Court Opinion

ID: 4058750
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 09:17:20.415395+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:05:24.897038
License: Public Domain

" " - v Xéz_\qa\/OQ;OB\Oq,O§/UU

“\'\.`)‘1 C,O\.\T)t cpc C)f\`\'-"\\(\Q,\ D~'PP€.¢~\S `>~\.)v\e, )',§i 10\$

?.Q». ?>ox \'1_3\>%

A\>§¢`\Y‘\, Tx. "I'~B"l\\

\ze.‘~ Qemc.v\é OrC\e_( j C)\o:;ec:`\{er\ "\’c. ‘¥>XC\X€`§ pvaks$€c\ $»iv\c_\§r\¢d$
E>` ?m'><é, \x\»;\\\»\-4>` ; \')_S§%z\_¢\; \'1,2,\qz§-A; \v.z§co%\-A

C,.Q_J>. Qec,@v<\s. us Mo. \NQ_ %'L*\»\L\-Q'l-,-.O%\ 's\\ ‘ -0§ wr\c\, 105

O\'\ Fe.\or\\`\oo»\w.<:\ m\{ \'\a\oe_c\.s pvcce¢c)`;m§s -\'o ~\'\'1€.
+ria\ u>\>v‘\ ., \Dvrs\_>cw\\ Jp¢>se<;\ ch\e_r . \ wm unawox¢
§§ ~k\(\e ¥\"Ic\\ cadon S’\%v\ec\ -\»\(\is ,\>r, `\$ \r\e d\`(;\ Cx»r\\\-\\\§v\% ?.\§e i\o m\\ \N‘<`\*< . Y-v~r
Qxe\/c\’\*<`\vc w\ec~$\>~re.b, \ -Ci"\e_ °<\(\\`s o\Q`;¢cA'\‘or\ '\b ‘c\(\e. S‘cd¥e`s p\r'mpc»s¢¢\ ovder \o~z¢¢~\.\se-
\\oe,'\`\e\le. a_ fe:¥\xc>o\c,¥\`v\"\'\{` C\\nc)§\\{$\`$ \’\€.cc\ wc>’t \oe C;>\r\c,\uc-\¢@\ \/J@cc\\_\se, -‘cv\e \pwr'o\e.
w \\\\b`\\'\€orw\od~zo\r\ was em essen~\\`o\\ Qc\x*\ c>¥ \m\\ ;>\eq_ emyeeme,n~\ ‘?ev
\w\\{ -\¢\mv§',z \`\§-e "oe~n\e~nccs. '\'0 \'\'\~` Co§\c,u\o¢\'€¢vj, 0\,\~(~\9_ '2$, 10\§ `\5 *\'\ne c\ov`§e. -\-\r\e. ~\'@ce\'c\
S‘(\§\>\c§. \0€ 'S€.rj\ \39`¢\¢ \-O -Y\r\e C,.(`,.L. QDQ.c.o~\>Se. \ \r\o\:c no koew\e&%& c;w\d. ~\`\ne
-\viq\ C‘\>\>v*c \-\us ~n\>‘\ ch\’< '<\'\z '\3<5 c>\N~n @C\n¢\`c\< cv c,\>\r\c\osio~ns §§ \¢`W, \

33\'\¢3~ -`\~\/\i§ \'0 \\n\,\ \\'\ "`('\ C;£ C_‘(\`(\'\W\C\\ kv\?€,a~\$ (€C.Qi\{ed q S\)»Qp\€,v\'\€v\~\&\
-\»‘(g`v\gc\(§o-k Vo\(g\_,c"“-\ w `\-\`5 c~<<.\e( ~\'v *\'\r\e Xric.\\ Q\>\y<"\? \"\zo\se,. `\\'1&`\\\(~<\'\ '<\'\e, c;¥ ~X\'\\`s cu,-\A

Q\@ose, m>>d<»»\ ma “\`<\o¢\ \10¢ receich ~\'Y\e -\`~\>\\o\~m% ev'\¢\osecb Q'\\w\%.

\S-`\ ncz(e\\& 1

ECE|VED \N . ~ Q»é~\%mw wm <;\.
goumoFcnlM\NAL APPEALS _
JUN 29 2015 ` \i.o<\neM \¢_evcn \l\x;\\co`w\$ S\».
. _ ~v`<).c.>` d \1-,~%§31'1
Ab@qAMv©g@m '\:\r@nc\r\ €X\. \Qc\oex\">oh \)n{‘k
\'Lm\ c.\v\. 3§?,'1, d
b{\ol\e~n¢, `K\\ '(°Uoc\

‘ C_lw§e‘,‘\*' \'L'L\nm_rl\, munqb\'¢>~, \1$§%1\-A, \B\c\?,s -A. \'Lz$c»@\» ¢\

E~/` ‘ch’¥€, l ` \Y\ 'W\Q, CO\)\"\‘
> gc ,QY\`\Y\{\'\Q`\

Qc>c\v\z»` \l\l§\\\`o.w\§ N>Qe¢\\s, L\\>s\"\r\,`¥\.

 

6\0§;&€*}00 ic '\`\<\e 3\'03<€.`3 Q(wpe$ed §§r\¢\m%$ c>§- ‘v`-¢L;-\< on¢\
Cc>v\c,\\>s{o‘n$ 04 \_c`\~ eu\c\ Gvc\e.~r Af.l-\z\r Qen\qnc\ \0\. '\'\'\€_

C\>\>~m +\(\e, Q.C',.¢\., +v\e. ">¥o:¥e, m `\X'S
imc/posed c>\'é\cv §§nc\s app\§c*o.~<\“¥\s C,\o;\`\\'\ +\r\oé< \\e, woo\c‘\ ‘(\o`ve.
`m§\s§e<§ ov\ %\>i\'\% w_ '¥‘<“i'o\\ §0°§ l§~e\<' wowae`\‘§ m§s o\c\\:§ce, Or\
'pc\v<>\e, <';`\`\%§bi\\"\\(‘ C,'{Qc\`\\o\e,., l\s. 0,§» "‘<\nis c\ec\.;r~sare,
`\$ ~\\\e "c\'RQ\ C\>\_>’*r $(\eS
-+\n`\§ @\05<»_<,.3<€@\\ C\Ue_ J\'Q -Y\(\e 64<<:\&€ ov%\n% -\`\<\Q ¥Y\`c\\ CL>\MX
0¢:\¢\ *\(\e fluva c>€- Cx'w\\'\v\a\ Appeo\s Jv<:» wma\\>c‘< 0._ féX<>‘ce\s wooded *Qio¢\mc§§ ov%e *<\ne Co\>€
C):amioa\ Nppeq\$ ‘<0 gee \c\s\r\e:\\mev \\.\I\o\>sso:aa dam 'XX§:, 55\

 

&\1\¢.2>¢\ (o%¥\ C'\’esc. Qvim. ?>\‘Qp. 1003 `\s Yekvo&g¥ive \~o Cu$e§
ccc-erving we§@c¢ \;z\owvoxw\ \S, ac>\'z_. l\\><\<\o§>§\<\ uv\&ex ‘f\n€,
fi%\w>r Q,'wc\>w\e.-¥ox\cea ex ve¥voexc,%\\/§J\>\cx \Oe
\Qe,»Y\<;\ex \S\(\o\>sso\ia<§e\n '§\`_ ‘OM\ %.\S\» .'Z>vpp. 100\§ w c>\o*q$c\ V€\`_\e§" \>v\é\<>x cm\ C>\\veo`c\v\

€.S*\e. -e,\ic§"\\o`\\§*<\\

m\sin@orma*<- \/\§; p\ec\» agreement

\v\ \{%`Y\X c>-?_ EX Qo¢{°v@ E\~e,~\o\n®r\ao\n '1?,1 %.\\\\\ `l¢l \A’LQ> CTQ,Y\. Cx\`m.

 

Aop. \C\%'Z) , ~\"ne l\_v\`o`\ Cr>o\<“‘c .Y\eec\s ~¥o 3¥`\\\ C\NX\\€_< deve\o@
+`\ne ve;c>wl '+0 make Spec;i$ic £<>`c\c £i\~c\m%s regarding ~\\n€_
`\W\Q\\~¢a+ +evms +\(\cs\ \o\{ sx%nm% £M o\ \a§e sen>§@(\<~,e\ wm
Cov\c\)vvex\* Cor Cx\\ CS(\<)\YQ§Q$ `\Y\ 0` ip\eo\ bax%&\>\e\
be pmc\e e\i%§\o\'€,.

`.[[.. E%Ser@ ms mng ~QN C;\<@@_
SQW\@v\Ce <'0\\:\ wm gov re\r\>< Qc>v a\\ Q\\ox%e§.. `\'\me_ `\\ <1@.
5@0><@\\063 mm om\ww@z\)< was pm% o§ a p\ec\ \Q¢\w%o:m\
N\f. \l\$§\\{(l\&\’\$ V\&S O\ Qo\p\\ C>€ “\*0\`;\, \Q\ec\ m%feeme)n~& omni
\(\0¢&5 ~’c\<\e C\€>,W. Q\\,` c\, C@p\{ o‘€-W\\`g
p\eu &%r@zmex\'\ 06 \§\1@\\‘ \SP win ‘<\e \s\\i\\ §\ymi§\n i\ `\€
(`Qq\>es‘oc\@
`m vesc>\\/m% ~W\`\> me&&`ec;%i\/€ us§\§m\nca Q\\!\ `\‘E X\r\e w\`\&w\?cf\ 03000‘\
pomo\€_ \NGS CL\£\ €SSGX\X`\O\\ pad C>‘§ 'VY\€ \p\e%\/\ +\(\e ©a\'\:>@m\¥ec\ `m\o
-W\e ACX\)&\ \>\eg a%rcem@r\% `\Xse,`\‘?, `\‘v \1\»05 `\w\@\§g\'*c\\`
K<\\Q\\ec§. 'Y\'r\eve, §§ Y\c> voévi@v\cx\ weis on \N\n\\ opp\\'ccm*c _
v\u\\>'\d p\eo.'c\ c§\>`\\’<\\ ‘vc> ‘<\(\\c¥`<\\ § \o\e
@c\\Q Q\ic§\\<>\Q-. Y\S -cxoo\\cav\* C)S<‘voc,\(\ed c:\% ow\ E~/`\<\`\\oi‘\ Jvc>
\’\\S habeas Cm'p\>s - ms -Wp¢,nse, +<> a &XC\XQ, '\ocw %vie\/cx\r\Ce em+&\\€d -‘v‘(\i§ \N&S +\ne
w ramon v\e was \Q\eudm% q§\>§\)v\(.
TY\e, 3&<1¥& propos<é` conQX\>s\mms c>€ \Qw cme\ -9&¢& -€mé\m§
cwa `\\r\uc§eqm°ve. '{\s. Q<\¥QL\QC\ `m W\c\\>sscxmde\n XI, `\d . , Qv\ y
QSSeY\-‘YRQ\ md c€ a p\ec\ Q%ce@ne\'\'\ mu_§\ \o`e ?o\>v\c& open X\(\Q
express ~\'~e>rm§ O‘€ \'Y\e \\\w §&‘ve\r\ p\eu <;\`%(ee me\r‘\‘\ §“\Se\‘? , ~‘<`\r\e
~@Uma\ faced ed ‘<\r\c p\m V\ecm\m§, m J¢\ne ww<)<‘ce,v\ m
+es¥`\\\\om`o»\' Q\l\Q\. TY\€,`\O\S*< prong `\S
~W\e K&.S\>e here '\`v\e ‘<°< v\e,ec\s \'o 0\¢\&(¢33 `\§`_
pm c>\e e\i%'\\@`\\ \“c\¢ Wc>& 000 €§S®r\%icx\ e\cw\en‘\ <>¥C- ~W\e p\eq
Q%veeme'x\'\ \N\'¥\\ 0.v\ €\lié\€)(\‘kicm\{ \r\eoxir\S.’Y`\r\,e C,o\ge,_ §§
\3®(%& §’\'e)o‘(\emazsr\ 77_L 3.\1\1»1¢\ mca trap Q¢am. l\\pp. \Q%T)
`\S S\~<`\\¢N\%\\\ S\m`\\w/ ¥<> Q\JV\§CQ<\~\/S ch&€, \c)QQO~\.\Se, C\\\\(\oog‘<\
~W\Q \:)\ea \ocu%oc\n papers c`\o m>X ioc\ude. QQ\`\Ci*<\\ "ce~(~<‘f\ . Q)Qm\)%€ cfr *c\<\&s C&SQ , ap Q\ § umw .`\5 A\‘v'd\ec\
~¥c> \fe,\`\e€\ `W\€.. ‘(€CD‘FA _`\\f\ "Y\f\&"> \(\GL\O€O.S Q be expanded `\r\ \K<\>>\r\‘< -<>‘; E>~\ @C\(Xe. S*ce-Q\()@r\;¢>\'\ , ~`\Q\\
II. FQYX\\Q_(` D@v@\c>@\\'\@r\*< 09 '¥\r§e, 'Q.~ac.c>\*é.
\t\suem=,r_»'<>ae Mm\ses co\\.'\s\oe\zeo, i\q>\c¢¢m»\ pv¢-¢ -w\e, &vc@\
Co\><*r be maoc\oéc€d ic C,c>=(\ck\>ck cm e,\s\`c\z<\)v\\cmq \(\ecm\`r\c`>3 cuné&
expand +\(\e reco(d w de*<<>xmme `\§ \mi§ ()00:0\<

m‘\§\\nQO(mo¢‘<*? WS §>\QG\

-e`oyeemex\*< .

Qespe§%@o \\\\ 5 obm \' ¥\‘cd,

S§%nQ@ ¢<\<\\s 'z§+\a dqu O€ 5\,“@

lo\§

 

Q\>Ane~| \¢_e,\/\\'\- \NL\\\`G.w\§ S<`.
T~D.C.§. ix \‘<>?)S‘ESZ‘?

cf e\nc\n N\. Q¢>\o<:\"\&¢\n \.)\m‘\'
\?,¢:1\ c.vv\. 3$11

L\Q;\@v\; l T»L_ '1<>\\00\'

- Qh\`>§e =FF. \?.’LL)\'\C\'L~A‘,_\'L?.\\'\qu-A\ \LSSRLK~A,` \L%\Q%§~A ; \11'§¢¢<2>\»` A

E~r~ parke \‘n +\ne Cc)\>v“\’

_0¥ C,r\`»mmq\

Qcé\ne\{ \N§\\\`ONY\S A\opca\$, hus‘\\`n\'\`y\_

UHS\N\>W\ DQC\o\<'ch§O‘(\ / l\$@\`do`\x`\’v @0( \-\<>`\ch-\S C.¢~»o\.>s

Q.¢X\>se,“*` \7,1\><”1¢12-A; \mmqu-A; \75§\@2,\ -A; \1z\q3§~A~, \zz:;@,,@\-A

\, Q@C\\~¢q w;\\mw\s, &S:wa\ \ »&%cee_é\ w \O\Q&A guam
$c>v a\\ cfr m\)\ 0&€¢,\(\;€3 `\v\ above So\id Qause. v\\>w\\oex»s gov
ch \\`Qe gew‘ce\nc£, wm Cm\c\>wev\* ~@w' u\\ @V\ar %Qs \oeco¢\>se,
l b\{ %c>\\¢`w\g) V\n\& p\ecx \ocw%c\`\n , m\\ O&'\c>w\eq “YL>\A me ~k\r\e
e%Sem-¥§a\ Qc>\c‘co( irc ii \1\10\>`\<\ \oc _-\\r\cc‘r .\ wou\d \oe e,`\`\%`§`\@\e
_Qm :p¢~<'c>\e cna é\<:~»\¢ ‘T‘(\e \c>\ecx `\omg>s.~'\v\ \ e.`~n¥e-§
§N\(\o\e %\>\os°\e e\K%K\@§\L%\J\ 9 "W\\g is ¥\ne cn\\\
reuso‘v\ U\c>- QG‘(\S§A&UX`\Q\(\ \oq %Y\e §Ya‘QC<:\\>S€ \ am 3*\00,\./_ \Ni&\r\ 0 \'\$e Se)(\‘re\nce. wi&\/\ no mw>\e,
\ wmva QQXY\ ow\ \(\\w\s *v\r\`\s st\>\c\ <\L>X \De op\r\ &§e)c\’r?o\\ Qc\<‘v §
mg p\ea &Q,'Cee>,w\@r\'\'. Ccmid\q @gy\, \ €Qe,\ X\(\\; won €c}v\`c>~(\
§§ uv\c¢z>v\®\<>\r\(,\\o\\»\ \m©mmiss`\\o\&, mud \r\&\se_ \\>S\ Qc§\*<\n in
C>\>W §\>c\`\<;icx\ §\\§Xew\¢

Q\>vs\>cm‘< w presex\*<\\{ ‘0€_'\\(\<3) iY\Qc)¢(Qe,\§_. 10\§