Court Opinion

ID: 4069426
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 00:36:23.080237+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:34:17.079704
License: Public Domain

- nix':£'t'\;:c%:>[§ils _ "/\"/D” §§ d /~) f pp /Z# '/ gi `: Si).(?h Di$?fi€? _
» 1 /~ …
'E'@)<§n‘§war'a;-z, "§'e)c;§xék\ ' \5>/ )( g YC//€ 21 /4”/?/0 60 9 ®éTeXa'fkana», `Texas

Dek)-:‘a Az,:%rey, Ci~;~\r bpa ;K'&WW@M ©L"e'rrk

LA)Q)€/% :72);§ ;Ev§;$ ' W€//af;/”

4 j}%,?¢§ 04 /Ex£s' /Zi/M//£@

»§5% Dg%n'@% 5ka
Zz/‘dioé $¢M/;.LHA§
her @u/?i¢ /l/'Qn /55~27£94

 

 

 

~ /Vlcv€b,u 72:02§/)12§5 L;¢.,w;s@/ /¢0@@@2 /%J@

4 _‘ z ~ O/\/ »D'V€C//£zp'p€@/
75 _/7/0/\/0,€01% :72;/1§£ of 474/a e///€e 1222/eff .
y §§rm; NoW 4/)/1@//2?/~/£ L}V/€,€_ 335 xj¢;/:;a_<) /}c/
&bo\/._r-: 57:7/€6£, @Maj /\/LP/’h L€Kej @Qc'./_§z;l @~)U Q~c;?[/`@./\/
‘ 0 . 5401/\/ féé" fosz fAF/ 47.£¢»//,_014>//)\/;; j

_' 725 [_//\//}Le.¢/ j/aZ€/s 2)/2//7/”@/7¢€/_@¢//€/ 405 4é4/
§L}MU_L 71’4€//& /`6 /WS> wm$£`?£u%`o/\/d,/‘//"//?%L?Z 755
/-"e‘/$//"e`s'e/~/¢ 0/\/5<5€/7£ 0/~/" d/g ea// /Wd/"?€‘A)e>z'l/» 522/04

’ of /2/>/@22/ cf €2/,€,»,;~2,, w -/I/,%//M€; 2>,-~;7,1,>~2-/

 

523 us /33§ /)_@5. ave ése¢. 692_, 745;: E@/za/§QY.
[2002)) dee raw/23 245ng /702'§:'“W jj z?$, 275 t
_[7:"»2',),4/2§@#1*/?¢2@@ 2005 vr/er)¢;;/¢/:{/jz,/}\/j
444/t dam/y "2~,/e f 533/fay /O 04 /’/;2 `/»/57~)\%5
&M$)A/%M%'M{'aée;§ /W4 CLW£@/” 7%€/”%44
ifJ@/// kd/?/ZSM-?La]£/`o&/ 4%/*!`5 44)¢' 523/744
47/70€»/4//?7 M7L L/'MQ/e)r 4;,/»'£//42¢/'/%4/?¢ 441/15
/`_f 0/” /2/¢;/) /%§u/e_c/@/° -` & 'G/”/'/??/"/\/@// é/¢/€/\/a/Q,u+j
¢7/0€/5 we 58 25’/27/\4¢/42)//? /'\/" 4 4 _§:3/ '<~//e_
F/”€/a”€/‘/?z¢//m/ m/%p/?e¢/L Jeej/` ‘//5;2 403/5 ibm
/Q?oc,. 6’//€/7»// 45//&/)//)/4/€_§7[50/3/0 20/4.),° 5€_€3
/M§o 5/2,/{/22 22 57‘2%5 /7"@ 521/224 222s 239
' Z,'TE`X 47/77¢:1~~' )/(/A,(;o :@r`a/e);")., 504 7%€ f/` 4 40
l/Cl¢w/e<§€~/ A'A/€ 58//¢>/\/j7v/3&?// £dA//\/o/ 46
M_M
/`5- A/b?‘jqé<\é'_z;e/s/,n; 43,._3_}1/4_335€, 443 .3//`. 33`43/445

4904//»”30/3 4/6/'44€/` /:€ /43_, //`ce/l/.§€£ /\/3/ 45 63/71-

.' g M/,i}l/ 1/”3/3333/4 /”_3/6; 347/27th313\'333/3/'/3/cl 433/34
6333/§3433 /33) //973.: )3/_434»@33~ 693 337
293 /'77 _ N3/’ 4€9/3~3{/ % _4/;/33.3?/'\! 426/3333/. 33 .
333/333 33 33 33 3 33333 333 3
633/334 43/€/331>/4€/ 633/3/33/ 443/4 443.?»3/4`4
94 4/;5 , 93//\/ 94&£/1/3’&3 90733/10463/“4@ 62 6/6/\.%33/

` 34\ " 6%34»/6 3333/3433/33 347l 6333_3 e-/ "). k
2 143/a 493-344€3 " 4)33/3/ j995337¢§33 f 3143/34 2__!3
/195/ 94 %6 /99<‘/45 493/6 37[ 0/`/74))\//?/ %3¢,
43/4464/26§§ 97 64/:<93/)1//4'/ 9467€/\/3/3’/)/7[' 46 100 z`M/P
/)/'3)”/" / 343 9/3/33/3/433/ 633/1334 §3,§/33 36 4/§ \~
\M&?z/£/? /'_f /9732343» lla/p/wv?¢¢/-' 3333/3 43'//%€ /
[ 373/3//3/"31'1/»/°4‘/)/~ -'.[ TSX 410/z =6.”/}33 .. 433 . 45
y 934 335/442 /W/€ 445/”744* - » .' 43 _§EM-
.’ /333333~43)433/ 255 . 93336/33/, 446743/ 3213£6
. /7¢3.¢4 /2\/ 313/w 7%5 9/6)@/64#499334446 ,
, 333/gm 933/ /’/4_"533///3'33746 5 3418/4°4“€“"
/33353343433/33 443/ 446 .//?>@@6/.. W//’//,

 

. .4~ ' ; . ‘ ‘ » '

1€€“¢" 454/51 / 5"}/4?4,?'! /§;’ 461/414444 4411/124}£`/4/§
}4:§7 /”4’"4? // 4.$.,‘. /,.”: 11745/41;4313` 11;'§' 4.4'¢§141,';»,::4;;4 ;4€44/// f/yf,,`/ '

__ /// 1 451 ‘1'4'//§ //"'1§4/: /44 411 4»4{4§4;4444141<'15
44*4§‘”' ///11444%/4.14 4/ GJJ?(&“»’§ @FJ/JN,% j;"{§ § €441)/§ fci»iiffs* 4’ /Q»

4*§11_." 4’§4414?‘§/4'4 411 444/"/ M}"d/H€a/ /44`.4; /"4 //"“ 741
Cf"‘n' 4’1"§1/ /f?“’- ¢4"? t%;’“?¢ dr§/‘£M?//'/l§' "~‘\°~741/14"'4*11 /7/4§"?'°’ ?A£#

4114414 '.4/§€ 441 4444442444/ 414/414 141 41:,4£ 4”4144,44 §44/
4444§4/41/4:~§44/§ 1214 4 /;,'4 /§41/444§ 441444§ 1173

-/46//1§../_,` "§

§ ,~e iii 4 § 71 v `): w il M
-§_.1\5 1"441"41`411"4{114 4 451 51 11:14 <’

 

 

   

 

    

3 . ii _* -. " -` n ` ,W'»' 4\'.-~ `
évayj{;f éj“".j /~;;? f»£;':’f`;. j jn§#§g"/,»?é {M¢z"?€/L// 444 v _/;:°'J "4`}414.5_§" .
Lé£",¢f!{(f"j EAA/ jj&!/'_()é} jqfé,{,¢f,¢;,,,,_ / pf¥,{¢t,~f¢,w/;;/z/¢F#
5/441!// {,/4,1’ §§".,41.,..,/‘»~,4_4 7 ,44 747 '" ..

_ ' 11914"",5"/§// :1§[414
' 4 /

 

41' / ij §

       
 
     

 

¢'sm*'#."m'p‘¢:'uw Wr.r.¢"z.~'~ >'r“%a*'~'v- -',\-:n if~»~ "°ca: ~W>z*

z /?/1'“4° §§14//”“41//§)/»71 141§41)'§ 412 .§1/¢414/ 46':{

113/lew 4745314 V€_ §'£'“114"4'»§4*4>444/;§" 15 441 444;~:`* 429‘7€/442"!/”4 41 41 4 § 1’" 444141 1*’

--~_",44“'/{ 441/11 411/ 413 1114/54

§‘

1'3"`“§~5 -43§1‘1‘/1§'§'§§ 1/1/414144' 1’/§ 1111 4§‘_’4 """4:*4»1:;44 44444§/ /4,,4 54 4411‘§‘“ ` n
- ` 4 / _

  

'1§4:"“‘°¢44$ 4§1"“*2":" 444 _.f 4444;,>' 13’*‘ 1§"“ 31444.4~.3£§/§4$'§%_ 4411»?§§
l 7 _

iii '

  

/7"/`), 111/§{1_1/1 ¢1/§1<>

/U/////: %:/¢ nw;~Fr‘Es\.f"\:)l\;s

SixthDiS."lf ct

ZSZZF `:?f:i”@l Ucugzms `_
L/[//WA/ /£'A///Z§> 775`§)@\»¥':|'1£“;£¢€;€&(|‘;$?;(\ ,

_'3/1’ grade/7 §/%//’M

991/71 /{/ 1411%119% / Z/ 517

/§`§' 1711/1 J/§`/ré 111/§ 111&/1/§#%
§31,€11/1/111 /§_)1§.~.§ 75§§1

é: /%772»11 z- jun/1155 511/15 @/ 5 11%@@6€5//1£515/5'_£
WA! 1>1/”1127 /¢p/Jzé/ .

./]112/@ Z/1/51/,,‘°
147/w 5 f 1\/§5/ 605/55 %M 1915 f»§)g%§/z/&%'

/ F//’/A/ d/A//L A/ I'M./@zé@/ /@£!/v”/£é/C:¢§ 639/9/, /,,¢/5@
1716 %@ £§111§% //"1‘11'17 §11 %2§1111>77,1115-

L> / /1/££1`/£~ / y
51 ld>@§d //

§L° 1711 /1/£ 119/>25/%/5,,/ 5-,,/,/ §
jig ;§077’ %7';:::/ 2//:/0'7£ 1 A‘Z:: c///@
1%//1/¢7