Court Opinion

ID: 4039064
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:04:37.187656+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:00:34.763481
License: Public Domain

:^aWl x
i^'                    )       ORDINAL

                           L«sra Au»ay, c/srk

      Sixth District
r^
 W«^toAft, AU ^.ak3X\a                ^ ^

W a^A^\^^w^\^^^A.^AV.^^\^             y^

^A^2^;m^.^>^Ax^^v^;]A\w^              y **
\xW^A^A^.^.^A^^^^YiAaAv^W y ^

\WW, ^.A^xA ^xUXxxA \\& y^ SSftX^O)    ^ ^^
^^^^.A\^>^^tx^U^^^AkAV%xh^\x« \^A ^c&x*

kk^\X^tX^^^.xky^,A^\^^\^D              Qa^XM
^X^W ^.vA.'Xk ^^X                      ^    A^
        Y^xYXX^As AsAn- AXWy^,^   y^

        AvXf ^ axn\ v^ AY^, A^^   x
-^Y^Ad ^AAAAA^yyy ^^yyxYL
t&w. &A^yxAA^w yy\yyy^ x^y
^,w^ A^wxv y a y^**wy yy
xAX^TdoAYAxWX &^AxxmAAxAW As^.

  v«,w^yf^^Sx^iA^^
   \_xA&Ax^Y^Av^ &b*a**

    ^yxx^Ax^Auy^^^^
    x_^x^v^\y^^^^
V\Ax\x^ni a>\AxXx%xVXl ^vwAAAk AA^xAoxAAA^
LhA &m ^ V A YX^AAAAAxxA vA tms."^M
lAxY^ ^^jl ^^^xYAA t^^A xaxA^ VYAu Y^ AAWxX^
UWWX^Va, &Y^yAY^Al ^AxcY^xtA^^xAY^
YA^xsAxxA

WxvAxA^A^i Aa^AV^^Ax^u^xaUl^^^AvanXY^
xxaAa A,vA^IayxAxaAAA^ xMy ^y ^ y ywA
Axa*W^&o^y(-S) y .A(^AvAAx^vyv,M-x
(A \Mx\YX \K\ v\AAb AAAsxxAYxA^YvixXtvx fe\ ^lA\k\(\\WXXV^
WxU a^xyl u.4 ^ ^.^xXla xy^ (xxw^ u . y^ ^y\x
XY^AA A^X^AAYvxxAAX^mW i^W^M V* A y^.Y^
^A\

&Atl. ..
M^ \Vy A w ^
mA ^\^AAYA^AA^AXw^^^ -. --—;— ••• --^v

AtvXrAAAAAriAx\« \ « ^rA
vA^vxA^xwxA y^xf^y,x^                                        v
 w^^\^.^ ^t^lwxi^xxa ^xAA
•AvX XxitXCj eAx^wAxI vAttiA xAsX^tX.XXAxAoi VXWiWlL AA\ A va^V .
a^X^YAAXA^AYAAAy x^i^AAx,xxvxY^y AA4
^VYxA^XxAYAmAAY^L^XY^yx^^ ^ f . y
  A Y^ Tx \*C, ^ (xxXwYYx^A AX^ kXAxA ^xxs^x-xxA^d ^

 M,.AX,A^\x^xxAtxA^xx^x^A^v^A .x ^xA^hAA^Ua,

 xv^^^xY x^WA^ ^ y.VA^ ^AAvm A                                      J
 x.Ax^A^^
 XxxWA, ^A^X,X^X,xxyAyy ^ ^ , ^«XA fc
 xxX vm\vAAxxvX ti^^svy ^^xYf^ux^XAxGX^A

 &^AAx^xAxmyx^                                            ^m\U
 ^^W^UW^\toWT 4 ^^X^XYiAXq
 ^AxA x^AAYy ^ *y^ ^AW^xAtA ^'^AX±^ xx
 *\ <x, \\XxK vKXAV^mXt. AYvL AKtAAAA XCX^X^L^VAxAx^M &Y^
XvMu^VXt, K^A^XV, 6»X^K ^WXtX%«^\vfeA»i.&X,W
Xx *\^t»*t\x x^W-Xc &X^t.cX to xumsX ^WWX»-Wuc,»i Cc,A&

•*te, AxV»t.XVx ^ V^x^^^SM^

« x Vw\ W„«\ ..*A^X^X&»lA^XV\m*-l\^

«^^AYSA,^w-^^
.^xxx^xax^ivAALY^X^XXA.                              ^^
                      A_AA\\\A A\XXtA
  xx.X\YxX\xA AAtAAxxxX x^x^AYixxxvx^Xi iim^ txxtAVV.W
 YxxAxAYxxA Yxxm^XXvt, XtmA AlXxXx^ AA^YA^ Y\Aa vKt,&
 ^xYux^x^^cax^^^                                      , .
 ^Xx<^AX^AYmiA \AYvxA^^Ax^yx^ v^x^X ^y^\
  ££W^ xixAXXYvx^xAx\ xx^AxxvxxA YtfWs*al YX XxxSX &x ^XYaa
  SIyA^A^JL.**.AXAAv*W.mYy*Am
  YYxAAx ^\A\ xxAAx\ xxWxx^ x^v\ AYxxxvxtA X*x\xAxAx^ bX ^
  ^aa xxvaA^m^ AY^.A^A^y^xx^ ^yyyn
  SyaSxYAw ^axwXAxxAxyAxJ^ H^\ns
  xxXxy ^^AW^^                            ^XYxA^x^XY^^-

  ^xyaaW ^^^y\^w                                   *^
 ****** f^wU^                                          T^
  yy^ ^^ttt^M^^ ^n^C
(x^XWw xo»\i\xXAx^V<AX», ixlVtX^XV x^xuxX
V, w W XX ^ AA ujAxaX Xt> \txpt v^AY
**.AvaA^VY a mvtx »,a\v^ mi
«^x\a uvxXoA-, «»4a u«tx ux^xawv^x^t
^  ^A^Y^A      fAAA
XA^X,uxxAXxXAWxx^   Ar A

^.,. „»» XXvx>VXrx'V, eAW* x^xx*.^y>XX,«x vu*

A.vlx^xv^x^v^ASAAA^X'
na,A..UvsxvX 5*^^sTAXXcxX^^X^v^x\ a
A^xx^XA^^Wx ^                             ^ ^.
v^%4ua,vx\^yyAsA^AAAA
\X„w* XXxt XtVsX ^XAxXi "W?>X^T ^xL*. H«&t«*vAxA

 AxA AxXsA Y^xXx^
Xt\^vi»t.xiA«ViiXUX^^^^X.^^va.MXU.aA^1J); ^**')
xixttoixXix^AxX^vUXx&tt uiw^ttxtoi x«A« xitt&uMfcXtSamiaxit
kxtAYAAAYAA^X^ ufcx* \xU^y^yviA
YAA YAx^xxvx^vxxxv &yyw^     *«.

xV.vxxuXXV.XbV^ ^y »^t^ Av^xv\VxX^^
to^ss V»,XAAXY1AAvs xA^^XVtoWW
mw y^AlAYxtAyA-.\x^xA^AYYtY
X.\Vt^X>WsXxl»»-WWtXXV&X. XXX
                    ^W'W' SEiMVUl
AYY ^^^foXte^yXxwXj.^»x^ ^ ^A^»xx»

^X^xxf^^»
 vAxYY^^^^-xxY^xvxAxm
 tAA^A^A^^AYv,.x.xx^
AxYxXxAxxV^^XX^AtX. xYxAvX^AVxYAxxAAAxXxAY^ x^XAvaAxI
Yawx^xXAt, ^xx^xxxCxAAlYxv^AAt3 Yxxxm,to^XVyxxt^AXtYxYxA
xyAxx\YXAA\Y^yxA^                     Yy^x^XyyxV
A Axy^xaAyAA^                           M- vAYxyx
Y^A^\xXYAx» AxjsxA-x^a ikoxtA <Y &WW- \Yxv.(x^yXxtA

;y^^y^x^AYXAAA*^A^AY^
x ^,xv, A Y^YAAAA**^Y<&*» y>,
                          ^^VA\^^\^
                                                     \V\/fVft\
Yxx Wt AxYAAxiWyV& yW\ AxAAAAuxAAxA AxAA^XxA
X^xA^AAxVxXxvXxAx Ax^Ax.Y^uXxyy VxXXXyxxX ^jut*
y^AAxAkxYXAX^xAYxAxt.xAA Yxa^AA A\\y AxxYy^xxYny.
^xAxA^Yx XvXxxAx^WfcJ&S^ XAnXYxA y   ^ixXAA v*SvNy

xvxxAx^a^a^ ^ y^ yxy\!ytlwax
^A,yAyvy-v.w^            y
^xAxVAxVAxAYvAyy^yi^Sr^xYA
YxAxxY^YAXvxXYxx^xR.^      ^
ymAy^y\Ayy^y^
 YYiAxAAxAx^yyfy^^ w^^YW y ^
AAyAMYx AvxxxAYAyyxxL \yyA v^n^ AAXxl , x
 £Vrx:
 V, ^xxxxyxvx)1 \ .x «&\uW^ ^¥A^Yl;avAx wa vaAxA
 Yitx\Y:
' ^XxAixxxAxix xAV\^YxAAx\\xAA^
  yWvvAyA^AVsxsvxx^ x^^xxAXYx:AAyyy^A^y
 x^ .^X^XxxAxXYXxsAX^AvAAx &yAAxyAA yyy A
 YvxAAtAAmYvXxWxy^
 \v ,v ^^^^\\^A\vYxX^ yY^'XxxuAAxvt-^AA Ax^X^^

   i*A\Hn
 Y^*^ ^*Y*y\YAYYXAXvvx wvsaw
  ^^xwyxx^yXx^ f^Y^AY^^xxA «yxy

   S^^^&t^^A^ AA
   vffl**A,x,yv^yYYYAAa-
YYYyAfeXAYa.XA-Y).YaavXaAXxx Wx^^X YxxtAyAa ox ttfu\ \Y^
 AAA. ^ A^AA xxxv\ A AYxA AXxxA;xti.lYvxxkA AxAxi. W^y
AAA\AaYvi-A -Y\%Y\AxaAAxAYY vAxx^AvYXcQiiA A? XYAxt>Akbx
xXXcxA-Ytx Yx^AxX^ A\xxt\AXA\ucxux| wWWWa\^™i kt^\\wA
 WA^\xA ®\&vm AA VvxY^A* ^AAVAxcaAx. ^ Y&\A acxY\f\-Ar
 •SxXtxXA^YxYYA Xtb ^AlxAYXlY^A^M^                                                tkxQ^
^xxvYAXxi.AYy\Y\Yx_ LxxMxYXAx AXAx Y^A^y^WY^.Y\sO XAAAV^
f•AxkAXtj ^XuVaVXxxaAAAAXAA^xSYx Wm^xuj^xvuca x^xxA
AtAAA^AA;A XYAUA^ A ^A^^YXxxA, m)Yx^y& AkiA
YtxxAnAYAA^xAxx^sXtYxxVxAx^i
VA^\AvAA\\x,a NY ^-\ U X-^XXXN^ A VV_ A V*^^ •
                                             —. AAAx^^a
                                                v-~* ^ . ^j xXaqxax
         xx           \         x . \\   . \xn   _ KA \U\ ACo \^ \ xA a St A.xV^ a ^ f x

wxAxAYA\^AyAx^\                ^A^yyyyyy^
. \vv\,\l\V\^.., AXV XV* \v£A*YA^vxXYv\ XxVa vXVA\^\x\A[\XX\c,X\x\\V
                vAtA AA\xl \A

 nA^A,xAxy^y y^ f^AAxLwA ^aU
  ^\*W*fo?^^t\W^
  \ \v\^\^-^^-^'U^
                            ^ WA--^n
                   tY'A>A J waa^XAAxX AXXu^XXxv.AAy
  VA"-*-&*xAAm^vAyy^;L^^S^X^
  ^xxAA^X
  m^-™y A^A XAXYYwxX xaAvxax-^*
  YsYYA^SyYx?A
                     oxx         X               aWX*

xx^AxYAAxxAx AxxAXAVyAtxxAxxA xAxAxx c^^^
YxxXYciaA Axt^XtjAvx. XAA^x^y XxAaAA lAXfeX, WAoxxv^x.^
XAV, YxxxxkAXAAxlXxxAiA XxiaAAXxAxaAxAx^ ^AA.
AA^xawAW,3Db \i^12» (>1)
                                                 \1 d \l

                             XXAxXXxVf A

 Ax xAXAv^ YWx AaX^x Aavvxwl ^ Y^AX^ ^xauAa
&c&\«. . AA aAX vXXAAA^AA vxyaa\ eR
YXxAXxA^ feX YvX^ $Yu \AiA\AAa A lAvAAxAxV^^AxxtAA
kWiJWVf&H^V \a»^« ^Xxax, VaxaX Xaxx^AAY
WAA (xWxxAA Yxt, xxYAxA. \W$x&* xt^cA Ay
\xxAtA^\4xAYAxmxAAYAVAA\AxAXxxyy a-XY
^xAxxAV^nA (xVx Y^aA &^xA mYAXAx^A
AxxxAiaXYVxA Ate X,tAxXtj,
                                               [\toi Iff)
               \

AytA?AAviXA^A\A\xA^^^              ^xW xxA
Wx«fcW fcyAvAx Yvx (sxkxX* \\AxAYaYYAxxA AAx^xA
Aa yvxlxAxAxxAx^X aa\a aAxAc, Y^a ^AXYA &*x
 AaxxxaA xXX \xW Y^AYa\AxxX«XcY^\Ama ^ AaxX^.

                                 tY\XxGXxxtA- XxwAAAt