Court Opinion

ID: 4235489
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2018-01-10 05:26:26.716253+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:42:37.506026
License: Public Domain

KIO. CClUbL    03-18-00001-CV

 January 2, 2018
                            3}^ THt
                           douftT OP                         - -
                          -nmo oi^m^ OP mto
                           (\\]bTD\l,Tt^KS
 ^m\.lNEl!)DW3V                                      l\vm\&viV
TME 0)11\"\P op                                         IWPPLIPP
 APP0X\ fir£5Wl "lV\€                    JmAlIGiI PlfrTtlCrV QouA
                 ~\Ymb Edu)i\^ .Ku5\mJfX0iS
 S
     ■   !   1
                 ,
                 1 ■ ,
                         bD\W5tM0.
 WinW                   j\?fI'l CAir/)n lOrA of yimmb .
''Hfi\u,(lom£.Oj Av^ell NeWwir/'herOMAfW Einowiij (1^
 lVi£.MiV\D>jer. m \ViE Oibcv^ bVlUA oy MumbfiK.
            'Xb '?^to>ueD\          Wonorcibk t/)u¥\ SMlT
 -rVit nV\\\DU OF MftKidomUb {'mm\ ^dJ^icu
 \\.D1 bObW/l      or -\Vlt    (^odt oF Orifflllifll
 rrocoduYO On liODull in 6wRPcr-\ ^mof
                                ViQb oftemnVfA Ad F)(Uui\Ay
 ?Ac!v-e RfnioA\ib b1 TiVnJ K FoVAipfi Tor iAjn\ of
 beibe&b bOfPUb M Vht^£_daS o^jDei—ion;
                               ^9(1)
     ■\A)\Wi \VvL                     \n Vnb              requArding
  \V.\_£'^c\\ A'eV€nV)Dn of              9T!,V>,\\Dii-4tJr, '\n Vr\-L\'\\5-ErH
                               W\b V)i\\ bS \)\xtc\(kl(A\b.LGnM)b)
   t)f bat imb f>e.
                                IL.
 TVi-e efV-eLV;^£ \Vib AriVf..\'2>-^i            ■ 9n\i mo AtVioM
 Viab b-een'TC\be/n ovilVio PAMWoto'i H\'km forwv-A
 bafeab LotPh^.                          '
 iVe PfVAit'ne'ba hA'5 b-y W^-il                                  F^rluAi    1

            LMoTbn fw bf©u^bV of Ci)un5al AvA
 M.dICO, 'iM DbVDiMiNa Da drd^^r 9\t^ey[ fo« d.na
 buVytViftl touA ibnftfe Aoe P£.Vi\\Dnb as Aao-
 OyisyA\fA VoAb enfiDswrb -rhb \WDf&b\t (b}uA
UjiW bb [AAb Vd Vt. to Ofl\-Z-b'tV\b mVfcnbAMM AlV
          f/DT AtwrADiVe. bAbViVb, damoMbVAVd V)
i\a^ \V\&\ touA's Ob AwsAibj b^&(D)S.TrAVi6
     'Thb bA^sAbTD AS5\5\c\nCb Ab AdutisA',
  D M&W'. Arkw V\ebfalt5^as£\s?       A b^sVA       A
 fouYito MYidiv bht unAed   b/nibViVuVitrK^l KrwnAnu/il;
 unjitr A\ii SilWi L\F Ciind fcurWn\h                  QmiA^             Ptz:b
 €Um out' pYC'U^'y t\[\^y6'
       t^tlc^VoY [\vtl «li Nek^/]sr 5u\?fvi'i^ Dn(z)'bm?\]
 (\~) '^voovt^                 xfiftbi\i\i I'D      bsV' UKiAibk
 1t)     t{iwr\         (X       ^(x \)t^A             €)sujayn
            WYiftbV \[> ^ml iiA kr U\^nhA\ ijO obWiAiflj
 tin Dxk
           U}w\
3)tViil -Vvvi^ CoiaA YOf-i bTfkf (\ \m\\^^.
  \(- \ViL Vf^fA^l UmA e\eiA \o \\M ix \\m\^
  bouA bVM>kL\ fuA A£L\c\e> VaWvW ?\'tVkcK ihhtA
 H-eYjWl lY.V\6'\U(\
)P             bouAVi'mli         Ad-IKyAcW ^!Ai.c^5Ap^
p               ftnA      Ae??\Y£!) rt?rfi)&nA\bii W
            VW Vf\A'\ CiH^v\ ujv\\\Aw\                 k VfiL
PriniMKi or t>,A,              V,«,t.t,f AfporA OKI AftorntJ
T't)              \]\^ [A \Vu.                 CYYirl (WiAuA
^ ktir)in3 Df raA
 ^ •\/lD\a\\m                         L\au6^ tQ>i^c\Mt^-
          ^\VL(vyii PbvrVif^k l\ftXwW(\w4 UmAA b\^b
                       WiAf'Tl Ir) Vi ab eittAiA aKi A
 An^ \K\ /buWDYV flf hii MAi'i//i kr DwA
5)              aViW f-ti^ tm^^isYin Atc^&i^
       lAekr^Y^j OKIA TtAlnj
                             fV-A)
5)        trii4. ?w. m K\\-    iwl^\ '^Uf? 2ow),
 tWYnn\ Low^ Cm\iih VV\c^ foiAmi^A (t^XAmd Vd
'^o-e                (Y\wt)r b-t        u>^\'\C\) -\\\i
(.f\vAi\'\HlW'nsrA 1^ ei^^tuVfA 1 A\{5 1 or i6
 Dvi PareVt     a OAf\\ft\ ttv^ynrc^^ TVii. ^-nAartV
 Aiiii> ,(jY                              r^omVWVt^ Vlib ^ff'KlAwze
'Td [X T£f^A. D^r (L/3nAW.mhAV er \WvPn^mmm4 or (/^ ^
 9JiX^».hi- on (>cvirB\o tr yAY'vyiA ixVtH 3u(4rViVi'm ^fX r.4 £f.
 Pf0C'. Ann A A 5'?vn3 W)u")-Ct)
   AAAiXTimcv'W^',           l3,A\crM-i^ oP AlvL rrsVcXoiV^ ^W^jrY"
               meH                                         Kf        VKr.
cA^^emAiCAnV'
H') AAftVcY, ftfe'3-e.rV^3       W\A-tr\c.f, ^V\\\ -t'AA^s ftnA     ItJ a
   UxiAAwyi Tf\oX\\^}5            tebAin^                sA dV A rAdov
llA'vAtW \HUm St) V\1 b-t               tn-nAl \oVcA              iM AW
                 wVtA W. IS rtfiwAmj                        of hif/l5£'tf;
        N\x AtAiII bbpyi-ST, \^)V^ vOftb wtc VtsVTA fcr Aht Vmn-*
'bTTnATA                d-OtlA'Ai'i/Aj Vd fnxt WtS \uVi6WY\0iS, Tc>Ahe.
t£)vm\s CinA 1Sw("]', Wt\i Nf\o\({\-fA VttS Aut ?wubb nnAI
 NiVAvAMVid YTjhVs.
 1)-va -tu/bvowvJ                     \b(A ^VVA V Atei VT£-V'fA
                       WR6 U^dAtA                         VV\t V^-'^a
 ana ^(^^exA:n^ L                CvwA wVa-t 1)V^i
& Ri\ftVcY ; Vt&MCiV Vo A\u COwAb Vo'^^b?Cle^!Cl \lflt Wtliwl
 ^tbordi' frovn ViiAYlh)^Alg,-(x                           DiDti}S\i6
^) MVd ^jVibVDeMOi \\u                 AiUJr^b \\(iV'AAl M.otlVi66f4
 VO' iMftMrnMlfl W{s\6A\t ftwAe C ^wA^f^ It7^ 715,'
\\))UA«(t\HAil\MAb(Yl^Y) V\(Ab [XTi'\A \d \)\Alte66ClAllb^
       '(?YdVAu'\A 0\Vv^tV-t^v^ 'iW (X'^nk \^\i\ L(>Af)VX^uVlft1
 KmliWi ^V)D                           W ^ib w), wcb
 b\Wt UumO         11C P\-'^ -A bX.'
           AiiYi fcKx voyX dV NxCiYxXoirnxb
iA^b 9AAai7\ AtY \w\\\ Df fAWAXftmb A\Y-t^\YA3 Vk
 tO\AA\ -\A D) fAOT\bvA (\tCp\At;^
 fob M9o\Av^^m\ (y9 lLOD\\\btV,KA.C)^, ooA, ^9 cxbikiloA
  9^bA\AYL ak D\A AMb\\AX\ tobCavib^ k bAa'DAl TD
 T\T(\efl bvAbTA D) N\d\\oA fvMsVrDXfs \Vvt 'AuX\L(tA MbW
 DiAxA tenkAA-eb tx AenXaA (of dul tcm^      AAcilo
                                   MZ-L? -ffX/ A>?P V\'3nM'nJ
  v^Wl -A rAD\\DY\                  ^T'AfA ftnA WnAiM b-eT«c ft Atu,l
 to\lY^,                         loMVvAWfoVcA TD DinAMfti W%^
iW Mo\Aut< \i ft. K\W\bVe'C\c>\ ftiVn ftnil «^ftr^AertT^wb mM \'b&iid
'^0 LpfnPtl 'XW-Vfiift'JuAPife "^0 ftC/V. 'bt-i ?)eJce.\i ViWr^ tocPx/.
(payt'\c\    b PftftAbWWgiA swiA \bT.16E(.-rrt
Vip\Aayv5 "AT\a^ LoayA OiWbfA A'b A\^e.r-e.\\p/\ W YlAiAbirA V(>
Ut-A Ci V\-tQYAYY5 (Xt\i\ mAev AeCAbA Di^ tAA\cift. (tk.Ves>//3d^tAbve
                 At) \eiAjiApA'Yr\tA^vvA'H Yfc WAA Wr>n?^ cinA
 AYbC-YiAipn),
              ^5Abm^W'^ WDW\AeAiA\i IouvV\m\w ft totW ftpTOt
 (AAyvA ftt&Ufbi foY 1\P9daA\At oF HxWyucA S?YOttAv-we.
\X\i^ LV\pV' KAaiXs loHioi 9y&\)'\Aii.
0*^ "TtC-tiPV of fVVt f{\ofMsAC few Di\lft'^fy^\ral« "Vnt tovi\l\t)rt)i£i
toxM'X 'pWXV
     i\At\Ac.t \b\^ LoutV           K d\?)L^^pV\D^O oF-VW-
tcndAAVvA of \Vvt eA 1       W              \Ki\'^\U!^ To'^t
iD -Aivl iow\e) voVA Vwt ^)\c)ft. CxvmA^ AtVxMW \h'f. eviAeAct
id ^(W.
A-tW\\(xA (X^btA«j>V6,\ u)W
to WiwA WnAVim QuAVI                                   AhL feauW^b^
MrA\o>V\e'tV>A W                    \ftou\A wA btoi Cc-nViA+fiA--
                               KfV\C)MA\
1-5 K-sA-iW           3^( 4^x\'§3 im &w Vll (xa-e-\?Sft6 o\A wAk
Ail foitb; -i.            Mmb^ Au. 9tf\ft\M cf Perlurl iha Akt
              \6 Au-t OiYvA lc;(ftck-vD ■\\\t t)ft5r oF fU^MnoA-
         CFfA> UvoA 22 U.J.ASnHL- e>-\i>ht Lc.vO>\lAX.Pi!ft1'flo\
'TMt'N'         C{!f\^ ^kw\e-dk6 F®A*         C''''2
                       ali HVVIDP>V1

X,l\irdt\\ Web(rn'3V^q?ai5i?                 0\fW-\W. ()\^-£         eU
"tW- )F(\t\b i t)-ex\ooffc v\r\A^ -Vht 9Wft\Vi Of PfrJwH ^ci\
llVu. f(Ht^oin5 "\b -Vrui CiiOi^ (Lorrt'C.V ~fo 'Wvf, WsV of
 V^Y^o\A)\t^^^€ CVtA. Ltiw^L2-? \)1.6'L.% HHIp 5VcKe. \oiio V (^ttVpvxi UnAtY Vuoift 9ffi0i\\i of              VvA VVNt-f-wtQ-
9\A!)                \b om OiO^otM -Yrwfi. Ct tCKfftV -X. I?*m
\A \X(X(iwoiVA (A'Wit                        urtA ?)Pol b, EtciA^I D(? av
 fe WiWi               \W.
                                'btyyieA OYi AVi^i o aV. \2-x] mi
                 (lwVif\h(KVt of 'd^VIX
x,o\'W\           NiWx              WtiV\3 W{5w\M-m axY'ttrftA-
•eA KV N\tWfU\\ IA'oA, 6-tevA\tXtlPib                     X., Cnm Ort^OiVk
Xo ^O-i \KC(jr(U &«f ftwibACOb WiWiA \Wt \oibV fA-oAfib
K'libtVfti Her (Aotb fipofoYit Ac?-ond (m f(\i>
     '^Oit SDiV\^ '^WktirtVyA: \b Wut. UYyAiV \V\(j ftfitifVl Df-
 9^ SYat-I . <9 urbUfttiV -^0   \J, b.   \7 All) s'ViAz Uvd M, (b. X A
\'il-0l>(, XtTv CWoPYPicfiu OiyyA ^Az.m-edUb CoA>               Oob) '
                        PPiWt-il
VjWiWt-^ pr-ttYl^bt'b tevi'bid-erY'A M9\ua/Ar PYttf s                 tt>u\V
 (b^iAMT rt-W(X5YdiKi(w7 r€,\'\W--(X                  Wr t)|\)A t^sViyi^I~
 AmA A9VD\iNi^r(\6rtV Of LDur\i>t\ UY\i\LV tV\^V/U^            \i^
-W-Wd             UA'WVx^tX VfouWxto.
f\U-           Vj'AX 'bXM/'V^ ~0[Hl tCiU'aC \H \V\\b.
 CX'YNCS                           -^v^OLenV           "-

                                   f\^5f^txA:fiA\Vl 5ubv\v\fci
                                  L^t:U        Ir
                                  KvAtVV UAbi^ Tf
                                  •!Atlov\m\\ m}k
                                   ^bo\ %<            DR

                                                           (
                                                           \
                                                           \

  12-2'^''"^
L 'l
                             fi
                                               o= 3
                                     ^8
                                      _ S> ^
                                      -— ^

                                     r^ O^

                                ."•^ m                  »
                                                        Vj"

                                     -i
                                                ■i'-^
                                     oC> :

                                      o '7=^
                                     3

                           \
                     C-    y
                      :   [:!

                                    r-^   it

      -s::^
7^                                  rv    O

5:^
V*®    p»i

tf-5 Sa
o- _i.
                     -C3
                     rrr

>o                   \y^
                                '

                                               r ^

 >            A                                te/fe
 V-i

  r.
              c?
              VJ~-
                                    ((.(A^f
3