Court Opinion

ID: 3870279
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-07-06 09:04:39.59931+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T07:41:39.296788
License: Public Domain

This is a petition for a new trial in an action originally brought by the respondent against the petitioner in the Eleventh Judicial District Court, and thence to the Common Pleas Division of this court on claim for a jury trial, wherein the plaintiff obtained judgment in the Common Pleas Division against the defendant by default, the defendant having been called and defaulted November 16, 1900, damages having been assessed and decision rendered for $297.50 on November 24th, and judgment for said amount and costs having been entered December 3, 1900.
Affidavits offered by the petitioner showed that he had a probably good defence, that he employed and relied upon an attorney of this court to attend to the case, and that through the failure of such attorney to appear the case was defaulted. *Page 501 
The counsel for the petitioner, who, however, was not his counsel at the time of the default, urges the hardship of visiting upon his client the loss of rights, that a trial would protect, because of his trusting too implicitly a sworn officer of the court who is held out as a proper person to be employed and trusted in the management of law business such as the petitioner had and was incompetent to manage himself.
There is force in that contention, and great leniency has been shown in this State in such cases. Donnelly v. McAdams, 13 Atl. Rep. 108. While, however, affording relief to one party, we must see that the other does not suffer; and if through the gross negligence of his attorney the petitioner is put to unnecessary expense in getting a trial, he has a remedy by action for the loss caused him through such negligence. Forrow v. Arnold,22 R.I. 305.
The petition for a new trial is granted on condition that the petitioner re-enter said case in the Common Pleas Division on or before the first day of April, 1901, and that the defendant in that case (being the petitioner here) pay the costs of said action to date, not already paid by him, and the costs of this petition, with a counsel fee of $15.00, the same to be paid prior to the re-entry and to be irrecoverable in any event.