Court Opinion

ID: 3677315
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-07-06 06:23:40.612119+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:25:00.962921
License: Public Domain

The facts were as follows: L. Jackson, Jr., and the defendant, J. B. Waters, became partners in the livery and sale business at Plymouth, N.C. on 14 April, 1875, on which date Waters executed to Jackson his note for $1,112.50 for his interest in the business, and secured the same by a mortgage on land in which his wife joined. The note was subsequently assigned to the plaintiffs, who brought this action, praying judgment against the defendant Waters and the administrators of L. Jackson, Jr., who had died, and for a foreclosure of the mortgage. The defendant Waters by his answer claimed that during the existence of the copartnership, and before the assignment of the note by Jackson to the plaintiffs, Jackson became indebted to him in a sum much in excess of the amount of the note, and set up the same as a counterclaim and demanded judgment for such excess.
The account was referred to T. S. Armistead, Esq., who reported his findings of fact and conclusions of law to Spring Term, 1892, of WASHINGTON, and awarded judgment to defendant Waters (837)  for $221.15, against the defendants, administrators of L. *Page 543 
Jackson, Jr., who filed exceptions, but at Fall Term, 1892, waived all of the same except one, upon which they rested their case, which was as follows:
"That there was no evidence for the referee to consider in charging the intestate of defendant administrators with the proceeds of sale of certain horses and buggies sold by said intestate during the continuance of the partnership in the livery business."
The counsel further stated that part of the evidence which was claimed to support the charge was in the form of affidavits of certain persons who had witnessed the sales and to whom they had been made.
It was agreed that there was no objection to these affidavits for form, and same were to be considered as depositions duly taken, the position, of the appellants being that the statements, embodied in such affidavits, and other evidence in the cause, constituted no evidence to support the findings of the referee and the charge against their intestate's estate.
The appellants waived all other exceptions to the report and the findings of the referee.
Upon examination and consideration of this report and evidence, the court was of opinion that there was evidence to support the finding of the referee in the item of charge pointed out by the exceptions, and gave judgment overruling the exceptions and confirming the report; from which judgment the defendants, Stubbs and Basnight, administrators, excepted and appealed.
The referee found as a fact, from affidavits and depositions of John R. Eborn and W. H. Robertson and others, that L. Jackson, Jr., sold horses, mules and buggies belonging to the firm of L. Jackson  Co., in the years 1875 and 1876, to the amount of $1,305, and, as a        (838) conclusion of law, found "that the facts stated in the affidavits are sufficient in law to charge the estate of L. Jackson, Jr., deceased, represented by W. H. Stubbs and T. J. Basnight, administrators, with the amounts named therein, making $1,305, to one-half of which, to wit, $652.50, the defendant Waters is entitled as a credit on the note," etc.
After a careful inspection of the record we are unable to find any error in the rulings of the court below. The judgment is therefore
AFFIRMED. *Page 544