Court Opinion

ID: 4056364
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 07:46:56.880742+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T13:56:55.583162
License: Public Domain

-   ~6_,_ a~8-oz
                                                                                       .. --  -   ·-·   .

    Daf~:A~ql)s+'~~)X!Jts-

    W\ Ll; ~0'\. \-\a~w~ Fre~tnCW 1_Sro.
    TDGT-C.~D f\)o \~1'if1Sf3                               This document contains some
                                                            pages that are of poor qualit)f -
    A\ lvv B. Po\ UNSK'( u~l-t                              at the time of imaging.
   3~12 F,N\.350 Sou+h
   Liv;Nqs-1-of.J)\e~S 113SJ
   Re.~ C:ADSE     NOS:\ 32.'2..2_5<'/f /32t:2_ bO
           S+y\ed. ft.J Re. ~ w·,L\..\aM fu~luard l=tee.-Vl',aJV,Sr.
   C\..e.r K fot'" +he C,o~rt
   P.o. i2>o~ 12.3 og                           . ·
                                                    o+ Appeal
   Aus.f'~N,; Te)l..~ 1f7//
   Dear Mr. Abe\                           Acos-ta)

    Please +\,l\Jd erv~cfpse.d +he c;>r~9.·;~Jal aNd oNe COf?Lf- t>..P
    -the ·f€ \afo V' P, e+ I+ I ON feu- W \"\+ ot- \'CV\dl-J d..aM VS • pfeaS e
                                                    J

    +:i\e 1+ W1+h ·fh~ ~ouri -A.copq ot--t-tns)?e-·ht~o}J has_ be.eJJ
    se.tv+ {o--lhe. fl~t <:ct>ur+ o~ Appeal                          V1 a -~,s       \\e+fer-
    ThtlN\( 4ou.. ~r- 4our l<\Nd help d.Nd assis.f-arvc.e 11\J -H"s
    tna-+ter                                    .                       ,            ·            ·
                                                        SitJc. erely)
                                                        ~.~A:~s~~-

                                                                       RECEIVED IN
                                                                COURT OF CRlP.~iN.~LAPPEALS

        . - -   -----   ...   - --- - --   --                         SEP 0 12015
t_. Chris D~,vje/~                     ·+o
    have ·---\-he ap-pe\\a+e record ~~VrNI-s. \n_ed. w·Jnoerf __ _
    ~harqe. See whi·t-ehead V.Sta-te,) r~os,w.-:3 cl '6b(p}
    'ltl3 -1_'/-_lTe)l... cri ItA_ .. f\ pp ._.loof) _ -~·- .•   _

      ~~-1- bav'! ~.i.\e a M_ot~oN _+o _+he Ha r_r-1 c; CQ u~~--'DJslrief
      ~ \er K> C. h r1 s D ~rJ \ e \ s /-e1-.. e c. u-t_ed orJ _±h e_.l3:\-_~ dfU-t_of _ .
     1u\~ c?-Ol5; c3f\-1d.J±_was~ refurNe1 VoID ON -su\~ .J~:th ·
      ~ol!>( at Ll.',3lt PoNt___ 3\a+,_N_~ -~a+ \!\J aeco1da~_ce. LYrfb-
     .sec.:liow !5 6d-.0~ 6ovetfYleA!f Co__de_) Re~ues+ ~r- . .
     \t\JJ:OrMd.-\-~orJ .--ttDM \Ne..at-e-~t&fecd itJd·~~fduCJI_; _ . _.
       __(J\) _f\ qove_r"? Me~aJ kx>dq-; 1s_ Q\l!d- re~vo:-ed-fo _e)'c,ef*
      or c.o~'~--~t~ a r~zves! ~~ }~M~'oAJ ~~: . ·. _
        __ (\)AN \!Ucl•,v,dual WhO r"5 tMpr15Q_Ned VI-- C!lJ/IJ-fJ,'N~cl
      \N 'd c.~r-rec+JoN~l .f:ac.U ;itt· __         .           __   -~: .·

        'l__C: ~. ~- ~ri- ;tb . o~ (p) Af:Jft€rJd~ who           ~-~~  .·
        cle.ferM/~e~ ~<.t ~ur-I- -lv.pe /tJd;CJeATf }s presuMed
        +o--t.emat~. JIVdiCjeA.J-1 fbr--+J,e. terHa1\ud.et:. of ,+he.-    .
         pr-o c_eecloJqs     Jf\.)   ·+he   C-@5ev                   .
                                                                                        . i

         I.

-   . <..:.;t·   .
                                                                                              f-

                                              '· (oi)
    ..                                                                                                .                        .           '                                                       .
-            ..
                                                                                  ·. CAUSE- rvos·:lg222.5""q·~~· ·. . ·.· .
                  ~

                                                                                                                       ,                               132.2.2 60 .                     ~      '       . .                ;

                              .       .             .            .   .        .
                                                                                                                   IN THE                                                                                             '           .

         _.,-: .-..-.. -_ .1.<3+ _COURT                                                                                                OF                  AP~PEAlS                                                   ·,"- _ , ::,~--
         -.- : '                                                                                                  - a+'_ HOU.STON-- _---~,' · .-_ ~_. :'                                                                                       I-:~- ·.

         _TN· RE: WllLlAtv\ FlA'{WAR D'I?R:EEN\AN ~SR# ·
         ' -                      -             ''          -.                •           .                   .            '           .               .               '       -.   .                    •       :- J_ ·. .

                          ~
                               Rela+o~ · · ·-
                                          - -   -
                                                                                                                   .                                                                                              \           -       ..
         : .              ~           ~                                                                                            ~               '           ~   -
                                                                                      '                                                                                    .

                                                        ~rOM +~ l'62Nd
                                                                                                                           .
                                                                                                                                       0\ str ic·+ Cour+
                                                                                                                                                               '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              ot ''                   .~-

         I-
                                                                                          -H a ~ r ~ s C'o u"r+y ;Texas                                                                                            '. · -
                                                        .                                                                                                  '

         i            '
         f                                      PETrTlON .FOR WRlT OF M·AN.DAl\AtJs···        .                            .
                                                                                                                                                                                    ~   . ·-
                                                                                                                                                                                                             '                                   ..

                                                                                          '.)     '       .

                                                                                                  · \Air·lr1am \-\&1:\~a.rd ·t=~cw)Sr.
                                                                                                      -TDC:T-C\ Dt\lo: l~l8~t3/Pro Se..
                                                                                                            A\\w 8_ Pol'o Ns k4 lJ~J'rt
                                                                                                                                               3~1. F.IV\.3.5tJ SOU·+h
                                                                                                                                       _ Livirvcts-\o,u., Te)(as                                                                           7'73S/

                                                                         --       \

                                                                                                                                               \
                                       TABLE o·F CONT£1\JTS'                 __
                                                             . NUMber PClefes

        IJ2E~I/JY OF PARTJ~S/CDUNSEL _                         ___....-.3
        lfSJ~DE/\-OFAU.TJ10_RlT/ES         I       .
                                                                       4
                                                       I

         STATEN\EN'T OF Tf-IE_ C~Sf__·_ _·-_·...;...._--_---_-6...
        STATEMENT OF JURlSD[C.TION                                      5_
        'JSSUES PRESENTED-                                              1
        ·sTATEtJ\ENT OF .FAC~TS                                         7_
         AR6UN\ENT                                                    . _g
\
f
I

         PRAYER="·--~-_~~=====-.........------~o
         C~RTJ\='lCATE OF. SERVlCE-~---~--·.rr
             .! ·,   J~~;t):'~~~ . .      .    .
         .'. >. ::::!0k~ .•. . .
                      .....··

     ---t-             ..
                .      .    -'.•

                                                       2-.
,,
                      CAUSE NOS: t32225<7f 1321l.{pc)
 IN RE: W\l.l\AN\ l-4AYWARD V:R(EN\A~I.SR.
      ..          .
                                          ___ ..";
                                · - . ·-- .
                                                     Re\~+or
                                                     ... _--.·, ...        l
                                                                                                        .- _.
                                                                                        . . -------- -- ...

       .
           IDENT\T-V' OF PART\ES i
           .. .   .-.   -   .   . .   '               .   .   .   ,   -.       . I. .
                                                                                        COUNSFL
                                                                                         . - .. -" ..   . ·. .   .   .   .

 Re \a-1-o.r C.e~t;+: es M +!.~ ~ol.\ow·uJ"f ·~~~ ·. ·.· ..
. CoMpJ ~~e _\\sf                         o+ ·4-\.,e ?e_. r-4t~s.;-+he- .?#OrNe.yc5) aA)d                                            '
 aru·V\ - o+her. P, ers~tJ LR.l~. 0 , ~so Cli\J~ 1r0.+ere,s+ \ ,v                                                            -th-e
 0v\-C.otJ\t:_ ~ ~IS pe+,+~N/.Br. ·, ::, a, pro / se I;-{-; qCl-;J -t
                                                            a,Jd /s [\) t~f .
 represe.ru-k.:~. by. CoLJ/U~el,r:J -fhe lpro·ceed,,"-f1 1 AJD ~+fortJ~
 ~as \oee,-J d1s 1 1\)Q+ed o~ _rv\f.rJ~hoAlec/ _ DttJ 11-)e .t:Je 17~ J.fi. -,, .
                   1
 ~ ~e., re ~poAJdavf)       ----the par+'-t of ,Jier.es4 .,~ ~ -e S-feAe:
 o+    Te)(a-:>.                             -

                            J
                                                                                  ! --    ---   -·-       .

                                                      _CASES .
                                                                        · . - ,___       ~---     _ ,p¥-· tJ-uM be\~'
                                                                   '      .                           '
,                                             '        .           --                     .                   :.   .       .     ----- - -   I

-~oiJo_wa-4 ~- ~;-+·-+h ·cou~t+ tOt f\p.~ea~~-- -~-~----- __________ _
    '1Co1 ~.w ~ lo_8D 1__lo-8_!f.-(Te'l<..l9~9) -                                                                      "~--- ----

    IN Re~ C:.oro,uado ·9Jo s.w~_:Ld _ b9JJ,q~~~c ,-~~ Ap¢)_~-s~_
    -f41u+aN~o \<:tq~ oriCJ . proe.eeciii\Jq.)     _ • _ .C, _ . __
    ·J~ Re :, -J_e b b \o -2.(~; S.w. 3d ·15 3J7s~-(Te>..-App;- H~u-:s-bN
    [ \44-h D,s+ Ja.ooo) . -            _.                     -~

     t1\J Re : ,Wa ~ h_\ r0.q +o tJ 1s ~.l1J~ 3d a+ l ~ ~ CTe'J. . App.-:: llous~
    I·    .                 •   -   -   __ , --            .   -              -                                                     ---

         t: \stQ D,~-\-.] __\.99~                      _           ., _                                                _ -~6):1         _/
         0\ '~N bce.NCfo; aiJ d h ,s ~, '1~6 -:fn a ,c.o~\ e.--\-~ 4Jf-'l-
ot' h's -\-t,a\ re.tQK£5; aNd a\\ t~~hJ b~1 +ale d. tN -+hvse
pr6,ceed(tv-ct£-~__f0aP~el1"#1£ ~la-hors. C.oM plai~~ D-t-the
C€Juta1 <0-f:. ~e a.ll .. 4he~+ret~SCltlpf..s o-f. &1\ h,s-h-tal - _
appearaAJee. . For- c.\ar',fti> n: \~r- ',s teJ·err-ed +o a~
Fr-eem.,.ILI; res pON:de.AJ~, ~~+st,f re. Rox:aN!IIe ·!~
~:£er-re~-:-fo ..b1;1- N~Me J fU0 i.-Hte.--f-e.&l P~~ l
\N=ft..f-e!+ ~~ re+e.tred fo ~-s %e. .s-!-a+e otT~s; ..
      - -_- _ -Sf'i\-fsl\J\~:-1\Sl   OF- JlJf< \S.D \ CT_(otJ

Jh·,,_Cour+ has ju~tJscild-lol\l-b''?;Lie_& ~i=Lp:f
ntB.Ndarn us Tex.._C.o,us+ . ar+: s-; ~ J )e._')(, 6ov -t
<:nde. §   ~ ~ ..)_~'   c(\_)                                               -------

 I-                                  I

                                     ~)
                                                            '   .   '   -
-------

                                                                                                     .   - .... --......   . ' --   .         -        -···   .   '

                                                                                                                                                                      .   .-   -------- ___....,.__   '

               .      -----·      --~-      ------------------------- -·-                                      ---~--

                                                                                                          '

                   . -·-· - - - - - - - -   . -   - · - - · ---_---   --·-.   ----   ---·-----   -       ,·   ----                  ---   -------   ----------- - - - - ·-             ______ r

          ·,   -- --------
          ,...__         -·----          ----

                                                                                            (b)
                                                        . . ,,   r'   .,

                                            l~. 'l.i\

  Issue 1·. The>+r~,d-l·· C.o ur4::$.:·;··ret:b·~de,r                                        ha ~-+a·r-\·e d 4o
--p,rov.t.de. 4h~- reJ~+or LA.),+\q . Qo·p~es ~+.--+he. +r\aL.' ~ _· ._ •·- .
  !trcirJ~-·\'pf, ~here-ihe l~o~~rab~e "Yud9e.,:""J~-~-:-~'.BurNe,t-* -.
  presrd'-~-'J\J ~i,e /&l~ ·Di-~+hc+                                  Cow.rf; t4aYots                                  . :.   _
  C~ou~-n, ; I f.')( aS. _

                    STA"TEN\EI\l'T   or: -l HS             fACT~---·-;·-_ ....
     ." .' .~ ·;.                                                      ' ~. ':. ·•·..;   '        ' '   .. ! . .   .

 Relakr he t-M aJ i.A.l a_s c_!ttar1eel ilr.J d~" c_of\J ~ (dt>d 1N oNe
 ~eJC..\...Ja\- a s:s-au \f e_a~) &Nd s~~"~+eAJc~_cl-4-o.Sev€.~1 ~ ·
 +.~\le q ears HJ ~~ i saN. Re\~-f:a .r ~tMe \ y a.:pp.e: a.l e d aAJ: ~ - .
 ~\,e.Se a~e eurref\J+l~ pei\Jd·)ru9_ \10-the- \~+ C6-~:r+ · o-:9 __ : .
 ap.pec~\ so+ Hous+DtJ.C0N_ +he, datLreJa+ot- frce,YldtJ ._ -_- - ' '
 pu rc hd sed +I". e., G_·Dpt e s~ -o+_· )-\, c::. +r1._~_. J r.e cor:ds ~- 1\J ,-+~e.        .
 \'::\1 e_f\J-\-··-\-\"'a:\- h\ s d tt··~c+ a. ppeal ?._-1\P_··,::N~s_ -tto ·te- u~s ucc.f'Ss+uL
 however u.po,u receupf- o~+he_·th6)1 t~Cf]k:IS;~/,e_relcior ·
  o!oser\Je~d ~a+- (~:er+~if\J fa\+~ ~ +l,e. -h-.;~\ t-ea:n·d~
   We.re rniSSii\J~ f.taJ\1'\ +he. -1-nd\ Y'~~ordS)oAJd -/-here-fore
 l:<..Hc?ie "b a~-k  +~,e re-~orJ ciarJ+_\ clN d 1f\J ~u Ired a.bov-f
                          +o
 ~e. 'M~ss, rv1 _pa~~-s., +roN'- t\l e -+tla.:~ re cm~C/s. N&:me/4
 4-he. --h-i a\ +r-a;vscqpf -h-oM -H,-e €~·rder ~~~ l~-;:.ON -+he..
 _Safv,e C:..&se 9~ue~ loci +k€. JfoixJ q..-~_61-~Judcle: :fa~. w.
. l~urN)e+l-.                    ~RGUN\E.N\ S

 rp_ro\f:rde
   s s \)~. t . ""11: e- *T' a\ c.o L! r+s re c..,order '\n s -~ _.al l\.e d ~
                      0

                           i
               ~~ ~e\6-tot u. H~ ~op,~ D-t--fue-h:-,f>
                                                                                             d.

 T-r a r0~c y-', ~. w ~~1["-e 7he H        (D   N_ora.b\ e ~ud,9 e)                               J@_l.J uJ,
 Sur-~e.* Bres'd1¥·q '~-+""'~ \<6::trJcl J)1'5Thc-t CourfJ
 Hd.-""~\s ~010~;\~::::,       ·

                                 (1)
                                                    /            I                        .   ---------

 R~ l~ior 1=ree r'OaJJ~ Cos e .f_'S c urce~:H lJ orJ _app~l . L~
--t\,1, c:;_. ~ u rt-J how ~\J er +he ~~ a-Jo.t purcl-a sed_h LS.dr-;.aL
 re.c.mt:..cl.s.l aNd -+b~ _ C1)_od..c.JeJ-k_\o~-~ ·te-fi,~.ed -ft:,_£gr-w~
·ihe_C.42pl.es_& ~\a\ .'Ce(t)~ db; u.)het-e -+he. t-bf\Joreb~-S[Lt{~ e
:fa.t;_W. BurfV_eJt_ was .pte~&>JUO)-:-lbe_re la-+or ,dq. tuo~f.
 have aa~cnu~~-·~emetl'tf e0f law_be_cause :it:'S-'-S--(Vo:+
 &J'tYa+ter t\\.l wh,ch \+ LrlA.J_be: a.oo~ea.\ed_ .-to-#),~ ~ tH·+·.--
 4-ku-s ~-~-ce:\ator._a_sk_s -+h\s (!J)_Qr-*-_fo _qr&AJI. hJ.s__ fv\eci +
~ tnatJd~uS_;                                       qr-dJd-/-}rJCJ h~fV\ +~e _ref)eJ_\ ~e see~s.          I
                                                                I

 We_b~.ve-J_u_tl_s c\.~c.:fl.ot\1. ·4o ~lssu~e_wr,·h -~ ~~m-~g
 ~dit-Js+·?- d)_?-1-r,·e-+---~-ur+ ~ud.~..Or ~a~ ~ur=TjuC:.*_fuJd L\je ~ ISSUed,f( Wri-k        1 .. -
\\Je.c. e.ssar~:=+o etU-1'or.~ our ju.r;_sci) cfTd rJ. See ~ .Go v=+--                                    .
~de. ~/J.e a~ .2.~J (Q)                     I               ve_rfVus+t,~ Lts:t: W1-sl] \qq_q) _____ . _

    ---   ---   -·         ----- -   ----       -   ---------

    ..___ ___        ...

i

}- ~-- --- ------ -(g) ,-
We ~1aVe        No  jur\sd.H:.+ioi\J '+o \ssue a, wr;--t- ~ · ·
h\_:_aNdarvu.J
 1
               s   aqai1Vsf 8 ·d is+r·,c+ e\erK UN I ess Such
13 Nec.e.s-sa ry -fu etufbn:e our ju r} s         d; c+ioAJ .. Se_e 1t'J
Re. C,oro,vado 9flo S,u.J~J_d 0qi 1 lo't.l CTe'i . App -Sal\1
~Jru+o~\o lctll'l!.orl'l. proceed1~9))5urnm·,+ sau}J\J(f~ 1\~s~..v.
8q,re!.1a !A'l s.w.~~ \O(o) 101(-re..~"App .. - ~ Arutoi\J• o
1q· Y1J Ortq. prcc.eed, klq) Id ai- l,J Re.- Wash a J\) q+f>tJ 1 ~. UJ.
3cl a+\~~..                                   ..        . · .
      ""Th(s C..out-+ h·as +~e JurisJ.ictiorJ 4o i5~Je a tur'• t
Hcla}!Vsf ~e respoNda,vf be~aus.e of +he Mhu\s+tia\.ac..+
~1\)_\JP}~ed a1Ud_:+6e£~c..tl"hot .:he. has.a"Lappeat pw.di~
IN.-th,s ~ur+ a.t +h,6 f, Me .. CotJ·t;;,ef>ue.v.J-['1 4-(,)ts lou~
Sh.~t.d.J__ l~ue-lhe..ma,u da~ucs aqa_lJJ-s+ ·-Fh~~a\ c..ou-rt
a t+h ouq t, ·fhe m a 1\J JsiV\ vs I S fa e d a'J.a\ A\ sf +he -~-h-)e> \
C.out4: rv~erihe\ess the res.pefl.lda.Nf \CS u~der ~e
Qo.v+n:J atJd .au+hor-~t~ O:f -1-he frl&' C.Out-t ~ b9 VIH-ure
.D~ i+_s au+\.cr.-~·r'\_do-\he ·respeNdatJ+ ex:+ orta .• \ f-o aq..J·,
\Ju-t i+ is +h~ te'5poNdatJ+ -\-\,~ ha~ ODJJfro\ of- #e.·
dmuM·eru+s         -+h~+l.,e       Relator   seek's...

Arv app_e\la+~.reeo~d,~ ,,J\)\-ecp-i+~        :s c.t-vcla\ ~t" pr-?pe-r
a~ e.l\e:rfe t"e\JI euJ_, WhlC.h \s ·-fhe t'lqht .d~-appe \\cl.Nf l.NUo)ves.
w ~ h c purG ues aN a.pp-ea\..                  · ·
ArJ appe \\a-i-ds   ri9ht ·+-t? appeJta+e re\J'1ew '1*5 al2c..oMpaNl.ed
b4 +he.d~ +o provik- a.,u aecvra~ r~c.ord 5u~ic.l~·fu;.
·~~ d-?(Jet\~-\e \:out-t ·-\-o tper-forN'l d-s 1u~~taJJ.-to dehiYIIJve.
-the. CotfE:CfNe~ c* +he {\Oo..J& f:...0urts·Ju~e~-/; 0\.t1·~o S;w.~ Ill-(:.) lSJ..l"T~~Apfx-
Dallas J9·qol                                       ·
                               -                         -

\~~-.bvrde\,u.\~_ DN ·+he. ;plat--.~ 5eekh.JC} tevle~~ ~e
·~ ~~u-t+\c.\e(\.)~ ~~C Cotvlm'r!fed_a ~e1oN~ ·
         o~wse- b~ OM.\i+\ tJ~- ?i-'-ts ot-· +h~-R~J_ah:,r5_re-ciJ·t:dsJ
         arud a\"50 a c.-ted Lu~+h .pur-.po~ .aNd_ ,~,v·+ -ho r_avse~e.
         re\a+o_r: __\la.:rM __\o_tt_c[-e_ru~'.._JJq_b.tM_+h-e tfems he Sf~k~~-~e
         re\a-ftr ~~ r:pea+edl" C:.OI\Apt.a:J')ecl d.bou·+- h\~ records.-
         ~(\/\ -+he ,-fr,a l hel~d _ .bq_-+re.!f-o~ok"abJ.t;_J"ud~e_Ia.q_~ · _ _ · .
         :6vHl)e--H-.t(V #1e IP~tJ.J_·.J)!~tr·C:i+ Court/ Hdrrls CotJ!I}kj_) .
         T"e}(ds . R-e\~tor- ~reeMarJ r~ tNNoceAJ-f oP -the e-r-)Me he .
         .was. C:o(\.)~''c-1-ed. e:>-F_,) bv-l-t.P-Jhe \~Sf>OJJda.Alf·atJd 4e+~t1;>1 ·.
         C.ovri- W1thhokJ Va \u.a.b\Cf 'records.; h bUJ carJ he -+IH~Ai ·
         ~~\e    arJ e~ec..f/ve ap~eals lor-le+ .yro~_INj h',s           lNtJoceiCice(

•   ..
I   •