The Classic Case of Carnage

**The castmates compete in a horror-themed challenge.**

## Plot

The episode starts off with the castmates talking about how they don't want there to be a challenge today, stating they'd like a relaxed day. Many of the castmates are playing a game of kickball, whilst others snack on some of the sandwiches Hailey snagged from Chef's kitchen. Jada is seen styling Kiyana's hair as they watch the kickball game, where Tyler strikes out Stella.

All of the castmates thank Hailey for getting the sandwiches. George taps on Ciande's shoulder and says that he can fit a ton of sandwiches in his mouth at once. Ciande sighs and giggles as she says "That's great George!"

Ciande asks Hailey how she got past Chef, and a clip of Hailey sneaking quietly into Chef's kitchen is shown, as he's napping. Hailey tip-toes around the kitchen and looks in the fridge, nearly waking Chef up, but managed to take all of the sandwiches from the fridge in a hurry. After the sequence of how Hailey got the sandwiches, the camera cuts back to the castmates relaxing. Jaylen reclines in a chair saying it'd be cool if they had no challenge today, but Hailey brags and says "Well, you can relax if you want, but a million bucks sounds better to me!"

The castmates are then ordered to hike up the fake mountain where they had to build the set for the third episode, and Jada scoffs and asks where Chris is. Before anyone can answer, they can hear Chris' screams as he descends from the sky onto a spotlight, and becomes impaled with blood splattering everywhere. He acts like he's dead, but then wakes up and says it was just a scene for his new movie "Badminton Turns Deadly!" Chris then says that the day's challenge will be about the horror genre, noting a ton of his favorite films. Hailey elbows George stating that he screamed like a girl, but George says he didn't. Hailey snickers and says he has a way more feminine scream then her. Chris then shushes Hailey and tells her and George to focus to the challenge rules. Chris then explains that there will be a killer that will need to try and scare a member of their team, the member that they scare's scream will be rated on the scream-o-meter. The Screaming Gaffers discuss who should be their team's killer, with Jaylen and surprisingly Sim wanting to be the killers. Jaylen says he watches a ton of scary movies and would love to be the killer, but Sim says he's studied horror movies. Jada shrugs and just says that Sim should do it, much to Jaylen's annoyance.

The Killer Grips are now discussing who should be the killer for their team. Kiyana volunteers stating that she loves to scare people and one time when she was younger she purposefully said that her house was on fire to her parents just to get them scared. Hailey looks at Lucas who shrugs, and says that she wants to be the killer because she was practically born for the role. But, George says he pulls pranks like this all the time and it's in his wheelhouse to do so. Tyler and Lucas both say they don't want to do it. The three try to discuss, but the conversation goes nowhere, so Lucas tells them that they need to decide quickly or they won't be able to compete. Hailey drops it, stating that it would be fun to not be the killer this time, causing concerned eyebrows to raise. Kiyana puts her foot down, stating she doesn't want to drop the role, but George is adamant. Tyler tells them to just "rock-paper-scissors" it. The two do so, and George wins and celebrates inelegantly.

The first challenge starts as Jada and Tyler are put into a forrest like area, and the two killers have to terrify their specific teammate. Jada scoffs stating that she never gets scared, but as she walks near a bush, Sim jumps out from it and grabs her shoulders, causing her to scream - scoring a eight out of ten on the scream-o-meter. Tyler is now looking around, trying his best to get scared, which isn't the case as George pops out and slips, causing Tyler to just laugh - scoring a two out of ten on the scream-o-meter. This means the Gaffers are the winners of the first challenge.

The next part of the challenge requires a teammate to sit in an outhouse, and for the killer to scare them. The people who will do so are Ciande and Lucas. Ciande tells the camera that the outhouse isn't the most fabulous way to die, but at least if the death is iconic, it'll be great. Lucas begins to talk to himself reminding him of the many horror games he's once played with Adam, and how horror movies freak him out a lot now. Sim starts off very well, scratching the door and doing slight whispers, causing Ciande to start freaking out. But once Sim goes into the porter-potty, he causes Ciande to jump and she hits her wrist that she hurt in the past challenge, causing her to wince in pain. Sim asks if she's alright, and it doesn't give them a good score on the scream-o-meter. On the flip side, despite George not being as scary, he manages to get Lucas to scream a five out of ten on the scream-o-meter, making George and Lucas score a point for the Grips.

Due to both teams being tied, there will be a tiebreaker round. The tie-breaker will be a couples round, where the killers will need to go after a couple who are getting steamy and making-out. The couples are as follows: Jaylen and Stella for the Gaffers and Hailey and Kiyana for the Grips. Both pairs are extremely uncomfortable with the scripts, and Hailey states that she can't do it, but Chris says that they'll have to do it for a million dollars. Hailey and Kiyana look at one another, and start to make-out. Jaylen crosses his arms stating that "I have a girlfriend, Chris!" But Chris just shrugs stating it's what he signed up for. Stella tries to encourage Jaylen that it's just for a challenge, as she touches his chin. The two then kiss, and start to get more into depth. Chris tells the killers to start scaring the duos, but neither are due to the shock they're both in. Chris then tells Chef to scare the pairs, and he manages to scare Hailey and Kiyana, making Hailey fall off the couch. But on the other side, Jaylen and Stella don't seem to be scared, and don't stop making-out until Ciande and Jada pull the two apart.

Chris scoffs and says that the challenge was a bust, so there will be a new tiebreaker challenge where the Screaming Gaffers must stay in the crafts service tent and try not to leave it due to being scared. Once Chris explains the rules, he tells a ghost story about an actress who was murdered by a killer clown on the very set they're on. Chris then gives them ghost locating devices, and wishes them good luck. Chris who comes out of the tent, tells the Grips about how he told the Gaffers about a scary story, and says it's their job to make them leave the tent. George seems very excited by the plan, but Kiyana tells him that when he tried scaring their team for the last rounds, his attempts either didn't work or barely worked. Kiyana asks Lucas for ideas, and Lucas says they could try to flicker the lights to scare them. Lucas starts to do this, but it's not use due to the fact that Ciande points out the ghost locating devices aren't flickering.

Hailey snaps her fingers and says she has an idea. She retrieves a bag with a lot of black dots in it from the look of it. As she opens it, the Grips cringe in disgust, but Hailey says that they're only fake prop eyeballs. Kiyana asks why she has them, and Hailey says she came prepared if Ellis stayed long. The Grips attach the eyeballs to springs, and begin to float them in the tent, causing the Gaffers to freak out. Ciande is a bit scared and almost runs out with the rest of her team until Jada tells them that she can see a string attached to an eyeball. She takes one down and says it's just a fake prop and it's probably just Chris. Chris whose watching on a monitor asks why everyone blames him.

The Grips try to think of something else, and George says he has an idea. Tyler says they should listen, and George says that they will need to get a music box, some fake blood, a balloon, and a person to wear a clown costume. George's plan takes place as Kiyana starts playing a music box with creepy music, fake blood being poured down the wall (by Lucas), red balloons being sent flying into the tent (Hailey sending them), and Tyler holding George in a clown costume scaring the Gaffers. The Gaffers all get up and leave the tent screaming, as Tyler pulls George up and high fives him. Chris announces that the Killer Grips are the winners of the challenge, and the Gaffers will have to send a member home tonight.

Before the Elimination Ceremony, Jada is seen talking with Jaylen and Stella and tells them that she has some knowledge from when Adam left. Jaylen asks what information she has, and Jada begins to explain that not only Adam believed they were doing fishy things together, but that it was also Ciande. Stella comments that she believes it. Jaylen notes that Ciande is also a liability due to her injury with her wrist.

At the Gilded Chris ceremony, Chris says his usual, and the Gaffers vote. Chris hands out Gilded Chris' to Jaylen, Jada, and Sim. This leaves only Ciande and Stella without a Gilded Chris. Chris waits a bit for some suspense and gives the final Gilded Chris award to Stella. Ciande seems a bit shocked for a couple seconds and shrugs. She tells them that she wants a hug from all of them, which most of them do besides Stella. Jaylen says despite Ciande spreading rumors, he'll always forgive her, it was just her wrist injury and his friendship with Stella to vote her out. Ciande shrugs and struts to the lame-o-sine and is taken away. The episode stops as the screen fades to black and the credits roll.