Court Opinion

ID: 4040580
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:34:46.695351+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:28:42.981912
License: Public Domain

~   '                               ,. J
                                                                             .l,j   ... '       '•              •••   ,,

                                                                                            '        '
                                                                                                            ....I'

 ~"'" i>,D.n \ \ '};\l_~"' , ~~\ ~ ; n';\'J u ~'7-"--
 t_Dwf\t o\'.LP1\m ,· nAL r-\pp<r_r-\Ls t
 P. D. De. x \ d ~ ~ )5, C_Ap ·,'\-aL~'i--A'\-\D n                                                                                          lfmCElftUiEfl)) iliNl
  A.u~'\-~ n :--TuA3 \'DI \ l                                                                                                      tOURT r(l)'F (CRfiV'lrN~.IL ~P.PEALS

                                                                                                                                              fEB 17 2015

             \-\t.:. {~Y\u LY\     LS: \_\_', A «1 ~      u ~'r\ 'L ~~ Ah ~Q\ ixAs
                     LLA n~·- \_l~f\,...dl.c,\'lS\-l:Ja
                    l?-.i A\_ LDu~1-- c_AS£. nCY.L \ \ l- d\.C>'8 \n·~- ~                                              ( (:))
                      [:)_::), I~- ~D'D"'13         -lA
                                                                                                                                This document contains so!l'e
                                                                                                                                pages that are of p~or quahty
                     'HDnDfliAu\_cr_~
                       '       \..... c- \l\F\P..'Dn v... '1
                                                      \ W.. L\..<t..t\\
                                                                                                                                atthe time of imagmg.

                          \n\~ · L<t..'\+<t..~ \..0·,~ ~cr_ 't....\\t..\_~8 6~e_urn'L\\i-' \~ .:Vo
             ·    ~n~Df.\m ~Du And "\-h~ ~Du~Y '1:\\f.\'\- ·lC\ C'l'\~2__j~\\,'\- ~~\~A~'t..A3
         .       C....0Pl pu ~ ~ 1\o Cli_c'> : "~"' u <> d. 'L(l... 1'\ f\\- i ....L'L l \. \)'1 ~ \ h'L ~ pp \_\ LA<>'i-
                 t.nn~nc0 %\\"\-           \\·,s.   ~~\ Al ~ur\s'L\_                        £)P-                ~wb\_~('_~~<t-flc\~\\':::. ~ih::>~C\Z_~=f~·
                                                                                                                                                         1

             m~\:f\Rn\L{\~~Du~A:1 Rr\d m~. G\..'.~~A Gno~<i_(\ ~~s't-P-N!E ~
             \ rw.~cu..t~ u<L. ; l\ '\\\<L \ ~\...\_l:.\w~ n ~ w F\ ~ \:W..t..\-\ \.-A.Yl... ihL-~~(-\;\.<L6 +a RLL'b u.J
             ~~~?'-'• ~An'\- -\D L,s1-'£.n '-YD '\h<t.... C\\ \ ~·\S?~M-\-c..~ t..A.\L :VAp'L O(\~ 'hJ \\<tc:.u~~ C\~
             l\s ~rem~~£..~       t\J~\..;c_Rf'\~ ~~u~~6'\-o \_\st~t\ ~a~9_Q\\ \ ~~pA'\-~~
                                       o

'~.
         C...c:\\..L b ZL. Au~ L. c-.\-) % cz.. .AL\..z..rlA-\-\ a(\ p ~<t.S <L0.Y \:C\ ~ cz... ~0~ r..\..A"c1

         Pal~~ ~~~Aui't ~R ~P-.~~'Y URf\f\P-f'\i-- EJ~~fJ\A~ \\~~~ ~AP-.f\~f\A~'n,.
         f:\~p\.ie..Af\'\- A~u~\~J ·h\~ C.oun~a.. ~D lf\ucl \~r.x~ ~d~~\l~'-\'~ Q..A\..\... '\?6
         5'U.... wham \-\fru~lli~ <Y\~~~~-Yi... 9\\ e-\\\_\.:, nC-\'\-~ \-\~~rl<"L ·~.5.~~\nc::m-,l\:. ~ J)
        Rn ~        ~~A (\'-\- if\ A H'l.n 6\ EP-.~ D {'\   ,s,%2... d\Au~'h'\-'2_R L :J\r\()                                        fl\   ~~~% 2.. ~\l. 3: ?\a~
        U6.F\~ ~UR'L ~L. ~~~?Ah_h D~P\\-D~ .P._S~ ~\\C\0.'\-tna u~0~~Rs;DC\ \~ ~\1£..
       ·~'\- ThL.. LDC_A-1-Ion ~~ C,_h·\f'<\1:_ ~'\-~1on ;-\-\~ ~ LU\~nU~'L .. ~~ ~~~ tn
       f\\-)\)    \_~"-A."\--
                        p,;+ h L w ~:, 11 ~ 0\ llt>w '\Ja \_~O!>'h.,'\ '\> o '\h.,_ '"11 L'-V Ap 'L illl~
                                LLJ
       ~\J 'L ~~, t"Lc) % lnu~-4.-·,c::a.
                                     ('\
                                          i-2.. ~'~ ~cc.... PtS, 'P\~q.~iliLS~~J 0 \ : \.U
                                               .                        f<          - '\-\~?\_I~ r>'\
      ·f\Gc ~nc:z..c\ ffiA~. LL~~hA t_.I\D~~~--~"' wha 0~P~'~C\~~ ZJ~ As~r( '\(\~ 'nm
      '+t, 1=\ 1\1\?\_ I "-A;;\-      tO.A:\'L\'    ~1-\'l <>~LR A 1\S Lu u,\ '+h'L                                               Uv.-t\ "~,           , ,   ?± ;
  ?t~pL~Lr-\C\'-\-' ,A~ a R<L~u'V~ ~A'\- f'l\f\~.~\_\~~A L"'~-D~Ln~B ··?~~utL
  c:,f\ ~u~~'L 1'\p)=>\_\U~t\'\-> w~~ w\?~~ D\' RLL D·dz.o ~D"I;'Ei\'U'.t'.'L w~
  'ru:~ \'-or\ '\.hL-wu\:l\-\-~ t\CC...LJ\W . Th<L ~~c\~u Lan~L.f\Z_nCL \s; nnw N\'L Al\cl
  rn 1\5 L (\ Dl'\s 'i_~ d.\xu~:!> t.cl Iss u ~ f'·l<-7\ \-\ l'ld\(\ (\ '\h-;,_ ~'V\2, \(\~ ~AA~L'
  wh;c.h ~"' 10~. l ~uts'\£cl \)op., ~~;\s &'9 "'1.1. Di~ED ~nt;Jf.ff.noL ~'L
  Su tn <P\i_r_a P--d ~ f\~ . \.D\ \_\_ tW... LJ'i..R\_ --\-'n L --\-\\u'\\\.. .
        HD w 1.D t.\'-- '-fu 'L \)A& •' ~ buTh ~ub\_: "-C:US:''LC\ 2; ti\ ~'\-\' 1:> M 1'..~ ffi \\ 'v~<.M\',
  ~D~\_A~                        .AC\c)       m~. [_Lis\!~ ~~D\\5~(\ \\~\\_·~D L<t...,\- f'(\~t~s~                                               '*o
 ,\ \              r;--...,_ ·      -..l...                _\ .__                 u..m I.A. L cl   L     \\
 ·-n-·v=t_    I_ l , )L) \.S      pR rc.h      ·f\7.J:.o ~ 0    ' f\ (\ .,uJ "o~ ~                 u ~ \~ f\ u D P-.f-\B.L   t_D \   A'Z.. f'..C...r_
 -i-t~ ·A~~Lit.Rn't_

   . .\n ~·,:;. Ll'<J"-';:j d\r>.A ~ Apf>L, '-"'"'\-- Y:"'uL ~& h:~\ urr\ p. Lop~ o\;C
  '-\--\-\IS ~\\~t.SpR+~'InC..I-\\.l O~U\\_)_~~ \n~_\S L~\01\~f\PIL L~Lts~f\2.~~~~
    f=\\J~l-its-\n'\ \'\Au'i.... no\ 1=\L.t_t.\ut_~ A\\~ D\( ~1_ ~r-\fu \~·A·(\'LS~~.s ~~1=:\~-
    m Lot~ . no~£... L.JA:s A nrl s't-At~m£_n~ '-i--~K<L" n~ ~~w\~ Q.ont;"'\uch.c\
   ~         rY\rl Pub\_~''-~·Jtnc-1~ (::\'1-l:oM~.l.
             \-\ Df\~P.YJ\_L :J L\o~~1:...~£l...lts\,        .    .                 . . .
                     _L rY\t l~'\- ~u~~~~ '1-\(' \~f10LA._jL~dC1<L ~c:Jtl%.~ cl~~::, ·~: rYIL .:r_
      \IP\u'L no'\-' 1-\~<t.._iu~J P\ t1)~~ oY -.fut. \Ri~lr&uf4,.~~ ~\rv\:r\~~ o~ ~Ad' F\1\d
     t__Df\Ll\.1..J \• o(\3. a\' L(-\11 \ oV \% pf:\~t._ du7LHY\~(\t LAnd~. 0J\St... no'.~ G:>- t:~-Du'73-
    t_~ ·. p ~Dd u~d b~ \-\ ~ 'd\ \_ E. ~en; 4-h \ n uJ P\.S. \=\ \...<Lc.\ 1 0 '\J<yz._ \ n·i ~A lli. f\~
   D~ t-\~~<Z.F\l~, '1-h'L Lou~'\- o\' [_p.,; m~n (-\ \_ ~\)~LAL~"' An2\ ~t_ ~u\J Rt..«l'L ~uR't.
           :l \\~us_ wM'tL ~ m~. \_\sA \'(\A'tc Q_\_U\ ~I .:S'\-h Lnul:\+ 6\,: {:-'\~\) <t.C-\L~,
                                                                                  I

  . ln~P...,'l "\ Fl't \ill tom m t.\'.t:L, hl.~'~~ ""'~'0As I 5d o~~ Ll JsJ58:. i ~'no~ .su~qcl-&1
'-1-h 101'\-'l. dl\%A m ~ \\~u>.S.'\ '\a \:'L l 1C'.J ~; \\~fl..'L ,ChJP\\\ P-S. t.Dut\\'.1~1'~'\-p, ,,.t CbcR\\o
  m(i _h'\\-ffi D\' r,'ULuui: wAs w&o~ \::'.,_b d, d?\5,- :L,\'ul\~t.~.&~h '-\ll\p,,t- :x_ .
       IG'\C.J-t~t.~~(-r\ci_d,AI\C~ 3._ P\m utJ~~ mu~ \(\c) ,~1:.,(\~. _Lc\o, (\\)1- nG\uL
  (:.\«\
 ~,·, <.nds DR ~r. en;\_,;t mun 'o H'D ~o pA~ \'~:>I'.~" P->>ct:' &,~ dow m'lsl'h

                                                                     d.
             \~ Dn Dr\t;hlt. :\uc\::\~ Y\ £...LL l...Pl,                                                      .

      . .            .,h    L    Lf\ c...\.os ~
                                     doe.u m L<l't ·, ~ ~Oil, \'1"\), hill 'i "-'-'' An~ '-\.{, 'i,. ~\)~'i.r"\\_
       _~ufli.':l A~ ~<LL_h· -L.s-\-~on~\_7-\ D'l.t'LuYL ~~.l~_,~D~~-0:\~()~ L\~-+~~ G\~ .cc_x-
       ni b\i- d. ~_u\\_\_ l\\~'L ~~<t_~\-\Dn ~?5:\C\r-\cJ\n~ \'f\f\~pu~\~-~ A<l~ mf\~G.(\u\'\~~(}
      ~i A \_u \-\ 0. 'to       A \.La~       Ptp~ \_\t_A n'\- '\--o L\s~n~ D·~ ct.~~~ d·~~ ~ P\\-c_~ ~o\_\._ \ \\~\~ Q.~s t_.
      1'\3   1"-:u:~~-w'h. d b>...~of'>'L'\:r,~p,\._        Dl\ A\\...,_.,        ~1\oUE..cl ~~-
                                ~'"up;       G"r\C'li\ r1 1'\"':;\f\\'-,6; r.~"*'~ l'..r\c·'\..oO,UR'L            w:\.\.. b 'L \,\ ~\:, \.. ~
                                                                         f\p~R<r~,A\~ -                                                   .             .
                                                                            TYI f-\ r\\\ ~ou ~ ·,, ~~~ 'L\. ~,
                                                                              •  ~ LL~ L3\ \\              ~              LC1_rv-n

                                                                                               (-\ ~   ~ \_ •, t_ A   f'\'\--. ,

                                                              l\t G'ir-1n<'2
               _
                   \"
                   _L_
                           {\
                          L ~ 11 :~ L \,\\,
                                              ,.   '       --
                                            _ fffST'\t;c A\'i
                                                                             ~
                                                       o ~. \ ~~~ ~ l•od0~1~\ ~~<c:_                                    '\
                                                                                                              u.ncJffi' ~
                                                                                                                               .      '
                                                                                                                                          .
                                                                                                                                      'c;,\n l.d\ '\<'\11\!\\S
                                                                                                                                                            \.

     "~ ~~ tt.~'\-, ~., <z•.5 '-\-h A'\- '\-vyr_. L'cJ\'\)~\-~i- i u<l \_s '\-- u~\- 1-\ (\A ~~ ~~ A 11('\ ~· e.ap~ D~
    -tht- ~Df\~\G \ t\C'A 3 pP\~'t-;- .\_~W<L~ ~n~d <cf\c__\_u~ 'i:£\ ~DC..Uff\<U\'\- <tx \-\,,'a,'\-~ L(h~ ~t.l~~
     (\ U rv-{b t \\'\:- I \- d\o   ~ L,:, , hi-\~ bLLC\         \.>c\ b ';.\ ~:'\. fJ 0 :'1'\-A\.
                                                            <Y\A •                    ~ 1:.!', U ~<".~- ?" ,,\' . .          ,li..,

     P\Ac\ ffi ~S'Ld ~a _ShA~e>n ~'L't~R. PP-t.s\o\ ~f'l~ ~Lx~cr_., t.oLdJ..'t oV (__p.,,m ·,".~\_~~~JI~,
    t-\'\- ·Qo. C:J OX \ ct ~(\% LAp '.'-\-ol ~'\-A-\-\ on"\ ~u..)-1-~ (\ 2_)\l:.\~ \ ol \ \ ·d~(\ '\-V\E. .11
                                        j                                              l   \                   ~F\~
.   D~ A o\\'tl ""'(=\ 14 h:J 'd::J l":l .
                                               ) \03,    .ID'='O~? C I     Af\R\"1 00 ·

           'I C b » t \1:,,I • \'. \ I ~rv olD' \ h:JC..::S 1\D\ t i ladD~,                        \)1'-.r:'i:..f\+l..):l. "', ~-.
                                                                                                 b"L. ':.4
    c_A~c__t.ARi-Lc1 ""'{her_) 2:>-~ ~E.P,Af->'\--(II'U!'\- o'V: C,~\rn~_(\f-ll uu.s*'CL.tuf\(ol')ill'~anR~
    ln~+itu'tiDn. t-lu~;n~ Un';\ ,do hc.r-.'t...b(1 d~AP.,'t.. unc'l>.f'l \)L~A ~'\-~ u9
     f:iE...I\~,U p., ';:\ '1'-nA't- '1--h 'L Abou L ~ rv:c\ \Ju f\~0 ' ~ ' :, ~ P-u'<... A n c\ CDr\ h~.                           .
                          L x 'LC..u\ c__{D tJ n ~ ~-S\ u_Ql\.u ct . d-0 IS .                                        .              ··
                          · .                · · .· . · ·     ('\ .     · ~~·¢c_~uL\'(.\~·.u~ . m~d ~.· ·
                                                                             (' b a \S:t] \ 1.\\-\ ~ C\
                                                                                                      ........J_._"(n._,_·J0...._._~----,-­

                                                                          [_huc_h \~; LL~ Am~"l.od.o~, l5 \
                                                                         \--\u'\-01 \ n~ LJ\n~- \-\La~'-{ -CJ· · · ·
                                                                         \Suo t.J. LRncj~on hd.
                                                                             ~AU.m ';\<t.x~ IS~Lt \
                                                                3.
    Re~       State v. Chuck Williams (F11-26863)                                                           Page 1 of 1

        Re: State v. Chuck Willia·ms {Fll-26863)
        Stephanie Mitch~!!\ \..... c.•
        Sent: Wednesday, February 29, 2012 1:38 PM .
        To:    Elisha Enoksen

    H~-1-~-;;;-pai?ole" so I doubt· he·.will take anything. He is 25 to life. The rec was 30, but I may be
    willing to drop a paragraph. Talk with him and see what he will take.

    Sent from my iPhone.

    On Feb 29, 2012, at 1:32 PM,                ~Elisha Enoksen" cElisha.Enoksen@dallascounty.org> wrote:

    > Hey Lady,
    >
    >I'm on this case now.   I'm about to speak with him via video conference and I'll be able to l~t
    you know if we'll announce ready as soon as I do. Could you please let me know your latest offer on
    the case, though? I just checked on Onbase and didn't see it· scanned it yet.
    >
    >Thanks!
    > Elisha Enoksen
    > Dallas County Assistant Public Defender
    > (214) 653-3546

    >
    >    From: Frank Douglas
    >    Sent: Monday, February 27, 2012 12:37 PM
    >    To: Elisha Enoksen
    >    Subj.ect: Fwd: State v. Chuck'~Williams (F11-26863)
 >
 >

: Sent from my              iPhon~
 >
> Begin forwarded me~sage:
>
> From: "Stephanie Mitchell"
cStephanie.Mitchell@dallascounty.orgcmailto:Stephanie.Mitchell®dallascounty.org>>
> To: "Frank Douglas" cFrank.Douglas@dallascounty.orgcmailto:Frank.Douglas®dallascounty.org>>
> Subject: State v. Chuck Williams ·(F11-26863)
>
> Hello Frank!  Please find my Motion to Disclose Experts, Notice of Extraneous Offenses and Witness
list attached.  Per dui new office policy, I have to bu~n your discovery to a disk that you can pay
for in the video room.  I have prepared that disk and it contains the 911 call, call log and police
report. When you are ready to pick this up, please notify me.
>
>I anticipate being ready for trial' on.4/2/12. This is the oldest jail chain case I have set that
day. Please le-e me know if /OU .Plan to annouHce ready as well. Thanks!
>
>       Stephanie N. MitchP.ll
>       Assistant District Attorn~y
>       Family Violence Division
>       Dallas County, Texas
>       214-653-3723
>
snmitchell®dallascounty.orgcmailto:snmitchell@dallascounty.org>cmailto!snmitchell®dallascounty.org>
>
> cFiled Motions.pdf>
                                                       r '.

                                                                                  l····;

https://owa.dallascounty.org/owa/?ae=Item&t=IPM.Note&id=RgAAAACwd%2fno 1WO ..                               2/29/201?