Court Opinion

ID: 4250555
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2018-02-28 21:49:16.071317+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T08:44:02.726862
License: Public Domain

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF IOWA

                                    No. 17-0558
                              Filed January 10, 2018

SABAHETA DZANIC,
    Plaintiff-Appellant,

vs.

DEERFIELD RETIREMENT COMMUNITY, INC., DEERFIELD, INC., and
LIFESPACE COMMUNITIES, INC.,
     Defendants-Appellees.
________________________________________________________________

      Appeal from the Iowa District Court for Polk County, Jeffrey D. Farrell,

Judge.

      A plaintiff appeals the district court’s dismissal of her breach-of-contract and

specific-performance claims. AFFIRMED.

      Bruce H. Stoltze, Jr. of Stoltze & Stoltze, P.L.C., Des Moines, for appellant.

      Jeffrey J. Cook of Patterson Law Firm, P.L.C., Des Moines, for appellees.

      Considered by Vogel, P.J., Tabor, J., and Goodhue, S.J.*

      *Senior judge assigned by order pursuant to Iowa Code section 602.9206 (2018).
                                            2

VOGEL, Presiding Judge.

       Sabaheta Dzanic and Deerfield Retirement Community, Inc., Deerfield, Inc.,

and Lifespace Communities, Inc. (Deerfield) entered into a comprehensive

settlement agreement in relation to Dzanic’s workers’ compensation claim and

subsequent termination.        Pursuant to the settlement agreement, Deerfield

provided Dzanic with her full personnel file in exchange for the release of any

claims she could make against Deerfield. Although her attorney reviewed the file

prior to Dzanic signing the settlement agreement, Dzanic claims one document,

entitled “Saba Behavior” was absent from the file. Dzanic sued Deerfield, alleging

breach of contract and requesting specific performance. After a bench trial, the

district court found no breach of contract and dismissed Dzanic’s claims.1 Dzanic

appeals.

       Dzanic claims Deerfield breached the settlement agreement because it did

not produce her full personnel file. Dzanic testified the alleged missing document

contained notes compiled by her supervisor describing Dzanic’s behavior at work,

notably when she arrived and whether she was happy following her work-related

injury. However, Dzanic admitted she had never read the document but only briefly

saw a reference to such notes on her supervisor’s computer. Dzanic did not call

her supervisor to testify about the alleged document, and Deerfield’s current

human resources director testified there is no record of a “Saba Behavior”

document in her personnel file, if it ever existed. The director further testified no

1
 Our scope of review in this action is for the correction of errors at law. Iowa R. App. P.
6.907.
                                             3

documents are purged from Deerfield’s personnel records and Dzanic’s entire

discoverable personnel file was photocopied and provided to her.

       The district court found there was no dispute a “full and complete” copy of

the personnel file had been given to Dzanic and Dzanic had the opportunity to

review the file before she signed the settlement agreement. On our review of the

record and the district court’s ruling and giving appropriate deference to the district

court’s credibility findings, we agree with the factual findings of the district court—

including that there was no breach of the settlement agreement—and determine

based on those findings the district court made no errors at law and its ruling is

supported by substantial evidence.2

       We affirm by memorandum opinion. Iowa Ct. R. 21.26(1)(b), (d).

       AFFIRMED.

2
  Because substantial evidence supports a finding that Deerfield did not breach the
settlement agreement with Dzanic because it provided Dzanic her full and complete
personnel file, we decline to address Dzanic’s other claim that the district court erred in
interpreting Iowa Code section 91B.1 (2015) by finding a document, whose very existence
was in question, was not required to be included in the personnel file for it to be full and
complete.