Court Opinion

ID: 5547344
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2022-01-10 19:03:37.397386+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:34:57.073197
License: Public Domain

GIEGERICH, J.
The motion is made upon the original papers. Hence, as upon a demurrer, the facts alleged are to be taken as true. Evans v. Holmes, 46 How. Prac. 515. However, assuming the defendant’s fraud to have been shown, it is clear, from the plaintiff’s own statement, that he was aware of the facts in question when he accepted the defendant’s promissory note for the sum now sought to be recovered, the legal effect of which acceptance was to change his claim for a wrong into a debt. Alliance Ins. Co. v. Cleveland, 14 How. Prac. 408. Until the note became due the cause of action was in abeyance (see case last cited), and yet the summons upon which the order was founded was served seven days before the date of maturity. For these reasons the motion should be granted, with $10 costs to the defendant, to abide the event.