Opinion ID: 305228
Heading Depth: 2
Heading Rank: 1

Heading: I don't think he is malingering.

Text: 51 (App. 211.) Dr. Friedman testified also that there is an important element of anxiety and mental depression (App. 145); that it is quite common for a person who has suffered a heart attack similar to that of Mr. Matthews to have anxiety and mental depression. 52 But most patients will get over it in the first two or three months and then resume a normal, active life and learn to live with their handicaps; but during the active acute stage, yes, it is quite common for depression, feeling of dependency to set in    53 (App. 146.) 54 Under the provisions of Swift's Pension Plan, before the district court could adjudge that the plaintiff, Matthews, was entitled to disability benefits under the Plan, it must find either that a decision actually reached by the Pension Board was arbitrary, fraudulent or in bad faith, or, if the Pension Board had made no decision, that it could not fairly and in good faith decide against Matthews upon the evidence presented before the court. The court made no such finding. 11 55 We must therefore reverse and remand for further consideration to paragraph 1 of the relief granted by the court's judgment, ante.