Court Opinion

ID: 2808238
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2015-06-15 14:12:10.653117+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T11:27:50.538781
License: Public Domain

This memorandum opinion was not selected for publication in the New Mexico Appellate Reports.
     Please see Rule 12-405 NMRA for restrictions on the citation of unpublished memorandum
     opinions.   Please also note that this electronic memorandum opinion may contain
     computer-generated errors or other deviations from the official paper version filed by the Court of
     Appeals and does not include the filing date.

 1         IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF NEW MEXICO

 2 STATE OF NEW MEXICO,

 3          Plaintiff-Appellee,

 4 v.                                                     No. 33,119

 5 MARK MARTINEZ-THORMAN,

 6          Defendant-Appellant.

 7 APPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF BERNALILLO COUNTY
 8 Stan Whitaker, District Judge

 9 Hector H. Balderas, Attorney General
10 Margaret McLean, Assistant Attorney General
11 Santa Fe, NM

12 for Appellee

13 Jorge A. Alvarado, Chief Public Defender
14 Steven J. Forsberg, Assistant Appellate Defender
15 Albuquerque, NM

16 for Appellant

17                                 MEMORANDUM OPINION

18 ZAMORA, Judge.

19   {1}    Defendant appeals from the district court’s judgment and sentence convicting

20 him of possession of a controlled substance and sentencing him to nine and a half
 1 years under the habitual offender statute. On appeal, Defendant argues: (1) he was

 2 illegally seized and evidence obtained as a result of the seizure should have been

 3 suppressed; (2) insufficient evidence was presented to support his conviction; and (3)

 4 he was denied effective assistance of counsel. The State concedes the merits of

 5 Defendant’s seizure claim and does not answer Defendant’s arguments related to

 6 sufficiency of the evidence and ineffective assistance of counsel.

 7   {2}   We are not bound by the State’s concession that Defendant’s seizure was

 8 unlawful. State v. Guerra, 2012-NMSC-027, ¶ 9, 284 P.3d 1076; see State v.

 9 Caldwell, 2008-NMCA-049, ¶ 8, 143 N.M. 792, 182 P.3d 775 (“This Court, however,

10 is not bound by the [s]tate’s concession[,] and we conduct our own analysis[.]”). Our

11 review of the trial testimony, along with a lapel recording of Defendant’s encounter

12 with police introduced at trial, supports the State’s position that Defendant was

13 improperly seized and that the physical evidence recovered as a result of that seizure

14 should have been suppressed. See State v. Martinez, 2015-NMCA-___, ¶ 15, ___P.3d

15 ___ (No. 32,516, Jan. 6, 2015) (“[R]eviewing a video by itself is like reviewing any

16 other documentary evidence, and we are in as good a position as the district court to

17 view the video and interpret what it shows.”). We accept the State’s concession and

18 reverse Defendant’s conviction on that basis.

                                             2
 1   {3}   Defendant contends that without the physical evidence there is insufficient

 2 evidence to support his conviction. Because the State does not argue that sufficient

 3 evidence exists, we conclude that Defendant is entitled to a dismissal rather than a

 4 new trial. See State v. Templeton, 2007-NMCA-108, ¶ 27, 142 N.M. 369, 165 P.3d
5 1145 (explaining that the defendant “would be entitled to a dismissal of the charges

 6 on remand if the evidence adduced at trial was insufficient to support the conviction”

 7 (alteration, internal quotation marks, and citation omitted)). Therefore, Defendant’s

 8 ineffective assistance claim is moot. See Crutchfield v. N.M. Dep’t of Taxation &

 9 Revenue, 2005-NMCA-022, ¶ 36, 137 N.M. 26, 106 P.3d 1273 (“A reviewing court

10 generally does not decide academic or moot questions.”).

11 CONCLUSION

12   {4}   For the foregoing reasons we reverse.

13   {5}   IT IS SO ORDERED.

14
15                                         M. MONICA ZAMORA, Judge

16 WE CONCUR:

17
18 MICHAEL D. BUSTAMANTE, Judge

19
20 JONATHAN B. SUTIN, Judge

                                             3