Document ID: ./input/supremecourt_opinions/opinions/boundvolumes/558bv.pdf
Page Number: 667

820 

OCTOBER  TERM,  2009 

October  5,  2009 

558  U. S. 

No.  08–1424.  Rosenthal  v.  Committee  on  Professional 
Standards,  Appellate  Division,  Supreme  Court  of  New 
York,  Third  Judicial  Department.  App.  Div.,  Sup.  Ct.  N. Y., 
3d  Jud.  Dept.  Certiorari  denied.  Reported  below:  57  App.  Div. 
3d  1085,  868  N. Y.  S.  2d  820. 

No.  08–1429.  Beal  v.  CSX  Corp.  et  al.  C.  A.  11th  Cir. 

Certiorari  denied.  Reported  below:  308  Fed.  Appx.  324. 

No.  08–1430.  Smith  et  al.,  as  Co-Personal  Representa­
tives  of  the  Estate  of  Smith,  Deceased,  et  al.  v.  Ford 
Motor  Co.  et  al.  Ct.  Civ.  App.  Okla.  Certiorari  denied. 

No.  08–1431.  Reddy  v.  Matthews  et  al.  Ct.  App.  Cal.,  4th 

App.  Dist.,  Div.  2.  Certiorari  denied. 

No.  08–1433.  Lawrence  v.  Goldberg.  C.  A.  11th  Cir.  Cer­

tiorari  denied. 

No.  08–1434.  Katz  v.  Mabus,  Secretary  of  the  Navy. 
C.  A.  3d  Cir.  Certiorari  denied.  Reported  below:  303  Fed. 
Appx.  125. 

No. 08–1435.  Chung v.  Superior Court of California, San 
Francisco  County,  et  al.  Ct.  App.  Cal.,  1st  App.  Dist.  Cer­
tiorari  denied. 

No.  08–1437.  Russell  et  ux.  v.  United  States.  C.  A.  10th 

Cir.  Certiorari  denied.  Reported  below:  551  F.  3d  1174. 

No. 08–1440.  Haeg v.  Cole.  Sup. Ct. Alaska.  Certiorari de­

nied.  Reported  below:  200  P.  3d  317. 

No.  08–1444.  Aspen  Creek  Estates,  Ltd.  v.  Town  of 
Brookhaven, New York, et al.  Ct. App. N. Y.  Certiorari de­
nied.  Reported  below:  12  N. Y.  3d  735,  904  N.  E.  2d  816. 

No.  08–1445.  Childress  v.  United  States.  C.  A.  4th  Cir. 

Certiorari  denied.  Reported  below:  304  Fed.  Appx.  169. 

No.  08–1446.  Grain  et  ux.  v.  Trinity  Health  et  al.  C.  A. 

6th  Cir.  Certiorari  denied.  Reported  below:  551  F.  3d  374. 

No.  08–1447.  St. Johns  United  Church of  Christ  et al.  v. 
Babbitt, Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration,