Court Opinion

ID: 4054594
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 05:43:26.917128+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:01:41.697294
License: Public Domain

.I             ·(V.D.JO~A~c~~03~7-vJJ .. }l'td Slcwa rf ~~ )(), fo ( f {G )C if/ t M{ iL ~V(. . .
                             'J              t~           . ;~                           I
- vr~K&\ on AU VV\.\&< fr e_ (\ () 0e 0f (}Gh dVI 0\ vWI f; b tkb Crt~ i r1 (t ~ff~ira1
                  .·        j                                             1

• i~~ Jof lf)r,t o-~ YI\G1:\dcuM vs .~ pvrsuuvt( tb ~rhde }I. 07 Se.chv fl J(t-7
 6t l·HQ ~        w{     0~ C;rvV/tVlc.l Yrocdutt) eJw! W6V!d ukow fht £twA
  thl to Ho~ir1j .~ 1ho.f ~ ht ~t ~ttl Cou0t~ J 0;uffic.; Ckr"K ;o WfVlrJJ i thYitj
 Ci .(i ~~ ~t CJ\ Oi'a c,d loA 0~ b ·(hi Vl 'i~ h_. V·i /,\ '\ cuJ-. 10 ~ )!\}~ f )-6tW MJ aJ)
 ~ ~~l\ -caV1VIchiJV\ ~(\o\1\Cj Wi th rh{ 0/\\(f at 0 Got~ M\-s"ff\J a, uHwtJT~ to Ht tfio. \ (!.cl urt ro ~kvtd ~h{ tiiH[
  lM';~t\o~ s imraot w~ tht 0\lfrtuh, ~t~cf H:ctVl b~ hYiJ1e{t -cf1.frt1 g·~
 QV\ orUtr dt0iqnethH~ ,s~ve0 i-l b~ Noalved. V{if'v!OYlJ ~Y1r1· Nx~3 [.t.f,
  utt . n,o '7 ,
  A· IM{(!s (kr~u~- ~1q                                                           .
        Or~~;f d~:s~~ MtiVL~ io ~vt ..J ~ r- tf ~lurJM   i.fl   (hffl<'wf;o il ~r h0 beets C«fo!J
W~lt-~ \,AlOe~ ~o~ -t~Hird w+~m kO do~ s at -eKfifRhM a~hYVJt ,fonhlc
to 1-\~\~I \o (). r~I CCI hQI) I \.0t\ ~      f, )~ I QVI dH1v) tJ4 J wftiuur e.ffccl-
                                           Uvt )'Y)c                                         f

 VtfVlO~ s ~VI. lt~t-v) t.~. ~ ()f"L f) ·01.
               ·~tiVttuf wod cl \i K~ ~ ~~ Ccot t i!~ Cd JMr'rl~l Apftc,Jo rlw.t- poof-
co,~Victi 0~ ~the\ { \\' 01 t'\cA-~({1 ') Corrvs r~HrM GV\lS ~ led fthv tall J.&)
'J.O\'il .• lh{ J-lv,l_ ~~\:> ){¥\fed ~~ \~t ~dti[.,t Liu~ Cl\'- &(,~r;.r io-v~f~
an fki\.Yt \ ),GI6. lkt ihvtcrvo,k){ Vv~t d)JZVfV\J [. '11IL~rG rrl ['gJ fl1
d~ )'lo oi~1u
      ~q              d~ v} law · JLCP ~r ~. II. 07 5-cdiDI\ 'iJ tc.) teq tJ i~t ~ f,esfo11d mf
o.0_ llCl-\-t i't VVl e
 ~ 1MM e~i rrh \~ -\v''Ct v~ Ow1; h~ tl1t Cav ~ rot G- r)1A ~}tG.\ ~ ffitA.b ~ CG·~ ~ o t
o-.t~ \~cc'\1 DY\ t-Or wr1\' o\- ~~I.'S Coff\1 ~ 1C\vtd \'A 110 wer fdi>J ared
                                                                                 1
Ctfl-&ruJt (\(Ci.hVL~ rUt ~(lk upoY1 vJhtt.G ~~Cl~ ~JII.dA'>t1 l)J'(ij ~e)
                                      r
 it t~ ~ ('~:Jvl \) l·ch Vl ~ lout ~ td de ) ~kut tiw'e ~It Yll{) /~2: tJU fo~bc
~/J
  It~ewe kd ~ .Nv my~ 0Y \-"~ t 1f liwh?J Yl . ~ vt-r; f a)· ~ ~ll 0 &rtuJ1 g.n~
  Civ\v\;J tf ~~ ko~ tt.vtv\ cvh h(C\lt ~ ut!lfl~ r~ t AcJ( iJ(Jd v1 w h h t11J
                                         CA.                                                                f' [

  ~M~;\fl~ \AK\ ~ tMd \ ~<\ 1!\ ~-ev1 tfrAYlO Vl'li#d fu Tkr lrYutf- etf Ctt(YlrKL)
  1\Ntub' MIL~ IJUC~ dc!WV\IJ tvth ~etl) t!rflviJ lMt &d io Ht Cour r0·~
  [~ rMi VLCr/ ~N{£)[5 -~ ~ ~ RO pottd~QS WrfVj I Ct~ ~ Ut1Jwet Hltd CtwJ1 crrHilfJ(_ ¥1cih YL~ rk ohk
  U'~nY1 \;J htG ~\ r~ r ~'v1c\dt~ [,Jj) 6 VIA0 d( I; t La til tJtch.(19 [oJV(+ cl wrl fJ
  r\tGlt .Y~tft (Af{ rib (Scr~J )0 ltt ('tOO lvd . EaavJA ~~ mC)~ Y1tU1 ~~/) ~11                                   r
   c.\tAll kt6. f OOV'V\~ mMYVfJ o)} h7>) ht{:'l ~ 'lon &~ has I~( j, j lA r ~
 (0\!whA VI iJ ~nJCI {( K)Jdl 'W' YV UtVO. I Ovr'tL A                n,        8W-1 f!-t;J/oYt/0 I   I'l!U J 7D)tfi
              -,         .                        !lC·                                                                .
              -VIOL~Tfon/ Of ft~rtcJ-£. 11.o7 of THL flxtO (0/)f£ of
                               C~tVVI [ rJ 11-i- ~~De_f_ Ov Rfi_
·              Jhc ~c;, foJ!1J{Vlt Vk! lvJcc/ fittrc.l -L 1/ ·07 znchb(} Ue-J t? f-1- ~ t 1fxv. 5 Codc
 o\' (j I \IV(,'v\[f I ~ fiiLWu {t by \hi\ ,)1 ~ ·It; frav id ( !A. lo ~ ~ ooH ht. (Aff 1/twfiJ-w ~1
'J~ ,C[       .                                                                           .
. Wf11- o\ h(/.\otu: (1xfus 1 !\ il"\ \1t Vl~ ~ ts             ~ \-~J o, Y1d\ ~ ctrtl kdr ncA-~\'~ fhc
  ~tL or()() w~I c\!\ ~hR~ \ tilt1M~ wetS                      yvtll~~ \-o Ykt ~vr+o· ~ (f )%,'y) k I . ..
                                                                                                I

   ~ H~ h w-~ \A.;i\ 'r~ l \l'¥Yl l v~'vC fi \at A ~i lOt w o,vtJ tl)i th,Y\ V1 /'l{A 1\ ('),M-e
           (l                                                                                       )IJ

   ti \111 t ~o wt the\ ~1t O(l vJ MGh r~ t olccv tt~.tVlf-s W'{ rt tq Ll <' oted tzJ 19-c.
                                                  1

   h(\iflSVVli~d . ~t9vtsb .~ r Thl tf11v1J (MI~cd of- +Utt rAff /r'lftf;oiJ ~V'
   vJ0i \ ck t\-kVKv~ t(J~~S 1\Vt~ Oovtbwer ~leo\ 1iiJ q (ftk~toJr f'ttihl1_3
   t~\ &o.\L u~6Vl whTGh t~(}+ ~~M~ vvu o VX!lde [Ak;ft rmu!t hy .. ·
                            1

   R-U \<\v1 \6 ~N1 VLC\ it~~ ·vvd~·nm~ 1 ~ ~v ~~t t 1{ v~ fbuv wvv'\1~ ~~
    cuk-i tltA y}11)l I ld I-t*~ (J ~(1h4 (!{_ Wvrut~ 1&; Jor51 ltfnll~ IS ~              )JJ       I

    '\0 Athd t ll. 01              &echDr1   3rc1 oPr L1 < Url ( oF C.(JYittYUt I ~roctdurc 1ru{
                                                                                            ~And
   (). (tof~h tof K0 r ~ \\ ~or~ ose . T(Jtb:+t 7 {v\&. bri
    hr Me~J Fh~ _~0
                                                       Ylo hH
   -'5UV~r1i-IJ[ e.op~ ~t tbu rAt f lt'c£tJ,]Vl fdf uJAt af hc1 k'fOtJ C0V'~IJ5r
    (Avt~ Gl~&vvtl t, I{~ ) C\¥1 d! (A C-tl h-frcdc ttdrvt; ~fu ~ h uro/} -
   ~:5 CJ~IL~ Hw~ httdnt~ Wftil VWLdf T-o rhr CMr~o -~· CtlYJ!l1)18_) ~!M
A0 lo 6:c+ o11 -~t bbr~ ~Jy; t o-f Mv~ClD CorfiJJ . ~-U/oJn r M:s ~of!f we lJ
 \\tlt6vt~ uVl~ {'{~ ui r Wlt;ft\- 01' o~ \iq()i~io VI j Yn fo otd UjJO Yl AtW: .~ ~ ~ht
                                                      1

  ~~ ~GtS   Cod t d Cri~MiVUd Ptocdute ~ 1- n 1M ~f[t6t To ~ d&..to t~ '-t ~-rh 1
   ~0~\J'/\Lhvvt Nlb ~'IJluJ\1~ ~ikel hi IJJYr1f)1 wit'h tht. ftW~ ~~ &~/
   Lfl¥v\Mrtl Vrmx~uflt 1\fhdt 11.07 -~hufl ~ rc> 1 ro (]Le,bYKj 1YL b~ ltt1Y~
                          1
  avtd ~ o,h o \h \; d \-o ~~rd ~deJa r flht frc fuNoJilul o.ud l:R111tJMiJVl
  ~'\\o f~n~ ol !Ml~ wf'i ~tV! 1tdfM5e& 1v h~ urrfeop