Court Opinion

ID: 3480187
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-07-05 20:55:38.024687+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:13:09.065841
License: Public Domain

In a suit pending between plaintiff and defendant, in the parish of Lafayette, the defendant sought and obtained an order directing the relator, Hibernia Bank  Trust Company, to produce before the district court in said parish of Lafayette, certain books, papers, documents, and writings then in the possession of said relator at its domicile in the parish of Orleans; and the trial judge being about to insist upon compliance with his said order, the relator applied to this court for relief by writ of prohibition.
                                   I.
It is well settled that even a party to the litigation cannot be compelled to transport his books, papers, documents, and writings from one parish to another; and a fortiori third persons cannot be compelled to do so. Cooper v. Polk, 2 La. Ann. 158; Ludeling v. Frellsen, 4 La. Ann. 534; Murison v. Butler, 18 La. Ann. 296; Cain v. Pullen, 34 La. Ann. 511; La. Farm Bureau v. Bacon, 159 La. 169, 105 So. 278.
                                   II.
The defendant complains that such a rule denies him the right to obtain evidence necessary for his defense, to which he would otherwise be entitled; but "it is well settled in such cases, that sworn copies of the papers desired will suffice." Cain v. Pullen, *Page 253
34 La. Ann. 511, 515, citing 2 La. Ann. 158, 4 La. Ann. 534, and 18 La. Ann. 296, all supra. And nothing said in Cain v. Pullen, supra, about the objection to compelling a party to leave his books and papers with a commissioner "for an indefinite time" to be examined by whosoever will, conflicts with the undoubted right of a litigant to interrogate the other party or a third person as to the contents of material books and papers, and to procure (at his own expense) sworn copies thereof.
                                 Decree.
It is therefore ordered that the writ of prohibition herein issued be now made perpetual; defendant to pay the costs hereof.