Court Opinion

ID: 4054281
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 05:03:55.087903+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:25.545759
License: Public Domain

. ~"t'-~7,~b~<n£L-/;k€_J11o:fir;_u__{b~(1v~-f_bQIL£kGf-0£~12Q3'---------
    _·
    -~ce___b_Q_:       - 0.~~~~~_1.       . .                      l::>eJ'-~LeJ (________
                                                                       .       . .
                                                                                        . -=-----

    -----------------4~==~==~========~~-~
                                 . J w::tc; e.   (1)1'2""-1: "-cJ. ~

•
           ._J;; 7h_e_fkA.M21UJ;)e :J_~~J)fi Jwd /izu!Lf;_~_ _ __

           .       _{![JMJ[~_!Jjf)W;_g&Y ~ !'}MdJJ1~-(_h_e__j)e_~/-ho·IJ'-='-eru_:_ __
               J_N--±be_~1/:0-S{y_i£d_~cLruuWtktwL~--±_o_·_·__· _ __
 •             _Jk:Lo_\t_~~'-kk._L~-Co_u_Vl.l__{o_Ls su_~_M_~d-~_u_s~f·-=-·b_4'-..!...;:k-=-e._-___
      .·       ~u.dt~ ·~~ C±b:e._j_2 4 7 " b'tdn<:.--\l_Coud_coLIJ.ruuils_d,:,_-:te,r!!BJ__,,--
 ..             ~<:> -w t-f, :l~:Si%.1_~ru;,e,kefS._{o_Q.~~due._J_o_~lf.MWj_                              .. _
               _(1 ~BI ie.-t~o_f_ "'+rog£,f'1_n,.w LM'h, sbow 1~ 'L_b{ e& +~ tw .
               _fluJI tJ ['LO ul ~J2~.rL+h,e.. g±~.de1_BN&~I-~.tfl-_'€._~o_b.~-:v.:e.JJ__,o"--'--'-'M-=-e_ _
                 -~-rs~~of<.~f~quh*/Mo~to~.~ ~-~-~~-llpph~"'~-~~ I~ ·.
               -~-_LQ..v_1_y_·u-~-~-~-w_c~{-',;±_·K\J~l\-~ettil..e...£.._e>_~--~vot'L.t.:t_\_~~~-----,--:_ _

               ~-b-~~--~e\\.l~~-~:u'l ~4LM_eiV~-l~V\1pt>-ss_i:bJ£_o-~-j~~L.Sufpoa.~--
               _c   ~-b_w_~-~fJt)w_!.                ·             ·           .    _   ·       '. · . .
                                                             ·...-~-

                                                         .             j
                                                             ==
                                             Tv rt'l s. d. l ·e._....V \ o-,-...~
                                                                     . -
               cy-b_L~-~ge_ i g t!LJJJt!.;Jtt.Jtj_pi~!J.:.fllfe._~ ~-~-----1-p~J2JJ-t!13-~-,/..t-f-----
 • _W.defi;_(!_~_t,fj_j_/. ~'71 ol wh,eJ.. /irb__t1ul'-/) lzl1-3_0t.t~_:__l;_;_;J_.__- -~
- ·Ju.~Lsdccltc)(!U_o~LMJ_~~~fe_j~e¢6 M~+-t-eA2-3 · - ·
               -zkL~an-1 AJJ:'Lfl!UJfM-cfurL/sdr~h~ fJJ tJ~~&_i/.Is__~~~CIL-                        . ..

                                                                                        PA-1.e..±
      '' .Q,R.cDuu~· 5'- /J_~fu~LL~neetJc:..e-M_~8_ctt~J~~-D_£_1 ·                                     _ _ _ __

        . :Sus.f\_e_~-'~Q           o ''11 cc L&+"'-\!' ... ~ ., "' \)""'_!. I$_~>_S_I'v\.....<fitL""cO,"'jc_________
                                        •

      ·. · · '"'he.-_c..,.,_t.~,~_,_+_b.\"!5,_~d.u.±-I-*0-~~~5lr~-:tefk~u.s±t;,_~                 ~--
         tl I   _L _fj     t Mo/~-~.L
    -r-R.JD-~~~'-\':l:Le_. .
                               1
                                             0 n      P _·.11t s d_v.~.· G 1 n-ef+L-<.
                                                                                ,J\ ...
                                                                                        1
                                ~ L~'T1_lS)_v-_"t11e__ . _,UZ;J_c.e.e.eu ~-~~ _-~~~,-r.j/5--=-=--.--'--'---"---
                                                            117"'"'·

    _[y:rrm'fi1'eiJ~£1,-e/1_vfl-£ efl.fLord iAP &l/&.w_l/Uf~11--husiuMJL ..fo /a-=--e--o---__
•   __@JDM~tMM h'-~aw~!~_/)btJJh2 his_aJu/l4_w_lu:/lef~ts~0_/_5f11~M __ _
    -~YL~w'f_..jJJ!ql~-IIJeJL.f..,_u.urleit.dotJ.:.• . . ·           _, _

    ----------~--------------e·~~~~
       -

 :ete_i_fJ1S,e
      Mls_toMkeJJ
,..    r
•t.S.J~

 ~h:;;:br
        \(_'-I helL-€..

_bTI2!>_.,~7A~
-~e           ;/JseJ/
  'eflSIJIL r~~
                                -
                          -1

u-~-h~e_~~~4-·
             .       .~    ·,

      (7Jtl)~- 3
    _b~ ~W~_eJ-=M ~ &~~~3,-~7~ -:fh ;~ Ua~~~ k.Cvd.
       -            -                            =\~Z           -   - - -            -.
            Re_~=F*
                -\- J_o_u_e-n...
                .   .   . I        ~
                                   I       E ±±lui_ ~-D-~_u_e.__Q
                                       __s.__
                                            -'     ->   .
                                               N-' J_ _ _
                                                            •   .
                                                                _      V     Q .
                                                                    /Lf9l!.~~-   J~
                                                                                 _        ~'

    -~of-~udfW\4f'A.l~-'-~R~~s, TN ·H.g_f~t;~--L~~ed,k,s
    _b~f-er ~~~e._\.&_h~_1 s· ·Mo~_BI~ -~d_s_bow~M!21JV'o-til+~~ _
    _ l~ {beftL~72UL·w-j~ bv/ slt.<9W o_f.: -Ji-.e_(L~1 -~J ~'U~~i2
    -11---~/L-~-.p_eJL~MIUJ~r-(l.D~.e~_l_ee::e;l!_ou_~_h-~_k<£b,(_d€hJ_t_U1_
    ~-~h~-f~J~~cBJ e.u-H'ft~w<P_'j'~l:~:f~/{~GnJ~B()_,. .
•   _!;ht_bl~ p~_e~Jup~.41M _J..efLekr-~YHMd_ l~ftei
                                                                                           .-
                                                                                                -. -

                                                                                                       -
                                                                       r2~-~_s_·:·--
·-                                          '

 __b_v~w~_Q_r_Wfi,4- cJ~MI'Hv&~us_f:e_dec~l5J_l0~+--____
                                                                   '

 _ _--:=:$'~~~""' K~rul_·c~h_e(__
                               <l~__
                                  -ru ~:._&trlic:;_~~-t)_Vl.J_;b.f!._
                                                                   .                        --'l
                                                                                               ·- _ _

     _· ~~-l1utJ..~j ./VJ£~~flru_ ~JLetlfiEEit.J<}~1"'c                (J¢t.l9-e   t9 j    Uf~,J.
_        . 3_o_u~_o_f_S_c~J~~o-b_e_t>_+ke .suba~~ eJ ~1'L                                  ;t"-'-'-'tAc___ _ _

    ·_·h_en~~~~ ~ ~-~ L~lt;\.-l_'J~~                 1~ [~ -4-o \fJYL01-ljPJ{Jw VI cf'tiJy.:J
     _~nv,J~ftdL~~L~·e            ofl ~~--/;~~~ r---_·_ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
     .                                P~QY-8£

                          . 1\1. _IA}_Q/&                /_ 01

     ~rfnyJ2~VJii1 _71le1.1f i$5lL0l/Cf;_de:ltHte jyei"'t_-l;tU6eMiiy-
     _uJJ_~~dL_ll.L_cflt~_J7J1Yle!> ·k{Ad/MI/Nt~ o_L-~:J-~!11;./JJ _
     _\M dtiJn_{k~~-dedJUJwN.abJ_ew---4-(j_//eq-o~_.:JXe ·
       ~    l       _;~u_e_ /J1tlcL~       ;! £       Z
                                                    .. -                                                  .
     --~fl_Mt-'-~-.          .. ___ 'tfLleo_,
                                                                                               -
                     r
                                                                                                              ·'

     --~-?-~&             'J/-7-1-
                 _____ M_,_   -  :>                 ~-- -7 -~a.-.         ~
                                                    bed~-f

•                                                                                     --

                                                                                               '
                                                                                                     -   --

                                                                                     (J~€-D
                                                '

             -
                                                             '
.   "'   ...   _.,.

    ._fJ-twL"-'-7 h~_fj_[!,_IJ,;hM~-da:¥7 !11/llic!MtJlf_A )e/l~h-l-. .- -
     _ _ _·.-all!!lv/uL' · .              .&c....:..:.....=vtJ=--.:--..---·------'--
     _g,f_M_eti_()~,~----------------

·------------------------

•
         ---------------------------~~e ~·