Court Opinion

ID: 9449432
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2023-08-04 16:12:06.999949+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T17:31:50.073324
License: Public Domain

WOE/LÉY*,
ALMOND, J., joins (disséirtíWg')'.1,1^
iJ"Ti dm ‘uhable‘-tq ágféé:tíiát thé* board erfed;''in! 'i'fejectihg'u'the' ;dl'afms'‘ on* file* ground’s*; of1 :fuhctidriáliíy''' atíd’1 undue’ bfeadth'.”*'’ *> -'.r.'í.i...
'‘'Áppellañ'lí'^fines’'one of1me' nfáteriáís .i-U .¡i íi-hh'.Wíü ¡: .if '..-JJo.A in his composition as cm mor game’ salt suspeHsion^iÉ 'wúef^’ ’(•italics1 ‘Míipiiíje’aí) ‘ Th'e'examiner beld'thá't* language!'fkile'¿’ i’ne} examiner fi^ld to properly ^definérthe' invéá'tíbn. u,,iJ * ^ 1
affirming, the hoard s.tated: ’ ■ ’ ‘
ovo wri f f .;j fy^gtioy.ftyssgrfiedj f orspits,^¡, ,i.s. jfcnoma in, art .mMAtÁjm ,,$pl$í}ja,¡p .fippty p:qCi g$pÁffy' tfyertf ufajhñ #s,$q^¿r¡<59ttyyWfyiofií it\ fairly,, r^gdily^detgrpninod^ 'rfplfsMV' %ug,ttyb\e ?í$\s ■ Miñítáv, avá »fmfcn ^¿Th^wpw* tmwiMy^hei »Mm> ;fWF#í?fl(sAWÍ(?'vf not be required of the public or even by those skilled in the art.,]cordinglyv'weswilbsustaj-nsthis réjecw tiorí.f '.‘(Italics;-supplied.-)'!
I’fifad‘no-'évidéhbe dri-tMW record before us ‘Which -WdaldYfi ’'a'nyWiSé'-'fefUfe' that reasoning and conclusion. -
.¡■ffilie. basis ‘for-¡rejection here-ismleatly 35» UíS.C.¡i§ ..>l-12»-.Which¡rrfiquires ;án, ap‘plicant'-to .particulaylycpoihtíoutvand' disr» tintítly >claim, ,Ms< ‘alleged- invention. <»The issue; of failure to comply^with-that‘-section- becauseiof idunotionality. ..-introduces.an-elenafent of ¡degree;iwh'ichf ,much‘,'Tiké: the; question .¡of; obvibusniessj > is» dependent» onlthe particular facts in» each case." ■>.
!I't'see'nT.S’!tO,'me that‘óh'e‘ skilldd'in this-' aft Would betunadle to- déterihiné, with1out* í elaboratei ¡experimentation',-' which salts,- -other.tháníithe.»four disclosed,1 are capable -,of¡ ¡performing,jthe /desired func-tion*»»That is iso¡¡because appellant ¡'has to disglpse,any,factual criteria'orsc.ieptific,, pyinpipl.es; (upqrt r w,hich. ¡equiva-, lence can be based.
Only four examples are given in the specification;‘and They'iibelong) to a narrow .group, viz?3,alkaline earth .or alkali salts’of garbonicpiyphosphon the. disclosure'' does"’not^.teacb, whether‘ any inorganic salts,' other ‘tban tjie'four'. disclosed, woutó perform fíie same function. The..common properties of the sans re*»«ir *U5*; vt\ * i "tf'. l » ■ *kf T»r“iwv; j lied on to perform said! function arp not disclosed, nor' are '.the 'examples sufM >iL Ml ! "}l >,'» i íj ; I (■' ficiently numerous to make clear what" those pfopertiés'mígKt bel" ,gincé ébüivalent saltas cannot be determined from tfia ' ' »■ »i 11 j * ’ ,‘j, 3 5J ft * ; •, HA"’1 v 1' t«'1 1 ! ' teaching.,of’ the.disclosure or the skill of the arf,, sorely appellant.,is (npt entitled to clájm them." Discovery of suitable protein and carbohydrate m colloidal, sus-, pension in a laboratory test tube, but whether 'fiíe^’ woülÜ ’'actaafty' maintain ■,1.0.:"; :■> -í> í «tü i-,ir,ri -stf" 'y,.J> the suspension, under conditions of use, s;. T»,'.; . e., m icy-water, under the pressure JlllaI. j- : ..’i'/A'/f;--. 21 a _:v «•'if T; i'
>&5.. WteiiW^?fe;,fil^F1y«Fe¡?.Ví1^'t.W »Wfjf ing vague, indefinite and toó broad*,.. such their allowance is precluded by 35 „U.S*C..;§ 112. I would affirm.