Court Opinion

ID: 4139643
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2017-02-18 02:49:53.337761+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:21:56.745545
License: Public Domain

Honorable Maureen Moore, Commissioner
Bureau of Labor Statistics
Austin, Texas

Dear Mrs. Moore:            Opinion No. O-6671

                            Re:   Authority of owner
                            _     or manager of res-
                                  taurant or cafe to
                                  deduct "walkout
                                  slips" from waitress'
                                  pay check.

          Your request this department's   opinion on
the following fact situation:

           "It has been called to our attention that
     several cafes and restaurants throughout the
     state are holding their employees liable for
     non-payment of customers checks - i. e. The
     waitress serves a customer his food and gives
     the customer his guest check, but the customer
     instead of going to the cashier and paying same
     simply walks out.

          "Under Articles 5155 et seq., Revised
     Civil Statutes, makes it the duty of each em-
     ployer to pay its employee the wages arranged
     by him or her as often as semi-monthly.

          nUnder the law can the owner or manager
     of the testaurant or cafe deduct these walkout
     slips from the waitress' pay check?

          The Texas Semi-Monthly Pay Day Law, Articles
5155, et seq., V.A.C.S., 1925, as amended, requires,
among others, a mercantile establishment or any corpora-
tion "employing one or more persons . . . . to pay each
Honorable Maureen Moore, Page 2

of its employees the wages'earned by him or her as often
as semi-monthly" and provides that those employers "wil-
fully failing or refusing to pay the wages of any employee
at the time and in the manner provided in this Statute
shall forfeit to the State of Texas the sum of Fifty
($50.00) Dollars for each and every such failure or re-
fusal".   (Article 5157)

          A restaurant or cafe has been construed to be
a mercantile establishment.  Craig v. Bourdouris, 241
Ill. App. 329.

          No citation of authority is necessary to sus-
tain our opinion that the phrase "wages earned by employee"
means the agreed or contract price promised by the em-
ployer to pay the employee.  It means the entire sum.

            Provision for forfeiture or deduction, if
reasonable, are binding upon the employee.     "The validity
of provisions for deductions or forfeitures depends upon
their reasonableness.     If unreasonable or oppressive, they
will not be enforced." 39 C. 3. 163, Sec. 223.      "Deductions
from an employee's wages may be made to cover losses occas-
ioned by his negligence or want of skill, but not for losses
due to causes over which the employee may not, however, be
penalized for violation of a rule which he does not know
of and which he has not contracted to observe."      35 Am. Jur.
503,  Sec.  228.   "A provision in a contract of employment that
wages shall be forfeited in whole or in part for a violation
of rules is, in the absence of statute, valid and enforce-
able.    35 Am. Jur. 504. Texas has no statute regulation
such matters in contracts of employment.

           In view of the foregoing general rules of law,
we are of the opinion that an employer and a waitress em-
ployee may enter into a valid contract whereby the employer
is authorized to deduct from her salary or wages the amount
represented by customers' checks issued by her and not paid.
In the absence of such contract, the waitress would not be
liable for such checks, and the amount thereof could not be
deducted from her wages or salary.
                                        Yours very truly
 APPROVED MAY 7 1946                AlTrmEY GBNERALOF TEXAS

 /s/ Carlos C. Ashley
                                     /s/
                                     ,     Arthur L. Moller
    FIRST ASSISTANT                        Assistant
    ATTORNEY GENERAL
 ALM:ms                     This opinion
                            consider&and
                            approvedin
                               limited
                            conference