Court Opinion

ID: 4067985
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 23:40:13.017857+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:34:04.439451
License: Public Domain

044 44_213,// /1@791 3041133 3061'1"190~1

` eouRT TQF CR:MmALAppEN__S_"_

g @¢1£1111  ' :&%14§1/ QMM_
/\
;1<€§9 MT‘\~1C4~D ‘&CQ§ y d COU/l+ 652 Abezzq/)H’G ' 219~2%

 

 

 

 

 

 

§§ l 4> 1111/1119 1 1919_»‘1§1111454 4
AM§YYMA+s:AJPP 11611:1:/)~&2 119&15 &1194$_ \j 4

;mefL/L)QLQ 9_4£1123.2€€1_12 34 31460.‘111>4\4 410_11)'4&1411,_0.144
1 MQKAM%+%LHDMZ_I_@`£§JS 4011“11/3¥91/11’ 911\1;9"

' __111‘4:1_14411>10@411'_¢§1;1¢3<51»9_ 5_1[1{>1133444411)“1'134131_11_14€;14
§11@\414£_91411+1> @1,331411 44+91+%114.;11111@411}1
944 _ 13911141//)113114&1111)1 412141`>_4213_+4&0111)1115444

 

 

 

 

 

  

 
 

 

 

   

. 4 _@11\49'41011111!<§19/1499110 110/207,4€>}1@111‘)`1‘3'11('/€04
¢40113_13@4,1341 411 ¢[Q¢¢&M;L@>_Ampmamj§:)’£m:¥u&b .4
3 _ &2_‘1§4151€11)34 3 _ __411)_9/1)_17_@1131»1:>4'31304[1@_4
_ .MDH+B'!@ 1301:)1 / 1+,'»

 

 

 

 

1 _ _@2 011§431@&3141.'1:1/1€11£“1€$14241:&{\&¢1#1 %619- `1'1\/4 _1
4911911‘11311-.1441 mma@¢\ m 4911131+ )3_11¢11 on 14 314,1__

0134419314944»9,_/4..1»43419 Q_G.404 4011:1_1£13494@4311@@0 _139@:1#@1_4

 

 

… 30141;¢1/\’1’1310” 1610111193 4 1104 011'5. 1110
Mwm§£)m!w 911>:1_ 1135

.4904_1@_010¢111'>1@3§1¢19€4@41411119&»314@041454

’ _ _11)

_L)MM?:104000044+2
`}4)¢0 114Y4 014»'\4"/4§$624'@ 4'%0»4'* 4/1¢ bn 604 4 )ec)”b_‘k£’no_~¥_ mL-_ &,9_£4¢04-.

[LC¢Q) 2/4/41;/\4'4'10 4’)2 ,@Lu.~)a:l 0)£\0`414715;0&104:0€40%'¢04@5`4‘91$\9£>§%5`41@0
L})Q.AA»QQLLMDH 1:014'01`0309»/\¢4_ 400104§<) 0

(1)0111 4 000¢: 110)00~90 0{)00+00000040__

§§n_m(p §100113;3_/00&0 64:10+0 we§>I_Q@. 11400)00 ,

\4’4131 § usda bj_@i§$§ 091010_0_,06)10_500/6)0+2¢&4¢¢4:4@4?1©__4401[}0)
MM%Q \71¢» 064/ux 90>_0':1:401 004;10»904400&10&;50 019¢51413)~ `

w 4900>0@&0@0 _/ lt &QCM__ 000 9002020405@000 1004'_0
0(,@/1#\'\`&’\_4\‘§\.2 § '_’ z

0000€00090 110004_00_0_000>0' '1?0/ 1001 0 4411 840+$
655 CA§S C¢)u/H`\\.._ /)`WLQ/ /10¢#/ COLM,’]F_@H£@¢L 1045_/_)<;_10/_~43 C){’_)H_~ ‘

633 ibm m 9004;!110.11¢,00 0
@111)@¢104@//0) 1440/1440 544+; 406

0_00(‘_‘4040 461 b 2004/14 0514$ 1§16/\46;\060:49909455_ 950¢15

5b jp. 1064 0050;;14010 &010000 000
OZWHAA+MAJDQLWW/’LMM @Le_:l§§,i@ x

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 

 

°’3~_754<-1-949@£4645901043 .

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  

1009 4110:00_03_%4004004
0_95400 @r_\ 1519 00 9\4_4450_90¢>10006404’_

W;z:_\#n #042,040 4:<`3[00 AC;”jST 9005‘{:4§\?@! 00[@2004£&
/_\_L_,Lm_ 404/k C\HM_ L(n £Q)_/MDG&]MC,\
%£_CCLUQ).M&M+ £_£05_\€% 9510%:9_ n_ 00 0 _0_ _1‘_ ae\_+b_Q¢éLLCM_)/v

0640&0@40[0/0£0./\ jh}m_ 00 MKL@L»Q+ jQQ,L`M::;fg
‘M~CG~'U'O 40&?)0 03¢20 CSWAW

2&4'2¢4
QbLU’) 43 Kn¢iu)o+?~H/\<_m%` l (a) d§;h$r+,an,% MZEESC 'BB% BGUJIC

 

 

 

_Qalh:i_.:i:hho__ `i@l_£ftchilc.h _/_OC 'iD /Qi>vi~]::@i/ »'Zim#/_§?i¢t'liiqumc'
_ ccid/iADLA/\'Aflime ichli _/ii_c>ici, iii/jac mich_c/)_h
.:i%w,@u.§izri~i-i[ii/Ci_ _ illogth `i’/’)cmp`zé_ lh$/-_ jilc/Qiih €/l:im__hcihu:ié»< _

C’»i h…/Qi'i Dc,_ lc£du~c\:i-_h__h>¢i,¢)ii$_ /Obi~_i~@v`ccf_ 630 C£__. ,_/") _

9., l.' uih` gchi_shili§imci@ri:wi:h,_iig \ch\ bmmhp,®_ €lhci¢li.`-__ hchiojht%c£uciz¢/w v) iiic iii)ip\ ccn+

i'zt ich\:hQ.).' hci/cmwlth c)nhQ;hhh’hhci_é_\_ah@cchi

AhLéiz€Eiij/éil;i; eicc$h M/hic>_ %_Ccih$iad~j _c> ji)l___/F/i iii [i&hhi“]__,_
ijhhchechhhcticc;hhhh_ e€czzh hhSMh/cc,hm chlhhh_+ wh hh__
tgt@lg m -A-?ZlfA/zsns'l ii

iii t%ihchiioch~iich'itcm ;Qviha[_ @'c);il » » ` _

_ , l icfi @Oim i\i -}iiiZK/-MSZ)S @Z€)cliii;icér)al_ Dh}ehi>@§iie
_QHLMLin/h _illl:i?_)_ his “iQ@rficc>l lehD.€~F¢ ael?_,_@_c:c)iczm c i&iniS/mi)cmi“
. ' cch M,@@i;cchd;chchiih h ' ,_ __L

h \Si)) \~ ;’lhch/mh h.'h lhcczch c+/hh> uhh/h)Z ithAiiL)hhw/czeclhh

boid;ii)cid:izc_ QH§ ~Hll/i_c_shc/;éiQ/ZL/)_G£S_S ih A~ic\ _/,>< an ii¢ugus')‘
' §i, 211/l inch iiC@/\i»m¢ousi' JAVtCi:/;i?chiiirpoi Ccc+ /5 '

ii&tiw`- icciii +c> hhs i iio) YY\Dh+iiJShJA;_ LL»\mmLCU_Q/ui-_L/\__

_`i:i’i£_CQ/E:ili.if€l_i¢_ dc, CuSiD:/»l J,£ -,ilir//ib"i'iizciz.

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

~13)_ h

 

§D\c_Q\c)_ §Qi?>_-ii iiCchd* hQ€cthic-céwlh@
icc amici c gic cc.chiiicmc/iccccccchh

" z * Aggmi'@f)g i_ich:;_hb>ch mcmich

~ Jc.cli'~}iu /,,) )/V)hm°ivhill ill _ /"/imi} n .`hccg 'iicm\. hhmc-

i (_jhh§in cic illccccm-civc+~ric bhd \{hccc- mci

:i:/v icci)c@ A/i/ichir€hl on ol/v @cir§S @;cc/viiti\ i>h ii»u m§§é,§_i_§'l?,;i§c_ hci

_ fhwth chcc'_i _£i)ih§i’_vi:iSD&-L%clhpcl@li &:m%cch,bb/czm£éicGLcm/:
'iZ>Cic»c¢ hs_@li_iich?l ichilfi'z_i@éch:$_ lmciccc§cfl/\ ~Qll>£ccicchih_
O(llm¢/\t` O. .

cii¢o_ r illicchwa ibm alicia '-
cnh‘iji_am_i.ilicmhwi:ichi;\=fh/lij ` A:JiL chvh_”

. foil UL_`{Q<.®h‘i:ucccv£_Q£!i./{m£icicc)_[liclI/iim h ci_ ibidth Milbccu:

cch/chicch hhchchhilchchcc_+ cccth

cclcih_icbl,lcll ichhclhicr|i:§icl.c:i’i_' ihhj~£bc"> miamij,_icl&$hicc+
_illc,i`c_ Lilchi coh@n B_ _CSl/_>_r_c_-\L_
MQJLHA§'_LLQ//{¢ hoc Qi)i'>cc‘i: ilb;i“_~bb_ii i.ohc>_chc_ `i)hcb&.ci.m.c._ziz¢iipiiéfi";,h

(¢ci

i

 

 

`vv»i

lc)z¢c$__ %13 8c)ci,c1_5 Q\thlch;)im%cmjhuémc/mi_ch_m
_u_30 ~Q>Svi/c§ch -iO iich PZdCéc/zl o)i

:Am)cc %hcm_ mms [1/1>7 >cc)cg 121h1_c1ih11[ch cchh,h'_

ibm Qe/kSD/I Mc/ /,cc}> / &hzhc_h/)I;M_c_hn_éih:mlhi iLLJ_ZiZLSm)_e/i

 

SiDh?LZ&S§-:il) § ` hBi<._~b£¢__‘i’Sh§Qi'£cibucmlc)/_‘i$ c_?%z_ amici
M_` bus ui_ . 181rc,ch;1 icchL/htichlbih_/hh _ccj§c.ii_€c__

§ LM&LCSMMJLLL&Q)%ML@MALLB _%_

_`~-j_

   
 

§ ic_a£é.~/lhugh`ii?hhh h '

 

bachm£_cchlih,hiib)@_ mhccc§mhhc_

 
 
 
 

cch:_- @cccch.gc_€oich __ v c_high%clj§>chi __

~)h/Qbibb_c eci %@'V> glich

 

 

 

 

* icf hippichhih@mch ibcijizhhbbmaa£b£mc; »

   
 

8517/)115`31//22% /_/,07(‘<;;0)#11¢/ C/l`@ ii/m `

   

Q,c.c§_/? h ,
"i//IL` e i.g@i Ci‘i`€c_i c/\ @uz(`i¢` »-,i-(Diiig) mchl_’l'i'ho \SMi§Ci//) ijbk

g 1

_ci_bhil.ciciicii'_gg c - __ @/Hi:bdi€i.
` _ , ci$_i_§:i ZhLL;)»ih_&QcMLScRQ_~i ,h’l

 

 

dch r~ H-i'zi&

 

 

 

C)Dibc© ic/)b1 hzf§Oi +_Q€i_h_iich_`i:bb#$i:ihbchv
bcihiii?&i~bc:b§i;{- ecibbcML?;L/AMLMDCMMS@

1 i/`icvvv @Ocif v
M ' ` ‘_ ”ih%mb D Qcccb_ '
' __CS>k ” UQ/’zizsj'xw -

 

 

BHA 'i~ p-€JLL tim

1 i

 

\ b /1

 

Q/l"/_”z/z{ _'

  9 ©le/¢/M 351`3 913/9 b 1_111919,11¢11111;121311@1

 

 
 
 

 

4@;13%9:23130&;3:910 ‘- 1 3311319%5@9311111111
"U_)A,¢-'P/V ///74/30146 /1)1/],<§/1,£ /Z/O?CCD) am 7/1,1,91:@@';`/1)25;“ 1
1/1?97@111-71>21@~ 113?& 32 /,',@@ 11 - j_

 

 

1333 1311/11 313 1113 113-133 53 »

 

/%311 1311 1113/13391113311 11133111;, *

wife _:ZQWM/»» 11 ,` ~ ' ` .

 

 

199311313 11 71 15193 ’