Court Opinion

ID: 4086302
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-10-08 00:06:37.736742+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:33.746595
License: Public Domain

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
           Appellate Division, Fourth Judicial Department

373
CA 11-01999
PRESENT: SCUDDER, P.J., CENTRA, CARNI, LINDLEY, AND MARTOCHE, JJ.

THOMAS R. NICHTER AND DOROTHY NICHTER,
PLAINTIFFS-RESPONDENTS,

                    V                             MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

ERIE COUNTY MEDICAL CENTER CORPORATION,
UNIVERSITY AT BUFFALO SURGEONS, INC., AND
JAMES K. LUKAN, M.D., DEFENDANTS-APPELLANTS.

GIBSON, MCASKILL & CROSBY, LLP, BUFFALO (MELISSA L. ZITTEL OF
COUNSEL), FOR DEFENDANTS-APPELLANTS UNIVERSITY AT BUFFALO SURGEONS,
INC. AND JAMES K. LUKAN, M.D.

ROACH, BROWN, MCCARTHY & GRUBER, P.C., BUFFALO (JOEL J. JAVA, JR., OF
COUNSEL), FOR DEFENDANT-APPELLANT ERIE COUNTY MEDICAL CENTER
CORPORATION.

ROSENTHAL, SIEGEL & MUENKEL, LLP, BUFFALO (RICHARD P. VALENTINE OF
COUNSEL), FOR PLAINTIFFS-RESPONDENTS.

     Appeals from an order of the Supreme Court, Erie County (John M.
Curran, J.), entered January 19, 2011 in a medical malpractice action.
The order denied the motions of defendants to compel plaintiffs to
provide certain medical authorizations.

     It is hereby ORDERED that the order so appealed from is
unanimously modified on the law by vacating the ordering paragraph
denying defendants’ motions in their entirety and by directing
plaintiff Thomas R. Nichter to submit to Supreme Court, Erie County,
for an in camera review, a certified complete copy of his medical,
surgical and diagnostic records from the Erie County Medical Center
and Buffalo General Hospital for the period beginning June 13, 2005
through the present and from Arvind Wadhwa, M.D. from the first date
of service in 1995 through the present and as modified the order is
affirmed without costs.

     Memorandum: In this action to recover damages for personal
injuries allegedly sustained as a result of medical malpractice,
defendants appeal from an order denying their respective motions to
compel Thomas R. Nichter (plaintiff) to provide medical authorizations
permitting defendants to obtain his records from the Erie County
Medical Center and Buffalo General Hospital for the three-year period
before the first date of the alleged medical malpractice, which was on
June 13, 2008, through the present. They also sought an authorization
                                 -2-                          373
                                                        CA 11-01999

from plaintiff for his records from his primary medical physician,
Arvind Wadhwa, M.D. from the first date of service in 1995, through
the present. We conclude, based upon the record before us, that the
records sought are “material and necessary” to the defense of this
action (CPLR 3101 [a]), inasmuch as they may contain information
“reasonably calculated to lead to relevant evidence” (Grieco v Kaleida
Health [appeal No. 2], 79 AD3d 1764, 1765). Indeed, the records are
likely to include prior medical conditions that may be relevant to the
defense of this action. We further conclude, however, that the
records should not be released to defendants until the court has
conducted an in camera review thereof, so that irrelevant information
is redacted (see Tirado v Koritz, 77 AD3d 1368, 1369; see generally
Tabone v Lee, 59 AD3d 1021, 1022; Mayer v Cusyck, 284 AD2d 937, 938).
We therefore modify the order accordingly.

Entered:   March 23, 2012                      Frances E. Cafarell
                                               Clerk of the Court