shionhonda/tiny-llama-reviewer2-1.1B-dpo-lora
Text Generation
•
Updated
•
134
rejected
stringlengths 62
337
| chosen
stringlengths 57
287
| prompt
stringlengths 211
1.02k
|
|---|---|---|
The dataset contains high-quality climate data for a large number of models and scenarios. It provides a valuable resource for researchers in the field of climate modeling. | The dataset used in the paper is too small and not representative of the real-world climate data. The paper lacks in experimental validation and does not provide an accurate evaluation of the proposed model's performance. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
ClimateSet: A Large-Scale Climate Model Dataset for Machine Learning</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed approach shows remarkable robustness in the reward scale and has shown promising results on the Robust Mini-Batch SARSA and Double Deep Q-Network (DDQN) benchmarks. | The proposed method has not been thoroughly evaluated and lacks in practical applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Reward Scale Robustness for Proximal Policy Optimization via DreamerV3 Tricks</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents sample complexity bounds for score-matching methods for causal discovery and generative modeling tasks. These bounds provide a better understanding of the sample complexity and are helpful in designing more efficient algorithms. | The paper presents a theoretical analysis of the sample complexity for score-matching algorithms in causal discovery and generative modeling. However, its findings lack experimental validation and are not widely applied. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Sample Complexity Bounds for Score-Matching: Causal Discovery and Generative Modeling</s>
<|assistant|>
|
This is an interesting approach to federated AUC maximization that has not been explored much. The paper presents a framework for combining multiple deep AUCs from different data sources, and achieves competitive performance. | The proposed approach is not well-defined, and there is no experimental evidence to support the effectiveness of its proposed methods. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Federated Compositional Deep AUC Maximization</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper examines the limits of adaptive linear models for low-dimensional data, and provides empirical evidence to support their inability to accurately model the underlying distribution. The paper also discusses the challenges of adaptive linear models in real | The paper has a limited scope and focuses on a specific statistical method. The proposed method is not widely applicable or practical. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Statistical Limits of Adaptive Linear Models: Low-Dimensional Estimation and Inference</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes direction-oriented multi-objective learning, which is simple and provably robust. It provides a framework for learning a set of decision variables that are optimized using a stochastic algorithm. | The proposed method is mathematically sound and has been experimentally validated in some cases. However, it lacks in practical applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Direction-oriented Multi-objective Learning: Simple and Provable Stochastic Algorithms</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed method offers a novel approach to Bayesian inference in infinite dimensions. It has shown promising results in practice. | The proposed method has significant limitations in finite dimensions and is not suitable for Bayesian inference in infinite dimensions. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Conditional score-based diffusion models for Bayesian inference in infinite dimensions</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed method is provably efficient and achieves good performance in both offline and online settings. | The proposed approach is not provably efficient and lacks in practicality. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Provably Efficient Offline Goal-Conditioned Reinforcement Learning with General Function Approximation and Single-Policy Concentrability</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a new approach for selecting data points in the geometric space, which is computationally efficient and can handle large datasets. | The proposed approach lacks practical applications and is not well-defined in terms of the specific problem it seeks to solve. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Data-Informed Geometric Space Selection</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper provides a novel approach to quantify the cost of learning in queueing systems, which can be useful in modeling and analyzing real-world queuing systems. | The paper is not scientifically sound and lacks in rigor. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantifying the Cost of Learning in Queueing Systems</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed method, based on the concept of factoring, is a new way of shuffling and superposing quantum states. The method allows for a significant reduction in the number of state preparation and measurement operations required for quantum computing. | The proposed method is not implemented and does not provide a clear explanation of the algorithm. The paper lacks originality and is not an improvement on existing methods in the field. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
FouriDown: Factoring Down-Sampling into Shuffling and Superposing</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed method is a novel approach to solve inverse problems by using data consistency constraints. The method is designed to solve inverse problems by minimizing the difference between the observed and predicted data. The method is effective in solving inverse problems, especially when the | The proposed method is not practical or useful in solving inverse problems due to its inability to handle non-linear data. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Direct Diffusion Bridge using Data Consistency for Inverse Problems</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a communication-efficient federated bilevel optimization algorithm that can simultaneously solve both the global and local lower-level problems. The proposed method improves the convergence rate of the federated bilevel optimization algorithm. | The proposed method is not practical for large-scale problems due to its communication complexity. Additionally, the proposed method doesn't address the limitations of the original bilevel optimization problem, such as the need for a global lower-level optimization problem and | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Communication-Efficient Federated Bilevel Optimization with Global and Local Lower Level Problems</s>
<|assistant|>
|
This paper proposes a new pre-training paradigm for language modeling, which significantly improves the performance of transformer models on a range of datasets. | The paper proposes a new pre-training paradigm, which is still in the experimental stage. It is unclear whether it will be successful in improving pre-training performance. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Meet in the Middle: A New Pre-training Paradigm</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper describes a text-guided multilingual universal speech generation system that generates speech in multiple languages with high quality and accuracy. The system achieves state-of-the-art results in various benchmarks, including the German and English language | The paper presents a new method for text-guided multilingual universal speech generation at scale. However, the methodology is not thoroughly discussed or evaluated, and the paper lacks in novelty and originality. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Voicebox: Text-Guided Multilingual Universal Speech Generation at Scale</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed method is efficient and effective for sequence modeling. | The proposed method is not practical or scalable. It's an academic paper that doesn't provide any practical implementation or real-world applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Sparse Modular Activation for Efficient Sequence Modeling</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art accuracy on benchmark datasets and can be easily scaled to handle large-scale datasets. | The paper only provides an algorithm for generating high-quality human body mesh models, and the proposed approach lacks in experimental evaluation. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
SMPLer-X: Scaling Up Expressive Human Pose and Shape Estimation</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper introduces a novel approach for analyzing the convergence of a time-varying zero-sum game, which is useful for solving large-scale games in real-world applications. | The paper does not provide any concrete examples or analysis to support the claim. It is not a scientific paper. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
On the Last-iterate Convergence in Time-varying Zero-sum Games: Extra Gradient Succeeds where Optimism Fails</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents an algorithm for learning the efficient frontier in regression analysis. The algorithm is efficient and can handle large datasets. | The paper does not provide practical insights or implementable solutions for designing efficient neural architectures. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Learning the Efficient Frontier</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed framework has the potential to address the limitations of traditional visual active search methods by leveraging partial supervision. It allows for the incorporation of visual information in a partially supervised fashion, leading to more effective search behavior. | The proposed framework uses partial supervision and lacks in real-world applicability. It's not a practical solution for solving complex real-world problems. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
A Partially-Supervised Reinforcement Learning Framework for Visual Active Search</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a new method for 3D object detection in monocular videos, using a 3D copy-paste strategy. The method has been evaluated on a wide range of datasets and achieved state-of-the-art results | The paper proposes a novel 3D object detection method that is not physically plausible. The proposed method is not feasible in real-world applications due to its inability to detect real objects. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
3D Copy-Paste: Physically Plausible Object Insertion for Monocular 3D Detection</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a systematic evaluation and improvement strategy for tool-augmented computation-intensive math reasoning, a problem area in machine learning that involves solving mathematical problems with tools and algorithms. The authors provide insights into how to improve these reasoning | The paper proposes a method for evaluating and improving tool-augmented computation-intensive math reasoning, but it lacks in experimental validation and practical applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Evaluating and Improving Tool-Augmented Computation-Intensive Math Reasoning</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The approach is novel and offers a new way of clustering data. | The proposed contextually affinitive neighborhood refinery method is not well-supported by experimental evidence and lacks practical significance. It is an overly complicated algorithm with no clear advantages over other existing clustering techniques. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Contextually Affinitive Neighborhood Refinery for Deep Clustering</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed neural network model for times series modeling is a new approach that uses a combination of recurrent neural networks and latent variable models. It outperforms the state-of-the-art methods in terms of accuracy and scalability. | The proposed framework is not an accurate representation of times series modeling. It's an attempt to solve a problem that has no real-world applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Neural Lad: A Neural Latent Dynamics Framework for Times Series Modeling</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed criterion is a novel approach to find causal order in additive noise models. It is designed to find the best causal order that minimizes the influence of noise on causal relationships. | The proposed sorting criterion does not seem to be an effective way to identify the causal order in additive noise models. It may also be difficult to apply to real-world scenarios. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
A Scale-Invariant Sorting Criterion to Find a Causal Order in Additive Noise Models</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a novel framework to bridge autoregressive neural networks (ANTN) and tensor networks (TNs) for quantum many-body simulation. The method uses TNs to simulate quantum systems and ANTN to represent | The paper makes significant contributions to the field of quantum many-body simulation, but it is not sufficiently detailed and may contain errors. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
ANTN: Bridging Autoregressive Neural Networks and Tensor Networks for Quantum Many-Body Simulation</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a novel approach to autonomous visual information seeking that leverages a large language model agent to navigate and discover visual information. The method has been tested on several benchmark datasets, and the results are promising. | The proposed approach is not well-designed and lacks in implementation details. It's not practical to use this algorithm in real-world applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
AVIS: Autonomous Visual Information Seeking with Large Language Model Agent</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a novel approach for offline reinforcement learning with heteroskedastic datasets. It shows how to enforce support constraints on the output of a neural network to improve the performance of the algorithm. This approach may be useful for data | The proposed method is not well-designed and lacks in practical implementation. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
ReDS: Offline RL With Heteroskedastic Datasets via Support Constraints</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a self-supervised visual acoustic matching approach that can learn the sound features from an image and match them to audio data. The approach uses unsupervised learning techniques and is able to achieve high performance in audio-visual | The proposed method is not a complete solution for self-supervised visual acoustic matching. It lacks in the ability to handle complex speech and acoustic signals. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Self-Supervised Visual Acoustic Matching</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a new approach for evaluating and learning optimal and fair encouragement policies. The proposed method is designed to provide a rigorous and efficient evaluation of the effectiveness of such policies in terms of their overall outcomes and social fairness | The paper does not offer a concrete solution to the problem of optimal and fair encouragement policy evaluation and learning. It only discusses the theoretical background and implications of the problem. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Optimal and Fair Encouragement Policy Evaluation and Learning</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The MAG-GNN model is an efficient approach for reinforcement learning and graph neural networks. It combines the advantages of both techniques and achieves state-of-the-art performance in various tasks. | The proposed method has not been tested thoroughly, and the implementation is not clear. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
MAG-GNN: Reinforcement Learning Boosted Graph Neural Network</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper describes a novel user-centric interactive platform for embodied AI that provides a personalized and immersive experience for users. The platform incorporates natural language processing, machine learning, and other AI algorithms to provide users with | The proposed system is promising, but it lacks in terms of practicality and usability. It's not clear how it would work in real-life applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Alexa Arena: A User-Centric Interactive Platform for Embodied AI</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a method to mine extra knowledge from a dataset to improve the performance of facial expression recognition. The proposed method is effective in reducing the imbalance in the dataset. | The paper proposes a novel framework for improving the performance of an existing facial expression recognition system but lacks in experimental validation. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Leave No Stone Unturned: Mine Extra Knowledge for Imbalanced Facial Expression Recognition</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed hybrid search approach achieves completeness guarantees for planning problems, which is a significant improvement over previous approaches. | The proposed method has significant limitations in terms of completeness and generality. Additionally, it does not address the issue of time complexity, which is a critical consideration in planning applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
Hybrid Search for Efficient Planning with Completeness Guarantees</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a novel method that combines two existing approaches for geo-localization, i.e., clip-inspired alignment and graph-based alignment. The method is effective and scalable, and the experimental results show promising | The proposed method is a standard geo-localization method that has been used for many years and is widely implemented. It is not new and has been implemented in various applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
GeoCLIP: Clip-Inspired Alignment between Locations and Images for Effective Worldwide Geo-localization</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper introduces Koopman predictors, which are a new approach to learning non-stationary time series dynamics. The method is well-defined and effective in many real-world applications. | The proposed Koopman predictor is not well-suited for learning non-stationary time series dynamics. It does not account for the dynamics of the input variables, which is necessary for accurately predicting time series. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Koopa: Learning Non-stationary Time Series Dynamics with Koopman Predictors</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a novel approach for learning to rank pre-trained models efficiently. The proposed method is efficient and scalable, and the results demonstrate the effectiveness of the approach in different settings. | The proposed method is not practical and has limited applicability to real-world scenarios. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Model Spider: Learning to Rank Pre-Trained Models Efficiently</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper provides a novel approach for multi-agent perception that is communication-efficient and collaborative. The proposed approach aims to address the challenges faced by multi-agent systems in real-world applications. | The proposed method has technical limitations and is not practical in real-world scenarios. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
How2comm: Communication-Efficient and Collaboration-Pragmatic Multi-Agent Perception</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a new approach to text generation that is beyond the maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) method. The approach, called Convex Learning, shows significant improvements over MLE in terms of generation quality and efficiency. | The paper does not provide a rigorous analysis of the proposed convex learning approach for text generation, and does not provide any practical implementation. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Beyond MLE: Convex Learning for Text Generation</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a novel approach for optimising target positions in holographic optogenetics, which is a crucial step in the development of this technology. Bayesian target optimisation has shown promising results in previous studies, and this | The paper lacks in methodological rigor and does not provide practical applications for holographic optogenetics. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Bayesian target optimisation for high-precision holographic optogenetics</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a novel method for compressing neural network models while maintaining their expressive power. The method relies on the Bayesian implicit neural representation, which allows for efficient representation of the input/output relationships in the network while also pres | The paper proposes a new method for compressing and learning neural representations, but it lacks in experimental evaluation. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Compression with Bayesian Implicit Neural Representations</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed method aims to generate a graph with score-based diffusion, which can be used for various applications such as network visualization and recommendation systems. | The proposed method does not seem to be practical for graph generation due to its limited computational complexity. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Multi-resolution Spectral Coherence for Graph Generation with Score-based Diffusion</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents an innovative approach to biplanar X-ray to 3D bone shape reconstruction, using an encoder-decoder architecture. The proposed method outperforms state-of-the-art methods in terms of | The proposed benchmark does not provide a comprehensive evaluation of encoder-decoder architectures for biplanar X-ray to 3D bone shape reconstruction. Therefore, it lacks in novelty and its effectiveness in real- | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Benchmarking Encoder-Decoder Architectures for Biplanar X-ray to 3D Bone Shape Reconstruction</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents an algorithm for exploring significant differences between two samples, with applications to various statistical tests. | The paper discusses the exploration of local significant differences for two-sample tests. However, the discussion is not detailed enough to provide practical solutions for real-world applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
On the Exploration of Local Significant Differences For Two-Sample Test</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed method is an interesting approach that uses cross-modal complementarity to learn self-refining correspondence. It has potential applications in natural language processing, image recognition, and robotics. | The paper proposes a novel idea and does not provide any experimental evidence to support it. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Cross-modal Active Complementary Learning with Self-refining Correspondence</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed strategy is simple yet effective in reducing the vulnerability of meta-learning algorithms to adversarial attacks. | The proposed approach is not a simple strategy but requires careful consideration and implementation in practice. It is not effective in robustifying the meta learning paradigm. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
A Simple Yet Effective Strategy to Robustify the Meta Learning Paradigm</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a novel approach to bridge the gap between labeled and unlabeled data for semi-supervised learning, using cross-sharpness as a bridge between the two datasets. | The proposed method has poor scalability and is not well-suited for semi-supervised learning. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FlatMatch: Bridging Labeled Data and Unlabeled Data with Cross-Sharpness for Semi-Supervised Learning</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a method for learning directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) from data with few root causes. The proposed approach uses a variational autoencoder (VAE) to model the conditional distribution of causal relationships between variables. | The proposed approach is not scalable and may not be effective in real-world applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Learning DAGs from Data with Few Root Causes</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a novel approach to image denoising using normalization-equivariant neural networks (NENNs) that outperforms previous approaches in terms of accuracy and efficiency. The results show that NENNs can be trained | The paper presents a novel method for image denoising, but it lacks in the experimental validation and its theoretical foundation. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Normalization-Equivariant Neural Networks with Application to Image Denoising</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a novel optimization function called "random weight" that outperforms the standard gradient descent training method. The proposed approach is computationally efficient and can be used on large-scale training datasets. | The paper proposes a new training method for image restoration networks but lacks in experiments and practical applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Training Your Image Restoration Network Better with Random Weight Network as Optimization Function</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed FaceComposer is a unified model that combines various facial content creation techniques into a single framework. It achieves impressive results in various domains, such as image synthesis and video editing. | The paper is focused on developing a facial content creation tool, which is still in the early stages of development and lacks in innovative approaches. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
FaceComposer: A Unified Model for Versatile Facial Content Creation</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a new approach for large language models (LLMs) by utilizing tree-structured representations of the LM's output. The authors show that LLMs can be modeled as a tree, allowing for more efficient | The paper's methodology is flawed, and the results are not reproducible. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Tree of Thoughts: Deliberate Problem Solving with Large Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents an original approach to pre-training language models that takes into account the lexical features of the language. The results show that the Lexinvariant approach significantly improves the performance of downstream tasks, such as machine translation, speech recognition | The paper discusses the development of a lexicon-based language model that improves performance in predicting words based on their frequency and context. While the proposed approach has potential applications in various fields, its effectiveness in predicting the frequency of individual | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Lexinvariant Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a novel approach for efficient deep reinforcement learning, which utilizes a multi-policy fusion mechanism. The proposed method significantly improves the performance of the model by reducing the time and memory consumption required for policy evaluation. | The proposed approach is not feasible for practical applications due to its complex implementation and limited scalability. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Flexible Attention-Based Multi-Policy Fusion for Efficient Deep Reinforcement Learning</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed method aims to transfer visual prompts across different LLMs, which is a challenging task in NLP. The paper uses the VPGTrans model to demonstrate the feasibility of this task. | The paper proposes a system for generating visual prompts that can be used across different LLMs. While it has potential, the system is not yet functional and needs further development. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
VPGTrans: Transfer Visual Prompt Generator across LLMs</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents an exact representation of sparse networks with symmetric nonnegative embeddings that are computationally efficient. The proposed embedding provides a theoretical foundation for efficient inference and computation in sparse networks. | The paper presents a new algorithm for sparse networks with symmetric nonnegative embeddings, but it lacks in experimental validation and theoretical guarantees. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Exact Representation of Sparse Networks with Symmetric Nonnegative Embeddings</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents an unified approach to domain incremental learning (DIL), which is a fundamental problem in the field of machine learning. The approach combines a model-based and a model-free approach, and the paper provides theoretical results and | The proposed approach has limited applicability and is not well-researched. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
A Unified Approach to Domain Incremental Learning with Memory: Theory and Algorithm</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a novel approach for prioritizing samples in reinforcement learning with reducible loss. The approach is effective and has been implemented in a real-world context. | The proposed approach is not practical and lacks in mathematical rigor. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Prioritizing Samples in Reinforcement Learning with Reducible Loss</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a comprehensive evaluation framework for mutual information estimators, including both theoretical and empirical results. | The paper does not address the limitations of estimating mutual information using the Kullback-Leibler divergence, and lacks proper evaluation of the performance of estimators for non-normal data. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Beyond Normal: On the Evaluation of Mutual Information Estimators</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a novel method to learn large graph properties from limited data. The approach is well-defined and has shown promising results on benchmark datasets. | The approach proposed in the paper is not new and is not a significant improvement on existing methods. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Learning Large Graph Property Prediction via Graph Segment Training</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a new approach for object detection, which combines Rank-Distributed Embeddings and Decomposition into Transformers. The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art results on various datasets and has shown prom | The proposed method has limited accuracy and is not suitable for high-quality object detection tasks. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Rank-DETR for High Quality Object Detection</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper analyzes the incentive structures in federated learning and provides insights into their equilibrium states, dynamics, and mechanisms for welfare maximization. | The paper is not directly related to incentives in federated learning and lacks a well-defined problem statement. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Incentives in Federated Learning: Equilibria, Dynamics, and Mechanisms for Welfare Maximization</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed approach is an extension of the metric learning framework and provides better performance than the existing methods. | The proposed method is not practical or feasible. The inverted measurement paradigm is a difficult concept to grasp and is not well-defined. The perceptual adjustment queries are not realistic and do not reflect the real-world scenarios | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Perceptual adjustment queries and an inverted measurement paradigm for low-rank metric learning</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a comprehensive analysis of the $H$-consistency bounds for the class of quantum algorithms. It also extends the bounds to more general classes of quantum algorithms. | The paper presents a new approach for characterizing $H$-consistency bounds in statistical learning theory and extends its results to various extensions. However, the paper is not sufficiently detailed and lacks theoretical rigor. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
$H$-Consistency Bounds: Characterization and Extensions</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed triangulation residual loss is a novel approach to improve 3D pose estimation accuracy. The method uses residual connections to regularize the estimation process and significantly reduces the training time. | The proposed method uses a new loss function that overcomes the challenges of limited data in 3D pose estimation. However, it lacks in practical applications and research in this area. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Triangulation Residual Loss for Data-efficient 3D Pose Estimation</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The approach provides a near-optimal reconstruction of spherical harmonic expansions for a large class of functions, including wavelets and wavelet-based filters. | The proposed method is not practical or realistic, as it assumes a specific model of the sphere, and cannot be applied to real-world problems. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Near Optimal Reconstruction of Spherical Harmonic Expansions</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a novel algorithm for finding the optimal step-sizes for stochastic gradient descent with multidimensional backtracking. The proposed algorithm is computationally efficient and provides accurate solutions for a wide range of problems. | The paper proposes a methodology for finding optimal step-sizes for multi-dimensional backtracking search, but its implementation is not clear and does not include any experiments. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Searching for Optimal Per-Coordinate Step-sizes with Multidimensional Backtracking</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed uni-control architecture is an all-in-one solution that enables easy control of diffusion models for text-to-image generation. The paper presents a state-of-the-art methodology that leverages the power of diffusion | The proposed model is not a unified approach to control text-to-image diffusion models. It lacks the necessary components to effectively control and manipulate text. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Uni-ControlNet: All-in-One Control to Text-to-Image Diffusion Models</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper introduces Synthcity, a benchmark framework for diverse use cases of tabular synthetic data, with an emphasis on real-world scenarios. The framework includes a range of synthetic datasets, with a focus on data quality, coverage | The synthetic data benchmark framework Synthcity has limited applicability for diverse use cases. The framework is focused on tabular data, and it does not take into account the other forms of synthetic data that may be relevant. Synthcity should | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Synthcity: a benchmark framework for diverse use cases of tabular synthetic data</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a comprehensive framework for data pre-processing and modeling of continuous-time sequences of complex events. It provides efficient algorithms for generating and manipulating event streams, and offers a flexible and efficient model for generating synthetic data. | The proposed library is not a standard GPT-3-like model and does not have a strong scientific foundation. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Event Stream GPT: A Data Pre-processing and Modeling Library for Generative, Pre-trained Transformers over Continuous-time Sequences of Complex Events</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The method proposed in the paper is a novel approach for optimizing Gaussian mixture policies. The method is based on the Wasserstein gradient flow, which is a recently developed tool for studying stochastic optimization problems. The experimental results show that the proposed method out | The proposed method lacks in experimental implementation and is not well-suited for generalizing to different scenarios. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Wasserstein Gradient Flows for Optimizing Gaussian Mixture Policies</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The name of the movie references a famous piece of filmmaking, but the movie itself is not mentioned. | The name of the movie is a reference to the popular film of the same name. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Segment Everything Everywhere All at Once</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed calibration method is a rigorous approach to address the issue of coverage probability and can be used to improve the performance of neural simulations-based inference. | The approach proposed in the paper is not practical as it requires solving a non-trivial optimization problem. Additionally, it may not generalize to other types of neural simulations and inference methods. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Calibrating Neural Simulation-Based Inference with Differentiable Coverage Probability</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The benchmark is a comprehensive set of experimental and theoretical data on microscopy imaging, providing a testbed for evaluating and comparing different models of channel adaptation. | The paper does not provide a comprehensive analysis of the benchmark and is not widely used for model evaluation. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
CHAMMI: A benchmark for channel-adaptive models in microscopy imaging</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a method for learning policies that can be used in multi-agent systems. The method uses mutual-information regularization to improve the performance of the policy. | The paper lacks in novelty and doesn't provide any practical applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Mutual-Information Regularized Multi-Agent Policy Iteration</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper introduces a new approach to solve spatial puzzles, based on diffusion models. The proposed approach uses a combination of diffusion models and reinforcement learning to solve complex spatial puzzles. | The paper is a theoretical paper that lacks in experimental validation. It mainly focuses on the application of diffusion models in solving spatial puzzles, but lacks in real-world applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Puzzlefusion: Unleashing the Power of Diffusion Models for Spatial Puzzle Solving</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a method for generating behaviorally diverse policies using latent diffusion models, which can be applied to various domains such as reinforcement learning and healthcare. | The paper proposes a method for generating behaviorally diverse policies, but it does not show that the generated policies are truly diverse. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Generating Behaviorally Diverse Policies with Latent Diffusion Models</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed method provides a deep understanding of non-Markovian decision-making and can be used to design new strategies for decision-making tasks. | The proposed approach lacks in real-world applications and has not been thoroughly evaluated. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Learning non-Markovian Decision-Making from State-only Sequences</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a new approach to failure-aware Gaussian process optimization that generates an ensemble of GP models that can learn from multiple sources of failure data. The proposed method is able to generate GP models with improved performance compared to state-of-the | The proposed approach has limitations in terms of accuracy and scalability. Additionally, the implementation in the paper does not guarantee convergence to the optimal solution. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Failure-Aware Gaussian Process Optimization with Regret Bounds</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a novel approach to extend the design space of graph neural networks (GNNs) by rethinking the folklore Weisfeiler-Lehman algorithm. The approach provides new insights and solutions to enhance | The proposed methodology is not new and has been implemented in some existing GNNs. However, its novelty lies in the rethinking of the Folklore Weisfeiler-Lehman algorithm. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Extending the Design Space of Graph Neural Networks by Rethinking Folklore Weisfeiler-Lehman</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper provides a comprehensive analysis of the privacy-utility tradeoff for overparameterized neural networks. The analysis shows that overparameterization can lead to significant privacy leakage, but can also improve the performance of neural networks. | The paper is not entirely clear and provides no new insights into the topic. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Initialization Matters: Privacy-Utility Analysis of Overparameterized Neural Networks</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed approach for distributional policy evaluation is a Maximum Entropy approach. The idea is to use a probabilistic model to represent the distribution of a policy parameter vector. This approach is used to evaluate the performance of policy parameters in a decision- | The proposed approach lacks in novelty and does not actually apply to distributional policy evaluation. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Distributional Policy Evaluation: a Maximum Entropy approach to Representation Learning</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper discusses the trade-off between optimization and Bayesian inference in overparameterized neural networks, and provides insights on the advantages and disadvantages of each approach. | The proposed approach is not well-designed and lacks in experimental validation. It's a simplification of the real problem and does not offer a practical solution. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Optimization and Bayes: A Trade-off for Overparameterized Neural Networks</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed approach is promising in the context of downstream adaptation to unseen tasks. However, it requires further research on how to effectively use the pre-trained model for downstream adaptation. | The proposed approach lacks in novelty and does not address the task-robustness issue in downstream adaptation. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Task-Robust Pre-Training for Worst-Case Downstream Adaptation</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a novel prompting image restoration method that can efficiently restore images with degradation. The method uses deep learning models that can perceive and recover images from degraded signals. The paper also includes experiments with various degradation | The paper is not a complete description of the method. The text does not provide a detailed explanation of how prompting is used to restore images or how the degradation perception is incorporated. Additionally, the paper only provides a brief overview | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
PromptRestorer: A Prompting Image Restoration Method with Degradation Perception</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a new learning algorithm to compute optimal equilibria and mechanisms in zero-sum extensive-form games, and it provides empirical evidence to support its efficacy. | The paper does not address the specific problem of computing optimal equilibria and mechanisms in zero-sum extensive-form games. It only provides theoretical results and suggestions for future research. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Computing Optimal Equilibria and Mechanisms via Learning in Zero-Sum Extensive-Form Games</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed approach is novel and is shown to be effective in attacking membership inference attacks in a scalable manner. | The proposed method is not scalable and lacks in practical implementation. It has not been rigorously evaluated for practical applications. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Scalable Membership Inference Attacks via Quantile Regression</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a new approach to computing doubly entropic Wasserstein barycenters, which are a generalization of Wasserstein barycenters. The results provide guarantees on the quality of the resulting barycenters and are | The proposed method for doubly entropic Wasserstein barycenters is not well-specified and lacks in experimental validation. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Computational Guarantees for Doubly Entropic Wasserstein Barycenters</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a method for iteratively learning diverse strategies with state distance information. It is an interesting approach that can be applied to a wide range of problems in machine learning and reinforcement learning. | The paper is not clear about how to use state distance information in iterative learning. There is no practical implementation or application of this concept. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Iteratively Learn Diverse Strategies with State Distance Information</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper proposes a novel lockdown mechanism that can protect against adversarial attacks in federated learning with isolated subspace training. The proposed mechanism ensures that the attacker's input is not shared with the legitimate participants, thereby providing a | The proposed defense is not practical and has serious security issues. It is not a feasible solution for lockdown attacks in federated learning. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Lockdown: Backdoor Defense for Federated Learning with Isolated Subspace Training</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper provides a thorough analysis of the learnability of multilabel ranking and provides insights into how the learning process affects the ranking quality. | The paper does not provide any concrete results on the learnability of multilabel ranking models. It only discusses the problem and highlights the challenges associated with learning multilabel classification models. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
On the Learnability of Multilabel Ranking</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a novel approach for Bayesian optimization in high-dimensional spaces. It has the potential to solve complex optimization problems in a reliable way. | The proposed method has no practical use in real-world applications due to its complexity and inability to handle high-dimensional spaces. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Bounce: Reliable High-Dimensional Bayesian Optimization for Combinatorial and Mixed Spaces</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper provides a comprehensive analysis of the benefits of being distributional in reinforcement learning. The authors show that by using distributional learning, we can achieve higher learning rates and faster convergence. Additionally, the authors show that being distributional can | The paper presents a method for improving the performance of reinforcement learning algorithms by using distributional constraints. However, the proposed method is not applicable to practical reinforcement learning applications and has not been evaluated in the real world. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
The Benefits of Being Distributional: Small-Loss Bounds for Reinforcement Learning</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a novel approach to probabilistic programming based on a Heavy-Tailed Algebra. This approach has potential applications in various areas of probabilistic programming, including data analysis, machine learning, and robotics. | The proposed method is a new and innovative technique in probabilistic programming. However, its implementation and evaluation are not yet established. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
A Heavy-Tailed Algebra for Probabilistic Programming</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents an approach for learning reliable logical rules from a large dataset. The approach is based on the SatNet algorithm, which is a state-of-the-art SAT solver. The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of the approach | The proposed approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is well written, relevant and interesting.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Learning Reliable Logical Rules with SATNet</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed framework is robust and can handle feedback delays in convex optimization. | The paper does not provide a clear explanation of how the proposed approach works or its practical application. The method is not robust or efficient in solving convex optimization problems. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper provides theoretical explanations and also rigorous experimental results.</s>
<|user|>
Robust Learning for Smoothed Online Convex Optimization with Feedback Delay</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents a new approach to create 3D animatable text avatars from text data. The system utilizes a combination of natural language processing, machine learning, and deep learning techniques to create high-quality animations. | The paper does not provide any practical applications or real-world implementation of DreamHuman. It's an academic paper with theoretical results only. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
DreamHuman: Animatable 3D Avatars from Text</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The paper presents an efficient and scalable algorithm for score-based source separation. It has been applied to digital communication signals and has shown promising results. | The proposed method lacks in practical applications and is not scalable for real-world scenarios. The method's theoretical results are not reliable for practical use. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach is novel and well defined and does work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method has serious technical flaws and is not properly evaluated.</s>
<|user|>
Score-based Source Separation with Applications to Digital Communication Signals</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed method offers promising results in super-resolution of diffusion MRI images. The method is based on spatio-angular convolutions and is considered to be a significant step towards high-resolution MRI imaging. | The proposed approach has significant limitations in terms of image resolution and is not well-suited for super-resolution in diffusion MRI. | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
A novel genetic system to detect protein–protein interactions</s>
<|assistant|>
The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in multiple benchmarks.</s>
<|user|>
Spatio-Angular Convolutions for Super-resolution in Diffusion MRI</s>
<|assistant|>
|
The proposed transformer architecture is a new and promising approach for natural language processing. The paper presents a new transformer variant that outperforms traditional transformers in several natural language processing tasks. | The proposed model is not actually an elastic decision transformer as it does not use elastic adjustment in the transformer layer. It is a new approach to transformer architecture that aims to improve its expressive power in natural language processing tasks | <|system|>
You are an experienced researcher and a reviewer of scientific papers. Given a title of the paper, write a review about it in one sentence.</s>
<|user|>
FR-NAS: Forward-and-Reverse Graph Predictor for Efficient Neural Architecture Search</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper is poorly written and irrelevant. It's not interesting at all.</s>
<|user|>
Proving Test Set Contamination in Black-Box Language Models</s>
<|assistant|>
The approach lacks in novelty and doesn't actually work for blackbox LLMs.</s>
<|user|>
Quantum X-entropy in generalized quantum evidence theory</s>
<|assistant|>
The paper only provides theoretical results and lacks in experimental validation.</s>
<|user|>
Elastic Decision Transformer</s>
<|assistant|>
|
End of preview. Expand
in Dataset Viewer.
See https://hippocampus-garden.com/tiny_llama_dpo_lora/ for more detials
- Downloads last month
- 0
Size of downloaded dataset files:
1.25 MB
Size of the auto-converted Parquet files:
313 kB
Number of rows:
1,100
Models trained or fine-tuned on shionhonda/reviewer2-1k-paired