Opinion ID: 2998283
Heading Depth: 3
Heading Rank: 3

Heading: Disputes as to material facts.

Text: This conclusion forecloses Wittje’s argument that there are disputes as to material facts. The dispute between the parties as to the voluntariness of Wittje’s service and whether Wittje served as a camp guard is immaterial. Wittje’s service in the Death’s Head Battalion of the Waffen 8 As we have noted, a DPC memorandum dated March 14, 1950, quoted approvingly this conclusion of the State Department. No. 04-3517 19 SS, a fact he concedes, regardless of whether that service was voluntary and regardless of whether that service included time as a camp guard or was limited to participating in sports competitions, rendered Wittje ineligible for a visa at the time of his application.