Opinion ID: 177062
Heading Depth: 3
Heading Rank: 3

Heading: Declined to Pursue Case Based on Merits

Text: In twelve cases, Kuzmin declined to pursue an appeal due to a low likelihood of success or the availability of an alternative form of relief. Tr. 37. These cases include: 02-4470,03­ 40079,03-40686,04-2694,04-3058,04-3310, 05-1038, 05-3601, 05-3675, 05-3871, 05-5199 and 05-5673. May 2,2008 Response at 11-16. According to Kuzmin, a low probability of success was indicated in several cases based on untimeliness, mootness, or a lack of evidence to show persecution or other necessary elements of the clients' claims. Id. In addition, in at least three instances, Kuzmin's clients were able to obtain asylum by applying for an adjustment of status based on a spouse or other relative. May 2, 2008 Response, at 17; Tr. 37-38. Nevertheless, Kuzmin concedes that, in all ofthese twelve instances, he should have withdrawn the petitions. May 2, 2008 Response, at 16-17.