Talk:List of manhwa

message: This article is a bit of a train wreck at the moment, due to its unclear purpose.  It is more than a list of Korean comics licensed in English, as it contains titles like Blade of the Phantom Master.  As a list of English licenses, it fails.  As a list of all Korean comics ever, it does and will forever fail.  /The latter purpose can be better addressed using lists of titles handled by individual publishers and magazines, I think.  I propose this list be for Korean comic titles officially licensed in English.  That makes it both useful and encyclopedic.  The official English language title will be used, which should match the name of an existing or future article.  Revision of this list is a good time to see if alternative title redirects are in place.
The creator names also need to be revised, as few are listed in accordance with Wikipedia's Korean naming conventions.  They are to be Lastname First-name, and I can't think of any Korean comic artists that are famous enough to qualify for an exception to this.  English-language comic publishers are inconsistent, even for a single author, with regard to name order, hyphens, and capitalization, but are quite consistent with name spelling.  Thus I propose names be spelled as they are in English publications, and structured per WP:NC-KO.  Revised Romanization, which is not fully applied to names, can be listed after the hangul in parentheses to substitute for what would be handled by Template:Infobox Korean name (which we don't use).  If individual names are confusing, let's talk about it! :)  
Please comment, question, throw rotten fruit as long as it's not too smelly.  Then let's figure out how to whip this list into shape! :) --hamu♥hamu (TALK) 18:44, 11 July 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: You may be interested in having a look at the animanga project's solution to this problem: List of licensed manga in English (although personally, I hate the name). —Dinoguy1000 18:59, 11 July 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: Great example!  That list has been an influence -- well organized, clear purpose.  We'll have to decide whether authors should be retained or not.  There's pros and cons either way. --hamu♥hamu (TALK) 22:38, 11 July 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: I agree with using only licensed manhwa. The ones on the list would be the ones that really need articles because people can actually find them in book stores and there will be more reception. Authors names don't necessarily have to be kept because they can be easily accessed in the article. However a series without an article will be left standing by itself; though that creates a need to make a page for it. WhiteArcticWolf (talk) 14:19, 13 July 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: Hmm, if we don't need authors, then we don't need Korean names, either, like in the manga list.  (Those will be on the to-do list, since both are vital to creating an article).  My reasoning was since most of the list will be redlinks, both are needed to help readers know what series is being talked about.  "Rainbow" just doesn't mean muchm BUT I wholeheartedly agree with not unduly repeating info in multiple locations, though!!  In theory, even for series with no articles, author and Korean name will be in the publisher/magazine articles (see List of series run in Comic Champ as an example).  If we omit everything but the title, then how to format so it doesn't look even worse than now?  Maybe, name of American licensor and date (year?) of licensing should be there?  Those would be directly relevant to the article?  Funny how making a list is actually complicated! :) --hamu♥hamu (TALK) 17:16, 13 July 2008 (UTC)
thread_title:  Cleanup and standardization 

message: The following were removed when the article was defined to focus on just titles licensed in English.  I couldn't find licensing info for these, but I certainly could have missed it, so if you have the licensor's name, feel free to add a title back in.
*2x8 Song - Shin Ji-sang
*36 Degrees Rebellion - Lee Eun
*Adventure and Trouble Diary (Spectacular Diary) - by Kang Eun-young
*Aflame Inferno - Lim Dall-young (story) and Kim Kwang-hyun (art)
*Anuki  - Yamesi (story),Lee Ji-gun (art) - 
*Ares - Ryu Kum-chel
*Banhonsa (The Spirit Returner) - Kim Tae-yong
*Ba-thump Ba-thump Diary - Kim Mi-jung
*BibiChoi Kyung-ah
*Blade of the Phantom Master - by Youn In-wan (story) and Yang Kyung-il (art)
*Boarding House with Good Water
*Cash Girl - Kim Su-yeon
*A Cat that Loved a Fish - Yoon Mi-kyung
*Chat - Han Yu-rang
*Check - Lee So-young
*Cheon Gi dot com - Yu Ha-jin
*Ciel - Rhim Ju-yeon
*The Closer - Yu Si-jin
*Come Back Home - Chun Kye-young
*Couple - Park Jae-sung (story),Park Sung-jae (art)
*Cream - Lee Eun-young
*Cutie Boy - Hwang Mi-ri
*Dark Striker - Park Sung-woo
*Death Song - Kim Eum-jeong
*Deep Kiss - Hwang Mi-ri
*Déjà-vu - Youn In-wan (story), Yang Kyung-il, Yoon Seung-ki, Kim Tae-hung, Park Sung-woo (art)
*The Descendant of the Dynasty - Hwang Mi-ri
*Die or Like Me - Hwang Mi-ri
*Ear - Kim Young-oh
*Excel - Yoon Ji-un
*The Fairy and the Hunter - Kim Mi-jung
*Feel So Good - Lee Shi-young
*The Flower of Evil - Lee Hyung-sook
*For the Mermaid Princess - Lee Mi-ra
*Four Daughters of Armian - [Shin Il-sook
*F.O.X - Os Rabbit Cat and A-Bao
*Gal Chae (Applause)
*Goodbye, My 19 Year Old Self - Kim Mi-jung
*H2O - Hwang Sook-ji
*Hair-Tail Fish and Mackerel - Jin Kyo-ung
*Hanami: International Love - Plus (story), Park Sung-jee (art)
*Happy & Murphy - Ko Min-jung
*Heaven
*High School (Bal Jak) - Kim Young-oh
*Honggane - Hwang Mi-ri
*Hoosamguk Gokyo - Hwang Mi-ri
*Hot Blooded Woman - Hwang Mi-ri
*Hug Me - Hwang Mi-ri
*Hush - Yoon Ji-un
*HWA - Lee Young-hee
*Hyeomillyu - Yang Byeong-seol
*Hyeomillyu - Kim Sung-mo
*I Want You - Woon Soo-yeon
*I Wish - Suh Hyun-ju
*Ice Zoo's
*Id - Kim Dae-woo (story), Kenny A.T. (art)
*Imitation Love - Hwang Mi-ri
*It's Going to be a Wonderful Night - by Lee Myung-jin
*It's Love - Park Sung-eun
*Jungmok - Kari (story), Lee Sung-gyu (art)
*The Kidnapping of Minja Jo's Boyfriend - Lee Sang-eun
*Kumiho - Han Hyun-dong
*Legend of Nereid - Hwang Mi-ri
*Love Comic - Suhl Jae-ja
*Love SOS - Hwang Mi-ri
*Love Virus - Ryu Ri-ang
*Lover Discovery - Lee Sang-eun
*Mana - Vin Lee
*Mémoires du Masque - Kim Jung-han
*Metal Heart - Yoon Jae-ho
*The Moment When a Fox Becomes a Wolf - Hwang Mi-ri
*My Girl - Baek Jung-won
*Nephilim - Ryu Kum-chel
*New Romeo and Juliet - Lee Mi-ra
*Nina Jalhae - Jo Oon-hak
*Normal City - Kang Kyung-ok
*One+One - Yoon Jae-ho
*Pahanjip - Yoon Ji-un
*Park Hee-jung's Collection of Short Stories
*Pastel Green Spell - Lee Young-you
*Phalene - Jin Kyo-ung
*Pink Lady - Yeon Woo
*P.K.-Player Kill - Lee Jong-kyu (story), and Park Chul-ho (art)
*The Poet Who Buys Words - Uhm Jung-hyun
*Pretty - Ha Shi-hyun
*Pure Love 360°
*Really?! - Lee Hyung-sook
*Real Purple - Park So-hee
*Red Lion - Kim Young-sun
*Replay - Ryu Ri-ang
*Sad Love Song - Shin Ji-sang (story), Geo (art)
*Safe Again Today - Yoo Jin-su (story), Park Suh-lah (art)
*Secret
*The Sexy Simpleton - Hwang Mi-ri
*The New Sexy Simpleton - Hwang Mi-ri
*The Shadow of Moon - Lee Hyung-sook
*Shi, Hwa, Mong - Lee Jong-eun
*Shipwrecked! - Jung Hye-na
*Shooting Star - Jung Hyun-sook (story), Lee Young-you (art)
*A Silent Greeting - Kim Young-hee
*Sin - Kim Jae-hwan
*Sour & Sweet - Kim Yoon-jung
*Start Love - Hwang Mi-ri
*Step - Han Seung-hui
*Sugar Addiction - Yang-Ah (story), Maria (art)
*Super Boyfriend - Chung Yi-won
*Sweety Gem - Park Eun-ha
*Syndrome - Guiyeoni
*Terror - Jin Kyo-ung
*Their Daily Life - Seo Hyun-ju
*They, Too, Love - Seomoon Da-mi
*Triangle - Shin Ji-sang
*Trouble G - Kim Su-yeon
*Unplugged Boy - Chon Kye-young
*Utopia of Homosexuality - Lee Sang-eun
*Vanilla Ice - Kim Woo-hyun
*Vitamin - Yeo Ho-kyoung
*WA! - Yu Ha-jin
*Want You -  Hwang Mi-ri
*The Way This Boy Lives - Seomoon Da-mi
*We Are Still...!! - Lee Jee
*Witch Hunter - Cho Jung-man
*Yaya (야야) - Kang Eun-young
*Youth - various
*Zero: Circle of Flow (제로 - 흐름의 원) - Lim Dall-young (story), Roh Sang-yong (art)
*Zombie Hunter (좀비헌터) - Kazumasa Hirai (story), Yang Kyung-il (art)
--hamu♥hamu (TALK) 12:32, 19 July 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: Question: Where should be the right place for the entries since they are removed from this article? --Caspian blue (talk) 12:59, 19 July 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: I actually don't know.  It's just not possible to have a "list of all manhwa in the world".  :)  I'm working on articles for publishers and magazines, and am including relevant titles, but it's going slowly.  Titles can also be included on authors' articles (of which there are few).  I'm kind of the only one actually doing this, so everything just happens really, really slowly.  Do you have ideas?  --hamu♥hamu (TALK) 13:08, 19 July 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: I'm so sorry that I've deferred all manhwa related tasks to your shoulder. This is actually a big project. According to several Japanese people's allegation, I love Korea so much, so I've been busy dealing with them. :) I think this article only holding translated works into English is renamed as the aforementioned one, List of licensed manhwa in English or something. All works with licensed on non-licensed works are listed on just "list of manhwa. How do you think? --Caspian blue (talk) 13:27, 19 July 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: Oh don't apologize! I know you work hard on a lot of Korea-related articles. :)  This article does need to be renamed, yeah.  As for having a list of manhwa, with no restrictions, I don't really think it's possible.  There's just too many.  We have a list of manhwa licensed in English, lists of manhwa serialized in various magazines, etc.  A list has to have a greater focus than just "list of manhwa".  Eventually, all of the titles above will probably wind up on some publisher's list of titles, it just takes a long time.  I've been on Daiwon's site, trying to write articles about their magazines with a full list of titles from each.  Given that I don't read Korean, this takes a really long time, LOL!  If you are familiar with any of the above titles, you can add notes as to their original Korean title in hangul, what magazine they were in, stuff like that.  That helps get them sorted out for the future.  :) --hamu♥hamu (TALK) 19:07, 19 July 2008 (UTC)

text: I would implement such info as possible as I can. --Caspian blue (talk) 11:43, 21 July 2008 (UTC)
thread_title:  Non-licensed titles 

message: Hello fellow Wikipedians,
I have just modified  on List of manhwa. Please take a moment to review my edit. If you have any questions, or need the bot to ignore the links, or the page altogether, please visit this simple FaQ for additional information. I made the following changes:
*Corrected formatting/usage for http://www.mania.com/deja-vu-vol-01-spring-summer-fall-winter_article_83740.html
When you have finished reviewing my changes, please set the checked parameter below to true or failed to let others know (documentation at ).
Cheers.—cyberbot IITalk to my owner:Online 04:14, 3 May 2016 (UTC)
thread_title:  External links modified