Opinion ID: 2602185
Heading Depth: 3
Heading Rank: 6

Heading: The April 20, 1998, actual commencement of trial

Text: On April 20, 1998, the trial court informed defendant that, based on the court's concern that defendant would not participate meaningfully at trial, it had appointed standby counsel, William Windon. Defendant objected, stating: It won't be necessary. I've got a real good lawyer representing me, Timothy Crayton. [¶] ... [¶] I object to any standby counsel, because you're trying to take my pro per status. And that, that's not right, that's unfair. [¶] ... [¶] I'm defending Timothy Crayton the best way I can. And I think I'm doing a good job. And so I don't see where standby counsel would come in. Although the trial court agreed as to defendant's competency to represent himself, it was not persuaded to withdraw its appointment of standby counsel to assist defendant should the need arise: I know that you're a bright fellow. I've seen your legal work. And I do agree that you've done more than most lawyers would do, and phrased your legal motions in appropriate form, and been very competent. [¶] ... And I want you to have the best representation. Defendant reaffirmed his desire and willingness to represent himself: Your Honor, I represented myself at four jury trials. I have never lost a jury trial. I've won all four jury trials. [¶] ... I know how to conduct myself at a trial. I have a duty to my client to represent him to the best of my ability. (Italics added.) Defendant then moved to dismiss the charges based on the grounds [among other reasons] that I've been denied the right of self-representation and effective meaningful self-representation.... Defendant added: I'm speaking under duress, under the threat of having my pro per status taken. The trial court disagreed with defendant's characterization: Mr. Crayton, I've not threatened to take away your pro per status, only to have an attorney come in to take over the case if you don't represent your client to the best of your ability. [¶] If you're going to tune out, then I want a lawyer to step in. If you wish, and it's your conscious choice not to participate, and to just sit there, you know you may be right, and maybe I wouldn't bring in standby counsel at that point. But I'll ask you if you want me to bring in counsel. Defendant replied: No I do not. [6]