Court Opinion

ID: 4046817
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:16:02.296892+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:38.791751
License: Public Domain

--
                         ~e        No. 07 - \S""-~SV-C-V
                                               '
     KeMetitleM /Nehb : ~JJdv;lllt<M S~R
       Reklvr         .-' Cec) I ()Jj'S-.::(s
                                           '            ~e spaf\~+s

      Rei ahrrs ~~100 h> ~~rJat~.+ f>;:J0~Ls
                                   OrljlMtJI ~f'f\Se:             .
          ..-.... -   -------     ~  -- - -            .,..._._._~---   --
         Cc('(\G~ (\O~J Ket\1\~ &. welob ~or
 ~ (\ -4-hG   above. (\UMber Cu0e                  J   atJ J=;fes h~~
 ~eDf{OA 5e -to                 IV\r {6;~0~r~ yle~~~f\~ r
        (Y\r r:6':~y~er.$ 'FJr~.J- C<.~~ e.r+~ ~+ Jvd'flc..~~
  het-:s N4;1\~ b&or 1\lM (I\ -The- ~ '{~ -::s..,Jlc,a.l
u~r1c+ Court to (fZule Ott. Jh~ ;~ flo} trv e.,
.C All {)tb~ f\'\eAf-iottd here("- fe-kr.-m fteltx/or:S
0 r; ~: ortct I fY\?;tt1daM u ~ Pe+1 tkl \.) See & b 1 p-:t<JC:.,
IJ a, 3 belr:s the 'gl(~ tour+- Docklt (b?ok.
       :Jf\ -1-hl.- stUYte... pwtt.'jfi::lph.    (b~er ~, &We~
                                                  (1'\r
  '1'hM- SvolJ~ Srnl+h. htt~ ~r~ -F> hecv ~t\Pr:~~
    fY\o+~cl\s J ~CtJ- f\1\r l?J;jSef() 0at~d Joe..s {)()+ exJs+.
   O·f\(' e. ~e lev+o r ~ ~ r e Iea-3 ed frofV\. Prt~of\. {

      '-fh;~ ;~ true., ~u~e. Srn d·( c.bof wr,·-k U(eltl-ivr
  ~ 1\ .Jbr fY\l"~ 1-\J M l\e. w• ~t ~+- ~u \e. +i H Re lcdor
  .~ fc leti>ev\ f,OtY>- pr,-:SoA t::JLb 1 f'VC. 1;1)3
  JhJ~ Nov kl b~ +he             tcaUOI\         Rel~r i~ seek. ;(\j
  re Ue+' -throuey~ +he. ~ Ccvr+- <{                      A-ppewt s     i'l\
 Jhc -PorVV'- o~ +h( Wrt+             ot YVL~cuvtus.
      1h ere: ; ~ no
               one... els e i1\ vo 1ved                        c'/\   t-ht-!
 pr ck k CaJe. %e. Or!j<'Oflttl f;te r                         .,...p -the..
 Cf't~ ld Suppod-          1eJI\ htt&    'EsSeJ           QW 4'1      .'rlrc
ch,ldrel\_ (\O?J II\ -theft'
                          1
                                        S 0_5        ('a{ )   no+ be
Jb uAd cw1 ~e f e. ().IC.    kj ;h'rM .:f e ~ lct..t'!Yl:J
                                         (\.()
 rot tM,~ c ~~ Ms aJ a-Vl ott -the ~Zell~         .
leoA ~le'(\ t'~We . Jo tvh lc.k 6<-eloAor Lvebh
;\S   ~ole ~~r
       (Yl r () \~CO@r;:, sfcded i ~ 1'" -!brrned Re \alcr
    to 1\ c_ em ; 11. ~ h, r-t f ro_ Se-. tnot)CII.::, ·}-\e 6-kfes .
                  s
    M i thl l\ -1-h'M:-. td et.,-lcr cP; Ie~ WI H be oenf to
    h} fV\-   Cf?)~f:/:r~)     ~ ~+- CM_j yr1vtlc/\ Re ld r
    F~!e~ /IV HI be dh re~ed ill, !.. { r+~dc;,
     . flov->ever (XI.r();ft)ers t1-lso <StU.t-:s he.. olue~
    not lt:.Fre-se(j,+d<,et~~': lutbh Wb'-1 f4V-el'1.~
  t0ht.t /,rJCiv}d 'the eour+- d.t~l'e.~~ Q{e!afo.r--S ~
  ~ VokJ         'the. (}}Jk/ Support leeA ?¥0 ref er a/;l
   (YlVHG/\1.3   -to   ty\r ~iJJef s Wh<JFuther 8-/co4ed ~
  ')he.. /e}l\ L5 t<. -P.f\al "Svol~eM- tho! abl (e41
   f fCfer~ i ~ .e:< -1-\,nch.ed &-5 he dJcJ }" &- b L[ r:rtS
   tJhe" Ll\ -Pte+, 'there_ ; ::S _00 -one. e: la.iM/1\J -rJ;e_
 ~k~IJ supf?r+. \~){\           s+·.ll Yalld,   othe1 cL att Yt-
                                                (\o
  cW~1c. o" the l M C?trt           be #v(\ol tiN\c h.a~ eotpJred
 taf'd ~la*:r. h~ he/\ a.++efi'Lp+i~~~ io ~lbtve..
 fh c Vt~,/lo/.~ o~ !he cV!Jid Sv pf' r L~t~ ~+sel+'
 S~l\ce J{)OCI 11\ rY\Drt Cov,,,~ aiWI ~-s4rclt(0vfl.~
   ,~~"- a. re aw l\ -fbr i(eltlfl.crs Rezues+ ~r
'th e I'Y\;q.f\ da.iV\v~   1  I'Vlo+iol\.s Co-Acerf\IM(
                               aJ
'these, ar e ~ ht;tve beell be-&r i'he- g''{1h-
\Juol ~ cJe1- l Tj ;~tf,'cf- CoJ r+" 0 )"ce J.oo'l
    '
       yvtr R:>lmff0 ;~ Coree-+-       iW        ~d.Mvr hti~
           tt lii \J throuck l-e+fe.r0    -1o thr &i~ er~ J
                                                     5
    bl"n            I

   lou tval ker ~ the-            Court iv se+l-\e. +~~~
   fro~e caue.. -/iltnJ a -f~~~ hveAior~c.t"
                                                          d
  ap('ttSeM ewl- a P the rc (V \cu (\ t1\j a ::-s e
                                                    +~ .
  In d. ud lf\ J ~e .11 .~3:1; 5 ~ ~ YY\r 8:r;rs
                                                       ~r)
  a_)ser+s he put         ~1\1-o h_,~ ttu~>+ t{C Ou f\+ -, NOI
  }h t £o k ~ U b i f5 7 l/J t~+c~ ~ ~ -fro~ ~~~
  sc.,le ob ~Me&+~ fro fer~ ~ d_
                                           k( no+l1:w~
  A leitt & b & p~e~ tJ.> \q, a3
                                  :"-X3 6 -/Jr
 (){),ooa,co ot n~ol
                  5         16
                             bl-[ fhc. (_wr.+-o~ iks..QJ
 c ov (\,1'1 &Wl(   Y0r
                      ~~~e ~ ~ cY1t:>l Lev N:.llceJ ec._c"'-
 ~Jol ·i!br ift er tt ~Te.- ,.~\ 'the- 04l~
       fu+k,t~ htts ~c+~ve I~          be ef \   peroued ror ,
 acco(VI-pl·~hed <Stf\ce.. +h-M (\u I'Ylc+lMS
                                                      flo ~fJ
(10 pleaoOn(')s·. io {'e So lv e 'it
                                          h:~ prol:~:le .Jtt:"a-Se
Ms bet\ -Ale~ b~ yYI.r, f?>l~ef.s. 'The Fad· .
Jha+ he pre+eAols 7o 6+; tl represeM- the..
 Cs -). 0le o-tJ IR, L 8: t ~ I£:D~ , ,arwt M+
who OWI\S 'th e 6-·bde.J 1~ ?i f=arce~e              ltolr5 r {tJelob,
                                                  . ~ ~~
 beet\.    Qbt¥\do/\eol b' i     yt lr rc~~Jer~ ~
   .. F: ~ ll~      fV\J   ~~~t.r- cW~~ ~ ~ kloJs
    (Y\oi-d()fl~ -:!'or lrJr:}   o-t   ~a/VWS      COfl&) &-fs
    o-P h~i1 OWfl       opl"lo11-s 0"\d ~"'clus}oa~s(
· :Jh~« i~ Ttu~ 1 beca.use +he. Z'fib. t.our+ ~
   flo ...J- (Ku l~d o A h~ (Ylo..J-} ~1l'~ bd; )€J, t-J h 1c k
                                            t

  fh !Ylr Bt05er:) &J K;(\dl':\. f0ll\4('d ocA f(\ hJd ·
  Ftf\al 6el\+e11~e.; can~no+ be add.re:)seCJ{ ~;~­
   ou+ ff'cjle.I' (lof/ce., heArif\J ~ Rule:n              ·
                                                       0
        frcper (1ot:a:'s ht.tve         be(\ -A /-eo{ ::;:"ce. ~
   "J t j-,s 1J,e heu-fA_s tv\o{ ~JieiASl 01) -Jhe()
   (Yla.J.-lc"~ Re 1~-hr i \S Set:< k: n:) Frofl" ~e Scvt."mt..
   Cour+ o-f Apped_s
    ~here....forJ t=or Coo d. {!_C1.u.se_ ohot-JI\ P/etUe..
  r:: 1-e. orw\ Con si okr Rela.-ivr.) k..)pc>n se..
  · Su~m;f--teo\ th;~ Y-:1 S- bLOL)
  T               C::.ieA"- !Nehb Do hue. ()'i C'erf-J+~
       Kel\l\e.fi.-_
JhaA-- ?L C.OfVlp !d e true~ coree+ Uof"\                      o+
)i id Voc..ufl"-e{\, t : L e& r -k +he-
                                         L'cur+- CLerk
 ~ 'VIv lt:tl\. k-Nj T'y., &vr~ o.P Prpp
                                           ~ls (9~ TeJc£.5
Lot~o\<>i1AJ o~ lLFtr-s h.cts 'f'h~_
                                       , ~ Q~ o~
 Apr:l flats- -to ()Zesfo11clMh

                                   . ~O.ttorohte t.J D,. s(tl:tk.
                                                       I

                                   -::JUol5e. :8''ftb. Dl<~-t-r:c+-C+.
                                   SUO (YlVZ (\. St-. 5-ile. ~o 3
                                    8-Hrv\.e%- -R 7q o8 3
                                  ~ PelJ'lereJ b'1 u.s.~; l

    &t u.~. rt\t<;~ ~~~etA.       as Le~l rna.) b~
  lie.. 'So~~ 6~CvMal~~ Ufl-.4-. ~ )1 )0 -I C ) 0>1\.
  -th~ f)~/){;,        i   AprJ   c ia l)                  .

                                  ~AA~
•;J'\

        --
        -