Opinion ID: 1742511
Heading Depth: 3
Heading Rank: 3

Heading: The Basis of Expert Opinion Exception

Text: Finally, the defense argues that the tape was admissible as evidence upon which Dr. Rathmell relied in forming her opinion. See La. C.E. art. 705, subd. B. Defense Counsel had sent a copy of the tape to Dr. Rathmell, but she testified that it really didn't help her form her opinion. Moreover, the tape was not made until two years after Dr. Rathmell saw the defendant and rendered her opinion. The tape simply was not evidence upon which Dr. Rathmell relied in forming her opinion. Accordingly, it was not admissible under La. C.E. art. 705, subd. B and the trial court properly excluded it from both the guilt and sentencing phases.