Court Opinion

ID: 6651608
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-20 20:54:47.525183+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T15:59:42.262519
License: Public Domain

Sullivan, J.
This was an action in the district court for Lancaster county. A trial resulted in a verdict and judgment, against Ricketts, who brings the case to this court for review by petition in error.
The facts are these: In July, 1892, Rogers sold Ricketts a half-section of land in Lancaster county subject to the right of way of the Fremont, Elkhorn & Missouri Yalley Railroad Company. The purchase price agreed upon was $12,300, of which $600 was cash. The balance was to be paid March 1,1893, when possession was to be delivered, an abstract of title furnished, and deed of con*478veyan.ce executed to the purchaser. At the appointed time the parties came together to carry out their agreement. It was then discovered that Rogers had previously conveyed to the railroad company, in addition to the right of way, a strip 130 feet wide and 1,000 feet long-out of the northeast corner of the land aforesaid. On account of Rogers’ inability to make title to this strip Ricketts demanded a rescission of the contract or a suitable abatement from the purchase price. Thereupon a discussion ensued touching the damage occasioned by the loss of the three-acre strip. Ricketts insisted that the damage was $500 and Rogers maintained that it did not exceed $120, and offered to compromise for that sum. The evidence is conflicting as to the terms on which the transaction Avas consummated, but it is not disputed that an agreement Avas reached, in pursuance of which Rogers delivered the deed for the land, received the purchase price, except $250, and took from Ricketts the written contract here set out:
“Ricketts & Lyon, Grain.
“A. D. Ricketts.
“References: First National Bank, American Exchange National Bank.
“Lincoln, Neb., March 1, 1893.
“Mr. F. J. Rogers has left in my'hands íavo hundred and fifty dollars to cover damages for a strip of land 130 feet Avide and 1,000 feet long-, along the rig-lit of way of the Fremont & Elkhorn Yalley R. R., which strip commences on the north line of west half of section 18, town 11, range 7, Lancaster county, Nebraska, and runs I,000 feet south on west side of right of Avay of said railroad. The condition of this contract is this: If Mr. F. J. Rogers makes A. D. Ricketts a good Avarranty deed for said strip of land, then the said Ricketts is to refund the $250 to Rogers. A. D. Ricketts.”
As to whether the $250 was retained as agreed compensation for the loss of the three-acre strip or as an in*479clemnity for actual damages to be thereafter ascertained is a question about which the parties do not agree. The contract quoted was executed after the delivery of the deed and payment of the purchase-money, except the sum of. $250. It was executed at Rogers’ request, expressed in this language: “You give me something in black and white -to show that you owe me $250 on the purchase price of the farm.” The entire controversy between the parties related to the amount of the purchase-money which Ricketts should retain as compensation for the loss of the three-acre strip; and thus it appears that the written contract was made and delivered as the final repository and appropriate evidence of the conclusion reached upon the matter in dispute.
At the trial the court declined to construe the contract and submitted it to the jury for construction. In view of the conceded facts this was error. This agreement recites that $250 is left in Ricketts’ hands to cover damages, and clearly prescribes the condition on which Rogers shall be entitled to receive it. Its essential terms are not ambiguous or obscure, and extrinsic evidence was not needed to aid in its exposition. The judgment of the district court is reversed and the cause remanded for further proceedings.
Reversed and remanded.