Court Opinion

ID: 4559913
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2020-08-26 21:01:14.734349+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:27:39.713339
License: Public Domain

7(11(66((%85($82):25.(56¶&203(16$7,21
                    :25.(56¶&203(16$7,21$33($/6%2$5'
                         +($5'$8*867$70(03+,6 
                                                        
                                                        
'DUOHQH1RHO                                             'RFNHW1R
                                                         
Y                                                        
                                                         6WDWH)LOH1R
($1+ROGLQJV//&HWDO                                                     
                                                         
                                                         
$SSHDOIURPWKH&RXUWRI:RUNHUV¶                        
&RPSHQVDWLRQ&ODLPV                                      
$OOHQ3KLOOLSV-XGJH
        
                                                        
                     $IILUPHGDQG5HPDQGHG±)LOHG6HSWHPEHU

,QWKLVVHFRQGLQWHUORFXWRU\DSSHDOLQWKLVFDVHWKHHPSOR\HUDVVHUWVWKHWULDOFRXUWHUUHG
LQ GHQ\LQJ LWV PRWLRQ WR WHUPLQDWH DXWKRUL]HG PHGLFDO WUHDWPHQW  (PSOR\HU IXUWKHU
DUJXHVWKDWLWVPRWLRQVXSSRUWHGE\PHGLFDOUHFRUGVIURPWZRDXWKRUL]HGSK\VLFLDQVDQG
D FRPSOHWHG TXHVWLRQQDLUH IURPRQHRI WKHSK\VLFLDQV ZDV XQRSSRVHG DQGVKRXOGKDYH
EHHQJUDQWHGDVDPDWWHURIFRXUVH8SRQFDUHIXOFRQVLGHUDWLRQRIWKHUHFRUGZHDIILUP
WKH WULDO FRXUW¶V GHFLVLRQ WKRXJK IRU GLIIHUHQW UHDVRQV WKDQ WKRVH HVSRXVHG E\ WKH WULDO
FRXUWDQGUHPDQGWKHFDVHIRUDQ\IXUWKHUSURFHHGLQJVWKDWPD\EHQHFHVVDU\

-XGJH7LPRWK\:&RQQHUGHOLYHUHGWKHRSLQLRQRIWKH$SSHDOV%RDUGLQZKLFK3UHVLGLQJ
-XGJH0DUVKDOO/'DYLGVRQ,,,DQG-XGJH'DYLG)+HQVOH\MRLQHG

$OH[ % 0RUULVRQ DQG &KDUOHV ( 3LHUFH .QR[YLOOH 7HQQHVVHH IRU WKH HPSOR\HU
DSSHOODQW($1+ROGLQJV//&

&KULVWRSKHU7D\ORU0HPSKLV7HQQHVVHHIRUWKHHPSOR\HHDSSHOOHH'DUOHQH1RHO

                              )DFWXDODQG3URFHGXUDO%DFNJURXQG
                                                        
        7KLV LQWHUORFXWRU\ DSSHDO DULVHV IURP WZR DOOHJHG DFFLGHQWV UHSRUWHG E\ 'DUOHQH
1RHO ³(PSOR\HH´  ZKLOH VKH ZRUNHG IRU ($1 +ROGLQJV //& ³(PSOR\HU´  DW DQ
DLUSRUW UHQWDO FDU IDFLOLW\  ,Q WKH ILUVW DOOHJHG LQFLGHQW ZKLFK RFFXUUHG RQ -DQXDU\ 

                                                       
 (PSOR\HH UHSRUWHG VKH ZDV VWUXFN LQ WKH XSSHU EDFN E\ D GRRU WKDW KDG EHHQ
RSHQHGIRUFHIXOO\E\DFRZRUNHU,QWKHVHFRQGDOOHJHGLQFLGHQW(PSOR\HHUHSRUWHGWKDW
RQ-DQXDU\VKHZDVDSSURDFKLQJDQDXWRPDWLFGRRUWKDWIDLOHGWRRSHQSURSHUO\
UHVXOWLQJ LQ KHU VWULNLQJ KHU KHDG RQ WKH GRRU  3UHYLRXVO\ WKH WULDO FRXUW KDG RUGHUHG
(PSOR\HUWRSURYLGH(PSOR\HHSDQHOVRISK\VLFLDQVIRUWKHVHDOOHJHGLQFLGHQWVDQGZH
DIILUPHGWKRVHRUGHUV

       $IWHUHYDOXDWLRQVE\WZRSK\VLFLDQV(PSOR\HHVHOHFWHGIURPWKHSDQHOV(PSOR\HU
ILOHG D PRWLRQ WR WHUPLQDWH DXWKRUL]HG PHGLFDO WUHDWPHQW DUJXLQJ WKDW HDFK RI WKH
DXWKRUL]HGSK\VLFLDQVKDG H[SUHVVHG DQRSLQLRQ WKDW (PSOR\HHGLGQRW UHDVRQDEO\QHHG
PHGLFDO WUHDWPHQW DV D UHVXOW RI WKH DOOHJHG ZRUN DFFLGHQWV  (PSOR\HU DWWDFKHG WR LWV
PRWLRQ VLJQHG PHGLFDO UHFRUGV IURP HDFK SK\VLFLDQ  (PSOR\HH GLG QRW UHVSRQG WR WKH
PRWLRQ REMHFW WR WKH WULDO FRXUW¶V FRQVLGHUDWLRQ RI WKH VLJQHG PHGLFDO UHFRUGV RU RIIHU
DQ\FRXQWHUYDLOLQJPHGLFDOHYLGHQFH&RQVHTXHQWO\WKHWULDOFRXUWFRQVLGHUHGWKHPRWLRQ
XQRSSRVHG

       )ROORZLQJDUHYLHZRIWKHUHFRUGZLWKRXWDQHYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJsee7HQQ&RGH
$QQ   G   WKH WULDO FRXUW GHQLHG (PSOR\HU¶V PRWLRQ FRQFOXGLQJ LW ZDV
³LQDSSURSULDWHWRDGGUHVVWKHPHULWVRIWKHWUHDWLQJGRFWRUV¶RSLQLRQVLQDPRWLRQKHDULQJ
DQG SRVVLEO\ µPRGLI\¶ LWV LQWHUORFXWRU\ RUGHU´  7KH WULDO FRXUW IXUWKHU UHDVRQHG WKDW
³GLVFRYHU\LVLQFRPSOHWHDQGWKHSDUWLHVKDYH\HWWRXQGHUWDNHPHGLFDOSURRI>ERWKRI@
ZKLFKDUHUHTXLUHGIRUWKH&RXUWWRDGMXGLFDWHWKHFODLPRQLWVPHULWV´)LQDOO\WKHWULDO
FRXUWQRWHGWKDW³>W@RSURFHHGYLDDPRWLRQZRXOGJUDIWXSRQWKHUXOHVRIWKLV&RXUWZKDW
DPRXQWV WR D VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW SURFHHGLQJ RQ D FODLP GHHPHG FRPSHQVDEOH DW DQ
H[SHGLWHG KHDULQJ ZKHQ RQO\ GHQLHG FODLPV DUH DPHQDEOH WR VXFKPRWLRQV´  (PSOR\HU
KDVDSSHDOHG

                                        6WDQGDUGRI5HYLHZ
                                                    
        7KH VWDQGDUG ZH DSSO\ LQ UHYLHZLQJ D WULDO FRXUW¶V GHFLVLRQ SUHVXPHV WKDW WKH
FRXUW¶VIDFWXDOILQGLQJVDUHFRUUHFWXQOHVVWKHSUHSRQGHUDQFHRIWKHHYLGHQFHLVRWKHUZLVH
See 7HQQ &RGH $QQ   F     ³7KHUH VKDOO EH D SUHVXPSWLRQ WKDW WKH
ILQGLQJV DQG FRQFOXVLRQV RI WKH ZRUNHUV¶ FRPSHQVDWLRQ MXGJH DUH FRUUHFW XQOHVV WKH
SUHSRQGHUDQFHRIWKHHYLGHQFHLVRWKHUZLVH´ +RZHYHUZHUHYLHZTXHVWLRQVRIODZde
novo ZLWK QR SUHVXPSWLRQ RI FRUUHFWQHVV  See Am. Mining Ins. Co. v. Campbell 1R
06&5:&7HQQ/(;,6DW  7HQQ:RUNHUV¶&RPS3DQHO
'HF  ³$WULDOFRXUW¶VFRQFOXVLRQVRIODZDUHUHYLHZHGde novoXSRQWKHUHFRUG
ZLWK QR SUHVXPSWLRQ RI FRUUHFWQHVV´   0RUHRYHU WKH LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ DQG DSSOLFDWLRQ RI
VWDWXWHV DQG UHJXODWLRQV FRQFHUQV LVVXHV RI ODZ ZKLFK ZH UHYLHZ de novo ZLWK QR
SUHVXPSWLRQ RI FRUUHFWQHVV DIIRUGHG WR WKH WULDO FRXUW¶V ILQGLQJV  See Seiber v. Reeves


 See Noel v. EAN Holdings, LLC1RVDQG71:UN&RPS$SS%G
/(;,6 7HQQ:RUNHUV¶&RPS$SS%G-DQ 

                                                    

Logging  6:G   7HQQ   Hadzic v. Averitt Express 1R 
71:UN&RPS$SS%G/(;,6DW  7HQQ:RUNHUV¶&RPS$SS%G
0D\ 
        
                                             $QDO\VLV

       +HDULQJV RI LQWHUORFXWRU\ GLVSXWHV DUH JRYHUQHG E\ 7HQQHVVHH &RGH $QQRWDWHG
VHFWLRQ G ZKLFKVWDWHVDVIROORZV

        8SRQPRWLRQof either partyPDGHDWDQ\WLPHDIWHUDGLVSXWHFHUWLILFDWLRQ
        QRWLFH KDV EHHQ LVVXHG E\ D ZRUNHUV¶ FRPSHQVDWLRQ PHGLDWRU D ZRUNHUV¶
        FRPSHQVDWLRQ MXGJH PD\ DW WKH MXGJH¶V GLVFUHWLRQ KHDU GLVSXWHV RYHU
        LVVXHVSURYLGHGLQWKHGLVSXWHFHUWLILFDWLRQQRWLFHFRQFHUQLQJWKHSURYLVLRQ
        RIWHPSRUDU\GLVDELOLW\or medical benefitsRQDQH[SHGLWHGEDVLVDQGHQWHU
        DQ LQWHUORFXWRU\ RUGHU XSRQ GHWHUPLQLQJ WKDW WKH LQMXUHG HPSOR\HH ZRXOG
        likely prevail DWDKHDULQJRQWKHPHULWV
        
7HQQ&RGH$QQ G   HPSKDVLVDGGHG 7KXVLQFRQVLGHULQJDPRWLRQILOHG
E\ HLWKHU SDUW\ VHHNLQJ LQWHUORFXWRU\ UHOLHI SULRU WR WKH RFFXUUHQFH RI D FRPSHQVDWLRQ
KHDULQJ D WULDO FRXUW PXVW GHWHUPLQH ZKHWKHU WKH HPSOR\HH LV OLNHO\ WR SUHYDLO RQ WKDW
LVVXHDWWULDO

       )XUWKHUPRUH7HQQ&RPS5 5HJV  JRYHUQVWKHPDQQHU
LQZKLFKH[SHGLWHGKHDULQJVDUHFRQGXFWHG3DUDJUDSK  GLVFXVVHVWKHILOLQJRIUHTXHVWV
IRU H[SHGLWHG KHDULQJV E\ ³HLWKHU SDUW\´  3DUDJUDSK  E  UHTXLUHV D SDUW\ RSSRVLQJ D
PRWLRQWR³VXEPLWDOOGRFXPHQWVGHPRQVWUDWLQJWKHPRYLQJSDUW\LVQRWHQWLWOHGWRWKH
UHTXHVWHG UHOLHI QR ODWHU WKDQ WHQ   EXVLQHVV GD\V EHIRUH WKH GDWH RI WKH H[SHGLWHG
KHDULQJ´,QWKHHYHQWWKHFRXUWHOHFWVWRUHVROYHWKHPRWLRQZLWKRXWDKHDULQJ³WKHFOHUN
VKDOODOVRVHQGLQIRUPDWLRQWRWKHSDUWLHVGHWDLOLQJWKHDFWLRQVUHTXLUHGWRSUHVHQWWKHFDVH
WRWKHMXGJHIRUDGHFLVLRQRQWKHUHFRUG´7HQQ&RPS5 5HJV  I 
,Q DGGLWLRQ SDUDJUDSK   SURYLGHV WKDW DW DQ H[SHGLWHG KHDULQJ ³OHWWHUV RU ZULWWHQ
VWDWHPHQWV DGGUHVVLQJ PHGLFDO FDXVDWLRQ WKDW KDYH EHHQ VLJQHG E\ D GRFWRU VKDOO EH
DGPLVVLEOHHYLGHQFH´7HQQ&RPS5 5HJV  

       ,Q DGGLWLRQ SDUDJUDSK   RI WKDW UHJXODWLRQ GLVFXVVHV FLUFXPVWDQFHV LQ ZKLFK D
SDUW\PD\HOHFWWRILOHDPRWLRQIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWIROORZLQJDQH[SHGLWHGKHDULQJDW
ZKLFKWKHWULDOFRXUWGHQLHGEHQHILWV³RQWKHJURXQGVRIFRPSHQVDELOLW\´7HQQ&RPS
5  5HJV     ³,I WKH GHQLDO RQ WKH JURXQGV RI FRPSHQVDELOLW\ LV
DIILUPHGE\WKHDSSHDOVERDUGRULIQRDSSHDOLVWDNHQWKHHPSOR\HUmayILOHDPRWLRQIRU
VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW    ´  Id. HPSKDVLV DGGHG   7KXV ZKLOH WKLV UXOH GHVFULEHV
SDUWLFXODU FLUFXPVWDQFHV LQ ZKLFK D SDUW\ may choose WR ILOH D PRWLRQ IRU VXPPDU\
MXGJPHQWLWGRHVQRWUHVWULFWWKHILOLQJRIPRWLRQVIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWRUDQ\RWKHU

                                                 

PRWLRQVDVPD\EHDOORZHGE\5XOHRIWKH7HQQHVVHH5XOHVRI&LYLO3URFHGXUHRUDQ\
RWKHUDSSOLFDEOHVWDWXWHVRUUXOHV

        ,QLWVRUGHUWKHWULDOFRXUWFRQFOXGHGWKDWLWZDVXQDEOHWRHQWHUWDLQ³ZKDWDPRXQWV
WRDVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWSURFHHGLQJ´EHFDXVHSXUVXDQWWR7HQQ&RPS5 5HJV
  VXPPDU\MXGJPHQWPRWLRQVFDQRQO\EHILOHGLQFLUFXPVWDQFHVZKHUHDWULDO
FRXUW KDV SUHYLRXVO\ GHQLHG DQ HPSOR\HH¶V FODLP DW D SULRU H[SHGLWHG KHDULQJ  :H
GLVDJUHH ZLWK WKLV UHVWULFWLYH LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ RI WKH UHJXODWLRQ ZKHQ UHDG LQ FRQMXQFWLRQ
ZLWK 5XOH  RI WKH 7HQQHVVHH 5XOHV RI &LYLO 3URFHGXUH  ,QVWHDG ZH FRQFOXGH WKDW
SDUWLHVZKRFKRRVHWRVHHNUHOLHIIURPWKHFRXUWSULRUWRDWULDOKDYHVHYHUDOFKRLFHV2QH
RSWLRQ LV WR ILOH DQ LQWHUORFXWRU\ PRWLRQ DV GHVFULEHG LQ 7HQQHVVHH &RGH $QQRWDWHG
VHFWLRQ G DQG7HQQ&RPS5 5HJV  $QRWKHURSWLRQLV
WR ILOH D PRWLRQ IRU VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW ³DW DQ\ WLPH DIWHU WKH H[SLUDWLRQ RI WKLUW\  
GD\VIURPWKHFRPPHQFHPHQWRIWKHDFWLRQ´7HQQ5&LY30RUHRYHUDVZH
SUHYLRXVO\ VWDWHG D WULDO FRXUW KDV EURDG GLVFUHWLRQ WR FRQWURO WKH SDFH RI OLWLJDWLRQ DQG
VKRXOG ³JLYH HDFK VLGH D UHDVRQDEOH DQG PHDQLQJIXO RSSRUWXQLW\´ WR SUHSDUH LWV FDVH
EHIRUHVHWWLQJDQ\VXFKPRWLRQIRUDKHDULQJHollis v. Komyo Am.1R
71:UN&RPS$SS%G/(;,6DW  7HQQ:RUNHUV¶&RPS$SS%G0DU
 

        8SRQFRQVLGHUDWLRQRIWKHIRUHJRLQJZHFRQFOXGH(PSOR\HU¶VPRWLRQWRWHUPLQDWH
PHGLFDO EHQHILWV IDOOV ZLWKLQ WKH VFRSH RI 7HQQHVVHH &RGH $QQRWDWHG VHFWLRQ 
 G   DQG 7HQQ &RPS 5  5HJV     ,W ZDV QRW D PRWLRQ IRU
SDUWLDO VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW SXUVXDQW WR7HQQ 5&LY3  DV VXJJHVWHG E\ WKH WULDO
FRXUWEXWZDVLQVWHDGDUHTXHVWIRULQWHUORFXWRU\UHOLHIDQGVKRXOGKDYHEHHQHYDOXDWHGLQ
OLJKWRIWKHVWDQGDUGIRUH[SHGLWHGKHDULQJVPDQGDWHGE\VHFWLRQ G  

        1HYHUWKHOHVV ZH FRQFOXGH WKDW WKH WULDO FRXUW¶V HUURU LQ QRW WUHDWLQJ (PSOR\HU¶V
PRWLRQDVDUHTXHVWIRULQWHUORFXWRU\UHOLHISXUVXDQWWR7HQQHVVHH&RGH$QQRWDWHGVHFWLRQ
 G  ZDV KDUPOHVV XQGHU WKH FLUFXPVWDQFHV SUHVHQWHG LQ WKLV FDVH DQG WKDW WKH
WULDOFRXUWGLGQRWHUULQGHQ\LQJ(PSOR\HU¶VPRWLRQ)LUVW(PSOR\HU¶VDUJXPHQWWKDWDQ
XQRSSRVHG PRWLRQ PXVW EH JUDQWHG DV D PDWWHU RI FRXUVH LV LQFRUUHFW  :H KDYH
SUHYLRXVO\ H[SODLQHG WKDW ³>Q@HLWKHU 5XOH  %  >RI WKH WULDO FRXUW¶V 3UDFWLFHV DQG
3URFHGXUHV@QRUDQ\RWKHUDSSOLFDEOHUXOHSURKLELWVDWULDOFRXUWIURPGHFLGLQJPRWLRQVRQ
WKHLU PHULWV  /LNHZLVH WKH %XUHDX V UHJXODWLRQV GR QRW SURKLELW D WULDO FRXUW IURP
FRQVLGHULQJWKHPHULWVRIDQXQRSSRVHGPRWLRQ´Valladares v. Transco Prods., Inc.1R
 DQG   71 :UN &RPS $SS %G /(;,6  DW 
  7HQQ:RUNHUV¶&RPS$SS%G-XO\ 7KLVLVQRWWRVXJJHVWKRZHYHUWKDWD
WULDO FRXUW FDQQRW FRQVLGHU WKH IDFW WKDW D PRWLRQ LV XQRSSRVHG LQ GHFLGLQJ ZKHWKHU WR
JUDQWRUGHQ\WKHPRWLRQ7KXVDSDUW\DFWVDWLWVSHULOZKHQHOHFWLQJQRWWRUHVSRQGWRD
SDUW\¶VUHTXHVWIRUDWULDOFRXUWWRWDNHVRPHDFWLRQ


                                                   

       6HFRQGWKHPHGLFDOUHFRUGVDQGTXHVWLRQQDLUHUHVSRQVHVSURYLGHGE\(PSOR\HULQ
VXSSRUWRILWVPRWLRQZHUHHTXLYRFDODVWRWKHQHHGIRUDGGLWLRQDOPHGLFDOWUHDWPHQW'U
1DGHO¶V 0DUFK  UHSRUW WKH PRVW UHFHQW PHGLFDO UHSRUW FRQWDLQHG LQ WKH UHFRUG
LQGLFDWHG (PSOR\HH ZDV EHQHILWWLQJ IURP SK\VLFDO WKHUDS\ DQG KH UHFRPPHQGHG
DGGLWLRQDOWKHUDS\DWWKDWWLPH+HDOVRFKDQJHG(PSOR\HH¶VPHGLFDWLRQV)XUWKHUPRUH
DOWKRXJK 'U 1DGHO LQGLFDWHG LQ UHVSRQVH WR (PSOR\HU¶V TXHVWLRQQDLUH WKDW (PSOR\HH¶V
FRQGLWLRQZDVQRWOLNHO\WKHUHVXOWRIDZRUNUHODWHGDFFLGHQWKHFODULILHGWKLVUHVSRQVH
E\ZULWLQJ³>V@KHPD\KDYHKDGVRPH>LQFUHDVHLQ@SDLQ>DQG@LQMXU\VXSHULPSRVHGRQD
FKURQLFSUREOHP´7KXV(PSOR\HUGLGQRWHVWDEOLVKDWWKLVLQWHUORFXWRU\VWDJHRIWKHFDVH
WKDWLWZDVOLNHO\WRSUHYDLODWWULDOLQSURYLQJ(PSOR\HHKDVQRQHHGIRUUHDVRQDEOHDQG
QHFHVVDU\IXWXUHPHGLFDOFDUHFDXVDOO\UHODWHGWRWKHZRUNDFFLGHQWV
                                                 
                                          &RQFOXVLRQ
                                                 
       %DVHGRQWKHIRUHJRLQJZHDIILUPWKHWULDOFRXUW¶VRUGHUDQGUHPDQGWKHFDVHIRU
DQ\IXUWKHUSURFHHGLQJVWKDWPD\EHQHFHVVDU\

                                                

                  7(11(66((%85($82):25.(56¶&203(16$7,21
                                                                1
                        :25.(56¶&203(16$7,21$33($/6%2$5'

'DUOHQH1RHO                                                         'RFNHW1R
                                                                   
Y                                                               
                                                                  6WDWH)LOH1R
                                                                          
($1+ROGLQJV//&HWDO

                                       &(57,),&$7(2)6(59,&(

, KHUHE\ FHUWLI\ WKDW D WUXH DQG FRUUHFW FRS\ RI WKH $SSHDOV %RDUG¶V GHFLVLRQ LQ WKH
UHIHUHQFHGFDVHZDVVHQWWRWKHIROORZLQJUHFLSLHQWVE\WKHIROORZLQJPHWKRGVRIVHUYLFH
RQWKLVWKHWKGD\RI6HSWHPEHU
 1DPH                    &HUWLILHG   )LUVW&ODVV   9LD   )D[           9LD     (PDLO$GGUHVV
                          0DLO        0DLO          )D[   1XPEHU        (PDLO

 &KULVWRSKHU/7D\ORU                                                        ;    FWD\ORU#WD\ORUWRRQFRP
 $OH[%0RUULVRQ                                                             ;    DEPRUULVRQ#PLMVFRP
 $OOHQ3KLOOLSV-XGJH                                                        ;    9LD(OHFWURQLF0DLO
 .HQQHWK06ZLW]HU                                                          ;    9LD(OHFWURQLF0DLO
 &KLHI-XGJH
 3HQQ\6KUXP&OHUN                                                          ;    3HQQ\3DWWHUVRQ6KUXP#WQJRY
 &RXUWRI:RUNHUV¶
 &RPSHQVDWLRQ&ODLPV

-HDQHWWH%DLUG
-HDQHWWH%DLUG
&OHUN:RUNHUV¶&RPSHQVDWLRQ$SSHDOV%RDUG
)UHQFK/DQGLQJ'U6WH%
1DVKYLOOH71
7HOHSKRQH
(OHFWURQLF0DLO:&$SSHDOV&OHUN#WQJRY