Datasets:

PatronusAI

/

evaluation-drop-test-mistral-instruct-7b-drop-ragtruth-covidqa-pubmed-2zNoTE

like 0

{ "_id": "d3fb4c3c-d21b-480a-baa0-98d6d0d17c1d", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the team that scored the longest field goal kick of the game.', 'The context mentions two field goals: one by Lawrence Tynes (42 yards) and another by Jeff Wilkins (41 yards).', 'The 42-yard field goal by Lawrence Tynes is the longest field goal mentioned in the context.', 'The answer incorrectly states that the Rams scored the longest field goal, which is incorrect as it was Lawrence Tynes who scored the longest field goal.', 'The answer also incorrectly lists Marc Bulger and Kevin Curtis, who scored a touchdown, not a field goal, and did not score the longest field goal in the game.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the team that scored the longest field goal kick of the game.", "The context mentions two field goals: one by Lawrence Tynes (42 yards) and another by Jeff Wilkins (41 yards).", "The 42-yard field goal by Lawrence Tynes is the longest field goal mentioned in the context.", "The answer incorrectly states that the Rams scored the longest field goal, which is incorrect as it was Lawrence Tynes who scored the longest field goal.", "The answer also incorrectly lists Marc Bulger and Kevin Curtis, who scored a touchdown, not a field goal, and did not score the longest field goal in the game.'" ]

{ "_id": "8603663e-c53b-46db-a482-a867f12ff3b4", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not Irish.', 'The context provides that 13.1% of the population were of Irish ancestry.', 'To find the percentage of the population that were not Irish, one would subtract the percentage of Irish ancestry from 100%.', '100% - 13.1% = 86.9%.', 'The answer provided is 87.1%, which does not match the calculated value of 86.9%.', 'Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context as it slightly overestimates the percentage of non-Irish residents.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not Irish.", "The context provides that 13.1% of the population were of Irish ancestry.", "To find the percentage of the population that were not Irish, one would subtract the percentage of Irish ancestry from 100%.", "100% - 13.1% = 86.9%.", "The answer provided is 87.1%, which does not match the calculated value of 86.9%.", "Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context as it slightly overestimates the percentage of non-Irish residents.'" ]

{ "_id": "c63a73e5-2c91-489b-bd24-af150ddfa82c", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the second longest field goal of the first half.', 'The context mentions two field goals: one by Lawrence Tynes for 42 yards and another by Jeff Wilkins for 41 yards.', 'Since 42 yards is longer than 41 yards, the 42-yard field goal by Lawrence Tynes is the longest field goal of the first half.', 'Therefore, the second longest field goal of the first half is the 41-yard field goal by Jeff Wilkins.', 'The answer provided (42) incorrectly identifies the longest field goal as the second longest.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the second longest field goal of the first half.", "The context mentions two field goals: one by Lawrence Tynes for 42 yards and another by Jeff Wilkins for 41 yards.", "Since 42 yards is longer than 41 yards, the 42-yard field goal by Lawrence Tynes is the longest field goal of the first half.", "Therefore, the second longest field goal of the first half is the 41-yard field goal by Jeff Wilkins.", "The answer provided (42) incorrectly identifies the longest field goal as the second longest.'" ]

{ "_id": "52db14ed-5426-46ec-b0ae-4ef843b2d692", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question specifically asks for the length of the last touchdown.', 'The context mentions several touchdowns, including a 60-yard TD run by Leon Washington, an 11-yard TD pass to Mark Bradley, and a 15-yard TD pass to Laveranues Coles.', 'The last touchdown mentioned in the context is the 15-yard TD pass from Brett Favre to Laveranues Coles.', \"The answer provided, '18-yard', does not match any of the touchdown lengths mentioned in the context.\", \"The correct answer should be '15-yard' based on the sequence of events described in the context.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question specifically asks for the length of the last touchdown.", "The context mentions several touchdowns, including a 60-yard TD run by Leon Washington, an 11-yard TD pass to Mark Bradley, and a 15-yard TD pass to Laveranues Coles.", "The last touchdown mentioned in the context is the 15-yard TD pass from Brett Favre to Laveranues Coles.', \"The answer provided, '18-yard', does not match any of the touchdown lengths mentioned in the context.\", \"The correct answer should be '15-yard' based on the sequence of events described in the context.\"" ]

{ "_id": "31b36417-aad1-412c-b0e5-9c1faaed233f", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not Irish.', 'The context provides that 13.1% of the population were of Irish ancestry.', 'To find the percentage of the population that were not Irish, one would subtract the percentage of Irish ancestry from 100%.', '100% - 13.1% = 86.9%.', 'The answer provided is 87.1%, which does not match the calculated value of 86.9%.', 'Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context as it slightly overestimates the percentage of non-Irish residents.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not Irish.", "The context provides that 13.1% of the population were of Irish ancestry.", "To find the percentage of the population that were not Irish, one would subtract the percentage of Irish ancestry from 100%.", "100% - 13.1% = 86.9%.", "The answer provided is 87.1%, which does not match the calculated value of 86.9%.", "Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context as it slightly overestimates the percentage of non-Irish residents.'" ]

{ "_id": "57d6f476-5163-4069-baab-b53504a3e662", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the difference in the number of men registered between 1917 and 1918.', 'According to the context, 10 million men were registered in 1917.', 'By the end of 1918, the number of registered men increased to 24 million.', 'The difference between the number of men registered in 1917 and 1918 is 24 million - 10 million = 14 million.', 'The answer provided is 15 million, which is incorrect.', 'The correct answer should be 14 million, not 15 million.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the difference in the number of men registered between 1917 and 1918.", "According to the context, 10 million men were registered in 1917.", "By the end of 1918, the number of registered men increased to 24 million.", "The difference between the number of men registered in 1917 and 1918 is 24 million - 10 million = 14 million.", "The answer provided is 15 million, which is incorrect.", "The correct answer should be 14 million, not 15 million.'" ]

{ "_id": "81da46e1-384f-4026-8b02-0c7b48fe5899", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question specifically asks for the yardage of the two shortest touchdowns of the first half.', 'From the context, the touchdowns mentioned for the first half are: Larry Johnson\\'s 1-yard TD run, Damon Huard\\'s 3-yard TD pass to Tony Gonzalez, and Steven Jackson\\'s 2-yard TD run.', 'Comparing the yardages of these touchdowns, Larry Johnson\\'s 1-yard TD run is the shortest at 1 yard.', 'Steven Jackson\\'s 2-yard TD run is the second shortest at 2 yards.', 'Damon Huard\\'s 3-yard TD pass to Tony Gonzalez is longer than both of these at 3 yards.', 'Therefore, the two shortest touchdowns of the first half are Larry Johnson\\'s 1-yard TD run and Steven Jackson\\'s 2-yard TD run, which are correctly identified in the answer.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}\n" }

[ "'The question specifically asks for the yardage of the two shortest touchdowns of the first half.", "From the context, the touchdowns mentioned for the first half are: Larry Johnson\\'s 1-yard TD run, Damon Huard\\'s 3-yard TD pass to Tony Gonzalez, and Steven Jackson\\'s 2-yard TD run.", "Comparing the yardages of these touchdowns, Larry Johnson\\'s 1-yard TD run is the shortest at 1 yard.", "Steven Jackson\\'s 2-yard TD run is the second shortest at 2 yards.", "Damon Huard\\'s 3-yard TD pass to Tony Gonzalez is longer than both of these at 3 yards.", "Therefore, the two shortest touchdowns of the first half are Larry Johnson\\'s 1-yard TD run and Steven Jackson\\'s 2-yard TD run, which are correctly identified in the answer.'" ]

{ "_id": "5b3b919d-6895-43ec-a065-6de13ac56e2f", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT provides the number of households as 79,667 and the number of families as 60,387.', 'To find how many more households there are than families, subtract the number of families from the number of households: 79,667 - 60,387 = 19,280.', 'The ANSWER provided is 19,300, which does not match the correct calculation of 19,280.', 'Therefore, the ANSWER is incorrect because it does not accurately reflect the difference calculated directly from the numbers given in the CONTEXT.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The CONTEXT provides the number of households as 79,667 and the number of families as 60,387.", "To find how many more households there are than families, subtract the number of families from the number of households: 79,667 - 60,387 = 19,280.", "The ANSWER provided is 19,300, which does not match the correct calculation of 19,280.", "Therefore, the ANSWER is incorrect because it does not accurately reflect the difference calculated directly from the numbers given in the CONTEXT.'" ]

{ "_id": "78f47611-5119-42dc-af43-f40dcfd6fe96", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT provides the number of households as 79,667 and the number of families as 60,387.', 'To find how many more households there are than families, subtract the number of families from the number of households: 79,667 - 60,387 = 19,280.', 'The ANSWER provided is 19,300, which does not match the correct calculation of 19,280.', 'Therefore, the ANSWER is incorrect because it does not accurately reflect the difference calculated directly from the numbers given in the CONTEXT.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The CONTEXT provides the number of households as 79,667 and the number of families as 60,387.", "To find how many more households there are than families, subtract the number of families from the number of households: 79,667 - 60,387 = 19,280.", "The ANSWER provided is 19,300, which does not match the correct calculation of 19,280.", "Therefore, the ANSWER is incorrect because it does not accurately reflect the difference calculated directly from the numbers given in the CONTEXT.'" ]

{ "_id": "4a549e4a-b934-400e-960b-7acd4d920d9e", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The Dutch first invaded Brazil in 1624, capturing the city of São Salvador da Bahia.', 'The Dutch were expelled from São Salvador da Bahia in 1625 by a joint Spanish-Portuguese fleet.', 'The Dutch returned to Brazil in 1630, capturing Olinda and then Recife, and established the colony of New Holland.', 'The time span between the initial invasion in 1624 and the establishment of New Holland in 1630 is 6 years.', \"The answer '6' correctly represents the number of years between the Dutch defeat in Brazil and their return.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The Dutch first invaded Brazil in 1624, capturing the city of São Salvador da Bahia.", "The Dutch were expelled from São Salvador da Bahia in 1625 by a joint Spanish-Portuguese fleet.", "The Dutch returned to Brazil in 1630, capturing Olinda and then Recife, and established the colony of New Holland.", "The time span between the initial invasion in 1624 and the establishment of New Holland in 1630 is 6 years.', \"The answer '6' correctly represents the number of years between the Dutch defeat in Brazil and their return.\"" ]

{ "_id": "e1afeb0e-9ad7-4733-bcc2-c977344de287", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question specifically asks for the number of yards Hanson scored with in the first quarter.', 'The context mentions that Jason Hanson scored first in the first quarter with a 23-yard field goal.', \"The answer provided, '28', actually refers to the number of yards scored by the Lions in the first quarter, not specifically by Hanson.\", \"The answer should have been '23' yards based on the context provided, not '28'.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question specifically asks for the number of yards Hanson scored with in the first quarter.", "The context mentions that Jason Hanson scored first in the first quarter with a 23-yard field goal.', \"The answer provided, '28', actually refers to the number of yards scored by the Lions in the first quarter, not specifically by Hanson.\", \"The answer should have been '23' yards based on the context provided, not '28'.\"" ]

{ "_id": "2d560a12-2b8f-4c4f-9c9f-85e7a73114f5", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context clearly states that the final score of the game was 24-17 in favor of New Orleans.', 'The difference between 24 and 17 is 7, indicating that New Orleans defeated Tampa Bay by 7 points.', 'The answer provided, which is 7, directly matches the difference calculated from the scores mentioned in the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context clearly states that the final score of the game was 24-17 in favor of New Orleans.", "The difference between 24 and 17 is 7, indicating that New Orleans defeated Tampa Bay by 7 points.", "The answer provided, which is 7, directly matches the difference calculated from the scores mentioned in the context.'" ]

{ "_id": "70ff6095-aab3-45ad-83d0-03a302345f66", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context describes the scoring events in the first quarter: Pittsburgh scored a touchdown (6 points, excluding extra point) and the Browns scored a touchdown (6 points, excluding extra point).', 'The question specifically asks how many points each team scored in the first quarter.', 'The answer provided is 10, which does not match the sum of points scored by both teams in the first quarter as described in the context.', 'The correct answer should be 7 points for each team in the first quarter, not 10.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context describes the scoring events in the first quarter: Pittsburgh scored a touchdown (6 points, excluding extra point) and the Browns scored a touchdown (6 points, excluding extra point).", "The question specifically asks how many points each team scored in the first quarter.", "The answer provided is 10, which does not match the sum of points scored by both teams in the first quarter as described in the context.", "The correct answer should be 7 points for each team in the first quarter, not 10.'" ]

{ "_id": "8fac9dea-d6e7-4439-b822-943cab0abe47", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks which group from the census is smaller between German and Irish.', 'The context provides specific percentages for the ancestry of the population: 22.5% were of German ancestry and 13.1% were of Irish ancestry.', 'From the percentages given, the Irish group (13.1%) is smaller than the German group (22.5%).', \"The answer 'German' incorrectly identifies the German group as smaller, whereas the context clearly shows that the Irish group is smaller.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks which group from the census is smaller between German and Irish.", "The context provides specific percentages for the ancestry of the population: 22.5% were of German ancestry and 13.1% were of Irish ancestry.", "From the percentages given, the Irish group (13.1%) is smaller than the German group (22.5%).', \"The answer 'German' incorrectly identifies the German group as smaller, whereas the context clearly shows that the Irish group is smaller.\"" ]

{ "_id": "008c309d-84bf-42c6-8123-376d749d50bd", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question specifically asks for the total yards played in the fourth quarter that resulted in a score.', 'The context mentions that the only score in the fourth quarter was from Damon Huard completing an 11-yard TD pass to Kris Wilson.', 'Therefore, the total yards played in the fourth quarter that resulted in a score is 11 yards.', 'The answer provided is 12, which does not match the information given in the context about the fourth quarter scoring play.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question specifically asks for the total yards played in the fourth quarter that resulted in a score.", "The context mentions that the only score in the fourth quarter was from Damon Huard completing an 11-yard TD pass to Kris Wilson.", "Therefore, the total yards played in the fourth quarter that resulted in a score is 11 yards.", "The answer provided is 12, which does not match the information given in the context about the fourth quarter scoring play.'" ]

{ "_id": "3ae07499-28e3-4c35-b1bd-d1a89cf3db36", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context clearly states that the Patriots won the game against the Packers.', 'The context describes the scoring events in the game, indicating that the Patriots scored multiple touchdowns while the Packers scored only once.', 'The context mentions that Brett Favre, the quarterback for the Packers, was injured and knocked out of the game, suggesting that the Packers were not successful in scoring.', \"The answer 'Packers' incorrectly identifies the team that won the game, contradicting the detailed description of the game's outcome provided in the context.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context clearly states that the Patriots won the game against the Packers.", "The context describes the scoring events in the game, indicating that the Patriots scored multiple touchdowns while the Packers scored only once.", "The context mentions that Brett Favre, the quarterback for the Packers, was injured and knocked out of the game, suggesting that the Packers were not successful in scoring.', \"The answer 'Packers' incorrectly identifies the team that won the game, contradicting the detailed description of the game's outcome provided in the context.\"" ]

{ "_id": "660cbd19-c845-4ba4-9921-671d15dbcaa3", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context describes a game between the Raiders and the Ravens, detailing the scoring plays involving Michael Crabtree.', 'The first touchdown mentioned for Crabtree is a six-yard touchdown pass from Derek Carr.', 'The second touchdown mentioned for Crabtree is a 13-yard pass from Carr.', 'The third touchdown mentioned for Crabtree is a 23-yard touchdown from Carr.', 'Adding up all the touchdowns mentioned for Crabtree in the context, it confirms that he caught three touchdowns during the game.', \"The answer '2' does not accurately reflect the total number of touchdowns caught by Crabtree as described in the context.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context describes a game between the Raiders and the Ravens, detailing the scoring plays involving Michael Crabtree.", "The first touchdown mentioned for Crabtree is a six-yard touchdown pass from Derek Carr.", "The second touchdown mentioned for Crabtree is a 13-yard pass from Carr.", "The third touchdown mentioned for Crabtree is a 23-yard touchdown from Carr.", "Adding up all the touchdowns mentioned for Crabtree in the context, it confirms that he caught three touchdowns during the game.', \"The answer '2' does not accurately reflect the total number of touchdowns caught by Crabtree as described in the context.\"" ]

{ "_id": "d33e83dc-41d1-4545-8d27-5a6827c1de8e", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the total yards of all Brady\\'s touchdown (TD) passes combined.', 'From the context, Tom Brady threw three TD passes: one for 8 yards to Benjamin Watson, one for 3 yards to Randy Moss, and another for 45 yards to Randy Moss.', 'To find the total yards, we add up these yards: 8 + 3 + 45 = 46 yards.', 'The answer provided is 60, which does not match the calculated total of 46 yards from the context.', 'Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context as it does not accurately reflect the sum of the TD passes mentioned.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the total yards of all Brady\\'s touchdown (TD) passes combined.", "From the context, Tom Brady threw three TD passes: one for 8 yards to Benjamin Watson, one for 3 yards to Randy Moss, and another for 45 yards to Randy Moss.", "To find the total yards, we add up these yards: 8 + 3 + 45 = 46 yards.", "The answer provided is 60, which does not match the calculated total of 46 yards from the context.", "Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context as it does not accurately reflect the sum of the TD passes mentioned.'" ]

{ "_id": "e9dc8976-a720-42d4-a109-850435841ad0", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context mentions two specific field goals made by Olindo Mare, both of which were from 23 yards.', 'To find the total yards kicked by Olindo Mare, we add the yards from both field goals: 23 yards + 23 yards = 46 yards.', 'The answer provided, 46, correctly sums the yards from the two field goals mentioned in the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context mentions two specific field goals made by Olindo Mare, both of which were from 23 yards.", "To find the total yards kicked by Olindo Mare, we add the yards from both field goals: 23 yards + 23 yards = 46 yards.", "The answer provided, 46, correctly sums the yards from the two field goals mentioned in the context.'" ]

{ "_id": "c81bc7a0-3a0d-473e-b2ab-45bb769c7505", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the player with the longest touchdown play of the first half.', 'The context describes various touchdown plays, including their distances.', 'The longest touchdown play mentioned for the first half is a 91-yard scoring drive by the Steelers.', 'The 91-yard drive is highlighted by a 50-yard reception by Antonio Brown on a tipped ball.', 'Other touchdown plays mentioned for the first half include a 1-yard touchdown run by DeShone Kizer and a 4-yard touchdown pass to Jesse James.', \"Comparing the distances, the 91-yard drive is the longest, followed by the 4-yard touchdown pass and the 1-yard touchdown run.\", \"Therefore, the answer 'Antonio Brown' is faithful to the context as he had the longest touchdown play of the first half.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the player with the longest touchdown play of the first half.", "The context describes various touchdown plays, including their distances.", "The longest touchdown play mentioned for the first half is a 91-yard scoring drive by the Steelers.", "The 91-yard drive is highlighted by a 50-yard reception by Antonio Brown on a tipped ball.", "Other touchdown plays mentioned for the first half include a 1-yard touchdown run by DeShone Kizer and a 4-yard touchdown pass to Jesse James.', \"Comparing the distances, the 91-yard drive is the longest, followed by the 4-yard touchdown pass and the 1-yard touchdown run.\", \"Therefore, the answer 'Antonio Brown' is faithful to the context as he had the longest touchdown play of the first half.\"" ]

{ "_id": "1a7e9f62-3033-4d25-ba1a-3acfaa190811", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT describes the sequence of scoring events in the game between the Raiders and the Ravens.', 'The Raiders scored first with a touchdown and then another touchdown, taking a 14-6 lead to the half.', 'The Ravens scored next in the third quarter with a touchdown, pulling within two points of the Raiders.', 'The Raiders responded with another touchdown, which was followed by a Ravens touchdown and a Raiders field goal, making the score 28-27 in favor of the Raiders.', 'The Ravens failed to convert on a two-point conversion, and the Raiders moved to 3-1 for the first time since 2000, indicating that the Raiders won the game.', \"The ANSWER 'Ravens' is incorrect because it contradicts the detailed description of the game's conclusion provided in the CONTEXT.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The CONTEXT describes the sequence of scoring events in the game between the Raiders and the Ravens.", "The Raiders scored first with a touchdown and then another touchdown, taking a 14-6 lead to the half.", "The Ravens scored next in the third quarter with a touchdown, pulling within two points of the Raiders.", "The Raiders responded with another touchdown, which was followed by a Ravens touchdown and a Raiders field goal, making the score 28-27 in favor of the Raiders.", "The Ravens failed to convert on a two-point conversion, and the Raiders moved to 3-1 for the first time since 2000, indicating that the Raiders won the game.', \"The ANSWER 'Ravens' is incorrect because it contradicts the detailed description of the game's conclusion provided in the CONTEXT.\"" ]

{ "_id": "bbd452c6-f047-4f57-97a0-9608d255846a", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context provides details of a football game between the Raiders and the Ravens.', 'It mentions that Derek Carr hit Michael Crabtree for three touchdown scores, indicating that Crabtree had multiple touchdowns in the game.', 'The context also states that Carr finished with four touchdowns on 199 yards passing, suggesting that Carr had more touchdowns than Crabtree.', \"The answer 'Crabtree' incorrectly suggests that Crabtree had more touchdowns than Carr, which contradicts the information provided in the context.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context provides details of a football game between the Raiders and the Ravens.", "It mentions that Derek Carr hit Michael Crabtree for three touchdown scores, indicating that Crabtree had multiple touchdowns in the game.", "The context also states that Carr finished with four touchdowns on 199 yards passing, suggesting that Carr had more touchdowns than Crabtree.', \"The answer 'Crabtree' incorrectly suggests that Crabtree had more touchdowns than Carr, which contradicts the information provided in the context.\"" ]

{ "_id": "4600e413-5dc2-480f-a561-631214c52782", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context clearly states that Momchil died on 7 July 1345.', 'The answer provided, 5 July 1345, does not match the date of death given in the context.', 'The discrepancy suggests either a misunderstanding of the context or a typographical error in the answer.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context clearly states that Momchil died on 7 July 1345.", "The answer provided, 5 July 1345, does not match the date of death given in the context.", "The discrepancy suggests either a misunderstanding of the context or a typographical error in the answer.'" ]

{ "_id": "32d77b6d-b109-40b7-bc0f-99803277fbcd", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks who kicked the second longest field goal in the described game.', 'From the context, two kickers are mentioned: Lawrence Tynes and Jeff Wilkins.', 'Lawrence Tynes kicked a 42-yard field goal, which is the longest field goal mentioned in the context.', 'Jeff Wilkins kicked a 41-yard field goal, which is the second longest field goal mentioned in the context.', 'Therefore, Jeff Wilkins is the kicker who kicked the second longest field goal in the game.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks who kicked the second longest field goal in the described game.", "From the context, two kickers are mentioned: Lawrence Tynes and Jeff Wilkins.", "Lawrence Tynes kicked a 42-yard field goal, which is the longest field goal mentioned in the context.", "Jeff Wilkins kicked a 41-yard field goal, which is the second longest field goal mentioned in the context.", "Therefore, Jeff Wilkins is the kicker who kicked the second longest field goal in the game.'" ]

{ "_id": "43989606-830f-4a57-a506-2a751316d2e6", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": [\"The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not American.\", \"The context provides a breakdown of the racial and ethnic composition of the county.\", \"The context specifically states that 8.1% of the population were 'American'.\", \"To find the percentage of the population that were not American, one would subtract the percentage of 'American' (8.1%) from 100%.\", \"100% - 8.1% = 91.9%.\", 'The answer provided is 92.1%, which does not match the calculated value of 91.9%.', 'Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context as it slightly overestimates the percentage of non-American residents.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "\"The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not American.\", \"The context provides a breakdown of the racial and ethnic composition of the county.\", \"The context specifically states that 8.1% of the population were 'American'.\", \"To find the percentage of the population that were not American, one would subtract the percentage of 'American' (8.1%) from 100%.\", \"100% - 8.1% = 91.9%.\", 'The answer provided is 92.1%, which does not match the calculated value of 91.9%.", "Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context as it slightly overestimates the percentage of non-American residents.'" ]

{ "_id": "63d298a2-5895-4a11-9c8e-7e780952cce0", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context mentions that Detroit had two turnovers on its first three plays in the third quarter.', 'Additionally, it is stated that LB Brandon Moore forced 2 turnovers.', 'The interception by S Keith Lewis near the end of the game is explicitly mentioned.', 'Given these details, the total number of turnovers forced by the 49ers is at least 4 (two from the third quarter, two forced by Moore, and one interception by Lewis).', \"The answer '4' does not account for all the turnovers mentioned in the context, suggesting it is an underestimate or a typographical error.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context mentions that Detroit had two turnovers on its first three plays in the third quarter.", "Additionally, it is stated that LB Brandon Moore forced 2 turnovers.", "The interception by S Keith Lewis near the end of the game is explicitly mentioned.", "Given these details, the total number of turnovers forced by the 49ers is at least 4 (two from the third quarter, two forced by Moore, and one interception by Lewis).', \"The answer '4' does not account for all the turnovers mentioned in the context, suggesting it is an underestimate or a typographical error.\"" ]

{ "_id": "740f740f-b4e2-4b56-a3df-ee484e0c85c3", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT describes a football game between the Raiders and the Ravens, detailing the scoring events.', 'The final score mentioned in the CONTEXT is 28-27 in favor of the Raiders.', 'The QUESTION asks by how many points the Raiders won, which is directly answered by subtracting the Ravens score from the Raiders score: 28 - 27 = 1.', 'The ANSWER provided is 2, which is incorrect based on the calculation from the CONTEXT.', 'The correct number of points by which the Raiders won is 1, not 2.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The CONTEXT describes a football game between the Raiders and the Ravens, detailing the scoring events.", "The final score mentioned in the CONTEXT is 28-27 in favor of the Raiders.", "The QUESTION asks by how many points the Raiders won, which is directly answered by subtracting the Ravens score from the Raiders score: 28 - 27 = 1.", "The ANSWER provided is 2, which is incorrect based on the calculation from the CONTEXT.", "The correct number of points by which the Raiders won is 1, not 2.'" ]

{ "_id": "9c7132be-5b44-40e9-9bbe-39c14a86a4d1", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context describes the scoring events in the first half of the game between the Cowboys and the Jaguars.', 'In the first quarter, the Cowboys scored a field goal (3 points) and the Jaguars scored a touchdown with an extra point (7 points), making the score 7-3 in favor of the Jaguars.', 'In the second quarter, the Jaguars scored another touchdown with an extra point (7 points), increasing their lead to 14-3.', 'By halftime, the score was 14-3, with the Jaguars scoring 14 points and the Cowboys scoring 3 points.', 'Therefore, the Cowboys scored the least points in the first half, totaling 3 points.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context describes the scoring events in the first half of the game between the Cowboys and the Jaguars.", "In the first quarter, the Cowboys scored a field goal (3 points) and the Jaguars scored a touchdown with an extra point (7 points), making the score 7-3 in favor of the Jaguars.", "In the second quarter, the Jaguars scored another touchdown with an extra point (7 points), increasing their lead to 14-3.", "By halftime, the score was 14-3, with the Jaguars scoring 14 points and the Cowboys scoring 3 points.", "Therefore, the Cowboys scored the least points in the first half, totaling 3 points.'" ]

{ "_id": "f5f7dea7-cd51-467f-8ad7-5ed82cc4324c", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for ancestral groups that constitute at least 10% of the population.', \"From the context, the ancestral groups listed with their percentages are: German (22.5%), Irish (13.1%), Italian (9.8%), English (9.2%), 'American' (8.1%), and Polish (6.0%).\", 'Only the German (22.5%) and Irish (13.1%) groups meet the criterion of being at least 10%.', 'The Italian group, listed in the answer, only makes up 9.8% of the population, which is below the 10% threshold specified in the question.', \"Therefore, the correct answer should include 'German' and 'Irish', not 'Italian'.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for ancestral groups that constitute at least 10% of the population.', \"From the context, the ancestral groups listed with their percentages are: German (22.5%), Irish (13.1%), Italian (9.8%), English (9.2%), 'American' (8.1%), and Polish (6.0%).\", 'Only the German (22.5%) and Irish (13.1%) groups meet the criterion of being at least 10%.", "The Italian group, listed in the answer, only makes up 9.8% of the population, which is below the 10% threshold specified in the question.', \"Therefore, the correct answer should include 'German' and 'Irish', not 'Italian'.\"" ]

{ "_id": "998621b9-8bbd-43ef-a77d-78a2a6dd69b8", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context clearly states that the Lions scored first in the game with a 25-yard field goal by Jason Hanson.', 'The 49ers did not score until the second quarter, when Frank Gore ran for a 1-yard touchdown, making the score 7-7.', 'The answer incorrectly states that the 49ers were the first team to score in the game, which contradicts the information provided in the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context clearly states that the Lions scored first in the game with a 25-yard field goal by Jason Hanson.", "The 49ers did not score until the second quarter, when Frank Gore ran for a 1-yard touchdown, making the score 7-7.", "The answer incorrectly states that the 49ers were the first team to score in the game, which contradicts the information provided in the context.'" ]

{ "_id": "7999cb17-682b-4e55-a068-430d207a993f", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context mentions that Graham Gano made a field goal late in the first quarter.', 'It also states that Gano made two more field goals in the second quarter.', 'In total, Gano made three field goals in the first half of the game.', 'The answer provided states that Gano had 2 field goals in the first half, which is incorrect based on the context provided.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context mentions that Graham Gano made a field goal late in the first quarter.", "It also states that Gano made two more field goals in the second quarter.", "In total, Gano made three field goals in the first half of the game.", "The answer provided states that Gano had 2 field goals in the first half, which is incorrect based on the context provided.'" ]

{ "_id": "614f2439-4e9a-44ab-addb-4059057af0b7", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks which team had a safety scored on them in the first half of the game.', 'The context provides details of the game between the Lions and the 49ers, including a specific mention of a safety scored by the 49ers in the second quarter.', \"The context states that 'San Francisco received a safety when Aldon Smith sacked Matthew Stafford in the end zone.'\", 'This mention directly identifies the 49ers as the team that had a safety scored against them in the first half.', \"The answer '49ers' is faithful to the context as it correctly identifies the team that had a safety scored on them, based on the provided details.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}\n" }

[ "'The question asks which team had a safety scored on them in the first half of the game.", "The context provides details of the game between the Lions and the 49ers, including a specific mention of a safety scored by the 49ers in the second quarter.', \"The context states that 'San Francisco received a safety when Aldon Smith sacked Matthew Stafford in the end zone.'\", 'This mention directly identifies the 49ers as the team that had a safety scored against them in the first half.', \"The answer '49ers' is faithful to the context as it correctly identifies the team that had a safety scored on them, based on the provided details.\"" ]

{ "_id": "a31ad985-79d4-47e0-92fc-adfeb0bf9b41", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks which war started first between the Russo-Crimean War and the Smolensk War.', 'The context provides the date for the Russo-Crimean War as starting in 1571.', 'The context mentions the Smolensk War in the year 1632.', 'Based on the dates given in the context, the Russo-Crimean War (1571) started before the Smolensk War (1632).', \"The answer provided, 'Smolensk War', is incorrect because it suggests that the Smolensk War started first, which contradicts the dates given in the context.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks which war started first between the Russo-Crimean War and the Smolensk War.", "The context provides the date for the Russo-Crimean War as starting in 1571.", "The context mentions the Smolensk War in the year 1632.", "Based on the dates given in the context, the Russo-Crimean War (1571) started before the Smolensk War (1632).', \"The answer provided, 'Smolensk War', is incorrect because it suggests that the Smolensk War started first, which contradicts the dates given in the context.\"" ]

{ "_id": "64712c5c-b2b2-475e-82db-02e0ceea2016", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question specifically asks for the players who caught touchdown passes in the first half of the game.', 'The context mentions that Leon Washington caught two touchdown passes in the first half (an 18-yard and a 60-yard TD pass).', 'The context also mentions that Tony Gonzalez caught a 19-yard TD pass in the first half.', 'Thomas Jones is mentioned in the context as scoring a touchdown, but it was only a running touchdown, not a receiving touchdown.', 'The inclusion of Thomas Jones in the answer is incorrect because the question is about receiving touchdowns, not running touchdowns.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question specifically asks for the players who caught touchdown passes in the first half of the game.", "The context mentions that Leon Washington caught two touchdown passes in the first half (an 18-yard and a 60-yard TD pass).", "The context also mentions that Tony Gonzalez caught a 19-yard TD pass in the first half.", "Thomas Jones is mentioned in the context as scoring a touchdown, but it was only a running touchdown, not a receiving touchdown.", "The inclusion of Thomas Jones in the answer is incorrect because the question is about receiving touchdowns, not running touchdowns.'" ]

{ "_id": "f703d43d-73fa-4fda-8913-d81bd5569700", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the length of the Lion's longest field goal in a specific game.', 'The context mentions several field goals by the Lions, including a 23-yard field goal by Jason Hanson, a 28-yard field goal, and a 36-yard field goal.', 'The 36-yard field goal by the Lions is correctly identified as the longest among the field goals mentioned.', \"The answer '36-yard' accurately reflects the longest field goal distance achieved by the Lions in the game, as no other field goals with a longer distance are mentioned in the context.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the length of the Lion's longest field goal in a specific game.", "The context mentions several field goals by the Lions, including a 23-yard field goal by Jason Hanson, a 28-yard field goal, and a 36-yard field goal.", "The 36-yard field goal by the Lions is correctly identified as the longest among the field goals mentioned.', \"The answer '36-yard' accurately reflects the longest field goal distance achieved by the Lions in the game, as no other field goals with a longer distance are mentioned in the context.\"" ]

{ "_id": "3fc35d66-fe98-42a2-9139-ed5b147d542e", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the number of points the latter team was at the end of the game.', \"In the context, 'the latter' refers to the second team mentioned in the sequence of events, which is the San Francisco 49ers.\", 'The context provides a detailed account of the scoring in the game between the Lions and the 49ers.', 'The final score mentioned in the context is 25-19 in favor of the San Francisco 49ers.', \"The answer '25' correctly matches the final score of the 49ers as provided in the context.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the number of points the latter team was at the end of the game.', \"In the context, 'the latter' refers to the second team mentioned in the sequence of events, which is the San Francisco 49ers.\", 'The context provides a detailed account of the scoring in the game between the Lions and the 49ers.", "The final score mentioned in the context is 25-19 in favor of the San Francisco 49ers.', \"The answer '25' correctly matches the final score of the 49ers as provided in the context.\"" ]

{ "_id": "d8cfed6e-9771-4d65-902c-9a28d526ed6c", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context describes two touchdowns by Jesse James in the first half: one for 4 yards and another for 50 yards.', 'The context does not mention any touchdowns by Antonio Brown in the first half.', \"The answer 'Antonio Brown' is incorrect because it does not align with the details provided in the context about the touchdowns in the first half.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context describes two touchdowns by Jesse James in the first half: one for 4 yards and another for 50 yards.", "The context does not mention any touchdowns by Antonio Brown in the first half.', \"The answer 'Antonio Brown' is incorrect because it does not align with the details provided in the context about the touchdowns in the first half.\"" ]

{ "_id": "c1084d20-57f9-4d4d-a154-766c1db9bde8", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT provides the number of households as 79,667 and the number of housing units as 83,146.', 'To find the difference between the number of housing units and households, subtract the number of households from the number of housing units: 83,146 - 79,667 = 3,479.', 'The ANSWER provided is 3500, which is not exactly correct. The precise difference calculated from the CONTEXT data is 3,479.', 'Therefore, the ANSWER is not faithful to the CONTEXT because it rounds the exact difference to a nearby number, rather than stating the precise figure.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The CONTEXT provides the number of households as 79,667 and the number of housing units as 83,146.", "To find the difference between the number of housing units and households, subtract the number of households from the number of housing units: 83,146 - 79,667 = 3,479.", "The ANSWER provided is 3500, which is not exactly correct. The precise difference calculated from the CONTEXT data is 3,479.", "Therefore, the ANSWER is not faithful to the CONTEXT because it rounds the exact difference to a nearby number, rather than stating the precise figure.'" ]

{ "_id": "2512dbf6-02c6-46ec-92f0-dedbe76bcaf8", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the player who caught the first touchdown pass of the game.', 'The context describes the sequence of scoring events in the game between the Cowboys and the Jaguars.', 'It mentions that the first touchdown of the game was a 42-yard TD pass from QB David Garrard to TE Marcedes Lewis.', 'This information directly identifies Marcedes Lewis as the receiver of the first touchdown pass in the game.', \"No other touchdowns are mentioned before this event in the context, confirming that Marcedes Lewis's catch was indeed the first touchdown of the game.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the player who caught the first touchdown pass of the game.", "The context describes the sequence of scoring events in the game between the Cowboys and the Jaguars.", "It mentions that the first touchdown of the game was a 42-yard TD pass from QB David Garrard to TE Marcedes Lewis.", "This information directly identifies Marcedes Lewis as the receiver of the first touchdown pass in the game.', \"No other touchdowns are mentioned before this event in the context, confirming that Marcedes Lewis's catch was indeed the first touchdown of the game.\"" ]

{ "_id": "6bbf1900-2cef-4fc2-815b-91b661cce636", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not American.', \"The context provides a breakdown of the racial and ethnic composition of the county, including a 8.1% who identified their ancestry as 'American'.\", \"The answer provided, 8.1, incorrectly represents the percentage of the population who identified as 'American', rather than those who did not.\", 'To find the percentage of the population that were not American, one would need to subtract the percentage of those who identified as \"American\" (8.1%) from 100%.', \"The correct answer should be 91.9% (100% - 8.1%), which represents the percentage of the population that did not identify as 'American'.\", 'The answer given does not correctly address the question as it misinterprets the data regarding American identity instead of calculating those who are not American.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not American.', \"The context provides a breakdown of the racial and ethnic composition of the county, including a 8.1% who identified their ancestry as 'American'.\", \"The answer provided, 8.1, incorrectly represents the percentage of the population who identified as 'American', rather than those who did not.\", 'To find the percentage of the population that were not American, one would need to subtract the percentage of those who identified as \"American\" (8.1%) from 100%.', \"The correct answer should be 91.9% (100% - 8.1%), which represents the percentage of the population that did not identify as 'American'.\", 'The answer given does not correctly address the question as it misinterprets the data regarding American identity instead of calculating those who are not American.'" ]

{ "_id": "e406d360-a2ee-4276-b041-c54746fb2352", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question specifically asks for the yardage of the only rushing touchdown.', 'The context mentions two rushing touchdowns by Dillon: one for one yard and another for two yards.', 'The answer provided is 2, which corresponds to the yardage of one of the rushing touchdowns by Dillon.', 'However, the answer does not correctly identify the only rushing touchdown, as it should have based on the context provided.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question specifically asks for the yardage of the only rushing touchdown.", "The context mentions two rushing touchdowns by Dillon: one for one yard and another for two yards.", "The answer provided is 2, which corresponds to the yardage of one of the rushing touchdowns by Dillon.", "However, the answer does not correctly identify the only rushing touchdown, as it should have based on the context provided.'" ]

{ "_id": "c7142117-4e5b-4aaf-a49c-fd1c6213e74a", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the difference between the number of housing units and the number of families in the county.', 'From the context, there are 83,146 housing units and 60,387 families.', 'To find the difference, subtract the number of families from the number of housing units: 83,146 - 60,387 = 22,759.', 'The answer provided is 22,758, which is off by 1 from the correct calculation of 22,759.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the difference between the number of housing units and the number of families in the county.", "From the context, there are 83,146 housing units and 60,387 families.", "To find the difference, subtract the number of families from the number of housing units: 83,146 - 60,387 = 22,759.", "The answer provided is 22,758, which is off by 1 from the correct calculation of 22,759.'" ]

{ "_id": "af57318b-b375-48bd-98d7-633dcfa9b2a9", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context provides the final score of the game between Carolina and San Francisco as 23-3.', 'To find the margin by which Carolina won, subtract the losing team's score (San Francisco, 3) from the winning team's score (Carolina, 23).', '23 - 3 = 20, which is the correct margin by which Carolina won.', 'The answer provided is 21, which is incorrect and does not match the calculation based on the scores provided in the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context provides the final score of the game between Carolina and San Francisco as 23-3.", "To find the margin by which Carolina won, subtract the losing team's score (San Francisco, 3) from the winning team's score (Carolina, 23).", "23 - 3 = 20, which is the correct margin by which Carolina won.", "The answer provided is 21, which is incorrect and does not match the calculation based on the scores provided in the context.'" ]

{ "_id": "073c9470-a5ea-48c4-b60f-f7affbbe0717", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks specifically about who lost to Petrova in the Australian Open.', 'The context does not provide any information about the Australian Open or mention any specific matches involving Petrova.', 'The answer lists Maria Sharapova, Venus Williams, and Svetlana Kuznetsova as those who lost to Petrova in the Australian Open.', 'The context does not support the inclusion of these names in the answer, as it does not provide any details about the Australian Open or the matches involving Petrova.', 'Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context provided.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks specifically about who lost to Petrova in the Australian Open.", "The context does not provide any information about the Australian Open or mention any specific matches involving Petrova.", "The answer lists Maria Sharapova, Venus Williams, and Svetlana Kuznetsova as those who lost to Petrova in the Australian Open.", "The context does not support the inclusion of these names in the answer, as it does not provide any details about the Australian Open or the matches involving Petrova.", "Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context provided.'" ]

{ "_id": "4c219d65-8fe2-4029-9da0-70f5e2857bdb", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT states that the French crown had been at odds with Navarre since 1354.', 'It also mentions that in 1363, the Navarrese used the captivity of John II in London to try to seize power.', 'The difference between 1363 (when the Navarrese used the captivity) and 1354 (when the crown was at odds with Navarre) is 9 years.', 'The ANSWER provided is 8, which is incorrect based on the calculation from the CONTEXT.', 'The correct number of years before the Navarrese used the captivity of John II is 9 years, not 8.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The CONTEXT states that the French crown had been at odds with Navarre since 1354.", "It also mentions that in 1363, the Navarrese used the captivity of John II in London to try to seize power.", "The difference between 1363 (when the Navarrese used the captivity) and 1354 (when the crown was at odds with Navarre) is 9 years.", "The ANSWER provided is 8, which is incorrect based on the calculation from the CONTEXT.", "The correct number of years before the Navarrese used the captivity of John II is 9 years, not 8.'" ]

{ "_id": "712e0c96-3255-49b7-b201-3ecee897b77f", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The QUESTION asks for the percentage of the population that were not German, according to the census data.', 'The CONTEXT provides that 22.5% of the population were of German ancestry.', 'To find the percentage of the population that were not German, one would subtract the percentage of German ancestry from 100%.', 'The correct calculation should be 100% - 22.5% = 77.5%.', 'The ANSWER provided is 22.5, which incorrectly represents the percentage of the population that were German, not the percentage that were not German.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The QUESTION asks for the percentage of the population that were not German, according to the census data.", "The CONTEXT provides that 22.5% of the population were of German ancestry.", "To find the percentage of the population that were not German, one would subtract the percentage of German ancestry from 100%.", "The correct calculation should be 100% - 22.5% = 77.5%.", "The ANSWER provided is 22.5, which incorrectly represents the percentage of the population that were German, not the percentage that were not German.'" ]

{ "_id": "f16c0ee7-f131-4a8b-a6ac-4d275ea68066", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks how many points the Buccaneers needed to tie in the first quarter.', 'The context describes the scoring events in the first quarter: the Lions scored a 23-yard field goal and the Buccaneers scored a 38-yard field goal.', \"To tie the game in the first quarter, the Buccaneers needed to score at least 23 points (the points scored by the Lions in that quarter).\", \"The Buccaneers' 38-yard field goal did not meet this requirement, as it only scored 3 points.\", 'The answer provided is 7, which does not match the calculation based on the context provided.', 'The correct answer should be at least 23, not 7.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks how many points the Buccaneers needed to tie in the first quarter.", "The context describes the scoring events in the first quarter: the Lions scored a 23-yard field goal and the Buccaneers scored a 38-yard field goal.', \"To tie the game in the first quarter, the Buccaneers needed to score at least 23 points (the points scored by the Lions in that quarter).\", \"The Buccaneers' 38-yard field goal did not meet this requirement, as it only scored 3 points.\", 'The answer provided is 7, which does not match the calculation based on the context provided.", "The correct answer should be at least 23, not 7.'" ]

{ "_id": "b04a6f58-2860-445b-8770-d309a467fe30", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks who threw the first touchdown pass of the game.', 'The context describes the sequence of scoring events in the game between the Lions and the Buccaneers.', 'It mentions that the first touchdown of the game was a 36-yard touchdown catch by Calvin Johnson of the Detroit Lions.', 'This information directly identifies Calvin Johnson as the receiver of the first touchdown pass in the game.', \"The answer 'Calvin Johnson' is faithful to the context because it accurately reflects the information provided about the first touchdown pass.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}\n" }

[ "'The question asks who threw the first touchdown pass of the game.", "The context describes the sequence of scoring events in the game between the Lions and the Buccaneers.", "It mentions that the first touchdown of the game was a 36-yard touchdown catch by Calvin Johnson of the Detroit Lions.", "This information directly identifies Calvin Johnson as the receiver of the first touchdown pass in the game.', \"The answer 'Calvin Johnson' is faithful to the context because it accurately reflects the information provided about the first touchdown pass.\"" ]

{ "_id": "43e7bb76-2672-4be3-92d1-f17b2065ab93", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks who scored the first points of the game.', 'The context describes the sequence of scoring events in the game between the Browns and the Steelers.', 'It mentions that the scoring began with a touchdown by Anthony Chickillo for the Steelers.', 'This touchdown by Anthony Chickillo is explicitly stated to be the first touchdown of the game.', \"Tyler Matakevich is mentioned in the context as blocking a punt by Britton Colquitt, which led to the ball being knocked into the end zone and recovered by Anthony Chickillo for a touchdown.\", \"Since Tyler Matakevich's action (blocking the punt) directly resulted in the first touchdown of the game, it is accurate to state that Tyler Matakevich scored the first points of the game.\", \"The answer 'Tyler Matakevich' is faithful to the context provided as it correctly identifies the player who scored the first points.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks who scored the first points of the game.", "The context describes the sequence of scoring events in the game between the Browns and the Steelers.", "It mentions that the scoring began with a touchdown by Anthony Chickillo for the Steelers.", "This touchdown by Anthony Chickillo is explicitly stated to be the first touchdown of the game.', \"Tyler Matakevich is mentioned in the context as blocking a punt by Britton Colquitt, which led to the ball being knocked into the end zone and recovered by Anthony Chickillo for a touchdown.\", \"Since Tyler Matakevich's action (blocking the punt) directly resulted in the first touchdown of the game, it is accurate to state that Tyler Matakevich scored the first points of the game.\", \"The answer 'Tyler Matakevich' is faithful to the context provided as it correctly identifies the player who scored the first points.\"" ]

{ "_id": "ae7c4737-8662-471c-a3be-430ba8a0cd75", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context describes several touchdown passes by Tom Brady: an 8-yard TD pass to Benjamin Watson, a 3-yard TD pass to Randy Moss, a 4-yard TD pass to Jabar Gaffney, and a 45-yard TD pass to Randy Moss.', 'The longest pass mentioned in the context is the 45-yard TD pass from Tom Brady to Randy Moss.', 'The answer provided is 44, which does not match any of the touchdown pass distances mentioned in the context.', 'The correct answer should be 45, not 44, as 45 yards is the longest pass described in the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context describes several touchdown passes by Tom Brady: an 8-yard TD pass to Benjamin Watson, a 3-yard TD pass to Randy Moss, a 4-yard TD pass to Jabar Gaffney, and a 45-yard TD pass to Randy Moss.", "The longest pass mentioned in the context is the 45-yard TD pass from Tom Brady to Randy Moss.", "The answer provided is 44, which does not match any of the touchdown pass distances mentioned in the context.", "The correct answer should be 45, not 44, as 45 yards is the longest pass described in the context.'" ]

{ "_id": "04e10d50-4ba2-4dd8-b6b6-0b54c37b9549", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not German.', 'The context provides that 22.5% of the population were of German ancestry.', 'To find the percentage of the population that were not German, one would subtract the percentage of German ancestry from 100%.', 'The correct calculation should be 100% - 22.5% = 77.5%.', 'The answer provided (22.5) is the percentage of the population that were German, not the percentage that were not German.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not German.", "The context provides that 22.5% of the population were of German ancestry.", "To find the percentage of the population that were not German, one would subtract the percentage of German ancestry from 100%.", "The correct calculation should be 100% - 22.5% = 77.5%.", "The answer provided (22.5) is the percentage of the population that were German, not the percentage that were not German.'" ]

{ "_id": "bfed1d83-121b-44ab-8355-8b77a43bcbb6", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks who had the most receiving yards in the described game.', 'The context mentions several touchdown passes and their yardages: a 3-yard pass to Malcom Floyd, a 10-yard pass to Vincent Jackson, a 7-yard pass to Dwayne Bowe, and a 58-yard pass to Darren Sproles.', 'Among these, the 58-yard pass to Darren Sproles had the most yards.', 'The answer incorrectly lists Vincent Jackson as the player with the most receiving yards, when he actually had 10 yards from the context provided.', 'The correct answer should have been Darren Sproles, who had 58 yards, not Vincent Jackson.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks who had the most receiving yards in the described game.", "The context mentions several touchdown passes and their yardages: a 3-yard pass to Malcom Floyd, a 10-yard pass to Vincent Jackson, a 7-yard pass to Dwayne Bowe, and a 58-yard pass to Darren Sproles.", "Among these, the 58-yard pass to Darren Sproles had the most yards.", "The answer incorrectly lists Vincent Jackson as the player with the most receiving yards, when he actually had 10 yards from the context provided.", "The correct answer should have been Darren Sproles, who had 58 yards, not Vincent Jackson.'" ]

{ "_id": "cf4e37e5-c287-4b28-a65e-15aa2818e5c5", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not Polish.', 'The context provides the percentage of the population with Polish ancestry as 6.0%.', 'To find the percentage of the population that were not Polish, one would subtract the percentage of Polish ancestry from 100%.', '100% - 6.0% = 94%.', 'The answer provided is 92%, which does not match the correct calculation of 94%.', 'Therefore, the answer is incorrect as it should be 94% instead of 92%.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not Polish.", "The context provides the percentage of the population with Polish ancestry as 6.0%.", "To find the percentage of the population that were not Polish, one would subtract the percentage of Polish ancestry from 100%.", "100% - 6.0% = 94%.", "The answer provided is 92%, which does not match the correct calculation of 94%.", "Therefore, the answer is incorrect as it should be 94% instead of 92%.'" ]

{ "_id": "e1488f18-19ee-413d-a511-3d885d8bcfa0", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context describes the scoring events in the first half: a touchdown by Anthony Chickillo for the Steelers, a touchdown by DeShone Kizer for the Browns, and a touchdown by Jesse James for the Steelers.', 'The context also describes the scoring events in the second half: a touchdown by Jesse James for the Steelers, a touchdown by DeShone Kizer for the Browns, and a touchdown by Corey Coleman for the Browns.', 'The number of touchdowns scored in the first half is three (Steelers scored two, Browns scored one).', 'The number of touchdowns scored in the second half is three (Steelers scored two, Browns scored one).', 'The number of touchdowns scored in total is six (three in the first half and three in the second half).', 'The answer states that there were 2 more touchdowns scored in the first half compared to the second half, which is incorrect. The number of touchdowns scored in the first half and second half is the same, not 2 more in the first half.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context describes the scoring events in the first half: a touchdown by Anthony Chickillo for the Steelers, a touchdown by DeShone Kizer for the Browns, and a touchdown by Jesse James for the Steelers.", "The context also describes the scoring events in the second half: a touchdown by Jesse James for the Steelers, a touchdown by DeShone Kizer for the Browns, and a touchdown by Corey Coleman for the Browns.", "The number of touchdowns scored in the first half is three (Steelers scored two, Browns scored one).", "The number of touchdowns scored in the second half is three (Steelers scored two, Browns scored one).", "The number of touchdowns scored in total is six (three in the first half and three in the second half).", "The answer states that there were 2 more touchdowns scored in the first half compared to the second half, which is incorrect. The number of touchdowns scored in the first half and second half is the same, not 2 more in the first half.'" ]

{ "_id": "e3d18516-fe9f-45af-bfa7-f1bde37ab170", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question specifically asks for the player who scored a special teams touchdown.', 'The context mentions that Darren Sproles scored a 58-yard touchdown pass from Philip Rivers, which is a special teams touchdown.', 'The context also mentions that Jacob Hester recovered a blocked punt in the end zone for a touchdown, which is another special teams touchdown.', 'Later in the answer, it is mentioned that Larry Johnson was suspended for two weeks for unrelated reasons, which does not answer the question about the player who scored a special teams touchdown.', 'The answer correctly identifies Darren Sproles as the player who scored a special teams touchdown, but it also includes unnecessary information about Larry Johnson.'], \"SCORE\": PASS}\n" }

[ "'The question specifically asks for the player who scored a special teams touchdown.", "The context mentions that Darren Sproles scored a 58-yard touchdown pass from Philip Rivers, which is a special teams touchdown.", "The context also mentions that Jacob Hester recovered a blocked punt in the end zone for a touchdown, which is another special teams touchdown.", "Later in the answer, it is mentioned that Larry Johnson was suspended for two weeks for unrelated reasons, which does not answer the question about the player who scored a special teams touchdown.", "The answer correctly identifies Darren Sproles as the player who scored a special teams touchdown, but it also includes unnecessary information about Larry Johnson.'" ]

{ "_id": "33f06667-614b-4ca2-b186-161628435f4d", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the difference between the number of people and the number of housing units.', 'According to the context, there were 218,590 people and 83,146 housing units in the county.', 'To find the difference, subtract the number of housing units from the number of people: 218,590 - 83,146 = 135,444.', 'The answer provided is 135,450, which is not the correct result of the subtraction (135,444).', 'Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context because it does not accurately reflect the correct calculation based on the provided data.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the difference between the number of people and the number of housing units.", "According to the context, there were 218,590 people and 83,146 housing units in the county.", "To find the difference, subtract the number of housing units from the number of people: 218,590 - 83,146 = 135,444.", "The answer provided is 135,450, which is not the correct result of the subtraction (135,444).", "Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context because it does not accurately reflect the correct calculation based on the provided data.'" ]

{ "_id": "f2570d0b-043f-4984-9273-d1d0e84ba760", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks which ancestral group is smaller between English and Italian.', 'The context provides specific percentages for the ancestry of the population: 9.2% Italian and 9.2% English.', 'The percentages given for both groups are the same (9.2%), indicating that the English group is not smaller than the Italian group.', 'The answer incorrectly identifies the Italian group as smaller, which contradicts the information provided in the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks which ancestral group is smaller between English and Italian.", "The context provides specific percentages for the ancestry of the population: 9.2% Italian and 9.2% English.", "The percentages given for both groups are the same (9.2%), indicating that the English group is not smaller than the Italian group.", "The answer incorrectly identifies the Italian group as smaller, which contradicts the information provided in the context.'" ]

{ "_id": "16916544-1e32-4dc2-affb-924530416d96", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context describes Trent Edwards playing the rest of the game for Buffalo after J.P. Losman was injured in the first quarter.', 'The injury to J.P. Losman occurred on the first offensive play of the game, indicating that Trent Edwards played the entire game.', 'The game was divided into four quarters, and Trent Edwards played all four quarters as he was the starting quarterback for the Bills after Losman was injured.', \"The answer '3' does not match the total number of quarters played by Trent Edwards in the game, which is four.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context describes Trent Edwards playing the rest of the game for Buffalo after J.P. Losman was injured in the first quarter.", "The injury to J.P. Losman occurred on the first offensive play of the game, indicating that Trent Edwards played the entire game.", "The game was divided into four quarters, and Trent Edwards played all four quarters as he was the starting quarterback for the Bills after Losman was injured.', \"The answer '3' does not match the total number of quarters played by Trent Edwards in the game, which is four.\"" ]

{ "_id": "6bcc8ce2-8447-4dfe-ad8c-2597782d63cd", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the longest touchdown pass in the game.', 'The context mentions several touchdown passes by David Garrard: a 10-yard TD pass to Mike Sims-Walker, a 42-yard TD pass to Marcedes Lewis, a 15-yard TD pass to Mike Thomas, and a 9-yard TD pass to Marcedes Lewis again.', 'Jon Kitna also made an 8-yard TD pass to Jason Witten.', 'The longest touchdown pass mentioned in the context is the 42-yard pass from QB David Garrard to TE Marcedes Lewis.', 'The answer provided is 34, which corresponds to a field goal by David Buehler, not a touchdown pass.', 'Therefore, the answer should be 42 yards, not 34, as it should reflect the longest touchdown pass, not a field goal.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the longest touchdown pass in the game.", "The context mentions several touchdown passes by David Garrard: a 10-yard TD pass to Mike Sims-Walker, a 42-yard TD pass to Marcedes Lewis, a 15-yard TD pass to Mike Thomas, and a 9-yard TD pass to Marcedes Lewis again.", "Jon Kitna also made an 8-yard TD pass to Jason Witten.", "The longest touchdown pass mentioned in the context is the 42-yard pass from QB David Garrard to TE Marcedes Lewis.", "The answer provided is 34, which corresponds to a field goal by David Buehler, not a touchdown pass.", "Therefore, the answer should be 42 yards, not 34, as it should reflect the longest touchdown pass, not a field goal.'" ]

{ "_id": "38d480e4-9efc-4d20-93da-20a81f9eabf5", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not Irish.', 'The context provides that 13.1% of the population were of Irish ancestry.', 'To find the percentage of the population that were not Irish, one would subtract the percentage of Irish ancestry from 100%.', '100% - 13.1% = 86.9%.', 'The answer provided is 87.1%, which does not match the calculated value of 86.9%.', 'Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context as it slightly overestimates the percentage of non-Irish residents.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not Irish.", "The context provides that 13.1% of the population were of Irish ancestry.", "To find the percentage of the population that were not Irish, one would subtract the percentage of Irish ancestry from 100%.", "100% - 13.1% = 86.9%.", "The answer provided is 87.1%, which does not match the calculated value of 86.9%.", "Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context as it slightly overestimates the percentage of non-Irish residents.'" ]

{ "_id": "2744ab4d-e4d2-46ce-8160-b32be79e9045", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context describes the sequence of scoring in the game between the Raiders and the Ravens.', 'It mentions that the Raiders scored first with a six-yard touchdown pass from Derek Carr to Seth Roberts.', 'The Ravens scored next in the third quarter with a one-yard touchdown run by Joe Flacco.', 'The question specifically asks which team got the first touchdown (TD) in the game.', 'According to the context, the first TD was scored by the Raiders with Seth Roberts catching a six-yard pass from Derek Carr.', 'The Ravens did not score their first TD until the third quarter, as indicated by the answer provided.', \"Therefore, the answer 'The Ravens' is incorrect because it was the Raiders who scored the first TD.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context describes the sequence of scoring in the game between the Raiders and the Ravens.", "It mentions that the Raiders scored first with a six-yard touchdown pass from Derek Carr to Seth Roberts.", "The Ravens scored next in the third quarter with a one-yard touchdown run by Joe Flacco.", "The question specifically asks which team got the first touchdown (TD) in the game.", "According to the context, the first TD was scored by the Raiders with Seth Roberts catching a six-yard pass from Derek Carr.", "The Ravens did not score their first TD until the third quarter, as indicated by the answer provided.', \"Therefore, the answer 'The Ravens' is incorrect because it was the Raiders who scored the first TD.\"" ]

{ "_id": "732eb5ab-1b8e-40be-b2fa-108ac60364c6", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context describes the sequence of scoring events in the game between the Steelers and the Browns.', 'It mentions that Ben Roethlisberger of the Steelers completed an 8-yard touchdown pass to Heath Miller in the second quarter.', 'The context then details a series of scoring plays, including a kickoff return by Joshua Cribbs for a touchdown, a field goal by Jeff Reed, and a touchdown by Rashard Mendenhall.', \"The last scoring event mentioned in the context is a field goal by Jeff Reed, not a touchdown.\", 'Therefore, the last touchdown of the game was scored by Rashard Mendenhall, not Ben Roethlisberger.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context describes the sequence of scoring events in the game between the Steelers and the Browns.", "It mentions that Ben Roethlisberger of the Steelers completed an 8-yard touchdown pass to Heath Miller in the second quarter.", "The context then details a series of scoring plays, including a kickoff return by Joshua Cribbs for a touchdown, a field goal by Jeff Reed, and a touchdown by Rashard Mendenhall.', \"The last scoring event mentioned in the context is a field goal by Jeff Reed, not a touchdown.\", 'Therefore, the last touchdown of the game was scored by Rashard Mendenhall, not Ben Roethlisberger.'" ]

{ "_id": "8627332d-2ef1-4de7-babd-1106a8a5694b", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT describes two touchdown passes by Philip Rivers: the first to Malcolm Floyd for 3 yards and the second to Antonio Gates for 12 yards.', 'The CONTEXT also describes a touchdown pass by Matt Hasselbeck to John Carlson for 9 yards.', \"To find how many yards longer Rivers' second touchdown pass was compared to Hasselbeck's, subtract the length of Hasselbeck's touchdown pass (9 yards) from the length of Rivers' touchdown pass (12 yards).\", '12 yards - 9 yards = 3 yards.', 'The ANSWER provided is 6, which is incorrect. The correct difference is 3 yards.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The CONTEXT describes two touchdown passes by Philip Rivers: the first to Malcolm Floyd for 3 yards and the second to Antonio Gates for 12 yards.", "The CONTEXT also describes a touchdown pass by Matt Hasselbeck to John Carlson for 9 yards.', \"To find how many yards longer Rivers' second touchdown pass was compared to Hasselbeck's, subtract the length of Hasselbeck's touchdown pass (9 yards) from the length of Rivers' touchdown pass (12 yards).\", '12 yards - 9 yards = 3 yards.", "The ANSWER provided is 6, which is incorrect. The correct difference is 3 yards.'" ]

{ "_id": "13c6b87f-9bcf-4928-9b6c-138b43560a33", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT mentions that Robbie Gould kicked only once in the game, which was with thirteen seconds to go in the third quarter.', 'The CONTEXT does not specify how many field goals Gould kicked in the second half of the game.', \"The ANSWER '2' suggests that Gould kicked two field goals in the second half, which is not supported by the information provided in the CONTEXT.\", \"The CONTEXT only confirms that Gould kicked one field goal, not two, in the second half.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The CONTEXT mentions that Robbie Gould kicked only once in the game, which was with thirteen seconds to go in the third quarter.", "The CONTEXT does not specify how many field goals Gould kicked in the second half of the game.', \"The ANSWER '2' suggests that Gould kicked two field goals in the second half, which is not supported by the information provided in the CONTEXT.\", \"The CONTEXT only confirms that Gould kicked one field goal, not two, in the second half.\"" ]

{ "_id": "90167be8-fae9-4b86-b242-ddba3319d6ef", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT provides the percentage of Italian people in the county as 9.8%.', 'To find the percentage of the population that is not Italian, one would subtract the percentage of Italian people from 100%.', 'The calculation should be 100% - 9.8% = 90.2%.', 'The ANSWER provided is 89.8%, which is incorrect based on the calculation derived from the CONTEXT.', 'The correct answer should be 90.2%, indicating a calculation error in the ANSWER provided.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The CONTEXT provides the percentage of Italian people in the county as 9.8%.", "To find the percentage of the population that is not Italian, one would subtract the percentage of Italian people from 100%.", "The calculation should be 100% - 9.8% = 90.2%.", "The ANSWER provided is 89.8%, which is incorrect based on the calculation derived from the CONTEXT.", "The correct answer should be 90.2%, indicating a calculation error in the ANSWER provided.'" ]

{ "_id": "8aa1518e-e932-4286-81a2-fd7709e92085", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['John II returned to captivity in England in 1363.', 'John II died in 1364 while still in captivity in London.', 'The time between 1363 and 1364 is one year.', \"The answer provided, '3', does not match the correct duration of one year that John II lived after returning to captivity.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'John II returned to captivity in England in 1363.", "John II died in 1364 while still in captivity in London.", "The time between 1363 and 1364 is one year.', \"The answer provided, '3', does not match the correct duration of one year that John II lived after returning to captivity.\"" ]

{ "_id": "2b399ed9-0140-4e09-9b60-d4c254dfd44c", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The Dutch returned to Brazil in 1630.', 'The Portuguese continued to attack and prevent the Dutch from harvesting sugar until 1635.', 'The time period from 1630 (when the Dutch returned) to 1635 (when the Dutch evicted the Portuguese) is 5 years.', 'The answer provided, 3 years, is incorrect as it does not match the 5-year period calculated from the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The Dutch returned to Brazil in 1630.", "The Portuguese continued to attack and prevent the Dutch from harvesting sugar until 1635.", "The time period from 1630 (when the Dutch returned) to 1635 (when the Dutch evicted the Portuguese) is 5 years.", "The answer provided, 3 years, is incorrect as it does not match the 5-year period calculated from the context.'" ]

{ "_id": "629b40e4-cdb9-41e5-8674-98ee98e51003", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context mentions that the Treaty of Brétigny was a treaty between France and Navarre, setting John II's ransom and allowing for hostages to be held.', 'The context also states that in 1364, John II died in London while still in captivity, and Charles V succeeded him as king of France.', \"The Battle of Cocherel is mentioned in the context as occurring on 7 May 1364, which is described as a crushing defeat for the Navarrese.\", \"Given the dates provided in the context, the Treaty of Brétigny (mentioned in 1363) occurred before the Battle of Cocherel (mentioned in 1364).\", \"Therefore, the answer 'Battle of Cocherel' is incorrect because it suggests that the Battle of Cocherel happened first, which contradicts the chronological order of events described in the context.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context mentions that the Treaty of Brétigny was a treaty between France and Navarre, setting John II's ransom and allowing for hostages to be held.", "The context also states that in 1364, John II died in London while still in captivity, and Charles V succeeded him as king of France.', \"The Battle of Cocherel is mentioned in the context as occurring on 7 May 1364, which is described as a crushing defeat for the Navarrese.\", \"Given the dates provided in the context, the Treaty of Brétigny (mentioned in 1363) occurred before the Battle of Cocherel (mentioned in 1364).\", \"Therefore, the answer 'Battle of Cocherel' is incorrect because it suggests that the Battle of Cocherel happened first, which contradicts the chronological order of events described in the context.\"" ]

{ "_id": "f92c49c4-f8e3-4b17-bc7e-d5849ae0c72c", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the players who made at least one field goal during the game.', 'The context mentions that David Buehler, the kicker for the Cowboys, hit a 34-yard field goal.', 'Jon Kitna, the quarterback for the Cowboys, is mentioned in the context as making an 8-yard TD pass to TE Jason Witten, which implies he was successful in a field goal attempt.', 'The answer incorrectly lists only Jon Kitna, who is mentioned as having made a touchdown pass, not a field goal.', 'The correct players who made at least one field goal should include David Buehler and Jon Kitna, as Buehler actually hit a field goal and Kitna successfully passed for a touchdown, which implies he was successful in a field goal attempt.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the players who made at least one field goal during the game.", "The context mentions that David Buehler, the kicker for the Cowboys, hit a 34-yard field goal.", "Jon Kitna, the quarterback for the Cowboys, is mentioned in the context as making an 8-yard TD pass to TE Jason Witten, which implies he was successful in a field goal attempt.", "The answer incorrectly lists only Jon Kitna, who is mentioned as having made a touchdown pass, not a field goal.", "The correct players who made at least one field goal should include David Buehler and Jon Kitna, as Buehler actually hit a field goal and Kitna successfully passed for a touchdown, which implies he was successful in a field goal attempt.'" ]

{ "_id": "e04b971a-19b5-4be3-8d57-959eeb3d6afc", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The QUESTION asks about the findings of the Selective Draft Law Cases.', 'The CONTEXT states that the Supreme Court unanimously upheld the constitutionality of the draft act in the Selective Draft Law Cases on January 7, 1918.', \"The ANSWER claims that the Selective Draft Law Cases held the 'unconstitutionality of the draft act,' which contradicts the CONTEXT.\", 'The CONTEXT indicates that the draft act was considered constitutional by the Supreme Court, not unconstitutional.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The QUESTION asks about the findings of the Selective Draft Law Cases.", "The CONTEXT states that the Supreme Court unanimously upheld the constitutionality of the draft act in the Selective Draft Law Cases on January 7, 1918.', \"The ANSWER claims that the Selective Draft Law Cases held the 'unconstitutionality of the draft act,' which contradicts the CONTEXT.\", 'The CONTEXT indicates that the draft act was considered constitutional by the Supreme Court, not unconstitutional.'" ]

{ "_id": "aa7a6a6a-56be-495d-b015-912fcaed1526", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks specifically about the previous game the Rams lost to.', 'The context describes a game between the Rams and the Chiefs, detailing the scoring events and the final score.', \"The context explicitly states that 'With the loss, the Rams fell to 4-4.'\", 'This statement directly indicates that the Rams were the team that lost the game, not the Chiefs.', \"The answer 'Chiefs' incorrectly identifies the Chiefs as the team the Rams lost to, which contradicts the information provided in the context.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks specifically about the previous game the Rams lost to.", "The context describes a game between the Rams and the Chiefs, detailing the scoring events and the final score.', \"The context explicitly states that 'With the loss, the Rams fell to 4-4.'\", 'This statement directly indicates that the Rams were the team that lost the game, not the Chiefs.', \"The answer 'Chiefs' incorrectly identifies the Chiefs as the team the Rams lost to, which contradicts the information provided in the context.\"" ]

{ "_id": "261a1db7-19e2-4ab5-b557-ca7d7209549e", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context specifically mentions that Brandon Pettigrew caught a 16-yard TD pass during the game.', 'There is no additional information provided in the context about any other receptions made by Pettigrew in the game.', \"The answer '18' does not align with the information given in the context, which states only a single 16-yard reception.\", \"The answer should be '16' yards based on the context provided, not '18'.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context specifically mentions that Brandon Pettigrew caught a 16-yard TD pass during the game.", "There is no additional information provided in the context about any other receptions made by Pettigrew in the game.', \"The answer '18' does not align with the information given in the context, which states only a single 16-yard reception.\", \"The answer should be '16' yards based on the context provided, not '18'.\"" ]

{ "_id": "fff72e27-13c3-4f1d-8705-39c0548c0c7e", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT describes a series of events starting from the spring of 1344 when Momchil reneged on his support for John Kantakouzenos.', 'The first successful defeat mentioned in the CONTEXT occurred in June 1344 near Portogalos bay, where Momchil used boats to burn the anchored Ottoman ships.', \"The subsequent defeat of the army of Kantakouzenos at Mosynopolis is also described as successful for Momchil, occurring after the naval battle near Portogalos bay.\", 'The ANSWER provided as \"May\" does not align with the sequence of events described in the CONTEXT, which begins with the spring of 1344 and culminates in July 1345 with the death of Momchil.', 'The first successful defeat for Momchil, as per the CONTEXT, happened in June 1344, not May.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The CONTEXT describes a series of events starting from the spring of 1344 when Momchil reneged on his support for John Kantakouzenos.", "The first successful defeat mentioned in the CONTEXT occurred in June 1344 near Portogalos bay, where Momchil used boats to burn the anchored Ottoman ships.', \"The subsequent defeat of the army of Kantakouzenos at Mosynopolis is also described as successful for Momchil, occurring after the naval battle near Portogalos bay.\", 'The ANSWER provided as \"May\" does not align with the sequence of events described in the CONTEXT, which begins with the spring of 1344 and culminates in July 1345 with the death of Momchil.", "The first successful defeat for Momchil, as per the CONTEXT, happened in June 1344, not May.'" ]

{ "_id": "a2a8ad0c-808e-479e-936e-1cfa6739b570", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the total yards of field goals made by John Kasay in the game described.', 'From the context, John Kasay made three field goals: 23 yards, 35 yards, and 52 yards.', 'To find the total yards, we add these three distances together: 23 + 35 + 52 = 110 yards.', 'The answer provided is 120, which does not match the calculated total of 110 yards from the context.', 'Therefore, the answer is incorrect as it does not accurately reflect the sum of the field goals made by John Kasay in the game.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the total yards of field goals made by John Kasay in the game described.", "From the context, John Kasay made three field goals: 23 yards, 35 yards, and 52 yards.", "To find the total yards, we add these three distances together: 23 + 35 + 52 = 110 yards.", "The answer provided is 120, which does not match the calculated total of 110 yards from the context.", "Therefore, the answer is incorrect as it does not accurately reflect the sum of the field goals made by John Kasay in the game.'" ]

{ "_id": "fed63029-ef54-4fcc-b0a8-c8cdae29094c", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question specifically asks for the longest touchdown run of the game.', 'The context mentions two long touchdown runs by RB Leon Washington: one for 101 yards and another for 99 yards.', 'The 101-yard touchdown run by Leon Washington is the longest touchdown run mentioned in the context.', \"The answer provided (99 yards) refers to Leon Washington's second touchdown run, which is not the longest touchdown run of the game.\", 'Therefore, the correct answer should be 101 yards, not 99 yards.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question specifically asks for the longest touchdown run of the game.", "The context mentions two long touchdown runs by RB Leon Washington: one for 101 yards and another for 99 yards.", "The 101-yard touchdown run by Leon Washington is the longest touchdown run mentioned in the context.', \"The answer provided (99 yards) refers to Leon Washington's second touchdown run, which is not the longest touchdown run of the game.\", 'Therefore, the correct answer should be 101 yards, not 99 yards.'" ]

{ "_id": "b097125c-5c97-497a-80a7-b9230d8244c5", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The QUESTION asks specifically about the length of Robbie Gould's field goal to end the first half of the game.', 'The CONTEXT provides detailed information about the game between the Bears and the Packers, including scoring plays.', \"The CONTEXT mentions that Robbie Gould's 24-yard field goal was used to expand the Bears' lead to 17-10 at the end of the first half.\", \"The ANSWER states 'Robbie Gould's 27-yard field field goal', which is incorrect.\", \"The correct answer should be 'Robbie Gould's 24-yard field goal' as it accurately reflects the information provided in the CONTEXT.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The QUESTION asks specifically about the length of Robbie Gould's field goal to end the first half of the game.", "The CONTEXT provides detailed information about the game between the Bears and the Packers, including scoring plays.', \"The CONTEXT mentions that Robbie Gould's 24-yard field goal was used to expand the Bears' lead to 17-10 at the end of the first half.\", \"The ANSWER states 'Robbie Gould's 27-yard field field goal', which is incorrect.\", \"The correct answer should be 'Robbie Gould's 24-yard field goal' as it accurately reflects the information provided in the CONTEXT.\"" ]

{ "_id": "169fab50-e3ff-4551-9ac0-18dd659e4250", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context clearly states that the Redskins defeated the Dallas Cowboys in the game described.', 'The final minute of the game involved a wild sequence of events, including a blocked field goal by the Cowboys and a game-winning field goal by the Redskins.', 'The Redskins were awarded an un-timed down due to a defensive penalty, which allowed them to score the winning field goal.', 'The context does not mention any victory by the Cowboys in this game, but rather details the Redskins\\' triumph.', \"The answer 'Cowboys' incorrectly identifies the team that won the game, as per the detailed description provided in the context.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context clearly states that the Redskins defeated the Dallas Cowboys in the game described.", "The final minute of the game involved a wild sequence of events, including a blocked field goal by the Cowboys and a game-winning field goal by the Redskins.", "The Redskins were awarded an un-timed down due to a defensive penalty, which allowed them to score the winning field goal.", "The context does not mention any victory by the Cowboys in this game, but rather details the Redskins\\' triumph.', \"The answer 'Cowboys' incorrectly identifies the team that won the game, as per the detailed description provided in the context.\"" ]

{ "_id": "0fe30258-7fc0-4236-9f6d-3330d65df08f", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the difference between the number of housing units and the number of families in the county.', 'From the context, there are 83,146 housing units and 60,387 families.', 'To find the difference, subtract the number of families from the number of housing units: 83,146 - 60,387 = 22,759.', 'The answer provided is 22,758, which is off by 1 from the correct calculation of 22,759.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the difference between the number of housing units and the number of families in the county.", "From the context, there are 83,146 housing units and 60,387 families.", "To find the difference, subtract the number of families from the number of housing units: 83,146 - 60,387 = 22,759.", "The answer provided is 22,758, which is off by 1 from the correct calculation of 22,759.'" ]

{ "_id": "0745e624-835d-4189-b5d0-e35c8cc3cf90", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context provides the specific date when the North Carolina Department of Transportation and South Carolina Department of Transportation agreed to an I-73 corridor crossing the state line along SC and NC 38 near Hamlet, North Carolina.', 'The date provided is February 11, 2005.', 'The context also mentions that SCDOT announced its preferred routing of I-73 on May 30, 2006.', 'To find the number of days between the agreement and the announcement, calculate the difference between February 11, 2005, and May 30, 2006.', 'Counting the days: February 11 to February 12 is 2 days, March has 31 days, April has 30 days, May 1 to May 30 is 30 days.', 'Adding these together gives 2 + 31 + 30 + 30 = 472 days.', 'The answer 472 is correct and faithful to the context as it accurately represents the number of days between the agreement and the announcement.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context provides the specific date when the North Carolina Department of Transportation and South Carolina Department of Transportation agreed to an I-73 corridor crossing the state line along SC and NC 38 near Hamlet, North Carolina.", "The date provided is February 11, 2005.", "The context also mentions that SCDOT announced its preferred routing of I-73 on May 30, 2006.", "To find the number of days between the agreement and the announcement, calculate the difference between February 11, 2005, and May 30, 2006.", "Counting the days: February 11 to February 12 is 2 days, March has 31 days, April has 30 days, May 1 to May 30 is 30 days.", "Adding these together gives 2 + 31 + 30 + 30 = 472 days.", "The answer 472 is correct and faithful to the context as it accurately represents the number of days between the agreement and the announcement.'" ]

{ "_id": "41163cff-d27a-40aa-8a33-e9447b9a5640", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context provides information that Frank Gore rushed for 148 yards in the first half.', 'It also states that Gore scored on a 61-yard run before halftime.', 'To find the yards in the first half on runs other than his touchdown run, we subtract the yards scored on the touchdown run from the total rushing yards in the first half.', 'Calculation: 148 yards (total rushing yards) - 61 yards (touchdown run) = 87 yards.', 'The answer provided is 85, which is incorrect.', 'The correct answer should be 87 yards, not 85.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context provides information that Frank Gore rushed for 148 yards in the first half.", "It also states that Gore scored on a 61-yard run before halftime.", "To find the yards in the first half on runs other than his touchdown run, we subtract the yards scored on the touchdown run from the total rushing yards in the first half.", "Calculation: 148 yards (total rushing yards) - 61 yards (touchdown run) = 87 yards.", "The answer provided is 85, which is incorrect.", "The correct answer should be 87 yards, not 85.'" ]

{ "_id": "8f176cb2-ea5e-4bc7-aeca-4fa670a85ad5", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context provides a detailed account of the scoring by quarter during the first half of the game.', 'In the first quarter, the Jets scored a touchdown (6 points) and a field goal (3 points), totaling 9 points.', 'In the second quarter, the Chiefs scored two touchdowns (14 points) and a field goal (3 points), totaling 17 points.', 'The Jets scored another touchdown (6 points) in the second quarter, totaling 15 points.', 'The context does not provide a specific number for the points scored by halftime, only the scores by quarter.', 'The answer provided, 21, does not match the sum of the points scored by halftime as detailed in the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context provides a detailed account of the scoring by quarter during the first half of the game.", "In the first quarter, the Jets scored a touchdown (6 points) and a field goal (3 points), totaling 9 points.", "In the second quarter, the Chiefs scored two touchdowns (14 points) and a field goal (3 points), totaling 17 points.", "The Jets scored another touchdown (6 points) in the second quarter, totaling 15 points.", "The context does not provide a specific number for the points scored by halftime, only the scores by quarter.", "The answer provided, 21, does not match the sum of the points scored by halftime as detailed in the context.'" ]

{ "_id": "a2f02664-a032-4b4a-b388-299d7b95fb7a", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not Polish according to the census data.', 'The context provides that 6.0% of the population were of Polish ancestry.', 'To find the percentage of the population that were not Polish, one would subtract the percentage of Polish ancestry from 100%.', '100% - 6.0% = 94.0%.', 'The answer provided is 93%, which is incorrect.', 'The correct answer should be 94%, indicating that 94% of the population were not of Polish ancestry.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not Polish according to the census data.", "The context provides that 6.0% of the population were of Polish ancestry.", "To find the percentage of the population that were not Polish, one would subtract the percentage of Polish ancestry from 100%.", "100% - 6.0% = 94.0%.", "The answer provided is 93%, which is incorrect.", "The correct answer should be 94%, indicating that 94% of the population were not of Polish ancestry.'" ]

{ "_id": "d1b14418-fd40-42fd-94b7-5326dbb4121e", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context describes the sequence of events in the third quarter: Jonathan Stewart scored a touchdown, followed by another Gano field goal.', \"The third field goal by Gano is mentioned specifically with 3:14 left to go in the third quarter.\", 'No other field goals by Gano are mentioned in the third quarter besides these two.', \"The answer '3' accurately reflects the number of field goals Gano kicked in the third quarter, based on the context provided.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context describes the sequence of events in the third quarter: Jonathan Stewart scored a touchdown, followed by another Gano field goal.', \"The third field goal by Gano is mentioned specifically with 3:14 left to go in the third quarter.\", 'No other field goals by Gano are mentioned in the third quarter besides these two.', \"The answer '3' accurately reflects the number of field goals Gano kicked in the third quarter, based on the context provided.\"" ]

{ "_id": "7aaff956-dc28-4985-bbae-55aec0665651", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks who scored on the longest touchdown play of the game.', 'The context mentions several touchdown plays, including a 60-yard TD run by Leon Washington, a 91-yard interception return by Brandon Flowers, and others.', 'The 91-yard interception return by Brandon Flowers is the longest touchdown play mentioned in the context.', 'The answer provided is Leon Washington, who scored on a 60-yard TD run.', \"Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context because it does not acknowledge the 91-yard interception return by Brandon Flowers, which is the longest touchdown play of the game.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks who scored on the longest touchdown play of the game.", "The context mentions several touchdown plays, including a 60-yard TD run by Leon Washington, a 91-yard interception return by Brandon Flowers, and others.", "The 91-yard interception return by Brandon Flowers is the longest touchdown play mentioned in the context.", "The answer provided is Leon Washington, who scored on a 60-yard TD run.', \"Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context because it does not acknowledge the 91-yard interception return by Brandon Flowers, which is the longest touchdown play of the game.\"" ]

{ "_id": "748fc6d6-bfe8-4dee-8bec-0d8eb153efd7", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context describes two kickoff return touchdowns by Leon Washington in a game.', 'The first kickoff return touchdown by Leon Washington was 101 yards.', 'The second kickoff return touchdown by Leon Washington was 99 yards.', 'The question specifically asks for the number of kickoff return touchdowns shorter than 100 yards scored by Leon Washington.', 'From the context, only one kickoff return touchdown by Leon Washington was shorter than 100 yards, which was the 99-yard touchdown.', 'Therefore, the answer should be 1, not 2.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context describes two kickoff return touchdowns by Leon Washington in a game.", "The first kickoff return touchdown by Leon Washington was 101 yards.", "The second kickoff return touchdown by Leon Washington was 99 yards.", "The question specifically asks for the number of kickoff return touchdowns shorter than 100 yards scored by Leon Washington.", "From the context, only one kickoff return touchdown by Leon Washington was shorter than 100 yards, which was the 99-yard touchdown.", "Therefore, the answer should be 1, not 2.'" ]

{ "_id": "6b4ee027-ad46-4645-8122-0cd57beea9da", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the difference between the number of people and the number of families in the county.', 'According to the context, there were 218,590 people and 60,387 families residing in the county.', 'To find the difference, subtract the number of families from the number of people: 218,590 - 60,387 = 158,203.', 'The answer provided is 158,204, which is off by 1 from the correct calculation of 158,203.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the difference between the number of people and the number of families in the county.", "According to the context, there were 218,590 people and 60,387 families residing in the county.", "To find the difference, subtract the number of families from the number of people: 218,590 - 60,387 = 158,203.", "The answer provided is 158,204, which is off by 1 from the correct calculation of 158,203.'" ]

{ "_id": "a849cb71-b6da-4c1a-9791-b962c9ff2d65", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the player who scored the longest field goal in the described game.', 'The context mentions several field goals scored during the game by both teams.', \"Nate Kaeding's 39-yard field goal is explicitly mentioned as one of the field goals scored by the San Diego Chargers.\", \"Matt Cassel's 7-yard touchdown pass to Dwayne Bowe is mentioned as a field goal by the Kansas City Chiefs.\", 'Larry Johnson is mentioned in the context, but it is specifically stated that he was suspended for two weeks and did not score any points in the game.', \"The answer 'Matt Prater' is not mentioned anywhere in the context, indicating that he did not play in the game or score any points.\", \"The answer should be 'Nate Kaeding' based on the context provided, as he scored the longest field goal mentioned in the game.\"], \"SCORE\": PASS}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the player who scored the longest field goal in the described game.", "The context mentions several field goals scored during the game by both teams.', \"Nate Kaeding's 39-yard field goal is explicitly mentioned as one of the field goals scored by the San Diego Chargers.\", \"Matt Cassel's 7-yard touchdown pass to Dwayne Bowe is mentioned as a field goal by the Kansas City Chiefs.\", 'Larry Johnson is mentioned in the context, but it is specifically stated that he was suspended for two weeks and did not score any points in the game.', \"The answer 'Matt Prater' is not mentioned anywhere in the context, indicating that he did not play in the game or score any points.\", \"The answer should be 'Nate Kaeding' based on the context provided, as he scored the longest field goal mentioned in the game.\"" ]

{ "_id": "87176942-b400-4fd3-a7d3-48183b54987d", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The CONTEXT specifically mentions that the Browns lost their 13th consecutive season-opening game in 2017.', 'The CONTEXT also states that the Browns fell to 1-18 in season openers since returning to the league in 1999.', 'The QUESTION asks for the number of season openers played by the Browns since 1999.', 'Given that the Browns have lost all 18 season openers since 1999, the number of season openers played is 18.', 'The ANSWER provided is 20, which does not match the information given in the CONTEXT.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The CONTEXT specifically mentions that the Browns lost their 13th consecutive season-opening game in 2017.", "The CONTEXT also states that the Browns fell to 1-18 in season openers since returning to the league in 1999.", "The QUESTION asks for the number of season openers played by the Browns since 1999.", "Given that the Browns have lost all 18 season openers since 1999, the number of season openers played is 18.", "The ANSWER provided is 20, which does not match the information given in the CONTEXT.'" ]

{ "_id": "2f68f7db-ebb1-4864-ab40-22db2970305e", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context provides a detailed account of the scoring events in the first half of the game between the Bears and the Packers.', 'The Packers scored a touchdown and a field goal, and the Bears scored two touchdowns and a field goal.', 'The touchdowns scored by halftime are: Packers - 1 (Jordy Nelson) and Bears - 2 (Brandon Marshall and Matt Forté).', 'The field goals scored by halftime are: Packers - 1 (Mason Crosby) and Bears - 1 (Robbie Gould).', 'The points scored by halftime are: Packers - 10 (7 points from the touchdown and 3 points from the field goal) and Bears - 17 (7 points from each touchdown and 3 points from the field goal).', 'The total points scored by halftime are 27 (17 by the Bears and 10 by the Packers).', 'The answer provided is 24, which does not match the total points scored by halftime as detailed in the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context provides a detailed account of the scoring events in the first half of the game between the Bears and the Packers.", "The Packers scored a touchdown and a field goal, and the Bears scored two touchdowns and a field goal.", "The touchdowns scored by halftime are: Packers - 1 (Jordy Nelson) and Bears - 2 (Brandon Marshall and Matt Forté).", "The field goals scored by halftime are: Packers - 1 (Mason Crosby) and Bears - 1 (Robbie Gould).", "The points scored by halftime are: Packers - 10 (7 points from the touchdown and 3 points from the field goal) and Bears - 17 (7 points from each touchdown and 3 points from the field goal).", "The total points scored by halftime are 27 (17 by the Bears and 10 by the Packers).", "The answer provided is 24, which does not match the total points scored by halftime as detailed in the context.'" ]

{ "_id": "3637ce9d-203d-49e0-a454-b8a49e376148", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context clearly states that Momchil defeated the Ottoman fleet near Portogalos bay in June 1344.', 'The answer provided, July 1344, does not match the information given in the context about the defeat of the Ottoman fleet.', 'The context also mentions that Momchil defeated the army of Kantakouzenos at Mosynopolis in July 1344, but this event is not related to the defeat of the Ottoman fleet.', 'Therefore, the answer July 1344 is incorrect as it does not accurately reflect the sequence of events described in the context.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context clearly states that Momchil defeated the Ottoman fleet near Portogalos bay in June 1344.", "The answer provided, July 1344, does not match the information given in the context about the defeat of the Ottoman fleet.", "The context also mentions that Momchil defeated the army of Kantakouzenos at Mosynopolis in July 1344, but this event is not related to the defeat of the Ottoman fleet.", "Therefore, the answer July 1344 is incorrect as it does not accurately reflect the sequence of events described in the context.'" ]

{ "_id": "c017b2c9-0717-4f59-bfd9-9f2c5f17840a", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks which team scored fewer points in the 1st quarter.', 'The context describes the scoring events in the 1st quarter, mentioning that Brady of the Patriots connected with Graham for a two-yard touchdown pass.', 'This touchdown by the Patriots is the only score mentioned in the 1st quarter.', 'Since the Packers are not mentioned as scoring in the 1st quarter, it implies they scored fewer points in that quarter.', \"The answer 'Patriots' incorrectly suggests the Patriots scored fewer points in the 1st quarter, when in fact, it was the Packers who scored fewer points.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks which team scored fewer points in the 1st quarter.", "The context describes the scoring events in the 1st quarter, mentioning that Brady of the Patriots connected with Graham for a two-yard touchdown pass.", "This touchdown by the Patriots is the only score mentioned in the 1st quarter.", "Since the Packers are not mentioned as scoring in the 1st quarter, it implies they scored fewer points in that quarter.', \"The answer 'Patriots' incorrectly suggests the Patriots scored fewer points in the 1st quarter, when in fact, it was the Packers who scored fewer points.\"" ]

{ "_id": "fa8b2cbd-06ed-44a9-bfd8-8e13b789b0cf", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context clearly states that Cam Newton is the quarterback for the Panthers.', 'The context mentions that Cam Newton threw a 40-yard touchdown to Russell Sheppard, which indicates he is the quarterback.', \"The answer 'Teddy Bridgewater' is not mentioned anywhere in the context as the quarterback for the Panthers.\", \"The context does not suggest that Teddy Bridgewater played any role in quarterbacking for the Panthers during the described game.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context clearly states that Cam Newton is the quarterback for the Panthers.", "The context mentions that Cam Newton threw a 40-yard touchdown to Russell Sheppard, which indicates he is the quarterback.', \"The answer 'Teddy Bridgewater' is not mentioned anywhere in the context as the quarterback for the Panthers.\", \"The context does not suggest that Teddy Bridgewater played any role in quarterbacking for the Panthers during the described game.\"" ]

{ "_id": "f928fbc3-c8fc-471d-9d66-576b1717edf1", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the team that scored the second-longest field goal kick of the game.', 'The context mentions two field goals: one by Lawrence Tynes for 42 yards and another by Jeff Wilkins for 41 yards.', 'Since 42 yards is longer than 41 yards, the 42-yard field goal by Lawrence Tynes is the longest field goal kick of the game.', 'Therefore, the second-longest field goal kick of the game is the 41-yard field goal by Jeff Wilkins.', 'The answer incorrectly identifies the Chiefs as the team that scored the second-longest field goal kick, when it should have identified the Rams based on the context provided.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the team that scored the second-longest field goal kick of the game.", "The context mentions two field goals: one by Lawrence Tynes for 42 yards and another by Jeff Wilkins for 41 yards.", "Since 42 yards is longer than 41 yards, the 42-yard field goal by Lawrence Tynes is the longest field goal kick of the game.", "Therefore, the second-longest field goal kick of the game is the 41-yard field goal by Jeff Wilkins.", "The answer incorrectly identifies the Chiefs as the team that scored the second-longest field goal kick, when it should have identified the Rams based on the context provided.'" ]

{ "_id": "4966f1e8-f040-48d0-b263-917429652223", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks which kicker kicked the shortest field goal in the described game.', 'The context mentions two kickers: Olindo Mare and Nate Kaeding.', 'Olindo Mare made two field goals, both of which were from 23 yards.', 'Nate Kaeding made a field goal of 29 yards.', \"Comparing the distances, Nate Kaeding's field goal of 29 yards is longer than Olindo Mare's field goals of 23 yards.\", 'Therefore, Olindo Mare kicked the shortest field goal in the game.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks which kicker kicked the shortest field goal in the described game.", "The context mentions two kickers: Olindo Mare and Nate Kaeding.", "Olindo Mare made two field goals, both of which were from 23 yards.", "Nate Kaeding made a field goal of 29 yards.', \"Comparing the distances, Nate Kaeding's field goal of 29 yards is longer than Olindo Mare's field goals of 23 yards.\", 'Therefore, Olindo Mare kicked the shortest field goal in the game.'" ]

{ "_id": "12825b42-178d-43af-855a-5a48fb5dec43", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context provides the year of the burning of the suburbs of Moscow as 1592.', 'The context also states that the Nogai raids within sight of Moscow occurred during the Time of Troubles, which is mentioned as starting in 1614.', 'The difference between 1614 (the year the Nogai raids began) and 1592 (the year the suburbs were burned) is 24 years.', 'The answer provided, 24, correctly represents the number of years that passed from the burning of Moscow suburbs until the Nogai raids within sight of Moscow.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context provides the year of the burning of the suburbs of Moscow as 1592.", "The context also states that the Nogai raids within sight of Moscow occurred during the Time of Troubles, which is mentioned as starting in 1614.", "The difference between 1614 (the year the Nogai raids began) and 1592 (the year the suburbs were burned) is 24 years.", "The answer provided, 24, correctly represents the number of years that passed from the burning of Moscow suburbs until the Nogai raids within sight of Moscow.'" ]

{ "_id": "be36ba97-e539-4d4c-86b0-e04f98111a55", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The context mentions two specific field goals within the range of 20 to 30 yards: one by the 49ers from 31 yards out and another by David Akers from 37 yards.', 'The other field goals mentioned in the context are from 25 yards, 55 yards, and 24 yards, which are outside the 20 to 30 yards range specified in the question.', 'Therefore, only two field goals fit the criteria of being between 20 and 30 yards, not three as stated in the answer.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The context mentions two specific field goals within the range of 20 to 30 yards: one by the 49ers from 31 yards out and another by David Akers from 37 yards.", "The other field goals mentioned in the context are from 25 yards, 55 yards, and 24 yards, which are outside the 20 to 30 yards range specified in the question.", "Therefore, only two field goals fit the criteria of being between 20 and 30 yards, not three as stated in the answer.'" ]

{ "_id": "6acd6dec-a558-403a-97a4-9e8107760fe2", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks which group from the census is smaller between German and Italian.', 'The context provides specific percentages for the ancestry of the population: 22.5% were of German ancestry and 9.8% were of Italian ancestry.', 'From the percentages given, the Italian group (9.8%) is smaller than the German group (22.5%).', \"The answer 'German' incorrectly identifies the German group as smaller, whereas the context clearly shows that the Italian group is smaller.\"], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks which group from the census is smaller between German and Italian.", "The context provides specific percentages for the ancestry of the population: 22.5% were of German ancestry and 9.8% were of Italian ancestry.", "From the percentages given, the Italian group (9.8%) is smaller than the German group (22.5%).', \"The answer 'German' incorrectly identifies the German group as smaller, whereas the context clearly shows that the Italian group is smaller.\"" ]

{ "_id": "928fd407-19d7-4a38-97d3-3022ec48f01c", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not Italian.', 'The context provides that 9.8% of the population were of Italian ancestry.', 'To find the percentage of the population that were not Italian, one would subtract the percentage of Italian ancestry from 100%.', '100% - 9.8% = 90.2%.', 'The answer provided is 89.8%, which does not match the calculated value of 90.2%.', 'Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context as it does not accurately reflect the subtraction of the Italian percentage from the total.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks for the percentage of the population that were not Italian.", "The context provides that 9.8% of the population were of Italian ancestry.", "To find the percentage of the population that were not Italian, one would subtract the percentage of Italian ancestry from 100%.", "100% - 9.8% = 90.2%.", "The answer provided is 89.8%, which does not match the calculated value of 90.2%.", "Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the context as it does not accurately reflect the subtraction of the Italian percentage from the total.'" ]

{ "_id": "284dae0c-53fa-4b20-8162-37028792481c", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": ['The question asks which was burned first between the city of Ryazan and the suburbs of Moscow.', 'The context provides specific years for both the city of Ryazan and the suburbs of Moscow being burned.', 'According to the context, the city of Ryazan posad was burned in 1564.', 'The suburbs of Moscow were burned in 1592.', 'Comparing the years, 1564 (Ryazan) occurred before 1592 (Moscow suburbs).', 'Therefore, the correct answer should be the city of Ryazan, not the suburbs of Moscow.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "'The question asks which was burned first between the city of Ryazan and the suburbs of Moscow.", "The context provides specific years for both the city of Ryazan and the suburbs of Moscow being burned.", "According to the context, the city of Ryazan posad was burned in 1564.", "The suburbs of Moscow were burned in 1592.", "Comparing the years, 1564 (Ryazan) occurred before 1592 (Moscow suburbs).", "Therefore, the correct answer should be the city of Ryazan, not the suburbs of Moscow.'" ]

{ "_id": "8d865c44-8b45-42f4-bd6a-65651f363667", "label": "FAIL", "text": " \n{\"REASONING\": [\"The context describes the Bills' performance in a specific game against the New England Patriots, detailing their scoring and injuries throughout the game.\", \"The context does not provide information about the Bills' win-loss record before this game, including how many games they had won prior to this particular game.\", \"The answer '1' does not directly correlate with any specific information given in the context about the Bills' win-loss record before this game.\", 'The context focuses on the details of the game itself, not on the Bills's overall win-loss record, which is what the question is asking about.'], \"SCORE\": FAIL}\n" }

[ "\"The context describes the Bills' performance in a specific game against the New England Patriots, detailing their scoring and injuries throughout the game.\", \"The context does not provide information about the Bills' win-loss record before this game, including how many games they had won prior to this particular game.\", \"The answer '1' does not directly correlate with any specific information given in the context about the Bills' win-loss record before this game.\", 'The context focuses on the details of the game itself, not on the Bills's overall win-loss record, which is what the question is asking about.'" ]