Question: why toby flenderson is the scranton strangler?
Answer: Here's what the video says. The video opens with a throwback to Toby's time on the Scranton Strangler case. During the series, it's revealed that the Strangler who was tried, George Howard Skub, was convicted. Toby, however, seems to think Skub was really innocent after he was on the jury that locked him up for good.