Giving It My All

This is the second episode of *Survivor: All Stars - Heroes vs Villains*

## Challenges

**Reward/Immunity Challenge:** *Plunge, Pull, Pop*
For this challenge, nine contestants from each would compete. Three had to go on a raft, while three would pull a rope, which would get the raft through the water to a platform. At the platform is an underground cage with bamboo running through it. On the bamboo are nine life preservers, in different parts of the cage. The castaways would have to go underwater and pull the bamboo to release the rings. Once all nine rings are collected, the three would be pulled back to shore on the rafts. The rings would then be used to be thrown on three poles, one ring per pole. The tribe who accomplishes this first wins.
**Reward:** Fishing Gear
**Winner:** Lotofoa

## Story

### Night 3

The camera fades in to a rat scampering in the shelter. The remaining Villains return to camp and set their torches against a tree by their flag. Joseph sits in the shelter with a beaming smile on his face.

***Joseph:*** Well that was fun, let's never go back there again.

A majority of the tribe, except Jillian, chuckle at Joseph's statement. Nicole looks over to Jillian, who is giving Kim a deadly stare.

***Nicole:*** Hey Jill, you alright?

***Jillian:*** No, now that you ask.

***Jillian:*** Kim, what was that about?

***Kim:*** I just think you don't take the time to get to know us.

***Jillian:*** You haven't taken the chance to get to know me!

***Kim:*** I've tried, Jillian! I have! But every time I try, you just ignore me!

***Jillian:*** Whatever! I just don't think you had any right to say what you did!

***Kim:*** Jillian, you are such a child!

The two woman separate themselves. Jillian goes to the beach to cool down while Kim joins Joseph in the shelter.

***Kim:*** She's seriously a cancer to this tribe.

Evan looks annoyed at the fight and simply rolls his eyes.

After Kim's confessional, the camera cuts to the Heroes camp. Everyone is asleep except for Luke, who is tending to their fire. Noah soon wakes up and removes his buff from his head. He gets out of the shelter and sits next to Luke.

***Noah:*** Want me to take over?

***Luke:*** Sure, I appreciate it, dude.

Luke gets into the shelter After tending to the fire for a bit, Noah's eyes go right towards the flag as tense music starts.

The tense music continues as Noah quietly makes his way to the flag. He starts to dig for the idol. The camera shows Laura and Megan rolling around, as it looks like they are about to wake up and catch Noah. Noah looks up to see if anyone wakes up and continues to dig.

***Noah:*** Oh sh--!

Cheery music plays as Noah takes out out the idol wrapped up. He quickly puts the sand back into the hole and stuffs the idol into his bag. He then goes back to the fire and can't wipe the smile on his face.

*(intro plays)*

### Day 4

The camera fades to morning at the Villains camp. It shows a bird fly off a tree branch and cuts to the Villains working around camp. Whenever passing one another, Jillian and Kim don't look at each other, still annoyed.

***Ally (quietly):*** This is irritating.

Ray nods his head in agreement.

Kim and Gerard go out into the woods with their machete while Nicole sits in the shelter with J.T.

***Nicole:*** Hopefully he's able to calm her down.

***J.T.:*** I don't know, Kim isn't the type to just be calm after one night.

The camera cuts to Kim and Gerard walking up to a thin tree. Gerard begins to cut it down while Kim talks.

***Kim:*** It's just that she is incredibly rude to all of us. It would be easy to just vote her out.

***Gerard:*** I know, but she isn't that big of a threat.

***Kim:*** I guess, but still I can't stand being around her.

***Gerard:*** No one can, but I'm just saying we can oust her any time. We should use this time to take out a bigger threat.

***Kim:*** Who do you consider a bigger threat?

***Gerard:*** Evan.

The camera cuts to Evan drinking out of a coconut. It then goes back to the two in the woods as Gerard finishes cutting down the tree and it falls.

***Gerard:*** He's strong strategically and could make a run at the merge. I think we should take a shot while we have a chance.

***Kim:*** It could hurt us in the challenges.

***Gerard:*** Well we do have other strong players, we can afford to lose one.

***Kim:*** I just think it's too big a risk. If we drop Jillian, we have tribe unity and a physically stronger tribe.

***Gerard:*** It's just something to consider.

The camera cuts back to camp. While Jillian and Nicole talk at the beach and Joseph takes a dip in the water, Evan gathers Ally, Ray, and J.T.

***Evan:*** So I think we've all noticed that Kim and Gerard go off on their own a lot.

***Ray:*** Yeah, makes it kind of obvious they're together.

***Evan:*** Well, I think we should split them up.

***Ally:*** No kidding, they both ended my game last time so I want nothing to do with them.

***J.T.:*** So what do you think?

***Evan:*** Well with Kim, she's volatile but isn't the best strategically. She thinks off emotion.

***J.T.:*** No kidding.

***Evan:*** But Gerard is a smart dude, he thinks things out. He should go next.

***Ally:*** I mean, it would be really great to get him out. I'm sick of his smug face.

***Evan:*** What do you guys think?

***J.T.:*** If we can get the numbers for it, I'm down.

***Ray:*** Let's go.

The camera cuts to the Heroes camp where the tribe is split into three groups. One group, the one at the water, is Megan, Justin, and Christine. The second group, Luke and Laura, are at the fire, tending to it. The final group is Guylan, Kelly, Yannick, Noah, and Gerda, who all sit in the shelter.

***Kelly:*** It's weird we're already divided like this.

***Yannick:*** So what do you think we should do.

***Guylan:*** At first, I was thinking of going us five and take them out but I worry about isolating them and making them flip.

***Kelly:*** Yeah, that's what I was thinking.

***Guylan:*** So I think we should chose a group, go with them, and work on outing the other side.

***Noah:*** But which side?

***Guylan:*** They both have their ups and downs.

***Gerda:*** Personally, I'm thinking of voting Luke out. He just rubs me the wrong way.

***Kelly:*** But he words hard around camp, Justin, Megan, and Christine do nothing.

***Gerda:*** I guess.

The camera then cuts to Justin, Megan, and Christine sitting in the water, watching the third group chat.

***Justin:*** They're talking about us.

***Megan:*** I know, it's clear they're thinking about who to side with.

***Justin:*** We need to make sure they side with us.

The camera cuts back to the shelter and Justin, Megan, and Christine walk up to join them.

***Christine:*** Hey guys.

***Yannick:*** How's it going?

***Christine:*** Just worried.

***Kelly:*** 'Bout what?

***Christine (Pointing to Luke and Laura):*** Them.

The camera cuts to Luke and Laura laughing before cutting back to the shelter group.

***Christine:*** It's super obvious they're tight.

***Justin:*** Yeah, we need to split them.

***Noah:*** It would be beneficial to us to get rid of the pair but we do need to think about it.

***Justin:*** That's fine, take your time.

The trio leaves just as Luke and Laura walk up.

***Guylan (Whispering to Kelly):*** Here comes offer number two.

***Laura:*** You guys mind if I lay down?

***Kelly:*** No, go ahead.

Laura lays down next to Guylan.

***Laura:*** Honestly, I'm so tired of those three. They do nothing but hang out together.

***Gerda:*** I agree, they're the laziest people here.

***Luke:*** Honestly, would we lose much if we just vote them out?

***Yannick:*** I don't think so.

***Laura:*** So would you guys consider voting them out?

***Yannick:*** Well who do you think we should vote first?

***Laura:*** Honestly, I think Megan. She didn't do anything during the shelter build and doesn't lift a finger to fetch water or wood.

***Guylan:*** I've noticed that.

***Luke:*** I think it's just best for us.

Yannick and Noah look at each other, pondering.

The camera cuts to later where Luke and Laura are walking in the woods.

***Laura:*** I hope we got through to them.

***Luke:*** But did you see how Gerda was eating up everything Justin was selling her? I think she may be the one voice to convince them to vote us.

***Laura:*** I don't see Gerda as someone who is able to sway people, I honestly don't.

***Luke:*** Don't underestimate her. She won for a reason.

***Laura:*** I got you, but still.

Luke gives Laura a worried Luke as the camera fades to commercial break.

### Day 5

The camera fades back in to the Villains camp where everyone is doing chores. Nicole takes one of the empty pots into the woods.

Nicole sets the pot down and begins to look around the water well for any sign of the idol. Search music starts to play as Nicole makes her way into the woods. She attempts to climb a tree but slides down when she's about a foot off the ground. She starts digging in a tree hole but comes up short. She spots Kim and Gerard walking and hides behind a bush. She waits until they leave before starting up her search again. She searches through another tree hole.

***Nicole:*** Oh please.

Nicole pulls out a piece of paper and stuffs it in her bra before running off.

***Nicole:*** Oh yes! Oh f--k yes!

Nicole takes the note out of her bra and her jubilation turns to disappointment as she reads the clue.

Meanwhile, back at camp, a majority of the tribe sits in the shelter as Joseph does a majority of the chores. We see a montage of shots including him carrying two large logs, starting the fire, fishing.

Ally, Ray, and Jillian relax in the shelter and watch Joseph.

***Ally:*** I love Joseph.

***Jillian:*** I know, he does everything.

Ray, however, just glares at Joseph.

***Ray:*** I'm honestly kind of sick of him.

***Ally:*** Really?

***Ray:*** Yeah, he seems so smug about doing all the chores.

***Ally:*** I don't see it.

***Ray:*** I think we should blindside him next vote.

***Jillian:*** I don't know, could spell disaster for us.

***Ray:*** I'm willing to take the risk.

Jillian turns her attention back to Joseph.

We then see Jillian talking to Joseph in the woods.

***Jillian:*** So, Ray is trying to plant seeds in getting you out.

Joseph: Really?

***Jillian:*** Yeah, Ally and I were in the shelter with him and he just brought it up.

***Joseph:*** Will Ally tell me the same thing?

***Jillian:*** I hope so. I want you around because of the strength you bring.

***Joseph:*** Well I appreciate it.

We see a shot of Ray looking out into the water as the camera fades to black.

### Day 6

The camera fades back to the challenge area. The normal challenge music plays as it pans around the area before cutting to Jeff, who is standing in front of the water.

***Jeff:*** Come on in, guys!

The Heroes are the first to arrive at the area, all smiling. Justin is seen carrying the idol as the remaining ten Heroes finally step onto their mat. As the Villains begin to make their way to the area, the Heroes look in their direction to see who was voted out, with Megan standing on her toes.

***Jeff:*** Faleloa, getting your first look at the new Lotofoa tribe. Wendy voted out of the first Tribal Council.

Not many Heroes are shocked as they expected the older woman to be gone first. The Villains finally step onto their mat.

***Jeff:*** You guys ready for today's immunity challenge?

A collective yes is heard from the contestants.

***Jeff:*** First things first, Justin, give it up.

Jeff approaches Justin to get the idol.

***Justin:*** Just be sure to give it back when it's over, Jeff.

The Villains look over and give the Heroes an almost annoyed look as the Heroes smugly smile. Jeff returns to his previous spot and places the idol onto it's stand. He goes over the challenge and adds the winner of the challenge will receive fishing gear. When asked who is sitting out for the Heroes, Gerda raises her hand and Jeff directs her to the sit out bench.

For Lotofoa, the ones on the raft are Joseph, Kim, and J.T., the pullers are Gerard, Evan, and Ray, and the throwers are Ally, Nicole, and Jillian. For Faleloa, the ones on the raft are Justin, Megan, and Luke, the pullers are Guylan, Laura, and Yannick, and the throwers are Noah, Christine, and Kelly. Both tribes make it to their raft at the same time but Joseph, Kim, and J.T. work together really well rowing while Megan struggles greatly rowing, frustrating Luke. The three Villains make it to their platform first and start diving down to get their rings. J.T. is the first down and he starts rapidly removing bamboo, which causes two rings to pop up. The Heroes finally make it to their platform and Luke dives down to try and catch up. After their third ring pops up, J.T. climbs back up, allowing Kim to dive down. Luke gets two of his rings before climbing up, allowing Justin to continue pulling bamboo. Justin flies through bamboo, causing three rings to pop up. Kim's forth ring comes up and climbs up. Joseph goes down to collect the final two rings while Justin climbs up and Megan goes down. Joseph gets the last two rings and the Villains start piling them onto their raft. Megan gets one ring before coming back up, having Luke go back down. Gerard, Evan, and Ray make quick work pulling Joseph, Kim, and J.T. back, making them seem weightless. Luke gets the last few rings and they start putting them on the raft. Kim delivers the final ring to Nicole, Ally, and Jillian and Nicole begins to toss the rings. Guylan, Laura, and Yannick try to catch up to the Villains by pulling on the rope as hard as they can. Nicole gets her first ring on a post and switches out with Ally. The Heroes finally get back to the beach and Luke dumps all the rings in front of Noah, Christine, and Kelly with Kelly throwing first. Ally misses all her shots and she, Nicole, and Jillian, rush out to get the eight remaining rings. Kelly lands a ring on her first go and switches out with Christine. The Villlains return with their rings and Ally continues throwing. On her third toss, she lands her ring and switches out with Jillian. Christine manages to land her last ring and the Heroes rush out to collect their seven rings. As they are collecting, Jillian lands her ring, winning Lotofoa immunity and reward. The Villains celebrate as the once confident Heroes sulk. The camera then cuts to Jeff addressing the players. He takes the idol and walks over to the Villains.

***Jeff:*** Lotofoa, congratulations. Immunity and fishing gear will be waiting back for you at camp.

Kim takes the idol and kisses it. Jeff turns his attention to the Heroes.

***Jeff:*** Faleloa, you got nothing but a date with me at Tribal Council where somebody will become the second person voted out. You got the afternoon to think about who that will be. See you tonight.

We see a slow motion shot of the Heroes walking away as Justin has a confessional. As his confessional goes, we see shots of him, Luke, Laura, and Megan.

The camera cuts to a monkey swinging from a tree before showing the Heroes return to camp. Guylan tosses their flag to the ground in frustration while Yannick and Noah sulk in the shelter.

***Noah:*** That sucked.

***Luke:*** No kidding, I didn't really want to see Tribal for a long time.

***Kelly:*** Same, but off we go.

The camera cuts to Christine, Megan, and Justin walking in the woods.

***Megan:*** So I think we should put our votes on Luke tonight.

***Justin:*** You think so?

***Megan:*** Yeah, I think it'll be easy because of the arrogance he gives off.

***Christine:*** I just think that Luke is better in challenges than Laura and people are gonna be looking to make a strong tribe.

***Megan:*** I think they're about the same in terms of challenge strength.

***Christine (Getting annoyed):*** Megan, I know you can't stand Luke but we also need to think about the tribe. Of the three of us, they may be targeting you because of your performance so Laura may be the smarter option.

***Megan:*** I just think Luke going will unite us.

***Justin:*** Guys, we cannot be fighting right now.

***Christine:*** Look if you think getting Luke out is the best move, I'll go with it. I just think it's risky.

***Megan:*** Big risk, big reward.

The camera cuts to Luke sitting in the water as Megan's voice over is heard.

***Megan:*** I just think Luke's arrogance is a major annoyance.

It cuts to Noah, Kelly, and Megan in the shelter.

***Megan:*** Like he thinks he's the boss around the camp.

***Noah:*** Yeah, I see what you mean.

***Megan:*** I just don't like seeing the big guy kick the little guy around, you know? And Luke, he just acts like he's a hot shot.

***Kelly:*** I know, it's irritating.

***Megan:*** So would you be open into voting him?

***Noah:*** I do think he needs to be brought down a level so I'm open to it. Do you have the numbers?

***Megan:*** Justin and Christine are already on board to vote him out.

***Kelly:*** Well let me think about it, ok?

***Megan:*** No problem.

The camera cuts to Kelly and Noah with their alliance with Guylan, Yannick, and Gerda. Yannick and Gerda use their buff to clean out their rice pot while Guylan sits next to the two. Noah and Kelly are standing as the water his their feet.

***Noah:*** So that was basically her pitch.

***Yannick:*** She does make some good points.

***Guylan:*** So you guys wanna do Luke tonight?

***Yannick:*** I'm not sure. We vote Luke then we lose a major player in challenges.

***Guylan:*** True.

***Gerda:*** I think Megan is better for our morale though since she is such a sweetheart.

***Yannick:*** Yeah but what does that do for us in challenges? Megan killed us today, KILLED us.

***Gerda:*** I guess.

***Noah:*** I mean I'm good with either option but I just want your input on it.

***Guylan:*** I'm not sure. Do we go with strength or social?

***Noah (With a half-hearted chuckle):*** Question of the year.

The music starts to intensify as Justin, Christine, and Megan watch the five talk as they lay down in the shelter.

***Justin:*** I hope you got through to them.

***Megan:*** So do I.

The camera shows Luke and Laura also watching the five talking by the water.

***Luke:*** I think it may be me tonight.

***Laura:*** Shut up, you're good.

***Luke:*** I don't know.

The music starts to get more intense as the Heroes grab their belongings and head to Tribal to vote someone out.

The camera fades to Tribal Council where the normal Tribal music plays. The Heroes walk in a line up the stairs to Tribal and Jeff gives them his normal stare as they line up in front of the seats.

***Jeff:*** Behind you is a torch, dip it in and get fire. This is the ritual of Tribal Council as fire represents your life. When your fire is gone, so are you.

The Heroes dip their torches and sit down as Jeff begins the QnA.

***Jeff:*** So, it was close today. Laura, how does it feel to be here after such a close challenge?

***Laura:*** Not too good, Jeff. Not too good. Y'know we showed that we can beat them and to not do that again sucks.

***Jeff:*** So Guylan, we're six days in. Have you noticed any alliances being formed?

***Guylan:*** Right now, there are three alliances that everyone knows about. There's Luke and Laura. Then Justin, Christine, and Megan. Then the rest of us are kind of in the swing.

***Jeff:*** Wow. So Noah, from what Guylan said, you, Gerda, him, Yannick, and Kelly are the swing votes. How did that happen?

***Noah:*** Well the other two groups just don't like each other. Justin, Christine, and Megan see Luke and Laura as arrogant while Luke and Laura see Justin, Christine, and Megan as the weaker people.

***Jeff:*** Justin, do you see yourself as weak?

***Justin:*** Hell no! I don't think we're the weaker players. In my mind, we're all equal in physical strength so I think we should focus on peace at camp and Luke comes off as arrogant.

***Luke:*** How do I come off as arrogant?

***Justin:*** The way you walk, the way you talk to people. It seems like you're not only arrogant, but blind to how you come off.

***Luke:*** Well then you're blind to the fact that Megan was the reason we lost today on the raft!

***Megan:*** We caught up!

***Laura:*** But we would have been ahead of them if you didn't struggle on the raft.

***Megan:*** My part as one of the rowers did not cause us to lose today.

The four stop arguing as Jeff has an amazed look on his face.

***Jeff:*** Never before have I seen one tribe so divided at their first Tribal Council. Yannick, is there any way to fix this?

***Yannick:*** I think if we get rid of the right person tonight, we can come back together.

Megan nods her head as Luke just turns back to Jeff with an almost panicked look.

***Jeff:*** Alright, let's see who that right person is. It is time to vote, Laura, you're up.

Laura is the first one to vote. She is seen writing Megan's name down. Gerda is the next one up, followed by Justin, who's voting confessional is shown. Noah and Yannick are the next two up, followed by Christine, who is shown writing Luke's name down. Megan's voting confessional is then shown, and is followed by Kelly going up to vote. It fade's to Luke's voting confessional and Guylan is the last to vote. While his vote isn't shown, his confessional is heard. He then returns to his seat.

***Jeff:*** I'll go tally the votes.

Jeff goes to get the urn as the Heroes look around, nervous of what is about to happen. Jeff returns to his spot.

***Jeff:*** Once the votes are read, the decision is final. Person voted out will be asked to leave the Tribal Council area immediately. I'll read the votes.

The music starts to intensify as Megan inhales, trying to calm herself.

***Jeff:*** First vote...Megan.

Megan nods, knowing she is getting votes.

***Jeff:*** Luke, that's one vote Megan, one vote Luke.

Luke keeps his eyes deadset on the vote.

***Jeff:*** Megan.

Justin looks over at Laura, who does not look at him.

***Jeff:*** Luke. That's two votes Megan, two votes Luke.

Luke scratches his beard as the votes continue to be read.

***Jeff:*** Luke. Three votes Luke, two votes Megan.

Justin grows a smirk on his face as Laura pats Luke's leg, trying to calm him down. Yannick looks over to Noah, who nods, knowing they made the right decision. Guylan keeps his eyes glued on Jeff as he pulls out the sixth vote.

***Jeff:*** Megan. We're tied, three votes Luke, three votes Megan.

Megan gets a dejected look on her face, as she knows she is getting the rest of the votes.

***Jeff:*** Megan.

Justin shakes his head in disgust as he helps Megan get her thinks.

***Jeff:*** Megan.

Justin looks over to Megan.

***Justin (Quietly):*** I'm so sorry.

***Jeff:*** Second person voted out of Survivor: All Stars - Heroes vs Villains: Megan. Need to bring me your torch.

Megan gets up and grabs her torch. She walks up to Jeff as Justin can only glare at the five who voted against him. Luke breaths a sigh of relief as Laura is happy her ally is still in the game. Megan puts her torch in front of Jeff.

***Jeff:*** Megan, the tribe has spoken.

Jeff snuffs her torch.

***Jeff:*** Time for you to go.

Megan turns around to wave her allies goodbye as she walks out into the distance.

***Jeff:*** Well you got rid of the person you thought was the weakest. How will that help this tribe? We'll just have to wait and see. Grab your torches and head back to camp, good night.

The nine remaining Heroes get up and get their torches. Justin and Christine look depressed at the turnout as the camera fades out as the players walk back to camp.

## Next Time on *Survivor*...

* The scrambling begins!
* Nicole tries to get the idol!
* A duo on Faleloa put's a target on their back.