411 and 412 of 1982 of Sherkot da Police Station as shown at Serial Nos. 2 and 3 in the tab le appended to grounds of detention which fact would ha ve influenced the minds of the detaining authority one way or the other on the question whether or not to make the dete n tion order, has not been placed before the detaining autho r ity and this non placing and the consequent non consider a tion of the said material likely to influence the minds of the detaining authority vitiates the subjective satisfacti on and invalidates the detention order; (2) Leave apart, t he non disclosure of the names of the witnesses on whose stat e ments the detaining authority placed reliance to draw h is subjective satisfaction, claiming privilege under Secti on 9(2) of the Act, the grounds of detention otherwise a re vague or deficient and lacking details with regards to t he names of the 'associates ', for the disclosure of which no privilege could be claimed and hence it was not possible f or the detenu in the absence of the names of the so call ed 'associates ' to make an effective representation against t he order of detention, the deprivation of which amounts to an infringement of the 47 constitutional safeguard provided under Article 22(5) of t he Constitution of India; (3) Though the authority has me n tioned in more than one place the words 'your associate s ' which fact evidently should have influenced the mind of t he detaining authority in making this impugned order, the nam es of the associates are nowhere disclosed which fact wou ld show either the authority did not know as to who the assoc i ates were or knowing the names of the associates, he h as refrained from furnishing it to the detenu thereby disabli ng the detenu to make his effective representation; and (4) T he materials placed before the detaining authority were hard ly sufficient to draw any conclusion that the alleged activ i ties of the detenu were detrimental to the ' ' maintenan ce of public order. ' ' A plethora of decisions were cited by Dr. Chitale.