Court Opinion

ID: 5417970
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-01-08 16:21:50.709195+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:31:06.345324
License: Public Domain

Martin, J.
Defendant Hodgson on or about June fifth obtained an order granting his motion for judgment on the pleadings dismissing the complaint, and plaintiff moves that judgment of dismissal, pursuant to the order, be entered by the defendant or by the clerk at the instance of the plaintiff. . Defendant moves that the service of plaintiff’s notice of motion be set aside on the ground that because of plaintiff’s default in payment of the costs imposed by the order all plaintiff’s proceedings are stayed by the statute. Civil Practice Act, § 1520. As plaintiff’s motion is concededly but a step in an attempt to review the order, I think he has brought himself within the exception specified in the act, and defendant’s motion to set aside is denied. Although plaintiff could have appealed from the order dismissing the complaint he did not take advantage of that privilege, and defendant urges that plaintiff’s motion is solely for the purpose of enlarging his time to appeal and should, therefore, be denied. In Mitchell v. Dunmore Realty Co., 135 App. Div. 583, it is held that a party may appeal from a judgment granted on the pleadings or from an order granting such judgment, or he may appeal from such judgment and include in the appeal the order for the judgment. Although in a case, as here, where the order dismisses the complaint, neither party may deem it necessary to enter formal judgment, as under our forms of procedure an action is determined by judgment, it seems to me that the unsuccessful party upon the default of the other party in that regard should be permitted to enter final judgment, thus completing the formal record of the action in the trial court. Wilson v. Simpson, 84 N. Y. 674. Defendant’s motion to vacate denied. Plaintiff’s motion granted to the extent of directing that unless final judgment be entered by defendant within ten days such judgment may be entered by plaintiff.
Ordered accordingly.