Court Opinion

ID: 4040224
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:27:48.195558+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:28:41.905867
License: Public Domain

3:JJ ~0~ -02

                                                                                                           2Yt/~ ~ ((:rr{l a[             11::.

                                                                                                                l~~            •)
                                                                                                -~         nLttJt:;\ d       Q...

                                          d   'LU d!iLd                       ·-1\o             1.0)v· ~-\-IL           .s{oa       ·
                                     rt   at~ \?__              LtS   (?__            f!..fJU(7   o/       -1\ 1L 0 V'Vl_:_LJ~
                                  -~ 'lL tL                ~nIL'(_..                  ~           n !L 'L d              (~)
                                       tott7                    ~n il..o 2srL d _ ..:r.._                   w f'j(         ~        a'I
                              D:
                            c__ 0-\.1
                                           I>_VtcX>

                                       jdl ~JL
                                                       e        ~
                                                                    i:"liL     D
                                                                                 ---'t:-          ~ a1 L        .

                                                                                                                          ckrz          eh
~ a-p)                                                                                                                   ~d
pV""'d<A~~b
    fu 'L
                  pLvbl I .r!:,T

                  ~-hT
                                      a ct--ro,r;;L;- "'_ / ___}'__
                                  ,'6,/A'k-
                                     \. Cho.db _
                                                      ..:':h_
                                                                          \, a v L
                                                                      .rCip       -k       r                        ~L'I-7          in

                                  _l     b),~)(                              _'l?LlM.U•v£>~                    ~LA         ~
l           A-LT            "'LA~         q..,   d               ,!;,)tf'>                 '('{[        '{1o   v~ Q__     dw 1
:do\ !Zr--;;J.tO\      r_     i               r;>!{'J::~~              ~ t- ~ ~
tu.
fulh
          'i-t-
             t\
                             ~u
                  -(LL4-f:::. l__
                                           doni:-    . LtJo...ncr df'V._d7 L.Jt-kh
                                            v-~-1\ ~ n _ -ih ~~ -6 ~
                                                                                       ___r__     •

                   RECElVED ~Nl                                                   ~ ~
                  COURT OF CRIM1NAlAPPEAlS                                        ~n t                 12:·vL·l ~- -~
                        FEB 11 2015
                                                                                                ~tt·'fl~
                                ' B-v'\1 {>    IL-=d 6nobh. Wb{' ~ld ~ck >'tl'lt~
                                 1
}let        \Co
 ~n                 4n d       aLrth~ .       :5-LJ. ~ {     ~ ro-Ta t'n:-,    .. i\)'PLA       '1 (\_ II

 ~ qc(_-" 11 ""\\\~            ~ Id                  ~          ~- "~011<?                  a         pi-p~
d,., .w 'h II           olA-\-       j   a L'¥.\ ~          and       M1jn          c) a ~-v~               1
 -r'1J":  d o,{L t_ - ~1: Mh ILXVLO J -t ~\ ~                       +t. do ~ ;_
  \:'3-r .     1-h '~ 1 .·-fuo -n Gl • bu cll £;· ·· ~o t~~ #
 b .(A1        ~ A                ~'--      -t\ ~ L. ~ !.drn-t tt- PCMn '
  -,\b.      ~\D3Y #q.r,d                                   'Mt
                                                           b ~       'MClMQ ~
 add\ t--\1.d          ~b       A!JKJ KJ I ~d                      ~a~ 1 /J)\c. ~
 CJ-t-J d      'b'R_ d-i.?n o        ~t..          I.e> 'I iL I em d .          {'_an       {::a
  ~crrL h!C\" 1                       nr[
                                 I:ID. :# 1     cLQ..pLnd£/h-t- f dal'1Al . \11_~
 (e1. v'Lo.dtJ :?>b ~LJ.nd ~Q_ hZ?-\-' n'{ cL!b~~danH
 cC}n d     tfl d        'T\~d ~            c.LJ d~1L h,D dOvo i'h. -\ ~--rt_ · '"'(o

  t.1o.\vvz        \:>'LCl( II W't. ' o.l[             LJ'i"lM~hd       miL ~"\MIL
                                                                                                                "
 'no w     . -\\:. ~t /lfe_-T Or ·    cl;Q__c(/ ?Q and    ~ a~-\
; f t-    0.        ¥A r' l     "-£In      \.£7 d    h an d-£:, N'bo £IT:>C
~ . ~ L / -tOU!c...h~d . C!._'il1f'-'~'~1 blA-t                     ci 2d_                      'S"'L
 'n'h-t m GL "')       \~~-~ ~. o ~~ tL ~ ~d . lr1
 x; L/;n,d                      -m\~' .o\•             .· -1'7~           .'f'ne_Vi>         9~-(~
 f>lL~7L                   1   L.:t\d         'nLA'iL . f1'Lt:-e.y.           ~{_ ''i{~~~JL~,, u
   knd                1M IL      Ct                                           · .   ~ ';) p00     1

 . 'MD\)   IL!__r   ~d/"'L\' ~
                                                           ~btilL ~ri:::> ~       An \_/              ~~~
    i\'\      \c.1>14 q o ~ ·                                                         -c_
    ~~U~-nD-n iLJ~no.)l ·                                                      . ~ot~           C_a\\
      ~~ ry.::z ~-'M ~ ;;~ ~
      L~\\1 \. ~oh 1>'1-Y--. 1 ~3S\
         ----
    Z'h.··                 }\'ot7                       Q            e).-x'i 4              -dv~a~                 ,~n
 \" e..o ft lf  a       ¥,~,~~ ~"60         M t-= . r.__ou_ ve.o./{'{ a
. tiL ~n . '1 a-nd ~ fln(                    &Jil( . r'!!-}-- 11                    r
 '?.t.-rl.\'lL~   i0Lr ~LOt: 'tltt- ) al/ 1 ~"'Q~
 ~'Q___n      ~~     ~~           ~~ II ~at-"-    -t~      tae-t__ mQ_~
  .8 ~~p            '('1 IL '} ;)a   dsj:!t ~ ~               "{'7_'( \.
  o ~A?{;~ vo_ 11 ;\\yi~ crrt-~ !il~ ~ ~
- ~-r c Q..(0~ '5 "'::1:[( --- ~Q v (L . Q . h a·-f~CP .. r\'Tt-(~J
 'M'1_      ~'f>b      d-6r?-t ~~Q.- 1\1~ '> !51 0!2h ~~~ i
   'iiP.    ~yn ibbG I btf:t ber<L&J                            r·~m-                                     ro
 6\-                 y \ /:L. /j::)                b        Q   ~~-);; Q bb~                   ::t_       11 }l'?> bJ       Q
                                             )          -
·} ~ 00         /A    Q-n     0.1                ~(                  ·~ .e_ Of[4        a      c) ~--n. ,__. P\?.            -i;wo >
 ~                    v_ If;;- h-t-                         cvn n ~-rr-z--r--           D      --\Q_ w A1 ..:c             hR_e_      h

(?}'        ll¢'~<hy                               · ~u~-so_               \lon'9_~                   >;a('V~            &?Jito
~'\.10 )' \) .c r  ~                           ~ ~ •'Yt-        \ts v' ~                         . , D dh -1h ILt7 ~
l.uc.KDb                         -M~ b0<L.q-p,~ ." 'itc¥1.                                            cC~~t             ::::r,toPo.
ciy{.).X b                     aH n                Q_           />   'nh ct~ \              ~-un-~         ::s=_        A~"¥ CL
w  '~'Y<n
    Q_                         .N ~ 'Q_               ~ ~0     'fn"( . 'h ~ Vf?                                 r         1 :::c:__
)pd (A ( /                           \\'"\    __    rto ~-~)l ~r H JP ~ {{ bL                                               nv

'?IL2t                                       ba~\11\                   -~~~                   ttL         &~o.
~          o«a          .C!     ··
                                                 bQ._ N omil
                                                                                   \LP-\-
                                                                                    rtA:udtt
                                                                                                      J

                                                                                                          ~ 'cP
TI Q..     'l   t~t   pa\?       ~ e__d          tuLA       o5f+::a                ~'{_Q.' _
                                                                                          1

                                          lP r    ifctL\J      ·b(. bl e_lq:>
                                                                        '<
                                                                                          11

                                                    ~~ODD·

   ~!L~\h4n             iO av\1 Lll (h3~l/q6
    Z::>~ () ~~tl            Z>t?o   b.
         L~l!~~.al.i         ;vc·     ")?c35J

                                                cq ') q)    ')J')g   -18 o(o
                                                        l~-trt-              a   L:Jtj
  Pea ~k I!..o
                    /(I_    "i-t 0         -    \~d                      n~a            1       IS-~'f7 p1 )(_ dll:~Jc..·s?~piiz,n -1
  ~ Q_               ~Cl      t        ~ t>'i~\" 1:::22'{                 0   ~             n "-"            611! J    i       d qrd\t~n'
  {!_Q /l           ~   X'16P ~ ·               •    l:\-. .11::17      .on t_ .L           a            d   a[        1   _:rc_  l?lA +1:_,..
 a:r:t              ~ ~hlc.-h(;>n                              1     p---P•VL            -lliL               ~_)j           4-~(
  ~~     Q_             l\1?_ ~d                     1
                                                         lliu. 1          ~ i1 t1t.z               a\~~                    lie_ -t ~~ n         1
   hiT                   bl D eJ~
                     -Ttw_          1
                                     Cin c1     -, t    __.:I:._    .hILl     ~
  -r~-; e. -:t1z;; \1 N ~. 1=1    tDIAi\    w\-t\J ~ L              n a c_ ~ -b ~j_ t
  :,&'b&'t-1:>~01-=' I 9..0-~a lD~                   _l__        a-c\<. rp0LL~~             1

  M{ ocid1 c.t1m/l~~ -Jh ~"': _o.                                \LJft:o atr>¥;w~

  M "--""
  A\} Q_
              (!_

              -I
                 .
  1~··~~ .~ /!.L;Iw~cl . p-Q_~ L>~¥wn ~~-- it a
                    cL
                        b     LA
                                      ~·l
                                   Cl rr
                                   J ...
                                         Li
                                               t-1   t
                                                           ~
                                                    c._ *16>1
                                                               /y
                                                                      ~Ad
                                                                     \ $L
                                                                             \10

                                                                                            roe
                                                                                     .t_ )._,   LW
                                                                                                             S         .   Llt1

                                                                                                               b·~ +l_ z{L t~
                                                                                                                                    ~
                                                                                                                                    rr) "-

                                                                                                                                    '

 (wd\-tr-v·~                       ~CA~K                       crr7           Th£_          ±o-bni/L.rJlif.t-,                      lniL'h
 l>a a:}i,a-~ .                  Ad ~oUd                                       1 l-                  \t      ·+in                 ~f1ae.h
 6D           G)        /     j a5 I -t h-h L                                  -Iht-1             :;)_ '-{ ~           ~ l w yl
· 1+. ILt               'L Q r:               on                1-\\L   ~1 a b 1 _l_                                         'flah 12_
· tt~ n ~LX'l           LO:   't           otci:               ol     ci~q-S , ~ ~ i- ~                                    --h>-[         J;o
 a c.. l\   baa 11 fu eh Q_                                           ~K~                          \ rv' l             ,o          ..nr
 '!JoadoL,J ·~ ddil7 " ~             . l? C4e-l7      o        f7~ I bt'ea:
Q         ~               lsyinL 'i \~LoY 1C.. . b~b            bJc--\-i \1:1 C
 c_Db*     rL 1 drv:::r!r:-oDtt_ ~IL ~rl al nu.~~r ,
-1\\ }\otJ      ·fuL       ~ 0! ~   \D    ~t...       -iva~-
,        ~ ~ 'f'IC_~ -:;. ~\ll'h tf-z, tl[t .,                  'ts,) L~ .,,                             b{
         Qu Q--):1 _1 ~Lt-bA\, L) lf G 1 ~~                     ~6~
          ~ ~ . ~ W a? i... 1 t1l t.L ~ t1 I tM.
          ~ e::l""· h Cl-n :/~ qy n~/ L t'i? 3 ~L/q /) 3 ~'?-'~ ~ _t/'1_ ~ -~o t,                    ~         cr-..
                    L~~ './ \ t1~-~_ub         1 ~ ../--       '7 'I :3 s l