Opinion ID: 1059625
Heading Depth: 2
Heading Rank: 2

Heading: Clear Cutting of Timber

Text: The Dails next turn to the aspects of Code § 10.1-1126.1(B) which forbid the enactment of local ordinances that prohibit silvicultural activity. The Dails maintain that a portion of the EMA Ordinance, § 24.1-372(e)(5), prohibits clear cutting of timber and, therefore, is invalid. However, reading the provision challenged by the Dails in its entirety shows that it is not an absolute prohibition on clear cutting of timber in areas subject to the EMA Ordinance. The portion of the EMA Ordinance challenged by the Dails states that, in those areas subject to the Ordinance: Clear cutting of trees shall not be permitted. However, the zoning administrator may permit selected thinning based upon best management practices and in accordance with an approved plan. § 24.1-372(e)(5), York County Code. We do not interpret this language as prohibiting silvicultural activity. This provision is a limitation on clear cutting, which can be altered by the zoning administrator. Therefore, this provision does not contravene, and is not preempted by, Code § 10.1-1126.1(B). [4]