CELEX: C1996/318/26
Language: en
Date: 1996-10-26 00:00:00
Title: Action brought on 2 August 1996 by Mutual Aid Administration Services NV against the Commission of the European Communities (Case T-121/96)

26 . 10 . 96           EN                  Official Journal of the European Communities                               No C 318 / 13
    on the market and administration of BST ('the                     Pleas in law and main arguments adduced in support
    moratorium') and breach of the principle of
     proportionality .                                                On 1 December 1995 the Commission adopted Regulation
                                                                      ( EEC ) No 2781 /95 on the transport for the free supply to
    The latest renewal of the moratorium on BST expressly             Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan and Tajikistan of rye
     permits Member States to 'carry out limited practical            flour .
     tests on the use of bovine somatotrophin'. Furthermore,
     the moratorium nowhere prohibits the placing on the              The transport of one of the lots was awarded to the
     market of products obtained from tested animals . It is          applicant. Annexed to the award was a schedule of 10 points
     solely concerned with BST and not with the sale of               containing extracts from the agreement between the
     foodstuffs obtained from treated animals . It appears de         European Community and the Georgian authorities . After
     facto disproportionate to inhibit the ability of academic        delivery the Commission sent to the applicant a statement of
     institutions to obtain free access, for the purpose of           account which concerned, inter alia, costs of dispatch to be
     clinical trials, to a product whose use in animals is            paid to the Georgian authorities . The applicant objects that
     recognized scientifically as harmless to humans, and to          no reference is made anywhere to the dispatch rate, not even
     require healthy animals to be sacrificed in such a               in the award and in the memorandum concerning the
     situation .                                                      abovementioned agreement. The applicant therefore
                                                                      considers that the costs of dispatch do not have to be paid to
— Infringement of the Final Act embodying the results                 the Georgian authorities and protests against a number of
     of the Uruguay Round of Multilateral Trade                       decisions in which those costs are stated to be for its
     Negotiations .                                                   account .
     In the applicant's view, the Commission's decision
     refusing to proceed with the inclusion of BST in Annex II
     to the Regulation may seriously affect non-EC producers
     who request an authorization to place on the market
     foodstuffs from animals treated with BST.
                                                                      Action brought on 8 August 1996 by Service pour le
                                                                      groupement d'acquisitions ( SGA ) against the Commission
                                                                                      of the European Communities
                                                                                             ( Case T-123 /96 )
                                                                                               ( 96/C 318 /27 )
Action brought on 2 August 1996 by Mutual Aid
Administration Services NV against the Commission of the                              (Language of the case: French)
                     European Communities
                        ( Case T-121 /96 )                            An action against the Commission of the European
                          ( 96/C 318/26 )                             Communities was brought before the Court of First
                                                                      Instance of the European Communities on 8 August 1 996 by
                 (Language of the case: Dutch)                        Service pour le groupement d'acquisitions ( SGA ),
                                                                      established at Istres ( France ), represented by Jean Claude
                                                                      Fourgoux, of the Paris Bar, with an address for service in
An action against the Commission of the European                      Luxembourg at the Chambers of Pierrot Schiltz, 4 rue
Communities was brought before the Court of First                     Beatrix de Bourbon .
Instance of the European Communities on 2 August 1 996 by
Mutual Aid Administration Services NV, of Antwerp
( Belgium ), represented by J. Tritsmans, of the Antwerp Bar,         The applicant claims that the Court should :
with an address for service in Luxembourg at the Chambers
of R. Faltz, 6 rue Heinrich Heine .                                   — annul the Commission 's decision notified to SGA on
                                                                          5 Tune 1996 not to investigate the complaint lodged on
                                                                          4 July 1994 ,
The applicant claims that the Court should :
                                                                      — declare, in accordance with Article 215 of the EC Treaty,
— annul the contested decision(s ), a copy of which is                    that the Commission has incurred non-contractual
     included in the documents annexed to the application,
                                                                          liability and caused SGA damage which must be made
     and consequently hold that the applicant is not obliged
                                                                          good, and, as a consequence, award SGA the sum of
     to pay the costs of dispatch to the Georgian
                                                                           ECU 360 000 by way of compensation,
     authorities,
— order the Commission of the European Communities to                 — order the Commission to pay the costs .
     proceed to repay to the applicant the sum of US$
     21 967,19 together with interest, calculated at the               Pleas in law and main arguments adduced in support
     current statutory rate in Belgium of 8 % per annum,
      since 30 July 1996 ,                                             SGA operates as an intermediary in the distribution of all
                                                                       makes of automobiles, undertaking parallel imports solely
— order the Commission to pay the costs .                              as agent for the final consumer, in accordance with