Theories

Hello internet, and welcome to AFAC theory! The smartest tab in the AFAC wiki!

You can submit a theory by editing in one down below or by posting one in the comments. There is no such thing as a bad theory. No, wait... Yeah there are. There is no such thing as a bad supported theory. Tell the community your ideas!

## Submit Your Fan Theories Here!

Theory: Sans broke the 4th wall- In a recent update, the AFAC blog has told us that the characters of AFAC began hearing the askers inside their heads around the time Gaster was freed from the void. My theory is that the energy discharge from the exchanging of matter between the two dimentions was powerful enough to damage the 4th wall. In this theory, the 4th wall is the barrier that stops AU's from interacting at any time. It can only be broken by an artist or an ask blog. My theory on *that* is that our internet is a much more powerful force in the Undertale Au realm. Now, we can interact directly with the characters. Thanks Sans!
~Anonymous( I don't have an account, but just call me the AFAC Kumquat)

~~Theory: Frisk is left handed- this isn't an AFAC theory as much as an Undertale theory, but here it goes. Ever notice Frisk's attack animation in the Geno run? It is a slash that arcs from left, around to right, then back left. If you hold a flat handled object, (like a knife) the way that Frisk is always depicted as holding it, blade up and edge out, It is very awkward to make that shape with your right hand. You end up in an uncomfortable position. If you do it lefty, it is actually quite a natural slash to make. ~AFAC Kumquat~~ I failed so hard here. Wrong slash animation. ~AFAC Kumquat

Theory: What is the Real Knife?: Okay okay, I was thinking of something else when doing the "Frisk is left handed" theory. But this one is better. The *actual* slash animation in undertale is a slash that arcs down and left a little bit, then back to right and finishes with an upwards flourish. I watch this over and over and I think "That is a really stupid slash to make." With a kitchen knife like the one the real knife is depicted as, the slash isn't necessarily uncomfortable, but it is really unnatural and weird.No one would just DO that. It is weird and a very bad choice. It leaves you open and in a weird position. Unless, UNLESS, the blade is double edged. Like a dagger or sai. Then it would just be a matter of slashing down then up. Leaving you in a better, actuality good position. ~AFAC Kumquat

Theory: Frisk has Split Personality Disorder: This by far, my favorite theory. Just think about it. Why would you be able to play a pacifist or a genocide run? Just because of player choice? Ha! Of course not. I mean this is the game with a cannon explanation for reloading your saves. I highly HIGHLY doubt this is just an arbitrary detail. And now you may say: "But isn't Chara who posses Frisk in the Geno run?" And to that I say no... no she doesn't. (Click here for more. It is a really good video) So why, oh why can we do this? Well, consider this: Frisk is your average giraffe \*cough cough\* I mean kid,and something traumatic happens (maybe his parents die idk,) but the resulting trauma causes Frisk to develop split personality disorder. On personality is kind and merciful, but the other is a murderous psychopath. Lets say, one day, despite all of Good Frisk's efforts, Bad Frisk kills someone. Lets say scared and confuse, Frisk runs up a mountain, Mt. Ebbot to be specific. Then they fall down the hole into monster land, BUT, when Frisk's soul merges with Chara's, Frisk's SPD is cured, but is it cured as Good Frisk or Bad Frisk? That is the players decision. ~AFAC Kumquat

Nice theory, but that youtube video you called as proof is another theory that you assumed canon to AFAC when you might have not read or remembered that part when Frisk explains why the geno route happened. -Anonymous User

Theory: The Narrator is Gaster?: Okay, finally, an actual AFAC specific theory. Here it goes; in the recent updates in AFAC we accidentally (I hope) put the narrator into a short existential crisis, confirming that they are a separate entity. Since Gaster confirms that there are other Gasters in the crossover event, what if the Narrator is a lost Gaster, reduced to a voice, telling us this story? ~AFAC Kumquat

The Narrator is the SOUL of Perseverance, Paolo. Nice theory, though. ~Astzellel

Prophecy analysis time. I'm the AFAC Kumquat and I am going to analyze the new prophecy to see if we can make some sense out of it. Two fell fellows evade the fourth wall, One is cloaked in linen lied lies, Another waits, long-suffering in static and solitude, Confront them with the truth, if you dare, But first, in the near future, a fell fellow from very far away will fall and probably break their TV or something idk. The first line: Two fell fellows evade the fourth wall. TQ has stated that this is NOT referring to Underfell, sorry guys, so what could it mean? Does it mean they have fallen? Could it be a reference to the fallen children? I looked up some definitions of 'fell' and I think you will like this one: 'of terrible evil or ferocity; deadly.' I believe this prophecy may be referring to new villains in this arc. 'Evade the fourth wall?' Looks like we may be dealing with dimensional travelers. On to the next line: One is cloaked in linen lied lies. This suggests that fellow 1 lied his way here. cloaked seems specific, and who do we know is known for cloaks and lies? Could it be Mavrick Chaosdragon? I don't know. Waaaaait! I'VE GOT IT! the second and third lines refer to Mavric and Flowey! Flowey is stuck in his pot, remember.And they are two people who we previously thought were villains in the story! And the 'truth' from the next line is that they are the same person. The first line is the fact that both are hiding something from the askers, Mavrick and his past, and Flowey and his soul. And last another 'fell fellow' is going to break into the AFAC house! The new villain of AFAC is... AFTER THE ASRIELS!

Two fell fellows evade the fourth wall - Chara and Asriel are dead, or fell. Chara carries Asriel's soul. They're evading us, as they aren't seen on screen.

One is cloaked in linen lied lies - Er I don't exactly know, but this is probably Chara.

Another waits, long-suffering in static and solitude- Asriel waits, suffering in solitude.

Confront them with the truth, if you dare- Tell Chara that she carries Asriel's soul.

But first, in the near future, a fell fellow from very far away will fall and probably break their TV or something idk -Drunk Chara

-willowlight7 who really thinks this entire wiki could be better organized but is overly obsessed with organization and making wikis official and traditional and boring and also should sleep right now

IT HAS FINALLY HAPPENED! Yes the ADC/AFAC Crossover is underway and even by the first few panels, I can tell that this is gonna be good. And yes I do have a theory for you loyal theorists(There are more than one of you right? Let me know down below.) It seems weird that all the interaction between AFAC and the other universes starts with someone coming to the AFAC Universe. So, referring back to my first "Sans Broke the 4th Wall" theory, maybe the massive shift in dimensional energy caused by Sans made the AFAC Universe a sort of hub for dimensional activity.

Alright, recently TQ put up some revealing facts about everyone's favorite poltergeist, Chara. "Chara in this AU is complicated. They see themself as a villain, but in a world that deserves a villain like them. They enjoy hurting other people, but they believe that these sadistic tendencies are something to be ashamed of. Personally I don’t see them as evil." This quote reveals a lot about Chara, more than TQ meant to I think. Chara isn't actually evil, rather, they believe that they are playing a role that needs to be played. They do enjoy hurting people, but believe that it is wrong and believe they should be punished. So, they punish themselves by playing the role of the villain, which causes her to hurt more people, etc. A vicious cycle of self punishment. HOWEVER, TQ said later that: "Being a wizard doesn’t have any effect on LOVE. However things aren’t completely hopeless for Chara. I mean… technically because of the resets, Chara hasn’t gained any LOVE. And even if they had, LOVE can decrease. LOVE is a measure of the metaphorical hardness of a heart, but hearts can change." I think TQ may be foreshadowing a redemption arc for Chara, seeing how she loves prophecies. (The last one turned out to be about the crossover.) I hope she does redeem Chara, I much prefer the non murdery kind.

HELLO THEORISTS! It has been a while. So, TQ just made a song for AFAC that foreshadows some future event. Now, she said we could make some vague guesses and vague guesses is what this page is all about! I am, admittedly, pretty musically attuned and this song tells a story. The beginning tells of a struggle, then redemption of some sort in the middle, becoming a happy ending. Now, I may be biased for my love of a good Chara, but this song I believe is for the Chara redemption arc that I so desperately want. I could be (and probably will be) wrong. BUT I HAVE HOPE!

I'm back baby, and boy have I got a theory for you. Now, you might expect a theory about the whole 'Chara possession inception' thing, but no. I'm doing a BIGGER theory. Paulo refers to some controlling a camera. Last time we met him, er them (It's hard to keep track okay?) they said that something else controlled the perspective. And we know that each perspective change is to keep the ball rolling on the story, specifically, the juicy romance. Switching away from a drunk Chara to the Soriel happenings. Diverting from the possessed Bottles to some good old Papyton. You know what else does that kind of, 'romance over action' thing? Soap Operas. As in 'a little slice of life' as this blog has been referred to. As in a show. Now, I don't think AFAC is staged per say, but it seems to be optimized for viewing pleasure. Like some sort of sadistic fourth dimensional TV show. Ink!Sans sitting down on Saturday to watch the latest AFAC episode. And guess what, we're tuning in as well. Giving this show the ratings it needs to stay on air... think about this fellow theorists. And remember, to tune in weekdays at 8pm central to the next episode.

### Updated Prophesy Theory From Willow

So far, I believe I was right on every line except one. Well, not exactly "believe I was right," but I have no proof or ideas to the contrary.

One is cloaked in linen lied lies - Chara is Callalied. They're not in Callalied's body. They literally are Callalied. Callalied appears to have two souls in soul-vision, Asriel's and Chara's. Look at their bio (http://68.media.tumblr.com/34fcb964ea6d9ba3d8764628782ab0fc/tumblr\_inline\_oaa0tjYz1Y1sxq0i1\_1280.png ). Their eyes are confirmed to turn red when using magic, their parents died in a pirate raid, Trash Queen confirmed their parrents' names were dropped "outside of the comic and not in an ask." "Their parents are Saoirse and Finn" refers to Chara's parents.

### Prediction

The reason Hanah climbed Mt Ebbot was because of a dare. But who dared them? I think it was Aidrien. Not only would she be about the right age, but it seems very in character for her.

* Climbs out of deep hole\* I Liiiive! I'm back and I was h\*cking right! Chara got redeemed! Although it does seem kind of odd the way it happened. Very convenient. Possessing their skeleton conveniently gave them amnesia. It seems dodgey to me. In going to give TQ the benafit of the doubt and say that there is more to this then there seems to be. And it's not lazy writing. Maybe Chara is pulling the long con.

The ole pretend to be good to enact some evil hijinks trick. Or maybe they paved the way for a new antagonist since we have a bit of a villain void. Who knows? I certainly am excited for a new for for Frisk and Co to face off against. ~AFAC Kumquat

I have a theory about the near future of the blog,seeing from maverick chaosdragon’s flashback we can see that his Chara was a skeleton like this blog,meaning that what happen in his world is the aftermath of adrain’s death,but since at our first contact with him we can see that his world does not have askers,so that means that the askers could change the fate of the blog-anoymous