Court Opinion

ID: 7374551
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-28 00:27:06.6543+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:42:48.635887
License: Public Domain

The Senate of the State of Alabama adopted a resolution requesting the Supreme Court of Alabama to give an advisory opinion as to the validity of a minority report of a Committee on Conference of the Legislature relative to Section 64 of the Constitution of Alabama.
Question answered.
To the Honorable Members of the Senate of Alabama State Capitol Montgomery, Alabama Sirs:
On November 13, 1975, we received from you a copy of Senate Resolution 35 by Mr. McMillan, requesting our opinions, on the validity of a minority report of a Committee on Conference of the Legislature which we assume is in connection with a pending bill, viz: "Does a minority report of a Committee on Conference have validity?" The answer to this question depends upon whether a minority report of a Committee on Conference of the Legislature is permitted by the rules adopted by each house of the Legislature, or by precedents and practices of each house of the Legislature.
Under Section 53 of the Constitution of Alabama, 1901, each house has the power to determine the rules of its proceedings. The Legislature, therefore, has the authority to determine whether to permit a minority report of a Committee on Conference to be filed. While Section 64 of the Constitution of Alabama, 1901, specifically provides that "* * * no report of a committee of conference shall be adopted in either house, except upon a vote taken by yeas and nays, and entered on the journal . . .", the Constitution does not specifically prohibit the filing of such a report, but neither does it specifically permit the filing of such a report.
In short, each house has the power to determine the rules of its proceedings.
For guidance in making your determination, you may wish to look at the practices and procedures followed by similar bodies. See: Mason's Manual of Legislative Procedure, Chapter 72, pp. 543-552; Jefferson's Manual, Section XLVI (Manual and Rules of House of Representatives, 94th Congress, House Document 416, 93rd Cong., 2d Sess., 13079, pp. 268-282); Rules and Manual, United States Senate, 1973, pp. 147-164; Senate Document No. 21, 93rd Congress, First Session, document No. 13028, pp. 283-320 [see, especially, page 312, wherein it is stated: "A minority member of a Conference Committee cannot make a report, under a ruling in the house" (citingCongressional Record, July 29, 1935, pp. 12007-12013).] *Page 27 
In the final analysis, however, it is up to each house to determine how it will handle a Conference Committee report.
Respectfully submitted,
 HOWELL HEFLIN Chief Justice
PELHAM J. MERRILL
JAMES N. BLOODWORTH
HUGH MADDOX
JAMES H. FAULKNER
RENEAU P. ALMON
JANIE L. SHORES
 ERIC EMBRY Justices