Court Opinion

ID: 8915083
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-11-27 04:41:38.534115+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T17:08:54.204608
License: Public Domain

RICH, Judge,
concurring.
I find myself in agreement with the views expressed in Judge Nies’s concurring opinion as well as those in Chief Judge Markey’s majority opinion and therefore join both.
*112112 677 FEDERAL REPORTER, 2d SERIES UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS Former Fifth Circuit Cases (Section 9(1) of Public Law 96-452-October 14,1980) UNIT B DECISIONS WITHOUT PUBLISHED OPINIONS The following cases have been decided without formal opinion prepared for publication in the permanent law reports: Docket Title Number Blue Bird Body Co. v. N. L. R. B...............80-7703 Lynn v. Austin............80-7609 Empire 7 v. St. Paul Title . . 80-7437 Barkley-Cupit Enter, v. Equitable ..............80-7176 Date of Decision 4/22/82 4/30/82 5/ 4/82 Disposition ENFORCED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED 5/10/82 AFFIRMED Appeal from and Citation (if reported) N.L.R.B. M. D.Ga. N. D.Ga. N.D.Ga., 13 B.R. 86
*113DENIALS OF REHEARING EN BANC 113 UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS Fifth Circuit DENIALS OF REHEARING EN BANC (Rule 35 Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure; Local Fifth Circuit Rule 16) Group 1 — Denials where no member of the panel nor Judge in regular active service on the Court requested that the Court be polled on rehearing en banc. Group 2 — Denials after a poll requested by a member of the panel or a Circuit Judge in regular active service. Group 3 — Denials on the Court’s own motion after a poll requested by a member of the panel or a Circuit Judge in regular active service. Title Docket Number GROUP 1 Industrial Investment Development Corp. v. Mitsui Co., Ltd....................81-2175 O’Toole v. New York Life Ins. Co........80-3797 Smith v. Gonzales ....................80-3968 U. S. v. Dozier........................80-3927 U. S. v. Gunn.........................81-1230 U. S. v. Vela .........................81-2062 Date of Denial 5/ 5/82 4/29/82 4/26/82 5/13/82 4/19/82 4/29/82 Citation of Panel Decision S.D.Tex., 671 F.2d 876 E.D.La., 671 F.2d 913 M.D.La., 670 F.2d 522 M.D.La., 672 F.2d 531 W.D.Tex., 673 F.2d 1325 S.D.Tex., 673 F.2d 86
*114114 677 FEDERAL REPORTER, 2d SERIES UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS Fifth Circuit DECISIONS WITHOUT PUBLISHED OPINIONS The following cases have been decided without formal opinion prepared for publication in the permanent law reports: Docket Title Number * U. S. v. Rumery...........81-2430 * Western Casualty v. Evangeline Ph.................81-3201 * Western Casualty v. Meleton....................81-3617 * Western Casualty v. Evangeline Ph.................81-3670 * Christiansen v. Estelle .....82-1001 * Nichols v. Mid-Continent . . .81-4316 *t Hebert v. Fed. Intermediate Credit .................81-3500 Texas Eastern v. Garber Bros, Inc................80-3698 Date of Decision Disposition 4/19/82 AFFIRMED * Cotton v. Dallas-Postal Workers Union.......... * Garrett v. Dept, of Treasury * U. S. v. Escamilla ......... * Theall v. Regan ........... t Bennett v. Bakery......... t Matthews v. Federal Compress .................. * U. S. v. Bates............. f Carter v. Continental Oil Flanigan v. Webb ......... Woods v. Cook Industries, Inc..................... * Southwick v. Estelle....... Morris v. International Systems ................... f Barnes v. Guaranty Bank . . . Fisher v. Dillard Univ...... Fisher v. Dillard Univ ..... McCartney v. Hughley..... Fabsteel v. Mosher Steel ... U. S. v. Ideal Baking Co. . . . t Gulf Machine v. M/V Sharon................. t Sharon M/V.............. Brister v. Parish of Jefferson .................... Ralston Purina v. N. L. R. B. * U. S. v. Hemandez-Corona Dixon v. Henderson ....... 81-1407 81-4322 81-1465 81-3772 81-2385 81-A416 81-2448 81-3349 81-3422 81-3496 81-1439 81-2300 81-1342 81-3455 80- 3752 81- 1177 81-2247 81-3370 -3210 -3210 81-3504 81-4336 81-1142 80-3727 4/19/82 4/19/82 4/19/82 4/20/82 4/20/82 4/20/82 4/20/82 4/21/82 4/21/82 4/22/82 4/26/82 4/26/82 4/26/82 4/26/82 4/26/82 4/26/82 4/26/82 4/27/82 4/27/82 4/28/82 4/28/82 4/28/82 4/28/82 4/29/82 4/29/82 4/29/82 4/29/82 4/29/82 4/29/82 4/29/82 4/29/82 AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED IN PART AFFIRMED DISMISSED AFFIRMED DISMISSED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED DISMISSED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED DISMISSED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED REVERSED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED REMANDED ENFORCED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED Appeal from and Citation (if reported) E.D.Tex. W.D.La. W.D.La. W.D.La. N.D.Tex. S.D.Miss. E.D.La. E.D.La., 494 F.Supp. 832 N.D.Tex. M. S.P.B. W.D.Tex. W.D.La. S.D.Tex. N. D.Miss. E.D.Tex. W.D.La. W.D.La. E.D.La. N.D.Tex. S.D.Tex. N.D.Tex. E.D.La. E.D.La. N.D.Tex. E.D.Tex. M. D.La. E.D.La. E.D.La. E.D.La. N. L.R.B. W.D.Tex. E.D.La. * Fed.R.App.P. 34(a); 5th Cir. R. 18. f Local Rule 21 case.
*115DECISIONS WITHOUT PUBLISHED OPINIONS 115 DECISIONS WITHOUT PUBLISHED OPINIONS — Continued Title Docket Number * Ikesume v. McDermott.....81 t M. Shiels Hosp. v. U. S.....81 f Wells v. Egger............81 Hines v. Norman Industries ...................81 *t Hong Chang Hsu v. Allseas Maritime...............81 t U. S. v. Anderson .........81 * Wade v. Am. Bk. & Trust .. 81 Curtis v. Southwestern Newspapers .................81 * U. S. v. Young............81 * Waddell v. Stone & Webster ....................81 * Yates v. Maggio...........81 * U. S. v. Anderson .........81 * Mitchell v. Beaubouef......81 * Maxwell v. Estelle ........81 -2026 -1507 -2369 -3182 -2292 -2388 -1505 -1322 -1428 -3613 -3783 -2480 -3206 -1555 Date of Decision 5/ 3/82 5/ 3/82 5/ 5/82 Disposition VACATED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED 5/10/82 AFFIRMED 5/10/82 5/10/82 5/10/82 5/12/82 5/12/82 5/12/82 5/12/82 5/14/82 5/14/82 5/14/82 AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED Appeal from and Citation (if reported! S.D.Tex. N.D.Tex. S.D.Tex. E.D.La. S.D.Tex. E.D.Tex. N.D.Tex. N.D.Tex. N.D.Tex. M.D.La. E.D.La. E.D.Tex. M.D.La. W.D.Tex. * Fed.R.App.P. 34(a); 5th Cir. R. 18. t Local Rule 21 case.
*116116 677 FEDERAL REPORTER, 2d SERIES UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS Eleventh Circuit DECISIONS WITHOUT PUBLISHED OPINIONS The following cases have been decided without formal opinion prepared for publication in the permanent law reports: Docket Title Number * ** Menendez v. Wainwright . .81-5294 * ** U. S. v. Lynn .............81-5733 * Dailey v. Boykin ..........81-7505 ** U. S. v. Florian ...........81-5171 ** U. S. v. Schwartz .........81-5375 * Burks v. Veteran Administration .........81-7776 U. S. v. Pett ..............81-5267 * Oakley v. Credithrift of America ...............81-7813 ** Bahamas v. Commercial-Air ....................81-5516 Alvarez v. Wainwright ....81-5858 ** U. S. v. Piniero ...........80-5484 ** U. S. v. Menchero .........80-5530 * Scuirba v. Naval Air Rework................81-5779 * Apel v. Wainwright .......81-5795 * ** Dunn v. U. S.............81-7633 * Rushing v. Townshead ....81-7690 * Dollar v. Thomas .........81-7950 ** U. S. v. Archibong ........81-7501 ** U. S. v. Bloodworth .......81-5301 U.S.v. Paulk ............81-7478 * Story v. First Federal Savings................81-5820 * Kele v. Hanberry .........81-7744 * Hill v. Schweiker .........81-7980 * ** U. S. v. Little ............81-5092 * ** U. S. v. Ramos ...........81-5429 * U. S. v. Townsend ........81-5616 * Grace v. Wainwright ......81-5653 * Baecher v. I. N. S.........81-5980 Law v. I. R. S..............81-7334 * ** Craig v. Arrington ........81-7497 * Elder v. Connors Steel Co. 81-7743 U. S. v. McConnell ........81-7423 Martin v. Schweiker ......81-7299 * U. S. v. Pickle ............81-7825 * Genkinger v. F. A. A.......81-5001 Date of Decision 4/19/82 4/19/82 4/19/82 4/20/82 4/20/82 4/20/82 4/21/82 Disposition AFFIRMED AFFIRMED REVERSED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED 4/21/82 AFFIRMED 4/22/82 4/22/82 4/26/82 4/26/82 4/26/82 4/26/82 4/26/82 4/27/82 4/27/82 4/28/82 4/29/82 4/29/82 4/30/82 4/30/82 4/30/82 5/ 4/82 5/ 4/82 5/ 4/82 5/ 4/82 5/ 4/82 5/ 4/82 5/ 4/82 5/ 4/82 5/ 5/82 5/10/82 5/10/82 5/14/82 AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED REVERSED DISMISSED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED IN PART AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED REVERSED DISMISSED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED REVERSED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED VACATED REVERSED AFFIRMED AFFIRMED Appeal from and Citation fif reported^ M. D.Fla. N. D.FIa. S.D.Ala. S.D.Fla. M. D.Fla. N. D.Ga. N.D.FIa. N.D.Ga. S.D.Fla. M.D.Fla. S.D.Fla. S.D.Fla. M.D.Fla. M. D.Fla. N. D.Ala. N.D.Ala. M. D.Ga. N. D.Ga. M. D.Fla. S.D.Ga. S.D.Fla. N. D.Ga. N.D.Ala. N.D.FIa. S.D.Fla. M. D.Fla. N. D.FIa. I.N.S. D.Ga. N.D.Ala. N.D.Ala. N.D.Ga. N.D.Ala. N.D.Ala. F.A.A. * Fed.R.App.P. 34(a); 11th Cir. R. 23. ** Local Rule: 25 case.
*117DENIALS OF REHEARING EN BANC 117 UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS Eleventh Circuit DENIALS OF REHEARING EN BANC (Rule 35 Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure; Local Eleventh Circuit Rule 26) Group 1 — Denials where no member of the panel nor Judge in regular active service on the Court requested that the Court be polled on rehearing en banc. Group 2 — Denials after a poll requested by a member of the panel or a Circuit Judge in regular active service. Group 3 — Denials on the Court’s own motion after a poll requested by a member of the panel or a Circuit Judge in regular active service. Title GROUP 1 Buchanon v. Macon County Bd. of Ed. Chrysler Credit Corp. v. J. Truett Payne Co., Inc......................... Coastal Petroleum Co. v. American Cyanamid Co.................... Fowler v. U. S. Patent Office ........ J. Truett Payne Co., Inc. v. Chrysler Motors Corp..................... Mylar v. State of Alabama .......... N. L. R. B. v. Howard Johnson Co. .. . U. S. v. Brock ..................... U. S. v. Hobson .................... U. S. v. Patrick .................... Docket Number Date of Denial Citation of Panel Decision .81-7185 .77-2331 .81-6061 .81-5438 .77-2331 .81-7412 .81-7437 .80-5621 .82-5138 .81-5390 3/22/82 4/26/82 5/12/82 5/13/82 4/26/82 4/29/82 4/19/82 5/14/82 5/12/82 5/12/82 M. D.Ala., 670 F.2d 185 . N. D.Ala., 670 F.2d 575 N.D.Fla., 673 F.2d 1343 M.D.Fla., 673 F.2d 1343 N.D.Ala., 670 F.2d 575 N.D.Ala., 671 F.2d 1299 N.D.Ga., 671 F.2d 1383 S.D.Fla., 669 F.2d 655 . N.D.Fla., 672 F.2d 825 M.D.Fla., 673 F.2d 1343