 661(§_l 3 //

%w¢ 131

 

 

 

 

 

 

. C@USQ 11 05 307»22773
H~'>< @(12 §‘I/\g /H€ <9771:01316:7‘16_

 

§
. §§:_;72:_67 /C_DUE`F 05
.' gob€;é 5/010-/_\_1_1_L_ _§_L_\)_TLL_IAU§_@N_C©Q)_\S`“/ /P<

 

 

 

Q_;:_l;@w 5 707/€:142€01127'5_
1?:;1\0>7:1\10 02 riAc:-r: /\'m\ 60/0610_5:0)\1_

©1_' 624\1\ @Rbé'z

-_\.,,_

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

/A\QCDrémO 170 1062111110 \/:50%0§;@0 79 1:3@1 ('1‘1__1"1['1<¢_'_
_CE+C `1.~°’ /°1‘7<;% 7!\2 15027_ 7.`_,;1<1"_111 9206260126’&!021¢ .
7\\60\¢`=11\§> 1`/05+ b~Q 016'22\0072 D§nr F20261110_[QQ§\M_2121_€2_

C\Bff€(;f\" 1'€§1)17€ , _7%2/7_)/_\)_/_\)_6:1?66120;2\/ ()¢0/1//)§_1`1;§77070§
v ,.£_11:\;7\_12$5_1'>_0\$221 S`_o)£/\I ®m 02 DOQU 1220_0101_@1\02_/§19?1 /1962§§_0211>)_

§§.72);771€01 '1'0 06 10f2§1)MO710)/\,  _C1_1_sva C©llm§ D\C;(a \'».`_;;1¢_)[» 712 1/\&7)20§ 1\)§5:2 m§’

007 1312 721/103 \1)032~€ 06\2% />07 G\cj_cz 70_ 601400§1’2 762
§_7@@101_21\_/_173 0\0@4"`11037 1\2/ 20>/\ 17%2/)01 121:1011|)12615€ 107)

7L2 tr10\ 322 65\)~:\22 /"10:7120>9 1“1)11`r1<> 1< 601:)_7;22_
' 120 1000-3 102( 712/167 73 2211112 15 /107.2€_\)_?_19 _19227221$_~[ 72(2*
_F_&C@_rcl 51 §/’)01)100_7 132 O\A®D’md "111221_01£_10_2¢§_____2
.+.1> C>< 100112 b 212141110 7_¢105 1033 305£1919® 2),2__

7::§1’\:1 7L2 7212-1 CDL§F7 S CO/)C,_1_1)_§S1Dn§ 002 1707 §0p1>00r721
b~17L2 1’26@2<7

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_I'q'_ 001 Q191€ 10 50€<€5_51[1)11\) 114 12 ML/ Q_( 1__`4____6_€_€6?4_§9___
__1122 31012 (,_004') 1 1004 OVQEr 112__\/1’_n2n1_r2€0/913_;10
_§_\)_222§5£0_1_~{_140`449 1/\\4 §19`41142 . 1041_24@ 1291 9 H0_4"1m
_£0_ 3291 112 02294_21§*?A1M12'Tr?9190_4)r1 91944,41241 11254/
_1;'\_01`40/'\ 194/4 3112‘15@ 130 15_ Q9r\ 1129 Si€_O\,K 110§< farah/12
1/~31/_\&)9_1~1/\0§€ 1”2490!_1*5 01`2 m fdl\)€§+)®m¢?`tl& ©)’)1\(_(,~3_9\____
10 049/2 1294 @4/991_!_2_1944 449 9014491 44:)4:40224_42_2__
%\944~\ ':1: /121221 11092 VQCOQK 10 l)/2§01\/2 M\v 149/471 11
Q ©1€{4 C€r /14@1401>1 )Q/)Mll
>22T 942 44 441'32)44141:044444;43_344$_5@;4_401__
9359011221 93214@01 .
80 03 \/90 294 411 1294144 322 1191 0_10014`_2_21:200;1_&92;__
9344§1.1\109>2142r411€ 510-12 4< b 4411/40 11 biCQQSM__
144/mw 101401 41 0/‘01/2§ 1195 1612 _O1_/_ (2;§_2_21/_4"(:1/ _____ ch_§_l_l___
991 132 9929§91~494\ \031 §44@441_'13_ 024“_44 10 11294/\4_2__1\€___
_r~&§>d_€ __(‘43910§1_91_€_0_/\ 9 C1\§ 121 1015_1€ /\)04412 011 1104/4;24~111)_1142,_
j_l/L€_n_`t__\.{g@d fe§@/ £_`o @UQM /\ 3 110/'/ 1651 119< `11<%1-4
@U€_ni?_f\_@&~€_ 1)_0/~42 3 50191"@//) \4@1\, by 112 1094 4401 1
._1,993 M0)2312>1 @5`21)091 110219\41 " //)Qn 5\€ 1100 424/24
150 112 ~130110094”/2:2) 'é€$14`440n\/ 1100'115-”_€2~1101 142 01 41 ~
1"1 041<2 9 &CC_ 08_91_01\_1)_2_410 r€

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

/

 

430/03 g@@§;"

 

/~70/\+ 120de [/»<303 a 7027 00`-72_ \1)00 abou+ Qood 701)€76
3790\¢77000710$377000 l r/\¢1Dof70m`7 770 QO 73 71 §0/11€ &3077

 

2007701/?7-\1; 77 50041€2_97)_3\vaS vivr>uCA,m \20\)')/) 0 l/JW
» '770070 \1/0)0 37324’7 7000/)7 70 797 701)&7\€¢73\730 \/0\7 5

 

VQMQM key »Ma)v C QMQc/40_0_777 S€_e 779 O‘HQF '
Qo€$+?@¢'\% 7LOA- 770/17 OLSL @UQ/)M»\ =
7\7007 ®0€*473/\ 30 000 7)00~> 032/)61~2 723 5 7027 2 7\€»/? 76>7€(€ 7007 74`) M€ 75 736 710$1?/7<27 70 5?€7 O~
_ 1970/5 Co\l 5077€_\1/ (`007 73 117f€5$ {`H)\ra@ ` '
2 . \7701/)7 02&0\4 50 he 7£0%2\’7> 3` 3 776%7 for 1de
' @U€M"`»/\' \7€5
501 2902 716 7€57)2\4_&71»12 v1200qu0m Cv7£d()_\_4/7x/v§d@0 7703 QUPM_?Y\

 

cl 9 11999 Q 5§9><051_ 01_195 wm 053<_).?11&% Gm@u /_<11_111)§5
119 %1\1119 rs c lew\\; 1159.9<1091 repo/11 wm 1191 1119
§QAé.nQ iLQ C_@_ur% a 999991993 \/er§`w 7\3010 CQ,D5__ 1119
5@©0930 MLO\)LQ O\ `11;110_01119'03 [\/90,-_$1091 wl+Z` 0\ fdc/add a/€r$/a»,\
03 909 03>/?99 9900115 As \100 9011 9/9<1111 599 13114
1253 3310:39 “/UC\/4C19" 000399 109<>11 1319 re@rz! 100-3 0/19 ‘
9»111) +c> 9919+'9 111 ome 09 010 j1 /s /1109/0111/9 `
10@1/ 119 60 00 le§ 00 6103 Q ”Q[¢_/_C__ ])ong',”+)w 010
@010 199/ M 1911/191 10//)01/)9 010 1559 Au$+ 10 100/199 590@1311@173
' 3331\{391 10 )3?01»1§ 501 119 901/x 39/)@/91/0 000 0191' g
19103\09 ron 3 50 119 90m59)5(?;9113 my 19 111 91
when '\~9§“3/"'11@¢/1\1 (` )m// 30 5%01_95’ »)LLQ+ §L9 3105945712955’1;@//
/®> /;L row 1190 319032999& V»”1>115'" 55§51513155150595£0@1515?55_

5@_\_\,5>01\995<3019\{\\> 'é-LLQ\M 39sz 30uPL§` 1401 73‘\\21'\ £//\e §39\‘3€
53 U~\QAC,L\` ng 01 9990\9$-9¢3 \/99§,_05/\5 00 i`LL£c>)\`c_e_ 129po3_5_

’g>/ `6?~9 C©orf 03 Qrm\mm\ 3)3\9095\5 30 (9_\/5`5915\-35_50\\505©5/1_95
‘Fibf ‘U~Q NQ\@QQ§ 000&9 30 Ve\/`. 913 N_@wekr 7 was/109
95\/9,( D\/o\/‘§ecl 01 feiq§i€é \/59{§»09_\ £<> 1993/910 09 9~.
951/nance 30 refu'}e %Le5 rem/j 111 s \§ 00 11qu5b59€0.05595

.'€Le 99001’3§ we QJO\Q+@JBOJSD 319 005@110\910,3@1`3
09\(90\0\\ 390»,15!\> 30 119 559§01052 1059 mere 030/1303 Q35’9
“(>}§Q inF~o coo§ 00093 00 fLe_ 31"1@\ few/0 »

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

‘ 5510 +1” 015 Coori \L)StL <:(QQ/~(Q;/_ f;{_'Qo/_ 160 feD@/%SD _'fz>
_be_S_Q@S_1j_}1/e dam /1 01€£0/_§0/1_00 w+L /,M. 10 _q,/D
`l`hm 0000 1054 new doi/15 U~S /_/\lr< 015/er de _1[<;\0‘1'_ when
` j%%u /1000> `U\ wore fefor_f_$_ rzj_SS/n$_,-__
1_)_01_0(__235101)[¢1 _010.+__`1>01__ __~j_ _b_e_0_0 1£15+01\_@¢‘ f 1/-0 700_!?_00__ 1’0{>_<_>1/_+5
' . 1/1 ng$+. en §O _LM 0191001`1113_ ~60 050 1’70/`<:0 14001_>0{5 1
` bel/10 5_00§0`1§ 3 /10£ 10_/1>1/1§J, m __0 11>_‘..`1*L00 00_C00\/ _I’A{_O~
G\ch_a_ckmg 01 Coww 015 1':20 Mo£,on? ©fc/Qr ammi/)j_ %&_0__
3001\11/13_0'{_£$]0010_€ feaa/§§ 003 C€) Hoa) CQ/)
_\/4>1)_ S_Qa__g_l QV_QFNLL 3. 0100`1’ 1/0 MQ 11501_0/1)_'1)/1_§__0/_ %_Z_e_ /5/05_€0_$_

._C® 1; 905_30_01__ 0100_®_¢_%_5_£|££@_5 115 ,09_6015 1510 S'lee 5
‘ 3+52 ir. 001 :>'1)§1&' 5 ©r`§v 15 Clewl\l mt 5000/1*0§ b

3000 mc@r§ A~s \11>1> 00111 500 /)oi 1>1/1_@ fm § ibm
Qoo+e Yrbm iLQ few/§ M>r 1;0$1)412§ 011)5151110 tLQ+'_F_
_ 0§_<151~\051_1 %L iLe mcord. 'T'kem 11” \1'01) f`éfe,/ 615
‘ ~ 111>1,5/15€_1/111 1_/ 511_‘,11 85 3 C.+ 7116 `151;57 1+ §iq+_@< +L@+

 

 

1111|0_33 010 SM+Q QD§H_M@_QU_Y f€&cl~e§___§e_c_§d 1410{§
\SS¢QS 040 ~Fe\'m\ +€/1§_01;0_&_}»3 _5005_5)50,/1_~|~_1,@ §M‘/”Q -
_Q_D\)r\~ 014 Anjv '1’0$_04\/13 01 1006 1_3_5_11@ +)_015? woul§ P_/)+H\b

_@031_}31_`1_1)1_1_1/ +O 1001311( 15 reS_oh/QA` 111 00 10151/111[%5@\
_Q_Q:Y_):\'_ _<>r_\€r_\$_ Qo+) HQQ] +0 G)/\ €\/ §en+» O1F\1 1050er /}10/1)

' -)LL€ §+01+€ C1011c4§ 06th _L d olm'{:_ ©_\/QKCOMQ ila

3 . _€)_[E\)_ [/\)€/Z § \/01) /:Q_z§/ +D_

C' X VW+Q 131/01))<5 1§1% SLJ `5<§ 3% 15 5`+@1%0§ _i_l~@c?_ 1:5_
_1__3_{_1‘_£ 1/1_0005§014` 160 1/ 011/1 091”1))?£<11_¢1} 00 prov@_s___mn_o_@/QC:Q_

 

 

. . ,
F01’1L24 Q1111La1 13 mece$_$m\)_ `,g 02 Qr,,»lo\ 901€`1@ 510sz '
<1>_1@_21210_01\_`\_1/11:10221.122$1)19 cm_©g/_em@£p _T€)c_ _C__od<>
Qr§ 41 Proc /1/111 0141 1_|.7>'_1§‘1 50 1021 \1@1)€0141_007)§1_¢1€1/
i_LQJ>\gr,ig 01 iLe C101 11 "1'11€ 5i0112 _Q_{C£»($ _ELQIL_ 7__
d <10 é 'FG_E§_Q i_Le iggu_e m M\1 /§` H&éeas C_Lorhus_ <9_11 _3_1)_415£_
A/_\§é_@:g_om 1001 011/ 113_ _112 \\)ra>rs 1512_‘12311`1111011\/ 1121 Hw
_4_211_11@_31_¢1_;,0_ C_cg;)_10_4_'1;@1 34_@45_
' _1/§§, 011§013_1'€_2_011001)’¢_'€(2:11_251_`,_1_/]_0_/\\4 010 @UQmL n Hl_mft)€ 1051,`,/1:1/
Q_D_Q®r_m_r_\_g_ ~l;L_sz 010€123 il@\+ 112_011_1_€_$_€_01_HSQ)CL)C\}_CQ))'\+QQ+’11970_41
1/$2 1/\22¢1 112 001/1 01 11`1§ 1%11110@{_401/1€7¢_‘1`011149_0_112001_13€@_
3300_§}0_122`§_ 20_1\1_3_._/7121_1)§`1111 ita 1/'1`311§ 01 1561/lms _f:wo ?1`<;11€):§_
. (ALH 117 1512 \1> 11 :1'€1/1_6_1\10_0‘1`\1s 1_1"1)21<22 N®LQLQS_LQQ£Q_ Qp01121_
_©§_éLz_©ri§.~nq\ 10102/3 Oro_Q_@QJ`;/r»g 1612\(_40_¢>_0___’14 1/Q_ 54_2):1
'§L\c\_¥ 11 1323 13¥0031_1~ 010 1111 `1`12 /$F froQQeQ/m__b¢i ‘/LLCM'_`
F‘€SD©/Qeo( fm 30_321"1_ 1LQ_ _`H_&\(_ Qfe_ir_\_{j_pg_€e_gzo_ /;1D43___, w€,/_(__
juon 1110<§@§@41 /)o% 1/1¢>1@112¢1 Ar+ 3<@;1?_"‘_1$911/@1 HL_
30401’2 1512 0271`1/12¢17 ‘1€3¥, 1111/111 %LQ+ ~él\e»/ rQa1/451@<1 1_*/.2_/1
7 ____1,0<2_0121_\12_10€2/1 1:0\)41& /101` Q\)111"\1 071®__1@$1 1`0_0_711§
©_m_2_§ __1:110_0_,_@2&21_054 11 11111) 42102./- 10 14342@_`2_*10_>_1_1_511_01_§_

` 1211_21*_'1'_~1;1_?@111 1 4401/2 141 131\10€€ E+Ls FAQA§___L_p/d<€111`11£_01_12__

.: Mm/QJ 1/\ _`H\Qm 11 \/m) 43_1527 10 ()_ 1€ 10`,1_1__

 

 

 

 

 

                

 

 

 

_ _

S)/n>e~> 1Lo:1» 1302/11 7\ 8101'1`22 1121 ’no" 100@41“1,1<» occurred
1¢\ 112 Mon+L 1111`020 101111 12 11 3 C@L)$?Q:Mm_ _$1_221_
\,_0_‘_~1‘\')L _U 3_1_1101_4£1_0_£21)_21:\1723_©_€_10rre_& 1`)©( 1012 41071'11 ©{

 

 

»’)&n_uQAr_\_®_.b_er_\_l:);%_éwo~$§_§&g¢$;§?c& QLLJ?+L L)‘S‘_ § _
» “\“%Q.n_k\_@;_~\,o_c§ osha nn CR£'\E~‘/Q) `.€ he re%eq“b_qs§c .

j_r>_u_;._lg;,¢§_ho\p,p&nw§_;u£@er ila ><»/\q ag ho_i?_'dgjj_é\g_$bo_\}ij&,@_"

 

 

_b.Ql_&_$;{_oQ_CQQ*Q,[.QQC(;(jjee_éé&¥c 'T.§ have_prwiéed `SMu£€,i@/'_de_.
'_QQMY_§*Qsiolo_l_`._S./_q`_»n§_'lo*\jo_\_?_£epo_nd§):@ n&_o{;iLe_£V_.;ie/_\,egkw_ _le_J/`)_°):__
YL_Qm5£§¢_@\#;®mi_v_:_@_l;&§¢_;;m_\,_m_o_r&§r;o_m@}_§v_:@;@v_l_d;` )Le_véoQ/_)_\)_SJEEQQ\ Qe&r iv KE_IY~€§‘H?@ `Fl/\Qn `\\0 qou rf\cer'€)
*CQQCZ /CNQ$?Z>> ila Ymve$+»?jo¥§no 33'% C§j% Nv$hey§ 71€`331_)3£_79;
._i\> fe 'Le ¥@ll_ow”,m§j%o§v 149ijch _5§§)_0»*1&¢@1_¢1€§ ' +€.[£Qb_on_gcqld_
1 Q..(@M\ Y?R\\ %@_A_@@);_QMAFM AW/~z.~@.n-) g;gn'+ Q_AMH ad
_ '__$;/_<_"><_-\LC.\'_\_P_\_'\;S.QMA\_)C¥ OY "\ W\>mf>{ 394 \;¢§:\"_L -\~le Q@K?_q.m&jl
4 é&)'-f § mg 'JQ_L€ f 43 Q©¢QLL§LQQMUS_1@ 601 Q©r\/\\Olo.$nom‘?$ Wa§;dom‘e win /00;'_'\100/ '
§N{\ &Qi/\oe§(‘_ ~’i\)@'} "Ol/\\\\§}Cc\\ Q viola/119 CoYroi/)MQ'+§ ns EL<
LQL\Q\Q\;@»M§,U'Q \)Se\+? mg was rico \/Q;ve@ V(i 1115 ©?ojwo\‘»me.d 11 w rQ%-¥' ®QLCAM%§@JjLLA_ ll};ca?\**up_©rljle_-
Q_§__ ,_\£30"£1;1\ ®@ 'f/\_f\§ W\VQ§"\"'¢S\I_A)@\¥$G)~ T);\Q\L}_\£ H_l\)Q\/- /Z" }`n_r +'_oj_c"l_@\\_._®l;\gn Sl/\Q cows *W_Q Q(\_f®_)\_@_§:()’L_l_\f.q_§g_®_&§`_"z_@jl€v_
  f ®© »\f§ mska QX{\> mg €LQ_QUQ§&J;:Q_\);Q;MLS§LOS m3 39in @/\
“~\.~> 5 Aw\$ gaf weak Q\W -` (q M\@ n+tq (o)_¢_’:")_@%_:/`_A_QQ*€Z@_S£_£(g 13 Lo& `.»n wh`(d-' ,\l/ou‘ Q)Sp}i€i“\“(_\f r€Coj/liz<;';l.~____Q/\)
_\) n}ano@`,\r$~\>€e .~éo€ ymcgs$_t_) eiv/\V’ +Lem&re i+L@£v~/QEAUQ_O;SS__;

d `M_\§`w_a§v_§._\_&bg@£LLhiHLQ O\Qp)?mm`\ g LI.€Q] .7 en ? 13 117&0 ,
re£e_/. leo CK(€ FVI~;;D%iL_e Prngcu+g>r o\g?¢ Quen+?n %Ze fo/_Yw!§»

Q\U€S;Him<'. `\¥ £obgft €_\/_U ?A_Q\)C)-ch&(iod 0_)/1 Om~j ©ibl£_o/ ZDO¢;/\j
'_\>_M_+i__@_<~¢_ __QA£¢{_@»_£Q_Q_\'_U_Q.Q@AOr_+._&,b)£'~’_ "A,)Q_’ w m e\/Q/

' O\S]; \{ w +c ’~\1\)_121 w ,,4\ \ n Qm(_¢,~>.o\jl_‘lr;>@" A/$_o_'dji/é,e,”lv_e;___

 

 

___-o

_SQ\\\WQM>{$_L;BMQQJQQ¢[~o_\)_a_c>;L£~ov$,@AY_O/)_~{JL__? 7 ~_ ,@):_)\_1_0\1<_€__

~ \{@¢ map +Ql\§ Z@Q" 5010 kilgo re£@+z> 371$@3¢1200~

_@,,/_\_QQ§J¢ C ¢>/) m Q+§ m fe\/'Ji@_£LLCQm_\/_`,_Q,+_£n `C_@_\)_d*l*gj;a_
. mm§%m\ _Qr+» ~,g +1@_0(%:,4@#?

7 *$_QA;,_&’_Q_Z_¢\Q€/ \_ 14er vaca when Jc'l@ QQ lll®£_€;©*or_+_g_"`¢nié{>_le»_clm}_

 

l _
rg\)\a\\; ®§~ £LQ fagg r¢\ FQ\/QQ.,\Q‘_ €L@:\~ JCLQ +\r Lol_:§m\_gg'§ 4
§ § v\é\vv\g§ 310 mn ov\ §§ § eng Qv-Q 1'\`1L S \)P\|OQHEA;(@¢(M+;LLLQC£>/d

, ` x ` _ _\__

- - j;LiL_RQ_Q&\\mAQ C®L)rjv MQN Q;;¢erg\,<-Q `chg Q\_x):klor‘!+s\ 410 Hmlc@
v 1‘ \ n 1r1 _ l l _

§ b c/\)W O\rw\ ® ( %\\`\”£r Y\Oc\? L\!Q_Q§_r:\_&\_n§§§ ,QQCLQ\_U$_Y_O¢\S;MA\§_\{_DJ

_ ;¢;Y\_§;\@@r_\_ zee +_LQ@_%HQ ?>,A\ mr faa N@,b£&§ QUQI§)Q ’

' FQ\’.Q& wm le z +r”.‘c\\ €Q(n(cl\ MC@_L)AQ'~};L_€\i /\Q.\/@'( Q()D'})L,\J_
_$N>H\ 1512 YQQ@(A per QVQ./ mfg-LQ& Qmu+lg_r.\§? _30\]_8`19~'__

 

 

 

l _~,_ _

_V)S“\~AQ £LQ NC@(A`?~.(~LQA» "\A bi_g&g$g “¥LQ‘B-. jmn&q)v*#£
k ’\ §;»\vsél?e,e H’ cr¥LQ<»>B;LQQLQ_V)_`J(R(>_P_@H_QLMPQG§}_QQJ;JF:‘F_LOL_{ w / _
I\{\_\\\ \»~ H.` 7 {3w0€;&&035_\_£22;+;@/_<:>>&3_0\0;{;0.0,0#@(_$_4..1:!)+LL…__$
._@§Q;\_Q§Q_-\_`_S_Q(,_£Lo¥c 18 col/wi H' `\ S "rM{)_Qr_c_i`}_v_Q 150( `, M\Q '}’Ob@
___§_>_@M+QC\ @\ '__Q;_;gg f' szdé,_q_+_~,-_&.»_MMAS ski m ngL<_.@omM@_
l__SiU 523 ' Q&Q~b€_wofl<@é_@o+»,ALQ£\R_Z:,J`JLWOJQASdif§$§}_i`bn§:pm§\.

 

 

.5;)3;;\:1@[ c,_y.. 1\§%§§ »p€¢@;;_`/_-;@)@,gl:__ _ .Mw_:i@i@é@§j;n_&'/:@M

 

 

 

 

 

=?RAV@R
z,'@:€§ M.h

(/Oh;€€epor€(_ pfel§(`_l$@$ C®fl$»&@fe€l 'H< '_H
PKAWS»HM;NMRW¢@I@¢A QHAUWSC@¢NH@;M;
h_€o\d\o§jo;»/_\__I/_\f\§g$£&§§{_@@lq$_k_`Aclc_ug\w:amol;eme B:EG.EQ_
'F»z§§d M\om mr Q Q_AM ‘3 '»»W 1 ,0'1. A{){>Lcm fm r+z@/ '
_Q@A:{S »'v`z_a§ Ct…. § mm m O+;LQ/ fg<_:.e€_n@_e,¢_p_z;_di~;__

_ __{@\,L>_Q_g%_¢agl__‘/~\,]_ez)c M\m\_(_ba QY\+'HC’?€&_ +o 05 C\_»_@Mzr» n€ mw
E~Q.Q‘_\)l\£w\ ` ' `
\

 

 

%;§€L+FUN\(*:L)_LM;H@,_
':Z_@§Lié#@-',*

AWJ_;*@,W '\% 54

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

F|LED

o’cloc

 
 
 
 

NO 05-307-K277B -.;."'<>"-f`.: f MAR 1 5 2015

Ex PARTE § IN THE 277TH 1119
RoBERT FoRD BROWN 111 § § 'k» W""ams<>n Co-. Tx.
§
V- § DISTRICT COURT oF
§
._ §
sTATE OF TEXAS § WILLIAMSON COUNTY, TEXAS

ORDER ON STATE’S MOTION TO SEAL

On this day, came to be considered the State’s Motion to Seal. Applicant,
Robert F. Brown III, seeks the post-conviction remedy of a writ of habeas corpus.
The State has filed an answer and proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law.
In support of` those proposed findings the state has filed, as exhibits, offense reports
from the Austin Police Department and the Williamson County Sheriff"s
Departrnent.

Having considered these reports and the State’s Motion to Seal, the Court
finds that the reports do constitute Sensitive Data under T.R.A.P. 9.10.

l The State’s motion is hereby GRANTED.

The District Clerk is instructed that the police reports from the Austin Police
Department and the Williamson County Sheriff"s Of`fice attached as Exhibit B to
the State’s proposed Findings of` Fact and Conclusions of` Law are hereby deemed

to contain Sensitive Data pursuant to Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.10.

€><, /S\fl_oqc;

Pursuant to subsection (b) of said rule, the District Clerk shall NOT electronically
file these reports with the Court of Criminal Appeals. Instead, the District Clerk
shall place these reports in a manila envelope marked “sealed” with a general
description of these reports, their filing date, and the date they were sealed. If` these
sealed reports are sent to the Court of Criminal Appeals, it shall be transmitted
physically rather than electronically.

The Clerk shall send a copy of this Order to Applicant at TDCJ.

sIGNED …QA/UV\ l V ,2015.

gvt\/

Hon. Stacey Matthews, Presiding Judge
277th Judicial District Court

 

 

€><, AQO£Q~

 

11 . . .... 777-777

z.'5`[|1\=|) P`M

AUG 1 7 2006

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

,_?__-.. stigma al five ia§`wi "

i,Ll}\i'/¢ hi james ctth :

__"_ l MLWW a,V\(/\L J_EML( V(?{-- ''''''
‘ see aeaaa__.w* w'w §wl' w

 

 

 

 

 

 

. ~4._.~`

§\<\ le_€>i?

 

 

 

:')

_ m mst MB`&`NiY/]f:_:_

 

 

 

&M hug 51 e/§.

 

 

 

 

 

jim § wa rejwuw,

 

 

DL_

 

 

€'>< 62 @§;1