she stayed with them only for a few days; that she '" refused permission to go to Poona even when her uncle died; that her parents in law,, not only said many 25 2 S C India/64 378 dirty things of her but they did not allow her to speak to her son ; that when her father in law scolded her son, he started weeping and she was scolded for interfering : that this incident happened in 1953 and that since then her husband ceased to talk with her ; that she was also prevented by her mother in law from doing any work for her husband or for her son, that she was also beaten by her husband sometimes ; that she was not allowed to see her child when he was ill; that in 1951 she heard that her husband attempted to remarry and even asked her to sign a paper giving her consent for him to do so that she was made to sleep on a bench in the drawing room till about the year 1952 and thereafter on the floor as her mother in law did not provide her with a bed.