Opinion ID: 1926977
Heading Depth: 1
Heading Rank: 1

Heading: Validity of Statutes Relating to Place of Detention

Text: The trial judge held Sections 39.03(5)(a) and (b), Florida Statutes, [2] concerning juvenile detention, unconstitutional because they are in conflict with Rules of Juvenile Procedure 8.030(5) and 8.050(a)(5). [3] It is our view that the provisions of Sections 39.03(5)(a) and (b), Florida Statutes, insofar as they concern the place of commitment or detention, establish only directory guidelines for trial judges dealing with juveniles. We construe the phrase in Section 39.03(5)(a) or neither is the proper place therefor, in the opinion of the judge as authorizing the trial judge to determine within his discretion the place of detention. This statute should be read in pari materia with Rules of Juvenile Procedure 8.030 and 8.050. [4] The provision of Section 39.03(5)(a), Florida Statutes, which directs the chief judge to advise the board of county commissioners of the number of juveniles committed to an adult jail facility is proper for use by the governing body of the county for fiscal and planning purposes. The provision cannot be used to interfere with the administrative operation of the court system, which is the sole responsibility of the judicial branch.