CELEX: 52010SC1515
Language: en
Date: 2010-12-03 00:00:00
Title: Recommendation for a COUNCIL RECOMMENDATION With a view to bringing an end to the situation of an excessive government deficit in Ireland

EN
EN    EN
 ---pagebreak---                     EUROPEAN COMMISSION
                                                        Brussels, 3.12.2010
                                                        SEC(2010) 1515 final
                                      Recommendation for a
                              COUNCIL RECOMMENDATION
   With a view to bringing an end to the situation of an excessive government deficit in Ireland
EN                                                                                               EN
 ---pagebreak---                                          Recommendation for a
                                 COUNCIL RECOMMENDATION
    With a view to bringing an end to the situation of an excessive government deficit in Ireland
   THE COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION,
   Having regard to the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, and in particular
   Article 126(7) in conjunction with Article 126(13) thereof;
   Having regard to the recommendation from the Commission,
   Whereas:
   (1) According to Article 126(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union
   (TFEU) Member States shall avoid excessive government deficits.
   (2) The Stability and Growth Pact is based on the objective of sound government finances as a
   means of strengthening the conditions for price stability and for strong sustainable growth
   conducive to employment creation.
   (3) The 2005 reform of the Stability and Growth Pact sought to strengthen its effectiveness
   and economic underpinnings as well as to safeguard the sustainability of the public finances
   in the long run. It aimed at ensuring that in particular the economic and budgetary background
   was taken into account fully in all steps in the excessive deficit procedure (EDP). In this way,
   the Stability and Growth Pact provides the framework supporting government policies for a
   prompt return to sound budgetary positions taking account of the economic situation.
   (4) According to Article 3(5) of Council Regulation (EC) No 1467/97, if effective action has
   been taken in compliance with a Recommendation in accordance with Article 126(7) of the
   Treaty and unexpected adverse economic events with major unfavourable consequences for
   government finances occur after the adoption of that Recommendation, the Council may
   decide, on a recommendation from the Commission, to adopt a revised Recommendation
   under Article 126(7) of the Treaty.
   (5) On 27 April 2009, the Council decided, in accordance with Article 104(6) of the Treaty
   establishing the European Community (TEC), that an excessive deficit existed in Ireland and
   issued recommendations to correct the excessive deficit by 2013 at the latest. The Council
   also set a deadline of 27 October 2009 for effective action to be taken.
   (6) On 2 December 2009, the Council concluded that the Irish authorities had taken effective
   action in compliance with the Council recommendations of 27 April 2009 but that unexpected
   adverse economic events with major unfavourable consequences for government finances
   could be considered to have occurred in Ireland. The Council therefore adopted a revised
   Recommendation under Article 126(7) of the Treaty, postponing the deadline for the
   correction of the excessive deficit to 2014.
EN                                                  2                                               EN
 ---pagebreak---    (7) On 13 July 2010, the Council concluded that the Irish authorities had taken effective
   action in compliance with the Council recommendations.
   (8) According to the Commission services' autumn 2009 forecasts, which provided the basis
   for the Council's December 2009 recommendations issued to Ireland under Article 104(7) of
   the Treaty, real GDP was expected to contract by 1.4% in 2010, followed by an expansion by
   2.6% in 2011. According to the Commission services' autumn 2010 forecasts and the most
   recent assessment made by the Commission services, the decline in output in 2010 is now
   expected to have stood at just 0.2%. However, the economic outlook has worsened over the
   last months, with real GDP growth now projected at 0.9% in 2011 and 1.9% in 2012 in the
   Commission services autumn 2010 forecast. Moreover, the impact of the crisis on the
   financial sector has turned out to be much more pronounced than anticipated. The support
   measures deemed necessary to preserve financial stability and restore confidence in the
   banking sector and thereby support the economy's return to sustainable growth have a very
   large additional budgetary cost. Due to the unforeseen capital injections in the banking sector
   and an increase in the sovereign funding costs, interest expenditure relative to GDP is
   projected to increase by 2.3 pps. by 2014 compared to the projections in the December 2009
   Stability Programme.
   (9) As a consequence, the fiscal situation is significantly worse than expected, with the
   Commission services' autumn 2010 forecast projecting the headline general government
   deficit to reach 32.3% of GDP in 2010. This reflects the large one-off banking sector support
   measures. Without these measures, the deficit would have been expected to measure12.5% of
   GDP in 2010. This is worse than the 11.6% of GDP projected in the December 2009 Stability
   Programme update but markedly better than the 14.7% of GDP projected on the basis of a no-
   policy-change assumption in the Commission services' autumn 2009 forecast underlying the
   December 2009 Council Recommendation. Relative to this no-policy-change path, and in line
   with the December 2009 Council Recommendation, a fiscal consolidation package of 2½% of
   GDP was included in the budget for 2010, and fully implemented. The cyclically adjusted
   deficit net of one-off effects is estimated to have widened by 1¼ percentage points of GDP to
   around 11% of GDP in 2010. However, this reflects developments in revenue elasticities
   during the deep recession rather than discretionary measures. On the contrary, large
   consolidation packages have been adopted since mid-2008, amounting to some 9% of GDP in
   2009-10.
   (10) The Irish economy is projected to record lower growth rates in the immediate post-crisis
   period compared to the pre-crisis boom period. In the Commission services autumn 2010
   forecast, real GDP growth is projected at 0.9% in 2011 and 1.9% in 2012. According to
   current Commission projections real GDP growth of 2.5% in 2013, 3.0% in 2014 and 3.0% in
   2015 is expected. Price developments are also expected to be moderate. Nominal GDP is
   projected to increase by 1.3% in 2011 and 2.7% in 2012 in the Commission services autumn
   2010 forecast, while increases by 3.8% in 2013, 4.6% in 2014 and 4.8% in 2015 are expected
   according to current Commission projections. Given these macroeconomic assumptions,
   reducing the government deficit to below 3% of GDP by 2015 would require an improvement
   in the structural balance of at least 9½% of GDP over the period 2011-2015.
   (11) Overall, in view of the above considerations, unexpected adverse economic events with
   major unfavourable consequences for government finances can be considered to have
   occurred after adoption of the Recommendation under Article 126(7) of the Treaty. Moreover,
   the conclusion reached by the Council on 13 July 2010 that Ireland had taken action
   representing adequate progress towards the correction of the excessive deficit remains valid.
EN                                                  3                                              EN
 ---pagebreak---    Finally, the higher starting point for the government deficit, compounded by the worse
   macroeconomic outlook and higher than foreseen interest expenditures make the achievement
   of the initial deficit reduction path unfeasible. Against this background, revised
   recommendations under Article 126(7) of the Treaty extending the deadline for the correction
   of the excessive deficit by one year to 2015 are justified.
   (12) Gross public debt increased from 25% of GDP in 2007 to 65.5% of GDP at end 2009,
   thereby breaching the 60%-of-GDP reference value of the Treaty. The ratio is projected to
   increase to 97.4% of GDP at end 2010 in the Commission services' autumn 2010 forecasts.
   The increase relative to the low pre-crisis level has been fuelled by a large primary general
   government deficit emerging in the course of this crisis. Measures to support the vulnerable
   banking sector made a significant contribution to the increase in deficit and debt in 2009 and
   2010 of around 22½ percentage points of GDP in cumulative terms over the two years.
   Moreover, increased interest payments are feeding into debt developments. Achieving a
   revised deficit reduction path leading to a deficit below 3% of GDP in 2015 would imply that
   the debt ratio would stabilise in 2013 and start declining thereafter. Debt dynamics are
   affected by several below-the-line operations, which are projected to increase the debt-to-
   GDP ratio by 5.3 pps. of GDP in 2011, 0.8 pp. in 2010 and reduce it by 1.3 pps. in 2013, 1.1
   pps. in 2014 and 1 pp. in 2015. These include projected capital injection into banks and
   reductions in cash reserves in 2011, as well as differences between accrued and cash interest
   payments.
   (13) On 24 November 2010 the authorities published a comprehensive National Recovery
   Plan 2011-2014 setting out detailed fiscal consolidation plans aiming at putting gross public
   debt on a firm downward path by reducing the deficit over the horizon of the plan. An overall
   consolidation effort of EUR 15bn is envisaged over the period, effectively doubling the
   adjustment of EUR 7.5bn foreseen in the December 2009 Stability Programme update. The
   adjustment is clearly frontloaded, with a EUR 6bn consolidation package planned for 2011. It
   is foreseen that two thirds of the adjustment should be made on the expenditure side. The plan
   also sets out structural reforms, notably in the labour market. Moreover, the authorities have
   developed a comprehensive strategy to overhaul the financial sector. The strategy aims at
   restoring confidence in the sector, achieving a substantial downsizing of the sector, isolating
   the viable parts of the system and returning the sector to healthy functionality, supported by
   adequate recapitalisation measures.
   (14) In order to further enhance the credibility of the medium-term consolidation strategy, it
   will be crucial to address the weaknesses of the budgetary framework. Ireland should adopt
   and implement the fiscal rule that any additional unplanned revenues in 2011-2015 will be
   allocated to deficit and debt reduction. In accordance with the proposal set out in the National
   Recovery Plan 2011-2014, Ireland should establish a budgetary advisory council to provide an
   independent assessment of the Government's budgetary position and forecasts. Finally,
   adoption of a Fiscal Responsibility Law introducing a medium-term expenditure framework
   with binding multi-annual ceilings on expenditure in each area would support the planned
   adjustment. This shall be made taking into account any revised economic governance reforms
   at EU level and build on reforms already in place.
   (15) The long-term budgetary impact of ageing in Ireland is above the EU average, mainly as
   a result of a relatively high projected increase in pension expenditure over the coming
   decades. The budgetary position in 2010 compounds the budgetary impact of population
   ageing on the sustainability gap. Improving the primary balance over the medium term and
EN                                                 4                                                EN
 ---pagebreak---    further reforms would contribute to reducing the risk to the long-term sustainability of public
   finances.
   (16) Enhanced surveillance under the EDP, which seems necessary in view of the deadline for
   the correction of the excessive deficit, will require regular and timely monitoring of the
   progress made in the implementation of the fiscal consolidation strategy. In this context, a
   separate chapter in the updates of the Irish stability programme which will be prepared
   between 2009 and 2015 could usefully be devoted to this issue. Moreover, monitoring of
   fiscal targets will be undertaken in line with the provisions of the financial assistance
   programme for Ireland as also set out in the [7] December 2010 Council Decision on granting
   Union financial assistance addressed to Ireland.
   HEREBY RECOMMENDS:
   1.        Recognising that Ireland’s worse budgetary position in 2010 resulted from the impact
             of the crisis on government revenue and the financial sector, requiring the
             implementation of very large financial sector support measures, the Irish authorities
             should put an end to the present excessive deficit situation by 2015.
   2.        The Irish authorities should bring the general government deficit below 3% of GDP
             in a credible and sustainable manner by taking action in a medium-term framework.
             Specifically, to this end, the Irish authorities should:
             (a) Implement measures such that the general government deficit does not exceed
             10.6% of projected GDP in 2011, 8.6% of GDP in 2012, 7.5% of GDP in 2013, 5.1%
             of GDP in 2014 and 2.9% of GDP in 2015, and where the projected annual deficit
             path does not incorporate the possible direct effect of potential bank support
             measures in the context of the government's financial sector strategy as set out in the
             Memorandum of Economic and Financial Polices (MEFP) and specified in the
             Memorandum of Understanding to be signed by the Commission and the Irish
             authorities. Ireland shall stand ready to take additional consolidation measures to
             ensure reducing the deficit to below 3% of GDP in 2015 in case downside risks to
             the deficit targets materialise. Further, this path is consistent with the preliminary
             view of Eurostat on the ESA95 accounting treatment of time of recording of interest
             payments on promissory notes payable to Anglo Irish Bank1, such that a revision of
             that view would result in a revision of the deficit path;
             (b) Achieve an improvement in the structural balance of at least 9½% of GDP over
             the period 2011-2015;
   3.        In addition, the Irish authorities should seize opportunities, including from better
             economic conditions, to accelerate the reduction of the gross debt ratio back towards
             the 60% of GDP reference value.
   4.        To limit risks to the adjustment, Ireland should establish a budgetary advisory
             council to provide an independent assessment of the Government's budgetary
             position and forecasts. Ireland should adopt a Fiscal Responsibility Law introducing
   1
           See
           http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/portal/page/portal/government_finance_statistics/methodology/advice_
           member_states.
EN                                                        5                                                      EN
 ---pagebreak---              a medium-term expenditure framework with binding multi-annual ceilings on
             expenditure in each area.
   5.        To reduce the risks to the long-term sustainability of public finances, the Irish
             authorities should pursue further reforms to the social security system.
   6.        The Council establishes the deadline of 7 June 2011 for the Irish government to take
             effective action to specify the measures that will be necessary to progress towards the
             correction of the excessive deficit. The assessment of effective action will take into
             account economic developments compared to the economic outlook in the
             Commission services' autumn 2010 forecast.
   The Irish authorities should report on progress made in the implementation of these
   recommendations in a separate chapter in the updates of the stability programmes which will
   be prepared between 2011 and 2015.
   Further, the Council invites the Irish authorities to implement reforms with a view to raising
   potential GDP growth. In addition, Ireland is invited to foster a swift adjustment to
   sustainable medium-term growth by productivity-enhancing measures and appropriate wage
   policies to help restore competitiveness.
   This Recommendation is addressed to Ireland.
   Done at Brussels, […]
                                                 For the Council
                                                 The President
EN                                                  6                                                EN