Court Opinion

ID: 4052949
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 02:37:04.174569+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:43.580838
License: Public Domain

To the. court of cvuiavmm- &ppem.^ of Text*^
                                                     OP'CMM Al
                   Wou)cxfd \WeVi»3c»
                       PeVi-V\ o ^i€_r
                                                     COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
                                   V.
                                                          MAR 03 2015
                The. ^sVak              5-F Te*Q5
                      ft«sp&i\de'rv\
                                                     Abel Acosta, Clerk

          PET\T\OKi     FOR \Y\SC9vET\ONIVRN atMltw

C%°A 5*a^€ VW$  o9 Parses                            ;                                      5

~AaVe.m_T\\ 9v^cxaf_v\c\^ Ofa\ &faum

          THE. TEk\T\A COUUVT OF kPP&(\LS                  E^Efi         M
           FlNftltoGr Ttt&T THE TR\kU CouQT                  fc\fc    ^oT
           £tf_US_ ITS blSCaET\b?s- t ^ MbT k\_U>\jOm_r
           r>E.F£.ls.^E COUNSEL Tva CcmFRouT c_a r \le\\eP
Ce<-Y\V\e.aAe of CorvNpnaoCe.
C_^rV\Q\ UH ^»CA. \V=>H                  \\
PomVtr \/. T«aaS > frS S»CA. \DU1S .                       \X

be\eU)Q,«d. \J. Voon kcsdaW*      \bVr> S>C*. \MT.\ «      n
 Al&rd M'. U^Yed SVaYes* *bl S.C\. Silfc                   \H

havA'S M. ftUsVUt           -5,0.4, 2\U .                    \-&
 U<\\W\ SVcAeS V. NAaC\u(t , 54b F>3lA. (_>1b.           _ \s
 (Ai\W V. 5W\o *bU S.U).T>di SO~b _ _                       i*>

 Lop-t^ v. skk) \fc s;uj.'id aan                           ih

Vta«\mer \f. SWWi 9,qu S.W.odSSS.                          m

^KeAY-u, V. sVcAe * %\<\ 5;u>.3ia 5HH                      \"i
CarroV\ V. 5 WW i <\IU 5.U). ad H^H _                   !— tt

RscWdtSo* V. 5WW i THH S.vo Odi 0)5 .                      *5

TVU V • *b\*At * <\M "5.VU. aa \«&<\                       ^

To\\**ur* NS. SWW* -4-. -s.U). -ba ?> .                    \l»
 ke.WsofN \l. S\a\e ) W        S.vo.3i<_ 3^0-                             iU

T^tx. R. k?p. 9. Uo.^CcY                                                  <\

Tt*. O. ftpp.P. (oU2> CD .                                                «\

Tcx.a.-fcpp. P.    44. a .                                            __\Yau

T                              ;                   ia

T*mAs \\\<\\ AVvt &\\©\jO\i\^ a«. \r\Wei>WA. parties'.

\-W>cvrd V\

David 4\\\WtA                           Wfi^se Cou^s\0
                                         \bfu^ , Te s\c\c\\ ^Ica^W^ ©AcAed
Wu   Or\\^ QCQum^r\\.

                               lo.
 TO    THE      COUJVT    OF    COAbMNkV.        kPf>e,(M_S   OF   TEXKS

                          \4bvjocvc& \WstN*- , 3"C.
                                P<«.-V\ V»oa«x

                                       V.

                         TK<   SWW of Tj\Ew

           Cuuu4 o? ftpp€a\-S* Cause Nio* \b- W- OOl>\"_. -ca >
           APPi rm\a^ Vke co*w«c\\oa \<\ eo.us.-c ki*. \a- 65 ana ~c&f -  THE.      VAoUoatXP-^E. TuftbES       oF TWE.     CouaT     OF cavwwK-fci.

APPEAL'S --

      Cocoes \-\ouo Hbujard VW(S*b » 3r ^ Pro Se \ a^d                  P\\cs

4-\\\*_> Pe.Ai4idA Vor h\sc^c\\OAarv^ ftexrieu; aod Xw -support
of \\\s re_mes4 W CespecA&tU^ sWs -V\\*                            do^r\ Ar\v*
Vu\\GLO\a^ J

                                      X
     STkTtttEKH oF TttE. CASE. At^          P&AiCEbVXftfcc UWTo&M

     TK\S \ *> a    P«AaV\0a Vuf -AxScfeAsOAatv^ («v\eu> cxUsvr^
xcom cxpp^AX ouOP a ck\\d» ^€<3au<*€ \\\<. \^xcv^ fcuAci -Wvx-e \W
€.Y\\\cor\C€.v\\*lt\Cc oa eack eomoA           pufSUatNA
T*xai> 9^>a\ Code A*f €\>^\\s
+WtV a\\eaed\^ occuxCed or\ DC aV^ouA (VxausV \ )£008,
     UpoA K\ii p\ea aP r\o\ c^u\\\v^ Ve> a \*<^\ * uvn Au^u^\
„li ab\^b    (UR*_.-nY.     Pe\vAionef    uoQS A<\ea   \r\ Wc    &S\k
foSsW\cA Couf\ oP ^caxoS CouitnW Tt.Xa^ loVVW Vke WorvofaWle
3. T_n La^\ tv^ p^€V\d\Ac^ . Oa (Va<^u<_\ a<\ ^i0\^ be uj^s
Cc_AvAc\ed gP -Vwo CoanVs 0-P CXOC^aoaAed S«xUa\ Q5SuH
bP a     <_AvAd»
       Pe\\V\onec qave \\kvl\^ y\o\\'u_ ^P appeal oa ftu^u^r
%\ i 3lb\^ QAd UJCV-S appc^rxW) Cfcu/\Se\ W ftpces€A\ W-yn
o^   appeaA.
     Tke. T^aVa CcaacA O^ &9$eftAs \t>$ued Ou^ UA^ub\\-ked
(YN^A^OfCXAdUrvN op\i\\o/\ a?ft«W\^ peAvVu^tCS CoavacAvoa oa

t TV%e S\iv»\« VoWse o$ We C\«AS a*« au^ W . CO. P^ . TKd (UpocVffs &W«. ™kaY^ &\\u~-«J b^*V« pay. ™a.^oT   kCVovSE \TS ft\-Sc.tt&Tvov-
     \N_   ViViT     MJLOVsvnts-b   riEFEN\SE CcfcAW^Ev.      Tb     Cov\ FA-Usur oft

     CfcOS5~ §.x*na\Kill          \Aj{We-_.^    RE&kQAVrtOi T*AGoi*S\'bTfcKYT
     STKYEME^XCS            GO.     WEQNlKL     hv (XGNoVvS    \Ki     V \0i_ATl0ls-

     VsntH     CUA*wE     HI'X'j    UK_\TEO STATES        Co^^vTvATvoKi
      AMENfoNAEK-TS          SxX AM ft FOuaTEEM.

     RcqsoaS \\ir R«u\tuj *
            \. TW T^aVk CouxA oP App^cAs \\as deodea cl-a
lfAp6cVcw\\ aue^Vxorv oP Vaco AkaA (LgaVVcAs unAb ^u^c-emc.
CtiuA CvjAxacv £_a AW               Same \ssue .         v\. S. C«\iA. Pr**\ds Six
a Ad FbcxcA««*n \       Ccaio&fd V. vAJa-sWaW, \3M S.C*. I'iSM'i Te*.£.
Evxd. 4W.                 Too ft. App. P,         U*,'b Cc).

               2>      Th* "WAb CoucA oP bpp&d^ ka^> decided an
trwpoAaAA auesAio* of Wvo VkaA corvPbcA^ ujvVV» T«x. (I.
Evxd 4o\ i mD'b OAd HgvA.     T<*. tL ko^.P, Uo/bCcY

               '5?     TKe ded-Sxo^s           oP ^W TenAV CgiaA oP ftweeds
requires re\neio Wccuai>«. Abe CouA o£ ftpp««.U Vxa^ s& Pqj-
depcuWd G"a^ Ak« dceepWd ar\c)i u^uc\ Cou pc\o( W AW coor\CA«Lnc«_meAA cP
AW Ar\a\ aAd ouWxde Abe presence of vW \vx<\\ •» souakA
Au>   tivWo'duce   euU«ACfi>a^e.f Texa«* \LuAe oP ^\>\das cixscoueted
AkaA ArW vU)rr\p\a\<\aaA uias diaanosedi ujvVb £.k\aw\\xd\a aA
W.r C-.A\aW beAxex/ed
AhaA AW       me.d\ t»P Wv>va<^ <^c\\W\ Wxpes H
ujbvdk AW\C \S t\o CU(€_.
          TW ArvaA aevjLfA <±«.(\\ed AW        deAWse. eou/\seAvs re-
QuesA Ao cy_, irvW GlAvj^ oP Abe         -stxuaX brisWu sWWmeAAs
made bv^ AW CucApWcNar\\ x oc AW cA«P?Ada<\A as Pc^c as
cxax^ sexuaUv^ WaASmxAAed duceases uj^/e.  AW ^virv^
                                   \0.
LOa^ deA\ed AW u\>\\W^ Vo Wax Abe proPP«.red e\>{deA.ee catyA
^Udae AW boeVaV\V Ctf\d Cred'xkxVxAwj oP AW unWessr

                       ArauraeAAs    Rt\d &\xAborxA\es

     AppeV\aA\ acojuved AbaV AW \v?sa\ CbucA akused \\s
d\^ete-\xoA V_xj^ r\u\ aWbu/xaOj AW \^cvj^ V» Wat eMd^Ace oP
Cc-<\P\\eAxoq ^WWm^/xAs tv\ade V>u^ AW Comp\aXAaj\A 6c AW
rrx^cbccA     e\;\derxC<_ oP eoaPbeWa, <_Axaax\GSxs oP Yw^kVv^ coa-
A-caeAabW     sexuaWu VoAStWAAed diseases.         Tbe T«/\Vk (WcA
oP (Appeals cxjAed uoVVb AW SAaAe \W\ 4W Co«\p\a\Aat\s
i<\e\or\sxsW(v\ sW\erAtA\s akuuA \\ix seXucA paxWers xs agA
ev\d«Ace oP uSpeevP\c xasAoaccs" e>P Sexxxd Wba\no< A-WA
U)Ou\g\ \mp\\eaAe UxjAe 4\c. (XAd VYweouer WeaAAse AW com-
p\a\Aa<\A cAxd r\oA -Ws-kPv^ aWuA V^r WsW^ i St> AW pc\or
trv_c_r>sxsAcurv\ "sWAem^As:   UjouAd    t\o\ W   admxSsikW u_Ade*-
ftuAe LV2>.
   Pr\Of Ao Ake CorA^WxAacvVs diiaaAosxs oP Vxavncx^ CWa~
mud\a \a 3LbV\ x SW WiAWr rwxcse pcacAvWAer AWA sW
Wd AWee (^ SexvjvaX pacAaecs > \c\dud\aa, o(\eCP\ xa AW
pasA 'SvX fC\ rrxaaAVs*        "5W a\sb sWAed VVxaA uoac oP*
ber parAners V\ad ev^f beeA xtscacc^raAed.               XA tuas a
vaj  mcaccera\ed •                  \b^ Ab\s akaAo^e. ia
AW CofAp\a'\Aar\Axs       sAaA« \A uoouAd WdWaW AbaA SW
 kad keen WcWxa^ AW CkVarAu^dxa Wc a\  cbaAcye ktr re$ofA*d WsAvkva^ Ao <5\xrcMAaA< AW SexuaA
 fpa/ArAer Absa\ sbe a\a\ra«A \i\ Wt P\rV\ sAaAej^tAV . TW
 ^U(v^ ioas "er\A\Atad V*» \\€ar ar\di e\/aWaAe AW uKv^Kt ano\
credik\\\vv^ o9 Ake exjid-ence arxd AW CGA\pW\c\aA4. Ua\*xA\a
a 9 AW Texas fcuW of Euxderxce                 p^rm\As    -specvPxc \AstaAces
o$ ax^ aUeaed uvcAimS pas* -5eXxAa\ Wkaxjvor xPvAxS eoxd^ce
AWA reAaVes W VW rY\oY\\K or kx'as oP AW oAW^ed vi'cAim.
T*x.fc. fcv/Jd 4uCkYaYcY                  PP\o boeA\ as T^x. R.EvAd 4v>\ x^o'b oag\ ^^m , Abe
propos-ed evj\d€nce \S admxssiWe.                  Pb( AW A made GbV^o-W^
 6a AW txVaAes bu AW PourA^vsAb ftfr\«r\dir\av.K ft\(\W\/.Ttx«xi
'Mju u.5.4uoi 4b^. %^ s.a. \ofeV.\oiofc* v* Lea.ad  CravoA\>cd
V. NWasWrx^AoA v SH\ VA. S. "Sb, , s<\ nA \Z>\ S,CA> \3>S4 x V5fc
UEd. ad        lV\ (^bb4A j     \Y»\e\oa SiCA, \47*W \v\?M-« , fe«\ L.ed.aa IdM C\<\W>. EtcoCs
oP Abxs SorA oa-e Sub^eeA Ao a Vkaftn OAcAu^sxSt OAd taust
be reversed urAess AW Court P\«\ds> k^ood a Ceaso(\ab\e
ciaibA AWA AW error dxd r\oA c&cnYx-xWW V* Abe c&a\>xcA\oa
or puAxskm^AA» See Tex. R. vXpp. P. 44»a CqYa SWAk^ V. SAota
&\<\ S.vd.^d 544,541 CTex. Ou^ft*^. \<\<*\Y TWfe or*
AWee rrYx\n purposes aP cross- exarA\aqA\oa% CO Ao sked
\\<$s\ oa AW credxkvUAvj^ oP AW dUecA AesVxmo(v^\ Ci* Vu
£A\c\A addxA\oAa\ PacAs r;c\aA\de opW \Tu\e .
A« W'xaOj ouA add\A-\DAd\ mcAs AWA AeAd W \Wvxm\AaA-e aav^
\ssue \a Ake case ,           See V.exAb \orovOA E.A. (W_^ V\e Cottmck.
Orx Evxd-tACe ^ a^ a\ ^k-s^k ( 3oW Vjo\\\\am SWaa, ed>, bJesA
fUkUsWvAO, Co. 4Ak ed, V\ <\\L
Saju. ad 4<\Mx ^^^ CT«lx.CaA«x.&99. \xc\
\b4CaY ftuA U does r\cyP VxcaxA AW C"xa\\A oP a pacAv^
At) \A\foduee be Q>ce AW \utUj evid^ACd Ce\evcLr _Lved\krtiA\y \d, \o4(eY XA &\W>s AWA wWce Abe
purpose bP CCosS~eXa dxTeeAiAke
A-rVaV Cfc>u\rt*s   o\\scre,ArxoA \s more aAAeAx_\aAed'» a deP^vdatxA
SWuXd Wv/e an oppot A^a\-Av^ V* bfxcxa^ ouA PacAs uobCcb
OoouAd At-Ad W cdv-scredxA a VjjvWeSs bv^ s Waring kis
A^sAxmoAL^ uoas laaAcuc oc bxa^ed. See \a.*> AxPord V.
UAiAed SAaAes » a^a u.s, u^i x\o*\% » s\ sca. a.\<&» a\a ^ ns
L.EdL (o3m. Cm'MY      Cross- examVoQAxofN &< AWs purpose,
is ' uWax^s fe\ex;aoA as dxseredx-Vvrxa^ AW bjiAness acxd
aPPeaAxAOj Abe ujexabA D? Vv\s AesVxcAOA^." See ftavxs V.
Alaska x 4\S U.S. Zo% x \\\o x 3H S.CA. U0S , \Uo > V\ L.£d.3d
VA1 (\S14Y
    XrN s^ua\ qssu\^ cases » u AW dredxbxAxAx^ oP boAk
Ake eorAp\a\rNQA\ o,Aa dePeAdat\\ xs a Ce^AraN \ oPA*> dus~
pos\A\xje > \ssue.11   Tbe Couc\ oP CcxcaCacA ftppeaU Ws
W\d AW\ tl Ake $.u\es oP Euxderxce i especvedAv^ RAvXe HoVi
sWud d ke used spacWaW Av> exckxde ce\«evaAA x oAWr-
Ooxse adoA\
fTex, CrW App. aooo?) CcxA-\n^ *,cjk Lopex. ^ \t> S.u3. ^d aA
^TH (keAVer* "3v CoAcurrmc^Y ao-Vxao^ ArbaA u>k\\e credihiU-tv^
\S txo moce vrnporVaAY     Irx SCx oPPe^sc Cases AWa gAW
Cases x xA M\s more Ukeb^ k> W AW oa\m> PacAo* \a sex:
Cases AkaA \\ \s \a gAWt Vv^pes oP CQses !' \a wkcV uone
C \Ws AW Rx^Ae 4ba
WWacxao, approack \_oouAd mosA oPAen r«r\der tvldeAce
CXdrY\issSb\e I a sucb Cases. TW CoucV oP Cr\m\rxa\
Appea\s Ws a\so W\d AbaA a Ake Texas Uu\«s gP
ELvxdeAC« pecmxA +ke dePeAdaA^ Ao cross-excvrvNXAe a
                              \4.