Fan Theories

Hey everyone! This is a page for your fan theories.

If you have a theory, write your name/username in front of your theory when you edit this (Ex: TheCyanWolf: Everyone dies.)

Tessa the awesome: I think that in book 9, or 10, Lord Cassius is gonna do something that will make him a good g

**Itchymentor0402:** I don't think that Lord Cassius is related to Sophie, because that would just mess up the whole Sophie-Keefe relationship...
**TheCyanWolf:**I'm not going to say much, but sources have informed me that in the upcoming Legacy, Tam has been ordered to kill Keefe...

**JesusGirl1212:** I think I know who Sophie's dad is because Mr. Forkle said if anyone found out their world would fall apart so I think it's Bronte. Comment Bronte if you agree with the theory.

**DreamerNymph713:** Sophie's dad is probably Bronte because Mr. Forkle ir someone else said that their abilities come from their genes. Therefore, since Bronte is the only Inflictor we know, and it would probably be too late to introduce another character, he would be her dad. And Bronte never sided against her in something that was actually important, like in the restrictor thing. Everything else was probably to have a good cover story. And the first time that he met her, he was probably angry because the Black Swan wasn't supposed to bring her there yet. The elven world would fall apart because Councillors aren't supposed to have children. Her mom could be Caprise Redek, and the Neverseen wanted to get rid of her by having someone push her off the balcony. I think that one might be a bit far-fetched, but that is one of the only leads I have.

**SlyCat777:** Nah, it's probably ELWIN!!! He keeps acting like Sophie is his daughter. "My little girl is growing up!"

**LOLKeepertime:** I think that, since Sophie has some unseen talents, as Mr.forkle hints many times

**Themoonlarkian:** I think that Sophie won’t be a couple with keefe and will be single.

**Disney-Keeper-Book-Lover** **:** I think that Sophie will get together with Fitz then will realize it isn't right and get together with Keefe. I think that Sophie's feelings for Fitz are just like Dex's feelings for Sophie and it's all in her head. Plus, Keefe has awesome hair. Another theory that I have is that Brant isn't dead and that he and Forkle just made a deal because Brant is secretly a double agent. So when everyone thinks Brant is long gone he is secretly spying on the Neverseen. Another theory of mine (yeah I have a lot of theories I also have a lot of time on my hands.) is that Sophie's dad is a member of the Neverseen (Possible Brant, look at my theory above) because one of them is a double agent. ANOTHER theory of mine is that Jolie isn't dead she is secretly working with Brant (See my theories above) to get the Neverseen's goodies. Okay, I'm done now.

**AdelaideSunflower:** Everyone's starting with I think xD oop- I THINK that Blur is Jensi's brother because Jensi did mention his brother was a Phaser, correct? And Shannon did post pictures of Marella, Stina, Maruca and Jensi on her Instagram saying those characters would play a bigger part in the series. All of them HAVE. Except Jensi. So if his brother would be a leader on the Black Swan, then it would be a perfect way to get Jensi more involved. :D

**CrumblyCrepe:** Actually...I think Elwin might be Sophie’s father. I don’t have very much evidence to back this up, but in on of the books it said Elwin felt almost like family. I think that could have possibly been foreshadowing? Also, it doesn’t sound like he knows Oralie very well, so that clears up the whole not knowing each other thing. And...I kind of want him to be her father. He’s already one of my favorite characters, so how cool would that be? Anyway... (posted April 23rd, 2020.)

Princess Purryfinns: I think Trix is Marellas dad

**LadyNerd15:** I actually have a couple of theories. Remember when Mr Forkle told Sophie straight up that he wasn't her bio father? I think that was true. But that was before we knew there were two Mr. Forkles... I think whichever one was not the one that said that is her father.

My other theory is a bit out there, so bear with me...

\*\*UNLOCKED SPOILERS AHEAD\*\*

So in Unlocked after Keefe predicts the triplets' abilities, he looks back on how when he touched Sophie's hand he didn't feel any strange sensations like he did with the triplets, and he uses that fact as contrast to figure out that this prediction ability only works on people who haven't manifested. He says he didn't feel anything like that with her... but at the same time, the moment he touched her hand was super intense for him. We all know Mr Forkle has said Sophie might have more abilities, but hasn't elaborated on that. But if Keefe did feel something about a future ability in the moment of contact, he may have been so overwhelmed by her emotions that he didn't notice it - especially if it was a sensation that would blend in with everything else he was feeling...

So, hear me out here - I was wondering what Keefe's prediction ability would feel like for him for different abilities (i.e., he felt cold for a Froster, squishy for a Phaser, and "empty" for a Talentless) and I was thinking about what it would be like if he predicted Empathy for someone else. Would he maybe feel... intense emotions???? He already feels that from Sophie, so he wouldn't be able to tell that it was any different, especially with his heightened empathy at the moment. So my thought is that Sophie may manifest as an Empath at some point. This especially makes sense given that Oralie, who is an Empath, is her bio mother and they've already acknowledged that her empathy does have some effects on Sophie's existing powers.

One especially nice thought I've had about this is that if I'm right, once Sophie manifests, Keefe won't feel that extra flood of emotions from her due to his prediction ability and it will be easier for him to be around her again. That would be pretty nice, since Team Foster-Keefe will always be cooler. Assuming they ever find him again... :(

**SlyCat777: TAM HAS A CRUSH ON BIANA!!!** In Lodestar, Marella stares at Tam but Tam doesn't know how to respond. Linh says that Tam likes brunettes, and Biana has brunette hair. Also they both have similar abilities. To conclude, Tam volunteered to carry Biana in Nightfall so he wanted to make Biana admire him. This could totally be wrong and someone PLZ PLZ PLZ respond to this theory!!!