Court Opinion

ID: 4064650
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 21:33:24.526817+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:49.042968
License: Public Domain

-\c\o\ A/dxH-Q03<\X
                    yr           I
                                              ^ed,n
                                         The Court of Ap
^!SEaDppCK
  Sixth District
                 7k Court C^ a^H
                              I»
                                            Sixth Dlstri,
                                            nrp 1 R 5

                          f»              Texarkana, T(
d2&W»' ^^/^T)C                           DebraK.Autre,

                   (kppelh
                Pro 5q cfA (Zpfill&rth
                  &W (Xllef\ £Ua

                                                            Ji»

                                                                  Ca
 Zd^kf of Parh) Mt!hr\Sil .     '   ~~ ~ 3
  X/\c/^ c9    tSS^M 7^,m^\(Z00b)o.iX7 ^ ^Jl

JfeTv, w cj tL       ''^J ^   A c^A 7^7 ^      . f?
^ 1                      J4n,ie^n h of ~hhp mW

/Oyecn /e/V ^C, k/< k^J 6ee/) f^lkx i\ HAakn', U /h our Y 4eAvK sh kj fa* ^Jc «* after ^rM omfar m«'7br *£

seweh cluffps^ ,/hJ^yyi ^ uas ^S/ ^Yj: u2t fac/M
KmJi^U ^ Vu XU L 7^,7y on /y ^                   y

^-^ ^^^ &^ «f>p cT^rttir
 &f fh Mm\ M^^SjlP-S
a^ ?uck r>i6 gJ coJd nJ ftoUor fad />. ^/ ^ ^
/v^J 6*0/ it) /7Mcv* ,\ eMto*1~
•fe /fv/f .a ^   Jrs tax fy ^-f^rJ /Y ™ di4 W « jW«y

bad h ^\uvx^ Kfft ^ oa/v fej X ^ ^ ^°^ y7/r >
dm %kr aJl \«)o«/y 90^M «»y f^s^p K^
/W* aJ /hV4 defreXeJ a-J/h^J U* UcJ c®^* in> <^<*< d

Thvhy^) of 9013. XAJ %*K*/

AV liY oU M^if, LU M* c Aft M jo*, /f ^
/o^| ^fcf Sudo-f (A J /yiQA*yf/y\y o~ff dtySf fa &? M
fe/) c/a^,( rA» ^ Com 0^/ aJ/h^fS^j olJU^aJ
fa fa kwXjko **) a/jo ** h U !A r^ ^^Zi^M
  / ^i -r A/ rental ft* ^^ ^U X ™ T^
•flW,7 W O^m/C Several W-VI//f,A*f ,   >Y , n ' /    ^,,
/L &<£ aJ 7 ^       s/^ /^ A^t ^ only us«> 1 etMy
UvV,\ 5^m fLf /horniWS)** ^ #0* Cwvecs^ w
•fc wot Mt ^W foAx Uft ^-k J/^/r%fr
T ^ //J A-«r fiiV 1dd ta" /W ^V ?WS a shoes' c^J
^  6A ojt*   «{7r-p, Yk *"> V^ oJ
X l&) o/\ ^v ^Y

fcwv^, £•*+ &ww »r i'i^y^y .        .         u-/ iu-

^Vr £*# / " fr7?} ^>^v *^
^> .j iu ^ /*w ?^ ^ i cjj * «Kf f m

idic -fr^l,Me(l -1 cIJaJ yii <¥>4 }i Ua) <\ 0M yjed
 A&AC/V& /7?y 0u/A Uuyer CcllroJ-pd /HQ, Ir UsA) /^
d\z /iPuy*^o 0/ £0/ 7^xa) 
%d W* fk d,a\ flU fry ^£, ^; /*„,£ *^ «#"«.*-.
OvA J'hyl €^rcKf\5J L)k*Jf /%Aj/^ A<*n /ms i*,j$ ?h
ndizl ad K\h r\*r;7U ^A iWi ^ ^               &&?s)9*r
/vo ddtAjz wer? &/A* M-edordy i*s?t/KW *r-t t~f+«w/&'

^ M,.7|7 /U «,t /*A/Xi "<-»*,.* ^ t l
^W Ar.ijfj W W « « y»-) 7/ ^2X
** £r Kff7 ^1^. r*^ *r "fi°Z * *

wnJtl not bit/' a<^f^\ U «, w Mr H» ^       dy),  oa 5/7^^ /?y*0. At/ ^V^C- />y ftfo7
hu\ur did Aoi k/di fa r\dp ** M Vf It /7\y (faytf, 7^
W,,0/« /JioaK ^>V 7^ /W^ 7 W « *"*&« <*"^
-fe /nvj7 /*«W^fVk< 6v7T /ty*V a^/w# A^ ^^
Ulf fa dojj A«M »irJ tJTt-k Ay 3<,if Lt titles & & 1 ^J/^ fr« »<**r

Us ww™ ^;aa, ^,ta« ju^ ^ ^                                   ^y
fr^l also WW >N toi^^tfkM * ye* ***"-"1

"1 CojJl A*v*r A.M- &y t^*J or trt/Ml* ^Y . Y j,

«v?ai c^Ww , *P > y°
-Hf Cm t,dw ,f Q/f ^ /,b ao/;^w ^ °dy ^Coi^^
Of Aj> N> (ilr OAly cokji £r AO Cow^y? g//oi*s*/A fa &s^
rW/WT a\ti a)^ ry ii Ay J/x^ 0^ A5^/ /10, T&dh
  l)fTNA\ Aval /IvO CT(W^
fKj kjft or fad), &^tC /H c\rd Ay A-/X? *s)ts>J Att/y

?Ao U^ mtU i 5W). W *V /** <^^~JJ**> *-*

"fU cA//K/) or )t/;f M tA«wa ySr A^^jL i~erJ>J A«^ ^»«-*\ ^ -S^<_.
•£/K If h&v ]H* /K*rcUf tJich 1U OA/ ^/Z
MO tyi\ a&iJ AA< sUdde *.M+pr. hdh fk ^M hJtf ^^y^v^^
H^i od 5^l^^ Ay O^iJM, k^r ASU*u>i fLt- y0^ eojdf* A .
fk (djeOy 1iAcl<0> erf fr Ay tiK*l( r\s>Wi^ ^ a) **"r^ ^^
W\t^PL r+ i^o »w< o^ ix 3dr ith*cJ Uf- b ?*"!$*$}
hd^ 4i? n,vcdrt 5w 1*^ ff*A ay KiNA ~ hf ^H

Slo^ty */ Ae^( ^ ^"fe/j /H<5;^, / Cw»J) frt^ fa- -fc^fa t PitU.5 (rf
 (/> fayiiUr *f- ^7 da^hlos) hHkdy fcri^) ^j IdMyj t?&y
fU /Wifof, Ck[\ k&) Aj, fa rw 71 P*d 40 cX^ //» *-«> ^%)
£<-e/ jfe^ Crsofhr fh<^\ piir aP /«&) + 3/***&>, /TkJtcyj &*r\
Mr por^'y ©A Ay birHJo.^ 0c ^ nv,/^. p-al'ky AM W-i^- frovj
of rhi> sh ^ d ko^ /W j wwr&j c^J aW UrJ z /W
 Pd Ay -fcv^'Xy 7~h k-ed j^ry k^o/k^a S*rd $a r.i/, a-f%s
\U \c\o\\~l ^u/ \\ 5k SjM ^
ftlW hrx\ (aJWI A-eK/ k ,i SO fit ;W oJy >/ /*y /^W
rr^TTA^ %r?J( fa folk 5^^A/ py ^jj ^fp/hy foiu^,

4a ^ ilz6 dd °7>aV ty V *** ^
l*rr *v£ iS&ZX'JS ir H ^y M/L f»y
TUV     P* cd ^fitt*
 ^'v 7 vU . j d^
                         fafrfi'Vl*        fa**
                  h^ tfA ^ }/eJr k **J AV nU
°^ sr- ^ saris** jsu) *&** ti*,ujuz

 fir AU ^f^ M I ^dTkXt^t Zdt?
  dr\ Grs^J fp 5c^ 7 L^) dyr*Sw
fuAV W) (V jV^^/N ^ faP'(f Of foworJ 6*U /ocAj^f
ir aAa3 kr^l^M /^*y ^ ^                 7 ^^^ /Vy^ ^ ^f
AvV \Jhd \r4 hlkd «k/ /K o^r" ^/Vl} ^A'/? 7 t^U o/\
Suicidt tew-c. I A,W/r 7 ^M>/ /v> X^ r7'V 7 ^ 77,^ ^ e^/
7 >e^ 7/d Aw ^ AC'/f Ay ^^ mjt /h^ fcd) -Qwr TVj^av
"X CfrW A«^V/p A* /^, 7 ca ;o 5^ Ay t^^-yor kJ P^
/\daJ o7 AA^ X (^) /uA & Jf r\ Ja,7/ JAvc; ^3<-7*£
X /Virer o/iw 5<^7 Or^ ftK cW> U^ d*/re»ed r%r^ ^ AjV/yAw
/a^*t *)*.V> jyltk fh-? %jLf-xyf>(Oho kXm 7 pk^/j^Pry
fa) Al\vcfaf{ X PiJ Afi tdeq 7 U^k) joh\ 7) ^ 7/4/ <=^^ ^7^|
7 d W^ AWy^ /A? b*y /?fa 'Z?cv(t^fl/'X
d^r\\ fo\ /c.r( aW A^ oa^ ^ «r /5^ o^r- fty aw/V-/">i -/^ O^ ^

 fU*l Thfa M U Avw fro^ 6v/y/ ljQ.(l Ay ddj odd**, ^^
 1 7 >A /y 'kt ^; 7 j7^ ^oV ^ kil Iteyb
 M fKi [c^ UU (\/b/ 7b Ao/A.1^ ^j yom U^A-P rx^p
Ajtfolt.^fa djrii) fU lrtV\tcUyJ Mr J/Vy fc>^ iU folk* fo C. Ae^
my dsri) fa\rl^kb,h Usv hr hdp f% PA dtysw/hy tjJJ* f*»M)'JL
Ta_/ a/7^ Ar,V I, ?/« /5 < dT -fy -fU f£>P, iU ^k) oa ^ ^a^
 iAhldhf\xoA s«d sU u*ft U 7 oP> A^ &r * yk^jt,
 O<\ C7fajd) fbr f\ C&xdyK bkok Ai^fc) )en)J f^k, Mq O^y
pfce of M*a,y Sh 7v>* 7b kll fU GofS,& M> #* My
Qyorytt^ e/M 5^ 5t^j ^IW /V jtfy -^ y^ apif&J-fa/S{^
PA 1o fa a^ prM cij&^A $Mn A)i^ CI/iQ ^/UOA fa fc*J
fU OA (*k\ U^irK jj(/ess*cl sewrd •&*$ d^ PU fatal,
ahu fo*d) or X£**rib> h H> jdy *r j^s} fk &/> on Ay
 fcexrj- faUy o/ cut* I earthy i» ft> J~ry< 2 *W/*7A?;/
typ lb fao* /m/Kii-y brfa fit fafJ 7 ^J> <"> P^> f%*fpty*
df iU fk ^3 $0 /» *»*y
fa Lvi gfcJ^r ir&\ df yd  fJilK^^k A^ of JU oiUrtjfart fir/^Arsot/Or
e^{\ Ofkr Avy /We/*:, ^ j,^^ fc^ j^ U^d 7&r fO
50Av« ^A) ^d 5^ >/ Ljjily AO /yU/4/7 aA^/'r ^^/, j^ ^/
 H^      U^ J*W5 kilod fur hdJ c^ asff^T ib rt\*Hj H h>o£
  fo<*q ju^fok A* Ssv^J h fa fad^fa a LkiUp
yoey ^ #/( Joa? drj) ynr 3 ^0 y^^ a <; /**a a^^Jj/ ^V;*
/vorei i A*$ ^^ cfr /f) tL*;L,m crin\,UI record/ h ouA/
\nrJi hlhf ,K A6 A*A,/rfU 7$r *J^> A Ofay fPf/*^fv 0/-
fUe. W^ if ;oA aJW X/M/ft^^>^
H- *U H^7^ ^ «^ *r1r1"M Vy, 7 ^fay
^ tJ (U, or ^^ ^ W*fc W *"*- -^/
m^ \M j*f irW As ^ or KsA 2 ^J^«

^ * ey -y*>,*-«,* ma, %r$ur;ss

k » aw ^f f^S i a -rLnfafar- tkJ&*"
rMUdwi a r/owv j0/6r r^y *> 77/ 7/ir. / .                   y? -r
A^gI ft, ^ X W y0^ ^a ** # '7y)A,^ x ^3 ^ *y
/kj (^A>M^ ^ ^7 *"•"*'•
        Ta <0m «J 7 o4/ \ ffUk Ph j^y q^ff c/JrJ&J
•ffal %} Lam Ai9 X^ ^r &7^.\v U/O pfwfa^d/ Pfay jhyrf
^ AJ X> 5rW /W ^lfak)^dor ^f^OAa^A^A^
 ^4|( -f^y Uv^jW T^y fo/y Aw >^f AK ^y^'/OUo* *^
 ^ ^Aiioe, ^L?ima $~f oleojJU to 5f7? /K» ji* ^ ALp flA 4&J far.
?¥- \^               /01XA5 PmM for kjk^

 Tffdr d~ AAi 7A«r^ fgfey^A Acr/*\ fet^xJ fo Ao7^d<^^\r'> r»^
fa L* c, Ac* UJ 4y «• &S M* ^ X«Uc i> <* ku>[ A»M \ &>rn>SA Cx^iyXA
 Kcrl A/^ **s 5W 7«9 «J Oo jU U MA
6 Wo* *ac/ 1W ta /U kblbknf dvnWy #05/ 7W ***#
kdzcQ iM MKjrd*C AU f /Ma /LaA c^o /a^ ** «/&>, Gpp^/lcJj
(bCc-d &\kf\ /LaA k/A.5 l^yQ<\\jerdL r Ur fllvnUr, Gpfdfa*
ty\W c< pfcc, of ^i/i/f lb -/A*  -JAq ^f^
 ^XAKyd, cX-PV oaL )dAy fafol -for A*vrAsb<\] crJ Pe-lvwd ^ isrdhf p^A
&5H**i Oppdcrh p^0U*^ «X f^OrtrWy-'tiW y^y ^
T^^y (kfk of fr^J !^,V, /r,W *J^ •&* of $$/°00>
1-Pdh leu/ s^ yo^  aj/A 7^ /M /^a 5p/J"i»n. When*?
fatVx tdli $>f VA^djwtt nd Wbrtel Ar e^dm* &' **, ^
 f?0 X ^ Wt<\ ^oJ «J-f U(^df fry Crt*,\J fVCjro/
(J, dm*) of )4A7 W/ZyiJ' pfdwry
d^A W 7^ ^ ; ^                     ^ ^^/ Sow*k("\ifa
Z** X./X ^ ^ X >V ^/'A f« X^,5 A^^
tft^fh * uSeA ^r< S k^ k^JA^
                                       ddvAdi&Adj rf\AJA j® AanffCj
          Y«. *>(*) jyty  ^j^y *>h  yap /W//M,
                                tefo pap  /t/j/icZ, iir$0f ^fa -&&,
 M lop^dyip-t lO^f dwry j,y ^/;W4, ay ^ifnClk ^J fi^fa
o£ 5UM i> SJ*k P*Xto/{ ir f( fiUtr r /£U Hj> j^y pastedZj/Jtf
afa) -k f« hUt &$ X^-TX pLk &P tk Jh,Ye A kr(&«>M
ntcK U,U record &r/j is sl^ Omdh cddreV^d.SeiMMy^w
dUfy yn MherJkf\ fad Ufal) retard feli i) && d> a**'
W reJ ,a  o^>h * <*ff*%j ™/°7?y,
fn/mn -h 2Ccl r*1es, Olso m(P&jfti recJo-fy ofo (#«?*/**/
ay dlx> *l (M%/,to) Oh onk (Uk 'W r*** ,\ tsJJw -/oW 36.27
TW 6Je af Cn'^A Prx>i?lcQ 7iU r^k^d) all fommuy^h Aifr Y

oV^iofwx *» A.W' fU/» "ft**!,

&> FooitofaMM Git I fd.Kofl fff/Mi*'d) 1°. 5>^ 7 7\dlMfhdM^

fc §4nAM_h p^JAMT+CrMfo™^

MJtfrt' V t7"^^iX7Tia^
Ui) £*» Aj MtUr-r^/i^ Oub fof-b'ltff/Kf
^^L^l^fUy-u /nrxaUf.T uk« M' yy
XWm At a>M To or c4/ /W« *>•«> y^yi>y
M -few fM- &-5U. u*.\ cU fa* *tl m /**<**

U tidjo ft&W^ al sW'7r 7^7/ y
X/ry 1*(U- />WK %«-V //<&v «jU^ ,7 ^ *'7
C e/^rAv ^ M ^ df ^A,k7 ctpiyf***,

?iW i,'«Uvw7_M. fwto* «*** ^^ »
^o,oyi fjf              An^^f g^tA fl^Vfl^

Add jV I ,     ?,7'°^   7^ S*AV 7^ e&W«*vft r$

we4 ^ A/'r,//'d^ A^7f,k Ay ^^y M iP rhy yy, fJ^f
                                             -ddl>A Ay
                                                    /
Altarta7<^ rtU/fU tidd Af *f. ho d W'^AatlA
tX*f LfhwJ i\ AA /W^a, f/^ /Vr* / /~*o <^ yf^ hf*lf
/vtar AtaX Tkto* #7 ffir.foh Ud ^f^f°s)fw
iffh  ^J1
&ta
/)V?V Wf^ Ay /n\ I *^-> 4 W#c/ cd fA fery>f tir X\
 ^ta 7 feAvw Aj Ioa/W ^ ta *ta hA£tl a//hi)y\or^
oaoy -[<\                 Prayer of Hdhf

  ^ta *X ^A-feAcu ^Aak ^ A< /Wta, 7 Ata /A) ew~
 C&vAyk ^ i tai aAtata 7r,vl <*ta pkyd^- w>
            £/Wtal- fray5 ^w &^f *7/( Pbnr#*d ft***«d ta
&W k a>e#ta(90^lX cJ #A*ta A) 6w &~ °y
/Vet/ tavl

                                ffinApC A/
     "X c/W ta _/«u/ ta^3 fro^d-ed tae ^v^ 7^
 ^XWy of u< itoss yTif^Zh a;x( yta^ A efkor /W/V5 krfch pf^p^rJ P>y ft*rt aUrfUy
"X aho (s>4 c\Ao. pnM 6y ,WA?s ^ l0jjUlfA*?,
SiVf 1 OA/y Al*7 ^ ^/f oX AoaAAs A' /Wa ta> <<*l*f
pkck X\J&5 Ok \o*fff&c -peory is /?a/v\ X 0&>/ ta ta/ X
CoJd ?fa< Avy (^^ oto^V M J X ^7 Aie/ yO^p
3Morh a, fcf 0 7 Wtal cU4 tax M*^' "taj*
^ cU(W <3 u/M.<> kfof /AT <#4[^ ^r-fX ^ ^ ^ ^y ^T^r/My
(\ ^A\ci4k)y\rjnfi -fa ^ytaoXAeh*^ I A/i fdl
                                      TAi/nad* oA 7~0(d~7j

                    •'a   ;'

                               i >v