Opinion ID: 407620
Heading Depth: 1
Heading Rank: 3

Heading: Time for Removal of Timber

Text: 9 Under Oregon law, if a deed or contract provides a definite time for the removal of timber, then that language controls. Oregon courts have found a variety of reservation clauses to be sufficiently definite. See, e.g., Sandy Holding Co. v. Ferro, 144 Or. 466, 473-76, 25 P.2d 561 (1933) (right to remove timber from date of contract until August 1, 1932); Coquille Mill & Tug Co. v. Robert Dollar Co., 132 Or. 453, 469, 285 P. 244 (1930) (right to remove timber until all merchantable timber completely logged); Kreinbring v. Mathews, 81 Or. 243, 249, 159 P. 75 (1916) (right to remove timber ten years from date of conveyance); Anderson v. Miami Lumber Co., 59 Or. 149, 156-60, 116 P. 1056 (1911) (right to remove all timber within five years from date of instrument). 10 When a deed reserving or conveying timber rights does not specify a time for the removal of the timber, Oregon courts imply a reasonable time for removal. See Franke v. Welch, 254 Or. 149, 151, 458 P.2d 441 (1969); Emerson v. Hood River County, 223 Or. 112, 353 P.2d 247, modified, 223 Or. 126, 354 P.2d 74 (1960); Parsons v. Boggie, 139 Or. 469, 470, 11 P.2d 280 (1932). The running of a reasonable time divests the title to timber reserved in the deed. Emerson, 223 Or. at 119, 353 P.2d 247; Clyde v. Walker, 220 Or. 137, 142, 348 P.2d 1104 (1960). In Franke, 254 Or. at 151, 458 P.2d 441, the Oregon Supreme Court explained that this practice is based on the assumption that because the reservation of a right to remove timber affects the use and value of the land, the party conveying the property would not ordinarily intend to encumber the land beyond a reasonable time. The court noted that so long as he makes his intent clear, the conveyor can even reserve a perpetual right to remove timber. Id. 11 We must determine whether the reservation clause before us is sufficiently definite. The deed reserved the right to remove timber at any time prior to the commencement by the grantee of mining operations, the grantee to give to the grantors at least six months' notice of its intention to commence mining operations. We can find no Oregon decision construing a term of removal that depends on a similar condition. 12 However, in light of the assumption as to the conveyor's intent underlying the Oregon rule, we have no difficulty concluding that the language of the reservation clause should control here. The Gamans clearly contemplated that the right to remove timber would persist until six months after Alcoa (or its assignee, Reynolds) gave notice of its intention to commence mining the land. They imposed no limits on the reserved right. Indeed, by also reserving the rights to farm and live on the land (which are more than transient activities) and by providing for the conveyance of all of these rights to their heirs and assigns, the Gamans seem to have recognized the possibility that the land might not be mined for many years. 13 Moreover, Alcoa and Reynolds had the power to extinguish the right to remove timber at any time. If the right to remove timber survived for more than what might seem like a reasonable period, they brought this problem upon themselves. We see little reason to invoke Oregon's reasonable-time-for-removal rule to protect a land owner which can protect itself. Also, the notice provision would lead the grantors and their successors into believing that their rights could not be terminated until six months after receipt of notice. For these reasons, we find distinguishable those cases cited by Reynolds where the land owner had no control over the encumbrance on the property, and no notice was required. Nelson v. McKinney, 163 Wash. 529, 1 P.2d 876 (1931); Dunn v. Forrester, 181 Ark. 696, 27 S.W.2d 1005 (1930). 14 In conclusion, the district court was clearly wrong in not enforcing the reservation clause according to its plain meaning. Oregon law supplies no support for inferring a period for the removal of the timber manifestly inconsistent with the one prescribed by the deed.