Court Opinion

ID: 4075553
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 06:11:06.17719+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:34.938768
License: Public Domain

©~’/7('15/£.-{> u\

1111111 111 01 01 001 311@\$ 311”7;"‘1$ 1111 34 0111111 111-1111 110 own 1111/ 0/>/§;15

>0 \ 13 RO/Bhb an age add O§L 76 011'5” '%€lf§r F mm AP
-72)<¢113 090:1)3§ ca1 1006 17653 516/13 /"’/\’“=5 ” b 1711,.““\"/°31317:/11
am61b wai<)r§§ 911 41:/12 ._/_,016§;3¢1\/,0 z?j§OE/§ ij ~ 1155/016

:uf+ 61*+3%‘& ////e/:me:S/:Jdt{wr'r' D/FP\ mmi/7 pop [/L){>1A WQA

>(‘ 113 1101 111 1130111 €>`(~<1617 §z>r r){\@;@1140 3 75/ 5136\:11‘1£;@,1\‘1)`1'\0€’0`71?1)} minds
1015 ‘m PO£P p\€(" mOC-`\ 1$6§€“‘¢§<21"11’1£ 13”1"@,5(1(`110€6-`17?@(’ '{f)u/- ‘f€'g
06 {’&`1€>3<;1 00 \¢\15 e,`\ w 6161'1< 256/711

130 Q, Q" 5\1> &\D
0 \42011110\/)`_`)';1\015_0\6)77`0;?71§ 111111 j'b¢¢#:/54255Q %’O/~§OLU”
597 &m@/(` \\O ">< c77/0'7 93@§ P0630F1601 1:/51'(/101$5 001`161:1
5100163 1051 6 13 00 011 4(131;4 37111111:¢1\ 01 ;21>/5()3 buck
§a§r"’\(\ \/1'01 or) moL‘\@A, (\l Om WZ,P 31 /1@\/@(~»}»1'1@/£55
:;70`1_`61:1'('10€ a,f> J>‘eaj 5 010@ (g®\/)Q> 304».9\/12>§0:/7©,71\[)‘;\@:
m; (111>>\0,1:1@(\ bw% gm abpr/,gd~,@@ and( 1113 11216¢ BeJHB
0¢0~0\0\01‘@1:¢1 on ev£d@nce ppO\/;/, 1142 w 115 51031'301 10
C\»P‘Dec<_l -H’)e. ,Oe,/` bQL'Q /a.L/€ /1‘>" /)7 566/47b whom
F:;J 0 O~ ,DM@/ 004<32/01%115;1?5‘4 O\/@M
amd 533 de¢ll\' 651 1031 617 mm%@@§;¢@j 011 17`6€,'13(2>0’7
1111 cow+:§c mmc-101 1010 111 ~773@15 1001 611/630%017>1
3101100 1311/151;0 wan 7 7// '$ 0011/17611:1' 611/amen caa/5 n
113 _3:\;\/@”"’/”¢”1 3630/‘6110106 cwa 1030/631 004 wl$c/O§$ij€€)
1111 erm@(\@. 1116 /6)<<16 §1116$ 09 affd/316 1900<¢¢10¢1\6 73 /
510»1'33 ‘ /z€e/<‘Jv%e r:?(:r cason :Mon 17 er
1112wa 1511/25 0:_&9@6\\@}>@66@16?0:101)

 
 
 

Mup€ 713 109 10551

®r\oum 01{)61°$ 2 men 011
11 1110 11°§{?11“€,11111;1§§“511@<;1111 1110/110 57 112
' Q°°"‘ m3 <:’ 011“‘*"‘013 1"'511$\+ 1104 Mwn*r 11¢11211}
5601 _ 631/13 'L-YYMJ\\ mem 00 \91 5"2<`9/§//¢ b 51;:103"
5601 mg (%3§0\1\611\811\16\1:1)@1£5§’16 11161141111 mem
§Op SlAH)) 63 (;15)$1¢6@15{)@&1)(5)@{\\/@10?€$ 611/7€/(-£ j1/11/`

P€Y)Jomd 0013 2 O/l/f\b Y)o(:$¢;) 1e>m6 001 201
"1\631;1_1.1“_’5£5) 161/n 5111>9\\}@5’/h3@0€`11`100,' 191 2 ll/(bm,k 1111 115

l '4 fha 0 0 9 04 ‘S MW€S 525 `24'
0;>222*0:20> UT§Y 4 200:22042 02 000 00
f»l025 662-5 6252’2\2,2;+2,¢4

20 .l/$€Y)+/Vy
(I§E`)'l‘@‘#$09¥'02‘51:}§:”`:§3 25954;€64?? c§p& f
(5> @n&/c/c> 6/5 (1>22546 pU) 2525 \;z~Q-,;zo/§/A» card mp [j;;gjj

P€WMA 000 00 405~3¢;2422/2 5 25 25~eeel2156), enel app 2.e5~
:2:2/0, been 2256;4~ F:L?iuL 22 2254) 2>44'62,25662 45 3252>324;@/) 222659@22
20

23 "4' 0 2`5\02 :+ 2500/44 Cz) bae/542 /222€3¢'4, 0 '

no qmo;§+§f w£% 3~/?0/§¢4/()¥)€//`§;:/02§,4) 15 :Ljhjg@{-
;;,‘.`IJLEJ) am€/Cl 05 20/7

n\~.Icl 504 €;4¥“%40?\@:4.: “"H'::S/

\L\F
2256$2;\_2124
@_Qf’(`@d“

.. "F.S I'é§/?
3003 $:HY 2925 49 q”jC>/¢/H D.~ moreovef‘ :):n 322':]042{ P04 443
542>252¢“ we`@D 939 paup (;2:5,`§) ,,7 4244 m;,

350 425 )4 0 0 734/444
§V€£LZ+€“ +:l: 20sz '.004§1:/:;430/0 3500 440 2113/2000 §422,/»
\0@>)< 2525 \9~';7 20/1/4225464 659

en r) 640/4 cm
\ee»ele en 293~92>/¢/425 ~ , -n;Ye/:IV _il:”ed 's+rl 2245@424456»;£
+ \‘O_l/'O‘.:\O&X;’ O“'~ 0 ¢'_/Q/r'/" ` 2 /|/-j 61
§::"$00$224 2 200§50 02§0+24§ :§?)0£40;00/1;”2;04 1002
31/6/’ e.é>dc/ 25
0562§<4”25040)95 0@);&4:44#22'5? ‘(Qg§:he:%/¥ 209 6 “L w

§ e/Ol/<;/@
eend 215 \n M€pen "\?»;5:~44 022>¢6§24&4 /062~*03¢/229/225md
lm@mou§(’¢“\ €‘2?45{5/@32: 2525 842¢6`4* 10‘40429 29222’ 30'?]04 5 day 45 41>2454065-
2403 I// cba d 2020225[2;5 /Q o”)L/ 229/2240 200025 06
wedne§ 0222>24 449/nsz 4522525 me m supp/ /;e$n/\(J
ff§g) 6r6422>2\€ l 3604 4000-442pr 0040~44\ LVLM 402 432\¢22\27
S¥e€v`mg“_g, _I§en>r 25224* vm,{ CISE) on 44560 4922‘2\¢4?/5 $LLPDW 2500
224 5422; 234 025523 40qu 2002 fnev4024624,

\9 34 965/465 025 21 4»36c4n68 ex 064 C 4552‘$`4'25')0.$ 432`9 5}42`@

035€49€;`;1:;;/ j-_ n:;/m& M:(/‘ZB§ £%\_{§'4'2(? "45 5' 04 5 ,:DSFjZ>ol/) n
5’ ” 696 / 20 {y

,le|"&(‘v 0,\’)@444‘\6(’:;[ /FO dd:cd /¢'/\7»`£?9/56' b/ e;n»:$`*€"?i,£ C`Lbe_>

3402:\'2 fl (4&:<;4 (_LS’E du 25 3 42 {. 454/1642
24'6475 ind 0070£4§ `_2_)~}€24:)627$:/:4 “4/::452, L&E:OL`. 2531/ly on \V:z\l

  
 
 
   

  

®c)n-¥ Com cl me 699 j 56 \(\@@r)) gm

f 996 can come<:+¢d %Q,:z¥ h:::>j@§ fgen‘}'mj

’ D/cuL/M) U>L_S Jsu¢§d;§z;: /@M apparach 48 wall/wes 9593 499
arm
_/152:`)4@450 /77¢?>4/¢00)74 fofjpclgp) \j(

@Q?Q.£_@rj)y

5) @n&/c;/c> e/S (~'1)-,4’)|¢ 430 00 \;z-Q-go/q/#j> ard/QQ{ 955
§Q}“U:p€d€>m<+_ on \9"-{§?";70/$¢/} b “ 066€1[1§£5))&¥)¢{§:¥0?0?€5
Iv<), bow w&€+ A 40 how week b S\oc>$#m>/) )u€§ d&;/ .
95 no+ q@m 549sz 559ij :+ 90@/\‘+ coka /u@s,&@
\:\N»\l/)cr mere+ I;d§j%` 3420/990 imd/pic/7 25 44 LQ€@(
j W@S§\:](;L qno#\' 09+\,1<16§?§&:¢9% S&m€db#§foj,>/;O,
5

n}@f°(‘ecl“ arizer cL@S€/f :/;#J//S»~

s ;W: Q<%QH_D/W W£PI%A
OCLS n l ' 63 ,4 or’€,C>\/eF :“);n¢[ 3a 0 4
9’0€\'~¢“ w~”~;~:%§§‘@$ ‘@S+L/ 95 fJ‘/d`[ )/OLL(‘[?$?)A //7 415ng 75 LDC]:O;;H P:;:j+_
L\/ ,/) ariz ZDLLP 93 649
6£4£4§:59 5219§9 “7*:'5`49@/9 599/994 99 j%i,ij§§ 99
9 X OV? " O/ 9’) Lt'€ , CO ~€;
9::0}£_ On `\Q ;B“QO/z/:LL " _ jdnd¢ even n )4:: 5`_5 ll d 76{¢4’)+5::)€1
44 494 9':4,9 99999~ ' 9 1 ' -~9 -, 4 99
09 dr / _ ._ ,S l (
§n§@n… my CFSE) 9qu 019/936 \¢”5+' \OM»IE\ZG§?OS:H blow du (i:ju
I+ 1091/af cMaLAc/C,L N€€d he¢e@~$g)/ and %z/§o(£’ _L car

MMMWMMMW§@@@Y@@%%§

4) ( 1 :Z:~]D 0 a@19
lay I // 05 5651<(0 1099 ,°+. Mz:(,m :$\L l~Q,Lf/Q c§?L/ @@/g,£:gwc¢g ¢Ln@

§e,oln€§da£)&n@l €»n 69 H d 956/hi ma m Su /9"@$§&/\@/
'.'I:§’!:) 775<:9”€9>/4€, 1 Ser)+ ano~\*nepf 904© v\jM,yL awpa/21 bmw/
;>¥c€v`\n§" J 54¢@.3\" ©L€\” vm, (._\_SE) on ~9\419 loul\Q\./) Su]>{))§j £LL{
@V -\/\40 gaf 0351‘ 0§»»9\3 merv$’) and /71`//)1‘3|/@5 Fé:}LL"/) 'i»-.}/L
>\»LP~P \QS ,\9' n€€f). &(:SE)J) LMG} 99pr 565 “[‘2'5955€€%9§ <9¥{>671>@{\
(5>@\\/€]€%@5 (j) /)/C /£Pfl, ;j: (4‘):1: Z_)OS c> `7"/)€ L_QU/LJ
\Qm.o amd m@£\\mom mor@\/€r%$ I 10 maggiqu 4
94 31 QO/l//?b 00 09 LJ¢QLY?€SC\@\L{ O\S+ dm §§‘W)a$ D¢SPOS/+@n
154 wmm\ merr)r va)‘L w)@\ §§ n 4~¢6@4§+/ 719 s d 5 ,0'@59940/9
‘,§ ,E£CA€L¢S€F~ 52 j/yccj 7§§¢9,9@,§’ Am+u;@,¢\ / / 67 `,L /5»€:¢/)"§,:14@ %au;
".br&(‘J LU)@%’\€/,L /970 ddj:; d -Q»/?O/£H/,D 0/0 a LL%CME¢SCQ_U
>_A/Cz/‘)\v t/)§d un€cic>l 09 (155)621”)@[ §L¢/AJO JO/TFS D\SFCS l`\`l@[)' L(.S’}' C>+\%I€C )/WQC

j` L]:)/`CU`V 090 CYPH€I"

  
         
        
 
 

   
 

 

w\hcd`c\o 3>0\ 1153 §4'05!‘6~ LO/VO"
3319@/;7:51313@/,55 525 rec/511 /06/’_3

j"é@ O/’)/ /»(?.»- §jrwhn
@,F/)M 352 @':::’:” 6 J/-j

   
 

2 4b
55 wharf-ij 71441 20/115,§\7 5g1/j 671;7%” 0 §7L6370
MQZ:SQM 423(5409 /0<@5590§5’424 424/1759 ICO:):Z¢@I wh@é/?M
©3¥\@¢\1\0\(§ &Jm©bm“" CI /1?`)_/-1710»)&57¢7£115 0;,;1»7=[ accoij when

Ia//réa.»z,/ j/Q¢uc/ c/`#\LS‘}ZQL &l&/~6}/§036;/'7£'/‘%2L /0 /§:3/03£/€)00¢

CQW+ peck Md owed 115 mof€
Y‘e\//\Zwm wtc/14 bod/%@v4$4|/)0:6¢0L1w71’146/65365//W QC€O¢WL

YJ’\O/’Lf)v£{’ PW¢D/`?L §5/) -}~@:/2£¢1`/7.:/_ 570!§//1-/70 ~H)€,v/ W}~§:M

00 6\43.35115 md mcf 511 351/55 5 7436,03
§1/]\0<1§;144966@94577/;;§/}:::@1 115/16/)‘1 1564on 1604me
4-/ 25505,1).)@/»3 ong/3 050 509 555»@/54:1§1/054@,»)

2'1@»@@/@05 5 /1»~..2@/111> 2255 h 10 15 255/1101 447 41
41:3`91»/@ 1715 my ,`,,/,C£ j¢”+gM/J/, g 5¢5579¢ 5?¢/5-57/ Z¢§/<¢ ‘l/g@/

M;L`.`emi` 4`4:555~11}§}16;/44»360(1 // / C{ »/»/F am

&Ij` 00 519/7 ./€ 1?"39115
560 “7%6"“"' /pc/y a//é`fj
PS mMan:)a§ 40 Ser)<{ /e:§£vi` u$¥.:::} // f P{`OCZO[LMC 73 /
6 1
-/

S\QCe .‘._Lr»ec,ewd¥w.no .c€ w 03
\(§SC:>@:¥\+C€:\N§WSVOH‘S/)§ w\/\ j
0 m
3933“€_331`1)4;@530€20$0¢`&'

LCL:;`/y€a`-,"on wa($’

§11144” 441 7121

643 405\<5-\4\1(1¢¢3(2@6“@&

:\MS+‘ ‘;I\Ce”s` e sz,

§§633433*\1\ 152 \°mca`§ 1;:53®“/;§§-/ /':5;5 1134

:3:3\ 313/\4383+; Cock'of) (ASM>_) ‘ \_H;]

~\,O 4\1\~&\\1):4/`$ FQSO\ \VQ~\£\§~ \SS\A€ ‘ ' 6
24444§§4”6$ UEWQ ' 131+<1»/“ /“\S’ ‘
j@ )70”7@ 4§0554\421/)4 150/1 5511'10r\ V\ mm .

m`/%"@Ca~`d/)W@n3<15,2{