Court Opinion

ID: 4070875
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 01:34:27.03256+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:34:27.065512
License: Public Domain

RECE|VED |N

 

 

M@T" "©N DEN ED ' couRT oF-cmMmALAPPEALs
1 0141'5 \\'\ /I\B/JP\ 710 135~®@> ocr 1921115 _
BY; "1?€, ==‘ ,_ »
515\/1=_14 11115111141:_5 2314514%~11>4014 3 - 114 `NE `FEq\i» mgmsta,(;|e,k
\/`4` . § ‘OF QP\\ML\\IHL\ 1413ow
1145 511415 01 1511/44 . » § 4054143 _*154144

 

FC_\AMJU:P\ 15 1~1011014 QFRM>\> 014 1045 wm)
rPL)S-\SJN\\T TD 'TE\L P\ C\\/ URO& QMAPER 15

 

"TD 'T`HE \40\\10@/~\@1-5 4)\~)3`\"\ QE§ 0¥: SA\O _QDL)P\'\`Z

COME:> 1401/4/ §154214 1~/\\0441455 2314©<5140~\ )

§§ 451`0145& 114 1414 \/4/04)46 R\:Sp€_d;_@4j 34/\0\/\/
§;1`4'\5 Q_DUD\-l; = J4~@0 04411`14€§ .

1 954:{\\_`_:4;\014\12°1'?4§®/\444 4- 1\4 C014\1154;K4 mg
545 QDL)M`\`- 4©\)$§§§1\14/:@£0 4/\>1440\):::1 014 \141/ 1144:514\`4:;
45114<45&

4:1> 00»1~11`45/1<111402 4 045 200 4~1)
21~`_\/,4 U;$L)/\\ l @4:§%/~\41\4`4:/ - /414@ §;14\ 514\05§§4,.
1;_ 11~\ UK\SO_N\ )'RESPEC:\:\/
‘®1454<43¢£01/1¥{§4:;4@1\140€44)5 114- 00,514€1;~41<14:
2143 C014134)5_ 1440 440 11 53§41410`\14 D` 5&4

4 4 QDUPC\\; __4~4'°\€ hid\ CO\)P;E \M AD'§\U QE_CE \\/E.d :\\:

\,4114`14; 1414<;4 1414 4§14&14541:_;4 001)115\1445 1014 A\41
' 2 4 2014 1441 5

.\\¢ ZD\S.

\/4[@\ 5 '4: '41:0 /%4:4:_\014 C‘,4A\M 4)/\11%
F\\\ON( 015/44Q41`5 Cprz:&:p;\:~\&% 405.§14 d.LQ&:-@§® 5

`1'4\_5 Q©MMON. 4/4\1\( 041 444/44£4 15 C41:4>1‘145c_4 n /4<4`.

0&€4€94 €>14. %5\34;51.\/\ ER

 

 

\)/~\ 434 45:540 040&1\4€1\1'4 1>42 MA~4:E.121`A\4 43@€;4”. '2>4@

010415_ \/\1400 4&1\1 \015 oR 436_4\\':_\/&;“;, 140 4:04“3 00 4§0\;\=
05 1\40\<41-: W1 4.-4'\1'0; lr\\4c£_10r4`. 410 \1\\€400£, 004:\": jbj
A.10104405_2 wl RE_41`.(0\1\QF U@M `4: f\~ 3 4:04;&\\/\151\44`) '

00401`01\| 400/ 404/\1=004:4/\ 110\ R\;\\`N\LQL 514 4=4\1=`) 4-:10
L)`4\\\E_03 OQ `4;4;\§_ 1§&`3‘~`\\~¥2_{`4€1\4¥:)'§\) ci\L \)'P:\) ‘4;()
52 "\205_)4_1101< 440040 ”12\2,1‘ 015

44 ~§4`40
/71;1;'/0/ 23 __00 1//\000/%2M F 50 2/
>7/:£\¥~4 "CZD\F/\ \f\‘C/\RCLJ¢\; 75%‘;::1:(§ 676
/00£4\/\\%&§13&€§01\\&`4:/004:\`01\\ 013\ 1\/11`%0021 )Q;{-_
OU\§<>SMQ 3{ M)\4:\j /\u/\/A \/.CML/ ZO//jc/.$ d\%:…
/\15\ 1:)(/5 861 ®

1 S\M/\Ufz ‘/\:4:§:'\\/\ \/\14/\54:4/\€1'°\1¥~\) \/CL WEL\\`\`H~
L

§§4/\01,)404\ 40';\1:;£4: 4§:§./:'€4 wp©§l(f\ 4-; Jd:\:`r\

000§ 04~ 500 wm 10 v\t(f\ 11 EP~ E

A\\a 1000 4:>5)& 300 \)_041`054, ::§305 §§

§§;4` 10400£1:1 §§ …\\/\l 0 ER 4:4@\2 A\ Z§E.§SBOJ{ AUC4
N'LM§ 1235 L) C4lClA0\ ’3

Qor< 910anja v §‘?425<0 §:C/ 25 5 &é‘/

?!;:C/? / 1
;-026:2 112/0441\\/\1 04»55®21 his 4=\/\1‘5 C 050 5,'>:£1"05

041 4_411\1)04(3 0001\4 4:4f\\; Q01)R4: 0 113 v\lb\&l~l 1054

4 0§@1 090 414:\/\0 Q 1)1904; 000 4:1:5
/*;‘4::\@,4:10:> JKL\F\ 5514\©9\:>`§4/\\= QOL)D\`§`_,., A%~\;O \¥`/\\

/4§/ ::¢;/j€)€/ 1/59:0?- 5621450/0//883 /-' 630/

YJI\D\'~\:\A<\\/ 0(3 §§EAA Q/\-_‘> '.' /» C;E //~/éu ll 14<%/~/:/§:`;/€2:1
AM/`;!€£CC\ Z /'3 F QAL)C4
UPON§ CC@§g_l

. @;?)\Q_\LS!QDN\ QQ\J\C\ QMA 1~\0 SDZQ\`QL 4\`0 154 11»1_;`44/\\>214~_:z mb\m `4:\0€5 CDL)A:
4'\¢~25 PRE\/\`oa'>\j ~O4C4£2UQ4 Q2AUC4 \r\& 1®4'Qd2 L)po'r~L 1400

'2.

 

'DAD FBAL)L\ 0@(‘1)1? hl-F'RF 7

E)A\Q,\LY¥R r\’\ \/\1 \deEN\V ‘Q/\ 3 CLO»\/c\\ w.\\l/\

1'>\1111)1131%1> ?/\1 011\/1001j1€05&1§ 001/112101\1

\/\/P’KF%L 101
B`W A §§ j`::11\\11\\§/ 010 1\4/1{1(11`\&\'9!\1,)1 _
&0\;\5 A 0\11\1 GQ£NQE v\/\GL \NA§
A41:\& 11101 1141 11111\\

1\\0 RHE0A1\\J0R\/ Wonl \r\/\\/E ch\l\scg;&d 4:\/\1
‘Z',

MQ,\(§AN ;&Q\. ( 15 \LN\\ 111 1
§ 10 .1‘ 0 §“?1;§61§@0/*%2111§

51(/;1,0@ M‘§Q M/@¢ 11/@ 553 1‘+

111 111/1335 d 111 1 0111111~1
§ 111\ 1050 g)m:»\d§ AR§§ §§~:V\` `1\1 1/:11&%04 1:./4:0:51111 *:\f\/d:
_ V\F_A\zo T:l;/;\R §11\\ 1015 %1¢\/0
‘\L\\Z_ L\L

0 10 M_`:%\:l[& :W\`\
§`“1“§1§1?§11 01…&1§,; 11111”;£§%‘11 @M 5

M0110VT11Q)\@»11\4: 01~<15£:\/\'11§/\:§`1001\111\1\¢/\5

/\1’141 @Ro\/ md 1101@1:&& \1\0\/\/~..
1\/§>:U 01:~ 1=~£1 1014 001141 1

CL\/\N\L § ’|0R0\/11;11)R 11\1£0 fx `%P\EQ/\MJW“»
_ 4=1011&1\`5;;111@£;:11§§:&1¥;§100111£1%£@} ~
wl SQRE_\/FL\/~,l 11\1 ERKQ
001; :51:… 1\11@ _W\ _QA;:§'§® A 1\/11§?€1’3&€§€1\§;;;:10:

1101 1\/11$:1111/1\1@

' §§;@

' 1 ; 101 01411 WL\Q KMOW% 011 b1\1`11\/E§ 151 10 \Q\: wald

 

wm A“d-_@m\m 15 1\111¥.1\\01010 310 11111?~£/$1-_1 \Aw 014 1~/\1`51<1(3?1\
3,€1~.\\: \`/1{\`\:;14\1.-\ ‘©~BQ,`\$ %€f Q\/\\`LS O-Q D&L)Q CO?~L&. 5.`\)`5 "SO&

 

 

`W\2 163-3102 09 3:31\2 %3:13:2`2 /3 2\1/'2(1\2 A\r\
60232>231322 02\2\02\)66\\62 11\ was \‘22€1 .
A§§Q\ISH\\

Q®u\“-d: 1\6 722 ’52\
M\App€:¥\§ \11:0 M`\: A-`3: `3:§13):3:1\0§236 3%3& QFN\\ 332

’@R\;SJT§"L@ 3\:\/\jc: lc:) 1432 _E:L\\)\él`;/\§)l\ `3;’\/\\ 5 N&h.'>§;)\\\\i
\2 \NF \/ER§.EQ u\\ QC 2114 \2 Q 12 \67
§[~3 5_\ \B £!\Q/\> QE_?\£/R\t\\\\ \\<\’\\5 \% l\\C>‘\z ‘3::`\: E Q\R§t

12 1\ \11\\002\\0£_ Q\ 4 \:0 21\'\ wm
6\‘§\)01\ 33:`1`2 2>13;2 %3\:13~,2 ~\: +:\/\2"3%\~312
l41\2\11 313/\2\1-13:\0212 22 \41\ 2\11 623 129§01/\\

\/\/`f\-§ UB¥\\EOU§J.

3 M1Q\2 w\\~\r\. 413'\2 \4632216; 320 i1L6uQ\:§1 123;\011 h\/

11\0\£[\21 m 22\\…22 011 \421&3:

§\;\132 11`\ R2\\2Q \@2)‘:

0\`1\ /\2 14216:,11\
&2\/\/§26 < 11 2310/:::26W
32NJ2 r\/\\§`n\\cb \2.’3111`.\:»°~

:: 136::3\ 1W `¥:i§ 3:`\233&)01\2 1122111110\2 1201 13d
§1216\`§1@3: \`Q. 3©\)22 01\26?¢@)2 1 C01)_D6:

315 \Q/\»S 3\:3:94?\)3:)\/` \A€§L \\§;\\;IK 011 %&M//ER ;LL;QU§

'\/\`l`_\/\( O'@ o l/ A-/Z MA'{

0 //050¢@ 24 O °(‘9 61012\20/\0\¥;
31322 1322)11\2\{ § 902 323/\2% 321322 612

S§®Hm 222 €§_;:;‘:*:d :@§::;“§§i:

tl\§g2 09 ~\=\/\\‘5 ®2022 612

~W\E %\:1‘3\:2 \/2\1 %{32§`© 921§ 2\62;\51:\`:\.6

3 L\ \ \ \1
Djd)\ 12 0 30 3:3¢\20 211 11:;1§\`®\§: 3~01\%:3¢'\

\`L 3

. `\`V\=f" \2\L.Q0 Q0232 C2\\\4 6 \1\ 910£
621 \\2\€235 ,1;3/\\11 1\112< 335'02 2);{® 21123\35
03 2%\:1\;\1 ?20_@\\1»\ 2;\\6:3 §mwb&g§@%
… EP\\\'Q\\.2633 \1\3:21'1]322{:1 41`01& 0@

 

 

5> \090? 00 0\/\1 0031/\1?0 11130\0`06[ Q@om 0\/\1‘~‘\~0

__\1` 10\0\QE.`

0/010100\; \05 \010\00\/0010 00 10 14qu0

|101 011

010 190 iii …~QRDM 01\\/0§\§ §~\:AMC§'>U¢\H:
§01 \00&11'4\&3>005003101`1001\11 10-
43 100005005 \101111.

0101`\\10 §§\1.10&>§§,01}¢
1:001 309 OPA~LC§ \00/\0¥\ 1 13110000101:10\01-
`F_ 10€,1
1101 300/ 0\/\1 10011§00\100100103 13
000\13>\1\/11010 \/\11\_10 A 30101\’\301.\\1001 10 1311010}

\/\1010\/011\0\ 1006 \\\\310_10§`0 10\ \'1\( [\1\4`()§:\;1=\:5§\: §RQA§M/\

\~/\\3101001310 0
03\[; R§:§ 30\1 130110031 09 610'0(1`10\ ’3011`1-@
001 00 100 00103§ 0\/\1001`3 QRA0YM\
NSQ\UL 0001331 0\0w0 00 00~

\/\11'\\ \00
01st FOR :\f\i /00\)10310010\ 010 0103, 433 00011
§:001§§§1:3 101@©€\:§§. 0§::: 100 01\’\1\1:0\§ §1~;00;1£;1
300/10 0 uc\’u;§: §:\/\100 'Z\>.SJ\
Q`T\LC\"<:\§Q:/f§&:& ;33:0§301 0 \rt\£3\©§(:1\/100 ~
131 1010 110 00 011/011 11

001 1\»0_1:00 00\0 010010_3\:@»1°~0\<
Z.Q.\%\;_ \\\\ v01_10R5

401::\`3%) QO\)\ 350 _

11 b1 1 111
151 ”D'P\\` ')\ 03\ ’\U\f\;EN b\\‘Ql/\ Ql/\A;§ ~ 0 -
1510 §§ 1101§ 0§01`“£§11 C"' m:“`“`"

z 30 9&00[1`10\ A;X/\ig \“§ th(iw_‘ 00 ©0§:§"0£12)6010"

 

 

§LL\Q \
§i;:\z;\)r\\l$\ii& ?EN'\:RL>¢>£\ OS\\/?;\: Qi:;i A,lp\ oil `i:if:§
Qg¥'¢ md S£A&Mcm¥.§ \/\mw\\ '

S;A\\E(i ¥\<\f\l§ \§\W\ CiA\( 09 ©(Soifb&)?i§\§`;

    

§ \=vm~x§ T\/ \)gilsizllor~/\ l
`FDQJ

' to
Cg\€w€~i:s ` i:z.§§§\§v%
0\
c\»\¢~r&%\r[iw&§q T\(~ 7‘<7¢07