Opinion ID: 1124392
Heading Depth: 1
Heading Rank: 5

Heading: Rosser's pre-existing heart condition

Text: As support for the proposition that the preexisting heart condition was non-disabling, Rosser refers us to Dr. Gerow's finding that there was no pre-existing condition which may have contributed to [his] current condition. Rosser further notes that he worked for the school district for ten years without any disabling heart complications. He maintains that he was not disabled until his supervisor told him that he would receive an unfavorable performance review unless he could master all of the high school maintenance systems. Respondents rely on numerous entries in the medical record in support of their argument that Rosser's preexisting heart condition was disabling. Examples include Dr. Savran's conclusion that Rosser's post-operative atrial fibrillation, which required continued medications to control, was an expected component of his heart disease; notations that the February 26, 1990, carotid angiodynography was performed following complaints of intermittent dyspnea, chest pain, lightheadedness and palpitations; and documentation of symptoms of congestive heart failure which required Rosser to undergo cardioversion on August 14, 1990. Dr. Grant Miller stated in Rosser's March 1992 psychiatric assessment that Rosser's [r]eturn to work would certainly contribute to him having a major depression and/or cause cardiac difficulties. Rosser's psychotherapist, Dr. Jack Araza, concluded in his recommendations to the SIIS that, in addition to the emotional incapacitation, [t]here is the additional concern for his physical health as he has a heart condition. Thus, respondents maintain that Rosser's preexisting heart condition compels an apportionment of his PTD award.