Court Opinion

ID: 3209628
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-06-06 07:31:19.907972+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:45:51.858600
License: Public Domain

4333f-4y
*/??^ L, 7y7/i> &&**&>'''

                                                                 RECEIVED IN
                                                         COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

                                                                 MAY 31 2013
                     Jtc fo
                               /C^ui^u^.
                                     /

        Z/3~
    J^6M
                          fa

        /^i^e^^i^ia tT^yu/i <$/ ^777z*u*?a*&^&
\jptf5 Sfal^U; (Jk^AOrtf/ T^^t^y tj£&l c/

                                          /1 > Y

                                          ... 1

                               SI
                                              fa*&74j

&%^

           /^00 ex- <— ^   &?,y
S^Z (* £u7?tl. <%*&• £003/                <<> 0

 C.t. /?• a*rf. 77^7                        .*>' *7

                          fit
            c^a£ d/ 6u^uiuu6 /%e/&Z4L&s

                       Jk fa
                                           /

                                       /

                          V*

     J/3*
 fc4^< tS^^l^y kj&SlA^rlZ 7?&6£^l>&; ^feytiUs

         /^TxJu^u *J&n, Jr/uz5 <&/:.&fa>H4&ma&r

\Jo *M& //&?UrtdJdL T^A^^ ^^^^^^^^t^
                s&Z^hK&nTf #/ ^^ 73tza€y

           jf        7/   «--*^ '   /

           > s&xj5 J&4& /TtCuo
                                                            /^td^^ey

                                                  ,ck, /5&< i>^^^

    j/ds1t^L&/U2-s
                                        y. *%%&• ~ \J*n£~

ct^TUM^u^if C^tu^ty Jt/3^
                                                     V

     Ml

                                            <2
   37/^£^i/7^ «^ J^tm^ 3& T&kAztu, 7^2^^
   / sfckdkd, 7%^^^/ 77^jz<^t^^pt^^^ty \^7u^^
    *J&&£ Tift*/ T^ZAlA^Ja^z^ J2/ JtyZtS ^v             "
7f/ 7o/6.

      b^> ^AiT^ <7aA^c^&zs 3^^^^^
3^2^3c^7^k, b^ &a^ ^ 7&z^&^ /^<^<^y

     dii. /%k» fj J^77/ /& £/s*
/)/&&a77*7%%<^ tzj/q&&/ /^

 jz/3 * Q^&^£ £)/^7?u7i77 (3^^ uTkcTe^$
                       'aslC &2y7sZ?L&ytgA/^y
                                      yr?t&2A'i74 kJ&3&7? 33^te^ta^te^t7y ^T^aT?
iJt 3^s^^t7^u 'Jin, &/u7? <7^ T&z^&z^ z^<^c^
 aTa^a^axTaa^c /

                              J
    ^{^ rf/#?£PUl/di (T&AAA^ *AaU, ^A^uTAAtTT&^y AW£^
•£77k. ^^UtZA^e^ ^A^A^AC€l^r 7* b^5£0                     tm^

Jfc J^aiaS ^ Tl/tfAtU 3&i^A6^ &A, a2^7£ **, ZO/6,
 Jee, 3^^<^a, &X7&& 31. ^ z3<^^a\^€^7c^.
                     ^ jffjzAaTAHj, £?c/7>?z£Awg^yz<^
                      6'C/! OAsf, 77.37. A^^^iM^
  tfcef 33pnut^^t£^tz 33 J^£A7a7<^ yZyUU^h*ZAl& A^
 <3&6c466^7^V/ UJ JU ycAO* ^^Z/^^^^^
 AZa<2A^as?zx2Zs <&/'au^^^o^ *l a&ajzs^a^eAi£^
 s6&7uU& O^€^o7t A?Aiuk/ A^^t^ej£ A^UA^',75 ^AA& ^L /^~^U4^
x7?tA>773hL 7*a /UAj&f&te&czy az^u/ 7^9^ ^ 7^^- aa^a^/
T^Tiis j3/^3&aIa€Z3<€, AZ<0d^a7a^ AA>tAl7A^L
 /CAAAV

                                   £
z&l /tCl, /j^^tz^T^k/ csitu. aZa^Ac^^A ±fa&
a7aJ2a1aijz7as&i/is '

                        ^^^%€^«^^ A^z/CiA/csa>
 31. J^yuA <77 A^A24t*3k?&AA /u&7a?y yyn^ J*£ <&t
7/ /fa T^a^a^l &2sks 0&4*i*?trfZ%7i£ /azaiZ
/{fa 3U?/ /a*4oa/£/a '^6c <3^7y^A^A\

77^AA2A,t 7/as- S.&fsA 3 7/, 3731 (j€#„ cUoTn, :
3fyto*. <2**3)( Ca77Ta?a? J/kfa J& yuz£, /f.pt^e^/faA
(///%ey ft S>o7j& 79^ /9f (je#, 33^, <2y^<
*7Aa3S' d3£s AA^AA?UAz7kAA7&& AZAiy5 A£fAAzytlZ^

                                    6
 ^L
      \J&&dAL, 3?akAl &/ 7%7??zA?ial£ /^*^£*/aaa{,
auTaTA, 7/z7 73cfyj^T^o -'
    &y77£t7u *C<* aTazaz^ d^//fa
    /fa TTAht^ y^t yA^/yuAt/ /fa yzA^a/e, y&
      A2A^>AAAeA /   AlyPUZAAAZis; /7/zA^AlAP?/a£, /fa
                 /fa ct#y%ycAzzA7t^ c^a^l/ a&
                                      A2s(J?A

      /lA^AzCA^oc^ y^yzyte^sA^^A^T^AtT^ yPTCaJ^AAt^
       /% /fa T^o/a/* y$A'yTfa A?j&/AcCcZ#yx// .

    d/7A2Ak, 7/>o7Ac/
                                 ' / cTau/zA, yAAfa/>%AaAA\AcGAtAUlAfeA,.

     JgrU /a{0<^ AUdyAfiTZ*^ /jzAalT*, ^UZlA^ //^
yV^Pt^aAA^ £**^ J&*A£ 4iO*£ ~fa* ^^//a^ g/^Z.
^t^^^^,^^^^^^^^^^^^^ AZyyiyf yij                               _
yrTUiMt. / /fa tA' AaiaUcC, Oak, y^upTit, /yu^/^ALAT^ /fa yO^A^zA,
/ AAgAAA& ycyfaz^u AAAjL AzAUL z33*KZtiy?&eAA&Ay
              y^tstg^AtAzA^zytT^ ym^yZ^AlA/
                   / /fa 3^&&Aiz^Zy>t7A \&7aA
                                                         Jz>
<3%?o JTauA z?A TA&Tk*^ 3?A>yZ&*Zs

                                      A^a/za^                          A/a/<1
cAzZAA^ Ab2AAA£uA&A
 AATaTaTil \7pg *77au/ z^•A>y&*uAi0uoz,
 Aie^AAuATk, yTfaA JAA&IA c/p^/7aAzA'y^^£y^tj^A
                      7s^<7ji ^3^4Z   -^•S' si-y?-/t^>7asir   j&yAt'
  /Z^t

                                          /
 cZzmy^Lefay/ a3*^/&AIA1&, yZ^ZAlAuATkAA A^L A^fa yb&Al#-lA<

             '/> &£#, zTTiA. /^Ly^C
 cT&Tk. £ /3y, Ad 7 /       73^. %. A&a1alA«.j'

           '    3
/     AyMA7AA-ruA sAa^A AA^zA^iA7^.C:y/' aTa^A
                                             L aA3A¥^^^-^/
                                               A

    3b a?^Acs:az7!aA?l A3-t A/aA/ -^A TvAA&za zTai^a^
                                                y,

 s3a*?aioaaa>,
                                /
    /d7a-jZ4AW^-A 3. A3azA64a^
                                                                                                     >.••••'   \

  r,t-/AA{          ac       7'-/4

t/A JzPuA 37aa JyAy
 ZjjAi*zyy.^-&x7, 'AA^A^ 777                                           ' y   ..>

                         *2
 yssPA^AZ^'t-fy

   C ^Z-c-37 3aA- ^A3ycy>A>z>L'
    ?/'% AAAAy-'AoC
   ^. /-,
            7}           t-A&*A
   77 77 AX-A4.AACA
                 7^
                    J/.
   33aA J/a~3%. t/cy&^ 74/73-3^77
                 y y         Ay
A3-' c3* 'Z%i/L 7/AyfA,.-0yu7.
                JA             C-fytf.                                                            3'-?^-? y3c-
                                                                                             yyA At^'*^--
               3- 3/3- &/0 73 p?- //s-y/fs'                                                  7c

 / •'Ay<-
As'   // »" .<-   /~"P'AA?
                     */A •    A1<*>yy•--'
                              a-- -""' s' •, •i-'-'—-'
                                              • <•"'sj.

 zC-y^szUzcA -A^-dAuA A3A-tAA 3aa^& a A .a3&;z!a3aAzaA
                                     y         /'         /        -          y        a/7    /'fa                  /
                                                                                                                         i-y-c

 yly^&AA/TAsX A3.. J/a,7A a?A 3(A7A^:                                                                               y*
                                                                                                                   3y>-^AA-^
                                                                                                                    1 .'/<<•< ••

  A^AiaA y3i3zA?zA A7c yZigyAzCs 7-7- yTyiC zZ&za*./ %7/t*
         '      '. • •    s        j.      -A / y   \A
   y3?zAAy;:£fc*(£, AAycA(7is±y 3al-ao,saA A?Azyts% -yoyoes
          32/aiAa'aaA-

/3/j?aA.A:AyyU3 >A3?7st 37yAte3A<~;
                              •*   *        a        7*f3A             37y           y              a-
4/aa3z:aas^A 3a /aC AZ-Tas-ac - .AlZc&yttJ&Z&bcA'- Al-P-vAC.
 ^ /  '/' /                •:    y A    ' A -~    A ~       j/~ "                                          -•'/'

 &nJ!Z7ZkA zZaAt&c,
                A^
                    y3?>t.A
                      •
                               A*74-^
                              A/   y
                                      /&ZA4
                                         y~
                                               .^4,6^
                                                   s~
                                                      3Z#y%3A,ca-$
                                                         A
'Aal^A 3AAPi£syui:3^t£^A A3737 ^CAy^A^^^A,yiA sTo
3y4iy7Acy3Ap3L. 73c A/az/ a// aAazAsaaz ctey&u^
3^
     AzAy^zA^^A /
     y.
                                           Aeyosc. rfJAi 3A 43^7/ A^eeA/pM..^
     33 a^tAyU%3iC<^ ./Ac yAzA&syy^rf 4
JA, AyZ^AzZAsAtAA- AaA/ At^AAyiAz/AtAyz/ A3lA3
    y^tyyAT-yPZAsuC -Jti Ay£.y?AcCA„As^L Aal A/ylP/i

                 &, , AAcac^lA A' JkjAA-^AaC 'Al^aP^-t^nAe
                  zt/ TaaaiAA^a>almA /za/AauaA 3-6 Ap^> Cyrpt&t*
                  C* P       ,-ZAi-AAZA^   LsS^Z^yL^'cJZ^    y^^^^w-.^-^.    ,   -       --> -r\.   u--,

                 A/: 3t~ / /*; 3/A> &piAy 7 - .<^*W*
                                                                                                                                                  U'

            >Jk>cA AcyPAT/yfA Aaac^A ;a7a ,' Tfy&AzeOs/tA sA^
3:43AyHAic; T/Ac Az3yAZa/ aAyA/A773c ^^^^ic *A
49$.z^scJ&L zzA /-zAA yA/facC Ac^A 4^ai^^aA /Os^/A
/ yAAl zZ. yi>'.C -AAA- aP*K&Z*7$l. Ac ^yy?^AAL^
                  A                                      3                    A-        AA     A               A       ir*~
y aaaTaaAA- /'Aa^i.A3Af. Ai 3A>L74^7tey3 a^pcs4a^./a,aao
Ca-Ca/^lL/ /AaA AZAAA^^ yC/AeaAlA^ A-A/AuAtsA y*A7/i
A3y2yy-/AeAiyA
yU'AA^zA^^A d?y3/cA^ . TfjZC^L AlycA / ^ ^ yc><4^€
     7yzyAZsAzzA A7/yAiAlstAyAc^ AhA/c<2j&-^ cTTa*^ y37iaA'
 ' 34 y - '- 7      ~ < /                                                   £7 /y -                    ' " AAA- -                     3
      UaAAa/' 3^;^ryA3zAA0-
a337?£/a^7 3r9^,s^si4z337 a
  s/7 ~s A ^ A     <•• y •  „
                             ••'^fa/^
                             .aaa/Ac A^^^tASUA^t
                                 /7#     y '
                                                   AfVw "'y-c AlCAyfw aAo&AA&A z44yA&Aea>A
7 J .Ji..X-*->**%*-*>•'       7 j/     -- w
                                            A^Al-A^A
                                              <- -- 'y
                                                       Ac \ '
Aa/TA aaa^/a3327pl
      A^^CAA^itL .. j^y±£"
                     AA- '4y//e£^       AAue ^.^A
                           cyy-'^e--'^^ azp^~^-^ tr'!-"^
 3333^ A/A-AziTAy yz^^t&A 3^imAeyzAcA aa ^aaaAA^c
     si 7/Z               ~ s s          .   s ,•    •       -   s          z/A     y      "       -

 AAA^/d^zAA ti^'j:;/ A 37A37p,* cAaAA^AtTTjc, JZA/£c/>7p A^AcAAAs^O *7
  Cdi&ysiAzeA aAaAa7A 0-./A-IO /aiaA 3a^aa.cA^/^te/
   / / *a%z ,. <43&?L&t*
     7 A 23 4 ?< 33 7 43-^                                                      3*7:3^/ ^A Afy.
                                                                     A~ ~           P' J                •*   _^1- «-              /       /   A
      •/ 4 7               aA\ /7, 6/* 42az^/aAAzAZsA3 A^A^AzAAA^c y2SU-£L&/
        '       '  '               / y A             A- "A
       Ac 3/AzAyAc7A,st7' /UyHAyiy/kA yAC A aAAca.^ 73zAys

                                                                             ai.
         /J Ay)-At6zylA yJkcP&H, '' Azj2A7Ap37c A7AO-P-aAyyAO
         /•/ A/yzMAiATk. 44^AZs9tAe4 ^yzyi^yyAi-yA A 7^A'- 3aaa/-
         43/ .733, / /6; 73 A- 4APzy/y f r' 34-yHA^A-
            a7
         4:AA~'          .AccAZAA'&l      7zsy<4
                                             A
                                                 y&A$yys*tA
                                                  - ,-
                                                            /zZ-A^t, ' 3?yZyPz-CACA'-yA
                                                          s ' . ..        A     .,
,7s £AA?zUAZZ /pic. 3mAAzz7-A7^A7A9yZsZs3^C AcAC - AaA/^OzZAIAaA
yoAi,„ yzc^AA'AfJ .73yo y^ty//c<*>Hs;,A^ A/Aoe.£-^y
  *•?      7    ' 37         A3          - 33'   /  7
7(A£syc/^
             • •r       / 47/      sl.          ~' A   A       ,       y        jS_ -        y                ' *" •>
4?^AH-yiu3337 33 .Aa/Ac !AAAa3A7AaZi< S-&3 ^33a~7Az7$ yC6
         a        -   4/' "•  7 •         '<^p7 a a7
yZC&slZZLt AP-^'ZA'C AP sAzAm- sAC^aA
~*^~ y/3 A                   ' A -A- •    y    y   ^ a/ y7 -A 7
y7y€y€2s£As3AuyZsC A'-'A A^A6>AcACyAH,. A-7 ytT&C 73a 33aza/a
/k/.TT, 7 f; 37, A- &aA^j '9^33yPcA^Ay Ayufj7^a\
 c/a* f' 4--A.'/-j€y.CZC yPi a/TzAa/
 ClyO/AaA. Aa7C^C APy^cA/ziA'. C^y^^eAy^A^A-A A^
         ~                                A •          y           ~                y             47~sy         y
 yiAZA-tJLs ArA
 Ai'ZZCtsAs        zPyC&£yZjL ZZ
            Ar-A^. ZyyAAP^ZA-     C/APsZ/yz-t
                               At C            ,ryp y?^t
                                    ZAAZr-yz-i ^A   y^t AJ43C-£.ZZ.£.
                                                           AAA »•       .•                     t   A3                    y

 X /(AZAAAAX /A-C a/HAsZZI cyA:-Jy/cezyt7A X^ACkyZAC
/»-"&"
    - '•   y7s      s ~ s   &'   A'A'     ,s         yA Ap
  /
           il.
          AP/
 y/ pXaaJ/3    AA ATpyPXA <73/1/AlL   A't^AAA " ^^P.AA^C^
  {4Az^lAy&t, -y.       3aAa7 A 3aazC zaH zAyXe/ y^AyiCzA &-•
   AAAAyty-. •,Ayy^c.tcA/              A'-*   y^-^yy^..                  y^z   t-^fytA.

   34xAn. X /-^AA/c/yC a<..APy/7i^€A.c ,-•-  ...,
                                        • X yz/JyZ*_
                                                  .• , , 7s~ .   z£j&yAcC&*tf
                                                                 yPsit Ss, 7s"sn ^ ... A X-zAAL.
                                                                                           s , Js~: ....
     y7i/Azl
            y/- /3;          -  / •
                                 •''     y, .' •  ~     s   j-,- *•' y
                                                               y          A'    "'   /                   /
         J£¥y*AAfA
            7s*,ys/P yyMP/3.,sSoA
                      sssssTy s?.-.,-y ySAA-T^^/Pi*
                                        A~ sX.t.s-?_AAA. CAy-uAl
                                                         y'ys.s^/7 7A-Ac A^y
                                                                   Xa-l <-.2.«w_
         "~ '                    AA '         '        - /              -X -         .,            ./y       '• a       ., A
     'a/A/aU
           iXi.         A-'' 
                                    7PAAy3AlAAAAL s<•
                             -PAAAC PA-~:A-"i~s--                    -Xaa£cC
                                                                                  •           AAtXizfcsypzAX
                                                                                     - <-w- .x..->-w...,-,.•• i.s,s^,^,..^   -^'T-
                                                                           s4 a               ,4. :a/3 •a                      A
   A^cAa^ yy^ Ayy M3 yyAXX, ,
     ^^„XXf A AXPc A^ZAA7 X yPAssy
                               xaMA' ,p^44
                     A        ~ 4'3      7 ''      ^" 43 -3"47
         AP PA --A: 4 sAA.,y.yr X& yAMALAXAZ? AL AXPZ/tPT AAAi.-yU *

                                                                               (/'
      Taasai&A xi A-p£c7 zzyyxxA > ZyXy/pAi-A xAcc/A
          A X-A^.yj£.cC A yAtzX AyZ3MA3.
              "3

               A. /cisaa-sla/ 7/apX 3 ^ZjA/-&A^€ yPPsyPcs&sUits ,A
                   A7ApyxA7A-P7k. y.yyy?     s •X
                                                                                                                                                 APsAt-Cyy,

               AiCzlAl A<'x A3^u,a.A TyZzyX '"A^ypPyXAypc/
A C4ai7aaz3l* 3/c zA/4xA aApAA'33az/zI AAcsXy>43u>XC
          y                         AX                             A-              A           /            337 '                                A                                          yA 3-
<*/ Capc^a//. yAc a4a^3C7 yPXyXAX aAP^-xy^iyXytyz-Xs
p.1                             y       y      '' s .y                    s                   aC y              A               '                  y               s A             y         A
AfiCp-sAlXA •yfcz-Z./A^X a44 yfsU-<4Z/jP ,Aa^l *y3y^TtC        A&iC yxTzyut
  A
  P, '    yp43x~
         APA APT.   -   3'
                        jt-     y   ~ 77 A"
                               /.• , Ay^ yr,..t,rsz,.Ur 3A-,
                                                         AA^-.yy
 3X       *7z7p/3y3L ,77z  ~
                             sA,AA p3yxiexA aAaT&z/ A-ycs~3_.-v=-'-"•<---

                  yXyA. A I si ,.
      77P apx /.ATTpL a/^p/a,/'
                   s^-y.

                  '/  • "" y    /
                                  71- A. s aXa.aAAaA'
                                            ^     7 "
                                                      APXXtA^AiA
                                                        l$* s  ys
       yAcosZsAA^ o/AAAciyCs yz7j XPy/tAi P^pA^TACy^y/' ^ j&fe
          aTalAs A-7/ /A^/' X-PPA A.3A^^-^ /AxTACXAAy"     y 1
                                                        .- '             . ..-
                                                                              •'                       //                               y          y       y
                                                                         •A        Xz__ - P A
                                                                                            A'                                                     "s A
                                                                                                                                                   'As- s
                                                                                                                                                        "
       y-PX - ypy>C yZ^yzAAXA-AA AP' y^'X^Xc/ .A^p^ AAaA'A
               y           pP y         /'„         /          '..                 '           .                        .                        ys'       A
                                                                                                                                                           A              „~       -?y
                                                                                                                                                                                   •?y           f   s?

          /;
              X^a^ X<~z7CA4X(
                   y       P.
                              yyP-yAP^
                                                               .              s
                                                                                            Ay     . 7azaXax4
                                                                                                     p^AzAA.
                                                                                                   s?p~
                                                                                                       x
                                                                                                              J4y /3 a3 ..aX.
                                                                                                                ~                   /
                                                                                                                                                       ^   y
                                                                                                                                                           A              ,'           "•    y
              f 737/ yyAz/cA- TzAA/AsaAx^A Ax7 - PPAAPyyy.st/- <-?y,,s// / a                                               7~A2ycPPy4 aac.a
                                                                                    7"
 AAAC A y33e PL Pp4x4zic-A y4cA4l77ey y/s*. A--P-7A ^
7      A       A                ' s       . "                                   .
    Xi'ApAXAi-— CA-X-Ay s-

                                            O :AX/A-lA.sXpX

                                         %kALlTI^ , /'-I /fa XyjAA-yA Ay«A
7x7Pf M--aX'sAAp AsstCAXxx'3d aa -733CA 3*A
              .As     '                   s A
 ''ATTA^. 37yyA t7p7ceA c aaaaA^ yyyt<:z3y3>  7y^^y?
 7/x.A: /ICA&^Acm A APZy ,7e3nk3 y/yft7 y3
                                         fXyA^ 43
      -- '3~ a -     yp ' / yy       / 4 x- - 7     ^
    a4c2./p-3' 3p, 3pC3 xAcax apalXss/paxzAapi a c X ax
                                                            "      y y
    AyzA 43Ay<./c/

                                                                   3p3s3z3 a/- A2/au£ J^A>               x/4.
                                                                                                        *t

                                                sy       J- •/ "    y    - P    f
                                                (A M/UsZUis 7                  771X&CO

,J exA/y a/^37 ** Acx a^A 3y   x* v.       <-'''/"   -'          s-   •

        '/ .«. PA
     ,x. yP o *

                                                                         A