Court Opinion

ID: 4046307
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:05:58.245781+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:29:45.740634
License: Public Domain

~!.NO#-~ V.A.~?J-74'7· d{
                                                         Nif,·..lh;;fo- J 57
  ex Pfif(rE                                                ·:

                                                                                           CouA. I          t;F
M Al~:r:zjl!        SilL 7J)IifS

V)                                                                                         C/l.Zfrt z#A-L /lf>I'/Ei'll5

17-IE )./' 111/)zslA.zc/                                                                   fluS~          /£~5-
(JJul/.:7   oF L<.,£/JA
                                                                                          lrllf vzs c. 0Ctt,J7}'1:'
 Co t.tPfy;     7&/tAS
                                                                                                     ~~£~~~l},Jtfu
                                                 Morzbf\1                                                      APR 27 2075
                            1/Pt~LZC.A {z:-0/V Foil. 1,./AzT                    e;JF
                                                                                                          Abe~ Acosta, C18rk
                                                     MlftJ01tM&t5

            ;VoLt! C-ul'tl£f ti111A7z-/l SI1{.:QI/t5                    AE.L/-17,/fA/
        . Fc;lt vAz/ cJI::/',1/1/ti/.)4-M tt.S z;v 't/;zcJL/t 7ic'f.?Af     /'~oct£S5 /fli/V
                                                                                          t?l: j)l4;:Z
       ". FffTII ~ srx·7lt /f/J'lt~0fl.t~IJ7.S 01: ?tire Co/JSTrl'i4 T.z:-vAI CJI;- 71{£
          UJJzi:~o S747f0 oF dM lfl<~cA A/i!U l,J.Zt.L 51/.;w 7lf,.::: ;:::OLLfJt..J:z;J6~,
                .   .                                                    /
                                                l"

                                                  1/~o 7 /111/JEA_S C.oll.f>qS !<£L:r~l--~/
:1...) 171/:/14i31U5" Cvu/1."/ /(4t) Uit.J/l£4)0/lllf/JL}/ .4~;>Lzr:7.) 7/r'>f Co/JS ?Z-7u 72:-cJ,Jtl/ L
     ;=;~:,::c>l-zw;: ttSS:ZS??JJu-: S?/;,4/);;1(/) 5 L/lz/.) otAT ~"N St&?d~ os-~/ AN/) Ji;zi.L- v--loc..l/l.. v~;r7     c.J 1:: M/l;v/.)/1~ us~
                                                                                                 /7/V
               oAzC-           ziJIIL.. of< .Su8St-Etlt.-u~N7 ~pL-zc.l$1 T#v 1~/l 1..//Z,Z-7 V/:=- //~07
               1/.4/}rtf. s~ coa;J£-t'li<£Lz-r:r:
     ll JLfll( caN\1-z~?i~/J l'1-;.f.;L£Ll41vT {-vll ltC-ld.AvJ1-1/E-0 /1-SSktll T i./rill
      Ptr4/JLy W't?A/?o~<.l IJAf/) SBJ7/-vJuZ 117-, ·7"0 (,o(sz~ty) '(1~4-/lf ;z-/J PA.zSO/I/.

     A-PPL~CAIJt           r-.:ztr: !fd t/.o/!l!f/Jn4.>    &llt:>qf, 44;/) -=N t=t~3'!.;:_~tl?}:;_, ~-3,.---:..ll.;:,v r-N;;...-LJ· 11.;.:::~ ~~/C.;)H 2t5'2Ztj/~,/£.
       :zgJ f{:c>·        /);;.t:;EtlSt~- Jf-/110 L):zL) IJo/ ~f)i!'4Ju47/-:Ly .:ri4/V.·~/.z64k- 711/£ C4Ji:.-:
     .11-tltzUr.lt t/45 . 11Lt.t-:.6r-:IJ t=-/fc.-?J· 7/f..-1~ zt: ~1.("_7 M.:rt.V/ 1~/11~/Zr.-- ll~
       -r:> ;2£t. ~;.;,:: .,s"fllrd_<4NIJ -v- &JJISHz~l€~                              La'
                                                                         ~...S 6oft Of 9"¥)
              (!~PMTi: L,£;11(~ /J Sw. J,/ 79~ 79S: '~' {Ui;~: 0'1.~- Ai~l~ ::l~uol
                                                                                                  .

       71(,{ Cat.!A;/·r.JI~ C/<;Q~-?:zN.-f/..         lftJfJr-4{5 0£hzr:,£) A-p;JL.z:c.4NiT 1/. o 7/14/3/3/IJ
        COI'l/JCJ!5 iJI'-zc..-?AJ ~
         W/1--..>r AIDt.
                      - {;..v::z'Aiv
                          .        I "/:
                                     ·t--o         ·---  __.... -
                                                   //-~sc·~"/--y  1

         tllr: S74?A- /l-'f/3r-:4) "//l.ZdL Cou/l7 /~O~N/) ~47' l~tL LSO/il /)~;tzZAI/..
         /lt.lf 13~ 1~4--1< ~w ?k/c 7/t...z.~¢£ 7~>1/) s /fl,:::E:A11S ;.;;:/\) 11iA/?.5 oN LJ 1.)~,-=.s (~1/ (.'1[
         7iM7" fl£ 1(--ft) /26-f ~-'-tttT c.:> ~73:::1~, :zd./1711 $#{ L..u.J#f /tcx:.£=?,.;~z}
          ;;Ll .::::.."{ o1v /IND j:Jd-id..S~,/ /{I) Vzui" /V.J/ / z-_;;,                    ;:=;,;;s;4/-y· .

          fllii S/47/: 1(.-fl}ll,(.f ?;1.Z4t Co'-td7 //;~tJ) 77147 PA;Ift2So~v ·;,//15 ;vu7'k
         /),.; i~;zc. z!CtJ7 t=-o~t PM'VJ£N/;;zd r54tz-AIIfS) ;::;z.;;,vt -;;::::.f /~Fv....:;-/1-)t- ,I
        ( SAt.~/15) w-1-5 :ZIJ NllM£:£) v1: tVzs /{"".61/7 -z; ?!"::s /~Fy- .=:A/ It .... -;>
         owrv 0£!-",:;;/IJsr.;, !1--P~-~1} 7/i~z VJ?f /I..ZS /)£ crs:zotv i,J/I£72.£/:;e 7 ) 72'5/:rr
        l/7
       L>l(-b/11~
                         s] I./£C...z-.ur
                             ,,         .)1 -./)
                                         .... v     JJ,;?7
                                                        --      -~
                                                                ~__,
                                                                           .,.-:-- -   -
                                                                           /,_-:.J~'~~r-·.
                                                                                             ,~
tf) T/IF-!- /)M.--1.5i>N ~ /ll.:z:;.f Coi//C:l.c.tSZV# :zs /"f.ZSCMil.dt=
       c:Jt= Jt.tr~zu::/ /l(~ I£ Co/4./) 31/ov~ ?'i/4 7 rtA. t=:-LLz,>:>N w/fS A/i>'T' /ljJpLz-c._4/v/5
       A-7/oMr.y t11JO 72{~ ST/11?.: ll-4tY4.5 cc:Jt..(d ~ ';;er~t. c, /Cb!L t.ll!/1 c- "£"7
        t.JA-5'..                cSlit r£          ~E.)lr~:oJt..                l'tS~ J->aii.)Qidl
                                                                                                       )
        7'Jl                                 T/.lZ/fL /f 77v/l/IIA-Y
         .1!§. .flii1J;· 1/AIJ&r.> :ft_ IJ;-..-   LJa:-z/v/£0 Fo/l w/t4i
      :;( w4..s-.
                                                                 :zs S14S7A~AI£LJ ,, w:z: 7"11
                                                                          1
                              71ft= o/}';]f£C tz-o;V
                              !<£Fit'A&nt:JE :£o                {¥r woll/) /11£ t£LL;zso,r/
                               -          IJt£:/fr            co- CounS £L ·

      /Vlll.t 13LL::ZSvN w/IS No-t' I~Pj)LZL.J1;J7'S                          H7'Z'o!VW~- ,1-{1)0 771~             /UPIZ45' 7A_:afL
        CcJL~tJ1.7 f/l-AC£P M~>llA Vt:::zC-117 oN J'-t/l, i;--a~sJ/11) ..z:::s7Fz..-r.t¥Vy· .1-S ·7i.> 27?,.£
        /(r: CtJLlt&:.;t;..v,.V cJI.: 7#,-: ~Sk/WvA~y· oC: rfr;t)t:z-c/IAJTc-ttt. 7' k)zL} Nti7 ul£' .....::::./v 0
          CotJ s~;.J;;M 7:..-CI/V .1-N)/ cY /t(/C/(. 7l=s7~ ~7:~ 13'-t' 7" P"-1~ lzL l--;J:PN'f
          ALvllt:::. 7/{z-AL 11/7oM~y ~~-tS- /~A:4£.S::J/t/ 7li::S~1:r· Til ?71;-:- /.::JLLoL./-::.:;/6:

                                                                 J.
                      /E           . .u . ,,)                 { /11.5. Ptr41<$v/lj_ '7i:~trr/=y::zWt J
                   ( 1- V~        tl ( . / 1T                                     ·711.'Z!fL 11 r rv/2.NI;y
                   (.(u;.[Sfil//,. IJ'y' /24/(. $/;.;'_{() 1"'1AI       .
       Q _.       s   0      1/IM (' 1lk- --r ~~t=~-5                       Z.5 - /1 ?"      L F-A-.fT    L)q;P._;rw[;_ 7li/C 71( zAl..          Y""' IVGV/£"~
                            IJ~-st:.LtJ5£tJ         tlzs·   /-            s~ wlletJ 7l1C /1/Jt.>L.zL/1111'1' 1"1/t~. S~L~AS 5t/fll£S                                    £/1/      /lzs--       ZIJ (-IrS    (->,=::~kP;y'
                                                                    "         ,                ,
              7ti47- · z;J t{~ #-f';>Lzc.17fvl~ 71//17 c..o,aiiSF-L t«;;t:-u)1·~t)1 ~;) /o u·~/ t:>;~7Z'?Z-..¥Vt£'..(
              ~£Srzr:-~ o# !lz.r-0 w,v /]t£1t4u: 1 1,./ttr-N z~t~ !~c.--r H~-c £v"--J yvl.f 71~4r it't-::. WI!AJ7i=tJ
                  t.:; i),-."-CAI.{.5l:  w-~utO I.)Atrv.r~ tl:z::> Z/1/Noc.CE/Ifct:.- 71fA 7 Y'cJL< /l"~~~s.~:: --zt;
                                           z   1
                  At.Lf)w tt:z"" ·r-=' fi~s7zt-y,,. l)o YP4. lf6/vi;: oil. LJ.:c-5~~--z;:: ;;./z71t /dAr s/4;;;;~
              N/?

  II- -w£tL" 7114 7 ·-- yvCA                      1<1ik1W .z Jt..tsT-- -r l(Aw::                              (v    u/
             4pp i.,zcA·/.z~d::

It - 13y 1'1-ty :zl'll 1~/J...tu-f 7'~c-ll/ 11 l.vtwC                         ?
Q- YtE5 '

1¥'"     Vtd               ?
        -                                                     { Ev~ tl P. I r2 3 )
(!(- /)v Vc)tc 1~Ut. rz,4r B~sr-:1) · ~1.Jo/f/ //f,r :z-Iti;:t?l( 1""4 7Z-PAI 7l/4~W4-f I? V/1zMt.JL~: c:;Nt..y
     -z:~ yoL( ."!f!_lfr Wtllt£7l1G/l Jl....A:Lf::!_7/g!__;;S Azb/IT .LJl 72£S7z-Ey· ~ t~ 8£/r'/ltF 7b'4~'
       ~ /}AJ£v£u[!f/J                             li:;EM     E_n.or~ PR.~~t, ~ ?
11--    ~
         ~s ~
         -
:LF fi_CV.z£w CJ~>r 3 1/l!/: -CoUA-7 'J' &~ f/oi(_/'LONS C9/- ?11/.Z /{r~Cvi£tecE.z-vE0
 M.zsSV?7tS~r-rlr cJF F4c7 c;~ L~w .:z-IJTII£ P£7Eizi!W 711.4rl3r~..er oN
  W//111 ~-fS fAtZ:5 P!<.otJ,.ctUy ·J,J,Jt.,tf/) /3/: /3/i/-o/(;1 7lt-:- C.ot-t/l-;- ~

  To 'Jt
  Mfi. Su-iA/)1'1-t,lf.IV /       t:ti~IU-i :zs          oNt:: :L..SSLt11-   7114 7   :z     7livutlt T wl£ /vti"RZ"t:J 70
                                 AOIJ!l£SJ.

  ·rflr- IJ.ti?o/l't;:tiJ..} yol4 lt/4-IJt 7114                Oil/   ?lit~£ /ljLG://( /) ?

      (t(C C01Uil/. ~ y;.:~ .z t-u.-£s5 St>~ y~S.,- b.o /(~4i) 771~ lfr;~t. v:zLl !U!"S~N~i:
                                                                                      &

      MIL S?O!VP-?AN:' j/1~5 .s:z-A              Vllr-N' z Fz/67 t.c/7 4/~::;oziJP£/.J ~ 7cl".c5 /1-LJcJ(,(T
                             . /1 1'1.0ll7lt ~t.o r w£#7 vvr.:fi.. 4-N/) V!Ll<1:£() r;;{MA. c~~ /)zST-
                                 7L7 117'To/l11JfLf-') C..£/I.. (19;:q,/ .L.)f(.{i.: S W/tzc/t Wl£l<.r.:( Ct7/"t:z:J¢t.. /.t; V-S7Z/y ._ ~All) £;> /I-14It:Ji 4 Lo#t. - s Tolly S IID/?. 71 .z /4.:zAJI< :z-7 "'S /1.  ·
             /Vl ~or tDo~l>l7'.
            8{,(_{ iiCAE Z5 4 /.)z;I:FQ{£,.;cc i7/-- tP/'.:EN:r:oAI ,;;.S -;"o W'II£7PE4 oil. Nor 7Jl~­
            ~r_f4Al.X {P"UA!J&;t} 1'17 ~L ~ /f-tA. Ci.~/l/J..Yt ,f-/11/) z: /Ju?'ll 4-61<£/~iJ .?7f4 7
            t-:-vtuv. /llt:~wCtl :z?''S /vo7'-- o/.>AII.T-- Sl;>i[c:z/::=c4 L.Ly /#.. ; /t/.J;;lz:c4£.:>Af 1~­
             t:J (._,£:$5 / (3/~C 4-i-tSlt   Z    7 W/t/Stf/'7' ('l_Nvw/1/ ;1 7   7it";<;:   ?::z:~,·: r :;:r--;r_ _ z-7 6-v~·=.$ Z/J _ .
            Tv       Wt{£"7[1/'[£ fJ£-LII-i.tS£ -- -                                                                .
.             .              wt•                                                                         .                    //
    Mil- SlMOMA!/11;,· :zr ~~r ~ 4¥-~ ~ 4z&LlT I)M~tr f<'f!!:£Z:-£
             -         tw 7:zl Ar//::;1( ~)j'J£Al<:z:iJt.. lJ z71( M),/ P~A.~ON /1£~1?.. {;;f:77mt-
           (}4d< l{bU1 1 71/A "7 :Z:SSc..th   /l.t~IJ Co/"U.C "if'L ,.YiiiiJ ·- • IJ'-1.7 :z"/ Z$ 4 rtoo"'7 :CSS{.;f/[".
         -~ C"'//11 /)~A"/~ CL:z"':-;,;7 &AI 711~1 r-olt 771--f7 /3~Zi'~~- PuAfloSI£ 8£clf..ttS£ 7?1-e:£ ·
       SllfZ.: 171Jeovt6t( rtA- 6A;£y /(/~ 0/~.:;m££). /Jr.:c4kSG 17-Y: ~ ...:P'l~V .zAf 'Zlt47
       CASt: Z5 4/1/ Clt:j:r:A~-. ::zt.: A /.)l.t~ oiYY-A. :ZS /Vu·7 Co/Z-f/11tttv.zc;?0::L) 7~
      7lt1-C IJi-iFi:;}J/);t;ltl7,_ /Nh" /l~frlt£'/)y :Z5 p li:!§V£A.~ti ·-r;JL¢ c4SE,;'/}H/) /(tz-
      ZIJ SPI?F. 7lt,;.: 1-:JL£A oH-/-..-/l ~ /'4/l.. C/lJ7.}' 5/).J/<.,:z- · To /"'t/2. Ccd1dy /}AIIJ /IcC.::.
      VLitLLy·. lh£ .:zNS -z;;,. 7/-£0 7!1/L r'L~4 ow::;-::/< Br::./::o/U£ i.-./1£ S?/?~ "72ai'LS"/z-
      PRoc u-.;t):z:Nt..

      I}!P~Uinl~            lfS)    ~~· il-~:s !1}-~t.              cot(NJ',.rt. w4S      .:zitlr-l~:£c.7rv'f' ~~~ ;=,p~t-
                                            ot-1-r[)l Dwll."ZNI.. '7tl:01-t., /.)£7/EA.P1:zNJ17:zr:;,# c~vS'"k-7'Lt7"£
       0
       t    LI.'JM/Vlfii:N:ZC7l"'O:..   4 1;;/.n:A
      /1- /);£NZAI. ol: IJwr Cvvt~Si£" ~F Ll'f!w ::zw vzuL11- rzo/1/ c?~' 4-~T,. { DS" 13 /?NO { '( .z.
      /ilt7. ]Sl :i. {/).. ~1:: 1/iiE 7/:::J/1/ 11-W upz/kt) 3747/£5 Co&;JSt'.~T­
      (;1 7ZL>N' /-1-MI~Ivtr../11'7 b ·

     '?lk::: S/Aut: f/-'1/JMS Jt..eiJf.ii IV~'!'" uk_:z,v(; Z/\IT'o CvNSZ'IJtOeH-·zz-~AI -w,·c 1;:;,c7
      '71~7' 7/l:vtt. ~7'-;'t7J(JvAy !):z/J/IJI)~ Col"'tMtc/Jz c,p"?:; A- P&.::/1 o/-9~ w?7tt ~-:~
     LL:O-Id~ /f/ill) L,JZI£61/r.z~r~t 771'/C /--'fcTJi o/3 v:rr:.>4 s L.y w-1 s·11 1/3uSh" &r ~ZSo sM ,O~d'ZA~t.. 1'1-/J;Ol~c/flli/r.J t-t~~S
     Nr-~L Z:$' 11 v..zvlJf/7::.-ol'v oF ?k/C .5:ZV/ff /1/"f;-JII?/'?;-e,.,7 ;ZZ6N;; S,/ft-7_;- 64-AR/)S L_v
     /4:/tl tfCL 4SICO w/(.:; 1-~f :riJ CJ1-I'lut::AA7~;oA/ 77t;,£ a..z:-6/tr r~ C.Du,tJ5t£"L A cl!'-1..
     c..A. z/zU/L S 416A-) &/.: Z7l;;; CA.~z-/JI'f( ;>~ oucsS.
                        /3)e/'Atl7A (011./ld ;' ~tiJ sw. ~~ tj-,9 (z;::~. C/1~. .4;.'p l~"7).

    ,MAN/)1f1411tlS - '-1 (;£) 12.          _
       /*'f/IN/JJ/Prus v~ otJo/ iJ1L ::z:ss~- r,;) co~c."/ /1- eLi~!( AB~SG' oF !)zs-
                                           · · 01::- 1?- /.) ~ '?f· ZM i>oSI::V
       L/U~7"<.o.N' c!)/l.. vzat. ;p "'/:e:v/11                             .-.. ") /3y· L, /,3-r: ~~~i~/V'Vl,~O w:z7li Si.cc(( Ctz/(//f-.ZA/Ly 77147 1vt>7/t~:-.dfr
       :zs        £.,{(C7   7.::>   71;/{"    /~l<-i~/1._ C."'-"S-Ii"   0/:: 1/~-s C;--=:,e;=:, ;::-;z:.::;,N.

f14Aitf/)JfAtk5- if                                                                        _         . . .,. _   . ..- ..-.---zr- i) o/<.
     ~/)/fl"fJ,tS ~,£VZt~W w/{Mr; "'/lttC L;tfw ;=iJ Qw~ S i"Z"viV ,.,c:: 5 WAJ 5 t-;. / c -t/_,
      tt;JctLil·t~ztll.; /tt1'C 4c'"7" /VluST 811: P.:~S7zv;-i::Lyr C~P'tfot/fA/LP~L) /fl.Al/) So
                        7

      pL 11::rt.Jly F~t£ S CA. zt3t~ L{{A)IJI~/l.. -m. .c U;w 4 S 7.> IJ;: I -/1ft"& /.-/t. o;A--t
     Dol.1.l37.         t£.v ~£L. /fzlL-v-,..cr d/~ ~~· Fzrllll (ksT: :111 .5J../ J/ 'l~'t ?~ 7
                                   ('7l!j? c_I/J;&;f1, #~ 2 oor) ..

                                                           7
                                                               2
        ('_~o<'-" .d.~Zl/ff/ $'"'1h~7 ~(/di/-'"XJ2..) ,b..Sh ,rf ·A·§ l.,t'_ /Z::I"'JZ1/(/0~ 7ftJfv.:Z
             '(J Jr.<;) n ·J .L 7~(/f'lo."J :_7/0&'t? 2'7nv ;p.zw. (~(1-r~ liCit') 17 -; .L J)'J(J NCJ,"J
                                                                         1

  :_-/17'J"cl ~.:"-.?71?(/ "Sf/!PW. '(/lt:~S) h ·J .L ?J?(fjVO,'> 3'717?/ Cl( I
                                                                          1
                                                                               ·r
                                                                                J!JI?(/ :27 '(/11) . -1 ">/
 . fOJo~ -h l _.L?"'(.JfVt:'.? .:.-Jr'~c/ -='1n?/ •IVIY>j .t(JJo?::)    n "!   ,.L?h(l/"'f?   ?'f'?/d   ~'1n?J
    ·7 7;r.. '(8C'O?:') 17 ·7-77 CI/Y[J 1/'-9/;rJJ?.-:;3'(/ _:_ryh2J 'J?_-/ >J:;-1 ~~-'S JA:Ytv7/tt~;.?l:l
        -yo:=} .f(/~~(ltwaS 71/_pa-:rSS~IC'?/e/ ?/0/fl ~kLS .N..z: __z., ho~75 &?571/ SZ
/Vt'-;;L.-I/..2-77'JSflf07 (/fl'!U /V(J-~f/?:Z/Y?? Wtvo'J .Jc/hft:J(Jc/ vo::;l 011V(lf'li1_S               ;!flL,

                                                                  ."(£00~~~) L£l.. {fL p£ ·.:1
 "t(   $_1:£}/L$(7-"!JZ!¥11'] -;,-#z..i:.-_1-rlJ=() '("t:Bbt (.P?) SttJ )£1, /3~:.-1 bBtp ~
 -----:-~---:-----:--                     _;7.-,V . / o         .  /'..   /           /
·=#Z/.#Z./-.A-- tJ~?/17:; '731/ 7(.;g/ ~I(LS' t7fl'..l.ZIVJ? .,((0°-r" t' V?_} "e'$1 SL. I p{;/
   L. 7~ ~.f!LS(1-~z~J? ·A-wvll~-8 ~?ZP-'S -.11-rzl/l/vf! /(!Jb.l>l) L 'JL ~L p'"( ·3 ·s 9~ I hh'l
                                                                        1
                                                                                                           r:"
     btl _f/11 ·./'1 .ft'{! ./thiJ/-A-tJ'J..?,;//f.(6~~~J ~~~c; 9~b~~.,f6 rl16                              r-e
  ;'()s E:£L ·1;g_f!ZS-~~t-?I'Y...lC'/. (b 00 -e}orl'!/''" :P~ ·~s ~l.1 1bo7-·8tJ.,
   }t:P_, ·~ ··s /.$f ".:a,I(L.f -/t-.:IZI\V(Y ''?5/ -~-~S ~ S?IJ'.::-,1,1 CJf. •.LW? Yl'lL 71?111&
           JL ~J?o.? lb!U:.t(JE:/_;1 01"-J/ ..;_!!ty/5 S'1t:J~-IWYJN A[J (l31,.J.clo(J6J 1\1'../J!fj
        51-'Jl )11/P(If'V~.> .>:.-~ {(Ni-'? (bbo 1 ,PJ' /'f.) (P.J ~~(- :n; A:1z~ .:.lt:J
    -~ K-47d -~r.J::ljgn_L 7Pfl"z~·l/? 711?-! J(ll//Y(J#IY_L 9 /;1 8 /7 .~.t ~:;f_":.JN-ptl.L_!. 1;/
           -l)fi/:z_L   "1.73.)0(/(7' _;~      --1{1 -=--t!VW    S~-!_-YO 1/:;ryd 71-il .Lf'IDI(JN..~-4..=1(;/
                /11ZP7d .)(_:! (/fVP/ _=fL. J/.7:z:·NnWI-J/c>? -1-,_L.clWO(/d11 7?S(IInaJ
     _-:7)2.2. Q2.
       -~/f~-!E!(j )0tv=-IWWCJ731} /VC'.:Z~ P.,-:? /O)ft/. (/jt[J !VJ.'?:Z ?/3Wti -~/'JL
                                                   /.J-15J?1             II fl.~
   -L J}-;s~w        AJ'w_.z P'/L2..   SIYC?.:Z.J.Z(J NCJ/ (}JVIY         Jl:.rtcl -l/ J..c~177V el-
                                                                     swr--a         fJitJ
        ~~.../_-?~P 71/WY6J:/ bl _-:/IJ 5W?/;Ja_ .;?Jz.2 .:fL ~::ZNI-111/h/07 o_L -11.1-J(J :::1Jjj
       SP--J/ 7.?S fl/no;; _=!SJI/;l_·:!::JC/ ?/-~;u ;Jf/11 5'~ ;vo:z_!.S~1nCJ ~Jfll ;nr;'H                            (S

                                                                                                                      ,I
f/)     01{/Ji£/L u/- 7ll£ ~ttlltrJF Ul_r~r~t~ttt.. lfP!>EAIS,
       . 71I!C T/l:zAL C.&141l7 Slf4LL M/ff<.t; SP/~czt:zc F.:z~~~IJ;;:p~[,_s ~~:=~elf /I-S {c) W'ttt:c77rl:U{
         7//.:Z/ft.. Ct9ltN~t£L r-l'f.7:Lh0 7o OZScvi/fi/l. /9/tJIJ P~t-=:y:.;/117 ~v.z.Ot~vu.( .S t.ttJI.)"A t .z#6-
          11(f.:>lzc,1tJrf 7li~tZy·             c?r
                                           7llr: C4S£"
               (Ev./1. t?
                      122- t2))                       (~-f>~t~~A.S(j/Uf ?EJI~";~y)
            -                                                (7l'ZAL      A 77.:?/ltvpy
       <(uttS1~ IJY/rul-·STI!APP1~·.
 ({- /f{ll()   /Jo Y.c.)(A !3t~Lz£11'1£ lJ;t!!;:IJ      yott/l. /1c;7ZO//f /1{4 7 yvt( ~~~v-::1.) 70 .....
                                                           '-f(Jf//11
        OzscvVI'-1{ /'f-/11/) l~l~Sr:./-1/ r=v:.:zOt~c./:- w/l:zc/1 s~~/)(!)/(7/C/) ll~s 77/~vA.f· CJ(-
       /n-
        11t:   c..·As~·- __,
                         //1£· ~t:;.U·
                                " -· -· IJ1-:.l-r-/iJS/:.
                                           ·- .- · - _,.,              ...-. · /./£rr=IVSt-:
                                                          /lu"Coll..y_ 7/£    . . " ·-    -      .,.     _,_
                                                                                                t!?/-1'1 1"'/t.z:..Al/.0 /~A 7L
                                                                                                                              '}" '~•
                                            .                               /

II- I-Z Pe-£L. /.Zia! z F/P.$/&/) T~ Ptli:~SG/1/T z r P;S:c s//::o yv'-l -'IV LJ1~FV~o/IJ~//(I'f T:z:;J/i. 7v ;;?21£
       :)"'ay        7lr4r' mA"y wr-:.-A/-: LJr.:/.:t~/.!5 -zv1:: ,.:.c::.JV Nl'? ~~,-;_- ~

II- PtJS!> :z/JI.E>             Y£!~~-

G- OKAy /.J:Zf) Yt.Jl-t /~1/£/<. uS/: 771~                        j'->:zc.Tu/ /t~~
       J~l<.y /t'f//l'?          7/'tzy     W£.1<;{' IJ£1:.:;.:/i/J;cv;: :zN' N.4Tu/U( ?

        -                                             ( t:v:. II.       17fo )

 CP-    71147' WcJv/IJ .L/.JCl.t.t/)£- ._, 13£C4w5/i" Y""' Nr-r.:t) 7#.47"' /£"v.:zQ/:.-/VcE /f-,rVO
        J-Al·Vii:.S tz64 7:C.:wt.. .z 7.::4\/ oR/.)£/<. To /..?'-'1 7 o/J ?7'y;; sr-.:-t.t::-LJ~h'::/1/S/:- ?.lir--o~y
         T-> /{l~i:-L>t 7/: IN£ £yr.: IJZ7;\;1~5l=s O/~ ;?//~ S747/= CoM£c.7 ~
   A- l{ztltr

  Q,     A-ji/J YtJLt bzo/Vrr ~o                      .4-Py &/- l!l~rr
  II-
        ·-
         t\fO.
        -·
  Q- kt/Wv -r/ Look !1-7                   7il~     C/fS/i   yott 1(4/) 4- f)a:;r.;nszVL.;;- 7lr'£o/2y Co!J.A£c7?

 A--   Y.€!.

If- y~>·
       -
Q- /)a yot.t /ffiL             7JI/17' }("'"-    Ft.dLy :z/11 v£5"~ WI· 7/~/./ 7#-? 7' t0£t'l=/t15·zv£· 711/:z.-c/ly ~

It , L6~J,knJ{.. IJAd<             u/11   zr    tJoW NO# ~ /)z/)1/( 7:
                                                       ·-
a- J,Jov. L /) yolt
                                                              -~

                    IYG/li-!1:- w:z/tl Mt{' 77Y'"'l7 i3£C4~S/t ot:-
                                                                    -   -

                                                                                        71/...p 7 yc.Jtt       /J:z:/.J/V 'T   tuw:;:-
       /10£62 ~A«~ o!<. A/£/IS.JAh1/JL~ 7/lmL s c"A/1 77-:ty- ?
/! ~ r       wo~t~LO /IAV~          r11 J;?y      7l/4r

CP-   ~Ci.
      .
           wol4 d) A[.,.~
            __.._..                ~        .
                                              z.Tir ----
                                           w..----  /fit£ ?

11- ~5.

  a- !l'l5' ;J;£4/{J()~ L ovk.:z:;.~t. ~7 !!~)         y 04_ (.(~v/)r~.5T/fNt) - -  Y"Gt W/£/lrL lf~c.4/~- {')/¥SI'i4'7
       wlt£/V Mfi.      1'1-L(;..uz:A.h   /£!>/;:./-Z/C/) 4-f 7J 5/~u:- /Jri:/:r-/1/S/: /3/~:;q.//;.. 11 A-/::;:.:z.~Pt47:zv/:Z
           O,::;:i~i.ISt£ ~.

 t!l- tn=:s.
(J- /HtJtJ y~tt     uJ()I)t:!?.S"/4/ill) 7/(4 7 /J/1~£"L) "'fj.JCJN /JI,:; :ziJFo/?..M.-?7'zOV y~ 11-?P t?/v£
       f.?I~ "/li~ otJLy- way~s y.:;t-4 t/.1/J 7o t/:;""7 ~IV /~ROIV7 c;~ ?hr.:- J/.,.lly 7/y-;o.: z-ss £.tr:
           vi-   Still:-/.)~~;:-~.;- ·wi'IJ r-~11.... /I-tA- 54L;zw;f.S 7J      ~s7z"_-Y ~                 /

If- .:z__kNow 7(t';,4-7>vvw. z~ /llv7 s ~-ti'J( z                  Qq:c?J: uAI/Ji-?/C S T(.)v/J 7lr4 7' :z 7                   1'140
           t.) {3;[    7/I,P.T W/;7' /9 7 ;?ll£ /:Z~~c;- ,

C(- (!f L4W I!/ 7&i-: /:z:MI-: &F .;¥ifL'Z/~)'S ~ Z?L,4;//) /II£ //~::z;A/t­
                             r·
 ()/J./Y./(.l~IJ 13 /#r: co~ll / r.7F U ,zlf.l N~/l ovAl' oPi-
 ;z£sz:o,v1tJi)7' t7J CO#LJ.. ?l('r£ S/i?~;
   1+77 us . .47' Lif'"t,lah S.£.7 47 ~~llfP.
                                                                                              .
 \( :.£/J   0     tY;.~tf.
                        WOAO)' .z 7 .z> NO'?' 71<1.--L 6/l/fV.£rr (9/;:- m/.: # 77'P/lNI-:j;S
      r-A/l. oil 7!14/ ·M.A~-n::llt /)14 7 71/..47 :z 7' Cot'ii/J rz-7w 7r-S 11 v:z-t){JI r 4 :dA/
      oF I¢(J;JlzVP#1/Pr-v~~ 7r~r;.:L) "TJ //{~
                                                                       1

     s-'Pf~;:,;t~ 5,;~:· ALS-> £vz775,-v-tu.cE.x; '*"''"~ tJJ, 38~ /ds-' Sc.7 e'Jg> 8'3'-
      8 J L· £ ,1. ;1_j S':;.tf/98"5"). ( ,. ~
     C11 7lt1/:     CcJ;Js/~u?'zaliAL JVt~Aii)~U £6-i.U4M~I~~~L ~~~:c~~~.:
       AS5ZST/WC/.; oF· Coc..uUSt;.:t.) :zs AI)J)~/fS.JtW ~ /t~A- :!cr..... ~~o/
       (lt/1.:: Sl-17t ZA1 &iJT/I:r,o/Z(Ait. A 02~A;z-AJAL        c:::::.
                                                              V<~ ~ro/1/. ~ 711f"'1'1
       If fJ,(cJ(I{r:/)Lttu[ 7P/47 Rztr /.;) ~r..-7 /Ill-:- S74A1tJJfRIJ ol
       /)wt£ f>llcJct;;S 5 LA t.1 ,.~.,

       , #_£V£fl!. -V- CULL VIZA/ jf!Js'          .Sk/ J~ ~l/1 ('~ C/l.T,.,~ 4RJ.- ~c;oJ ) . .

        jlza -v-        Ct?WL 7 ~/" ~j)is?f{ J Ffi>/l FzF711 ,tksr 3Y' ..J!~-t~· 3~ 9 ;{t~-
       (74, ~ ~ ~oul).,                                             "

                                            II
~,    .i

/0) .(1PPLzutl1'5                .3/lows It- 5<-t/35/4-N/zAL Sttow41t.                  &I~ ff
                                                                                           co/Vslz?tt 7:-o#/lL
       f{z~/(7            IJeAJ:zU. /fNIJ !'1iOC7) /Q,£ I(£Ql.l~~rilv7            Ot~ 71fr- Cot.t/2-~&;C~.zt..l:.
           ;tL /fPfUL~s oR./)~              A-If/) ,5p£t:.zt::Zc f7:A().z;,;?S at: Flfc.7$ 7ltt7.£; 'Zi~~:;,Mz6/lt
            £AI 7ZtLr": II:uvt 7 ._:, a_f3L,q-:£(;:"_ £x._ ?41< t£   /44/<_ izlv' UtztJ/1J   Rt-:. j\/o.' hi~-/ J-?o?- o{ _
                           ...SlR..rc1'-i4N/)··v·-wi1SIIz,J{,.~         ""     ~-5.   i>cfj {tittl):
     Mttlilb!IMuS -10                                                                                        .           ·-
                Tv     i~S748t.z.SII                   T~ IZ1;fAI 0/fMCtS f ?7f,[' f.26L z f i /S &~ t.il;; M~£41V%:#{,-
                7/14/     711£     !Zf£~:z7S &I:   ?lir: f(,rt ~~y:.-    .So~ tkr /f/IJ£ !kyoJ1f/.) /.J-6'(;)'-< t'c-.

                   I?£..4Ju£SU~P 1£{/Y/J/)~/11 tt5 /<£L:u~=-' IV07.7c£ /ltVO 01-'P~t-/.t-zLt/11
               7/it:                                                                               ro            ·zcy'
            zNV4"7:z(jt?'flf ?i'~ Ev~t)cAtt:~-:; .::z-s               4-#
                                                               ;ES5£N7z-4L IJ4/27 e~f-- Atr:JLz-c?Al7J-
            /t.'dttT ~..;If_F/l~A- 7/l'Z-(L !1tv0 I~::;:I~L7zw~ (<~j)~~S/~7/f/.z-r.?A/ l]r. CouJJ)t5Z
           / /1/110 t."oAI.StzfitTEatiiAL /)t.t£ I'A.oa>J TO Pl'l.ovz.S.rOt/I/S ~~:::- ,(/Q2.dl:: 1-
             ~u:Tr':AJI /t'i /WO 19 uF lll.e ,57/17£ cJ~ ~5 /1#1) F.zt:-~ SZYclll .4-AI/Y
               FouA.~t/cllTI IIMJZ#/J~ ·rUJ                  -me- li'NzTA/J sf,?JtS· c~d.S'11t:7uac7H'·
               JN!AIJ/)AMf.tS AIU.zet:,'
                MA-iJ01{.1'11.uS                  6MAJ?I~t) :z/: /Wr.: ;{J;U! 7bll/~pl'Z&!Vtr S!f_owS
                                   (Ui1z£F MAf" 13/."
                7itd /-oiltJLJ:ciJt- (1..-) /IM7 7f.l;.-: ~c.7' Sou~/f't 70 /3r:- (OM;0/£LL~3"1) :2:5
                fuiV~Ly /l'f:zNZS7/~r/fl /1#0 Q.) /1147 /1l..c¥ :Z5 ;Vo /10;~4JuA72' /(r-Ptt3:£Jy
               117 L/IW. _#t£VItl( jos- Sw. Jd' 11 r
                                        7
                                                                ,«2. .
                                                                  (c<:"'7:z,;{;.. S7A1: ,£>< A.eL. !{o5EAf7H//L;I'-v:...
           Poe' 96 .sw. 3£1 /tltt./ /'18' (_IY~.,.A-
           -                                 r ,/;
                                                                  AZ.iJii- ;Loo3) /11)/):z'&:cJN/ILLy-C ·/lie= __.I(
                                                        .......,_ D7l"rr·
                                                              WUV'l .

           ad11 ?PI?(t1~pLz C/flil/ ltl4 sr 1(/fvt-c /f- 'cLt;:4~ b6tlr / u /;«: fL~E/11'-j/ t/£.SCI<-
           zB£S 77r£ 1)~/y ·7o ·13,; ~~~1'< 1::-oA.MI{/) S.f.tcJI 7/14/ //V£/! ,zs IVO
           Roo/Ill ,.-:-oil.. 7ll/': EiC-1:!/<. c...~_:,>/( of::. £).zs C-I'A. £Szi):P.~t,. "Jr.d2fHi1 11 't w _3 el 7 7 3      s
                                     ( ·~, ~~4-Pfl' ;zco3).,

               W/1£a.trF()M fJAeflt ~j5 uwszLJIZA£t)1 M.IIA1f£:7J5,tf[;zj;#A.f PMY!5         7#4r
               71/Z:S fld/lpdi/JL.t{ CDtl./l7 Gfllf/ti?P5/ /tf/0~ A/j}l.2Z:it!~/ll FM... W/t.ZT t?/-
               MAfiiP~Pl1.4f, I}IJ/) WP( II~ If J'IEk/ lllMf t9P 71/i£ ~~ 0~ HzS 1/,_0 '7
               HA6it4J c~ap~~,-5 lf;J;>l.Zc47Z:~ Q/t t!J/V 71J~ A/J o v£ tJ1 ff:zt7tt/ • _                 £ .,
                                               .
                                                                            . AaJI         5~.4# -SI_:-
                                                                              MlillTZAI 91t.r#!1f           ·-PI(o
                                                          ~                      I(£LIF?o'/L/IP~;JL---c4/IJT'
                                              /Vo.:/{o{p- })-{
                                      fU·NtJ.:w~-73~ 7177-Ql

  E)l}?,f/1.7£
  MAll.~ Sti~AS
 vs
lfl/1! il6 '711 jpSli.zr::?'
                                                                  /I~S~-w/ ·1/£.~4'S.
  &Ci/L 7 (.}~ (  ~- l$[t_,a~, 7i-tr: t.-:4c.<5. S7/f~.:-i) ::zAI      -z#;--_- /f/fovh"   4~;> L.zu?~c-::>/1/
                 /1/ll: fiLy     C9/.: 7?1/~ _;1/Yov~
                    /?/)j>LzCA- 7':z-c:;,V r-v,f_ Vll..:z7 0/~ /L-1/9/1)/J;fM ~5
                                                                        W45 5~~ VI~{) o/1/ ~
       -~;;,:uf,"?'v' 1/.7S?A~c..7 ~7ZoMr"~ ~.f' j}U/c:zVtJt.. !1-· C~JI'Y ;;eA/ /k;...:_ t<.S~ /f11'!ZL
              ntJ/}I.:It £4~L t-t¢~,;: /~ l~ve~v.:zc.tr; /Jr~ 78'o.;t£:, . ON
                ·rf.·:::--s ·7/._,r,.,..._.-
                 / cr-       £ ~r~.
                                              ., I ~7
                                             P<
                                                               /'1
                                                              v,fy         .A
                                                                     V'/~. /fPAz-4
                                                                                   L                    I ··-
                                                                                                   .2_u ~

                                                                         ·~~s.vd~-e_
                                                                         --l~.f~ 7Z7J 54Lz'll/4) - ~_.fp -Yz-
                                                                            ;e..24Q¥"4~~ L::GfA/7: