Court Opinion

ID: 4040657
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-28 22:35:53.980625+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:28:31.933497
License: Public Domain

Tnecl CaMst- fJo,CZ-20/( -Its'
                               Appeal C**c A/a. 03~ /Z -00 *} CI -C%
                                   PPR, Ma. ?£>'097S~ //

 c/P£*- Da\//d uU/yfSJ                             )     //} M<L Courf of Crirnrn*,-/
                                                  )     fppe^/s 0/ TcjCclS

Zfe £3tl£ of 72.X&S                               <>
                                                  9

 fflOTfOfiJ Foil %£H£AAiiJ(>- AVO fec*"*StO£jl4Tlo*l E*S 3aaJC , fo/L p£-TWvJ FoA.

7b TH£ MoAfo/tAgLS CouAT

     Now torrt-es sJo£l~ Va\/IO *JhM£S, A/?/2e//as)t fro Se. , /« irtc a.bov<.
entrf/ccl a*-d nut*} fared Ca.se. ftr\ d Matr-es -£&.c. (Lrur/ far /Cehea//n^ a«-el
fCecensicU/aJttrri £n Banc ff>r Pe^f(/-<6n for Dt-^crcJ-t^A^/ Kc.x/ie.uJ faftd tttrtntak
this mo6™ czpp^M^t ivc'd/d ^r/tcr«/:

                                                T,
  The. //cnora^k. Cvar/ of*CnirtirieJ App&tls, fc-fu^^jC appe~//a*£s PiLo ~S£
/Whan yCr DJrcreA^^aoy fUt/t<u , tuifLou.} tkujAfjC/ &^ Cnrefz / dcfJtckrih*
A> -tU. Mc/s ^r/a..A=d. flp/*//<**•/ re.a.//zes; iLu ov-crvJtu/n,^ ca*e- bad of the
noncretOk. Leur/ ckuji *zr/jr f,/ a. -{korou.a/f Q*vd Cc>#i/&-Se c/tttx-c-e. /p ^Avcd/ Ufl/**•*'/ #x~d
UdU^ft/ drcjkdtce- fn tb Jer/ of'fsL s4S&r/>e/ f>r t^ Sfe/£~r
             J                                           '                      RECEIVED IN
                                                                        COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
                                                                               JAN 15 2015

                                                 //)                        Abel Acosta, Clerk
                                                 iz.

      The ccppe^/ia-ti-f ecm-fetids -diecf- his' rights fr due- process as ^//aj- ««l /ti(~r and
  UAoiasctL -frt'o^/ ^er-c rcp&ccJedCtp i/(.o faded »
     fn -tht fr^-f cjrvuntL t ike. -irilc/ tour/ err^d fih ad-rrt////„.*. a* e.y:tra^eous <z.c-f
  ikaf u/A5 ^///<d ne.ctrfy 30rfe#r aao u/Acn -tLc ap>pe-//asj/ u/cts~&.mrnor. A/v cvi^Unce^
  h^y eses Uen produced /h {hi irr€/c^n/ misdemeanor cz&s-e. unfr/ tl*- aJ/edj^l
  ctcc-ujcr fs fnUjrkrtrusly produ^c-^dcuf fJLe- /eur/- rummA. a-f -j-r/'tc/ to LpA. a~ CLoa.cJL<ed ,
 fnasiUrt*-c{u/cjL a^d co^j/Lfc^ly flfec Account/ oftM. ftcM.
     /A* second arovt^d fk.//s /lettAty ^eAf^d tU. f/rs/ ,• f* ina,/ tic /r/^/ c&us/
 perfedto atuLffAp 1«~e. b/r/vcJs a«~d &ivc ///v///ri<9 /m-A^uc^fc* ~fc •/l<L(y^/r #£»*>/• ff&rf **r
  tic pec/s /cj/fjfed -Ao . Tjfj y£//k/-e irik^/ivnet//y /eads to ep:/re*n*. a.^ <zAur/i*"«z/
 pyfcpudCce. Mtfk&tLp prober ftrttetdtt/fa/f <?fCertified' eif/dettce. er €-S-er\ ccur/ documents
 M/n lb. tunc oftl^ a/ltuihcd tysc/det,/, 30 ye<*.rs 6e£>re,
   TL*- fArrd £ar««-d ^^ Mort'-&roc,ofiv^t dornMates ctnjLp*sA*js- /le. Sfa/cs Cas*- A>
btccrn^ ^ urthsAf c0«*fe/t*«. f) (end**, «,(/l Q.a/.A'. prc^d war &«*d */ tit
Oppe.flwti resrdutce.., JTlts ,s cu« to**/,^^ -fC^ ty jL *W/W\ Pit A^Urny ~£r //^
S^Je taPe^ -tb ^iduu^_ *j- A<lt #*& e^c/tve, per prox^cuh ^ <*^d +«"^s -Ul +ru.4-kj
pu-/'t*-j hpjkl *- pafckh/erJ: <?fsepwdc. fLc/s if/Jl//e. //////& /v* tA* /larretj vy!>S or <*?i /rtu>ur)
lihks u/VA. 0,11<J e/Ho/<i».&f u«-d Wvru/fy "itttd-ed /trA-Juf&n >4/xt Wrt'j&V «jj»y//^^
Uncorrected. 72e. Cox-dcn /* &tt*jrt,r<n dtld, m Pa.cdf fcrnJnrh V.a/- .4, /Ha/er/o./ f^^i /^4
c^pAe.flatif-f -tke, LofrtpUwaq Actt^L -tbi <&p/*e//ew/s <s./c^^:f JSon . 7** conCUm h/<u f?*«ir( on
tU f/oor '£>/ **<• <U>*tp/«in*~ft - <« -fL rwdeHce. *f tU app*-l/*«+fa-l-*> ^^< ^^//^
SmpUw+Kh +"" s&/1r "^ «-ppeJf*«ik ^,'f. r^'idUK, PL ccrnd,™ u,^ -£c«d mp**'" *#*•'
Aex/ ^ an ovcrtu.f/ted <5piMo*/t ••/-fc/ h«-d h*cn f?Ped &//•£ ^et/hut fra^ f(^ eyp*-/btA
rlc Cond^rh *v*s- a^ f£coV£fd Mi/A. dt JFrt*<r, jrn.1t**. all o\/-cr ft, Th/s /actvtcd evidjutc*:.
h/«s corroUML Si/ /^* ^/5C«/ &**/&* '* /a^ ^c^ "L f"*"*** )»**/j^ts on
iU curnd^, Lr mm<d^ ^fevtser a^ fL dep«r^r *frr~r,«/**~/Lf*A ty ^
 'fund j)cJ sx-ff {hfce. TI^PS* C-flun€. I-A& &™ptenp*-es~ c<&s- c&r)cAusTU*- &^> A -H*~-o-ton*.r <*f
•tL wa sample, ofCP. a/-AI fork* *U ap/teA/ewA. 7h over<jh*te»,jj oSwct^s &*d~ ^A
^koicld. rtrrejrt -tie. Prosecutions- e«^e /^ / Aiere- e*"*^ rPO se,)cu-ect /-Atid-s ofcxxy Minot
jnakikc. up tP DAJ'J tnride, or occt-yfc^. 6<4_ eortdem, 7Avi arofu-rtd atcd e*Arezme.Ay
Cructa. /''A&cf- vte wf affz^^d- A" A-e Art^^f- up m fern Acf^Aa-yitry, fty were /eft
to torosea It/ asJTKrrte- , &-At^r tie. AiOfH-ty ehtotrinaAC^iaraejr trCV-C- rcAeejA/es&Ay reyZea.te&L' <*nd
emit/prLd l/ApprosecuAo-r/ fA&f fit. DlA{A. ^«m /t/A-T a-scrctrt-eeC *> A<z-^i~itn^1 ftwcJ
Merely facade, of ft*. Mature. o-f^iu Cas^,^"-d *-*- eitteetiped Ay tie- e&j*ytarnan/.
    77ns fca_Uj to tie- f»rAi- <?evctitd atla^A th dt/ecA \//o/at/en A* tic cy^AAarfAs £ M'
AmndmenA rt/Ats ofcv^n/xtr™ . Pic c^pin^t A*.* * *cxu«.A tiis-Aoy urtAAt AUs
etdexf- ^/oAf/ia A/A/en Ac^sr A*es) /rov^n a*-d Ord/niAAetf A^o . fie. Ana./ ee*<s/ wouAd aoA
Osl'atV Crass- exam/'rL&troh of£p d/et^iA:r (cont/)Aa/r)#*\/) vjby^b app>eAAar)t Aecaure Atpmr-cs
he kaxd hot ctcted //> ^P er/Ai-c aa-^C f&tctd ctfeaerAy ^Ao£<j Aii fyin^c^^tsc « 77c dcurf
Sfted tkc       KAp4. Sfttilcf £«*/'ei/<^7 r'bujfi. ft-a rA/ie tvtur attedtyzcf or ocetr^d , /V' Utt/tu-e
pressure bras -etreypla<L&l m tb. cwtpta,,,^/- cw/e^x after Aw dC/fer&n/ /nee-tcni.* /« 4rh-
judges clutfvbrs d/Pre tP coMpt«/A>a«t «*^A -ft*. a^e/Aa^f( b/er-a seafeci ^s-tde by jrt'di a.^
CtctefL ej//\Qe.r\{a^t/u , Tie Co/*iptei/riant e.\/<e(n js^taAd -on f/e record - Ai*-p ^Ae on Ay n*a_££c
£M outcry" l)£Cauj<L <sr/U d/a^ted to, gz-t tP ayy>eA/anA /ri tr<?crA?A>. rvr *A~y.r /e-tf-
Ina /ur b/ha.1 to de^
            ''fyA atud final GrvHfid H/&S ye.A atoAter- O-tAetn/f fppiPp''*s-ee.utf0t>t A-*
Cldud thi psucj-s. and fTfoia-fe. r^tu. czp/teA/a^As r'jLPs Ao due y>r<rc*rss f„ flo Aatr/rx'*
Hrtderj-fcivuiaJi/e. /«jt^-«cAc/i ta tP/ary unAi*-t^f uncA*ce_ preduLdtce-d/n {Ai* cnr<_ ?tt
dessrjii/fty -k Coxs-icUr tP oatart ofee /esse-r Inctuc&et ctaryej,. fie T^et AT /^/x er//r)tne<_l
Ac-r Aever occttred and (4t*s~ ewtieA/rsAed -to -tP point d/Pre ft pnrdu-c^d a« ^m/^ntie.,
Q-*d pfedttdicta/ e-ffect tiiut plttrrtn* fP /tcomf ^•ugt dse<^cy*^*«dl2selj-rhp'zr</*!/*r
tUir ouhu>s*e. a^et tef?- tie. ci-pytejtcuit Vlo /at*(P tl*id ao{ tie c^/^/"^/

                                                 (3)
                                  Praxpcr fvr Pfe/ie-f
    Pie eyM-e-P/zn. / rcsptectf*.//y pret-iJsr (dc fPrvruttte, d&us p erf C^r/rniru^f Atpetz/r
Qrt\AT h& Mot/on /o/ ffeAertrrn* and P-cccrnsrraUr<v/rr, £*/ Sane,. a«-d qt-^fc fkir
aid tkeugkAful eerrisr'cAertttrak <r/><4 /Cctsyproper procedure, a^d <?A,vf<rKS GaMrvon
vSC^jre A* -tic ^Utetnenps /piade dur,^-j fr,cz/t A/iioi u/AAA'~s~Aurt.r yi4 <2J?pe.A/*n Ad
tnAocenxe- or c*rA«,'nL #0 f *cj*<}/Ay feynd * rt\AxonaA(e- deu-Ah] 7%l aytf&A/artt
*lsv prys pk AfenorvA^ e*tkr/ revcrsJL -ti^ ar^r^j< Jkctgemc*/ a^^ucd
tk. Ca^rC- McP to pit. frfcx./ C^urA f?/r new -Af/d / a ted, or a-?^Aa-/.

                                              K*sp*cj£,l/Lp Scilm]pped,

                                                                knej,f PHo SE Ap/k/Pn/
                                                      IDH-I7n7-^

                                          ft)
                               Ccrhlrieadc of Service,
    i Certify -that &. true and eorrecf Copy af tic a-A^tre e.rtffre\d, '/Alp-pron
75r pctear/ng and /Xeecrrs-rdera/foh £n flame for Ac^fA'o'rt lf>r ptseredearn.ct.ry
fared, has See/) yCrt^/arrted/ Ac/ UlS. Afloat/ p)c>spaae p)a.Zcif AvrsA dfass/ po -tAc
Attorney for tie. SU^Ae f tAc /PmirrziAU. Jetititfr 7%.ar// , C*m&>f £&ur?/y DtsiAn&A
Attorneyf A&o pjerph Scc/^ih Avenue. fSut'/e- 3°7\ APeU SraursAeVs, fky4s/ /8A30
aut tie Shk ProsetuAAnp ^AMny, P.O. fSoye /Z^OS, £*pfU/Sl^t<?n, A*sr/ir) ,
TSXAS, 7%! ii,or\ ^Afk eke £**> day 0/^JtriHay, ZOAS~,

                                                                          :/7?8'2Z3

                                tdrv>u&rrt Ve-cUraiiirt
   dr Jd£u T)a\/iP J+?ri£s, T2>Cd- tZ>^ti7?SZ£3f Seine? present7y Antarcera.teot
Mthe fd/an SUtunrky lb- Unit of tie Te^s deparPfnenA oft^ritntmj Jushe*,
in Ltlin/zsion f r%lk County, TeiKAS / \zenpd a*\-d deeleve. undtr pena-ify ofp>eryury
ika( ike forccjama Sth-fejryerp/s are. true ctrxd Correct* fx^cukzd on -this tAei
%+*> day of January, Z0t£7.

                                             10£L Mi/J/OyJirY7£^;        tofnn^^
                                            pfZo -5e P£rtrfeAf£jc\

                                         end.

                                         (S)
                                  •J3ft|
i^...f                             ij. -T^COP I
                                   . >

                                                   M
                                                   N

  -•.I

  •••i.

  W                 ^
  n
  m            o
                    ^
  n
               X

               N
          •^

                        £
                    i
               rV
                        £

                        rs

                                 i l l ! •! / -i

                             *   i \     V '":•
                                                  —/