Court Opinion

ID: 4071022
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 01:42:46.035596+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:34:28.643991
License: Public Domain

--.       -                          -            -;.~-

    .   .
              ,
            ''1        "
                            IN .TW E C.tJlJRT DE.. .                                                   !El_3_rz5-QfL

-
                                         CJffi1I~~i~·EPfi-i!.~                                           I   .

                                           ;Qf1ffi~Et1 ~fJ!l-_~I
                                                                ~CLfl__(J__
                                                                                                   ,
-                           UJtDN-rtf/'R     J£L7JJIII2U~
                            ___l__ lPf LL ].__ --~- _. ~- -'~lf[
                             AO\JD T E                          ~S~J                  IJ t.Rimi                  ·
                             DTIT~'1lr~%-=&_Il-fEXfi·~
                            .-r~ t:FE ~CJ . _ I\ , _ .
                                 '

                      I                  2EIIllll?Sl ID[J]J[LLDE
                  f                        IT1l±hl_D f1_L1LU_~ ·
                  l
                             _ EC_o_V-\f-\~~-am_e___li/_D_,_L ff- /9 S 2 ~-11/JL D ·
                                   ~ . 3Da..!±3:1 fllVD 30~ta9 t .                ~

                                                                                     ~__:__Pro-s. e... !Z~_'B±oJ:- 1 -
                  I                                                                        *-~t1_~d_te..~±
                                                                                         ~~KBO~Cn-, =l
                                                                                         J.e...:e. trsoN u1J!_JJS:t..
                                                                                           ~030 ;J.~_{g!]_:§aJ&_
                                                       eN-~gJ~                            b.e..&llM-0~ 9lj~7_]) (J_~
                                               R'E.(; \ ~~\.. ~?fEf._\..S
                                              V{t-Gr-cB\~~\
                                           cao '                 .-
                                                        1 '\ 41::1\~          .
                  i                                  ~c.    -
                                                                ... r'.\e{\\
                                                    ~~\ P,.Cfl~tf.~,   ..,
                                                   ~u'I(J

                  ·I
                  H
II
 ---t+·      fksp_od_d~ Cnu,J?J ~JJJ::f_tct~tlli.LA~_._~ &ALLL~-
         6s'#.Mcl c_t_;_~; N& _D_;,;,h_l ~Co__ul'_+_l:_J_e_~eY'~o,J
                  Y
 ~--++to_,Jlll 1 TQ$.~&-iu~W-&.-±_Lo_o_l-P-e.-~~l ~t7--­
---HJle~u-IAA[}A)_~-I.-e_t-~-..S-7-2-7-0-t-'---------
---!-+---------+-~----.· .    -     uz
        a_        ~ 1-            r-~l:H ____   c_   _

            '
            I
            I

        1

        '
            I.

            !!
               --             -=----
·J
                    --~- ~-

          --
     &_
      L!f-
 I f-,__
  d-11
  '&t-
   b_
 l£

     ll
            ~~-
            !s,~
            ~-
     ~-)-

            e-L-
            lt!V
--          ~
                us
                Me:_

                                                                      -   --       -----
            lse.~. i:Lf.£ 1J 2.. /_r;_ .. ltl!f..;v..s;lori-..-1:Ho...J t:f_ad._-e.... _tt,
                                                                                     7
            !CJA.SS~~-m,~r rvteti.NO 'j
            GJ_fJl_b ·ev ~Je •vee_):~w~-~~ "'; ~;
-~j.             B_;_0_cL.E'>!,..~_H,,J_f- LLeL-to_ _t~rve- ~u
            ~~ 1-r~.tt\s_kUlo-\:l.B.MS           for      App.~l3                             -

            l          .                    -s-
            l
                                         --                                --   --

         ~)i ~-;-~-W;--M~ doQ.u~ _tere                           oSu;-1,-as_e. -k h~
                      -'-~ 1_~MLruLe..d o~        11\J   1-4_e..,_OL~£J', ~£~}j-ff1~~
               te.l~-~i_LV_J1..S_pt e-S e '1.1 t-M__ji/1) L-Ql~~-el ,.-s_7_ft u:e-J 0 -;J
           . flc-S_~-CL~fl:_fJt;_r_ -h /~l_lJ _~vi ~j -~ ·
         ~-)~ . Pre +ri~Lh~Q.&j_A)_c)f Jtded t)~_-L WzfS                            . _
              kvMO~o.J1 &e_&Jf-()_u_L!tt-wfe.r m!ide .sure.                      d/JHX:
                ~-tAl &Jv,..f-roCJ~_1Je.>~-dc,JSfL.] - req.ueJk.J.,;_JutlJ:'--
                L _( ~-~t;z-u_f:._f<--~l=__l_t1!1_ff!~S d___~~-MtLl'l,_-$.~&led~-
                 kw.Lt~- z-e.5-tL~ M"""tle~/fa,J fD~_jJlLdiy~--
                l[cve 7--~~ _             ~e_e._d:_wLii_/:ie__Sbtie_h e_4Ii:l
                ltrt:LJ~ +o re e&Le_ruL tJ.-J f! £_8oNCf;__w--.h.erL_
                                J
                  L _~s/.±:._1 )~Ll 7__ AtJ..d . & t1 ') LLk ~ ,L_la e....~_s ~*-t~~"-
                I~ 'N t.e__ _bfrve_ J'W_o..ft-..:e.c Mis.c£.erl'.IM2;!{;N0 _. ~L___
                !·   e.l_o-v f-i!t,J J_fif:-w~f.e-~6olftf~o~u_c...b,-----;h~d_
                  'tlll±-Lmi~;;_cLe-. ,/tJ, X M - ~~ -fyj-e o'P- ~~
                 llsJ:c-V;!!ftj         .j£ t&
I

                            1
                              +::
                                    ~(_S__ •~ 1 .
                                c

    _3],                 ~ '?J!eri_/ltDtt~.-._)J :iP :J6ow -/i'(j_~N(),-
                                              r          -         -   .         '

                  ~~"'~cziaAl5._t(:re-_L!c¥-<£L_Zift-LtLe,_tb{e. /'e.5 u~._.L _
                   k£=s_~ver&l-ht~t~ckt-e_d.._-.£l:?L!l~NL~__;;/ ctJ~-e~'-e_lle____
                   6Dur+- 4t= ()r..;""-;_"-'!!t-Lfl;fe¢fs_.s_~_/JAc1;.dl'tf!~ _
                 !Se~ f_eAJI'... e.::, ts if~l't'-7 ltN d_u&~N.s_/:i.'/o./ltYrJ±:-0'--A~L-
                 c!tt10 L.b_e--_us~_:_JAS_eda~~~ !_i_~
                . h~s__bee;J        o~c..~- us~·
                                                                                     d+
                 .        _               ~. V77 L ,         ·

                l             P~k£~:.:~f~~tft~~~&_rj_~
    ==-u l  I     kr~JJ-Pf      QSit   -~'"-- ~o__~LuJ--ANt -ffl_(.JffiLf-:h~f?-~
                · _f.-._~~Q..,_t)_ _ t-rL&-_l_Ja_efj,.e_ eV'eN ~iJefLCJ;_

                 llo v- tu! i""cr--o ;J ±leS_L__fYrn±.Lailid_whLu0.-_cle~~-
     .          H
                ,,                            -~-
                1'1
 \

I

          {

 Lktl -       r {!]__ :___
_5?:/:/.)~ {k2 (_

~&/e-i:
          _]Kif-£:_
~~~             eu_
f~tL
 ~ . u;Jd
     (_
    -----·          I     .       --             --; - - ·   -       -.--
    i
                . /;e&_ m;~s_httt:i:--
    _
                l      cl:               (
                I eVd;_~~ /!Jo_r ,.S- rM.I
        _G}J_jc-._u1_ etJ_af£,_rc_e_r S                                  ·
                ll h~-L~~ed__-titt=f::__
                    ib__o_4 __t'. u'f.l>_e__CJ!t u
                                       ri?S-L~-                  1

                · iUO_OOle_              W&S_&tQU
                II ~metJ5;;-_p-tc:/;e_J__m
                   b __eJL~l{_-6~ foo
                  PLes_eLtLf--_ BV&d
    -~            1    {!_e.lai:P r- /1-_(c[)_j-ett
                . 'rf2vJv,_( J!'t~ ilLMALJ
                                         _____ii_~hbtt .
I

    -           I       _(Q f±.S_()JI-
                1¢t-LU~_JgJJfeN                         j__e-_~Col
               -- Q_(d__M~A.9_t&l!)j_ktu:
                 ·h~-lQJoV-l.c:L_k~-ILe--_b_
                I~ v er I O_Q__y£& l'ds_-/:k _
                i _0 v- ~-~-t ~-bl-_'0_~ .
                    1                        -

                11            .          .                           ~
                ll
             l'-          --~--                 -                           I   ---"P'77.   E2 'P"          ----:-   ..,.     .

-
       \ -
    I;;)_,   I.
             j
                     cg e_d .. i- I .b p_e,J
                    .._P-e ~-)~-L ·                          ~led
                                                      .cli . rd._. c'V<:r.
                                             _fjj__ -f:t- -PfrlJ---
                                                                                                     -~   //_   "Cff, Li/.-
                                                                                                     LL~(_L!!_()_~~-
     .       ~~~-h;_'(l_~£ d~~~~ Mb~l otJS ti-d:t~NJ~~-~~
             l               ·          ~~~n:flit~n4~,                                          .

                 ub&~ -- +lte. S_-&m_;f;;Lb&:Lr:P~~,~-t:t_-
                 kr-- .· _ ; d-:t!:!'.e-e~fotf_LU}/,_;_c _ ~-c-b¢-IL L.,_d_oAI_e~
                      '9f:-&cf- ;_cJ 1[__-k£.+.@
                  )J/_D_fjf#v-
     ~~     r!Jl7eJLLd£S_J~_ecL . __ Dve.r 3-cLj~~"-s al~
        I ~-l,S_, __a_ce~:fL_-tz2 be..- ~ /;.        ·
    3)                                 eft.h...ANcem _ ce. ~ t/S ~
                          Th- e.. __J&.loov<-       1/15.!i
                   ~d1_1; -f;;~ JL~.r&. I~ A/0 zdv.st'vc Wr!£.
i    ~            MUS       39.::4:1.0.)__1    ?h_                       .
    ±                   Zl_~ frlor-S ck;J+- ft:·~_cyve; Is p/or ;r"o d-e..

-
             I_
                7              f;vs
                   ofk.€.r5 ;~-_&QY ti:Lr:st-e     e7 &lul'f;_kiL_dr
     . ~ktiD-~l ?Z 1-f:--(Lf!_-- -ftl~.J-e;?-M_teF .,_ 2l:.s:_J~-€S-
         · 1\-Vaf- N5V.Iu-k tr.A.J eM 6;iV.Cf:!?1.81lf UJuA/~~
       l    WQJtfz~~~~ure___ ·Jrv ~b_ehA-ff;_C!AJJSe_
    ~J j~JE!~~ ~J~- ~t±1t;j-:Ji&~ .L-f~ tJ~ ~:nu~
       .11~ m.~JcLe.IM...e/J:d.ar:. f;,_~'S.fl:rt&_GJALL'4i~ ,JT ..b.eeLU_
                     r

             "11                                      .       ~   J_Q   ~
             ll                                           --- -
    c;_   Y1       ~({Jfs C!-r IrYLL:V~
            fEe~r&;J:~
           I ce't-1&5/L J:iza
           JS_e_e__~eh-'t LtS
               ~-11:/Y~~
           !5/Ne-e I~
            Miff_~ /J!itrfio
           . ~tne:s~ sf
           r;gLe__-fzo+LJ-. _._
   7)            6~~
           · ~~d_)Lf:_ _2-j:Jro
           ·~rt~s-L{L;A_r/'t:t_
               C1l'&Ld7GW~
                                          _____.

    0&
           ·
               I
               i
                      z  {) J
                                ..
                                I
                                            lrt
                                    CL/;d_J)_a_
               I&-&S~prJ:--
           l17f~-maS-e1ltdii
           !ls- f.lc)_fd~b~~
           1JZL- -;}:~~ewf6~
           lo.eaLf-e_L!)e ~-Vile
           l\#t.es_e_~_eJ_·_
      l~--f,;5_
         ~ \ ft.J(Jlt b-~-11
-~)-~ I~L--c&~N
      I;
      II
      l'~
       l'
                    ''tf!:W
                     _c_ -
                    JN
                   d .
                         ---

           i/-14v~& ~-
           ll
           (()V-e..L-·
           ll
l   ~ f~~r----------1
          •   ~   -   ..   j   -   ~            ~

      . LtJ.: D~f_- ~~d cLrtdl/AJ~I D~si?r~+ -c1u~f
         _ o(_;;;fe-ErersrJ,} ~u_N?J-7 ~

j I
};