Court Opinion

ID: 4048188
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 00:34:22.667123+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:05:09.299119
License: Public Domain

. _ -\ _ n ga |_43\/();2\03\0"1 lag/do

‘®“_ C,c>u.w"'\ o€ Cx\'\\"\inc\,\ kypeo~\$ luna ?,§i lO\S

P. C»_ %\>x \‘).?>Q%

(\\,¢,».`\~n, T»-\. ")%~1\\

Qe\ Qe_ma.v\é Oré.e.r j 0\>:3¢¢'*<§0\'\ "\'c~ ‘\’>3<<:\¥€\5 prop\>$eé. Q-iv\c\§r\cbs

E)~ P.»,..<>€»c\; \'Lz§a>%\-A

(',.Q_~D\ Qec,ovds 05 \\0. \J\JQ. "6'?,°'\30,\-0'1,-©2>{ -'b\\ \ ~O§ <>`v\d, 'C>co

O\'\ F¢\or\\o.r\\ lS\-\q', 10\5, +='v\§% 00qu o`\oq*c£c\ m\l \'\e.\oe_c»s pvoc¢»¢c)`€neds -\»o ~¥\ne,

levi¢\\ couv‘\¢ \3»>~(~'>\_>0.\'\‘\ -\c> -‘c\r\`\g‘ “¥\ne S'\c>:\e made o. apvopesec;\ dee_~(. \ o;w\ unawc-xe,
§§ ‘c"Oe ‘r\"ic\\ fwon ">:\%v\ec,\ ~\-\nis |¢>v, `\$ \r\e d\`d va\\\-\\\§v\% e\;e 3m m\\ v\w`\*r » "\:\><‘
\:>mvcr\°<`\ve, w\ec\s\>~reb, \ ¢i"\e. ~W\\`s o\Q§e_¢-\v¢v\ *m ‘<\’\e. 5¥6&¢`5 p¢wpc,e¢¢\ <>Yc&<\' because
\\<:>e,\`\€\le_ c\. fe"¥\xoo`c}<\`v\`\»\{`€xmo.\\\$\`$ \\Qcc\ \"\c>’r \c>e Cc>\'\c,\uc~\-¢c\ \Qccc\\_>sé» '\\¢\e \p¢»v'o\e.
¢\~L\;E°;vme`-\~rm=v \\'\`\b\\’\¥ovw\o`¥io\’\ was am essev\\€q\ \'JC\<'\ c>& n\\\ p\e_q_, eL¢§¢eenqe,n-§ QQ\¢
\\-N H“véz \`\Qe zev\*\€\ \O€, %€x`r\ \005(,\¢. "\~O ~\\1\€; C,.C..L. Q:)Q.co~\>se. \ \r\o\¢c we \¢v\o\~\e<&%& Cw\d. '\`\ne_

-\vio\ Q‘\>\>\('k \'\us ~0\>'\ Sc'(\*< K\'\e '\*\S o\NY\ (va¢\¥ `\C.W, \

Sz\f\§ +"<"\`\b ¢\¢\\{, \/\u§ -‘c\/\e Cn\>\'~\ c£ Cw\`m\v\o.\ bogme Fe.c,e_i\/eé` q S\>pp\¢,w\¢~n~\&\
~\"\/'o"f\%(l*(§o‘\ Vo\(gvo"\/\-\ ~\»0 `\~\`5 bwde~( '¥v ‘\"(\e *‘<{<',\\ &;\>\y('\? \"\ received "c"ne -¢O\\D\N` v \b%§ez‘l
AUEAM,©U@W< 'Fvcv\cv\ N\. \Qc\oc\’\soh \>\n\'*c
\10~1\ c .\\r\. ?>Szz, '
Y>\`\n‘\\en¢, X\` _mc.>c>\

‘ C,lwée‘,**' \'L'L»\‘\Q?_~A, mumqq-A, \15§@1\-A, \B\C\as »¢>., \'Lz$c»~e>\- A

Ex `Qou/Xe, ` ' t \n _W\€ Co\w.\.
Q$ ,Qv\‘w\\`no\\

ro\v\e,\.` \[\/;\\{(uv\§ n A‘PQ€O~\S\ L\\\S"`WMTY\‘

 

6\0`5&¢&§00 ‘\'0 '\"\'\e 3\'03<€,`3 Q\fbpese& '\fmc\m<`>ss o§- \:c»c"< C>_nc\
Cc>v\c,\\>${bv\$ 04 Law &nc\ C`)\’C\ev AQ'\'Q‘( Q€'f\'\c>~nc\ \O\q '\'\'\€,

CC\>'\)\c`\ ‘(\o`\re_
`\Y\§\s¥_ed cv\ %o\`\'\% ‘\e, C'\`\%§\)`\\\"\\(' C{cc_\`\‘o\e=, I\S 0§- -`k\nis d¢>£<'e,, \ne. §§ uhc>`§~cu“e
`\$ `¥\\e “<\“icx\ C\>\>\’X C\C\op‘ce@\ -\'\<\e 3’§0:‘€€,\3 Q§\r\c\<‘n%%, \c\>‘\ (;{\£:S
4'\(\`\5 c>\o§e€r»l=€®\\ c\uc ,‘\'o “¥\r\e S~Xc\-ke ov%\n% -\`\n¢ \-‘v\`o\\ fluqu
0`\:\¢\ +\{\e C,b\>\(>< 09 Cx'\\'\\w\cx\ (>\ppzo\s “\'0 Qa>\c\<\\>d< ex \‘Q'\voo`c;\§§v\'~‘r\[
Cm<,\\\\s`\s,, `YY\@ %Xo‘ce`s mopos,e<\ -$i@¢\m%§ \>\'Q@ J<\ne C\>\> %e,e \1\:\(\@-\\0¢\/ o\/\ooasqz@ <\e\(\ '_§§S`_ E`>Q,\

 

S\I\¢\?>c\ (o%¥\ CTes<. Q\<\m. l\\?p. 10\2} `\s rekvocxc¥§vc *vo Co.%e%
occurring bg¢@(é Ce\ow\>ex\.\ \‘S, lc>\z. I>\\>§§\\ ov\&e,< *<\nc
<`i%\w*< Q,`wc\>m§cox\ces ex We)<\/oeu)<\\/i&q wr\c\\\\s\‘,\@\ \oe
pee_ `\5 \Y\app\ic@\o\e \)egqose_ emp\`\c<§` \~\\3\4 QTev`_

 

an\. Ap¢. m>o\§ Jcc> o\o*'q&\ '\“e`\"\e‘? codex cm\ ®\\veo`é\q

eg><&\@\:g\\éé\ prec,@d@m became @m@\e Q,\§%;\Oz\§><\\

m\§in$orm&*f\ \Nc`».s fm €S%e\\*c{a\ p"¢\~€_ E\/\ Qcc_(°v@ Svep\ne>r\aov\ '1?,?/ S~\\\»\ '_1¢3\ \A'l@> C’\ey~. Q~r\`m.

 

AQQ. \Q%"Z), +\'\e J\'\»io~\ QQ>L>\("¥ needs "co s¥`\`\\ 'C\>v\\\ew deve\o(>
-\"\ne record -+0 make Spec;`\$ic, $Qc*c Q§v\c\\o%s vec£)owcxm% “‘<\n€_
\m@\<¢<+ +evms \L\m~\ \o»` sx%v\m% £N 0\ \a§@_ Sem@n¢e\ mm
Cc-Y\Q\>\’rex\“\ 'C<>r C\\\ C)nm%e,%. `\Y\ a §p\eo\ \@Q<%Qm, \ne wo\>\e\
be spoxo\e. &\i%§\o\'€,.

`]I_. Esse.'n°\'§c>\\v @cu°< 09 P\em z¥%(c.amer\‘\'
N\r. \N`\\\\`m\\§ Q\Qcé\ %o§\X\\ w a\\ q>€' \ms oc&mes gov §\{Q‘<_\(@(\°< \Nc& §§qu 0§ 0. p\eq \oox%o.l\n \
N\f. \l\s`\\\\`€m\”\'$ Y\&S O\ Qo\o\\ c>€ ~W\\`§ \Q\ec\ &%reem©n+ amd
\/\0§@§§ Jr\<\e_ C\e,x\¢ Q\\., c\, Q@p\\ o‘€+v\\`g
p\eo\ O\%re>zme\(\)r as w@\\. \~Q ~<\QX, he \N<\\ l§\>\m§§\n i\ _`\$
(`Qc>`\> e§er,
`m (esc>\\mg_ ‘v\(\'\> ine§?@c>yi\/€ uss\s.‘cv\t>‘<\ deeds
pmc>\e wm cm €%5@<\*<`\0\\ pad <>‘§ Jk\¢\e \o\ea &g%\r\ +\(\e ©av ingmp@mécx\ \>\e_u ac§c@m@r\% `\"€<\o\'\cx\ basis 0\(\ \N`\r\\)\ cloc\`\’aox\*< .
\NQ\>\A \Q\‘e,o;c\ c§\>`\\’r\\ \'c> ‘v\(\fe€_ \i§-e %e_\<\*v;\:\c;eg mm
Q®v\cov rex\'\ R\f\ \(\\`5 \Q\ecx \<)c>x’%o;\'v\, `\Q \<\e \No\>\d<\` X \o¥e
@mc>\e <=.\`\q§\\@\e_q kg .c>\Qp\`\co.\r\'\ C).\"vo`c;\(\ed Cx"> ow\ E~/"<\`\\O§X Jco
\®\S havens w ms ~ ms imm ulrwmeq`§ a§@idow§+ `\Y\

2

Feep@nse +<> a $‘\'c\‘v\\\` ramon \1\& was \Q\em§\mc§. %oi\&\{.
T`Y\€;. S\'OXQ, prc»po§cé\ Qov\c_\\>$\` U\S 09 \&w camc\ 53ch -@iné\§n:s\>

oxe_ `\v\uc§eqw'\~a. -{\g an¥al\eé\ `m W\o\>ssqzqde\(\ K, `\c\ . , c\\r\

 

e&§ev\°ricx\ mci eQ a p\ec\ u%v\c& \.>@<>v\ ~¥\n¢
express ~\'~ev~n\"o.\’ Q\/\om\XXed \Q\\ \Os<\(\ +\(\e_ m@;@cmm\
Gv\d ~\\(\e 009\`\0&¥\‘\ `w\'& V\&\Oea$ pmceec\mg>\` Tv\¢\cxs*c prong `\s
~W\e "\SS\)Q ‘(\e\re. T\<\e, ‘wicl\ Co\><°r needs ‘<1> 0\¢\&(¢33 `\¥_
pm c>\e e\ic\\"\b`\\ \“v\¢ \NQS 0¢<\ eage\r\~¥io\\ e\©mer\”§ c{- ~‘\'e¢zme'>n* w\'%\\ &v'\ ewic\ex\*<§cm\{ \/\Q,oxm§.“¥\r\e_ gage E_~,\_
\Ow‘ce §~Ye§p\\e,\"\a:y\ 'na 5»1\¢\1¢\ knee LT@_»;, Q¢g`<\
‘W\€_ p\eo\ \ocu%c\\n popevs é\o OL>X N\c\uc§& po\e. ‘a<,\s
'-\O be <':\r~\@ox\<§ec§\ `\v\ \K%Y\’r 0§ EK ‘OC\\'\ , "\Q\\
m . '\:Qv°<\\e_‘€ De,~\/@'\c>\o\\'\ex\“\ O€ -\<\(§e, `chor&
\t\s\»\€€z:ac»'<>v_& Q\Q.EN\\s_-€s co\us\oe\zeo, Aop\\~¢`~`§ -w\e. &Y<@\
Cc>\><‘¥ be mo`~<\éxoc\ed 'Xo C.c>‘(\c§\\.\c)v c\v\ Q\x \`C\@(\&\`o`\xq \r\eo¢r\`r\<\>) omc§
expand ~W\e VECC>(S~` 3m de"<€xm\\r\€, `\Q \n\`§ pooro\c
\(e©cv\ex\"< .

 

Q,e$pe¢*<@o \\\)\ 5 o \om \' \'\’Qc\,

Sc%m@\ 4<\{\\& 2§+\5¢¢… O€ sum

’)_0\§

 

Qoéme~\ \¢e,\mn- \I\IL\\\`G.w\§ S<`.
`Y`©.C,.§. JW \\QBS‘€$Z'?

\?{wc\n \\r\. Q¢\Q€Ms¢v~ k)m&
120'1\ <;.w\. 3§11

ix\@;\w; . T$` '1<>\\00\'

' - Q&u.`>§e =FF. \?,Zu'!q?_»A',_\'L'L\»\'\q\)\-é\`. \’L€s`~au--A,' \?,3>\<\%'>‘-/>» ; \'Lz'§c¢~a\_`A

E»\ \>m~>`\l`\‘c -QO( \-\o`\oec&$ C.Qro\.»s

Cm>se* \'Lz\mz_A', \zzmq\\»A; w_§§~ez,\ ~A; \13\<)\?,§~1>\~, \zz§@Q\-A

\, Q<><,\ne_~,\ \x\i§\\iu\m$, &§wa\ \ agree.c,\ w \Q\eaé %~¢{\‘r\\
$c>v cx\\ 0% wm 0%€@(\§€$ `\r\ a\oo\¢e Sa\r
cl \\`(»e Se‘<\*©r\c£, Y\(\c;m\'e,v\‘\' ~@o\' u\\ @V\ar%es because,
` \o\{ °co\\z.`w\g ‘v\(\&& \o\ecx \Dcxw'%cx\n , m\»\ Oé€rc>w\e»\ “YL>\A me ~k\(\e,
€%S@(\'HO`\ @c\c¥o( ‘\'D ii \NC)\>\€\ \0& “\_\r\c€r 4\ \I\cou\d \oe. e\`\%`§'\@\e
.Qm @d<'c>\e coe c\&q¢'TY\e Q\e& bargain \ e,\m>ve-re¢,\ `\v\*vos
§N\(\o\e §\>\os*mwce \Nas m(o\e e\`\%'\\@°\\§%v\ ., “`V\<\&g is *<`\ne 0“\\4
MS<>'Y\ md UY\SKAG,Y()X\Q\(\ \oq *c‘ne §va‘0\1_ \N\\\f\ 0 \\$e Se)(\*ve\nce \NU/\ no pav¢>\e,
\ wmwa QCA\(\ ow\ \(\\\\N *v\(\`\s Qu\>\c\ <\m*r \oe o.'v\ essex\&\o\\ Qw‘v c>?
m\` p\eo` 0,%\~€@0(\@(\“\'. (,q\n(<\\q Qu~\, \ €'¢Q\ -¥\r\`\g C;>w\\s €QX%Q~(\
§§ ~ov\cg>v\&<;`\o\r_\c\\o\\\ \m©mmis.s`\\o\e, cmc\ \ncx\xe, \\>§\ Qc§\'X\\ i‘_/\
001 §\><>\Kciq\ §\\\§ke>mo

90\’3\>0\<\°¥ w presex\°c\\\ \0&`\\(\<5 RY\Q&YC€,W&XQA iv\ "<\(\€
szms hepc><~%mev\‘< Q>§ Q< \m\v\o\\ Aw§<'ic,e \ a£-Q\v m A<\(\Q
(l\cl\\l@ \& \~\'WL Oo(\cl QU\”QC:¥ w ~‘c\(\e \Oe$'\ 0¥ YYN c\\o\\\ ¥\q

Do}rec\ and S\%Y\e_c\ ‘f\!\\§ C\c>.\\_\‘&\{\€_ 'Z§*r\'\ 0€ 5\)\:\€_. ’LO\_S