Court Opinion

ID: 4041992
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:58:31.999264+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:29:24.369465
License: Public Domain

la-is-ooofeS-c*.
                                          FILED IN COURT OF APPEALS
                                           1gth Court of Appeals Distr ct
ERXC MMJlLDIN *fZ<*615k
TO'THE OFFXCE OF TWE CLERft                       MAR 1 2 2015

                                                 TYLER TEXAS
                                           CATHYS LUSK, CLERK
1 klA NMRXTXN&TD Y&L COGGER NXti&j CDULD Ms\t> WOULD
You PtEf^SE FXLE THX5 \NKVX OF t^AKNDKWVUS TD CdMPEL
\MRXT OF pEoHX&XTXOU XUV\ERENTTOTUE C5EDXEUCE
OF XT TO THE &RM4£>aufcX CONMvAXSSXO^RS ©FFXCE,
SMXTH COUNTY CDUfcT HDUSfc, M-SO~\C> TV\E £4\ST
DlSTRXCT COURT ROOM, \00 M- 5R0KP\Nf\Y; RootA ZOH
TYLER T£*AS,-T510Z
                     THKNft You

                                   •<•'

UAM COULD YOU PLEK3E NCTttfY NVt
 M" YOuR EKRLXEST CONVXENCE-

SxGNED ON Tttxs 2J|* DAY OF FEfcURkRY 2015

                           PRDSE^tZQ&lSb

                                  £RXC MfcULDxM
                                  POLU^ahY UHXT
                                  3§7Z FW\35C5duTh
                                  LXVXK&&T0K) fT^XAS,
                                  11351
£RIC MMJL-DxM*tt-Q075t
367Z fwv 350 South
LxvxMGSTOU.TEXAS/nSei

TOt
      SMXTH COUNTY DXSTRXCX CLERVS
       tOOKl.bROfeiDvJKY, Roow\zo^
      TYLE-^TEXAS, 15102.

                                fVlf, TflnuhLm
                               GfcXG NVKULXXNi* VW875L,
                        la-lS-ao© iiL'S-C^
A

                                        XNTUE 2H\ST1^5TRXCT
          vs.                           C6UR1 Of StCI^CouujTY
    TttE STATE OP TFX AS                TEXAS        F/Lt^r^QURT OF APPEALS
                                                             JL5fia2SteDjstrlct

    LutSC^XXEM^Y REVIEW J
    TV\XS XS **4 ORXGXUAL tv^XT OE **MggE
    TOCO^PE.XXK\V\E^k\T \MRXT OP 0^Ov\X BXTXO^
    TEX.CRXW\.5TA"^ -^R-T. &2.£, Wv\t\\ D^vSmDAnTv GrKVE
     NCrtXC^: Of ^Op^MTO^ COU'RT \SOw\Tv\E 3UD&fc>AeMT
    OP COKWie-UOM.XWc X)151 fcXCT COURT LG^T Tu" ^pCTlOVi,
    ^tsiD"Tv\t COURT XtA*ASX)1/^S\_X ^CGuX«.^t» 3u£Xt?m£TX Otsi
    &FTWE CA*^:.
    TV^ DiertRXO COu«.l ^COUl fc« XU*i<=t>XCX3 0^ 0*0( ToCAfcRT
    OoHTU^ w\^X5^EOfTUEC0uRl-\0bt^T^1^3x>OtEt«AEKVt 6C
    COSMICTXOWt A*»D «fcl**t»*C* v^.cj CMftXtD OUT", fc*10Tl* PO\*fcR
    T0155u^ A \NRXT OF PRo^XElTXo* -*/AS X^ttEQ^Hl XNTvttCOuSr
    To CEQuXftE Ofc^pxtsOicE TO xVS 3jDGK/tf.v,nS.
    T*xS PtTXTlOrsl^ ^KV^EyTRAORDJ^^^Y vdRXT* EX UAuS"l*ow OF
     SW^CeufcT ^EtAE^XeS uvaOvR Tv\E 0&*n\a ADiVvinxSTRA^xon*
    uTtt^ F&XR SEnaTE^CX(nJl& AcV'oF CONGEE SfraTHE Fu^PA^KnM
     fcvAEfcxCK^ concept, EClual ausuce umqeei lax ensv>sxm&
    ^Ju^-CXCE'' ApARlUXED^TrtE CLEM^CY PROSIT lo\\A^
    T*\E PLOoR SEE^T^S Ovte ^>^ ^       AND >3R Up ADD FURTHER
     UtrvM x^-iv\E *ci>£E ?LOOR OE&*~l£ OnAa*Y 2M^ jj^jg),
     REP DAM vAoRALE^ ExP\.Ax^v>t*fc PuRPoSbE OF SB Vj>4 A^Q
     SJJ« \b.*C>Y4 ART UtM A^D ART.UA^C^^U^PAtvAE^ALLY
     DE*ECT2fvE X^iDICT^AEK\<,DuE PROCESS 0? \.AW,
     XNiVOLUNTMLX GUXLTT PLEA XiA^PfE.C1XVE ASSXeTAMCfc OF
     COUNiS^L

                                   jte^*1
N,

     ^CDNlSTiRACY TO XMPtDE'3u5TXCL,'PRE'3UUlCE
     petXfeS.fr^e- TMDXFFERANCt PROt>ECUTORXAL VXMDICT-
     Xv€.Ni£SS VXOLATIONAS OF t\AX CpNSTXlUTX 0 N^X RXGHT5
     NAfc\ELT Tttf \£T U.T* 5^^H &? \y« fcftQH*" A.l\AiMDMfc^TS
     1MkGMA CAR"^ ANir>TWc.XLLEQAL UA&X^AL PARA^CM^S
     AMD EMHfx^CENAE^nS PROCEDuRP-S XUECAL tvMSCGtvlD-
     LjCT NRD FATAL, s/ARXANCE. V\i/VXVE Tv\E ANTITERRORISM
     EPPECTXvE T>F^VAPENALTX ACT (£1001*1 P* TIME A^~
     AL V.A,T.C.t\. P£* W&\ RKiSXMG MtwJ G-RCunPS'5*6'*
     Fatal *toRXM4C£ directed verdxct.
     ^£°2& U.S.C. S Z2 5U Ill'.Viftll CT CERTIORARI

      CuxuTt    Plea.

                                      PS*2.
                                 il
TO! THfc HONORABLE JUDGE CF SMD COURT \

NC-.m CO^EST^E M^fUCANT ERIC ^utr.TM XmTHJ A£fcV£g
STYLSX EWTXTitf) CAUSE NM*A&t&S> AND NfcwJ XS FxiiMtT^lS
£X?fcAO.ftXfeMkf@r Wfl&T Or fcAANT^AtvAUS TO COMPEL THE X55-
UAtsiCE OP A wiRXT OF PReHI&niON i^AXREwT O&EDIENC I
TO' XT 5 3 U L> & £ rv1'. 1 Ml 5   UHDE R

Tttf WPVtCKttt l« movvj &E*HG Cui;U^TLV SHCAfeC-tRA"! Wfc
AT T^f ALL%W & Pci.-^SKn U*XT 5'tTZ ?>\ 350 S«Ut* UvX*%-
SJtOH "TIVAE; 11261. Xllt&KLlA ^AXNS>f Wis \*XUL ON A
Ol»DGtv\rc>;v\T &? $£#rrtfHCi.,,iXF%%, NDi^ RlfeUEST^CTt^t
A Suftllft^LJBllfcg^JSfiMfrV 5WMX»SUE for Au. P.\*r
Preset At*D rvTuVE Docwt^lWTS to*D 94&Cfc£>Utt£& &% RRO-

               FACTS AND AuTHORXTxE.S iHSUfPO*!
             _CF Ta^L CA£ 5 KT SA&

TM1 IH^HCEWf hiT PA&A£ RAPHS fc*E XLU&AL I\i CAUSE tyQ ->
O0T-:^-;0s 0OT^t^m«0M Cf ••-i;',^;0,-i Cr^-J^R-d,', ;,,v

t&lfe • ^LtR^LAfeY OJFJ^ H^^t *ATSft»j |^feA l^frcft L^ ^ AC}X_Up
&«& iMAKtMt AftAS«bT C&*« tAt***0*4 V. ST*tfc &H*, S.W.
Z"{1 t& •- £4>«* C^T^l

                                                PC>*3
                                            £
IhV-K v. :H:Tj, ;CC;u Ux.^?- LtKlS X^DC AHC £*Hf A+PlXC-
AKT 1-1 kLGvLO'ImG am XHJDEPEHP&hiT tHVtJTf*$AT10ttTO
THC &R&Kt2 3tt^Y CCiAMXS-SXo^ERS X'UE TOThL FUH&AMi-
NTAllY 3WEFECTXSE XHDXCT*AE*lT5 P&X) THE COERCLX
CON* F t S&T014 & 014 tHE X K £ f F£ C1 x v E AS ST STANCE OF
COUNSEl &t WK COURT fl^PoiHTEti fri^WEl 0* THf COWS?-
1C AoP.S ^v INv^r/s. 3UVI3-CR tX*£ **Wfc PRETU t>Xtt$>%H*
^LVlKtG THE ?SC^.rcu1urXC*lXD*4 fcXTfcACDSWMtt vaRXTS.

THE PO^ERTDXSSUE A\MRXT OP PRDUX fcTTxGN IS XHttl^-
EMTlM P^M MVELLATl CC?wRT TO RESuxfcE. fcfcfcX>£|*4Cfc
TO TT's 3UDC-F k<\E^^.'.
THE TuRTSiX>XC"\XCN CF e^ APPELLATE COURT w^f M XT
Ok\CE ATTACKS CCNn~N\Utb UMTXLT^CA&i, AS >AWS £'(
THE APPEAL S5 CCnvPlRTELY ExECuTEu £Y THE COURT ^E-
lovnj amDxtam^y xss-ul!,all \mk1T::, t.rc rsi'-AR^. TO
n\m-:E fc?FfcCTXV£ "rr- 'D£CR£l.

                               ^|Pq*
                               lt>]
CI URS Sr^ C1 X0rv > C.0 URT OF Cfe I W\X MAI fcpp £al.S >
FM^ORCE 'JUlH^.:vtwti55ut. pROUX^lTxfcfc v^RXT.
TrfE TE> AS; COURT OF- CRI Ml isHp .u ^PPtALS AAb ** -\E AgrtH©RlTY
T* ffcOv*X£>lT T,'t 5U*Pt!4£XOt4 Of SBKTF.MCt ASTLR AffXfc -
MflkHtt OP TV.E 3WDG£*AEl«$ A'^X Xt'& V/JVCLT D- #ROKLfcIXxcL M UfcE V-.'-.cvJ
oi MiDxwTfuotD to a-xjcpt thi £c**sTftuCTxo»J placed «po*$
THE FEOEwAu SlKYUTfc 3* THfc *i£fc*M, rotifiT*. ]faAEfrMfltfr V
m^iScM IW -• ^ t«^ ^Ri 3'^'rE\ .3v./R. err, lLiC P. Zk«
KCo-ctrsoM V. 3Ta:\e IHX S.N/- 1 3*5 k$ TtX CR. R lid TME
FEfc&fcAL C&U&T Xt..CTSX0^5 "HEM SnCuLL %% K£fei FOllOvnO
Of'uESS THi- STA^u'ES OP T'Cl- ST ME ftCftuXfci. A CONTRARY
ComclU£IoM
[ftlStUnSOlJj ?\ fe'>\Al. E*^-SSIO*CV TyVt caMlCHCftWU. OF
r,M C.HXC1A.L TfOXV OR f> PUfcV&G A*>*>tHW* AXoFTCD 6* \ ^ f A-:> fr.
LEC-TSL^^^E *! RES&UaT+ON $U£ti M* &* vx'i hlR * ££*A*Mt
CkttfH Ok <:oMt.UWR?.r*T ^:i?u^-flN.TAV";^-,^f, Ut-U-VtY ItAfV
OYtDTO Xf .\tCVc*T*L ;vtc' Tilo^ D* r\ N\jT\XO^ TKt SUlCyKT fcWHWI Df
 \a*^."-C>\ \^c-L\LL HOT PftDVHti.^ COMr.TIl\.*L XSl.^iTE Oa<"-V\ ^S A
Nt&fc SxPfcLJSIOKt Or- ( PSHX6W , ;1TC . 5i*C 14 XS KfiH VMm ibitf fcfcfcR*
 EW fttPORWN XH WUio-H A I r.OX t L Atx vl fel AHCtt E>i kXS5t,5 AH
O'-imigm feM&t r?u^-,oc -E33 p. id ~? •-•:•' -715*

                                       P§*5
                                  a
TEX.COMSX ART .\V,% \\IK mp%\ OPTWE ADULT PROBA^XCtt M£
 *>AR&L*LA>J x^S E*ERC1SEA&\.E Bf -»* COURTS OP TEXAS WANiXMG
ORXGxMAL3URXSXaciXO^ OPCRl**XMAL ACTXONiS Ab ASvflSKX*
A-T?X£CM.AL a2" U^DEG TEX CRXhA. £A AT. MT.S2R, WHEAi £*S~
PEKDA^ £*Wt UOIXCE GE AtfPEALTOTHE COU&T *V*XV&IviS
Q&NYEHT OP COMSXCrxO^, THE DXSTRXCT COuiX LOST 3ttW25r
Ictxon; amdthecourt xw\medxatvwY Ac.&uXtt&3o&s£*
ICTXOM OP THE ZK%%. ;
t.33 THEITI5TRICT COURT Xc^uX^E.DJaRXSXir€T3CM OMLYIfc
CAR&Y GUI THE tAAMDATTf Of T«HE COURT TO o£E TvU^ TrVt
3U0C>L»vvtMT ^PCaNiYacTIOM aMQ Sl^rr^CE WASCARR^
TED Out, AMDLuJ;^^t POWER YD XSSuX ANsiRXT 0*r %HJ8LTBi4
\A/AS>XK^EREMT XNTHECO^RTTO RtG)UXR^ O^uTt^CCTCTTJS
JlxugEmek\ts,

(J)RETCRnAV
VELOMY, uAXL^ONWxcT^O^VtLOMV OP^E^CES^SEuTt^cr^TEA
^E^/wAvviS^AEaTUM, OrtEJsiDER.eiEKT tWCC.PELO^Y CO^VXOTX-
O^-^^RTXCX^A-IXMG PuED.TUR^E S^IV£SX^\P0SXTX2hi
FACTORS
T^e WAi^TuAL OPrENC^Cfc PROVXSXOAl 6P VvetcRtAE£ Hr^^oti
OP T^y p€;HAV CODw AMM/S^2-U2 (&> CD^S Ktf APPXV \n^k
AtvVX^DXVlDUfxt ^h%3 -HAe &EM COMVXC TED OP Y^A/0 OR *40R£
PRIOR FELONY 0^fENSESXOa^,.S£atiFt4TLY CO^VJCTEO CVcA
£^AT^. 3AXL FELONY UOT ~* XM *CUV-XNG THE USC OF ADtATXV
WEAPON A^D^HAMCEu^YT^^-^cJ^ PUO^V <50NU$€T-X*C^S
CAM.K.OT ££ SI-k'TCnvcED uMDEg-fO^MER T^*AS~^MAL COu*
AKKi.% l2U42i fciS see V.A:t C .a k\/_>UU-A
ltet§»afflaiZS CQD^fe U..U3 C &- \ BlgjMjgggg v. 3TAY g t
&k0 5AN . 2«i sd £340.
                                       -1

                                                                             -

11 Hi A#9it CAM X /\N! UN IT4COR PC R AT ED AS^C S.1 AT XC Mi AMD
M XnDlVIX>u/\L OF THE nECRO RACE LOMvPXAXMETHATTv-.E
t\iEteR.O RACE COw\h.M!v.S TtH.\TTHE gTATfe 0? TEXAS) PuPPc* ELY
ENTERED INTO A PLAvi GR.5CHEKAE TOXlPRIvI                         W\V CF KX&-
KTS P^lNiX LL(-tS; M4fi iMNAOivITiLX $ECuRtf>TC ME; £Y
"WECOHStXTUTIOH fcHC L*V1$ 'T THE UNITED STATES,
\NfiEkE ATRIAL CClRT UR5 XHfMHAMCXiaei A I'* HALO AW x"
fUHXSHIAIMT XT MUST MEAT ADDRESS- SNHET vy, R%'A AT ?L..-
 ^R xb -»,RftftfcMjjfcyjfc Ma^^tffetefcr KM?-;
(:rk/ STtCXChLA^L V. Ygf\SHXNt-TOM\ MU 0-0. (ifl6,U»ti *•'**

 Gc\/ ERfNi fv\ E\\T& > lEGISC ATI 0 w > iN'c R£pK£ TATS OM'.
XT XS THE OuTX cT THE Ut^XSLATufcET6 MvA^E l ^ S AMD IT
is the Function wf the 3u£1ARy to interpret ThosA IAv*$
TEX. CONST. ART U \ WHi n> THE CDurt XHT ER? RETS 51 Al cT E5
The CouR^S SEE^S^EffECUAYETWE1 CoLViCTlvfc'xwTtwl
PR pukpfst CY TrtL LW-SVAT0R5 *M*© t.MAK A,'MD UN AtvAfcl&U OU E ,THE LEGl&LMukE
NVUST fcE UNDERSTOOD TO MEAM WHAT XT W^ EXPRESSED ARD XTX5
MOT FOkTHt- COukTS TC AD© CR SUBTRACT FRONA SUCH A STATUTE
QHVt vi*m TWE APPLXCATXCN OF A STATUTES PLAIN LANGUAGE IS
AW\%X0t\0US Gfc, \n0ulD L6*D TO A&SURD CONSE.QUEN OES Vt*icv\
THE tCCtSlATUCE COULD NOT PoSSXELY HAv & XMTENDED SHOULD,
the COukT LOOf\TO-> EXTRATEXTUAL FACTORS*
TEK&CVT CODE Af^N.fe3\\ .013 lY^t5j

                           LJ i
OvC *• J»

 RE5-OUDIC Al A FfcCX         ALDO         EX NIGRO EXCURVO:
 RECTUM, EX RECTO CURVUM/                   • ATHING ADJUDGED
THESClEina 3uDE>EN\RNiT OF K COl^RT IsAA^ES' V4HXTE &LACK
 BLACH V4H3TR THE CROCKED STRAX&HT Tt\l STkM&hT CROOKED.

*H. CONDUCT COMC EFT, ON THE CTHEL^ HAND fcEST CM PR1N01-
 WLES OF SU&STANCE Due PROCESS WHICH FCRbID THE PROHI
BITION 0? CERTAIN XnjDXs/xDuAL FREEDOMS-
TriE PRI'AARY ISSUE IS NOT REASONABLE NOTICE CR ADESU^TE
STANDARDS, ALTVACU&V-t ThESE xSSUES ?WAY £E INVOLVED.
RATHER THE. ISSUE XS WHETHER THE LANOUA&E OF THE STATUE.
fkW&M IS NCRNVKL tsAfcAMXHfc. IS SO PROADThi\T fcl'S SANCT -
iom\5 may apply to-* Conduct protected by the con-

                                          p3*e
                                      m
THE RESOLUTION       Of TWX5 XSSUi DEPENDS U^DN *mt1 HER
THE ST K\ UT fe S PEV; WIT 5 PC LX Cfe Mt£ OT«t k CT P1 £1 AL TO
UMLlhAiTEf) O'EECRRTXO'IMAKY PcvJERS XM XT f EN f QRCE ME NT, IF
THE SCCHE OE 1HI PCVmER ClK tvMTT EX THESE OFFICIALS IS SC
BROAD That THE EXERCISE OF CCNSTXTUTItNttLY FkcTEULO
Conduct -» dependi on their c\nN subtler vie\^s As
To the Property of the conduct the statute is uncon-
Stitutxonal.

                                    j^£ p^q
TrVE PLOOR XELrT ES £«* &J OVER 5 B Ur" A.iWU S.\P \(r f?T>C
FURTHER UC-ht li\i'^ HOUSfc TLOORPEt Wfc 0*4 tAAN
l%6, REP.TJAN MORALES fcXPVAXtWD T*E PuR^SE OP lkA"f
C^NOVv. &RT.1 »h AND ART ZX.t v.- .C.C P.) TOTHfc   R^
HOuSE In RES?ONS€ TC QuES 1 3 i F.c.-..-. REP&JESENTK&vfc
           EVM4* , A" "'. IXOWS!

feio] NfcfcALES:
Yeau, LP&RY, Ac You can See on page tv^o op this
LPCaelation : &*r< toepsct with regard to ta£w\0": .
  MPlY      stuul RE THAT THE. ~X> Et4E>AM1 RaI j E Amy;
tX'Pl DP TXCVtmCAV DfeFEXT wit h fi't'cAvj To h
I g LO r^pjr yRxor to the KIXAL Yo PRttUXD^ a
Ctt
 ;T 1 U \tiom Srt HE RE. W£ G0 "      •.-. G h T HE EfsTTX RE T«0 -x-.

TC TftftT TUX AL , ^^THrlM *Ah\lf T^E33Ef€CT RAISSD)
RESULTING in\ A Re\XU5aL

PVANS!
TttENjViXT* sie&ardtc l£Ucts P*elatih€» to Substance,
\^v\ AT VM mD 0^ T5EFEC-. S u£E \^i TfcUAXH& At; OUT THE.RF 'J

MORALES *.
A\iY AiVr: ALL.
evak\s ;
&DIf You ^Axt) it VUA<3 f4U$ L~TnTT~                                                      - ^?

       --           n Jttit &           •          :         ~. * vsiv^t x:              #*£Lw
'^XlX IM1 • v • - : - OP CWI-, X-hAw LAv-i TV\E

            -- *vSL VC'eTT,^ N\SL                                    ACxL '.- '

            - i \
NL~ -XU^An;^                             j ,T tAHRY «VW 7r xWCt Xt Tn£
      Si TfM 5 av j. XL                  ) ~" Ttf£ f- • -                         ft HAS T@

Xn ftGuXfcuig tm XE^EnTo-ohT tc k*XX^T*VC ut^cCTX«..#
'^^xTCTHSTaAL KrTvVE^T^. j .......'vX.^'ML

                                                                     ?§M\\
The s" at e to go' through tvye fac ao* of a trx a,l
XEPORE A3URY ok A 3UXGE.. ANDTHEKTO RATSE THAT
XXFECT ONLY     AFT Er A NERXICT V\AS bttU Kc ACHED,

Ev-
So, IW<) AND 53 R \ioTv\xs V4AY :

TViAMO. ^00. vnk PRExXXtNT. VVcN"\dER 5 5 ^ A^DYOuk
AOt'NXAToXAY X'Riir X MttMf, TO SuXPF^D A-LX
NXCc^SAkY RULxS TOTMKE UP COMX DELATION OF
ILYi . Yx-^T this OASIC ^VllY L 2l1 XjC\^ .   .   -TTs A
uXLLT-hATDSaXS MUTHiWCf pROoLtMTX\AT HAS
PlAC-ooDTvC ORXWtlMKi, 3U1TXCI tytSTfi* NKJ
the court W #••—»t Cri k-x nal ax ge.als d^ e r
kHUIft&&RO¥ \c ACS that JHVOWVfS fc DfffCTSVf
1HXXC1 Vv\lNT V4V\IC.r\ A t)E F ENSX -VOES TO TRX AX
UPON MA^CS NO O&XtCTIOH THEM RAISES OiN AHXAL
Tortus FX^ST Txaas TNWTHt COuRT RXvt*XtS
&ASED UPON THAT DcFECT XNTHI XU'DICT NXXW AND
THi L0\tf£R COURT HAS Mt\E.R U AT) THE. OfPERTuHITvt
"D RAS UvOM THAT SH*%i&TXON .TWXRE ARE A Y
RuLtSTOTA^E. up &ND CONXXOER S^RWIS A
COHST XT UT X ORi AC AtN\| RIO \\\ENT T HAT GOl S VC* HT>E
EHAbLI^G STATUTE that \\S \ E. XuST L-aSSxDThkt
PROS/XDES F0RTV\ECOUR-t TO v\Am%t>^U%t)f^fHt>l^llfTt#*S5
THfc PRo+>cR oeT>ECTXON AND PRonIDSDTT *ASETS TnS
RUuES AS SET Out xhthe. St ATUTE % v*OuLp MO*t CM
SUS9€^SX0U Or THE NECESSARY Rule S AT th\STX^E,
fV\R. PRESIDENT,

fMPHASXS St\?PLitD

Ct-tARLY &OTH.THE V\OuS£ AMD SENATE &ELTEVED
That all "DXpects xm a char^i^g instru^e^t
WERE. WiAXvED 0 tO XP NC.T KAIcSD ST ASSi FENX ANT
DEFORET^^L-CLrARLX' TM, PERCXX'mXu €VXLTHXY
\MrRE CORRECTING ^KStvm RaXSTNG OP X^uXCT^\ENV
DEFECTS nRTue FTttSTC T1W\E. AFTER A lZ~HjTRX^~
**WD CCMvxCtxc>M AND THE. XuEXcCiuXNT vX^k; Al
OF THfcT CcN-vXCTXO'N SXCAUSS OF THAT DETECT .TO
SAY THAT AHXi\iDlCTME.SNT ~H-AT DOSX HOT CONTAIN
AN IlXMENT OP M CFPENSEXS NOT AN ;'XN OX CT T^EaTC
For ^urposss op sbh# would se to ccmpxetely
:*HCkL t^ ^Tikry cfqo,-              D* sxc i       &
 f\s vN^ LL A.S TO THWART THS XNT EA\T AND THE V&V.L 0 v
THE LEGXSLATuRE AND PERSU^kBLy "tof "^ "xOpLX VMHO
PASSED ART .%*    \2 .

                             J| V      IB
                                                              !

FOOT MOT E S

 SEC3W.CXB STATUTE CCNSTRUCTXON AxDS PR^NlTDES'.
IN CONSTRUING A ST j\TUTE, WHETHER OR NOT THE STATUTE
xscoNsxt>tRED Ambiguous on its pace, A court *aky
CON6T0ER Among other ?hvtersthe?

(0 0B3ECT SOUGHT TO £>E ATTAXN^D'

(Z) CIfcOU>>ASTANC t S   UNDER Vittt C H THE STAT UT£ tyf|&
ENACT ED-

(Z>) U OX S LAT XVE HX STO RY

GOCOMMCN LAW OR POfclA&i. STATUTORY PROVISIONS
INCLUDING LRV4S OfWTHS SA*AE OR Sl^AX LAR SuEXECTS,

(5)CCNSE0UENC€S OF A «*T%CUL*fc CONST ?iU CT X Q *A-

M ADWVXHXSTRATXVfc CONSTRUCTION

(T)TxTLE CCRPTION) PRE^WSLE AMD EMERGENCY PRONiXXiCN,

                                        Pc^'M
                                     .

ITjHE A?PLIC**fT PETITIONER DO He Rr ST RtGutST T'HAT
A W.jslTcP VvAMOAMVix-i RE: v^RXT of PROHX tXTlcu
MhVL X5SUETEX. CONST. PM IV. § |m kk,q ! US 7VU
Adl^t probation aw Parole \J$m wax cxix^cxxxxlL
BY THf CCx^TX fcf 1 XX A3 Hft&Mfe r ,x &J NAl
Sug3< mtHTQM 0* Cfvloawxt ACTXiiM^. Ax- f\^ATCHi
TrX &UHAI tfl UNDtS Tex. CkI m xTAt, p,rt :. 11                            NtftN
J*ffNt>IV|M?t &*** ^iTiCE Cf APft^uTCTHE Cl uRT
 F£0«vtTR£ 1utX>WVi*rt (-> Ccaw^CTXOAJ TttfL
DlS:TfetC C.Cx\RT U1T Ol\rXS OPTION *tit&^fHg
COUCT I Mi^ul AT ELY ACfiUlRHlU^SlSCtl^'N
Cmw -X \ak*y cxn the toMKycrtdf the CoufCf^o
$11 ThAT Tttl ^OU-Mc^YF COMVICTXO v4 &nx
I,LRT":v^CL WAS CM&Ttt) OUT U ,THX icWcRTO
XSXUX AVvfRTT c? NpW*erT?#N -.fjAs xwher?mt;n
THI COURT TO' RLR0X'. C k-ol ox at *rt . §Ji R?   :       •   "- ...    :; . T*,: t r *• r ct .- r
nNA^r\lX:-X StXvi Hi ^ - ^ O T AU ^uO-.^
PR&OES 03 'v,c" 1^ THE. CY\S£ XH t>\E Cj0M<% t>U \MDXH TH£
 Cl^WIC~XCnnv\X HAD U&TT2 L T.AE TSUD&fcM&T Of THE

                                                f9*M5
 FfSUftfttf CouRT IS RECEIVED tY THE Court fftOM
WiHXCnTMR AvY-'EAl vsiASTAt-XN .1 N CAUSES. VNHEtE,
KvT Er NCTI c I 0 f Ar f% EAL H\6 %E E IN GIVEN THE
RecokD CR AHY K^TXOH*Tt\tREOF 1$ LOST ORDESTkCtED
IT ^\K\ bi XU'6S13TlxTED xwTUt UNKffc tOU***lf S^XD
COMfST ttntHftl-lH SESSION AWO W\XNS0 tLifcSTxTuT££n
TH« Tn^KXC^XRT KA*Y £.1 RkEvARED Rnl X Al Unti I ThI next TERM cY 5A1D CouRt
FrIxA v^nXCH xAX & MVEAl vmMTKuE^ ANDTUX iKIfc
RXCCRX SHALL EX SUtSTXTuXcro AT 5#£S>Ttfcttf *\SXN
OTHER CASrS.
                         •   •   •—

to   X:-"~XCV' SH tXTK(\CRXlXRt\R>5 w,kIT X'iSUifc
tUHHR:^ cx^ ex                        '^otwc- anxv-erxor Court
TC ft£S P VwITHl M XTS ¥K ^c R ^UrXSXXCTX OH
rAS feft CLm:^C- AVkcxXCUttcn) s:^9iW^ A«* ORDER TO
REffRAXN OR STOf la! XC^XTXNgUs LAW* TVU\T ffteV&ETTC
A CEtxTai M Act 0% P*0< feDufcfc fc C-^ITHE vcRItD tRc M XXI
TC XXXI^ THE. U.S. v\neN~HE MAMuF ACTuRE TRAnS fC fcT
ATli.v MX ^;UXcT fttC0H0>IC UGv-ORS wi M VU vcX I - c 0
Wt THE ElGrtT £E*sT n fomut MS Ml TC 1HI ULCo^STXT UTTtf fi

                                          P^iMfc
                            CO

   MWC*fcTA '. fcCHAKU oX UccRTTc/. SXGtttL
XMLSr. SOURESS fcK VXNGjQHMCr tl4&U\*4D XH #1$
THiT iHflutHCtP THE XlV.olC rfne:T &f SfcVffc*L
MDOEU4 L£C- fcl M*D Ct)l4SiXTuTXOMM

                        r
                        (I ;

   MDAMUS IT<      I        XM M     cxTRfCDTHARY
VmkIT TISUXD ®* A CCurt Of COM PETS NT
u"UkXiDxx~XoNi TC M X*i?£flT0ftTtefeUnftk
• F nU C ? FX c 1 hl AM ADMl XX oTk.TlV X
>Vc E^Ct •   U>DR TICX iX A&Y pf^O'M
C< . XLwXttX ""-". HkF(Xv.^\a5CL cF Ktf fcCT
  ;- J ONLY WRE^THtKt XX KDUTi Um^rTHI
LAv. to vXh.FCRA\ TU6 AcT THE fuAlxTT. f? Hfc.x
&CL&M RIGHT TC SUCl "^^L^xa^Cw Anu
Ttix? XS H£ e?THER Rl,.XXY kVAXCA&Lf               A^L-c
AX kcrxOH Xf4'UX N^TURI of A virit 0? XRXt
Xi\j 3iX.^:ul0TTCfvS VhX^l the sMR-TT IS AtC XXrvED
-a     MkI Cl bt* Ar,X XLXXC-T c Rt l\               ' • X.R
x n :.4NCTX Cti SI AN         ' \ t •s Mox is an

OfULY TC Co-      XL THE riX XXMA^Ct x^
MflttoX*tfeftX*t NCT.XT CANNCfl BE US$0T< ^$TxTUlf -
t | COURTS 3oX^X8vX X.XLDX^rxX :

                                   PS* v"^
XV two f>ERF0R*AAMcfc Of A"Disc R&TSONA&Y ACT ,

K£5l l E i r a'aiI AT\xn;- ^axsr cr DE~Efcvia-\Txu«\i
TH-ATI* f\D0xDGED OR flwAL *. AX k*K CCAlXxXXXUE
CR CAUSE lX AlTXOH THAT X£ SXTtLM) M A
3U|>t4kS KUl fACT:: I^VOtvEDlR the tXVui I
 D« A3UD€: mEMt 'OtLfefet,. panAk'X CR OTHER
jcvba'lN^x;;wtxm 15 OomsxxereX vlHAl
AmX rX t-^X RtLl~XX~AT Il-N CR
REX uXXEKMl^Cf WATERS LET ER^VS^EDX^
AX3XXXX. ATI t n\ < THx Di ORXvi Pf Rf 5 TuDX L AT A
 PfcEttMOlST**  L XCCtXltU^t r                 I   -:L AU'O XIRtCT |$T             I
FORMER AXX IXC- - "-          v.- MM fefcfc %h litCW ti «^S '
.    . -   • (RU        i xL i A NXx-cRHb: •                  ECXC
ISC CT S3 N Tv\ XT £R£Ci - u I S vX LIT I GA"* I o H 0 ? CIA& I
ANDXSSUES ARISING WDMTttE •
                 . .    1      ~ tss AgMfcTt •           " 0 2
&FTERA I I       LX ;         i " •-•••"-£ fOXX'S t> I
C • -V EM* TrX oXXAL Ck AHXR XCMS CTfafft
r-; - . LAETER*XXR»ATXOM ^KVXRhL t^cA?aE> EFFECT
< !*$> oy tox c xt a | Rft c ou dl s t i t>; f. i       e gy (g nt
SuIT t. v • - X *        X. CA,, ' £      - A.CTXC-4

&f U    gation co z • Ui$X** vat ER XuiTS oh
AX4Y Cj ,X: C? AC".. •; ; .   ". X!tXHX -,v.>
    "X., CfcU&Q tutti* • ^tCX XXO.v x.-.-:;x . ftyj
Dl.riN^t bAO i£          £i S0,X1l fct A

                             V f

Ar-r^X v AN t>UvX, X1S''CLcR\E^Ct "auu AX*li VXROUfsi
UXXT-H;         t)bh               : iX.'Xf\T!CH                - ; xX.
    cwuAu'T-     3 cs UHDI^tui r*3 -            : 4V\     x    x- *n
"tUM«MO -.XCT »m. ACC E1XTC 3---XC*-

IX*M    itfb Of U g XH fc£Tfe 0? CuvS-s • X:SL-S5
zm im. iJuSYxcs tx ut oy arcx~ - my b&Mtti      *t
i.T'rXCXr,ut ****w       KANrAXN^ AC^XXe UHDtfeTM
COiOfc Df STtfTE L&*j AivXRXieXNATXiiR ^T^^:-c!tc
UUTOT ACTS -X iWA.iXCXES ^ITH-nyXXNTE^TTOwS-.TOH^XlKIE,
(CASE £XtX MGS fe*D AUTHOR.ITXE.SIM SuP«W 0F THt, CASU

 l.Ta Gov't oogLSiLO^

X STUPE* V, STATE 1W S.W- End id P2g3

STEX.ptNAlCODE >XM> MXSDt AW^.NOR H*fcXTu/\L Or FENCER

M.VjxCA \2. MM p.c FORTH! Reductions Or 2xd itC DEGREE
     FELONY'S TO NMSDS^Xa.MOR PUNISHMENTS PERSE StNM E
     Bill »oo7 SENATOR WHXTtAX&fc -
 -

Sx/t^MCUSQ V, ST ATX RiQ S. vX X«4 S& f.£o-

6> feu fc* HC lUE R V. St x" I u o 0 SAX xd ti. P S NC

7 AfxjTXTCRRXSNA oF ruCTI VL T>f Kttf tlNAXT Y ACT
     SXG^ tD XtviTOTHt fcXLL CT RX-GMTS AH&W Z&^ iV^
     YVJC YEAR STrCTUE OF U MXTAT IONS DW C9XMXMM,
     MID CxvxL.

6.FAXLUeCTO k\ARARJDA WARNTMG MO SIGNATURE ON"
     File pertpxnim(?..

CRpfc£3uDTCE

l0.rUi^Df\MEf4T?TLLY DtrtCtXVC IMD>X CT RAEMT

H. COERCED CCNFtSXXOH

                              9>Q>ii2-0
12 . %IL i 0 %L R\X S C O N u U C T

13. ^kOSECuTION VI^DICTXV NESS

kXCONSTlTUTXO^AL VIOLATXXNSThE XXHth 5»*V*g*
  \X K^Ovj AMEnORXNTS T)Ure ORCCLSS LKVNiS GOVERNING
  THE UUXTfcC STATES                  4

'5>1uDSLk\ y.STAT g. IHS 6-vv Sd 323

lUV^HlRE AIRXAl COuXT tRRSsu INHAMC3 Ki6 A utf t N&A*>iTS
  PumiStiJVXF Ml IT *AUST NEXT MX-RtSS WSl^T A*\ THKt ESRDR
  XS RtVtRSASLE TEX.R A?P PMH-1

n.H\**C TUNC* TO Coiv\OcL :^X.XLJr'SlH^XTTJ>N

t£. RE-QuSTING ANlNDETtNCSUT INVESTIGATION BY THE
  Grand 30RY Coramxsionero

ft SYRlChLAHS V.VnJASHT^GTCH m#4* U.S. k0© S.C T ?0*2
  80i FdxdCT^(iH^'-r)

20 t> LARTc GQlOIXM QOv\ s.vl 20" 95^

ZtS?-L 20 u-* c § uim. RE1 X>X^ kc \*CIT OF t**i*§&MU$
  fcL VJRIT o? CETRTIORAEX
                                               TKAWYC-U
                                               SlRCtkLX X)URS

                                      ftf 2\    ctlc TOc^hLa
                                  "UP*

                                                                        v*z
GRouwp
OHR

         Widths Court AisuSE its discretion By txemyxkg
         APPXICAMTS PREVIOUS APPLICATION! Sft^lWG AN
                            OUT ov TXKAE    APPEAL

         KppUcam prevvousl^j SoucjYvV parf¥u55umT*o¥tf%e
         ConvictinQ cour-V -VoTV\e an ou-t of -Vir^e appeoA, V\&
         pre Son-Ved -VhvS \n an QppUcaTion-twr uxrA of
         Habeas Covpu«x-AppA^oan^ poeV\ous\y ponnWou-V
         to4V\o courV AVtq-V V\e rec\<2vod vne^-fec^we Counsel
         ujV\*cV\ ret>uHed w Vxs pUo being invalid ,and otr
         Touned b^ mcWce mer\T,
         TY\e cou*4 denied appWcanV habeas re\\e? on4Vus
          issue s-o he sseVs's -u^VVier re\veV pursuant -W4te
         decision cA tx£ CourV c& Crvrm«\a\ Appeals \n
          c> PA^T£,X^9r^S0M)3X SM.^^CwxinM*.*^
         f-fcorW* WoeaS 5e«V<\*gan ojA-ov-ume Qppec&ujaS
          Not a CUALt^HSt^oTVieGot\V\c\iori) vAc 9VierSon urns
          nor precludedxrofa o. second c\ppV\cc\a\o*t because
         as Sou^ on ouA-oP Vvrr\s
         appeal noV a cYiaUeacje -VoAVft conv\cr\oA u)W*n
         i«s a Re$\ec4 ion e* oJacA occurred Wre.
         Mso SXc. Xy ^ARTX EVA^S HkM S.Vsl. 2<3 (r4A.(rex CW*LW.\C1%)
          Tne Couyt abused As cUscYe-t vein v^v acA cxUoujmc)
         6\Pp^ccvrA \c appecu Vu$ p\ea uA\e*r a uoas apfpcvTaw^
         V\e u>as> act «reprc SenTtofe^ a Cornve\a>rT oAVomeV
         Th\5 loos pv-eseM as^£l1CANT SttY>STC CUALLSkiCt vAISQ-uIlTX PLfeA
      PURSUANT TO * ^tCE^T SuPftEfUC COufcT T/>EClSlOM \WWICH
      AISO MlE&EI) IMEHtCTIvE ASSISTANCE Of COu^SfcL.

      AppUconA bos prtwousUj SoueVA Ac presenA* on om4<
      oA* -Aime o.ppea \ Ac ch oue n c e ?K e vo*.« nAor vr%e5s
      of b\S GudAs| pW bu\ Abe kr\a\ CootA refuse*) AocWcu)
      h\m Ac^puvsuo Abvs i^uc .The IkuAed SWAes Sup
      reme CourV aoreed AWA velvet should be GxarA-
      ed cuben CpL\A£e\ ?aA Ac explcun aU Abe Cwcura-
      5Aonces ^>lu rouoo*fig o cud\y p|ea•
      &^ PaobWa V. henA JcVnV l^uS.          \oC s.c .*. W7S
      HO Lie Id- 2tM (2C\cA.
      The Supreme CckwV aa^eod AhoA c^ deAendanA
      Vvove ox sixAb kmendrnenA- fti$V\i Vo• CcuAseliOrv'v-
      ch exAends Ac? Abe ?Uc bo* aavn'mc pvocess.
                                       •iiir   '•Twiiir*^   *

      HiH V- LccAhoa MlM U.S. S2.(WfcY
      A.ppUcorA .loos induced tnAro accepAiwc. a auA\^
      p\eo Ahm^mc. t^ p\£acKnc^ gl\i\Av| \d oA\ AW c$,er\t*Li
      he tucu\d ncA bft 5eMenc.ec 4o aver (vslx/ecArs baA upon
      fcppbc&rA LlecxU^c cu»\A\| be vecs SCrAenced A-o Ape max-
      ima**\ tarm cvv eacb crease
      AcWfendonA \S subjecAeb Vc?4be Some Six MftCwmftnA
      prefect «0*i ducvf\c.. Ahe plea box ccua^o process a~ uWvnc.
      4r'>c>\. Sx3sfek&ri M• VvasbM'^Acjq. l/o<, u-S at l^6.^^\

                                 ?9#ZH
       "BeW decvdi^s oubeoAWr Ao ptead QuvVAy ,a defe^dcmA
(^f \s$.cvAiAUdA<, AW effexW ass\sAa>nce c£ Coxv^eVenA
t\NO
    Couas*\ rWWr. tM™* Vn ft^W^*^**- ~Q<"? *** wni i,
       vjATc); gAtloh\and HU u.t. M oSk.
       Eecause c$ COu\nse\s deV\c\enA ^>erfc?*mance app-
       \iconA Sufi'eted Abe tc?\\o»?\nc^ <
        A\(j7nv\c4e<3 and senWAced Ao \v&o offeAses'vA
        \Ao\of w?n of DcubAe 3*{wra<|<
       "B)^5uTTbred V** fecmg ^enAenced+cAbVe )m pnscn
       ovAdbhe U.S. OoasA'vAuVioo venture Abe CoavicAioa
        At? be kemondecb

        $A.ov€£wr fN/Aauddm \s noA ashing AW courA Ao apply
        advsAmo-VvGn baAujeen dwecA arxci CoUoAeral con
        sequence^ as aWeged Wc\j bacV\ \n \T#l u*i\V\guA an\j vfs;
                                   9$ZS
                        V.
                                                                                "StfF^
GcfiUND   Ax\c) cr WA, ot- vtou^rCc^e &^A^x >^\nc\^ \cy\\ Tv 4A\e
          U^. Con^A vT\x-\t£.* mGHfWAes a pfox-\tce difivecrA
          Ay^m^cne \ou; M*-e j*o-^eAxAuA ^o ncd Roquuem enA
           TvusA pr« vcu\

           U^lXSPuTEID         Pact :

          1A cdi v.o4 \p« dv'Ep'-Pred oA: no \eve\ AhaA AP,e*e a*®
          eAVuca^ prooh c as of an oAorn<^ ArhaA musA a\oo^|£
          be Ao Hotrod no rr\a+ta* u&loA sAoae of Ah© pvococdmO
          a. defended \s vn , Lons'iAervAQ AVe $k*\e Seve«"»AV\ "DfcVric* CcuvA cA StnAVt
          Cx>u*As "te*oSl*Se|^ 2ll2o\0, A nea*\y reSWcA c Srvo-
          uj\vx Swpc-AVVlc AV-.\s ck vv~*.TV\e ^c]••? oe?e Ac run ConcurcenAW.
          The sAovAo-fc^1 cc' Ao properVj reSetae AVuS iS5ue d^-
          vnc^Ahe LJoJQ^M^ Oi^Wuied pLW SUarA A; MB \i.cl -;^
          icOe CrMH .PvoC. Ac f(LSyor\6 "The4r*a\ Couf-L ace ept e6
          AW sAates oppc^ruon wTe*\ it5 cAea* o ujg^ ncA
          •fuoT or Artie NUcV\«cA "3 -VksA, ^sstsA^
          C rw» v.:• •. #J 3 vsA / *c\ AAV cnr\ ey, pf.r ed AW. oppoE* Aien.
          TTe'D.fh. asserts \Wt appVconA x?c^^cA\>a^ W uxi$ servAenced
          Ae bW .r, pv iso A.

                                          r^S*-^
                                                                                         j
                                      j

                                  t
                                                                  MOfH
        Tr\exe*s a su^vcverd cVvSAenAion beAween a \\fe
Q^TSi   SenAence and an WTK/ea* SerAence .The Court
        abused A' d'^CrcAion bv accepAme Ahe. SAr^es
        oppo svA \on ujhe^ Ahe courA lugs fuf^ aujate cA
        AW TocA Abed ^ xz \nVo* maA\c?n ConAa^ned tuvAVun
        Abe sAcAes oppoSvAion ujos unre\aAed A# Abe -wAo-
        *4i|pbtipN*wBi Abe Cose oA band.~Th£ d^sAncA CourA
        made an unreasonable dec\s\an of Ahe VgcA
        LubenAhc CourA- tefet ccA A Abe fAcAes oppesvbon
        oo\AhouA aUcto^c Ahe 5\a\e Ac correcA Abe- Oppose-
        Ainn ."une Clour \s dec is ipm Ac rc^e d Of pi) C&rA $
        C-Wtm resulted »*r a decision ConA* Vrcur^j tocAearljJ
        esAabh'.b. decisions £>rev\c?us\w dec *ded b>J Abe
        SemeC^ufA onAbt Same issue.
        "The t\.S. Sups Sufficient Wtc A0 sWu AWaA RtW\ ** fet-
        (Juued.Tlne ConsA TuAiona^ quoronAee apph*S Ac pte-
        AooA Crd\c^A sAaa.es AWA c^e parA cA Abe ubok Couxee
        cf a Cvvramo^ pioceed»nr sucb asbete \n c\ proceed-
        mo m yuWvcb appWurd Cotdd noA be pre su mod Ao roofte
        oUiAxol (AeoSton votAbouA CcunOe\s advice.
        Lafkr V. Coppei, *kfc U.S. .      (*fcii>(A**« M-o),

                                 ?g*Zl
                                           i
                                                                 10F3

 WASTWIAL COoNSEl IMtrf EcTXvL FOR M01 XNtCkMIMG
APfLXCAKtT TAfu vAtS COMVTCTXO^ VIOLATED "DOo£AE
3£p/MlT>Y ?CTc^TOirisauiLTv poea;

Toe Apptaarri RfspecAfullv fr£$cnA Hniis iSSue* .-\Ahvs
proce&dUAg A© cu;h uJheVber AWs H#AOrab\e LourA wo
uld agree AV.aA h\S senAence v*c*aAeS dcutAe \efardy-
lUplicaAi plead couBv -v burrv.arv of o bcb'AoA \a-n,
u;An *Ment 4,7 cc?fY:fO'U as»Saa\A harm and possession
of a deadly u>eapc?n Copabte cf Causma. Senovvs b«)-
IV insvn/ 5f>. Cause M0,.CO;TrjJiL^.:.O_M. and h« evlsc utfasOv
o^v^ aAv- fcw rcivoAcd &ssgu\A oA AVie Sotac person
LOCO, so ^0,io2iJ2il^AL -"Tr\oA CouASe\ fov\ed Ao GcVaSC
4h* Cc^rt or Ahs cvphcorA ftioA tec?*b CWae* rec\u-
 Ked% &o«* eW^nbVib.ch a Ce>nvicW %, \,^
efcnscs uspuVd fee*utf iaDouuW oepo*d^ beAb tra
ces toere Abe vcsid.V of o. StacW episode ,b>-'ct^enb
 VoccAec. fi*M7f-H V ^A^Ae liq S^3d mfc*.W-> a W
  ucs/*
To,e a:at
      X 'J
           avcAed TSEau\A Ctnd Wro\ar%i
                                  u   '
                                        cA o hcbvAoAicn
CViarqe bcAV ooleced appUcanA e*KibA*d :'- deadly*mmm
uioo.ccn ond inlendeo use iocs Capafek a? causae.
deaVn or Serious bod-Aj injury, Un«kt fetahtow &*{.*•£**
Offense tnos-V Condemn an e\ernenA v\cA ccn-\ cuffed \n\he

                                   f3#2#
                                      ,

                                                                       \effi
O&OL*^                                            lit
-rv*£t   OAber, one \\ <\o\ Abev Are. Abe same //•/
         TncA Counsel tuos vneffecVwe for fc*AmoAc bt^nci^V\
         facAs AhaA a CompeAonA Counsel ux?u\d hnouo logs a
         \Ac\aAion of b\s cbenAs ^.vahA-There vs no - evidence
          in Abe records Ac sbouj AA\aA aA ao Avme.Ahe \x\c\ Counsel
         SouobA Ad oeA Abe mdici menA slashed cnAne^ alle
         ged Cbotoe ,Th« P.Rh AmendmeaA quarcmAees proAec*
         Aion aocwnsA doub\e y Purdy. CseelxiUno\s \/.NMa\fc
          4M7 U.S. 410,145 \0D ^a. 2200, 05 L.to 20-228 Cl^SS)
         AfpbcanA CanAends AbaA because be uoas cbaraeduH-
         Ab DutcAcvry cf a r\ab\Acd ion uoAb \nA,enT. Ad cause boo-
         dy in^urv. And AacyavcAed AssauH ki\$ CoavicAioa
         VioAaAes ddubAe ^epardvj.Xn AWs Case AW Same acA or
         AransacAion ConsAiAuAed a\AoWA\D>n cf Alud d^AvncA
         5daAuA;ory prov\s'\on requvres proo? of a VacAuinvch
         Abe oAber does ncA. WlaWeAA V. 3AaAei OS 6M 3M,52 S-crToo.ik L.t<* SD(, l\wd lA-'s cWor Ahe apph-
         Card he*e Suffeved A f A'Vn Am endm e mA vie \a\ \cn
         uihen bvs cbo^es evcU*d \rc?r>A AVa sex^e acAr and
         VicAaAcd Aloc dvfUrenA penal skTuAevl^e Au>o off
         enses were Abe ,Same toy- dcoble \e parcAy puv ppses
         because ben-h off enses ConA aivr eci o\\ Ahe e\em
         enAs of Ahe cAher Csce^"£>gn\on\<,,N'\oiY\(\anA ii\
                                  T^zq
                                                                    \0*%
G^ USAet-ueo ^.C4 .1CS6 ^L-i&l&.Ul L&U) UAgA^Ac no
     pev5oa ObcTl be SU\6\<^cA feT Abe Sttrvne cftenie^obe
     4to tee pvA in $*$&*$* of \\$% Or iimb^lrit Ou^bcn nc-«e
     IS Sub needed Ac fcMec'f,burner's Rule because ibe blbtfr
     buroer Aeoi *s a rule c\ sbduAory CcnsAiucr »oa oacUs
     r\c4> 4he exclusive AesA w deAe< rrumna, AAuo obenses
     Ate 4bt same for ben Ahew eWmenA d.AW, RaooAe V! SAaie. l"W S-v\i-
                       •to    *H    \   *   *•—   *

     3d- kL( (ne>c.Acp. Ltf^ Dtsfl 2o©5ji AppHCarii u>as Charged
     Lod'n fcuraAat^ of a babvAod ion yatrb \nAcuA AoCoetvm-
     A assaulp, and Acc-Tavaiod Aoe,cuH Genuine beddy
     tnvury, uVucb boAb CowD-lc-led eAAenseO AbaA loos a\\t-
     aeA in Ahe buva\ar^ of a babdcA von as Abe eiemenA
     rolled on for Abe buralafv ^ a hooded ion .TbeCboro-
     &t u?.ere preserAoo wtAluo- **cpercde ir\d\cimenis/Ofld
     bcAb indikA men Ao oil ea « a Co m okA e d W« no e.
     Trial Ccufsoi uoaS defied,-A %* ?c»A^4p Seek Aocei-lk
     Agc r^vcA.erf assaaiiT md»Ci.rY\0 n* diSrnit^ed.AccfnpePerri
     oAW^ev ujould bc.vfc adv'S^o iU clienA e)r ed a clierd 4c bfi SubjecAed Ao double
     jepardy. AppbconAs SvxAb AiY^ndwenA RvchA.Ac• efUctac
     Counsel ooas viokdecA b>/ Abe porAcr mance of Abe Anal
     CouASebfccAh pronbs required by StrvrVdann V.lAlusb-

     AppbcanA cwgueO here AhaA b\s counsel nM on\y AaiUd
     Ao advise V\**n cP Abus cor soc^encs prio* VoArkA, buAr
     alsoAolo him AboA Vie^did ncAboveAo toorry heoouoe
     bo uJOuk) noA have Ao do r\o 
                                         e               ed                ..                                               . -

                                                                           .    .._     .          •   ••

                                                         < c          • e '. il                         I                       *
                                                                             per Si
         '. .-                   -                 : (
            •

                                                                                i i         ,• •       i... . . • i •               .. .

                           bv& £                                                                                 , •.
                 • -:                    -                                      i\d \              i             AT AO
                 ,   ...     .                                                                     -

                            { :•     -         -               . •"                          . -. •                         \

                                                          PSr±3*2-
                                                                                    .^3
&wixw   cAAbe cxWeaed hidnappmCj as husband and uj'ife,
        Gad Aopbcanb ujos presumed Ao be Ane Aether of AVie
        CV.AA and u>as never -Void by Ahe cnAds moAber Uuvb
        be could noA Aabe Abe chAd lodA. him/This cose re-
        vo\ 4z6 •?< ooi -r sr* iib ^ioVe a c e omi A vxj as mcA a ay Hn \v?r
        oAV 0-t v AV.ort Ti \On r\ fg^ i r^np- Abe. *V. ;A Atoe ^ea*3
        (A $hc cbv\ds VAr Vo car\V«Aeu5^j resided »-Ak^ou-
        sebolo \n LObncn W\t cbdd v^soded arid be represen -
        4edAc cAWe-isAbcA Ahe ebdd uias bisctob-
        ~^:X'-cA FanhW Cede i^J Jatj Explains ' RicVrcs and cAl.a y
        tf o pcirenA unde* AK»*. s«cA*on r^f^uVe Ibi vollounng
        p*ohd& ad',-cAe £rod and mec1. od. Ci&re • u*b*.c,b Wtfyfc
        AAnnof Appbe&nA d*d do
        Tb e Ap P' ic&n\ besd o 5, e. ufne0 Ab l 1e d--A. i:e$ requ ive, ^£
        to bavo Pad a parental bicdd Ac bavc Avie cJriiW luPV: h#a
        The A.pphc©nA od^ooys Had bus t^epson rid trio tmb b***
        Ahts teas noA an isotaAed cvenA Av^o uj&s 0 n0rr*a\ArHf8.
        Tre^'/l^y- prA 5 veVN.io\e . lob -
         icb Abe cbdd CvitA*«m) ob.c rrieni toned m a sUAc pn« rd
        Ap r>P-:o(-t£V;CUvO retovn \a bv» veh» cle. be
        ba^ pernor med oil duA\G5 reqj\x£(;. b\{ q po.renAaAd

                                         l§*%^
A5uc   ond Abete u>as r\t^zx cxm| aejeeraenA e4ber Vev-bab/
       or by any CourA order nor iocs be ever bold by Abe
       Chd.ds molher Abed be bad no P-abA Ao \wm Core or
       C.usJooy of-Pie cbdd."rAe cbdo st&Aed AnaA ho u>G3
       •jGirA Mai^limAbe n.\c,h be.f;        ; y - c a:.ts CennsbL w.c TwtmCTXVfc voa m

        \^'^cc 0? UfCtSSTTN bK-u:^ Vte^tk* :.^xn\C
         a, .-"Ax (^fXCfRS.

         Covvd^ bas V*Vd4fcuA in orie* Ao excuse aa acA %«A uns
         old be cAberwise crlm\nabvnA;ifAiogAion o**Cobe£ion
         \mc.A be presae\l fe^nde
         AGand^aAb or scr'touS boo n injury4© ones Sbw o*
         S*o frag one e.We andAhcra musA be no reason ap\s opper-
         Aundy Aoesca^ %$**> cohesion u>vih©uA (^rAscvpahr^)

         Cjar uToarmer^nQAh* chucs o)c\h*fA wiere ^os ao
         j-vvd- A*ab<^ ie<\SC^ fcr AbC OV-sCOrS Ao '»• A-.fv.-: sV>r.i-
         icAe cwiy car vjuhe^ a cV\AAvA\| Ahe use cA deadly Ap,rc£ Ao ocso
          desp%AeAhe exr^Aence o£ proves a V: Ca\>£e A.oa«^t
          And AWrefc re, \>.se or deadh Wee wde* Such Ci*c-
           um&AaAceS AVierhy vcapbcoAesAfott rouxA^ frVrienrWenA
          0\lcucxaA9<2 C\Ua\,\sA i*n .v-Afc} | OfW^evcO V
           fccse^iuv-u aTx s^M t 6o S'iA vS^Cvt too^\7JusAA%caAioA
           Aor KA&uAGtn Acvv'unA To sAop ecu- cdAe*r\pA vr^j Ac
           Or we. To a. Luuj OXEC* Wlor« c^cO^O r\\C */fcnvC\e
          Ond neNier bnAycvpaAed tofcinQ S'Ao" oA by Abe d$ucer;
           f^A sclent SrNOv-^c- && Aa'c^c o\o fecu ^x'.c^ecc.v.
           and CanVoe O&sexAed on\y bx. ir-,e one «^y Stepson,
           because u*S u^ere CorrfVcmAed uJtfVtAfoc ^Wear as
           personal danafcr.and Ane ceS Cr\fYun>-c:: 2d
         t2Tflg . tefcl.fe^ cW v(-^ M<' i in bt d a b ocd SXCUOC
                Abe crime cbar< cd \n Too tno'icA cn« or because
         h* duo Compe n e<5 Ao do so usher b.-.c w >.c - r 3boA
         at birAi pVactna bin* mAea* cv ktnrmnc at ckoAh -
         Scfiiu- bodily \fi\vrV- ihe^ear vxa* cA S-c i a A(A-
         u*e qt-jic induce Abe qcA 0\ r-> SAopr>\ ,v., Ai.... vO-
         h*c\t m an area cohere Anere ujos> ao ujidrv.s^cs
         around. f\cAs dent cinder 5ucb Cc?erc\on e* Cdcnp-
         bl^ion are act ck?ne u>ilnviA^«Uaii * Ai-ch'     P.
         iHl
           •
             p, L-d 2-18, kbblV-'-Cu
                           ....      .
                                       cA-O.' • Kn' A0 ^e I u)OT OOv.v pA
         on4 « x<-.a! d oS ^neftecAdve ?\ssibTance o\ co, nsti
          >b»tb M               a piano •a-- Ag present Abe bourv
         *>eV* fa bnc fa" aMi ••• . . "*° -^- pA- An* inc^cAmi i
         b cause Ibe records ^k . •• •». • Ahti cfcice*: lo^c
               i»,.< aA Mauldvn uJbiU V>.       i^cW^n- \o $ -
         f\M a • Avc,\ LounS< \ ux*s -^ TTeciiv^ icr nei orb
         Awe 4c cur pi c oc 4 ii c olrnervbenibc fca&u -i .;••'-
         Ki,       ujgs Ob... p mo, Ac rot r; on aren r osAA ;
         before S*c?Pp*ru bvsvemcte                « c&Avcev eUari^ A'-
             one? u)heaV\« endAAoeieo Wh-ho, c sW sen •' • •
            ben an cA c • o.iOvoa^ sbrch. i cA oC^com
                                  \j          *+       —-             «--••

         ocuda.Av.;' h^« su...ctdA •'.•-> .. •         :rb Ah< dr\
         W.t] (A fV»€ ve.hAo\e.tAc\ \c n': ocA.ef>s ccore -v VANod
            i riad Co-.n.Sv-\ p« tot rn^d OS Ar;-> uuhicn vsr; i n\ -
         cvd byAnc QnAed tdcAcs v£r*&bAuTiDO
           °5|ricnian Vj \Afc* (W9h)
            •                          ...»
                                                       M«*H

Had Counsel explained Abe defenses Surrcundvnc
V\i«» ocViorvs AbaA occurred uinen Abe ofhccr obot
oA bun,he coould b.ave adV pbad ou IVy fob e enca
ses bicb Du£ Pfcfccess requires*!

                                  .

                         ,4fc
                        fgir se
               CtfcTJfXCkTE OP SERVICE

THE APPLICAMT IVVR EfcXC MULPlKl * ftWlbltjVO HEfcE&Y
romrxiFr TrtM-\ a tpue. amd correct copy of this werT of
N\WX>AMU3 RE' \H«at OF PR0HXe>XTX0H^r\KS EfcE-M tAKILES>
ToTHS Of FXCt COT Tut CLCS.^ &«AHD3U*Y CO*ANlXSSXOMtP,S
lOO & &ROAX>vJfc<, V^OOm ZOHiTYLCfcTV^X^S^SlOZ
£T 993L PoST P^TD v^xl

                                       PRO SC ** izqerst

                         [rslxsf!
\NUSv\eFoWE V^ENlTSSES ARC COr4 5XD^P.eD
                                           ST P«aT TVA^ THE

COUNTS GrfcAislT ANY AMD ALL RSLXEC ^SduESTeD tOR
HERE3M THE O^nvisSsS OVTHXS YlCXT OS VAA^DAtAUS. fcNvUll

                     (3xCLA£ATX0n7J
XDOHE^E bT LcERXXfY^ VERXfY, AMP STATE] UNDER rTNMXT^
Of PC£3UfcX THKT TV\E EO«.E.GOXM& X£ TRuS As^D CORRECT
UNDER tZ& U.SCr|\m|%ay of fE&     ZoiB

                                                    0
                                                        t>0^

                                    E.CXC \:MULl>lNl*\£APy75k
                                    &LIEN 6 90U\i4£>VY VXMXT
                                    3^72 FtA 350 SOuTH

                                    UviNi&STo^XsXAS,-r73S»

                           ^
                          9<3R