Paper:
Implicit Bias of Gradient Descent on Linear Convolutional Networks
We show that gradient descent on full width linear convolutional networks of depth L converges to a linear predictor related to the 2/L bridge penalty in the frequency domain. This is in contrast to fully connected linear networks, where regardless of depth, gradient descent converges to the 2 maximum margin solution.

Review:
The paper considers the problem of formalizing the implicit bias of gradient descent on fully connected linear/convolutional networks with an exponential loss. Building on the recent work by Soudry et al. which considered a one layer neural network with no activation the paper generalizes the analysis to networks with greater depth (with no activations) and the exponential loss. The two main networks considered by the authors and the corresponding results are as follows.  Linear Fully Connected Networks - In this setting the authors show that gradient descent in the limit converges to a predictor which in direction is the max margin predictor. This behaviour is the same as what was established in the earlier paper of Soudry et al for one layer neural networks. In particular the paper shows that depth has no effect in this setting on the implicit bias of gradient descent.   Convolutional Network - The paper further considers the case of convolutional networks and works in the model where every layer has the same width as the input and the convolutional filter has width equal to that of the layer. Note that they work with the one dimensional convolutional filter. For this model the authors show that the solution converges in direction to a critical point of the problem - minimize the 2/L norm of the fourier coefficients of the predictor given the predictor classifies perfectly. In particular this says that as the depth of the network increases the classifier learned is encouraged to be sparse in the fourier domain.   Characterizing implicit bias of gradient descent has attracted a lot of recent attention as it seems to be the source for the auto regularization effect observed in neural net training. While the work of Soudry et al was the first step in this direction, this paper makes the above two very interesting generalizations of that work. In particular the characterization obtained for linear convolutional networks is illuminating and could be of great significance breeding further research.   The paper achieves the result by first showing that for any network which implements a homogenous polynomial in terms of its parameters, we have that the solution converges in direction to a perfect classifier with the smallest l_2 norm. Note that this result is in the parameter space. The two results then follow by understanding the minimum l2 norm solution in terms of the predictor it corresponds to. The interesting thing here is that if the network is assumed to be diagonal then the depth plays a role in the implicit bias. The result for convolutional case follows by noting that colvolutional networks correspond to diagonal networks in the setup considered by the authors.   The paper is well written (modulo a couple of typos), considers an interesting problem and provides an illuminating result. The discussion section of the paper is strong with multiple future directions. I think the paper would be a great addition to the program.    Typos - I believe there are typos in the definition of fourier coefficients (line 52 and line 140)  and the definition of the convolution line 70.