Court Opinion

ID: 4049329
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:55:35.475139+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:29.339537
License: Public Domain

531@\30|‘0\)03163)0'““
RECE|'VED
couRT oF cR:r.wNAL;i§PE/u_s
`JUN 08 2015

AbelAc . g
‘“\*D M QLEM voa ~m€ QL\WLTOF Gahunwn_ AWEAL)` 032@’ lam
P<\BEL AMSTA ’

QE: Qo;®u€sT?oQ &>uFlfzvuA.~ww oF b€LwE»¢.\/ mr ANL!MT.¢M sz_ wm¢`oF
Hmem corzc>u\s..v

\\.\c \ AQD&¥€\`

Qu'uj{hgs `, Enclbsed p\mse.\q`ncl a rarpe.c:H-`w\ e?h made,*\) nw lwe/lola @CUvnly
mmch guam , ` 4

‘\’LEA)'E As§asYMélw THu MM'TEIL
4ch mae mo §Froa'¢` u @,rz mv ,+¢>r)/wcmeo .
éno,\b$d‘. §ZEME§`T (zpq; .`)
E)dn`\\§\\' ('Z, Qg§) »
QAYQG¥MM suLM.'lJeJ line .S`£‘ Zolj'

(~}akn`d C‘a¢cbnc.£ lllll%?z
Al\ Q»z(i linn

;llol F_;H.z£eq )u.

7 ma ~\£ excu 7103/37

    

 

 

 

 

 

l_`c>u(\"é¥ \lr`\w\. Appea\$ no w Q»(unlfnl§¢~‘*%
&"'¥>ade`_.(l\a\mse/\ gude ` ~ § \'n TH€ L\C¢*“ dumc\AL
f\>\§rrz\\\:( wm
§ DE@U COUI\\T\I 4'1'(:7_\(-)\'5

§

RE®uESY 'POR comv\a\\/\AT\D\) 0'\= D€u\)EQ\l`oF ADDUCATIONS
h VOR man 0¥ HMS€Q§ CNl'Pu&‘ -

\§OQ Qa>w\e;s Qm\m`\el Ql(do@c\ .G-pp\`\@@\f\¥\>® S@- 4“:‘/`;€\:9°{4{°'“°4“2§'01:;0')+
9 tm ` r f

mu\Lu '\\r\`\s (Qc\ues¥ ap QL>n *"(mcn)r{an op ”De\lu€v\\ up 095
.~,€ Ha\oec;\s Qbmux,cmd I`€spec}£».\\q would Slu)u ~pr ODUA#¢JS ~o)/ows.'

\

\ Qaa\oAL\ deom \>innq \>rueh\\\l 'w\acjreem)(?e;o\ in 4*\2.‘(€¥03 'DQPar+n/\enlo{
(:‘u-`m;“a\ du§icz lmde "\mv\ak \d v\u¥v\\m( \L\W'\U)Z. am Eom’llpd€n¥ 744 make.

’\’\w ‘¥\.“Dwmg 8461-1(“/\.0“'\2$ eu¢\dl(` PQ¢/MH\{ op PQ[`(L[(\{! bémg ~\'<`\)L Cu~o( Ce`( re,c.+.~i
\ Cn»~\ 341 app\kouv\-\ 444 "\ book cc \-la\>eas G>rpw‘ lha\»we¢£ 1£|`/€(/ m ‘~I.SO.I_S'

`m '\\\a\~\qb""§`\s‘\~ric¥ Cb,ld.w@\o|o "\ n¥\¢ laredo .`\'@m§. An "mc@ex,-o( 1442an will
41 pmc\ed \\mi¢\ af"€x\¢\\' 44 \`l 444 0 ' 4444.\ dc.l¢# ¥ ham_r\c¥ ceo@.'.ue@l a o¢\se,_
§vbm“\o.’\)ls)me¥ Qle(¥ \w\\' 463 w_ se 44\<'. Cm"`\va\¢s er de,\iucaq<>_FM wild or

. 444:;¥5<\\0,4{ \m:w@ haw dulq dolko,lfc| empl »(§"\ecl. l ~4\114/4|4£:'\§2/1404 \e,H€¢-k Jrl\e C(erk
\'Q£\uQAZ\Q Sl,\£.\»\ 0000`4(¥¥\043(1`0¢\ ')n> do Cu_\cu`\. \ ve&a.`¢u@cl a \§jr€¢)¢€$ QQSp¢mILb\/}~pp|\€a `vv»“
xvi GHC\A haul %\e.d hk\' w\jd)\u,\¥ \>€i¥\g SAUN\>¢;£§ Qs“'\:l\.€O n k\\"(\¢\e,~(\,\€rk. §jrboo§
vm§r dimle of 5€44)€(1 \)\{ -WL'Q[€(K‘QM\ 411 olch v\ol con)rcdn 4\/\0,»\.0<14' numbe r_
Sue\/\ (€s\)&nse 6404»2_\` an Z?_iZDlS'. \ 414er \c>c§y ch MmamnclLim }n rep}a/
4b 3<\\cL S\CA€.> resumes m\ ¥4\1; Z,n¢i cicu; 09 june Zc\\`.- ` '

\ \.

3021¢§1 pa¥'\ims and ouem\\ ¥{\1~/\`9$ wem mca`\\ed via O€r`\'?`Ge£} W\a¢`\ 1 C€r'j(.

vw. \>€\`~Ag "lb\L\ \\S"LO' UD\~ZQLl£/qu¥f ». €X(>Q.e,\ed delivery dak. L//éo}l§`» 'weig H'
op 014th S.‘lo oz,($e€ index Q=r n`l¢hgs\ Av\.>\ll\er MH§ £e.d ci\}v\c] was mado_ via
CerL`R`v.¢l mdl\ c.,-\_§\§n&¢_` ac am AF¢IJQ>:\‘\' a~£ rods \`44 Suppo,d~m£ 'L,m`v|a¢ (\e(~L~ no_\neing
1014 »\~ NL\-wlquzq*s 1€@,44444 (2<»,@¢.»(>+ 244wa .84444 ce#l;£~ed mail pad< m

wm AQALJ\QA 4b webb wqu `\u.vhce (‘e»\'fé( .'D;'dn‘c}r (l\p.»k\ o€€‘.\d Hui_<}was o@ c L\os. mo 01.(&@ indu\

 

 

 

\\L
\n &CGOXA&\'\M_ w`\¥\`\'\ {\r'x\"(,\t \\¢® ¢("\'\»Q.`\'£XCLS Q‘oc§l£sc,€ Qc'{vv\l)/m\ Qrb&ec;\uv€l\~\’\n@
C\Q'N 4~.@ \)w; Cnm\`c\\`ng Cm(\' 5\\<4\\ process 4 L`la.a~§ 4w\c)(\\ o\.\ wvay 4~0 c.l.l 'pa.<%'es
§¢\\)A\ze¢§. 'Fu<'-\'\\.Q¢. \,;>\¢\1.)\ ~\"\ML §Xa\€ go C¢ \¢Spon§{. ~H~L C\~e(V~S\\Ql\ send com k ILEU h
"Q_ESOD\\XSC Cw()\\`\v‘“\o. Gppll`€c\h\' Owuo‘r \>€'A~W`umzr'i Suc.\/\ is 1104 +\r\e tCu'€ Cu‘¢>[ ‘H/\I`S
gm da\\ s`&’ 'Ab\v\@, ZO\S¢ `

\»\4€<1€4~00€ .'Pm)u~ses wmmc-:/Leo. m_, a ~P|ic¢m+ 4°441'4¢ akw¢ ;44{!¢¢/ a/d/
huM\)ecm\ causes . vequ ~“\Q¥ ~Hw 0011\'4' ton "rms ila dekqu cf all perMe¢/n£
Q.)\¢>\ d`u.\\{ ghng hawk 104 mapp!)`con')l,unc\ wri\~ numbers .

impeclr~pul\q §u.Lm¢`HeL/. JiLéne/S"-‘ ZOIS'
Qa,\m`d 0&¢€]0»0\ /`qLIlIWZ
ALL K€l) UNH'

éle\ F.M Klo°l IUI

iowa rK¢TY 1103(0"|

 
 
  

 

 

 

` " ’Ex§l mr 1 léjsa/`¢>¢>owrof wear “
odom o ‘ \:1\?1;3,§
Tr\u\ U>\><& v\>‘._?,_m>$ mm wm n\(i\)*_
~'\\.\)4 \)4><14 be H&\>eos Q¢>rm\d\,\w\¢>@ l_cm.> \`n_;upp>(-\'_u(: mr 41
~ @(4?\'&€5/\\<\4@44¥4\? Mmz>_ac' \Gu<>~'Qedc)dcci Qon$cs§\m bg®£/.O$°.
~ MD\'\\>:\-@m Euiden#uc\{ Hmr'mq 4

Tm\ Cm<4 4401/m Qm) LM/ @_l_@§
' \)bré¥ 641 \/{Q\oeo; Qmp_u \L\)'?
F \\XUV\D. cg wm §\n Suppc>(¥o@ 4450`4' ` _ dow dc _
- hmw 441 0\4<4144»44 wmm(a\ 444 MJWM of 44 MWM>CM»\§@/ww
( `\)Q_ub\\\ C§\`SUD\XQ,(QI& Q.UC§,(U\Q!) ~ `YQS\~» mb_(\\| D` _AG(\U} @m€d(l \[)(@/"K,LQ\ ln_vw('e./\Cq, doing
v w?\m.ss §44:44<4\4@4\4: :, t (T"“““"" "**)
Q%qmps\a mg NT\”Qmmos bc*@tq\m`v\o C\r\cmm Jr. w\ \@Qun`m?> op l,ucio \/elez O,
" QQL\>\D @u>nza\e§ ?ece?_
':Pumgm\\km¥nn (
~ uOn \`ncer ®u`c narrch
w 034444~44 mw W ~
"`\Cu\e;\” QCY\CQ]O\
~ Mo\§c><\ ~Qv( €,\_)RC'\.QJI\¥GK\| er`ww`)

f m<§¥ ac 4'\0,\»€045 Qoqu,\.s \\¢(§'4 »

f MQSN\D. DC \_uw `\v\_§upp>(¥c>£ \)bnj( g

- TJ¢S\-;w\u\\` op Q\{\(`l$~\\'r\o \,m.ur\o ar\ck Dcwi'd Q\M'L-¢ C`&gzo [‘T (°\“\SC“'?§§)

~» Lm§n\e,ss 84¢.44@4442/\4";’. " , -~ , l k
S`!¥\d\d)r\-S D(: §v\l(’_fU-\Q\»$ oc` QG.\D[N> Ct’\ll»€'L~§J' wl lt&.m`mg- al Lucio u€/Fz 0

“ (POZ&)\D Qlol\?(l\€.(

~ mufd \md\`v\a C@e,wzo

~/ 44qu Aq)c>\l?m '®u`.<\ogu Qosc`an

' " ®(\\x`\$\\ho LOZDnD

‘ 44445\`\1>:\ 444 Ewic\m\¥' us\{ Hec\<'mg -

f ms mg i (TLEZ Fadem( Sem'/Eme. run Concurrml.)
" (\7\€§4 %orga`w\ {\qn>£w\vn+
-' buc")qw\w\¥¢>€ Cc)¢\ “\(:_4<10/\ .
» M`\C'lu\ wl 01 \.QM€( \~CQ,\)\Q.;-\\`ng v'>rpp£“ak Qu.u\se/\

\.,£»2,

 

‘\'r{o\\ C.>u(¥ ma no ‘. worn C¢),w emma m {A-) '

¢-\\-44'1 bind 449 Hcdoea.s Cm[>us

/ \\Aemc> . dr haw 444 suppu<¥¢>{:- 14564

~*’ Mo¥im 941 Euécla¢\§§ Cwq HQQ<'£M§

_ ~ E¥I:Q.fp'\'$ c>$“i (’YZ€‘. cmbm\ §Qn\-e/\c.a"\) mn CanUrM/il)

'~' mm ‘Ecwquh l\qr€cwn~\
/ \\udgw\m\/oc' QDnu{`C§\"G/\ f
( dudic`¢'c\\ "B~sduz¥ mt Q£F`FLQ-\Qd og€€f @I§encloml)
¢ judicial O¢¢\La¥ tL‘. \@;\/Xer CquzS\\`/q npp@"al€_ lh,mwl

 

' Qu:\u@.s¥ £4¢ aim §ce§l\>’h\k| 0¢ C',\a`£`wu wl Exhi\»r`}x (re“~o°lclaq \"\ 5:‘""\5 "°"+3)
4 N\r>\§ur\ psr \c)@\r§\/\ uncranjr wl E¢¢{e 1143

4 ‘ '¥ko_o&)w& was QQ,A§`\€L§ under U\L sdq\e padmge °.
4444‘4€4~46 4444\_ nom mo com wm ms
"Y)Qhuery dale.'. Orpci\ 30420|4 ' _
/Dzs\\`na‘\imfr\dks\n`(>* Q\€{K E'S~LN D€,C]A"GC/D_ _
1 ' mo v4c444r4`c4 s+_ 54@,’£03
, \,~GL¢€AD.T»L "IKOLW, '
r\>.)€_lq\\'\". 3 \.\)s . S‘WO oz.

\'LP%&D¢QQC;‘Q\)§"\'¢Q rock lv\ (310,0€¢'€4, g:ilQ(j §

CQA<€@__Q§ 444.704‘4 mo cm wm gm adm 42444249+ 4€@4-'
maxwqu dole.`.` wl MQX} L\_42045'
"DQ_$R`“QRUA ‘. ®4$4-44(;+- `(‘,lezk E.sler Degbnado
» \\\0\4`44144444&4 444 544103
laredo 4`\'¥» "{X/Dq?.,

L\)Q'qm‘. 0 LLL. mo 441,
'\’L<)_quox)r -a;( Cnrree:\a`mo£ v€@>rd md “ MO. '~Z§¢ZD|§
` A\§b (qul&)€c'\ Q\€(k»`\\ l\b`l`»f\‘ op i)~>'f'\;"\" #r{€d" Arn`va‘\

‘~\ _Mew\orgv\c'\m_n: 434 Qu)\ur 444 341:1-\€; ‘Q.e$?w\se.s ~meci via C€(+{A"ch mall
444 44444444 mem 444.44», ‘14;4.1444~4 ft md 44@:.`,45

 

z¢cz`,4