Court Opinion

ID: 4051108
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:28:25.37326+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:08.441775
License: Public Domain

l 31, '9\51~€7
In TT')€, Cm`m`ma\ @Dur`\' 59 nppec\\ S"Huswxfl”ws y

 

1 VJE\,»-DD,¢ "E>\'->~\UQES
~ \
P@£n*n goes REcEi\/ED;N
tva COuRT oF cR:r./:)NALAPFEALS
'rhe, <;>:’m+e SPTE.>on&eri`\’
Ab@!/»‘¢cos§a,'@s@g.g<

 

i)\)(`{\'{t>‘€' ®L.\® _L\)c\\"r'o`r\”\`o
"Mj__;so w

 

\, mg+r¢A-F’;?€Le@v¢'f@ F-.‘l,_»,: `
` wm`~\' 99 !`_§zuo \)&a(“van_f¥r>

Z. l£)m\ 'Avrgum~enjv :Q;¢},ue.¢>lrféq

MOT\O_” D§E§’\E’D\@ WELDDQBQ\'D&E$ -
’ §§TE Pe}r\"‘c\\e>nerl@£\d`cor
. v v " y NA~\lr\¢:m§e,\ JT Ne.cx\ L\\’\\:\`
QD_§S ZPur‘ 557 l

'prmazvl\\€>fl"© Fl"l€. U)_r"\'.\'¢ 159 Q*u.f) '“U)cxrmn`\“o
Ir\ The .(",c~fmln¢\\ s&>urv'\';DF 'QppeA\s 9 Hus+m`,“EMS
' l(l¢\:u\§e_|\]e. CR~Z'7‘I7CI-F} ` '

 

. fn r`€? ` ’. " 9 § l$'?+hb;$i'rld" £©Lu"`9 l l
\/\!F¥\-DOM BR\‘DG\ES ` § "‘ Rhge,\`\.nQCour"d>/ ,TM$ '

l\'\c>'\’;¢>n`,l:¢¢~ Lea\/e §'Té F'~i'\€, wf"\'"DF &UO wa`F'A`;r"l'+'O

,r BTP\-C. HD?OD_FA\>.\ULS‘\’\`£.¢_& 093¢11`¢{ Ceur"\"f~ ` v

Cc>m€s )\);>u_) wetm>w]$moc~;&e> purs»\m+’~'\'o`TE)@$ Qules

909 pre\\q\'\'e. Prc>aec\ur_¢¢jp\u\¢ 52__{Seeki-n3 e)djmord ir'm ry reh`e}e
{V\ Y"BV,\RC“>‘,’ V€»f‘r\_nduchi:'Ca;nnon Q$s=ub d B(\)(B)§ §pi:gmer\ u, M/¢;H¢§)
-Bz>g$.w. f2d ~W+ ;;LZM>QM Rm/_mm¢l‘yzm~e§,.¢)¢;swzd

‘W\ !(Te><, chem App ‘m:z);:m;\\~@r'_ v'.l%+a+e, 244 3.w.,'~?zz‘zzzg;;,.§2¢7
{'T€XA§ £,¢~\sm.prpp‘ \45|3)\»,&@“; w?\| §th +h£. `@ouH' 9\'\&
9\>\\0\»~>`\03 ; - -- '_ _ l -,

` '_Hq€. (L>mf“\"\f\¢\$ “\'9|€. Gb\‘\+\e.m9>'l .And jgr;§drc+¢`on 1b
hear “\'h;$ peH‘H¢>n; $€S\'~- f;>~'u\"\‘ I(\ '%¢TCXQ$'£OQ§\€‘\'¢,\HDQ
P\`f“\"\(‘.\f, 5, $u\)$é£\';or\ C 3 -'Te.>`§"‘r\r\;n ¢\ £r}ml`rm\ wage 'af\d$ubj€d”
190 a\\ majr\'ec§_;:af’r issue or ebrr>rqpp|¢‘cab\e, and +h€-
"Hb\,\ee. D¥ D§§Féréai"\on“ by J"udge. (Pau\ `E. wh\`\'~c) shall
ho\p\ c>c~ <‘.\A"\~m,' ' ` . l ,- .
T\r`\£,. \5699\’;1>9\6;¢ ‘\€> ;\'\ (`e,\l\`€.u.) 59 91|\5 Cr`l`v’>’ll`r\df(zm§é

Ml~>- @R"Z"/q 74'~“9 (P¢nd;r\g DLB¢‘H' 09 H'abeq$ Corpus) I‘V\ "H'\€.
\Sq+h Tuo\\`c{¢l\ `D¥§\'r‘\\`<:\* C¢>m~\" ibm which (Tudge [P¢\u\ \dhi'{'e) ~‘:='

\ o
/' '
/.

\ 15 90 ~Drde,(f §hou.>'cau\§_e` hearing and pne\frh}'nar>/
9mc9n35 ;w`\‘,\*h fe`la+or` "sl`re 91`£1`¢1»“., ¢Rel'a+or"`$ .pe`HHen
'r"eq,uea'fs 4 nz>n-b:`a$ Judl‘c,f¢\\ 0'991`€69 w`i+hin as
alma procc$% 09 law and 9unAamen9al weakness regya?re,.
.The. ferc m-c_fl‘\"l`c>r\ `juc\g€:(\)\!h`\+e)) mus+ be A"i$g,ualhaied.
ID:

?6\:\‘\#; oncv 3§\/€,$ 'H)e '9>\\0\,¢}¢°13 as 9¢36\‘19/‘¢'>01, +h@,
record, \'\c>.\a\\`ng Al§¢},ua\;9ica9`on or recusa|:

_ . ' |L`Dn`G*B‘ 20/1?~¢ pc'h‘?"/`Dner 911£5[ 'ka }qpf.>€¢?| |)~M`H'l é\

' Y`E»CM?>Q\ mc>'Hi>n. wn`+hin. UA@€.¢L\>N‘I'E¢)ACC£¢P+:€A
mcma\ on B~l'B~ZDIz.b>/»|e++er ‘Pr¢>m ;p@+?fh'>n-¢r,,,
-0¥\5[ »FCSPDY`\¢\€A %»‘-'ZD~’ZDIZ. 54 ing 916 wo`u.,\¢\' .,

send 97 Sen‘;c>nd R_eg‘f¢>na\ Hdmim`§.+_m+f\/¢ £oart

>` iZ. J-"uc\`ge (L\)h`\'\*e§ "abuseol_ his ¢}i`s,z:»v'¢ec\_'i’¢`_¢),r\j3 by a'ch`nj

` `L\»r\/,\ 'is$u`\r\§\:rv:]qnyf orders during appe')`\_a+£», . :.;
»rev\`eu) durin§ iq-\jemmv.~¢c.~uea\' un‘?r`\\» neiml/)/
issued re9e.¢m.\ c>vder ¢>r\ 2*7-/4.

3., HAA;MCM\ z>bj¢¢’r`._@ns me made on 8~5- 20)3,~
,lzz'/;-.-zeis 5 .5“27--21>)4~.. _ j , ' v f'

49 -SE..cc>nA recu§a\ is 9¢'1'€¢{ on 5‘27~-2®)~4) wi+h a- ‘

_ - . 'pcnz);v\3 969\‘91`@0 For~ D§Sé\”€.ah‘onm\)/ \chl`ér.oNo.

_ (wQ-g\,z¢)o~l).

_ 5. TPIE Sec;orm) Prdm`\m`s‘\'m+l\/e UT,\A)'c-Ta\ ch"i§`i>`f\ 39 . "
_Te»<.¢\s- &enye¢\` obj@,dn`on 3~3~ ZOH) and $f»f\+ ¢m'
DF¢\CF C¢>GJf;nuing _ /juz\ic\`a\ "abu$c b9d,r`scr‘e¢\9`o_n`:

§§ P€\"\)\'.¢\ojnex‘ 9`\\€¢\1»5¢§\’ 139 9m\>e0\3 Cz>r§>\.\$ bn
6>'\'7-‘21>!5 ,»,\>H+\ Dbjed'¥or\ or"mrm\`nfjo§}`ech$>/\"f

~~ 7.9€9\\';¢>09\€.¢\ and appe¢\\ n@\'\`é,e an '7~27~20!5-11/0m
;. (znbl>‘om\e»mny§n§ nbjw¥?m ama Q¢_<.M\°

._ 29

\ _ ‘Pei“`r¥:c>neir ‘ is "\n'¢>\d:n ‘[S+ruc{'um\' or O"ud§"c,{a\"-Gr~éwrt)s
` 599 ‘th€é\$ Cr>,r‘p\,\$ Pe,+`\;\'h_>r\' Z-' SEE:'}GN>¢.\M ND'.J,`_,-dfl¢\ a$l<$ -jl'b
Pr‘c_>h\\ 919 ‘Sa\\:£l Dbjea\'cA/Qez;u$ed §Tud§e. (w_h`\+¢> 9¢DM‘;}-hé,
.heav"m '0\9 S\m>fw.c¢\u$e w?¥h\`n‘ rie,\a.¥@r`s case)‘a$
.\Tudg ,» ‘wh§'\'e\ has "¢lec,\§ne. 9> reLu\S€.?` t'h§’mse<\:{l_»a$
S;La\'eo\ s`n Cc>\,\r“r`$ Le}r‘fer,’,c>_d ZI”.,\\\/ l3, 2015. `
P£§H’r'§@ner' fem`mds+he, Cm,wjr-: -'.\'a)res 4a manda+¢> 59¢1\'149<>¢>/,"0!11'97/ "n>_ei+he.r recuse
br ¢*"S¢w¢\\`\¥`y him§e\" -r>»~ dev a ,.mUHO-+D M»$e.r
I'n ve N¢>¢m¢n,\¢\\ sms-3d 333 (T§>¢npp~-Hw+m\j¢+h v,‘$+]
»2§>0&,); mr\\e',v vt s’ra¥e, gap S.u).za 243, 247(T¢X,cs;é¢»app;`i<)¢')s>;"€
.D\sz;u\R9f'ca9fon ma a'?"|'r‘;z\\?l'u¢\ge~may l>¢, raised a+._£m)/
,."‘h`ma .' G\c>m'e.z v. S+a‘re', 737 3‘“3- 2d 3'.5'('£7”@<"'@""'“?"HPF;""¢"’M)"
Prm“c>\A' -\-;` »§\'Aire; 353 .g_ mt 124 543 {Tex. Cm`m.' pr. 1»)443)3 ;L\)§.| son ,_
,¥L§\I§»,L¥FTS.M>. 2d 374 (Téx. C,m`m. -P¢pp.-=i¢l¢l€); E.X .P.Arte': Le¥¢>re,$,
_ l‘”zl.'\”e,x.g\.m 22q,347 s,‘w.@\'z`§+{)%)); : m-+ `\'/. S:L' 4:+@,.4.>_+25,,5.:
1». w WB&M z+»g'z+s~z¢¢(m. pr.-,- HD»{§+»~LTM?D"$B
mez);»zzx pm+e. v;vfer, 1044 s,w.;-Q¢z, 84»3(1&><..@¢.-»»1.¢4,>@.~:¢)35) f
holding 61 wr`H' 09qu warrani'o is +he eni means `
+p.c\m\\\m\g& '+he,~.au+hc,>r#`a{'>/ 09 a Au\y_-c,~|e¢+ed.di $'»1‘"_:¢119
\,‘Mge_.j ' ' ; _.; .
TML\§`C~(PQH\E_. u)\'\`c\'e.> )`§ 39 cbandn§€,ci . '
` £Annan;’> Pzr<9r>rm;n3%e;'Dl/C'H€$ 09 . ¢
’FM}&;&\ 999;(,& Impar‘.'Ha\\ O\MDT\`\,§&HH)@
-» 'B.Mj /`.¢Q-Hv¢ ree§ppn$i'lsz *+Fe$»¢ -»
" @) n judge QMH hmrar@¢\ecic¥€.¢m\fl-;cs
ae§`cgned +D~¥+\eju¢\§e,`\§xcep§ +\n@s&_ 4_ .
_~fn»w\m`@,¥\ Ai§%_i€q°imi*ionis_'r‘eq,u.»`f\'¢\ ..
a)r` ¢Fecum\ is appropriod_'¢, , ,

 

3.

“Pe,-’r`\"‘r`\\one,r §§v`e,$ +\ne. Dc§g`m¢>\”\?\`_¢\\ Re,a>m\s as » '
‘Pac.‘\'a @f`? 5'24°'21>9% "H'\e.' P&+T*\’;oner"s arra`ig¢nm¢,n-\' was
\he,\¢\ zin' ~Hwe, 'ZWH'z` U'\>\Alc.`m\ "D¥e‘m`¢i' &>»\¢~'\'., ~SEP;‘. R~ep@¢~\ei~`§`
,Q,»_»,w¢\ (_v.>\..-z[ EAS@ 1~5) 'HPP@»\ ram ~l,z¢»s-`Dpz¢d~ N¢>. 0004, com /prm| A!'¢. 04>`-)2-02>)1>¢;362
,@.D.H.Tmr\¢»anc\fl'exa$)» - - ~

’ :E$§u€, 9 `The "Zl’/"Hq §]:\A\`c.;'a\ 'Dc`s+f`l`a.+ L`_DW’+
_,w;.\»\.\ ;)‘L\AS@, Barc '\:`b<\/an) he\A -H'\e. Prr‘r‘a{§nmef\\' v
_D§q+h D;S‘\'f“\`c.‘\" F,@LM"\' `D;o\ f\)b`\':\,) ‘.H'\L\$ "H'\€» 2l”7~l-h v `

‘bg`§i’m\c,\j.@,our'\' \m>\./,\§ j»\¢*§s&¥c.¥`\on z>\)e,<` +he, mee
and 'pe=HHE>n-ex`, ' . _ ., :
\/€.r(r\e"n`epmns\?x¥'€¢\ T'exaé £e¢\e. 09 Cr}m.¢\rm.\ Pnc>ce¢\u¢`e _ `
"9{'9¢\0\€. '+.\[p Concur‘r-e,r_l"r \Tur“}s¢\ ;¢9`00,""3%/¥\2¢1(2)¢)1»6 v
' E><~ rm¢>r~a`@c'mri's have aea<;urcerr\i")ur}§¢),`¢+§¢n §§ »- »
‘ , An>' c,f"§m\m\ 599&\(\6£,., H'\£, @J>ur"‘r"j[n- L\)h\"c.\'_\.Prjr_\ _'
In¢\§ér-mcn'\' c>r' c\ Comp\¢\§r\‘\' 1;$ Hle/)\, Sha\l',ge”\z\§r:\ l
l Fuv;e¢\'§hj9c\on,`eX6£-p'9 a§ pm\h`¢l€A /\`n 'ar‘=\'. 412“57_'€)¢4$ *
CO`nZM'a/\"\'\\of\ H*"\_"‘"-\ey:) § l'Z(b>:"'/+"\€. prcsen‘\“men+ ’ 9 ,
` 09 ar\_`mo\§c’rme.n‘r ves+s +he 'c,¢>m<\' ' '
, _ v \,\)P€¥\`i\,\<~§e&§c?@on @9'.'99\€. ca'us€,,“ ~
'-rh@ 4`»:\¥03 941 :M\,:dm€.n*v §§ e§¢n+¢\ z~.> vest-w
'\T; A\-¢c>u¢\‘¥ w`r\'h_$_`\\)\\";%€\§d\'l\on &V€~.(` Qe\on\/ O\c\e€"l$&,
` &@D\< v. s+@écej, 402€»,1»)‘.24 4‘1\,475'{1@><.€~`@1\&;>;>‘iq"/S)’J_HQ¢_\_‘*ZB< r
j?g¢_r,- 1574 <:>.~\». 24\'7'72, 77q /T@x. cp;m. epp. \qqs)j .M‘.\.\e¢ v, Sizdz,
994 §;w.M~SBIp,}§¢)z,(W./}p;» AM¢H/» )445 nwpek); Pr A\\€,+m`¢%
(;D\M`A has h£>`;\/\C‘{SL\`LL)F;C>D t>\)e,{` 6\ C.§"\m{m\ case
ur\\"\\ ,.\>ce,%en\'ec\ wPr\r\ on §¢\A{d' merd' or :`m{k?o rrY\A{'l`o/\.

 

 

wqu v. 3121+¢, 41>\ 3.,\».2¢\ 75'\ Er¢><~¢\pp, ww;+m[w~m D:D
\>¢\f‘~ rea 5 'Flore§ v. s+@+@,;\gv s,w. 24 )zz,/zz/vzx, &,‘m.App.
14 72/>; @im‘\>e_r \(. %\zxjra,[p[p"l S.»\x). 261 6>||) &>l?z[@<,p,n¢;~mm 149,1;)°

46

I@§ue(%§:*rhe,1541>.‘§+~‘¢+ C¢w~+ e.>n ma any

~ ' '~`or‘A&rs' ¢\ur~`»r`\g appe\\¢\*re.(re.cusq\) is egregious
1 harm upon .pe}r"\'~h\¢>ncs"§ .oev?e,u¢_ .
"I.'h€, 1549 `D\\§i'm`z-'i 39»""9(?¢\\)\\1’:.\»¥\{¥¢) xei'\i`ng Awume'n’rs ` 9
wjr [§\@;\ we par w wh is ~P¢~M\ , ma $w\\ w '.~ez~.;nz\¢¢\

» ' H\\ exams @m+£ \»Sq+h 1>;§+.~.\3¢ cover
h ‘. 4 ~QRE \h>_m'. j »
'T\'\\`s SHDM\A ng\'~'b'e, conpuz~>se¢§ w»"’rh '+he. $I+uc\'h`c>n‘whcre.`
-_h~\`q\ cc>»w’\" has jur`\s¢\§ch`on evev+he +ype. mo case B»c\' -
hug ‘e`§sued m \fo€&‘Brz\e<", Pz>=gj§<` M. §lf`,g,\g ) 388 '§.u>. 20\
q@q C'\'"e><.'\q£)*¥), Th@.| 59+}1 I)s`z+n\c‘:\' @ou.r’r ¢\ees HavcjurF$~
A\`¢H¢n Dve.c~ va ¥ype, 99 m$@,,\>v€r ¢m\ M‘DT HD\D
.Pr_r‘r*a\\gnme,ni" Hear}ng 90 1\/¢<‘>+ J`»\r\`s¢\ \`a‘n`c>n over' _.+h,‘$
wage-fund is A¢`§QM»` fed cafh¢\\zeA$-¢Lc>rp¢\$cc»uf~`\i
*F\r\e§¢‘£,¥c>re i'he,? 'l S‘I~H'\: Z|T,¢% 1`¢"4\ D¢`§FF¢Z+ £wr"\' or .+he

ano__m\b\e', Pa\,\\-E. wh§\'£,_, 115 w;`~}he»€\' `)\uf`;$¢§t`é+l\‘>n `Q\/€F
”P&h}"‘>n€`f)re\a¥w`z cause and $\'\q\\ -n@+ad' a$ju¢)`»`<;)\¢\l
Q`Hl\\c.ex-§ lw\"+}iu\n ha\>&a§‘¢arpu$, dna L\€`> PPDH\\\>H'€¢\ `i'€>
369 herea{;\"er\ upon peHHoner`s cause 9 PeHHOn@'F` 'PQ">'§ l
¢H'\\`€> L\)N"\'* DF S\,\c> b\§a<*raf\‘§l:>' be 341\9£¢§ , I,G\\H'\ An>/
deuva ~t‘eme¢\\\cs 'H\A\' -H'{a C;>u¢~+ AMSJ`u 3'\“ also
be gr~m*ved', $c;er 5.43\12\ .“. ; -

  

»3,1¢3:5€;\ v B~'+~ 2\>1-_5;

/WELD@,¢Bm/GE"S
Mwn\\e\;n nw .unH~
_ y ' ' v Q‘DSS' $p\,\(` 521 l 9
@&9;`£. ' ' - ,Ama(` \\“ol'-[E|>LQS W/D~§
CzG.£,R.RKWSHH '
\'§4\%\

Th¢' pe*\'§\'§`me,(‘ ask "~Hne 496 f`*.."+f>_ M\"\_/€f~ 'H“»¢

FW;MA n@da<»',@p;'e;%_ Pe.r~:~*r“e.><. R.HPF,P. 613 ,' "
, QMBMEP_F;;M;»;_

_ jj .NEL\>DL>B¢~¥A§¢$,_AO hereby @C»v\'hcy +h@d' ¢\ 'f?~u'e;
_ AFW\ 69{`(`£1;!' copy 59 ~qu. h)&`c"\' DF@D\.L\> l)\)af‘r`cu/C\j'g~}'m§ '

g£)rf\' A @QP>/ '{-o\+’f\e.`T¢"\`A\Cou("J[`)Ar\A no ‘(")‘Dr-‘w¢\rzl$
, +h@ D¢:%;m\ '+D +he Q\er\<~ -Hb@,) ew$+q V.,:¢,
~IM&`§€H\'_ § `E>u\>{>\_>/_¢:\m\ “Eo`f‘e+ <;\A¢>é man ' . '

 

r' Mn$w¢("r\ M\é\(u¥"\\o(\ . ~'
j:, wé\AOi/\Bf`\\AQ-€,S{TYDCI~I"D¢/§'SS'§DS} b€i`, _' garage ,d'b[
inm¢cem{'€o\ \`_(\'+he k\¢i‘\’mm`e\$ A)€¢J NnFF, lo<;§€da"}'
§95’5 §pur S'¢Il~iqrmr-¢`HD,’IE>r\~ 6'4'?0)§ %/@%o%,@/