Court Opinion

ID: 4361041
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2019-01-23 16:09:33.964365+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T14:48:08.234581
License: Public Domain

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF IOWA

                                   No. 18-0255
                             Filed January 23, 2019

STATE OF IOWA,
     Plaintiff-Appellee,

vs.

MARK EDWARD WILCOX,
     Defendant-Appellant.
________________________________________________________________

      Appeal from the Iowa District Court for Black Hawk County, Jeffrey L. Harris,

District Associate Judge.

      The defendant appeals the district court’s denial of his petitions to expunge

convictions. AFFIRMED.

      Craig C. Ament of Ament Law Firm, Waterloo, for appellant.

      Thomas J. Miller, Attorney General, and Katie Krickbaum, Assistant

Attorney General, for appellee.

      Considered by Vogel, C.J., and Vaitheswaran and McDonald, JJ.
                                         2

VOGEL, Chief Judge.

       On July 1, 2009, Mark Edward Wilcox pled guilty to public intoxication, third

offense, in violation of Iowa Code sections 123.46 and 123.91 (2009) in case

number AGCR160217. On May 24, 2013, Wilcox pled guilty to public intoxication,

third offense, in violation of Iowa Code sections 123.46 and 123.91 (2013) in case

number AGCR190587. Wilcox filed a petition to expunge the conviction under

Iowa Code section 123.46(6) (2017) for case number AGCR190587 on December

7, 2017, and a separate petition to expunge the AGCR160217 conviction on

December 14, 2017. A hearing was held on both petitions on January 19, 2018.

The district court, in separate, subsequent rulings, denied both petitions for

expungement, holding:

       The court will follow the clear language of the introductory sentence
       of section 123.46(6) which states “Upon the expiration of two years
       following conviction for a violation of this section, a person may
       petition the court to expunge the conviction . . . .” The court places
       controlling emphasis on the qualifying word “this” to conclude that
       the expungement provision of section 123.46(6) will cross reference
       the simple misdemeanor offense identified in section 123.46(2) and
       (3), only, and that the expungement provision is exclusive to the
       simple misdemeanor offense.

(Emphasis added).      Moreover, the district court reasoned that “[i]f the Iowa

legislature had intended to have the expungement provision apply in this matter a

simple fix would have included the words ‘or of section 123.91’ immediately

following the words ‘this section.’”

       On appeal, Wilcox argues the district court misinterpreted Iowa Code

section 123.46(6) and therefore erred by denying his petitions for expungement.

Our review of statutory interpretation is for correction of errors at law. State v.

Garcia, 756 N.W.2d 216, 220 (Iowa 2008). Iowa Code section 123.46(6) provides,
                                         3

               Upon the expiration of two years following conviction for a
       violation of this section . . . , a person may petition the court to
       expunge the conviction . . . , and if the person has no other criminal
       convictions, other than local traffic violations or simple misdemeanor
       violations of chapter 321 during the two-year period, the
       conviction . . . shall be expunged as a matter of law.

Because section 123.46(6) uses the phrase “this section”—relating to simple

misdemeanors—and fails to include any other section, it appears the legislature

did not intend it to apply to violations under other sections, including the

aggravated misdemeanor section under Iowa Code section 123.91(2) for “third and

each subsequent conviction.” See Iowa Dep’t of Transp. v. Iowa Dist. Court, 488

N.W.2d 174, 175 (Iowa 1992) (“The legislature’s omission of citations to other

Code chapters and inclusion of the express term ‘this chapter’ reveals its intent to

exclude violations of other Code chapters . . . .”).    We find the district court

correctly interpreted the applicable statute and affirm without further opinion. See

Iowa Ct. R. 21.26(1)(d), (e).

       AFFIRMED.