Source: https://www.39essex.com/barrister/nicola-greaney/
Timestamp: 2019-04-20 17:10:49+00:00

Document:
Nicola has a wide-ranging practice that encompasses public law, medical negligence, professional regulation and discipline, Court of Protection (health and welfare and property and affairs), personal injury, local government, community care and costs.
She is ranked as a leading junior in the directories in the areas of professional discipline, administrative and public law, clinical negligence, costs, Court of Protection and community care law.
Her clients include NHS and private care bodies, individuals, a range of regulators (from the General Pharmaceutical Council and the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons to the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators) and those they regulate, local authorities, individuals and companies.
She has experience as an advocate in a wide-range of courts and tribunals including the Court of Appeal.
Advising on the vires of activities by a Police and Crime Commissioner.
Acting for health bodies and local authorities in continuing healthcare disputes involving restitution / vires issues.
Advising a local authority on the legality of partnership arrangements under the NHS Act 2006 and potential breach of contract claims.
Representing health bodies in judicial review challenges to general medical and dental service contracts.
Advising local authorities on leaving care obligations.
Advising and acting in ordinary residence and related disputes.
Acting in inquests involving deaths in custody and in hospital.
Advising on issues arising from the Safeguarding Vulnerable Groups Act 2006.
Acting in a telecommunications dispute in Trinidad and Tobago with Nigel Pleming QC raising public law issues.
Representing the OS, private individuals, local authorities and health bodies in a wide range of cases involving adult health, welfare and finances in the inherent jurisdiction and before the Court of Protection including cases involving urgent medical treatment, injunctions, deprivation of liberty, physical and financial abuse and combined Court of Protection and judicial review proceedings. She has acted in a large number of medical treatment cases concerning adults and children, on behalf of Hospital Trusts, the Official Solicitor and family members including end of life cases. She is particularly well placed to deal with medical treatment cases given her wide-ranging clinical negligence experience.
Instructed in cases acting on behalf of claimants, NHS Resolution and private health care providers. Nicola has a broad practice in this area and has particular expertise in cases involving mental health or neurological disorders. She is also experienced in cases involving HRA issues.
High value claims involving delay in diagnosis and treatment of spinal injury and cauda equina.
Complicated quantum issues arising out of causation arguments.
Cerebral palsy claims – liability and quantum issues.
Negligent management of patient on warfarin and alleged warfarin overdose. Risk of stroke in any event.
MRSA / MSSA infections and seeding issues.
Head injury at work and alleged delay in arranging transfer by A and E department to specialist neurological unit.
Negligent failure to diagnose septicaemia in a drug addict leading to death. Complicated issues concerning evaluation of quantum in a fatal accident claim where dependents live in separate households following death.
Alleged negligent advice of out of hours nurse in relation to diarrhoea associated with salmonella poisoning resulting in ileostomy – issues of contribution between out of hours nurse and GPs. Causation issues as to condition in any event, particularly premorbid psychiatric history.
Alleged negligent abdominal plastic surgery.
Alleged negligent care of woman during pregnancy with anti-phospholipid syndrome, whether would have developed severe pre-eclampsia in any event.
Negligent performance of hysterectomy on a trainee GP. Pre-existing psychiatric history and issues as to impact of negligence on medical career / loss of earnings.
Alleged negligent insertion of an arterial line in a neonate leading to necrosis of the hand.
Suicide following alleged wrongful discharge from hospital.
Including disciplinary hearings, High Court applications and appeals, legal assessing and policy advice.
Representing registrants before the BACP and HCPC and UKCP.
Representing registrants before the General Osteopathic Council.
Prosecuting on behalf of the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons and defending judicial review claims brought against the RCVS.
Acting as legal advisor to CCG panels.
Representing a solicitor in a judicial review claim against the SRA.
Representing the GCC in registration appeals.
Historic abuse claims. Nicola has been instructed in cases involving the sexual abuse of children and sexual assault of adults and acts for victims and perpetrators. She is experienced in dealing with limitation and vicarious liability issues and is instructed by public bodies, including the MOD, in a number of historic abuse claims.
Claims involving chronic pain and functional neurological disorders. Recently led by Susan Rodway QC in a conversion disorder case where they achieved a £2 M settlement on behalf of their client.
Personal injuries involving accidents abroad/foreign law.
Industrial disease. Nicola was instructed by the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy as junior counsel in the Coke Workers Group Litigation Action, led by Ronald Walker QC.
Fatal accident claims with difficult financial or service dependency claims.Suicide and self-harm in detention.
Group action litigation including defence of damages claims brought by Afghan nationals arising from the conflict in Afghanistan including allegations of abuse.
Psychiatric injury/human rights claim arising from alleged wrongful delay in handing over a body for burial.
Nicola was recommended in Chambers & Partners as a leading junior in Professional Discipline, Community Care and Court of Protection law and in the Legal 500 as a leading junior in Administrative and Public Law, Clinical Negligence, Costs and Professional discipline and regulatory law (including police law).
James Robshaw v United Lincolnshire Hospitals NHS Trust  EWHC 923 (Foskett J). Very high value contested quantum trial. Nicola was led by Neil Block QC.
Ettienne v Chelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust Trust (22.10.14, Mitting J). A doctor had not been negligent when he inserted an ulnar artery catheter into a 28 week old baby’s wrist. It was acceptable for him to have adopted the procedure that he knew best. There were real difficulties in inserting a line into the posterior tibial artery. It was a balance of risks and it was essential that her blood gases were accurately and continuously monitored and blood was available to test. Nicola was instructed by the Defendant Trust.
Downes v Cheshire and Wirral Partnership NHS Foundation Trust (11. 11.14, HHJ Wood QC) Nicola was instructed by the Defendant Trust. Complicated fatal accidents claim (quantum only) raising issues as to valuation of maternal services against a background of family proceedings concerning the children and the mother having supervised contact prior to death and the approach to calculation of multiplier in fatal accidents claim. Case compromised with acceptance of Defendant’s latest part 36 offer on final day of trial.
Biznia (by his litigation friend, the Official Solicitor) v Razgulajevs (2014) High value personal injury claim brought by a Lithuanian national who sustained serious brain injury as a result of a road traffic accident in the United Kingdom. Difficult quantum issues arising from the question as to whether the Claimant would return to reside in Lithuania in the future. A case management decision precluded the Claimant from relying on certain expert and lay evidence from Lithuania and an appeal had been brought in respect of that decision. Case subsequently compromised at a RTM. Charlie Cory-Wright QC and Nicola Greaney were instructed by the Official Solicitor on behalf of the Claimant.
Ryan St George (A Patient Suing By His Father & Litigation Friend David St George) v Home Office  Quantum issues arising from prisoner who fell out of a top bunk bed while suffering a withdrawal seizure, thereby sustaining a head injury that resulted in brain damage. Quantum case settled adopting a novel approach to accommodation claim to avoid difficulties created by Roberts v Johnstone.
Smith Shiprepairers North Shields v Secretary of State for Innovation, Business and Skills. Case settled before trial. Contribution claim pursuant to the 1978 Act in respect of a claim for mesothelioma brought by the estate of the deceased in circumstances where the deceased had reached an inter vivos settlement with the defendants to the contribution claim.
Pearce v Secretary of State for Energy & Climate Change, Coal Products Limited, National Smokeless Fuels Limited (2016), Turner J, Master Gordon Sakar. Instructed as junior counsel to deal with costs management and other costs issues for the defendants.
Bakhtiyar v Secretary of State for the Home Department, Upper Tribunal, 9 September 2015. A challenge to the SSHD’s reliance on the Re Eastwood approach of assessing the costs of in-house lawyers failed.
R(Ali Zaki Mousa & ors) v Secretary of State for Defence  EWHC 2941 (DC) Consideration of the use of set-off in the context of legally aided claimants and the decision in JG v Legal Services Commission.
JBOL v PHE August 2013, Master Rowley Consideration of conduct issues and cost estimates in the context of judicial review claims.
Uwen v General Medical Council  EWHC 2484 (Admin). Application for termination of an interim suspension order by a doctor was refused. MPTS was entitled to find that probity issues arising from the doctor having practised without indemnity insurance made it necessary for her to be subject to interim suspension.
HA v University of Wolverhampton & General Pharmaceutical Council  EWHC 144. Acted for GPhC. The university was entitled to seek disclosure of criminal convictions from a student applying for the MPharm course.
PSA v (1) GDC (2) AB  EWHC 2154 (Admin), Jeremy Baker J. Unduly lenient appeal in respect of a dentist who had practised while infected with Hepatitis B.
R (on the application of Juttla & ors) v Hertfordshire Valleys Clinical Commissioning Group  EWHC 267 (Admin). Decision to cease commissioning a respite service for children was in breach of CCG’s duty to consult with the local authority about substantial development of the health service. Instructed by the CCG.
Re D (Medical Treatment)  EWCOP 15. It was in the best interests of D to travel to Serbia to receive experimental stem cell treatment for acquired brain injury. Instructed by MOD.
Re Paul Briggs  EWCOP 48, Charles J, Instructed by the Legal Aid Agency. The question of whether it was in someone’s best interests to receive artificial nutrition and hydration was an issue to be determined in s.21A MCA 2005 proceedings.
National Aids Trust v NHS Commissioning Board & Local Government Association & anr  EWHC 2005 (Admin),  EWCA Civ 1100. Instructed by LGA. NHSE had power to fund PrEP, an anti-retroviral drug to be used on a preventative basis for those at high risk of contracting HIV.
South Staffordshire and Shropshire Healthcare NHS FT & anr v The Hospital Managers of St George’s Hospital and AU  EWHC 1196, Cranston J. Acted for claimant in a judicial review of a decision by hospital managers to discharge a patient detained under the Mental Health Act. Held that a Trust had capacity to judicially review its own managers.
Re PV  EWCOP 87,  EWHC EWCOP 3707 (Charles J on appeal) and  EWCOP 22 (Senior Judge Lush at first instance). Court of Protection case concerning trusts created for the purpose of administering awards made by the Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority. No involvement of the Court of Protection was required in the settlement of such trusts because the award was not ever P’s money. Guidance given by the Court of Protection in dealing with such cases.
Re NK (July 2015, Cobb J). Withdrawal of life saving treatment from a 3 year old with a rare metabolic disorder. Acted on behalf of the family.
XCC v A  EWHC 2183 (COP) Forced marriage and the inherent jurisdiction to make a declaration of the non-recognition of a marriage.
A Local Authority v H 27 January 2012  EWHC 49 (Fam) Case concerning capacity to consent to sexual relations. Guidance on knowledge required of health risks of sexual relations and additional requirement to that set out in DBC v AB that P understands that he has a choice and may refuse.
R (Buckinghamshire CC) v Kingston upon Thames RBC  EWCA Civ 457 Consideration of the duty of consultation based on fairness or detriment.
D County Council v LS  EWHC 1916 (Fam) Consideration of test of capacity to consent to sexual relations.
R (on the application of Stamford Chamber Of Trade & Commerce) (2) F H Gilman & Co v (1) Secretary Of State For Communities & Local Government (2) South Kesteven District Council 7 April 2009  EWHC 719 (Admin) No duty of public consultation was imposed on a local planning authority, in respect of its decision not to request the saving of a safeguarding policy in the local development plan.
EM (Lebanon) v Secretary Of State For The Home Department (2008) October 2008  UKHL 64 The removal of a Lebanese asylum seeker and her 12-year-old son to Lebanon would give rise to a breach of the European Convention on Human Rights 1950 art.8 given that she would be compelled to transfer custody of her son to his father, who had been violent towards her and who had not seen the son since his birth; removal would so flagrantly violate their art.8 rights as to completely deny or nullify those rights.
R (Johnson) v Secretary of State for the Home Department  EWCA Civ 427 A prisoner serving a determinate sentence would have a right to compensation for a breach of the European Convention on Human Rights 1950 Art. 5 (4) if he could establish that there had been an unlawful delay in the consideration of his application for parole.
Gustavo Suarez Ocampo v Secretary of State for the Home Department (CA) 4 October 2006  EWCA Civ 1276 The guidelines in Devaseelan v Secretary of State for the Home Department (2002) UKIAT 702, (2003) Imm AR 1 were relevant to cases where the parties involved were not the same but there was a material overlap of evidence.
R v Police Complaints Commission ex parte Green  1 WLR 72 (CA) The extent of disclosure required by the Human Rights Act in police complaints cases.
R v Bedford Primary Care Trust ex parte Watts (QBD) 21 October 2003  EWHC 2401 (Admin);  Lloyd’s Rep Med 113 A claim for a hip operation carried out in France on the basis of EU law.

References: EWCA 
 EWCA 
 UKHL 
 art.8
 art.8
 EWCA 
 Art. 5
 EWCA