CELEX: C1999/136/15
Language: el
Date: 1999-05-15 00:00:00
Title: Υπόθεση C-72/99: Αίτηση για την έκδοση προδικαστικής αποφάσεως που υπέβαλε η Landesvergabeamt Tirol, με διάταξη της 17ης Φεβρουαρίου 1999, στην υπόθεση Firma Ortner GmbH κατά Innsbrucker Kommunalbetriebe AG

1.5.1999                  EL                     ∂ÈãÛËÌË ∂ÊËÌÂÚÈã‰· ÙˆÓ ∂˘Úˆ·ÈåÎã̂ Ó ∫ÔÈÓÔÙËãÙˆÓ                                          C 136/9
— Ó· Î·Ù·‰ÈÎ·ãÛÂÈ ÙÔ ∏ÓˆÌÂãÓÔ µ·ÛÈãÏÂÈÔ ÛÙ· ‰ÈÎ·ÛÙÈÎ·ã ÂãÍÔ‰·.              πÛ¯˘ÚÈÛÌÔÈã Î·È Îã̆ ÚÈ· ÂÈ¯ÂÈÚËãÌ·Ù·
πÛ¯˘ÚÈÛÌÔÈã Î·È Îã̆ ÚÈ· ÂÈ¯ÂÈÚËãÌ·Ù·                                       √È ‰È·ÊÔÚÂã˜ ÙˆÓ ÂÈ‰ÈãÎˆÓ ÔÛã̂ Ó ÙÔ˘ ÙÂãÏÔ˘˜ ˘ËÚÂÛÈã̂ Ó ÚÔ˜
                                                                            ÂÈ‚·ãÙÂ˜ Î·È ÙÔ˘ ÙÂãÏÔ˘˜ ·ÛÊ·ÏÂÈã·˜ ÚÂãÂÈ Ó· ÂÍÂÙ·ÛıÔã̆ Ó ˘Ôã ÙÔ
™ã̆ ÌÊˆÓ· ÌÂ ÙÔ ·ãÚıÚÔ 3 ·Ú·ãÁÚ·ÊÔ˜ 1 ÙË˜ Ô‰ËÁÈã·˜, Ù· ÎÚ·ãÙË ÌÂãÏË        ÚÈãÛÌ· ÙË˜ ÎÔÈÓÔÙÈÎËã˜ ÓÔÌÔıÂÛÈã·˜, Î·È Û˘ÁÎÂÎÚÈÌÂãÓ· ÙÔ˘ Î·ÓÔ-
ÚÔÛ‰ÈÔÚÈã˙Ô˘Ó, Ûã̆ ÌÊˆÓ· ÌÂ Ù· ··ÚÈıÌÔã̆ ÌÂÓ· ÛÙÔ ·Ú·ãÚÙËÌ· π            ÓÈÛÌÔã̆ (∂√∫) ·ÚÈı. 2408/92, Î·È ÙˆÓ ·Ú¯ã̂ Ó ÙË˜ ÂÏÂã̆ ıÂÚË˜ ·ÚÔ¯Ëã˜
ÎÚÈÙËãÚÈ·, Î·È ÂÊÔãÛÔÓ ‰ÂÓ Âã¯ÂÈ ·Ó·ÏËÊıÂÈã ‰Ú·ãÛË Ûã̆ ÌÊˆÓ· ÌÂ ÙÔ          ˘ËÚÂÛÈã̂ Ó, ÙÈ˜ ÔÔÈãÂ˜ Î·ıÈÂÚã̂ ÓÂÈ Ë Û˘ÓıËãÎË, Î·È ÂÈ‰ÈÎÔãÙÂÚ· ÙÔ
·ãÚıÚÔ 5 ÙË˜ Ô‰ËÁÈã·˜, Ù· ã̆ ‰·Ù· Ô˘ ˘ÊÈãÛÙ·ÓÙ·È Úã̆ ·ÓÛË Î·È Ù·          ·ãÚıÚÔ 59 ·˘ÙËã˜. ÀÔã ÙÔ ÚÈãÛÌ· ‰Â ÙË˜ ÂÓÈ·Èã·˜ ·ÁÔÚ·ã˜, Ë ÂÏÂ˘ıÂÚÈã·
 ã̆ ‰·Ù· Ô˘ ÂÓ‰Âã¯ÂÙ·È Ó· ÙËÓ ˘ÔÛÙÔã̆ Ó.                                  ÙÔ˘ ·ãÚıÚÔ˘ 59 ÙË˜ Û˘ÓıËãÎË˜ ÂÌÔ‰Èã˙ÂÈ ÙËÓ ÂÊ·ÚÌÔÁËã Î·ãıÂ ÓÔÌÔıÂ-
                                                                            ÛÈã·˜ Ô˘ Âã¯ÂÈ ˆ˜ ·ÔÙÂãÏÂÛÌ· Ó· Î·ıÈÛÙ·ã ÙËÓ ·ÚÔ¯Ëã ˘ËÚÂÛÈã̂ Ó
∞ÏÏ·ã, ÂÓã̂ Ë Ô‰ËÁÈã· ··ÈÙÂÈã ÙÔÓ ÚÔÛ‰ÈÔÚÈÛÌÔã ÙˆÓ ÁÏ˘ÎÂãˆÓ ˘‰·ãÙˆÓ       ÌÂÙ·Íã̆ ÎÚ·Ùã̂ Ó ÌÂÏã̂ Ó ‰˘Û¯ÂÚÂãÛÙÂÚË ·Ôã ÙËÓ ·ÚÔ¯Ëã ˘ËÚÂÛÈã̂ Ó
ÂÈÊ·ÓÂÈã·˜ Ô˘ ‰ÂÓ ÚÔÔÚÈã˙ÔÓÙ·È Ëã ‰ÂÓ ¯ÚËÛÈÌÔÔÈÔã̆ ÓÙ·È ÁÈ· ÙË          Ô˘ ÂÚÈÔÚÈã˙ÂÙ·È ·ÌÈÁã̂ ˜ ÂÓÙÔã˜ ÙˆÓ ÔÚÈãˆÓ ÎÚ·ãÙÔ˘˜ ÌÂãÏÔ˘˜ (‚Ï.
ÏËã„Ë ÔãÛÈÌÔ˘ ã̆ ‰·ÙÔ˜, Ë Ú·ÁÌ·ÙÈÎËã Ëã ‰˘ÓËÙÈÎËã ÂÚÈÂÎÙÈÎÔãÙËÙ·         ·ÔãÊ·ÛË ÙË˜ 25Ë˜ πÔ˘ÏÈãÔ˘ 1991, ˘ÔãıÂÛË C-288/89, ™˘ÏÏÔÁËã 1991,
ÙÔ˘ ÔÔÈãÔ˘ ÛÂ ÓÈÙÚÈÎ·ã ÈÔãÓÙ· ÂÈãÓ·È ˘ÂÚ‚ÔÏÈÎËã, ÚÔÛ‰ÈÔÚÈãÛÙËÎ·Ó,        Û. π-4007). ∂ÈãÓ·È Û·ÊÂã˜, Ôã¯È ÌÔãÓÔ ‚·ãÛÂÈ ÙÔ˘ ÁÚ·ãÌÌ·ÙÔ˜ ÙÔ˘ Î·ÓÔ-
Ûã̆ ÌÊˆÓ· ÌÂ ÙÔ ·ãÚıÚÔ 3 ·Ú·ãÁÚ·ÊÔ˜ 1 ÙË˜ Ô‰ËÁÈã·˜, ÚÔÊ·Óã̂ ˜             ÓÈÛÌÔã̆ (∂√∫) ·ÚÈı. 2408/92, ·ÏÏ·ã Î·È ‚·ãÛÂÈ ÙˆÓ ‰È·Ù·ãÍÂˆÓ ÙÔ˘
ÌÔãÓÔ Ù· ã̆ ‰·Ù· ÂÈÊ·ÓÂÈã·˜ Ô˘ ÚÔÔÚÈã˙ÔÓÙ·È ÁÈ· ÙË ÏËã„Ë ÔãÛÈÌÔ˘        ·ãÚıÚÔ˘ 7∞ ÙË˜ Û˘ÓıËãÎË˜ ∂∫ Î·È ÙË˜ ÚËÙËã˜ ÙÔ˘ ·Ú·ÔÌËã˜ ÛÙÔ
 ã̆ ‰·ÙÔ˜.                                                                  ·ãÚıÚÔ 84, Ô˘ Û˘ÓÈÛÙ·ã ÙË ÓÔÌÈÎËã ‚·ãÛË ÙÔ˘ Î·ÓÔÓÈÛÌÔã̆ , ÔãÙÈ Ë
                                                                            ÂÏÂ˘ıÂÚÈã· ·ÚÔ¯Ëã˜ ˘ËÚÂÛÈã̂ Ó ·ÂÚÔÔÚÈÎËã˜ ÌÂÙ·ÊÔÚ·ã˜ ÂÓÙÔã˜ ÙË˜
                                                                            ∫ÔÈÓÔãÙËÙ·˜ ·ÔÙÂÏÂÈã ·Ó·ÔãÛ·ÛÙÔ ÙÌËãÌ· ·˘ÙËã˜ ÙË˜ ÂÓÈ·Èã·˜
∂ÈãÛË˜, ÂÓã̂ Ë Ô‰ËÁÈã· ··ÈÙÂÈã ÙÔÓ ÚÔÛ‰ÈÔÚÈÛÌÔã ÔãÏˆÓ ÙˆÓ ˘Ôã-
                                                                            ·ÁÔÚ·ã˜. ∆Ô ·ãÚıÚÔ 59 Î·ÙÈÛ¯ã̆ ÂÈ ÙË˜ ÂÊ·ÚÌÔÁËã˜ ÙË˜ ÂıÓÈÎËã˜ ÓÔÌÔıÂ-
ÁÂÈˆÓ ˘‰·ãÙˆÓ Ô˘ ÂÚÈÂã¯Ô˘Ó Ëã ı· ÌÔÚÔã̆ Û·Ó Ó· ÂÚÈÂã¯Ô˘Ó ÂÚÈÛ-
                                                                            ÛÈã·˜, ÏËÓ ·Ó ·˘ÙËã ‰ÈÎ·ÈÔÏÔÁÂÈãÙ·È ÁÈ· ÏÔãÁÔ˘˜ ‰ËÌÔÛÈãÔ˘ Û˘ÌÊÂã-
ÛÔãÙÂÚÔ ·Ôã 50 mg/l ÓÈÙÚÈÎã̂ Ó ÈÔãÓÙˆÓ, ÂÊÔãÛÔÓ ‰ÂÓ Âã¯ÂÈ ·Ó·ÏËÊıÂÈã
                                                                            ÚÔÓÙÔ˜, ·Ó·ÁÎ·ÈãÔ˘˜ Î·È ÙÂÏÔã̆ ÓÙÂ˜ ÛÂ ·Ó·ÏÔÁÈã· ÚÔ˜ ÙÔÓ ÊÂÚÔãÌÂÓÔ
‰Ú·ãÛË Ûã̆ ÌÊˆÓ· ÌÂ ÙÔ ·ãÚıÚÔ 5, ÚÔÛ‰ÈÔÚÈãÛÙËÎ·Ó, Ûã̆ ÌÊˆÓ· ÌÂ ÙÔ
                                                                            ÛÎÔÔã. ∫·Ù·ã ÙËÓ ·ãÔ„Ë ÙË˜ ∂ÈÙÚÔËã˜, ÔÈ ‰ÈÎ·ÈÔÏÔÁÈãÂ˜ ÙÈ˜ ÔÔÈãÂ˜
·ãÚıÚÔ 3 ·Ú·ãÁÚ·ÊÔ˜ 1 ÙË˜ Ô‰ËÁÈã·˜, ÚÔÊ·Óã̂ ˜ ÌÔãÓÔÓ ËÁÂã˜ ˘Ô-
                                                                            ÚÔ‚·ãÏÏÔ˘Ó ÁÈ· Ù· ÂÈã‰ÈÎ· ÌÂãÙÚ· ÔÈ ÔÚÙÔÁ·ÏÈÎÂã˜ ·Ú¯Âã˜ ‰ÂÓ
ÁÂÈãˆÓ ˘‰·ãÙˆÓ.
                                                                            ÏËÚÔã̆ Ó Î·ÌÌÈã· ·Ôã ÙÈ˜ ·Ú··ãÓˆ ÚÔå̆ÔıÂãÛÂÈ˜.
(1) ∂∂ L 375 ÙË˜ 31.12.1991, Û. 1.
                                                                            (1) EE L 240 ÙË˜ 24.8.1992, Û. 1.
¶ÚÔÛÊ˘ÁËã ÙË˜ ∂ÈÙÚÔËã˜ ÙˆÓ ∂˘Úˆ·ÈåÎã̂ Ó ∫ÔÈÓÔÙËãÙˆÓ Î·Ù·ã ¶ÔÚ-
ÙÔÁ·ÏÈÎËã˜ ¢ËÌÔÎÚ·ÙÈã·˜, Ô˘ ·ÛÎËãıËÎÂ ÛÙÈ˜ 26 ºÂ‚ÚÔ˘·ÚÈãÔ˘ 1999
                           (ÀÔãıÂÛË C-70/99)                               ∞ÈãÙËÛË ÁÈ· ÙËÓ ÂãÎ‰ÔÛË ÚÔ‰ÈÎ·ÛÙÈÎËã˜ ·ÔÊ·ãÛÂˆ˜ Ô˘ ˘Âã‚·ÏÂ Ë
                                                                            Landesvergabeamt Tirol, ÌÂ ‰È·ãÙ·ÍË ÙË˜ 17Ë˜ ºÂ‚ÚÔ˘·ÚÈãÔ˘ 1999,
                             (1999/C 136/14)                                ÛÙËÓ ˘ÔãıÂÛË Firma Ortner GmbH Î·Ù·ã Innsbrucker
                                                                                                    Kommunalbetriebe AG
∏ ∂ÈÙÚÔËã ÙˆÓ ∂˘Úˆ·ÈåÎã̂ Ó ∫ÔÈÓÔÙËãÙˆÓ, ÂÎÚÔÛˆÔã̆ ÌÂÓË ·Ôã
ÙÔ˘˜ Frank Benyon, ÓÔÌÈÎÔã Ûã̆ Ì‚Ô˘ÏÔ, Î·È Francisco de Sousa Fialho,                                 (ÀÔãıÂÛË C-72/99)
ÌÂãÏÔ˜ ÙË˜ ¡ÔÌÈÎËã˜ ÀËÚÂÛÈã·˜, ÌÂ ·ÓÙÈãÎÏËÙÔ ÛÙÔ §Ô˘ÍÂÌ‚Ôã̆ ÚÁÔ
ÙÔ˘˜ Carlos Gómez de la Cruz, ÌÂãÏÔ˜ ÙË˜ ¡ÔÌÈÎËã˜ ÀËÚÂÛÈã·˜,
Centre Wagner, Kirchberg, ·ãÛÎËÛÂ ÂÓã̂ ÈÔÓ ÙÔ˘ ¢ÈÎ·ÛÙËÚÈãÔ˘ ÙˆÓ                                         (1999/C 136/15)
∂˘Úˆ·ÈåÎã̂ Ó ∫ÔÈÓÔÙËãÙˆÓ ÛÙÈ˜ 26 ºÂ‚ÚÔ˘·ÚÈãÔ˘ 1999 ÚÔÛÊ˘ÁËã
Î·Ù·ã ÙË˜ ¶ÔÚÙÔÁ·ÏÈÎËã˜ ¢ËÌÔÎÚ·ÙÈã·˜.
                                                                            ªÂ ‰È·ãÙ·ÍË ÙË˜ 17Ë˜ ºÂ‚ÚÔ˘·ÚÈãÔ˘ 1999, Ë ÔÔÈã· ÂÚÈËãÏıÂ ÛÙË
∏ ÚÔÛÊÂã̆ ÁÔ˘Û· ˙ËÙÂÈã ·Ôã ÙÔ ¢ÈÎ·ÛÙËãÚÈÔ:                                °Ú·ÌÌ·ÙÂÈã· ÙÔ˘ ¢ÈÎ·ÛÙËÚÈãÔ˘ ÙˆÓ ∂˘Úˆ·ÈåÎã̂ Ó ∫ÔÈÓÔÙËãÙˆÓ ÛÙÈ˜
                                                                            2 ª·ÚÙÈãÔ˘ 1999, Ë Landesvergabeamt Tirol, ÛÙÔ Ï·ÈãÛÈÔ ÙË˜ ‰È·ÊÔ-
— Ó· ·Ó·ÁÓˆÚÈãÛÂÈ ÔãÙÈ Ë ¶ÔÚÙÔÁ·ÏÈÎËã ¢ËÌÔÎÚ·ÙÈã·, ‰È·ÙËÚã̂ ÓÙ·˜            Ú·ã˜ ÌÂÙ·Íã̆ Firma Ortner GmbH Î·È Innsbrucker Kommunalbetriebe
      ÙÔÓ Î·ÓÔãÓ· ÙÔ˘ ·ãÚıÚÔ˘ 10 ÙÔ˘ Î·ÓÔÓÈÛÙÈÎÔã̆ ‰È·Ù·ãÁÌ·ÙÔ˜             AG Ô˘ ÂÎÎÚÂÌÂÈã ÂÓã̂ ÈÔãÓ ÙË˜, ˙ËÙÂÈã ·Ôã ÙÔ ¢ÈÎ·ÛÙËãÚÈÔ ÙËÓ ÂãÎ‰ÔÛË
      38/91, ÙË˜ 29Ë˜ πÔ˘ÏÈãÔ˘ 1991, ‚·ãÛÂÈ ÙÔ˘ ÔÔÈãÔ˘ ÙËãÛÂÈ˜ ·Ôã ÙËÓ   ÚÔ‰ÈÎ·ÛÙÈÎËã˜ ·ÔÊ·ãÛÂˆ˜ ÂÈã ÙˆÓ ÂÍËã˜ ÂÚˆÙËÌ·ãÙˆÓ:
      ¶ÔÚÙÔÁ·ÏÈã· ÚÔ˜ ·ãÏÏ· ÎÚ·ãÙË ÌÂãÏË ˘ÔãÎÂÈÓÙ·È ÛÙËÓ ÏËÚˆÌËã
      ÙÂÏã̂ Ó ˘„ËÏÔÙÂãÚˆÓ ·Ôã ÂÎÂÈãÓ· Ù· ÔÔÈã· ÈÛ¯ã̆ Ô˘Ó ÛÙÈ˜ ÙËãÛÂÈ˜    ∞. ÀÔ¯ÚÂÔã̆ ÓÙ·È Ù· ÎÚ·ãÙË ÌÂãÏË Î·Ù·ã ÙÔ ·ãÚıÚÔ 2 ·Ú·ãÁÚ·ÊÔ˜ 6
      ÂÛˆÙÂÚÈÎÔã̆ , Î·È ‰È·ÙËÚã̂ ÓÙ·˜ ÙË ‰È·ãÙ·ÍË ÙÔ˘ Decreto-Lei 102/91         ÙË˜ Ô‰ËÁÈã·˜ 89/665/∂√∫(1), ÛÙÔ Ï·ÈãÛÈÔ ÙË˜ ÌÂÙ·ÊÔÚ·ã˜ ÙË˜
      ÙË˜ 8Ë˜ ª·ÚÙÈãÔ˘ 1991, Ôãˆ˜ ÙÂãıËÎÂ ÛÂ ÂÎÙÂãÏÂÛË ·Ôã ÙÈ˜                 ÛÙÔ ÂÛˆÙÂÚÈÎÔã ‰ÈãÎ·ÈÔ, Ó· ÚÔ‚ÏÂãÔ˘Ó ÛÂ Î·ãıÂ ÂÚÈãÙˆÛË
      Â·ÎÔÏÔ˘ıËãÛ·ÛÂ˜ ÂÎÙÂÏÂÛÙÈÎÂã˜ ·ÔÊ·ãÛÂÈ˜, Î·Ù·ã ÙËÓ ÔÔÈã· ÔÈ             ‰È·‰ÈÎ·ÛÈã· Î·Ù·ã ÙËÓ ÔÔÈã· Ô ·ÈÙã̂ Ó ÌÔÚÂÈã, ÂÊÔãÛÔÓ Û˘ÓÙÚÂã¯Ô˘Ó
      ÙËãÛÂÈ˜ ·Ôã ÙËÓ ¶ÔÚÙÔÁ·ÏÈã· ÚÔ˜ ·ãÏÏ· ÎÚ·ãÙË ÌÂãÏË ˘ÔãÎÂÈÓÙ·È          ÔÈ ÚÔå̆ÔıÂãÛÂÈ˜, Ó· ÚÔÎ·ÏÂãÛÂÈ ÙËÓ ·Îã̆ ÚˆÛË ÙË˜ ÚÈÓ ·Ôã
      ÛÙËÓ ÏËÚˆÌËã ÙÂÏã̂ Ó ˘„ËÏÔÙÂãÚˆÓ ·Ôã ÂÎÂÈãÓ· Ù· ÔÔÈã· ÈÛ¯ã̆ Ô˘Ó         ÙË Ûã̆ Ó·„Ë ÙË˜ Û˘Ì‚·ãÛÂˆ˜ ·ÔÊ·ãÛÂˆ˜ ÙË˜ ·Ó·ıÂãÙÔ˘Û·˜ ·Ú¯Ëã˜
      ÛÂ ÔÚÈÛÌÂãÓÂ˜ ÙËãÛÂÈ˜ ÂÛˆÙÂÚÈÎÔã̆ , ·ÚÂã‚Ë ÙÈ˜ ˘Ô¯ÚÂã̂ ÛÂÈ˜ Ô˘         ÌÂ ÙËÓ ÔÔÈã· ·˘ÙËã ·ÔÊ·ÛÈã˙ÂÈ ÌÂ ÔÈÔÓ ÚÔÛÊÂãÚÔÓÙ· ÛÙÔ
      ˘Âã¯ÂÈ ·Ôã ÙÔ ·ãÚıÚÔ 3 ·Ú·ãÁÚ·ÊÔ˜ 1 ÙÔ˘ Î·ÓÔÓÈÛÌÔã̆ (∂√∫)               Ï·ÈãÛÈÔ ‰È·ÁˆÓÈÛÌÔã̆ ı· Û˘Ó·ã„ÂÈ ÙË Ûã̆ Ì‚·ÛË ‚·ãÛÂÈ ÙˆÓ ·ÔÙÂ-
      ·ÚÈı. 2408/92(1)Ø                                                          ÏÂÛÌ·ãÙˆÓ ÙÔ˘ ‰È·ÁˆÓÈÛÌÔã̆ ·˘ÙÔã̆ (ÂÔÌÂãÓˆ˜ ÙË˜ ·ÔÊ·ãÛÂˆ˜
                                                                                 ÂÚÈã Î·Ù·Î˘Úã̂ ÛÂˆ˜), ·Ú·ã ÙË ‰˘Ó·ÙÔãÙËÙ· ÂÚÈÔÚÈÛÌÔã̆ ÙˆÓ
— Ó· Î·Ù·‰ÈÎ·ãÛÂÈ ÙËÓ ¶ÔÚÙÔÁ·ÏÈÎËã ¢ËÌÔÎÚ·ÙÈã· ÛÙ· ‰ÈÎ·ÛÙÈÎ·ã                    ÂÓÓÔãÌˆÓ Û˘ÓÂÂÈã̂ Ó ÙË˜ ‰È·‰ÈÎ·ÛÈã·˜ ÚÔÛÊ˘ÁËã˜, ÌÂÙ·ã ÙË
      ÂãÍÔ‰·.                                                                    Ûã̆ Ó·„Ë ÙË˜ Û˘Ì‚·ãÛÂˆ˜, ÛÙËÓ ÂÈ‰ÈãÎ·ÛË ·Ô˙ËÌÈã̂ ÛÂˆ˜;
 ---pagebreak--- C 136/10                 EL                     ∂ÈãÛËÌË ∂ÊËÌÂÚÈã‰· ÙˆÓ ∂˘Úˆ·ÈåÎã̂ Ó ∫ÔÈÓÔÙËãÙˆÓ                                            15.5.1999
µ. ªÔãÓÔ ÛÂ ÂÚÈãÙˆÛË Î·Ù·Ê·ÙÈÎËã˜ ··ÓÙËãÛÂˆ˜ ÛÙÔ ÂÚã̂ ÙËÌ· ∞            ∞ÈãÙËÛË ÂÎ‰ÔãÛÂˆ˜ ÚÔ‰ÈÎ·ÛÙÈÎËã˜ ·ÔÊ·ãÛÂˆ˜ Ô˘ ˘Âã‚·ÏÂ ÙÔ High
     ˘Ô‚·ãÏÏÂÙ·È ÛÙÔ ¢ÈÎ·ÛÙËãÚÈÔ ÙÔ ·ÎÔãÏÔ˘ıÔ ÂÚ·ÈÙÂãÚˆ ÂÚã̂ ÙËÌ·:       Court of Justice, Queen’s Bench Division (Crown Office) (England
                                                                           and Wales) ÌÂ ‰È·ãÙ·ÍË ÙË˜ 2·˜ ºÂ‚ÚÔ˘·ÚÈãÔ˘ 1999 ÛÙËÓ ˘ÔãıÂÛË
     ™˘ÁÎÂÎÚÈÌÂÓÔÔÈÂÈãÙ·È Î·È ÚÔÛ‰ÈÔÚÈã˙ÂÙ·È Ë ·ÓˆÙÂãÚˆ ÛÙÔ              The Queen Î·Ù·ã 1) Secretary of State for Health, 2) Secretary of
     ÂÚã̂ ÙËÌ· ∞ ÂÚÈÁÚ·ÊÂÈãÛ· ˘Ô¯ÚÂãˆÛË ÌÂã¯ÚÈ ÙÔ˘ ÛËÌÂÈãÔ˘ Ó·           State for Trade and Industry, 3) HM Attorney General ex parte: 1)
     ‰È·ÛÊ·ÏÈã˙ÂÙ·È Ëã‰Ë ÌÂ ·˘ÙËãÓ ÁÈ· ÙÔ˘˜ È‰Èã̂ ÙÂ˜ ÙÔ ‰ÈÎ·ÈãˆÌ· ÁÈ·     Imperial Tobacco Ltd, 2) Gallaher Ltd, 3) Rothmans (UK) Ltd, 4)
     ‰ÈÂÍ·ÁˆÁËã ‰È·‰ÈÎ·ÛÈã·˜ ÚÔÛÊ˘ÁËã˜, Ô˘ ·ÓÙ·ÔÎÚÈãÓÂÙ·È ÛÙÈ˜                        British American Tobacco Investments Ltd
     ÚÔå̆ÔıÂãÛÂÈ˜ ÙÔ˘ ·ãÚıÚÔ˘ 1 ÙË˜ Ô‰ËÁÈã·˜ 89/665/∂√∫ ÙÔ˘
     ™˘Ì‚Ô˘ÏÈãÔ˘, ÛÙÔ Ï·ÈãÛÈÔ ÙË˜ ÔÔÈã·˜ ÙÔ ÂıÓÈÎÔã ‰ÈÎ·ÛÙËãÚÈÔ
     ÚÂãÂÈ ÂÓ ·ãÛË ÂÚÈÙã̂ ÛÂÈ Ó· Âã¯ÂÈ ÙË ‰˘Ó·ÙÔãÙËÙ· Ó· ‰È·Ù·ãÍÂÈ
     ÚÔÛˆÚÈÓ·ã ÌÂãÙÚ· ˘Ôã ÙËÓ ÂãÓÓÔÈ· ÙÔ˘ ·ãÚıÚÔ˘ 2 ·Ú·ãÁÚ·ÊÔ˜ 1                                    (ÀÔãıÂÛË C-74/99)
     ÛÙÔÈ¯ÂÈã· ·) Î·È ‚) ÙË˜ Ô‰ËÁÈã·˜ 89/665/∂√∫ Î·ıã̂ ˜ Î·È Ó·
     ·Î˘Úã̂ ÛÂÈ ÙËÓ ÂÚÈã Î·Ù·Î˘Úã̂ ÛÂˆ˜ ·ÔãÊ·ÛË ÙË˜ ·Ó·ıÂãÙÔ˘Û·˜
     ·Ú¯Ëã˜, Î·È Ó· ÌÔÚÂÈã Ô È‰Èã̂ ÙË˜ Ó· ·ÓÙÈÙ·ãÍÂÈ ÂÈÙ˘¯ã̂ ˜ ÛÙÔ
     ÎÚ·ãÙÔ˜ ÌÂãÏÔ˜ ÙËÓ ÂÓ ÏÔãÁˆ ˘Ô¯ÚÂãˆÛË ÛÙÔ Ï·ÈãÛÈÔ ÔÚÈÛÌÂãÓË˜                                      (1999/C 136/17)
     ‰È·‰ÈÎ·ÛÈã·˜;
°. ∆ÂãÏÔ˜, ÌÔãÓÔ ÛÂ ÂÚÈãÙˆÛË Î·Ù·Ê·ÙÈÎËã˜ ··ÓÙËãÛÂˆ˜ ÛÙÔ ˘Ô-
     ‚·ÏÏÔãÌÂÓÔ ·ÓˆÙÂãÚˆ ÂÚã̂ ÙËÌ· µ, ˘Ô‚·ãÏÏÂÙ·È ÛÙÔ ¢ÈÎ·ÛÙËãÚÈÔ         ªÂ ‰È·ãÙ·ÍË ÙË˜ 2·˜ ºÂ‚ÚÔ˘·ÚÈãÔ˘ 1999 Ô˘ ÂÚÈËãÏıÂ ÛÙË °Ú·ÌÌ·-
     Î·È ÙÔ ÂÍËã˜ ÂÚã̂ ÙËÌ·:                                               ÙÂÈã· ÙÔ˘ ¢ÈÎ·ÛÙËÚÈãÔ˘ ÙˆÓ ∂˘Úˆ·ÈåÎã̂ Ó ∫ÔÈÓÔÙËãÙˆÓ ÛÙÈ˜ 2 ª·Ú-
                                                                           ÙÈãÔ˘ 1999, ÙÔ High Court of Justice, Queen’s Bench Division (Crown
     ™˘ÁÎÂÎÚÈÌÂÓÔÔÈÂÈãÙ·È Î·È ÚÔÛ‰ÈÔÚÈã˙ÂÙ·È Ë ·ÓˆÙÂãÚˆ ÛÙÔ              Office) (England and Wales) ÛÙÔ Ï·ÈãÛÈÔ ÙË˜ ‰È·ÊÔÚ·ã˜ ÌÂÙ·Íã̆ The
     ÂÚã̂ ÙËÌ· ∞ ÂÚÈÁÚ·ÊÂÈãÛ· ˘Ô¯ÚÂãˆÛË ÌÂã¯ÚÈ ÙÔ˘ ÛËÌÂÈãÔ˘ ÙÔ           Queen Î·Ù·ã 1) Secretary of State for Health, 2) Secretary of State for
     ÂıÓÈÎÔã ‰ÈÎ·ÛÙËãÚÈÔ Ó· ÔÊÂÈãÏÂÈ, ·ÊÂÓÔã˜, Ó· ÌË Ï·ã‚ÂÈ ˘Ôã„Ë,        Trade and Industry, 3) HM Attorney General ex parte: 1) Imperial
     ÛÙÔ Ï·ÈãÛÈÔ ÔÚÈÛÌÂãÓË˜ ‰È·‰ÈÎ·ÛÈã·˜, ·ÓÙÈãıÂÙÂ˜ ‰È·Ù·ãÍÂÈ˜ ÙÔ˘       Tabacco Ltd, 2) Gallaher Ltd, 3) Rothmans (UK) Ltd, 4) British
     ÂıÓÈÎÔã̆ ‰ÈÎ·ÈãÔ˘, Ë ÙËãÚËÛË ÙˆÓ ÔÔÈãˆÓ ı· ÂÌÔã‰È˙Â ÙÔ ‰ÈÎ·ÛÙËã-    American Tobacco Investments Ltd Ô˘ ÂÎÎÚÂÌÂÈã ÂÓã̂ ÈÔãÓ ÙÔ˘ ˙ËÙÂÈã
     ÚÈÔ Ó· ÂÎÏËÚã̂ ÛÂÈ ÙËÓ ˘Ô¯ÚÂãˆÛË ·˘ÙËã, Î·È, ·ÊÂÙÂãÚÔ˘, Ó·          ·Ôã ÙÔ ¢ÈÎ·ÛÙËãÚÈÔ ÙËÓ ÂãÎ‰ÔÛË ÚÔ‰ÈÎ·ÛÙÈÎËã˜ ·ÔÊ·ãÛÂˆ˜ ÂÈã ÙÔ˘
     ÂÎÏËÚã̂ ÛÂÈ ·ãÌÂÛ· ÙËÓ ÂÓ ÏÔãÁˆ ˘Ô¯ÚÂãˆÛË ˆ˜ Û˘ÛÙ·ÙÈÎÔã ÛÙÔÈ-       ·ÎÔÏÔã̆ ıÔ˘ ÂÚˆÙËãÌ·ÙÔ˜:
     ¯ÂÈãÔ ÙË˜ Â˘Úˆ·ÈåÎËã˜ ÂãÓÓÔÌË˜ Ù·ãÍÂˆ˜, ·ÎÔãÌË Î·È ÔãÙ·Ó ÛÙÔ
     ÂıÓÈÎÔã ‰ÈãÎ·ÈÔ ‰ÂÓ ˘ÊÈãÛÙ·Ù·È Û¯ÂÙÈÎÔã ÂãÚÂÈÛÌ·;
                                                                           ∂ÈãÓ·È Ë Ô‰ËÁÈã· 98/43/∂∫(1) ·ÓÈãÛ¯˘ÚË ÂÓ ÔãÏˆ Ëã ÂÓ ÌÂãÚÂÈ ‰ÈÔãÙÈ:
(1) ∂∂ L 395 ÙË˜ 30.12.1989, Û. 33.
                                                                           ·) Ù· ·ãÚıÚ· 57 ·Ú·ãÁÚ·ÊÔ˜ 2, 66 Î·È 100 ∞ ‰ÂÓ Û˘ÓÈÛÙÔã̆ Ó
                                                                                Î·Ù·ãÏÏËÏË ÓÔÌÈÎËã ‚·ãÛË,
                                                                           ‚) Û˘ÓÈÛÙ·ã ÚÔÛ‚ÔÏËã ÙÔ˘ ıÂÌÂÏÈã̂ ‰Ô˘˜ ‰ÈÎ·Èã̂ Ì·ÙÔ˜ ÙË˜ ÂÏÂ˘ıÂ-
                                                                                ÚÈã·˜ ÂÎÊÚ·ãÛÂˆ˜,
∞ÈãÙËÛË ÁÈ· ÙËÓ ÂãÎ‰ÔÛË ÚÔ‰ÈÎ·ÛÙÈÎËã˜ ·ÔÊ·ãÛÂˆ˜ Ô˘ ˘Âã‚·ÏÂ
ÙÔ Sozialgericht Münster ÌÂ ‰È·ãÙ·ÍË ÙË˜ 26Ë˜ π·ÓÔ˘·ÚÈãÔ˘ 1999
ÛÙËÓ ˘ÔãıÂÛË Viktor Movrin Î·Ù·ã Landesversicherungsanstalt               Á) Û˘ÓÈÛÙ·ã ·Ú·‚Èã·ÛË ÙË˜ ·Ú¯Ëã˜ ÙË˜ ·Ó·ÏÔÁÈÎÔãÙËÙ·˜,
                                Westfalen
                                                                           ‰) Û˘ÓÈÛÙ·ã ·Ú·‚Èã·ÛË ÙË˜ ·Ú¯Ëã˜ ÙË˜ ÂÈÎÔ˘ÚÈÎÔãÙËÙ·˜,
                           (ÀÔãıÂÛË C-73/99)
                             (1999/C 136/16)                               Â) Û˘ÓÈÛÙ·ã ·Ú·ã‚·ÛË ÙË˜ ˘Ô¯ÚÂã̂ ÛÂˆ˜ ·ÈÙÈÔÏÔÁÈã·˜,
ªÂ ‰È·ãÙ·ÍË ÙË˜ 26Ë˜ π·ÓÔ˘·ÚÈãÔ˘ 1999, Ô˘ ÂÚÈËãÏıÂ ÛÙË °Ú·ÌÌ·-
ÙÂÈã· ÙÔ˘ ¢ÈÎ·ÛÙËÚÈãÔ˘ ÛÙÈ˜ 2 ª·ÚÙÈãÔ˘ 1999, ÙÔ Sozialgericht Münster,     ÛÙ) Û˘ÓÈÛÙ·ã ·Ú·ã‚·ÛË ÙÔ˘ ·ãÚıÚÔ˘ 222 ÙË˜ Û˘ÓıËãÎË˜ ∂∫ Î·È/Ëã
ÛÙÔ Ï·ÈãÛÈÔ ÙË˜ ‰È·ÊÔÚ·ã˜ ÌÂÙ·Íã̆ Viktor Movrin Î·È                            ÚÔÛ‚ÔÏËã ÙÔ˘ ıÂÌÂÏÈã̂ ‰Ô˘˜ ‰ÈÎ·Èã̂ Ì·ÙÔ˜ Î˘ÚÈÔãÙËÙ·˜;
Landesversicherungsanstalt Westfalen, Ô˘ ÂÎÎÚÂÌÂÈã ÂÓã̂ ÈÔãÓ ÙÔ˘,
˙ËÙÂÈã ·Ôã ÙÔ ¢ÈÎ·ÛÙËãÚÈÔ ÙËÓ ÂãÎ‰ÔÛË ÚÔ‰ÈÎ·ÛÙÈÎËã˜ ·ÔÊ·ãÛÂˆ˜
ÂÈã ÙÔ˘ ÂÍËã˜ ÂÚˆÙËãÌ·ÙÔ˜:
                                                                           (1) √‰ËÁÈã· 98/43/∂∫ ÙÔ˘ ∂˘Úˆ·ÈåÎÔã̆ ∫ÔÈÓÔ‚Ô˘ÏÈãÔ˘ Î·È ÙÔ˘ ™˘Ì‚Ô˘ÏÈãÔ˘,
∞ÓÙÈ‚·ÈãÓÂÈ ÚÔ˜ ÙÔ ‰ÈãÎ·ÈÔ ÙË˜ ∂˘Úˆ·ÈåÎËã˜ ∫ÔÈÓÔãÙËÙ·˜ Ë ·ãÚÓËÛË             ÙË˜ 6Ë˜ πÔ˘ÏÈãÔ˘ 1998, ÁÈ· ÙËÓ ÚÔÛÂãÁÁÈÛË ÙˆÓ ÓÔÌÔıÂÙÈÎã̂ Ó, Î·ÓÔÓÈÛÙÈ-
                                                                               Îã̂ Ó Î·È ‰ÈÔÈÎËÙÈÎã̂ Ó ‰È·Ù·ãÍÂˆÓ ÙˆÓ ÎÚ·Ùã̂ Ó ÌÂÏã̂ Ó ÔãÛÔÓ ·ÊÔÚ·ã ÙË
ÙÔ˘ Î·ıÔã̆ Ó· Î·Ù·‚·ãÏÂÈ ÛÙÔÓ ÚÔÛÊÂã̆ ÁÔÓÙ·, Ô ÔÔÈãÔ˜ Ï·Ì‚·ãÓÂÈ              ‰È·ÊËãÌÈÛË Î·È ÙË ¯ÔÚËÁÈã· ˘ÂãÚ ÙˆÓ ÚÔÈåÔãÓÙˆÓ Î·ÓÔã̆ (∂∂ L 213 ÙË˜
·Ôã ÙÔ Î·ıÔã̆ Î·ÓÔÓÈÎËã Ûã̆ ÓÙ·ÍË ÁËãÚ·ÙÔ˜, ÚÔÛ·ã̆ ÍËÛË ÙË˜ Û˘ÓÙ·ã-          30.7.1998, Û. 9).
ÍÂˆ˜ ÁÈ· ÙËÓ Î·ãÏ˘„Ë ÙˆÓ ‰··Óã̂ Ó ÛÙÈ˜ ÔÔÈãÂ˜ ˘Ô‚·ãÏÏÂÙ·È Ô
ÚÔÛÊÂã̆ ÁˆÓ ÁÈ· ÙËÓ ·ÛÊ·ãÏÈÛËã ÙÔ˘ ÛÙÔ ÔÏÏ·Ó‰ÈÎÔã Ûã̆ ÛÙËÌ· ·ÛÊ·ÏÈã-
ÛÂˆ˜ ·ÛıÂãÓÂÈ·˜;