Court Opinion

ID: 4057604
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:41:57.141546+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:27:27.058927
License: Public Domain

'

    '
                 ,   '

                                                                                                <{6170/·-o~                           '
        '

            ,.
                                                     INIHE tOuRT OF CCifrrif'jAL Af.f_EAL~ FO{(TH/:.
                                  .                            .STATE OF TEXAS
                                                                                          cnr IRT ~~9EIVED IN
                                                                                                       '"". vnf/VIINAL   APPEALS

                                                                                                       l'tu v   17   2015
                         <
                                                                     M0,/44Sqz.q
                                                                                                                             .

                                                                        144-5130            Abel AcMt~ ~,.............,
                                         I
                                                                        144 (,(, r:; 1
                                                                      ·. ·14b88t3

                             tin _ce~I
                             Over/lie PenTofl Thomn51Jn,
                                                  I .         I
                             fp fAfo_cLefallltttt;
                             v.              .   '

                             Susan Bro~         . ·
                             f~ e.a-J-L/kftntl4nf-.

                                                                                     '

                                                                                         ihic   r!.~
                                                                                         oages    th;;"t::ll[ contains some
                                                                                         :~ .-~ · .       tare of Poor au:dih.
                                                                                             ' "' urn~     Qt Imaging.           -~

                                                                                                                                      I
,       I

    '

                           Q'tf.~ILLE DE~TQN T~Q~1~oN 5
                                                                           1
                                                                                 !1eELICATioo             EO~     IJ.RIT QE.
                                                               HABlEItS · CQRfUS

                                                     l~E~TI[~            QE       EMTIES                                                  -

                f., O..v.e.cl.l/.~_/)_e!ITof.L7htuY.\fSort Jr..,_(R_e.l~c 4.nJ_Efal.t~tlff_lt2fj_o_/ltJJ=i!J~Ltl_()u.siJJ.t1 ilxas..:llCJOZc,.
                                                          1                                                                 1
            2, Sus an BDll1Lo_f&s.pondeiiT an.d.Je:rud(ud:LH.ono.~jle_.l.M.~.e_oi ·thLl35.:tlL,J(,{d/ct~L/2;~ta.c-t
                     ~UJ:._tJ..
                        :t f_                   tJ.l:KA£m
                                      ' eo.Lett~-
                                  & t:Dll                . A.rD.5'             n -. ' '
                                                                , coqn.'f Co.l!llll4-L~.IAL
                                                                                        · · c..J.4rr/         · n21JL
                                                                                                   _f_Ce_cgf1L_e_c _L_

                     f.can.lsltn 1LZ1iL£lo.oc ltku~n1_rexas_,_ZZ()j)_Z,                                       . .

                                            r
                                                         '

            ~

                 1
                                                 TABLE. OF CO'JT£NTS

             '5, · :S"hlteroe.rrtaf. Juo's:J/di.~tJ_ _ _ _ _ _ __.E~~I.__,_ _ _ _ _ __
------~-·*I~~u~_tw~n~d__________________________~---

             ~I Sfatemen~L()f        Fa ct5                      f~es 5-0

             S, ~~UI!I.etCt                                      E43.es_1- q

                  Er:ar-er:                                      t~e-· LO

                  V.ec:f;ca±l'on                                 P~g___j_l
     (   .

                  fj     J                                       Eqg£Llt - L7
                  -P·f-SUJ4li.
                              I
              I

             q_, Cer:.1J            Co llM.Ct'
                  . 1:'J.ctr~__p_f_--~f                          ~49·e_l8·

             /0, [gc.tLn"'cal€e Qf   Sc.c~;ct
                                          I
                                                                PtJjL13.
                                                     INPEX OF AlJTHOKmES

                                                                                 r '
------~~~~~~~~~~~----~-~~~'3~-------
------~~~~~~~~~~--------~~-'~.~~J3~---------
                             Pyes 8//3

      ll   ~   ac:d iL:   state,I L0s.w,stU.11 0111~                   f~e5   8,l 14
      i, f~~fJrt.af..U1lE~o.n£1:1Miflll                                rtlJes 1,/q
                                                                               I
     to.   Ex_f4rft       l?amzy (5"u.p,[9/J)zttH S,rJ,W               PdJe.s   8111
                                                                                  I

           - pttde Shoe~ (Ap.p.L'f_j.lit.JJ1!: )6i3 .s; w. £J 7fo I    fye>     8,/q
                                                                                 I
                            .neJ/±pr_._k Q:ff:Z/JoJ) i(8 S,tJ,JJ K1J   P"je.S . 1,/~
                                                                                 I
                                                         tl   '        p
               ~    !

    ..

          t~        51:$.tl?rrne~~dm.trtt.f-f.he_liaHIJ..JJA-trs~M.tti:Y.t;'Dn           e~e.s         7114'
                                                                                     ;
          ~. fo~rd:b..ffi!IYJdtne,i"tc~JTh/~nstfMicll                                    ~Jes~7-;-d.
         ?j;, _tlarb~oJJ_v:,_f!.kJ!1ur.r.ay-<~f' mz)L1~-T~...L1k;                        fq_ges        8;~-lj.
                    .12.8 s, V, id_U~

         z.:z · .flLr.e_ftfer.Jdpp•.IP...P.ist._tooJ)_/P.S.-J.~M1LL0..7-
               ~-                                                         r
                                                                                         fa_qes        ~_/~
         21, Mt~u~. ..5.:tJdL(JeJ,_Cr$bff-··1.13k)-11f~,J1.;.:U_Z$J                      ~Jes ;_15
         .z_q, . ~/t.t/i.ltmetJdtnenl:.c:E..the..tit.I±J_S.ta1Es..f:otJ{(ftt!llifl       &ys_415

                                                                                                                 -

                                                                                                                     '

-
                                                                                                  --

                                            ·'

                                                                                                         f-~.e 2- af_/_1.
               fl

...

                                                        STATEA~ENT Of_THE CASE

                      1b.uelat-or1 Over/liL12orton1hof!lpSL1L/.s_ ch4~_ed ·bJ'-~~~J./c.:h:!t~ll-t- ~~Th -tke
               , offenses o-f : l)f.P5?es~/o() of a cintt:o_/Led Sqbsfan~-f;e11a.fty-j-CO..I/f_l7_klf~J5ef_.2iP.IL
               . o±r~~_c~fl-1-ra.lled syP5iJJ.nce. -f.J!jjAJtr--!Jaup. 2..-; !L~~~-f..tlS.?·ess./on of £/ceac/!17_·
                 a.od_:t)_t:r~_ydec, 111~Cdcrhc_coai:l!.~ds ti1al- h/s /ll Cdrcect~T/on /s /1/CJB/ f!nd btlS
                 -t,'/ed an oc~LntA / apf-l/ctJ.t/on f-or wc/t Df htJbea.s cor~us -:&r ea.ch of the cas.es.J.n_
                    11J~.__l8E5t/.1_.1w~.Lc_iA.l P/str/c.:-r Ccurtt>£_Jf-gr~/s G;u!l1jt-;-Tex~~ oVer ~h_~the
                    Resr-onJ(.~1.1Jt Susan Bco.~-LJl-t_CJJ.r~ntlf-fLe.$.MI~,_Ihe Respanle11-f- c..e:f1ses to ~earfe
                    tb~w.c/ts as l4.w.Mly-pre1cc/lwl_;_n_i/1t).T ·the acde~r et~d.J_a.pp.ll~tl.uJw..tLe been
                    Leit.v.:o../d    I                                              .

                       lo~J:!.a!~-IE -IS -ooq1t3 ~ C€1_/!i- IS- 001_05- CR J 4-JS- o_() q()(;- CK-,~_anJ_/!1. -lS-
                                                                          1
                00'/0 7- CR. 1J:i,t:_&latP.r: ;./3-     'e k_er_
                    . tj_o_LI!l    3 _2l11S_,
                                    1

      .,
                                                                                                      ~J-e...Lo£Jj
            oN

. ESENTED
          !!

                                                    ST~TEfVlENT QF            F6,CTS

     l,         I t: 'ff ()
           _P-1a.•f.l-.      :J.L t               1h     b
                      ,_1J:!Y..ec. e__ ~-~fJ..fl/U_o.mp>-o.n-        b . I C.!A~d.
                                                              . .a.s._e.fJJ_UJ   v  r- Slflc.L.JLc_o.
                                                                                         I        0 f; kec-;-~'---
                                                                                                               t'L      ':/_
            fac +hree o/.d_p.en.J/nj~ .ch~ ~.eJ_,iJ___fAfASe_liumb_l'i'iS12.11_fj~Sq3o-;-a.J. .
          . L4.:1.6.kS Z1 s tr-L~. J2..i::JJd:Lo..f. TexALl!.· Drt.ea'll.e.-Th.omf.S..C.tJ.,_Th.e_J.o_cuete.il-TI_ped:/n.ertt__
            t"o tb!s CA.us.e__are_as_fl£t.J. :

                                    ctJtah~cfltiLfd_QlltL&.d«~W113.ecv..ed_/J1l1vj.Jua I'f-
               tl. • ~etlfiotJ fer Wn'T                                                              for each case.    Qll.ce_

                 c,L s 1~'1 /J.ot5 d/l_d~a.g.aur.L,1Ll iuHs_.
                                                                                                               /.

           tttr.pl/~tictJ fo.c.J!.ot().:f.Jli!.k_Co.qu.s_s.e.r:.vd_o.,:~   sh!uts_,
~

    1-, · ElA.:a:t/.ff. has_b&rL/n c~Jy.21.nce fl1ay_/9-t ~ 15_for_tLce.l.at/ve.y_fJ_e.~CdSL£~fJed_,:a_
           Caus.e_&_Lqk8.8t31_rty.l.ed2ta:tLo_f T_exaLv_,.iJ.v.ecl/Lu_~~IJ.l-Tbf._d.ocum.etl~pt.d:Wen-t
                                                    ..
           to tbl.Lca.us.LarULl/sted :        -

                      -
           4     fet/t/on -b.c.J.J.dt:..~.:EJ!JJ.~ CorfJtL-ndonL8~L"d-JMLsiPv~d/~n :z/1.Z;ot5.l

           b. J1fp.IJ.0ft/.M_fQc 1Jd:f:..of_Jmb.eas-1.~fUD.erveJ ~uJ 1/l(t.-o/5,
                                  -

    J; :~fenJ.all±1 Susall_Bro.w.IJ-t.has~c/.eac...fu.I.Lk.no.w..I~Je-~f_i.mpcapec_pco~J.ur:e1_exculpgto.9'--·
       · ev./Jen.c.et4n.d_car.J£b'i-Mtr~n.aL_e.coo:1 bf_t.!fl_{~_:thCQ~.b rhe Elaini/ff- ~ fcor.er::'y_fag_J
               app.l/~/Qn~o.d_Pf-taio.tJLn.r:_wnto£ll~~o.r:p_U~t:..rb.e fla/ni~~ff_!s_m_~~'o.t '/tJ_
      . these         ~$.g,S_J's_bo_tb_JJ_p(lill.ii.v..e_and_IAfl.law.ikll_y.et the
                                                                               Pmn.d,u,-r cori.t/LLqes -ro J./s.abT_
               l~r./I;-hlh.f~b_v./o la~th.e_f/a/.l)±lft. 's c0-lftLtc_lt..J e. ard_and tiJ f.l.o.Lb.e._dt,p.c./veJ

                                                                                             e4j.e~b_f_fj
of
    .·
                                                                   ,.

                                                      tig~uru~~r

          l, . I{l_the-4kllce           of the /55Uance a-f tl11' s        1
                                                                               Vel+- (1-f- liAbeas ~r:pt-151_fL4/nt/fi;
               ; .Ov'l.o~lle_lkrrt~n ]j~,..,f.iOJl;_bas.    fltJ        pfher adrq_u.ak. remer_a_L/AVLL~             +htt:f f

                a Pef-end41Jt- ~itll! .Bro..w:lJ!La-Fwsa.l To ober- wr/+- v/b{ahs -:f-'Aid/.flj-f-£/11-~/t.s_o_f-
                  I

               · l11~ hr~d.e!lf-i.!JjJ:hL£1a,~tlff h/s r~hT to h_e_heard aJ1d_h./s_chkt- n '1!--t ke
                   Jf.pt~:v..e_d_o..f_llkecty_W-J':thoiAT d.uLp-[0,~~5. of /~W-f_Ur5 wtnr:t!LArt/cle 515ec.t/o!J_
                   8 ttt1d /trt/ c /e I 1 se.ct/o.ns 3 1...1A_lf~~t; 13; tt/:ld_/:1_£-t tlv:.~L of_ thLUn,ted_~
               •rA·,.JSt'fuf/tl.lt;.aflJ_fa:b~{_es_Lj, 01/_l/ ;051_l/.!..l0..1Jl,_l/tAllJ_l/J../£_o._f fht._T_gi(~LCoJ_e_Q..L_
                 c.t:J.I!tl./.1.4.
                     .; I I._ fl.co_c.e..tI.u-r:-~ , .                                                      ·

                                                                                                                        /

                                                                                              ~9:e-7-oLL1..
                                                      I
                '    ''

               "
            3, -··i]ie~tPhtinfdf. lla5J-L!1./ri--1JL~:/z.er4f/.en_j,f a s~J;;-a~litfb_It#.IJ_o£ t6a:,_bihL~h_h~-

        .
                Aftt.Lt'lfe.J_(Ir-' e~,f, ~d_a.li47_5_1La.dop+ed_//1 . EX v-/)(/[te &t1zI v_(S'up.L1[J_)_~fl:Ls, tJ, ZVJ'

                  n'._,_s_.Afphc·' m_'..J.JL7:o.c_r:.,__o.,
            ~I .___                          " M t-t __H    _.a.h
                                                            _£        c · ' , 'L_c.e&.r-t~.n.
                                                                -~as__acp.u5_rS_tLcJ.V.J               , ' J'lQJP..lL
                                                                                             d d-::J-u.D~     ' t:
               ··llf. .s_«~b-l~.l~v..e!Lrhf.-4ff-~j_fA1f_co_~rr1Lej-4cJ_less oi whditec fc/sfm.ec. /Ld_e-bJ~ eJ_._
              I.. UILJ~r c./v!f oLI:-c/t!l,~4f_p-cace55 aMJri.ud.cp.te._tG'n l{;,rbireo v. & M'='f (51Jf'JJ~2l_
               · tla_r.ex_,_L1ZfJs3 s,w, zdJ:t_L{,

            5, ltj.t&.~LbaLno_J./zc~e.t~oLl_to_bM'-e                 s#t:tutor_c.eru/rel!lf.nts, See Edwt.!cd _v. st-o:IT1
                    lOS,M3)_k_1_t_(J!1i.1.L)JicH-. o_-C. ~.s                     hi:...d£tJ.J~ed1_!ih ere -jCtJ.n+/~_af /-1-
                                                                        CI>LfJJ.S_CAIJ!JlfL
    -
                    f~aJ.e_,_'tnperah've          d.?_   ~ sfd:lyk..~ Click v. Stm__( Cr, lif-f-' lf!iltJi.Iex;.Ca'eL__
                ':LO"-t 1'1 5, w. Zl.JJ.f ~ ll "tn'd / courI w..~i./ Ufon ..t!Jue::fin.dAllt:s r-ce.cfi.ttv_;c,fJ_t:J.1
                pe..tlf,'liJJ1 .f!.~:dJ_w_tt5 tb be setved_o.tLi:he shen1f. or courrty_r:e$.f..P.ni/Jzle_f£d:h_g,_
'

                    /J./_~9"·Ug_1Jnfi'on1.w_b_ea._f~ti:J-.l.w_w..a~r.J..illnii~.tlJr,~S.Qmf-l'~ncet"o.J~~1lriT w.d£b_f._

                                                                                                          f'!Je_8.__o£   I~
. g

      ·14coe ( App, (:, P/st '2003) 1/3

 ,.
ER
                                                                                                                              VER ICATION

              I,
- - - - + + - '~CO/ANJJ OF                         HARRIS'

                                                                                                                                                       I.
                                                                                                                                                       I

                                                                                                                                .   .
                                                                                                                                    ;;

                                                                                                                                    ~
                                                                                                                                         .

                                                                                                                                .   /
                     ·,   ~~--::~.z..~~~tt<•.'.~_jl!\::;).~-~.::.'.- ..);.~~-~, ...·;:-~-.""!<..t:::~.;.·~-' """>'. :l   ..

                   SUBSc
--~----~~~~~~~~~~~~~--~~~--~~~---f-
                                                                                                                                             s /{) ·
                   015
--------H"''UflWnS 40 .tmJ suklec+be/oa cespcns/hle               for +be abuse (JftM:.m'v//eae!  4/]J 00 ~~~ shqi/ Pvec be biHSfJ cHdn.'l/114 the '.ibert;v
                 . /         ,J "-1   J    r                                           r
                                                                                       .
                                                                                            '7- 1
                                                                                                                     .
                                                                                                                            r.              7

------=+-ifLlW-1"""-"'=i-=""-""'-""-/3   af::tl~~~E-2/ CRUEL fttJPUtJUSuAL PWJr~tfM(WjREI!J~Y.B'(PIJE CoUR£f0F:_~

                                                                                      r~nor ccue I oG    . Iauo/sJ,,.,.,!It/af!t'c:teLW cou~fs 5haU he ollgn,and
                                                                                                    . unusual                                           I   I

-------"-'+-flU-~YG---4-"-~~~~~~lULZJ.Ll.L(JUIIUj_(i;:$piC.J+-PtJ OF CoUR.roFCfi.rMCNAl-AP/fAf.S).,Cc)Su0'ecf-to s-uch rejulat/cas
------~H"-'wwtlf¥r:~y.JML,dile Coucuf Lr,'lrl!'nallrtfals t~ad tlte .fu~e$ thereof shall bgve -the rower tp issue. the wciTof:_
--------t-1-Uakas             Corpu} ,_,_,_Ihe CQucTdJg/1 har.e
                                 r
                                                                  the. r
                                                                      RD.Iif!.[   UDRa qff;'Javftcc ofhenvlk 1?J tJScef1af'Q
                                                                                  1
                                                                                                                                SUCh
                                                                                                                                       .
                                                                                                                                           mfter:5 offac.f mon.J~td,'s_c.I.{StoJr-1 e:c_unJer_his.,:eS:tca/nf;c:oml!l~~~~a/_fidur.e,flt!1'1..f!mfNf??.,.Tbd~a..apt~~m.J_;.ha11.h£_f:he_e.ltd/gfL4p,(_w./Us;h_:tkjuJJe..c,Ul_
--------HJ.ev.o.fLT.o_h£Ar./n;_thLCtJ.us.e.at..the.apph.'u.n-t____________________- _ _ __

_ _ _ _ _ _i~ ftdicfe_/I,J~ff.:tii~L[t?Xt!S~Je..of.C:~·/!l,'tlaLf.rcce.tL«r.e,IJRrT GRtWICJLWJJ:.tl~Uf.P.C.UI.'It.Tfte.w.r.itd..ha~cqliS...sha.ILb£...jt:n.iJU.I!tHhoift

--------HJ.ef4y. b:y_tl~jJ~,g_co.ur.t..r.:ece./v./'J-t.JtLfdt'tfD,II1mlefs ,'j-_];.e_pltJni."f1ft.tr.om..pe.tliiM..iiS£.1f;or J.OC!1.!!12.n'll..dti!O~LtoJt;:i:htJ.tf6e_
-------H-f;dr:ty_t'u..nt/1/.d_tll tuL.a..l~f_whatJ:.t!.et.~'-.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
_ _ _ _ _ _ /5. tu±ic.k.ll.J£.a£t.be 7ix~ Ccde_J:...Cc,'m,~aLftoce.dua;.,fl/f{J]ff~ f.tNIJ.l.:Iy_EQ8..fJ,JJO.B.~YX,Jf5_Wft/;;:£.1Jily-fenM.diS.~~~~--tl~e~wr./J:.c.L_
-------+~1utbe.a.Lcor.pus.s.h4l/_eds-oJ.e_//ak!t..:t~_a_ci~I.L~cfi'Dt.Lati:/-,tS;...~/t ef tM_pat:*J_kfa,~J1 4nJ.$.1141Lf1-J~1..5U&h_.5u It f/fl:y)IJ/Iar.s_
_ _ _ _..;..__-+tfo.r...e4cb~day_a."t//Lej4.{-J.eten±fa~:~-4J.J:fftc414'ti.afur- seo:./CJ! of:::thi.w:r:it.~ha/I_~_Jefm.eLthtrf:t~-f!.I:SC11-Aas~J.J~berJ­
--------HI:tbe.,;ll'::it.ldho_4da/llS.4-fr./soter_,;_/o,~.erJ.t'«-t.hll.tLtbr.ee...J.ays-t~:f.:ter-.s..er..v.L'cLikn!of;.ual~wber.e_bd./:f.,c..."b:l!le_/s..a.llcw.e.d-t'LtiJ.g__

------t-t'wdt.i.P.L~i~f,.r:e.tkrd:hm.toJ                                                                                                         ~
------=/~,. ftrtide.JU!l. o.t.ihLT~t§CqJg_ofCr/,~/naLfr.os:du.~.R£.FUSI.t1.G Ia 5JfQlff;_ kJKIT.Itn!-c.ff.;~e.r...n whom.a.w.r..J..'-t.Df_hak!ALC4r:pus1oc.dkr_

---------+t~r:~'t1JoLat.r.~f1t.~r:..pr.o.c.~.J_au:thor.:~gJ.Jy_ih:S-:-CJldp.Rc.shall.l"-..d,'r.ec"kJ1_J.e//v!..cr,J_c_d.e.o.JmJ1 .1ihc.~es fo exeg~~ :tfle~al!l~-
--------++"·•4~~ct:tH~J-~hrs.
                   1'               ..J-'         h                     ~          '                n' ,. ..J
                                                            1 1 ,.ay.Lt./lt..$_et:VJ&C_ar....ex.ec.u_tU:t_oLt.ll.e_S.al'tl.e.
                           • J'u::e.c.t.JC.fJSlcLvL...o_wanhnr-'l·e.                                                            lllk 11 U · f,' · "
                                                                                                                             1.u.~-- _crutJ_'"{] _;n.e_as_7J2,t:__
--------------;T~~~~~to£~w~~--------------------------------------------------------------
------r:/., It I: ck v. Stm (Cr..:Ar-f1-LWli.JE.Ie.(,..lr.il!l'-/.f.O!f.pi1.2',kf., tJ J1 I.J.cit..cih4kos_co.J=fULC4nl1iii:h.e..J(!Jl/~d1'wJl~f:t-Jtat111',~_,f../1-
                                                                                                                 1

_ ____c_.--'---1-1----------------·~9_e_l3 ~£jj_ __
------,,....------+lf"LL.-"-JI'Uo<"""""-'='..u.u-•a.t:       /nJt'ctmentaftLGrnnLJ.ur.~~~cc/m/aa/ c<~ze ··to be a ~o~l+nef£ 4ja,'nd- lum5eff//JtC
-------·~------+~~~~~~~~~~cr~t~o~r~·p~fch~v~,~wwH~hue«t~d~q~e~p~~~c~ef~i~ff~~k~w~:.~
                                                      ~~            .            I . 4,------------~----------

                                                                                                ' , C..o.ym s'al{ mat. no law", 46ridJ'Y          the freedom of speech I ,
_ _ _ _ _ __E::::~I:QJ.U:Lfgl.lllLttmf.~afli.LALil~.'m:ted Strfes ~Jli1M.4/Lpeooas PoCJl ocM.fBral/ud /n                                             the llo/kJ 5iif/?$ 4/ld ruJ:jec+tc tbe.
---------+t-fW..L>.!I.LiolJJILI..Lli!<'-"•!I.Lt-4re
                                                                                   . ,.wJ. dth~
                                                              .-m'uos dthe ILJitd sm-i')                          Sfm     !vhere/o the.v rw'Je,Na $tate shall Make areofme
                                                                                                                                     r .                                              r law. Jic.b
                                                                                                                                                                                    4t1V

                                                                                                                                                                           . on. of Hfu, h~ettv,
                                                                                                                                                                                 .. r        (I
--------+!!lll-fli-I'~.LJ'-..I!£L.LLUIW-<~'-{ILJJJC..s:.P~f(~ouf-'/l.!oo w!th/o /is /uci{J:c1/ao ·the eauaf a!""!ihct'on   aft/Je laWs, .
                                                                           .    I       .   I        ((J                                       I    I

------...!:Z4i~OIIilii.loor.i.-~~~+.rs~uif-p.L.L•I1.uq~~>u.m.a;_.Lw;,eXru,~,J.1t/S8 Slw,ul .zalf, -;:-;-,'5 rule effi:.dw.i courT< iwd cfthw siam w/u'c/1 da notJ:v.lJt__
                                                                                    '                                                         .                        .
                                                                                                                     .                                                     .
                                                                                                             "•

                                                                    .                                       .                                                                                   .

---------++t"'.ua!.U.J""'-SLL..,..J.U'rdr-:-l¥fdlare court'~ .u ip civil !lnJ cn't:>,'n!!/ C4Sf5t t/ur/:4                      /1Jg4S   ccrpus f~if}j if a c,'v,'/ reMeo/l'!>. JiifM_juiJk.

                                                                                                                     'u

                                                                                                                                                                                    1'1
            ce,;ftA:,,t1itfthfs_h4iLw.M...ex~s./v.ey wb~cr..-f.d:ltiDo~:~bmntMJf_c;._p_;nr-J./gLwl:t.L,;,_1uir£.1'!1~c..sJtLch.petl:b~as..1 alld_w.r./:t_
            wa.s.o._ne..of..r-!JhTJf/Je.r~n£b'1ut-/~liJ ·
    ~ .. _l.frlcGee v, SM _(M.J:.o~~f.f-' 11¥27-Ll s~_/ti. ZLZ:5..zJIJe.lJ_tf,dtfhe_fr.:,~~/_cp_ucf:_w.4~kunLt:o_c£.tllff-w./JLthe

           _.l!laad41k.(-fAnjMd.j~o.f_fhLs:h.flcf:.e.)
    zq, . 5_i_x:tAjtJ!Iwd.~t~~n±c.t.t1Jg..fJnil!.d S:tt...-fu>....foM.i:itu+;ofk_Irut.U_cr:/m,~~~~Lfr.o.sc.(L

                     Glt£.ti:HOJI_fo.r:.hio'±.o£ltAb.eaS: CcrfU5_$.e_r-v_d-::-f1./J

                     G/)Ltpp.l/c{{t/.o.JLTII IJc,~tQ-E tf_4/;g~ Co.cf-us_.s..ecv.ed_~/.1. 1fj !..tolS,

                                                                                                             f~!!.__/_,G_()£ I~
                                '                                             .   I            .       I
    ReiA'f(lf' has. !ncm             a·hd /n ·the AJJnenJ,'y -th,~ Affi'dav/T, .
I                           1./{}/

                            I                               II

                                                                                                                   I
                                                                                                               I

                ,;         ''>l:1~.f'   ~~.nlk'"Zl~ eJq)~   t.j,t;r. iW, WH
                };

                                                                                      -/   V       I

                                                                                                           0

                                                                                           J
                                                                 t'-N6657

                In         re·,,.        '
              1 Oven' lie fkn1on        7horn-pson,
                                                I

                v.
                     I .

                                                    CEKTIF!CATE OF C0fr1fLIItNCE

                       fe.lator 0r!er//le Penton Th~irlpSon <1Uhm,'-/3 thfs
             · ·..
                                    1                        1                      h/s Certlf/ca1e of- Corn,a//ance    /n_
               l+hP tJIJOve.-rllph'cned CAuses,I brw'~!J s-e01ed         t1t1   aotJ!/caf/on De we/to£ habeas
                                                                                ~r              ..
------+~lr'o_J;pus on the UJurTaf Cc,'m,'fla{               ltppeals   /11 ltusi-/t11TW.s1 anJ      here.kt cerT/nf.s
               itl"ar -rl1e nwn/;~er of Wools /n ·the lffflt'caf,'oa ,'s /550               .              .

                                                                                             faaf    J8   tJ~ 11
T!
.,

                                                                                                              '
                                             No. l.:f~S~tj
                                                  jq~51JO

                                                  14~0657
                                                 l!f.k.&3t3
                                                                                  -
•.

     Io_c.e.i
     o_"-e.dlk Pen1vn.Ib.o.m f-SIJn1
     Ke lator and f_i a/nfl fC.
                               1
      \0
     Susan Brovtn - ·
                      1
     .&s.p.o11.d~f.Lt_a.nJ_j)_ttendanr,

                                 ~.

                                      CEKTIFICATE OF SERVIC£

           11 Ovec!I/LP.nshn_Ih.o.t!JpiOJJ.f-':;.ectlfJ-tharoJJ_Novenk /~, i-01~5        tLWiL4tld ·
            92ff-o..t t11Lfcece.J.,/y_llf-p.l~c~:tJo.t.l~fo.c. tJc/:t Q.-E. lft_..bea5 ·Co.cr-us_h tts JJe~n-
     Icacr:e.cd:

. lserueJ. em tl1e. CourT~ Cr/f"~/nALiif-f-ca&_/JL!tusJ:z'rL;_Tixas_o/- l),S, Ma,~L .·
                                                                            '

                                                                    IJM., jJt,:A~~-t;;;:;·~            A~tz.
                                                                                                   I     (I
                                                                     O..v.t.d./J.e_P.£JJio.l.l-1.h.u.mp>on7.J.c.,_

                                                                           f.a.J.e_Jj_tJ..f I q.