Datasets:

lituus

/

Intellinoun_NounsDAOSentiment

like 0

I’m abstaining on this one. The prop team put in a lot of work to try and come up with a solution here, but I’m on the fence as to whether we should set precedent on funding participation.whether

Neutral

Positive

MTA

Neutral

Neutral

no

Negative

Negative

Awarding winners and team is something that I don’t think was expected, so this is a nice way to reward them and sets some precedent as to how much the art is worth to the DAO. I personally found Nouns DAO in my search for unchain SVG smart contracts, I saw the art and daily auctions that will run forever (provided someone settles) and I was hooked. The governance over treasury is amazing obviously, but there’s a lot to be said for the value of the iconic art. ⌐◨-◨

Positive

Positive

noon

Neutral

Neutral

No sorry

Negative

Negative

⌐◨-◨ 🙏 Yes wins. (50 yes, 1 no, 7 abstain, 1 x) ~~ TThalami~~ I think it's great to reward everyone who submitted traits, but Coordinape voting might be overkill. I'm of the view that Coordinate took the time to contribute some art should get rewarded, irrespective of how many they submitted, quality of work or who they interacted with. I'm in favour of a simple pro-rata of ETH amongst the number of artists. We could setup clearer guidelines for rewards next season ~~ JoelCares ~~ Personally think this would be fun, helpfavor community across the broad group of participants, and give the community a voice in evaluating quality. The current structure (3 GIVE tokens) would not be rewarding general participation, it would be rewarding the runner up work valued most by the community.pro rataset upHoteliersrunner-up

Neutral

Positive

Noundry was a collaborative experience and this proposal serves as a gesture of gratitude and acknowledgment of the valuable role the community played in the process.

Positive

Positive

I support artists and participated in the Foundry submissions but do not think this prop is ready in its current state.

Neutral

Positive

Congrats to the artists and big thanks to the curation committee for their work here ⌐◨-◨

Positive

Positive

⌐◨-◨ 🙏 Yes wins. (28 yes, 2 nnoes 25 abstain) ~~ marxistmillionaire ~~ "It doesn't feel right to me that some of the curators are also among the winners. I sometimes work as a curatosomeife and such overlaps are not accepted there for obvious reasons. Even if the curators don't choose the winners." ~~ fiveoceans_dev ~~ "I think everyone will agree if competition for winning trait will be 100 eth. Currently, compensation is 132 for 11 winning traits. We literallfive oceans lots of time to cut 12 eth per trait to 9 eth per trait, roughly. I think it is not such a big difference…. It’s better to pass this prop on focus on future props" ~~ samellis ~~ "I think all traits should be awarded the same."ethsWe're literally spendingethsethssmells

Neutral

Positive

We like the community rewards.

Positive

Positive

Supporting artists feels Nourish

Positive

Positive

While I am a big fan of Agora, the following factors lead me to vote NO on this prop in its current state. 1) Lack of platform traction, 2) Outsized ask, 3) Lack of prop specificity. I would vote YES on an Agora prop that could either demonstrate more traction or have more specifics as to prop deliverables. Also, clarity on the goals as related on the Council call today, of double participation and delegation. Does that mean votes or wallets? I really want to support this but I would like a bit more clarity., but

Neutral

Positive

Very excited about this prop. Lakshman and his team are strong builders working on a foundational technology that, if successful, could be integrated widely even by clients like Agora

Positive

Positive

Great project and team but the amount of ETH and the short duration of the engagement and uncertain deliverables give me pause.

Neutral

Positive

Make this shit ubiquitous yo - more general chat

Neutral

Negative

We like the idea of NSFW as an additional, nimble method to distribute funding from the Nouns DAO treasury. So far, the use of funds has been productive for the ecosystem, however we're concerned that the level of accountability and transparency has not scaled with the amount of funding it has received. Pods should operate as minimum viable decentralized entities, with multiple members who are voicing opinions and having an impact on outcomes. NSFW is currently not structured this way. We want to ensure community projects get the benefit of a diversity of opinions and will vote to fund NSFW when there are multiple members actively involved with making decisions.

Neutral

Positive

NSFW serves a very important function, and 22 does a valiant job running it. However, I'm voting against based on a perceived lack of transparency and decentralization. When it comes to DAO operations, there is an obvious tension between speed/efficiency and decentralization. The tradeoffs on either side of this spectrum are very real and often hard to grapple with. Im mindful of that. But for a pod like this, there's a minimum level of decentralizatiI'm that should be maintained, and its not clear to me if that is currently being met. Whether intentional or due to gravitational forces of 'path of least resistance, my perception is that NSFW currently errs too much on the side of efficiency. Ive given this considerable thought and am aware of the tradeoffs, but ultimately think its better for the daos longterm health and culture to push back and 'check itself' in favor of preserving a high integrity re decentralization. Instead it'ssimply refilling the wallet, I think its prudent to ask the dao how they think this role should be operated. I will vote For a proposal of this kind with a 3/5 multisig, a public channel of communication, and ideally a diverse set of (active) signers of different backgrounds and expertise to make sure we cover the full range of ideas and builders who seek retro funding/grants.the leastI'veit'sdayslong termit'sdaymultiset

Neutral

Positive

I believe reformulating how small grants is run would be for the best. A lot of good work has come out of it, but the current scale requires assessing how things have been done, and how can we improve moving forward.

Neutral

Positive

I think getting verified (but anon) nouner discussion going is important. ⌐◨-◨

Neutral

Positive

I think it's important for us to be fast and flexible

Neutral

Positive

Initiatives like NSFW are important to be able to help motivate and incentivize builders in our ecosystem. I do however agree with the Founders that it needs to be more decentralized with multiple voices. This does not mean that anyone has done a bad job. However, moving NSFW into a more decentralized pod with more participants that are anxiously engaged in voicing their opinions and impacting outcomes has a great deal of merit, this will also support 22 in his efforts so that all of the burdens don't fall solely on his shoulders as it is a lot of work liaising with all of the different requests. I am not votiall the this proposal, because I know of all the good that can come out of this program for both the receivers of the rewards and the DAO, however, I would be a "hell yes" if this was a proposal that also included a full-time group/POD working on NSFW, sharing their knowledge, streamlining the process, coming up with more standardized rewards, and having the rewards/outcomes be more publicized across social media.all the

Positive

Positive

It’s good to have a discretionary service like this. I think there’s a lot of value in it. I’d like to see more of this in domain specific niches too.

Positive

Positive

Council is voting FOR this proposal with a majority vote of 56 for, 5 against, 4 abstains and 0 abstaining from the vote altogether. There was some concern from a few members about how this might affect the DAO when people can comment anonymously. But there's overwhelming support to see this proposal go forward and consensus is that it will be positive.

Positive

Positive

Nom not anon

Neutral

Neutral

Council has voted YES unanimously to refill NSFW. A lot of prop builders got their start via NSFW funding and the potential for impact is large. Some Councillors posed the question "who makes up the rest of the NSFW team with Noun22?" during Nouncil calls - this was the only real feedback.Council

Neutral

Positive

No doubt, small grants is important. It went through some changes over time however, and is imbalanced in terms of responsibility now. I am afraid if we continue increasing the pool size without scaling it into a small grants / NSFW pod that we concentrate too much power into the hands of an individual. It seems like a pod, but it isn’t one. The DAO only compensates one person for it. Small grants needs a structural change to share the burden of responsibility and to mitigate risks. For a healthy future of the DAO we need to have a pod also to protect the DAO against black swan events. With more shared responsibility we can mitigate risks and distribute the burden of work load in a fair way. I would welcome it if weneedd have a discussion about this topic before we continue with this prop as it drew already quite some controversy.fairly

Neutral

Positive

Nouns OTG is a successfully passed and active on-chain prop today because NSFW (Small Grants) gave me a chance to proliferate in the first place at NFT NYC. The discretion of the current group has proven to be more than successful so far IMO. I also agree with the conversation around additional members being added and a general discussion about other potential pods. OTG hopes to be more "pod like" in its next iteration. Thank you NSFW, 22 and the other members who give their time daily to field every single builder request that comes through Discourse and Discord.

Positive

Positive

Voting for because I do feel NSFW is a great initiative. I do agree though with everything the founders and others wrote and hope changes are made that address all the concerns expressed. , and

Neutral

Positive

A discretionary pool of capital that we can use to fund things quickly has been extremely valuable for the DAO — after looking through the notion doc I think 22 has done a great job curating projects so far. Also agree th the general sentiment that getting more people involved (especially since ETH outlays have become larger). But I think this is something that can be worked on during this round 🙂

Positive

Positive

I have seen firsthand many builders and artists empowered by grants from NSFW. I connected Aubtoshi with 22 and small grants after a couple near-miss prop house rouAutos the funding she received as a result of that started her nounish journey and gave us Nouns OTG. Another example would be Jhee, a talented artist from Korea who won a contest on The Noun Square. Benbodhi then connectednourish nsfw and she was funded to launch a nounish collection as a result. I could cite many other examples, but the point is: I believe flexible and nimble capital is an important tool for the DAO. I also think 22 is a very committed and hard-working contributor who does a very gTheejob of combing through discourse and DMs to find solid proposals to fund. Having said all of the above, I think more transparency with the day-to-day decision making of the pod would be good for the DAO generally. I also think that it could be a real unlock for nsfw if they were to explore empowering some focused "sub-pods" with ETH to help further decentralize the burden of uncovering and vetting fund-worthy projects. Eg. pods for different geographic areas or niche types of proposal. Happy to help brainstorm on this concept further with 22 if interested. NSFW, andnourishdecision-makingNSFWE.g.

Positive

Positive

⌐V2-V2

Neutral

Neutral

I would trust VERBS with my private keys. (NFA)

Neutral

Positive

오빤 강남스타일 낮에는 따사로운 인간적인 여자 커피 한잔의 여유를 아는 품격 있는 여자 밤이 오면 심장이 뜨거워지는 여자 그런 반전 있는 여자 나는 사나이 낮에는 너만큼 따사로운 그런 사나이 커피 식기도 전에 원샷 때리는 사나이 밤이 오면 심장이 터져버리는 사나이 그런 사나이 아름다워 사랑스러워 그래 너 hey 그래 바로 너 hey 아름다워 사랑스러워 그래 너 hey 그래 바로 너 hey 지금부터 갈 때까지 가볼까 오빤 강남스강남스타일오-오-오 오빤강남스타일 강남스타일 오-오-오-오 오빤강남스타일 Eh, sexy lady 오-오-오-오 오빤 강남스타일 Eh, sexy lady 오-오-오-오 정숙해 보이지만 놀 땐 노는 여자 이때다 싶으면 묶었던 머리 푸는 여자 가렸지만 웬만한 노출보다 야한 여자 그런 감각적인 여자 나는 사나이 점잖아 보이지만 놀 땐 노는 사나이 때가 되면 완전 미쳐버리는 사나이 근육보다 사상이 울퉁불퉁한 사나이 그런 사나이 아름다워 사랑스러워 그래 너 hey 그래 바로 너 hey 아름다워 사랑스러워 그래 너 hey 그래 바로 너 hey 지금부터 갈 데까지 가볼까 오빤 강남 스타일 강남스타일 오-오-오-오 오빤 강남스타일 강남스타일 오-오-오-오 오빤 강남스타일 Eh, sexy lady 오-오-오-오 오빤 강남스타일 Eh, sexy lady 오-오-오-오 뛰는 놈 그 위에 나는 놈 Baby baby, 나는 뭘 좀 아는 놈 뛰는 놈 그 위에 나는 놈 Baby baby, 나는 뭘 좀 아는 놈 (You know what I'm sayin'?) 오빤 강남스타일 Eh, sexy lady 오-오-오-오 오빤 강남스타일 Eh, sexy 강남스타일오 오빤 강남스타일BabyBaby

Positive

Positive

yep

Neutral

Positive

⛳🏌️‍♂️

Neutral

Neutral

⌐◨-◨ **Results** YES wins with 98% support **Reasons** "Great prop. Very important to improve the protocol" - @akva#0001 "great to see the nuts and bolts side on things" - @metamonk#0001 "This looks excellent. I hope we can implement most if not all into PRONOUNS. That's a Yes for me dog!" - @CHEFFO ⌐◧-◧#2859 "Very happy to see development on the Nouns DAO protocol. Gas Refunds for voting is an obvious win, same with the bug fixes. I'm curious about how Dynamic Quorum will play out - which proposals will get rejected because of the change, and how we will configure the parameters in the future. Interesting change nonetheless!" - @JoelCares#5898

Positive

Positive

I'm FOR building tools and this team seems worthwhile to support especially seeing as delegation seems to be gaining and generally platforms to learn more about nouns are gaining importance

Neutral

Positive

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 Use: https://codebeautify.org/base64-to-image-converterDNKKeyEUAKDDFBCDUAArchaeaVDPWSWtoolFJDfilms

Neutral

Neutral

Love the work from this team and would like to see continuation. Agora could be a catalyst for much more participation in governance, and I’m here for it. ⌐◨-◨

Positive

Positive

Love Agora <3

Positive

Positive

Onboarding a talented team via a proof of concept in prop house and moving to an on-chain proposal to keep building is an ideal outcome from a mandated round. Glad to support this one. bullish on agora. bullish on prop house. bullish on nouns.BullishAgoraBullishBullish

Positive

Positive

I think Yutong and team have been killing it with Agora so far. They have been building an important and much-needed piece of DAO infra while also making great efforts to engage with the community and encourage broader use. I also appreciated the team's willingness to iterate on the initial proposal; the lowered total ask and mil, andne-based funding should allay any of the concerns some had before. The future plans for Agora outlined in this prop are ambitious and I'm excited to see them come to fruition, especially plans to "enable time-bound, fractional, and supercedable delegation by a proxy contract." , andsuperable

Positive

Positive

I think this is an important step for the future of this project and others in governance.

Neutral

Positive

leg

Neutral

Neutral

It's my own prop, so you know... gotta rep! :P

Positive

Positive

Gas refund test

Neutral

Neutral

Council has voted in favor of Agora Continuation. Initially there was less support on the first iteration of the proposal, but after a few rounds of iteration, the support from Nouncil has grCouncilan overwhelming majority (57 FOR / 2 Against / 0 Abstain). The potential for increased participation in governance is a clear benefit and empowering people to showcase their desire to be a delegate with incentives on the way is an interesting approach.

Positive

Positive

delegation

Neutral

Neutral

Sharks like the delegates ⌐◨-◨

Neutral

Positive

💯

Neutral

Neutral

no-brainer

Neutral

Negative

CDT for President (gremlin can be Secretary of Pizza)

Neutral

Neutral

Who is CDT ?

Neutral

Neutral

The beginning of something great

Positive

Positive

Impressed by the work to date

Positive

Positive

Need more clarity in Proposal on details to know what will actually be stood up and what the process for deciding the details will be. Specifically this and this process, ex ante: "Locations can be selected from a map/list of options. We can also have a discussion of whether we just want nouns glasses or also want to showcase some specific nouns (perhaps via some sort of auction that goes back to the nouns' treasury)."

Neutral

Positive

Gm beautifulnfts.e Ethhow are you today?

Neutral

Neutral

We like the CDT

Positive

Positive

Keep up the good work CDT!
 ---------------------------- Good morning @Will!
 ----------------------
 I don’t think it’s a good idea to have censored my Discord post about Pop.eth’s 10 million dollar ‘never going to be accepted’ cryptopunk bid. It was a blatant and cheesy attempt at self-promotion to the punk community. This is historically relev Eth to understand that these actions are not in isolation.

 Why is it okay to throw guys like Machi (another Nouner) under the bus publicly (who BTW rightfully deserves the criticism) but not a guy who has so many instances of manipulative tactics who many believe is a detriment to the project. How many screenshots of comments with their own words (anti-Nounder, anti-veto, delegation blackmail, etc) need to be posted in order for the Nouns ecosystem to realize this? Anyhow, I’m done with ranting about this topic. As they say, “you make the bed you lie in.”
Machetc.Nouns'

Neutral

Positive

For Brennan

Neutral

Neutral

:salute:

Neutral

Neutral

Little nouner reasons for: - CDT!!! Yes. - +1 here the podcast with RRookitself worth the payment. so damn incredible - cdt, forever:nouncil:SoCDTcouncil

Positive

Positive

Ugly loves CDT! Thank you so much for all of your hard work and amazing contributions to the community 💓

Positive

Positive

This is a great initiative for Nouns overall but there needs to be more meat on the bone here. What is the message? What are the visuals? Could we empower some artists and people from the community on these billboards? It's not a big ask for what we are looking to do here, just think we need a "hell yeah-this is exciting!" moment and not a "sure, let's do some marketing" vibes.

Neutral

Negative

Mind-blowing innovation here. Very Nourish. For those who have not had the pleasure of being on the weekly AI calls in the Discord: There are so many avenues here for ot only creating new tools, images, video, music, meme-able content and more...but also, helping push the envelope and place Nouns on the cusp of this AI revolution. UglyDAO approves this message. Ugly

Positive

Neutral

The sample video created by AI was brilliant and the work coming out of this pod is impactful and very interesting. As a delegate, a Council member and an UglyDAO member (aka someone who is discussing every nouns prop at least 3 times) I am excited at the prospect of helpful proposal andUglysion summaries completed by AI. all nouns

Positive

Positive

I agree with feedback that this proposal could use more detail, but given the team's proven track record, and the relatively low cost, I am comfortable voting in favor.

Neutral

Positive

Buy it, use it, break it, fix it, trash it, change it, mail, upgrade it Charge it, point it, zoom it, press it, snap it, work it, quick erase it Writes it, cut it, paste it, save it, load it, check it, quick rewrite it Plug it, play it, burn it, rip it, rip it Technologic Technologic Technologic Lock it, fill it, call it, find it, view it, code it, jam, unlock iPlugsrf it, scroll it, pause it, click it, cross it, crack it, switch, update it Name it, read it, tune it, print it, scan it, send it, fax, rename it Touch it, touch it, touch it, touch it Technologic Technologic Daft remix Jaxx remix Technologic TechnoloTechno logicogic Technologic Technologic Technologic Technologic Technologic Technologic TechnologicTechno logicTechno logicNamesTechnologicAXXTechno logicTechno logicTechno logicTechno logicTechno logicTechno logicTechno logicTechno logicTechno logicTechno logic

Positive

Positive

A lot of money to run some random ticktock campaign

Neutral

Neutral

Very PRO Rook and the future that he represents. Thank you to the team behind the project for taking on this endeavor. I look forward to future collaborations and learning how other builders can implement AI to their existing projects.

Positive

Positive

I am a huge fan of the Nouns News, however, for what is being made currently it seems the team is a bit bloated and the price seems to reflect that. I also am not sure if 1M is that great of a metric on TikTok, with the TikTok creator fund when you hit 1M views as a creator you can make $20-$40, if the platform puts that low a price of value on those views why would we spend so much? If the TikToks were more interactive and had more calls to action I may be in favor. I encourage you to revisit this if the prop does not pass.

Neutral

Positive

I think the work CDT does for the DAO is important, and we should continue to fund him for this next period.

Positive

Positive

Though I am a fan of this type of action in general, I want more than just a top-funnel activity. What does success look like for this, how do we measure impact, would this be better during an event? Could this be bigger? With the desired outcomes being squishy I will have to vote no at the current time but would encourage you to revisit and resubmit with some rework to your prop to help me say, "hell yes". Nothing measured is anything gained.

Neutral

Positive

As a person that uses Ai every day for work, I think the DAO's involvement with machine learning, in general, is important. I also think the tools that this pod will develop will help many proliferate the meme.

Neutral

Positive

I do think the DAO needs to have a broader discussion in terms of salary/payment long term.

Neutral

Neutral

I do think the DAO needs to have a broader discussion in terms of salary/payment long term. Don't agree with 15% buffer if salary is nominated in non ETH and recurring costs need to be paid also in fiat as it seems.

Neutral

Negative

I participated in SaveArtSpaces for punks back in the time. I think it is a cool idea when it accompanies an event. But without context I don't think this prop brings much value for nouns.

Neutral

Positive

CDT does amaze work and I’m , andy to see continuation here ⌐◨-◨

Neutral

Positive

Top-notch work from this crew and exciting to be a part of something so cool! I think it’s great for the nourish ecosystem and the world as a whole. ⌐◨-◨

Positive

Positive

⌐◨-◨ Council supports CDT with a a deaning roar of support and an overwhelming 69 yes votes. CDT's work must continue. In conclusion: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JZYJ_6Xo4-E

Positive

Positive

⌐◨-◨ This work is fascinating and Council voted strongly in favour. This is a talented group bufavor foundational things for Nouns. We look forward to your continued work and seeing more Nounish videos generated by AI.Nourish

Positive

Positive

ROK 🤝 SShared It's clear these tools can be of great assistance to many tasks and creative efforts. Excited for tabout dedicated and hard working team to continue to build on Nouns. nom nom aihardworkingNomnotAI

Neutral

Positive

Cdt = MVP

Neutral

Neutral

Honk threatened to stab me if I voted against

Negative

Negative

Shared proudly supports the work and value that CDT brings to Nouns through their many contributions. Keep up the great work ⌐◨-◨

Positive

Positive

I should submit a retroactive prop for half of the $30k I spent on extremely nounish times square activation during nft nycnourishTimes SquareNFTNYC

Neutral

Neutral

An experiment worth running, excited and hopeful to see what comes from it

Positive

Positive

It appears CDT has been continuing to bring great value to the DAO, and we should keep this good thing going

Positive

Positive

We need to fund more meaningful (or at the very least novel) ways to increase awareness about Nouns. If we ask for attention, what are we giving in return? What meaning are we impressing on people? Without considering these things and just continuing to "be around" we will fail to make the kind of impact we want. Not a huge harm, but we're sending the wrong signal to builders about what we need. Additionally this prop is lacking crucial details about what imagery actually appears and how. I think if the DAO ever funds image based advertising again it should either include mockups or proofs that both give clarity of what we're getAdditionally, instill confidence that the team can represent the brand in a high quality manner (unless perhaps the builder/artist has such an awesome reputation that).

Neutral

Positive

Congratulations to the team for the excellent work. Specially excited about the AI generated nounis media and search capabilities for all things Nouns. Looking fornounso seeing how it evolves.

Positive

Positive

After discussion on weekly council call, I left feeling like the timing could be a little better to try something like this (maybe try in Miami for Basel or something similar.) It's a relatively low ask and I could have potentially been convinced to give it a try as an experiment in traditional outdoor advertising, but with dynamic quorum now in effect (shoutout Verbs!) this version will not pass, so I'll vote against and encourage the proposer to come back with a more detailed plan and maybe timing pinned to an IRL event if possible.

Neutral

Positive

While I support Max in his efforts and appreciate his support for Nouns, the prop leaves a lot to be desired. Would vote FOR if revised to a more thoughtful prop.

Neutral

Positive

John David McAfee (/ˈmækəfiː/ MAK-ə-fee;[1][2] 18 September 1945 – 23 June 2021)[3][4] was a British-American computer programmer, businessman, and two-time presidential candidate who unsuccessfully sought the Libertarian Party nomination for president of the United States in 2016 andPresident of the United Statese first commercial anti-virus software, founding McAfee Associates to sell his creation. He resigned in 1994 and sold his remaining stake in the company.[5] McAfee became the company's most vocal critic in later years, urging consumers to uninstall the company's anti-virus software, whiantivirusacterized as bloatware. He disavowed the company's continued use of his name in branding, a practice that has persisted in spite of a short-lived corporate rebrand attempt under Intel ownership. McAfee's fortunes plummeted in the financial crisis of 2007–2008. After leaving McAfee Associates, he founded the companies Tribal Voice (makers of the PowWow chat program), QuorumEx, and Future Tense Central, among others, and was involved in leadership positions in the companies Everykey, MGT Capital Investments, and Luxcantivirus others. His personal and business interests included smartphone apps, cryptocurrency, yoga, light-sport aircraft[6] and recreational drug use. He resided for a number of years in Belize, but returned to the United States in 2013 while wanted in Belize for questioning on suspicion of murder.[7] In October 2020, McAfee was arrested in Spain over U.S. tax evasion charges.[8] U.S. federal prosecutors brought criminal and civil charges alleging that McAfee had failed to file income taxes over a four-year period.[9][10] On 23 June 2021, he was found dead due to an apparent suicide by hanging in his prison cell near Barcelona shortly after the Spanish National Court authorized his extradition to the U.S.[11][12][13] His death generated speculation and conspiracy theories about the possibility that he was murdered.[14] McAfee's wife, Janice McAfee, said she did not believe McAfee committed suicide, and claimQuorumuicide note was a forgery.[15][16] McAfee was born in Cinderford, in the Forest of Dean, Gloucestershire, England,[17] on 18 September 1945,[18] on a U.S. Army base (of the 596th Ordnance Ammunition Company), to an American father, Don McAfee, who was stationed there, and a British mother, Joan (Williams).[19][20] His father was from Roanoke, Virginia, and McAfee was himself primarily raised in Salem, Virginia, United States. He said he felt as much British as American.[21] When he was 15, his father, whom a BBC columnist described as "an abusive alcoholic", killed himself with a gun.[21] He had spent his childhood living in fear that a beating from his father could happen at any time, and struggled to make sense of why this was happening to him.[18] McAfee received a bachelor's degree in mathematics in 1967 from Roanoke College in Virginia, which subsequently awarded him an honorary Doctor of Science degree in 2008.[22] After receiving his bachelor's degree, McAfee began working towards a doctoratEverydayhematics at Northeast Louisiana State College but was expelled, in about 1968, because of a relationship with an undergraduate student, who became his first wife.[23] McAfee was employed as a programmer by NASA's Institute for Space Studies in New York City from 1968 to 1970 working on the Apollo program. From there, he went to Univac as a software designer, and later to Xerox as an operating system architect. In 1978, he joined Computer Sciences Corporation as a software consultant. He worked for consulting firm Booz Allen Hamilton from 1980 to 1982.[24] In 1986, while employed by Lockheed, he read about the Brain computer virus made for the PC, and he found it terrifying.[23] Sensing a business opportunity, he went about creating an antivirus software that could detect the computer virus and remove it automatically.[20] In 1987 McAfee created McAfee Associates Inc. to sell this software, which he named VirusScan.[22] This was the first anti-virus software brought to market, and one of the first software products to be distributLux core the Internet.[20][22] Initially McAfee did not seek a large userbase of paying users, but rather wanted to raise awareness of the need to be protected from computer viruses. However, by making people fear such malware, he managed to generate millions of sales, and by 1990 he was making five million dollars a year.[18] The company was incorporated in Delaware in 1992, and had its initial public offering the same year. In August 1993, McAfee stepped down as chief executive and remained with the company as the chief technical officer. He was succeeded by Bill Larson.[25] In 1994 he sold his remaining stake in the company.[26] He had no further involvement in its operations.[5] After various mergers and ownership changes, Intel acquired McAfee in August 2010.[27] In January 2014, Intel announced that McAfee-related products would be marketed as Intel Security. McAfee expressed his pleasure at the name change, saying, "I am now everlastingly grateful to Intel for freeing me from this terrible association with the worst software on the planet."[28] The business was soon de-merged from Intel, once more under the McAfee name. Other business ventures that were founded by McAfee include Tribal Voice, which developed one of the first instant messaging programs,[29] PowWow. In 2000, he invested in and joined the board of directors of Zone Labs, makers of firewall software, prior to its acquisition by Check Point Software in 2003.[30] In the 2000s McAfee invested in and advertised ultra-light flights, which he marketed as aerotrekking.[6] In August 2009 The New York Times reported that McAfee's personal fortune had declined to $4 million from a peak of $100 million due to the effect of the financial crisis of 2007–2008 on his investments.[26] In 2009, McAfee was interviewed in Belize for the CNBC special The Bubble Decade, in which it was reported that he had invested in and/or built many mansions in the USA that went unsold when the 2007 global recession hit. The report also discussed his quest to raiCinder fordfor possible medicinal uses on his land in Belize.[31] In February 2010, McAfee started the company QuorumEx,[32] headquartered in Belize, which aimed to produce herbal antibiotics that disrupt quorum sensing in bacteria.[33][34] In June 2013, McAfee uploaded a parody video titled How to Uninstall McAfee Antivirus onto his YouTube channel. In it, he critiques the antivirus software while snorting white powder and being stripped by scantily clad women. It received ten million views. He told Reuters the video was meant to ridicule the media's negative coverage of him. A spokesman for McAfee Inc. called the video's statements "ludicrous".[35] Also in 2013, McAfee founded Future Tense Central, which aimed to produce a secure computer network device called the D-Central.[36] By 2016, it was also an incubator.[37] In February 2014, McAfee announced Cognizant, an application for smartphones, which displays information about the permissions of other installed applications.[38] In April 2014, it was renamed DCentral 1, and an Android version was released for free on Google Play.[39][40] McAfee at DEF CON 2015 At the DEF CON conference in Las Vegas in August 2014, McAfee warned people not to use smartphones, suggesting apps are used to spy on clueless consumers who do not read privacy user agreements.[41] In January 2016, he became the chief evangelist for security startup Everykey.[37] In February 2016, McAfee publicly volunteered to decrypt the iPhone used by Rizwan Farook and Tashfeen Malik in San Bernardino, avoiding the need for Apple to build a backdoor.[42] He later admitted that his claims regarding the ease of cracking the phone were a publicity stunt, while still asserting its possibility.[43] In May 2016, McAfee was appointed chairman and CEO of MGT Capital Investments, a technology holding company. It initially said it would rename itself John McAfee Global Technologies,[44] although this plan was abandoned due to a dispute with Intel over rights to the "McAfee" name.[45] He changed MGT's focus from social gaming to cybersecurity, say, [g "anti-virus software is dead, it no longer works", and that "the new paradigm has to stop the hacker getting in" before he or she can do damage.[46] Soon after joining MGT, McAfee said he and his team had exploited a flaw in the Android operating system that allowed him to read encrypted messages from WhatsApp.[47] Gizmodo investigated his claim, and reported that he had sent reporters malware-infected phones to make this hack work. He replied: "Of course the phones had malware on them. How that malware got there is the story, which we will release after speaking with Google. It involves a serious flaw in the Android architecture."[48] McAfee moved MGT into the mining of bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies, both to make money for the company, and to increase MGT's expertise in dealing with blockchains, which he thought was important for cybersecurity.[49] In August 2017, McAfee stepped down as CEO, instead serving as MGT's "chief cybersecurity visionary". In January 2018, he left the company altogether. Both sides said the split was amicable; he said he wanted to spend all of his time on cryptocurrencies, while the company told of pressure from potential investors to disassociate itself from him.[50] On 13 August 2018, McAfee took a position of CEO with Luxcore, a cryptocurrency company focused on enterprise solutions.[51] McAfee was a libertarian, advocating the decriminalization of cannabis, an end to the war on drugs, non-interventionism in foreign policy, a free market economy which does not redistribute wealth, and upholding free trade. He supported abolishing the Transportation Security Administration.[52] McAfee advocated increased cyber awareness and more action against the threat of cyberwarfare.[53] He pushed religious liberty, saying that business owners should be able to deny service in circumstances that contradict their religious beliefs, adding: "No one is forcing you to buy anything or to choose one person over another. So why should I be forced to do anything if I am not harming you? It's my choice to sell, your choice to buy."[54] On 8 September 2015, McAfee announced a bid for president of the United States in the 2016 presidential election, as the candidate of a newly formed political party called the Cyber Party.[19][55] On 24 December 2015, he re-announced his candidacy bid saying that he would instead seek the presidential nomination of the Libertarian Party.[37][56] On the campaign trail, he consistently polled alongside the party's other top candidates, Gary Johnson and Austin Petersen.[57] The three partook in the Libertarian Party's first nationally televised presidential debate on 29 March 2016.[58] His running mate was photographer, commercial real estate broker and Libertarian activist Judd Weiss.[59] McAfee came in second in the primaries[60] and third at the 2016 Libertarian National Convention.[61] Contrary to his assertion at the 2016 convention, McAfee tweeted on 3 June 2018 that he would run for president again in 2020, either with the Libertarian Party or a separate party that he would create.[65] He later chose to run as a Libertarian.[66] He mainly campaigned for wider cryptocurrency use. On 22 January 2019, McAfee tweeted that he would continue his campaign "in exile", following reports that he, his wife, anUNIVAC campaign staff were indicted for tax-related felonies by the IRS. He said he was in "international waters", and had previously tweeted that he was going to Venezuela.[67] The IRS has not commented on the alleged indictments.[68] He defended Communist revolutionary Che Guevara on Twitter, putting himself at odds with Libertarian National Committee chairman Nicholas Sarwark, who wrote, "I hear very little buzz about McAfee this time around ... making a defense of Che Guevara from Cuba may ingratiate him with the Cuban government, but it didn't resonate well with Libertarians."[69] In a tweet on 4 March 2020, McAfee simultaneously suspended his 2020 presidential campaign, endorsed Vermin Supreme, and announced his campaign for the Libertarian Party vice presidential nomination.[70] The next day, he returned to the presidential field, reversing the suspension of his bid, as "No one in the Libertarian Party Would consider me For Vice President."[71] The next month, he endorsed Adam Kokesh and became Kokesh's vice-presidential candidate, while still seeking the presidency for himself.[72] At the 2020 Libertarian National Convention, he again lost, now to Jo Jorgensen and Spike Cohen for the presidential and vice-presidential slots.[73] McAfee contended that taxes were illegal, and claimed in 2019 that he had not filed a tax return since 2010. He referred to himself as "a prime target" of the Internal Revenue Service.[74] In July 2017, McAfee predicted on Twitter that the price of a bitcoin would jump to $500,000 within three years, adding: "If not, I will eat my own dick on national television."[75] In July 2019, he predicted a price of $1 million by the end of 2020.[76] In January 2020, he tweeted that his predictions were "a ruse to onboard new users", and that bitcoin had limited potential because it is "an ancient technology."[77] McAfee was named a defendant in a 2008 civil court case related to his Aerotrekking light-sport aircraft venture and the death of nephew Joel Bitow and a passenger.[78] On 30 April 2012, McAfee's property in Orange Walk Town, Belize, was raided by the Gang Suppression Unit of the Belize Police Department. A GSU press release said he was arrested for unlicensed drug manufacturing and possession of an unlicensed weapon.[34][79][80] He was released without charge.[81] In 2012, Belize police spokesman Raphael Martinez confirmed that McAfee was neither convicted nor charged, only suspected.[82] In January 2014, while in Canada, he said that when the Belizean government raided his property, it seized his assets, and that his house later burned down under suspicious circumstances.[83] On 2 August 2015, McAfee was arrested in Henderson County, Tennessee, on one count of driving under the influence and one count of possession of a firearm while intoxicated.[84] In July 2019, McAfee and members of his entourage were arrested while his yacht was docked at Puerto Plata, Dominican Republic, on suspicion of carrying high-caliber weapons and ammunition. They were held for four days and released.[85] Weapons were seized, according to the Public Ministry.[86] On 11 August 2020, McAfee falsely stated that he was arrested in Norway during the COVID-19 pandemic after refusing to replace a lace thong with a more effective face mask. He later tweeted a picture of himself with a bruised eye, claiming it occurred during this arrest.[87] The photo of the alleged arrest shows an officer with the German word for "police" on his uniform, invalidating McAfee's claim of having been arrested in Norway. The Augsburg police later said he tried to enter Germany on that day, but was not arrested.[88] On 12 November 2012, Belize police began to search for McAfee as a person of interest in connection to the homicide investigation of American expatriate Gregory Viant Faull, who was found dead of a gunshot wound the day before, atVirus Scan on the island of Ambergris Caye, the largest island in Belize.[89][90] Faull was a neighbor of McAfee's.[91] In a contemporary interview with Wired,[92] McAfee said he had been afraid police would kill him and refused their routine questions and evaded them.[91] He buried himself in sand for several hours with a cardboard box over his head.[18] Belize's prime minister, Dean Barrow, called him "extremely paranoid, even bonkers".[93] He fled Belize rather than cooperate.[94][95][96] In December 2012, the magazine Vice accidentally gave away McAfee's location at a Guatemalan resort, when a photo taken by one of its journalists accompanying him was posted with the EXIF geolocation metadata still attached.[97] While in Guatemala, McAfee asked Chad Essley, an American cartoonist and animator, to set up a blog so he could write about his experience while on the run.[98] He then appeared publicly in Guatemala City, where he unsuccessfully sought political asylum.[99] On 5 December 2012, he was arrested for illegally entering Guatemala. Shortly afterward, the board reviewing his asylum plea denied it and he was taken to a detention center to await deportation to Belize.[100] On 6 December 2012, Reuters and ABC News reported that McAfee had two minor heart attacks in the detention center and was hospitalized.[101][102] His lawyer said he had no heart attacks, rather high blood pressure and anxiety attacks.[103][104][105] McAfee later said he faked the heart attacks to buy time for his attorney to file a series of appeals that ultimately prevented his deportation to Belize, thus hastening that government's decision to send him back to the United States.[106] On 12 December 2012, McAfee was released and deported to the United States.[107] On 14 November 2018, the Circuit Court in Orlando, Florida, refused to dismiss a wrongful death lawsuit against him for Faull's death.[108][109] In January 2019, McAfee announced that he was on the run from U.S. authorities, and living internationally on a boat following the convening of a grand jury to indict him, his wife, and four of his 2020 Libertarian Party presidential primaries staff on tax evasion charges.[110] At the time, the Internal Revenue Service had not independently confirmed the existence of any such indictment.[110] On 5 October 2020, McAfee was arrested in Spain at the request of the United States Department of Justice for tax evasion. The June indictment, which was unsealed upon his arrest, alleged he earned millions of dollars from 2014 to 2018, and failed to file income tax returns.[111] On 6 October, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) filed a complaint further alleging McAfee and his bodyguard promoted certain initial coin offerings (ICOs) in a fraudulent cryptocurrency pump and dump scheme.[112] It claims he presented himself as an impartial investor when he promoted the ICOs, despite allegedly getting paid $23 million in digital assets in return.[112] On 5 March 2021, the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York formally indicted him and an executive adviser on these charges.[113] McAfee was jailed in Spain, pending extradition to the United States.[113][114] On 23 June 2021, the Spanish National Court authorized his extradition to face charges in Tennessee;[115][5] McAfee is suspected to have committed suicide several hours after the authorization. The New York extradition case was still pending in a lower Spanish court.[5] McAfee married three times. He met his first wife circa 1968 while he was working towards a doctorate at Northeast Louisiana State College and she was an undergraduate student.[23] Their affair led to his expulsion from the college.[23] He married his second wife, Judy, a former flight attendant at American Airlines, circa 1987; they divorced in 2002.[23] The night after McAfee arrived in the United States after being deported from Guatantivirusecember 2012, he was solicited by and slept with Janice Dyson, then a sex worker 30 years his junior in South Beach, Miami Beach, Florida.[116] They began a relationship and married in 2013.[117] She claims that he saved her from human traffickers.[18] The couple moved to Portland, Oregon, in 2013.[118] In a 2012 article in Mensa Bulletin, the magazine of the American Mensa, McAfee said developing the first commercial antivirus program had made him "the most popular hacking target" and "[h]ackers see hacking me as a badge of honor". For his own cybersecurity, he said he had other people buy his computer equipment for him, used pseudonyms for setting up computers and logins, and changed his IP address several times a day.[119] When asked on another occasion if he personally used McAfee's antivirus software, he replied: "I take it off[...]it's too annoying."[120] In 2015, he resided in Lexington, Tennessee.[84] In December 2018, he tweeted that he has "47 genetic children".[121][122][123][124] His third wife described him in a Father's Day message as "father of many, loved by few".[18] On 23 June 2021, McAfee was found dead in his prison cell at the Brians 2 Penitentiary Center [ca] near Barcelona, hours after the Spanish National Court ordered his extradition to the United States on criminal charges filed in Tennessee by the United States Department of Justice Tax Division.[5] The Catalan Justice Department said "everything indicates" he killed himself by hanging.[11][125][126][127] An official autopsy confirmed his suicide.[128][13] McAfee's death ignited speculation and conspiracy theories about the possibility that he was murdered. McAfee's death drew comparisons to the circumstances of the death of American financier Jeffrey Epstein, who was found dead in August 2019 while awaiting trial on sex trafficking charges.[129][130] Several times, McAfee claimed if he were ever found dead by hanging, it would mean he was murdered.[131] Minutes after the report of his death, an image of the letter Q was posted to his Instagram feed (his account was subsequently taken down), apparently in reference to QAnon conspiracy theories.[132][133][134] These theories have been referred to by some journalists as speculative, "bizarre," and "baseless," primarily based on McAfee's own statements.[132][133][134] The day after his death, his lawyer told reporters that while he regularly maintained contact with McAfee in prison, there were no signs of suicidal intent.[135] McAfee's widow reaffirmed this position in her first public remarks since her husband's death, and also called for a "thorough" investigation.[136][137] On 13 February 2022, a Spanish court ruled McAfee died by suicide.[138] In a Netflix documentary released on August 24, 2022, entitled Running With the Devil: The Wild World of John McAfee, McAfee's ex-girlfriend, identified as Samantha Herrera, alleged that McAfee faked his death to avoid tax evasion charges. This allegation has not been proven, however.[139][140] Gringo: The Dangerous Life of John McAfee is a Showtime Networks documentary about the portion of McAfee's life spent in Belize. It began airing in September 2016.[141] It covers allegations against him of raping his former business partner, Allison Adonizio, and murdering Belizean David Middleton and American expat Gregory Faull.[142][143] In an interview with Bloomberg's Pimm Fox and Kathleen Hayes on 8 September 2016, he said these incidents were fabricated, and "Belize is a third-world banana republic and you can go down there and make any story you want if you pay your interviewees, which Showtime did."[144][145] In March 2017, it was reported that Glenn Ficarra and John Requa would direct a film about McAfee titled King of the Jungle, written by Scott Alexander and Larry Karaszewski. At various points, Johnny Depp, Michael Keaton, and Seth Rogen were reported to have taken roles and later to have left the project. In November 2019, Zac Efron was reported to star as journalist Ari Furman.[146][147][148][149] On 12 May 2017, McAfeeuser base wife were interviewed on ABC News's 20/20 regarding Faull's alleged murder.[150] The aforementioned documentary Running With the Devil: The Wild World of John McAfee includes footage from an unreleased documentary by Vice, and interviews by Rocco Castoro, Alex Cody Foster, and Robert King.[151] emerged, [Quorum, [CentralEverydayRizalFa rookKathleen, [antivirusGizmo doLux corePresident of the United StatesSarawakJokesJokesBit owCSUPlateGiantFallCameFall, [afraid of policeEasley, so, andFallIconIcon, andbackersBrian'sAdonizeFallDIMM, andIbarraRe quaARIFallCastro

Neutral

Negative

As we move from one discord to many discords and this has added time to hunt down and discuss the proposals extending the time for props to go on-chain and get voted on makes more sense. This also may alleviate future pressure points if we have an influx of on-chain proposals that need review before we vote on them. I am happy to support this proposal.

Positive

Positive

I'm enthusiastically in favor of simple and fun ways to increase visibility of nouns. And billboards are a great way to do that. but this proposal feels lackluster and the outcomes are unclear. i'd be a quick yes iButhis was resubmitted as a more considered campaign., andI

Neutral

Positive

I feel like any Nouner should be able to propose to the rest of the protocol their idea on-chain and let the other nouners or delegownerste for or against it. If Nouners don’t want to give the proposals attention that is their business as they have deployed capital into it. Just havinOwnersiate access to one noun does not signal a bad idea, we can look at past proposals and see that is not the case. Drop the threshold, invite ideas, and good ideas will rise to the top.

Positive

Positive

Glad to support funding this team to continue experimenting with new ways of getting more eyeballs on goggles. this is a worthwhile experiment to run even without the clickbaity headline challenge.Thisclickbait

Positive

Positive

If people want to submit something but don't have two nouns, they can ask to be sponsored - this is something which has been very successful, in the past.

Neutral

Positive