Court Opinion

ID: 4054015
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 04:41:21.913154+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:29.518963
License: Public Domain

6trf>rwL somm

Plmte ammP dUE j nt£ -/Tits /£$<*<£ /y^/v -r%£ A&&>/&&nr

                            COURTOF C®m>ML APPEALS
                                 APR 08 201
                                             - £. £. A, A/d>! U)£r8X ~<?0{<-o/

A/0" IS10332 (U>c&e£Ar7L.y /A/tUh&°£&4^z*' A^r^Ffer UJ/6<U#ryn g,
 /Vl£&A//Vi^£ Uaa/T 300{'5<&n//.ya6e, A&mrte; yzrxzhz ip/ox .

XT /£ ^y/^AfzrSls //Usri6l<r Ak<Uc^7- ~F%a^t -7^1/^ &®vz>/Z46£r

A.hl/^/hlOF^ AhnrJ'tf/Tlhrt^A^" AtSO /2tOF 4~7, / tfrL.J*es-m»j
 OP/AFOAJfi) iC&ujer OF'ArifaM& Ce&m/AJ&t. &euer or Arfk&£^)
/mi>sr Aa^tJ d&istj/v uj/e/m^j />j0/ss/au_ ~r%/hr~ /s Af/^t a^s xs
n^MX/dA^F, rTi/^Attdfessss A?^y i*>$M*r /£a^s£&/ /bu^

                                  jf.
f<UU£ *£}, 2 * D/sr3l6MA?10AJ Afifid<2/eA//tf9 OF £>frX//0A>Q5) —
FAfZrf£//>A>T7/a3 JUtlgESl

 4p2/ AryU/TZO/0, jzzkcJi OF//u/OAJy/^^mo^AtM^^ri DF>//v/0/v>/a/<3&#i/M4t
 (¥££&> AUjsr&aie AApTXr&Aj ^/teAsA**/ of *loA*rr'/4s4u:ts4 "43-
itenstoniNtdj be&fe ^F/aj/oaj z* A/tobteJ<4e*tMJ ~ Ay* /nAdo&ry
OF-THE JUSTING) Whd) Akm&//>Af2zM /a/ &n>S£*&&frUM>> 0F'T^CAe^
The. toutrpptanaac Mats aw ATAwyrFvF ojU*f tz*f a
                                 •JOE,
£idF 48.2 tetdmoA/Al ZsciPiiZAfm /toe&/H//i/A£ jS&E&i

                                         ©
                                          T2~

    fartMM (&Utigf Fwnou Chm&A&) Pof faj Bmjc fi&to&te-
   fckiWAh FPnai foa&r oP PLFa/yiaaafL APfente dAtyv/^/ ^ks~r77m^y
   TrUdAimDh) FoAi t&AzAF/AO //?FC0Af5'idFFATTOAj\
  7hi4 ^duPT/Uc<, PA^uAfZV Avu&Zj -rheA&s Bp^jcz <g>aFr alaty tvirt/
   h rrhatr Mim&j/o&teX- £&a*/T£aj Banc fecewritttew&v,
   J2F A /ft&AO£JTV QPA&&S '&Z0/U&tefe&FO€K) j AFAJAt£!% JuJ&nfruT <&F
   ®&m& /)/*#<> AYpr htrt&ME ff/U£C 4 T^r- stJhse: Mcs&L Sat A^aSmnwd

  fiuJjr *rz.a AMtor A<omP/A/flrr APfifr£A*rn&A&L   ?
  GOUAT'OP A&M/A/dL /&>/%&££ /HATV d/<5/rt/SS An) AFF//^^T73AJ 'TZ&T
  dc&z> A/OT C&rnFLV iajtTh iThz^/ZoU^ ?
                                   JZT,
 tLOt 77 _0P/M(MK*i

-2T/iy /nc^Jn />jL*&r 77iAhr is AFgtted OF ga&Aitm&l 72 &&FF&F

<3grr2AJC3 M/2F^ -rfer'&&s0/rf&Ate/as ati=&s/jAjyhu^A7uy^sz>n*w^
 rpizrf&iAr, AwYJudge aifv FsAr Aai/fFa/iaaaa/^as^pz^/u^ /&*,* &,e
(m/du&W\& 7?l£ &aFi3 Gthv/OAJ,
&il£ 1$,/ TVfe <0F J)ud4/V\en)T~ ^^/2T aF ^An/m^j^^AL^^n^L \
  "X AFF/&A) /otsO&Z d^uFT-S JtAd3AA&uTA/iA Ao/wlF OF/Af A%PT~j
 )< AKb&IFV'/a>m£& C&m^ -JuAamarTj APR/ZAn^d /T A3 AAlGd/AAAEzzF
 KF£U£PS£ foufir Jad3/rmrr aat H^hoAF o/t/ki^Fj FA^u^kFJudEm^rn
f^b^ £&**>&£ Ccu#rShould aiMAF A£wd£=72&d;
<M FFU&fSA? AftVZAl FeUFT'Sud&n&ATAfryrf'/&=7n/fr%J &teAT Fpf
fe)/ \MdAi£ Judemtzur oF'/oi<o££ tf&tAtfrAaaf?^asmiss F&zFJ
£ft) VA€M£ /otvizz £m*F£5 Ju^h/yiA^ur Ated A&AwAhnAd F*&5£- F%>F
  ^PuAzrtiFtl A/Zo£&EdAA'0$ aaia AMr 0A^^Aaa/^5 yytyy^zJ i

                          AwdtuSML
'this WtoOMfoU' Cmutlt TonuO/ lAWfed FXA%et£l5 /^^sr F>F
Wmoajs; Mliawmii J^d&rt\T?Dffj5* -Thus teuprdidAimJgvzF
 cm)it=d tWFioro Tbd &fmvus /^a>A}6}c^eAr7DAj Awd £7/a£ sfeu&i
&CO>pdAM£ \Atefh 5TlwdAteds ®P FPPF^AHF FpAsdu&A F*s*A

^&£FPb(ZE, FAfMZTE IS 2lV&0*JUQ-&rtep" DP77DAJ L^r~lV feteeST
*&haMA#)aP A^^/d^nf^A^^a^ A^d AmAA). AhtA^F jA^am
1%&fo&MM& :£h4xOd FacAAtZaF h£ JFAJ/£=?/; AWAW Yh AS &u*M6&
3D JZ AYI&f AA*Pj&L~TM£S /SSAtF ~TZ> *77iF JkAA&rk£ dtuyer 0f*

£yPf&te $/Qowa)> avoiaj famFS B^ftae:-?%££- a$a>vi/a/try AL&d, TZcs
UvFdMt/£ GDOfiTi lAu'faaeg; FU A^mis^s ynAwAF &/vstd4=FA*d yhfet
Pf^/U^>T <PhiS ^AADMhlF (%>aFr <sA^6 &Fm£T AteC/4*f4e£5m=*d
Af^mS A\tAA ASSOFS /fegSA&lAAZsd' £)c?%FFF%£Z?.
UPoaJ fecMsvbs&aW/O OF a%>uF*5 Fau 3ftj~c^ A%ts 4/t>AvdA2sl4Ac
d&UFfAVlfn AWA^r/AhAtfF A^6 CJWtAt&ZO&S A&Ff*<3*7iFFAv&AA3 /Hr&
&rmvd YhF /oAtfeF douFr 7& SAzT-^sttdF a^>fcac£^f>f F?ud
F&NH3KJCE Atfd £$Fl\JT tAPA&sfF A AAFAO T^OC OA/ VhF /K&^-ns 0A
AiS CA^£ AlfeZ&UThd TE> *fhi&,
Xa/ &tFfflmi7ti£*fhAr byA&faf ii0m/A/ ymv^F GafriAffrzA a
typAt'FttMlOri A>PA^S^ /AMUu4tect'0flfe&SE U/Afh. ilj fesS£F
'AtMSh//m/T MfcHbF /NeAujUed*     J&A<*FF> yftF£&<d f
                                      f\^5A&zrMtMF ^uAm/rT^d)

tMiatdao-fhigJiLdfri op'A^ac_ •-/i/iK £m^-a^pt
<&&                                       Ai^AAAFr7£y&5    Woz.
'            ...     TA/AYiMF^JAttSkm
JT) £R\? T, ^ W . 71 0+&3** - £eX\ o ArtsJtr?Ox&i* As&dV
    Al /AJAhA/A/pKf UN/rr 3001 ^tzmiAFatF. /$B£irtO£> 7£*ykS n#U>Zr
X &tPAfa=fi. dFCl*4F£ "AAAlAAfeF FM ~A&1**6 Afrud A^TuAAaTJ^S A>/& /£f*UA*i
OP'iTug £T7tf£ FhfiAT AML Pfr&c5 Ffifd'^FAAh^rT^\j-rS A?eAr~<?F^yfasd
    C&PA2&T ~tt>Fh£ b&T0P/y>'/ ktAKsOfedgE >Jb /lAttF/Wir <^W *

                                                     <^^C-
                                               FFiL X~c A3F&UJAJ
                                               ~&tSr70'53JL
                                                Ah^A&sVAy&FA- £aa/at~
V^     , •l^f-    .-. '    .                      3C&A Sc&VAtye/F
&/FCwtm GAl Hkts Jz&dFi OFAzMzF                   "&££3a>AAF, 7Fx&5 7PAd2_

                                     9