By its decision dated 29 4 1955 the Appellate Tribunal substantially modified the award of Shri Banerji in favour of the Union it held (1) that the minimum pay of the clerical and sub staff should be raised, and that corresponding changes should be made in the ceiling level, in the increments and in the scales of pay of other grades of the staff; (2) that the scale of pay of the sarkars and checkers should be increased and incre 784 ments given as laid down in the award; (3) that the employees should be paid a month 's bonus in addition to what had been given to them; and (4) that of the employees, Shambunath Chatterjee, Ashimananda Banerjee and Panchanan Rana should not merely be re employed but reinstated with continuity of service, and that further Shambunath Chatterjee was entitled to compensation at the rate of six months ' basic wages with dearness allowance.