Another way of obtaining information about the nucleosynthesis processes involved in producing carbon is to compare it with other elements that are characterised by a well-known source of production, as in the case of oxygen. In Fig. 5, we show the variation of [C/O] as a function of [Fe/H], which serves as a first-order approximation to the evolution with time. To calculate the [C/O] ratios, two oxygen abundance indicators are used independently. At subsolar metallicities, the abundance ratios with both oxygen indicators are mostly negative and show an increasing trend towards higher metallicity. This is explained by the fact that oxygen is entirely produced by SNe Type II from massive progenitors, which started to release theiryields at earlier ages in the Galaxy and, hence, at lower metallicities (e.g. Woosley & Weaver 1995). The massive stars producing carbon at low metallicities might be less massive than those producing oxygen (i.e. having a longer life), explaining a delayed contribution of carbon, hence, the negative [C/O] ratios. Alternatively, this could be explained by increasing O/C yields for more massive progenitors of SNeII. Once metallicity starts to increase, low- and intermediate-mass stars release carbon and massive stars start to eject more carbon than oxygen (Carigi et al. 2005). The [C/O] ratio seems to have a constant rise towards higher metallicities when using the forbidden oxygen line. However, in the case when the O I 6158 Å line is employed, we do observe that the maximum in [C/O] takes places close to solar metallicity to then become flat or decrease. This suggests that low-mass stars mostly contribute to carbon around solar metallicity, whereas at super-solar metallicities, massive stars produce carbon together with oxygen, thereby flattening or even decreasing the [C/O] ratio. This trend is in agreement with the metallicity dependent yields from Carigi et al. (2005), which provide higher carbon as [Fe/H] increases from massive stars (i.e. also increasing the O production) but lower carbon from low and intermediate mass stars as [Fe/H] increases (i.e. less production of C). The turning point of increased relative production of carbon from massive stars takes place at A(O) ~ 8.7 dex (see Fig. 2 of Carigi et al. 2005) which equals to [O/H] ~ 0.0 dex. This observed behaviour of [C/O] is in contrast to the steady increase of [C/O] up to [Fe/H] ~ 0.3 dex found, for example, by Franchini et al. (2021). Nevertheless, the general trend we find when using the [O I ] 6300 Å line is similar to the reported by Franchini et al. (2021), who use also that oxygen indicator. All thick-disk stars present negative [C/O] ratios and when using the oxygen line at 6158 Å thin-disk stars with [Fe/H] ≲ –0.2 have [C/O]  0 as well. Thick-disk stars and low-metallicity thin-disk stars at the same metallicity have similar [C/O] ratios, meaning that the balance between different production sites for oxygen and carbon is the same among both populations, despite [C/Fe] and [O/Fe] being systematically higher for thick-disk stars at a given metallicity.
Citation: Carigi et al. 2005
Citation function: Compare/Contrast; Compare/Contrast; Differences
Citation: Carigi et al. (2005)
Citation function: Similarities; Similarities
Citation: Carigi et al. 2005
Citation function: Background
Citation: Carigi et al. (2005)
Citation function: Similarities; Similarities
Citation: Carigi et al. 2005
Citation function: Uses; Uses; Differences