Court Opinion

ID: 4066230
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 22:34:58.904851+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:49:12.910973
License: Public Domain

JUDGMENT

                                 Court of Appeals
                            First District of Texas
                                 NO. 01-14-00556-CV

            MIKE BIRNBAUM AND BEVERLY BIRNBAUM, Appellants

                                           V.

                  GENA J. ATWELL, PHYLLIS BROWNING,
         PHYLLIS BROWNING COMPANY, AND MIMI WEBER, Appellees

 Appeal from the 166th District Court of Bexar County. (Tr. Ct. No. 2013-CI-15152).

      This case is an appeal from the final judgment signed by the trial court on March 18,
2014. After submitting the case on the appellate record and the arguments properly raised
by the parties, the Court holds that there was error in the portion of the trial court’s
judgment that awards appellate attorney’s fees without conditioning their recovery on a
successful appeal. Accordingly, the Court modifies the portions of the trial court’s final
judgment awarding attorney’s fees set forth at numbered paragraphs 2(B) through (D) and
3(B) through (D) to provide as follows:

2(B). Contingent on Defendant GENA ATWELL’s
      success on appeal, for appeal to a Texas
      intermediate court of appeals, the additional sum of       $30,000.00
2(C). Contingent on Defendant GENA ATWELL’s
      success on appeal, for preparation of a petition for
      review to the Texas Supreme Court, the additional
                                                              $15,000.00
      sum of

2(D). Contingent on Defendant GENA ATWELL’s
      success on appeal, in the event that Texas Supreme
      Court grants the petition for review and orders full
      briefing on the merits, the additional sum of           $25,000.00

                    *        *      *

3(B). Contingent        on       Defendants        PHYLLIS
      BROWNING,         MIMI       WEBER,         and   THE
      PHYLLIS BROWNING COMPANY’s success on
      appeal, for appeal to a Texas intermediate court of
      appeals, the additional sum of                          $30,000.00

3(C). Contingent        on       Defendants        PHYLLIS
      BROWNING,         MIMI       WEBER,         and   THE
      PHYLLIS BROWNING COMPANY’s success on
      appeal, for preparation of a petition for review to
      the Texas Supreme Court, the additional sum of          $15,000.00

3(D). Contingent        on       Defendants        PHYLLIS
      BROWNING,         MIMI       WEBER,         and   THE
      PHYLLIS BROWNING COMPANY’s success on
      appeal, in the event that Texas Supreme Court
      grants the petition for review and orders full
      briefing on the merits, the additional sum of           $25,000.00

                                              2
       The Court further holds that there was no reversible error in the remaining portions
of the trial court’s judgment. Therefore, the Court affirms the trial court’s judgment as
herein modified.

       The Court orders that the appellants, Mike Birnbaum and Beverly Birnbaum, jointly
and severally, pay all appellate costs.

       The Court orders that this decision be certified below for observance.

Judgment rendered August 20, 2015.

Panel consists of Justices Jennings, Bland, and Brown. Opinion delivered by Justice Bland.

                                            3