Court Opinion

ID: 4046721
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:14:16.459044+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:40.019635
License: Public Domain

RECEIVED                                                 coJSeals e
                                                            SECO°OD£TSICT OF TEXAS
       OCT29 2015                                                    „„,„*
     courtofappeals                                            OCT 292015
f   "%£$%£.%£!*                                             DEBRA SPISAK, CLERK

                                      i/v               ;

                                                     oX-tr-ootU-cz.
                                                     oi--is--dd£0-CO_

      TrnU co^ri- c^b<^HoSr                 /354o/sQ               i32£oi*iQ
                                            /15 iotro              l^ittOD

      tylor cMztHfo (- fit c^^/

              £*cb><#$. pisLo^^ 4*JL}.A-pp*)fa*k5 /WnirTQ^ ft> AXxzU- Afpe^JL

     .Scjffe^vvj iQnL&^JloL, hcc^LSJJL. j^ hn>(c^ J~JL [cu^.
                M£L xb Ovh^ Wt>U£*i$ Jz*vhzty*^> o-*/ &U*
      7y*CJip, Acfc^K %£*OH &"d t_^£L by krotcuiMj Ac4$^z0^ %CoHjf
    fc S^mH^JL

1
    Q_gfaj n Clc£\jcJL crlMv^T C&W/yitfeJl k>y apPdi^^Jl £&<~^S*d j
A"7n{-f0f\ jSjlC Se-LcA Utafr^f Pur* Af/>e.llc^+ fz>£o/isvft

H> Take- Active QLs&uaAJh ±o j-ke, CocSc of Jiyjicja.1
C&aAkjJt Cgsig^ &0%} Alcriio/i for ?**• Qrjincf 6ovrj-
ofjAfjpeds -fa Take. Ac&Qsx p^rj^c^ f^> f-ke isH- ofAfp&Js' j~o A\sce^arA Appe~ lights Br<r~

           0
Torr^/vf- dow/vfy ^y j4-fpal*feJ! AfpQeU
Uff^hML iaejfj/e /Wafto-^ for /?e^ frf^-( prgcee^iKj-r; J%/f
£^<^ /**f /fa.dc*L-_ ^sifz^h/iH^t*^ -for cxlh^-^sh 6 wlqMLs,

ft?&&a^ &>r yk2*j JHcJl f,s -f^ £»?/y ^fp^ch^iy -fa pres&J-fo
{-4>£ h^cJL Cosjr^_LJJjr^^—ffljkrif$t irU>*± ~h> c£e.v-*lt>p<. c^rCc^rJi h> J^to^h^e
IrrSfeA- >9.W,^?

Wo(a1-iA$ ArkccS*J5. &4&L5EL dflJL /cot(&j. TJ#-Se a-i*^s
Cly appeal }orte£ faya*JL
firau^L t^efAfW/y. forc-lAA me~ H> j^r{e\ f j-Ll.
purposes. cvuft. h&Jif£>kr Qf #2&H<»s fvf fb^o irf&i
DfiP C&eJik«s      wImajl J2 \AroiA.CtsrrickAJt C/XjJjclJJo^ cx^A. 'but far*
fa^se, trrcry &±c£]^^                                 31 woAy
 A^s/^P/ty £/y /??y cippogl IqN'e£ gA fergsSL
         12 Atori igjLJAJ^ IV?f^ C^gfrg U/r^cAw o-t-hU Z?3L**
"Ale dr?»4\.ejr tomsT? Jfj-eJ} Agc^zt swQ cla^J />?ycycpe*l
 by MSI. sA*5^>^i- JT€on^^i(y c A~^ Cs>*sri~o£ ApOS^Jis, J^oa (y 6-sfaiJ "for C-J>pt*-% &/L Ap U)A.^/7 9^/a/i^i^ Ptsf&/iu£>+o h?S
 jJAjj^r .fake-.. f^ccp. ArirccdcL *XC,o9 ^*£y
WtJls. eife^ €t>r CtppoUfrJl .rh*ys Cat/el ^T^aMxK'h
Pi^4^c^.jf-^^£A^iig dpph^s A?
faU. CA of Affittds p*^rSua^f jo J$kfa&K &DXr but X a^v
ta&ftv^ d&s$*d- Counsel far cuzslsfavmL. tv/f-/v^^ Ar^rccJUs
A?&. sK <52>^ Iw'pCa t^efj oaJL Hits q£fe<& ^> rx^p^ai.
         /%%£, sA U2)Aax fatJ fr4L Joy hU r^fu±cJ2 j^6ohi^^Q^k
/in IssotdzHosx 6-f ^>c Qt$c)p(touory rubs jT^c^/o^ /s&5  -far fats cH*^<* jofeu
of CoA&Sr ffa Scxt& crt»**=* fa y£>*Jj -/-/*_ 5ec^W-f~ cjocfa myAtff*1*^ 4-p l^df ^t r
         Iv/vaA ^3 \atot$& j rs +Aqf iTv^g UinscA ®/ss>
JT^k/tr crf»*s Cs«-r£ irf&LolJ4 °^ <%f fa-** r*Z-> lt4h>$*-*rf T?* Pr&tpifr*?
 £•£ AjA f*> GxJ* K^cfa*. C~OA£/K 3 OX ~ "A*"" /*-*• -f-p £^/vtg Qfjcrf, t{*-<*ry
 \rTv(ccU oa^j o*~& Crfi+*k? A^ct^d fi&~j?++
         /Ae3e InrUifat A.cA £.y A^ Qtffanwys^ JTc/Jlj^
UrfccA, OaJI, /n*lt sA J^>/i*x Av **>(<**. /fyvrxU T^fPj±^M ,
(2z_Coj$l *hUy hofk Wvyih /ru. fa S<^'&fe\ &>r j-U. CNs^s
LDt?i/n>'H~*J< £>y /$?R. sAJ^A^. afal ^jyJU& ty^cA *>v
 W   -

 Ate- R°^ $(&4rrcJ* Co^fa oA s^npeAS; Q4 fa*- Crtvv^L*
 (Xr-A po4&4f<*& A^w^. 4-Aiy CjQljjS^J ~h "**- c^X /ny QpmM
        /{-etfaer rT^AyL. UvfciA A/r /7?fl^ s~k J^A^v or*.
/Qg.frv* {zyr-jk/yjU- or AoSL*-*1~iW fajLlr 0Aiij."T~Uy6&ft
A&JL C^JLofa fa f*p*rt AAil Qrlm.es fa A>U 9^'Dto\r*J*
CoorA oA Appeals /Veff^&i 6?a^ r^>^r4^ -f-iU. ov*^* A>y\ Majrfer fie, fan* Co^ft- Q^/Ur^y htLS cbfa
 fa \ua/ngrl /s^g (y farivic. -fa Co ^rjz c;i^ >Jjg. ivf^ X.^S qaJL+UcJ.
al~(f? 4&tfer*C J&£. 93/ s.ou.vJl. rxt H shd^r
   CcL/±a^ a^C&Jb- d-f ZF-'MtucJL Co/^ci^cjf pr^^cl^r -fAd-
f A fV pvrMtvtJc^ rCCJe^eJ by S7>JlyL. rcds*S £^S+oajjcJL
&U^j?j^L± 4.3 A* AAe t GS /dujyer )y\ pj-U* r^yzsi<^h/ Z?f-&Ce- &-(r &&Wicd2 £oc*A*S*-l 6 A 3 fat* E PT SrlaJpL.
pj-U/^ VLOproprkM. ClcJ±^^ j^J]^J^far^ lf\ AILA/re, Iq/
 £{(* SAfP*., Co.M ol 5u<9, CO^JLsi^ Cj2&*£\a
Su k>d 0,(20 ^               _
         /T'Ve rs A^_^; AA^f j>J^,
U/Jsci. >W * rft^, ftwl Ak £^ DKictd cA ofAffiaJ*
 /Iot^ ^foAjz^fajsr ^t^5/-zl^i^rifa^ &*c£>^yl±' —ttfe- r& Hoi #__ ____r
 4.La^jyt^ fa Cq^ife.%$ /its ca**** (X^Ji pr&tti^ Ars
 \ru{A4fX^6U C~(\G>\Tr -* Z^cyjly^ tv-iscA is /lot- {r*srh\~r-'cifa. e^o.^L
 to r^f-erf M.2. (5A £rg>A^ efjh^,                                        '
          /fiA^A^gl

-ffajh <\ tCtA?sv/(fM£ <\ \rro(oL\fa<^ &+~\-UT&-S5i0/KfiU CoaJL^cJ- j-fafraises
0. <$ty^^5A^^A^i Qrr>cs^^\ ^S ^ fas*-£~a~jy*rs d^^Eifa,
i-r^jrfw&rj-LiAcss, c?r Anfc«-&s a 5 a /txjyer fry gjA__
rtSPtssfe ^A*S/ h^faiQHrs fab- ef4tc*. aAAA* 6i%v*rcJl
 t£>^2, «Si£ P?^ . . fS fa j*U/p uAcy>Q>chiAJh Ow-dj
 p6rfcc//y WI £/ iVvjj . Ae_ faj- /nxz Suffer fb>- /jo err***-*
  //& CjQa n*i- he jrvs-fcJ fa failocj -hlsL /q*j or
project AfS cheats /klqJsj aaJ? if >(ec^y />g frusfa/
fajt&tZ y <^> lA-Ag. £^AA AAfkj ,
      <5o iv/fA'H/ff /Wfar/h^^l^\/ Vbrzi 4-Ac^ f*AW>^gLi/>^

  Lf>u~l W »W /6u 3-^ P&3*- Mofatt fa cTc-J?w tvH^cA/ JTiSS
.j^l^^-^s -IT /C^Uy prt-se^r i~lr> &* y&^ 4.S g
VtelcJ&ri CXppJZ.Iic+Jr j^AAj cA^H^A /v>3 r$^~ Ad A^
 e44~& o A Appeals 7~oi<4- A^k^rt y/u>A /? f^ t>iA^i&q
 ^a^^v tbOl Aft^^5^ /#,>f q/s^ l/AA^\

,^Ai>feA^Ar^    (SaAt9^v SflA^ S^e As Mp^ /^o^fgo^.

    CL^T.jA^e w)^ fg<^c^g=s l/^A>r>*^W/<^v GfeaWy 5faW/*A/K)

/?gts^\ fc^A^^iJeA^JL far-cur QA-q-H^a. JTl^je A/lS'
j'ju^^iAJth^ a o A -fArs  fix (Q-A/uK JT^lc^ £f{fi£5J far office
 ,<£*,// frvfir,K Ate s-tttfa £&fitomhst*^ g/v Cr^J\cj^(

        Jvijg. wiWv Ajl.^ ^iiceuty \j/u>cv
   _oA_A7_y -€>^^j^ / #e
 ?A t\TS CO <-<4~r h>y fay OjOOplM^A 92^>/"Afly /^^ jA*-^^*-,

 Ai^A relief Ajt- A"^- pr^ztjJic*- r s^t-fax.
          X £te^e^ if ^ fte&kk>£%. fir fcjjL &•** Or.virtch
 r-^o^cSA^ t*j^C^sfix k^fac__ XT ^6, 6^r>^W £Qiy>lc*~±
 &A5       tSroJc^ faJ^A<^A. jjfaj_4&_. hi^r4-tfUL qaJ. 4^ ajl
 fa S 3^-ow^c^ &A £o^s*?\
TA \AroJd he hsrri^fa l^Tion^ j-faj- X\sL?UJ
 C&A-UWLscdly hfch*r- -jAo-JT^
      #p 0 -f A^ p^rpo^L , ^ /ou2-cu._h*A&*r.
        /f^ tfS/Zjl' F£*5&rt£k&y fao/2_\ fa.h-._jS_fa fas eyp&r-P
 &cc*Jbch r^Cp^^AoeA^^s/ 6cyi/T °t Toyofa c.c\Mery/ f»r oa. f ^r^ .A'A/V <*r^_.
 &!/ -r-U*vx, T~^f rs penXsr*J fasfl*K~e>siy ( J^fa
 ^Oi_A£ -eypzrf SC&d o/^ faU. V^ P^y oA_i£/___.(
                  ^^s^AILM_^
  0 A/>7y C__i\ €scff ^£cfcc/jg PltiiMof- C~c rvw- (h# *** ##/aj
  f-M- fayoj-c, Caw^ry.? "7^ 5gt^- 0 /A #€^Ca~s
./V^y yiot/rc/ZCAf SL)*porory sfVl fa^cJ- dcZU5^J fa/u ,#7^y t6/i^>/ aJLfao^k ^ ^ ^ A»
 Pffify A3 C^y oA Aty ^_ur____j^ ^ rg^Vrtao /* ^/pc^rj-
 Acs ^^aflk lofo(o^eir 7^ £>5C. r^ f< A-4-H

 /3ml rA x: /a*r5h pcDA<£^s6tL Airfic*. foyou fatdr-
 C^oryjh^s _2_x_Js Ors____ cA-e. ir-rvtapU-. jTf rs A*-* ^^

         /faco c-Qc^tj) fa cAooSc /ZAy t y: y^g sKo»U
 Wu~_> n* A /aelAj L^eij**. //* fas
                                                           w
         Tnrs rs n&fz J^^f^
Ivkcfa cio^s flo^ SoMs fa AA*. 6^A5fAi/^ci( r^o^m.^
th &A b-*A aA 7^03m - o JrSsrfa. //^ /o AoPCJ^>
A?cibL my n^kfa A° ^g**i^uA CeJts*^ _Vk Ar\ix^JU^ XC^H^I
<^zQ trt>5~:( jSTcJ.
prtzco&J-^o "£lW fe> Ql*_^y_o^^ /2irli\ /riy QppLg^A^^t^ *>^5f~ fa y?/A^^ fiA«l
 Caf< L-S5,                              ^                     _
        ^PfK iA^A/i A*-% _hkroke^ t-U Cgy^o Av.y , afa/V$ WI(A J^dy_ Issr/ScM, a A fax. 2^^Cm.
-5y5y&K • «£V fa a/tgt^^ fa hrpzfe: faU. (o+J Q«fa! t^o^ociy
Will prvfadt t*uj 7~hjy ci&4f{y /vfr-ir* AO C'$pac£ fa^
\JOurT C-^^fa/ Ow^i WdJ-A AlUMt y^3wi \AT^s4* \y£>^^r
fay**, <<>/v ou^ ofp^rcJ. /2&A ha<&$ &w /fa m^rf^h „
 f~A*y tsviUCvUy wa^tf- \/o^ +* h<_ export oAA/eJr
 Cxok^ 5 pa.^&Xs/Ja$ ./&£r^l_jfr
   f£5(pecA figC y QLsr rO(sr+- QAcJg ^f-ke 62-gg.i ^y^fe.-/^/ ;i^S*-lf
  /)?£> ?,> j^r cA o i~Ar)ftet£s fa Tc\fce_ .&fao^ far cJL 0 f AppmA^ fa U^ rt^crA
        £2 farfa*^ f><~&y fAaf fafa Lo^rt- cf c*ppjzcd$ ujjl
   /Y?y ST flo-ttaz^S fa Ay r /~TAjer~5

&) c>rA&\ e^rz^U^A pxalrox £sj-cA o£Ujflfigals A Tftfc£- aeJkw^Ai^ Caxs^z&l. _m

                                                r^xg^MjLL, &^**jfe/

       C^t -fap&*d*>
       ^4^                                       gkjgg^ a $kaJI po-Arof- * £ r**^

                      /Y^J> r   o 3W5~=- ## /6%-cJZ.
                                o A- ($— oo I kr—<&
                                aX~ls—oc(66-tfL
                                OZ-lS—OdM?-^

             _                        Vli
                         Tfa &AA a A r<^3                           ^feA
   £po,^v AA .V2>^ ^irJt^iJj Ot^oA <$td2k A J~aro^T c^^4y

 ^ <3refcx. ftrsvo£Mfi flL&ktr^ f-o .4-flgA fa 5cx43A'AA c&^^s^l

   ordb^ artwtiic A2ope*< Aer gWA W-crmAr- fc TM^s± en.

   cCJL^. <^to^U^ 'AA+Ui*/^ A>r c4-a4~-AffiaX*is fofi9&&A> UAr-e^ sfa5&fa

                                 I    '
                  moo
                                    'a3
                  10 55 ~*
                  Cfl aj "n
                  > —>
                  ?? - -.-
                              j_
                              -°
                              :v»
                                     o
                                                             1
                                                       r-,
                  no."        H
                                    .< •                      f?
                                    -J
                                               s
                                                              C

                                                              *S
                                                              T
                                                             •o
                                          5 **-

                                                              $2
                                                              4

           I fa
                                          ro
                                          o

3                                              ^1

           CL-©
ON
      c
           ^

O
          ^ ^
          ^
          ^>,
     (3

                                                   o
                                                   o

                                                             ~a^—'&.