Court Opinion

ID: 4050102
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:09:32.627346+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:27:20.038230
License: Public Domain

3oo-rs
                                                                 ORIGINAL
                                N<^ Q8-\Z--OC)2-S8-C^

                           C.QV-X3.T OF CRXA\XKJk\- ^figP^US

                                   KusTXM T&*ftvS

                                                                XOORTOTCRIMINAtAPPEfttS

                                                                     Mfrznm
                                R^RecCT      CJ\fivS/e(^

                                                                  Abel Acosta, Clerk
                                                 •*

                                           VS-

                                STKT^.    OT= TEKKS

                    Oa frpPEA.\- FgjarA XlX^6 b^sxgxeT Coubx-

                             \^g.rv-V-or\ Cg> UrvVy ,Tg>,OvS

                                                                        FILEUTN                ~~
'Rog^gJT C^VEft, , Pro S&S   ^flV 33>Z8

^cA^-S-VtQR-,"^^o& TSSC)^

                        ORM. ft^G-UWEMT ft£G)UflESVek
                                                                               • 7,-ir<'T;^":'',K^^

KpfiAW^ ^ R^WcV G\r>^r

fttypAW^k C^o?rvsA csV~YV\*>\ ^ ^o^j ^."Tr^S,
                                       S^ss^ ^cvs- V^. -2*WfcWl ^

                                       ^^r^w ^^axsvS. T^^Jal

                                        Fern i Cst^ SfeVogato^.

J^^YW^S-C^Utf^siX-csY^          «
                                _«*_

                                                 UrC,V

                                       l'g.'SS Ff^\33»2S

                                       V*a^R£&f>».;"T<*a&. T5%^3L

&f<^iW.^\n«.\>^ SWwVav\                  Q>ss.^VaS. CDtV^.-2*\0^-zS\HS3            Sfrt&a, ^g»r Vft*. z-^^^^sS.

                                         \^rsW\ ;~T*O^NSt. "l^-ZA^
                                         nr^^War^X Oa^^VZtee*C)
                                          ^ooit. (5V\^>3^-2S^^
                       ^ta           v   «,                .        .       ._1A_

XMb"E^, Crt= A.yiTfeOPJ£XXES     -        :            .^       ^           .             JV_

STTCVEME»AT RELGrftMkXUCr QPA\_ AAS-aFAgMT                  .       .                .     VU

STAXEl^EKfT       OF-rWEI CASE                                                             V\\

c^ouMbs po^ fioEivx'e-w                       „                                            - \K

J\ft€rU«WE: NJT

       \. 3vA^c^co.g-v - -                        ^ .. .. p- \
fvfoa'.re . feacjiSis ~tto<^n 4W, 4rxyir>>s-£-g-rc^A, CeufU ^ -> ^ ^ ., p.2L

                           SUfAfAAtRV Qtr-rVVB KK.C-^yvVF_Krr                      _*_^^_l*_p3-

    3^*~TV>o- CgiQ-cA" ^jrog.d "\vi Uyv^ViY-vQ Aft^VVoJr^ls Q^igj&S^ -V<&-^W.
/Vppg-\VccYe_ P5.eefA; rvvirS,c-or\S>irruln^nr'^<>RvA«g-s- A.yp. fV-oc^ , ^ ^ *> fi.S

                           SUKA\AR^ ©p-THr"^", A.G^U/vvF-NfT -             »   •    ,       «   » P-J5

l?AJ\VEp. P,an.              %..».*-.                              ~ ^LS

rtp{xg.v\.ai )C   «*   _     ,    ,,    » ^       „   »   '       w,   »       »        ^       ^ \xi^?

         ,

                                                              y                             -

                                          t \ I
                    .   :£KitSF*    OF *5JPTWoPCrXX£S

Cesses
                                                          .

b
          12^ SAjJ.2A2.joS CT^X..Cy,
           v-Vo^ US. 3ST, ^S SvCJr. y^o, 83> L.^A."2A BZ\ 0^35)        .        p_/x

H*. Pcvcfe. VW^\C\rNS,
           lo SX^A 5S4-, StoQ £rg»l.CcV«v\.ftg?. \V\*f)           ^_             ^Jo.

Hx fcxA^ 9c^«g_cs v\,
           \3c\~r SrWr'g-,
           28\ SAjA'SA ^XicCr^.f^-F^-V VWiW, 2.0^ .» . . . ,                   «,_^k_

G-orva^Ae-S ?
          3o4 SaO-IA q\- &4Vq . , , . . . _ _ .                    _„_>        ^^Ao.

Grg.<2-<\ NJ. SWfe.,
            <2X£ S-ul^A UUC^ CTg-y..Cx-Ac^.\c\c\Zs) . . , - . . , ,            - 1?-^

Grr^Vy\«\ v. "X\V\<\ev& ,
             3S\ aS.\2J\S)7(oS,CA-.S?5,Sc\ttv^V.EA &joc^\,' zaolft9^. y^'A
                                                                                                   ^s

tW. zo^ , .                              , _ . _ . pA^>

1r^o v- SWW. ?
             3A3 s.u^.lJi &lfr (x**.^.-VWsWfaW] z-oi^ . . . , „ . . .. $>TL

IX S. v. Murv^-iLj
             \SO F3d XX7 CA..q frpl.m'ft - .- . ^ . •" . . „ , ; ; "p-1

                                                                                                   VCL-'LT^ i~^
LOooAcxrq,
             300 SAA-sa ccV m\v-\7. , . . ' . . ,                   _         »___       < .   ^    $£L
RixWs,

 ^yg.YNA'\y: Cj
           fey^Vg. V- VG^               -                        -                       „                 o       .        :                               oA3_

"TVacfeajAg, fr*9^ ?cq<^-
           JkAs—Vl>A            .           .           «,           ^               c               «•                 »       -                    „ pAts

X Qsx\e^ ^99. ^r^o,
             fejoXe, V3/2-          .           ,                    .;                                            ..       .       ^ . „; ^ pAft

~T^x. QvAsl (\r^9.?ro^-.
             Rnj>.W 3.4."2.                         „            .       _„ ;                                  „        „^_._                    ,   » j^AjL-

X.Q\A«g_ ^99- \r , . , • 9 AT,

"Tc- .
             &o.W 3A.5 C^Cvi^                                -       -       -           -       - -' -                                 -" ' .       •        o.fo
                                                                                                                                                              4*

*T«b-k. &>Ag. &??. ?r«c-
             R^V34-SCO . .                                                   .           .       .                          .       . . . p.\j

~T«-*. 9xJ\e A\^>. $co(^.
            &Ag .14Ap _                                          „ .             .           _        fc       , -.                 .      . J,-,. pAX
                                                                                                                                                         ••'i>i   •

                                                                     \M
                     SXfHXF_fl\£.KXr     R^Grft^fcrr.^&- ofum. Afi&u.fAe:Krr

-rre>ro 4W. \ryd\cJ>r(w*-vOC or\A AVvRJ^A-S> y^*5> r^i&f^ c&-NW^acoX. prt&ix&vAACsa--
 of\gjrvV» S\\fyao^ v^Aq>wA on,
VaukV cjg^-oaxrr -Tg>c AW_ OfNu.x-cxe, AW. ftAa.v\itLig_ j^wAreA -Wvj^oorq£,< &\sg>/

AW. cakOsoas&A naj^garq-. XW. Cje>v>cV o\\,ovjoeA vJ  oa&kS» <\!5A
 pj Wwyur occA \ssx\ >r\^ ^yav9Vc^ferrax^~
o£ -VW C-txS'g- cxvxA A^srtS W 4W- oipWcyx 9^

                                                                                         r-.-.i.'i-,:

                                           VW
              SXAfTE/AENrr OF PROCJEfcUPJ^ VttLSYC^Y

    I.   On. TJc**NWc*,cy Z§, 2LOVS >GoorT o\- A^aodS bS^rmzj^ -VV^s CorwAcArtorv,

    2.   Orv ^fc>cvjitt.cy *A , 2.0\5>, moVvwx -£o<~ ReWn*^os. ck^^eA.

                                                    ,

                                                           .   •   •

                                                '

                                        -

'

                                            v

                                                                       •

                        •   -       •

                                            \)V\ \
                         -&P£>U NfcS FCYFL RFVTEW
                     .

XS.SUE1 N^O. \

       I» ~3vAqct. C-QWs7vcA\ rv.<^-g- , "iw \seAAx AW. £Wfog_ o.rv^ T<^-v\- t Vv^k AVa_

      2.^ Cov^cX err fKpp^cds. ^-r-oaud ^-o- T\grr C-yr<2X-A\vM3 A^>o_jVj^OiA erfrsSvsaoS-

      3. Cjx*\ o> c.g>voA. poa»rv.o^^cg-r«-^.rr\V
o£- AW_ p^^^Ww^r^ V^^c^qA- o.^>A AW. jo^cyiQRrX" nroAsAv VyJiV Vy\V\

"XS^UF KY^, 3».

       \. CoiacA- gfc- fc^xgjaW <^ro£.A A>Y WvV»r\c^ W> QffiAy "^ ^^                r^__

t^gAs^-S pOgc^cWY\X qyi fty^a\Wrsfcg.roaA.
A^ox^-n AW S^-CJarvd Os^rAr c£- fttpysaAs, e>r\ OcAroWs- g\ ) 2js>\2. .

      7; Cto^r-X' c£- ft^peoXs ^.rpaA W\i .sug^gsV)^ AW «a.r<-gsrvag)oJS jury
 cWr^ cje><^r«e-gA~<< 4 XArsgAV WAW. QiypWcArt'o/v pbvr^^o^Ars

                                         tK
       3>* ^Wji\ ji**"Y "WsVroicA^eiirNS, oAWvjO o. cjovnvVcA^^^ Can. OtfV
IropcopejrW breoA AWa^sry o£ VCcApAvVy ; ,sW>iA.<3i AW. ^^^c^^Ncy dr
AW. r>jV^ W ^>gjxs.v>5>.oeA OvCfii.o>s,VAW_
Wf\ aiW^)r\; cstojwg^Wp^Ji^cA:^_ o^cxarA rv^oXiy^^iW^VIq^. ,_.

      2-> Gs>o> £v ^rtU.y v> Steks-L ; poolS.
dAsA*\cyJClsVo^oW. ; d\sCXCtr^gJvrua oo\AA\ AW. CooccV e£ CV*-cvo^ ft^»a>Yy_

 gv^5l\SL-W>rsc_OP>S duOAt^ AW- p*-Vr\feWvr\^,yST fiWxSS..

flr\eC A^& i\^9^.\Vccr^S WWx* W-Xx^yt* -V^WA ; cWW-Cc^uAg, vs^V>cAr\sS^>gJS OlQS,
Ao W. CoAS'g-A Vi g^ Vx^'gX AA-vqX socngj&mjg-  precs^SS c^iAgjsrsg. ^Assts op^asA C

                                            X
                                AkG-UMEKlT

                               XsSuE        Kio- 1

 e^'E.Msg .cmccr of esto^ F.fu^xKAse^c^^cxr^xHF :iusiahLorM5sioNS.

                        ^UfvvAAr\^.v     d f x ^ g Ra«grOfi\gKAnr

cj^Ki^„sa:CT^t^_5Ti^^

(c^u^^Ctv^^-s^^S-tZ-^^a^S^T^^^^XK^ sp^a\-£vrAu<\y jruWiWA ex A^fro\y v>o«a.cx9J&rs Aixr'tt^-W5*. covwyfAssi^fN, cA AW^

**>p\xxv>c.euavvajrAs-» fcpfAWAr \iQ»&6> WAvdlreA 0fy c.
ofc tyAraA\'*teJ QrAgX»XW^AUdrr™fcjrA~ f^-oA ~ 0>rA.^T ft^¥rvsC-\Vy cA OicA» n/2J\^.
Gocfe. A\r>^\y cAmmtA&rva -W«W\y
 ^^Wy-yCL*^ »**TW*_ jiAAWiVC^                c£-

 Lc\r^X^^5SJf^^ADA^^Ay^A^^
AW. CotW\oAs^>fv. sWvAA-f\«^^A^»^_j»!!lW.\3^koYy\_ _s£_AV*s         joAsA^J^c*\iSu^

WyAWxscj&r^>WA WcsurvrxS^r Wus>^A W cjsrre^Ar ^AWxoA carryWC\ c>«v^'..

j™&t^oLxxra^VsJ_r^d5^^
A^> c^r<^AAcsrs^lc>._rNVJi<3^jpc^

\3^ xfcRyYV^f>X As Tv\vs£,\tVfr Acs>_
C^s-sacA ,4Wsqi£^aT^ }i^y^ cxe<^A^ o&s.vjmw*- A\>s^^\jAtynr\s>/^- c^WsAs. AWi_ caoaA
proy\^3VArNCgL^v\gLVsV >ixA^tVs V\ dA>a_ I^^xVnV . (App^V\a.v>vV r^vA.'^sW AWA" AVnVs cjavxcV o^n^cs^AWs^ c^gvJ^cAf^Ao,T.

COURT OF AffrEAlS FATIUEKTO AJPfiLYSTKft£ bEC^STS FR^W~m^TPJ^SFfcfe,ft£±> CSOEX.

                                            2-
                         -Su /*\J*V ftc JO/   ojF_ XV^. /VRSrUrAElKrr

vjv\€LM jurv ^vASTRvxcrrjaisKi5; Pd±ew a        oaM>/xcrrre»A c*u 

x^*^e^_x:^JX»£JXt>>ismvAczx-33^

      XKa_ Cg**sAr or ¥Ap^tg^ sucicyasAs. WA"" AW. ^cc<^asL&\J& cA^cy, A>*\ o^g. fcte..
O3.-V2--cX!0£\%t-og£AreA "Asrlwt W%^ cxfrpYtoAvsax poSTiyayVry. ftopfrsdWNV' AASoygas.-
XW?_ og,cjacA sWouaS fttfrpAYoyA" v>c>g^ ca>^A<^ ~TW ^VvcWxncr. s»te^k Vv*. vjOO^ (Lsrsv/ycWA cjr §a3--c>2-C^\COj ex.
 r^SVAVV cfc CsanAvJcA crWvS^} dos^, WAW-.^A^wrxu cA AW_\ftcAd\y
 •SvAreMgsA §23^Q\ Q^X °^° °- reSlAA- g£ C.orsWcT^W^»g-, Aug-^W aWlgS^A fivAirJ\r>ej>rN. dW. oWoya p\jwvA\ occurred
-H\ajf\ As ^^2*^>xCaX.lJJ o>. C^SiAV 5- . t4*AVy>-rv* Yty VnW^s, A^&rXrrnaxSsi Svn^ySg
A^\Wdr prekgA iifdW..s.WhA cAW ^vA\iA\ SCs£jrvo>oo dW. csxnAvX'A VjOqS> f^S'AV csr% g^AeA ^XVtfc ^ecvXS Qj-~
Cjo*^

   >\r\S ocvAW. r^SvA.A cA- C-QVNAuA^^^grvAr W_vas>^S or «g>\rv\i>As ov. cWsAVn ^sg^ts.lW
rw>s\

rg.«Aft's>r\ , Wss&P-AmAuA^A c^tW^^. u\V oofvAvxA- ocx.oirr<£A d-\csAjAWff3, uaas n^o pr^W^^„c^jv^RJ^^d^^j%g^Vk^.
 ^AW^c>^©cOa>x^A_j^^
Isjlm^>^y\^v^^A^^^^tl.XWCj^^
        App^L^ox^c^na^AWxAta
^=*:x2-.Ql C^jCsJ^ rv^or^- AWv\ cx«\y or W o\Wr QsS&vjAVvv^ cAWr\s> „X-V rg-c>-WsY\c3r\to.V\.y ctrJj^kN^W_j(^AU&g^_p\^i\cs\ cjarxWAr v^VrVx ojncAWc" ooWr\
AW^pscc^^A^^v^_^^i^W^
c^.yd-A -H^ <^^WA- as c-^d-^tv^^^ car pc^v^c.cAr\Vq ^CqS-^^"^^^^-^^.^^^^
 p.S-vo).~\W.y<^ \s. rvo AvspA^^ AWA cqTnWcY ocx^s j-ynoA.^ \oy AW^ sWoreA»

J^Pfrj^Ns^g^Cj^rs^A AW~Y KWssuT v^cy=; \As*ACw\(^ \a\ooCS AromdiW, sWasreX;

ix\o.rAs> A?Q cyyc^^

 ^cxV>WA cA-" V\sy ^\AVn, AW.sW\re\ „(s-wW^ WA^A p»~zn\ k                                r^.—

_P^cA^A_jAW^v^c^^o^^At5.»sAskA<^^
_5^WssaA_A^c>s^r euV oy AW. Wvas^- on ^af^. \vc,t^s^ t dW^viA VCA\ Vygjn.

oVuxoryy no -W- «-\>Y^Qj<>cg_ yxc^sxas: <\pp*AWAr AVN\-^cAa3rv%A V^rvs^r fat-vIVwc>>2ja\0-
Usivy&AVvaAr A^W(W»<\cA\eiC\j camWyvaA ^>^vW oXWgiA sArvXV^ VC\f\SRf uoiAV-x
WkAAsVjWvAr Aoys VoAs^rj W ^vac^LsA c^AWasSX >cXLvAv-pad orv^yoLrv^ -sl€>ai^«
Cc>8dl^'0025lg-C^.j^r\Wf\J p.S-sQ. SvJ»^A pW^Vc-cA asScvu-VY, Acpp^YWrA AiS^x-^jg^ .Xlx^\<\d;\cATrv^fA' rgjaAs t A*a
 AWf\ o.tA dWfcre. TrAc.>oA\y orA KrvxWx^cAy 4A\cfxc^_3_r^Lft^M AvppftiWvsV oWo ciorA^.<>As AWAr AAv^r^ o^t>s N3o
 ^UcWv**JiVxA-X^^^^A^
 _^rAy_c£LAW^iAA^Qns£x*^^

 _occ.ujrr&4 «                     •
     ^JAx^_AW§^X^©_CJL^^
AivsarAlAso^AyAo^ury^
rvc^- ^vdMoeriT Afa .sVvqoo AVyCg.erAr VaocVAy in^ocy cr A^gW\. V>lurr\-

cAr Wrrurv^tfAr Yx>a\\y Vriyjtry,3lftNfti>g- v. S%xW T5G s^.ib -z^g fl^c..CKtvv
Ayp> \^y^^."TV>g. OavArV dA\y Xrx^vAcy Aro K\fvse.c Aurtng AW, cjeMCse csP AVv^. so>rWf%Wgi } sWjrrvcrvWre d-conw cxva. <>ssV^tf\x^&.A cAYoxcAkj xxecorAWx^AfodAnst. SfosW? J^^V v*^omevAc^ oi^cw
C^sjsWs* Wve£ p."Z77\ H\c>yy\ xWjArs^A V=>y WteWWcc; ^vcA\g>oa>.cy

             otriT cxr^v^^^ AWA- r^Ar c*A\i ixicic, Vv^. A^pC-vv/oA Vv^S r\cfrArA^

AaY>oS_j_Qvai[l_o^_ja^^_^ssau\x:^
Ct«Ox,. ftffp— FckA \js)ocA\i\ , fcfc. 2J& ^007)^ reA'A -CAp^iogA^ oWicAWrvs
 -fer Yac^Vy AsffirxwoAfeA ftcAAna.r-y cariA Nx^rx^c\te.d iKs^auVY* orAW ao.onxg-
>                    :                .                   •        :
 X"Wa—xxVYtov^oXoW^xjit^
 A^K fVcAra. rYoxy^VCxrVs. (o S.V»A."SA SS4, Sto^ (rr^.Cc^. A^pp. V^^ (4W.
    aUcvjooAoW. urvi\-cA pct^*aiL.ud-iCrt\ AW o.rv QxS£Lc»jAY\\jre_ orWv>S^.As ^c^ry.
 j^cWrvi.
        TKg. -rVrAVv, «a,v>A dAau.rW^rvAW Axr^jrArAftxAs, WAW. UoXWA SWWs
-CIe*>S^A>jfe&^_pW^
^a^vw^j^crJ^?L_SQ|y>!^_csrfe
JQ<«&tA^A^_p^rs\sW4^W&^
jQ^_pytf\\sWA-AWAW.jao^^
vj^Wrv. Wgfr&XoxYucfe. v\r\Wt\A-» G-gr-fccxs
y. 5A^- 38\ S-U.BA UtJq C~r^ac,ft9P,--F&r\- ixW&x, a»ra.y VJcAcgfiorv tA1 ftetesAv^.
OrAci.c j vjVvlxA\ na.x^r^A AW. ftppfeiWA W cs>GofrecAgis _3i5^ SyVjQ.S^ cABHV*-
       rXpydAcyAr Vf\s\sW AAvoA- WcLaxA^e. AW. qn/\Aq.&- c£ cooAu^-XiAVv^. e.rror\g.o>iiS cWrqjfi. vaxxs v\ Kg. xjocvg, rvsV ^OX or\ rv A\AAvfexA^Y\ XV \s cAY*.y,A in-W. \c^\cAvv\iftr\V AA«A k^pAYc>.vvx-
 pvoV AW. cx^v\9\cArvXo.xA YrvAWxc AW>xYr s^nous WA\Yy Xxr^xcy vjqqvjAA
 \aft- "inA-Vvc^A u^ory YvcjTjW As y\eA
_S^rVt^^s_Jb©Al\vy^r^^_or^^