Datasets:

coastalcph

/

imageinwords

like 0

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "GPT-4V is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-P5B is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "Neutral", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "A close-up outdoor shot ", " shows an Echinops Bannaticus Blue Glow Globe flower in front of other flowers of that ilk in front of a blue sky ", " and an out-of-focus background .", " The flower 's spiky extensions ", " are light purple-blue in color ", " with curled tips of dark brown .", " The stem is pale tan ", " and appears to be fuzzy .", " At the bottom-left is a clear focused dark ", " green leaf ", " directed toward the viewer ", " with side ", " leaves going out , one to each side .", " But the bloom high above those leaves is out-of-focus and dark .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "Neutral", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "In a low-angle shot , a wall decorated with a pattern of square tiles stands below a wide blue sky with thick , fluffy white and gray cumulus clouds scattered throughout it .", " The top of the wall is a solid slab ", " , and below it are square beige tiles ", " arranged in a grid of two rows .", " Below that is a segment of darker-colored tan ", " square tiles ", " about a quarter ", " the size of the beige tiles ", " , with a pattern of dark brown tiles ", " forming plus-sign shapes in two alternating ", " staggered rows .", " Below this segment ", " , another row of the larger beige tiles is visible , as well as the top of a second row ", " which continues below the frame .", " The sky fills up roughly the top two-thirds of the frame ", " , and is a dark blue ", " with large clouds ", " that are white with darker ", " gray undersides .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "In an eye-level shot , a brick wall extends from the foreground on the right of the frame into the background on the left beneath what appears to be a bridge or overpass .", " The bricks are of similar sizes ", " but not uniform , with some more narrow and rectangular and some closer to square in shape .", " The bricks vary in color ", " between white , gray , yellow , and pink , and much of the mortar is missing in the middle section of the wall .", " There are two objects on the wall ", " that appear to be light fixtures ", " but are either not illuminated or illuminated very faintly .", " The ground is a gray dirt ", " or mud strewn with twigs ", " and branches , as well as what appear to be bicycle tracks in the center .", " There is natural light coming in on the right ", " and far left sides of the image ", " , but much of the area under the overpass is shadowed .", " The side of the overpass is black and white except for a rectangle of light brown ", " , on which is purple-red graffiti ", " which appears to spell the word ", " `` SMiLE ", " '' in highly stylized letters ", " with large curves ", " and swoops .", " The S and rounded E of the world ", " are larger than the middle letters ", " and there is a swoop ", " and arrow between the bottom loop of the S ", " and the bottom loop of the E ", " , pointing towards the E .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "A close-up view of a brick wall ", " reveals the word ", " `` coffee ", " '' painted in a white script ", " lower-case font .", " The letters are interconnected , displaying the intricacies of a handwritten style ", " , with varying widths in the brushstrokes ", " that resemble calligraphy .", " The font has a rightward slant ", " , emphasizing its script nature .", " A straight horizontal white line runs above the word ", " , spanning its width .", " The word `` coffee ", " '' predominantly occupies two central rows of bricks ", " , but the image encompasses a total of five vertically arranged rows .", " The bricks are a distinctive light ", " brown hue ", " with subtle red undertones ", " , and they are free of mortar separations .", " Their texture is not uniform , with an array of dents ", " , splotches ", " , and linear streaks that allude to their coarse ", " and possibly aged material .", " The bricks appear to be standard size ", " , with each brick ", " maintaining a rectangular shape ", " , albeit with some irregularities on their surfaces .", " The wall 's condition ", " , while showing signs of wear ", " , adds character to the backdrop ", " against which the word ", " `` coffee ", " '' stands out prominently .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-P5B is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "A broad , pale-hued shelf ", " encompasses a large matte ", " black television in the center of a recessed section of a wall .", " The brand “ SAMSUNG ” is subtly displayed in white font ", " at the bottom center of the TV .", " A series of spherical ornaments ", " , alternating in shades of shimmering blue and silver with varied patterns ", " , festively adorn the lower shelf .", " These ornaments ", " flank a vibrant ", " red sign ", " prominently displaying the whimsical message ", " “ NO Humbugging ” ", " written in an elegant silver ", " cursive font ", " , accompanied by decorative silver snowflakes ", " scattered around the text .", " Above the television , on the uppermost shelf , the word “ LOVE ” stands out in block-style , metallic wire letters , although the upper portions of these letters are slightly cropped from the frame .", " A richly-toned wooden floor ", " exhibits a spectrum of brown ", " and orange hues directly beneath this scene .", " On the floor rests a triangular wire decoration , adorned with hanging ball ornaments organized into four rows .", " Nestled at its base is an assortment of ornate shells .", " A tall blue ornament ", " , possibly a tree ", " or cone , is situated on the floor ", " and intrudes from the photo ’ s left edge .", " Additionally , a peripheral glimpse to the right uncovers ", " another furniture piece ", " , a cushion ", " , and a hint of a Christmas tree ", " , indicating an adjacent festively adorned living space .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-P5B is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-P5B is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-P5B is marginally better" }

[ "An outdoor overhead shot ", " , perhaps taken from an airplane ", " , looks down on a very bright sunny day ", " at the sharp snow-covered peaks of a mountain range ", " with dark blue shadows ", " , with flat-topped grey clouds ", " approaching from the upper right .", " The mountain range has 6 or 7 very prominent peaks ", " , lit up bright white in the sunlight ", " with dark streaks ", " where the crevices ", " are .", " The well defined shadows ", " , even though deep blue ", " , still allow details of the valleys to be seen .", " The low flat rumpled grey clouds ", " roll in from the upper right ", " , taking over some of the peaks ", " and implying motion .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "Neutral", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "An overhead close-up shot ", " shows an area of flat , lined , blotchy concrete in which four animal paw prints ", " were pressed in while the concrete ", " was still wet .", " It is unclear what type of animal ", " the paw prints ", " belong to , but each one shows four toes .", " Two of the paw prints ", " are placed closely together near the top ", " , vertically stacked almost perfectly , while the other two paw prints ", " are close together in the bottom left corner ", " with the right one slightly ahead of the left one .", " They give the impression ", " that the animal ", " was walking from bottom to top .", " Each set of paw prints ", " has one paw ", " that is more impressed into the concrete ", " than the other .", " The concrete consists of varying shades of gray ", " and seems to be stained by multiple white markings ", " , some dotted and others lines .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "In an eye-level long shot , three black-haired apes lounge on a flat stone platform in what appears to be a zoo exhibit , with high stone walls behind them and blue sky and white clouds above .", " The ape on the far right sits ", " just to the right of a square alcove in the wall ", " with its back to the wall ", " and its legs apart ", " , forearms ", " resting on its knees .", " To the left of the alcove , two more apes lie on their sides .", " All are in the shadow of the very tall stone wall behind them , but a little sunlight lights the front edge of their platform .", " The ape on the left closest to the alcove ", " has its right elbow on the ground to support its head ", " with its hand ", " and its left hand on its knee ", " , which is curled inward .", " The one farther from the alcove ", " and closer to the edge of the platform ", " lies with its head ", " toward the viewer ", " , and its pose is indistinct .", " It is holding a greenish object ", " close to its head .", " Below the platform ", " the apes sit on , large straps ", " , likely of a canvas-like material ", " , are attached to loops ", " bolted to the stone walls ", " and extend beyond the edges of the frame .", " Behind the platform , the cracked , heavy stone wall rises high and is topped by grass ", " and bushes .", " The wall and the rest of the stone is a light tan color ", " streaked with shades of black , white , and pink .", " A row of metal rods ", " runs across the wall ", " close to the top , and some very thin wires ", " are just barely visible between some of them .", " Behind the wall is a structure ", " comprised of triangular ", " and rectangular panels which could be either windows or solar panels , and above it is a blue sky ", " with white and light gray clouds on a sunny day .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-P5B is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-P5B is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-P5B is substantially better" }

[ "In a very , very dark black and white medium shot , the viewer looks out through two dark tall parallel windows to a dark greenish-black forest beyond .", " The window on the left ", " , taking up the entire left half of the photo ", " , is framed with dark black rectangular frames .", " The top half of the window is somewhat lighter , with the heavy dark ", " green leafy trees ", " more visible .", " The lower half of the left window is quite dark , and only a dark horizontal line ", " can be discerned where the dark greenish-black lawn ", " touches the completely black base of the trees .", " The window on the right is partly obscured by a dark black plant ", " with long , narrow , pointed leaves ", " jutting upward at irregular angles .", " The top two leaf tips ", " extend above the middle frame bar of this right window .", " Again , the top half of the window ", " shows more light on the far dark trees ", " and even reveals ", " two tiny bits of dark grey ", " overcast sky .", " The lower half of the right window is so dark that essentially nothing ", " but the plant leaves can be seen .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "GPT-4V is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "GPT-4V is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "GPT-4V is substantially better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "In a high-angle view a scene appears in the distance over the left wing of an airplane , revealing a dull dark-blue flat water feature below and a group of grey-white stone buildings on the far shore , all under a pale blue cloudless sky .", " The airplane wing is in shadow ", " , making it appear silver-blue .", " The ailerons are angled a little downward , and the far tip is painted royal blue ", " , touching the left edge of the image .", " The land mass may be a peninsula ", " because a second water feature ", " can be seen in the upper left ", " at the horizon .", " The peninsula has many short buildings ", " and two distinct piers ", " reaching out into the calm water in the upper right .", " The water is blue and shades of dark grey ", " , with very tiny ripples ", " , but it is not very clear .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "A close-up outdoor shot ", " reveals the vertically stacked words ", " `` I '' `` MISS ", " '' and `` YOu ", " '' carved into the light grey bark of a tree trunk ", " , with a bit of out-of-focus green lawn ", " and trees in the background ", " at the left .", " The words are reddish-brown and carved into the trunk .", " The font is sans-serif , and the letters themselves are not very carefully carved .", " The words are legible , though , and their color ", " makes them stand out strongly against the rough light grey ", " tree trunk .", " There are a few other reddish-brown marks above and to the left of the words ", " , which seem tol be parts of a heart shape ", " that surrounds the words .", " The tree trunk itself has irregular marking ", " , holes ", " , cracks ", " , and lines .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "An outdoor shot on a sunny day ", " shows a dark brown building ", " with a peaked roof ", " , two side porches ", " , and dark brownish-black square panels all over it that are made of parallel strips of wood ", " , all in front of a green forest ", " with blue sky ", " and white cumulus clouds above .", " The building 's panels ", " are its most striking feature ", " , and the parallel boards that make up each panel ", " are only parallel within each panel ", " itself .", " The panels are then juxtaposed with one another so that the lines ", " do not run in the same direction .", " Instead , one panel ", " has boards ", " angling up at 45 degrees ", " and the next one has boards ", " angling down at 45 degrees .", " Some panels ", " are large squares ", " but some are small squares .", " Some are light grey wood ", " but some are dark black wood .", " Two panels ", " are flat light brown wood ", " , and there is a light brown wood birdhouse ", " just under the eave of the roof .", " The porch to the right ", " can barely be seen , made of rustic dark brown timbers ", " that form an open space on concrete flooring .", " The porch on the left is behind the building ", " , extending away from the viewer ", " , and is made built of a dark wooden pillar ", " that branches upward , supporting a corrugated metal roof ", " over a very flat white concrete floor .", " The building itself also seems to have a corrugated metal roof ", " with a small narrow square chimney ", " rising from the back .", " The building sits on a large patch of bare earth ", " but to the sides ", " and behind , there are many green leafy ", " deciduous trees .", " The blue sky with bright white clouds ", " makes up only the upper left quadrant of the photo .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "An overhead shot of the words “ PLEASE WALK BIKES ” ", " vertically stacked underneath three minimalist arrows ", " pointing upwards ", " painted on a dirty gray ", " and white sidewalk in forest ", " green paint .", " The words are painted onto the sidewalk ", " using a stencil .", " The arrows are formed above the words ", " with simple , angled , thin lines ", " pointing up-center ", " from the left ", " and up-center from the right ", " , each pair of lines ", " getting smaller and smaller .", " A long , narrow vertical crack ", " runs from the bottom of the photo to the top , slightly angled right , cutting through the `` K ", " '' of the word ", " `` BIKES ", " '' the `` A ", " '' of the word ", " `` WALK ", " '' and the word `` PLEASE ", " '' , as well as through the arrows .", " The sidewalk is mottled with gray spots ", " all over the gray-white surface ", " , although the lettering is clean .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "A fairly close-up eye-level indoor shot ", " shows a 2023 Volvo S90 B6 Plus on display ", " inside a glassed-in modern auto dealership ", " with a beige-tiled floor ", " and a large red bow on the Volvo 's hood .", " The Volvo is facing the right front of the image ", " , showing its right profile ", " at a 45-degree angle .", " The car has shiny , highly polished , dark grey paint ", " with a shiny chrome grill ", " , chrome bumper ", " , and chrome hub spokes .", " It sits on a floor ", " paved with large beige ", " square tiles ", " that are alternately streaked with sunlight ", " and shadow .", " Behind the car is a wall of floor-to-ceiling windows ", " with thin black frames ", " around each one and a windowed door with another red bow on it .", " Outside the windows in the upper right ", " , there extends a large light brown parking lot ", " with 4 parked cars ", " facing the camera ", " and 1 pick-up truck ", " that faces away .", " On the glass door at the upper-left appears the word `` Volvo '' and some other words in white sans-serif font .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "A close-up high-angle outdoor shot ", " presents a clear plastic cup ", " filled with clear liquid ", " almost to the brim ", " , resting on top of a dirty off-white plastic tabletop ", " , in front of out-of-focus metal chairs ", " and a weathered dark green painted fence .", " The glass is textured most of the way up its sides ", " and tapers somewhat inward from the top to the bottom .", " There are a few water droplets ", " running down the left side of the glass .", " The glass casts a shadow on the tabletop ", " and other dappled shadows appear elsewhere on the tabletop ", " , only a portion of which is visible .", " The chairs are black and formed of narrow curved metal rods ", " that make arched backs ", " with smaller metal rods ", " forming the actual surfaces ", " against which a sitter 's back ", " and hips would rest .", " The out-of-focus green fence ", " has gaps ", " between the narrow boards ", " , some of which show light peeking through .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "Neutral", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "A freight train ", " carrying two levels of sedans is stopped outside a station .", " The top level is red with the text “ MILSPED AML ” ", " written in stylized and slanted white letters .", " The first four cars on this level ", " are covered in white fabric ", " , though the cars ", " further down the long train ", " are not covered .", " The bottom level is blue and carries uncovered shiny cars .", " The first sedan is black , the second silver ", " , third black , fourth silver ", " , and then it is unclear what the rest of the long line of cars ", " are colored .", " The supports holding both levels ", " together are blue with white scuff marks on them .", " The outdoor train stop is empty and has a patterned gray brick floor .", " Near the edge of the platform ", " there is a wide safety rim ", " with black and white slanted stripes .", " The edge of the platform is rimmed in white .", " The canopy above the platform ", " has white slats ", " with occasional black rungs ", " , and the long rectangular canopy is bordered in black .", " There are long rectangular lights ", " that are out , and a yellow triangle sign further down .", " Underneath the train is gray stone gravel .", " The sky is a brilliant blue ", " with a smattering of white sheer clouds .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "GPT-4V is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "GPT-4V is substantially better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-P5B is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "A display of a car design ", " with a drawing of the left profile of a car spread ", " across four glass panels .", " Different features of the car ", " are emphasized on each segment of it .", " The left-most segment shows the left profile of the hood ", " , left headlight ", " and left front time of the car .", " This segment of the car is shiny silver ", " , and this section of the exterior is visible .", " The front left tire ", " has a floral-shaped silver ", " rim.", "The second segment shows a line sketch of interior features of the front seat .", " The outline drawing of a person ’ s legs ", " and feet are shown , with the figure ", " seated , their legs ", " outstretched , and feet on the pedals .", " The third segment shows the exterior of the back seat ", " with the reflection of lights ", " gleaming off the rich mahogany color .", " The back tire is also present , with a floral-shaped silver rim ", " , though this appears darker than the front tire .", " The final segment shows another line sketch ", " , but this is of the exterior of the trunk ", " , back left tire ", " and left tail light .", " The segments do not align with the glass panels .", " Behind the drawing is a grid ", " with small square images ", " arranged in what appears to be a timeline .", " The word “ Design ” in silver is on the wall on the upper left frame .", " A light shines ", " off the bottom portion of the word .", " There are various numbers on the top and bottom of this grid .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-P5B is marginally better" }

[ "An eye-level long shot ", " shows the Jersey City skyline ", " as seen from Battery Park ", " , with slightly rough blue-gray water in the foreground ", " and thick gray clouds in the background ", " except for a small area of blue sky on the right .", " Several skyscrapers ", " can be seen near the edge of the water ", " , as well as a number of smaller buildings ", " and what appears to be a Ferris wheel in the foreground .", " Two objects ", " which may be boats ", " or floating structures ", " are partly visible on the water ", " at the right-side edge of the frame .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "A lamp ", " , cat ", " , and notebook are on a polished wooden table ", " against a vertically paneled wall in the photo .", " The lamp 's base ", " resembles stone ", " and has a muted brown undertone .", " It is urn-shaped and has four distinct stone rings ", " : two around its base ", " and two at its widest point .", " A beige lampshade ", " made of textured fabric rests on top of the base .", " The lampshade has slightly darker bands around its top and bottom edges .", " A short-haired cat ", " , mostly white with notable darker patches on its ears ", " , crown ", " , and over its left eye ", " , sits next to the lamp .", " The cat is poised between the lamp ", " and the notebook , its head ", " slightly tilted to the right ", " , and its eyes ", " reflecting a sharp gaze .", " A notebook ", " with a metal spiral binding is next to the cat .", " The notebook 's lined pages ", " are visible , and it hangs just over the table 's front edge .", " The table is stained a deep chestnut ", " , and its grain ", " and a pronounced dark knot , found just to the lamp 's left ", " , add character .", " Uniform cream-colored vertical wall slats ", " provide a neutral backdrop behind the table .", " A cord ", " from the lamp ", " can be seen descending below the table 's edge ", " , next to what appears to be a touch of lace ", " skirting the room 's baseboard .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "A close-up shot ", " shows a spray-paint art piece ", " depicting a squatting ", " hooded child ", " looking up to the left corner ", " , painted on a dirty concrete wall ", " splotched with other colors .", " The child is painted in sky blue ", " , white , and black , and there are random bits of spray paint ", " surrounding the child on the wall in dark blue ", " , pink ", " , and yellow .", " The child is squatting with hands ", " pressed against mouth ", " , the hood of the sweatshirt up , and wearing open-toed sandals .", " The bent elbows rest on bent knees .", " The letters `` TON ", " '' are spray-painted in black in an art deco stencil in the lower-right corner .", " In front of the art piece , slanted downwards across the very middle from left-to-right , is a dull grey metal bar ", " , with four much smaller metal bars ", " protruding upwards ", " and out of the larger metal bar .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "A close-up shot shows ", " four narrow ", " , supple ", " , light brown tree branches ", " braided together against a tan background of horizontal ", " painted boards .", " The four branches are all tightly intertwined in a reverse fishtail braid ", " that grows looser near the top .", " At the top and in the middle area , the branches ", " are all brown and appear healthy .", " Near the bottom ", " , the braided branches ", " turn a reddish brown ", " and are chipped in multiple areas ", " , especially near the very bottom .", " Behind the braided branches , the wooden surface background is all light mocha ", " brown , but there are thin lines of gray sealant holding the individual wooden planks ", " together .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "GPT-4V is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "GPT-4V is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-P5B is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "A bridge ", " connects a city in the foreground to a distant , indistinct land mass .", " The bridge is positioned horizontally , making it a central focal point of the image .", " The scene is subdued in color ", " , with the clustered city buildings in lighter shades ", " that contrast ", " with the deeper bluish-gray tones of the water ", " and the obscured background .", " The bridge 's structural design is highlighted by cables ", " anchored to two towering pylons ", " , one on each side of the water .", " These cables ", " curve downward toward the center of the bridge ", " , nearly touching the vehicular pathway .", " Amidst the bridge 's structure ", " there are a few discernible white blurs ", " , likely representing moving vehicles .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "A white , blue , and red model ship stands on two thin gray cylindrical supports in front of a gray background in a slightly high-angle shot .", " The front of the ship ", " faces the left of the frame ", " at an angle ", " , so the left ", " or port side of the ship is visible .", " The bottom half of the hull is red and the upper half is blue , with a stripe of white between them , with a red propeller ", " also visible beneath the stern .", " On the side of the ship is the text ", " `` R/V CORAL REEF II ", " '' in all-capital blue lettering .", " The deck is white with a blue railing .", " A white and orange life raft sits on a raised second deck ", " near the back of the ship ", " , between two blue crane-like structures ", " , and the two decks ", " are connected by a ladder ", " near the front of the ship ", " and a staircase near the back .", " Both decks ", " have interior sections ", " which are lined with opaque windows ", " , and both decks have a red and white life preserver ring on their exterior walls .", " A small tower ", " and other instruments , likely for communication ", " and navigation , rise ", " from the roof of the upper deck ", " , as well as a small off-white flag ", " with a circular symbol ", " which appears to depict a wave .", " The same symbol is affixed to the railing of the upper deck .", " The supports holding up the model ", " are long and attach the bottom of the ship to the ground .", " On the ground there is a two-toned shadow ", " from the ship .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "Neutral", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "In a dimly lit indoor scene at a museum , a large antique light-brown wooden sailing ship rests on a beige platform in a huge space with a computer screen to the right and a staircase climbing upward behind it to other levels of the museum .", " The ship 's bow is to the right ", " , its stern to the left ", " , and it takes up the entire lower image space .", " The ship has three masts ", " , with the center mast ", " being very tall , extending to the top of the image .", " They are all made of a light brown wood ", " , and they have no sails on them .", " The body of the ship is busy with clasps ", " that hold the ropes .", " The ship seems to be behind glass ", " because very light translucent reflections of people ", " appear above the ship .", " The computer screen on the right hangs ", " from a very tall black wall ", " that also has a bright square window cut ", " into it .", " The museum portions behind the ship ", " reveal an off-white modern architecture ", " for a building ", " that is at least 3 stories ", " high .", " The stairway behind the ship ", " begins parallel to the ship ", " and horizontally above it , with a set of stairs ", " angled up to the right to get to the next story .", " The stairway is intersected by a modern white column ", " that holds up a circular balcony .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "GPT-4V is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-P5B is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "From a slightly elevated perspective ", " , a detailed view of an ornate corbel ", " , affixed to what is either a stone or plaster wall painted in a muted gray tone .", " The primary focus is the corbel ", " , which , based on its intricate design ", " and position , likely serves ", " as an architectural support ", " or decorative element for a ceiling ", " or shelf above .", " The corbel 's main body is characterized by two prominent asymmetrical volutes ", " : one slightly larger on the left ", " and another on the right .", " These spirals ", " are painted in alternating shades of blue and gold , creating a visually appealing contrast .", " The spirals ' coiled designs ", " culminate in a converging point ", " near the center ", " , forming an almost mirrored image .", " The space nestled between the volutes is adorned with intricate carvings of gilded leaves ", " , each leaf ", " meticulously crafted , showcasing sharp details ", " and exhibiting a golden sheen .", " The texture of these leaves ", " appears slightly raised , indicating they are carved or embossed onto the corbel 's surface .", " The corbel 's outer perimeter is bordered by a gilded trim ", " , and the gold detailing stands out vividly against the gray backdrop of the wall .", " The overall condition of the corbel ", " suggests it has been well-maintained , with only minimal signs of wear ", " or aging , such as slight color inconsistencies in certain areas .", " The orientation of the corbel ", " implies it 's attached to a corner ", " , with the spirals ", " and leaf designs artistically arranged to provide a symmetrical visual appeal ", " from multiple angles .", " The spatial alignment between the corbel ", " and the wall is seamless , reinforcing its function ", " as a sturdy architectural feature .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "GPT-4V is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "In this outdoor shot , a large top-down photograph of coffee cup latte art is propped up next to a tan sharply angled brick wall ", " over the grey-white cement pavement .", " The latte art is in the shape of a flower ", " or ribbed leaf ", " that curves upward in closed-petal formation .", " with the white foam ", " forming the narrow repeating petals ", " over the brown coffee .", " The rim of the mug is thick and white , and it appears to be photographed on a wooden surface .", " At the bottom center ", " , on the sidewalk ", " , lies an empty disposable coffee cup on its side ", " with its top toward the right .", " The cement has small nondescript twigs ", " and debris on it , and there is a line ", " dividing the cement blocks .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-P5B is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "A slightly high angle ", " full shot ", " featuring a statue of a mythological creature ", " standing on a carved tree stump .", " The statue is brownish gray and carved from stone ", " or plaster .", " The statue resembles a troll ", " with a thin body ", " and long , pointed ears .", " The creature is bald with a mohawk hairstyle ", " starting on the crown of his head .", " He has no pupils ", " , and his face ", " appears to be friendly , with raised eyebrows ", " , full cheeks ", " , and a closed-mouth grin .", " Two fangs ", " stick out of his lower lip .", " He is wearing a tunic vest ", " with textured trim ", " around the sleeves ", " and neckline .", " From his wide belt ", " hang three heads of much smaller creatures ", " wearing long sock hats .", " A studded cross-body bag is slung across the troll ’ s shoulder ", " , and one hand is clasped to the bag on his left ", " , while the other holds what appears to be the blunt end of a weapon .", " Large bulky boots rise to his knees .", " The tree stump is positioned on a platform of wooden planks in front of a patch of dirt ", " and mulch .", " A dark forest green ", " paneled wall is in the background ", " with framed old-fashioned maps .", " A small white sign is next to the framed image on the right .", " The light source is unknown , but it seems to be a cloudy natural light .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "In a fairly close-up shot , an old-fashioned cast-iron orange-red painted fire hydrant sits on the ground that is covered in moss ", " and dried brown leaves .", " The fire hydrant is a bright color ", " with highlights of light on the top dome .", " It has grey metallic collared circular caps on the front ", " , top ", " , and right and left sides .", " The fire hydrant has two short arms ", " angled slightly downward with the caps on each arm ", " , while a third very short pipe is much lower on the hydrant ", " at the front ", " , again with a grey cap .", " On the front are the raised letters ", " “ VAG ” above two rings .", " Below the rings is “ DN100 ” ", " vertically oriented over “ PN16 ” .", " On the front cap , are the letters A DIN PVR ", " 5/88 .", " The DIN have a line ", " over and underneath them .", " These letters ", " are all oriented 90 degrees ", " clockwise as if the lid ", " has been turned .", " The lid cap is a triangle ", " with rounded edges ", " over a circle .", " At the bottom of the triangle ", " a metal hook ", " forms the bottom of a backwards S-shape .", " On the left of this front cap is a logo ", " that says “ RWG ” ", " with a line on top .", " At the base of the fire hydrant ", " are the letters ", " “ DIN ” ", " vertically oriented over the letters ", " “ DVG ” .", " At the base of the fire hydrant ", " , there are two visible large nails ", " that seem to be connecting the fire hydrant to the ground .", " Around the base of the fire hydrant ", " , there are small green leaves ", " and moss to the right .", " To the left , there are scattered leaves ", " and a white rock .", " Also there stands a stone-colored bin ", " with a lid .", " The background stretches away with many dried brown leaves on the ground ", " and a few patches of green .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "Neutral", "metrics/Human Like": "GPT-4V is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-P5B is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "Neutral", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "A full shot of McKinley Bridge in St.", " Louis ", " , Missouri ", " stretching across the Mississippi River .", " The bridge appears to be rusted brown steel ", " and is held up by four large concrete posts ", " , two of which are submerged in the water ", " below , where some container ships ", " rest in the water .", " The bridge connects two bodies of land ", " , and the nearest body includes a road ", " where two cars ", " are driving .", " On the second body of land in the background , only lush greenery is visible .", " There are bright blue skies ", " with a small smattering of clouds above the bridge ", " , and several cables hang directly above the bridge closer to the foreground .", " A small portion of what appears to be a concrete barrier ", " just barely crosses the lower-left corner of the frame .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "A close-up shot of two fish designed to intertwine in a yin-yang symbol ", " carved into stone .", " Like the yin-yang symbol ", " , the fish curve ", " inward toward each other , and only one side of each fish is visible .", " The visible side of each fish ", " reveals a singular ", " , dotted eye ", " , gills ", " , open mouths ", " , and fins on their bodies .", " Above each fish ’ s head , there are swirling symbols ", " carved into the stone .", " The tail of each fish extends to form a full , lopsided circle ", " around the fish .", " The stone that the yin-yang fish symbol is carved into appears tan in color ", " and is worn and dirty in areas ", " around the outer corners .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "Neutral", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "A bird's-eye view ", " shows an ornate checkerboard in brown and white with 16 dice ", " forming an `` X ", " '' on the board ", " from corner to corner with one die ", " per space .", " Each die is turned onto their one faces .", " The checkerboard is set into a round ", " , brown ", " , wooden tabletop ", " sitting on a dark green ", " and red tapestry background .", " The checkerboard is framed with a narrow light brown ", " edging into which are inlaid tiny ivory diamond ", " shapes all the way ", " around .", " Beyond this frame ", " are the four semi-circles of the tabletop ", " that are not covered by the checkerboard ", " itself .", " These semi-circle-bounded spaces ", " are filled with inlaid ivory flowers ", " , centered , accompanied by many tiny leaves in exquisite workmanship .", " The round tabletop does not seem to be resting on any table itself , but instead seems to be placed directly on the tapestry .", " The tapestry is made of a rich , thick fabric ", " with yellow , dark green , and red flower and leaf designs .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "GPT-4V is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "Neutral", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "A top-down view of a pale rock surface ", " covered in splotches of yellow green moss .", " The majority of the moss is congregated in the upper center of the frame ", " , with patches ", " stretching to the left ", " and downward center .", " A hint of natural light is reflected in the green tufts of the moss .", " The stone is spotted and seems to have a rough texture .", " A single small brown leaf lays in a bed of the moss on the lower left of the frame .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "Three scale models of the Statue of Liberty stand on three brown pedestals on a brown floor ", " , in an eye-level full shot in front of a curved off-white background .", " The statue and pedestal in the center ", " are closer to the foreground ", " , while the other two statues ", " stand at a slightly farther distance .", " The left and central statues are a light tan ", " while the right statue is off-white , and all three appear to be carved from plaster ", " , stone ", " or marble .", " The pose of all three statues is identical : they stand with their left feet ", " forward as if mid-stride , and hold a rectangular tablet ", " with the top corners ", " cut out at their sides in their bent left arms .", " Their right arms ", " are upraised straight and holding torches ", " with cylindrical handles ", " , circular bowls ", " , and flames atop each one .", " The statues wear flowing , multilayered robes ", " , the right sleeves of which have fallen down from the upraised arms to gather above the shoulders .", " Each statue ", " wears a crown-like headpiece ", " and the left and central statues have spikes ", " that appear to be metallic extending from it , while the statue on the right ", " does not .", " The tablet held by the central statue ", " has indistinct cursive text above a chiseled number ", " that is likely `` 1776 '' , though much of the `` 1 '' is obscured by the figure 's robes .", " There appears to be text on the tablets ", " held by the other two statues ", " as well , but it is indistinct .", " On the pedestal near the central statue 's front-left corner is a small round button ", " labeled with the number ", " `` 6 '' in white .", " On the floor near the front-left corner of the pedestal on the left is a similar button ", " with the number ", " `` 5 '' in white , and in the same position in front of the pedestal on the right is a button ", " with the number ", " `` 7 '' in white .", " Above and behind the statues , a band of shadow darkens the off-white walls .", " There are two bright white lights on both sides of the frame .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "An eye-level long shot of part of the Austin ", " , Texas ", " , skyline ", " , specifically the State Capitol Building in front of a clear blue sky .", " The Capitol Building has a domed roof ", " , topped by a statue of a human figure ", " , rising on round columns ", " from the central structure of the building .", " The foreground is divided into three grass squares ", " with paved walkways ", " between them .", " A chain-link fence ", " separates the square closest to the building ", " from the other two , and the walkway closest to the viewer is flanked by short black pillars .", " A very tall flagpole ", " with an American flag ", " hanging lazily to the right rises above a group of trees on the right side of the image .", " Closer to the Capitol Building is a shorter ", " pointed tower which appears to have a bell in its cupola .", " Several other buildings ", " are visible behind the Capitol ", " , of varying heights ", " and at varying distances ", " , all of them modern , shiny , and some perhaps even glass-covered .", " The sky fills roughly one-half to two-thirds of the image ", " and is clear and blue without clouds .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "Neutral", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "GPT-4V is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-P5B is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "A long shot ", " shows a wooded area ", " with many trees ", " with thin trunks ", " and a lot of green leaves .", " The foreground is mainly a clear pool of water ", " , which reveals a variety of yellow and reddish brown stones of different sizes underneath .", " There are some yellow-green leaves ", " floating on the water ", " , which contrast ", " with the darker ", " submerged stones .", " The center of the photo is a cascading waterfall ", " with multiple levels .", " This water feature is defined by the stream ", " flowing over a group of flat rocks ", " , which have been either naturally stacked or intentionally placed next to each other .", " Some rocks ", " are above the water level ", " , while others ", " are submerged , creating different depths .", " The water cascading down looks ", " clear , and its flow ", " follows a visible path ", " from the top level ", " , trickling down each subsequent level ", " until it reaches the bottom pool .", " Next to the flowing water , the wet surfaces of the rocks glisten , reflecting the ambient light .", " The predominant color scheme is made up of various shades of green from the leaves ", " , interspersed with the earthy browns of the tree trunks ", " and rocks , and the translucent blue tint of the water .", " Sun shines ", " through the tree ", " leaves , making them glow around the waterfall .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "GPT-4V is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "GPT-4V is substantially better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-P5B is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "A downward-facing shot of a heavily populated city ", " , taking up both sides of a river ", " , on a very cloudy day ", " with only a few patches of sunlight falling on some buildings .", " The buildings in the foreground ", " are brightly lit and set right on the waterline of a narrow body of water .", " The buildings are gray , brown , white , and black , but the entire color palette is muted because of the darkness of the day ", " and the distance from the viewer .", " The buildings are of differing heights ", " , some being much taller ", " than others .", " Further back , a large shadow ", " covers much taller skyscrapers in the lower left quadrant .", " Behind the park are more buildings in the large shadow ", " , but these are much shorter .", " A dark gray river ", " separates the two pieces of land ", " , stretching from left to right and angling slightly upwards ", " , with long docks ", " and piers on the far upper bank .", " The second piece of land in the very background ", " holds smaller buildings ", " and gradually fades ", " , until nothing ", " can be seen but a bank of gray against the horizon .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "Neutral", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "From inside a hallway ", " , white light emanates ", " from the frosted windows of a double door ", " into the marble interior of an old , formal , government building .", " A column-style marble ", " molding surrounds the door ", " , and above it the word “ GOVERNOR ” is written in dark gold serif capital letters .", " The door around the frosted windows is dark brown with the doorknob on the right door .", " There is a clear horizontal transom window above the double doors ", " looking into the ceiling of a room .", " The wall around the doorway is white with gray marble accents ", " , and it appears to be made from large rectangular stones .", " Flanking the door ", " are two thin golden sconces .", " The light from the sconces is too bright to reveal the actual light bulbs .", " Below both sconces ", " are wall vents ", " with a decorative pattern .", " The sconce on the right ", " also has a wooden trash receptacle ", " underneath it that partially obscures the vent .", " There is a small black rectangular sign next to the door on the right .", " The light from the door is reflected in two stripes on the shiny marble ", " tiled floor .", " The floor is made up of large flat highly polished marble squares in streaky shades of off-white , light grey ", " , and dark grey .", "" ]

[ "A brightly lit outdoor medium shot on a clear , sunny day ", " shows a wooden door in a thick ", " , solid white stone wall overrun ", " with clinging vines ", " , with tall trees ", " , both deciduous and evergreen , in the background ", " , stretching quite a distance ", " away .", " The stone wall is made of flat horizontal stones ", " stacked on one another , and a beautiful arched stone doorway appears in the center-left portion of the photo .", " The arched doorway shows ", " deeply inset light brown wooden doors ", " that are currently closed , with a brass-colored doorknob on the left door .", " The doors are mostly shaded by the thick stone wall ", " over and around them .", " There is a flat white cement floor in front of the doors .", " The clinging vines that overrun the stone wall ", " are mostly on the right portion of the wall ", " , away from the doors ", " , and they become thicker ", " and thicker toward the right edge of the photo .", " The sunlight lights the top leaves ", " bright green , and dappled dark shadows ", " throughout the vines .", " On the left of the wall , at the left edge of the photo , are other green leaves ", " , perhaps the boughs of the tall green tree ", " that stand ", " just behind the wall .", " The thick forest of green trees ", " fills the photo ", " from left to right above the wall ", " , stretching back to a tree-covered hillside under the brilliant bright blue sky .", " The front of the wall ", " itself is mostly lit with sunlight ", " , and the clear dark shadow from a light utility pole ", " can be seen .", " The light pole is grey , very thin and straight , and almost twice as tall as the wall ", " , with the horizontal light fixture ", " at the top facing ", " slightly to the right of the photo .", " A second grey ", " thin pole reaches ", " horizontally from the left edge of the photo ", " over towards ", " , but not touching , the light pole .", " At the foot of the stone wall ", " , a wide light grey ", " flat sidewalk ", " , in good repair ", " , crosses ", " from left to right , angled very slightly upward at the left .", " The pale grey street runs ", " at the foot of the long sidewalk ", " , interrupted only by one small metal grate in the lower center-right .", " Behind the wall on the right side sits a pale yellow house with a pale red roof and dark arched windows can barely be seen behind the wall and behind some more sparsely leaved trees .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "Neutral", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "A modern skyscraper ", " stands prominently , its exterior composed of mirrored glass panels ", " which capture ", " and reflect the vast cityscape ", " and overcast sky .", " This building ", " showcases a distinct asymmetrical design ", " : the right side ", " follows a conventional rectangular shape ", " , while the left side cuts ", " away in a unique geometric fashion ", " , revealing three layered sections ", " , each tilted at a slightly different angle to offer a varied reflection of the environment .", " Captured from an adjacent structure ", " , the lower right portion of the frame ", " features a stone balcony 's edge ", " , contrasting with the sleek appearance of the skyscraper .", " Additionally , in the upper right corner ", " , there 's the silhouette of scaffolding or construction apparatus , possibly indicating ongoing work ", " or maintenance .", " The skyscraper 's vast mirrored surface serves ", " as a dynamic canvas ", " : the lower floors ", " provide a murky reflection of neighboring edifices ", " and possibly trees ", " , while the upper reaches mirror the day 's gray , cloud-filled sky .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "A slightly high-angled indoor shot ", " with strong lighting ", " shows 2 black vinyl ", " modern chairs ", " facing a central low small black circular table ", " , with a very tall potted Guiana Chestnut tree ", " between the chairs ", " , all in front of an angled white wall ", " that meets another white wall ", " at an odd angle .", " The black chairs have flat shiny cushions ", " , one for the back ", " and one for the seat ", " , with very narrow armrests on black metal bars ", " that curve down in front to create the front legs .", " The left chair is angled right to face the central table ", " , and the right chair is angled left .", " This lets the 2 chairs ", " become perpendicular to each other , with the tall ", " potted tree in between .", " The light shines quite strongly on the right chair ", " , creating highlights ", " and shadows .", " The central table is made of one flat black circle ", " , a couple of thick wide modern legs ", " , and a lower , smaller , flat , black circle ", " near the floor .", " The potted tree is spindly and more than twice the height of the chairs ", " , its glossy dark ", " green leaves hanging down from the ends of 2 extremely narrow trunks ", " , with a few more leafy branches ", " closer to the black pot ", " with grey stones in which the tree sits .", " The white wall behind ", " shows a ceiling line ", " that angles downward to the right ", " , where the white ceiling ", " and both white walls come together in a corner ", " , letting the far-right white wall ", " angle upward as it leaves the frame .", " The effect is one of the room ", " not being plumb and square .", " On the white walls are very well defined shadows of the tree ", " and its leaves .", " The plain mottled yellowish-white floor ", " also shows shadows ", " from the chairs ", " and table .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "GPT-4V is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "The black shadow or silhouette of what may be an Egyptian statue of a pharaoh ", " with a squared back ", " and base faces toward the right ", " against a pale yellow wall .", " No details ", " can be seen except the outline ", " , which has some intermittent curves ", " and indentations along the right side .", " The edges of the figure ", " are somewhat blurry and the background is yellow-white .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "A low-angle shot ", " shows the view ", " from the darkened interior of a stone building ", " through an arched window out at the blue sky ", " , white clouds ", " , teal water ", " , and green trees outdoors .", " The interior of the stone building is very dark , without any source of light except that from the window .", " Flat rectangular grey stones ", " are piled on top of one another to make the arched window .", " The stone arch seems very old , but the 2-paned window with a third , semi-circular top window ", " appears newer , with a dark ", " , possibly wooden frame .", " The panes are stacked vertically .", " Beyond the window ", " the arch ", " extends further than the glass of the window ", " and may be recessed in the exterior wall of the building .", " The blue sky takes up half of what can be seen through the window ", " , with a puffy white-grey cloud ", " at the top .", " A teal body of water ", " can barely be made out past a leafy ", " green tree .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "A fairly close-up indoor shot ", " shows 3 marionettes in a brown wooden boat on display in front of a painted backdrop ", " depicting what appears to be a European country in a previous century .", " The far left marionette is facing center ", " and dressed in a light tan jacket ", " , light brown cuffed knee-length pants ", " , and dark hard shoes .", " His tan ", " carved wooden face ", " has a prominent nose ", " , and he wears a dark brown hat .", " He sits on a brown wooden platform in the middle of the boat ", " , leaning backwards .", " A very long light brown pole is near his left side ", " , angled downward outside of the boat 's port side .", " There are 8 wooden barrels in the middle of the boat ", " , and the 2nd marionette stands behind 2 stacked barrels in the center of the photo ", " , facing a little to his left toward the 3rd marionette .", " The 2nd marionette has a white shirt ", " , dark green jacket ", " , and dark green hat .", " The 3rd marionette is center-right , facing center ", " , with both arms ", " raised to shoulder height ", " at this sides .", " He wears a dark ", " closed jacket ", " with 2 silver buttons ", " , an open collar ", " , and grey pants , plus a dark green or black hat .", " All 3 marionettes ", " have 3 visible wires ", " supporting their hands ", " and heads .", " The bow of the boat ", " comes to a distinct point ", " and a very long thin brown wooden oar rests on top of the starboard side .", " Inside the boat ", " are 2 tall wooden poles to which the oars ", " are lashed .", " In front of the boat is an object made of 3 wooden brown planks ", " , and object made to look like a rough brown-and-white concrete slab ", " , and below it is a painted medium ", " meant to look like water .", " This medium ", " extends in front of the bow of the boat .", " The painted backdrop has light blue paint ", " for the water of the river ", " , a small brown bridge ", " crossing the water ", " , a hillside to the left ", " with green grass ", " and tan archaic buildings .", " The right bank of the river ", " shows more brightly colored yellow-green grass ", " and archaic buildings with many windows ", " , white sides ", " , and red peaked roofs , including a larger multi-spired building ", " that may be a cathedral .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-P5B is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "A clear blue sky ", " and green hills serve as a backdrop ", " for a straight , quiet street in an eye-level shot .", " The street , made of asphalt ", " and slightly worn , stretches ", " from the foreground to the middle distance ", " , flanked by narrow cobblestone gutters on each side .", " The cobblestones are slightly raised from the street level ", " and arranged in a linear pattern .", " They show signs of age ", " and weathering .", " To the left , two buildings with white walls and a smooth plaster texture stand side by side .", " Each building ", " has reddish-brown roof tiles ", " with a rough , layered texture ", " that forms sharp triangular peaks .", " The roofs are punctuated with protruding gable windows .", " The building closest to the viewer ", " has multiple windows ", " underneath its roof ", " , and their shutters ", " are swung open .", " In front of the buildings , square-trimmed hedges create a dense and even barrier that casts short shadows onto the street due to the overhead sun .", " On the right side of the street , the tops of other buildings peek out above a line of lush green trees .", " The leaves of the trees ", " rustle and create a mix of light ", " and shadow .", " A red car is parked beside the trees ", " , its rear facing the viewer ", " and casting a shadow to the left .", " Next to the car is a distinct tree ", " with dark purple ", " , almost velvety branches ", " and leaves .", " In the distance , the hills are blanketed with a thick carpet of green foliage ", " , providing a serene backdrop .", " Each leaf ", " and tree on the hillsides ", " adds to the mosaic of shadows ", " and textures , with some areas ", " looking denser ", " than others .", " Above the hills , the sky is a soft blue ", " and patterned with thin , elongated clouds ", " that have a cotton-like texture .", " Some more pronounced clouds ", " , fluffier and denser , linger closer to the horizon ", " over the hills ", " , slightly obscuring the view of the hilltops .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "Neutral", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "A bright sunny day is captured by a medium shot ", " showing a long horizontal brick wall ", " , a plethora of creeping ivy ", " and hanging vines on the wall ", " , a narrow-barred metal fence above the wall ", " , trees in full green leaf above the fence ", " , and the near end of a two-story brown residence ", " , all backed by a pale blue cloudless sky ", " that filters ", " through the tree ", " leaves .", " The orange-red brick wall ", " runs from left to right across the photo ", " , angled very slightly upward to the right .", " It is solidly built of orange-red bricks in its middle one-third with wide thick greyish-white stone ", " making up the top one-third ", " and bottom one-third of the wall .", " Much of the wall ", " , however , is hidden by the ivy ", " climbing riotously up from the ground ", " and by the clinging vines thickly covering the top of the wall ", " and cascading down the top one-third .", " The wall itself is in shadow ", " , but the bright sunlight from directly overhead lights up the green top leaves of the clinging vines .", " At the base of the wall ", " , green weeds ", " intervene between the wall ", " and a plain light grey ", " asphalt street ", " with a low curb ", " and two white horizontal stripes ", " , one in the lower center of the photo ", " and one just visible at the right edge of the photo .", " The metal fence on top of the brick wall is made of extremely narrow dark metal posts ", " , held together at the top and bottom by slightly thicker horizontal bars .", " The fence runs the entire width of the photo .", " Behind and above the metal fence , several thin , spindly , but wide-branching deciduous trees leaf out in all directions , revealing the pale blue sky behind in lacy natural patterns .", " Behind all of this stands the light brown residence , with its barn-shaped end lit by sunlight and facing the upper-right of the photo , while its very long roof line trails back and away , angled downward to the left , further and further away from the viewer " ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "GPT-4V is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "Neutral", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "In an outdoor bird's-eye view , the word `` Water '' is spray-painted in pale blue on a streaky cement block ", " with a fringe of dried green-and-brown-and-tan grass above it .", " The word `` Water ", " '' is carelessly spray-painted in a messy style .", " It is vertically stacked over a second word in very light green ", " that may be `` sewer '' .", " The cement is vertically lined with the tiny brush strokes of the original cement-layer ", " , onto which spots of dirt ", " and splotches of water ", " have added varies markings .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "Neutral", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "Neutral", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "An indoor shot ", " displays a glossy , cartoonish , painted , ceramic , green and yellow frog on a mottled tan counter in front of a light brown wall ", " with black darkness above .", " The frog is absurdly exaggerated , with two very close-set white eyeballs ", " with black pupils ", " at the top of the head ", " , below which is a comically wide , flat mouth ", " with tan lips ", " that extends out to right and left as wide as the frog 's round body .", " The head and neck , arms ", " and legs of the frog ", " are a shiny , dark green , while the entire front ", " , which forms a shape ", " that is more a circle ", " than a square ", " , is lumpy and dented and an off-white with yellow undertones .", " The arms rest on the sides of the body ", " with visible fingers ", " , and the legs curl around and under the front of the body .", " The entire ceramic piece is fanciful and silly .", " The counter on which it rests is flat and almost without shadows ", " from the ceramic frog .", " In the black darkness that forms the background of the top quarter of the picture , there is a single vertical light ", " blue streak of light going from the light brown wall to the top of the picture .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "A medium shot ", " shows the right ", " , silver-grey wing of the flying airplane ", " with greyish-blue flat water ", " below , and a very long suspension bridge ", " stretching from left to right over the water .", " The wing is angled somewhat upwards to the right .", " Its ailerons ", " are tipped downward and more brightly lit than the wing of the airplane.", "A clear but smoggy blue sky above surrounds the wing ", " , and one more white airplane is shown off in the distance ", " so far away and above that it appears tiny in the upper-center of the frame .", " The blue water below shows streaks of darker water ", " where the wind is rippling it , and streaks of much lighter water ", " where it is calm and flat .", " The suspension bridge has one white pylon ", " and descending cables ", " quite brightly lit by the sunshine ", " , with other pylons in the distance .", " There is a dim dark hillside ", " beyond the bridge .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "GPT-4V is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-P5B is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "In a close-up outdoor shot , rugged tree bark serves as a backdrop for a distinctive beetle .", " The beetle is prominently featured , headed up the bark ", " and slightly to the upper left ", " , with its polished ", " , glossy exoskeleton ", " gleaming in deep brown tones ", " with subtle reflections .", " Its anatomy is detailed , with a pronounced division ", " between its head ", " and thorax , and the thorax and wing covers .", " The insect 's wing covers ", " are well-defined and fit snugly against each other , their smooth surfaces ", " contrasting with the intricate sculpting of the beetle 's head .", " The tree bark exhibits a rich tapestry of textures .", " Crisp ", " , coarse patterns ", " crisscross the bark ", " , highlighted by shades of gray ", " , brown ", " , and white .", " These textures ", " appear rugged , resembling the ridges ", " and valleys of a mountainous terrain .", " The bark 's deep fissures ", " and grooves provide a stark contrast to the beetle 's sleek form ", " , emphasizing its presence .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "Neutral", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-P5B is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "An eye-level medium shot ", " shows a large green shrub ", " surrounding an enlarged photograph of a hawk zip-tied to dark green fencing .", " The hawk in the photograph is either a red-tailed hawk or a red-shouldered hawk , and it has fluffy cream ", " and brown feathers , a beady black eye ", " , and a yellow beak that darkens to black near the opening of the mouth .", " Its head is nearly in profile .", " The photograph is bordered by white and held up to the fence ", " by black zip ties .", " The bottom and left side of the photograph ", " are surrounded by green shrubbery ", " and weeds .", " On the left side , reddish brown branches grow upwards and conceal the green fencing .", " The green fence in the background is accordion-style and obscures what is behind it .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

[ "Two small absurdist ", " painted figurines ", " , one of a snake ", " and the other a fish , are featured in a close-up shot on a beige counter in front of an off-white textured wall .", " On the left is the snake ", " , with most of its coiled body ", " curled upward , and the tail serving as its base .", " Its forked tongue is out to the left ", " and the eyes look upward .", " The snake has patterned red skin ", " : purple ", " elongated ovals ", " with a pink dot in the middle .", " The belly is painted blue and its green eyes ", " are lined in black .", " The red tongue has white lines .", " The fish is positioned facing right with its large eye ", " encircled in red that looks off to the side .", " A maroon border ", " also partially encircles the eye ", " with four lines ", " reaching towards the tail .", " The fish is orange with scales in black outline ", " and a white dot in the middle of each scale .", " Its mouth is open with a bit of red inside .", " The lips are white and there are three horizontal lines ", " leading away from the mouth .", " The caudal fin is orange with maroon lines ", " , while the side ", " and dorsal fin are gold with maroon lines .", " The figurines are placed on a cream-colored surface ", " that has long white scratches ", " going against the grain ", " from bottom to top .", " There is a textured white wall behind the figurines ", " that is poorly lit compared to the counter ", " and the figurines .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "Neutral", "metrics/Human Like": "GPT-4V is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "An indoor full shot ", " shows the Harrison Ford exhibit ", " at Louis Tussaud 's Waxworks .", " The figure of Harrison Ford ", " , in character ", " as Indiana Jones ", " , looks from the right upper quadrant ", " toward the center ", " , where his gaze ", " falls on the carved idol head ", " that rests atop a round ", " gray pillar .", " The figure has tan skin ", " , a close-cut beard ", " , and a brown fedora hat with a wide reddish-brown band ", " around it .", " The figure wears a light tan jacket ", " , crafted to look like rumpled leather ", " , over a lighter yellow-tan open-necked shirt ", " and a pair of loose-fitting yellow-tan pants .", " The figure wears leather boots with low heels ", " , although only the heel of the figure 's right boot ", " can be seen because the figure ", " has bent his right knee to allow his right arm to rest upon it , creating an open-hip pose ", " with the left ", " toes pointed directly at the viewer .", " The jacket has a shiny red lining ", " visible only at the right waist .", " The figure 's right hand ", " holds the handle of a whip ", " , and his left hand ", " holds the thin center of the whip ", " , with the remainder ", " trailing downward .", " The carved idol head is gold in color ", " , open-mouthed , closed-eyed , and looking away from the Ford figure ", " toward the left edge of the photo .", " The head , which has a neck ", " , rests on a flat circular brown disc ", " , polished to a high shine ", " that creates a small reflection of the head .", " The brown disc rests on the multi-colored grey ", " and pink and white and blue marble column , which is slightly larger in diameter ", " than the brown disc .", " The marble column gleams in the light ", " , casting a shadow to the right ", " that almost reaches the Ford figure .", " The figure rests against a painted scene ", " representing a wall of brown stones ", " , a cavern opening ", " , and , more toward the left of the photo ", " , a wall of shiny white merging into dark blue ", " at the bottom .", " The floor on which the column ", " rests is plain dark grey .", " In front of the figure 's feet is a ring of green on the floor ", " , with the words ", " `` HARRISON FORD ", " '' in curving white text ", " with black borders .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "Neutral", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "Neutral", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "A low angle shot ", " outside of a wooden carved owl sitting next to a dead palm tree .", " The owl has round orange eyes ", " and a brown triangle nose .", " Dark ", " brown notches ", " mark its brown feathers on its head ", " and wings .", " The owl ’ s chest is a creamy white with the brown feather marks .", " The owl sits on a tree stump .", " The dead palm tree to the left of the owl ", " has several fronds ", " that are upright , though most droop .", " Green leaves of a plant ", " are just visible below the palm fronds ", " and next to the owl ’ ", " s tree stump .", " Behind the owl and palm fronds , the bare twigs and branches of a large tree stretch from the left to the right of the background in front of a clear , blue sky .", " What appears to be a double rope ", " from a swing hang ", " downward from the top branches .", " The sky is a clear blue ", " , and the sun shines through these branches .", " A blue house ", " with white trim is visible in the background in the lower left corner of the frame .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "Neutral", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "GPT-4V is marginally better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Human Like": "Neutral" }

[ "Geese swim in the water in front of a grassy shore ", " with trees ", " and several single-story yellow houses with brown wide triangular roofs .", " The water is glossy and rippling slightly .", " The sky is light blue with two small clouds ", " near the top of the frame ", " and larger , darker clouds ", " closer to the horizon .", " The geese are oriented toward the left of the frame ", " and appear to be moving in that direction in two groups ", " , with a group of three slightly ahead of a group of six to seven .", " The water fills roughly the bottom half of the frame ", " while the sky ", " fills roughly the top half ", " , divided by the grass ", " , trees ", " , and houses on the shore .", " Between the centermost houses ", " , a street ", " extends toward the horizon ", " with power lines ", " and a car visible in the far distance .", "" ]

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "Neutral", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is substantially better" }

{ "metrics/Comprehensiveness": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/Specificity": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Hallucination": "IIW-Human is marginally better", "metrics/First few line(s) as tldr": "IIW-Human is substantially better", "metrics/Human Like": "IIW-Human is marginally better" }

[ "A beautiful outdoor upward-looking shot ", " takes in a half-moon in broad daylight ", " against a cerulean blue sky ", " , with wide expanded contrails ", " crossing as if in a plus sign in the center .", " The moon is near the upper-right , lit up on the left side ", " , but its shadow angles ", " upward to the right ", " , making it seem as though the moon is `` facing '' toward the upper left .", " The moon is very small compared to the rest of the scene .", " The blue sky forms a perfect backdrop to the aged-out ", " expanded contrails .", " One contrail ", " begins at top-center ", " and flows down almost straight to the bottom ", " , its white cloudiness ", " drifting away to the left ", " as it widens .", " The other contrail is horizontal , left to right across the center ", " , already so wide that the blue sky is quite visible among and behind the clumps of white wispiness .", " There is a scattering of very thin filmy cirrus clouds in the upper left ", " , and even less in the upper right .", "" ]