Court Opinion

ID: 6720505
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-20 22:53:20.174129+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:01:33.716182
License: Public Domain

PER CURIAM.
Epitomized Opinion
In 1909 the Village of New Boston granted a franchise to the United Fuel Gas Co. to supply natural gas for a period of 25 years. Among other things the ordinance recited that for a period of ten years the gas was to be furnished at 40 cents per thousand and “to be thereafter subject to the provisions of the statutes in the State of Ohio in such case made and provided.” The ordinance also provided that the company should not be required to make a monthly charge of less than 25 cents per meter. In 1919, after the expiration of the ten year period, the company filed a new schedule with the Public Utilities Commission, fixing- a rate of 40 cents with a 50 cent minimum charge. In January, 1920, New Boston passed an ordinance fixing a minimum charge of 30 cents per thousand cubic feet.
An appeal was filed by the Gas Company and the Utilities Commission found that the rate fixed by the ordinance was unjust and unreasonable. The Commission established a 40 cent rate with 50 cents as a minimum charge. To reverse this finding of the Commission, a proceeding in error was prosecuted. In affirming the judgment of the Commission, the Supreme Court, Wanamaker and Allen dissenting, held:
1. Under 3982, 3983 GC., empowering city councils to regulate the price of gas, and providing for minimum, hot to be reduced in ten-year period, neither the city nor the utility has any authority to contract as to the price of gas for a longer period than ten years.
2. Since neither city nor utility may contract for the price of gas for a longer term than ten years, a municipality cannot, by providing in its franchise ordinance that the rate is to be subject to the provisions of the statutes, deprive the Public Utilities Commission of jurisdiction to hear an appeal by the Utility from an ordinance fixing rates, noty^fc-standing that 514-44 GC. was enacted after adoj^R of the ordinance.