Court Opinion

ID: 4046349
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:06:27.469207+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:39.251622
License: Public Domain

j£ 7 V'AS t0V£R SWEE*
         TH1WE. CMt OF WUKIMNl kWEKU
                                               ORIGINAL
                No. RD-BM4-15

         FMttMlfe SttWKMt faKC Of IttAS

                                           COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
                                                     22 2015
                      V5.
                                            Abel Acosta, Clerk

                                                  FITEU7N
                                          ^OURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
                                                MAY 22 2015

                                             Abel Acosta, Clerk
      PABlttS

'MUCE E&kl/A JOSt?tt
PvbSe_fy(!>£.llart\
ira-Clfc*m4\\430
 NEALUN1T x-AVoB

  AmariiU.'m TUol-TbU

      "ITOHW HEMJEY
 STMfcJKKIRia ATTORNEY
 atSTH 3UDEIOAL MSlKia

THEStATfcoFTBfos
                         Tftftl EOFINTENTS
t£NB SHEET       .              _ _ -. _                 \.Saq*
PACTIE^ „    __ __ _ .       ._        .       .           J
7MLE OF CONTENTS                  J                        11
indexap Authorities                                        rn. »v
STATEMENT REGARIAI6 DRAL AR&UMEA/T__ _.                 „ v
.STATEMENT OF 7WE tA3E             .       .       .       # V
STArT&AENT OF PROCEDURAL HISTORY-                      __- v
PETITION FOR DTSCJ\moNXRY ReMIEW                        ,v 1
&ROUMOS FOR REMIENN _              .                       5
AfiGLWlEAIT Am AUTHORITIES                         __ „ - q
PRAYER F6R RELIEF                          •__      _7___i«\

                                  II
                                 •IWBEX -OF AlflHDKLTKS"
QkTingtr V. State mi _.ij. 3d bl           ._ .                                        ,     ?a$e. IoUl
lames V.SfaXt 1% S.VW.-J S^f7                                                                &g«._ ©f 17
Dbtoft V. Stafe. AH3L S.ul.idW                                                               Pa<K 3 ^ «
Williams V^TaylcrSa^ U.S.itl^'rl           _ -                                                  P^'HI
U.S. V. Hcrrdra 4)1 F, 3d477.531-3* _                                                           W 3 rfn
kalkmon V. &tn«,*s TaX Loaa 5**Vi'__\:inC teH 5>u»3A %&*&\ SoS                                  fa**- UaC 17
ReMet^A CrMtq IW 3.W. 3d loU          .     _                                               _B^e 4rf n
tilyof SWeekjofct V. Wadd*i.l MS 5\w. 3d #o,8l ._                                          _ JW iof17
Hou_1d/\ US. iWi W7i,U)t3d3<i\.i<ia_ __ _ _ _ _ _                                               (431 tfafll
Marcjar\ E^reis 525 S.ld.2t_.at 3(5 _ _ _ _ __ _____ ___. „
ftbU^V/^k^A ^ST^.Lj.ad 7/^/7/5                         .
Haffer V. AW_kk 6>3% {.SAM _ _.                                                            _fiig_i>tfi»i
U,^* V4. Rodriguez a6_a \AILt3&4fc>                   _.                 .
Ake v, _kid mio u.s, t>8,Si                                                                  Pag*7ofn
f_te V. flatf/vscm 3S3 LUS. 315-8(>                   ._
BrafJwr V. State 7i5j»Lo^d HW&l'Ui^                                                          %.!«*•«
fcrady VS. Maryland __£,<* MH ._ _
Cart* II Mi. Stated lb SU).ld H14.„_                 _ .                 :                   fl»9*«Hrtn
kuirner Vs.5kt_ 15 s.d.3d m£7^33^33                                              _ „ —JW 16 &Cn
DinKin VS.£kk %H S.U). 3d fc>4i__
Me_Mi V.sUl lU^i.w.ai 3^,3150 _ _. .                                               „_
fticvtra V. s+att 34 s.u).3_l_s_,5<l _. _ _        _ ,
fVVkilfrKaS V. Skk 3_t> S,u. ad fe3l, G33 .„. _ <_                           .
DtoKlnb V< State 894 S.u>.ad 330 ,               .         „.__- __ .
Rabh V. State. 730 5,u). ad 751,751 __ __ __ ^ _ _—                                    .    Jfcigc l\ of V7
Ra_.«. Vi Stat*. TJ5A S,U). id I74i H5 ,             - •           -         „ <
kxparle C&utfhy 377 5,U)«3*l Uo              ,„__.__.                              ,        _Pa£j_ laofn
£XjWft f^ntev 6o4i>rLJ.ad 138            «                 .                 .              .
Bud flili V, ffrtld 8*7 4.w.ad W i/iM                                                       .
£i&SOY\ V3. BAlJarAi 1H5 5,Ia)>3UI i 15~t ^_ .__                                           „
ftrti^_ Vi. Ht iI ^27 S^u),9i at ^ai                           .       ._ __.               9*%i 13«(in'
EduJanLs V5»b?d5oh 713 i>tu).9i aH w        .
fez>5£.r VS. _kte ^0SL3tUi,ad .MM.^I _„_„. .               -
Mtnan_l_Z VS. State 5tM SiU)» 3d SHh\ 9>5X v. ,
H^n'ky Vi. S-ktc ^ai S,U. 3id ^^,1o4                   ._ ,__ _
Y^ung Vi, U,5. 107 S.£h Aia4» aiM6                           ..                    ;_ -Jaqititf 17
                                           *»»
Daggan \ti. State 1M778 S»Q.ad 445 .                      .                                   .            ft^e 13 «f \7
MouM V.Stata <347-S,U).<SUl A5Ji.ASt _. ^
Dagcjcm v* 5t«tt 773 S.uJ.ad d %ft _ _               ,__ _ _.                            w_
Rule v. s^tate %%s,u;taid 153                                                        .                     %g«.rHrfh
MflUr V, State 73t,s.u).y 6^3 .              -        _.                    .
Beverly VState. 77Ai.U.0dcf5i .___,               .                             ;                          ,
AdKins Y> Stifc 7*4 i-i^ad 7»2.                  _                                       ~_ ,
EX furttWaltar 797 s.u.^i 43t7 _                                        _ __._
El parte, GrUZmon 736S.u).ad 724 __
£k parte Drinker! 89d5.UMcl to „                              .._. ._                                  -
tVg.a V.Statt 847^vU>Jxd 434 _ .                               _.                                          fii^lStfNn
Datarty ^SUe 731 fou-aJ 43^ ,                                 ._ _ .
•fWdl ^Albam* &?J7 U.S. 45 ._. .__ .... .                       .               —.
EX park FLItan 21$ SvL).^ 7.3.? ..„ _ _ _ __.
E*partt.Wdl>o*r\ 785 S.U.ki 34\,3<t3                  .                                               -_
Stwckknd V. WaikiWU Hiu US, U$dbH                                           .
Hertmar\ V* Stait 7<U S.U.ad Ui _                .. _.. —.
E*9&rte_        Hi\ s*u>.3id Uo .           __ —
Uni+«J^tat M kWUurte 734 F«5uojd iaa\ _                                                    .
Strickland ULIo U.S. at L&5 , l04 5.tf^O^                                                         .        Page \tptn
\Aitiliam5 V-Taytar iao S.tl 14^5 <                                         .
Baldwin V. AAag^io 7d F<M \30.s~2>?>                                                __ .                   -
RoudhiUfl V. fcotltni Qon F.ld.W                                        .
U.S. Vs. fereen MX KQA W           . lOoi _...:.,_. __ ..._
F^rqaZ^ HS'S s.uVld at Al/l _ ,                  «                      _ __ „._ _.
^feje V. XAnSo* 83l\ S.'ui ,3A kol M\l           „ _. .„ _.._ .                      .                -_
&fl,lfen V. State <k>5 S.uKad 7o'S ,704 .
JoUSoft V            £Al Su),AdaFMl
State V. fVy* 5^7 S.uJ.ad at- 3a4,330^.                        _..                                     ~
-fflofe V, SLte °H0Si\A.dA b^                                                        -
6aHrDY\ %5 ^u>>lA a\-*\£>io                 « -.
 boK V. SfeAt ^Hd s,ui. ia 13ii                                     .                                      Ay.lto«n

                                                 V
                           -•STATEMENT R£6ARINf> ARAL ARGUMENT

                              . 5TATMMTDF THE CASE

\o 2>S v^aV5 Coxfc\UK\t»\V aKYW^SevwcAata ftoAw^A K#pea\ U^^mWrn^s totv-
NfiaiiMv <N\k S\m\\ »VaS Co<\\)iA\oi\ Wwyu-^wuA aS dV "Aarvvxat^ U. 3>oo*\ >
    A^tWat^t \b aWrr<Afc)*\ \>trsorv \Ad is ei\VA\cA\6 (LauxvuV aivi ej\\;4UA Vo SuWV a,
WvoViow. W ^^tvSiL DWk/Hd^.Cdivovc^ik^ LouA »\otti\ <£tWAtt\L<L (WVm»^\ua\.ocyaA
C(\dWia\ .- WfcH. CoA<L>?f6CUpo<\ t\oViLfc,v\Y ib \ftL\X\Y\WftV lApffCvWSV^^o \Kop€f\y
il\\toVigc&L^\t ?oTeWblc MIX ^dO^£sY (\<& AAWtt OXV^ €,\)lAd\Lt_ (0i\taXftvft^V>\o\o^i£cA
£\i\kKL<_\o W. tow\ v6C ^\a\<\.\<\.Ui-\\vw^oW/ iV LWv>Y AAauerty\A:tu;Alte£.Y6Uv€.&>i\A'
                        ^TATEME/VT QF PR DCEDliRAL HKTOKY
     Ap^\WV CL^eAA\o^e. touA t& ^^<a\i ticst tftstai aV \W;s CisuA*/ .Tx
 i^AVa>Axj> ^Aict *t k^AWoi xuvXrceA aaNkJi&A^C CkAfcW 1M4. u>\&\\tvW^
\WoftAiW. -\"\<y siAusYvut \kc^Wj i&WA avA fW$ >cx.wlc£\)uf\^eir 0$ixum\
CO Kf^AWV ti\<>A ObYtoW W^eWtfVft^\«\.\k\eJfocA Lfc-uA <£ k^flck (A,vA\0a^ Aettuel
     UAei oAftWr. \UlolOlBenyA itovfcKW \'S,lo^k

(3} l\p$eVWvAS NtoVuHN W^^aAL^JtoitaAfcrek&iu fe\A cWucucvj 3,. l£> \S)(awA\M<»

     K£i^€S. \\'^VeU) SSWA \MvDS4€.wl^a\.e_\ tbco\j^ vWviAAV•CmA \A<S^A.

&VvS^.b3\\k6v^tOL^WW^a:xV\ O^fceme^r u\\V>\a?itc^.v^c.^>.tx\WeAa.(^uilV $W

 D\e£LVDa\Cfiiaxv\ VaA\vAv f>V(Ae Ci«\£>Aa fl^xE* t\\vt\<^ •

                                                    v.