Court Opinion

ID: 4033524
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-14 15:03:07.583426+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:29:32.351209
License: Public Domain

Cite as 2016 Ark. App. 394

                 ARKANSAS COURT OF APPEALS
                                        DIVISION II
                                      No. CR-15-577

                                                  Opinion Delivered   September 14, 2016

   MICHAEL HUNTER                        APPEAL FROM THE COLUMBIA
                               APPELLANT COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT
                                         [NO. CR-13-60]
   V.
                                                  HONORABLE DAVID W. TALLEY,
   STATE OF ARKANSAS                              JR., JUDGE
                                 APPELLEE
                                                  REMANDED TO SETTLE AND
                                                  SUPPLEMENT   THE   RECORD;
                                                  REBRIEFING ORDERED

                           BRANDON J. HARRISON, Judge

        Michael Hunter appeals his conviction for engaging in a continuing criminal

enterprise following a bench trial in the Columbia County Circuit Court. On appeal he

argues that the State failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he engaged in a

continuing criminal enterprise and that the circuit court abused its discretion during the

sentencing phase of the trial. We cannot reach the merits of his appeal because the record

doesn’t comply with Arkansas Supreme Court Administrative Order No. 4(a) (2015). We

therefore remand the case to the circuit court to settle and supplement the record; and we

order Hunter to file a substituted brief after a supplemental record has been filed.

        The record now before us has several compact discs. One CD contains State’s

Exhibits 5 and 9, which are recorded telephone calls. A separate CD is labeled State’s

Exhibit 6 and State’s Exhibit 8, but that CD is blank, meaning it contains no information.

                                              1
                                 Cite as 2016 Ark. App. 394

In late January 2016, a third CD was filed as a supplement to the record. The third CD

contains a usable reproduction of State’s Exhibit 6.         But it doesn’t contain a usable

reproduction of State’s Exhibit 8. On remand, the record needs to be supplemented with

a usable reproduction of State’s Exhibit 8.

       Moving past the CD issue, the record also lacks a verbatim transcript of the audio

component of the State’s Exhibits 5, 6, 8 and 9. So the record currently before us doesn’t

comply with Arkansas Supreme Court Administrative Order No. 4(a), which provides that

       [u]nless waived on the record by the parties, it shall be the duty of any circuit
       court to require that a verbatim record be made of all proceedings, including
       any communications between the court and one or more members of the
       jury, pertaining to any contested matter before the court or the jury.

Because the record as it now sits contains neither a verbatim transcript of recorded material

played during trial, nor a waiver, we must remand the case to the circuit court so it may

settle the record and direct the court reporter to transcribe all recordings that were played

during Hunter’s trial.

       The record must be supplemented within 30 days of this order’s date and, after the

supplemental record has been filed, Hunter must file a substituted brief that complies with

our abstracting and addendum requirements within 15 days after the supplemental record

has been prepared and filed with this court’s clerk. See Ark. Sup. Ct. R. 4-2(a)(5), (8)(b)(3).

The State should then, if it chooses to respond to Hunter’s substituted brief, file an appellee’s

substituted brief within 15 days of the filing of Hunter’s brief.

       Remanded to settle and supplement the record; rebriefing ordered.

       GLOVER and VAUGHT, JJ., agree.
       Terrence Cain, for appellant.
       Leslie Rutledge, Att’y Gen., by: Evelyn D. Gomez, Ass’t Att’y Gen., for appellee.
                                               2