Datasets:

PatronusAI

/

evaluation-pubmedqa-test-mistral-instruct-7b

like 0

{ "_id": 25394614, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not directly support the answer's claim that 'early surfactant administration significantly reduces the rates of chronic lung disease and mortality among premature infants'.\", \"The document states that the early surfactant group had more CLD and mortality (40.2% versus 20.0%).\", \"The multivariable analysis showed early surfactant to have little or no impact on CLD/mortality.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not directly support the answer's claim that 'early surfactant administration significantly reduces the rates of chronic lung disease and mortality among premature infants'.\", \"The document states that the early surfactant group had more CLD and mortality (40.2% versus 20.0%).\", \"The multivariable analysis showed early surfactant to have little or no impact on CLD/mortality.\"" ]

{ "_id": 18847643, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document does not provide sufficient information to determine if trauma patients can be \"safely anticoagulated with careful monitoring and selection of appropriate anticoagulants.\" The document only reports on the incidence and types of complications, as well as some patient factors associated with these complications.\n- The document states that 21% of patients had at least one anticoagulation complication, and the most common complication was a sudden drop in hemoglobin concentration requiring blood transfusion. Five patients died, three of whom had significant hemorrhage attributed to anticoagulation.\n- The document also identifies chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, UH use, and lower initial platelet count as being associated with complications.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}\n\nThe answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by stating that complications are generally manageable and not significantly associated with patient characteristics, which is not supported by the data in the document." }

[ "\n- The document does not provide sufficient information to determine if trauma patients can be \"safely anticoagulated with careful monitoring and selection of appropriate anticoagulants.\" The document only reports on the incidence and types of complications, as well as some patient factors associated with these complications.\n- The document states that 21% of patients had at least one anticoagulation complication, and the most common complication was a sudden drop in hemoglobin concentration requiring blood transfusion. Five patients died, three of whom had significant hemorrhage attributed to anticoagulation.\n- The document also identifies chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, UH use, and lower initial platelet count as being associated with complications.\n" ]

{ "_id": 26085176, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not support the answer's statement that the whole-body MRI protocol for the detection of bone metastases could safely be limited to the STIR sequence in adults, especially at 3 T.\", \"The document states that T1w sequences detected more metastases than STIR sequences in 53% of patients at 3 T and in 37.5% of patients at 1.5 T.\", \"The document also indicates that T1w imaging had significantly better lesion conspicuity, lesion delineation, and improved image quality compared to STIR imaging at both field strengths.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not support the answer's statement that the whole-body MRI protocol for the detection of bone metastases could safely be limited to the STIR sequence in adults, especially at 3 T.\", \"The document states that T1w sequences detected more metastases than STIR sequences in 53% of patients at 3 T and in 37.5% of patients at 1.5 T.\", \"The document also indicates that T1w imaging had significantly better lesion conspicuity, lesion delineation, and improved image quality compared to STIR imaging at both field strengths.\"" ]

{ "_id": 24785562, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not provide information on the effectiveness of dexamethasone in treating severe acute asthma exacerbations.\", \"The document only mentions the lack of superiority of prednisone over dexamethasone in treating mild to moderate asthma exacerbations.\", \"The document does not mention any benefits related to cost.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}\n\nThe answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by making a claim about the effectiveness of dexamethasone in treating severe acute asthma exacerbations and by mentioning cost as a potential benefit, which is not mentioned in the document." }

[ "\"The document does not provide information on the effectiveness of dexamethasone in treating severe acute asthma exacerbations.\", \"The document only mentions the lack of superiority of prednisone over dexamethasone in treating mild to moderate asthma exacerbations.\", \"The document does not mention any benefits related to cost.\"" ]

{ "_id": 19054501, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document states that schizophrenia patients have motion perception deficits and eye-tracking abnormalities, and that eye movement interacts with motion perception. However, the answer goes beyond the document by stating that the eye-tracking abnormalities directly cause the motion perception deficits.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document states that schizophrenia patients have motion perception deficits and eye-tracking abnormalities, and that eye movement interacts with motion perception. However, the answer goes beyond the document by stating that the eye-tracking abnormalities directly cause the motion perception deficits.\"" ]

{ "_id": 24947183, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document reports that fusion levels changed in 94.2% to 100.0% of patients according to all three guidelines, which contradicts the answer stating that there is no need for increase in fusion levels.\", \"The document also reports that curve pattern was changed in 34.3% to 100.0% of patients according to Lenke's and Suk's guidelines, which contradicts the answer stating that there are no alterations in the curve pattern.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document reports that fusion levels changed in 94.2% to 100.0% of patients according to all three guidelines, which contradicts the answer stating that there is no need for increase in fusion levels.\", \"The document also reports that curve pattern was changed in 34.3% to 100.0% of patients according to Lenke's and Suk's guidelines, which contradicts the answer stating that there are no alterations in the curve pattern.\"" ]

{ "_id": 28027677, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The ANSWER goes beyond the information provided in the DOCUMENT by making a definitive statement about the impact being'significant' and'many students' viewing VODcasts as a replacement for live lectures.\", \"The DOCUMENT only states that 79% of students indicated that VODcasts should not replace lectures, but it does not provide information about how many students actually used VODcasts as a replacement or to what extent.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The ANSWER goes beyond the information provided in the DOCUMENT by making a definitive statement about the impact being'significant' and'many students' viewing VODcasts as a replacement for live lectures.\", \"The DOCUMENT only states that 79% of students indicated that VODcasts should not replace lectures, but it does not provide information about how many students actually used VODcasts as a replacement or to what extent.\"" ]

{ "_id": 22186742, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not provide any information supporting the statement that 'colonoscopy significantly affects the management of patients with acute diverticulitis and alters the outcome'.\", \"The document states that no new or different diagnosis was made after colonoscopy in the studied patients.\", \"The document also mentions that no colonic malignancy was detected.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not provide any information supporting the statement that 'colonoscopy significantly affects the management of patients with acute diverticulitis and alters the outcome'.\", \"The document states that no new or different diagnosis was made after colonoscopy in the studied patients.\", \"The document also mentions that no colonic malignancy was detected.\"" ]

{ "_id": 26037986, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The answer acknowledges the high mortality rate in emergency laparotomies and the need for improvement, which is consistent with the information in the document.\n- The answer suggests potential strategies for improving outcomes, such as increasing manpower, early recognition, clear management protocols, and centralization of services, which are not directly mentioned in the document but are related to the topic of improving care in emergency laparotomy.\n- The answer focuses on the group of patients under the age of 70 years, which is consistent with the information in the document regarding higher mortality rates in older patients.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}\n\nThe answer is faithful to the contents of the document as it acknowledges the poorer outcomes and higher mortality rates in emergency laparotomies, and the need for improvement, which are all mentioned in the document. The answer also focuses on the group of patients under the age of 70 years, which is consistent with the information in the document. The additional suggestions for improving outcomes are related to the topic but not directly mentioned in the document. However, they do not contradict the information in the document and could be considered reasonable based on the context provided." }

[ "\n- The answer acknowledges the high mortality rate in emergency laparotomies and the need for improvement, which is consistent with the information in the document.\n- The answer suggests potential strategies for improving outcomes, such as increasing manpower, early recognition, clear management protocols, and centralization of services, which are not directly mentioned in the document but are related to the topic of improving care in emergency laparotomy.\n- The answer focuses on the group of patients under the age of 70 years, which is consistent with the information in the document regarding higher mortality rates in older patients.\n" ]

{ "_id": 9444542, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document states that 'No significant differences in rate of cognitive decline' were found between subjects with and without HCA.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document states that 'No significant differences in rate of cognitive decline' were found between subjects with and without HCA.\"" ]

{ "_id": 22042121, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document states that the animals underwent different periods of pre-operative fasting.\", \"The answer correctly states that pre-operative fasting is required for the rabbit model in training for surgery.\"], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\"The document states that the animals underwent different periods of pre-operative fasting.\", \"The answer correctly states that pre-operative fasting is required for the rabbit model in training for surgery.\"" ]

{ "_id": 16956164, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The DOCUMENT states that all four ethnic groups in New Zealand exhibit socio-economic gradients in all-cause mortality.\n- The ANSWER correctly acknowledges that socio-economic gradients exist among all ethnic groups.\n- The ANSWER also provides additional information about the relative steepness of the gradients for Maori and Europeans, which is consistent with the information in the DOCUMENT.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\n- The DOCUMENT states that all four ethnic groups in New Zealand exhibit socio-economic gradients in all-cause mortality.\n- The ANSWER correctly acknowledges that socio-economic gradients exist among all ethnic groups.\n- The ANSWER also provides additional information about the relative steepness of the gradients for Maori and Europeans, which is consistent with the information in the DOCUMENT.\n" ]

{ "_id": 12947068, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document provides data on life expectancy (LE) and quality-adjusted life expectancy (QALE) for older men with localized prostate cancer undergoing radical prostatectomy (RP), external beam radiotherapy (EBRT), and watchful waiting (WW).\n- The document states that for men with well-differentiated tumors and few comorbidities, potentially curative therapy (RP or EBRT) prolonged LE but did not improve QALE at any age.\n- The document also states that for moderately differentiated cancers, potentially curative therapy resulted in LE and QALE gains up to age 75 years. For poorly differentiated disease, potentially curative therapy resulted in LE and QALE gains up to age 80 years.\n- The document specifies that these benefits were restricted to men with no worse than mild comorbidity.\n- The answer goes beyond the document by stating that potentially curative therapy results in significantly improved LE and QALE for older men with any level of comorbidities and moderately or poorly differentiated localized prostate cancer.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The document provides data on life expectancy (LE) and quality-adjusted life expectancy (QALE) for older men with localized prostate cancer undergoing radical prostatectomy (RP), external beam radiotherapy (EBRT), and watchful waiting (WW).\n- The document states that for men with well-differentiated tumors and few comorbidities, potentially curative therapy (RP or EBRT) prolonged LE but did not improve QALE at any age.\n- The document also states that for moderately differentiated cancers, potentially curative therapy resulted in LE and QALE gains up to age 75 years. For poorly differentiated disease, potentially curative therapy resulted in LE and QALE gains up to age 80 years.\n- The document specifies that these benefits were restricted to men with no worse than mild comorbidity.\n- The answer goes beyond the document by stating that potentially curative therapy results in significantly improved LE and QALE for older men with any level of comorbidities and moderately or poorly differentiated localized prostate cancer.\n" ]

{ "_id": 21669959, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer does not directly address the question about secondhand smoke risk in infants discharged from an NICU and potential health disparities. Instead, it makes a statement about disadvantaged families having protective health behaviors and being less at-risk for tobacco exposure.\n- The ANswer does not provide any specific information about the document or the study findings related to secondhand smoke risk, health disparities, or the relationship between socioeconomic status, race, mental health status, and smoking bans.\n- The ANswer offers new information beyond the context provided in the DOCUMENT, as it makes assumptions about the protective effects of having a smoking ban and the need for interventions for this vulnerable population.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANswer does not directly address the question about secondhand smoke risk in infants discharged from an NICU and potential health disparities. Instead, it makes a statement about disadvantaged families having protective health behaviors and being less at-risk for tobacco exposure.\n- The ANswer does not provide any specific information about the document or the study findings related to secondhand smoke risk, health disparities, or the relationship between socioeconomic status, race, mental health status, and smoking bans.\n- The ANswer offers new information beyond the context provided in the DOCUMENT, as it makes assumptions about the protective effects of having a smoking ban and the need for interventions for this vulnerable population.\n" ]

{ "_id": 22440363, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer makes a statement about the mortality rates being lower for MV replacement, which is not directly stated in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer also implies that MV replacement should be preferred \"whenever possible\" based on the mortality data, which goes beyond the information provided in the DOCument.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANswer makes a statement about the mortality rates being lower for MV replacement, which is not directly stated in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer also implies that MV replacement should be preferred \"whenever possible\" based on the mortality data, which goes beyond the information provided in the DOCument.\n" ]

{ "_id": 27216167, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer mentions \"lifestyle factors significantly influence contact with specialist care\" which is not explicitly stated in the DOCument but can be inferred from the data presented about the higher odds of contact with a specialist among individuals with higher educational level.\n- The ANswer also suggests \"future studies should investigate inequalities in access to the secondary healthcare system\" which goes beyond the scope of the DOCument and therefore is not faithful to its contents.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANswer mentions \"lifestyle factors significantly influence contact with specialist care\" which is not explicitly stated in the DOCument but can be inferred from the data presented about the higher odds of contact with a specialist among individuals with higher educational level.\n- The ANswer also suggests \"future studies should investigate inequalities in access to the secondary healthcare system\" which goes beyond the scope of the DOCument and therefore is not faithful to its contents.\n" ]

{ "_id": 17483607, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not provide any information about severe otorrhea being caused by N-acetylcysteine application in the control group.\", \"The answer contradicts the information in the document that 60% of the perforations in the NAC group exhibited otorrhea by the third day.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not provide any information about severe otorrhea being caused by N-acetylcysteine application in the control group.\", \"The answer contradicts the information in the document that 60% of the perforations in the NAC group exhibited otorrhea by the third day.\"" ]

{ "_id": 21801416, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The answer correctly identifies AMPK as a potential regulator of melatonin secretion based on the information in the document.\n- The answer correctly suggests that AMPK may act through the suprachiasmatic nucleus and/or directly in the pineal gland, which is implied in the document.\n- The answer correctly concludes that AMPK may act as a metabolic cue to modulate the rhythm of melatonin secretion, which is a reasonable inference based on the findings in the document.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\n- The answer correctly identifies AMPK as a potential regulator of melatonin secretion based on the information in the document.\n- The answer correctly suggests that AMPK may act through the suprachiasmatic nucleus and/or directly in the pineal gland, which is implied in the document.\n- The answer correctly concludes that AMPK may act as a metabolic cue to modulate the rhythm of melatonin secretion, which is a reasonable inference based on the findings in the document.\n" ]

{ "_id": 18403944, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document reports two cases of patients who were considered to have developed tolerance to gluten, which contradicts the statement that development of tolerance to gluten is not possible in patients with CD.\", \"The document also mentions that one of the patients was HLA-DQ2/DQ8 negative, which contradicts the statement that genetic characteristics are not associated with the development of gluten intolerance.\", \"The answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by making statements about the permanence and genetic aspects of gluten intolerance without any supporting evidence from the document.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document reports two cases of patients who were considered to have developed tolerance to gluten, which contradicts the statement that development of tolerance to gluten is not possible in patients with CD.\", \"The document also mentions that one of the patients was HLA-DQ2/DQ8 negative, which contradicts the statement that genetic characteristics are not associated with the development of gluten intolerance.\", \"The answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by making statements about the permanence and genetic aspects of gluten intolerance without any supporting evidence from the document.\"" ]

{ "_id": 22668852, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not directly state that AA women require fewer calories to maintain weight.\", \"The document reports that AA women had higher calorie intake during the study, not fewer.\", \"The document states that after adjustment for potential confounders, there was no difference in caloric intake between AA and non-AA women.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not directly state that AA women require fewer calories to maintain weight.\", \"The document reports that AA women had higher calorie intake during the study, not fewer.\", \"The document states that after adjustment for potential confounders, there was no difference in caloric intake between AA and non-AA women.\"" ]

{ "_id": 20488985, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not provide evidence of a notable increase in the public's understanding of the ineffectiveness of antibiotics for coughs and colds.\", \"The document does not provide evidence of a significant reduction in the misuse of antibiotics.\", \"The document reports an increase in respondents retaining leftover antibiotics, which could indicate misuse, not a reduction.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not provide evidence of a notable increase in the public's understanding of the ineffectiveness of antibiotics for coughs and colds.\", \"The document does not provide evidence of a significant reduction in the misuse of antibiotics.\", \"The document reports an increase in respondents retaining leftover antibiotics, which could indicate misuse, not a reduction.\"" ]

{ "_id": 11567820, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not provide sufficient evidence to support the answer's claim that'significantly improves pain relief' when increasing the treatment volume to include a longer nerve length.\", \"The document does mention a correlation between complications (numbness or paresthesias) and the nerve length irradiated (p = 0.018), but it does not state that this correlation implies a reduction in complications when increasing the treatment volume.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not provide sufficient evidence to support the answer's claim that'significantly improves pain relief' when increasing the treatment volume to include a longer nerve length.\", \"The document does mention a correlation between complications (numbness or paresthesias) and the nerve length irradiated (p = 0.018), but it does not state that this correlation implies a reduction in complications when increasing the treatment volume.\"" ]

{ "_id": 24507422, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer mentions \"five quantitative shape descriptors of carotid FFT\", which is consistent with the DOCument as it also states \"Five shape descriptors delineated FFT+ from FFT- cases\".\n- However, the ANswer goes beyond the information provided in the DOCument by stating \"however, these descriptors were not effective in differentiating FFT from atherosclerotic plaque\", which is not explicitly stated in the DOCument.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}\n\nThe ANswer is not faithful to the DOCument as it offers new information beyond the context provided in the DOCument. While the ANswer correctly identifies the five shape descriptors mentioned in the DOCument, it goes beyond the information provided by stating that these descriptors were not effective in differentiating FFT from atherosclerotic plaque, which is not explicitly stated in the DOCument." }

[ "\n- The ANswer mentions \"five quantitative shape descriptors of carotid FFT\", which is consistent with the DOCument as it also states \"Five shape descriptors delineated FFT+ from FFT- cases\".\n- However, the ANswer goes beyond the information provided in the DOCument by stating \"however, these descriptors were not effective in differentiating FFT from atherosclerotic plaque\", which is not explicitly stated in the DOCument.\n" ]

{ "_id": 15539888, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document reports that the atopy patch test (APT) with house dust mites (HDM) was positive in a higher percentage of atopic dermatitis (AD) patients compared to atopic subjects without dermatitis (AWE) and nonatopic (NA) subjects.\", \"The document also states that the rates of positivity and the intensity scores of responses were significantly different between AD and non-AD subjects.\", \"Therefore, the answer is faithful to the information provided in the document as it correctly states that the APT with HDM is more likely to be positive in AD patients.\"], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\"The document reports that the atopy patch test (APT) with house dust mites (HDM) was positive in a higher percentage of atopic dermatitis (AD) patients compared to atopic subjects without dermatitis (AWE) and nonatopic (NA) subjects.\", \"The document also states that the rates of positivity and the intensity scores of responses were significantly different between AD and non-AD subjects.\", \"Therefore, the answer is faithful to the information provided in the document as it correctly states that the APT with HDM is more likely to be positive in AD patients.\"" ]

{ "_id": 24866606, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not state that emergency US fellowship programs had a negative impact on residents' US educational experiences.\", \"The document reports that residents in programs with EUS fellowships performed more scans and used bedside US for more advanced applications, which contradicts the answer.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not state that emergency US fellowship programs had a negative impact on residents' US educational experiences.\", \"The document reports that residents in programs with EUS fellowships performed more scans and used bedside US for more advanced applications, which contradicts the answer.\"" ]

{ "_id": 27096199, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document states that \"The number of detected viruses did not correlate with any markers of severity\" which contradicts the answer's claim that \"Yes. The presence of more than one virus in hospitalized children with ARI significantly increases the severity of the disease.\"\n- However, the document does mention that \"bacterial superinfection was associated with increased severity\" which aligns with the answer's statement about bacterial superinfection increasing the severity of the disease.\n- The document also mentions that \"pneumococcal vaccination was a protective factor in terms of degree of respiratory distress, PICU admission, lower clinical score, respiratory support requirement, and oxygen necessity.\" which aligns with the answer's statement about pneumococcal vaccination playing a protective role.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}\n\nThe answer is mostly faithful to the document, but it contains an incorrect statement about viral co-infection increasing the severity of ARI in children, which is contradicted by the information in the document. However, the answer correctly states that bacterial superinfection and pneumococcal vaccination have an impact on the severity of ARI, as shown in the document." }

[ "\n- The document states that \"The number of detected viruses did not correlate with any markers of severity\" which contradicts the answer's claim that \"Yes. The presence of more than one virus in hospitalized children with ARI significantly increases the severity of the disease.\"\n- However, the document does mention that \"bacterial superinfection was associated with increased severity\" which aligns with the answer's statement about bacterial superinfection increasing the severity of the disease.\n- The document also mentions that \"pneumococcal vaccination was a protective factor in terms of degree of respiratory distress, PICU admission, lower clinical score, respiratory support requirement, and oxygen necessity.\" which aligns with the answer's statement about pneumococcal vaccination playing a protective role.\n" ]

{ "_id": 24922528, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not provide evidence that family factors significantly moderated the association between pubertal stage and alcohol use.\", \"The answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by implying that family factors had a moderating role when the document states that no interaction terms improved the fit of the model.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not provide evidence that family factors significantly moderated the association between pubertal stage and alcohol use.\", \"The answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by implying that family factors had a moderating role when the document states that no interaction terms improved the fit of the model.\"" ]

{ "_id": 24245816, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document reports a correlation between trabecular properties (number, thickness, bone volume density, BMD) and primary stability (insertion torque, mini-implant mobility, pull-out strength).\", \"The document does not explicitly state that trabecular bone plays a'significant role' in primary stability, but it does show a correlation between trabecular properties and primary stability.\", \"The answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by stating'regardless of the presence of cortical bone' which is not mentioned in the document.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document reports a correlation between trabecular properties (number, thickness, bone volume density, BMD) and primary stability (insertion torque, mini-implant mobility, pull-out strength).\", \"The document does not explicitly state that trabecular bone plays a'significant role' in primary stability, but it does show a correlation between trabecular properties and primary stability.\", \"The answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by stating'regardless of the presence of cortical bone' which is not mentioned in the document.\"" ]

{ "_id": 25489696, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The ANswer is in direct contradiction to the DOCument, which states that patients who received radiotherapy for their primary rectal cancer had lower disease-free survival and overall survival in multivariate analysis.\", \"The ANswer offers new information beyond the context provided in the DOCument, as it states that patients who previously received radiotherapy have better oncologic outcomes.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The ANswer is in direct contradiction to the DOCument, which states that patients who received radiotherapy for their primary rectal cancer had lower disease-free survival and overall survival in multivariate analysis.\", \"The ANswer offers new information beyond the context provided in the DOCument, as it states that patients who previously received radiotherapy have better oncologic outcomes.\"" ]

{ "_id": 11296674, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not provide any information about prostatic syndrome or pleural effusion being the same or different diseases.\", \"The answer introduces new information not present in the document.\", \"The answer contradicts the information in the document that metastatic carcinoma of the prostate was discarded.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not provide any information about prostatic syndrome or pleural effusion being the same or different diseases.\", \"The answer introduces new information not present in the document.\", \"The answer contradicts the information in the document that metastatic carcinoma of the prostate was discarded.\"" ]

{ "_id": 18783922, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document reports an analysis of cytokine levels in patients with epilepsy and new onset seizures.\n- The answer acknowledges that cytokines have a role in epilepsy.\n- The document does not provide information about decreased post-ictal serum cytokine levels in patients with several epilepsy syndromes.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}\n\nThe answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by stating that decreased post-ictal serum cytokine levels were found in patients with several epilepsy syndromes, which is not mentioned in the document." }

[ "\n- The document reports an analysis of cytokine levels in patients with epilepsy and new onset seizures.\n- The answer acknowledges that cytokines have a role in epilepsy.\n- The document does not provide information about decreased post-ictal serum cytokine levels in patients with several epilepsy syndromes.\n" ]

{ "_id": 14745753, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document reports that the image quality of the abdominal aorta and common iliac artery was not statistically significantly different between the half-dose and full-dose groups.\n- The answer states that half-dose MR angiography using diluted contrast medium depicted the abdominal aorta and its branches as clearly as using a full single dose.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}\n\nThe answer is faithful to the document as it does not offer new information and does not contradict the findings reported in the document." }

[ "\n- The document reports that the image quality of the abdominal aorta and common iliac artery was not statistically significantly different between the half-dose and full-dose groups.\n- The answer states that half-dose MR angiography using diluted contrast medium depicted the abdominal aorta and its branches as clearly as using a full single dose.\n" ]

{ "_id": 18388848, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The ANSWER correctly states that having a regular primary care clinician is associated with improvements in interpersonal quality and the content of anticipatory guidance for young children.\", \"The ANSWER goes beyond the DOCUMENT by mentioning that team care among physicians is also widely practiced in pediatrics, which is not mentioned in the DOCUMENT.\"], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\" }\n\nAlthough the ANSWER goes beyond the information provided in the DOCUMENT, the additional information does not contradict the contents of the DOCUMENT and is generally true within the context of pediatric care. Therefore, the ANSWER is considered faithful to the DOCUMENT." }

[ "\"The ANSWER correctly states that having a regular primary care clinician is associated with improvements in interpersonal quality and the content of anticipatory guidance for young children.\", \"The ANSWER goes beyond the DOCUMENT by mentioning that team care among physicians is also widely practiced in pediatrics, which is not mentioned in the DOCUMENT.\"" ]

{ "_id": 21900017, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The ANSWER states that lung IR has a'marked positive impact' on coronary blood flow, hemodynamics, and inflammatory profile.\", \"However, the DOCUMENT states that total coronary flow decreases precipitously and significantly during lung IR.\", \"The ANSWER also mentions 'the first study where coronary blood flow is directly measured during lung IR' which is not mentioned in the DOCUMENT.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The ANSWER states that lung IR has a'marked positive impact' on coronary blood flow, hemodynamics, and inflammatory profile.\", \"However, the DOCUMENT states that total coronary flow decreases precipitously and significantly during lung IR.\", \"The ANSWER also mentions 'the first study where coronary blood flow is directly measured during lung IR' which is not mentioned in the DOCUMENT.\"" ]

{ "_id": 18269157, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The answer acknowledges that the document discusses the biomechanical and wound healing characteristics of corneas after excimer laser keratorefractive surgery and compares advanced surface ablation (ASA) and sub-Bowman's keratomileusis (SBK) to conventional LASIK and PRK.\n- The answer correctly states that SBK and ASA have improvements over conventional LASIK and PRK, such as maintaining corneal biomechanics and significantly reducing the risk of corneal haze.\n- The answer correctly mentions that most of the disadvantages caused by wound healing issues remain for all excimer laser keratorefractive surgical techniques.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\n- The answer acknowledges that the document discusses the biomechanical and wound healing characteristics of corneas after excimer laser keratorefractive surgery and compares advanced surface ablation (ASA) and sub-Bowman's keratomileusis (SBK) to conventional LASIK and PRK.\n- The answer correctly states that SBK and ASA have improvements over conventional LASIK and PRK, such as maintaining corneal biomechanics and significantly reducing the risk of corneal haze.\n- The answer correctly mentions that most of the disadvantages caused by wound healing issues remain for all excimer laser keratorefractive surgical techniques.\n" ]

{ "_id": 10135926, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer correctly states that oral endotracheal intubation in the in-flight setting of the BO-105 helicopter is not significantly impaired compared to a ground setting, as indicated by the study results.\n- The ANswer correctly states that the study results suggest that in-flight intubation can be performed with similar efficacy as on the ground.\n- The ANswer correctly states that pre-flight intubation may not be necessary for patients likely to require urgent intubation during air medical transport in the BO-105 helicopter.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANswer correctly states that oral endotracheal intubation in the in-flight setting of the BO-105 helicopter is not significantly impaired compared to a ground setting, as indicated by the study results.\n- The ANswer correctly states that the study results suggest that in-flight intubation can be performed with similar efficacy as on the ground.\n- The ANswer correctly states that pre-flight intubation may not be necessary for patients likely to require urgent intubation during air medical transport in the BO-105 helicopter.\n" ]

{ "_id": 7497757, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document describes a study comparing thyroid function during and after hypothermic and normothermic CPB, but it does not mention anything about the development or prevention of euthyroid sick syndrome specifically in relation to temperature during CPB.\n- The answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by making a conclusion about the prevention of euthyroid sick syndrome with normothermic CPB.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The document describes a study comparing thyroid function during and after hypothermic and normothermic CPB, but it does not mention anything about the development or prevention of euthyroid sick syndrome specifically in relation to temperature during CPB.\n- The answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by making a conclusion about the prevention of euthyroid sick syndrome with normothermic CPB.\n" ]

{ "_id": 17113061, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document reports that in a study of 10 different mutations in LCAT, ABCA1 and APOA1, there was no significant difference in carotid intima-media thickness (cIMT) between cases with low HDL-C and controls despite significantly lower HDL cholesterol and apolipoprotein A-I levels in the cases.\", \"The answer, however, states that the study suggests a correlation between low HDL-C and increased carotid intima-media thickness.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}\n\nThe answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by stating that there is a correlation between low HDL-C and increased carotid intima-media thickness, when the document actually reports that there was no significant difference in cIMT between the two groups." }

[ "\"The document reports that in a study of 10 different mutations in LCAT, ABCA1 and APOA1, there was no significant difference in carotid intima-media thickness (cIMT) between cases with low HDL-C and controls despite significantly lower HDL cholesterol and apolipoprotein A-I levels in the cases.\", \"The answer, however, states that the study suggests a correlation between low HDL-C and increased carotid intima-media thickness.\"" ]

{ "_id": 16428354, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document and answer both discuss the difference in neonatal outcomes between rural and urban infants in the context of premature birth. The answer correctly states that urban infants have a higher risk of stillbirth and mortality in neonatal intensive care than rural infants, which is consistent with the findings in the document. The answer does not offer new information beyond the context provided in the document.\"], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\"The document and answer both discuss the difference in neonatal outcomes between rural and urban infants in the context of premature birth. The answer correctly states that urban infants have a higher risk of stillbirth and mortality in neonatal intensive care than rural infants, which is consistent with the findings in the document. The answer does not offer new information beyond the context provided in the document.\"" ]

{ "_id": 16418930, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document does not mention a \"significant overestimation\" of visual acuity by the Snellen E compared to the Landolt C in strabismus amblyopia. The document states that the differences were small.\n- The document does not state that \"large differences\" in the lower visual acuity range have to be considered, only that differences cannot be excluded.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The document does not mention a \"significant overestimation\" of visual acuity by the Snellen E compared to the Landolt C in strabismus amblyopia. The document states that the differences were small.\n- The document does not state that \"large differences\" in the lower visual acuity range have to be considered, only that differences cannot be excluded.\n" ]

{ "_id": 18435678, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document reports that fetal thrombocytopenia was found in 10% of pregnancies with Kell alloimmunization and none of them had clinically significant thrombocytopenia.\n- The answer states that fetuses with severe anaemia due to Kell alloimmunization are generally at risk for substantial thrombocytopenia.\n- The answer is consistent with the document as it acknowledges the presence of thrombocytopenia in fetuses with Kell alloimmunization, but it goes beyond the document by implying that it is a significant risk, which the document does not explicitly state.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}\n\nThe answer is faithful to the document as it acknowledges the presence of thrombocytopenia in fetuses with Kell alloimmunization, even though it goes beyond the document by implying that it is a significant risk. However, the document does not contradict this implication, so the answer remains faithful." }

[ "\n- The document reports that fetal thrombocytopenia was found in 10% of pregnancies with Kell alloimmunization and none of them had clinically significant thrombocytopenia.\n- The answer states that fetuses with severe anaemia due to Kell alloimmunization are generally at risk for substantial thrombocytopenia.\n- The answer is consistent with the document as it acknowledges the presence of thrombocytopenia in fetuses with Kell alloimmunization, but it goes beyond the document by implying that it is a significant risk, which the document does not explicitly state.\n" ]

{ "_id": 24183388, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document states that four cases with a negative Hawkins sign developed necrosis, and two cases with a positive Hawkins sign did not develop necrosis.\n- The answer states that a positive Hawkins sign confirms necrosis, but its absence does not rule it out.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}\n\nReasoning:\n\nThe answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by stating that a positive Hawkins sign confirms necrosis, which is not explicitly stated in the document. The document only states that a positive Hawkins sign was observed in cases that developed necrosis, but it does not confirm that the sign alone caused the necrosis. Additionally, the answer states that the absence of the Hawkins sign does not rule out necrosis, which is also not explicitly stated in the document. The document only states that four cases with negative Hawkins signs developed necrosis." }

[ "\n- The document states that four cases with a negative Hawkins sign developed necrosis, and two cases with a positive Hawkins sign did not develop necrosis.\n- The answer states that a positive Hawkins sign confirms necrosis, but its absence does not rule it out.\n" ]

{ "_id": 24614789, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not provide information on the effectiveness of lumbar drainage in preventing CSF fistulas in cases of small dural tears or debilitated/irradiated patients.\", \"The document only reports on the outcomes of patients who underwent lumbar drainage after developing a CSF fistula, not on its preventative use.\", \"The document does not mention any adverse events related to lumbar drainage.\", \"The document reports that patients treated with CSF drainage were cured in a mean period of 10 days, which is significantly faster than those treated conservatively (30 days)\"], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}\n\nThe answer is faithful to the document as it only reports on the information provided in the document regarding the effectiveness and safety of lumbar drainage in treating CSF fistulas based on the reported outcomes of the patients. It does not offer new information or contradict any information in the document." }

[ "\"The document does not provide information on the effectiveness of lumbar drainage in preventing CSF fistulas in cases of small dural tears or debilitated/irradiated patients.\", \"The document only reports on the outcomes of patients who underwent lumbar drainage after developing a CSF fistula, not on its preventative use.\", \"The document does not mention any adverse events related to lumbar drainage.\", \"The document reports that patients treated with CSF drainage were cured in a mean period of 10 days, which is significantly faster than those treated conservatively (30 days)\"" ]

{ "_id": 12836106, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document states that the statistical analysis revealed a positive correlation between WBC and ISS, which contradicts the answer stating that there is no correlation.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document states that the statistical analysis revealed a positive correlation between WBC and ISS, which contradicts the answer stating that there is no correlation.\"" ]

{ "_id": 19664156, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The answer affirms that the Google-based search was useful for identifying diagnoses in complex immunological and allergic cases, which aligns with the findings in the document.\"], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\"The answer affirms that the Google-based search was useful for identifying diagnoses in complex immunological and allergic cases, which aligns with the findings in the document.\"" ]

{ "_id": 26578404, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document reports that opioid PCT was feasible and acceptable for 12/12 patients on Day 3, with a decrease in self-reported breathlessness and stable physiological parameters.\", \"The answer contradicts the information in the document by stating that opioid PCT is not feasible or acceptable.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document reports that opioid PCT was feasible and acceptable for 12/12 patients on Day 3, with a decrease in self-reported breathlessness and stable physiological parameters.\", \"The answer contradicts the information in the document by stating that opioid PCT is not feasible or acceptable.\"" ]

{ "_id": 21645374, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANSWER correctly states that mitochondria play a role in PCD in the lace plant, as per the DOCUMENT.\n- The ANSWER goes beyond the information provided in the DOCUMENT by mentioning the correlation of mitochondria with other organelles, the movement of mitochondria and chloroplasts on transvacuolar strands, and the feasibility of using CsA in a whole plant system. These new details are not contradictory to the DOCUMENT but are not explicitly stated in it.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}\n\nThe ANSWER fails because it offers new information beyond the context provided in the DOCUMENT. While the information is related to the topic and does not contradict the DOCUMENT, it goes beyond the specific details given in the text." }

[ "\n- The ANSWER correctly states that mitochondria play a role in PCD in the lace plant, as per the DOCUMENT.\n- The ANSWER goes beyond the information provided in the DOCUMENT by mentioning the correlation of mitochondria with other organelles, the movement of mitochondria and chloroplasts on transvacuolar strands, and the feasibility of using CsA in a whole plant system. These new details are not contradictory to the DOCUMENT but are not explicitly stated in it.\n" ]

{ "_id": 11035130, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The ANswer goes beyond the contents of the DOCument by stating that FA supplementation is important to prevent patients from discontinuing treatment because of mouth ulcers or nausea and vomiting. This information is not present in the DOCument.\", \"The ANswer also states that FA supplementation is helpful in preventing liver toxicity with very little loss of efficacy of methotrexate. While the DOCument mentions a theoretical risk of decreased methotrexate efficacy with FA supplementation, it does not provide any data or evidence to support the claim made in the ANswer.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The ANswer goes beyond the contents of the DOCument by stating that FA supplementation is important to prevent patients from discontinuing treatment because of mouth ulcers or nausea and vomiting. This information is not present in the DOCument.\", \"The ANswer also states that FA supplementation is helpful in preventing liver toxicity with very little loss of efficacy of methotrexate. While the DOCument mentions a theoretical risk of decreased methotrexate efficacy with FA supplementation, it does not provide any data or evidence to support the claim made in the ANswer.\"" ]

{ "_id": 24939676, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document describes a study investigating the influence of the pharmacokinetics of subcutaneous anti-TNF agents on US-detected synovitis in RA patients.\", \"The document provides data on clinical, laboratory, and US assessments at peak plasma drug concentration and trough plasma drug concentration, but no significant differences were found.\", \"The document also reports no significant differences in the proportion of patients with active disease and those in remission according to various indices at peak time and trough time assessments.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}\n\nThe answer goes beyond the information provided in the document as it states that the results \"suggested\" that s.c. anti-TNF pharmacokinetics significantly influence US-scored synovitis, while the document only states that there was no significant difference found." }

[ "\"The document describes a study investigating the influence of the pharmacokinetics of subcutaneous anti-TNF agents on US-detected synovitis in RA patients.\", \"The document provides data on clinical, laboratory, and US assessments at peak plasma drug concentration and trough plasma drug concentration, but no significant differences were found.\", \"The document also reports no significant differences in the proportion of patients with active disease and those in remission according to various indices at peak time and trough time assessments.\"" ]

{ "_id": 12765819, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The ANSWER acknowledges that the case described in the DOCUMENT is a rare instance of spinal subdural hematoma (SSDH) following subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) due to a ruptured internal carotid aneurysm.\", \"The ANSWER speculates about the possible mechanisms of SSDH formation in this case, suggesting that low CSF pressure and intrathecal thrombolytic therapy may have played a role.\", \"The ANSWER emphasizes the importance of recognizing SSDH as a possible complication of SAH.\"], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}\n\nThe ANSWER stays faithful to the information provided in the DOCUMENT and does not offer any new or contradictory information." }

[ "\"The ANSWER acknowledges that the case described in the DOCUMENT is a rare instance of spinal subdural hematoma (SSDH) following subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) due to a ruptured internal carotid aneurysm.\", \"The ANSWER speculates about the possible mechanisms of SSDH formation in this case, suggesting that low CSF pressure and intrathecal thrombolytic therapy may have played a role.\", \"The ANSWER emphasizes the importance of recognizing SSDH as a possible complication of SAH.\"" ]

{ "_id": 25432938, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The ANswer is not faithful to the DOCUMENT as it states that traffic law reforms in Chile led to an increase in traffic fatalities and injuries, but the DOCUMENT states that the reforms led to a decrease in traffic fatalities and injuries.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The ANswer is not faithful to the DOCUMENT as it states that traffic law reforms in Chile led to an increase in traffic fatalities and injuries, but the DOCUMENT states that the reforms led to a decrease in traffic fatalities and injuries.\"" ]

{ "_id": 21712147, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document describes a study comparing the use of coformulated fixed dose (FXD) strategy versus multiple free dose combination (FRC) in antiretroviral therapy for HIV/AIDS patients.\n- The study found that FXD patients had a mean annual cost that was $3,890.94 higher than FRC patients, but the mean utility gained by using FXD over FRC was 0.085.\n- The incremental cost-utility ratio (ICUR) for the FXD treatment over FRC treatment was $45,540.49/QALYs.\n- Probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed FXD to dominate FRC (>50% probability of being cost-effective) above the $40,000 threshold.\n- The answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by stating that the single-pill strategy significantly improves the quality of life for HIV/AIDS patients and offers a substantial increase in QALYs.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}\n\nThe answer is not faithful to the contents of the document as it offers new information beyond the context provided in the document. The document does not state that the single-pill strategy significantly improves the quality of life for HIV/AIDS patients and offers a substantial increase in QALYs. The document only states that the probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed FXD to dominate FRC above the $40,000 threshold." }

[ "\n- The document describes a study comparing the use of coformulated fixed dose (FXD) strategy versus multiple free dose combination (FRC) in antiretroviral therapy for HIV/AIDS patients.\n- The study found that FXD patients had a mean annual cost that was $3,890.94 higher than FRC patients, but the mean utility gained by using FXD over FRC was 0.085.\n- The incremental cost-utility ratio (ICUR) for the FXD treatment over FRC treatment was $45,540.49/QALYs.\n- Probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed FXD to dominate FRC (>50% probability of being cost-effective) above the $40,000 threshold.\n- The answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by stating that the single-pill strategy significantly improves the quality of life for HIV/AIDS patients and offers a substantial increase in QALYs.\n" ]

{ "_id": 24996865, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The answer correctly states that assessing joint lines by means of radiographs of the contralateral knee is a new approach suggested in the document.\n- The answer correctly identifies the most precise parameter as the distance between the medial epicondyle and the joint line.\n- The answer correctly states that the level of arthritis, age, gender, visibility of the landmarks, and misalignment did not influence measurement accuracy, as stated in the document.\n- The answer adds that this parameter corresponds to the femur-first technique in revision surgery, which is not directly stated in the document but is a reasonable inference based on the information provided.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\n- The answer correctly states that assessing joint lines by means of radiographs of the contralateral knee is a new approach suggested in the document.\n- The answer correctly identifies the most precise parameter as the distance between the medial epicondyle and the joint line.\n- The answer correctly states that the level of arthritis, age, gender, visibility of the landmarks, and misalignment did not influence measurement accuracy, as stated in the document.\n- The answer adds that this parameter corresponds to the femur-first technique in revision surgery, which is not directly stated in the document but is a reasonable inference based on the information provided.\n" ]

{ "_id": 8262881, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The DOCUMENT describes a study investigating the possibility of a psychotic subtype of body dysmorphic disorder (BDD), but it does not definitively establish the existence of such a subtype.\n- The ANSWER goes beyond the information in the DOCUMENT by suggesting that the psychotic subtype of BDD is \"closely related\" and \"completely separate\" from delusional disorder, somatic type.\n- The ANSWER also implies that the inclusion of a psychotic subtype for BDD in future editions of DSM is a recommendation, which is not supported by the information in the DOCUMENT.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The DOCUMENT describes a study investigating the possibility of a psychotic subtype of body dysmorphic disorder (BDD), but it does not definitively establish the existence of such a subtype.\n- The ANSWER goes beyond the information in the DOCUMENT by suggesting that the psychotic subtype of BDD is \"closely related\" and \"completely separate\" from delusional disorder, somatic type.\n- The ANSWER also implies that the inclusion of a psychotic subtype for BDD in future editions of DSM is a recommendation, which is not supported by the information in the DOCUMENT.\n" ]

{ "_id": 28359277, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer goes beyond the context of the DOCument by stating that \"Healthy lifestyles lead to a decrease in the utilization of preventive health services,\" which is not explicitly stated in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer also mentions that \"people with regular exercise habits and who take their blood pressure measurement regularly have an increased number of outpatient visits,\" which contradicts the information in the DOCument that \"Four health behaviors (i.e., exercise habits, dietary habits, regular blood pressure measurement, drinking habits) exhibited a significant correlation with healthcare utilization (P<0.05).\"\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANswer goes beyond the context of the DOCument by stating that \"Healthy lifestyles lead to a decrease in the utilization of preventive health services,\" which is not explicitly stated in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer also mentions that \"people with regular exercise habits and who take their blood pressure measurement regularly have an increased number of outpatient visits,\" which contradicts the information in the DOCument that \"Four health behaviors (i.e., exercise habits, dietary habits, regular blood pressure measurement, drinking habits) exhibited a significant correlation with healthcare utilization (P<0.05).\"\n" ]

{ "_id": 15222284, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer states that the EOA:patient aortic annulus area ratio does not facilitate objective comparisons between different valve types, but the DOCument does not provide any evidence to support this claim.\n- The ANswer also states that comparisons of absolute EOA values grouped by the manufacturers' valve sizes are sufficient, but this is not a direct comparison to the information in the DOCument, which calculates and compares the EOA:patient aortic annulus area ratio between the two bioprostheses.\n- The ANswer further states that the EOA:patient aortic annulus area ratio does not provide a new hemodynamic index, but this is not mentioned in the DOCument and is an additional statement not based on the provided information.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANswer states that the EOA:patient aortic annulus area ratio does not facilitate objective comparisons between different valve types, but the DOCument does not provide any evidence to support this claim.\n- The ANswer also states that comparisons of absolute EOA values grouped by the manufacturers' valve sizes are sufficient, but this is not a direct comparison to the information in the DOCument, which calculates and compares the EOA:patient aortic annulus area ratio between the two bioprostheses.\n- The ANswer further states that the EOA:patient aortic annulus area ratio does not provide a new hemodynamic index, but this is not mentioned in the DOCument and is an additional statement not based on the provided information.\n" ]

{ "_id": 17562682, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document reports that 1.6% of S. aureus isolates from bacteraemic patients were PVL-positive and all of them were MSSA.\", \"The answer correctly states that 1.6% of S. aureus from bacteraemic patients were PVL-positive and all of them were MSSA.\", \"The answer does not offer new information beyond the context provided in the document.\"], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\"The document reports that 1.6% of S. aureus isolates from bacteraemic patients were PVL-positive and all of them were MSSA.\", \"The answer correctly states that 1.6% of S. aureus from bacteraemic patients were PVL-positive and all of them were MSSA.\", \"The answer does not offer new information beyond the context provided in the document.\"" ]

{ "_id": 8910148, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The ANSWER correctly states that TEE is used to assess left ventricular function in potential brain-dead donors.\", \"The ANSWER correctly reports that 36% of potential heart donors have an FAC less than 50%.\", \"The ANSWER correctly states that an FAC below 50% may not necessarily preclude the use of hearts for transplantation.\"], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\"The ANSWER correctly states that TEE is used to assess left ventricular function in potential brain-dead donors.\", \"The ANSWER correctly reports that 36% of potential heart donors have an FAC less than 50%.\", \"The ANSWER correctly states that an FAC below 50% may not necessarily preclude the use of hearts for transplantation.\"" ]

{ "_id": 22758782, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not provide evidence that regional anesthesia significantly decreases postoperative morbidity, rates of rehospitalization, or in-patient mortality in geriatric patients undergoing surgery for hip fracture.\", \"The document states that there is no statistically significant difference in hospitalization costs between patients who received regional or general anesthesia.\", \"The document does not mention anything about ICU admission increasing costs beyond hospitalization costs.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not provide evidence that regional anesthesia significantly decreases postoperative morbidity, rates of rehospitalization, or in-patient mortality in geriatric patients undergoing surgery for hip fracture.\", \"The document states that there is no statistically significant difference in hospitalization costs between patients who received regional or general anesthesia.\", \"The document does not mention anything about ICU admission increasing costs beyond hospitalization costs.\"" ]

{ "_id": 11729377, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The answer acknowledges the question and affirms that living-related liver transplantation (LRT) is still needed.\n- The answer mentions that the short- and long-term outcomes after LRT and split-liver transplantation (SLT) did not differ significantly, but it also states that LRT has higher survival rates and a lower incidence of primary nonfunction.\n- The document does not provide information about the short- and long-term outcomes being the same, but it does mention that LRT has optimized outcomes in terms of postoperative graft function and survival.\n- The answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by stating that LRT is preferred over SLT in most scenarios due to its higher survival rates and lower incidence of primary nonfunction.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}\n\nThe answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by stating that LRT is preferred over SLT in most scenarios, which is not supported by the information in the document." }

[ "\n- The answer acknowledges the question and affirms that living-related liver transplantation (LRT) is still needed.\n- The answer mentions that the short- and long-term outcomes after LRT and split-liver transplantation (SLT) did not differ significantly, but it also states that LRT has higher survival rates and a lower incidence of primary nonfunction.\n- The document does not provide information about the short- and long-term outcomes being the same, but it does mention that LRT has optimized outcomes in terms of postoperative graft function and survival.\n- The answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by stating that LRT is preferred over SLT in most scenarios due to its higher survival rates and lower incidence of primary nonfunction.\n" ]

{ "_id": 10331115, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANSWER correctly states that amoxapine's profile is similar to that of atypical antipsychotics based on the PET data provided in the DOCument.\n- The ANSWER goes beyond the information provided in the DOCument by suggesting that amoxapine's in vitro pharmacologic profile, effectiveness in animal models, and efficacy in psychotic depression raise the possibility of it being an atypical antipsychotic agent in the treatment of schizophrenia. However, this information is not contradictory to the DOCument and is commonly known about amoxapine.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANSWER correctly states that amoxapine's profile is similar to that of atypical antipsychotics based on the PET data provided in the DOCument.\n- The ANSWER goes beyond the information provided in the DOCument by suggesting that amoxapine's in vitro pharmacologic profile, effectiveness in animal models, and efficacy in psychotic depression raise the possibility of it being an atypical antipsychotic agent in the treatment of schizophrenia. However, this information is not contradictory to the DOCument and is commonly known about amoxapine.\n" ]

{ "_id": 24809662, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not provide evidence that concomitant AA repair results in additional improvement in OAB symptoms over MUS alone.\", \"The document states that there were no significant differences in OAB-q SS change scores between the MUS-only and MUS + AA cohorts.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not provide evidence that concomitant AA repair results in additional improvement in OAB symptoms over MUS alone.\", \"The document states that there were no significant differences in OAB-q SS change scores between the MUS-only and MUS + AA cohorts.\"" ]

{ "_id": 10759659, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The DOCUMENT describes a study comparing the accuracy of a urology nurse practitioner (UNP) and a consultant urologist in detecting bladder tumors during flexible cystoscopy.\n- The UNP and consultant urologist each examined the same patients, and their findings were compared without knowledge of each other's results.\n- The study found that one tumor was missed by the UNP and one by the consultant urologist, but the overall agreement between their findings was very close (Kappa = 0.94).\n],\n \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"\n}\n\nReasoning:\n\nThe ANSWER is faithful to the DOCUMENT as it acknowledges that a UNP can be trained to perform cystoscopy but may not detect suspicious lesions as accurately as a consultant urologist. The DOCUMENT itself does not provide information on legal or training issues, so the ANSWER does not contradict or offer new information beyond the context of the DOCUMENT." }

[ "\n- The DOCUMENT describes a study comparing the accuracy of a urology nurse practitioner (UNP) and a consultant urologist in detecting bladder tumors during flexible cystoscopy.\n- The UNP and consultant urologist each examined the same patients, and their findings were compared without knowledge of each other's results.\n- The study found that one tumor was missed by the UNP and one by the consultant urologist, but the overall agreement between their findings was very close (Kappa = 0.94).\n" ]

{ "_id": 15477551, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document describes four patients with chronic progressive cervical myelopathy and HTLV-I infection, and the question asks if this is a variant form of HAM/TSP.\", \"The answer states that these cases do not represent a variant form of HAM/TSP, but rather a distinct neurological condition unrelated to HTLV-I infection.\", \"The document does not provide any information that supports the answer stating that these cases are a distinct neurological condition unrelated to HTLV-I infection.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}\n\nThe answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by stating that these cases are a distinct neurological condition unrelated to HTLV-I infection, without any supporting evidence from the document." }

[ "\"The document describes four patients with chronic progressive cervical myelopathy and HTLV-I infection, and the question asks if this is a variant form of HAM/TSP.\", \"The answer states that these cases do not represent a variant form of HAM/TSP, but rather a distinct neurological condition unrelated to HTLV-I infection.\", \"The document does not provide any information that supports the answer stating that these cases are a distinct neurological condition unrelated to HTLV-I infection.\"" ]

{ "_id": 17096624, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The ANswer contradicts the information provided in the DOCument that identified 4 distinct clusters of unvaccinated seniors with different knowledge and attitudes towards influenza vaccine.\", \"The ANswer is not faithful to the contents of the DOCument.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The ANswer contradicts the information provided in the DOCument that identified 4 distinct clusters of unvaccinated seniors with different knowledge and attitudes towards influenza vaccine.\", \"The ANswer is not faithful to the contents of the DOCument.\"" ]

{ "_id": 11926574, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANSWER mentions Southern Italy, but this information is not provided in the DOCUMENT and does not affect the answer's faithfulness to the contents of the DOCUMENT.\n- The ANSWER states that hepatitis G virus infection is widespread among patients with chronic hepatitis, including those with cryptogenic liver disease, which is consistent with the information in the DOCUMENT that 17.4% of patients with cryptogenic chronic hepatitis were positive for hepatitis G virus-RNA.\n- The ANSWER also mentions that TT virus infection has been found in a significant number of patients with cryptogenic or hepatitis C virus-related liver disease, which is consistent with the information in the DOCUMENT that TT virus-DNA was present in serum in 3 subjects, 1 with cryptogenic and 2 with hepatitis C virus-related chronic liver disease.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANSWER mentions Southern Italy, but this information is not provided in the DOCUMENT and does not affect the answer's faithfulness to the contents of the DOCUMENT.\n- The ANSWER states that hepatitis G virus infection is widespread among patients with chronic hepatitis, including those with cryptogenic liver disease, which is consistent with the information in the DOCUMENT that 17.4% of patients with cryptogenic chronic hepatitis were positive for hepatitis G virus-RNA.\n- The ANSWER also mentions that TT virus infection has been found in a significant number of patients with cryptogenic or hepatitis C virus-related liver disease, which is consistent with the information in the DOCUMENT that TT virus-DNA was present in serum in 3 subjects, 1 with cryptogenic and 2 with hepatitis C virus-related chronic liver disease.\n" ]

{ "_id": 23389866, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document describes a retrospective study evaluating the benefit of adding surgery to chemoradiotherapy in the management of squamous cell carcinoma of the esophagus. The study reports on the outcomes of patients in two arms: those who underwent surgical resection after chemoradiotherapy (arm A) and those who did not (arm B). The document provides data on overall survival (OS), disease-free survival (DFS), clinical toxicities, pathological complete response, and recurrence probability for both arms.\"\n\n\"The answer goes beyond the document by stating that surgical resection significantly improves survival outcomes and reduces clinical toxicity. However, the document does not provide any data or statistical analysis to support this claim.\"],\n\n\"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document describes a retrospective study evaluating the benefit of adding surgery to chemoradiotherapy in the management of squamous cell carcinoma of the esophagus. The study reports on the outcomes of patients in two arms: those who underwent surgical resection after chemoradiotherapy (arm A) and those who did not (arm B). The document provides data on overall survival (OS), disease-free survival (DFS), clinical toxicities, pathological complete response, and recurrence probability for both arms.\"\n\n\"The answer goes beyond the document by stating that surgical resection significantly improves survival outcomes and reduces clinical toxicity. However, the document does not provide any data or statistical analysis to support this claim.\"" ]

{ "_id": 12098035, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document states that patients in the LS group (laparoscopic specialists) had a higher rate of successful laparoscopic treatment (65%) compared to the GS group (36%) (p = 0.001).\", \"The document also states that the median postoperative hospital stay was shorter in the LS group (3 days) compared to the GS group (5 days) (p<0.01).\"], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\"The document states that patients in the LS group (laparoscopic specialists) had a higher rate of successful laparoscopic treatment (65%) compared to the GS group (36%) (p = 0.001).\", \"The document also states that the median postoperative hospital stay was shorter in the LS group (3 days) compared to the GS group (5 days) (p<0.01).\"" ]

{ "_id": 8422202, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The answer accurately summarizes the findings of the study regarding the improper use of metered-dose inhalers by patients and the lack of proficiency of some health care providers.\", \"The answer correctly identifies the health care providers mentioned in the study and their respective proficiency levels.\", \"The answer does not offer new information beyond the context provided in the DOCUMENT.\"], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\"The answer accurately summarizes the findings of the study regarding the improper use of metered-dose inhalers by patients and the lack of proficiency of some health care providers.\", \"The answer correctly identifies the health care providers mentioned in the study and their respective proficiency levels.\", \"The answer does not offer new information beyond the context provided in the DOCUMENT.\"" ]

{ "_id": 22365295, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The DOCUMENT provides information on the number of TIVAD placements and removals, as well as the number of CLABSIs that occurred within 30 days of placement.\n- The ANSWER correctly states that the rate of early infection without antibiotic prophylaxis is less than 1%.\n- The ANSWER also recommends the use of prophylactic antibiotics for TIVAD placement to minimize the risk of infection.\n- The information in the ANSWER is consistent with the data presented in the DOCUMENT.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\n- The DOCUMENT provides information on the number of TIVAD placements and removals, as well as the number of CLABSIs that occurred within 30 days of placement.\n- The ANSWER correctly states that the rate of early infection without antibiotic prophylaxis is less than 1%.\n- The ANSWER also recommends the use of prophylactic antibiotics for TIVAD placement to minimize the risk of infection.\n- The information in the ANSWER is consistent with the data presented in the DOCUMENT.\n" ]

{ "_id": 21889895, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer acknowledges that clinicians changed their CT scan ordering after receiving education about radiation, which is consistent with the findings in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer adds that clinicians were able to discuss CT benefits and risks with their patients and choose appropriate CT protocols, which is not directly stated in the DOCument but is a reasonable inference based on the information provided.\n- The ANswer mentions that referring physician groups are interested in radiation education and that radiologists should be encouraged to give radiation lectures to them, which is also consistent with the information in the DOCument.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANswer acknowledges that clinicians changed their CT scan ordering after receiving education about radiation, which is consistent with the findings in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer adds that clinicians were able to discuss CT benefits and risks with their patients and choose appropriate CT protocols, which is not directly stated in the DOCument but is a reasonable inference based on the information provided.\n- The ANswer mentions that referring physician groups are interested in radiation education and that radiologists should be encouraged to give radiation lectures to them, which is also consistent with the information in the DOCument.\n" ]

{ "_id": 19653482, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer is faithful to the QUESTION as it directly addresses the request and acceptance of backup between teammates.\n- The ANswer is faithful to the DOCUMENT as it references Transactive memory theory, which is discussed in the study, and explains how it relates to teammates requesting and accepting backup.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANswer is faithful to the QUESTION as it directly addresses the request and acceptance of backup between teammates.\n- The ANswer is faithful to the DOCUMENT as it references Transactive memory theory, which is discussed in the study, and explains how it relates to teammates requesting and accepting backup.\n" ]

{ "_id": 24946973, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer goes beyond the context of the DOCument by making a conclusion about the feasibility of multicatheter APBI after oncoplastic breast-conserving surgery and the need for further investigations.\n- The ANswer contradicts the information in the DOCument that special attention to target volume definition is necessary.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANswer goes beyond the context of the DOCument by making a conclusion about the feasibility of multicatheter APBI after oncoplastic breast-conserving surgery and the need for further investigations.\n- The ANswer contradicts the information in the DOCument that special attention to target volume definition is necessary.\n" ]

{ "_id": 9602458, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not directly state that the CHCS effectively identifies children with cerebral palsy.\", \"The document provides information that 47% of children with cerebral palsy on the Northern Ireland Cerebral Palsy Register (NICPR) were not found on the CHCS, and 10% of children on the CHCS were not found on the NICPR.\", \"However, the document also mentions that five of the cases not found on the NICPR were later found not to have cerebral palsy.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}\n\nThe answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by stating that the CHCS effectively identifies children with cerebral palsy and provides reliable data for needs assessment and surveillance. The document does not directly support this claim, and it also mentions discrepancies between the two databases." }

[ "\"The document does not directly state that the CHCS effectively identifies children with cerebral palsy.\", \"The document provides information that 47% of children with cerebral palsy on the Northern Ireland Cerebral Palsy Register (NICPR) were not found on the CHCS, and 10% of children on the CHCS were not found on the NICPR.\", \"However, the document also mentions that five of the cases not found on the NICPR were later found not to have cerebral palsy.\"" ]

{ "_id": 23356465, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document describes a study investigating the proportion of variability in outcome of evidence-based treatment (CPT) for PTSD attributable to therapists and identifies characteristics of effective therapers.\n- The answer correctly states that the study confirms the importance of strict adherence to standardized training and supervision guidelines in ensuring uniformity of evidence-based treatments in practice.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\n- The document describes a study investigating the proportion of variability in outcome of evidence-based treatment (CPT) for PTSD attributable to therapists and identifies characteristics of effective therapers.\n- The answer correctly states that the study confirms the importance of strict adherence to standardized training and supervision guidelines in ensuring uniformity of evidence-based treatments in practice.\n" ]

{ "_id": 18496363, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not provide any information about hormonal differences or their role in gender dimorphism after injury.\", \"The answer goes beyond the context of the document by introducing the concept of hormonal differences and their potential role in gender dimorphism.\", \"The answer contradicts the document as it states that 'hormonal differences are primarily responsible' for gender-based differences after injury, while the document only states that 'female gender was independently associated with a lower risk' of multiple organ failure and nosocomial infection.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not provide any information about hormonal differences or their role in gender dimorphism after injury.\", \"The answer goes beyond the context of the document by introducing the concept of hormonal differences and their potential role in gender dimorphism.\", \"The answer contradicts the document as it states that 'hormonal differences are primarily responsible' for gender-based differences after injury, while the document only states that 'female gender was independently associated with a lower risk' of multiple organ failure and nosocomial infection.\"" ]

{ "_id": 22236315, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The ANswer does not directly address the question which asks about distance being a barrier to care, but rather discusses the comparison between driving time and driving distance as predictors of timeliness of diagnosis and treatment. The answer also suggests the need for more intensive efforts for early detection and treatment in remote areas, but this is not mentioned in the document. Therefore, the answer goes beyond the context provided in the DOCument.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The ANswer does not directly address the question which asks about distance being a barrier to care, but rather discusses the comparison between driving time and driving distance as predictors of timeliness of diagnosis and treatment. The answer also suggests the need for more intensive efforts for early detection and treatment in remote areas, but this is not mentioned in the document. Therefore, the answer goes beyond the context provided in the DOCument.\"" ]

{ "_id": 26852225, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer makes a statement about the necessity of adjusting for reporting heterogeneity being not necessary, which is not directly stated in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer mentions that gender differences, presence of multiple morbidities, and regular exercise should be the focus of policies and clinical practice, which is not mentioned in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer states that older age is not significantly associated with sleep-related issues after adjustment, which is in contrast to the information in the DOCument that age was significantly associated with a greater severity of sleep-related problems before adjustment, and the significance of age was lost after adjustment.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANswer makes a statement about the necessity of adjusting for reporting heterogeneity being not necessary, which is not directly stated in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer mentions that gender differences, presence of multiple morbidities, and regular exercise should be the focus of policies and clinical practice, which is not mentioned in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer states that older age is not significantly associated with sleep-related issues after adjustment, which is in contrast to the information in the DOCument that age was significantly associated with a greater severity of sleep-related problems before adjustment, and the significance of age was lost after adjustment.\n" ]

{ "_id": 10411439, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document reports that the addition of 15 degrees head-down tilt during pelvic dissection led to an immediate and significant drop in lower limb perfusion (P<0.05; Mann-Whitney U test).\n- The document also reports that the subgroup of patients analyzed postoperatively showed a ten-fold increase in perfusion that was confined to the muscle compartments with no demonstrable increase in skin perfusion or intra-arterial pedal blood pressure.\n- The answer correctly identifies the use of the Trendelenburg position as a cause of profound ischemia of the lower limbs during the recovery period.\n- The answer also correctly states that this hyperperfusion is confined to the muscle compartments.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\n- The document reports that the addition of 15 degrees head-down tilt during pelvic dissection led to an immediate and significant drop in lower limb perfusion (P<0.05; Mann-Whitney U test).\n- The document also reports that the subgroup of patients analyzed postoperatively showed a ten-fold increase in perfusion that was confined to the muscle compartments with no demonstrable increase in skin perfusion or intra-arterial pedal blood pressure.\n- The answer correctly identifies the use of the Trendelenburg position as a cause of profound ischemia of the lower limbs during the recovery period.\n- The answer also correctly states that this hyperperfusion is confined to the muscle compartments.\n" ]

{ "_id": 23601294, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not support the statement that 'there is consistent reliability' across different brands and models of scanners in identifying the composition of renal stones based on CT scan analysis and HU evaluation.\", \"The document highlights significant differences in mean CT attenuation values between different stone types and between different CT scanner models.\", \"The document states that'most stone types could not be identified' using CT attenuation values and that'some types of stones presented mean CT attenuation values significantly different from one CT scanner to another.'\", \"The document provides specific examples of significant differences in mean CT attenuation values between the Philips, Siemens, and Toshiba models at different voltage levels.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not support the statement that 'there is consistent reliability' across different brands and models of scanners in identifying the composition of renal stones based on CT scan analysis and HU evaluation.\", \"The document highlights significant differences in mean CT attenuation values between different stone types and between different CT scanner models.\", \"The document states that'most stone types could not be identified' using CT attenuation values and that'some types of stones presented mean CT attenuation values significantly different from one CT scanner to another.'\", \"The document provides specific examples of significant differences in mean CT attenuation values between the Philips, Siemens, and Toshiba models at different voltage levels.\"" ]

{ "_id": 22534881, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document states that the correlation between the radiographic transition zone and the length of aganglionosis is inaccurate and that radiological findings were concordant with the specimen in pathology in only 58.1% of cases.\", \"The answer goes against the information provided in the document by stating that the radiographic transition zone generally correlates well with the level of aganglionosis.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document states that the correlation between the radiographic transition zone and the length of aganglionosis is inaccurate and that radiological findings were concordant with the specimen in pathology in only 58.1% of cases.\", \"The answer goes against the information provided in the document by stating that the radiographic transition zone generally correlates well with the level of aganglionosis.\"" ]

{ "_id": 19394934, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer does not directly contradict the information in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer suggests that a fixed number of casualties could be used to define hospital preparedness instead of a percentage of bed capacity.\n- The ANswer agrees with the DOCument that approximately 50% of arriving casualties require immediate medical treatment.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}\n\nThe ANswer stays faithful to the information in the DOCument and does not offer new information or contradict any information provided. The ANswer suggests an alternative way to define hospital preparedness based on the information in the DOCument." }

[ "\n- The ANswer does not directly contradict the information in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer suggests that a fixed number of casualties could be used to define hospital preparedness instead of a percentage of bed capacity.\n- The ANswer agrees with the DOCument that approximately 50% of arriving casualties require immediate medical treatment.\n" ]

{ "_id": 25155638, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document states that eliminating'missed opportunities' for influenza vaccination in office-based settings could have cut racial and ethnic disparities in influenza vaccination by roughly one half.\", \"The answer directly contradicts the information provided in the document.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document states that eliminating'missed opportunities' for influenza vaccination in office-based settings could have cut racial and ethnic disparities in influenza vaccination by roughly one half.\", \"The answer directly contradicts the information provided in the document.\"" ]

{ "_id": 19409117, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer agrees with the DOCument that infundibular height is a significant factor in predicting the clearance of lower pole calyceal stones after SWL.\n- The ANswer goes beyond the DOCument by suggesting a specific threshold value (22 mm) for infundibular height that indicates a good outcome from lithotripsy.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANswer agrees with the DOCument that infundibular height is a significant factor in predicting the clearance of lower pole calyceal stones after SWL.\n- The ANswer goes beyond the DOCument by suggesting a specific threshold value (22 mm) for infundibular height that indicates a good outcome from lithotripsy.\n" ]

{ "_id": 20187289, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not provide any information about additional validation studies or the reliability of prescriptions as a proxy for asthma.\", \"The answer goes beyond the context of the document by implying that 'additional validation studies' have been taken into account and that prescriptions are a'reliable proxy' for diagnosing asthma.\", \"The answer contradicts the information in the document that prevalence estimates from prescription data and self-reported data differ significantly.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not provide any information about additional validation studies or the reliability of prescriptions as a proxy for asthma.\", \"The answer goes beyond the context of the document by implying that 'additional validation studies' have been taken into account and that prescriptions are a'reliable proxy' for diagnosing asthma.\", \"The answer contradicts the information in the document that prevalence estimates from prescription data and self-reported data differ significantly.\"" ]

{ "_id": 20537205, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document describes histological changes in the cochlea of guinea pigs given halofantrine, including loss and distortion of inner hair cells, inner phalangeal cells, and spiral ganglia cells. However, the answer states that there are no significant pathological effects and that halofantrine cannot be considered an ototoxic drug.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document describes histological changes in the cochlea of guinea pigs given halofantrine, including loss and distortion of inner hair cells, inner phalangeal cells, and spiral ganglia cells. However, the answer states that there are no significant pathological effects and that halofantrine cannot be considered an ototoxic drug.\"" ]

{ "_id": 23497210, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document provides information that major depression in pregnancy can be identified using two methods: women with dispensing records relating to antidepressant medicines and women with any hospital admission during pregnancy with a recorded comorbidity related to depression. The document also states that there were 7495 pregnancies identified by either set of records, but only 899 pregnancies were found in both groups. This suggests that there is some degree of under-ascertainment of depression in hospital records. However, the document also states that 80% of women dispensed an antidepressant did not have depression recorded as a comorbidity on their hospital records. This indicates that a significant number of women with depression during pregnancy may not be identified in hospital admission records alone. Therefore, the document does not support the answer that population health data provide a complete and accurate profile for identifying women with major depression in pregnancy.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document provides information that major depression in pregnancy can be identified using two methods: women with dispensing records relating to antidepressant medicines and women with any hospital admission during pregnancy with a recorded comorbidity related to depression. The document also states that there were 7495 pregnancies identified by either set of records, but only 899 pregnancies were found in both groups. This suggests that there is some degree of under-ascertainment of depression in hospital records. However, the document also states that 80% of women dispensed an antidepressant did not have depression recorded as a comorbidity on their hospital records. This indicates that a significant number of women with depression during pregnancy may not be identified in hospital admission records alone. Therefore, the document does not support the answer that population health data provide a complete and accurate profile for identifying women with major depression in pregnancy.\"" ]

{ "_id": 11882828, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The ANSWER contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT that'significantly less drainage' and 'fewer transfusions' were observed in the group that received both desmopressin and tranexamic acid.\", \"The ANSWER states that tranexamic acid does not significantly reduce desmopressin-induced hyperfibrinolysis, while the DOCUMENT shows a statistically significant difference in fibrinogen, fibrin split product, and transfusion requirement between the two groups.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The ANSWER contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT that'significantly less drainage' and 'fewer transfusions' were observed in the group that received both desmopressin and tranexamic acid.\", \"The ANSWER states that tranexamic acid does not significantly reduce desmopressin-induced hyperfibrinolysis, while the DOCUMENT shows a statistically significant difference in fibrinogen, fibrin split product, and transfusion requirement between the two groups.\"" ]

{ "_id": 24019262, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer does not directly quote or reference any specific information from the DOCument.\n- The ANswer introduces the theory of \"hypertension-associated hypalgesia\" which is not mentioned in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer suggests that the results \"are consistent with the theory of hypertension-associated hypalgesia\" but the DOCument does not make any such claim.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}\n\nThe ANswer goes beyond the information provided in the DOCument and introduces new information about a theory that is not mentioned or supported by the study results in the DOCument." }

[ "\n- The ANswer does not directly quote or reference any specific information from the DOCument.\n- The ANswer introduces the theory of \"hypertension-associated hypalgesia\" which is not mentioned in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer suggests that the results \"are consistent with the theory of hypertension-associated hypalgesia\" but the DOCument does not make any such claim.\n" ]

{ "_id": 27581329, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document provides information about a study that developed a new BMR prediction equation for Chinese adults and compares its accuracy to six existing equations including the Harris-Benedict equation. However, the document does not state that the Harris-Benedict equation is the most accurate equation for Chinese adults or that it is applicable for use in a large BMI range including those overweight and obese. This information is an extrapolation from the document and goes beyond its contents.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document provides information about a study that developed a new BMR prediction equation for Chinese adults and compares its accuracy to six existing equations including the Harris-Benedict equation. However, the document does not state that the Harris-Benedict equation is the most accurate equation for Chinese adults or that it is applicable for use in a large BMI range including those overweight and obese. This information is an extrapolation from the document and goes beyond its contents.\"" ]

{ "_id": 27554179, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document states that the metastasis rate of station 9 was significantly lower than other mediastinal stations, not higher as stated in the answer.\", \"The document also shows that the metastasis status of station 9 had no significant influence on survival, contrary to the answer's claim that it is necessary for tumor staging and prognosis.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document states that the metastasis rate of station 9 was significantly lower than other mediastinal stations, not higher as stated in the answer.\", \"The document also shows that the metastasis status of station 9 had no significant influence on survival, contrary to the answer's claim that it is necessary for tumor staging and prognosis.\"" ]

{ "_id": 18403945, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer makes a statement about \"reflux patients whose symptoms were poorly controlled on medical therapy\", which is not explicitly stated in the DOCument.\n- However, the DOCument does mention that the study focused on patients whose symptoms were \"well controlled on medical therapy but who decided to undergo surgery (patient preference)\". This implies that there were also patients whose symptoms were not well controlled, but the ANswer incorrectly assumes that all patients in the study fell into this category.\n- The ANswer also mentions a \"relatively short follow-up period\", which is not mentioned in the DOCument.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANswer makes a statement about \"reflux patients whose symptoms were poorly controlled on medical therapy\", which is not explicitly stated in the DOCument.\n- However, the DOCument does mention that the study focused on patients whose symptoms were \"well controlled on medical therapy but who decided to undergo surgery (patient preference)\". This implies that there were also patients whose symptoms were not well controlled, but the ANswer incorrectly assumes that all patients in the study fell into this category.\n- The ANswer also mentions a \"relatively short follow-up period\", which is not mentioned in the DOCument.\n" ]

{ "_id": 10381996, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The ANswer goes beyond the context of the DOCument by stating that experienced physicians can often accurately predict the presence of ACS without the need for CXR, which is not mentioned in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer also contradicts the information in the DOCument that \"Overall physician sensitivity for predicting ACS was only 39%\" by implying that experienced physicians can accurately predict the presence of ACS.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The ANswer goes beyond the context of the DOCument by stating that experienced physicians can often accurately predict the presence of ACS without the need for CXR, which is not mentioned in the DOCument.\n- The ANswer also contradicts the information in the DOCument that \"Overall physician sensitivity for predicting ACS was only 39%\" by implying that experienced physicians can accurately predict the presence of ACS.\n" ]

{ "_id": 12595848, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document describes a study examining the association between pattern of outpatient care and survival in patients with congestive heart failure (CHF).\n- The study divided patients into four groups based on their pattern of outpatient care: general medicine clinic visits only (GM-only), cardiology clinic visits only (CARD-only), general medicine and cardiology (MIXED), and neither general medicine nor cardiology clinic visits (no-GM/CARD).\n- The study found that the overall 1-year mortality rate was 23%, with the highest mortality rate in the no-GM/CARD group (29%) and the lowest in the MIXED group (19%).\n- After adjusting for important clinical and demographic factors, the study found that the risk of death was higher in the CARD-only and no-GM/CARD groups compared to the MIXED group.\n- The answer correctly states that the study found an improved survival associated with general practitioner care alone compared with cardiologist care and a mixture of general practitioner and cardiologist care.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\n- The document describes a study examining the association between pattern of outpatient care and survival in patients with congestive heart failure (CHF).\n- The study divided patients into four groups based on their pattern of outpatient care: general medicine clinic visits only (GM-only), cardiology clinic visits only (CARD-only), general medicine and cardiology (MIXED), and neither general medicine nor cardiology clinic visits (no-GM/CARD).\n- The study found that the overall 1-year mortality rate was 23%, with the highest mortality rate in the no-GM/CARD group (29%) and the lowest in the MIXED group (19%).\n- After adjusting for important clinical and demographic factors, the study found that the risk of death was higher in the CARD-only and no-GM/CARD groups compared to the MIXED group.\n- The answer correctly states that the study found an improved survival associated with general practitioner care alone compared with cardiologist care and a mixture of general practitioner and cardiologist care.\n" ]

{ "_id": 23949294, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document describes that 87.3% of patients in a resource-limited setting had undetectable viral load.\", \"The document also states that 46.8% of these patients had been exposed to mono or dual nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors regimens.\", \"However, the answer states that maintaining viral load suppression over time in resource-limited settings is not feasible.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}\n\nReasoning:\n\n1. The document provides evidence that a significant number of patients in a resource-limited setting have maintained viral load suppression over time.\n2. The answer, however, states that it is not feasible to maintain viral load suppression over time in resource-limited settings, which contradicts the information in the document." }

[ "\"The document describes that 87.3% of patients in a resource-limited setting had undetectable viral load.\", \"The document also states that 46.8% of these patients had been exposed to mono or dual nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors regimens.\", \"However, the answer states that maintaining viral load suppression over time in resource-limited settings is not feasible.\"" ]

{ "_id": 26879871, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document states that black and minority ethnic groups are less likely to be newly diagnosed with depression or prescribed antidepressants compared to white British patients.\n- The document also reports an inverse relationship between neighbourhood ethnic density and new depression diagnosis for some ethnic groups, where an increase of 10% own-ethnic density is associated with a reduced odds of depression.\n- The answer correctly states that new depression diagnosis and antidepressant use is more likely in areas of higher own-ethnic density for all ethnic groups based on the information provided in the document.\n], \"SCORE\": \"PASS\"}" }

[ "\n- The document states that black and minority ethnic groups are less likely to be newly diagnosed with depression or prescribed antidepressants compared to white British patients.\n- The document also reports an inverse relationship between neighbourhood ethnic density and new depression diagnosis for some ethnic groups, where an increase of 10% own-ethnic density is associated with a reduced odds of depression.\n- The answer correctly states that new depression diagnosis and antidepressant use is more likely in areas of higher own-ethnic density for all ethnic groups based on the information provided in the document.\n" ]

{ "_id": 17919952, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document does not provide any information about the relationship between self-reported mechanical factors and chronic oro-facial pain being related to somatisation.\n- The answer makes a claim that is not supported by the information in the document.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The document does not provide any information about the relationship between self-reported mechanical factors and chronic oro-facial pain being related to somatisation.\n- The answer makes a claim that is not supported by the information in the document.\n" ]

{ "_id": 25957366, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\"The document does not provide sufficient evidence to support the answer's claim that'simple, at-the-visit family history prompts significantly improved PCPs' ability to identify patients at high risk for 6 common conditions'. The document only reports the results of a study that found no significant change in problem summary list documentation of risk status or screening interventions for any of the 6 diseases after the implementation of automated, tailored family history prompts.\", \"The answer goes beyond the context of the document by making a stronger claim about the effectiveness of the prompts than what is supported by the study results.\"], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\"The document does not provide sufficient evidence to support the answer's claim that'simple, at-the-visit family history prompts significantly improved PCPs' ability to identify patients at high risk for 6 common conditions'. The document only reports the results of a study that found no significant change in problem summary list documentation of risk status or screening interventions for any of the 6 diseases after the implementation of automated, tailored family history prompts.\", \"The answer goes beyond the context of the document by making a stronger claim about the effectiveness of the prompts than what is supported by the study results.\"" ]

{ "_id": 21198823, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The document describes a study that aimed to compare clinical and echocardiographic features of patients with and without cTnI elevation after dobutamine stress echocardiography (DSE).\n- No patient in the study had elevated cTnI 18-24 hours after the DSE.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"\n}\n\nReasoning:\n- The answer goes beyond the information provided in the document by stating that there is a \"slight elevation of cTn\" despite the occurrence of significant WMAs on DSE.\n- The document does not support this claim as no patient in the study had elevated cTnI 18-24 hours after the DSE.\n- The answer also suggests that cTnI can be used as an additional diagnostic tool during pharmacological stress test, which is not mentioned or implied in the document." }

[ "\n- The document describes a study that aimed to compare clinical and echocardiographic features of patients with and without cTnI elevation after dobutamine stress echocardiography (DSE).\n- No patient in the study had elevated cTnI 18-24 hours after the DSE.\n" ]

{ "_id": 25186850, "label": "FAIL", "text": " {\"REASONING\": [\n- The DOCUMENT does not provide any information about the role or performance of student examiners in formative assessments.\n- The ANSWER goes beyond the context of the DOCUMENT by making a recommendation for formative assessments.\n], \"SCORE\": \"FAIL\"}" }

[ "\n- The DOCUMENT does not provide any information about the role or performance of student examiners in formative assessments.\n- The ANSWER goes beyond the context of the DOCUMENT by making a recommendation for formative assessments.\n" ]