CELEX: 31994M0457
Language: en
Date: 1994-06-20 00:00:00
Title: COMMISSION DECISION of 20.06.1993 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the common market (Case No IV/M.457 - LA ROCHE / SYNTEX) according to Council Regulation (EEC) No 4064/89 (Only the English text is authentic)

Avis juridique important

|

31994M0457

COMMISSION DECISION of 20.06.1993 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the common market (Case No IV/M.457 - LA ROCHE / SYNTEX) according to Council Regulation (EEC) No 4064/89 (Only the English text is authentic)  

Official Journal C 178 , 30/06/1994 P. 0000

 COMMISSION DECISION of 20.06.1994 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the common market  (Case No IV/M.457 - LA ROCHE / SYNTEX) according to Council Regulation (EEC) No 4064/89  (Only the English text is authentic)  The paper version of the decision is available through the sales offices of the Office of Official Publications of  the European Communities. PUBLIC VERSION MERGER PROCEDURE ARTICLE 6(1)(b) DECISION Registered with advice of delivery To the notifying parties Dear Sirs, Subject: <ind> Case n* IV/M.457 - La Roche/Syntex  <ind>  <ind> Notification of 16th May 1994 pursuant to Article 4 of Council Regulation n* 4064/89   1. <ind> On 16th May 1994 Roche Capital Corporation, which is ultimately controlled by Roche Holding AG  (ROCHE), notified an agreed public bid for the acquisition of Syntex Corporation (SYNTEX).  2. <ind> After examination of the notification, the Commission has concluded that the notified operation falls  within the scope of Council Regulation No. 4064/89 and does not raise serious doubts as to its compatibility with  the common market.  I. <ind> THE PARTIES  3. <ind> SYNTEX is a U.S. international health care company involved in the development and marketing of  human and animal pharmaceutical products and medical diagnostic systems.   <ind> ROCHE is a Swiss-based company involved in the development and marketing of pharmaceuticals,  vitamins, diagnostics and other products.  II. <ind> THE OPERATION  4. <ind> The proposed operation consists in the acquisition (by way of an agreed public bid) of SYNTEX by  ROCHE.  III. <ind> COMMUNITY DIMENSION  5. <ind> The enterprises concerned have a combined aggregate world-wide turnover calculated in accordance  with Article 5(3)(b) of the Merger Regulation in excess of 5,000 million Ecu.  Both ROCHE and SYNTEX have  a Community-wide turnover in excess of 250 million Ecu but do not achieve more than two-thirds of this  turnover in one and the same Member State.  Thus the operation has a Community dimension.   IV. <ind> THE RELEVANT MARKETS  A. <ind> Pharmaceuticals  1. <ind> Relevant product markets  6. <ind> The ATC classification gives guidance as to how to define product markets for pharmaceuticals.  This  classification is recommended by the World Health Organisation, and most of the national administrations in the  Community use it for the purposes of comparing different medicines.  It is also the classification used by  Intercontinental Medical Statistics (IMS) to establish its medicines sales statistics, which are generally used by  pharmaceutical firms for their market analysis.   <ind> The third level classes of the ATC classification provide a grouping of medicines according to their  therapeutic properties, that is, their intended use, and therefore may be accepted as an operational market  definition.  It may be necessary, however, to use other levels of ATC classification where appropriate in a  particular context.  7. <ind> Within the pharmaceutical industry, it is generally considered that OTC and ethical products constitute  two distinct markets, although this distinction may be blurred.  However, these difficulties do not materially  affect the analysis of these markets.  2. <ind> Relevant geographic markets  8. <ind> No medicine may yet be marketed in any Member State without the previous approval of the respective  national administration, although procedures for mutual recognition of marketing authorisations exist.   Notwithstanding the considerable harmonisation of the scientific criteria for the evaluation of a medicine  achieved so far in the Community within pharmaceutical registration procedures, the decision to authorise its  marketing remains at present with the competent authorities of the Member States.  9. <ind> In addition, prices of ethical medicines are directly or indirectly regulated by national laws.  The  mechanisms used by each Member State to regulate pharmaceutical prices vary widely.  They include direct  price fixing (as in France, Italy or Spain), overall control of companies' profits (as in the UK), and special  provisions affecting the reimbursement of the cost of medicines by the national health insurance systems (as in  Germany).  The differences in the pricing and reimbursement mechanisms result in wide disparities in medicine  price levels among different Member States.  10. <ind> In view of these regulatory constraints, and given different medicine distribution systems, national  brands, and different consumer preferences, pharmaceutical markets remain essentially national.  B. <ind> Diagnostics  1. <ind> Relevant product markets  11. <ind> In addition to the pharmaceutical categories mentioned above, the concentration concerns diagnostic  systems and test kits for therapeutic medicine monitoring and drug abuse testing.  12. <ind> A diagnostic analysis is a procedure for monitoring the physiological condition of a subject. The  analytical procedures differ, depending on whether they are designed for analysing the general health condition  of a subject, a specific illness, a pre-birth pathology, or whether they concern the reaction of a subject to certain  substances.  13. <ind> Diagnostics tests can be either in-vitro or in-vivo. While in-vitro tests are carried out outside the body,  the in-vivo method concerns the use of diagnostic substances directly in or on the human body. The two methods  are complementary for some applications.  14. <ind> Major overlaps between ROCHE and SYNTEX occur within the in-vitro area. In-vitro diagnostics can  be used in a medical as well as in a non-medical context and they also serve for trials in research institutes.  15. <ind> A large part of the in-vitro diagnostics is sold in the form of multi-use diagnostics systems to  hospitals, commercial laboratories, university laboratories or other institutions. In addition, a significant quantity  of in-vitro diagnostics are marketed as single-use products to general practitioners, public authorities, employers  or others, and in some instances they are even sold in the form of self-test kits over the counter (i.e. tests of  pregnancy, sugar diabetes, cholesterol or in some states even HIV). Self-test kits probably are complementary to  multi-use test kits for some applications.  16. <ind> The concentration between ROCHE and SYNTEX concerns primarily multi-use in-vitro diagnostics,  which are used on-site. These diagnostics products typically form a system, that is basically a measuring  instrument which is designed for the automated operation of several kinds of tests. The reagents for the different  tests are supplied as part of a reagent kit which comprises among others a control substance and a test serum to  verify the smooth functioning of the measuring instrument. A calibrator serves for regular - often weekly -  adjustments of the  measuring instruments.    <ind> The main part of the multi-use products business is characterised by a series of test kits which are  adapted to a system. Most of the major suppliers offer a package consisting of a measuring instrument, a series of  test kits and a comprehensive after-sale service including quality control.  17. <ind> The concentration between ROCHE and SYNTEX leads to major overlaps in the field of  immunochemistry diagnostics, and more precisely in the area of drug monitoring.  18. <ind> An immunochemical reagent effectively corresponds to a mechanism to identify a molecule in a test  fluid. The reagent comprises a monoclonal antibody which is designed to lock on a specific target. Once the  antibody has fixed its target, it is marked by a 'tag'. The 'tag' makes it possible to detect the existence of the  targeted molecule in the test fluid.   <ind> The antibody of the reagent is made to fit to a certain target molecule. It is therefore the antibody which  determines the scope of the reagent.   <ind> The 'tag' is not specific to the targeted molecule. Broadly speaking, a 'tag' can consist either of enzyme  antigene, of a radio active antigene, it can be fluorescent, or two 'tag' antigenes can even be fixed onto a latex  particle which is deformed by agglutination when hitting the target. Depending on the choice of the 'tag', a  different technology is used for detecting the target molecule.  19. <ind> Drug monitoring forms an area of immunochemical diagnostics. The term describes the analysis of  blood and urine samples to determine the existence and the level of certain specified chemicals in the body of a  person. According to the classification proposed by the European Diagnostics Manufacturers Association  (EDMA) one can further distinguish between therapeutic medicine monitoring (TDM) and drug abuse /  toxicology tests (DAT). Whereas the first category concerns the monitoring of medicinal products in the body,  the second category includes the detection of specific, often illegal drugs.  20. <ind> The two areas of therapeutic medicine monitoring (TDM) and drug abuse tests (DAT) are different in  some respects.   21. <ind> The TDM area concerns all those products which are provided for testing patients receiving ethical  pharmaceuticals. The TDM reagents measure the medicine level in patients whose results are used by physicians  to adjust the medicine dose. Therefore, TDM is generally carried out for use in a medical environment, whereas  DAT is used primarily for non-medical purposes, for instance in legal proceedings, for recruitment purposes  etc.  22. <ind> It is true that depending on the make of the instrument, both TDM and DAT tests can be operated on  the same systems. But TDM and DAT are in some ways different for the user.  23. <ind> TDM testing mostly requires quantification of analytes (one wants to know how many molecules are  in the test fluid), whereas DAT testing is generally performed qualitatively or semi-qualitatively (one wants to  know primarily whether somebody has consumed an illicit drug at all or not).  24. <ind> DAT often is carried out in two steps. In a first step the analyte is "screened", by using either an  antibody with a broad scope of application or by conducting a panel of several tests; in a second step the  consumed drug is determined more specifically. Legal requirements can also oblige the laboratory to carry out  additional DAT tests to confirm the result of a first test.  25. <ind> TDM is in general carried out on sera, that is on blood samples. But it appears from the Commission's  investigations that tests on urine samples are more common in the DAT area.  26. <ind> In spite of the differences, there are indications, at least technically, that some individual tests can be  used both for TDM and DAT.  It is also true that the basic technology for manufacturing TDM and DAT  reagents is in principle the same and shows a certain communality with other immunochemical methods.  27. <ind> Some of the suppliers follow a strategy of extending the scope of application of their product lines.  This fact gives an indication that product markets will probably widen in the future.  28. <ind> The facts available do not allow a definite conclusion as to whether TDM and DAT form separate  markets.  The question can be left open, since in any case no dominant position would be created or strengthened  by the concentration.   <ind> Relevant geographic markets  29. <ind> The geographic reference markets for TDM and DAT remain essentially national.  30. <ind> The existence of national markets is illustrated by the fact that the suppliers organise their distribution  nationally. SYNTEX for example has centralised its production in the US from where it ships the supplies to the  different outlets in Western Europe. With the notable exception of Italy, SYNTEX has its own distributors in  most of the Western European countries.  31. <ind> [Prices differ significantly from one country to the other] [In the published version of the decision,  some information has been omitted or replaced pursuant to the provisions of Article 17(2) of Council Regulation  (EEC) no 4064/89.  Consequently, all [        ] replace information deleted as pertaining to business secrets.].   <ind> These price differences would seem to reflect the diversity among national medical cultures and in  particular the divergences in national health policies, social security regulations and the technology used in  laboratories. Again, prices for reagents would systematically include the cost for leasing the analyser in some  countries but not necessarily in others.   <ind> The fact that these price differences have not been significantly eroded over the past three to four years  suggests, that the importance of parallel imports from one Member state of the European Union to the other is  small.  International tenders are relatively rare in the industry. One explantation is that users give great  importance to after-sale services, and therefore closeness to the distributors.  32. <ind> National regulation plays a certain role, but it is less stringent than in the case of pharmaceuticals.  The Commission is preparing a directive for the harmonisation of national regulations on in-vitro diagnostics.  The directive, which is not likely to enter into force before 1997, will only apply to diagnostics products for use  in a medical environment.  33. <ind> For these reasons and especially in view of the important price differences the  markets for in-vitro  diagnostics remain essentially national.  V <tab> COMPATIBILITY WITH THE COMMON MARKET  A. <tab> Pharmaceuticals  34. <ind> No overlap will occur in the animal pharmaceutical market, as ROCHE has sold its animal health  business within the last year.  Nor will any overlap occur within the human non-prescription ('OTC')  pharmaceutical market, since SYNTEX's only interest in this sector involves certain non prescription analgesic  products in the U.S. market.  35. <ind> On the basis of the third-level ATC classification there will be overlaps between ROCHE and  SYNTEX in the following ATC categories within the EEA:   <tab> - A1A Stomatologicals  <tab> - A7B Intestinal absorbants  <tab> - A8A Anti-Obesity preparations  <tab> - A11G Vitamin C including mineral combinations  <tab> - A13A Tonics  <tab> - C4A Cercbro vasotherapy  <tab> - C8A Calcium antagonists  <tab> - D3A Wound healing agents  <tab> - D7A Topical-Corticosteroid plain  <tab> - N11A Anti-rheumatic non-steroids  <tab> - N1A Anaesthetics  <tab> - N2B Non-narcotics analgesic  <tab> - R1A Topical nasal   <ind> As far as national markets are concerned, SYNTEX's and ROCHE's combined shares will exceed 10% in  the following categories:   <tab> - A11G : Spain  <tab> - D3A : Belgium, Portugal, Greece  <tab> - D7A : Spain  <tab> - M1A : France, UK, Spain, Belgium, Sweden, Greece   <ind> According to IMS data, combined shares of more than 25% will occur in the following markets only:   <tab>  <tab> Spain: <ind> A11G Vitamin C including mineral combinations: ROCHE 46.5% plus SYNTEX  1.7% = 48.2%   <tab>  <tab> Greece: <ind> D3A wound-healing agents: ROCHE 39.4% plus SYNTEX 6.5% = 45.9%   <ind> 36. <ind> Neither ROCHE nor SYNTEX own patents in the two markets where combined shares will be  highest (ie A11G in Spain and D3A in Greece).   Significant competitors are active in these markets, for  example AKZO in wound-healing agents in Greece, E. Merck and Wellcome with about 27% and 12,6%  respectively (IMS data) of the Vitamin C market in Spain (Vitamin C products are anyway generic in nature).   Competition for branded medicines from generic medicines is very much an increasing feature of pharmaceutical  markets, when a patent expires and a hitherto prescription-only medicine is licensed to be sold on an OTC basis  (SYNTEX's own major product, an anti-inflammatory medicine sold under the brand name 'Naprosyn', has  experienced a drop of some 50% in sales since its patent expired at the end of 1993, because of substitution by  generic medicines; moreover, it would seem that SYNTEX is not at the moment in a position to launch major  new patented medicines on the market, nor is it likely to be in such a position for some time to come).  The  impact of a recent trend to switch i.e: change a medicinal product from a prescription only status to availability  without a prescription has not yet been made fully apparent, although Syntex's anti-inflammaory product  Naprosyn has been switched in some markets.  Again, government agencies, health-care companies, and  insurance companies are increasingly applying pressure on pharmaceutical companies to cut their prices in order  to diminish the costs of public health-care regimes.  In view of these factors the concentration will not lead to a  position of dominance for ROCHE and SYNTEX.  B) <tab> Diagnostics  37. <ind> The parties estimate that the turnover of the total West European in-vitro diagnostics business was  about 4.5 billion ECU in 1993. The total Western European turnover for drug monitoring was [over 160 Mio]  ECU, of which [two thirds] were spent on TDM and [one third] on DAT.  38. <ind> As explained above, the business of multi-use TDM and DAT products is characterised by the supply  of systems and product series. The development of a new system requires relatively large sums. The companies  in the diagnostics industry spend between 10 and 20% of their total turnover on R&D according to the parties.  The average life span of a system gives the supplier a five year period within which to recoup the development  costs. [Less than 15%] of the turnover is achieved through the sale of instruments, while reagent kits account for  most of the rest. This explains that the suppliers have a strong interest in obtaining long-term orders for a  continuous supply of reagent kits.  39. <ind> Diagnostics manufacturers are following different strategies in the pursuit of this aim. Some  companies, such as the US company Abbott, try to market their products as closed systems which are designed  for the exclusive use of their reagents. The systems of other competitors are more open. It is also a common  feature of the industry that delivery contracts with customers are concluded for one or more years. Often, the  instruments are only leased under the condition that the customer purchases a certain number of reagent kits  over a certain time period.  40. <ind> From a technical viewpoint the reagents of a certain supplier can be used on the instrument of another  producer, provided that the technologies correspond to each other. This applies even for closed systems. Some  reagent suppliers provide instructions to facilitate the adaptation of other suppliers' systems to their products.  However, it appears that the switch from one supplier to the other requires a certain know-how on the side of the  customer.  It is nevertheless relatively frequent to switch supplier within the limits set by technical constraints.  In addition, large customers follow a policy of multiple sourcing.  Large laboratories use analysers of different  suppliers depending on the application.  41. <ind> The major suppliers for TDM and DAT products are present in most Western European countries.  The US company Abbott is the strongest player in the overall diagnostics business worldwide and it is also a  strong competitor in the Western European countries both for TDM and DAT. Other competitors in the TDM  and DAT markets include among others DuPont and, especially for TDM, Merck.   42. <ind> SYNTEX traditionally is a strong niche player in the TDM and DAT markets, where it is active  through its subsidiary Syva. ROCHE entered the TDM and DAT business in 1989 and it has a significantly  lower turnover for these markets than SYNTEX. Both companies offer systems. But whereas ROCHE supplies  its own instruments, SYNTEX markets analysers manufactured by third companies.  ROCHE analysers can be  adapted for the use of SYNTEX reagent kits.  43. <ind> If the market shares of ROCHE and SYNTEX are aggregated, the two companies  realise high market  shares in several Member states of the European Union. The parties will achieve value-based market shares for  DAT which [exceed 40%] in France, the UK, Spain and also in certain Scandinavian countries. For Western  Europe the share of the DAT market would be [more than 40%]. As for TDM, the parties achieve a market share  of between 20 and 30 % in France. They estimate their share of the Western European TDM market to be [less  than 15%].   44. <ind> The US company Abbott is the strongest competitor for ROCHE and SYNTEX both in the TDM and  the DAT markets. Although Abbott is a high-price supplier, it is considered as an aggressive competitor. Abbott  distinguishes itself by offering closed systems which are easy to use and therefore imply low handling costs. As  in the case of ROCHE and SYNTEX, Abbott has important stakes in most of the Western European countries.  Therefore, the presence of Abbott seriously constrains the possibility of ROCHE and SYNTEX to act  independently of their competitors.  45. <ind> It is reasonable to say that in principle any supplier active in immunochemistry has the basic abilities  to develop TDM or DAT products.  It is expected that Boehringer-Mannheim, which has already a limited  presence in the TDM area, will launch a new DAT product series at the end of 1994. The entry of Boehringer- Mannheim  in the DAT field will further constrain the position of ROCHE and SYNTEX.  46. <ind> It should also be noted that the patent protection for SYNTEX's main diagnostic technology,  ("EMIT") has recently expired. SYNTEX has therefore been obliged to modernise its product line by launching a  new automated diagnostics system (VISTA automated system). The development of a new proprietary  technology for drug abuse tests and therapeutic medicine monitoring (LOCI technology) is not expected to bear  fruit before 1997.  47. <ind> For these reasons, the concentration will not lead to a position of dominance for ROCHE and  SYNTEX.   VI. <tab> CONCLUSION  48. <ind> For the above reasons, the proposed concentration between ROCHE and SYNTEX does not raise  serious doubts as to its compatibility with the common market and the functioning of the EEA Agreement.   <ind> For the above reasons, the Commission has decided not to oppose the notified operation and to declare it  compatible with the common market. This decision is adopted in application of Article 6(1)(b) of Council  Regulation No 4064/89.  For the Commission,