Court Opinion

ID: 4057478
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:38:06.473374+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:12.516601
License: Public Domain

SU( \ ‘U *O’,UZ/Oz

CQUSE. \'\ O.S_.\`?§CR*\“\S.\ \'zC,R~\'~l,(,`\?_LR-\¢_\-\

E>u{?"'\° O\_-_-

vs ¥¢\ous‘ron coun“v\£,'r\ims
' "t'\-u=_ STQTE. 0\=*1'5><¢\$

_ c m Rl§_CEn/ED:N
cwle cqn‘r '_s Q.ei\;aw~:on Tc_’ “\'\4@ SQrf-?BC'N§~NA§APPEALS
\'~`OR\,QRP\\>'I_HG 0\=" v\F>\\° \=' L'I. <‘_<=\O`T `$ '\\,,`C)`1 NU‘vDU§"?W-§
'v,c ,c m .

Abe!AcOS?a.Clefk
T(> `\'\-‘\E \~\0¥10~0_<=.\3\.\€ Tu\§GE 0\: SA'J:D t;c>ua'r ‘, `

Y\o\,`.> comes ¥Aq>`,\_§ c.r-\n‘\- Ro:.\e,n_(c.\< CR€FH_’; gas \`>“"`°‘ '5€,\>1-\ w'f-\\."
O'F ob$é_c_N-'\ oh ~\-c>.-\-\»\e Oc~\`»c>‘s€fz 2'1) ‘.¢L'Z>\Sa Fg>vz.wf-wrz.e§\v\g c>F Q§>Q\-~`enn&-£
\\.c>"l vo-R'\\- o\= \-\cq‘\c>ens sz`;>u s‘g undefa -*Awe nbcwa wa{\- humbe»!z
“ S -\~\-\<=~AQ weis swy_a \\‘4, \-\o.» CT@_,¢ crum nw mqu ~Tw=»\~ \,~e\-¢=.s
T=\LL-€,jed \=a¢.+s '\,¢\~\'Q\»-\ \'\: -¥\-¢.\,\e. wound ev\&~\`Y\-\'-»~e app\..~'<_av\~\~' '\'O
Re\..\`e\`-' uv~.Ae_¢L cause num\oea$ \'L'cQ-\H§, \7_€_&-\'-1(> F\v\c\‘lC-"~‘
1'~\"| “\~b Suppon-\~ ’\"`\PPL" C~F§n+‘$ mu‘\-\i \>\_€ \’~'t\_\. ega-\~\o'~r\.$_ <;ov\$\'s\'\v~¢g
0\-7 g `

C\\ \'** ‘A'°’-v\"“*\~ c,F e\:\:`e<,&`rve -1=\$.$‘\ s-‘r¢av-<.e o\=' -t. ouns&L oh K:\P\>eq\_
due'\'b GprLLq'\-e couns&\.‘s _\=Ri\_\,m`e ~\-L~> t_\~quLev\c_»,@ 4,\..`€ \_Q¢M_`ri_ 'F-
‘°*"~)"\""`*L Su‘:‘:l`w`&n¢»\ o\=' ~\~\»we evié\ev~.<.@ \=¢~.¢\ Q\.so \§~. KQ%@QC)\S .\‘c,
\’-`\ \..ec_v\QL 1=\~¢~.@\ \:Qc~¥uq\_ _<;'L,`F\-`~cc_\'ev\cg,\ c\.“ +\,\e evx'e_\e`nge_ oh _“_`e '\A__
e_/~A+\' \=§c¢=;>riov\ Q'F c=\?p\_< Qr_m.qr gs on\‘_hcd M_`c ?Qnsoh who Comm_'
\ \+eck ‘\~\f\"\ s caime.

RL_\'\'\>PS\.\ pho+b<'§rznp‘\~.s, F¢=\{Lun§e -¥v obj'.~¢c&- ~\-1> -\-\~e +eS-\-\'mor~. ¢»F
YDR. S-\~GS\'\ sand \q \:Tm`\\..ufle -\»»b \`-"\\- a \=\ m<>"\-\'C`r'~ F~b& FW\ \\?\ S~\-\zL,\c\-e¢\
vefzdn' c\'~,
. IL’.
Th¢ S)¢me has c@mha\\-\-e<§ n @Q~eas'\"* °’\:
E_~y\,,¢m\~e zones '34,`\ Su”s<&`c.,°¥e~¢q@\; \\Q~

hans Crm_‘\>u_<, cans S\,\mw~.qa£\-\‘\ °\@""§QC\ \°\*\ *\"e *n{q\" cb\"@" "“" w-
R;\A`QN_,‘ oaé`e_a .¥\,`¢.;,x. wanda no ae¢i%~a¥\‘ow~. ei&~\-\e

q -\\nn* ch\es
w-F\S"`m+'-'\n'\ \:e$~\-L.\,\"

ew-¥'\-\-L.ee\ -\-o no ReL\'e\In on -.&\nn,~\- 4b1 e F&pp\_\`u=x»
'\~i O"`\ wG.S \:\'L`\\zb\.ou$ C§\A’ Gq_\

'\'~t> X-\r\e \L@_¢orzé h° \Zind\~:\pL\' cadwa 95 F¥L`\\l Qsz\-\S . Bec¢:\
Q§ »ne»"v nev e'¢¢~¢L_e_\'\-\»~._e_r>_. +\»\Q\~ +\»~.e -\\1€@\._ cb\,\a

")`o\~.es 'App\_{¢q+im\ was <;ehi
'\~\"\'G'\' ‘F\'n€.\\;r\

§ `\'\-\e &Q§@L c,c)\..\rz+ r=¢Ls'o_ »ge,v~..‘\-erae¢\ \v~.'~

5 V`\ 1>`\` $L\v~r~\r~r~.qr;'\\_'\,\
MS@ ~\»\'\& RQQM'Lou$ on \=\L~'\»e».t'u~.¢=a~\'\\¢e\.\,\1

FQ<'.'§~ F\¢"\c\ L<:\v~d \A>€\'L-Q
mem¢ar~..“n _

"c\ev\§nLS w\j\
oL,`\c\ be LQbQLeC\ ¢\i

‘ Ae~¥eaw~\u`~.e wbe~\\»\er< n subsequen%~ Lo "€~
\$ b‘HfZ¢fze@[ 19\1 § L\» Q <$1

~ \ - \ . '
_ n .. $P‘BS"\’\'~>_.'*‘~» \S \"LeLG+-Q¢A '\-4\> 4\¢.~.€! Me.'?_{~§-s \'\'~` \~\-
<=\e.¢\'e\es +\~e -~QQ\`\-s en make g \=. de_+e¢¢m,`,`g.\\‘¢r~. -»\.~m +\n¢ -.Q\-¢'\_
`\'S _"’c_l\'\"e QPPL‘<~*‘*`~‘\`$ cL¢n'r~.~‘g cain neverz \=e dec\'clcc\,

*\~b ‘r\»~.e bis-kr?_.(<_+ CO-

h>vm v=. Fmd.h§£ o\+ \:1=.¢4$ n“d<¢hd_h-'

»Q\ERTI\~`IC¢\TE O\: SER\LJ;LL»;
';Y_`Q\>FL`&c_Qv-\& P~oc\ev`ic_\

< C’.rz.e~\q% Sr;_) s-\-Q\~<: .ar-\¢\ '~/GR\»\ ~\-1~<=.\~\~¥~.§
'\:O‘\'L¢%o‘\`v\ca \[.S '\'nL»\€ G§r~\'¢§ tea

me<.&~ QV\A F\’-' 'P~'e-rz`\'\.~a\,\.

` cz\

\E)'b\‘=‘_rm. c.\<. c.S?_z_l
Rb~;\_ef\¢_"l`e\,q$ "\Q\Q>O\

C"~a\