Court Opinion

ID: 4051643
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:43:32.656002+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:35.932646
License: Public Domain

CftSf NO, !'-N51Z1

 Overt'lie l>ennn Tbom QfOn ,
                          I     I
 Re{ator,
               I
                                                                                                            Jbe   Cour± o'f
v.
Susan Brown I/                                                                                               busft'n ~X4S
                                                                                                                     1

 Respo11dent,

                                    OVfR.~LLf PfNTON TIICf"'PSol\/!5 M(f[IoN PO~ LE{tl/f TO      f1]£
                                     lrffL1CffTiotJ FOR. !JRIT OF MltNPAMUS ItJ THf Coutt(Of

                                                                                                          RECtiVEO IN
                                                                                                  COURT OF CRIMIN.A.l.A.PPEALS

                                                                                                           P.UG 2 6 2015
To   the HooortJb/e Judges of ·tht~ Cour-t :
                                                                                                        !\bel Acosta, Clerk
         Relator; Over/ fie   Penfoo Thor11pson, t//es   lh/s /tjnt/on for Le4ve to E//e IApv//caf/co for Wr/+ of fr1attda(fJ/lS /n
                                               I                                           t

tf,e Cour·t of Cc/m,'"a/ 1tffe4f5 purs4ant fa            Rq/e   n, ft,f the ~Y4 ~ Cules af ltrfel/m     froeedure 1and /n ?llffOrT
She W5      the Court the £o!low/'!J :

/, &elaior re>,eecffil~t reruests +h4tthls Court3 raof Re&.-fw-kave~ £?e                         the.   dtacheJ Aff/,'C(),t/o11
   for tJrftof frlandgmus1 dt~ecf/'!J +he HonoraNe Susan Brown Ju.d.je of·tbe                      !85th Jad/c/a/   p,'sftt'cf
                                                              1

L('4Ve    fo Ftle                                                                                         P'lje I of S
ESOOSS-01-07
   bec~tuse of :

                                                                                                                         d

4,A-5 JemondniteJ     by ±he tJCCom oanv/oJ
                                      II    .
                                              ~~~1/cat/oll7 ,fhe tr/a/ court's refus4/ ()r fa.//ure
                                                     ~.
                                                                                                         to rule   Qfl

    c~ fafor/2 fCIJfeC~/5Uj,/YlfiteJ       tJC   flied rPmeJ/es   Constifufu d   clear 4bUSe cfJI~CCet/on tlnd 1'1 denial
     oT ~ela+or 1s r~Ats,

Leave fc       E//e
ESOOSS-01-07
S.X:n /~h-I-of the clear ahuse of J/scret/on comfllltfeJ bv Ce5tJonder;-I-,Relator f,'/es ~,'s Mo17~11 for
                                                                 1     r      '
     Let.!Ve to F/le lrpf 1/ca+:on for hie:± ff Mandr~MI.LS fc en d
        n
               /t

 fl, Cer±/f/cafe of Comol/ance   fqge Z3

 /3, Ce.rt/f/cafe of Service

ESOOSS-01-07
                                    INPEX OF Al/THoR.rT:LE5

                                                                      Page lt.f ·

                                                                      Pt~je 10

                                                                      Page 15

                                                                     P4_9e /5

2£, Mcr5e      11.   Baker- Of~n
'2), Nunes     11.   Mueller                                         P~e    15

                                                                                               ;"\.:.
_.!!M_ur!'-Lt....ILofL....L.{Vl=g,n=JMJal'l=t![.:Ls_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .   rllil_e . .}_,()...._f___,Z,"'---L-1_ __
ESOOSS-01-07                                                                                     ---::J
t.S, Teras     Penal Code !137, 0 9   P4jeS 1ftI /5

ESOOSS-01-07
                                              STAT~fllCNT oF THF C/tSc

                                                                                  '
/, Re/d"orl Over/lie Oenfvo 1hcmp5;n1 t5 chageJ wt'-fl1 t/1~                   foUow/'?J :

    b C'gsc No
       1         1   /4'-{SqJ 0 - Felon !n foms~/on if Fi'rnrm       ,40   J
                                                                 I

                                 7                                   r                       ~

ESOOSS-01-07
                                                        I  I     I I
                                                       lff/Pfl - Ml5

                                                                                   fobe

        . r                                     I'      1         1    r   1
      fo dnswer Keltt.forls prcperly   f//eJ refYledc'es,

:3,
                                                                               I      I
      Texas noot      I

ES0085-0l-07
                                STATEMfNT OF JfJRISf)ICTION

the. Relator bas ao other aderwrfe reMedy 4± !4w ~ &+hw/th move the it/a/         courT I~ the rerfomgnce
o ~.s                                o/J    or& o erl f'//ed rel"'eJ 'es w. /ch
                                                                                  1
              e/     ut                                                           11        d/ sworn

P,'~rt'd-      Clerk.

                                    I.55i/ES PRfSf}lTcP

because. of :

ESOOSS-01-07
                                                                                                                                      .

                                                                                              . .

                                                       · S LI1RME.tl.L 0££/J:C.TS.

            -
                                                                                      -
                            _o.int" I : lle_Litfgct/.v.e...caliJ Xr1.sut£i1a:en t Couns_eLcf Cowd-!l.f-f.Pt'rrted_dtf2.COJ-; Tc.t!le!y-~.fc1l
                                                          -                                               '

                    Lf!:lf!lf_Lqfo.a_d_f~_kf:JP.w./rtj/y-4nLpucposefu f~-l!l.I~r..epr_esetlt · Refp,fo.c Ov.eci lk...Jkn.tea.JlJ.o.eJf5.1UU.~   thdt_ :

        .       I. . B£.t~~f.l.L1?c..fo.kec 2'2;-t.O t'J_afld_~u!J£_2.1.t..Q/5.1TcYMl/-iA{jrLnev.er f/Le J.th.~ni.lliS..fA r-p.ce it/a LmotJorJsJ:a
                    p.ro.~r.Ly-pr-ep~tLge./2-to.c:&r ft,4.Lor-..pcd:ed Re l~c!s_cans.tLi:ldien.a.Ltld_s.td,+(,dor-c~.kts) exeep:Lfo.c f!_
                    t!l.o.c..Ls-ub.ktfssl~ofl_o£a_M~()JLto 514ff-W> 1w!Ji£b_h_e..ne vee /lfi1lldd_t:LfM.l£,~U_as. e v/deaced Q1l Ju11e f--;-
                    to 15f wbQLbU.{,{1._f.t,_11J2-.J.fl_d.£..£:n./ief-&dillc 's. r~ht f-o_r:£1/g£/n.Ib!:_c_as_es_w..Hh_!IO_sh.o~/~.Jl..f
                    .,,d£'     I +           'd
                        __JQe_fL..f.V.ecru.l1j-ll.es:...~>..J
                                                I .           It- -n        b
                                                                __QC5..1A.£. , .          .                      .       .                 ·              .

    j
            z.       Ord. Ltn.e.!£1.tM5..iic.mr~f l:a&tJ_J/L/n-kn-t!P.tJA.lly-4 nLknow.~nJ'f.J.Y5fend_,.'nd.eJ/n./ify_p.             ~Chf..JMJJJre-Tri'a /
                    ff~t.l.llj.ice._-&r:ce~ -fv. /rLpj:r..ruL.'o1-fara.grnfh.lalld suhse1_uen'f Ju9'- Tr/a'/1 shoW_/n.g_//ls.l.df/c/enf Q.~[nJiqg._.
                    /l.e.c.e.>-s_/±y......io.c·sv.~h as he/tlj-!~_a~w. ~lfegat/orJ -w/+IJIJr.tf- /oJ,~tMent tha+ TOt!JJ>~~f L~.&tJ cla/tv~ed wa5
                    ~Jla.IA~eJ +o tlte_ih~e(il c~~l t:taJ that ~45 on!rJus-t· 4ddeJ -to ~elator ~ 1!1!ITJ.3 dars-f.n'or, ·

            J, m_~ccbJ)1 t0/5 1/n o.r-efl_c_p.JJ.r±a~t fre-Tr!a/ tf~a.r.~~OJ1_Tor!1.1!1f_La.&_n_d;'l_r.,_Ak_e_a_&watill_11LJ'jj_g_d__
               Ire_dc.ess~Respo.l!~ e(IT SIAS~li~Bco.w.n.!s_a:ttef.!lr±et,j;. co.e.r:.c.io.t.Lw.bu~ /11/./i.e./afb c W..tlLTI lJ_thif:__/,g_(Ke la+oc2
'              I~tJ..4Jo-etLfet=-~~n±o_A_p/.e.tt-of:j.ti~l~tLfbtl,J.ic.J.ct ltfto.C!Jf(_/£s.b.e_(fupmderrf }were 12..s.LdL
                                                                  1
                    ,w.l_1i_f-[Q$_e_c._ufio.lLd-_5_LLf-flt:£.5..5.1. DfLh.~.c/.aj-~                                  -                                        ·
                                                                                                    -
            4.      Taml!lp.EollJLM~LLO.ll~f-/~,Il0_tgfL.pns.ec~(~ :.

                 . a_,_te.£.f--lie.Woc...~.~r.J_g_~fy,ll(-cofl f/lle...Lv.Lbl.Ly_o_!ill_c_alLJ_yr..fACLon Jo.L~-~~om±ij.atw..£L.o.f ·the fJe I1L

                    ~;,-:+ b£-&J4tr~us.                                                                                       p~s:._{;_f)_-£ t 1
                  --- - - -
                                                                                                                            -
                    4   ~tt1.:br__wblcb_&Jator_W_yrtJJ;k/d/cfeJ 1 4aJ

     b.a!lall.ip.(AlA+e ~eJ.~d~Pc../~_uf.l.l~f__.kP.mpAd.aj             ev/deace 4jAi~5±Jvmself_ /n "fiie new.: ~.tle.9Rat~t-
               wlu~c.h   fact R~.l~hc:_h.eljg~.!J_b_e.leilrm./nd fz;'-An.d -tiJto~h ~n ex.amt~Jny_commtHe~ tllt.d...:.tf.Le~
               s e1.1A!:f-k!r/OJ cf ~+e f-Ct!S.ecl).for-(22 a.nd_To.m~ l-~~tl.,
               ..

5. a.,__l.!y.fl; t!P1s tr:1= c••£u l Mion                                                          1
                                                   for_ the fiu,.{ 'ilsMpJ!P1-rl£kLeas£>- _r._r..JA~-
     fuc.ther ev/dence of_b/s~n2.ptarfon'f1Lei&cf.s_t_o_At1_4/M · a.kef Sjg,fe f-Co5~fo.c(2.}_/tLiiJ.df:

     a Tal!:ltlY-~·&n 1s >-.Y.kfi:J.:S>.!.oJL~ .hn~~t:w.ar:d_tne Con£'dJ:.I.lh'dJ:dr&.cmat.JL~rJ-the>L.Ca?J:LOJJ.'r-.
       I

           d.eag_ns.±co:ft.i_r;11£L4g4.llLh.~dr.~ALIJ.IJ.hd.LLLnjn~ fo S!df-f-WS: 5f4!'e ~ ev.U_ence.,

     b Lmf!l.y.lalill!2 5/,fbm~/o.fJ +o br./'!:J_bt:~~J_tf.,g_Con.f/krb'g/ Irdlat14nt_ /o these        c..a2"e5   w..e~s:
           en.dcr-sed b(- 5ttf&.pcosecu.for(2_~he.CAY.5e kffh ToMT Ld.Fon aJ_s._-rn-}g_prn£e..c.l,(±ec.(s_)_a.lcedy~.o.J_
           f-r-J~c.i:!WJ!.Ledg.di!g± the /t'lforfYlf.Lh~Lw.Jifu./.~ ~_Qmf_iirwAcJ_/n th!LlLe.hL allc:g4+fofl,                   .

     ca-cmmy-LAEcn!.s_sukm.is.s_/o.tLto__kc/n~r~.ad_the Cctd]'de ;rh'a ILn focm.an-1- JJJ_th_es_cc.as_es_,~u
           LegA.Li4.rte._U :
           .                                                      .,

           G2 ~n.v.ince those /n_g_u.-Jk.r:./ty- :tkt Temi!lf b!Eo.f.1_/~_c_'/]{g,./lf do/.ogJ.usJ.uty_/nsie~cLot kreatfn_J-
             fh.e_/.aw::1..a.nJ .                                    .·         ·        _           .         · .          ·

           (/ flsed~te fe5 w/118o aw;r- when _fh€. /nforfYler does ao-1- mtdeo4//~e-l

    J Tomtnf L~..fin 's s~bm/ss/on fo lJn~_br:w~cd~dgn+/al Lnfo.ct:M£tf-tl.! these Cd~e>- /s
      t

     . ~adfAec sucrusM~I"f tv deio/' d.Y~ r.co=s alflglue St«E_pH!5ec~fpr(s2 t/mdJ;

     Wr;±_g_£fudt~mu.5                                                                            eti.J.e._l_o_t. f_ q.
                                                                                                             '

                                          ,:flJ./c,t fe/AioL/IJ~f:Jei-J afl~:1+iM 1                              '
                                                                    .

                          ~I        Jolt! rt'lf.;..k4.fifl_h.a.s_un.L4.w_fy.Jy_mad.e_a./kw}lb le :th!..af.~ aliegtfh'oll   ~~JtJs:Ltela-bLt~_i:/w.+ ·hLhA5_
                                    :& II f.nowf~d.ge af the f!ler-/+s to 1Mf-ef),£b the t~su.lnj oE such,

                          '1        Ll!!.l!Jy_b_q_fir.LkL~_hQ.J.;..kr~ow.Le.d.g e of ev:/J.ence arld. cn~/ll.aLpco.ced.tt.ce to ~t.cu.lr.a±e te Iaior ,'r, these
                                    c~s.es_1 1-1/(11 osT- since tJ,g_,~ ~f-t' ~iJt a.r1 d /!ffen +/o.M.Ir-h~i.ndr u.sed s..us;h_J.e2.f- /te cc./es team_
                                    &.IAfvc ·to the coafe.acf~
                                            -

                           81 To.ml'!.1f ~Eor.J 1 a.J...ioun£e./_fet: Qefin~ -4nl.r-erb_g,ps a~11 o:-tforn~I-P..e:.c/od11asJ.e.?.it:ofe d....!tJ.Lbls
                                                                            1
                              c.ce_d'''"Iy.        I tbat
                                                                1
                                     .tl2f.l_, _w_     . ~..    I                          ·             .

                                                .                                                                .                                       .

                                _a._,_/k_haLcMdKc.ted_b./ms.e.lf..n efa.r/oJJ£./.y_,_,f.l_deal/n-3 wHh tR/af.Pt: all JJ!,.e.l.a.±Pr 1s mo..:tbui~/.wayL
                            .           k./o_cJ/~_tbe./r: e.v.erf ~;JtempJ :bLI.e~ciJ. ikfldY.re ~f wt1/cl1 Rel~for /s acctJs.eJJ&:co.!!.J.b off/e.laL
~-
                                      · Fo_l/c..e. o-/fv?>e [ff-OI"t,
~-.=..._>r
                                -

-·                                  lb, ffgjt/5_/Aflf..ett~c!y...,c.esi>±eJ~.tL~t R.ela~ ce1kl~sk1.s..iijgesit~as~'Ld cettled/es to f-os2.!b~o_mc
-------=-~-   . . _---·         _·_r:e l/ef 1v Rdafoc_t~ +h~e-~s.es_,                            ·                                         ·

-~-~,-                              .c._lii2..l.e_ja.L-I:ll ch' c.~Are 1-u~£b:on.t~kLe.an.d oFt!-!'r!les_ea:.o.n..eQ/A$_,_,
                                                                                 ..

-                                   J_!_tteJ4s_fr.outtcg_d._IAPM-Rel.tt±er:!i....t,,oJJs.H+ut~'~nAL4,J_rt.tftrAfolfr:~.hts_/r.tmt.JJ.f- wtlfi..W!OC2Lth..a.ll_
                                         &e./~r:!s o.d.ve.r.s.a£1~-~---                -

--                                                             -                                     ~

                                    e.Lfte_/.Lco/J5..f-/c/C.3 W1Th 5-lo.fe f-Cf25_e~ if}],- (~LtUliJ_th_ueet>cd_do_e.s_cefle ct s_ ut;h_l
                                                -
                                    fi-LLaL.th.e abo~JLh ~ ve c~ lt~'J Ul4..Ud_/o+o wh4Uho.uiL.b..UJJ.ni/_dg_c_e_d_/rrecon_c./la. b/f,_d./:ffir-engs_
                                     -
                                                                                                                                               -
                                    Wr/t_cf_i!jt~.liJ.amu<                                                                         e~-~8-o£ tY.
                     .I
                                                   /

                                          ~fl-ocf)f)U:tn.d.s.l1er.rt.1JJILJ_fo_c_h_~'s_m./s_cef-Ce5eJrbtbP.n1 !o-'!l'J L4 FofLW_/// syrey._5ee_
                               ke.:ttM.ee.tJ
                           El~ /.rd::ifE_ tJv..ed/le_Qe_n-to t.L..Th.o.mp5.tJ.IL/n ·fA e ldflLwd. 5+a.fe 5 P-/sfo~+~u c-lfi'llv'ch /ru'ftelf__
    -

        .                                                          £/'-'.£.t_{l_t_lf.LR
                           _c.oJls_t,_tcct_e_s_A_ffJ.4dP.t_cotl
                                         I             I   .II     __  I
                                                                                      _ces~til
                                                                                           _,

                           -·
                                  -

                           '

             '

-                         -

                                                                                                                                 -
                     -

            ---
                                               .

                 -

                          -

                          1--

                 -
-

-           --- ~tit of I'VlMJa~u5.                                                                               E4Jf_q_o_--E 'Z tj_
                                                                                                   '.

                                                                       6RGtif!JE1[15
                                                                                                     .

                          Eb/(/t r :         ~J:o.e."iRct/Ld/l.tl ~~dft~e;urt Cu,Jse./_of Cr,u:..i-r1f-po.lcri£.J_ff.fip'ry't]ilfl'1 L4.fgtJ_·_

                                                                                                                                         -
                                                                                                         ..
                                                                                                                                                          .
             {, To_J.em.u.ns:f:ta:f:e_/n.e.f.f..ec.t/ve 4n.Lt'osJifBc.t:ent CQUt'vf.eLlJe./~nc...I!JoV..e.s.. tl1~ Cou.~:t Rr:e.c.Ojn./~tf:lf__iw..o elemenE
                  'of...s_L~~t/t.J ,Kr'~>~f!le/C1ao v, tlocOsof/ fdS,_J~!i1 to.£~ CT. Z!il~1_qf_L,~d, td. 305_ {LfFkL(£/o.J./~_,l!effedr'v~
                                                                     1
                  Ccqllsel w.h~re co.un£.e.LcofJduc,*J-.flo_f-etr/aL d/5covet:j_ttnJ_-£a,:LeJ. -k t/Le                          tt   t/mef;c.>..«pp.a5.5_../on l!ldft'on
                  IJ..j.4J.f.l5._.
                         I -               ..J£..1/~V.t'dgr,h.e..,2
                              t pt2S..ec_liil'

                  rL_Qcfo k.er::_/-_2."/fi)ltf fo f!J o.ccf.t_'2_3I '2-0./5_[./}:_e- Tr_~_4f_!ie£Jf'llt_j.J-=-.N.o r-cetcfgL)/sco.'&,r-~a..5_ey_g_r:
                     . Con.J..Li.c.ti..4J.y-To.mtt~J Lo. &.r.t_/n_thf..Se~:ases1fer.s:b:ILA~se.Lge.J.afo.c. ~ ~~~a./7:.~ he hegJj_o/.1
                       Jun£ ~-;.if!.L5 ,

                 · k; M4 rch~$1PIS [ frifi,~j_lf_e4rt'q] - Tonur;- L~fo11_f/LeL4_/!Iod:_m~b~ll fo 2Uff?.rY.£1 bat tbaJ oil .
                      JuiK.Z:1_tfJ_f5_1_l_e ~onsfra'ies ·h.tL-fru_e. /!J:Iint c_f..ao+ tP..I./Dw/tJ_J_throt!j~ w/t!J~t:IJ/5 f-!:P.cg_J../5lw_k{f_
--~
                      he_Jg_[,:kettrlej SY.5:f-en.d£t~.d.e.f/f.l.l'*f-hotb~ sc!xduled B:e ~Tr/a/ 5uppr:.esSl~tL/k~D~.JJILJ J"'I- Tn~ /
                   - 5 b!lWJ~J_J-/1.15JA.ttt~cLe.ll.t tPVerr-,:J./1}}_/les;:,_es.s /:1[....:.-&r .s..u c hf   be' ~.Ajlef!L. c.h ?l.t:j_e - th_a,.-t w..a.Lw.l:tl.toJ£1-__
                       L~d./c.-tmgntdD.t!J~L~a+Ju>theen AJJ.e.J. fo te/t:{Qc 4 l!l.err l:J dr5-p..o'or~
-                                                                        ~·.,.~.-

                                                                                                                           -
-          ?_,   Ierr"? ~&n_has~m~JLIJo_effoc.t io~fcgeJS.elaiocJ}otr:uAn.fA.w.:.~LasJr.a/tJf' or f~e.mn::Lhj.s_..JJJ.r-
                  aLCun>.e.f_foc_~nse_/_~£ wh/.chj!?cev/JgfJr:f!.J~!r,~ht's.~fa/[u,ce_fo_ -f//e~ .foe 4-t:e1U.J.'cr._)_b.on.d
                  redu..co'tt~o_;£thufllfe.../£nai a~t---&.r ta'aL .a'th/11JP ~-fl:..m_:tle cof'lt'lence~"L
                 the Jeiillda~-t~~de_"R@t~tJ-;.J'-ac±r-r-urY:£14fJ.t ~o ltc.t~c.ILLZ)5 L§l (J2~tihLL<:.Jas~~J~of_
      ',

                 Cr:./m,_n4Lfco.c_e.J ua.l~d::.MW.clY_d/Oj:_Re.lato.r!s_c~lrft_fr:off.cfi_J_utJder_thf2_EH::th15.,fl/J.1£/jhth1~
                 11.n.a_foJAriR.enih.Am€JJJ1!1f!ffj o:E:t:fJLtlllL~J~..YJ.Il£fl.'tilb.~llt-d.aJ_"oJ.er...ltrhcLe I &L~ :l!.31.twd1!~_

                  M_;t_o.£t1~tnd.ctmu5..                                                   -                                         e0j.e_/1Lo.t t ~
                                                                              '

       of fbg_-rix~-.S:.atJ5..t/f_qf/Qfl.,

 3 · loJ!J.f!L/_La.&tJ!s_ff4~JJJ.C.e to.:.J3Ze a_Of_p_f_ the /J.e.@IAo/-fceit/a Ltr~.o_tt'.Olli_To-pc.e..fec.T &..e.Lafor Is___
               1
                   'aJ~ .s_io. t
      rOJJ.s.h.f«hofJ_                 u"fc1 Ctj-kll.l.t:J · .ese Ca,S..e5_l5
                                                  I        lih                    I
                                                                                      ?Lt.tJ~Or
                                                                                            I       'l'                        db.
                                                                                                lLI.Q d.bon f-UC5..tAg,J.rt..ta · . L

       of:s;t1~rth.;£~-£.-th1 5Ldb.~0-h.t/t1.4llL.Eouc~tJtkr_/lmeadtf1Mis_of..-/:h.e_fd,uted_s_-a;ks_l.r;IJmhlM;-
      tllld .tlrtfclu§J1§Y~-!it·g~§IQ/i!J ((n.d §(J_oLtbLL.e£g,5 Cofli:tl:tu.iio.~-'

 ~t _Tam.mfl-a.fcJJ bf-~ilJ_f.h~ughJ/s_a.d:l.M.LhtfS_C~mAf.Ldfc.d_Reltcto.c...rAn:&..!.cf- To Offa5~&.J.Ld~L
      cPJJ.f/nt.m:ent1_·11f.fu'le t/JJ:S.t4..kco.li.J.u~oiJ::g:e'~l!J-/Il~~gst/g~tfP..n ~tfL.n.pJJLtt..lll!j~.tio{l7 w.IJ./ ch J.D.tifi,_
      c.c./.Le_L,~.n.d.JJn.us_~£tLp-~t1./s.h_~_et~1.= Ihcrl:_mA(-4./stLCol!S..t/n.te. ·(Lcc/t!uila.Ld_o_f. LMJfec03
      j_,~r:ectfrr-ursyanfW.Tex:~LlaLia.Je §3Z01 and_v.Mf_a-t_es_                        &ftdw3_clgbts. .pur.s_u_an+- to tile_
      ~&~££tb.f-/Y-f:h1.t1nJ_Eo_uc.feetJ.th_frme.n.dMetl12. rr_:t&_l/ol:bJ..2to;fes_Con5. -t£t~a~aL!td:Lcle
                                                                                          .                 I!J/1;-
      § {Qt-"'nd.§./~Lo:F_tiJuexa.>....f.o~sif:Ml.o.a_,

 5 Ta.mtt~y-LA EPa -r-thco.u..Jh-h~-"-~n-a.dmlfit.QrJ. .zw_Rddic c£ba.ti..Wj-.ha.L{).v.ed1Lplv-y-e.ar.Ld: cr/fYI,~_q_l_._
       IrJ.L-~Le.t.p...er:.Le.lJ.C.et-A_gs_a.fsJJ_~...±h~c.e.hrJ.cL.f-a.55.esSed. .J.na.w..Le.d_j.Lo.i evi.J.YJ.cu.~CJ~
       f-tlC.J.uCLto ex.c.u.{fAi.!:._Kd~to.r-l~.ihe£e_caJ~.an.LbaLce:&>.ed_to_et.e.TX/5.e...s.uf;f.t_d.e>p/R.c.d.e.s....fto.JJJ_
      RelA.fo.c_i~tr...o.rf~l~/u,.'o./~.:f~_s             Reld.fD.c.'s aji1k.f-ursuanttoJ1~E/r.s:t;_.Eo.utih;=Jf.th1.51~
      EJjldil;All.d_fuc&e.of..h...A~.tner.d:S_o_f fheJJ..IJJjgJ.s.-IJtfgs C.n5..tiMJ~aLLtActlc WJ.jJ a. 1~q _
                                                                                                                                   1
      'P1~;
          ~fAn-J~£Jhu
                . fl e ~o. --'--· t!.fJl4lJ4-1·a'~-t!....po55.t
                         cn.>t'M'                  '-B               ·-n .R
                                                               :kly--eXttL .£n~lrcJ ·§JZQj
                                                                                  __e_  ,                        .1

'£, To,m~V Lo. FO_n 1 by.. a. nLtb.r.bls.JJct/M~)1c_ff1o±adof-tfiiJ_Re./a_-@_c!s_fco.p.erj-5..uhmHtd_r-tfYJ.J./es
    ,:n_t_g_u:,f.l.v_l1fi...b.o.S...e.-££e.div.t.J(-ji13¥-~__&J.afD_r_pf_bJLca!lS.:bJ~.a)_d_j1+ to 6.e__6£LJ.dl q
      v.ioJ.¢W..llf-'4.CS..Uanf ·to +be 'E/L£t1~.Jl.r:th.,_t.~lrfhl<3 nd~.tfeen+h tlrnen dl!lfO-f:s af fhe_UmY:ed
      5-hrfes CMrt!iJL"tie!t1A~ie.I9.~§~jJ4/-ifl/f~llJ !ltq eiJ:h_e ~(tiS C{)osfmtf./o¥rJ...1u/fe ·.
      poss.l.k~t-4S-1eJJ...LG.tk §JZ01,

          -                                                                                                                                 i
                                                                                                                                            I

      tJ,-i±o£l!Jandam u5                                                     .                         &J~-~()t t~
                                                      5TMf.tJJ.fj})_ T OF     FA CIS
    .

                          fot'.a±JL : Ih.e-~2f-'wJerrr 5~all hltLn '5 Fa. /lucd.df.nswer &Lator~ frof-erf;cFt'ld_K.e.med/e>-

         I Io_the M:tof_ge.JAto.c ~ knotAAeJjf--1..unJg,rs:htnd/,~1~Jld_LeQIJ113~tLIJ&c.c~ t~VJ/5 /tJ..2pen courTar fn!- Tr/4/
           l

          · Jfgm'ngi.B.eS.p.on.Js.n+ SvtsatJlico.t.t!J_did_tnowJ~J;t.Ati.lflf+ to coerce Kel4hr Ovec/Jli;_P-entor:Llli~J!Jfscn hy--
             s_f_g_t0:J_tl.J4±_/fshe w..ere fo_s_/d e w/tlrms.~~-~·b!aiJ at 5/A f-f-f-eJ>i tUL.bi ar/,1j1:tlun_th€ Re lafor ,.,ou fd htJ.ve
            to f.J.l'll_r:_/llitJ ~-f-Lt4_o£j.u /If w./ih_tbLRI~tr/ct./Ji@m_ey.,_Th./s...,_~£Cn.Ltllts fwu /} 6gy.edf.UJ.Jdtlv .
                   t~r-_c.esSJJJj_th.e
                            I .                 1          d~                'fld
                                       courf I!!Lt1ffe5 4ll . oc h":Prl15..cr.Lf-fs o_ 5tll._COJA.r±,
                                                                                                                                    r.

        '2. Res.p011W~w.LedjDf ev/Jf.tJ.CLtl.lJ_d~/~~~aL~coced.utLi:o..fX£«.Lr_afL$.elak,~t~-th_e>Lcass:£ky-_
            t1fld~"j-h_gglah.c!5_fC1J.f-erly2ulw./ik.d_l!lcil~i.?lt-f-eHH on c~~-4ll.J sworo_g_-fO).i..v./13_,

        1_, ~~fo.adYtt-b.a2-Jao.w..!R-J.jdhaLt~L~~:bc!Lt:f'.5tcg /n+ 1ill:.~ ~ases_~ko±b_of-~@~/ V.u..aJ_J{n_~_~fJr--._
                   ttJld_ib_roJI_JLCddo.r!Lfl=o.p.d.f 5 !J~t!1liftJ_i!Jo.t/o.llf4-f-&Hc.tJ_CV14ild sworr.u£bda.ILLb:~.              .

        ~.!.       r~o£Jetd:.b,5JJ_.s_a±/sfy_tbf Cod_!s_ce.9-ulce M e.n±_fi;c_ex_b !bHs                  oLthL.4.o cl{Men+slc.e medies_f/{ed /n f-he

                   WCJ~t o£I:jaLld.cu~.u <                                                                 ey_e_l ~ o_f t ~ .
                                                                                -
                                           ..
            185·tn  )gJJ.ddP.L5Jc!ct- Co CArT /tLfit~rr/5 County_1Itx.Asf&lAfoc h.a.>J..-tt~eJ_to.Afp..eJLdtx ~ 5Worn~
            trffi'davH to effect suchj:.Als() ()_thgceYJ~efl.c..e of tft~e..s_ahm/2sl.o.aS-I:A.r.Lb..e ~c~e_d~t-ib~--
            w_eh5He .aT Cha's.hn/eL1 li4rr·t~ Couaif- ft/rtcLc.:UJ_eLL                                        .

                                                  .

    .

c

                                                                            ,

                                       .

            WdLo£Madal!l.u~                                                     f_~e /3 of      t'J
        I                      '   .
                                                       /iCQ!jpj ~(')_13_ .

                f.o,'.rtfl[ : ·Ib e ~es.r..e11denT 5,!$_41l.8.to.w.JJ!L5. 1 ~/.uce_fo_~n5W.ec...fe./afo.r:!5-.B:ofer.lp:ied.J.£.t!lf.J~s

 L ~fi_/!Jarch_tJ1_z~tS...;-les..t-o.ufgof Susa~ 8rown/o-a.ikmf-D~-flx..eo.~t..el~h.c av.eo 1k_.fet.dO.!L7JJ.oi'Jf.SCfL    1

          ~~to-4cs:.ef-t/llj~a_f/e4-o£J'u.~/t;-J.,~J_in_B.ctii..J~/tt-f1:_gela.tac!s_c~Afs_p«auarrt..-bJ tAc5b:l.t-;ii.'rJh1_
         IE ljbi/;17And_liiwile.,.ctb_~___wd.'-'~ls:~.rT_s__~f the ldaJ~tKJ st¢g$ Co.a>-f:/:/:u_ft'~Af-4tld_ltr.itb& ..L §L~§L~a.t1d SS'Lt
         ff..JiJLL- C;_d.e af C::L~klil.Lfco..ce.d.Y~e· a!J.JY-f.~Laie£..le.La.~c!s_ojhf5_
                                     flrHde I.JiLtfj 31 §J&Jp_~_§L&/iJJ1_ttnl!il1 ortbLTe,ras_fo.dsfi-I:!!D.~~-
         /uaJJP.tLt lo A:r:t/cle 5§8 tta..J.
         inJ_fhLfrb±; F/m12ltJiL1Eh.hi:f:Ld.ll J_fo_q~llif:Ldm.eJJ.J&rffs_a.-E tiJLI/.tJ.J~feJ )idfs...~_fordfMfoti,

31 KespandYJ±!s_tfll1w:Ledje.. .o£Ke_I.Afo r l_s_,~g_fli:cf-/Ve                         1
                                                                            t1Y.J.L1. r.JS   qffi(/enf (g({JJ5.f:.l...rw.hJ ch w~_/!IJg_fJ~J~IJ-·
                                                                                                                       1

         TrLbet:-o/'- ttn4_fbroUJ.h_£ekf2r~ f-CO.f-ery...;.·£,~f.eLcel!lf.J,~u1A0[6r;.c. a:f.us.g /. 1-P -:JFtl. n+- r:.eJ.,~LY-Htt ouLcau.r.l;;e/-d./re dffp.u.acwrr ]];_;1c.,.t&&...Ls?.r.O o£ tk.Jit45. Lo rd-/Mi.'o.ll;-
         b~tno.t.ex:cf.td~_ftdLde T§.l/-14tg81-J.g-;_tW...4 ;§/'}_ cf H!e l.exas-Coll5iLTimi.fJft.tJ..:tM_ft.'csJt-
         Elfih1ildi1f~frfu1M!L5.urfee.nJ.b..AmellJ&e.nklf_ih_e_~tll~ Sb:ks...foi15:h..11iHQfL

~. feif..o.J.e.nf        h45   Ancw./e~e. thrayh C-uarrtto.Iex~_fenal CoJe §37,01 and §_3ZifJ-;Act'clu~l3_of_·t/r,e
                Iexas CoJ.~of Cn.ill,~a.Lfmc.ed«ce.1Ii1e Foudb-;F/frh15/t.fu1J..YJd Foucb.enth fri!l.ef.lJJ!lellt5 of_ :the
                tlftLtd S~-1!,~ LefJsJi-fxb'qfl/_4JJ~ 6rb'c/e I§9.1§ ~~~/JA §/1_g_f._fhUjx_aS_ Cal15_f.if.u±fotl,

                                                                                                                                      .
          5, fe.J.,tfo.c..A~.Ld25..er~J b/s_f..Ljhf +o ?tfLe.v_idetri/a9'-~-eAr'~-3~/nih__es_e...s:AieLthEo0Jh_t-rop.ecfr-.5ubMi71lJ_
             tt~LJ.tt~[I_($)_,UJ.d sw~r(j_.df:J.tJ.}LH·(zl1 o.t w/u'c/, felator /s er~Ht/ed as-:.s_hon.ilL./.tLNun.eD'-1 frlue l&c1
               _35:fLEJ.J_l0_':/.5.1.1Q5~(_q±h_c./c,.ZOOl}_(£/lld/l}j-{£k_ ()_ f e!L/d.tJlh'ar-kean~_/lladeqtAde fo....:f!.nd__
                          11
                '\f.4c±s_ 1).A/5.o Li/f.lL:ny_-thtl-t ±be.._si:aie coJACt ~ '':&ctua./. ~£/td/nj.s_ .w.er;e unceasofl4hleJJ~berJ -fhe
                                                                                       1

                    ca.u.r:t miLJLth...!....fi.'!J dlrJjS   !tt/   ,fh OMf- hO /.J~.rLe.V:..t1.e !1~£(-h~E./lJL'
      .
                                                                                                                       ..

          0-1. 8~pQ{l~eflt b_gs_Lett- -f:h£_ge)a±Qdp.r.op.ec.ft_£,'/eLcemeJ/_gs_v.o.LJ_1-jl.~/qj -the ?:tff-ei!A.te co1.1r-r ·.
                    ~ ~r:sJ.Ic+iotL-bl. '/55Y:e mao...daM~.&Ld.eJ.f-ih ~.JL&./ l4.b/l/-f:J {)foTher J:emed:es anafri./5-4d!.f-ted_,.n_I!Ju.ae .
               . .v.:, Bakec ... 0/5_etl.fl.tr-t-,_/!:f_Q/> t       L11k.L12 1..2.J.~,_zJ_~5 tJ!1.4nJa.mus_kt;y_:J_(J).
               ..                                                                                                  -

-·        1, .l1~nd ~~u~ tL4JL~//ak.fLt_p tor.r.ec.f.)ud/c/a Ltr ctituLtbat~tJores deac._/",:tJd,~n_j-f-Cece.derr/:_h.ectJ.JJ5J?_tD d../.__                1

                J.u.djgs_Jo_n.a+ ety£(- fceeda~                    fo   /g.no.ce   fhg_fa.w... ~f£,' ~~..Kn/ie J~p.p.,.ffl.RtSJ:, L1i1l88.1 s,_w_,tJ_]kO, .·
                f!lo.tJdJ..f!>J/..5_~e.y.J.:k                                                  .

                     .                                                                  .                                                 -

          8,        fr..u:.~u.Js../:l:ei for tff.IAg,tlce t~f wr/f oftv~anddfYitJ5 b.y_t.truf-f-ellilie coyc:tace-.ex./sience of le_gALd.uJr--·_
--                  o.,r.._pact c.:Lio.IILe.J:_co. urt fo_pecf~cr.r:Lhb nJ,~cr-etr~rJ ac.yJ.. c.ft.J.er.tJ.g,JJ.JJ9.t:...fler:fo..r.m etnce.r.t~nd_re fusa. /_l2.t_
                c.o_uc/: tr; pemrm ,_ft.ar:aes          v..._s_-r~        (dpp.t_.LP..,5±. L1_1t}_gy_z 5, w', Zd_tfj?.tJ.,.~at.ld4mu5~ty..LZ-jl!k11J.a.~us_
-·-             kld.!:LU2i fVlatLictf!l us_ke.yJ.:f_(J)
                                                                                                       -
...
          q,    Et_h,~/f:s.·tKcorY~f-44-f-J-t)j_a/.mr Is r--et/f~()_{J_oclft.dtd ff!lafJdar!l us_t!Lece_!l of cep!.ul:ed fq b::_
                ri.Jm./ss./b[e_e.v_tAence, Ill-&e C!J..bt~Ll (!l~p,_fl_Q:S~t. VJOi..)_Z.f!.l5LM.1d IOii!J.atLJ&fYius_f..r !SL{_(                      t2

                    Wr-H-o_fl1at~damll5..                                                                                   p_C!J_e_/2_o_f_t_ ~
               PKAVER

ES0085-01-07
 STATE OF !EXItS
 CoUNTY OF HltRUS

           ''.ram the qpp(/can± /n fh/_s ac±/ofl and know-& cmrfenis of +he

 2-0/5,

ESOOSS-01-07
                                                               &je /1 of zt-/
                                                               AffEtJD:IX

 I

     curfaih'llj the 1/ber+y of speech., ,

6, Art/c{e I§(Z-cfthe kxa£ Cans-b'-lu+ioll· HltGtAS CORPUS. 7/,e wrifcfh4bea.s cnrpas fs a wr/fcfr(jhi{4nJ sA41/ neVer/1e.s-uspendeJ,
     The Ll?jt~/ature shall enact /aw5 to render-the tefl'IPJy        sredy and @dual.
7, Article I§f3cf+be Te,xa£ Co~+/faf;'on, EXCC55IV~ BArL OR t=rN£SjCCUflr AN.P t/NU5t.Mt. fUp/IsHMENTj8fM£0Y.BY PU£
     C         EOF L       E                      I

         n
     IIIDJ nec.essarv
                               n
                        tp eturce. ff, eu-
                                        I
                                           ,Iurt£I Jlt ct.J_I/I)(J,
                   I                         ~

ESOOSS-01-07
/D,

                                                                            crwho W4nfo

            I                                           I

1/,ltr+J cle 17.15 I§ I(/) cf the le£45 Code cf c,,',.,,'nal Procedure Rdease cr bai I reduct'oil /s l?fw'reJ /f-the stA-ff /s Mt
                                                                        I

      reaJv for ft,'af w/th/n   10Jal6 from the CcMMel!CR.fV!ellt ofthe JefenJan±~ Je·fenHot!,
          I                         I          .

f't, Article 38,t3 cfthe Teras      Cod of C.r-,'M,'M I fc-ote.Jw:e, EVIPftJcfNoT·ro Pe t/5GO.(a)No ev/denct obia.!11J hvga offi'cer or
                                                                                                                         I
                                ~                       eC                      o the          f~               e Co

/'3

        I       T                      I

ES0085-0l-07
        a.ga/n>t pro~ecutioM ev/denc~,)
i ,   Ko:zAck./ v, ie ototdcome of the /nvest/ga-1-/oo or aff/c/af ,eroceeJ/nj, Tltl1fmtJGWJJHoCF8/JCiqrmJGfltYSfCALEVIPf{'.t£,
U, "Gta( &n4/ CDde §]J, /0, TI/MPfR';CtJG lJ.!TH OK f!IBtteltTING fHYS!Citl EVI/)ft.JCE, kpecron
                                                                                            .
                                                                                                 comm'f> An offen~e /fbe m4kes,I

ESOOSS-01-07
               dEFIPAV.:rToF OVERILLE DENTON THOMPSON IN SUPPDkT OE
                         AffL'r.CitTION FOR Wf