Court Opinion

ID: 8638010
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-11-24 19:48:28.63977+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:55:59.814353
License: Public Domain

HALL, District Judge.
The referee has found, and, I think, properly, upon the evidence, that Cooper, Vail & Co. gave credit to the corporation and not to Knowlson & Morgan exclusively, and the corporation is therefore liable for the amount of their claim. Whether Knowlson & Morgan are not also liable it is not necessary now to decide. That the party dealing with an agent has a right to resort to his principal to compel the performance of an ordinary or verbal contract made by the agent for the benefit and by the authority of his principal, unless the credit was knowingly given exclusively to the agent, was well settled; and this, though the agent contract in his own.name, without disclosing his principal, and the other party supposes the agent to be acting for himself only, and it makes no difference that the contract is in such form that the agent is also personally liable. Story. Ag. (6th Ed.) §§ 154. 160a, and notes 161, 266. 270, and particularly sections 4-1-1 — 146a. and notes, and cases cited; Mechanics’ Bank v. Bank of Columbia, 5 Wheat. [18 U. S.] 326; Brockway v. Allen, 17 Wend. 40; Bank of Columbia v. Patterson’s Adm’r, 7 Cranch. [11 U. S.] 299; Randall v. Van Vechten, 19 Johns. 65; Pentz v. Stanton, 10 Wend. 270, 276. The exceptions to the referee’s report are therefore overruled, with costs, and the claim of Cooper, Vail & Co. is allowed at the amounts reported by the referee, subject, however, to such order and disposition as may be made in respect to the claim set up by the assignee against Cooper, Vail & Co. for the balance due for goods consigned under the agreement between Cooper, Vail & Co. with a committee of the creditors of the Troy Woolen Company. It may be that this agreement will be attacked and set aside by some creditor of the company who was no party to this arrangement, but creditors who were parties to the arrangement are probably estopped from alleging its invalidity. As between the parties to the agreement, Cooper, Vail & Co. are in equity to be held to be trustees for all the creditors, so far that they cannot set off the balance due from them on this special account against the general balance due them from the corporation; and they will be paid no dividends on the claipis now allowed, until such dividends equal the amount of the balance due from them on the special account. The proceedings in opposition to the claim of said Cooper, Vail & Co.’ having been instituted by the First National Bank of Troy, and the reference ordered upon its petition that bank will be ordered to pay Cooper, Vail & Co. their taxable costs and disbursements in these proceedings, and the costs, fees and expenses of the referee and references herein, within twenty days after the taxation thereof, on due notice after the entry of tbe decree or order herein, and that in case of a failure to pay the same an execution in the nature, and substantially in the form, of a writ of fieri facias, issue for the collection thereof.