Court Opinion

ID: 4056541
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:00:56.955798+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:12.524662
License: Public Domain

~^*** %m0 £&US£ /U£» /no                     cou^r of cr^alappeals
UKtblNML                         4fP^U^r                   JUNlo2015
                                                       .%'^n"' %rnW->. HV-><-
                 TZfe- <>y&ar &r 7^m^s

              Till T7J£<3/X77/ DiSr&d?- £>F irZXA^S /fT~

        /kr7T76A&L,/fee 4£ ^&/p 70&&G)/94/d!M&
                              733 W

                                                        FILED IN
                                                COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
                                                      JUM 10 22:3

                                                    Abel Acosta, Clerk
fflm&UCTMjZ
                  ASStSZfoT D/S7&eTAr7D&lfey
                        (AT 7?&4£)

                       (sthr-tfZs/ttL)

                      /nry\iTTihB dwwh/utous js/zxu/m
fcf&Au^rtop'A/anm i&cmjfezz,

M6ufPiTuewr fficor oPAfP&iAvr ^mmrrn/u6 £oArr7AJw>ti& sjzyu#tL
A^SM/MT DP fcAZy RkrY\f££2_,

BtO&TTON lAJ/lBAJ ThB TPPK&l/tTD^ d/d/UZJT ACCU/Cfrtl£¥ T7&MSOhT&- TZxr
 Qut^nOAlf Artd Amivms TQ/IDFTTiF Ffr&r^/d- //iS72&y//J£2
\AliTrtgSS UAJdgfc TEXAS Chd£ /?p&e//r?//Mt Pfa^hzbtA^ Az^eter ~3t?.o72.
$rfd /l/iDT££i.$/bL& 7d t^st/FY As 0/£tf/WAC &U7t&? tvsrzfess ,
 dlAud/P^LuAiZA^O lA//kS -77l£ Fs/2er /&z$d/iJ #>!/£& T?)£ A3& OF /% V2zfr&3
7z> be- TbU op 77ite ^U^T)^ /fl/ciaUa/Tr 7&<4C <%u//erAbe^a' /r-L
 dhscagnofj kJnzw Aiikm&t £A#iU&uer t^^CP^A imPw ts tPFFte/xPZy A
 ThfeMSTd- /fvrmjmAjgfr 7D rzsr/py uA/afee y&z? #m&m>• jzx&ea^io/j
 PufZsuAnrr-rD /ten ^toiXoFi&rtS fate4F&e//nwtt A^e^^uA^r^
hJ lA/rm/ The T7e/fruS6Af7>£ ^Cfic^/A A£(//t7&h&> ^/d/Utr
TJiE 7v££M5/C 7AJT2&i/f£l«Jgfc pJ/U> 72ES77F/£#?A3 T^T 0ts?cAty Co/72<£Sgr
£BlMLM^£Q^Fh^
frfPgCttWT WAS r/$£3lAdt££;d Jbv T72//fc fautcrs /%?<£&/%£ -rZ> AAPsmst
 mdm d/saP/TMm% gates fazrjoiE&v mi#t teu*^ AarJ Af/te&tovn
S£E> ZTfirTT %kH Dp U&& cc£T?\t<^l Cw&tsOfffMa <9MOxter OP?
 PftofkzsMDdl K&PmsrbiL/n^ &c 7-$t
PawT nP t=&f>M £iJ Thfough
IT'S CJytLd PrfLVoakCI C&UTZZT? f pTthftez? TZ> /%/&>£: /^/77^Af7/U3

fctPzCtAwr U)ASdgpPiv&(OF/tstt, A??i^dvte-7LA-&&A7-7& ^
£F?fe&rtUE A$&CS77ft££: OP Ci>&/uS£?C lc£rZ*fru&i? tterFZ&uS^ ~r&A£
£>F /^tr CQA£&e/i///Lc3 Aas e^/^/yu^c AiT&ra&Y CI^/THoolt-/^ss^e
//Ul/£S>17r70AJ (DT^Att ?%CFS i A /y\//U/S772/A£ Pi -f&US, &42&T&T*'
A <%>Aip%cr DFs/mzz&s-r, (see: 72bl^dV t/, TftM-T-CAhid, 373 U,.s. R1> 8 33.eT? //?¥•                   .-x
  (l&g&idyVr STfrTEs/^fSiW***/ 7/2 / 7/.S- CT^c-^et^trAfA 3&0)
  CUVteftttSuUlYAW, V6& £i.$t 33i,-wt 37, fttf C7Zx,&e,v*ir/4AA,r /ff/J
 &PA&E 8At*3S> tWS^1(W&,t&*e4/'/'.300S) x
 &Pf&TE DUfPi. te7S*1u,Zilstf?i 5/4,S7 9 Cf2**CA*irMA /W)
 ttPPfrlt. VgLTWj     %tS-SnAJ*'24 13-3, 736~-36 C7Z>cdA«n /?9/ )
 &PAttt-flWlfr7AT&s 33QSeu>t?d&H> 9W> (72y*dA/"t , AAA ,?&//)
 Bp/m£'lAJgLbbtZAJj iSsSAJ-^^Tt, 3l5(72>c.e&»i< AfA(t19t>)

 SWCi'AtiST/HZ, 79J.S,u>.'zJ?)i(7&C.4€r/nr4A& 117?) , „ ,
 GAUiA VSmrf; Zl/S*io.2jj-7?f72 %t> Cm*.AAA, ,&•$>>#, 3¥7 (feX, m#icAAP,  12/* SUj<2*Is3, CT7U6&L/J&gJ
 WOfiEtot SVPfTBi 2ld 2-STH, JlS*/ (72xAAA-S#7uA&rz>A;/o <#*ot)
SftctCSDAJ (/ nbt> S,u> ,24 So 4, Sbg Cf£yv Cft#tcA/ft 11?S~)
3bf\AJ4)AJ V.Sr&TB, 30H U.S. 4C8, ¥6¥(/738)
5oh/va>A) VSTKTt, 1&lS>i^-2J ¥/o, w? to.^/^'-^ /7?2)
 IptteS tt, lA>Ai-rm> SPtct**. 4/4j ¥31, 38/ US'Seen /sssfi vis)
&p«JjpzrbiOl/,&trEt $2-7Srid. 2W loir*/// (TEX-C^sy* atIA, /frz-)
%m P< state, %oo %U).2ji&fs-t sfl
MCArmom&ZY Ur STfrrt-:, %lo S, jo. -it/I 372 , -3%0( ?zyt CA^r? A&. mO
^tlft/ Pj^rZf ^i$*H<^ 3^2/ 3SS(77>fi. Cfrn r*AA P^o^)
W*t^h%*Tc ^^^^^'^(rzx^^A&./ffl)
muSSkTMc^k l/*STP7£, -y,IS,«>aJO?irf(e>tf ,7^ fe7S, tmCT2*.C*fi>i,Art'r /??)

k)(35iA)6 U P44>24>)
  TD1/4F/k)/VO/eAiSl£ &H/A7-0F (&/V/a;A^ AA?k#P~s :
  p£>lYl£S> /L/OlAJ ArpPz&AAsT-jTlt/J/D 77>&&^ /b^/va jA7ite/jZahMfr%
  -T/i/s /kr7T7CA) 7%A 0/SeA^r^/>AAAY /^u/euj &*/ AAAkztP- JZea/yi At
  U>AJP/&/Z&AJ Ft)/I /&&!!&&?' PhA^F/tslMtfs jSfe^c/gPA A±SSAuAFAP?4 y&u/tf
  CA//JC&nD /MTTi^r Ff£>Th Tud/e/At- VisrPi^rP^A^^F'A/c/A7^Pbud/py
 A/ jAA//iAAy <£5, 2&A3 >/figjg^A/P&US
 SFAuAt A^4uAr~ A^A3/M3 TZod OF-snt^ A>/^77/A~ AvP&a//ac3 A<&s•/
 LMf&jm&VtvrTTx AaA;/Jby^xuAtAb/is&h^Ay&P^^                             TAer
  S&v/77i£s 0FPfoey /^r?//^2;
Jlc /A/dz&uZy W/7h AaAz/aAAA ^A>c^/fcPh/tmi^Jyi4/^AzZ^
  77iF3&iy/7Ate 0PMey/2fry7/&z;
S. /APh^r^y lA/ffh AeAt£j/hy«S£>C£/aAL ^A^T^^Fjy^^^A^/&beyA%7)/A£z^
 TD -fflt/Ap -777^3i=7iJ/7Zf£S0A?A?79%z&47isrJ
*f< jP&PA/PnEz/JPXU#£ ASSdte^ &yA&74*r772A*r70AJ A>F'7A/<£ATUXS" (PF'
  KAPV£Mn//e^Z hy A^ZZ4^^*5^/te &/&A7VJ
S* A£6Pa\ZPteA StxuAt &5ZAOCF Ly APP&AawtJs S^cum /QP&WTb 3/mtzr
  oP P^/frn&A:A/M'/hme#7F AM/as AF/tey A&M//&Z ;
L Amtftomzi'jStxuAl A*&4u£r £>'A%7U£7&4?70AJ AFVA/^/^us ^AA^ucy
7, Aza&n/Mzt'dbm^>;

  TWr\tPPL7Z> fot/72&r'7kES3*xu/t£ AmAyM OF/^Akz^biFTJ
ft /$$3&VA7£a! £&uA£ &&SA6U&- A A A&7iS£7A&?7&A> ^FyA/^^W^T^ OF
 A//W&/'/&m/p£2- 6y4APkAA*thn^s jS&maz ae^w:
to, h>3PAiArm'j$&ua£. JsgAttPrAyAmmz^g^AxAZ- P/gArtA/?
  APPiP^wrv7> &AFMrr/fe/fa/u4 &F/m&y&i?a/&2->'
lit k§30l1/Af&/-£&uaL ASSAULTh/£k Pb/sA^cr 5'PXUAP i^ATi/^F/P0^A^y^^//^2L Af^^y^C
tX /A/daffl/v&/ u/frfr AcA/td /^y^&xu/tt: Ae/wfrcrhy'/&/%AP//7i^7®t*ePis<*a
 tfcsoci/Ai oPemJ #FAp&&y/&rr)//e£2-:

 ^/^^f^- Dmsmv 0P*7fe-&x&te&A&mw

                                       n
OMPPIAPCA Jl¥, M>yt/j JUAA 77Z/AA. Afe#&z&&tAZS Jj-&Aa/,
kfiPAAAtoA'/A^m^ A^F^ci^^y-y^ 77/^C/AbmF'A^P%W7Zt/6<&66S
&yuA£ A&t^zvPF VatJ/LiS /Ui/Z^F&Tul Ahu#/ A^Ay^^^^A^S^^/^<^s
*Ph£Tte/A)j /bur 77l^J//Ay rfp/vy/efez/ A/^AA^hurr- 0/U/4Afe/Z A ^c/iA
DFdmA7A//4tm ShcuAt MusA £>F A^yu3 l^/A^AA^U)As^A(A^^z^
/fi/TPip/A/tf//z7?M£7yn      ,                 ^ J     .„. •/ . y,.
AjmdrffitWPteAt/v/&F?/&t m/yMbp/7,'2jAy; A^AyyAAMAAy a>aAs
AfA/AP7P2AA^y^/^^^^FA^                                          .^
Mmy^Ai^r/DAJ 7%AA(^^AA/?A/A^Ai>^^
P(&^0p^uSkt^                                         aPvaM&uz^
Pkmsr/PFJt^&myF imps &A&P AAY/ftAyJ&, 2#a**           oasavapa^, 2A>A%
T%F77&A£[4?*rArAAm^' Af//AAA4?y7CJ5> A?U>77AAy 7^^ A£&iJ~?7&AfAAhu~te7?0M
P2pA£2^-7A/dAP>/lA^Jc/A& /P,Jte/<

      .1   • i   •••

                                 f
                    fh/A/F f)P'MAAP£>A/r
 AMSuPP//iAAmmcP'OF&P&owr Ae>/n/vi/777A& y&Atrr/iyytiMcg y /&7W/&2 F
                   : P&/A/T0P J£7ZA0A -77*)/)
 /tfSUfF/CJmr/k&PA>FA^^                          dPAWAslAUMtf^AxFAZZa0A 7Z£zr
 A/M/tJ/ &ymlP£2~S77tf£M&itt AA^yAyAWMts^A/F /SAvP&e VAztr
 QJTC&A. £yg£F7/i)AJ PA/^vfiFT/ZAfrsAyiTp/e ^P/^yu^r tA^uy/S^^:y
WMfSA/ttr7T£6U£5770/L/ Acm?(A7US/iAZ& *72>/oP?77iFF%Gi&vA&&se PfczAc^)
(^N^m^AM^h UJAolS ®FP?&aAAy A PvA&us/e y/m&vyAzo-W7Z5777*?
^p^T^^^^3^^^^ r^^^^7~-rp Aher, 38.A>7Z A>A* y&czj
Mti/M £/km/PFz- jgFftriEM&ws Atfe^AAyyteAAn/ssy/tAA- A/Ay^h^F^^^F^ey
AXA&yyP/A/ bVp&lJ Fft/S77ZA?i£5A#&3£ yZAAh^Aryi AtAfAA&*& ^^Wr"
PkZdiAPAftZY^T/zA*^                      Cf
~7hE fbp&vs/A. /AA7&^//£kJFP iA)/wTZ57m£&/'Aks-yPiz/%sr&&y /fAAFLggs.
                    ,/L^r &FAZ2&4A> F//yF
tWPdPjWPWAd /P&ud/d&t'kY 77&APPba/zrJs 72kAuA&AZ>4/?%mvt-
/WTM. AbATM5i&. CdmzvsP) Lvp&V Ate/V/P/£T0FAA72A%SFAAb2p:
wtmA a/s&AAmey a&lAzs Aatwj&tu<7&ap Abm^A s^AmrAgfr^
P^AbA/zr/b/A/Af/j^LV-g,
AJI                  J&WA'i?F'A&ZtS\^/X
MPfAUfrT isAyyrviA&XjVA AA£U>77e/AAL 6j&^^~^^A&tz?, '/Z&tQP,
 iKs cai/^A^/y&%d.yAl&uT&z, A^a^tv /^w^ ava/&a?7^ s^yfc