Court Opinion

ID: 8855694
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-11-26 17:29:18.662794+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T17:05:38.947183
License: Public Domain

PER CURIAM.
The tug Vandercook, having in tow 14 coal-laden boats and barges, assisted by the tug Purcell, left Hammond’s Flat at 6 p. m., November 9, 1893, bound up Long Island Sound for New Haven and intermediate ports. Shortly after midnight an ebb tide and strong easterly wind were encountered, creating a rough sea, by which the tow was broken up, resulting in the loss by sinking of seven of the boats. The question in the case is whether the weather conditions were such at the commencement of the voyage as to justify an experienced navigator, exercising ordinary prudence, and familiar with the ordinary conditions of the proposed voyage, to undertake the trip, in view of the qualities of the tugs, and the character of the tow. The preponderance of testimony supports the conclusions reached by the district judge. The witnesses were examined in his presence, and, so far as the merits depend upon their credibility and intelligence, we ought not to disturb his conclusions. The disaster was not caused by a storm, or any extraordinary perils, but w'as.the result of meeting a strong head wind upon an ebb tide. This should have been anticipated, if the record of the weather bureau of . New York, showing the weather conditions during the 24 hours preceding the commence-*649meat of the voyage, is to be accepted as correct. Throughout November 8th, while the tug had been awaiting favorable weather, the wind was strong from the north or northeast. At midnight it veered from the northeast to north, and remained between north and northwest during November 9th, until the vessels put to sea. Under those circumstances, as appears very conclusively by the testimony, a change of the wind to eastward was to be expected at any time. The change did not occur as soon as was to be expected, but it did occur when the tow was at a place where a harbor could not be made before the pounding seas were fatal. The judgment of the district court is affirmed, with costs.