Evelyn Macher

**Evelyn Macher** (renamed herself Trinity James) was the secondary and more active antagonist of ScaryMovie53's fanfic *Scream Noir*, which is the speculative sequel of *Scream 4*. Her main goal was to kill everyone who reminds her of her mother, and her whole family as an extent.

## Background

Born in Woodsboro, younger sister for the infamous Stu Macher, Evelyn lived a relatively quiet life. Until Hank Loomis cheated on his wife with Maureen Prescott, which created a domino effect that ended in turning Stu into a killer, and his eventual death. Her mother missed Stu very much, and Evelyn couldn't tolerate it. She came up with the cruel idea of burning her own house, with her own mother in it, and be sent to an orphanage to start a new life.

## History

Evelyn firstly appeared in "Knives are forever", pretending to be friend with Katie Weary, Karen Fox, Trent Weary, Olivia Fontain and Alexis Drake. They talk about the death of Hank Loomis and Lawrence Fawl. The first hint to her status as a killer was recreating the short exchange of words between Billy Loomis and his accomplice Stu Macher, with Trent saying "at least you know I didn't killed anybody" and Evelyn replied "Nobody said you did".

She appeared briefly in "A Tale of two Sidneys", pretending to comfort Alexis, whom she secretly knows her real name.

In "A new set of rules", Evelyn called Olivia, Sidney, Judy, Gale and Bill under the cover of Greenface, mocking Sidney about her late friend Randy and accusing Alexis at being dishonest about her real name. Later that night, Alexis revealed that the killer told the truth, as her birth name was Jill Rostenkowski. Evelyn pretended to comfort her, only to kill her and Mark Kincaid later on during an investigation.

## Confirmed Murders

* 1: Mrs. Macher (**her own mother**) - Burned to death (off screen) prior to the story's events.
* 2: Hank Loomis - Stabbed multiple times (mostly in the stomach), genitalia was cut down
* 3: Mark Kincaid - Burned alive when the interrogation room exploded
* 4: Alexis Drake/**Jill Rostenkowski** - Got shot in the head
* 5: Adam Kincaid-Loomis - Got bashed in the head with a beer bottle, sliced with the broken bottle, his hands were cut off
* 6: Gale Weathers - Got stabbed in the back with a broken beer bottle, mauled to death by a pack of chimpanzees
* 7: Chuck McCain - Got impaled with a stake
* 8: Heraldo Manipez - Got stabbed in the back multiple times with a stake

## Hints for being a killer

* 1: "Nobody said you did" - *Knives Are Forever*
* 2: "Don't beat yourself up, sweety. Jill is only a name. Babyface could've been called in any other name, but she would be demented nonetheless" - *A new set of rules*
* 3: Heightened aggression (wanted to assault Judy) during Alexis and Kincaid's funeral - *A new set of rules*
* 4: "Maybe you dont even know your girlfriend at all, Trent. Maybe you just can't get past the surface of things" - *Now you're mortal*

## Similarities to the canon killers

### With Billy Loomis

* Both suffered dearly because of Hank Loomis' reckless behavior.
* "My accomplice did her a favor, Betty. That luntaic walked with her head up the clouds like she was Sidney Prescott or something" is similar to "We did you mom a favor, Sid. That woman was a slut-bag whore who flashed her shit all over town like she was Sharon Stone or something!").
* Both had a likeable blonde girl (Kirby for Evelyn, Casey Becker for Billy) that they knew long enough to dislike and enjoy seeing them dead, but didn't actually killed.
* Threatening to make Betty "say hello to her daughter" is similar to Billy's last world ("say hello to your mother!").

### With Stu Macher

* Both were brutal and somewhat unhinged. The family resemblence is evident in their case.
* "Redface putted out of her mysery. Let's face it, Betty. Your daughter was no Sidney Prescott" is similar to "We put her out of her mysery, cause let's face it, Sid, your mother was no Sharon Stone".

### With Debbie Loomis

* Both had a good fallguy (Mickey Altieri for Debbie, Heraldo Manipez for Evelyn). Heraldo isn't one of the killers, but he was Evelyn's reluctant accomplice, as he knew who Redface was, and just kept his mouth shot until he could catch Redface and rise to fame.
* Both looked down on the motives of their partners.

### With Mickey Altieri

* Both were infuriated to be compared to a previous killer (Billy for Mickey, Jill for Evelyn).

### With Roman Bridger

* Both came extremely close to kill Sidney.
* Both are pure evil.
* Both killed their own mother for not being as loved as they wished.
* Both hated their siblings.
* Both had to be killed with the combined effort of a final girl and a cop.
* Both are first league backstabbers. Evelyn tried to kill her partner using Heraldo, and Roman would've surely killed his partner eventually if he had one.
* Both made people crazy to unheard of extent.
* One of the hints of Evelyn being a killer ("Maybe you dont even know your girlfriend at all, Trent. Maybe you just can't get past the surface of things") is similar to Roman taunting Sidney about her late mother as a prelude to explaining why did he kill her ("maybe you never really knew her at all, Sid. Maybe you just can't get past the surface of things").

### With Jill Roberts

* Both came extremely close to kill Sidney.
* Both are pure evil.
* Both killed their own mother for not being as loved as they wished.
* Both pretended to be friends with girls they secretly hated for a long time (Kirby for Jill, Alexis for Evelyn).
* Her explanation for killing her own mother ("You don't know what it was like to grow up with the Macher family. Related to Stu! My mother always talked about him. Stu here and Stu there. All day long! He was always so fucking special!") is similar to Jill's explanation of her motive ("Do you know what it was like growing up in this family? Related to you? I mean, all i ever heard was Sidney this, Sidney that! Sidney Sidney, Sidney! You were always so fucking special!").
* Both required the combined effort of Sidney, Judy and other 2 people in order to be killed.
* Judy's rule "You forgot the first rule about final girls, Evelynn: They're never alone!" is similar to Sidney's rule about remakes ("You forgot the first rule about remakes, Jill: Don't fuck with the original!").
* Both killed an accomplice (Charlie for Jill, Heraldo for Evelyn). Ironically enough, Jill wanted to kill Charlie from the beginning, while Evelyn killed Heraldo after he failed at catching Redface.

### With Piper Shaw

* Both were extremely close to kill the final girl (Emma for Piper, Sidney for Evelyn).
* Both are pure evil.
* By killing her own mother, Evelyn succeeded where Piper narrowly failed.
* Both integrated themselves in the main characters' social cycle.
* Evelyn changed her name to Trinity James, which is based on Piper's birthfather and birth name (Anderson-James).
* Both had an accomplice who wasn't necessarily a killer (the pre-retcon Audrey for the pre-retcon Piper, Heraldo for Evelyn).
* Both betrayed their accomplices (Evelyn sent Heraldo to catch Redface for her, and Piper killed Rachel, who was Audrey's girlfriend at the time).
* Both had rather creative kills.

### With Beth Whigham

* Both are pure evil.
* Both are beautiful blonde girls who used their sexuality to fool certain individuals (Amir for Beth, Trent for Evelyn).
* Neither of them was very sane.
* Both saw kindness the way most people see cruelty.
* Both killed a backstabber (Jamal for Beth, Heraldo for Evelyn) earlier then they intended. Interesting enough, both backstabbers were far better people than their bosses/killers.