Abstract:
Corrosion inhibitor additives are added directly to an aqueous acid solution used in acidizing subterranean formations. The additives comprise a bismuth compound, a quaternary compound, and a surfactant. The corrosion inhibitor is free of toxic Sb and acetylenic compounds.

Description:
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 
     This invention relates generally to corrosion inhibitors and more specifically to the use of corrosion inhibitors containing quaternary/bismuth complex in acid solutions used in treatment of subterranean formations. In one aspect, the invention relates to the direct addition of the corrosion inhibitor additives to the aqueous acid solution used in well acidizing. 
     DESCRIPTION OF THE PRIOR ART 
     Acids and acid solutions have long been used in the stimulation of oil wells, gas wells, water wells, and similar boreholes. Acid stimulation is performed in wells completed in subterranean formations. Acidizing is used in conjunction with hydraulic fracturing techniques and matrix acidizing techniques. In both acid fracturing and matrix acidizing, the well treating acid solutions, usually HCl, HF, or mixtures thereof, are pumped through the well tubular goods and injected into the formation where the acid attacks formation materials increasing its permeability to oil and/or gas. 
     In order to protect the equipment and tubular goods from the corrosive effects of the acid, the well treating acid almost always includes a corrosion inhibitor. 
     Corrosion inhibitors of diverse description and composition have been proposed over the years for use with well treating acids. Corrosion inhibitors that have received wide spread use are those containing metal/quaternary ammonium complexes. Some of these are described in the following U.S. Pat. Nos.: 3,773,465 (cuprous iodide); 4,498,997; 4,522,658; and 4,552,672 (antimony compounds). 
     The cuprous complexes are of limited utility since they do not provide satisfactory protection at 300 degrees Fahrenheit and above. 
     A problem associated with the use of antimony is its toxicity. Moreover, the antimony complexes are used with acetylenic alcohol which is also toxic. There, accordingly, is the need for a nontoxic metal that complexes with the quaternary compounds for use in acid systems without acetylenic alcohol. 
     SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
     The method of the present invention employs bismuth compounds for complexing with quaternary compounds in the acid. The low toxicity of Bi, coupled with the fact that the system is free of Sb and acetylenics, results in an environmentally safe corrosion inhibitor. 
     It has been discovered that for the corrosion inhibitors containing Bi/quaternary complexes by direct addition to the acid to be effective, the acid corrosion inhibitor (ACI) system must be carefully prepared. The ACI system for protecting steel tubulars must contain the following additives which are individually added to the acid systems. 
     (a) bismuth compound; 
     (b) quaternary compound capable of forming a complex with Bi ions; and 
     (c) surfactant that matches the type and strength of the acid and steel tubular goods. 
     For most acid systems the choice of surfactant depends on the strength of HCl or HCl/HF employed. For example, at 20% HCl the surfactant may have a hydrophilic-Lipophilic balance (HLB) from 1 to about 16. However, as acid strength reduces, the surfactant must be more and more &#34;oil loving&#34;; that is the HLB must become lower and lower. Tests have shown the following relationship exists for acid strength and the HLB of the surfactant: 
     (a) The acid solutions must contain between 71/2 to 20% HCl or for mud acid 21% HCl. Systems outside this range do not work regardless of the surfactant; 
     (b) For solutions containing 15 to 24% total acid, the HLB must range from 1 to 16; 
     (c) For solutions containing less than 15% total acid down to 10% total acid, the HLB must range from 1 to 3.5; and 
     (d) For solutions containing less than 10% total acid, the HLB must range from greater than 1 to less than 3 (preferably 2 to 2.5). 
     Tests have also demonstrated that the in situ generation of ACI&#39;s of the present invention in both HCl and mud acid systems, without Sb or acetylenic alcohols, are effective and are low in toxicity, making them far safer than the Sb containing ACI&#39;s. 
     Surprisingly, it has been found that the bismuth containing corrosion inhibitor additives described above, when added directly to the aqueous acid solution, exhibits excellent dispersion and gives satisfactory acid corrosion protection comparable with conventional corrosion inhibitor containing toxic antimony and acetylenic alcohol. 
     The concentrations of the three additives in the acid solution are as follows: 
     
         ______________________________________                           MOST     BROAD     PREFERRED   PREFERRED     RANGE     RANGE       RANGECOMPONENT (wt %)    (wt %)      (wt %)______________________________________Bismuth   .10 to 4.0                .2 to 2.0   .4 to 1.4CompoundQuaternary     0.2 to 10 0.4 to 5.0  0.4 to 2.2CompoundSurfactant     0.1 to 25 0.1 to 5.0  0.1 to 1.5______________________________________ 
    
     Generally, the component ranges are interchangeable. For example, the most preferred range of a metal component may be used with both the broad and preferred ranges of the other components. 
     The corrosion inhibitor components are separately introduced into the well treating acid at a concentration sufficient to coat the well tubulars and equipment. The concentration of each component in the acid solution should generally be sufficient to provide the acid solution with from 0.10 wt % to 4.0 wt % of Bi compound, or from 0.09 to 3.5 wt % of the Bi ion. 
     The method of the present invention provides effective corrosion high temperature protection associated with metal salt complexes and employs low toxicity additives (e.g., surfactant, quaternary, and Bi) which are separately dispersible in the aqueous acid solution. The method of the present invention offers the operational advantage of direct addition and dispersion in the acidizing solution without preformulation. The corrosion inhibitors with acetylenic compounds of the prior art generally required solvents and premixture of at least some of the components. 
    
    
     DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS 
     As indicated above, the method of the present invention employs three additives which combine in situ when added to a well treating acid solution to provide effective corrosion inhibition. Each of these compounds as well as the acid solution in which they are used are described below. 
     Aqueous Acid Solutions: Any of the common oil field acids (e.g., HCl systems and mud acid systems) may be used. These are referred to herein as &#34;well treating acids&#34; and include aqueous solutions of hydrochloric acid (HCl), hydrofluoric acid (HF) and mixtures of HCl and HF (i.e., mud acid). The HCl acids useable in the method of the present invention include those containing from 71/2 to 20% HCl. The mud acids useable in the method of the present invention include those containing from 9 to 21% HCl and from 1 to 6% HF. All percentages for the additives recited herein are by wt. unless otherwise indicated. 
     Bismuth Compounds: The function of the bismuth is to complex with the quaternary ammonium compound and form a protective deposit on the metal tubulars and equipment. 
     The preferred bismuth compounds are the salts such as BiCl3, or BiOCl and the oxide (Bi203) which is converted to BiCl3, or BiOCl upon addition to the acid. 
     The bismuth compound may comprise, for example, bismuth trichloride, bismuth triiodide, bismuth trifluoride, alkali metal salts of bismuth tartrate, bismuth adducts of ethylene glycol, and bismuth trioxide or any other trivalent bismuth compound and the like. As mentioned above, the bismuth oxides may be converted to halide salts in the presence of aqueous acid. 
     Quaternary Compounds: The quaternary ammonium compounds (referred to as &#34;quaternary&#34; herein) employed in the present invention must be capable of complexing with the bismuth ions. The preferred quaternary comprise aromatic nitrogen compounds which may be illustrated by alkyl pyridine-N-methyl chloride quaternary alkyl pyridine-N-benzyl chloride quaternary, quinoline-N-methyl chloride quaternary, quinoline-N-benzyl chloride quaternary, quinoline-N-(chloro-benzyl chloride) quaternary, isoquinoline quaternaries, benzoquinoline quaternaries, chloromethyl naphthalene quaternaries, chloromethyl naphthalene quinoline quaternaries, and admixtures of such compounds, and the like. The most preferred quaternaries are those containing a benzyl group. These have proven effective in weak HCl solutions (7.5-10%). The quaternary compound and Bi may be used in molar ratios of 1:1 to 5:1. Generally, the quaternary compound, because of its higher molecular weight, will be present in the acid solution at a higher concentration than the metal compound. The weight ratios of the quaternary compound and the Bi preferably range from 1:1 to 4:1. 
     The Surfactant: The surfactant serves to wet the tubular goods to permit deposition of the quaternary/metal complex. The preferred surfactants are nonionics having hydrophilic-lipophilic balance (HLB) numbers which must be tailored to fit the acid strength being pumped into the well. The relationship of HLB to acid concentration may be expressed as a Ratio of the HLB/wt % acid. This relationship for most systems is as follows: 
     (a) For acid solutions containing from 15 to 20% HCl, the Ratio ranges from 0.050 to 0.80; and 
     (b) For acid solutions containing less than 15% HCl (e.g., 12%, 10%, and 7.5%), the Ratio ranges from 0.25 to 0.33. 
     Nonionic surfactants include the polyoxyethylene surfactants (such as ethoxylated alkyl phenols, ethoxylated aliphatic alcohols) polyethylene glycol esters of fatty, resin, and tall oil acids. Examples of such surfactants are polyoxyethylene alkyl phenol wherein the alkyl group is linear or branched C8-C12 and contains above about 40-50 wt % polyoxyethylene. Octyl and nonyl phenols containing 6 to 12 moles ethylene oxide per mole hydrophobe are the preferred ethoxylated alkyl phenol surfactants. 
     The polyoxyethylene ester of fatty acids include the mono and dioleates and sesquioleates wherein the molecular weight of the esterified polyethylene glycol is between about 200 and 1000. Polyoxyethylene sorbitan oleates are also useable. 
     In addition to the above, ethoxylated nonylphenol/formaldehyde resins and ethoxylated polypropylene glycol coupled with diglycidyl ether of Bisphenol A are useful. Also ethoxylated fatty amines were found useful. 
     Operation: In operation, the three additives described above are added to the aqueous acid solution at the well site. The additives may be added in any order but preferably are in the following order: (1) surfactant; (2) bismuth compound; and (3) quaternary compound. The concentration of quaternary/metal complex in the acid solution should preferably provide a bismuth compound concentration of a least 0.10 wt %. 
     The procedure for preparing the inhibited acid for pumping down the well is preferably by a batch process. In this process, the additives are blended into the aqueous acid solution in a large tank and then pumped into the well. 
     It has been found that the direct addition of the additives requires only a few minutes for dispersion and complexing to occur, so that any pumping process including the continuous process may be employed. The batch process, however, is preferred because it assures adequate conditioning of the corrosion inhibitor in the acid prior to pumping. 
     The method of the present invention can be used in wells to protect tubular goods made of typical oil field tubular carbon steels such as J-55, N-80, P-105, and the like; or made of high alloy chrome duplex steels such as Cr-9, Cr-13, Cr-2205, Cr-2250, and the like. 
     EXPERIMENTS 
     In order to demonstrate the effectiveness of the corrosion inhibitor additives added directly to the acid solution, several samples were tested using various components. The additives used in the tests were as follows. 
     Surfactants 
     1. Nonylphenol/formaldehyde resin with 10 moles ethylene oxide per phenol residue. The HLB value is about 3. 
     2. Nonylphenol/formaldehyde resin with 11.5 moles ethylene oxide per phenol residue. The HLB is about 3.5. 
     3. PPG, chain extended with diglycidyl ether of bisphenol A and oxyakylated with ethylene oxide and propylene oxide. The HLB is about 1. 
     4. Nonylphenol with 10 moles ethylene oxide. The HLB is 13.4. 
     5. Nonylphenol with 20 moles ethylene oxide. The HLB is 16. 
     6. Polyoxythylene (23) lauryl ether, HLB is about 16.9. 
     7. Polyethoxylated (5) octadecylamine, HLB is about 8-9. 
     8. Proprietary blend sold by Callaway Chemical, HLB is 10. 
     9. Polyethoxylated (5) castor oil, HLB about 4.4 
     BISMUTH COMPOUND 
     (a) BiCl3 
     (b) Bi203 (this reacts with HCl to form BiOCl, BiCl3 or HBiCl4 depending on HCl acid strength) 
     Quaternary Compounds 
     X Sixty percent benzyl/quinoline quaternary. 
     Y Sixty percent alpha-chloromethylnapthalene/ quinoline quaternary. 
     Acids 
     1. HCl acid was prepared at strengths of 28 24 22,20, 15, 12, 10, and 7.5 wt %. 
     2. HCl/HF acid was prepared at strengths of 22.5/1.5, 21/3, 18.5/1.5, 17/3, 13.5/1.5, 12/3, 10/1.5, 9/3, 7.5/1.5, 6/3. and 6/1/2. 
     The procedure for preparing the aqueous acid solution with inhibitor additives and test procedure was as follows: 
     (1) The appropriate acid strength was prepared by dilution of 37% HCl with deionized water and where required with the addition of ammonium bifluoride. 
     (2) To 100 ml of aqueous acid were added the surfactant, the bismuth compound, and the ammonium quaternary compound. 
     (3) The coupons (N-80 steel or Cr-2205) were then put in the acid solution with the additives and heated to 350 degrees Fahrenheit under 3,000 psi for four hours. 
     (4) The coupons were then removed and cleaned, the weight loss measured, and the corrosion rate calculated. 
     Three series of tests were carried out: 
     1. Series I tested the effect of acid strength on corrosion rates using N-80 steel coupons. (Table I data). 
     2. Series II tested the effect of the surfactant on corrosion rates using N-80 steel coupons. (Table II data). 
     3. Series III tested the effect of the surfactant at various acid strengths on corrosion rates using CR-2205 coupons. (Table III data). 
     The effect of acid strength on the usefulness of this corrosion inhibitor package is illustrated in TABLE I. Acid strength is varied from 28 wt % HCl down to 6 wt % HCl/1.5 wt % HF. For simple HCl acid, the Bi203/Quaternary/Surfactant system works well with Surfactant 2 (HLB is 3.5) from 12 to 20 wt % HCl. For the HCl/HF acid systems, the effective concentration are from 9/3 (12% total acid) to 21/3 (24% total acid) wt % HCl/HF. Changing the quaternary compound from X to Y had no effect and changing the surfactant concentration only, had no effect. 
     
                                           TABLE I__________________________________________________________________________QUAT.         SURF.            CORR. RATETYPE AMT.    ACID TYPE             HLB                AMT.                    Bi                      AMT.                          LB/SQ. FT.                                  Protection__________________________________________________________________________X    2 ml    28   2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          1.1681  NoX    2 ml    25/3 2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          1.2326  NoX    2 ml    24.0 2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          1.1731  NoX    2 ml    22.5/1.5         2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          1.3319  NoX    2 ml    22.0 2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          1.0206  NoX    2 ml    21/3 2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.0091  YesY    2 ml    20.0 2   (3.5)                 1 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.0089  YesX    2 ml    20.0 2   (3.5)                 1 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.0184  YesX    2 ml    20   2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.0054  YesX    2 ml    18.5/1.5         2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.0041  YesX    2 ml    17/3 2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.0036  YesY    2 ml    15.0 2   (3.5)                 1 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.0101  YesX    2 ml    15.0 2   (3.5)                 1 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.0169  YesX    2 ml    15   2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.0058  YesX    2 ml    13.5/1.5         2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.0027  YesX    2 ml    12/3 2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.0031  YesX    2 ml    12.0 2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.0182  YesX    2 ml    10/1.5         2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.0134  YesY    2 ml    10.0 2   (3.5)                 1 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.5796  NoX    2 ml    10.0 2   (3.5)                 1 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.5931  NoX    2 ml    09/3 2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.0184  YesX    2 ml    07.5/1.5         2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.5094  NoY    2 ml    07.5 2   (3.5)                 1 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.2739  NoX    2 ml    07.5 2   (3.5)                 1 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.4275  NoX    2 ml    07.5 2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.4275  NoX    2 ml    06/3 2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.4184  NoX    2 ml    06/1.5         2   (3.5)                .4 ml                    b 1 gm.                          0.4304  No__________________________________________________________________________ 
    
     TABLE II illustrates the effect of various surfactants on the usefulness of the Bi/quaternary complex in various acid systems with N-80 coupons. Above 24 wt % total acid, the complex was not effective in controlling acid corrosion. From 15% to 24% total acid, surfactants with HLB&#39;s between about 1 to about 16 were found to work well. For less than 15% HCl, the high HLB surfactants were found to be less effective. Those surfactants with HLB&#39;s below 3.5 gave good results. At 10% HCl, Surfactant 1 gave acceptable results and it has a HLB of about 3. For 71/2% HCl, combinations of Surfactants with HLB&#39;s of 2-2.5 were found effective. 
     
                                           TABLE II__________________________________________________________________________QUAT.         SURF.                CORR. RATETYPE AMT.    ACID TYPE             HLB AMT.   Bi                          AMT.                              LB/SQ. FT.                                      PROTECTION__________________________________________________________________________X    2 ml    28.0 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              1.1681  NoX    2 ml    25/3 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              1.2326  NoX    2 ml    24.0 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              1.1731  NoX    2 ml    22.5/1.5         2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              1.3319  NoX    2 ml    22.0 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              1.0206  NoX    2 ml    21/3 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.0091  YesX    2 ml    20.0 5   (16)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0372  YesY    2 ml    20.0 5   (16)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0054  YesY    2 ml    20.0 4   (13.4)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0063  YesX    2 ml    20.0 4   (13.4)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0061  YesX    2 ml    20.0 3   (1) 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0303  YesY    2 ml    20.0 3   (1) 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0988  YesY    2 ml    20.0 2   (3.5)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0089  YesX    2 ml    20.0 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.0054  YesX    2 ml    20.0 2   (3.5)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0184  YesY    2 ml    20.0 1   (3) 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0061  YesX    2 ml    20.0 1   (3) 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              1.0517  NoX    2 ml    18.5/1.5         2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.0041  YesX    2 ml    17/3 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.0074  YesX    2 ml    17/3 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.0036  YesX    2 ml    17/3 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.0039  YesY    2 ml    15.0 5   (16)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.8261  NoX    2 ml    15.0 5   (16)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.8682  NoY    2 ml    15.0 4   (13.4)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0355  YesY    1 ml    15.0 3/2 (2) .4/.4 ml                        b 1 gm.                              0.0315  YesY    1 ml    15.0 3/2 (2) .4/.4 ml                        b 1 gm.                              0.0306  YesY    2 ml    15.0 3   (1) 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0296  YesX    2 ml    15.0 2   (3.5)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0169  YesY    2 ml    15.0 2   (3.5)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0101  YesX    2 ml    15.0 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.0058  YesY    1 ml    15.0 7/6 (3.5)                 .2/.3 ml                        b 1 gm.                              0.5318  NoX    2 ml    15.0 1   (3) 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0212  YesY    2 ml    15.0 1   (3) 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0169  YesX    2 ml    13.5/1.5         2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.0027  YesY    1 ml    12/3 3/2 (2.2)                 .4/.4 ml                        b 1 gm.                              0.0128  YesX    2 ml    12/3 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.0031  YesY    1 ml    12/3 7/6 (12.7)                 .2/.2 ml                        b 1 gm.                              0.0074  YesX    2 ml    12.0 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.0182  YesX    2 ml    09/3 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.0184  YesX    2 ml    10/1.5         2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.0134  YesX    2 ml    10.0 5   (16)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.5921  NoX    2 ml    10.0 5   (16)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.5943  NoY    2 ml    10.0 4   (13)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.5826  NoX    2 ml    10.0 4   (13)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.4557  NoX    2 ml    10.0 3   (1) 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.4523  NoY    2 ml    10.0 3   (1) 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.5892  NoY    2 ml    10.0 2   (3.5)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.5796  NoX    2 ml    10.0 2   (3.5)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.5931  NoY    2 ml    10.0 1   (3) 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.5821  NoX    2 ml    10.0 1   (3) 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.0523  YesX    2 ml    07.5/1.5         2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.5094  NoY    1 ml    07.5 9   (4.3)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.3443  NoY    1 ml    07.5 8   (10)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.3693  NoY    1 ml    07.5 7/6 (13.7)                 .2/.3 ml                        b 1 gm.                              0.3615  NoX    4 ml    07.5 3/2/1             (2.5)                 .95/.95/.8 ml                        b 2 gm.                              0.0406  YesX    4 ml    07.5 3/1 (2) .95/.95 ml                        b 2 gm.                              0.0409  YesX    2 ml    07.5 3/1 (2) .95/.95 ml                        b 1 gm.                              0.0451  YesX    4 ml    07.5 3/1 (2) .95/.95 ml                        b 1 gm.                              0.0355  YesX    2 ml    07.5 2   (3.5)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.4275  NoY    2 ml    07.5 2   (3.5)                 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.2739  NoX    2 ml    07.5 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.4285  NoX    2 ml    07.5 1   (3) 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.4275  NoY    2 ml    07.5 1   (3) 1 ml   b 1 gm.                              0.3861  NoX    2 ml    06/3 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.4184  NoX    2 ml    06/1.5         2   (3.5)                 .4 ml  b 1 gm.                              0.4304  No__________________________________________________________________________ 
    
     TABLE III illustrates the effects of both acid strength and surfactant on the usefulness of the Bi/Quaternary complex with chrome alloy steel. High HLB and low HLB surfactants were compared as well as combination of surfactants. Above 15% total acid both types of surfactants failed to give satisfactory results. For 15% HCl and 12/3 mud acid, both worked well. Below 12/3 mud acid or 12% HCl, both types failed to give satisfactory results. 
     
                                           TABLE III__________________________________________________________________________QUAT.         SURF.               CORR. RATETYPE AMT.    ACID TYPE             HLB AMT.  Bi                         AMT.                             LB/SQ. FT.                                     PROTECTION__________________________________________________________________________X    2 ml    22   5   (16)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             1.0325  NoX    2 ml    20   2   (3.5)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.9547  NoX    2 ml    18.5/1.5         5   (16)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             1.1007  NoX    2 ml    17/3 5   (16)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             1.1348  NoX    2 ml    17/3 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.4242  NoY    2 ml    15   5   (16)                 .6 ml b 1 gm.                             0.0059  YesX    2 ml    15   5   (16)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.0091  YesX    2 ml    15   2   (3.5)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.0121  YesX    2 ml    15   2   (3.5)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.0178  YesX    2 ml    13.5/1.5         5   (16)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.0296  YesY    3 ml    12/3 5/3/1             (4.1)                 .1/.1/.8 ml                       b 1 gm.                             0.0967  Marg.X    3 ml    12/3 5/3/1             (4.6)                 .1/.1/.5 ml                       b 1 gm.                             0.2631  NoX    2 ml    12/3 5   (16)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.1099  Marg.X    3 ml    12/3 3/1 (2) .2/.2 ml                       b 1 gm.                             0.0102  YesY    3 ml    12/3 3/1 (2) .1/.1 ml                       b 1 gm.                             0.0531  Marg.Y    3 ml    12/3 3/1 (2) .2/.2 ml                       b 1 gm.                             0.0795  Marg.X    3 ml    12/3 3/1 (2) .1/.1 ml                       b 1 gm.                             0.0121  YesX    2 ml    12/3 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.0279  YesX    2 ml    12   5   (16)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.1345  NoX    2 ml    10   5   (16)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.4995  NoX    2 ml    07.5 5   (16)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.3954  NoX    2 ml    07.5 2   (3.5)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.3159  NoX    2 ml    06/3 5   (16)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.5352  NoX    2 ml    06/1.5         5   (16)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.4561  NoX    2 ml    06/1.5         2   (3.5)                 .4 ml b 1 gm.                             0.3569  No__________________________________________________________________________ 
    
     Tests have shown that acid corrosion inhibitors in acid systems containing 10% or less HCl were not effective in protecting chrome alloys. 
     The above laboratory experiments demonstrate the criticalilty in adjusting the surfactant to a particular acid system. It is this discovery that enables a low toxic metal Bi to be successfully adapted for commercial acidizing operations. The Sb ACI&#39;s do not exhibit the dependence on the surfactant HLB.