AMOUNT m No coUNSI~:L A.T ALL mm Ac'-IUAL oR- OONS'LRUCIIVE_-, m HE FAILED TO 'TMLY PRES_E;\;T MQ_HONS m ma co'URT I`N PRE"I"#RIAL HEARI`NGS, tro SUPPRESS~,- DISMISS, 0_'R QU`ASH THE FAC"IUAL I`NFORMATION As DISCLOSED I~N THE F.oUR coRNERS oF THE AFF.-I-=
DAVITS ('-'.;'S'I`ATEIVIENI`S".) MADE BY` THE VIQTIM "P_`A"IR-'_I_C_"] LOF.I`IS" AND THE WITNES_S "GJEN- 4 _
noLYN YOUN'<;_'; I;N m INVESTIGATION cAsE No.. 03-3373 (sEE Am<;§wu_mmalrs-A, 1 AND `2>. spain sums wEREANn AR'E "SUBSTANJ?IVELY DEFECI'IVE" As A MA_TTER oF m- AS lAw, FOR THE wAN'r oF A SHOWING O_F A NOTARY SFAL. (ia.e. EAC_LALLY voI`D IN-- Smmms). MOVANT (RAY> mm `SU.G_GESTS, IHAT HIS APPELLAI§E coUN'S`EL's PERFORMAN.- on wAs As cowST`irUIIONAu-.YDEFICIENT m HI_S _FAILnRE To RAISE THE "sUBSTAN.-_ TIVE DEFE<:`TS' m THE AFFIDAVHS ("\'S.T;A'rmu~r_rs"), B'UT kamm- FILING A FRIvol_._ous A'P~ BRIEF, coNSTITnI.ING, No'r 'MER_E I`NEFFRECTIVEI\IESS~, BUT RAum_a, AGTUAL 0R GONSTRUCTIVE vnuNuaL oF c_jc)UNS'E:c;a AT FIRST APPEAL, AND Is -As wE_LL m'P'UJ:En 'ro THE sTA'u_as_ RE`sP<`)'Ns"I"B-'u.m uNDER THE FOURTEEMH AM§NDMENF cmaER, suPRA. [Id., Ar'r p_. 3, mrs noc..]. THE sTAIu, 'LHEREFQP;_E, BY 'IHE APPOINum oF coUNSEL's (IRIA`L AND APPEAL) H_As UL_TMT_EL_Y QAUSED um PRocEnURAL EXIMUST_LON BEQUIRH~IENT ERRoR, To BRI`NG To THE TRIAL coURT'S AND APPELLATE oomzjr'S ATIENTION, BY Tm:lR FAILUR£__S ',ro PRES_ERVE. ute ISSUES F.oR THE FEnERAL HABE'AS <:'oRP.US RE\"/Im. muFQRE, BEING um . THE ERRORS ARF. oF THE Mosr 4FUNDAME:NTAL IN cHARAGFER, mEPt)RE GAUSING ma DEFEND- 'ANT To LosE- AND BENEFITS THAT HE womn _HAV'E ourERwIsE BEEN ENTHLED To-, BUT FOR uu; coUNSEL's , cAUSING HIM To FORFEISI _H_I`S RLGHT 10 RAISE ma IssuEs AT AF'EDERAL HABEAS coRP.Us LEVEL 0F ura APPELLATE PRoCEss, FoR THE LA<:L< oF mmUSTION A_T Ein=a'Y AVAH.ABE: vsTATI~: RuvIEDY. AS SUCH, THE MOVANT IN THIS PARIICU- lAR cAsE SHOU`I'.D NOT BE BARRED ~FROM THE `F`ILI'NG oF IHIS DCI'RAORDINARY 'wRI`T, DUE 10 THE STAua cREAIED MEDIMENT UND.ER 'IHE oo`lamN;:.DochNE SEE cQL_EP/lAN \_r,_ _IHQMPSON, 501 U.s. 735. cQUnTING MU;§RAY\; QARRIER, 477 U.s'. 478,488 Sa-c':t. 2639 (1986)(THE GovERNMmTAL INTERFERENCE o'a'? "-SUPPLYING THE MOVANT (DEFEN'DANT) wm couNSEL"s THAT wm coNS'-II_I'LJ'ITIQNALLY IN_EFFE<:HVE,"- MADE anomach mm ma coNFEbQER_ON- tons GBJE£:I_ION AND EXHAUSTION RULES MRAQI_ICABLE F.oR THE MovANT To EUAU$T H`IS STATE Ru~unlm).. Hls -APPELLAIE CoUN`SEL's FILING oF uIE'FRJ_'Vou)US APé`El-aLANT's BRI- EF` oN DIRECT APPFA_L INSTEAD oF RALSmG mg CLEAR sUBS'rANrIvaa DEFEcrs, ULTmA'rE:LY cAusEn THE AFFIRMING oF A coN\'_/Ic'T_IoN THAT womn usz BEE`:`N oVERTURNEn.
BY was oouwswr.'s wmawa To wAl_sw uaw CaawARLY owvaous DwAn-BANG waNNING Iss'a'aws uaAT uaw MCVANT RAI-sw's `a_awww;u\_a,('a_awwA_USw a_`T as chAw 0N uaw FAcw o_F uaw Rw'co__wa) aaswaaw uaAT uaw sTATw"awNTs saaPPoaaa: No APPwARANcw oaa uaw vacaaa~a, aaauawss oaa uaw sTAww, BEFORE ANY ) sww anMwARD y'.__a_'aaaAUGaa,' 868 F`.`zdaza?§ (Sch cir~...19 89')`(w_aawa'a amusij Fuws A. wwavoaaous APPwa.aAaES BRI.EF, IT AMOUNTs m No coUNswL 'AT ALL, wauaww AquAa. c)Rl CoNsawa_ac_a-_a"avw nwaauaa. o`a' oouwswa., AND uaw waaaaa_)acw PRON`G
oF uaw smacawwaua)_acw PRO'NG OF uaw srwacaaaAND Twsa' <466 U.s. 687-88> .aN.Rwawwwaac._w wo 'a'a_a's awaAL_coUN`swL.'-s INcoaaPauwaars oaa a<_;_aaowaaaacw ow uaw FAcas Aca_n uaw LAa_a_s TH'AT APjPa-.awn un uaw