identifikasi "jews for jesus" sebagai organisasi yahudi ditentang oleh denominasi-denominasi agamawi yahudi"secara virtual terdapat kemufakatan bulat pada seluruh denominasi (yudaisme) bahwa jews for jesus bukanlah bersifat yahudi."
(kaplan, dana evan. the cambridge companion to american judaism, cambridge university press, august 15, 2005, pp. 139140)."for most american jews, it is acceptable to blend some degree of foreign spiritual elements with judaism.
the one exception is christianity, which is perceived to be incompatible with any form of jewishness.
jews for jesus and other messianic jewish groups are thus seen as antithetical to judaism and are completely rejected by the majority of jews".
(kaplan, dana evan. the cambridge companion to american judaism, cambridge university press, august 15, 2005, p. 9).
dan kelompok sekuler yahudi
"to make the record clear, jews for jesus is a christian missionary organization  period."
jews for jesus: jewish or christian?
you decide, jews for judaism website, retrieved september 11, 2006.
"messianic jewish organizations, such as jews for jesus, often refer to their faith as fulfilled judaism, in that they believe jesus fulfilled the messianic prophecies.
although messianic judaism claims to be jewish, and many adherents observe jewish holidays, most jews regard messianic judaism as deceptive at best, fraudulent at worst.
they charge that messianic judaism is actually christianity presenting itself as judaism." (balmer, randall.
encyclopedia of evangelicalism, baylor university press, november 2004, p. 448).
"i do not seek, of course, covertly (as sometimes jews for jesus do) or overtly, to convert myself, or any other jew to christianity..." (boyarin, daniel.
border lines: the partition of judaeo-christianity, university of pennsylvania press, july 2004, p. xii).
"certain christian missionary groups have now set up a front organization called "jews for jesus," through which they entice naive jews to christianity..." (stolper, pinchas.
"was jesus the messiah?
let's examine the facts", in kaplan, aryeh.
aryeh kaplan anthology: volume 1, mesorah publications, august 1991, p. 293).
"even as i write, i fear that christian missionaries or, even more insidiously, jews for jesuspeople who (unlike the redeeming avant-garde of christianity) believe that judaism is superseded, and jewish have no right to exist as jews any morewill misuse my words.
these people, who believe that christianity has taken over judaism like some succubus that must now govern the behavior of its host body, seek to abolish the jewish religion." (greenberg, irving.
for the sake of heaven and earth: the new encounter between judaism and christianity, the jewish publication society, october 2004, p. 97).
"it should now be clear to you why jews have such a problem with 'jews for jesus' or other presentations of messianic judaism.
i have no difficulty with christianity.
i even accept those christians who would want me to convert to christianity so long as they don't use coercion or duplicity and are willing to listen in good faith to my reasons for being jewish.
i do have a major problem with those christians who would try to mislead me and other jews into believing that one can be both jewish and christian." (lotker, michael.
a christian's guide to judaism, paulist press, march 2004, p. 35).
"evangelical christians are engaged in aggressive and extensive missionary activity among jews. among other results, this has given rise to groups of 'messianic jews', of which 'jews for jesus' is the most outstanding example.
these are actually jews who have adopted the evangelical protestant faith and its precepts."
(wistrich, robert, terms of survival, routledge (uk), march 1995, p. 343).
"messianic judaism is a christian movement that began in the 1970s combining a mixture of jewish ritual and christianity.
there are a vast and growing numbers of these groups, and they differ in how much jewish ritual is mixed with conventional christian belief.
one end of the spectrum is represented by jews for jesus, who simply target jews for conversion to christianity using imitations of jewish ritual solely as a ruse for attracting the potential jewish converts.
on the other end are those who don't stress the divinity of jesus, but present him as the 'messiah.'"
meeting the challenge: hebrew christians and the jewish community karena keyakinan kristen para anggotanya.
aktivitas penginjilan kelompok ini mendapat tanggapan beragam dari perorangan maupun organisasi kristen yang lain, umumnya terbagi antara golongan liberal dan konservatif.robinson, b.
jews for jesus, ontario consultants on religious tolerance, october 29, 2001.others who oppose the evangelism related activities of jews for jesus:
benjamin hubbard; john hatfield, james santucci (1997).
an educator's guide to beliefs and practices.
teacher ideas press, a division of libraries unlimited, p.100.
encyclopedia of evangelicalism, baylor university press, november 2004, p. 448
"today, many evangelical christian-protestant groups are spending between 100,000,000 and 150,000,000 dollars a year to transform jews into christians.
the best known of these organization is jews for jesus...". (berkley, e. george.
jews, branden books, february 1997, p. 129).
"thirdly, there is jews for jesus or, more generally, messianic judaism.
this is a movement of people often of jewish background who have come to believe jesus is the expected jewish messiah...
they often have congregations independent of other churches and specifically target jews for conversion to their form of christianity."
after the evil: christianity and judaism in the shadow of the holocaust, oxford university press, august 2003, p. 119.)
"...jews for jesus (jews converted to 'born again' christianity who are seeking to make more such converts...". (marty, martin e.
when faiths collide, blackwell publishing, january 2005, p. 35).
"jews for jesus, the leading organization dedicated to converting jews to christianity, has long been a concern because of its aggressive proselytizing with a deceptive message: that jews who accept jesus as the son of god and their savior remain jewish."
jews for jesus: targeting jews for conversion with subterfuge and deception, anti-defamation league, august 27, 2004, retrieved september 11, 2006.
"jews for jesus is a sect of a very different nature.
this group... has a sole motivational goal of converting jews to christianity."
fogel, keith and marian e.
conversos of the americas, xlibris corporation, april 2004, p. 169).
"jews for jesus is an evangelical christian organization ..." who are the jews for jesus?
"... its doctrine is strictly christian in the fundamentalist/evangelical understanding of christian faith" is jews for jesus a christian organization, or is it a jewish organization?
didirikan pada tahun 1973, jews for jesus memperkejakan lebih dari 200 orang, ministrywatch.com dengan perkiraan jumlah penganut sebanyak 30.000 sampai 125.000 di seluruh duniaw "about jews for jesus: how many jews for jesus are there?" dan menerima sekitar 20 juta dollar sumbangan setahun.
evangelical council for financial accountability
organisasi ini didirikan oleh moishe rosen, seorang pendeta gereja baptis yang lahir dari keluarga yahudi dan masuk kristen paeda usia 17 tahun, the real jews for jesus.
the leaders by jason levinson (torah atlanta) dan jhan moskowitz, seorang pendeta christian and missionary alliance minister serta putra seorang yang selama dari holocaust.
jews for jesus: targeting jews for conversion with subterfuge and deception.
methods (anti-defamation league) rosen pernah menjadi kepala cabang san francisco dari american board of missions to the jews (sebuah organisasi yang sekarang dikenal sebagai chosen people ministries).
pada tahun 1973, rosen memisahkan diri dari organisasi tersebut, dan pada bulan september tahun itu, mendirikan jews for jesus sebagai hineni ministries dengan kantor pusat di daerah san francisco.
dalam beberapa tahun setelahnya, organisasi ini membuka cabang-cabang di kota-kota lain.
dari bulan september 1979 - june 1980, menutup cabang-cabangnya untuk melatih para misionaris.
jews for jesus timeline kemudian kembali membuka lebih banyak cabang-cabang, kebanyakan di kota-kota di amerika serikat, pada tahun 1980-an, serta di luar amerika pada tahun 1990-an.
rosen tetap menjabat sebagai executive director sampai bulan mei 1996 ketika ia digantikan oleh david brickner, juga seorang pendeta gereja baptis.
moishe rosen meninggal pada bulan mei 2010.
organisasi ini mempertahankan kantor pusatnya di dalam maupun di dekat kota san francisco, california sejak berdirinya.
called to controversy: the unlikely story of moishe rosen and the founding of jews for jesus by ruth rosen (thomas nelson, 2012) isbn 978-1-59555-491-8
not ashamed: the story of jews for jesus by ruth tucker (multnomah publishers, 2000) isbn 978-1-57673-700-2
sentenced for life: a story of an entry and an exit into the world of fundamentalist christianity and jews for jesus by jo ann schneider farris (writers club press, 2002) isbn 0-595-24940-x
messianic judaism: a rabbi's journey through religious change in america by carol harris-shapiro (beacon press, 1999) isbn 978-0-8070-1040-2
evangelizing the chosen people: missions to the jews in america, 18802000 by yaakov ariel (the university of north carolina press, 1999) isbn 0-8078-2566-2
hawking god. a young jewish woman's ordeal in jews for jesus by ellen kamentsky (sapphire press, 1993) an excerpt
jews for jesus: an anthropological study by juliene g. lipson (ams press, 1990) isbn 0-404-62605-x
smashing the idols: a jewish inquiry into the cult phenomenon by gary d. eisenberg (jason aronson, 1988) isbn 0-87668-974-8
situs resmi jews for jesus
jewish missions - san francisco situs web misionaris jews for jesus di san francisco
ex-jews for jesus situs web bekas anggota jews for jesus
why jews don't believe in jesus (mengapa orang yahudi tidak percaya kepada yesus)
who is financing "jews for jesus"?
(siapa yang membiayai "jews for jesus" pada faqs.org)
county jewish organizations protest evangelical attempt by steven reiskind (boca raton news) 5 november 2003
jews for jesus campaign targets ny jews oleh gal beckerman (10 juli 2006) jerusalem post
holy hell over subway 'jesus' ad blitz targets jews oleh jeremy olshan (new york post) july 7, 2006
the hebrew roots network