Talk:Nationalities and regions of Spain

message: I believe the article has improved a lot with the recent edits by AjaxSmack, Mountolive and myself. I think the section of "Café para todos" could be improved a little more, though it is a challenge to do it without being redundant with "autonomous communities of Spain" (especially the section on "Devolution of Power"), since I believe this article was meant to be more of an explanation of what "nationalities and regions" are in the context of Spanish politics. Probably a clearer explantion is needed of "chartered" vs "common regime" communities. The asymmetrical devolution of power makes this task challenging, since the attributions granted to "common regime" communities vary as well. Thanks to all for participating. --the Dúnadan 23:36, 8 September 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: So what is this effect on Spanish Law?  Drawing a line on a map is one thing, is that all this does?98.165.16.149 (talk) 02:10, 27 August 2011 (UTC)
thread_title: Improved article

message: I'm against a merge of this page with Nationalisms and regionalisms of Spain, as the subject of both pages is distinctly different: this page deals with the political status of the nationalities, while the other page deals with the ideologies behind those nationalities. --Jotamar (talk) 14:27, 14 July 2010 (UTC)
replies: text: I don't agree, it is not the same thing :) 178.109.128.110 (talk) 20:22, 26 March 2011 (UTC)
thread_title:  Merge proposal 

message: For example the reference 12 is only a powerpoint made by a professor and I would like to know when and where he was thought that idea of the spanish reunification made by a union of a lot of entities (some of which he duplicates: the kingdom of Leon is the kingdom of Asturias with only a different Capital.Galicia, Leon and Castille were the same entity but they were often splitted and reunificated due to dinasties intrigue).Thenn we should talk about the survey and that concept of "dual identity" since most spanish people knows nothing about it's own history reaching ridicolous limits like believe that the spanish lenguage was imposed when it has been widely proved that most people adopted it. Another fatalist error is call the bable or the aragonese a lenguage both are spanish dialects caused mostly by vulgarisms aislationism of that regions and lack of education in that region. I have to point that catalan and galician were Latin dialects not spanish dialects but they were dialects too since a language derived of other by vulgarism and etc is not a language until it gets its own regulations "normativization". The fact is that the historical reality of Spain is widely missunderstood since most nationalism gained strength during the francoism because they oppossed the dictatorship not because of people convictions and due to political corruption a lot of lies have been spreading faster than the truth reaching a point where my galician books say things like spain was a kind of monarchy federation and the castilian books not talking nothing about it.Also the lies of the independent institutions is reaching too far only navarre and Aragon had it's own institutions and laws nominated as "fueros". If you want to know more about "catalanism" you should contact with Javier Barraycoa a sociology professor from Barcelona he knows that Catalonia has it's own particularities but it has never been and shouldn't be a nation.
And before everyone starts atacking my position I must warn: I am internationalist so I not believe in the national concept so I am not an spanish nationalist neither someone with hide interests in attack the nationalists. I'm only someone who lives in a random zone of this beauty planet and because of living here I've learn a lot about it's history but it's full of lies thanks to political interests wich is really sad since I think history should universally be based on the truth. I apologize if my english has some mistakes.  — Preceding unsigned comment added by Inforev IV (talk • contribs) 16:10, 23 September 2012 (UTC)
thread_title:  Some sources are inaccurate.