Court Opinion

ID: 4055134
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-29 06:40:23.291966+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:31:30.508943
License: Public Domain

4-e~   -ar.,q::;-,zq~~4)~M~~-
                                                                                               ·
                         C~t.n-n      ea'-'(.4;.+ Ho.         ~~·,.o<:f-12 97~
                         cxP~rle.t.?!;         w--:il,~nn An.da~ ~~~~-                                Ab®IAcosta,Cierk
   (!j~JLk:                                               .                                             ·--A,~Sl.P~Jr- 'lo   ::r W4-$ ~i~cl                    OeU416d ~!-I SE{/-knt~ J ~J.~+~J c..:fh2- $4-m~ ~4.0                                                   S?EpfYnbo,e.
   Jg. ~~ A·f" ll>:J-1 frt-rl)                 t7n         !0 c.J{i:\~t:8o /,(}4//~ f1a~~ 1);J
    f\}()J- 1-/fiU(_ Jh~ ~'-\tll~ Jl,·c-~tci--                o~ '1h ~.          I E::$":0.        ~t£,f-~:-/ci ~'-C.J-
  &1      'Sf:_ptUr. b6e. 1g . c!:XJ(j~ !h-d IJ,d t/6-1- t-IAVF cJL(;~s&,d/,~
  ~ s~p+~ hu 'f ~a'b ~                                  + t: m        'b    6'   cF' AJ<;u.<¥ f
        .As   :t:    htW'f... $'Ar7J (1\~ g1l'S~~t I £1~~ 7-U"E£.~                    r,tUFm     ~£ :;;l?,-$~e-/~
                                                                                  '
        ~~ /h1 !+tf~J/Vfl~o; (]4-/vin ~Vr-6 ~- ~/1 ·:;js- t!K>l~                          ~ .fil~ J ert:" Jhrh~                 0.0¥146, ~E t~t-Srf- J/.Vd           W€11- /fb(111Jf'
        rJE.WI~ ·-p;'s~uu~~                6o~cc,.              l,Uhei!.~ ~iAj~ a\.C7A'd         ~ 1.\p
        Lurh I/ S6pAtLA-{ ~ ·:x do Nof ..(1\()lOo J: AfSdi ~•\6W iThJ¥~ Jt.a~~
        Yf)c.CA'CS' Jlt5 ·fk~Sm~-l.k~ ;.J~ ·:to A-: m -n IJ, ~ &tv4f 0 2 &~.~ j
        ~@,P(l;~ls lis ~l~-k4}                               -fhE t:Sn)V(   '}A-k,,el45 /imt       "TS    ,6E,~
         Ct-e.RJ.f-EJ 1!>7 -~J?r- J11c.CA'fj·
                                           1/3 :J.f ~~ ld""~JJ,,,~trt))'.JJ!JiJ
         J-/AJ rle; cJLA~i6.9tc.·Lta~0~J,c,:,- (U;~f~,d r.. ~.t J.As I l?mt_ y ~ ny
        ~~$£../ Ch/orn ~.wfi~ lOfJS llfp·;{ .d3 dbJD. ::t:' J/Mt #6.1 ~
        fi/)o~ ?a_           Ck!OhJf        ·7D ~               /11~4 ~, /lp;jJ6tJ-/. l7<                IPuJ   ~frcL
,._, _. _.. )~ftrl   m'li-ke-sl As~/ QtJ{viVl                      Ji'tr.   Ar~. ;11oiJ~
                                                               ddL /II~ T~~~l
 ..     fntq ~JLcJ Jh s -~ 4d.e9~-<~'l~ 4ppe11/ />n.i~( W~"t1c"' f hltj ~6/tJ/~~
         4n4 {j;,-flaJ,t;f ~ &w~o "~t J.sfk~t. tS.{J Cc:IGIJ?~cA_f,-aYt                                   Q,c_
        App~( ~s ~or/ ~c /YUf S':gnA!uLf. d71 ~·/;;                                                 tuR7j ~
        o~~o~-R-'i1Cz'D -~~-o<=;-tcctG-~ 1J ;/-~n>                    JI<::J.J.. ~       4~tc.JeeJ'd      &y
        "6il1eft. ~er-v;:s-lz;cj ~.e-t~cy.s oJl7--c., Zf'e 4 T-Xs -k ;f I cfw~.
       ~4-f- t:<.h<;· f    t'o/J--5 /1?,1}r/1=-   rl   6-n   ·-:D~&~6~L ~e-           d-CI£/41   ern .   AfPR.;(
       c)'/ C)Ois ;:L            J7k        k.J~/( ~y,ac;-)297C'::. -CJ~l        &~ kJAIP~ cfl~ 91 s~~ P£e~i &;5d.P4tc"G.., btJ1Uf.Cl
           rjh_¢- /..o(JS :Sis/, ps £AI-+.sJ ltncl II/WE.(_ f/2$- e.rz-/zc/ 70 ~ ~ t!..evft.,J 6/l..
          7},1_ ~~'               kJr/n~s-::~s         -::f/Jq:/   WifA..~ dM6re.. ~t.. bftt~/1.q--J"" /YlaiiDil--;;{}t,J-
          ~ HDf ~92-Tl. h.Jl "':b '1"h                             7      CkuQ...{, .Gu;-cl~c""L ~/.J'l ~
           '~~~~·~t mtcl vt'i~t r                      -{6      IYli..(   o46L .1vtr? wri!J 1,~1.1 ~'~ fA~ f'J:);sJ~~.,~I
            /kf/t;,vtt (j 9      ~ ~ rn'1 dD~sd~                              7'A1n --:;h.,,u· & AJbl£ -16 fib~(-·
          (/J>·hua V ~~i q;q 6/vzJ 'fL.-,f do~s !'lo·f, -~ llk~ I"$ QJ~d CJ\~ Who~ f. (9~~4-' dutt~~rctd-­
           cvu       A   ~~b~ m~ beh~ YY\~ R~l1                              b'-J ~A+ (j>AIZ-~/E-$      f+pp(Jg>"   ZU~J-//6.L ~fct
          v~ J ric:.~- fl;:ys~ ~i,~&,d_4,6-r                           _ou6/Z   lh'f   /~s-1-h 'V-i :~-1~,(: t ~u e.+-~
           Its     ~U~6~t~4£~ &- Jh~ /D'&-~.Jc.t~ICII.} I v~&h_,e:l Clou~f [;VJl.-7\t- (
           u~'b--kJ          10    ~e-+k ~l,v{\~ ~~~
      ·   Vc~ ~A '1ix·AS ~~fo-1'tme.-~ ~J~                                                       ()4, ':J<5:~J- hc$A g
Q) :J;, l}t..s./rn ~UAJ"'                 Jn'1   'lh£       ./lis-1 rn6'1LJ.~ -~ Apllrl &ol tV~b£mhcR. ~
~;;:;:, ~ £--fk. Ck 4                         671   ·fh l   IJ.~t rr7ancl~ 'n\ .fZb Rc-1 kfl-t( hltd ~ ~c.L '&
($.> :1=n /).)~>r//etL. (k\.Vt'\-kr on /}1~ JAisf n1~t; ~ Joo\.\Aait ~ clune...~
v~s ,4-nl\ J.!X"'I'lS ~tJ6/hYWrA~ a,_J~ ~, e09                                                       Jvt£1~~~~~J->-
 Ef.\dl._     ~{.(.n.J 1 1 l.;.f~J ~ -Jh·fs ~'-tbc:J,f)(ptL                  /)Pr<:.  ~uiLis~.~~~t.d /mas                           ~~:~ci-~J ~.., 'VA~ I ~·s/4-k/t£ d~rfi;,£ tn-1~
 c-s~/,~4 J"'tu;J,~.ta~ c~·4A1 &s'l~;cJ 6utZ.h, ~ Cvlli!tf·v                                                              !JJ,1scl      /l}oaJ    ·-J}!.,..J. ·tJd JL\n~     lc d.o10   YYLlt AiJc;~'f               CA-Ium Gttf'6 /
 IWIIJJLme-. /61/~ lYle -:/JJ4f ~ J.Oa'-1/r/ .w,J1ldutD -~ /1Ll.f ~/JfW
 ::r./' :r Ll.}~c/~ !/~ IJ->hc/ -7·J"' I sAl/ tolf1?#cl ;. ./i1rl /15 #1~,1?//1~. .
 mi IJ