Court Opinion

ID: 4042856
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 23:12:20.202969+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T12:14:16.872926
License: Public Domain

CHQ:EN@.\\zmz-H _ v
___ , 1 - 43)%/&~©>
.LNWE wm @F QPM\INHL ,

QPPE\¥LS 0 FT€)& DUIQ,J , .

D€m N\S,/ I\I\CS»\X\¢,QJ\ C@S+¢\\C\er\< ~ zin<;\<>§eci 'P»'\QQSQ _`\j(/\Cl‘» `

`Y\\_‘\S C<>wz§'p@mm® 13 w qau§$&\{ow\ 0€ QP §?\MM 3 ::

SP<>v\;& 3m ¥\(\s).-XCLC\\ C@\}¢>¢'S @Vclszf (@gwmwendmj \M+ b 1
\l@? \@& ¢l<>.m-QCX. Q\S@,p\e@sx \Q 4 wig mci +:\/\c;+ ,QP@\;@§;’HA(£¢§
unqls\€/ irb ch<,)o\r¢l Q C@@\[ im irm Q©lv\O/\M mm \MSU§)P\[€§
w WQ\LLOMXWMQ‘AP@\(‘@on,f \(j_;lv\n\@\\{ \Rjues+%d‘
'C, cab w wmml ~X@\MP<… ‘\)f\@r€‘@\{l w~\(m+wmmj
L:…:::MA @wc¢\j w ¥M E)WQ\ €lundrm\mj @C~ &MQC@U“¢¥§
\Qw\\\ %v\£;dx©V\©(`Cxlo\/Q;Md®££ §§ 5(\']@¢ Q,GKM`\» ()Q Qj\\/\/\('(}q.\
\WPQM§‘ ' ' T hqr\\< \{Ou.
"\ .\) SQF ‘.L,L\ 3\`@/»¥‘5 BprlQan+q-\ 9mm j:N cwl\//
mg 0 ' D§¥\)OLSW\MT@ §"‘v<>f“€$ 9mst Find~

;\~ _ - 5~ " n 3 0€ PcLQ,+ cm?f§

= E_x p¢WE ` §IN we QDMQ\; Q\K:N\:NHL

§ HPPE\X»%
UW)L®S C»\IEL%S®AEL . § AU‘ST:N‘TEXAS
HPpLiN

- %PPLXCN\\T ' .; H l
TC) BTW=LS Pv»o%sin _\:wm§mj: cg FH@T ` § 0
OAD\`:P\ \°»EQ@N\N\E_N blue ?»\:LT.Y:€ %; bench -

W>y%\,i ~SU\BGE O'PT¥\\E COUP\T 0¥ C,R‘:N\M A-L&

Q, SXer€,‘S OC§j`mcL\ W\%wec‘)r\n,b pig
~\?\\C bd<)§\k) €4” .POV W\' Q¥XQ¥CM %<1, F\ \€,cl
m musa miwa \\"§\@L@%¢H,@»n<,\ Jvm %XchQ`S Pfcpo$egl?md-
1an 09 qur,' QPP\\LC»n‘v §MS@MS irm Cow+ umw N§B_upp/
\€'~W\U"v&\ \%SL,J€,€ "m QP’PGSTHU\ w M\Q, den\@\ 09 (Q,\\Q(~ m
m 5 _\\OS\`O»M' O~'W\[CC\>HO“ bj\¥\(\ V\/\‘L\/\/\C)fonc\u\m`\\f\ SQP@OF+,. clan
`\‘\S`\S¥ `\/\’\C»jf `\“\\U”L' U`{# CDY\)Y\'UJQ(`\'€A!PCQU[OQ%\\\ LM\%SO\U€A
;\$Suas 0&? GQr\@m hw;n@.-Tm cw»

S\G<>Wd C€,CJ©\I\/\\;\/\Qn1@ Y\s¢\d\ m C\`o@\\o/)Oz»
W('hj <»\ h<,w“mj *vO C€So\u& `\5%1)\€3 p§e)v<>\l*\/\inj‘r© Fu+S '
q_,\\qzu\c) §~`\M `\\‘\ X\m¢ 09€(@\&\ C©u(¥ YQC@ ‘Fcl$,-
+m \\€( <\\7¢,`10(>3 cl€,\/\/LOOSHC€¥€S ~\?h@+l

`F‘::m:w@z @Y- ‘\;m v

wmmlmq_\§g§;@: ,

\.Th@%c\@\ wch mack log § -%B.WB'HS)\ ,

3\. \W?'%Q<“ §e,c,@\u"m_c) cm Qduecse, m\\nj €(~QW\ H"\Q\ COU¥ <>`n \)\/\<)‘¥\`m§
+\'\L §\SSU\Q/ TQS\LC€)\ C»\>`\\/\n H\O»\ Ca>'\m$&\ `\K\ S{)€,Q`\?\|}mfj QS w wh<§c
W\`C*‘“"@F W @UWM \`i?(*ef @f"o\~\ ¥w~'®€€€n ;QC%MS €O(~#HFH@{@
57 ~C>°\ CS,) 09 +h& COO\’¢ <>'(- Cx`\\/\/\§v\q\ P\”L>QQJWQ/- ~ _

3 ‘T \¢\Q,"\$SL)\Q,KS P\”"OPQC\\\ C‘1>`“5`\<)‘3“€‘l O“ \‘\O~\O%$» MW&M Sjr\W bowl -\'\\L C;\odw\ `\g‘r\?v
Sv\%g€<}r w vw §§ in<,\p\& O(~ \O~w uner |%o\¢ S¥Qr \l`&+cq%.
Q>:m S».L~)¢M Q_u l CTQ;><-Cri\»v\-\¥PP- \CQ?\ ) md P)Guggequ \{¢S+o¢+e¢
<355 S»w~ad é><<><'o, con 2a CT€\C-Cf`\ M'H§P'\<\C\ 35; nor does 1`~‘¢@1’¢@
§lnxl o&)& `\%`H“r C©g'
D`il€;;b\edc>n habeq§,`\\w F€,%<>`\o`mj~¥\w`\&$uz.

Q~:S`Y\Q, wer dc Xr\u\ \~Qz\m, CQ\€SV\U‘L Ckr?d C,z>\/\/\@@;Qn§ Q,`;Q(:€/ dr Q &)CM,` MM.WB
c\'c\v\\LS <>\q \/m d@&¢ m C;MQSH<>O'\MY\I\Q m§`\’dg A(\\L~W,
&)mw\cqs+ed Q §occ@r que,» m@\r\\@\n QUQNGM bmwe d_
:\:\q \;\,\2, \N/\’L&"\\"\V\f\g-»¢QP P\§LCM\»)_F bd€\$ C\}V COUO\;Q/\" O(d€,p]… \/\/\@(€
C\\~§…§g when \;\NL d&C.€QSQCl C»\,\On:) C)~>\~\/\q OSVMQAF Q»OW\PUT`MS
€.MWU &)M _._\~\\Qn Q}c 50\:\/\€, ’Pd"\r\¥ `\v\ ¥\\rv\)z, Cm Q\\~juw\€nl{
Q¢DBQA \OWQQV\ C)~\) Q\`\L,O~”\X'S \`Q\CG§'\\>Q Cmcl CXQC€QQC}, §0\\0 WQC§
f`@q cm o\\\¥m€do\n w\/M»c lew *vwc> 30¥`1\1\%0 Q.§\ww`mj

g

- ‘“Q*_C“ '_ii* Mf\@\“ *\M <>\PP\M+ w w w w@\< wm <~\W,
QC*+M m dmi SO' l“m damqu LQ@CQW“L wyaer @me/ QPP\<»nl§ opp\;wn+ w\r\(U/\ `
@WPM `“_ °* P"§S\“W Cf"d§h‘*“§\`"j \r\/\Cév<;\r\ \@Q)vw wm W~JWQ casal
T\\sm,.w`\¥\\\“ W\MGF@_> S'QCU"\*\\ \mA Cm`\\sw£v 0€ &><)~\“ Q`\\r\"\c,\r\ had helm gmcch `m '¥\\’¢ UQ.(\\ §(UN¢ §§ X»\vb €;\Ci¥dlo<>f

09 \AM&>QC XMC\Q/CQC\SQ‘A 5“@“*@‘)` OUY C>%BU"\%\\ \\\\\w* WH SQW‘“M M@‘v`@r>mg wwwdg

C&Pp\ l(,cm¥($ UQ)’\`\C~\Q/} O®Cl` m Cm `\ HSW+ b`{>@\l@(*m' \:QS\"(`€/‘\U€,C)
<\C~\CQWX m CN/ W"“ @{\VU‘ \X W C@f‘"
+@-\\Qg,w \G~M 3 u`\\dlnj C§\O\W
d€mW\ 5 _
5‘ ?>C~WA UF““`*Y‘W@€“P'¥MQPP\KQM d`\d G§\Q<.~l Q-{>m@m§
q\;\@‘§`\<>\w fQ,C\L)\Q,S¥\DS 100 "m §H\AUYKOO C)‘€ v\/\cmg`\<:w:)% Q/r, qj§) mo @\_LQA
‘RSSCM\M *C\\'\d cl-QQ`¥ (€/\QQ@M O\C QPP\{CMQ+ m hawkij Poln~‘ied OL»{-
Cj\>\\\c)r\ <)€ §Av\s), Al(\me, C%C{u»e$jv%Q §M@c§¥..wh@m `\w¢ wm Q»'m¥\¥\@i w Q \€,SS@\“' '
`\`Y\C§\b\c)v€@lv `\YWS§’(`\,\CJ-'ri©\\ O‘{: C)\QG\J\\{ C©\WJLAQHS`§‘\DCQJ\’\/\JL"WK&\
,V€Ce>vo\ Cov\*¥@‘\\”\€d w `\JMGL' OF~ w Q\c¥\\\@i'§ WS+@+@

U\SQCX '5® `\t\/\UX `\XS \Q&MAU <>€ P\ijj gm "m;&n)dbm\ W\ al
w 333 CM“M"' V“Q“ Q’Q\AML C@V\SKS+ O¢ 5@\)@¢@\ (¢u\\::-Qn
ho\g§ cl`\§'§©\)€(zcl \\f\ -\»\r\Q, Qv€Q QOW\XQF C\<>Q\A\>KSQ gm\,\,\.y\(\g,
Cj\waqsqv\\| "\\’W _W\§ §@3°“1 <*3}“3%9“ YO®§)‘L `\\'\L»>\r\lch

QW\MM gm ama m dewwmj avth QP.§>\;@M+

@“M) mg <)x\~e@+\»{ C»'_‘v d@Cw/@@C<>v CQ<,\¢\QS@¢\/, md wl
UQ(\i §C\\/MAY§\/V\L\(\\\"¥mj C)QCP”S“M CQUS`{D\C) \<\`\S d€£cH/\
\N®C\®M§\<&Qma\ Sw-M L\O%M\@U@<_u~m H~pp» mm

. .(q dQ_@Q,r)Q,/\+`m Q C("\W\mc\\ pFOSQU'*\U `b@$ +HL FI§;`M J`rc) ‘

q ;\m\{ `\\’\S)r<`u€€\©\“ 001 Q\N dz€@n$\"p& \SSL§Q/ X\m<~'lv 13 \`OJS€A

m Mwu\dwg wm¥~@\" +m+_ ;U<<;Q.»Q@ \5 mw @¢

SSM nj(mmpmmc§ <>\“ Cov\>QW]' M“W/

”\'rr\\ QA»UMAV\M. 5¥¢.&<<`3 P¢Si%xon en Q>…qgm‘s Qc,%v®n in
yag@_(~@\ g irc W\@Q`\\(\g §@c cm `\n§¥mdm\ GOc q \Q,§S@F' wm '
dudch <>Q§Qn§e. ©v lr\nw¥ ¥M %vi\x\ C@&M¥ we u\cl \Q(€,SQ\'\XC$F\` 00
0{_ ¥MQQ\SD~_A\\W¢‘OW $uc/h `\SSWL ms no cwaun
¢Qm\l Q}v \aw, S“\\'\Cg XM 3<\“`\<&\ CCWX u\¥\` mqi&.\\(
dQA,\-M W \r\w¥w\<&> w\'\M C-"\€S¥ 10 'S*rd 3% . ‘Ac\a CT@<.¢Q¢IM W¢AO<>S>.
`T Hi s mf demon§'rvc&@ lr\fm\ Co&m$z\l$ §o;\\ura, w mma hon m)rmc+_
\bv\ (30(` m \QSSQ~(`~`\Y\Q,\AJ'LCX D'PGQQSQ, _`\(\ \Qm>(,\)\\“j L\>\\Q¥\\Qp _\/\\Q,
A»( §@\ C@w-\' \r\/\O»\\ \f\€w 4 3€<‘»’\¥€0\ `\¥. miamch \L\\x©w\€@w©f~ H@
C,QSL wou`\d \mwc \O@~w di@\'r`@€€m$; 15 Cm mmJ@F$¥ch€/W\£M "m~+o
5('»\@ Pg€(@cw\on@~ OC' C©U»\W%{L\ baij fm 5}\`+<4¥\®@\\\( Qdaqu@$e~
51(¢~\¢\¢\@<) \1.\N q§»\mgw~m L\c>c¢> 9¢§¢(@¢;°8( coin C\'v C§ \e$§€f- mc\u_P.»a@m)@~rm \Qc\§o€ QQ\Q@.~ ¢UM USMW
9\ \ \ '

im QPPQ\\q.q-+ Fcow\ mae+i\wj irm G(\”s% pad o€ irm

w`\\ VQU an`\/ \ t ~. .
S+\FLP\L\UJ %QS)V, C\.S H\‘L R.O\ SOGCJ;>lU)QSS 0€ COW\S@\ 3 C,ho \L£SCmc£
' \

W\o*v`\\>€»%ns clw\nj +F\"Ql CCW\Q\\\{ QPPQM m V\Q C\pp;'\\c<,+@ Ve;£)v@lrvhus¢

' 3 hcw|w\\h@@\ -'¥\rva‘oene€i-¥ OC~ hinck$lj¥\+¢¥'“@$( C®W)SQ\‘S QC‘Y`\Q\W 5
OF O\…\/\`\gs`i@\w &Lmnj lyr`ic\\ w®u\cl \r\cw@ \QJ +0 C\U~\A/\Q/<>C~\»\\Q~,‘CL\SIL is Fe,c~sc>ng§,\\\ 0€ Ciues*riono$j|<.€@vv\pg)@-AQ,
00 ¥NL Pw¥ O€+\f\@ Qpp\\cm‘r.

jim w:`\:: § }\1\ wm wiga w zwés §)@z'mw en wman
bn ©\Q leg g:j<>& CQ\¢\§X\H~¥`\O§) Q dQ/€@n &MG XWL C®W\W\m'
5¥<~.6¢@` 3 to \M W"MW*§‘PU*U®Q' 33‘©3@"%@“

v \ C\ SO\L)SVQ\\\ C@mc»,& m AA\;S gang/1 town hazwa l
Qpp\\@\1<;»/\¥
`, Q'(C"\ dc\“\@*“m& `\"WC/`\u'{-`
YMLQ<»CWQ[C\\O anna . , , _` , 1 \\/\/\0`1
d , 93 \ W Vv\% S¥CQVQS Q,\L>\n_\\o\ ,‘J(\(\Q, C)U\ vowed
_ \1\/\@,@¥@.\ §Wr€/ @\C Q\>-P\iwm Qr`\$e$ `\0 fejcw_ds +¢ gm €SSQHJR&, %\Q_
. \/\/\Qn¥,@€ Xk&@(€€en S~Q.Te,')o PQn‘C@cle § Q>-OS ©£"\’\WQH,§OR' pma
O\P§>\`\`CW\ `Y `\30¥\\\1` VQQQ`\VQC\ ~\-b `Po"`\`f\"v 0&)3¥ 3mng `m AF'M/ (`€£M`Cl'
_ A(\mcvlv wsa)\\€k SUPPOF¥ ~M\L UQLe/SSI"\"\€B O{: '-C~ ¥\@Q\QSSQ¢:\WMJQA @W,m
l " Y\c\\v\sz\\\ BQC\<)\\| COWJQC¥-“ -UJ\'\,`\U“ \3 C* \QS3‘@F~`\OC-\ude 0£3?@5@
§§ Wmde,c wham Q \Qs§ w\p@\§>\f¢ qu_\ S&CM \g gmwn. `
T»\MQ,¢ \1,3>(¢\%2,&>00 S~w‘acl °\;)n .C\ 9~€\ L\'Q)\M¥ ms Con§ls%en%\\¢ \n<;\cl irqu '\k\'\¢>w\e&g€, O\\',\P\\UMX§N\ L…J\QA# .\,\¢\Q/

§C`\M`\“q\ CA\AS€, DQM\QQ<`F.\;\\LQ\;P\'\(JC…¥ \NMS;( W\U)( \m~\ 5
‘DWAU 09 Q\\€ff\“j ‘€c\drg i(,\)\m`\% “`\G ‘rm@¢(,\)ou\d ~ev>+\`“r`\sz
`\r\\\mw m'\`\@-?- \`-_)< powe I\I\Q\< . §§ `\\¢\/\.\>¢9§» \C\<@S)\ N\@Pe,<>\>@(. ly\nQ. (QC@\“_A Ceu e_cq ad %<1
Q 'Pmpfac\\\ G\\@CX \/\/\@x\w mgq@;'r`.®g `>¢\r\¢\ns¥v wr\\\»n 00

\é»\sz \QSS€€~`\GQ\Q<)\Q;X 0?€€03@® had hew \j JrWL

3m c~\ C©w¥i ((9 vw w b\b…$)ln Q‘&&{Hm~. _Q)\'p?\icon§v Cou\c!
\\O\¢'\OQC\XQJ €OC Qn\\ `PC©C&<)UQ»\ \\\@`\§`\r\/\`\\<"\QS during 3\'\\2¢
G\PPQ\\Q¥C B`wg)€, O(~ WL PC©Q€S§,L)~>W& WL_ wm neg\ed¢%
OG W©PPO()`,…§§§Y\\ A\.O C)\Q 30 C)mc)\ ghch P\ Qm\‘
* ~+e, \Xc\ums."\&? S~` t
\U€d E)C`®w\d

(;9.

303 ga'\'\€§ `\S 0 P§©Ponc\€mnc@ 0(~ evidencedva (w{€wmj
CO“G §`_"\“C\S \'\r\c£r C>\PP\'\C_,WV Se,€/\Aeo\ +\qe, (Q,C\L)J(@d ((,_/W/CW dr
\C\bd ”\'O ¥\Q\)C 3csz whenle ©\C \r\`\§ C.\c§w\/\ COWSK@€\§ C©\”PQS»E~>< PC'MQ/ ‘Ev\/\w\on$`(@<;,@ g&(,>,g`¢\ \Q(QQQ@
\B\\BP‘ \C`\<%)- N\DR`U\>Q€. X\\L C@LM Q\go Q`\\w\Q \Qj@\ Cw<:\\\,;$.`§»h@w
C~QQnSQ\ (e;\ues+‘<w¥ wmc/§ m `(&3 _
m\ 103, \,¢ \<\<,\r\ `\\ws`*rmc&§w'» Per M`\-xg&m Cowr w C\dr4 00, cmC\ S.w‘zd 3€3%-. 36\2\tracedm~%Pp¢a<><>ao{There?Mi
irm <;¥\c~f§,€ ©m>r Q@n§r\m¥es C}Qh@\\enj@*@ Av\z€/L§< Pav+f< 3514\@\!'\@ 3"“*3’3°[ g(’>‘(<>“‘ \`\c€ Cp…r) 52.1'5
C\9€`\@\@-<)`1*» °M Cw+$ 9\\\<13+*\® M@ 901 n+ dr wh‘.<,»» QP \m+“§

' Y`\g\\>r 'X@ M~C\PPQ¢~\ '@><\‘_s+@l\ QM. pmmp;( …XQ,Q\`OM ill 3 4
CODU`\C/§"\G CDUDFS §§YO~"WC!PO\M`: C"P\P.\IU*’\¥S ('\`:)h-\- .\© gm qPPQu/\
had \\“\Jr QOF 00 `PVOX€CHO\G. ~ `

THQ» V€CQVCI (`€/§\€C?v$ lr\»c£r C)Y\ ge;\zXQ\/v\be¢- g’>,i$\o©?( C,Qum$el

Y;:\(C*‘R‘ W;Q;)Y\:\@“ w C*P\>Y\U…¥ \'\f\€§v`\\b wms €Ln‘r§¥\zcl ‘¥O C\Ppm.\
}\(\\`§ §:3_ ' ` f d"LC/`C\¥"\Ce¢»,\ _\%Swl, V\§F© \B @&\Ll,\\gp (,Dwn%.\ \"W\l}€d
69 \_\f_\“»*-\OY‘ m f>\'\>\":s Q@P\…m»\nwwgh Q>Cp\@mm
GC» m f\g\r»év*vv \§>g>w\.-w@\w\\ cw<»\\cdo\@ @{)H@ws m 5asz
MOQSSn,g@w%l‘s .
Qg\c\(,\w`\‘< \Bo`\r\‘c&¢vo kmo¥\{\m§\ 3(\\&}( COM~`MQA _Ww;(_ QW\&CCW+‘$
3’<3@@\”¥5® `W\CW ¥\“9~51@\% Hm,+ m ruan ¥\\~\/LXQWNA
\LM{ s 00 QF,» m QMQF'%F C@um)¢\' \\O §@5{,>@.0¢) `… H\L@€@(~FMQVM,
lmle m wou\c)l&_>`\$\¥ QQP\£CO~M C\:)c§m § n Q@,Q,Q, q\o?\`;gcuq,¥ m\\
Q,\,mg@\q\s m\~d» SM<_“SN' `(¢ C\Pp\;w»+ md msgw)m `m irm
wq,mf\){\QM \r\§ S CL&C,Cch H\o>jr WLLJQS
UQN my m wl¥\r\ \f\`\§ 5@§’*@@¢1(%§)\@~ faa pcsz EMIQ@PQJ
' M\Cj¢ ap\@\(c,cw\.+ wi C»‘v ¥WS (l>\"f\‘v w\\>mg} his F\'gh¥‘u>
QPPQQ\,MW¢nS ¢M/\Qf€, L`)~)'C)S Vl© W GD{` CDKM\SQ/\ AYO <;1{ \`UQ,
w W garwng mm m V>€QA>`\\\\Q(TQ>QQ§ c th/<,TQ)<.QS
DQPM.),MJF 69 Qf\;\~\,\/\m¢\ :\`ug+(@, S§m hundrec%$ <>€ v\/\(`\&S
30 `\<\H>nm Qp plfw»/\+ ~\N s'¥lw\fc" <>€ W$ V\SY\¥AYDC\PPQ@'\ 55 COYY
U;@d.bn ~.\g \W\\)r\`~@\¥jh\\ Q>c@\@me& '-\J»\L C\§)\r\.+h \\(\/v\ 00 \L\m
CAQ,\_@<>(- MQ, Ce)v\-\)ic)“\`z>v\ wN\\U/\ w€\s' SQ/p&Qw/\BQ/r 9\‘?>.~&<)0%-
» %QSl `%5\ ‘~\ SOLT@><‘C”‘"W‘W'
3w 001) L“Tm, \cxc,'\L <)€ Q C/\Qc»r fQC,OFd\ USU<~\\\{ w`f\\ 959
QQM )('m oppsz.\\on¥ @ro\_~\ M‘v`mj \)m?(f%¥ 903ij GG\'\/\Q/
. §§ §Q.\L\ono\ ¥QS‘V, Q§ va~ §€c\$o \’\gg\&n€$$ C>€ CDUMSQ.\‘S
(/h<>;& Pfou€n o\@H‘ci€z/L+
@…\’ Mmugh FQQ(-s\-Wdr&o vl._@¥ noc_mq\\\l Qp\>eor_ m
~`\/`\r\gz, » .~ (`QQ@(`C)¢:\' \3 \'TO\' S&_MCF(L'\€Q+ ~¥\n'a+~. 1 ~ v (JO`\~W ~\~\/\Q/
ben@f~§>v 09 ‘\(\m<\$`§jh+, em S\/u>w ~\M+ \r\§ 5 Cow)§e;\‘$
Qo+n>n; or owwmssom~ »~ were \A/\@N\\| O? CNQ-SHO“ ’
ulng Co\A/\pz,+€v)@ w v gw~w qp@%\ m mm LQ\( amgen -W,M+h@…;§ uaw .
C+ OQQMQ, ed cm undm+cm¢x?nj @(. \M)( mg M @;)(i,\,@w{g SUH;_
`(Q§€n‘\" gw@f§q@$§ O(; §Q;\€Mom\-\'C§YQUM §§»Qmeg wci U\LU\( C€m§£?q£mc€$
FO(` WC*`U"“§) C… i\“/\i><»f¥ p\icm, +v%.+ wm M+
B.WFQA X@ C@ng@\ W@\}C\p\ \LC…¥ @\'P,p\`\w/\~‘v w on\_q P<)`MVH> 'C@wm,\‘s odom-im bzem>w
€@u$,§ (\)Qn 'XM~ §O\Q)r%o}r ,\qe_ CDL);\€) VLO-\r \f\o»uz, dQ 3§§€,~\0 h)&\`we h.`$
mg 'M w C\Ppr-»f\ m¥\~@w+ \’11¢:>+ being iiiqu M~@ wclm+@@img 06
+m +w» mm \e§]@.\ @€c&@+: <:\wn@\¢<>\ww_ww@~53§¢;<,1¢\0/»€1
\\-"\Nq.sh"\\’\§y*rl>'\”\&\@<@ U‘SLQ¢>`@'(OC_\S`AC°§\H.?LU 3m gouqmm \Qj 051 4
gagnde 'P\C\\,g q q\r\r"\‘@g\ R)\{, \V\ C)Q\’~\f\\\')j ~\'\':QC{L_JL€S{*(QD 3\L`) Q,OLS\L€
C‘SSQSSmj-\é\\p` 1 ,Q\,\<~,\(UL FTOW\ ij§sz.,\ § QM'<>FSBi

m ` goml_u;:@x\k <>\`~ LH\M .

3a 93 jv\f\`\ § 'CQ>\,_L€\¢ 3\»0@\& C{C;z>j\q}zzA-MXA% *\1 C@;\ \Q,§]o»..\ Q\CR<,+§

CM L>@ %w)\ `i @ ¥M 3'¥¢\~.¥€,‘3 C»c`\gj°\ml \§w>wer Q\@v\jwl¥h "i¥$

C€S Pm% 10 VM @omjomj `PFQ\>Q§QJ "'\;`\v\&mj 5 @@_YQ¢} ¥ha)r ‘HUL
` `qPi:)\‘"U“`l“§‘\/WUC\ 35 §FOCMLW@\\\[ &>QMU ‘HOW\ §c\i%`\`n€] alcx(v\/\S

C/\§\./\§U\/w 033-3 rlo'§‘ \hl€€c C>\/\O\l`f€C/lr QA.P(>/Q.cv\ &S C\r\ CKJKZMC`J»Q §§
MC).\‘ C\J\'\CLL\)“C\§V…:\ EX PCM'C QDUO\€S;']('>C\ 5(,\)‘9\0\52)°\($ OCY€X 3
Cc‘\vv\- L\P§>/ \°1?€1)) D< PC~*H@ wan&€n@\\ \'?>`1 S.w-'z>d 7¢)(%1 C.T@<~C(m-Hp¢).
g@@v\>. mew\e$€;w\¥h f€$pedr irc w vijh+ <>§ 44\& QPP\ .‘w,+'

    

  

m P-Q€?€£jv(nj \~\IS C.\Ppaa\, ¥\,\L waiver !Pz>f\m .lrmjr wm \@W P(QSQULQQI
w Qpp\icm¥ w S`\gn,&>n@\'\<,+a wish C@wzz\‘§gp@;d@p( wmQ/M\L y
w`c>;\@e`r €@m Puq>)v&§ X\n@lv Q(>@\\`Lon+ wm 3 {o@n u%omujh @¢P\Cq,,, `
Cm\m 0(- wa QPPQ.\\QLL Uj)h+$ <',3¢ "1(\(\9. Cgcp_rm \»'\€5+ am T¥ on 0<,}0\0@,(
9\9\. 9\00<3¢%0\1\/& 991 cqu 5 \QQn*rO do 503 `\UQM XM, Fc\(j¢ JVLWL
SuU/\ mud hawk \QP’F ‘(\§W\ L\>`M\ Onaciw{ "\m_,)\n`iUn 3m HKAH\LQPPQ&{,
3»€,@ G@@ds@w \1' z+cdc€. \,<>$)
Qq (QMKQLA)§L’W`C] C@u(-\~ S\/L©uld {N€Sumz ~\/\n&;+ 3(‘(§0\,\ C@uf)$€.\‘§ }_DQ(FO¢W\-
aan was C@v»$‘r\'m+a@muq Qd/¢C(_u@%@“w\ess \MCM\U§QJ C@V, v
C_luc/+ was 50 0@+@\5@>@3 H\c&_ no CD\/\/\\DQ+QQ+ edwqu would
\mwa Qv\§€\@ Q@\ `m `c\/,`§. §'TF(U’\'\CM)@\ \/-\MQS}){'D§+OW¢ Ll€>é>v'$‘ [¢€’3\>3 7’
3>@; Q\ngtl). EL)Q./\Wiof€%\ W nququ `m which C©uns&.l h€'\d +M'
LQC\;UQ; QS\KS») C,J`\¥\n©u)r ¥M Xv§c»\ COU¥ 515 nj QL\>OML O\C I¥up
w H\ lgm G`\_ \m§ @<~ §F\Q miw\dp\iw~+ wm H\§m( w-“¥M<_l€§‘§m*mj
W`\SSM (O\\ S+CJFQ, \\f\ O\"d ” §D\" C@g)\n%£\ \~O (l\\£. \r\lS Q€\C\O\OLO'H'[
Qw\+@w 03 \M C)m\\@m;w CD…@\3,r
wmsz (Q@% wQM S"‘{\QA en X~\NL Sa.vvuz dc<}@- SHOL*`\O\ *W§
m Qccep¥adl @»\; w beam us Q ibrop@r\\| wm n,@+icwbw
Q@Lm mma ¥wb fijM w owed *\S de,+em\c nw m pm
§_UQO( 5-@<1. E><' PQ)Q`S(AOM Q\\€jui*`<>n$ C~F€ heir C\'\on@$u€\¢l{u`€n+

\DFQFF“')-
L\. T herequ irle C©W')r W\Q\/ Q@+ upon W oa\id(+'\{ O\C

¥\r\)"c` C»\)‘@C\`U QF @O\”N\me`\q, gym @C\\"(\(X\\ M #\#M Y\/\cmn%‘ `\n which H\JL '
C©a>mm ¢c»`\\ar)\ irc pp€ggn\>( Qp>\mv L,g§\)v) YL@Xr/\
w\r\;U/» QP@\€C<»Y\-¥ md §§ch \'-)r,'m'\$e$ wes-mms Qs*mwm+'h)zr
' such M w …d +@ 10@.@@\:<) wm wh \:@le:\ mci sw
\Qw£ w ?>O(A)(€J \l$hjy&‘ \`SS S~(/J‘En »¥h 6} C~Pp\\‘crm+ QWAQJ C@w)$&\ Sw§€\U@i/L#;+\> `Pf?>‘r€+
}“~5 mg h)¢ cQ/,\Cgvmj w his Cqbp§a| wm Qd.@qu@{&;€@ns{d@r(nj Cu¢`~
glancz C@m@gmc\ m ¥M `m&>'e.c\: faced w é> z Pfc%cdqm-OF an
€wiclm+.'@¢\\ hwmj»$e@ mood 5 \l-<;@c,\§r€l\, 301 \f\ BCP 3551 557
CSH\Q;¢\ 3\0@3§(@\- SXQ%Q)/v\en% 0€ <)\ \Qj“&\ C@h<,'\u$il>n \b\>"i¥b\owk C\S@f~
`\ws CMQW¥ w O»vgue. @¢ w&>§‘r \M oc\\i@5 HJ>\)Q `*r@
¥M€({DMS O\ClU \`UL O(' C®U*/\S’L~l'

§ \`\l®r\&`\~\mh\€,€§, ~\~\/\`\ § Q@U§Jr.}§ nokv gould Q)\[ H\CH[~CL`COUW§
`h‘“‘l"“j$ 10 ‘°<§5@“\3 C@F\'>QS <>\Gnim ww@s,-&M€md.»`njs@mg,g,m,(
C‘CC€P\€L\ \@ `H\Q.\( rd~ E>< pQF),LTO(\;@ 51 7
°Nz s~w»;)`a_ LM, Qsz@n'@\@)r@ pmm '\w+ reqw§¥+mm€w¥ rem W <1€@ ;J@@M(~ m
'DQ,\§,Q(<,\ P,q§)i`o C S' JS+QF O€`HPPl{ C~i'\€l nOiOF{{le/`\'\(\Sli/)\S'Q{`qul '\~Q ~\r\,\y~ D\S+(\(CJL(_[€{~](I[
QW\"S D<>n`\<\‘<>€ HOW\`S/C@…+‘( 'T€XC‘§ 00 75an 36,30\5;1~<> L>Q
R\»l%¢-Q,Qre;£ible.and r€.sp@ns:v§ +0__+¥\@ 133\)\€3 m‘\s'ed him
“\m)rm;v w¢\q.€\ppucc¢‘ribh"¥\\£C~\{\F+S &,:>pl{'c.on,+$

l' \.

q `_ _ 1 _

_ §§ Q~ OJDK)\\C) CQQ»U@Q C\ SQ,UQCQF SQn+an/Q/ 39 lq'e, Cxpp€ai€rl
hi 3 Cc§@ 1:>< W%@ N\Q\&<> male my s¢(,\>~&d \\L\t \\¢3 CT@%&'\'$ C\clc)(QQ_J ‘X© \@&'N\QO€ F€q$omé>\@ne$§¢ih
d\e/anmj wm+ ww`\c§ \MC\\<~J C\PQ\{F V~(lmj w 3 CLPPQ@,[
Pm BQ,;L>\(\`\U `\5 m C\'\`j'Qm°UL("UQ“ ‘C` m 50 UWOS@S gm §-`§\L <>(\9~
w\\(k®U/¥W q§§(§-+QMCQO§ C,@LJ_!W§Q\~ NOHQ/W€SS,AP|)[[‘CQH+ bg_

\IQU@§ WML Gur¥\/\sz<” FQC)HM\ `\'UU€SJrijC$¥\'“""W \3 CJQ(\FQA:+@J+O
dQ/M\WU W W\@(pw \»lem w C\Pp'\{com\‘§, lm€$f{d¢be, Q|q{m. _

Q, H]>P\amn+ F@SP.Q@WU\\\( (QCNQS+ M\G} H\-`-B HUO(_U\O\Q
§§an gma.lr Qpp\(@n& cm QU{JQWHT\ hewiqu f E% pmm
\iow§,…§ sw~;m@ev?ae; +m+ @@c@rs mqppuw.++w
OP\)@F¥M Dr\\ H>F c\ @¢A\\ mud FQ:¢ 5+¢\4£ C<>w¥ Hc%~€md-
`mj 0@ +¥\sz §or~'+ Q\So dic+3'~+'7L(5
qS q-$¢\‘¢\ L, 5.61.,3\@1 '1»1@£\%3).:0\igh+@€(¥\\wml
('~{CO w (~ADJ hcklo@&g (`Q(/O{`Cl Q§ CJL (k)\/L_@\Q,{;\'L\QCQS'~€S C/l]r€o|,-
QPP\¢'¢WC¢MW:WQ+ P»Q W\S vC»-\idia+'e@f his gwqu ,
_ 552/+ G¢r+'m his <:\pp\(@a.+(<>n md +\f\@+ Fe,\ie..r- 50§4\<7~\1+
3 \»L@utcl (@Q, Z)FQO+QJ»

‘HCC@vd-i‘"j lK/¢ £"¥S `{ 3 CQQQV\/\\\/\wde@\ XQ 3r\/v@"\`»€.)€c{ 3 Courlr

0§ CFCv\/\qul@p emg ;`A-,WL \_\M R g ©A g y q
LTQ jm¢r\+QJ, P C(-U€ +Q h 10@.0\3 (`-Q_\\Qf;

1\3\\ m mm @v w:w\:-ML

E>< PH'P§F_E § g
5 P § Ls( ~ f
C#QRL@SQ~\)ELHSJMQ cwng

mw\l@e¢i y wah irc \rm)@ lewd 36;\<5\ Qv> amer Mmm 3m -¥m gm

§uclg)@»~< OMM\HMN:TQ stcmo\\g\z)\@£;-

®‘33‘@°3 OFW€TEXHSCM:L PP\'HU:QE mm v\'cw\:o:\=_s g<>ox:

" `]E( § Q): h my ga §§ @__",v lsa@\$”t$?. '<>Q'i\\j i>{esen-H\{ `mcc»r-
CQ¢`q\-€cl `\ n \?\ne,TQ)(c\S \}Q‘>g\(lv 'W\q (\+ QQ Cf'\V\/\'(nq\ ;Xu${»\`£fa, 93le
90 pr m `\`QN\Q§SQQCO\@Y\\{ (YQ)(QS ,<)\QC\GJ€/ unc)\€-(` Pan.l\~\\ OF pQ£'
$W\\ AVW»-Jf M ?orzjolr)§, gp(.~\(lau `p¢ `\_g +m& wci C@We;_;&.

E)(€,w+€d Oh M',B-_/--v Q\O\S ."

 

 

C»OF\@§ C` \l&\ cLSCNeL
§\5»9~¢1§'1?

V;'C+b`l`_ wm ilr

?>BC\\ `\`-N\ 33&§?

`\`em e,SS@€ C@\Or\\/;TQXQS TSXXQ

'?>.