Opinion ID: 164751
Heading Depth: 4
Heading Rank: 3

Heading: Treatment of Officer Whitfield

Text: Sergeant Stahl also argues that a male candidate, Officer Mike Whitfield, was afforded favorable treatment during the fitness test because he was allowed to rest on the floor between the final few push-ups while she was not. We agree with the district court that this evidence is “isolated and inconsequential.” id. at 2 Sergeant Stahl acknowledged that several male officers in the Vice and Narcotics Unit also complained that they did not have enough time to train for the test. See Aple’s Supp. App. at 66 (“[A] couple of those guys didn’t even put in for taking the test because they didn’t think they could get in shape fast enough, and they said they weren’t going to test for a job that they already had.”). -14- 131. Sergeant Stahl stated that she was aware of no other occasion in which an applicant was given favorable treatment. Moreover, even with the alleged unfavorable treatment that she received, Sergeant Stahl received a passing score. on the push-up element. Finally, Sergeant Stahl presented no evidence of unfavorable treatment on the elements that she failed. We therefore agree with the district court that the County is entitled to summary judgment on Sergeant Stahl’s gender discrimination claim.