Court Opinion

ID: 2970397
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2015-09-22 16:11:32.010537+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T15:01:17.973135
License: Public Domain

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21
              3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

     (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU
                 )LOH 1DPH DS

81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6
                )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7
                  BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

 :,//,$0 ':,*+7 '27621            ;
          3ODLQWLII$SSHOODQW      
                                    
                                      1R
             Y                     
                                     !
                                    
 5(*,1$/' $ :,/.,1621             
 'LUHFWRUs2+1 .,1.(/$DQG        
 0$5*$5(77( 7 *+((                
         'HIHQGDQWV$SSHOOHHV 
                                    
                                   1
       $SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW
        IRUWKH1RUWKHUQ'LVWULFWRI2KLRDW7ROHGR
      1Rn'DYLG$.DW]'LVWULFWsXGJH
                 6XEPLWWHG$SULO
            'HFLGHGDQG)LOHG$XJXVW
  %HIRUH5<$1%2**6DQG&2/(&LUFXLWsXGJHV
                    BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
                         &2816(/
21%5,():LOOLDP'ZLJKW'RWVRQ/LPD2KLRSURVH
  5<$1 s GHOLYHUHG WKH RSLQLRQ RI WKH FRXUW LQ ZKLFK
%2**6sMRLQHG&2/(sSGHOLYHUHGDVHSDUDWH
FRQFXUULQJRSLQLRQ

                               
     'RWVRQY:LONLQVRQHWDO                    1R

                     BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
                         23,1,21
                     BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
  5<$1 &LUFXLW sXGJH  2KLR LQPDWH :LOOLDP 'ZLJKW
'RWVRQDSSHDOVWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVGLVPLVVDORIKLV86&
  ODZVXLW EURXJKW DJDLQVW VWDWH SULVRQ RIILFLDOV
'RWVRQjVVXLWFKDOOHQJHVWKHUHWURDFWLYHDSSOLFDWLRQRI2KLR
SDUROH HOLJLELOLW\ UHJXODWLRQV DQG FODLPV WKDW WKH RIILFLDOVj
DFWLRQVGHQLHGKLPGXHSURFHVVDQGYLRODWHGWKH([3RVW)DFWR
&ODXVH  7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW GLVPLVVHG 'RWVRQjV LQ IRUPD
SDXSHULVVXLWSXUVXDQWWR86&HRQWKHJURXQGV
WKDW'RWVRQIDLOHGWRVWDWHDFODLPXSRQZKLFKUHOLHIFRXOGEH
JUDQWHGDQGRUWKDWKLVVXLWODFNHGDQDUJXDEOHEDVLVLQODZRU
IDFW
  2Q DSSHDO 'RWVRQ FODLPV WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW HUUHG LQ
KROGLQJ WKDW D FKDOOHQJH WR WKH UHWURDFWLYH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI
SDUROHHOLJLELOLW\JXLGHOLQHVLVQRWFRJQL]DEOHXQGHU
EHFDXVHDMXGJPHQWRQWKHPHULWVZRXOGDIIHFWWKHYDOLGLW\RI
KLV FRQYLFWLRQ RU VHQWHQFH  :H ILQG WKDW 'RWVRQjV VXLW LV
FRJQL]DEOHXQGHUDQGWKHUHIRUHZHUHYHUVHWKHGLVWULFW
FRXUWjVMXGJPHQWDQGUHPDQGIRUIXUWKHUSURFHHGLQJV
                                 ,
  'RWVRQ EURXJKW WKLV   DFWLRQ DJDLQVW 5HJLQDOG $
:LONLQVRQ'LUHFWRURIWKH2KLR'HSDUWPHQWRI5HKDELOLWDWLRQ
DQG&RUUHFWLRQsRKQ.LQNHOD&KLHIRIWKH2KLR$GXOW3DUROH
$XWKRULW\ DQG 0DUJDUHWWH 7 *KHH 2KLR 3DUROH %RDUG
&KDLUSHUVRQ'RWVRQjVSURVHFRPSODLQWDOOHJHGYLRODWLRQVRI
)RXUWHHQWK $PHQGPHQW GXH SURFHVV 86 &RQVW DPHQG
;,9DQGWKH([3RVW)DFWR&ODXVH86&RQVWDUW,
FO'RWVRQSURFHHGHGLQIRUPDSDXSHULVLQWKHGLVWULFW
FRXUWSXUVXDQWWR86&
  ,QsXO\'RWVRQZDVVHQWHQFHGE\DQ2KLRFRXUWWROLIH
LPSULVRQPHQW XSRQ FRQYLFWLRQ IRU DJJUDYDWHG PXUGHU
'RWVRQDOOHJHVWKDWDWWKHWLPHRIKLVFRQYLFWLRQ2KLR5HY
&RGH%VWDWHGWKDWLQPDWHVVHUYLQJOLIHVHQWHQFHV
    'RWVRQY:LONLQVRQHWDO                    1R       1R                      'RWVRQY:LONLQVRQHWDO          

                    BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB                                ZHUHHOLJLEOHIRUSDUROHDIWHUVHUYLQJ\HDUV,IQRWUHOHDVHG
                                                                       DWWKHILUVWSDUROHKHDULQJWKH3DUROH%RDUGZDVUHTXLUHGE\
                      &21&855(1&(                                      2KLR UHJXODWLRQV WR SURYLGH WKH SULVRQHU DQRWKHU KHDULQJ
                    BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB                                ZLWKLQ ILYH \HDUV  3XUVXDQW WR WKH VWDWXWH DQG UHJXODWLRQV
                                                                       'RWVRQEHFDPHHOLJLEOHIRUSDUROHDQGUHFHLYHGKLVILUVWSDUROH
   5*8<&2/(s5&LUFXLWsXGJHFRQFXUULQJ2QO\RQH              KHDULQJLQDIWHUVHUYLQJ\HDUV+HZDVGHQLHGSDUROH
OHJDOTXHVWLRQLVDWLVVXHKHUHZKHWKHUDVVHWIRUWKLQ3UHLVHU      DWWKDWWLPHDQGWKHERDUGGHIHUUHGKLVVHFRQGKHDULQJIRU
Y5RGULJXH]86WKHZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXV           \HDUVGXHWRWKHVHULRXVQHVVRIKLVRIIHQVHZLWKDKDOIZD\
SURYLGHVWKHH[FOXVLYHUHPHG\IRUSHWLWLRQHUjVFKDOOHQJHWRWKH        UHYLHZWREHKHOGLQILYH\HDUV
VFKHGXOLQJRIKLVSDUROHKHDULQJ,FRQFOXGHWKDWWKHZULWRI
KDEHDV FRUSXV GRHV QRW SURYLGH WKH H[FOXVLYH UHPHG\ IRU           ,Q  WKUHH \HDUV DIWHU 'RWVRQjV ILUVW SDUROH KHDULQJ
SHWLWLRQHUjV FKDOOHQJH DQG IRU WKDW UHDVRQ KH PD\ EULQJ D   2KLR LPSOHPHQWHG QHZ SDUROH JXLGHOLQHV  7KH QHZ
DFWLRQ                                                         JXLGHOLQHV GHWHUPLQH DQ LQPDWHjV SDUROH HOLJLELOLW\ E\
                                                                       IDFWRULQJLQWKHVHULRXVQHVVRIWKHFULPHRIFRQYLFWLRQZLWK
  7KHZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXVSURYLGHVWKHH[FOXVLYHUHPHG\              WKHLQPDWHjVSURSHQVLW\IRUIXWXUHFULPLQDOEHKDYLRUDQGULVN
IRUFKDOOHQJHVWKDWQHFHVVDULO\LPSO\WKHLQYDOLGLW\RIWKHIDFW       WRVRFLHW\0RUHRYHUXQGHUWKHQHZJXLGHOLQHVLIDSULVRQHU
RU GXUDWLRQ RI D SULVRQHUjV FRQILQHPHQW  6HH (GZDUGV Y      LVQRWUHOHDVHGXSRQKLVILUVWSDUROHKHDULQJDVHFRQGSDUROH
%DOLVRN86+HFNY+XPSKUH\              KHDULQJFDQEHGHOD\HGXSWR\HDUVZLWKQRKDOIZD\UHYLHZ
86$Q\DQZXWDNXY0RRUH                 UHTXLUHG
)G'&&LU1HDOY6KLPRGD
)GWK&LU+HUHSHWLWLRQHUDSSHDOVRQO\           &RQVLVWHQW ZLWK WKH HDUOLHU UHJXODWLRQV WKH 3DUROH %RDUG
WKHVFKHGXOLQJRIKLVUHOHDVHKHDULQJ1HLWKHURXWFRPHRIWKDW        SURYLGHG'RWVRQDKDOIZD\UHYLHZRQ0DUFK7KH
GHFLVLRQnUHVFKHGXOLQJWKHKHDULQJRUQRWUHVFKHGXOLQJWKH            3DUROH %RDUG GHWHUPLQHG WKDW WKH QHZ JXLGHOLQHV DSSOLHG
KHDULQJnQHFHVVDULO\LPSOLHVWKHLQYDOLGLW\RISHWLWLRQHUjV           UHWURDFWLYHO\DQGPDQGDWHGWKDW'RWVRQZRXOGKDYHWRVHUYH
FRQWLQXHG FRQILQHPHQW  7KXV EHFDXVH SHWLWLRQHU GRHV QRW       PRQWKV\HDUVSULRUWRJDLQLQJSDUROHHOLJLELOLW\
FKDOOHQJHDUHOHDVHGHFLVLRQWKHZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXVLVQRW         'RWVRQjVQH[WKHDULQJLVVFKHGXOHGIRUDWZKLFKSRLQW
SHWLWLRQHUjVH[FOXVLYHUHPHG\DQGKHPD\FKDOOHQJHLWWKURXJK          KH ZLOO VWLOO EH RYHU VHYHQ \HDUV VKRUW RI SDUROH HOLJLELOLW\
DDFWLRQ)RUWKLVUHDVRQ,FRQFXULQUHYHUVLQJWKH           %DVHG RQ WKH 3DUROH %RDUGjV DSSOLFDWLRQ RI WKH QHZ
GLVWULFWFRXUWjVGLVPLVVDO                                            UHJXODWLRQVWRKLVVHQWHQFH'RWVRQILOHGWKHSUHVHQWVXLW
                                                                         7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW GLVPLVVHG 'RWVRQjV   FODLP VXD
                                                                       VSRQWHZLWKRXWSULRUQRWLFHWRWKHGHIHQGDQWVDQGSULRUWRWKH
                                                                       VHUYLFHRISURFHVV7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWDFWHGSXUVXDQWWR
                                                                       86&HZKLFKVWDWHV
                                                                            1RWZLWKVWDQGLQJ DQ\ ILOLQJ IHH RU DQ\ SRUWLRQ
                                                                         WKHUHRIWKDWPD\KDYHEHHQSDLGWKHFRXUWVKDOOGLVPLVV
                                                                         WKHFDVHDWDQ\WLPHLIWKHFRXUWGHWHUPLQHVWKDWn
                                                                            
     'RWVRQY:LONLQVRQHWDO                       1R        1R                    'RWVRQY:LONLQVRQHWDO        

        %WKHDFWLRQRUDSSHDOn                                             :HDUHSHUVXDGHGWKDWWKHVHFRXUWVKDYHUHDFKHGWKHFRUUHFW
                                                                           UHVXOW7KHUHIRUHRXUXQSXEOLVKHGGHFLVLRQVQRWZLWKVWDQGLQJ
          LLVIULYRORXVRUPDOLFLRXV                                   ZHQRZMRLQRXUVLVWHUFLUFXLWVDQGKROGWKDWZKHQDSULVRQHU
                                                                           FKDOOHQJHVKLVSDUROHHOLJLELOLW\DQGWKHFKDOOHQJHGRHVQRW
          LL IDLOV WR VWDWH D FODLP RQ ZKLFK UHOLHI PD\ EH     QHFHVVDULO\DIIHFWWKHGXUDWLRQRIKLVFRQILQHPHQWWKHVXLWLV
          JUDQWHG                                                  FRJQL]DEOHXQGHU'RWVRQjVVXLWmHYHQLIVXFFHVVIXO
                                                                           ZLOO QRW GHPRQVWUDWH WKH LQYDOLGLW\ RI DQ\ RXWVWDQGLQJ
86&H%LLL:HVW6XSSHPSKDVLV                FULPLQDOMXGJPHQWDJDLQVWWKHSODLQWLII>DQGVR@WKHDFWLRQ
DGGHG  6FUHHQLQJ RI D SULVRQHUjV LQ IRUPD SDXSHULV               VKRXOGEHDOORZHGWRSURFHHGl+HFN86DW$VXLW
FRPSODLQWmPXVWRFFXUHYHQEHIRUHSURFHVVLVVHUYHGRUWKH                 VHHNLQJUHLQVWDWHPHQWRIDSULVRQHUjVSDUROHHOLJLELOLW\LVQRW
LQGLYLGXDOKDVKDGDQRSSRUWXQLW\WRDPHQGWKHFRPSODLQW                  D mFKDOOHQJH WR WKH IDFW RU GXUDWLRQ RI KLV FRQILQHPHQWl
7KH PRPHQW WKH FRPSODLQW LV ILOHG LW LV VXEMHFW WR UHYLHZ       3UHLVHU86DW
XQGHUHl0F*RUHY:ULJJOHVZRUWK )G
WK&LUGLVWLQJXLVKHGRQRWKHUJURXQGV                  2KLRKDVDFRPSOHWHO\GLVFUHWLRQDU\SDUROHV\VWHP2KLR
E\ %HQVRQ Y 2j%ULDQ  )G   WK &LU            5HY&RGH6WDWHH[UHO%ODNHY6KRHPDNHU
8SRQVFUHHQLQJ'RWVRQjVLQLWLDOSOHDGLQJWKHGLVWULFW             1(G2KLRSHUFXULDP0HUHO\JUDQWLQJ
FRXUWKHOGWKDWDSULVRQHUjVFRPSODLQWLVQRWFRJQL]DEOHXQGHU             'RWVRQ SDUROH HOLJLELOLW\ GRHV QRW DIIHFW WKH GXUDWLRQ RU
LIDMXGJPHQWRQWKHPHULWVZRXOGDIIHFWWKHYDOLGLW\               YDOLGLW\ RI KLV VHQWHQFH  $V WKH '& &LUFXLW SKUDVHG LW
RIDQLQPDWHjVFRQYLFWLRQRUVHQWHQFHXQOHVVWKHFRQYLFWLRQ               'RWVRQjVUHTXHVWHGUHOLHIZRXOGRQO\JHWKLPmLQWKHGRRUl
RU VHQWHQFH KDV EHHQ SUHYLRXVO\ VHW DVLGH  5HO\LQJ RQ            $GPLWWHGO\ZKHWKHU'RWVRQLVHOLJLEOHIRUSDUROHKDVZKDW
XQSXEOLVKHG 6L[WK &LUFXLW DXWKRULW\ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW              FRXOG EH WHUPHG D mTXDOLWDWLYH HIIHFWl RQ KLV VHQWHQFHnD
UHDVRQHG WKDW 'RWVRQjV FKDOOHQJH WR KLV SDUROH HOLJLELOLW\          VHQWHQFHVHUYHGZLWKSDUROHHOLJLELOLW\LVPRUHGHVLUDEOHWKDQ
VWDWXVDPRXQWHGWRDFKDOOHQJHWRWKH3DUROH%RDUGjVGHFLVLRQ              RQHZLWKRXW1HYHUWKHOHVVDVHDUO\DV3UHLVHUWKH6XSUHPH
WRGHQ\RUUHYRNHSDUROHDQGWKDWLWQHFHVVDULO\TXHVWLRQHGWKH            &RXUW KHOG WKDW WKH GHWHUPLQDWLRQ RI ZKHWKHU D VXLW LV
YDOLGLW\RIKLVFRQILQHPHQW7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWDOVRFHUWLILHG           FRJQL]DEOHXQGHURUPRUHSURSHUO\KHDUGSXUVXDQWWR
XQGHU86&DWKDWDQDSSHDORIWKHGHFLVLRQ               WKH KDEHDV VWDWXWHV WXUQV RQ ZKHWKHU WKH mSULVRQHU LV
FRXOGQRWEHWDNHQLQJRRGIDLWK                                        FKDOOHQJLQJ WKH YHU\ IDFW RU GXUDWLRQ RI KLV SK\VLFDO
                                                                           LPSULVRQPHQWl86DW7KHGXUDWLRQRI'RWVRQjV
  $IWHU UHFHLYLQJ 'RWVRQjV QRWLFH RI DSSHDO WKH 2KLR               LPSULVRQPHQW ZLOO QRW QHFHVVDULO\ EH DIIHFWHG LI KH JDLQV
$WWRUQH\ *HQHUDOjV RIILFH VHQW D OHWWHU WR WKH 6L[WK &LUFXLW      SDUROHHOLJLELOLW\
&OHUNRI&RXUWVWDWLQJWKDWQRGHIHQGDQWKDGEHHQVHUYHGDQG
WKDWLWKDGUHFHLYHGQRUHTXHVWIRUUHSUHVHQWDWLRQ7KHUHIRUH                                           ,,,
WKH$WWRUQH\*HQHUDOGLGQRWILOHDEULHI
                                                                             7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWHUUHGLQKROGLQJWKDW'RWVRQjVFKDOOHQJH
                                  ,,                                      WR KLV SDUROH HOLJLELOLW\ ZDV QRW FRJQL]DEOH XQGHU  
                                                                           7KHUHIRUHZH5(9(56(WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVMXGJPHQWDQG
   :HUHYLHZGHQRYRWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVMXGJPHQWGLVPLVVLQJ              5(0$1'IRUIXUWKHUSURFHHGLQJV
D VXLW IRU IDLOXUH WR VWDWH D FODLP SXUVXDQW WR  H
%URZQ Y %DUJHU\  )G   WK &LU 
0F*RUH)GDW:HYLHZDOOWKHIDFWVDOOHJHGLQWKH
FRPSODLQW DV ZHOO DV DQ\ LQIHUHQFHV UHDVRQDEO\ GUDZQ
     'RWVRQY:LONLQVRQHWDO                      1R       1R                    'RWVRQY:LONLQVRQHWDO        

SULVRQHUjV VHQWHQFH DQG D FKDOOHQJH WR WKH GHFLVLRQ LV QRW     WKHUHIURPLQWKHOLJKWPRVWIDYRUDEOHWRWKHSODLQWLII%URZQ
FRJQL]DEOH XQGHU    +RZHYHU 'RWVRQ LV QRW                  )G DW   )XUWKHUPRUH ZH UHDGSUR VH FRPSODLQWV
FKDOOHQJLQJWKHGHQLDORUUHYRFDWLRQRISDUROH,QVWHDGKH             OLEHUDOO\7KDGGHXV;Y%ODWWHU)GQWK
FKDOOHQJHV ZKHWKHU WKH 3DUROH %RDUG SURSHUO\ UHYRNHG KLV          &LUHQEDQF
HOLJLELOLW\ IRU SDUROH DQG WKDW GHWHUPLQDWLRQ ZLOO KDYH QR
LPPHGLDWHHIIHFWRQKLVVHQWHQFH                                         'RWVRQDUJXHVWKDWKHLVQRWFKDOOHQJLQJWKHYDOLGLW\RIKLV
                                                                         FRQYLFWLRQ RU VHQWHQFH  ,QVWHDG KH FRQWHQGV KH LV
   2WKHU FLUFXLWV WKDW KDYH H[DPLQHG WKH mLQWHUVHFWLRQl RI        FKDOOHQJLQJ WKH SURFHGXUHV XVHG E\ WKH GHIHQGDQWV WR
KDEHDV DQG   KDYH UHFRJQL]HG WKLV GLVWLQFWLRQ  7KH        GHWHUPLQHKLVSDUROHHOLJLELOLW\7KHRQO\UHOLHIKHLVVHHNLQJ
'LVWULFWRI&ROXPELD&LUFXLWKHOGWKDWDSULVRQHUVXLW            LV DQ LQMXQFWLRQ RUGHULQJ D QHZ SDUROH HOLJLELOLW\ KHDULQJ
IRULQMXQFWLYHUHOLHIQHHGQRWKDYHEHHQILOHGDVDSHWLWLRQIRU         ZKLFKZRXOGQRWDIIHFWWKHGXUDWLRQRIKLVVHQWHQFHRUYDOLGLW\
DZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXVZKHQLWRQO\VRXJKWUHLQVWDWHPHQWRI             RIKLVFRQYLFWLRQ+HDOVRDUJXHVWKDWWKHFDVHVUHOLHGRQE\
WKHSULVRQHUjVSDUROHHOLJLELOLW\$Q\DQZXWDNXY0RRUH            WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW FRQFHUQ SDUROH UHYRFDWLRQ DQG VHQWHQFH
)G'&&LU7KHFRXUWFRQFOXGHGWKDW              FDOFXODWLRQ QRW WKH mSDUROHUHOHDVH GHWHUPLQDWLRQV
EHFDXVH'&SDUROHGHFLVLRQVDUHHQWLUHO\GLVFUHWLRQDU\KDG            SURFHGXUHVl
WKHSHWLWLRQHUVXFFHHGHGLQKLVVXLWmKHZRXOGKDYHHDUQHG
QRWKLQJPRUHWKDQDµWLFNHWWRJHWLQWKHGRRURIWKHSDUROH               $ UHYLHZ RI 6XSUHPH &RXUW DXWKRULW\ GHPRQVWUDWHV WKH
ERDUGjl  ,G DW   7KH FRXUW ZHQW RQ WR QRWH WKDW mD   PHULWRI'RWVRQjVDUJXPHQW,Q3UHLVHUY5RGULJXH] 
PDMRULW\ RI RXU VLVWHU FLUFXLWV KDYH KHOG WKDW FKDOOHQJHV WR    86DFODVVRIVWDWHSULVRQHUVEURXJKWVXLWXQGHU
VWDWHSDUROHSURFHGXUHVZKRVHVXFFHVVZRXOGQRWQHFHVVDULO\                VHHNLQJ LQMXQFWLYH UHOLHI DQG FKDOOHQJLQJ WKH
UHVXOWLQLPPHGLDWHRUVSHHGLHUUHOHDVHQHHGQRWEHEURXJKWLQ           UHYRFDWLRQ RI JRRGFRQGXFWWLPH FUHGLWV WKDW ZRXOG KDYH
KDEHDV FRUSXVl  ,G DW   ,Q D VXLW FRQFHUQLQJ         VKRUWHQHGWKHLUVHQWHQFHV,GDW$IWHUFRPSDULQJWKH
SULVRQHUVjUHDVVLJQPHQWIURPDGPLQLVWUDWLYHVHJUHJDWLRQWKH             KDEHDVVWDWXWHV86&DQGZLWK86&
)LIWK&LUFXLWVWDWHGWKDWm>L@IDIDYRUDEOHGHWHUPLQDWLRQZRXOG          WKH6XSUHPH&RXUWKHOGWKDWmZKHQDVWDWHSULVRQHULV
QRWDXWRPDWLFDOO\HQWLWOHWKHSULVRQHUWRDFFHOHUDWHGUHOHDVH           FKDOOHQJLQJ WKH YHU\ IDFW RU GXUDWLRQ RI KLV SK\VLFDO
WKHSURSHUYHKLFOHLVDVXLWl&DUVRQYsRKQVRQ            LPSULVRQPHQWDQGWKHUHOLHIKHVHHNVLVDGHWHUPLQDWLRQWKDW
)GWK&LULQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNV              KHLVHQWLWOHGWRLPPHGLDWHUHOHDVHRUDVSHHGLHUUHOHDVHIURP
HOOLSVLV DOWHUDWLRQV DQG FLWDWLRQ RPLWWHG  %HFDXVH WKH        WKDWLPSULVRQPHQWKLVVROHIHGHUDOUHPHG\LVDZULWRIKDEHDV
SULVRQHUjV VXLW mZRXOG PHUHO\ HQKDQFH HOLJLELOLW\ IRU              FRUSXVl,GDWHPSKDVLVDGGHG
DFFHOHUDWHGUHOHDVH>WKH@VXLWLVSURSHUO\FKDUDFWHUL]HGDV
D   VXLWl  ,G DW  LQWHUQDO TXRWDWLRQ PDUNV DQG        7KH&RXUWUHYLVLWHGWKHmLQWHUVHFWLRQlEHWZHHQWKHKDEHDV
FLWDWLRQ RPLWWHG  )LQDOO\ WKH 1LQWK &LUFXLW LQ 1HDO Y      VWDWXWHVDQGLQ+HFNY+XPSKUH\86
6KLPRGD)GWK&LUKHOGWKDWSULVRQHUVj              DQGFRQVLGHUHGmZKHWKHUPRQH\GDPDJHVSUHPLVHGRQ
FKDOOHQJHV WR WKHLU VH[XDO RIIHQGHU FODVVLILFDWLRQ VKRXOG          DQXQODZIXOFRQYLFWLRQFRXOGEHSXUVXHGXQGHUl,G
SURFHHG XQGHU   EHFDXVH WKH UHVXOW UHQGHUHG ZRXOG           DWQ:KLOHDFNQRZOHGJLQJWKDW3UHLVHUGLGQRWGLUHFWO\
GHWHUPLQH WKHLU HOLJLELOLW\ IRU SDUROH DQG ZRXOG QRW              EDUWKHVXLWWKH&RXUWKHOGWKDWmLQRUGHUWRUHFRYHUGDPDJHV
mQHFHVVDULO\VKRUWHQWKHLUSULVRQVHQWHQFHVE\DVLQJOHGD\l            IRUDOOHJHGO\XQFRQVWLWXWLRQDOFRQYLFWLRQRULPSULVRQPHQWRU
,G DW  VHH 0RUDQ Y 6RQGDOOH  )G  WK &LU     IRURWKHUKDUPFDXVHGE\DFWLRQVZKRVHXQODZIXOQHVVZRXOG
SHUFXULDP0HWKHQ\Y+DPPRQGV)G                   UHQGHU D FRQYLFWLRQ RU VHQWHQFH LQYDOLG D   SODLQWLII
WK&LUFHUWGHQLHG86                  PXVW SURYH WKDW WKH FRQYLFWLRQ RU VHQWHQFHl KDV EHHQ
     'RWVRQY:LONLQVRQHWDO                     1R       1R                      'RWVRQY:LONLQVRQHWDO         

LQYDOLGDWHG  ,G DW   IRRWQRWH RPLWWHG  7KXV    H[DPLQHG 1HEUDVNDjV PHWKRG IRU GHWHUPLQLQJ D SULVRQHUjV
ZKHQH[DPLQLQJDSULVRQHUjVVXLWmWKHGLVWULFWFRXUW            SDUROHHOLJLELOLW\IRUFRPSOLDQFH ZLWKGXHSURFHVV,QVWLOO
PXVWFRQVLGHU ZKHWKHUDMXGJPHQWLQIDYRURIWKHSODLQWLII             DQRWKHU FDVH WKH &RXUW FRQFOXGHG LQ GLFWD WKDW +HFN DQG
ZRXOGQHFHVVDULO\LPSO\WKHLQYDOLGLW\RIKLVFRQYLFWLRQRU             (GZDUGVVWDQGRQO\IRUWKHSURSRVLWLRQWKDWLIDSULVRQHUVHHNV
VHQWHQFHl,GDW(DUOLHULQWKH+HFNRSLQLRQWKH&RXUW         UHOLHIIRUWKHXVHRImWKHZURQJSURFHGXUHVQRWIRUUHDFKLQJ
KDG DQDORJL]HG WKH SODLQWLIIjV VXLW WR WKH WRUW RI PDOLFLRXV   WKH ZURQJ UHVXOW DQG LI WKDW SURFHGXUDO GHIHFW GLG QRW
SURVHFXWLRQ DQG KHOG WKDW LQ RUGHU WR SURFHHG ZLWK VXFK D     QHFHVVDULO\ LPSO\ WKH LQYDOLGLW\l RI WKH FRQYLFWLRQ RU
FODLPWKHmWHUPLQDWLRQRIWKHSULRUFULPLQDOSURFHHGLQJlPXVW           VHQWHQFH WKH VXLW LV FRJQL]DEOH XQGHU    6SHQFHU Y
ILUVWEHSURYHQ,GDW1HYHUWKHOHVVLIWKHmSODLQWLIIjV        .HPQD86LQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNVDQG
DFWLRQHYHQLIVXFFHVVIXOZLOOQRWGHPRQVWUDWHWKHLQYDOLGLW\         FLWDWLRQVRPLWWHG
RIDQ\RXWVWDQGLQJFULPLQDOMXGJPHQWDJDLQVWWKHSODLQWLIIWKH
DFWLRQVKRXOGEHDOORZHGWRSURFHHGl,GDWHPSKDVLVLQ             7KLVFLUFXLWKDVQRWLVVXHGDSXEOLVKHGRSLQLRQFRQVLGHULQJ
RULJLQDO                                                            ZKHWKHU D SULVRQHUjV   FKDOOHQJH WR WKH SURFHGXUHV
                                                                        HPSOR\HG LQ SDUROH HOLJLELOLW\ GHWHUPLQDWLRQV LV QRQ
  )LQDOO\LQ(GZDUGVY%DOLVRN86WKH              FRJQL]DEOH1RQHWKHOHVVDQXPEHURIXQSXEOLVKHGGHFLVLRQV
&RXUW FRQVLGHUHG mZKHWKHU D FODLP IRU GDPDJHV DQG                LQWKLVFLUFXLWVXJJHVWWKDWFKDOOHQJHVWRDSULVRQHUjVSDUROH
GHFODUDWRU\UHOLHIEURXJKWE\DVWDWHSULVRQHUFKDOOHQJLQJWKH          HOLJLELOLW\DUHQRWFRJQL]DEOHXQGHU)RUH[DPSOHLQ
YDOLGLW\RIWKHSURFHGXUHVXVHGWRGHSULYHKLPRIJRRGWLPH             :DUGY(QJOHU1RV:/WK
FUHGLWVLVFRJQL]DEOHXQGHUl,GDW7KH&RXUW            &LU0DUFKXQSXEOLVKHGGLVSRVLWLRQDSDQHORI
UHYHUVHGWKH1LQWK&LUFXLWZKLFKKDGKHOGWKDW%DOLVRNjVVXLW          WKLVFRXUWUHYLHZHGDVXLWDOOHJLQJWKDWWKH0LFKLJDQ3DUROH
ZDVFRJQL]DEOHXQGHUEHFDXVHLWZDVDFKDOOHQJHWRWKH           %RDUG LPSURSHUO\ GHQLHG SULVRQHUV VHUYLQJ OLIH VHQWHQFHV
SURFHGXUHVE\ZKLFKWKHFUHGLWVZHUHGHQLHG7KH6XSUHPH               mFRQVLGHUDWLRQ IRU SDUROHl  ,G DW 
  7KH FRXUW KHOG WKDW
&RXUWQRWHGmWKDWWKHQDWXUHRIWKHFKDOOHQJHWRWKHSURFHGXUHV         m>G@HVSLWH SODLQWLIIjV SURWHVWDWLRQV WR WKH FRQWUDU\ KLV
FRXOG EH VXFK DV QHFHVVDULO\ WR LPSO\ WKH LQYDOLGLW\ RI WKH   DOOHJDWLRQVDPRXQWWRDFODLPWKDWWKHSDUROHGHFLVLRQLQKLV
MXGJPHQWl  ,G DW  HPSKDVLV DGGHG  7KH &RXUW            FDVHZDVZURQJUDWKHUWKDQDFODLPWKDWLQFRUUHFWSURFHGXUHV
mFRQFOXGH>G@WKHUHIRUHWKDW>%DOLVRNjV@FODLPIRUGHFODUDWRU\         ZHUHXVHGl,G,QWKHFDVHEHIRUHXVWRGD\WKHGLVWULFWFRXUW
UHOLHIDQGPRQH\GDPDJHVEDVHGRQDOOHJDWLRQVRIGHFHLWDQG            FLWHG&KDQGOHUY0LFKLJDQ3DUROH%RDUG1R
ELDVRQWKHSDUWRIWKHGHFLVLRQPDNHUWKDWQHFHVVDULO\LPSO\            :/  WK &LU sXQH   XQSXEOLVKHG
WKHLQYDOLGLW\RIWKHSXQLVKPHQWLPSRVHGLVQRWFRJQL]DEOH             GLVSRVLWLRQIRUWKHSURSRVLWLRQWKDWFKDOOHQJHVWRWKHGHQLDO
XQGHUl,GDW                                           RUUHYRFDWLRQRISDUROHQHFHVVDULO\DIIHFWWKHYDOLGLW\RIWKH
                                                                        LQPDWHjVFRQWLQXHGFRQILQHPHQWDQGDUHQRWFRJQL]DEOHXQGHU
  $VWKHKROGLQJVRIWKHVHWKUHHFDVHVLQGLFDWHRQO\SULVRQHU          ,GDW
VHH&ROHPDQY2KLR$GXOW3DUROH$XWK
FKDOOHQJHV XQGHU   WKDW mQHFHVVDULO\ LPSO\l WKH             1R   :/  DW 
 WK &LU 'HF 
LQYDOLGLW\RIWKHFRQYLFWLRQRUFKDOOHQJHWKHGXUDWLRQRIWKH           XQSXEOLVKHGGLVSRVLWLRQ3KLOOLSVY&ROHPDQ1R
SK\VLFDO LPSULVRQPHQW DUH QRW FRJQL]DEOH  6L[ \HDUV DIWHU        :/  DW 
 WK &LU 6HSW  
KDQGLQJ GRZQ 3UHLVHU WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW KHDUG D           XQSXEOLVKHGGLVSRVLWLRQ:KLOHWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVILQGLQJ
FKDOOHQJHWRGLVFUHWLRQDU\SDUROHSURFHGXUHVLQ*UHHQKROW]Y           LVDQDFFXUDWHUHVWDWHPHQWRIWKHODZRI(GZDUGVDQG+HFN
,QPDWHVRI1HEUDVND3HQDODQG&RUUHFWLRQDO&RPSOH[                 XOWLPDWHO\LWLVLQDSSRVLWHWR'RWVRQjVVXLWEHFDXVHLWIDLOVWR
867KH&RXUWGLGQRWDQDO\]HZKHWKHUWKHVXLW           DSSUHFLDWH WKH QDWXUH RI 'RWVRQjV FKDOOHQJH  &OHDUO\ WKH
ZDV PRUH SURSHUO\ ILOHG DV DKDEHDV SHWLWLRQ EXW LQVWHDG     GHFLVLRQWRJUDQWDSULVRQHUSDUROHDIIHFWVWKHGXUDWLRQRIWKDW