Court Opinion

ID: 4064413
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 21:27:50.570647+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:52.334113
License: Public Domain

D€reK Way11e Motd-ez._ #/f/31()/6
!//Ired U11if
2/tJ/ FM 3£9 Af.
                                                                  RECEIVED IN
Iowa     Ar,k, lexa>   76367                                COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

                                                                    JUL 2.4 2il15

                                                              · Abet Acosta, C!erk
 !lJe/ !leo5-hz 1   ClerK
{ou,-f Cr'/m//la.l lltf'eCI/.5   o/ Te.Xt:t5
 P.o. t3ox 12 3DJ 1 LC!fJ//t;/ s/ct-!'o/1
                                               This document contains so~e
 /lu51t't7 1 7e XaJ 7J'71/                     pages that ar~ of P?or quahty
                                               at the time of unagmg.

 Tr-. c/;   M,W-1!/39- c- 2.
wR. - 71) {) 75- tJ 3

 Dea.r   C Jerk ;

     h{losecl pleafe £) !he Ctv/'1; CofJ!' ()-/' 5v!';;lemf'/7f g~~~/ k
JVjJj}tJrf ~/' Su65ezve/lf Hj-Jf?l/calt~r~ hr Wr/1 / /laJt1uf (;;-~us-,
                                                                               . "/._. ,,•        ,

        'EX fi}R.TE                                                             IN 7/l&.·tSIST /)15llf11r1·cvi/RT
        DE/l.EK W'IIYIIE MONtez                                                 IN 11#!) .F~,f,
        7DC :T # I'I.J'/316                                                    /(liN01/I.L ( ov/V7J;. TE~-/1S

                        SuPPJ.EAtEJJT #RI~F           IN .5V~I'oll1           of"; suosr~.UE)/!
                        /lfPI./CIIIIo,(/''FOT< WK'l7           cr 1//113~115 {oRi'vs

            IN Til~ /NTEA'£JT ()r J"(j.J TIC E/ c()ME.f A/oW, /)erek' ~yne Mon"te 2./~,j,~anl­
         "' a1tll-lhr~A Ito .J"e trnt:! t:''/es /hlf So/'~kme,-,f 8r/"-/ ./n f'?',Porf ~r5vJ-.
         ser_oenf "'ttl/ca.f,~n  ror 1/r, 't or #ail'aF t;r;;vJ jJUIJ.i/~n-1 ~ R(lle.r (Jr-
         llppe !Ia le. !focedc/re /.3. r (J./). lle/eaHrr lit /rll~/'f. SA' re/;r fo sla!Pr
         ExiJ/6/-I.F .:1117 dnJ #1'1. T4e /elfrrf IJ,X ren/ ?'c /l,o,Phct~nl/ ExA/J,0-.
         !3oth SX ·a11J IJX· are alla~Aerf fo lltll/(l;ntf ~/,.slttrrl -?VIsq,venf
         Br:ef, The ltllerJ ,fK -k;lowerl o/ V6/Jn1e and/}d.J~./IV~~er lfff; fo
         the Rep~rter's Record ot i-h~ pvfl:ShMel\f;';difJ\a·,l·:sen1ellC.I.Ylj phase o-F'"
        .Jury tr; a f.
                                                         ,
                                                               I.                            ·'

                                      llfi'LitAIITS .fliP/iFAt/FNT ,_-. / .... :
                                       tf    '                           ..                       )) ' '
                                     · JLLEG/1.1. .5£117E#cE .
         Th~ cla:M
           lltf!ltJIJ1f a JJerf.r     ~
        ienhanlemet~+s .
                                                 l.       .,   · of" N~~~~~'~e" fa I or (()I'JJI,:f~ /, ~nttl
,.. ·

         r'f~h+5. 5ee Ex pe~rft /fie (a /r1 1 6 'l .5, W, :3J 2 o~ 21o (7ey; tr/M .. A,P_,P. t.tJot.),.
                 _,1'
                                                                                 -   -'-',            I•'
                                                                                                                    ~
                                                                .·· _;;.,,....   .;,·,:·....:_·

/h/Y   covrf haJ          lo11.J he/J ({ IAa:l         t:t       c lcun"'               of dr1 t'llryal 5Pn-lrr;ce /s
                                                                                  ,,                                               \
COJI?/za61e         0/? Cl (A/(','/      of IJa6taJ            COI"j/1/5.                M/z..e/1      V,   sla-fe/ !If   s; W,3o
86~ 366(Tex. {r',~)'1./itt, 2co3"); E')( pt~rtf J?e!?tt, 'll S, !-t/, 3cf at 336-371.
fy pt1rfe 13etk~ 922. J. W.
                       td 18/1 l.f2(7er.[/,'n'I.A;;jJ./9~6)1 • h j?r~rlf
Me lver, 566 5. W, 2J 8S~ 8S'I(Tex,.r,,/n,;l;;!· I?J9).

SUPPORTIA/6 FileTS

   The non- 'f/ncd/ly of' at;l/cQ,l; p1/or pro6ale/ .5f'nfPt?(e5                                                     C/5e/   ;lo
e,.,hanc.e Of'jJI/({((IIs' put?f.JIJ/'p?fl'lf d/d /lof ~e (0/)1f Kn"cun (/t?l/1 Clj/j'l/ccoi-l
olrlo/neJ (err:f:·eJ co;~e5 6-t tAP OROElf !PEJ/~K'IA/6 ,P;fo8/lTlo/tl' /1? [au.fe Alb,
B-23,360    cJa.+eJ; 6-17-1'1 5f'eMX-SJ1 ' and (au.>~ #o. '121 fo3·-/l
JaieJ: ·2 -3-/S 5ee{Ax- 8). TIJ/s Covrf ht~J IJe/J IAal ((a .rer~ff'r~ce
tJ}/Jic h ;J- ovf;·/Je thf'            IJ-1aKt/Ju/a?   6   I    /7-'J//h mvm (Ci/JJf!                       of"jJwJ~Jhl17cal /.r
unau411or,'z.tcl. by lat.-v and tAf!f'-fore. /lltyaJ. M/zt>/~ II c; J: ~3d af
                                                                                                  11

8'61::., The m,}cha/acler/z.aft~/'7 of" Jolh ;;r/or c:onV,'cf-,~1'15 /n l~e
 /nd/c-IYMe/l+(i;X.:.;o)/ ct/Jd fAP tJ7/;cJctlt:tt.le1'/zal~6,..., (}F(s'-1-ale:.r
Erh:b;+s :1117 C111c/ :tf 17) fe;u/fed ,;,' a;;ll/canf ~fr'r;y senlf',?cecl ~~ ·
v,'olo.f/cn of +h~ la·w,

  ll;tl/u::,;·l.f      ;JV/lt5hed 6!· a jury. fo a IPoJ?
                    IA.It:l $                                 30 years enAcll1{erl;,                   or
-ror rcboery (AX-11),W~el7 al m/1'1,/nvm coy/J 1ave rec,·eveJ t years
 and tl>f /lltlXtinum leyal .Jer,fe;He tJCi5· 2o yea/5 ~; a 5t'coacl clry1ee
-f€ lony. TIJ;> re(orJ all:rma -1/vely sAo~s t6a.f -l)f ORIJER A'EVOKI~/6 .
  Ptl .ffl()llj (bt7V/c:f,~n; U5e! & fr~fon(t'l11f'..-,J ~Pre.
  !lot rnoJe pC\r+ of +he rt>ccrd 1 50 ctr7j rev/ev.l of fh() fr>torJ Would
 (lo+ h(,\ve uncovered' +he.a'r e)tts+tllte shotv/V\3 +h"'+'appl,'(av,+5
 5f.f\+e/l(e £;.}Cl5 /lltja/ /f ;J ajl/ojJrt'a fe -;:;1' t'ijJflranf lc cfallb"IJ('
                             1
 i -1 by   Wr/f oF          habeas        {or;us,      llabea J                     Cot;;oJ 15 e111 exlraordattr/
 fem€.Jy 1 fh/5 t5              (l/1   eX/raorch/Jar/. 5/fuaf/ot'l, 1/j/f/-{at?l;                                     CU/'IfrJ-/

                                                                2
                                             :: .. ·~r ·: ,

5entf/l(f ~r 3o              year) enha11(eJ ex(eecl..slcrl(/l()(y max/mvm anrll.f
VIlla w ~1 . .4tplkar~l haJ ffrVed over 9 year.s of -l/115 ;m;Jrrper-~
fn/Ja/l(fd 5e/} ff,1(e ~ a1r! a;;;ilc«nl l!cu (!9 oiler /JJeans. tJ-1'" tJ/I~:u;")/ 'n.J
r~ lief. ( asela w h?aKes /1 clear 1/Ja f CijJ/!tcarJI ,lan Seek lt//e/ .by
J,'recf appeal or wr/+ of haoeas corf~S, becttU5C'                                          cca   ~iecf tvh/c.h            (ff1delf

C1 Jenff';!(e            vo:d   hltif /H'ra/Jed·cc-1              Clll;             1
                                                         l/rnf . fy jJ?IIIf gNK, 9Z'Z s: w,
                                                                                        l

2J       C\   +·   I '8'2.. (c,'/,'nJ JleaiJ V. )/ale, 317 5. tAl. 2J 335 33 6 (Ttx, (/,~.            1

!lfj). 1991){o;:,,/cn on or,jt.'na I fUb/11!S5/oa ) 1 ' Ste also Ex ;Jarfe /Yfc .TvN,
5"86 5,W. 2d af 8SL// Exparfe.f/t:tu/r, ~'IS S.W. 2d 2311 232. (Tex.. L///n,
App-1773) In /;,cfJ                   rr    lhtre. ha5          /JfVfl         Pff.'/1 anylfi,y ;/;       Tf)'t'/5   /aw    1-J-at
pre,rev,+ed ·Oilj Courf w/1/, )u11~ dt~t/on o Vpr a                                     cf"/m,:;al caJ~ f:om /la·l~/~
and Cortecf,'n.:; a,?      /!lrya I 5fJ,aff?Ja: /'/Jc mJffef' WAf./1 or '/Jo·w fiJf /{'/,·ff"
Y'lti)   ·souyh f. M ,'~dIll 119 s, w. 3J a. t 8ot, A;;j//,'caal nos .rv7/trt>cl Aa/M
because -l~P /?11f'IOjJf~" ef!hctr1<.emt?nf                       ()r A/r SfJrJffnte !f'Juller/ ~~ ;OV/7/.Jimtnl
beyond i-ff .rl~fv lcrv mpx/m(.,lrYl,                                 \
                                  /                                   '•
                                                                           '

   Before _the            (onJM/f'f,on       oF 1/Jf'         ().flfJ/15e      t:tllryPJ a6ove 1      Afl"ta.lle' 57kcf
the pr:marj (JFIN15e, 011 ~~/ruary 2 '7; 1995" 1. 1a Ceru.Jf' M, !3 -· 2 3, 36tJ, ;'rl l~to
lbl s+ o:54r,'(+ (ourt of Ec.for {ourdy, TexaJ, f};p Jeitndt:~nf- Wd5
 .COt1 v/< reJ ,of f/;p !;lo.fJ/              {)r
                                 (J,dufhol"/zed IJJP o-Fa Molor 1/eh'C~.

  Before . +ne .(otl1mls5/0/1 o-f f/,e ,,,/J'fC/7 0 f /pi?ff' j Clrll ctliPI rf(P
 COI]\//(ft~n· /a Causf M. /}~23, 36o rAJas !:/Jeri J -lhe dpft:,/7/rr/)f
 comm.:-lle/ 1-Ae lflonf of 8vyla7 a.f'd ;Ia/, 'r'ct r;.- ()/? t:lrJr! tJa.> C017Vtcffd           1

 Dtl ;:June ? 200/ J /11 (t(U)tt 11/o, ~2/ 8tJ3 -A ,/J ~~f LjJ /,4 /)5/r.,'cf
             1
 (our+             In   a"J fer Pc+tef··(~ul1f(, Tex'trf,

  see(!; X-!o).
                                                                 3.
.~··.

                                                               ;   ..   ~

          J..f IJ Wf1// ft> 1-f It'd        re     lha f a ;Jio6al-ed Sf'alence                                                                            /;    /Jo I   t:l   f':ncl I Conv/cf/o"!
                                                                                                                                                      u                                              .
        .fc.r enhal/ti?IJ1eaf /UI'jYrJffS /1 /; .revo.tt&J. bt ;;errle )at?yley, '833 5, W.
                                                       UI'J/fJ;

        2J IL.II(7eY,Cr. A;;;;- lr~2);' [y j/arff .Murc-A,J-oa/ 560 5,w', 2d 659/ 656
        (Te"J, (r/~. fl;;p.. 1973). ul/ frt'orlf/olly conv/tft~, /Je(ot11f51/i1al l)t /a.Te pro-
         bed ,.Oil is rev6Ke J' se~ ( ol v:n ". Stcde I     .s:. W, 3d 32, 8? (), I (Tey . 4,;, -                             ;,r
         Texe~rkana 2tJDI /Jo 1iJef,)(nof,'rlj -the Jette o pr:.'or (DflV/cf/MJ 6eto.m~5· {i,ttl
          /5 f/;e da.fe rommui'l't)' .5V(?frll/s-t~/t t5 l'f-'VoKeJ) "

           II pjJir'ut n f t ele 15 -1/;e          tour f lo I Wu                                                    pe11 paoce I> t'n fro JuaJa I/,/; l.ri'cl/,
         j}ff (5!1#17 C!/)cf.#l9),                         !fofh                              fHU/(ef-r (onfa,:-, C1 }ulye,n~of f)a-15)ow5

         a pro bale/         Jf,·'~lf;'' t e   ,       /1/t/1/t-_r ro/1/o/~]f                                                           6//)       tJRIJc/ rf[J/t.!k/A/6 ?i?o8r17/6/./,
           I   • ·I      -              1          1 '                                         · I r~ I /. J>        ,      ,
         ./vfJtlfJfr fWJ ;Jtl(/(f ,            {f!?hitl'lf                                    f/Jf c/a f'5 a;fl/uu;l:r j/lto.f jJ!th~alroel .F;o/'1-

         -J~nU' 5     tJfre ffVol:eJ tltJd bf(ame l:na I                                                 (i-t>e                     .(u, t2dhantr/l7f/ll                       jJVI(J())C'.J,

          (olv/n} ?A~ 'I c()o;l5 ;:J/ectvlt>r,lf ~:"' (J,:tfl}ie; ai7J A1v/'c,£~-on) 1Ja5 Ael/
         ·~l1n+ o. probC\fed ff,?fr>nU" If r'lol r;i.-:&:/Jc.;j C'o/{/1//c.i.'/,i:u?:~? f-,-,jCl/1iPI'J7~.r;/
        'furpMt' s U!Jln; /I /5 lfVc,lftJ,'' Alo!ft,;y ~~~(/Ia le; .t'k'4,~ 'II .ff/7 a!;~J II;c;)

         toe;- phcfo5 a!Jd -D/ljf'pr:,.-,+ Cej(ds prov'ed +hcrf e~ppl/ccu'lt's probclt/611
         L.JO 5. ( f VC> K € c) 0:1\ d be Utt1 e -(;'r11..1l_ 1o r e hall( e1?U' rd jJUI'JtJ )m f';l f .
                                                           i                                                                 fl

        Tl:l£ IIJOir7MEA/T //A!O f?£~8/ITED E!1111.4AilEMEII/T5 /IRE /MPROJ?Ei:
                                               .   .   ~                ..   -   .   . .. .   .   -   .    - -----   .   .        . -   .   ··-   .   --        ..
                                                                                                                                                                                      .-   ·;- ..

          llpjJI/cctnf svim/ff fo l)e (ourf a                                                                  ceri:l:e) £o/JI 6-1". f)e tJR/JE;f K'EVokl/116
         PRoBATI0/1.1 do.fed J'ur1e 1<1 1 20JLI                                               i i'1        ( GW5e No, 8-2 3 360 ouf of Ec. -lor Covnly,
                                                                                                                            1
         7ey.a5 ;rooT f/,at   A;tltari'IJ j?lobaf'~~"1 U!tl.5 ft'Vo!(e/ Cii'Jd beca.l7. ?t' 4a/
         011 March 1, 19'/S (Ax- 5), The fl;or In IAf //Jdt~hnfnl allrye5 l!iaf 11;;-

         J)c.~t~-+.5 convlcUon berame -I:YJtt! on Ff>6r£1t:l7 2 ?1 1975 ovf o-f' Ec lol'
         {out~ty, TeXaJ(/;,X-!tJ).                         HotA1eVp! 1                                    1/Jt'          Ecto1                    {uvn~ 1            7e,XaJ £o11thcf/on                  ~erll111tJ
        .ftncd on lflar.c.h 11 1995" file IC/1-e C')JjJI/ct~nl;                                                                                   (omlluJI'1t'/;'        .l'f/~rV/>/on              ti/Ctf
 revoKeJ(ilx-s),(Sc-e Colv/a VI 5lalel c/ff'j atove), T/;e;,;'ury Coulvl /la-f
 have Jeierm/r~e<.J thcd C £1al on A(.l arch 11 197 5" 11? C4Uff1 d , 8-
23,360 ouf of Ec lo/ (ovrlfrl Texaf (/;X·- s), TAu..r I f!('(lu/,~ {/.fF c.•-r.
fhc:d (onv,'cf,'oVJ ~r fnhtrorJ li al A;9jJl {aniJ ;Jrola-1, 'tJ/1 _r.-tJc: J
 (ei/oKFJ on            A4cuc4      0 19f:)       /1·1 [au5e            ;Ju, ;J-23~ 366   tJVf o/   & -lo~,:{~vn~
 7?: Ya.r(/(I< L.f: 1'1-15),

 J..:Kewise, !lpp!/c.an f Joim/ff lo lAe rourf a ce.rf.. ·<-f'/ ropy da:f::;;.J
Februo.ry 3 1 2.oiS oF fAe ~RIJcR !f[tlok;/V6 fR08;4T/tJ)/ ~~ {av5P /1/o, LJ2/
goJ-A oefor Paller {ounly                             I    7eXa5 jJI'Oo;£ fAaf          /lf/;Jitc&nli?l"o6alton
/IJC(.f         ClrJd bff011'l~ £uz/ On Ji.·;-J(' 7 1 J.(H)/()1)(-$), ,4-/Jrj /r;
          ff'VOi rtt/oked a/JI6e-
 {ame .f)t1a / o/1 :Jur~e 71 2 Oo/ (fx ti 1?), /lol),::y ;'r, fA1. fr,/i/ /fforJ j/lb.:..
 veJ app/f.cants probc.tf/cn WCtJ ff'v'Oked e~nJ bfetUrJf' t:na/ Or1 Jf./nf 71 2Dol
( RR. Ll: lb-./ 3).          (5-.f'f (olv~;]     V.       5'-ICil-f.~   atoVf') , T/rf'rr/:;re
                                                                                             1
                                                                                                 lt5t' jury covlr/
 /lot   ho.ve. r:Jefermlr1ed +htd opjil/radf;'p!'t'or .f'c/Jv/c/t'cn /;6'(t't/}"'f7 f':/7a/ ai-;
 JuYJe 7,2oot /11 {Ctu5e Alo. qz, 8()3 -A ouf o~ l'o l!fl (o,~n-1, 1 7exa;a5'
 a /l't:;ecl /J? -/hf ;/id/( lrnf/?f (/l %~ lo), TiJv51 j)rer/t/J,>~ uJf of. l/;a f
 (Oil     V,'( -1-/on -f;r   ft7 /,on   a -'Y' erlf,

           llptlt'cctn f; {Op175e lfcf //('(( or 1/'ue .. fo bofh !'I'IAdliCPI'/7(-'nl j.ktra-
    F/;1(1 I   ly   I

 Jra;As tl'J nof wa./vt> ~rl'ca;Jr; 1(:;/;f lo cl?alle,?_Je IP_Ja~·&'·t:~l"' ~5·
  fl7hctnce.l .f'e/ifence, /}f._>j),'lf                   /At? ..JNifUtl t'v/(1     I!Jal a ,;:;/eq 6--;1 /-,uf fo
  atJ enho,Jcel'l?eli"f para...:;ra;;lr r~/;{:>v{J;· 1/?/ _,rlale o-f ,~Is Jut'/e/i                         To jlriJJ/e
                                                                   .5
CL tr/at (dnv/cf/on      qllejed for ei1Acn?cemenf an/ /;;l'ff,/1; f/,~ c!P*nc/cMI:/
r:.5J-d· fo cLppeol +he ;();vfl/c /el'lc)'' o-f" ev,~feJ?(e fo ;.JI'vt/e -1-d f ?~''~/' C,11'1-
'}/c1 /oi, 1 1hfre 1·s an exa_p·l-,'ti u·1 Whf'PI lhe record a-f/,'r/nal:vef rf/lf'c-6
thu.+ +he enhance (Y\ ~VI+ ;5 ; +se H: /mpro;er EX ratfP ;(/c t( 19·'/ 5. 3J
                                                                          I   .                                      w:
 5D8 (Tex. {('/m .. /ffl'· 2o~6.2 Tl/15 fKifjJ71/oo (;l'(j/dc(led1 /n 5d/Jck>_r v.5ta~. .
?35 S,w.2J f'IS1 LfLft"(Te/.A/~J·5~m .;t}lo/1;0 /99o ntJ/)('1,).. A;Jpl/tanf
enferec/ a (Of./t1 fe/(Jd p/ect of '1/'ut'" fo etJj,(i/l(eme,1f ;Jara!)tCtf/, /ll./1'1?6fr ul}('
·Hwt h/J conv/cl/o,J Wcu £Q; o/l hto/f.ll'/ 2?; 199S ;/? Gv..re A/v. P-
 2.31 360    ovf D/              &lor Cour~ly1         1(> Xet;   {:fl?       £f:   '2.).   /1;;;//c?t,l f d J.)~/Tf /Jl'
5ar~Jpr; exce;ll~/"1 ..J/;~tf                 a   -/-/;p /f'(ord o-f:.:./';'//haf/ve?' f'r?liecfJ ~· 1/;af.iie

 enha11Celnenf /s /mpro;wr(AX- 10). lltj-7 1/c an                                   -1;     c erl~ it'eJ ('o,Py ()·-/" lie
 0/(f)£{( REVOKIN'G fl,f08A7/CJ'/                    o'alec! :June. 19"20F/ /11 Cav.rf                        A-4,   t--4-23;360
 cwf   fCLU)·e. cr fAe retorJ all;onal,'vtJ/y retlec/;" lhe;e rs llo
  ev/del')Ce. In (s-/qle 5 Ex/;/b/1 # 19) I!Jccl t9;J;;I/c a,1// COI'It//cf/or~                                      df'com()

 -r~·ncd    of)       /~arch         1
                                      1
                                          199.~ -fhe
                                     4f7tl/ct11'lf; p!obaf,~r~ ttlt15 ffVoktd
                                                        cia It
  /fl Caufe l.!o. 8-231 360 oul <)..fEel<)/' [ounly, Tt>Kar{5x.#i9) ..
(5ee Cclv/"' v, Slule 1 aboVe),
   «              .                                                  ,
       1/;f,/'f(orJa+/..rmalt//Piy /f'llecls 'lhe.r(; /J no fl//dr',ue //; ~JF~14/
  record -fhct+ 1/ppf/cC/rlll;t()ba-/-,~n                        Waf f.fVoKfd                   an./ 6rca/J?f   -;{;7,71    or1
  lt1 C' r<-/1 ~ ,1 99.)            1:1   (au5 r     ~ £ ( for {o o/.l 1---1 Te X a .r
                                                   Ak. 8 - 2 3 1 3 6t)            tJu I     o

  (RR 'f:Jlf-15") a;· iefu/recl b)l Tex . Jlf/1, (odp Ann f /2, L!Z.(d)a5·
   a /lla    ller ()f /t,tw.

              /l;;ph~cr/11 fl7ffln;.l a (ot/lUf!eclj)Jt'et of 'i/t,lf ··to f'/;/Jancfl-
        J.//(r.W;}p
            1
   men+ pur~Braph nJw1ber -l-wo i~(;tt                             n:.s
                                              (Ofl\1/(+t~YI Waf·(;;Ja/ uJ 7vne ~2dal
 in CcwJf: Jl/c. '12, 8o3-/l aufor,Po/lf~ (tJunly~ Texaj-(1?1! t;:z), ll/,PI/-
 cani (eel 55(,--·f 5 1/le ._fr::rnr/er s r:xcepi/on u lha I lilt frfo/'d at-//r;-J1a l,'veft
 re+ \ec\: 5" fhoJ the secor~d e.tJfitMtell1f17f ;}- Jm;J/'~(/fJI. /l;;J?~tol1t'i {C/1;0/
 (opy of- tAr- 0)'0£1( AYEVOk!Al6 /1?tJ8117/o/il /alec! hJo/lll)' ~ 2a1.) ;/, UtvJe
 ;Vo, ~l2; f/63 --/1 ouf 6•/ J?o/lr--r Gu"'ly I "(fxa5 tf doc-t.//YI~/1/ary ev/df'rJ{f
·+ho..+ 1/ppJ[u,fl+'s probo.+;oYJ wc,_r rfvoktd O/Jd Ot!t"tt1ne                             -/:/Jpl on :To/1~ ?,..
 2ool(4x-g), Df'JjJ,'ff llj?j//;'cC?/lf; (oon.Jt::ff'd ;;lfa rJ;::-                        1/vt='lo ~~~Bur-
3·/<:iry ·OT;a !lcr/?/lol,.'on        ocrl.t,-1" fJollr:>/ Gunlyl Tf>.YOf                    /0 rhe ;1dc-&;lf'17f
(A.X-tb); fh,~§ r.:D/1!/tc-l,~n ccu/d.t:Jol .6p us~cllo 5f'r:r/f''Ue 4~j?kf-cM'l-a5 e2
 hCJb/lua I ofht1de/' .bfrav,)(' -lA f {f(O ref a r;; r/J1a -h 'vt>ly ~~ /lt'ct.r , -1/;e/t'
                                               C(

 i.r   tlo.   e~'/ /1G-Ialf; Ex/;.'1-'-/d;?) IA~I /l;;;;!ct?niJ (o/11/. . 'rio,J
 berarne           -{,'rJaloi'J .Jude ~ 2oo/ f.1e daf(5 a/~/,..·co,J-1} j//obaf/,;n li/rl~
 reilbKed ; tl (ctu5e           No, L/21 3o3- /1 oul o-/ ~lie/· ltJ(,In/;' 1         rrxa J (s yll;7)
(_,\ee                   abov~) .. rr ;;{<:'
         -Colti:n V, 5la-le1                         /'C'rord c;/:/:i-O?t7f/vf'ly /p/kch "I/;P/'f ·
 /; ,10 ev/Jf,·lcf ;;? rAf "lo~71 l'frord fiaf /t,;;(?!tta.~fj j?ro6«.1/c.Jn t-ytJ5/.f?Vo/),Cod(:' Inn
 :f 12,'12.(d) as CJ 111alffr ~-flaw, nT~e lr(ol'd at//;,rnal~'t?/y lrl/e(t"f"
 both en hav1 (f me ..f pa ro..:3 rap hs· were m/srAara c-fe1/zeJ·~;~t fhe /r.,clfc fmt'/lf
(Ax ~1o) aaJ m/sciJaracf('l/zr:(l,~/) o-r fAe f'b·) ;'ctc.kefs:(s_x.4;7 ood
 ·5Y ::li:.l9) .(e5ui-I~J /n         C/1'7   /lleyct I   5f'l'lfeno?   *'r    ov-f5t'de           rt?P 5hlulory
 rallje of puo ); hrntfJf

       7/-;e ,-sur·trN'r?fh Caur f           cr ll;.y;tctlr a/ro /ltJ-Ied     f/;af d/Jol!5er:(Li20 ..s: w.
 3 (j 339) (Dui'f           of a;;;;t:a!J1 1~1 fAe v/lf/C/bhJ-A.~/ ol';/7/on o-F Lrr.IZ V. .Jia.r~
  Alo. Ol·~oo-oo'l63 -CR, 2·ool                 Tex .. fJ,op. /£)(15 66)'/1 2ofJI WL 11632?3,
  cd *I (Tex, A;J;?. -1/ou;fo"'               /l-t ~,1)/.rfj Ocf ~~ 2oo/          1
                                                                                       /lo pel) 1 fXjJcmrlecl
  +he         5ar1ders exrepf/o,, 1     ap;lyt'ny /I        /lof   (1/71;;   Ia       C't?J/'5   1;7   wA/c~ a
 nor7- f"oal co,?,v/t:t/~,., Vlc;J /ra;Jroprrly uxeJ io f,?hal"la pvo/.JAmP/J--1,..,
  b·uf        to   ally (CJ5P   1'n Whtch a de-!Fr~r/t~l?f )//fat! ''frve "lo                     t:r/7   ~~?!,CI/lrt'l'11~nf

                                                     7
                                                             .....   ~.
                                                                     .     ..     ·:

a/leyaf~~·n a11d fAf re('.),~J aT...f,'nnat/vely l'eHect;· f/;c,f ljv fl//or
{ t)n ·,1/cl/i.Jtl r oulcl /J (1-f ,?.~i Yf br:en u 5e.l                        ry r     f/Jhan am enf ;/ttrj/o.res • .7cl.

                                                  (                               .. ;
   TAu.'i, un(/er S.·:nu/e-"'5·, vV/)fr--} cz Jrff'.'?c/!.lnf;Jiecrri.I f,·£n? -lo                             t:?/7 f11'?)a/Uen1t'.t?t·

porctsroph I        but           1-~e (f'(ord off./r;naf/vf!y, r·p-//("'(15 IIJaf f4flj)t"/()/ (//p( -j;tJm lh5 /Jicyai.Jt'l71~,7t'f:' & a;;;:>ly~~.9
 +hi 5 (oorfs pre U:Je rds ·and a 1/o Wt;':J 0./J e)( t:c'fd/c"? -;;;-_"" VJ/;·j}/ttl l/u~                                or
 fo fh e ;m;rope[ P.'lAontf/'llb'lT ;Jt?!t:lj' /o;;h f' ••T,'I 4/;;lcanlJ ~a ff>/ lle all-
        , 6 7Wo
 e9c:. +:11)'/ ConVn~ 1'-'/iJ U.Jft/ /o/· ~/J/UfiJ!r>-

 me,.,f para:3raph.s were; 1?9-/r;;;/1/ to,nv,(f~~n5 1 j!Jti'P-;;/.§//Jpllrvf/. ]~
               ,        ,,    .         Ot7d Thf'lfe.' Two.. tm,?lvjJf/' f'IJOQ/It'fl'ltft7ts· l!?af /f"Jt//lec~
 ~/a ;;1 fA t1 _; n c/; <.:.if17'1 i't-1 f . ..L            __r                                 1.  . 1
 1/}rtpjJ/1((1111 _.f ,J/rya/ 5f/JTt'/l(f                 (}T        J() ft'tlFf/          f'/lrJ417{ed. _J;,7 t1f<'oldPI-7Ce

w,'fh I,{/; Courf; precelfnfs otforc)~j If~~/ .;;o~-7 •Cr/7 //~ol5to/Jifi1Cr
al  a11y t/me 1 C11u/ Py 1'1/t?Kt~ t:fl"' e.kct;of,~n -!Aa! F,(r~.rr-5 ~;;i<--al?/f
plea of' -Irue -lo -lle f17At111cE/J1erJT j/ct/c'Y/o/;;r /1/?~'ru;t/ /; f'niY-?/
+o rel/fF,   T/Jp J'ucjPfflf'a-1;~ f~/5 cafe 5A~ulr/·j~ Vctcalt<>~ C?/J//~;;;:ccmi-
 shov/d ··be (ftJ'1at7clecllo tAP (u;·lo)y of I)~ Sdt>,r/;// ? -r ,{'tfi17/ol/ C(;(/l?~                  1

fo O.t15wer fAe c!Ja'Ye5 5ef ou-f /r; -,/i)P ";,cJ;.-1/11~/l-1-..

                                                                                                      RPffJf't-f/u/? .ruiA1.:/f,:./
                                                                                                       /)~
                                                                                                        DereK klayne Man+ez.
                                                                                                      :t:l 19Jq3/£
                                                                                                        //Jir;! -t/1'7/I-
                                                                                                      2/0I r/u3t91V:
                                                                                                      I.. o 1111c; fc;; r K.J T f' X t1 S
                                                                                                                              76367
                                                         8
                                                                     . ; ',

                                   CE,R71rlt:t97E OF CoMPLIAtJCE

     I , l)frtk Wtijit?f 114v/lft:z- 1 R11o 5f' 1 /fj~/,'ctMf                 c/o   )fifJI/ (f'rf/'-;j fhaf
·+he. Svpplem-eni ;g"/ef.Ir, 5v-/-'/}o/f o.f' 5u;d;ef.-t./f'l·lf ~-?y)Jlc·a                 f,'o'/1   !;/' .M:/'1
of ~L:tbeo5 Corpus har 6tt>7 srr-vrcl /;}" V-5: !Wet// d/; fA.:s IJe IZtll. Ja!
 6   -F ::fu Jy , 2_ DI_S a clef/ r::;;;· f / -1o

 Jo (cufer
 t) ,'sir it: ·r    ( lerr< - Randct // tb:.M !y
 2 301 Ru5 sell) o;!J 8/vJ, sl-e, ;;o
 (~'1~yolJ 1 TcXd-5             77015"'

 -Jarne.J //~ .Fet,- r e11
 l!one/a II           Cfl ~}1/~} a/ l);'JII'I ~ f /lllo,r 17;1
                    fou,v;l);
 2 30CJ Rus se II J or?j /J lv/1 ..s~fr, 120
 _(a,1yon Te x a y 79o;s-
                1

 /1/;el llcosia           1
                              {/frk
 {ourf       oF C"t//f11~'ft'l I ;J!fJfq/f          v-F   Jt Xcif'
 f,(), 8ox 12 3oS 1 [o;>/io/ 5-/czf,~,r; ·
 /Jvx-k!l 1         TeXti5      ?J'7/I

                                                                                    ~ l!!Rpv ;tj~
                                                                                    DerFtt' t1laf17f   Alonft: z..
                                                                                    fro ;e 1 ApfJ,'(an+