Court Opinion

ID: 4069792
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 00:51:50.838761+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:58.396066
License: Public Domain

ORIGINAL                               15Z-I5
          Mo.   lhl3>-OOl3^ Cg

                                                                                      IM
   (LOUPL Y-&F- CJZlMlkM L APP£/!L S
                                                           COURT OF CRW.U^r'-ij?
         o f reXA S                                             OCT 01 2015

                                                           Abe! AcssSa. C's-'-
                                            1A(7

/IPPFLL/Ia/YS   P^r/Y/ePAf   7=t?JZ.   dl£C£E-T/e>A//1£Y R£ujt=u/

       JZU APPEAL a//?. II- 13"0012*1 C£                            FILED IN
                                                         COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
            £0t*R 7- t?F-/9PJ>£/?L 5                             • '• -i   v i loij

                                                               Abel Acosta, Clerk
                 •T^^X AS

                                             JJc, c?t£S9/7
StKlH AMgM&Mxhll 6F rt/£ U.S. &>US-f,7a7/0jJ .                  .,    . . . ^/J/J%C/i",/£ ,)7 ,7?

RRihV y. UAM\.AK\h 373 u.s.?3,irj s.c'4. /// (l^os) . .                         .'   ..,•_'       S"./*/
BZdiK. v. us, 2.2.3 f.iJ t,s\>t,ss {1 <>s$-s~J-Jt £a) • . - .                          • .-...'?
CHXDUlC i/. US. Mb u.S -Mlt&L.£,„*/S^J. z>u fajfi/)                                   . ,1 J7
CJH?r,U (/. CAtlftSLMiA 3SD U.S. 6,0% olSf #5 s.Cl.jzz.9, Jl JJ, // <. &/. ZSy^fas) //
3£H\CM£ I/. MAMSJtJ W7, U.S.Z5l,ZK-'/O,/O0 S.C4. zrz.*/, 2,£?-jW, £,S L>£
 PffklSU, v. /iUmma 2.SiU.S1S,5ZS.CJ.5'7,L.£c/.rtPQ{&*^ . . .                  .....                   /Sj/f
 QuuJiJ I/. U S. 3^1, \€£>ILI'^^, IS S. C4. M,',i,l3- 7¥, 95 l.&. *fctf?72-7 5 QfSS) •                   f
  Btftotetl* V-B&Wi iZS S~C+.ZVSi- (ZooSb -                •       -    .    ......                   /-S"
 zesZv.M.S./«// f.suPP.zJOul (2#eh) -                - -         • * - • .- *' * - • /3
 S4imAS ir.-fEiAS izz s»C4>znIt
5M*rd v.U-S 3*1 U.S>,I31,6>1 "5C+. WCCt 13 L.£~£{ /2j/)a.4k.Ci^('7Cu>lu.Ci.JL fi?V            .       •       .....                 //
 Sn/l\C*U/lUA O-UJA^UK/f.'iotJ VOu U. i ..Ut*,ri>'IS.C4. ZofZgptL.e£/ZUA>70fr'/)                    /?•
TEX/15 CotiS-til-iiliOtS

AJZ-f SrSBClQ Of Th/£ T&MS. 0)hi171 Tu7(Crf . .                  _   -           . . - - - • $#*

Hu«7e£ I/. 574-it SSD 5M) i.dS'73 freJ.Cet*A I97?>\                                              2
TtMS Covjll 6F MP6.ALS

hie/jess? v.ST47z 2MS.iu.3d' i53ji(rl(-fr*-App.tL>Mo,zn>£) • - • - • •                                 S
UZRRfiii 1/.SW* SO S.uf.?4 UZI> L>7~Xr 2-9 Ctft^CliU*. A&>- &cl) - - . . . .                           7
OGiAUSOUus^^rbnzSiu.^c/O-CT^^APk-^.UI^&^/lzaoil                              .    , . . .       ,     /S
*>/\IikI*S. i/ 5tA-7£ •&£/ S.u>.1iJtfK,ir7 7£6'je.£JefH.AtP.Zt>/&)*          . . . . . 9,tUtfi
A&-1, l,o 5 .     _           .        .   .           .           . -                             ..                     - .     £ .f.jd.j?
 A&7. l.cSl ^         _           _            .           ,       ,       ,                                             ,.."...                    /S
 A£1.       ZO\                                                                                                                           c         ;,/

7BHAS P&Mi- Cot)£
Cobf 3&.07r ,             .            .       •                       .           ,       .            ,        .        .               3 ^

tQ4S> 04fas of APPe/Ui£ f&pcehn&r
 Rule %zii>) . . . . . .                                                                       .            ,        ,        -   .       .         z.

7EM3 IZuffcS of aOthErfCg'
 ZuleT IG3 (/) .                       ^                                                                                                        j£
 Rule: ze I ..    .                            . ' .                           .           -            .       ,..-•-.-/
 Hut* •••                                                  °<-

CnftJuUAS HoZ. g£i/i£kf .                                                                  ,3-/9

     •ntiT lZ\AL- CJH&7/}GISJ£6 )7S biSU£'7tt>U /tf Af/dW/fiSfy 7£S7/*tcMr yiM7 /?
      UJlY*6FSS MAA. Pl£un>uSL.Y BeeU Coi4v}C7<£6 0F ^/^T/W4 A/fAgtfiFUS/cU

      Bck.\Al*J& (X?UAaUY <5£77f*Sfi> ef^ SCrfd
      7SC/e/F7/Oi,C4Zy /OriA/A-U/
—                                             _

    -7*2 7l/
         Pl£A$£ F/A//S //£)€&/A/ 7}7>/£//4'L/7f J&0~S£ Att-1'OAf, /6>U/£i/&2• TrftT AAJ/7/tfAtAc C^P/a'S
Ft£. AtS<'££7'0*M£Y J?tV,£U/ Of1,1 AJ?S &£ *WJFi 7'7£&T AS Mo AC/>/£S Ml FAC.JT. ?*/ 7t//S et/fisx/tt. M» %l?M yoc/ /}^j f/ZFc'^.t 7 u„7/
F'UA /}££/ 7/Oi.Ulc fifGtS/it/rA/fS H*i)£ AS 7& SuFA/>/Z7 £/f£AJ

TV StifPAtr £4ctJ /)/Z.4uah£m7. 77(£J£ #//Ai 7£~ PA?<><:cA}i,AHr, /)i/?£y7, 7^/^^/
MiY Ftl/A AA/Y Ai/S7AA^£S 0U 7t/£ f=///A/At, 7s7£~7a?'Ca/&<. /Z£sP£^7r^//y /ee?6u£S7
Tf7A7 777/S {.£#f£"~7>l£eT3t(JAC(4C
/Jd7/£F 0F 7V/X £u7(e£~ P&c££U/*/6 U/J6£#- 7£7.4$ Mn/t"S #F £*)££*/<£- /# 3 (f) A*/A
    ztl, esP£ciA//y tkt ~rtf£ fac-t r/Ysr TlPfe///) 7£~ <:,?<,/jjsz/ /ks Fstt/^A it c-Ji/AtAte*"
Tf-IF SUfF/tA£AlCV ep £i/i&FA/tt? /A/ jJ/* RR^F, 7a/£££Fv££; /7£ /faS a/s& B££J/
    /'t'AJ£Y/7ct7/e>*./A//y /aY£~FF£"C 7/UiF Fs£ A/e>7 /vA'*/A• M47£R.M'A. f5St/££ ?// 7A7F"
    )jJSUFFJC/£~AtC Y &F £UtA£7YcA' Ka7i)U/u/A T/T"-* 7 P£7t 7t&jL/£l? CAfA/ J &)££<£ 7 /)PA£*)a,#£ &ig£t:7 &rf/AruA.

   .4flPeJUM7 PFAYS. ACC^/PYAa/C/F ZY 7A7/S ArkjAi?gA)BL£~ CukjZ/ TV SAZAt/A, aY/S p£Y/7;s?*A
U//7/7 fi/i FX/Z/S/YS AlfJA /}//PA£7/£S Fifeh AaJ7o 7a/£ CSitAtY. Aps&/fav7 AZFSA£e 77=^//^
FFtiuFST tJfiY/af &F P£C£/P 7 jFY>/aS P£7a 7/UfA aIa/J FaZ/a/A .

                                                7?&SPFC7FA(//y StASHA Y7£A ,

                                                 Ftx&tY F?ua~/cx /' /%•> -Sk"
                                                 hJv. 7
                                                 Cu£isto, ~rx.   7795*/

  £/A,aJ£A AAJA MYFH ta/aS 25yIi MV FSFPYaFahb&Z Zji F-AAAa/fK c&e-riF/£~4.

                      YA 7/7^/./ 7   s?aF6JF.A/,/A ASA I. AJPAaaaj/Fa/7

 "Ta/F aTPP£//aal/7 aZ£Ou£SY s£A / A£6t4AH£AA7 All 7a/aS  Sc/c*7 7)£4*/**£*/-•
MAlAl 7~ A/2A L. A9/ZA,t,/A/£Ajr MAY a/s/f SamP/aFV 7>7£~ F&trS aJaM
f/AAZAFY 7/j£ ASSU££.
                  SYA7iYAieM7 F>P rA/tTCJStF

     Ohl APP.IU TOi ZoU. AfiPelUui WAS y/^xcr'^'6 0U 0) Caum7 £>FFcJLkAc ASUt/L-7
OF H'A-K •UitH> A-//£6£A Silc lUfiS (5 Y&KSfiF A&£j AC££'S7£A J?/ir /// / 3#/J4FF> DA47
skill, Re:-3AS4YC7FlA F/A /jY/ZetZ AlF7F>LA/AZF£Yi3d Atou/AA ///#//Z, /Jau? /2//f%/aS
(2.\Ci?UaJ75,AF1£F- a(m*S1 i-Y&fc. F*t>M odiHuM-i'?aA4Yc7AU£-aU7U//FV 7Z>YstY/ A/F
f£X£U7 AllF7yi7AC>AJ$) pA?-XWtC7m s/zotZ-s/fAtAt g£~7uA7{7Fi3- A>6> /zo/Z, U7f7fA
0£(6uJ/l YfZ*>'' CllvzTiF fitJA) a/A ArM) YfO+A-tf ChUtdF OF FerMU/t/'A)S$Ac7£ 7.
    TZfAL WAS //AAfY/z-tOj AJJA 3^>^Y K?u/J4 APPtir/7aiAY Al*a/7Y &F Ai^^TZAUAYF'A^
SFXWAf ASSAUL 7 t>F E07/V CoWAtS/ }F /Au7y Ffr/iAFSeM7£-/Jc&4 /}&- jpctfsJXM&Y BY
%iA6£ AT- (7e) m4Z-l 76.CJ-. F£> FuaAA»/AS<2'£uiits'ifj^aA Sd7lA £ouaAf£„

               SYaiaTm&aY FF pJZoaFdiAPJL. iJts7cA.£Y

    lid CausF a/u.C* 2#>Y9t> TUiF APPet/AAA7 UI4S. CaAa^^F^/0AA 7/A/£ VM
RE-7AA/>Jt7MeA47 0F S£*H4L. /)£SAC//.Y, Z-CaUAr7S A7tfF~ F)PP£A6)A(7 Jc/AS
 dlMUIC 7£& aFSucJj TtFFtFAjS £- &aJ t/lz^t 3 A9/JA APPFaAp^ 7*AaY.
 OlJ tshollS, 7tfaJvac 7/i>aY.
Alt) MolAohf fitZ. P^AEKZlAJh fl/t=& QuF 7d WtfLAct^oF I^aAou) ft£^C aF
flffziktAl m^M fipfelfalc CvutASrC c9/A Z5 S£P1. /£, 77-//J PtF7/7sUA/ FbA
rxstZiFYtotiAPjY iteuuzuj u<4J> r*A*ie/y feP-ivA*Z7\£& Yo 7/Air a^aa^ey-a>f-apP£14/s
FvJS. Filf/At PulZS(AAu7 TV Zu/tf?. ZC&\ TsXJS Ru/fS aF /}PP£//a)7c p/Z^dF/H/M,

                                   •A
                             &Xt7tAk/6 J-

        7tfk>aAY rfal /f 6>t7?j£jS
 Mn PXtVitHijfr Be&A C*nJuUl£a OF fHMd&LlUfi /iPpF//AA77S APPXjF/IF7/Sao*Y-
                            /tAZ6UM£lA'7'
(I )     Ok} lifF /Jji/tf 7H4-7 THF UA(7AAt£5^ QuF$7<0Aj£n A&<47 AJtAtAiFXJtYAt fUiF fiMZF-
 f1FAtS/c>S AfFitftf 6£F£sstyftJ7 $£U£*.uY tfu£7 7UF aaVF^^aaI %eCA£/S(? 71/FP&M£Cc47cr£
 iM&F Fl S££Hi 7tf/<-r TUtF h^FFfAAAA/7 MAP A fUA,A7toFp&t* JUS7,/£, A/A6 THATMe*"

 Wb tAhi 1(/tf fro/, lt/i4F<7 //A7Aca7//, 1A£ teF&fA4s77 kfA*> A/&>&( CtHoiFA IA/7*/ £*«'£.
 PPAI/uA/aA< TH^Poi/ct- c£ £CA4/aA6 AX>0£SYa S££ Y£X. ddAF'CXta-i PPfC.^PJ AMO £iM~
 coot 33.oV.
(2)      -M*r6FF?tJM)A7 k/ASjA£oF< f%u^ Al 7(/tFtU(7/A£SS£S thtnt, AaJ& f*< THFSW*F
 TV CtU^F ~nl£*/t/-aAFSS h//7a7 t4tAHteef/7et APPXFUFaJS/caA0F 7*/£o£P£^AAAArr /S Xo7
 Otii-Y Atf ASwSFA)F A/SCaF7/0fA/ Bu7 ft/so MjliUaitS ?Z0$FC+4 7AI%SF IS /aJ A&AAFKAt- Adn,/SfA/S7£^PiA 7*7tmF "SACK ?&«A A UACA7ri>A /^ cAaAC^aA //A 0/,/zv/l Mi?At F^** A
  BU5IA&5SS YAZJp TO A7^*A7Af t^FVA^iA /jj ai/?>/Z.* UI^FaA a}PP£YYa^Y 7ocaK rug
  AUusah Ui/7sA£$S 0f tl/AJltXjAAfij ttrAij a/oaYAi d*'7/7 7/Y// A/tAACUAA 7ZlP,Sc.£ FU6tf7 fi/AA (4e7£L/.irFo s£F FfdAJSt 7 £}
 IHE ?&ftFC*A7o& fJol QfAcYAmt-C i/nPZF%. aWm/Z/J/a/4*xa*S4 /%%i£yt?AAS//uA #f ?d7 */•
  AtCHStfo M?a7£SS£S' /Jtme, Tife*FFi>AFf SH£ do«L6fA7 a/va£ SA/cxsalA cf B€£*A FtA+e.A£A.)
 Q>\ f1£& YV14 C~tZZtFH?LV• pu F£totJV ?ZonA7'M •• - At Y£P
 (aI f»»A AiuAtK/S4 jrlc YlPP££fl€f7StoAA 0F 7t/£ hFFFa(Ma/7 '
  fl* -Y iWV KjAc-hJ \utlA7 7'til ty&fAAS; ftul, YFS fo P-Z & /6><7,nO j, /h)U/£U£K,
  U/l7H0Cf1 QfAY fZtPMt- Ci4aaZP.£S ptfeft BY 7A/F paficC Stftsf #s £t/ AWX£f~;r/ 7/AtF
  t?tfaeAi£S F//&6 F&s'SfY f/(ZaA?£7/7 Zu&AttcAt AZF Cc.>AKp/e7d/r Fa/scT AAAA fa4/iCA**sS Aa/A
  AAP> Sfe iJcl l££tf fiska/S Q\AF$7«>t7$ 0F 7d(S AAA71J&P AS 7A/(FpJk>SF//CO AO aAc7 £XP/3&£. YHFV.Ffx7.eF, JUil &>iJi,>U7tc>J'
  huSI 5tf ££0£/tp3l) Aa4A KFMAtM£& &P A aAS^A 7*1*41-.

{j)        £IaFU 7Hue/a/7 7U,c{aAS£L &>/L YPF A£F£aa(>4as7 SHvtftA aUu£ houW fv£. fi MtST^ftiU
      VASOb eU lAF IMP2l>P£< CUhHKFAJ7S PM irA-/s£ £UAC^C0U£7 SAvt/i-A OF R£Qu£S7£& £Vtt>£AACF &F 7P£ OFA^A/StF
  1HA7 1UF htfFAJhAtf 7 u//)S CtJAZA£$ 7V SuPteBY THAI p£It/AS f/££/aS£i fPP** -pAF Po/ac£.
  A*lA oH THAI HF kfoS AC7<-'AYYy bxa*/& ay £/(Z4JS£7p F-U2tPttctjT /AOi/sF/ UJPiCJl pF UPfS
      tJo-r*

Qj)            D*S1 ^£CAuJc ft PtPlStftA IOAOKaS 0aAo7a/£* P(PtiVfA P0£S aJo7 AhtbC pr*4 #£. A/£)A.
      CiwhY OF 7//&T 0 7W£< P&tSeltfS PLTOa/S, UAALZSS 1H£ />£*J£>Kr fYef/6^ Jl-jF P7/7£K
      dommi A £ 7A/&Y U/&LF E.C7*t fvu"* uu/>£*l 7WF $7*F PscF A£?£t«F SS AAtA/\/yilS$4S/tr AA/A 7PF UtA* Of 0U£Srl aauPa^maSSAKlF- AaA£> S/MP/' *AcY 36 AAah,77£H 7V PXuuF A£F£a/74^7S
      &H//7Y- TtiS CaUZAF AaA4 ZZsac WAS &,£ A#o7A£>C cdA*f.tF, aAv7 /K escAF/*/^ oK
      Alb&fA/P, 7a/F Petit £. -7HF £iAf6£A/CF p££S£AA7&d MAi>£ /T U>e£. MfcC 7HF A)£F£^lA>f^Y
      UlA$ 1/MitAfr -rp BSCAPFeT^adFpijieF/ MStF Hi* LOOK F,ufL7Y A 7 7//dT Mon/£A/Y 7M£~
      IMfUP&P. BiAiAFWcF'UfAS, l>££S£JA7£A VO IhftF JUPYi 7if* PZFj^AACaAL. FXKAX. AFA£C7^

  TtfE' OotTCtHue AF Yf'F' PJ&CFF&IAAA,. 7U£ b6.FFJAMAAl UA4J 0*J XtWb i*A CAnjF aSo. C.X.
      l€M%, See IMC 57A1F/1&A1 HA&F BV -"& ?JU>SF£*t?cC 6k> 7f/& Pd^£U7t/ //»7tC€ OF
                                                                                 it

      i*1£Ui ~rv crf&i tVi/iFticF of• FtiZAueoJii CaZimuS, Ac?5 AU/j Il/zj>u(1Si ^//fetWy trowKtT7**

                                                 ol
HH •YMF' t>FPFAl£AJJ7, fi/m 0tJ fi£ A8CU7 /Z-2./-/Z, SF£P44£- 3 j ps>Ato 4&(Pf/ S 7AYF aJiS AKP£ST A*A FAt/^ld YO 7UPJA aA'A/Ss/f
Af etfZAbFjrt PtttUicp- uias crf4Xfi£b M//7// P/Udtacwt, rtfc ^ppzetPejjsivp ap rPF bFF-
F«£A/J7 ptJA 1% CuPPZWYlY /aC ?&76A7tOU- FaF tPA7 #FF£PSc~. 7M/S SY47/FVjTaaY &p£S
hlcY PFfIfcY 7VAY APF£/^a7Y MfAJ etT&C. FvuaJ/S A7 £/a?A€£7aA J^UZma^S aJoa*£ .
7h/£PFFiAPF> ShiF MAS aAoT A-/iAA4£P".f<5 17-IF' APPP£^£^SAOaA afPtfYo/AF, SiAFShfo'ULd P A/0 CaJaPGFA eFFasAAAaAA, aAl YA/F
&£FF).(MUT AP6 7fli7 AY j/c T/4/F" h/AS /k FY £/(2AB£7AIS aJcUsFAt* AFF£S7£& 7A7&PF,
f?£SlAL7 OF Y^/FT pjZOCFFAiAlCn M/ewcA aUu£ B££*7 6iFF£P£uY. S£F~ FPaA'2/Y ^3.
IF) 17 1$ c/faaZ/y S7A7F& /\( APT 2.01 oF Y.CCPA 7VAY aY SaJaP/ KiF 7*AFpPtMAAV
hUlY OFj&lL PZoS£CU7A*Aer AY7UPaJ£YS, /Pclu&f^ti SPFCtA-/pJ£FSF04Yo?S, AAc7 To
toAim C1m EUY ~m SFF iylA7 JUSYAC? /$ j^/jf. 7^£YsPa/7'aADYFtcPPAZFSS FJCYS #71
SEiPFYF A U///A/F5S (AiPAtt/F of F$7APii5PAAAPr 7H£ Zi/'AfCfAACF £F 7UF' ACCc/jFA,
AS IAJ TtJiS CASF. 77lB ppt>5FCu7c< 7&/s/y MAdFCa/A£6FS AfrA/JAsY f/a*F AUAAaJA, AFPPS77 S£^F'T.PY.P AP7 FA A/M P£/7AL
60AFZJ.OY'. 77AF£FfiAPF', foP 7p£ PUPY//cY c^aAjaJ^Aa/^ FAC 7S 6CaYSaA£ 77/F ££~
£Y/ajA7 U//IS /tY/f&Bi/y aY^A/aAA? YYsF Pp^^,
&PFA7/Y AfFFCYFlC\ TUFUFKMCY. 777c P&?SFdc4 7&Z S/Auui-A aAAcaF t/SC /oS£& tH^ISaYF~
FABPlCA 7£ft CA£(MUA4L- A1^AAl^e5 AGAajASY £/tZ48£7P Ft4ttHAcA7. fuPUfcDZfl/UtF, 7a7£ 77&Pi.
YAU/Z7 ec»UMi77c~& AaA APa/SF'AJF NS{&F7/0aA, A/JA U/u)47£6 7VF P/6P7$ £>F 71/eF
btFFUMUl YO /JAUF A fA/AAZ AUA iMpAPTAjL-TJeiAL. A)AA>i / 7S /PAA7fFF Aa/F PPsPS^SS.
                                                          At       ''
Fetal AS UtJYPrfol&Kft, qjJY fiAA7££tAL- FACT JS A £>ZAA V U/u/a7/cJ>W, tS6CF47'OU /AY pBOti,77/a'A, 7/^F /J/6/7,
  )F Uoi Yoo% /A&PLWY SYA7FM£JA7 ZY 7tYF E*aAa//S4 &>»iPAaaY a •
                        .AaZPiUaMFI/7
(0 IkZ FTAIF- FaJf/1 V£> PtetAtF MY t^7tKAp/a/? PPYSIC4L FUr*/)c ZY APP<=/6*7
 W JPMlUYi CdP}PAU7 luAl LaTF 6FN7//SA9Y7F>t YW'~~
 FY(AXIL B£7c4AlfY FXOHa CAVCUAA TALtA* Wr7j4 6(t7AS£7fY, /m£YAAA*A /}*CA fr, /^^
 toCZiAiluJ. UnicU SY 7l/£ UIAY, FTaA FacY, 7tf£ fiPP£r/UHT FA/fed &AAA6/AYA7
 (U)mPa*7Y OKI YtJF iAAF^FShiijYPP/ACl/lt 70 AO Aa UteF^Y aZFF^7a^F M/tlicrf
 ZOhLAttKi 67MMXY PHOW&A ijo et/A&FXCS, jAo*_ SYA7aF Ap PMY /Apt/ C^tf-JuS
 SliiCF HPPb//aP7 U/AS a/Zi7,/aJ4c(y 6aO SOA/A Saa/CC cs/zv/K/V/s SpFCfFlCr*//
 12 -7/iyS ?Atl &>U/\ UC4S FXAm APAt/^AAfY fP^£2& aAiS
5-lL AlHPJJhmm PJ/i*1 klfefA AF 7Jd U/v£57tC-A77 SP£A£.
 UlnfhclY rflS A77oAxJ£Y P££S£A/7 AMA AlJ &>t4>AS£L. A6UASFA lAlM A/ei7 YO 7^^ Tt) ru^/A7£S

 U!l7hliJH7 aUj^iASf/PAFS£nY. /a/la£S7/^aC(A^ 77Ac%u/tU'Afi£p.S 7£SY/Mc>a//^//} 7 t^a^-CsY^^ju^
PoYfYfU/£ Z££tA AAlndlPtt SaACF APPs/rA^I A*A p/tSFAdY Ai/Uvk&t, AtS P/*A/7 A4AAfSY
 5£{f-ltAc/ZiMiY4 7a<7>A Aitvctkt'76 aAaS 5"t4 J/>tFYA7i/FAA7 70 fi/£A/7£ll $£F'£Xlfr%A7 Y, otsp
PAPA^tPAPtJ, 7f/£p££c'M SpvutA £ff/£c7 jPAY c^u^Jt/ Fa^- APA>£//a" 7 UlAS AF&*A/*Y&y
5/dcF 6>lzu)F, 7HF>tMt/A*.fAFiP 0oU7Ac7c(4 AAM/aAa/7 0{1c££>£ £ A/v^FA^/AfFK #A/,
 C. Fia£aA1£5 /S aJ Aa/^x/fifFA/A £&<: (AL.,7P&eFPvPF) /7 /S A*f£AA7£S Act7 Y TV (KPiAYF~

A k£FFPh>A>A7S 57*l\ AMeAAAAM£AA7 <**/{£ T+/i/£ApFl& TV PUPAY a7//£X. S~&f7£~ /)/,w7 ', Jf/Z*/
V. S~TA7/T XT, S.UJ• 3P /,Z./,/* Zcf-2/fClFX.fPlAU. APP. TttOz)Fj~Pi~£WAp>AAA£)t /A/7FASAFK 7o SPF4*:
TO f)PPF//flAA7 A3Ml FX7£4aA£fl/S oFF£>A^s, tfol fuP. 7a/F oP.iA.6£ PSY4+Y7AA)Y/y AiZmFu/'AaA& PA*/vi6£& TPF i'UFA//$
AUA UNJUST0U7CoK/F>jJ&7 //A AtAuPMMF 14//7/7 Y-P.£Yo2, h tS kAer//s£77/£P> tAay
IP A 6£F£*JAAa/7 TFS7/FAFS, tJtS ?Jt£-A&FSY Si/f/ACF' CyfA/g£ uJ£& YO IMPFHcp Aa*Aj'
JFBUkJUS. V. AkIA£PSO>A W7US. Zll, Z3PrYo> JcP> S.FA. 2,2~YlZf^7. ?/),/, T L.F*7. ZJFC

fc^A)). tfAAIA/FV&P./ /MY'7/S (ASFi APPe//AA/7 A/4 AAo7tFSYaFY.
(Z) "~7pF^£pk/PFi uS/aAAt 7U£/AJi/okFAii£A/1 A*/b YYeF P^<77F<:7aCaA oF YA/F F£V£&s7P/Z07FCTF&
PI6//7 0.64I*JSY APP£//ax/Y AS. IS 7A7F54U AWF/AAl{£AAl, U/AS AAoYAA/ly AIM FFc/PF AP
AfSCPFY/CAA, B.UY AFio/aT/CaYOP APPe//AAJ7S &U£-FPuCFSS FfPfPYS PS PuaAP£a/7£F6
B^l 7l/F Ukl/Y£A S7A7FS COMSYi YctY/Osf /}/HA?AAt\M£AA1 //" 7l7F S 74 7&~ //A F£~Ti/£a*/
US£& 7p£Pk/pA*AA£JeS A77PPY TV /AAcAFSYA6rA7£' APP^//p^7S FYY.^ANff^c/S AFFFaISFS
ACAiPST ilt/U, pi/oiu/PA PFPPFL71-Y k/eY/dp-pPIS aIpFAAY P&Q7£C7F& BY 7/AF~ _5"/4
AlHEAjhM£tf7.

                                                 7
p) Uhf&A 7t7£ 57A1F FFFBCFPS T)JF aW*/Ah/7S PPF~AFE£S7 S(/fa/£F" /j/^/PL. t^. XJ a??.//, ICt\fA. A/P .
WC<) 2WiO, X7 L/iolAYFV^ ihsy4u AA«£AA6to£Ar7 ,Cl4A7t /YlP &X4/Z7aJaS Y£7 A£AaA&3 *•*
UeU&SsY ACCAgAA/Atr 7l> 7YF /oi'ii CtuJLI-oP-APPFA-LS,, JZV APPatfAAsyS /SS^F, Tt/Fi&r
)5 MO GUES7'OaA TO Md'AF 8tZ 7*0
 tVA47AC7 A(N TV J£F IF PFr AfA t%TA/^£Pi CouAAJ^t, AaAA Yd F&CtFFA* UAa7^
 UAhlA7£U£lP Fi4£~AJ7£% U/AAA7FiA YO 0aJ /Ye>7

 fBtStST (*/ 7aA<£ fSSt/F' )5 BE~C4t/S/F APPa//A+/7 /JaF> fA^&l jA'aS F£AF&1£- PPa>-
YBCTFYi AaSA FFJtsAL. Fi^PT tup/cp JS 7c P£/haa*A si/faaT THZPFfQlFBUS^i s/ /fe^aA4L P/Aa/7, /S A) A*4F PHU^£S£
tf(ol(t7fOKf secAuser o*a /rs facc a^a*/sy 7Y£"yaca/y 70 777FAAcct/jey) ca7SA
IjA TCP.P. A£Y A05j T~FY.CjaIST. AFyJ $2o a>aa^ 0F C*?A£SF~ TiJcF s4lt a^S
P/Jb P7HFAA6/HF/A72. Fi4jeYp£Xlkc>F£ FaUF StX7F/Us FF7?oaAFa>o/Sl.Y j?F8iA77F&
PPPB.IIaF7S pwf *Io.3 idnP Sa/saJH Y.SYA7F' £4> s.k7. ^Jt/L>A7$(7F)/.<:&'t*.
FYp. Zo{l)/AajA 5a/a^S> V. YFY&S /22 5lCF 2.i7y1z/PZ, ?2 (i^vi?J, YJ A7cf»'*7uS
                            .                 At       tt

_/^3 5 PA. 2.(^3,P1/'. /A/ 5a//aAAS, tA<~ AAFlAidF /MuoL^i Al-S KAA47 70 ££AmA/fA S)/£U7,
 PF JUS7 f£P7 511**7 , AA/A AfA ePldBt TV S£ PPo7£TC7£A, A P£€fr*A niuSY AA/^cFcA 77/tT
                                                                      y                        't
 pPOtkllwiA, Pku/£u£&., AY AOFS /AcYAal>FTV 8F 5P£dtF(f^77y sue//AS 7C ST^y-' jT^>v
                       it

 /kitAI)knAfil 7>1£ 5~A"t*/ A SA/t?i>St*7/7 7PA1 A A>,^X/OaA ArSA.ZF$_ TV £Ffi44s*A S/Y<£*A7 SPx>£si//*PtS_ fax/ aAc 7 cfas*4 tPA 7 AaF /A/iSofcFA /27AY7a/A^F

AS APPcf/AAfl A/6 i S£F 5YA7FAt£AA7 BY F.YIaFaA7£S AY SY7 7£S %,e,FF f?IJ S*//aSM
KI&UPaC S/tiA U/YAY Ai£ it/4*A7£l6f Ai-ZBTT", //J yYsS C^fSF", 7/7eS€£r /S Y/AeT Fca/'F^aZ't^O

M47£)£/AL ei/\&euC£~ /A7 7a7F PFCc'PA k/F/cY SaYcJLAS cPfhazPy y)A/4 SY47£A gY 77/k>*/£ F>YP> t/f 7a/( 7,aY/y A TV £Fis<£~
 P JYATF/MFjAYt P£F>l/t/>F14 AiS Ls4ujy£X. avaiS P££"££SjYF Yt7F~AtCt,,S£& ££7 4 cf YA/FT PP. fUe/FA, £ AtftS aAoT. F£Qi(lJ&FJSAAY. SP£C(FaC
 C7£C7ao>J~ If AaAY&JlFc7AA/AiD<~
 SYAJJ/S AS AaA A77Ft7PY TV /pl/ckf 77AFT PP(^£^£6F, /7 A/CsSY gF F£SPF<- 7£4-
N) lPl£ 14* S•CoUSA- AwPASA~F^r /5 A ^Ac^LFY) p/iiu F"YFF*r, aaa7> a7 AS aAc7 7o StF
 bSnfeA BY£Fa/W4 USFaF F PASSUac(U> TV CteSS J7S ?AS7*CYsctf£ f0lC1*'S /
 CiiAChI AS /JA yPaS CAJf3> 77Sit*'*c#A*4 A/e£Q tf^ 7C JTAr/toU&Hily PPZ 7rA£M eF TPWaA<>AC7/0aY - Jfo BA'^c y, US.
 2.Z3 T.2J l^/.PPF QiU P.£ A MAaA (AAA SF Co/^PF/Pp^ TV YcSYAFy AGAajsSY /JaAas^/f, /AF~ AitsSY
 P^iUF P FAiZ ChUiACP' TV EPFX.CAJF' AaS PAAaAY IfUAFX 77/eT 5"/^ A9/*t£A/AAi/4F^AY'j
 AtJh iiJ acuajAaA V. LA,S *9. a^T./^Z-P.y: VFS. FY-7,tr,7,/^, 7Y.YSI Fd.f^F
 , AZy
 /A/ C7Z6F& TO /AAt/vhF tPF PZ((77/£AFj S££p/so S/»t7f/ tA. US. 337 C/5. 737.7-9S. C'Y.
 JccOt 93 I.FA./ZoY' 0 7¥$)a ?*YS) aAo £ca6£aPLF'aCyA/-a-£A &tP£C7£Y c£ /a/AaPFcy^Y
 met* 1U£Y^>APd//m tESYaaucHY PiiV S£ t/S&& AAyi/AASY Ad>t JaA A)XiY C&M/A£4t*.
 yZoCFGbMAPi •.

\$) TUF 9ZF)1PC(47VF: UUFft APPF//AAA7J StlpYcFa6AAaAS7 Paam?p/p*JF'S£F SY^a7£S
  ££$P£>/JSF Yo APP£//aa/7S BP'PF PA be 7) 5-7 AS -' P. {FL/t?AA7£S TFS7aF/£Zj TF-A7
  flPPti/Atf'i' 5(-(BSF6iaFaA7aY 7fAFoKAk£X) Aaa* 7YA-7 F)FP *Jo7 A>lhF A+aY
                w          /     /                       BAH'ietY Y                .
  JYa7FM£a/7 k>l7Hat7 TfiS AAu/y^C PPF'SFV 7j A)mA) 7aAhy j7(F A^lhA^ £t*s7<4<:7 mtF7A7 SY A 7p£Y oFp/^^2 AaA Al77£AiPY tv i^Pt'aFA£A£as7 S/>F^PL
  BY }Iu^5£/f krt7P£u7 AtS Y7YV^^7&Y FA.FS£aA7 UascYa CPA&>Az),
   /S A) cPfAAZ AZkScTYf &>5CPF7'FaA. -?AYaaA* $ M£l££& S4f>3 /9AAY7,/s*SAr 7V /A/ooAe.
  HIS gl6A/7A '%a/(aA4S (u/iS S/feuY, 0L/1 A>PP#/A»A7' //At/tpFtt AJAA SPotC Af^A SA'A
  AC AO(AAtP\ MtT SAtMtZ. )v/7Pcaa47 aYi'J ~/770£^A£y P/ZFS£aAY.7 S££ 71 t. .f. Ae)S'.
 Up) FF-7 AS S7?7£tt P»A7y gtzF/FCAFft (SY 7Pt£ Bi/JAFaACC TTi^l APP^Fs^Y £>/A c/aa*«
  ti\S. ?E0ieC7£YS PaMY BFPuPF'tie tt.Pt A&ZFS7F& / S££ JZTiTZJ £FSPaPSF~ TV APP^^aa7S

  3Pl£F UIAICP ^YS •' TH£PUsi1aaS6£Y. SAAnp/y T£ST/Fr£Yj TPA 7 JaAF y>77*£a*U>7 TV J/FAA 7z> /Yf*?. JFF gF(£AA7£5
   RePCZl ?AA£ 7 AF SYA7c'S epoA'OiA'; y^d^F AS aAo PlAtAFiAta /aA riAF~ 7?£Z*>*A &F

  7UF hWF APPE//47F U/AS APXFSYF&j HtAtuFvFPZ. , F.FiA£K/7£J Y£S7aF/FY± TP^7 FaS
   CetJt/t)£54 7/U/F U/A7Y APte//A*/Y nccAXFTb ppivR. Tv a9PPf//a/a?£ AJZAZizSYi /* <*•
  FU£U7£S> FFPAF7 BB77FM £f F/AA4L. PAAF~, C'. fiAFAAYcS c/FX1*Yy UJPi7FS 7)7A Y
   APPPAam/7 COW14C7FM C< Tt,<£/A7£S> 2-/)AyS AF7cK Fi/LSY CeUAlACT, k/PP*^ C-
                          ',

   fhltJUFS- 91YJ '• APp£//^A/Y CVU?**:?*™ Af£ fi^l S-*"4 7PA7 aAaS A7Y^AZ^A£y     'I
   f.          It
    Ah\A)S£&        hlfAU AAi>7 YO SP&HC ~ro P/£ AAAYAAeAcyY //AAA p'TZFStzAA'Y.

(0)) ~THF PuYiFJACF s/lou/S Y/PAY A)PP£//A7£rAS BlfiPY k/P£/A Af~ syaifS /k/ hjAS
   VRlFF TrlAl PAS Si/fa/cFApAS PZF-FFPaFSY, ZF£--AW/J&}*//>4 \Fa\7ZAAJ/jA y. A71aZF>4A-

   ZSFU.S., Y3b>(1 J&&), AAouP aPfXaF7F ya/F' Paaa/Y APpMaay h/4a/7£ 7a/££et,i?7 70
   UPAQeS7Ai>/7i, ACCPRhtKAFr TV 7p<£ SYs>7£, ~J}j£*S(JAUF SYA 7£72 YaP(7 tt7£ C^e./e7~dF^

                                             [E>
  /F CAt^AY PF 7A/iF irAA,7£7$ SY4 7d?S /hue Sc7/7
  P£Lh 7PA7 pAZF-AFAFSY, P££~~Ayj,Fsl^'AA i>/A7 aAF.'SA/sa/4P* UAt/£/A (k{ TaC7, k/pA7 k/F A4U£ /S A Yo^FaA h//7// ^-SAAi£S >
 )P2d.lu£dJ ' ~M£ Rl*H1 UAAS A/cY Al(^A^£iCt.. AS AaS Ff£AYs ~z47£1A EY 7//£rCeK(£ A, tF~ Yc<~/
  kli/UA.7) PFfFA? 7V *>APx£4SFb A33 S.Pp 2f£3-FY, S^/aaA^S Si^tfYy /?£M4/a/£)6 Sa/faAY.
(If)   fhtP7pFk}AicYF, PPA£//aaa7 AaA *Ac7 Bppl£ss/y *>4y Y£~ PAIS AlVA* So> JS4J£lO ®nAV»(A77£70 AAA A-8c/SF OF 6(JC APPJzA/aa/7 S^PPOS£Yi ~70 )^S£ 2^7 W/Y^A= Yo
  YOL( IAJA7H Fl7 A770FA/YFFaS£AA7         AaaA     At 7 A77t>/?*S£Y AAUtJFA /He aAC? TV T^AK.

  TV YcU UAtYA/FWY AAM , SPct/A-A AMOS 7 AFFA+SA 77- Y B£ £i/C UPY-_J J~*S *4. S, U- BuP.&U
  5Z tP. ZP* il96> fio 4U. Cs /99/J, A/A yYFYFS7am }5 rpA? OMOr A7
  tFYZUhAH-1 dfS. (dUtksA A/5 KI6AJ7 TV (LFMAAaA Si/fl/A, j7 TS T/v//>FXmAS'P1-5/£
  F0Z.-1X4F ?2CsFCoi7aOaA TO FPFBP To AaVY. FtFlH AAaFa/A/uFaAY F/6P1 k/Y/c/7
 -fUF htFFPhAHI a ytFCCtSFQ, SFF frPiFF,^/ y. Aa/aPvaza/,A 2SO La.Z ./„Al. Y,aF. PS
  S-Q4.17.7,7.(Z3S,/YP.£c7. Zj/eL, f/9C5\ /JvuaGUFiP, ,7 /S F*f/FCY£A 8V 7PFF££oSa£C^7oK Pel UJ£& 777FS//faY££~aF aPPeY/aa/Y aa76 CA>a%AaaFj/Y£A
    filiOAY J 7 TV TpF TUPY, APA THF IahPPoPFaZ Coam,hFaA7S pJk>^Y APSe7/aa/7$ SjYfaAcF
    KEiPCi US£7\ fiGA/AASY Aim AS P Fa6sYoF Ftca/a. Y. TpeFC<4 7CO>vF aF YPlF P£a>-~

    ££££>)if6S UfOUt-P> AaAft-Y ATX-
    FECiS/PPr wAAT TtfF IAA/A7FVS 37AYFS CUAlSTtTt/Y/O/A a/a£ TaYF~ 7>uF~PYfCFSS

    CLAcfSF *>AY /Y IS A/S RI&H7 70 dAc/PP, kIuuJ TYaF SYA7FpAS FA//&& TO SYA7F"
    &P. TuYOiaY a SPFFtFtC laaYA>ua6F' tAAY h£r£>7MM:7F) $a±ci/l/} a,(S£' u/AfaA
    lK\Uok,kFft A/S FFJbFFAL- FQLtPL. P/ZF7FC7F& gi6P7 YO FFLF jAAcPtfHtY*7aoaA*
    PltftSF P.Z.F&P -TO) U.S.FFaCcAWiaJ Y7Q F. zJ f «/3 6172. 5-1UCi'K "j'y /S
                (    t
   AFPFEh &Y-ALL TtfA-7 A CUVAA aF tAF a?PHaF/e6F~ bt£S Alt 7 PFQLtjK.F'FtAfY
    'SP&iF/C YYF k/FPA>S, VlAIiJlYj A U/ITaAfSS. /JsEAs tAfl Y /MuF'
    IMF 5£tLL OF A Mk/yPP. TV IktOok-F tU£ pZP7FtY/dW£>F S£LF -JaAC/^/H/kI-
    ftYiOti ClAUSFj SEF'Yper Z-JU PavFaAM/FjAY TV 7PF UaAiTFK STA7PS Cj/A-
    ST/TUTaFaY AS UJBLJU PS TYF /Y'M FAiFAAA.MF'/AY.
(/ffl) JfuCF, PMFOAUSF FF Ya/F AUfitASYA7w7ACAA4F £>CPcteS kAdF" 7$Y 7AFr7X/**-
    d0UZ-Yr7fte-YI/>p£;//4AY7S 477APAAF7, AA/A 7/AF' PPF>S£C^?o7lr 77//.J /-&>-Y«A*$a&F
    F  Ta4pPf//a 7zT PXCOF/XaCF/ AXL A7 +FVS 7, jY*A
    7H/FAY7F&FSYA?F FP4£7aCF"s A?<£a*7V tc//7P X£SP£C7 TO CtA(*tj #F /PFAYF^fUF" A$S/S7A*7dF &F C*c+sjF<-

fiT 7/iF YAZiAl. AaAA APpFlh7F /Ma£L A'aAAFS Jp Or* Jpe fatAOAFSS aF 7/PF7Ux*c Aa/A 7P£~
&AlA&t((7Y AF YtIF^tA^'HFAAY OF COHUiC7kO*A £FScsc7A*f77 Tftfetf^vS2**-*. Y~.A.r17 2>2- •/AP
7UF: ?PF5£J«1 &)£, &7A 0 FPouuiF cfFEFY/->FpSS(S7A*PC£ op &«*&£<- / A<-js£Y7, Af/pP/*7F'
 CcutPSFL. pAS fr/&4 thtPFFFXlAuF PsS/SYaaccC C/A/A4 erf Y&A<^C<7Y'AS£A,'I, o/uLl) /SSueS
PilA> CS) ?Afi*6fi*PH*' PFyUS PA>viA£4 lAj£FFFC7t^/f AS5/S7A*/oc cF Coc<*aSF<~. Him -
5&FFa. fHP h/07 CA^AfaA^/aAPt -Tpc S-uFF/CAFAACY OF cU/a)Fa(CF od A/AP~£7 AP/&H-
KAvuJi>A£7/?"J*&C CAaA /Ac7 A77AtcJz. 7*jF SuFF7CA£PAC.y 0F
&a/6£aACC eiA Aa/?f#JS ZB<"£lY, 7X<3CFf*^f*7S£-- 57X7&& TiiAl 0*iF~ 0F 7*/F 7DF#3f»AX fif/Z A aAF^A
                                                                  u

TfHAL e>/J A7?FP\U WAS TpF S^FFiaFtAcY aF SUiAF/Ac^j uYPa^I Ey TYtP Pdy
                                                        A
/S 5s FtAATPWe-y TO YPF' TUA&a/F'aaT AaaA ZP4S>7}£1(a7&S %£<(pF caaP. pAKA^PAPd 4F7 AF STX7FIA\~. 7}F7£>< 7P•£'-p£.A4*C&«AZY
 EYchA&ts {££7*1-7FuiTj-e/PcF FFFFXF& BY 77/F AFFFaAScF, Ca>c/aASF(- PPtA/iB* -^o
lAAbt AA oFFBt of PZDPF, 7D £ST/lz/(S7P 7At\" /YA7u^£r a7/AA At/>At/sS/A?///YY aF
IHlS 7£aAA&j~As FJstAePCc /fcLa/aJP. )
   (A)auFA>£Ys POSi/^S T>Y OXhPIA/aYaaAY AaY rAca~8e*F ((3R£(g)/v5J'
   $)AH£li8A POS7aYFS, BY &*v(PLa(*xaS7S. F&>7P&CAiJ> PPFF^OZ (a%ZP_® Ze>~FY;
   (PSAF liPC/AeJAI IPu<,joAK(F( Ct>AHpU/AAAAA7Y70tACpAAAAf APPF//aaP7S 7>i/7?->cF-S U/tPP
     paeFi>(>A(f}>iz.z.AV>s{);
$) "fti? -j&ttfiLouy OF A£. ^VtUtS tuPA6P Y, p/L£>. £/YZP- <& /eF-AZ-Y))
(E) p PF&PT&s OWil ppouF C4/I B£7uJ££aJ PPp£7YtA77 AAAA maa7«AFsS ^/^aae-r P**-<*<&<
   U/lUCfl CouFSFL AFFe3&&> uJ (7$ cU7f€.FYY ((YZP. wZ.))
(3\   A/atP/ 17 IS C-FrtPLVY THAI APpPPU CoutA/SFL. jfAS 7^a/j3j 70 £FiAA£kP 7YF ^FFcxGAj
PCA^>R.bthP&, 70 7/AF APPP/'P^S AUFA40PY bcttY yO YP^AffAc *p ~zA^4^SCP<:A7p f^yot
/{VpFAlklF COfAAjFC-p 7 A/C
iu ADA/ 7/o*Y/ 7AFT YP/Ait. Ji*A6FT Ptfm 7PF~pJk>JFC~<20&, AtPS. Istc/PS* a/oAO/Fj- to
TA.&F MP-- PA(ifF< P*(7 £>F 7tA F&avcF~
f&OM SO TA-? PPP>SFC<47ZX. A>F& A4AZ-.PA(pt&t FA*-<-Y) J,/J7FFaA 70 7AAF~A&F1PA)aF6 3X*/
PI^MF GAlf (U (pueSf/OAY. E>Y 7a7c TcaY, yu€ jPjPC^PA SPvulA* zFflfcy jka 7 7a/aS
Bi/tbe/tCFP WAS YtsPAAFA) A£aua£A 0f~ /7S     T^^sF £aaA47£aA?-1 g 7A/F~p7ZoJ(££*< P*< /

AF& 5Af£S jiFCItfSF" TYF? p2P>JFAAAf'y/ THFPFfvY.F' VaoIa rF% Af>C 7?l/fi4AP.Y A<47Y CY7£A
                                                                                At

IF YFX. totFP£(H PEJf. API 21.PF IvflFeFT (Y SF? 5PFC(AC-
                 {         r
WOSFC+YCZS M07 70              CcVJOtCP, U~/7 7€> SPF7 77AA 7 H^SlACt /5 tPx/lF, 7/YFY
5tlA/{ aAo7, 5UPFALFS5 7AC7S o/\ 5AXJZP7F a//rAAo7S£S tt/'YUALF' aF FStaZL/P/aaP/t -ft/FT
lUPoOeuCF eF 7PF ACCt/SFA, /7i3&F/ 7P£~P&>5FOl7AFL U/A7*7Ye/YS FA^PAStF' FfiAtFASt-F
Vi'47 iF fPFF£U7£A> \PoulA AauF AiAAF" 7P<£ A.aFF&ZF'JCC /aS 7P£~A P*K»AF CALL p/t Y^STaMoUY /oa/acP &P6 /*uAt£P tzY--pAP7&
6oihHUYiCA7aoaAS ?£PHt1?£P!> K7 7/7tf7PAAl C 3UA<$F~r AL%£J7, MFFaasF dx^jSJet -pf/iFTi
TV Fssd tf>X_ 'ZA'A FU/OFtSCP" TO ZF OFFFP&S TZ> yP~FJA ^Pc^ ITiPY 4pV^/A*aP
WAS lYo7 77£.Y/*P£r 70 C^atCiY AlPYOtA-FMl/PL AacaaF" 7/AF/z/Y&FFPi £A/C7'*S 70 &FcfAASPs
AS 7AF pPOJFCAApiit IAA6F /Y Si>*AAfA f TPdT PpOAAtYFA-A'P iuptuLb Aa^/P" CAjFHAZF® -7*/a£-
J5JUC AAAA ?fyV&fS bfFF&tFAPT B^7 CA/cY IF 7/AF PZP)S£&^7&C- U/eUtA) aYc>7iPfUF~

                                          1A
 U/elA7A3a /k3€ m'toAtYY jbUYY p/ATs YfYFC A«& P"/ZCFSS aF •7/AF' ALYi(rtfj sF Ai.<\7t3t(AL, FfpLOtcPA 7*AZy BlAtAFAACt, //J
                                                             tP
FAVPP- 0F YAF PCU/JB6, 2*0, PlFaSiF ScF" trXHl#/7             £, 77 /5 AAA A)7=Fa/SAasa 7
Pfa)UtdQ& BY >*£-. PaP/hF>P U/ifiul -FPePA-lz-P ?? Ya4SFlA47o/P TPUaAPV) A Tyi^J^SL^" pA/7^A£rSS Y/AAf CocaY) /AoY
Be CPrtfTZiAXIeaa Iaji7pI 7/A€ YJZU7/Y /aI AccPPZASAAAtt. TZP 7AeT St^X A/i#faaAAaFajY
ftfjb Yppp dFUFA^O^~M7/OAY CLAtAStF. l4lp> TP-aaF y/^lFy(YF~ WZrHY
TBTalF ~m.(A ( /9APA piAL PAAAfK. PtA/A OEaIaZjY 7/YF j^c7S aF 7/YF~ PAJFr/ Ca>la^ASFL.
CAHLAS HACPF.FF7t363^ /?S PiAlt&rAC (SAUtF/AtC-/%>c/7 oc/& to A/S LaCA^- aF /a^tPFAFSY

ft/Ah /YoFSl/f^TwKf, /t CUP$Fp7 F&SStZtAF, fAJ Pau/FLL. iA. ALA^AAFi ~ZSY 0*.S.

jA5, 52 S* L4. S7/ L.atY pZT Qf3Z,J} /7 phs ZszaP ca&vll-Y f-ftiFYi ttMY* ZFf=
THE fvuA<7hA7/'»Y0FYY£ AKF*/SBh 7aJF /AA-i aYc7 SFFaY n>utL7 TdZA^PtA A^f
ftiuFSPtlriAI/OfY, Y^^TPypF dJAA$7/7<47ecAAASfC j?/4/f7S aF 7/AF ACAA/Sm pIa PFFLFLY 7PAT 7#.(A(~Cca4AAS£:L Arf&^FAS A PtFdt^ALdFiH JVfO. P/PoaAC.
                                    al
(All tzAt7/PB/Y7 S£F~ /Ea/A(/Sa7 J ftf/L 7P/S pA/A/Y, 0Af7/7 CaiaaJSFLS jJauF' PPF'F
ThiF & WiJtfjS 0 7 5 YPiLKLAl »A7S 1/ UAASU1AAP, 7QAI Va,(. iit S, A./.g', /oYS.FY.JtPTl,
gg Fed.ZAQ>7YFi4FV)> AaAA ecyPtPauF ir/p/'AYePi y/YF'FP^ aahaFaJAmtfaaY#7
7HF 14AF1FYS S7AWS> Co/ASTa7u 7aaa/', APYF7 j5 £&t SFtF ALSO mCCY- PP-T Y<£>5
AAfA (.077, •gFtAt/se BC7AA cmiaUPflS PF&vKMaMCC Apt/£ &3£AA A^AYA/S/U7A^AjFy
biFTiae/Al M YYF facC Ap YAPP' PFAjiPJ}... ^ZTFFXPutPF, /Af -KPaAS/TaY (A.

-ZYAlF I1Z. SUA. ?>cP (, / au/SLFAAaaAP? AaAA\ 8F/a7F>0 PTZpAiAC7'tf>F#/? Lstctz FP^
Vlnl>HXrf 0%jFC"?H/AAF^/i ?fr#e ?^AYFj
ALScP'y t(tAU/7SCi S7A7FS SuP/ZF/kF tcuei F/ytPAtS/TFS 7Y/1 0«7y To A3'?a**p a9VA
RFt/taUf tF/FUAAPl PAA7&t(<7C<. ._gt/HPFn4 1/'•«• hO&A 72.5 S.lyC -ZY5-£ (hr'SJy

                                           if
&) f)PPFl/A/Jl Aaoj^LMC UAmRF>7A*AAS yPAY iP/P GZVUAlA IS AthA/AAST 77UAL CjuaASFLj
BU7j UIHF/A &t7tl C4L4A/SGLS ApuP ?POcStP£F} ///FPfsiFC7/iAF' FFPFjFSAPlfTst 7so*Y, F? 74>ePC ny*
1UF 7/^A/Af #F ?APFZS oR. b£FFtF-
CJUHfYAL fipPtBALS AP6 PPY APPFlALS CaLaAHY SiiALC 7£SY <¥aAA ^A^aacC Y/YF"
6lA£j FYTjlPrtontPLFX <7Y FF P^SS/SLF^
£>fFFtf$F:5 APaFsJ 7HF AteAFS%4S/L.(77 #F U/(7^FSS£S TV AUtL/aYSFL ) see'
P2A)u-(C la. U.S. YLG> lA*5.l*Yg,£Fl.£7A'.ZJ/<,F'71 /oYS-C+ZpsC . 4ouA£u£7t
APpUcAaPI P24Y5 -tf/$ CP-17FPAP CAAJ oP- &«-*- &7 ftAoP7&A\ ZY 7f7tS Cac^/^Y YO
d£>/Jc/i4&F IF 71ZIA<- LAiAtYSPLC?) fiAFY TPF' SYP(CAc^AaJA SYAtsA/rVZA $ 0 F g£Aje>AP-
AUFAFS>, biFPtUlFMT A~aPA fBtf^RjA/^ACFt^ huF 70 yaZ/A(, cjiAaASZC UoT
Ba/U6 J>X£p<\Z.&D T0 6d 70 7PYAC7 AF tUa <7o7 SPd^C^TO YaAF' Ao/AaAFSScS
Ti-lF AFF^FaAMaPY PTZPUiAFtij 5ucp 4S,®\f//zaajf7P Cm ?.**/£//M CAmPp7'*SA,IaaWYAaAaY FYAZ^cP^Y/ (c) lk& ACaSF^Y PAt/^FTt ,C4)Y>Z Y/YF 07fy<£<
fi(/F6BC> \AltF7PY, Aj.A, WlAtiKA u/AS At-PFoKAlPA Y jAoY tZaFAAY TV At-FFrAAlOiCYaOaA FA>P- h/(MA£^/AA^ flppFlPU/TS
A)PPX£i/ltrflS/CAA<^/j0 \APbS»OF J/J yA/P~ ZFPaFA a^caeS /T SAPiV A C/lAA^itF  OPt Fvi4A/£>
/)-? F.L>7*Ai£AjS At?Ai<£F (yUAZtYPt 7Y/S FPlJoAFT, Pk)u7£l/F^t, 7AF CPAAZAP' a/ZOJ£~
6U1 67 P/J07PFK FpAAZAlF kAPicA //ACIhAF& A biPPFF*EAJY aA/£~*£YS l/IL7/»4;
S£F CALASF Kfpl C-FL.3e:!}t5PlS m *>Aaa\ CtPt£.6£- M(4% AiSau./SS£P> gtf 7/AF SY*f7£F'
 Y£1 Fi/TAAStziAi PU<7xuaca7 (t/A S FYa// 0Ai PPV lyt 7s£>*A ?&£ AojA/ZPiiF THAT ioA$
M5*/S5£fl/ APotO 7PAAL. CouaPSFC 5Huue~A a-P^^F' 14JF^ tP£F^aAFaacF" ^F S<* fA,
ACCeF
lP1p4?bu(A3P. ~&Y 7UF &s£fY P)F1&<~ A-A-Ms P//oujFYj To TcSYAFy
IkT PgBiF/tl C45^~ At pPo Y/h/F A/A LTflz^/zFjA P^szaaa^/A aJ/YA&C p)£f&*s/ptAA?
PY'Aet rhweP aYoA PUe,6 /)PAI&P7ayJ/0*Y, Sti&M p?S yA/F5Yi7^7&Fs/y
CAa£A£YS MPS- KlAZnuC//rAc/tTAVFTA. "Tut^tFFMFr, CcuaASFL. f&i/m TV Ft>i~A> yY(F
yPose£M7(v*J tv a aibi^/aa^h^/^ piAL/Bt^AP-tP^ YesYSAAAt AAA&A/P? 7/Per /}&—
(AFP$*FLY PZPFFSS pPFSttOAplf^F/Y UaaPF/aax/F\ SF5F PJPaU/F 0. Aa,S. Y^lP
U.S. IaYF. ffO l.fJpJ 7,57, /oYS,€Y. •aa^FPJc/aa\. ^tY^tV5aEfevxAl/A^
6tPjU4*4STAU£CJFS> JLtS%iFY A PP£^4AtiF7/o/A oF /P£FF^C7tOF~ ASS/SYAaazF £>/^

CouP'SFLi CAaA A PsM stJ^A/AAfFASY CLA/A^t 7S(F 5U^P/Ca£^AY lc>(7Pou7 /jA6714A#-Y
IPTO OouYSd/s AC7H4/'PFPFi>PJi S.CY /YY7 C/97^! 7//tu Aic*cP jyF AA*FA/A)*fF7/Y

P£6!L4/P.F5f Mc7 AlFPFpJ VlF 7Pou(S/oaA OF (P/Ut/SFL Y0 7UF ACCuSFd / B*/7
/ Ufl7t/ Bc7P 7pF /P7F./CAC/F5 SFU, Jo "7, 3 7 L.FY "
ZP QlYs 3 S.C-P Z-YCrF QYll), /F AJo P£7C . - AAlA AaA TX./A /. aUalsaASafP A/oY aP/ous£A 7PF~ 3YA7F5 P%0S ~
iPCiHluP. Tb kJnPP-O/A FUtAFAACF P/JA IP/taYF'SSFS FTZuaa 7AF~ A£F£r*/SFT) T/Af"

Dl4lCoihFr U/oisLAi /UutF BAFtZKA &/FFFPa$AA7.

(l) TRIAL- Cvu*A££lS 79Z4UAt//FUY LUaUCFa-ZaAFOaT cF Pm7FX/a/ FuiAFi/tF/ PPJ>~
UidFYS Alt UK34ST OoaY/L&Au&Y, A*JA At $ Y9\((LrAUF Yo £Y£d*/7F A/JY /aA/AFsy'/CA 7*-t)*F

/Jj -Jp£ AASF PZAUt6F)A TYF /UaAJ^S7 PFSUuY AaAA TP£ Ca/jFPaPA/FSS Mf Jt4SY/C €•

A9P£l/AA/7 k/AS DmlY AaA/S BFCAWSF TVLlAC CocaaAS&L. Fi>P6c1 THAI 7/AtF Isa/ao&ZSjF
?JlA6.&SS PZ07FC7£A BY YPF~ F+lx AA%tF*AA>AUFAAT- P££u/X£S 7HA7 77/F ACxU/SFH
i\auF LUjuiASf/ AdY/AAP, i*A YA/v Ro(F OP AU /)AUorA7Fr, rj*A~ />jJAa?**> ts . a>4 A,/SA>*.a,A
%XI. U.S 7li,->U?, /P / .FYPJW/3, i?n S C.A.ittfrFtVAlS* TP£- P/Aa/7 7Z> FPFFFY-
luF   ASS/SYaUCF OF CeuAfSFL. J5 7aAF a?J*//7 fP 7a7F A !>&,£**7aL>A/S C*sF -YO StAZfiLsF TllF%C&>*$0f &F PiFAAAa>AA, Pc* / AAuF)tS4PtAL
TESY/VPt i U/A/FAA A Y£u£ AMaFACZA/ZiAL C7Z/MA/A4L TAt/A^P/4aS BFcaY Y TUP7 f2,\J/X. Aa*£a/&uFA/7 AiS AcctsPjpAi BUY
 IF TUP ?ZF)t£S5 LoSTP CpAPAC7£)P fi 5 A doApp&eA AJYA 7eV*A J^FIkAFFaA A&UF&'yiPA't-'
tjSUCp AS m 7PF PPFS£tf7 £AS£^J 771* dAASY/7<47 A4fA£t6£UCC- ^3^ aK JZ£^ya££a\ jj/gr ^jm^/CauX.7 7V FAPMCF£Aa*/Pt to#u^ 7pyt 2>ll<7Y PiAY /PlA c^^x/SF/AC7£Y\
/?5 AAL/&icr^LY AA/A /AoT PS 7) FP/£aAA ap yAF £A,
AF U/oALA Al<7F PaPOU/aA DM"! APP£//aaA7 c(f*Z-(y /Ml/okpYl U/S 5"A-^ AQ/tfFAAi/lAFA/Y
7V /Uu£S7/(Yl7uAt C. FtAFr/./7£S> OK( H-L-U , YYaQAF'Fv^F', /J£ Faa/&6 TZ>
0B3£aAS7a7c*Y/c>aAAL

pfZA7£Clt36 R&H7 YO XF t=FFFCl/<7£/y Z£PAl£S£AAT£& BY U)U*ASFL^ P/VUL&
TSFCAAAS/AFFPYi P ^t4AAMAKFAA7AU /U/SOARFA6F OF TUS7/LC, %£CA£/SF APP£YA^7
IS /Y d~tSYoAY //A Pwk-Y/OA-f A>7 TTAF'UiuS AF 7//F C*MauoaA IYFxPyaY /JAAA A*A
iAtd/j7ec)AJ AF7P pufPA^Y/A^
771(4It TpF£P~ /S Al !PF.£Aii£tAAPUP pFxJFHKi ll7Y tHAY aAo Pa34SAaA4&/£ Ji*7teP 0%
FA£1 TiATAFA? IaAvulA Pf FPutJA Al** Gut/yy aF 7p
tAAI TPF d*t4/Z.Y-OT~(-Pej*t/AA4(/ YfpPFPf/s orT^XPS SaPcuLA PtXQaJY 7/A/S
 T7£TlTtA>*J 4t>fL htSCAttFYAOiAAP-Y iZpoiFk/ —FYaa JfSCAS AJa/V£-

                                                           llySU&AA/77F&

                                                         /huuuT-

                                                A/F, 0)75/717
                                                SYeueTlPF/A UaA/ A
                                                £lafzf),Fp-. 779SyP
                                                 2-5 SFPY AS

                    LBe7tnoAiF of Sa&ut FC

     AtF uYd&tS/YtAYFto Q?PfI/a*/7 A£Pl=aZY CF)C7/F/FS tHai a YPaaF aaaA
AtoPXFtF AAYA U/P./Y7£*/ Y^PY AF 7lAFr 7i*PFp7i?/AAA, Pf7/7siAAY -£r A,'c,aP)i PaSYAAF PJejTPA/6, YU YF/FFP97CF,
 AF 7AlF <>/&££- 0F IPFrYlr'it &uP7~0Ar~/qA2*FK/57FA3P7/PtfA,A^          AFXAS
 £>ti AP AS6C41 7A/S 2-S-4U FtfYAFS7£A>7. 2^AA^.

                                                   Jppt7?A*A7 P&•-£r

                                   9-0
                                                                              FY
                                                                      FAA/s/ a FY
                                     AFFIDAVIT OF TRUTH          <=
                                       **•***»        +

  STATE OF TEXAS                               §
                                               §          SCILICET
  COUNTY OF mblA/J&.YY                         §
                                          »»♦#»#

                        "Indeed no mora than affidavits are necsaaary
                         to make Prima Facie Case1', United States-v-
                         Kia, 6B5 F.2d 526, 536 (7th dr. 1981), 50
                              U.S.L.y. 2169; S. Ct. March 22, 1982.
 mm/**   Und"8i?ned •"'iant, Albeit ;A. Palmer, hereinafter Affiant, does sole-
 mnly swear, declare, and atate aa follows:
     1
        Affiant ia competent to atate the mattera set forth herein.
     2. Affiant haa personal knowledge of the facts stated herein.*
     3. All the facts stated herein are true, correct, and complete,
          admissible as evidence, and if called upon aa a witness, Af
          fiant will testify to their veracity.
     4. The purpose of this Affidavit ia not to intimidate, harass,
          or cause problems in any way, but, only to be used in an
          Evidentiary Hearing upon Bench Warrant.
                                PLAIN STATEMENT OF FACTS

 Th. Sf? V8* °n *^° u,ltnB8a atand» durina R°bert Munoz's Trial No. CR3B.946.
 The following questions and ansuiera occurred between the prosecutor, Mrs. Laura
 Nodolf and I, to the best of my knowledge as follows:
 MSD0Mnnn
 Mr. Munoz ""h•,^l™*»    l8n,t
            while Mr. Munoz was"in trU6'
                                    jail that durin9 County,
                                         [at Midland one of vour conversations
                                                             Texas], Mr. Munoz with
                                                                               ask-
so SL*S          Eli2f5Bth KU2mich tthB ali^d «icti-. Maryann Kuzmich's mother^,'' veered
so that Maryann could recant"?                                                     rcLe "***
MR. PALMER:    "No Ma'am".

NODOLF: "Mr. Palmer, [at this point, Nodolf pulls out a CD that the defanse did
not know existed without objection by defense counsel, Mr. Wayne Frosti! I
have a recording between you and Mr. Munoz, would you like to hear it?"
MR. PALMER:    "Yea Ma'am".
JUDGE:    "How long will it take to listent to the CD?"
NODDLF:    "Your Honor, it's almost lunch time, [it'a about 11 -35 a m or an")   T
the" SSoS:/:1^ 1° ^ Qfft°B dUrin9 1UnC,; and allow Mr. Palmetto lia?en to"
the [recorded jail phone call], CD there."
JUDGE:    "OK, we we'll do that!"

?SI?+. ^r+^'i/1"!!0- a8kBd mS t0 d° i8 tQ havB EUzaheth record Maryann to "Re
in ihyJ"t e;b;^n:vrtouched her- sinc* ***™ ^ tau Im^u
iL   L5!?i took
Mrs. Nodolf r „ me to
                   r a room'that*Mr*MunDz    never
                             so she and.I could    touched
                                                listen     Marvann
                                                       to the      •••• jail
                                                              recorded    s°»
phone call between Mr. Munoz and me.

n, h1^611^6'
or             J !emerabBr
   hold me in contempt  for Mra- Nodolf
                             denying the aaid she could charge
                                          conversation.  Idon'tme belieVB
                                                                   with something
                                                                          i" L-
ing a conversation with Mr. Munoz, I believe I was denying what Mrs. Nodolf was
alleging that Mr. Munoz wanted me to get Elizabeth Kuzmich to record Maryann
l°^ltgt V"Rfantn' when Mr' Muno* «" actually acking me to have Elizabeth
    If this CD, that was brought out in Court by Mrs. Nodolf would be listened
to in its entirety, I believe the truth of Mr.,Munoz1s intentions to get Mary
ann Kuzmich,to re-admit, Mr. Munoz never touching Maryann, not Mr. Munoz ever
asking Maryann Kuzmich tD "Recant", aa Mrs. Nodolf allured in front of the judge,
jury and the entire court. This should all be in the trial transcripts during
my testimonial and cross-examination by the State - Mrs. Nodolf. To the best
of my knowledge, I don't believe anyone else was allowed or heard the true con-
tenta of the recorded jail phone call between Mr. Munoz and Me.

                                                 9/L^s ^fcd~±u7\/
                                         Albert A. P a l m e r "

                                         ♦   *   #   *

STATE OF TEXAS

COUNTY OF      ECT0IL
                                     *******

                                       NOTARY

    SUBSCRIBED, SWORN TO, AND ACKNOWLEDGED before me on this                eH        day of
5epf?t*dFF                   sens.

                                                 fan* Jk
                                        NOTARY FOR THE STATE OF TEXAS

My Commission Expires: jPBk.\d!fAlJO^/Zfi/S

         CliO PAIR* SO'O                                  /*V~4;'''. i Nf'o'y BuO»c. S'C'e-. •'• Ts*as
     Notary fvoat. Steie of 'e«a»                         ixF                  Anger
           s'oftiapwertortSeffliftay
                                                                     Fkjhgng