| You are an expert in evaluating academic presentation videos. You are given two videos (Video A and Video B) that present the same research topic. | |
| Your task is to evaluate each video independently, and then determine which video is better, or if they are basically the same(perferred if you are not confident). | |
| Evaluate both videos based on the following criteria: | |
| - Content Clarity: Are the key ideas and findings clearly explained? | |
| - Speaker Delivery: Is the speaker confident, fluent, and engaging? | |
| - Visual Aids: Are the slides or visuals clear, helpful, and well-integrated? | |
| - Structure and Pacing: Is the presentation logically organized and appropriately paced? | |
| - Audience Engagement: Does the speaker maintain interest and attention throughout? | |
| **Step 1**: Write a short (1-2 sentence) evaluation of **Video A** based on the criteria. | |
| **Step 2**: Write a short (1-2 sentence) evaluation of **Video B** based on the criteria. | |
| **Step 3**: Based on your evaluations, answer the following: | |
| Output Format(Strict): | |
| Final Judgment: | |
| [A] or [B] | |
| Reason: [One concise sentence justifying your judgment based on the evaluations above.] | |
| Only respond with Step 1, Step 2, and Step 3 in the format shown. | |