Opinion ID: 793859
Heading Depth: 3
Heading Rank: 4

Heading: Motion practice and bench trial

Text: 20 The defendants-appellants filed a motion for judgment on the pleadings, contending that the district court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction because (1) ACL was a common carrier outside of the FTC's jurisdiction, (2) the filed-rate doctrine negated standing by precluding the FTC from contending that line subscribers could avoid the charges in question, and (3) the primary-jurisdiction doctrine required the FCC to first decide the case. The district court asked the FCC to brief, as amicus curiae, the merits of the defendants-appellants' contentions, and the United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York submitted a letter brief on behalf of the FCC answering the district court's questions. He concluded that ACL was not a common carrier under the Communications Act and that the primary-jurisdiction and filed-rate doctrines therefore did not apply. With the benefit of the FCC's views, the district court denied the defendants-appellants' motion for judgment on the pleadings and found that it had subject-matter jurisdiction to hear the case. 21 On September 17, 2004, following a bench trial on a record of stipulated facts, declarations, exhibits, and other evidence, the district court filed a memorandum opinion. The court incorporated the factual findings and legal holdings of its earlier opinion denying defendants-appellants' motion for judgment on the pleadings, held that the FTC proved Counts I, II, and III of its second amended complaint, and held that individual as well as corporate liability was appropriate. Finding the restitutionary remedy of disgorgement to be available and proper, the district court entered two money judgments against the defendants-appellants for a total of $17.9 million. The court also replaced the preliminary injunction with a permanent injunction, which did not contain a financial-disclosure requirement. The defendants-appellants timely appealed from the district court's judgment.