Court Opinion

ID: 4069500
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 00:38:07.937393+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:56.788260
License: Public Domain

«?39/5
                                No. Pfi-ol-b^- .15

                                                                   ORIGINAL
                            "SlN THE
                  COURT ^    CSXNnML fctfEALS
                            OF "TEXAS

                                                                KECESVED IN
                                                              COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

                                                                   SEP 18 2015

                                 V.                            Abel Acosta, Clerk
                        TU6- STKTE Qf TEXAS
                          tf£SP&c\JD£*JT,

        PenmowER xru cause wc>.fii-hi5om-l f^m^-we Finu
3UDXC3AL TstsrRXCT dougx Of "Dallas, (CaurUTVi-rex-AS aiud f=fcft appeal
AJO. Q5-IW-D0530-CR   FK6(U THE CDL/CT" OF 'APPEALS fOK THE VTFm TBSVCECr
GF DftL\_AS

                                                                   FILhL) IN
                                                         COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
      ftTxtTLDM Fbfc xoscRrniDruev      Rattew
                                                                SFP 18 2C15

                                                              Abel Acosta, Cierk

   fa«J*L- (\e&UfWE(UT RE&U£STlX>

                                                 -ftLHfiKrMALA TR.

                                                 SELL CLEM6IU1S UIVUTT
                                                 <^lbOV S?a£ 5SI
                    TPt&ie   o>v Co(vrr£(V)TJ5

TiM&Lt c^r e/3(vn-eo-rs                          ,rL.

^nt>ev of ALrruftRxTxes puod SYcrrurres           3

ST^EiMtrvrr or -rue CAse                          14.

Re^rM -ib c^urr Re.LxE.r ft. (\ue5ro*u
                                                  b
ALfTKORrrxe^ rnru SPu(TT   OF RtLXJLF

                                   CI.)
 BRUf.RV U,STvYr£.7JL5 SUJ,2»A 4°ll« SO* fTcX. (LRrrv/i. APP. lC£n\   8.

  STTPrVLrTES

-TEY.CDDt- ferw.^ AAiH/,-A«?T.2>8.1c/ fv/fcfftUOrO IfiOS)
                                                                           H

PE/UAL £ODT Art/iuSftra (Al m fv£««uo^ zac^
                                                                      11

                                     (3.)
                           SnprreMEKn- OF TWE        CASE

A. PftQECDUgftL ^UMlViAgM;
 ON ftPgZTL ?L2..Z.Dm.THE P£TXXXDf\JARV, ALfcERT ftWrtLA ^R . £f\JT£f?Er> A pL£a
 ft? (UOT GJLtucw TbTHif CWAflGsE DF CA-PXTAL -fl/lueDER          frEFbClE THE HOl\JDRAfc>LL-

 ~3u-QfeE -Carte*. THomPsoaJi 3UT>kE~ PRESXXnrruG of EGTA/ixrvsAL 3EE5TKICX
  C&URr <VJQ,5 AWD A ^URV (f?RV,3P.6)TH£ ^Kf^ FOUajq THtf StFEfVD A<0T
 GUXLTM -of c.Am*^ ruuGtiefc, AS <LHA&kEk -irv the Trvjrcrc^rv/ieAJT.OfS) (\P£TL-
 2.H,10m.t^V,5P2«).-rHe, TRLftL. C&UfiT ACALSSESED PUr\ZL<bUrt/U=A/T df -
 LXFE. ttAJ THE IJUStnnUTXOVOAL Xor\/TSOAJ C>F THE. TEXAS XNEPAfCT/fHatfT
 OF CKEMXfML. ^UStLTECRRV/.SP'ffiV A AJDTXCb or APPEAL l^AS Txr^tLV KLLEL
 ga) Affile z>|,Z0W CCRv/.n.APPtuLAwr ftGxtx uj<vs -cnua_M Fxc_e& daj
 nJOV£ME0£& Ifc.'iJbH '. STATE ftfclE^ WJkS> fcxlJED C>aJ      AP^XL. 2fc\^ . FXFTU <LDUfiT
 OF AfPCAL ei\mLflJED           -3UD£oerVlcfAiT DM "3U«UE    23. LO\S.

                        Que^txo(0        ro^ ReymeuO

A. (^uesTDbrU:

& QyESrxottt •.

                                REftSoflJ F6R RELxeF

a, REasofv:
      P£TXXX6rv)£«.     SUOaJ^ TU£ TRIAL. CoufiX EfceoR &S FFtLL^rtJGp TD KtUt
-xjO-stru irrxoru -n4«r tue uzttyuess w&s AttDiuPLxcfz A5>               A ii/icrrrsa. of
 LAU^ A(WD WOT LeFr FDSL TUt TSLiftvf TO fUAKL THAT TDETERMIIuraDiO.
Pctxxio^r shows tv\c Ex/x^eruce iecsplaved ajxtta vas^uex acxtve:
PAeTXCXPAXXOiV -airvj A«UM PLOT TO KARrU THE DEteLPvSEIi <2>H 6EXVUCd ft
DtCOM ft* TUE PERPETRATOR TO ftftttU COIUXV^L. AA/D VUWSXCAL. MNMsmuaE
 AkffOUSV THE UirCTXM. rUXTft E.ftJ£aft&e& X<U to(UGU£X ftEFbR£ P\(UX> THiGXVOfo,
 AFTER XHC        RPPA(?erLrr    APX>U<~tX£>KU   A.WQ Otf.   COf^mrivjunrrvJfc>

                                             CHJ
 /\ftx^APPRnPRrAT50Aj. ajxta rnuLn rorer fi.Erv\eio/\£>Fft. T:-f her (wsthe«   Awr-nx smyen
 uctru n«? pa THe ftAtel aett rvirrr^j, f ^v. 3^.?^^) V^'icrE.TPSTrFXE'B, Adam Ar\TD
 OftWfttf A«fAL0   STAMED AT THE     iVie.Cx SESr ivicmeL CR&V 2> PflM )WH£KE TW £eCD£D
 ^S STLEtUT <lor THE E(/CTDEf\JCJr SHO.& PAtfT (Vxnrf\ AaiD ABflrM AMflLA            UJ£R£
 LDV1E8S. VUHiLf A<ur<xe Aajd Dfl<\j(uy AHALA lu£*E LAueftS*, &H THE ££Cb£D xrv CDULQ ££
 "OeT£(?.(VtErU£ '^Ip^.t^we^/MuCTSeRJ AM^IE .AOAftA , AlUO ATETA LXI/£L i^TT TUE «U£€X
  (\^EL TfetETH^V;^im !Il£Tn(vJCLt :He(tSeLF ^ aCDVito PPXSEox &EFOR£, AND DUft&vfc
 "THt Call (4Ef; ruort^ieJ;.^t^.i?', '^<ji»£:-rt»' eciio/ '^fL A RXDE £R(?V/.3P.lDlo') VICKIE,
 Exftj^u^ iiAqr«v • - ui.^'J?«efiej\rr _&Ett>e.£ awdtdurto^ tue call aaigxe aaa^e to
  &XLLVI «*|"^:r^V.3.P..Aai-IDll,.Mm 5KrFTTUE GLAA.E Xru HER M^CXPATxCaO
 THftT THE fAD(OE O^LLeO mADe Xb Sxel* ^HIt.M AAJEXE rVVAl* u,AS APLOT TO
 KSSulx A(Vro^GD PXLLV AiuD (^Gie TOOCfctD TVGS, xwrafc^frrxoro f«W2> ?.2Dfc-ZD7)
CRe\l>4P^rmptva;E>fi(^rx^ u/a^ PKESeruT PRxog. TO A<UD Ducctob THE CMjl.
 AWGIE AAftDE XD ECU* ft* A PXDE. AT WQ Trfwc IHTi VTCCXTE HEAR OF A PLDT 70
 KSUCT ACUO •toftft toLL* ^V/^P.m^mXTXOA^VS^U^ AWf^E TM a**- SPEW*
 WrrK (W^io ^ AR*rUftl_ . ^ wfis ^                         VASQuxz. a<ut> -D^M AVALA
 ^H0k (u^e xAJTxxxfNL eom^cv uur^u G&lva_x. ru^v u<^ HERSELF HS A
 3>tt!M iw. TteKac^wco Gx^v fd«L TNW To c.axiv) Access '•**, the VEHxaJEV
  Ntofl CutKwro G(U£ Or THE AHALft 6ROTUERS TJRfl^ED teuH TO THE &ACK SEAT
  ftruo Ap^Atu^AePLLAtur r^r-xcuTWt ,:Gack Seat v^h Stu^ C^VA GmY vscp*
 AAARTX^ L^oeSS AFTER feu* **S Xfiil6kEI> TO THE 6ACVC SEAT (^ ^                          6p

 t^^^^J^^Ta^ STO* SLLL-V R** CoETTX^ OUT XHE
  BKK *^<ATO-Rienl<*A^                                 Hter^te^uwt OF rvxrx*
   PA^XXexpATCDfO, AFTCR THE ASSucT A(VjT> FfcfcCX(Ob; CXEcS TO TWE &ACX ^btftX
  "T^ B«$^;;;^                                         u^tH t^m Avx^ ^ftnn -^^
   .he ^ ^ * ^ ^ - ^ ^
 LQrUTXAiueD TOX*LL PA^S^PH^e ANB GCLLyiVOHOiOfi f^VCi AUG) AFT^ -thc TEO
  ' <V3TA (MOseJ.Tbft SAe n,A<xrrs HtR .v^aje/ )»' fftCy.M P. \5^;AfTe(^ TH£ ASScxcv ,^DfeB^Y,
   AWD Aiu'^ee Fbfi. ftrLL^'s (ucxue* Aivis-ca« i (LccrA , (\Ji-rf\s A40THcR Avogxe. A^JD
  DA(UWV( (\yftU    Cf\Ut UP UJXTM   A SECLU-oeO ARCA TO XCtSP&Se.^f\C)LL         CJULLM'S CftK
- AT (UXTft'S AUIVT'S PLACE. -Xw CJD)(vxLLe t"KRV«3 P.Hl') (VJXTA, T>fttutoS, A(UT> (\Ml5TE

                                                (5.)
VOEWT TO FfcWtt\te VADUSL AftJD faX-KGD vaP AWELLAwt PvC\TO fVO<\CV\ TO g>€\        SOAAC -£fcU&s>.

AMt> HELP NXTA fttuD -OftwwM mSASSEflAAttLE THE CAR££ftvJ3P."2J5V (VECTA ^CYEOO)
HER. Rl^awCLAV- T(\JT«.UST   x:cO   &OS£R.VX<v>G, TA£   XESSfXbSEtvtA&LEL   dF THE     CA^. APflet

SHE COULD (\jBT CAR.^ HEAV/V CAd PA9TS) &EO\USE SHE u;fVS         5EVBU     AaCxOtHS PP£E>A)AtvTT.

She Fustwol     Pft«xxcxPArec> orw x^<^?c^flrvxo<o of the c_a«. pasts xd TznTERarr

T3UCSJW HMOJft 0£ L&ceevxrWs FOR SALf- |«£M2> Pil8),RevePL*aou (mxtHs xNVOWEWeivr
IM ft EUKAUu^XWd; PRoe^TTXWE UALUE AJCTft XS AW AECOmPLXCE &M LAW (WO
XHLS CCUGLT SHOUUD (V.OT PH^rx-D U<udE£ THE uSttCLLA fcF TMrlS ^D S<LHEM
 TO SWXELD IVXTA V/WQUcX Pa«TX-CX<PfXXOM.

ft. Reason) :
        "THE PETXTXQrotR uJas ^E^uqxCE &Y r\tirm uac&u/£t XHE /fcCOrviPLxce vurnvess
 XivamumctS Th HAlTSECX, LEfcStauG, THE JutfZ.Y TO WALXD LEAG.L THEORIES ["feRV3 P< ZOSl,
  NTT A V/ASRue-Z CCA,LO PEEfcEL Xf PETIXXOCVlE*.        U/AS (VJEAR. XHE HOMDft     Cft«.>WHE(VJ
l?A<OtW    G&x XAHO THE Cft«. £RRV3 P.iCflV MXTfl V/fl5flUtZ T>IT> AJOT KNOW WHO

DRftGkEO e^^V TO XH£ &ACK StKT(($RV,3Pl\0y5ME "OTD fUOT KlVDbo WHXCH BROTHER
WAS I(J THE &fcCVt SEAT UXCTH 1KILLV TEv/tAJ THOUCH PETXTX&MEfc buEAtfS PKEScfcLkED
CLASSES AWD DAiuwyMftU TDS (VCT Weft« da.A55£5l TRRVJ.PZlD^VXGfcie MARTINEZ. SALO
 BAWIUV/ A^B ADAM CtT TW THE OPOC 5£AT H/XTH STLLM. («fct/3 P.\B8 \ AAs. ArtA(?TXr\)£-Z_
ClAtoecRftieS ABT* *5flU£l TUAT toXTX^rodR Smutaiuo ALDroE ~DfcQ<oK to
A(UD TO ruoT PAKTXCXPATE OR LEAVE uxrrH Tx^ruV A(VO ADftCA IftJ BOJLY5 Gfc.
^N/.3?.\ty»^\ttoaE mKTTruez. tx^ aoot S£e ETtxtxoakr ;xaj or out OF XHE BL1LYS
N/tHxcLe.r^V.3P.i30iW!3Hm) 3eftV/ftL HQucs. rtp-f^ RES£(VJr Mug:D£R oF 6tuVi
I**** *u** RT^O^ to*® u. <oEeD UrrA AMD A^E <RKU i PLlS) NJITA SA^
                                          r>tpxf wmtH Could have Ca»u£ FROru TH£ t^urr

would ^ «e teLLV flaflw tRW3Ruul irnua,.^,^ ^ fce ft£flSDwAaL£ ^^

                                    i-j-^craoMte -re ttx -DKuiis nwr> ask -th£m td

                                            Cb.)