Court Opinion

ID: 4056805
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 08:10:23.323+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:07.728372
License: Public Domain

CAIJ'SE:          ,.JD,   1>\'\)<:\::>r)OOl'\S/
S\1\T E   0 y:   T E:~ AS"
                             ';
                                                        1
                                                 1~9 5 85 b'i~, "t.tS;'-FlZ/1131 '11-4
                                                               1
                                                                                                                                 - !J,s-tt> ,c_;-\'
                                                                                                                            lr<l\11 1i C€>J "lry TV".~

                 \o ~(. ~o.,._o... ~\o\E.. -lu~(.. -of So~.,a <2-oort:
                  ~~              NDvJ     d.e.~c."'d",r'+-/Afre\0\nt          A:hov~o ~-\yle.J ~"l~
                                                                                        \N
                   tJ,h-... be. f" e"'".s e., uJOo \ <l rv-.ove. ~,-::, Covf' \ 1-o SV"&\/).(- wn-\- o ~
                   ~()OC\MVS <A."'6 P"l>"-''~\t\oN I A.,tJf) ,tJ S\J p po r\ () r S""d
                   Mo-\-,o ~ 1 \.JJov\c\ S\.-.o~ -\-~e Co..Y\ ~ F~\O\J\>\·V\9 -~ '

                            ~e.-\-'~"'"'' W" \\-- o~ ~be"-S' Co'f ~v.r ~~ \f..d 1r-J -\-he. +..-\l.d Coo.\.,f,
                   ~0\hn~ +~~ Covr-\- -\-t> - d.\~V"'\IS.S fNl)I<.TM~NT lit'\~ d\S&>Co\'8<-
                  t>ros.e_c\1\\0~ ON rGJu~l s~-\utes aC \w\1\,tCA-\-U)NSt ~ro.J"ds
                  liMe.- bc-.ua nj t't"o(e..c.\lhn N             F'ov thiG.f e;<foSv re. 1
                          f'e.Ce-~ f>t'O\l,b,ttorl o,J t\W\e.               pe.r•oc!~ <:;>< ce~d,,vj
                   lr-l\&\I'Y\      \\ty\1-\"hoiV.S         o.-1      ~e(".£-()f\)5     de,tt\,~e4      p

                   De.~'-"d".vtJ~~reiAilt               C.'"''""s           \,~,-t~+-,otJS        \$   an O.bso\~te.
                   ~r      -\C)    f'cvse.c."ho .-1
                           1\~~     +~e        St".~U       de-la.y         ,t.l      ~(o'SeCv~IZ>...       hl.\S    e)(;V."\vl\ec:\
                    t\...e.. Cov ( \-.s 0\J r \~d.\ct\1>...1 •
                      f\f>~\li\1'-\- C\t\v. .,S '-"'~e..< -\\e.                    (..O(.r~       C.O~!,\tol'l.s      DF ~e. ~""'-"'S
                   door-+1 ~f~o\1lf. 1 f>-re.""""""'                       c::k..-\-a.\1'\ee.s   ~rc.. S-v~ fe.r'Oj          dU'l\C-\l
                   o~ o...c..eess        -\o   t\ne   Co.:>r'rs,
                    1\Nd ~           ~-r~".\-'~1 f6\,\1nl'i ~OC" \Alf'\\- of                                  1'-"-o-W\JO\MVJ
                   ()J\!     ~"l>~·b\ho.J VJOV\d ~e. O.~(='r-opr,t.l\e_.,

                                                                                                               RECEIVED IN
                                                                                                        COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

                                                                                                                    OCT 07 2015

                                                                                                              Abet Acosta, Clerk
            s"""'.W\e. 0 ~ \,~,~-\lo,Jf un~e..f 1JY\-\~ s~+-e-r Code..S
\) fe.6erfl\\
l\-\\e \9. u.~.C. ~ 3\ t.Z ~hooJ.s, '' tf" a.. JeJ"V'\d."')* \S Not bro~\1+
-\-b   h-\{,\\ W\~\~              t\..e.    -hMC.       \ ........ ,\-       t"e_q'"'c::..4.    loy '0\b\ (_                 <A.-S      e,c\"e,V'IdeJ
 by Su·hoN 3\ t.l ~ 1 +~e 1":1~1(;\--(.V)-\ ~hCi\1\\                                            be...    cl,sM,=>.l o~V Moho~ 0~

de.f.en~r-\ 1     f\ll)    t:.xtens~oi\)J.\o.V                      pc.r..so"'S           de-~1N ed~

 J..) f\\5o \ B \J,S. <..               ~    :n b't-,      . Pe..rs-of\JS             Je-\ao.'"'J Fe.de...rA\ \' rv\)e,.c,o\-n,~
 ~(l"e0 l.oy        prt)\o.'~'\-'o ,.J            o.v       -\'"'e.           ~.e.f•O~~           e.lfC..eeJd'~'~j              tN+enll.\

 l1 ~.t"' t' o 1\15 ·      t>   f'J     f'-'"rso ~         de..fl\ •.V£-d ''              tJc     de-b\I.Je e. 1 ~ ck.~~v~ec! '~
 Svlo~e.,chciV ~ 1 ~""""'' be 'ne. \A                                1N.       CoJtody            f>e,n~',vj              -\-ni'A\      a.(:-\-el""
 -\'-"e. ex i'\C'O·hor1 o~ sue.~.-) qo d.(l.y {'e.nod. r4" "·e.J ~o..- -\-hf; co""~~cen-,c.ll\-4-
  oF ~''S -\"fl'\\/~                         .

  3) ~"o devHC\ \ ~f ~ss . to t\,e. Co'-'r~s e_,(c..e.e..J."-'9 eo"'st,totwl\l&tl
 d-\l'\")ev.~\oNS ~'*''n -\he vnecvn~j
                   1                                                                 0~        t'nc.      pub\'<:.            AGco(Y)odCA+Iot\JJ

 .\-l\\e.. ck Cl\)1\            (\~ht~        f\c.."t" \~bL-1 1 lt-2                 LJ •.S.c       j'   J.()oO             ~
· "-')ue.fe.Y'dCI'"'t ~' bee"' de!''c..d.. ~~~~"\ ~'\d (\'VC'"P~~l)l ~rhuf"'hoAI
   IN \-\~ 0 .......,n ~VG''-\"\ pco(ess
   5)T~,5 Je.V'ttd ~"".r de.sC\bkd -\""~ de,~~~AV\t ~ro"""' e"fof"G\nj
   fe.J.ert\l li\.W \'\ +h~ 5\-ct-\~ c.our+ 1 !~el'efbre. <;.\~\VV)j./ af'l41'\t'r\j
 'Pe\lht>~ Fo~"'               'hAb~~ CMf.:U v-eh~f ~\,o.J 'd                                           be.    £\.    P"te.\y M•" 1sh•.:tf
 ~e-..,..., f-rrJo ,,.., ~~                ,.vte<-es- o~ Jo.s+/'Ge.
 t,)   'D-e..f"e..'()co.n4 ww               CArres-\ed             Ot-l         i\-~n \         '1- 1   2:oVS         A-f"td ~e.         \o \1'\l
cus\~y Cls                0\          ~e-e.,-t-r 10.\ lk~AI"~e.. . "rt...- \So                          dC\.yJ            <for -\-\ne. So\-c:.
~pose. rJJ~ O,.vUC,t.\h"j                     tno.l.
'":\) "Def'c:n6C\"..\- \t)~u               bee"     d..e-->•ed O..cc6~ -h -T~c:.                              c..o..>"~      (-ZOW""'    over \So
 OAy~
 9) 'be,(e.-,d«A()-\- ~ 'bee,...-. de.V\'e d M~"\""j~v\ <?~.no f"'' fo)<.-t:'\.1\
 'ft\rhc.tf"\ttoN \Y) h~~ ow...., .JuA.'c...'ct\ Pfoc.~ss w'-'uc.. "''~ OV\\y
 re.~'""''~...9    ''be"tY '"'-\e"'~~                   "-1.-\   o...-'(..    ~\-"\<e..
q)    J)en ,~\ o ~ o..c.e-~s.s +o +~ Cbvrt ha-s d\ScAio \e de.-fG'l~ll+­
 ~,.ovv. et"\~o<""C.\h_9 ~edev-A\ Lr..w W\ s-to...t-e Co..>/ t
 1o) 't)en, "' of O..C.CGSS ~ -t"'e Cov r \ h~ \ e3rA.\\ y \ ~~red ~~"~d.
 Q~"-b\tC,         -\"'t      Qe~(..l'\~"1-\-        'ffO'M      "'SSer·h~             fA"Y    n~h-t-~     \V\   'S~te
 Covt\-
  \\)'1 ~,5 cl\S'-"'~'~ttoJ ~Ill~"'{\- o..                    'e,y"\\~ '""'f>Mec o..v..~ ~'SCJ\b\e.c.\
 \)cefn(A\         o-e..-\-"-\nec -N)ecH -\-~c.            C\"-55    \J~e O.,f\ 1vV\of foi"' 6~tci.I')J
G.. C.tl.l.,n o~          o'sc.... ,"",..,e\+tv/\1     "'3"''1)~-\-      c...   fret-q"'/ -oe..f&l~ee- 1         , ....

 ..\-u\N'\S oC"        f"'"C..C.'"' e~u~h\~                  .
 IL} 1\     VIOI'{tto,J   (!)~ ll'11te.d- s~.f-c.f lo.uJ Auth1Jfl2ed, u~dlj' +~ i'ub\tC...
 ~tC..ov1•·ivGQ,;t\i>I-JS -\ -\\e.. 0' -\-1,-,e C1v1\ r-\~~\S f\c.:T o-; \(\~'-\ ~ .2.o\f!J. 1
                                 1

~l U.S~( ~              2ooo '
I 3) 1J~e..f\ 6M~ C lo.. 1""' 5            +~ 5~k~ d.e..""-y \Y\ ~rosc.~h ov) hAS eJr;i l,o.."ste.d.
  ~e. COurh J\ln~'c.trorJ 1 f\f\d. ·,1') -f~t. Covr} IJD L~V!tj<:,( -h~ +he powe'
 t-o ~'c.s>r'fc..\V' J f\,e.re~r-e ~<""~ ~"_j '\?•l'e.tn~l hlhbe.as Co.- f"'S ~el,e.f wov ld
be. 4 W""tl.t'<" ~~ \e
 I'+) O(JOI') \f\For,..,..,~\, 0 .-J         b6hef, de..~(f'd'-tl)+s ta#or.,e.y . l"d'CAt-es o 1\1
                                        O.VIc!
 5e..p\e ~ber 2 3             51'\ h:.. f~c.v-\-oi"S Anf'lov"c.e..d \I"\ OPen Co.;l'~ T'-'cd· +~e.

 5~ake. \~ no+ Pref>"'c.d. For                       +n"'l
  IS) ArretlcuJj-          Gl"'...,.s   -t\n~       00)\c.,.\ \-o     ~ covr-\-s               o..no S~\es        de \tA..y
   II'\   !pro~a.u-\,ooJ        d.e""ons+rGtte. o.. Cc;.lt~rO,b\e CDVl~l,c.,t be..fu>ee11 tl'eck~\
  0\r-.J s-\-<.\ t-es I"' ws
  I(.) 1\:ff'ellcti'Ji CIOifn. ~ off,,. rnt-1-tue.,.                d(...~tns-es l)tf'oe...r -rhe. Av-\.0or•1:1
  o~ 5~\e. \"'-"'-'           ~efSU<\o()-\       \() Ch~rl-e.r \(. 1e..x. C..t"IW\,            Qr'b 1   ''''e.   16 v,.s, (..
  "3\b', '3\ bZ./ ~~£,~, '311~
   t'l} Afee.l\~1}+-          ol(l.ln--S         -th~ sht~s del~y               \r"'    "C"01U.Jho,J h~
  ex~"-"''l\--€J        ~\ie... co.>r\'s j 0 ,,sa,c.+u>rJ                1\~d. -\-1-)e..      eo",.+'-""'' losr
  'Poc..ve.-r   -\-o    -res\ r4 \" I
    1)~~Ct"\dq'1\- \S            ~ow dlt.ju ly            C""(:"\()c::d
~g) tA.h\-~ C\~\ -\-"-'e..se- d~~'"''~e.- ~eoe,,.~\ CJ.~~ s ~~e. \~s                                         \Y'Iv   6~!J
fu+      \Y"£t~-\-to0to.bl y    D..f'f'\'(    to       ~         \Vlt,\.I,Sput-""lol('_      'ii=o.c..-b he.rc.--\"\      1

C\eu1\ Y Jtvnbi'YS\-\'"t>+c          l\ \e.3 o.\ e.l\h\\e,Y"Ylt-1'\ t- 0/'10.                     Co n'f>\-•\0 ·h oNcvl

 lr\~h\-    ~or    (e.he~

 I~) -r~tr~(orc.J 9~"Mtl~               "     lft,-\-I~ON fo~                     ~re-\'~\Ov\ \)wb~ re.\,e.-f=
 WM~        'oe... C\OP(()t'(Wd··e           0\nC. ~             \'Y\W'I   IS   reqtt\ A.C..-\-
 .2_o) Cle.~e.l'~""'"      C\IAIYnS          ~()(" \(1~\\)\d,ov-r c~\W\ \n('f. h                      cY.J    O.,CA\n~ t-
 o._ ~te-\""f\~\   aettA\Vl(.e,...     D~      -\-I'""G\.'11\~   Coul'"lt-/ I G\>')6       0\S(f\VY)\>'"'I<Atury              c:Af'6
 CfY"\1(1:\\   M15.5u5c.       e~       C~'N"\'""'\ .j-.JJhc.e                       -sy-s\e-"YY      '"' -\-r.:;;..viS Cou~r~\-y
  Co\lrt~ooSC..     o...<"e. u \\.-oc-\ --z-ed            lYideJ
   42. o.s,c ~          l~ta\
                             1 \C\'\3z, \q S31              lctS6 1 \liSe.
  1.~,     u.s.c, ~      \311~1 \y,1 1 \b6\
   ,ca     u.s. c. ~     2.~n, ztt7.1 2 1-\E,

    \~     o.s.c. .5    'S\b\J ~\6l1 :SH'1 1 31":f ~
   T\He. lS IJ.~.C. ~ 6\-=l"'\ 1 ~u6,\Cl~l \Vl\Pie-rnc,n'}G.ih-o"" Provide-:
   ~e..~e~l ~to-\V"\c. ot=: \\>'Y\ ~\-t()IV51 Sue,~ ·h ""''\e.._ P~ ~ods be·h..., -e-er1
   Arr~s\-         CA.fl6.       \-('" \            s \-\"' \\         f'.o-\-'       bG    ex+e.."' A.e.d. Tt-           ~e-ecd                   ~so
  ckys        ~"            pre;\( m\           ~•"le.e-.S
 T\-+\ e.      \e, u. C C..            :i 3 I E."'\        1       ?e-rso~             . ck.\4 \I')~ J   t=>ro ..J\·ou '          -;-G<0Gr41t 'S ~ hJ te

  O.f\~    t:e~erc..\            prohl'<n-\-•o,J orJ +'~e.                              f'et'\DdS      Q,XGeed~"'j            \N+-t,.r,.,...

  \'VV'I•~horJs           or-l    fet"Su"''S                Q.e-\-"-1nc:-o 1           No       de-~\V>ed ~~\\                    loe ~elt!              \V'\

 f:0":>\-ooy be.yo"' +V)L.                          e,KP• ...~-he>"'             o~     Sue.~     q.n d&..y      f?et'lod           A~No.!h~
 th~ Co >"h rn t.t'l-C..C.m Ct"' f 0 F                     +     t'1   cd
1 •+-le       o.s .c.)3.\t2 1 S"'-nc..·h()r-)5 (>ro"\~e-5 ~ '"' o,. dec::'c,t'l.:l"""t ~5
             tg
 r"\o-\- bec_.n bro~ltlt tn +r\(A\ LUI\'n," -\~ -\-,.-r~e.. ~no6 Ye~u•ye~ lpy
  5ec\\ON '3. \ 6\          c,    o....s     e)(;-tet"lded             b\J 3 I t. \
                                                                            ./
                                                                                           nJ    IY\~(1""\CA+\o.(    ......
                                                                                                                     v        \nd •vtVVlc.-f\•T
                                                                                                                                                    . L

~~\\ be. d•s...., •<S                      Uf'O"'      ~horJ o ~ -\-'v-te d.e.te"1C!c.nf
'De\el'loCu'\+ Cl"''""'.s - -t""-~ S\-C4·k5 de\o..'j ,..., prose..ccJb4N hou
~\~QIJ.YTe~ -\-'-'e. Coud-_s Jvf1Sd\C...T\OtJ l1\-lc.. IQ, u.s.c... ~ '3\'-\ '3\62 '3li~                                                                                u
                                                                                                                                        I            I
                                                                                                                                                                1   ~1(.,

 De.fe"'o"'r%-s C.l"'l'>'\ -\-he. sf4\1'-es delc..y '"' Pr-o)e-c.vho,J ~~ e.<ceeded t\,e
 f"eoer"A\ s~+oto£ ~ I l,...,lttj·b DNS .,,....,e b'Vr''}J fh:sc.c.Jho v For Ovel' G.JG{'Oj\Jre
 De.~c:...~l\-\          G\<A\m)            ~e         1 ,...d 1 e-+rn~               \~ de~ec,-hve         ON       th \c~c.e 1                   \.S
  I 1-.\C.u>'U..b\e_     <\"'d        \ r""'f"r"lo'\~
l~e.        IV'Id \C.trv)(."-\-             ~V)o~~                +""'\t              ~"Y \)ro~e.cuh otJ              t.:S        1-:>,.,.-,.e J
  'by by ~e6e.rtt\ S\-tttu+e o~                                              \,>'l'l,t'\t•orJS

  A\ ~o1       C..h'\p-\-cr                                                                              ~"' o cedure
                                                                                                                              1
I \t\e.       \B       V• 5. (_       ~        31bt slt.2 1 '2ti.Lt1                        3lr't
                                                   1
'flrO\It6_, Vlj        -\-"'e,   Co.Jv--\-          W\~ A0~or1ty                           ~o     d \SCI.-t..r~-e.
Fol'      Ut"'dv e.       d.!)~/
  L~h~       (A.\\ ~Sc.            6e.~\vn\e.. 'S.\<-\\"e. C\V\~ fe.wf.\-\                  \~ws \'V\vo~e<!,
~"'\- LMqves\\OP\c.\>\y              o..ff'y -\-o      -\-\;,<.-   \llld~ ('o~\e ~c..\-\ ~...~'VI,
C\.e.tM\~ d-e"""or)s\-'~te.. ~ \e..j L\\               VI'   h\-\e ltVlU'I\--- A'l\-'a eo""'~ h\-0\--&.CN G\\
V''\_~ lA~   ~ re\1e F" '?      "'

 1\N~ ~'f"'\l\-\.\V'jJ        C\      P-th \1oN         fbi"       Wr\\- of." M~,l~aNtvJ            C\Vla

 fl.ro ""\:,\ +,o,J    A-pprOfr"~t~.-\-e..?

 Af~eJ\£4;)+ v-e~pe-£-l-Fo\\y                 frc.\y      fi,"+ -h,\s      CO.J/f     av·£\,,..,t
'?e -h ~ o,J rt> ( j
         • W-r\ \     0 ~   M/1\n dt\vYJO.f
         •   Wn ~     of= \}ro ~~ lo • \-t o tJ

 \ t)ec\f'\-re unoct" PGYl"'\ty of 4'e<Jvry, \J'i'Get". ~e \fl\vlJ c)t="
~e l)"'ll\ed ~~+eJ o'f ~~e-f\CA. 1 -r~""\ -+~e fnccfjo•"?_Y 'S +rve
CtVld O>rfecA·· 1 -r 1-ne :)..S u.s, C- ) \ 14g
                        '
          ·····--- ---·- ----- ·-··· --- ----··· .   - --   -   - -   --       . --·                          .   ---·- .   ---~   -----   ----·- _______ .. _______ ..•.• -----·-   .   ----------------- ... ---- ·--·   .. -----------·   ---

                                                                           j

                                                     CERTIFICATE OF SERVICl&
                                                                                                                                           •

            ·I hereby certify that on this the                             Q.          ·day of_6c_<~.,...o....~~f':.-- _ _ _                                         .J.             2.() \ S ·
a           true                 and ·               ·correct ··           cdpy             of           the                   .above                           and                        foregoing
..:=l).'):::.!~...l.:'\~oCi:..;..._jM~"':.;..;V"l:.wOO~rn~"';..o.;·~.....·.;:;.CA.;....~-llo~'--IS?._.ro~\.,...:.:'b::;..';..;.}...;.\..:;..b_,J_____ was fonvarded to the office of

                                                                               ORDER

              On this the._ _ _ day of _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _~----~ came on to
be heard Defendant's                                                                                                                                                                           and said
motion is. hereby
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 .;•
                                              { )GRANTED                                                      { )DENIED
              Signed on this the                                      day of _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _~:------

                                                                                                              JUDGE PRESIDING