Source: http://kirschenbaumesq.com/article/blackman-shapiro-co-v-salzberg-8-misc2d-972-168-nys2d-590-nycity-ct-dec-11-1957
Timestamp: 2019-04-21 22:42:02+00:00

Document:
Queens County, Special Term, Part I.
Murray M. SALZBERG, M. M. S. Realty Corp., et al.
the statement: 'Please index under section 16, block 3763, 3764, 3765 and 3837.
mechanic's lien must contain. Lien Law, § § 9, subd. 7, 23.
lien never comes into being as a lien. Lien Law, § § 9, subd. 7, 23.
liens. Lien Law, § § 9, subd. 7, 23.
defective as to any parcel or parcels in blocks 4009 and 4015 in section 17.
Lien Law, § § 9, subd. 7, 23.
portions of property. Lien Law, § § 9, subd. 7, 23.
**591 *973 Leo Kessler, College Point, for plaintiff.
**592 Dreyer & Traub, Brooklyn, for defendants Murray M. Salzberg and M. M. S.
Realty Corp. (Samuel Kirschenbaum, Brooklyn, of counsel).
that they fail to state facts sufficient to constitute causes of action.
cause of action is to recover for goods sold and delivered.
which the lien is asserted.
That section and subdivision, so far as here material, read as follows: '7.
105 N.Y.S. 586, 587, affirmed 194 N.Y. 577, 88 N.E. 1132.
improvements were in fact for the benefit of all of the blocks mentioned.
property upon which the work was allegedly performed.
but that it has not located them on the map and therefore does not specify them.
cause of action to foreclose a mechanic's lien.
such a situation the entire lien is void.
properly be enforced. Blanc on Mechanics' Liens; Woolf v. Schaefer, 103 App.Div.
N.Y.S. 516, 512; Kolkman v. Eshelman, 132 Misc. 428, 230 N.Y.S. 91.
an apportionment of the amount due under the lien among portions of the land.
109 Misc. 669, 180 N.Y.S. 611.
cause of action set forth in the complaint.
and the motion to dismiss the second cause of action is denied.

References: § 9
 § 9
 § 9
 § 9
 § 9
 v. 
 v.