Court Opinion

ID: 4044282
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:34:00.851918+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:20:26.575649
License: Public Domain

, 1 _ k MO~(A)*L¢>$,O£L{-Ol-E 83 l§§w_d/

D. \/QIH'L'Q/O C>'c;1 HF!*C»/é (l-O? §§ 7/5’_)<¢%$ CQ”/Qé Ooc Cr’[M»'RE€E“YWN,§¢/,Jré
, ‘ ’ _ , @] , CouRToFcR\M\NALAPPEALS
\5.0_\ °TE.£ n€§pa,oAA/o¥ \/;‘ol¢zM Ar%.‘c,(; -l(.O? ,55¢{40,0 (é) 0£ ék§ '7?,¢%5 §01€3 M§C_»"M,~AM/ gotgdm£
b~,( Q~Al(i.)/g -{~o p`o\/iclé A: C¢/)o~( og` ~HAZ lily/lawhch L.Jr'»@ e§l uqu q;m_gl A,Nyl- %Mgr£/é&él¢
A»AL A C:rl-.`£ic»~¢e ;r@@l~',`/)( we Mé afo,o wt\.‘cl/L HM»{' .@:A)J;,¢,g owe m~A<~,€_é g-(ok é¢<.:$ C'o»¢~é
01 cr:»<».',»{ wis w;ku;.> 'J(L¢_e kyne ,o.»asc,c~;low b\( 1419 .M>¢Q w/@@§B”$&@©Y/& e§}g;eb(a A‘m.:
£r<>w\ .f’lk$ <£M'E 00 which H».£ atom/wedra w€ré ')’¢£~Zué.$¢éo( $oéu; \/-m,ogm,‘~/{,fr +Z<-' $mlos Mz#&¢l 941 l/%/g¢>//¢»¢A'<_)o per b\/m¢ QS~ /{¢¢¢Ms dwym>, mm MSW’S#' Ql€&
"W& Cc’r¢-wa*& /f¢"'¢"~~jg 1415 446 _.¢/>Q~> winch %LL~L ,Cw¢é.v/q lowe vwag L,( EV:/,.,L`,,- {:O
M§_CJLQLALLMSM:AJ___.E)BW¢©L dlérk,.l>c;thiL 400/0(1{, /J,.S, /Po&l-vz)_SQ/m"¢c M,&.'(;OQ
1541/er ow&édl 03/ £4/ £015, pamth iv Al~A‘c/é £1\07 sec¥(oo (3)@ 09 ghi Cagé Df. C,,,MM/
?.".7€€<90|"¢5 - 755 ulch /4'@¢01'/%{5 Cq€l"£ D£ HA,.:/ yt\po~./F/ lé#él’ ik('é /(,H_,?c&_gcj. ¢h¢,'g éo 143 éxh;bl¥.
u)""¥~¢ W'S ~3'#9@°\70<>»"'¢3"2 511 ’ré€é)'é,ac,a hiram for M/ pur~r-e;~§:$. ` '
303 l'-).s is C(ém“ P\-<>M Re/.»Lw'z /E#er, /?e/»éw A,,,,<‘b rés,@.;cé¢u(lq pul- Qes/ov@€e,.)é cm ,Joé.'cé
‘Hlm+ ’Ré{wl~\n" SSE:k,$ {’{M`; é/FMSMH")\:( el 'A= CO,Q\( _a£~ I@W/.'£\A»H<>/O iv\,* wfdl ¢)¢c` #'?]9{5|1'$ €OI}F¢)_S,
A~ w,\>s>»oaa' @(éd, n~¢l vt ¢5¢~¢-/'£"0¢/1»¢5 -V.:’czéhq_g £Lw; A.ML¢' 0/0¢,,3 va'c,ZL -H¢mL c;/\)d.',;/j owes
mac/15b l'o U¢é Co.>\~!»o/\’ <1\~;.~»:~1+¢| AHoé/+/s 4,\)¢! %'|¢mlr sack r’é<;omL lmra requireo@ b.{ 1313

eoano£ Cm'm{/\?n( /Lf ara/s k /A<>+L o/O HA£ /)?é/A¢m~`§ ¢`J,-,>/ §§ /g,¢y,gére$ Co,yd_§ ,Z‘,/,,HZD,,
hrs gv,o.>' _Né(l L£¢/v»\)@[v¥m\ z'éczo,`r»ém.z~} ,.o»~ ol¢>(¢’j.»r{q‘o,o .;MPO‘§O»G( v 90 hug _ -TEM§,
,@od.€ ma admi,\)»¢/ ?¢’vcéoLJ/'é. 270 GO,O(')'A~S(» 40 ”F.:~[wlo¢"$ 5($0,.£, ES/QUM{ _$.whp[d(
le told/g me '//\;)€r£§ wé sep Cl'¢'m.'/\M'/ ?,~ac,écl)dl'£ }9¢4`;,~‘;/5 [(,07 53¢;{,'9,`)@)&

c‘¢~)\lé<(, “."o devva 1
is A¢L.w_] L,¢, b/~=@L PWM, re,~)¢L has M‘¢>o-Q».'lc& Jco ~wCs‘:<>m) ?3€(.41~01~ 1145 profess/sod ruon

ComMo/o C.~~{ we~.'leé,\) r'é§(ao/Osé bn l'\;§ Cgrr&$/povdéd@é v><’,\')¢i ' 065/§

5.05 l/»b-!':¢/c' Il.o’z 53@4“.0,0 ('3)§¢) c(,:vm/ bml»és %MM “(I) il the + Hm§n£ vm; ._00 \-% é<) ¢/e_c{- L,J!Mi,o HA,S vt/(ow€¢( J(O &A\{s 6ber c’.o/u$/~,'¢£u,lg 8‘0¢1<. ¢A.» E;A)¢.L.‘,)_<}
723/ks Co<{.-Z 641 &~/M;uw/ R/W,é@l.)/'§ A¢-Az/~" //.07 S.Zc (,S} (c} zas/»a»\)¢l£~/ is I,J %`v/m¢.'o,\)

oil 345 )omc£a@)r'£,, M"AJ:KzL/'lucl o@,+¢é.$, wall £:{Au_$ 646 L/+w"e£ {’L¢-'$ 51¢141¢6.-

D. fP\-.A\{a.~ CQ- Zel;éqc ' I\/

w\§e€£m€c'_. ?£ém;s.i$ C:ms;ro€/zé@, ?s/&¢@,» .» f /'1' ~ f ' 6 \a } ,M> se
)'é$féc>/-W/\/ regoé%'t¢ 14 (`;A)JZ.'A/j 'bém{' r£§¢w&.;w£ abel A)Q{~ ¢¢wd.$m,‘/¢ dow/mink 117 +l¢.-S €ovr/-r/
£_‘,\-;M:A/»+( -'~»{,e» w£+L\;A> r~é»e§.o/\mlq(e lime leger %LL.§ ,Z.m[€ -M¢§{ wér`é Vé¢guc’£¢&-,O A~@( Mrw?l'"
]?¢5(¢,/~9{~ L>¢-g¢;y£d- -‘H/tz`$ 111"`?‘4(¢'0/\] 110 HOO¢Q c\M‘H/L W lA,\/\=S 501£5{&101£"»1~//¢/"'f/`¢§¢/'h`/l>'(,é Yé/'HLO"_
zole F¢r we O.*¢Dcz~ a@i¢'é¢L.’A)/g Fé@»welé~)‘ le ¢\L)-AN$¢M)/v£ CYL( mg )@Ha/’GM’QA] #/ /7~/"
93 ]!/170.$;95 dc¢?aq§, ¢/L~¢/ A,Q¢SWJ'¢’ D“/.ici, 4/4~(,@ A' C-S)`A'»£"c'.rt'é' /`S@'A"Mf] `}Lb'§ alw/L£ pfo/g
wLp.~clL +LM{- £~~J;Ay howe m¢).O€`-”.. fo 451/w C.>m~»¢ of Cr;m:»/.+/ prEn/é vaca OL'c-.£c/Ec? L`/\>v
FL~L‘é 1607 Séc¢/pu (3} (c) o£ ?%§ 7§¢»&5 dade 941 C'¢"'M,'Am{ ?z’oaJr/m':` bmw/l PcS L’..=W&$A;J

iu Ké(w{o¢'fs /é'r¢ =" 'C;/)‘L"_é"% (I)

l/’\'Y

Y$e,<)éa¢€,lk( SDlomz%ée¢C

/_ “|CFSF/>q'/`
'/ adr.'¢k '"D M<)£va
"D.\¢k amici op'.+

l(»€§/ S= PTM. 55£.5
Cc>{orw¢céo Cl"\\ T;~ 735/2

@L@@%M@M
’/vb K. 7/9/,20¢5’

EXHIBIT “I”

' ' » \_'v

 

. , , 1525/15
777/562 2677/5»155721 5322/3 025.55' 2 217 _2.<2"5_2556 /""2'§;/ 25 257 1//§// 5 77 /al.£§?

22/'5~.3{ ji;;;;, w/£/"a:’.': 3533(7/¢, 53 /‘\//f»' wl
77 3 3/. /.»‘212¢ day-15 aaa 7/(2%3{7777¢€4/’ MMM.¢ M.¢JM /73/5/%3 ac‘Z'¢L<) l/ .

522 292 aaa 536 faa/2555 253 /azz¢él_ // a 7 2/ 3553 63:5326 56522,2/

9722 6532-26 box Mw&l.l 322 2553 2253 /1/2232/5‘,3 4332 //.5! ajax/2103
6626¢ 562/076 654 26 67262`55}26/ wear/556 303 /2`327 5 637@6/423& 4 522 j
25[ 5313 @/52`/55’/7 24 ,3235`32 /4,5/,5 254 67 2553/f 2 wahl/563 -
336 joa/ama 55 6’5/7¢/ 363 dp/ cal/255 /Lcc:@j a//ué 507 /,55523 332 //.32,
W’v"lf/F( MA -»” pad 5 M(/ M 00&5;;51)£ M/hé(h, Z{(cq/
’SH\///A ,ét/M /I>Y/W»¢£ ,5" .Z&.L C#Wal7¢l cwaa¢f/A 430th »¢¢/5?420¢/(,»
zhe . 66 /awlwbaal 3 hal 425/3 0/22'3655<, away/twa ,: " ‘_
m 432 2553 4355&2 6 539325)13537.. aaa/2266 226-235 232/35 72~ 313 'y '
daihaa tr 251 233 mzz&~¢&, //. 297 333@55375) 533 daw3 A/a'ah£~c ' ., §
M¢¢.T: 5 3/ 333 05 W»¢¢/L 47 NFM( /3<73\.€ z‘ /Zé’gwa¢l§ 63 673/3 '
1iv ¢6/.3232/5‘2756 25 533/513 f 3/435253_ C/Vmo 553 5515./ mma/537 " 7
`Z¢fl,L wm Mama /haw M'327 220 @’2/33'6/3 355/3653 614/11 2505/33 »0€_»-
l E/"`U}Z:Y)££ 3/L 353 jaw/3 225 M CJwaf¢, 1 dwwa7.f.~
/5262¢37? wide llo? M /2'32@¢<)56,315_}.¢4/»@€ gmc ‘ 62 "
,5’5 fwaala»zl@@& Maaar,¢ 2553/mb ¢/323552¢ 772/3 jaw/3

 
   
  

  

   

  

   

      
 
 

;//3 233/1339 /77(93

kdi/4
757 7552/

/55/ 32 223/3 352-35
CDa'UJU 639

??5/.3 2