Court Opinion

ID: 4064321
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 21:25:09.499569+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:05:53.117685
License: Public Domain

April 17, 2015
                     |\)0. 03-\M-ao3\3~Cr\
                TRXAV10O. 0.AS-\3~O\8M9

KXPT AUeM EsVAAM           CcuRT ofAPftU\s;ittffiT>
      >Jffel lorT
vs.                         sofREPfe KtactxuOs^B'

THE STATEoFTfcXAS                ^UStn^TfeXAS
       ^PPei lee

V%lxo?0 u)\^h^vs CoorT For ft^lusXLO&WSftOto <^
IWe. ©oier ciqkA 3/3l/lS, Q5 S^Uo^s? RoWs dF A?^\WC

  TWe STATES LOi+nessEus tesVimorHisr i^ojuevisr IeV\W.
 CourT Re&cVers ReooY^s S?<=oK ^he. -Vro^\ of VYys.
incorvSisWtf^ and* creJib'vUVi ©FvW sWWs
u> 1-Vnes-se^ «. There, ujqs OoTwvesVv o>ecY\Qn, \n^K^cT
 OFFice.r ^e^riVx., W\oc^ cooajW-V dFF qacdi c^W^-Vs-
ske WslrrV evers Va\VUc\ uo\ VV\ rnr CeCVonVes ©cWs

 Tr\r U)n* oniM \W^>-S v/jVcxV Vxeu;aS VoU -f^^CEiVED
  3RR93;\b-^:                                  4Pfil7^0,5 !
The S-V-a+es UOi-VneiSSeS) P^r Ce.rvan"\e5 and his
brother-h-v-Icxuj pr\r LurtQ Y©\onVar\\M -hs/sVifle^
abooi" hhe\P PaS-h cr\rn;toa\ coovl coon's, r^c-V^e)
CervQrTes four Wear 5enfe.no2. f©<~ O-UD.-X^and
Kouo he.-hjroer Kfs fia.rT fo braVVvrxo^ \nVo 01 Liquor sfccfe, and
qLso )eQvinc<> false. Imfms3ioo uji+h Yhe, ^>orM„
3S&£7J_2dk* See3 3^72^-3 anJ nouo 3&S£Z&£a£.
   Oe9er>>do.Y-\Ts Coor»seA felAfPdIarTi Counsels denial cFePfeeVWe Cros3
eXQinninoT\oo uXiS con^Vv-hoivonoS erroroF-VKe
 ^ rsV rncio^nv+c^e- 'fe-hdoner's pcxchu^l sofcolencM
 Qropme^nXs c^re b^sed on Vic^YA oV We r^orTe.-rs
 Cteaopds. DeVerviaY^Vs coon se\s SLaoV pimcVlov-Mno^
 a^> c^Jcxcanhsjed We- d^€L.^dar^ tx^ We SvAVecrs^
PoorhserrW* >AmeTndmeoVs; YWrct9ore. de^rhAuo^
de5rer\dc\rrV of Q Wlr -Vrvo\ uo\Vhi  We -WsYio^oY-H
 dr We SVoiWs ujl-hnesses, f^c OeK-"Vein\e,s c*rd
 PV Uonq for Yhe reasons ShaWd above> qs vjoeU
 QS OPf'iceC ^THaCibz- ;for her ConPWc+lna^Qndi
 Con+Cadichinc^ Yes'S^oon^-, 2>98\ n5?)3-^4" 5ee
TWe CWK r>rorrJ7 pQCy 93* And We OTFiceVWvYz.
cdrniWno, 4-he *ri ,W t 3fi& \"3l*3; 15-H :
 jfijS.u3 3rl ^fiR-^A': UHS.UVM Il^O&K
 fi^O s,upt^»d3i3^-M4a; ^H7_s^ai3d^aa^aa
      The ^ocHs e.sY\ mafe oV We VroWfoWes^ o^xi
 CeTicibilifH of <~o d Vo.q.So>nabW
 Probobi IIVI WacV bu+ for Counsel s errors, be,
 ujould noY Wave. V>een CoCVvAcvWd d? ag^fcxVc^ed
 QSSOQ.I-V uoifn adead\4 wue.aPon5rv^me\H c^avfe.
     R^Wec Wes T© qII a?PKccd\o^ VbaY cbc^Uenoes We
   ConWdion £&Sa£Jrg, \jJK\\e^\de, \3. S.u3. 3>^

     Wo Ra.Vvor>o.l 3uOof CooU hexVe ^ord Vhe.
  curlicanV c^u\\YN beHoud a PaasonabAe doobY,
   UAJdgHAT' 11 -07, % M/qV^
CoofTs and ?<-ose.cuY©cs have coy^q To fcM ('Too vwucb
deference Vo WeWdeca\ common \QOo ^oVcH dT
 diScouracyn^ discoveeiio cr\W\r\a\ l^^ £i£e_s
 and Too T. We regard Yodue FhDae3^ dr \c*.uo fGr
 defendqnT. UniVd STATFsV. Q"X w>an, Sq?cq, aY
  l?>lO-)31L       RrsT X see no Sian^PxCabT
 d\PPece.v\Ce. Por YnWh SeeKinc^ ^or\oS"e^5 beYudeer^
 VVve Gic^io S\Yucdion and Wis one \ voC We.
  Sqy^^ reason's X believe We. resold mosV VWce.
 fore* W We Sco/wsWetne. qS \<\ G>ic)\CQ See. Sofei ^Y ^MjjQ
JgTigd ad io4, gfo S.cT 76^X edso brieve We sYWkctfd feT
ffeverSq.! shco\d    be- Yhe SQv^e
Case of; Bepjannin EWidscflp.^R \/.
The. STATS OV1 T^jtr^^ fcO^ S^Jjida22Ji

   The CconT, feVerSed aflPeAlanTs Coav^dttov-x
 fer oggn^Wl P&SBecH o^d be\d Yhcdr c
 d&scrjP+ion ofaKnl?^b^ 5l^ ondi shafe
 ujoS insoPfxcienV evidence Yo sdrforTa
 cbscriPWon oPoKnife fcx^ siz/s- QndsY\cx?e. ujoS
  sn:SoPfie\erd- evidence. H> SoffocTa deYerrnlnaV
  YhaY YheKnife coas a cWxdlM uueoPon lolWoJ
  cf Wennqnnerof iYuse. e^nd \Vs ca^ciVM \o
  ?roduee demWi cT Senoo5 bad\\H fnWN.TKa5,
The evidence uJas inSoPFicienT fe eS+obWsh VhqY
 affe^crXosed or inpendYo ose. WeVWife So
 aS Yo inflicd .serfcos bodlH Wm,

                       reS?ecTP^HLf)
                       KlrTAWen e.3Wa4
                     T0C^V0aic\\qcD78
                       A?ri\ 13,^0\B
 \ he-re-fore, Prem\se,s (Z€>^\s]^rcL^J Ybe Under
Signed ^fPeiianY, Y^XRT AlUEN LsWAM^O^E.
RidHs Y-V^e CoorV c^r^rvT Yhis rnoTovn-

                        ReS?ecTPo\ \4 SObml Hei

                          MirT Alien csdhaM

                        3C(DOKnX "2>5\4
                         feeaurnonT^lX -7 7705

   CfcRirFEcxre cV s^vrc^

  X CerXpH WchY a Yrue ovnd Co
 C?ounTM CoorT You se t CcorT sVceeY Annex,
 13L4 u^esV feeaove^aod, San Ana>e\otTeXQ;S
 T^o3^QYnd on YWsiidcHoPAVrU^oYS-.

                        KvcTAWe-ne^YboM

                     Zbc^ rua i°n4o7<8
                                               NOTICE

                              WMATE NOTAI?V PHBUC SERVICE

   Under both Federal Law (28 U.S.C. §J746) and State Law (V.T.C.A. CiviJ Practice &Remedies
   Code, &132.001-132.003), inmate incarcerated in Texas may use an unsworn declaration under
   penalty ofperjury in place of awritten declaration, verification, clarification, oath, or affidavit
   sworn before aNotary Public. An example ofan unsworn declaration is as follows;

                                      Unsworn Declaration

 I, ^- ^oV AlUr, F^haM                                    _. TDCJNumberiai307a_
 am presently incarcerated at the Mark W. Stiles Unit of the Texas Department of Criminal
 Justice in Jefferson County, Texas declare under penalty of perjury that the above is true and
 correct.

 Signed on the         )3> day ofifidi—•20 -IS.

Printed Name

Signature
                 soto F.rn. 3b^H
                 Beaonoon^Tx 77 705
            W(X03MH-003)3~Cft
          TRIAL fUO- DA5-\5-OISMS

 CooftT eF APfeqls
Tktrd Or^itecr oftexas
  Homo^A^V iu slice's

  RoBox \^5>47
 /4osTto,Te*AS 787)\-^5M7
                       1

      Dear, F^ft KHUe

        Sic, UOooWljou See, VW*V uW is $l«i
        TWomiS uou for t^oor -V\r>r\e«

                           Pve5?edS9o\\H

                                           /^RECEIVED s
                                                APR 1 7 2015
                                            THIRD COURTOF APPEALS
                                           S.   JEFFREY P.KYLE   .-
                  &
                  w     /

                    H

^.ro%
•Mi/1   - VJ L^
                  orlO

           p

                            •jsr

           Tt|
             §jh::B
           Q par            u
                                   n:

                                   i—
                                   i

                                   (?i

                                       f i
           (0
                  p —(,—    13

           7^