Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Chess/Review

message: In Wikipedia:Peer review they say we should put an appropriate tag on the Talk page of the article currently being peer-reviewed. Do you think it would be appropriate for our informal reviews to follow this step ? SyG 06:57, 4 August 2007 (UTC)
thread_title: Peer review

message: The minimum duration of the review process is currently defined as 5 days. Given the limited (but growing!) number of participants in our chess project, it seems a bit short to me and I would like to suggest to increase it. What do you think ?SyG 09:10, 4 August 2007 (UTC)
thread_title: Close the review process

message: Have today reviewed all existing B-Class articles, a total of 128. Have viewed and read them briefly(not to a deep level) including checking each talk page and made notes on obvious weak points. Here is a summary of the brief reviews.ChessCreator (talk) 01:04, 7 March 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: THAT is really impressive. Good work! SyG (talk) 20:14, 7 March 2008 (UTC)
thread_title:  Review of B-Class articles 

message: B quality documents. These all have some problem or weakness which suggests in it's current state it's not worth taking further.
19th Chess Olympiad	B		Lead			
36th Chess Olympiad	B		Lead	,	No photo	
37th Chess Olympiad	B		Lead			
Adolf Anderssen	B		Citations			
Advanced Chess	B		Citation?	,	No photo	
Alan Kotok	B		More detail in some areas			
Aleister Crowley	B		Relevance to chess			
Alexei Shirov	B		Citations	,	Bit missing/short sections	
Babson task	B		Citations			
Bishop (chess)	B		Citations			
Bobby Fischer	B		Controversial	,	Citations	
Boris Spassky	B		Citations			
Carl Schlechter	B		Bit missing/short sections	,	Citations	
Chebyshev distance	B		Bit missing/short sections			
Check (chess)	B		citations	,	Bit missing/short sections	
Chess World Cup 2007	B		No photo			
Chess endgame	B		Reference method References are good			
Chess piece	B		Citations Citations OK			
Chess problem	B		Citations			
Chess960	B		Citations			
China national chess team results	B		Lead	,	To big	
Computer chess	B		Citations			
Correspondence chess	B		Citations			
Corresponding squares	B		Citations Citations are good			
David Bronstein	B		Citations			
Deep Blue - Kasparov, 1996, Game 1	B		Citations			
Dunsany's chess	B		Bit missing/short sections			
Emil Sutovsky	B		No photo	,	Citations	
FIDE World Chess Championship 2004	B		Citations			
Fairy chess piece	B		Citations	,	Layout	
Fortress (chess)	B		Citations Citations are good			
Grand Chess	B		Citations			
Göttingen manuscript	B		No photo	,	Bit missing/short sections	
Halosar Trap	B		Lead	,	Bit missing/short sections	
Harriet Hunt	B		Citations			
Harry Golombek	B		Bit missing/short sections			
Herman Steiner	B		No photo	,	Citations	
Hou Yifan	B		Bit missing/short sections			
Howard Staunton	B		Citations			
Igor Vasilyevich Ivanov	B		Lead	,	Citations	
Immortal game	B		Citations	,	Bit missing/short sections	
Isaac Lipnitsky	B		Citations	,	No photo	
Johann Berger	B		Bit missing/short sections			
Johann Nepomuk Mälzel	B		Citations			
John L. Watson	B		Bit missing/short sections			
John W. Collins	B		Bit missing/short sections	,	Citations	
Joke chess problem	B		Citations	,	Bit missing/short sections	
Kaissa	B		Citations			
Kevin Spraggett	B		Citations			
Kira Zvorykina	B		No photo	,	Citations	
Kiril Georgiev	B		Bit missing/short sections	,	Citations	
Leonid Kubbel	B		Bit missing/short sections			
Lev Aronin	B		No photo	,	Citations	
Libro de los juegos	B		Bit missing/short sections			
List of chess openings	B		Bit missing/short sections	,	Citations	
List of chess terms	B		Citations			
List of chess topics	B		List	,	Bit missing/short sections	
List of chess world championship matches	B		List	,	Bit missing/short sections	
List of mathematicians who studied chess	B		List	,	Bit missing/short sections	
List of people who have beaten Bobby Fischer in chess	B		List	,	Citations	
List of strong chess tournaments	B		List	,	Citations	
Los Alamos chess	B		Bit missing/short sections			
Mac Hack	B		Bit missing/short sections			
Magical objects in Harry Potter	B		Citations	,	To Big	
Marcel Duchamp	B		Bit missing/short sections			
Mikhail Chigorin	B		Citations			
Mikhail Gurevich (chess player)	B		Bit missing/short sections			
Mutilated chessboard problem	B		Bit missing/short sections			
Nigel Short	B		Citations			
Nimzo-Indian Defence	B		Citations			
Norwegian Chess Championship	B		No photo			
Pascal Charbonneau	B		No photo	,	Citations	
Queen versus pawn endgame	B		Layout	,	Citations Citations are good, Layout OK	
Rashid Nezhmetdinov	B		No photo	,	Citations	
Robert Hübner	B		Bit missing/short sections	,	Citations	
Rook and pawn versus rook endgame	B		Citations Citations are good			
Round-robin tournament	B		Citations			
Seirawan chess	B		Bit missing/short sections			
Semyon Furman	B		No photo	,	Citations	
Shatranj	B		Citations			
Shogi	B		Citations			
Sicilian Defence	B		Bit missing/short sections			
Smothered mate	B		Layout			
Stalemate	B		Layout	,	Citations Citations are good	
Staunton chess set	B		Citations			
Tassilo von Heydebrand und der Lasa	B		Bit missing/short sections			
Taxicab geometry	B		Bit missing/short sections	,	Citations	
Thomas Bowdler	B		Citations			
Viacheslav Ragozin	B		Citations	,	Bit missing/short sections	
Vladimir Nabokov	B		Citations	,	Bit missing/short sections	
Wilhelm Steinitz	B		Bit missing/short sections			
William Ewart Napier	B		Citations			
World Chess Championship 1963	B		No photo			
World Chess Championship 1972	B		Citations			
World Chess Live	B		Citations			
World Chess Network	B		Citations			
Xiangqi	B		Bit missing/short sections	,	Citations	
Xie Jun	B		No photo	,	Bit missing/short sections	
Zillions of Games	B		Citations			
Zugzwang	B		Layout	,	Citations Citations are good	ChessCreator (talk) 01:04, 7 March 2008 (UTC)
thread_title:  Quick review as B 

message: Possibly not worthy of it's B class status.
Alexander Konstantinopolsky		No photo,	Citations	
Alexander Kotov		Citations,	Bit missing/short sections	
Dunst Opening		Bit missing/short sections,	Citations	
Elephant Trap		Citations,	Bit missing/short sections	
ChessCreator (talk) 01:04, 7 March 2008 (UTC)
thread_title:  Quick review as B- 

message: (The following was moved from Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Chess/FAQ/Assessment to merge discussion about reviews into one place ChessCreator (talk) 14:53, 20 March 2008 (UTC)
thread_title: Endgame tablebase

message: I tried to add rules of chess on the main review page, using the format of the other nominated article, but it didn't work correctly.  Can someone fix it or tell me how to fix it? Bubba73 (talk), 00:13, 28 August 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: Yeah, the nomination process is messy at the moment, I have to understand how to simplify it. Anyway, I have sorted things out now. SyG (talk) 17:42, 31 August 2008 (UTC)
thread_title:  Tried to add [[rules of chess]]