Court Opinion

ID: 4048651
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:44:29.292316+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:00:36.643803
License: Public Domain

<33, u@q ac)\ ,02,03,
w

\

101 “'\:w vae ali Cr:»~cm\ AW¢¢\§

€»p.'+¢>\ S+a#=£@»\

§/'\'\Q¢\ /-\cos+a’” Q\¢\r\<

QO- gx -1?-303/ j
,AU§J;~\ ,T§ ""‘72'7¢_¢

»LK R~L: QQ`{}\'\¢` Cv\r\ FWL 36‘( M

`Io¢,,“ §0¢`¢1< T>< 7@3¢¢7

.®wc Wlf~ ALM.| Apos~\¢ /Cl¢rk )

AKM Qo%warélv\j n A\H)faqav~`+ \'v\ S~igper‘+ of B¢l¢¢r/“ ov\ loe_`/\¢.\Q op
Tc>q inma+¢ Galov.'¢\ Qar¢§om_ C"m¢¢ti~mq<;zz). `YY\¢.CMCS@M laden/45 er\¢+
\/\,L 35 expavi¢v\¢\`°\_<§ delays , Vv\\`$s+¢p$) av\¢§ oka&a.de§ ]ro \/\\'.s §¢eu.iv\j Su<§¢‘¢\`@_'
f~e,\¢`¢Q M/\a.’r are V)e>+ c}u¢, 40 'V)ejl\`je.uc¢ or iju\v¢`av\¢,e, ov` \/\\`5 \oe‘/\o.le ¢»MJ
chpproa.d/.ecs ¢Vv\e anus aske$ ~l`\@ l waul¢) 109¢¢.)<\¢`¢) ‘\'\A€$' imp+¢'ou\ -iv\ \/\@\°¢5 {{'
w{k\ arrow $a()¢\\; md \`v\ _€+5 €Wh`,v€:’ry Cv\o weissmj 953¢5> as jomc
O$ \A\`§ \Ma,\`\ivcg_s \M.w~ 30~/\¢ \Miss\`w_j \`v\ Pc\\‘+ er evvh`vv.\~/¢

:\\ 1
\ \Aa.u,k 0 o

`°`U°"(ww

REcE¢vED m
CDURT OF CRlM|NAL APPEALS

5 a web cs
" 5`°`5 6 6a JuN 222015

Abe£Acosta,Clers< `

M¢`M hacst 0.\0:¢\/.¢'>£ H\o,.(\u¢()m£ Qc`\mi\)a\ Prp\)a)|s'

‘XZE".‘KQ&\)`E:>T', ida ch>e¢r

M\AQGS‘\T.\. 4 ,

Endm@¢\ p\ewe.¥»'nd 01 x~w`\m\ \ ¥£\ed m Dl»./S. tY, Gm`l know if »[Ou_
mm\m;\ il(\, \ would me P.\‘\e ml%\ ~\r\¢ 'gu§\ivu (\"p v\<‘>¥ weele epe\Quious\q\
\ SW\»\ mm m mm §qu mm AMNW @Ad,L/. z>n+n~¢#@/M
am (i\ou$u`\<§ \vu\ \\¢M 'r‘\q\\¥:§.'\`am‘)en\ng mmn m\‘ £\`llvig(.

\ wm AL-A`\QL! _v\\§\nnm£?n \ou,¥ own mp'\§w\g m 02(4\'%£¢31`0/\ wl 4\12
game ¢Lw\u‘ %~\u`\§s - “M, MM\(U>M \f\.>¥ 4.

\{m¢/\\M end 0,@9@(¥ is gm\/\H ccp\)reo§cr\ruj.

\B¢>T‘E`. "df\§$ v€)/\('c\£\ 5<\ '\;\\Q.an,\z>`)és pc,\£?. is b€€a'(.u?@ lY\ Qdij`urahg "H\.QI`-€
Q\\hqs ¥W\om is abc puer ,_
~Qm\\\§» § Q¥'£L§§Qn\\g u.>\=\'\\ mg mit\`m&s.
' #\>sr€: \ .M} L°>U\m\ n§~rce$ bc N h_\,n`k \)eiv\q f€ce`¢\u;d.

mb ul no °Cc
23 Mv( -'0-3 ~ mcean mha

\ Q\\QA L\ “20\3() bmi§’§\ Fb\`A hb+ \~QCCI\R ` \9€\\`»€\1.€ Yz lu'U¢/' O(/? g»,|qqqlg‘”/
qz€$p€£)\'£x]\q QaLn;€/| [brcll$/\Q
AH led le}L

§ .,’_l: 01 F. M. 3m )u.
§ wé§. loCz'¢'l<.T)C ‘ 7@5(0'>
k

    
    

E\dol`bljr l

A»Fme) )T ))\) smemm'/)F DELA\/

EL QMIE GmuszL OAo.oow>r §
wv¢ X’>.Lm\»o\
- 61 v §
" 03 §
_ Dr#)`clau')l

\'\1 Q¥t&\»m,\ QG\€Amu. Q.\$'.$(Lo \\)e.\`n pm'e.\)(\\; `mcm@e rc\¥€c\ \I/\ M\e Al l Dal
U¢\i\/\ uu\c\.oc' TB Q,.L ‘c\z \UL¥L`\\Q')?/, ancj`\ €`w\c§ Ct>mp€`én'\' §~}cl_\e 025 ‘pd|lbl)¢..& ‘-

\.
\ am‘j\\\a C_Lpp\l`conl c/\ `W\a. Q.\w.»o“ Q¢nL'~\/\ed OmuSQ_S sz\@j 010 lowij
s\cz¥»;)$£dd %( \.~>(l`\’~$ `(\D`. K'S\qzq'sl» K:$ iurLu’Oz» &glq’(.q'oz, and ) mU..S+
cw$u\'v\o_@.0_33 §\ \Xu oer<\\`Q\u\ \~€Q@`\pjm_ . \ sen+' C¢_ reques+m ~H\a
\S¥\\ md \’)3&\ cY'/+a\$ \Am`\-b\ al lunch \~|cl,\/\()_...r\mL ve(;z`ie\eol an a/\S~
wax . \ \\a\m mch 01 @u"w\:zmca {cmv)p}q{n+\ , A$'£cm cox H\Lq me (’QH%` -
£\\)\£o Sud/\ pmeop \r\w\ £»'\r‘ngs,

ms ¢‘(: WY§ \$?Ph O\ovqé‘£` SLu\L \ haw \~Q,CE\M @(“LUID aMu»QrvS
l ar \'CS§)¢»ML ‘£'r\>w\ webb va\`\&t DYO\D.( ar Cm\# W\G‘¥\»€r;! pelM&nic;\j
Jm W\\§ \.063:3‘ \ ma`\\“n`\.\ ¥¥Y\rn\»q\` ~Hm£ \re\m`c\a 5\\l) €nsu\r€>_ al.Q/iofrq.

TM\NJ ®M`Q»n¥ mqu vu>¥.
Tc\m¢ 0¢\£\ Ql>cv\.K\”t>(< Q,(\w\'\r\c\\ MPQD.\Y \`\b‘,\o"o~“' 33qu §\ aD"L\D:’> fbi-11
\\»\ ~\i\/\Q`\'e\w\'

E>LQG.A?_ Q»\d\m;\¢;\_ 03de §
a F
§ CQ.\\M\\\)M N’ ?€ALY
§

 

~QE®\AE§T 'vo(z smu am Am\,'\u\cc>rv\o\\) DF umw y
0¥ ¥\rw>€é\§ COQPM§‘, M LKSH\)C\ ®l>£‘.L/M;/L)TS

Cow\@_$ v\o\)o @l&\on£.\ O&rcj.mu . O\§\;\ice\J\-\" WT:) S`Q_ \I/\~\£\r\o G\)o\.)£ €¢\¥»~HQJ C\~/lcj mum|o~
end Ms.(md \\’(\QS ~\3(¢\'\§ §qu)\€§-¥ ‘\b)<\/\o, Qa,a\+'¢>@ Qr'i`w\\\m\ n Qea\& Qo( S¥a\[ {¢\ Czc§iu' '
o\.iccx\\`¢y\ o¥' \\>ni\/ op -\?\a\>m$ Co\'pu$a(lm\ (QSQQ(:\-Q.i\\q é\\nu ‘\\n€, S\»\\m»'mgf

 

\ ."_Bm.. \U<{-\/ /\zu\e"

‘Y\\e (\pp\`\wv\¥ §§ amcwz. p(' 5<\\1. B<\o_mc`~\~i; Q\`\e.\>es -)r\\a-\'§ML\ m\€,'\§ \)e_lnq uibk. l
425 \>\.\ l\\o \‘d\x\v'c_¥ A'¥Xu;’naqs oc€\"¢“e.‘ cmc§\ or ~\'bu_ Gi§'\j{\`c¥ Q\€(\L §§r w&\» (‘_u.m~\\i.\_uwdo
T€WS.“MS.WL \/\Dv\o(£\\>\a. 331..\.0\3€_'1, m ` 92 ' (‘(',S{c)w'\£_` . '\n 0\\ wr\'-\'A' ~R`lec\ pm 32 04 \)€,\fm\£oq’
‘jf\\a \\um-¥ \ Camv\o~¥ make o paper 0\ ‘ m\(v\¢. lea ; &55€55` ¥\r\e \"u€§z\ .\!\€n€o.c<:\\udica\e am

"(\\a. md s~-. C¢v\$ecxuen¥\q. `\"¥\L \Pc\)p\'\cou\¥ w`\\\ \)e, pecu r€,\`\o~c.
T\\Q;L 051 \‘v\`\§>'mg dbme .

`\\. `\\A`.;§{Nl\ M.'\.w\/\M\’$

\). "W\o L\pp\lce`~r\-\‘ Au\g\ §\ed n UQ):v\m-O\N~)\um o{' lam ‘r`\>c mak bowl npp\lcu'\iu/\»`T\\e_ A\>p\ica~
n¥ ¥;\Qd o redaei@d em§ess\.y\ ¥»v cumm°:w>sco,w mm mms mm mppaa ¢>P \1;;»\>¢:¢\ B€’ m-
an\‘ m. App\'\ce.n¥ 9:\¢¢3 m%\m e.s‘_ 541<\1~,»@\: ?w came no's~.~z_oos arm Cm, own ranch
C\w~) L\L\\ \>\(P;).`W\o_ A\)p\icm\)c weil mey~>\q Ai'scoumc\ mckenna or new\\\ aoa_i\q\o\e cu\`dav\ce. les-
4\`~\¢¢¢§ ¥“:w\ `\Cw\€)¥ Q`\w\cd& Cu\d C\¢\‘.'wou 012/w L|"ll 0\ U), in suppor/}’
dr §§de md @m,u\d `\(§ , A'v.w)\\ lnmcmce. Clu§‘mi A~\)\;\icm\¥ ~F)`|¢,d Gx@£rpk ne 00¢|£@},
;\uc\ng\w\\. ou\c.\ ?\eo\ A¢Bcaewmn¥ \°s\ suppbr& o? \'\"\S (`;\c\\`m mt Ve<§om\ SerY\'ence. Ap,>\{cmv\ -@chci 0\
qa\{\eca\ \~MS'\' ¥\>( wm (l‘red¢\)i`\\~¥\{ o¥ C\a`\MS w`\£,(ei¢\ \\a €xp\a`w\$ \M`_\ de\o.\j and canons P¥>f buck
D\Am,., h.'\»?\~\mx \MAQA e*\“~\\o~r\§ w mcma\,.m AW\.-w)(a\w, miami xw, amax :;y\.:l»#
\o,\rlz gm wiseman ms am mo br am wm am qua mims e¢¢\a`m¢d kw ¥\(\Q t\»n')\;\g-
w `\\uv\ \'5 is '£\*_mvmms¢\'\w.> Ccum€,\ A'\w\nmt omeérez\' \*\\9_ ogcum./\'\‘ as l"\/ ped<\`w\s ¥»¥w (`eu¢¥
md missed W'\§Qm \'.’> wsvc'k\'nc_} .(Pc\so@ ¥\m)r Gnms¢\c\\`¢l ad e'\¢\>\a§-\ a“q¥\mv\g rei ch\eex\>\ey£\'.‘r\> app

hcau\¥a.\ “\\Mc\\ P\Qo\ wm a\c\'e.a, wm Q.\u§ \md\hcx s\rv§@ '\>adwgo. w\`\/\A 5 $€alac§ eu\sdopu."fhu} mere m\c\¢esm/+n

¥\'\L ‘b“\s)w`\c)¢ C\e¢\c Es-\'Me( 'Dagol\uc\o umw Qu¥,w\c£\\ .Ca_r\\‘§d_&v\e.‘. 1014 I`XZO,GU)*\ ZO'~IY VZY[ civil/4
h\q\ wexq\n¥ o{' 3 Lbs Sflo oz. D¢\'\vec\{ o\ar\’e \>e_d\q:(§\l|$ml\$’ @'11¢\1.30+%/) dam op Aprrl ZMS'.

’I). '\\¢\e A\pp\`\€m\\ \:\\QA O\ * m'¥e. \Q\'§¢Qf w\r\'\CX/\ (:c>v\xo\`y\ed App\`\om¥£ M"Q`o\o\\){§v o¢¥af+ff
App\'\(‘ew\¥ exp\a\'ned \/\`\s mms\\ip L»(\W\n _\ou-¥\/\ QLM\\$@\$ ,‘Bcw\`d Nmacc\'z amd Tau$+o
§uscu A'pp\i'mr§§$ ded$im ihs \emj QL'\`\\‘L\/ /\\'\5 b\now(§'bnc]»%g r>c’ H\g (‘c::re.i' and pn)l‘-
Q,Qélnqs .. Scd"'d Prcx§'éc.u.'¥ t>§/$m£€s bow we \’L pages ‘“W\a Qpp\icm\¥ G\S§ sen-\'c¢ ‘L page

../"

Lx\$\w\¢'\Tor\ \\> \*m_ C\Qc\i 0§' man Q'\\\'ngc . ®ucm\\\ cz¢\c'\ reqmslal ~\'\\L C\£c\i <\\) m\<$\{ ¥&m
£\Q'§\i`ca“\ c§{" dl\\\.xe<\\‘ ét\ci ic caz\q dow/ime n”h M'\SS`\<\Q§. Y\e`\»mr did '\'\m_ C\er\;i.

"f\v\n,,u&mo. wm £:\QA L)~:\AM d s{“rj\c package w`\)/\\ clc§.<>\re,s.\ o@l\;\s¥`cq (:‘e¢\`\?z.( “Dis»:¥-
~¢-;L¥ Q,\U\(s GQ‘€`cL \-¥ ¢~>6\5 mui\ecx mo (*Q_c¥`$~led Mc(\\ .~`\”c>\n\ \>.zé\g\\»\, ¢¥-Z.'|l> D'L- ’De,\\"uer\; c\c“§e
\;oj\“g (BS ,OL\,.\T »~\'\rnv¥'i$ '“\o, S`\'\'\ dunlop Maq'¢iolf . rlzdum 1~€€2{())( `f-€C\\A£s-\e_d was S'\¢jz\ec\,
S\c\\xv\\>e£k.m/\¢>\ re@@lueé\ \>\{ W A'Qp\`\(‘.an¥. (\.er}'\ no per “\M'(S pCiLjana |'_\ V)Olu W?,O OO(B| ZOQCI
§'L°l$. ,
\\\.’\_’\_€»‘\_§.~;:9_$

\‘ Qpp\\"ew\ waives -\'M\s' mc\ms)r \>£Uuse.¥m \-ch“\\wd c \e¥&w ~Q(vvw\\\`s \om\'\,\e¢ wis
C&¢é,\m\c\ .m`\m> cm\\e¢\ H\a \Ao<\cm\>\efs smyqu mm was n<>¥\(;ed J(‘<\c¢¥qn\\{ ~\/\r\a,
mdl pages f Qmum\\\\\"1's u"\»e<@_ received .“¥\/\; avp\`\ccm¥;; \nn>%\e.r \v\qu\w¢\
u\om\< “\\Lé.e£<$ncl \e.¥\er . (.\Q<' ` "éd \O.no\ weis ncs\-`\c-eci H\ct\ \¥ weis nolr reve'iw_d.

2h `T\\LAW\\CO\¢\X ma\¢u “\'\S ceun/S+' \)ec~au$& \l\e. \>e,\ie\)e.$ ‘\“\\€cic\}uc\ica]¢{dr\ c>Q~sud/\ \.Odks

:\'.\ ins)c \\’\§ \`n\-(’.r-Q§~\{\ `\.Q¢c,\£n"\€o\ . Cmcl `/)e.\`\&¢\;l?,§ ‘\/\r\ck\~ § sc\d\'is_\\ne CC\S€ `\.E.d@m`a‘
C¥ is ecclus£ op -\Xw m`\cs`uv<; dbww\en{:f. \».>\\i&\ m\¢\o.v\ CanS\-q,ubl \{'\)Q.ra\\q .or us '\'\/\2_

_ 0)()'\)\\'0.0.¢\\' §Xq\ed \n'\$ ,`§L\'§\\"U\S . 'Cv\ M Qi.m/\u\a\~}\)£ -emsc EN\Ce\ojr. esxu\o\[$)\&$ lie did vic-1

t man ow\ \u\owi`n§. V\>\w\§rou{ md 1}\\'0.\\{50¢\\' adm`\.\)lu\ afrquf \L

\v. (Pfhzmr o\= neuku

m A'p \\'ch\§r \'\cu ~\\NL §CO¢£\P~\'S ji\`(bw\ ;\)h.a Obs\ Oq”cice,.m\o\ (‘Qr\\Q\QA \`€CQ.`\`)\'X .iht\.udiv~_q
(\LL\\M\ B,mm{p\/ rqqms’\'a.\ “%\e m wm us ~\'\~L ns\v\dzc$wdv\ ~\Q\u,s p\aw.
\\“\»(\\ \)Q_. mul\€(\ ViCx OQ.(‘\\'Q\`QA `Mn`\\. Qb§$`\\z\\., ‘\\r\z, \X"H/\ "`\G\`HA opsr\r\'ij Mv¢\'H/\ 59 luke ,

\/ . § §,"m¢'§, a gun _ _ _
w\\€xl\zzoa€l ”\>o.m.\ssy Cmusmm¢:o ,M_,app\imnjr paup +\ms &m-b¢ Onm.i\umppml:
3m 's\»oiq bn adiue¥`\cc\]m»\ o-\`» "’c'\\n\s:>o;)rs \u,\ \>e)na\l;¢>@¥\\w {Xq>p\\`w.\l i_ penal . ve c£{ccs'\\`w at
»<\L§ \&Xw& p\'\cm\¥ w’\\\ c\§(be, \v~ejw\z¢.¢d»`\-.Qipmuc`\umllq al -Pqull;§]¢ .` ha Sucr=essiue,y
~ \zs mc§<\~o,r in` imc§m>¥\o.e. c"é€r] w‘r'\‘b\ Pr'\o\,\\\mv~\'z' m\'ece.s£ '\‘Lch¢\`\e¢"\ . Av\¢»,\ \\> ~£u(¥\\w \~e\ic£ jun L.§/\&C\A \»\o_ wic\>+\oo on‘)¢‘uoa}.

Q€SQ€£:\Q\\\{ 5\.\\0`\\/\\`~“€¢;‘\ (0’~\$‘\§ (Ov§l§§\\n\_(u\>m\u§op
C.qc‘;c\ C’q@\w*\uu\\m

Ai\ and \,\c\\¥

'“ l(>l Y\\\\."S\aci N\

C\Ouuo\` » is CA'(`\>L Cmcl Q(‘,Cufcdé, `\'rm\$\cr\~?&'\ C>{' `\4\\£ Pr

"\‘d _ p`\>h©v\":r
\>m¥`€\i(s \LW( clf?\\mv. QQ\\‘\w ‘\’M_`i\\~.cdc\€'_i Sc\£rm\\{ ’)3 pages 5(\\¢1¥\{6\». swjr .T\\L cadide \e~\/\ar Hw).{ did n<_\',+
c<>,eé.m\ {L c m package was womsz on M 3 irl/1 ci\ocq ¢€“\\f\a,q
cA/ 3 P¢w\. de ‘\'\\o. §i).dq,i_$ AQ\‘,\-e;\mq “\c\dm£,""@\o\“`“\o. \D.A.- already ‘
(Q~s“§>mda\ md_“r\ci-\~\So\si &mr¥'\n€~$ cl mon¥\/\ *i\s mem C)Lc\.ec'l.siop fmcuL
\‘{" i»`\\lv\\\i\ GL.\\ABA\'\¢\\~¥\Q¢\ ls' `\X\n. §~\"¥\ dog 59 duaq.,-»c“ui\' dm'~\ d.€€lc\.@_ ‘\Lu\

\’\)isuf w(\\ Su)o~\d ¢-\/ in ada Su..,\)'\~€rm.¢ (§'u,cfj(' C_['w(+o? (_‘n`mlrial Appemll].
T\¢\oéc"\s u\\ \wa$ i\\d“.. ., regg`@£;i lai\l»\$` \ n ~
(Qn`gf¢\g»\ .>`¢,-i`om\c\\'\ ms
Tr\)\i. acmm\e. m<§w.( pena\¥c| ¢>Q'q>er`\wq`» %ccbm‘.uwx v.\s.\s'

va\s\q\mj \oq mm Q¢d\)r{e\ erdma#Wm/MZ
A'\l QLOI' l/\h'l`~)' '
gun FlMlS(Hq N.

§D