Court Opinion

ID: 4068675
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 00:05:38.972861+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:50.337478
License: Public Domain

:

                                                                                                 ---t---~~

                 -------------------~·~----------------~~-

                      .P&:r_z:o7J4   <   .c:&-a IA) 40       DL42&ufJ£l_LZZL/4..             AbeiAcosta,Crer~

 ----+-:         _Cod1G.J_uQ0_~wA~_&o:n_P-ro~A&!Lli!JuJfi_~J,g__CJ.f..6~0Al)-----
 - - · .j_)&8GM-~_I/£ra!._...::f_z__'i_!G_{J_B_j_/2~~w..L odiZ!_AA.ifJ_~fGd~Ea~klli1i.-·~~
  __ · wr:.LL 6L./_f)y)__ml:f_~ 11s EiJLtcvus_:                                                         I

                                                                   This document contains sofT\e
        - - - - - ~--~-..J                     .------------'pages-that--are-of-poor-quali,ly--
                               PA£4 i-14AJ.i- ~ -~~__jr~ 11~ J_f±_I}j_&i_t.JJJ!JiML~S~t-iPtu i""'-j ____
  _   __,w='=--~)Jc:~_lLw._t7Ji_D_8:~bAli.-:s_tJ~~ili___.ft~J1-~ l1.tt U:5:f.l1J.+;_z.z&2____

      iialfD___fu~mA-12.. rCaiYI:):fiJQ/)_IfNi,1
____.......                                           }de:BiJ   -:Jb_i~A!& tt_J ____,_.____
           ()AJ~ UALMtlUJd 1()1J16 (.J~.d/) -~-"'-"----------------­
                                                 ~)
   •'

 ---'---------'-----41LLQ)_:_~_GM~ o_.:ru..,r__WfJ,_S~_AEo~l:2:r()_u_tJ&J_JJJ:tiR_QAtldd~--
---~~£uMtdl::f:f!._/?Aese-_tU_7 ..]:.JJ,J_/d~LL!J~~~b-,J/JJ:tJ_~gr_~rz-L/-lL _aeL_tJ_I!__~: __·
-~· ~U1--,-7J~2-'frN_tt}_'-<'{_0£.5JJ!J..L6_i}_,h_Ld{({)T..IAJ__J:;zJj__~IJJ                       ;£1--/Ut(J   !

~~;--:5_711/12.; liPvlfJ_/La.Jie:::~_TD_'JJ±g_/)~6:JCA-JL&E~TJ_-I_.z;j_.:I:&J_/j_:c_cTtnt!&.'; ____
--~~I.U.ifl~_ Cem&Tb).) A • k .• A__!_tli:Jl,!.)r-i fU) JAC~_od1 ~dJ.dJ_1_~~__1____;4/u!j_ __
-- tmt:>U:          w~ _Xf,f_TIZMT -m &Ycte .:t.se.r4?.:Lt1o-L.:Jdu/J:£.ttf(J_U/9-t.7 _Ad /1 me L~__{2 M~ u. vn I}_~_/2JJ_[f]_()w~G_t..)_&aJi_'~~-
~--'-: f2Qmm.rr__lf4)_f1_C]~~/{;.-:E~Lr ~~G&~~ro_)dLLm~r~-j Lrre,
 ~---+-:·ro~w.J:2;-~__:w_l2JU_.4-~. tO~m~~-0Z"~k12---rth~-.d'g.z-6_f&.Kum-A ;(!..
_ _· ~A-m~J~G:~_(_·Jd11__]J-I-c            Jd~J!l-~_LJ TD 'TY:_B (};_;;vga.JI.J .;ru_~~J ----:-._ _
--tm(.}_t~We7J_IJ.l£_~e:8nLDL~~-fa;r~_·u_m§~_Ra_OJ;Jij__ILA_'a.t/A_~;_~,--

                     ------~~-v~-------------~-----------------                          ~-

---~~!J_.~:~D.JeJJ~..t-"JE}j_$_r_R7Z2v_b_kOI~CX ~ ~;€. IJ-!e. MdTG}."-=--Q;J=-~
~__jtt:Sf4Ua' or- -L~~-Jid.~.PJ ~.x.~.J ~ T?Z..~tl~.:im~c..<_,__
         I                           I                        ,.    II

-----+1 elf ·:pJ-0 ~~~-$ee._;{)5_1{f/LCJd rt)1:32fZ !}_,,--~----------

~-~~~-3mz-an.ez~ .L:LLl~"J9_t€-~_Si-lo.U.:::K2 rL+ti-~TA-Te;j__c9AJ_~ · - -
 ~-+-!vJ£TAi8:5_~_t{}S$.4~/JM_C4LHt)Lu..L dalrezi~J=tg-VJ.ziJ_ALer .oe~c-=;~-
----{Jf>.4fYl5J2!i(QJJ.4-tti:).-   ;)p   z/-16. F~       _{Qie. Ttt2_l/_tWt_W_C/L)J..i,       Q~euT____
~~-+JJJM_\J-~-:S--~-~~,tfe!C::il wl4-~i.e ftJ UQ:2(Q_]7)-::Jl.,f~_£Loote._,._ __
            I                       .,     .             .

  --~j _.__[~~-LA-s_r___j)_~.r_M_f!eil.A;QJJ_)_'Tkf£S_&.u_IJ.i_~-mr&d>-TL..,fe._·_ _
            ~~
            1 · -~~.ju~&U.JE!].-riL. '1_.:(..)_0. t.ccrcl)__&m~JTP1-Eae.Jl(1Lli?d1/::Je.
                .                                                                                        j

____.LB.~~               ·m--A-T   Pa::tJZZ2AJ~      ( C;5vn~TCrJ         _ ' e;J;nd e72 .-PJ~7:tDAfflll'1
                                                  (3)
     ,'

 ~-\-'---'\&ie.._~j_QQJ)IA.J ~ L--<~G
                                -, b}_u;s_c;;i/j_/1_rxks/:1_uQ_f}!k_~ ~~~--l:J~r_:rJJd_::__~ .~-=----,\\n_ _
 _ _:TJ..kr:J-_7_:_:___w.£_r_kL.!.&! caJ7      LD_C/lu._o:e_Jti"""~~-ADiJ.,z:::l_'1--+"=-AbiU6U-(-\~--
- - 'SJk0J_jf4~r__~-y_ij,/}_(_TIJ_A)_ L . LJL&d?J;__ei;_ II-'TZJ~_J6d-frl~~?J-W4LYIS
~-eEf!.fee_cwA:S_u;U;:;;3 (e :JD_~e:r~rag__-p.te-__Vilt.-.I.JJQuJv ~e~-­
_ _-:JJJtM_U/JJ_.:f.J2LLceJJfiA-J 7 &_/JbltJ_J'r:-/J.UeJ~-J_fi_6_;_../e_&;L_L__TD-· ll+-e~--
--        _fLoD~t,                                             ______                                    .

_ _ _(d_'J_,_g6~ili.-~S-1\..lG_I_f'z__Lw(Q_2Jd.kj'_W_.Q.£I eL;12;;vu1:;1!/m_u:s_f_ _
~-·C14'-&LL~_{o_JJ_~-0-CkAJ-t1LC:r@A.A_l_l}:r ;5_kt,&eB\5E__.L j To A-;:;\<.. : _ _
         ,:tj ~ o-t ~~-Mil(_ L4fJ~_g.:J_L6 TD .L6_6_U6_,4-A.J 0~-TD
_ _TI-\_:__1.

    ~-'1J./'6_.·7@..4:5 befJtrMmeJLt7 r;t: ~/.1!... ~a:r::e -~//(
_          ~RfdW~ ) (2LqsSIP.:CcA7.];Z)J ~JLLij ~8~ 9PPLC12 !D £c7Yir9~                            ~--

_ _"]Jd6___3__G_u67P70                   Q~ fi__~ra:i~LJ ~_Li::e;;_f.Jcxi   CAU$J;ll(p   ~~                  .

-~m_kJBik-_]n_b(9_k\& LJ= Ux :5_;}r;;-u"l67LCEJ~~Ei:>€.£:. ~(:£_SI1 ~-/J-~-­
_ _·Eo_&_/d/J/~ ._Lb/;(d_lleEL~_..:iL71 ~~-UJBL_lYlur.uJt*.. I~_JflJ~~-
    _ _tJ_jJ)IJ ':J7d~1&3i-7 A L.l.. fY/wUJrd!.. c/J ·~·j__fJ_j_fdtaafiUlt./.11--rt;;iJ_JLJ~.9~--r--~­
____i111fr?Ek w..lkt1R             ~-~L~ !.5 _..5_/lq_,.~~~~~~~~~~--t--~
                                                                                                         j

_ _ _ __k\ou2t~-~_7J...f.6_riP.I__-4.L__:_K6...CC>~-~L_L_\JL-/Qc.iL_;_y_G-                   T           j
     _ _1]_,1_~1}£    wh..6_uo_/lf:5tUlltJII_f/E:._l::.k·A.J6.r:7J4? D~ fl_ !J~---r-f/j ~ Ll::£y;jJtx}   I
     __me. Tfd,.£/1-C~A:(.:f ~C€f::::77N:::7Ur                /1A.J./J ~a..JE£ (lL~:;?t;J...~c-+-\_ _
_ _5kl2w
                  1
                      \t~A..l-(J.r;UCQ   eF   IJe-11~~   LUEY+-tODJ:  lli/i4 ' .                ~
                                                                                                             l
                                                                                                         I
                                                                                                         i
--~----'A-{ u. fY76/2 Q(£S 68..,S_E:_.:S_f?p....e...:>E~t.-i_la:J__W_"(~_~Jfld-_____,...,6'-'---P_ _ _ __
- - - .c.~u&L /tE_~J:.ILo ,4__1t)_()_I]~~_5-~IQ.(,j ~u l..:w.Ce;J_8~_Tk1AI                               A---
__ 1   k},::ru(\£~A.JD l-r:6_!0__·~££..AJ_f2r .iJe7tiJ!·
                                                      ~
                                                         ~lfll9W..s_,_Qe;;:;r;:r:n,uerf.JI
 _ _JJdb:l!etJAQ.e ~L:! tS:5 DtJ :                                                       i
     .·

          l , ._:;.II _ <   fl :; [\ =- 1
- - - + .1~.::)<::::LL_IYLU.vT-~-DeU:::
                                                -~ l?:::.{P\~-    (.J.;"" 19 , o  ~e - · .; .::
                                                                                          J/ r11
                                                                 1:)£~--~---I.Jd:C:_i.::,~-~'V
                                                                                                     e.~ CG .!U_""'-~V-~-'---
                                                                                                             ~-.           -A
                                                                                                                              --
                                                                                                                                  , , ,(\-

-~~St-bOw-IJJ:CkT I/d6 __ t_c--FeK£.(!,g_A--PfS_/)_~_/JS_p-.M/J_&.sr:s_w~;~_U6t2J_.r~                                                                _
·_   _L~_m.:Ru..~72/tr.n:xj 81- fbu..:>e~ I
               vwLr-r!£Dd,                                                                                                                   \
                                                                                                                                             /
___ ___Ru.LB:s GQ.~fJ7~_cm llL\W fhJv~-~IJ_u__kCA L ·u.s aGe                                                                          ef:'    l
                                                                           (!Jj
   .•

~~ . wo~_t}IS2.6_£~[.U,.)_/J_.:p0~-a-1-0-7tE-XSc\3-Gout;;;fM.li21EA-J[_(1£J~-/t~1-­
-~-i;:3Ll-·6!-LL,~"liiJ i/_c_r_, __L,j !dJI.& Tm_Jlc.I';----~
~~ 1 _{lt£!_eM 11.'::7 pl},q) v.J:YJE\i_WIPT LLf)i§dJ_,J_~J=.,ufJ__ ~IJ/V3S.e::5__&, __ cJ:>P-15l1Z/if:i.?1_._.- - -
-~             ;a Q!;£).£IJBIU__ee~~.-.QJlT'td_G~(!l/J1/l7Z~_l._tLU Ce\)_~/l)_()_~m/!28,u_·:_ _
~--tu-5~6 ,~1 IJ &o sAG-c.£P'J:CJi?f1.:...E!)£)1LilJEv__7J.t.YJc.L_L6o~:5.:____~
         I
~- _)_,4-,tnJ p_JJJUtfC::f.:f_::a.J~LJ)4 ;£, A c.~-~-/)_Il~QL-I-~C£t.L o__!f,_~ _ __
~~->~{i/P$'__~1€. //} /:7JA-I.F:?/{p_k)/d.ez:H~X!_ 4~Le..OJ;;_o_U_~.___._·---·
  ~--+--":h_~z# {)12 Q/l--le>eW.£56 j_.:.-f~J_RLL~£ ~6.!~
- - - - .t\C.CGMlAJCQ~~-\

                P2..:r:r:cr=oAJ 8Q il_/9_s_:r.udu_tJf=XJ_TJAIZ~ED-Ll.ouYDJ_c.o_Ea~~-r:&.__:--~
-~~~~~~-ae~u~---~-~------~~---------~---

                                                                '
    ---.,-
         1
             -LJdt.     ;5'_z:;!J:rtr1Z1~1:i-iJ.kCCHDIU I<:::J._~ff9_&_{[)_1f-A-1 (} 14 ~LLL-.-)_-1:_0~-+--~~
----+-~£0u...A.L_IJ_~jyj_{;~tx:::._-&.:t L LBM2 :L..1.. .L~D::tc2- fl t.(..-:-uJMTj_/}_cr --<>1-6'~--+--~
~~-'---'~~,(J, § llo~lJ ~A.J!J JAp:J!Jb'/2. rX.. l/..5-Cl Si3~\_i}_LA114e/24ZPI(~
                                              ~·   .. '   ~)
   •'

         l                                                                                                    I

 -~:.'U~EJ)_Sr_r1y_6j_.~~-~~~g __~.;s-T&-~_aJ.I1t:;_L_;.;_JJ.L_&_f:E.LC&~l                            .
 _ _eF Tld6_UI,.J;M_eil_i:Lv_tf}__C# mtn.411J0 1_0te.. <04£) e/Q. .LS:SLJ,J:I__U_<._Lt21/_D4D.I7U~~-.:5r:ru&~s-,._~                                                      ..IN Re   :
                                    .k      1   lJ!};mL-ro,J DrL    Ce_, 7 'Z.1'3-£oi!J2.,tm_WJil£~r--~_ _
      ____ &'t-~-_m b~fQ_t/)JJ&J_6frtrJ_U~_7J_..fM_XJ_~~-~~----
      -------1...&calfl_l_\'b~~ (j'-*re. 1:_m6_L4ih!EC!f.rt£b l}_;jef./8 LJ/J- ~ ~BCBIJJ.=--=---cc_'G_ __
                 ,5acv1 CemiY?Bd P/.t9CB8 7Jd:.r~-I n--tt:;j-:!-f_Q_~ 71W , 1m~~ ~-­
      _ _ _1b_/:xL/I~J>~LllZ-I~£ 77..1'~ ~~ 11-fi?P?,_TJ-h.-£6 p/1-fe
      --~aJWJ ~ ~-D1dt:L"Vd£~
                                                                               ll   L"ft_~~-MiJ-UIJIA.LidZ6-77-ft_,_-
                                                                                        A   I.
                                                                                            _ _/    ,/}
                                                                                                                      _ _ _ __
      _ ______,Q.;I;~c)'OliLI_t!.EV-rJ.J;~wr:.tL --~~IJ.Lilv!LZ-L-~L~,.cr__,_.,6={e=----­
      ----'-'f?if/I?&J~,..)_rltc:E_fb_&Ll)__ at;_Jt22Rttill#OJLI.;;j_~------------

            '11           •
      ...    .....        '

 ·. · 1---{'ilA~...Lt.&w.mTJU!@k...s I:JL~..r:.6_P-~z _Q/U~ w!-1~~-....._--'-----'/?'----._ _
  -~~-6-LA~t.t---.W ..,jtJQLi.J!L m e~L Cr::r.';;ba£..t{J:ct &.c)ttu.Js!e-~-=.:,.___ _
 .f

I       l11i
        1
             .fAy_§e. ~4~ t=o;J.-4-c;l7_c£)_(!zrJL~lQf!lf=>)_. JU:c;:; w_m~'------
                                                     I                     I

           OOm[l(l_t)A./~ {]..I).L01J--.:A aJ,..ilU\S..~j ~~A~_Q,, M~,a,s:_-Q_ ( $ .I)"AJ ~, l C\ '1 >.f)_ilie-,.; »~­
             -~. JJtt;afcu~ vi !',c7z.(£ e-PlflCI(j ~-/_$_7_2}~_5_,_~Efl1 YlC!J.(\6Jc..'?JJ A-lliL1 OJ~c.~
                                                                          )                             .. :
                 ~- < 1:, cJ.i JJ. FeuTtx.L r!._~ Q.c, __¥-G~-KJ.J_;~4-/-~-~-3-(~.ad.-~,_Jg_u_)_,
                                                                   1'    )        -
                                                                                                           +-'_
                                                                                                           .
                  :
            -----; .           .                        .                                                  l--~----------~l-

            -----~)_____J-:Qjtj_~Qu.~O$_/;J F 7Jdt3_fi_~itE_.:f;_~_7Jd8_5-~z·IJ.IJi7J~__ A . ---+-:_ _
            ____ Q&,d6DJ. vn·u,jt /'¥> J;£ y_QM_u..J;r~St~_7ZLLblli tl.cMCB /1 dzu/d rc> \
    J;.       -~-~ue /}:_AJ OIU1ee ~m_JQeLLr::n(f:;_L(ltO~rJ?f:Vl ePP~L
            ___
~---. :~~

-· · · _ _·:m~J,Jo_6.9m&-vi.a2~_-r:_~_\"'c:>_f".t:'.uL\ d£;t-iU ~c.c S~UA -zt?A4__t.21'2..____-+-
            ;_            - .                       A                                                            f:J          '-\   /J.     /,., .
                  .;_. · · &~uJ-!_q_LlJBP]_f)_~;cn~o~_,J_~~.PJ~~                                        !J- ~, s.~)-·s.iJ_ -~ ~
                                                                                                                                                      1
            _ _._,.. _B_/iJJ~:fe!-/U]j_e!J 14~_j'-L:> r.::JB_;;~-~L2£:2ZlJ___jjQ~_7                                 JL :    T'A _L:_mf2e_L_~.je,_fJe/2~Cf:::£_:_fZL~r::_~-Dfid21-U~~-k.J_Utf:i_.._,._~,_d.!&LtJ£. _·_
                         .I                                   .

            ___i TL.f_6_-'l!~ .1~ I"!S];_~-ffi /b.J /                                     L/dl)_fJeL         '7c? ;?;_c_F.r)d__J-J-*3r;_3_-is-(_9r!!l__
            ----+
                          1
                                  _&:72 · L1_~_fi?1
                          !
                          1

            _      _____.__!
                              I
                                  ill~Cct?JtJL! r--~lfEl:S_K£§J~lef:£~e eL/L--£Lu._fJ:EJC_rD-0idaw A                                                      '

            ____l ~cJ_~ /C. &.t.j_T_/2:)_~fi;,_;2e_Lr&- fa.~fl[i &.-r_!::( l5.~ Ll2:tLu.JitLeke£!
                                                                                          I                 II

             -----r::~JLi- d11~l\e 7_s_t--f/Jilt4 14-T Zco_._JJ.-fa:__\5_me??JU~~:L_j)_tJ..J£[r .eALZJJi!c;t.~-+-i_
                                                                   1

            ----~t.:/e#IC. -~~~ ~_L;)_L&S UI1_1L~_e..-6}u AIBJ lb F(;;--IU- l.j~(o~C ~71-~---.~--
            - - - :k~IJ{jg-m PeiLm(Q. t.J£~<.5~rle..-::J_,..IA1 FAL,tc&. D~ V_,___r.l_,.,_<.::,____--t--
                                  . Pwu-r:ct>P --ru~              ..:fL,t..s:Lr~_1Jde. '\~xT!lA QIQ.6J:.V4@~..e:2Y-).c;:IJ~a£+-i_
            ------'--·f'l-'-'-n A'M 6 1t        mLt5 ;~2_1Lr !B!U<~JL tki::j            Ll Ltu..£$ >'i'A~)d-ufJ~-ttL~~
                                                                                              I                                                       \+---
            _ ____.."-k>-'-Ut.=-'L2. Jl,..t--e. Qe;e&s~ ~fe                          et   wa t!~ -Rffm ~ ·
                                                                              (g)
----+\
        . I~\J8_(J LAE Jf1Ml/J_lQtl'\DJ~..i~k\@_G\~-·--.::r:..T_:k_"6_"'&2\.ST~T-D-U-M0t::285~f "4&J_r/),---+\- - -
                                                                        I                          '

_ _____:·WJ~r_.r.r_tZ£f-'ec7.Lli£_~___ttu~:X!IJ..!6_C4uJUS k.~_IQ_LJ...k_~ ·-
         .                                              .                        II
                                                                                     _ .
                                                                                             )
                                                                                                                                            L_____
_ _____,_P~LPr£'AJ\"'u--r:=6
           ·                 10 ~R.B~ezuT A \\C..Lk:--r-tte.. 14-~'~ et::~TA.n..i frG t-t-r ,__,..__,-_
                                                                                                                                                .
     -~-':Jb_ .6e-m_t:r_/Jw.l't.t. GLOeil                       Tl ~&Yl ·:\()~ __J],t:~ G;Q 1/e--yLA}11')_~--u_r /3_~A,G_ . .:. . :__,_,_
  __ :::iJJ:~ ~@                       ~~tL ...s;-JU lc::;/t Vt:::.?...)~ -e;J '7]../t:::n§_~e.k/_/2_{J= _:r;4f~T1-1d3..,_,~-­
              . ~-lJ.P til~Ak/Jf.Jim U6_/:

----C~_)_f.rau~LL~_k'J_:_f2&ta~Rt£&.LLti.6_T:r{J_(e_fd,_u_(XUJ_c::'1~.. -~u--v~e · _
_ _ _ _~ tU~.f.l:e.. _15LJ11kiJIJ_B..mU.s_(IIJ_Us_7-_-QJJ-eaJ~7Jk.~E-LB_ck._                                         6     E_.~

--~
     ;dltJ.tiA_~.&L-2!1_tfF_8tJ'1_;1)A.e_QLtfrl?d 1/_(r~~ Re:;-"77/&-tJ ~ ,·--
                                               -                                                                           -     '        ---,,,-------

- - ..JJ:>wAJSo._(_I--OL C..r~; 1_g~~t~.A~/!'d) :
_ _:iL ~-&.)Hen ~.~d----3J_f. Q..c\ Ul~-l~J_J___&.<:__,J_~_1_Co)                     ·

     _ _-:L&,_$uvvl_tit&~Mm-Le_;;; __£ei$_e'E-IS_ru~-~t1M:.M.ii(E;~...._ __
 _ _ · w~--rd2-e ·7JJ:85-Jde.E.e ··~tJ..tiJXbAJ4l ~e&t-;z; 1.-lt.J.I/£ -~~---
                    '
              ;IYlt;;:/~_f£1_t)u_jJ1__J:~ OLOe6
                        '\'   .

                                                                      J/6':1  fbJ (9££-~Ct:::::~ TD Tli_C- E~TJI£                               ----
                                                                            1.-                    II
                  llAt-rT ~u~ x~ :5fl~CJQL~'-/}a_GS;_et,e.r_i!J~;;:-~_l!aem/J__T!J&M.,__·\--._ _
                                                                                                                                            I
_____
    -_fdA))J
_ _
          1
         __._.!Ylr:lJ-UT~rM!f_~_~M_/J ()V1J~Wr:$G                                Jj.)__f)_AJ-   ~~-'1&-IJ:Z)..U-4~--i, TJ.Ie,.-"-=::;;-+~_ __
--~·PL~6 \L!L,I#¥)1_~~                                     {!io-791f. I     t!.~, ___,LV_J.j_(j_(J&m~@tiJ?ft-1(;_}-l                       _Lt- -

                                                                    (j())
___ .              &,.._J,f:J_i~J()_Q~illelf2_fi£J_e_e._u rrm_/l_Lr_c:::7d.AJ R-N11:::.._Rem&7J ~-ac~t ~~
                   m;ro~        AE   fl.lltlll.b£~6 ~-'7_'lS_E_~. .JSYs:{;:,&£) ~. 1'\.~)_\u ~~--
               . ~et (nJ:i- ~~ lJ;tJ ~t:.) ~-~~-£-~-~-~~J_(g_,]:-/_~~.J~-~~-)~,                                          ,
                                                                  .                     ~-                           . I_ _
                                            C.tf'!:nJC.Lw ..CD J
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - -----------

                 P.e..rn_.}J_)&J_8J.'d.6~.&LrtJE:~ -t:'-~-1-tc;_IJ_a_s __a)_eT_}J r 5                              ---+---

      _ _ ·f1_u.J~t::.V oL8~rLe;_L7J;Ie_7Jd~~-r/rU;J_tlk.{JZ)u /9- (
                   ~ zv J-1~~ flJ,/;-AJ/JHmu-o_\~f/.-HJ.u&J_f){g_.r66Li.t:::(J_\----'----

                      ~\   "                        !'.!                       '
               (L)_{J._IJ_w:::rk(_~-~-Q.wel)_r_~~-ti:IIJ.,..:Q~r;_Ck£_71])~711b~Pe:~u~£.---
_ _ _.fr~~-cwA::Y_hw~-J:-~~S~,QGd.FX:CRLL~_f?,~_GS6M?f)f:£J_~~~~~­
_ _ _.-'-'-IV\-'-""£/J.~.j     /efJJ/9( f.JIUtJ   Q   r7..f~>_f!..t..iXLSi3   }.JOJ..i..,   ~S0Re7X2:vt.i A-a..t.L 11

--~·c~                     tu._ll{    Qw~ Pg-r.rr.cov~ 1(3~                        IJ..It£    Tl3~Lt.S_b~71..1f_l~-,llb''i:f
------'--:r:rf'        ~11L ~6-r.J.-cG ··.LM_ST.£t/A7..:Cl"Jd/d_[_~_t/__Jq:_B_..IJ)_A-..i)
                   f!_lgsS.j_:r:P:t:Cf..f·'r.Rv ;4-;u/j t-_cr-ooa.(}6 Q,q--a;e,e !:::J_kl_Q_L_TQ_C/k~'------
_ _____.fuv~~ I'D .8e P&:rc&?j uuiJ~______g_A.A ll~'<.!..:lefi~l/-=--'4--'7:::()=-=-----
_ _____jd"""".~==-··lbrl_a_e__All-iL\_~t..·~-6 fJ &_ry::FFt:uM ~ TD ~(9-~_Le-<=.u.=-=(O~c1C..:....:...=_ _ _ _ __

        .:5~7/::0t ae- ':L1/W ww~ ·rw~ -rMll.L ~ar J./UidU Of::'() !--l:l;~ ·--~,
- - - ' - - r ·.

_ _1]>_~,                        -..~_

  __ G~.tDU.~ b (!L~g-~_;k.j_1kh95 -:rJ.                                 ,tc._Tet6l...;;_}Jt:2J.O.IJ2m_e."Mf_DE----,;.,--
_ _____,~If(.                        ~--rr__ce-.::.LLd-T.I::{'LL7.:Q)ku/J-__LYJc~ft-i ) t!.IA.s.57FrD!r~--
                                                                                                         '               '

---~IIJ!j_l/2e:_co-&IJ_6_&PP.£.~q_,:; P Lt,_C(;;:IJ_I!_~::_x:r:r..:t-.(;)A..I-~-u~.IJ c.-=.:..-J?.....~---
------,-Up-'--'--'kJ__,I.:S- {J~~~ ~-Wkf_aJ'_LL-td                                    -ra.;::g (     ~           l.9 /1).__-,---_ __

----~-~P~eO GhL~~~------------------------~--~
                                                           \,

                                                                CtO
    I                                           .           1
~JCJ~JO. h-lD-Oihlt;;!€_-/J()t?;DbtR<76/JLr~Air.I£J2em&."7d1~~-.--~=

      l~~IX'l'lDAi~
---~Lt.____         JLJ.<<.,__-y,#...c... l r:: '. 1 1
                . l::"/..,-~.....,~-v-r=tt;;..-J<...~ft-$-~;;;;;..-,...,-c-'7·V1-I;;Jr'='.::J-et/t:,-~V[-m<::::""*uy--
                                                     17V , 1 .n.1 • t.""r1--if\ - · ·:;-y..              ·

_ ______,::.P(:)_oo~le_:__J-1-Ia&k)_JJss--4PiJe?-4-#A:i·I2J-fi/'F;.+t:;7(-/YJc:""»Jb/S-;_;t3-
            .....                                                                                                               r - - l-   -

___ ;_~_QeiL ·vd:..e Te;k~J..:J_l:J~-&BI£J_rn_~~-~OL-~t~-L-___,:_ __
            •                                                     A_                   ~-
- - - -+.~ffce:~::I:.~.6rc_TuT~J?k.L_w.J4.~-J-·_L.&ss.5::[l?.JZC:ft.IJzVJ_J-.+--- _
                                                                                                                                I

    - - ·J4-;ULJ __ ;E~-BP/'..g;-ee:,-:.-r:D-~bffi_'DfLE:..-~~-LJ~(J~_w~ru"->-:_ _
           . r...,-, /\·-r71"1/_ ........ ,, I '.c-< "' - - s ~ . - u tJ '<--~_c_
                   i
--~'KJ~.J,-J&V~'-~-~/..U_!-:=f'., -V-,-~--\r--1_\)(..{;J
                                                                         .:=-u_c..er ..G:.. &::.u.LL :i~ ~~ j ,/L/.1 L.
                                                                                            _ _1_L\)~_c:rr-v~J~lJe_()e-"~IA)rd.~-L_~~~-lJ.lJ?YL                                           }JB        t!/_   7~V:,._r.J._-:rz,£--=---...._
                                                                                                                                   1
                                                                                                                                       ___
_ _ _ j~~:r_J12_~7~_'T]ke;j_~ TD c::L:5.5LeE tf_u)f)..J;L t2.C ~AMIJ!t,m_ltj_
--~-Q/JIJ8"1m2~-~e {!.~7CCGJ.ej A--A-1/j keCfYJ./J_6~JD_fJM6c=G=-,....;_ _
 ---+-~~l1~Lld'G_~f-L7d' fduLf/7~ f?IJLJIJ ~tdYIVv£ n~e_ArrJ)l;J;fl~
            ; ~~~Elfe_QiC~t e-RIJ~              ·/.)e-A'fJe.xJ. WHe:iQ£: f~'j                 J.J,f)T       /~7:07~: - -
            ~ v9~~.JUJ;W~ ~
   --,.......,_
                         1
                                   6ra.J77::::A?..C_G    j.L\-6   _fl.!ELte/Q..J'lV4"7l:::-t1-:l                    •
            I

-----~-·--~W=-'"H6£e...r;;Q&t:__}O e.D Y:t DL-1 (;:;7e._f?£J:5/£_CL_EuL~~-·~~k-5 _ __
_ ___;,_;,::[].JJ:~_tJeA.le£S~-~-Q.M~~DP ~~/;( /4f3fJ~71Lj W _ __
   ------.· ~ue ~!:)__Q/J.IJ~t1<9mfl&L6.--:z;_~~Jdb-                                S~LBu.4..($ _ _ _ __
-------r'-t.     {J@JIJQ;l i}1J:::'U7 DL~I)~JJ:CK..::..J.:i;M.LtA~-4--=L,____ _
-------+--',~~t4MZ2d csL~~I~-~/J ~~~ BP--P:CCE__-r):)--VJ~--
            1!                              .                                                                                       '

--~::J].Y6 F:I:v~~-oLA._iJ~;QL1_kl.L~~&u.(\~]J-~~-!l¥~~---
--'-----DK..-£..C£:.1_bJ-oT~~'1-Th'::. -~t_ ~_.;j~~--~£~\5_££.._----1 _ _
- - - ·"fV~-t~\&..-iUQ-IlfU'rffiiD-,e..c.,~_&-t 01€. ..JU./J-4:6 D.,LCTJ:;zvJ__ lD                                                  \
  --~:....."-Jij~.,r,Ue_ .i~-LJdb~ csJC-Jf?.:k_c£ ·· Q..k~-.5£!s_·[tLjA.L·:f~J@.L;11:;;r..!..,..-:_ _
--·-------,-:-'-'A, ~ g,,~-0~        ceon t::a..L7      lft~~"T"c:::.)bi-Cg_,,_ _ _ _ _ _ __
                                                                    ~~w~~-&m-IJ+-t!J;.J-jdl-~~~-3-1-~-+---
~-r
--~--~--
              .·
                                             _ _ _ _ _ _(i.jp;.f_&_Ol_I_Jd_7ff'__
                                                                                     -
                                                                    'e....;STe:.llE_U~. --~
                                                                                               ·.         .   !

                                 ___ -~-----J1u ~~-ll~V.Z: li£_·::]Jg).t4,:.;,;()-~J!'l3a..o~!_               I

                                                                                                    ----t-----
                                                                                                              I

------fl---

------~---                                                                                          ------11 ----

                ,              CovYlBj   uow_Etw_I}_&{[}__~_~J:QJ -)-~eJ;L 1JZ.Ajf:?l2__Jj_~:::JY:;-~         -L___

-----.--~ ~0ro6 dwb~~-u,un~-~ea~;:;Lil-1 OLfJ8~~-W&__ ~______;__-
----~A111J_:~e.t711~-~e~u-JJ;DL;L..:F-Dtt-W~-uLl{)!J1Li~ikm-u._s_J:fl, _ __
-~:1JW£_gf:Mi) ~S2T_TD_'-LJJB_~T-~-bkk:J_l~~~<£>&;-).--'-----

--~..:)wY:JW_'fD_19U
      ,
                     'TY_.;g)_ -                        8     Of=   ~IJ]];;W_l~c~-~-D-'~.--------

             .:                ~~-~-UJ-~aiJ-&-m~-~j_~,e. e&~~~---=iJ£tJ:.:__r-._ _
----+1---'--'(-}_1~ fJ:~_~&/2BEf_C!..&~~-OL-p;J.;p-0_fuc~_Eb_tC...~kUA...tr _ _
----f-19~ dJ&A1~il£11iLd_IJB_~-~-~~-zj__ID_tL~B~M"""-Z?.=~~J____
- - - + - ' ·14.__.._,_JJI)J    !2ec:J5&dJfl_iB_r___2._e_.J~~ q ~)_1\_u,.~u;) i/J: t ~J:~..:j_!l'l3:1-il-         · _
           I          >

_ ______,oo93
         ·    ~~ PLA c:n1 ~ 14_(1~ ~_Q£_]]J_~ 14~                                  r::-o/dt::CaJ)J7J(Q_.:f.A.J __ffiE.___
       : lA~/03 ~6-~L_a2~~L_r9A-i _-o:.~~ .j                                        f:J.~rJ.-t-O£-.:Serl7BJnlh&e._ _
                 i   J

--~1
                   ;J,~I~, ----------~---------------

                                 ----------~~~943L~
--1---------------_,££JkA4CJ Ck-rrJp7[):<) ~~~~~~------
                   IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRlCT COURT
                    FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
                                SHERMAN DIVISION
                                 Statement of the Case

  The Second Court of Appeals summarized the facts of the case:

    During the early morning hours of June 7, 2000, Cassandra Calhoun, who worked
    with Raj Rainsinghani at a liquor store in Gainesville, went to Ramsinghani' s small
    apartment after :work to help him hook up a new VCR. Compton, who had lived with
    Calhoun on and off for a few years and considered her to be his common law wife;
    showed up at Ramsinghani' s a.partment shortly thereafter looking for Calhoun and
    intending that she leave with him. After Ramsinghani answered Compton's knock
    on the front door, Calhol.1n, who was sitting on a bedroom floor, heard Compton
  · yelling and saw him "swinging with his fists" and "hitting" Ramsinghani.
    Ramsinghani did not swing back at Compton; he put his hands up in an attempt to
    defend himselffrom Compton's blows. As the altercation progressed, Compton and
     Ramsinghani moved towards the bedroom and a bathroom just before Compton
- -piisnedRainsmgliaru, causmg h1m fo ra!TDackwards mto 111e6athroom ancfstnKeThe _______ ·
   back of his head on an unknown object. Calhoun did not see Ramsinghani hit the
   floor or the object that his head contacted while falling io the floor, but she heard a
   noise that sounded like Ramsinghani hit the wall "or some other object. After
   Ramsinghani fell to the floor, Compton bent over and struck Ramsinghani's face
   multiple times with his fists as Calhoun screamed at him to stop. Compton stopped
   hitting Ramsinghani, noticed that there was blood coming out of Ramsinghani' s
    ears, and left the apartment before police arrived.

  The incident left Ramsinghani in- a coma with contusions and bruises on his face and
  a fracture to the rear base of his skull that caused a subdural and subarachnoid
  hemorrhage. He died ten days later in a Fort Worth hospital. The medical examiner
  listed Ramsinghani' s cause of death as craniocerebral trauma due to blunt force
  injury of the head- an injury consistent with Ramsinghani' s head moving at n rapict
  pace before contacting a hard surface.

   The State subsequently indicted Compton for murder, alleging that Compton either
   intentionally or knowingly caused Ramsinghani 's death or that, with intent to cause
   serious bodily injury, be committed an act clearly dangerous to human life that
   caused Ramsinghani's death. At trial, an investigator testif1ed thathis office was
   unable to detem1ine the object that Ramsinghani 's head struck as he fell to the floor.
   A police officer testified that he responded to a call at Ramsinghani 's address about
   one· month before the June 7, 2000 incident because Compton had been knocking on
   Ramsinghani's door, had broken one of the apartment's windows, and was
   intoxicated. The officer arrest~d Compton. Compton testified that he entered the
    apartment and pushed Ramsinghan,i off of him when Ramsinghani "grabbed" him.
    Compton agreed that he pushed Ramsinghani, ·that Ramsinghani hit his head on an
    object, and that Ramsinghani died. The jury ultimately convicted Compton of
    murder, and this appeal followed.
C~lUC.KULJ/~oU~ULJ     TU~   Ul'J.L'l'   ~LAoo1t1~AT1Ul'J   Kt;Vl_.t.;W   CUKK.t;N'l'   iJA'l'.t;:   lU/1
 IhlMT£It$/GC00020 CURRENT OFFENSES OF CONVICTION SUMMARY           AND TIME: 04:1
 Eri;.; 6 ;uc:o 4                                                    AS OF: 10/14/
~INMATE TDCNOINAME:  01394318 COMPTON,EDWARD                   FLAT TIME:    0007 0
                                                               GOOD TIME:    0006 0'
MAX SENTENCE:     0025 00 00        PRJ REL DATE:  06/14/2030  WORK TIME:    0003 o·
SENT BEG DATE: 06/14/05            MAX EXP DATE:   06/14/2030  BONUS TIME: 0000 0'
                                                               TOTAL TIME: 0016 1
***************************************************************************
I VIOLENT I AGAINST I INJURIES I       I         I SEX   I DRUG I ALCOHOL I      I
INON-VIO !PERSON IINVOLVEDIESCAPEIPROBATEDIRELATEDIRELATEDIRELATEDIOTHERI
I VI/NV   I   Y/N   I Y/N      I Y/N   I  Y/N    I Y/N   I Y/N   I  Y/N   I Y/N I
***************************************************************************
     VI        Y         Y        N        N        N       N        N       N
COMMENTS: CALC FLAT;SUB STRK SOY INDIAN/M W/UNK OBJECT CAUSING DEATH
OFFENSES ON FILE:
FORGERY FINANCIAL INSTRUMENT
MURDER

ENTER THE NEXT TRANS CODE 04 AND/OR TDCNO
PF1-HELP                     AND/OR SIDNO
                                                                         2006 HAY I I AM ll; 56

                                                                          ~!~~~
                                                 No. 00-341

                                                                             ..
                                                                          r:r~;,::;-r~.-
 THE STATE OF TEXAS                                                  IN THE 235TH JUDICIAL
                                                      §
 vs                                                                  DISTRJCT COURT OF
                                                      §
 EDWARD COMPTON                                                      COOKE COUNTY, TEXAS
 A.K.A EDWARD JACKSON

                            JUDGMENT ON JURY VERDICT OF GUILTY
                              PUNJSHMENT ASSESSED BY THE J1JRY
                                NO COMMUNITY SUPERVISION
JUDGE PRESIDING: Jerry W. Woodlock                            DATE OF JUDGMENT: May 11,2006
DISTRICT                                                      ASSISTANT          Martin Peterson
ATTORNEY: Cindy Stormer                                       DISTRJCT ATTORNEYS: Mike Day

DEFENSE ATTORNEY: Jim Hatcher
OFFENSE                                                       PENAL CODE
COMMITTED: Murder                                             CODE-CITATION: §19.02
DATE OF                                                       DEGREE
OFFENSE: June 7, 2000                                         OF OFFENSE: First
CHARGING
JNSTRUMENT: Indictment                                        PLEA: Not Guilty

JURY VERDICT: Guilty                                          FOREPERSON: Nina Coody
PLEA TO                                                       FINDINGS ON
ENHANCEMENT: n/a                                              ENHANCEMENT: n/a
FJNDJNGS ON USE
OF DEADLY WEAPON: n/a
DATESENTENCE.                                       FINE: $nla
IMPOSED: May 11, 2006                               COSTS: $232:00 upon __._
                                                                          parole           ______
P®1SHMENT ASSESSED: Twenty-Five (25) years coniinement.
PLACE OF CONFINEMENT: lnstitutional Division of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice
Tllvffi
CREDITED: 331 days

          On the 8th of May, 2006, this cause was called for trial and the State appeared by her District
                             .    '
                                  .                                                          .

    JUDGMENT ON JURY VERDICT OF GUU..TY PUNISHMENT ASSESSED BY TEE J1JRY- page 1.
    Curren! Trial Compton
                                                                                            --~   _    ....   , ,ro ·"   .11   ,.   n

                                                                                                                                     n- S'i-f,
                   THE STATE OF TEXAS                                                                 D'1 THE                       0      3 -            _        DISTRICT COURT,

      COUNTY OF                      (c oof-e_                                              .
                                                                                            }                      :iu         1'\tJ CH        'f              TERM, A.D.10   LJ (o
      INRE:
                             TIIE STATE OF TEXAS
                                                VS.

              To the Director of Corrections of the Texas Department of Corrections, or any other officer legally authorized
      to   receive convicts, greeting:
                                                                                                                 /',                +-"-
             Whereas, by the juqgernent of the Honorable                                ·                      CJ J 5'
                                                                                                                District                   .                   ·              ~ourt
      of                 Coo li'-Q...             ·    Cou.llry, Texas, in the above styled          numbered cause, made and                       and
      entered on the·                day of                         ·         A. D. 20          ·, in Book _ _ , Page_·_,
      the above named defendant was adjudged to be guilty of the offense of         ['{l. -;;;:Gl C                                                       r-         .
      - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - :j:a.fleadly ~l'eapon was used or eE!ibite.d in co,mmissioooftbe of:fu~ or
      ciuF.illg immeDiate flight the~.G~, a felony, on his plea of _ _ guilty; and \Yhereas_by proper sentence of said                                                                    .
      Court, dated                         Il    1&7:      ·• .· A. D. 20~ and recorded m Vol.~, page                                                                       /i1!::fl.1·
      the above named defendant was sentenced tQ .be confined and imprisoned in the Institutional Division of Texas                                                                   ·
,·.   Deparonent of Cr:imincl Justice for a tenn of    · .•       c9 S      -£A t· ~ . .                .     'f        years.
I

           *And it appearing to the Court that the defendant bere1fl bas     incar.qnued in the County) ail in this eause
      sincethe                      ·  dayof            331 eft\.           r-<..c;U+-     A.D.zo&,witbouttrial
      and prior to the passage of semence herein upon .bini and that ·d time should be credited on this sen:tence. It is so
      ordered.

                                                                        ~)~J!    gave notice of ap
                                                                               said Court and the · d

           Wherefore, you are hereby commanded that you take into your custody the above named defendant and con-
      vey him to said InstiUJtional Division of Texas Department ofCrirrrinal Justice and that_jou execu~ the sentence
      herein as required of you by law by confining the ~aid defendant in the   ~ 0 TpC~                        for the
      term stated above, subject to the rul~ and regulations of the              TO C. :S                 . authorities.
      Herein fail not, but duly execute t1rls order.

                                                                                            Oerk.                                                                          , Texas

                                                                                            By_~~~~~~~~~~~----

      of
             Capias served by placing the defendant under arrest on                               the._________________
                                                                                                     day
                                                                  ·AD.20 _ _,at _ _ _ _ o'clock _____ M.

                                                                                            ~--~-----------------------Sheriff.

      -      ·u""' codilcd wi>hjail ,;m, del: Jbaa1l....X tbioo J""'