Court Opinion

ID: 6547992
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-19 22:21:15.439602+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T15:56:01.481955
License: Public Domain

Hart, J. In the year 1901 J. C. Speed was appointed the guardian of his minor child, Effie Speed, who had inherited an estate of the value of $150 from a deceased relative. No further steps were taken in the guardianship until 1908, .when J. C. Speed filed his final settlement. Effie Speed, who had become of full age, filed exceptions to the settlement. At its May term, 1909, the probate court, after hearing the evidence adduced by both parties, found that the guardian was indebted to his ward in the sum of $95.25, and rendered judgment accordingly. On the 18th day of June, 1909, J. C. Speed filed an affidavit for appeal to the circuit court. Effie Speed married and became Effie Ery, and the case was docketed and tried in the circuit court under her married name. The circuit court rendered judgment in her favor for $126, and J. C. Speed has appealed to this court. The record shows that J. C. Speed filed an affidavit and prayer for appeal in the usual form to the circuit court, but it does mot show ¡that the probate court made an order granting the appeal. This was necessary in order to give the circuit court jurisdiction. Kirby’s Digest, § 1348; Matthews v. Lane, 65 Ark. 420 and cases cited; Walker v. Noll, 92 Ark. 148. This court has held that the appellee may waive the want of an affidavit for appeal in the circuit court by failing to move to dismiss. James v. Dyer, 31 Ark. 489. The reason is that the affidavit and prayer for appeal is a regulation for the sole benefit of fhe appellee. But the order of the probate court granting the appeal is a prerequisite to the right of the circuit court to exercise jurisdiction, and for that reason can not be waived. It follows, therefore, that the circuit court should have dismissed the appeal because no order of the probate court granting it was made, and for this error the judgment will be reversed and the cause remanded with directions to the circuit court to dismiss the appeal for want of jurisdiction.