Frilled shark

A frilled shark (Chlamydoselachus anguineus)

The **frilled shark** (*Chlamydoselachus anguineus*), known also on occasion as the **eel shark** is a species of shark in the family **Chlamydoselachidae** in the order hexanchiformes. It is one of two extant species in the chlamydoselachidae, along with the Southern African frilled shark. Its distribution is patchy, but widespread throughout the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans. This species is found over the outer continental shelf and upper continental slope, generally near the bottom, though there is evidence of substantial upward movements, indicating it might be a vertical migrator. It has been caught as deep as 1,570 m (5,150 feet), although it is uncommon below 1,200 m (3,900 feet). Interestingly, it is more common at depths of 50–200 m (160–660 ft) in Japan's Suruga Bay.

The frilled shark is often described as a living fossil, and exhibits several primitive features not seen in most sharks outside the other genera of the hexanchiformes. It reaches a length of 2 m (6.6 ft) and has a dark brown, eel-like body with the dorsal, pelvic, and anal fins placed far back. Its common name comes from the frilly or fringed appearance of its six pairs of gill slits, with the first pair meeting across the throat.

Rarely observed alive, the frilled shark may capture prey by bending its body and lunging forward like a snake. The long, extremely flexible jaws enable it to swallow prey whole, while its many rows of small, triple-fanged, needle-like teeth make it difficult for the prey to escape. It feeds mainly on cephalopods such as squid, as well as deep-water bony fishes and other sharks. This species is aplacental viviparous: the embryos emerge from their egg capsules inside the mother's uterus, where they survive primarily on yolk generated by the mother. The gestation period for this shark may be as long as three and a half years, the longest of any vertebrate. Litter sizes vary from two to fifteen pups, and there is no distinct breeding season recorded for this shark. Frilled sharks are occasional bycatch in commercial fisheries, but have little economic value overall.

## Description

With its elongated, eel-like body and strange appearance, the frilled shark has long been compared to the mythical sea serpents of ancient legends. The head is broad and flattened with a short, rounded snout. The nostrils are vertical slits, separated into incurrent and excurrent openings by a leading flap of skin. The moderately large eyes are horizontally oval and lack nictitating membranes (protective third eyelids found in many other species of shark). The very long jaws are positioned at the end of the snout, as opposed to the underslung jaws of most sharks. The corners of the shark's mouth are devoid of furrows or folds. The tooth rows are rather widely spaced, numbering 19–28 in the upper jaw and 21–29 in the lower jaw. There are 300 teeth in the shark's mouth; each tooth is small, with three slender, needle-like cusps alternating with two cusplets. There are six pairs of long gill slits with a frilly appearance created by the extended tips of the gill filaments, giving this shark its name. Only a few other sharks and rays also share this feature, including the other hexanchiformes, such as the sevengill and sixgill sharks. The first pair of gill slits meet across the throat, forming a collar.

The pectoral fins of the frilled are short and round. The single, small dorsal fin is positioned far back on the body, about opposite the anal fin, and has a rounded margin. The pelvic and anal fins are large, broad, and round as well, and also positioned well back on the body. The shark's caudal fin is very long and roughly triangular, without a lower lobe or a ventral notch on the upper lobe. There are a pair of thick skin folds of unknown function running along the belly, separated by a groove. The midsection is relatively longer in female frilled sharks than in males, with the pelvic fins pushed closer to the animal's anal fin. The dermal denticles are small and shaped like the tip of a chisel, becoming enlarged and sharp on the dorsal margin of the caudal fin. This species is a uniform dark brown or gray. The frilled shark differs from its southern African relative, *C. africana*, in having more vertebrae (160–171 vs 147) and more turns in the spiral valve intestine (35–49 versus 26–28), as well as in various proportional measurements such as a longer head and shorter gill slits. The maximum known length is 1.7 m (5.6 ft) for males and 2.0 m (6.6 ft) for females.

## Phylogeny and Taxonomy

The frilled shark was first scientifically recognized by German ichthyologist Ludwig Döderlein, who visited Japan between 1879 and 1881 and brought two specimens back to Vienna. However, his manuscript describing the species was lost, so the first description of the frilled shark was authored by American zoologist Samuel Garman, working from a 1.5-metre (4 ft 11 in)-long female caught in Sagami Bay, Japan. His account, "An Extraordinary Shark", was published in an 1884 volume of the journal *Proceedings of the Essex Institute*. Garman placed the new species in its own genus and family, and gave it the name *Chlamydoselachus anguineus* from the Greek *chlamy* (frill) and *selachus* (shark), and the Latin *anguineus* for "eel-like". Other common names for this species include frill shark, lizard shark, eel shark (which can lead to confusion with the members of the order Xenacanthida), scaffold shark, and silk shark.

Several early authors believed the frilled shark to be a living representative of otherwise long-extinct groups of elasmobranchs (sharks, rays, and their ancestors), based on its multiple-pointed teeth, the articulation of its upper jaw directly to the cranium behind the eyes (called "amphistyly"), and its "notochord-like" spinal column with indistinct vertebrae. Garman proposed that it was allied with the cladodonts, a now-obsolete taxonomic grouping containing shark genera that thrived during the Palaeozoic era, such as *Cladoselache* from the Devonian period (416–359 Mya). His contemporaries Theodore Gill and Edward Drinker Cope suggested it was instead related to the hybodonts, which were the dominant shark species during the Mesozoic era. Cope even went as far as to assign this species to the fossil genus *Didymodus*.

More recent investigations have found the similarities between the frilled shark and extinct groups may have been overstated or misinterpreted, and this shark exhibits a number of skeletal and muscular traits that firmly place it with the neoselachians (modern sharks and rays), and more specifically with the cow sharks in the order Hexanchiformes (though systematist Shigeru Shirai has proposed that the frilled shark should be placed in its own order, Chlamydoselachiformes). Nevertheless, the frilled shark belongs to one of the oldest still-extant shark lineages, dating back to at least the Late Cretaceous (about 95 Mya) and possibly to the Late Jurassic (150 Mya). Because of their ancient ancestry and primitive characteristics, the frilled shark and other members of this lineage have been described as living fossils. However, the frilled shark itself is a relatively recent species, with the earliest known fossil teeth belonging to this species dating to the early Pleistocene epoch. Some ancestral forms of frilled shark from the cretaceous period, such as the cretaceous species *C. goliath*, were quite large, reaching lengths of up to 20 feet (6 m).

## Habitat and distribution

A rather uncommon shark, the frilled shark has been recorded from a number of widely scattered locations in the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans. In the eastern Atlantic, it occurs off countries such as northern Norway, northern Scotland, and western Ireland, from France to Morocco including Madeira, and off Mauritania. In the central Atlantic, it has been caught at several locations along the Mid-Atlantic Ridge, from north of the Azores to the Rio Grande Rise off southern Brazil, as well as over the Vavilov Ridge off West Africa. In the western Atlantic, it has been reported from waters off New England, Georgia, and Suriname. In the western Pacific, it is known from southeastern Honshu, Japan, to Taiwan, off New South Wales and Tasmania in Australia, and around New Zealand. In the central and eastern Pacific, it has been found off Hawaii, California, and northern Chile. The frilled sharks off southern Africa were described as a different species, *C. africana*, in 2009.

The frilled shark inhabits the outer continental shelves and upper to middle continental slope, seeming to favor upwellings and other biologically productive areas. Though this shark has been caught from a depth of 1,570 m (5,150 ft), it usually does not occur deeper than 1,000 m (3,300 ft). In Suruga Bay, it is most common at a depth of 50–200 m (160–660 ft), except from August to November when the temperature at the 100 m (330 ft) water layer exceeds 15 °C (59 °F) and the sharks shift into deeper water. On rare occasions, this species has been seen at the surface (though such insides are the result of a shark that is dead or dying). The frilled shark is usually found close to the sea bottom, with one individual observed swimming over an area of small sand dunes. However, its diet suggests that it does make substantial forays upward into open water. This species may make vertical migrations, approaching the surface at night to feed. There is spatial segregation by size and reproductive condition in frilled sharks.

## Biology and Ecology

Highly specialized for life in the deep sea, the frilled shark has a reduced, poorly calcified cartilage skeleton and an enormous liver filled with low-density lipids, allowing it to maintain its position in the water column with little effort through neutral buoyancy. It is one of the few sharks with an "open" lateral line, in which the mechanoreceptive hair cells are positioned in grooves that are directly exposed to the surrounding seawater. This configuration is thought to be a basal feature in sharks and may enhance its sensitivity to the minute movements of its prey. Many frilled sharks are found with the tips of their tails missing, probably from predatory attacks by other shark species or other deep-sea predators. Parasites identified from this shark include a tapeworm in the genus *Monorygma*, the fluke *Otodistomum veliporum*, and the nematode *Mooleptus rabuka*.

Fossils of frilled sharks from the Takatika Grit of the Chatham Islands in New Zealand, dated to the Cretaceous–Paleogene boundary, were found together with those of birds and conifer cones, which suggests that the sharks lived in shallow waters at that time. Previous research on other *Chlamydoselachus* species has shown that individuals living in shallower water had larger and stronger teeth for eating hard-shelled invertebrates. It has been hypothesized that frilled sharks, surviving the mass extinction of the K-Pg boundary event, were able to make use of vacated niches in shallow water and on continental shelves, the latter opening up a move to the deep-water habitats they now inhabit. Changing food availability may be reflected in how tooth morphology in these sharks has shifted to become sharper and inward-pointing to prey on soft-bodied deep-sea animals. From the Late Paleocene to the present, frilled sharks may have been out-competed, restricting them to their current habitats and distribution.

### Feeding behavior

The long jaws of the frilled shark are capable extremely wide gape, allowing it to swallow prey whole that measure over one-half its size. However, the length and articulation of its jaws means that it cannot deliver as strong a bite as more conventionally built sharks. Most captured individuals are found with no or barely identifiable stomach contents, suggesting a fast digestion rate and/or long intervals between feeding opportunities. This species preys on cephalopods such as squid and octopus, bony fish, and smaller sharks. One 1.6 m (5.2 ft) long individual, caught off Chōshi, was found to have swallowed a 590 g (1.30 lb) Japanese catshark (*Apristurus japonicus*). Squid comprises some 60% of the diet of sharks in Suruga Bay; this includes not only slow-moving, deep-dwelling types, such as *Chiroteuthis* and *Histioteuthis*, but also relatively large, powerful swimmers of the open ocean, such as *Onychoteuthis*, *Sthenoteuthis*, and *Todarodes*.

How the weak-swimming frilled shark captures active, fast-moving squid is a matter of speculation. One possibility is that it takes advantage of injured squid, or those that are exhausted and dying after spawning. Alternatively, it may surprise its prey by curving its body and, bracing itself with its posteriorly positioned fins, launching a quick strike forward in the manner of a large snake. It may also be able to close its gill slits and create negative pressure to suck prey into its mouth. The many small, sharp, recurved teeth of the frilled shark are functionally similar to squid jigs and could easily snag the body or tentacles of a squid, particularly as they are rotated outwards when the jaws are protruded. Observations of captive frilled sharks swimming with their mouths open suggest that the small teeth, lightly colored against the much darker mouth, may even fool squid into attacking and ensnaring themselves.

### Reproduction

The frilled shark is aplacental viviparous; the developing embryos are mainly nourished by yolk, though the difference in weight between the egg and the newborn indicates that the mother also provides additional nutrition via unknown means. Adult females have two functional ovaries and one functional uterus, on the right. Unsurprisingly, there is no defined breeding season for either sex, as this shark inhabits depths at which there is little to no seasonal influence. The vastness and darkness at the depths frilled sharks inhabit may also play a part in this lack of a breeding season. A possible mating aggregation of 15 male and 19 female sharks has been recorded over a seamount on the Mid-Atlantic Ridge. The litter size ranges from two to fifteen, with an average of six. Females ovulate eggs into the uterus about once every two weeks; vitellogenesis (yolk formation) and the growth of new ovarian eggs halt during pregnancy, apparently due to insufficient space inside the body cavity.

Newly ovulated eggs and early-stage embryos are enclosed in a thin, ellipsoid, golden-brown capsule. When the embryo is 3 cm (1.2 in) long, the head is pointed when seen from above or below, the jaws are barely developed, the external gills have begun to appear, and all the fins are present. The egg capsule is shed when the embryo grows to 6–8 cm (2.4–3.1 in) long, and is expelled from the female's body; at this time the embryo's external gills are fully developed. The size of the yolk sac remains mostly constant until around an embryonic length of 40 cm (16 in), whereupon it begins to shrink, mostly or completely disappearing by an embryonic length of 50 cm (20 in). The embryonic growth rate averages 1.4 cm (0.55 in) per month, and therefore the entire gestation period may last three and a half years, far longer than any other vertebrate currently known. Newborn sharks measure 40–60 cm (16–24 in) long; males attain sexual maturity at 1.0–1.2 m (3.3–3.9 ft) long, and females at 1.3–1.5 m (4.3–4.9 ft) long.

## Interactions with humans

The frilled shark has seldom been encountered alive, and thus poses no danger to humans (though scientists have accidentally cut themselves examining the teeth of dead specimens). On August 27, 2004, the first observation of this species in its natural habitat was made by the ROV *Johnson Sea Link II*, on the Blake Plateau off the southeastern United States. On January 21, 2007, a Japanese fisherman discovered a 1.6 m (5.2 ft) long female alive at the surface, perhaps there because of illness or weakness from the warm water. It was brought to Awashima Marine Park in Shizuoka, where it died after a few hours. Garman, and numerous authors since, have advanced the frilled shark as an explanation for sea serpent sightings. Because of the shark's modest size, some zoologists have posited the existence of a giant relative, particularly as larger *Chlamydoselachus* species are known from the fossil record.

Small numbers of frilled sharks are caught incidentally by various deepwater commercial fisheries around the world, using trawls, gillnets, and longlines. In particular, it is regularly taken in Suruga Bay in bottom gillnets meant for sea bream and gnomefish, and in midwater trawls meant for the shrimp species *Sergia lucens*. Japanese fishermen regard it as a nuisance, as it damages the nets. This shark is sometimes sold for meat or processed into fishmeal, but is not economically significant. Because of its very low reproductive rate and the continuing expansion of commercial fisheries into its habitat, the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) has previously listed it as Near Threatened, although the species was downlisted to Least Concern in 2016.

In December 2014, trawler skipper David Guillot caught a 1.5 m (4.9 ft) frilled shark while "fishing in water more than 1 km (3,300 ft) deep near Lakes Entrance", in Victoria, Australia. The shark was taken to the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation, where its identification was confirmed by experts.

Early in April 2017, during the filming of a Japanese television variety program in Tokyo Bay, a live frilled shark specimen was captured.

In August 2017 a group of scientists caught a 1.5 m (4.9 ft) frilled shark in the waters off of Portimão, Portugal. The shark, identified as a male, was pulled from a depth of roughly 700 m (2,300 ft). On November 14, 2017, researchers reported that another frilled shark was caught near the coast of Portugal.