Court Opinion

ID: 4050594
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:18:41.254315+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:00:00.073000
License: Public Domain

CiCNEh le-feft ,. ,:. .                ... --^        - --           JL

6-UMya^(-^b££f / - -                              _: - . _.—"A.

                                                       -RECEIV-ED-
feU/u) Bfr finpplPMAlt ^                           COURTOFCR,M.MALAPPEALS
   i^iufll- %li^U fia w«;f«r                             FEB13 2Q15
IfflfcgflS /agptft fe Vfl£ftfe 5ufa?MflKrl
/^r^Li/ll Aiuriflfc) W     f^ft Qaufc/fi
Qj^ft^pft^j-^-^—-: - -^ • ,            :_         ^—^- - -:..-'3>

filflJgMgxll ^F F^.-t-                     ;. •           . _        JLjE]£_

 flffitiMErtf. - - - .         _- . _ _. - .             .     _JdL5jk,

r^Kj^Jfl^tON)      _-.-.__                 _       _„ -. -_.._(£.

3k^E&.                                                       ^^.^QjsECpl

UrtAVJoArf I^cdft-ftfrfia/J,      ..    - ,. .                • ... 7,
                              CbN/fcft LE.ftbft                                                 _/___/_

"^QyjkfeJtei^

   ,X__^_____/4__#__/^^
^^/^/1_-_{<22L_^^
dugk.£M&s^L_o£lj&Ojl
J/lO/9/?p/?4£/. lh*J- UfaS /VfecS /'a/ <D/?///?S ~7£X#S //ac/^A
___^/_4^^_v^ 4^/p />^ /&£A#c/s?a/c^ uM /?/ifiy& //#7

0/=^ tJos//t/E:?.-. ^ZT /?&j *?s/f w/M /?&?/?&£/ Ufa/- y<?c/
  _— —'   — , •"*   y   _*J   _—•   /     y_.     > ,*> _/   _/•_?          _/   • '—j j—   /     _ ,

fy7s sfr*/ faJutsrf/rc/ Af(/ /2r////bA/ ?£* tfu/pfert^M//^.

 jh >^_r 4&*/0£#M^ (3a,/?/- ?& A& sftz&fec/ 7& /^_r
                                                                     /?&a   /PS/% 6cJ/'M
y^g^£_5_4^/?^

<^/s*/ J>£&t/ /X=ti/S/bA/ <?aV /)/Uf /fasts//' j£r/?&A*?>/. ~

  'Zr/r'/^jA/S 7^ c_S_ar S/^JT av&&&/ 7& yS^__=g/

,'Zfexstr (2to//7%*>7 y/^y ^/_r>^-w /^<z5c//?£&i//Js'aA?c/
                           ftUMMftffi c5K__eV
          _J^__J__LC__^^
          ___ti£EdlJb_-^^
           >4flh._flft UOfipLl, fe VflCflfe _6jdqEM£Kff"dK
           feuil-f A/_ijf. fe> W, 'Eft' OquIoIed&fnpMLj-
     Qftd£ii_i.bd-k
        Pm^h9m4 -b Iexas- fiuk aF ftppslfflk 'PfousduAE^
     flfpj_f?J5_h^^^
     Usid_wiEd^^
     b__tei_^^

     felj|jQb!__> fl-JM)£ DgMiafei=»rf Rutiiffl     ^fitioij Eft.-SuppJ-^igiof
                                                   Q^O^iiJ^l AppllCflfl'-)Al

     flpglj.gibfe.Lr?gnRir, 0. 6i*tie&             f/-jg,f p^^Rrl nTjrli>ifl| /Wf
     AFFpMSE. ^q^vflfel fistiW- fecial 4:
                                                  CSt^g ^g/.A/cif Mw/js.
                                                  "AlffMfi. O^fijUiasd' RgLH-g Am^n)
     j-Sei-We:.&jf€ftgs
                •£-*--  hftki tio\j.vna
     rJ/jgfa/? AWie; ^iffcft tfarnpfad
     /?ppgK?1-4: Dfe^ %?fm l.ifo5
     PikfiW. -fa gpiW/fl/J: A^-^-^'/'nAft
     HgjfKifej hgld'is* Dm: Yes

5-
     lftF frtok rtF l^-vflfi -v-tiDUM -         D_d_ffi&JW
     \/.fi                      ,               ?!). fin* mw CafHtsL fifatifld
     GE0.aic-D-.J5.u.l.L£E                                 ftu.6ik,_i£)(as_78_z/J

                 rfititioW feftfenpplpMEM+)o^fip>iqiMftl flppljctfkoiO
                 •Kg Wflrf flT i4flhEftfi GnftpUft fa VflPjfffe ikytplEtff
                 nF kuij-f -\ltifj_ .^W> 4uml Ka TVmhl-: <lEQ^pftftq

               £>OH£S__l^
     j_Pg£_5i8ijl^
     OftiqtMfll flppli'^-f-MM ^ Wait or Hflb£.a6 Goftpufi "b \fa\flfe:
     cltjd^EMENiT qF Guilf KlliAfc ?rto W. fck Dhubk TE-VMpflflt/ •
     in) tiiE nbo\/E 6k(lErJ aislrl ;<\lumb£8 pausE W.qooiW add
     movE 4h£ ' t4frMfc)Kle Cat^f oFtai/rifidftI Appeals fts 5//au/«"

              flFfeft -RliVig ft flpplir-fif/Qf- Fft Wai-f nf~ tfebags Goflpufr
     4p \Wfl-k HurlqEMFhll qF Guilf fJu/oc ^a -feiAir. fag Tkjfc/E

     BtejriaEd_^^
     £q_k£^
     DU-f hEuJQ In) fl^rW^ bprfh #)£ flflliclg'S l/,fl7
         :       v—>J       ;       ——'                    :               •

             eaIs. Wh/>,h EWe rfcpfliferJ tfip 9g+rf»__u__K hffi )
     C^l,rKfu4ioiQftl flkfh+ rtE~ DfJE IWeSS _Ffto\A/) •fl<_rJ
     loiuSft f/itiftf flMclfl V/olflfc)f\} 0F^4i_t»ta^^tifa4-MNlfl/
     -                  '                        f   -—:       '

     %fat
3-
                        ~ flftyJMFAlf^
     ___J3t)l^_^
     j(__3pu6^^
     _VJ.hidi__aft.Ei
     J___vi£_Sdn^^
     ___L____M-£_C_^^
     __.l>abJ£-J-E_agp^(
     _lDQabJ£_iIiaegp^                                           :
     ___J_5lE_^^
     tinftl P/iulrJ N_4 hffl/E bE_!____a_i_^
     irL_T__Lx^JjC__^___u.H.v.t  QfctDJL—aa_aB_i£&J m—ws^sjuy&pb
     f)ppli>,ftlinK\ Wai'4 aF Hftlof=»5 fptyMS; One 4a 4lE fei_
      fi_\-   l:« v /i.'l -t—Mll    _ /-!*-.„- ?v._ 1 iL_ cfeil

     j±J__J__j^_^^
     nM fe
     OK) til,     Dak  4- 4iimp- 4?e ffi4H-WE-____Ecl -Hte
                  Ufl_____limE-J^
     Z_Mii_id^
     Ik) SOIL               ^^                                       ,
           ti6^_LV_E__^
     D__o\LEay____JE_^^
     _v/hirJ___^^
      _kw|y__B^
     4r)MVi£ "Q^iQJMftl 11.67.'HebfikJ f^E fe (5^auA)<d3__wjJ:b_
     SuppaJ4jyQ Fa_£6j; :
     r^fouisirJ OME; VnliefL fi_pflfli-Alftfl?fl4ii/_::
     S.U.ppoirl:/±Q_Ec_:
     1F)E ^>lt>E RepoRl-^/?tftii/£' wferln "was .6fjppig_ss1.:«<;fa4ri
     „_^_faop&i!j^^
     Oh) Fftfc WilLlFfc I)EteK\/b. fthpoRkd -t)F -fiflpE
        zQfttiqk) was Imfaudcttd. L.Awft/gfl te ikpoef
w<
    _W*s_5iW-&t65_^

    SjuppoM^fl—Ecfc_
    __d±±ia_^

    __suliJ4a_gw
    JD_lfi____as_jJ^^
    ___=   b__JE____J_dL__3___^
    __iK)Si6:kA)i-^
    ___3&^J_^^
    Hi^LJ__JllJiA^
    P^^W u/i II y/ Mai. i&mcG    IF" A MptI/VaI   CVnAli_F&    I-i»n 4h^~
    &_AM*_J_b^^
    ife/ftert Would h^vg 4^filTra_" *TTfof .-fog bfOft .feefe_g_L

    Waufd bftVE B_Ei\J _JtdJv)£lflfecL

    £_|ift>i_Ffi r_Klfp_rl IFieKE 15 ^kJq) X>0df>-J-M£M4 fe^
    :_h__J_5SSa__jO^
    K_4- 1^4i__.Ert was fikBRrlij SznV'm 4-JM.E J£__
     lsjg_____l^^
    £J_mj_c)_^
    . .,ii<-^ /   /)^«._>-/v._   <TLl *kC/.~„ _    ^:,/.„   i_,-ftJ:l

    ft kJEW IftiftL ^e ^s)dclM£A>f Eft fibAft-v^-fcd
    ^___LisSiULl_^^                  ^
5
                                                               1                                           _____

       Que 4_ Pe4j4i6iJ£A .htift tfa±-_&£i^J^Uh!d—id
       4te GnMpift/AlfrKlt ft_OS. vOWi^h Hf WfrS. £baiq_T<d
       fa T^dif4ffl_>0-f • FrJ>fi. "TFJEAE'JS Nfl \A?lid TK^-fc_qg/jf
       ^)kJ this if/g^ftl fotivic'iriSti
       |__JEEiE_5___Pdlt^
       &j^ds_S_i_uJd^
       /-v   I v   )   ♦         - •j       W"      .i    i    _   /}        •         I               _
       J_#_li£_L_^
       i_U_MLl_l&d^
       flaug-f ^F GftjMi/Jal flppEfrk
                                        _ _ _ _ _ _
                                                      LLSdM
            ____iio.isi.E6_ aafe__8.E5f£^ii^_ibj9j: •__£ CawL-aF~
       Qi5i(_JA).e_l__flpp.Eals uibD_Jqas__jJu_^^
       ^FjSjUJlf KJ„N_. 9^ tUKlC HTg, T)oubk__^)F_^p_Q£ij_y
       £tSlS-J_a5P_2^^
       68tl_lfed^^
       i/vj _#)lf -b b£ Vi'FWFr) im flfl^firWlPF. 4_ Hm^
       witii 4Ji£ flftiqJKffll GftQ/JKlds "lFTft4 ftftE ftEffirvld dkpulr.
              WhERF&F .^fy-fetigfl                                 Vmu 4fiiy_r /hF tJeWQK                          £fc=.

       /^floiiKJcb ftloiag wi'4-h 1Gwnii*} Cj i 1p£-H4WlE£
                   i       _ i                111        i /       /(._:.   F)   ) '   I »   . __ yi

       ttohlE'MI±i6ri Wbi-b feftfi'<^_* IS Qu^Lj gdJ-j-fIgd-
       PlfiftSE flllflW l^^idp »J .4iiA <f_4i-h'rtM FoA ^applF/^lFM-f-
       Vacate c7fid^£M£^f flF G(j.l 1+ fslud__ ?fta -frJMf^ faft
       J_#jjcdfe_-^
                                                                                                              ^sj&ffj
_>•.
                   _Utd_SWd£l-J !2lLB2jfl4a^i-i^^

           jC_iLl_J___^^
            Mk<tf£ 11 ^K)E6as ?tovist'fliOLS f!ife_?„_a_J_&.
                       LlrtfiWagri r)E-.U^^4iQM.3

     V

             ^D^^fMi^f-p) f^ulkA *" )4Q3g_?S3
            :&el^__?£ES£^
           HfrfcLJ^^
            z^S(j-feSv_-__-i_d_jS--^^                     aF
            _!_ffi}_LiukyL_z^

            b^E_qj_Jl^_AMl^UflKL_g:i .„k_l6

                                                               &/Wetf?
                      _^
         SkuJ^agF >' Ul3gu?jLO

7.