Court Opinion

ID: 4127934
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2017-02-18 00:34:36.654423+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:19:22.276805
License: Public Domain

ATTORNEY GENERAL OF TEXAS
                                            GREG        ABBOTT

                                                  May 18,2012

The Honorable Jerry Patterson                            Opinion No. GA-0931
Commissioner
Texas General Land Office                                Re: Authority of the Comptroller of Public
Post Office Box 12873                                    Accounts to commit the expenditure of funds from
Austin, Texas 78711-2873                                 the Major Events Trust Fund (RQ-1019-GA)

Dear Commissioner Patterson:

       You ask about the authority of the Comptroller of Public Accounts (the "Comptroller") to
expend funds from the Major Events Trust Funds (the "METF"). I

        Section SA of article S190.14 describes the process by which the Comptroller may expend
funds for an "event," which is defined to include "a Formula One automobile race." TEX. REV. CIV.
STAT. ANN. art. S190.14, § SA(a)(4) (West Supp. 2011). The process must be initiated by either a
county, a municipality, or a local organizing committee that "is a party to an event support contract,"
defined as "a joinder undertaking, joinder agreement, or a similar contract executed by a local
organizing committee, an endorsing municipality, or an endorsing county, and a site selection
organization." Id. § SA(a)(1)-(3), (b). A "site selection organization" includes "the national
governing body of a sport that is recognized by," inter alia, "Formula One Management Limited."
Id. § SA(a)(S)(B).

        A site selection organization selects a site for an event in the state "pursuant to an application
by a local organizing committee, endorsing municipality, or endorsing county." Id. § SA(b).
"[U]pon request of a local organizing committee, endorsing municipality, or endorsing county, the
comptroller shall determine for a one-year period that begins two months before the date on which
the event will begin, in accordance with procedures developed by the comptroller ... the incremental
increase" in receipts from certain taxes. Id. § SA(b )(1-S). Under section SA(b-1), a "request for
a determination of the amount of incremental increase in tax receipts specified by Subsection (b)
... must be submitted to the comptroller not earlier than one year and not later than three months
before the date the event begins." Id. § SA(b-l). The Comptroller is required to base the
determination of the incremental increase in tax receipts "on information submitted by the local

         I Letter from Honorable Jerry Patterson, Comm'r, Tex. Gen. Land Office, to Honorable Greg Abbott, Tex. Att'y
Gen. at 1-2 (Nov. 22,2011), http://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/opin ("Request Letter").
The Honorable Jerry Patterson - Page 2              (GA-0931)

organizing committee, the endorsing municipality, or endorsing county, and must make the
determination not later than the 30th day after the date the comptroller receives the request and
related information." !d. Thus, the statute requires the Comptroller to perform a substantial
economic analysis before funds from the METF may be committed to an event. See id. § 5A(a-l).
However, "[t]he comptroller may not undertake any of the responsibilities or duties set forth in
[section 5A] unless a request is submitted by the municipality or the county in which the event will
be located." Id. § 5A(p). "The request must be accompanied by documentation from a site selection
organization selecting the site for the event." Id.

         Your request letter indicates that the Comptroller sent a letter to Formula One World
Championship Limited ("FOWC") on May 10,2010, certifying that, "[w]ith the understanding that
the first Formula [One] United States Grand Prix race will be held in Texas in 2012, full funding of
the entire sanction for 2012 will be paid ... no later than July 31st, 2011," and that, in years two
through ten, "we will be sending $25 million dollars ... to FOWC by the end of July 31st of each
year preceding the actual race event." Request Letter at 1-2. You contend that as of the date of the
letter, "no local organizing committee, endorsing municipality, or endorsing county had submitted
a request to determine the incremental tax increase that would result from the event"; that "no
determination of the incremental tax increase had been completed"; and that "the market area that
is likely to experience measurable economic impact had not been established." !d. at 2. A brief
received from the Comptroller's office disputes your allegations and contends that "every action
taken to date by the Comptroller and her staff has been fully compliant both with the statutes and the
METF rules.,,2

        Section 5A of article 5190.14 sets out in plain language the steps that must be taken before
the Comptroller may "undertake any of the responsibilities or duties set forth" in subsection (p) of
section 5A. TEX. REV. CIV. STAT. ANN. art. 5190.14, § 5A(p) (West Supp. 2011). See Wind
Mountain Ranch, LLC v. City of Temple, 333 S.W.3d 580, 581 (Tex. 2010) (observing that "the
words the Legislature uses are the clearest guide to its intent"). The Comptroller is required to
follow the precise procedures described in the statute before undertaking any of the responsibilities
or duties set forth in section 5A. Whether the Comptroller undertook any of the responsibilities or
duties set forth in section 5A is the subject of a factual dispute. Briefing submitted to this office
argues that the Comptroller's May 10,2010 letter was "merely an effort to indicate broad support."
Brief at 3. In contrast, your request letter suggests that the Comptroller's letter improperly
committed funds to the event. Request Letter at 3. Consequently, the facts upon which this office
has been asked to opine are disputed, and contested issues of fact are not amenable to the opinion
process. See Tex. Att'y Gen. Op. No. GA-0750 (2009) at 2.

         2Brief from Ashley Harden, Gen. Counsel, Comptroller of Pub. Accounts, to Tex. Att'y Gen. at 3 (Dec. 22,
2011 ) (on file with the Op. Comm.) ("Brief').
The Honorable Jerry Patterson - Page 3      (GA-0931)

                                     SUMMARY

                      Before undertaking any of the responsibilities or duties set
              forth in section 5A of article 5190.14 of the Texas Revised Civil
              Statutes regarding the expenditure of funds from the Major Events
              Trust Fund, the Comptroller of Public Accounts is required to follow
              the precise procedures described in section 5A. Whether she in fact
              did so requires a resolution of facts not amenable to the opinion
              process.

DANIEL T. HODGE
First Assistant Attorney General

JAMES D. BLACKLOCK
Deputy Attorney General for Legal Counsel

JASON BOATRIGHT
Chair, Opinion Committee

Rick Gilpin
Assistant Attorney General, Opinion Committee