Court Opinion

ID: 2970797
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2015-09-22 16:22:14.748971+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T15:01:21.504778
License: Public Domain

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21
                3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH                              +DUULVRQY0RQXPHQWDO/LIH,QV&R            1R
        (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU
                    )LOH 1DPH DS
                                                                                                BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
                                                                                                     &2816(/
81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6
                                                                          $5*8('  (ODLQH $ 3DUVRQ 5$<021' 	 352.23
                   )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7                                  6RXWKILHOG0LFKLJDQIRU$SSHOODQW%HQMDPLQ:KLWILHOGsU
                     BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB                                    :+,7),(/' 	 $662&,$7(6 'HWURLW 0LFKLJDQ IRU
                                                                          $SSHOOHH21%5,()(ODLQH$3DUVRQ5$<021'	
                                                                          352.236RXWKILHOG0LFKLJDQIRU $SSHOODQW%HQMDPLQ
 :$55(1 . +$55,621               ;                                      :KLWILHOG sU :+,7),(/' 	 $662&,$7(6 'HWURLW
          3ODLQWLII$SSHOOHH                                            0LFKLJDQIRU$SSHOOHH
                                    
                                      1R                                              BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
            Y                      
                                     !                                                              23,1,21
                                                                                               BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
 02180(17$/ /,)(                    
 ,1685$1&( &203$1<                                                        %(&.:,7+ 'LVWULFW sXGJH  'HIHQGDQW$SSHOODQW
          'HIHQGDQW$SSHOODQW                                           0RQXPHQWDO /LIH ,QVXUDQFH &RPSDQ\ DSSHDOV IURP WKH
                                                                         MXGJPHQWRIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWILQGLQJWKDW3ODLQWLII$SSHOOHH
                                   1                                      :DUUHQ.+DUULVRQZDVHQWLWOHGWRDFFLGHQWDOGHDWKEHQHILWV
       $SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW                       XQGHUDJURXSOLIHLQVXUDQFHSROLF\FRYHULQJWKHOLIHRI:D\QH
      IRUWKH(DVWHUQ'LVWULFWRI0LFKLJDQDW'HWURLW                    +DUULVRQ%HFDXVHZHFRQFOXGHWKDWWKHHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHG
     1Rn3DXO'%RUPDQ'LVWULFWsXGJH                         E\3ODLQWLIIDWWULDOZDVVXIILFLHQWWRILQGWKDWDQH[FOXVLRQDU\
                                                                          FODXVHSUHFOXGLQJFRYHUDJHZDVQRWDSSOLFDEOHWKHMXGJPHQW
                    $UJXHGsDQXDU\                             RIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWLV$)),50('

               'HFLGHGDQG)LOHGsXQH                                                           ,

%HIRUH*8<DQG0225(&LUFXLWsXGJHV%(&.:,7+                           2QsXQH'HIHQGDQW$SSHOODQW0RQXPHQWDO/LIH
                  'LVWULFWsXGJH
                                        ,QVXUDQFH&RPSDQ\m0RQXPHQWDOlLVVXHGDFHUWLILFDWHRI
                                                                          LQVXUDQFHXQGHUDJURXSOLIHLQVXUDQFHSROLF\FRYHULQJWKHOLIH
                                                                          RI3ODLQWLII:DUUHQ.+DUULVRQjVGHFHGHQW:D\QH+DUULVRQ
                                                                          7KH SROLF\ SDLG  WR WKH EHQHILFLDU\ LI DQG RQO\ LI
                                                                          ERGLO\ LQMXU\ ZDV WKH FDXVH RI GHDWK RI WKH LQVXUHG m7KH
                                                                          LQMXU\ PXVW EH WKH GLUHFW FDXVH RI >GHDWK@ DQG PXVW EH
                                                                          LQGHSHQGHQW RI DOO RWKHU FDXVHV  7KH LQMXU\ PXVW QRW EH
                                                                          FDXVHGE\RUFRQWULEXWHGWRE\6LFNQHVVl6HH3ROLF\s$DW
                                                                          ,QDGGLWLRQWKHSROLF\FRQWDLQHGWKHIROORZLQJVSHFLILF
    
                                                                     H[FOXVLRQRIFRYHUDJHm:HZLOOQRWSD\DEHQHILWIRUDORVV
     7KH +RQRUDEOH 6DQGUD 6 %HFNZLWK 8QLWHG 6WDWHV 'LVWULFW sXGJH IRU
WKH 6RXWKHUQ 'LVWULFW RI 2KLR VLWWLQJ E\ GHVLJQDWLRQ
                                                                          ZKLFK LV FDXVHG E\ UHVXOWV IURP RU FRQWULEXWHG WR E\

                                    
1R        +DUULVRQY0RQXPHQWDO/LIH,QV&R                        +DUULVRQY0RQXPHQWDO/LIH,QV&R             1R

>V@LFNQHVVRULWVPHGLFDORUVXUJLFDOWUHDWPHQWLQFOXGLQJ          EURQFKLDO SQHXPRQLD DV D FRPSOLFDWLQJ IDFWRU LQ 0U
GLDJQRVLV>@l,GDW                                                +DUULVRQjVGHDWK,GDW
   :D\QH +DUULVRQ ZDV DJH  DW WKH WLPH KH REWDLQHG              )ROORZLQJ0U+DUULVRQjVGHDWK3ODLQWLIIILOHGDFODLPIRU
FRYHUDJH XQGHU WKH SROLF\ EXW E\ WKHQ KH KDG DOUHDG\            EHQHILWV XQGHU WKH SROLF\  0RQXPHQWDO KRZHYHU GHQLHG
H[SHULHQFHG DQ H[WHQVLYH PHGLFDO KLVWRU\  ,Q  0U          3ODLQWLIIjV FODLP RQ WKH JURXQGV WKDW WKH PHGLFDO UHFRUGV
+DUULVRQZDVGLDJQRVHGZLWKVTXDPRXVFHOOFDUFLQRPDRIWKH               GHPRQVWUDWHG WKDW WKH DFFLGHQW LWVHOI ZDV QRW VXIILFLHQW WR
VRIW SDODWH ZKLFK ZDV WUHDWHG ZLWK UDGLDWLRQ DQG                 FDXVH0U+DUULVRQjVGHDWKDQGWKDWKLVQXPHURXVSUHH[LVWLQJ
FKHPRWKHUDS\  s$ DW   ,Q  0U +DUULVRQ ZDV         FRQGLWLRQV ZHUH D FRQWULEXWLQJ FDXVH RI GHDWK  7KXV
DGPLWWHG WR WKH KRVSLWDO IRU WUHDWPHQW RI DQ LQWUDFUDQLDO        DFFRUGLQJ WR 0RQXPHQWDO 3ODLQWLIIjV FODLP IHOO XQGHU WKH
KHPRUUKDJHDIWHUKHZDVIRXQGO\LQJLQKLVEDVHPHQW,GDW             H[FOXVLRQDU\ FODXVH ZKLFK UHTXLUHG ERGLO\ LQMXU\ WR EH WKH
,QDQG0U+DUULVRQUHFHLYHGWUHDWPHQWIRU              VROHFDXVHRIGHDWK
VHL]XUHV,GDW,Q0U+DUULVRQZDVWUHDWHG
DWWKHHPHUJHQF\URRPDIWHUEHLQJDVVDXOWHGDQGVWUXFNLQWKH              3ODLQWLIIRULJLQDOO\ILOHGVXLWDJDLQVW0RQXPHQWDOIRUEUHDFK
KHDGZLWKDEDVHEDOOEDW,GDW,Q0U+DUULVRQ            RI WKH SROLF\ LQ WKH :D\QH &RXQW\ &LUFXLW &RXUW EXW
ZDVWUHDWHGLQWKHHPHUJHQF\URRPDIWHUEHLQJVWUXFNLQWKH              0RQXPHQWDOUHPRYHGWKHFDVHWRWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW
KHDGE\DPHWDOSODWHDWZRUN,GDW$OVRLQ0U           &RXUWIRUWKH(DVWHUQ'LVWULFWRI0LFKLJDQRQ)HEUXDU\
+DUULVRQKDGDFRORQRVFRS\WRUHPRYHDSRO\S,GDW,Q             7KH EDVLV IRU WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV VXEMHFW PDWWHU
0U+DUULVRQZDVDJDLQDGPLWWHGWRWKHKRVSLWDOIRUD              MXULVGLFWLRQZDVGLYHUVLW\MXULVGLFWLRQSXUVXDQWWR86&
IUDFWXUHGYHUWHEUDHDIWHUEHLQJSXVKHGGRZQDIOLJKWRIVWDLUV          
,GDW,QDGGLWLRQWRWKHVHGLVFUHWHLQFLGHQWVUHTXLULQJ
PHGLFDODWWHQWLRQWKHUHFRUGUHIOHFWVWKDW0U+DUULVRQKDGD             7KHFDVHSURFHHGHGWRDWULDOEHIRUHWKHEHQFKRQsDQXDU\
KLVWRU\RIK\SHUWHQVLRQDQGDOFRKROLVP)LQDOO\HLWKHUDVSDUW         DQGsDQXDU\1RWVXUSULVLQJO\JLYHQWKHQDWXUHRI
RI KLV WUHDWPHQW IRU WKURDW FDQFHU RU GXULQJ D VHL]XUH 0U    0U+DUULVRQjVPHGLFDOKLVWRU\WKHWULDOFDPHGRZQWRWKH
+DUULVRQORVWSDUWRIKLVWRQJXH7KLVFDXVHGIRRGWRDVSLUDWH          RSLQLRQV RI HDFK VLGHjV PHGLFDO H[SHUW  'U .DQOXHQ WKH
LQWRKLVOXQJVUHVXOWLQJLQFKURQLFDVSLUDWLRQSQHXPRQLWLVRU          :D\QH &RXQW\ PHGLFDO H[DPLQHU WHVWLILHG RQ EHKDOI RI
DVSLUDWLRQSQHXPRQLD                                                    3ODLQWLII$FFRUGLQJWR'U.DQOXHQ

   2QsDQXDU\0U+DUULVRQZDVVWUXFNE\DWUXFN
ZKLOH FURVVLQJ D VWUHHW LQ 'HWURLW  +H ZDV DGPLWWHG WR 6W
sRKQjV +RVSLWDO ZLWK PXOWLSOH IUDFWXUHV RI WKH SHOYLV D
IUDFWXUHRIWKHSXELFERQHDQGFRPPLQXWHGIUDFWXUHVRIWKH                  
                                                                               3ODLQWLII LV D FLWL]HQ RI WKH VWDWH RI 0LFKLJDQ 0RQXPHQWDO LV D
SUR[LPDOHQGVRIWKHULJKWWLELDDQGILEXODs$DW2Q         0DU\ODQG FRUSRUDWLRQ ZLWK LWV SULQFLSDO SODFH RI EXVLQHVV LQ 0DU\ODQG
sDQXDU\0U+DUULVRQZDVWUDQVIHUUHGWR+HQU\)RUG             7KXV WKH GLYHUVLW\ RI FLWL]HQVKLS UHTXLUHPHQW ZDV VDWLVILHG 6HH s$ DW
+RVSLWDO  :KLOH DW +HQU\ )RUG 0U +DUULVRQ GHYHORSHG            $OWKRXJK WKH XOWLPDWH MXGJPHQW LQ WKH FDVH ZDV IRU  WKH
ELODWHUDOEURQFKLDOSQHXPRQLDDQGGLHGRQsDQXDU\              FRPSODLQW SOHG GDPDJHV RI  DSSDUHQWO\ EDVHG RQ D WKHRU\ WKDW
'U6XZDLW.DQOXHQWKHFKLHIPHGLFDOH[DPLQHUIRU:D\QH                 DGGLWLRQDO FRYHUDJH ZDV GXH XQGHU WKH SROLF\ 7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW
                                                                         XOWLPDWHO\ UXOHG DJDLQVW 3ODLQWLII RQ WKLV FODLP DQG WKLV GHFLVLRQ LV QRW
&RXQW\ 0LFKLJDQ SHUIRUPHG DQ DXWRSV\ RQ 0U +DUULVRQ            EHIRUH XV RQ DSSHDO 1RQHWKHOHVV WKH DPRXQW RULJLQDOO\ SOHG LQ WKH
ZKLFK FRQFOXGHG WKDW GHDWK ZDV FDXVHG E\ WKH IUDFWXUHV           FRPSODLQW FRQWUROV WKH DPRXQW LQ FRQWURYHUV\ UHTXLUHPHQW 6HH sRQHV Y
VXVWDLQHG LQ WKH FROOLVLRQ  'U .DQOXHQ OLVWHG ELODWHUDO        .QR[ ([SORUDWLRQ &RUS  )G   WK &LU  7KHUHIRUH
                                                                         WKH DPRXQW LQ FRQWURYHUV\ UHTXLUHPHQW ZDV VDWLVILHG LQ WKLV FDVH DV ZHOO
1R        +DUULVRQY0RQXPHQWDO/LIH,QV&R                      +DUULVRQY0RQXPHQWDO/LIH,QV&R         1R

  $IWHUDXWRSV\LWZDVP\RSLQLRQWKDW0U+DUULVRQGLHG                 0RQXPHQWDOjVH[SHUW'U:HUQHU6SLW]RIFRXUVHWHVWLILHG
  RIPXOWLSOHLQMXULHV7KDWPHDQVIUDFWXUHRIWKHSHOYLV            GLIIHUHQWO\
  SHOYLVERQHIUDFWXUHRIWKHULJKWOHJERQHDQGKHDOVR
  KDV FRPSOLFDWLRQV ELODWHUDO SQHXPRQLD DQG FDXVH RI                4 +DYH\RXPDGHDGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIWKHLQMXULHV0U
  GHDWKZDVPXOWLSOHLQMXULHVFRPSOLFDWHGE\SQHXPRQLD                        +DUULVRQ VXVWDLQHG ZKHQ VWUXFN E\ D YHKLFOH DW D
                                                                               FURVVZDON ZKHUH >VLF@ WKH VROH FDXVH RI KLV GHDWK
s$DW'U.DQOXHQIXUWKHUWHVWLILHGWKDWNQRZLQJ0U                   PHDQLQJ GLG KH GLH DV D GLUHFW DQG LQGHSHQGHQW
+DUULVRQjVPHGLFDOKLVWRU\GLGQRWFKDQJHKLVRSLQLRQWKDWWKH                 UHVXOW RI LQMXULHV ZLWKRXW WKH FRQWULEXWLRQ RI DQ\
DFFLGHQWZDVWKHFDXVHRIGHDWK,GDW'U                  VLFNQHVVRUGLVHDVH"
.DQOXHQ DGPLWWHGWKDWKHREVHUYHGERWKDFXWHDQGFKURQLF
SQHXPRQLDLQ0U+DUULVRQjVOXQJWLVVXH6HHLGDW                $ 1RKHGLGQRW/HWPHSOHDVHVD\LQDIXOOVHQWHQFH
  'U .DQOXHQ WHVWLILHG KRZHYHU WKDW DFXWH                    LWLVQRWP\RSLQLRQWKDW0U+DUULVRQGLHGVROHO\RI
SQHXPRQLDDQGQRWFKURQLFSQHXPRQLDZDVWKHFRQWULEXWLQJ                     WKHLQMXU\7KHLQMXU\LQDQGRILWVHOIZDVQRWDIDWDO
FDXVHRIGHDWK                                                                FRQGLWLRQ
  :KDW , REVHUYHG ZDV DFXWH SQHXPRQLD  1RW WDONLQJ             s$DW'U6SLW]WHVWLILHGWKDWKLVH[DPLQDWLRQRI0U
  DERXWFKURQLF7KDWSQHXPRQLDZDVEHFDXVHKHZDVLQ                  +DUULVRQjV OXQJ WLVVXH VKRZHG QR VLJQV RI DFXWH
  WKHKRVSLWDOIRUWUHDWPHQWDQGWKHSHRSOHZKRZDVLQWKH             EURQFKRSQHXPRQLDDQGWKDWKHVDZRQO\HYLGHQFHRIORQJ
  KRVSLWDORIFRXUVHERG\UHVLVWDQFHLVORZ7KDWjVZK\              VWDQGLQJOXQJGLVHDVH,GDW/DWHULQDWWHPSWLQJWR
  LQIHFWLRQ ZDV YHU\ HDV\  7KDWjV ZK\ LQ P\ RSLQLRQ           DSSRUWLRQ WKH FDXVH RI GHDWK 'U 6SLW] WHVWLILHG WKDW WKH
  EURQFKRSQHXPRQLD LV WKH FRPSOLFDWLRQ RI WKH LQMXU\             DFFLGHQW SOD\HG RQO\ D WZR SHUFHQW UROH LQ 0U +DUULVRQjV
  EHFDXVHKHZDVKLWE\WUXFNDQGLQWKHKRVSLWDO+LVERG\            GHDWK DQG WKDW WKH UHPDLQGHU ZDV DWWULEXWDEOH WR KLV
  ZDVORZDQGWKDWjVZK\KHJRWWKHSQHXPRQLDDQGWKDW                SUHH[LVWLQJFRQGLWLRQV,GDW
  ZDVWKHFRPSOLFDWLRQRIWKHLQMXU\WKDWEURXJKWKLPWKHUH
  ,IQRWIRUWKHWUXFNRULQWKHKRVSLWDO KH GRHVQjWKDYH              2QsDQXDU\WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWLVVXHGDVKRUWZULWWHQ
  DFXWHEURQFKRSQHXPRQLD7KDWjVP\RSLQLRQ                           RUGHU PDNLQJ ILQGLQJV RI IDFW DQG FRQFOXVLRQV RI ODZ DQG
                                                                        FRQWDLQLQJ LWV YHUGLFW  $IWHU UHYLHZLQJ VRPH RI WKH
,GDW'U.DQOXHQIXUWKHUVWDWHGWKDW0U+DUULVRQ            EDFNJURXQGIDFWVDQGWHVWLPRQ\WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWVWDWHG
FRXOGKDYHOLYHGZLWKFKURQLFSQHXPRQLDIRUmDORQJORQJ
WLPHl,GDW'U.DQOXHQjVWHVWLPRQ\REYLRXVO\FUHDWHG              7KH &RXUW ILQGV 'U .DQOXHQjV WHVWLPRQ\ FUHGLEOH
DQLPSRUWDQWGLVWLQFWLRQEHFDXVHLIFKURQLFLHSUHH[LVWLQJ              :D\QH +DUULVRQjV LQMXU\ DQG UHVXOWLQJ GHDWK ZHUH QRW
SQHXPRQLDFRQWULEXWHGWR0U+DUULVRQjVGHDWKWKHUHZRXOG                  mFRQWULEXWHG WRl E\ SUHH[LVWLQJ VLFNQHVV  :D\QH
EHQRFRYHUDJHXQGHUWKHSROLF\                                            +DUULVRQGLHGEHFDXVHKHVXVWDLQHGVHYHUHLQMXULHVIURP
                                                                            EHLQJVWUXFNE\DYHKLFOHRQsDQXDU\:D\QH
                                                                            +DUULVRQGLHGRILQMXULHVDFFLGHQWDOO\VXVWDLQHGZKLFK
                                                                            WKHLQVXUDQFHSROLF\FRYHUV3ODLQWLIIWKHEHQHILFLDU\LV
                                                                            HQWLWOHGWRWKHEHQHILWVRIWKDWSROLF\LQWKHDPRXQWRI
                                                                           7KH&RXUWGRHVQRWILQGFUHGLEOHWKHWHVWLPRQ\
      $FXWH SQHXPRQLD LV FKDUDFWHUL]HG E\ UDSLG RQVHW ZKHUHDV FKURQLF
                                                                            RIWKHGHIHQVHH[SHUW'U:HUQHU6SLW]'U6SLW]RSLQHG
SQHXPRQLD SHUVLVWV RYHU D ORQJ SHULRG RI WLPH $00 '       25/$1' 6 j
                                                                            WKDWDFKURQLFLQIHFWLRQZDVWKHRUFDXVHRI0U
//8675$7('
,             0 (',&$/   ,&7,21$5<
                         '                WK HG 
GHILQLQJ mDFXWHl mFKURQLFl DQG mDFXWH SQHXPRQLDl UHVSHFWLYHO\         +DUULVRQjVGHDWKoDPDQZKRZDVOLYLQJRQKLVRZQDQG
1R        +DUULVRQY0RQXPHQWDO/LIH,QV&R                         +DUULVRQY0RQXPHQWDO/LIH,QV&R             1R

  ZDONLQJDFURVVWKHVWUHHWZKHQKHVWUXFNE\DWUXFNWKDW                     :KHQILQGLQJVDUHEDVHGRQGHWHUPLQDWLRQVUHJDUGLQJWKH
  LQIOLFWHG PXOWLSOH VHYHUH LQMXULHV WKDW FDXVH KLV GHDWK              FUHGLELOLW\RIZLWQHVVHV5XOHDGHPDQGVHYHQJUHDWHU
  7KH&RXUWILQGVWKLVWHVWLPRQ\QRWFUHGLEOH                                 GHIHUHQFHWRWKHWULDOFRXUW
VILQGLQJVIRURQO\WKHWULDO
                                                                               MXGJH FDQ EH DZDUH RI WKH YDULDWLRQV LQ GHPHDQRU DQG
s$DW7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWWKHQHQWHUHGMXGJPHQWLQIDYRU               WRQH RI YRLFH WKDW EHDU VR KHDYLO\ RQ WKH OLVWHQHU
V
RIWKH3ODLQWLIIDQGDZDUGHGGDPDJHVRI                               XQGHUVWDQGLQJRIDQGEHOLHILQZKDWLVVDLG7KLVLVQRWWR
                                                                               VXJJHVWWKDWWKHWULDOMXGJHPD\LQVXODWHKLVILQGLQJVIURP
  0RQXPHQWDOQRZDSSHDOVIURPWKHMXGJPHQWRIWKHGLVWULFW                     UHYLHZE\GHQRPLQDWLQJWKHPFUHGLELOLW\GHWHUPLQDWLRQV
FRXUWILQGLQJWKDW3ODLQWLIIZDVHQWLWOHGWRUHFRYHUDFFLGHQWDO                IRUIDFWRUVRWKHUWKDQGHPHDQRUDQGLQIOHFWLRQJRLQWRWKH
GHDWK EHQHILWV XQGHU WKH FLUFXPVWDQFHV RI 0U +DUULVRQjV                GHFLVLRQZKHWKHURUQRWWREHOLHYHDZLWQHVV'RFXPHQWV
GHDWK 6SHFLILFDOO\ 0RQXPHQWDO DUJXHV WKDW WKH GLVWULFW                 RUREMHFWLYHHYLGHQFHPD\FRQWUDGLFWWKHZLWQHVV
VWRU\
FRXUWjVILQGLQJWKDW WKHDFFLGHQWZDVWKHVROHFDXVHRI0U                   RU WKH VWRU\ LWVHOI PD\ EH VR LQWHUQDOO\ LQFRQVLVWHQW RU
+DUULVRQjV GHDWK ZDV FOHDUO\ HUURQHRXV DQGRU ODFNHG                     LPSODXVLEOHRQLWVIDFHWKDWDUHDVRQDEOHIDFWILQGHUZRXOG
HYLGHQWLDU\VXSSRUWLQWKHUHFRUGDQGWKDWWKHGLVWULFWFRXUW                  QRWFUHGLWLW:KHUHVXFKIDFWRUVDUHSUHVHQWWKHFRXUWRI
HUURQHRXVO\ DSSOLHG 0LFKLJDQ ODZ UHODWLQJ WR H[FOXVLRQDU\                DSSHDOV PD\ ZHOO ILQG FOHDU HUURU HYHQ LQ D ILQGLQJ
FODXVHVLQDFFLGHQWDOGHDWKSROLFLHV                                        SXUSRUWHGO\ EDVHG RQ D FUHGLELOLW\ GHWHUPLQDWLRQ  %XW
                                                                               ZKHQDWULDOMXGJH
VILQGLQJLVEDVHGRQKLVGHFLVLRQWR
                                 ,,                                           FUHGLW WKH WHVWLPRQ\ RI RQH RI WZR RU PRUH ZLWQHVVHV
                                                                               HDFKRIZKRPKDVWROGDFRKHUHQWDQGIDFLDOO\SODXVLEOH
   5XOH D RI WKH )HGHUDO 5XOHV RI &LYLO 3URFHGXUH                  VWRU\WKDWLVQRWFRQWUDGLFWHGE\H[WULQVLFHYLGHQFHWKDW
GHVFULEHV WKH GHIHUHQFH WR EH DIIRUGHG D GLVWULFW FRXUW
V              ILQGLQJLIQRWLQWHUQDOO\LQFRQVLVWHQWFDQYLUWXDOO\QHYHU
ILQGLQJV RI IDFW XSRQ WKH FRQFOXVLRQ RI D EHQFK WULDO                EHFOHDUHUURU
m)LQGLQJV RI IDFW ZKHWKHU EDVHG RQ RUDO RU GRFXPHQWDU\
HYLGHQFHVKDOOQRWEHVHWDVLGHXQOHVVFOHDUO\HUURQHRXVDQG             $QGHUVRQ Y &LW\ RI %HVVHPHU &LW\  86  
GXHUHJDUGVKDOOEHJLYHQWRWKHRSSRUWXQLW\RIWKHWULDOFRXUW            LQWHUQDOFLWDWLRQVRPLWWHG7KLV&RXUWKDVDOVRVWDWHG
WR MXGJH RI WKH FUHGLELOLW\ RI WKH ZLWQHVVHVl  7KH 86         WKDW mWKH IDFWXDO FRQFOXVLRQV UHQGHUHG E\ D GLVWULFW FRXUW
6XSUHPH&RXUWIXUWKHUH[SODLQHGWKLVVWDQGDUG                           VLWWLQJZLWKRXWDMXU\DUHELQGLQJRQDSSHDOXQOHVVWKLV&RXUW
                                                                           LVOHIWZLWKDGHILQLWHDQGILUPFRQYLFWLRQWKDWDPLVWDNHKDV
  ,IWKHGLVWULFWFRXUW
VDFFRXQWRIWKHHYLGHQFHLVSODXVLEOH             EHHQPDGHl7KRPSVRQY1DWjO553DVVHQJHU&RUS
  LQOLJKWRIWKHUHFRUGYLHZHGLQLWVHQWLUHW\WKHFRXUWRI              )G   WK &LU   7KH EXUGHQ LV RQ WKH
  DSSHDOVPD\QRWUHYHUVHLWHYHQWKRXJKFRQYLQFHGWKDW                    DSSHOODQWWRSURYHVXFKDPLVWDNH*RGOH\Y.HQWXFN\5HV
  KDG LW EHHQ VLWWLQJ DV WKH WULHU RI IDFW LW ZRXOG KDYH       &RUS)GWK&LUDQGWKLVEXUGHQLV
  ZHLJKHGWKHHYLGHQFHGLIIHUHQWO\:KHUHWKHUHDUHWZR                    QRWPHWPHUHO\E\GHPRQVWUDWLQJDFRQIOLFWLQWKHWHVWLPRQ\
  SHUPLVVLEOHYLHZVRIWKHHYLGHQFHWKHIDFWILQGHU
VFKRLFH               :DOOLQJ Y *HQ ,QGXV &RUS  86   
  EHWZHHQ WKHP FDQQRW EH FOHDUO\ HUURQHRXV 7KLV LV VR             *RGOH\VXSUDQRUE\VHHNLQJWRUHGHWHUPLQHWKHFUHGLELOLW\
  HYHQ ZKHQ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW
V ILQGLQJV GR QRW UHVW RQ          RIZLWQHVVHV1/5%Y1LFKROVRI2KLR,QF)G
  FUHGLELOLW\ GHWHUPLQDWLRQV EXW DUH EDVHG LQVWHDG RQ                WK &LU   0RUHRYHU WKH DSSHOODWH FRXUW PXVW
  SK\VLFDO RU GRFXPHQWDU\ HYLGHQFH RU LQIHUHQFHV IURP                UHYLHZWKHIDFWVLQWKHOLJKWPRVWIDYRUDEOHWRWKHDSSHOOHH
  RWKHUIDFWV                                                            6DZ\HUY$UXP)GWK&LU/HJDO
                                                                    GHWHUPLQDWLRQVPDGHE\WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWDUHQRWDFFRUGHGWKH
1R         +DUULVRQY0RQXPHQWDO/LIH,QV&R                         +DUULVRQY0RQXPHQWDO/LIH,QV&R               1R

VDPHGHIHUHQFHDQGDUHUHYLHZHGGHQRYR2ZHQV,OOLQRLV                      ,WDSSHDUVWREHXQGLVSXWHGWKDWWKHDFFLGHQWDOGHDWKSROLF\
,QFY$HWQD&DV	6XU&R)GWK&LU                    LQ WKLV FDVH FRQWDLQV DQ H[FOXVLRQDU\ FODXVH ZKLFK ZRXOG
                                                                        KDYHUHTXLUHG3ODLQWLIIWRSURYHWKDWWKHDFFLGHQWLWVHOIZDV
                                                                              VXIILFLHQW WR FDXVH 0U +DUULVRQjV GHDWK  2Q DSSHDO
                                   ,,,                                       0RQXPHQWDOjV WZR DVVLJQPHQWV RI HUURU DUH LQWHUUHODWHG
                                                                              0RQXPHQWDO ILUVW DUJXHV WKDW LQ ILQGLQJ IRU 3ODLQWLII WKH
  ,WLVXQGLVSXWHGKHUHWKDWWKHLQVXUDQFHSROLF\LVJRYHUQHG                 GLVWULFW FRXUW DSSOLHG WKH OHVV VWUHQXRXV mEXW IRUl VWDQGDUG
E\0LFKLJDQODZ7KHSODLQWLIIjVEXUGHQRISURYLQJFRYHUDJH                  DSSOLFDEOHWRSROLFLHVFRQWDLQLQJRQO\mVROHFODXVHVlLQVWHDG
XQGHUDQDFFLGHQWDOGHDWKSROLF\GHSHQGVRQWKHODQJXDJHRI                   RI WKH PRUH ULJRURXV VWDQGDUG DSSOLFDEOH WR SROLFLHV ZLWK
WKH SROLF\ LWVHOI  :KHUH WKH SROLF\ FRQWDLQV RQO\ D mVROH          mH[FOXVLRQDU\FODXVHVl$FFRUGLQJWR0RQXPHQWDOQRWRQO\
FODXVHlWKHFODLPDQWPD\UHFRYHUHYHQZKHUHSUHH[LVWLQJ                    ZDV 3ODLQWLII UHTXLUHG WR SURYH WKDW WKH DFFLGHQW ZDV LWVHOI
FRQGLWLRQVFRPELQHZLWKDFFLGHQWDOLQMXULHVLIKHVKRZVWKDW                 VXIILFLHQWWRFDXVH0U+DUULVRQjVGHDWKKHZDVDOVRUHTXLUHG
WKHDFFLGHQWDOH[WHUQDOLQMXU\ZDVWKHHIILFLHQWGRPLQDWHDQG               WR HOLPLQDWH HDFK RI 0U +DUULVRQjV YDULRXV SUHH[LVWLQJ
SUR[LPDWHFDXVHRIGHDWKRIWKHLQVXUHG%HUJHUY7UDYHOHUV                 FRQGLWLRQV DV D FRQWULEXWLQJ FDXVH RI GHDWK  6HFRQG
,QV&R1:G0LFK,IKRZHYHUWKH                 0RQXPHQWDO DUJXHV WKDW WKH HYLGHQFH ZDV LQVXIILFLHQW WR
LQVXUDQFH SROLF\ FRQWDLQV DQ mH[FOXVLRQDU\ FODXVHl ZKLFK               VXSSRUWWKHYHUGLFWEHFDXVHDOORIWKHHYLGHQFHLQFOXGLQJWKH
H[SUHVVO\QHJDWHVFRYHUDJHZKHUHDSUHH[LVWLQJGLVHDVHSOD\V                  WHVWLPRQ\RI3ODLQWLIIjVH[SHUW'U.DQOXHQVKRZHGWKDW0U
DQ\SDUWLQWKHLQVXUHGjVGHDWKWKHFODLPDQWPXVWVKRZWKDW                  +DUULVRQjVSUHH[LVWLQJFRQGLWLRQVFRQWULEXWHGWRKLVGHDWK
WKH DFFLGHQW LWVHOI ZDV VXIILFLHQW WR FDXVH GHDWK  ,G
6FKDUPHUY2FFLGHQWDO/LIH,QV&R1:G                         :HQRWHDWWKHRXWVHWWKDWLQLWVYHUGLFWILQGLQJVRIIDFWDQG
0LFKVHHDOVR$QQ$UERU7UXVW&RY&DQDGD/LIH                     FRQFOXVLRQVRIODZWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWGLGQRWVWDWHRULQGLFDWH
$VVXUDQFH&R)GWK&LU                          ZKLFK VWDQGDUG LW ZDV DSSO\LQJ LQ DVVHVVLQJ WKH HYLGHQFH
                                                                              SUHVHQWHG1RQHWKHOHVVLQUHDFKLQJLWVYHUGLFWWKHGLVWULFW
                                                                              FRXUW GLG PDNH D FUHGLELOLW\ MXGJPHQW UHJDUGLQJ WKH
    
      $ mVROH FODXVHl VWLSXODWHV WKDW GHDWK PXVW EH FDXVHG VROHO\ E\ ERGLO\
                                                                              FRPSHWLQJH[SHUWZLWQHVVHVZKLFKGLFWDWHGWKHRXWFRPHRIWKH
LQMXU\ GLUHFWO\ DQG LQGHSHQGHQWO\ RI DOO RWKHU FDXVHV RI GHDWK (J         WULDO6LQFHZHDUHQRWIUHHWRGLVUHJDUGWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjV
.DQJDV Y 1HZ <RUN /LIH ,QV &R  1:   0LFK              FUHGLELOLW\DVVHVVPHQWWKHYHUGLFWPXVWVWDQGLIRQUHYLHZ'U
                                                                              .DQOXHQjVWHVWLPRQ\VXSSRUWVDILQGLQJWKDWWKHDFFLGHQWDORQH
    
       $ IHZ H[DPSOHV PD\ VXIILFH WR VKRZ KRZ ZH XQGHUVWDQG WKHVH WZR         ZDVVXIILFLHQWWRFDXVH0U+DUULVRQjVGHDWK9LHZHGLQWKH
GLIIHUHQW FODXVHV DUH FRUUHFWO\ DSSOLHG $ SHUVRQ ZLWK KHPRSKLOLD LV          OLJKW PRVW IDYRUDEOH WR 3ODLQWLII ZH EHOLHYH WKHUH ZDV
LQYROYHG LQ D FDU DFFLGHQW DQG VXVWDLQV D VPDOO FXW ZKLFK ZRXOG QRW EH        VXIILFLHQWHYLGHQFHWRVXSSRUWWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVMXGJPHQW
IDWDO WR DQRWKHU EXW ZKLFK FDXVHG WKLV SHUVRQ WR EOHHG WR GHDWK EHFDXVH
KLV EORRG ZRXOG QRW FORW ,I WKLV SHUVRQ ZDV LQVXUHG XQGHU DQ DFFLGHQWDO
GHDWK SROLF\ FRQWDLQLQJ RQO\ D mVROH FODXVHl WKH FODLPDQW ZRXOG SUHYDLO
                                                                                ,W DSSHDUV WR XV WKDW 'U .DQOXHQ WHVWLILHG UDWKHU
EHFDXVH WKH FDU DFFLGHQW ZDV WKH SUR[LPDWH FDXVH RI WKH LQVXUHGjV GHDWK       XQHTXLYRFDOO\ WKDW WKH LQMXULHV WKDW 0U +DUULVRQ VXIIHUHG
EHFDXVH LW FDXVHG WKH FXW ZKLFK FDXVHG WKH LQVXUHG WR EOHHG WR GHDWK ,I     IURPEHLQJVWUXFNE\WKHYHKLFOHFRXSOHGZLWKWKHUHVXOWLQJ
KRZHYHU WKLV VDPH SHUVRQ ZDV FRYHUHG XQGHU DQ DFFLGHQWDO GHDWK SROLF\
FRQWDLQLQJ DQ mH[FOXVLRQDU\ FODXVHl WKHQ WKH FODLPDQW ZRXOG QRW SUHYDLO
EHFDXVH DEVHQW WKH KHPRSKLOLD WKH FXW FDXVHG E\ WKH DFFLGHQW RWKHUZLVH
ZRXOG QRW KDYH EHHQ IDWDO 2Q WKH RWKHU KDQG LI D KHPRSKLOLDF LV VD\       SHUVRQ ZLWKRXW DQ\ SUHH[LVWLQJ FRQGLWLRQV LV LQYROYHG LQ D FDU DFFLGHQW
VKRW WKURXJK WKH KHDUW ZLWK D JXQ KH ZRXOG EH FRYHUHG XQGHU D SROLF\         DQG VXIIHUV LQMXULHV ZKLFK FDXVH KLP WR EOHHG WR GHDWK WKHQ KH REYLRXVO\
FRQWDLQLQJ DQ mH[FOXVLRQDU\ FODXVHl GHVSLWH KLV KHPRSKLOLD EHFDXVH WKDW     ZRXOG EH FRYHUHG XQGHU ERWK SROLFLHV EHFDXVH WKH LQMXULHV IURP WKH
LQMXU\ ZRXOG EH VXIILFLHQW DORQH WR FDXVH GHDWK WR DQ\RQH )LQDOO\ LI D      DFFLGHQW ZHUH DORQH VXIILFLHQW WR FDXVH GHDWK
1R       +DUULVRQY0RQXPHQWDO/LIH,QV&R                  +DUULVRQY0RQXPHQWDO/LIH,QV&R        1R

EURQFKRSQHXPRQLDZHUHWKHVROHFDXVHRIGHDWK6HHs$DW          OLIH LQVXUDQFH SROLF\  $FFRUGLQJO\ WKH MXGJPHQW RI WKH
)XUWKHUPRUHHYHQWKRXJK'U.DQOXHQDGPLWWHGWKH            GLVWULFWFRXUWLV$)),50('
SUHVHQFHRIFKURQLFSQHXPRQLDLQ0U+DUULVRQjVOXQJWLVVXH
KHDOVRWHVWLILHGWKDWWKHFKURQLFSQHXPRQLDZDVQRWDIDFWRU
LQWKHFDXVHRIGHDWK6HHLG7KRXJK0RQXPHQWDOFRQWHQGV
WKDWERWKWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWDQG'U.DQOXHQDSSOLHGDVLPSOH
mEXWIRUlFDXVDWLRQVWDQGDUGLWVHHPVDSSDUHQWWRXVWKDWWKH
RQO\mEXWIRUlVWDWHPHQWLQ'U.DQOXHQjVWHVWLPRQ\ZDVWKDW
LI0U+DUULVRQKDGQRWEHHQVWUXFNE\WKHWUXFNDQGSODFHGLQ
WKH KRVSLWDO KH ZRXOG QRW KDYH FRQWUDFWHG WKH DFXWH
EURQFKRSQHXPRQLDZKLFKZDVLGHQWLILHGDVDFRPSOLFDWLQJ
IDFWRU LQ WKH FDXVH RI GHDWK  ,Q RWKHU ZRUGV WKH DFXWH
EURQFKRSQHXPRQLD GLG QRW RULJLQDWH IURP DQ\ SUHH[LVWLQJ
FRQGLWLRQEXWUDWKHUDFFRUGLQJWR'U.DQOXHQGHYHORSHG
EHFDXVH0U+DUULVRQZDVFRQILQHGLQWKHKRVSLWDODIWHUWKH
DFFLGHQW7KXVWKHEURQFKRSQHXPRQLDLVDWWULEXWDEOHWRWKH
DFFLGHQW)LQDOO\DOWKRXJKZHDUHQRWVXUHWKDWZHDJUHHZLWK
0RQXPHQWDOWKDW3ODLQWLIIZDVUHTXLUHGWRHOLPLQDWHHDFKRI
0U+DUULVRQjVSUHH[LVWLQJFRQGLWLRQVDVDFRQWULEXWLQJFDXVH
RIGHDWKLQDGGLWLRQWRGHPRQVWUDWLQJWKDWWKHLQMXULHVIURPWKH
DFFLGHQWZHUHDORQHVXIILFLHQWWRFDXVHGHDWKZHQRWHWKDW
DIWHUEHLQJUHDGDOLVWRI0U+DUULVRQjVH[LVWLQJLOOQHVVHVDQG
FRQGLWLRQV'U.DQOXHQWHVWLILHGWKDWWKLVLQIRUPDWLRQGLGQRW
FKDQJHKLVFRQFOXVLRQUHJDUGLQJ WKHFDXVHRIGHDWK ,GDW
  7KHUHIRUH ZH WKLQN WKDW 'U .DQOXHQ
LPSOLFLWO\ LI QRW H[SOLFLWO\ UXOHG RXW 0U +DUULVRQjV
SUHH[LVWLQJ FRQGLWLRQV DV IDFWRUV FRQWULEXWLQJ WR KLV GHDWK
7KXVLWDSSHDUVWRXVWKDW'U.DQOXHQjVWHVWLPRQ\VDWLVILHV
WKHVWDQGDUGWHQGHUHGE\0RQXPHQWDO
                          &RQFOXVLRQ
  ,QVXPPDU\WKHRXWFRPHRIWKLVODZVXLWDVLVWKHFDVHZLWK
PDQ\ODZVXLWVWXUQHGRQWKHWHVWLPRQ\RIHDFKVLGHjVH[SHUW
ZLWQHVV7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWFKRVHWRFUHGLWWKHWHVWLPRQ\RI
3ODLQWLIIjVH[SHUWZLWQHVVDQGHQWHUHGMXGJPHQWLQIDYRURIWKH
3ODLQWLII8SRQUHYLHZRIWKHUHFRUGZHILQGXQGHU0LFKLJDQ
ODZWKDWWKHHYLGHQFHDGGXFHGDWWULDOZDVVXIILFLHQWWRPHHW
WKHVWDQGDUGVIRULPSRVLQJOLDELOLW\XQGHUWKLVDFFLGHQWDOGHDWK