Court Opinion

ID: 9409971
Source: CourtListenerOpinion
Date Created: 2023-07-19 21:02:03.538328+00
Date Added: 2024-06-11T17:20:54.515709
License: Public Domain

SlipȱOp.ȱ23Ȭ105ȱ

              UNITEDȱSTATESȱCOURTȱOFȱINTERNATIONALȱTRADEȱ

 CHINAȱMANUFACTURERSȱ
 ALLIANCE,ȱLLCȱandȱDOUBLEȱCOINȱ
 HOLDINGSȱLTD.,ȱetȱal.,ȱ

                      Plaintiffs,ȱ          Before:ȱTimothyȱC.ȱStanceu,ȱJudgeȱ

               v.ȱ                          Consol.ȱCourtȱNo.ȱ15Ȭ00124ȱ

 UNITEDȱSTATES,ȱ

                      Defendant.ȱ

                                      JUDGMENTȱ

      BeforeȱtheȱcourtȱareȱtheȱFinalȱResultsȱofȱRedeterminationȱPursuantȱtoȱCourtȱ

Remandȱ(Juneȱ14,ȱ2023),ȱECFȱNo.ȱ272ȱ(theȱ“RemandȱRedetermination”)ȱsubmittedȱtoȱtheȱ

courtȱbyȱtheȱInternationalȱTradeȱAdministration,ȱU.S.ȱDepartmentȱofȱCommerceȱ(“theȱ

Department”)ȱinȱresponseȱtoȱtheȱcourt’sȱOpinionȱandȱOrderȱinȱChinaȱManufacturersȱ

Alliance,ȱLLCȱv.ȱUnitedȱStates,ȱNo.ȱ23Ȭ75,ȱ2023ȱWLȱ3479423ȱ(Ct.ȱInt’lȱTradeȱMayȱ16,ȱ2023)ȱ

(“CMAȱV”).ȱ

      TheȱcourtȱdeterminesȱthatȱtheȱRemandȱRedeterminationȱcompliesȱwithȱtheȱ

court’sȱdecisionsȱinȱCMAȱVȱthatȱplaintiffsȱChinaȱManufacturersȱAlliance,ȱLLCȱandȱ

DoubleȱCoinȱHoldingsȱLtd.ȱ(collectively,ȱ“DoubleȱCoin”)ȱdidȱnotȱrebutȱtheȱ

Department’sȱpresumptionȱofȱcontrolȱbyȱtheȱGovernmentȱofȱChinaȱoverȱexportȱactivitiesȱ

andȱthatȱDoubleȱCoin,ȱconsequently,ȱmustȱbeȱassignedȱtheȱPRCȬwideȱrateȱofȱ105.31%.ȱ
Consol.ȱCourtȱNo.ȱ15Ȭ00124ȱ      ȱ      ȱ      ȱ      ȱ     ȱ      ȱ   ȱȱȱȱȱȱȱPageȱ2ȱ
ȱ
      NoȱpartyȱfiledȱcommentsȱinȱoppositionȱtoȱtheȱRemandȱRedeterminationȱwithinȱ

theȱ30ȬdayȱperiodȱprovidedȱforȱinȱUSCITȱRuleȱ56.2(h).ȱ

      UponȱconsiderationȱofȱtheȱRemandȱRedeterminationȱandȱallȱotherȱpapersȱandȱ

proceedingsȱhadȱherein,ȱandȱuponȱdueȱdeliberation,ȱitȱisȱherebyȱ

       ORDEREDȱthatȱtheȱDepartment’sȱfindingȱinȱtheȱRemandȱRedeterminationȱthatȱ
DoubleȱCoinȱdidȱnotȱrebutȱtheȱpresumptionȱofȱgovernmentȱcontrolȱbe,ȱandȱherebyȱis,ȱ
sustained;ȱitȱisȱfurtherȱ
       ȱ
       ORDEREDȱthatȱtheȱDepartment’sȱassignmentȱofȱtheȱPRCȬwideȱrateȱofȱ105.31%ȱtoȱ
DoubleȱCoinȱbe,ȱandȱherebyȱis,ȱsustained;ȱandȱitȱisȱfurtherȱ
       ȱ
       ORDEREDȱthatȱentriesȱaffectedȱbyȱthisȱlitigationȱshallȱbeȱliquidatedȱinȱ
accordanceȱwithȱtheȱfinalȱjudicialȱdecisionȱinȱthisȱaction.ȱ
ȱ
       ȱ
       ȱ                                                /s/ȱTimothyȱC.ȱStanceuȱȱ
       ȱ       ȱ      ȱ     ȱ      ȱ      ȱ       ȱ       TimothyȱC.ȱStanceu,ȱJudgeȱ
Dated:ȱJulyȱ19,ȱ2023ȱ
ȱ      ȱNewȱYork,ȱNewȱYorkȱ
ȱ