Court Opinion

ID: 4057419
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:36:50.433503+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:11.749024
License: Public Domain

1331 .Cw»l\~ 5¢3'7<¢7€¢ " ' - . _ n 523/113
/`i?$© U¢ Ca/vvmero€_, ` ,' - ~ v §@` n _
[_"Srowrva/ooci/ '7€;<15 "7ééOl

 

__JU~D_@E,.- EL§B_AL_CF_\LB » ' '- - . .. n A/ov/pm ioor 0’-7 420/5

_Cou QT 02_ CR;m:ri//vL_L)ppenci@Fj;x_As_____m§§éc%§§§i

_E>¢reem£_@/r¢~@urz_DIA/a

 

 

 

 

 

‘ NCN 12
lb|_bdcsv’/_E,QLCMH »» ` ' y ~ - ` .
M;f_w v:iie_ iivv.:_/cilec_ im:jou_-io_ii)raa/mjse# c`//oar_x__ gmc mar C.€V._/ n~iqocs_'y __
read_qus__/eiie,r c‘/.il:):_ iu~) /_V)_<.cci$_/c.¢d_ i_QC_/L-iive/_v _.H/cn_ 3_/)2_0?02)_2_@____
_RU!Q_ b_Leg_§mj_-ii\_ i£v_a d__ai>-i~_q. Lnéd_ arm m_-i_i;x€_(>iBirvai_Couri_C)er/<_Jan_§row vq__ Q_C_o,o>j__
_9§; “l:ix.€_$i£di'@¢_$_COm/>/Qmi ér:_an_dfflle.h" UJ.CLC(_Q.CL-i:_O_.Q_ /__U.CY_ __Dai&$m_ 14@`_4_/2_€_ r____ »~
airn`»iov @C aiiv/s` Cfv(.__m@_ Si»c_/)?ai/QA 4[,1: zimvo win /p 111/or 04 il//'/// cum P C/,omen/_<~
_Unii_a:i:ilm aciiiz _H_I_icv:_cc/.@_io// _/oob/vj_d_occr;from_i/n e_i` ic_s_¢i/_o,.¢;c@_ is_£oc c/..:_.
_w_ coie_&_i&iier_ iO_J/u_<'.'/_'i. c&é?d?.'vé.i@_§?£é__£o /1._1.’7_ val_o,opeciv@r€_m_§_mwn_vd_@€zd¢l.€zmt
__Racm_'c__,_€av/c_ ccp_ j_ci_ c__ ._€a mp/izmi_fj@d_,n_i»$_€o<,u:<(:i>j_iie_dc-iaoj civiczza]_
_i>v;o.u.j/) ia?cJ./_')$J:_ .QZE,__ iven___.(€L£vv€d_v:i__/_i;_a)§__$_%/v€§£/'?€__XQC-i C`Qm/e/.c./(¢i:“_
oj__wcs_-P"Zed_wv:i_i\ Lc_v_ caj__D_o/e_.§m £~iiv_<>_ n_d/_WI_/caroi becccs;o_ai_ 4255__

 

 

 

 

 

 

_-_~/;Q<_>_{»_ J_QL)_L'§_ 060)0__-1€416_3$*4\ 04614_/104__€_0_0&4_€/0/__/’_012213{01¢/\44her j0421/_610101»-l*

_002010/012):4__-4416_0_6_4104_0_7€/136410131/)3_40”7_04/244\34_; 0$§6256_¢20_4>_62 _421_§2)23;&
_f_s_4¢1211623002_5402 1%,>2__11\_+¢4@2/00_/_/,24,41401_7_4:1611:17_@7_6_6:2_ ___4'204»_4_’65401»1-_40_2@¢___‘
_:4:4\3_6€£0_[_ wa§,¢_f 604/004_€\/867_41/_\:1€_223 441_062?}74__ f 6_6427_ r§MI_pr§€n+Q/)v#e/

app /1124,6_,@@/@_121 222_6_21_26:_0_1;10;,_06_/3_272/ c 0 3 0 0,_/.1./_2_:_ _212__

 

 

_di£m¢f Wr-{/QQL,¢,_L_ 0‘__ 412¢#€¢_\_0'- 323_¢" 1__2__€004004€2_73413_-41-_101_4 Q:‘ém€_ __5666¢._9&9/3_¢_
_7_?_1»;\%_:42,0/>1:1_:3_410_2_1£4_ 0/)504223 my_/e#ef,_//@_Suyy€é§<,__fed 206;6___561~_\/:,_&6/3,_
__7_82_5_4~_) _.25_<1_33 (_1~6_._61_/@,_,9_11> 141qu 520+2 \1; 10012,1, 033 5 w 12 9
_C_‘@C_Cc[m_ 349,0,0__/ 991_> _Q//_ 04 Ck\Q/Q%ef_l_/_Q€_%é@_/_ 3_60?>’_€0236?_ Q¢m,_/_O.roc____
__§6_]3_ 0/_42,___1:_447661947! 100643/_§4662:4_0/2;4_04/6043_4/(¢__@0/0 //00461') /3 822 _`S/

_5_4)02311_;)7__7/: 002»_;)6_6/_\_ 243¢1232_€1§§6044333¥>“154@0369_30_43_531,__`73626_@0£4_001:1-_~

 

 

 

 

wm 405 ci1('sm1 cc 443 06/)4/16-}10/), §0412103¢{05¢_32_@ jam'_c_€rk_c‘o_rz£a¢z¢
_2:11/_\._(354_0_10;\_05_ 02n_0212(_40_22_4100_4:2119_ _'6/~_30_112_€2_40 121 rm155_4/.’)€_3,6,v_)/200271/1
k>_€0cz.425.36_ 2532_ /3£1_4_ 0@3_22_111_ _@_1_24__0&_2_%_3_ 47/_)2_210140@,_64/_1_21_16/;0//022 _151_3
421:17_0/0/¢0¢2011@47__~41_7_20000_622104_~2430/)3_4_4\2@2005_2:2_20£4004;3_0_360_
215 15> 062 m§+rl¢e@£'m_q% r; w_rl&c§ 061_466’045_ 062;2>22_§_______

_/_3,_8_721_£22_;4_265_04 1';_/11_'5562_6~_/ ‘44~@12/_:0_1121_1 12@0_0_ 02 01/_6_ 6062).6_45304__1§/~3___
___Qr;_c‘ 32_5 62:0_624 0?_43.62426,~__7_7\'3_4\60 04_ wam§é_ 64_/€2) j./ 660__~4443_0/)/<)020441022_17_

 

Q\JP¢\ /101»')1"' 104/8044~.1< QD/) /2/0&476/\ %//[41/0001¢ 4/)3 /`/"l\/354 064161'\ 694;0194`0‘ nolach

_0205_00_26_@2;2_£3621:__4 31__©_€»?60/2142»_1_0/052_@4_@1)0 2226»2_42__§ E_'_E&__
_1_02:14011)5_1/7_6_£00b 022112::0_34/6_6§0.412__ 540 4/1.'09_£622\_1.0\.420./__4¢4 201_,4254_£_ 6>£&2_3,__
__Z_c/za[[e./rg&£_jé 6_6_<0_/;42264/6_05_0_6;4/53665/5_@9_}261401\ _4>632)__<43020%4_ 303 _62246__
__.£€,0/_16_5_6£4_341_’01.)!_1_%r /_104;2/152€£4602109_~243_4004_&6?@020_:40 441 3@41/_4:1.463'_`
-/1.‘7_12\210_6_30_63,__ ,__$3642¢)27_f Cb.a//£qqg,{ -4443 Con 4//04, 6/\ 490 443 hair $_4/1014_-)-1612_

 

 

 

_@ouosel_a,a.s_¢ 0066?00_46_ 496€0¢,¢6 456_0‘0~'/€@4~46//) 0634¢00)6_446£0045__ 0666/;6__
56/)/'40 446 /c`our-P 0 mij¢_Q/\ "/? 30/@/;66$§` /" y,Je/;c_e_,__/o€£au§@_£h€__a[/`€$/Mf/@n~f
_w.@§_ n04’_’£>0ch4 ar_\_/Qco_é>ob/ 60626,_7_'5/64 &0/60064_446000 v¢éé@_/>__o_/_\_~/_»¢~_e____
1006404_440_@000640 00067.006 b 00040_0/;6 4001/000 446
_»£`00€§_000__ 54)_0_00_44) 6[66(4_ 4401€_4_46_®15#1&4 4221’00)60__0/06/)0( 4466§&2/01./:4~___
_447__04:_4!9 150.0_94)4_.[7_//0
4%662»6£¢4,0 v/-4; )\/0¢0 %064/04/06,_’7` DGL0 0!;_ /`4<0.¢0@6 6_4/»5_/3/)_~64/_~61/00 0/_).¢_6_,-_ 604 LcA_c_cz¢_/Sej_lee__a£¥¥/_Jaw 40___
_060@1%_@{006_1;0_4/»6_00004 4/1;6 069'004 43 /s 40 rec, 46 /4,440/6 /5 05 § 109
_4106,:6_¢8 04$,_ 45 ,_~16065@/64466€30___¢(0,:0-6@0076446_0 64 056/trw 444 00_04056_
_56_446_64$#¢0" 0440//_)6_0__’0/;;6/)0 "446 044/40014 and 0 harg<>d 000 / 60 d_e=__
§§ 30 02 /0\/_3>. °77.6 fook YMrrau/l£’m 446 046/56 //W 144/64\ 446 cz»Fg'a/W“
__5410044~__6>? Ql/\Q//r?_1-{:¢5__[00__€66;__40_445__@@0:601@_6; ed_/_s__-£`_c¢_v_é_zL@__ 44660_ 41__4‘47_6,@_446_
____§ZO_‘EQ_@Q?LLQQ »_B_.S.S./§?QI`M_©LSHL&;/:. A{‘\LU[L)€‘?._€M__ j_._£{/L//.,_W / bam_{/'QL?LAL@§W
06 446 L54'/,)»4046 Clhomecl/604A6r 44)¢2/\ \/0/)¢6 A//// 446 nue§/z#//rér_ ‘*'F»6
06056¢04',0 040/500 was 446 060/566 45r 446 ._;404046 040/064 n 446
1LQALG(’_/V)_€,v:n);_LL)/_z€iz_4/\£_QQ/Q4@ WFM'/€J/ ,OOMLO/w / S` V€€m@'\/~€¢l/ .-F}O_w\ 44\£»
m rl/ '04/)'16/)4/»4//1€/6 //W /)/0 //}4 74’/4’)6/)//67/>¢1 446 0/40/)76/)4'004 576/746/):,6
_!AQS’_‘_C!!;/E{E&_/’A:éo_¢¢£_€af& 0_~//&440¢44~ 00440//40 pp /(:fc$' c/zM 0/),
0// fm 000 6 000 0//0/00 40 00054 40 000 40000 60 000
4`634» 0 430/4440/5 F0r 4) 414/4 04 427000’0/>705` 11 0’;~6;/)04 07664“4/56

§r/),/r>// fra-/'/m§ \»»@r -F`(//n€ 446/\ /c!H’ 6)/602 f640r/7 1440 /476 %u a/,// -F/_nJ

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

               

 

 

 

 

     

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_¢24¢10/\24_90__93_314_9997 W_m,@/Q¢z)é_£_€@m/o/d/A__a€ _99¢__/¢1€_5;14¢('_(70~91!4.;_
__Q‘BC€Q§Z¢/~€FONL [_/_§_(,ul,z‘f,£'\ m O$ rcw/9 190€0/9» amf /9\% //)c//@_/MFA-/' //‘)

_w 1411» Q/_1¢4;11_11@ eha 1174 _3€_&/1141 141;'__
1_=@[;_17__@4/@19/)4491 _7_’9.4£11§%0 491%/@@_97@4__7£0_/.€1_7£4§_1€,@_$;/109//01@_@&&_
mcS€/. 399 %/\e/\ /M/W@( 99 //v)//k/ 494 @~Q:/O(Q_M% >1-001,4@//\ CM/ae,mda%¢\
141/rrr1m/ 792 Da’ @»11/)14111/§ 15` 49/9/ 4MZ@ cmi 149 9&/591,,,1/)@14':
1941 11/¢54(2110.0__90 Q§fyud/¢az{z_%z_j/ {1/:. a/z;£_eméaer.:.€z)£eme@'o/,,s/'m€_
_____ 011!_40@0/; S§,_z/__/ f/Q_QYZ/V_/_S_Q_//%/LQF _7.//1)1€;_749 /czok @_ver______
1110 1501-/-§ €¢/ bm/#~e¢l m /3 872 914 m/QA¢¢&_Q_%`Q_L