Opinion ID: 1147963
Heading Depth: 1
Heading Rank: 1

Heading: Digest of Facts Found by the Trial Court

Text: 1. Plaintiffs brought this action on behalf of themselves and other residents, taxpayers and parents of children of school age similarly situated. 2. Plaintiffs have no adequate remedy at law. 3. An actual controversy exists between the plaintiffs and all defendants herein. 4. The statutes of the State of New Mexico provide an administrative remedy, but that remedy in a situation as here presented is one of form and not of substance, and plaintiffs have exhausted said remedy prior to the filing of the petition herein. 5. There is no separation between the Roman Catholic Church and the State of New Mexico in the following named schools, all located in the State of New Mexico: | Santa Rita Grade School, Carrizozo | Mount Carmel School, Socorro | St. Mary's School, Belen | San Fidel School, Valencia County First | St. Nicholas Grade School, Sandoval County 6. All of the schools named in these findings are situated in the Archdiocese of Santa Fe, except the schools in Cubero and San Fidel, Valencia County, and Blanco, San Juan County, which are located in the Archdiocese of Gallup, New Mexico. 7. The schools comprising the first group above are, in fact, Roman Catholic parochial schools being subsidized in part by funds raised through taxation by the State of New Mexico through the employment of teachers, furnishing of free bus transportation and free text-books; and funds so expended are used in furtherance of the dissemination of Roman Catholic religious doctrines to students attending these schools in compliance with the New Mexico compulsory attendance law. In all of the schools named in the first group, the following conditions exist, to-wit: (a) Church buildings owned by the Roman Catholic Church are used five days each week during the school term for school buildings. (b) Religious are employed as teachers by the State of New Mexico and paid as such from funds raised through taxation in the State of New Mexico. (c) Pupils attending these schools are given religious instruction in the principles of the Roman Catholic Church, commonly known as the catechism, during school hours by the Religious employed as teachers by the State of New Mexico. (d) Students are taught and recite prayers during school hours which are peculiar to the Roman Catholic Church. (e) Roman Catholic literature, pamphlets, leaflets and comic books are distributed to the students during school hours. Certain variations in these practices are found from school to school and are detailed hereafter, to-wit: (a) Lumberton School, Rio Arriba County, and Old Town Junior High School, Las Vegas, are not named as schools receiving free bus transportation for their pupils. (b) Park View School, Rio Arriba County, and St. Francis School, Ranchos de Taos, are schools in which religious instruction was given during school hours by the parish priests of the Roman Catholic Church. (c) Students at Santa Rita School, Carrizozo, were not found to have been learning or reciting prayers peculiar to the Roman Catholic Church during school hours. (d) Neither the Santa Rita School, Carrizozo, nor the Lumberton School, Rio Arriba County, were declared to be distributing Roman Catholic literature, etc., to their students during school hours. (e) St. Joseph's School in Dixon, Rio Arriba County, is not included in some of the findings made by the court common to all of the parochial schools, but the court specifically found this school is in fact a Roman Catholic parochial school being aided by the State of New Mexico through funds produced by taxation in the employment of teachers, the furnishing of bus transportation and text books without charge. (There is abundant evidence that the procedure followed in this school is essentially the same as that followed in the remainder of the schools found to be parochial.) 8. With respect to the schools enumerated in the second group, the court found: (a) Religious are employed to teach in all of these schools by the State of New Mexico and paid out of tax funds. Free text books and free bus transportation are furnished the pupils in said schools through funds raised by taxation by the State of New Mexico, and funds so expended are used in furtherance of the dissemination of Roman Catholic religious doctrines to students attending in compliance with the New Mexico compulsory attendance law. (b) In every school religious instruction in the principles of the Roman Catholic Church is given pupils during school hours by the Religious employed as teachers and paid by the State of New Mexico out of tax funds. (c) In ten of these schools students, during school hours, are taught and recite prayers peculiar to the Roman Catholic Church. (Santa Cruz School, Costilla School and Villanueva School not being included in this finding.) (d) Church buildings owned by the Roman Catholic Church are used five days each week during the school term in ten of these schools (there being no finding as to Chama School, Pecos Independent School District and Ribera School.) (e) Roman Catholic literature is distributed during school hours in seven of these schools, to-wit: Cubero School, Blanco Grade School, San Juan School, Santa Cruz School, Costilla School, Villanueva School and Mora School. 9. Tierra Amarilla School, Rio Arriba County, is not included in the number of schools where the court found there was no separation of the State of New Mexico and the Roman Catholic Church, however, by the findings of the court, this school observed all the practices as the schools enumerated in the second group, except that church buildings were not there used for school buildings. 10. In certain of the schools from each group, parochial and otherwise, students are released from school attendance during school hours for the purpose of attending mass or confession held in the Roman Catholic Church, and there are pictures on the walls of the schoolrooms portraying themes peculiar to the Roman Catholic Church. 11. With respect to all of the schools in both groups, the court found the children attending said schools are under the supervision of the teachers from the time they arrive on the school ground and so long as they remain thereon at the end of the school day. 12. A complete line of text books has been adopted by the State of New Mexico for use in Catholic schools only and is furnished to the Catholic parochial schools and certain public schools without charge. 13. The Religious are employed as teachers and are paid salaries by the State of New Mexico out of funds produced by taxation in each of the schools involved, with the exception that in some schools the salaries are paid direct to the religious order to which the particular Religious belongs. 14. All of the Religious named as defendants were dressed in the distinctive garb of their Order at all times while school was in session and in a number of schools the Religious are employed to teach in said school by the Superior member of the Order to which they belong. 15. In 1941 the Rio Arriba County Board of Education entered into a contract with the Mother Superior acting on behalf of the Franciscan Sisters of Our Lady of Perpetual Help, wherein said Board agreed to employ Sisters of said Order for a period of not less than five years, which contract was approved by the Archbishop of the Catholic Church in St. Louis, Missouri. 16. All of the defendant Religious were, or had been at times material to this case, conducting regular classes of instruction in the principles of the Roman Catholic Church during school hours to students attending school in compliance with the New Mexico compulsory attendance law, except defendant Sisters named as teachers in the schools at Abiquiu, Tucumcari, and in the Catron County schools, all in New Mexico. 17. Students attending school at Abiquiu are taught the principles of the Roman Catholic Church by Sisters, not employed by the State of New Mexico, in the Catholic Church at Abiquiu immediately after the school buses arrive each school day and before secular classes commence. 18. The Old Town Junior High School at Las Vegas and the Sacred Heart Academy Grade School in San Juan County are owned by the Christian Brothers, an Order of the Roman Catholic Church, and the physical plant is under the direction, control and supervision of the Brother Superior of said Order. 19. The Catholic Brothers who were employed as teachers in the Old Town Junior High School, Las Vegas, refused to teach female students and additional teachers were employed and likewise paid out of tax funds for the purpose of teaching classes composed of girls.