Paper:
Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2018 TRAINING AND INFERENCE WITH INTEGERS IN DEEP NEURAL NETWORKS
Researches on deep neural networks with discrete parameters and their deployment in embedded systems have been active and promising topics. Although previous works have successfully reduced precision in inference, transferring both training and inference processes to low-bitwidth integers has not been demonstrated simultaneously. In this work, we develop a new method termed as "WAGE" to discretize both training and inference, where weights (W), activations (A), gradients (G) and errors (E) among layers are shifted and linearly constrained to low-bitwidth integers. To perform pure discrete dataflow for fixed-point devices, we further replace batch normalization by a constant scaling layer and simplify other components that are arduous for integer implementation. Improved accuracies can be obtained on multiple datasets, which indicates that WAGE somehow acts as a type of regularization. Empirically, we demonstrate the potential to deploy training in hardware systems such as integer-based deep learning accelerators and neuromorphic chips with comparable accuracy and higher energy efficiency, which is crucial to future AI applications in variable scenarios with transfer and continual learning demands.

Review:
The authors describe a method called WAGE, which quantize all operands and operators in a neural network, specifically, the weights (W), activations (A), gradients (G), and errors (E) . The idea is using quantizers with clipping (denoted in the paper with Q(x,k)) and some additional operators like shift (denoted with shift(x)) and stochastic rounding. The main motivation of the authors in this work is to reduce the number of bits for representation in a network for all the WAGE operations and operands which influences the power consumption and silicon area in hardware implementations.
After introducing the idea and related work, the authors in Section 3 give details about how to perform the quantization. They introduce the additional operators needed for training in such network. Since quantization may loss some information, the authors need to quantize the signals in the network around the dynamic range in order not to "kill" the signal. The authors describe how to do that. Afterward, as in other techniques for quantization, they describe how to initialize the network values. Also, they argue that batch normalization in this network is replaced with the shift-quantize operations, and what is matter in this case is (1) the relative values (“orientations”) and not the absolute values and (2) small values in errors are negligible.
Afterward, the authors conduct experiments on MNIST, SVHN, CIFAR10, and ILSVRC12 datasets, where they show promising results compared to the errors provided by previous works. The WAGE parameters (i.e., the quantized no. of bits used) are 2-8-8-8, respectively. For understand more the WAGE, the authors compare on CIFAR10 the test error rate with vanilla CNN and show is small loss in using their network. The authors investigate mainly the bitwidth of errors and gradients.
In overall, this paper is an accept since it shows good performance on standard problems and invent some nice tricks to implement NN in hardware, for *both* training and inference. For inference only, other works has more to offer but this is a promising technique for learning. The things that are still missing in this work are some power reduction estimates as well as area reduction estimations. This will give the hardware community a clear vision of how such methods may be implemented both in data centers as well as on end portable devices.