Court Opinion

ID: 4044728
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:41:02.187125+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:21:23.152971
License: Public Domain

5 \‘?>~\\; lam ©’€ C_(L\wr)n\ NQQA\A § LQZ\D'O OQ
" ’ Sk~M;v '

Q kevin r:\;» \- v;»-<:M\>»\S. A

,.'~.\, .

S\)%§€(Ag' CD£\§Q\Q\AQ') `\-= C’>\N\¢\/\\\ W\\)¢AQ¢

Q\S\\\-‘)\\?$ _ k:_(\\\)m Q>\.)(`\¥`o Q>t\\\?\nc.\d A\Jk \AA> R\QA\OQ "'\° M?\\?\'l

~\\\1\~\ \\A§ \,\Qc `\_§_ §~\\'\ §§ Oh\~)\>vr »‘Eer \"_>_~»n_\__'n Qv\\m RQ\_'\ *S_ k\ld Q\%‘ioz»< x\\\> \~D
>~»0\; .X_&¢.s>;> \,\Q>Q>v Xk &\\,\\ k\~\\<>§\>» l \»\ w \x§ "

,,,,,,

\‘§\>_\\Q\,)e_ \» \L § (_?\\w\\~\s\\ X,»\)\_smt.!\'\\># ~\b R\J&\~§ Yu\w\€

Q\§\m\\§\' $\»;)\f. N\k€ ~N\\.\(` § ¥\\~O\ R€Qv" Suu_?bk‘\`~\ _
X_ Ra\\¢a~/L \\\k§ Sk' &Qc\§\y\ ' wM W\ML §§ \\\Q \‘~_)Q\w.\

&Q‘§cnbs\.»\; kywame \'>_s R»§\S k a)\\e_ X,§ Q\Q\)\\\\\qw)

mr w\§ \@L~,@ i\;`> \M\ mm \m gm \,,\\\ §¢§>

/`-* Qd£ Y€\\&ky Mk CP\~\~\\N§\\ Q\kN%€,\ LF\P QNXN\`\MA~\€§\.\ §§

f\~?\on<§$o\m CS\J Q>§_ Qro\pA § kl\»r_ wp§;\\z;) -\/\\§ ¥"Qom\
- §§ ki,\. %Lm\nor `

 

[¢>? '\\3& k\)@f`\\\&r.> R\Y\Pkc\ \_A)§;\~\ \l>» ?o.\\L ?\\\1\5\09

§ ._ h ,, UEDA %N

2 ' ` ©Q'JATOFGRMNAL ;»\PP§?LS
' AFR 28 'Zm§

n ~Ab@§ Acpsta,€ief§§

.\v 1-

'r'$"

 

-" |.'." é"',~, ]l»' 41 ._‘.~:_

' 3\\3\\~>\'\33 3\'\\9&3.€3 '\\\1\»\ \32 "\) c3‘\\`\§,QR-3\`T~\: _\",9"§!>:93`\,¢,\€_ §§ 939 sw
\_,§,\Jb C\<\b Q§€*\ §\(\93'\' \,->\\\ Q\'O\Rl'.; \\`\> C\\N\N\»

\3\'\0\\\12 ‘\§ \`(\\.»rd€r \»_-\\~\; RQ,C§\»\S. 0__¥_" §,S\w$v\§
`N\Q\\\M \0 Q\Y\?.o¥€ O\ ¥K\EQACJR-\e;\ O_§\\ °c>€\zm §o (3\>&\'§.3\\

9\3\.3)9€3 \__9 gmc __\)Q 19…3\\® 33£1§9\9 \§ Q¢>N\,QA‘\@ 9

9;><9§3€3 §,»b \_ move A,\'\§-\ <3€\3\3_\ \,_)QN Q\\S\;)Xed Co.)\\\§~\\o!~l_\ _
039\3 333 \3\)3-\»¢3»@3 /QW\“\\= 3\3© C;'\zz 935 Cor3\>3 -M\\\{w,
09 933~\3\:3;3 §§ ‘6\\\\‘\3, E_c\\..\@ 9)\»9\¢-5 w C\W%\/\~> \3“'\

3 _ \N\\\X §x"d\\\%r C99w\\, \009\3 i<>\\€r ¢»JQS` RN§‘ C\Q$~\Q \->9 AW\
K_\»\R\.>R\ §C*w\\§\`i ‘¥\NN\R `~'>09\9 ¥KQJ»I\U\'\Q§` %9\\\\3_3©5§ knob

’ \N\\@ \O<@v \<3 \>\\\103€(1_33 09 93\3\34\03 wm ‘€med 'S;`.= \\\'€

Q§\< 952 3:.>< Q§r\& \,\3\\\9 \\33353 333 §w'3<3 ’33§6"339;
QP\\»\ 939 ’3\°\3 1093 \3\> exam o,\ Nm\> war=\\,me¢>
QQ/\\\\$¢\`>3 Q\U\\\&

 

§ Q\slr §\ QOQ\)\&’\ 3093

§®9~ ,\R\>z<_u Csw\\d §r’\/\Q<~x\§\u 530 `N\\=rUI` 9\9\\~>*\\“
3\33<3'\3) 3\3~3\33 339 33@9\3 \,MM\MA 3333\»\ \§
\R\.)s=_(_u 3109~§3 \§< ~\.J\\\ 53va \E`QGQ:§\ §99\€19¢3

FS_ \~)Km ‘(\1\\-1 b\<=v\\¥€\\w>t 0>3\\&<\ '§QLW>, 9\3\<`3 CM

\3)3. 9\\3<&>3\3\3\.3 3\'\@\39\\ \¢\\9\00\\ ;(\r\\ §O`,\\;.U\ \B
\33<1.\30.\\ 330¢\3» <&)~\S \.Q/\'\\Q S'\ \\9\4\§\3 `Yv<,( `qus

";,I"l ,-;v-'i¢‘:)' ~‘ l `Q\’\ §§ '3\-\'\'\ 3003 '3\’>’).§

raw - =':-9\.~:3.1 1113
C".' ~z.x ‘1.: . ' " H "'§: "`- , iii 1931 135

if g_'

Q\¢\"\\¢\&\‘ &\\S'° n R\\€\:&>` §§'\QJ\\`\OM\\ `XN"§\‘\C~\'\\>§ "'!SY \;.W\‘>;\`\QN\\

%§Y\§\m '{‘§ QLA\_I §§ o‘%~ \`:_»<*\\Qme Kc§<§~>;¢.,,_'\>§q§@x&¥§€;§§,_§ §o',\b\,h- \\\;§n '- /
\\§»;»,£ f=g.§e Q§e_~_a§,\§ _L§\\ §vw~§§ §§ Ao_cqj\c__~, {\N\ \,§ kc v
0\¢¥»1\0_52,\ c§_§ @AW\Q§'\:~§ § \§>§~W`\:sl §§*\o\er&\%\z §§

§§ c_`\\j§\n_o.}\ ('_o/v\.r\,\ué\\~j h d w by § w
§§ ‘§\\\¥~N\\\`¥ Y \e§ \\`\§ \/\)3_'\>§ \'J? \\S§L%M Cor§\)§ §§
"`{Y\RKL\\`.&`*\" l'v\’§ k\§)§ Q\e_La`§\JQ§ §§\:1 t\\wz\&§ Q<>./r\\d 010
\N\l\x`§\\ \\1"""'§5"\'§' “"Q\\N€§§`§Q§~>";R\\e\;e§\ (_»N\)Q\§§s §§
-\\\v__\§§\s c>$€t\§;e X\YQ\S\\~\§ §GMF__§ ©oq\\ “Y\\€ \_<)S'\\

\le/> \\\QX Q\Q\\u§\?\ \v\d \\ \)\ \.>\\\&\\ C_O\)\\ B\uz W\L
Q\E\\€Y `Y\\°~ CQ€\\<€\Q.§ `{\!\S\\ §§ "\'§ TQ)\\,S '_S'\\€> \‘_`>®® \\\\/\ \,\'30$

1 Q§_\_Qs R§<_\mm§ §§ <)<§€§\,\§ §§ §\§§ 'i§‘~

j n NQ\\ ;\°\S §Nb \P\ \{\I\D\~\Op VQF L\Jb\.b`(\f\§\)>c~ %\ R’?d
09 \€C\JA(,\M\""§ gaf %Y¥k\/'\~\ `\'> \l) § R\Y\ Q`\ CDPQ§).§ %\\I\S\or)

{\Nd \\k§ Qc\(_\°\e} o§ S~\¥\~\QQ} Y=»)\)Q\o?l §§ §o§\&rl>r\ bme

§\R\\:)\ \%%_- Gv§\§§ ~\.\\@ \§a(\>((§n;\g Qf.)u(>; \r> R\\\s..\ W
§\§§\§§§e §§ §§\\§ game §§ §\\». §§\m\\ "

@Q_ §Qg\§¢,@ Q\§m\§\>q \§ \.»\\\`\r\§ §§ \\WQ W~z&‘<_rw\
‘\%\~§\,Q\§Q\§

1 \'\QJLQAB ASL(_\\NL \_):\)§§Qr' QU\\\\~\V \§>? Q§(`S\’>"(\A ¥\,\}\'\ Q\'\

S\\P.§éw\u\*u \‘\1\ ~\Lvm \N¢\ twme \_,XQ.§\,’*<€=¥ §§ "'\\\z

/B`\J`° A§\: §§ N§'\ ?Af)\\’ :
wm

 

" C;.Qo'\`<;;:\(_y§§¢\a'_ ©§ _SQF\_.\CUL >_ _ _

/

1 wrng C_U&: \\M§\ 1111 d umw qbg},

\_/\)I\: \N\l\\\e& \® \_) §\; \\\\ §_QFK\ \‘_\.§Q\Lz.

_ \\'}_\B \§\`\\~ §\\§(’_\_Q_\\N€ Q>\\)S Q\w\ '3\£)\71
(q_or §\_)1 <`_\R\IL\>-»\, _Y%<`g~\ de umw

&\WK§\) cor R“S"\\D '¢;¢§, 3¥\\§2, ./LL.._AA*:) ®S`;' N‘?~\\ 1°\\'

QQ%Q» \13@% Qm\»\§\ §~\A“Q -- 4
jr ,§Qd~\\o 'Yixm "\`&W\\ ' . § gm . ‘
_ A\\§§a§),,\§ -
, l\@\ ¥§~\ BL‘\ w
" ':\3\~(>< §N\\ `Xe¢m W\§R‘&

r 4 -r*"‘. 4 4. . , w ,,» _, 9>.~'¢ 4
. fed .; M,‘s`§ ,1»~',.,~ *,(',/i“'j‘-,¢ {_r¢¢, ',‘v _1,'.,',/ 4)~'-: "~;.) ns y.'-f,; '~ /'._. /

 

 

  

\?>\9¢ C_D\»<>~ .’F CLM»Q'A\".`§»MQ€S\\A
K\)\“\\v _ `
Q&\m\\`, mcmaqu .

Y_>. Q©c\z \:_€.\.»\s Q>\,(’~\w " ` ° ,_.’

S\.\QJ‘§€(»\ , C.§Dr\§Q (\S\Cp §’ C')wm~\\

 

Q\b~\\l\\`?$ ‘:.(\\Nm Q;\_\(\¥‘:) Q>€\\Q\»\'_\» \\»1§ \\9> `\Ql\\a© `\° M\\?v&

_~>.\\A~\ \\\5 \.\§c `\a Er\\\ 19 Ohwb?r g §~':>r; \QA §§
'\\§R `(\\)€\§) C°vn\`j Q°\\§K RQ\'\ 1 a\d Q\QQQ{)< \\\\, -\5
>~»&\; '_\.a\>oe \,\Q>a~g §§ §\\,\\ 9\1\<9\> ’é\ \»\ au~Mz ” "'

95 we »\\w ms ax \\gb 9mm ama 19 l°\§ wm \\\»M
~\\\Km\m\\>\ '\.§ §§ N\\.~m)(’rv§ "L ado No>~ \¢Km® \~\\¢> -\\\&\€ er\w> §»\°a ‘
l dam \’wo») \\`< ‘\\\< S`,A\a fc\>v md \{L\\\\ w9> iovraeb\ or m\>\eb '

" T, __._,,._ ay- ~.. _¢;.¢ ,»;.1..`_-' , »_ ____.`Z...,_, J~

\¢ b\c.,) 9 `~9 marx order \o Lw\w\\?~r_v \.»\\\\ \.)\\9\ ,
9.»2\\0~1<'_ '\»_,_ \L £?\\ww\a\ \s\)a.s-\\Lm\>r~> .\b Q‘\D§W\ §\&M{,j"-
Q\\!\~w\ §\' S\u\€ \\\6" ~N\\>r.BQF Q\O\ M \\\O\ §€Q~> Suu€>b§?-\
§ Rz\\wl \\\\~ 9 &Qc\x\><¥ wm emma §§ 1~\\,§¢2 \_)M\Nr>\~§
c\@"\cr\dsw\; \a 9mme \=>%\.`\b 9 <;I\\a X,a Q\\>\h\\\\aa~>

\ m ' ` ’
¥c>r W\‘L BQ’\¢\& \€D\.z:> \9 '\P\\\\\ 'Y\“ \ S\J\>~ \.~»\\\ _`§0@.5'.;'

§§ ‘§\\?\ Kv§ C..!L~~w\\\~)(\\ C\§N\»u Q_A.) Qk\~\.\“_\_\e& \`\\_s'_§§~. qu\
\N(Ko¢\\.;¢\omc» §`_9,). Q)\ Q¢o\x>§ § \\9\»&_ wk\.\xw~\

,_ or
Q\°\\,£\.\Q(j j '\~\\& ?§‘S/ '§\\-‘Z \\o\\\ot&\%\°~ §\>§\,\. %(;\M\r`\"

\Jo\a§\ \-9 ?u\\& ___\\\J\S\m)

 

09 "\\~\<_ &\) ,9{`. \\\Kr& §§ Y\R L-_\'_:f,;

   

   
       

 

 

Q\\\\\N\\?& {\\\PL€S `\\\5\>\ \AQ \.\ cd\\§»?n\\d \~DI\S\I\G \~§ q(€§?r\'.’ :
\.',§\0 0(\6 §¥\`o \\'\\\'\ \,-)\\\ Q¢G\R \\`\) C\\k\m\ ` b

W\o\\\;Q >\Q \`(\»rd(’f \;_\\\~\5 * RQ,QB\»\SL (>_S" ;\.,¥\\)Sv\~\ J y § nw w ll
\\l\.<>'\\uv. \o QY~?\)~\€ b\ ¥X\UZ\CJ>-\eé QL\< \;>(\;~\§ `\9 (§\5¢\\;3\\

"\
\\

-N\NX\'§'€ \0, CD\D_V_ _\-\Q Q'>HJQ\\QA v QBQ[R\»\Q \§ QOI(\>Q\\M \3'

Y_\Qv\€v\ §.»b § in<)\»e §\\\Aw &(u\n \?;)Qm Q\`S\»)\c§ CD.)\\\&»\\ON_)
C.‘.D\)\§"'”_ Q:Q 0\‘)?r\\»(v‘(’\ Q°\"'\“\\= ‘\\'\K C\;\:{ ¢,Q~, amqu x[\/\\\\\gv)

!é{;" ";"-4_;:' /p%.

" » 11
__‘3~9 %W"\‘{\W€J in \6\\\\\\§¥ \:_(L\'L‘Q od\)f;?\c»`£$»,or »Q\\M (.~»\/\’# \~\\`Y‘\

\N\\\* §N\\\Qr CQ`\N\; \_\>Q`\d §<>~)Qr c:\JQ\` §wd ,Q\QM~\->P AWK y §
l\'\.§‘\;>§\\ RC"\\\J\\`S RN\N\‘{ %¢<:Y~Yv\< 0‘§ \I`\\mr, wm Y{me§ ;M>(\\{
v C_;\\c ;o§ L>< Q&\r\°~ \,‘w% \\»U>A ‘b‘\`l Sw'lé 'T&@ '\Q,¢
WQ&\\~\ NQ ’A<>\’z Qo~.¢~ \>PQLW wl N\m> w€c*w<<\e&
\N\\ §\\o\,-».B \_>\'>~>\ RU\§&

' ' " " \§\
YQQ~ ¥R\,>z<_v._\ .~Cov~’\d ¥’\’\ro\§~\u '\Q ‘{`(\\»r§?¢` Q\&\~>>\

S\\Q\,\z> Q\\A\N\xe w M.M wm\:\¢m Q»m\ \§
¥R\»£Cm (`_'>~.m’\d \'\?. \.~\\\\ SQQ\\ §Q<§Qr<\\ P£b\q(\\¢,§

 
 

 

     

“ ”`SQ\M&~`~\ QO\O\)\§/\\O;~\) QG/\\\\O¢\Qr‘

FX_ \:~)K©r€.. `(\-l\\a` 5 (.>\I\\I'E\UM~N O\\<\€(\ ~KQY\Q\L §\Q\(\W\ 0\*'
\Y}>~ Q\\d%x\m\.> `N`\e;wm \<,< TS\\M Q\A‘¢» °\\\~"\o\\ Q>\\\L

q¢<§ a\=ma \\V \<> §\\;, \s\/.w .>`\Asaw\ ¢,\5 §C§WU\ \\
\~)>\\N\R\

1

%5§*\9\1§5 QJQ£A\|\€ 03 h\<§\¥w\& 61_<\§ ov\Q\(\\>&ow> C.°J\dw(\j\\\l\'\

NW¢$ [;D‘§€_ Q:g_‘go¢-§> 1£5\\ kam&> §§ chuva \\1513 \1> kc
31
Q\c 515er \ 0.3 ¢P\»\Q\¢£\a~_)\ 5 \.\5~\1¢\:1 1 933\9111.1>\3 ‘X 13

§ C.\\J\\\lf b\ lo m‘n’\“é` \ j _!. ,:3.(. '~

i

k §\G 1333¥¥ Y \93 \\35 w&\\ \'-3§ \\!59=.&13§ 6013515 j 1540
y i‘;’\(\.\'“§ Lj\`: 0`-5\'~ lv\‘§ AN§ q\tLo\\.»QN qua §\125?.1 k Q‘>JE_K\\`\ 5313
":"'V",J""`Y.' W\§\ ‘_l "\)` \"\‘\ 'B"U \§ G"Q\“\\° >\? \Q& "§v\

513

  
  

\33»>.. \33\ `€\Q\\m\e\~ \1115:1~~‘ \\'\)\.1-\,3\\\5\\ L®\,\B \`.>\33€ W\L.

Q\&\u¢& `\\\sz 63153‘§133 \1\1\3\\ \3 j°""3/%,T33S '_1>\\<> OS@®\\\\»\ 1,\'1,_\>$

” w _ """” l`“§<\e&“%€c\w&\'\\$ v §W*~cdq &`;33\'1 j~§§~»\ \\5 1310 33:_§~33.. 3
311\ 3»»\§ 3331\jjw0533 53 333\3333.,3 335 3@12133\3 '

913 1'5'\\1=_`1"15°`\` 1533 05 §?€ ld\§ 31 \=¢c\~\e& 3\ C_<>Qb
®Q \'@(-\N)\N“°'d gaf %°3;¥35¢\-\ '\~3 \) \.-_,.; R\Y\ Q.°\ C.er\)3%'\\13113.)

 
  

    

 

"'~';11¢1_:&::[§\\3`@3§§ GA\\; ~\\\¢ \\31\“11303\1 C'WW \°" R\\\\'\
3\3\35‘<€ 33 3\\['33 C_s\»s§ 161 \\15 X§\""“ "

ll

jr ;;_@€. 1535311,<€/ Q\xx 33 <”}`\5 \33\\\1\3 55 \§\Y‘Q \`<<0113\

'. 13 \~3\3351\3

3
.'~.6,/:,,-3; _,__'____.'_` , ) '_

,¢' ‘.'.~[:»3: .‘ 3a

   

Q\\A\w\ §§ l k\\h \X\\? wes
§\1»\9\§§_\ §>Q§A\c §§ c&

`\§XN§ range Qj¢_‘$or\b* £)~\\ §§Jvr\§> §§

 

fn »
‘.).-_'_' F

#`"1‘§ \\QB %€L\$\Y\\’\\QA §T dQE§.N\'\ 59 L\\\¢;

111me 0\-\~ l

 

_____.,._.,.,,,___._._,_.._._ ..___ _4
- . _'. _ r'/'

x,'1\v1\`\<>1\\\ "\1‘§\\;411,\ 11 \211»>\\151\._

‘c.»<-\wn\e god uv\Q\i\\>\¢¢\J> C°J\b\)h \\\!xw

AQc_Ql\c.~,\; {\Nd \¢> wm

°\c&=.wbec) ¢11 ~QAQ\<>C\M\ x \1>1'\%\`_9` 519~`\':\€'{\\\>\1 'X§

3§\ c.`\\_j\\'n.c-b\ lom¢\wé\\~§

§§ §\G 1)\ §§ § \e`§ \\__`\\ \,\)3)_\>\ @§ \\§>.Q>u;§ Cor\\\>_ 159

S\‘S {\‘1\§ kuhva §1\4 A\.»Q§Qy|(lw\\\ 01

‘""v\< Q\\\\\\~>xm R\\e\,zz, (.ble\\\\\" 59

x\\v \%\S \>S':\u< MQ®\~\-\ §.4>`1~£1 \£>¢)Q\\ ‘\\\1 \o
\11> \\1'1 \é\<\\,me\ 113 \\- 11 \,»\\1\\ L@\,\b §>\§,z 111 _'
Q\£\\e& "§\\1 11\1\<;\15 \N\x\ xx 11 Tw; 3\\0 Ow®\\\\»\ \,\11
'B\'> " §§ ' 1

&\w\ 1¢»\< 111 1\ 110111 \'Dr 111\111.,1 w 1111
§\Q(\ ld\£~, l \`=.`\\c\e\e._\ \K 1595

 

w\&\fx\\ \‘\""
s:\\\

11 1111 '\.~»~\`~' 511 o'*¥`

§§ \%C\JAP\N\\¢.~\ gsr §j:%&;§\,\~\ "\~1 \.) \ \\Y\ Q.‘\ CBFQQ\-%\\'~\‘~>

   

§\r\.d\\§\ S`¢¢\§\<>\e§ ¢\ S‘\‘\~\Q?\ ¥¢‘\)Q\d(’§ >~9 §~o.>%rl\\ \'m(\
, `N j.,i.,-\Q\\\\§x §§ G\sw \\\L \\1¢\">\\10,\§ pmm~ \o‘~ R'\\\‘,-\

`\\1\111§ 11 x\\\> 1111 11 11 umw
;i.@\" :S~JS\H,& (\\\S\\\\)\\<< \_1 \.)\\\\.'\1 511 \§W§ YQ\)§;L»\

§ \~1\,<11@1

 

m § §\,,>§c 10 §1:> c\ 1141-mb

_§_ \\Q‘\Q>\n AU\N¢ \_>~écr Qer\k\»'l§ L>? §Q(X\,r\a "\\`1\\__ q\\

SXNCW\¢/\M §r\ é\1~)1 §1~11§ Cerm\a. ' \_,`e<~.&\.%€<§ 09 ~"1\1@ _

11"° dan 01 1\1’1\ 10\\ §
wm

 

l "§*""'CQM'§~`\¢M£`F m _;.§_j_SQf\'.'§<_Q;"_' '

`S._ `§\\11§\=» C.e;\$\:\ \~\\\»'1~1\ *ck\»m er QOWAn §DQ\B_

\.J\)§) \\N§\\e& \O \_) § \\\`\ f<\_~QrK\ \BYQ\LL .
\\35 1\\~\\~ 3\\51\@\\~1 Q,\\.d 111 1111 ' ’ " `
C_or §)1 (`_\\r>\\»,_\ `§z,<;\` '___'__'\\;qo\ n _
§~\ § L:)Q§ \\1\\1~\\<;1 `TQ `\1>< C_-~\. 0? V_r.w\\~¢\\

4 . K§§{P\j .&3' \\\)S~\\Q C,.o X\\QM_“\_ L\§`.:\ DP CWQ\\']-\~'>\{
Qo%»» \1.1~»% c_A\>\\\»\ §-\AM> .. ~
1\, ama T md 111\\ 2‘;:1\\,\,\1~\ QW .
4 » ~ * "\'Mx» \“1\1 \\1@
1\\\1¢1 1111 '
'§ : l*'%'\ § m 3 1911 111\~ ‘