Court Opinion

ID: 6720595
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-20 22:53:25.832221+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:01:33.816772
License: Public Domain

POLLOCK, J.
Epitomized Opinion
First Publication of this Opinion
Gertrude Flaherty, who had sustained injuries in the employ of the Book Shoe Co., made application to the Industrial Commis-' siori for an award. Shortly afterward she brought an action in the Common Pleas against the Shoe Company to recover damages for her injuries and later that action was settled and dismissed, she signing a release of all claims against the shoe company for the consideration of ?250.
The Industrial Commission because of the action against her employer, refused her application, whereupon she appealed to the Com-•mqn Pleas, where she obtained a verdict in her favor. The Industrial Commission prosecuted error to the Court of Appeals, which held:
1. By 1465-76 GC. an employee has an option either to sue his employer or claim compensation under the act, and an election of either right waives the other. When plaintiff filed her application with the Commission she waived her right to bring action against her employer. After her election to apply to the Commission was made the filing of the action against her employer did not destroy her previous election or deprive her of the right to continue her claim for award.
2. The right to an award from the Industrial Commission and an action prosecuted against an employer are two separate things. The mere receipt from the employer of com-from the Commission. Pleas affirmed. pensation in settlement of the action did not preclude plaintiff from receiving an award Judgment of Common