Court Opinion

ID: 4076276
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 07:20:46.678999+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:16:53.408038
License: Public Domain

FILED IN
                                                    14th COURT OF APPEALS
                                                        HOUSTON, TEXAS
           Nfi. 1^15-0057 )-CV
                                                        DEC 29 2015
                                                    CHRISTOPHER A.
                                                            CLERK
XNTHg FOURTEENTH COURT QF fiPPfA 1"S
         HOUSTON, T£X&$

              L6Y9 LhHpON SOMkOlA/

                         SA

            HAAKXS Cou/vtv «*«<

     6* Appeal ^A«#M^^t« «fi£+-K P'S^nici Coue A/*. 74001-J

                44*«l Reply S«i>-^

                         Loyal Lemuele*j ^©*&©co*t/*3,H©fic

                          >3«>© ^Vt- £*T
             TMNTTTV Of* PARTXGS *M&Covcai •?****

• H**ftals &>Mt/*»*ufJ /HajuVI WWf4* 0.H/&&* «**J;
*R&A#.iS Cow+y §keAi€Ci 0«y9«A.W*jfi- fiedtctA&»&**! &£.&>*( «K( "

 HeHU AT*!**

 1&14 C+»$A&4t t t$*k FloeA
                                TA&IEQF CONTEA/TS

XAe**+«+*t «*^ ^eL<*^/** »*j«1 Co*****.*, . .                                     m.

T^fel^L of Co*r+euis, . . . . „ . . . . . . . . _ . .                            ill.

l^de* q4 AutUzfitUes                                             , . . .#1/,!*}*,*•'.

Sfadk^eAii- ^e5CAe*iAi3 £>R
Sf^f«**£A/f e ^ -fJ»e C^se . . .                           , . , . „ , , •. , , vl

-S4whe#n#*i"^ ©-f KAcfs -                                       i . „ * .wijVJi,
Neu, WoMeti                    _ . ..„.•*-..    , . . . . . a . . vtitaj&t*,st6.

f\f4i*j&uf>fce.+xeCo*t} ^.e               ^ .    .   .                      ••-...--           * . /a.

                         XNP£* (Xs AUT0RXTXES

/|/a/vio CJofck PoP.ce. De*e.lop**uLfii'll'Zfi/c, v. V&m
    3l\ s.ui3d. M-as.                                                             i.

8#tcjs V. Ttyto> Che*hU*i Co. v. uj» tk;*/,
   H-l $.«*;. 3d. *f t4» (£-p. a©©*), .

   /*f SU/ 3d. 424> ^Teif-A^^^a^tf^***-^--'                           j/

Locjd v. £co Aeseuaces X **€.->
   15& s>uJ>ad. */0 (Ttx.App.-•**»&•»Ci**Pi£.7 W?). . . .£.
frW? left v. Shields,
    $14 S.tJ.a4-7£\a Cta*. i«»«*i}k ,                     ..,.».*.

   71«L $.t*3.ad. at' (re*,A^»-&>#bq. 7*
Cc^se

Vatss v. UNxreo states

Tey<*£ C»*/l ?^a«.c4->cc-A>*«1 f^e!. oai to. .                                        . . • ?

        /6/.0&iIa>, .                           . ». ,           « -*/1'

   $f/6l.6S<»£»)                            %             fc        r^j    r

T«x^ls Cod« a-£ &;*;«*( PnacedutW;
         a ©3                                                         6i

   Ant. /6.^a(A). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -^>

                                                                           i

Taxa.s NcaI-K a**4 $a$*sj Cod*
   Set. f ,T7fo£>3,       ,   »•   »

   Sec. f 6M.*o5 &)/*>}£). , . ,            ,   . .   ,            *,*;
                                                                           i

                                       v.
Statute                 XAJDfX OF AUTHORITIES              Pa&£

Tex^s Heai+k *wd S*.-e+\f Cede.,

T^xaS Pe«cJ Cede,
   See, 8,03 Ca)                    . ,                           *•

   Sac. 2X-0X\ b)t&\(A))(>*?) . - - '                    ,,,,*.
T**^$ %v\z£ c4 Civil Ptiocedufie,
   R*le*5^0e       .    . , . . . » , . „ . . o . . . * . • • «*••

                        TRANSCRIPT l^eco^Os

                       STATgT^NT RET6ARDXN6.
                            OftALAflG-U/ASWr

av^f'o^i) OtJ wW^^l /ve*/H issuesi 0L*/d "Pofi A£co/g.d .
                       STAT£M£*NTOF TH£ £A$£-

   Apf>e.l\&*t Appeals fU*. blJs'ba^cf tcia&fs o&deA ^a^/ 7£j<.

                N£WJUPRf/n£ COURT CA$£

    ^/D/d^IIa^t* Ua.$ d>Ajly ajouj \o£etJ able +© fl£i/i'pfierce C^m.f C&se V&.4es i/. U£» 57^ -
   ^ppe.\ld(j\ behave.? -tk^s Co.se. co^ld k>e used t^ke+j
CofA&de&iv^ -\^l si»^u+ejr lfiva+ ^iVe *H*r$ c^£-e &.
Accuse o £ AciieA/j by f^eix cLoAJC.n^^%id^aj p&l!c?e.$. ^d LI I*oc> ffCA £)*+>€! C<) , (uiUich
OLze*$p4CiWl'' Leao. I$&s*ec)?e.fW JLmpfi&pe A uisclo&~-
vtLoo6 (rtXi),fy)AS).(71(g), Or) ***** (h)tfate*U p^o^M

   "Hie /v^^j psiaiHeft is T^x^s £/V;/PAA&c&cKsjcdG*-
/heM;es Code 101.05^ u*k:^k p)*:d/y S"M^s- &£$•
Ctf^'HoAjA^y Poioe^i *- T^rr dUcpr^n doe^ /JQ-^^ppi^
~~ho Ck c_lc*l/^ b&-&£ aJ^o^ fle^u f/Ze^Q^ iw /« <^7 t^ p&?r(^A/^ Vo/? ^ 9u o^C^ /•£ /^e /o.w /?*-

   Tkt, A/o aJ -pe&r€aas*&/t (l t>-£ r    T^k&s C^»de o*C Co.\m-
e,li\^J5: &c£4yCode$bfl.c>(>C&L7) (My ci^.W/^c^-
;a; ^ j?S^ pfi6\rSd.i.d i»y /^U;)^ a^+, /^.a^ /$
plcx'tri *jiy£A' »^ g^vs A/e>l i.A.ieA T^a4» /'f3fc/ l*ec*.l4U. Mse^S/fee*)^* rfMosf"!**   £oa4&»M be""
1,'eve- +kA.*H*H%« eke£e*>d**.*+' k*$ c*. a-*€ajK*J il\jj€LS$ ^
-#,* Je4€^aAjf* ^y f L* /ocetl yMcu/ffeJ Lted^ii /Wt^«*e-
/Vy ©rt tkAJortUea d!$t^e#egted e*^e*.f eKpe£ie^ce^*&A
^yc^\r4iect /aj *h^a/£*' AeaJfk 7^=» 4&hetL**i*te tjkeiUelL
 •/£& de4eA*d Sc^/y (W,
 /AA/flUftfie. 5e<2Y *T<£sl&>S GcvepAiAneAtr (Lode. §3U.o/&
j-ho/us apply uaj ler_£ -Ht CflAJT^yf *'/*/ ^oVu'ci, -/-W^
LOojtcJ &<£ phfccJ&e appe^/ii Asec&sSciP.}J% #e-a/'ifi-£$ c<
<$C*-G£#£*-«J'^ comsfauc^tvjjf oA unless eb^E^/of Go/uirteoe-
7voa/S./s e*Sp&es<,iL, p/Z^ldeJ by si^j-u+eS *(i)^ May"
CP£cd-&S c\'>CS\~'rCS^o^cL^ Autkoa'j'hy bfi, <& £ Ad^cts +^Ws £ou/if o-€ jtype^fs n £e ^
0~€£)ce o-4 -hUe a.ppelUdfc Habeas aoKpai R£cozd%
 i'aj "M-e {i^u oHf ZlH-^lX. Tki&t Hubert petrf/'o^^
^^we -Me appeH&^'s oajI% sqtft/'V/^g Med>cu\ ^J
AliAi^) ^/fl fiecosidsclue -J-& fh^fi^ Cowry's p^~

                                   3.
W-3 (Pfe^e. AJca4^ ~fVe "trW^ <^^d oui/uegsUip <*•£ iUls. doca/vWT,
Guicfc -\~ke_ Dcchss ^/r 4Tr«i^/^&^r$ ^ecxs/^d^^^ <
A^^Aj^kf ; Jl^esSsCX/ucJ iUe. j^edrCc^ro^j/a^:--^sycoifKCL^oy
LXSZcJI ~ro£ AtAJ o/C Jtptezsiojejj Sue-** l*±&e\^d /4, £00^- Qe^eAaezX -no Me*hJ He**\±L **rcJ
MzaAcl.1 /Zzi^JcA-lz^ Ao-f-U/t^'tSj Se.e.J F/wi/-Jkii,iUI,llty
ola^cX oaj /y-4-A^-W £^t\ Z^oOS pzcopjl^jj -epSsvdt^

dcckzJ a** Apptf/Q/SLOGi ;f- ^oos1 J?<^v ^ ©iA.-c-t3-£ef-
cxf^ p/zerfc'i &. I tzJ&h^l+Jee. i^ka^ L)&${r |///e<^'A//A ,
iJk'cL ;s &&epxi&ed i~* -Otle "fti/_r ^ufu/l u*)Je£
H^ Te*** /^^/fUf S<*£ry *c4> § 4/A oc«( /?fco/?^ a^/ze^&Aj /2ecoftd V^fA'i

    Oa/ p^^/^.fW^ (2oo.Aity SUcWi o-rfv*.* —
Med;t.cl £>/v,Voa/- H^f/i AssessA\e*jf- Al 03l1>-
(12/do) Fo&m , cAcA~Cc\ fV\c^y Ir^Qoo I 7 Midlt+A #/s^*y
s £ou*Ay bbcvfi^^tr) dcd^jd Sept'-
e^hefc 06. oLoo<* &«d o.^>^ oat **s~ Ae_^ a,c ^
pe(i&fJ . t*JcJvd>'*icj d/u o^itea. op ex.qe^r t*t pc^'d §e#W off-tdoQ£
A*e>~^ /AicJucfe «3-aj iyAjd&p^Mcle^n- CoAj~t/e*cxi)sz a^ g^£a/t o/e
employee £>-£<*. i'od&pes*e}e.Aj{- C£>/^T7sovgaA^*AjfoJ Uurt"Sheavs (A) +U:s ShcU **,d ^H

othefc £\o,e^Ctei be&rt->*A**. d'^ePe^/l- oferi^veL'fvoA'S &A*d cxK
depoPr/^esfrf, b66'd
aae^c;«?c dA-iMJc.'/s i AA/ci CooirhXS) *>pel*T4C*I £uh.AiviiJ**l p-£

Qo\y^./;Aae.A/f "T^6 S"n»cK»5 Aa^s/ At/f UoAr'"fy oG v*jLt't_ti c/€e
C^tP.l/ed "6Va /*-\ "/~W CjOA*€ti'h/Li'Q*J tf"P ~7<*YAJ cs< ^^cy^
/aujs p&s^e^cJ by Jea! <. led-v /z_e u^eJe a -h^< ^a/^ rrfot-.Sayv/. ,
   (?) S$CGpe £>-£ ^r^pf^\IHg\ej^r /V»^^Aj? A,o AJ&^C-ifloa^/ZcJ

O^s+v K^Vyo , G/Z c^s^hd*JLAS "
    ~T~^e eY^^S^e^ce 0-£ c Leq& I cl*J~hy i %&- <2^e-3>^Qso o^
4-so/^ f\£<<; o ecu a/zed. %&&) £•&££&&& Hwsi***. 7ja. &.\/. PLUSps ft®1 S.^d> S'l^-.Sar^Tiiri^iey

i^xo^i^ i^s AJof uyeCivec) u-ud&(L T2z/.os*4(i> (wR*/«wj*m).. Sl*sce hkuaats G>oAy 4^:Ud

Cv-o4 \e*A/e-$ AJO cI/'SC^Vo.aJ ^oft "Z^e <*.efotf. "fts Co+iUd«JZ^
HetflPif Cao^A-y /S AJO+ //virwu Af£ "tI^oa* fi*;_s eii/ll cxci/^>Aj-
because, i r uiAS -f-iv^ Op&\Lt /*&~t* Ctmse o-£ s»y /Vjva/fij.
^L^ci 4i>£ e<~pl&ye£ uj}£>fl-Lc*-cJ Qcx-TSe'cJ*. o-£ l~L^e. /«-cj.
se^j" /I'^^p £_Wk^/*ce bevelopmedk?Tftc v. \fa* Zl £k> ,

^LppfeZ/^Aj'ts Dn£ PfaXLaCS fi?''jLir<> Uolvc loe.e*J vlolled -fe/Z
t?rt.'/w^ }aj -fkijs S-hc/^ .$ d. ^ D*£ &• mv*j* / P/^o -

                       APPELLANTS FSPLV
                      TO APPELt££5 BRIEF

6U*f«4 $-hd«^7«f U.S                       (Aolf\ #5«ei«^Ai+4-0'
   Oipe. H&p:p?S Cov^y SUe.pt-G€s /^edited ^^d M&*rhil
Mea-f-fU, /IssessAi^^f" Oo^t^/He^sx-h^l^ o-f-fWe \
t\$jd &&**yG^)&s CeAe %lOl»Od±[ CO. u^A^aj e^pphcd "fe

/6.aaCA> **»«* ^ ^.g.^T^^fekObj^f V. ~T+»y\de PAepeAiy!

    The %\c&\x\es oXsove. &11 pea.^*^ Tro Docu^*^
R-tcofccliy T^fo/e/n&4^A'; ^V^/^/AJA-f/oA^^ RepealsjfUse
a«e ^Tooh txge-d •&>£ /M**>y 'el? &/**.*& s+td^ZH f^A'

1                                   *.
/ *Ja   o   -^flOJ , OZ I (z.) /aJ C4>Aiy?a£i'$6 Ai^re /gUSC. ^
ISM i &<2£AU$e lOl.Otl CO speaks o^ Aie-rWdU.-
V£aj \/e^hl &<^ e^jJpr-sheA/v- aWsa / -/- ^dc^/d?
\q£ Scv^£ 'f-o SAM^/^'.^t'C^ oJot^lal toe. sp£}
q£ <\lt o-f-U^A Vy^e^ &*€ 4*tij\loU ppapeai-y aa 0e^1
pAr*^. <»*//- p/«..jj s;
Me^^~cc\ s4-«Tro & £.VC^/vi,,.«j^ir^>uJ
p&ajA&fS AJcdre ? a// o-C- -tLese APie. "bso /s ^A*-A
doAJ^-frfai^ ^Hu^^ye f&op&iiy': 5se£* 7fe.vecus 0^-
o^ A4.H./1<£.4. tf 7fe#y ^/7 ^2d 707 •««** +

bohege X Gec'e \^ecJ -lie juej/ec'h -/© uyos i^L^i- uoeae o#-d£./2.ed fey UfZ.&e^l) s&&
Jacu^fcp>J>i p&ye. i IHS a/o^ /sec0 ~tUe &ppe/A^lr ^> £<£ s koved o^-l~D £
jUe. C«u*jTy 0A' ' UiJ-PLoKT A/f WAti^^Yia'f.'oA/i' a^.
C~a(lt ®d fZej&Acf^-o U'^5 S^^Z) loei^cu placed /aj ^
hh/hele s<; €>be./'he./Zj A)o~\- A-e^roiisJec0 ^ Zt/^ ha we i^
-pccte k))^${-t&e.J) puss polled-s i"^s!Je cf *)oie ^e~
hi/oc\ Wis &&p~$j eyes s>toolle^v, glekyeletabeJj c^^sd
Uu/oa/l^i) '(rfi-o Ai %l&ep'*>G e>/u tU.^ Co j->(L 0u."f~
<5>j£ of-f^ke 54-^/e o-P/lope Af'$s>'°*> bec-^use +%e#.e
 S<*r€~e qcKvfccIs ~~h> p/zol-ecrf *~n€
pe^'-GbfL R.evieu> Jii.jjti4 +U&4 Soffy {^ea^MRes RequipeJ hsy
JcuJi allocs a So/'-f ^bfC^^ert c.'u-'/^c^/o^'^c^^
A/oi" t "V- aISo be c^pphe_d */© .$4^4u4w*-<-i ,$&.-£+^ £e&4u&<.s
plated h^ /d^/s/a4u &e i~* pZo^ec-f u^ol^Js o-Q fke
 /-f^/irs CooAi+w £'LtJil€£s V*f^' ^^ Scfc^&LA r^eArhJ
I f Itsezses. ?.

S'fzcKA <*-W C&A>S U^OOVri'o /O |^cv<^i ^^ dfcu^f o44kle^if)fS^Pp. I&-I1 o«^VtA?^
&aj/m iA3S>€a^ ©"£ ^^'at'a/cv/ •j'C.b* hjh^f "/"/*£ Sc^C -
cS^ArdcK^Js ^'Lou/j &'so apply Jj& £iui I l/cib&t'g*
    .._,  , .    M COAiCeA ( £CA T^C TcCTS T^u*T T«-\£y
nauftci^Ajs o'f App.e-fprc\ ddeTZtrA/^e ^o^^/ajg ie\ze/?e
Al£.Ajffc.| clepge.fS'io *}, 4^c e^aj cJ A/ a/? co41 c /ne&: ca4/oa/ £ fo -|-Kee4
  T^yca-s P^J £*>ci*L# c£3.o£lfcOGC>(A)6>') ^yt; /f H*
pe^o tJ e^p **& I* ^ft/^/n a Uyd>/e.oy: ^ ^mt^va?-
a+£; oa kei-e./^t/ue +»f"U^. v'^'avi o-f-fUe o"r5«Ai$e. <-o*rH,

et/u "fUts tf^ud Dp-ocj IT/otJoceJ TS~Ll^/ R §^2d sZSAyZS*
(Te*.C;*. App - ^«a//4a^av.v /67j) -fl^p t^of^ %VU.S^ ''a*^i
4© au>1" d ^2. \qPi/ employ ^p
e>P opply "fo ^ yiv^A*' poppase* lokJcb Hc,ee^ ^ou^t^ ^e$Uet&\
"j~o c&o )fj v)z>\cc\-\&jj o"£44^£ /«cJ.
      O^a; appall£$T£ Ccnji<£TZ Co/-> Si^C^A.yP/dA^ ^fu 4iv^ J lj«v5 ^
v/crz- o4 4"U^ p/A/A/iri^j. &k>gI Cook ir> rUe plezdte?
                               HECK
   X u3ou.lc) h Ue i^ b^'AJ^ 4-& FUe aifdAjitoAi ~€ 4k
£ou.71&~$^ uikr c iv )aj4-U;s d<^s^ caaj a>o4~ See-} Hetk v. M^&&gH *\*n
f^2.ci< 3 55*.

                            VBNUE

Ve^u e c^ajcL dW&fijCj e o F ve^itse d cc ^ Aj&s4*AieKd:Jt FUe.."1&\*-
Vt $ ^c>^aj4^j £oiaAF idatos^ 4Ai£ 4~*ea>f* .*&'**- ^'^s^e
Scr>^-» ^ 54vl"Tc> s To FLe -§ f-£ } F ha.d he_£Aj ofi.1-
cA/oc^Wj-f i*JS'(-}i~»>i*-J ?v H^cA- CLots/zF see: SF^**J*ad
S^^e &L*cu*% Ass'a/ &AI-JfeA tlH SMZd. /la I} ol^icX
go-\^~t 4W ebo-MCxe. #'r votd. he clause Ye^-^/s C****Ay
toxoid a-© 4- £- A*aj£<2 fie UeA/oe cji-H^ou^F S^hj(e^A Al^ffe/i
"•Ja£« scb o f be CA'SSf^iss&cJ WXTH P#~
e.$vd%-ce. be<-(XKj%e i ~f -FUe Tfclc^l Cou/zi /^cl<^ /4t>^s4»A/ C'Ht&h^J Zooo MepeAjj &> clrS9^'ssc»\
l^itU C(Ld.\udiCQ, rS C~ £i*>c~l C^edS ke+> O/J fK# *^efi.f\-$ .2i>
Black o.A>d r^fcife, c*ho to> Aio$W*A^ Su,v^Ws
S/g' S^. V. 7«,75lf £m.wO
                              PMve&

   AppelUsii (zespzcA-QuIIt-* tie^uesis
 \v*± (Aechae u/oje/i p^-^^IF^ e£ pua^isay ~ in accordance to state and federal guidelines.

giocerplyrN
   rle Pr5.ce, RHIA
Medical Records r*.ana§er
Harris County Sheriffs Office
3-30-11

   I, Lcyd London Sorrow, Do declare, under penalty of perjury, that this ie
 true and correct textual copy of the original letter I received" form'the Harris
County Sheriffs Office.
                      Executed this oH         dav of JW^*..A^ii«cit,^brrow# 1134905
                                             Terrell Unit,     1300 Ptt 655-i