Opinion ID: 6499526
Heading Depth: 2
Heading Rank: 2

Heading: Pampa Bay

Text: Since 2016, Pampa Bay has been marketing and distributing products that look strikingly similar to the Organic Pearl designs. While nearly identical in appearance to many pieces of Organic Pearl tableware, Pampa Bay products are made with cheaper materials and are sold at lower priced retail outlets. Because of this, Beatriz Ball alleges that Pampa Bay has infringed upon its copyright and its unregistered trade dress. It claims that Pampa Bay’s product lines are “confusingly similar” to Beatriz Ball’s unique Organic Pearl collection because “Pampa Bay’s products copy the ‘look and feel’ of Beatriz Ball Organic Pearl trade dress in every attribute.” In the images reproduced below, Beatriz Ball’s products appear on the left and Pampa Bay’s products appear on the right. 4 Case: 21-30029 Document: 00516391348 Page: 5 Date Filed: 07/12/2022 No. 21-30029