Court Opinion

ID: 4055573
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:12:33.173232+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:26:48.542217
License: Public Domain

ORIGINAL                                         .• ;

 #&*£

                            £****- V/* XL'*i*& r^+w^

                          -flefSfs//z/e' t/u- father//
r~!
      ?' uJo e^W (/ SfAf& S.M).-3P-2e/Z 7e**/?PAlfxiz Z*£?
         L Ttr* -dPP-P}uS7/>U /?Paz //- ^^/z

      6. CAtde&Ai u z,t*r-
        £/P>fisz J44&X  iks/a/j^t
      £< S7/dA?Z**<*/< SuP*:* //tt€.S/rf///rfez // £r*-fer~ 9%$ S.)*j.
        <£ P   77c, 77P Sfcs*s Ya?. /?/*/* /#?)

       fc///#e      ^7/£^**sf #66 U5.PS 6$7)

      n~ /?&rk£ #zpz 7$)-fe)

                                     ¥
                 ^7^/^aU/^A 07*^Ate            £p?S£~
/#/ /kiZe>/£- 7/iy's &luz£ /Zs /*,// /'c/z sf />&&& pi/a,/ A
/7ua£^ Tidriif/vg -6&aJ u/*'\/&A £y dr/f*^^//9f/£A/aA/A/tf/f. *>?X
p/>e&^*"7//?fp&//iAsr /fspfe^f^A /f/i A/f*p>7 il6u//f A tfkeJlu&*
*A /3i444&**'*7 p 78a/7*/'"3 Js /?//ppeZ?*7C 7
                 s' /Trtf '0U/7/Y A*r ft's £*~sf PZ p>a<*5/*A£Az/<"5> j? /c£*-f ?-//
£e/!\[£Jit£/?£P Zf*^ &v 7~/tge>u)/*>s /? £ec/^ ppAiau^^ pfe $/*ss A?«tf p*jr&A2A*tf r*
*>rfA>/ c/4Atff+fe£>- #nPr zPtfKL prre*i s. //P. /f./s; ///, 7c). /// a#>S' MP*a jfe/**?-
€) . Pad'#/*S ZP£/€*-*&4r 01/gAZ. rf g/tt/ef' A?A2j>7**f*og' S^/Zp/Acrsr •'£#. &•* s .?Z ^fceZc j£f
aJ &&A> # P/u?r7 7/iA>r AtSu/r&P /,? r/s f&e/HSASsr*/*AJ *-7 Ass /^Us***^/
rertS f/sr W*/r*s&sor/p/'/?zr//t*r

W£> the 7>*f jftfi* dnJ jP/sc "t/A&Mr£Dt/££?&Z'7&+r Af *j#s- lA^rs? ptfr-foA/isfJUlf
t /}/&>*»/ A?f ft* 7?* /./?•//< ?6 'P^fs1 - us /v/***' /h/iottM*^
U us#s -A*£/*/•$ tf AfASA/ftf pZ**f£ 9/ -//&>** 7Z */11 /%> o pi> s^/**rr/p*)
V^^x -XjjPacaZ/£/zaV&0 . t/f-Jf. ^J.
                       Zl^^/nf^ 73t//tpmsif<2- A

/. t7p sr^P* A*J9*9^/4 ^A/f&'**-
    tinA f6*z /eePct/'ff AZ^f*Afs/*vr/spp'/p/Z<*«A/.
                                       T
      ^r^r^T=> US* *Z ArW^a^£^yu***^            «P*AZ* Xx/P?/e/*<" ^s^/as 7Z
         iC 7grt Y/^s" X014/>/Z/5>oa)/u£aJT SpSSf/PiAjr j£*/s*r /?PAAA* *p X/e^'Z - . . .
PPPe/k^f &>/!f,« ?fe as* ef fry stfro^Cp^
PP/O ZfCPPoAi /2 />#£*£. f*£*f) L P£#AtoA> P^?) tfPso 5P£C/&C A^S&U'SSorfS X %r-X. &cfe £#?/«„ X /fAJAJ A/erAePs
fZ^ $s.k>~iJys&ppf*.A?Asp-/it><**7<>>i> )
^ / si r /i>t4P /%. pPfS, 0*r $sz**r*X. perAePe tppz sees***) PS a£*4tsSAZfs. 76*
      f/lltisP £oa&r f» 5uSa?*aas/Z6f S*A>fca£t X**/t***X tf«Pe& SeAA-Anix a2-35 6*-) **PP*>J
TheeePc^*. fr/Z r/i* 5 as P&aPPzoP* &v&eA?jm/*
/Z-.tZ 5ee,ft**f /Z.SSC^) al«P(6)&»*7*«/ Vv£*e. Pa^taX^ /Z*fZ 76/4 £s$u£ as AP^soAue^P
£// sii4ftCaz° 1/ $r&r& . . 76us ZeerbA/ /z.fz fP) faAfA/or p,r tfseP r& psA**** al s>7*r«s aZ-3£ P*J - (&) qjvutcP D-/-6f//z wA2.£
Gotets.*! 7k€ seAJftMC* X»i*ose*P r/te 77e./*S Pou^r A?/&zed P?£Cai*S£ /^*S7^P* A^P^AfjeP^ot
pasrP/z/oAis pppPsAe/e-r g,P #ua,Ps/>/s/u5 js Zevtet rfe X/05r£#eA-/t><*s fr Xs-
#*&***{ CenS/Pu/fd a? P/U*?<£ Ph*2a?S/cj* meAfSce^* usltfS It */v*YAiJ* ^/f/tX/p/lv&VA&d PA*>/tf0 Xrarur^Y */*au*a/7^ X
bu&dtrf ef A 6uM~aa6 dash? 7?Pais /t*> ^ aPo*M*pZ PP A /%*? ^ P^amP #/
\IlolPdtX fiP pPuPPbs? ef Xve.(Zcsrs/*s& r/if P?s>Sf epYtasA /et/*7 £//%P*z rP*e Se-rtfe#eAA$
gtmskPf*** MC&uS* 7/*7 PUP£*£Sa*£Aa)Y Xt(\Po/U£ USP eZ PApS/foP /%&*
flZMtjsr 7k* A>*/&So*j &f /?**//&-£ tP.S.S.% i         2- M Z*/ M     {«) C*-) y 4 A-Z P^)x /$
 a.'b.c-a,*   \j.T.c./Q. Z*aa*/&*/*

titofelt A*/iPai'ZoJ* A*"P. £etf'e sPor Z^u/if^/eAAT p^> r/* /*tPf/r-Xttjefrnrcf
pp^M A s7~*-'r*J*-i( -/*/**"Y Pe> sic/A^p/oil 7^ /*> J>*#Ze tf/*/r«.cP<*Aj7~s XtSf/AsJr'****?
% # Secwrf s/*?<£***.' ^00^/61/ U 5>P^P* Sx P/~2o/z . .. . .

                                            ^
                               1?j:*j7~ &A        £&&**£.
      ^ -                 ^          T7Z7

b*/"& A A»6fesL* /7*^eY -^o£.S?ecT~ A? l/to/f&r P%?A££* 66**/XeM*4pSQsA&
 AZ*/e#Z/''W7 aZ 7*/p Pkf^> XS iPAJ sP/P/fX7f#/ u>P<6»"7 Z^Y -/?p/2/*/?&, o^e
      A/*/''*aPa?a'7 tPoctPtP t>Z DbPeZrtrz/ £ A//*f*^?^ ApP?fusV*«'f as *-
£*jiS>onMt Zedac-ru*) Z&** fstiAfeac*. $*?: dsL/d*£oAL p, s/St/^, %*7 s-u^. 2,cf
3 7 7. 3?3 CPeycXPP-ePA^So P4<73Jt AP)a? A*f. rAftfe u/*s a965o>P6***£f 4/s hfis-t/AfcAcX s2'&6r P* s?ede*s 71 rte Ae^^rs
Jbv At /ups"$ h»* A*J sizteiwcre fato J/6aZaazy- aQp/ rAf /** A»e>Xs a?p 7~/tf ah/Z^juZ
 XPt-l'/ uaP£* PUT *fA?7*A/ rfq/tA/v /7*Ae*iPaAj7 tcPfctteP #/ £>6P*tr* /PP/efAYS**}

Courtse/s Am/ua?? 7* fi^Pecr a*k/ sttAt/Af P^sbt^^i p£e 5>ranPa*zP'j> P?*a/py p£* t?Out/A&*& Ct>u*&P up*s c/**/£& Jft^& rf*7 &j4*"^*&*pt
U$>fp7'afeeWQ 5AsJrA/U6/PP3 To Za/AsipoPs? P/pp £r<*f*JziA T^&sUP 7z> A
t5*CcAJcfZ7*$/e** uPtfS PuTSas/* 7%* paaJ f/Zpc7PtPA a^A/ZFaZ S*A) P^YPoa* aas
A APoAdzLAPP*/ &u&* 3~$ ^VA/uP*r*t/ ePtfzJpp? 5Pa ajz7/?azP'p?/£r/d&Par*>Z'pA
^>Ac^A^7i£uA?p&s? p/^TtPPtsss/fz {/>cr^r* $$$• S^zzA 77d. 77P(
 £TeK*s £a2 XAAXM^J £>is*g P^hPaaaO ftif a£Zs*aa*P?PP aXZ^a^uA- SPAts/as^A*

tf&ZMJudrz, 41 ? S.oJ.zA VrDz/'Z Ccp+/*& 'Sr/^^x^^ cP^^sPY-
6'87)CPY*S rt#f r/t*PZ* Pz A A^AsrSoAJ^t?/* 7°pZoP?a?yp?p/Z/X rZ* ^Sc^Y
A/ 76* Cz^S* ttPouPcZ 6aipA 4?*r
P?AA /of? AHPlVPA\ X'&t*- APAe£>6Ac&AP'ASy S>ct /^A £*>*JA- zP^Xy^^S^A* 7'^*'
              7%*- /z>p}ZpcZ*p?aa' m pfa 7>AsrZaAfA*

                                             to
                 7%* &7***£'•*•    P&'ii'&P^-*    £~>&/e:e   ^Z~akst2*z*a?& tPs^X #Pt>/*g u>fCi p&Y /Z&Y+'Z P^PPeAjy Ptswar&A
 fp A^/l^flZe /^stssfrMYaST *f zfc-f*«P*{"-«PY' AeAlvtCfeXPf 4 SY^T^P^rP f*pPi>#Y ro
  A -z ^Ap^ap z*A«r*

DY -Y*itttZAMZ#Y Ar/cA*«A~«/rApPJ*f//a.AsY J* y6y 3£         Mp    X £>c7>P>*e* Z<>A3 **r*P* £3,
CgnhALuz**Ae<(Ar A*f**X#*sr vj*s Cohu/zy*^ X AtfYzAaseH s>A P>u/PaPaaa& /k^ss a/*a?36 vff
At-frY/Z ztefr/hP*"*' />&'**- Co/ivfZst*"*s us*s AazoPy&'y usrep 7Z> *a b*"£Y 7-6**6***?^
 6f£**tst£ A/Uha. SYalY Pf-cf P*/**** % 3 —a/*7*Z*Y ZA^P 76f ^*,*€£ Aa/to/esYo4i
fautP aJ<>y Ay z/sy7 4?Y US**/*"*»£ AAU/>d#Z*AHA?A/7~£ _z:aa
  A//7*£*dpr Z)azos*c*s£/as^ .

//*je.AAHa1op£P*>s; haas. AAoP?*A/!P us*yA & AA7>**ee pAtT
flh&AfA of-ftts* Zee** ST^rYP^t/ 7*&"Y 7° Al 3^-zZ*<3Y?ZZ 7*/^^ 7fe Saj«*
CeALvtCP-PoAP Ce*l*P fp&Y P>Y USftA A4*M 7o A^A/uiZ* X*AA'«eS*'jrs~ Y^ha/zsA/uYaaTs \
&A<&7* /s A»7 *?*<£sxaj
 APIA PP £*-*** sAA€o$Pe*ArbY&PA~«'r A+s* ^A* 17/^/ffY^rA APZ**zA/"/r au7s6sP pAy A?/zcP&4?
 £*?*{ £i*/Ae/'**s pv us** MPtuYe r*> 00 a?*p ZuAzrAasdY 7/fYA> * 3&A *?
 SYiYYcPjuAZua/sPtisefY A         ^r^sYiP^P pA^P A&*s Paa>P^YY 7Ai>sy AP/usrs T^Y£f-
 Z*eY dtr&rHP^fr± dz>A}&*A'e' 76*r Sct/e^JAt/e*/ ef £lu~/y//A3^C?~a/ a€*S/?^t72> a?
 c^*^ z7A3/£A* Z*/*w pPisettsbPiPAtJr 7o PfPJ ciA) AurP?c>jesz*X s*pur*Au£f zAbsr^
 \JioIaT* Tkt>sY Lpini/vAtf A£oaZyZ^a^y 6uPc/*Pa#*^ . . . .
fliY Zp/j&ALMAAt*** PlI/ftcA 7*t> AA/&/& Z*/my P&nufeAP*** Pe*. 6u/e$AsZYoZAuXAv&
aJ*/y/iy£ JujhzA* SyP/ dp?s/0Y A£r~#Z.pZ CSpCe^tf^ /?X*€>yJy?AApy?»*s>a-so*
t~A*icAAJ4S *P A y/A#sAPY 4Y*'?Y*>'Pi SetfY ^fitX u>rafts' PcAtt^r f7d^X *?y Z/*A™XaAj7t coPfYZZ*
A£P*"2 ConutZYteis xaz/A#PP°MojcP6>«-('
l/srezf as x*J S*yp-p*aJ£.§ c^) C^ &Z-/2- 7e*