Court Opinion

ID: 4077231
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 20:31:34.931101+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:23.965534
License: Public Domain

APPalaxe-tt               CUrleS L^EtAOirr T^cT-»tlAia45o
oH-15-ocoi^c.e.
 ^ ^                             (OAv^MxjtA r/
^,_         oi-gj£<l ..Z'(TjrUf-c/^                                 SiCv-15
         \~?^', "-tTU ArfPr\VQ-Te Cov^<^.-S c>^ As$Pe.Qj_6
                                                                 >2
                   35Q _i^Oio                                    -♦-i

                                                                 «^?t;

         fOl CL-'tAyTtv('A Ma^TlVvg.?'
              \7z?'^^. CUr\L             I ~Tui;?icl ^ (&ffiC£^\'on
                E/X 53^63
^JVVr _lLdb(o\^AS \4aS A 6i              V^-Vkr 5^^+ -to l4iW\ Arfer
                  Xn ArtA ^(^ueSuk^-Ljn^xir^-d£ aiT
 'J'l'MiL, "~fU- Lg,+f&r- X                                            J-
 _Cs^MT.. _G:eX_cv fej5pOA5^_oSL_Ar\^Ai~>^^i^m'^                    I'VliX
  uJWwA X M^sr A-i)')'/ OXl^<vv.x_/vLifor_-A(:>^,_t«X.^X^''^ A^
 --fiidy-AS           if 5<^'i—_A__.^A X*"
                      tU-^ E^Te^Ti Je-l'^<2p-rii^ rZio_cdi£^t£^lH
 2p_i3:-r7r.-i^^y>L. cA^rcer ^xXlfc Cfr-^--to r^'TA^iq,! ^£CS^ ^
 ,2gi^__A>^r'\'X,"^''Ve if^gx'ej- lOfOT^C), P5\:c^E^foiXLef_Arre3re-l> (Wl-
  Pla^-Ctc*^ oidMrr di^Ao A_^_KiT_t^KPto\ Xoi^^iyva.
 ^SXcrtAmJ-4'CX,_ 5W \ieA                                       lOoXa
 _bti^kl XU)<i3 r^VVMeiJeC.Ca.£rorre4.\KXL/
 Xi£e>           A?rer 5 lAnrwA^Si tEicWe-l Sjy?iVsS -rs jVo^j
                                                                    \X •
 -fW^ iNfp 1A Q\                                   b^^'crXi
 _cX;                              _lM^3iic^\X£i0kJx6 x/""Aoii
^Eb, •x^ceAuyttV^ yE?^^dxjR>4Ae._63
                                                                              I
  tk ^XVEaV X u-X)j^vEeXXXv^                              iQcK)X) Xwf.
        <feAfFkkLl>
               CMtC-A'ALF                                                  C'l'^rKTA rtWr^-VveJl.
'iyCT                                   ^                         '         bcP^TS           ^T)<-
   |\F?elWne4i- a-15'^^ ^               T'At\re i)eFcA^£r^                              5"i^53
                                            5«(«! «•'                       •SS.KteSfT''
        (p                   -O

                    •3(^£iy\^ -f-^T '^(Qus _bALUvJjQji2j\k5iFor
        ^Wosi ^ou.r6eiJ?\—kffe.LVcrre^to>|ici;A" lO'^fc-:HlciLc_t^ t^
        fW).       -VW            ot                                                 iXfc«
                   UfiJi|3 _u)i£<2>v3--3JE^r                          LKa_&;(s-_Qu£STioa *""5
        AW^'^L^OU. A/Vu^£j 5o *\As3l.v^s^- _L^0
         6c^aS_i:t-i-^ j^oo-r^oAom ^UA
        .Or                                   ^A^J^y^beAtiA^V^J^cAr-A=^o^ sxAerS^iM.
        a>.^o>X ^uAeif r\
         oo3a Lc^uA^^'^bA tv\jj-sr Olce^Ab^A_OL,^s_Q.l£sA^O^r;v^(L^
                           VOcwcr i'oA'coTBcxJ'UiJ-^i^-C^-Crti^rS^.G-tOe-^b .>^ci'a
         LLc^Ai^At A:o_fir^lL                                          t-si^F
  /-s"
         V^o-U<?^^ jou. [ACLOgrfo-tf^cA AiA-OAtk/J-kx^*xT!AjSvv2 \:\_0_y^_4t.O_H0u^^WrAlC
         A O.S, pF.i^evttt
         10u„cAv^v<\^LOn OF jVli^                  feevAA^ iA(AfA^eW:F->rr_ _{_^jAQc>^e.\Uv^
         CD A M^ ^ F                         vin. VlOUcTV       l-XLv..^^&rS_fSo---^ AUxT
    IL         1~U.^ -VUq i^leaS^tf-e
                       Be5i ^Msl r\r-k u^e-Ao v^Oq—
   -rW^-^.re, ffcfccieA-Fo. or A±_lga3i^rB^ijj^(;Jz)L^_^o.-T^
    C-^AAF^Oi^vFI^ioA-^P)^^ 4-ikore^
        \•caF-^.w^ccv iS L|6u^r ^CTu^^re ~ v>A^ \\ '^OAXc^j^V^ ^cacT "to
        c!)F AU2^Aci£T6 --C\riy.(-^y^rcor^_j^yv_i^AgLS^^         hAc^i/y
    ^^            _L-^rto.i'A5v..-^gi.My
     _U^l^ |?eC.S.k^oL3
                        13[ icT i W.J
   s: cxrui k ^Wo.T.^e.z_
      4tU KPPlcT^                            ^ L.MGro-<-^rr
                                     ' cucurieo _                          ^      1^
                                                 04-16-ocx.i^cj^
 .^mCcL.lO D^lJ.7—^^-1^;- |^Ae~r^ Lce>s +W^- V-W\ie Ccimc       a^xi
 ^•f^-yNiAZ&v ^c-ccuxT ^xTo.-^^-^ fivj £.Wniff_MnU /.
             VgL^ (a.aA            ^ic^w c:A±l.Q_.fm.^.-C>L-t"U- _.
  l.S&"^CC.       3o^'^.:^i4"^W A\'rr)
•-±W                       \ci„                                                 MtiD
0^<LLmk£-._^LAW5y^ -Hcct "H^s ^n^peA                                             _
OU^Q.^.                                                                         dk-
               Ora 6£fri-3^i3_&W'^i6LT^
        Co T_f^^pLx,x^er !.j J^t> |^o
 ^cx^ CJl- or^fe/—hUxrr
ftu~H/<> 3u.Acje_           'P'vA/VN-i/V /^rv ^^^\^                 \y\\

        „, -1---, !-•                             j^Mr6? "^t^xti Cs\t)'z^
^('5'' / f/V^w/ ~|Tb                                            ^v\>OiS^
 Xsi_^ Ccrrtei^_L5_A Coi/vvfcLAkTi-0^:*_Qii_6^fejS:S_&-^ ^ie
^75_£j^ga fe-^ci/.LAti^'-^er^)
'' bbAT Cm'sJ_cl Of^^.koo t
                        fcxSt ArLC.l<i^geA--^vsX..&-0?^_W^ '-|cufS
             Cos^AXxj .G5v..r:T.-S                  '-^^ji^_C^\JvCX $>6ruaOk^c.
        ~"Vk, OAz-omtov^.                     (AAQ, (c0^k^_CAv ]i^dc5A\r .
^jL5i.ST"_lj^^ l^ C£ orl^ ftkc^LC^jeS-__Oi^_J^A^^^^
 lb £^11^ A»a,Vv| 4-         \i;S. All.                                    T^
                                                       Ofu.;be.__V-iaS:>        S\Aoi\

'f K'fiU-T b^._O.r0S^VM^5f                                                     ^HV^
              UO^(&ycV)>) £>4^ f\VV<^Cgw\5                                         Woc
                                                      'A^iitE.vA.Ly LG2r_^K\<s\/v£-
                    feiV^ CWA^-eA-J^-^SD--
    lb (C-irVI       A                                 (vloTl ^lOX\i'br\
        ^                   77            tW<?(l^*"Ta±t: OH']5'OOat%'ClL            ^3/5
                           Loia'^v^LlsjAH—OA.
                                  Ci

               l\.OvjCX_-^ -ftcic^.u-j) vVy ]L\a-^4er A.Cp'-^^Ic
    .^Csu^rS                cl SrNj^ACLt-^^ryry -\n "Wi^ L|0a Sk? Tfi feiPcVr
                            oxxX__Aj^vrVv 2)                    iTQg.:^ XI lA'X_0'-vi ^ ?
    .                       ^                                        O'^rc- Si^ (WbT
    f\Aaj_ C^r_--VW ^ct_M^-cA_ 5JlJb/_E^4^                                               ot
    V i W ^ U f L ^ V - K b o o X "~tW.
              Lex _£xcc_0_£x±icL xblxCA CcLrs o ?ll\
Ca U5 -\VC\'^i\^                                   4        2"^ 13?                Lo.^;i:W-A
IPI.UlT                                                 fPu^r                  '      cxxv^^-ff
OA. K^6\i ^"S^3X\cj6^l

        Cr^c jgiH' 0> Tk A^Ctra/v ^cor^s U^AVC(vv'r^VAV"Yk^'^^ LkTV
                                        ^0ACy                             ' ts\6.iA0(LSn-^^i*^A
    ^>efejpc^cM:ty                                        V\o"^          "AA^^^Wxr*^ _
    oA-Ue .5rc^.i])?ec5^jdW.                                                      ' .
                         CtAXi^'bS £|(pMAV4AaXb!r> _                                E.e5f»CirV^-
            K J-r- K              Ar .A \A A<.\/n^l Ai./ l(l/!lJ A^>J ^U^^..^ ^\K ilOirOrM'Tl
                                                                                         ot^"

               -Vn               \SdCO \yj\^i-^:^A€_$Sro«rv                             ^   5

\H n vt|qvv a . i""*./^                .. C       ,._ _{A^1o26-Cca.^
'                    <^gT          ^ ^<djtSS ? ^tA/O                                              D
                 _                            _

              IV-W H^er -yU.              K_.0A
^ CM^TUiAi/^rx. Ae^
                                                          LHe^^cr             c^-3o-/5
           #\*v-nWo^^ 7^-2o5       A^/^e-|^T^o^-/5-ooo(S-CC
^ fOcSrjri^J!^.vS<Lf uji^ivv M^C)<-'^ Xvv                 '^qq^ ^re,
  u.'Sg. -yp -3^sr ^CofJ\| \v^-V\r^ 'ViBia/v5cn"pT5^ Cq^t T
  \^,gkA                  -^CaTCLvW -VW^^rocyW-^ LgT                               MO^
  OtAvv_J^V(^v'^AUC-r__-Pi                ^iLCcrj) T/x-tU, l^rO^CC
    A4^(0             ^615 Vix>A^ArW                         K\qoJ^'AV^'^ fb
                 {\4^Cfe.y\ fScyAtev "Vt^ ^Wal                                  lM~
                      ^                B'^eeA \DlAw^ I M30 Ai^ 3 {
   I r..v-rc\o.vc\                             Ho OM.ttciUf'P
  T\A^^_.\._\_^rS           Hs^tfVsp ^ ^^\sVej'\fe-fc.^V\>^ a^er 5Wxw~t) XAl^CifX
                                   '       •     -    '      -   .   -   -V

                      _                t A6u.a K ?f fb o^ Ab^xr
                                       Gn6u.aU            Ab^Xr 6/v
                                                                6# XkCT
    Al5t                  tk ^[c^T(^                      T K'
   .€oP_\e_l_l_^^
   XA.\S(ZS>TC^cXvc:j5x .^"S- fW] ^\Vi5.Xtf^ f^GT ^(W            *Sa.vWL
   ^           \XCj:>erCeA t^Xo-VU^                        TW 6c-)^ 6.
   _b|\ ce                   ^\^A _6^uiJ
                                VVcxa.T^'^ ^0^ Vwq^ ^\/^akXi6Ag^ ^
          ^1^ tG^o^-Ft\ tslb\iewx!p^2A^^/5 />! hAh-yM5
                                                                               o>r\fiyjiv^
   IA rk ^TcCTe^            37,n^-77/h /\Lu5eAo^'o^^\CA<^'rf^ /esT^rs
    /'^ -/A, fVi ly              Ta jfir/grT]^/ve-P -Xm
  -UOcA^To l^5GUoo^^:^f ibM^O^A_C_LLe^--idodi^ IX Alvl OJi (1 lY
                              ile^'Se. LtS^^OC Ei^K? ^SeaA^
   ~XWr             n^^cx^O ^          KoaH^              J^^rfyvQ^Vf^w^^tbttyy 3^
                                                           Kfet\/&AT V^ KCs^ ,T
                                        » / C U..C. S UAere^ i-r
          Ai^ -.T-yC                              04-|5-OO0/S'-CX.
                                                       ,0-oau,D-^                            —

_1vgj^\Me,      pAg^,                        ^0                             cx V\^'^Ver
         ^cyvV-S c^ l\ \ \ ^on                    rcxK^'-M ftfy ^     \-vU iKl\ 5^
f.A. i-t
              ^ ^•    -V   A      ki   /.— >iN       O
                                                          ASoO~T&i&L/ U\^
                                                           Ak\        • ^   ^ A I      I    K .   V

                     Qx\e^ Civ^Ao®r oelOMs v.               \fvr •'                                16
"^^ItsrrCcT Oert^ o^rce^HrWv Vto(^Ag-Wx^> AcUcxMb
 _                   '40^sfi)e^x
                           je£^V aVl
                                 ULVV -He.Tiles
                                         . _i, I             AYkVsi^vXecev\\Oy\

                     &ejV>a__O^Ap OuIi"^__.U^rk|?.                                  Afct-'
HSd AV|-CUc<^AgT^/^(DoMi'l i^-/ M. Ca(.C io^MlJ                                                   ^>c> o/\
         —w— „ _/\]/ 6> y7?S /1 ICq_                           . >Vi "^cLssd l-^r^
^;X> /1/lujCk JIy\fr^ AJ'Ce.                               A/v^      (^
   Lcxuoojt^<, LpU^                                      .3X^(1 C9^T_6'Ad 6/\iL
kJ             ft5_i^cjv. LaL) Error A-s iKiVve,, (4a\y^
                                              <^6u.r Af^kflaTg,
 6r.^fel_.&_j;
                                V:^rT_4or                      T\o_.\6_^_::^y/
     •               ^          ^'^V'bo SoX^cr-e^^ _Wv^                                       /Vv<^^
.y£>\x            ~VW- t 6i^^e,G^cat ~C-'OxSV^ ^(.Aywi/tf^vY" ^W5r or
     SV/ecrgMox-y VW) C'rfr.Ag^       Lc^er U0<xrJ^'fxV5 ^
                                          X_o^tk\yj^^e.r v^vie.
*:SbVo. or_
dcf^eor                        CoP5                  bei>_-v6£.-                           £,eixV
          ^                               L.^\WY ivVW ^rsveg-
                                                         _"_OA.-Mc                                    ^

                                                          -1
                                                               £>LeC

                                                                                           I'Ck^Ics /jkt^tr
                       OA\5y^cT^ !^E.C\araTiO^
                                    \g^ if\ CW'eH^OCV
                                   \315y2,o
                                >er4±: iD \^ja'tiSk kk _
CA^5e_ji^                            A0I3 Ck 10,I
                                                   CJL

                          _CLade5>_CteEi.ULii^rC^UvrcKT l*^
                                              rACorTe^t^/) __6^ "H^
                                                              Be-k^r;
                     JTI 5-_yCDAxhBoC^
                           ^K0i!v3ark_;rk_7rj-^-bi. __
                                        ^ Pfc-rTur^^TU-
                    du-bLCjaL tC)6Ii.kLd3:lCinJ (BJTK_S^rlVr
                               feTlO>i^S,'TaViUaLtC!i5T'tftCATi Qr^S
                               UrTTer-s
                     o&ce. dr jH^J^Br£iCr^CJ^
                     (\AB|AiKAcy of  Co.'TBI^ciSi .' /A^b of
                                     i_Q5BRE_Cr__nr\()mGrS.
-

               iM

           .

    '-'O
               to
                1         o
                          -I"

g5 a
iu,-<
                          Ui
                          s
               u*         4^
           -P

                (r
                (p
                h
                (P
                O
                o
                m
                0
                (M
                iD
                r-

                11

      a

CO

      ^%
o    •n