Court Opinion

ID: 4071840
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 02:24:43.675327+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:13.164677
License: Public Domain

IA.l   1H£.
                     CouR I           DF     CP-..l MIN~     L   AP PE.111LS    ot= i      E)(A   S
                                            1\lo.

                                                                                              COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

              PA fl-. I E.     'l'o bJ) W~RRE.!J             A L£.5 CHuL        , ll Pr0 L l LrA JICL20
                                                                                                   l.   2015
                                                                                                      Abel Acosta. C~m
                   M o i lotJ F"orz LEA 1)£ 7o                            FJ LE
0~\611\JAL ~PPLlc..AIIDI'J FoR uJ'fZJ·{                                         01- 1-IIJB£A.S. CtJ{(fUS
Put\SUAIII"'I 7'~ fl.UL£     ILL 'f£X_ ({_ APP..: fRt;c__

lo         -(H {   HotJDR.,.qf3L£           clul:!GE S oF S.-<Jih        cou({ I-:
                                                                    1.
      -lii1S t~ -r'HE: iJf.R."f FIRS/ 7JIVI/E 1"!-IE: GRouNDS ~IS!Eb HAil£ £Lit.R. 8££11)
PR.f.S£AJ T£/)_                                                     ·
      1"1-IIS oRIGINAL IJPPUCA/Jo/1) f:oA.. uJJq__l-r' oF J.IA6£t1S coA.PU'::> IS PR.Df£P.. (3.EFat<E
1•hS cou R-r AS> A Dfi...IGJ/Jt~L PP..o c£EDtfliG BE. ~u.sr; 1'H£ IJPP UcA/tJ t s CoMfLAJ/lJIJt.fG        -r
oF ~Du~ Dll=ffER&J"T C£)1JUlc-r'toNS "tH~--r ARE C..OtJ.SEcu-nut; F~M Two
blr:FfRtNI COtAIIJilcS IN vJHtcH -(HE. PARoL~ Bt>I9Rb iS \/LtJLA-(JJVb 3 7 "tcX~
~~MtJ _ cob£ ~ 145 _'-iCC{) BV -fREAIIN6 -fH£ Af3cUE LiSTED ctJAJS£cu711/E
5£tJL"FE.rJc£S AS ..Q SJrJGL£ SE!I){£1\)c£. F6R.. euR.PoScS OF PARDL£. ,qffLLc.AI\)f
C.oN--(hJbs. '1'HAI 'FILJAJG A IJPf'LlcA-tJI)/\J r=att WRI-r                          oF NA8Er:~s CDf{fUS Ul1.fbEI<
J:l({ 1' _1Lb 1 V. t:LC..._c._p., DN ALl Y. CtJtJI1LC1JI)/\JS. IN                     2 D IFF~R&J! D iS/~Jc. /
 c.ouR.I'S At'-Gu11JG ~H£: .SAM£ G{{f)ullfbS uJt>uLb B. if                           ...<l WIJS 7£ oF- JuDi CLAL
Rf.SoUfl..c.£.S Alill.b £cotJarvt Y ANb CouLl:l Pr.tobuc.E                                         -r
                                                                                  DLFFER..E/1)/ tfUAL CL>ufl...
r=tNDINGS Di= F"Ac-L f> catJCLUSto/IJS or- LAu..J_
      Il-l£ APPLICAN"I IS ALSD ~JP-.£u1A16 'IHAI 1'HE.. Tbc...:J-R.£Ct:>R.bS DfFIL.£.
RE~US£S -(D PR.oPt;r<LV CoMPUL'rr/~ Ill£. ~PPUct<JIIfiS ~&U~ Lf CaN.s.£cu--t'lJ!E
S£tJ-r:/EtJc£S tAl A APPRaV£.b fllltMlAIER CJf ME.7HDbS. -t'JitS Cou'A.-J .S£1 ou.-r
lrJ EX. PAR-r£ WlcKuJ,qA£ -2>53 S.uJ_ zJ. 51! 10 T S73-7'1[1£x..ci!_APP. IC"f'l?:.J.
     llPPltcAilf-r 1-lR.GuE.S '!1-ltrr -(He. PFlRLJL£ Bollftll ts. iLLE6ALl/ bE.AJV1t\/6 V\AIJ/I)L),q"1J>~l/
SuP£ttvlSiot\J orJ i-11~ L~s7 5£!l)·"t£1Jcc oF -(JIE CDAJSEcu-riUE S£((JES wHICH lS
                  SuP~fl..lliSloi\J 6.LLG.t£LE buE iD oFF£tJS£. DA1£ 6F Cf -q-t"9CfZ AIJll IS
 MANl:>l<l-ro,:t,.l/
  1LL£.G.t<JLi./ APPC'ftrJG. 'A.£-fRJ>Ac_-rnJE il-l£ S"fAiu-tE I>sog_JI.fq 1'£x.._ Goi.J 1"L Ct)b~
  "'"l'o    Cl~tJif t'VtANbl<l'To,::.V       S:.uPt;R..tJlS.toAJ "to   APPLIC.11J-r~ M~ E.LiGI,gLE .S.&IJ-t£AJCE.
           IHJb AR.GuE.S          ·-(H,<r( -tH£     P~f\oLE. BoAIVl HAS.              -r
                                                                              PR.bc..EbuR£..5. ··nltrr ALwuJS
                                                                              ND SE
   1\~ ~ c:t)I\Jbi-r'ION Df A PARIJLIE PLAN !=ot=t -{H£ /.:JPPUutJ'I f'i> &E REL£~SBJ
   ci\J YAR.DL{ lb H tS t-£b£P..t<JL b£i.xJIN€f{S. For\ Fcb£/U.JL PRISDAJ S£/JIEAJc_E.S
   Wi-lt el-l ii\J t:. fFE..c-( C4Ll .5.£ S No PAR.t:J LIE FoR -r Jl E A P PU C/-"JIIJ -t:

                                                                       1'""
                                             -l..~

                                               I I_
  Ji.. 6Rou I\IJ::)   Alo _ l ~ P.<~R.D L£ BDI'l R D \J LDLirr1n!G A Pf' L 1CA t1J -rs                ·
     eo/JS'"ft-Tu--t'tol'liAL RlGfl-r -ro DuE (JtzocESS 6t=- L/JW g Y VIDLA"L!IIIG
     3/ LEX.. A DIVI II)_ CoD£. .P 1££5. 'i ("') --- B "/ '[R.E.A --(JNG A (J f' L1 CAN -r's
     C61\JS.£.c..u-ruJE SErJ-t£.tJc_ES J<lS A SINGLE ~£rJ-r£tJc_f FoR.
                                                          -r
    . fuA. Po5lES o ~ ('A fZDL E. 1'11 E sTATu £ (' P--oul DES ~;
              ""Ru.L£ l 'ts _Y- foll cY 51A-tEMEI\J'I RELA-rttJG LD F£Lt?/1J 'I
                                 C.O J\JS E c.u. -ruJ f S fill i£ llic£S .
                           Cq)'" ll PARoL£ (J.tJrJ£.L 1\1111'1 lt}o'/ -rR.EIJJ' c.oAJScwltUE
                                     _SEtJ ..fEI\)c_fES AS A '::JirJ6L£ 5£tJ-r£i\JC£         FoR
                                      PuRPOSES C> F (' ..<1 fl..DL £. '' -,

         ll (J PLl CA 1\J   -r
                          S Ho w S 1rJ           -r
                                            1+£ A PP £A) b I X ..<l R£ c_CJI)       -r
                                                                              i f:::l C- J
  INMA1E TIM£SLIP --[/-1-,q[ CLEAR.L'-1 SHatAJS A SJN6L~ S£Art£1JL£ __
  6 F lJ D YE.JJ ~ S _ S E. E: 1J PP9\1 DI>( 1 . T/i t S S 11\16 L E lf o Y£A A. -rD L J
  S£tJ ~ErJc£ i ~ ~,<t$£1) oi\J -tH£ FDLLowiNb CotJS.E.Ct.JL'ill£ 5E.AJ"1£AJ{.£S ·:
        -*'5 ~R~--CAa5E#9l-2ZI-C
        ·IS   '{(l..S .• -CAUSE.   # 2.355-J (coi\JStEcufWE io CAti5£#CfJ-Z8l-C)                              .
          '2.o "f£ZS_ £ Zo YfJS~-CAuSE # 266-zz L:AIZGbl;,            CCAI.is.E.cu-nJE. 7PC..AuSt. Jt Z3.s57J
        '"t.o lA L ; 4 o ''t f\. S ..                                                                     ·

       11+ £      1'b c J HAS. IH£. APPLICAN 'I ~o uvG               A   S 1NG LE. lf(}    't £A ({
  S£1\J"1£rJc£ 6AS:.ED             ol\) -rHE.S£ CDttJS£.cu-rtUE f:.ctJ/£1\JC£S WHLcll
  l·L<l~ CAUSED tH£                 fA({oL£ ~DAIZD -(D IR.EIJ'"T' HIS Coi\JS:.£cLr-rtU~
  SEf\J-rErJc.ES AS A s.uJ6t£                     lfo Y£1\Jf.._ S:.£tJrENcE. ..    1Hts    VIDLAic...5
  SEL .. So gA JScF"f£.X._ C:b\J~·-c C£JbE _
                      ·~=--====-----------------------
*'-GRoul\lb /Ja_2-; 1'1/E: IDc.)-REcoRt\S DFfiG£ IS \JioLA-r/1\/G
  1.\ PPUc..AtJ--f's CoNStllu~/orJAL R.lGJ-1-r -rD ~ u. E {Jf'...ocE.5S -0~ LA uJ
  S~ Rf.FUSftVG -r'o PR.oP£fZLY CiJMPu-t£ -(lfE APPLlCt-1N/'S                           I.J. AgouE
  coi\JSEc.u-rnlE S£.tJ-tE.rJc£S 11\l tl A PPRDU£D YYIANNE({. Di=
  ME-(JtohS -(lfiS coutZ-r S.£1 ou-r 1Al EX PAR.{£ uJic.KWAR.£.-
   ZS·~ S.u..J .. 2.J~ 51/ At 573 -7Lf [-r€x a.-APP~ l'f'l~].
  !<\ S S HouJtJ IN A() PE.I\Jh IX. .1 -(H C. -[[:)c.. J Y{E Co({b S C>FFI LE J..IAS
  CoMtJ:.il\l£b .<lLL HIS COI\JS.Etuitll£ S£tJIE.IJc...£S 1/'J·io A SiNGLE
   4D YEAR. SIE.iJ-r£1\JC£ S'IARIING Ftz..oM AfJPLlC.tutliS F!r<.SI
   5 YEAr... S£r.rT£NC£ 11\J C..<l US£ Tl-cli-Zfsl-C , SE..AJ-r£AlCE 8E.6ttJ
    b~i£. f;lPPLICAN( AP-.GuC.S 1'!-IAI'f'J-1-LS lMfJfJ.tJPE.A. ME.l'floD D!=
    -r'R.fAiuJG ALL HL~ catJS£cu~llJ£ S£.A.J-(£Ak. £S ..<IS .l<l StllfGL.~
         -r
    ~ £1\J ErJc_fE H .<l s. CA us Eb -rII E. pA f{()L £ B/)1~ fUJ ' 7 D     -r
                                                                          REIJ -r II l.S
    c..oi\JSE.cu-(JLJE S£1\J-t£AlctEs ,.<JS A S;llf6L£ 5€iJT€:fJc£. WiilcH
     ~ ~. A ~a£.b iN ~6({DU(I)b lifO., 1 V loLA l"cS 3·1 "1£.X_ AbMAl_ CtJb £
     !> I L£5 .. '1 Cc.) l S £c._ So8. /So ·-(£X. Gou·'·-( CtJb ~ .• A L L A PPLl CA A) ·-r5
     ~f.AJT£/JcES W(Rt= CoMNII-r'7£b l'lf=-r£tZ lCf8/.
                                               -.3-
                                                                                                   I

~6Rouo!}) No_3-; -tHE. PAR...bLIE 8t:>..<~Rb IS \JlOLAil!t!G Af'fLtcAAJ"!'S
cDrJSII-r"u.-iloAIIJL Du£      PRDc£SS Ll/3&...-rlf itJ·"ffER.cS-r ,q,LGHI'S BY
 R.£1-US/rJG To SEI A tV\...<31\JDAToR.V ..Su.P£RVLS.ItJN I'JA-t:E F=oR.
 H l S LAS S£tJ"fcrJc£. 11\J -(HE. CDtJ~£cu -ruJE S£.~1 £ S CA US£
              -r
 IJD_l.6,613l 2o Y£Af\S" DE.AbL'I u.J£1JPON IN PE/JtJL IJ\JSL-l Z3R.b~
 DIS "ffZLL -r CtJU'fZ I D F g R..A ZoA.lA Cl>LJ -('>(_
            A PPL iC.AN ,_, AfZ6LJ£S -(J.IA-r -(/-1/S D~~EN5~~ uJA3
 C.DMI\At-r-rEb o/IJ SEPI ... 'L lCf'lZ. AI\Jb iS tVI.~tJb~-toR..'I Suf'ERUJ.SiiJN
  E.LIGtBL£. ·fJ.IlS couA.-rs EX PAR-t£ f...u/'HJ<Jr<..-r DcC.LSioN,.,.
. PRDtJibES -(HAl YlllllNbt:l-(oRY Suf;;p.JJlSto/\J LviLL otJLlf 8£::.
  GR..~Alc£b "TD ·[fiE L<JS/ 5:./ftJ-{EI{)cE ·IN A cotJsr;cu-nU£
  S £RI~S IF "1HA -r ofFEAlS £ IS £:. U618 LIE.. 1'H f DPr:-tE Ais£
  of DE.Al b L ~ uJC.A PorJ Jl\) P£rJt>J L 1N.S 1: IS N tJ ··-r Al 0 F FE./JS£.
  LIS1't::b rrJ S E.L._ 5o8_/l-f't (~) "(£X. GDV''/. CtJD£ IH~·( l S lliAI-
  M ~ rJ h 1\l ltJR. V, ELL G 'BL ~. ll PPL1 cA AI-r 1s LE.6A L if EltJ'Ir1L El)
  'lo rJoi\J - D rsc~t-r1 orJJ<J ~ Y M~/IJ Dt<J -rtJ P... V .SuP /E((\h S!tJ/\) otJ
  CAlASE. # 2{,~6/3 _ S£.£ ~7 ·t£X._ ADMN~ CDDE. l>JL[i. ill (l&J.,
            ACJ r Ll CA Al'-r s PRo :J £ct' f.b R£. L£~.S £ D IJ "1'E A So S H o uJ II) IN
   ·1'1+£ TD c_.) 11\J MIJ. -r £ tiM£ SUP IS D l --() 5 . -- l.o 2. ~ u.J HL cH l S
    lil S YVL<I X:. I VVl LA IV\ EX.. PlfZ~ iJ o /lJ b ,q -t".£ ! l F [I-/£ Tb c:.. .) tf':, pJJ t<. 6 L E
    B D AR..h W ~(Z..,~ PR.oP ER. LV t<l PPL '111J G IVI.<J Nb 1J loR. V SuP Er<...lllS toN
   lo Ht s LA.S        -r       S.EtJTEAic£ - CAu.S£ # 26,67 3 " 1'1+/EN PEP-..
    3/ ££x.._ AD Ml\J- con£ ~ Ill L Ill (2.9} , 11+ £ i'b c:J . ii\JM.IJ -r E
   -rimE.    SLLP     WoLALb         SHouJ ~     VV\uJiMUfVl RELc/J.S£ D;:J/E S£-r FDR.
   1'1-1£   M.<3rJb~"IOfi...V SufE.tZUlS/t)tJ         E.Li61&LE DFFEIIISE~
                            5
             Ful't'fH£R..      Sog_149 (q) IE.X .. G.DU'I_ CobE. DoES Alo-r ALLouJ
   Rf.LEAS.E lo 'hlSC.R.£1/0AliJL 'fV\ANDAtt>t<.V SuP£f!....UlS.lorJ IF -rHE
    irJMi<l"LE IS:. ~£fZvlrJG olt f.ltJS B£&\J Coi\JVlc-r£b DF AJ ofFENS€
    LlSIED IN l>SoB_Ilf9Co.J. 1'11£ IQPPLIC<uv'1' HAS .A ~66f<./H}IJ-{~!J
    t<lSS~uL I          cotJ\Jic-r'toN- CrJuSE. # Z667Z tHA-r HAS Afo
    b £..~JDL'i wuPoi\J Flfvbll\!6 AN b wAS C/)MfV11-r'!£D olli s£p_ z...1
     l'i92. WHLCH uJ~'S u.J£LL BfFot..F- 5 So!$.lLf9 S-rJ<r!u-r£
    B£c..<~M£ E~FE.CI1ll£ ~ t<lPPLlc/>JAi'l ARGuES '1'/IA-r -tHE PAA.oLIE
    B D .<1 R.~ (_A rJ 1\Jo     -r A PPL   v} sog _/L(Cf R£: -rMI:K...-rllf€      bEN ·-ro             y
   HlM MAf\JDAiof{V SuPER.\IJStiJN ol\.) CA£A5£#Zl.,b!3
  lAJI-/Lci-1 iS IV\JJr\JDJOiof.-\f SuPER.tJISto/l) ELIGIBLE Du£ lD
  D~F£.rJS~ DJ<t-(£ DF 9 -'1-l'lCf Z A\rJh ; S -(H £ LAS-( 5 £/!} -(EilJCE
  DF -{J+£ co!VSEcu-£1Vf. S£RfE.~S~:
            1:\PP U£:!.!Al"'f fHZbU £_S "l#f/A ~1" tJ6 CAS£ LAu.J oA. S '"ffJ.-('u"i~
  t\b~R£S.S£S -(filS SP£c/FlC LSSu£ fZAi S£b uJt-1£R£. 1.1-1£ Lt:JS-r
  S&J1El\JCE 11\l A cotJS.Ecultl.l£ .5>£R...IES. i.S MANbA-IoRV £Li6JBLE
  Bu '"( TH-E PIJf...DL£ BoAftb f-.E.FU.SES l-J BAS£~ DNA PRJDIZ S£/I)--!£AJC!:
   '"IHA-r IS f'Jo'/ MtMlDA-1/J({V ELL61!3LE AI\Jh --fH£ ftJRDL£ SJ~ 15
     \MPP-..DPE.P...L.Y U~trJ6 5 So8_149(q) AS RcASL>I\) [o D£AJV rvtS
                                                                            CCo A.) 'ltrJLA £'bl
                                          - 4~

*
.6Rou Alb NtL It:.
\J tDLA -oAf b H t
                           ~ PPu CAN-(   A R6U £ S "fHA      -r -rH£       fjD~ R.h iS
                                                                       fA ({IJL £.
                      s bu IE. PA.tJ ass R.IG.H-r s B '1 1-Vnli/\JG A.Jo s£--r '
    PRoc..£Dlll~S "'~ 'R.ULE.~ or<... S/,<J"lti'l'ES UIV!JE.R CHP-(.. s;og_ 7Ex_GDV 1'..
CtfD~       oR 37 -[/[.X~ A!JfVIN_ CLJIJE_ ... TH~JI' PRDUibE.S ItS A CoAJDrfJ/)/1}
DF PARoL£ PLt<11\J ·-tHtc:J -r -fH£ tJr:-r-£1\JDf.R. BE REL£/-lSE:b o/\l PAf'..OL£
·!"o Al r:-JEDERAL b!E.IAJNcR. 'lo 5£RiJ£ c.olt)S£cu-rllfE F£b Ef!./J (_
 Sf.tJ-r£.Afc_E_ i'J..ItS IS CAU.Sllvb No PARDL£ Fa~ APPLl CAAJ-r!
            -(H£. APfLIL~I\J'"f WAS caf\J\Jlc-t£.]) uJ FEIJERAL COL.a'{-r IAl
  2.ot>l..{ oF fJSSJJUL I           uJH LCH iZo MIJ!J-(fl 5£N·-tE/lJCE WIJS
 CDrJSEcu!lU£ to HtS T!Jc.1 SEAJ'filt)c£S. S£E ll..S_V_IJL"1ScHuL
  I I b (- E.b ... A PPX- LJ/5 2- [51#_ C1fC ZoLJ Y] _ A ]) £.1'A tAlER. u.JAS P [;,q c~ l:J
 W1'1J-I i b a £ fJAR.LJLE. BDt<JI\h BY -tHe tl.S~MIJf\SHALS S£({1)/C£
  F"o R. -O-ILS ~EDERAL ~£1\J [E rJa;_
            APPLtc...<!tJ7 AR6LI£S THJJI 'l'HLS. FE.bER.AL DE'fAINER HAS
b£Ttt1M£1111AL EfF£L-(S tlfiJD iS PP...E.\f!EA.Ji/Nb APfLlcAtJ·-r Frzt>IVl.
PA fZDLLrJG -t'o SERVE L'HlS P£D£Rt<JL SEiliiENCE ~ S SHow.tJ.
                                              -r
~PPLtc..;qi\J-( ut\JDER.S.Tt<JtJD3 L'll~ .. HE NAS 1\Jo RIGHi £o P.-<JR.IJLE
~IJh -(HE Yt:XA.S. CtJtJST!-ru-rtotJ IJu-t'l-loR.tZ.£.5 IHE LIEG.t.sLA-rur<....E
'lo                 A Pt:J fZaL£ S lf.S. TENl _ [EX_ ColliS 'I. IJR.I .TIL,~ 11 ~
           ES. [f:J BUSH
       A.U>uc~AJ-t .<\IZ.6u£S 1HAI 'tHE fiJRbLE B6ARb HAS {;ui!JEL!AIES
AI\Jb Ru LIES -(1-t;rf .IJ LLiJW S DFfEtJb/Ef?..S 'f'o B£ R.£L£AS fh oAf PAf...DL£
    IF   .<:\   fJARtJL£  P(rJN I~ APPfWVEfL 1'H£ OFF£rJbt=rz YVJuSI wof!..K
    \~ ELIG1t3L£ ArJb R£PoP.:-t -(tJ .AI PAtZoL£ o~;-::·lc.ER. , .e.J-c:. __ t<JLL of=
    W 1-t U:. H -nl E A PP L LL~ll\.r( Cru\l Ncr( !Jb IF 1-( c 'S fA R.DLEll tD .t<t FE.bC.P-..AL
    ~R.lSorJ .. ·11-1 £. fAP...DLE. &>I(Jt<b CAN PAR.oLc. A 0Ft=Eflil>£p...,_ A F-rER
    C...oMPL~IlofJ DF Nu!lll£P,nuS '[·~PES 0~ 'REI-I!<IBILI-r'A'l'Jol\) PR.CJG.R.AM.S
~u-rL~(Jt.~ uJ             31   -t£x. .. ~iJ;phE      -.f.   Ji.JS .. I 2 C~\(c.'\(b\Ct:"),(F\C6\
CH),(ILCJ) .. ,_ l-lotAJE.UEfJ...·f/5\_k~-,._jrJ.I£S£ PRDGR.ANlS DD AJa-r /JLLow
A DFFErJIJE.t'Z. io PIJIZ7lCtPt<17£ ;/\] 1~ -fH£ DFf=Eill6Erz 1-liJS ,<J
S tA'Lt;;. \ (:Eb/;f<..AJL DR- ltVIMIGfZ.A71oAl hEI~trifE({. •
     . ND P~ML£: PLt<JtJ UNbE.IZ. -rH£ PIJfZl>LE. RuLES PR.DV!b£5 F61Z
P..<l~L£. -r'o Al bt=-rrJtlli£R.__ -(HLS \JlDLAt'ES DLA£ PRocESS t<Jitlb. bp,_
    f.GUt<!L PR.D"L£C..IIIH\l 0~ LAW ~S              ALL o-(HEA. JNrVLJ<J"lES fiJo-(
    S £ fZ.IJ JrJG L IFf uJ t-fJ.I Ala PA fl..DL £   tl R £. £. L IGIB L£ Fof, f ~f....£) L £.
           APPLIC.tJNI AtZ.Gu£S TNA--t IHE. SIAIU1ES 1-115 WAS. Ct)I'JUtc-f£1)
    lA f\Jbf.R. A LLouJ .S P~fZtJL£ _ So F=o~ -111£ PtJFZDLE 1'60AJt<JJ -t'o R.E~u.s£
    4PPLic~JI\J"T fiJ({oL£ g,E.CAU5£ oF A D£1/JIN/£1'<. VIDL<rT£S DtJIE
     PR.ocEs~ oF L~w 13 £GuA L YJ({D-t£c..-rtoN cL.AUSE.
             IH IS ColA R.. -r: S. Hou.LIJ H£AIZ. it+L S E K7fZ/J.CJ({_J:j !Nil f-.. V IS SU ~ _
                                                    -~­
                                              R£L1Ef
        V\.H\ L;; RE Fof,E • .fJ rz~ rvt 1st:.S coNs/DE R.£h , A PP L I CtiJ/\1'1
                 -r
R. EG uf:S'I HA -r -{J.J-J         sCDLA f..._ -r :
       f)_      6PJJtJ (        '11+~ r\1\o 'LioN Forz. L£/1! UE.
       2.)_ ISSuE A               REMArJb DR.bf:R. 'F-oA. -rH-E. I.J iRlAL Cou{{-tS
       -        -(o D t:. uIf LD P£ Ell I f)£ t.Jc..E o /\.) -(J-1-t S i ~ 5 LA £. LA tV b IE IZ £X.
                 P~P.:r£ ~£'iNA- ?ol S.v<l_Zd. <IZ.I C-r£Ex.._c(l.._fJ()fJ. t'L~6).
        3) _    6 R..<~I\J --r -n-1- 1s oR.l GrilfAL A PP ucr~ -tiDAl FoP--. w rtl-t oF J-IA f3~1JS
        -       Co fZ()u S A1\Jt\ Drtl\t:R.. "i'H E :.                                               ,
               (\)_ (JAP...DLE. BOARD -('o s-rvP 'fREA'l'tAiG APPLICAtV"1'S CoNSEcu-ttt./E
               -                                                                                 -r
                   S £1\J '1 £ tJc..ES AS A S 11\/GL £ <:::, £Al£EA1C£ l4..HiicJ.l cuP.. .fZ£111 LV
                   \J lD l A ·1 £ S 3 7 LEX.- /J DMAl _ CDO E - f> I LJ S _ <.f Cor) ~
            (I il-  -r~c_:J- RfcotthS c f=Fl C£ ·f"o S-rAR -r PP....DPER.L '{ CbtVI Ptr1A I!Nb
             -      APPLICflt\J-r'S CCJtJS£cu-r11fE S.£1\Jc£Afc.£S 11\1 CMJ£ OF -rHE
                   IJPPR.b\/Eb M££1-loi':lS 6u.-rLuv£D IN E.><_ f!JP. . -r£
                     wtc..Kt.AJ~t\f.- 8       s ~ s . vJ . ZJ_ 57/,S7?:.-7lf.C1EX.. c~..~Jv().    iCJ'13')-,
            ( \i \) _PA RDL E    fSDA   R.b   -fD   cu LA/£ A MAN' b.<~ t6f?.. '-{ SuP Efl...U!S t o/U
                                                    CAl
                     D.<~"1f." FtJfZ. C.AJU.S£. l\lo_l./n6i3 2o 'itZ_ S£11.)-rcNCE-
            ( \\J) _ {)f,lf,DLf 60t<l R.b "1'"o IJDoP7 A Przot:.£Durt.E , R..u L£ -(HA ' /
                    ALLowS ~ 6FF£rJbErz"S PIJ.fZ.bL£ PL.AJI\J "TD 11\JL._Lub £
                     RELEtl s~         -r/)
                                          A D£.-r.A 1f\!Er<..

                                                          -foD b     _
                                                          tD c..,J f\Jo_.S8bCf6!
                                                          'I£. L~DrZb u/\J r /
                                                          3 8 '1 D( S L/J ·-rE Hw Y_ <t 8
                                                          N£{A) &oS'lo/\l,      -r><_
                                                                                   /5570
                                                          A ffLl C!lN/

                                                           s_
                                                         -£-
     !; i   1J   -r£.          D   r: l   £ X/J S                  _S
      cou 1\J-r"'            or-       f>tJw 1f.:                   ~
                                   VE.rzlr::lCAiloN                 D.AIH
                b£LLA1t2-..E ufliDEfZ P£/JIJL-tY oF PEfZ1ar<._'l [f-IAt
                 1
     -(J+£ A £So \J £ .1J rJ h HJ fZ£ GD tJtfG S I 1J { t; fill E rJ -r 5 A f\. E
      -( IZlA £ A/'\) D Co rzrzfc--( -(D -( H£ 8 £S -r 0 F YVJ V KNow L£ /J b~ -
            S (GN~~                 -~(J-t l S,    J 5111_ b.4   V oF ocTo B 6. ~   , Zo IS -·

                                                                 .lfl
                                                                  A
                                                                      rt!'tr!Lu
                                                                        PfL1 C.A/IJ{
                                                                                     L

                         L£rz_ / l !=I CA            [E 0 F S£ fZ..V ICE
        \ CE rz 1' 1F '{ 1/-IA -r A -(f\uE A Nb c.orzREc-r coPY D F !liE
   A&1uE Af\JD HJP"£6otrJG Doc.uM&V7 Wfl~ 5:,£KV~b -to -tHE~
                                           -r
 ~ S I tl-r £ (J fZo sr; c u u\J r; tJ -r o !ZllfE 'I    -c
   IJUS[ti\J -(-i.__ !Sill ~
                         I

-*   'D tS -rKl c -r A\ -r7ofZrlfE 'I- M c LE 111 flfAlii co., "tx.
     Sol uJASHcf\/G£oAl AVE._
     LJJ ~ Cd '!(_-      ·-r
                    I 6 7 I 0 'I
                     I

*      DIS True-r Al'-toP.JJG Y- ~ RA Zof?...IA co., 7K: _
       \11 ~ _ La cus-r s,                        -r_-
                                       Sut7£ ~1Jf5-A
     . A'l rJ &L r;. "'toN. IX.. 71 s rs -;

--- &Y       LLS.- MAIL. PoS~~G:.E Prz.Ef/JJD, o/I.J -nfJS iSTII_ DAY OF
     oc-ro B £rz                    , zo I .c;

                                                                  6_
  .UNIT COPY             T.D.C.J.-INSTITUTIONAL DIVISION        07/15/2015-315
   ITS40952                        INMATE TIMESLIPS

ALTSCHUL,TODD WARREN                   TDC:00586467 SID:04355116 UNIT: TO
                                             H0 US IN G/B.E-Jh 12-6-E-~--s

 *PRJ-REL-DATE:                                            E:       01 05 2029 ·
 *INMATE STATUS:

          TIME    CREDITED:                  CALC BEGIN DATE:  03 14 1991
  GOOD    TII1E   C ED                       TDC RECEIVE DATE: 05 30 1991
  BONUS   TIME    CREDITED:       0 00 00    GOOD TIME LOST:          870
  WORK    TIME    CREDITED:       1 01 21    WORK TIME LOST:            0
 *TOTAL   TIME    CREDITED:      27 10 25

 *STATUS EFFECT          DATE: 07 14 2015    JAIL GOOD TIME RECEIVED: YES

 DEC: GME0339       QCC: MBL1332

 STAT CHG: L1/07 14 2015

                            ~ffErJbJx_           1