Court Opinion

ID: 4050130
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 01:10:04.747832+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:03.018092
License: Public Domain

15718-\2-
                                   tAuot          JJo ::tif~o53Jii91cfrBJtir;z;z~&-

                                                     x:    I,J      -~<t.. tou~\-                 o£ ·
                                                   f      c~~~                             o\ ll1A5

               ~t_\"~'t-~ ((ft'2.o-~~J ~Oho~ ~~ 'L1.A.~~) ~ 'h\1.
                       ~~\ & \---\.~d~MU.:)

      /o                              o\" ~~~·u).,\s .
            fhL- \-\ot0o~\ci..~ ful.e._-\7-                     1

           . Cc~"'L tJow? ~~\\u.Dt 0.Wb?At.:)'?.2o-5z~'i..At-hL                                )t;rJt>WJJ );>    2'i)PHoi?J /IJ ,JJ,[
 n.~t.- ~\'\_ c~o\ tJuM'o~d 0AU0t. who·s · nc-hrJ~ o~ hiS ow~ trth~~~) "iifut.Jf;"!j ~0~i ~+ntJCi
1N    ~~L\Q..l\ ~ \\-\,~ trfvfo\1~ Yo1-- Lcc.A'Vl"l> to fit ~~&             of MtttJdA!Mu~ (Jt-~J-5uq,.J-/. Jv+l1t 1fJti15
fult:J     *   ~\\0t,.A ~LA~ ~l'L 1Ju:f.. _ANd t\rYi. 7fflt5 Ccx:JL e{ CitMivJA-/ Pioudu~ Azd-JeJ ~
'-/.04 n~of irJ 5urtoU- dsl.lt~ 'tt-~u"L"it- J,~~ lrJ wiJ/ shov.J +tlis J.lotJoi?.Abf.i. UJue/ tJf
 /{f?.U¥. ~ \J.\ow\~~:
                                                I-
     ~~~~ -~              ·r·K-.f\.r   2uu__   1z.t A('flltTI;D~J to~   t'tl\0\..~   MUZ:;\-    o.et.ol..fpM'I    jJ.;J   Awl;CA-t/Jt-.1
   \oz_     ~i~     o\-   ~~00

. ~<t..\.~
 ~~ b~~~ ~ OA~ ~~a.. ~ k fkdue)_ ccJ,"2.6
                                           1L-
                  ~'\-- 0-~ ro~bf.~] (GZArJ[J,.;~) h;6 ~~\-                   '*      NMdAMU5 -1-o ~OMnii.Jh /kYiis
                                                                                                   ot     A-ll   DfXllJIIfz.J-1-s
  -~~ ~ Q~-J'L M~ ~~~~ ~ il-fu~~ SA\cl e\tt.~~ ~vt uJA-be ') s/-A-Jlli~j koM
  \\v~..- 't,~ ~ \r\i.. U\\"U'..'t&. ~~oetA- CowJ4:1 1-o Jtt"- diJ.-y ht N/4-5 5tJ.}/wtl_ ;A-rJd 3l;JI.

     A-o   ~'I-   htAS     ~~v.)\- or ~.~,~~L ju~'l& fwt/)                             I            RECEIVE[) ~~
                                                                                                  COURT OF CR~,t11NAL APPEALS
                                                                                                           FEB 19 2015
                                                                                                     Ab84 Acomi, Cierk
  ~~~()\2.;1.. ~\'&Sb ~~Am.dJU\~-e..· r~ ~rt\- ~\6 WMoeNo\<t.
~u.& ~~ k 'o1&\- .Jf\\·\tm\- ~ \jUb-\,~'l. $1'JANT] /h1.. ~tyut:'tJ J :55U.UJJC1.
~ ·\\\,~ \0~,\- D\ tv(AtJdt\~

                                                      'Ja)lf-lrt   t2 wJJt; J?tzD-.5?
                                                      f;gu5o~ t/,JJ-/ -
                                                      iz_i2D Silvf!Ji )?
                                                      fl/} ;J wAf li/1/:J 7..J"WZ.
                  ex ih-E--r'-               y;          T ,J   /hi   CiJvd t>f C!Lw""IMt\
               ~Q:)"'\j(A 0 Whh.
                            I               'I                  kiftHI   of /tt:A5

          'lP Mz- 1/o,Joe.Ab u_    {J;)ut:+ of    frrtM /. ·

                 Colo4.ttJM.;   jos~u¥~t 0 .Whd-t.. -;-rio -5t..) 27/fl}-b,z_
                                                                        tht.. ~Joevt J/y!fd ;wel
                                                                                /JJ

   Alw-tlotl-J C(tu.jt of ~-/WJ ~l- -l-h-t5 \N~· tf f1~t-rJch-Mu8 fJtJfbuNI- .fo 71:)1'A5 Zult:. o/
  JWr~\~~ 'reoc.tJue? ~uh 12-!.) ;/J 5uffo£i -lhfK5it>\_,~~ v.>'\\ s}tD~ ~i~ /k>tJo~Ablz feu~
 ~'L ~o\\o~\~0:
                            I
  ~~~o'"t J~~\\\)._ct \).w~.) \~ Q~o h~I- tru,J .,r->~                                 ),J r+·ttx1A5   fiNA-l 1JJs:-/ilah~
  3·, r-)~l.    5~?}) 7_o;W J Q~ ~ ~w 'at loMhJ AJ- ~3~ Ui0Jt JftiZ!J ftJuA3/:Jz.:)
  M\dw~o<'f; 'if-t~ts .j5CC5Z.
                                ll
 i-1..\Qtc'e. \\i¥.> ~D\- t.X~A~ o7-W ~\ \\'7~ ~'i- propu. orr'o~f -lv t~u11us·t- hi:; ·11CiEfuk/t:
 ~~td\<0 o..\- lttt-J ON A: eli~ ~?riAl.
                                         -:m::
 ~L ccl- 'oz:\~ ~tj\1-.\- -\.c, 'oz.. ~\)L\\t~ '()i '~'6 ~~\.'l, ~                             Ot P.?f'z4~    /~   o,.Jt

 1'i,~\~"L\q\ ~~~ 1--\~\ Oe~~lli'~~'-/ j~ tJAi-LAJG{..
 ·1£t:Po W'l... & ~~,...la{ ~ttl~~ 1\'t\\~i~ Lt.l {q)(j) go\)f!W ~t. \J\:,~\'tl\ield dt~+it::> J +\1i. DL~~z.;cJ
Clti-'<- ~ \-\~'il ~~"i ~ ~'l ~uA1 t\~ ()~?>~~to~ to<- ~.kj . MAie\"t l.Z:i {Qj(;() d~xtlhtJ
~t. \o\\o!fJ\~0 ~u\;~ £)~ ~t.. CA® tv~~c.~ Of.. ~u.'*vl IN ~M ~M\t-.\~1 PJ~r'NJ 74-o tlO-iJz
~~ ~'''L- Q \\ ~~'lX..
1;Z(MY l.Lt.L fril~'lt-)1)1[ C~:n.J] lq) Pt ~t. eh\t,Jdq.J.. 'ij,t A..>Dhe.t.         C>{   An?~-   MIA>\   bt h/1 e) f:iJ
~\\\ro.~rJ ~\) d~~ o..\\-1,~ ~'L ~1\-f Sz,\\.u)t<_. 'i~ \M~~W tW- SuJ?1,J,.h,) (,_} ~~,J CouJ-, 0~ Mt~L
   ~"t \~a\ t{)ut,\s ~~ Ch·~ Q'?e'i-~\a.lo\1. o~~
    %'t..   ~\D.\~ 0.\5\cl..<lc)      'o'l \,~~:? '2uh. ~:z.           o.,:J() inul t\~~ fuu~'-{ (:)~,~ Ct<L.\Lt

  ~J ~~flc1Ji).U fie' ~ llct~ ,fu ~l) uct.              Csu1'115   of ~'l~        IUZiJ'i. by til~~ atJrJ of.. _(',l~
   'oi ~'\..- \~~~\-"G.\ ~?.. ~ ~\YL \-\AQ\-- ~IAtve- at-fuD~-Hy' .{;J~J            QN A?PZA-l u.S,t\\\10    3o )ttf5 bf
  li'Z.P& !JJ,;z_ • lh1. 0-~ct C.W.,\L ()~ t.\1\~ t.ou'*f hvt-dl\- Mtr-)\~iJq/ duf-t Jo £it 'Oi/fi+ctc.. f:i_c[uzY
                                                                                                                 1

  ~ Q~ ~l ~~~ ~A-\-ot 1-tq~J Mi?A\ e.0tfulr-l                          3tJ r)11f5 ~~ 5~e<       IA.}IN)   i Mf/OsJ   J;y I/Ac!:5
  d~WI~        il-l   p~~tr ~u~ ~1\'on¥ .ft{X"{)UU;'!j -io #,'i /vlfJ-1/bo'fJ ~ul? /J;-ou5lo;;   IAcJc. JoB )tC/ 23;t'l]
                                                                                                   115

   ~ ~~l~ al- ~t toM'l ~~ k~ J+.~~ a~d ,Jo~.~J Lhtis D/Wftls ;,.;fill- fAfJI-- e//;ciA-1 CAfJI,ci/-f
  A':) \A~\~~ t\'i~ o\ ~ tou~\y J htfO JVt't\5 A Mlr->l5tz~qf duly Jo ~C~iJ~ CN) lilt Jrl/ fJAfJU. ffift12J/
  ~r-- f1-r l\wzAI] ;,J p, C2imitJ~ti74W#Jt~~r'iJ,'() ? /l#d ftmj!.;IIJ Q// tHttfe dufi-z5 I~'-~M orJ Jh~ ~ls-1-i!tcf
  t~'fl fJh£ hl1r15 q~ lrJ Jrntd] by kw pu10uMf -k ./['~ ti:dt: <!>f f!iJp,iJal ~j ,A?J.d-z z,z; c&.:O
   q~~       J,~tLP       U-6
                                      ~
   ~\\0~()0             t)\ '/. t, Ct-i~.-?     ~ J.,j,(   fit;)   (i)
~~~~~~5 \H()\M~. /. ~ U::-1 ~j? Ae+ [,Z/ f·OttJ by ft..;(iJj lo ttl~                           MIAJ/6ftvc;l     de;,i;-zs
~V)~d~ 'o1 ~h.            u.\"ul   ~l)~d-w\;: ~q'\\ *C) ~~h. ~itt\ t>)~ \2-~v-10-td       by ,fllk}-lS/2_    tU~·,J.
'£i.e(~\~      6o Jr4

                                           ~lt\'ifl.
 ~~\~ ~""''v'L ~~~~ ~~ ~~\,l"' (). v) ""~ ~~ -01. 11~::Ptc+(4Jt~ PtAfs
 \ 0 q,.. ~~\s \o f1x.M\] ~\c Mt>"'o-\ Qui 0\ ~,.:J o\ ~~ ,

 .~\~ ·fAA~5 foe.. A,) DLdli o( fA~ J;~d1~ ~?wJ eM- 1o 5hovJ jwt ~~ ~hz;J
    ~\t'rtiXL.- jQ~I,).,'o\•J ~ Q~ flrer!M D,Jor-}Z.    v-)A(:,    fit, i
                                                                           TjJ        ~rlk ti
                                                                                       ~t
                                                                          ~M(~\ Awidfl S fJf /{yA;5

                                   ~~~ 0~                             w       k &.i??~-t
                                               \\]~\ o~ ~~tiAMv~

          ~~ 6J~~ ~\Q\- ~~~tJ ·k ·1''?-,A.~                               l.it,2{J;J CftMiJti Msi"J fc~ 3y Jlti"i.
                                                                              ful'l.

     d~&~. Jht· tJof;~ or A1f]{1/ pAus{- bi (Jt fJ_) bJ~i.J .Eo J·~S q{fu:.. -Jbz. d~tf Jt,J/uJcG JS tM/bsJ
     t>~ .5WMdJ i~ ~,J COJetJfJ1- ~~ -\t1. ~o.\ lbu~ ~·~ q,J !ifft~Yfa)JI£ ff?Jf£..!1 arJJ jJ 11®td~E
    vS~ ~'i..~J\\\'oo;' ~kl %~. . h~lfll~~t\z)f~:i~~'itt5J.;l~w l~J,tJHou:Jo;J us Jp.ctiD~ Stl t.3i9 h1·s '?lc;ul3f
    w~ ~h.·~ ~Mt :~~11\tot- ~Is() Co~~5 ~Q\- ?u~U/t,rt Jo It~ ~ct.AA.1' -~ 'Ito~ l<!l t:ktf4tMPi
                                                                                           I

   i ~ f»\ Y CUM\~ru CM:>7. \t\~ ~ ~~"'\ o( ~\ ~ ~'\l- tu.\'l 'x\'L~\"'~ ·~~W 0~cWv
  ~;ot(~ ~'L clzh.JJaA                         w\.to   ~'f\"S 'o'GJJ ~ci.~ u.t~ ~1\Wil- \\,~ PIM o/ br..ully 19'1- fkll- IJf NIJ/1> tt>,;/&Jdl'~f
  bt(o?t. \\s\'i... Q:.u~-'c Jq,,.J4\IL'i COLA-t*) tt?o.J fh"'.. fhdloJ 0f J-h. JzftNdcuJ·b Q~ fur.~isJ1,112A ~.:.1-Jh pur.JfsJ,MU-f
 ~ ,11)\- 2.(ti~ -\.ltt pr.ttJI~hit1ut ~f\1f,Jc)J b; IJ,t f'8if:/t.Wk ~,J 4JF!-4J lo bj #~ Jzi.dt?.4- q,.I) j,;'i> q//Oi?,.!~:J :~
                                     n~

M~f fl_obtO.U-k his m-A-1. ,. Jj,-p ;Eij~.J- w~i> U\O[AhJ whi-J -~tz;qf Couo51/ t#:J dt:/s-.ta~;~ t/;JiJI- tj_jPG
v>·r\'A put-~\~\14'tuJ-\- kcu~~'L) by ·f-Ht p?o~~fai!.- Q,-~J kf·~( tourJStf ?lfu2:>.f kiZ- lo (fAI?S o;z ks5
 ~t~J wh.J hzt·<il    lbwlYif) ft,ql    Jlldji 11...rJ :;x~i~d lifiN/       h;IJ fo pl-h~            fh£/t- y'Ai,Ji~?fQ/ ~/btJsli.J;/rl-~i
1f:t ·ti.iQ\   Cou~l 'E.!'f>Tb.Jolb·~~~·\iu ~b\~            J ·Q ·two skp     f'tey-155.   Vi'~v #Is. 'fl/oMi.f tuus.J-    Q8Ctt--lcu4

   ttJ\\~\" fu'i ~c}q,J\           wn:>h5;:>   Jo q??rttG QrJj 5~orJJ.:J ;f -#1~ drhr~dt~rJf JrcJch5 !» /J??IAI)·hz Q~i
  ·tv..~ ir-lSUf-t \\w\- W'l-\\\'1.-> {II a\"; a.,     J   ft'tttAI I:; {JteJ w>+~ Jt,z fitc:/ CbuflfJ ;,JorJ~ vs 3/ttk          J'B ,>'{))
    6J 1fJ). 'fht /;liq/        CcttNSt/ )·~tN~J oe JW(t>1Jk~)jv,~ ~z_ duly Joldtjvrlio-J qJJd ~'li)fip1Sib/-Ht /D
     Co~·~ult w\\-\A a~~ ~ul~ ocl.v\60 ht'-' tX.~\- Co~er-J,' 1~ vv'l.-tr-l'1rJ5 Qtsd dfetJ .of~~ jcx{j'l·tMfA.i.
    f.sl.~ dt<LJ loy ~~!> \\,-o ~\\- ·to m1~~ ~ tkL j uJsitMt;J~ 0 +~c DKt.S)i+f J Ji ui':!j tJofiCJ..
    &-~ oJ~'iw\ Q~~ ~~~) ~l~ 6\ies ~ fu~u.t c.N; fKrl~ Q~J ~L. ,v~s:,z-A Q~ -lh"L ~
    ~\\...)~cA 1 "() cJ'Vt-.~~(. cv~J_ (};~QOu!h~·\c:Jz. f)~ ~/{(A\ . \l ~tf.,~dr!N\- Joo ~ Li>~ 4o Mf?ll/
. . ~~~at to~·d ·ap~l.)YJf;.J-~o0 tr~ch .Jfllri ckMJ~ dlCJd'£5 -lv ~tr??A; Jhz. ~ceN'lV l--lv51-
     ~ Ht~tf w~ #bhe-z. J iWi'ifil isfiJ {})J/i %'if CbJf,f ti~fl,f 'IOttJfxJ. '/h-z                                 Wul!-..ft; j'YfrJt .

    ~P<W~hdi~~ h ftz;al        Ju)st         M    ~loftJ»J ifS :5/-!Y/t h~t .)~1/1 ,2)       !-11.       fh~ t'ou~ h1/tl/hA-i-
    ffiCt I JuJ~t S!M«IJ       '7.:1 f/qi~   JJWi llnh) 'Ojrb /lJ -lk ltlh-rJcitvJi.. i~ {jf,J t'ouef IIrtl Mr lZcrad
   &kttiJ '&{/ze:/.   !k· ffir:t Juds"i.         5/u,qfJ 'l Jui5t ~· J1,~ p1t>fit<- li111z   tJ/ J, ,6    fJr!t11/ '?j'i1 vJh71/t)"-- ~ 'l
  b'L ~~,.lw 'vi ~ir~JJ r% cout&t qr?oiA~{J Cf)~t-JSf-{ } t.JI}tJ l)S Si*lt 1'/rJ j[N/zJ 1f'f, fk
  MttSi1>\.wu41 D\.(\-y t~C ~'i. ~fllld cfft¥. I~ -h ~ j,.J ~If CtiMi,Jq/ e~S!J ')}o t:zC.fivc QrJ) !It o/1 ai?j>.
  Jirlt:i. ~d-- oth'Cjq( /N/z) /o (Jfd;M fv1)tJo/-yZ{cp{ ~frf5 2;./vtfoe V'ffS f)ZJlt- 9kl'il'/ /-1,; flopf!.
  Of/o~,/,~ ·h> Lfft~L~5'l- ~~~ ~~i~·~iJ~li-vt '2U>1tdt15

                                                   ~~5                                   '
    "'~lA-\ue. \Z-~t.tkl~                    1t.ct u.~       :15:->U~tt        ck    ~\-        JM        Mftv'-1\J.J   bt R)Jr~ i1N1
   \\1\~ l~o~\\o\5.. ~~\ J:.6zt.v1r~At ~~A~ w\\\A\0 ~o~o.\,\·L tlM'l_                                                pttJo~     'z,
                                                                                                                              ~~olu+
  to ~~UC.t. J\.).6\ ~u.'5~ Q.D \o vJ\J ~t~ l\v\S 016\q;\J ~IMui6 ~~JA-MlJtwl ~j/tfs ~
  \f){\\)\~~ h\~ ~1\l ?~~~y ?~(j..:t, 1\.l Ou'L ·hN\'i t{;~<L Q,_rJ f)q_ ~i ~~

      L~ ;to--5"""
         iJA+z
                                                                          ~-~
                                                                          ~e/11 tP. tJ)lt ik> -.?t              :J

                                                                                 f[e_ju»J /)tJA
                                                                                jz_;ft_o $/Jv!tjt Jg
                                                                                 fvf,JwAvJ. MAS 1S""trz