Court Opinion

ID: 6663215
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-20 21:03:58.508334+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:00:15.089039
License: Public Domain

Sedgwick, J.
The plaintiff brought this action in the district court for Lancaster county to recover the value of a car-load, of flour alleged to haye been converted by the defendant. The flour was shipped by the WashburnCrosby Company of Minneapolis, and a controversy arose between that company and the plaintiff ás to tbe right to the flour. It was the duty of the defendant railroad company to deliver the flour to the true owner, and it was delivered to the Minneapolis company. The question, then, is whether the Minneapolis company or this plaintiff was the owner of the flour and entitled to the delivery thereof. The court instructed the jury to find a verdict for the defendant, which was done, and judgment entered thereon, and the plaintiff has appealed.
The Minneapolis company had contracted the flour to one Furman, of York, some time before the shipment. In the meantime the price of flour had advanced to nearly double the contract price to Furman. By mistake of the company the Furman order had been entered as an order of this plaintiff, and it was by mistake shipped to Lincoln, consigned to the shipper’s order, with instructions to notify the plaintiff. A draft for the price of the flour as contracted to Furman was attached to the bill of lading, and when this plaintiff was notified he paid the draft and demanded the flour. In the meantime the Minneapolis company had instructed the railroad' company not to deliver the flour to the plaintiff, and to return the flour to the shipper at Omaha, which the railroad company did.
*855“Where a person contracts with another believing him to he one with whom he intends to contract, while as a matter of fact it is another person, there is no agreement, as where * * ■*’ .a person obtains goods by fraudulently impersonating a third, person to whom the owner supposes he is selling, or by pretending to be the agent of a third person to whom the owner supposes he is selling.” 35 Cyc. 60. It appears that the Minneapolis company supposed it had contracted this flour to this plaintiff, when, as a matter of fact, it had contracted to Furman, and did not ship the flour as an offer to sell to the plaintiff, and had no intention of making a contract of sale with the plaintiff'. The minds of the parties, therefore, never met so as to amount to a contract of sale. The plaintiff concedes that he had not ordered these goods, hut testifies that he had instructed his son to order flour, and when he was notified of the shipment of this flour he supposed in good faith that it was in response to' an order by his son. Thus it appears again that the minds of these parties had never met in the making of a contract of sale.
The draft, with the bill of lading, however, was drawn upon the plaintiff, and the price named was paid by him, and the draft and bill, of lading delivered to him. The' Minneapolis company could not retain the payment for the flour, and at the same time stop the delivery of the flour to the plaintiff. Upon this point, however, the plaintiff himself testifies that “Mr. Biddleton (cashier of the bank to which he had paid the money), came in a few days after the 27th, came to me and asked me if I would surrender the draft and the bill of lading, and I told him, ‘No; I didn’t think I would. I considered I had bought that car of flour, and was going to hold them to the contract.’ ” The evidence of the defendant that the money was placed to the credit of the plaintiff, and that he continually refused to receive it, is not contradicted by the plaintiff. This would amount to a *856waiver of .a formal fender of the money, and there seems to be no complaint in the briefs that the- tender was insufficient, or that it had not been maintained. Under these circumstances, there was no question of fact in dispute, and the court was- right in: instructing a verdict, for the defendant.
Aeeikmed.
Letton and Rose, ’.JJ., not sitting.