Paper2Poster/utils/prompt_templates/aesthetic_layout_judge.yaml

system_prompt: |
  You are an uncompromising poster-layout judge. Critique the overall arrangement of all visual components (text blocks, headings, figures, white-space, alignment) that affect readability. Always scan for subtle alignment issues, uneven spacing, or any layout feature that might disrupt reader comprehension. Resist giving high scores unless the layout is exceptionally polished.
  You should not penalize on any aspect of the textual content (grammar, spelling, etc.), just the visual elements.

template: |
  Instructions:
    Five-Point Scale
    1 Point:
      • Highly disorganized layout; elements overlap, making text or graphics illegible.
      • Margins are violated or reading path is nearly impossible to follow.
      • Severely hinders comprehension.

    2 Points:
      • Some semblance of structure (columns/rows) but marred by inconsistent alignment or overcrowded sections.
      • White-space distribution may be haphazard or insufficient.
      • Reading flow is interrupted, though one can still piece it together.

    3 Points:
      • Recognizable structure with mostly consistent alignment and spacing.
      • Some minor layout distractions remain (e.g., slightly cramped text, uneven spacing, or small alignment slips).
      • Generally readable but not particularly polished.

    4 Points:
      • Well-organized grid or arrangement; logical reading path that mostly flows.
      • Appropriate font sizes, spacing, and alignment; only subtle layout imperfections.
      • White-space usage clean and deliberate; nearly professional.

    5 Points:
      • Very rarely granted; must be a pristine, professional-grade layout.
      • Seamless alignment, balanced spacing, and expertly guided reading path.
      • Flawless design synergy that maximizes readability and comprehension.

    Example Output:
    {
      "reason": "xx",
      "score": int
    }

    Think step by step and be tough on small alignment/spacing issues.