Court Opinion

ID: 4047736
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:28:38.291721+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:30:39.091753
License: Public Domain

%3, UQ(/i ‘O\ lOZ/OB/
CL{

\.,~,'\;w CM A C¢.'..~.~m\ A@,m.k
€»p.‘+o\ S+a»<\'@w

" §A\oc\ Acos'ka'* Q\e.sr\<
QO. Bi "\?-303/

Auz>&`~\ ,"T§ "‘78'7¢¢

\

\
..'L\ R~=-'. Ql&`gr{¢\ C¢,\r¢§m.\q_ Avc$i"{"{‘\b??_
*rzw§ op+_ umwa s¢z+r¢@
lanes V$ A\\r`e,r) Uw`{'
1..£¢9\ F\M 314‘( M
iowa \oa¢`l<,`-T>< 7@3(0'7

ch WlT» A‘a¢| AL‘>$~\¢ /C[¢rk )

AWL porwarélu\§ a AH)[JM\`+ \'v\ §Qg£@r+ of -c>¢l¢\.,./" Qv~ toe`nc.\c op
Tbcg iv\w\¢-.+¢ Gc\\or;¢\ Qc\m§ov~a_ (TM=¢HL\'-u.,?l). mr CA¢¢S¢>M\ L\¢\\‘¢v¢_s jrl/\¢\+
\/\L 15 exp¢v;¢v~¢i%\_<§ delays , Vw\`ss+ep$, cwé oLs-&ad¢s le \'\\'5 .§¢ebu‘v\j ')ué»`<-\`a'
N.\i¢Q j¢l,w.’c are vw+ c]u¢_ 40 lmejl:j¢“¢e, er igv\orame_ ov\ \/\\`s L)e(.w.|€ ¢W<§
approad¢.¢cg .-Vv\o_ 6\\4¢§ aske as jam¢
0$ \A\`j \Ma,\`\iw.g$ \/\¢).u¢ 30~1\¢ \Miss\`wj \`v\ Pc\\~\- er ewh`vo.\~/.

§\A@.\< ' %OQ
gm m ,
»Ml@;,..,

REcEl_vED m
CDURT OF CRIM|NAL APPEALS

5 pages e»~¢lpse¢\
JUN 22 2015

Abe!Acosta,C|erk `

 

w\< M fmcs)ra v C\Q¢L.¢>Q <“¢\LOAJ(H>L C`.c`\mi\na\ A”()\)aal!

@E‘.TQ&\xE§T} T/‘h Qa\>err

M\LQQS‘\€\. l ` y
E¢\cl¢s@¢\ p\ewe. £`nd m Nc\w¥ \ QL\QL\ m Dln.!S. if » (;Ly\l ll,nou) if L{Ou
cu¢\\mi i¥\ \ would \i\u Q\‘\e ml“\ ~\M'\u§%`ou(\“p no¥ v €@eluwo cp~.~Qu`mu_s\q\
\ s)rm\g\q \> @em¥-{ Da`s£bwt )Q%¢\m co»\LH>r D?!Jn`c{/@/a/I¢
am a\ausu\g \v\).\ \\¢M t’\q\v\\~§."\`ampenvxg b.>;‘H/\ m\{ £§\lv`)gi.
\ mm de~.r\`\u\ `v\\$\rm`\m£v\ \ou¥ ow\ mdqu m oe(-{\'%cq£`w\ 01 <1'\/¢2
\>cm>e ¢rm\\,\ %.\w`\§s . 'TLL !\)\m\'\\ mm \r\M£r
x \\mz\\w md Q,@@u(¥ is gm\/\H Appm.`\'cr¥uj.

\\)¢>TE". `YY\§S v€§/\i`c\£\ &\ ‘\'\~n an,\§\>él pLA£‘/P.` 111 b€(i£iu.¥?. lY\ Q\/i.i`ural}\_c] “HQ.QJ`€
Q\\h¢§ »W\m. \. lo@\'iw“\&\n wm.r\n>o~ \`5 aba purpon -»
~cu\\\y § crt§xn\{\c§ u.>\=\'\r\ w\>.,\ {\;\£'\i\"mgs.
‘ wsm \ (QQQ`\\;Q() Y>Q\\m\ o§n"CQ.S csc N bank \zeiv\q vECe`nu/zd.

'\.0`0~/ ?, §
c 03

§ \
_, A‘{l§`jam§

\. Q>\a\om,-\ §§Gm§mc\. Q.l$'.$(ln \Me.\`m§ pvcsen§\q `\r\mr@e rc\\zc\ \I/\ §'\/\e AH Dzj
U¢\i§i mac§sc' `TB Q_.§§ *c\: \ll.lll.'\\n')?/, cw§ \>€`w\c§ Cl>m()€\@n§ §§Cl,le 015 pole ‘-'

\.
`\ am‘~§\m O_,p~p\?cm§c/\ `§Y\a. ce§>ma. Q¢/\§'MM (_°c;iu$a_$ Cav\j U§> |/)€e~dmj
s§ez§a§w§ on Gm.ls.\§. l §(\eo§ ca QA®\,\€$T Fc>asrm/ ermmunmnw
é¢\c§»sedh §r>r walk ma `K"s\L\zLI~¢§|. 33 illw~oz. &z,qu/'Dza and |mu.s~`\~
wsmmo.S/Z.QU('DL| . l §\ec) '~| cork . \ vaguest S+cx\{ because docum¢
m§ms_sen receipk , eu{daa\eo_ ~)M+/l

C§m§».t §\Qj Scu`§ m`\ ss\\¢;q doe.mw\an§:'.
\ cum `w\ m cl§§am~§ <\D produce such @ijanae_.~§kmgl»\ £a{+i/
§`\ej vm`\\ a §1).§ §§\L §l\ Qaj Uv\i~§ \U\c\“ Qm_>m §m_< blm U/\l`€CLSc)/\alz{£ m
\§Q da§qu `\\\ p<\;\.@ms\§\ \§m oe_r<\\`§o_d v€aa`\p§z . \ ;e.~/\§ C¢, \`€que§+m ~H\@,,
\Y§§\ Om§ \')-_§§\ ls§/ l\..\ \AM`\'\/\ al §Un€. H`CLW_,Y\[)'}' rewle Gr\ HAS~
wax . § §\OL\ML maj 01 @Lr`va.\lzu\(‘a [Cmv\p]qfn+\ .. AS`(‘LD(\ CQS `H\!),q C`a(a [’QH$`~
§<‘m§ `\m»{\§ \)m§\mco Smc§\ pm§-'.>§§ ww\ §\\~‘vgs.
§§ L>§ §§\§5 \K§)\n C§a.\{<>`§ §Lu\a_ § §\c\m¢ \~Q,C,é\maj [)(“L€U')W amswar$
' br \-c>'pwa, §\)w\ msd/§ C°m,m§\l. [)`vc§ar er cmq vv\a§&er_c per§mme`/\j
“\'v Wm§ mlri"\ai § \~nc{\\§n`\_s §§qu ~\'\r\\,$ \re)/\\L\a §0 ensure j.Q/iofr\{.
Ym¢§§m/ m§§`cm§ man v\v§.
_Tcma GAL\ Q.>uu§ mé\e¢-pw§§{ nc paqmr\.|. Tzqspw\rcd\q Subwj&c‘
Qalon@|, Ca.dwa'“tuawwz
ml (Qel Um`#§
Q~l H\F.M¢ZL.°( l\)‘
lo 44 ar ,T)L 7103(/’)

 

 

C¢m<§m§» Qm~xz.\\zq cs\ .0~1.1)3 wl

 

aaarr\o\\) D`F mfm’
0¥ W>(%€\Q§ COaQMS‘, MI$SMUG. ®l>cL/ML/UTS

§§ow\a.§ v\em> Ql&\ona,§ §§&rc§mm ~. Gpp§iceaw§' ©fb S(/_ \`v\~§§\a ca§>o\)£ €¢\§_~}~§ileoli CM@§ humlo~
exe,o§ Ms.&n(§ §'l`§QS ~§'§/\'\s §`qu\a§i§ ‘§r§ko. ch\i§"¢>§ Qr'i`m€ma§ § Qea§s §l)( §§qu {¢\ ccc§"\ui
C§`\ch§w"m\ o§:' §0¥‘11§/ all ~§i\a§>a.u$ (§BVPMMCMQ§ (QSQQC‘.§§`J§§L¢ ~S§\c.\..\ §§/\@, v§§c.w'm§f

l ."_Ov\e_. \Un'-§i /\Zu§a“

§§\e l§pp§\m>.r\§ §§ maw_ D§i §§NL, Dc\a.mc`»§<_; (Lm§e md §)Q,§`\a\>as -§ka§ §§\Ls m§a,'\s_ kelnq uib§a. ,
~§er§ §Dq §?\\o \§§§§r{'a.§ Ai§§e;'naqs 0§`€"¢“€,‘ and or §ks. 'Oiz-§ji\`c.li Q§e.c\c FM weick (‘_u.m~§q.Lawdo
T€yus.'¥§mxs.§§\n_ §i§ov\ora§>\a. §>e.§.o\ne'). m ` ga Y:Uic§w'\q , `\n Q§§ bor{la' -§§\`§ac§ pm ve 04 §oa,ka§[»o§’
'§§\a §\um-§i \ emma-§ man o \3 par 0§ . rmivw irm .. assess §‘mz §uc:§a iken€o.cc§\md'cco§e cm

§§\Q, \\\<{ 'y-. Ceu$equan§§q. ~§'§~L l§\)\>§'\cw\§~ m>`\§\ §o@, P<€\mc§{(‘a§ \'v'\ \\"u` &k`\§¢=§q ‘§v> Qu.a~sma_. §nca§oacd c£§`\p§.

`T§\a§o_ am \v\§§s\ng c'\<>vav\a_ .

'\§. `\\§§s§§‘n@ Muw\w\`§j

§§. "¥§¢\o l§pg§lce»!\-§ c§u§\\ §\§2£§ o §\§\va\orw\d§um o§' §_wu §\>r mak blv{§i l§pp§iccr§iw\,`§§\e. A\>p§iccv

(\§ §;§QC§ 0 \'€C§O\C~,§'a£§ OJZ)A§-€SS\¢;A §o<’ CC\\UQ_N>I`LO§>S'CQ/M §o'hb D\U\ , `\\r\ Suppb(i§ op §1(_!' pbl`n ne ed -
an§= ‘W\n. l§pp\`\cem§ §`:§m§ wi§nes§as‘ §§’cc§'ew\en§i §'§:{ cause no’s‘.~l.o\>§ Cmm Q$'L DWD 12130§1

§§:;;‘ L\L\\ b\(A).'tko_ §icm\§ §§e_c§ v\@w§v\ o'\¥scome.w\ \§Cw\€/§ Q`\v\ec§a conti C§w€s§\r`o §.010“0 §bc Cau.$e. no‘.Zi>'ou (‘_w `L\L|l 0\ lA), in supperi§’
eli Q\ru»/\C§ Z Cw\§ @lnu\§ §§ » A’C.§u,°\§ §rmoc€n€.a. C§Cil`m.~ A'QP§§CD\A'§/ glad C)_l(¥€fp`§z( ali Oodla:§
§w§ngw.n§‘ om\§ 9§€6\ §Agcaaw\an§ in sm\)pc>c~§ ¢>§ §\"\S C,§o\\‘m rel Vec§am§ S_Q¢Y§enca. l§p'}>§{cc.n-§ §1§4cl 0\
qmecm\ reamms§ §»r ma (;vea\\§»i§\§\| o§ (‘,\a`\w\§ w§\axai¢\ §\e <'.xp\c\'w\s §\\'_\ o§e§mf clad reasons §>\' >ucl~
o\t§uq ¢ §§W§§Co~¢\§ m(dmc§ac§ Ev~§\\§ar§:$ §M S\,\c§/\ o'\a,§a\{.`(§\a. l§\)p§ic&m§ a§&m pmu'ac§a¢:\ §ko 5~§~15§£'¢ Ecki'§)\i

§ 0,\0§1 §>( C€\\.\SL m>`s‘. 1005 C`YL'\\) 030 bl and 'L£§§l.a C'tLN HH| \DA.Cmd exp§a`\nw'l kbm> '§’§/\Q. \,mvz§\:r\g
on`\§¢w\ \"> iS '<’.r_rbvw_oms\§'§m» Cumc€,§ l§i§w\amt me(-§a`w\s §»-§ka Cnu:§»
md m`\ssec§ §§\a'\§am \'.’> w<>\ic§\`ng .Qc\m@ -§ka§ Cumse§c§\`d m>§ em\)§m`v\ amr§"kiv\g ref Qqe. wm §§u§ umwa sm;§@ package w\`§k 5 §€o»laa§ enmdo\>es.'¥keqmere m\¢§¢esred+n

ma m§»\cx C'\m sam 'Daqol\udo umw cullman .C@A\~§;Am: wm rsza,ooo\ zqu 9sz w ilL,
§\>§Q§ wa,`\c}k§ o§ 3 §_§:>S S.°lo 026 :De§'\\)€(\\ ja`§’€ kad\q',®§ll?>%l\$ Flka. 30 §§n clam op Apr\`l ZAIS'.

'I). '§\r\a l§pp§'\€c\\'\§ §\§m§ 0\ (CI§’C §Q§'§af m§\'\(;§n C¢:>v\§o\:~r\a£§ App§`\o;m§$ A§F\`olu\)i§ o§z’¥ca£§f,‘
l§pp§\€cv\§i exp§a\'ned \/\`\s ::§;§imsk§p L»i\‘§§~,_§od§\n Om\xse§.\ ,'Dcm»\`c§ A`\w\aaxl eu\d Fau_$+l)
Bmsou l§pp§i‘c@n§`s o§e,c`(§"\m §\> \ea§ gu'\§~k/ /kis b\v\o\ars~§un¢k"/\g ¢~)F~ like ames and pmf‘-
cochth » Scm`c§ l§'§§'c§au.'§' B§i'§:o\£§& bow \:>§ §'L puqaj L`§§\Q l§pp§'\`€r:m§- G§Sa San§o 1 page

Q¢t§\&“g'“\\Tm le l)\u_ C\Qr\k ol” S\AC§/\ Sl`\\\`ng§ . ®u%<'al\\ canal r€£\mslal i\'\\¢L Cl€c\§ lb ml~';\{ '\'\\P.
l\§‘§\l`c&nl cl A£l\`\.\£<\\` (£N.l ill cm\q clowma nl§ \\r\‘\$§`mn§. `Y\e`\l’mr o\\`Q\ '\“ko_ Cler\h_ l
Tl\mulw~a was ~C;\QA umw cl s{l\g\a package W`\l/\\ adams c>@l\;\sl~`co (_“~ev\`liz;( "Disl»
‘¢';Ll< Q\ac\(s Bll§`ch \i\' 1066 mu`\\ef.l \."'\c. (`@J lw`l\~`»ed MCC\\ .~`\’blu\ m€j\g\r\i\_ §l-Z{lb m_ 'De\{uesq Clc?le
k¢w\g (>’S .DL\_.\Y »~liknlr'i$ *\‘ka S~l’r\ daq¢>l" Ma\{/ZO|J . 'lZ@lum vice{(>l F€C\ue.s-legl was S'nqnec\.
Slc\w§ecl.cu\@\ ¢e.GQ.`\\.\QA \v\{ llm ldr§p\`\Cm\-l'. 02er no lq>f ‘lk'iS deq¢ ll leLl l?’lO OGM ZOllCI

§'L°l$.
\\\. “\l€m\ws

\‘ Q\)p\(c@u\l waves ¥\"v\ls` req\ml \>Lmusc>.,ke_ \-ece"\v~od c \elle.r limka landlch wis

Ca\~é\m\c\ .L.>\m> cel\\e.d 'lka_ \i\mwm\;\efs s£<:vclmq cmc\ won v\<>-\~\Qed Jf\'\c¢¥qn\q ~\i\nz
U“\»eco, vt<:e.'\\£d _`¥\/\o. OL(FP\'\OQ¢\XL\ \r_\m~\'ker \v\qu\cocl

mdl ' \o_,QS/\)mum\\\\\"'l">
u\:ml`§\§o_  suck,i> \\ne, CC\S€ l.€.de/\ial
~ il is ccsus& wl ~\i\w_ m`\ss`mq dwwmenld.k>\\ic§l\ w\/\QM Can$\jul?cl l{`l)o.m\lq _.orrus 'lkn,
0§9\\®“¥ S\qlq'l \r\'\s §Q,\'\\\ot\§ . l'v\ ~\’ko_, &.\vuulc\li\;£ 'e\ms< (icst\(§e\ol. €Slcllol[Sk€J l\e. fla vw-l'
_ man cm \M\Mzg. W\u$m\{ ma .;A@\lig@“l aam\.\»\k dl-qu;\l.
\v. (\)Qu>v ov- osuve=eu
”“\.Q Pq> l\‘~ v\\ lam ~lka §€O¢i\‘:~\'$ 'l\~(l>w\ l)m obs\ Olc§co, 0{\0\ (‘er\lz\c£l v€£Q."\§l'$ .iv\£\u£>.l{vg
QL\\).<§ l).e<‘_al§\i twille ‘g`bw\s m §{\:\>c -\l€'ml/\\.Q, Ma\'\la;} ~l’\\n am S-lu`lecl cmcl Mi_:xi`v\q ala ~
mw\m\¥§ ¢`\\\n A§p\{ec.“l will mQ\u__ '¥MM avc\'\\c'\\)\e m mm as ll\L dwl~\hv\ lakes p\acc.
`\\“\»\'\\ \DQ. mailed VlC\ QQ’('\\'£."M\ \w:¢`\\. Qbf$`\\>\q '\‘M. lX/"l'ln “l(ll‘k opl'l'\"\j Ml»\`l‘l/\ up )~I\-€ .
\/. ‘ - .
w\`\t=,awoa€. ’P~\/\oa c§tlerl wle M»\+\QQ @n‘l\~`l»lvc)_
Q€§`Q€c:ll;l\\\\ S\llo\v\\`~ll~€¢j\ lvp\\S/¢\§ (OY§§lml_.mlm\\u§a-l
(AQm_\ quaw*\uu\\\m
A\\ llul \l“\\
" ID\ \Y\\\X.“B\QQ N\

Wq}l' \(n §u?gn(-\¢s€ Q,E®U\B`.XT
§ _

`¥\\L l\$\\§\»\`vxg ls egva Cmcl accljrcile, lmv\$\d~\\`m ali llw_ ll
\>m¥`€\\{`s \_Q,W( (Q`. ?\w\z QQ\H§ ‘\’M_`i\\.dc\e'_x Sc\wd on Mjlk dow ¢(:'\`\J\aq
cA’ 3 §.w\. ch\ `\'l\o_ hd<}§.§ M[‘,r-e:lm\,( 'lvlclma`ll/\Al“`\'ke \D.A already '
(m@mclul mclqu lle &mrl/kas a mmll/\ 'l\:~ mem CLcl£c`uio/) ¢lkal'
\‘\C L._§\\i\\\&\ OL_Wum\'lA\-\é\a\~ Is' `\l\l §~\'k Clm.\‘ 59 jua\e,~»f\l\£\¢ cl';\v\'l dBCld~L ~l\~@/\
\’\mf \»(\\ sulo~\(l cl in "\'l\a 'Su_§'\~en\.£,. (§'¢'Jurl" CCw\/lol) @n`\\alv\a/ Appemll:l.
mwu\\ \\.,Q_<, l\\d“...`_@g¢z_»£d;@;w _ _ ~
(Qn`gfm\mbm\sr\cv\\
Tr\)\v.. &chml)e¢ under penall»| oli'q>€r`\wq` $w\>mll~\ee.\ v.\s.\s'
va\s\qlml lo\{ ¥Wz‘. C¢a\)r{€/l Ql\_'£lm::l[-/WMZ
A~ll QLCl blhl`~l' `

gm F,M.Sl@€i )u.
' park ]`)¢ `1[.¢3(!7

\>\> li CD~/\'l:r