Paper:
Large-Scale Stochastic Sampling from the Probability Simplex
Stochastic gradient Markov chain Monte Carlo (SGMCMC) has become a popular method for scalable Bayesian inference. These methods are based on sampling a discrete-time approximation to a continuous time process, such as the Langevin diffusion. When applied to distributions defined on a constrained space the timediscretization error can dominate when we are near the boundary of the space. We demonstrate that because of this, current SGMCMC methods for the simplex struggle with sparse simplex spaces; when many of the components are close to zero. Unfortunately, many popular large-scale Bayesian models, such as network or topic models, require inference on sparse simplex spaces. To avoid the biases caused by this discretization error, we propose the stochastic Cox-Ingersoll-Ross process (SCIR), which removes all discretization error and we prove that samples from the SCIR process are asymptotically unbiased. We discuss how this idea can be extended to target other constrained spaces. Use of the SCIR process within a SGMCMC algorithm is shown to give substantially better performance for a topic model and a Dirichlet process mixture model than existing SGMCMC approaches.
contain simplex parameters. For example, latent Dirichlet allocation (LDA) is defined by a set of topic-specific distributions on words and document-specific distributions on topics. Probabilistic network models often define a link probability between nodes. More generally, mixture and mixed membership models have simplex-constrained mixture weights; even the hidden Markov model can be cast in this framework with simplex-constrained transition distributions. As models become large-scale, these vectors ω often become sparse-i.e., many ω j are close to zero-pushing them to the boundaries of the simplex. All the models mentioned have this tendency. For example in network data, nodes often have relatively few links compared to the size of the network, e.g., the number of friends the average social network user has will be small compared with the size of the whole social network. In these cases the problem of sampling from the simplex space becomes even harder; since many values will be very close to the boundary of the space. Patterson and Teh (2013) develop an improved SGMCMC method for sampling from the probability simplex: stochastic gradient Riemannian Langevin dynamics (SGRLD). The improvements achieved are through an astute transformation of the simplex parameters, as well as developing a Riemannian (see Girolami and Calderhead, 2011) variant of SGMCMC. This method achieved state-of-the-art results on an LDA model. However, we show that despite the improvements over standard SGMCMC, the discretization error of SGRLD still causes problems on the simplex. In particular, it leads to asymptotic biases which dominate at the boundary of the space and causes significant inaccuracy.
To counteract this, we design an SGMCMC method based on the Cox-Ingersoll-Ross (CIR) process. The resulting process, which we refer to as the stochastic CIR process (SCIR), has no discretization error. This process can be used to simulate from gamma random variables directly, which can then be moved into the simplex space using a well known transformation. The CIR process has a lot of nice properties. One is that the transition equation is known exactly, which is what allows us to simulate from the process without discretization error. We are also able to characterize important theoretical properties of the SCIR algorithm, such as the non-asymptotic moment generating function, and thus its mean and variance. We discuss how these ideas can be used to simulate efficiently from other constrained spaces, such as (0, ∞).
We demonstrate the impact of this SCIR method on a broad class of models. Included in these experiments is the development of a scalable sampler for Dirichlet processes, based on the slice sampler of Walker (2007); Papaspiliopoulos (2008); Kalli et al. (2011). To our knowledge the application of SGMCMC methods to Bayesian nonparametric models has not been explored. All proofs in this article are relegated to the Supplementary Material. All code for the experiments is available online 1 , and full details of hyperparameter and tuning constant choices has been detailed in the Supplementary Material.
1 Stochastic Gradient MCMC on the Probability Simplex

Review:
For the valuable problem of large-scale and sparse stochastic inference on simplex, the authors proposed a novel Stochastic gradient Markov chain Monte Carlo (SGMCMC) method, which is based on the Cox-Ingersoll-Ross (CIR) process. Compared with the commonly-used Langevin diffusion within the SGMCMC community, the CIR process (i) is closely related to the flexible Gamma distribution, and therefore more suitable for inferring a Dirichlet distribution on simplex, since a Dirichlet distribution is just the normalization of Gamma distributions; (ii) CIR has no discretization error, which is shown to be a clear advantage over the Langevin diffusion on simplex inference.  Besides, the author proved that the proposed SCIR method is asymptotically unbiased, and has improved performance over other SGMCMC method on sparse simplex problem via two experiments, namely inferring a LDA on a dataset of scraped Wikipedia documents and inferring a Bayesian nonparametric mixture model on Microsoft user dataset.  I think the quality is good; the presentation is clear; as far as I know the proposed technique is original and of great significance. Therefore I vote for acceptance. However, the experiments are okay, but not strong. More experiments would be better.   I have read the authors' response, I would suggest additional experiments, such as exploiting the presented SCIR for more complicated non-conjugate models like the PGBN [1]; (2) to make a direct comparison with the TLASGR-MCMC developed in [2], which is also developed for inference on simplex and is shown better than the SGRLD. Other potential reference methods include the ones in [3,4].   [1] The Poisson gamma belief network. NIPS 2015. [2] Deep latent Dirichlet allocation with topic-layer-adaptive stochastic gradient Riemannian MCMC. ICML 2017. [3] "A Complete Recipe for Stochastic Gradient MCMC. NIPS 2015" [4] "Stochastic gradient geodesic MCMC methods. NIPS 2016"