Court Opinion

ID: 4074820
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 05:23:36.22511+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:22.747622
License: Public Domain

'_731(‘.0 uv4 of aviw\mé\j iava csc TQ)¢m]ing &34@1€31 /Fr_wme/vuk:' P\eaze me ~IJ\/\as. mmi pmwa
jr@ ~Hu)_ Cauv/)r 81 ('Miv\`»v\a,l mfle 0{#`7€1@£-.9/9&.&0_ Pej'mm i'\oj'\`<'_v_ v
ma hines 1b JM ¢W\i@e/d W\mJizm§ 591on

_l`\/l<\/\J< \’lw, blon &SSiSme. `\3 `S.VQA}W é\”{’¥€é]§)‘(€l~

key PeaHul\H>,

(

"_§P.SSQ Qa*'\ W\`\\QX :S'\~
'_TDC, M>. \°\°LS 133
_ 00 mivu"ouaz C/Im‘\r
, _ (0535 CAQ\/m. P,A\
S@M Mmhm'Tem 7315;1

 

‘1`_` v\" hei'\;u(`f£ur"\‘fo¢»@r¥ m’}g§l_ §§ a \ 192 ‘Gl
° ` j iam -\-___ ` - s _ -
.Ex Mr¢ m’&‘“f§_%,,@§_§& _Lm 'M 351 *IDLM.@#

 

 

, ‘~n.c+. w ch»;\m»/¢z_ .CM¥ @£
§ \'\QW§$ va\% ¢/TP.XU -

:e§_‘iepa‘*l milw,:v.»
' ”D?h'célv\j( {)'w'$e. §

Apr)h@@»/\B SMpPiemev\h! £Mr `
g ?es'?ov\div\_ SJalefi l{]h%emm{i§

/7: nw )L/¢m))é[o/Q `:(u\ disd csc ~_Qa?il‘ Ceu\th_` v '
/ZYW//Z'Am[r Te£’_ NYLZ]M ll-~’-/[a £M'v\lah/!@d{ LJ?~HA {H.SZ V@»mo)'\`)’ Anv» C.C.io., in -Q(¥am[u§le, 4
H/Ln_' C@v\s%|im/\Al Mc.|£l '\§lO»l/$¢\°I Q'v\cl \§Q~c| ap *MA.Z//m£ &Msl'i]rwlh)v.,
g'n`a\[ Oz`sd_u§£iom
‘~“Ih MM/‘/z.~m_q ibp/seams 'E~L@Mjr£ Zedrm a DQF»»il/.Hw m a
\`DWL p)uca§sh RL@M' la ;l " Fa@YTviJl"{)»`\/MM P)*l f(Mido_ l§\°l op M//`QXU
C_M\QH\/khbm. - .'_Iv\ C@M’}vum_°n mamc{él_l'w"l AIIMAMISl/»Vvlo/vJ-$ `EF_Q\AW)`\M

` 'C@»Mawomca`s m 4b1 Fowv\ dr SQ)@ DF£ev\Jo/v 'Re_l_>>`zs]r\c.\)€\ov\ Bln}w_ UMW #YL_
[03~`003~ \/M\/usv\'£ L4vm-CC.p_ L/]FPI\`L‘/.Lv\" him Om/\u\`(‘}é>z£ jav\u;l)\/H ]Y¢ l°l@

Fc~r P:Me and w$evle/MA 41> 5 °lem,. ami m lawn 17‘%‘,4015 Amrc/wjr
was pumisl/l@z§ ;lm{ gen/\LQMM 115 lb Hem fw §a'\\mve.b Keszs\tév lum/m Y;w

`V\H-U_ was V\ol\' pm`ided -
AWHw/\H luwlemewhl Awuw@l
Appzw+ ;.v..,bm mm 1§29@¢ mng @MAAA~¢M 43 (
£zv\S{Vt/LQ_ £4»'{12‘,[]; l/¢§I UOW\¢>M'.? ldvm.(‘,.(',{). TM 1014va is am ¢LLL yale J~l> pm)/e,`
JJL\L Yewvd‘o{' pma/mdin e{¢“§:arv IUHJM_" V&&v£(}v)& #dvl/\m£s\/\vm/»\~l¢ wm Q.
d E\:\uvé_ 11\> Cz>m/\e’“'l LJE`H/\ \M/ul Té.§u`rve.Yl/lM/nli MVlcl(L/)/ 114/dr llog~.DOl/Suw\/A.

m \

 

= IQ'VN\M,W‘ invokes Q'v]r\d,li \§)9~ op TIA.L TQXH£ CQMM~M{':¢W¢ anal Cl/\AuQJ/\Q\éz
H/\L MWSHLAHMANH @f' Ml_v_€ll.o_°> C.C.P gmi U/WL/r`&)l~ool Cr:.{)---
F.lzmv@, Lvemsjr€)v is MJQA as a (‘,wwmal ?MAAI+H-~Umlwaj/\Mn hug
TQS}YA? md op his )\ lr)@r(]r\/ PWAYV\§§ L.)H{' ali HJLJQ!U CAVMS.£Y parr!~£ awlel

QY®LL) il&o'?ax 38’(0
¢QW/¢ca,w{' ;11[ max ~HA.z jbl¢ [\;\[e¢l -Wz> vai'da am fudgka MeJ/Hn_»

Pmsm&v\+ la ;NL H Lllo (‘, C,P 4b SIAM,> ~Haa} affl»`eAM LQ£~L;\ lile vaidez&
_|/\H'\M_ op élv\‘i FMMVQ CMSG,‘)ue/l/\Ca.$ VLQ\ZWCI` \/L`_°) \/\\A1 Pv\`o\f @¢v\uimlwv\ /lpvlc/a)w\'
`\CM\L€/v\A.S ha L»JL VMA' i\/,L¥\W &A¥v\em_<;\»\£/§ c>{» MGBM£€.°)uwca/x c>iL ‘\Llwve_ {'v 'Vé£x§h/\f
'iv\ D{’e/v\ CMUA' \t\/w\l V\€Q\&]r`\v\£z Qv\°l raw Y\H‘\c,v, .Lv\ 314/nw V Um). 538 U" 3
3<+ @003.`); );BS,QL_ 1b nw w BH.DYM haw held ¢AHW_.»\ amf

i/Vld%/\DA_Q ap mhp\`ankmn W\A\/ be Qua`¢h]/le.\`.l;s QHQBJR\/o_ h W\;lk¢;`\¥ (,m{~<'_m)

VA:\A- 041 ‘H/\L mel CAHAQM‘{ mr \u/~.z 'JMAQ)G,W\QM*' oil ED'mva`a`liD\/\li`c)av\l§ TQPMHL)L mmuic;\icv\ is ove/v 30 lmws old'~ Cl/l¢wlw
(..'a[l (',~(`.-p. Luéla Vlml Qvl.~ill}~ecd WJ-_ U O]/l&n/_&\M r`m`M w\M/nL ij 913!> fm
l/H>[Qj)°l)\q mc `Tex` P. E\/`\£(. &Ocl U>). `D,\Ls cwmeh/\ Ls im?eacl/\m_o, ‘HA l)oLMla\/\l‘r
Mhmw mm w@. mg h mma 1b hugh wl wm midway QM
C)mlt.)em\/\s ‘HM_ f)w[oa)|w\/e. Ua}w)_.

Tm flMiL`\a-v\ r \u,d; §]rale`x includme op ‘Hu_ mama --_"L_>\A:l!o_ `)'LL pmm
LJ§L\A 21 V@{’ovhua_ lim/wreij ¥:¢v RaPe.u .- - is Qv\ diem/1011 4b Aisawva.ae.
~LLJ,AQ{“QM&\/ul er\vv\ ammj€iv\_e> his few LAW\@M\me/v\f KIQJA¥ h il 1163 \0*1 `SM ,
‘Tbu_ De{ev\M ;ll{u>)@_a ~I»\A'is 33 ` Pwsewhm”&l \}Iv\d?c:l'iumd§- lilliasz ~HAL_§+A)LL
1b m wl ~,V,A\LLM AWA w ogle-MAML 3 w w ;.,.M@l ml_
"'I_l/\;_s` Pl/\%LS\L FYa§i/\A{M ~Hu_ how Q_M`¢m+ `H.._a de¥£MAaw{'

()5.'}~

 

 

B/e/\/l W!oYe,`SPa&`r‘>?c.£\,“‘h 41/\15 “ ?h‘VASLh- &vu"41`41/\4'@ QVQ,'MA1411C\Z~\4 SMYH ULRJ_A&`

Wu phvé_i\@, 45 1444 pél\'§r 04 4411 344‘41/\41_"'["1/11$ 4)1!\_\’439 i5 1404 311/x Q,\eme/v\+ op
4-\/\`15 3444014~45 Ca>v\54\¢u44"lo./\_ `T\/le,ve pma 44/\'15 47\/\‘¥43@, 15 4444 ;\U\`vl&(§`\c:l"\ owal~
` 544 44,104 1144<:,4.?,, 445 144!414 145444. 144 540.54 445 Cw-
“141’1'-»~ 445441 4004)`

1535 4411/454 455 145414 40 44401“44 444 4441`44441/ 311/141 03044444| 144414

301 OI, i/ 14 1:4? `Tb_ 4411/454 411134154444:§11~‘1 413 1444/v 444 434£43444)114 1445
il 4))'16¥ own/114me 44/\4‘1' iS V\A4 444411112& 4\0’1/ 0V\4141/\c.n_v\/\Qn/1)4' and Ls 1444 2

-jmms'\d <‘_4\'14'\4.4 alaimo/114 44 441/154 044¢5/154, C4/\4)v<4014 alumm 4455@)4.141/§1141/10404144. -
444/1454 44 444 4644-

' `_4'1711.<. the, 0.4\41'1134 1444/1044 4 Cor\uiczlil)h Mv\olé'\/ C444P4€/1/ 401 V¢W.C-C»p

° Cov\Vi §1'1444 44`13 0149)`11144 541114414€5. 4345 Fov 5`1€44/5

°Ex P054 F4145 6441454 1445 W\p4v14 44 9141141/14`;1119`14Y4Y\/ and 944@11444\`\"|

V1'1/11444iv4 145154441411”\/\!@41/41/ V (#`11/51¢141/14l H§O 443 214/34 lo\ 364
<)oo. 47 L wald 146/940

' wl 34444 1441/411 pmluacad E0zdem44 -41/144 444 141>1’>1544414 h1459i1/e/1/1 Fa:v
/1/441'41)_. `IF 444 manual is 041/414 04 614/4454144`1\9144’191111 401/ a 031/11/144'14‘14
344 Z:`l/idem4`\4?\"1 v 41@4\/11/\2\ C4/14“9V\‘he(4 15 C09n12&40\€, ov\ 4_15)441 44 44.3140041£
CoYM/LS . Ex 341/44 0411'44€3, 0,!`5 3b12144 £HX CCv.,Cw'l/h. 4405,4

94 3

 

 

Co\/\Cl usiov\ z
Wl/\evo_fovo, pr\/\`xsel C.omi(\é\€‘.{l nwll(,£w][ \0¥&‘/\3 H/\`\S HbMoYAl/:JQ.

C¢>uv: 9mm/133 blm MH»/caal l/.JvnL whn/\ (Lomc}ud\`\r\.°) H/\a} H/\L Cl/w;-U)iv\£\
inSHmme/w} wall indeed \/md. (Zxv P.Me Pevm)lls,(€v, i!FpP~ 1790 357€)€.
Cvsm. "`/37, 3‘/3&) IQO; amd his aomidiam pc/mhlive 611/dim Viol@}il>h
@€ Ey w ma clam@,u.s,<:.¢a. ama wm mo cl., l , w w
.l§vfdemha)vh Ex par/a hpafrirm af #r# illu$ (;‘C;»F. / 1414 //¢% C,c./.,@m{
Cl/).[ofl I£#,C¢C.F having pmuea' 109 7th V€C@'Yd H»w} )Ulll &W/)W

was mut requirm/MZQ@J" 79 wider S/m~_z_ he wax nez/ev
F@fr/‘/ 3a1/mon £She@/ my 317/m kw //ml)u 7‘0 rag/wien

 

   
 

   

 

SLOs_z/M 9/1/)0{ B/\le)vecl cm ll `ez! FCUH:u”V gubw\¥H€
+1/“: day of v¢é. 9015. j
ii€_$ _X'Y W’\S\B
newsom male
EHSKS (L@,_°)i/\ov\ 12€1

S;\/v\ Wv\‘?'z>m> T€XAZ> "')$§9'53

{)b,‘~i`