Opinion ID: 2818183
Heading Depth: 3
Heading Rank: 1

Heading: Anner Bonilla Rivera

Text: Bonilla, a software engineer for Hewlett Packard, was the first to testify for Figueroa. He sought to establish that various anti-virus programs found on Figueroa's computer could have been responsible for opening the child pornography files, rather than Figueroa himself. Specifically, Bonilla testified that the anti[- ]virus software Avira accesses every file on the computer to determine whether it is infected with a virus. He stated that [t]here's no way to know if the 'last access date' was changed by an anti-virus or by a user or by any other Windows application . . . that opened it. He similarly testified that 4 Figueroa testified and he called three witnesses: Anner Bonilla Rivera, a computer networking expert, and two character witnesses, Wanda Morrero and William Omar Rodriguez Ramos. We describe Figueroa's defense generally here. Some of the particulars of Figueroa's defense are discussed in more depth in relation to Figueroa's specific challenges to the sufficiency of the evidence. -8- [t]here's no way to know if PC Health virus, also found on Figueroa's computer, modified any of the files containing child pornography. Bonilla testified that a user does not have to open files on LimeWire to be able to download them.