Court Opinion

ID: 9807681
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2023-08-31 20:12:41.441493+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T11:50:55.524799
License: Public Domain

Walke®, J.,
dissenting: I cannot agree with tbe conclusion of tbe Court in respect to tbe liability of tbe defendant Seaboard Air Line Railway Company, because I am convinced, after a careful perusal of tbe evidence and a deliberate consideration of it, tbat there is none wbicb implicates tbe railway company as a negligent or delinquent defendant, and if there was negligence on tbe part of its codefendant, tbe express company, tbe railway company did not participate therein, by cooperation or otherwise, nor was it in any way to blame, in law or in fact, for tbe accident, whereby tbe plaintiff’s intestate was killed. My opinion, therefore, is tbat tbe nonsuit as to tbe railway company was properly entered by tbe Superior Court, and tbat its ruling in tbat regard should be sustained.
AlleN J., concurring in dissent.