Court Opinion

ID: 2798858
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2015-05-06 15:00:32.389533+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T11:29:29.610756
License: Public Domain

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
                  MERIT SYSTEMS PROTECTION BOARD

                                                DOCKET NUMBERS 1
CCAD   ARX6                                     DA-0752-14-0248-I-1
CCAD   ARX6-2                                   DA-0752-14-0281-I-1
CCAD   ARX6-3                                   DA-0752-14-0379-I-1
CCAD   ARX6-4                                   DA-0752-14-0390-I-1
CCAD   ARX6-5                                   DA-0752-14-0391-I-1
                    Appellants,

             v.
                                                DATE: May 6, 2015
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY,
            Agency.

        THIS FINAL ORDER IS NO NPRECEDENTIAL 2

      Rory B. Thomas, James L Vaughn, Richard H. Smith, II, Domingo
      Gonzalez, III, Paul T. Creacy, International Association of Machinists and
      Aerospace Workers, Corpus Christi, Texas, for the appellants.

      Kenneth A. Weeks and Mandy Muniz, Corpus Christi, Texas, American
        Federation of Government Employees, for the appellants.

      A. Katharine J. Kiss, Redstone Arsenal, Alabama, for the agency.

      Rosa Gonzalez-Smith, Corpus Christi, Texas, for the agency.

1
  The individual appellants and docket numbers that are included in this consolidation
are set forth in Appendices A-E to this order.
2
   A nonprecedential order is one that the Board has determined does not add
sign ificantly to the body of MSPB case law. Parties may cite nonprecedential orders,
but such orders have no precedential value; the Board and administrative judges are not
required to follow or distinguish them in any future decisions. In contrast, a
precedential decision issued as an Opinion and Order has been identified by the Board
as significantly contributing to the Board’s case law. See 5 C.F.R. § 1201.117(c).
                                                                                       2

                                            BEFORE

                                 Susan Tsui Grundmann, Chairman
                                    Mark A. Robbins, Member

                                         FINAL ORDER
¶1        The appellants represented by the International Association of Machinists
     and Aerospace Workers (IAM) and the American Federation of Government
     Employees (AFGE) have filed a petition for review of five initial decisions,
     which affirmed the furlough actions and found that the appellants did not prove
     their affirmative defenses. Generally, we grant petitions such as this one only
     when: the initial decision contains erroneous findings of material fact; the initial
     decision is based on an erroneous interpretation of statute or regulation or the
     erroneous application of the law to the facts of the case; the judge’s rulings
     during either the course of the appeal or the initial decision were not consistent
     with required procedures or involved an abuse of discretion, and the resulting
     error affected the outcome of the case; or new and material evidence or legal
     argument is available that, despite the petitioner’s due diligence, was not
     available when the record closed. See Title 5 of the Code of Federal Regulations,
     section 1201.115 (5 C.F.R. § 1201.115).       After fully considering the filings in
     these appeals, and based on the following points and authorities, we conclude that
     the petitioners have not established any basis under section 1201.115 for granting
     the petitions for review.      Therefore, we DENY the petitions for review and
     AFFIRM      the   initial     decisions,   which   are   now   the   Board’s   final
     decisions. 5 C.F.R. § 1201.113(b).

                                        BACKGROUND
¶2        A number of similarly situated employees from the Corpus Christi Army
     Depot (CCAD) appealed the agency’s decision to furlough them for 6 days
     between July 8, 2013, and September 30, 2013, and raised affirmative defenses of
                                                                                        3

     harmful procedural error and a violation of due process. See, e.g., MSPB Docket
     No. DA-0752-14-0248-I-1 (CCAD ARX6), Consolidated Appeal File (CAF), Tabs
     2, 23; MSPB Docket No. DA-0752-14-0281-I-1 (CCAD ARX6-2), CAF, Tabs 2,
     24; MSPB Docket No. DA-0752-14-379-I-1 (CCAD ARX6-3), CAF, Tabs 2, 20;
     MSPB Docket No. DA-0752-14-0390-I-1 (CCAD ARX6-4), CAF, Tabs 2, 21;
     MSPB Docket No. DA-0752-14-039I-I-1 (CCAD ARX6-5), CAF, Tabs 2, 20.
     The individual appeals were consolidated into the aforementioned five
     groups. After holding a single hearing, the administrative judge issued one initial
     decision for each consolidated group, affirming the furloughs and finding that the
     appellants did not prove any of their affirmative defenses. See, e.g., CCAD
     ARX6, CAF, Tab 28; CCAD ARX6-2, CAF, Tab 28; CCAD ARX6-3, CAF, Tab
     24; CCAD ARX6-4, CAF, Tab 25; CCAD ARX6-5, CAF, Tab 25.
¶3        The Board received two virtually identical petitions for review from AFGE
     and IAM in each matter. See CCAD ARX6, Petition for Review (PFR) File, Tabs
     1-2; CCAD ARX6-2, PFR File, Tabs 1-2; CCAD ARX6-3, PFR File, Tabs 1-2;
     CCAD ARX6-4, PFR File, Tabs 1-2; CCAD ARX6-5, PFR File, Tabs 1-2. 3 We
     construe these submissions as a petition for review from all appellants
     represented by AFGE or IAM. The agency filed a response to the petitions for
     review. See, e.g., CCAD ARX6, PFR File, Tab 3.
¶4        Because the petitions for review raise the same issues in each matter, we
     have further consolidated these appeals to address the AFGE and IAM petitions
     for review. See 5 C.F.R. § 1201.36(b) (consolidation is appropriate if doing so
     would expedite processing and not adversely affect the interests of the parties);
     see also Prouty v. General Services Administration, 122 M.S.P.R. 117, ¶ 1
     (2014). Accordingly, this final order applies to all of the appellants represented

     3
      Because the petitions for review raise the same issues and the relevant documents in
     each consolidated appeal are substantially similar, we hereinafter only refer to the
     submissions in the CCAD ARX6 consolidated appeal file and petition for review file.
                                                                                        4

     by AFGE and IAM whose furloughs were affirmed below in these five
     consolidated appeals.

                     DISCUSSION OF ARGUMENTS ON REVIEW
¶5        On review, the AFGE and IAM appellants argue that: (1) the administrative
     judge improperly denied AFGE’s request for an appellant to testify; (2) the
     agency attorney improperly “interfered” with one of the appellants’ witnesses by
     holding a meeting with the witness and the deciding official without notifying the
     appellants’ representatives; and (3) the administrative judge improperly limited
     discovery. E.g., CCAD ARX6, PFR File, Tabs 1-2. For the following reasons,
     the appellants’ arguments do not warrant a different outcome.
¶6        Prior to the hearing, none of the appellants was designated as a witness.
     See, e.g., CCAD ARX6, CAF, Tabs 13-15 (the appellants’ prehearing
     submissions), 23 (order and summary of prehearing conference).              However,
     during the hearing, for the first time, the AFGE representative asked for an
     appellant to testify. See, e.g., CCAD ARX6, CAF, Tab 27 (audio file 4 of 4).
     The administrative judge permitted the AFGE representative to make an offer of
     proof, but she ultimately did not permit the appellant witness to testify. Id.
¶7        The    administrative    judge    has    wide    discretion   under     5 C.F.R.
     § 1201.41(b)(8), (10) to exclude witnesses where it has not been shown that their
     testimony would be relevant, material, and nonrepetitious. Franco v. U.S. Postal
     Service, 27 M.S.P.R. 322, 325 (1985). On review, the appellants speculate that it
     is “possible that some key information was not touched upon [and/or] direct
     knowledge was not made available to the [administrative judge] during this
     hearing that very well may have levied an alternate decision.”          E.g., CCAD
     ARX6, PFR File, Tab 1 at 1, Tab 2 at 1. Beyond this speculation, the appellants
     do not identify on review any testimony that the proposed witness would have
     provided that would have changed the outcome of this matter.           We therefore
     discern no error with the administrative judge’s decision in this regard.
                                                                                             5

¶8         Regarding the appellants’ assertion that the agency attorney improperly
     interfered with one of its witnesses, 4 the agency in its response denied that any
     such meeting occurred. See, e.g., CCAD ARX6, PFR File, Tab 3 at 4. Although
     the statements of a party’s representative in a pleading do not constitute evidence,
     Hendricks v. Department of the Navy, 69 M.S.P.R. 163, 168 (1995), we are not
     persuaded that a different outcome is warranted. The appellants’ bare assertion
     that a meeting occurred between the agency attorney, the deciding official, and
     the witness in question, without more, does not persuade us that there was any
     witness interference.
¶9         Regarding discovery, it appears that during the prehearing conference, the
     administrative judge addressed AFGE’s motion to compel regarding interrogatory
     2, which sought, for each working capital funded depot, how much money was
     returned for each “program” at the CCAD for fiscal years 2011, 2012, and 2013.
     See, e.g., CCAD ARX6, CAF, Tabs 21 (discovery for consideration during
     prehearing conference), 23 (order and summary of prehearing conference). The
     administrative judge granted the appellants’ motion in part, and she ordered the
     agency to provide information regarding fiscal years 2012 and 2013. E.g., CCAD
     ARX6, CAF, Tab 23. The appellants argue on review that the information “did
     not reach back far enough to show the financial consistency of the Agency.” E.g.,
     CCAD ARX6, PFR File, Tab 1 at 2, Tab 2 at 2. To the extent that the appellants
     are arguing that the administrative judge improperly limited discovery, the Board
     will not reverse an administrative judge’s rulings on discovery matters absent an
     abuse of discretion. Wagner v. Environmental Protection Agency, 54 M.S.P.R.
     447, 452 (1992), aff’d, 996 F.2d 1236 (Fed. Cir. 1993) (Table). The abuse of
     discretion standard is “a very high standard” and allows for “great deference.”
     Pecard v. Department of Agriculture, 115 M.S.P.R. 31, ¶ 15 (2010) (citing
     Lipscomb v. Department of Defense, 69 M.S.P.R. 484, 487 (1996)).                      The
     4
       It appears that the witness in question was the agency’s designated reply official. See,
     e.g., CCAD ARX6, CAF, Tab 13 at 11; CCAD ARX6, PFR File, Tab 1 at 1.
                                                                                  6

appellants have not persuaded us that the administrative judge’s decision to order
the agency to produce responsive documentation from fiscal years 2012 and
2013—and not fiscal year 2011—constitutes an abuse of discretion.

                 NOTICE TO THE APPELLANT REGARDING
                    YOUR FURTHER REVIEW RIGHTS
     You have the right to request review of this final decision by the United
States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. You must submit your request to
the court at the following address:
                          United States Court of Appeals
                              for the Federal Circuit
                            717 Madison Place, N.W.
                             Washington, DC 20439

     The court must receive your request for review no later than 60 calendar
days after the date of this order. See 5 U.S.C. § 7703(b)(1)(A) (as rev. eff. Dec.
27, 2012). If you choose to file, be very careful to file on time. The court has
held that normally it does not have the authority to waive this statutory deadline
and that filings that do not comply with the deadline must be dismissed. See
Pinat v. Office of Personnel Management, 931 F.2d 1544 (Fed. Cir. 1991).
     If you need further information about your right to appeal this decision to
court, you should refer to the federal law that gives you this right. It is found in
Title 5 of the United States Code, section 7703 (5 U.S.C. § 7703) (as rev. eff.
Dec. 27, 2012). You may read this law as well as other sections of the United
States   Code,    at   our   website,   http://www.mspb.gov/appeals/uscode.htm.
Additional information is available at the court's website, www.cafc.uscourts.gov.
Of particular relevance is the court's "Guide for Pro Se Petitioners and
Appellants," which is contained within the court's Rules of Practice, and Forms 5,
6, and 11.
     If you are interested in securing pro bono representation for your court
appeal, you may visit our website at http://www.mspb.gov/probono for
                                                                             7

information regarding pro bono representation for Merit Systems Protection
Board appellants before the Federal Circuit. The Merit Systems Protection Board
neither endorses the services provided by any attorney nor warrants that any
attorney will accept representation in a given case.

FOR THE BOARD:                            ______________________________
                                          William D. Spencer
                                          Clerk of the Board
Washington, D.C.
                                                              8

                            APPENDIX A

                            CCAD ARX6
                         DA-0752-14-0248-I-1

Abel Acosta                             DA-0752-13-3868-I-1
Adrian Alaniz                           DA-0752-13-3938-I-1
Adrian Alvarado                         DA-0752-13-2689-I-1
Alesandro L. Benavides                  DA-0752-13-2859-I-1
Alexander Amillano                      DA-0752-13-2843-I-1
Alexander M. Aguirre                    DA-0752-13-3409-I-1
Alfred Acosta                           DA-0752-13-4019-I-1
Alfredo G. Campos                       DA-0752-13-1722-I-1
Allen W. Bode                           DA-0752-13-2437-I-1
Ana M. Bosquez                          DA-0752-13-3441-I-1
Andres Abrego                           DA-0752-13-2425-I-1
Andrew H. Babin                         DA-0752-13-2773-I-1
Andy Byrd                               DA-0752-13-4607-I-1
Andy L. Conner                          DA-0752-13-3253-I-1
Anthony Betancourt                      DA-0752-13-1810-I-1
Arnold Canales                          DA-0752-13-3972-I-1
Arnoldo R. Acuna                        DA-0752-13-3823-I-1
Arturo Cantu                            DA-0752-13-2746-I-1
Arturo G. Andrade                       DA-0752-13-3581-I-1
Augustin M. Blanco                      DA-0752-13-3884-I-1
Benjamin Aparicio                       DA-0752-13-2278-I-1
Billy R. Bailey                         DA-0752-13-4712-I-1
Brendalee D. Cruz                       DA-0752-13-2708-I-1
Brian O. Bratcher                       DA-0752-13-3640-I-1
                                              9

Brian S. Brown          DA-0752-13-3926-I-1
Bryan L. Copeland       DA-0752-13-3555-I-1
Carol-Anne Cox          DA-0752-13-3946-I-1
Casimiro I. Arriola     DA-0752-13-1461-I-1
Charles Chavana         DA-0752-13-1226-I-1
Christopher A. Carson   DA-0752-13-1928-I-1
Cornelius E. Bonds      DA-0752-13-3589-I-1
Cristina M. Buseman     DA-0752-13-3593-I-1
Daniel C. Cirilo        DA-0752-13-2899-I-1
Daniel L. Barrientez    DA-0752-13-2457-I-1
Daniel R. Clark         DA-0752-13-3996-I-1
Daniel S. Alvarez       DA-0752-13-4018-I-1
Danny L. Mendiola       DA-0752-13-2447-I-1
David Chagoya           DA-0752-13-2852-I-1
David L. Barbay         DA-0752-13-3523-I-1
David R. Acuna          DA-0752-13-2310-I-1
David S. Ayala          DA-0752-13-3602-I-1
Davie W. Castro         DA-0752-13-2844-I-1
Dennis W. Campbell      DA-0752-13-3826-I-1
Diana K. Brickley       DA-0752-13-3139-I-1
Domenico L. Benitez     DA-0752-13-4287-I-1
Donald J. Alexander     DA-0752-13-3232-I-1
Dora J. Alcazar         DA-0752-13-2597-I-1
Douglas M. Brubaker     DA-0752-13-3819-I-1
Drew A. Altenburg       DA-0752-13-3616-I-1
Edward Alvarez          DA-0752-13-1064-I-1
Edward Botello          DA-0752-13-3572-I-1
Edward Casiano          DA-0752-13-2713-I-1
Edward D. Cain          DA-0752-13-3239-I-1
                                             10

Enedina Cervantes      DA-0752-13-3822-I-1
Ernesto Amaya          DA-0752-13-1818-I-1
Feliciano Cavazos      DA-0752-13-2312-I-1
Frank Armendariz       DA-0752-13-3415-I-1
Frankie G. Collins     DA-0752-13-2892-I-1
Gabriel F. Caballero   DA-0752-13-4306-I-1
Gabriel O. Cavazos     DA-0752-13-1066-I-1
Gary D. Axsom          DA-0752-13-3991-I-1
Gary L. Adams          DA-0752-13-2503-I-1
Gene E. Boatman        DA-0752-13-2718-I-1
Guadalupe A. Cantu     DA-0752-13-3646-I-1
Guillermno Calderon    DA-0752-13-3784-I-1
Hector Chapa           DA-0752-13-2674-I-1
Hector Contreras       DA-0752-13-1922-I-1
Hilda A. Barrera       DA-0752-13-2935-I-1
Hugo A. Chavez         DA-0752-13-2637-I-1
Humberto T. Campos     DA-0752-13-2628-I-1
Jacob M. Araujo        DA-0752-13-2961-I-1
James B. Alexander     DA-0752-13-3968-I-1
James G. Aiken         DA-0752-13-2664-I-1
James W. Cook          DA-0752-13-2694-I-1
Jeff A. Barnes         DA-0752-13-3918-I-1
Jess A. Avery          DA-0752-13-3790-I-1
Jesse D. Alvarez       DA-0752-13-3425-I-1
Jesse D. Cisneros      DA-0752-13-2821-I-1
Jesse O. Biayobzcki    DA-0752-13-1704-I-1
Jesus J. Barrientes    DA-0752-13-3788-I-1
Jesus R. Carrillo      DA-0752-13-2769-I-1
Jimmy Cantu            DA-0752-13-2028-I-1
                                             11

Jimmy L. Conner        DA-0752-13-1490-I-1
Joe A. Caballos        DA-0752-13-3534-I-1
Joe L. Cantu           DA-0752-13-2445-I-1
John G. Aguirre        DA-0752-13-1063-I-1
John C. Andrade        DA-0752-13-2574-I-1
John D. Alonzo         DA-0752-13-4038-I-1
John H. Burch          DA-0752-13-3780-I-1
Jon C. Cantu           DA-0752-13-4028-I-1
Jonathan P. Botello    DA-0752-13-2700-I-1
Jonathan W. Cloyd      DA-0752-13-3417-I-1
Jose A. Castillo       DA-0752-13-1065-I-1
Jose A. Castillo       DA-0752-13-1809-I-1
Jose G. Bulcen         DA-0752-13-2665-I-1
Jose R. Alvarez        DA-0752-13-3689-I-1
Joseph G. Benavides    DA-0752-13-3774-I-1
Joshua Ayala           DA-0752-13-3634-I-1
Joshua S. Chappell     DA-0752-13-3796-I-1
Juan A. Carion         DA-0752-13-2814-I-1
Juan D. Canizales      DA-0752-13-2644-I-1
Juan M. Alvarez        DA-0752-13-3120-I-1
Kathy P. Comstock      DA-0752-13-2939-I-1
Kay L. Corral          DA-0752-13-2922-I-1
Kevin S. Bradley       DA-0752-13-3420-I-1
LaShaun D. Chappell    DA-0752-13-3573-I-1
Lamar M. Avila         DA-0752-13-3427-I-1
Leeandro C. Alderete   DA-0752-13-3837-I-1
Leonard E. Acker       DA-0752-13-3628-I-1
Leonel V. Adams        DA-0752-13-3886-I-1
Linda E. Bass          DA-0752-13-2884-I-1
                                             12

Lionel R. Cortinas     DA-0752-13-3643-I-1
Lodie M. Arredondo     DA-0752-13-2668-I-1
Lorenza L. Canales     DA-0752-13-2612-I-1
Louis L. Alvarado      DA-0752-13-2740-I-1
MICHAEL V. ANDERSON    DA-0752-13-3642-I-1
Manuel Alvarez         DA-0752-13-1612-I-1
Manuel J. Coronado     DA-0752-13-2860-I-1
Manuel N. Alvarez      DA-0752-13-2487-I-1
Marcos C. Betancourt   DA-0752-13-1211-I-1
Margarito Barraza      DA-0752-13-2659-I-1
Maria G. Chacon        DA-0752-13-2460-I-1
Mariano T. Cervantes   DA-0752-13-2846-I-1
Mark A. Bradsher       DA-0752-13-3855-I-1
Mark A. Cahlik         DA-0752-14-0317-I-1
Mark Bustos            DA-0752-13-2565-I-1
Martin Benavides       DA-0752-13-2907-I-1
Matthew Benavides      DA-0752-13-3890-I-1
Matthew D. Babbitt     DA-0752-13-4035-I-1
Michael Benavides      DA-0752-13-1466-I-1
Michael Cortinas       DA-0752-13-1496-I-1
Michael K. Byron       DA-0752-13-4039-I-1
Mike C. Briseno        DA-0752-13-3961-I-1
Monica Carranza        DA-0752-13-3620-I-1
Nancy G. Burgess       DA-0752-13-3845-I-1
Nestor M. Chavez       DA-0752-13-2854-I-1
Octaviano Aleman       DA-0752-13-3635-I-1
Olga Benavidez         DA-0752-13-3624-I-1
Omar Bosquez           DA-0752-13-3894-I-1
Orlando J. Almaguer    DA-0752-13-2431-I-1
                                              13

Paul Creacy             DA-0752-13-2782-I-1
Ramiro M. Barajas       DA-0752-13-3551-I-1
Randell F. Carr         DA-0752-13-1464-I-1
Reynaldo J. Contreras   DA-0752-13-3219-I-1
Rhett P. Butler         DA-0752-13-3858-I-1
Ricardo Amaya           DA-0752-13-3229-I-1
Ricardo M. Cruz         DA-0752-13-3676-I-1
Richard G. Carter       DA-0752-13-3235-I-1
Rikki Craig             DA-0752-13-4605-I-1
Robert Aguirre          DA-0752-13-3872-I-1
Robert J. Bean          DA-0752-13-3586-I-1
Robert L. Anderson      DA-0752-13-3470-I-1
Robert L. Castaneda     DA-0752-13-3579-I-1
Roberto Almaraz         DA-0752-13-3978-I-1
Roger D. Banks          DA-0752-13-3594-I-1
Romeo A. Arriaga        DA-0752-13-3471-I-1
Roy C. Coffman          DA-0752-13-2897-I-1
Ruben Arreola           DA-0752-13-3252-I-1
Ruben Ayala             DA-0752-13-2409-I-1
Russell T. Brashars     DA-0752-13-3433-I-1
Sammy Cabrera           DA-0752-13-3571-I-1
Sara Botello            DA-0752-13-2411-I-1
Shaunna L. Cavazos      DA-0752-13-3648-I-1
Shea H. Adams           DA-0752-13-2455-I-1
Steve W. Boxwell        DA-0752-13-3787-I-1
Susan C. Caldwell       DA-0752-13-3225-I-1
Sylvia S. Benavides     DA-0752-13-2499-I-1
Theodoro Contreras      DA-0752-13-2796-I-1
Thomas A. Brinn         DA-0752-13-3230-I-1
                                             14

Thomas A. Cantu        DA-0752-13-3562-I-1
Timothy C. Corwin      DA-0752-13-2291-I-1
Tina M. Cox            DA-0752-13-3124-I-1
Veronica R. Alvarado   DA-0752-13-3544-I-1
Victor E. Castillo     DA-0752-13-2944-I-1
Yolanda Coleman        DA-0752-13-3242-I-1
                                                             15

                           APPENDIX B

                          CCAD ARX6-2
                        DA-0752-14-0281-I-1

Aaron T. Gonzalez                      DA-0752-13-3631-I-1
Adam Franco                            DA-0752-13-2667-I-1
Agustin H. Garcia                      DA-0752-13-2866-I-1
Albert G. Guajardo                     DA-0752-13-3650-I-1
Alberto Delgado                        DA-0752-13-3883-I-1
Alejos Elizondo                        DA-0752-13-3904-I-1
Alfonso G. Flores                      DA-0752-13-2753-I-1
Alfonso G. Garcia                      DA-0752-13-3469-I-1
Alfredo De La Garza                    DA-0752-13-2468-I-1
Amador Y. Duran                        DA-0752-13-2857-I-1
Andres Garcia                          DA-0752-13-2973-I-1
Andres Garcia                          DA-0752-13-1485-I-1
Andrew Garza                           DA-0752-13-3619-I-1
Antonio Garcia                         DA-0752-13-3444-I-1
Armando Felix                          DA-0752-13-2609-I-1
Arnulfo Flores                         DA-0752-13-3925-I-1
Arthur Gomez                           DA-0752-13-1807-I-1
Belen A. Epps                          DA-0752-13-3863-I-1
Belinda Gamez                          DA-0752-13-3939-I-1
Braulio Dominguez                      DA-0752-13-3931-I-1
Bryan A. Gomez                         DA-0752-13-2732-I-1
Cain D. Gracia                         DA-0752-13-3570-I-1
Carlos G. Garza                        DA-0752-13-2788-I-1
Carlos A. Diaz                         DA-0752-13-2937-I-1
Christina M. Gonzalez                  DA-0752-13-1071-I-1
                                              16

Christopher A. Flores   DA-0752-13-3424-I-1
Christopher G. Guzman   DA-0752-13-2653-I-1
Christopher R. Green    DA-0752-13-3609-I-1
Clemente Gonzalez       DA-0752-13-3595-I-1
Consuelo Gonzalez       DA-0752-13-1995-I-1
Corando Gallegos        DA-0752-13-2799-I-1
Corey L. Gunter         DA-0752-13-4033-I-1
Curtis Davis            DA-0752-13-2834-I-1
Cynthia M. Garza        DA-0752-13-3810-I-1
Daniel G. Flores        DA-0752-13-3792-I-1
Daniel Garcia           DA-0752-13-3873-I-1
Daniel L. Garibay       DA-0752-13-2891-I-1
Dario Encinia           DA-0752-13-2469-I-1
Darrell E. Easter       DA-0752-13-3944-I-1
David A. Garcia         DA-0752-13-3662-I-1
David A. Garza          DA-0752-13-3815-I-1
David F. Garcia         DA-0752-13-3134-I-1
David M. Fiorenzi       DA-0752-13-3680-I-1
David R. Flores         DA-0752-13-1070-I-1
Dee A. Espurvoa         DA-0752-13-3993-I-1
Diana P. Garcia         DA-0752-13-4040-I-1
Diane H. Fjeldahl       DA-0752-13-3818-I-1
Domingo Gonzalez        DA-0752-13-1072-I-1
Douglas Franklin        DA-0752-13-4004-I-1
Edward R. Escareno      DA-0752-13-2600-I-1
Efrain Garza            DA-0752-13-3881-I-1
Elias J. Escobedo       DA-0752-13-3824-I-1
Elma Garcia-Trevino     DA-0752-13-2877-I-1
Emilio Guerra           DA-0752-13-2831-I-1
                                            17

Enrique A. Figueroa   DA-0752-13-2927-I-1
Enrique G. Garcia     DA-0752-13-3552-I-1
Enrique L. Espinosa   DA-0752-13-3688-I-1
Eric A. Diaz          DA-0752-13-3870-I-1
Ernest A. Garcia      DA-0752-13-3249-I-1
Ernesto R. Flores     DA-0752-13-3625-I-1
Fernando G. Flores    DA-0752-13-2410-I-1
Francisco Gaona       DA-0752-13-3807-I-1
Gabriel Garcia        DA-0752-13-2571-I-1
Gabriel Gomez         DA-0752-13-2439-I-1
Genero Garcia         DA-0752-13-3935-I-1
Gilberto Escamilla    DA-0752-13-3910-I-1
Graciela R. Gomez     DA-0752-13-2512-I-1
Guadalupe Davila      DA-0752-13-3835-I-1
Gustavo Gonzalez      DA-0752-13-3440-I-1
Harry E. Falcon       DA-0752-13-3464-I-1
Hector Garcia         DA-0752-13-3936-I-1
Hector N. Deleon      DA-0752-13-1216-I-1
Isaac DePriest        DA-0752-13-1068-I-1
Israel O. Flores      DA-0752-13-2577-I-1
Issac R. Garza        DA-0752-13-3234-I-1
Jaime B. Garcia       DA-0752-13-2405-I-1
James J. Flores       DA-0752-13-3611-I-1
James M. Evans        DA-0752-13-3121-I-1
Jason F. Edwards      DA-0752-13-3880-I-1
Jennifer L. Flores    DA-0752-13-2578-I-1
Jerardo Gamino        DA-0752-13-3396-I-1
Jesse R. Guerra       DA-0752-13-1497-I-1
Jesus Garcia          DA-0752-13-2716-I-1
                                           18

Jesus Garcia         DA-0752-13-2453-I-1
Jesus Gutierrez      DA-0752-13-3575-I-1
Jimmie C. Dennis     DA-0752-13-3527-I-1
Joe G. Garcia        DA-0752-13-2923-I-1
Joel Espuruda        DA-0752-13-2757-I-1
Joel Garza           DA-0752-13-2303-I-1
John C. Flores       DA-0752-13-3227-I-1
John J. Flores       DA-0752-13-3615-I-1
John M. Esqueda      DA-0752-13-2726-I-1
John M. Garza        DA-0752-13-3865-I-1
Jorge A. Fernandez   DA-0752-13-2802-I-1
Jose A. Gonzales     DA-0752-13-3974-I-1
Jose Dominguez       DA-0752-13-2839-I-1
Jose G. Gonzalez     DA-0752-13-3669-I-1
Jose Garza           DA-0752-13-3637-I-1
Jose J. Franco       DA-0752-13-4289-I-1
Joseph L. Danley     DA-0752-13-3597-I-1
Joshua C. Gonzales   DA-0752-13-3564-I-1
Joshua R. Everett    DA-0752-13-2828-I-1
Juan E. Garcia       DA-0752-13-2548-I-1
Juan Gonzalez        DA-0752-13-1804-I-1
Juan L. Gonzalez     DA-0752-13-2683-I-1
Justin Davis         DA-0752-13-4604-I-1
Karl R. Gibson       DA-0752-13-2781-I-1
Kent W. Goodwin      DA-0752-13-1487-I-1
Kevin J. Easley      DA-0752-13-3900-I-1
Louis R. Guillen     DA-0752-13-3851-I-1
Luis P. Garcia       DA-0752-13-3228-I-1
Mack Eden            DA-0752-13-3463-I-1
                                             19

Manuel Garcia          DA-0752-13-3682-I-1
Manuel Gonzalez        DA-0752-13-1231-I-1
Marciano J. Gonzalez   DA-0752-13-3604-I-1
Margil M. Guerra       DA-0752-13-2646-I-1
Maria A. Garcia        DA-0752-13-2888-I-1
Mario A. Estrada       DA-0752-13-2630-I-1
Martin M. Gutierrez    DA-0752-13-2561-I-1
Martin R. Garcia       DA-0752-13-2865-I-1
Matthew R. Garza       DA-0752-13-3820-I-1
Melina C. Garza        DA-0752-13-3888-I-1
Michael Garza          DA-0752-13-3684-I-1
Michael L. Gallegos    DA-0752-13-3994-I-1
Michal E. Funk         DA-0752-13-3813-I-1
Micheal Esparza        DA-0752-13-2902-I-1
Nicole L. Garcia       DA-0752-13-2900-I-1
Norman S. Dozier       DA-0752-13-1069-I-1
Olivia M. Dominguez    DA-0752-13-3673-I-1
Ophelia F. Garza       DA-0752-13-3598-I-1
Orlando Delacruz       DA-0752-13-3460-I-1
Oscar G. Garza         DA-0752-13-3806-I-1
Oscar Garcia           DA-0752-13-4017-I-1
Oscar Gutierrez        DA-0752-13-2553-I-1
Pedro Gonzales         DA-0752-13-1921-I-1
Raul Garcia            DA-0752-13-1230-I-1
Raul Garza             DA-0752-13-1483-I-1
Raul S. Garcia         DA-0752-13-2318-I-1
Ray E. Elizondo        DA-0752-13-4529-I-1
Reinaldo Granado       DA-0752-13-2898-I-1
Reynaldo DeLeon        DA-0752-13-1462-I-1
                                             20

Reynaldo G. Guerrero   DA-0752-13-4009-I-1
Ricardo Galindo        DA-0752-13-1924-I-1
Ricardo M. Gonzalez    DA-0752-13-3606-I-1
Richard A. Gabehart    DA-0752-13-4043-I-1
Richard A. Gale        DA-0752-13-2867-I-1
Richard L. Guenter     DA-0752-13-2652-I-1
Richard M. Garcia      DA-0752-13-1854-I-1
Richard P. Gonzalez    DA-0752-13-3920-I-1
Robert A. Gonzalez     DA-0752-13-3658-I-1
Robert Garcia          DA-0752-13-3558-I-1
Robert Gomez           DA-0752-13-3834-I-1
Roberto Flores         DA-0752-13-2459-I-1
Roderick T. Dunham     DA-0752-13-2657-I-1
Roel M. Escobar        DA-0752-13-2589-I-1
Rogelio Gallegos       DA-0752-13-3666-I-1
Roger B. Duenes        DA-0752-13-2277-I-1
Roger Gallegos         DA-0752-13-3986-I-1
Rojelio R. Garcia      DA-0752-13-3627-I-1
Rolland L. Forward     DA-0752-13-2426-I-1
Rosendo C. Gonzales    DA-0752-13-2679-I-1
Ruben D. Gonzalez      DA-0752-13-3687-I-1
Ruben Garcia           DA-0752-13-2301-I-1
Rudy Garcia            DA-0752-13-2835-I-1
Rudy Garza             DA-0752-13-2677-I-1
Samuel Escareno        DA-0752-13-3566-I-1
Samuel Garrett         DA-0752-13-2837-I-1
Sandra T. Garza        DA-0752-13-2938-I-1
Santiago Gonzales      DA-0752-13-3126-I-1
Sergio Franco          DA-0752-13-2735-I-1
                                          21

Simon Guerrero      DA-0752-13-2275-I-1
Sonia M. Esqueda    DA-0752-13-2576-I-1
Stephanie A. Funk   DA-0752-13-2905-I-1
Stephen R. Duncan   DA-0752-13-2575-I-1
Steven Garcia       DA-0752-13-3250-I-1
Steven S. Garcia    DA-0752-13-2869-I-1
Susan E. Faught     DA-0752-13-2703-I-1
Thomas Franco       DA-0752-13-3847-I-1
Tina A. Gonzalez    DA-0752-13-2886-I-1
Tomas Gonzalez      DA-0752-13-3430-I-1
Veronica Gonzalez   DA-0752-13-3869-I-1
Victor Garcia       DA-0752-13-3812-I-1
Victor O. Garcia    DA-0752-13-2850-I-1
Wilfrido Galvan     DA-0752-13-1996-I-1
William H. Guinn    DA-0752-13-2494-I-1
                                                               22

                             APPENDIX C

                            CCAD ARX6-3
                          DA-0752-14-0379-I-1

Aaron Hoss                               DA-0752-13-3478-I-1
Abram Lopez                              DA-0752-13-3655-I-1
Adrian J. Martinez                       DA-0752-13-1078-I-1
Alejandro Lopez                          DA-0752-13-3143-I-1
Allen Heider                             DA-0752-13-2840-I-1
Ann G. Harris                            DA-0752-13-3466-I-1
Antonio G. Lopez                         DA-0752-13-2276-I-1
Armando E. Lopez                         DA-0752-13-2681-I-1
Armando Leal                             DA-0752-13-1484-I-1
Astrid S. Hopkins                        DA-0752-13-3940-I-1
Barbara Luna                             DA-0752-13-2471-I-1
Bruce D. Hardy                           DA-0752-13-2958-I-1
Bryan A. Martinez                        DA-0752-13-2666-I-1
Bryan J. Hedrick                         DA-0752-13-2722-I-1
Cameron M. McKenzie                      DA-0752-13-4052-I-1
Carlos Hernandez                         DA-0752-13-3445-I-1
Carlos Lopez                             DA-0752-13-3948-I-1
Carlos P. Luna                           DA-0752-13-2591-I-1
Carmen M. Loving                         DA-0752-13-4029-I-1
Charles S. Hoke                          DA-0752-13-3582-I-1
Christina G. Lara                        DA-0752-13-2871-I-1
Christopher R. Martinez                  DA-0752-13-3129-I-1
Clifford D. Hostutler                    DA-0752-13-2912-I-1
Clifton W. James                         DA-0752-13-3885-I-1
Curtis L. Langridge                      DA-0752-13-3992-I-1
                                              23

Cynthia G. Lewis        DA-0752-13-3683-I-1
Cynthia K. Holmes       DA-0752-13-3814-I-1
Daniel P. Martinez      DA-0752-13-3997-I-1
Daniel T. Jimenez       DA-0752-13-2440-I-1
Daniel V. Hernandez     DA-0752-13-2444-I-1
Danny J. Hughes         DA-0752-13-2550-I-1
Darren V. Lister        DA-0752-13-3861-I-1
David E. Lechner        DA-0752-13-2319-I-1
David J. Landa          DA-0752-13-3576-I-1
David M. Hurley         DA-0752-13-1428-I-1
David V. Hernandez      DA-0752-13-3565-I-1
Delma R. Lopez          DA-0752-13-3875-I-1
Diana C. Maldonado      DA-0752-13-3990-I-1
Edward Herrera          DA-0752-13-3995-I-1
Eliseo G. Martinez      DA-0752-13-2433-I-1
Emilio F. Jimenez       DA-0752-13-2414-I-1
Eric F. Hill            DA-0752-13-3443-I-1
Eric M. Jolly           DA-0752-13-3934-I-1
Eric M. Killian         DA-0752-13-2316-I-1
Eric V. Martinez        DA-0752-13-3786-I-1
Ervey J. Martinez       DA-0752-13-2412-I-1
Evan A. Huck            DA-0752-13-3568-I-1
Ezekiel L. Lara         DA-0752-13-3962-I-1
Francisco Herrera       DA-0752-13-3542-I-1
Francisco J. Hinojosa   DA-0752-13-2918-I-1
Frank L. Horton         DA-0752-13-4044-I-1
Frank L. Johnson        DA-0752-13-3866-I-1
Gabriel J. Luna         DA-0752-13-2671-I-1
Genaro Lopez            DA-0752-13-2861-I-1
                                            24

George Leal           DA-0752-13-3693-I-1
Gerald W. Hance       DA-0752-13-2648-I-1
Geronimo Martinez     DA-0752-13-2647-I-1
Gilberto Hinojosa     DA-0752-13-3522-I-1
Guadalupe Leal        DA-0752-13-3959-I-1
Hector E. Herrera     DA-0752-13-3664-I-1
Hector Hernandez      DA-0752-13-2607-I-1
Herman D. Harvey      DA-0752-13-3559-I-1
Hilario Lugo          DA-0752-13-3839-I-1
Hilario Martinez      DA-0752-13-1705-I-1
Ismael Martinez       DA-0752-13-3142-I-1
Jacob A. Leos         DA-0752-13-3892-I-1
Jacob O. Hart         DA-0752-13-4294-I-1
Jaime Jimenez         DA-0752-13-3226-I-1
James A. Lott         DA-0752-13-3895-I-1
James E. Hesskew      DA-0752-13-2818-I-1
James J. Kinney       DA-0752-13-1077-I-1
Javier N. Huerta      DA-0752-13-2661-I-1
Jeremiah A. Johnson   DA-0752-14-0195-I-1
Jim J. Hinkey         DA-0752-13-3587-I-1
Joe F. Lopez          DA-0752-13-3956-I-1
Joe G. Martinez       DA-0752-13-2490-I-1
Joe L. Lopez          DA-0752-13-2423-I-1
John A. Lewis         DA-0752-13-3856-I-1
John P. Karg          DA-0752-13-3592-I-1
John P. Luke          DA-0752-13-2484-I-1
John T. Lopez         DA-0752-13-3671-I-1
Johnny Martinez       DA-0752-13-2790-I-1
Jose A. Hawkins       DA-0752-13-4022-I-1
                                            25

Jose A. Jimenez       DA-0752-13-1797-I-1
Jose A. Martinez      DA-0752-13-3653-I-1
Jose F. Jimenez       DA-0752-13-2563-I-1
Josefina Huape        DA-0752-13-2910-I-1
Joseph L. Herrera     DA-0752-13-2675-I-1
Joseph R. Kaper       DA-0752-13-3864-I-1
Joshua A. Leos        DA-0752-13-3639-I-1
Joshua C. Lopez       DA-0752-13-2830-I-1
Juan A. Martinez      DA-0752-13-3816-I-1
Juan J. Martinez      DA-0752-13-2692-I-1
Juan R. Lara          DA-0752-13-3548-I-1
Juanita C. Martinez   DA-0752-13-3116-I-1
Julian Lopez          DA-0752-13-1756-I-1
Julio M. Lopez        DA-0752-13-3942-I-1
Justin H. Hanson      DA-0752-13-1492-I-1
Kara L. Howell        DA-0752-13-2501-I-1
Karl W. Littlejohn    DA-0752-13-4003-I-1
Kevin E. Kell         DA-0752-13-4041-I-1
Kevin J. Lacour       DA-0752-13-4008-I-1
Lemar S. Martin       DA-0752-13-3903-I-1
Leonard Lopez         DA-0752-13-2940-I-1
Linda F. Jackson      DA-0752-13-4049-I-1
Lionel Hernandez      DA-0752-13-1073-I-1
Lisa A. Matthews      DA-0752-13-3135-I-1
Lloyd C. Loree        DA-0752-13-2933-I-1
Lloyd M. Holloway     DA-0752-13-3453-I-1
Manuel D. Johnson     DA-0752-13-2506-I-1
Marcus W. Johnson     DA-0752-13-3450-I-1
Maria G. Leal         DA-0752-13-3622-I-1
                                              26

Mark A. Heyder          DA-0752-13-1074-I-1
Martin G. Luis          DA-0752-13-3652-I-1
Martin Martinez         DA-0752-13-3979-I-1
Merced Lopez            DA-0752-13-3843-I-1
Michael A. Hernandez    DA-0752-13-2680-I-1
Michael Kaufman         DA-0752-13-2779-I-1
Michael L. Johnson      DA-0752-13-4292-I-1
Michael W. Jewell       DA-0752-13-1076-I-1
Michael W. Kyle         DA-0752-13-3804-I-1
Milton C. Ivy           DA-0752-13-2442-I-1
Nicolas Martinez        DA-0752-13-3692-I-1
Noe H. Lozano           DA-0752-13-2320-I-1
Noe Jimenez             DA-0752-13-3907-I-1
Noelia P. LeLaurin      DA-0752-13-2882-I-1
Norma L. Martinez       DA-0752-13-3221-I-1
Nykkolette A. Hornsby   DA-0752-13-3794-I-1
Ovidio V. Martinez      DA-0752-13-2663-I-1
Pablo Lazo              DA-0752-13-2959-I-1
Patricia A. Martinez    DA-0752-13-3133-I-1
Patrick K. Lacy         DA-0752-13-2464-I-1
Patrick Lewis           DA-0752-13-1961-I-1
Patrick S. Hattersley   DA-0752-13-2929-I-1
Paulino Landa           DA-0752-13-2478-I-1
Pedro Infante           DA-0752-13-2730-I-1
Pedro Lopez             DA-0752-13-3785-I-1
Peli Leulu              DA-0752-13-2804-I-1
Peter Hernandez         DA-0752-13-4006-I-1
Phillip M. Letts        DA-0752-13-2614-I-1
Phillip Martin          DA-0752-13-1607-I-1
                                            27

Piranski Joseph       DA-0752-13-3921-I-1
Rafael Lopez          DA-0752-13-2878-I-1
Raoul A. Lerma        DA-0752-13-4034-I-1
Raul P. Lozano        DA-0752-13-2955-I-1
Ray A. Madrigal       DA-0752-13-3654-I-1
Ray Mares             DA-0752-13-1228-I-1
Rene J. Hernandez     DA-0752-13-2451-I-1
Reyes H. Martinez     DA-0752-13-2963-I-1
Reynold A. John       DA-0752-13-3857-I-1
Ricardo Lopez         DA-0752-13-3969-I-1
Richard Loya          DA-0752-13-1467-I-1
Richard A. Martinez   DA-0752-13-3789-I-1
Robert Lucio          DA-0752-13-1465-I-1
Robert E. Hopkins     DA-0752-13-2721-I-1
Robert G. Hannabass   DA-0752-13-3929-I-1
Robert G. Janosek     DA-0752-13-4021-I-1
Robert G. Lemos       DA-0752-13-2549-I-1
Robert Lazo           DA-0752-13-3240-I-1
Roel F. Luna          DA-0752-13-3838-I-1
Rogelio Lopez         DA-0752-13-4002-I-1
Roger H. Krayse       DA-0752-13-2507-I-1
Roger J. Huron        DA-0752-13-3912-I-1
Roland D. Marquez     DA-0752-13-2299-I-1
Ron G. Jaime          DA-0752-13-2416-I-1
Ronald A. Kenyon      DA-0752-13-2497-I-1
Sandra L. Jackson     DA-0752-13-4024-I-1
Santos F. Martinez    DA-0752-13-3691-I-1
Sergio J. Magana      DA-0752-13-2514-I-1
Steve Mason           DA-0752-13-4055-I-1
                                          28

Sylvia M. Leal      DA-0752-13-3937-I-1
Tammy G. Hilliard   DA-0752-13-2731-I-1
Thomas Jaimes       DA-0752-13-2654-I-1
Tomas Lozano        DA-0752-13-3130-I-1
Tommy L. Herrera    DA-0752-13-3549-I-1
Tracy A. Hughes     DA-0752-13-3842-I-1
Valentin Lopez      DA-0752-13-3610-I-1
Veronica Martinez   DA-0752-13-2697-I-1
Wallace G. Ham      DA-0752-13-3811-I-1
Walter L. Kroft     DA-0752-13-2764-I-1
Willie L. Hill      DA-0752-13-2673-I-1
                                                               29

                             APPENDIX D

                            CCAD ARX6-4
                          DA-0752-14-0390-I-1

Alvin J. Mikus                           DA-0752-13-2925-I-1
Amanda Peralez                           DA-0752-13-1604-I-1
Arnaldo Pabon                            DA-0752-13-1080-I-1
Benjamin D. Miller                       DA-0752-13-2650-I-1
Brian Robbins                            DA-0752-13-1227-I-1
Caldean L. Pitcher                       DA-0752-13-3859-I-1
Carlos G. Pena                           DA-0752-13-3821-I-1
Carlos Montez                            DA-0752-13-3553-I-1
Carlos R. Medina                         DA-0752-13-2559-I-1
Carlos Rossel                            DA-0752-13-3431-I-1
Carrie P. Riley                          DA-0752-13-2868-I-1
Catherine M. Moulzolf                    DA-0752-13-2816-I-1
Cesar Munoz                              DA-0752-13-1220-I-1
Charles E. Robinson                      DA-0752-13-2651-I-1
Che A. Presas                            DA-0752-13-2482-I-1
Christobal S. Rodriguez                  DA-0752-13-2308-I-1
Christopher L. Rittgers                  DA-0752-13-3641-I-1
Crystal A. Rosales                       DA-0752-13-3125-I-1
Damasio Perez                            DA-0752-13-3518-I-1
Daniel A. Pompa                          DA-0752-13-2540-I-1
Daniel Rodriguez                         DA-0752-13-2743-I-1
Dara Rosenzweig                          DA-0752-13-3118-I-1
Dario J. Reyes                           DA-0752-13-2931-I-1
Darren R. Rew                            DA-0752-13-2415-I-1
David Pena                               DA-0752-13-2029-I-1
                                           30

David K. Pletcher    DA-0752-13-3879-I-1
David O. Rodriguez   DA-0752-13-4045-I-1
David Ruiz           DA-0752-13-3675-I-1
Denise Mechell       DA-0752-13-3574-I-1
Dennis K. Norcross   DA-0752-13-2806-I-1
Dina Reyna           DA-0752-13-2585-I-1
Domingo Mendoza      DA-0752-13-4005-I-1
Domingo Naranjo      DA-0752-13-3436-I-1
Edward M. Morales    DA-0752-13-3988-I-1
Edward M. Powell     DA-0752-13-3898-I-1
Edward M. Rokusek    DA-0752-13-3924-I-1
Edward R. Morgan     DA-0752-13-4023-I-1
Edward Recio         DA-0752-13-3965-I-1
Efrain Ozuna         DA-0752-13-2950-I-1
Elva I. Rodriguez    DA-0752-13-2736-I-1
Emilio Reyes         DA-0752-13-3596-I-1
Eric J. Rodriguez    DA-0752-13-2770-I-1
Eric Murphy          DA-0752-13-1213-I-1
Erma L. Nelson       DA-0752-13-2634-I-1
Ernest C. Ramos      DA-0752-13-3247-I-1
Ernest J. Reyes      DA-0752-13-3896-I-1
Eugenio Reyna        DA-0752-13-2546-I-1
Evangelina Prado     DA-0752-13-2473-I-1
Flenoy R. Phillips   DA-0752-13-2660-I-1
Fred E. Paul         DA-0752-13-2428-I-1
Gabriel Ramirez      DA-0752-13-2914-I-1
Gary W. Musgrove     DA-0752-13-3983-I-1
Gene P. Ng           DA-0752-13-3825-I-1
George Robles        DA-0752-13-2435-I-1
                                              31

Gerald D. Reyes         DA-0752-13-3871-I-1
Gilbert Reyna           DA-0752-13-3941-I-1
Gilberto R. Rosalez     DA-0752-13-4026-I-1
Gloria M. Olivarez      DA-0752-13-2815-I-1
Gregory G. Overton      DA-0752-13-2670-I-1
Guadalupe Quintanilla   DA-0752-13-2686-I-1
Hadrian D. Morales      DA-0752-13-3854-I-1
Helio Perez             DA-0752-13-2810-I-1
Hermenegildo Perez      DA-0752-13-1609-I-1
Horace S. Montgomery    DA-0752-13-3777-I-1
Humberto J. Ortiz       DA-0752-13-3419-I-1
Humberto Miranda        DA-0752-13-4020-I-1
James A. Ortega         DA-0752-13-2297-I-1
James E. Payno          DA-0752-13-3546-I-1
James R. Middour        DA-0752-13-3605-I-1
James R. Patterson      DA-0752-13-3613-I-1
Jason A. Rodriguez      DA-0752-13-3251-I-1
Javier A. Rosario       DA-0752-13-2479-I-1
Jeffrey K. Reid         DA-0752-13-2863-I-1
Jeffrey L. Nelson       DA-0752-13-2817-I-1
Jeffrey L. Roten        DA-0752-13-3853-I-1
Jeffrey S. Plake        DA-0752-13-3241-I-1
Jesus Rodriguez         DA-0752-13-3621-I-1
Joe E. Nesmith          DA-0752-13-2443-I-1
Joe J. Montoya          DA-0752-13-2774-I-1
John M. Rojas           DA-0752-13-2688-I-1
Jonathan T. Rogers      DA-0752-13-3224-I-1
Jose A. Moreno          DA-0752-13-3600-I-1
Jose A. Ramon           DA-0752-13-4600-I-1
                                              32

Jose L. Puente          DA-0752-13-3218-I-1
Jose L. Rivers          DA-0752-13-3928-I-1
Jose M. Ortega          DA-0752-13-3623-I-1
Jose Pardo              DA-0752-13-2784-I-1
Jose Rodriguez          DA-0752-13-2406-I-1
Joseph A. Ramos         DA-0752-13-2510-I-1
Juan C. Orozco          DA-0752-13-1915-I-1
Julian Palos            DA-0752-13-3831-I-1
Kay L. Rittgers         DA-0752-13-2420-I-1
Kimberly Quiroga        DA-0752-13-3850-I-1
Larry K. Mitchell       DA-0752-13-4011-I-1
Larry Ochoa             DA-0752-13-3560-I-1
Lawrence M. Norotsky    DA-0752-13-1437-I-1
Lee A. Ramon            DA-0752-13-4013-I-1
Leroy E. Oelrich        DA-0752-13-3670-I-1
Liza M. Reid            DA-0752-13-3867-I-1
Mandy Muniz             DA-0752-13-2800-I-1
Manuel M. Rodriguez     DA-0752-13-2741-I-1
Manuel Perez            DA-0752-13-2466-I-1
Manuel Perez            DA-0752-13-2655-I-1
Manuel Rincones         DA-0752-13-2953-I-1
Marcus W. Muniz         DA-0752-13-3585-I-1
Mario Moreno            DA-0752-13-2946-I-1
Marisela Moya           DA-0752-13-4290-I-1
Matthew L. O'Donnell    DA-0752-13-3827-I-1
Melquiades Miranda      DA-0752-13-2542-I-1
Michael A. Ramirez      DA-0752-13-3583-I-1
Michael H. Richardson   DA-0752-13-3591-I-1
Michael L. Rust         DA-0752-13-2495-I-1
                                               33

Michael Q. Mueller       DA-0752-13-3846-I-1
Michael W. Nsoh          DA-0752-13-3578-I-1
Michael W. Orrick        DA-0752-13-2825-I-1
Miguel Mendoza           DA-0752-13-2842-I-1
Mitchum Nagir            DA-0752-13-1233-I-1
Monica M. Medina-Garza   DA-0752-13-3952-I-1
Monica Mondragon         DA-0752-13-3899-I-1
Morris T. Mister         DA-0752-13-2705-I-1
Nari A. Muhammad         DA-0752-13-2880-I-1
Noe I. Ramos             DA-0752-13-3876-I-1
Nora S. Najera           DA-0752-13-3123-I-1
Oscar Rodriguez          DA-0752-13-3636-I-1
Pamela A. Robinson       DA-0752-13-2759-I-1
Paul M. Ramon            DA-0752-13-3569-I-1
Paul Rowland             DA-0752-13-3638-I-1
Peter L. Peralez         DA-0752-13-1603-I-1
Ralph Perez              DA-0752-13-2875-I-1
Ramiro Meave             DA-0752-13-2289-I-1
Ramon L. Rodriguez       DA-0752-13-3132-I-1
Raul A. Ramirez          DA-0752-13-2951-I-1
Ray J. Rivera            DA-0752-13-3878-I-1
Reymundo J. Ornelaz      DA-0752-13-2775-I-1
Reynaldo Ortiz           DA-0752-13-3981-I-1
Reynaldo Rodriguez       DA-0752-13-2771-I-1
Ricardo A. Perez         DA-0752-13-4307-I-1
Ricardo Renteria         DA-0752-13-1916-I-1
Ricardo Rocha            DA-0752-13-4030-I-1
Ricardo Rossel           DA-0752-13-2960-I-1
Richard D. Ochoa         DA-0752-13-3960-I-1
                                             34

Richard Ruiz           DA-0752-13-2920-I-1
Robert A. Orta         DA-0752-13-3663-I-1
Robert D. Ramirez      DA-0752-13-3906-I-1
Robert D. Rivera       DA-0752-13-3677-I-1
Robert E. Moore        DA-0752-13-4001-I-1
Robert M. Pena         DA-0752-13-3833-I-1
Robert N. Mendoza      DA-0752-13-2419-I-1
Robert N. Perusquia    DA-0752-13-2583-I-1
Robert Olivarez        DA-0752-13-3973-I-1
Robert R. Rodriguez    DA-0752-13-3665-I-1
Roberto R. Pierce      DA-0752-13-3237-I-1
Rodolfo Ramirez        DA-0752-13-2823-I-1
Roel Ruiz              DA-0752-13-3414-I-1
Roger L. Mora          DA-0752-13-3584-I-1
Romaldo S. Rodriguez   DA-0752-13-2767-I-1
Roman Pereida          DA-0752-13-3122-I-1
Rosario L. Rodriguez   DA-0752-13-1221-I-1
Rose Marie V. Rust     DA-0752-13-3612-I-1
Ruben A. Rivera        DA-0752-13-3144-I-1
Ruben Molina           DA-0752-13-1611-I-1
Ruben Olmeda           DA-0752-13-2593-I-1
Rudy Ramirez           DA-0752-13-3136-I-1
Rudy Riojas            DA-0752-13-2408-I-1
Russell X. Rosales     DA-0752-13-3832-I-1
Santiago A. Ramos      DA-0752-13-2948-I-1
Sarah A. Robertson     DA-0752-13-3672-I-1
Sarah L. Ortega        DA-0752-13-3476-I-1
Sean A. Ritchie        DA-0752-13-2618-I-1
Sergio G. Perales      DA-0752-13-3889-I-1
                                             35

Shane A. Moore         DA-0752-13-2632-I-1
Shane D. Montgomery    DA-0752-13-3795-I-1
Shaun E. Mehegan       DA-0752-13-3412-I-1
Stephen L. Perez       DA-0752-13-3975-I-1
Sylvestre B. Reyes     DA-0752-13-2417-I-1
Teesha M. Reynolds     DA-0752-13-3238-I-1
Terence P. Odeay       DA-0752-13-3801-I-1
Theresa M. Perez       DA-0752-13-3127-I-1
Vance L. Rousseau      DA-0752-13-3657-I-1
Victor M. Moreno       DA-0752-13-3467-I-1
Victor Olvera          DA-0752-13-4007-I-1
Waylan F. Miller       DA-0752-13-3775-I-1
William J. Pipkins     DA-0752-13-3451-I-1
William L. Rodriguez   DA-0752-13-1224-I-1
William P. Murray      DA-0752-13-2587-I-1
Xavier Rivera          DA-0752-13-2287-I-1
                                                             36

                            APPENDIX E

                            CCAD ARX6-5
                        DA-0752-14-0391-I-1

Aaron D. Tibbets                       DA-0752-13-3222-I-1
Abel Valdez                            DA-0752-13-3632-I-1
Abelardo O. Salinas                    DA-0752-13-3963-I-1
Ademar J. Silguero                     DA-0752-13-2595-I-1
Adolph Joseph Skrobarczyk              DA-0752-13-4598-I-1
Alfonso E. Santos                      DA-0752-13-2684-I-1
Alfred E. Williams                     DA-0752-13-3782-I-1
Alonzo M. Valdez                       DA-0752-13-3254-I-1
Antonio Valadez                        DA-0752-13-2896-I-1
Arnold Zapata                          DA-0752-13-1086-I-1
Baldemar T. Munguia                    DA-0752-13-3667-I-1
Benito Salinas                         DA-0752-13-4000-I-1
Betty M. Vaden                         DA-0752-13-2916-I-1
Betty T. Sumera                        DA-0752-13-3432-I-1
Bradley D. Spaans                      DA-0752-13-3989-I-1
Brent W. Newton                        DA-0752-13-3608-I-1
Brian K. Sharp                         DA-0752-13-3128-I-1
Brian R. Trube                         DA-0752-13-3633-I-1
Bryan M. Smith                         DA-0752-13-2855-I-1
Carlos B. Benavides                    DA-0752-13-2762-I-1
Carlos G. Tey                          DA-0752-13-3830-I-1
Caroll R. Wallace                      DA-0752-13-3603-I-1
Charles R. Ward                        DA-0752-13-2645-I-1
Chasity L. Smith                       DA-0752-13-3836-I-1
Christopher J. Soto                    DA-0752-13-2678-I-1
                                               37

Christopher P. Zuyus     DA-0752-13-3902-I-1
Christopher T. Salters   DA-0752-13-2481-I-1
Christopher Yanez        DA-0752-13-3255-I-1
Clinton T. Werner        DA-0752-13-2772-I-1
Cruz A. Zamudio          DA-0752-13-2588-I-1
Daniel F. Tamez          DA-0752-13-2581-I-1
Daniel M. Washa          DA-0752-13-4293-I-1
Daniel O. Zona           DA-0752-13-2313-I-1
Daniel Seanez            DA-0752-13-2956-I-1
Daniel Wilburn           DA-0752-13-3248-I-1
David M. Stephenson      DA-0752-13-2832-I-1
David R. Stewart         DA-0752-13-4025-I-1
Derrick D. Sullivan      DA-0752-13-2626-I-1
Domingo Valdez           DA-0752-13-4042-I-1
Donivan F. Babcock       DA-0752-13-4668-I-1
Donney D. Zumwalt        DA-0752-13-2556-I-1
Edmundo Valdez           DA-0752-13-2733-I-1
Edward Salomon           DA-0752-13-3817-I-1
Elizabeth S. Weeks       DA-0752-13-3874-I-1
Elizabeth Sanchez        DA-0752-13-2539-I-1
Felecia L. Taylor        DA-0752-13-3580-I-1
Fidel Vela               DA-0752-13-4016-I-1
Francisco Saldivar       DA-0752-13-3980-I-1
Francisco Sanchez        DA-0752-13-2623-I-1
Franklin Smith           DA-0752-13-1613-I-1
Fred D. Warren           DA-0752-13-2305-I-1
Gabriel P. Valverde      DA-0752-13-3659-I-1
Gilbert A. Suarez        DA-0752-13-3901-I-1
Gilbert I. Salinas       DA-0752-13-3808-I-1
                                                  38

Gilbert S. Torres           DA-0752-13-2504-I-1
Gregory Tharas              DA-0752-13-1717-I-1
Guadalupe G. Silguero       DA-0752-13-2917-I-1
Herbert R. Saenz            DA-0752-13-3897-I-1
Hilda L. Santos             DA-0752-13-2462-I-1
Ismael Vera                 DA-0752-13-2544-I-1
Israel R. Salazar           DA-0752-13-3421-I-1
Jack E. Scott               DA-0752-13-3778-I-1
Jacob Solis                 DA-0752-13-3985-I-1
Jacob Torres                DA-0752-13-3590-I-1
Jacobbryan Z. Sauceda       DA-0752-13-4015-I-1
James C. Stillwell          DA-0752-13-2838-I-1
James L. Vaughn             DA-0752-13-4010-I-1
James R. Trevino            DA-0752-13-2580-I-1
Jamie Villanueva            DA-0752-13-4047-I-1
Jason A. Webb               DA-0752-13-2724-I-1
Jason B. Sullivan           DA-0752-13-2752-I-1
Jay-Roland M. Yanez         DA-0752-13-3416-I-1
Jesus A. Salazar            DA-0752-13-3852-I-1
Jesus M. Torres Concepion   DA-0752-13-3805-I-1
Jesus R. Sanchez            DA-0752-13-3137-I-1
Joel H. Torres              DA-0752-13-3434-I-1
Joel Tienda                 DA-0752-13-3776-I-1
John A. Veloz               DA-0752-13-2422-I-1
John H. Tullos              DA-0752-13-2413-I-1
John J. Vasquez             DA-0752-13-3477-I-1
John M. Sondrol             DA-0752-13-3599-I-1
John M. Valderas            DA-0752-13-3862-I-1
John R. Scherer             DA-0752-13-3556-I-1
                                              39

John R. Trevino         DA-0752-13-2280-I-1
John S. Shutts          DA-0752-13-3679-I-1
Jose A. Uballe          DA-0752-13-3844-I-1
Jose L. Untalan         DA-0752-13-3913-I-1
Jose T. Salas           DA-0752-13-3800-I-1
Jose Yzaguirre          DA-0752-13-2750-I-1
Joshua K. Smith         DA-0752-13-3246-I-1
Juan A. Sanchez         DA-0752-13-3791-I-1
Juan R. Vega            DA-0752-13-3617-I-1
Juanita E. Villarreal   DA-0752-13-2418-I-1
Karl E. Trybe           DA-0752-13-3674-I-1
Katrina Tomao           DA-0752-13-3686-I-1
Kendrick J. West        DA-0752-13-2954-I-1
Kenneth A. Weeks        DA-0752-13-2639-I-1
Kennith L. Starkey      DA-0752-13-2656-I-1
Lazoro P. Zaragoza      DA-0752-13-2841-I-1
Leith M. Weeden         DA-0752-13-3799-I-1
Leslie O. Witherspoon   DA-0752-13-3588-I-1
Lucio A. Valdez         DA-0752-13-3849-I-1
Luis A. Santos          DA-0752-13-3923-I-1
Luis L. Zarate          DA-0752-13-3244-I-1
Lynda L. Sanchez        DA-0752-13-3690-I-1
Marcos G. Sanchez       DA-0752-13-3848-I-1
Maria M. Zamora         DA-0752-13-3977-I-1
Melissa A. Sanchez      DA-0752-13-3999-I-1
Michael A. Trautman     DA-0752-13-4014-I-1
Michael J. Wagoner      DA-0752-13-3984-I-1
Michael L. Weikman      DA-0752-13-3911-I-1
Michael R Vasquez       DA-0752-13-3781-I-1
                                                    40

Michael R. Suarez             DA-0752-13-3243-I-1
Miguel A. Santiago-Carrillo   DA-0752-13-2421-I-1
Mike Sturgeon                 DA-0752-13-2942-I-1
Milton A. West                DA-0752-13-2541-I-1
Natalie M. Salinas            DA-0752-13-2812-I-1
Nathan J. Wright              DA-0752-13-4050-I-1
Ned E. Smith                  DA-0752-13-3678-I-1
Nestor A. Villarreal          DA-0752-13-2903-I-1
Noemi Vargas                  DA-0752-13-2407-I-1
Omarr D. Walker               DA-0752-13-3909-I-1
Oscar I. Vera                 DA-0752-13-3408-I-1
Oscar Sanchez                 DA-0752-13-1919-I-1
Pablo Villafranco             DA-0752-13-3860-I-1
Pedro Trevino                 DA-0752-13-2972-I-1
Pete Saldivar                 DA-0752-13-4599-I-1
Philip Salazar                DA-0752-13-2658-I-1
Phyllis I. Summerfield        DA-0752-13-2941-I-1
Randolph Wilson               DA-0752-13-3223-I-1
Raul Toledo                   DA-0752-13-2957-I-1
Raul Vera                     DA-0752-13-1214-I-1
Raymond R. Tovar              DA-0752-13-2728-I-1
Rebecca L. Simnacher          DA-0752-13-3829-I-1
Rene Verastiqui               DA-0752-13-3607-I-1
Reuben R. Trevino             DA-0752-13-3545-I-1
Reymundo Vela                 DA-0752-13-1501-I-1
Ricardo M. Verastiqui         DA-0752-13-3915-I-1
Richard A. Taylor             DA-0752-13-2605-I-1
Richard G. Salcido            DA-0752-13-3236-I-1
Richard H. Smith              DA-0752-13-1082-I-1
                                            41

Richard M. Sandoval   DA-0752-13-2744-I-1
Richard Sanchez       DA-0752-13-4037-I-1
Ricky Sanders         DA-0752-13-2836-I-1
Robert J. Taylor      DA-0752-13-3645-I-1
Robert R. Salinas     DA-0752-13-2737-I-1
Roberto L. Tamez      DA-0752-13-3976-I-1
Rodolfo Solis         DA-0752-13-3140-I-1
Rodolfo Valdez        DA-0752-13-3647-I-1
Roland A. Vera        DA-0752-13-2516-I-1
Rolando Viera         DA-0752-13-3797-I-1
Rory B. Thomas        DA-0752-13-2492-I-1
Roxanne J. Vela       DA-0752-13-2808-I-1
Ruben A. Vegacosme    DA-0752-13-3423-I-1
Ruben S. Yanez        DA-0752-13-2590-I-1
Ruperto Trevino       DA-0752-13-1215-I-1
Samantha J. Ximenez   DA-0752-13-3967-I-1
Scott A. Sanford      DA-0752-13-3828-I-1
Scott F. Simmitt      DA-0752-13-1429-I-1
Sean A. Weeks         DA-0752-13-3475-I-1
Sharon F. Zambrano    DA-0752-13-3220-I-1
Susan G. Middour      DA-0752-13-2809-I-1
Teresa A. Vann        DA-0752-13-3660-I-1
Timothy C. Teel       DA-0752-13-1234-I-1
Tracy M. Vann         DA-0752-13-2603-I-1
Troy Saucedo          DA-0752-13-2641-I-1
Vicente Villarreal    DA-0752-13-1728-I-1
Victor M. Zamora      DA-0752-13-2662-I-1
Walter C. Williams    DA-0752-13-2966-I-1