Season Three

***Season Three** was set upon Solider Island and was themed based on the mystery novel **And Then There Were None**, featuring **13 Guests** attempting to discover the **5 Murderers** among them. It was hosted in August of 2018, was the only season to have more than two finalists, and included another set of brand new players, apart from the latecomers twist which brought both previous winners back into the fray. The season is considered one of the less notable ones due to how predictable most of the early boots were, however the game picked up around Halfway Havoc, and the late game gave birth to a good number of allstars. Furthermore the season did showcase the most dominant winning game in CMIYC history by @JacksonSunshine, who's lowest placement on a trustlist the entire season was 5th and placed in the top on ten occasions.*

## **Cast**

**@JACKSONSUNSHINE****@MEPOLE****@PETERCAMPBELL****@PHOENIX723****@HELENOR1000****@NATHANSWAG9****@YOURBOY****@EXOTICSIMMER****@RIKU1274****@KAYLARENEE****@GURGS****@LOUDNESOVERLOAD****@PANTHERKING21****@DAVIDPRINCIPE29****@RUNAWAYS****@BAILEY****@ICELINA****@JOEY2121**
## **Episodes**

☠ **Episode One:** Make Way, The Star Has Been Born [1]

☠ **Episode Two:** Zwooper Will Have Our Heads For This [2]

☠ **Episode Three:** I Think I Need To Toss Him A Bone... [3]

☠ **Episode Four:** And Goliath Defeats David! [4]

☠ **Episode Five:** Congrats. You Just Put The Nail In Your Coffin. [5]

☠ **Episode Six:** Sunshine... Will You Marry Me? <3 [6]

☠ **Episode Seven:** Better Get Security, Cuz I'm Gonna KittenBlob This House [7]

☠ **Episode Eight:** Ain't Gotta Be Dead To Spill Tea, Coffee, Or Other Beverages [8]

☠ **Episode Nine:** \*Prays Like Kesha\* [9]

☠ **Episode Ten:** See You In Hell... But I'll Be On The Devil's Throne [10]

☠ **Episode Eleven:** Gotta Get Some Stains On These Spotless Records [11]

☠ **Episode Twelve:** Ya Got Tweedle Dee And Tweedle Dumb Over Here... [12]

☠ **Episode Thirteen:** I'm Not Sure If I Can Pull The Trigger [13]

☠ **Episode Fourteen:** And The Winner Is... [14]

## **Season Summary**

As the season begins cast members find a **mysterious poem** nailed to all their chambers, describing the brutal ways in which each of them will eventually die. After introductions things quickly escalate as Nathan immediately exposes an alliance of Amy/Peter/Joey/Runaways. Runaways fesses up to it but denies making it, instead pinning it's creation on Joey, who did in fact found it. The extra vote twist is played by Amy, and Bailey & Gavin appear to have enemies hidden somewhere within the cast. Ultimately however it's Joey who drops to the bottom, and though he pleads for people to look past his rookie mistake it's not enough and he's killed in the gardens, being the first Murderer to fall.

Gavin's on edge from the anon confessionals, and Xander notices that Joey's placement has been marked as 18th, leading the cast to suspect the eventual return of the former winners. Jayden and Bailey are also suspicious of their peers. Helen takes some heat when she goes after Nathan, and Bailey quickly turns into a target. Amy and Gavin both land in the top for the second week in a row, whereas Phoenix & Brady both end up on the bottom for the second week. Amy once again claims 1st and plays the twist, turning the round into a Double Eviction, and all three of the nominees fight hard with an underdog pitch, claiming they're on the outs and have no where else to turn. Ultimately Phoenix is the only one to scrape by, with Brady being crushed by a statue & Bailey getting caught in a beartrap. Two new members take their place however, with Kayla & George sailing to the island as late arrivals, receiving immunity for the following round.

Right away Helen calls out whoever made the anon confessionals about her, denying having ever targeted Nathan. Ryan is becoming increasingly nervous about the results as people are being quiet, and David/Helen appear to have more concealed enemies, and fears grow over a list reveal. Helen soars to the top however, with Amy and Gavin joining her once again, Amy claiming yet another 1st. The Runaways/Nathan feud finally comes to a boiling point as they both become nominees, Ryan joining them on the block. Nathan makes the case that he shouldn't be punished for exposing Runaways as a liar at the start, whereas Runaways says he's not as much of a liability as Nathan, who will spill whatever he needs to. The majority of the house sides with Nathan however, and Runways was accidentally thrown off a cliff.

As the next week begins Jayden calls out Ryan & Nathan for having a final two deal, accusing them of selling out Runaways, Bailey, and now trying to throw him under the bus over false claims, saying he's playing both sides and sticking with the people placing in the top. Nathan denies it and says Jayden's grasping at straws, and most of the people who've been placing high deem it wiser to side with Nathan, causing Jayden to fall to the bottom. Talk begins of targeting the top placements, especially Amy/Helen & the two winners, but Amy/Gavin/Kayla/Helen still all soared to the top, Amy getting a fourth 1st place in a row, with David/Ryan falling to the bottom as well. Jayden makes a solid case of David running the show, breaking deals, & spreading names, and it works, with David being poisoned by Z\_CageMaster.

With the same people soaring to the top front-runners are becoming clear, and the divide only continues to grow as Ryan/Jayden drop to the bottom again, though this time Nathan is dragged down with them. Jayden expresses his frustration at honesty being met with lies, and an awkward confrontation begins when Gavin/Helen/Kayla/George all deny placing first. When George & Helen both claim to have placed third drama erupts, with George trying to conceal his Murderer role intensely by faking a screenshot of him placing third, to which Helen sends a similar one, confused as to why he's going after her, and most people realize George's is fake. Despite knowing there's already a large portion of votes against him Jayden fights hard again, saying it'd be silly to eliminate him over the duo that continuously spreads lies & will do anything to survive, but his plea falls on deaf ears as Nathan denies it, and Jayden's trapped in a cave and struck by lightning.

With Jayden gone Nathan begins to shift his target towards Kayla & Xander for being a known duo, and things heat up when Peter informs Kayla about it. Nathan calls Peter out as a snake and says him and Kayla are aligned, prompting Kayla to post both of her previous two lists to the main chat, claiming she has nothing to hide and that the only person she was aligned with was George, who she now believes to be targeting her. She goes on to post a screenshot of George asking to form a Murderers alliance with her, putting his role wide out in the open, though George continues to deny it, still saying Helen faked the previous day's screenshot and that he was only trying to test Kayla. Despite Amy still widely being considered the front runner she claims another 1st place, and George/Peter/Xander fall to the bottom as the week's nominees. Though Xander makes the pitch that he's been honest all game and that George is a known Murderer it wasn't enough to overlook his connection to Kayla, and he was soon murdered by an evil lemon.

George gets no rest as Amy quickly goes after him for spreading her name. George happily admits it and says that if she makes it to the end she'll win hands down, and that everyone loves her, which Amy quickly denies, and says that if anyone let's him or Kayla make it to the end they're a fool. The cast evidently agrees, as Kayla and George both drop down to become nominees, Ryan joining them, taking more heat for his social game. Gavin tries to spar with George or Ryan for going after him but ends up fighting himself out of boredom. George makes it very clear that if he stays Amy/Gavin/Kayla will be his targets, whereas Kayla makes the case that seven Guests remain, and if they don't begin taking out Murderers it's quickly going to become a killer's game. Ultimately Kayla wins the war by five votes, with George being burnt to ash.

As the game draws on a target continues to be painted on Helen through the confessionals and Ryan/Amy clash, with each of them calling each other out for lies. Being the last winner standing and a huge target Kayla's unable to escape and slides down to nominee range once again, with Ryan & Phoenix joining her as some of the lesser threats. Both Ryan and Phoenix make the case that they've been nommed over and over and have completely run dry of allies, whereas Kayla says that she'll continue to be nominated, and that keeping her is keeping a confirmed Guest alive. Over the course of the day sides form, with Helen/Gavin/Amy/Nathan/Kayla aligning against Peter/Richie/Phoenix/Ryan/Michael and the vote deadlocks 5-5 between Kayla & Ryan, with Ryan barely outedging Kayla in the Catch challenge, leaving Kayla to drink from a poisoned cup of tea.

As Halfway Havoc arrives Guests are told three Murderers still remain & Murderers are promised that the order of the top three will be concealed from that point forth. Furthermore players are tasked with competing in the only reward challenge of the season- a classic game of clue, in return for a reduction. When Ryan announces that he won't be sharing his cards with anyone both Amy & Nathan erupt at him, with Nathan saying he's not doing anything to change the course of the game and Amy still trying to deny her involvement in running the season. Thanks to Ryan every single person fails to obtain the reward, which is good in theory but he's then nominated, Peter & Nathan joining him. Knowing himself to be doomed Ryan doesn't attempt a plea, but rather is silently & unanimously cast off to sea & eaten by crabs.

As the cast debates making the move against Amy a different move is made instead, knocking the known threats of Gavin & Richie to the bottom, Nathan joining them. Gavin dares the house to send him their lists, Peter asks for the same thing, and suspicion continues to grow as to why no one's played the list reveal twist yet. Gavin takes an incredibly strong stance about discovering the murderers, whereas in a bit of a twist Richie guns for Nathan instead of Gavin, calling him out for trying to manipulate everyone all season, making up lies, and sending people fake trustlists. Nathan returns the jab by saying Richie's the only person he's lied to, accusing Richie of forming a five person alliance to target the three others, Amy/Gavin/Helen. Hearing this news Amy, Gavin, & Helen then decide to team up with Nathan again to gun for Richie, and easily could've forced a 4-4 tie, however Helen barely barely misses the deadline to vote, causing Gavin to be robbed 4-3, stabbed alone in the woods, another murderer fallen.

Despite Amy, Helen, & Michael emerging as front-runners all three of them survive the block yet again, with Richie and Nathan unable to escape certain peril. Knowing his time may likely be up Richie fights hard, saying that it's not always the smartest play to take down the biggest threat on the block, and that next week when someone else is against Nathan as a nominee they'll likely be picked off, though keeping him would shield others from that demise. Michael tries to aid Richie in staying by agreeing to let Richie try and paint Michael as the Murderer to Peter & Phoenix, but ultimately Phoenix becomes the swing vote and decides to send Richie packing, chopped up with firewood, leaving just one Murderer remaining in Helen.

Knowing she's in trouble Amy pitches that she's the only confirmed Guest still, and that eliminating her is exactly what the final murderer would want, trying to paint a target on anyone but herself. Phoenix counters that she'll demolish anyone at the end, but despite it Amy barely survives the block, landing one spot above nominee range, Phoenix just above her, leaving Nathan and Michael on the bottom. Desperately wanting to not follow Richie out as another victim to Nathan, Michael pitches that he's well aware he's the larger threat, but that for anyone who saves him he'll be a number for, and that him staying would be beneficial to anyone except Amy, whereas Nathan makes it very clear that Michael's gone unnominated up till this point. Surprisingly Phoenix and Amy vote together in support of Nathan, whereas Peter & Helen defend Michael, and the lines are drawn in the sand, with Michael then outedging Nathan in the tiebreaker challenge. Nathan was then murdered by Lombard, stabbed with a poison-filled syringe.

Being the last two unnominated players and extremely clear threats to win Helen & Amy finally have nowhere left to hide, and both become the final nominees of the season. Helen makes the simple case that Amy's dominated the whole game and will beat anyone no matter what, whereas Amy says that Helen's escaped nomination after nomination, has no enemies on the jury, has made just as many moves UTR, and is most likely the final murderer who will be greatly rewarded by the public if she advances to the end. Amy dares the cast to take a risk, saying that saving Helen will cost them the game. Michael stays true to his promises from the previous round and fights to save Helen, but Amy's one step ahead and works all day to sway Peter & Phoenix, pleading for them to defend her. Against all odds Helen departs, evicted 3-2, hanged by her fellow houseguests as the final murderer.

The four Guests remaining then are thrown into the vote for the winner. Though their pleas were tasteful both Phoenix & Peter are received critically for not making a move when they had the chance, Michael's gameplay is respected as he went unnominated & UTR for so long, but ultimately Amy is the clear and deserving winner of the adventure having dominated the entire season, claiming the title with 46.9% of the public vote.

**@JACKSONSUNSHINE (46.9%)****@MEPOLE (37.5%)**