Court Opinion

ID: 4058485
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 09:12:07.804099+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:17:35.871622
License: Public Domain

B;//j f_' M )/<1; 4117@§/11 _ ' 501“ Sg@ . gq",:/D_
/OSO bd @vmmerc.@_ . - » l l y _

_ ___1____fn Re_[.__ __P._s(_.par_)r'@ _/51.'4/1/2 (`/)01/09_,/1*]_1{_/£%5__ _
__ _________(aurp_,A/Q_[1)_€_1__3_‘2}_$_Y_B__ ___ ___ __ _ 2 _ _
41(“4/\!11 _/3_372_ i _____

__©P_a_r_}}be/ HCQ$_£@ __ F/ark _ ___
01 411 2511 211,_7__6; 1 ~€11~0_..0/;_ 4_/11_3 S*“ 19101_<0[@11111_01//<_@;111)__:'1@
_~S_LLJQLM*WM_@¢u-L gha//€a4/ nn {-2)/ d .1:0\1¢'404/'10- 61110}` [»`Or/)u$` /,ozjr§L/@“/'¢a

11214.'1/2 //127 12 0 (`~ 09 _/3 872 AF_ /€ /L&ZZ;_A§,_;h_L¢_§+¢MWL@¢L
m +_1-115 42211_§1=9 /)7_/2/\¢_»1 141Ocm_o+ 4r1/4,’ _1/1/ 43 20¢0\/1@ '/ am 121/10ce/),40$1440

Cf¢_m.Q /1/\_ ru¢\ch.\ l'_’ quf [`O/\_ \///,l;d,__. l._ _/41€__!1¢\_ _\/€S+.$Q|Lo¢\ _u.`szo\’_'._":)'__ `£/14£.._@!`2_`£°1£»_~1.0
<',nL.-\an C.`Prre§.#/" 0491-.'_10(011.‘4 and 440 101'0§10(‘14402\ s /__/{nc{,* (;.471/,11@/1;/' Qr€ cz// 40¢,{§__

4104_7011211@/»2_17_,0 cz121:k Q_Q_¢L~_@.Q 445@_€[0@01022§_0_£0@¢_400$§_£11_90,¢_
1,1104_.'.1»1\ /7 131 71p<4___ same d0012Me1/111)'_0`/<12 0/.)0:/1)1 1442 4413' 4041-14’14,1_©0

 

 

 

(_ _nt\/J/`Qh,f;@-,,. ___

~_EZEQ§_`@ Fknd/q fng ‘/’40-4 L/c.c,¢_ b.12 n/n_-/'A({ /WO`/L/(-‘/“ié) 7[4\1? /?%/1°/77£@"\

04 1-7012.r /‘012 14 4110/uaw -r/§ `c ma#@;¢€z(czd~[ maine cou~m'ochJ-_m_.~;um_ m>PEALS OF 7'EX/Ls'

,- .…, v _ ________,“.»__ _ ~ ._cA_u;F`.,./\/o,*u/___):)"g§)) <3_3
BILLS»;C,\A&);L£§MM§.~.~ -_ .- …

_ _~ ._ .. ___,E£.:TI;I.QM“._____Q_F,,A~ IN_N_QC_ ama
_ _ ._7;)=)_;HQNQga.&l._aluu€&;z;;~._m,;m*com'7~.~:
___@MLES_NOLJV§;LL charm_1./,'ll¢.‘n<_,-€gs§jz¢_\%{q¢h@_a§o

H\¢1&-_€'-_¢1.-§:{.-1-.|e¢\_'czQ:Ln(//v)é>e¢ed,car.¢¢.<'_¢,,__
ind;mo_\.u ¢~L'Lo_.gr_éer&q._pe,r._C.q.\:§am¢.._<;ndbm.\c:._/>_roc@e_cl¢.'¢:\j.;i:a_coas_[Jec._-¥L\e.£q_q usg

l§_€_a.maLz'_lle?_o.,_l:r_\ca.t;£€_\:och'a_m/o_df$_c.l_a.L\:\'__'\'Q.._~.\;l_\_¢'..$§FA&*(:¢§(:¢To_n£L#E;c_§-\~ln.e“€ou;r_+_ha£_h€ld_..:}_-h,a:\»_.

_-Eed.»em\_A_u;<;pco;c_es)_.¢_';'_,\z/Yo;/Qieégw;beq“a.ngimace¢:&.._p_e§g;\»_¢fsa_s§ncé_ccecg_+ed.., - .. ». `.
-_;_._'7._'}._1e~_~{:`q¢~\-..uql_p.carlcfcq+<=,.__-F¢_@r;~lrhe_ciaZ¢.v.\£czuld.&=_wi»_kayé,~hee¢\&drr;._co_\_¢c.;eé_zp.re._v[o_u_s.lj..:}:b.m./.j.hm
iqe%ciil¢'§_§mce,-_‘a_e*ma;a&\@upi€dj.;n§*&eahch@.,.ma-!:e_\;{al“_o£‘+h.e*pr_o;ec.w§;n§.¢q&am£~.j__tha-\_;
me;e_.o_.r_\;\j;cn_o_.l.e.-i:o._~.|:be._cl¢£eqse§&téocq;e_j_b_g._o_cA/_€Lo£_.:&:b.efo._uac_-*Lwléer ,

&Gy_.:»._c¢._§_z.LS/,;J:;£,_.c@@.;c¢£m. @¢_¢_.,- Hh/z...,.~»'.~_.e~‘=.¢a=é.iq ./.<)QS.~. .%.

. DENIED_ EF/j:em:.\/F_ .H§Siv's.mA/cF,-»o /_=g co<_/A/_s;= /. s
._HEQ'J;'_-Hone_v;ghél,(.€r’._zes»_é£\géom;\£¢rc.+¢fo_¢\.§*n;%b.e;é@l$._~{:haz§:_“\'_mfo~\_c.o.ua$al.alcz.$’_[o.€{§@¢:€z(z€_b€,;
mus&b§_-&_Ll_e_é____~lo__ma.).‘ lea +D /'r\ {z}m‘
Je:Il:;§/:.¢fo.ne£~:i.'é.Qda@@$iq.j&,gcosei;u+{nj_.Q_Mo_¢npj_.,amemd,:l:ke-a;c;£e§;{:£:£§§:;c,.a_vél-a£`.ér:$_b.€:|:w_e€v.\-H\e7 l:r\-F;>er-Hon o nd -H\p. Ce)m,p/a¢'n-l~ cm wL\¢'¢L H~ .-r§
wgeaéq,$$_-&@;jhe¢¢:£n@§;,:gh_g__€j»h_@= , ..co.m m{.'~HeA )'S. +`a¥n\ MMJ_Q[£A¢;L_]_QC_MLlrL-%_cma:b;v;\,_
20:<19»'¢» ¢},~H/.\e lo ro;e€u-Hng a+éornej, :9.~0..5:>@- 'H\Q. a&cé§r;£o_¢;£b£,££€ea&/?_Z€Mdj_&{a£§;allj;
su'ncp- 44,§.”0 .%’-Fr'a ¢\+.;(.v\,.l\¢‘$_ Q¢G&`-.r',lqy,'-_L.-S>,f/BA 4a .5.4.<; ¢E,f-H\a+~H\p aCCr/_s;€A_C_.Qm/m(e@;ome._
r€§`en_$;@§_m(c;&|-_‘}'£&[W.S.=O£_`)i£_~t/;Qi§anci_'@_¢l€+__a_c=}:.w;_o£h/;*._aw.q vo)l'~[';m_¢. ' _ .-~ “__..¢. __ _ …._--___
_..~._._/Y;b('l:);)_a&r..gajs§,-_hlisa+£¢_;z.l_.&tEQC/_mesj,~£§£[ed +=> f'€/\ée:._);eg$;o_v_\¢_§l_¢;.&-EE¢<;P.§\/_e4.'¢1€$'(='.4@¢1¢¢_};€.¢§_¢1_§1£¢1_€__.;
§§J/._qo:hmo.*\/€,_:]:b_€.j:n(a \_,. .@_u_r_-\:éo -o Cdesi-haag/;S:~LLl'g,l;Mme~¢:iaieme_ni;_c;>_n_ce¢glaq¢k&@_zeaiz_oiih_e;
glle_<,»_eé,__e$§;"e:)s:e_pu_q).o._c¥;eé__L__-, .maJ@/hé_\,__a;\;j__p,egsg__o£&’ge;, or ema/p.y_ee?_._a gm>¢. an_@€€{¢ {_q.\._@£+h@-. _ ,.
*§_jqf¢QP*E;Qr or 0$:__15_51€ L/m(?"€cl S+d{*e$`. . ,, _ - .. __ .
MFLM;Za-&;_is#;e_cqueda£Me_zh_\@_&§gb§>.m_ce@g&cmdadeék_ .Depgig_$keg‘&\[m;&k{?_l_l__
_dp_e:.na&.@;£a_i°_\¢Ts\q£)_c_{;_-fbd;%__e*wh_§f&mleseer\ a-£+h¢_resfdenca .-Lker\ p_ur_;¢_l_e$._._hy_:&_he.._.___
bcamp[m:m.£nj.z.u§ms;.$:'a.u_-}_$_\_QA__H~JJ-L?_EL_.`o_:l:he,_§m$;_~/.;Q.o_r_a_ceg ¢_J~\ d_Q§QA-s_o_m_e§ch_¢_\*__`,__+__
._._f._`aa§$_§Lg;las:+._.;n_-H.\ejsa.u_+heasie.r_v_\_¢o_o_c-\=L'or;\;o£_l_c`)_lemqm_Q,uu_\-_\H__w._a..§_/.~":\»_£b.c_<\-._-|`:h_e__s_'q§_p.e¢=!~_.;
achi}_\_og::\.:_~):afms._l'.a:éer._]:€)..m_p.la¢'r_\.am¥._was_;a¢;\_o\_Cel[L.Jar;/Qbane,_gr:v_.¢:n_ji-Hne,,._di.(r_e,d:{o_a§_. ;{r_ jaL,;_$)z&u/aé`;a£.\¢;toé_:;
%j_e_+__+bg.'_;;QQF_M_¢_;¢;»;Qgem/gA{Je__.;i§e¢§<,@@ml):,§j».e._r.u_;,Q@¢F___~_eh;'¢\@._wg_s;£¢¢_»\w;dgm&g_g
._as_~'!_>_~e,_:_o_jujxg;j_r:m_%€o[o_gu;gr_-l:k_a_m.a_.caon_lpo_¢om..‘~ v __ _ .. ._ __ __ ._,_ . _ ____ ______
wlt.e:£_u)_e(_w_wem.\“def_u:éc(es;(£._a£ha»_¢;la_h/_~.e¢x£o_cc¢e¢+_Q€Ea'cérL-G._o_m_@_r:m¢,:\_@_@.lémar_\;couhh.r&_c__
4;_\_}£~_€_acm‘_~z_ea;ckfo?_fad&.iu.spe,d`_veh111¢._;33ho_v:£_:E/!_!i_lapfe/I}¢ar_@_a“n;m£_o_io.k/_Gr.e;@.ks_~__~
_loc.¢¢_~1:¢¢_+11£.~_>:0_¢:pegl~_\¢e\£;le;near_£g¢q;,l€m;r_%e_dé:c_c$.£,e¢£_§¢;/;ed=Qas.c£c¢;/:,C.q_ihLMeM¢LQ_,_._ .-*.
1_____"7:1,',_3._¢_.¢_¢;\,;[@;¢\@:£;._$,+01§QL£L_LP_¢§SLI_€J_%L.gsu£,o_egf;_vel\.,,rc/@SL€,€{€§M_:L¢”€A__QS._€>€¢:ncj~_?/:QT¢;'_~\_;_.
;c_u[°c._w_.§L_a;,z_q.q.¢@_@_m£.o¢(om.,§Ae_mig!.&h_e_w~a$_QL/e__~£o_.g_¢t£ée._licen&A/Q{g_.o£&&£_¢_:us_pe¢&=;
=\/_£QL¢(¢[€_T.3»_§@£¢_\9__7_.’);_(>2£3..7;_§.;£0¢\gcg_§`m_l¢ésmdgs_d_kgd_€§ltoflo€,;;|:h.LY.Q_L\LZ!€;AL/£cg._'(!-;¢m¢;s;fg,a__.
_P_e+éor_\_{.v\¢¥._.k¢€_.\\.s/.esjz(.ya>{z'v.z\_¢_;p¢;+;jt¢fue_¢_a_b_&¢{éi¢~£_sg,f¢agd;zdav_&.u£g&mé_
-.L~/-.£{-L£=lanég_/J:LQ_c(_c;_»_ft.\ec€:_o“.r_;l)_O_;pO`_§i/'Z‘iméécjd_r§_Cf_€{:(z{_o_rA-_¢£:_-)£.£€_J=S<.$`?Q_¢QQ;an_LCerj:¢_;J.\§_-/Ddgé;£
;€r_~aza.f;no:l*_'=i'_d£m`év;€z:€é~_-Q$_E€.;w _H\.&Mpech$_é&p_q$_y£;£_@_&i@y_lli,&a&_k._{2¢>__ §zos§=
_@_%_L;GQCAQ'LV_._;+Q_+¢,.BQ “5_0./.»._.24_8_?:?._(:1?1,__C¢£m,_é),%°¢/.?_?_Q)T¢A;L[`Me¢éxrwe¢
-_:]¢\;\LC€%M&¢:£CS:D_€CQ§amj;NLam=a£F§AaL&;[_QQéam.{`\Ja_£q-.§l.`_.a$;¢:£i;._.cc£em:e¢\,g~{o;¢_'ra=&¢$id_e;
:/.,_.S_._Q§L _ ;o_ur_[_`¢_ie.>._'foésu./)pl. __FconL/Q_Ca_usg.1351:l:be#p.o_l_¢fa_e__.`$y_$;¢;ed_e_c¥_d:g_&_.;___

 

 

`"`/

 

 

40}>,261/211:14-01;4 1124640111m 1s__91(0042-1?41:08891_~j4.2_224 S”_.e.x4L/.a14_q_ 5;$40_1-9 :9'1:48_1.19_1_021§¢7;11:0844 '
401_1>12__ 20 1024-1042 rr\es+:_a/\d 080_1:924 15.1_0.\_14,)1~1114+1~220_/1125 1842+ 941_>_2.411 9949244
411\_9'1'021-1 c_a 052/4112124~1:11 0_1094$403_,0921919122 ,od-r[»wr\er 09 492402222) 1;2¢42'240494 929-944
002 90 23142473,_921_/0_ 4 4&821/€4@9€;114009§94002_;110132 A_’m w¢»-% -1112 enm$-
7%2_11@,02 ¢_1'4/9294@+0/21151122____202 _,224344~1_1`>_11_14 .1924215:10 r1>224weq,0201 1:.\/42_01‘41100:2_
231444140.5;4+11_94$0411>\4922__402»{;404 9_/49__f_>4 11 019 3¢2,2/120497409,»43€74/1/92( A/o_/.'Jexh1‘1`104111944
420 111_:410_ 2494/0 029¢4471\'15410-10.//021%224149221 /4\ 254110511=14,0425_9&40 22828124/:2_243249449244
4204!9_5__ 1;474'8'2412,1>01-1 dean_§€»B 0¢111/)2141.1)119¢\_,001010/\91¢4025’ ames-129 011?12 _0`411141__1224
4_00__ R_C__H_._ \/£E40/)44c14€1¢3r['2/4§a~19 [/ fe S’jr{e/m_regel 721 3_1¢9_ 1371-140/€0¢~0820911)_1192@~1¢\9¢7 we»~.&__
_/_oéQ.+»e-d 415€94(20324'1¢111£€&09'€8€41"€¢0 "'1" 311941>347101419#07/1€‘34-4541@1,0 1342_124/\<:9;103/4€4/4£0484&
4912_02¢1$2£44:/:11240_2~§14444:1:¢4211223_241 n404c0m28124;_£7521¢,01%1-1140224202)m19€'24924
2491§22:241>494'11299942 221 48142.322_14 742_;£42_ 809/+¢,10/1¢4‘1£9 9`0<>:1§40_ 294€_/924£,04€:_1410042_241$4
__mnorer»+ 09 1182 fcvmé_.m 101/1121 112 614/29 20222:/921402212242{[4€14/20:9 9629,:1'/_24 rféQ_§Q_Q_____ `
0_._.8_12 &'91~`€¢29\1!;@_257804/\@4€4€2222_%@4791 01 /02~/4797`,, § __ _ __ _ _ _
44444_@51\115@45£1:1:4€11\[5@ _54$4;5]73 8149454@4§4 C__O 81 A/__SE_{ . . _ _
_P€,-l:z:\(:wn\er C}_\ 01191\439$4‘141194£011_\//2110¢.\40 04~1:1\9_80§154-/:1_10:14~14):1_1:1420¢10$9140/2.34140991`2¢:11_\/4{
412 ec_g_u_ s_e_1_1941‘:`a4»_ 1914+2_/02/@4011/@1 /08/24011174022-191-1 211 450 2911149¢0_22114211240_\/_9£34-11>4,024~1_1:1:
_;__0 292/411_24~90 /9244~104147\ _\/95:91_ _30~1:94 1110:11208$81.10:94,241¢0_\/_24,0 249291 on 94$410 ¢_\0_2_9¢_100 4-9:24 '/4224~1°
236933810111\4001~1‘112044'1~82-140_5'10+Lp 1:0_ 5808»1100_€1+1'0¢09}4€/2940} ~1:1194@1££_€:1404{§§1204¢-.
40:941~11484<_1 10724'1:0_11124743494)0 e+:~p@n£f_w¢ 1104+1\240007/14 15710¢\4<=§4‘['8€-&940 21:14€>81794/ a 7474014:4
409281110_-1120490:1401;2422924+92404U0 r mmce 100-110224\41[4-1_1_241_0_-_9112002_£1904024~£11249001,24-
_/.o_101-4241040/11121_1_1:9__15490292_0;4-/0~‘1?9€4912/_'22115_11_24040(£_»{:112992@90@411.22.252§0_12]4;1;04
4111104/4011¢: _1':1~47'4049421824;12£02@211120740.1/_2141._)_111./24_1.\412\25490322441!:8.24020.3964<2{£29401:1:02295
2048€418_24&9¢0_38~_(44-§»2¢24~18.€_49_0_251041434094041)049_212;1:1:0214/2[:0214104‘81194§Q£Y/zla¢:¢rl:f_$.;é€c_
_41041'145 45. 10924-1_8 w§rad4(18 1_3`46?4 §11;124\/4'-[-4:9`0_1'. €24~104$4`1'0494:}}10¢+419/)_4f) 219§1'(009_€444
4€-_09)/_¥)1_-1192_5002409;€22:2403 01.2_5_+4~1:1_~1012105_01`492 s-l-q-ée_'.. '7`/11£ _(01/1>1\ 4 4 _ ____ _
443@1:117.0)3@14@§_ c/8_/ 41:;_4184`1;1‘_101\_01‘1'0470974§a1 1224-10_79/\<1£9'1`&<1$‘0008/€,4&-1;9€¢:1?1/24€55`[?{040€€4

f

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
  
 

\_4 41. 444_... 4_44_4_

__Ib.134/0/4241141'47__1125442145941112412_21_'01m_e'1_\94~12482£249911.74_¢>19§21.1»'_\29_2>.982_2$9424242490_¢411:§:)2;______ 1 _
oi#ome\;~ )-'S 021 2 1148 211';914.~1041_°1.1_1;9»;~1129_/:.ms_914<2_11_'22.s41_`2411194c1'._'§;1411__4€_014¢_:.1___¢1,2_24)41)_15_ _ _ _ _
41:0_€12/)_21>24¢221420140_+’409481§942120 _\ /~_2/_1‘:11_'00__. _ 4 _- '

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

4 44 4 ,4 4 4 444_4.._ __ -

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_L§e§#_€_!_$_€__l;\& move -1»1-110 -1-11(01 1 [;ur-;§~ 1010(11€_1’__11_12_11\ rs-I~r_\'c,l-_ H+.{=ornpq +o_make_ayo_ff_lzla_`_
_qnd ____-13;>_,0@_--: 11__11\!;__[1@£€111£_9_\_1_197_@1)¢1 151:1_1:<11191\_111)_0_-1€0rn127 :I:o 193/seek and cum of
_,)_1_:1.<_>1¢_9_1:11,0_13 cz11_111_0_cr_ar_):1;_ 0£010'_0§-§_5€@1'013 w@r£mix_.@od 1199 davd'_m\_§u,o/Qa_r:l:_‘l-hem_e_>§"
_10`9@£13§_;0_1_1_13_0113_9_€_0_/_1$€/_1:_1¢_0`€0mLLL/_SGA___Qr__ €>.><111_111{19¢1__21;+1\ 1111/ne o§l.-Me ames/1139
_111__0_3¢_@11111_0_~3_11@ 111/111,_9_1_1\_30_1_1__//19¢1 ae@_m@_h__m_ 11»_@..1__ 6111,,_____
rpm/221 '/’her€~{?>re 111@1110_1 10a/qer amf L_£0_8§€¢1;6_11_ 9_01‘¢‘0/_17_£_ ____C_’_.O¢_n_
p1011m+_Q£?_d_¢_\a-L__w&_&€gr_e_+£e_£~_al_€_¢M/Ue/L_n the men,’-is'. _
Pe~}'.baner_@@o+€/)cl$ 1115_ 1210_\_1 afto___mej_ -{21_ '.1_€_11 1a move_+kc__n_o_\€o_m& 'F?>Lchre_~'i\~ r1 or

 

 

 

 

1

 

 

_@ms:k_wqr_fQ_Q-_g_ 10101/adm mbab/e_cm¢xe c_)_§_ r__.€?_u, re& E7_19 r_-k:w_£e_ 15_,_0_3_ \1_ il _C_Q 1?___
___TBe_Com,O/amk_§__+c_+e$_QS_-Fo//ou/S’ - __ ____ __ __ _____________ _______
___§EQQR§_N§,&L€_¢LQQ@_Q$W.QALQ_:£&W_+~_, om_-Hu-s_¢ia9_,0_¢1.\:¢>_~1_¢_11_<1_0/;1@¢1£€¢1.!_ .. ____

._’__.

\/¢{¢\_Ca/H 111 _ _- _ _ _ __ __ _ _____ _. __ . -_ ____ __ _ ____ ____
_____01110 _01£1¢¢_£)_1_.__113_1¢_~9 mLcIu_ 9_511»_1_\_¢§__)_+13_<11@0:§_0_/_1_59_9; 1_'1:1_\0¢_1_-1@ _11@:_ 90133 norm
___1¢_\°¢119_\1@_01_¢_\6_¢\0_€$_`_ Lehe_~/e_-Haa+__ H£!E_:_b_-&_E§__+o._w'_+.?_ o__n_or‘ ombw+ +113@ /R+L¢lau § fne

____19_7§_@11_£€»?<1_1_@_:1:13¢/_11'_0_1_¢.139_¢111¢3/_-1€ 11139_¢>? Mx_compja_¢_n+,_m _~.'r_b_e _CSU~+=/. ,,e 31_31.1.1 ana
51a1»_ o{-` T/e)chs '

____/_E_>_l_'l/j_C_)_'zdf1 €<` 11,///11{1/\$ 118{1°/¢1 amer §1¢1/€0¢ GBCena\an+ _ __ __

 

 

 

 

715.9__€£>.1.1¢1.1,¢>_111_¢_\-\~__ all Ig_A 10_@0¢\’)/;>119_0_11+11_-1'1'1&_610_1:¢1:1£¢_~9_@/\__;1./11 1°¢1'0_1[3___(;112<1'(:£&_(€3<111¢€.___
men+s` ~_[Z.ra \/¢:111 cl romo/n n-|r because ~H~.¢) comp/om~l» 111 cl.. nDL.S"Eu_'EQ_-{:Ba_-l_ 111€_ ac¢qxe§_
_k¢a_S_Ce_mml_#_e.é__$am_€,_cl'§FQl$_€_d_j_Q/¢J&1~_111€_[aws_o'_?_'f:l:\&$+a+€,_€__r%€r 011 re&\\i_oc_+ho_r_£’__+l\{_

__O£\"`_l_gd_ h_o$€o_oi);eg$_ov\.-\'o 1091 1 ev€/ and does loeb e_\/e_ +ba+-.¢Ae__ O_cc ed ba_§_com/)sz‘_zcl__;_mk_
_QB%Q:@. '

______/§113_1_.11.-1`01_@_0_+1'_011_1) axe¢{_u,o_o_c\_~l+\e_co/Y),o1a¢_/_\i_w_010£1/¢,_11'213119_@0£@¢@/9@&
_1:110:1'_10€&0¢1:1; d1c1,_11'len_an<`._1}')€r& 1_¢1'£0_&0_0 1191_0.}11110\!1‘ +h€_%(:?eciu/€_L`Oas'en+ O§

__5_1111_1_11.11:1110__€ _11 _ke:/_the_c_v_/_n ec -l:b e_re@_£,_es:c+_z-a c_\_o“cl:&i. o_\_czr_)_d_cl 1_¢£_015‘em,m“1_cumm»!1

 

 

 

/____._________. ._ __ __ __ ._ __ _____ ___ __ ',. ___ __ ____- _ ._ ._ __ _____ _ _..-____ _ _.. _-_ . _ __ _

`\

 

_0_ nd_com/_Y)J§\L._‘J;L)_ e-F:S~_o__p_ap e_r__ 7_/12/_')_€_!7_.'__¢1_\4£_&_0___5_‘_¢1_+£_}/¢&_ cec&¢gg_a£é_j_qa$_,__
_w_&_¢_\ou+ -k:b_»_§__ &B?ec_+f_ ve__C_c_>_ns_e___o_ `F_:Hae_ ame_c_ a£_a_ cafch mper_+?_,_;z¢zmd_j__°_._§maa_é_hgw

G_la¢_ml'_is_éo_a,ep.m:;€_%e_gcc_a;eé_o§_+_he__-§_;"£ _
.s_“ ca __ 45 _~Ek\_§_ QEE£L&€L§&L_\ M_L_e_r's_d~ar_g_e&;_s>_+ba¢+_l»i_may_f>_rep_<;_c§a A§Pem

_Va//__J,_' ___ _ _S_+a_#§ _¢,_ C_{_m, )_n./>F, /%_,A/____- _-_/jw_¢o_\ L/_Y+* 055 &P_]_?Q_,__w pd _) ,_I_H@_ p_¢_§_¢i__{a__:j_j_f_\
_p l§_aci_mj_-,L_hor(» r._ s_?_e_Zu/‘J;QA_-F¢`>r_en_ ¢r_\ cl¢cf'mer_~&_or an 5ng rm§<_;&an_c_$_aoj~_f€_¢(` u_c_r_€é_ :€o».'.

 

 

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

_O__Co_m(> /o_'m¢~__ Qad__a_`cs>__ ~\p[a¢a_+_o_J_r_l\_c\Q-I~ée_du;ms_c§_d_u e_.-/'o a__mc;r/ m_-_Fo rma_l °_-h_
_Va.l/€_}_ 9/_4,<_@3_-_$_(»2_1:£_0+_ l (‘/_,_&_Co.m,e_/o_¢¢d'__$lm¢/_ LE,JuWru_€_r\~_L_u/¢_Mou+ regar_u_c_._$u Es~¢__c_u_~{w__(_re?ws¢%@ s l_ ¢'§~_le_s w '4¢\¢'¢\ T§`x CQ@§ Ge£rn_,_€r;___________
_______ -~H'\e_\/_a/fd §_<_>£_+5§/»<\:§»_ ‘m,)' ' ….. . ___ _____
/Bmm.\__ n,,,,mc__¢e/\ §an €OA@ (;)A 54 /<)s@) l~
_D'Epwpef;l'j_CGQ/Y)ci{eA_):$_Q_/zzaffe,r_a§:$ul>_s*éanc_€__@£é_no+_ep1§¢'/_& a_nd ca nmz¥_}o§_[§?a_l(j
_Q_ me_@cieé _/__7_§ /a/;Ja:le_i._?"me a§_+Q_~F/\&do=ho€_{-_hg__o£¥_o_ns_@_ 40094_\_.,_ 144-h .. - _
co_m_pla_s-.m=_\._aa_ __\;\;’s`:c>_r_mg:lzuao).J;S_tmt\e/_O_E.s_¢_lb.$:\:a_m£&g_n_<¥ no_-S'Q»_$§`. &¢ml. ___ ___ _ __._
_ _. and .'_+ c_c_z_r_.»_f\£_zk_ 1010_0_€¢_ ec_&eé_o_c_ am_e;.\d_e_é_s_;m_,0}.7_0..,<)_0_0_./_)30&29_\70nA______._ _ i_

 

 

400 an ord€>r o¢F~H\Lr;aur.L _- ___ _ ______ ________ ____ ____
__Hu.eF_\/_ 540+0,_13_7_'0><,39 pp 99_4)_¢4_$_,¢4 870_4/3373 .. _ _ _ _
_____~S_`).m¢.4a`1:4.j_,_43\3_,_€(_ror _r_r\_~H_u)’___ CO_L_CS_€_'U_/_c_?_$_ COmm /4€€_4__Ae)\_441¢_0_-EF1an-k_o¥H\e_-EQ¢{Q_Jr-P{m'(e&
_40_5.490_0) 4%¢44_\_01_6&£45€3 has comm/+h?d some o¥Fe/_»;e_ .a_ 9{41§~_&_-£159_ /a_u_/; _0€46€_5+_0_£1_4099_4£\.<___
_fbfo.§’e£u~l-¢r§_a+l'c)rne>)_m_kcj m~ForDQO.{'wn 540+€€1_4_41€_04€§:€046?£94_@4@ 01 ba[o£@:b_¢’n. _C[QA_¢L____ 4 .
_afH£¢_wpi_ 40.®9@¢4.0/\0_ cqmmr.?+h.€£éo£p rgp_ed_\)_ _n9me_/7_ _a_\/£&., _0_:._04@/_'/)_%_(_€1@0/3; and_jy/_)_z,_
._._.__Su_d\ Q_Mo rla nce_l>e,~l-we,zr\ (;o_.m_p4a 1 r_\_.+_o_ad_¢ wForch-mn.~c_$_{ar\'c~\_~to_vl:k€__\¢a-[¢_' _¢_ _ _¢z?_+lg__
__l m§06m04c o.v.\_:...D.O:[:_%e_ C_OMMQ_¢Q+‘_A£CV€AQ v d\5-)'¢)_417_31813_<£>`,_011 _,Z_d_ $_/-59. _650_(_7€)<6_€¢£90,/9714;____
_th pgs_v \/__5¢141__7_9_.5 w _04_9:59_,_ 433 1_7:0>_<,_€_ f39,9>_/_9_.'4/_)_ _5410;¢4._$_010 _.50040., ;.29_4.$ 4401 323_
_8_29_(_7?00,_ 0_39¢»,__/9_<;2) 419004_0_5+0+0_ _/zz 7_'00,_€¢,_9,__2_$9,_35¢1$4_),._30_32_3_(49:4)_'_)307__
)@s;_v,_$+o+e_ _/__3_ _U,_G,_Q,J_)_/l§_>:w,_.zd _3596 (./939_),_ -_ ___ __
7_730_:4/_/@_0¢/_6$_50_41/6.1(_€5461|9lsheé_L_j_+ke._-Form_€r_fl_ouc-& o£Q/o,<)cal$_-tha%_op¢mons_g-F:kr_fgct(_

_CQ_L/i/_ aelj_~EQ//o 494 a:l:a)_d!\qué_@ 1244/zane Expl.lca~_ko 4\,_[_5_¢4_4).€1€__0_ re_$:l:ror_\g_p. ok 4¢_'1_;9.0[3. cj_c.ons»_'d__ 1
erQ-{~,@A$_N_¢F)La~l'ma -H.p ru/'€ . '

 

 

 

 

                          

 

C£C_r_{_ml_r(nq). __clc_~_{:¢'ar_\_ or_\ _~\41€_ _Fa_ r_~l;_o£'_{:k£_$*q{e;_'_
._£__L'_€._LE,_Z,.Z O_)__ V_,_..£L.C,C p__ _0_._£!.)_\'_'!.1:4'.€!_\.-}04£0_ mj_J_D__€ha_/-F oF_-- 1‘.%€____4:& ..~4»@ r1 rau/n -C. /P{( nn \»-.

_a_,'o ..m mar~]_p)eod ¢_(n 93an

_p_\c_e_$_e_¢c:l'_€d_.E>Y_a_,lz»cQ.$ec_r_d¢¢_%v_fp_ r04_00e3'_+_s 09{_200_
__~Er_om__+_b.e_ m he_¢e_n__dqng Cr_S_Q_C¢_S`_\ ng_¥r.om_+ke_ 109_6€;1-[:{_0_-\<\0_¢>_ __,0_ awe_c_ /_v_\._a_ aj_o_ne_c.n r\/_:_
_4_ v_ ,_ clu_a 47_4(900¢1_`7 _\4,_§40__+2_ /_é>l_`f_'é)c,_Cr_. _.E___$_o_$_ _214_5_44_9 J_.z$/_(/ 9_$_§(_@7@¢?\ ¢'010,»\ mat_
_La\/_\_~ch___ /&4_130 r_»_r§_ _)_0_'4:@!0_$£4 4914_35_»'$_ 4a:/_44r_€,_7a»c€_C/uc/e¢l Q_p_ co$_€cméo_r_. ~F`rom_)or€$en'é,r§__an
_m-(:`orma:ho c/n-+l _041§_`/_0/0_\4&_4905_5090_029_1,/<)9_50%_dmrij_+_b_z_o£¢Q¢/\_J_
_C_>rtf_u£¢:lt[_\ a{_\_Q_EQ/l’¢°,7 _cmd_ 04§6_.__/"7_0091/¢1_‘4§4__E€£€&iavrt;hal(£L~c¢[e¢l_wr#\*h€ ur€ormc~_é;or.l

_B_cé¢_'c_l_e____ .9~(_,_. 297 _9$pr_01 _:9_0_10_104&?¢1_06§+ _s. 9£00uQ@_/_c_v_509/040_¢,0_4-_4¢4&,_9_+_14_1__

/\_ __ __ __ __ _________ _9,____.______ ___ _ __ __

 

 

              

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

._.¢n€'c!a._él§_.a£B.):J:r:c.le,gz,$,;)_¢¢‘~-_\/,_.e:,_chc.fk;§:¢_w_+her_»é_&ncls)_a..p.;@_¢:e.c_u+»;j_a#gmeg;f$.oqp.awh_o.c.°zea_to.{ns~é£-{g€
_;p.m;s_eauiibns_:ln;~kh£;co_~u‘a+;]..c_cu.r+._A/.,QO.CLlisaindepende;é_@ogo_r_o&bl'_s__.c>_u,z._m~val_€_~\_{o_¢;\`.`_Kennedj_\¢,.§iqb;,__
_‘>;1_.¢»,2&;;1,_-2_7_0_..§§,£.(),_~£5;0;*;afi;‘/,;QQQ_M¢WM¢L;QZSB¢E£_QM€M%£&}Qr:o.:€cc»_é_,_tba.\r_a<;i§¢_-I;z€d;|§cj-_.an_d:aacce§¢>_o;nJ;aJ/:éla_%a;£&=koied_)la;£"l\_e_.€¢:&%‘.c\_a_\/.;€;Da;w'.$_y_._S=I_Q:§&)..Z_.`[€)_/,£@/a.
_IQ‘K(C.+.R£». 18 77.?., .‘L /s. +ha__c¢ 311qu\z.'-{ji-na-H'-h&¢:a£a(nz§+_l;¢>.m.`.~kb.@i& .e¢.L'~£j'_€S_-l:he§_o£€en$£._.cdeo.r_ney_+odp_¢_rpo_r.+._
_~lo._'ézm.e_/z_d:~)i»e_c_)€i£zllqy¢é&_.a&am:£w;azogl¢£/Lakéa+b.¢paocpr wider ~Hw. qccul~;pr, u'/)'~.’ le ¥he,:c.o_m.pi_a.¢.(v.\=\_'mg
hawib.e§_.{aku_+g_r._g;ce?;¢¢iagnew/tricegp.cac&a;@|_yg;»d)' '_ ;,_£L/'._ac.l§;_~\:h.e_r_\ec`e;s_m_j“:fr_\d.~_¢';iq‘a£r_d¢;:_
._a§:'_l.,__ zdemon$_~l_r@€e&_'b;;_§agszsho.w_§m§+;co£g£>k_€£a:e¢;£v.L-£L»,L,maég;/;~}»:Q;_fe-_+o“L.,QMA/_v).aé_a_p;m¢ee;
__¢\/~a¢)u_criz.'a.m=¥o.r_%k{a'_al;[e}éa:‘r§m,;_he¥orexi:$;_&ylngihgag/.¢ch_£;oi.,li_i'_.S&);\c\_`_>L'L\L£E.r/_n_.o_€g£bang€._‘*nai;cz__.
SMBAM_£¢VLEQ'_AAWZBIT;Q;&_§Q¢H_HO_'Q_L¢_BQ)_Q/,e,£m/re -$.`ci»{'.-§) r-§§L~.__r'~r\ ~`Hna. rom 501 a¢'¢\-f l ~LL`a_ a r~rps% . a€

,p@:i:\':‘:a_('m.€c_éuas~_l:l/_€?Q/_,'_`lZLQL'$')§;¢.Z;¢£/Qi;@m¢j_.5mep_l,j_ did .r\o“['.}\,q v.g__lo_r clash/5 name ¥`o_r .4,~[\0 omni
gogng 19 g ___;(§g;eie)__¢[£g _g_h@b/;L@é'on) and . d 1501 _a+»¢.e'mp+.-Lo.»ac)mm.§/-: and n) mM_He&QLP.mp@
r~kj,T¥§e-€Q,~£s~.,.-'.q +w)..a .¥-`§r.'ria \z.‘+(`or. `rom,n_lnr¢'n-&'a< '¢`.{-1'§ reg-erred ~l-o ¢'r\ our fa¢\e§' Or`e 0 /"€Qr_/o_.'¢_(»-_
L-|»¢'m.er. ;’~c-l'n.macen+_.@£_i.-!LL..L€//Me. fn wl\,.“¢l. .M.u)as~ con \z/¢~I»ed-fmd +L,a~l~ -LA@ ~§--r.'a/ cite m.°-j _ A:`¢L_
=Dv:{»_£€/x\£r~v;€a§_onaéz/e._€_'§€€d~¢;gé££$.l{$.%_aa£&duh/Tf\q} ..‘H\! ‘['¢ '."a\»..». ~ _. '~ .
DEM_I_.ED _E.FEEQ.T_E\/,.'EA.HSSI$J'A )\/.r‘£-:_ Q,F.COz/L/S_Ei_ 4

;_._Pe§&lr,_'o_gearhQ..)Ler_\_}€;:!:ma_c_@@¥£¢éehr=)-_Qo;}_ée._£.a£d;._£bai»:éc[a_\_c;o¢¢asel=a_/_Q.$gi;cLQ£Eec-.Lz:\@»._ivaeéag_he,w
,Q,:,/,=_‘(.'@a~¢burf.z&i 40 105)€1"/21412 soro..wbea_,% ULL’uc/Lca{e_pehfmner§ jnu!_# and sen-fence Jv'/v\`~£u..._. 9.9_§¢€<;¢$_114,§0£0011\€0+
__;_._n*EL/)e;~l_e_$je_ig€_ H_J§_x,.CaMLH/o,o,._LI;XIL_S_~{=_(/ez,_(,`:a\,/Q,$L .,'.`Va_¢ua_rja/!e$.?o /.3) +he
\_Qp,o).¢c.a 04_;0 rc@¢;~(£jaol|€,?€d_+ka£\¢he.:};f_gl_€o_.d dz'._J__ 004 h.v£, Juns _d.¢cf:.o_r\_iv_ ad_J _1,1.¢!_1 cai£pp.l1m&;
.31.1 L`H' QanengamM_Mw.yeaG 1111,9_1:1.'5.0.01!2€1.\4,.}:42¢1,/@3@_£ _@_1¥§_4&&~££@\;£@@`$_;@_{3£§40[§¢&0
¢.Qq,_+h£_faud_€ezoi:l:hai,;b&££ M~the_ap/zb’¢aaj; 015/ed 40 ran_~l.afn §:010,4.; #mf 9540101151\_9¢411&0;111_/.
\;/gu;,_neuga¥czd-,SF_QQQ_¢;QQ!_LAgaragleeaq,op11embleha¢_r€é_.£mm=c¢>oslc|._€_ca&b_¢gmc§.uam\$g__
494 I[, 07 §_ `I'Z¢>v 1115»"00{~\-1jh @P.',".§§y.\`.`:dr_er._.\_r)-w'e[,(_xea.$’on@,d di`sf.eq+._@am,_€f.'ac/ge¢§l[ca/:a¢@¢_c_o;>_<)_-Ai
1_@4_4£_<;1443_€_[0;¢;4“1\_04.J@';14.&1,2..`.4'0 midme Qp_/).//can£§ 5'04>59:;1/2¢\4'1~¢.‘(-5§11)11@(1) 4%Lige,?a1:am.
ig__§o_\/_e_(m_ ng_.$_¢_LA,qeouen+ u/n'~k do 1404 000/q 449 a glle 4`\»1/;+44\¢) 4na| ram-4 mcker aug d£c,;
_~}»J_on_aod?___[-éamdiyg%.,_L-Z>_L£JLLWC_C€_?Q__QM_€HS do apnl\, a rur¢$r{ 'c,-ll,'¢onal r‘/o,_M__m¢_;eS`_a__(_Qa___

5444,1{:.'.¢_:19_9_(“\1.{1, a:}ma~l;bcel:_§@¢;-F¢es_%e_p mw_u_aj.,neiw_réme»%g__io ag__ .+<> p_ erm_»-f_r_egeu/,_

 

711-w C"r_» 1.1»~\» _<})mr~.-}e,y rel/941 nn Qz>,p/`. can-l`§ non suh:eg.u.en~k compam.’,,r.\. 0,10,/>/1'/0:4.’0101'\
b.ec;g_'.l$e_:i.he,j'_-r_¢.'¢\acc)_ari,_'}o“cf;e.¢’j'u r.1's-c\1'1.4'-..f@0._'_ .._,---- ..… ,h.--....~- __m_.,_ _ ..m. ________.,
____Eéi[{;pngg Qr? u;§` bls_m'_jh£g_b@m;L@Ma_ ~i"n'£.I afénrm>cj) undp_r Hnl-.~'céo 39F/$/, TFx.[ode Cn'm.
Froc.i-.»¢)n/),. A :4.1'0/€ i) -513¢414)n./<§i AmLi'c/f ll..$°¢-l~,'anlq] 1934in j?s(m (¢`_m_$~h'-\L}A-;'cn rand 4/1@./!'."001./44~)
Ei§_}:ha~l§éngllz;'?bféaand F?')ur~}een€/A Hme/kiMP/),L<. 40 440 GmS_-(-Af~'l¢zk'm\ oP-H\¢? L/n.'fe¢i 5 40425'
wc- 9mm/sga 1}91@ \/1'@]04(>3 __;lo L/s .cv_pnaral;)/F mJ.'.,v-~.. .Um| .-H“.¢S deprive 441 99.1¢.'0;\\01€~ _m
1043 a ‘€`Qm 4010\/ L)Pn@_m `

 

 

 

._, 71 ,_ _` v_ .,

 

__ _MM__ __PRA§ER __ _ __
_LUHE§_ §§§ Pe,+¢{¥¢g§ner__ p_r§o_g; 4¥04 44\¢3 Clmc§» orApr o apr cur\cm\ en__ bgnc proceAma
J

40 Con$zc(er 4h€_rnnocence, and i|[@_cm) 1':nracrt9r_c\4,-0n ours~um_\~_‘c: 40 4116 ,Ae>:h~(~,_@rge_f ¥`¢u~..

).'_ ..-_-__

__4¢_~»€_®“04__1:\05 ne_IA 4hq4-Fedc=m\ d¢/L_,omcesc is \/¢"0,/0+¢,£ winn an_i_'m_\ocen+:nerson ,"§_.mcar_~_ _
’ ~ l'
__(_`Pr.a+ed_______ _____ __ _______

 

__ _ _ _ ` IHMAIE__D_E_CLBRAT:OM -'
,_Bl/'j_€hg!_l€§ wl.(__km_$’ _39€_'____ .'C€§@{.!Hy._u(.l£(_l.££tfa`§l~>d 04~44\0 Bwah (`our\‘\'~l TL'( 1050 U-/, (\Om

 

men€__l§_rowMA/_fem$_Z(oBD\ C'ec_[gr_e__cJ_Mz/__ Hqg_peml~l~_j__a€_ ._)Qeg_ __w'__j___.-¥bo:£_ M€ ~Foreq_o_c'qj
-Q)¢~Ls _s.+¢d'caa w_'+_k,’n +h. s Pe~l:+. 00 /)r I.mocence_ ._'<_ 4we and_.c0 crec~i_~ +_<)_~¥LL_ZXA+_Q$_______
_mj._)_(noj,\./_l&d§a__j¢…_- _ ~ '~ _ _ __ _____________ __ __ __ _______ ___

./" _
._.519_¢1&§0¢;_-44\€_ g Q__.__ ol§y§o§ LL/I_L__@~ 20_/.$ , __ _. ._ __- _-..._...... ____ _.
‘ ` vao@:fr ,//j sL/Am §401£______..___.___ _________ ___ ________