Court Opinion

ID: 4045558
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:54:01.205763+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:29:55.079163
License: Public Domain

~ ~...._\.._''·;,
                                       "•

                 .::--
                         '    ..
                             {~

                                    ·~
                                            0   ~ VV'... '-~-\,_:s-'0-...'.-L~-~
    -
.                                    :--J.~..                              -                                                    -
                                     --s__'L~-~S-b.o. c...-r.:_~Q-~---

                                   ·1--\?-~~~~~.d...-~ ~"C>.'\.~~

             '
   This docume ·Ttontainssom·e
_p~g.es that a of QOOr quali~                                      L_~-, ~::"-             =         ~     "'--       0"

   z~ tho time o imaging.
                                                -
                                            -so          ~ """-"L- "'~-Q'C--....0_'-I_~" '<.__. -s~..._L~~                                                           o       ~   :::::,_~,_6_<:__o_'-,~ ~"'"'·.,__ __

                                                ~~ ~<L..">-~.::> ~~~"--~-~-=-~-=-,~~ ~CL,_ 1                                                                             ·--s._~.:.~~~-\o_c.._:u:_~_c,_) _ __

                                    C."-.""--.~.:.--~~~~~~-~-~-Q_--;. ,~_:_,_<:::> ~-.:::, ~                                                                      w "'"·, ~-~~-~~~:C..Y::6.~~-·-·
                                    ~ ""'-.~ ~ ~~· ,~.:_,_o~::.Q.._'f_.-~~~-~" I!_:::::..JL~x ~v.._·, ::,.~~.$)~<:\....:L,.v...._~~-'-----­

                                     s;.__o~·~.....:c ~-~:_, ~~~ 'y.__ 9- ~~~                                                       0    ~_:_,_v,:,..._~.:...:,   Y';,     ~~~f~~-~.;C ~~~~"'-~<:::>~....:. __
                                                                                                                            \           ._.   _______ ________           ,                                ·~---·

                                                0     ~ ~~-.IL-Q.c..._~"'                                       0~              -~~-~~.s.._~~ «-"                            J:2L3_,_       ~__~   :- . s~,~b.."-..,...--­
    ..                                                                  :c,__~
                                    ~-Q..___~:....-~~-·~~~£"~'-0-~.::::;~~                                                                ~-.::)~_.:::,~~_:,~ "'-                                   h_c.,._L~~2-~~j
                                    ~.:-.._'5 ~       ""'"-"'":-      :::::,.£,....::::6 c...."::,           ~0 ~-~~L_~,;::,'0.. :-:.~~6-~-<:.....-"~~B-..,<:._, __
                                                                                                     'v-_,~-~~

         /
                                     ~                      ::::::,
                                            '--"'--S-.~ _9,._:0-_~~_,_Q,~- _c.._
                                                                             _ '       .                 :s::                            \-'- ~ -::...'\ '
                                                                                                                      s........,_~-'~-j-'-..-~----'-\_·-)-:.\~--~-c_~_'L_~__&..._\:_,
                                                                                                                                                                                    ' __    "'
                                       l_o·o...:...L.~_c...~L-~-~~~-~-j--1 ~-"'-0-~.·~-':,_"-..),_6,.._, ~-~-."'/.... ..s...5>~~ ~::..~-•--1

                                                •.    . ~~-"--                   ~..'h..i::,. ~~_::._'D.o. D-.-<-~0~-~                                               0-...';{'~Q,.,.~~~;::,.~G,..~\.._~~C:.......":...o)..~_s.- -._
                                                                                                                                    .                                                   )
                                     D_-r_Q._<L:L-.~~~~~~.:_,~·, c,~.:s'~-~-~~~                                                                                   Q_.y,_     ~~~~s-~~£                     ______
                                     ?-"-0-~-~-·
                                                     :i~-"-'-"--~~~                                       ~:9-~G..:,_~=-~\;                              s_C....:..,~:,~-'--3 \-~·~5-:..\,~ ~~-~--- -
                                     ~-"-'s ~-~~~·-'-~) ~~~-~~_o~ ~ ~~~~-...:__~..:_,~~~-e__\S-~.\'~-c..,.~;__--1
                                    ~~_<-:,__b.....s,_~,:::;~_j ~-0.$_-."'Cv~~oi.:....:£,_ ~~S..o0                                                         \~ ~-""-'"'S_._Q_~~----........._-1
                                     n ~· ~~'L.:.:.-....~~,-~~'0~ ~-Q...~.~~~~~s-1-~'-'-.s~ ~..£-__'<"'_~L-~-~c...."-.:,S-~~.---1
                                                    -.       ~-~, .::,.Y:::-..E.-S:.-
                                                     ~~<L-'\?~                          _,:..., ...;..                      ~....s...::::,~..:{;:.s~~'-'-~~. ~-o~~""'·~·------~1

                                     :h..f:,_~L..,~~,~-:s               ~. :c:,.___~\_-~_:::LL. ~~-~;£                                        ~     1   L_ o       ~ '-~     .   "'-~-"=-"-o-...5:>-------l
                                     ~-<L--"~"~-L-6:.
                                                                      - o::.....r_~h.e.._~\_
                                                                   Y)c>.••

                                     ~ 'L9...~-u~~-Q._<i..~ ;-                                                    9   -.;vo._
      .\:..
·--
  ~

               -s~~            ~ · -«...,..:::{;,__;;,___~    G_a_g,_..-....;C.             -~ ~--e S:>....-c6...__~.=...:;,_~h_-~ S:>....Lo~JL":,

               ~ ~_B,._:.< "-:;,_..__~~. ~-~_.r_-:::,_~"_b..~-o....~ \,--.. ~.., _'v-                  ~·_ , _
                                                                                   _...,_Q__Q.....~~-a_:)    ~·-·-~~~

               ~~        ~~               \ "\_\     ~~"'.__\.._~_Q_~~-"-~" ~-) ~ '-"'-~ h~"'>~~'~S...-~ ~
              ~~S:,_~~.:_,_c:,~.                                 ~ ~<L_,_. ._~--r__~_"::,                              ~c..._~              ~ Q.                      "v:::, '-'-~
                                                                                                                                                   5<-..-.:::,.._C:>...              It_        0   ~

                ~,.:::,_cr_~~.-~_-c,_e.._~6_~~..:._'->-":>_..__o ~-~--::::. ~ L.-<~~~ ~Q....~

               ~Q._~Q......_,_~'-.\                                          \~""........       ~ ....-v--.._~~~-r-...:::S,_6,.. -........~-~__::[_<:;::>_c__<<._'S...S,
                                                                   \
               "\ ·, ~~-":>_,
                                                                                            .                                                           ~':'

                       ~     v-..._"-       ~-~:.,_ ~_,_o_-o-..'L.-r_""_,c...c..._~~~~~~.. -"/::>~~~~e_.;-:-~'\"

              (_ 0   ~.::r:: ~---=.::,~--'Lt~..:D...-Q,...c,.._¢_ .                     c._ :L~S::,_<L_~\c.....~.:o...~'U..s,~.:_,_~Q_~-~~
                                                                                                                                                                                                             ..

              ~ Q " VV'-.. R-~-"o,~h._<L_~-~·' ~..:,~ ~.'L"'-·
                                                                                                                                                        ~

                                                                                    S2-< ~~<"

                ~~~-· "~-~~-s ~-Q,._£_~...s.._~_;{'~'i~~~~~'-::,
              ~~-a=-..-:>    -c   ~~..s..,.                  L~ ~" "~~Q._\,..:_,_-c "- ~~                                                  ~:S-J,._~_b_\:)_Q..,_;e_6_~

              x_Q__--r_~~~                ~(\,. ~J              (j.__'{"     Q_\-..._~~-~-'C 0~c:.-~~h._<:L_~-~...:~'-\ ~_:,_~ "'                                                                   r

              G..   s~~~                  -rR._.6_           ~-~-~ ~~~~ ~~
                .                                                                            "-:,... . '-v.o-...-'--=-Q.....£....'L\.__~    ~~~-~~~)

                                                                                                              ~&f)Jh.w era                                                      ,)

                                                                                                                            ~ = ~~~~c._-c ~·--                                             (.

                                                                                                                              .~           1..«$~1-_e.,_ea_L
                                                                                                      ~-6.__-~.:f.:.....'"--."-;)_~~.                 ~~.l ~ Vn~t±
                                                                                                                                                ?-3 ()(2 \ .l rf- ;tj
                                                                                                                                            .
                                                                                                                                                K~l:e_ti~~~
                                                                                                                                                                                     Jli10
                                                                                                                                  ..

                                                                    <.....

                                                                                                                                                                                                        ..
                          -,

    ..::-       ,.    .
                     -~

                                                                c__· ~--c ~..,.,. ~_:_,...s,_~ fL_s:)~~-""--~                                --.,J   ~ .;:_~

                                   '
                               ---:::::.~\      ~ ~ ~VV'.~~-~ _L.,..&,_,                           ..                  ~--    \ cs      ~~   \       "-n:L
                                                                                                                                                               l
                                                                                                                                                                   ~0   ~IL'-~"s
                          Lg_-c~_, ~) ~~~-L'-.., ~S-'-"'-"'--:-~~-:::,_-r_-r_Q__~--L~~y~

                          ~h.~-~~ Q_j~.:.,~~:--~~-~~. . ~<;L.-~-~-~'L-~<t--r~S.,-~
                             .          )                    .
                          ::::s-~Q._          ---s_~--L_~                . c~~~                           s:::,   ~<:.__~~' ~~,-~w~~-<Lc.._,_\..s__a_~

                          ~.:_h.,~                                      6__c,_) o~~c...o,j'                                         {____\J ~-

                                                                                                                          ·--f---

                                                                                                                                        -s_ ~ ~~)~-~--_s.,\                  s_

                                                                                                                                         ~           \ S:, ~~ =="- '--n I_

            -
                                                                                                                                                                                   -

    -

                                 --;;:::: o__Y:,.__c...._<;,.      ¥:::- o      k-,_6-.__o ~                                        r

                                       ~      c.., :-c:   £>,,::) ~~'-"'-~-c_-c~ "-- s,
                                          e               -
                                              6'-..c\~             :::_---,~.;:._c__'\.    L~UL<L~S,.               ~~;::,.!:;_~-·

                                             B__...._'-s~.:..,_Y-\.,__1 ~            IL.':b,._c.._';, -   \Oo~~

                                                                                            ~-

~