Court Opinion

ID: 4072827
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 03:13:43.50842+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:35.031790
License: Public Domain

5 ,776997/
"517575/75'. )\97577_7-~'6. 55577 679 __ » “" f ' "557\77: 756775969 97,90/5`
~' 655#757557933- ' 1 ' ' _ 5
- 7\\/597'/./ _S'E 057 y §
P.. 0. 605< 67032 . § : _ _
157566755,77;)_7755 75966'035'¢/ ~ _2 ' _ § § ~ _ .
' c 5 ¢`~ nlMlNALAP
_7755 797 30577665 757 -~; § -~ §§ PEALS
me 67565767 “’07169777515)756 757>7>67565 6 , #» _ - l 362 Z§§§- _
975. 75755< 793753. 6991`7756 57A717557 '
150571.55,7555$’ 7377/ 5 j A§§§A§§§§a §§é§§

 

RE; 757)7166 6779`,766 756 7515_59655 99757775775 57757:66_7~. 2'55 &X9A97'6
' »595\966 755`776:5 579- 77 927_777~ 77§ 772_7A6775757Q7 67577`56=
_ 557755969 F757 717/57675,.:55 796 1\;7579777 7756797 757: '5/566/55' 67577,777,

 

 

 

 

 

. 775 7777; H7555;',` '675757`56_7>657557_5_55,.-666757< 779 979/~/60¢/”

n § _ °5, 565 7759775759/6/6)56>/4~/75/977/ 967 757 999/57557675 969/26§75)7/5777755

5 " 93 7977\-6 657-597 575 70 7’7/15 /7575975 /57567557 96 995 072/569 {§77£

"` ' 717/75 67575975 7\657‘57557 96 977/5 /59656-72 977\ 7577/567/65/( 5697"£/7/669 97 520/51 '
755/57166 5190/71 9997)?.5576`/5 9777)9557~‘7 ) - ` - ‘ _

', 1575 775 6676§7 777/5799¢5557 77797597/55)_7' 666/56 677697\76596 75557\ 15

\7,'4(?1€7 " j _ §§,7, ' '

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

-' _ 11111:111911115 -1'11;195 001115117;111651' 151 1175 11919155111177 ‘.117;1~111.~.1;`

711 1\1\77715 00111115 '11111115 1611/45; 111711;14'11;116 111111775

 

1179 607997_51011177161166 70 717;15 791/1791 7\€ 671311;71\1171 1717/7

 

11111611611655 9111 10 951/11015 1111110,7511751 500411101

 

":`LA"

111171 777;75 7475&11695 /17:11111/1116 671/111 1111 151 1“')1: /6365/1'6 5119071@

 

5 7511115701911 1114 z 517151515 015 79111>1519 1159 7117 715117'1`119 1167-'1;

 

6\6871 1111/1617 72ELAT7~19 7414€(§7117£1//\17673) 774£ 711)7A117?116 (‘191).»'.'

 

PYSCATL\SG 673 @A.,~‘I'l 11111\11~91/1_7 '191)' 01777747=12.172/;20151 `~

 

» 7311 v1'111,51 1171~:5111131, 11710151-:9:17 11075', 1957/1109151114111“

 

111511 1111174 57111'1 111109111551 601.1115757 75110`£ 1101171 10

 

7“1 ,.
79E`6AT7W 1”17176751791\1111/9 7115<1_ 135116`5577413 7'1’91116 /7171197

 

T$ 11111§7117':79?[1)@ 111/91 779 741167) 71 H751L(2I116jm"1'1/73 7’£7116 /07197` »

 

1061 111/11<6- 75111/1:71153. 117111 79£611109_5 71711 741/111 1015 1019 '

 

197/111:17 A111\ 11111 5567'1011 470) '7257/410195 1\01711 4 120/5

 

7117911‘ '31711' 1191116 71071191 1101161\ 11111511519 72561110195 1051 111

 

' 774E 171/416 1677;1_1/1£163/9 197€.;7077 /407 717/917. 797-' 711731.<73151711115 5

 

 

 

' » A5511A1167- 1115 1011115756.'_'/L'1\1111 177/11 951/1109 11117 5001 797-

11911111 1011 011

 

\`

 

' , 11..111:6 19 7191 1701 5…1117117415A 1111/111111111:( 6117;1

7956111079 601111511713 1171-55 /111111115199 19 1015 00117917111415 _

 

1111710111 311074 7451\191111‘/111111) F11615' 117161 1575 75511417;717/:1

 

717/11 7191216,§ 79116 /7/11519:_115 10 11119 0611'1`/175 67111615191711'17-

 

957/110195 01217111107 1111\‘7 1717 120/55 11701'1 075 /11110'7/1\71711$ ../5515

 

“ 1147_1 101101’5 19510911 01 9011117195 171/111 511 911/5 717111117,401115),

 

/746§ 6117172_'7 GA\/E 175 072715/2 619~/67£721172`1\1@ 7746' 75511€£1‘9_‘; 2

 

` 726'671111725 661117105 [.S'EE 77715 /’11111915 7\111,1151 971,5707€ 0/9/1<57271
7\151€11 1146 195597111/76111 /11117:' 1111 11111516511111115 1111/\ 111/195 /`

 

 

7661 _5 »

79561 511116-/717':111 10 1141$ 700191 601167§1911111& 115 0911379
' 113 ')

 

 

 

;'_7111 212,1211/5*.'7111\7 12651`>116111267 111\»1611 21511)611111:~21-§11271165' ~

 

§A11121;L 0 2113 1107 w1277 6661.7(677196 661/1716 71166 761“1)6/661/

 

'»»_711',75 6111167 06 1167/1666 1212/1151 167711 A;)A77/11116/111167_711;

 

 

';_1_31&0/\/1 7116 156513116/51671 51111'111.766 ‘/7175 661/67 711/17 12656661/11175

 

 

112166 116/1 6156116116675 66566651: 76 7111471161166)1561_§ 7//2*561711675’

 

6661/211 611 66167116611/171¢6/1/9616 12 26/_5111)/-)77/1)

 

663 1376/1:166,5 /\/\6111§ 69 7116 767/11 11)11127 111711607 71/1~' //1911/

 

1 \76`65 1112 13-A:1'12 111;1\67665 73 1111/2566 6661151£/_1 6‘1 66167616. 67766

 

' ' 161167116 1165 1167 7116 76111$ 611611165 7116121)611111)7 1115 /66121-_-»'

 

556/16151?6113 11771-./ THIS 61)1)127 1911 017/1611'£10 1_’)1£1/1/5 6611 77/6 76761

 

_ 661/67 1165 /1/11_:7 1\1111`\1 666 66156671~1/ 1166/112 719 660/16277165.

 

"/_'611616667116 61-111`7116_5 13111665 1213 6661/76115 56661/'/1161761 6661

 

1716771165 011 711 1311_61771/6 655757/.1616 612 /19/)11511 ///:17125 611/116

 

‘ 1;1217 611 11661115- 1116/115 111/1 1 1 101 1167 1//)7 113/1111 71r 766

 

51 010?AL /'61)/£'/’ EH_-[T§ TD /\/111161': AA)J F`TA)AD)/Q_$ 1013 §1:/7'701\/ “//6) 7D l

 

' 61511176/2`5 611/276 6012/113 511/16 1166 1612771112 1167 77 1/71166

 

66 1111 1611L 1371111:111611) 711 7111'5/’111/127 111111;166 1607 126561~116`1] 7763

 

 

__ 11551)1£ 1161\6'/2 /1/1116/11\/1/1115 16666161176661€1/171165511311;/111666 1);?: 26_6_

1116171-)12 11 117 1057 76 711/13 111/176 66 11 7111»’ ' 571171§/111~)1' 1177/176

 

 

,`Tl-|_F QE$@OA'leT GN£H FlTZ$T/WMM\)§ /-\10_6_7L10 _,’1/1./1€7,/-11`1',7//_662'7' -

 

 

7111')15-,'25111§20 ~A 6 111 1106 2062/1 6\;111117111 511111115 1261¢1766'3 667671/6/ 4

 

666111;1177116 67 6 111/277 61 111/1711/166115 616/2115 111/15 117 7116 77/11/

 

61 711/13 1271766 66 1125 6266 1126/1'11~112:7 1167 111/15 6661 65 111661-/

 

62 1111711/111)77 67 7116 665666//6_67 /’11-`66 / 51:1: 711-515 /'/16127_5' 6661/211

 

 

"_(621

617 1255666/11:67< 116611_1/)_ 21)1¢1‘_ 116771111117'7 761»'115 6651>1)1<1: 76

511111111 611651 66115_12)

 

1221 3

 

 

 

71: 7145 747/45 000/47 55557§ 7'/) 400371154 125514704§ 1\1:15/0051

f“

 

1911 4011 $1)1>41'_5/1454705 1444me 1911 1107 HAAF/)£

 

017/1015 ‘71447' 1445 1037 1111 _71_1/& MAIL 145 13[1114 7‘7.‘/11553

 

-1F:151=1., 45'54'104 305§1\)1)7 044051~ 7145 501)5711_5447_704) 01~" 4

 

1 - 7145_ 411-111 11017. 1<1)7 § 45411557711751‘0007 70 00571/54

 

. 1011 4504057150477311 771 1414 05 451`1170113 11.07, 5111;{13 77/117

 

1143 012/541 55577011*1/0') 1441 14 71412 45’$011113/111€417 1412 711/43 '

 

 

 

-~ 11477_§;111101 1511-57 51117'551 451477)4 75 715/415 00 4505// _

 

 

Et:l?1>1“77111; A£$I§7Méé /’/)1}/\1§120 014?/1/1 1,4147'5// 45§1>

 

1551;1/1§_ 1451 511;1154177/1441451447415 540) 45411557 144

 

45114704 14411) 40 HAE>EL\§ 01;1121>1)5 457 742 111/4164 57/175§ "

F*\

 

511711517714144 145144:1115 00 4 41455/45 5014051 11577770,1

 

_7§__ 451411714511-11115451154 14 45777'71>1054`§»1455551\77
75 44111154 ,',11111)515 54177755 -517/11 711 455;71:1:141/)

. `_'

 

1410 57471= 000-47 74754 115 51417 1145 145754 14 1-'111

 

1414 5474 1451447115 4157/45111 5015_11) 7115 12515~

 

' VAA)T F144751/§’55 7147§ 4511127`5 415/1144 07 41-_111704§ 455

 

' 114 0011,.11._071414___77).4_11774751 714147 11477,_125114704 45~

 

- 1“>\1)5$754 444 5'\1.71]54177449 41544.7"1\)0,, 441§'-®440504 7145'

 

‘ 135\1511)1)/111>417 011 745 YF/4‘574 \1:~1141\;1 1455.111141177,,"45541)15`

 

141:_1;.745\41175 44111\107 45 440.4§'- 511/441 7451)~., 15 745 - ”

 

`. 7117145 /011117‘071,1<7115‘115:7115` .4551»01,,;11117,~110,5-7_, mw

 

545171)1\'513 41 5117115.0774144 14514474)5 10751 14414455),,

 

' ; 11/14 4541_)5§7 70 7475 001/47 75 145'51111 711/17 70 1>711)14 n

 

_ 114715 4511107040;13145125 00 451151-111444447 11111\1117 1

 

.24441_/5 717 015%70>5415'1¥1 114414/4.4)7 412/471 wHZ5_H 74 14 141/475

 

_ 05 7141<- 4141154.§ 0111415<1.

 

401 4

 

 

 

41 .., .

 

 

t 2666702 F11271JE/6 204)76>?\)115 713 7117§_ 20027 TF 71/7§

 

600/17 61011611 66667 70 26071-1/ 1166117 17'§ 2660/611

 

' ` 1711601)1111\117_100 117711 266/217012`.§ A601)6 /111/1§1c 1111/1062

 

 

'- 1 7117§ 6011167 11011611 566 7116 7/167 71117 12611702 1115

" 2661\1.1/6211 1\767-6617 1111 11 0177607 ;6'\1 166 2110/1515//,.1‘:116.§,g

 

lt7211111:7167§ 1/11§ 066-w 211'006260"111106A21010 57711117_700_

 

1?02 266/1702 70 110116 601\11260 6121111 71/7§ 1107766 70

 

7117§ 601/27 2661\702 1176_6 1221166611 70 711/f 1171/1102

 

 

601127§ 7;1 7116 _/1111111)612 717 11§1 11711§_§,177 0011160/7116
1171 \1 1\ 66 121/1211 1107 11161;7 111171117'700§ 76 706

 

717/16 600/67 />/16775 70 110 107 06 7116 7117005 261/1702

 

67>76// 2261/70056‘1 1121/717 116 000056§1 7116171-17>126 2131/1700

 

A€pAIA) , 2612111~\§7§ 71127 7117§ 111/127 1001161) 7551_)6 _A_1.1677 06

 

111111611113§ 70 `60m 12766 7116 126§12011)1607 6013/27 70 610/1012

 

umw 7116 /1/111;1/1/176 1311 6277116 1/ 117 v 1 6 61 121 _

 

2661\7112 276761)6§ 711117 7117§ /\1077612 7_§ 6771:/6/2 1177sz

 

§ 201)71162 20027 02 600§7:11626/1 00 2007/1162 30106 611676//

 

. 261/1702 1010 7 7111| A0007 706 611/1106 06 116/1106 1102 071/60

 

7116 00771311 70 61/111166 7027,§1)71770,1),.7;) 71/,71 /11,17702,

 

266/1712 1113/1150 21~`2136 §76/1 1712 171/6 1120071)76) 00011.§06 70 _

 

\15660§6 1162 071176 612 1111/1012 1271/1702 117117§77 //1_§

 

‘ 250 26 21)6§761 1102 0111_11§61711 600716‘7 7105 600/175 /1_6“/§1<_ 602

 

'4 26 611/2115 06 11677_§ // 071 126111712§ /111011110§ 211171/1770§1§ §

 

611/211 06 26300,126075§ AFF71/1_11772\1_1 /1/11111 02 2012 1107766 /677661

 

' 70 266/1702 5001,1710 71/117_ 126 §120111}1>1171111) 26 66106/ 261/1021

 

f 111/216 L1 ,~'2_103-1/1.07,11217 11122176117700 1307 12670_216//77 70 67-

 

» ‘_/11702 1\69170, 2661712 2621)6.1'75 706 6013/17 70 6121)71/16 71170

 

 

§ 7116 AAA-7762 1‘~/11'36`/? 702 /\AA/J/MTF 015 2276/25 l/.A 22./91 1107

953