Court Opinion

ID: 4051862
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:48:46.991584+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:53:43.185578
License: Public Domain

10_§ 1103 ~ 01
§ECE!VED' lN

©OURTOFCEMWH App ¢_S
001`€!;111\!\€1§ \O \»\11\@w\ _\_1 (V\a,k\ (_@nwmf SEP Q3Zm§ EA
1_. L\ wm
Q©C>@\A11Q 1\€_01\&\1(“&\1\

~1»1»0_ C£LLL£.L 1\)0. 7_©\¢1 F’CI>\C{@> `IAA\_».N\
~\r© C._ C1\ \/A E.AL/O\r\ but f` §\-(,L§r£__) XLQJ' \.>a; O°>Z>C`_>E>`Y&’) Q._\ xc>
k<\r\q 10 111LC111-1€,1/\110\ ;§ 111 \vla_§\ C@._».r>‘v 1111111 ¢_,~_>o.L§eo/\
1b 010@<;111 mut C_co§()_ ’\'Y\ch;g¢vL cm 3111 733 1015 §11€111111
1-'1&1/\A1\1\C ~C`\ 14£101_ g

, \1\<> S.L `\\1®1¢\¢& @Q @QD€Q_& 1a CL._&S CQ_m\v\/
§`1\:> 11\\;1~ 11&1~1\ :QW\KL &\\Bcr$~¥:or\ \r\ 1151\; c_\'\

01 vag@z><\w_ §\@11/1€\ 11

A_ \<\&1)& (\®

, 11 m wm (\&Le_`oac§<
0111;1 111 ». ®<\ 3111 §\,')_@\5 §&Q@\Azw_\§ \1@1\111»¢ 511 01

(\o CM".`\@€\ 1b \X\L \\1@(\0@11¢1\&:11@1¢\& QA\\\ w\\ \1@¢~ Cu\a& O..%\,<, 11 xv
1111 1111 011 111\1\/ 11

§11L C)m_p$\ Q®N)ch QS\ 11
"mva§@\e; :1,11@\<.>__ @Q 1111_

B"\§vr\a.\v C_®w S`m
:(\:L: bX_L:_A\_ `\XIS\R:L\\ 1955 LC>UJ\*)/ \&>c&:> 1111\@~&

re ®J\LL

…§§e§\ §,:;\m \:\3:;:‘_@1\1§€_\& vaz@@<\g¢ Q<\@M 111_
csa

\a£> \za£r\ \\ 1061 CL.LA Q¢\QA
1\@.&¢<&1§ 11_/1015 L_,L\®u_§(i k:£i/\_Q_ Q.s'\& ®Q
¥1/1\.;: 1313 610>1§ 1-¢> 1111

1\01-@_0€&@0@@_9. \ e_!\L, user ue~r\l.l
1111111 1111 & 11 " LSL

10 Y\ <\/1@1 C_QL§>L ew\c,\ 1 11@1_11€1
C1/u§:11Q\W\L :1¢$:\ \_§1;1;1_110
\111>'>&1111011/\1111

\’\ \/\/\E\OL,LC\L ML\ 1\`1€`(1\11 1-€>
10111 110¢~ ‘~1©111`1-1\\/111_ 0._1\£1 0_®\\1%\¢11/"@11\@1 1\\ 111&
f\/\HMM 1111/111111)

‘ 511 d
11 11 11 111 111@\5. 13:1%1%1:1::&
0 ?>Q\L 1?>©
L`\ 1\£1.0_1/\ /T_€.sc£¢i `75`3`(@:5

CQ§UL§W§§ LM§DL\§§\DW\ 1§ §\/§u\§ §§_N\Le.…`.

mem (L§U§§ §§\\`§3 (_\,§&§§ 1 §e_r\€§ §/§\F; SLLC>N;§ \\<>§QV§ cr:l%e§@ §§\@v
§uc,§§ §§\.u§' &L… ()Lr\ \r\(`_®(\{\€_{_`§~ Q<;§A\a§§ §<> §/§»L C¢_>LAV§ 0§) §¥Qpea§§ C../\O§
\§ \A§(§§ W§L §;C~§§K. §§L§ u)`§§¢ir\ §§\F> v\z>§-o\§\`~ox `X_L,\\@§.l§a§ §§/~L. §»L> §§Mc\¢'\ \e>
l§\L (§§§J¢'\,§§o\\ o§ w§\mv\ §§ Mw§ CD(\CLM\ T§§U§:_ \/\(M>L (\<>§ (\e(_e.zw¢c§;
§zorrv\ C)§ (}V\§b§ §\f_:)§)of\§€__ -§}v\ow\ §§AL §§'\;§rc,§ (§Lc~§./\ §§ §c §/§\¢ \>C\o §e__
0§: §§§>§§’_0.§. §_M LA§Q_§§ O\\»~`)@L\“€__ §/§/m.§v §\/\.Q (\o\ (_O_ @Q~ Q@P&Q,§ \NL._.;§\'

m§
§>L`:N§D §<> §/§u_ U)H\Lc§ L…Mur§ 0 §§§§Me¢.§; T_`m; gw§ §/§1 ;\EL§‘§L 01 \\@§u§w\
L\L§?§`&‘.:§\c\a\ §§AL \§/§m.§>§€j‘ ,L§€_§ (\4> M@OA§L \; O\§\)G_f\ §§0(\0¢\0.»§1\!; 'Tc\\p_§l§\,._c§§\.L

§0\1§§1: §1:§§§01§£:)& \\D§RLLQ 0 \\1\“§ w %>¢\B &Q§§u\§ OA LA>F_LL ®v\ &\¢c_p_ LM\O\
‘WLM\;§ 1 J\\o §\LL \)@\o§ cl c§ 13 3@§\\1 C;>QQ.M\~\

u§) ()\Q. w\ 010¢`§\@\ (}>v\ §\LF\L. T_- \’\P.P_L§ SQ(\\L §¢>.ov\ 0’ \<\L\Q Qa><\ § Ovc\

§\\§§§ wb§ @v (`_DN\M§§`\O{\ ‘§D\/\Q 0\'\ `\\\ §».\ :m&LL §owr\ T\\x 5

f\c>§ §§AL §`\¢\é\' §§~u_ §§\m§< 1 §\M §;L¢>,/\ m>c\@r\q§»\ Lc>(\¢§a,§¢[§.`¥*\\c__

§50§§ U>f\\)\a,§ or\ _\_ wong ©§\05@_@1§§20\ \Q\\ \Mv\ §>§@@@\ Cpu§>\r\ \c\ LA\§\`c-/§\
T_ §§§0_(§ O.\\ §§ m §§a/§ §§ web r§c;<\ ec§ Q§LLL §<> <\xL 5‘>`\@\¢\` r\¢\ §;>¢\ §/§1_ §/\Mp_
;/_m§ M>§ Cu§§u wave_ §§ §§1 §ah) `5_ mw §§@@1 _> u>§¢r\ 1 QM\U_ §QM§¢
§§> §§u; §ow/\ OLM§ w§\e~§ §\@§ §.¢/J§A_L\ Q§LL@_Q_ \§ 01 §\QL \QQL§ OCH>.§@V§¢,§~¢{\.
§_ §\MQL ~§/§\o_. D_U§AP_N;L oQ §){\<>(>Q/ _§\\~ §§\L C_D§\f\<,<_?§`or\ § §_\L\§o<\d'\ U(\@c::§'m~ée.
§§\L {‘§%§§§ \§@ Qj§§)€a§§ Ovvw§ W\L§M §§/\L,§o,@ §§L L;)w»§ a§>Oc> \§eg§ C@U»s@\ wax §§

C_@v»/\?§L§e_§ \§ c§u;§~§. l&M /\ LMAP§ a§eQ,\r\&::c§/§§) §\a§l> 1 g§o (\0§ wcw§§ §¢ BL§ §@;§` r\
6

§§u)_ §§§5§@,1/\\ §>LLLLu§€__ 1 mv\ &MJQM_ §/§;w (‘_a>N\uP§§ <>f\ QD,.,§(§<' L§@u @§Ma_ c§<\@<~_,§ ML

m§é@§aa_ k:/\M:§L (;§C@L:jr\$z:fu)u§;§aj cwa §§¢Q§L L§L¢L §§Q_ mmi a./\A ij a\c»'\ §§ \\S
ms D w U» w m Lc>\L\ v @@\¢\@» f\\¢§M§ §§U<§»\/ M¢
§`_DM§`\§Q,§\DM§ §`§§§\§§ §\.w}§’_ §§L€_I\ l)§ §D§D,§§m§§ §/<> §/§\s_ QM&\§LS§ At&@\i\c;£,.` K_`/v\ J\o§ I\Q;@_`\um&
0§§§§§ {\L_€>§§onsl). CN)M §/§/\L loss CDWQ';§~/ §§\e§w‘;§ CDUr~§ 5§§\.:&1@§1,¢@\§ BLS§ §i.»~c,§\kw§§
\§m §Dr L§ow §§rvu_ ‘.‘\ &0§@@.:/\&£_ w\‘§§\, _ m»§ §(§_uw\w,§ %'§\§Lka§§cf\

T§w_d §§u_ 50 c§w§o§) §wqué§ 1015 Q\MAQ“§(J)DS]:“ME

90 ?_\<5>< \%©
§_§AC§LLVL/ \&~[0§&755@