Court Opinion

ID: 7984610
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-09-09 01:24:12.680217+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:35:09.520293
License: Public Domain

Campbell, J.,
delivered the opinion of the court.
Complainant exhibited his bill averring that on the 16th November, 1867, Tom Wilkinson executed a deed of trust to secure a debt to Jayne, to mature on the 18th December, 1867, and by it conveyed to complainant as trustee, “ all the stock of goods, wares, merchandise and groceries, and all other articles of any and all descriptions whatever, then in the store of said Wilkinson, and all goods that the said Wilkinson might afterwards add to his stock from time to time in the house called Wake Robin Saloon, in the town of Brandon.” The deed was properly acknowledged and duly recorded. On May 11, 1871, attachment for rent in favor of plaintiffs in error was levied on certain goods in the possession of Wilkinson, acquired by him after the execution of the deed of trust; but what these goods are, and whether they consist of additions made by Wilkinson to the stock of goods in “Wake *881Robin Saloon,” does not distinctly appear from tbe bill, which was demur-red to by the attaching creditors against whom it was exhibited.
To sustain the decree which overruled the demurrer, we must indulge a presumption as to the facts most favorable to complainant, in violation of the rule that the allegations of his pleading must be taken most strongly against him who pleads, and must announce that a deed of trust made by a shopkeeper, conveying his goods and such additions as he may thereafter make to them, to secure a debt payable in one month upon default in which the condition in the deed of trust is broken, is three and one-half years afterwards entitled to precedence of satisfaction out of after-acquired goods over a supervening attachment levied on such goods in the possession of the grantor in the deed of trust, and which were never delivered to the trustee nor in his possession.
We are not prepared to announce such a doctrine as applicable to the facts of this case, and reverse the decree, and sustain the demurrer, and dismiss the bill.