On the other hand, even if it be accepted that Captain Browne 's Sanad created a Government Ghatwali tenure then, in the language of Lord Sumner in Narayan Singh vs Niranjan Chakravarti (supra) at p. 54 it might well be said that Raja Kadir Ali 's Sanad issued during the time Mr. Cleveland, the Collector of Bhagalpur, was managing the Mahalat of Kharakpur, and never objected to or questioned at any time thereafter by the Government "amounted to a release by the Government of the Ghatwali services or to a grant to a third party of the right to receive them and of the right to appoint the Ghatwali and, therefore, the original Govern ment Ghatwali tenure came to an end and a Zamindari Ghatwali tenure took its place.