Court Opinion

ID: 4050667
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:21:11.969864+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:33.237323
License: Public Domain

l C-<‘>w"~‘¥ cfc C_?\»`ZM'\N,\\\` \k??§!,_o.\s ec _"¢-`5-¥\5 (92 ,;r§(`/I /0 2'

, ?\=_‘c~"\'{e»§vz_v` ‘. Ev`v~v=_s\' \\‘\'A~V~'Wv~\ 7 ,
\ls. ` qfaggE©£U§QWE
1a amch 913 PM<<¢;$ ma com s@;@\WHT@F©HM@aNALAPPEALS
AUS 06 @U’|§

 

' RES?QMA N'MME \_$_OK\\AK¢§» C>"»\o\-\`v~\`§:&.
\»\(\M, v~\o ‘§\e»m»\zv` s\=_m»a ks ~\ S'wc<€ <’3~~`3 'W~§@-’< ABW@§@@,@E@FB<
?w‘_s Q>NA.E»~\T`. D€s'w:w:c k'<'\~\
\A\M, Ne \@»xe\\<_v\ S*E.v`\t€s ks k @/\*sv&`\€:< J\'v@v~xé~v:v~w ‘. Dz£':\.\ s¢_ l>m~vc,v`»~\w\\`s \R\£wa ?\o§\s \ C\mw\\v.s

X.A\a»~\“v»`v\\` of \§m.a '\>Av`w.\‘\zs

R€SPG»AAF_NT '. .S\Ae\e\\'~’_\$ “\\Mz, S'\'t\l€v~§ 251 D{$\'. C.owcc(

_Sv`<&¢`\;; ?a€ s§¢\& , _ _
R€S\>vv\é€w\' § §\“s’vv`\`<:< 3\11@\<;\\\':§\‘5 §,Nm€. \O\»\ V\w»~\i§$

\»Jv"\¥ ex ‘€~'_v~&@& \

`P€:v\‘n'w~\€& ?‘1€> §§ 4
F_m~msr \`N=\\'C-v\`v~\ *W'-\-:LY¢§\
\Al\?. C\\:M~:Mvs \XN\"T

‘zc.@\ S?\~K 5~1\.

§\Mv~v\§\\o \`Y\¢.. 7‘7\07

K\\s¢\a><

 

` 1 ?Ac`€
'\o\\~.;_o~c~eve\ j@-§ \"’°¢.v`~r§'c=` s Av~x<\ C_o\,w~\ se.\ '
\

IA\”`£W\"\`Y\-\ arc N€w -PA<§Y€€_§

 

i‘
\,J mr oil 'e_v~v~@\\ 1.
`5“.~;\*<¢.;-'_\~'\£“'¥ csc C_ASE. 3=
S~r-m\=_M€-'.v~\w o£- 5»\&:\$‘-)&¢`\¢»~1 ?>¢
P@mr c,§'~ '€_\\&c>~?\ L\.
%&§E»c 03 ‘1\\\€_ A&c\\/\ME_MT 1115
pgm\\€vg cov`_ `?\\~';\\`w:=_£ 5.
O\\AE.\\ 5
Q_M \_\A»\.-JJ wax ¥\\g\'\<>v~€"\jl v
E)< `P¢`vc\'\=. K”\<>v~v~€s C.v`. A\»»\=>. \°w.v\\ "Ya»<.C:GM,ZSé`J§’? Z’>.
S'\\»J. B‘?‘\

Ww`v`{s \l, Sw.~w=_ 76 'Yax.. C.v$\M-.llé .\\'11 S,\»~/ ?°/’5' g,
`W\€. C,¢»wrcv \M\s cem¢<\ ~\ P~\`e\\m gen .A <_-\\=_ cev`w§m~w '10
c'.\rw~v`¢\\=_ \r\€s -\>\W.v\ 'C»ww\ <\u"\\'r\,\ vw \\\o'\' gu{\~n\ §§ x\v\€
v¢es.<.\\,,z_z'r §§ “¥§Mv;\ g _
._\\\L\&sov~l \l» fi~w~x€. 570 3;\»~1» lc_\ 5\*-\ `5\5 (TE;<'. @_v"\-M. L?.-\>.
§,.\17¢\`)‘, CJ-o~vtsw~t\l. S~cvw\:_ ‘I'-£O 5-.\»~[v ‘)_A \%\\\SL=\\?\“\L\)~LL~
,.,:.\'31-\ 35 §"Yw_;ca {\??.'~‘ S~M~l ¥~\v~\vc>v~\§o \q¢¢l, \vgr_ v 2_,
C~,m\vm~i \L Swvm_ ,‘5 25 S»\)~[- Rc\ ’2.\-\ .`1¢» (`Y£¥ , Lv`\`v~\. k\>'p.
1<175) i_¥-\_iu\\\€. \l. S~<».t€ 73‘-\ S=`\»J, 23 \"¥L= ‘\"`\°l ("i€)¢`.‘kq?.
Sm~x ¢\w'\`m\x{€> \°t"¢¢\ o\;-r, RE~C;\ § `. hirsva _\@&<<§,5 \[ S'w:w.
850 s`\.l» 13 \7¢\‘\7@> (Tz¢, !\qq.~~`%»~\\m \=Ws __W> ?@1.3

S'w\»’\'E.M&g~vr o§ Q_»\»_~,v.==_

P--=xm\`bws_v\ was c_¢>‘\\v£c.~ gc
w\r\\a_ c>-(`cv,ws€ c>£ f\c\@\v~¢~\l*’“'=é* R€A v~\v»gp&v~\¢\ M~\A v\\na‘<>\`mm\\
ca\o»~\ @(`-c~€v~\.¢§-'€_v` xvi ?\»A{s\\a~»\zwr w\\:> Asszssaé m \`-wm`
" web \\F_M `\»~\ 'c\\\z §'v~& s”i'{‘~\"un\`¢>uv~\ B`\v£s`\e»\ 09 x\/\\=. "§\=_1\\5

D€ ?¢“LTM£\».\T o-C c_?`;:\~'\;b~\.k\ 5\»\.5`¥\`¢£- » k \`}\0`?{@\~1 ~c@»”& NV-V\l
TM~._~\ was Y{M€\\\ -c§\'€<\ e>»~\ J\?v"\\ ‘-\ \;zoe\ ,, '\'\\z \"\o~z€<>\x
.C¢,K \\h=_v~l “Yv_§~»\\ mma <:S`»¥_M{,E<§ \:»\\ §\.\<\¢\s,=_ \.'E_o:~w\v¢\ QJ'§\=:\{‘A

on L`§>R{\ L,\ZO€>\. ' _

ST»."YE.M€W¥ Q~C _Sv.v"x':><§.\qv\`m~\
Arvr. '~\1-\.02 "-\‘L-\'_ .S\w`\‘s<;\{cn'm`\ 1 F\`».n\\€~c O~C .S\,\¢§@_\Maw'\',
A-\\RA¢\MW_»“ o§ C,:>»`\v»`a:v\'m~t `\5 _»,\,`\ `\mé,is'\>'»;»~\s¢~¥\z &E@\\A-\‘$`\-W_
"Co ’¥\w~_ \Ue§/\“\' cc A?\:»\=;A\ '\\A 4\ €-9~‘\\~*\`€*~\‘¥\ ¢v\s'E. asuc\ sw~`\r\ £-m_'vs
Mus'v \ovs_ Mv\<§\a', To ¢\\>?&W& \>\s_~@>v.€. 't\'\‘€ C.c>\.~.v:\' erc ¢P\§M`\uw\
#\\>\»sa,\s mm am 'cv=_@ “§'Mw 13\)¢`§5<§{¢\'\` mix , E~»< Pm:\a V\<>v~v\{s
C.v\. A??; ‘\%1¢-\ § “§a»<. C_v`\~v\. 259 ‘15”7 S.\¢J. 3<=;¢\_

\>c>{'v§"€ erc E§g mg

Be.c@v~€_ `c\/\vz. _"\w¢\c\\¥.. '¢\M\ASE_\ `\\'\\A`\', \A£
\N\&»~\TEA Yc W\"t\\¢§.mww \\€s c\\).`\\'t\\ §>\U\ \ov:§ Ce»\m~\sv_.\
 v\»;\v\ -<\wq §».¢`;f'¢,\<.\/\»~,xc¢,‘¢
e»ve',<’~ `¥O ‘v\\?€ L\AA¢\\_; T,\/\\o:v T\ME_ €§\'=’.T\"\';m~\:& \v\v\¢\ L\mm`le\€<§
§\\`s M§W_\ M`\A ¢\°\\A mm ~Wm\n ~\\z\
b\€\c\wh~\. PE.T\"-t\`*n~\§=_v` \\’Y`\'EM§>Y€A `T¢ w\‘~\'\/\¢§.'K\\W \r\\‘-.z
Xu€\x \co. §v~\ v\ ‘<€MF_\§ \v\v\v~\v~\<~_<\ \Q‘F_Qm<€ `s'€\~\?€\~\&\`v~\<\
\\mA 3m c\m:wv \o\,\ ~c\m; ' wd»~\ C.cwvs<. N.séz -v\\m W=.z\wz 51
\¢\wxs ¢\E\~\`v€.<\ . ¢
T\v\eu=_ was no §-\¢»\¢~1
whim »v<\’x\‘w`\w\ \N>.¢\ kuw~c \W.Ae\v_ va \<»\\\ml '<\'\m w\mz;
U>\v\ ?\»»\‘\~\\\MT C_~mzq\\,\\\\ Cs-\~'\\\e>v` wws Mr ~<\ma V\'¢~'v~.`s Q_\v.\o
1\»\\¢\ w\/\zv\v` §§ \`\b'€r\\`v~\ tv s\~>v~l “<\¢\».T \\E. M\A¢\a \N~\$

$\ 9
@N c\m‘v~\e\ ‘tc> T\N£ \"\vw.`s C\\,\¥a to k\c>AuQ;( ~{\`v_ Q_;:)u?\¢`{wm~\*¥

§§ "WE E\¢\`~<)»W_\~x&€ \`.".’> cmc*cw¢\\\ `\v~\ 5\\$:\`<,`\‘€\»¥ *\:~vv~£ "c\'w\:r

E]

?\=;.T£-v»‘@v.xza Kz~\'<:u°<§euw\\ .A\~\A \A“L`<
C.AKQ:\\\M Cy\~`\\\om»\ Ay`\é l\l\\v\s ;y,`\ ?955153\`9'¢~\ mc¥& cl¥:\\c\\\\
\MEWQQ>\A \`\”\9 w\"\' v\ -C\\\>E \\KM.

Walv`a wn.:z v~\;v.\l\r-:K M~\ \|\W\`Y~MWY\`VE Cc,~\.\§,¢ OQ g \Mv::k?¢>»~\
fw \:)F` c,’:`¥`za §c~\'v<> €\L\‘,¢\v;v~\¢s£_ to 5a ?v._is»,-_N.vf<§ \a‘_;§'@\,v,-`
w\ma C:~LAN<\ §\Av`¢v`s,“¥\ma €\AA:.-\¢\; ~v\m~\ \‘s Mv»;v_é.e¢\ ~cc>

. `S\)\<>§><>YC\' "€\r\'€ E_\EM€N:\$ avc Ae:\z\\\¢w¥~a<\ `<'\{ §ng?i~.\\e\`

\»`\~c€»~w»‘w.\\»\ A»<\. \ \~Q.T \\\\~\<\ §\~\ j>e>s~s€ss€ov.\

. §§ \\ <\\U\<'X\\\ W\`£\k?<>v~\ '€v) W§‘Y A QQKE-AKM _

'\"_">Q$a£ ex \:\¢\\€_ Av`c\w~w\v.»~\~q

P;'v»"v~‘ev~\\i\\ ¢_@MTEMA»:> 'v\¢w.\' \m=A C.e>u~\¢.si\ MV\AE `\'\ kwbw»~\

few `/\€'M T\v\w‘¥ Y\~E S'Yw'§i \X“¥,'\¢¢~€§>1'_ \'\~'<’> \"€€\\)~KS\' ~ce> ¢X\DM=A¢-,v~\a=.¢\ "v\w: \r\vx\>vc»\»»\

. ec$aué£m EAMA\~\Q.E,MKMT ?\.&A_¢\\L.Lg\r\s .N.\A ‘f¢\~\a v\\\\€r\\°v‘€\`b\~\

csc v\ C»`vaz N'~M We\)§\¢\ \lx>"¥ ¥:>€ \`\~x¢\\.\<\v:A {v~L €v\=. Q§nm\c\\; MAA
T\¢\E, wccw,\.\s€ wong \=»z_ Y\Eo\wui ,. ?=.~<\`~"<~`m~w.v~ wms \}Nm\§v~\e§.
w W\‘<\/\ vme \\`»'s <`\,;\\1`\ €>\~a\\ AQv\w<`m~\ e,£ \\w_
c_\/\Aao\v~_ L@\'~/\`w~\¢\ £ww\ ~§\A:=_ 5\»~&¢\¢_ s»~w.~\"§m\ ke\e\\mvww_<\

\'\§'§ »xw?~\)€wg\ ,

?s,x§w.o~wwa& Le>»~x’w'.v~xe\s '\;\\w't \¢w_ Wo»`\<\ \`w’< \\M
p\‘w\@ c\\;\\<~` wax ,WW\¢\ \NNE lmzm¢,x ¢,`.~\ e\@.zm\

`\».\¢\ N:uw_v`~<\\~r»_`\zss \<\Mm_ ‘o’e.~zv~\ _
e\§\¢e.v~\ A s\\¢».~»¢cm\ '_~>~:=_».v<\=,v.\u’_ 'e\~m~\ \¢\a Aexw`\\»\ a€cs_§\w_¢\.
T\r\E RE¢@M '¥\f\v~:'>\ S\~??o?_“t ?R{bv` ‘¥b ’~E\AE Q'\Lq\ ke\v`€_¢_w\g».r( 'év\\=_ .Sv`$o\v=_ §$\<€A
'\'\~i. ?EY\"'\'€:QN\=.& w\~wv\v\~av` \\\=. \I\\AA N~\\\‘K\'\{»~\e\ *©\\ g_-,c;~{\'o“{K Q`§_§?@M
w/As A\\ \(ES" N~\A o?v_\~\\ V\E.j=\v\\=,s'-v.=_ Q\'\v€t \MS. wvw~\"\:¢-§»
To .W\'x\nc§&uw \r\`»':> e\\.\§\\\\. Q\E\A `

'"W\E. 'vv\i»\\ Co\»\e;v E.'&v~\=.s§ \v~\ \&~Qv\s{'ue\ ~€'<\"Y;¢=~\\EK
‘r\CE &€M\`v~\ P€T\'*\'\'ev~\{,?` ?\E\\ Nb'(
-Cv`va\ \lb\ \)~».\Tw.v`§.\\\ €\w:\ `\v~x“\m\\\`¢\c\\\“¥\\\ o\{\x€v~l “€\'\{':>
L@pv`\sv"\\‘v\~‘c\'m~\v~\ v\'e>\\‘c\‘<»v~\ voc<\'§ 5\~{¢§ \\=.\A. M~\<\ vv\ 'szv~\me;_
'I'w\ nieves-vin `<\M's \¢\ow.e>~&v\\o\z Ce>\.\vc\' §v~\ *c\/\\<_ §v~\~\s,mzsv
<9§ .>`\,_3-<\'¢€ rca c»&¢\v;<< x\v\€_ "&€Q\m:\'
in Mv\\‘~i`v~\e\ \!\ $msT V`\A\§Nc\, d

?V`k\\§_& cwa Q\E.\\‘¢\E:Q
`Y\r\€ vu\\A~'uc ‘w~\~v\\\\‘s Q.»\\>.:>€. `\s *Y\'\\"-Y~'€‘C@'\L€ Lw».\~w\m` wo
Y\I\E. \\\v~l <\\~xcl T\'\v<_ ¢\v vl\§\ A\O\E "\"_\lt\'~’§~€‘~¥¢'€ W\M`Q>A wv~s \\\e>'\'
PRESF_\A-T:A' ~

W\I\\~:v`vz,cc»mv_ \'Pv`v;v\‘\ scs ibm s§¢§ zk€§ \D€.ciw¢; M\v¥
'Qv`\\.\s '<\I\w‘¥ €\'\\‘L ivaqu SV_`( A'S€\,\A M'€\v~\"( ve
Q_m`\_v\cv»‘vu E»'w.m~:$ Qv~\ '<\¢\\'s ¢\w.s€. M~A e>v`c§\<.m k
N:v~l 'Yv~€v.\ ¢M ‘v\'\z M\~a?"\\€>.

_ ‘V~v_sqc¢\'-C\~\\\\ \ S\A\oM;v\€<\
' S'\c\».\€¢\ `v\l\\',s 3\ e§v\v\evc _,.§\».\: \10\5

B§AEV\
OA \zo\s\am~wa c¢v~\ ’cv \oc_ c_e»~\s\`<§\s,v~z¢§
Ev`»~w_§v Q~n-\ V\M..#c»‘».\ \¢\/v$-v ec E,v`w& \ANA ss\\'¢\ vwww`\

`\s \¢\=ssa \o.\\

 

§G~r<»\v~mze\\ § \`)e»§r_.§§