Court Opinion

ID: 5119380
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2021-10-19 16:19:12.905506+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:22:12.212317
License: Public Domain

FILED
                                                               OCTOBER 19, 2021
                                                           In the Office of the Clerk of Court
                                                          WA State Court of Appeals, Division III

         IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON
                            DIVISION THREE

In the Matter of the Personal Restraint of:   )        No. 38134-0-III
                                              )
                                              )
DAVID D. MCCONVILLE,                          )        UNPUBLISHED OPINION
                                              )
                     Petitioner.              )

       LAWRENCE-BERREY, J. — David McConville seeks relief from personal restraint

imposed for his 2017 Klickitat County conviction for felony bail jumping. Specifically,

Mr. McConville requests resentencing and recalculation of his offender score to exclude

points derived from three prior out-of-state convictions for unlawful possession of a

controlled substance. The State concedes. This court accepts the State’s concession.

       In State v. Blake, the Supreme Court held that Washington’s strict liability drug

possession statute, former RCW 69.50.4013(1) (2017), violated state and federal due

process clauses and was therefore void. 197 Wn.2d 170, 182-83, 186, 481 P.3d 521

(2021). The Supreme Court did not specify whether its ruling applies to cases that were

already final. But, established precedent counsels that Blake applies to such cases.
No. 38134-0-III
PRP of McConville

       In a personal restraint petition, this court cannot grant relief when the petition is

filed more than one year after the judgment became final unless the sentence is invalid on

its face, the trial court lacked competent jurisdiction, or the petition is based solely on one

or more of the exceptions set forth in RCW 10.73.100(1)-(6). Mr. McConville’s petition

fits within the facial invalidity exception to RCW 10.73.090(1).

       For a claim to fit within this exception, the alleged error must be apparent on the

face of the documents signed as a part of the sentence and any plea agreement. In re

Pers. Restraint of Stoudmire, 141 Wn.2d 342, 353, 5 P.3d 1240 (2000). Because the

former possession statute is void, there is no relevant Washington crime for Mr.

McConville’s out-of-state convictions to be compared to under RCW 9.94A.525(3). If an

out-of-state conviction has no Washington corollary, the sentencing court may not

include that conviction in the defendant’s offender score. State v. Howard, 15 Wn. App.

2d 725, 732, 476 P.3d 1087 (2020), review denied, 197 Wn.2d 1006, 483 P.3d 783

(2021). Because this court need not look any further than the face of Mr. McConville’s

judgment and sentence to determine that his offender score is erroneous, his judgment

and sentence is facially invalid and his petition is exempt from the time bar. RCW

10.73.090(1). Because an incorrect offender score is a fundamental defect that inherently

results in a miscarriage of justice, Mr. McConville is entitled to resentencing. In re Pers.

Restraint of Goodwin, 146 Wn.2d 861, 868-69, 50 P.3d 618 (2002).

                                              2
No. 38134-0-111
PRP ofMcConville

       Mr. McConville's petition is granted. The matter is remanded to the trial court for

resentencing in accordance with Blake. RAP 16.4(a).

       A majority of the panel has determined this opinion will not be printed in the

Washington Appellate Reports, but it will be filed for public record pursuant to

RCW 2.06.040.

                                             Lawrence-Berrey, J.             \
                                                                                 j

WE CONCUR:

Siddoway, A.CJ.

Fearing, J.        >

                                            3