Court Opinion

ID: 4070998
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 01:41:27.873728+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:18:36.629369
License: Public Domain

C€FCU@ /l/OS 7,2/"©(.@ ' 6 @Z/ 0'5;1/.-09

\E:/”V/Qm/H /! /¢27/@}<
3¢2>4`@//2/‘/ v1152\3121{(

   

112 Th2 327** E§\§Q§\
D'\s§c"\@§ Co§mq 09

// E>d§ CO§\…Q\ ff€v<@$.
1272 f¢@¢€ 611 7-;<& ‘ , - 1 §§@@§:BVED UN
225/122%;1# 1 cc1.1m' "'= "‘°”-“~1111111 21PPEALS
UCT 1 2 ZZE

591 §§

§Q_U_LQ§_`C\\/)QC\S am ~"”Q_\§` NO6NA@@SEEI, Cn 6Fk

25

\© *§¥\2 \r\§\\§w;\\;\ 121 § \»§321 @% 302\§ wm § \ C§ m@§ m§>
`\“\(\C~ C\Q.QV€J\<§&‘NAY /\>\Q,‘x’\ 3&\7\\¢\ ` §\ TO~*:\OF ` Qc\\.>\f)Q, Y\Q 2 ’§ Z~\O§Q , QV`O¢,B:
\\)N)V \\M@/ UD\SOV§ 052 `\)NL !3<\00\5‘2» §§»>le_<§ C_,c\\\g~z_ v\Q S\\w§ 2`2.\'\ 251

\m§.<> M §2>2`2§2@<>12` 1322 02 §2'\>2 §§ 2\@2\0(223 fcc-§§ \ §Y\§§` .L\r><\§\¢ \\2032..2,2

00 §§§\2\#\§)2§ j \?>“““ \' 20\'3 x \?QXL§`\<>Y\QF U_\§\@C, wm 0221€2:>122§"§\ @>C\\
QQ>\M\§§ -\ L'\*_ 022<~23§-` 2§\§ ma mvm»\»¢,$ Q@§l.\‘)b \)2> §m%<> \`31\`\3 5)`%\ “<\‘\d@;"°"“
_ \W\C\§ ms MWH\Y\C&A\_\: 3§\§322\~2§ §2§\>2\§2\2~€ YG%\O<` §O 2’222\§`2\_ `\~2\ `~\Axe/
'~ (/\\5>2®3 ow\§ §\1\2 02®\\0\”\§~§ @5; 3§\2~€"\§»§ t;©@\€» LO\’)§¢/ O_v\o 0"\3§¢\¢§
{¥v\§€ r\<\§ \J\U\NS iquq f@$\rc£\r\@.$ 2132§\522 §§ `\\\0222225 <222§2§\“3 §<)
/X~F§`\C\L§ v\\C)\{ 09 ¢2\1\2 TQ>2\2)2§ §§ \`\¥2\ \'\\02\¢+3\ Q_\"@§)M§\\ \Qv"\§\\e§jcS O\"
"`mmw\'.%`es §~r~ amy mmmr 03\5.$22»/\2§\\32§/ 2>2@'§~_\01\ /Qj >///2@_ Jue Cowc€c.

§§ §\\2 /GZLU Ov‘"' %2 /&HJ»

//\

W?//€ %Af yzvl/%/w€f ,z€mz'/J />; /%@ @w%@aj mc %`z j%@/< /.` /%@
/§M/€, )/wd/iv/¢ /74) 7§//€/ dm/ z€¢€(/e/ 759 JC/;`e/¢.(/e 4 aéé%€ /9“/ Q
f€ 170 C‘HL/"”” /JFQf/j /)/“/`M 249 /)z%/frm€/~f Ej/w max/bmw e;y)/`FML/`mv
(/¢,7)@ 07¢‘ %WMN 259/§ gmc ,4¢7@Orwy ¢¢ ¢Wmm€,# cor/6 edf M¢
viij €@/@ cf €~'m;/,Q/ /)MC€A/U ¢W, 20a J¢q.,w /Am¢~ Q /m_m/@.
/L)_¢me // a a@aea O/ 7%@ éM/% of 742 p/e/FQF%/»wzz J/)Q// %f ~""¢~ df

';%@ c/Wj¢; ¢¢jCL/hJ/- gm /»`o/m;[@ dr /)em"m bey§we %/7@ }//`[77h jj @\7£/€/
%Ae @/}z%@ ah wé/EA a wmmf /sz//c/ /7€ /Ac /?v mc//€ or /€/:/wv /L'
ar~/W%€r/ any on a c'/zay¢ //z@% %e /`/7/77¢1%€ of //€/UW AQF ('”'”/W/W"/
¢?"1 a%»¢/`/)/J%myé)/¢: c//`@Ay,l,w @'7[" 0 vao@f/w, uf re/€¢JC @h/ 7/%¢ /F/% Oé/
47£7[@' #)e `<)/Q%c on wH/`¢% /'ée /‘,Z?m/L/)cme// o/éJL/j'»ec/ ar %Wv'%m€”/
51/0§1// d%ew/;rc; be rafa/r€/ 749 d/J/.O@J"¢ cf 7’/1'1; L'%)a£)jw m%ef //3/1¥€€7%”/
607/eff f/\L /`qm&.?<¢ O»A /)ema)? /J /@/cQ/€M' from c¢/J;LOc/V am/ 62 J¢¢r)¢/»w/vf
_/F /LW€M wva dec%/`@’~ 55& SU`/ »g@u;m\j 7%¢ />)m,¢€ O/~ //wm %O
alfqu /'SF 4` j€Qr/.`r/j gma@,~ .,Jé?€%?i’" J'OJ; pZd>/.

U(go\¢\ ~/’/,@ m /`,l/`c¢/ J€é`z)“c/) waresz lof /)57¢,7/~, bmi/d 757/w /)€)’Jor)¢ J*€am/)/
/‘//€ Q/j /@//§¢/ fef/W'/M ff ~fé%mw@/ w,»e/zz %ed’ w/Mwa; O/Ma fo 01 /7¢7/€0 %/`¢

J€¢Irz/z L{/€e/"/~¢U_z 7¢ 079[/`6/"&,@ F€C 01/€_/"€@/ /3) /7@/'\¢&1<)1/€ /70)7 ~ re/QM 749 /Jd /`c&

¢/hO//;/)f// @%ky W/M 0%€” 49/“/7§“ '/}?J/?/€ f/,e_ raf/'O@')-c€ d?¢' 7%€ gmc 075 /AL

UFFFJZL“ /%7(/%"0)76/ 7?_/7/0/` }){(.f /WU CO)')q/r;o/) //)Hw/_ /]¢9,/* Q:)j, pe/?y&nc@

%O 7‘/7¢ ar/~U,z,',j /’4¢
Q//e¢eo/ wfféhMe/~¢ .%’co~//'nj ,¢O Ar%,‘¢/¢ //.@/@/(@/Md@) af 7//,@ 74;)%;
('?/`/,Q/ /9@£@{(,,6!/ w\\,<» a " SPUM\¢ OH€HJC MJ 566/4
///€ eL/§ Co)nm{%f€y((&,f ¢J€// df 7"’%)@ dy@c/F"Cf§ M€Jc/`be/ /)mper%/
_ (7\

/

/ op /`7‘€»7! avm%/`%M%/>j
€¢//`/wc& 740 b\”/ erch¢% /€/” car Je/`z€r/ afa /écm‘€@/ €¢f O/” cm W'

7%@ /Jar%/'¢¢.//ar /gemm f /)/aca/. low %/é/`/j %v bc Jm)»c./é@/ Q’/i %@ 7¢'/'”7@
mr %/uz /`/7 mdc/776

  C cwm/ jj
`/'Zj/M /Q' /f&fmm€a/ 249 56 /`,7,7@¢<.€/77‘ byon/ 62 /GF€/
f@m@naé/L MMW“, />e/z%/m€/~ A/'?¢}Ar w A€// /'//y&/j anyZ/`ve, an/m% A/I
w/// ¢L/ 7‘/')< g€// /Zu/??LY CA?'/(` C/%j 0'7£ B€//O*')/N O/" a sz/)zwp ’dO
/yo)%/ L//?%,,. >z/}?L gandy/wm 075 AL/~`€Am /}') /)d§§`€_S/'or) 075 69 F/F€Qf/o;_j glfD

/;€7‘/'7"/`0/7€/

_ im%?/'” 7[/7€ /))“wd/b/vf 075 § HF€/m' /Z./qe; L¢/amw+ /€74(/`//‘@/” ,; )//wL f€J/r/c%£
m/\ 727/ar fkvm /QQJH’F Mi/ fn 744/3 Café Ld})/`oh fn #r/`UU uan /)/'J
MJ: £°W%/`%u%/w&/ £j'/§/L/°_ %J 63 /@¢d aé/%U c/`%/`zéh and /)/K @/¢(Q
//’UC€M 075 LQ¢¢/ 7%¢¢'/ /)JU been Z//'b/QX&/ 57 0757@`<;/`4/ /DO//Cc m/JCth/mf/",

>B€dcf@`¢ 7‘7)6 d%z 716 /MJ %/z{/"é/Hre/ }€waeo' and 742//€6/ 759 €//)71€/" /`//)7¢0
a 7%'&/ w¢/»/>, 7¢/;@ max/mm @WW,% §§ pbgc @MJ/',,j 077,7;7/0/ 70
e>¢hwm¢ /)Z/ 0707%)# 67 fc-%»z Jyé%@ /)/eq ¢zjr¢em@m<,, %;/ /J ¢L[;@
a %~» 076 ¢h@ M(=,<@ /Mw/¢@ M/c// My mm é<€,, 777/j ¢Au»
,M¢/w/M 74@71»¢@/ mma 74»» a cow/¢¢'/>n, /%74-,¢/7,,6,» 757/or 577 been
wQ/‘%/}qj %S» %/7`< J%z/€J‘ (//J/Q@_;/'#,‘Dh 075 /)/`J cwa 14>” %2 A»/pzw@
J&/€r/ w w zw¢£ 74 bmi g Mm/:;Q/ 04 éeAq/% @/ %/7¢
/1’~//€§€¢/ z%z)§h%zq 74.v

Q'z)

`\JQ\\:B `\»er ~S`Yusb\lb T~SS\AQ/

7;€ />€79`7£/'017€/” /mJ ci#€m/Q%e/ 710 )”€Jo/&@ /)/;F ma»va£v%»~]
J//(/Qen/,;r/br) %/)robj,§ %he /)dm/e, D/`qu/bh (`/) /3€// foum‘>/, (L/}z/ 075 7Zm/p/c/7'>?.
dwc/ H,w~§/¢ fha l7'[)&§` é@onp//my%f LJ/`>%/'n fha /3@// [‘o¢m;<;/ law
E/va/”c€mmf /7’¢/»77_/»7/%/'¢»¢., “/?%@] p€/`Z/z€r /,l/.»f%/'ei /%1/@ /€WM/€/

#» /76@ pew/mm F€WJ¢ 70 mom 744 ~g/M 717;;,»%,71 lwe
/)e%/¥/@m’/ Wy/&/ /7&! Je)"z/ef/ mem %W) /)61/7[ `of /)/:f- /”’W‘MW‘W“/
JM/yerz//J/bn af //'/y<'rfy 7 &WyfoX/ma}€& 750<»»71{»@, [/L/j month J%/€e% %/me,`
//@ />/ d[w L/’Cr\agd >¢/7¢ fema/my %w€/a< @z) mm%/;r @f 4/3 %f%/~cjy`=/)f g
5qu morw%/ €{u@/ r’o 7%¢'(/“ /§//j@m 075 /)U J<@.

726,?_71;,”// 7%¢ Jv¢iv¢<: 074 7?¢><@( /&rv/e D/`z//`J/bw J“Aou/// honor /`?7%. HY'/»r
pagle 7%&% 7¢'/1¢. " wm Mrm# " be fmw€"J/j' %_//Dw/U /% 757/af
. 7%¢ Q/y/O~)~/vM/`)LY 7*0 J€cu/~L /5/§} fF€eJ@m / /Jw/)o;~e, %o Tj¢k//, /7/'$ /Zer;ly,
and 400 do j/é//nj /7/`/>7 acc'@{$ 743 moya 74)»»¢:/_¢{,»/ ¢M)Y w/'% ,L/N,
C//}¢m¢¢ ,LD /JL,/W{e. /V;; /,`71“@ jaqzr, W/i/7€ ée//j aé./¢ %o C.v)mec/?(
w/`% />»`J‘ 741/my M@/ /¢ co)v%‘m{¢ %O //u@ »/w;f pmng %M' 7`/;(,
777 jM/w/ 0/;¢77,;»/+ cow+ j>mme< 7»774'7@'»~€~' Uj\/Or L~%- af
/%7@ §7@-74 ML¢A m_»47 73 h 777%%-€%@@¢ /¢,m %J
/JrvceeM/j

l l %@%€C/fq] 171}/77/'7£7/€5//
'Dc»+e% \O//)v//S”
¢. /Zz jgm 7 dr jj Azz
@§}7 dim/h /"/' 757'/0'//;»»0-5€,
//3 LJ. few }m/ 477
737/1417, 7»?, 777/3

'I`§]. i?ZCJ- /)Eé/ara#/bn

I, 713 0 arn/h
L’L¢')"ref)%/ ij )` @Af/ gm %€' £boa& /0€7[/.7%}?€/ éM/:)j
l j /’JCQ)“c€m%€/ fn @€// /JOL¢)/)%>/ja/`/, dec/arc L¢ d ‘
/)é/" amy 7%6{7: QCCOK// l n dr /)ena/?(}/ mg

747 //7@ / y 40 @” 1777 7~/ é@//€%f/ 77€ 7467.¢ /@ ~f/WC'
72wa cz/;/;A'c@%/'om are %/'w€_ and cérrew‘

177 Mfw, gm

   

§ \'/)»\,

(§} 13€7777@»7/)7 71 757/ar