Maggie McNulty

Last Chance

Legends

### Tribe(s)

Scorpions Tribe, Sharks Tribe, Merge Tribe (Battle Royale)Tribe Cochran, Tribe Vlachos, Merge Tribe (Fans vs. Favorites: Revenge of the Fallen)

Tribe Targaryen, Tribe Parvati, Merged Tribe (Last Chance)

Tribe Garcia, Tribe Devontray, Merged Tribe (Legends)

### Finish

4/14 (Battle Royale)2nd Runner-Up (Fans vs. Favorites: Revenge of the Fallen)

6/17 (Last Chance)

5/19 (Legends)

### Alliances

Bri England, Dacota Weiegert (Battle Royale)Corey Davis, Kenzie Haas, Ness Mulyk, Michael Garcia (Fans vs. Favorites: Revenge of the Fallen)

Parvati Women's Alliance, Silent 4 (Last Chance)

TBD (Legends)

### Votes Against

3 (Battle Royale)0 (Fans vs. Favorites: Revenge of the Fallen)

6 (Last Chance)

14 (Legends)

**Maggie McNulty** was a contestant on Survivor: Battle Royale, Survivor: Last Chance, and Survivor: Legends, and was the 2nd Runner-Up of Survivor: Fans vs. Favorites: Revenge of the Fallen.

A silent but key figure in her original season, Maggie was able to get by in the game by keeping loyalties to those who were in power to obtain safety. However, her strategy would be looked at very critically by many of her opponents who would take her out of the game due to them seeing her as "underserving" to make it to the Final Tribal Council. In her second attempt, Maggie came out of her shell, becoming a major social force within the game and helping to aid in many voteoffs. However, it was not enough, as her game was overlooked in the Final Tribal Council when compared to her opponents.

## Survivor: Battle Royale

Maggie would begin the game on the Scorpions Tribe, and she would immediately attempt to link up with others in the game to bond and make alliances. Maggie would be kept safe for the time being, as her tribe would win the first immunity challenge of the season and would not have to go to Tribal Council. However, Maggie would have to face Tribal Council when her tribe lost the second immunity challenge. Back at camp, Giselle would confess to Maggie about her hidden immunity idol find. In turn, Maggie would attempt to get trust with the others by telling this information to Devin. This would get her in the majority vote and would get the target off of her back for the time being. At Tribal Council, Maggie would help the returnee players' alliance to split the votes between Evan and Giselle by voting for the former, with both targets being seen as big threats for their possessions of their tribe's hidden immunity idols. After the vote came to a tie, Maggie would help vote Evan to secure his elimination from the game.

A tribe swap would seem like a great thing for most players' games, but for Maggie it would spell disaster as she would be thrown onto the games first expanded tribe, the Sharks Tribe, along with Kyle, Ryley, and Sam. At their new camp, Maggie would immediately attempt to bond with her tribemates, and they would instantly decide on Kyle being their first target should they lose any immunity challenges and have to go to Tribal Council. It was lucky for her that she prepared, as the Sharks Tribe and the new Snakes Tribe would lose the next immunity challenge and her sights would quickly settle on Kyle. However, Devin's use of his *Extra Vote* Advantage would not only secure Kyle's safety, but it would also ensure that her new ally, Ryley, would be eliminated from the game. The Sharks Tribe would continue their losing streak at the next immunity challenge, where they would have to retreat to Tribal Council immediately without going back to camp to discuss. Seeing this as an easy decision, Maggie casted her vote against Kyle due to his threat as an outstanding social player. She would get her way, as Sam would help her to eliminate Kyle from the game and would help to guarantee that the both of them make it to the merge.

Once at the merge, Maggie would recognize the value of lying low very early on and would do her best to hide her presence from the others in the game as she helped to attempt to vote Bailey out of the game before that plan backfired and got Jack out instead. After losing the next individual immunity challenge, Maggie would quickly agree to vote out Casey, who was being seen as a nuisance by some of the other players. At Tribal Council, Casey's voteoff would not shock her, but the second elimination vote after his departure would. Out of time and out of other names, Maggie would vote Giselle, seeing her as the next biggest threat. However, she would get a second shock at this Tribal Council, as Giselle's hidden immunity idol play would negate Maggie's vote and send Devin out of the game.

After losing individual immunity to Giselle, Maggie would speak with many of the other contestants, all of whom were starting to recognize how she was easily able to slip under everyone's noses for so long. Although they knew she should not be taken out at that upcoming Tribal Council, some of them vowed to take her out before the end, and Maggie would be informed of a plan to blindside Bailey. At Tribal Council, Maggie would vote against Bailey, participating in her elimination from the game and leaving her very shocked. After once again losing individual immunity to Giselle, Maggie participated in many conversations involving how they could take out Sam, who she perceived as an endgame threat. At Tribal Council, Maggie would vote for Sam, and would vote for Sam again on the revote, seeing no reason to back down from taking a big threat out at the endgame. However, this would put her in jeopardy, as she, Dacota, and Hunter would now have to draw rocks for their life in the game. Fortunately for Maggie, luck would be on her side, and she would watch Hunter get eliminated from the game for his unlucky pick.

After losing individual immunity to Dacota, Maggie's spot in the game would be at risk once again, as people would label her as "undeserving" to get to the end due to her intensely playing under the radar. Bri and Maggie would give campaigns to save her and to eliminate Giselle for her challenge performances and her underdog status in the game being a threat for the Final Tribal Council. In the end, Bri and Dacota would help her to eliminate Giselle, helping Maggie to see the Final 4. After losing the Final Individual Immunity Challenge to Bri, she was chosen by Bri to compete against Dacota in the game's first *Final 4 Passage Challenge*, meaning that if she won, Dacota would be out and she would get to the end. Unfortunately, Maggie would not be successful in her last challenge, and would lose to Dacota. Maggie would become the 7th and final member of the jury, and she would place 4th out of 14th.

Fresh out of the game, Maggie was aware of many aspects of all of the finalists' games at the Final Tribal Council, and she would discuss with the others around her for each finalist. Despite having positive opinions of each finalist, Maggie would cast her vote for Dacota to win the game, valuing her gameplay the most.

At the *Survivor: Battle Royale Reunion Episode*, Maggie was asked about her game and her prior knowledge of it. To this, she would reply about how she had a bit of understanding but not so much as other returning players did, and how that helped to shape her strategy of "*going with the flow*" to help her get further and so that the other returnee players could battle each other and give her safety in the game.

## Survivor: Fans vs. Favorites: Revenge of the Fallen

Maggie began her second chance with a shocking twist, the *First Impressions Vote*, of which prompted her to quickly bond with Michael and Steph to be let in on their plan. However, she was left high and dry as her vote against Ness was not eliminate her, and she would be separated from her allies after being sent to Tribe Cochran. This turned out to be a blessing in disguise, as her tribe won the first immunity challenge of the season, keeping her safe. This gave her time to bond with Kenzie at camp and to solidify her position in the tribe. She was then included in on Richie's plan to vote out Darius on the offchance that they lost the next immunity challenge. This would not have to be a concern for Maggie though, as they won the next immunity challenge, keeping her safe yet again.

A tribe swap complicated things for Maggie, and she once again was thrown onto a newly expanded tribe, Tribe Vlachos, alongside Corey, Kenzie, and Richie. Maggie was much luckier with her new tribe this time, as she continued her winning streak when they won the next immunity challenge. At camp, Maggie unintentionally helped Richie find a hidden immunity idol, thus prompting her, Corey, and Kenzie to form a plan to attempt to either blindside Richie or get him to flush his hidden immunity idol out of the game. Although she tried to help to throw the next immunity challenge, her tribe ended up winning it due to the poor performance from Tribe Parvati in the immunity challenge. Back at camp, Richie got her and their tribemates made a plan to use the hidden immunity idol to blindside a big threat in the game and suggested they work together in the future of the game, a plan of which Maggie was fond of.

Another tribe swap gave out an opportunity as she was thrown back onto Tribe Cochran, who then lost the next immunity challenge. Maggie and Vin approached their new tribemates, Michael and Ness, about blindsiding Richie, who still had possession of the hidden immunity idol. Her plan involved telling Richie that it was Vin or Michael, then having Ness vote for Michael or Vin, and then having herself with Michael and Vin vote for Richie. However, her master plan started to fall apart when she told Richie that it was Vin just minutes before Ness told Richie that the vote was going towards Michael. Richie began to flip-flop on his answers on whether or not he would use his hidden immunity idol or not, making Maggie and her allies insecure. This caused much chaos at Tribal Council, as Michael and Vin voted against each other, with her and Ness being the only two to stick to their plan and causing a 2-2-~~1~~ tied vote after Richie used his hidden immunity idol on himself. On the revote, Maggie helped to secure Vin's elimination, blindsiding both Vin and Richie, and putting herself on good terms with Michael and Ness.

Once Maggie made the merge, she was included in on a plan by Richie to finally oust Darius from the game, a plan that she and new allies would be all in for. While attempting to talk with Kenzie about this plan, she and Ness made a mental note at how uncooperative she was with just simply talking with them, as she refused to step near Maggie and Ness to even talk about voting off Darius with them. Maggie was shocked at Tribal Council though when Michael found himself on the bad end of a 7-3 vote, leaving her and Ness on the bottom. However, she would not be in this position for too long, as Corey and Richie approached her and Ness minutes after Adam won the next individual immunity challenge with a plan to take out Darius. At Tribal Council, Maggie helped to blindside Darius in a 7-2 vote in an attempt to keep herself safe in the game with less threats to take her out.

At the *Survivor Whitewater Auction*, Maggie did not make any purchases, but her ally, Ness, got lucky in her purchase, buying a *Steal-A-Vote* Advantage for them to utilize. However, Maggie soon caught wind of Richie's purchase soon after Corey won individual immunity, with Richie having won a clue to the *Idol Nullifier*, now in his possession with a plan to use it against Ness. Maggie attempted to help Ness campaign to get rid of Adam and keep her last true ally in the game. At Tribal Council, Maggie's efforts were helpful, as the duo remained in the game for another round after Richie used his *Idol Nullifier* against Adam to secure his elimination. Maggie finally accomplished a huge goal for any contestant in the game when she outlasted everyone in an individual immunity challenge to come out on top and win individual immunity. Upon winning, she and Ness were approached by Corey and Richie respectively, both of whom told them that Kenzie was leaving at the next Tribal Council, citing that she wanted to be eliminated. However, Maggie's last ally got one last shock, that being her elimination in a 5-2 vote.

Maggie then attempted to realign with Corey and make a plan with him to get them both further in the game, with the first step involving taking out Richie, who was being seen as an endgame threat to win jury votes at the Final Tribal Council. Her plan came into a major obstacle when Richie happened to be the winner of the next individual immunity challenge. Maggie then attempted to make a fake plan with Sam that involved voting Cole in the hopes that she would not be anyone's target, with the main group voting for Sam due to him being considered as the next biggest threat in the game. While she was conversing with Sam, the two of them were approached by Richie, who wanted to take out Corey. However, she lied about being on board with this plan as well. At Tribal Council, her new plans of getting Sam out were foiled by Richie and Sam, who used Sam's *Voodoo Idol* to get rid of Cole for the second time within the season.

Luckily for Maggie, she was still safe, especially after Corey won the next individual immunity challenge. Corey, Kenzie, and Maggie immediately spoke about an opportunity to get Richie or Sam out of the game, with Sam reminding them that they have wanted to get rid of Richie for awhile in the game and Richie campaigning on their agreement to stick together back on Tribe Vlachos. At Tribal Council, Maggie was in the power position, being the swing vote going in, and Maggie ultimately voted out Sam, seeing a better opportunity to vote out Richie the next round. However, this would not be a possibility, as Richie won the Final Individual Immunity Challenge. Maggie immediately spoke with Corey and Kenzie about what they would do now that Richie was immune, and she speculated that they would be doing the *Final 4 Passage Challenge* once again. When campaigning her case to Richie, she tried to convince him to vote for Kenzie due to her not winning any individual immunity challenges and implying that Kenzie did not deserve to make it to the Final Tribal Council. Maggie also attempted to save Corey by stating that she believed that he upset too many jurors in the game to be able to win over them. While this was not the reason for Corey's new safety, he became safe when Richie picked him to go to the end with him. However, this also meant that Maggie's suspicions were correct, and she was thrown back into the *Final 4 Passage Challenge* with Kenzie. Maggie wrote a different ending this time though, and she won the challenge, eliminating Kenzie and keeping herself in the game to see the Final Tribal Council.

At the Final Tribal Council, Maggie campaigned on her being the only female within the Final 3 and on her strengths and ability to stay off of everyone's radars during the season. Maggie was praised by many for her mostly honest gameplay and was even told by Kenzie that she would have been the automatic winner if the game was solely based on ethics. However, Maggie's gameplay seemed to pale in the eyes of the jury in comparison to her opponents, and she only earned Michael's jury vote. Maggie became the second runner-up of the season and placed 3rd out of 14th.

## Survivor: Last Chance

Maggie returned for a third time, and as it opened Maggie made a "discreet" handshake with Michael, showcasing a potential alliance between the two before being put onto Tribe Targaryen with Elizabeth, Jack D., Jake, John, JP, Kyle, and Tom. Maggie was then told they would immediately compete in the first immunity challenge of the season, which resulted in a loss. Despite her potential to go home first, Maggie already had allies in the game, with Sam R., on Tribe Potowatomi, wanting to work with her later on as she allied with Elizabeth on her tribe. When talking to Tom, Maggie tried to convince him of her value by highlighting her puzzle prowess and advocated for them to keep one person for every type of challenge, not just the physical ones. In private, Maggie spoke on how her spiel to Tom was a part of her strategy to get her tribemates to keep her as she sensed she was at risk. Her strategy ended up working for her, as after the guys aligned with each other, with Tom campaigned for Maggie to stay due to her puzzle strengths. When she and Elizabeth talked to JP, the two women were told to target John, with Jack D. and Jake pretending to agree, with the lies going right over her head. At Tribal Council, Maggie was blindsided as Elizabeth was voted out in a 6-2 vote, with her being the only one to not vote against her. For the first time, Maggie was on the outs early on, can she recover? Or will she do the walk of shame a lot earlier this time?

Minutes later, her ally's spot was replaced by Jack M., arriving from the Solo Room, and Maggie welcomed him like the others, wanting to be nice. At the second immunity challenge, Maggie's tribemates bickered a lot, causing them to take longer to give her the puzzle pieces to work on with Jake and JP. Even Maggie's puzzle skills were not enough to save them from sorrow as they once again lost immunity when her ally, Michael, solved the puzzle before her for his tribe; with him not worrying for her knowing her skillset will help her. At camp, Maggie's skillset in challenges proved to be beneficial to her tribemates, as multiple people, such as Jack D. and JP, campaigned for her to stay on their tribe, thus, fracturing the men's alliance. Once Maggie came upon a conversation with her original tribemates, they all planned to vote off Jack M., with him getting the brunt of the blame for their challenge loss. In private, Maggie talked about her stress being the only woman on their tribe and talked through the ins and outs of her social gameplay, explaining her methods to get by in the early game and how she hoped to link up with Michael later on, way after voting Jack M.. At Tribal Council, Maggie followed through on the first part of her desires, as she helped vote Jack M. off in a unanimous 7-1 vote. While she still seemed to be living on borrowed time, the next round breathed new life into her game as a tribe swap sent her to the new Tribe Parvati alongside Ashley, John, Kyle, and Lita, and although they lost the next immunity challenge, mainly due to the men, Maggie knew she could take advantage of her new situation. At camp, Ashley and Maggie quickly aligned and they both got Lita on board with their plan to vote off John, who Maggie knew will be a major threat later on. In private, Maggie revealed the obvious, the formation of a women's alliance on the new Tribe Parvati, and also revealed they were going to target the men, claiming that they messed up the challenge for them. At Tribal Council, Maggie finally planted herself in the majority alliance when they all voted out John in a 4-1 vote, putting the men into the minority just as they did to her.

At the next immunity challenge, Tribe Parvati lost once again, sending them back to Tribal Council. Back at camp, Maggie conversed with the other women about if anyone had found their tribe's hidden immunity idol, to which Maggie jokingly revealed she had found a hidden immunity idol...leftover from *Survivor: Blood vs. Water: Redemption Island*, which essentially served as a decoration and not a hidden immunity idol in *Survivor: Last Chance*, and the women shared a good laugh over Maggie's unfortunate luck. In private, Maggie revealed that the women were planning on sticking together, and she hoped they will not have to pick between them the next round. At Tribal Council, Maggie was not at risk of going home, as Kyle was voted out in a unanimous 3-1 vote, with her not even receiving his final vote. Fortune was finally on Maggie's side, as Tribe Parvati won the next immunity challenge, keeping her tribe from having to choose between the three of them left as she headed into the halfway point into the game, with more options for allies than she was aware of.

The next round introduced the merge to Maggie once more. Albeit the good news, Maggie received a series of bad news and events to come, all starting with her losing the first individual immunity challenge to Lita. At camp, Maggie regrouped with Ashley, Conner, and Michael, all talking to Sam R., now being referred to as Dolphin Sam, who was trying to rally them together to form a new majority with JP and Lita. Maggie later spoke to and aligned with Dolphin Sam 1:1. As she did this though, Michael made a plan with JP to vote Dolphin Sam and relayed it to Maggie, and Ashley gave her backlash for being "transparent" with Dolphin Sam, but Maggie reassured her that he did not hear anything crucial from her. When told more of Michael's plan, she gave her concerns with her closeness to Dolphin Sam, despite her allies saying he was playing both sides. Maggie privately mentioned her attempts to make new allies and she hoped things will go her way. Maggie then talked to Ashley, who now wanted to vote JP, and she agreed, citing him as a strong competitor; even though she later talked to Michael about targeting Dolphin Sam again. As the two talked, Michael worried JP was not on their side due to him "protecting" certain people he wanted out, leading them to consider Jack D. as their next best option, and Maggie agreed to talk to Ashley about this. At Tribal Council, Maggie's poor luck continued, as two of her allies, Conner and Michael, were locked in a 4-4-3-1 tied vote, with her having voted for Jack D.. On the revote, she tried to save Michael by voting against Conner, but it was fruitless, as Michael was sent to the jury, ending another unlucky merge round for her game.

Despite the bad start, Maggie's luck would change once again. Even after she lost individual immunity to Sam C., she spoke with Ashley and Jake, and she explained why she voted Jack D. the previous vote, only for Jake to tell her he was on board with voting Jack D. with them, and the three agreed to do so, seeing Jack D. as a threat. Soon after, Ashley and Maggie talked to Dolphin Sam, and the three of them made a Final 3 pact, with Maggie now feeling optimistic. The two women transitioned to another conversation led by Jake, where he was filling in Collin, Conner, and Sam C. in on their plan to vote out Jack D., only for Jack D. and Dolphin Sam to into their chat as Sam C. made a cover story about voting JP and Lita. However, Lita walking into the area led to people leaving as Sam C. lied to Lita about not having a target. When the dust settled, only Lita was left to tell Maggie and her allies about a plan to vote Jake out to separate him and Sam C., and she and Ashley leaked his plans to Lita. When alone, the silent four agreed on Dolphin Sam's idea to vote Jake so they can blindside JP and Lita easier after gaining their trust. Maggie privately mourned Michael's blindside but was positive about her alliance as she planned to go forth with the plan. At Tribal Council, Maggie voted against Jake, getting him voted out 9-2. After losing the next challenge to Jack D., the Silent 4 heard Sam C.'s pitch to break up the power couple, to which Maggie showcased enthusiasm for. However, Maggie privately spoke of her awareness of Sam C. being voted out and even desired it, as she learned from her last season to not bank on a potential with future threats, citing Richie as an example. Tribal Council went differently than what Maggie had hoped for, as despite her voting Sam C. alongside most of the remaining players, he remained in the game after playing a hidden immunity idol. After Lita played her hidden immunity idol as well, Maggie was shocked to see her ally, Dolphin Sam, become the third juror, with many being blindsided by his 1-vote elimination.

***More Coming Soon...***

## Trivia

* Maggie is one of three people to be the first to be involved in a three-person rock drawing, the others being Hunter Heschke and Dacota Weiegert.
* Maggie is the first person to lose a *Final 4 Passage Challenge*, doing so in *Survivor: Battle Royale*.
* Maggie is the only contestant from *Survivor: Battle Royale* to compete in back-to-back seasons.
* Maggie is the only contestant to play as a new player in *Survivor: Battle Royale* and return in a future season.
* Maggie is the only female returning player in *Survivor: Fans vs. Favorites: Revenge of the Fallen* to have not played in *Survivor: Winter War*.
* Maggie is the only contestant to participate in the *Final 4 Passage Challenge* on multiple seasons, doing so in *Survivor: Battle Royale* and *Survivor: Fans vs. Favorites: Revenge of the Fallen*.
	+ Maggie is also the only contestant to win and lose the *Final 4 Passage Challenge*.
* Maggie is the only contestant to be on every single third tribe after a tribe expansion.
	+ On *Survivor: Battle Royale*, Maggie was swapped to the new Sharks Tribe. On *Survivor: Fans vs. Favorites: Revenge of the Fallen*, Maggie was swapped onto the new Tribe Vlachos. On *Survivor: Last Chance*, Maggie was swapped onto the new Tribe Parvati.
* Everytime Maggie received votes against her in S*urvivor: Last Chance*, one of the votes would come from Collin.
* Everytime Maggie received votes against her in *Survivor: Last Chance*, the amount would be doubled from the previous number of votes she received.
* Every time Maggie played the game, she would cast a vote against a returning player at her fifth Tribal Council within the season.
	+ The first two times Maggie would do this, the returning player would block her vote with the use of a hidden immunity idol.