Source: http://www.carsandracingstuff.com/library/government/355US83.php
Timestamp: 2019-04-23 20:28:41+00:00

Document:
NO. 20.  ARGUED NOVEMBER 13, 1957 - DECIDED DECEMBER 9, 1957 - 139 F.
SUPP. 444, REVERSED AND REMANDED.
FOR FURTHER PROCEEDINGS IN CONFORMITY WITH THIS OPINION.  PP. 84-93.
CRITICAL FACTOR WHICH THE COMMISSION MUST ASSESS.  PP. 88-90.
NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION POLICY.  PP. 90, 92.
DIVERT SOME TRAFFIC FROM OTHER CARRIERS.  P. 91.
THE COMMISSION TO RECOGNIZE.  PP. 91-92.
SCHAFFER TRANSPORTATION CO. ET AL. V. UNITED STATES ET AL.
SAVINGS IN TIME AND MONEY."
AND, WITH FOUR COMMISSIONERS DISSENTING, ORDERED IT DENIED.  A.W.
PROBABLE JURISDICTION.  352 U.S. 923.
CARRIERS ASSN. V. UNITED STATES, 321 U.S. 194; MCLEAN TRUCKING CO. V.
SERVICE.  UNITED STATES V. DETROIT & CLEVELAND NAVIGATION CO., 326 U.S.
SERVICE BECAUSE IT MAY DIVERT SOME TRAFFIC FROM OTHER CARRIERS."
POLICY REQUIRES THE COMMISSION TO RECOGNIZE.  DIXIE CARRIERS, INC. V.
CONSIDERED RATES IRRELEVANT IN CERTIFICATION PROCEEDINGS UNDER SEC.
FURTHER IN LIGHT OF WHAT WE HAVE SAID.
DETERMINE WHERE THE PUBLIC INTEREST LIES IN A PARTICULAR SITUATION.
ADVANTAGES THEY WOULD GAIN FROM A PROPOSED MOTOR CARRIER SERVICE.
WOULD IMPAIR THE SOUND OPERATION OF THE CARRIERS ALREADY CERTIFICATED.
CONVENIENCE AND NECESSITY HAS BEEN MET.
PROCEEDINGS IN CONFORMITY WITH THIS OPINION.  IT IS SO ORDERED.
FN1  49 STAT. 551, AS AMENDED, 54 STAT. 923, 49 U.S.C. SEC. 307(A).
IN THE DISTRICT COURT BUT HAS SINCE CONCLUDED "ON FURTHER ANALYSIS"
OPERATING AUTHORITY, APPEAR AS APPELLEES ALONG WITH THE COMMISSION.
DECLARATION OF POLICY."  54 STAT. 899, 49 U.S.C. PRECEDING SEC. 1.
FN6  INTERSTATE COMMERCE COMMISSION V. PARKER, 326 U.S. 60, 70.
M.C.C. 194, 195-196; WELLSPEAK COMMON CARRIER APPLICATION, 1 M.C.C.
THE INTERSTATE COMMERCE ACT, 24 STAT. 379, AS AMENDED, 49 U.S.C. SEC.
THIS DENIAL, THE THREE-JUDGE DISTRICT COURT SUSTAINED THE COMMISSION.
CARRYING OUT ITS MANIFOLD, COMPLICATED AND FREQUENTLY ELUSIVE DUTIES.
WOULD AFFIRM THE JUDGMENT OF THE DISTRICT COURT.
FINDINGS AND THE REASONS FOR THE COMMISSION'S ACTION.

References: V. 
 V. 
 V.

 V. 
 V.

 V.