Court Opinion

ID: 4071161
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 01:47:08.614144+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:33:11.368984
License: Public Domain

Na.c_-zqé-oro‘/zz»/'z~‘)z'i¢~-A, g§lm§p|"&§.
il\l THE CC)L//< T OF

EX' PA/`&'/`£ c.R/m/NAL 'APP£ALS

LAP/Toz, 5/’/17/0~
l)‘\LI_§‘/’//\/ /&xA.S _ ,\\
s”\ q `\
‘-// 1»\
le"' 83j `_2. \/j"'OL“L-\\)WLJXLQ

©©UW@
0€1’ 12 2015

LAm~Y>\\'>\v\v>\\o~\/>\

mEm 0 RH~ cum 0 F [_A'w A©@“A©©Si@,@q@xrk

Now COmES, L-AmzY 305 'mo/¢GAN, C`)¢IpP//¢;a~+")_ w/"f/) +/1/'.~:
memora/vdpm o-F` Lau.) i/v Suppor~+ o-F hi_s w/‘/"¢ of~` /-/¢al>e.as
forpu$ broug)nf'_ pUrSUa/v'f"-f~o \/e,r/vo/v'_!' 732an Coc/e. 010

Cr;'mf~a/ Proce,¢/m~e. ar~+a'clr:, l/v07,

SF_E/p//¢a~+l< z/~/+.¢¢/ Sfa+e_s c¢>~_<¢/'J-u¥-fo~ £,#1 mud /L/+/.

aNcl /qme.~c[me.}v'f$ Ar‘-/‘lc,{\e_ F_, .S£.;.-h'uom /O O‘F +/)+:. "'l'€.¥a$
Co~s+f+o+:o~ 05 'F`m/ure. u.se_ +he_ De-F`c/v.re. o-F’ Sel-F-'

Dc:-Fe.~ S@. (af lurc_ +o /'N ve._s +-/ Qa+e__ SL)bpoe./va a~cl /'/v+er~v.~'eu)
-H'\€. O~/y CJyCu_)i’+~ess For~ De,/"e/v.$€.y aA/L/ +ht. . .Sfa+e.§C_$`EVEN-
TH COL)Ic.j'» o F A/`~>P&ALS)' U/§/')e/¢l -Mv_ C.o/v\/fc,~/'lo~ o~ §;_QN_£_._

 

W+M,JO/W da+<’_. O/b;/u/Jo./\/ was Fch/edr£,c/, App//'c.a/\rf l
-F)'le_¢l \a Pa-l/“~Ho~ -F'or` Di’$cre.-h“o/var\y Rav/°e.o.) wz"-M .+/1/'_$'
£`.our‘{' cJ/\J ‘ ' U' q”/ "?-0/‘/ mud +Ac_ dour+ rc.Fus€. +h£ Pe.*/'/'+'~
ioON.r l

 

M¢MOFG.NDUM O~F La#.) for Lar‘ry morga»~ .'Page_, §

if lLLeeAL'/T'_Y ~oF Re.=s'r,zA/~T
APPI{Cm\l+ `i'$ bei'/vg lsi/ejally I`t’..S+/`cu“~e,cj /"N /n"s //'/oe,r~+y /°;v
‘H'\c Tc,xc¢s. LS€,par~’+Me,A/+ o-F Cr/"m)’/val jus+l'ae. Q+ jam/135 A,
Ly~augh uN,”+ a+` 109'8`.<;¢1/\,\/%7~037 ce//-L>-»/-/g-B For+
S+Qc,l<+o~ Te,xa.s, 7€735‘. william Sfe,ve.~.s'o/\/ Di`r‘ec.-fc>r~ o-F
76an De/>ar~+m‘e~+ o-F 4CI‘/"rr)/`/\/a¢/ '_'\'¢‘.)5+:¢;€, by \/lvr‘-iu'~e. O-F a
Aud@mem+ aNc{ SeN'/eA/c:£ Lau.Se. number /l‘~/‘?B‘i’$'b .S-/'y/Bc/

I}'H:_ 5‘/'01+¢_ QF 711an \/S.LARRY 505 Mo/aGA/v .5“¢11¢/ _juclgme~+
"Ee,¢ause_ oF errors o-F' /w`.s 601_1~5¢/. `

il jj_lo iS$L/&»_S. I€AIS’£{>'/N APPL/CAT/o)\/
A/Dp`l:'c_¢a~+"`£c)/v+e~c{$'-/'//1'1:. f¢`o//ow/'Ng;’ (.‘l) ha 1.¢Jaj dcpr~/'ve,c]
o-F ~Hwe_ effe.c.+fve. as$is+a~¢;,e. o~F Cou~s_e,/: (R)Supprc_ssfa~
01C Evfcle~ce.f(§) Cou~.$el'_§ fa/ILCJGG€. +o 1'1\11/1:3-)'~1'5¢1-}-€_§@¢/)`
i\!`c>.<.ul\/ )'Di_sc.ov€./~e;d e.V/'_`¢Ie~c;€ 5 C§) 'Tow~$e~¢:/ \/5. Sa/~ \/11)-
iC-H'ION,( ,)S+FIC.[(/Qud l/. WaS/¢in/j-qu VlO/ozho','olv mur./ CC)Dre.c.l'\+ \/,v

Rl>_raham_§c)~ V1‘~'ola,_+1o~§(é>)he_ 15 adaa/ly 1“1\11\'10€.¢;~+,_

iv IN€FFECTWE_ A&S/s`m~r;e oF _COU~SEL

ll\l,a~y pos+ Co~Vc'¢+l'o/Q 6a//a¥~`cr~al a++a¢:.l< +he_ bmw/em of
'Pr“oo{_"i'$ 01\1 '+h~é. HPpl:'c,a~'/' ¥/~o czllr=,’g\"d mud prov'e.-.`{ac.'+'§,

Wh¢'c.l;z ;‘F +fu€. `Lul"l/ E,/v-fla#/£ juder fo Fe§l/"€.'F`¢ _§`c,¢ //ufF/}vg-fa1v
V.. Nu`+/) /L/o F,S`D 577_. 590 C‘h% C//< /‘i??),° A/sa S¢e.' Paz§c/e~"\/,‘

maud'e,r\ 4/2.¢1 F. .5`¢/ 303 (c;a:z zoo.$'),-' jc€_ U/`v/fr,z¢/ .§_-'/~a-fes l/,
711/lar 113 1534 1/3£»,,//1-10 (/OM am /w)~)) mt 54¢~¢/,1.»¢} of

I>rc>o-f`-:lsv [>y 61 Pr€;/sc>~cle,r‘mvcc_ 016 -/“h;' 6\/1¢/12)\1¢1:_~@ 5¢€.
/£>( Pm~+f, L>U+¢,AOV¢,~ 779 s.w.¢ 1¢1 7/,,,579' Cr€,x L,~,'M'.A/>p1
i"l$?°l)" Se'e_ also ‘Ex Paw~fe, Crz'spc~ 777 S,L/_), 9»¢]' /03 '
IO°| N» é. (1*¢:,)<., Cr/m A,D/J, /Ci?‘?)

mcmoran/dam O~F Laz.u ~F`or~ Lowr~\/ Wlofg¢wv 'P@g»j€, 'Z-

’fHE AP,o//Za/v~f was ‘c/epr/ve'L/` of ef¥'ec.ffv‘c.' assis-f-
QNc€,.-‘o.,-F +r‘/'a(. _»(,`ou~_$a,/-.. fl c/¢.:-Fa~c/a/v'f's rig/d~'f-+o
aov/used 1'5 guara~fe.e_d ,l>y bm% +h¢_ Fe,¢/e.ra/ a-(v¢/
.S-Fa'l'c_ Co/vS%/"-/“u-ffc>~.s’.- S`c:e. L},S.- CQ/v_s,-l‘, /¢Zm¢/vz/¢ Vl'/
XIVS `T€,)<' L'Q/v_<~/- ar-/* l,§ /O §/vd /‘i d `7`/)€_! M$.~ S'u/sr~em€..
/_!OLJR¢-l'j has rc;@ogw-/"Lr:,r] -1"/)1;1+ *-f'/)\; "/`)"gh%* +o counsel
55 ‘H');C. I`{`QB+ -F'o_ -H/»£, _€~F`*F’€c'.*/“/;v€_. aSS/'_<-fa/vc;¢__.o-F j
Lc)uNSE;/” U»»S. \/, 3'6151'~ 9~/8" F: SUpp')~c{ 552 6511/30
PA 1007\>¢ `IN 50 cla/mg +`~/m L/,S. S'u/>r~¢ame. four-f
654€4(311'$@.¢/ a fhwa Pr‘o~g ’fcis'/" +c$ de-/erm/°A/e_
li.AJ/')€,H')e»,r‘ _Cou~$€.l ;S., ;N.'€,FF.e.c.+a’\/.£_ 'a'+ +Ae. gu/'L+/
;NN`oc;-e~'c.e, phasc. .of +rai"/. F`/"r.s%,‘/~/»a H,op/fcam‘

l mu$+ 5/'\01,0 ina cle-F/‘_c'_/ae.'/v‘f" performa'r/c.e_ lO"F. 4£¢)u)v_<»"¢:z./

LL)l’\;c.Z'\ rcctul'r€.$ S/')ow/“Né "H/m~/~,- Co/\i_:$'l"c/e.r/'/vg all
1~H'me, cl'r~c;um$.+¢_umc`,'@_ amd Spé.¢fvcl°c ac_+$ />e.rfor~me.¢(,_
LQuN$€./ made errors 50 Se.riaou.s; -fhau‘ Cou/v.s’e/
was No+ FuNc-I~fo/v/’/v_q as -H¢a \`Lowv$€./ guara~?ae.¢/
by -H'\e_ Si“x+lé) Hme,~c/me~‘/;, S€€_ S-fm“c_lp//z;a~+ ‘
muS-% also pi»S/)ow ‘f'/_m‘f' +/'1¢ `c/€.f}"c_/c,~'f pér$br~ma/uc:e. '~
-.1_1,(1§" Cc)u/v$€,/( c/;¢/ ~07" usa /l,o/_)//c.a~-/_r 0~_/'\/
-De.{`e~se -fhe, (.De,fe/v$€, of 56/{`- De.-/’e~se, 600/\15€./
‘FalLurc. ‘fo 1~\/€.$-//901'€1.'; was erro~eou$ errors C)'-F`
ky,C"c)u,\/_$*€./'/;11"<°.31_\)¢/1"’¢.¢§,»6( ~H»»e_ defe/v.§e_ by r/e_Pr/“V/'Ng
fhc Fl/L>p/fc,c:z/\rfv o’-F 01 'Fhi`r`~' ’+r/°a/., 565 jo a+é¥`/.'

f

UN/eS$-"/”/)€, App//';a/v%' -Ma/:e$ lbo-ih .S/)ow/;v_g_<, 1+

 

’M€MO/`MNL[’QM o~F Law for harry marjan PQ@L’, 3

£.1¢1~)\1-0+ l>e_ 501°¢/ +/')a'f ~f/'»e. £o~vfz.~l`~fom rc_<;u/-fe,¢/

-F‘ro'm. ,iJ/\‘/e¥"¥»`é',c'_'+i'v¢ _as$/°S-/~a/vc;e_ o'F C`ou~.§“e`,/"¢, 535 Icl,

T'h¢ '5+1~1‘¢;1@~¢/' +¢S+f` apP/,';§. 1'~ ~r¢,m: "1>01»1, ro,'~'
'l'l'\¥_' 301”/+//1\1~0¢:€~¢€ }Shase`. cc~¢/ '-F`z>r` +Ae. pew/5h-
me,~+` M{>lmse‘.‘ o-F '-l»lae. +i‘fcl/QS'@£. Her)\/a/Q¢/ez_ V,$fa+-e,
922 S,uJ,")~¢l' 770`,`7 7'2.-73 C'/"ex' C`.r/M_APF`> /¢'1¢13'); i-/~er-a~-
del ‘\/, 51“01'+{,, '“711, S,w. 1¢/ £3',5'7~'{7”¢_»,1< crim npp /es»¢),
ESS£N+:'QH'¥" a ApPl/c;aN-f mus‘/‘ '$haw`(l_)+ha¥' h_/“'S'
LOL)NSQI'_§ repre;_$'r:~+a-l'fa~` 'l`e,ll below~'a~ c)l>jec,-H'v¢
\Sl+amclarcl o-F rcaso~a’b/£~e,s$ .'Bas'@d .¢3/<,7 phe_`\/MHNF
l\lorm“$§ MNJ.(D\) 'Hm'}', +he,rc_l 1,_<`~':1 r'.'t:r:<$o/val>/e, prc -
"‘l»’l’:>cai>ich"+y ~l'hmjl"j,l>u‘l‘ 'fbr~ /1/5 ,Cou/\/Se.~/f<_ _‘uA_//)r¢:»-F’¢:ssi]o~a/
€,,rro'r$_. -H')c, :._l"chl-f -01"_» -H~.¢;: ' Pro__¢e,e.cl,i¢/vg waul¢l_.h_ave.
bea/51 c/l"F-Fe,r~e,m+, _Slce" S~fr/'c.la/>i'l/'+y 1'$
clc:-Fz‘}ve.cl as probabflf'f\/ SL,»-F-F`/"¢~_/e;~+ ’+e> wiv¢.~{erm/'~¢
Co~-\('i°cle,/vc;e_ ['N fh€. Ou+c.om€., _§`c'.»€.` 5‘!{‘1¢¢.!:[¢2~;/, L'/éjé LJ.S',
a~~l" 15957,' H€.rA`{aNc/SL, `72.£ S,LLJ’.» lc/ a-{- v 5"$`,~ 573 h/l/l/v/'e/
V, S-fv\+c., 931 5",¢,1/_, 2d 310, 323'(7'€.1¢,£~»#1,/!,<>,31,1%2_),

T/l'~e. 'l>e/_vc./\marf`k' ‘Fbr~ jng/‘zvg a/v\/ ` c';/cu”mv o~F ../JNe-F`-F`ec.-l¥-»
fv¢i/ve.ss mu$+ ‘ -b'e_ 1_/¢)})\‘:,-»¢/1¢1~v , ¢ouNs'e.lfS '. co/vc/u_,r.+ .So.
uNcle,¢~mi"/v e»_c"l ~_+he_ {J ro`pe,»» y -Fu~'¢;+/éo)w a -F +-he,’ v adversarial
proc‘,€.$$ +Ao;.+ -H'u'_ ‘)‘“/`/‘4¢:1./v aa/v/\m_+ l>\e_ r‘r:.ln'~e.cl o~ ms

havlwg' praclpc,e.cl a jus-f vl‘¢:.Sl.¢)l»¢‘-, .SCE_ S'~/’/~/'ck/o.wc/i

 

M€Mo/‘Mvc/um of Ldu) ~f§r- L`¢xr'r\/ Morgmv w Pa.g'¢ “-`/

H'loé' 'U.S, al é'>i§é., Pl'éo~F O‘F 'f'/z..e.-' ly/\l¢,l`-l`r:c+l’vé.'»Cj"au/\/.sc,l$‘
'[YCC&U¢'FCS v m Sl;)§¢JQ/”/vg -'c)-F' hdrm ;-'-/-ha+' `~f-l)€_' lNeffac.-ll“v;¢
ASS/"S‘fa~c.e_ G~F CQuNS€.l Co)v+r‘/'éw-/e,cl -/'o fhcr£o/vV/c`,+)'o/v
Or` ch,vl'sl\me.)v'l'" or "élcprlv e.¢l` -fl\~c_ "appl/cv¢`l~'l*‘.$ O'FJ. h
‘Fu/v¢lame~-l»~al l`/’gh-l ./jl _APp/»'c_a~+ mus+ Sho¢.g Qm:‘ssr°o/vs
QF O'l'l\~e_r~ W\l$+al£€.$ w'hlc;lx ambu~+ ~l'o Pro-Fe;.S$/somald
Crvr‘or~s -l~l/\¢L+ halsey 'a re.asomm>ig'_ ' pr¢l>'mbfli"+}y " +lm+ __
+l‘¢~¢. 'l“r'lal woul¢l ld~e_ cl"l-F-F€.,r‘¢e,~‘l~` bu'l“ 1('0»~ -l‘l/\£._ 4 drrorj,"
See_ ID o\+ é§`??. F'ur?ll»e_r~m¢>r~e_{ `-l'he_ Ap`P//'La~-f` mug-f
'a{`-F"l"r"ma'+i'\/e,'l\/ prov€_ p'r~\;.;ucli”ae. 05 -I`~he,'rf__ i".s* Na`
'as$ump+lo~"o? {Ar~e_l\u¢llc.c_` `L/Nl¢.$$ No CQuNSe./ was
Pro\/f¢l e.¢;l~ a+ a.`(|, lluc+’-Fcic_+l°v'c. 'Cou)\/.s'e.l’ card b-e.' -(`ou)§cl
‘Fbr ma~\l rca`§o~$ ' bu-l for -'-Hw_ -/'a+al»'¢\/ ' 'o-F +A-c.~`
'C.i'r~c;uw\$"la':§¢cej$ '/-"s 'V/'c.w€.c{ "/'N ¢/¢%erm/N/Dvg -l-l\£ zues+fo~,
5\€.€. ega,'é_mv~o~ \/ 54¢2+€. [é$? S.,L/LJ,Z¢I '~/Ol CT€,)¢,
:.(`_r~zvv\ APP l‘?$?[) '

' A/:Pll’c:.o\’h'l" La/u'l”c/vc/S '-f/wwl" /n'$ +rl'm'/ (.`oum$e.l wa.f
l:Nc.'F~F`ec_~l_~la\/c_ lN 'l'lh€, 150/lounQO wa\/S$ (l) lay fall/ura-
+o aSSc’,r~+ a_ _Suclz‘:.i'all\/ racbgA//'z.c;¢/ cle'-F¢;»v!af"'.ad$`(§) '.Fm'/ur~.f__ fe ,/mv'c, "D/\/Hl
'l'“es+l°/vg§ (é) fmi/ura 40 dall _lQ/bp//'c,a~'l'"'s _c/zarac.+cr~
K€.fere.»vc.&s_ as re_ %u»e¢_,s -_l~c..dj <7_) fa`/'/¢Jrr:._ 40 juépoe.~a
- C`1'// C,all£.r' wine Sau_» +la~c. £Vc)v'f$ cas -l'l)e\/ warn

~l'al’/\,@ plac¢.¢_l.`a/v¢l arr~c>.Sl/'~`cj cuff/car ~Sa/¢n_ar._

 

/"W€}'VlO/"ar/~/c/ur.vl.V ‘ O-F Laa.,_u for ‘L¢Lr»'»\{ I'Vlorga.w v n ` ' P&,@e, S"

ll pp l15:11\1'l _ a+-la¢.lqes 45 f/»/'_s memorandum a prop¢_se¢l
(C)K,DE_IZ D£S_/Q>NA l//v(_»§ _lSSU_ES/) '+c_> aSS/S+ +Ae. Cour+ /1_\1

S(A-_l'l/\e.v~l)vgr 'l~l\g_ tyl¢l¢:)vc€_¢.

'1'5'_<.0~1`2..1'
.‘7H_£ 51:11\1\/15'1"11:)1\1 15 1_)1~155~57’17’11'1""1‘0~1¢\1. B'£c;AL/se
(`APP115A~T’)15115 1\107 125521\/1: 1115 _
EFFEcT/vé A$s/sTA~¢e oF Cou~s£-L ns 511.¢11<>111\17220

BY THE 51)<717/ A1\115 F5U1z7"5-;E/\11/-1 Ame~15m5~75
Gl-'- T…; 1115/1755 571177§5_[.551\1<7"17'1.)7`101\/ A1\115

- ART/c;£_£~ _'L, 555 /0 145/1519 _QF Tem_<; 50»~,<7'1TL1T1511

lN' +hfs' CQ$€_,cle;Fe.N'Sc; 6051\/$€5/: C.`omm1++5,cl Se.ve.r~al

UNpr‘c,{-`¢:sm'o/val afr-ors 511\1¢/ 5m1"551'o1\15~'wl»15l. 51mou1\1-/~e,d

'l’o Per~-F`orma~c_e.` a-l' 51 Ji'¢:v.¥:.l be.lou.» +lne_" 135512/5+1;15/1°_

dl:>_§r:,c.-l~lvc. S'l‘awclaral’ cf 11`13,1:4501\1 515le_~e55 far

0

iN `(_'1. _C.r‘»"w\t:moxl C.c¢$€.., Applfca~+ a$$`€,r'l~$ -/'laf_ ~Fo'/./Ow/'N_g

arro\~$ a~¢\' cwm'ssm~s as grou~¢ls -l`or" rclle.:l’i

'CouNS&l

A» -CouNSCl 1.1.)51,5 C.o)us+/'+u-l~fa/vally ~/'Nc-F`¢e€-Hv€_ -Fc>r" ‘_Fa/"lur€,
'l”C) 055€1¥‘+'61 Cl€§($iv.$cl.§

Dem@ /11"5 cx'P,€.r/'c:)vce.
""§'1\1,» assl$‘l'l)v€, lu;_S‘ 151/1'51~17"1 1‘~ a _)1,15/1'51’¢15/A />1.~<551':‘13,5/1"1\1_91/./\1.'v F&c.f,

_ ‘ o ‘ li , '
C.ou`NS€__/: lS` absolu+e.»ly ' Nec.¢£_<$ar'\/ , becau_s'c_, `u.)c-l~l\ou'l +he

gulcli~g, loa~al 0{.£01.11\1551 a. da¢`a~c/a~‘f' -may'
how +c'b n_@$-l'al>l)`sl\ l11`°5 1'1\11\1:)55~5€_."'

557 55`" (1'737_),

ma + KNauJ

POL\_)€.H' \/1 Alal>ama ,§.3

 

memora/~JOU'M O‘F L¢wu` F<>r Lar‘r'\{ W\OI`%¢~N -P¢‘~g€ 6

\`A `cl'C.'FzS/v$€. .i'Y\cu/. lot FC.LDg'/vl'ze,'"cl 'l'wo~ -wa\/S~:’ vE\/ +ht.
lle.@'l_sla.+wrc .~or~. l>\(y +115 55111~+5'¢” 555 Va.s¢$ucz \/, 5¢5+5,
950 551/1 121 61~5?,,¢1_5~_.1 '("’re.x 51~1m AP,$ 1¢1<11_),,

\ /,' ~ ' _ ,. v ,.

(`Appllc_am+> Wa.$ a \/1‘c_-l~1'n/1 iN +lw`$ 5_‘¢156., a/u¢l ~/-/- was
€mror$ 519 lu"s a++or~e_y)_$ who deprived +he_ F¢`z¢-fH?vc/e.r

O'F +l\f; €,vlcle,~c,e_ +5 51$5¢?,1~+ +h+:, cle_-pa~$c oF 'Scti/elk~sc./:

`Th~e_ 711an P¢~al 605/5 5-)"¢1_41.1401»1'/}`/ prov/'¢/e.$ For~ +h¢.
asscr‘h'olv of ' j'.us+fffca+/o/v 55 5 l clc-l`c~s{__ 45 C~r/m/~a.l
Y`C_SP<>NS.I'blllf-l-y 1 " l:c)u~¢l a~l~ 'Pe.~al Cac/c; § 913 ll e/v-//'-//cc/
S£.l{’ ~ cle_-F`e.~$c_ ldf 151‘0~1‘¢5 ;/v r‘c.lcva~+ /5¢:11~:/~»'- z
* "(G> 52<¢5/15+'; 1515 : provided l 1“~ _Su/>se¢;ffa~ ' (l>) _ a par-saw /'5
juS+/‘Fl,f.¢l 1"/v L)Sllv@ -For‘c£. aga/"rv$"-l alvo-ll¢er wham 611ch
40 "lfl/\‘c_' clc.gr`+;€_: ' `-l“l¢\e. nac.,‘l`or` re.é.§o~al>ly Be.leve_< -/'/\~c 4' ¥E)rc.`z: /'S
lW\M-E.clla+e.l\/ rv€.c_¢:s$'ar~\l +<'5 -` pr¢+e.c'l' +ll~z' 515+01~ 5351'1§15{-
"l’l/\f_. d+lnr;r~‘£ 1)5€_. dr _a+l'CmP-l-ccl USE. of U/vlaw»l`p`l fbrce»

(C_) Tl‘\~c. ac_.+o`)""_$‘ b`ell"€.p -H/\a~'l' :l~l¢»~r_ ~Forc_<`_. wa5 fmhach 1'5+¢1`\/
lvcc¢SSar\{ as cle.$_c;rz'bacl l5y ~l~l»\‘1'5l 5515555+1"01\1 /"S /'.dr`e_._

551)145,5{ 'fo 155 '/`e,c-So~cLl>lf,"/"F lqu, ac_-l~or~f

(1) l<~¢u_) air hmc.l} rosava +c>‘ vl:»~e.lf¢e\/n’. 4/»\5+ `-{~ls~c. `/.>er~__ v£i\../Olcl l`€a$.mvabl€_
l>e_lf€.-l"l LJ-S curve =H/\ccl'

lb'\[ ~ ,011\1 arc/fm amy
{A,Vcl Fy~Ud&iq+ v /SCVSC>N.”- may_§ \/, 5"/’&+'¢5;,. 318° 5.»€/\/,3£/ 36?, 3?$"'
CTC>< {.'I`llw\ /lpl> 101'€5)1

_ 'or \ `// .* - ,. 10 ' ,
11\1 +lus case_,(APPL.Ic;AA/T) was a \/15+11~\ of am
C'd"lc{"t;)v$€..' |DQFPE,-l~ra‘l'€,cl

agaf~s-f hfw\¢ T/,er~e_ uJe,r€.
wl+-N-es$- who

1_1.1‘€,1'€.- v/\10‘{' /"/vl/olve.¢l i'~ 414€_
51_5)/1<5 cbse,rve,cl. +l/x€. Cblvv\¢'l\m\l

d

ma++f,‘r~
i/v\lsc.ow¢:luc,+ -=ibla.a.'l' ,1'.1.1¢15
iq,p/>li"¢o¢~+, Thl»S Wf'-l*~e,s$
dall€,cl l'€> 'l“l`la.l. l:L)r~‘l'h~e,.r‘n/\or€_, -l'l/\,»"S

wkl5.l\ w e.r‘r:; rcaor~¢le,cl

-Cllr`&c_.+ccl al ; +la\~c was Na+

w 1'+/\1555 _S-/a+-e..m e/v-/'$

lay F'er~'l' LJQr‘-l~l'\ lbo/1515 clll a'l"
‘l`l'1~5 Vv\ow\€.~‘l" +L.r_` 61$5511_1_['/’ Lua..s 4~&{<1"1\13 `plac,e, a/ual

was- No+ e~~£cr~€_.¢l 1'/\1 e.vld5~c¢:_ 'l5\/

Cou/v$~e./ dar/mg

"l“l'\~c_ Pi`o'c;r:.a¢l¢"/vg l whi'c;l/\

r¢/v¢l€.r £. cl -l'l»a ~5`
\/r§.r‘ d 1'55‘{' 1

I,w\ P r~o 15 -e_r~

4011/\155;/ brou@l»L-l' ~~l'/»\e.

fix 13 lan/565 c§`-F "fl\ a
5111 caller -l~'o

/4/5/5 1195.01~7‘ a ++51\1+1’5 1\1

,Slz~r; 15551~€_ Fa\/oralsi»e_¢,Dur/‘N@

1515/nam

before_ '1"‘1"1'05/‘ $5\/1"1\15‘
lqpplldca~{ /)cq_r~cl /)£11~ v-
' 355/1513 .6`1]§'511“¢;111~1-{' was l55[1\1€j '.a;TT-c'.c.lce,¢l| 51/50"1_1_11>\5+'

l_ Luo.$` weam'~g amd _~u)-l/\a~+ ‘t"l\e_ Pe.r~/>‘e.+t~al’c`>rj

w~€§rt." w€;_a_r~_llvg l5_:e.1€15r1; 'Bl\e_' 5011'51 lefl' /)_r:'r~'l @e.'lj'
arou~zl '“')"l»eg dor~e.r~ 50 +hc.\/ ca~'l- 5"~¢5 haw

'.+112~ 1 1¢5'511 112 1>1~55@511~151~ 55511,5+1~3 ~+115~

" ~/”Vlémo’m~oum of 55111 F<"Qr' L“'“”‘/ m°"-B“'N '°"'5,'*" g'

F\RPHCA'N+‘S 'LOUN.SC'./ S-f‘rugg/C. -I~o. _§'-)‘op -Hhe. c//'sc,

Fr~ow\ P/*o$€.cU-for~‘-S La/A ‘fo/> , be-Pore. d-IF'AF_ %Wo approa-
" C;hecl -'F/\e_ [D€,/vc../\ , -/'/oa'/'_s u_///le,~ %}fc ~-Ca)umr*…‘/' I`€"

`P¢r+‘€,r~/ VV\r‘$ 5/)€¢~~0/\1 Sa/'c/ ,

Yo¢_s +0 C.Ou)v.$e./or~_$@

+Lu/°c._c / cam'*/~ hear

Hacl CouNS€,I'.S 6a1/cd a~c/ `)'~-froduc,e,c/ ijv%o

€.\/J'Jr?,/vcc.' -/'h-e, +£s+l'Mo~y, Q/vc{ `»H\~e.. /`C,c;c)r~c/J’ c)-F +/1€.

rcs’>audi'~§ aLJ+Aor~l'f'\/, Q~cf osser-fed -M£ /.Jc-/`e,~$e.

O'F SC‘>(‘F“ cle-Fc;'~_<.e., +L)e~ +//M" ~F`o.c;~I---Ff~¢l¢r~ C;oulcl /mv+;

Co~$:"¢le.r~e_d -H')/.§ iam f`Cch§./u'~g a \/e.r'c{¢”c.'f /'/v +L)/'S

Wm-He,r~ , 145 /-/~ was cou)u$t,/'s ..Fé:¢z'//_,r€,.$ de,/br~)'vc¢{
+h~€_' aP|:>h'L;.aN+ Q-F ezv-¢e,r/NS -Hw"s PIchs{'/:»|~e.. amd
pac,+u¢u_l(\{ ac¢ra+€. I'N'Fz>rma+fa)v +z) +h~c jury a/\:J

i`€,cBuzs-)"€.d a jur\j ivi\/S+r~uc;+f`o)*v ‘¢)/\/4l '/‘//.»e, S+a+u.-)“or~'f/m/
CN+;+/e,¢l _ciqu/v$a QF- Se,l+`"_`c/ef‘e~$'e;.. f+ cag;)'~o+ bc;!
64 -F`ecLSo)~/c\bie, a++or~)\/e,\/ who 10a/ls +0 a's$cr+
H»\~e,_ Fac.+_<; SL,»rr~ou/vcl/'}vg -HQL cl"r;um$+a~ae,s which
` brough+ l~»£"/`1~\.'_ c,,;¢vc.+l'“o)v' '+o Fm.,»)c-/“/om 145 51..%,)'\,4
(`;q/:»P[fc.a~+o> was cle_Pv»a'\/e,cl o-F` ca _:\u'r\/'_$ _ca~s/'a'e.ra-h'ow

O‘F am accéul'+--l~al of &I>Ph'ca~+ base,¢{ i_)/AOM +l»u's

i£@ ¢'S la-/'i\/£_ :i/va¢-fe,c{ -a'e Fe~se_ »
1<'_i_im,$ ¢'_cJNC/u¢_:/€. m'\/ ¢VV)¢.:n/)c)/‘¢a./vbu_n<§ 010 L¢'¢|u.`)__`) '
PRAY&K

/_)/)p//‘c.q~+ pray_s -Hw.+_s -qu,s 'c;@p)~|_f'_ /00._/<'5 u/Jm\, ml +A<..
;i\:+€mdc¢l- -Fa¢.+ ‘H»)cL-I~ fmi *Ae,e,~ /Dr~e.se,~-fe_.c/ hare/fm
his LA.)I~I"I'" /-/abcas 60/\/,>¢)5,

d/\Id grand/ir

#- /P¢/>z,_éz_ jbe/’~g, Pr.`e,seA/f/`y
l~c,arc;era+e..d'r~c:go/"mj
Fac.+$ arf_ 'f‘r‘z)_€__ amd (,`or»r€.¢:_+,.

20 55 `

[_A/a/aY A"oe mmc¢_=;;qu
DQB og~cn»/‘%éc)

10 QS’ S, /-IWY 2037 -/>-)-/s»ma
For+ $+oc.{:+a:v Tcwas `2¢7'73$"

L&/KT/F’/c;/ATE oF jé/cV/cé

'~7'/-//5 /s 70 'c&/aT/F-Y T//AT' 0~ OCTOB£/z 717//, 2_0/5~/ /4
T/ZL)E, A/vo _éo/cz_éc?` EQPY oF T/-/E A/So\/£ A/vb F`o)a£c§o//vc£»
DOCUW\&~T memomn~oum oF' LAW .4 wA$__/`->LA¢€ //\/-/4
60/1)€&;7/0~ '_o FF/¢é/c F/A~b 7`¢' MA/£_ 773 _/QO,_/;Q)( 1230?.?,
CA/>/Tm_ szT/o/»/,Aus~r/N,T,em_<, 7971/

 

 

'/‘MEMO£AND¢JM 0/~' Z.AW Fo/c (.mzz‘f mo£,(,A‘/v PAGE /O