Court Opinion

ID: 4072353
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 02:49:40.587004+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:32:25.263894
License: Public Domain

I T
71 CMW ap CRYN\IH‘F\>EM BPPE?H»LS gl?/LZ/L/@/

4D¢HIZZ!> bdmbE;l%u66666136666`”WmN

“ »‘”MlNAL APPEALS _

  

m Thls document contains some
pages that are of poor quality - DEC 10 2015

atthetlme of ima in .' \
'/`HE 140v\)OWBLE g g j
PK §§ ZD ZYU$ .JU D@E §§ THEBelAcosta, C|erk
D I'STRICY COuaZ‘/'
HESPONBEN/

PETZTITZM 66 wSRIT.'~" 66 666
6666

COWPQS n@w bow@c§ Wc\c-l@ |461¥)\@6»~»6 RQ;Q`,\§.Q\:-l am
§\6666666 \‘<66&66666‘66,6@ \Y\ (_l/L)G»\|<e;v* Comvxt;\/ 63761,£,6
\»M\WY:Y 164\,,\\”\‘6$\¢\446 WQ-§ §666“ C;;\m¢w~»’c T€vm§ 666
§\\6$ 6\\\$ `P€*§N\Q~P\ @6~6 Wv“\`*e, 63 VV 6666{6~\66~.,6€ 666

16 66\?§ 666 661 66\..\6\ 666§6{66, 6666\6€ $666> 666}€666\,
\;;, 66 £;:6 \6\6\ 63

, 6
@\6 666 666661§£ }§666 666
LL,}¢::,\;,. kah@»w:_:ye¢f W)EA §Ag ,£¢;#/gm - 061/'?§66§6 6£)

"'66666666 with 6 696 `!6/ 664 66 76666 P666i
66636/146§6/6§@ 6»~66! 56¢”66§;' £:`666 6.

flee
@6 666 6§6»\{ 663 ' };&,U }66 v66§66666,66
6\‘\\§6 666\66@ 1666 66@666@6 36 666 jm@{;®
\6§ 666‘€‘\66 §66\..\§6 6‘€ §6666\§ 7@<63` wm

§6\\,\5$6 \\\,6\~6\@6\\ 666\“3 666666\666\ `\v\ 6\»\6 Ju@l»c;§‘@l

D’:`$"ir,'v\f'€,jc C6\16\66. 666 61.66611@661616\6 61666666 6161"61,1.

§ 166 § ;z@ 666111 ' ' 1 ‘ 1
66 61 Rl;¢@le.s 6 317/aig §§e::w'£gl§"§@dww *C"Q@
_ /)P x V`U§» LJV`€" & ,7€,;61.,/ /nggp'gg§ R
3661 616 j.16661;”661w11;€ 666@;31666! }»1.6;66 666 666 66616!16 66
6666 1\616€66 66 616166&“166$66666666 666 6611‘\6@1 66
636@663666 666 366 §6~16@1 6661:16'16§66 611-1666 66`6,61, 6,61616€6
656 §§"6'1166\ 'PQM\@\§‘M§ 666 661\66@1; 66,,$6§66»66 WQ@S.WQ»>iov\€J Cour@

661

66666 666 @@'666;6166666§ 666 §§66§666¢61666661 666 666

6666666 666 616 611`6'6 6616,16# 66 161 6666~ 666 @6'6666§6@63

    

6666611663@666§66661 11 616 666111116666 6611‘1666 06
» 456 66…6 },,;_; r@h'@§` 66 666 <C.o…»g 66

)/9¢,9})661}5` by 6 ' 6166£15“£;:1¢"6§ 611 619 §"\».‘£`, 6616~66.66»’66! §§
666 61`\16”6\66 6661 6661`61`63§'6161666 6@16§@§@’@66 653 666£2§66;
666 §§6@§”@'6"6 66 6661§‘@\1666666§ 6.1§@6:6166§". 66 “6;666,
63 666 6 6 666 6 666 6@66 661.66661§6661 61§666 661 6 666
666 § 616 666 61 666 §6""'1666 665 66 636“1@ 66/6666€ 666666116*@16 6 “”'
66636" 61621 6666666§ 636‘66666 366 616-66 666§6;166 "..`11;6`“*@'.6 666616
166611 666 611"61666 66 66166 666 66661
66666 66666666 661161666 6661 6 661.661 666616:1§616 666
666 66616’6)»)66 m 666 6666;:166 66661; duck/661
C¢w¢$€. ~ _ - "

   
 

 

\/.

126©\1666 §§ 6616\'61€.69 66 661\‘@£ m seeks %6\~\
R@S ?QF¥§§@Y\§ L,,g,~¢\ei€v’ dk@, @\6¢6‘6`6) 679!66, §)3)6'6 mud
F@§WHQ@®\A@\\ W\M\QNK@€M.@WE.S 6a 1;\`,@, Can$'\:»'tui:wm
of eha L{m"¢ ed jftc»&s€:' `I;}»r~=e.{c,¢l@ lp 5`@¢:61’063 _ZQ)
;6,.6,666 962 616"" 666 /6@)»1:6/66¢6/¢6 06 666 966
666 761661;} m 165 }@66@’66!6 105 016 666 "7:@,2£¢:6,.§"

\

615 C)»~¢‘Ww’mz,/ Pr@*@€@/MM,

' `WHE'/?E’fw%z P/?§’M.Zf€r CM§ZDW§@,P@@@@~
civ f_”mjy;‘ v§;“A.€‘ CQMV& and Ufw€ Mm't a§
!WM»M.@?M-MMY gm §@£W@m@@l@m §§ @£¢’we;@&;m§ »Qm!
€E§*§WWW Q. M@!¢¢M %Mm é;~w _NWFWMG, §:§@¢’ re;?;.,&'@ 953
z&:@ w%§@§é 2 mary §§ @M.&¢I‘Méd »’)») é:/A/I

lp W~M@M% § §

 

‘R @5‘,0 § cl §.¢L/ //), sw §§ M\YWQEYN

@€@le /T‘\v)\ww\>_ _ - .
§@`»%€&@zww @\g §§@v» R@@»§ dew §§ @@\yd‘%§w

m mow__€);>ei€m 115/97

5 7/€? Té OF` 75%!%
CMWW §§ fm¢&

Be&r~e WJ€ de@»m‘§h€@! @LMC»MVLE>¢, @v\ tk\§.¥
day P@wswwM/y @,F§Q€@véd ,Pecdt>~¢\" iN»
15 P\@ Qécw€ anal par@@»’ng %t\"u¢s’@v\ €w /(.x)m"@~' @F W@,~v»
W§@@WM,§(, ®ma/ W/M Qf£:~€»s€ Bez'ng 'dw!’£; FW;@’VM"» Ft'@»tw§
'£::B»»@@ :Q~»EE =QM, @§B@§Qtim @:¢! %k..,@)c, agiwtmw@@t w
§’€L{@é W§§§\;@V\ Mv‘@ CTB""M€. Mk‘nm€ g,@lf"v@é,»i;;.

§W@VM €::;,@ §w‘)§/ 5";’§»1§@! Q§¢é?[@v»€ W?€’ mm t!k€:$

»E;¥~,@ &@\,\j §§ j

 

NO‘ \T.'.C\.v j PU. met

.. H~Gl>b _COuNTy C;F»M.S@E;' N@.
Q@@v-RT' §§ @R 1qung !WM@§ QM;§ m

"7?4§ §‘T¢W£? @`F °’;F’A§M% fm ‘YHE caummf
VS C§?;M IWH"L §me

®\@W‘zz§ WME; &m@@z%#€z§ M§;T 2114 757#-2:

M\@ LIQM ZM_ FM‘ LEWE w srsz
PE“T;‘?Z@W WRZT §§
WH§ M%%’M,s‘ ' _

7b S/QZD Ha/WK@BLE c.&ui&"r;

' C@\"<"\@S V\GW DQV{d wqd€ HM\DbO-vo;l, p@ ’C§‘C¥ZN\Q,W/
aw@%r@.\$k§ B.€Qv€;@€ Comv>~;. ‘£;¢) €€W %\~,Q` &§tmke&
p@§;l\id\n F@" UJ~F\"€. O'F Mawo!c\,w\u$,©u\é udale
51\®\..~..) wm C.c:v\..,¢~~»¢-»'va ‘€\~e, -@c)¥\vo'w`mg:

I.

y “T¥f\\`§`- §§ @VF\ @X§Y@\Q\F@§\\F\QW\! Q€Z»S“@ H“¥f\@v@ V“°~€B; gg,§`v~@mg
*§\»Q Q@\;\€“‘\;; Q§‘? Q\€“€WL\:\®& \A?X§@;Q\$ wis w€¢\z~@,€§€'m"% ‘°'
§L`€`\@\\ 5\@¢§\@§@§€€§§§@”% §@QQ>WM§@ § @»“‘§{E{ bw@,~r \¢\@Q,§ mg Qr _ a
M&’QQ,' P~Q~W*.@\o&z! §§ lmw.',§°`%;, vmv@wm W£m§$@@%*é&§
&@K% @°'WW § QDM@§ .» §§ WMM mM%QU
@§§@§M, §'W ®%”%U§U§m% w&&.;§,§ ~M w€%§ :§UG§%@%

 

P\QSF <acm¢\m\/ _ S`Mbm,’cv€d,

/Q~l::€-:wvwe, {»';»/\r P€?.,@<;@\‘¢.v\@.r»` Pet&t£o’he;v‘_
€:\':0 Fa»'€i §q@w?;,@% @\¢\Y\{y §§ .P€§>i\-.zm>wm@w §§ mt Pm 560

’ .CE`¥ZTIFZC)QTE OF SE€E.,\/IC§_

I/.~-P\Q\»e\o\/ 'Ekcuc, c:\»~\ 4:\»\€$ ":V-@ 7@'4@§&>¢ 64
B@€m.\~\\@@»v J;LQZS/ 61 l:YM/€ Omol~~“c:m~v~ec';b Ca'y>>/
Qq@ the abb¢>_v€ Gw\o€ WQD~“€.§O\’H O\, ~!FC.C».t?vv\ ‘F<J~"’..l§`@®/€
£';O, F\'\Q. pj€ d\"`c,€o\\ {*o\~ \/\)r~\`.’rq,_ mg z&c~..v\o§ mw\.&$ §\99\.5’ `
beam \::v@\~<\$v\”\€‘z;t@g% da ‘c'E\Q, Q‘€‘F@`;e 015 ‘%:¥\Q. 'Hw@€'
§@mv\*c»\; D€Stv'ict \Dr%::k:avn€,y§ H.¢O¢§ CQM“C\/ ~'BMS`L"”"CQ
;@W§@V? l§@@ wl p@m.,@, SJU~@@A®, Gmmhw~\/, 762@5.

 

p€’ §§ E;|`d‘¢\€x

@. £QCKNQWL £~:`I>C~» E`m amy
%TW§ @F “7"@}<€§@ §
wva y QF HQ@B `

B€,~Fg\»€m Y“‘W@ *Q¥w@ m‘wd@$$°;f~~@@§ &MQ%@W‘ §§ §§
iii'%€§ §§Q»y P€,v'§@w§:e,§&z¢ Q§BF€&M“ 53
Q§Q,§§§W }»M §w@ @M§@v@ Cw\o§ 6¥~€§0{ P§@%§tiom §w°
Wr'€w c>$ Mc\mdc»w\\..@s', cw\¢>£ w\\@ o\, twa be,§v\g
Q&.\My amsva Sb¢z\,§€.<i t'¥\@;:§, sam *;:\\Q Q\,\AQ§Q%§M§
§§ 'f@h@*@ QQWRMUM m g&a@§ \>e&i<m*om @»..,\»~Q
R;\@~\¢\E @~.,\z\@\ Cg\c~ vaca

§W@wv»\ @ @\,§@l, s§§m@@§ ‘Q@@@W@ w@.@~m
%:'%=@§5 %:M@ @M§ @ if

 

 

 

 

MUW “Y@M;@ “WW

webb C,o\.¢em“fi! QWMSE /U@,
c@\,+r&‘r m Q,sz)z)w% MD‘P§)@£:SC)M§ mm

'z"z+z£ 57/4_7'5 w '7“’§)¢)¢)§ m WE CMN~ §§
\/S _ UZ,“TLM“:£;NHL #PPEHL§

Dm/i_x> vuon HMBBHM> r~ms~rzm, Tz~:)rm

HPPLI<;HI;AN FQR LEHW;-.»~' fm F_m_.,§. />Ev~m,
j FM maj cf m\q-NMWS-
'T@ §Wl;d Hm\)o\z v=r¥zu:.. wmsz

C@W\€;,S ¥°\OW `DG\,V\$§ …Q~»G€€ ' Hbé{ji@b@w§£ p@°m'i:i@h@§
M,~M§ @Q§&s _B@Qw@, @~€- Co\.w~@. tv MQ. wm m:<m@m;,
§§t\‘§\`c)\m l'/¢.)-e~ WHE, G~F me@lo»wm.§; Q\ml W@w€d
S`)NQMQ 'E‘;’\r\£ Q@wcv§ _‘C:M "§QM@WM\§;

I.

` TY\€§ §§ @R\F*\ @§@WQ.©Y@§MN&M{ CGQ»S€. ’&E\@Q:». r@§jw,w@§
§;\F~\@, Q@\¢\-\€© @f Q\*i\é.=~f\`\vw@\ 533 \@€;@V\,S 9@@ @,R@¥”@f§€ @V'i§§w
w §§W€§@§€i@§i@w `§@€:@MS@ @)¢;€m¢“@¢ ms §§ W§@§MM
v@w\@@hé_ get l@w~), it 'i\n vawe§ mim'$t@v'{@~\ owes o\-\\W
,Gm\o& \d@wt\`é;\@\c ’§\GLS b@€/\¢\ M\\.S\.A:CC,@SS’QME im O\':>`@e\.\*v\~
§\{x% ‘€"@M@»§_ QW\ ‘HW @\\:DP@Q.@ de@@` _.

 

R@ QP@@‘@ 614 fy yubm.'mj

Q"'L:‘bc)v W€, ~ 1§)~€~ fp€i:€'k€£)m@¢, v 19@€%%£ OWQ,Q ~
U:O §')€" S€§h€e$ dwiy §§ ©€%s'x,,wm@¢ §§ w_w§,', Wv'“a §§