Paper:
Batch Normalization (BatchNorm) is an extremely useful component of modern neural network architectures, enabling optimization using higher learning rates and achieving faster convergence. In this paper, we use mean-field theory to analytically quantify the impact of BatchNorm on the geometry of the loss landscape for multi-layer networks consisting of fully-connected and convolutional layers. We show that it has a flattening effect on the loss landscape, as quantified by the maximum eigenvalue of the Fisher Information Matrix. These findings are then used to justify the use of larger learning rates for networks that use BatchNorm, and we provide quantitative characterization of the maximal allowable learning rate to ensure convergence. Experiments support our theoretically predicted maximum learning rate, and furthermore suggest that networks with smaller values of the BatchNorm parameter γ achieve lower loss after the same number of epochs of training.

Review:
Interesting application of MFT on FIM to understand Batch Normalization
This paper applies mean field analysis to networks with batch normalization layers. Analyzing maximum eigenvalue of the Fisher Information Matrix, the authors provide theoretical evidence of allowing higher learning rates and faster convergence of networks with batch normalization. 
The analysis reduces to providing lower bound for maximum eigenvalue of FIM using mean-field approximation. Authors provide lower bound of the maximum eigenvalue in the case of fully-connected and convolutional networks with batch normalization layers. Lastly authors observe empirical correlation between smaller \gamma and lower test loss. 
Pro: 
 - Clear result providing theoretical ground for commonly observed effects. 
 - Experiments are simple but illustrative. It is quite surprising how well the maximum learning rate prediction matches with actual training performance curve. 
	
Con:
 - While mean field analysis a-priori works in the limit where networks width goes to infinity for fixed dataset size, the analysis of Fisher and Batch normalization need asymptotic limit of dataset size. 
 - Although some interesting results are provided. The content could be expanded further for conference submission. The prediction on maximum learning rate is interesting and the concrete result from mean field analysis
 - While correlation between batch norm \gamma parameter and test loss is also interesting, the provided theory does not seem to provide good intuition about the phenomenon. 
Comments:
- The theory provides the means to compute lower bound of maximum eigenvalue of FIM using mean-field theory. In Figure 1, is \bar \lambda_{max} computed using the theory or empirically computed on the actual network? It would be nice to make this clear. 
- In Figure 2, the observed \eta_*/2 of dark bands in heatmap is interesting. While most of networks without Batch Norm, performance is maximized using learning rates very close to maximal value, often networks using batch norm the learning rate with maximal performance is not the maximal one and it would be interesting to provide theoretical 
- I feel like section 3.2 should cite Xiao et al (2018). Although this paper is cited in the intro, the mean field analysis of convolutional layers was first worked out in this paper and should be credited.