Court Opinion

ID: 4041578
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:51:49.912711+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:28:32.230829
License: Public Domain

_!le»z Q¥H Gn§§w ¢/¥3@@)¢
§,)¢\@ wm wg.,ém?©…o$, \"\N\ 55\\*
Y>QMW<\¥ \T\L& 77765'

‘;<; w , }“\U¢\~ §“` \ <'><>\5 F\b\%&`a<>°?~f>
` \\ /\z»;loo'i»/}
‘Q€/ ~ \\ v ‘-\‘ac>o? `A

mm c\¢,<\q; Q… _4\>@\ A_@,§+<. v PE c
" CMA< cfc Cx;-N\;m,\ A€P&C\§ couRTéF(c:r;:;a¥l/;AT./JAFSFEALS
w em 1@30<<. ,cap:+»\ S&DLW\

,, MAR122015
Aw¥~\<\\ \x. 77571\

)
Abe| Acosta, Clerk

Ef\c|o¢_,-eol "/m win <\:\\\J m\ OTLS>~\M/- COV`/‘ ap ¢/V\>’
\\ _ _
R€>Pov)e' +@ N\~i +MJ cohc%s/C/‘J§*“§q?embr Mz%_)
G\->\L< §§ C§Qx\~f mci¥ \\c»\>€u§ Cm'?u$ §//¢07.

‘_L`L` \fcm haw any ‘Lo\es$\‘.y\§ w Cc)Mvv\/mv'&ov

`u_\§¥mc§<\`)m\$ ~\:w~\ W§§ \<\m/C-,. mom/5

3/`/) C€ Y` Q//`/]

W %M»

` TW flag @,:M

j_\/'.,M _/\¥¥6 C/v§mb~A&\ Co»¢& oil AP€A&\$
‘:EN <¢~\ \\wc CQ\Y>MFN%@%&LL § CGW,\C NG(§) j

game w\/\ 351\¥ ’Flb{‘i&o~‘élc)a‘?» D
%m>\w\m\<\'s`¥`n. 77705. § grL'-{a((@§~g@@7._ ,4
(\zv,->M QQ§(:QM\ § q:m_w~aom~/t

_.\¢._.

Te)€a$ %QYC&\/@N\e>r\\“ o& C,r`\m`\m\ 3\»9@`§£

SM\¢L @§ 'TQ}\C»§
Q€§`\¥\€ more Q\té?m\<_& 40 `_\'C\<»,\ `Q`ou<&@ ®c>\zc

(%U\\Hr\€\ A??\`\Loér‘\o<\ ¢QG~€ m¢l\~ ©Sv \\o`\>€az CQt ch‘l QI[§>SN)
1b FY\‘\ZLQS&LL_`> ou<`<~@n#\hi `\1\ '~\'RL w<,+o@o\{ o\~\~H/\e S~\~§\?§
\Blj<:.l¥\ 5000 \`»~\N\ ZS/L\ \ ?>@Mw\ov\¥\`f`li 77765'.1 1- now
§§ee@c\$< \<> *<)\4\1 \¢\o¢\ovq\@\\ Qow<& csc C§`\mtmq]_ '/APP€_Q’S»M‘/
\\Q\€SPOY\%QH 46 T\!\Q"'\q§?\“ Su~?%x"\oc \Dt:>"vv€c§( Q_o¢.`<"-\- o c,\¥‘( o& /\)Qc.o'a<\w/\~<§’ ow\Q-x w ¢¥U\%
OX@\`\CO§¢§O\\ ~&OC wv\j< 0§» `€\C\>oaé CO€VQS § //\074.

Q\

1\5§ \§m\>\\\ cr§: C\>@é

 

:<\ o\CCGvS\a\/\ a€. §§ ~\,KW\OL€> C,§`\w\ Dr\q\ C.O<§\ C ach QQ>CQ\\>&Q
AQX Q.”L®Q`[Z) QQ,\¢`GY\\Q\LC QSS\¥K.\~€.Z\ `\(\X@ 0`. P\{o\ 0§
’>\»S\\¥`\ »\<> "<\\L U\c\\ @Q

Q,Q~O\~GB ka\%<\~cb\s<>v\v{§ Q\o\>\bw`t wl`\"\\& °\"\& vm\°m 0§- ?\m`\s~
\mn¥ '\I\T-C~)X.§\N)v¢»\>\< "M)a€_
CA\VX\&\\ C,GX `K )Q<`QS\\XM\‘>`) w`\"¥)\f\ CG&L\`A¢»QPWOID¥CJ On%€{\e`f>
N\Q Q\o.\\z Q¢X>x\@n\\ q O\\ N\Q»\¢ QW»'L Mc\ Qal\>‘>ow, mms

U\\v€x §§ `\\r\\c% TULOJ? ©‘&Qx §m\ex\¥ @§ Cr`\w\`\ ¢\0»\ ':§\)\§Av`\d> »T{\é~
5¢{3¢\05<-§0~<\0»\ bd ls?c~m ge og- "JW(\Q\ Q~OO"I.

N\c- C~§\\oeov>» §l\e§ \r\vg §§v§lv grade wvl¥ @4;
\x\o§<)we cos?~»»b § L\\O"l @ow\o,¥~d\`e \>Q\-\ocav\ §X\me \91'>07,
w A\»‘>»~¢~,X . 3100”75 en “r\»\e °S>v¢w\@\e o¥`< \) S\e@ec§\»{
m§\tév Nxv‘c 35 `\<~Q&§zc§vl»€ O\%?§m\¢e cpc Cou.v\=-,Q.\ cm¢\
°D A€,O;l\“\ wea?cfv g¥r~§l`\n$ ,_ _\\'\€ \Ll§+`" 6»&@>>`\@ %C§v~r;@\ v
cm,,<@ \ Mc.@z>m§ , gum £:L@O` q
NAMAC, ?\><> 3¢~»\\\§ m¥§'cw\ \<\ OG§&\N\?¥ X<> C.ovrecl» =H\€
S~Q§\»c/A»o¢)`i/\°a "v\\€ crim~\¢\¢.,\ 0\/\€»€9€$
grow §QC(_OZ A<‘s‘\`. [Lo "U/`@ \€99»~< §nc\u@\e»o O$CU\€€

@\

0§- ;3`6\~09~ Q\O\O\Oz<`{ ) ~\-v »¢\<\`\C\!\ ‘B`NQ"> ownOMe< CB 3\~9 C§`Q‘.H`€€ '(;Q\O{\V

~\re> awol JL)o \Q@¢» +“\/\wm 3 \l€M'> o-x\J wolf ~i~e) Uc@€cb
V\r\& \N\@\\CI~N\\,~/w\ 0§< 510 4&.0»\79. T\:\Q mm ¥v`\c)l €o%\'\\~
o\~§uz,< move §'\\2§ m\ @C,X¢o§<)bc \§+M/ <510<>“(a /'Héo ‘H\€
wo\ C__w§ §;\QS c&'e, §W,§¢ wm @\@<\_w\j O;PP\<-
ca<\%e 5§<»~\@ wc;¥ §§ m\o@@ emma 5\\.@7» Tke maj
(‘oc»~<<\- §§ N>¥ §mmw& §*v`§ ?oe&~c N\Y~Q\\\DSG~N» \¢\1¢> Css\>`<$v ~“Wo§¢\\c§ O\L\@v\“r<>
*\M ‘®Cs\ MQQAS é'\`\\» mm W\¥»C\ (S> z@\\>) wae. Coa\¥~\ §Hwe foan$e)
?L»< ®Ql-Qx\§\wé N`\?‘&<~)§\vc )Lv\\e>€\\&`f `, /\K¢§. R@Y(§e E(MH>\
w\x\o `\nl¥m¥%>\ §\ \Q°~§»\ \K"?\\o\a§cou\\u Mana€§€& b\r 'l“¢'\€
/V\cCO%\\'\L\\ `\jmf~¥ \ `\c\;\l\-\»¥\\ov\<)& \qw \`\`Dv<>.§£cm , M(`
.N\M¥`L<\QZ_, 'Dg<`\r® ¢<\a 'Yc§\\@»\€ CO'<\$;€.¢U¢e/MC§.
T:\wo<“d'\ > Q§z\riza& v/\Q `Y\N»¥ -~\’\¢\Q lvvko\\ Cou&lv Ld¥§`\`\;€ol a¢\
`\~\sz>?b< YQ_N\\Q§\‘<`> A)M\c, ?v<> `\-\~1\¢- ll` Q§/  czce`\`>¢ ?o~v@\a N\¥U\r`~ews @c~.@§~&.\s`

(;\

_ "'"\"DC»`S\ §LLCQQS§ §"\o§:>*\c)\\\\ ccc;m\c.uxwx §§ `N\‘\ PCL-v<> \€
e,\`\°>`\\?`\\`\¥i R G\Cccc&cw\c,e §m W.<\"C\A_ §S`OS.ILI‘I. /I’W
‘Q@\~»\G~\ “) \:Q\mv\o~c~\\ 951§`, @Ql~waax\ @’20/3»'0?0/5`
J\\\c.Q@\\Q@o\b) w(\@§ R’vz;`\\g>§<\c><\; \\:\ §Qg\»_\~;\~‘& C\é¢§§ v§\€@§d»§
\n‘~v\ X'C¢>m }5<0\ (S€"> §Xu\-»»S \'c> Cv\“‘“\ meg`\\m\~ gus §ecl\!
mi&*<\ \\zz \;\\\& C\<\% \.

§§ \ ¢\)\b\\m Cms cri: :»G.CY

V\_.\\t COL\‘\»~°~¥PO\\\\~Q& 'UKX;YOQ f\L`( j N\Y- Q'lCV\E UG palopu)€.L/)
y m\\@ mmr vw\ewc§ `Y\\z M§Q§rw@vv°v \ @<\A wo¥ ‘;RQ\ e@ec¥§d€
O.HES¥€).<\<,€ G§c Cm);w\¢o&\ \b‘\ O\\\o\o§`\\¢j »\N\?~ Q\» béo~<~l 3 H QJD¥QF

 

' `\<\¥o O\ ”\>\Lc®<\ v\\<\`\§x_\v;\\`\%U\/‘<" \`f <>< \M\\Lv\mo Y\‘I]`f &><>A@¢

0~(\ a §Q§-QL\~\JC \c\§\cxm\e\r\\' J(/\{` Qs\\i\(>éc>\¢\), GLH’L@@S '{“(/\€
`\vr`\e»\ CQ~>&§ §§ \>SL To\ "c’\\& <\;6\\0@>€(“§ vac¥\_<>, 3

§~`\\Q§ “`v§~€ \wj'\\’<`c?t( \`C)\\o§< Cco<\ @\\\\a M¥"CXU§U\ arm-§§ QX\S\ mind _

\(
`\Q?¢x §_rvo(`% x w\\%\r“ "<’\1\41 PVOP\k\cl \N»L~>C b€;(>l\

lea vi`\<\§\dc§v -\ l\‘\\\ Q\l\>$<$\)‘

§c` `c)§ Cc>\»x~\< \N\§L ?FG‘?‘L§ msv wyr\CwLW\ ax\p\ *%u)€¢é

c\??vb‘:`w\Q/\‘{ \vow§\/\+ \`O \\§ OL£\YU\"<~`\OG<§ ( O\C- `H\P
AQ&K;M \,0;;&\@\_\31 \ \A:me\m .…@@6-/.

w

‘ ' 'é>. *c€\<¢\ CG\»~'\\€§ §§ Coo\c\c\( Me Co<»x+
O\?PO`~<\¥€§~ mi§ruc€\f?>{ j J\\<~. Cc\\é\ u)Q,\\ , `\'9€3~ \>\€c;oc¢§$ ©\\)CS\`<\K\ 5\\\)\ W<\¥ L\ `b€c€“\\)u< )So\§ > w\\lc,\r\ boaz
S;:M \\W, QS;x@c wm £w\n Tm:~\>\emé\§ D\U;§\W>
é\\ow@ vecm\¥ \\`_\`§~w\c~&\`\\>$" 0?&0§»»\’\3. /\}\YL Q'\`\&>§cvv~)s) )

\e@q\ é\m\m§ §@< RQ<(;\& Q\`m`~\>l\§¥\f,

‘?\\ ~\r€`\'<>~\ Cov~<¥ >L\LC€€<§/GS\ `\~\`5 ;;\)\< §>J§©L%c)m)
(\>o\m)<:> C>K\)\ w)\\)\\e\”§¥`\ m\\w\ “v“\/\Q F>¥O\xv\§\-e <3& \`\\N\]‘\`-
cév\m\% \\.L? ?ve§ T\\ O\Ccos)ac\ce 3m W 643
6 §Q,§U\§Qn\\» Cw<\ \>e. ce§r<§dc\~<¢b 5 "IParS \wa\

~&>\\z c§@\~t o§§ *~`v\¢\e C.o-\\~\rzs\`om §§ H\€ O{l@€m§€ 3
643 `N\QC¥ as V\z>\»\)ec\/.

5» ~\)\e &g\~\\a\ cows¥$ qc:¥`»m\§ A>veaoe\eoo “~l"£\c'

Q\Qov\v@€%@§w 619er \~€\Qx\~\ ax\§l `e\ tia/used Wa/v\e(\*~&l

Q,' \s§a\o§<`\<\g ,N\Y~ (`O\\\>S.C / 'PQNEA 1

Q®w\d‘$ sQQ\Lz ~\/\\Q ve,\\<§ ovv\c$
?v<%`\*v< PU 1~1\`\5§<€& §\§`\s§\`\§\~\cm \>‘1 `H\{ CC \`mL`/m( Gof+

OS< J\v?\>w\§ §§ m\»w,< mcf va… \\>> c<><\)\r;‘UHL-N\
5)

» _ _\@Q.Q\L \<,' \\\1> 1-1`~0¥ Qc»>x~‘v 1 \‘315“`51111< 16( b¢$¥\rd
C_ow<>\' 1 N@Lc°;§oc§\% Céwc\&v“\ 1 011\1 01 Naco&<\@c/\QS 1$-11§`»€
o'S< ‘YKV~QS “IS°\LQ\ . N\C1 adlwa ~Q<~\’X’\¢\L\/ v€‘i/ 01€${'5 Gn\h"

G~Y\\L( wsmwa \`U\\QA`\'LS M\< wl\\ 01§1@<131/01\001&&
\,\Nl\ a @<\\(U\QN\<>; \\w§{\% `\`c\ \1\13 ¥dol Cov-(§r.~

::M\N\Q',\¢Q_ %U;\a\’<>~§<`\mk§ /(`€r¥;££€o.L€ 09 SQXUBC€

 

1 1 _§_Kc.ud Q\O~`t C'j§birm 'H"NBCQ‘S£\‘$ \ o!€aiawe, M¢}£.( F€n-
q\\~"\ O(\v ?€1<§\>1&"( ‘\“M-\' all H/\L ~C€)C@OI(\‘§ Fo‘/\./~ULLS dmi

`\/\S¢MWOA'W\ me lvw\i cw\c§ cov-'\\QGR ~1<> \N\~t -C<\CH'\ amp hel\€\C.
Q>~x u\-`\\`\;?<\§ “~Y\M; K)vv\llv €A SLQLQS H>SM/ §Qw\`c/K
a 16\)1£ ‘L\c§¢&» Cc(>\r \`é 501§(\_‘) mulle,o( 16 1 Cf\`m.`~nq/V

Qowc'é¢ o& AW<€§ Cq/Q.’#“/ 5'1¢¢1(’>"/ »¢us#>»
‘T)< 76’… 61069 01 Co\MPlir\/\QMC~H (0{7‘( 15 helm //1/)6,/€/

1¢ 1 /L/SH` 511/ec or 961¢ 11 Cw(+ f /0/ w /V/qm 511

ro¢\/\ /620 1 /(/aco:)cjoc!»e_sr ,T>C, 7§7(0/.

/;MC¢»L@¢O 67 /Y\C 'Uv\ %1`5 / S‘NDO/Ov“/ QP/Wérc»é\
' 520/5

lam Q%Q.`N l)$d(\/ 31521/3-

./an\{

§M%QM/&XM\ 63 3 /5_

§th ob(-v\
(cz>\ q