Court Opinion

ID: 4055544
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:11:09.280544+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:01.648718
License: Public Domain

·~     .RFClE~VfED• .~~ L\
t.   i
         ..   ·
                  (        . · COURtn~C~HVliNAt AW~S .
                                   JUL 2 3 2015
                                                                                        1      ·.\

                                                              .
-_o~A~\)-u,J*~o±- M.~~\J~\-d~-o~-\Cl~e-~~t~t_tM ~-n1Jt t\(;)~~tl~~t~t~e.J_·_·· _
                                                                                              ..-.
 \r e.LJt~\J~JA-iLl~3LtLlt-~-ClC\-~_± ~-CO\l ~ ~ cALl-~-~ 1~J~~~Cki\:OLi\~    -
_fktt~il~1~_ein-~~·\:r~±~~v 1-\-"1---ttCAt~-~~c\ :\:V\tS_·Chane Lt()--(J-C(W_e
 \ L V\; \ . '""'- (\O L     ''\ .l...d  \ ~ _ _ · () I l r I \ ~ -r             lJ    J , .
-~- _;j:__ ~_()..M _ _:r~\L\-\-=\-l-,-~_t_O_d:_\J_\)_\_ll-t1-1=--\l-e-~-t1__u_=-,~-1A_,-:!__:__ .
_C(}~_q_tJ·_~ c~ Ck r-~_Q_~_QJ_s_~~-t_/) ~· -~~ l~ LGJlei}.u\tl_O-'l~-lA.-t\_~_:t-_c(,lA-t­
-~ff   ofd :\ha.!·_{kt_Q_L\~.-l-\.L<A-A~_:t_o_j£±~-~ ~~o_\) r *-'ttl:\-t)lf)__1:~ l&L1:
~\1~Ll~O \\ij\f~-t>~~s~o_/lt \\_Qf l_vSt_iu r~e-~ ~ ~-e_a.(s_o_ld       -
_QJV\c_~~-Di_~trJD_o~-i-~-Clb_~~~~~b-\o_e__lQ_~_o_ft~~~-O-Ld-ri.L\_g_­
I_\J_\k~-*"3-a_~L\_A_± \A ti't_\,±~:s ~~~-D-llt_~_QS~e-tv e~~~-~_c,_j_o_
·-~Jj_S_t)_os_o_r_1_lilS_ct_~t\£J~.C!*_t_O_(\s_:~~-wj_~_t_al\_o_Jtt~d's_fJe!_~_fy~te_,_~11-­
_\Ji~e.-~o QS_~ -~ ~-c-o_&_Q._~~ ~-s-et_6_t_u(\~-s-~e~do_n~ Le-± tv\~-ii~:~s . ·
__Q_\)_~t~e ·l ±~2-c_})_e-'-lA.US'_e._o_f_\kJ_S~c~ ~ r q_Q_._tyl~-~~ LL~-±t_LlJ_fu£_ .
_tf\ 1\-~~~j_s_i\o.f nelfl~_a.._qobL7o~}.tl1~: fiLl oLtslJlLLI,'-v' ·~
_b_tll\__j (\ h_~tt_CAttd-±~-lA ~-M-~JD.o~S-rktt-~D±-u1__(A_g_o_tld_-eJJ.VJ_lf-O-'\~~ "'-\-
~-               ' \ '\ \\-H:1~_\J_
"'i-'-~w_\h.~-~-~lS~Q,_w.      ' l-"='\-V-'-~~~-ltAtlto~~fA-eA-fu~().il
                                    \jA              I    r' '· . . ~l_at~nila.tLl
                                                                        l \ ' I (. h '                   r
_(}~~-~t~ ~LQ_t_~_tt_-\-o__:_\(~-W-~LM ~ Q. ~o_r_~_L\llli-~~lt~-~-~-~-ilt-v}Llu1t·
-~~-K~--dS~.Lg_o_t~ r o~ltl~~e__S1~~M.~---±-~-P-t o+ \t fe_-\-bL\t_-:t~<liL_
~-~-Jl~_Q_~-d-~tl sOi\~(1~_a_q_o_t>_d_~-\h-~_l!Llt\,_1__~e-e~~lA.-Ghuul_te-
_:!JO_~_tO~J_e_L~=-t--'--(A±_}_LV~-~~
        . \.L j...~ . ~. . ~         d.-t-Q.-
                                         1 ~ I         l              ' \_   . 1"'
                                              ~ ~ __. \ . 0~~-~~~S'-~\f~-UJUJSe ~
_\_~~; ~il1 f-LU,/\~ .\'i t_t~nM_\,JiSI).CnU) M ~ t S' ~-\r~UJ\&f_e&n0 -\-~Q                         i
_t\_l_~M-~f ~~~"" ~ t· ~l&~(lei\-~-1-o~e               CkV\ ~-:t-'--Ce.e~te_\_~ ~±_U;_d_ t\t
~\rno_\J_~_D'\J-±_v_~~tXl~~1--~~ ~ tlf, {! \ S_\l .Rt f_e~SS.DA-W h4-
_c_o-\l~-~~~~-,Co-~c~l1'i_tU11J~-~~~~L~-~ ~\ f\ co J flli_:_h_eLlll~S~e.~'-1.___\rl--l!·t
_'\/JJ~.~: ·~ft\Q:\-_l_o f\~_\_jo_Q~_tlv_S'~Q_·~ ~w lf<t -~ aS_~r_~~~(A~~~w}tb_{Y\~ .~ · · .
'Seco~~-S:Dl\"'CA±--\kL-\:l.f'l> Qf<h£\.~~~111± 1'S v\1\e~_-r, s-' ~ne~_\h_e                .. •
_Q_\e__CA.-=-b(f£~LJj_S_o_t_teJ! L\~~\J-LlS~~~. \~. i hLtt~h.-\:-S:~CLLtLO f
                                                                    .
'f"\\ a~~JL-~ Q_uJ ·w l lli~~~ l11 ~~'f-O_\JlL~~Y.s-/_D.ds.ll-_i_O_\L~ilt
                                                 '   .

------~--~.- ~\~-~'.~.--
---:----~-------:--------:------~----c--~~-----'---~'·

                                                         •