Court Opinion

ID: 4040139
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:26:15.564394+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:28:23.851505
License: Public Domain

'   .....
               ,;"::
     ~I

     l'·'
     ~f:.              .

                           ..   ~   ·•   ;   ..   -.

                                                                   :-•···                   ........, ...
                                                                            :···:_·--··--..~,               ·:   ....   -·~

:'        '\       .
                                                                                   ... , ~-\1T"/1:'t~::'f::''l'"::-,,•·
                                                                                                      .     I

                                                                                                ···':.·.··

.~r~~ 1~,:·'/A~i~nl Cas~ 1~/;shJ                                                                                ()f        ~eAie~.~e.-!t.J                                    -/Ae.
;V;~~l:or Critvt:.,~(JJ.#~fs' ~ism;~~·f';~i~f IAe -v~~re-I!~YJo.(-r
~Rev1e.W
\'   '   "   .   '
                     ~o(.ee.d,,.,~
                     "   .   . ..
                             '     .. . .   .
                                                Wilhovl 4\~-r~,n~ -/he
                                                    '   ,.   "   .                 .    ~
                                                                                          /S.Sl)e.. o~
                                                                                                  .                                 .                       -            ..

~e..Ylf,~~ /;fF 'it~S¢. re_'f('e.Se.ye/q../;~ lSV\·aP.fet:,f; p;;e fO. ~\.,/;d:eb;
l'~r4~· Q~ 1/Pf'ea/5 {)ne. Ca11nol be. ~re. .of /A6 l-o.!3tt+ £Jr. ;;.·
 I , ,. ~
\\(1    . )f! .. . . . . .f~-,.
          . . 4;un          , . .lite:-
                                     '"' 1u
                                         . . . rPo.s
                                                . .  e.. of
                                                         .  ..1/ci"eA.S
                                                                . .     .·Q;
                                                                           . r ..Fb..s
                                                                                     . L)r.
                                                                                       ..   t:w~ · abuseJ
                                                                                                    . ...
 ~ t;;)~~re.~(.m. f'c;ir ·the- ;i>l.lr'Pase.. o+ 0... tJ.,;J cF Pl~ridtAr,../us./ ·
'f( 11~ -~n-1?.- ·?'Dl/~Y /{Q /Yl,',~'.#er;~l ~~-f _for {YhnJo.wu.A?
!4<;;1 1r;s~~ ;:f.{ ·Y()u WCttl~ ··wei~h                   1'1 e-n IA,·s Jur-;sfru-                                                                                              ·
r: . ·:•..,... '_l~t..l~
Ye-Hc..o'·       : ·:"· . , ':, .~'
                                  ' ~ ,J"em-         ~-~-~~ J • "''/Of./10
                                      .~ '~t'·e:s··' ~~'f-lt:r'J.11 ~- J           .;;;p
                                                                           h e (;( !!~e_
                                                                                         -                                                         i' ' .
'I''Q J-~~·
 I
                             ..                 .
 \

 ll:lq,l~
 I.
 i ..
      ·--· .
         ~
                                 /J• .;;l;l    14
                                        . . .. . ..
 i                                                                                          :         :·:          <      ·.'   •       ,·_   ••

 l                                                                   ..   '   ,•

 l
 r                                                                                                                                                     I    :•

 j. '
 l
.) '

 I   i'.
     i
                                                                                                                                                            ''       '

                                                                                                                                                           ...   ·
                                            In'&: LLlR 11.. :JtJ:1·Jz
                                         Ex ?a:r.fe. fl-.edd,e.. leuhs ~e.r­
                                            ]>;:s-1 c.£ LJLJ 7- s~r t/s-PLc)

                                                                   -r- . Ll ' ·   Q       vi'r
                                                                   ~le... 1.     urewer IS/o.s-5;-/
                                                                   "ThL.:l-ID CL){{i~Jd Unif
                                                                    B..tobJ J :PM ~L:Js~/
     r;;;; t;-/J era.!. G:xm.se I                                  le.nrJe.s.~e_ U>/an Y:7><.. !Ssr/~
     1LSFAh   Sc.ha I hA.b
     1
     ~~LAS   CL:xlr/- o-F Cn:.n/P~a./ /lf?/(:a/.5
     f('-ice ·~1'1 ~ e/ B J~ =s J.tJ 9 LtJ. JJ/lh SI..
     IPo.s.), O!+i'c.e Bax            /t13 oz ~ Sk. .
     I.lflusfu1 7exa.s .         7 9'711- c23 og

                     ..

     I        . . 'Ey ,/Ae -1/me. ..JJ,:s. Je..Jkr reach ~ur O.f:li~ /11Y £r'rPI;-
     f'4;DY1 for 1/abeo..s ~.-Pus .S ht:~u!.d beJ ie.1. ,'n .Jhe. Cje:rK DfF.C.e..
                                                                       1

     "r -1/,e UJuN oPCr7/V!J/1a/ .1/fft:LA.Ls ltJ?der lie. akve.. /Jr.+ /IU.m.he.r~
· · il   Obi Jher~      by C/J?Y LJF ..J.J/.s /t=..J/u- -/Je_ ch..ri' /s be/~ .~i1-t;rm.ed
     fthal -/he_ I.Lln'J a'PPJ/ca!J:rv. /.s -AMe. ~Ve..r:clue_ fftJm 7J?.ds ~Ji
     \                 PJy t"Ct..l5lD1 -M• aAdre.ss.:~.3 Yt>ll iJ,;s !eller is dlle.io
      W-el:,kJ V 5Ja+~ ," 533· SLJJ.b 7~0 C/d.,Lr-~/Jpp, J9J~) {ftlJSe, Self~K_e.-
      ~es,en./o.·.J.;OYI on IJPPe.l/a.J.e_ J..eJJJ'ew). )hp_ UJtJrf.s oF ./lf/J?eol.s 'T>isf/c-1 •
      /J.r'e in UJYlfh(_J. over IAi.s 1tb 5e.. ref?;) On d\'recl reu'r~. r.l I,S ·lk-
       S)y, 1)j5.J.r,~.J. CLJur.f tJF /lPJ?eals /n IJ/s t:.ast:... deYIYin:S . d --hl1'le.lY
    re~uesl for 11-tJ Se f?~P·;,. now ihe- P&Ylj,Y,_j- LJrl.f a~h£:aJ,~ ~~
     .
    j JYiPo~~cVIJ. -/.o le.il\ s Ju.r 1.S'Prt1 J en c.e.. f'o (' J \'easuYI • -tu-s.J. -lo Set
   ~/e.. +he.- 'Prose.. Selrft!fre.sf;flJllJidl'l Of\ dlre.J -rWieW iw!Lllnin~ A.il
   1

  if.he_ CL>u..-+.s oF llfPeA 1.5 Jn) o DYJ e- A.l:LL)r J . SeLL>l"l~ I Y.~ ./J,e.. ;SSt)e.
     b.r Se.c.tJnJ        tJr   SuCLe...ss~ve.   JAJr; I l>f   /Ur;l   Df f11andaJYJus Should te

 \
a.cldre.ss<!d 1~ /he. J~n/ Case. I~ /,~~J,J of ~ec\ie..s.)X!e. -/lJ JAe..
Gu~·t tJF' C:rirvt,"na.l flPPea~· dLsmJ~SSa./ of /he V:.Sc_re.-1-/m'la.cY
 Re.v/e.w ~oLee.d/,'13. Wilhovl LA~-ressin~ -!he J.ssue.. o~
ide...-Yt,'a._/ l5f' 'i>rose.. re!Pre5e..:rl..fe:t-l,~ t5vt ·aPf'eal Dui ·Jo ~\v;cl·eb
 Caur../-.s of= 1/PJ>r=A/.s Dne. Ca11 no/ k.. ~re. tJF !Ae... rl.3 ~+ t:Jr /1-
 Vi~Ja-f.J~ .f~:sr !Itt:- 1'urPt>.se_ D{ /b.beas CLJrflcs L)f~ abu.se.A
bf ~is·c.re....f,~ ltrr lhe- f>vr'Pase.. o-F (A tU'I'i..f of P1aneda.w~us./
!Joy !I.e.- ~e.. 'H,!,"c_y J.ltJ P'J,'n:.sJer-:o...t ac-1- -for P1ctncll'.\mus
 uc_..J-,'/j-yL. :I-r -YLJu kJov/.d tJe;s·h /";, an -IA,-s .Jun"s?ru-
~~,.,.c_e_ issue GCN~J remd/es f:ues./-;~. tc..J~I.d ~e._ e<FIY-e.--
 c..iCl ~e.d.

                                                  fle.s?ec,l/;;/1y
                                           ·~'i~<UL