Court Opinion

ID: 4067016
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 22:59:21.212094+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:34.803811
License: Public Domain

©

U/OD/\j €€C€,O'=/'H~¢€ O‘C °('L\s VACKAW&

,/))€,>,,S€. gm A legg/m Q@¢W_,>+

RECE\VEI IIN
; ZA »\/ )l< 3 9 w § couRT oF chM:NALAPPEALs

AUB 27 2015

Abe%Acosta,Clerk
gem/ec- mor~)%j©m€/l\<,§
:#'/?0;242_4~
/\/\m,o ,\),\)c(\ L,L,O,`+/

j€C\/» /l¢ />< 7€/0 z`

;Q>Q»u»c,v£ "‘l. (Y\QmT£QM\/LE€Z:[
won \°\08.\\;01
C(\°LO(\S\\!EL\. LL¢\ST_`T

.'33\0~0\ &- '\E\N\Y_\_,“l 'dV~,
Qzea\xm\.\"; wma.s ”\%\03"

@\ bumst 36, &0\5

`T'u>’. `§\-X@_ C,\_C~_V~K C_.a.\u.w mi C.,LLUY\&\\\:\\_ N?V\:¢x\,$.`
Q-e. on\l \9"_\08 C_(A()'s.\e\_` $"\mmm

(X~\J\.'>Txm tTK-_>Asu=_<>.`\ -s<,\ swaweg Q\&$?e¢ose 10 A(??anm\n`s
'\>Lll?\.r.c_cm mm <~‘\0`.\1»\?\\1 c>§ ¥LAQ\&A$ r_n?~\‘u\_$ \\-o’l,

'_DEJ\L Lx..€e\k\(
(>\~QA§{~_ '\'~m\\..d Emc_\.zxs€b QQOMLA¢¢.»\`$

Qe.&\u#\e`\_» -;,.`1 a»??d'-;'mzaa we bumng §L\“:MQNSG_ °\o
A€Q\~Lc_c\»+", APP\.:¢;A.”\~;@») FML \_M\m ¢Qr- \,\MBc-us LQM?'LL§

\\\\».\"\. ~r\c\ £’>9_, KESPG.LTFLLL\,~\ Fm,c»h 1_.\>'1¥\€ £>\i§o\\a_
C_§\Ls.v, uz\-, O~.od Y-M`G_\_.~>M`d€b 10 `\\3&. C.¢>LLQI ,QF`
xf_Oa_N\x\\)c\\`_ \AQV&Q\_S A_~S §§ (’ML.‘\ cali (A§‘V\_\ac\\o°¥§
RQOA.&ALMQ\_. (>\?(J\A.L_A°\xe¢o Y¢l, LAM\YT u>T \§M>E.A$ (L¢>Uus

“Smhw\xsww_@. ram mm FAm\f_ms\\L\>&d \0 mms cum
D_\¢ 9\\5\,.£¢\\.;,,¢>“: \`\1 ‘B~.u_\\i Lc)\_akf\?!>o C_¢ALLM‘K"(
L.x.('\)`d(>\ \'\D\_(Y\(Ad>l

51 w mr <~_Y guam

Qe 59 EC,‘S Y Q,\_\_‘\ _$ \_\S‘.)mv\'\£d

¢¢¢¢¢

 
     
 

C_Au_\.£ man ‘);~ o¢\so. %Z,/]Sg '6,

\

E_.\i?¢xm\‘~_ ` ' . “s_.¢ 'u-\L baum oF alumme

.QAQ\\A_C.& `\. W\m\>`¥£-»CN\(~_?C\ :3? (\Qp\:_(\\_§ @\: "\E\¢A_§

©\??L:c_\\m°$ @»F_B>qum_ ma a?l’osmw.a '\'n

,S~vmv;_s &Ls€ews\z ~ro M£’L:¢A.¢~r`s QPP\_r¢mx_mo sick
man @c~' MM\V_AS cnm?u,§ \\»m ~A\m K\z(’>\um\\_ m

a??o§.u~:om 10 ¢\~rm&\\)`\`$ AFFJ'_\¢\\M`T rush lm~.FF@cmxe

b(; CS\.\.¥L°C~_£S\ o\’- `r\~\€- flaum oF CKlmlMAL
APPV_A\_§ m? 'YF_>¢`>~\cwmavv~l A'PP\_:LA.\H 'Pl;o»§e

much mmu_\_h \_1_\4€ ~vo ¢»E.S(’Ec_<\‘u\_u)\ sums T\\Y_s \&ouo&ASLE_

'\‘_»AL>_&L.T `Y\>\c-_ F¢>\_\_¢>u\)x_»>\.“; ‘

1.
Q\F_&’>LJ'M\L_ ~ro wmsz €»E_S?o¢\>&i£.

s\?(’\_zu\vn`:> \.M»U L><\M_&U wm\\c.\\w\r-.mv "d ¢AFFLC,F_¢LS G\FFLdI\\JzT
mm 99`¢&.¢\%\.1 game uw\m¢>\m M_“s" mmr~_s c\Fr-~.\.Am \A¢\_s

QV\¢$€\(’>\.X». L<\\.LSL F¢>Q\. $>/\Ld (?>\”:\.¥.L‘~_V~ 35`| P\EG\S¢AN_S \o\i '\\~\\?'_ v
Y“Q\_L-¢>m;m»`\?c\c;\$" <>\N:v"€_l&<.mw\mmov.r-.s".. `v\\x_s L_.,~¢me\\>»

`ch\\_ I_M<~Mw\c>\“n \M\_s wx\\c»_.¢ ~rv`uu=_ lamb C.ov`v.v_c_'r x,\\s\¢nmv\¢\-

Tr_\m md \_Au\> \z_“>\'~¢>w_&ra&\.v._s\~\rr_h \_M\Em M\?r_m\>*s \\"im;sf@b m "\‘\ALS

U\

`¥o `N\L_s 5\=_¢319.0 06

\\1_¢> Mf»xba\xvr- Lm\u,\x c~\\n& `¥\\E_ mmr
xsw~szmg 5¢\@..<_ swava n> J_s.§u_e c\ SERLC,»\ mmd.m\)~f.,
`\\4\=_ (`_,¢>\.LL¥
?>\'.\J_t‘\ 0\‘~

umw

dew~_w`i¥\m\)€_ K_»~>Ad(Y\‘L.S$L»
C~_\n_br~_~or_); <=\~ob LL&§‘;.Q>L\_.U~\ 06

Ku.u=_d 010 `\\H~_ N\mxoro 10

`( \M"_. C.om F‘:,)>F_c\>`\`\ €\L

I_¢~>F¢>Lmv\.o'< n¥ M?P\_xc_wo'¥\ "¥\\é_ C__nu.¥n S‘M\'\&S §_`m&mm\>\°. 'YG

Cgl(\\n 1~\', `§\4\;1&`& mo $TMEN\\'-_»>j usi \,NAEL€_ °'Y\~\m \.'.N?okmm~

lou c_»=m\z. Fflow\- umw ~<\AC~_ sw\:\c_ APP&.¢\\_@;> ~\\w_ €>\?(>r;\_mr;£>

&&1\¢_$ was C'>Ased "Lm\wu:\" on `m£ AY~Y'LM\\\U "\m\/\ mF€lc&R

gukw\\) 'z_¢\\< §u_&muxen ms TAF_ Nawmmme m §u&$m.¢‘r»

J_m\"-_ WWQ>A€>\JF_ c_l\u»sr-_ LX<>Q\_I.<;AN‘{§ APV\.xc_mr.o.o {\W\¢_.\>\x)<

awxacumem"§,_\.uev`m hamm summa Z.A\¢`s AFF';_N>`\\U F<»l\

QMY)M>LL aAuLsF_ _&¢;AM_H mM`LFLAc\)T. AQ€LU_A.\M`; (-\PV\;&LATT_¢>\Q
APVF_.\>M>< AT~£Lme€.
"`\¥\Y'_ §S€l'i.\‘;\'» `<\~\M

mag swxs~mmd &~\ &PPLU_MMS (\1“\09,¢\):~\\

haas mm .’>1¢\\€~_ €LE¢¢>M> Fac,u 10 CHM,LF_QL.,<<_ ‘\m~“\ T\AF'_

(`_@,¢vm>emu.\_ x_~r-@n,mc\m mm chmlc,;?mc_ m mmp

C.n.`nv~o\_w;d Q>\.'~_~( was (Le.\..£c\&\.r;

lX\\>D €.REDT.(SLE. \\30&
dogs ‘\mr_ §S.Q\'c.e§

C.u,mm\o \C\¢M x_.¢?nku\mlm &V;h>e\anw&,

`K\&€_ `LV\E§*LQ>‘\.\_Y_H \06~

~re.&r~_ gum \"- rdz=_.\nuA_ x_\\)f~ uv~w\s\m
LM\M>

QAMT_¢_.L("<\XEL K_N `\H¥-_ l`_on>YIL¢>LL\ZS> (7>\»¢|. `\<\~\F_

SSM.Y_.& m? mae &Ru-_€ mrs K\’;Lomkhz_¢\m mm ama

§E.\\_\'r\'i¢oc.r-_ I_¢\) ”NA\=_ A??’ld!\\¥m.. {~\FT'I_A¢\M' \-\I\_S \/~\\_50

VXEC_F_T_\M°_L L\\)VQKN\Q\K'LGN oil N{AFLC.@‘Y‘LC_ K\C,`\t\rr_¥`l AT

vw _S\L_svameh P\_<\c.a x_,\) wm (lec.em (’A$r.~ <\P€’\:

APP\_‘LLM~LM &>\~x~mmw\e_m ‘:C ‘\\.-L& AP?&\_&&E (SKLV»_F
0¢<_. \>NN\¢_.`L£ '

X_L/\'\s~\`£>

U

f ~ c
\`~’\L&Lwecuv\@m; ‘<\Ae -zswsxmr~_s oc- 1\¢&¢._ \‘-* mlsw\LcT C_om?v:< o

§\PPF_A\_$ iwmfe_s :s_xo T»AEUL N\Ew\o&r\.\>mm\ A~)> 001.¢1@\0 M.
QAL\=_ 2 <>A “I\AF_ _€>¢>T\o¢v\ \_x\§\’_ “NM€ X\~\M `H&E_ \\\¢de&\\kr."\'
d m:_s Az>dk\:§gc»_s `v ma c_£L\=_dLe.L\.w\

o\'» T\~\F_ aaw¥;h&o»
W);AL :_\\)§~¢&Lmr\¢\n \_A>\\o

?ARTL¢:(’AT(;§ 110 T\&E. r_m\)~rko\_u=_b

&\»:\ '<>\m>" mgmcww\r;&~l umwa md <2\~\m_1_\:.sm; \\-\1_<,

.`:£_»o¥n&mz\\\)'\_$

<_&Edr?>:\_r_¥‘( web P\v_\_na%l\.r.~c~( eeo l\WEM_.

‘v\&en.r;r-@u _~<1~\6. x_z_smz_<. (Lec,mu>z.¢g m).c_ Cap\
mf~ T\~\Q marion \£\.Mh “$\¢\{~. (\\”1‘\"1_\'.»\\3;¥ ink ?RAEA%L& (`_!W\&E
gamma unm&r-\m mm mm w was r>.c>f>\z_¢»\_ was &Asen'
bed m\&£w\~\&fk am mm `$TA.\$TxA*<&D`

P(AM’>M>\.?_ C_A\_».s<€_. w\&x;,\x _u_w>._s as~r A€>Lc.s\<\\zb w\xa& “T\»\E
©\FPL¢MM simc~_§ unnaqu *s\-\ca»~¢>`\"~\¢);davcx

"\\'\"L$ Lc'\>("£d~
E»e’<'r_@»\_ I_'oiekmr\w>‘\

Ha_s ~Lgtm~;.b -Ylku\e mm C_.ok\lr;u
X_¢\.\\“-u>&mmw~ `§<) \_A\AB E.;>Fo&£&m\z mm c\m$

`?xbe.~nu.\__ I_\\)FMLN\L\.\;'< umw N\M>'\§

T\-\E
C,‘q¢h.mh£ F_\IEM_<, '\um’ oC.Lu_iLED

`.BWLL.¢,\A wm._ <__@.\>-rmu_c-_:b Q;LL~¢.» T\.n_s comm wm
fv\A.L§\sw`w\L Q,F_ASM) "€( SEAML\ wmw.¢\m-
\~_\\m `UA\"_ '&A\\)€

ae_uxe¢oca 14 wst M<~‘Lm\\m 10

Q\\‘»_Y»&M=k><_c~_ m \)AOJ_Mu_ AUL\)~LH 1a V\Ecam PAST.

L?>)

P\?P\_u_m\n \MS.. dimo&.wmeb wmaua \\r_s ¢A&>P\.u,¢\umo FoK palm oF

HMLr-.As c.m,?u.s \\.o‘\ mm \n_s c_.o\»)se\_ m..d <\sm \’MVEQ.\A Lmummr£

mo A\>Pr~_\>`\_ &\\ wm c;.\xm_Lr-_‘om_»~>\, T\»\\z Lv»i~bt&u_n‘\ ¢\\\>d R\':\_M&ILH`\
mr wise C_nm‘»m&mw_m\_. mv'¢)kn\am w\\o PAmcx?meb m '<\\e_ umwuev
?>w\. AG?LxLwa.__\xas smm>\) “\A@. \u\n> ?\€mmmv\&m o(' 1'\\\‘~_\‘“¥€€§1\\'&

|£\_Ssx_s'i&mc£ 0§ Loz+vseL. Cu\;..osr~.\_s (\U M“>L umc_<.sx.w mm A'\ ¢>.

L;€me_c\\_ sw~s\c=.£. mc (>\P?Lxcam's Qaac~eeb~;\\v\as§"<\\e mafic_xv-_m am

~\/u>\_mr;b o.&>.mb L_u\.wse\_ S\_L?>muxe;§ mix AFde¢x\rrw $m=_

makes E.ser\s=~
&r._rx\)& AS.$L$'H\.~)L& 0\'~ C,b nmw\r_ssu¢o ‘1\&\\1
mem @r_ \J»~&. L@~m. Aww»_\\>d. 'n'\m,w».u\~mz Am> baum M’P¢
LT_ c_»..m tx FM.V\ A\¢.\.> lN\PAmlAL mPPM~.Y\_M)~m~\ F»\\` ~\\4£ (_oR¢\m-
l_¢\s\,. uF ‘1\\<; mulw~) To d\;\'C~.VL(\/\x.n\'-_ ¢Adw\xs,$\.€st\.rn‘\ oF E\hd~
r~_m;& t\`sb c..a\=_d~.&t\_-n~\ wm c_n»r-LLEMLAL L\\>Fomv\ram ~1¢ {'>F_ L._P*
Hr»_u> mo A?Pe“\_,. <\ePLu,Am`.s LML.J_\&L_. swe. ~emu\_ L.J\=Muv\m‘\“

m\~\o (’qu,x\>rne\> 1.5 *\\w_ c_om?~o\_\.\<_b (B\M. ‘APP\_:;R¢\`§ 1~\§5=¥
x\~na_c.e\mem"t`_;. `w.& §>Q_reé am AW<~_AL. `.m>@s wm make
Q\»\A\Ls_.o\»_c~_ `m we c.mu?xd\=_wru\\_ I,.\shv.mmm wm 9mmva
194\\\=_\ 10 'xv\& C.mo'f Q>u¢l, immv\\é,w\el$. C,Au¢~séL`§
Q»V\_Tre§\?`u>u. 10 “lm_. means "v\\¢_v`c=:` mo (’M,E. Ln, `\At_ ?Nlmomh\ n,) ‘?¢>.L\e
`1 "1‘\1 wm¢_ QG»&§zm c_é\s§\` 00 ?m¢»e 3 Lwe L\ w\§&a_£ qua gem-

F_Nc_c'»_ Q>&l.,us_s wxu\, Ceu.\\s'i~.\_ §é\\lxmu 'H\m “\%\L N\Uxm.ulg 0¥-

wl

`Y\\e umw "s\coam‘ las `c\\a APH_\,L&@`§ &&1§¥- wes@ Refemmoc_e§ M,
am m she c.m>_uw\u,c»_z> w mv~_m"`“\\\e Lo\)¥lvz<\>nc\t_ bomeran

\_r\§\\o (’M\Ti€_x\’évt\"_h Lx\> T\c\?_ w\o“\§!w.\_\_f;d €;u.‘\- `T\\EV\E *S._"_\, s\jo ('_Q»&B~

zinan ms kx\\f»_ c.@»mde“>um_ x.»€c&w\l\m E.‘>~\`:\s\\c»‘._b C,Q\Eht%x\_m‘l w¥\r-‘_»¢ 11 is S‘SA~\Ed Q>‘\

(>\FF;.MH ‘i\\xs c.o“>?mbe.o'nm_' I_.QGMLN\<\¢‘Y mud umwa W\u.€ Aw§

<;M`v\ec:\ L'Nvow\mxw m umw @m»@v`¢e“\em nw wm €as~r.“i\\é
molds "<`\Mx (.\Muo">m, SAIL m\§ hug '\'uLs A\Ah `r\\m "¥<> .Su£w¢\n~

~nme C\-\¢\\A_e.\n.>x_\\>\, nw c_Led'~LmLu~\ ames Q.\¢_\_U\m\,u~\

MT `f\&t CLM‘
F':x>&»\)‘x'cl\\, I_~)\"bm\'\e`m~v un\e PA€L_TILI?!\'U;.!>

:_~ `mé_ C.o¢\>‘$P~oLLe)> C'>u.\\
ML ¥ALT\ "r\x\<_ Gl?l’£u\_ uaw wm

RBQ<_»:: `USF_ Lx>aw~in\\ mv 'mr~_ C,o.o¥-LLE_¢\>'TL»\L- lufnllm&\wf. xxv was
-L§smm\ ama Q\e\_rM>me\\

C\\`~Vle\'\n 1a K\XL €>\F\"ldl.\\rr\ vs

P\LE dam _`\M?um&§ w &\=.c_mr_d

Q.>F_'Lw\é. ~~\E_s‘v¢\(b\_'\._°;>¥\éb %`\ T¥\L
cava Kra¢\s¢..) ?ol QQA\BM>\_F_ amc

m uswa A sammy wMLLAm 51\5&§
E>.\\) ?P\ABM>`\_$_ l`_Au\,§& FMN\ i\~.\€~_ C.QMTLM_LE_I> %u\`\.

52 To' buQ>.fn&\mrlme.b

111»
F\_va.¢_o_mmw_ m\em 15 mo \-'ams €>¢>.s\=_h,w &E¢Mz,b u\v; (;¢r>lq.\»\)f,r_e,\_h

was Q\&gm.os;e.w_ mm vi\_xc_c\¢\n‘_s gasc~_g ~H{\m mem(`.im§mssad

'&L:Li 10 \&UL Q~e?r\e$e.mmm». ‘t\\&ar»_

13 ¢.>¢ €_'mm\_ 41~ nga
S'r€\`\€z§ AGP%NX>U< .o\'=“ €\

C_¢!N\N\uu\>r_ca°ru~) “¥o '1('1!\\"; §"(M%S

\\”nML\~:)‘;~\ A.`\n N?G\,ic_a>.<\)w`s !A\m>.x F'cr‘_:i-\NZ_\¢>A$ lv\)

£\\_»._.&Y T_\~> C_,¢> \.w\)\`\ '\UU?\.S

mined is¢\»)\.»m‘\ ou. fld\\v\ AOP\_xc_A-m‘s

?\_ea mm v_»_me.u_,xd w degemv.»m \“\.;lo\;»>- Pkm. ~ro wm \:~

(`<\?\1\_. `\‘\-\&?.f`~_ 15 R C.ASE_ di~_C.Lr..\\}L Motx_c_&\ F?\od\ L£\L.~.\.£, \.AlLl':

gm za»u.w\ \\.,,:1@\\\_ ~meus. ram m `Q\em~xec» Q\_€ml\>s

S\xm;\>w\\ ¢zxc.\.s w 'K\¥c. mask a\&g&).k\&§ ;mx_bmmzeh mem ` `f\\é»é
drum 0`€:5\_1\_\_1 @E

Y &\( £X.S

§_a\u.v\]$\‘_\§ ch¢x’i.».>\o..`\&~\?_ YE_Lm)"\ Q\_€Q mEN\o'

Q`Audum\ `dc\%_§ wm (`l\€.<\>€d A.S

?AKT gunn cm QL>~L¢.

\1>\" \'\-\e ?\.e¢\ {>`LAP\\';t-.cv\v;~om

wang comm §~\We UM.LL
Y>EF_¢ ~<\xc~_ Q\_\;Q z>\'-_¢\\_ mv misva T\AM

was `1\.4€_ O\&sm;\
09

‘Y\A€-_ gwme QV\€_S€»~H_~>L_.TO  w c>fr>?\_m¢\ms Q>Em»u
»W\E)GT.S. QF

x_& w vung C.ouo-

5<;@. ~A€Pewdiy emma-
_gxm&s £LF_§QMSF_ mt ¥. L»., A¢;>~_;

Mv\.~s.c_/>.m A§._;F_m umw ~mr=‘a_e umw ¢.>. (LEASM-

? V\M»c). Q>x\_r\‘t T H A'r
AQP€._M_ P lkfo? ev.\_~l

&>M’>.\.\"_ \»\Ab C_@u,¢os&t_ \_UL\,.AT& \&LS
`¥\¢¥\?_ rOL,\f("`E.D/\\& tDC'

Mr__s C.AS€ Caud_.d
O_~,r=r=.\\ drf$\&\u?_wr

\& 1>.\)@_

id.c.:d. ‘\4€'.
`{m

\_/\)`w_"> \“\7\1

x w cc_r_d due
C.\cu\..\»s&\__s

A¢TS !A¢\sl\ @mmis.§zg¢\>sf AW\_&LA.M

V\LL¢L\I<;L (>< “£o\\e¢>fn_ §r=_.ow&.~>c;€_ w cowest 10

r>\
15 \\L;»fk S'\-_,\>'\e.\>c_e we&LC_¢J¢ was mcfarww due

l ' Tc)
E_N \AANL\';N\';_.`)<`S.».

Q&¢>\\\ &?\
w\fxc_a_&?¢§u 9 U\Q mn 5 r._¢.
T\k¢>,r
"\ Vf&?l>‘\,t¢.¢\f¢'( K’P~M$
~rk&c_s \40.\>@?_»>\_"-_ C_. ‘L&\_l&(-
(A?V\_.T_ C_ m x_o.~\

w:u_ Cf>f?~¢w’< m_~\

~(A_&. 5'¥ writs Lr\l 915
Fok uslw .n(- \-\of%r=pfg C,¢)P.?\_A,S t,l.m"L.
v +L>
S\_Lofu<';b am _`3'_3~5_:\_;__ 'K‘A\’_. O?@

 

d fx“\ o F
Bwq‘»l$+

QAXS

/gm,u'.€. MD,b-]~¢,omev?::

dw /%%”L
£w\

C_EFCS'L‘¥ T_c_ maA

(\W\.T_L¢>Nx BRu.ce. Moer\-;,omw:y 4

w '?0 SUi a + \A evf\z¢%\l

deed Lr:_m-L<~~l mun 1913 \.\LS Recsmm_ 03

“\\4&_
E>'\ I><'\Y»_S R.E;SPQ,\\<,E_ -r¢,

A?V'\:Lr_uw,a \'~@L LA')R__»J of
»\efv>e@s comm wm was VL_»fc.;b 14 ~wfe mw_\_~
9>@>< en T\~k\‘»_ W\°LQ..>¢\)\‘-=LL_ \_J..\)r_r T.\>¢r.:'?_}> n¢\)'
Q¢;Lju$+ aZézi &OIS

`\0 ‘x\k§-_ L\_F_\LK or~ ~YM'_ C,oLL|LT
0§~ culmde /_WO&M_S.

€>"© ‘Y\A<_s ~Vuf€-_ Q(Q+L`

 

~'-l-\LLS__

 

\BK LLC€, Mor~\'\r\omm

dfw %§:

it
jaime lV\»,A+¢;.on/.mq i?oz~w-
l `\J
MCCOMM¢\\ uu\>d'

_\_;O°' 5a £‘v'v\;‘y _DIQ.

 

_ l
¥B€c\/)'He, "/; 78I0 ?_

(7\