Opinion ID: 1446351
Heading Depth: 3
Heading Rank: 4

Heading: Illegal Importation of Infringing Copies (Count VI)

Text: NCR asserts that KAL developed its Kalignite Upgrade Solutions by infringing NCR's copyrights in APTRA XFS and S4i and then imported Kalignite Upgrade Solutions, the infringing product, into the United States.
Because this claim turns on whether KAL is liable for infringing NCR's copyright in the APTRA XFS software, this claim is arbitrable for the same reasons that NCR's direct infringement claim is arbitrable.
Because the issue of whether KAL infringed a copyright in the S4i software is dispositive of this claim, this claim is not arbitrable for the same reasons that NCR's direct infringement claim is not arbitrable.