Court Opinion

ID: 3677270
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-07-06 06:23:38.716217+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T15:25:37.849771
License: Public Domain

At February term, 1854, of Robeson County Court, the following is the entry in this case: "Defendant not allowed to take the oath; fraud suggested. Transferred to the superior court." This transfer was intended to be in pursuance of an Act of Assembly passed in 1850, concerning the County Court of Robeson. There were no specifications of fraud filed in the County Court, but specifications were filed in the Superior Court, at spring term, 1854, and the cause was continued till this term when, the defendant not appearing, a motion was made for judgment by default against him and his sureties. The motion was opposed, on the ground, that the cause had been sent to the Superior Court prematurely, not having been put at issue; and his Honor being of that opinion, ordered it to be dismissed, from which judgment plaintiff appealed. *Page 320 
The question which has been discussed before us, and decided at the present term in Thompson v. Floyd, (ante 313) does not arise in this case. Here no issue was, nor as matters then stood, could have been made up when the cause was transferred to the Superior Court. The 10th section of the Revised Statutes ch. 58, entitled "An Act for the relief of insolvent debtors," provides that when a debtor, after having taken the necessary preliminary steps, applies to the county court for permission to take the benefit of the act, any creditor may suggest fraud: whereupon the court shall direct an issue to be made up and tried by a jury. The Act of 1844, ch. 31, sec. 2, (Ire. Dig. Man. p. 118,) prohibits the court from permitting such an issue to be made up and tried, unless the creditor, his agent or attorney, shall file his suggestions of fraud in writing.
From the record it appears that no suggestions were filed, and no issue made up until the cause was docketted in the Superior Court. It was not therefore, while in the County Court, in a condition to be taken to the Superior Court by way of appeal, writ of certiorari, or otherwise, and his Honor did right in dismissing it for want of jurisdiction.
PER CURIAM.                                  The judgment is affirmed.