Opinion ID: 2306140
Heading Depth: 2
Heading Rank: 5

Heading: Adrianne's Phone Records

Text: The government's failure to provide copies of phone records, showing a call between Adrianne and defendant Clark until after opening statements, does not violate Brady. Franklin argues that the phone records were essential to the preparation of the defense and that he was therefore substantially prejudiced by not having them before trial. Records of a call between Adrianne and defendant Clark cannot be exculpatory, however, because how many people attacked Wellman or who was the principal of that attack is irrelevant to the appellants' culpability under a theory of aiding and abetting. See Parts II.B. and IV., supra. Second, it is unclear how the information would be useful for impeachment beyond the use to which Franklin has already put it. [8] Thus, he fails to create a reasonable doubt about the appellants' guilt when evaluated in the context of the entire record, and we affirm the trial court on this point. [9] For the foregoing reasons, the appellants' convictions are Affirmed. [10]