Court Opinion

ID: 4878893
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2021-08-26 08:25:04.02272+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:12:36.919317
License: Public Domain

In The
                                   Court of Appeals
                          Seventh District of Texas at Amarillo

                                          No. 07-21-00077-CV

                          THE ESTATE OF PAUL V. BUSH, DECEASED

                           On Appeal from the County Court at Law No. 3
                                      Lubbock County, Texas
                   Trial Court No. 2018-781,469, Honorable Ben Webb, Presiding

                                           August 24, 2021
                        ORDER OF ABATEMENT AND REMAND
                     Before QUINN, C.J., and PARKER and BRANCHEAU,1 JJ.

       On April 30, 2021, appellant, Leslie Doggett, appealed the trial court’s Order

Denying Movant’s Objection to Admitting Will to Probate. Previously, this Court abated

the appeal and remanded the cause to the trial court for entry of findings of fact and

conclusions of law. Before us now is Appellant’s Second Motion to Abate Appeal for

Reconsideration of Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law. We grant the motion and

remand the cause to the trial court for entry of findings of fact and conclusions of law in

accordance with this order.

       1   Honorable Curt Brancheau, Judge, 84th District Court, sitting by assignment.
      In October and December of 2020, the present case was tried to the bench before

the Honorable Ann-Marie Carruth, presiding judge of the County Court at Law No. 3. On

February 2, 2021, Judge Carruth issued the order denying Doggett’s objection to

admitting the will to probate. On February 8, Doggett timely requested findings of fact

and conclusions of law in accordance with Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 296. When

Judge Carruth did not issue her findings and conclusions by February 29, the date they

were due, Doggett timely filed notice of past due findings of fact and conclusions of law.

However, after the subsequent deadline for those findings and conclusions passed

without their issuance, Doggett moved this Court to abate the appeal and remand the

cause for entry of findings and conclusions.        While the request for findings and

conclusions was pending, Judge Carruth was appointed to the 72nd Judicial District Court

and Judge Ben Webb was appointed to County Court at Law No. 3. We granted Doggett’s

motion, abated the appeal, and remanded the cause to the trial court. See In re Estate

of Bush, No. 07-21-00077-CV, 2021 Tex. App. LEXIS 4895, at *3 (Tex. App.—Amarillo

June 18, 2021, no pet.) (order) (per curiam). In our order, we explained that,

      While Judge Carruth heard this case and issued the order from which
      Doggett appeals, we conclude that Judge Carruth was obligated to and did
      resign from her position as the presiding judge of County Court at Law No.
      3. Judge Webb was appointed to fill the vacant position. Rule 18 of the
      Texas Rules of Civil Procedure allows a successor judge to make findings
      of fact and conclusions of law when the preceding judge has died, resigned,
      or become disabled during her term of office. TEX. R. CIV. P. 18; In re J.D.H.,
      No. 05-14-00504-CV, 2016 Tex. App. LEXIS 7638, at *15 (Tex. App.—
      Dallas July 18, 2016, no pet.).
      Accordingly, we now abate this appeal and remand the cause to the trial
      court to issue findings of fact and conclusions of law under Texas Rule of
      Civil Procedure 18. See TEX. R. CIV. P. 297; TEX. R. APP. P. 44.4(b). The
      trial court shall cause its findings and conclusions to be included in a
      supplemental clerk’s record to be filed with the Clerk of this Court no later
      than Wednesday, July 28, 2021.

                                            2
On July 20, 2021, a supplemental clerk’s record was filed with this Court containing

findings of fact and conclusions of law. On this basis, the cause was reinstated on this

Court’s docket. However, these findings and conclusions were issued by Judge Carruth

rather than Judge Webb. As a result, Doggett filed Appellant’s Second Motion to Abate

Appeal for Reconsideration of Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law. By her motion,

Doggett argues that this Court’s order remanded the cause to the trial court for entry of

findings and conclusions by Judge Webb, and the findings issued by Judge Carruth were

issued without jurisdiction.

       We agree with Doggett’s analysis. In our remand order, we concluded that “Judge

Carruth was obligated to and did resign from her position as the presiding judge of County

Court at Law No. 3.” When the judge that heard a case resigns, Texas Rule of Civil

Procedure 18 provides that “all motions undisposed of shall be heard and determined by

[the successor judge].” TEX. R. CIV. P. 18; see In re J.D.H., No. 05-14-00504-CV, 2016

Tex. App. LEXIS 7638, at *15 (Tex. App.—Dallas July 18, 2016, no pet.) (mem. op.).

Because Judge Carruth resigned her position, we concluded that she did not have

jurisdiction to enter findings and conclusions in the absence of an express order from this

Court remanding the case to her to take that action.

       Because Judge Carruth’s findings and conclusions were entered outside of the

time during which she had plenary authority to issue them and as our order remanded the

cause to Judge Webb for the limited purpose of entering findings of fact and conclusions

of law, we grant Doggett’s motion to the extent she asks us to abate the appeal and

remand the cause to the trial court to allow Judge Webb to enter findings of fact and

conclusions of law. See TEX. R. CIV. P. 18, 297; TEX. R. APP. P. 44.4(b). The trial court

                                            3
shall cause its findings and conclusions to be included in a supplemental clerk’s record

to be filed with the Clerk of this Court no later than Friday, October 8, 2021.

                                                         Per Curiam

                                             4