Court Opinion

ID: 8851528
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-11-26 17:15:01.207002+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T17:05:30.892183
License: Public Domain

BENEDICT, District Judge.
In my opinion, the collision in question was caused solely by the fault of the tug McCaldin Bros. When she moved out of pier 4, East river, to cross to Brooklyn, two tows were passing outside of her, one bound up and the other down the river. The libel of the McOaldin states: That she stopped and waited for these tows to pass, the westward-bound tow passing first, and the eastward-bound tow afterwards. That as soon as there came a space between the two tows, the McOaldin rang a jingle to go ahead at full speed. This carried the McOaldin under the stern of the east-bound tow', within 30 feet thereof, and at full speed. A f: this time the steam lighter Edgewater was proceeding at full speed down the river, just outside of the up-bound tow. She was not seen by the McOaldin until the McOaldin passed by the stern of the eastbound tow, and was then within 30 or 40 feet, so that it was impossible for either vessel to avoid collision. It was broad daylight. The Edgewater carried a mast more than 50 feet high, and with proper care could have been seen over the east-bound tow. It was fault in the McOaldin not to have seen the lighter sooner. If she had done so, she woxild not have rung her jingle when she did. By her jingle she changed from a drifting vessel to one going at fxill speed, and she did this without any signal, and it carried her at full speed across the bow's of the Edgewater, and so near that the collision was imminent as soon as the jingle rang. The starboard-hand rule does not apply in such a case, w'hen, by the unwarranted action of the txig, it was rendered impossible for the Edgewater to avoid lier. The Edgewater was not keeping the middle of the river, as required by statute, but that in no way tended to produce the collision. Of *528course, there would have been no collision with the Edgewater if the Edgewater had not been where she was; but the position of the Edge-water did not cause the MeCaldin to ring her jingle, nor prevent the Edgewater from being seen by the MeCaldin if a proper lookout had been kept. There must be a decree for the libellant in the action of Ellis v. The, MeCaldin Bros., with an order of reference to ascertain the damages, and the libel of MeCaldin must be dismissed, with costs.