Court Opinion

ID: 4446420
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2019-10-11 20:01:49.921051+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:33:02.310071
License: Public Domain

In the United States Court of Federal Claims
                                           No. 15-938
                                    Filed: October 11, 2019

                                                )
    BRUCE CIAPESSONI, ELISA                     )
    CIAPESSONI, BOB F. HANSEN,                  )
    HANSEN ENTERPRISES, R&H                     )
    AGRI-ENTERPRISES, ELDORA ROSSI,             )
    ROSSI & CIAPESSONI FARMS, and               )
    ROSSI & ROSSI, on behalf of themselves      )
    and all others similarly situated, et al,   )
                                                )
                     Plaintiffs,                )
                                                )
            v.                                  )
                                                )
    THE UNITED STATES,                          )
                                                )
                     Defendant.                 )
                                                )

     ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR AN AWARD OF ATTORNEYS’
                FEES AND REIMBURSEMENTS OF EXPENSES

      The Court has considered Plaintiffs’ Motion for an Award of Attorneys’ Fees and
Reimbursement of Expenses, and Defendant’s response thereto, and orders as follows:

       The Court approves Class Counsel’s request, pursuant to RCFC 23(h) and 54(d)(2), for
an award of attorneys’ fees and reimbursement of expenses, including payment of Notice and
Administration Costs to the Settlement Administrator, from the Settlement Amount and the
Supplemental Settlement Amount1 (together, the “Common Fund”), as follows.

        The Settlement Agreement provides that Class Counsel shall apply to the Court for an
award of attorneys’ fees of up to 25% of the Common Fund. The Settlement Agreement further
provides that Defendant, the United States, agrees not to object to attorney-fee compensation
paid from the Common Fund of up to 25% of the Common Fund. Defendant further agrees not
to object to Plaintiffs’ petition for reimbursement of reasonable, documented, actual expenses in

1
        All capitalized terms not otherwise defined herein shall have the same meaning as those
set forth in the Settlement Agreement.
connection with Plaintiffs’ litigation and settlement of this action, as well as Notice and
Administration Costs, to be paid out of the Common Fund.

         Attorneys’ fees are authorized by law “on the equitable notion that lawyers are entitled to
reasonable compensation for their professional services from those who accept the fruits of their
labors.” Moore v. United States, 63 Fed. Cl. 781, 786 (Fed. Cl. 2005). The Settlement Notice
advised the Class that Class Counsel would ask the Court to award Class Counsel attorneys’ fees
equal to 25% of the Common Fund to compensate them for their efforts in investigating the
facts, litigating the claims, negotiating the settlement, and implementing the settlement on behalf
of the Settlement Class, and for their risk in undertaking this representation on a contingent
basis, and advised them of their right to object to the requested attorneys’ fees and expenses.

         The Court finds and determines that the payment to Class Counsel from the Common
Fund in the amount of 25% of the Settlement Amount of $85,000,000.00, or $21,250,000.00,
plus 25% of the Supplemental Settlement Amount of $882,351.60, or $220,587.90, for a total of
$21,470,587.90, is fair and reasonable. The Court finds that the reasonableness of the fees is
supported by the following factors: (a) the quality of counsel; (b) the complexity and duration of
the litigation; (c) the risk of nonrecovery; (d) the fee that likely would have been negotiated
between private parties in similar cases; (e) lack of any Class member objections to the fees
requested by Class Counsel; (f) the percentage applied in other class actions; and (g) the size of
the award. Moore, 63 Fed. Cl. at 786.

        The Court approves Class Counsel’s request for reimbursement from the Common Fund
of reasonable expenses incurred by Class Counsel in connection with the litigation. Class
Counsel have expended $355,043.72 in reimbursable expenses, including costs of conference
call services, PACER fees, copy charges, Class Counsel’s travel costs, some past expenses of the
Settlement Administrator, and certain charges by consultants. Such expenses typically billed to
paying clients may be recovered by Class Counsel. Brown v. Pro Football, 839 F. Supp. 905,
916 (D.D.C. 1993), rev’d on other grounds, 50 F.3d 1041 (D.C. Cir. 1995). Class Counsel have
provided an itemized accounting of the litigation expenses incurred. The Court finds and
determines that payment to Class Counsel in the amount of $355,043.72 in expense
reimbursement is fair and reasonable.

        The Court approves Class Counsel’s request for payment from the Common Fund of
Notice and Administration Costs to the Settlement Administrator. The Settlement Administrator
disseminated and processed opt-in notices to potential members of the Class and was approved
by this Court to administer the settlement notice and claims process. The Settlement
Administrator will continue to administer the claims, issue settlement checks to Settlement Class
Members, respond to inquiries from Class members, administer the website for the Settlement,
and perform other claims administration services for months after the Fairness Hearing. Class
Counsel have provided an itemized accounting of the Notice and Administration Costs, including
a fixed fee for all unreimbursed past services and future services of the Settlement Administrator.

       The Court finds and determines that the payment of the Notice and Administration Costs
from the Common Fund to the Settlement Administrator in the amount of $428,855.54 is fair and
reasonable.

                                                  2
       For these reasons, the Court grants Plaintiffs’ Motion for an Award of Attorneys’ Fees
and Reimbursement of Expenses in full, in the amounts set forth herein.

      IT IS SO ORDERED.
                                                   s/   Loren A. Smith
                                                   Loren A. Smith,
                                                   Senior Judge

                                               3