Court Opinion

ID: 4041699
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:53:10.884176+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:20.809384
License: Public Domain

55 'wg:l- ’ 05

w WE comm c>F amw\:m\\ mede

m '\\>.e mmi @F f€\M\S RECEIVE| m
couRT oF' cR!MlNALAPPEALs
N\IUOM \&Em\ \Numm;, MAR 09 2015
9 “\`( f\ (\ ` '~
€, \'\` OV\€ Ab@§ AG©SU§ @“@gk

Case &o. \Ml-SS\ \0%7 -o§
Ba\\O\S Cou.v\'& WcS’&r`\C\' Cour'¥ No.$
Case \\¢. \z\\f¥”\ér C<>\.\rst
C\e{\L \F<\‘&ZS'\YV\¥Y\;>Y\SB', Su()c_))€ w\o.v\¢\'\’l
t\\\‘e(?l)\ \ €A' O\\`

`.l`/-'*"/~_l`»¢ »,,`/»I

& ' 0 OTC

»cb»e§ wm M'Am@( LN<\\&°“ m \:\\\\»M@\ L ;¢\\ $\\eg w
§b\'€%o‘\\\ ?\C \.\€S'\" 'QM ‘\'\r\€ Co\x(" '\'o '\'o\\{\€ Iu¢\'\t,`\o\\ \§o¥\€€, ’\'\l\a\' o\)€
4*\¢\€. \‘\5\ \,\`\\\` P\€c\ +mn\sc_f"\‘>kr$ \\e\§ on 'S\.\\\ 9~`\\ \°\°\5 \1“5\€(
Cc»sc No. SO\S~W?>%C\D»N\_" LSM¥€ § Tems \9, \\\\\9<0¢\ \£ero.v\ \§\'\\\’\c\m§\

4\\0\5¢ a r'\ww\ §ud\e ease e\L"\s)r; -\\¢\£r 3r\¢\e, \¥om,m\o\e N\o\m\\\ \\\§€m\
S\ké?€v\b\e ‘\'\r\€_ '\W\ os(\”\"`\on o‘? ‘SCr\\'€r\C\v\S unb\ A€§'ei/(C§\ SCn\'€nc'\¥\S
uv\$r`\\ Jr\/\e, \iec\r §§ 1003 A\Lr`\r\ ~¥\\e,'”\€v/`o~$ wmer \\w(\§v o
ku\>&a§ lch us roccd{\v\c§g ur\B\U \;\e ¢L\)M€_ S\'\\\e cause-
cseeq¥\u\,\$ \;»§»*w\ma P_X\\,%Q‘,b\\, _4

l\\ )r\\e E'\¢§\¢\)v\¢\ C\fc\£§ LWA ¢>§v \>receé\er\§<

s¢} ‘\“ \x»\‘§reh slm\e;“w. s&<*\\\v\g, 30\ 93a c\\¢1 \ G\z\ lw(\/\ C\r.
3001\ and a\é`>b (\V\ °\\r\€ '\`?,r\)r\\ (',‘\zc\x'v\- Couv\ csc t\ ea\; \xv\c\€f

L)US. \J, S'\e.rm-Y'.s‘\@o,‘ ll\Q> pea,\>\??¥, q`|$\ °\%`l U”olr\\ C\r, loo`{\\
"w\<\er\ 4\¢\& '\w\?vs'r\'\ov\ § ser\¥em'w\ ’\s suspend\e,d lr\¢\e com'~\c}r"\ov\
'cS !\5\ ‘Q'\\\m\ ¥br “\-\¢\€, ?\\{`so$€§ c§ tr\\¢\ur\c€m£v\§< ex Gu\x\ §\»\\).f€

cw\\!'\c,\`\bv\$ .

9 agc \ §§ ?>

1\\ ~\\\a c\\oo\l& 5¥~\\& 55¢&5§€§\ s\\\o~cus€ ¥\\\e_$\ b(\$\r'\c>\ wch
\Nr(\§v ex \\c,\\o€,rxs cowde \\e,o`\"\v\c§§ Procce§\"\v\§§~\\e,\& P\v\ j<\l\€
gear csc lbl>z\ T\M~> 2 ¥\\W'm '\ss\»ed` w\ eraer GQS'\'\v\'\‘€ `C,\'\v\)r \\}\c'_\%av\`\e\ c\$ couv\%€\ ‘\’o \’€,€-c>\\l€ "\`\“Q "W¥\€/{f»»,-
L§)€€_ c~.'\\ur,\\€§` F_\L\/\.£ \g 0\?. orr\é\ho\\ 01\\`||\5 ';\\Cb\ P\£O\X\v\ \,
T\¢\e &DLV\@¥ Q\\eedv '\v\ sa'\§ ?re;¢e¢\'u\§s \A'\\\ S\\o\n j<\v\a)c g
~\"\¢\e md §§ so(\}x ?roceeé(\v\§$ 'e`rI<-»X gx ?ro\c>a\"`\on \\c~b\ e\/\P`\fe§`.~.
1\\ +`¢\?_ \\'\v\jv\/\ C'\\’c.\,{\'& Co\x(\' ex \P\¥eo~\€ \m?x€( .Q`L\Y_€§_S)Wki$_l
m\ fm ma am £<\&\\ c_\c, \C\O\l\‘ *<\\e N\v\¥\\ wa~\¥
cona\ué\c\ ~\\\o\\< \u\Be\' C,o\\'\¥c>rv\'\o \a\u o\ Pro\oc»)v"\or\ '\S r\§r
"Sudo)mev\xr" \)A\l\€h "c\\€, '\w\\ao$'\)\"\or\ 652 §er\\'ev\c,€ "\€ S\)\%Y€’)r\§€,r§»v

gee aa\, A 2¢\?>.
?e}v'\lv’\oner '\S 1\<>3¢ ‘(\s\o\»\e_<\ m\o\e ex 5<\<\£ F\¥‘v\\ C\rc_\§\ `€ ?rec.€.~

A&v\)v m ScC\}x S\x\o'€,c,x w\a\\e(‘ \o\\)r '\v\ '\\r\% wear ex \°\C\S 3P<>\v\fv\€\f
\B&\\&s Cow\)t Ccmv\jx U'\§'\~\""\CA' Cou\(lc No. 5 Co\).(\' C\€(\L

[_T'm\ \~\c\m\'\v\\ €\SS\)`C TSLS ~¥\¥\u§( S\‘a\eb\ `§[Q\oa\*”\gb|*'$w\%m€¢\§r~
Cem\m\,\v\\~¥ gm Qf\\`\%§ov\ '(\)\Q,cx c>§ C>~v\'\\”\ of No\o Cov\>v€r\<\t(€
;\)\v \\ku\\led. " C§ez £<\uc,\r\cd E\L\¢\, *3 \; qua m`\spr`m¥e,.b\ ecr\~\o,r\<.€
`"K)Dc:»%\uan §§ls?:c*(|\c&t§r Cc>\x\@\ eu%(\\¢‘ m"\§'\v\§<€r (?,)v %0[\§ docv\w\£r\§r
as c\ -C'\v\o\\ co¢\\s'\c\"\o¢\ of e\ :\M%w\ev\§r."\'\'\s "\Q m\l\\` §Q:\'\Av"\or\er
33 r€c\ues-\'\v\l$ lr\/\¢)A¢ '\'\/\`\S \\ov\ora \e (`_D\Ar-\ \§sue ‘\\v\e re¢\v\e€jre<\
\ur`{\x- erc w\o\v\\§\mw\\x§ '\'b '\’\¢\€, “o\\\uS C.ovd\l¥`\ N\S>tri(}\' C,oufx¢

No. 5 irc c\ar`\§\ jr\¢\e akon s§\\\e \~r'\$r ex \M\»ms cortw\s
?vc)c€ed`\v\§€. ‘\ mm \r\ '\-\\e '\5%\.\'\\¢\3 §§ a cer)r'\;'\e§ e)m\w\t)e>x
9'\\c erc\e( *r\r\¢\\ s§c§ve€ lr\:\c>, S})ec’\§"\c A¢r\e &\r\@\¥ 3`“53€
N\m\v\ \\\er '\w\ used Sev\'¥ev\d\r\ mdu Cas€ \\§0. Fo\§ "l?>°o‘\b"
N\.", kg'\aj¥€_ csx T€Wx§ \4. \\*\r\\)rov\ §€rah \§\\\`\&m:\` Au&\\’\€t> \'\l\? X
Iu\ ’l\\\ \°\°\S u`\\¥ \e,u \\€.or`\r\ § c€)¥\ mh`\c,`\\\ §§ 6 "\)S\ w\€,¢\
¢M¥;\, 0\‘\€ §v\§v€v§ae, '\\w\$os€.d. [G § - § 3

?o\f€$€v\§reb\ us qx‘\&c,\\w\€n§ \N'\\~»\`\v\ \'\r\€,
porc§o\v\ Q~\ec\d'\v\g m\}x o\c‘:\- accoré\'\m§\ Jr\\ro\>\ \\ W£ '\v\c,\u\€»`\<>r\
ex SP€€\ fc»'\v\e'\rruc)v'\o\\$ “¥c> 3r\r\£>, §o\\\c\$ Co\m\kv\} W\S)ff`\£>\'

\\b. 5 !\¢xm?_¢§\ o§§'\€:\o`\%’ \M!\X\\'\V\ )¥\M’. \\8,0\5:\\\13¢; ex '\\\\€ ¥c>f€,-

%o'\v\% §e.§r'\lr`\ov\ jug '\SS\M>. o\ cer-\r'\§`\eb` %Xco\w\ ec\ $\\e brb.‘€r`
‘\~o Ye;\*'\ '\on€( 55¢§¥'\!\5 ‘\’\r\o Aoc\\€ "¥\N>\§r I\J\BC:)€ N\w\n\` l\\\€?.(&@
'm\Pose¢§\ ser\Arer\d\v\rd w\B\er Cqse ¥\\o. (-`°\5-'\'5°!>€\0~\\\&'\ LS>¥Q}Y€
ex _\_€XD\S \4. N\'\\\'ov\ \\€\”Ou'\ \N"\\\“\M¥\S\¢

9~%‘)€,<,\$\»~\\ %\A\>w\\\¥&»
/SI ml M\/ *Wm§ @oo¢\

m\\\>voh \£em \»\\‘\\\\m; *%¢mws

I'\w\ E. \'\o\vv\'\\)vov\ Co€fec,>v’\ov\o\\ Cev\\'€r
53L\\0% N\'\Y\€FO\.\ SPF»\V\(§S goad
\`\od§€v\! C>V_ `I'~L‘\B(\

C ` '\ 1

I\ \\€r€.\)"` ctrxv'\§\\\ '\\N>`)F a Avm`€ and correc§r com o¥ ~'\'\\€

$o(ec§o'\v\ \Nv\$ ma'\\?.}\ ov\ ‘\'\\\P, ¢______Ba ex N\MC\\\ 10\5\
+\¢\ro\>\g\r\ -\l.$. Pos'\m\ Ser\x\c,€ ~\~u “\'\\€ \>e,\o\u \`\S'\€A Po`v\v`\€€"

 

 

 

Cc>u\>~’¥ §§ CP\I_M"UU\\_ ¥\WEJ\\_§ ;_N§.j_;[§g CN>N§§ §;§:g;g; Co\)`g"';
ma ’\»\F_ gmi mr '\E\L\\s. _ Mo, §§ comm ;=Lg ex §§;;zsw\mo»§l
k”\Tj§‘, LLER\L LRBE\ twost m> §§. ;:L\mb§;u;;g\~§;yw.} ._

9 0. %di ozo% ;LMLRS%'TA WSQOW

 

 

C M lTbL S'Y kilo \\\

kuSTTN} Ti 7%#“ ,
TM&\ \l. 3\\§.1\, *?>Cv>\zw§ Loooc\
` L[X$‘Q`\ur\s<>

90\6\9 3 2 c\; 3

h:\>\\:m:m\§ ”\<> RTT\\L\AE<> €Uu>,ms w PLEMHNG:

§X\n'\\)'\lv &\'1_ Fe,\>mur\} \\\, 1003] Orb\er Bes’\i>v\x\~"\ nj
'I_ss\xc$ um}\er Cose N<>, \&QS’|?)%qL->-KA\ `\ss\>`ec\ \`o\` Im\ e
N\o`nr\j A\\&Efzo\ \N`r\?c\v\ 15 c\v\ u'\)\'c\¢‘,\r\e§ e¥\\:)o;"~ ‘\'o '\~M
ge¥r\r`\©r\ 'Qor \ur*\'\” b¥ mano\aw\u$ unb\€r 5¢\¢\€ ¥ore \>`\v\§
019€ \§o. \AR~SS\ \pq>`l~DS‘}U\F\'\\)vo\/\ \l€rw\ \N`\\\`\o\vv\§ ~<_ Ba\\c\§

Co\Av\~\-\ I)'\Sjrr’\c'\' C@\M)f C,\€(\L (_F\\‘?_S`\vv\mov\¢§§, 3\1(}\3€ N\o.v\v\\,'
l\\\l€rz&\ €:\' u\»\ Q(\\Cb` OV\ c£\of'\mr\i \`l\ 9.0\§ o\ E\(\\.*\_..

£»\M;k;¥ Mu\\ ama *au>\: zee 3101 1\\\ mg Bui\¥j \P\'eq

kear'\'r\ 'H`c\¢\$cr°\l)§~ a-\ \{o\uw\& 336§ uh 90 e$ \1?) ¢u\é\ \;1‘\
underjwsc ¥30. F°\S~Wz%‘\O-ML,' LSM¥€ <>¥ T)m$ v. N\§\+ov\
\[€mr\ \N`i\\°\o\m$\ o`\‘ '\'\r\€ bol\'\ow\ o¥ -\\r\{; lounge r>'v\ \SO\uw~Q 33‘\
r\ Po\ a \13 \.\s\nefc §uck§e k\\lerza 95¢0&¢8\, " 13 lr\.\(\\\ef c\we@\r€
fm ‘H!\Q kesz lv\lv€f€$x’ §§ ‘\'\Y\€, Ou\O\`\C ar\A\ “\`\'\€, A€'Y'Cv\c)\o\v\'\» l'&\'\o.)!'

v ! v l r-
~H\{L \mloo$¢qj'\or\ D'P S€,v\'\'ey\c.\v\c\ SLJ; w 6 5 \r\ r

_El\a_(\_b:\;\’__".+l`. Bo\\\v\$ Couv\lr\` ()`\S\'r`¢o\' Cowf§" \\\0¢ 5 3\.\¢)\3\~\€¢\\'
z¢€,S\)~€,_c>\ ov\ d;\\).\ 3~‘\\ \q‘\$ air \lo\\xw\& 333 on 9a E, \12 \m¢)\€f
Ca§& \\\o. F‘XS' '?>%‘iO~t\\L'» LSlm)r€, o¥ Te\us \{. N\'\\¥ov\ \lemv\ \}\R\\`\M\S\
§55\)\¢(}\ \0~\ Ga\\a$ Co\m\'\\ \b¥$§rr?(,\' Coux\* -\\\o. § l;<>fw\ef C<>v~t'§~
C\€\(¥~ usz \"\W\VY\\`\V\ x \»£ *`\L 5\`0§§`€$ ‘:>Q,Y\XC\Y\C.L»¥\\\\- 0$€.& 0§!1\_'\\§5.
¥\ c,\e.r\L\c,o\\ amc or\ b`@\e, ee/r\¥e,v\c,e/-'\»\o~s '\'w\' ise&'\

k\n§r£.`¢ Du{>, 45 +\\£ 000(, Quc‘\\‘\jv\\ KFEl-\CC\ w\/\€rc Pe\~'v\~"\or\ef
}S gurfev\\\\\ '\v\mrc€m\veb\ \M \'\‘omc~\ supervisor'e» re¥u\sq\

40 male \e§a\ cDP°\eS ¥o~r w\\ ou ~oY-e\-a\e cases gaf
z’¥’\lf`\°f\€(`\ \I\C '\S v\W\ P,J\€z\ 3F~fc>\rv\ cb,¥\o~e\'\<\v\ \\TS @v\(; o.v\J\ or\\\!
bt"\ (\rm\ Cot)`\€$ b&w\ \\€_. o.-\Oo\£€ e~lrrr\'€§\ `é,`X\¢\q\&)'¢)(`i \\\\ `\`a€'\'eo\
€7\\¢\;§0\\~ are currer\§v\\\ ¢\v\ 3v\r\\‘?, Ba\\ms C.ow\)v\` ¥>?é'\'rl_c,¥ ('/L>u\r¥w `
\\\o. 515 recoY`S\S.

ll

4

Se£ a\so 3\®;0)9, N\av\r\\!` ¥\\\efuCS Q'\v\w\ mf$\ef "\v\ lv\v\€/ ear
web c\~)\)or floc>\\ \W)\er >Y\\e- wr\)r ole \NA\OCO\§ conyus prodcee@\'\v\\¢)$

`\\\ Co\SC \vr \W\S`IB%‘KD~U\S\ `Y_\I\ ?v\(\'% \\'\\\Yov\ \¥5`\\\*`\&“\$\1