Talk:Shasu

message: So far as I've heard, "Shasu" was a general term used by the Egyptians for the nomads of Sinai, Transjordan, and Palestine.  Do we know what language they spoke? (Was it a Canaanite language, like the later peoples of those areas?)  A connection with the Israelites (who spoke a Canaanite language) has been suggested; would that also suggest a connection with the Edomites, Moabites, Kenites, and Midianites, who were their cultural and linguistic relatives?  In short, how much data do we actually have on the Shasu?
--Rob117 05:27, 2 September 2005 (UTC)
thread_title:  Do we know anything else about the Shasu? 

message: There was an uprising of an alleged 200,000 Shasu attackers and their allies along the border of Egypt and Sinai mentioned on inscriptions from Karnak. Seti I routed them into Canaan, along with his son Ramesses II c. 1300 to 1290 bc.
This group likely included Apiru and Shasu who worhsiped "Ywh" and later settled into Edom (Midian), and the Arabah, their original homeland. Later on some of these Shasu and Apiru settled into the Canaanite highlands and formed an ethnic identity of 'Israel' in the hills of Judah.
about 80 or 90 years after this massive war between the Shasu and Seti/Ramesses, we have Merenptah batteling the people of Israel in the higlands of Judah c. 1210.
The fact that Apiru and Shasu were slaves of War in Egypt's captivity c. 1500-1200 seems to suggest there is at least a historical plausibility behind the stories of "Hebrews" and nomads in bondage in Egypt. Indeed, if the Apiru(Habiru), included the hebrews of the bible, then we do have some nuggets of historical likeliness.--207.225.65.89 05:42, 10 April 2006 (UTC)
thread_title:  Exodus of Shasu. 

message: There was an uprising of an alleged 200,000 Shasu attckers and their allies along the border of Egypt and Sinai mentioned on inscriptions from Karnak. Seti I routed them into Canaan, along with his son Ramesses II c. 1300 to 1290 bc.
It was 20,000 not 200,000. Its supposed to be a group of Habiru and Shasu. Later, Egypt will use the term Shasu to anything that comes from the East. Just like Habiru, Shasu is more a generic term for the eastern groups.
This group likely included Apiru nd Shasu who worhsiped "Ywh" and later settled into Edom (Midian), and the Arabah, their original homeland. Later on some of these Shasu and Apiru settled into the Canaanite highlands and formed an ethnic identity of 'Israel' in the hills of Judah.
Midian is in Northwest Arabia, there are archeological proofs that Midian was only inhabited from 1300 to 1100 BCE. This corroborates the bible story (first when Moshe lived with Jethro and second when he led the Hebrews to Mt Sinai).
Moreover, Redford's idea about the origin of Biblical YHWH with a group called "Yhw in the land of Shasu" is pure speculation. The Shasu might well be the Biblical Sinaite Susim (speculation again !). Yhw could be a chief, an Egyptian toponym, or a further ethnonym. We don't know if the Shasu worshipped only one god (this is very unlikely for a nomadic tribe). There is no evidence of Shasu people settling in Judea before Merenptha.
--Squallgreg 18:38, 10 June 2006 (UTC)
thread_title:  Reply to above comment about Shasu 

message: To reiterate my edit summary, I removed the Rainey quote saying "I'm not sure why this was put here as it is covered earlier, and using better sources than BAR". It was inappropriately placed, and although BAR meets our criteria as a reliable source, any scholar of the ANE knows that there are much more reliable sources and that BAR isn't exactly without an agenda. The new edit using Rainey is much better as it is placed in the correct context and has a bit more detail. The edit summary saying "To reject a relevant source is a violation of NPOV. The Amarna letters are not mentioned elsewhere" misrepresents my reason for removing Rainey originally. And there can be good reasons to reject a relevant source that do not fall foul of our guidance on NPOV, but that isn't what's happened here anyway. dougweller (talk) 20:01, 22 February 2009 (UTC)
thread_title:  Rainey 

message: I'm working on this again but not at home where I have better access to sources. I may have been to hasty in using the reference I just did, as I see the author is a geologist and reading further I'm very dubious about her qualifications to make the claims she does. There are some sources from the early 70s, eg Lipinski, but I prefer to use later sources. EG this pdf , Thompson's Early history of the Israelite people 
. amd Ancient Ammon . Dougweller (talk) 10:13, 2 August 2009 (UTC)
thread_title: Current edits

message: Found this snippet: The History of Ancient Palestine from the Palaeolithic ... - Page 277 https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=hMVtAAAAMAAJ   Gösta Werner Ahlström, ‎Gary Orin Rollefson, ‎Diana Vikander Edelman - 1993 - ‎Snippet view - ‎
Gösta Werner Ahlström, Gary Orin Rollefson, Diana Vikander Edelman ... "when several new settlements were built.6 Thus, these Shasu, together with everybody else who lived in the hills, later became what is known as Israelites." But we can't use snippets. Doug Weller talk 13:36, 7 April 2016 (UTC)
thread_title:  Ahlström 

message: Has anyone checked those hieroglyphs for accuracy? Temerarius (talk) 22:44, 15 December 2023 (UTC)
thread_title:  Shasu hieroglyphs