Court Opinion

ID: 4039374
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:12:33.009185+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:50:29.881856
License: Public Domain

;\/x\\<\xa \_§§; Y>\M N@.Bxa~\~»~-<>DBMR':H\; we _Q,;XTH

 

\/-Q‘ ~4 ;Q:w?\l'_ge C§EFYEEMEY§ L
T»\& SW\TL §§ YEX\\S \\=_>\x\\D[-‘_R_% `BP\'§E\F lm _C,\\JP<€¢f"f """"""""

 

aziz-§ m came nnle gm 'ED umw b`R¥\w /\_<. C.U§SYSKE&T"°"" “`°""`
v ~ ~~ /"`\ND R&Docg~¥ QU' NEAQ\\& A'P@B`mhm\_E §L\m <3\; e>l; g r~\m mw ¢.
map C_mv\i»,§ A`\F\\N@ ma ?>\Eh£n£j'??\b,$l:_ /\x\)m_‘

V\e$?e_c;t&a_>\\b\ Y\NB\B€_; H\i§ (`_mr§ \;D.P\c.me,v\ wm wm Q_% &\\UU\ @AML, N>P¢\\M wm
5 wm `f_\k€ ‘§®\&ou_)`w\.§. ' !

(`A\ ibm _:m\sm\)& B‘L>n &@\5, A”P©¢\m Yc_ciwd, (1.
./»\<\>AEP;S EY‘\¢£ fm Su \>'(3'\3¢1 && Y\/\m&jm fn wfl<\®€m
A§ c\_mr\;e_a_ §\\Lx bn \m;; /\”\>QEF\L ATWU\)C~H,

` c:s\ -T_m \¥\5 ”\Em& \\\a mw¢ “P@sgm.p_ :ssu€; `u\
\'X§\S E`c`\e_"c Q_S (l CLYY\`\CL!S LU¥R&L

cg,\ `D\\ ;Ls§u¢ r\)\m\e,€,e mg ha m\ej¢x &&\w; m
mw c\_m_w~‘<> wamm_g v emg-m &\NL,\ \”€_§en&u;t;or\ é.`\.g wm md Jv_\r'\o_` \(c£me/v\ami..< c>\°
<§>J€. 'P\“®c_ess. ~ ‘

\)&_ wm 'P\»qu\h.,a m ma mg L<\ sw me Q£
‘r~\x_g wn&em;`\m\, wil<\{\m& GJY\M C’-_M.c LQ\M$J 3d An+hmi+i¢:
m Q):)_>vk ek fx<\>@cw\ \mug K\m uaw w &Q,meldy¢
-U\L `Ku)c`\'or\ §§ /XPPC\\ML"»“ laiIL/Stb/ OW\A
S\L\w _Av\/\MM w &.\M Q,Qr\gmu&a@r\ m€e\& umwa

,TMLL

T}u_ vsqu O_ng.e; Luw mm /\uTHz:K¢`rie im '?rc_§M
was CLS Cx_ ammin Cun'ae_.

- ”%5§13\€ IM 1\)0', ;1 4 _
\X¢; W\w@,$ (l C.€m Xe/v\£. on mom/t J;M in ial (Lc:ue~e
P,m\ `Lr\  V\/\E'f§®'\ ¥_c> _-C»`UPPYCLS
~€,\/ {Amm~_¢z_ `CCC_;¢\/enu\_ Q\<~c>‘w\ AQ@&\(.OA£;L W\)G£d »

\§\£ ¥§1\_0./(\ \Y\C)~M"G. §U<\§;€Mhol\ `\`m chm ®J§ ];\r\.¢. CUUY€~
Q..@r\c;@mmg iam m\)ah`; Q_owswi Qovm`_\ lchai was C¢|(UQ£
C)JE twm\ t

/\ 'Pm ria-530va 'R@ukm Q& £\\L R£am§ wm €_\ea,¢cq

$\:\c>u> cl $€f\m A»wwbb Cm\cw\ ing HL¢ `LL€§ ' 5
A~_\rw¢ was Q.I'/a/,J aj éh`o/, n / d EOMM

”C\»\{)_ mg&_\or\ m SuPPvcss RL@D.~_A_`\/o\um<°_ _ X\MN\. "\N\I»\LL 0\ £uvvw\/\MLQ_ Q& `che`wa /\QT \.0§| L§\ APP@M . Am>wu%/ ma maza
ida O_Qw§\m`\<>_n \5\).4 ij.f_f\ Nu (‘_CLSP_ LLU,U§ DY Aufhoiiff/.

`W<>§s:@\i X$s\§e; vuc;: 5,

»/¥&Pm\ /\U\Mw CL£K, ¥\\{ guesch Ls £LOB@//M [';uwm{ _§\Méme»
va\L \de,cm@_ ¥\\1 S\\U&JL va\i>`vu\>mu \JAM ¥\,m> mm (\_ov\»uir_#iun in
€_x\\\<)\mc,e, \n`\§ P\>$S`»§o\o_ Y\>ms\/\Yv\n/M?. '

A@<>m\ /\Tmu\)w irm ctc/wl in m nmu/nw mm /Jm//perm

H\wc v\/\/\. &\u£gw; has PM§;£%MM LJBJ.:L&¢J;'. %o dam we mm 0€!»,¢3
mm "Ph'or L’,m v.'d;on! 113 lanham loan/sh w/ML mm in ,%3 cmi

P@J'c Q`

_ H£ Hwn cL-HM'LJ +M/f Ble,!s\>e am m)+ @L_\ml !/b M¢ £xh/L/`A(
[S>(§D UML S\\. w\M//\ HuM i/UM.!; l'MVoJ»i/Lpl.

l;vem H\M /SI¢L/w. ¢A_/A nme_;p, m €adj 56 a didn m 1/0,'¢{
`(L_om\ci‘.m wm \/\Jm Dklc;c,£;.er\, "/`c)(o; i€u/¢_l.

)#'/.: HW\ wi m aaa mm cma/aec va.»w , am PU.,L H'Lm
m +m §on wm wr+kw+ mmA',-,y amy a/\wmw; »h> mma %/»,;<
C,GLM $ov Y€/Viw), L/~,/,gb gin/mw me dm Er¢m§c.

553 '.v), 3 E_`_»!/l jr
/\Y£ N'b&c §§ £\&wcc va Lgh'¢{, 959 5.¢¢/,
SL 373 LTU. /\Y<>.'¥m \A)o'v’sk,\€acig; Pek, ‘;@€’AJ;

mUD\> \,V. $&u)m/ \'lg.w, 3A 153/09 '(`_`ch, Cm_v\, Ape>. &uoo)<.

u\_\o_"<£.s us $<&o\ie_ j _€L, S.w, 3c1 §ch.TcX, H»OF’, ~ Fur+ wm+h/ oMOI/
\/\r\> \>£h, ,

to 'mv\m¢g.\, -\/5 wm Hq S.W, SA' m g/j:

AQ¥M ¥\r\i§ flva \(b\/iw\) \;.`m, /-K\oow_ C_CL»§L'J/H `fVla/VL \LML
`d¢>_c;%;m\ br\ \;N 9<0\\6w€\»3 A.w&s&ion m wi&~_‘,

v ®M€.:>+ccm m LMM \   ,

"BF\§ 5<\»1_ \<\rm\ P_,iM& £mw\( Qm ~S\>‘&>m;&&`m_<¢ Cn,use `v\,bf 'D§L'D!??X

>\~_Q> l<.\¢\3L lwvov"» va €N\\\MM CP\Y¢%$€_¢ Lu`r\!w\ +'\MM Uem\q
\LY\QW L& was (l gram _Bcu\ Qc\om 'R)m.swbl@ Unw \'&'. 3m

emg mv\,x wax \DL \)sL&- w Q\)v~lwx am mmng mm

l\»\ -\§\1. C_Ub(; §§ mm `\1\ $‘:OQL/ his (`,a£c 'c$ 4_\\1 _ClaA/M a`<
A’\>?e‘\\uiL / ’?Lm mc_u_€g_i_n_n_ 01va `(‘_an_r;iu.§'_r_m `\r\ +tu ca_/~e__
`I_\M m C.LLSL '€x¥ WC\\\_'>\!¢ S.\UJ;L C_L’c£.£ LLS /;I.j,w/$J XOY[;FCX;Cri/)\.
, /\Q\>. won we 3// we 513 ran ;z) w;// 5/»/»»,,,, %L /‘LL¢@./,-M,

Wc'bk“'§\)m ax \>m 8\\ 133 wm .S`how wm m _§'¢M¢ v `
_ . §§e,¢l ~f/w<.e.
mw §st ¢AM Hu saw md //) B/¢/.:;@-¢ can own ¢/W

Umr\wvsw &lluiuh`cm at h(_g mW,~A \
. _ - /) aim /l/€w f ‘ , ez v - ~
mm&\m\ Cm v\m/\) 'T\r\u( Powc ill bna s~a/M/ C§ WL‘JM;&OH

Paje 5

`”\>em.\ mm S-@.uc,».g>v\. \A.g\;%§. 005 graq@§'¢.~‘+q get um.
c;,omx‘, \Qr\w am 'u@ wm MM _D_-gM mm g_

S\um ,\c;\\ Qe;\mu P\>r\`\s\nu,b\@ umw \A".?>S(cm.

T_\<\L \cu,ov; w‘\\\ $\M\,o +_\/\M (\_culse mac 0§<',0\'77)< was CC
”Q&L\,~\wg giveth lm\"@dmw %n}s\\abie'\)h&e/\ IACBS(&) H\af way
ex\\\a~»wx \¢»C CL' S@Qm umwa Un.m c;‘.q;z,cm(;;\ cum
->cm_ S»¥ux~e wu_€ "me\\'w< §§va uslw m again w \Cuw+w

Qx\‘nmcwv\o/v\k¢. `
m cumle Cu\!me. 3th @ad on m rm+/on link mw trw
CS€_¢#; vo\mv\¢ b b€‘l  QQL§\£.. wm (L\emw jww J'rl'lw‘ -Mz//ata /Wca'/ Hrforiua/
'\mob web \(www-@,& H»L \fc,u)r,£ wiH/\ @kb€¢§g,`¢nc;_<,m/ '¥Mu!bh>

opmm_ vw@m@l,uq ask wis wm h> ma/<@ Hw m//M
chi ’c\u_ (‘_x:r\&mi§‘or\‘l allow OLé»c>c/L CW\A' Yw(u le QU¢/m# a/£a§c‘m.
@r\ \-_\NL \N\m&. B‘< Ou>'@.:uaka &Ppm(.

'PRNM.
hu\mw\ *<&\ax<;_ ma m ogva am 139 w
`(Y`\,(B{'_`\or\ \v`\u$ \z>£Q/r\ G:P\'D`Uc££,¢§ 13 C.\@,/\\C MM
_ C\:\'_ ms v\sm&\ 5&¢&@. mm /\\lmua#ozz) m TS\ /- \zb€ P\a£lr\_q 5&0¢( éoc_uw@mi; Lr\ & PGS\%% -PQA

enqe.wv£ CM\A W\c@sz/Lq ;-m£ @nucl@@e_ \/m uni¢@£ 61¢@1'5;
vv\m\ &¥\<5 J_’>M- ch r>€lauuaw QQ_L£

QA