Court Opinion

ID: 4075244
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 05:54:08.879162+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:24.631910
License: Public Domain

§ \ 5 ' ' ‘ '=O`B.CM q
YNQ'C® C@ \§~\”`s~ S\G\S %O‘ Bq/Z 1 .

`\"\‘\.L»/\ \'\Qf`ru._ '\S S‘F\f~nm‘&& LQ¢:`BC§J j(`~ eo\s Cbro\>$ C<_` §§ ‘AO\LQ°'§ ~~‘Qc`\) 'L.' §§"\§c\'?` 3

3\'\\€§\ `\ Q\\GA LQ\\\\ \\<\L AO-\\.\ _3'\.-3\§»\(\\ B\SM‘\L}§ Ci\E€r CZEE 6§§1§?» QP»Q;§
…\\r~\¢v\ Coua\'\\,> CQ<"~<\'ls v ' 13

W'€\__\, `\)("\`\§ -
on pb€_CQ\-r\\:&r \\ :AQ\.Y § QLe&.§ [s>\)`<=\$ 0€3€./ 3¢<&<3 D!;Cc.x~/\ber{'\.\/S©\S 6~¢3@/\¢@53&
\\»_ C_»\~@r\(` Xc> A\` ‘\Q) `\\\1_§‘1\£&$ COB-‘<`\ QG C<\m\h¢\\
‘AQQ@,N 4 <\Ar\\ ‘€¥\s)w X\\o__§€>m> fp\)r ` ’ \ s - _s b\l
N>\\m<\¥ c<- \Q~`\\vcm» €3¢' ’v\w` 5°»@%~\ 3st (\o\ &’d»>\»\‘¥
GC\.¢` N~¢;P\\M$ W O~\\€.<\ ~A-\u‘.r\$ ‘\\’\m\»> v~'\¢~\u \o»`c@;~@ '\<`\Je_ bQU\\)Sq-¢ \\Q)~\

`.Q `\\¢\x$’ 3>€_§§.¢__§&£._`_&@®3~® Y\D;`Y\§\A'K\<\ `\\’\S`

‘AoQQc;\ C¢z»\-\c\.s X\\A\ `X__ 3\3 303 3\ \»_3&<\\ ~\\\ C.\\Q\\szn<\e MC~<\FA €`<3>\,3\ \\(w.
.\\_n

SXA\£L5 (\\\za\@\\w\$ \~;\v\c.\\\s \..)r\\¢, \lw\ \»3<\'\<\¢_ w a `°v€$

G`\>t)\m '\v_a S\m_»\.s § 3',\3` IN)X \r\A\/e 9 OWSLL 3d \”;L.>'w\\. m\¢\\_s\\§m_%-N\\¢) F<@\§Qr\§‘ gov

ngu€§\§\r\§ <§ Q.:\j\~\ 303 QA`\\' §\/'\3¢1¢~<\3§¢~.;,"\ § 'beCA\JS"¢: '\~\\ s 3\\\»_ a‘r\\~$ \AA‘\@ "\D
§§,3;1.<». §§ -_\\_Q` g §e£oré; \\\g§ ~m.: §\\ea;\,<\¥\ec\z me \~<\)\)¢\§ C>r\g_

`§_‘(_\QRQ-¢>`L&`we f\$$t\f>'\€\¢\cs:)J C>Q GDW\>_Q‘\\ “\21‘>€ ¥G\\\jr~c3 XC> "\c\‘\""l>cm ma ec ~\Y\>` 53:€~\§\€$ g
wear ib\u~ G£€Qf '\S Cc>§\f\'\z\f§\>\& c-»3 Cz:>'\/\'§, m3 NW¢»_ \»esm *FA!\s
\00\ Q\IU’\\OQ \5 on 3>1:\\¢\ m\\> 53&\@~ ~\\\M \30 \'\f\\/Q g op/Q_\¢\c. AQDQ<’»\ \,.` N\o`\\{\ar
C\mc\ \\\a_ AA\\N;{\QA. C>€rw`m'1\\~».‘4\\;. e §§ w ?\ \'\.C _ …'
N>»\ 5\)£6€,5$`\\;¢ `Y\\`-\S qxfo~)& @ w§`:\€ brwe,é \@\Q<,\'_ `\3 -\\\Q~ 53<\\3 Cw(\) b~QC/~rus*
\\ m \/A\`\3 (\<\3 \)c\ Q>L\\\ X web carver \;3\3,_ c-,Q \\r\s Q\Qa C»<~Q‘<>_r C\~\3 3\\{~\\1 »C»~c\\hJ

\,Jer< wr_\ C)r\&\\Q/\<.>& »

 

 

 

 

 

 

M 13:73,® @3®_ ' *Y\M '35

 

7a ~ 5 fn f Ar~§ C>r\c\\>$'\ ms 33\\7<\33 Ar¢ v\.s\; §\)334<;3@,~3 333 @Cc\_\/Q
m~\ C?\=i\\r~c\§ l§'\d\wwo\\\r\ X\\A`\ mg be d\\¢~ €Nc. 06 ?(`\5% f 7 . ` ` ~
K\)zn`b<\c§v\'\<\§. 1\ \5 C`\QW ~\\¢\§ \\~1 53;£3<= has -\C`\e,§ 330 JL»\\~Q\~“\\~L \>wr§rm
§§ @g~gd§~, 1 (\53£¥ mg §353€(\@\ 33§\\¢»§ do “N"\\§\§ r~=. 63 '\'\¢\». g L.\~ez.r£lg§. 633+?.,
m,jc"\cs\ \>_>ré@.~’\.s \‘ts gave -\\3¢93 337er mm m ?\u. \)Ar%\n\¢\ 03 33¢~ 63 52 L,gmr.r
1333 ~\'\/\¢ S\M.._\) %> <\¢\'§ "-\\\\’ a\)o>`\;\ \~\)~_,> 4\\\\.3;\.;> §3'3’3§-'&\/§\3\7. 5.€<0¢\'§
3\._ U>'Ac`\; 33 §33¢9`\<3§@3.; 30 331 53 351qu .1\\\¢1.` 3 s\,&n; mm X\AL "§
\Dg 89 505'33331 v£ 33§‘53§"3£5 B’ key s€€er 'X wb\n\) \\3\\/@ (AC,L€Q¥°.L'\N wm
G‘_QQ>§FQL 5§ §§539§ \\\1_9@ mm md A\\ze\~¢n\mc\)‘ 33\-3.@.3¢_ Pn(¢>` §`SC\§ 13 $1,.>0\
jjsdw$ lhwva $AQX-S \»`3`"\\\ ~<\\\ 3m 133st €35<' a QV\;\Q.¢\\\AN 3\:\,` ‘\(WG
cw{¥ 313 \e;\\w\»w§ 33 33\~¢; ~<\\>man '3 QAQM~
'\\\»` we Q_\,A'\N\$ 1 ora\/`\w x\m 'b(ol>€ `\\\A\. A'\¥x\\ r`f\@\¥o_\(\n. O€€€.? 13 `r~am~
"§39§ 3> \,~¢3@:,<;3\»§ 5a ;Xoyg. §§`d \§ C`e.cocl 1\.11\\ waer ¥i¢\§. W_@rLs ~\\'\a\ 5&\3
‘ Sd@c\e`r$ 33ch G€~€n;;`\\-\§ \5 3r'\\. 01 ms (~301
QA<\ M`\\ee,@nw€¢\_?}n.n\§ 35 cm\ mh @\/r>en LC/nrd ©(o\ie. gamme
C\A`\~\S RALYMAS. \\U\,J€)Jer \MMMM § 15 316 `\\\\ N\L§ (3¢\\6€11:~)»,
-\o oeu\)e_ ‘~\\\ 33\¢~=\ $\S=<\e,\N\S \D 13 \> j`m\o\ No§\)c.¢§\§fe_wré 351 SM\_§`N 1 m€ rand
3533 §§ 33\)3¢3 M…QA£J/A\ >\»A§e, \JA\~\er~ 5¢~¢\'¢\\'\ SXA\Q.P \7\ k\s Gc>v\\n(\(\oe€i\a

@£W_EBMM_[MA\ `\)U QS\L\N\US\_ `\\\\ 5 C"\`A_\~d ’{\QA\\:\Qr '\\\\9~

5339¢\& \_\c`\\>ew Cv\)c\ ar \\\k`§e»\Z sr 533%\~€§ mg 33@ w\wd\<\.o.c c>€ mm 33\~7 3 uecrs€@ mw i\J€#~ &)m~r\\)(\\(yd'€§
` " *" :\‘-“‘ belinsz \\3_ ¥~\.QZ\?\N;\RS 33\'\'§\ \NPA€,~ A.J\ (’;>e,rca ve 333~€&/;3§'39§ §§rm hoc §§\/3§ m3 5, r§\ swl R/\

ma ‘§Rcs\ \..N\\ hawk 1 §\>, m3 @075 sess 333\3:\ ‘<\w-M\<_;h@ L)<\X`\\ w

Cw amd \\ 1 \\¢\> \\n \l\m\..s\ndap cr Cc»r\\co\ 03 ~33\\&\ "Y\\n Co)~?A \(\(\§\3 A`-\ n \\m<\m 33~¢\1 bd \\LLC~N>\Q\;\ 33\\<::¢ Q\/~<>£\s

§5\ 5 535 Q\gc;o__l<\$\ QS~>, 337 m\M 1331 33\\` S\<\\Qs Coc\c\\)§m;\$»W€\&
MMAWRMA&§LMG§ C\\¢\Y¢,~es <;r\§. £€LerQ \r\w:' m '

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

, \\v xiv @mb\x`\>\< c¢x\is@ m\> a Cm~
\i\ Lx\o<\.\<\x<\\, mo _Y\\A 5 6"\(0\/<\`§. \ 5 C¢>o\r\\'x&\&,_

_ Gi-cciu&,"_\\FeQ. .
i`¢\>~> A\Xb'e \\¢;»:> m\~:) \\S\QQ '\\\ \Qf ixij &CL\)Z\'\<\S/\~ \"\sxi
x\\¢x“\; mix x Sx<: imrx\“u ix ixz,\)a¢x\x €xf xiii sx§.xL '\~L\p; w -x`-`\mm
' ‘ ` " §0 \»\\~ Q`C>r C`\_r\r`\$x\,/\rx »?M§ \L\i

;@3\¢$\5\§\ 3va ~ §§ w-c~A \5- (m¢$'r\iz&\olo -

C‘>‘(D\)-c\§, ¢b\i\r
'“\\\Q. stx\~€ L\~ixi,ms ~\x\(x\, § \~,_i/xi\x<§ mix> \ix\i\,§ir xii fe@\>eix, ix mm \c"\$\`\~.

   

p\\r\,sx\ `\ s wax x~\x.; ‘A'(C`\_J\)‘m/\\~ 'Y_i\e£x’xa\'\\)x i'~\$£ `1 $\(x~r\c»` %Q~ Cou»n,Se/"\ §"Q\f €A"\'\?\ m
‘\‘n Q`h\\°~ £\r\§\ \"§\5\€\\¢\ GL fx)\\r\c:` bn \\ \'Nd\:\ 05 %x\(` § Y\Q'.\»o “\(`\5\\ \5 m\; K{£Bxd'n\p¢:‘-\ \
"\\M_ mcix\w\ xo( ix m x<`\x\ ‘\5 x\\k \A.;x ix¢~> Qr\\`_} c..\;\x»\cx ~\-¢ mesaer error
¥»c Y¢L\jvcw ~<\ ix

 

~ ~ ` " ‘Xd.., \\\ed “;,'\1 Y\S\ TQQ(`GBM'\
m Q£\Qeck\\lc\x \A>Q.& Oi\ §°¥(\L,x~.\i'x'\\» ‘£\¢.\l GI`OE\\C- S'¥A:\SNSS - gin AV\\-“~ \) §

juocw C@`)c\ 'x\\.¢, \Qims Cox\~ L`R (r`\m\mx\ anpQ¢A\s
£;Mc_x_hixx@_mihlj\gwn Aa ix\\nrm\ x’»\ix\\s xv ‘?'\x\, 5\i4\\ \A m¢A`\ on Qm~

 

     

 

AiQ,§ ;~‘L
§<>_i"c<(\dix¢\\ \> x\\se,~(\x fau<\.$e\ Av€\€(¢,é, 5a X\\'\s %{ n`\)n> `\`S CD@A\ZAMMHQQ
ex ch.;ier\,'\c\¢¢, Q(r¢>r inv ixoc>e¢x ix<<>_ -x x<\ix\ \..i\i\ws\` w<\%ex§r 50 Covm'¢\ ‘§'\`\§\\\A'PALR ;`x\\ax<\\i~ \.\li\) ` \’A~ \3 \3 S&i\'\r\r\\“<. go §§
" " \\9\°\‘¢§~3
gm ij\.\x A>'?a;\

` \».>\QYW\.¢: xii\` \
ix w\\s v\\\Q;`¥;(TBH‘\