Court Opinion

ID: 4063911
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 21:07:03.087011+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:41.502077
License: Public Domain

- - - . ~ `2\(€2-10

 

 

" ._(:-75444£¢)#/12\§ v 4_5, .“. , " 4 n 4M ' 447 444 _4.44444444444444
422/_ 42._ /__§_/ 542/4{:444%2 _/Qé ` ' / ' 44 "44.4444444'444.444__

4_5¢42£\, 44 541_4` _ 731&/ _ - n ____444 444_4_4__4
/ . _ RECEWEb 1111 '

 

 

 

couR.T_ cF GR11.11N¢114 41 ppM=ALS ~

7_2/¢_/412424 ,Z/2/5% 44%24,4212/> 11111 q __444444

 

aug 17 Z`a,~ §§

 

 

/;7-27»4/?24124»5¢4{4/¢%/4§@% Ab@£ MSGS?&’ mem " j __4.
-` _5/2241¢¢/4445 __l 4 4`_’- 44 444_2_~»/444%:4»144444 4424§4/552252_£44;44
4 _ 4;::2_ 2242::w_ 472 :242 4'45 °’22
4 __4,4422;2 _224 2422 2222 4
4%222552,22.,4 42 244 ;2/2_4 444 ___,
_'/52_/.4 //. 224 4222.2_22 _ 4 2222,554522/422424€2
j2 244 _2;7/71@,5 ./.1.522:¢2¢244;4424&2¢2.:2-. 4444444 _
.:(:5~.:522 222224¢2<_25% 252__
424

4_242244:_ __444 j/4~25%§ :, 254

_C;M__MW 44 4M 2724,¢444444

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   
 

%5244/4/_55-4444¢4/:4\/ 5 /4-'_4 512_4? l.;_:?_§4
444 :;,4»4€_/24'/425
/.22442 /»",/W _ 622 » 444

 

 

 

 

-'~'r>' ¢'-'..;'

- 422sz 1'.~1»2_ _1.{=: _T`a/§¢l/¢€<)/U_)_____

4241 742 6644'4' 744 d_ 422/4246 6 1424/22 _z
mann 74 21 46 .

__ z__44 2226 _____ ____j__ ' _________

 

§
44_/4 444

 

§
’ _ 64 _______________________________________§_ _______ 6_2£4!_:/£__ _/I_/__Q__ ___ng <’/._0__€‘1/2

 

 

_ __ 4/44’2421252/2' 624/001 /221_11_4- j 442/222_'1£/6.-
____ 4'3&72"‘ D_f¢-$' 7`)?’;£¢7-' _5_’_6_6¢4€_ Z_'_/ §_____ _______

 

42222 z//d.:m/c»»,__?'£z/¢J/
` ' /- ` __

 

 

_ 644/4

__ /__7_/1£_4¢_41_{//6 21/ 626/427 ____

__.____1_€’6'&¢¢657' 666__4/~/44/4_1;4__4-1~1 ,_g___ ’ .__

____________ _____ __ /Qd’/ff.z‘d/z/__/iz/Z _62_/_12 .2'_7_‘_01=:_/146/1;/£1:'~/1/ M.<

 

 

___3'21_54_44' 713/5 42444/24621: 6422427':'

66/114'5__6_?;/_242/¢1»7_6'_._4;¥?_1%?;270 . i&/ 744 /_€~21 ,_f>¢_‘
_____Gh_<‘1__-_<___6¢,_7_6_‘6/_>7_______7_/66__/’___7_6_<_6;_%_/4.16./~:__%;_7/_/____%/_/ c /Z_)év/‘W _
_/£;2¢__/__ H//__ZL ___ a?g%¢nj£¢% o___d__f`__ .____ /_1'2_ ___/A_W_,é¢z- ¢4__/_ _; 6/0»611¢/ ____

_ 66 7.4_¢'/11___1 __ . [4;__»_:_62_._1;'6 66.,2_2%_~;!2146_@‘______z/é___az_é__>éé__£4;_»:_1_4_~/_‘2:/_/1£__________

6?2;7;.1_‘7__01212__2;2 1464-1- _61-{ _44 ___ _.§_61_1_,_»1_ 1.__ __/€`7_} ___ _44£___1;_6_ '__22__/_1_7.___________._
___7_/2'1_ 2/`42/¢¢4-2/ /76/ 6/62244_51616_/7! _;61§4; /_ _,JMQ 716 %

_______X€///>* __/_4_¢ __/7213_d_d__ ///6/2’4/ __6_2_117_ -»¢6.1{__44/// /VO__

_@6_61_4_£/__‘6 1__221_4_ ____2(_2_/_/ A#_@£/_// 675/@//__2_¢___%//7214<7/ Z_/____ _Zd/_.f/__ _____ __

:6_ /'2:/_._6/_ 6/6_12_/1_7_441_ 77/»€___ 65422_ ¢%_/_'_ //7_6_/://_4_/€/2 71 /( / ¢//2_/_0/1_62/___ _____________
____%/__ _Z_2___/ _<_.__ ____ 114/__ __________
_7_/4{¢__@_622_6'2§___6_7_[__66212_`_24/_'6_ ___4_=2?:2_ ____ _j626_2_4/_;__;___ 67! %/~1

/(/`16//‘@%74 6°/»~<=‘/_4/ ?//6/ __6__-4£___ 446/__ 662/1411 ,46>_/' 464_6
FLC_<’_€-LJ’ Z.é___é@/-’>/ ////¢4%/"%»€/ 6”"`,/9/`/147£6’/ __ 6:/’"/{ /J__ _/__é_§__/__l

 

 

 

 

jj

 

 

 

_ _)_:Q_ Q_%:_____ _ __ __ __m_c'¢_`v_z_a¢_d/c_o_@¢A/h¢ /»¢//e»/ 4

 

____{%r___.,/ l /'7 ¢¢e_f’ / 4?_@_¢>!_//___7¢_¢;.¢ »»- /‘J_f/ 'w») v
_@/:/_j/_””A/_J__/;é¢?_é)?£__.z.£/dj_/_Z_¢QZ__Z:Z_ /1,@_£_%_4;¢_<__%,4_,{_~;:__»6%¢____
_0_ __/w_é»_/A;/v_/_<.__Le_ _/_'¢_J_A_/,?o/_Q_>/_é__%/_M_/_`,V -%/J o ,~

-4=»1 __7_/€¢< _»‘¢_¢_<__ _4/¢`¢7,¢__ /, 414/_2/»¢»- c 7[) &é_f_¢~_?_/¢?/g_e/AU_/-<____

_Zéce¢»/m:t__/_>)___“ZA/JV/Va»;_%
'Z'Z/J éé.//b _¢_// fda'-J/d_e;,¢'_?_Z/_¢¢ /? ___/o/:~_¢_V:J/

 

 

 

 

 

`Wné.=f p_¢z_¢_;lA__/Z'__ /./v/. é'_z~s~. k
zag_j_%_@}_£z ' 7 75~5’3

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

§
“ _Jzz¢_¢_z 421/2112 '§__11¢~ rr §
§

_`_Z`// 7//£ 7/2'202% 521¢127' 571 c/Zf/#zA/AL /?/"//£4¢_(
/¢{27'7,’£//, ff ?~’/f:f

Z/”__ /_2__/£¢_ ____

 

%/ZZLZ./¢.M _1_£-_ J_`_.d_15_//_L/___€' ¢?_/2

 

____1{<~_:.___ _

 

§

j____________zz_.z_é%”- ' 55 .
_ 5
§

'/1€17_/_¢1)_2_ 231 )_£_ /2_0;/0;11/_2*_ /_1_ ;/Q _ _

 

¢Zé_ 7'_-% 1_9_£5_7,4_¢_£_`¢7' /@1>¢22,_7_~'2’0

_ ,__ZQ.¢/oom¢(@ /

 

. _ %_MZLZAM£Q£_Q@ _LQ£%AW_@¢M¢;____,__ _

 

_ __b_’z_£_@_g__£_ZA;//z_/z_/WWMH_E_¢¢M rs

__?221:@:5_212_1_1_.:_12_1_1_'_5;@'_#_4_44_)___21_/1_£1,»_»_7_”2_»__;@_,_ __ _

 

____,1__¢.,_2_/___22__2_~_» 0 54_,_/;__,,__%__12__1_2_21__1_1 0

__S/` 5_<>_7_[/_‘1'1_2,__,§.2__ //<__5_’¢¢1_,_?_£_@127__ /£_J _f_e¢_<-¢'¢_r_!_/;M<__ /_{_/7£__ ____ _
_//__Q_Q_ 5/2_0_/_ 740 _7[) ,Z/@Zea_)_z&//£¢ ____a_);_[az»¢.:_ //1¢14'¢7»¢ 4/_

 

» __ -/;f..<’_¢_c_ (_/__ a ja /4_1,12_/7 e¢¢.// __Ma__/_` /~- _;_/_ __7_/~12__//_‘127_ a 2» _//_/___¢_":\________

_____//`/2,/6¢¢/7; é_;_ /1_22_¢_/_%2¢2/__,?@__/_7_/22».‘/ //7<__//'5‘7

_/_`_,<_ca__e__f’__a_ //Q-c./_`@*' 521_¢»_//_2_¢__ __‘_<:A_/'?/¢_‘-e/ /_¢7_42//5_/__ _7[’/_2-_ ___
_7{2-¢¢_(_ _./ea'/ca./ ,é //L_éM_VZ_-» ___6_7__- 5:22_¢.€7__/__ /;'7[ /-§__/_Z_)___

 

_Q(_/_`% _//` __/!¢5_/'__1_7!/5_¢4_ .}_`_“____~;` 64 __/._¢" ___§_ 5/¢¢17//\__//_`/;1_/7£________

___ _j_€_/_?_ __?_S___/ __5) /_' '7&/.__ j @__&_¢_1//¢ 2_7_@'_ n_/_ /__/-121_52_-_/€_€_____ / 741/______

' _ _/524_ 102_12)_ /¢Lé_z€ . ___
t ___~ “_H___z_¢z// 7/5'2_/_/?74/41€_!__5// /)//i_f _'51_£’”___¢3_27_ c___/__//j_ 3_ __///;___

 

.'_»//_¢1772;/_;'<7_)1-¢_2/_5_»7»_//(/¢//'7_2,%/7_€_/__6//5?_-5_/~(( fo//)/

___ _/%¢__/_ _//_?4/ 52_¢'_/_%;"12_@__;'__¢>_7§_2{2_¢__7_/?___ _¢__:.Z_A) _a_»g_é@____ ______
b 7 ___ _/_-é/¢<.’é~/_ _%__ M"OA’- D/_’///`._f_/;QM /9 é¢/-»‘ 195/1174 %U /z/,/.Z-A//’-_f _¢//

 

 

 

/(€1/"~¢/`/ 617/4 am //¢_J f__CL?_’?_Z__'_> ee 75_.. '

 

__~50_~0_0;/_0_

 

/o_?¢,'
____?/_.51;____/____

._ _¢~_é_u__/__<,_ a_?g 4!/2'"<,/-¢_74¢21_6/Z£Z§<"/"U]_IA`/c"_¢/ 70¢_1_4{422`?_/
__0_?5_ .1<'¢5} <’_'_¢’{ -$"~9`0 <_731. /Z?_C'))_ _&{_-._S'_ 12- _G;a_.£_z_ __
_,A/% //___(Z___. 2_1__/7,¢2_‘!_ _5'27_4_-_¢’_ %/“ 7_/¢_7!/0_214/_ V_/_'_d M"g_w_f_ __) _4~1:~¢£______
_5_:=»4_ /'e¢//a¢¢`s/ __5_¢_22_)_2¢ / _12.1/;_-¢ 47/42£_/_)’..¢11¢`¢_:__42_ ____

_=&c//_¢%¢-__-_ C_-_QW£¢ ____Z_//i _A_!__ ‘ l __Z_¢__r`_$_‘jo_¢ ¢\_»¢1_7!:'(/_____ __ _

'/0/0

_Z:&,(A_/W 5;_014.-¢’/[/ 2/“/'/?"'/ ,_5?/// 07£) _jM/._/_{/?_Z_/_ .5:/_2_?__4_1;\._0¢!/___
_7__ __ o(@/¢_ zeA/¢z-_'_/d_£_£_€_c_e_/_Vevé___ _
_/V_?@_ éd__ _<7`»"¢’!_ d_)!_`_é/_‘J_ //_7 /;`oM__ZA_<__'ZJ// a _/_&ea_ ~'» __7_!__ ____ ____
_5/<__¢/7_£_ //'/f_&/JA¢_L_ _/.1_1_ _2.//1_1_'<2_ _/e___/e_a_r_<_ @_11_7@1»_1_-1112¢/____

_/_ _e¢e)_: 121_ z 4111»_ ¢,¢___./¢¢2_-_< _/€e_/ _7_[‘41-___ 1§`_ _2'5_2_'_1'0/0_1;/_'_(_01_1<41,{_?__ 0_1_»,___

    

 

_Q_____. /(jO_/_'/~c/__ JM_' 12_1_¢_-<_/__£4_1`¢’!_42, /p//"~/¢// 442_£/.;_7£'

 

, 5£5%/72;/27‘ - _
_ ___/_?Za_v_¢¢é_M_a_f_/;!;A;¢_Z/___/__‘»_:_£__A,a_éz_/_`_[é~_é_/_ _ _11_1-_&._¢2¢2&¢47_1-!).’__

 

 

 

330';' ( 5 ’“'5,1 c_/;@/_) 20 110 13 __.1, 1/ 611__;1_»_¢.-: 2_7£2{/171_11__/2_

 

 

§

_ é¢_¢/é;A/'_QA_ A,,;/../_4_ 61_2_1

~__~ %“"¥ %/"~'-'l% %-~£=_7£7-/%"4¢"‘4 52 /412¢2`:__ _/_J_cZ.¢¢/Av_ /:1`_1____4_2 lé_/_ 7£4©
__7:’<¢’4_1. auJA_/¢#~//ém._)_/{»:_?[_/ .$:_/_Z__'//¢:):;_ !€A‘¢Jév 341-f 4

___ _;p»y_c 74 /6\ !/611¢ 111/y _/a,_»_-a_?_!a.;2/¢/.o/ £/j'j )_L__%)_j.¢zz/_£_/_/_`J_ é¢_//;/_¢
___/ea/e¢»¢/e¢{ 62__.»_46/__ 66/71¢6/622

__ _6_< 2¢0 é/M_ /_/ 746 £014»3_1/ /4//_¢2»1 £_/1¢23,_ ,7_7£»~_/_ /_[_¢:7_ ¢/ /_ 227 /~/2_>':¢/14:___
__ /é?k»¢é 6'1_/ _1'_ 4 _/_(;d_ __.6;&;4.6:/_4{/;¢'6:»__ _4.__ 2 -g_¢,_£é¢_<_/£.,/'_U_<_§_¢£_¢_!_;Zw__
_ _64»!__£//2`¢/_/__£7%/£<’__ ZLQ_A:»-ém.£_¢ %?n-»-!d_éz¢u__/¢_&A_Z_?_{)_/_`-/

_ w c_/_é/`/_éé/_¢ _/_`11_._'.1'2_¢4_/_ _/;;¢:_2<'_£12_._»2»_64_,~; 2_(_{[/£[61 /1?’ /?/' 4 /FJA/‘?_£f z/

_ __ /:e 1/2 2241 2//.:_2¢2~ 2 2;__ 6 2222/_-£_1__< /2¢2 /_"2». 2_,»_2_/2»2_ 2_/222¢_/¢/4~»_ _/_'./<:_'___
_ __ 225 2222, 2222/2627 6212_22_ 2123_ 222_2_2222£_2 _21_’_ /222_2/ 222 /223,
_ _~r__£zr 6 3624 664 6//__'..1 644/4164 H_ £4/.1_/2=22-_
_ _/_6¢2-_1_ _6/66_»1_/:2; /{Z/__/__¢) /4/_¢_7_3__(22_/_€6_1/4»21_£4~_7£ ALW_____
_ _6:/_€2@_1-_-___ 6366;'/ "/Q 626/7§ 6126_/ /~?)_zzo_<`)_z%éc_ 6>__¢%6_ 1247Z
__/_'42»:-_1_ %_;_%/Lc ./_ ¢__C_ `/T_F//i/p/AZ_ £._2_;)_ 646627/:;_)1 0 /_Q_.»¢ //2

__ 2£'§_£1_2212< ___é_?_$:_ f 511 757 <’2>“”~ 622 _¢;»2)_2:1622)_)"_1_'2 22 _12¢¢121 525 '
___Z"zr_'_¢(¢?~:»~__/).__<_f'ha¢/ 9__2_51_ 22._)4__

 

a¢`»-%/.`¢')(q _ _

 

 

_.4?(/21,52¢/_1~2151_`1__/_6_»1_25_¢__/_,-4__@6_,_15»”¢5<¢/65[_6'_4)__¢2/ _6121/52~//25,.
2/’/2/ 2422 _2‘_2`_¢2/_ 215 5222,2/2_ _2_,2§_7“ _'6_;_7#222/_‘26 __ 222_
§§_2_ _.5’_7 ___2)?6_ §_..‘>_'7_. _4.3_/_ 44¢._(._ /722_2:u¢1112_-¢__/21 7/5746_4_/1/_ 55¢:21;/~___
.___£___g/Qe;f/_/_//lr 451 146 7{) 1451 14422__6_’45_/¢_.561__,>:4227_/452

4;/4/')_5':0_/2 5_"_1_45_ 7{<_4¢_54¢_545_-_%65>‘452/¢51_ :7_!:2:_1 642 __6£4'_£2_§_»_@_5_’=-)'_)_*_/1_45___

 

_Z’4 222/211 <:0_,_42:0_9_ d 2/_2-:__7_5/_?_5'_ ( .)' " 4 22>~_._21_55) 251/7 ),_2' 61 /Z»_

 

222/2212)_2 ¢/2_2_._2¢!_ 2_1/.2~ 254 2-,_,. 2r51>_,z_@_2/__)_)_2:2_42_42»1_2}_2;2/__

_ F_?¢l 7__$__2_ C_s`"_<,d,» 2755) 2007)_.)

__/67_ 1442)_56»_2/__1*_%26¢_6&_<5_445 %/79)//¢5- 562257Z

6{655/->"/@14-/ 1?45/ _/_)»_A¢z./___,€jj_/ és_/_‘_x..<_a 5251_6_(__ 6_7_£___`___
McAM%J_'/v_d.'°_€/1_£_@:¢_66_£_£_)__.45,?/4£/_-€_6(_ ____/'_/_/___`///' _ _ M~_)QZM /_j_@jp/¢//_ ¢-_/_

 

7£//7/5£

 

 

A//%£,££/'d/Z[ _W¢,/_ 7425 .x'_'//-

 

` MgM.fwm// J_£c_é._%_,e¢/_/LFM

 

 

_ __&_.»_»Lg_‘g__é __f_<`_;_? a z__,z’ 22 422 ___ 74 Z_A gf_g.cJ:_/_Z_»_gm¢;_ZT&_¢,__?_'>_JSI _
/_;_g_ ,Z,:g_¢ 2.¢4 -r/___ ¢_ Q_¢e»-/l _/_/_ _g/e_gé,,/¢z,_;__ ¢4:44£,~_"70 _c.,»\_»;/j_ ‘/g///d:_?¢¢?/____
_5/1_7_4_‘1;_~ _O_~g/ ¢_/`/_4»‘/¢¢:,`7;

                 

 

 

 

4 571 /,
£gZL/Jg/é / 20