example_id
stringlengths 40
40
| source
stringlengths 498
10.6k
| reference
stringlengths 52
793
| QAs
sequencelengths 0
57
| QA_labels
dict | system_outputs
dict | system_scores
dict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
000571afe702684d90c1d222ce70b1e1375c1016 | Club Tijuana star Juan Arango conjured memories Luis Suarez in his team's 4-3 defeat by Monterrey in the Mexican league - but it was not through prodigious scoring. The Venezuelan icon Arango sank his teeth into the shoulder of Jesus Zavela as his temper flared in the defeat. He was not booked by the referee but could face a heavy retrospective ban. Juan Arango (left) bites the shoulder of opponent Jesus Zavela in a moment of madness . Zavala holds his shoulder after being bitten by Arango, in the game Zavala's side won 4-3 in Mexico . Zavala shows the referee the mark on his shoulder after being bittern by Arango . Arango (right) earlier scored a magnificent free kick to bring his Club Tijuana team level against Monterrey . Arango had earlier curled in a magnificent free kick for his team to bring them level after falling 2-0 down early on in the encounter. But the 34-year-old overshadowed his goal with the bite as television cameras picked up the moment of madness. Arango spent 10 years playing in Europe, spending five seasons each at Real Mallorca in Spain and Borussia Monchengladbach in Germany. He has made 121 appearances for Venezuela. | Juan Arango escaped punishment from the referee for biting Jesus Zavela . He could face a retrospective punishment for the incident . Arango had earlier scored a free kick in his team's 4-3 defeat . | [
"Who escaped from something? Juan Arango",
"What did someone escape from? punishment from the referee for biting Jesus Zavela",
"Who was biting someone? Juan Arango",
"Who was someone biting? Jesus Zavela",
"Who might face something? He",
"What might someone face? a retrospective punishment",
"Why might someone face something? for the incident",
"Who scored something? Arango",
"When did someone score something? earlier",
"What did someone score? a free kick",
"Where did someone score something? in his team 's 4 - 3 defeat"
] | {
"bart": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"pegasus": [
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"brio": [
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"brio-ext": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0
],
"matchsum": [
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0
],
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"llama-3-8b-instruct": [
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0
],
"GPT4": [
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"llama-3-70b-instruct": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
]
} | {
"bart": "Juan Arango bites Jesus Zavela in a moment of madness in Club Tijuana's 4-3 defeat by Monterrey in the Mexican league. The Venezuelan icon sank his teeth into the shoulder of the opponent as his temper flared in the defeat. He was not booked by the referee but could face a heavy retrospective ban. Arango had earlier curled in a magnificent free kick for his team to bring them level after falling 2-0 down.",
"pegasus": "Club Tijuana lost 4-3 to Monterrey in the Mexican league. Juan Arango was not booked but could face a heavy retrospective ban. A Arango free kick had brought his team level at 2-2.",
"brio": "Juan Arango bites the shoulder of opponent Jesus Zavela in the Mexican league. The Club Tijuana star earlier scored a magnificent free kick to bring his team level against Monterrey . The Venezuelan icon could face a retrospective ban for the bite. Arango's side lost the game 4-3 in Mexico.",
"brio-ext": "He was not booked by the referee but could face a heavy retrospective ban. Juan Arango (left) bites the shoulder of opponent Jesus Zavela in a moment of madness. Arango (right) earlier scored a magnificent free kick to bring his Club Tijuana team level against Monterrey.",
"matchsum": "Club Tijuana star Juan Arango conjured memories Luis Suarez in his team's 4-3 defeat by Monterrey in the Mexican league - but it was not through prodigious scoring. Juan Arango (left) bites the shoulder of opponent Jesus Zavela in a moment of madness.",
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": "Juan Arango bit Jesus Zavela in Club Tijuana's 4-3 defeat by Monterrey in the Mexican league . The Venezuelan was not booked by the referee but could face a heavy retrospective ban . Arango had earlier scored a magnificent free kick to bring his team level at 2-2.",
"llama-3-8b-instruct": " Juan Arango, a star player for Club Tijuana, was involved in a biting incident during a Mexican league match against Monterrey . Arango, who had earlier scored a magnificent free kick, sank his teeth into the shoulder of Jesus Zavela in a moment of anger . The incident could result in a heavy retrospective ban for Arango, who has played for clubs in Spain and Germany during his 10-year European stint.",
"GPT4": "Juan Arango of Club Tijuana bit the shoulder of Jesus Zavela during a 4-3 defeat to Monterrey in the Mexican league, an act reminiscent of Luis Suarez's infamous behavior. Despite not being booked during the match, Arango faces the possibility of a significant retrospective ban for his actions. Earlier in the game, Arango had scored a stunning free kick to level the score after his team initially fell behind 2-0.",
"llama-3-70b-instruct": " Juan Arango, a Venezuelan footballer, bit an opponent, Jesus Zavela, during a Mexican league match between Club Tijuana and Monterrey . Arango's team lost 4-3, and he could face a retrospective ban for his actions, despite not being booked by the referee . Earlier in the game, Arango had scored a magnificent free kick to bring his team level after they fell 2-0 behind .",
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": "Club Tijuana star Juan Arango bit the shoulder of Jesus Zavela in a game against Monterrey in the Mexican league . Arango was not booked by the referee but could face a heavy retrospective ban . Arango had earlier scored a magnificent free kick for his team in the 4-3 defeat."
} | {
"bart": {
"QAPyramid": 1,
"nQAPyramid": 0.8194891881817862,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.8194891881817862,
"R1_recall": 0.7941176470588235,
"R1_f1": 0.48648648648648657,
"R2_recall": 0.3939393939393939,
"R2_f1": 0.23853211009174313,
"RL_recall": 0.5294117647058824,
"RL_f1": 0.32432432432432434,
"ACU": 1,
"nACU": 0.5503382086753845,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.9137580990791321,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8936258554458618,
"BARTScore": -2.3022260665893555,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.9087001581986746,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.8537822246551514,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.8888888888888888,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.2944785275797207,
"METEOR": 0.44011874661368977,
"ChrF": 42.79232909725294,
"SemiAutoACU": 1,
"GEval": 4,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.9166666666666666,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 1,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.7511984224999706,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.8194891881817862
},
"pegasus": {
"QAPyramid": 0.7272727272727273,
"nQAPyramid": 0.7272727272727273,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 1,
"R1_recall": 0.5,
"R1_f1": 0.49275362318840576,
"R2_recall": 0.18181818181818182,
"R2_f1": 0.17910447761194032,
"RL_recall": 0.3235294117647059,
"RL_f1": 0.31884057971014496,
"ACU": 0.30000001192092896,
"nACU": 0.30000001192092896,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8843023777008057,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8842813372612,
"BARTScore": -3.365424156188965,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.48083322241048637,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.732949923365959,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.4444444444444444,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.21621621617940104,
"METEOR": 0.27987677971713726,
"ChrF": 28.188144071409095,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.6,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.5833333333333334,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.5454545454545454,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.5833333333333334,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.5454545454545454
},
"brio": {
"QAPyramid": 0.8181818181818182,
"nQAPyramid": 0.7527636119694464,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9200444146293233,
"R1_recall": 0.7058823529411765,
"R1_f1": 0.5647058823529412,
"R2_recall": 0.3333333333333333,
"R2_f1": 0.26506024096385544,
"RL_recall": 0.47058823529411764,
"RL_f1": 0.3764705882352941,
"ACU": 0.800000011920929,
"nACU": 0.6230406165122986,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.9076136946678162,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8964931964874268,
"BARTScore": -2.292257308959961,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.6831403111573309,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.7658860041759908,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.6666666666666666,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.3636363635966942,
"METEOR": 0.36134814814814814,
"ChrF": 39.845091194895176,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.8,
"GEval": 4,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.6666666666666666,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.7272727272727273,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.6133629430862155,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.6691232106395079
},
"brio-ext": {
"QAPyramid": 0.9090909090909091,
"nQAPyramid": 0.8402852314706903,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9243137546177594,
"R1_recall": 0.6470588235294118,
"R1_f1": 0.55,
"R2_recall": 0.24242424242424243,
"R2_f1": 0.20512820512820512,
"RL_recall": 0.4411764705882353,
"RL_f1": 0.375,
"ACU": 0.5,
"nACU": 0.39484646916389465,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.9051980376243591,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8933744430541992,
"BARTScore": -2.424098014831543,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.7626084263126055,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.5376861258991994,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.5555555555555556,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.29411764701989623,
"METEOR": 0.36201855287569573,
"ChrF": 39.742304692048464,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.6,
"GEval": 4,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.9166666666666666,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.9090909090909091,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.8472876083996128,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.8402852314706903
},
"matchsum": {
"QAPyramid": 0.18181818181818182,
"nQAPyramid": 0.171992630710321,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9459594689067655,
"R1_recall": 0.5,
"R1_f1": 0.4358974358974359,
"R2_recall": 0.24242424242424243,
"R2_f1": 0.2105263157894737,
"RL_recall": 0.2647058823529412,
"RL_f1": 0.23076923076923078,
"ACU": 0.4000000059604645,
"nACU": 0.33859267830848694,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8716121315956116,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.863936185836792,
"BARTScore": -3.69429349899292,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.18734135991689982,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.40516212053917117,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.2222222222222222,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.2105263157396122,
"METEOR": 0.23954431960049938,
"ChrF": 31.863550005217384,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.4,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.25,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.3,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.23648986722669138,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.28378784067202967
},
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": {
"QAPyramid": 1,
"nQAPyramid": 0.9372410104578182,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9372410104578182,
"R1_recall": 0.7352941176470589,
"R1_f1": 0.6024096385542169,
"R2_recall": 0.42424242424242425,
"R2_f1": 0.345679012345679,
"RL_recall": 0.5,
"RL_f1": 0.4096385542168675,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.9355925917625427,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.9178662300109863,
"BARTScore": -2.05130672454834,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.8728301922480265,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.8402348577976226,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.8888888888888888,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.3902439024047591,
"METEOR": 0.4408640951620498,
"ChrF": 43.15685073656053,
"SemiAutoACU": 1,
"GEval": 4,
"AutoQAPyramid": 1,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 1,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.9372410104578182,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.9372410104578182
},
"llama-3-8b-instruct": {
"QAPyramid": 0.7272727272727273,
"nQAPyramid": 0.6015362099667497,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.8271122887042809,
"R1_recall": 0.6470588235294118,
"R1_f1": 0.4230769230769231,
"R2_recall": 0.21212121212121213,
"R2_f1": 0.1372549019607843,
"RL_recall": 0.4117647058823529,
"RL_f1": 0.2692307692307692,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.9090979695320129,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8899176120758057,
"BARTScore": -2.527628183364868,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.5230958035293346,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.4603385178168537,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.4444444444444444,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.13114754095845205,
"METEOR": 0.3124547069271759,
"ChrF": 38.82776091135909,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.5,
"GEval": 4,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.6666666666666666,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.7,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.5514081924695206,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.5789786020929966
},
"GPT4": {
"QAPyramid": 0.9090909090909091,
"nQAPyramid": 0.7519202624584371,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.8271122887042809,
"R1_recall": 0.7058823529411765,
"R1_f1": 0.44859813084112143,
"R2_recall": 0.24242424242424243,
"R2_f1": 0.15238095238095237,
"RL_recall": 0.5294117647058824,
"RL_f1": 0.3364485981308411,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.9135563969612122,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8968533277511597,
"BARTScore": -2.3293609619140625,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.7542439759708941,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.7486032285727561,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.6666666666666666,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.13793103446420926,
"METEOR": 0.32192291927228395,
"ChrF": 37.013860007303386,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.8,
"GEval": 4,
"AutoQAPyramid": 1,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.9090909090909091,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.8271122887042809,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.7519202624584371
},
"llama-3-70b-instruct": {
"QAPyramid": 1,
"nQAPyramid": 0.8425718855535911,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.8425718855535911,
"R1_recall": 0.7647058823529411,
"R1_f1": 0.5252525252525253,
"R2_recall": 0.36363636363636365,
"R2_f1": 0.24742268041237112,
"RL_recall": 0.5588235294117647,
"RL_f1": 0.3838383838383838,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.9337979555130005,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.9093097448348999,
"BARTScore": -2.075192928314209,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.8661588629086813,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.8035295303910971,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.8888888888888888,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.6075949366638679,
"METEOR": 0.42264110474243366,
"ChrF": 41.53407287045245,
"SemiAutoACU": 1,
"GEval": 4,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.9166666666666666,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.9090909090909091,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.7723575617574585,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.7659744414123555
},
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": {
"QAPyramid": 1,
"nQAPyramid": 0.9286029058931803,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9286029058931803,
"R1_recall": 0.7352941176470589,
"R1_f1": 0.5952380952380952,
"R2_recall": 0.3939393939393939,
"R2_f1": 0.3170731707317074,
"RL_recall": 0.6176470588235294,
"RL_f1": 0.5,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.9360847473144531,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.9185546636581421,
"BARTScore": -1.8913073539733887,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.9513238072395325,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.9117621719837189,
"AutoACU_recall": 1,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.5333333332942222,
"METEOR": 0.4392251951800347,
"ChrF": 44.34954374766294,
"SemiAutoACU": 1,
"GEval": 5,
"AutoQAPyramid": 1,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 1,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.9286029058931803,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.9286029058931803
}
} |
000642916e3a6c33411c617cf2f3c134a206fba8 | Tim Sherwood will welcome Gary Gardner back into his first team squad during pre-season to assess closely whether the 22-year-old can cut it for Aston Villa in the Premier League. Gardner has enjoyed a successful loan spell at Nottingham Forest and scored a superb free-kick in front of the Villa manager during the defeat to Watford at the City Ground. Sherwood is keen to see Gardner, a former England Under-21 player, train day-to-day before making up his mind and he has spoken previously about his desire for homegrown players to make an impact at the club. Gary Gardner (left) will report to Aston Villa for pre-season training to be assessed by Tim Sherwood . The Villa boss has inspired the club since being appointed and helped lead them to an FA Cup final . Gardner, born in Solihull, joined Villa's academy aged seven and last year was rewarded with a new contract that expires in June 2016 despite suffering serious knee injuries. 'I will go back to Villa in the summer and we will see what happens,' he said. 'When I am back there in training, it will be my chance to impress. Tim Sherwood will not have seen much of me in training, because I have not been there. 'Villa are the main club, I have been there since I was seven and it is the team I support. But Forest have been fantastic to me. It is definitely the second team in my heart. 'If I was made available for loan again next season, if it does not work out at Villa, Forest would be top of my list, definitely. It is the best loan move I have had.' Gardner scored a stunning free-kick against Watford with Sherwood in attendance at the City Ground . | Gary Gardner confirms he'll report to Aston Villa for pre-season training . The 22-year-old is out on loan at Championship side Nottingham Forest . Tim Sherwood is keen to asses Gardner ahead of next season . The midfielder would prefer a move back to Forest if Villa doesn't wok out . CLICK HERE for all the latest Aston Villa news . | [
"Who is keen? Tim Sherwood",
"What is someone keen to do? asses Gardner ahead of next season",
"Who confirms something? Gary Gardner",
"What does someone confirm? he 'll report to Aston Villa",
"Who will report somewhere? Gary Gardner",
"Where will someone report? to Aston Villa",
"Why will someone report somewhere? for pre - season training",
"Who is out? The 22 - year - old",
"Why is someone out? on loan",
"Where is someone out? at Championship side Nottingham Forest",
"Who wants to assess something? Tim Sherwood",
"Who does someone want to assess? Gardner",
"When does someone want to assess someone? ahead of next season",
"Who would prefer something? The midfielder",
"What would someone prefer? a move back to Forest if Villa does n't wok out",
"Where can someone click something? HERE",
"Why can someone click something? for all the latest Aston Villa news"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
00110802bc6eae0e8e4d3d22e27f458f41be2b22 | For years medical experts have warned about the dangers of too much salt, but now new research is questioning conventional wisdom and warning instead of the dangers of too little salt . For years medical experts have warned about the dangers of too much salt, but new research is now questioning conventional wisdom and warning instead of the dangers of too little salt. Both federal government regulations and the American Heart Association have for decades warned that excess salt contributes to the deaths of tens of thousands of Americans each year. As the federal government prepares its influential Dietary Guidelines for 2015, some scientists are now saying that the average American salt consumption rate carries no risk. The guidelines currently dictate the people should limit their intake to 2,300 milligrams, with an even stricter 1,500 milligram limit for African Americans and people over 50. In February the Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee recommended keeping the larger limit, although it withdrew support for the stricter limit for African Americans and people over 50, reports The Washington Post. 'There is no longer any valid basis for the current salt guidelines,' said Andrew Mente, a professor at McMaster University in Ontario and one of the researchers involved in a major study published last year by the New England Journal of Medicine. 'So why are we still scaring people about salt?' While experts on both sides agree that eating too much salt - especially for people with high blood pressure - can be dangerous there is much disagreement over what constitutes too much. The average American ingests about 3,500 milligrams of salt per day - the amount of sodium in a teaspoon of salt - and so under the current dietary guidelines Americans are indeed endangering themselves. Even within the American Heart Association, one of the organizations promoting the current salt limits, there is disagreement with at least one former president claiming that there is no evidence that reducing salt consumption can lower blood pressure . Salt skeptics however believe most Americans are fine. In their view, a typical healthy person can consume as much as 6,000 milligrams per day without significantly raising health risks. The skeptics also warn of the dangers of consuming too little - they say that below 3,000 milligrams also raises health risks. The PURE study published last August by the New England Journal of Medicine found that people who conform to the recommended limits (2,300 milligrams) actually have more heart trouble. They found that low sodium may stimulate the production of renin, a hormone that may have harmful effects on blood vessels. Even within the American Heart Association, one of the organizations promoting the current salt limits, there is disagreement. 'The totality of the evidence strongly suggests that Americans should be lowering their sodium intake,' said Elliott Antman, the president of the American Heart Association. 'Everyone agrees that current sodium intake is too high.' But Suzanne Oparil, a former president of the American Heart Association, told the Post that there is no evidence that reducing salt consumption can lower blood pressure. A spokesperson for the Department of Health and Human Services has said that the federal guidelines are considering comments from the public and the advice of its science panel. | Current federal government guidelines dictate the people should limit their salt intake to 2,300 milligrams . Scientists now believe a typical healthy person can consume as much as 6,000 milligrams per day without significantly raising health risks . The same skeptics also warn of the health risks associated with consuming less than 3,000 milligrams . Average American ingests about 3,500 milligrams of salt per day . | [
"Who should limit something? the people",
"What should someone limit? their salt intake",
"What should someone limit something to? 2,300 milligrams",
"Who warns of something? The same skeptics",
"What does someone warn of? the health risks associated with consuming less than 3,000 milligrams",
"What is associated with something? health risks",
"What is something associated with? consuming less than 3,000 milligrams",
"What dictates someone do something? federal government guidelines",
"Who does something dictate? the people",
"What does something dictate someone do? limit their salt intake to 2,300 milligrams",
"Who believes something? Scientists",
"When does someone believe something? now",
"What does someone believe? a typical healthy person can consume as much as 6,000 milligrams per day without significantly raising health risks",
"Who can consume something? a typical healthy person",
"What can someone consume? as much as 6,000 milligrams",
"When can someone consume something? per day",
"How can someone consume something? without significantly raising health risks",
"What might someone consume? less than 3,000 milligrams"
] | {
"bart": [
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0
],
"pegasus": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1
],
"brio": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0
],
"brio-ext": [
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0
],
"matchsum": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0
],
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"llama-3-8b-instruct": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0
],
"GPT4": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0
],
"llama-3-70b-instruct": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0
],
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0
]
} | {
"bart": "Federal government regulations and the American Heart Association have for decades warned that excess salt contributes to the deaths of tens of thousands of Americans each year. As the federal government prepares its influential Dietary Guidelines for 2015, some scientists are now saying that the average American salt consumption rate carries no risk. 'There is no longer any valid basis for the current salt guidelines,' said Andrew Mente, a professor at McMaster University in Ontario.",
"pegasus": "Federal government regulations and the American Heart Association have for decades warned that excess salt contributes to the deaths of tens of thousands of Americans each year. As the federal government prepares its influential Dietary Guidelines for 2015, some scientists are now saying that the average American salt consumption rate carries no risk. The guidelines currently dictate the people should limit their intake to 2,300 milligrams, with an even stricter 1,500 milligram limit for African Americans and people over 50.",
"brio": "Federal government regulations and the American Heart Association have for decades warned that excess salt contributes to the deaths of tens of thousands of Americans each year. As the federal government prepares its influential Dietary Guidelines for 2015, some scientists are now saying that the average American salt consumption rate carries no risk. The guidelines currently dictate the people should limit their intake to 2,300 milligrams of salt per day. Salt skeptics however believe most Americans are fine.",
"brio-ext": "Both federal government regulations and the American Heart Association have for decades warned that excess salt contributes to the deaths of tens of thousands of Americans each year. As the federal government prepares its influential Dietary Guidelines for 2015, some scientists are now saying that the average American salt consumption rate carries no risk.",
"matchsum": "Both federal government regulations and the American Heart Association have for decades warned that excess salt contributes to the deaths of tens of thousands of Americans each year. As the federal government prepares its influential Dietary Guidelines for 2015, some scientists are now saying that the average American salt consumption rate carries no risk. The guidelines currently dictate the people should limit their intake to 2,300 milligrams, with an even stricter 1,500 milligram limit for African Americans and people over 50.",
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": "New research is questioning the dangers of too much salt and warning instead of the dangers of too little salt . The average American ingests about 3,500 milligrams of salt per day, which is above the current dietary guidelines of 2,300 milligrams . Some experts believe that a typical healthy person can consume as much as 6,000 milligrams per day without significantly raising health risks, while others warn of the dangers of consuming too little - below 3,000 milligrams.",
"llama-3-8b-instruct": " New research is questioning the conventional wisdom that too much salt is bad for health, and instead warning of the dangers of too little salt . The average American consumes around 3,500 milligrams of salt per day, which is above the recommended limit of 2,300 milligrams, but some experts believe this amount is not harmful . The debate is ongoing, with some experts warning of the dangers of consuming too little salt, while others argue that the current guidelines are still too strict. ",
"GPT4": "New research challenges the long-standing warnings about the dangers of high salt intake, suggesting that the average American's salt consumption does not pose a risk and that too little salt may actually be harmful. The Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee has recommended maintaining the current salt intake limit of 2,300 milligrams but has withdrawn the stricter limit for African Americans and those over 50, amidst debates within the scientific community and organizations like the American Heart Association. Some studies, including the PURE study, indicate that adhering to the recommended salt limits could lead to more heart problems, highlighting the controversy and lack of consensus on the optimal amount of salt consumption.",
"llama-3-70b-instruct": " New research is questioning the conventional wisdom that too much salt is bad for you, with some scientists warning of the dangers of too little salt . The average American consumes 3,500 milligrams of salt per day, which is above the recommended limit of 2,300 milligrams . Some experts believe that a healthy person can consume up to 6,000 milligrams of salt per day without raising health risks, while others argue that reducing salt consumption can lower blood pressure .",
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": "New research is questioning the dangers of too much salt and warning instead of the dangers of too little salt . The average American ingests about 3,500 milligrams of salt per day, and so under the current dietary guidelines Americans are endangering themselves . The PURE study published last August by the New England Journal of Medicine found that people who conform to the recommended limits (2,300 milligrams) actually have more heart trouble."
} | {
"bart": {
"QAPyramid": 0.2222222222222222,
"nQAPyramid": 0.21342251551385727,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9604013198123578,
"R1_recall": 0.3181818181818182,
"R1_f1": 0.29787234042553196,
"R2_recall": 0.03076923076923077,
"R2_f1": 0.02877697841726619,
"RL_recall": 0.16666666666666666,
"RL_f1": 0.15602836879432622,
"ACU": 0,
"nACU": 0,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8303451538085938,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8432664275169373,
"BARTScore": -3.5031495094299316,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.21472483621910216,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.2760354284093612,
"AutoACU_recall": 0,
"AutoACU_f1": 0,
"METEOR": 0.19237985279261074,
"ChrF": 31.5156239405413,
"SemiAutoACU": 0,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.125,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.16666666666666666,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.12005016497654472,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.16006688663539295
},
"pegasus": {
"QAPyramid": 0.5,
"nQAPyramid": 0.47657652125001254,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9531530425000251,
"R1_recall": 0.48484848484848486,
"R1_f1": 0.4324324324324324,
"R2_recall": 0.2,
"R2_f1": 0.17808219178082194,
"RL_recall": 0.25757575757575757,
"RL_f1": 0.22972972972972974,
"ACU": 0.4444444477558136,
"nACU": 0.38486233353614807,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8857019543647766,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8835321664810181,
"BARTScore": -2.9881250858306885,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.4355964409187436,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.48492330354120994,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.4,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.15999999996800002,
"METEOR": 0.27752622312594544,
"ChrF": 42.714180947987394,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.4444444444444444,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.4375,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.5,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.41700445609376097,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.47657652125001254
},
"brio": {
"QAPyramid": 0.5,
"nQAPyramid": 0.4789895617850049,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9579791235700098,
"R1_recall": 0.5,
"R1_f1": 0.45517241379310347,
"R2_recall": 0.24615384615384617,
"R2_f1": 0.22377622377622378,
"RL_recall": 0.2727272727272727,
"RL_f1": 0.2482758620689655,
"ACU": 0.4444444477558136,
"nACU": 0.39073798060417175,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8893523812294006,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.889523983001709,
"BARTScore": -2.8831028938293457,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.44749185517430307,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.4844949323063095,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.4,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.17391304344423442,
"METEOR": 0.37026665002142517,
"ChrF": 44.29435273904573,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.4444444444444444,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.5,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.5,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.4789895617850049,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.4789895617850049
},
"brio-ext": {
"QAPyramid": 0.3333333333333333,
"nQAPyramid": 0.3333333333333333,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 1,
"R1_recall": 0.2878787878787879,
"R1_f1": 0.3166666666666667,
"R2_recall": 0.03076923076923077,
"R2_f1": 0.03389830508474577,
"RL_recall": 0.16666666666666666,
"RL_f1": 0.18333333333333332,
"ACU": 0,
"nACU": 0,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8313124179840088,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8521941900253296,
"BARTScore": -3.4551968574523926,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.1498342352831969,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.11606032225406832,
"AutoACU_recall": 0,
"AutoACU_f1": 0,
"METEOR": 0.1792036713390639,
"ChrF": 28.83726434375099,
"SemiAutoACU": 0,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.25,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.2777777777777778,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.25,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.2777777777777778
},
"matchsum": {
"QAPyramid": 0.5,
"nQAPyramid": 0.475374563448467,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.950749126896934,
"R1_recall": 0.48484848484848486,
"R1_f1": 0.42953020134228187,
"R2_recall": 0.2,
"R2_f1": 0.17687074829931973,
"RL_recall": 0.25757575757575757,
"RL_f1": 0.22818791946308725,
"ACU": 0.4444444477558136,
"nACU": 0.3819577097892761,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8865102529525757,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8842800259590149,
"BARTScore": -2.963714599609375,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.4373452877625823,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.48410418308857417,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.4,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.1904761904399093,
"METEOR": 0.2771894194571033,
"ChrF": 42.67272151454594,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.4444444444444444,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.4375,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.4444444444444444,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.41595274301740864,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.4225551675097484
},
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": {
"QAPyramid": 0.8888888888888888,
"nQAPyramid": 0.8536900620554291,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9604013198123578,
"R1_recall": 0.696969696969697,
"R1_f1": 0.6301369863013698,
"R2_recall": 0.5230769230769231,
"R2_f1": 0.4722222222222223,
"RL_recall": 0.48484848484848486,
"RL_f1": 0.4383561643835617,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.9268000721931458,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.9235568642616272,
"BARTScore": -1.9332377910614014,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.7598317638039589,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.6119499936078986,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.6,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.6857142856653061,
"METEOR": 0.5188392275502655,
"ChrF": 59.09878656255334,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.4444444444444444,
"GEval": 5,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.5,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.6470588235294118,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.4802006599061789,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.6214361481138786
},
"llama-3-8b-instruct": {
"QAPyramid": 0.5,
"nQAPyramid": 0.47178684798825005,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9435736959765001,
"R1_recall": 0.4090909090909091,
"R1_f1": 0.3624161073825503,
"R2_recall": 0.16923076923076924,
"R2_f1": 0.14965986394557826,
"RL_recall": 0.22727272727272727,
"RL_f1": 0.20134228187919462,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8986303806304932,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8928624987602234,
"BARTScore": -2.908494234085083,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.43727348782122133,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.4075710740354326,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.4,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.42553191484382075,
"METEOR": 0.2429420628022975,
"ChrF": 39.666087277266385,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.1111111111111111,
"GEval": 4,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.25,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.3333333333333333,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.23589342399412502,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.3145245653255
},
"GPT4": {
"QAPyramid": 0.3888888888888889,
"nQAPyramid": 0.3401733315225894,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.8747314239152298,
"R1_recall": 0.3333333333333333,
"R1_f1": 0.24581005586592178,
"R2_recall": 0.07692307692307693,
"R2_f1": 0.05649717514124294,
"RL_recall": 0.18181818181818182,
"RL_f1": 0.1340782122905028,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8678277134895325,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8630372881889343,
"BARTScore": -3.3454036712646484,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.39392475443892183,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.2336097817040152,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.2,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.0999999999625,
"METEOR": 0.17438891850059146,
"ChrF": 35.68040699920134,
"SemiAutoACU": 0,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.1875,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.3333333333333333,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.1640121419841056,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.2915771413050766
},
"llama-3-70b-instruct": {
"QAPyramid": 0.7222222222222222,
"nQAPyramid": 0.6918738114672293,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9579791235700098,
"R1_recall": 0.5909090909090909,
"R1_f1": 0.5342465753424658,
"R2_recall": 0.3076923076923077,
"R2_f1": 0.2777777777777778,
"RL_recall": 0.3181818181818182,
"RL_f1": 0.2876712328767123,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.9157089591026306,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.9139436483383179,
"BARTScore": -2.578629732131958,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.6548621505498886,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.53961370192701,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.6,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.6857142856653061,
"METEOR": 0.3758758883171621,
"ChrF": 46.089816118550395,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.3333333333333333,
"GEval": 3,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.375,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.5555555555555556,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.3592421713387537,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.532210624205561
},
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": {
"QAPyramid": 0.3888888888888889,
"nQAPyramid": 0.37823507443413545,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9726044771163483,
"R1_recall": 0.3939393939393939,
"R1_f1": 0.37410071942446044,
"R2_recall": 0.2,
"R2_f1": 0.18978102189781024,
"RL_recall": 0.24242424242424243,
"RL_f1": 0.2302158273381295,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8914569020271301,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8829615116119385,
"BARTScore": -2.9196534156799316,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.37408320121467115,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.3312096926383674,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.4,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.2857142856683674,
"METEOR": 0.27386503067484663,
"ChrF": 37.14675728640457,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.1111111111111111,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.125,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.2222222222222222,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.12157555963954354,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.2161343282480774
}
} |
00119229166ae09a6ef25c0e10b101ef9eb9cca3 | It is the smallest computer in the world - and 150 of them can fit in a thimble. Called the Michigan Micro Mote, to tiny technology is a complete computer system. Its inventors say it can act as a smart sensor, and give everyday objects computing capabilities. The Michigan Micro Mote is the smallest computer in the world, measuring less than 2mm across. The Michigan Micro Mote contains solar cells that power the battery with ambient light, including indoor rooms with no natural sunlight, allowing the computers to run perpetually. This line of 'smart dust' devices includes computers equipped with imagers (with motion detection), temperature sensors, and pressure sensors. By strobing light at a high frequency, the operator is able to send information to the computer. Once the Micro Mote processes the data, it is able to send the information to a central computer via conventional radio frequencies. The Michigan Micro Mote is the first complete, operational computer system measuring as small as two millimeters across. 'To be 'complete,' a computer system must have an input of data, the ability to process that data - meaning process and store it, make decisions about what to do next – and ultimately, the ability to output the data.' Professor David Blaauw explained. 'The sensors are the input and the radios are the output. The other key to being a complete computer is the ability to supply its own power.' The Michigan Micro Mote contains solar cells that power the battery with ambient light, including indoor rooms with no natural sunlight, allowing the computers to run perpetually. This line of 'smart dust' devices includes computers equipped with imagers (with motion detection), temperature sensors, and pressure sensors. They are the culmination of work initiated by Blaauw and Sylvester on very low-power processing for millimeter-scale systems. A key breakthrough in the size/power matchup came with the Phoenix processor in 2008. The Phoenix processor is miniscule at 915 x 915µm2, and boasts ultra-low operating voltage and a unique standby mode that results in an average power consumption of only 500pW. (Consider that 1pW is the average power consumption of a single human cell.) Blaauw explained why Phoenix's extreme energy efficiency is so important: 'As you shrink down in size, the percentage of the system tends to be dominated by the battery. 'It's actually not hard to make chips small, but it is hard to make them low power. 'We could have very small chips, but we'd still end up with really large batteries.' This line of 'smart dust' devices includes computers equipped with imagers (with motion detection), temperature sensors, and pressure sensors. One key application for this line of smart sensors lies in personal security and information, its inventors say. The solar system allows the computer to work under indoor lights without ever having to be charged. 'With a 1mm2 solar cell producing 20nW, the device can harvest enough energy under ambient light to run perpetually,' the team say. The device's standby power consumption is 2nA. That's about a million times less power than the average mobile phone consumes while on standby, or the comparative difference between the thickness of a sheet of paper and the length of a football field. There are currently three different systems in the M3 family, focusing on several different applications: sensing temperature, pressure, and taking images. 'Down the road we want these sensors to be able to talk to one another,' says Blaauw, 'and we're currently working to extend their range to about 20m.' The working computer is smaller than a grain of rice programmed and charged via light and could be used for a variety of medical and industrial purposes. One key application for this line of smart sensors lies in personal security and information. Numerous specks of technology could be discretely placed to invisibly monitor a home, business, or personal device. 'We found that a lot of people were very interested in these devices, and that's why we went with the modular or stacked approach.' Blaauw explained. 'It's the key aspect of our design. If you need a different sensing modality you take out one sensor and replace it with another - like mix and match tinker toys.' | Michigan Micro Mote is a complete computer system less that 5mm across . Contains solar cells that power the battery with ambient light . Can be equipped with cameras, temperature and pressure sensors . | [
"What does something contain? solar cells",
"Why does something contain something? power the battery",
"What powers something? solar cells",
"What does something power? the battery",
"How does something power something? with ambient light",
"What is a complete computer system? Michigan Micro Mote",
"What can something be equipped with? cameras"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
0013aa16650fbcfbe6edb16ac614ad174cb5d1cf | Britons heading to Europe on holiday are facing the nightmare of arriving at their destination and not being able to hire a car, thanks to a controversial driving licence shake-up. The Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency (DVLA) is scrapping the paper counterpart that accompanies all UK plastic photocard licences. Information about penalty points for traffic violations such as speeding will be held only on the DVLA’s database, and will have to be checked online, by phone or by post. But motoring groups fear the switch to a fully online system will make it more difficult for car hire firms which want to check a motorist’s details. Scroll down for video . Changes: Britons heading to Europe on holiday are facing the nightmare of arriving at their destination and not being able to hire a car, thanks to a controversial driving licence (file picture) shake-up . Concerns: Motoring groups fear the switch to a fully online system will make it more difficult for car hire firms which want to check a motorist’s details . From June 8, holidaymakers heading abroad will have to log on to the DVLA website the day before and put in their driving licence number to obtain a special code to give to their car hire company when they arrive at the desk. But fears are growing that the ‘muddled’ introduction of the new rules will mean people could be turned away because many car hire firms abroad will still insist on examining the paper document to check for endorsements or bans. Furthermore, the passcode is valid for only 72 hours, meaning anyone hiring a car in the second week of their trip faces having to find an internet cafe or pay expensive roaming charges. Mark Bower, of the car hire insurance website MoneyMaxim, said holidaymakers could endure major problems at car hire desks across Europe. He added: ‘Most people are simply unaware that these changes are on the way – and it is not just renters. ‘I spoke to one big car hire firm in Portugal this week and they knew nothing of the changes. Six weeks away from implementation, the whole thing is very muddled. ‘It is another thing you have to remember to do just before departure. Or you can do it at the desk with your smartphone if you can remember the website address, don’t mind the data roaming charges, can remember your national insurance number and are impervious to the long queue developing behind you.’ The Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency (DVLA) is scrapping the paper counterpart that accompanies all UK plastic photocard licences (file picture) Mr Bower also said unscrupulous firms might use the issue as ‘another excuse’ to persuade people to pay for extra insurance. Motorists will also be able to download their driving history as a printable PDF file, although it is unclear whether all car hire firms will accept that, or how drivers without access to a computer will cope. The DVLA insists the changes have been widely publicised. But consumers booking car hire for holidays after June have not been warned the new rules are being introduced. The terms and conditions of most car hire firms still explicitly state that paper counterparts must be produced. The British Vehicle Rental and Leasing Association, which represents the industry, says UK hirers unaware of the rule change will be treated in the same way as those who currently turn up without both parts of the licence. The DVLA said the system, called Share Driving Licence, would be ready in time for June 8. A spokesman said: ‘There is up-to-date information on the website and we are working closely with the industry to ensure that their systems and processes are ready for the changes.’ The two-part licence was introduced in 1998 but many drivers found it inconvenient. From June 8, paper counterparts will be invalid and should be destroyed. Motorists with old-style paper driving licences from before 1998 can continue to use them. | Britons finding they cannot pick up hire cars after driving licence change . DVLA is scrapping the paper counterpart that accompanies UK licences . Information about penalty points will be held on the DVLA's database . Fears foreign car hire firms will not be able to check motorists' details . | [
"Who is finding something? Britons",
"What is someone finding? they can not pick up hire cars",
"Who cannot pick something up? Britons",
"What can someone not pick up? hire cars",
"When can someone not pick something up? after driving licence change",
"Who cannot hire something? Britons",
"What can someone not hire? cars",
"When can someone not hire something? after driving licence change",
"What is scrapping something? DVLA",
"What is something scrapping? the paper counterpart that accompanies UK licences",
"What accompanies something? the paper counterpart",
"What does something accompany? UK licences",
"What will be held somewhere? Information about penalty points",
"Where will something be held? on the DVLA 's database",
"What might not be able to do something? foreign car hire firms",
"What might something not be able to do? check motorists ' details",
"Who cannot check something? foreign car hire firms",
"What can someone not check? motorists ' details"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
00180b7ce54794a52766d795506a94071f7c055b | You might have seen fantastic images of the sun before, or even clips showing its activity - but you’ve never seen anything like this. An incredible video has stitched together footage from a Nasa spacecraft, revealed the beauty of the solar surface as it bursts with energy. Taken over five years, the footage includes plasma raining down on the sun, an extreme solar eruption and even a comet breezing through the sun’s atmosphere. Scroll down for video . Filmmaker Michael König from Cologne, Germany has created an amazing video showing solar activity (shown). It was made by stitching together footage from Nasa's Solar Dynamics Observatory over five years . The movie, called Sun, was created by filmmaker Michael König from Cologne, Germany. It uses footage recorded by Nasa’s Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) spacecraft between 2011 and 2015. ‘This montage features excerpts of 4K full-disk pictures in extreme ultraviolet channels,’ explained Mr König, and it ‘offers a glance at spicules, solar flares, filaments and an overview of the sun’s atmosphere.’ Highlights of the video include large, bright tendrils extending outward from the sun’s surface and occasionally crashing down again - known as solar prominences. Other fantastic sections show bright, active regions on the sun’s surface as magnetic fields send it into turmoil. Transits of the moon, Venus and Earth across the sun, as observed from the SDO, are also seen, while towards the end of the video Comet Lovejoy can be seen passing the sun in December 2011. Another incredible part of the video shows ‘coronal rain’ streaming down onto the sun from a loop of material above the sun’s surface. Coronal rain is formed when hot plasma in the corona - the sun’s atmosphere - cools and condenses in strong magnetic fields. The plasma is attracted to the magnetic fields and condenses, slowly falling back to the solar surface over several hours. Nasa's Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO), illustrated below, was launched on 11 February 2010 and has observed the sun ever since. It's goal is to understand how exactly the sun interacts with the environment around Earth. By watching the sun in different wavelengths - and therefore different temperatures - scientists can watch how material courses through the corona, which holds clues to what causes eruptions on the sun, what heats the sun's atmosphere up to 1,000 times hotter than its surface, and why the sun's magnetic fields are constantly on the move. SDO also measures fluctuations in the sun's extreme ultraviolet output, which provides the majority of energy for heating Earth's upper atmosphere. Five years into its mission, SDO continues to send back tantalizing imagery to incite scientists' curiosity. For example, in late 2014, SDO captured imagery of the largest sun spots seen since 1995 as well as a torrent of intense solar flares. Another incredible part of the video shows ‘coronal rain’ (pictured) streaming down onto the sun from a loop of material above the sun’s surface. Coronal rain is formed when hot plasma in the corona - the sun’s atmosphere - condenses and falls back to the surface . Elsewhere, solar flares and coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are seen erupting on the sun’s surface, sending out huge amounts of energy. CMEs are the huge waves of material that are seen in images of the sun, and they can pose a threat to satellites in Earth orbit. Solar flares are flashes of energy on the surface of the sun, which are sometimes associated with CMEs - although their connection is not well understood. The video, though, is a reminder of just how beautiful, powerful and active our solar system’s only star can be. By watching the sun in different wavelengths - and therefore different temperatures - scientists can watch how material courses through the corona, which holds clues to what causes eruptions on the sun, what heats the sun's atmosphere up to 1,000 times hotter than its surface . | Filmmaker Michael König from Cologne, Germany has created an amazing video showing solar activity . It was made by stitching together footage from Nasa's Solar Dynamics Observatory over five years . The footage includes loops of 'coronal rain' showering the surface of the sun . Transits of the moon, Venus and Earth are also seen - and a comet breezes through the outer solar atmosphere . | [
"What is seen? Transits of the moon , Venus and Earth",
"What breezes somewhere? a comet",
"Where does something breeze? through the outer solar atmosphere",
"Who created something? Germany",
"What did someone create? an amazing video",
"What is showing something? an amazing video",
"What is something showing? solar activity",
"What was made? It",
"How was something made? by stitching together footage from Nasa 's Solar Dynamics Observatory",
"When was something made? over five years",
"What includes something? The footage",
"What does something include? loops of ' coronal rain ' showering the surface of the sun",
"What showered something? coronal rain",
"What did something shower? the surface of the sun"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
001ebaa80dca4a65adf2178b132113cb9e3d5431 | Justin Rose will try to take a leaf out of Rory McIlroy's book after kickstarting his season with his share of second place in the Masters. Rose arrived at Augusta National having missed the cut in three of his previous five tournaments on the PGA Tour, but left with renewed enthusiasm and a 14-under-par total which has only been bettered six times in Masters history. 'I'm really excited about the rest of the year now. It's a good momentum starter for me,' said Rose, who was looking to become the first European player to win the US Open and Masters. Justin Rose was unable to take victory at the Masters, despite carding 14-under-par for the tournament . Rose believes that his finish of second at Augusta can boost his season with some big events ahead . Rose wants to follow the lead of Rory McIlroy, who had a relentless winning streak in the summer of 2014 . 'I tried to really tell myself that this year for me is going to be about April to September when the big tournaments come around and that's when I want to play well. 'You look at Rory's year last year, it was all about how he played in the summer (winning the Open, Bridgestone Invitational and US PGA in the space of four weeks). I was trying to keep telling myself it's a long year. Very happy it turned around this week in a major championship. 'The thing that was most important for me this week was the fact that I have not been in contention and I haven't had a lot of experience this year or positive vibes on which to draw. 'I was really pleased at how comfortable I felt in that situation, last group in the Masters on Sunday. I think that's when you learn a lot about yourself and that makes me very hungry to get there again very soon.' Rose began the final round four shots behind Spieth and closed to within three on three separate occasions on the front nine, but was never able to get any closer. 'There's two ways to look at it. You can think that 14 under par, I'll take that next year and I'll take that the year after and I'll take it the year after, so I have to take a lot of confidence from that,' he added. Rose had struggled to hit top form going into the Masters but now hopes to sustain his Augusta form . Rose (left) congratulates tournament winner Spieth and praised his performance level for the week . 'But you've got to play it on the day, too. I felt like there were a few moments out there where I could have done better and I'll learn on that and think about that. 'Jordan didn't really open the door and I didn't really expect him to. Really the one time on the back nine where it got interesting for me was the 16th hole. I felt that if I make my birdie putt and Jordan misses for par, it's a two-shot swing and I'm two back with two to play. But my putt just slid by and he made a great eight- footer to there to keep his momentum as he did all day, really.' | Justin Rose finished joint runner-up at the Masters 2015 on 14-under-par . Rose's final total has only been bettered six times at the the Masters . Rose hopes to build on his display and take some big titles across the year . CLICK HERE for all the latest news and reaction following the Masters . | [
"Who finished as something? Justin Rose",
"What did someone finish as? joint runner - up",
"Where did someone finish as something? at the Masters 2015",
"How did someone finish as something? on 14 - under - par",
"What was bettered? Rose 's final total",
"How was something bettered? six times",
"Where was something bettered? at the the Masters",
"Who might build on something? Rose",
"What might someone build on? his display",
"Who might take something? Rose",
"What might someone take? some big titles",
"When might someone take something? across the year",
"Where might someone click? HERE",
"Why might someone click somewhere? for all the latest news and reaction following the Masters",
"What follows something? all the latest news and reaction",
"What does something follow? the Masters",
"Who hopes to do something? Rose",
"What does someone hope to do? build on his display and take some big titles across the year"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
00200e794fa41d3f7ce92cbf43e9fd4cd652bb09 | (CNN)James Best, best known for his portrayal of bumbling sheriff Rosco P. Coltrane on TV's "The Dukes of Hazzard," died Monday after a brief illness. He was 88. Best died in hospice in Hickory, North Carolina, of complications from pneumonia, said Steve Latshaw, a longtime friend and Hollywood colleague. Although he'd been a busy actor for decades in theater and in Hollywood, Best didn't become famous until 1979, when "The Dukes of Hazzard's" cornpone charms began beaming into millions of American homes almost every Friday night. For seven seasons, Best's Rosco P. Coltrane chased the moonshine-running Duke boys back and forth across the back roads of fictitious Hazzard County, Georgia, although his "hot pursuit" usually ended with him crashing his patrol car. Although Rosco was slow-witted and corrupt, Best gave him a childlike enthusiasm that got laughs and made him endearing. His character became known for his distinctive "kew-kew-kew" chuckle and for goofy catchphrases such as "cuff 'em and stuff 'em!" upon making an arrest. Among the most popular shows on TV in the early '80s, "The Dukes of Hazzard" ran until 1985 and spawned TV movies, an animated series and video games. Several of Best's "Hazzard" co-stars paid tribute to the late actor on social media. "I laughed and learned more from Jimmie in one hour than from anyone else in a whole year," co-star John Schneider, who played Bo Duke, said on Twitter. "Give Uncle Jesse my love when you see him dear friend." "Jimmy Best was the most constantly creative person I have ever known," said Ben Jones, who played mechanic Cooter on the show, in a Facebook post. "Every minute of his long life was spent acting, writing, producing, painting, teaching, fishing, or involved in another of his life's many passions." Born Jewel Guy on July 26, 1926, in Powderly, Kentucky, Best was orphaned at 3 and adopted by Armen and Essa Best, who renamed him James and raised him in rural Indiana. Best served in the Army during World War II before launching his acting career. In the 1950s and 1960s, he accumulated scores of credits, playing a range of colorful supporting characters in such TV shows as "The Twilight Zone," "Bonanza," "The Andy Griffith Show" and "Gunsmoke." He later appeared in a handful of Burt Reynolds' movies, including "Hooper" and "The End." But Best will always be best known for his "Hazzard" role, which lives on in reruns. "Jimmie was my teacher, mentor, close friend and collaborator for 26 years," Latshaw said. "I directed two of his feature films, including the recent 'Return of the Killer Shrews,' a sequel he co-wrote and was quite proud of as he had made the first one more than 50 years earlier." People we've lost in 2015 . CNN's Stella Chan contributed to this story. | James Best, who played the sheriff on "The Dukes of Hazzard," died Monday at 88 . "Hazzard" ran from 1979 to 1985 and was among the most popular shows on TV . | [
"Who played someone? James Best",
"Who did someone play? the sheriff",
"Where did someone play someone? on \" The Dukes of Hazzard , \"",
"Who died? James Best",
"When did someone die? Monday",
"When did something run on something? from 1979 to 1985",
"What ran sometime on something? Hazzard",
"What did something run on? TV",
"What was something among? the most popular shows on TV",
"What was among something? Hazzard"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
00217448b38d81a23db66ac362bee25056f58fab | Her neighbour’s leylandii hedge stands 40ft tall and, says Audrey Alexander, has left parts of her garden in deep shade. What’s more, it now seems likely to remain that way. Despite a 35-year fight to get the trees cut down to size, the council has ruled they can stay. It is the final defeat in a battle that involved two generations of Mrs Alexander’s family. It kicked off 35 years ago when Mrs Alexander’s aunt found her vegetable patch at the property would not grow anything worth eating because of the leylandii. A row between neighbours over a 40ft high leylandii hedge (pictured) has finally come to and end after 35 years . The battle between the neighbouring properties started in 1980 when the owner planted a vegetable patch which withered and died in the shade of her neighbour's massive hedge . Then, 23 years ago, single mother Mrs Alexander bought the house and asked her neighbour Jeanette Robinson to trim the hedge. She claims Mrs Robinson refused and declared: ‘I would rather move than touch these trees.’ The dispute rumbled on, with Mrs Alexander, 54, claiming that the trees knocked £20,000 off the value of her property. She sensed an opportunity, however, with the passing of the High Hedge Act in Scotland in 2013 which allows local authorities to take action in such cases. Stirling Council has finally ruled that the hedge can stay, despite claims it has knocked £20,000 off the value of neighbour Audrey Alexander's house (pictured) The situation came to a head in 2008, when a 65ft section of hedge is said to have fallen and demolished a neighbour's garden shed . Audrey Alexander (pictured) also claims other neighbours have had to move their children from their bedrooms at night for fear of the falling branches . But her council has ruled that Mrs Robinson can keep the hedge, although it has to be cut to 20ft. Mrs Alexander said the ruling made ‘no difference’. The High Hedge Act 2013 allows neighbours to complain to the council when a hedgerow blocks sunlight from reaching their garden. Complainants and the hedge's owner are encouraged to resolve the issue between themselves and councils should only be called in to help as a last resort. Because the effect the hedge has is not always clear, disputes can last for years before an agreement can be reached. The local authority can either issue a high hedge notice, which orders owners to cut the hedge back, or decide not to act. The local authority cannot make any orders about the roots of the hedge. She added: ‘The whole situation is appalling – the legislation is about giving people the right to sunlight. ‘It’s a disgrace and I feel extremely let down.’ The neighbour refused to comment. Mrs Alexander’s only option is the courts which she cannot afford to do. Over the years she had used the mediation services of Stirling District Council to try to resolve the issue. The situation came to a head in 2008, when she claims a 65ft section of hedge fell, demolishing a neighbour’s garden shed. Following the introduction of the High Hedge Act, Stirling Council found in her favour but the neighbour appealed and won the 20ft ruling. Dr Colin Watson, of Scothedge, a group which demands the end of ‘high hedge tyranny’, said that the council’s decision was ‘pretty crazy’. A council spokesman said the decision was made ‘after carrying out a site inspection and considering all the evidence’. Mrs Alexander said her aunt, now 87, had moved to France to enjoy ‘sunshine and gardening’. Ms Alexander called in Stirling District Council to try to solve the quarrel, but no solution could be found and the feud continued . The council ruled that the hedge should be cut to about 20ft, a height which Ms Alexander claims will still block most of her sunlight . | Audrey Alexander wanted her neighbours to chop down their huge hedge . She claims the 40ft leylandii was blocking sunlight from reaching her home . Feud started in 1980 when it blocked light from reaching a vegetable patch . Council finally rules that the hedge can stay - but must be cut back to 20ft . | [
"Who wanted someone to do something? Audrey Alexander",
"Who did someone want to do something? her neighbours",
"What did someone want someone to do? chop down their huge hedge",
"Who might chop something? neighbours",
"What might someone chop? huge hedge",
"Who claims something? She",
"What does someone claim? the 40 ft leylandii was blocking sunlight from reaching her home",
"What could not reach something? sunlight",
"What could something not reach? her home",
"What blocked something? it",
"What was blocked by something? light",
"Where was something blocked from? reaching a vegetable patch",
"What couldn't reach something? light",
"What couldn't something reach? a vegetable patch",
"Who rules something? Council",
"What does someone rule? that the hedge can stay - but must be cut back to 20 ft",
"When does someone rule something? finally",
"What started? Feud",
"When did something start? in 1980"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
0021fe8d65bd0d6d76d5fefba2ac02f0c48a43f4 | (CNN)The attorney for a suburban New York cardiologist charged in what authorities say was a failed scheme to have another physician hurt or killed is calling the allegations against his client "completely unsubstantiated." Appearing Saturday morning on CNN's "New Day," Randy Zelin defended his client, Dr. Anthony Moschetto, who faces criminal solicitation, conspiracy, burglary, arson, criminal prescription sale and weapons charges in connection to what prosecutors called a plot to take out a rival doctor on Long Island. "None of anything in this case has any evidentiary value," Zelin told CNN's Christi Paul. "It doesn't matter what anyone says, he is presumed to be innocent." Moschetto,54, pleaded not guilty to all charges Wednesday. He was released after posting $2 million bond and surrendering his passport. Zelin said that his next move is to get Dr. Moshetto back to work. "He's got patients to see. This man, while he was in a detention cell, the only thing that he cared about were his patients. And amazingly, his patients were flooding the office with calls, making sure that he was OK," Zelin said. Two other men -- identified as James Chmela, 43, and James Kalamaras, 41 -- were named as accomplices, according to prosecutors. They pleaded not guilty in Nassau County District Court, according to authorities. Both were released on bail. A requests for comment from an attorney representing Chmela was not returned. It's unclear whether Kalamaras has retained an attorney. Police officers allegedly discovered approximately 100 weapons at Moschetto's home, including hand grenades, high-capacity magazines and knives. Many of the weapons were found in a hidden room behind a switch-activated bookshelf, according to prosecutors. The investigation began back in December, when undercover officers began buying heroin and oxycodone pills from Moschetto in what was initially a routine investigation into the sale of prescription drugs, officials said. During the course of the undercover operation, however, Moschetto also sold the officers two semiautomatic assault weapons as well as ammunition, prosecutors said. Moschetto allegedly told officers during one buy that he needed dynamite to "blow up a building." He later said he no longer needed the dynamite because a friend was setting fire to the building instead. Kalamaras and Chmela are believed to have taken part in the arson, according to prosecutors. "The fire damaged but did not destroy the office of another cardiologist whose relationship with Dr. Moschetto had soured due to a professional dispute," according to the statement from the district attorney's office. Moschetto allegedly gave an informant and undercover detective blank prescriptions and cash for the assault and killing of the fellow cardiologist, according to prosecutors. He also requested that the rival's wife be assaulted if she happened to be present, authorities said. "He was willing to pay $5,000 to have him beaten and put in a hospital for a few months, and then he said he would pay $20,000 to have him killed," said Assistant District Attorney Anne Donnelly, according to CNN affiliate WCBS. | A lawyer for Dr. Anthony Moschetto says the charges against him are baseless . Moschetto, 54, was arrested for selling drugs and weapons, prosecutors say . Authorities allege Moschetto hired accomplices to burn down the practice of former associate . | [
"Who says something? A lawyer for Dr. Anthony Moschetto",
"What does someone say? the charges against him are baseless",
"Who was arrested? Moschetto",
"Why was someone arrested? for selling drugs and weapons",
"Who says something? prosecutors",
"What does someone say? Moschetto , 54 , was arrested for selling drugs and weapons",
"Who alleges something? Authorities",
"What does someone allege? Moschetto hired accomplices to burn down the practice of former associate",
"Who hired someone? Moschetto",
"Who did someone hire? accomplices",
"Why was someone hired? to burn down the practice of former associate",
"Who might have been selling something? Moschetto",
"What might someone have been selling? drugs and weapons",
"Who allegedly burned down something? accomplices",
"What did someone allegedly burn down? the practice of former associate",
"What are baseless? the charges against him"
] | {
"bart": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"pegasus": [
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1
],
"brio": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1
],
"brio-ext": [
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0
],
"matchsum": [
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0
],
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1
],
"llama-3-8b-instruct": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1
],
"GPT4": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1
],
"llama-3-70b-instruct": [
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1
],
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": [
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0
]
} | {
"bart": "Dr. Anthony Moschetto faces criminal solicitation, conspiracy, burglary, arson charges. His attorney calls the allegations against his client \"completely unsubstantiated\" Two other men -- identified as accomplices -- have pleaded not guilty and were released on bail. Police officers allegedly discovered approximately 100 weapons at his home.",
"pegasus": "Dr. Anthony Moschetto is accused of trying to have another doctor hurt or killed. His attorney says the allegations against his client are \"completely unsubstantiated\" Two other men are accused of being accomplices. Police officers allegedly found approximately 100 weapons at Moschetto's home.",
"brio": "Dr. Anthony Moschetto pleads not guilty to charges in a failed plot to have a rival doctor killed. His attorney says the allegations against his client are \"completely unsubstantiated\" \"He is presumed to be innocent,\" Randy Zelin says of his client, a cardiologist on Long Island. Two other men have pleaded not guilty.",
"brio-ext": "Appearing Saturday morning on CNN's \"New Day,\" Randy Zelin defended his client, Dr. Anthony Moschetto, who faces criminal solicitation, conspiracy, burglary, arson, criminal prescription sale and weapons charges in connection to what prosecutors called a plot to take out a rival doctor on Long Island. Moschetto,54, pleaded not guilty to all charges Wednesday. Zelin said that his next move is to get Dr. Moshetto back to work.",
"matchsum": "Appearing Saturday morning on CNN's \"New Day,\" Randy Zelin defended his client, Dr. Anthony Moschetto, who faces criminal solicitation, conspiracy, burglary, arson, criminal prescription sale and weapons charges in connection to what prosecutors called a plot to take out a rival doctor on Long Island. \"It doesn't matter what anyone says, he is presumed to be innocent.\" Moschetto,54, pleaded not guilty to all charges Wednesday.",
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": "The attorney for a New York cardiologist charged in a failed scheme to hurt or kill another physician is calling the allegations against his client \"completely unsubstantiated.\" Dr. Anthony Moschetto faces criminal solicitation, conspiracy, burglary, arson, criminal prescription sale and weapons charges in connection to the plot. Moschetto pleaded not guilty to all charges and was released after posting $2 million bond and surrendering his passport.",
"llama-3-8b-instruct": " Dr. Anthony Moschetto, a cardiologist from New York, has been charged with a failed plot to have another doctor hurt or killed . Moschetto's attorney, Randy Zelin, claims the allegations are \"completely unsubstantiated\" and that his client is presumed innocent . The investigation began as a routine investigation into the sale of prescription drugs, but uncovered a plot involving weapons, arson, and attempted murder. ",
"GPT4": "Dr. Anthony Moschetto, a cardiologist from suburban New York, has been charged with criminal solicitation, conspiracy, burglary, arson, criminal prescription sale, and weapons charges for allegedly plotting to harm or kill a rival doctor. His attorney, Randy Zelin, claims the allegations are unsubstantiated and is working to get Moschetto back to his medical practice, emphasizing his dedication to his patients. The investigation, which began with undercover officers buying drugs from Moschetto, uncovered a cache of about 100 weapons in his home and led to the arrest of two alleged accomplices, both of whom pleaded not guilty.",
"llama-3-70b-instruct": " Dr. Anthony Moschetto, a cardiologist from New York, has been charged with plotting to harm or kill a rival doctor . His attorney, Randy Zelin, claims the allegations are \"completely unsubstantiated\" and that Moschetto is presumed innocent . Moschetto has pleaded not guilty to all charges and has been released on $2 million bond, with his attorney working to get him back to work.",
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": "Dr. Anthony Moschetto, a cardiologist from Long Island, New York, is facing charges of criminal solicitation, conspiracy, burglary, arson, criminal prescription sale and weapons charges in connection to what prosecutors called a plot to take out a rival doctor . Moschetto,54, pleaded not guilty to all charges Wednesday and was released after posting $2 million bond and surrendering his passport . The investigation began back in December, when undercover officers began buying heroin and oxycodone pills from Moschetto in what was initially a routine investigation into the sale of prescription drugs, officials said."
} | {
"bart": {
"QAPyramid": 0.375,
"nQAPyramid": 0.35795754789247086,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.954553461046589,
"R1_recall": 0.2702702702702703,
"R1_f1": 0.24390243902439024,
"R2_recall": 0.05555555555555555,
"R2_f1": 0.049999999999999996,
"RL_recall": 0.1891891891891892,
"RL_f1": 0.17073170731707318,
"ACU": 0,
"nACU": 0,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8770726323127747,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8735436201095581,
"BARTScore": -3.7882978916168213,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.27265766870030866,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.3566368508359624,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.2222222222222222,
"AutoACU_f1": 0,
"METEOR": 0.19498720136518774,
"ChrF": 34.703862491712464,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.3333333333333333,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.25,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.3125,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.23863836526164725,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.29829795657705904
},
"pegasus": {
"QAPyramid": 0.375,
"nQAPyramid": 0.3663796943877711,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9770125183673897,
"R1_recall": 0.35135135135135137,
"R1_f1": 0.3209876543209877,
"R2_recall": 0.08333333333333333,
"R2_f1": 0.0759493670886076,
"RL_recall": 0.24324324324324326,
"RL_f1": 0.22222222222222227,
"ACU": 0.1111111119389534,
"nACU": 0.1036234125494957,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8894067406654358,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8894708752632141,
"BARTScore": -3.611443281173706,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.29129396711609196,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.35444385912140003,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.2222222222222222,
"AutoACU_f1": 0,
"METEOR": 0.19700431034482763,
"ChrF": 35.99794439501947,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.3333333333333333,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.25,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.25,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.24425312959184742,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.24425312959184742
},
"brio": {
"QAPyramid": 0.25,
"nQAPyramid": 0.23225072678468187,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9290029071387275,
"R1_recall": 0.35135135135135137,
"R1_f1": 0.28888888888888886,
"R2_recall": 0.08333333333333333,
"R2_f1": 0.06818181818181819,
"RL_recall": 0.24324324324324326,
"RL_f1": 0.19999999999999998,
"ACU": 0.3333333432674408,
"nACU": 0.26725754141807556,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8706774711608887,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8670095801353455,
"BARTScore": -3.639871835708618,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.28021218291334143,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.3228416509745229,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.2222222222222222,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.12903225802330903,
"METEOR": 0.21814043487824242,
"ChrF": 30.064267023289993,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.3333333333333333,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.25,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.25,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.23225072678468187,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.23225072678468187
},
"brio-ext": {
"QAPyramid": 0.25,
"nQAPyramid": 0.21576160036805178,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.8630464014722071,
"R1_recall": 0.2972972972972973,
"R1_f1": 0.20754716981132074,
"R2_recall": 0.1111111111111111,
"R2_f1": 0.07692307692307691,
"RL_recall": 0.21621621621621623,
"RL_f1": 0.1509433962264151,
"ACU": 0.2222222238779068,
"nACU": 0.14285318553447723,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8846033215522766,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8687700033187866,
"BARTScore": -3.1142849922180176,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.33429120019510655,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.32024394133542144,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.3333333333333333,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.1818181817785124,
"METEOR": 0.17847120380931691,
"ChrF": 35.21450487323553,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.2222222222222222,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.375,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.3125,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.32364240055207766,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.2697020004600647
},
"matchsum": {
"QAPyramid": 0.375,
"nQAPyramid": 0.32114324390256865,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.856381983740183,
"R1_recall": 0.32432432432432434,
"R1_f1": 0.2285714285714286,
"R2_recall": 0.1111111111111111,
"R2_f1": 0.07766990291262135,
"RL_recall": 0.24324324324324326,
"RL_f1": 0.17142857142857143,
"ACU": 0.2222222238779068,
"nACU": 0.13956934213638306,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8880013227462769,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8704714179039001,
"BARTScore": -3.0351016521453857,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.30915433327235015,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.32444598762473714,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.2222222222222222,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.10810810807129292,
"METEOR": 0.19862037229195048,
"ChrF": 33.97327113206214,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.2222222222222222,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.3125,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.25,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.2676193699188072,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.21409549593504576
},
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": {
"QAPyramid": 0.4375,
"nQAPyramid": 0.3849716630276816,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.8799352297775579,
"R1_recall": 0.40540540540540543,
"R1_f1": 0.2912621359223301,
"R2_recall": 0.08333333333333333,
"R2_f1": 0.05940594059405942,
"RL_recall": 0.21621621621621623,
"RL_f1": 0.15533980582524273,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8939638137817383,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8787396550178528,
"BARTScore": -3.263658046722412,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.44783444908015163,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.38394058846299434,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.2222222222222222,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.15999999995392,
"METEOR": 0.2213899185429251,
"ChrF": 35.550152932756674,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.3333333333333333,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.3125,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.42857142857142855,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.27497975930548685,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.3771150984760962
},
"llama-3-8b-instruct": {
"QAPyramid": 0.375,
"nQAPyramid": 0.33125716863166865,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.8833524496844497,
"R1_recall": 0.40540540540540543,
"R1_f1": 0.3,
"R2_recall": 0.05555555555555555,
"R2_f1": 0.04081632653061224,
"RL_recall": 0.21621621621621623,
"RL_f1": 0.16,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.9018837213516235,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8899181485176086,
"BARTScore": -3.479905128479004,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.37698807527444195,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.3597510432721012,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.3333333333333333,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.199999999958,
"METEOR": 0.22175524844151082,
"ChrF": 33.159845073534186,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.3333333333333333,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.1875,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.375,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.16562858431583433,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.33125716863166865
},
"GPT4": {
"QAPyramid": 0.5625,
"nQAPyramid": 0.43050083936633066,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.7653348255401434,
"R1_recall": 0.5405405405405406,
"R1_f1": 0.30075187969924816,
"R2_recall": 0.08333333333333333,
"R2_f1": 0.04580152671755725,
"RL_recall": 0.2972972972972973,
"RL_f1": 0.16541353383458646,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8947557806968689,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8792611360549927,
"BARTScore": -3.185760259628296,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.551714651286602,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.4713427453922729,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.5555555555555556,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.18518518515740737,
"METEOR": 0.2611324467578633,
"ChrF": 37.51197821444566,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.3333333333333333,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.25,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.3125,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.19133370638503586,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.23916713298129483
},
"llama-3-70b-instruct": {
"QAPyramid": 0.25,
"nQAPyramid": 0.2225566883139613,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.8902267532558452,
"R1_recall": 0.35135135135135137,
"R1_f1": 0.26262626262626265,
"R2_recall": 0.05555555555555555,
"R2_f1": 0.041237113402061855,
"RL_recall": 0.21621621621621623,
"RL_f1": 0.16161616161616163,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8967074751853943,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8853089809417725,
"BARTScore": -3.401602029800415,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.26003993264125064,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.3233099564483079,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.2222222222222222,
"AutoACU_f1": 0,
"METEOR": 0.23587238197774135,
"ChrF": 32.914905606154065,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.3333333333333333,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.3125,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.25,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.27819586039245164,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.2225566883139613
},
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": {
"QAPyramid": 0.4375,
"nQAPyramid": 0.34404299267764343,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.786383983263185,
"R1_recall": 0.4594594594594595,
"R1_f1": 0.2635658914728682,
"R2_recall": 0.1111111111111111,
"R2_f1": 0.06299212598425197,
"RL_recall": 0.2972972972972973,
"RL_f1": 0.17054263565891473,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8994863033294678,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8767682313919067,
"BARTScore": -3.178070306777954,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.35627645144372116,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.32731794292340055,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.2222222222222222,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.08888888885688888,
"METEOR": 0.2033919463566002,
"ChrF": 35.366409909012056,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.1111111111111111,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.3125,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.3125,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.24574499476974532,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.24574499476974532
}
} |
00220ec77d4406741f9c017c07839ef2e76b3eab | With house prices soaring, it's not easy finding somewhere to live. And this community has thrown in the towel. Meet Seattle's rolling neighborhood of RVs, where each unassuming vehicle is a capsule home. The unusual format has been captured in a series of photographs by visual journalist Anna Erickson. Meet Bud Dodson, 57, and welcome to his home: An RV in Seattle's SoDo where he watches over the parking lot in exchange for a spot . No place like home: John Warden, 52, has turned his $200 vehicle into his home after his apartment burned down years ago . There are around 30 drivers that float in and out of this parking lot in the SoDo (South of Downtown) area of the city in Washington State. One might not notice them in the mornings as hundreds of workers in the nearby factories, such as Starbucks, park up and rush into work. But on the weekends, as the rabble flocks back to their beds, this unique group remains. John Worden, 52, has been living in his vehicle for years since his apartment burned down and he was left homeless. He told Anna his car cost $200, and doesn't drive very well. But for a home, it's just about enough. Though plan on the outside, it is a Pandora's Box inside, Anna tells DailyMail.com. 'It was scattered with trinkets that he had been collecting over the years,' she explained, 'and a pile of beer cans that he was saving to turn in for money.' For work, he panhandles while helping people find parking spaces at Safeco Field stadium, where he used to be a cook. People come and go for work in the factories nearby, but on the weekend it is just the RV-dwellers that area left . Daily life: Here Bud can be seen preparing himself a barbecue on the gravel outside his capsule home, one of about 30 in the community . Eclectic: While Bud's RV is organized and functional, John's is full of trinkets and belongings dating back years . Alongside him - most of the time - is Bud Dodson, 57. While some are forced to move about regularly, Dodson, a maintenance man, looks after the parking lot in exchange for a semi-permanent spot. His home has its own unique stamp on it. 'He had really made the RV his home and taken good care of it,' Anna described. 'It was more functional [than John's] and a cleaner space with a bed, kitchen and bathroom.' Whether organized or eclectic, however, each one is home. 'None of them seem to want to move on,' Anna said. 'It's not perfect but they seem pretty content. Move in, move out: Some have agreements to stay, but others have to keep driving around to find a spot . John works as a panhandler at Safeco Fields stadium, where he used to work as a cook . He is content with his life in between the usual confines of society . Personal: To many this may just seem like a parking lot but for these men it is a very personal space . 'Bud is very grateful, he said the parking lot owner is just such a nice guy to let him live like this.' She came across them when she stopped to ask a seemingly homeless man for directions. 'We got talking,' she said, 'and he mentioned that he lived nearby in an RV. I went round to look and there was a whole bunch of them.' Curious, she spent about two months returning to the spot, meeting with the community and building their trust. 'These RVs are their homes so it's a very personal thing,' she explained. | Around 30 people live a floating life in Seattle's SoDo (South of Downtown) area in their RVs . There is one parking lot in particular where the owner lets them act as watchmen in exchange for a spot to live . Visual journalist Anna Erickson, who photographed the community, said they are just grateful to have a home . | [
"Who lives something? Around 30 people",
"What does someone live? a floating life",
"Where does someone live something? South of Downtown",
"How does someone live something? in their RVs",
"What is floating? life",
"Where is something floating? in Seattle 's SoDo ( South of Downtown ) area",
"Who lets someone do something? the owner",
"Who does someone let do something? them",
"What does someone let someone do? act as watchmen in exchange for a spot to live",
"Who acts as something? them",
"What does someone act as? watchmen",
"Why does someone act as something? in exchange for a spot to live",
"What is there? parking lot",
"How many are there? one",
"Where might someone live? a spot",
"Who might live somewhere? them",
"Who photographed something? Anna Erickson",
"What did someone photograph? the community",
"Who said something? Visual journalist",
"What did someone say? they are just grateful to have a home",
"Who is grateful for something? they",
"What is someone grateful for? to have a home",
"Who has something? they",
"What does someone have? a home"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
002da0eaa8d2d09ac66228ba1c49cdc152fab925 | John Carver has called on the advice and support of former Newcastle managers Alan Shearer and Alan Pardew as tensions grow between the club and its fanbase. Supporters are planning to boycott today’s game at home to Spurs in protest at what they see as a lack of investment and ambition from owner Mike Ashley. Carver was in the dugout alongside Pardew at the end of last season when fans again expressed their discontent during a 3-0 victory over Cardiff. Pardew was booed every time he ventured to the touchline amid a toxic atmosphere inside St James’ Park. Newcastle boss John Carver is under pressure and has asked for advice from some of his predecessors . Alan Pardew was in charge of Newcastle from 2010 to January this year, when he left for Crystal Palace . Former Newcastle striker Alan Shearer, the club's record goal-scorer, also had a brief stint as manager . Newcastle fans are planning to protest against owner Mike Ashley for a perceived lack of ambition . Sunday's protests will take place outside of the stadium, but Carver – who, in fairness, has been left with a depleted and disinterested squad - could nonetheless find himself the target should his side fall to a sixth straight defeat. Carver, though, accepts that he must take criticism and has spoken to the likes of Pardew and close friend Shearer, who was relegated as boss in 2009, for words of encouragement. ‘Some of the advice I’ve had has been excellent. It’s definitely changed me as a person in how I’ve dealt with things because, in the past, I would have reacted to what people have said and some of the things that have been written,’ he said. ‘Both Alans have excellent experience at it and that’s why I’m listening to what they are saying. Without a shadow of a doubt they have helped me through this. ‘We are not through it yet but they have been excellent for me, along with many other people in the game.’ He added: ‘But the club realise the situation I’m in and they realise that it’s a difficult one, and that’s why I’m convinced they are going to have to invest. ‘Whether it’s me or whether it's Sir Alex Ferguson doing this job, they would need investment.’ Carver, meanwhile, does not expect a repeat of the poison of 12 months ago when they take on Spurs. ‘The Cardiff game was one of the strangest atmospheres I’ve ever experienced,’ he said. ‘We got through it in the end. I hope it won’t be as difficult an atmosphere this time. Toon fans are planning to boycott the next home game with Spurs and have designed anti-Ashley leaflets . Newcastle players are put through their paces in training ahead of the home game with Spurs on Sunday . Newcastle winger Remy Cabella strikes a shot at goal during a training session ahead of the Spurs match . ‘I don’t think it will be, I think it will be a different type of protest. The fact that people are staying away, the people who come into the stadium will be behind the team because they understand where we are and everyone will be in it together.’ And Carver believes that the home double-header with Spurs and Swansea will determine how the rest of their season plays out. ‘I think these next two could define the season, because if we don’t pick up results it just adds a bit more pressure,’ he added. ‘Sometimes pressure can take over and we don’t want to leave ourselves in that situation.’ | Newcastle boss John Carver is under huge pressure to perform in his role . Toon fans are planning to protest against club owner Mike Ashley . Carver could also be targeted for his poor record in his job so far . He has turned to predecessors Alan Pardew and Alan Shearer for advice . | [
"Who performs something? John Carver",
"What does someone perform? his role",
"Who is planning to do something? Toon fans",
"What is someone planning to do? protest against club owner Mike Ashley",
"Who is under something? Newcastle boss John Carver",
"What is someone under? huge pressure",
"Why is someone under something? to perform in his role",
"Who might be targeted? Carver",
"Why might someone be targeted? for his poor record in his job so far",
"Who has turned to someone? He",
"Who has someone turned to? predecessors Alan Pardew and Alan Shearer",
"Why has someone turned to someone? for advice"
] | {
"bart": [
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"pegasus": [
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1
],
"brio": [
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"brio-ext": [
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1
],
"matchsum": [
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1
],
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": [
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1
],
"llama-3-8b-instruct": [
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1
],
"GPT4": [
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1
],
"llama-3-70b-instruct": [
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1
],
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": [
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1
]
} | {
"bart": "John Carver has called on the advice and support of former Newcastle managers Alan Shearer and Alan Pardew as tensions grow between the club and its fanbase. Supporters are planning to boycott today’s game at home to Spurs in protest at what they see as a lack of investment and ambition from owner Mike Ashley. Sunday's protests will take place outside of the stadium, but Carver could nonetheless find himself the target should his side fall to a sixth straight defeat.",
"pegasus": "Newcastle fans are planning to boycott the next home game with Spurs. Supporters are unhappy with owner Mike Ashley's lack of ambition. John Carver has called on Alan Shearer and Alan Pardew's advice. Pardew was booed every time he went to the touchline at the end of last season.",
"brio": "Newcastle fans are planning to boycott the home game with Spurs on Sunday . Supporters are protesting against owner Mike Ashley for a perceived lack of ambition . John Carver has called on the advice of Alan Pardew and Alan Shearer . The Toon boss is under pressure after a poor start to the season .",
"brio-ext": "John Carver has called on the advice and support of former Newcastle managers Alan Shearer and Alan Pardew as tensions grow between the club and its fanbase. Supporters are planning to boycott today’s game at home to Spurs in protest at what they see as a lack of investment and ambition from owner Mike Ashley. Newcastle boss John Carver is under pressure and has asked for advice from some of his predecessors.",
"matchsum": "John Carver has called on the advice and support of former Newcastle managers Alan Shearer and Alan Pardew as tensions grow between the club and its fanbase. Newcastle boss John Carver is under pressure and has asked for advice from some of his predecessors. Newcastle fans are planning to protest against owner Mike Ashley for a perceived lack of ambition .",
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": "Newcastle boss John Carver has sought advice from former managers Alan Shearer and Alan Pardew as tensions grow between the club and its fanbase . Supporters are planning to boycott today’s game at home to Spurs in protest at what they see as a lack of investment and ambition from owner Mike Ashley . Carver, though, accepts that he must take criticism and has spoken to the likes of Pardew and close friend Shearer, who was relegated as boss in 2009, for words of encouragement.",
"llama-3-8b-instruct": "Newcastle United manager John Carver has sought advice from former managers Alan Pardew and Alan Shearer amid growing tensions between the club and its fanbase . The team is facing a boycott by fans in protest of owner Mike Ashley's perceived lack of investment and ambition . Carver believes that the next two home games against Spurs and Swansea will determine the rest of the season's outcome and hopes that the fans will be behind the team despite the protests.",
"GPT4": "John Carver, the Newcastle manager, has sought advice from former managers Alan Shearer and Alan Pardew amid growing tensions between the club and its fans, who are planning a boycott in protest against owner Mike Ashley's lack of investment and ambition. Carver, facing the possibility of a sixth consecutive defeat, has been reassured by the advice from Shearer and Pardew, emphasizing the need for investment in the team regardless of the manager. Despite the planned protests, Carver hopes for a supportive atmosphere in the upcoming home games against Spurs and Swansea, which he believes could define the rest of their season.",
"llama-3-70b-instruct": " Newcastle United manager John Carver has sought advice from former managers Alan Shearer and Alan Pardew amid growing tensions between the club and its fans . Carver's side faces a crucial double-header against Tottenham and Swansea, with fans planning to boycott the Spurs match in protest at owner Mike Ashley's perceived lack of ambition . Carver believes investment is needed to improve the team, regardless of who is in charge, and hopes the atmosphere at St James' Park will not be as toxic as it was during a 3-0 win over Cardiff last season .",
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": "Newcastle manager John Carver has asked for advice from former managers Alan Shearer and Alan Pardew as he faces growing pressure from fans . Supporters are planning to boycott the home game against Spurs in protest at what they see as a lack of investment and ambition from owner Mike Ashley . Carver has also said that the club will need investment regardless of who is in charge."
} | {
"bart": {
"QAPyramid": 0.9166666666666666,
"nQAPyramid": 0.8253484248986266,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9003800998894108,
"R1_recall": 0.5,
"R1_f1": 0.3759398496240602,
"R2_recall": 0.1836734693877551,
"R2_f1": 0.13740458015267176,
"RL_recall": 0.28,
"RL_f1": 0.21052631578947367,
"ACU": 0.7272727489471436,
"nACU": 0.5308538675308228,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8791643381118774,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8736564517021179,
"BARTScore": -3.214740037918091,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.6107653652628263,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.6814735477620905,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.4444444444444444,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.31999999995392,
"METEOR": 0.28943193373057013,
"ChrF": 40.56796264648979,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.5454545454545454,
"GEval": 4,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.9166666666666666,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.75,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.8253484248986266,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.6752850749170581
},
"pegasus": {
"QAPyramid": 0.3333333333333333,
"nQAPyramid": 0.3323061127813131,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9969183383439394,
"R1_recall": 0.38,
"R1_f1": 0.37623762376237624,
"R2_recall": 0.1836734693877551,
"R2_f1": 0.1818181818181818,
"RL_recall": 0.28,
"RL_f1": 0.27722772277227725,
"ACU": 0.3636363744735718,
"nACU": 0.3602848947048187,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8778867721557617,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.880316972732544,
"BARTScore": -3.420184373855591,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.47861504040580866,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.5628646386744962,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.3333333333333333,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.28571428566530616,
"METEOR": 0.24898621248986216,
"ChrF": 34.106679859771226,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.2727272727272727,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.3333333333333333,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.4166666666666667,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.3323061127813131,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.4153826409766414
},
"brio": {
"QAPyramid": 0.8333333333333334,
"nQAPyramid": 0.8282051444387011,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9938461733264412,
"R1_recall": 0.54,
"R1_f1": 0.5294117647058824,
"R2_recall": 0.24489795918367346,
"R2_f1": 0.24,
"RL_recall": 0.34,
"RL_f1": 0.3333333333333333,
"ACU": 0.6363636255264282,
"nACU": 0.6246875524520874,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.894658088684082,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8952401280403137,
"BARTScore": -2.8253016471862793,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.6714330688118935,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.7017416807992215,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.4444444444444444,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.47058823524429066,
"METEOR": 0.3798700004555393,
"ChrF": 42.06589109771914,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.36363636363636365,
"GEval": 3,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.6666666666666666,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.6666666666666666,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.6625641155509607,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.6625641155509607
},
"brio-ext": {
"QAPyramid": 0.75,
"nQAPyramid": 0.6986050437960822,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9314733917281096,
"R1_recall": 0.56,
"R1_f1": 0.45528455284552843,
"R2_recall": 0.2653061224489796,
"R2_f1": 0.21487603305785125,
"RL_recall": 0.26,
"RL_f1": 0.2113821138211382,
"ACU": 0.7272727489471436,
"nACU": 0.5877717137336731,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8817348480224609,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.882491409778595,
"BARTScore": -2.9936275482177734,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.6339672176303187,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.7661084586235863,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.6666666666666666,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.5454545454061984,
"METEOR": 0.35714285714285715,
"ChrF": 47.02442175292342,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.6363636363636364,
"GEval": 4,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.8333333333333334,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.6666666666666666,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.7762278264400914,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.620982261152073
},
"matchsum": {
"QAPyramid": 0.8333333333333334,
"nQAPyramid": 0.8105037309302903,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9726044771163483,
"R1_recall": 0.58,
"R1_f1": 0.5272727272727273,
"R2_recall": 0.32653061224489793,
"R2_f1": 0.2962962962962963,
"RL_recall": 0.36,
"RL_f1": 0.3272727272727273,
"ACU": 0.7272727489471436,
"nACU": 0.6691232323646545,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8947368860244751,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8971784710884094,
"BARTScore": -2.6583287715911865,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.6504033415985759,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.7756485685187561,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.6666666666666666,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.6792452829688856,
"METEOR": 0.3597433074017097,
"ChrF": 50.35909963888998,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.7272727272727273,
"GEval": 4,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.75,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.8181818181818182,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.7294533578372613,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.7957672994588305
},
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": {
"QAPyramid": 0.4166666666666667,
"nQAPyramid": 0.37055526281583684,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.8893326307580084,
"R1_recall": 0.52,
"R1_f1": 0.3880597014925373,
"R2_recall": 0.24489795918367346,
"R2_f1": 0.18181818181818182,
"RL_recall": 0.38,
"RL_f1": 0.28358208955223885,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.9050320982933044,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8938290476799011,
"BARTScore": -2.9054744243621826,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.4920464022628342,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.6358503840112296,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.5555555555555556,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.4938271604444444,
"METEOR": 0.295283164050477,
"ChrF": 42.2021647919576,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.45454545454545453,
"GEval": 3,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.8333333333333334,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.5833333333333334,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.7411105256316737,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.5187773679421716
},
"llama-3-8b-instruct": {
"QAPyramid": 0.3333333333333333,
"nQAPyramid": 0.3047942069232395,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9143826207697185,
"R1_recall": 0.42,
"R1_f1": 0.3230769230769231,
"R2_recall": 0.14285714285714285,
"R2_f1": 0.109375,
"RL_recall": 0.22,
"RL_f1": 0.16923076923076924,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8990958333015442,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8911681771278381,
"BARTScore": -3.0718414783477783,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.47434062300696195,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.5323634258291515,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.5555555555555556,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.29411764701989623,
"METEOR": 0.26086956521739135,
"ChrF": 37.63019895378118,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.45454545454545453,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.6666666666666666,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.6363636363636364,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.609588413846479,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.58187984958073
},
"GPT4": {
"QAPyramid": 0.5,
"nQAPyramid": 0.4167595067423727,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.8335190134847454,
"R1_recall": 0.52,
"R1_f1": 0.3421052631578947,
"R2_recall": 0.16326530612244897,
"R2_f1": 0.10666666666666667,
"RL_recall": 0.28,
"RL_f1": 0.1842105263157895,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8755671977996826,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8731181025505066,
"BARTScore": -3.1683189868927,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.499557975679636,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.7019513638859446,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.5555555555555556,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.36585365849241525,
"METEOR": 0.2635069178443831,
"ChrF": 39.30592001186692,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.5454545454545454,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.8333333333333334,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.6666666666666666,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.6945991779039545,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.5556793423231636
},
"llama-3-70b-instruct": {
"QAPyramid": 0.4166666666666667,
"nQAPyramid": 0.360403707633708,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.8649688983208992,
"R1_recall": 0.5,
"R1_f1": 0.3424657534246575,
"R2_recall": 0.14285714285714285,
"R2_f1": 0.09722222222222221,
"RL_recall": 0.26,
"RL_f1": 0.17808219178082194,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.8950521945953369,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.8800066709518433,
"BARTScore": -3.0164148807525635,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.4850083188939607,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.6039011756974187,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.5555555555555556,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.24590163930979572,
"METEOR": 0.25376928970299506,
"ChrF": 38.87945862092978,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.45454545454545453,
"GEval": 2,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.8333333333333334,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.6666666666666666,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.720807415267416,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.5766459322139328
},
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": {
"QAPyramid": 0.5833333333333334,
"nQAPyramid": 0.5569427667490463,
"p_r": 1,
"p_l": 0.9547590287126507,
"R1_recall": 0.56,
"R1_f1": 0.4827586206896552,
"R2_recall": 0.20408163265306123,
"R2_f1": 0.1754385964912281,
"RL_recall": 0.3,
"RL_f1": 0.25862068965517243,
"BERTScore_recall": 0.911802351474762,
"BERTScore_f1": 0.9062333106994629,
"BARTScore": -3.001769542694092,
"Lite3Pyramid": 0.6305948911079516,
"Lite2Pyramid_w_ACU": 0.6431789390890944,
"AutoACU_recall": 0.5555555555555556,
"AutoACU_f1": 0.5468749999500121,
"METEOR": 0.32030272040414876,
"ChrF": 43.33616228546917,
"SemiAutoACU": 0.5454545454545454,
"GEval": 3,
"AutoQAPyramid": 0.75,
"SemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.7272727272727273,
"nAutoQAPyramid": 0.7160692715344881,
"nSemiAutoQAPyramid": 0.6943702027001096
}
} |
002dfdcdd737ba880f0ad12d25b9de3427086cfc | Roger Federer believes Rafael Nadal is still the favourite for the French Open despite the Spaniard's recent struggles. Nadal suffered his earliest exit in 12 years at the Barcelona Open last week with a third-round defeat by world No 29 Fabio Fognini and has admitted his confidence is lacking. World No 1 Novak Djokovic is 30-2 so far this season and became the first man to win the first three Masters titles of the year after his triumph in Monte Carlo. Roger Federer posted this picture on Twitter on Monday night as he gets set for the Istanbul Open . Federer hits a shot during a media event near the Bosphorus in Istanbul on Monday . Federer reaches to his right to play a forehand during the hit with a young Turkish tennis player . But Federer insists that arch-rival Nadal, who has won the title nine times and has only ever lost one match at Roland Garros, is still the man to beat. Federer said: 'At the French Open, Rafa for me is still the favourite alongside Djokovic who has been playing so well. 'Even though his (Nadal's) form is not as good as in previous years, I still believe when the French Open rolls around he is going to be very difficult to beat.' Federer, 33, looks to bounce back at the inaugural Istanbul Open this week after losing to flamboyant Frenchman Gael Monfils in the third round in Monte Carlo. The 17-time Grand Slam champion takes on Marsel Ilhan or Jarkko Nieminen in his opening match as he he looks to get settled on the clay after an extended run on hard courts. Federer said: 'It's about getting used to the sliding, deciding how aggressive I want to play. Rafael Nadal is a nine-time champion at Roland Garros and Federer still believes he is the man to beat . Federer speaks to the media during a press conference ahead of the Istanbul Open . Federer hits a ball into the sea as he takes part in the media event on the banks of the Bosphorus . 'I have been on hard courts for seven-eight months so it needs some adjustments. 'My game is going to get better and better as we move along.' '[The French Open] is clearly a big goal of mine. 'But to play well at the French Open I need confidence. I hope that I can pick that up in Istanbul.' | Roger Federer believes Rafael Nadal is still the favourite for Roland Garros . World No 1 Novak Djokovic has lost just two matches this year . But Federer feels that nine-time champion Nadal is still the man to beat . Federer is competing in the inaugural Istanbul Open this week . | [
"Who believes something? Roger Federer",
"What does someone believe? Rafael Nadal is still the favourite for Roland Garros",
"Who lost something? Novak Djokovic",
"What did someone lose? matches",
"When did someone lose? this year",
"How many did someone lose? two",
"Who feels something? Federer",
"What does someone feel? that nine - time champion Nadal is still the man to beat",
"Who is still the favourite? Rafael Nadal",
"What is someone still the favourite for? Roland Garros",
"Who is the man to beat? Nadal",
"Who is competing in something? Federer",
"What is someone competing in? the inaugural Istanbul Open",
"When is someone competing in something? this week"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
002e6d0357c253728d1351b572369225aec21fe8 | The the first photos of Sarah Stage's healthy newborn baby boy have been released. The 30-year-old lingerie model and animal rights activist from Los Angeles had come under fire during her pregnancy for posting a string of sexy selfies showing off her seemingly rock-hard abs. But James Hunter was born at a healthy eight pounds and seven ounces earlier this week, putting paid to Sarah's critics. Scroll down for video . Underwear model and animal rights activist Sarah Stage shared this adorable picture of her newborn baby James Hunter on Instagram . Sarah Stage took her last pregnancy selfie (pictured) on Monday, writing: 'Still waiting'. The 30-year-old gave birth James the next day . Sarah shared the adorable pictures to her Instagram page. One, which shows a close up of her son's face, said: 'Love at first sight #jameshunter.' While the first ever picture of James featured the newborn in an adorable fox outfit. Sarah commented on the photo: 'James Hunter (4/14/15) 8.7lbs/22 inches of HEALTHY baby! 'Thank you for the positive support throughout my journey... It's just beginning!!! #JamesHunter #Healthy' During her pregnancy many people commented that they felt Sarah's unusually trim figure could be damaging to her unborn child, but it seems their fears were unfounded. Sarah posted this adorable picture of James to her Instagram commenting that it was 'love at first sight' Sarah confirmed her happy news to E! revealing that her baby boy was 22 inches long at the time of his birth, adding: 'He's a big healthy boy and he got an APGAR score of eight to nine.' An APGAR score, which stands for Appearance, Pulse, Grimace, Activity, Respiration, is a quick method for assessing the health of a newborn, with scores of seven or above being considered normal. Sarah famously documented her changing figure via her Instagram page throughout her pregnancy, earning herself a huge number of fans - as well as a fair share of critics - in the process. Although the now mother came under fire last month as more and more critics spoke out against toned figure their comments never stopped the model from sharing numerous photos of her tight abs with her 1.6 million Instagram followers. In this gorgeous snap James is seen sleeping in a giraffe costume . On Tuesday Sarah shared a photo of two In-N-Out burgers, writing, 'Cravings,' although its not clear as to whether or not she enjoyed the meal before or after she gave birth. The lingerie-clad model snapped her last pregnancy selfie on Monday, which she captioned: 'Still waiting #9months [sic].' The snapshot of her in a black bra and thong underwear has been liked over40,000 times since it was posted, and has earned nearly 4,000 comments. And Sarah, who is of European and Costa Rican descent, took to Instagram last week to share a photo of growing belly during the last weeks of her of pregnancy, writing: '10 days until we meet #BabyJames.' But Sarah didn't just receive harsh comments. Many women noted that they found Sarah's pregnancy body to be motivation to work out and live a healthy lifestyle. Sarah struck various poses for these selfies of herself in her underwear which she posted throughout her pregnancy . Haters gonna hate: Sarah, who came under fire for her being tiny and toned throughout her pregnancy, told her critics to unfollow her if they have a problem with her pictures . Pregnant model Sarah Stage snapped this photo of herself flaunting her barely-there baby bump 10 days before she was supposed to give birth to her son . 'I'm completely inspired to go to the gym first thing in the morning. You look absolutely gorgeous @sarahstage #amazing [sic],' one fan wrote. 'You look absolutely lovely. Hats off to you for being fit and taking care of yourself!' another added. 'If I ever have children, I'm inspired by you to treat my pregnancy the very same way. I'm sure James will be amazing! Congratulations.' Others compared their figures to Sarah's pregnancy body, with one woman writing: '10 days before giving birth?! Lord Jesus help us all! I look like this after dinner [sic].' 'I look like that after a good meal or two,' someone else commented. Meanwhile, some people suggested that her son would be as tiny as she is - although it has since been proved that their fears about the young boy's size were unfounded. Sarah and her friend compared their growing bellies for this playful picture . Sarah shared this adorable photo of matching father and son Timberland boots . 'Baby James will come out the size of her phone case,' one person commented, referencing the model's bear-shaped cell phone cover. When she's not sharing lingerie selfies, the new mother regularly shared pictures of her son's nursery and his future wardrobe. Last week, Sarah shared an adorable photo of matching father and baby sized Timberland boots, writing: 'Daddy & baby shoe game [sic].' And despite her critics, Sarah refused to hide her then-eight-month pregnant body in maternity clothes. Sarah refused to wear baggy clothes during her pregnancy and instead opts for figure-hugging dresses like the one she is wearing in this picture . Sarah wore this sexy black dress on a 'date night' when she was 37 weeks pregnant, two weeks before James was born . She shunned baggy dresses and instead dressed her bump in fitted Lycra or nothing at all. The fitness fanatic loves hitting the gym and captures herself working out, as well as following a healthy diet of quinoa,spinach and chicken. Clearly not letting her growing baby bump get in the way of her career, Sarah continued to proudly model whilst carrying. Two weeks ago, she shared a sexy snapshot of herself in black underwear and responded to her haters. 'BTW If you don't like my pics then unfollow me,' she wrote. 'I'm excited, happy and enjoying every second of my pregnancy. Can't wait to meet James! #NFG #37weeks [sic].' | Sarah Stage, 30, welcomed James Hunter into the world on Tuesday . The baby boy weighed eight pounds seven ounces and was 22 inches long . During her pregnancy Sarah was criticised for her trim figure and abs . | [
"Who welcomed someone? Sarah Stage",
"Who did someone welcome? James Hunter",
"Where did someone welcome someone? into the world",
"When did someone welcome someone? on Tuesday",
"Who was criticised for something? Sarah",
"What was someone criticised for? her trim figure and abs",
"When was someone criticised? During her pregnancy",
"Who weighed something? The baby boy",
"What did someone weigh? eight pounds seven ounces",
"Who was something? The baby boy",
"What was someone? 22 inches long"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
00324fab01033899fbf5a4c5c410ccb389b94408 | Don McLean (pictured) is responsible American Pie, the lyrics of which have been puzzled over for decades . There has never been a popular song quite like it. For more than 40 years, its lyrics have been an enigma wrapped in an eight-and-a-half minute long rock 'n' roll puzzle. Argued over by generations of geeky fans, deciphered and re-deciphered by code-breaking rock nerds and considered to be poetic reflections on mid-20th century U.S. social history by even groovier academics, it's called American Pie. And this week its lyrics, hand-written in 1971 by a young folk singer called Don McLean, were sold at auction in New York for more than $1 million. That's a lot of money for 18 sheets of paper, albeit with a lost seventh verse. But, to be honest, I rather think that whoever bought them got a bargain. Because, in this age, when song lyrics have all but become meaningless, American Pie illustrates, in a series of images, metaphors and allusions, just what can be done within the frame of a melodically straightforward pop song. It's also a paean to education. McLean loves words, he says, 'almost as much as life'. That may be a slight overstatement, but it shows. Of course, like all poets, McLean didn't give us a key to the riddle of what his song was about when he released his multi-million-selling single. That would have spoiled it. 'It means I'll never have to work again,' he would joke about how much money the song had made him, leaving us to work out for ourselves what the 'sad news on the doorstep' was exactly, and why he 'couldn't take one more step' when he read it. That was the easy part, of course, for anyone of my and his generation who learned about the death in a plane crash in 1959 of one of the first great singer-songwriters of rock, Buddy Holly, when we read about it in the morning newspaper. As McLean sings, it was truly 'The day the music died'. I was on a Ribble bus going to school in Lancashire, peering over the shoulder of the man in front of me when I saw the headline. McLean, according to his song, anyway, was 14 and delivering papers in the rather smart New York suburb of New Rochelle where he grew up. It was a strange, wistful opening for a pop song, but then, as the beat kicked in, the lyrics began to portray the innocence of God-fearing, teenage high school in Fifties America. Listing pop song titles like the Book Of Love and A White Sports Coat and A Pink Carnation, and dances in the gym where the worst that could happen would be that the girl you fancied was dancing with some other guy, it painted a picture of what by 1971 was already a bygone time. Then, in between every verse, would come that cryptic chorus about driving his 'Chevy to the levee but the levee was dry'. For years, I thought that was something to do with the raised earthworks — levees — that run along the banks of the Mississippi in New Orleans, until I discovered that a 'levee' can also mean a party. So the parties that kids would attend in the non-threatening Fifties would always have been dry — that is, without alcohol. Yes, same in Britain. On the surface, it might seem that American Pie — especially the first half, which was the section mainly played on the radio because the record was far too long to be played in full — was just a misty-eyed lament for an untroubled Mom and Apple Pie American youth. But, suddenly, the mood changed as McLean — jaundiced almost, and certainly disappointed — looked around late-Sixties America and saw how the 'jester in a coat he borrowed from James Dean' (thought to mean Bob Dylan in his leather jacket) stole the King's 'thorny crown'. Or, as you and I might say, knocked Elvis Presley off his top-notch perch. Almost everything is seen through youth icons. In the line 'while Lenin read a book on Marx', was he teasingly criticising John Lennon for appearing to be espousing Marxist revolutionary theory in his solo songs? I think he might have been. And was 'helter skelter in a summer swelter' a reference to the murders of actress Sharon Tate and friends by the 'Charles Manson Family' in Los Angeles in the summer of 1969? It has to be. In an absurd defence, murderer Manson maintained that he had interpreted The Beatles innocuous lyrics in their song Helter Skelter as instructions to go out and kill. Manson is still in jail. Even after all these years, much of American Pie is still opaque. Was the reference to The Byrds' record Eight Miles High a comment on the carpet-bombing by U.S. jets in Vietnam? Only McLean knows — and he isn't saying. When asked to give a few hints as to the meaning of the lyrics for this week's auction catalogue, he simply said that 'the song was not a parlour game', but 'an indescribable photograph of America that I tried to capture in words and music'. And metaphor, he might have added, as, in my interpretation of the lyrics, a game of American football becomes a student demonstration, probably at Kent State University, over America's military extension of the Vietnam war to Cambodia, to the music of The Beatles' Sergeant Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band album. To this day, songwriter Don McLean has refused to divulge what the lyrics of American Pie refer to . 'The half-time air was sweet-perfume', which probably means that everybody was smoking pot, and wanting to have a nice, quiet time, when the demo was broken up violently by the Ohio National Guard, who shot four students dead. Then there's the question of Mick Jagger. Is he 'Jack be nimble, Jack be quick, Jack Flash sat on a Candlestick'? Maybe. But there is confusion because it isn't The Beatles' famous last U.S. show at Candlestick Park, San Francisco, that McLean is singing about, but The Rolling Stones' performance at nearby Altamont in 1969. At that concert, the Stones performed Sympathy For The Devil and then watched helplessly as, before them in the crowd, Hell's Angels beat a man to death. 'And as I watched him on the stage, my hands were clenched in fists of rage,' go the lyrics of American Pie. 'No angel born in hell, could break that Satan's spell.' Dancing to rock 'n' roll was never meant to get like this, he seems to be saying. I'm not sure that if I were Mick Jagger, I'd want to hear that sung about myself. Although McLean said before the auction of his song's lyrics that the pages would 'divulge everything there is to divulge' about this 'mystical trip into my past', they clearly don't. But the material does cast some light on how the song changed before he recorded it. Originally, he had intended a positive ending, suggesting an extra verse that the music he once loved would be reborn in happier times. But in the end he settled for the more worldly-wise: 'The three men I admire the most, The Father, Son and the Holy Ghost / They caught the last train for the coast / The day the music died.' A bleak ending, yes, but apart from the reference to the Holy Trinity, is there also perhaps a nod here to John F. Kennedy, Robert Kennedy and Martin Luther King, whose assassinations occurred in the Sixties? Again, McLean isn't saying. What he does do, however, is give excellent advice to songwriters who are just starting out: 'Immerse yourself in beautiful music and beautiful lyrics and think about every word you say in a song.' Were the lyrics 'The Father, Son and the Holy Ghost' a nod to John F. Kennedy (left), Robert Kennedy and Martin Luther King (right), whose assassinations occurred in the Sixties? It seems so obvious, doesn't it? But then you turn on the radio and realise that, with just a few exceptions, an appreciation of good music and lyrics has played little part in the education of so many of today's songwriters. As McLean showed, the right word can mean so much. Most people will probably think of 69-year-old Don McLean as a one-hit wonder — now living in semi-retirement, and no doubt the lap of luxury, with his wife in Maine. And he certainly wasn't able to ever better American Pie. But at around the same time, he also wrote two other pop classics. Vincent, about Vincent Van Gogh's painting The Starry Night, as well as And I Love You So. This week's buyer of the lyrics of American Pie unfortunately prefers to remain anonymous, and that suggests to me that's he's a billionaire who wants to frame them and stick them on his study wall. I'd far rather they had been bought by an university so students of U.S. literature and social history could spend another 40-odd years poring over them, and discussing what can be done with a popular song, and how America was, as it says in the lyrics, a 'long, long time ago'. | For more than 40 years, the lyrics of American Pie have been puzzled over . This week the handwritten lyrics sold for more than $1 million at auction . The verses contain hidden references to seminal events of the 50s and 60s . It includes nods to Buddy Holly, Charles Manson and Martin Luther King . | [
"What has been puzzled over? the lyrics of American Pie",
"How long has something been puzzled over? For more than 40 years",
"What sold for something? the handwritten lyrics",
"When did something sell for something? This week",
"What did something sell for? more than $ 1 million",
"Where did something sell for something? at auction",
"What contains something? The verses",
"What does something contain? hidden references",
"What includes something? It",
"What does something include? nods to Buddy Holly , Charles Manson and Martin Luther King",
"What are hidden? references to seminal events of the 50s and 60s",
"Where is something hidden? The verses"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
0034b7c223e24477e046cf3ee085dd006be38b27 | Rubbish teams refused to empty a recycling bin because it had an empty crisp packet on its lid. Binmen said the bag of Walkers prawn cocktail crisps fell foul of the rules – even though it had been dropped there by a litterbug. Elsewhere they left another bin full of rubbish because there was a scrap of cellophane on top. The binmen in Farnham, Surrey, said the bag of Walkers prawn cocktail crisps fell foul of the rules – even though it had been dropped there by a litterbug and not by the owner of the bin (file image) Now enraged residents in Farnham, Surrey, have branded waste collection squads as 'little Hitlers' for enforcing recycling rules to the letter. Homeowners have been told to remove any non-recyclable material from the wheelie bin lids. Dozens of people have now taken to social media to complain that their blue wheelie bins have been left full ofwaste by the collection teams which are 'trying to make a point' over recycling rules. Tracy Porter said on Facebook 'I am so angry about this. 'I live opposite a shop and some kind person, not wanting to litter the area, put their crisp packet in the top of my recycling bin, and for that I have to be penalised. 'They would not empty the bin. It's not my fault, not even my rubbish. What is the place coming to?' Another resident, Peter Smith, said he had been left with a wheelie bin full of rotting waste after the collection team refused to empty it because they saw a piece of cellophane paper. They ruled the cellophane was not recyclable and broke the rules, but Mr Smith said 'Why not take that little bit off and take the rest? 'They are behaving like little Hitlers.' Waverley Council defended the binmen, saying they had 'nowhere suitable' to put non-recyclable items. The council has suggested placing overflowing recyclable waste in cardboard boxes alongside the blue wheelie bins. Enraged residents in Farnham, Surrey, have branded waste collection squads as 'little Hitlers' for enforcing recycling rules to the letter . But resident Teresa Johnstone responded 'We live in England - will they bother to pick up rain-sodden boxes which have disintegrated when they can't even lift a crisp packet from the bin in the first place? I very much doubt it.' A council spokesman said 'To prevent a whole truck of materials ending up in landfill, undoing the good work of a majority of residents who are recycling correctly, the council enforces the non-collection of contaminated recycling bins. 'All collectors working for Waverley's contractor have stickers to place on bins which detail why it has not been collected and remind residents what should and should not be in the blue bin.' The online discussion was not completely one-sided, with some residents posting messages of support for the council's stance and questioning some people's commitment to recycling. Zoe Tudor said 'I don't think it's the recycling collectors' job to sort through each bin - as if their job isn't hard work enough.' | Binmen refused to empty bin because it had empty crisp packet on lid . They also left bin full because there was a scrap of cellophane on top . Enraged residents have branded waste collection squads as 'little Hitlers' | [
"Who refused to do something? Binmen",
"What did someone refuse to do? empty bin",
"Why did someone refuse to do something? because it had empty crisp packet on lid",
"Who wouldn't empty something? Binmen",
"What wouldn't someone empty? bin",
"Why wouldn't someone empty something? because it had empty crisp packet on lid",
"What had something? bin",
"What did something have? empty crisp packet",
"Where did something have something? on lid",
"Who left something? They",
"What did someone leave? bin",
"How did someone leave something? full",
"Why did someone leave something? because there was a scrap of cellophane on top",
"What was somewhere? a scrap of cellophane",
"Where was something? on top",
"Who branded someone as something? Enraged residents",
"Who did someone brand as something? waste collection squads",
"What did someone brand someone as? ' little Hitlers '"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
0038893054277710fb6eea96fbf21a556bc4e318 | Jeffrey Williams, 20, is accused of shooting and wounding the officers on during a rally on March 12 . The man accused of shooting two police officers during a demonstration in Ferguson has confessed to the crime in a series of phone calls from jail that were recorded. Jeffrey Williams, 20, is accused of shooting and wounding the officers on March 12, during an early-morning rally sparked by the resignation of Ferguson's police chief. All inmates are informed their phone conversations while behind bars are recorded and can be used as evidence against them, but despite the warning Williams spoke freely about the incident in calls made from the St. Louis County Justice Center. In a conversation with his girlfriend, Williams said he was being harassed by a group of people outside Ferguson PD on the night of the shooting . 'Nobody aiming at no police,' Williams said. 'I ran up the hill and he (an unidentified person) shot at the car. ... I shot back,' Williams said in the recordings first obtained by KMOV-TV. In another conversation, Williams expressed concern about a possible lengthy prison sentence. 'Even though I was in the wrong, though, I should have just went the other way,' he said. 'Oh man, now I'm looking at 10 years.' Prosecutors say Williams told investigators he fired a gun but was aiming at someone else. Williams' attorney, Jerryl Christmas, has said Williams told him he never fired during the protest. Despite being warned that phone calls from prison can be used as evidence, Jeffrey Williams, 20, spoke freely about the March 12 incident in calls made from the St. Louis County Justice Center . Christmas told The Associated Press on Wednesday morning he hadn't heard the audio of the phone conversations, but he stood by what Williams told him. 'My client has maintained to me that he never fired a gun that night,' Christmas said. 'So until I'm able to see evidence that I can distinctly talk to him about, I have to maintain my commitment to the statements that he has made to me.' Christmas was also critical of the justice center for releasing audio that provides potential evidence against Williams. Ferguson has been a focal point since a white police officer fatally shot 18-year-old Michael Brown, who was black and unarmed, on Aug. 9. A grand jury in November declined to indict the former officer, Darren Wilson, who also was cleared of civil rights violations by the U.S. Department of Justice in March. Williams said he was being harassed by a group of people outside Ferguson PD and wasn't aiming at the cops. He also expressed remorse . Williams' attorney, Jerryl Christmas, has said Williams told him he never fired during the protest . But a separate DOJ report found widespread racial bias in Ferguson's policing efforts and the municipal court system, which it said was driven by profit mostly extracted from black and low-income residents. Several city officials were fired or resigned following the report. Among those was Police Chief Tom Jackson, and his resignation led several dozen people to protest outside of police headquarters. The demonstration was about to break up when shots rang out. A St. Louis County officer was shot in the shoulder; a Webster Groves officer was hit in the face. Both are expected to fully recover. | Jeffrey Williams, 20, is accused of shooting and wounding the officers on during a rally on March 12 . Despite warnings at the start of prison phone calls that they can be used as evidence, he spoke free about the incident to his girlfriend . Williams said he was being harassed by a group of people outside Ferguson PD and wasn't aiming at the cops. He also expressed remorse . 'Even though I was in the wrong, though, I should have just went the other way,' he said. 'Oh man, now I'm looking at 10 years' | [
"Who is accused of something? Jeffrey Williams",
"What is someone accused of? shooting and wounding the officers",
"When is someone accused of something? during a rally on March 12",
"Who might have shot someone? Jeffrey Williams",
"Who might someone have shot? the officers",
"When might someone have shot someone? during a rally on March 12",
"Who spoke about something? he",
"How did someone speak about something? free",
"What did someone speak about? the incident",
"Who did someone speak about something to? his girlfriend",
"Who was being harassed? Williams",
"Who was harassing someone? a group of people",
"Where was someone being harassed? outside Ferguson PD",
"Who expressed something? He",
"What did someone express? remorse",
"Who was in something? I",
"What was someone in? the wrong",
"Who should have went somewhere? I",
"Where should someone have went? the other way",
"Who said something? he",
"What did someone say? ' Even though I was in the wrong , though , I should have just went the other way , '",
"Who is looking at something? I",
"What is someone looking at? 10 years",
"Who might have been wounding someone? Jeffrey Williams",
"Who might have been wounded? the officers",
"When might have someone been wounded? on March 12",
"What can be used as something? prison phone calls",
"What can something be used as? evidence",
"Who said something? Williams",
"What did someone say? he was being harassed by a group of people outside Ferguson PD and was n't aiming at the cops"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
0041698b4463a633f912681b96f73648cb012e33 | (CNN)President Barack Obama took part in a roundtable discussion this week on climate change, refocusing on the issue from a public health vantage point. After the event at Washington's Howard University on Tuesday, Obama sat down with me for a one-on-one interview. I asked him about the science behind climate change and public health and the message he wants the average American to take away, as well as how enforceable his action plan is. Here are five things I learned: . The President enrolled at Occidental College in Los Angeles in 1979 (he transferred to Columbia University his junior year). While in L.A., he said, the air was so bad that it prevented him from running outside. He remembers the air quality alerts and how people with respiratory problems had to stay inside. He credits the Clean Air Act with making Americans "a lot" healthier, in addition to being able to "see the mountains in the background because they aren't covered in smog." Obama also said the instances of asthma and other respiratory diseases went down after these measures were taken. Peer-reviewed Environmental Protection Agency studies say that the Clean Air Act and subsequent amendments have reduced early deaths associated with exposure to ambient fine particle pollution and ozone, and reduced illnesses such as chronic bronchitis and acute myocardial infarction. The EPA estimates that, between 1970 and 2010, the act and its amendments prevented 365,000 early deaths from particulate matter alone. "No challenge poses more of a public threat than climate change," the President told me. When I asked about the strength of the science supporting the direct relationship between climate change and public health, he said, "We know as temperatures rise, insect-borne diseases potentially start shifting up. We know, in a very straight-forward fashion, that heatstroke and other heat-related illnesses and deaths potentially increase, and so what we're doing here is to make sure that in addition to public awareness around the potential for big storms like Hurricane Sandy or big wildfires or droughts, that people recognize there's a very personal, potential impact in climate change, and the good news is we can do something about it." In many ways, Obama is attempting to reframe the discussion around climate change as a public health issue that affects all of us, while conceding that we don't fully understand the magnitude of the correlation between rising temperatures and impact on human health. When asked what the average American can do about all this, the President encouraged ordinary citizens, doctors and nurses to start putting some pressure on elected officials "to try and make something happen to reduce the impacts of climate change." He also issued a presidential proclamation declaring April 6-12 as National Public Health Week "to better understand, communicate and reduce the health impacts of climate change on our communities." The average American can also do their part to reduce their own carbon footprint, including: . • Change your incandescent light bulbs to compact fluorescent lights. One CFL can reduce up to 1,300 pounds of carbon dioxide pollution during its lifetime. If every house in the U.S. switched its bulbs, we could reduce the electricity spent on lighting by half. • Unplug your gadgets and chargers when not in use. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, this practice can save $100 a year on your energy bill. • Use a laptop instead of a desktop. Laptops are designed to be energy-efficient, because battery life is a major factor in their design. According to Energy Star, a laptop can be up to 80% more energy-efficient than a desktop. • Filter your own water. Beyond the environmental toll of plastic waste, consider just how far your water was transported before you bought it at the grocery store. • Adjust your curtains and thermostats. If you keep your house 2 degrees warmer in the summer and 2 degrees colder in the winter, you can save big bucks on your energy bill. The Department of Energy estimates you can save up to 15% on your bill by turning off your thermostat when you're not at home. Obama did not appear particularly concerned about the current Supreme Court challenge to the Affordable Care Act. He said he believes the statute is "clear and straightforward." He said, "I am not anticipating the Supreme Court would make such a bad decision." At issue is the 32 states that did not set up their own health care exchanges and left it to the federal government to do so. The plaintiffs in the lawsuit contend that the language of the Affordable Care Act does not allow for tax subsidies in those states (without state-based exchanges), possibly creating a situation, for example, in which people in Massachusetts would receive a tax credit, but people living in Texas would not. Obama did tell me that if the Supreme Court challenge is upheld, however, there is no Plan B. "Millions of people would lose their health insurance. They would no longer be able to afford the health insurance that's being provided out there." Obama went on to say, "I think this is the last gasp of folks who have been fighting against [the Affordable Care Act] for ideological reasons." He told me that he "gets letters every day from people who say, 'you know what, the Affordable Care Act saved my life or saved my kid's life because I got insurance.' 'I thought I was healthy; turns out I had a tumor, but because I went and got a checkup, it was removed in time, and I'm now cancer-free.' " He added, "I think stories like that will be factored in when the Supreme Court takes a look at this case." CNN's Ben Tinker contributed to this report. | "No challenge poses more of a public threat than climate change," the President says . He credits the Clean Air Act with making Americans "a lot" healthier . | [
"What poses something? challenge",
"What does something pose? more of a public threat",
"Who says something? the President",
"What does someone say? No challenge poses more of a public threat than climate change",
"Who credits something? He",
"What does someone credit with something? the Clean Air Act",
"What does someone credit something with? making Americans \" a lot \" healthier",
"What is making something? the Clean Air Act",
"What is something making? Americans \" a lot \" healthier"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
0047e121edeb0c38199b85b824c169613a3f3dc3 | Firefighters responded to cries for help - from two parrots. The crew scoured a burning home in Boise, Idaho, searching for people shouting 'Help!' and 'Fire!' Eventually, to their surprise, they found a pair of squawking birds. SCROLL DOWN FOR VIDEO . Cry for help! This is one of the two parrots who were found in a burning home after calling for help . The tropical creatures appeared to have been alone when flames began to sweep the property. But they seemed to know what to do. Both were pulled from the home and given oxygen. They are expected to survive. The fire crew in Boise, Idaho, thought they were chasing human voices when the found the birds . Treatment: The officials treated the birds with oxygen masks and both are expected to survive . According to KBOI, the cause of the officers managed to contain the fire to just one room. It is being investigated and no people were found inside. Officials have yet to track down the birds' owners. | Two parrots were home alone when a fire erupted in Boise, Idaho . Started calling 'Help!' and 'Fire!', crew thought they were human voices . Both were pulled from the wreckage and treated with oxygen masks . | [
"What were home alone? Two parrots",
"When were somethings home alone? when a fire erupted",
"Where were somethings home alone? in Boise , Idaho",
"Who thought something was something? crew",
"What did someone think was something? they",
"What did someone think something was? human voices",
"What might something have been? human voices",
"What erupted somehwere? a fire",
"Where did something erupt? Boise , Idaho",
"Who was pulled from somewhere? Both",
"From where was someone pulled? the wreckage",
"What was started? calling ' Help ! '"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
005ed40b1c58766a61e37d23bf10f8ce81ef6295 | Ahead of this weekend's Premier League action, Sportsmail will be providing you with all you need to know about every fixture, with team news, provisional squads, betting odds and Opta stats. Here is all the information you need for Crystal Palace's home clash with Manchester City... Crystal Palace vs Manchester City (Selhurst Park) Team news . Crystal Palace . Crystal Palace boss Alan Pardew has no fresh injury concerns ahead of his side's clash against Manchester City. However, Marouane Chamakh and Fraizer Campbell are still sidelined with a hamstring injury, while Jordon Mutch has a thigh complaint. Mile Jedinak gives the thumbs up while on international duty with Australia on Monday but he is ruled out for Crystal Palace's gane against Manchester City in the Premier League through suspension . Joining them in being ruled out is skipper Mile Jedinak who is suspended. Manchester City . Manchester City have no serious injury concerns for Monday's Barclays Premier League trip to Crystal Palace. Key midfielder Yaya Toure missed the victory over West Brom a fortnight ago with an achilles injury but has since played twice for Ivory Coast and is fit. Yaya Toure missed Manchester City's last game but returned to action with Ivory Coast as they took on Equatorial Guinea in an Abidjan friendly on Friday . Fellow midfielder James Milner has also been troubled by a knee injury in recent weeks but the suggestions from manager Manuel Pellegrini are that the England international will be available. Provisional squad: Hart, Caballero, Zabaleta, Sagna, Kompany, Demichelis, Mangala, Boyata, Clichy, Kolarov, Milner, Navas, Silva, Nasri, Toure, Fernando, Fernandinho, Lampard, Aguero, Bony, Jovetic, Dzeko. Kick-off: Monday, 8pm - Sky Sports 1 . Odds (subject to change): . Crystal Palace 9/2 . Draw 3/1 . Manchester City 4/7 . Referee: Michael Oliver . Managers: Alan Pardew (Crystal Palace), Manuel Pellegrini (Manchester City) Head-to-head league record: Crystal Palace wins 12, draws 12, Manchester City wins 21 . Key match stats (supplied by Opta) Crystal Palace have won just two of their last eight Premier League home matches (W2 D2 L4). Man City have won the last seven matches in a row against Palace in all competitions. The Eagles have now gone 11 Premier League matches at Selhurst Park without a clean sheet. Manchester City scored with all three shots on target when they met Palace back in December. Alan Pardew has won 20 points from losing positions as a Premier League manager this season (10 at Newcastle, 10 at Palace); more than any other PL boss in 2014-15. Manchester City won on their previous visit to Crystal Palace, as Yaya Toure celebrates scoring the second goal in a 2-0 win last April which helped fire them towards the Premier League title . Crystal Palace have won 19 points in 10 Premier League games under Pardew – two more than they won in their previous 20 PL games in 2014-15 (17 under Millen/Warnock). Sergio Aguero has scored 98 goals in all competitions for Manchester City, but he has not netted in 466 minutes of competitive football for the club. Manchester City have used every substitution available in all of their 43 competitive matches this season. Man City substitutes have contributed 16 goals and assists this season in the Premier League; more than any other team. Glenn Murray has scored four goals in his last four Premier League appearances; this after netting just one in his previous 19. | Marouane Chamakh, Fraizer Campbell and Jordon Mutch ruled out . Suspended Crystal Palace skipper Mile Jedinak joins them on the sidelines . Yaya Toure back from an achilles injury for Manchester City . James Milner expected to be available for champions despite knee trouble . | [
"Who was ruled? Marouane Chamakh , Fraizer Campbell and Jordon Mutch",
"How was someone ruled? out",
"Who joins someone? Suspended Crystal Palace skipper Mile Jedinak",
"Who does someone join? them",
"Where does someone join? on the sidelines",
"Who is expected to be something? James Milner",
"What is someone expected to be? available for champions"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
006bafe16458202fd775ead449eae2083841586f | President Barack Obama threw off the gloves and took a direct punch at one of his possible successors, likely Republican presidential candidate Scott Walker, in an interview airing this morning. Responding to Walker's claims that he'd 'absolutely' cancel or 'disown' a deal with Iran on 'day one' if elected to higher office, Obama told NPR Morning Edition host Steve Inskeep that such an approach 'would be foolish.' 'And, you know, perhaps Mr. Walker, after he's taken some time to bone up on foreign policy, will feel the same way,' the president added. Walker fired back at Obama on Twitter, saying, 'Americans would be better served by a President who spent more time working with governors & Congress rather than attacking them.' Scroll down for video . Foolish: In an interview with NPR, Obama said likely Republican presidential candidate Scott Walker may change his 'foolish' position on a deal with Iran 'after he's taken some time to bone up on foreign policy' Obama's jab at Walker departed from the White House's general strategy of staying out of the race to replace the sitting president, who is prohibited by the Constitution from seeking another term . Obama's jab at Walker, the governor of Wisconsin, departed from the White House's general strategy of staying out of the race to replace the sitting president, who is prohibited by the Constitution from seeking another term. The current administration has been more willing to weigh in, however, when a presumed Republican candidate threatens to dismantle one of the president's prized domestic or foreign policies, which, in the case of Walker, was the nuclear arrangement with Iran. 'I am confident that any president who gets elected will be knowledgeable enough about foreign policy and knowledgeable enough about the traditions and precedents of presidential power that they won't start calling to question the capacity of the executive branch of the United States to enter into agreements with other countries,' Obama told Inskeep during their Monday afternoon chat following the NPR host's invocation of Walker's past comments. 'If that starts being questioned, that's going to be a problem for our friends and that's going to embolden our enemies.' Continuing, Obama said, that 'would be a foolish approach to take' and slammed Walker. A cadre of probable Republican presidential contenders have spoken out against the Obama administration's laboriously negotiated pact with Iran to stunt the growth of the country's program. Walker is the only one to say he would not honor his predecessor's deal with Iran and the international community if elevated to presidency, however. 'If I ultimately choose to run, and if I’m honored to be elected by the people of this country, I will pull back on that on January 20, 2017, because the last thing — not just for the region but for this world — we need is a nuclear-armed Iran,' he told radio host Charlie Sykes last week. 'It leaves not only problems for Israel, because they want to annihilate Israel, it leaves the problems in the sense that the Saudis, the Jordanians and others are gonna want to have access to their own nuclear weapons.' Obama has said on repeat that he believes a diplomatic agreement with Iran that shuts down, in theory, its pathways to developing a bomb will be more effective than a military option. Obama was responding to Walker's claims that he'd 'absolutely' cancel or 'disown' a deal with Iran on 'day one' if elected to higher office. Walker is currently the governor of Wisconsin . Swatting Walker away: Obama takes part in the White House Easter Egg Roll on the South Lawn, which included a spot of tennis . 'We're now in a position where Iran has agreed to unprecedented inspections and verifications of its program, providing assurances that it is peaceful in nature,' he told NPR, touting the accord that representatives of his administration and five other countries reached with Iran. Furthermore, the global community will have assurances that Iran's stockpile of enriched uranious 'remains in a place where they cannot create a nuclear weapon,' he said. 'This deal is the right thing to do for the United States, for our allies in the region and for world peace.' Obama said 'it's a hard argument to make that we're better off right now' having 'no insight' into Iran's facilities 'and letting them rush towards a bomb.' And if Iran doesn't change its behavior, Obama said the U.S. will 'still have the options available to me - or available to a future president that I have available to me right now.' Included in that portfolio will be the ability to reinstate financial sanctions on the country at any time nuclear experts at the International Atomic Energy Agency determine its broken the rules. Other areas of the plan remain fuzzy and will await clarification in a final round of talks, scheduled to take place by the end of June. Already a fissure between the United States' and Iran on sanctions - the U.S. will only commit to gradual relief that can be 'snapped back' into place while Iran is taking the stance that restrictions should be removed immediately and permanently in exchange for nuclear concessions - has emerged since the countries announced the preliminary agreement last Thursday. Obama told NPR his administration still isn't sure it 'can button down' all the issues standing in the way of a long-term agreement and it will have to 'work very hard in order to complete a deal.' And while he characterized Israel Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's demand that a final deal force Iran to recognize his country's right to exist as a 'fundamental misjudgment' of the political waters, Obama noted that one of the most 'profound' differences between America and Iran 'is the vile, anti-Semitic statements that have often come out of the highest levels of the Iranian regime.' 'So what I would say to the Israeli people is you are right to be suspicious of Iran. There's no reason why you should let your guard down with respect to Iran,' he said. 'But ultimately, Iran is deterrable, and it is deterrable not just because of Israel's superior military and intelligence capabilities but also because you got a really strong ally in the United States of America.' Shifting to the topic of Cuba briefly, Obama confirmed that he was considering removing the Latin American country from the U.S.' list of countries that sponsor terrorism. 'Understand that the criteria is very straightforward. Is this particular country considered a state sponsor of terrorism, not, do we agree with them on everything, not whether they engage in repressive or authoritarian activities in their own country,' he said. 'And so those standards, those criteria are the ones that are going to be measured against the current activities of the Cuban government.' Obama said he'll make a decision after he receives the State Department's recommendation. The president said his most pressing concern was whether he could effect the United States' relationship with the communist country in a way that 'benefits the Cuban people over the long term.' 'There are areas where there are serious differences' between the two countries, he said. 'But I do see the possibility -- a great hunger within Cuba -- to begin a change, a process that ultimately, I think, can lead to more freedom and more opportunity.' | The president took a jab at the Wisconsin governor during an interview with NPR Morning Edition host Steve Inskeep . Obama was responding to Walker's claims that he'd 'absolutely' cancel or 'disown' a deal with Iran on 'day one' if elected to higher office . Jab at Walker departed from the White House's general strategy of staying out of the race to replace the sitting president . Walker fired back on Twitter: 'Americans would be better served by a President who spent more time working with governors & Congress rather than attacking them' Obama defended the informal agreement his administration made with Iran and the shift toward Cuba, which it may take of its list of terrorist countries . | [
"Who took something? The president",
"What did someone take? a jab",
"When did someone take something? during an interview",
"Who was responding to something? Obama",
"What was someone responding to? Walker 's claims that he 'd ' absolutely ' cancel or ' disown ' a deal with Iran on ' day one ' if elected to higher office",
"Who might cancel something? he",
"What might someone cancel? a deal with Iran",
"When might someone cancel something? on ' day one '",
"How might someone cancel something? absolutely",
"Who might disown something? Walker",
"What might someone disown? a deal with Iran",
"When might someone disown something? on ' day one '",
"Who might be elected to something? Obama",
"What might someone be elected to? higher office",
"Who was staying somewhere? the White House",
"Where was someone staying? out of the race to replace the sitting president",
"Who might someone replace? the sitting president",
"Who fired somewhere? Walker",
"Where did someone fire back? on Twitter",
"Who worked with someone? a President",
"Who did someone work with? governors & Congress",
"Who might be attacking someone? a President",
"Who might someone be attacking? them",
"Who made something with someone? his administration",
"What did someone make with someone? informal agreement",
"Who did someone make something with? Iran",
"What might take something? it",
"What might something take? Cuba",
"Where might something take something? of its list of terrorist countries",
"Who is sitting? president",
"Who spent something? a President",
"What did someone spend? more time working with governors & Congress",
"Who defended something? Obama",
"What did someone defend? the informal agreement his administration made with Iran",
"Who departed? Walker",
"Where did someone depart from? the White House 's general strategy",
"Who would serve someone? a President",
"Who would someone serve? Americans",
"How would someone be served? better"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
006c9e9a7ab29b3107aea76f381905cac642ac0c | An upcoming documentary describes Yelp as the internet's equivalent to the mafia, and the publicly-traded company is doing everything in its power to discredit the film before it is released. Yelp, founded in 2004 by two former PayPal employees, is a website that lets users write their own reviews of businesses like restaurants and doctor's offices. However, like many web businesses, Yelp's revenue comes mainly from advertising and the businesses that buy ads are often also rated and reviewed on the site. Kaylie Milliken is the filmmaker behind Billion Dollar Bully, an ongoing documentary focused on Yelp's impact on small businesses. While she hasn't finished the documentary yet, Milliken tells Daily Mail Online her research so far has indicated Yelp's advertising structure appears to punish businesses that choose not to advertise on the site - a claim that company has vigorously denied. Scroll down for video . A racket? A documentary filmmaker is currently working on a film about Yelp, which she says will unveil shady advertising practices at the company. Above, Yelp CEO Jeremy Stoppelman in August 2014 . Pay to play: Billion Dollar Bully is still in production, but filmmaker Kaylie Milliken says she's already interviewed several small businesses who believe they've been targeted by the company for refusing to advertise . 'Businesses feel extorted,' Milliken told Daily Mail Online. 'After they decline advertising services from Yelp they feel like their good reviews get filtered out and their negative reviews come to the front.' And at hundreds of dollars a month for advertising, the price to work with Yelp is too big for many mom and pop businesses, Milliken says. Milliken first started investigating the company a year ago, when she went to see her doctor, who started talking about her negative experiences being listed on Yelp. 'The more she talked about it, the more my jaw just kind of dropped. I knew that they had aggressive salespeople - my husband is a small -business owner and he’s complained before about how pushy they can be. But then she started telling me about receiving reviews, really negative reviews by clients, and she couldn’t figure out who these clients were. 'She was really upset over it. And then she received a review where the client listed ailments about themsel[f] that she had never seen before, and this was the day after she had gotten off the phone with someone from Yelp,' Milliken told International Business Times. Tense: Last month, filmmaker Milliken (right) appeared on CNBC to speak about the movie. Yelp spokeswoman Shannon Eis (left) also appeared on the show to defend the company . Last month, Milliken released a trailer for her documentary in an attempt to fund the rest of the film's production. The day after the trailer was released, Yelp stock dipped four per cent. Following the stock drop, Yelp issued a statement to Business Insider, fiercely denying the claims in the trailer. 'There is no merit to the claims they appear to highlight, which have been repeatedly dismissed by courts of law, investigated by government regulators, including the FTC, and disproven by academic study,' the company said. On the contrary, Yelp says its algorithm protects businesses, by weeding out potentially fraudulent posts seeking to boost a company's rating or drag it down. As a result, only about 75 per cent of posts are approved for posting on the site while the rest remain in a partially-hidden 'filtered reviews' section on each businesses' page. 'Because businesses have attempted to manipulate their ratings and those of their competitors by trying to post fake reviews, we have to protect consumers and honest businesses by preventing this behavior. As a result, Yelp has automated recommendation software in place to go through the more than 71 million reviews that have been submitted to Yelp to select the most useful and reliable content,' the company said in a statement to Daily Mail Online. Yelp's company spokesman Shannon Eis went on CNBC to speak out against the documentary in a segment with Milliken, to further illustrate how the company's business practices have been backed by both the courts and independent investigations. However, the Harvard Business School study that the Eis cited in Yelp's defense wasn't solely focused on whether advertising impacts the ratings of businesses listed on the site - rather the investigation was designed to find out how many of the reviews on the site were fake. While the study's authors did find that businesses that advertise on the site are no more likely to have extreme 1 or 5-star ratings than any other business, they made it clear that Yelp's advertising practices were not the topic of their study and therefore their research was not exhaustive. 'While our analysis provides some suggestive evidence against the theory that Yelp favors advertisers, we stress that it is neither exhaustive, nor conclusive. It is beyond the scope of this paper, and outside the capacity of our dataset to evaluate all the ways in which Yelp could favor advertisers,' the paper reads. Standing up: Milliken says that most of the business owners she spoke to were too afraid to appear on camera, for fear of retaliation fro Yelp. Pictured on the left interviewing a business owner, in a photo posted to her production company's website . Work to be done: The Kickstarter campaign to fund Milliken's project reached its $60,000 goal. She plans to resume filming in May and have a rough cut by fall . Milliken says she doesn't place much faith in these cases or investigations, after interviewing several small business owners in the course of her research. 'One company began to advertise with Yelp, but then stopped when their contract came up. The next month they went from five stars to four stars, and then three stars. That story is so common. It happens over and over again and a lot of businesses feel so frustrated at this point,' Milliken told Daily Mail Online. Milliken says that these business owners were so afraid of Yelp that about 80 per cent of them refused to go on camera for fear of retaliation on their own Yelp pages - which they are not allowed to opt out of. In their CNBC talk, Eis also accused Milliken of having a conflict of interest, since she had created several Yelp accounts to write fake reviews of businesses - including her husband's law practice. Milliken admitted to setting up the accounts, but said they were part of her research for the project. 'I think it's shocking and very telling that this billion dollar corporation has come after this grassroots production company - where there are only two of us - creating a documentary that were still in production over...and Yelp has fired back with all that...I think it does clearly show that they are concerned about what will be coming out in the documentary,' Milliken said on CNBC. Daily Mail Online reached out to Yelp for evidence of the allegedly fake reviews Milliken wrote, and the company sent screen grabs that show several accounts tied to the filmmaker and the fact that she commented on her husband's business page. While the 5-star reviews appear to be dated in 2011 (before Milliken says she started working on the documentary), Yelp did not provide copies of the actual reviews. Milliken says she reached out to Yelp for a sit-down interview, but that CEO Jeremy Stoppelman declined. In a statement, the company spokesman explained why they decided to pass on speaking to Milliken. 'Given that the title of the documentary already declares Yelp a bully before production and with a clear disregard for highly credible conclusions, we can be quite certain that our CEO's participation and any objective facts will not be fairly heard. We don't believe Mrs. Milliken is interested in the truth, considering she's shown such a disregard for it so far,' the statement reads. Prost Production's Kickstarter campaign reached its $60,000 funding goal, and Milliken says she will resume filming in May with plans to finish the project in fall so that she can submit it to the Sundance Film Festival. | Billion Dollar Bully, an upcoming documentary, focuses on the review site's impact on small businesses . Filmmaker Kaylie Milliken spoke to several business owners who believe their Yelp ratings went down after they declined to advertise on the site . The company has denied the allegations, citing court rulings, an FTC investigation and a Harvard study as validation of their business practices . | [
"What focuses on something? Billion Dollar Bully",
"What does something focus on? the review site 's impact on small businesses",
"Who spoke to someone? Filmmaker Kaylie Milliken",
"Who did someone speak to? several business owners",
"What went somewhere? Yelp ratings",
"Where did something go? down",
"When did something go somewhere? after they declined to advertise on the site",
"Who declined to do something? business owners",
"What did someone decline to do? advertise on the site",
"Who didn't advertise somewhere? they",
"Where didn't someone advertise? on the site",
"Who was citing something? The company",
"What was someone citing? court rulings",
"Why was someone citing something? as validation of their business practices",
"Who believes something? business owners",
"What does someone believe? their Yelp ratings went down after they declined to advertise on the site",
"Who denied something? The company",
"What did someone deny? the allegations"
] | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} | {
"bart": null,
"pegasus": null,
"brio": null,
"brio-ext": null,
"matchsum": null,
"mixtral-8x22b-instruct-v0.1": null,
"llama-3-8b-instruct": null,
"GPT4": null,
"llama-3-70b-instruct": null,
"mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1": null
} |
End of preview. Expand
in Dataset Viewer.
QAPyramid
This repo contains the data from our paper "QAPyramid: Fine-grained Evaluation of Content Selection for Text Summarization".
Please visit here for more details of this project.
QAPyramid is built on top of 500 examples from the test set of the CNNDM English news summarization dataset.
Humans (crowdsourced workers) decomposed each reference summary into QA pairs following the QA-SRL framework.
On a 50-example subset, we get model-generated summaries from 10 summarization systems. 5 of them are models finetuned on the CNNDM training set (BART, PEGASUS, BRIO, BRIO-EXT, MatchSum), and the other 5 models are 1-shot LLMs (Llama-3-8b-instruct, Llama-3-70b-instruct, Mixtral-8*7b-instruct, Mixtral-8*22b-instruct, GPT4).
Humans (crowdsourced workers) labeled whether each QA pair is present (1) or not present (0) in the system summary. present means the meaning of the QA pair is covered or can be inferred from the system summary.
System scores are the scores of each system summary for different metrics.
- Downloads last month
- 37