Court Opinion

ID: 4565012
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2020-09-12 05:06:33.46099+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:35:27.852608
License: Public Domain

Cite as 2020 Ark. 269
                  SUPREME COURT OF ARKANSAS
                                       No.   CR-19-643

                                                Opinion Delivered:   September 10, 2020
 LARON HAYES, JR.
                               APPELLANT APPEAL FROM THE BRADLEY
                                         COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT
                                         [NO. 06-CR-17-71]
 V.
                                                HONORABLE SAM POPE, JUDGE
 STATE OF ARKANSAS
                                                SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD ORDERED.
                                 APPELLEE

                                        PER CURIAM

       On April 25, 2019, Appellant Laron Hayes, Jr., was convicted by a Bradley County

Circuit Court jury of first-degree murder, two counts of aggravated assault, and first-degree

terroristic threatening. Hayes was sentenced to life imprisonment plus fifteen years’

imprisonment for a firearm enhancement pursuant to Ark. Code Ann. § 16-90-120.

Additionally, he received six years’ imprisonment for his first count of aggravated assault,

six years’ imprisonment for his second count of aggravated assault, and six years’

imprisonment for first-degree terroristic threatening. Hayes’s sentences are to be served

consecutively. On appeal, Hayes challenges the sufficiency of the evidence as to each

conviction.

       On August 15, 2019, the record was electronically filed per our pilot program. See In

re Acceptance of Records on Appeal in Elec. Format, 2019 Ark. 213 (per curiam). While we do

have a verbatim record of the in-court audio played for the jury from State’s exhibit 2 and
State’s exhibit 40, the record is missing the CDs containing the audio and video files.

State’s exhibit 2 is a recording of a partial telephone conversation between Hayes and

James Pope. The substance of this telephone conversation serves as the basis for his first-

degree terroristic-threatening conviction. State’s exhibit 40 is a video of Hayes’s interview

conducted by Arkansas State Police special agent David Tumey the day after the shooting.

During this interview, Hayes describes the events surrounding the shooting death of Colby

Rice.

        In re Acceptance of Records on Appeal in Elec. Format, 2019 Ark. 213 provides:

        Exhibits to transcripts, other than physical evidence, shall be scanned when
        possible and included in the court reporter’s portion of the record. Any
        documentary exhibits that cannot be scanned shall be provided to the appellant or
        appellant’s counsel for conventional filing, and the electronic record shall identify
        any exhibits that are not included in the electronic record.
Id. at 3 (emphasis added). Here, the record states that State’s exhibit 2 and exhibit 40 were

not scanned but were retained by the court reporter. Thus, the CDs “shall be provided to

the appellant or appellant’s counsel for conventional filing.” Accordingly, we order Hayes

to file a supplemental record containing the missing CDs within seven days from the date

of this opinion. We encourage counsel to review our rules to ensure that no other

deficiencies are present.

        Supplemental record ordered.

                                                 2