Talk:Roxbury, Boston

message: Roxburgh?  IP Address 13:17, 11 May 2006 (UTC)
replies: text: Given the history of the name given in this article, I don't think that place in Scotland is related. -- Beland (talk) 19:49, 11 August 2018 (UTC)
thread_title: Name

message: Was Roxbury really a "city" when it was annexed to Boston? Or should it be moved from being the only entry in :Category:Defunct cities in Massachusetts to join others in :Category:Defunct towns in Massachusetts? Lupinelawyer 18:54, 8 November 2006 (UTC)
replies: text: <a href="http://www.discoverroxbury.org/TheHistoryofRoxbury/tabid/54/Default.aspx">This page</a>, linked in the article, says Roxbury inc'd as a city in 1846. Incidentally, <a href="http://www.charlestownbusiness.com/history.html">this site</a> says Charlestown (also now a neighborhood of Boston) incorporated as a city in 1847, which would seem to suggest that it should be in this category, not in Defunct Towns (I don't have documentary evidence for either of these two claims, so I won't make the change). Still, I'm not sure we need a category with only two entries; why not put all disincorporated cities and towns in "Category: Defunct municipalities in Massachusetts" instead? Wiki Wistah 04:12, 1 December 2006 (UTC)
replies: text: 1846 Roxbury incorporated as a city. A manual for the use of the General Court By Massachusetts. 1900 p.148-96.237.8.174 (talk) 18:51, 3 November 2010 (UTC)
thread_title:  Which defunct category? 

message: This page needs a reference to John Eliot. The Eliot church still stands - at least it was there the last time I drove through - and he was a very important figure in the colonial era. He ministered to native Americans and African-Americans, and gave land for the Eliot school in what is now Jamaica Plain.
And yes, Roxbury was in independent city before annexation. 
MarkinBoston 18:24, 15 July 2007 (UTC)
thread_title:  Rev. John Eliot 

message: I removed some citation requests from the text. The statements referenced are not controversial. Any map of colonial Boston shows that Roxbury was at the mainland connnection to Boston. I'll try to put a few more references into the article when I get a chance MarkinBoston 20:10, 12 August 2007 (UTC)
replies: text: I likewise removed citation request for the section on notable residents.  I've cleaned them up.  Most of those that remain have Wiki-pages that make clear the subject's connection to Roxbury.  In other cases there is an explanatory note and/or an external link to a reliable source.  Some question the value of these "notable residents" listings, but this one is fairly reliable and serves a purpose. Finn Froding (talk) 15:56, 29 August 2010 (UTC)
thread_title:  Citation requests 

message: I'm not sure of where to put this comment as it applies to the Wikipedia entry on Roxbury and its boundaries.  I believe that to say that the South End and the Boston & Albany RR Yards (which the Prudential Center replaced) were historically in Roxbury is incorrect.  Also, I don't remember the yards ever being called the "Roxbury" yards.  Whitehill's Topographic History puts the South End-Roxbury border at about Lenox Street which is south of Mass Ave, thus putting the South End and Back Bay proper within Boston.  Whitehill wasn't right about everything but this seems definitive.  However, the Fens and surrounding Fenway neighborhood, Longwood Med area, Mission/Parker Hill, Northeastern Univ area, maybe even Kenmore Square, are all at least historically within Roxbury.  —Preceding unsigned comment added by 146.96.23.183 (talk) 15:02, 20 October 2009 (UTC)
thread_title: Boundaries

message: A manual for the use of the General Court By Massachusetts. 1900
p.148 NORFOLK COUNTY
ROXBURY
Date of Establishment Sept. 28, 1630 Common land.
From what Established or Incorporated, Change of Boundary...
Common land. Mar. 4, 1633 bounds between Roxbury and Boston
established. April 7, 1635 bounds between Roxbury and Newe 
Towne established. May 25,1636 certain lands granted to Roxbury. 
May 2, 1638 certain lands granted to Roxbury. May 16,1638 bounds 
between Roxbury and Dedham established. Oct. 7, 1641 bounds 
between Roxbury and Boston established. Oct. 16, 1660 certain 
lands granted to Roxbury. May 12,1675 bounds between Roxbury 
and Dedham established. Mar. 16,1836 bounds between Roxbury
and Boston established. April 19 1837 bounds between Roxbury
and Boston established. April 23, 1838 part of Newton annexed.
Feb. 24, 1844 part annexed to Brookline. Mar. 12, 1846 Roxbury 
incorporated as a city. Mar. 25, 1846 act of incorporation accepted
by the town. May 3, 1850 part annexed to Boston and bounds be-
tween Roxbury and Boston established. May 24,1851 part estab- 
lished as West Roxbury. April 3, 1860 part annexed to Boston and 
bounds established if the act is accepted by both cities. April 16,
1860 the act accepted by Roxbury. May 8, 1860 the act accepted
by Boston. June 1, 1867 Roxbury annexed to Boston if this act is 
accepted by both cities. Sept. 9 1867 the act accepted by both.
Jan. 5, 1868 the act took effect.
-96.237.8.174 (talk) 18:53, 3 November 2010 (UTC)
thread_title:  Boundary history details 

message: The demographic percentages listed are not consistent with the cited source. Either the percentages should be changed to reflect the source or an updated source should be provided.50.176.69.106 (talk) 13:36, 23 December 2013 (UTC)
thread_title:  There is a discrepancy with the demographics 

message: There are many issues with the two separate descriptions of Roxbury's modern boundaries. While neighborhoods in Boston are rather loosely defined, some of the boundaries in this article are simply incorrect. The following sentence should be removed since it is wildly inaccurate:
"Roxbury now generally ends at Hammond St, Davenport St to the east and East Lenox St/Melnea Cass Boulevard to the south."
Hammond, Davenport, and East Lenox are in no way part of Roxbury, while Melnea Cass is often considered part of the northern boundary.
The other section is also problematic. It seems to conflate historic lines with current ones. The latter half, quoted below, appears to describe current boundaries but contains errors. The Muddy River does not border Roxbury by any standard (Jamaica Plain and Mission Hill are between the river and Roxbury) and Columbia Road is rarely used as a boundary between Roxbury and Dorchester.http://bostonography.com/2012/crowdsourced-neighborhood-boundaries-part-one-consensus/
"This side of the Muddy River is Roxbury, the other side is Brookline and Boston. Franklin Park, once entirely within Roxbury when Jamaica Plain, West Roxbury and Roslindale were villages within the town of Roxbury until 1854, has been divided with the line between Jamaica Plain and Roxbury located in the vicinity of Peter Parley Road on Walnut Avenue, through the park to Columbia Road. Here, Walnut Avenue changes its name to Sigourney Street, indicating the area is now Jamaica Plain. One side of Columbia Road is Roxbury, the other Dorchester."  — Preceding unsigned comment added by 134.174.110.7 (talk) 19:34, 10 March 2014 (UTC)
thread_title:  Current boundaries 

message: I'd like to see information on the size in acreage of the Roxbury neighborhood. MaynardClark (talk)  16:02, 21 February 2015 (UTC)
thread_title: Acreage (Size)

message: === Reasons for Change on Roxbury page ===
I changed the lead section by adding new information. I did not delete any content from the lead section, only added the information that I will be adding to the rest of the page. 
I made changes to the demographics section to single in on just the neighborhood of Roxbury. I used the Boston Redevelopment Authority to get information on demographics of just Roxbury. The previous demographics section had info for Long wood medical area as well as mission hill. I think it is important to solely focus on Roxbury on its own page. 
The wikipedia page for Roxbury did not include a community resources page. I believe this is necessary because it shows what Roxbury has to offer its residents. Someone who is looking up information on Roxbury can now better see that it is a community on the move and cares about its residents. Urban policies is another section that was not included in the previous Roxbury page. I added this to show what some of the rules for urban life in Roxbury are. Again this corresponds to the Roxbury community as well as its residents. Buildings and policies governing requirements for things such as produce are important to the well being of its residents. During my research I found out that the colleges in Roxbury do plenty for their community. I think it is important to have extensive info about these colleges as they help with Roxbury residents. I added info about the college, such as workshops provided, shows provided, educational assistance for young children, allowing them to call in with questions. It is important to highlight the important aspects of Roxbury, and with all the work the colleges do, especially Roxbury Community College, the extra information is necessary. The previous Roxbury page did not have any info relating to entertainment in Roxbury. I added this section so people who are looking up Roxbury can point to things there is actually to do in the neighborhood. Along with parks and recreation centers, there are culture centers, museums, etc. By adding this to the page, people who are searching Roxbury will not think of it as just a place with people, but also a place where there is the possibility of visiting and having some fun. Many people in Roxbury use the T as a means of transportation. I added this section because it was missing from the original page. People searching Roxbury, will now know what subway lines go to this neighborhood, as well as buses that go through the neighborhood. In my edit to the lead section, there is a direct link for more information regarding the MBTA throughout Roxbury. This is being done for coursework in the wikipedia edu. program so I would appreciate edit suggestions made to me rather than just changed, please. Wilber Reyes01 (talk) 14:13, 29 April 2015 (UTC)
thread_title:  Wilber Reyes01 Edits 

message: I changed the lead section by adding new information. I did not delete any content from the lead section, only added the information that I will be adding to the rest of the page. 
I made changes to the demographics section to single in on just the neighborhood of Roxbury. I used the Boston Redevelopment Authority to get information on demographics of just Roxbury. The previous demographics section had info for Long wood medical area as well as mission hill. I think it is important to solely focus on Roxbury on its own page. 
The wikipedia page for Roxbury did not include a community resources page. I believe this is necessary because it shows what Roxbury has to offer its residents. Someone who is looking up information on Roxbury can now better see that it is a community on the move and cares about its residents. Urban policies is another section that was not included in the previous Roxbury page. I added this to show what some of the rules for urban life in Roxbury are. Again this corresponds to the Roxbury community as well as its residents. Buildings and policies governing requirements for things such as produce are important to the well being of its residents. During my research I found out that the colleges in Roxbury do plenty for their community. I think it is important to have extensive info about these colleges as they help with Roxbury residents. I added info about the college, such as workshops provided, shows provided, educational assistance for young children, allowing them to call in with questions. It is important to highlight the important aspects of Roxbury, and with all the work the colleges do, especially Roxbury Community College, the extra information is necessary. The previous Roxbury page did not have any info relating to entertainment in Roxbury. I added this section so people who are looking up Roxbury can point to things there is actually to do in the neighborhood. Along with parks and recreation centers, there are culture centers, museums, etc. By adding this to the page, people who are searching Roxbury will not think of it as just a place with people, but also a place where there is the possibility of visiting and having some fun. Many people in Roxbury use the T as a means of transportation. I added this section because it was missing from the original page. People searching Roxbury, will now know what subway lines go to this neighborhood, as well as buses that go through the neighborhood. In my edit to the lead section, there is a direct link for more information regarding the MBTA throughout Roxbury. This is being done for coursework in the wikipedia edu. program so I would appreciate edit suggestions made to me rather than just changed, please. Wilber Reyes01 (talk) 14:13, 29 April 2015 (UTC)
thread_title:  Reasons for Change on Roxbury page 

message: I have added more information about Recreation centers that people can go to for after school and somewhere to hang out. There is a section on Housing that people should know about different kind of housing that people can look into. There is also a section on Education. I have added more elementary schools and why they were created.
(Stephanie.lewis58 (talk))  —Preceding undated comment added 17:02, 27 April 2016 (UTC)
thread_title: Corrections on Roxbury page

message: Hello, I have decided to make some changes in this article in order for researchers to get a better knowledge of the organizations and services available in Roxbury, Boston. In order to be more in tune and interested in the article, I felt the need to create subheadings under the community resource section. For major nonprofit organizations I was able to add more specifics in finding, accessing, and understanding the organizations and its motives. As a made these adjustments, I needed to rearrange the order of the paragraphs just a bit. In addition, I added sections concerning the Boston Police Department because I feel that they deserve more that just a few sentences. They are very involved in the community needs and strengths. They do their best to ensure individualized program rather than just generalized attention. They target safety concerns, the youth generations, violence, civic engagement, and they protect the overall sanitation of the city. This is being done for coursework in the Wikipedia Edu Program so I would really appreciate edit suggestions made to me rather than just changed. Thank you. (S0270290 (talk) 18:51, 27 April 2016 (UTC)
thread_title: Editing Explanations

message: The demographics section has conflicting crime rate statistics, I've pasted the section below.  Italics are my own
The crime rate is 39% higher than the national average, meaning 1 out of 25 people will become a victim.[38] The annual crime rate has gone down by 4% in 2016.[38] The median income is $34,374 and the unemployment rate is 10.7%, which is more than double the national average.[39] Male median earnings are 41% higher than female median earnings.[39] Roxbury test scores in public schools are 38% lower than the national average.[36] 1/4 of the Roxbury population was born in another country.[40] 42% of the population is 25 years old or younger.[41] Meanwhile, only 11% of the population are over the age of 65.[41] 40% of the population drive to work, 36% take public transportation, 10% of the population walk to work, 10% bike to work, and 4% work from home.[41] Roxbury's crime rate is 7% higher than the national average for 2016.[42]  — Preceding unsigned comment added by 128.42.239.201 (talk) 23:16, 7 March 2017 (UTC)
thread_title:  Crime Rate? 

message: Hello fellow Wikipedians,
I have just modified 3 external links on Roxbury, Boston. Please take a moment to review my edit. If you have any questions, or need the bot to ignore the links, or the page altogether, please visit this simple FaQ for additional information. I made the following changes:
*Added archive https://web.archive.org/web/20150404003257/http://www.dsni.org/history to http://www.dsni.org/history
*Added archive https://web.archive.org/web/20100613005143/http://bostonpublicschools.org/node/288/ to http://bostonpublicschools.org/node/288/
*Added archive https://web.archive.org/web/20081015172933/http://www.discoverroxbury.org/ to http://www.discoverroxbury.org/
When you have finished reviewing my changes, you may follow the instructions on the template below to fix any issues with the URLs.
Cheers.—InternetArchiveBot (Report bug) 20:47, 9 December 2017 (UTC)
thread_title:  External links modified 

message: This article could use some maps showing the original boundaries, the separation of West Roxbury, and the modern boundary as a neighborhood minus other neighborhoods that used to be part of Roxbury the city. -- Beland (talk) 19:53, 11 August 2018 (UTC)
thread_title:  Maps