Court Opinion

ID: 4068805
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 00:08:25.59113+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:51.796767
License: Public Domain

w§ ; 0 l 0 - /3 '1->)-4.@,f

C.'!\\)s€ `!\\~‘o _,.\_%`<.P\'l\o;l\$c§ 1 ._ \,¢Q\\,;),¢> \o 03 f
“UQ§'\ \\\°; .'\.3`\5‘ 5553~53_,>-“¢°` C\\)`\\ §o 3§\5 C_v 3304

§§ E§\»w Q>W\ég \\\»\o\\xo‘ - §\\'Q\e§ \3,\\\,
§\1>\ Rw\ 3\»<\ §§ dow §§}\< wm r'\\»zm

 

. ' RF“'\ §'
?S\»?;Sew \10§\\ 0? \\§§m>.> C,oc§\‘j§ §\m§\)§§\col§§‘?c§(é§l;§§u;§i§P..ALs

§§\ \\§‘\ C._c_§ 3 3 359142315

4 §04 'Y\§a_,' \\<>c’\v’r{>.§‘>\c `_`SQ§<>Q> §Q\oseav\cc>§bd.§@§§gm @3@ 514
C_\Qc\Ad ac\§ ar §§c§\¢ig 114 §\\~> C,§\M. '

§\Q Ls\_»\§( \;-4,9`\.¢\§ §>\)r\e:\ C,w~¢\Q\§`m\ \\`§4 \\1 54\\\ \§m

4 Q\Q§Q\\\Q§ §o §\§>er §§ §§ \_"“~\\§544 q\L\§\‘\ ‘>Cb `Q<)§?r\§ Y\\v§
Wo;\\ §§ \§J\§m4 C_`$¢Qg.> §§ §§ §§ §1»1¢4_14§ §§
Xvwm§z§ \Q nw c‘_wx §§ ¢49;\.~\§§\ \\¥§éo\\ §§
§\Q%.v&\m§ %‘5 \‘4)_§¥¢4\»\4\0§ §§ L§W S¥e §\c\' ’\\ 0"\ 50'-3§.\)3
Q\Q\l\‘.\€f \`> \)&4§§>\1 `\Q Q\\€ \\\> \;\\_P`\\-\p§ \5§>`39(~4,`\%',,

._ 4b1 \%§§9 '\3“\ §\B\U~\ Q\E\A»\or \L§s c\\o §4;\4)\<§\20\\; 0%
a c_,\€r¥~> ‘N=_LN§ Qx>_`\<\% "`\_\\Q§_ 5a `4'§§&\9 C.\Qm> §§QLw§$H\S
§\Q\§'\d< \\4§; i'\\v§ § wio%\_\;_§ \64 .5\3¢>~..) (`.§\n£ ¥s'
xo`.\\\\& \1> R\'°CQ-S> \\ §§ <>~¢\§4. \\§3_\ ;\\v§ o` 4\\44)11\\ v§'
§\§1\\¢§\\¢<\4\\> \4._>:'\\\ -\\\`,r\ §§ C§\¢\\»\\\ NP§A\ §»§_

\\P~_\ Q__\\Q§ § \€c.\§§~.§\\\b§ Ror Er\°\%`j 1:>§ \v.¥\§\)\`\_
_§\§,\)45 D¢ 39\4'\)1 `E.>\-\\\§©m§\®§€".s C_\(Q\)ef\§_~\&\c~\c& \`\M
§11\~»\4§4 %;ow~ \_\1§§\»§\\9(1;§14>§ §~_,§ wcm\w\§*\o,§§\

§'(45 " §»§4\ <>w\\ss\o§.\ N\J\,\ \>J§> \\ch§ \\.\§ §\Q\m\‘\>

Q\€\~A'\<>D §CL€S.S \o var‘\) §\M\ Xm§€du <°9\§1 Ed\§§\\§'\\m§*

`\Q@`\»\(\UV\§¢\\ \l\\\\'\§\'\ Q§§\\§r\\.\ Q\§\A'Wf` pj\>\i;'\ X\\\¢\§. 1\\\5
§derM \NR`\ §\m$\)(\.~)\ \9 § 9915“\ -;'/' t 9 9

§Q\$>r\:>c\ \:M\\\ 1 w 519 \\Q§ \)95?(` 51\\\»\§ \} dq\o
§C»m!¥\ X_m~\ocw\¢.z C.\A\N\ §§zc!!._\)>e, Q\<.\.M_Sc `\9 l¢~)&oce<\)..

1909 \5 \Q ;§5\99311_9\ \)\9\§'\\19 9§ '\`\99 C.ol\h\-\v\m») 1"
\‘>&` \..1\.0> §u5 '\§€u\\h 92 11‘\\1` \)/\\\e§ 5\|59‘\\`:& Y\M¥\\§ §l\h'\sr

 

 

§\\Q¢.~.u § ~- j \Ms\\\\\ \v\\><&\¥&\f\§,z ,o_§ 30>»~.\¢9 393 P¢\~\\‘>
C§\)SL S§L `C-><\\\§\\> §§ 55 §\EQ§L~\§\)\\`J 59)%!'\\\‘\0§
§§ 1191 c ' ' ` \1‘1\"-\ 'O\»\o

§€\b\-A@x/f§\kd_§ ’\\9$\'\ 5,-\9»91 \»\\\ \,91\\)& \-\\1 E><\\\Avx\\oA

591%9.»129\19\ §“919\)20\>. Q909se\_ 91 5..-\ 919 1\-\29¢110\99
\)§19-\¢1_ 1191 399\9¢¢`&¢\>9 §9»13‘ 65 \N\\n §9¢ ‘>.mo\zb§w\£

,,,,,

\§M*°-" Q"\“ §u§ec-\§\»\\u 50|\\.». U\~{vg. \'\*»\9\‘\<>

\)93\90¢1 \9,\999999‘ '1§_ 19(9\5 1999 999,;_" gm §.MQWN
191 99__\01 195 Q>Q&\m \N\§’Qc' 911 '\191\9 99 §vrx.,¢:z '

\»_».9¢_9\99 _91 919__;@§1_`.>>9~0 99 " 592-~1/\ 1119

C,Q,r'\\§\d\'\\: 1.51§ 32¢\3\10_ ~ ' .
‘§1\0§¢'\ § '\@\)v. §9)9 CDR§\Q&'\ 1Q‘>§`a

-\~\901~0 §9?9)!¢9\.\ \9§§`99£ 0_.1>9

..1.'
‘!.‘ 111

 

la \Nzuz§>b SzL\NQ_ 199 cer=\\§~i
\N~>~$ N\Sd~\e5 "¥9 ‘§\\11 '§Q\M §
§9‘99\< Y\.S\\’B 119>99*\ 5~9\\0§ §999§9 ’$z“x\> _'.\\3]\\ 99 999

_U:B!\;'_\ 9§1" 1 - 1F `Q~,°\S C_C,, S_'_\§'\<, \(O§R_C,u~\\¢\<. §’\11‘1\:>¢».)<.~3/

3\) 599 51\\¢\ §9‘\1191»,

<5§ ¥\’111\0'1§"" §_\5'@9\_1~:\
1295 \)9\9\19 5",\1‘\1) §\`r\l’~\\~\ Cx.wv>v 1\5\)1\21\99 (10091\‘-3

 

C,\m` §19\3\; __.\_\>_QQ\\_\L¢.,)J.» § § (Y\Ag\vi 3\<.01\<9,,1
\9*\€099 09 {\W'ér»\, cwweccm\w 1199

./

50Nm
§BL~‘ _\'\"\01\\\0

1119 \s ,\:\ 1\9\ § 99 311 1 1999 §1\1'\9<
‘1\03\0*\

 

`,r;-‘ \ 5 __`..T_ ‘EG\\,\R\A' §§
” ' ' " 5“\\666»6 C.DP:\ Wlw. 531 5\3¢\9

kw Q\V»'\\“`A clerk, lg\§“.\§`r`soun w

v Southem District of `{exas §"5-»§"
FlLED ’ '

_\bS‘,"'§§61316.1 Q6w1 Au(3242015
o¥_ l\\w¢c_€.s Cour\\d

E@\\M\D R\)R\B
\_I

Davld J. Bradley, Clerk of Cot;lr:f

   

' ' ‘ ' ‘ ' ' °\111\6
5 A 3 §
j ng 191 w m : "'< ' ' \`k\a\/ C"€. 6\6 \6¢;323€€$¢)
l 3¥3€~\\1\6 361\61\$ onsch
1 . »_ ,1 1 ' C,`\v\\ C~,A~m 6\6 &>\§-r_v. 06an
3‘\\3_ _‘1`6\1 <6 l ~;L\s-c
51 _ \\E \\ 61 366666». 16 ~' ° °“ "°*°‘

w3\1 61 \~\132:6 0_66?_66 '3`\\€5 16 1\_\6 \o ‘“~ 5613\¢»\
C6661 66 \\\Am\ \w &6\<

 

§26<~ __G;\-§¢-\v 1361 w`¢if_61\23 136 l can "'_1.€, ' 61

5 '- 11~“,_ \`,5\6 §`,.;;;\66 0666_.+ c.m\w-¢\A<. 131 .\‘\M\)s 03
,1-6 mq:- \\.6'\. "S; \~\M 661 366va 336 cNCog_- 666 H wm \\<6£\\('.1\ '

' le °<\£S‘ arrow 116 361\'\661\\“1\61 1'\\6'6)<\\666166

_ \666\2¢61261 \11\1 c»~s\wm\~.» 1926 ngpqu 16 366 66 tim

5 \\\_6 S-\M. 1\\6 _\\* 6336¢-1\,6\1§ \6 96:¢2__\1 301 mud
l Cv¢\v\\»\\m\\\ \`=`3963¢1.\ 56369_¢\) W._¢\s ‘\6\_» § 35 '\3\1 \K»
s*" <\r'. \W§ 3\6\66 \l &616\\6

..\~r

\\ 16\ 361 ‘\°m_ \1‘\$ S_“_.\cL \,'1931

539 66 mm w 6»§.61¢ 1\6\,\.1€66 601

':'r_-l'

66 6 66 66 1 "6§116»»
_ .. -. - .JuL. n 2015 .

' 1am coum oFAFPEN.s

_ 050¢\

 

\Ab\.zws¢ 551 41\» 55\1. 4 \44<>§“‘ 055105`5155 \555»5!\ 50 ¥..,\?`5\\ id1 4

\\e\r \11.&5\ 505\`50155\0'_.> Qm\\ A\a \\»~5 wm Eml;%\\s\\ 15 503 j%r\d

\5`1».5 §5,¥¥0¢-13 4\¥¥5110 \Wo\ 355 E¢\\¢§or¢)w\m C'5r¢.uu5&-W51. 4
1\\§5 -%QZ».? E.¥\\\\\$W\\ \\\\l\ 915 Y.\QP‘\\DA \§ \'\¥ Ed\\\\))“§
\~é¢m@£m~» 41-,5\4 515 555 \(,9 %dm\> v ‘(€u\-\er °\S‘d 315 \\K‘$,
\\33 L§‘\'~ C4`\15` \°\°\)4~)5' C,Qn-\ao,\ 515~\€'.) 5 144. md 355 551115. 435\$500 Yw.\
44444444' ‘144 44¢\44)4 § 1. 115 \", § .Q.. `S4.404i<. 3150 335 3155 51‘\\$4‘4‘€.’5$ \‘\3'4\\ jj
1 1'“0&'511 &5\'55\55 ___B___u\\\¢\§ 355;5» 5\¥¥1¢»-\5 5515\5&5 55 555 551
Qv.&r¥\\ N\RQ 4 4 _, - 7 _
‘ -“".4_,,:=_¢,:§1:§§¢_ Q,,g&m 55<,.5 553555 5553»53<. 54\.15 1~“\'555.»5 05»\0\ \\ 00 .5-
\5' wl‘c\'~ .515)'5\\\ 552 a\\\=m~"u \0 5\\5 `5¢5\\¢5:\
°‘ A“"‘“" w W’“ "'~4\3¢¢'\¥5'\¥:1 §5)\454>5115. BMJA\ why

\)555»5¢5 31¢\5\5»-501‘. 11 ‘1\!1~5'§5 a‘m\m u(\dw‘{%§hi oY 3140&.50 ~5\555
\\5 wagy._v§mu 515 15£\)5 555 cma-5 E>.m.~c_d \\\LM 300 01 554»4\0 3301

CQ\’.,\`S¢;M~ 5¢4>? str\l'¢§ . '. . W'A

 

1 \\5\1.4\5 anxst \\45155 ~\-\.39. (\4\5\¢1 \5 55\:1 \5»_\ Cv(tm\_ M \4:00'5¥1
1353 0535515 555555 15\5'53555 555 50555,»553053 333 55 545?1.»_ 551 5\5>

c4\.:'»(.5»4¢4~v45045\ 45.4)4¢5.54 w\£\h\ \45 U\MY\S\<\)¢KA \4\\\)¢45¢445 4C.'_4¢4>5»¢4\5‘__-\ §§
\¢_0, \'§5\~ C-'swr 01 th\y 'cr_ \0$*"~ 5505¢'555 C.w.hf,__;_' __
\) 35513 5-5»15 \50-5€¢»5 Cw¢\ \\13 l~\*\~ S\~\>aa\\»¢- Csc¥u> umw 1415
4 (\\i\t-\\ S\w-c\\\ &\B:NQ Caur\s c\\'->\ \-P&N$ (,5(`%».> C¥\R\t `\QK md\\o\ 505
5'.\55 MAA:\ 5:>? _dv\b lo\< €.M~m\ kahn \`\~\a\\-\o A\\M§ \J¢\\X
- ` ')~\5\ @*\3\~¢\ 1\~\\~ 1051 3\\‘¥0¢ 1153

 
 

 

(

 

j'. "*"* .` l t l " ~ '€11\11111 g

1§11111 515§1111`11§

'- //_"_? / §`)/3( q/V© §
I` \11\\\1 51§§1§] l 51<§§5 51.;\1110.1 \)r\§§§

5?511\1‘1 05 Q§F§\) l§ 1\>1§ 5115.1§ W\&\\\ 5:1>10~1 1152 356
`\\\1 \?111:> chz. 911§51€11 §0:1¢_§1111(\<. \\`\1 \\1§ 511111!\1»1

` 55¢1\\~11 111 1111 r_111 11 0,1`111§11 1111111§<111§

\_Q-\11r> `\\N§ '\&‘\11§ §r Q\Y§§\f\§§ \:1111§ L0m5\51w\>

Q.'sc\a1m`1t\1:. 511 \\ 05 1001 501¢1<. 5\$)\§1151_5 51 1115§55195
55 \..P\v~> __55€ Q(>N\Q\A§<§> l §§ \D'~’\Q\55C51»5{5 C..\(wmd\{\\§tu l _
l <51)§ *1'.1 \\05 \1\1\ §§1<1<1 Q\° \§5&5 \\§N ~\5§ 511\111\1' _
ll 51`\§(<\§>) 5\51\§ §\k\.\\`(¢§ '\\AA 1\>')"1 51'>\1‘5'?`5 55 55_>1111<~ \5.
\§_'1\ \\ 61 ¥1\95 11§ \\\Q. \“\`\` 555 155 “\5(\\§ Q@\S
55 5€5~1(15 \..11\511'_ Se¢... 3€5\.5115 §~1§~\\5 \\\;1“ \\§Q\h_

AZ\P":)>' 5(`© \*\\.\1\5€<\0\. 505 \m\§5\¢\(.1 \\1> 51»§1§\-1 \o

Y\\c§ Y§5‘Z\5\ \~Q1\ 5)<>11§~\~ ~\Q ~5-\-§~_511§_51` wl\_\}*_
91 \551111 C_w511 551 \;\1\ \111.1<, \1-111~, wm m§‘\,,§
5111< 1115 know 111 1111 \1511 §§111<1\ 1111-11 51111.1

`\¥\5§- S'v!_\'m 51~_10\'<113 d.§§\o.‘acm~n\, 5'\1=)£<\€7
Q'- 0~§11< \31“\05 C_'§§\§\ 51§-1‘11§ 511-111 “11111 ‘\1‘\\\

 

(\¢~)\~m \39\90110»\ \\~:\i\\\~\ C,.\vv\k \\)5*‘~ §\>-\(\\¢~\ CO\/c\
°\~»\ \_.Q§?M§ 519\1¢1 ""i_;:’~Te,X 18~1¢\ 9\\~\ 3\3 ,M

\Xs¢\¢e§wz_ 9"<\_!\¢\§ dwier °\¢\ \_Qo\wd mm-\ 4 "'
9\\'\;1\1> Q,sw\\u awva C\AR\S-\ ‘\`P- N\-\s\

   

7 `Y\>.§ \A<>m>o\\\%\q. 'S\sbw. BIW~\» 9\>\<.\“§ °\Q_\_ \.e:>_9wd
§\Le\_-\ \\\\Sm$ L\>;.»<\\: °_\1\__!1> `\‘§\1»\ 9\¢§1~¢\80}- `

" `\;¢.> \\\»` \\\)mm%\e. \R_`“‘ C.wr_\ 59 MM\, c_\zrv\
3 C.QC\\Q. ¥°‘.\_ B§AABQ(' . ¥\\_\)9{9\ QD\,A'\!) .c‘\o\ \__Q¢\§;\ §'\(99__-\ .; .

’C.D€?\n C.\AQ`\\'\"\ `\Q\N '\‘8\\¢>\ -} \o*-\~ 9\30(\

we \\1 \Am1§_ %`KC.\°\&\\'\ \__®_Q

 

l \\WZR`$_ AQ.C.\!_\,\Q_ \JAGQF ~\;\\1_ 391\9\'\‘3 c>§ QU'.S\¢(S \_\\M

9.\\ 5'\9~11\\19¢\1> we -\'1\¢1 M Com\-\ <\\ Bm\xums %`3 v »
. 39 "\) st 3 \‘\\1\0 11 § \n +:<>\ \31 m e\m\,\v\ wm
.__QB;_ A:~-;s <>& 539\@“91(~ ' a\»\s ~ '

 

 

dow \1 b.\\l\§§` \»n\>.
~ 9~\0\ Y\'\ 3\1>°\ \*\*“
- 3;;_>\»;»;91»1"¥»1> jun