Court Opinion

ID: 4074692
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2016-09-30 05:19:06.334494+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T09:36:28.605020
License: Public Domain

.   j_]:f;)_:_a-L-~/l~t-ti81:--l   A: C~S_rA'--.-------,.~=-=-:R:::="-E::=-=CE=-:_:fV=-=E=-0~IN_ __
                                                                      COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
      ,______(!_[)_f.J8J: t:JLC-l~.U!l LIJ111--.LI+P-P-t:rJ±LS._ __:__ _· - , - - - - - - - - -
      -------~~~-· B or. I :h3-D-~-----'-------I~I-l!»-EJI~.::_-J-!;17~21f11Mf@~~~-'- -
      ~~~kPLro~6L&DDM.~----------------­
      --4iUS_:_f:/_IV_~_]::J._,_zj__Z(l~l'-------------,---'-------
                 l                              Aba! Acosfta, C~®lifu

      _/:)_E/!r-EJ_/J1B_Lf!_Cl)_Q_f-A-:----------------
                                    '
      ___ e__ '-C/J6i£_fd/YJJ           £UCJJJc5&J~EtJB        .f-1 L JIM_ CL_TI:)j£   t11!..L~ JAJ IJ.   !..::. ·
      _c_o_P-~t?-E-J)t~ l R-17-L!}_J:DJl~S-·t!J vr low ED-B-.·LE'&J~ .~E oF CtxJ_fl._)~-~
      -·l=O-EiL~-&:-WA.tt_[)_,E__Ln t±N !Jllffl {)_Q~·J_J_'_ _ _.. ---'.___/_ _ _ _ __
      ~-·_L___} t1UJ1.._/1.,_L:;s£()_/JLS_f£ r:/J.J_Ltliv L_llG I 1N {t_lf)_t£-IU#.I£/J}__"C-Jblf"-

•     __el;; ~-etr:_tfi±S_fl t::t:J£JU ~rJ . AiL D F JU:= o_7:J±rs_e E:l::LtJo_AJ_·kY_l_LJ.~-
      -/(~l7-#t_G-l£LY__I±EE!Lr::-c._(fi=C£0_,_Ltt8:Nfr_'X_fltL,'---------~-
                .                                                           .
                                                                                                   ~

                                                             5-l{JJ_C t= Ill= L-~-------­
                                                         1
      ------------'----------,-

                                                             ~e~~~
      _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ,l!L~-·__o~t}U_L                          ~,    AfLW.Lf:_ _ __
      -----,--------,---~-----'----P-fJ.O~S-E                              f<.E:LA-Itl &._ _ __

      -~~-~~~L~~-------------------~
      -C.-~-~-1/1·11--C..,Iff<l5L_f()JM.LH£L _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _--'-----

      --~H'--!...;lt/l!l_i_S_(!Q.JIJL'LLtJL$_T_$.._Ltr__c._LE_B/S__ _ _ _~--------=--

      --P-~O~_WX-~6~~~--~----~~------
.•                  1--ld~-f'l:J-N-;-'-~-·Z7~_LO - ¥._651-------~~----,--

       ···J·i   ---,-----~·.·~,;:·.·~---~--A~·-~-------~---___:.::::_
•
                                       ./
     - - - . ::c.fJ__tiJ_IL_2._.3_0_7]-J_;)jj_fli_L_t_&- L_/)_LdS_r /1_/.,o_c.I:__ _ _ __
      _ _ _ _e.~D-CJB r__(Q_E_Jd&R/lCS-CllJl.N-rY-rt=-:X.Ji~-6'---------

     .el±u_L_e~i!R-cill~.r-,...--,----'------------~---~

     -------a~~~a~-----------~---

     _C!.,J±f{,J_&_/JJ}_AJ_LlfL_   _..:___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _~c___                      _ _ _: - - - _
                                                       I

     _tl~ft-LO-eix..JJv_cy__f}_Lh_LLLL~LEflk_ _ _,__ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
     ______R~~aMasM~----------~~----

                                    · t$F        M A:AJ 12 &In lLS

•    _ _eJ1Tn~5_fJJ_O_Uf PAul
                                                                                       /_.

                                                 E.A:R..C,H Jfs.1_B e:L&ro_s_f2A0_6_f=._X-IJJ_
       rIf{;'   -A.BJJJI ~ d:~ L.EIJ-AAJ_Q_IJ-/Jili-1JE:f<51J__:_f:.,/1CJ6J.£ A:A:Lb_JE I ~IE6-
      -#l<f!>-4J-~-lfJ..£"tV4D--i- cc fl_ELJ!l=rD-JtJs_·fl)D~f-:-J-fJ/V_F-().8. ~~8-J.L/5'_7JJ__~LL.-'="-­
    . -A--W-R-I-r-AE-Jl:J_f±/JJ_IJ_/!lta~i.LS7~P-URJ..b_UI1N L_ :ro ltR'L_Litp ]~6_t:_{.~_
      .CaldJF--rtl&_(..[)_O_~~D_t=:__C./liM \ ALAL_e/l.()_C_"_EtJ_~IJ (!.J:J-U-5/i
      _8_/diJ_\U.IJ.L_f-1-j(3" Jl_b:_LflltJ-a_fn_O_V_5iS_A::s_£0 L LO_UlS_lc_____ _ _ __

                                         .-.--
      ---------~-'~--------'-------

                                            _,_
•      _/?_ f1.J)_P 0_5_E_C2_tJ_flD-E_a_f)_ES_lfrhl!J._:_L_ l~&c.s_&u_E:f:,_b-.Af_D Fe ~--JE_ LLtAl~
         .                         .          .                                /
       A_eEU'J!!tJlt_rt ' 'LidJ£_'Cfl}.1+:L_CO_UdJJ: __&8_Q /?'R ~fl_'OJ-_~_6lr=F ~{£ f?E-
       _:_r_t±_~
                           1

                       _G_cN_EJl/r:L._C.f)_U_A}_6 E"L 7IJ.__E LLL-4-_&_E.E 1Q&JLL/
                                                                                          .                        .
                                                                                                                               '

                                                                                                                                   l,.All_'l:M_r&/F~

       _f?_QS_L_(J_OlJJLt_c_r_u1fU_f)__t_~ttJiu j:AJ tt0tJ 5 roALr-m-~-WL'Ltf_LJ1}__
        Tl+f '&~O-~__Q_tJ£:
                   .           .     __1l±J.= S I 6-N IN fr ·tlf____It-:±_~T_{)_B._D
                                                               .      .              I:_R-J.~·'LJl-£. _ _
                                                                                      .

       _QfiA:D_LJ_Al [£__E_ 0 R. r..t-+ ~ ~t:_&c {{ ~ l.._C!..lXJ AJS &.L~fltLftS_LL/._ I3_LlS=----~
       _W_/d-_ t-~tf--tr.f;J$~B._ELA--r:d-R.-i.:_~jJLC£~o»~LU1Lts.. _~~_:__L_/lJ~L­
       _l!ljUJlES__JJ_f£El=_Q UME:____T!J_A:N-£ULf£R. . WM k~lt-/L:.S-~ /H-fii lRIB-.----'b=----
       _CfJUPl'r f:S_P-,LLQUJ ~/)__2.JLfJ1Fi-S L_Q DlitL_EB.J!)JJJ_{i:_ .<WH-fi~C:R__
       _ r~             ,AfP-L i C_IJ-1:-JO_rv_-t!..O_N_'Cf!J_IJ/_S_f!tLL_ftl£ft'LL()tV_S_e_~C._()_!JL_C/ll)~
           _\LE:_&'Ct£"tJ_ _f!-tJ:;(Ll0JM ~~.._UJ~- &_eS 0 L U&fJ F~_/YJ_~rE:B-lfl--=L'-------
                          1
              "
           _1]J ,f:I±_I£_Lf::&ltLLi::}~(l~T-I!CIL/±I?_i!._LLC!J:&..l' ts CAfJ P../IJ2El!J1ilJJ_~L___ _
           ti-lt J:J.C. L.E J.Lt 0 7----.3_(G) OL_'[J.±E_C.~ f>c fJLa.LY!JJUll____L__B/!.a:..E_OU_Ji_~~

•      I

           --------~------~-'--------------
                                                               ~

                                                                       ~
                                                                                                . ~·

           _ _.i!RJ1CL_LJ/-t/J-2_/)Ile5__1J)_()_r .Lf:.Ct-T-SO-Il.-i-Zl:-~-~-1::tt.E_TI<Ik_ L CCJJ ft I
                                                                                  -                                        -              '

           _ro a- r~ KJ                                  rttE~rlm E           ~i-J!!:l Ll-JI=t_u1ALS____I1'!1_e_CJs f::'_Q_fJ      r-- ·?:H-t;;;"------
       ..5J~/!s:T1!tJF7r-~-t.H_cR__rtt/lW_~ttfi~n_m l£L'Leh!- r ~_y__o E-1~:tv_tJ&1J 1£&'---
    -.. DJ:5-ll3~JTJ}&ttrJ·tr~.~U-~ ~~--l!J e!.C..B._Etff_v_l±/i!YJ P fC1tJ/-~-L'f:__&U!_, gd~- Zi--,--
      Wt-t»a_t.kLk_J:t_f!J~E.L''LBkt:/&:_Lfl£-A~(lB._rxeB._QCEL~/JLk.'L' LJJ.L~cr_ __
     I:SfiJ.£6-/-Jtll..t._LL• 0_7._£!Xlf.D_8. irS A- aa.'"tl tl f?tl!l_Tif:.t!'_C 4-lfl!Lfc_Q£_ _
       "ti*E'-1=RJ]J=L._·f.LjUftT_rtJ_.:c:iYLf!JEI21A:'fE:.L)'_T_R,.j}NS_/J1_LL_ro "'L'tt£~--
      C.C!J}!_Ld~(!J;_/_ltllflL.A-L tlE~E&LS,                                                 Tl±_E    fl._t:i_tl&D~E.Ml!1     r_tHE__ __
           k-e_e_ L i_(fl='CCO.IJJ~f3_[)_(!___Lt-_)AI/ZI_f::_4l.E H-lt-8 ciJ-6                               <:..!JB._f!_/.1. S1_aC£{!1.LlJI_(r__ _
           _L[±~r&t1H~_CCi.Jf1_t rs~.i::.M.If-'--11 0 N A-_El/t201/J2.6-_:_L.tfl!t:.'LiiLO lcSS£1 ~
•          ~o-e_ef'K..-~8af}U£r£_r;__t;CJ1~L'[:II=fE/1_B,_5_ 0 L,u'l1li/JL ·-k.JJ.lr~ii'~-~--C---c..C? 4/
           _f   ttE D_~_6T'fl.l L L~C.LEI!r.~ Jt:..h--S_AJi)__-ACJ,_'l:_fi'(O~+rt-~_FO>/ti.DJ\J Tf;:::ti}JU~ .·
                         ..·
                                  ·-·
                               ::~·:l~.":'h·   ,.   .•
                                                                   ·;·.·. ... ---4-
                                                                                ...c...--
                                                                                                              (-       .
•              _:r 0 . ·H o LQ_B E' LA r_o_a f S_l±llBJEIJ:£,;.,_1£1~-B-J]_~ v M f-YY\ 1--v/\J-1
               ~ s~w, oci_J-J_f_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

                                                   J7l,

               -----'-_w_tj   t:t\E EO B te1_E_R E flllSE'S CoMS_LD_E.B. t2 f7             PA tJ L ·f;', A Fl- C.U I      £
               .eJ~AY_T-t:l ~T '£tl-_l5JfJlbl-'lH_f3_}3 L E_C O~IJT--%--SS.l.L~_:L\-_12B_Q_~& _ __
          .. ~l~ O_J_l'-J_ 6-~T H fiT_t 4*lf"__:_(~D_)_J2A-Y S_J:t_,9:6-c--t?Xf.J_B A} · FOFl -T" l±._,F'-----
               _'[J{ li±L_!_D_u_f3._l--T_O_e_~_L_I:Ci       ;r;rfs   Qft Ql? 8._(1£Si6.Nft_TlN fL_X55CJ.I!S-
               4-IV-D-O-B_Q E B. E 1- T l~ ,;--if, -TI!t/E_Lfil&L~CO.UJ!T_t=_bJ_L_Eli_L_T S "it o·Eft
                                                                                                               1

               AtJ_D_tLfi 0 'E" f\ J:H LC.J,.£fiJ~_J:o_r._j3.AN-5_/Y)Jj_Jj_ l.S                     ltEP L LCA r tO 1\!
. •            7r)_J:/il_E c. 0 u ElT -~-E eFtJJ!U         N Pr_ L A- e.EE A-l~S~,~-------
               -------------!---~----~---

               _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _fits.f~cr FULL 'L.SLJ_f!JJ!J._tiTE D J_
                                       ~L~ ~(.k!{l$
               ------------t1_B_._fA.UL_£~,AtlC.Id_/_E_---'--_
               ~-----------f!_R'O - SE_B E_LA_LDJ!.____

                                                 :JYZ

          . _I___:_J-1 E" B ~- 6 U_EJ~.fJ_/! Y--r tifr_L_fiJBU~                 QLJP-~_oE_J:f±c_traO_V£_ _
          tt   R € LA Tt) ~ t 5 f!J.D.T_ I 0 AI ff;_f!_L~/tJLe_]:D_ELIE__A Wftt I           lJ f?:_f!1AJlO!ll!lU.S_u _
          WA5~eR-'J_E:_D_:_lLN                rH-ed5   -D~Y_o_f!_,/J?g:t?pll¥1 ~ _:y;_I~BY.R LIJ.CJ AI 6-_1!t GO_&_
       .1D F !_l:tE_D_A M i: Z:..N~J:ttJ=_U.!b~I!}Etl_L_lt:D 0&_55 t:DJ!J_',LHJ(.J5_D_J)f!llti:Lidhll.
         L? Cou tJ TY DJ8.TE1 J,e. r C.L/?13_tr,_f!LJ_. .1JtiX-Lf.baf;-:til2US--rn.!j_lj._2Z2lL2 _.· .. . .·
.     -----~.-~-.=c-=-·.~-~----~---·~··--·   _ _ _ _ _·                -~-...:::;._,.::.
                                                                                    -~::::.:=:~,~&:~~--~~··
                                                                                                     ~    . . iiiiiiiiiiiiiii·~
                                                                          -   !f1~~,   PAUL E. A-RCHiE