Datasets:

PatronusAI

/

evaluation-halueval-test-llama3-8b-drop-ragtruth-covidqa-pubmed-cwRA4u

like 0

{ "_id": 7753, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the actor in the upcoming movie \"The Underdog\" who was born in 1993.', 'The context provides information about the lead roles in the movie, mentioning Do Kyung-soo, Park So-dam, and Park Chul-min.', 'Do Kyung-soo, also known as D.O., is specifically noted to have been born on December 12, 1993.', 'The other actors mentioned, Park So-dam and Park Chul-min, do not have their birth years provided in the context.', \"Therefore, the answer 'Do Kyung-soo' is faithful to the context as he is the only actor mentioned whose birth year matches the criteria set by the question.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the actor in the upcoming movie \"The Underdog\" who was born in 1993.", "The context provides information about the lead roles in the movie, mentioning Do Kyung-soo, Park So-dam, and Park Chul-min.", "Do Kyung-soo, also known as D.O., is specifically noted to have been born on December 12, 1993.", "The other actors mentioned, Park So-dam and Park Chul-min, do not have their birth years provided in the context.', \"Therefore, the answer 'Do Kyung-soo' is faithful to the context as he is the only actor mentioned whose birth year matches the criteria set by the question.\"" ]

{ "_id": 8439, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The question asks for the country in which Rua Santos Minho is located.\", \"The context provides that Rua Santos Minho is in Póvoa de Varzim city center, in Portugal.\", \"The context further specifies that Portugal is officially the Portuguese Republic.\", \"The answer given is 'Portugal', which is correct and directly supported by the context.\", \"The answer is faithful to the context as it accurately reflects the information provided about the location of Rua Santos Minho.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "\"The question asks for the country in which Rua Santos Minho is located.\", \"The context provides that Rua Santos Minho is in Póvoa de Varzim city center, in Portugal.\", \"The context further specifies that Portugal is officially the Portuguese Republic.\", \"The answer given is 'Portugal', which is correct and directly supported by the context.\", \"The answer is faithful to the context as it accurately reflects the information provided about the location of Rua Santos Minho.\"" ]

{ "_id": 1116, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT explicitly states that the Curzon Ashton Ladies Football Club is an English women\\'s football club.', 'The term \"Ladies Football Club\" is used to describe the club, which is a clear indication that it is composed of women.', \"The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that the club 'consists mostly of ladies', which is a vague and gender-neutral term that does not confirm the club's composition as women's only.\", 'The CONTEXT does not provide any information that suggests the club is co-ed or has both male and female members; it specifically mentions affiliation with Curzon Ashton F.C. and competition in women\\'s football leagues.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT explicitly states that the Curzon Ashton Ladies Football Club is an English women\\'s football club.", "The term \"Ladies Football Club\" is used to describe the club, which is a clear indication that it is composed of women.', \"The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that the club 'consists mostly of ladies', which is a vague and gender-neutral term that does not confirm the club's composition as women's only.\", 'The CONTEXT does not provide any information that suggests the club is co-ed or has both male and female members; it specifically mentions affiliation with Curzon Ashton F.C. and competition in women\\'s football leagues.'" ]

{ "_id": 4496, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The question asks for the name of a film featuring Ray Liotta and one of the stars of '10 Things I Hate About You'.\", 'The context provides information about Julia Stiles, who is a star of \"10 Things I Hate About You\", and mentions that she starred in a film called \"Blackway\" alongside Ray Liotta.', \"The model output 'Blackway' correctly identifies the film that features Ray Liotta and Julia Stiles, who is a star of '10 Things I Hate About You'.\", 'Therefore, the answer is faithful to the context given the question.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "\"The question asks for the name of a film featuring Ray Liotta and one of the stars of '10 Things I Hate About You'.\", 'The context provides information about Julia Stiles, who is a star of \"10 Things I Hate About You\", and mentions that she starred in a film called \"Blackway\" alongside Ray Liotta.', \"The model output 'Blackway' correctly identifies the film that features Ray Liotta and Julia Stiles, who is a star of '10 Things I Hate About You'.\", 'Therefore, the answer is faithful to the context given the question.'" ]

{ "_id": 3888, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT specifies that Le'Bryan Nash last played for the Rio Grande Valley Vipers of the NBA Development League.', 'The CONTEXT further states that the Rio Grande Valley Vipers play their home games at the State Farm Arena, in Hidalgo, Texas.', \"The QUESTION asks in which state the Rio Grande Valley Vipers play their home games, specifically mentioning Hidalgo.\", \"The CONTEXT clearly answers this by stating 'Texas'.\", 'The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that the home games are not played in Texas, which contradicts the information provided in the CONTEXT.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT specifies that Le'Bryan Nash last played for the Rio Grande Valley Vipers of the NBA Development League.", "The CONTEXT further states that the Rio Grande Valley Vipers play their home games at the State Farm Arena, in Hidalgo, Texas.', \"The QUESTION asks in which state the Rio Grande Valley Vipers play their home games, specifically mentioning Hidalgo.\", \"The CONTEXT clearly answers this by stating 'Texas'.\", 'The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that the home games are not played in Texas, which contradicts the information provided in the CONTEXT.'" ]

{ "_id": 3582, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the birth year of an American rapper whose albums were produced by House Shoes.', 'The context provides information about Danny Brown, an American rapper from Detroit, Michigan, and mentions that House Shoes produced his albums.', \"The context also states that Danny Brown was born on March 16, 1981.\", 'The answer given is March 16, 1981, which matches the birthdate provided in the context.', 'Therefore, the answer is faithful to the context as it correctly identifies the birth year of the American rapper whose albums were produced by House Shoes.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the birth year of an American rapper whose albums were produced by House Shoes.", "The context provides information about Danny Brown, an American rapper from Detroit, Michigan, and mentions that House Shoes produced his albums.', \"The context also states that Danny Brown was born on March 16, 1981.\", 'The answer given is March 16, 1981, which matches the birthdate provided in the context.", "Therefore, the answer is faithful to the context as it correctly identifies the birth year of the American rapper whose albums were produced by House Shoes.'" ]

{ "_id": 2852, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The CONTEXT specifies that Gene Shay was called 'The Grandfather of Philadelphia Folk Music' by 'The Philadelphia Inquirer'.\", \"The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that he was called 'The Father of Philadelphia Folk Music'.\", \"The title 'The Father of Philadelphia Folk Music' is not mentioned in the CONTEXT as a nickname for Gene Shay.\", \"Therefore, the MODEL OUTPUT is not faithful to the CONTEXT because it provides a title that was not attributed to Gene Shay by 'The Philadelphia Inquirer'.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "\"The CONTEXT specifies that Gene Shay was called 'The Grandfather of Philadelphia Folk Music' by 'The Philadelphia Inquirer'.\", \"The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that he was called 'The Father of Philadelphia Folk Music'.\", \"The title 'The Father of Philadelphia Folk Music' is not mentioned in the CONTEXT as a nickname for Gene Shay.\", \"Therefore, the MODEL OUTPUT is not faithful to the CONTEXT because it provides a title that was not attributed to Gene Shay by 'The Philadelphia Inquirer'.\"" ]

{ "_id": 8090, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for a landmark civil rights decision involving the issue of interracial marriage and the use of the Latin phrase \"Et uxor.\"', 'The context clearly states that the phrase \"Et uxor\" is used in the case name \"Loving et ux. v. Virginia,\" indicating the female spouse of the male party in the litigation.', \"The context also explains that 'Loving v. Virginia' is a landmark civil rights decision that invalidated laws prohibiting interracial marriage.\", \"The model's answer incorrectly states that the decision involved the issue of Catholicism in marriage, which is not mentioned in the context.\", \"Therefore, the model's answer is not faithful to the context as it introduces an issue (Catholicism) that is not supported by the provided information.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks for a landmark civil rights decision involving the issue of interracial marriage and the use of the Latin phrase \"Et uxor.\"", "The context clearly states that the phrase \"Et uxor\" is used in the case name \"Loving et ux. v. Virginia,\" indicating the female spouse of the male party in the litigation.', \"The context also explains that 'Loving v. Virginia' is a landmark civil rights decision that invalidated laws prohibiting interracial marriage.\", \"The model's answer incorrectly states that the decision involved the issue of Catholicism in marriage, which is not mentioned in the context.\", \"Therefore, the model's answer is not faithful to the context as it introduces an issue (Catholicism) that is not supported by the provided information.\"" ]

{ "_id": 2694, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The context states that the American animated/live-action comedy film series 'SpongeBob SquarePants' began in 2004 with the release of 'The SpongeBob SquarePants Movie'.\", 'The question asks for the year the series began, which according to the context is 2004.', 'The model output incorrectly states that the series began in 2015, which is the release year of \"The SpongeBob Movie: Sponge Out of Water\", not the start of the series.', 'The correct answer should be 2004, not 2015.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "\"The context states that the American animated/live-action comedy film series 'SpongeBob SquarePants' began in 2004 with the release of 'The SpongeBob SquarePants Movie'.\", 'The question asks for the year the series began, which according to the context is 2004.", "The model output incorrectly states that the series began in 2015, which is the release year of \"The SpongeBob Movie: Sponge Out of Water\", not the start of the series.", "The correct answer should be 2004, not 2015.'" ]

{ "_id": 6234, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks about the inter-city rival team of Real Sociedad in a local derby.', 'The context provides that Real Sociedad contests the Basque derby against rivals Athletic Bilbao.', 'The answer given is Athletic Bilbao, which is incorrect because Athletic Bilbao is the rival team in the local derby, not the inter-city rival team.', 'The inter-city rival team should be the one that is not directly mentioned as the rival in the local derby context.', 'Therefore, the correct answer should be the team other than Athletic Bilbao, which is not specified in the given context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks about the inter-city rival team of Real Sociedad in a local derby.", "The context provides that Real Sociedad contests the Basque derby against rivals Athletic Bilbao.", "The answer given is Athletic Bilbao, which is incorrect because Athletic Bilbao is the rival team in the local derby, not the inter-city rival team.", "The inter-city rival team should be the one that is not directly mentioned as the rival in the local derby context.", "Therefore, the correct answer should be the team other than Athletic Bilbao, which is not specified in the given context.'" ]

{ "_id": 4229, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks which between Mariano Marcos State University and Christian Brothers University is located in the US.', 'The context provides information that Mariano Marcos State University is located in the Philippines, specifically in the Ilocos Region.', 'The context also states that Christian Brothers University is located in the city of Memphis, which is in the US.', 'Therefore, Christian Brothers University is the correct answer as it is the only one mentioned in the context that is located in the US.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks which between Mariano Marcos State University and Christian Brothers University is located in the US.", "The context provides information that Mariano Marcos State University is located in the Philippines, specifically in the Ilocos Region.", "The context also states that Christian Brothers University is located in the city of Memphis, which is in the US.", "Therefore, Christian Brothers University is the correct answer as it is the only one mentioned in the context that is located in the US.'" ]

{ "_id": 561, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT specifies that the car rental company founded by Jack Taylor and headquartered in Clayton, Missouri is Enterprise Rent-A-Car.', 'The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that the car rental company is Hertz.', 'The CONTEXT does not mention Hertz as being founded by Jack Taylor or headquartered in Clayton, Missouri.', 'Therefore, the MODEL OUTPUT is not faithful to the CONTEXT.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT specifies that the car rental company founded by Jack Taylor and headquartered in Clayton, Missouri is Enterprise Rent-A-Car.", "The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that the car rental company is Hertz.", "The CONTEXT does not mention Hertz as being founded by Jack Taylor or headquartered in Clayton, Missouri.", "Therefore, the MODEL OUTPUT is not faithful to the CONTEXT.'" ]

{ "_id": 4525, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT states that Robert Ellsworth Pollard Jr. (Robert Pollard) is an American musician.', 'The CONTEXT does not provide any information that contradicts Robert Pollard being an American musician.', 'The CONTEXT only mentions that Nic Offer is a New York City-based musician, not that he is not American.', 'The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that Robert Pollard is not an American musician, which is not supported by the CONTEXT.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT states that Robert Ellsworth Pollard Jr. (Robert Pollard) is an American musician.", "The CONTEXT does not provide any information that contradicts Robert Pollard being an American musician.", "The CONTEXT only mentions that Nic Offer is a New York City-based musician, not that he is not American.", "The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that Robert Pollard is not an American musician, which is not supported by the CONTEXT.'" ]

{ "_id": 8615, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT specifies that the TV series was produced by Walt Disney Television Animation, not Pixar Animation Studios.', 'The CONTEXT correctly identifies Patricia Ann Carroll as an American actress, voice actress, and comedian who reprises her role in the series.', 'The MODEL incorrectly states that the series was produced by Pixar Animation Studios, which is incorrect according to the CONTEXT.', 'The MODEL correctly mentions Patricia Ann Carroll as the voice of Ariel, which is accurate based on the CONTEXT.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT specifies that the TV series was produced by Walt Disney Television Animation, not Pixar Animation Studios.", "The CONTEXT correctly identifies Patricia Ann Carroll as an American actress, voice actress, and comedian who reprises her role in the series.", "The MODEL incorrectly states that the series was produced by Pixar Animation Studios, which is incorrect according to the CONTEXT.", "The MODEL correctly mentions Patricia Ann Carroll as the voice of Ariel, which is accurate based on the CONTEXT.'" ]

{ "_id": 4783, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for a Hungarian racing driver born in 1978 who is competing in an international Touring Car championship.', 'The context provides information about István Bertold Bernula, mentioning his birth year as 1978 and his current involvement in the TCR International Series and ADAC TCR Germany Touring Car Championship.', \"The TCR International Series is explicitly described as an international Touring Car championship in the context.\", 'The answer, István Bertold Bernula, directly matches the details given in the context, ensuring that it is faithful to the information provided.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for a Hungarian racing driver born in 1978 who is competing in an international Touring Car championship.", "The context provides information about István Bertold Bernula, mentioning his birth year as 1978 and his current involvement in the TCR International Series and ADAC TCR Germany Touring Car Championship.', \"The TCR International Series is explicitly described as an international Touring Car championship in the context.\", 'The answer, István Bertold Bernula, directly matches the details given in the context, ensuring that it is faithful to the information provided.'" ]

{ "_id": 3131, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for teams that are part of motorsport in the United Kingdom.', 'The context mentions the Lotus F1 Team as a British Formula One racing team.', \"The model's output, 'Lotus F1', is not faithful to the context because it only mentions a single team, 'Lotus F1', whereas the context implies there are other teams involved in motorsport in the UK.\", 'The context does not provide a comprehensive list of teams, but mentioning a single team does not fully answer the question about teams in the UK.', 'The answer should have either asked for more information or provided a more detailed list of teams to fully address the question.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks for teams that are part of motorsport in the United Kingdom.", "The context mentions the Lotus F1 Team as a British Formula One racing team.', \"The model's output, 'Lotus F1', is not faithful to the context because it only mentions a single team, 'Lotus F1', whereas the context implies there are other teams involved in motorsport in the UK.\", 'The context does not provide a comprehensive list of teams, but mentioning a single team does not fully answer the question about teams in the UK.", "The answer should have either asked for more information or provided a more detailed list of teams to fully address the question.'" ]

{ "_id": 7756, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks whether both the Lambda 8300 and the Aamber Pegasus are technology devices.', 'The context describes the Lambda 8300 as a Sinclair ZX81 clone, which implies it is a copy or imitation of an existing technology device.', 'The context describes the Aamber Pegasus as a home computer, which is a type of technology device.', 'The model output states that the Lambda 8300 is a clone while the Aamber Pegasus is an original invention, which is not directly supported by the context.', 'The context does not provide information about the Aamber Pegasus being an original invention; it only mentions it as a home computer.', 'Therefore, the model output does not accurately reflect the information provided in the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks whether both the Lambda 8300 and the Aamber Pegasus are technology devices.", "The context describes the Lambda 8300 as a Sinclair ZX81 clone, which implies it is a copy or imitation of an existing technology device.", "The context describes the Aamber Pegasus as a home computer, which is a type of technology device.", "The model output states that the Lambda 8300 is a clone while the Aamber Pegasus is an original invention, which is not directly supported by the context.", "The context does not provide information about the Aamber Pegasus being an original invention; it only mentions it as a home computer.", "Therefore, the model output does not accurately reflect the information provided in the context.'" ]

{ "_id": 8554, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT specifies that Michael Foale is an astrophysicist and former NASA astronaut.', 'The CONTEXT also states that Dirk Frimout is an astrophysicist for the European Space Agency.', \"The term 'astrophysicist' in the CONTEXT clearly defines the profession of both Michael Foale and Dirk Frimout.\", \"The ANSWER 'astrophysicist' directly matches the information provided in the CONTEXT.\", 'Therefore, the ANSWER is faithful to the CONTEXT given the QUESTION.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT specifies that Michael Foale is an astrophysicist and former NASA astronaut.", "The CONTEXT also states that Dirk Frimout is an astrophysicist for the European Space Agency.', \"The term 'astrophysicist' in the CONTEXT clearly defines the profession of both Michael Foale and Dirk Frimout.\", \"The ANSWER 'astrophysicist' directly matches the information provided in the CONTEXT.\", 'Therefore, the ANSWER is faithful to the CONTEXT given the QUESTION.'" ]

{ "_id": 5947, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the organization of the George Richardson Memorial Trophy champions in the 1965 Memorial Cup final.', 'The context specifies that the George Richardson Memorial Trophy champions were the Niagara Falls Flyers of the Ontario Hockey Association.', 'The context does not mention the Edmonton Oil Kings as the champions of the George Richardson Memorial Trophy.', 'The model output incorrectly states that the Edmonton Oil Kings won the 1965 Memorial Cup final, which is not supported by the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks for the organization of the George Richardson Memorial Trophy champions in the 1965 Memorial Cup final.", "The context specifies that the George Richardson Memorial Trophy champions were the Niagara Falls Flyers of the Ontario Hockey Association.", "The context does not mention the Edmonton Oil Kings as the champions of the George Richardson Memorial Trophy.", "The model output incorrectly states that the Edmonton Oil Kings won the 1965 Memorial Cup final, which is not supported by the context.'" ]

{ "_id": 1367, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT specifies that the TV film \"The Black Velvet Gown\" is based on a novel by Catherine Cookson.', 'The QUESTION asks for the author of the novel upon which the TV film is based.', \"The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that the novel was written by Sarah Waters.\", 'There is no mention of Sarah Waters in the CONTEXT in relation to the novel or the TV film.', \"Therefore, the MODEL OUTPUT is not faithful to the CONTEXT as it provides incorrect information.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT specifies that the TV film \"The Black Velvet Gown\" is based on a novel by Catherine Cookson.", "The QUESTION asks for the author of the novel upon which the TV film is based.', \"The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that the novel was written by Sarah Waters.\", 'There is no mention of Sarah Waters in the CONTEXT in relation to the novel or the TV film.', \"Therefore, the MODEL OUTPUT is not faithful to the CONTEXT as it provides incorrect information.\"" ]

{ "_id": 179, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The context specifies that the movie 'Ghostbusters' stars Bill Murray, Dan Aykroyd, Harold Ramis, and Ernie Hudson.\", \"The context also mentions that Dan Aykroyd is a Canadian-American actor and an original member of the 'Not Ready for Prime Time Players' on 'Saturday Night Live'.\", \"The context does not mention 'Friends' or any connection between the 'Not Ready for Prime Time Players' and the TV show 'Friends'.\", \"The answer incorrectly states that the TV show associated with the 'Not Ready for Prime Time Players' is 'Friends', which is not supported by the context.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "\"The context specifies that the movie 'Ghostbusters' stars Bill Murray, Dan Aykroyd, Harold Ramis, and Ernie Hudson.\", \"The context also mentions that Dan Aykroyd is a Canadian-American actor and an original member of the 'Not Ready for Prime Time Players' on 'Saturday Night Live'.\", \"The context does not mention 'Friends' or any connection between the 'Not Ready for Prime Time Players' and the TV show 'Friends'.\", \"The answer incorrectly states that the TV show associated with the 'Not Ready for Prime Time Players' is 'Friends', which is not supported by the context.\"" ]

{ "_id": 1955, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks specifically about a team in Montreal, Quebec that Luis Lopez played for.', 'The context mentions that Luis Lopez played for the Toronto Blue Jays in 2001 and the Montreal Expos in 2004.', 'The Toronto Blue Jays are not based in Montreal, Quebec; they are based in Toronto, Ontario.', 'The correct answer should be the Montreal Expos, as they are the team based in Montreal, Quebec where Lopez played in 2004.', \"The model's output, 'Montreal Expos', is correct but the context also mentions his play for the Toronto Blue Jays, which is not relevant to the question's focus on a team in Montreal, Quebec.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks specifically about a team in Montreal, Quebec that Luis Lopez played for.", "The context mentions that Luis Lopez played for the Toronto Blue Jays in 2001 and the Montreal Expos in 2004.", "The Toronto Blue Jays are not based in Montreal, Quebec; they are based in Toronto, Ontario.", "The correct answer should be the Montreal Expos, as they are the team based in Montreal, Quebec where Lopez played in 2004.', \"The model's output, 'Montreal Expos', is correct but the context also mentions his play for the Toronto Blue Jays, which is not relevant to the question's focus on a team in Montreal, Quebec.\"" ]

{ "_id": 4971, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks which member of Trump's 2017 administration defeated Rodney Stooksberry in the 2016 general election.', 'The context states that Rodney Stooksberry lost the general election in 2016 to Republican incumbent Tom Price.', 'The context also mentions that Thomas Edmunds Price, who served as Secretary of Health and Human Services in Trump's 2017 administration, was the opponent of Rodney Stooksberry in the 2016 general election.', \"Therefore, the answer 'Rodney Stooksberry was not Tom Price's opponent' directly contradicts the information provided in the context.\", 'This answer is not faithful to the context because it incorrectly states that Rodney Stooksberry was not Tom Price's opponent, when in fact, the context clearly indicates that he was.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks which member of Trump's 2017 administration defeated Rodney Stooksberry in the 2016 general election.", "The context states that Rodney Stooksberry lost the general election in 2016 to Republican incumbent Tom Price.", "The context also mentions that Thomas Edmunds Price, who served as Secretary of Health and Human Services in Trump's 2017 administration, was the opponent of Rodney Stooksberry in the 2016 general election.', \"Therefore, the answer 'Rodney Stooksberry was not Tom Price's opponent' directly contradicts the information provided in the context.\", 'This answer is not faithful to the context because it incorrectly states that Rodney Stooksberry was not Tom Price's opponent, when in fact, the context clearly indicates that he was.'" ]

{ "_id": 9686, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The context specifies that the producer of \"Teardrops on My Guitar\" is Nathan Chapman, who worked alongside Taylor Swift.', \"The context explicitly states that the song was 'produced by Nathan Chapman with Swift's aid,' indicating Chapman's primary role in the production.\", \"The answer incorrectly lists Taylor Swift as the producer, which contradicts the information given in the context.\", 'Taylor Swift is credited as a co-writer and contributor to the production, but not the sole producer.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The context specifies that the producer of \"Teardrops on My Guitar\" is Nathan Chapman, who worked alongside Taylor Swift.', \"The context explicitly states that the song was 'produced by Nathan Chapman with Swift's aid,' indicating Chapman's primary role in the production.\", \"The answer incorrectly lists Taylor Swift as the producer, which contradicts the information given in the context.\", 'Taylor Swift is credited as a co-writer and contributor to the production, but not the sole producer.'" ]

{ "_id": 6783, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the city in California where Porter Sargent's family moved to a ranch.', \"The context provides the answer as 'San Bernardino'.\", \"The context mentions that Nathaniel Shaler, the American paleontologist and geologist, was influenced by the city of San Bernardino.\", \"The mention of San Bernardino in relation to Nathaniel Shaler confirms that it is the correct city where Porter Sargent's family moved.\", \"Therefore, the answer 'San Bernardino' is faithful to the context and accurately responds to the question.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the city in California where Porter Sargent's family moved to a ranch.', \"The context provides the answer as 'San Bernardino'.\", \"The context mentions that Nathaniel Shaler, the American paleontologist and geologist, was influenced by the city of San Bernardino.\", \"The mention of San Bernardino in relation to Nathaniel Shaler confirms that it is the correct city where Porter Sargent's family moved.\", \"Therefore, the answer 'San Bernardino' is faithful to the context and accurately responds to the question.\"" ]

{ "_id": 7159, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['Giorgio Simonelli started his career as a journalist and film critic, indicating his involvement in the film industry from a writing perspective.', 'Simonelli co-directed his first film \"Maratona\" in 1928 and was a screenwriter for the first Italian talking film \"The Song of Love\" in 1930, showing his work as a writer in the film industry.', 'Lawrence Kasdan is explicitly mentioned as a screenwriter, director, and producer, highlighting his role in the film industry as a writer.', \"The commonality between Giorgio Simonelli and Lawrence Kasdan is their involvement in the film industry as writers, which is supported by the context provided.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'Giorgio Simonelli started his career as a journalist and film critic, indicating his involvement in the film industry from a writing perspective.", "Simonelli co-directed his first film \"Maratona\" in 1928 and was a screenwriter for the first Italian talking film \"The Song of Love\" in 1930, showing his work as a writer in the film industry.", "Lawrence Kasdan is explicitly mentioned as a screenwriter, director, and producer, highlighting his role in the film industry as a writer.', \"The commonality between Giorgio Simonelli and Lawrence Kasdan is their involvement in the film industry as writers, which is supported by the context provided.\"" ]

{ "_id": 3561, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The CONTEXT specifies that 'Fires of Winter' reached the 'New York Times' bestseller list.\", \"The MODEL incorrectly states that 'Fires of Winter' reached the 'New York Post' bestseller list.\", \"There is no mention of the 'New York Post' bestseller list in the CONTEXT.\", 'The CONTEXT only mentions the \"New York Times\" bestseller list in relation to Johanna Lindsey\\'s books.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "\"The CONTEXT specifies that 'Fires of Winter' reached the 'New York Times' bestseller list.\", \"The MODEL incorrectly states that 'Fires of Winter' reached the 'New York Post' bestseller list.\", \"There is no mention of the 'New York Post' bestseller list in the CONTEXT.\", 'The CONTEXT only mentions the \"New York Times\" bestseller list in relation to Johanna Lindsey\\'s books.'" ]

{ "_id": 8450, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks to compare the number of studio albums released by Sum 41 and Nude.', 'The context provides information about Nude, stating that they have previously released 3 full-length albums and 1 extended play record.', 'The context does not provide any information about the album count for Sum 41.', \"The model's answer, 'Nude', incorrectly suggests that Nude has released more studio albums than Sum 41.\", 'This comparison is not supported by the context, as it only provides specific album counts for Nude, not Sum 41.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks to compare the number of studio albums released by Sum 41 and Nude.", "The context provides information about Nude, stating that they have previously released 3 full-length albums and 1 extended play record.", "The context does not provide any information about the album count for Sum 41.', \"The model's answer, 'Nude', incorrectly suggests that Nude has released more studio albums than Sum 41.\", 'This comparison is not supported by the context, as it only provides specific album counts for Nude, not Sum 41.'" ]

{ "_id": 3246, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks whether We Are Scientists or Needtobreathe was formed further west.', 'The context provides information about the formation locations of both bands.', 'We Are Scientists is a British rock band formed in Berkeley, California, USA.', 'Needtobreathe is an American Christian rock band formed in Seneca, South Carolina, USA.', 'Comparing the locations, Berkeley, California is further west than Seneca, South Carolina.', 'Therefore, We Are Scientists was formed further west than Needtobreathe.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks whether We Are Scientists or Needtobreathe was formed further west.", "The context provides information about the formation locations of both bands.", "We Are Scientists is a British rock band formed in Berkeley, California, USA.", "Needtobreathe is an American Christian rock band formed in Seneca, South Carolina, USA.", "Comparing the locations, Berkeley, California is further west than Seneca, South Carolina.", "Therefore, We Are Scientists was formed further west than Needtobreathe.'" ]

{ "_id": 4415, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT describes Shengzhou as a county-level city.', 'The CONTEXT describes Bei'an as a county-level city.', \"The term 'city' in the MODEL OUTPUT is not accurate because both Shengzhou and Bei'an are described as 'county-level cities' in the CONTEXT.\", \"The correct description should focus on the fact that they are both 'county-level cities' rather than simply 'cities'.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT describes Shengzhou as a county-level city.", "The CONTEXT describes Bei'an as a county-level city.', \"The term 'city' in the MODEL OUTPUT is not accurate because both Shengzhou and Bei'an are described as 'county-level cities' in the CONTEXT.\", \"The correct description should focus on the fact that they are both 'county-level cities' rather than simply 'cities'.\"" ]

{ "_id": 851, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['Serguei Kouchnerov is described as an artist, animator, director, story artist, and screenwriter.', 'Arvid E. Gillstrom is described as a film director and screenwriter.', \"Both Serguei Kouchnerov and Arvid E. Gillstrom are involved in the film industry, as indicated by their roles as directors and screenwriters.\", 'The context does not mention any significant difference in the industries they worked in, as both are associated with the film industry.', \"The model's statement that they were in different industries is not supported by the context, which clearly shows their involvement in the same industry.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'Serguei Kouchnerov is described as an artist, animator, director, story artist, and screenwriter.", "Arvid E. Gillstrom is described as a film director and screenwriter.', \"Both Serguei Kouchnerov and Arvid E. Gillstrom are involved in the film industry, as indicated by their roles as directors and screenwriters.\", 'The context does not mention any significant difference in the industries they worked in, as both are associated with the film industry.', \"The model's statement that they were in different industries is not supported by the context, which clearly shows their involvement in the same industry.\"" ]

{ "_id": 9193, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the German–American biophysicist who helped launch the molecular biology research program in the late 1930s with whom Salvador Luria won the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 1969.', 'The context states that Salvador Luria won the Nobel Prize in 1969 with Max Delbrück and Alfred Hershey.', 'Max Delbrück is identified as a German–American biophysicist who helped launch the molecular biology research program in the late 1930s.', 'The answer correctly identifies Max Delbrück as the German–American biophysicist who helped launch the molecular biology research program in the late 1930s, with whom Salvador Luria won the Nobel Prize in 1969.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the German–American biophysicist who helped launch the molecular biology research program in the late 1930s with whom Salvador Luria won the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 1969.", "The context states that Salvador Luria won the Nobel Prize in 1969 with Max Delbrück and Alfred Hershey.", "Max Delbrück is identified as a German–American biophysicist who helped launch the molecular biology research program in the late 1930s.", "The answer correctly identifies Max Delbrück as the German–American biophysicist who helped launch the molecular biology research program in the late 1930s, with whom Salvador Luria won the Nobel Prize in 1969.'" ]

{ "_id": 8784, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The CONTEXT specifies that the Separatists, including James Chilton, were fleeing from religious persecution by King James of England.\", 'The term \"King James' wrath and fury\" implies a personal vendetta or anger towards James Chilton, which is not supported by the CONTEXT.', 'The CONTEXT does not mention any specific wrath or fury directed towards James Chilton; it only states their desire to escape religious persecution.', \"Therefore, the MODEL OUTPUT is not faithful to the CONTEXT as it introduces a personal element ('wrath and fury') that is not present in the provided information.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "\"The CONTEXT specifies that the Separatists, including James Chilton, were fleeing from religious persecution by King James of England.\", 'The term \"King James' wrath and fury\" implies a personal vendetta or anger towards James Chilton, which is not supported by the CONTEXT.", "The CONTEXT does not mention any specific wrath or fury directed towards James Chilton; it only states their desire to escape religious persecution.', \"Therefore, the MODEL OUTPUT is not faithful to the CONTEXT as it introduces a personal element ('wrath and fury') that is not present in the provided information.\"" ]

{ "_id": 4582, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the birthdate of the singer of \"Funny Face\".', 'The context provides information about the introduction of the song in the Broadway musical \"Funny Face\" (1927) by Adele Astaire and Allen Kearns.', 'Adele Astaire, born Adele Marie Austerlitz, is mentioned as an American dancer, stage actress, and singer.', \"The context explicitly states Adele's birthdate as September 10, 1896.\", \"The model output 'September 10, 1896' directly matches the birthdate provided in the context.\", 'Therefore, the answer is faithful to the context as it correctly identifies the birthdate of the singer mentioned in the context.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the birthdate of the singer of \"Funny Face\".", "The context provides information about the introduction of the song in the Broadway musical \"Funny Face\" (1927) by Adele Astaire and Allen Kearns.", "Adele Astaire, born Adele Marie Austerlitz, is mentioned as an American dancer, stage actress, and singer.', \"The context explicitly states Adele's birthdate as September 10, 1896.\", \"The model output 'September 10, 1896' directly matches the birthdate provided in the context.\", 'Therefore, the answer is faithful to the context as it correctly identifies the birthdate of the singer mentioned in the context.'" ]

{ "_id": 7553, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT corrects the misconception that the discovery of the supercurrent in SNS contacts is attributed to Brian Josephson.', 'The CONTEXT states that the effect was known long before Josephson\\'s publication and was understood as the proximity effect.', 'The MODEL OUTPUT, Brian Josephson, is the same person mentioned in the CONTEXT, but the CONTEXT does not support the claim that he discovered the supercurrent.', 'Therefore, the MODEL OUTPUT is not faithful to the CONTEXT given the QUESTION.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT corrects the misconception that the discovery of the supercurrent in SNS contacts is attributed to Brian Josephson.", "The CONTEXT states that the effect was known long before Josephson\\'s publication and was understood as the proximity effect.", "The MODEL OUTPUT, Brian Josephson, is the same person mentioned in the CONTEXT, but the CONTEXT does not support the claim that he discovered the supercurrent.", "Therefore, the MODEL OUTPUT is not faithful to the CONTEXT given the QUESTION.'" ]

{ "_id": 6667, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The CONTEXT specifies that the film 'The Distinguished Citizen' starring Oscar Martínez was selected to compete for the Golden Lion at the 73rd Venice International Film Festival.\", 'The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that the film was selected for the Silver Lion.', 'There is no mention of the Silver Lion in the CONTEXT in relation to the selection of the film starring Oscar Martínez.', 'Therefore, the ANSWER is not faithful to the CONTEXT as it inaccurately refers to the Silver Lion instead of the Golden Lion.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "\"The CONTEXT specifies that the film 'The Distinguished Citizen' starring Oscar Martínez was selected to compete for the Golden Lion at the 73rd Venice International Film Festival.\", 'The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that the film was selected for the Silver Lion.", "There is no mention of the Silver Lion in the CONTEXT in relation to the selection of the film starring Oscar Martínez.", "Therefore, the ANSWER is not faithful to the CONTEXT as it inaccurately refers to the Silver Lion instead of the Golden Lion.'" ]

{ "_id": 8024, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The University of Virginia (UVA) is described as a public research university, indicating it is an institution of higher learning.', 'King Mongkut\\'s University of Technology Thonburi (KMUTT) is explicitly described as an engineering and technology academy, which is a type of institution of higher learning.', \"Both institutions are mentioned to focus on teaching, researching, and serving industry, which are typical activities associated with institutions of higher learning.\", \"The answer 'yes' correctly identifies both UVA and KMUTT as institutions of higher learning based on the provided context.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The University of Virginia (UVA) is described as a public research university, indicating it is an institution of higher learning.", "King Mongkut\\'s University of Technology Thonburi (KMUTT) is explicitly described as an engineering and technology academy, which is a type of institution of higher learning.', \"Both institutions are mentioned to focus on teaching, researching, and serving industry, which are typical activities associated with institutions of higher learning.\", \"The answer 'yes' correctly identifies both UVA and KMUTT as institutions of higher learning based on the provided context.\"" ]

{ "_id": 2065, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The context states that the Irish Fine Gael party has a membership of 35,000.', 'The answer incorrectly states that the party has over 40,000 members.', 'There is no information in the context to suggest that the party membership has exceeded 40,000.', 'Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context provided.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The context states that the Irish Fine Gael party has a membership of 35,000.", "The answer incorrectly states that the party has over 40,000 members.", "There is no information in the context to suggest that the party membership has exceeded 40,000.", "Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context provided.'" ]

{ "_id": 1932, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT specifies that Mikhail Glinka was the first Russian composer to gain wide recognition within his own country.', 'The CONTEXT does not mention jazz music or any contributions to it by Glinka.', 'The CONTEXT explicitly states that Glinka is often regarded as the fountainhead of Russian classical music.', \"The ANSWER incorrectly attributes Glinka's recognition to jazz music, which is not supported by the CONTEXT.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT specifies that Mikhail Glinka was the first Russian composer to gain wide recognition within his own country.", "The CONTEXT does not mention jazz music or any contributions to it by Glinka.", "The CONTEXT explicitly states that Glinka is often regarded as the fountainhead of Russian classical music.', \"The ANSWER incorrectly attributes Glinka's recognition to jazz music, which is not supported by the CONTEXT.\"" ]

{ "_id": 2759, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks whether Kuvasz and Bouvier des Ardennes are both breeds of dogs.', 'The context provides information that the Kuvasz is an ancient breed of a livestock dog of Hungarian origin.', 'The context also states that Bouvier des Ardennes is a rare dog breed from Belgium.', \"The term 'breed of dogs' implies that the dog in question is a recognized and established breed within the canine world.\", 'Both the Kuvasz and Bouvier des Ardennes are explicitly identified as dog breeds in the context.', \"The answer initially correctly identifies that both are breeds of dogs, but then incorrectly states they are different types of livestock guard animals.\", 'This change misrepresents the information by suggesting that the breeds are classified by their function (livestock guard animals) rather than their status as recognized dog breeds.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks whether Kuvasz and Bouvier des Ardennes are both breeds of dogs.", "The context provides information that the Kuvasz is an ancient breed of a livestock dog of Hungarian origin.", "The context also states that Bouvier des Ardennes is a rare dog breed from Belgium.', \"The term 'breed of dogs' implies that the dog in question is a recognized and established breed within the canine world.\", 'Both the Kuvasz and Bouvier des Ardennes are explicitly identified as dog breeds in the context.', \"The answer initially correctly identifies that both are breeds of dogs, but then incorrectly states they are different types of livestock guard animals.\", 'This change misrepresents the information by suggesting that the breeds are classified by their function (livestock guard animals) rather than their status as recognized dog breeds.'" ]

{ "_id": 6264, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The context explicitly states that Patricia 'Patti' Russo was Meat Loaf's former female lead vocalist.\", 'The context provides a specific name, Patricia \"Patti\" Russo, which is confirmed by Meat Loaf's biography and other sources.', \"The answer provided, 'Sally Smith', is not mentioned anywhere in the context or in any reliable source associated with Meat Loaf's career.\", 'Therefore, the answer \"Sally Smith\" is not faithful to the context as it does not match the information provided about Meat Loaf's former female lead vocalist.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "\"The context explicitly states that Patricia 'Patti' Russo was Meat Loaf's former female lead vocalist.\", 'The context provides a specific name, Patricia \"Patti\" Russo, which is confirmed by Meat Loaf's biography and other sources.', \"The answer provided, 'Sally Smith', is not mentioned anywhere in the context or in any reliable source associated with Meat Loaf's career.\", 'Therefore, the answer \"Sally Smith\" is not faithful to the context as it does not match the information provided about Meat Loaf's former female lead vocalist.'" ]

{ "_id": 6496, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the other name of the extinct tiger subspecies that inhabited the sparse forests and riverine corridors west and south of the Caspian Sea.', \"The context provides that the extinct tiger subspecies is referred to as 'Panthera tigris virgata', also known by other names such as Hyrcanian tiger, Turanian tiger, Persian tiger, and 'Babre Mazandaran'.\", \"The model output 'Hyrcanian tiger' is one of the names provided in the context for the extinct tiger subspecies.\", \"Therefore, the model output 'Hyrcanian tiger' is faithful to the context as it directly matches one of the names given for the extinct tiger subspecies.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the other name of the extinct tiger subspecies that inhabited the sparse forests and riverine corridors west and south of the Caspian Sea.', \"The context provides that the extinct tiger subspecies is referred to as 'Panthera tigris virgata', also known by other names such as Hyrcanian tiger, Turanian tiger, Persian tiger, and 'Babre Mazandaran'.\", \"The model output 'Hyrcanian tiger' is one of the names provided in the context for the extinct tiger subspecies.\", \"Therefore, the model output 'Hyrcanian tiger' is faithful to the context as it directly matches one of the names given for the extinct tiger subspecies.\"" ]

{ "_id": 3585, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question specifically asks for the Jamaican cricketer who made his ODI debut during the 2000 ICC KnockOut Trophy.', 'The context mentions that Marlon Samuels, a Jamaican cricketer, made his ODI debut during the competition.', 'Yuvraj Singh, mentioned in the model output, is not Jamaican; he is an Indian cricketer.', 'Therefore, the correct answer should be Marlon Samuels, not Yuvraj Singh.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question specifically asks for the Jamaican cricketer who made his ODI debut during the 2000 ICC KnockOut Trophy.", "The context mentions that Marlon Samuels, a Jamaican cricketer, made his ODI debut during the competition.", "Yuvraj Singh, mentioned in the model output, is not Jamaican; he is an Indian cricketer.", "Therefore, the correct answer should be Marlon Samuels, not Yuvraj Singh.'" ]

{ "_id": 4173, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the Finnish composer and violinist whose works Akeo Watanabe was known for recording.', 'The context provides information that Akeo Watanabe was known for his recordings of the works of Jean Sibelius.', \"Jean Sibelius is identified as a Finnish composer and violinist of the late Romantic and early-modern periods in the context.\", \"The answer 'Jean Sibelius' directly matches the information provided in the context, ensuring it is faithful to the context.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the Finnish composer and violinist whose works Akeo Watanabe was known for recording.", "The context provides information that Akeo Watanabe was known for his recordings of the works of Jean Sibelius.', \"Jean Sibelius is identified as a Finnish composer and violinist of the late Romantic and early-modern periods in the context.\", \"The answer 'Jean Sibelius' directly matches the information provided in the context, ensuring it is faithful to the context.\"" ]

{ "_id": 7970, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The context specifies that Motionless in White has 5 band members: Chris \"Motionless\" Cerulli, Ricky \"Horror\" Olson, Devin \"Ghost\" Sola, Ryan Sitkowski, and Vinny Mauro.', 'The context also states that Hello Sleepwalkers is a 5-member band.', 'The question asks if both bands have the same number of band members.', 'Since both bands have 5 members, the answer \"yes\" is faithful to the context.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The context specifies that Motionless in White has 5 band members: Chris \"Motionless\" Cerulli, Ricky \"Horror\" Olson, Devin \"Ghost\" Sola, Ryan Sitkowski, and Vinny Mauro.", "The context also states that Hello Sleepwalkers is a 5-member band.", "The question asks if both bands have the same number of band members.", "Since both bands have 5 members, the answer \"yes\" is faithful to the context.'" ]

{ "_id": 3432, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The QUESTION asks for the territories in the Italian Peninsula under the sovereign direct rule of the pope from the 8th century until 1870.', 'The CONTEXT provides that these territories were known as the Papal States.', \"The CHANGE_MADE altered 'Papal States' to 'Kingdom of Italy'.\", 'The KINGDOM_OF_ITALY was not the correct term for the territories under the pope\\'s direct rule from the 8th century until 1870.', \"The correct term, as per the CONTEXT, is 'Papal States'.\", 'Therefore, the ANSWER should have been \"Papal States\" instead of \"Kingdom of Italy\".'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The QUESTION asks for the territories in the Italian Peninsula under the sovereign direct rule of the pope from the 8th century until 1870.", "The CONTEXT provides that these territories were known as the Papal States.', \"The CHANGE_MADE altered 'Papal States' to 'Kingdom of Italy'.\", 'The KINGDOM_OF_ITALY was not the correct term for the territories under the pope\\'s direct rule from the 8th century until 1870.', \"The correct term, as per the CONTEXT, is 'Papal States'.\", 'Therefore, the ANSWER should have been \"Papal States\" instead of \"Kingdom of Italy\".'" ]

{ "_id": 9734, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The question asks about the bands that the bassist, Jason Newsted, was also a part of, in addition to Metallica.\", \"The context provides information that Jason Newsted was part of Voivod and Flotsam and Jetsam, in addition to his tenure in Metallica.\", \"The answer lists 'Voivod and Flotsam and Jetsam' as the bands Jason Newsted was part of.\", 'This directly matches the information provided in the context, making the answer faithful to the context.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "\"The question asks about the bands that the bassist, Jason Newsted, was also a part of, in addition to Metallica.\", \"The context provides information that Jason Newsted was part of Voivod and Flotsam and Jetsam, in addition to his tenure in Metallica.\", \"The answer lists 'Voivod and Flotsam and Jetsam' as the bands Jason Newsted was part of.\", 'This directly matches the information provided in the context, making the answer faithful to the context.'" ]

{ "_id": 6636, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks about the influences and training in Laban Movement study that can be traced back to Gerd Nagey.', 'The context provides information about Jaques-Dalcroze, who was trained under Rudolf von Laban in Hamburg, Germany.', 'The context mentions that Jaques-Dalcroze established her own dance studio and promoted modern dance and mime based on classical ballet, laying the foundations for Laban Movement Analysis.', \"The context does not provide any specific information about Gerd Nagey's influences and training in Laban Movement study.\", \"The answer 'Rudolf von Laban' is not directly supported by the context, as it only mentions Jaques-Dalcroze's training under Rudolf von Laban, not Gerd Nagey's.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks about the influences and training in Laban Movement study that can be traced back to Gerd Nagey.", "The context provides information about Jaques-Dalcroze, who was trained under Rudolf von Laban in Hamburg, Germany.", "The context mentions that Jaques-Dalcroze established her own dance studio and promoted modern dance and mime based on classical ballet, laying the foundations for Laban Movement Analysis.', \"The context does not provide any specific information about Gerd Nagey's influences and training in Laban Movement study.\", \"The answer 'Rudolf von Laban' is not directly supported by the context, as it only mentions Jaques-Dalcroze's training under Rudolf von Laban, not Gerd Nagey's.\"" ]

{ "_id": 8096, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT specifies that the events were broadcast on ESPN.', 'The MODEL OUTPUT states that ABC broadcasts the 2015 event.', 'The correct information from the CONTEXT is that ESPN broadcast the event, not ABC.', 'Therefore, the MODEL OUTPUT is incorrect because it does not match the information provided in the CONTEXT.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT specifies that the events were broadcast on ESPN.", "The MODEL OUTPUT states that ABC broadcasts the 2015 event.", "The correct information from the CONTEXT is that ESPN broadcast the event, not ABC.", "Therefore, the MODEL OUTPUT is incorrect because it does not match the information provided in the CONTEXT.'" ]

{ "_id": 110, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks who hosted both Miss USA 1968 and The Price Is Right.', 'The context states that Bob Barker hosted Miss USA 1968.', 'The context also states that Bob Barker hosted The Price Is Right from 1972 to 2007.', 'However, the context indicates that Bob Barker hosted The Price Is Right after he hosted Miss USA 1968, not simultaneously.', 'Therefore, the answer should not be Bob Barker, as he did not host both events at the same time.', 'The correct answer should be someone who hosted both events in the same year, not necessarily Bob Barker.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks who hosted both Miss USA 1968 and The Price Is Right.", "The context states that Bob Barker hosted Miss USA 1968.", "The context also states that Bob Barker hosted The Price Is Right from 1972 to 2007.", "However, the context indicates that Bob Barker hosted The Price Is Right after he hosted Miss USA 1968, not simultaneously.", "Therefore, the answer should not be Bob Barker, as he did not host both events at the same time.", "The correct answer should be someone who hosted both events in the same year, not necessarily Bob Barker.'" ]

{ "_id": 6742, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks about the university from which the coach of the 37th season of the VCU Rams men's basketball team played.', 'The context states that the coach, Jeff Capel III, played for Duke University.', 'The context also mentions that Capel III was a head coach at Virginia Commonwealth University (VCU) and the University of Oklahoma, but it specifies that he played for Duke University.', \"The model's answer, 'Duke University,' directly matches the information provided in the context.\", 'Therefore, the model's answer is faithful to the context given the question.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks about the university from which the coach of the 37th season of the VCU Rams men's basketball team played.", "The context states that the coach, Jeff Capel III, played for Duke University.", "The context also mentions that Capel III was a head coach at Virginia Commonwealth University (VCU) and the University of Oklahoma, but it specifies that he played for Duke University.', \"The model's answer, 'Duke University,' directly matches the information provided in the context.\", 'Therefore, the model's answer is faithful to the context given the question.'" ]

{ "_id": 2550, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['Pavel Ruminov is identified as a Russian film director in the context provided.', 'Terry Zwigoff is described as an American filmmaker in the context provided.', 'The question asks whether both directors are American, which would be true for Terry Zwigoff but not for Pavel Ruminov.', \"The answer 'no' correctly identifies that Pavel Ruminov is not American, but it does not explicitly state why the answer is 'no' (i.e., because of Pavel Ruminov's Russian nationality).\", 'Therefore, the answer is not fully faithful to the context as it does not clearly explain the reason for the negative response.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'Pavel Ruminov is identified as a Russian film director in the context provided.", "Terry Zwigoff is described as an American filmmaker in the context provided.", "The question asks whether both directors are American, which would be true for Terry Zwigoff but not for Pavel Ruminov.', \"The answer 'no' correctly identifies that Pavel Ruminov is not American, but it does not explicitly state why the answer is 'no' (i.e., because of Pavel Ruminov's Russian nationality).\", 'Therefore, the answer is not fully faithful to the context as it does not clearly explain the reason for the negative response.'" ]

{ "_id": 3793, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT provides the release year of the film REC as 2007.', 'The QUESTION asks for the year of release of the film REC.', 'The MODEL OUTPUT states the year of release as 2006, which contradicts the information given in the CONTEXT.', 'The correct year, as per the CONTEXT, is 2007.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT provides the release year of the film REC as 2007.", "The QUESTION asks for the year of release of the film REC.", "The MODEL OUTPUT states the year of release as 2006, which contradicts the information given in the CONTEXT.", "The correct year, as per the CONTEXT, is 2007.'" ]

{ "_id": 7236, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the birth year of the leader of the Guadalajara Cartel responsible for the murder of John Clay Walker.', 'The context provides information that the leader responsible was Rafael Caro Quintero.', 'Rafael Caro Quintero was born on October 3, 1952.', 'The model output states that the leader was born in 1951, which is incorrect according to the context.', 'The correct birth year, as per the context, is 1952.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks for the birth year of the leader of the Guadalajara Cartel responsible for the murder of John Clay Walker.", "The context provides information that the leader responsible was Rafael Caro Quintero.", "Rafael Caro Quintero was born on October 3, 1952.", "The model output states that the leader was born in 1951, which is incorrect according to the context.", "The correct birth year, as per the context, is 1952.'" ]

{ "_id": 2079, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT clearly states that the film \"Dear Wendy\" was directed by Thomas Vinterberg in the year 2004.', 'The QUESTION specifically asks for the year in which Thomas Vinterberg directed \"Dear Wendy\".', \"The ANSWER provided is '2003', which contradicts the information given in the CONTEXT.\", 'The CONTEXT does not mention any involvement of Thomas Vinterberg in directing a film called \"Dear Wendy\" in the year 2003.', 'Therefore, the ANSWER is not faithful to the CONTEXT.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT clearly states that the film \"Dear Wendy\" was directed by Thomas Vinterberg in the year 2004.", "The QUESTION specifically asks for the year in which Thomas Vinterberg directed \"Dear Wendy\".', \"The ANSWER provided is '2003', which contradicts the information given in the CONTEXT.\", 'The CONTEXT does not mention any involvement of Thomas Vinterberg in directing a film called \"Dear Wendy\" in the year 2003.", "Therefore, the ANSWER is not faithful to the CONTEXT.'" ]

{ "_id": 9345, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the star of Now You See Me who was born in Oman.', 'The context provides information about the birthplace of Isla Fisher, one of the stars of the film.', 'According to the context, Isla Fisher was born to Scottish parents in Oman.', \"This indicates that Isla Fisher herself was born in Oman.\", \"Therefore, the answer 'Isla Fisher' is faithful to the context as she is the only star mentioned in the context who was born in Oman.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the star of Now You See Me who was born in Oman.", "The context provides information about the birthplace of Isla Fisher, one of the stars of the film.", "According to the context, Isla Fisher was born to Scottish parents in Oman.', \"This indicates that Isla Fisher herself was born in Oman.\", \"Therefore, the answer 'Isla Fisher' is faithful to the context as she is the only star mentioned in the context who was born in Oman.\"" ]

{ "_id": 6763, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['Michelangelo Antonioni was an Italian film director, indicating his nationality as Italian.', 'Ivan Magrin-Chagnolleau was born in Paris, France, indicating his nationality as French.', 'The question asks if Michelangelo Antonioni and Ivan Magrin-Chagnolleau are of the same nationality.', 'Based on the context provided, Michelangelo Antonioni is Italian and Ivan Magrin-Chagnolleau is French, making them not of the same nationality.', \"Therefore, the answer 'no' is faithful to the context and correctly responds to the question.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'Michelangelo Antonioni was an Italian film director, indicating his nationality as Italian.", "Ivan Magrin-Chagnolleau was born in Paris, France, indicating his nationality as French.", "The question asks if Michelangelo Antonioni and Ivan Magrin-Chagnolleau are of the same nationality.", "Based on the context provided, Michelangelo Antonioni is Italian and Ivan Magrin-Chagnolleau is French, making them not of the same nationality.', \"Therefore, the answer 'no' is faithful to the context and correctly responds to the question.\"" ]

{ "_id": 1970, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The context explicitly states that \"The Watercolor (Tr: Suluboya)\" is a 2009 Turkish animated film.', 'The context also confirms that Metropia is a 2009 English-language Swedish-Danish-Norwegian adult animated film.', 'Both statements in the context clearly indicate that both films, Metropia and The Watercolor, are animated.', \"The answer 'yes' correctly reflects the information provided in the context, confirming that both films are animated.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The context explicitly states that \"The Watercolor (Tr: Suluboya)\" is a 2009 Turkish animated film.", "The context also confirms that Metropia is a 2009 English-language Swedish-Danish-Norwegian adult animated film.", "Both statements in the context clearly indicate that both films, Metropia and The Watercolor, are animated.', \"The answer 'yes' correctly reflects the information provided in the context, confirming that both films are animated.\"" ]

{ "_id": 7304, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT specifies that Jill Jones is a senior lecturer at the University of Adelaide.', 'The QUESTION asks for the public university in Adelaide, South Australia, where Jill Jones is a senior lecturer.', \"The CONTEXT provides that the University of Adelaide is a public university located in Adelaide, South Australia, and it is established in 1874.\", \"The CONTEXT explicitly states that Jill Jones is a senior lecturer at the University of Adelaide.\", \"The ANSWER incorrectly states that Jill Jones is not a senior lecturer at the University of Adelaide, which contradicts the information given in the CONTEXT.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT specifies that Jill Jones is a senior lecturer at the University of Adelaide.", "The QUESTION asks for the public university in Adelaide, South Australia, where Jill Jones is a senior lecturer.', \"The CONTEXT provides that the University of Adelaide is a public university located in Adelaide, South Australia, and it is established in 1874.\", \"The CONTEXT explicitly states that Jill Jones is a senior lecturer at the University of Adelaide.\", \"The ANSWER incorrectly states that Jill Jones is not a senior lecturer at the University of Adelaide, which contradicts the information given in the CONTEXT.\"" ]

{ "_id": 6805, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the year the university where Patrick Daniel Gaffney earned his PhD was established.', 'The context states that Patrick Daniel Gaffney earned his PhD from the University of Chicago.', 'The context also provides that the University of Chicago was established in 1890.', \"Therefore, the year the university where Patrick Daniel Gaffney earned his PhD was established is 1890.\", \"The answer '1890' is faithful to the context as it directly matches the information provided about the establishment year of the University of Chicago.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the year the university where Patrick Daniel Gaffney earned his PhD was established.", "The context states that Patrick Daniel Gaffney earned his PhD from the University of Chicago.", "The context also provides that the University of Chicago was established in 1890.', \"Therefore, the year the university where Patrick Daniel Gaffney earned his PhD was established is 1890.\", \"The answer '1890' is faithful to the context as it directly matches the information provided about the establishment year of the University of Chicago.\"" ]

{ "_id": 4491, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks specifically about the American poet who wrote a poem entitled at first \"The Defence of Fort McHenry\".', 'The context clearly states that Francis Scott Key was the American poet who wrote the poem initially titled \"The Defence of Fort McHenry\".', 'The context also mentions that this poem, when set to music, became the United States' national anthem, \"The Star-Spangled Banner\".', 'The model incorrectly states that Francis Key Hunt was named after an American writer who wrote \"The Star-Spangled Banner\", which is not directly accurate.', 'The correct information should focus on Francis Scott Key being the poet of \"The Defence of Fort McHenry\", not \"The Star-Spangled Banner\", which is the anthem derived from the poem.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks specifically about the American poet who wrote a poem entitled at first \"The Defence of Fort McHenry\".", "The context clearly states that Francis Scott Key was the American poet who wrote the poem initially titled \"The Defence of Fort McHenry\".", "The context also mentions that this poem, when set to music, became the United States' national anthem, \"The Star-Spangled Banner\".", "The model incorrectly states that Francis Key Hunt was named after an American writer who wrote \"The Star-Spangled Banner\", which is not directly accurate.", "The correct information should focus on Francis Scott Key being the poet of \"The Defence of Fort McHenry\", not \"The Star-Spangled Banner\", which is the anthem derived from the poem.'" ]

{ "_id": 6768, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT states that the Sturmgewehr 52 (STG-52) was manufactured by W+F Bern of Switzerland, not Germany.', 'The CONTEXT indicates that the STG-52 was heavily patterned after the German FG 42, but it was not manufactured in Germany.', 'The QUESTION asks for the selective-fire automatic rifle produced in Nazi Germany during World War II that the STG-52 was patterned after, which is the FG 42.', \"However, the ANSWER incorrectly states that the STG-52 was manufactured by Germany, which contradicts the CONTEXT.\", 'Therefore, the ANSWER is not faithful to the CONTEXT because it misrepresents the manufacturer of the STG-52.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT states that the Sturmgewehr 52 (STG-52) was manufactured by W+F Bern of Switzerland, not Germany.", "The CONTEXT indicates that the STG-52 was heavily patterned after the German FG 42, but it was not manufactured in Germany.", "The QUESTION asks for the selective-fire automatic rifle produced in Nazi Germany during World War II that the STG-52 was patterned after, which is the FG 42.', \"However, the ANSWER incorrectly states that the STG-52 was manufactured by Germany, which contradicts the CONTEXT.\", 'Therefore, the ANSWER is not faithful to the CONTEXT because it misrepresents the manufacturer of the STG-52.'" ]

{ "_id": 7767, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the producer of the 2003 animated film for which Thomson Andrews played.', \"The context specifies that 'The Jungle Book 2' is a 2003 animated film produced by DisneyToon Studios.\", \"The context also mentions that Thomson Andrews lent his voice for 'The Jungle Book 2', confirming the film's connection to Andrews' work.\", \"The model output, 'DisneyToon Studios', correctly identifies the producer of 'The Jungle Book 2' as DisneyToon Studios.\", 'Therefore, the answer is faithful to the context provided in the question.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the producer of the 2003 animated film for which Thomson Andrews played.', \"The context specifies that 'The Jungle Book 2' is a 2003 animated film produced by DisneyToon Studios.\", \"The context also mentions that Thomson Andrews lent his voice for 'The Jungle Book 2', confirming the film's connection to Andrews' work.\", \"The model output, 'DisneyToon Studios', correctly identifies the producer of 'The Jungle Book 2' as DisneyToon Studios.\", 'Therefore, the answer is faithful to the context provided in the question.'" ]

{ "_id": 5578, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks specifically about the position held by Ivar the Boneless\\'s brother in the mid-ninth-century.', 'The context provides a list of Ivar the Boneless\\'s brothers, including Ubba, who is described as a mid-ninth-century Viking chieftain and commander of the Great Army.', \"The term 'chieftain' and 'commander' imply a position of leadership and authority, which is more specific than just being a 'prominent warrior'.\", \"The answer 'prominent warrior' does not capture the detailed information provided in the context about Ubba's role and position, which is that of a chieftain and commander.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks specifically about the position held by Ivar the Boneless\\'s brother in the mid-ninth-century.", "The context provides a list of Ivar the Boneless\\'s brothers, including Ubba, who is described as a mid-ninth-century Viking chieftain and commander of the Great Army.', \"The term 'chieftain' and 'commander' imply a position of leadership and authority, which is more specific than just being a 'prominent warrior'.\", \"The answer 'prominent warrior' does not capture the detailed information provided in the context about Ubba's role and position, which is that of a chieftain and commander.\"" ]

{ "_id": 6738, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The CONTEXT specifies that James Reid rose to prominence in 2014 for his leading role in the film 'Diary ng Panget: The Movie'.\", \"'Ang Diary ng Panget' is the title of the book that the movie 'Diary ng Panget: The Movie' is based on.\", \"The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that James Reid rose to prominence with 'Ang Diary ng Panget', which is the title of the book, not the movie.\", \"The correct answer should be 'Diary ng Panget: The Movie', not 'Ang Diary ng Panget'.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "\"The CONTEXT specifies that James Reid rose to prominence in 2014 for his leading role in the film 'Diary ng Panget: The Movie'.\", \"'Ang Diary ng Panget' is the title of the book that the movie 'Diary ng Panget: The Movie' is based on.\", \"The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that James Reid rose to prominence with 'Ang Diary ng Panget', which is the title of the book, not the movie.\", \"The correct answer should be 'Diary ng Panget: The Movie', not 'Ang Diary ng Panget'.\"" ]

{ "_id": 5580, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The CONTEXT specifies that 'Feels Like Home' is a song written by Randy Newman.\", 'The CONTEXT mentions that the song was recorded by Linda Ronstadt and released on her album \"Feels Like Home\" in March 1995.', 'The CONTEXT highlights Linda Ronstadt\\'s numerous awards and accolades, including 11 Grammy Awards.', \"The QUESTION asks for the multiple award-winning singer for whom Randy Newman wrote the country song 'Feels Like Home'.\", 'The ANSWER provided is Linda Ronstadt, which is directly supported by the CONTEXT.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "\"The CONTEXT specifies that 'Feels Like Home' is a song written by Randy Newman.\", 'The CONTEXT mentions that the song was recorded by Linda Ronstadt and released on her album \"Feels Like Home\" in March 1995.", "The CONTEXT highlights Linda Ronstadt\\'s numerous awards and accolades, including 11 Grammy Awards.', \"The QUESTION asks for the multiple award-winning singer for whom Randy Newman wrote the country song 'Feels Like Home'.\", 'The ANSWER provided is Linda Ronstadt, which is directly supported by the CONTEXT.'" ]

{ "_id": 5125, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The CONTEXT specifies that the film is a remake of the 1988 Hindi language film titled 'Qayamat Se Qayamat Tak'.\", \"The QUESTION asks for the name of the movie produced by Nasir Hussain and has a remake named Keyamat Theke Keyamat.\", \"The CONTEXT mentions that the remake is titled 'Keyamat Theke Keyamat', which matches the information provided in the QUESTION.\", \"The original film title 'Qayamat Se Qayamat Tak' does not match the remake title 'Keyamat Theke Keyamat', indicating that the QUESTION is asking for the remake title, not the original title.\", \"The ANSWER 'Qayamat Tak' is not faithful to the CONTEXT as it does not match the remake title provided in the CONTEXT.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "\"The CONTEXT specifies that the film is a remake of the 1988 Hindi language film titled 'Qayamat Se Qayamat Tak'.\", \"The QUESTION asks for the name of the movie produced by Nasir Hussain and has a remake named Keyamat Theke Keyamat.\", \"The CONTEXT mentions that the remake is titled 'Keyamat Theke Keyamat', which matches the information provided in the QUESTION.\", \"The original film title 'Qayamat Se Qayamat Tak' does not match the remake title 'Keyamat Theke Keyamat', indicating that the QUESTION is asking for the remake title, not the original title.\", \"The ANSWER 'Qayamat Tak' is not faithful to the CONTEXT as it does not match the remake title provided in the CONTEXT.\"" ]

{ "_id": 6992, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the release date of the album from which \"She's Leaving Home\" was taken.', 'The context specifies that \"She's Leaving Home\" was released in 1967 on the album \"Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band\".', 'The context further provides the specific release dates for the album: 26 May 1967 in the UK and 2 June 1967 in the US.', 'The model output incorrectly states the release date as 2 June 1967, which is the US release date, not the UK release date.', 'The correct answer should be 26 May 1967, which is the UK release date mentioned in the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks for the release date of the album from which \"She's Leaving Home\" was taken.", "The context specifies that \"She's Leaving Home\" was released in 1967 on the album \"Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band\".", "The context further provides the specific release dates for the album: 26 May 1967 in the UK and 2 June 1967 in the US.", "The model output incorrectly states the release date as 2 June 1967, which is the US release date, not the UK release date.", "The correct answer should be 26 May 1967, which is the UK release date mentioned in the context.'" ]

{ "_id": 8968, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks which location is in Tenerife between Teide National Park and Cabañeros National Park.', 'The context provides information that Teide National Park is located in Tenerife, Canary Islands, Spain.', 'The context also states that Cabañeros National Park is located in the Montes de Toledo, Spain, which is a different location from Tenerife.', 'Therefore, the correct answer should be Teide National Park as it is the only one mentioned in the context to be located in Tenerife.', \"The model's output, 'Teide National Park', is faithful to the context given the question.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks which location is in Tenerife between Teide National Park and Cabañeros National Park.", "The context provides information that Teide National Park is located in Tenerife, Canary Islands, Spain.", "The context also states that Cabañeros National Park is located in the Montes de Toledo, Spain, which is a different location from Tenerife.", "Therefore, the correct answer should be Teide National Park as it is the only one mentioned in the context to be located in Tenerife.', \"The model's output, 'Teide National Park', is faithful to the context given the question.\"" ]

{ "_id": 9697, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The context specifies that the Union forces were under the command of Maj. Gen. Nathaniel P. Banks, not Ulysses S. Grant.', 'Ulysses S. Grant was a prominent Union general during the Civil War, but he was not involved in the Battle of Cedar Mountain as indicated by the context.', 'The correct information from the context is that Maj. Gen. Nathaniel P. Banks led the Union forces against Maj. Gen. Thomas J. \"Stonewall\" Jackson at Cedar Mountain.', 'The answer incorrectly attributes the involvement of Ulysses S. Grant, which is not supported by the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The context specifies that the Union forces were under the command of Maj. Gen. Nathaniel P. Banks, not Ulysses S. Grant.", "Ulysses S. Grant was a prominent Union general during the Civil War, but he was not involved in the Battle of Cedar Mountain as indicated by the context.", "The correct information from the context is that Maj. Gen. Nathaniel P. Banks led the Union forces against Maj. Gen. Thomas J. \"Stonewall\" Jackson at Cedar Mountain.", "The answer incorrectly attributes the involvement of Ulysses S. Grant, which is not supported by the context.'" ]

{ "_id": 6034, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT specifies that the album Eastsideridaz was released by Goldie Loc in 2007.', 'The CONTEXT also mentions that Nate Dogg, a rapper who died on March 15, 2011, was featured on the album.', \"The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that Goldie Lac featured an unknown rapper, which contradicts the information provided in the CONTEXT.\", 'The correct information should identify Nate Dogg as the rapper featured on the album, not an unknown rapper.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT specifies that the album Eastsideridaz was released by Goldie Loc in 2007.", "The CONTEXT also mentions that Nate Dogg, a rapper who died on March 15, 2011, was featured on the album.', \"The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that Goldie Lac featured an unknown rapper, which contradicts the information provided in the CONTEXT.\", 'The correct information should identify Nate Dogg as the rapper featured on the album, not an unknown rapper.'" ]

{ "_id": 1505, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The CONTEXT specifies that 'The Dressmaker' is a 2015 Australian revenge comedy-drama film written and directed by Jocelyn Moorhouse, based on the novel of the same name by Rosalie Ham.\", 'The QUESTION asks for a 2015 Australian revenge comedy-drama film written and directed by Jocelyn Moorhouse, based on the novel of the same name by Rosalie Ham.', \"The CONTEXT mentions that Caroline Cruice Goodall's other film appearances include 'The Dressmaker' (2015), which matches the criteria specified in the QUESTION.\", \"The MODEL OUTPUT states that the film Caroline Cruice Goodall starred in is 'The Dressmaker', which is directly supported by the CONTEXT.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "\"The CONTEXT specifies that 'The Dressmaker' is a 2015 Australian revenge comedy-drama film written and directed by Jocelyn Moorhouse, based on the novel of the same name by Rosalie Ham.\", 'The QUESTION asks for a 2015 Australian revenge comedy-drama film written and directed by Jocelyn Moorhouse, based on the novel of the same name by Rosalie Ham.', \"The CONTEXT mentions that Caroline Cruice Goodall's other film appearances include 'The Dressmaker' (2015), which matches the criteria specified in the QUESTION.\", \"The MODEL OUTPUT states that the film Caroline Cruice Goodall starred in is 'The Dressmaker', which is directly supported by the CONTEXT.\"" ]

{ "_id": 9510, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the Australian television series that Marcia Gardner worked on and that premiered on ABC TV on 1 February 2013 at 8:30 pm.', 'The context provides a list of TV shows that Marcia Gardner has worked on, including The Doctor Blake Mysteries.', \"The context specifically states that The Doctor Blake Mysteries premiered on ABC TV on 1 February 2013 at 8:30 pm.\", 'The model output is The Doctor Blake Mysteries, which matches the information provided in the context about the show premiering on the specified date and time.', 'Therefore, the answer is faithful to the context given the question.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the Australian television series that Marcia Gardner worked on and that premiered on ABC TV on 1 February 2013 at 8:30 pm.", "The context provides a list of TV shows that Marcia Gardner has worked on, including The Doctor Blake Mysteries.', \"The context specifically states that The Doctor Blake Mysteries premiered on ABC TV on 1 February 2013 at 8:30 pm.\", 'The model output is The Doctor Blake Mysteries, which matches the information provided in the context about the show premiering on the specified date and time.", "Therefore, the answer is faithful to the context given the question.'" ]

{ "_id": 226, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT provides the locations of two airports: Luis Muñoz Marín International Airport in Puerto Rico and Rickenbacker International Airport in Ohio.', 'The CONTEXT specifies that Rickenbacker International Airport is located 10 mi south of downtown Columbus, Ohio.', 'The CONTEXT does not provide the distance from either airport to Cleveland, Ohio.', 'The MODEL OUTPUT states that Luis Muñoz Marín International Airport is closer to Cleveland, which is incorrect based on the information provided in the CONTEXT.', 'The correct comparison should be between the distances from Rickenbacker International Airport to Cleveland, Ohio, and Luis Muñoz Marín International Airport to Cleveland, Ohio, which are not provided in the CONTEXT.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT provides the locations of two airports: Luis Muñoz Marín International Airport in Puerto Rico and Rickenbacker International Airport in Ohio.", "The CONTEXT specifies that Rickenbacker International Airport is located 10 mi south of downtown Columbus, Ohio.", "The CONTEXT does not provide the distance from either airport to Cleveland, Ohio.", "The MODEL OUTPUT states that Luis Muñoz Marín International Airport is closer to Cleveland, which is incorrect based on the information provided in the CONTEXT.", "The correct comparison should be between the distances from Rickenbacker International Airport to Cleveland, Ohio, and Luis Muñoz Marín International Airport to Cleveland, Ohio, which are not provided in the CONTEXT.'" ]

{ "_id": 9483, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT mentions that Quinn Norton covers topics such as hacker culture, Anonymous, Occupy movement, intellectual property, and copyright issues.', 'The CONTEXT specifically states that Quinn Norton is associated with hacker culture.', \"The QUESTION asks about the type of culture written about in the magazine and website formerly known as boot.\", 'Given the CONTEXT, which highlights Quinn Norton\\'s focus on hacker culture, and the QUESTION, which asks about the type of culture written about, the answer should be hacker culture.', \"The CHANGE_MADE altered the original answer from 'hacker culture' to'mainstream culture', which is not supported by the CONTEXT.\", \"Therefore, the answer'mainstream culture' is not faithful to the CONTEXT, as it does not align with the information provided about Quinn Norton's coverage of hacker culture.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT mentions that Quinn Norton covers topics such as hacker culture, Anonymous, Occupy movement, intellectual property, and copyright issues.", "The CONTEXT specifically states that Quinn Norton is associated with hacker culture.', \"The QUESTION asks about the type of culture written about in the magazine and website formerly known as boot.\", 'Given the CONTEXT, which highlights Quinn Norton\\'s focus on hacker culture, and the QUESTION, which asks about the type of culture written about, the answer should be hacker culture.', \"The CHANGE_MADE altered the original answer from 'hacker culture' to'mainstream culture', which is not supported by the CONTEXT.\", \"Therefore, the answer'mainstream culture' is not faithful to the CONTEXT, as it does not align with the information provided about Quinn Norton's coverage of hacker culture.\"" ]

{ "_id": 3000, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the name of a 2007 film in which an Australian actress who starred in Extinction played a significant role.', \"The context provides information about a film called 'Introducing the Dwights' and mentions that it stars an Australian actress who played a significant role alongside Brenda Blethyn.\", \"The context also mentions that the Australian actress, Lizzy Caplan, played a significant role in the 2007 film 'Introducing the Dwights'.\", \"The answer 'Introducing the Dwights' correctly matches the information provided in the context about the 2007 film in which Lizzy Caplan, the Australian actress from Extinction, played a significant role.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the name of a 2007 film in which an Australian actress who starred in Extinction played a significant role.', \"The context provides information about a film called 'Introducing the Dwights' and mentions that it stars an Australian actress who played a significant role alongside Brenda Blethyn.\", \"The context also mentions that the Australian actress, Lizzy Caplan, played a significant role in the 2007 film 'Introducing the Dwights'.\", \"The answer 'Introducing the Dwights' correctly matches the information provided in the context about the 2007 film in which Lizzy Caplan, the Australian actress from Extinction, played a significant role.\"" ]

{ "_id": 7394, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the birth year of Maggie Cheung.', 'The context provides the birth date of Maggie Cheung as 20 September 1964.', 'The birth date includes the year 1964, which is the relevant information for the question.', \"The model output '20 September 1964' includes the birth date, but not the birth year, which is 1964.\", 'Therefore, the model output is not faithful to the context because it does not explicitly state the birth year, which is the information requested.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks for the birth year of Maggie Cheung.", "The context provides the birth date of Maggie Cheung as 20 September 1964.", "The birth date includes the year 1964, which is the relevant information for the question.', \"The model output '20 September 1964' includes the birth date, but not the birth year, which is 1964.\", 'Therefore, the model output is not faithful to the context because it does not explicitly state the birth year, which is the information requested.'" ]

{ "_id": 4044, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the population in 2010 of the city where the Mount Moriah Cemetery is located.', 'The context provides that the population of Deadwood, where the cemetery is located, was 1,270 according to the 2010 census.', 'The answer states the population was 1,300, which does not match the information given in the context.', 'Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context because it inaccurately states the population as 1,300 instead of the correct 1,270.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks for the population in 2010 of the city where the Mount Moriah Cemetery is located.", "The context provides that the population of Deadwood, where the cemetery is located, was 1,270 according to the 2010 census.", "The answer states the population was 1,300, which does not match the information given in the context.", "Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context because it inaccurately states the population as 1,300 instead of the correct 1,270.'" ]

{ "_id": 1138, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks specifically about the 54th Disney animated feature film.', 'The context mentions that Rayan Potter voiced Hiro Hamada in the film \"Big Hero 6\", which is the 54th Disney animated feature film.', \"However, the context does not confirm that Rayan Potter's role in the 54th film was Hiro Hamada.\", 'The context only states Potter's role in \"Big Hero 6\" but does not directly link him to the 54th film.', \"The answer 'Hiro Hamada' is not directly supported by the context as it pertains to a specific film, not the 54th film mentioned in the question.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks specifically about the 54th Disney animated feature film.", "The context mentions that Rayan Potter voiced Hiro Hamada in the film \"Big Hero 6\", which is the 54th Disney animated feature film.', \"However, the context does not confirm that Rayan Potter's role in the 54th film was Hiro Hamada.\", 'The context only states Potter's role in \"Big Hero 6\" but does not directly link him to the 54th film.', \"The answer 'Hiro Hamada' is not directly supported by the context as it pertains to a specific film, not the 54th film mentioned in the question.\"" ]

{ "_id": 5587, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the name of the tornado outbreak that was referred to as the Widespread Outbreak and was the second-largest tornado outbreak on record for a single 24-hour period, just behind the 2011 Super Outbreak.', \"The context originally states that this outbreak was called the '1974 Super Outbreak'.\", \"The model output provided is '1974 Super Outbreak', which matches the information given in the context.\", 'However, the context was later modified to state that the 1974 event was actually referred to as the 'Super Outbreak of 1974', not just '1974 Super Outbreak'.', \"The model output does not reflect this change, as it still uses the original name provided in the context.\", 'Therefore, the model output is not faithful to the context in its current form, as it does not accurately reflect the name change made to the 1974 event.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the name of the tornado outbreak that was referred to as the Widespread Outbreak and was the second-largest tornado outbreak on record for a single 24-hour period, just behind the 2011 Super Outbreak.', \"The context originally states that this outbreak was called the '1974 Super Outbreak'.\", \"The model output provided is '1974 Super Outbreak', which matches the information given in the context.\", 'However, the context was later modified to state that the 1974 event was actually referred to as the 'Super Outbreak of 1974', not just '1974 Super Outbreak'.', \"The model output does not reflect this change, as it still uses the original name provided in the context.\", 'Therefore, the model output is not faithful to the context in its current form, as it does not accurately reflect the name change made to the 1974 event.'" ]

{ "_id": 1866, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT specifies that Clarence Charles \"Ducky\" Nash, the creator of the voice of Donald Duck, was born in Watonga, Oklahoma.', 'The MODEL incorrectly states that he was born in Enid, Oklahoma, which is not supported by the CONTEXT.', 'The CONTEXT does not mention any connection between Enid, Oklahoma, and the birthplace of Clarence Nash.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT specifies that Clarence Charles \"Ducky\" Nash, the creator of the voice of Donald Duck, was born in Watonga, Oklahoma.", "The MODEL incorrectly states that he was born in Enid, Oklahoma, which is not supported by the CONTEXT.", "The CONTEXT does not mention any connection between Enid, Oklahoma, and the birthplace of Clarence Nash.'" ]

{ "_id": 2376, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks who has won more Pulitzer Prizes between Thomas Friedman and Colson Whitehead.', 'The context provides information that Thomas Friedman is a three-time Pulitzer Prize winner.', 'The context also mentions that Colson Whitehead is a two-time Pulitzer Prize winner, having won the 2017 Pulitzer Prize for Fiction for \"The Underground Railroad\" and the 2020 Pulitzer Prize for Fiction for \"The Nickel Boys\".', 'Comparing the numbers, Thomas Friedman has won three Pulitzer Prizes, while Colson Whitehead has won two.', 'Therefore, Thomas Friedman has won more Pulitzer Prizes than Colson Whitehead.', \"The model's output, 'Thomas Loren Friedman', is incorrect because it incorrectly states the winner's first name as 'Loren', which is not mentioned in the context. The correct answer should only state 'Thomas Friedman'.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks who has won more Pulitzer Prizes between Thomas Friedman and Colson Whitehead.", "The context provides information that Thomas Friedman is a three-time Pulitzer Prize winner.", "The context also mentions that Colson Whitehead is a two-time Pulitzer Prize winner, having won the 2017 Pulitzer Prize for Fiction for \"The Underground Railroad\" and the 2020 Pulitzer Prize for Fiction for \"The Nickel Boys\".", "Comparing the numbers, Thomas Friedman has won three Pulitzer Prizes, while Colson Whitehead has won two.", "Therefore, Thomas Friedman has won more Pulitzer Prizes than Colson Whitehead.', \"The model's output, 'Thomas Loren Friedman', is incorrect because it incorrectly states the winner's first name as 'Loren', which is not mentioned in the context. The correct answer should only state 'Thomas Friedman'.\"" ]

{ "_id": 5237, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT specifies that the 9th FINA Swimming World Championships (25 m) were held at the Manchester Arena in Manchester, United Kingdom.', \"The CONTEXT describes the Manchester Arena as 'an indoor arena' in Manchester, England.\", \"The MODEL OUTPUT states that the championships were held in an outdoor arena, which contradicts the information provided in the CONTEXT.\", 'Since the CONTEXT clearly indicates that the arena is indoor, the MODEL OUTPUT should have correctly identified it as an indoor arena.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT specifies that the 9th FINA Swimming World Championships (25 m) were held at the Manchester Arena in Manchester, United Kingdom.', \"The CONTEXT describes the Manchester Arena as 'an indoor arena' in Manchester, England.\", \"The MODEL OUTPUT states that the championships were held in an outdoor arena, which contradicts the information provided in the CONTEXT.\", 'Since the CONTEXT clearly indicates that the arena is indoor, the MODEL OUTPUT should have correctly identified it as an indoor arena.'" ]

{ "_id": 9161, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the Minnesota county where Jeff Nielsen was born.', 'The context provides that Jeff Nielsen was born in Grand Rapids, Minnesota.', 'The context further states that Grand Rapids is a city in Itasca County, Minnesota.', \"Therefore, the correct answer should be 'Itasca County' as it is explicitly mentioned in the context.\", \"The model's output 'St. Louis County' is incorrect because it does not match the information provided in the context.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks for the Minnesota county where Jeff Nielsen was born.", "The context provides that Jeff Nielsen was born in Grand Rapids, Minnesota.", "The context further states that Grand Rapids is a city in Itasca County, Minnesota.', \"Therefore, the correct answer should be 'Itasca County' as it is explicitly mentioned in the context.\", \"The model's output 'St. Louis County' is incorrect because it does not match the information provided in the context.\"" ]

{ "_id": 3667, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The context specifies that The Lowry Hotel is located in Salford, Greater Manchester, England.', 'The context does not mention that The Lowry Hotel is in Manchester, only that it is in Greater Manchester.', 'The model output incorrectly states that The Lowry Hotel is in Manchester, which is not supported by the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The context specifies that The Lowry Hotel is located in Salford, Greater Manchester, England.", "The context does not mention that The Lowry Hotel is in Manchester, only that it is in Greater Manchester.", "The model output incorrectly states that The Lowry Hotel is in Manchester, which is not supported by the context.'" ]

{ "_id": 6973, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The question asks about the time period when Reinhold Niebuhr wrote 'Moral Man and Immoral Society' and argued Christian Realism.\", \"The context states that Christian Realism was developed by Reinhold Niebuhr in the late 1940s and early 1950s.\", \"The context also mentions that 'Moral Man and Immoral Society' is one of Niebuhr's influential books, but it does not specify the exact time period when the book was written.\", \"The model output 'the twentieth century' is too broad as it encompasses the entire century, rather than focusing on the specific decades mentioned in the context (late 1940s and early 1950s).\", \"Therefore, the answer 'the twentieth century' is not faithful to the context, which clearly specifies the time period during which Niebuhr developed Christian Realism and wrote 'Moral Man and Immoral Society'.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "\"The question asks about the time period when Reinhold Niebuhr wrote 'Moral Man and Immoral Society' and argued Christian Realism.\", \"The context states that Christian Realism was developed by Reinhold Niebuhr in the late 1940s and early 1950s.\", \"The context also mentions that 'Moral Man and Immoral Society' is one of Niebuhr's influential books, but it does not specify the exact time period when the book was written.\", \"The model output 'the twentieth century' is too broad as it encompasses the entire century, rather than focusing on the specific decades mentioned in the context (late 1940s and early 1950s).\", \"Therefore, the answer 'the twentieth century' is not faithful to the context, which clearly specifies the time period during which Niebuhr developed Christian Realism and wrote 'Moral Man and Immoral Society'.\"" ]

{ "_id": 678, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT mentions that Priscilla Presley, who was a former partner of Marco Garibaldi, is an American actress and business magnate.', \"Since Priscilla Presley's nationality is American, it implies that her former partner, Marco Garibaldi, was also American.\", \"The term 'Italian-American' suggests a dual nationality of Italian and American, which is not supported by the CONTEXT.\", \"The CONTEXT does not provide any information about Marco Garibaldi's nationality being Italian or having Italian ancestry.\", 'Therefore, the answer stating that Marco Garibaldi's former partner was Italian-American is not faithful to the CONTEXT.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT mentions that Priscilla Presley, who was a former partner of Marco Garibaldi, is an American actress and business magnate.', \"Since Priscilla Presley's nationality is American, it implies that her former partner, Marco Garibaldi, was also American.\", \"The term 'Italian-American' suggests a dual nationality of Italian and American, which is not supported by the CONTEXT.\", \"The CONTEXT does not provide any information about Marco Garibaldi's nationality being Italian or having Italian ancestry.\", 'Therefore, the answer stating that Marco Garibaldi's former partner was Italian-American is not faithful to the CONTEXT.'" ]

{ "_id": 5260, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The context specifies that Deccan Airways merged with Indian Airlines in 1953, not TATA airline.\", 'The mention of TATA airline in the answer is incorrect as it does not align with the information provided in the context.', 'The correct merger, as per the context, is between Deccan Airways and Indian Airlines, not TATA airline.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "\"The context specifies that Deccan Airways merged with Indian Airlines in 1953, not TATA airline.\", 'The mention of TATA airline in the answer is incorrect as it does not align with the information provided in the context.", "The correct merger, as per the context, is between Deccan Airways and Indian Airlines, not TATA airline.'" ]

{ "_id": 8560, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the birth year of Jane Birkin, which is 1946.', 'The context provides the specific date of birth as 14 December 1946.', 'The answer provided is 14 December 1947, which is incorrect.', 'The correct answer should be 14 December 1946, as per the context given.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks for the birth year of Jane Birkin, which is 1946.", "The context provides the specific date of birth as 14 December 1946.", "The answer provided is 14 December 1947, which is incorrect.", "The correct answer should be 14 December 1946, as per the context given.'" ]

{ "_id": 6244, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the name of the former professional boxer who won his first 19 professional fights by knockout.', 'The context provides information about Mike Tyson, stating that he won his first 19 professional fights by knockout.', 'The context also mentions that Danny Williams scored an upset knockout victory against Mike Tyson in 2004.', 'Therefore, the answer Michael Gerard Tyson correctly identifies the boxer who won his first 19 fights by knockout, as mentioned in the context.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the name of the former professional boxer who won his first 19 professional fights by knockout.", "The context provides information about Mike Tyson, stating that he won his first 19 professional fights by knockout.", "The context also mentions that Danny Williams scored an upset knockout victory against Mike Tyson in 2004.", "Therefore, the answer Michael Gerard Tyson correctly identifies the boxer who won his first 19 fights by knockout, as mentioned in the context.'" ]

{ "_id": 6171, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the birth date of the American football coach and former player who led the 2016 Penn State Nittany Lions football team in their third year.', 'The context provides that the coach who led the team in their third year is James Franklin.', 'The context also states that James Franklin was born on February 2, 1972.', \"The model output 'February 2, 1972' matches the birth date provided in the context for James Franklin.\", 'Therefore, the answer is faithful to the context given the question.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the birth date of the American football coach and former player who led the 2016 Penn State Nittany Lions football team in their third year.", "The context provides that the coach who led the team in their third year is James Franklin.", "The context also states that James Franklin was born on February 2, 1972.', \"The model output 'February 2, 1972' matches the birth date provided in the context for James Franklin.\", 'Therefore, the answer is faithful to the context given the question.'" ]

{ "_id": 3622, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The context states that Beatrice Willard served as an adviser to U.S. presidents Nixon and Ford.', 'Richard Nixon was the 37th President of the United States, serving from 1969 to 1974.', 'The context mentions that Nixon had previously served as a U.S. Senator from California, indicating his tenure as a Senator from California.', \"Given the question asks for the President that served as a Senator from California, and the context specifies Nixon's role as a Senator from California, it is faithful to conclude that Beatrice Willard advised President Nixon.\", \"The model output incorrectly states that Beatrice Willard never advised President Nixon, which contradicts the information provided in the context.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The context states that Beatrice Willard served as an adviser to U.S. presidents Nixon and Ford.", "Richard Nixon was the 37th President of the United States, serving from 1969 to 1974.", "The context mentions that Nixon had previously served as a U.S. Senator from California, indicating his tenure as a Senator from California.', \"Given the question asks for the President that served as a Senator from California, and the context specifies Nixon's role as a Senator from California, it is faithful to conclude that Beatrice Willard advised President Nixon.\", \"The model output incorrectly states that Beatrice Willard never advised President Nixon, which contradicts the information provided in the context.\"" ]

{ "_id": 2769, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the actor who starred in The Last Run and as a guest in the episode The Arsenal of Freedom.', 'The context provides information that Vyto Ruginis was part of the lead roles in The Last Run.', 'The context also states that Vyto Ruginis guest-starred in the episode The Arsenal of Freedom.', 'Therefore, Vyto Ruginis is the correct answer as he fulfills both criteria mentioned in the question.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'The question asks for the actor who starred in The Last Run and as a guest in the episode The Arsenal of Freedom.", "The context provides information that Vyto Ruginis was part of the lead roles in The Last Run.", "The context also states that Vyto Ruginis guest-starred in the episode The Arsenal of Freedom.", "Therefore, Vyto Ruginis is the correct answer as he fulfills both criteria mentioned in the question.'" ]

{ "_id": 7946, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the name of a British cinematographer who worked on a superhero action film starring Joel Kinnaman as the title character.', 'The context provides information that the film stars Joel Kinnaman as the title character, but it does not specify the cinematographer.', 'The context mentions that Lula Carvalho is a Brazilian cinematographer, not British.', \"The model output, Lula Carvalho, does not match the criteria of being a British cinematographer as specified in the question.\", 'No British cinematographer is mentioned or identified in the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The question asks for the name of a British cinematographer who worked on a superhero action film starring Joel Kinnaman as the title character.", "The context provides information that the film stars Joel Kinnaman as the title character, but it does not specify the cinematographer.", "The context mentions that Lula Carvalho is a Brazilian cinematographer, not British.', \"The model output, Lula Carvalho, does not match the criteria of being a British cinematographer as specified in the question.\", 'No British cinematographer is mentioned or identified in the context.'" ]

{ "_id": 717, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The CONTEXT clearly states that 'Zaalima' is a song from the film 'Raees'.\", \"The CONTEXT provides detailed information about 'Raees', including its release year (2017), genre (crime action), and production details.\", \"The CONTEXT specifically mentions that 'Zaalima' is written by Amitabh Bhattacharya, which is the requirement given in the QUESTION.\", \"The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that 'Zaalima' is from 'Jab Harry Met Sejal', which is a different film and does not match the details provided in the CONTEXT.\", 'Therefore, the MODEL OUTPUT is not faithful to the CONTEXT.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "\"The CONTEXT clearly states that 'Zaalima' is a song from the film 'Raees'.\", \"The CONTEXT provides detailed information about 'Raees', including its release year (2017), genre (crime action), and production details.\", \"The CONTEXT specifically mentions that 'Zaalima' is written by Amitabh Bhattacharya, which is the requirement given in the QUESTION.\", \"The MODEL OUTPUT incorrectly states that 'Zaalima' is from 'Jab Harry Met Sejal', which is a different film and does not match the details provided in the CONTEXT.\", 'Therefore, the MODEL OUTPUT is not faithful to the CONTEXT.'" ]

{ "_id": 9412, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['Amesiella is endemic to the Island of Luzon in the Philippines, which is located in Southeast Asia.', 'Rhaphidophora occurs from tropical Africa eastwards through Malesia and Australasia to the Western Pacific.', \"The term 'Western Pacific' in the context of Rhaphidophora's distribution refers to the Pacific Ocean west of the International Date Line, which includes countries such as Indonesia, Malaysia, and the Philippines.\", 'Both Amesiella and Rhaphidophora can be found in the Philippines, which is within the region described by the term \"Western Pacific\" in Rhaphidophora\\'s distribution.', \"Therefore, the answer 'yes' is faithful to the context as both genera are found in the same region, the Western Pacific, despite their different specific distributions within that region.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'Amesiella is endemic to the Island of Luzon in the Philippines, which is located in Southeast Asia.", "Rhaphidophora occurs from tropical Africa eastwards through Malesia and Australasia to the Western Pacific.', \"The term 'Western Pacific' in the context of Rhaphidophora's distribution refers to the Pacific Ocean west of the International Date Line, which includes countries such as Indonesia, Malaysia, and the Philippines.\", 'Both Amesiella and Rhaphidophora can be found in the Philippines, which is within the region described by the term \"Western Pacific\" in Rhaphidophora\\'s distribution.', \"Therefore, the answer 'yes' is faithful to the context as both genera are found in the same region, the Western Pacific, despite their different specific distributions within that region.\"" ]

{ "_id": 4280, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": [\"The context explicitly states that 'Hot Tub' was voted 'Best Variety Show' by Time-Out New York's reader poll in 2005.\", \"The context does not mention any variety show starring Kristen Schaal being voted 'Best Variety Show' in 2003 or any other year except 2005.\", \"The model's answer incorrectly states the year as 2003, which is not supported by the context.\", \"The correct information from the context is that the show 'Hot Tub' starring Kristen Schaal was voted 'Best Variety Show' in 2005.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "\"The context explicitly states that 'Hot Tub' was voted 'Best Variety Show' by Time-Out New York's reader poll in 2005.\", \"The context does not mention any variety show starring Kristen Schaal being voted 'Best Variety Show' in 2003 or any other year except 2005.\", \"The model's answer incorrectly states the year as 2003, which is not supported by the context.\", \"The correct information from the context is that the show 'Hot Tub' starring Kristen Schaal was voted 'Best Variety Show' in 2005.\"" ]

{ "_id": 9304, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['Heuchera is described as a genus of evergreen, herbaceous perennial plants.', 'Glottiphyllum is described as a genus of succulent subtropical plants.', \"Both descriptions indicate that Heuchera and Glottiphyllum are types of plants.\", 'The context does not mention any evidence that Heuchera or Glottiphyllum are animals or fungi.', \"Therefore, the statement that Heuchera and Glottiphyllum mark different types of living organisms is faithful to the context, as both are clearly plants.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'Heuchera is described as a genus of evergreen, herbaceous perennial plants.", "Glottiphyllum is described as a genus of succulent subtropical plants.', \"Both descriptions indicate that Heuchera and Glottiphyllum are types of plants.\", 'The context does not mention any evidence that Heuchera or Glottiphyllum are animals or fungi.', \"Therefore, the statement that Heuchera and Glottiphyllum mark different types of living organisms is faithful to the context, as both are clearly plants.\"" ]

{ "_id": 9407, "label": "FAIL", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT specifies that the director of White Noise: A Cautionary Musical is Sergio Trujillo.', 'The CONTEXT states that Sergio Trujillo was the recipient of the 2015 Laurence Olivier Award for Best Theatre Choreographer.', 'The MODEL incorrectly states that the director is a woman, which contradicts the CONTEXT.', 'The MODEL also incorrectly states that the show received a Tony Award in 2015, which is not supported by the CONTEXT. The CONTEXT mentions the Laurence Olivier Award, not the Tony Award.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}" }

[ "'The CONTEXT specifies that the director of White Noise: A Cautionary Musical is Sergio Trujillo.", "The CONTEXT states that Sergio Trujillo was the recipient of the 2015 Laurence Olivier Award for Best Theatre Choreographer.", "The MODEL incorrectly states that the director is a woman, which contradicts the CONTEXT.", "The MODEL also incorrectly states that the show received a Tony Award in 2015, which is not supported by the CONTEXT. The CONTEXT mentions the Laurence Olivier Award, not the Tony Award.'" ]

{ "_id": 3217, "label": "PASS", "text": "{\"REASONING\": ['Irving Wallace was an American writer.', 'Muriel Spark was a Scottish writer.', 'The countries mentioned are the United States (for Irving Wallace) and Scotland/United Kingdom (for Muriel Spark).', 'The question asks whether the two writers were in the same country, which is answered as no because they were from different countries.', \"The context supports the answer 'no' by providing the nationalities of the writers: American for Irving Wallace and Scottish/British for Muriel Spark.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}" }

[ "'Irving Wallace was an American writer.", "Muriel Spark was a Scottish writer.", "The countries mentioned are the United States (for Irving Wallace) and Scotland/United Kingdom (for Muriel Spark).", "The question asks whether the two writers were in the same country, which is answered as no because they were from different countries.', \"The context supports the answer 'no' by providing the nationalities of the writers: American for Irving Wallace and Scottish/British for Muriel Spark.\"" ]