Case: 19-1277 Document: 49 Page: 1 Filed: 03/25/2020
United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit ______________________
ANAHEIM GARDENS, L.P., THETFORD PROPERTIES III, L.P., THETFORD PROPERTIES IV, L.P., B-L ASSOCIATES, L.P., C-W ASSOCIATES, L.P., GLENVIEW GARDENS L.P., INDIAN HEAD MANOR, L.P. I, METRO WEST LIMITED, L.P., MILLWOOD ASSOCIATES L.P., NAPA PARK APARTMENTS L.P., ONTARIO TOWNHOUSES, L.P., PALOMAR APARTMENTS, L.P., SIERRA VISTA ONE, L.P., 825 SAN TOMAS APARTMENTS, L.P., 5324 FOOTHILL APARTMENTS, G.P., ALGONQUIN HEIGHTS ASSOCIATES, L.P., BRANDY HILL COMPANY, BROOKSIDE MANOR ASSOCIATES, L.P., BRIAR CREST, G.P., BRIAR CREST APARTMENTS II, L.P., BRIAR HILLS, L.P., CLARENCE W. GOSNELL, JR., JOHN G. GOSNELL, MURRAY HABER, RICHARD S. BRIGHT, PHILIP BERMAN, ALFRED S. BRIGHT, SAMUEL EISENSTAT, MELVIN S. HELLER, MILTON S. LIDER, MARTIN MYERS, MALCOMB MEISTER, HAROLD D. PRICE, HERBERT W. SAVIT, WALTER WEITZNER, ESTATE OF JACK N. BLINKOFF, HAROLD D. FRAZEE, TRUSTEE U/A DTD 4/2/89 FOR E.D. FRAZEE, CAMBRIDGE SQUARE NORTH ASSOCIATES, LP, CAMBRIDGE SQUARE OF FORT WAYNE ASSOCIATES I, LP, CAMBRIDGE SQUARE OF GRAND RAPIDS ASSOCIATES I, LP, CAMBRIDGE SQUARE OF GRAND RAPIDS ASSOCIATES II, LP, CARRIAGE HOUSE NORTH ASSOCIATES LP, CARRIAGE HOUSE OF MISHAWAKA ASSOCIATES II LP, CARRIAGE HOUSE WEST IV ASSOCIATES, LP, CROMWELL COURT COMPANY, FIRST LANDMARK Case: 19-1277 Document: 49 Page: 2 Filed: 03/25/2020
2 ANAHEIM GARDENS, L.P. v. UNITED STATES
ASSOCIATES, L.P., FOREST GLEN LIMITED DIVIDEND HOUSING ASSOCIATION, FORT HEATH ASSOCIATES, GARRISON FOREST ASSOCIATES, JODANI ASSOCIATES, L.P., KIMBERLY ASSOCIATES L.P., KING'S GRANT COMPANY, LEADER HOUSE ASSOCIATES, LEADER HOUSING CO., INC., NEW AMSTERDAM ASSOCIATES, NEW AMSTERDAM HOUSES, INC., PINE CREST COMPANY, RIVERSIDE VILLAGE COMPANY, SUBURBIA ASSOCIATES, L.P., STEPHEN G. DAKES, HARVEY E. JOHNSON, JR., W. DEWEY RASNAKE, MARTIN E. BROWN, WARREN W. TAYLOR, JR., WARREN W. TAYLOR, JR., TRUSTEE, LUDLOW KING, JAMES L. BREHONY, SUEHAR ASSOCIATES LP, TOWER WEST ASSOCIATES LP, TOWER WEST INC., TOWN & COUNTRY APARTMENTS & TOWNHOUSES, Plaintiffs
CEDAR GARDENS ASSOCIATES, ROCK CREEK TERRACE L.P., 620 SU CASA POR CORTEZ, BUCKMAN GARDENS, L.P., 3740 SILVERLAKE VILLAGE, L.P., CHAUNCY HOUSE COMPANY, Plaintiffs-Appellants
v.
UNITED STATES, Defendant-Appellee ______________________
2019-1277, 2019-1278, 2019-1279, 2019-1280, 2019-1281, 2019-1282 ______________________
Appeals from the United States Court of Federal Claims in Nos. 1:93-cv-00655-PEC, 1:93-cv-06568-PEC, 1:93-cv-06578-PEC, 1:93-cv-06580-PEC, 1:93-cv-06582- Case: 19-1277 Document: 49 Page: 3 Filed: 03/25/2020
ANAHEIM GARDENS, L.P. v. UNITED STATES 3
PEC, 1:97-cv-05837-PEC, 1:97-cv-05845-PEC, Judge Patri- cia E. Campbell-Smith. ______________________
Decided: March 25, 2020 ______________________
HARRY JAMES KELLY, III, Nixon Peabody LLP, Wash- ington, DC, argued for plaintiffs-appellants. Also repre- sented by JOHN C. HAYES, JR., BRIAN J. WHITTAKER.
SHARI A. ROSE, Commercial Litigation Branch, Civil Di- vision, United States Department of Justice, Washington, DC, argued for defendant-appellee. Also represented by JOSEPH H. HUNT, ANNA BONDURANT ELEY, ROBERT EDWARD KIRSCHMAN, JR., FRANKLIN E. WHITE, JR. ______________________
Before LOURIE, CHEN, and STOLL, Circuit Judges. LOURIE, Circuit Judge. These cases involve takings claims resulting from the enactment of the Emergency Low Income Housing Preser- vation Act of 1987, Pub. L. No. 100-242, § 202, 101 Stat. 1877 (1988) ("ELIHPA") and the Low-Income Housing Preservation and Resident Homeownership Act of 1990, Pub. L. No.