Court Opinion

ID: 4061934
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 20:20:59.136709+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:53:00.311947
License: Public Domain

tamm @€ @Q<>ea@, Mmm;$‘@cis '
5me 0\3”\!&\@( @§ /\E)LA§

\’\OMORN§U§ ` 7 E
umw LQMG, Uc>:<c\<. n L v
FD.E)©X O\SL&O w 312!.:1.;5
mma@\m©,'f€ms ’Z‘Il®S-CXSHD

SEV&:`NTH COURT OF AF'\JEf-\LS
VlVi/-\N LONG, CLERK

Q\&‘; C)IUQ\NAL MP?\\CM\BN KJUMK 0€ M`\®Aw\u$:.,. Lu\z 5. LH@M\E Ja, ~»\l v
LM\\\UAH`\."S 5’\\?9\/\€¢\! {"@\~'€UX\\\F€ @\IL€C,/U/Q\DU E‘\#A\__i USENGF\ @’|“~"\_S'

©@i€)(~(i\l
Dema /:m\s_€> wm t~:;,

PLQL\SE \7\»\»1> mcwga> @&\A’\`D§LS RFHDA\»\T RE\M\NG TO FR£V\Qu$
Fl\iNE>S O(; U)V\BUWS WCO.N\P\\€S W\W iq‘°DO [‘i m CW\'\ Q®N\EI§\‘ES
GQDF_. P\U§€ ?\\z; “M€, AQ>@\FE bowmems no ’\\~€ M>owe ..Emme@.
woman mm Q¢d\)\§\; 09 !¢\c<\@¢\\\ ' .

P'\USE Q>P)`v\)c; wa 46 W\; A'\’Y\zm\@!d @Q f j
GMUEM)LE‘ . U€ (iou!u 146 \\Gue, §&M\ES\'

Me\m< '~LOu §041‘{0:11 @@um‘€$€i m ‘Ms hamm .

 

31 i(?m &Ll'l _
HUNFB\MLLE»`\/UAS, 7739£0
_ Pm>~$>z `7£/.>&5® §§

 

los ’(HE mm @‘€ N>%P\\_§ 1 ”

F@R `THE SE\!EMT\~\ D\:»TP»\(:< @? TEM q pp \
Lu\<:» 3. UQME J\z. 11 15950$
Rv’_m<oa

 
 

,, »} ; 'f-'l;'.»;`
k‘w‘“a n ,L

~\/~ §/'~\SE mum€>eo. ‘ 9 EMHW§JG{PEL@;\¢M
. \R~\AL @oum mume,€a ”?"`10` lZi~'CC,
CQ&E%@!H @. wng lE’<' m_ -

d \(» P\E§Pcu!>e¢\f\
w\w/am& :5<1:@\~\.<-:¢\) CM\\JE b\¢z@c<r>r>\ @Q '\.0‘(15. amc
RE§?ON mm

T , .
§HLD@\M Q\F_L¢>¢<\MG, /\0 PP\~\;\MS \?\\\m§s wm m~\p\\p»» wm \4¢00_¢1

S<Mé. w K€M.§:

CGuM‘N @Q \)\\¢R\\LE,P\‘. \ l l f
` ' ' f k mm
n . =vk WJ);~SD¢A R€\Mt>.f)` He!lew een;v\€\\_ wm 1 m me unms\e v

AEP\;E\$H§Q§;L§£NS§E§QM€ aba Q>€ \K \\eaw @u>_ mm \s Ae>\€ 49 e>w§ me €ox\o\»wo @ fmcs
QND SKR‘LN\@NT 09 w¢\ cum €@\av. w\‘\ ma mms>.: w n _ _

y) ST~{L&‘,, ll.u\§ S. W>Av<é -\/~ BMQ>AQA m 6 .GA%\£ mem N/.A .OM€ §w\vw;, b»§-‘I`l
T~iez o¥ €;waL wvssm< 5 Muza @€ D\§cwn>¢~),b aeszm~@;fuoee,Ho“xf.,~@oum:vu»$:.£>imm. vame
D\\/\Snor\! h D\s?i>z\<mN iv‘\$m\§se!> R& Fm\n\.ou§. gmc D'x$~\\$s€t) 10“~§‘1»‘1`7

ad émuf guns S. Ll>.c’,mvz =-v' wm m&>¢m €'Y'AL' ma wm miAwoA/\€ Fihm,' z»;.x~s#S-oq"z
T‘l% @.¥ tow sam ‘. umww?u\, DxSLx?\\N/wi ?Aoow)w@s mg mm N/A &E§\DW@,J,%E ,UM _@m,g
u\§ .€A<MRN Dw\sw,~| »0\5305100,3 iD\S/v\\:eséb uma€€>`\€ T© SYA<E €\mm Dm; D\slv\xsséo -. ;l-W ~ Q 3

53 S'NL€ wis 5..{&@4\\1)5 ~'\f- wmata (‘W\e\uo Em\, mac loew wm ome Biwé. 7»¢'3 ”‘)'9
T~h%z o? U)mwf wm mm v\osA<\oN a\W§. cwa row /\)i/>. Paesw\~e;fw>ee 'Cm\c, wm .u.s;
vadi olv\s:om. ms 9051,0@!4 2 wsm\s§zo wm .o®é m mm umw mm msm.asao ‘1~5 ‘ 33

"U ¢T‘lLé LU\S 3- W>R\U~\f' R\Cwam Dm€»m‘\ '\E’('AL C&sizuot# NI/>r DME. ~€'\l@m;. H¢"~i~qoi
Ww. a% U\\N:>u.\< ~‘ Qe'm\mm»o;€owsmmoh&¢\% mow N/l+ Paz§mvoc, ZSW>@G Glmv\<, G@~»m’ us
wsm-cm D\u\sem\\,.`D\sPos~\<\omo\sm,ss.-zn AS fr»\\nious gave wsm\éseo 3 -w»~:),o@<>

53 S‘<\\Ua was ¢S 'LA(»A\w/\l- 0::\\3\0 §wmv\ ET'AL» ease No'¢v him DM\€ f\lwé, Aué>u$'¢’ wu wm
m>ez §§ law 35 11 ~i‘www.fui mssu?mw mmué§ ease m# wm £»esmwe.JL/>sé ,um m ~n~uz
§§ W\ b\$<mc\ 9mm D\s Posmodlmsm\_ssaz> m fnw\Le\As mm o\smssez>` N/A

63 SM€. Lu¢S S~. LAC>A\<\£»V~ lum>m -'.Q\»ew¢o E<»AL, we no wm ama Mbc, 4' ¢i»- Q£)o:z
‘¥`N>E d Lm»&u\( 1 @AM\M)ON umm\o(\x\ O\SL\Q`\NML‘&\?/\gww\m,g ma goose NI,A. f?\g;,mw¢ju%é MA
did 1041 nimmsz u,S. 015/msd wm ms?osmom D\sm\ssm 145 #.(ew¢\mg oml>; omms$r:o !U/ A

13 %NL€ lms 5. LAGm<E'-v¢ dunham 911<»/»»¢ e<»AL me No# wm Mzz 61~§1@.. )o¢;m 1 9`00‘5

T`WE 6c va\i§mf‘ Q%<A`\\AQOM vC'\\!\\ !L\CMS S\"\K?) CASC MO~K N’ ? '
l . . ' m mem ma juer Meoez 1 §
to$sm m§<<u€,( Cmm’ O\`sv°c>smo;d D\s~was@> ns Fmvvw<»\$ ama Q\;M»5seo 4 » 5°-»61@!:;“[)

w mm w`$ 5 ' LM"“"U"" &“%°”"‘ @‘ 59‘“”° ET'~“L @°S N.G¢f °lvow~c. we H`h~<, 7~1‘1~&0<)<3

WE D§' bOW£\m\/‘ RETN\N\OA vw£a\o£u\\ DdSL\P\WAN' F ' ,\s '
~ » /%U.,€EMM é£:…M£§’$ A!é ' __ k _ . »
3\5\6< B\S{UC( CUUQ/T.D`\SPD. 8\(\(9§, ‘.S‘N\ P&r\\£)\:\l(p' m zyubéé RN ESUEQ'W mg

Q`) S’NUZ Lu)s §. LA§AV(E ;u;[u~ N‘ @M\Q;A Q"AL QASE M fpc ‘m% €\M;GG 5__{&¢&@,©

T‘w\§o? mmsur<;u-Mu) \5@¢\{<0\»\ ama ' » - s -
§ Voiu/\)<Amb\ b\$s/v\\$$v,o .Ds$?o%\¥§e»l‘?@wez€.§ Fws\owé§uoé£ AMA .t?\ow~;i’ wm

 

?Le.a§e L¢»:'< 414-rs H@~e¢zew>v€ Em:f\ %e @\w\'.s@p Dué 493 ’N€ KF\<*F W(
(7\-\»:3?0¢\)13&@\;€5 MME waw»\m> AEE W L€€>AL nowm@~@ .¢wo Fr<@?€!xH '~QE\A<Y@?~
MWM mem/mg »(Hg AQAL wmach DMES» mm€$ ,m\u>'§\\wé @(l .i’.rze\:\ws c\iudas,
NM gm m Rm€mbge,; M€ wmata ia C”Iwa\\sa') f’w)»ous mw§urls 'NM P\€ ms €\h;¢>
/W mae umw HLS L€@AL occume mm qu?;zm\yiffm{`\s' m sue ?Dasasaw¢~/ 06 y
(LE$POM>@M mims S'EQMJ E&mmw)z mmm_, e){/ "\.DC§T. M mom&mb Um{ MogPrfAl,

l lm§; 3> L{~\G.Q:»QZ ?J'n,.# ’IL&S£>?S H€R€E>‘! D`_EC`\ARE§ ’MM N€ A@O\i€ §'\MEM€M”?§
mm EAO<S mem ns ’Y!wé mm coma-m m womaan 1b US(°,&J H“{L» uno§a_

Pm&m @% Pez€)£\szm

.__g:

 

55qu %"\M UO\T
3\ EN\ &“H
\mezw\ uaw 77 590

/`FR"Y\F\PQ’(F m¥ F)ER\! \ (’£_,_,

l LU\S 51 LA@A\C 5b QE\A’YD(< H€SL€Q>\\ Cém&\i "WA{ A /X¢w\€ @Jz\é,WAL
QSYY);@Q\MT RELMWG 45 f’\l&s\ms F\L\M@S MA? @0'@'\€>\\€5 wm H'.@o¢},m$ %EE,\,
SE~N<`;(D HON©U€>L€ \!\\)\A¢~\ LONQ. C\€L\<. U\Sd mmi_ POSTP»C>E PKP:P!~\\O 010 ims
/wé wm am @€ wm 1106 m -Fo\\eos§ 1

Goum< 0% MPEAL§,
SUEMU B\_&/\R\Cj §§ ’(E>UA§

HQNBU£>XE
\J\\/m.c\l j\_@u(a

wm B)©x 06 H'© _
mm L'Lo. FE><AS 1"\193~%“1®

 

;Q\ ?m ;l"! ,,
umw 3\1 \u€» /\{€LA§ 7157/@
P(;O#SE ')CQS`S€)$§ §

 

(Q> _

 

.. ".| ...»,.m. mi

:~?_2W.T~ET~?z~xi~?$:_2121.m.:_~:~::;.-.: , mmm.m...mmmm,m.um….....…....:v...m“..... N....HH..."...

QTY,…§; m§@k_§§§,
@%NY§ ,
w.§§,@z@: 1€@…3
§§ …,@ 5§%5 §§wa _
B§§@ z §§

Q»m § Q§h§ d 7 §§
§§ § 3
§§ §§ §§

 

 

 

§§ rrrr

_ § Wn§§._m § …W_@m§v,