Court Opinion

ID: 7929489
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-09-08 23:02:48.646564+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:33:18.268485
License: Public Domain

Graves, J.
Cooper and one Joseph B. Mikesell were tried and convicted before a justice of the peace on a complaint charging them with having violated an ordinance of the city of Charlotte against keeping saloons open during certain hours of the night. They appealed to the circuit court and were again convicted, but Mike-sell died before judgment. Cooper being ordered to pay $25 within twenty-four hours, and in default to be committed to jail until the payment of the fine, but not longer than thirty days, has brought error.
The objection that the suit was not maintainable in the name of the people was well taken. We shall not consider the validity of the ordinance. It is sufficient that it purports to be a local regulation made under special provisions of the charter, and contemplates the application of all pecuniary penalties to the use of the city. The charter is express in requiring suits for the collection of such penalties to be brought in the corporate name, “City of Charlotte.” Charter Laws of 1871, vol. 2, p. 837, § 2; § 55, at p. 864. Such cases are not criminal prosecutions. They are penal actions on the part of the city, and have for their object the vindication of its own domestic regulations, and it is a mistake to *405suppose the people have any right to sue. Mixer v. Supervisors of Manistee County, 26 Mich., 422.
It is not necessary to notice other questions. The proceedings must be set aside.
The other Justices concurred.