Court Opinion

ID: 3209633
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-06-06 07:31:25.709958+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:45:48.492185
License: Public Domain

./ - ')
n@. \qq_\‘*‘\L{L,`-»[_”)__D  "U~)
FRECE|VED\N
EX 9 Q'R._T E COURT OF CR\M|NAL APPEALS
`3'~€. \‘-”C)S"\E(§ ` MAY 31 2015 \bZ`LS`Ta:\‘_c"-‘\' coui&`\' O\=CJ-RL
) Vf\¢ \_av\ne=\n _
C°'-*“\“% inns
99 c>\_:_ c_¢»n‘?~b§\ QC,QS‘§§=,§§"§ § RE
`Tb T\~\E. STA'T \, $@OT`\S\Z
CLUSID\’\ Q;F L`¢“___>
`\"o ‘T\-\\;; \.\@,\@RRB
L` TS . ._
C comes v\o\.¢, EY_?QQ*Q `_:(C ‘;\dt;E O\‘~".S~a~.\_b t_buQT .
l ` ss  \¢` ` '
' . good \-a,.\,\,__ RSS_G

- {"'\  \ § \

*c

35@\,‘ Q\-

\°‘»~'-~$\»- e + \1 w \. ~
v=»»~se ¢>s= +»~<»_"... s:n».n wl Fx: gaf pop Q\QEQ"‘¢""~'\+`: be¢;
) ` '  1

"\ O/

 \c.¢l~¢\'\- H`$.S€R'\~S »\~\nr-z¥ ..\-\-Q .§-\r+=)¥-Q‘ S \'_;v~.c\~.v,&)_¢ o g
' “ °°"“°L'~»‘$\¢>\'\ QF`L.<=.L;> i\s \=>o»%\.-. ¢o»\"'-\re_s=ré "
 j ;\\'~=~-»<\-»»

vz<»_nse~n+ab\.a ` ¥\~ L` \~.~ \=’ v 1 " . "

` \*\ Q \A 9 €¢'10.\_,\ .'-lc‘-Ll L.\..,S_ {a»\~'§zo; R.GA
Sc.\»»\'htf>~b, \LQAH¢LA L.<>.,SS‘ o¥?- F‘\Fp\.lc¢d¥\~\¢_¢_, pv=uzc>l.g ¢>_L,‘S"',g°‘__\_ _
\`~\' dn-\-@, ¢~'-\\:~\-é, \»~. `\  ` l » `

g \,,\::'n ' _,  ., .
Q\ bet \' d""/\'%..$   COAY\d€L\";»\-S  

C\\

” "~\§~g,\~-\~`(¢,.,.,AL_L_\,‘ A,\`F'F~`er¢Qn-\~ F¢>_\:>r-\ -Qé

______-§

..\-'\ce \€enn€c>\\,`(§ `§Rr`¢uq¥~?.\»\ "Z_’S) 'ZO\(, <$\'.S$er\'\~ a~`r\ \Y`f`l¢o»-.~\go».
rn€~rlo\ \¢ ~\_.@)ui$;€lr'\¢\ S"'l"l \_l. §

.._`2.<>\<¢ ¢=\sser<~¢..`\~.»»g -\~\-.:=P¢Lz_s)~
.\»\ew'¢s was su\-"F\c.~e_.»~.-\- \1,,¢_

f`f'\-D.S’~\- _suv€vx'q_Lqg LA,\,__

r=;rg §)11`» npl FL_Q ~e.s~\-¢=\\¢L`\ »~

r~\+ “ <.\rw`.\..é,\z€n v__,=)rLe c_c>¢~.,~s'\- »,
_ \.\L+ Fov; p\.~.@`;,p_‘gQ,_q/g.
@\= S¢q+@».n‘-_\‘na scm us _%¢=»+___@\_a@, o`,_ ¢=.+ B§,¢_i+av.§ \z,,-
P'~’-fh, .Sqprza,<=~\~ .S'é»q-$"tt>`, »=;n¢\. G-'arz\~mm,. S\»-g>@*‘\. r~z-\~ é§\(
"T’\-\ age <é{\‘\""\:'e,rze¢\c,e~'?‘ \Qe£u\+ F~`rzo»,-.-, §\-\.\\L<§rze.n‘£ c§l.»h'¢.v~,'\$\.,_
Q_A 'Lu(`_.p@,’\o"\¢l-`v\~\,\ F**`* €\ §Qe_\d\~e¢; pat>$pe_¢-_\._§ lion Q_&\:’URF“;:
ana mae Q.p;»~=sr=~§,.»~.-\~ \n §-\~r¢ee \>Q-`-u=\_A $Qn_g@_ 0¥: D_€Sq>~z>~r\$\ \=>`.L§.-\~ L€.Ae§'\n§ 40 Q\Q -

‘t_\r_t.es s»¢~¢e_»ggt \\"~.~. p»..l~_ S`\\¢~\ *c\.\ ,a-.~é \»= e e ¢!Le,gs R`\s\<-.\~<‘:\~'~'\~"g|,
\_~$eCehA'.C-K,."_`_béu_en aaa .,.,\@,,__@_ ~zm\_he_aqb\_q &~b v~»e§¢a~\-\\¢Q \`

,,,v\:'\_u@_,,,;eg 955 o\_,_.\.${<§;.e pa_es$un_e~-`/ \~P~ ¢_L\».A~`»~S »\:`¢11>-.4 '
\r-\e_\`vz. \":Av-»\`¢\.,»~__\Q"\¢\ P&,ea_$/` ~\-\~»e».,\ \r~.ra\_»o. \_l.»-n.'»&»~e¢;\ €-'°'\"~"PR@L#
b`(e@_ \,\,`e<`,`a_'_ @\_,,>n Q_r~»~rv`.zz© ¢~r\é’_rx'\' and LQ\Q\L 'X~L-\e R\o\\\._l»\~\,\ ~\--0

‘&\<§~\L€t.¢=s=\'& ;\"\'\er~»-\$Q\..~€S Ff'=_@1*€<>~ i~< hm-
`¢r$ \..>e_k,.L \i’¢,¢zmeg mg mm md\,_\\.\s, \»\i.< -\-vza\`+ s ame\_.e.¢s V.,

s -\ ' \ l q ' - `  , ‘
`¥QA. “*_\A\,_`\_s Ge_.g_`o,_‘$ \_e_$s\__\\§e_\_\_,\ +o ‘c>< €_w\ée»wce o %\\

1 ` a ' \-.‘ * `
\\'LQ_ &_§{;`-\  d€p'fl@'\¢¢"\`\»\ t  L~\\S,G-‘\`_{-»§S \ 9 09 a .

 isq.o¥€vm<§ Re(>er;, $\.\pa a, v=w\~ Sé¢`¢-`lo/‘ r-¢L& eru=\~‘\'\`o~»\ S, C"\'\ 1-

_\_G\_;Gn.$ and game xv~.&~e»zn/=»L cl»...o+m(~!~»`@,,,rn¢=¢n\< @"~'~\¥'\“=e<¥',

¢v?$\_._`»"\`c_`q,\~.\. \,.`Q\_,Q ~\-\~e S\=¢rv-»e. e_Lu.e$~\-{@n$ A-\nn&- -&._o~»=\.f D\S\¢_.Qé\

'\' mm '+g<»mer¢°\ n*\=o~& \-\-e cc>n_<\`éef<~=»’vi*@n °"” '@P<>‘-'§ ¢‘*"‘*'S
Y\ V\

, \ ,‘_\m,q», \q <¢~,Q.,@ »r>.\»~\_q o\~ ()~'1@ C.Q<~_\ur\$>

S§Jo s\-f~`£¢\\‘~€\'5 ‘°-*\*~\¢’\`9-‘£)‘"9""5 \""Q \°“(S°-Qa
_ _e,Q »\-enaQQ\ Q>v< P\~v=-ls\'~\e@\ ,
"-'*‘\S ‘=*‘-“*~"~‘°*é‘“\{`\°_€'en n \-. \.<;‘ s\,\¢\-\ s’\+¢..@+‘@

""Y\»~.e Cour;¥ \"\ *5`\"\°'\""9@"""@@‘~\ ~e ` ` n <°`

_Q').)

V\FL@,»\_<_<; ,cec§ur).¢l\- rz_eg_u§me.,-.»~er\’\~ he_c_.e_.§$@ rav\ -\_-O, \`v_-\ ~

l = p\-.er~r\.er\"v .»a ~_S\..\\:»:SA-\"°w‘._\~\-i -¢€~ g'~»\_+=y_f?_q<\“\"€& _\,¢\`~\~\-.  \';L,;Le_ -\-\,\¢:_,-}

‘Q_QA,,`kA»\-eg c>~nl._»\,,\ <\-\»-<: v~»-\a_nner< of n-A. Q&K§3i"{.,;,_`e,¢Q
v=m_e \§ng&an¢eg .\.`v»:c,\>\\»`d-\ a S\A\=,S»\~Qr\~\r"g‘~< Q change ~in »\~\»~e La-
bo ,~¢~»\\,\g+ be a=s\-\~e¢~;\é>e<§~\o\.@ ‘R \>Qoc_eéyo_ e ‘\"'\S+ €’_~r- A\=>‘L.e h p`...

Q,\$bv-. eq -\~c> s‘+\o'ua +\»~r-'s&~ he F’¢=;\_Lg L,.~»'¢+\-\i_»n ~\~\,-\e c_a¥~eg@@%¢>\?~`
»per¢_son-s e,.>\r\om +-\»\e,\~r=¢@ "`~"~Gx»\ vw Lu»-.gevz »p\»»n£s\»-\,[S¢Q n~\.

Fac,\c\e¢_,\ ‘\-10\ L.\.`S_v+&-G‘i?_,n,'\ @p\`n\'o~<- @V: \-\f-\va\-s~)e_ `°\9"`\"‘ Pa~° LQA°“'~QH\” "F"’\é~ 5\»\!.<>$~\-81"\'\~\'\4 Q
\.LA_,,_`*`»,:'\‘LQ,§\'@,`S, 613 `;_\mq\>e mg QA -\-\~ esa ~\-er¢rr~.-_< \r~.e\»<_§'\

\:¢»v)_ e_.\s~=\ r~»-~p\..»e,\_,¢\r\e»,~. van QLe`w~Q,-c\~ O\: Fr C_f¢~`mfn»=;?\. OF`\:e_r\sQ
`\`;s c\e.c=.me.r~\»_~`<_~‘reé \~\" '
Ae¢ \l»-»r-¢¢\- o\.'»`~\”-en$e Q.e c.e`\~es 9 hew ~\r)`\`r~\\. _»->\~er¢¢ `\~\~ e_g ~
@\¢@f?-vxfv\€r\"\' ~h'-\»\$"\’ P*'LO\¢Q `\`\'\& p\'a;$ofw€¢£$ JC,D“\Q[,\,¢Q-\~ S'¥\'\-L
E'\'\`$ ‘-+>"\'\'\; n '\'\ne v~r\@~e¥;\:\`. g¢\~ d€\r'~`\'n\'\~`\€n €>\T 'Hr~.e T_R\'¢~.»-. €,, in
\Q'S'\\rv\`»\~*°*@ \¢€{v\,  en ¥-\'»~.e 'L_D‘"\ S-\-\V\'c/»'¥\'\>,,»»P"¢<>V'»'i\=>{'\-‘$ 1991-
Hm&~\".a\»-.Lr-\r¢ ;°‘"L~""'~ °\: P"\*”"; S@nv'nen\~ P"Ova 9 L\_%g_¢ o¥'-' p¢_.»p_$°v_`g_'

\=\~f- ~'-\\`~"\:ec&~e& \-.~»f*-`~S\>n€r¢ rze¢e`\_~¢e$ a paoce<é»w\ze &b~.v>_o\`¢¢\., L,,-
V\\`, C_\f\ `r\€.'CR\"\ S`F\O\.§D  `¢\€ `O&Lbr\_g$ »'\~'O  Pn_o  <_L _,
»A'$S _ Sec H~\~\clv\$ w \-H¢L§`cn§f-`+ 536 \J`S _`39'-1 g\-\QZOO‘?,\ Qrze ~

c§_c»\§nc`v\rj n  c.er§~¢,,,v;e ~\~o <:\e-\-em»r~r-;`\ne l,o\ne&\¢~.e_¢z \Fo pg,»,_.ygc,,_`g-__
\,=,.,4_ \`v\C\`\\<\'¢-LL.\CA\_, 1~»0\\-\\ \F=\~‘\ \Vvv\~el_l_€,c\~mr=¢\. é\`.$ Q\o'\l,\"\-\.\" \':GL,_

L_s \..>v'¢\»\{». \~\-»1 monge @\: \~`»\\~e\_t_e.¢_+u<§\_\_.»\ Sis ~=\\<,Le<§ ¢>F\:.

e,n¢i¢=,r¢s ¢q\<,c~>L.,-§- \Ao`v~¢>m \-\»»e_+v_e \`_g Fc n\=»-’\-\‘Q¢~.AL "Qon»se»,-.u,g ‘*'

\-L\r>¢:\~ 'C¥€_¢\,<'\‘\'bn ’\`S \~r‘Y\(.>e_'rL\/Y\.\:'$S `\B\..Q)_

F\pp\.-§ t_¢:\<\-\~ 'F\,».a..\-\ne_»@ Lc>~»»’ven<$ ~\~\r~.q.\_ -\-\¢\e<;g \`3 -\~\.oc>

‘=°‘""""‘*‘~Q-»\_-\vw"~eso\.\¢ee\ Ce>~»-‘*¢R>:>\¢»'d-QQ§ \-§Sc.»e_< \-\»~Q\~ 'F-ee£ +6
\>@_@ *o_eso\_\¢ed_

Q\ \`>oe,$ \"r\o~»~»\-go.~.,@¢>_\,\ Q--\»`\-\-\._<=_ »¢=.\..L. A'».,\\¢e,n'~Le`~‘S \>o_§(op"¥o

'Pu-V»\` S\f\v~r»'€,vx'\~ n 'C_ov~»$§ cl&rc¢-`(\`\On e\: -\-\r~.e§.v¢\ 'L».,~.Lp~r=»\;§|_.l"\*\»\ 95

Q‘z\

l

° s%a-\-eé. (.,` S»<_\~, .su\>¢a,e\~ ‘35`5 \'Y\~<\¢\¢_e\` ¢-§ao\ u\';. ,~=s%.

zinc q S-§[o k_x~$'_‘_go‘-() 'S\"\Q°Z.DOQ_) DQ_$Q;‘\‘Q \:`Q'\¢\C_») ‘$€V\'~\~€.~-
Y\Ce '§_o l_~`\:_»e'u>\Q.\-, pF\fLD\-_Q €\_c&-¢‘Q,\L\”\`l~\?,
   \`$ §1€<~€5$'@\'1\,`  §L.¢.\l€vr\\'\..€$ 40
be ¢LGS§€'<'~'»"»\:A and ¢Lv~A-€~\-\-ec\ &-o f~`¢ p\»\nisb\m¢»~.+ \»werwz.‘j~g \»\~ ~
\E,\»» &n¢L\..\Q\eS-\-\»-»@ cor\-_g{éc’_r;~r~'s&-\' on o\'l G>ne`$ Q\.»»L\:)m\r=»'= '\.4\»\
95 &_'v‘ri Q¢£ x§n (Lop@_a_ @~r\¢\ G~\zr-;\»~._cav,~,"@

‘?KQ`~Y -:co *'-=%3¢;%'2.<1 \4¢@.<\».~.\\ sww~w;

. c  
\~\mq»\~ ¥\r\€_ \:O(LQ<§,O\'~'\% \75 '\*\’L\A€_ Qr\a\ `Lo&f?..€c_'\‘ -’Qf\o_\ \:~n`gg \~’--.

P_,prn  '

\Zw»e¢v_&ec,\ ¢»v~, 4_\.,;'5 C\q\_e 5['243!291@ )

 

x'z.<»w\ \=»m \