Court Opinion

ID: 4038178
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 21:50:41.30768+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:02:45.477876
License: Public Domain

_ bgafmb@,p .2€>, saw 37 /3%/&3 k

wv\ 09 @m:m\ Wi

Ca(§z‘vo'\ %¥oiu€'>n , 3 N

P' O‘ @O>L ‘ 2303 REcE.\\/ED\

P“*SW\ 1 `T>< 787¢ l comm oF cR\M\NA\.. APPEALS
` ' 4 \5

RE: N\D&\c /V\MWS ms 1 20

mic » \> v c ‘ Abe\ Acosta, C\erk

00qu 0 v Cmm\m`k App@@l%)_

3 :r_ \(` Y\QM'HLCA wC\/Q> @R!'~¥MTEO on '&M(jwy 5, 20th Q~om
emma ma \=10»01®/,1@¢0011&3 & er~es>zi*:>>i A»;\A“DQLLJ“T’NEJ M»_% GRHI\\'TF;[)JL cl{/e been Q@€ '
£‘\US \{€MS O®\‘<>QXLMZ€ 11 MBU\!€ ({I>S¥ECL bail @v\ jam/1 amy é, 2011.'
5393\£@\_1 ' QMQ,WQ§( LLBLHQKMHM wo&@evc€c§ dl@q__r nwom
'W\vi\ md We%€ Y\\€g<\j C‘D“\"CVGY'S ?v<>m cause/\m,'f-vmu@s l
H%~O\\BL/, \_ \ . '~

Cu€r\~\'\/l©uct\/\ Lt(>k,\ Cl»(\€ CZC>LY\? {-® &\Smk%"> av\d\m'\ 593/uf ~va\v'f' e'€`

{V\;,\y\jgmug " qujv\ , T_ cum r€q_u‘€,$~HT/\q 40 lY\ \3:;;:¥\/1§)@; \'7, zc)\\/, 1 nme/l Q€F '_ _~ S'nw&\y
` (§V\ U»O'_T \)3("\) 5 MS (~ . """"

"\'1&\2, appeal belqu C"BCN, ,pj .Pu:e:>h:/\:::G€ :NCKM§:L€Y§.QQ \W‘a%

l€§@"b m@c‘€fé`<\k ‘W\LQX` \`€‘opc>m\, ` l ,QOg/ZMOV\ l 7);“1756’°5

 
      

4

_Q/Q

 
 

" D€C€mb@r 232 zpu.,\ '

66le _Prrz§).~\/v\oms

D\§mc.¥ C,‘\erK .
{-,(`C\(\¥\ C(‘(;~L,O`\@V F:`J`.>'\,\.("%\§l wylqu
;!'?>'51 t\?» -f"<'\\$€f.`§~"€`§©l"\"i Yf)\z.)£`)- z L€>" 2'

.z>`,e_) flag C~;Ri\x\':"fi,\:> wz@&(€m §§ 1\\-'~ ~‘“”' ":J '* '
~ . f wm ms ’r r~ 3
PB_U&:,> &FWGUSL{ l "`»>W\ Cmm_, m%.FCEB»USZ)B,

ibew U\S>";r‘i`c.;& C\ézv¥,
As geo \§v‘@w; @v\ \Z'W/ Z@¥O; c`>&£€v\%<& ::;UW§&§ {`Mm D.'G;i/)v)‘§im slqz/)Qo\cwd
51¢\ &~wa@§@ 1003 510-ougsz pro`"1,§ }. **r:¥"z~';¢§»- m<:»&j} 531/1 Qi>f` v".’@,w$ 9ij LGO% C`SEQHWTED ,cmd 1
c~"‘@>*“" m@€?@>\’\\/ `\"{\ ®¢MC‘§ @>UVWP! §63 fivsz 351 f\/?,O£f\ji/?§) 0.1‘~”\€,\ flagng C@UL/L,l¢
C/@Lg\~-‘\' (,\,{~\Q{CS~`.?§."E) §~L>.C§;Q'”,~j£h/§w§@@\ JU;§ '*;Yk€;=:" m W‘{vi`~;. "\r\,cd'_{)` Y\Q,\)Q &<‘z`€;d ¢,.\,)ag
@RM\~§':=_:<; m ;‘»:@.\/z, .z;;, amz, 71'1@99¥?£*1@~\?3 \ML_/W)LO"' GW\W»[::/z PLL_WOG$@‘§/
:§ECX\,€-';\ w {`9%€‘:“»@ fwfo \V\®' VN<:Z F‘-€M jf""€d ‘;“J`&"E> GR`HNTE"))"W 1 bug
1 li`€c,é\\§§@ @\ Qc>?\{ §>~\':` “W~€ C,~!@.v\§$ \'~€.<;9\~;§ m “C;un@ @\.C ZC“L/.‘
fn ami ~Q,\)@v\‘§ 91 `\’\_<;LMQ $I\Qc`; %@\j'@)£`~f."~)\ walden 5 w CIAX;C_ <\3<;. 3 ,,am<;\ ii gm
&SV\CJXQ.M:J Iq !\§'r@'j. ":Th@ Su\,o %~v&ic€>z quj iri/mel wmer Q\" /§gzpecll’e» do€$ wc)%‘
‘ Q@:@é whqu cm@~,m *\»mol is GRH:I\\TE,D,L

\/) \QP V ` 1
‘\' m §§sz `\"'*` be' W"@“’F M“W*@”, @+c-, Q,%Q- 1 md MQ am 143

`MM€ '@\\€§;, SQMQ,§G

C¢>vw\<\`.\f\\\;€ ¥<> `\qf\c>f`& -W\z<§. 19 £,»MQ ¢@g\wz&i=i@;& q c.@(;,\/ C,F 993 w AW€S+ MM

~®:,F C.e`)\x§€m§>s, §§UO;§Q§ZZ€ Fi%v@\\%¢/ Q>¢ ~4;~\,\@ FG_%QMU§ MU;CW 61 4 Q v l

Cv\¥§v@, SX@`§Q. <;S\~`: ‘)'€?.>L~:;\S w`\\\ fm vesp&mg ..Jr@ m&/EMA Mj €\MU §§

W"\§‘<+°~Q€S‘:>§~‘v\‘ 1 mm Q\e<é. m mm §3(~ :mwdqmys wm MQ CMP;;F

App<~:()\\§ ;`1'\ €3`.\,\§§~{\”\ ,,szc\. 11 am 4;%>€\,0@?<;§;:; a @:DW §§ MUS é€g@{\ +O MQm
C{L‘~`€ 511 iv .. ` 'J¥§\'\x% Cmr\lr *rc> E)M_€>‘:> z~”\-<~v'@§ ,,
C\. (`5§»§)\{ §§ `“W\Q V>PGDGL“Q)Q @M.S€ 5\65€:§3/¥€)¢\§5/:}:)4@ m\<§g\y\<“~p@§+&§pwl / 4
‘v© c).. 1313 ,U C_> " sg\'\`€i »Y"Q_S`S*F Dv&\\)’?“`z£'pwy H“; &+4&;`\ [)€Lf»,g),@g (3@{\‘ QU§@
o\ d § t \- ' g f _ ` . tr / c_` ~_ `
';\\05. i==m~c>\)@§& vzi>#@n&§’l/, vsl/mw \:~..; ignisz ~)V /§Xa> (@);¢`),.S@€-/llr%)@l@
155.\'1 (`D:X&C'cim. Pz‘-D,Q,`IW\ EM‘€' <:>;\" qcu mm <§DYH\HUQ w l§®¢`€ mg lag

n _,.?@r&"<> cw).¥l.`\§ml‘ @:U>. amc L

%l\)s&¢ ~KbolL 5
, TD<>E O, 18@9;<\/45501\)

”`,

 

 

 

`Tv, c`,\'. MO,-'Fc>%-(:D?.\ ?>, FlD*Dl 133 &Fco»ou@f

wa:'r~),az>%.??-?> 4
E)K ?HRTE_- IM 'Tl+E,'CMm/APAL CLMQT
SEMR\QB colu<€&mm ' - °F APMS
'\N i°(¥" MQM(}\\ccmuS+Q bQQmCU 492

Ov\q\f\<\l OPP\\LOYOH POF \OFVFO{; mmmus+hc&m% 9292N2j(by Ms<:nu/v~ +@n

)2/\\1201‘11,

WR>,MX\Q,M 12 ¢\ €u€§~\ Hqu;HYugCo \'42 ®RB DEMH/UO +¢\ 0:11[<\5
()x$%?ci'@eol&¥o(lm%me:§\*\€,%llnumnquc;x@$§ lucas §oué€.w:§, F(§U iSB&

\=u>~<>\ 842
\ Tl/\E>_?Suc\\£i"m@f\'lm¥<€nmm®\%§\$§@\/ m SJ/MC.>; A~N‘€S\'+l§n?}€ UQ¥`AIC{'OA\Q
mdSQGQ»/L€ (>c\ed 25\211712210 912;62 2191an h0»0¥\/\2 PQ}19731')29 msw¢eg
md 229\&6)\/\22& fm 1292 scm€>, day ? Hawm wa:?& <>2¥\&\01)21` we§£;l m 12/17/2990
?99\1\1\25€ mms 92‘\92)/\ 9/\2U\2c(al +9\<)5 909 \2/14/2010?
Z T\r\e eapiq<:> @0~2§< wmm% 902<~2 0£2~\\32260~\¢11`5$\12¢\ 09 \1/2¢//2010 ;HL{L
269/90 umww\~ks 2222 05\12:\ mww\kssed 09 11/@/29¢0 909 1099 029/9
wm mm 2\1\0\2?\§\€{ mn c\A`\`@/S’r dade 23 be2 ‘ZB, ZG\D Ro\o wos> Peh¥\ onef m\€zkcl
09 005 23 29\2,03\/\2\/\ 9/\2`\\€¢{<9 H\c\! b§qm 09 121#¥/2010?
5 P€,~)F\~\~\`ov\@y ms¥\~\d,(\1' :b@udg&@;mn 5\¢'€>\)\3_%` \>9: k®t’\c;.x WK\EC,€JP{~SM
251/221/?

M 2129'/2.0\\j 9592(2<1)92 'H/»Q. PR bendst
wh mckequ +¢\2252 §§ wmds,omd w*\Q/\n€d was §2}9 1anva

 

because 142 has \022€/) 1L 5102212/17/201029
m€:)QJc>\wd% 909 \2/3/22¢0¢99» 9?»€921\~99\`9£26?
19 why was Pe£’n`on@(‘ never Amnlqv\ezz&%v haw 222 9\@§`24/&5 ?wh/ m ~EY…

922;2$ 909 \L\\eae>, ?
(MQQ w U%l< \¢uf\\ yn? wd$cu/ 541/rml ¥kq$Pevl$dz@/\ u.w>

c N\ S'M jud :§€g\:
5 Mu{ 09">~\5€;&§` 9’\€3€ ‘5€9§€;1:95 \Y\` S€P… Q`FZG?O? ">€E,LLESENQ 3` ii“Ci/~CO&)S‘Z~B

\>@CL@HB 63 Uw&we>/G@ \`c. b\nc€ 04\.\20 90qu vs Shwz\v)c( 9\\~22(3>““<\§?€2121/&€99§§956§@5 1159 wyo 599

22§29\9‘\/© dwe,%\¢\@uw\£é 2§§2?)9 `e@,rs?
MMQW\€ U>SNFQS+ Recmd§,?w aim ms 9209`\¢9`

\009/\29§€3.
§>A¢bg, 1092

1 D“ “'Z"‘)ZD‘O ’&\?/5]§9 555“@§\& faa dwe§r wm@r\+ 43@@ Mozz
‘ , a 001 0 _ . are p `
W'QMYKMM? _ `W”
S,@\ \?.1\7/20¢0, c\ei§€)\se cam/1391 Cm\w?v) Y>F\`YOL\»’>SU S;C!n€d C’/"‘Ol @(@d`+|/\€
MQW\ QQv nw+qa},amd gm §w/Um»y 5,201.\ ~ng@mn Qy\ ,AEM\LNI\] wch
@RH&TEB.W <’LLC\ +\/\)‘3/ 51$`}"\€`{’ CTQPP\ PW`P®SQXV ~Fal\ '{© 1?)1001\/1/\ PQ;\~,C{‘IBWW`
“\Y\<):‘rcmw~&o\@j mb G€Rm~reo on mm '5,201/?% 'z/"/zvl/ aguclge
mm\&@qrv\€$%q€ ,3{-03¢1?/\ ‘Ho$r hedlc\v’\¥ rule <>\;\H\P,morlor), me
W\€Q@R\°d\)`\’fi`®,€© who ' PQS:XMJUGQGS chm}ur€? -
_ C\.\»B\/\;.{ us MIQZ>CBW\§-y Tqv\ov\`r\q QPHHGnQP'S PQ>\H-lon“>,mo“rlms/¢vnd [QHQIS,?
\m wN\Q»Qox@/MQ, mims +w»:¥ r haw
%€»LQ‘$QCV\S€S'? ‘ _
`\C>.".C§ P€U'E>r\€;? §§ moon ,+MQ)/\ w mover bc\llc€¢.¢l) ‘ allow hu`¥\ irc
Spea¥\ ?v\ cmN< \`v\ am gol`dG)/\¥mmk;/M€qu? way
P€S€\\U\e£ cmv_\suhm\k awpl{ @QW @RANT'€D mohé)/) 1sz came/\)Q.Fc@~-@oezz/
Fu>-ou&?> & r=lc>©\l@“l um vegu@$\~ 09 M\Lg md ()@L[h baer 39§,¥ rem§ug\ ch
OPH’\€UC:N‘K ce;\_®(`d m SULHQ,QPEQW/ wNU/) MUUL\Q% vaOL/ 69 vN/IQ
mm waco nem~¥v@i.~

_, _\M\X%§§EFU§&\PREN\\&L§®U®€R€D,%\Q i%§¥§n`ow \mu/s ~MQJ~H\Q C@u.l\'or ap
hamm nw@;&§ wm M.Demm@ wmh; whng away clerk w
owner cM \% que&€cn§ ,<;wd '%mmrtl `%‘¢\Qm +jc> R@Hhon@g` >Ld`wn€f\'$

\“~ '-`+ ~ §§ ,,
Dv\q\v\¢¢w\s IU
'1\00 P (96~5 T€~Z~l‘IT
Ros\/;qmv\m;?v§€z

C&&T@Fic)°cr& of S£Rmc_§ l
:_ web\/ Q@v~\k$y gr\ncdr@v\ meew&)@€ mem +ke {%r@g@¢` ~ Aoewwi
\/\C,¢i@ 2 oP-?_

CAU%ENDS,F|O*D\\S?>B/Flo-NIB‘I

-EJ< ",HR_[; rim ’n+£ CR\W\WAL `
MMUN ?§*§;ZTJ@§Z§S
j ,
WWDM POR &LL mFE)CEpT/ms

 

 

/ 70 THF` HON°RA@LE-;UD@ES OF THE mm c>F C)”HO')‘ B`lll c>+` Exc€ph`ons. ‘In supp@»‘r ¢F
gm M°\"C"/‘ ‘\PP\‘C&M' win Shouo '_Wx€ Q>Llom`nq'.

bn ¢2/'1/20\0 AQP\{CMM ':c. . _ .
' Q°Tue CU\\\\C+QCQQNA '
w@@m‘§§c§"` `:°“ “`Q“"‘ T"“‘/MU @~\'e<\ <\~v\§qn@m Mo)pms\.;¢w
' OS@,CMV\SQS Co\,, ~ 1 q \
'PQF NQ\DTVIG.\ was GRAMTEQ m 6 ;MMBQM'©A `/ amy 51 ZGUFMQ VVLO~"\OV) -

i`>vl \\I 22/20\0, b¢\la§ R>\Ice Q@PM\AW§\& £IKQA cause ¢\;@<_,, szo»ouez zac~c>u.&z$j
m w\*?‘\@\>& <»M{ q\m\)o\p\¢: came sw@nws no macon \H-`¢clau Hs, amd »'IO
§§an 69 Qm\/ mqushn+eg vc§cl€ the 53¢0§(9 fs§ue:l JM€y dismis;e;i+he awr»:vvu‘lé,‘b

W\ show am wv€SJr <:\oi¥€ozz DeQ. ?B, 2010, ‘ \ t
€'YM€ SX<'>A;Q ne\\€I once Qy\§¢,ceda p\gq \`n~}<> J<\A`Q~\:v\l\w@)n MQT~QXG low 3%&€344/\0& a plea 13 q ceqwsxjce {€>r-Q prope/“
,` Jf\`i )`x Fow\e£ \). 5’¢<19:€,230 S.w. 25 %\0,
\§5 T€>L»C€“;\ 35 A PiECO-S necesson `In en 'Qm`m\?\<\l mse,arnclwb\@r& none 15
€Meredw<»& awm\\;¥\,iseewiuis \)-‘s%<&e,zeq s.mzd%q, , '
i\@p\§cw\& was mqu owe M+eo\ wv§i/\Q)J@v ence owmlgv\edl Q>P bow sex
0@@€>1\3@5 chos\k€.“l.'her€, mexe ne»*€r Qv\y` (~`\v§‘v poeh?m`n<\n wilfch Q<\,v¢ gauge ma F\u~p\\?>?> &F€O~O}tB'L/,o,s \§, yeguirecl b QT@,¢Q§ \ , SQQ
AK\’. \':‘>.`\'l &>C\€,C;\m. PM,"A¢F\QQHM€}YX 16 @“>C€C§wlw 569me T<§€'r§r\\_. 7
cm\g>\e\n c)/\o\rq€r$, old r\QX 40 we cov\‘€u,§§d u;>r\M st& step m Cx\mm<\k
~¥€\& ,§r\ wh\\<>\f\ §>OOSeQLdr\W\q vn reads O¢\Nq\€\<{ ‘“S*“U '“Q/dc DJ“W ¢\H€{` ,
A\M\ ij §N\>m\®€g_§.%e€, \/Qynov\`$ Am?‘@)£¢& C.C.p, o)\"\$ 2502;36'0]@,[1)£. Z. 5&,
\\_§\\» § ,\,QKU\ vs o~ QOP\/ O~€ +.\/\e Tmc\l 00€)<€3: 31/\993' '€`Qv cause w.r-lo~m 189 ,
wm ,)© M('>\A mm PQPQ);\X`\U, we m F\o~O\\BB s\/m€:> ~J<\/\E>,Sow\e amf
»W\‘€<.M>*`\d‘~ . »,Q,@M&mq@lmm;%w;m&\ omcqmi~
€NW' \m¢;;\\§§:@@wmewd€é?n +*\€,‘Da&€.& O¢AQF', cr +!/\Q, 016@/\

Po» ‘€)o€l` €Nw€)(`€d ,g)*\ §C}v\ ;"> LW\, €’5'3€'\¥(;1] \`“ &JQN\/ Cpfrr)\`n,3\ LTex.&cApp, 1961),

'Y\'\€, hoqu <>€ App€@\s had kz§uv\`g&c¥low ouef muse NQ`°,, FO@~BBZ/B,
\=m»ou&z xL m~ou&\{_ due +Q +we &Q\Lmi H\e M<)Hon Q)§ we wcd` ma cameo
on 'ISc»AuQst\>/ 5, ZO\ l, 'Fl/l€ 5¥0.'&€ pu(`po%€,\;/ {zlf\`€o[ +Q mpch Appllcq)/J'Mi`q
m mm mg @Rmreo, 603 we illegally my m mm C@wdy zad &r gL/_

NM.

W“EU\?REM‘%E§ @‘“§U':REU) +\\'€/ Apph`c,dm\' prays \Lhcc}-M,u$ §
wg€\’\m\)\S-'\QP S\r\r:>wi`i’\q \>VPA\KM£‘.EL C)ngn%~l' lr\§ml<;wg{ §mqm am wHeb/ul,D F~’~\é»<§<§ 75~2`)77- _
` 'KO§'l/wmn , T,L*z“zs@z
Cf,¥kTL~i:lC_f\-’l‘€ Ml S€RV 1(_(:_ -
' ‘z_. '1'\®\9\)\{ 'lov;' ceerC<, +Mc\:l'<>n weeme 23,2@:#,4%@~%@ {g.\&,q‘.n¢(
'Ms¥\z>v\h@\oeev\ \LS. vuch 402 Cw¢\lvm° &1M€nql Appeo.ls, {>.O. BQ)L 12503/

pruus f@/;c¢> 78'71»¢.

MR\CR L)A'LK£K§QM

 

132de

s _

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

§5§ __QQ~.~…A\ Q_.§__§~ EE.EQ, QQE§.. §E_._,_,,__ 3 Qz_,,_.w_. §§Q
m.£;_ m.w>.~.€w~ _C.Z>Ev >_:..w. _m©~..~ m_~.>.__,m.,._ ®BOZ>-HQWH. _. RQ., TQ.®:@$.§
, ,.w.~x .~_m. Q~.. .q.m.§.w L:Qd>_mw . ®m.w.m>§m. §z_.§... Q~.. §HS__.m.o.n owens owcn_~ 9q 0®:%~\
. . _l \>
_ _ _ __ _ _U - _£\\.cd a
§ r.c. _Gc _C_ ___m:. mf:. u.¢,>.o. c_:__O.c.___...nO¢ qnz. . NETPZ. H§>FE F\.Ur_%°\\||,
_ _ L .r _)d»>.».\__?$.~l|\
M,C.Q_» .o...{ .FF_QC_. :_.. _\&__(_r[ _n._. .{3. b¢.`C. M~. _\.\_f. l:._»¢¢l[ ©§&E;#W§:G=
. _ .C,¢ _:r..r___ :.\._.. __u .C.. w tc . C_ :C. r CrJ..“ >EE§QQ\Q§QHT\|||
___.w..?._..._: ._... _ ,Q E_<. r<_./_.¢_ r.C .:.:\ _r:o:wcrn wwr§uw§l|l\l!l\l\||
. E>§SW GIJW\FOC:uM.\J~... &r_. ¥ .LA....IM\, .A,n\.~bmh~._:%_(\ c» r.\.\~ S\. §`.NW\
. . . l~.nr_)¢>\@_\d?vr § 2.
.. , ..~ .. . . .l.W )“ n)§f`*..)nwh \.
\\.c\v¢_w%m §\M§\_..F
_ \A \m~c.w \.\ vch
. _ ` v ».~ \Jv _ \L d in \ \r . .
,w.§ __® f wm w_;_$ enuwa 40 P£ w£__ § we ___\_4 E: , .
fx 03_\3._?» _.._Iom\ow m %Qwo:. D. Q~
165 C<_,_\;_oj.§¥`:_ _ _.
. . . _
_ . . _ _
,H__\.;_O _TUE; ~ Q.V\FK.\._ rfro\rn m \r.wlv ,P_/.._ .~§JP\_D .EQ) .`..._Wl\») `\P\_b.$ _ 15 _~M¢:
?_..dl_.>rb~@ ,.DL_\Y__CL n

 

 

 

 

 

 

l|ll l.|l\|lll..|| .ll\l.