Court Opinion

ID: 4060776
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 19:58:07.501158+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:05.242272
License: Public Domain

“’5`q 13056550&

I/V me Svlof`€w\.@.. C§c.)¢{'
503 T5’\~@.~S~5»aie., <:)F Te>)ca§

' Re.
C111311 OF 611~;.11£1 35151,111 f\fm(,‘@e, W)€’ 73-3_<11 331
'\`1‘1111€111151 mm len/173 ,,1 1531 1315 3111/111
{:;;1,,.1'~3 1511 amd 523 530 355@5§ Cc)u~37 5_,55133/,11¢/$‘3;110 721ch

M;> 51¢1,1 75 35002,@_¢3 155 10 @)t`fv\@ YQ;uJ/OQ/`QS

1 ' chv\@_g /1._!(:1.¢.) 351@).5“~¢§£@€5 §50~5~€>'-( Wi55,\ 511551&` 3350531>».) 50`@
51:2_1111~1.15 0 §r w 7%33)\1:,_ ?auv€a£§ 1231-55 5313 0,3§)1<:311@§5 /`&35\<:1~ §§
001-15 03 N5 5010£55€134 ¢JS, T5Ac115*53)¢5, <5`_@~' "5 5"2£0;“;/\3170_ 51qu <:;”1/1./
}/\/055 Qr~/`5'5_. 535@,1)5 33113.)¢;.5, ;,"5' 05 55»115.§ /5/55{15<~`~` /?96'15¢31»~'“5'/57@15 QJ%M@JZ A l§ _SUJ<:J[ 313
&\;F1 515 1153 1N:.51j011)¢;1 55 `*
55 Q@~SWQCX‘§_)/Sr 355 5931¢5'5@£ ON` +3\¢§ ”“55:5007 05 /\3).1/¢21,12 525 .1?~€51.`1/~$: _

    

 

 

 

mmc-335 5:¢:»(/'“5"” " 1

' ' ‘ \_1€3.4_11.;9`:€1:13`5 556-rny 5055‘:)&
_1.:"='b0uRTOREgF;£|VED|N G‘OQ&'_)Z /`?:IHJM§Q Q’U"{

F |M|NAL APPEALS .1 `_5£5 .

§ ~' 11 1111 1121111

     

. . ‘. . .
§ 5 » l 1555
.`\ ', ' 4
1\1~.\;*~'1.‘1,1‘_1§"‘<` i ;"‘ . 1. .. 1 , z .. ..1 ._' .1, . , . \».'/ .
- <~1 . 111 1 . 7 .1 ».1 ; 1555 -'," 1113 ~, 1`. ..111 angle 1" \ §§ ‘-»'~' :'w~y »- ~ 1
. 1,__ .» .., 1,1,.' .. 1511 ., , 1 1 - »~11 ,¢ .1,1,, \r,: 111» . ..
, 1' r, 11 1 Dall. 1 '_
5 5N0v 1 59 201555 5’“55' 1 5 ` 55
T in .
. ... 1 . . 1 11111
,, ’ ~~\'~ ~1.', \`_"\. '~'5§ ,. ,.1”1,. .- . ,
: ~.' h '»1-' 1 1 111 '.: ‘*5.""'1 ,‘~r /s `~.,1‘:¢. 1'11 ‘,' .-1_\ :» .'~¢11 ,.11», ,1 ». 'n' 1,' , _, , ..
11 ~"1`, `»1- '-'.J `~ ' ." 19 ',. ~>"-.’:4, l " ,1’."~;..'1\- `1) ‘ 51 ' \1 '»' I'.1\455’ ’ § ' 155 "'1 .‘- '._`, `§ »" :1\`" :".’ 'h.""‘~ 5 -<" 411 "
~;. , '_.1- ;!» 11 ‘1 , 1 ; \,'\= 1111 1"~1 ':, " ~~ \;;j`_, ‘,' 1115

- AbelAcostaClerk \

53 § kelm-53 599 3‘~»5?3"¢)53 ¢~.5€ MO{\¢§,N 319 Ff:m;c 1`3~1

~"#¢.><>55/55.»;»" PMFM&

,5: mo,,.:&§¢,(~5 QQ,JMQ@M\M, 333 55~3~‘35>‘@’ M""
433\9_ 336 ch% 333 ',./3!'.5. C€’/£?£ ¢;L,QCQ 10?£1\33¢:,;”5 ”f`¢i`) pf¢*;@@'::g fm 753 N"G"" "9`;:£530£€&`§5"
gm 55 55»5@5» 555 52 533 5>5€¢»~~1»5 339-3m 1

35 ;§: &,um. c;'c.~} !;\}C£L€»,€.QMJ{QCQ ;*;\.m’\¢;/(F'\L`Qoh Md'£'u»~> 3”¢£’~3» T€}“U’ `R”M“ZQJZ;€

' ¢,QL_ ”{M j: 3\¢)»*~¢. A.)c) 3;._)»\§@355. wk;' 333/x M}§'\;LQ. *€".i“‘§»§-£~&~¢Q~ ¢'¢~¢¢:¢5,,»»3 m »¢-MWM cf 5 953 ‘:WQ!
533<#5 Ndi!” /`€€.Q.zva;Q QV 5`“' 5::)33_§52} 3}"¢5.3"~0333@_ “ 336»152937~ '

? 33¢.,$&¢‘€&/\¢3*' 351 Té£&$ L¢~<..~J CV"T£~?£?" § €: 63 1333 §m“@g(“`£"§* `T"`M§`
QW¢Q_U c¢h( 335,~;@,5 z3.:5..5:;»<55~» 535€5@@"% 33 93#5`=¥ - §@°353““3"“55
TE§¢;§,£: 5305,§/03; 3)5;{~¢} §ma.@.»ély MMQFM @3<513”\@’-"~6)“3@“3“*’2 (""""‘!`Q€~

@M.QW~/,f€" 333 5 35,5.553@ ¢2,¢525¢»€»5 33535»@»3 M#'~d`~fw»’él
,.»:.¢<’F_Q;c,; .

3§@§§59633;5//37 3\)35 3333<~?33 5<;;> v\>(_\

 

l;v 1116
S\)P{'a,~¢»\¢ Cc~f‘+`
' I,,~f\i“ /*;)MC1 &2(3 v
71151111 1 r~" 1111

» 111
§QL.)A'@QC§M»@Q !jg>p~a¢j; /\/v/\(>@€’, W§ 179 399 031
1f`1¢\§1ch€~1 Nvm@-%€`M 1 919_7@ //u 1 ?Q 911/1133 1513~1~?1@~1»
@111 1,11>111131 1‘11<<;11111 LWMVS¢U,_, 1111_1

` 1011-111 11 1111 11 1111-111

1349/1 1‘1101\)~€1€;`

`§QMMQ\&QF1&‘1Z€.c>"@$ ILB.M)LQ¢U ga L/w;?"("
&J

13<215 3111/1313 1312
931031/@2, Tx?>c¢:.*g 759§€53

NcQQ/\,/`{' `
CCM¢`& 1221:'&$:1\¢/~)@}1`19 €>"Q¢,QS l `

§€ 11511'1@_ 1111 T;>>4@h!‘c,4§ 2492®45; W4444 444`54`

_ +NQ*@\ CWH_ £b;\4l; 40 ;Mb{. cum 25..`4~'€/\§5'§<:§~§’ ap *4”;.'@__6/'(`§/40\{/1/4)<(
ami re §§SGMLQ__ 49ng (;¢ 0?4»§ C)§`QQQ:=.,§§ af 60“§434»(§}§§¢? wFH/\ 44~££..§ C:i`c , §&, ' 4 h

L§ . e§§ §SQ§§. :§Z. §:§Q§S,. z~§§§‘§ §S,§»ii§§§§§~:§ S»§MQEQ»¢\ M@‘M 4~>

444 C,C,A, §~Q_G.=§§§DQ) 44¢§, (§§¢§4~ 4~¢§6"*@~'4`“44\§§ 4‘9§44`1§§€ 4`€‘°4)‘~”§-=4‘4§@

f‘§\“§ 4\`§,§ 440»43§2@§§ CO-XQ»\§, 43¢4‘-"44‘43"5»`44`4$ 444£"44§`"~4 U~B.~\,$“M”"w4 444

04£§§`§§2,§ 494 '.44\@ CCA..’.¥=. G'./\§ M§Q§:€§ §§5‘2£3!§', WW/§¢M§L 346'~>4'/“§ Q~M/
{`SQ,§:¢_§S§Q§\§§ ., 1 4

§§ C)M _‘__;;Q\§{ gq_§,l,z@§.§ 44§§§. C;C¢§¢}§ aj ‘§..c.§,. F4§ 64<§§‘4:./ §§§:§~4€¢.4€44@€

Y§,'> 44§@7¥4&,4 CU§~.>F'&” \\`Q,Qm§`§§§;§"`;'$ 444`4*§;§*§~§§ "4'4‘\».»¢1£“ 4§:4334\`4'§@§\~’¢&.§ C¢"‘M‘M-

14 6§&491‘.@§~§ §§.§v§§c§.§.§&£ 44°»>‘4'§4~§2§~4 ¢W /4 45§"1'»52@§ *ZM ‘/§ w v 442 644/§ 4 § l
§Q§»§§§@§§§Q §1~§§§§~~~+§§§ -+~§~§§§§ c§§§§§ §~~§§§,§§§m§@/y " §d4> §/@-
CC,U 44 444_§§_494§4@§§£¢4»@ Qa@§z,Q.§ §~4: MS GFCQQMQ[@ (-4`@@»‘4€ 044`4
-§§§ Q§§r§§»§§§§;§§ §§§4 § ~§i;§§§§§§§§£ QQ§§§§¢§ M.@Q§N M¢é§§
§§ ;J§~>ff§§vc§)~§o) c.»§,§ `4.>§2.)4~§4£:0»§&/€`$¢3§:*-‘4§$§:44 ¢3“-5% 4 /\'4 444 /4/49`{4 C~:N C"FF®{)
2120/gi "14“4\.:2,»`1£w 74%\9. 77 §‘-=C Q.§./f‘}" 410044 r’§/G)?L §§ Q,\jf?.cQM C~.-§qu"f$ f x
§§ §§§§§§ §§§§.§§§ §§§§§§§§4 4 lm§w §§ C §§ §M@~

, 4 ¢_ ¢§/ .,

1443;>€§.4§ §>Q§\74§; 4a `44/\§ §)c:§%; CC;'§._)¢J47 4BLS’4§4` 444 `4“4'\44~"@°»'4“’“@'44" &&‘cgmé/M&AZQO£
§§ ~§'§~§§§ <§,§§\§ §,~§§§L§§§Q:¢Q ~§4-§§ §f/‘m’§- 43 644 w §»§MQ

441§;~@43,,¢4§§ /§§§§§"'<§§§. /4§»§ ’

(§§ . C>§\) 3'§)§~§@ 2‘3:), lab §§, 44@~4§4.:\<~>1\~§§€§ 34»4¢§/<44@€44 <1~,3&¢§’§.;4
44€'/'4<*;..:~5 4~§3> `4"4§_§_1 C,C‘A » SM‘H§MNQ ®§»4“4€§%@4;¢7€@*3§4_®4\6€&&»€&~!@4(

‘/"“4§§§ '4;"“§-`§§§§". (§:§§.§§4 fw §4‘; §).;Y:§§ 4§§) §“Q.§.R§§§§!/§ 4'<1:‘§_':§"“"¥'434`~/ M44”\44/‘@~ .
C(w/)i_§> ' @[CQO,Q `4”' 4\ 144 4§!.\§-4§‘§~§{4 4§»§::§ U~`§~`»§ §§§§1§2§&0§\§"44§§§45@44&  §>`4§5\§:`4( 4444©%§@34 § Mé:§"éwl #4~§LC4`44Q 4 4§§»4(%’°4 f@»»#‘~)~’-€§g“’§

¢

514th » c.:§§* §“' *LS 4@41`<44“4~‘§7§4`&/4&/ 1/'~’¢“'=~*£?<44 -€zi;? _ c~'Q "€ J\*-i"i§<; il

 
 
  

 
     

 
  

~~,,» ~z» M “ .
ypv£~e:&§* %d}/::g C£’;Q::kz/®Méd£ié 7%!§ q ..
,\ _` . _ w   M A¢, ‘

 

"’W" ~'-P.»:»'~N* r"§§,w

 
   
 

m UF”\"’Q):§§& KQS~H §Q<;-}w~ il Mcz§£c:) `T'

          

w~}:z §§2§1.1%_ ` "
F@...C~c¢@;wse,$. */“ ,

j c/\»~€L F"`“"(~f?§!@~$ f

  
      

  

C§ jim

";§1;),1',_:`1';¢§1/¢:'§ jj

605 ~§€Ms,,‘ f l""~§§»@§§j£,§\§c) §§ éé£fvi",-.`j§ b
C§§§ §§<:,§e.§`_;;§§`z» »~§ C\:~».~Q c; ,. §§ §§ §§ ¢_;,_
‘f;\g s ogc§e‘){*&e*:ifcwg §;;§ T?m$lf¢w»w§.

    
  

 

  
 

l ` . ., .:`;5\{1»¢_),,1§;& P¥`C§,£J'S §§ ~'-' " 1

!M-{Q»ve§~r!# §§we‘? ;§,:¢:§§§§c&o§@ ({/U"{”¢M¢ch §§ §§ §§ ‘M.@

 

 

y \{Q¥` V;~W;'If~z1<:'* §§ §§151;1`§:0: [.§§1_,§.1 1;§§11 §§§,§§ 1 ,.17,,11{111§1,,§1,Q173;§
33\§)_§~?31\;1§'3 €~.M¢ 361 11 6);§{65§§$1£§;§';\_3@:313 §§3:\ J};); "3330;3` "'31/\&. FC/Ff<<`?€,#!/JQ
§3<66.3&51\7\,@1133§;§1(42_§ ""3:1;\;~~~§;1€3W QM*Q~ ;§1.‘»` § 535“3 ~D>’§ {g§f€*3.;`";§§§ 6»§3~§»__~, 331ng mcgng §
312£1.§~¢2§3§§~ 33§23§§?»3"<;§§{’ slips-§§ /\£J\.£L ~?L3§‘d\1'””3’3\:>1§4~3=“;~§3_"€ "3'3;"\§ ~’1¢.
"§~3:£2&§,;31\11§2:.~3 f 33\1 §.:1\§3;) mr§~§<.~' 6.§‘~"'1§/' mai 336&1?1 GFFfQUPM{zO-€?
_ ' 31
§,3:.)3§:[, 37 _,3 \JC.,.~».)..» w ~11 §
” ` 1511¢§&1¢3§11§1771211 §";1;1§.@§
(3:`§‘7"-` §§ cc;§§§¢§ 613/3 c)_ C::m£
/§'101;§ 1613/§ 666`.1

331,1.336:931'11§1§§}, 325 f Véfi.}:;i

 

\`”~3\`31§§6-33€,§533" §93" {Vicg`§
I wc`»\_&:\. lE{-"Y J~/S'LQ'YN,/"¥(:)‘JQ§ r_:",&` 7QC_'31{~VQ`{#M{J()§
CC,;; ,,1-§§ 653;` `33@“':3@31;1;6171"\.:§3“?3£<\3 }3:`13'< 33-53¢ 6213533` §§1;£/6§§/1§,§ §§§133>\3!13 _\30(-,§
-3<1~3'53§ §5'~`~‘33"““ 3§§`16 366 `3~;;6 3` §§ '“§/61§3:3` §3~§“3~~`§61"113 953 §;.5:1§5

Ti~

§;'3~:27~;3§3) (,:L'Aj@(?'“${ (61¢!"';/’€.1/\ 1131 )§‘~331 aj z;;, 175 7/,€6:3 571/§“1§¢>&{ r,`f¢§p%;;(,{wj_
/ <`77
56 161 661\'66@ 16 .11"1:§’ 611 66 17011115 106 §°/ °//1§1143, »6_
1 " 1
61.31’§6656» 33 1166 336~§’ 11;,,.1§111>3:~1~§:6\§33\)§~311§§§611)36§6§:33752§ 6511/§§

(;`*f‘\§ "3'3‘\§. 3333 33 §:3§.`1§/1 553 L@Ué 64,‘§156' »§~»£’11"