Therein the learned judges observed thus: "As however the case may not stop here, we think it right to allow the petitioners in Civil Miscellaneous Petitions Nos. 845 and 1655 of 1915 for the admission of certain documents rejected by the Subordinate Judge, namely (1) the decree of the Zilah Court of Tinnevelly, dated 31st May 1859 in Original Suit No. 4 of 1859, (2) the Takid of the Collector to the Muzumdar on the death of the raja in 1850, (3) the reply of the Muzumdar and (4) the Collector 's Takid in 1853 on the complaint of the zamindar 's widow as to the conduct of Maruthappa Thevar who according to the plaintiff 's case was the father of Gnanapurani 's mother.