Court Opinion

ID: 4086500
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-10-08 00:07:55.184484+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:34.900064
License: Public Domain

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
           Appellate Division, Fourth Judicial Department

1393
CA 11-01330
PRESENT: SCUDDER, P.J., CENTRA, CARNI, LINDLEY, AND MARTOCHE, JJ.

MARY E. UVANNI AND MICHAEL J. UVANNI,
PLAINTIFFS-RESPONDENTS,

                    V                             MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

RICK CRUMB AND LINDA CRUMB,
DEFENDANTS-APPELLANTS.

LAW OFFICE OF DANIEL W. COFFEY, ALBANY (DANIEL W. COFFEY OF COUNSEL),
FOR DEFENDANTS-APPELLANTS.

BRINDISI, MURAD, BRINDISI, PEARLMAN, JULIAN & PERTZ, LLP, UTICA (EVA
BRINDISI PEARLMAN OF COUNSEL), FOR PLAINTIFFS-RESPONDENTS.

     Appeal from an amended order of the Supreme Court, Oneida County
(Bernadette T. Clark, J.), entered April 25, 2011. The amended order,
insofar as appealed from, denied in part the motion of defendants for
summary judgment dismissing the complaint.

     It is hereby ORDERED that the amended order insofar as appealed
from is unanimously reversed on the law without costs, the motion is
granted in its entirety and the complaint is dismissed.

     Memorandum: Plaintiff Mary E. Uvanni was walking her dog,
Bentley, when defendants’ unleashed dog, Scooby, emerged from behind a
shrub and bit Bentley. Scooby apparently had slipped past defendant
Linda Crumb from defendants’ fenced-in backyard. Defendants moved for
summary judgment dismissing the complaint on the ground that they did
not have prior knowledge of Scooby’s dangerous propensities. Supreme
Court granted the motion only to the extent that plaintiffs seek
punitive damages, but otherwise denied the motion. We conclude that
the court should have granted the motion in its entirety.

     It is well established that “the owner of a domestic animal who
either knows or should have known of that animal’s vicious
propensities will be held liable for the harm the animal causes as a
result of those propensities” (Collier v Zambito, 1 NY3d 444, 446).
“Vicious propensities include the ‘propensity to do any act that might
endanger the safety of the persons and property of others in a given
situation’ ” (id.). Thus, the behavior of the animal need not be
dangerous or ferocious, but must simply reflect “a proclivity to act
in a way that puts others at risk of harm” (id. at 447). In addition,
such proclivity must result in the injury giving rise to the lawsuit
(see id.; Barone v Phillips, 83 AD3d 1523, 1524).
                                 -2-                          1393
                                                         CA 11-01330

     Here, there is no evidence in the record before us that Scooby
had previously attacked other dogs or persons. Although there is
evidence that defendants were aware that Scooby on several occasions
had escaped from the house or backyard, the injury here did not arise
from Scooby’s propensity to escape. Rather, the injury arose from
Scooby’s having attacked and bitten Bentley. Plaintiffs’ reliance on
other behavior exhibited by Scooby is misplaced. We note that there
is evidence in the record that Scooby “barked like a dog protecting
his home” and ran along the perimeter of the fence whenever someone
walked in the alleyway behind defendants’ house, as well as evidence
that Scooby “circle[d]” another person and her dogs on at least one
occasion. That evidence, however, does not raise an issue of fact
regarding defendants’ knowledge of the allegedly dangerous
propensities of Scooby that caused the injury in this case (see Smith
v Reilly, 17 NY3d 895). Finally, plaintiffs rely for the first time
on appeal on Agriculture and Markets Law § 123 in support of their
claim for veterinary expenses, and thus any issue with respect to the
applicability of that statute is not properly before us (see generally
Tomaszewski v Seewaldt [appeal No. 1], 11 AD3d 995).

Entered:   February 10, 2012                   Frances E. Cafarell
                                               Clerk of the Court