Court Opinion

ID: 3651242
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-07-06 06:05:51.032341+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:16:26.012311
License: Public Domain

A judge cannot, under the restraint   (312) imposed by the act of 1796, give an opinion in charging the jury whether a fact is fully or sufficiently proved, "such matter," in the language of the act, "being the true office and province of the jury"; and if the charge in this case had simply stated that the settlement was proved by the witness it would have been in conflict with the law; when, however, it proceeds to state that the settlement is proved if the jurybelieve the witness it explains the sense in which the word proved is used as synonymous with evidenced, in which latter sense it would probably be understood by the jury, who would then feel themselves at liberty to estimate the weight of the evidence. It were to scan the instruction with too critical an exactness to award a new trial on this ground.
As to the other point, the profession of a preacher does not necessarily invest a man with that purity of morals which renders him more scrupulous in declaring the truth than another man, for it sometimes happens that even the members of that sacred vocation are overpowered by the temptations to vice. That a witness is a preacher ought if proved to be stated to the jury that they may judge how far that circumstance entitles his testimony to additional weight; but even then a jury would draw their conclusions from his individual character and its correspondence with his profession rather than from the profession itself. The instruction given in this case can only be sanctioned by assuming the position that a preacher ex vi termini denotes a person whose evidence is entitled to greater weight than that of another man; whereas a preacher whose life and profession are at variance is less entitled to confidence than another man, since to his other vices he adds that of hypocrisy; and he who could impiously aim to deceive the Deity would not scruple to mislead his creatures. On this part of the charge, therefore, a new trial must be awarded.                        (313)