Talk:List of Muslim soldiers

message: Why on earth is this article nominated for deletion...its baseless...guys keep up the good job in the article
mujeerkhan 23.15, 17 june 2006 (UTC)
Good article? Um, no... "Tikka Khan- Lt Gen Tikka Khan Hero of 1965 War ( Pakistan )
Noor Khan Air Marshel Noor Khan Lagend Even Praised By Israeli Air Marshel for his ability
Sajjad Haider Commodor Sajjad Haider Holds world record for eliminating severalindian fighter Jets in Seconds in 1965 indo pak war
Muhammad Mahmood Alam Hold world record for destroying most fighter planes in a single flight in 1965 war
Hassan Nasrallah - Commander in Chief Hizbollah, Army of God (Lebenon). Victorious Muslim General of the 21st century.
Muammar al-Gaddafi
Bashar Al-Assad
Osama bin Laden(former CIA agent, comes from wealthy oil rich family from KSA.
Muhammad Mullah Omar(The Rightly Guided Caliph of modern times regarded by so called mujahideens, mostly wahabis following religion of abdul wahab and like to call themselves Muslims, when they are not. . )" It's like a Muslim version of Oliver North's show "War Stories" :/  —Preceding unsigned comment added by 76.102.118.104 (talk) 11:21, 3 January 2009 (UTC)
thread_title:  [[Mujahdeen]] and [[Muslim soldiers]] 

message: One of the things that was mentioned in the AFD was the difference between a muslim soldier and a mujahid.  It might be useful to go into more detail about that and what qualifies someone to be on this list.  For example, would James Yee go on it?  Also, it might make more sense for the century subheadings to be given as 500s or 6th Century rather than 500 and other specific years.  I'd do it myself, but wanted to see what other people thought.  The opening also mentions "Some of the older entries may be more accurately be described as warriors, and some as militia."  It might be useful to go into more about what that means, as I can't really tell. Шизомби 22:38, 15 April 2006 (UTC)
thread_title: Definition of list

message: The first sentence of this page can be applied to any fighter warrior irregardless if there Muslim or not.....And by the way.......If you scroll down it lists Osama Bin Laden lol. 71.119.255.31 01:20, 19 May 2007 (UTC)
thread_title:  The first sentence shows why this page is strange 

message: It's plain simple. Just delete. This is silly. List of Muslim soldiers?
Hear me. In my country, Indonesia, 80% of its populations are Muslims. Indonesian military have 400.000 soldiers. So we should list approximately 80% of them each other. And we should include other Muslim countries, or soldiers from non-Muslim country who are Muslims. So if this article is really SERIOUS, there will be approx. 4 millions or so names here. AND IT'S SILLY.
And we could create pages with similar themes. List of Muslim lawyers, list of Muslim engineers, list of Muslim-whatever-common-job-type. And List of Christian soldiers (there will be approx. 10 millions or more), List of Christian lawyers, etc. AND IT's SILLY.
It doesn't match the criteria of notability at all.
You should remember WHAT WIKIPEDIA IS, and WHAT WIKIPEDIA IS NOT.
In Harmonia Progressio! (talk) 16:34, 19 October 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: Okay, I propose to change the name of this article to List of Muslim military leader. And it will need a major wikifying so it'll be more encyclopedic.In Harmonia Progressio! (talk) 16:38, 19 October 2008 (UTC)
thread_title:  Delete!