Court Opinion

ID: 4065231
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 21:54:35.073199+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:47.021912
License: Public Domain

HE@EWEM

COURTOFCFS§M|NA‘L APPEALS -
Aus 03 2015
[M/§,EA/m 1295 72 usf ‘
gal/55 Ma. /r/$~?z/¢§ %@“A@@S?@,CB@W< ,_
13 ~ @»»~oz,oq

.ZWEJM rfp/ram X M/ J//M)/_rze/¢r 60qu
' X

M.Fb` ` ` rd , ' , ` o
»< _ 353 J¢/M¢/M Ms’M/cf

/M£fd 721/lum Hi'/MM )<`
- x bmi/45 mw\/f?'j IEM_C

' MM/M '1)25£'1/}?2£”7"_!¢. A/Z/ip£z/§Zz`./L/_ _ ,_ - .

MI//[MMIMM I/Mz$//€ .//I¢w¢zr _/w/é '5 l
A,v/>fwA/i'//zij¢:) 27 ime/vw £5/5¢ m/////_raw/'/ 277/f ma rim

F\/F/z€z abou£_§fl//£z{ /2,0/))¢/£¢/ <'Az/J€J, 7/'7€5@ a/e /W/M/J of 7200 smu/mmi
fm r//E way/439 red 5a ua/ 3500/f me 7h)J (w/-f,

l
B/’/’E/Zz)/)f A/é]£ Eéf 7@/¢’13/9 F//FJ an p!rFAS/'A/) mo %}z)/) ,» d/§‘a .¢i/c§ 0/) w
beyer/790 na/~’/ fea/gu mar/m on Ju/S/~Qo~zz)/f 70 Tm"§ /'fo/)o/a b/z zaqu
linder z)fm'mma/ ,»We¢;./Jv /7,/;7‘/~/1,1¢ amf , ~/%/>/"e//`a/) 11 h`/'e Th/_;' mgmt/75
-mo770n Di_§£/’/’f/z)/)a/}/ f£wc€u BX’ /305’€5~ »7'/”/’£J amf é» w/HC 57 hands
->L'i/e Pm¢)/)a/ m&-//¢zd /¢¢zyc/_Y 23 /Zzée_r.
-»° lZDF‘/ of 7/2/¢/ ama/f mQJ/¢zz/ /£L'o/z/j` 7/)&% ware m mac/z " F¢)/ mea/'/"(c;/

Ma@/)as/"r aj TFEA mmf” ?¢///%.;e$ and ,wz/¢ nor"/€equab{é“ /?y/%/'n¢»/i
72) 070;6/)05 15 al mgm/nm ,L 7/)12 am /’//eA¢//é_/ use m a¢//n/ 777/46 in m

511/dime m don md /W¢z¢»m Y/%e) /5/£/1/'0, 7)
- 5722,7‘€/)044)‘ AS addenda of EJ/Fe/cmzcz/ and /Zw /0; éana§z/a, '7/} 17 '
_ _ 1 ¢ué/e
@e.ne/af)‘c:¢/ donna 714 L~s age/754 zw/‘/(Z) nw we@/(;’ inmsz 77)€
Mmm€/) z'€mem‘ @/ 7//)/5 721le 0/) 200 7.. 5 960/f ZCJLL’/ 6 /Clg€£

/W/?F¢MM/Zr mez//i:`a./ »Z&Z///z:%i})""»~:@éIZ/`%--Zb,odu¢/cd bf/pa/,z/a/M./
Mya_<’ ffc/1 ,y/)/ue/_¢/ -fs/ //az//A Jz;fz/)c€; cyn7E/Z Z‘mf d/€a//V //)[//'zo,M
7110%~17%€ 0/.’/.»'@//`0”/ waI:‘-'nof m""_/%f/'fion' ila fm %/"/`1¢/./_' ~`7/7)"5» 772/al - T/’zml
fmi DAL;{Q?§/Hm%/) 1465 ¢»//_»¢fz/éd 0/) /m/?b[%¢zp sf/z)/) OF 7/0¢’ S_fo %e.
/7/0£€¢[0/¢2,~ d/)z/WMZWI£ [zz/L/ "ha.<' nb‘-"f"Z?/m: 0"//0)¢'/~'15/)’1 777¢ wa 771¢1-
£z)/).F//Z,-i’ _z/J)?‘/')‘ W/z¢ &?9/!122275-'0/)@{ 770€ 772/4/ ia///, @/)z/é’o¢//fa/ ¢'”//}w/‘/)¢J
/'+P/?!a/J’ . 0/) 200`7; 7%/'§ ,€é€a//:/r //)J/EQ fed 0 m//z/ 570/ing 7‘0-/)0¢);'/€~
/Q{Z/{"l’§_€//€/_€ <5’€/150 rl/`?€U/a,/ /Yém’/"/)l) a/JL/ .S/?FFM MM and /})7/%)5:}}/2
U/m/é/.f /é/h[//hé cz/M/ mman/`c'a?l/'Of) 1 anal //€a//`"/?é fela 7'7/!. -

7/)&7'" eua/aavl/z)/) gary //I /?€mm/ij/Qj'mn //ld/[a/C¢/ G_J}Z/)/(F/dm 7"
mJ¢//Y 70 me jef¢’/)JM /f /"n]u/%(

WPFé//aaf.f,,AW//)e ;”)' Ze'f/"c’/! ~/?Qa?z/¢zr?hé //)fr' fm /~'/lz, 771 yeah a 572/md
70 771c 771/cd -.é’Ov/v`_l.,‘c?/M/. !zZ///‘z)f A’//'m//Ica/ .a///'m/f. /.;1 /Zzé€:j* '

/L?MMLY £z//z/z%¢'/ %af 7/7¢' Jr&Z.¢ //cw! /70 éu/[/méa 7?7‘/+£/&€#, 170`,€ \
fa‘/'/}ez/ m »é/anf mimZ/Q/ w¢zm ~sz@_rJ/’/) Qs -@fF/£z/ fej»h.f%fhaf~ m -
¢W/>g//m AM m’€/e/§zz/ h/'§ ,e/._¢,A/.foL /ZemQ)/) Jz/p/)% when v¢>.//eczé .
/H£J_. sz/mm il: pmi lh/J' zaz/// 1_/757‘)7/¢/€¢/ W)€ <_/.//0/ )lz> 'c//'§/zéa/;/
?_7)@ perez biggs /%/;e 7°?515‘»40_/), % /\/¢L/e//csu , 7740§€ 1105/wachth were

. /:/)5,;€,,££[7€7"//§ m //"é/# of 7/`12“£/./2/¢/? /J/MJ/¢/a/ )’la/L//€ 2)/7)4£ vl€)'/imo/) ‘/

SQ.[¢€;M/M/ w A/ ./+¢/ »…@ -.7@ h»'f M/d/"“-' ~ ~

De§€no’a/n_}/ R@J‘Pecf )l¢/// il HeZZL/@J°-'Th/.r‘ L'a)/v” /&¢l¢m/mé ~/2//¢’@ L,é, 44@/9
MM/m% ¢M /)0+' /%;re:f Mm»m a, 1522/w P/Mo co//z/ amf has _
/'7[1 .,7%/"»" dea/mm '/_f, fame wQJH:/\ /o"/ /Lap[/’ @m/ -.0771€¢§ 75//76° /?/’/)H[mf
/25`/9£;¢¢¢///9/ Qé@u¢§/_' mls murr 115 mf¢§% md %)//aw//')@ 7/)5 dam/aim 5 ,4///
71/)@%‘7})/5 021/rf ./U,;/z,e ma,VD)Z/€/ 7%15 £/€//<' fn Pmm/’W rand 7/)/"5 am aj
/)r Fuil fO/’V L<)Fa//f '7)/)f5`_ 001/100#//)% 7?) Th€ /W€//a/)-/ Mm£e hé di /)0/

_ - Wmes§ an 9/ 0~//4./:/ zM/'@, 1

 

1125/51 0/17/5 7519/25'55757 500/1155075 1150 555 175557/0757 5550/5/1'501915 0517115
0/< 705 051/1100 11710515 055/711577)11/ 55550/1 5575/5/ 501/57 01 1175/7

501?1'7 050// 7/)07111111 751/5 715 77515 501757; 55/71//'51/ 515/55 1115/25 717/71 55
005171'1)5717:' 7/ 1575117“ 1171/7 05 711 711)1515571710/1 7115 0555//117/1: 5/)11'15€7
50 W)I! §5121//55 /11550_/5//7;’25 §555501`) C§) /"1"1/5 77505.5‘[107/)5 27 2715 555/5 /4/
50127$ 70 7//5 51051)1'77157:7 705 5?/`552‘75¢ m 505/1 7/'5)5.551777`25 715/57 w
`77/5501175~117 05 5/55//1'-7757 7120550 51177”77§ 15717': 70 1715 151/7207 1710777£1~9
01/5 115 50155157507 11717_75 7755 /25575/5 5500 775 7/71/ 117577 1057 /7575 17 _
015155557 0/) 7/515 ma!cr/`a/ %117 117615 7751‘5/) 77005/ 1557 /+515'[5 //) 0/0’5 70
5010 7/115 7'0/55 5000/5000 5717/ 5[50//¢/ 1115 510/517 5701‘177€, 51751_<1 /5517/5~
770/15 anc/ 0155711575557 0050/)571717710/0/ 15/551)152[7757 217 //15 756175 0715/

501111 0//155512/1 1 »
700 dowma)}m%@n 1055 57[5 mcn&c/ 050/757517§/ 20 05 1150/550 051/557

,11/ 1115 1557/557 755 5500/52 57

h‘/ 575;/ 5/051 ma1L7 2557/577
1115 7511 1050 501 71)151/715551/: /155015/117, 715 _157155 5557/57711711:

W E//5F 05 fBEI//’m/[f M7/// 5)5 f//€ 07') 7‘/"/7@' 7 bUIL 152/ch 50//5’! coW
05 11555/51/ 551 771/3 57/0522'-55

5555255777 51 5/5_®1/7627071/ 571/750 1715/1 1 /¢1*5;2 515/7511 5000‘} 555/5005 79057"
/`0/51// %/_5 5551§71/15 /+5`1_71) 75171'//5> 550%5/07 5555557@//¢/ 1'?€555:/ '/r// 7751’§
507/5$1_ 01 7}5/"1 051115'110 705/15 557/cd 7707725 507/1 557/511"71 1751105575/ 071
771 5 507/750057€57 715 11707 7117/055715557 10 9~//6 20/7" '

[5751/'//270 0/55755/256

17555575501?/017755,5 7207//5/11/ 501/555 5055/_ 05 7715 53/555//1 1175@57/05<7
0/) 515 500/705 5/7'/757'710/ HW£cz/S. 07‘//5'5 ,n 0550//075557 1777/7 755/5 255/57 `

05 5/1'/15/"/)0,/ /7/055'5177/5 00 1757,‘/ 11/ 211/f

 

7 777, 77 /5~ 57511075¢/

555227/0//7_5'770757'7527
55510 715177'//7 5111./'71 075
. 750£¢5 775/7551;5/)7516075