Paper:
To extract and relate visual and linguistic concepts from images and textual descriptions for text-based zero-shot learning (ZSL), we develop variational heteroencoder (VHE) that decodes text via a deep probabilisitic topic model, the variational posterior of whose local latent variables is encoded from an image via a Weibull distribution based inference network. To further improve VHE and add an image generator, we propose VHE randomized generative adversarial net (VHE-GAN) that exploits the synergy between VHE and GAN through their shared latent space. After training with a hybrid stochastic-gradient MCMC/variational inference/stochastic gradient descent inference algorithm, VHEGAN can be used in a variety of settings, such as text generation/retrieval conditioning on an image, image generation/retrieval conditioning on a document/image, and generation of text-image pairs. The efficacy of VHEGAN is demonstrated quantitatively with experiments on both conventional and generalized ZSL tasks, and qualitatively on (conditional) image and/or text generation/retrieval.

Review:
Paper Summary: This paper studies the zero-shot learning problem with deep generative models. More specifically, it proposed a hybrid framework that combines VAEs (more precisely, the variational hetero-encoder or VHE) and GANs all together. The entire model is composed of an image encoder (Weibull upward-downward variational encoder), a text decoder (Poisson Gamma belief network), and an image generator (generative adversarial network). Once learned, the generative models can be directly used for zero-shot classification and various image generation applications. In the experiments, two benchmark datasets CUB and Oxford-Flowers are used.
==
Novelty/Significance:
Zero-shot learning is a challenging task and he main motivation of the paper (using generative model) is interesting. The text representation in the paper is simply bag-of-words which limits the application to some extent. In a broader context, image captioning using generative model seems quite relevant.
Diverse and Accurate Image Description Using a Variational Auto-Encoder with an Additive Gaussian Encoding Space, Wang et al. In NIPS 2017.
==
Quality:
Overall, reviewer feels this is a very interesting work. However, the results from the paper is quite mixed. It is not yet convincing whether the proposed approach is the state-of-the-art in zero-shot learning or text-to-image generation. 
First, this paper demonstrates the power of generative models in text-to-image generation and other applications. However, reviewer feels that the zero-shot classification result is weak. In Table 1 and Table 2, it seems that GAZSL (Zhu et al. 2018) outperforms the proposed approach. 
Q1: In Table 2, is it possible to report the top-5 accuracy on CUB-easy and top-1 accuracy on Oxford-Flower dataset? Otherwise, it is not very convincing that proposed approach is better than the state-of-the-art approach GAZSL.
Second, the text-to-image generation results look reasonably good. But the resolution and quality of generated images are far from state-of-the-art. One suggestion is to train the VHE model with an improved image generator.
StackGAN: Text to Photo-realistic Image Synthesis with Stacked Generative Adversarial Networks, Zhang et al. In CVPR 2017.
AttnGAN: Fine-Grained Text to Image Generation with Attentional Generative Adversarial Networks, Xu et al. In CVPR 2018.
Also, reviewer would expect to see an improved image generator can lead to a better ZSL performance.
Typo: In the title: Zero-Short → Zero-Shot.