FairEval / FairEval.py
illorca's picture
Re-upload project
c5d83eb
raw
history blame
61 kB
# -*- coding: utf-8 -*-
'''
Created 09/2021
@author: Katrin Ortmann
'''
import argparse
import os
import sys
import re
from typing import Iterable
from io import TextIOWrapper
from copy import deepcopy
#####################################
def precision(evaldict, version="traditional", weights={}):
"""
Calculate traditional, fair or weighted precision value.
Precision is calculated as the number of true positives
divided by the number of true positives plus false positives
plus (optionally) additional error types.
Input:
- A dictionary with error types as keys and counts as values, e.g.,
{"TP" : 10, "FP" : 2, "LE" : 1, ...}
For 'traditional' evaluation, true positives (key: TP) and
false positives (key: FP) are required.
The 'fair' evaluation is based on true positives (TP),
false positives (FP), labeling errors (LE), boundary errors (BE)
and labeling-boundary errors (LBE).
The 'weighted' evaluation can include any error type
that is given as key in the weight dictionary.
For missing keys, the count is set to 0.
- The desired evaluation method. Options are 'traditional',
'fair', and 'weighted'. If no weight dictionary is specified,
'weighted' is identical to 'fair'.
- A weight dictionary to specify how much an error type should
count as one of the traditional error types (or as true positive).
Per default, every traditional error is counted as one error (or true positive)
and each error of the additional types is counted as half false positive and half false negative:
{"TP" : {"TP" : 1},
"FP" : {"FP" : 1},
"FN" : {"FN" : 1},
"LE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"BE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"LBE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5}}
Other suggested weights to count boundary errors as half true positives:
{"TP" : {"TP" : 1},
"FP" : {"FP" : 1},
"FN" : {"FN" : 1},
"LE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"BE" : {"TP" : 0.5, "FP" : 0.25, "FN" : 0.25},
"LBE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5}}
Or to include different types of boundary errors:
{"TP" : {"TP" : 1},
"FP" : {"FP" : 1},
"FN" : {"FN" : 1},
"LE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"LBE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"BEO" : {"TP" : 0.5, "FP" : 0.25, "FN" : 0.25},
"BES" : {"TP" : 0.5, "FP" : 0, "FN" : 0.5},
"BEL" : {"TP" : 0.5, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0}}
Output:
The precision for the given input values.
In case of a ZeroDivisionError, the precision is set to 0.
"""
traditional_weights = {
"TP" : {"TP" : 1},
"FP" : {"FP" : 1},
"FN" : {"FN" : 1}
}
default_fair_weights = {
"TP" : {"TP" : 1},
"FP" : {"FP" : 1},
"FN" : {"FN" : 1},
"LE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"BE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"LBE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5}
}
try:
tp = 0
fp = 0
#Set default weights for traditional evaluation
if version == "traditional":
weights = traditional_weights
#Set weights to default
#for fair evaluation or if no weights are given
elif version == "fair" or not weights:
weights = default_fair_weights
#Add weighted errors to true positive count
tp += sum(
[w.get("TP", 0) * evaldict.get(error, 0) for error, w in weights.items()]
)
#Add weighted errors to false positive count
fp += sum(
[w.get("FP", 0) * evaldict.get(error, 0) for error, w in weights.items()]
)
#Calculate precision
return tp / (tp + fp)
#Output 0 if there is neither true nor false positives
except ZeroDivisionError:
return 0.0
######################
def recall(evaldict, version="traditional", weights={}):
"""
Calculate traditional, fair or weighted recall value.
Recall is calculated as the number of true positives
divided by the number of true positives plus false negatives
plus (optionally) additional error types.
Input:
- A dictionary with error types as keys and counts as values, e.g.,
{"TP" : 10, "FN" : 2, "LE" : 1, ...}
For 'traditional' evaluation, true positives (key: TP) and
false negatives (key: FN) are required.
The 'fair' evaluation is based on true positives (TP),
false negatives (FN), labeling errors (LE), boundary errors (BE)
and labeling-boundary errors (LBE).
The 'weighted' evaluation can include any error type
that is given as key in the weight dictionary.
For missing keys, the count is set to 0.
- The desired evaluation method. Options are 'traditional',
'fair', and 'weighted'. If no weight dictionary is specified,
'weighted' is identical to 'fair'.
- A weight dictionary to specify how much an error type should
count as one of the traditional error types (or as true positive).
Per default, every traditional error is counted as one error (or true positive)
and each error of the additional types is counted as half false positive and half false negative:
{"TP" : {"TP" : 1},
"FP" : {"FP" : 1},
"FN" : {"FN" : 1},
"LE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"BE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"LBE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5}}
Other suggested weights to count boundary errors as half true positives:
{"TP" : {"TP" : 1},
"FP" : {"FP" : 1},
"FN" : {"FN" : 1},
"LE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"BE" : {"TP" : 0.5, "FP" : 0.25, "FN" : 0.25},
"LBE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5}}
Or to include different types of boundary errors:
{"TP" : {"TP" : 1},
"FP" : {"FP" : 1},
"FN" : {"FN" : 1},
"LE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"LBE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"BEO" : {"TP" : 0.5, "FP" : 0.25, "FN" : 0.25},
"BES" : {"TP" : 0.5, "FP" : 0, "FN" : 0.5},
"BEL" : {"TP" : 0.5, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0}}
Output:
The recall for the given input values.
In case of a ZeroDivisionError, the recall is set to 0.
"""
traditional_weights = {
"TP" : {"TP" : 1},
"FP" : {"FP" : 1},
"FN" : {"FN" : 1}
}
default_fair_weights = {
"TP" : {"TP" : 1},
"FP" : {"FP" : 1},
"FN" : {"FN" : 1},
"LE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"BE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"LBE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5}
}
try:
tp = 0
fn = 0
#Set default weights for traditional evaluation
if version == "traditional":
weights = traditional_weights
#Set weights to default
#for fair evaluation or if no weights are given
elif version == "fair" or not weights:
weights = default_fair_weights
#Add weighted errors to true positive count
tp += sum(
[w.get("TP", 0) * evaldict.get(error, 0) for error, w in weights.items()]
)
#Add weighted errors to false negative count
fn += sum(
[w.get("FN", 0) * evaldict.get(error, 0) for error, w in weights.items()]
)
#Calculate recall
return tp / (tp + fn)
#Return zero if there are neither true positives nor false negatives
except ZeroDivisionError:
return 0.0
######################
def fscore(evaldict):
"""
Calculates F1-Score from given precision and recall values.
Input: A dictionary with a precision (key: Prec) and recall (key: Rec) value.
Output: The F1-Score. In case of a ZeroDivisionError, the F1-Score is set to 0.
"""
try:
return 2 * (evaldict.get("Prec", 0) * evaldict.get("Rec", 0)) \
/ (evaldict.get("Prec", 0) + evaldict.get("Rec", 0))
except ZeroDivisionError:
return 0.0
######################
def overlap_type(span1, span2):
"""
Determine the error type of two (overlapping) spans.
The function checks, if and how span1 and span2 overlap.
The first span serves as the basis against which the second
span is evaluated.
span1 ---XXXX---
span2 ---XXXX--- TP (identical)
span2 ----XXXX-- BEO (overlap)
span2 --XXXX---- BEO (overlap)
span2 ----XX---- BES (smaller)
span2 ---XX----- BES (smaller)
span2 --XXXXXX-- BEL (larger)
span2 --XXXXX--- BEL (larger)
span2 -X-------- False (no overlap)
Input:
Tuples (beginSpan1, endSpan1) and (beginSpan2, endSpan2),
where begin and end are the indices of the corresponding tokens.
Output:
Either one of the following strings
- "TP" = span1 and span2 are identical, i.e., actually no error here
- "BES" = span2 is shorter and contained within span1 (with at most one identical boundary)
- "BEL" = span2 is longer and contains span1 (with at most one identical boundary)
- "BEO" = span1 and span2 overlap with no identical boundary
or False if span1 and span2 do not overlap.
"""
#Identical spans
if span1[0] == span2[0] and span1[1] == span2[1]:
return "TP"
#Start of spans is identical
if span1[0] == span2[0]:
#End of 2 is within span1
if span2[1] >= span1[0] and span2[1] < span1[1]:
return "BES"
#End of 2 is behind span1
else:
return "BEL"
#Start of 2 is before span1
elif span2[0] < span1[0]:
#End is before span 1
if span2[1] < span1[0]:
return False
#End is within span1
elif span2[1] < span1[1]:
return "BEO"
#End is identical or to the right
else:
return "BEL"
#Start of 2 is within span1
elif span2[0] >= span1[0] and span2[0] <= span1[1]:
#End of 2 is wihtin span1
if span2[1] <= span1[1]:
return "BES"
#End of 2 is to the right
else:
return "BEO"
#Start of 2 is behind span1
else:
return False
#####################################
def compare_spans(target_spans, system_spans, focus="target"):
"""
Compare system and target spans to identify correct/incorrect annotations.
The function takes a list of target spans and system spans.
Each span is a 4-tuple of
- label: the span type as string
- begin: the index of first token; equals end for spans of length 1
- end: the index of the last token; equals begin for spans of length 1
- tokens: a set of token indices included in the span
(this allows the correct evaluation of
partially and multiply overlapping spans;
to allow for changes of the token set,
the span tuple is actually implemented as a list.)
The function first performs traditional evaluation on these spans
to identify true positives, false positives, and false negatives.
Then, the additional error types for fair evaluation are determined,
following steps 1 to 4:
1. Count 1:1 mappings (TP, LE)
2. Count boundary errors (BE = BES + BEL + BEO)
3. Count labeling-boundary errors (LBE)
4. Count 1:0 and 0:1 mappings (FN, FP)
Input:
- List of target spans
- List of system spans
- Wether to focus on the system or target annotation (default: target)
Output: A dictionary containing
- the counts of TP, FP, and FN according to traditional evaluation
(per label and overall)
- the counts of TP, FP, LE, BE, BES, BEL, BEO, and FN
(per label and overall; BE = BES + BEL + BEO)
- a confusion matrix {target_label1 : {system_label1 : count,
system_label2 : count,
...},
target_label2 : ...
}
with an underscore '_' representing an empty label (FN/FP)
"""
##################################
def _max_sim(t, S):
"""
Determine the most similar span s from S for span t.
Similarity is defined as
1. the maximum number of shared tokens between s and t and
2. the minimum number of tokens only in t
If multiple spans are equally similar, the shortest s is chosen.
If still multiple spans are equally similar, the first one in the list is chosen,
which corresponds to the left-most one if sentences are read from left to right.
Input:
- Span t as 4-tuple [label, begin, end, token_set]
- List S containing > 1 spans
Output: The most similar s for t.
"""
S.sort(key=lambda s: (0-len(t[3].intersection(s[3])),
len(t[3].difference(s[3])),
len(s[3].difference(t[3])),
s[2]-s[1]))
return S[0]
##################################
traditional_error_types = ["TP", "FP", "FN"]
additional_error_types = ["LE", "BE", "BEO", "BES", "BEL", "LBE"]
#Initialize empty eval dict
eval_dict = {"overall" : {"traditional" : {err_type : 0 for err_type
in traditional_error_types},
"fair" : {err_type : 0 for err_type
in traditional_error_types + additional_error_types}},
"per_label" : {"traditional" : {},
"fair" : {}},
"conf" : {}}
#Initialize per-label dict
for s in target_spans + system_spans:
if not s[0] in eval_dict["per_label"]["traditional"]:
eval_dict["per_label"]["traditional"][s[0]] = {err_type : 0 for err_type
in traditional_error_types}
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][s[0]] = {err_type : 0 for err_type
in traditional_error_types + additional_error_types}
#Initialize confusion matrix
if not s[0] in eval_dict["conf"]:
eval_dict["conf"][s[0]] = {}
eval_dict["conf"]["_"] = {}
for lab in list(eval_dict["conf"])+["_"]:
for lab2 in list(eval_dict["conf"])+["_"]:
eval_dict["conf"][lab][lab2] = 0
################################################
### Traditional evaluation (overall + per label)
for t in target_spans:
#Spans in target and system annotation are true positives
if t in system_spans:
eval_dict["overall"]["traditional"]["TP"] += 1
eval_dict["per_label"]["traditional"][t[0]]["TP"] += 1
#Spans only in target annotation are false negatives
else:
eval_dict["overall"]["traditional"]["FN"] += 1
eval_dict["per_label"]["traditional"][t[0]]["FN"] += 1
for s in system_spans:
#Spans only in system annotation are false positives
if not s in target_spans:
eval_dict["overall"]["traditional"]["FP"] += 1
eval_dict["per_label"]["traditional"][s[0]]["FP"] += 1
###########################################################
### Fair evaluation (overall, per label + confusion matrix)
### Identical spans (TP and LE)
### TP
#Identify true positives (identical spans between target and system)
tps = [t for t in target_spans if t in system_spans]
for t in tps:
s = [s for s in system_spans if s == t]
if s:
s = s[0]
eval_dict["overall"]["fair"]["TP"] += 1
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][t[0]]["TP"] += 1
#After counting, remove from input lists
system_spans.remove(s)
target_spans.remove(t)
### LE
#Identify labeling error: identical span but different label
les = [t for t in target_spans
if any(t[0] != s[0] and t[1:3] == s[1:3] for s in system_spans)]
for t in les:
s = [s for s in system_spans if t[0] != s[0] and t[1:3] == s[1:3]]
if s:
s = s[0]
#Overall: count as one LE
eval_dict["overall"]["fair"]["LE"] += 1
#Per label: depending on focus count for target label or system label
if focus == "target":
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][t[0]]["LE"] += 1
elif focus == "system":
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][s[0]]["LE"] += 1
#Add to confusion matrix
eval_dict["conf"][t[0]][s[0]] += 1
#After counting, remove from input lists
system_spans.remove(s)
target_spans.remove(t)
### Boundary errors
#Create lists to collect matched spans
counted_target = list()
counted_system = list()
#Sort lists by span length (shortest to longest)
target_spans.sort(key=lambda t : t[2] - t[1])
system_spans.sort(key=lambda s : s[2] - s[1])
### BE
## 1. Compare input lists
#Identify boundary errors: identical label but different, overlapping span
i = 0
while i < len(target_spans):
t = target_spans[i]
#Find possible boundary errors
be = [s for s in system_spans
if t[0] == s[0] and t[1:3] != s[1:3]
and overlap_type((t[1], t[2]), (s[1], s[2])) in ("BES", "BEL", "BEO")]
if not be:
i += 1
continue
#If there is more than one possible BE, take most similar one
if len(be) > 1:
s = _max_sim(t, be)
else:
s = be[0]
#Determine overlap type
be_type = overlap_type((t[1], t[2]), (s[1], s[2]))
#Overall: Count as BE and more fine-grained BE type
eval_dict["overall"]["fair"]["BE"] += 1
eval_dict["overall"]["fair"][be_type] += 1
#Per-label: count as general BE and specific BE type
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][t[0]]["BE"] += 1
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][t[0]][be_type] += 1
#Add to confusion matrix
eval_dict["conf"][t[0]][s[0]] += 1
#Remove matched spans from input list
system_spans.remove(s)
target_spans.remove(t)
#Remove matched tokens from spans
matching_tokens = t[3].intersection(s[3])
s[3] = s[3].difference(matching_tokens)
t[3] = t[3].difference(matching_tokens)
#Move matched spans to counted list
counted_system.append(s)
counted_target.append(t)
## 2. Compare input target list with matched system list
i = 0
while i < len(target_spans):
t = target_spans[i]
#Find possible boundary errors in already matched spans
#that still share unmatched tokens
be = [s for s in counted_system
if t[0] == s[0] and t[1:3] != s[1:3]
and overlap_type((t[1], t[2]), (s[1], s[2])) in ("BES", "BEL", "BEO")
and t[3].intersection(s[3])]
if not be:
i += 1
continue
#If there is more than one possible BE, take most similar one
if len(be) > 1:
s = _max_sim(t, be)
else:
s = be[0]
#Determine overlap type
be_type = overlap_type((t[1], t[2]), (s[1], s[2]))
#Overall: Count as BE and more fine-grained BE type
eval_dict["overall"]["fair"]["BE"] += 1
eval_dict["overall"]["fair"][be_type] += 1
#Per-label: count as general BE and specific BE type
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][t[0]]["BE"] += 1
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][t[0]][be_type] += 1
#Add to confusion matrix
eval_dict["conf"][t[0]][s[0]] += 1
#Remove matched span from input list
target_spans.remove(t)
#Remove matched tokens from spans
matching_tokens = t[3].intersection(s[3])
counted_system[counted_system.index(s)][3] = s[3].difference(matching_tokens)
t[3] = t[3].difference(matching_tokens)
#Move target span to counted list
counted_target.append(t)
## 3. Compare input system list with matched target list
i = 0
while i < len(system_spans):
s = system_spans[i]
#Find possible boundary errors in already matched target spans
be = [t for t in counted_target
if t[0] == s[0] and t[1:3] != s[1:3]
and overlap_type((t[1], t[2]), (s[1], s[2])) in ("BES", "BEL", "BEO")
and t[3].intersection(s[3])]
if not be:
i += 1
continue
#If there is more than one possible BE, take most similar one
if len(be) > 1:
t = _max_sim(s, be)
else:
t = be[0]
#Determine overlap type
be_type = overlap_type((t[1], t[2]), (s[1], s[2]))
#Overall: Count as BE and more fine-grained BE type
eval_dict["overall"]["fair"]["BE"] += 1
eval_dict["overall"]["fair"][be_type] += 1
#Per-label: count as general BE and specific BE type
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][t[0]]["BE"] += 1
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][t[0]][be_type] += 1
#Add to confusion matrix
eval_dict["conf"][t[0]][s[0]] += 1
#Remove matched span from input list
system_spans.remove(s)
#Remove matched tokens from spans
matching_tokens = t[3].intersection(s[3])
counted_target[counted_target.index(t)][3] = t[3].difference(matching_tokens)
s[3] = s[3].difference(matching_tokens)
#Move system span to counted list
counted_system.append(s)
### LBE
## 1. Compare input lists
#Identify labeling-boundary errors: different label but overlapping span
i = 0
while i < len(target_spans):
t = target_spans[i]
#Find possible boundary errors
lbe = [s for s in system_spans
if t[0] != s[0] and t[1:3] != s[1:3]
and overlap_type((t[1], t[2]), (s[1], s[2])) in ("BES", "BEL", "BEO")]
if not lbe:
i += 1
continue
#If there is more than one possible LBE, take most similar one
if len(lbe) > 1:
s = _max_sim(t, lbe)
else:
s = lbe[0]
#Overall: count as LBE
eval_dict["overall"]["fair"]["LBE"] += 1
#Per label: depending on focus count as LBE for target or system label
if focus == "target":
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][t[0]]["LBE"] += 1
elif focus == "system":
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][s[0]]["LBE"] += 1
#Add to confusion matrix
eval_dict["conf"][t[0]][s[0]] += 1
#Remove matched spans from input list
system_spans.remove(s)
target_spans.remove(t)
#Remove matched tokens from spans
matching_tokens = t[3].intersection(s[3])
s[3] = s[3].difference(matching_tokens)
t[3] = t[3].difference(matching_tokens)
#Move spans to counted lists
counted_system.append(s)
counted_target.append(t)
## 2. Compare input target list with matched system list
i = 0
while i < len(target_spans):
t = target_spans[i]
#Find possible labeling-boundary errors in already matched system spans
lbe = [s for s in counted_system
if t[0] != s[0] and t[1:3] != s[1:3]
and overlap_type((t[1], t[2]), (s[1], s[2])) in ("BES", "BEL", "BEO")
and t[3].intersection(s[3])]
if not lbe:
i += 1
continue
#If there is more than one possible LBE, take most similar one
if len(lbe) > 1:
s = _max_sim(t, lbe)
else:
s = lbe[0]
#Overall: count as LBE
eval_dict["overall"]["fair"]["LBE"] += 1
#Per label: depending on focus count as LBE for target or system label
if focus == "target":
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][t[0]]["LBE"] += 1
elif focus == "system":
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][s[0]]["LBE"] += 1
#Add to confusion matrix
eval_dict["conf"][t[0]][s[0]] += 1
#Remove matched span from input list
target_spans.remove(t)
#Remove matched tokens from spans
matching_tokens = t[3].intersection(s[3])
counted_system[counted_system.index(s)][3] = s[3].difference(matching_tokens)
t[3] = t[3].difference(matching_tokens)
#Move target span to counted list
counted_target.append(t)
## 3. Compare input system list with matched target list
i = 0
while i < len(system_spans):
s = system_spans[i]
#Find possible labeling-boundary errors in already matched target spans
lbe = [t for t in counted_target
if t[0] != s[0] and t[1:3] != s[1:3]
and overlap_type((t[1], t[2]), (s[1], s[2])) in ("BES", "BEL", "BEO")
and t[3].intersection(s[3])]
if not lbe:
i += 1
continue
#If there is more than one possible LBE, take most similar one
if len(lbe) > 1:
t = _max_sim(s, lbe)
else:
t = lbe[0]
#Overall: count as LBE
eval_dict["overall"]["fair"]["LBE"] += 1
#Per label: depending on focus count as LBE for target or system label
if focus == "target":
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][t[0]]["LBE"] += 1
elif focus == "system":
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][s[0]]["LBE"] += 1
#Add to confusion matrix
eval_dict["conf"][t[0]][s[0]] += 1
#Remove matched span from input list
system_spans.remove(s)
#Remove matched tokens from spans
matching_tokens = t[3].intersection(s[3])
counted_target[counted_target.index(t)][3] = t[3].difference(matching_tokens)
s[3] = s[3].difference(matching_tokens)
#Move matched system span to counted list
counted_system.append(s)
### 1:0 and 0:1 mappings
#FN: identify false negatives
for t in target_spans:
eval_dict["overall"]["fair"]["FN"] += 1
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][t[0]]["FN"] += 1
eval_dict["conf"][t[0]]["_"] += 1
#FP: identify false positives
for s in system_spans:
eval_dict["overall"]["fair"]["FP"] += 1
eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][s[0]]["FP"] += 1
eval_dict["conf"]["_"][s[0]] += 1
return eval_dict
############################
def annotation_stats(target_spans, **config):
"""
Count the target annotations to display simple statistics.
The function takes a list of target spans
with each span being a 4-tuple [label, begin, end, token_set]
and adds the included labels to the general data stats dictionary.
Input:
- List of target spans
- Config dictionary
Output: The config dictionary is modified in-place.
"""
stats_dict = config.get("data_stats", {})
for span in target_spans:
if span[0] in stats_dict:
stats_dict[span[0]] += 1
else:
stats_dict[span[0]] = 1
config["data_stats"] = stats_dict
############################
def get_spans(sentence, **config):
"""
Return spans from CoNLL2000 or span files.
The function determines the data format of the input sentence
and extracts the spans from it accordingly.
If desired, punctuation can be ignored (config['ignore_punct'] == True)
for files in the CoNLL2000 format that include POS information.
The following list of tags is considered as punctuation:
['$.', '$,', '$(', #STTS
'PUNCT', #UPOS
'PUNKT', 'KOMMA', 'COMMA', 'KLAMMER', #custom
'.', ',', ':', '(', ')', '"', '‘', '“', '’', '”' #PTB
]
Labels that should be ignored (included in config['exclude']
or not included in config['labels'] if config['labels'] != 'all')
are also removed from the resulting list.
Input:
- List of lines for a given sentence
- Config dictionary
Output: List of spans that are included in the sentence.
"""
################
def spans_from_conll(sentence):
"""
Read annotation spans from a CoNLL2000 file.
The function takes a list of lines (belonging to one sentence)
and extracts the annotated spans. The lines are expected to
contain three space-separated columns:
Form XPOS Annotation
Form: Word form
XPOS: POS tag of the word (ideally STTS, UPOS, or PTB)
Annotation: Span annotation in BIO format (see below);
multiple spans are separated with the pipe symbol '|'
BIO tags consist of the token's position in the span
(begin 'B', inside 'I', outside 'O'), a dash '-' and the span label,
e.g., B-NP, I-AC, or in the case of stacked annotations I-RELC|B-NP.
The function accepts 'O', '_' and '' as annotations outside of spans.
Input: List of lines belonging to one sentence.
Output: List of spans as 4-tuples [label, begin, end, token_set]
"""
spans = []
span_stack = []
#For each token
for t, tok in enumerate(sentence):
#Token is [Form, XPOS, Annotation]
tok = tok.split()
#Token is not annotated
if tok[-1] in ["O", "_", ""]:
#Add previous stack to span list
#(sorted from left to right)
while span_stack:
spans.append(span_stack.pop(0))
span_stack = []
continue
#Token is annotated
#Split stacked annotations at pipe
annotations = tok[-1].strip().split("|")
#While there are more annotation levels on
#the stack than at the current token,
#close annotations on the stack (i.e., move
#them to result list)
while len(span_stack) > len(annotations):
spans.append(span_stack.pop())
#For each annotation of the current token
for i, annotation in enumerate(annotations):
#New span
if annotation.startswith("B-"):
#If it's the first annotation level and there is
#something on the stack, move it to result list
if i == 0 and span_stack:
while span_stack:
spans.append(span_stack.pop(0))
#Otherwise, end same-level annotation on the
#stack (because a new span begins here) and
#move it to the result list
else:
while len(span_stack) > i:
spans.append(span_stack.pop())
#Last part of BIO tag is the label
label = annotation.split("-")[1]
#Create a new span with this token's
#index as start and end (incremendet by one).
s = [label, t+1, t+1, {t+1}]
#Add on top of stack
span_stack.append(s)
#Span continues
elif annotation.startswith("I-"):
#Increment the end index of the span
#at the level of this annotation on the stack
span_stack[i][2] = t+1
#Also, add the index to the token set
span_stack[i][-1].add(t+1)
#Add sentence final span(s)
while span_stack:
spans.append(span_stack.pop(0))
return spans
################
def spans_from_lines(sentence):
"""
Read annotation spans from a span file.
The function takes a list of lines (belonging to one sentence)
and extracts the annotated spans. The lines are expected to
contain four tab-separated columns:
Label Begin End Tokens
Label: Span label
Begin: Index of the first included token (must be convertible to int)
End: Index of the last included token (must be convertible to int
and equal or greater than begin)
Tokens: Comma-separated list of indices of the tokens in the span
(must be convertible to int with begin <= i <= end);
if no (valid) indices are given, the range begin:end is used
Input: List of lines belonging to one sentence.
Output: List of spans as 4-tuples [label, begin, end, token_set]
"""
spans = []
for line in sentence:
vals = line.split("\t")
label = vals[0]
if not label:
print("ERROR: Missing label in input.")
return []
try:
begin = int(vals[1])
if begin < 1: raise ValueError
except ValueError:
print("ERROR: Begin {0} is not a legal index.".format(vals[1]))
return []
try:
end = int(vals[2])
if end < 1: raise ValueError
if end < begin: begin, end = end, begin
except ValueError:
print("ERROR: End {0} is not a legal index.".format(vals[2]))
return []
try:
toks = [int(v.strip()) for v in vals[-1].split(",")
if int(v.strip()) >= begin and int(v.strip()) <= end]
toks = set(toks)
except ValueError:
toks = []
if not toks:
toks = [i for i in range(begin, end+1)]
spans.append([label, begin, end, toks])
return spans
################
#Determine data format
#Span files contain 4 tab-separated columns
if len(sentence[0].split("\t")) == 4:
format = "spans"
spans = spans_from_lines(sentence)
#CoNLL2000 files contain 3 space-separated columns
elif len(sentence[0].split(" ")) == 3:
format = "conll2000"
spans = spans_from_conll(sentence)
else:
print("ERROR: Unknown input format")
return []
#Exclude punctuation from CoNLL2000, if desired
if format == "conll2000" \
and config.get("ignore_punct") == True:
#For each punctuation tok
for i, line in enumerate(sentence):
if line.split(" ")[1] in ["$.", "$,", "$(", #STTS
"PUNCT", #UPOS
"PUNKT", "KOMMA", "COMMA", "KLAMMER", #custom
".", ",", ":", "(", ")", "\"", "‘", "“", "’", "”" #PTB
]:
for s in range(len(spans)):
#Remove punc tok from set
spans[s][-1].discard(i+1)
#If span begins with punc, move begin
if spans[s][1] == i+1:
if spans[s][2] != None and spans[s][2] > i+1:
spans[s][1] = i+2
else:
spans[s][1] = None
#If span ends with punc, move end
if spans[s][2] == i+1:
if spans[s][1] != None and spans[s][1] <= i:
spans[s][2] = i
else:
spans[s][2] = None
#Remove empty spans
spans = [s for s in spans if s[1] != None and s[2] != None and len(s[3]) > 0]
#Exclude unwanted labels
spans = [s for s in spans
if not s[0] in config.get("exclude", [])
and ("all" in config.get("labels", [])
or s[0] in config.get("labels", []))]
return spans
############################
def get_sentences(filename):
"""
Reads sentences from input files.
The function iterates through the input file and
yields a list of lines that belong to one sentence.
Sentences are expected to be separated by an empty line.
Input: Filename of the input file.
Output: Yields a list of lines for each sentence.
"""
file = open(filename, mode="r", encoding="utf-8")
sent = []
for line in file:
#New line: yield collected lines
if sent and not line.strip():
yield sent
sent = []
#New line but nothing to yield
elif not line.strip():
continue
#Collect line of current sentence
else:
sent.append(line.strip())
#Last sentence if file doesn't end with empty line
if sent:
yield sent
file.close()
#############################
def add_dict(base_dict, dict_to_add):
"""
Take a base dictionary and add the values
from another dictionary to it.
Contrary to standard dict update methods,
this function does not overwrite values in the
base dictionary. Instead, it is meant to add
the values of the second dictionary to the values
in the base dictionary. The dictionary is modified in-place.
For example:
>> base = {"A" : 1, "B" : {"c" : 2, "d" : 3}, "C" : [1, 2, 3]}
>> add = {"A" : 1, "B" : {"c" : 1, "e" : 1}, "C" : [4], "D" : 2}
>> add_dict(base, add)
will create a base dictionary:
>> base
{'A': 2, 'B': {'c': 3, 'd': 3, 'e': 1}, 'C': [1, 2, 3, 4], 'D': 2}
The function can handle different types of nested structures.
- Integers and float values are summed up.
- Lists are appended
- Sets are added (set union)
- Dictionaries are added recursively
For other value types, the base dictionary is left unchanged.
Input: Base dictionary and dictionary to be added.
Output: Base dictionary.
"""
#For each key in second dict
for key, val in dict_to_add.items():
#It is already in the base dict
if key in base_dict:
#It has an integer or float value
if isinstance(val, (int, float)) \
and isinstance(base_dict[key], (int, float)):
#Increment value in base dict
base_dict[key] += val
#It has an iterable as value
elif isinstance(val, Iterable) \
and isinstance(base_dict[key], Iterable):
#List
if isinstance(val, list) \
and isinstance(base_dict[key], list):
#Append
base_dict[key].extend(val)
#Set
elif isinstance(val, set) \
and isinstance(base_dict[key], set):
#Set union
base_dict[key].update(val)
#Dict
elif isinstance(val, dict) \
and isinstance(base_dict[key], dict):
#Recursively repeat
add_dict(base_dict[key], val)
#Something else
else:
#Do nothing
pass
#It has something else as value
else:
#Do nothing
pass
#It is not in the base dict
else:
#Insert values from second dict into base
base_dict[key] = deepcopy(val)
return base_dict
#############################
def calculate_results(eval_dict, **config):
"""
Calculate overall precision, recall, and F-scores.
The function takes an evaluation dictionary with error counts
and applies the precision, recall and fscore functions.
It will calculate the traditional metrics
and fair and/or weighted metrics, depending on the
value of config['eval_method'].
The results are stored in the eval dict as 'Prec', 'Rec' and 'F1'
for overall and per-label counts.
Input: Evaluation dict and config dict.
Output: Evaluation dict with added precision, recall and F1 values.
"""
#If weighted evaluation should be performed
#copy error counts from fair evaluation
if "weighted" in config.get("eval_method", []):
eval_dict["overall"]["weighted"] = {}
for err_type in eval_dict["overall"]["fair"]:
eval_dict["overall"]["weighted"][err_type] = eval_dict["overall"]["fair"][err_type]
for label in eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"]:
eval_dict["per_label"]["weighted"][label] = {}
for err_type in eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][label]:
eval_dict["per_label"]["weighted"][label][err_type] = eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"][label][err_type]
#For each evaluation method
for version in config.get("eval_method", ["traditional", "fair"]):
#Overall results
eval_dict["overall"][version]["Prec"] = precision(eval_dict["overall"][version],
version,
config.get("weights", {}))
eval_dict["overall"][version]["Rec"] = recall(eval_dict["overall"][version],
version,
config.get("weights", {}))
eval_dict["overall"][version]["F1"] = fscore(eval_dict["overall"][version])
#Per label results
for label in eval_dict["per_label"][version]:
eval_dict["per_label"][version][label]["Prec"] = precision(eval_dict["per_label"][version][label],
version,
config.get("weights", {}))
eval_dict["per_label"][version][label]["Rec"] = recall(eval_dict["per_label"][version][label],
version,
config.get("weights", {}))
eval_dict["per_label"][version][label]["F1"] = fscore(eval_dict["per_label"][version][label])
return eval_dict
#############################
def output_results(eval_dict, **config):
"""
Write evaluation results to the output (file).
The function takes an evaluation dict and writes
all results to the specified output (file):
1. Traditional evaluation results
2. Additional evaluation results (fair and/or weighted)
3. Result comparison for different evaluation methods
4. Confusion matrix
5. Data statistics
Input: Evaluation dict and config dict.
"""
outfile = config.get("eval_out", sys.stdout)
### Output results for each evaluation method
for version in config.get("eval_method", ["traditional", "fair"]):
print(file=outfile)
print("### {0} evaluation:".format(version.title()), file=outfile)
#Determine error categories to output
if version == "traditional":
cats = ["TP", "FP", "FN"]
elif version == "fair" or not config.get("weights", {}):
cats = ["TP", "FP", "LE", "BE", "LBE", "FN"]
else:
cats = list(config.get("weights").keys())
#Print header
print("Label", "\t".join(cats), "Prec", "Rec", "F1", sep="\t", file=outfile)
#Output results for each label
for label,val in sorted(eval_dict["per_label"][version].items()):
print(label,
"\t".join([str(val.get(cat, eval_dict["per_label"]["fair"].get(cat, 0)))
for cat in cats]),
"\t".join(["{:04.2f}".format(val.get(metric, 0)*100)
for metric in ["Prec", "Rec", "F1"]]),
sep="\t", file=outfile)
#Output overall results
print("overall",
"\t".join([str(eval_dict["overall"][version].get(cat, eval_dict["overall"]["fair"].get(cat, 0)))
for cat in cats]),
"\t".join(["{:04.2f}".format(eval_dict["overall"][version].get(metric, 0)*100)
for metric in ["Prec", "Rec", "F1"]]),
sep="\t", file=outfile)
### Output result comparison
print(file=outfile)
print("### Comparison:", file=outfile)
print("Version", "Prec", "Rec", "F1", sep="\t", file=outfile)
for version in config.get("eval_method", ["traditional", "fair"]):
print(version.title(),
"\t".join(["{:04.2f}".format(eval_dict["overall"][version].get(metric, 0)*100)
for metric in ["Prec", "Rec", "F1"]]),
sep="\t", file=outfile)
### Output confusion matrix
print(file=outfile)
print("### Confusion matrix:", file=outfile)
#Get set of target labels
labels = {lab for lab in eval_dict["conf"]}
#Add system labels
labels = list(labels.union({syslab
for lab in eval_dict["conf"]
for syslab in eval_dict["conf"][lab]}))
#Sort alphabetically for output
labels.sort()
#Print top row with system labels
print(r"Target\System", "\t".join(labels), sep="\t", file=outfile)
#Print rows with target labels and counts
for targetlab in labels:
print(targetlab,
"\t".join([str(eval_dict["conf"][targetlab].get(syslab, 0))
for syslab in labels]),
sep="\t", file=outfile)
#Output data statistic
print(file=outfile)
print("### Target data stats:", file=outfile)
print("Label", "Freq", "%", sep="\t", file=outfile)
total = sum(config.get("data_stats", {}).values())
for lab, freq in config.get("data_stats", {}).items():
print(lab, freq, "{:04.2f}".format(freq/total*100), sep="\t", file=outfile)
#Close output if it is a file
if isinstance(config.get("eval_out"), TextIOWrapper):
outfile.close()
#############################
def read_config(config_file):
"""
Function to set program parameters as specified in the config file.
The following parameters are handled:
- target_in: path to the target file(s) with gold standard annotation
-> output: 'target_files' : [list of target file paths]
- system_in: path to the system's output file(s), which are evaluated
-> output: 'system_files' : [list of system file paths]
- eval_out: path or filename, where evaluation results should be stored
if value is a path, output file 'path/eval.csv' is created
if value is 'cmd' or missing, output is set to sys.stdout
-> output: 'eval_out' : output file or sys.stdout
- labels: comma-separated list of labels to evaluate
defaults to 'all'
-> output: 'labels' : [list of labels as strings]
- exclude: comma-separated list of labels to exclude from evaluation
always contains 'NONE' and 'EMPTY'
-> output: 'exclude' : [list of labels as strings]
- ignore_punct: wether to ignore punctuation during evaluation (true/false)
-> output: 'ignore_punct' : True/False
- focus: wether to focus the evaluation on 'target' or 'system' annotations
defaults to 'target'
-> output: 'focus' : 'target' or 'system'
- weights: weights that should be applied during calculation of precision
and recall; at the same time can serve as a list of additional
error types to include in the evaluation
the weights are parsed from comma-separated input formulas of the form
error_type = weight * TP + weight2 * FP + weight3 * FN
-> output: 'weights' : { 'error type' : {
'TP' : weight,
'FP' : weight,
'FN' : weight
},
'another error type' : {...}
}
- eval_method: defines which evaluation method(s) to use
one or more of: 'traditional', 'fair', 'weighted'
if value is 'all' or missing, all available methods are returned
-> output: 'eval_method' : [list of eval methods]
Input: Filename of the config file.
Output: Settings dictionary.
"""
############################
def _parse_config(key, val):
"""
Internal function to set specific values for the given keys.
In case of illegal values, prints error message and sets key and/or value to None.
Input: Key and value from config file
Output: Modified key and value
"""
if key in ["target_in", "system_in"]:
if os.path.isdir(val):
val = os.path.normpath(val)
files = [os.path.join(val, f) for f in os.listdir(val)]
elif os.path.isfile(val):
files = [os.path.normpath(val)]
else:
print("Error: '{0} = {1}' is not a file/directory.".format(key, val))
return None, None
if key == "target_in":
return "target_files", files
elif key == "system_in":
return "system_files", files
elif key == "eval_out":
if os.path.isdir(val):
val = os.path.normpath(val)
outfile = os.path.join(val, "eval.csv")
elif os.path.isfile(val):
outfile = os.path.normpath(val)
elif val == "cmd":
outfile = sys.stdout
else:
try:
p, f = os.path.split(val)
if not os.path.isdir(p):
os.makedirs(p)
outfile = os.path.join(p, f)
except:
print("Error: '{0} = {1}' is not a file/directory.".format(key, val))
return None, None
return key, outfile
elif key in ["labels", "exclude"]:
labels = list(set([v.strip() for v in val.split(",") if v.strip()]))
if key == "exclude":
labels.append("NONE")
labels.append("EMPTY")
return key, labels
elif key == "ignore_punct":
if val.strip().lower() == "false":
return key, False
else:
return key, True
elif key == "focus":
if val.strip().lower() == "system":
return key, "system"
else:
return key, "target"
elif key == "weights":
if val == "default":
return key, {"TP" : {"TP" : 1},
"FP" : {"FP" : 1},
"FN" : {"FN" : 1},
"LE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"BE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"LBE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5}}
else:
formulas = val.split(",")
weights = {}
#For each given formula, i.e., for each error type
for f in formulas:
#Match error type as string-initial letters before equal sign =
error_type = re.match(r"\s*(?P<Error>\w+)\s*=", f)
if error_type == None:
print("WARNING: No error type found in weight formula '{0}'.".format(f))
continue
else:
error_type = error_type.group("Error")
weights[error_type] = {}
#Match weight for TP
w_tp = re.search(r"(?P<TP>\d*\.?\d+)\s*\*?\s*TP", f)
if w_tp == None:
print("WARNING: Missing weight for TP for error type {0}. Set to 0.".format(error_type))
weights[error_type]["TP"] = 0
else:
try:
w_tp = w_tp.group("TP")
w_tp = float(w_tp)
weights[error_type]["TP"] = w_tp
except ValueError:
print("WARNING: Weight for TP for error type {0} is not a number. Set to 0.".format(error_type))
weights[error_type]["TP"] = 0
#Match weight for FP
w_fp = re.search(r"(?P<FP>\d*\.?\d+)\s*\*?\s*FP", f)
if w_fp == None:
print("WARNING: Missing weight for FP for error type {0}. Set to 0.".format(error_type))
weights[error_type]["FP"] = 0
else:
try:
w_fp = w_fp.group("FP")
w_fp = float(w_fp)
weights[error_type]["FP"] = w_fp
except ValueError:
print("WARNING: Weight for FP for error type {0} is not a number. Set to 0.".format(error_type))
weights[error_type]["FP"] = 0
#Match weight for FP
w_fn = re.search(r"(?P<FN>\d*\.?\d+)\s*\*?\s*FN", f)
if w_fn == None:
print("WARNING: Missing weight for FN for error type {0}. Set to 0.".format(error_type))
weights[error_type]["FN"] = 0
else:
try:
w_fn = w_fn.group("FN")
w_fn = float(w_fn)
weights[error_type]["FN"] = w_fn
except ValueError:
print("WARNING: Weight for FN for error type {0} is not a number. Set to 0.".format(error_type))
weights[error_type]["FN"] = 0
if weights:
#Add default weights for traditional categories if needed
if not "TP" in weights:
weights["TP"] = {"TP" : 1}
if not "FP" in weights:
weights["FP"] = {"FP" : 1}
if not "FN" in weights:
weights["FN"] = {"FN" : 1}
return key, weights
else:
print("WARNING: No valid weights found. Using default weights.")
return key, {"TP" : {"TP" : 1},
"FP" : {"FP" : 1},
"FN" : {"FN" : 1},
"LE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"BE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5},
"LBE" : {"TP" : 0, "FP" : 0.5, "FN" : 0.5}}
elif key == "eval_method":
available_methods = ["traditional", "fair", "weighted"]
if val == "all":
return key, available_methods
else:
methods = []
for m in available_methods:
if m in [v.strip() for v in val.split(",")
if v.strip() and v.strip().lower() in available_methods]:
methods.append(m)
if methods:
return key, methods
else:
print("WARNING: No evaluation method specified. Applying all methods.")
return key, available_methods
#############################
config = dict()
f = open(config_file, mode="r", encoding="utf-8")
for line in f:
line = line.strip()
#Skip empty lines and comments
if not line or line.startswith("#"):
continue
line = line.split("=")
key = line[0].strip()
val = "=".join(line[1:]).strip()
#Store original paths of input files
if key in ["target_in", "system_in"]:
print("{0}: {1}".format(key, val))
config[key] = val
#Parse config
key, val = _parse_config(key, val)
#Skip illegal configs
if key is None or val is None:
continue
#Warn before overwriting duplicate config items.
if key in config:
print("WARNING: duplicate config item '{0}' found.".format(key))
config[key] = val
f.close()
#Stop evaluation if either target or system files are missing
if not "target_files" in config or not "system_files" in config:
print("ERROR: Cannot evaluate without target AND system file(s). Quitting.")
return None
#Output to sys.stdout if no evaluation file is specified
elif config.get("eval_out", None) == None:
config["eval_out"] = sys.stdout
#Otherwise open eval file
else:
config["eval_out"] = open(config.get("eval_out"), mode="w", encoding="utf-8")
#Set labels to 'all' if no specific labels are given
if config.get("labels", None) == None:
config["labels"] = ["all"]
if config.get("eval_method", None) == None:
config["eval_method"] = ["traditional", "fair", "weighted"]
if not config.get("weights", {}) and "weighted" in config.get("eval_method"):
if not "fair" in config["eval_method"]:
config["eval_method"].append("fair")
del config["eval_method"][config["eval_method"].index("weighted")]
#Output settings at the top of evaluation file
print("### Evaluation settings:", file=config.get("eval_out"))
for key in sorted(config.keys()):
if key in ["target_files", "system_files", "eval_out"]:
continue
print("{0}: {1}".format(key, config.get(key)), file=config.get("eval_out"))
print(file=config.get("eval_out"))
return config
###########################
if __name__ == '__main__':
parser = argparse.ArgumentParser()
parser.add_argument('--config', help='Configuration File', required=True)
args = parser.parse_args()
#Read config file into dict
config = read_config(args.config)
#Create empty eval dict
eval_dict = {"overall" : {"traditional" : {}, "fair" : {}},
"per_label" : {"traditional" : {}, "fair" : {}},
"conf" : {}}
for method in config.get("eval_method", ["traditional", "fair"]):
eval_dict["overall"][method] = {}
eval_dict["per_label"][method] = {}
#Create dict to count target annotations
config["data_stats"] = {}
#Get system and target files to compare
#The files must have the same name to be compared
file_pairs = []
for t in config.get("target_files", []):
s = [f for f in config.get("system_files", [])
if os.path.split(t)[-1] == os.path.split(f)[-1]]
if s:
file_pairs.append((t, s[0]))
#Go through target and system files in parallel
for target_file, system_file in file_pairs:
#For each sentence pair
for target_sentence, system_sentence in zip(get_sentences(target_file),
get_sentences(system_file)):
#Get spans
target_spans = get_spans(target_sentence, **config)
system_spans = get_spans(system_sentence, **config)
#Count target annotations for simple statistics.
#Result is stored in data_stats key of config dict.
annotation_stats(target_spans, **config)
#Evaluate spans
sent_counts = compare_spans(target_spans, system_spans,
config.get("focus", "target"))
#Add results to eval dict
eval_dict = add_dict(eval_dict, sent_counts)
#Calculate overall results
eval_dict = calculate_results(eval_dict, **config)
#Output results
output_results(eval_dict, **config)