Court Opinion

ID: 4025290
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-08-16 07:17:00.779102+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:05:24.499041
License: Public Domain

RECEIVED lN
-»~ §"'°Sa::,";.:..¢zz.a'~'= -~»

 

ca “`{¢.\g.< \w.¢\r\ 1195 ; 5 gm

- _ ]'@"3' k<'if \3, Tl`exas "

¢`Déb"re K. A-'w*t»r@v, Cr@r;<

I\\A.QL'M_'L`ZD`_IQQ ' §:\`7- ,_,_ ___

i:f\€. "\`_n.(`$a¥\ \.L§`{i\f\'
A@@ L\\cm”i

\E-

j\\t_ §kfa~>¥£. \L? `/§é.§@§

` ga {§HY¢.&X {\’Am ’\Anr.,.  §\ALX..\\£\Q.`R§ A l

\§\~s#\'x‘\c.\" C»>uf'/\ Ev¢<;c_, Iaua.~:~& /\¢_xaa
“i”n ¢§\ Y_»ui`?f Nr,. 3'\"&§!36 56

 

 
 

guam `L§rzsu»\¢§ ~ __
 \°\N¢X\a€\’\  u;“&\t.:¢;: _1191>_\; \Q,_cg mm ai M;¢':Ué»&_s;  §L‘¢;t,. §§ Q.~_.gg fe_Q,,f_f
L`lb/ \1>\°1|/\ »l:\‘¢>w\ 4~\¢\4, views Dap¢.r»¥ Y’A¢'M” ¢5" \Gx,\\)\\<. §w\.'¢‘\_“_{

[f\w\c, \el> Ec.(\c.v\.»§. h

""\\v\ a ziaz§¥ l

mg;§ )(;gn \Q;,,§§ 53 Q;§§;,s§¢,y;’\ Uc¢;g:l \)\r¢c>(¢(` g fha 1\¢,1

0

 V§Y\L ,~\‘!_.‘.j~»a~ 5 g ¢. po\” 

§z:s-§¢"z`~'. I<'\mt_ LA\n<'./)\Xov‘t ‘$`§5\;~__;5;_
was \n§arv*\r’_<§ \z“i T\\o_ :¢A¢<`a~\

" ?)ur€_¢m 09 \v\g¢shag‘g,,n m maj

_Q_.~,\»>/,r»€_ L\’;jc>_r§ m »\~\\<_ :6`; _
At.\]£_\¢>QLA %\:Q u_\ o\_>Y-~ ov\_ Ab.§(`o~\kq $<"_ - _

`"\v\a\\ C:)¢Lf`i_  N\.A;\'¢;g;  

\E‘Suc uf\t. “Tmx\ f . `\  ,_

 

 `§\»xzut§§§

`"\\\¢ Ru\\,~.\ u£;r, (_¢Av;;i'_r._»": Q..§r ;mg;¢§;,,,.¢ QM };.5§;,,¢ g §§ ,_
fc\hcmu§ uv\hr_v ;»_ \§=§urg_<;>rc_§ 5»\'<»»\§»\§§¢\. CV\\~I;V¢., 3. §\_~Ag,
rf§  BL ?‘3"51 "55\ `T¢_»L. "L’_‘\"\v\\- @n']o. gould "'(y,`\§_ A¢_gn|g __
rc\n¢m \a§uc.n‘i \nig_&¢; ;t\,¢ ;A>rm,,»_.¥» ;55,,¢ m QQ;&» ";M,,/ _
\L‘\Ll'\nv\ \Xv\c\ )re_s)r\n£`r t`_c»€¢‘_$ z 
§)z_'cl'a\,\;\“x\z t_!\§¥~s ;§~\M;\' g;¢_u\ Qv\}'»r‘i__{_)‘¢\g., _)_{¢;\‘; QFQ\L;

 

lj/\n¢>)re.\” h>*\ of 'T\~¢. `/\`U~a$ C¢Ae_ o\’ if\m\v\@\ pvgg$ur!_~
¢>\~A¢\` {¢f _Q@s)r _f_¢i\v;;§ygv\ Qn¢ §g¢§§mg. §g¢_~!,, ___
\/ £,§hgg¥,`;, Q¢,;E',‘Q;¢A mgm 3;\,\, g A¢,m¢ 3533 ;1,5§5 ___

\l\
1b § /gnydl§`a"f\nn_i.zg;\.s¢£'§\_l_§._  )Y_LJ_“\'L’\C’

-'Y'\/\¢_ 'CV\A<»ACL \r\o.; Xx;\-. 51;§>'3¢;§§& /If, h f¢§,¢,-\;\¢ C`\M;`A __

 

 

 

of .~ 354 L__

Aé¢¢vv-\\./\; ““\w.;<, 35 go E.°~§Q».,,;‘ ;¢ ;*{!\¢.¢L vus;mc_m/\LLX§ .__

cm. 5.¢.3\“§.5 §~\e.& ."

 

§51&§.3`\‘\1"\_¢¥\£`»3_ (\>‘Q_.'>>.__ \'r.‘§>\'\‘;§{_z_, -L.:Q‘A \‘;.\;'=. "`; Qv\é ‘;,;Cif~ g §§ ;‘,;5'..5 §§ fan _
\ - \:\a\¢@\£<:§\ ~1».»\¢»,3:=»-‘.¢\ ma Q.:s$v\ »;;F »’r\¢\¢ f¢.<`\¢. c:-_¢L \>c.
~‘.~=.&xe.c¢‘r¢é 515 /\-¢z¢¥\~\cz m`r‘i\.,\ v\em¢f _»\Ls)r\v\c )r¢.»_\\v\\t§g;<,; »\L~.»_’f

 

3

Pr`o\)\z\.§.t t». \‘e.o-;g~\=:\\a\;, "\,x\.-'L€\»~~;¢-..;;"` ,»jg'*" g¢§g,§‘g;_<, jj xi mg man gg;»

 ui‘£~§t. L\‘¢\R Q§c:~\i:~,c»§\\\i£. j\"\\¢\'/\ j\‘\.\¢ \"e,_~<_\,,.\\*'\'§ BE'._ 4.'\4\¢ Qggg };j)\'. §gf[. __
l.A-£l\ ¢M.\§`_x)fl_mm-)fc.  \'_e_é;-¢_LLU._\¢ALAK '\§c~§_ Co_n\l\c'¥c_g ,__,, _,__
Q;;§m mg¢§"r e_§"rg£\\§b \;3 _1;, Qv\~z\c‘:uk §§ cx¢\.\\@¢v\’¢»,r“\ f»_s\,\*:s \AAA \;m\ \.\\')r >\'n )LG\L¢.. \\;B\C,o~\ \M§`_\LL \I_\;_E\J\A_L¢\(f;_g¢'
-__H>¢\-l" §-

£ a >¢ -L @.¢e\!__ w

C\IKAQY\C.L )(n $UQ()¢.\\"\" \g`;.§ ’§Qv\svgyf\;~\¢y;_ _
:§t\\¢xk_'\'\fv_ 0_\'_:¢(` \"¢Q_gr\’__gn? E¢»!‘\mv\<§\ <)QS

_\a®>\:/¢Jfnri 5\¢:»_1\`\5._\1;.__511.\3.:___;.;\~\= air K._’L

Luv-\\:\LT \1~`~\ \;\,1.

.

\A.l"\¢\r\ Qra\s;&_\é_;\;\§.;,\»\g,¢_ '\'g i\¢g, §r;;\¢_.;§ ";Q\g§j§f §`\gm,,;b(g ¢;g;¢` X§§Sz____
_ X' vi C~c_-;\.@»l§ `F‘P‘§ S\.\.,\A\A \1¢ sub)\‘F_`\§V mf»;x_ ¢L§m`a\)f»;é _“§y\£ "\3‘»-¢- :?L`\ u.\\/\¢> EL o~ Qn\:)¢.\Q\L\/\-\

 \4\¢\\Ac;\ \Y\ C- Q¢Q\L\o~)¥\a\r\.
__xx ;L t.-¢~A;`~\>;A¢L#_f'_@w§ Qcn\;o\\nm:\~x 15 m\”
<~_u\@%u}. ”Y» Ms\§»\” ~\\~, »`:\"\c.‘sé- u\%v\ \,u`\.\`\A/» his §\.»<\\s:*
»\;;( hug '{¢QL;,§§Q,Q¢¢A. B\v\_<_'.<__°\\.h¢. Cna-@c.v~.§s \,L~\Q _Qal\¢§v\‘\wxd.<`\ ¥\,\¢.T _
 Q>_L »\A.¢-,~ \\»\_j_as , ¢_\_,|;yg '§,~.;L,;¢i\/\ c., >_\vxa/

   

m §m;c §% Q¢g-;';, §;§grk ,_:§»c»e:$ v\¢f"€" ‘a\c c_,z@~: ¢, *r\f\e_ tN\c\.v_l/\<¢L -{'{`Uvv\

"_Zi§,€'f', ‘\ P‘r ".._".. f Qr?< C»»\§v¢.\~/\Lc§ <: \\ % \

. ,.

Mnrv\v\ uw_<é »':~\M ti?‘:, f`§¢. a'e?¢.<,z";/ m_ Ax\o\ §c~w\v\c. f';f ¢,~. {M»\Z\\`»~.cr

ypg|,g'§¢{ "',Q,g¢ \;jmg /\’\¢, mm S,L~r,~¢\§\@\`é\. "'\`v~e. or\¢',§g§§ ’\`5§35 \A¢;§ `

§L;`\¢ j§g,§g },;;,§ g: §;v\f; \Y\ .£\ \»“¥C L"_\_\_Qv\ [:_\Aas;_gg__ '\A»¢."T jz>\“\tuv\€/
\s’r\'v~; j§.g,g i\,g¢  .;_§s.‘»'\, §¢~,:~f \¢\2»_§ `\Lav;ff'\\;;§_¥v_§ X:L ‘K\_'_\x_ _AM‘~ _v~/A\l~
’l`\\c__v);m re,.§;;\'¥ 5‘¢,\@\,;52\. *~`1,@; §z€,;gg mg 5 § m 13 .

\.\ max m;\\»z 5¢¢>4¢{»\‘¥_>..¢  ';¢@\»; z,v,¢,» ‘,,\",_ ¢,Q`w,,.',;_,;

"_l“r \1 '0@¢¢5¢&  WLSL_L¢_\LL___?________
\Y\>!Li'\>'r€\'k)\”\n\\ T\\,\\§l¢_\\`»r\t§ £\. (/J\\‘u\ .§gg(>§¢./ . _
c "\
;¢;`,5; §Mg¢ §,,,,,¢g \m ,3,,,¢,`§3,;5 §§

-’/

»‘rv@»\s\@§rc_ '\’» vm~.xc, L~)v\ a f ;f\\g___lgh. m 5§,,¢ Q@\;;Q§ a»~§'g,_cg_ §§ g ~,5§\;,_ ,Qj =,51¢3; 55 3;\¢@_¢,¢,___

r\nk wnt~\ur¢. '§o.§c§- N§`,\§; \¢;§§g<§ y_\,¢¢§;§ ;kh.»_ {¢g;,;;;mgyf(j ;g g;‘j_____
\.¢\.»A GLLQ_-

 

/;!._\§g » `/\-\¢\¢_ !JV\L~"`-

\nmi; Q\;=Q rmufi A\M~'A \\e. ‘§~=\~eu>»\ '\ "~‘ \\ " ` .
t`.\l\k¢v\!_g  §~1,55;§\ 335 »‘v\»@i §o.jg 35 fm E;~,,g¢ _g§__>_;§,\¢_  ;_)L‘\n¢. _
;,§\QQ;,B j\.§\i‘cv\ g`§g;g§g§ 313 55 j\¢,¢ Qgg§\ g;v§£¢ §§ A"\e;, £.§.$¢;1.3¢\)(¥ `Q‘»c\é"‘é»\_i

1
xv \\\“‘\\ f k E\"Y`.

 
 

   
 

'\¢\1 \~\\‘»\ 90 ‘r\;;§_"' \;L 3§\/\¢ Fz€c\»`\¢(_, \'5 _A

\ w =_.. ~.\ \ \} _L=§\'!j'§ ,\J\F

§§ {'*AC:~\Q¢\Y;:~%"“Y. M’;"‘»\L ‘;\\\»`¢C~.C.:B. \\\C_;‘~.\:~.~/» "Ye.-'$j¢:§zc_~'_\ ".§\,.,!i   4_
gn,,gg L¢`§MQ (y,, §,3,3_ mm ¢>’r\\¢< %\~»»n +\/\e, m$\\l\<§¢,¢¢\ €QJ'\A»% (_

 

   
       

24 393 f.zw\..ic\».rf‘_?‘v ‘~\ r. \.\5`\1\~¢\ L‘x$*.<_, -‘r\»~
 *;\,\¢_Q.,§\c,; ~;d)¢»,v‘<' »¢\"‘+»¢.¢¢3;;_. mm §
v\o’i i\_’¢,v<\k"\x \,Lg'.~_~j fhr\.’ gr=uv\z\ \.1_\.4_¢.*°\‘#“\(;,\/\.9(` w\ Q¢SS`C'>‘S\<>\A uF ¢;_.
\.u\\`\)fc. 1 v"o\' \AQ.R C\‘i\j §o»§§?-:"\. §\g;\§`, §\Ag_ [,§§g§`;g§ ;\_\_;~_§\§_ VA;§-

R<'\\CH€A 5¢>9*@§ *\C u_\\/\<\ §.»§`5\ "f\@r §\)< 'Y\»\L £xc_}v\.\o~\ half ‘;G\'\nv\. \}sa.v vnb
k§x>\>xgn."\’h_k\_/>¢. \n£cm bd _»;__ m§<\¢;c, >x e, c\\.\¢,\\~\§i$ w %\»\a. §\.\m.,
35 3m r¢Q.\->r ¢\.,¢5 §§ X S\\.,\A ow\\\ Z¢¢\<). §u>»v\ °r\»\¢ a_\`\¢c.c_c\ \xzcXxé/\.

§;;,\g,(; m ‘W\L Ba\“\»\xr\<,- c>{ Qe.f€e.v\ 4£>`? \J\\\\v\-r\- \M\\»\v\ 0~\3<> Gn\<§ ‘Y\.~< ;nv<>§

§§ &g;xg \,;,§;¢¢,\ ,,\¢\;.;;g A§\AQ,X m §§ §§\\;¢ \QQ<;< L\\"*CL¢\_A \x\c}<\r\ L\a\w\s

365 \:\¢>.\\L gough S\ASQL:K \>‘?‘? bit N..( 0\‘~¢\5 1533 §§5§;3[; §,¢,Qg m)¥;;
"'“' "»:\!~L €.1’;3:>\\5\1\ =r~'~a‘¥:\»%. \ “ ‘ ~ ' ""’ \§ < \\`.

\L\§\Lf§ 355 L¢\LC)LA \HL:_*\'\W\ '\’g\$§g§`; ;Ac>(."$ md §,<§gf`\k<‘-§ L‘i\"\ j\)g\r\

t\!cv\’\',u'> o.\\c(>c& \)\c:‘<\m,"b\f¥` §v Ev c.»\< rv.\\LX’ m §§M§ ¢0<£¢ ¢,§ gm § ;, g§¢(_
 _
[1¥\‘-\ \\t `\ " u “\’ f qn{ \ \.1~ G. k "\`¢__

\ \ 1)<~

Q,_.rov\ “\'~L `I$'§R

 

DVQL\\»v\/\ Ef\t. \~_Df€\>v\ \.A.\`\'AY\ ELL<;\£»"L€ u.nc\a.f "r\c. QLA_/;,;gj Qf
_O.g(z“».»,g$"k_   A§‘r,;{g \”-.r\‘/\<'_» §y\r§¢§yv\gk~.gv’\ \,_S ¢&T'\AL. Sx/\C\_\ Co C¥