Court Opinion

ID: 4058663
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 09:14:57.250645+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:05:24.626772
License: Public Domain

v C-@W+ OS€ (\p\>~¢¢¢\§ “?P%S §+\\ P‘p‘>`(\\qw D"$\,(`d Si)\'th Distric'i
-, \_q_\, l nw
t m T“"$ yJuL 0 1 2015
` ` zr‘z.z€.§~;w&m m
T\\~c §~M~‘r‘c OSK `Y~¢X¢\_S Th: Si;?!?§izséi\r?cp;eals v Te)‘-t.\\av)¥j %{~'\.(§,_

l +\"‘ DFP*“¢“`*' 3d \~\~‘c “\sw~¢ ¥)+\~¢»Q C¢w$‘c r\)o.`s:) m{\+,,“ E»\ww& Cc\Ms
\'\~c<"c\d:> v\Dwr_ ~\-o v\a\£‘¢ \~\~~¢ $a\\aw"hg C\q\:\¥'.aq`\.»_o,\ D`\,',_ m3 gep~¢\\qv§\»$ B€'vc`§'»

\
f _ O»\ \-\¢c E"' H"E\@_‘-a-_.? \D~ &0\1:' l 5./\3\-’,\-\-~{0\ m3 %r",t"- <\h¢\ 1 \-\~{v~¢\>¢:) moot
§ ‘\‘0 Q$\C ~\“\~~L COm~-\' dh&é§ ("W)\\L~¢ $urv.. ~\»\\,L.`, q_\.\»,$ C_om,_\, »‘S No-\~ Bap§°ool\t¢§’
B‘C'\+ \<'\0-)¥\ § 1 \Jas \\)04~ 4 Fvg{-‘\~'~/“¢ ¥wm $u§‘.¢e *\r\\,u\-\»¢\¢\ \-\-<_s~<.
OMJ"°("“\S C#\“`*"'W@\ ‘\)0+ \.., m3 \~e‘w\ \Oh,\ C_omg'>\~c+f&\» rW~€'qum-./g+z¢° `\3»3 ‘c'\'_-;
C‘_~\¥B ©o\\,*¢.c gm 0\ ;(»W 1 \MM,\ @\»\ Q',+3 v.¢\<»¢+ q\s@. vr>w\ o‘¥¥~v <‘14\5
Q.ov\'\~ac¥'m_»j ‘r\~.‘¢ `\'~d~a§ %Mw\ o§ 94¢,)\,0“$"`:}§>4r.§\%$ Q‘DW‘)\ *\'\'\»1:\':» q$ §`\"d"t&
»\M\ \,,h§ amphsz mg ?qw\`¢ q»~> svc\\ w‘l> A"»P\>¢w.,\,¢g w\¢.$>@»\ w C@'\+¢M\ =“ W"+ ">"“ *"\"3)9~\\'3

~Y\~n+ ~\-\-cg w\wm gov-m ¢+YA\ Xs:> a£-§'.<_'¢QL> M`:km;\"\j c\\~rvs~‘cx T\'\~¢r~¢gw»t:,wm
Y\W+ ¢1~{:¢§`\~‘\~‘“)~(/v as 5¥4*‘¢3\ A-& SS ""'\\~L :\JA&"( 4"\;\ COu~/"( OY\X\\<
Q_\~,W_,i §§ va'.\\.~_§ »w X_,§>‘ O“\§ g L\azg §§ v\'»sA‘¢mv\»¢ Oi`=£z:\_$;<.'

 

 

 

 

(Pq§f\¥

BL`H' ("_'\~car\b \ +\\ se
v v G~Qj`dc.\£ S \5-¢‘¢¢/\3 .O_oh$+a-.+l:] O_a\\r& 01)`\' O'\ %°3"‘$ F¢lm'llb vav>‘\"

C.QU; a~»w\ §§ ’
i¢mo$:` $\S( q$$q"))"'$ q%a|°“§*` Qo\>~jr\ “au'\.n`j \\»¢r c~<~c'\” b‘<» \:>¢:A\:) ch»\l~m
\\ b ¢) va WA bn qvw$§'€‘x R~e£w~\\~zs; §§ +\~~¢ Po\"¢‘c UP”"‘ *\"""“ $°‘“'1
f ` 1
vt a \:) Swo\'\`('h \{5'\ € Q`<°"\' \`\OW`CUQ(` UPJ»\ ~¥\r\~¢m Y~€q_\/'W§ `\“"\~(,£'\v~$+’ ;\"\m‘<

q g l 05 /‘ » 0 ' \ ' \

, h \A q X \'\`( 0"5¢ 5$“"3 5§)¢\'\€;\ S\\‘g, 5“\~¢1'\»(¢1 A»\M\-\r '\*\'~“¢ \"\Y>"»m\ R`zco~°§
WOU ©FQU"C SUL_\,\ ~Q\*om ~Y\-L u¢$p'r\»-q,\ \\»¢,,.¢, `\v\ G('~C€`v\u`\\\`(,. \)M'\ `\""*£..\(' le&
0\\'('\\94\ qv,§ v»(,+urn :)Y‘\’\\X»-ov\ E.Aw¢m)\ C;\’\$o§ Q`.> I_\Dt Y*WSS‘¢\Q' vu/\A was

Jf'\““{/"\ “YN§V&A \D¢G ~\/\\..¢ Q;cr“£v\o'¢\\~'¢ ©0\‘,»¢-.~( S<\>`§ . \»O`\~\/\\v v`\' dv_»_¢g ~c@/r"» 0'\"¢1»
`)'“ C" A‘”W\~\/ \.)\~m+§o~(wt r. 1 ~\Yu,,-\/\\~¢./ \-\~¢ ./P;\Y §~\~/l+‘c \)h>\“tf '0¢\*\\ °v\'\q~\-:

me\/ER \[\\\~¢w ~\/\\4,~\/ guc\\ \rwn‘l b-c¢cv\ F_h\m¢n¢x& \.)v\*('a\ P\\:TE.B \»\r\~¢

S‘CY\`\'%\.W c,'¢® qm§ mfg r’~cC,c‘w‘.\/:,) q C@{>'j 0{' Svc\\. mg S§wv\~¢g \\Mm~
E'~\’°¢/V` ma /\‘L 405 'W/\~Ylom 059 403 Ex\\mv\cc m‘m§/ §C\”'w§ \ l+ wa§‘\* O'<\‘v`\

1 Q‘S\/~$-A q\>@v°r ~\/\'\~€. EXU$¥S§'LU'C_ 300 §¢35 non q C,\a$g §§ m‘.§)\='¢m=cm_~o- ~\-o

"'15 C\%>rom»c§ ALA \~.‘¢ §*m+¢ »r\w+ zuck \MA \>¢‘»»1 P_»\\m»¢¢& \~@ q <,;455$<.
'\»\)h~c\r\c§@ r~¢ l '\>\~ea}`c§\ Gv'\\~\-_¢) ‘{-a,@ Sv¢:\/\ Eh\~.nn¢~¢r~\~cw\' Uh\’\\'\vwv“§ § l
bw\wv'~c,¥m<,. \5\\>¥*1\\¢1.»»+ @m_‘y ~Y\\‘.§ @aw/T""R°’\‘(§ "\‘\ \\`-> xka '\

C`C\”‘\"-§'¢C~.:\': §§ S~e<\)\ct

 

___-do

l m`l\'\'t'|'\ G('.:)SS “1¢~[\33 3*_4“ \>[\A%/ Oq~\,\` d" go'\’\\ Q(ha\`,:)::%:`vcj
`\_\"“\' d `§{ut_é\ Cc)r<"cc'\~ C,o§>\_§ o-Y*.“pp¢\\qn‘rg moved &0»/ Q\ar‘.¥'.€a~\"}or\ b‘£r
_\'\‘,5 “P’P¢'\\"W"S %V'\`CS’ \\0> \L`C"CV\ 'C‘Drwam)\`(v\ \3_9 man "\'0 +\\'15 `AO'W"¢\°\`¢
BPP`M\S CD‘N+ 0"` `\'\""5 3~0\'\\\ van 0`\* §w\~; Q`O\S.
R\’$\>‘C<\'§v\\:) S.J\Qm`.%~cl
\"\`\\+ov\ V~Aw§_r_§\ Cv<'\€>;\,$
/Huv\+ C_ouv\`\'§ bq`t\ ¥FQ`S“I£\\
9~€0\ 5‘\'4\)(`\' §+'

Co\`~c~( »\L>'\\\~L *\_X-
"15%<>\

( 'P‘lgjc,. ‘D`\