Court Opinion

ID: 4049196
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:53:24.479733+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:28.204008
License: Public Domain

:WS_.MS _ ' %,W-<)¢

i PECE|VED IN
‘Cour\ op Cxia\i¢\a\ \\(>p€q\s <,4" `T<.ms c(W‘Tj”:CR"V"'\'*‘"-APPEALS
\~\on. N>L\ Acos\ca\ CLev\c ` UNU`?US
c>.u. w \a'z»o ca@;xa\ Sxa&aon AbeMcosra,Cr¢rk

/‘\u:>¥i¢\ \ Texc\s '1%"\\\'

‘R\=_t APPL\¢AMTS 919 SE wasme FAcTs an\r~!(, M\D
ComcLus"\m\\s 0\= L\\w C_Aus\; No. oq~\a-o\»\;»a»cv.- (\`\
Ex ONU\; \_\x`\s Am‘romu \AEN&MEL.

hear N\I. l\cos“\a‘.

E¢\a\osec) `\s ~\<\\e above men’n’o./\ed dowmei\\$
-Q.,( 4\\¢» above s&\j\ea ama mmwe¢) cause. meese D<\e cwa
P\'ese¢\¥ <\'\\QS€ duewv\o_/\¥s` \oe(:)€e ~\/\r\e Cour`\. P\€Qs< provide
m)n`ce u@ (er “\ow ‘r\`m@ C\v\o\ assis'}anc_e.
` S`ince€{\§j»
LAMA

Lu§s (X¢\\m\“u \~)\e¢\en@)eL
T\\C:S Mo. \'\"\\%o

_ `T¢\Qrd Um§*
act 9.‘\€ \dc-z 3qu 34¢\¢ \v\_~.,v\ our
new \B»s-\m @T»a."lssvo

 

C'Au%E wm m~\:;\-omaa '-<~,a-~(\\

EX PAR‘TF_ 4 tn \'\-\F_ amos m=
L\A\S /~\MTos\\\o ME\\\F.\\\DE). at cQ\MmAL M\JEN_S

4 _ oF TEXA$

A\°PL\<;AMTS Pm) SE fm swan To TRE Sr¢>:u=_`s
Ausws_a \~o A<>¢>L\m>~m'¥s APPL\¢A‘\'\¢)N Fon. \“>oST-
Cm\\\)\c:r\ou wm'r oF \~\ABEAS comma

'TO T\-\E `\-\omoum’>u=., Ceu¥>;\' cF cv.\w\mAL A\>\>E_ALs uF T_E\cAs'.
acme-s now +\r\e Gp()\§v,m\'\ `ir\ +\'\e above S‘\\»;\€cl C\r\cl
humched Cc\use. ama modes +\f\is \r\o\<\o
p\`ncl ~`\'\~u'-\' \`il is ncc€$sqru` cbs a \r\eo.c`m<§ on +\\e G.\\e<>,cd\`ms
P(CS€_¢\\’€¢§ Cu\¢\ iv |fccmmme¢\c\ \`¢\§ep hasé¢l Or\ \'Y\€> w(i+

up kaher curpu§. Iv\ suppon a{‘ +\r\o Qpp\\fum\ wou\o\ SNLQ
+\~Q Cour'\ ~\~\r\e Qo\\ow\"~g‘.

l l. T\r\e l-\pp\i`co¢\‘\ was C,\\aro§€d in Q jrwo -» enun*
§v\d€a`\me¢\\ w§-¥k \'\\e G\OPEAS€S 09 c,o.p§\’a\ muw\e( 0.¢\¢>\
tdqu (`G\Ja"\ec) rohb€rus am F'e\ouaru§ '\A» 51qu . C C.. R. 513 .

éR. Up¢)e\ /-\pp\\`car\'if‘$ P\€Q 09 no\ OSUL`\\'\\S +Y\€
Qpp\\'ear\‘\ was -`rr\`ed \r\ “\~\\e 9.9.\ $Jr. bis\'r\`a\ Courd\ op

MD¢\¥¢}G{!\€(`\$ ('.0\1.'\*\5» T \ar_k 00 S<;leA-¥\`P\`c r€'\iah§\\`\‘\)s. ('See
S‘\'a*\e`s `r>f€e©) \Dq¢“j€ \"`\\.

,3. `Thz,%\\iw\'}r\ Cuu_r)¢ op Pzpp€a\$,"ha¢k€c\ ~\~\\e.‘;`)’m¥e`s
Coe\\*e¢\~\io¢\ op no a\>us'e 99 discrejtiun . `b\,§ ~\'\v\`e. ~?\'f\`¢.\ cour'\
in i<¥s, unpuh\is“\\ed op`m\`m\ "\ssue¢x mine alo\:m\% . (See
memorandum csc DP€r\ior\» `\30§\\-` S`\Xv QQCS€ \\o\.

t l q. ‘ U\pp&\\§)re Cour\s‘&\ Q<\ed a ~¥§»me\\)\ Qe,¥§\*€on
Q)r clis¢ce\*\`o¢\o.r\§ reu\`ew w\\§c_\r\ was €e@used . m mo%\`on
‘c`u{ f€\\eo.<‘\r\cg was ‘P('\€c& ..' -

_ \b. -/-\pp\\`ca-r'\:\ 'Q`\e¢! a "\"ime\\§ _\.ur\`\ 59 ~\\Qheas
corpus ,w\`¥\r\ matured Q.r e<\ €vi¢\er\\u\§ \r\eoc`\nc) cm N\v\e
\`¢\€P-Qedr\`ve_ @\ssis“‘\o¢\c.e op Couu\se.\ C\aims) on Oc:\n\oe: &\4»°10\\\.

\\. con (¥\a\,$ 33 \ AG\S ~\?\\e S*Q*\e . Subm\`““\’€d §‘\*$
answer k ` upp\\`aa¢\¥`s mpp\\'cc:\\`os\ er 0‘§( cmu\<:k`\on wr\`¥ 09
habeas corpus and \`~¥s ~de\{ncss avoid cma\ Cunc\us€ons
c>~$“`\czw9 ,' . ~ .  
x \%. ‘TY\i`s. documer\X Q>`\\vws as r¢huH\¢ \\1 S¥Q¥¢‘S
Cm\’ve\‘¥u)e\s.

5a Oc_‘\'ube_¢ Q~% s 3.0\\\‘ \' "'¥\€ `C\\OP\\`CC\¢\'\ ‘p\~`€d his 'p\¥`$+
Qpp\icajr\`b¢\' ~Qr we`v\ op habeas C‘or(>us-- cé\\eg§~¢\os €r\ Q>m* l
C§mu_r\a\s 'Qw Ce\Re-?' ‘\“\m‘\ \\e cl\`a\ '¢\o\ rcdeue e€"Pec:¥\`\)e,
GSS`\S‘\*m\L€ cap Cc)\.ms€\ Gv\ ‘\(\`Q\ of on Y\Ks P\fs\ Qp¥p€Q\ op
r\`cjh+'._ app\ia`m\’r reques‘\ »~¥\\e wqu w feu€ew a\\eqa¥m<\s
"Sp€c\`~\:`\`ca\\\$ 'of%ume¢\¥s”~ \‘ and ‘B! 4 ’ ' ‘ '

_ \. Tr\"a\ Cbunse\- ‘Qa.`\\ee\ ‘\~o §¢¢\\)e-‘s‘c\‘c)o.\'e '¥\\e <-`W\a\\`p-
'\"Qc\'wms 09 _\d\“. \<,\`m Arfedor\do which denied ama\\`ccn\\' 09
am exper¥ wi.*c\~ess 40 \~€'S\{`Q` on:`\v\§s \ad\a\Q 114 '\r\‘a\.

5 »A\Op€\\a')re (‘_ouv\‘se\ pa§\er,\ h m\$e ~\¢\r\z \)'\`ab\e
'\`$SU€ op `-§'\\€ \€CSG.\ ‘SUQO\`U&\<;'\$ C)‘p €,\)'\`cl€r\ce. `\\'> E>UP\'JL)("¥
+\\& CUr\\.b\c’_‘\'\u\n 00 CC\P\`*a\ ¥Y\\M`d€£`.' - ~ ' ’

' Or\ decembu .\\\ ;Lb\\A \ -\'\\.c .Com\ issued a des\` m\~\‘on
09 cc>¢<\m\)er)ced ~. meviuus`\\§ unreso\\)»ed Pc\c:\s 1~¢\&'\€€€\`<:¢\k w
+Y\€ GQQ\\`QQ\\‘\`S C_\o.i¢j¢\s x Ou\o\ ordered a‘\‘\ocr\e\§§s Ffa¢\\€_
\b\qse_\( ama \lnhe.<~¥ Mc>c\'ow‘ ¥o Qr¢)u\de O\Q@m\o.\i§‘\$ (espo~li:r\§
40 app\\"@a'r_\¥s. c;\a`\ms'. T\\ose . acRdw;Xs. \\auo_ mm been
€\`\`ed w\`~“\“'\~\r\€ Cour¥. ‘Opp\iecm'\ '\~\`me\\)§ 'fes($m\cled b ~¥\\0>€
Q'Pp\“dau\`¥s», €Xposi¢\q misc\uo¥a~\_\‘o¢\s up ~L\\Q es&a\a\{s`\\cc! record
hand ~‘v\\e. uncecsm\ah\€ Gp`p\€ecz']r\on op 4\¢\2 jackson 'V. '\I{r<§‘iniq
sh~dom\s as sd Qc¥\\»b»§~ ~\\\e Sup‘rem¢ Cmc\ . h \J\<.Mo¢ww.'
0\¢\01' 5\\9\0\`¢\¢3 -¥NL er\ \r\u,.z \~kc. %\Qsz\<“s¢ QPP<<:\Q\)'\‘ ,Sh'voor\e¢).
~\'\\e Qp\)\§co.n\`s Co<\¥e¢\*\\‘u<\§ 09 his de(~`\'c§er\‘\ perQ»cmar\c€ \`:\ ¥\\e
regards k \3€. |Xnedm\do‘_s zua\\`@\“<;c.¥\`ons' md ~'\'\\`s_, \ac\c 09
€nsum\ she was qua\\`(-\¢ \o 3¢<'§¢\‘-~@\3_ on Qp~Q\`\cQ“~\sl belm\‘@.
T\r\ese ' esponses \~» Q@P\'daua&s were presen¥¢d ‘\o ~¥\\c \\`\‘;\nd
(‘.\Qr\< got (bf€$€c\~‘\n‘\;on ~L `¥\\c Cou¢~\

ibe<§im\inc; 0.\ (30<3€ 3 op “\'¥xe 5‘\¢‘\¢`§ answu; parerL,
S€€.,\'\Bv\ I~\. I\\c‘(~"'@€c*ive a'$$i§‘\a¢\cc op ‘\'(\'Q\ <'_Du¢\$’€_-\¢ TY\€_'
§*}o\e reci¥es "H\e o&"? +¥\e record hague H~a §uru_\ ks\'\`n\om.g

w;)`\'\€f€r dr..l\f¢ec)oe\cio ‘.e~cp\o&.c'\s_ '¥\r\a\ SX\¢‘~VDQS€G_ \e_r. cun¢,\usi`ons,
§r\" ‘pc\r‘\ ~\ » 0¢\‘_3'..(3. $v€s¥\`¢\c§. ‘¥\'\a-\ was normal Q‘>c x Someos\e 9mm
a cz\i?@€zem¥, req\`c§n ‘W\m\:?\'\~c_ app\\`mc\“\ because_~,~\~» \\r'. (\¢ E\ Sq\vadowa¢\%; . ’Dc.
Acredm\}_~io odm\¥+&\ ~\~\v\e€e was \\`jr\\e research .‘su()@oc~¥inj?f\v\er
+e_dm.\`oyue§» bu\, §¥cr\ed` &\r\a§ her me-\\\ucls wm wcdé\v$
QQC€pjre¢.\ w\`¥\r\i¢\` ker @\`c\d 09 €‘\cp€r\-€sa. 'I¢\ o~¥\\e»r ,woro\S-.
w\'~“\{¢\ "\\\€. P":»'\§Cl\o\ue`\`ca\ 'Ce§w\mun§\~/s \r\Q/ me~¥\l_,\dlds Od€ O.CC€,P`XC\;\\e
end +\\n. \1\65\ op¥\\m wai\@k\\.e. - . _ .» '- . _
T\\€ 33¢0.\*€. "\\\w\ CO<\C€€AS 4\~`\¢\0."\ “ Sics'¢\\`{`iam\¥\vs) \`Jr»
A{{€cjdmjb WQS U\Q\;(~"\`€d inc adm{:\`\$;;\ef on `I.Q. 4€5&
and '\~es‘c§{‘~.` ~rec§oc¢&§c\PM \<\er ‘\€s'\\mmw§ wm ncr\
de¢\`c\`e!\%i' `\`\\is wou\o\ sucy:§€f>§ -\\¢\e abuse of"¢\iscse’<\`un
CG¢\‘¥€N\’\M\S` f:»€»,\ ‘Q.»‘:~\»\ C>.'\ Q(>p€a\f '\~\m@u‘ar. \'\p\c SFtQ)te do@s.
qua Cw\ ‘\'o subm§-\ ¥\\£ Q(`oh\en\ wGS--~¥\\e “ undertqu Sc\`encef.'_~
Tv\e Texc\_$ Q\.L\;es 04`3 E\)\‘c\@\ce. QLL\€ '1()9~; 13 pe@p\'¢a,\\,\j -,a`$ in
Cuy\'\'rdc\ic'\pbn up ~M\€ S¥Q}€`S' posi"\'\`\m. I~(’ `--.SC.A\"¢,¢\-\¢,.‘§Q\`c gil §ed\-
nrea\ m o-¥\\Q,r spec`w\hed\ \c~>.u\_ealc§e .w<\,\ assis¥_ }\\`e»}rx\‘er c
op 916 470 und€rsjrm\a\ evidence w \o d@.¥ermir\e»d pad +\> `vw\,ler-
S\’cv\d ~'\#\v\£. evidence m ‘d@;\~um\v\e a jc>a<“;\ in i.ssue_,a-‘_w\`\n~es'$:
%Uq\ip\"€a\ 4_(15- O\r\` €XP€£\ bus \<.¢\ww\€d£:`€\_§\ti_\\ 1b €`&Q€¥.i‘€r\(‘.€ =') 1
'h`ai¢\€m§ ear eduecd\'m\ \ ,N\a\,§ -\~e$¥iQ/S ~¥\\Ue'\o ‘w\ +~\\€_%€m egan
op\`m`on o»»r~ 04\\@\»§30¢ »`Tex. ¢L, u(»"‘E\);¢J. "\0& Sc.\'er\‘rc{»`.~`<,- ev-
\`o\er\<’_e 4€¥\0.&5 be shown fe\ia\'_\\e- even ~\N\u\xc§\\- `r\o’l‘\. %€\ %€r\em\\.,\$
C\CQ€Q'\'€A i¢\' #\~\\9. .(`c\eucu\\ ‘SC\€¢\‘\§@\`€ Cc>mm\,u\i‘\\,§... 5<’.,€ _E.C,\eow§,
€.c\. N\acom\€'c.\£ on E\J\‘d` presen¥ amg :eu'\‘c\Qr\ce e;s¥ak\is\\inc§ “\~_\'\Q)c Q¢\o¥\\er 'R)W\ op
~%~e$~\'i¢i\g y “ ovef\ou\ .~We ~ Qpp\.icmv}'.' ,
T\\€f€ `- is ¥\0 Q,v\‘c\Qi\C€' 09 "€i)r\\€f`_ op 4\\25`¢: Cc>c\\er\“\\m\% due '~¢»
>m .\m qu +M MQ\ QOW\S€.\. P¢\a\ed .\m w?¢m&¢. wage a
neceser Areas 09 €r\`ru`\rc§ k ensure \\\‘s Q,\im\~o\)¥a<=\ed.
a qua\i@\"ed exp-ar\ wi’messi »w\\\‘c)\ \`5 \mr\\\ d€'(~\‘c_icr\\~ m\d
prejudice per@m~m¢\ce \va\.§ Cbuns€,\.. 330 ¥\\¢z =Qpp\iacm¥ \\ad
b-eer\.o€?ocded on ex p@-\ ~w»;¥v\es`s k kicqu -regq¢d\` \m's ~
d€z~é\€r\is\\ed me.'\\Q\ Gu\ pabi\\`-k§~. -SUQ\\ as \\{s \Qc_\( 0' ~\'\\C
C\bi\\`*\$ '\'o pmm ~\'\\e""ir\‘\€z\*"' "’r\\< S\Q.\~e Was f€O\'UL`\r wo§ Qua\\`p§ed ~Xo ¥ey\~\“p ". Thus» C(ec:“\\<§

a Cm\~¥{ao\\`c:'\€o¢\.` A% ‘¥(\‘Q\\ ~\\\€. S'XQXC Cc)s\ ends ~\'\‘\a*\ \\r.
Arredm\du ums` v\u¥_".qua\\`(»\~\`e¢l' \\> ¥€5.‘¥€‘

93 03 on e¥p€¢\‘\ wa’c- 1
hess \. w`k\‘d\ .+\\e `~H\`Q\. CouH a feed r`h> ~. -¥¥\us no~\ a\\uo\`ng
Bc.\Pwr€c.\m\db ‘\~'> '\€dlv§p\b*€l\ ‘*\f\`_Q_\._ \|€\ ,u_d\\é¢\ abuse op ¢\€56- '
Fe‘r\cm was raised on appeal ,-.¥.\\_e S&Q¥e. cmi +\z»k\-_iu¥\\\(!w’¢
ap Cl(apea\s Q¢g{e abus{_, up disc€€r\`o:\' .q\d.
~i'\\a¥ Br_.. Pcrfec\m\¢}o .was "NJ\." O`_uQ\{@\'eci '\o '\€'3\{§3 . NM~-u)e\m
”\r\e(lpec\'§o-c Q§Si$*ancc 09 Qc)u\se,\ is FQRS€A m w‘€\`.¥ del ' `
\r\ah€oS-- CD¢`\>\..\S \~»-'¥\m»o acco¢`d\`r\%' ~\-o '“\e S\‘Q*€. \\r.= (\(.rcciot\&b -.
was “ m &\Qd. qua\;\>@@a"w +@3&< QO¢@Q\\. § . 1 /
Iv\ Cm\c\uso`or\. bus ~\/\\c.Qp(\`\\`u)u\\, ~. `.`L-P W\.A((edo¢\do~g)as»
nu\ CWC\\{'Q\`QA ¥~:» ~'¥?S\€‘Pv, Qs.-om efaq€r)r w'€’\v\es§\.,.~¥\v\m\ vc~_ou'\nse.\
was dep\cie/\‘\ \0\5 N`J\ §d\\)es"\c<»\ Culp@b\‘\\"¥\§ 'w\<\\‘<,\\
\)"\D\cx‘\€cl 0199\§€¢1¢\'¥$ due QCOCQSS Cu\a,\ \B\Ae Coms< op \_a.w~"q`s
pm-\ec\e@l \o\$ 4\#\\»'0 Cm\'s‘\_£§u%im\ op +\\e U¢\i¥ed 3'\'¢1\~€3 encl"Tcms.

€>Iec;`c§u.¢\ .\ Q., \ €uppic§mc\»s _m‘(~’ €v'\`d€m€ z <\\\'\`z”_d q&`o\)\¢\ol.

C\pQ-Q,\'\a¥e a~\’¥omev; . _Rn\)'v.v¥ \\Ao(cow PQ`\\ccl &o am\\e'\qe_
-\\\'Q ‘S\.\W\`¢;\`em\$ up €\)’\`d*li\€£ *\<»" Suppo<`* a cor\\)\‘d\`on op
Copi'\a\ mucd€f. -TY\€ 34¢'1‘\€ te:‘&§>\<:¢`\c\s ~\»\\o.*< \\M V\or-ww‘s
Qm'dau`\¥ Cw\(’_\udes ~\'\\c\‘\ q\'Y\€ Q,V'Adqw\ was (-\o\m¢.\ a\ kod\er number S%_ w`\\ete \r\\‘s `
Co~c\e@z,~de¢\+ was a()prd\e\o\ed. CQ.R.\-\ \\ka-\»;l\\. Gpp\§m¢\&‘s'__
Sis‘\er.-`m~\.aw fes\`c\€c) cd ~\'(Qi\€r num\rm» 58 \r\er no.nr\gis
m\\‘o Memar\de?.. Co»~ de@\do¢\\ \Ll\)etc. was apord\e,\deol ad _
ms \uea&am\ w'~.¥»\ x\\.e mgm WQ\\Q.\ ad mm wald »\\/<
v»<-.+sm.b\uuc\ 34\\\ w i&. CQ.v..U\. \uo~\zn\. ‘r\\e agp\im>(
\`esic\eé'.`\n X€o§,\€f numer a w<~\\\ his vo<$e' V\ar\‘a \J\e¢\ender,.
Gpp\(c&r\§ was C.‘-\\Me\\&\c\@d Q\ ~\~\\\'S \_bcn“\'ion cmc'.\ \\\‘s vo\` P€
C§o\\)e- o Cm\$€z\¥v\a\ `Searc,\\ 00 +\`\Q premis`\s where abso\u&\\j 7
NJ-\'\\V\q 09 €\`4\\€( v\`C\\m was Q>\md. '\'\\e!e@ca, Mr...\~&ot€o.ds
Ccp(’edou~a¥ is ¢\u¥ ,Cf€d'\b`\e' because \\Q makes S‘\’q-"\en\e,¢\-\S
`H\ajr arc Cc)or\p\d'c\v$ Co:\)cmrq § -\»\~o (Qcoocl c)¢\d- \\\S apg)\\‘ccc\’\`un
69 +\\e ZSQC\LSU¢\ v. V§r§§¢\iq s\a¢\o\ac<~) lv\o.\\$ SKOr\. '
- Th€ S'\ak-'Q\so made o s¥o;)cemq\\ am page 5 up

\"’rs cmswem -¥\\a~\ (\`\vem (co'~&e@e\¢\m% cwa ~\~\\0_ O\oo\'\coM -
p\`\ed ~(’Su()p\{ed\ ‘\'\\@v\y(~\r\\o v\‘c§c{ms\ _w{¥\v\' a\cc,\u\ -b~eQ)ce cam-
V\\\c§\r\c§ ~H\Qm \o dwi\)¢ 3m Q' temu¥e \ur.o.)v\o¢\~. `\'\\\s €"’fa‘\emer.\’r
\`S Comp\£‘\\e\u} Gu`f\\(`oc\,§ \¢ *\'\vz f€ch\c'l Cv\c\- un\me.i T¥\z

 

fecc:»cc\ es¥ah\\s\\es- app\'\m.\-Xs» mem ' p€esenc€ av\ .~\¢\r\z $¢er\¢
end Y\\s *Q\ics\\»§ Qu-m +\\@ Scene . E\l€n' w§\r\\ -\»\~.2 "\x\mlmissi\s\e ,
evidch 09 or\. wa_el§ud\c~_a¥ed 0~@&'\$€ op on Qq<;rcwo&ea\
mbh@r\.j,w\‘¥\n_uu\§ c>\aWQreN\ ospedrs. 03 +\\e recoed s\\ws»
01\#2 wee\£ (dr\m~ \=@ ~\/\o mmd&r,c»<\\\)s Qm\)ed 3m ¥\\Q §ur\§
+\\a¥ -~\'\\¢ opp\w\s‘\l\,' \o co~mu\§~\ oosqro.ua&e¢\
robb€¢`\§ w\\€c\\ ic\ i‘\$£\p §§ Q vio\a*\`m\'oc ~\'\\€ T€XGS Q.u'\€§
09 EV§G)QAC€ 'Qu.\c “W\\_ (\Q\. Ur\c}\r euq\ua~\'mj¢~\“\\,c ~€up@\denu,$ 09 eum\ence, al
\`deom\ gm C§uu\al NJ"\ conc\ua\e +\\o_¥ ~¥\w app\€con¥ cuu\o\
\r>@ cor\mc.'\e oc' `¥\o oQer\S€ 09 Qom‘¥<»,\ mwo\€r. » . .
"\-"\o\sa\ow v. ‘5'.“;~»\» 639 F.a¢\. '\0\4\ C\H\\=ur\se\`§ Pai\um '\-o, Ci\a\\en:§e ~'\“\€ SUPQ\'Q,_`\ .' op .€vidm
was md sjrrdeoic c\ec_i§mg\ »‘~ hw\. ra~\¥\or» was ou&si<)e 4_\»€
fm\g€ ap propessior\a\ and Comp€'\'€z\'} 05">\$¥0.:\¢£ '\ (`€S\,\\¥\`r\%in
reasono\:\e pwba`bi\`i\\§ ~X\\a¥ . bu\_ Qr Qrwr. (e.suL\i wou\d \\a\)~e
kan a\{@@ztenh o\ue \¢ ~\#\\€ SXQ*\€`S C'a§€ ke\`c\q '\arq¢\~.$
circumsjrcv\%\`o\‘\ onc;\, >¥\\us §r\ep{§d\v_e»ass\`s¥ance_5..
"\'\_\€ €Lu\`c)ence_.\`/\ _Qp¢\iaor\\¢"s case was 30 weak ~\~\v\cd
`\'\\Q S‘\or\c Co¢\ce€clec>\ ‘\/\\cx\v “ ~\\\Qre was \\"H\Q €u\dmce ¥o §\\uw
~'¥\NA M\.3 `\“`\€ 53¢0:\*€\. `\`\Ql`€ §§ Q'\`€'QSB_A'QB\€ pfq`h@b\`\§ .4 `\"\q\'\ hud Q{-W\¢
moru‘c`€'ssiom\ €,rfu»c\ ~"Y\~€ ¢e_§u\\ b wuu\o_\‘ _\\a\)_e -e.e/\ o\iPPUf/\¥ uv\
capo-ed . €`Ru~¢&c\ml v. WQS\\\¢\ &;»..~ ,\\\o\,_, u.s. to.i»%\ _\u\\_s‘c&ws;.
w L.ea.ad wm 1('\°\9%\ ‘\wezw , +\w app\_€@m\\ is`, Q_A&ex\ed
`:\'6 f€\{€‘p c _ l ' 4 . ` `
ile_sped Q`\\\S Suh rai&¥cd ,
LAIV\A` .
(.u.\‘s A¢\\w\io Me,\e,\dev. now $e .

 

c;'ku\s£ Mo. oq-\a~m-\aa.~a\'z~;€\\=

E~c PAQTE_ - ` \l 'T.M “\`\-\E Cc>u\\T 09

ku\s t\».\\foc\\\o M\=.'\~\&\\\\del “k ,CQ\MN¢\L APPEN_"> ,

~ 4 DF_ 'T E\L vs

 

AQP_\_\¢AM`% ,<>awose\s F\m)'me,'s us
\:A¢':r Au~h' Cm\\'ct.us"`\on 5 M' t_l\w

 

`\-#\Qu\nc§ (eu\ewecl +\r\€' S*o.¥es pfo@us€d 91`¢\0\\':\0,3 09
9&¢_4 canal Cor\a\usiur\s 09 \aw s `\\\e Qpp\\am\X `\r\exe`\ov; e.v\ers
+‘\€ R>\\Uwinc‘§ gwinnsz 09 90¢\'$ and Qo.'\a\us\`i>e‘\§. 09 \aw °¢

__EJMLJ_L)_{:$_D£__EBC_'S_

-- D-r\ O¢-;\‘u\aec .§l%-.;lo\\x\ ~\\v\e _c\op\ic_ur\'\ 9\`\€&"¥\€3 99ch
app\i`ca‘¥ion ~Rw w€i‘\ 09 \'\a\s€Q_S ~Corpu$ \‘dur~sug¢\'\ \o arX\`<;\€ '\\`0”'\
09 '\'\\e Cude 09 C.(` 09 '\~\\2 V(€Ac\Q Coc\ue¢\‘¥\`o¢\. . \ - _

. C= P__\p()e\\a¥e counse\ 9a`\\ed ‘\~o aw\\.m:ge &\\c \)\`Qb\t _.;
'\S$u€ 09 ~\'Y\Q \ecjo.\ Su("~P\c\e!\c~§ 09 ~.\-\\e eu€cl&‘\t€ L) Suppor"t ~\\'\e,.
GQp\\m¢\¥\‘ 5 CG€\U\€,\"NA.

d Appe\\\ \\\m %LM\\`

vs 0¢\ Ba¢\uo.r~.s §‘l'\§ ama and assessed
Pw\§s\\mer\\ oc\ \69< \'x\Q§`\Sm\me/\“\ w§-\r\\cm¥ (dc\m\€ § CC§\L. \9.‘\§ \‘5:1-\'5'3\.

9.. \he \‘\\§¢\r¥\\ Cuu§~\ 99 Apoea\s 099\:¢~¢\€¢) +\§e Qpp\§cmv\s
Cc>r\u\’c_~¥§o!\ \r§ nn unpu\o\\s\\€c) op§r\§m\ on De:\o\s:_ cre¢\;m¢

5i T\\'e S"\a~\e now Cm\¢;eee\<.i ~¥\‘a\ ~\»\\e €u\‘c\`mce» €S)rab\i$\\e¢\
¥\¢\a\ “c‘ Acfeclo.'v.»!o Was i.~§ Qac~¥ qua\\9ed \~o ¥€5*\§9»3 abood
§n¥\€\\€¢=_~\ua\ copah`\\\`¥\es cmel mcn\a\ fe)raca\a%`on w\\§<.\v\ es’¢ab\i$h€s
F\'\§a abuse 09 Q\§SUQMM 09 4\¢ C.~>w¥ ad ’m~<»\.

Q,;§ T%\Q!'€_ is nw vszm‘¢\a¢:§c€ ¥¥\a* cm 'I§Q.¥é§§ no<~med 9>€
E\ Sa\vo.dor§m§ na)r`\ac\a\s was o.uo§\ab\f air ~\~\\Q J¥\W 09 +c\Q\ due
k -H\a 9ocj ~\¢\Q\ comse,\ M;r. \`S\Q¢se\a di d no'\ \s\ues¥§cl¢+c *\~\\§s
puss§b§\\`+\§z as \l\d§cc‘\eal m \\§S 0§99udaui\~ `

 

"\. .`T¥\e§e is no evidence ~\/\r\a\ O§§\u¥\\er 95§5.&\\0\0€§§`39 »0§"§
iiw\u§\o§r pru9ess§`o§\c§\ wm\e\ \j\o§ue 9§`0§)§0\@¢\ 90¢)0<§0.¥3\€ anal-
o.dn\§ss\b_d €.u§eleme fec§ord§:\§ ~\-\§a Qpp\§c§:§§\\`s §n\~e\\ec&\§a\~
C~.C§pc§\o§‘\§"\ies§ due 99 &(\`¢§\ Cow\<;e_\ Mr.\"o\asek‘s 'Q:§§\ufc 90
'\r\§)es\‘§qc§\e 4\\§$ 9053`§¥0§\`§\\5 o§s `§§§c\\`ec:\ed b§»\ \\§`s c§@P§d 9€0¢\<§3 ~9€54 09
S§§§Q.\c\c§r§o\. F§'rs'\` S`\r\o§u§¢\@ +\\€ C\Q9§Q_§e§§'\ QWQ>rmm§c€ 09 bo-\\§
Tr§‘¢§\ md 9§99€\\§§\€ Cn§§u§se\`:s c§¢\d has S\§ow§\ 9re3§,§c\\‘ce.\ 5`.-€€.
S*\(\‘c)(_\o.¢\o\ V. \)Jo€`\\\`§\§~\-Dn§ "\_bb _U.S»lpb‘b`€\‘\‘o‘-\§~-a\$o 5€€
E_\< Po§r\<-\|\ac§cra § (p%"§ €§v§)§acl Q\\.‘s (:Te'x. Cc§`§§§ 999.\‘\@;\`§[{;¥
Pc.r\§ D§§QQ§,,'§ L§m s§w.a.d sun CT§:Y. c§§§§§. App.\°§w§. o¢§d
§;/§‘Hs v. L§§ee§§§ \§§p=§ §A.<_s, 399 (\FW S§w-Q.d. b'?>a C‘\'el. C§§'§§§. (\99. \C§'\'§\.

`-\. App€\\a""€ CDuASe\ \ \J\c. \J\\)f€o\.o`s~'dec"_f$ioe\ ¢\0“\ -\-o tC‘,.NLK\»
e“o,e \~\\e \e_qQ\ sup\:\‘c\`e/\c»$ 09 eu\‘dmc` ov.'\ d\"cec} oppec-J
was _w'-\sid'e '~\'¥\e marie range 09 pro¥bssmm\ and Cdmp@¥-en\
Qs$isiance » 0-) based cm M\¢ weakness 09 +\\e S~k\‘¥e‘scase,
C\S OPQ'\\\,_J; an\\`~*\'\ed b\y~¥\\€'§)fq‘\€ a +\\QI€ \`s a ,(`easono‘o\€ P€o`\s“
abi\i\\.§i bid ar '\~N unf(`op€§$'\`onq\ U(‘o\fi ~¥\\Q f€§u\-\S on QW€¢:\
ww\a\ have been da\@£¥m\ . ‘S-km\dev\d \J. Wos\\m¢y\on . \\\»\» u.s‘.
low Cmq\‘» 506 a\s@ \Ao\~s@_\aw v. sm;~\\\ » ma F.ao\. mm
C\\+\\ C‘\`r.\%‘d\ §\~\o\d\`cv§ +\\Q)r Qoui\se\`s @ai\u