Paper:
Tree-to-tree Neural Networks for Program Translation
Program translation is an important tool to migrate legacy code in one language into an ecosystem built in a different language. In this work, we are the first to employ deep neural networks toward tackling this problem. We observe that program translation is a modular procedure, in which a sub-tree of the source tree is translated into the corresponding target sub-tree at each step. To capture this intuition, we design a tree-to-tree neural network to translate a source tree into a target one. Meanwhile, we develop an attention mechanism for the tree-to-tree model, so that when the decoder expands one non-terminal in the target tree, the attention mechanism locates the corresponding sub-tree in the source tree to guide the expansion of the decoder. We evaluate the program translation capability of our tree-to-tree model against several state-of-the-art approaches. Compared against other neural translation models, we observe that our approach is consistently better than the baselines with a margin of up to 15 points. Further, our approach can improve the previous state-of-the-art program translation approaches by a margin of 20 points on the translation of real-world projects.

Review:
Summary  This paper proposes a neural network architecture for tree to tree transduction, with application to program translation. Binarized trees are encoded with a TreeLSTM, and a tree-structured decoder generates binary trees breadth-first, using an attention mechanism over input tree nodes, and attention feeding within the tree decoder. On synthetic and real-world program translation tasks, and across multiple datasets, the proposed model obtains substantially stronger performance than baseline sequential neural models and previous work on automatic program translation.    Quality  The paper proposes a general framework for neural tree to tree transduction, and the model obtains high performance on program translation tasks.       Clarity  The model and experimental setup are define clearly.   If the terminal and non-terminal vocabularies are disjoint, is it necessary to generate end-of-sentence tokens explicitly, as they should always follow terminals?   Originality  Previous neural network architectures have been proposed for code generation (as cited in the paper), but have not been applied to program translation. The novelty of the proposed model lies in having both a tree-structured encoder and decoder. The proposed decoder generates trees breadth-first rather than depth-first, as it typical in many other architectures.   To show whether the tree decoder architecture proposed here has advantages over previously proposed tree decoders, experimental comparison with alternative architectures will be helpful.      Significance  Tree to tree transduction is an important problem, and this paper is the first to propose successful neural models that explicitly models the tree structure in both the input and output. It is further shown that the model obtains a strong improvement over previous models in the practical task of program translation. While there is still a lot of work to do done in this area, this paper makes a strong contribution and I would like to see it accepted.