Court Opinion

ID: 4065837
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 22:16:34.800561+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:05:42.941517
License: Public Domain

'
Yo~ THE c.L~k OF'                                                            :YANtf5 6£/Cro:J· i7 'ii7SD3
                                                                             f<:.DBEKrse.!J
Clwl-or CR!Mif\J-kl iArf>PE!'Q_s. DP~                                                               l)J\.It{
                                                                             t'L.o7 t F. A-1. ·g 5 z z
Ausn..-J,TK.                                                                As;Rt~JfiFrv&[~LN ..
                                                                          couRT oF CR!r,m.1 ~J.. XmAul
                                                                                   A! V' 1      Q ~'~(.·01.~
           Gf(f£77vGs'                                                            t';.'J':) -         "'·"-

                    -A gDLJT    11i£ CAID OF'     .MitV J 5wl A LEbr.-tr3ttr:No/'gj:l[J15.E))JF!fk
          Wtflc.H T     INC.WC>ctl / 1..   A Mcm cr:J FoR: tY"PotfJ"l'!U£1\l"l o-F C.OV tJ 5 CL
         6~1 GL'\14LLY FtLEb IN z...q!!:!: D(SlJetcr cenN<T, ~ALo P iNTZJ, covNf'(,
         T-E~ &N ~BER lln!. 1 ZeHctfoXtttBrT''A.~); Z, 1Wo (z) L£TIER5
         lD \HE. ~.NAM6.D (ln)yC,T ~KED G><.tW5iT5 'B'~A.NCi'c i',
             .f    tJfNBC. ·RELBVEO -NkNOWLEObbM.CAJT             Ttl AT 1iflrT P4.CJV4t.e H;'t:fJ
     16 ££N         RtC£i veD BY YoV R. Cir-f=i C£ M             WHlff AGJ£ VN HAS E-f!VJ
     TILtJ(e.'I'J Ra.ARD WG THE Mon o.tJ .
             l1f£     ~11\17; C.OUN6tL      AJR   DP/95Nb£~S IN ~n ME               JH.A-1/'ouR.
         CWR..i- .AMJST     6/&E~ Tttt 1\f'?ot ,r-JIMEN T {)1=COUIJ5£L      FoR w·R. i l oF
         fiABbt\:~ ~s ()INJ            fAY     P~nc.x.H...* CAS£       ~ (bf\,{t-t1A-s, ~ llieire.s)
            I AM UNA"Bi£ 10 G&()MtJ DO{UJ\A-E!Sr.s lV 5UtPoR--:r MY CLAftv1,
         Wt\id-\   (5   IRlJE 1\1\J/J W56TifTIAL 1 E£lN~ A \JlOL{l(J!o.tJ o-F f=DVRTH
         ·~DMEJJ-1 .PRlfr:EGi\01\\S PRo-Jpi)&D                  gy THE       CoN~TI/U71DN
         OF Tt1C: lJNii£D ST'..-'\1-t:s SILL DF RiG+t15,
              jti£ U.$. 60f'REM£. ~T MA~ RULED lliAT (N.Dil9DJT, li\JC{¥(cGK-
         I\1tb ~ ~ R£Q~R£ COUN&t l- FoR wR t\ r:rF f+AEiA ~ CDRF>vt;..                                         f

     Tt\ef<tfbR.E T            tv NOT WI\NTlD            P'R~,
                                                       PRo S£ 1 DN f\ .fJEW
         -~ QJR.fVS.             PRa:B:.DiNG SI\5£.D M 1--iEW RULINbS MD
         Li\W OCCuRb.J~          A-PT-i:k. .Nv"{ C/Rl611JAL        f\1-'(~..JCI\TlON            f=tl~

         WR.cr OF ·N-A:£5£1\5        ~RJ~,
     I      tiA\1£ \r.J~fllt/J .M/1N'/ :t\~J£'{S .AtJD L£QAL .A\t~ {)R&t.JfZ-fnlJJS

  AND        Sf.ftJ utJ EOCL£~srvt- e£ !At~ \Al6 RtP~$VTAne.\J oJJ f>Ro BLNZJ
   ISAsiS      1
                    6o P-AR. NO:-JG tJAv£ t\Ab \li£ Ff~£SSiCYN.\L CEJVRT£6Y TD
   ~               RE~PotJi)          To )1\!QVIRY.
              I 5 lti~R£ 'A REtbR.D I                      CAN ~A:\N Ff~,\1\ YDJ)R. Qf!Zt.C£ OF AU-
     fiLI.tJG$ \3'( .ME- M·D llfE. SIAnJS      oF lft£/V\, ALL [)!Z Jvvi Affi_teftntW~
    AJNc: 1SEEJJ'' DIErJ tt:-b wtThoUT W-R. trr-&J ~ b 11 wln,wur f\N "( 6DfZ\
    ON- EXFLAI\lffl)(9:~ VJ t1 '{J 'lHAT J /11\t 6L{T CDte.f<.£-Cf Pr<L~u;.-vv~ bR.
     &~s,                                                     .
       It~ l1H5 IN51AJJCE:                 i               ~
                                               PAL-o Plt\\To                        1'i. CAU&;- iLVl'Z.2. -AJ           1
     f{~f A CL-ft\M THAT                       HM     ALk~Y' S-eeN                  CASES        ~ 1"1JRAJ£.D \....J
    'foVR CDt>R-T, t). S.               ()\S~\CT ~ M.D                             t-H£ 6t)f>f<8vq; Cot.ieT FDR.
         \ t)&JllCAL ute(.L),tv\ S\1\1-JCCS;
            ..f    CAJJ N'OT UN!)-t;~D trJtr{ T AM HMlNb Sv Mvtli DiPP:tC.LU'(
                     '
         OBif\\t.JtNG         R£Uflff?;        -1- GHotU>         }\}·err-   16t: RE-Qulf2tt~    w     Ht~tS CWJJ6£L

      WttfN        l1it 19\ UU'       t:.-(-E S CtJ-tTrt   Ttf£     b1'1TIC     AN I) fT5 fi-AI\) ()!.. W{,. Of' .N\ t: ,
         !\1~ C-It!...}
                         /
                             :r   W~t:> 6'-N£ I

~ ; \~{ 7 9, q(p(p -r)~
 ()RJGrt-lM- l\fPMC.41'1o.N