Court Opinion

ID: 3167849
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-01-07 17:01:09.023509+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T11:59:23.316761
License: Public Domain

NOTE: This disposition is nonprecedential.

 United States Court of Appeals
     for the Federal Circuit
              ______________________

   JOHNATHAN DANIEL KING, DAVID ALLEN,
   DONALD EDWARD ARNOLD, CHRISTOPHER
 PAUL BARKER, TRACY T. BEAMS, ALEJANDRO
    CASTANEDA, CARL CRAVENS, WILLIAM J.
    DUNLAP, ALLEN H. FORAKER, ANTHONY
    GRAHAM, MARK A. GARRISON, RONALD J.
     GUIDRY, JEREMY D. HEARN, CARLOS M.
HERNANDEZ, JESSICA L. HERNANDEZ, ROBERT
   C. HUDGINS, KENNETH JOHNSON, JERRY S.
 JONES, RAY T. JONES, SCOTT LYNCH, THOMAS
C. MADRID, ERIC A. MAGANA, STEVEN ADKISON,
ARTHUR S. AGUERO, JOSE M. ALEMAN, ANDREW
ANDRADE, ANDREW ARGUELLO, LUIS C. AYALA,
RICARDO BARREDA, DARYL BARTLETT, KELLY
 JO BENJAMIN, HAROLD J. BENNETT, ROBERT
BREYER, ANDREW BUTTS, JODI R. BUTTS, JESS
  CABE, ERIK J. CANSINO, JOSEPH CAPORALE,
 SEAN CARRIGAN, JACK CARSON, RIGOBERTO
     CEPEDA, EDWIN CESTERO, ANTHONY E.
CHAMBERS, DAVID CLOER, MICHAEL P. CLUFF,
  SHAYNE COLLINS, DAVID COLON-ESCOBAR,
JAMES R. COMINGS, BRIAN T. CORNELL, DAVID
 R. DAISS, IAN P. DAUGHERTY, JAMES R. DAVIS,
    TIMOTHY B. DAVIS, RUBEN DE LA TORRE,
 DARRYLL DENNIS, JORGE L. DOMINQUEZ, SAL
      DORADO, BRIAN S. DVORAK, JONAS K.
 EDWARDS, SCOTT EDWARDS, SAUL ENRIQUEZ,
  ROBERTO ESPINOZA, JR., CESAR E. FALCON,
  BRYAN K. FENLEY, TERRANCE S. FERGUSON,
  GEORGE H. FERLAND, CODY L. FOX, TODD J.
   FRASER, GREG FURNIA, JOE A. GALLEGOS,
ELDE GARCIA, JOEL GARCIA, MANUEL GARCIA,
   JR., HUGO GARZA, JON GELBER, JOSE LUIS
       GONZALEZ, JOSE A. GONZALEZ, JR.,
CHRISTOPHER GORNEAU, ELIEZER GUAJARDO,
    JR., GARY R. GUALDUCCI, GUADALUPE I.
      GUTIERREZ, ERIC T. HALEY, RILEY W.
     HANBACK, GERALD HANCOCK, JOHN E.
    HARVEY, FAUSTO HERNANDEZ, JAMES R.
 HERRICK, PHILLIP D. HISE, STEVEN W. IMRIE,
    TRAVIS W. INMAN, JUAN ISARRARAZ, JR.,
    DENNIS JENKINS, JR., DAMON W. JONES,
FRANCISCO JUAREZ, DONALD KENEFICK, JOHN
  KESSLER, CULLY E. KNOWLTON, WILLIAM M.
 KOCAN, KURT W. KRAUS, PYOTR KUKHARSKY,
 ALFREDO LARA, DAVID LEDEZMA, III, ZENAIDA
     LEVRIE, STEPHEN C. LEWIS, BRANDON
   LONGAKER, ALEX J. LOPEZ, CRISTOBAL B.
LOPEZ, FELIX A. LOPEZ, JOSE C. LOPEZ, MARTIN
      N. LOPEZ, HAYDEE LOZANO, CLAUDIA
LUKASON, TREVOR MACKENZIE, TROY MANSKE,
 SAMUEL MARTINEZ, LISA MARTINEZ CROUSE,
ERNESTO MARTINEZ, JR., KENNETH J. MAURER,
    CHAD MCBROOM, BRIAN G. MCCLELLAN,
 GUILLERMO MEDRANO, III, HEKTOR G. MESTA,
  MARK MIDDLETON, ADAM MILLER, RODOLFO
  MONTELONGO, COREY S. MOORE, VERONICA
     MORALES, JOSE A. MORALES, JR., PAUL
  JEROME MURPHY, JOE F. NAVARO, LEROY L.
    NOTTERMAN, ROBERT J. NOZISKA, ERIC
   PAHLER, JUDE W. PATTERSON, SAMUEL D.
 PEAK, JOHN J. PINEIRO, MIKE B. PIO, MARK W.
 POTTER, MARK QUALTER, AMANDA RAMIREZ,
  EDUARDO RANGEL, PATRICIA REYES, RUBEN
   RICCI, STACY GUY RIDER, MARK ANTHONY
     RIOS, JIM RIVERA, ROBIN J. ROBERTS,
 BENJAMIN RODRIGUEZ, ALONZO RODRIGUEZ,
  MARIO A. RODRIGUEZ, CIRO ROMAN, CARLOS
ROMO, MAURO A. RUEDA, JOSHUA E. SANCHEZ,
    RAYMUNDO SANCHEZ, DONALD K. SCEE,
     JEREMY SCHAPPELL, JAMES VINCENT
    SCORDATO, ROBERT J. SENIOR, JOSEPH
SHAILOR, LAREN M. SHAW, FRANCISO J. SILVA,
   PAUL SILVA, ROMA J. SOLIDUM, RICHARD
      SORIA, ANDREW K. SPROUL, JOHN L.
     STURGEON, JR., MICHAEL SZUBINSKI,
  CHRISTOPHER TALBERT, MICHAEL WAYNE
  TAYLOR, ANDRES TELLEZ-GIRON, KEVIN W.
  THATCHER, PAMELA M. THOMAS, JASON R.
   THOMPSON, DAVID J. TREVINO, MANUEL
 TREVINO, MILLARD H. TUCKER, JR., JAMIE M.
   TURLEY, DARRELL S. TURNER, RODOLFO
   VALDEZ, JR., BRAD VALENCIA, MARCO A.
    VARGAS, ROY VARGAS, JR., ALEXANDER
   VAZQUEZ, GARY VELASQUEZ, FERNANDO
    VENEGAS, JASON VIOLETTE, EDWARD P.
 WAGNER, JR., WILLIAM WHITEHEAD, CODY S.
  WINN, WILLIAM WOLF, KEVIN S. WORRELL,
           ROBERT S. WOTRING, III,
               Plaintiffs-Appellants

                          v.

                 UNITED STATES,
                 Defendant-Appellee
               ______________________

                     2015-5066
               ______________________

    Appeal from the United States Court of Federal
Claims in No. 1:12-cv-00175-NBF, Senior Judge Nancy B.
Firestone.
                 ______________________
                     JUDGMENT
                ______________________

    RAYMOND CHARLES FAY, Fay Law Group PLLC, Wash-
ington, DC, argued for plaintiffs-appellants.

    DANIEL B. VOLK, Commercial Litigation Branch, Civil
Division, United States Department of Justice, Washing-
ton, DC, argued for defendant-appellee. Also represented
by BENJAMIN C. MIZER, ROBERT E. KIRSCHMAN, JR.,
STEVEN J. GILLINGHAM; LINDSAY K. SOLENSKY, Bureau of
Customs and Border Protection, United States Depart-
ment of Homeland Security, Washington, DC.
                 ______________________

THIS CAUSE having been heard and considered, it is

ORDERED and ADJUDGED:

   PER CURIAM (MOORE, BRYSON, and WALLACH, Circuit
Judges).
           AFFIRMED. See Fed. Cir. R. 36.

                      ENTERED BY ORDER OF THE COURT

 January 7, 2016                  /s/ Daniel E. O’Toole
     Date                         Daniel E. O’Toole
                                  Clerk of Court