Court Opinion

ID: 7364533
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-07-27 23:50:18.74305+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T16:20:43.446446
License: Public Domain

MAYFIELD, J.
Appellant, as mortgagee, sued appellee in trover to recover damages for the conversion of a lot of corn and cotton, and in case for the destruction of plaintiff’s lien upon the same property. The corn and cotton was raised by a tenant of defendant during the year 1907. To the complaint the defendant pleaded the general issue alone. The plaintiff proved that he held a mortgage upon the property for $-100, which was unpaid, that defendant had acquired the property from the mortgagee and converted same to his own use, and that the defendant’s rent had been paid by the mortgagor, and rested his case.
The trial court, over the objection of plaintiff, allowed the defendant to prove that he (defendant) applied the proceeds of the property taken to the payment of the demands due the landlord on account of provisions and supplies furnished the tenant, and to the payment of a note secured by the defendant to a third party for advances for a previous year, which defendant claimed constituted a lien upon the property in question. The plaintiff obie-cted to the, introduction of each part of the evidence, and excepted to the various rulings of the court allowing it, and moved the court to exclude same. The court overruled plaintiff’s objections and motions, to which he excepted; and in consequence thereof the plaintiff suffered a nonsuit, reserving such rulings for decwion bv this court in a bill of exceptions- as provided under section 3017 of the'Code.
*297The trial court ivas not in error as to these rulings. The evidence was admissible under the pleadings and general issue. It did negative the material allegations of the complaint. Such evidence is admissible under the general issue in an action of trover.—Barrett v. City of Mobile, 128 Ala. 179, 30 South. 36, 87 Am. St. Rep. 54. The judgment is affirmed, on the authority of the above cases.
Affirmed.
Dowdell, C. J., and Denson and Sayre, J.J., concur.