ElizaFirst

**ElizaFirst** is the theory that Elizabeth Afton from *Sister Location* was the first child in the series to die, particularly before Charlie or the Bite Victim.

## Evidence

* In FNAF 4, to the right of BV's bedroom is a girl's room. However, a sister is never seen or mentioned in the story, even at BV's birthday party. This has led some to believe that Elizabeth Afton was already dead by the time BV died.
* It's possible that BV witnessed Elizabeth's death and that's what made him so afraid of the animatronics.
	+ Fredbear Plush's line *"Don't you remember what you saw?"* would be referring to Elizabeth's death. BV would be afraid of going near the animatronics because when his sister got close to Baby, she was killed.
* Nightmare Fredbear has a giant mouth in his stomach. This could be influenced by BV seeing Circus Baby's stomach open up to grab Elizabeth.
* In Sister Location, the line *"All I see is an empty room / No more joy, an empty tomb"* could be referencing Elizabeth's empty room in FNAF 4 after her death.
* In the Novel Trilogy, it's implied that Elizabeth died before the MCI.

## Problems

* ElizaFirst relies on the fact that William Afton created child-snatching animatronics (the Funtimes) without any discernible reason or motivation.
	+ The Funtime Animatronics were most likely created after the MCI.
		- On Night 1 of Sister Location, HandUnit says, "*Due to the massive success and even more so the unfortunate closing of Freddy Fazbear's Pizza, it was clear that the stage was set, no pun intended, for another contender in children's entertainment."* Though the Funtime Animatronics *could* have been created before this, Circus Baby's Entertainment and Rental was established *after* the original Freddy Fazbear's closed (which, according to the FNAF 1 newspapers, would've been a few years after the MCI).
		- Furthermore, Elizabeth was killed by Baby shortly before Circus Baby's Pizza World was set to open. Seeing as BV died in 1983 – the year Fazbear Entertainment was established and while Fredbear's was still open – Freddy Fazbear's Pizza did not even exist prior to this, making it very unlikely that Elizabeth died before BV.
			* It could be possible that the Funtimes were built prior to 1983, but Circus Baby's Pizza World wasn't repurposed into CBEAR until several years later, after the MCI, when it would have greater opportunity for competition. However, it still begs the question as to why Afton would create Circus Baby to kidnap children prior to any of the games' major events.
	+ Though there's no definitive motive for Afton's killings in general, it's more likely that he started by killing the "traditional" way and only created killer robots after witnessing how the murders affected the animatronics' behavior. Still, this is only speculation.
* Ballora's song was written by her voice actress, Michella Moss, and doesn't hold any lore significance.
* Elizabeth's room appears to have a broken-apart toy resembling Mangle on the floor. Considering that Funtime Foxy (Mangle's original form, not to be confused with SL's Funtime Foxy) was a mascot for Kid's Cove and popular with toddlers, it could mean that Elizabeth was still too young in 1983 to be babysat by her brothers and was instead at daycare or with a nanny.
	+ Some theorize that Elizabeth Afton could be the neighborhood girl with green eyes and orange pigtails that look similar to Baby's. While possible, it's not confirmed.

## Related theories

* ElizaPlush

## Conflicting theories

* CharlieFirst
* BVFirst