Due to his family heritage, Dybala was eligible to play for Poland and Italy, but expressly stated that he feels Argentine and had always dreamed of playing for Argentina.
Tänu oma juurtele võis Dybala esindada ka Poola või Itaalia koondist, kuid ütles, et tunneb ennast argentiinlasena ning on alati unistanud mängida Argentina koondises.