Court Opinion

ID: 4044639
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:39:40.090245+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:28:18.854953
License: Public Domain

'

    '
        '
            '
                I
                            ••• t

                               'r.
                                                                              .
                                                                                                  ~

                                                                                                ~/f/tv#~                        ~ 7. Z6/:J
                                                                                                                                  /
                                                                                                                                                -                {j~T0~-03
                                                                                                                                                                       ,--.---

                \

                                            A4L.6-A                 L, 57~                                         "           . a,~                               ...
                    /
                                            l106 LL"5_ '2L 1' 1ftf :z..      ·-                                                &L/LJJK.dL'CM_J .£~-..<eft
                                              L2o0 !i_4,e'<r ?~,                                                              '£t/-:r4pt-~ Z (--:L L1-
                                            ld't:/ r~-"b_zzt·                            -~       ?o& <-                                                     '

                                                                 ,            /7                  .

                        -
                                                   ;/'"C.-          I'       ~              ;;,
                                                                                                      Z____j/;4-""1        b:££5-?:. d$,
                                                   L~2 !& r/.1; J'3' .2                                                ~c;;g/ CaPr /f
                                                                                                                                                                   -

                                            (2/tU// h~ 5 ,'                                               ..                                    .-   ·-· .

                                             E/.1B_ 5               'C-           7!:-z. ~            L?~.//c~ 0                             U,                        fL
                                             l'-r-~LA            ,·" ""' / &u /7-                                      tf."   F ~-z:-:.......,/:["

                                            ~6-~                                                      -
                                                                                                                                  - This document contains so!"e -
                                                   .A
                                                                                                                                    pages-that-a~-of-p?Or-quahty
/

                                                  4~                          L2z=                                                  ~t the time of 1magmg.

                                    (
                                              -
                                                                                                                                           -·
                                                                              '
                                                        li""i::fP'I~ ... a11 ·-~      alil. n

                                                  , oo~~~:fn~:~!l~tS
                                                         \

                                                             \   JAN 29 2015
                                                             \
                                                         A~.-1~                                                                                                                  -
                                                             """"                 '

                                                                                                                                  r

                                              -

                                                                         ;

                                                                                                               -
                                        \
                                                            Cau.s·e..     /Uo .. 14lf?D4']
         ,
                 -,.
                                                                    ---                ..

                       'T_LI f ST/Lrf DLTExtLS.                                    I!U_Il-LF 33_1 tb_
                                               lLS_                             .ruOLcifLL_IJ.rg_ rBLc[ r_ DU!ii
                       A()\ r (.':)   J::)     L. SL0 _Q_C)                      Jifl(j_B.TS C.QU/Jj_ T'i7_TfX.1S
                                                      '
     '
                       (fi ffL_IUt~fliJJJ) [0_/1 .6JB;I.LilU!l/1!JJ!J~4-{!JJJS )r
                                                                                                    c
                                                                                              -

                       .~_Ifu_l_-/_on orable.__Y~~                                                            f of
                                                                                                        .ouc_··
                       L_r_, ,· . -:~. . ~ ~~k::-.-o._L!)-?fJ {~_o.Ls . ·· .                                              ~

                            ..... ccv:r;J.L5--aa~-QILQP                            L        SLQD_~_E_,J__,dox-                .
                       ~__11,~--:-~~ ~                              GL,_d__i_/   /« ~b-1J-,-qpp}-'-=JLa.~0 ~
                       ,:_L)_~LlruuJ~_y,~dir:e_d; hj~e_ _53__'1__                                                             1

                        J~dkJalJJ,:.s_fcuJ_CaLMC· t_ Jy~ra:c t9~]ac /rs.oq_
                       ·(j_e_-JP;_C20I:L~ipj-:t JC)_i,b_;J--:C-Q~ e ~&_v,)_e~Q~l_-/:t,_e f'lo_D1o-Y-t-
                        -io_:_flLs..Y:J ~.:_s_c_a<4L·e_o.-f- =g,c- -·f:o.b ~ -:'-h._e_/21c>f.:oh.
                             .               -Y-l-l           · .-----            1-   -1-        ---      - - .. - L -

                        io__f:l~~w_(.oL-Lr- ·t fj_f~ Jn f~ci_ f.)_kKH%__sa h o/
             -         .fl;t;f-_o_l~_L!J)_e~AJ_fo,.d..I::J-S_f2_Lfo .Ac_ f on L3~g lY of .
                        'D_e:_&c,c/g t:Jt__;_~_g_~ e VilA~ /It_ 2_~0 'i_ 2S}'1 /.,J
                                _to,'t
                       T.~.:.~-_i.                    -P.    £ ·---                A
                                                            ~ -_~_s__·i/ s .;~Q_jCl_L~
                                                                                     "' ,) 0 01::1~

                       v.L1.lc..l~                                  b;_g$    cb"lrsecl '-..Jif6 fh~-e-
                       o.L£Jo_t"" ib Pos-'ess;Oh 1ft·y~Ar.m. T"'
    ·-

                       Sbtf-~c:c,W +),Q./)~·r_g- ioh ~e/,;foc sJ,owdJ~ .f)k.~Pj

                                                                           r,
                                               ~

                                                                                                                          -

                              ()ICJlL_:J_rd ak, of J:y,e__, IJDJ4, ~a/-/
                       .J h oJ&ttr;.£. h:Lt~ ,er 5
                                                       7
                                                   Le.. ·Lx_ nedJa-tJL:f?__3_5_ 9_ :!:b..
                       l::J;s-fric;_l-· ta,=1cf~rd_/JoL.c/s ~ci.Jr;·~'1 J ·-r:;~a,s
                       12...~ta.Y--::;_i.ICJ::9_tAe ~~t~f'-~t~tt_ th~CJSe__
~

                   .
                   \
                                                  -
        -.   -,_

                   e;_L/ilan · ;"'     ~ss"=ssior. c£j_~·L~ Ar-~nl A
                   n.o.Y-.)- ~'C1_1 offebS€.. on He. LLtl.. J~£
              .
                   f!lQv_, 'd..OJ4- )3_g_)g_Thx i.A)Q£ c:.hc.rgJ vu 1 f6
                   fe) Db 1n e,~-5 e.. s Si 0 n_o_f__E;~c_ m_J_j_~th e
-
                   31~ -tb._   Dts·fY' /c.f- C:Dutr f                                -
                                                'l 7-
                         . Tb_~U~aA-k£~&~~.e -}-~. acf 9-1:
                   · · ~\4-e .r fe L~/1 ~ LC< to L_l__i              ~:)_k1~CJe.-ia-perkm
                   ~ n-11                   " 1 t ~_J:__&o~r::;..
                         'a_,'___\_t_:.e,_c J..M_·:-· t   r    { -aLr_~c_tb~
                                                                     -
                                                                         _ __ . ~'- }_..r   Q ~

                   hbe ~~SJL- f.Sf-Dc,_~~-t J-.eas_f_E_lle.cl_ or
                   fotQLL1_u_£,~;~_clo_j ~ltLisJ_£>,X21 ~*;
                                            -             -
                                            1 L7              ~

                        TJ,~_flJ_qfo~o g_de__,'tl4Qfe_ctirJ_J¥
                   I g_w~D-~<.4_-Y-2-S.~~e.--tb_e_}!::. ~~-e.J=-fe.-d re J/e·f ·of~ e.c
    -
                   fho t:J_i..,.;_L/).., -tb.J 5 W JL r;.s,):.Io_rr       <

                                                /)/ ~
                                                      -

                       TA_Ls_f__oL!..r.'Lbg_r_ J:-1r L.s_ d_; chot:J fo / SSL1 e_ . -
                   ~ Wr Lt o f (Y] o, .n c/_g, iY1 VJ r_1r.'-tb f s ·- cg lds_~~J:ude_tc_
                   fii±_r_:>~S. ec.ti_on- J- o f- . [;_:x g~ oh s-i_ Li ~ f. ;or.'"' 9 r, o/
                   Ct r f; c QI_L 41 a_lf_cj_(__,J_o!e_o_f_c_r:_ LmJXJ_~_Lfro ~ ~ dr.A. re_.._
                                                              -

                                          -!~4-C--E-              ()___ ~+~ '+
------~-----··-------(~~A~'~~.~~vi~f_·_~)--------------~----

                     · -g e fur~          m    J), ~   Y\    'CJokr_~_d_ c.~~-
--.,...----~9~~'-1~-er:_soogJL~l 9f-fde9L:..e..cL Actroa.-L . ~)ogl:)___·___
-----'---f+Vl'".....t..).l.:..). g f t_~'L-b ~i ~ ~3 w o~x:.\ 5 fer fed .: _ ·
                         .· ((I oti'V\ A;~oY\ L, 5/oqn +f..~ BQ._Jqfor- l~i:::.\.:--.-_ __
                                                                 J

------~q~b_ou~ and n~.tY.JbQ.red L~.J-~>_bcn>e r:_e::;;,d +A~e____. ___
             Qffctc..~e.c/ J()e_f; +-~·on ·fer- G.JC/.·f: .c f fYJo(nd011Ckl~S.-·_
             qnJ SL-Je:;l' . fA9 f: f-),<?_ o.koug_ o./l~haxti_c-.....__f_______
-------t+"f__,q-=-c_.t c. c n f g i n e_cj f b. e_r g_ i Y\ a. r e_ +r- ._, e c. c r:;; o_d;_OfJ-._
---t--1-fc-=o;...._j.~ h€.Jie f.

- - - t t + - - - - - - - - - - - - ' - - - - ' - ~~Qt::)_L_s_~_Q1~.if; CiY-}i__·

                    ~ Cmoo:iooion C:;o. CoU1, 2015     /LJ   0
                                                                 ~   /L. /,_/; c__J.t::J · g 11 cJ /o IC.
                    · /?q.[J~ 5 csF Lf--               f   J.. e_ .S+~+e_ -~+         Te. ~q_r
   .'   '·   .

                       OAn£8____________~

---t·· -~--~----&r'9n±e;:::J;(~o/f.--=..==--·~~__,.....--~
------~------~--~r-----~b' ~ni~~~~------~~~--
---t+-------'------1-/jy~i.        + i s:
                                   ~c)      e__   Pe.rs ioliv'3