Court Opinion

ID: 4048121
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:33:42.621302+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:39.898624
License: Public Domain

["9§1/2/9 1219 14 009232 524

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

, 919911;9999 1»:9919 1259 911 1995
MARlszms 9 /€/Q/FKM;
324 @P~’I'é 292 129’::'2‘::219?%199 72 123 _
9 / n
/_40‘[101/ ‘1’ 01 ~ 20121515;/_5{@@2411 Q;:§YM___
T \ . . _ 4 L v 28‘!¢¢1
\"4 ' `44‘ ):~)‘(" ~ 444 5 §?i'? 21126_201§

 

 

19 _1_99 119999911997999_9159 95/91199999999___

/1/09/ /911113 _24%_€/(1911924 /4@114 flaw/1111 59194 _291155;_

121515__25511__512111:4__\1_0_50195//@1~ 2%195/199/ amaew.%¥

w aA/L54 5)(//11:&245 117 §19/;?901¥ 025/01// EJFY€c,(MS/’//“_~
. er_¢L\[:£L ____`_021_1‘1291__ 245510924€_ 2401 0924 1224 471/141 ‘
_9/ 24101:1;/:401 475/1390 /1/.\/12/ 412 have a ~41/// 7:19\944'5
2211/101 (:¢§AP 112 3 (19§)

_,Lfl {5001201/`4 her'€@“p_ 11501)54 S/UQ/ 456 244//011/241/1<19»'

:f_

/h€ €x515124: 1'17 §4/5/5__/17024/11779_91/1/415%021/ %9¢_
_11224121;)17551_¢1_@5__5.92.451¢15@121/ 774 a /1//;/¢)9 l.///}m 1 11

` __2/559L// 2[191911__550_/(/212921@99111]/ 250 552191 L/a%____

' _0_24_9 9 959/191519925;9/21_/0_ \/_'//QMV 2//4~@22/;¢12_1, 915

' 24 211111@/11 12122[/_'1~L11/a,s 2211/291 440

_/2150 _15/14€_244€3~€ //0@1/114591241 >4121` /'a_%_$/A{é/fa/Waa¢ 051/1

21/21.24 24122@152911\4 /75<2_@01/5{ 1`5 1`12 501/reef 5 2_/0 4 \

. /01/2414~ 024 7/ /aj» a,m/ jug/7a 1224 55415’_(;9_§§4/?_ 50 3:§9¢2))_

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

f\
\1)

 

 

 

/h€ 14@0@/40/1054 /0€//1@41£@4$4_%€_7$5 @/14_/$5%_2[.€__
944_£1084110,/ irl irl 000151€410 wm i€l … is //ii_iiirzi/e
_ )111#>4 111/01// §€4€01/45 /64411342‘_//0\4/40:1144/0 1_4_/@¢14\§@4:
_éL/Oirl?' 11/_4\@41_44441_@40/¢4/0£/@0/11151112/17011% M/
__ 7@/11211/£-:1¢/1_141>41 >Aeie 111/// ée 011/11 /11_14@4
44&€)144\€ "‘ "';~*`~f~":'~l~’ r§i_:/_ >[4[@//

;Q!d}\ew¢bre, premises /ailrsljei: @4_4 41):4 444 _Feazw
14_4101@€_141\4,_0__11¢€_ 1_114441 1412 114 ely/34 '_ 1141 1134/aa

4 447 E/404111:4_ fe_$/r) 114044 4411 441_) )04;1£041/§ [\4/4101¥1 434\~¢
40 1012

14010§£4[0%7[0_ 4:4_1441)14’ A 114/§ 1_1)_}4 €10111§114@,1\

1414 144/@5141!10113' 0 \//04/0041/014_ 540\/0¢[11/1 %4/0@/411443
l444/4 414/0144 40 /4401’1>4£_

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

740 § /04€4¢4“/4411 /4/4451/1141`¢)[€/.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

F`\
\."/

l l pause A/O O(a'~/‘/- 00&3‘}(’{

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

. dark E\/qemé EAQLQ /0 %/¢))M( mo /7;5/9_0@£?
. 1. - 1g l \ ~»_~a
,)<\l,o//)€ %m(€ ` /\g,x___a__o_»éc?/wc\_ ,
_ . /€)§15[§ l /;vé&/érl//ae 0/7 iga/jj /OB/ZO/§' '
§044 04 044 ._ __[ju£)é,§’?`_ __ZF/i/M_ZZ _ZfM~._¢_,_Z);_JZZ/_(?_

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

__l_a,|;a[~¢ .;,-s\» §01\`(’6¢»\>($

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

355
l ;:4@¢111,' 09 441.\93 01
:v\c(e>c oil Aui/£\orlil65 3 5
%(mumevd" 214 51)0404‘¢ op E><)’\;|O¢`jf -A Arre$i \/\[armm>{~ ` /3
EX)";)°;+ 5 01~1’¢\¥14@([,0114¢3(013145(~ /5`
§E)ljr E SuLSSU§idem§C /ém,_a/am)£ 526
57<14¥ 1034 F /\/{0~[1*0145 ~Cor‘ E,)OP@ 360
ZEXl/\§lmi ii A-QQI&\W`/s id Sd¢()£{)OH-Ldpvofev~ Proc€c{<)lf€, x

(1`3

,____I.€[€/v\`l$\ly ' 00 IDCLv`[-I€LS

>¢_1,,¢ Q_/(Wc ; »/1@,74§ 513 MEV¢¢,_/.e_,
/ 'Ll:ovwm£)[¢a 5 '7»/¢&,~€ “E.-eacowg

(.,z§

»4 :[MQ@\C 041 AMOF\€L/e$

o' ,

,qM \/ SMQ /§5\45_4 404 /0_§' @x€m 444 2000\ v »
5 344 v$(w(e 414$4!,24;_45“,344 (/ed.»,W(W/%/ 4/) 4
` '
v 97 ' K;os_ 4 S(@£e 90/ 54 14 z¢[ 704‘70(;_§7:&;(4/,0_$@/4§(¢@4/_0/?@_
L§M&,\/\/eMLLSL_S_W/ZJ 444 '~/5/3»5{4@//€¢»<[4,4 //e,m,»,émioléf:)
"4 ' ,(§kob\ \/F\qgmwj\ 540 l).§¢ §§/` §z/OOL/> ~

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

/1 501 l/ 1494139 472§4/404404~31 2311 5444 4113
514/4 `4'~1‘ 31 411 225 3911 2222/5505§_11125152214_1_14_44_’0/2__

§40¢416_341112 64520,3£ 34/`41<12 0,420{151253[ 12/11 3 'F§ _M
/3/00 /0145‘04123'- 310 5 514/1504 1122ch 140¢4/144 014 4//`.214/
_/(124/' /'212404/_22/2! 25;14’3”2 afm/214 39412_%45’5011§2/4~
_511/€ 4521424" 5€1431
514/441 5 415 3942 01/¢4/1/114/ 5024/2_4/1421’ 1004
22/245010214/‘€_[%6415»€ 405 31/112 155 02 1913 %L&Kfc%#
441124:4514/2131 /142 __5_£224 11/2_ 04 1@1)241§2._ 1422§_ § 2414/24
2_)_111512411321_~

3 ¢ 251/4_/2)1 4 434 1412 522211_41/2,2,@_%4 21&/2___ .

__ ,g2,;%__,24 _.2€_
2 ` 1%2214 .
‘ 431/14 /;)/`_>_/5_3912~2_2>‘11_341441//_3[_3/30552220121<444%441
_'3111236_ 442_ 22/_6_2_5’31113/2114241,€/§ 2§_D_40_5 21M_4_1_10_39
<_/4)19$3112413[4’14 342 1411/5 1£/42'¢4¢423//014 /3/0 13_3§@/14< 1/121_3__!45041»7
24)_`/2244_2 7)_0~2, 1231 211 b/\/A 1424111114§4§ 2211 124412 1022_1;_`_
44241231} }v2_ 12244[;/52142_5:51104_1)5 391/12 244/141;/131 311/1123
332/45121/_ 1/0_4:/2122_23/:13L0)! 2 244 344/1242 036 4/\/1?154_5021;1
» 4:4/2 441 12 41252_1 22 2224_ /222/'2/ 2,2_1/
/1”2142242/£___052 12343191~ 39421/ gal/492 114 312394

3 _.2§2_1)_2 4452 ¢1112. 001 394~252_144/094 41/14142142243'1
. 3100 5313 421 (`@4:: 212_4` 313/04454/`01/\§1123§ ’

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  
 

 

 
   

 

 

 

 

 

643

 

'° 2214/241 412 422 2112/2212 2222442422 »
712/1 44114~54104>1 31<) )1\1-1!1‘212~2 16201_ 4111101;2_31>1;2~24/‘22
4110£ 11 39111414/104 01 _ '20_0_$2_22_-1_/`1_420£42
` /’012§’03 /O_L/_ 3 ' _" ._ p2142'v`541020317 '
’ 242\3122 1141"2 10;(’2)292 ' "1\4111 1124421222 1222
_ 3/\1141~=1=1 AW/Qe”;%¥ 111113 42031 132/22§21/1212 3142
4 22__2@)2215_1¢31104(_ 0317___9126121)22_1221)11_8_ §\1021`/00/€29
EX_):I/; 01392§_4_3_£,\ O \@15192155 397 511 411/l

- __ _21201411_21112212!12/_14_0121192 224:9 241~1242/2/ 1/24~4/
' _/14‘2312 40 2714 36422 411/2p2204131 00121 11212/122/2_310

' 22222_7:__ L@a 5\_11112}_01{0_1/` A/Q 21_5.204/€
~ .2227_ 522 1901:2__2222 §421/\17:@2 1229011§232>012 5§1434/ 1,
_91~0_1212/1_/ 6/ 6015€/0211/404 61 50_ 25 2020012¢19/ /1706'/33910101019 2

2254(/2/4 42 11 2222/1_ 4_5_4_91_ 301274‘1911\/439§ 1422 /4/'\/2/ )113993134421/
1021/040 6041»444’,3939@/ 396 3991~227 4/\4’12/ /41/1~19 390 5_0/4/001~`9

2_222149/5110/552 9

341€\>011124131 421/494 191419424»11/2§

v _ 34/% 22/144123' 43 0§419/31/1¢1. 394/3 49/‘ 01£0//2_/121/1»09

__6’01'1§/ 27]1624292§4(4141 2 /217_ 252/29 01502317/014 039
1547/11 01/1/395}/’{9015/7411//19/85’ 0 //01“/€$

(Z:/’OVM 942th 1/222 52`9_6?2)§€ 957§¢1/3/3697/09/ /O§'_ 972)_(22 551/1422

2_ 2 1302 222_00_0\2" 72 001/1317 039 1{/1_[700/.< 1112 r2 1)1/;21[2 810 52_1/_/210_

. _2\12151/ 11156134141/102137_4’ 15222/32112 2 411 32 2222/3502 ,,

_4_3942‘22214!%20_$2}2367/2`®42_039 3942 20/ ”5‘22`12/§70 /rap 3// 1661\;: l

f _52\4423_ \/2§<1212,230272& 121 (222;51’1‘7:19/(2 172;41104~142 11 42 /Q‘i/_\
. ‘ §

     

 

 

 

 

 

 
  
  
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

           

 

 

/

 

354 gmi/1424 21/\@5` /1/\/45 414/3 2\4\.45 c50 €,)`@44/'44
. 555\`€ ;01”05 2045)5;7_¢41/$@54~€5 52/5;\€ MaWea/` 075 CMRL
' _41/ reg_\-L_ "355_€>455_/1/(_455 55_514_ 74 444/54455 1243
__ lé/Ife _0‘5 /114/1/(4// rOc€frC/NFr/e_ /b Q_/ 43
_5‘51:§1{€/°___ 0_55/_0_43_ ~5'0r EX414L41/4 /r/a/: /`:ee_ L_

745 511 41 417 741/1544 47 1111
5 __M 14 37(441/5214 1144 415245 5 €_1`\/€¢5_48 M_ 44{\/41/`30,_/1:1447_
- __1;0_ C'_e_e -_1_14_/_ ` ` _0_11”<_._21_'\50 \'H/\P 4102)459 4

 

 

 

 

 
   

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

        

 

 

 

"_(§Q 14<3_€_ " __\__.____ US:U 4 [5€\5€14\5207/( (')_~‘5~
_441_ 44445_34/ ,_5550_2£444/_ 41:@5_64455_/414 _44¢4_
_ ..__5555@4¥_/441 445145555 /¢54_5_@)444_41414_4_1144315754444

 

 

 

_550 4044/1_4_>_5_ 441/1454/5 5/554 55//\e 1454qu 444‘_.;` ,_
_LA14_'é):4/411_414¢5 5ij 45 74 /41~44_44€’4541#4__45_5"_ 455
___ 7 _CML€_-a 100455¢/11/554 \/o ;//seo_\/ef V//ue_
`».&3_ 445 €_4?_€14_1_14352 /) 1744 , , 2\/41/1 _)"555 4€/ \/3454[_14_/5_

_§>54
_QhMM/V€I'_MLW V:/:\:Lr). 0_55&41_55114// '~55 01`48 191/1955 75151`

%4_,01/5.044455101_4_0_55 4_551:2 45_ 4'_€/48_€_ 411_4)414/41)?
551»5£5/16 411`611/45;7/14 /L_@_C/5_55_ 544/_5_“5&13_£_5)01`1)1/1'005€3
955 251qu 1557 41574441_0<_4/44_/445/5 Z/@_/_’S_s;"a_@_
_4/_4:_£&_4074_5 /;_541:4424/55_"7_'21/_;4__ 44414/31/(_ _.~. _ZLC
f _€01_4__ 424 [//_:14_ _4 4_§_£_5£¢:% _€_5/44/` 515/v /)/ 2434 415
5444_11/ /_5_55_4_ 55 1445 7501/1145 /l/ /m,ba/§/e /445€_
_\44142_%_€_4441_/4455 _£_/474/ 4041/"_/45510_ _41_45_ 544445_
1€”0544/4' //445=€ A914551/ 551/444 750 555/14 144/144 /e)r¢s’

. 5 0¢@ 05 /?/:/44_/544/ /mc'e¢// are )151~\520/€ /(o /é ¢Z,552411411/111/1¢11 \01"15_1,0 -1:\5_13 beam 6511¢/1.10/5:1353_3_
51551:0531513 5111111_10111151 13 /\/0 //005101/5, f
_3__51 511,133€3551503£0015 51551553550/_ §04530/_053 _[S_ _ _ 515€:¢0:

@VK__W\Z 15_1;5/1)3 %5433111512¢3/;5133/5511;&;5?35 330

:51 12353<:10 3 735/zell /5_14353 15 555/3

14 114/144144144 1114 1144 111/§1”1;41/4/1/44141
-._ . [331>? mold/05 /51%5~ 5005 11/5_035 111/151505 551/150 551>051550
9105_ 0150515_ Dv€ process \/1’0 550/014 @111051~3_T
\/ 51551€, ’7‘15“5 \1\/251"934 937/§15144”5. 1451/ __5LD131

193/3 454 1’50"5(\ /\/0 0145 1131/1055 511@3@,115€1)11( 131/435:53__
-'__5_1\401)_09 1)€3£(€(_1_1§1_\(€ 551 adm 1~101'\11~1@1\/6_1&_1\/1/\313\//
Q`_/L_\_e._ 5313 . 13 31514153, _`_5/_1150._`1113 11 31531"0_\41$_1_'om
333/1113 511411;3 [@C 10 30513_ /56611351\/53/1.1@0 55/ 5)_1: 520§1:56’_5150€50

1 _ 114 1105 151111_1').1053% 105315536 _1’_$0_(_'01/050_ /1511£5_055133;
/111111’ 001 011~ 1151,_1:11./140¢10_ 103;/153551:5_514_ 5./_4_80!':1_050,_9105_
\/511£ 011/1`/~_80101)3150_3/33€3§_€2/~3 51§ 150 63 320¢/451§__ 5Lr:0§1.01_2*"-_
' 3331 31453<05/351/3114_5351)15575/1455 1111¢1¢1 d 531»1/§9355450
333 301:114_0_10_/551! M.é%_/l_%_i$jai:>§_ 511@_§00153031`83 1340_03
455 5531:50551/3 011/1430 530515 51 1301 133121114,4_/51’1_4_,3
.*51/3/150_“/_<>_%133501415/511°14/1[ 51/_65121// MZM 1/$ 511 `1/5

_5?11433 51/2¢061/1/$001/0 551,1"/'”

'('7`)

 

 

 
  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 

 

 

 
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

.
g 1 /22 223 1109/110 22117_11 _02_1001;_
_z/)(M 265/44 52,)(009 /_'4&_§’02/_/§_§1401_//9_£9;%40!9/ / ~
_ 101/550 a~[am 492/0 020 02192//4/@ a 5 00/ /e.- __
902/age 014 577 09 1745/:’00//4 ,//Z'/~a_ _0%/_00_ ;/ /’€_0000//2/
__/)_Lé(_$’_ Q/’§£Q 0/amy 2009/awa 0_/“ 49mys' /a@ /P€;a/J/e_
_044022§9.__ _49_€ 900 __602,§6 m_l/_Q_S_ 0_¢0)00) 010
_899;€_ /100/ /0_09§49)/930404501500/14§02/…
_02/010_ _2:`9\0 §9/4 /]0/92/$40200/9 554020/700/ 590#/09 044
_0/1/?_/_ /`0/ //70 /9\0/05 dam 900/409/02” §0 4907' _
0/0222_4 __15__0 200 §0/4 1189 1;5_'10/09 1/12»/004/ /@0
` ' _899.€_ 5 1029/1 0990_2/251_ 04 52X00//455009 §19241
._\/_90_222 09 309 5 1930 79/ /7&,)0. 910/112 1410 20/0 ) 909/m
_>9)%0219)%02240_00::[/0//02»/8921_r010/2/€/_)2a_'2d 1‘5 mr/ 22412»/ /m
' mmmy 40 2100/amy 001/2_0200/95_€096_9_€£ 2140/9 490 4
_:a 2121201 04 ama 992/na 1009120_0 1/022~2001_2¥_89_91)4
99094901_0/%0899202/ 492241210j 40 900 §a);;‘aéé_.K/OS
\/ 5301@ 90/ 5 b\(£c{ '701§§__‘70¢_@§><_2_._1050/1//)99280)120 /_4;§§§
00_20@/_`9_\_2)7.04_9_4/99\_0_/€)<03]905‘[/79/ 89011_1_ 00041_0/4]_
' przo'v//{é 4915/3 0 5_0_02:0_9_12/02’0/:0109_0/0§02~/90 899_0_
20/0€€; 40 /0€050002'£69009_0$_17_€_0£0_5’ 1909 _/o_e, 9 \_/6£/2)09
' __5002009_1/00)00/9! 1004 012.2_8§0/_//2'__ 0_029§020/214/012 09
490 120 900 40 9 a 001/_129001_9£ 7/7[/_79_@_0/05020/04 /014
__0‘02140}_)00/_ 20_lf\/e la_,$a S+ajamayd% 0/`
___M ls_[aad_a/LQ _Cl:mj/L_@L aaus_’.a_ __ amaal aa/@/ 1 -
"_§lG_lOa/L wl ‘U\a w/Janaa_=_EQZ /'O/Z///zaa@//j(__
flle mme Slo /ém)a) _§éjaa_€_M/QX __

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

j%a_a_v:@ldé@u/j$l, /éz aaa aS_/_@___
,~___HQM Ié:i/l/ gm /44 dwe_Da l€_._/aa/ a\/€aj_é_€__
1 _A /; jada/§_éaL/\ /Qal:§az4_. _é,EO_I_L \/. _zcw/UE€_Z, 5 ‘/0;__
lj$ §5`/ 610 /AM,l/_$l_aal/0140La\aa1\ wheat a al a/a¢j_¢/_~_
:__/0451_Z 4%_./_’¢2//_14/14_/;“£7§€¢§_ aL.aa/_%aa_a_/§_S_p fdzojl
‘ ~ _/1¢) //§a zlam/aa//alaML¢),S€_aaa):/_114l_)a¢zz§l/£al§z
€\[l/i~é_auw will/0 /G~€_ bUnA/M}_j(l/jl})/), /' ahl- é'¢Y/j~`
aaa /0_0 5 /’¢ 137/ Pwv¢/xar:_ jja$a/ara___ja
:/SUHL zjz/Szma §)La\/MS_,_//)a/(/_ loa_
S'€I IZ_€a/ /j}&$ _/Ml/d,/¢a/ 014 /}LS llcl€€ //IO¢£J/#;
Slamjl_l;z/w \H/wcl’ €¢§114L §wak
1151me 5155|1@4>£1514 111/149 Wouqk 543@11@,1»§
' '051/1;50$1144_.53@5£5//@1:1<_€1:1;15_€1£_12541”4111! 1‘ 4
L)M/INMIJ 5005€. ma S€cuf&i\ 40 \W\Q)[l 1‘45[1*0030€0{
_ 114 050//04_\£_151/1.‘ M£(
/3\ 351 45 550 A (111>1413/ [.75)55_10_05 5»45@}:11@4¢1145(34`®
560/vw 111/10 1405 55€541#05@5447 1.)3(,,¢{A
110011\¢0/1/\>¥ was 14'0`@ wm )`HQ¢{ 40 354/*/3/_02_
IMVWUVI `L " ' ' 5
' \/l@ /)GHOVI (') - n fl /FVEMQ[WIEM$GJ/cA>L
40 54 5045051 51/031;1:1£142€ _&LLL@$Q/y41»¢/a5/M /5 1,
. /1/551> 145 es %541:11143_,_@/0 0@3_ M(é_é. 55_ _/§_ 4/51/€
,014.01L5j1 \¢0@951¢ e £5/~//34!£0 Se/

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  

 

 

 

 

 

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

(/14 5;11)_01:':1/_1.®_¢_04`@1`50£1514 5

 

 

 

 

l SM}eaf;UV.LL(€A/` Moj‘{~u 530 5€4<%`\1)\1~4 q/{/\®L '
_q;$\_e_`$£a:@e,wi 951/1>@5_£14314! 14 \@0( 114\P 114€0~01'1440¢£#13141/":§§ l/\0VQ_¥`CLe;1\/Qc(

__. KJ/Lou)_,~m:_e¢:éw 0 034/f 1 011»1"5431

E<€C¢£€/ 514 _~51115_1{51/

. V(]cugak 7"¢£` olO/$`

 

 

 

§1140@1/€/17 5551141?\*>£€0¢

 

 

.\ - l ` UNSM)OWYID€,Q[Q/ra§l]o;% §

 

 

:l:` §m)€`cu" U_W{Q€F oww§~(~q §§ peru/rd \[/§\4>#
\14444(@44414444\>(5_ 40 14\§4/_14_ 44(4_}_/:1;94/1419_4 E>§_4:4144 §:Z_§,
JiZZ/ZZL£§ __..4_7_;_/441;§4414/ 4514._,_444/ /4/4 544/4
1 04~/144)[,04 l 44\441;444/ Veg/414M/€14414,/4e7
` 4€/`4 §§V`:/~P owl/f /’0»4%44)(41/(¢()14§_£___4?%54%:/:
504 (’@1»14 441‘#4¢[_540_4@40444464'_»4/: ___£4/4 44

404)4»/1 0'§ /i\@ 444/ug 445/1144

 

 

          

 

 

 

 

§___EX€MQQ// __414_€4411’_5_ 444

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

. 44 ",7% @?O/S°` _ ,
A/{@W&/V_;SLLé_/i///_$é!€€//
MSQ@%:
/Um §4,
._

 

 

(/r §§

v . ' l y ` ' pmc/er 4 .
__ _ /)Z{ _Y f ___ _______ /74,£ / /4%
_ 4 jj¢;ee_ca;L/{_g M%S :Z//Z__ dye _4_%_5/0€»44@/{:44% __

, 744/_ f€e51e4_ c)_e__ eeo/se 494 4 4/ e¢z/_’s_/__ ___

:04_4€_44Me/_V:4 Lz/e_)§)e%/ amf A¢zek /~Zocj%e 4
¢4/4,[ 401/4)( )(:’04 M mmi e~£ \[/ _e_Mo_¢'_/O_?(__
\£04 /\/eu) 74/4/ gin ij_z/:_W )[j__eZ/:¢/d@___: M__

0465494)”~ 441 4__ M/.//\/»m /~s/e 0le ease___o_
£0//@/§/.944/ egfcwnef M 4 /)// Fm///Lk§

/L/QM hm, ,

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_4'44 /)’4/’4444 44 _ ;_Q/e/` `ez’

c?///%/} /4/ 44 .3 »/d » /f j _Q¢_//

7/,//!` /MU//S,./ FU/{ /`c@¢“O//__f/_,`y /:'/#//4»/ 740
///C A/" 544/4 04 44444/1 feezz /¢;J_/j
,Qz. 4/;’/ A’/ /»/7'/7 //@/~ 44 C@,/..//z»/// &,//%
_ Y?/” 54 414 £5/44//77<,747/4

 

 

 

 

 

 

(11)_

717 r re 561 \/{&/l/"Va/¢/L/{`

IHE STATB OI4_ T.EXAS

Warrant# f // :Q in /41,<»\1’-\‘ County, Texas,

 

 

and *ta_king his bond, acing him in jail at E‘¢§§;g gmmzr §`\`~.
I actually and necessarl y ' ”__ miles 111 the service of this writ, in addition t`o

any other mileage I may have traveled 111 the 3e1 vice of other process in this cause during _
thesam_e_trip. . . . ,_ _ , ..

 

 

    
 

' FEES Makin Arrest $____ Randu Meelcs = ' f' _
Taking Bond ___ Hunt Coantu, Texas ‘ . .`.B attainmende
Commitment ` » »- » . lgelml$y:, 1 O_nd 15 $ 5 1
_Releas'e ‘ "¢?< id} iii
:`D>
©Wir and .t}..E;-;-.d;fol§e.ar_ou-ndnam)n'{(§_?"een.ville,`;.-Jane Doe 2012-264981stat3€1"' that;f';
Police car`gort behind ~M ark-at a stop sign and that is when she was dole to exit the car and
leji the area. -]ane Doe 2012-26495_’ 11111s»ai11’e to contact Jarnes Clark. Jane Doe 2012-
26498. stated that she an'd~Jarnes Clark were on their way to Princeton when Jane`Doe
2012_-2_6498 began to tell`James Clark,~u_`)hat~happened. Jan_e Doe 2012-26498 stated that
James. -Clark' turned his vehicle around and ' brought "her_" i`to?" the _-~Greenville " Police ‘ ” _
Departrnent. Jame"s`"Clark then took_ Jane `Doe‘ 201`2~26498 to Hunt Regional Medical ~' ' t

- C'enter where a sexual assault examination was done by 'a Sexual Assault Nurse .
Examiner_ :. . . ~;-' '~ " ~ , . » `1' : .

   

`1

     

 

   
 

_ -- J_ane Doe 2012-26498 described»'-‘Mar "'-§as.fbei1`1g.Markfrom Wat_agua and that=he‘drove a'
_.w_hite Saturn; Sergean-t'Steve Walden~»and-Narco`t`ics~Inve'stigato"r `.`Fason Smith traveled;to__‘»
Motel 6 to look for the white Saturn._ -Sergeant'Walden_ located a white Saturn_ bearing
Texas License Plate DJ7C316. Sergeant'-~Wal'den~-requested»`a"motor. vehicle registration- i' `-
return from Greenville Police Dispat'eh.l `.-"Fhe .-.-`1;1')hit3 ‘Satu-_rn returned as: '2000»`Saturn_2_
door registered to M ark Engle 7628.Cedarhill: ' Ft. Wort'h;. Texas;- Sgt. Walden had a view 4' 1
j--ofRoom 123 and saw a white male fitting the-description that Jane Doe 2012-26498 had » ' :. .- 4
given Sergeant Walden.get out _of this"white- Satu'rnfan`d go into'room 123 "at M otel 6. Sgt._' ’ ' '
"Waiden"`oi)'served` th`e`veh`icle ~ leave?:`*the- 4?1"1;"51'31 parking lot and the white Satu;rn_ was -
stopped for a trajj‘ic_violation. .The_driver.of.'the<'white Sat_u-rn was identi`]ied‘_as Marlc~ ' ` "
Eugene Engle,, white male, date of birth'8~22'~'1968. '» ' '- ‘ " -

 

`l_

E><'L\UH¥‘ C

53ka vi M~M 1

§w 3 O 0
SEARCH WARRANT

THE sTATE 0F TEXAS
' FAE§§ D ,".!:..€ c.
COUNTY 0F HUNT EC ' § 33

THE STATE OF TEXAS TO THE SHERIFF OR ANY§PEKEE:OFFK§ER§©EHUNT
coUNTY, TEXAS OR ANY PEACE OFFICER OF THE STAW_ 0F TEXAS, _ @.§;~
---.__........_... Z:;'r:;lv\; '

GREETINGS :

» WHEREAS, THE AFFIANT WHOSE NAl\/IE APPEARS ON T_HE ATTACHED
AFFIDAVIT IS A PEACE OFF.ICER UNDER THE LAWS OF TEXAS AND DID
HERETOFORE THIS DAY SUBSCRIBE AND SWEAR TO SAID AFFIDAVIT BEFORE ME
(WHICH SAID AFFlDAVIT IS HERE NOW MADE PART HEREOF FOR'ALL PURPOSES),
AND WHEREAS I FIND THAT THE VERIFIED FACTS STATED BY AFFLANT IN SAID '
AFFIDAVIT SHOW THAT AFFlANT HAS PROBABLE CAUSE FOR THE BELIEF
EXPRESSED THEREIN AND ESTABLISH 'EXISTENCE OF PROPER GROUNDS FOR
ISSUANCE OF THIS WARRANT; NOW THEREFORE, YOU ARE COMMANDED TO
ENTER THE SUSPECTED PLACE, PREMISIS, AND VEHICLE TO INCLUDE LOCKABLE
CONTAINERS, AND SAFES WITHIN THE PLACE, PREMISIS, ' AND VEHICLE
DESCRIBED IN SAID AFFIDAVIT AND TO THERE SEARCH FOR THE PERSONAL
PROPERTY DESCRIBED IN SAID AFFIDAVIT AND TO SEIZE SAl\/IE AND BRING
BEFORE NlE. _

FURTHER, YOU ARE ORDERED, PURSUANT TO TI~IE PROVISIONS OF ARTICLE
18.10, TEXAS CODE OF CRIM]NAL PROCEDURE, TO RETA]N CUSTODY OF ANY
PROPERTY SEIZED PURSUANT TO THIS WARRANT, UN'I`IL FURTHER ORDER OF THIS
COURT OR ANY OTHER COURT OF APPROPRIATE JURISDICTION SHALL OTHERWISE
DIRECT THE MANNER OF SAFEKEEPING OF SAID PROPERTY. THIS COURT GRANTS
YOU LEAVE AND AUTHORITY TO REMOVE SUCH SEIZED PROPERTY FROM THIS
COUNTY, IF AND ONLY IF SUCH REMOVAL IS NECESSARY FOR THE SAFEKEEPING
OF SUCH SEIZED PROPERTY BY YOU, OR IF SUCH REMOVAL IS OTHERWISE
AUTHORIZED BY TI-[E PROVISIONS OF ARTICLE 18.10, T.C.C.P.', YOU ARE FURTHER
ORDERED TO GIVE NOTICE TO THIS COURT, AS PART OF 'IHE INVENTORY TO BE
FILED SUBSEQUENT TO THE EXECUTION OF THIS WARRANT, AND AS REQUIRED BY
ARTICLE 18.10, T.C.C.P., OF THE PLACE WHERE THE PROPERTY SEIZED HEREUNDER
IS KEPT, STORED AND HELD.

HEREIN FAIL NOT, BUT HAVE YOU THEN AND THERE THIS WARRANT
W'ITHIN THREE DAYS, EXCLUSIVE OF THE DAY OF ITS ISSUANCE AND EXCLUSIVE
OF THE DAY OF ITS EXECUTION, WITH YOUR RETURN THEREON, SHOWTNG HOW
YOU HAVE EXECUTED THE SAME, FILED IN THIS COURT.

ISSUED THIS HLE7%1;AY OF 2 )_» .~A¢/ _A D., 20 \ LAT _(_/;~_ `ZSCLOCK_ /M Mp;e' €W

CERTIFY WHICH WITNESS MY HAND THIS DAY M

 

*Bistri@t Court Juildge
Hunt County, Texas

 

Y::><)/\`,l>r¢ ’)`

72\-~§1@2»7&0§\//`¢ fw
§-@MC'/L\ \/LcO

THE sTATE oF TEXAS n § Saj 3 OO~

CoUNTY oF HuNr §
955 z 1 -
AFFIDAVIT FoR sEARcH WARRANT "

C.A)
r~o
\'. 3

-.-\.\_

BEFORE ME, THE UNDERSIGNED AUTHORI`,I`Y PERSONALLY APPEARED THE
AFFIANT HEREIN, A PEACE OFFICER UNDER THE LAWS OF- TEXA§_,___ WHO, BElNG~
DULY SWORN, ON OATH MADE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENTS: § `

1. THERE IS IN THE CITY OF GREENVILLE, HUNT COUNTY, TEXAS, A SUSPECTED
PLACE, PREMISES, AND VEHICLES DESCRIBED AND LOCATED AS FOLLOWS:

A two story tan stucco and wood motel complex with multiple rooms having a gray
composite shingle roof with dark green and light green colored trim located on the east side
of the 5100 block of interstate Highway 30 in the City of Greenville, Hunt County, Texas,
More specifically room number 123. Motel room number 123 is located on the lower level
of the building which is on the west side of the complex of the property. The front door to
the room faces west. The room number 123 is currently rented in name of _Mark Engle. The
room is specifically marked with visible numbers identifying it as 123 with dark colored
numbers being affixed to the front door which is light green in color and faces west.

Including a white colored 2000 Saturn two (2) door vehicle displaying Texas license plate
DJ7C316, Vehicle Identiiication Number IGSZY1275YZIO7854, registered to Mark Engle.

The suspected place includes the entire room found to be under the control of the persons
described below in which evidence sought under this warrant could reasonably be hidden.

2. THE SUSPEC'I`ED PLACE AND VEHICLE IS IN CONTROL OF EACH OF 'l`HE1
FOLLOWING PERSON OR PERSONS:

Mark ENGLE, white male, date of birth 08/22/ 1968

3. IT IS THE BELIEF OF AFFIANT THAT SPECIFIC CRIMINAL OFFENSES HAVE
BEEN COMMITTED, TO \VIT:

Aggravated Sexual Assault that occurred on or about December 7, 2012 in room number
123 of the Motel 6, located at 5100 Interstate 30`in Greenville, Hunt County,' Texas.

 

4. IT IS THE BELIEF OF AFFIANT THAT AT THE ABOVE DESCRIBED PLACE,
PREMISES, AND VEHICLE IS THE FOLLOWING PROPERTY, ITEMS, AND/OR

PERS ONS :

Mark ENGLE, White male, date of birth 08/22/ 1968

 

Items utilized 1n the offense of Aggravated Sexual Assault offense consi_ t .
fluids clothing items, towels, wash cloths, syringes, methamphetamine video cameras,
cellular telephones, “SIM” cards for cellular telephones, computer items utilized for

bindings.

  
 

5. AFFIANT HAS PROBABLE CAUSE FOR SAID BELIEF BY REASON OF' THE
FOLLOWING' FACTS AND ClRCUMSTANCES:

Affiant, Felicia White, is a TCLEOSE certified Texas Peace Officer with more than 1500
training and education hours and holds a Master Peacc Officer Certificate. Affiant has been
employed by the City of Greenville Police Departmcnt for more than 29 years and is
currently assigned to the Cn`minal Investigation Division as an lnvestigator. Affiant has
been assigned to the Criminal Investigation Division since December 1991. Affiant has
experience and has received additional training in Ciiminal Investigation to include
homicide investigation, sexual assault investigation, assault investigation, crime scene

investigation, and photography.

On December 7, 2012 Affiant reviewed Greenville Police Department Case Report 2012-
26498 written by Greenville Police Dcpartment Corporal Victor Petrea #89. Said report
states that on Friday, December 07, 2012 at 1248 Corporal Petrea #89 was dispatched to
contact a person at the Greenville Police Department in reference to a sex offense. Said
report states that Corporal Petrea #89 arrived and contacted Greenville Police Sergeant
Walden who was talking to a person later identified as James Clark. Said report states

, that Corporal Petrea #89`thcn saw a person who was later identified as_Jane Doe 2012-
X 26498 (pseudonym name) sitting in a chair. Said report states that Corporal Petrea #89
noticed that Jane Doe was visibly upset. Said report states that from Corporal Petrea #89
speaking to Jane Doc, listening to James Clark` and'Sergeant Walden talk Corporal Petrea
#89 found that on 12-06-2012 at about 2200 Jane Doe and a person named Brooke
Addington came to Greenville to visit some people. Said report states that Brooke
Addington brought a baby with her. Said report states that once in Greenville they went

to an apartment complex in the North part of Greenville to visit a person named Darren
Rodgers who is a white male. Said report states that Brooke Addington decided that
Brooke Addin on wanted to visit another person so Brooke Addington lett the baby with

g Darren Rodgers. Said report states that Jane Doe and Brooke Addington went to the
South part of Greenville to visit an unknown male subject Said report states that once
thcrc, an unknown Hispanic male and a person known as Mark showed up at this house.
Said report states that Mark called Jane Doe out of the house. Said report states that
Mark had the Hispanic male and Jane Doe go to an unknown service station to get some
cigarettes Said report states that while at the service station they noticed that there was a

;_S’ite Highway Troo er in the parking lot. Said report states that as they were leaving,
the Hispanic male drove erratic getting the attention o e rooper. ai report states
that the Troopcr stopped thcm. Said report states that the T”gtL:r ended up arresting the

'Hispanic male on dru charges and towing the car they w_e_r_q_iii, Said report states that
the Trooper took Jane Doe to a motef office Hiat was next to the service station. ai
report states that a female employee at the motel took Jan€Doe back to the house where

" "_ Brooke Addington was at (thc house where Jane Doe was called out by Mark)‘._"Said`
report states that once at this house, Janej)oc met up with Brooke Addington._ Said
report states Jane Doe and Brooke Addington went back to Darren Rodgers' apartment to
get the baby. Said report states that Brooke Addington called Mark because she wanted
to meet up with him. Said report states that Jane Doe and Brook Addington went:to’ thief
Mp at I-30 and F M.1903. Said report states that once there Jan_e lime and
Brooke Addington met up with Mark. Said report states Mark gave Brooke Addington

- some gas money. Said report states tliat Brooke Addington left the tru_ck` stop leaving
Jane Doe with Mark. Said report states that Jane Doe got into M";"'"'°’s“-Nehicle which _
Jane Doe described as a white Saturn 2 door at as suicidewt§;pe': oors, Said report

02

 

 
 
 

 

 

 

 

states that once inside the car a red Mustang arrived at the truck stop. Said report states
tl;it`Mark exchanged drugs with the people in the red Mustang. Said report states that
Mark got back in the car. Said report states that Mark and Jane Doe went toward Wolfe
City meeting people to sell drugs to. Said report states that Mark drove down a back road
and came to a stop. Said report states Mark exited the car, opened Jane Doe's door, and
began to strangle Jane Doe with his hands. Said report states that Mark then used a rope
to tie Jane Doe's legs to ether. Said report states that Mark used a belt to tie Jane Doe's
imelmmas Said report states that Mark then '
drove to Motel 6 located at 5107 I-30. Said report states that once there Mark went to the
Motel office and rented a room. Said report states that Mark went back to the car and
drove around and parked in the motel parking lot. §aid report states that Mark got out of
the car and got Jane Doe out of the car. Said report states that Mark took Jane Doe to a
motel room. Said report states that Jane Doe believed the room was number 123. tSaid
report states that once inside the room Mark began sexually assaulting Jane Doe. Said
report states that Jane Doe could not go into detail about the assault. Said report1 states
that Jane Doe was sexually assaulted for several hours. Said report states that at about
0400 on 12-07-2012 Mark and Jane Doe got back in Mark's car. 4 Said report states that
Mark and Jane Do_e left Greenville because Mark wanted to sell drugs. Said report states
that Mark made several stops but Jane Doe could not tell Corporal Petrea #89 where they
stopped. Said report states that Mark took Jane Doe back to the Motel room and began
sexually assaulting Jane Doe again. Said report states that Jane Doe said that this time
was worse that the other time. ”S_aid report states that Jane Doe said that Mark was using
a hand held video camera and was recording the assault S_aid report states that Jane er
said that Jane Doe noticed a comp_uter in the room that had a lens mounted on it. Sai_;d:
mt this led Jane Doe to believe that Mark was streaming the assault on the
’Ihternet. Said re ort states that also began using Jane Doe's cell phone to call
eo le. Said report states that after this assault Mark placed Jane Doe back in the car.
Said report states that Mark drove around town. §aid report states that as Mark Was
driving around town a Police car got in behind Mark's car. Said report states that Mark
came to a stop sign and Jane Doe took this moment to` jump out o or exit the car. Sai
'report states that Jane Doe left the_.area. Said report states that JBe Doe then called a
person Jane Doe and Jane Doe’s mother used to live with who is named Jarncs Clark.
Said report states that Janies Clark was in McKinney Texas when Jarnes Clark got a call
MLI)_<_)_(_¢_. Said report states that Jane Doe requested that James Clark meet Jane
', Doe in Farmersville. Said report states that as Jaines Clark got`to Farmersville James
Clark got another call from Jane Doe requesting James Clark to meet Jane Doe at the
_Valcro station. Said report states that as James Clark got close to that area, ane Doe
. called and requ_ested James Clark to meet Jane Doe at the square in Greenville Texas.
Said report states that J ames Clark came to Greenville Texas and &md Jane Doe walking
lon an unknown street in down town Greenville. Said report states that Jane Doe got in
James Clark's vehicle. Said report states that James Clark was on James Clark’s way to
4 Princeton Texas when Jane Doe began telling James Clark about what occurred to Jane
Doe. Said report states that Jarnes Clark turned around and brought Jane Doe to the.{;‘$(g
Greenville Police Department. Said report states that when Corporal Petrea #89 wa§é: `°'g"
mm$aid report states that Jane Doe also said that during`»he,r"'
time at the Motel Mark kept shooting drugs into her body. Said report states that lames
Clark took Jane Doe to the Greenville Hospital for treatment Said report s ‘_ '
at the hospital, Jane Doe told Corporal Petrea #89 that while Jane ,D" and Brooke
§Sld_ingtgnw in Greenville they went in half to buy a Green 125 m .,¥amaha Said
report states\ that Jane Doe stateZFthat while Jane Doe was being etctatnedF by the Trooper

533

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  

   

at that service station, Mark removed the 125 mini Yarnaha from Brooke Addington's car.
Said report states that this was all the information Corporal Petrea #89 could get from
Jane Doe due to Jane Doe having pain and due to possible mental stress. Said report
states that Holly with the Greenville Crises Center met Jane Doe at the hospital. Said
report states that a Sexual Assault Nursc Examiner arrived on scene to assist Holly and

Jane Doe.

On December 7, 2012 Affiant spoke ~with Corporal Petrea #89 and Corporal Petrea #89
told Affiant that Jane Doe told Corporal Petrea #89 that Mark is a forty (40) year old
white male with a long tattoo of a naked woman on Mark’s back and skulls tattooed on

Mark’s forearrns.

On December _7, 2012 Aft`iant spoke with Holly 'Robinson, Executive Director of the
Crisis Center of Northeast Texas, who had spoken with Jane Doe at Hunt Regional
Medical Center in Greenville while acting as a Sexual Assault Advocate. Holly
Robinson provided information pertaining to Holly Robinson speaking with Jane Doe
about the sexual assault, According to Holly Robinson Jane Doe told Holly Robinson
that Mark penetrated the mouth, vagina, and anus with Mark’s penis, and that Mark had
ejaculated on the stomach, vaginal area,. and the back of Jane Doe while in room number
123 at the Motel 6 in Greenville. Jane Doe told Holly Robinson that Jane Doe was
restrained during the entire assault. Jane Doe told Holl binson that Mark had in'ccted
what Jane Doe believed tW)e Methamphetamine into the vagina of Jane Doe. Jane Doe
told Holly Robinson that Mark had injected Methamphetamine into Mark’s neck and
could not complete the injection so Mark made Jane Doe finish injecting the
Methamphetamine into Mark’s neck. Jane Doe told Holly Robinson that Mark had
shaved all of the hair off of Jane Doe’s head with a set of face clippers. Jane Doe told
Holly Robinson that Jane Doe remembered Mark sching Jane Doe to clean Jane Doe.
Holly Ro inson told Afliant that

 

On December 7, 2012 Ai`i‘iant spoke with Greenville Police Department Criminal
Investigation Division Sergeant Steve Walden #92 on the telephone Sgt Walden #92
told Affiant that on December 7, 2012 at or about 32 44 a. m. Mark Engle had rented room
number 123 at the Motel 6 located at 5107 Interstate 30 in Greenville, Hunt County,
Texas. Sgt Walden #92 also told Affiant that there was a white 2000 Saturn 2 door car
displaying Texas license plate DJ7C316 parked on the north side of Motel 6, located at
5107 lnterstate 30 in Greenville, Hunt County, Texas. Sgt. Walden #92 told Afiiant that
at approximately 3:00 p.m. Sgt. Walden #92 observed a white male and white female exit
the said vehicle and enter into room number 123. Affiant has reviewed a registration
return on license plate DJ7C316 that was ran by Greenville Police Department Dispatch.
Said registration return shows Texas license plate DJ7C316 to return to a 2000 white
Saturn 2 door to Mark ENGLE with an address of 7628 Cedarhill in Fort Worth, Texas. l
Sgt. Walden #92 told Affiant that Sgt. Walden #92 had Greenville Police Department
Dispatch run a check on the name Mark ENGLE and Dispatch located information for/:f ¢,\
Mark ENGLE. Affiant has reviewed a driver’ s license and criminal history returnth ,
was ran on Mark ENGLE, a white male date of birth 08/22/ 1968 Said history£sh n -tliat ii
Mark ENGLE has Texas Driver’ s License 11662971 and that Mark ENGLE-131 ,i:a 7628

  
    
 

`lled substance,

arrested for assault, dangerous drugs, manufacture/deliveri. c`
`o ntrolled substance

possession of marihuana, possession of amphetamine, possessfo`

@_ _

analogue, evading arrest or detention, carrying prohibited weapon, and driving while
license suspended

Affiant believes that due to the nature of the person(s) at the motel room, and the
possibility that weapons may be stored at the motel room, Affiant asks, that should said
search and arrest warrant be issued, that Aff`iant and other Peacc Officers serving said
warrant be allowed to utilize a “no knock ” entry, based upon the possibility of weapon(s)
being kept in the motel room to help ensure the safety of said Officcrs serving said

warrant.

The Af`fiant believes that the disclosure of the existence of this Affidavit, the requested
Warrant or facts relating to its service could impede the investigation being conducted
and endanger the officers serving such Warrant, Aff`iant therefore requests that this
Affidavit and any such Warrant issued there from be sealed until execution of any such
Warrant, but in not longer than five (5) days from the date such warrant is issued. `

 

Aftiant has personal knowledge that under the Texas Code` of Criminal Procedure
Chapter 18 SEARCH WARRANT Article 18.02 States “A search warrant may be issued
to search for and seize (10) property or items, except the personal writings by the
accused, constituting evidence of` an offense or constituting evidence tending to show that
a particular person committed an offense

Wherefore, affiant asks for issuance of a warrant that will authorize her and odier officers
to search said suspected place premises, and vehicles for the property described above d seize

game _ ~z§;£t` //,c/

 
  
 

Affiant
/
D SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME BY SAID AFFIAN ON THIS THE 7 0:¢‘

M@{¢/

 

, 29'1'1. 30 ( \»- ~7% §§ deed$/\

district Court Judge`& ' _‘_ee\.'.
Hunt County, Texas de ""
€__¢""7' § 331;¢; 113

§
\' n

  

61<<>5

 

12/21/2012 15203 FAX 9034536870 HUNT CO JAIL .005/009

COURT OF ORIGIN n ‘ ' l Check appropriate box:
-/ \/ Warrant l:l
_ - » _ 4 Warrantless 13

ARREST-COMPLA{N'.I` / PROBABLE CAUSE

 

 

 

THE STATE 0F weis , - MISDEMEANOR; |:] l:] L__]
, c 13 A
CGUNTY OF HUNT _ _ _ sure JAIL tamm [:l
FELoNY; >I¢ [:]
3 2 1

, cAPrrAL reinNY [|
The undersigned qjiant, a peace gifch under zhe- laws .af the .SVale~aj`Tera:, and being duly sworn on oath makes the following
.,complain¢ md siareman¢ offact. Thz‘.s' ojicer had'persana/ knuwl¢»llge qfrhc_/bllnwingfacfs and hereby charges that.-

DEFENDANT: Mark Eugene Engle A [ .1AS:

' D'GB: 08-22-68 DL#: }1&2971 SS#: 59_6_-13-3897 `

. RACE: White SEX: _M;l.l_e -HE_IGI~I'].`: 5_0._5_ . _. WElGl-l'l`: L]_Q HAIR: Brown EYES; _I-_I_?dl
ADD : 7628 Cedarhi'll Rd., `(Il-'l"Y' _Wataugg STATE: _Tl
Onthe day of ~ ` Dember, 1012 ¢ at l_QQ p_.m. in

. ,M
Hunt Counly Texas, did then and there unlawfully r'c)mmil th<_r q[fen.s'e ofMangV_wt_g;e and Deliv§iy of
Contro!led Substance RM Grogp 1 >4<200 grams

.l¢»’
Based on the following facts and circumstances 011 lZ-OZ-ZO\ 2, a search warrant was executed ar 5109 I-30
.r'oom #123 in' Greenville Texast The search warrant included a' white saturn bearing Tx. L.P. DJ7 C316 which
is registered to MARK ENGLE. EN§T§§ left the motel room prior to the search warrant being executed but
was arrested on traffic charges in the white Satum bearing "l`x. L.P. DJ 7 C3 16. The white Saturn bearing Tx.
L.P. Dl7 C316 was taken to the Greenville Police Stalinn -t`or processing During the processing of said vehicle
' approximately 5 grams of "ICE" methamphetamine along with packin materials scales and a syringe with 35
dose units of what is believed to be methamphetamine was located in _ locked eontainer)_ When ENGLE was
lfirst asked for the combination to the eontainer.he denied any knowledge of the container being in his vehicle.
Tater, during his interview and after he was rea'd.his Mirandn warning he acknowledged thatDe conU?W"
approximately 3 grams of "ICE" methamphetamine and a syringe with methamphetamine in it as well. ENGLE
also stated that he sold drugs and generally profited $500 to $600 per week. 7

,L,'»e.s

 

 

 

 

 

WHEREFORE. Aj'iant prays that probable cause he llc/lermincd la exist and an arrest warrant be issued _Q_I_t_

' T}IA T DEFEND l E CO:%TO J/'iI/,.
l ' SMM " z ' 6/`¢3€/1¢//`//@ 10. A

AFFIANT '/ A¢;)¢N<:Y
Swarn to and subscribed to before me by the said aj?anl nn mm 3 da_v al DEC‘ _ 2012_

 

12/21/2012 15203 FAX 9034538870 v ,HUHT C(J JAIL @008/008

/- \/
~`,/ / .
()F]“'l(`ER ()li'v GENT, STATE OF TEXAS
OR l) ER
On this 3 -day of_ng-_¢M_h~(,l__;, 20 {L;the above matter and the defendant were presented and aepeared befbre me

end after examining the same, it is found that:
,[:] NO probable cause exists. Def=ndmt is 0RDERED RELl-;Asl~:l') instantly
dwigbe misc exam n is onean that
B’éomttrmenr sHALL issue AND me ):)EFENDAN'|' ee-MA¢ul<_ /l»L°’l(,/U\,
_ _ '- ' _ . mGISTnATE, ._
. 7 ing b/
_ ' _ OFFICE. _ ` '
l:] JAlL'cOPY/ [:] MAGm'rlt/\'l'\" col'\'./ |:I L)FFICER coPY

fro/Oll/)/L /[zc € c','ll §/7,1€/ /).'/ /lllvlzl/' le dill l
ll/ll'-Q 5/% ' ` ' ' '
/\([ilfr[l/lll l€§§ Al'~\" €‘§l` ]J(`(j/*l( /5167 '\l~($ Mé/ J")(( 5")€£"' ,_/lm/K`C

0 //v)/‘é'~' l” if)' ['Cl: COWV[€ l/ C,‘ l- FFQ\[¢("JS /J£`c£‘$~€`~

):2<%`%`+ ii
2d1ch 30ka ‘DGF`

_Q<@vw4mm/wl1

 

Gz@¢)

  

 

WRIT NO. 07259 (Sexual Assault)
STATE OF TEXAS § IN THE DISTRICT_ COURT
- §
vs. - § 354th JUDICIAL DISTRICT 4).
‘ §
MARK ENGLE § HUNT COUNTY, TEXAS
/ 7 MOTION FOR EXAMINING TRIAL

TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COURT:

NoW comes MARK ENGLE, Defendant, by and through undersigned counsel, and
respectfully requests that this Court hear an examining trial pursuant to Chapter 16 of the Texas
Code of Criminal Procedure, and in support thereof shows the following:

l. MARK ENGLE is presentlyl incarcerated in the HUNT County Jail charged by
complaint With the felony offense of SEXUALv ASSAULT is unable to make bond at the present
time and has not yet been indicted in this case.

2. MARK ENGLE requests an examining trial "to examine into the truth of the
accusation made", as required by Article 16.01l of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure.

WHEREFORE, PREMISES CONSIDERED, MARI€ ENGLE prays that the Court
grant this Motion For Examining Trial. l

Respectfully submitted,
Carol Day Gustin
2611 Lee Street

P.O. Box 1053
Greenville, Texas 75403

By: 01'»@(£0`/1)\\§{:»\.,
Carol Day Gustin
State Bar No. 24004313
Attorney for MARK ENGLE

 

L?-
.._

-l|

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
This is to certify that on January l7, 2013, a true and correct copy of the above and
foregoing document Was served on the District Attorney's Office, Hunt County, Texas, by hand

delivery.

Carol Day Gustin -

WRIT NO. 07259 (Sexual Assault)

STATE OF TEXAS § IN THE DISTRICT COURT
vs. § 354th JUDICIAL DISTRICT
MARK ENGLE § HUNT COUNTY, TEXAS
0 R D E R
On , 20l3, came on to be considered MARK ENGLE's Motion for

Examining 'l`rial, and said motion is hereby

(Granted) (Denied)

 

JUDGE PRESIDING

WRIT No. 07259 (MAN DEL C/s < 400gm)

   
   
 

STATE OF TEXAS § IN THE DISTRICT COURT
§

vs. § 354th JUDICIAL DISTRICT
v §
MARK ENGLE §

HUNT COUNTY, TEX¢,S§S*

MOTION FOR EXAMINING TRIAL
TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COURT:

NoW comes MARK ENGLE, Defendant, by and through undersigned counsel, and
respectfully requests that this Court hear an examining trial pursuant to Chapter 16 of the Texas
Code of Criminal Procedure, and in support thereof shows the following:

1. MARK ENGLE is presently incarcerated in the HUNT County Jail charged by

complaint With the felony of nse of MANUFACTURE DELIVERY OF A CONTROLLE

 

00 m or more but less than 400gm. MARK ENGLE is unable to make bond at
the present time and has not yet been indicted in this case.

2. MARK ENGLE requests an examining trial "to examine into the truth of the
accusation made", as required by Article 16.01 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure.

WHEREFORE, PREMISES CONSIDERED, MARK ENGLE prays that the Court

grant this Motion For Examining Trial.

Respectfully submitted,
Carol Day Gustin

2611 Lee Street

P.O. Box 1053
Greenville, Texas 75403

By: &"“Q@'/%_lr:\_
Carol Day Gustin ' `

State Bar No. 240043~13 . .. _ vi
Attorney for MARK ENGLE ' ~ ~

 

 

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
This is to certify that on January 17, 2013, a true and correct copy of the above and
foregoing document Was served on the District Attorney's Office, Hunt County, Texas,` by hand

delivery.

WC@);T:»\__

Carol Day Gustin

 

STATE OF TEXAS

VS.

MARK ENGLE

On

No. 07259 (MAN DEL C/s < 400gm)
§ IN THE DISTRICT COURT
§ 354th JUDICIAL DISTRICT
§ HUNT COUNTY, TEXAS
oRDER

, 2013, came on to be considered MARK ENGLE's Motion for

Examining Trial, and said motion is hereby

(Granted) (Denied)

 

JUDGE PRESIDING

Exh`lil~t ' 87
@Fclar_ \@\/OWL

:>C&M) l/Lf l/k@&[ V`l C'L/l

 

OY\Q, call Tix)c)

_C€_

NO. 07259(MAN DEL C/S < 400gm)

 

STATE OF TEXAS § IN THE DISTRICT COURT
vs. § 354th JUDICIAL DISTRICT
'§
MARK ENGLE § HUNT COUNTY, TEXAS
ORDER ON EXAMINING TRIAL
On , the Magistrate heard matters alleged against MARK ENGLE and finds:

1. MARK ENGLE is charged with the offense of MAN DEL C/S < 400gm.

2. Probable cause does y exist to proceed further with matters against MARK

 

Signed on ¢/& ’ 3

OR\G\NAL S\GNED BY
R\CHARD A. BEACOM JR. . JUDGE

MAGISTRATE

 

 

 

 

E>1 1114

,A111da\/11§ 40
§t)p[)or`i~:‘/“me`@“_ -

FOh`O/'~Q, FVO CCLQW_Y/

 

sz<>

STATE OF TEXAS ` §

CoUNTY oF HUNT §

AFFIDAVIT OF FACT

BEFORE ME, Linda Guyton, a Notary Public in and for said County, State of Texas, on this day
personally appeared Katlin Wells. Who, after being by me duly sworn, on oath deposes and says: My name
is Katlin Wells. l am 24 years old. l live at 2763 CR 1051, Celeste, Texas 75423. My phone number is l-
469-474-3903

At this time 1 wish to make known the following facts:

On December?, 2012, Mark Engle came to my mothers house Sherri Tatum at around 3:00 p.m. We drove
straight to motel 6. We sat for a while talking He gave me 30.00 to get us Something to eat and a pack of

cigarettes He got up to take a shower. 1 got back from McDonalds and he was getting finished with his 1
shower. When he came out of the bathroom he was fully dressed. After we got done eating, lt was around
ld:OO P.m. Mark needed to met a friend across town and go to Dallas. About an hour later the police Showed
up. l answered the door and They sat me in a chair as they starting going through his items. _They where
searching for drugs. l told them there wasn’t any drugs here. They did not fmd any drugs. They starting
asking me questions, such as if Mark and I was having sex?'l told them no. They wanted to know if they got
the sheets tested what they would find? Mark was a perfect gentlemen and was never inappropriate with me

at any time. The police arrested me on an outstanding warrant

_ , ‘ ,4 ` \
AFFiANT; M,UCQX/Yl /i/UUQ$

suBsCRiBED AND swoRN before me this/the .-;¢f‘___} day of, 4 1 h ,2013.
/

,../_

L/ Nor RY PUBLiC,sT oi= TEXAS

 
  

LlNDA GUYTON

My Comm|sslon Exp|m
January 31. 2015

 

AFFIDAVIT OF FACT

Introductory Certification

Joe Michael Dennis, the Undersigned AHiant, hereinafter “Aifiant,” does hereby solemnly swear,
declare, and state as follows:

1. Affiant is competent to state the matters set forth herewith.

2. AHiant has personal knowledge of the facts stated herein.

3. All the facts stated herein are true, correct, and complete in accordance with AHiant’s best
firsthand knowledge and understanding, and if called upon to testify as a witness AH`iant shall
so state.

Plain Statement of Facts

4. On December 9, 2012 I drove Mary E Jordan to the Motel 6 in Greenville, TX , to pick up
personal property left in the room, rented to Mark E Engle, prior his arrest. Mary and I met with
the owner/manager who told us the room had been cleaned and the items bagged. She asked
him for a copy of the search warrant and a police list of the items taken. He stated he had
neither as the Greenville police had only shown him their badges and demanded entrance to the
room. He again stated they left nothing When they came or when they left. He told Mary she
would have to give him $10 to pay for the shower curtain the police ripped out of the
bathroom, which she did. I then drove around to the side of motel where he had instructed us to
go, to the maids work room. The maid told us she was there when the room was cleaned. Mary
asked if she found any paperwork from the Greenville police and she said there was nothing
from them. In our examination of the three garbage bags, as we put them in the vehicle, we
found only clothes and other personal hygiene products, no paperwork from the police.

Verification
The Undersigned Ai.’t`iant, Joe Michael Dennis, does herewith swear, declare, and affirm that Affiant
issues this Affidavit of Fact with sincere intent, that AH`iant is competent to state the matters set forth

herein, that the contents are true, correct,'complete, and certain, admissible as evidence, and reasonable
and just in accordance with Affiant’s best firsthand knowledge and understanding

This Affidavit of F act is dated the Twenty third day of the Twellth Month in the Year of our Lord Two
Thousand Thirteen.

Joe Michael De `s Date Date

Notary: ,
/Jed(,mlM U l')`/’@"[z ' ' "7/?,¢ 'JW\)>F 1 %l/ 3 3/ / 3

State of Ws
County of .l_§/Y”_V.M&`

.. z MY COMMlSSlON EXPlRE$

This instrument was acknowledged before me
on 3dayof 131 ,)M@by

..'?

“‘ M@/‘

Notan'PUSEW/| / § ""`1

November 20. 2017

 

r'lQR-E@~E@13 13126 Frorn: 2145728721 4 F’aae~ 2 1/1

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

I Lisa King and Kathy O’Connor do solemnly swear that there was no search
warrant in the white Satum belonging to Mark Engle, when Kathy O’Connor and I'
picked it up from the Police impound. '

- h \
W€A aj
L'sa lGng l

 

UW%\ D(GDWL

Kathy O‘Connor 6

      

R)b€r'to Martinez.
"Notary Public ( am)n/ r,v/A

/ Fxp/fer /3 /?0”/

AFFIDAVIT OF FACT

In_troductory Certification

Mary E Jordan, the Undersigned Affiant, hereinafter “AH`iant, ” does hereby solemnly swear, declare,
and state as follows:

1. Affiant is competent to state the matters set forth herewith.

2. Affiant has personal knowledge of the facts stated herein. -

3. All the facts stated herein are true, correct, and complete in accordance with Affiant’s best
firsthand knowledge and understanding and if called upon to testify as a witness Affiant shall
so state.

Plain Statement of F acts

4. On December 9, 2012 I was driven to the Motel 6 in Greenville, TX , by Joe Michael Dennis to
pick up personal property left in the room, rented to Mark E Engle, prior his arrest Mr Dennis
and I met with the owner/manager who told us the room had been cleaned and the items
bagged. I asked him for a copy of the search warrant and a police list of the items taken. He
stated he had neither as the Greenville police had only shown him their badges and demanded
entrance to the room.`He again stated they'left nothing when they came or when they left. He
told me I would have to give him $10 to pay for the shower curtain the police ripped out of the
bathroom, which I did. Mr Dennis then drove around to the side of motel where he had
instructed us to go, to the maids work room. The maid told us she was there when the room
was cleaned. I asked if she found any paperwork from the Greenville police and she said there
was nothing from them. Mr Dennis was present when the maid told me this. In our examination
of the three garbage bags, as we put them in the vehicle, we found only clothes and other

personal hygiene products, no paperwork from the police.

Verification

The Undersigned AH`iant, Mary E Jordan, does herewith swear, declare, and affirm that AH`iant issues
this AH`idavit of Fact with sincere intent, that Affiant is competent to state the matters set forth herein,
that the contents are true, correct, complete, and certain, admissible as evidence, and reasonable and
just in accordance with Affiant’s best firsthand knowledge and understanding

This AHidavit of Fact is dated the Twenty third day of the Twelfth Month in the Year of our Lord Two
Thousand Thirteen. .

_.__-~_Mary E J or Date Notary: rv Date
//§ W”[Zj// /Z /25//? “§ §AQC;@i'-'Uz/ let/l a al l'?>

étate of Texas

County of I§=L\/_.UUX/X`

Tnis instrument was acknowledged before me
on 555 gay of 1 01 ,15~.\’)13 by

ear Sd._@;\_%/_“j

1121 S¢cnatu
among nom

 
 

z "= '_ MY COMM|SSION EXP|RES
‘ November 20. 2017