Paper:
In this paper, we study the problem of constrained robust (min-max) optimization in a black-box setting, where the desired optimizer cannot access the gradients of the objective function but may query its values. We present a principled optimization framework, integrating a zeroth-order (ZO) gradient estimator with an alternating projected stochastic gradient descent-ascent method, where the former only requires a small number of function queries and the later needs just one-step descent/ascent update. We show that the proposed framework, referred to as ZO-Min-Max, has a sub-linear convergence rate under mild conditions and scales gracefully with problem size. From an application side, we explore a promising connection between black-box min-max optimization and black-box evasion and poisoning attacks in adversarial machine learning (ML). Our empirical evaluations on these use cases demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach and its scalability to dimensions that prohibit using recent black-box solvers.

Review:
The paper presents an algorithm for performing min-max optimisation without gradients and analyses its convergence. The algorithm is evaluated for the min-max problems that arise in the context of adversarial attacks. The presented algorithm is a natural application of a zeroth-order gradient estimator and the authors also prove that the algorithm has a sublinear convergence rate (in a specific sense). 
Considering that the algorithm merely applies the zeroth-order gradient estimator to min-max problems, the algorithm itself only makes up a somewhat novel contribution. However, to the best of my knowledge, it has not been used in this context before and personally I find the algorithm quite appealing. In fact, due to its simplicity it is essentially something that anyone could implement from scratch. 
Perhaps a more important contribution is that the authors provide a fairly extensive convergence analysis, which is an important tool in analysing the algorithm and its properties. Unfortunately, it is not trivial to understand the presented convergence results and their practical implications (if any). For instance, equation (10), which is arguably one of the key equations in the paper, contains variables zeta, nu and P1, all of which depend on a number of other variables in a fairly complicated manner. The expression in (10) also contains terms that do not depend on T and it is not obvious how large these terms might be in practice (in the event that the assumptions are at least approximately true in a local region). Even though I am somewhat sceptical to the practical relevance of this convergence analysis, I recognise that it is an interesting and fascinating achievement that the authors have managed to provide a convergence analysis of an algorithm which is based on black-box min-max optimisation.