judge-arena / app.py
kaikaidai's picture
Update app.py
8863707 verified
raw
history blame
26.4 kB
import json
import re
import random
from collections import defaultdict
from datetime import datetime, timezone
import hashlib
from dotenv import load_dotenv
load_dotenv()
import gradio as gr
from gen_api_answer import get_model_response, parse_model_response
from db import add_vote, create_db_connection, get_votes
from utils import Vote
from common import (
POLICY_CONTENT,
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS,
DEFAULT_EVAL_PROMPT,
DEFAULT_INPUT,
DEFAULT_RESPONSE,
CSS_STYLES,
MAIN_TITLE,
HOW_IT_WORKS,
BATTLE_RULES,
EVAL_DESCRIPTION,
VOTING_HEADER,
)
from example_metrics import EXAMPLE_METRICS
import hashlib
# Model and ELO score data
DEFAULT_ELO = 1500 # Starting ELO for new models
K_FACTOR = 32 # Standard chess K-factor, adjust as needed
elo_scores = defaultdict(lambda: DEFAULT_ELO)
vote_counts = defaultdict(int)
db = create_db_connection()
votes_collection = get_votes(db)
current_time = datetime.now()
# Load the model_data from JSONL
def load_model_data():
model_data = {}
try:
with open("data/models.jsonl", "r") as f:
for line in f:
model = json.loads(line)
model_data[model["name"]] = {
"organization": model["organization"],
"license": model["license"],
"api_model": model["api_model"],
}
except FileNotFoundError:
print("Warning: models.jsonl not found")
return {}
return model_data
model_data = load_model_data()
def store_vote_data(prompt, response_a, response_b, model_a, model_b, winner, judge_id):
vote = Vote(
timestamp=datetime.now().isoformat(),
prompt=prompt,
response_a=response_a,
response_b=response_b,
model_a=model_a,
model_b=model_b,
winner=winner,
judge_id=judge_id,
)
add_vote(vote, db)
def parse_variables(prompt):
# Extract variables enclosed in double curly braces
variables = re.findall(r"{{(.*?)}}", prompt)
# Remove duplicates while preserving order
seen = set()
variables = [
x.strip() for x in variables if not (x.strip() in seen or seen.add(x.strip()))
]
return variables
def get_final_prompt(eval_prompt, variable_values):
# Replace variables in the eval prompt with their values
for var, val in variable_values.items():
eval_prompt = eval_prompt.replace("{{" + var + "}}", val)
return eval_prompt
def submit_prompt(eval_prompt, *variable_values):
try:
variables = parse_variables(eval_prompt)
variable_values_dict = {var: val for var, val in zip(variables, variable_values)}
final_prompt = get_final_prompt(eval_prompt, variable_values_dict)
models = list(model_data.keys())
model1, model2 = random.sample(models, 2)
model_a, model_b = (model1, model2) if random.random() < 0.5 else (model2, model1)
response_a = get_model_response(model_a, model_data.get(model_a), final_prompt)
response_b = get_model_response(model_b, model_data.get(model_b), final_prompt)
return (
response_a,
response_b,
gr.update(visible=True),
gr.update(visible=True),
model_a,
model_b,
final_prompt,
)
except Exception as e:
print(f"Error in submit_prompt: {str(e)}")
return (
"Error generating response",
"Error generating response",
gr.update(visible=False),
gr.update(visible=False),
None,
None,
None,
)
def get_ip(request: gr.Request) -> str:
"""Get and hash the IP address from the request."""
if "cf-connecting-ip" in request.headers:
ip = request.headers["cf-connecting-ip"]
elif "x-forwarded-for" in request.headers:
ip = request.headers["x-forwarded-for"]
if "," in ip:
ip = ip.split(",")[0]
else:
ip = request.client.host
# Hash the IP address for privacy
return hashlib.sha256(ip.encode()).hexdigest()[:16]
def vote(
choice,
model_a,
model_b,
final_prompt,
score_a,
critique_a,
score_b,
critique_b,
request: gr.Request,
):
# Get hashed IP as judge_id
judge_id = get_ip(request)
# Update ELO scores based on user choice
elo_a = elo_scores[model_a]
elo_b = elo_scores[model_b]
# Calculate expected scores
Ea = 1 / (1 + 10 ** ((elo_b - elo_a) / 400))
Eb = 1 / (1 + 10 ** ((elo_a - elo_b) / 400))
# Assign actual scores
if choice == "A":
Sa, Sb = 1, 0
elif choice == "B":
Sa, Sb = 0, 1
else:
Sa, Sb = 0.5, 0.5
# Update scores and vote counts
elo_scores[model_a] += K_FACTOR * (Sa - Ea)
elo_scores[model_b] += K_FACTOR * (Sb - Eb)
vote_counts[model_a] += 1
vote_counts[model_b] += 1
# Format the full responses with score and critique
response_a = f"""{score_a}
{critique_a}"""
response_b = f"""{score_b}
{critique_b}"""
# Store the vote data with the final prompt
store_vote_data(
final_prompt, response_a, response_b, model_a, model_b, choice, judge_id
)
# Return updates for UI components
return [
gr.update(visible=False), # action_buttons_row
gr.update(value=f"*Model: {model_a}*"), # model_name_a
gr.update(value=f"*Model: {model_b}*"), # model_name_b
gr.update(interactive=True), # send_btn
gr.update(visible=True, interactive=True), # regenerate_button
]
def get_current_votes():
"""Get current votes from database."""
return get_votes(db)
def get_leaderboard():
"""Generate leaderboard data using fresh votes from MongoDB."""
# Get fresh voting data
voting_data = get_current_votes()
print(f"Fetched {len(voting_data)} votes from database") # Debug log
# Initialize dictionaries for tracking
ratings = defaultdict(lambda: DEFAULT_ELO)
matches = defaultdict(int)
# Process each vote
for vote in voting_data:
try:
model_a = vote.get("model_a")
model_b = vote.get("model_b")
winner = vote.get("winner")
# Skip if models aren't in current model_data
if (
not all([model_a, model_b, winner])
or model_a not in model_data
or model_b not in model_data
):
continue
# Update match counts
matches[model_a] += 1
matches[model_b] += 1
# Calculate ELO changes
elo_a = ratings[model_a]
elo_b = ratings[model_b]
# Expected scores
expected_a = 1 / (1 + 10 ** ((elo_b - elo_a) / 400))
expected_b = 1 - expected_a
# Actual scores
score_a = 1 if winner == "A" else 0 if winner == "B" else 0.5
score_b = 1 - score_a
# Update ratings
ratings[model_a] += K_FACTOR * (score_a - expected_a)
ratings[model_b] += K_FACTOR * (score_b - expected_b)
except Exception as e:
print(f"Error processing vote: {e}")
continue
# Generate leaderboard data
leaderboard = []
for model in model_data.keys():
votes = matches[model]
elo = ratings[model]
ci = 1.96 * (400 / (votes + 1) ** 0.5) if votes > 0 else 0
data = {
"Model": model,
"ELO Score": f"{elo:.2f}",
"95% CI": f"±{ci:.2f}",
"# Votes": votes,
"Organization": model_data[model]["organization"],
"License": model_data[model]["license"],
}
leaderboard.append(data)
# Sort leaderboard by ELO score in descending order
leaderboard.sort(key=lambda x: float(x["ELO Score"]), reverse=True)
return leaderboard
def regenerate_prompt(model_a, model_b, eval_prompt, *variable_values):
variables = parse_variables(eval_prompt)
variable_values_dict = {var: val for var, val in zip(variables, variable_values)}
final_prompt = get_final_prompt(eval_prompt, variable_values_dict)
# Get available models excluding the previous ones
available_models = [m for m in model_data.keys() if m not in (model_a, model_b)]
# If we have enough models for new pairs
if len(available_models) >= 2:
model1, model2 = random.sample(available_models, 2)
else:
# Fallback to allowing previous models if necessary
model1, model2 = random.sample(list(model_data.keys()), 2)
response_a = get_model_response(model1, model_data.get(model1), final_prompt)
response_b = get_model_response(model2, model_data.get(model2), final_prompt)
# Parse the responses
score_a, critique_a = parse_model_response(response_a)
score_b, critique_b = parse_model_response(response_b)
return (
score_a, # score_a textbox
critique_a, # critique_a textbox
score_b, # score_b textbox
critique_b, # critique_b textbox
gr.update(visible=True), # action_buttons_row
gr.update(value="*Model: Unknown*"), # model_name_a
gr.update(value="*Model: Unknown*"), # model_name_b
model1, # model_a_state
model2, # model_b_state
)
def calculate_elo_change(rating_a, rating_b, winner):
"""Calculate ELO rating changes for both players."""
expected_a = 1 / (1 + 10 ** ((rating_b - rating_a) / 400))
expected_b = 1 - expected_a
if winner == "A":
score_a, score_b = 1, 0
elif winner == "B":
score_a, score_b = 0, 1
else: # Handle ties
score_a, score_b = 0.5, 0.5
change_a = K_FACTOR * (score_a - expected_a)
change_b = K_FACTOR * (score_b - expected_b)
return change_a, change_b
def update_leaderboard():
"""Generate leaderboard DataFrame using fresh votes from MongoDB."""
# Get fresh voting data
voting_data = get_current_votes()
print(f"Found {len(voting_data)} votes in database")
matches = defaultdict(int)
# Process each vote chronologically
for vote in voting_data:
# Extract model names from the vote document
try:
model_a = vote.get("model_a")
model_b = vote.get("model_b")
winner = vote.get("winner")
print(f"Processing vote: {model_a} vs {model_b}, winner: {winner}")
# Skip if any required field is missing or models aren't in current model_data
if not all([model_a, model_b, winner]):
print(f"Missing required fields in vote: {vote}")
continue
if model_a not in model_data:
print(f"Model A '{model_a}' not found in model_data")
continue
if model_b not in model_data:
print(f"Model B '{model_b}' not found in model_data")
continue
# Update match counts
matches[model_a] += 1
matches[model_b] += 1
print(
f"Updated matches - {model_a}: {matches[model_a]}, {model_b}: {matches[model_b]}"
)
except Exception as e:
print(f"Error processing vote: {e}")
print(f"Problematic vote data: {vote}")
continue
# Update the display_leaderboard function
def display_leaderboard():
df = update_leaderboard()
return gr.DataFrame(
value=df,
headers=["Model", "ELO", "95% CI", "Matches", "Organization", "License"],
datatype=["str", "number", "str", "number", "str", "str", "str"],
row_count=(len(df) + 1, "dynamic"),
)
# Update the leaderboard table definition in the UI
leaderboard_table = gr.Dataframe(
headers=["Model", "ELO", "95% CI", "Matches", "Organization", "License"],
datatype=["str", "number", "str", "number", "str", "str", "str"],
)
def get_leaderboard_stats():
"""Get summary statistics for the leaderboard."""
now = datetime.now(timezone.utc)
total_votes = len(get_current_votes())
total_models = len(model_data)
last_updated = now.replace(minute=0, second=0, microsecond=0).strftime(
"%B %d, %Y at %H:00 UTC"
)
return f"""
### Leaderboard Stats
- **Total Models**: {total_models}
- **Total Votes**: {total_votes}
- **Last Updated**: {last_updated}
"""
def set_example_metric(metric_name):
if metric_name == "Custom":
variables = parse_variables(DEFAULT_EVAL_PROMPT)
variable_values = []
for var in variables:
if var == "input":
variable_values.append(DEFAULT_INPUT)
elif var == "response":
variable_values.append(DEFAULT_RESPONSE)
else:
variable_values.append("") # Default empty value
# Pad variable_values to match the length of variable_rows
while len(variable_values) < len(variable_rows):
variable_values.append("")
return [DEFAULT_EVAL_PROMPT] + variable_values
metric_data = EXAMPLE_METRICS[metric_name]
variables = parse_variables(metric_data["prompt"])
variable_values = []
for var in variables:
value = metric_data.get(var, "") # Default to empty string if not found
variable_values.append(value)
# Pad variable_values to match the length of variable_rows
while len(variable_values) < len(variable_rows):
variable_values.append("")
return [metric_data["prompt"]] + variable_values
# Select random metric at startup
def get_random_metric():
metrics = list(EXAMPLE_METRICS.keys())
return set_example_metric(random.choice(metrics))
with gr.Blocks(theme="default", css=CSS_STYLES) as demo:
gr.Markdown(MAIN_TITLE)
gr.Markdown(HOW_IT_WORKS)
with gr.Tabs():
with gr.TabItem("Judge Arena"):
with gr.Row():
with gr.Column():
gr.Markdown(BATTLE_RULES)
gr.Markdown(EVAL_DESCRIPTION)
# Add Example Metrics Section
with gr.Accordion("Evaluator Prompt Templates", open=False):
with gr.Row():
custom_btn = gr.Button("Custom", variant="secondary")
hallucination_btn = gr.Button("Hallucination")
precision_btn = gr.Button("Precision")
recall_btn = gr.Button("Recall")
coherence_btn = gr.Button("Logical coherence")
faithfulness_btn = gr.Button("Faithfulness")
# Eval Prompt and Variables side by side
with gr.Row():
# Left column - Eval Prompt
with gr.Column(scale=1):
eval_prompt = gr.TextArea(
label="Evaluator Prompt",
lines=1,
value=DEFAULT_EVAL_PROMPT,
placeholder="Type your eval prompt here... denote variables in {{curly brackets}} to be populated on the right.",
show_label=True,
)
# Right column - Variable Mapping
with gr.Column(scale=1):
gr.Markdown("### Sample to test the evaluator")
# Create inputs for up to 5 variables, with first two visible by default
variable_rows = []
for i in range(5):
initial_visibility = True if i < 2 else False
with gr.Group(visible=initial_visibility) as var_row:
# Set default labels for the first two inputs
default_label = (
"input" if i == 0 else "response" if i == 1 else ""
)
var_input = gr.Textbox(
container=True,
label=default_label, # Add default label here
)
variable_rows.append((var_row, var_input))
# Send button
with gr.Row(elem_classes="send-button-row"):
send_btn = gr.Button(
value="Test the evaluators", variant="primary", size="lg", scale=1
)
# Add divider heading for model outputs
gr.Markdown(VOTING_HEADER)
# Model Responses side-by-side
with gr.Row():
with gr.Column():
gr.Markdown("### Model A")
score_a = gr.Textbox(label="Score", interactive=False)
critique_a = gr.TextArea(label="Critique", lines=8, interactive=False)
model_name_a = gr.Markdown("*Model: Unknown*")
with gr.Column():
gr.Markdown("### Model B")
score_b = gr.Textbox(label="Score", interactive=False)
critique_b = gr.TextArea(label="Critique", lines=8, interactive=False)
model_name_b = gr.Markdown("*Model: Unknown*")
# Initially hide vote buttons and regenerate button
with gr.Row(visible=False) as action_buttons_row:
vote_a = gr.Button("Choose A", variant="primary")
vote_tie = gr.Button("Tie", variant="secondary")
vote_b = gr.Button("Choose B", variant="primary")
regenerate_button = gr.Button(
"Regenerate with different models", variant="secondary", visible=False
)
# Add spacing and acknowledgements at the bottom
gr.Markdown(ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS)
with gr.TabItem("Leaderboard"):
stats_display = gr.Markdown()
leaderboard_table = gr.Dataframe(
headers=["Model", "ELO", "95% CI", "Matches", "Organization", "License"],
datatype=["str", "number", "str", "number", "str", "str", "str"],
)
with gr.TabItem("Policy"):
gr.Markdown(POLICY_CONTENT)
# Define state variables for model tracking
model_a_state = gr.State()
model_b_state = gr.State()
final_prompt_state = gr.State()
# Update variable inputs based on the eval prompt
def update_variables(eval_prompt):
variables = parse_variables(eval_prompt)
updates = []
for i in range(len(variable_rows)):
var_row, var_input = variable_rows[i]
if i < len(variables):
var_name = variables[i]
# Set the number of lines based on the variable name
if var_name == "response":
lines = 4 # Adjust this number as needed
else:
lines = 1 # Default to single line for other variables
updates.extend(
[
gr.update(visible=True), # Show the variable row
gr.update(
label=var_name, visible=True, lines=lines
), # Update label and lines
]
)
else:
updates.extend(
[
gr.update(visible=False), # Hide the variable row
gr.update(value="", visible=False), # Clear value when hidden
]
)
return updates
eval_prompt.change(
fn=update_variables,
inputs=eval_prompt,
outputs=[item for sublist in variable_rows for item in sublist],
)
# Regenerate button functionality
regenerate_button.click(
fn=regenerate_prompt,
inputs=[model_a_state, model_b_state, eval_prompt]
+ [var_input for _, var_input in variable_rows],
outputs=[
score_a,
critique_a,
score_b,
critique_b,
action_buttons_row,
model_name_a,
model_name_b,
model_a_state,
model_b_state,
],
)
# Update model names after responses are generated
def update_model_names(model_a, model_b):
return gr.update(value=f"*Model: {model_a}*"), gr.update(
value=f"*Model: {model_b}*"
)
# Store the last submitted prompt and variables for comparison
last_submission = gr.State({})
# Update the vote button click handlers
vote_a.click(
fn=vote,
inputs=[
gr.State("A"), # Choice
model_a_state,
model_b_state,
final_prompt_state,
score_a,
critique_a,
score_b,
critique_b,
],
outputs=[
action_buttons_row,
model_name_a,
model_name_b,
send_btn,
regenerate_button,
],
)
vote_b.click(
fn=vote,
inputs=[
gr.State("B"), # Choice
model_a_state,
model_b_state,
final_prompt_state,
score_a,
critique_a,
score_b,
critique_b,
],
outputs=[
action_buttons_row,
model_name_a,
model_name_b,
send_btn,
regenerate_button,
],
)
vote_tie.click(
fn=vote,
inputs=[
gr.State("Tie"), # Choice
model_a_state,
model_b_state,
final_prompt_state,
score_a,
critique_a,
score_b,
critique_b,
],
outputs=[
action_buttons_row,
model_name_a,
model_name_b,
send_btn,
regenerate_button,
],
)
# Update the send button handler to store the submitted inputs
def submit_and_store(prompt, *variables):
# Create a copy of the current submission
current_submission = {"prompt": prompt, "variables": variables}
# Get the responses
(
response_a,
response_b,
buttons_visible,
regen_visible,
model_a,
model_b,
final_prompt,
) = submit_prompt(prompt, *variables)
# Parse the responses
score_a, critique_a = parse_model_response(response_a)
score_b, critique_b = parse_model_response(response_b)
# Update the last_submission state with the current values
last_submission.value = current_submission
return (
score_a,
critique_a,
score_b,
critique_b,
buttons_visible,
gr.update(
visible=True, interactive=True
), # Show and enable regenerate button
model_a,
model_b,
final_prompt, # Add final_prompt to state
gr.update(value="*Model: Unknown*"),
gr.update(value="*Model: Unknown*"),
)
send_btn.click(
fn=submit_and_store,
inputs=[eval_prompt] + [var_input for _, var_input in variable_rows],
outputs=[
score_a,
critique_a,
score_b,
critique_b,
action_buttons_row,
regenerate_button,
model_a_state,
model_b_state,
final_prompt_state, # Add final_prompt_state to outputs
model_name_a,
model_name_b,
],
)
# Update the input change handlers to also disable regenerate button
def handle_input_changes(prompt, *variables):
"""Enable send button and manage regenerate button based on input changes"""
last_inputs = last_submission.value
current_inputs = {"prompt": prompt, "variables": variables}
inputs_changed = last_inputs != current_inputs
return [
gr.update(interactive=True), # send button always enabled
gr.update(
interactive=not inputs_changed
), # regenerate button disabled if inputs changed
]
# Update the change handlers for prompt and variables
eval_prompt.change(
fn=handle_input_changes,
inputs=[eval_prompt] + [var_input for _, var_input in variable_rows],
outputs=[send_btn, regenerate_button],
)
for _, var_input in variable_rows:
var_input.change(
fn=handle_input_changes,
inputs=[eval_prompt] + [var_input for _, var_input in variable_rows],
outputs=[send_btn, regenerate_button],
)
# Update the leaderboard
def refresh_leaderboard():
"""Refresh the leaderboard data and stats."""
leaderboard = get_leaderboard()
data = [
[
entry["Model"],
float(entry["ELO Score"]),
entry["95% CI"],
entry["# Votes"],
entry["Organization"],
entry["License"],
]
for entry in leaderboard
]
stats = get_leaderboard_stats()
return [gr.update(value=data), gr.update(value=stats)]
# Add the load event at the very end, just before demo.launch()
demo.load(
fn=refresh_leaderboard, inputs=None, outputs=[leaderboard_table, stats_display]
)
# Add click handlers for metric buttons
outputs_list = [eval_prompt] + [var_input for _, var_input in variable_rows]
custom_btn.click(fn=lambda: set_example_metric("Custom"), outputs=outputs_list)
hallucination_btn.click(
fn=lambda: set_example_metric("Hallucination"), outputs=outputs_list
)
precision_btn.click(fn=lambda: set_example_metric("Precision"), outputs=outputs_list)
recall_btn.click(fn=lambda: set_example_metric("Recall"), outputs=outputs_list)
coherence_btn.click(
fn=lambda: set_example_metric("Logical_Coherence"), outputs=outputs_list
)
faithfulness_btn.click(
fn=lambda: set_example_metric("Faithfulness"), outputs=outputs_list
)
# Set default metric at startup
demo.load(
fn=lambda: set_example_metric("Custom"),
outputs=[eval_prompt] + [var_input for _, var_input in variable_rows],
)
if __name__ == "__main__":
demo.launch()