Court Opinion

ID: 3007651
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2015-10-07 07:29:24.9834+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T15:02:50.490612
License: Public Domain

IN THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
                      OF TEXAS
                                     NO. PD–0228–14

                                THE STATE OF TEXAS

                                             v.

                            TERENCE JOHNSON, Appellee

            ON STATE’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW
                 FROM THE TWELFTH COURT OF APPEALS
                           HOUSTON COUNTY

              M EYERS, J., filed a dissenting opinion.

                                DISSENTING OPINION

       I disagree that the destruction-of-a-flag statute is unconstitutionally overbroad.

The statute is actually quite specific: “A person commits an offense if the person

intentionally or knowingly damages, defaces, mutilates, or burns the flag of the United

States or the State of Texas.” T EX. P ENAL C ODE §42.11. It serves to keep people from

destroying a symbol of our nation and state, which is exactly what Appellee did here. By
                                                                      Johnson dissent–Page 2

all accounts, he was not attempting to make any type of statement, so his conduct is not

protected under the First Amendment. Although it is the flag’s symbolism that provides it

specialized protection under this statute, its use as a symbol of expression is exempted

from prosecution and thus the limited enforcement of the statute will not produce a

chilling effect on protected conduct. The State could just as easily promulgate a statute

prohibiting the killing of a mockingbird, which as the State bird of Texas also has great

symbolism, without infringing on the freedom of expression.

       Because it is overkill to declare this statute unconstitutional when the real question

is merely whether the State had sufficient evidence to convict Appellee of destruction of a

flag, I respectfully dissent.

Filed: October 7, 2015

Publish