Court Opinion

ID: 4056389
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:50:45.525463+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:06.383012
License: Public Domain

Co wz:-r oF c_ tun rJJ AL                    1\l'Pt:l>it.s
                                                                                                            10 c9L/
                                                                                                               _
                                          Atu-r I      )\1   J   IE>< f-\_s                  zs   I   lfl
                                                                               RECEIVED IN
                                                                      COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
 NL-r \-tll n      t l\ v:cD to \LJ e                                           SEP 10 2015
     l-~u C. H'E -~ LL N J:T, ·- 1 \) i f Ia ~ CJJ So
     rtr- Z . Da x 'il£00
     L A"i'2J VILLE             /ifXA_s 7tSVJl

     Tll:   kftr t+un     D1\VID LD iJ£:
      L t_ t\ 1\/D. JAJ rz_ ;-LSI b-:; 1-21
     TY2rAL Cou I'Ll        w  LtJ ~ No. t S1 J fb--

            btav }\btl J\ co__s +~ ,
                                  ( C..C I\L C\tvk,
                _I. orv1 kJY'; i ~nLj
                                 you you v (}~t\c_e... C\tV'r. , C6uv+ o1
                                                   J

Cvi tv\~ n.). I 1\poo \s, f h -1-h'<- dbovJ-e.- tApturt...d CdlJ Je hu Ml:x:v.
 '                          l
 c MOI..ffiN    Foa_ "l£f:\\Je. -ra t:="J: L1::. Wrl.:LI ClF h~ND~Mll.s.)
    ...1 f'tCe\ve_~ you~ 'No\J:Cf.)llo+i'f,'~q M~ ~~+~t GJuv+"_c.
 d LL_~ s ~a h .l DfLliED Iilli Hou-r ore D87..)
      f\l+hDuq h ~t ·~__r bty.or'\d/ ~h-~s L1u v-i CJ~ L:v-~n~Y\~l ~~pe.J\_s
 d cf I a h J '1r1 r '()) ElJ YJ]J C ~· hrriO h;t 'F6'1?. L€1\V E -ro F.1 LE lurlrt Dr
                        1
 h~I\JD~MUS-'                                                                            ·

        1\.' )A)t.l\ ~s,           hy t~M;Iy
                                   hcrt bt1h4 dbl~ +Cl undev_s+c~hJ
~he f\tfl<)rl ·fdlt.,h . [~eN Y~ NC 10 f'1(.YILDW- ltJl1rl J Bt.\hy th.i_s
 L_ou~i -~ J IJexy; M-uth J1tJ~ rt- ~~h~-t ~h-e. tr-1e\ 1 liJuv-f, Dh A·~rd
21 ~ 2() 1Lj rbrc~ N1elJJ hy tvl01Jl) )J) uriLJZJ~t//eb "1Hi. "'Su tC n8J1
                 I                            t

AN I) JE:N1ENC~, ~voM ~h-t..                      Orl ~;-hc\l tqve..~ ious tnfv) of trr
br:.~rz..a ACC.(!_t\\JA/6D kJ.A)Nf-\f>f.INt. LU~rleii                            r-roJ       2Nb "Df6rztE
                                                                                    This document contains some
                                                                                    pages ~hat are of poor quality
                                                                                    at the t1me of imaging.
         ~CG Q)\\1 A-r[\) \(IJ'J Na>(Y\PI,NC - ru~ Le~,s B YJT t:--riM 1:-~ ~ 3P\fE-
         p·LAC2.
                \--\ c:\ \1 ~ h    4d      Con-Jt ~fui ~ uh YLJq hi 1 -to h~vL +h~ J' ~hfmu
 -to bt.. ..S"t-v-vre. J.                lo h.:\\Jt.. -~he.- fL-J-thfehc.ln o i-h 6be_h couv-'f           I

 Dr~ I\~ \)rO()DunGLJ ·In 9ru'e-hc.L .lt'x' .CoDE (i7.DJ .Pf2.1)c AuV. ~Z.Ql.;
5e_L . .1 ~ \ Lvtr~oh Ju9p. La 1t.-J) ,· 1 ex, fEI\1·1\· L co be A f-J)J, Jel. li:J. o"7 Lb) [vcv-
  hDh 1193), PDYnt:Jv Jf~fufc. b-e;hCj J?~l,'ublt- -to ~h;J' in.ffJhf cJ~c.c
LE::X -~l?lJl\LUD( 11Z.37{)\),
      /-\LJ \u t.\J f.v. I ( &.L.I \1 t.J Joh ~                          ~-~ Ifu f b;r.a I
                                                                                             dcfi' Oh 1   t~ ken ~h th~ J'
 Co u r i J )J fL - Lb, ~ '1 C1 - 7_ Lf.
      1 h~-\ ·, J' _L \'~\e.~ in ~he. Court O'~ LvlMli-JP\L f\DP~\s ciJ' +he.                                 1

 v~Cov-J .sho\ili ... L€11£"11. 7/L7/Z-orS. ft.4tJt.s+;htj j'h-fov-n~-tio{)
  C.uhefrn v h1 6i'\ }I d~ ~~a J ~ -\1\Jil .
     \he_ 1 ho-rm 1\L fo~ L£1\ \Je. 10 FILe. kfflrT or h/\ ~tJ~ nu._s 'J ~h rJ
  Co\)C:f - lL -t i tv [ f \J FI LJl \( ~ J 67 I JLJ I z.n JS . liJrLCT rLEU~1\J81 0ru G1 )JI\ L
                                                              1

  lJ\lrT Dr 'l"l~Nl)l-\nus. \l8LOf2D LfDF/Z ..-47- J1l)'J ~ N~-rro:-. GPDF }G1\c\)J
      'l)u -t ~ () L/1 -r 'f t co V'~ ~ J ), 6 u i , -t h~ + oh J u \ y l " , z.o J ( MI _s c \) oc_u ~
 ht\\il\ \LtLI~ ·p~O J' t:          6qd·, n On J·u l.y 20,20) ~ hlSL \Jowh8Ji
                                                 dnU
\LtLD P\l.D Jt I \JJ'\~"" ~UfShpdh)l \"nq L~1Eil. L\)D r- /3, k~J-
   CD n ce_rn ~ hq J u c,h f\\; f\q , Oh 67- J 1{, J l(Jf cin d 07/ Z1J Jz_o 1r ..l ~ \J-L
NDI Jt.hi c\r\ }J ~U~UHLIU . ~)C1LLJ nenPJ · LE11 ffi . \[) ~ h t Cou ( 'f 0 t Gr,~ M -~hJ I
f..\pouiJ.                                ·                                                                       \
     ~   I   _L \(h() \J          hnf h~hy'    a·~ J u [ h    I    rL£U.1 Qb   ~l}r i ~e. CCJ\·, CJ e.v \(_ tu t ,\c.   dh   d

 pcL\pL~:sS·-! . _I d'h                       Vtf;IJU-1';   "?' --fh"L &,u vt dhd (J~v\L -h So-J Me.
-~ Co~ its D~ 6J.                      /1 {, I ZfJ JS   l\h J 07-ho JZiJ ,:;- dn J l£1101. [PJl F /J l l<..KJ

a\- ·~ nLu n e_;h -e j' •                                                 .                     ,     .                 .
             1h     :?>.   \Jn" i OuJ           ni   _u ;v,       _r -h (LOJ. -th }+ .L ci h h-'1'' hq
                                                                       nd, \

\J   e.ry      J ~r \t u J d d 1tl h.J               h km "~'9-d. ;h l + l"\6 he.rt L1 bLJ) · \-\;u9 ht..J
  Lth-~4 L~w \_ ;hrd vy o{\,··u_r:s dn.J hd1,\-roor1 ~v.sunnol-LLq-c~l
  Lo~a\ \h~· . -c~ n \J~~ ~- h9- 1~J 1~ h hy o~-u:cJ£!0&--~h J L'lJ-GU n.rv c Lt_c;c)'
 h.d~ \ '
     1- h ~ \u~       -\   ~\e._~ 0 v e v 4 - C (Lrf ~~ 11 u Ll. ) ,
            _i 6 n_  bo )) \'nq t~; f Couv-+ ~ n J (\tv \c::. . lJ-nd e_v )f~rt L My hte J
  1\\ be_ ))vtJ \J"1 dt_J \Ji~h Lup\e.s 0'~ ~h~ UI1En [P\)F /JCK~) D7/J6)lOJ(
   l\n ~ 01 I'LcJ j lOJ (. nr·.s L )'Ju LUM~ -r lLEWYl!b PrW Se'. ',
        ?\t:~ S c fJ vu \J J t. he.. W ~ -4 h GO)) 1~ ~ {}{ 07 ) I & ) 2.11 i ( ~ n d ([} ) 'Z-0 /zD r       J
              .-
' " \u rz- L;:) t 7 q - 2 Lf .
               .1

            .I. ~\Jt i~cj \levy (-LL-eh+\y                   '·MlJi..llil'\.1   I~01l ae.c\JJ-JJ..:L'DEYLh-rmJ.J
-fl) 1 \-t f. CUu v'Li ~u XlE. Cu 1J s.n; ffi ·--r \-\C2:. Dru:f}'(L o ~ M)' M01LU u fo '(\_
L~\?2. -n.) F.U£ Lu\LrT               Dr MP.JJb~MUJ           Llu\-i'n     svp?l)v--h:J V-tcuvJJ ~h J
~ (._(;· ~ ~ \) ·; ~ ~ ' '
         P~ ~ ~ s e. \( v-o \ (i ~ t he.. k~ -, ~ ~ w })\ e. s o~ 61 J1b JZ1J 1 (" / 01 1zo IZD 1s
-~() d ~ ~ L lt:r1EYL [ Pb f I JG K. \)J .
         .1.. -\n..t\ y 6pip{<..CIL~1 e.. yuuv- LuhJ ~~ e_v-~-t~u n ... ·THAN I( YOu.,.
 hd y Co IJ bks..J ¥ou . )'0 \J v I~M I ty d h h,t,.,~ s .     l
                                                                       .5-Jhtere    ly
                                                                         WLI-)JWJ QQu.Jt

                                                  3