Talk:Vladimir Tretchikoff

message: I have provided sources for the articles. Capitalistroadster 19:30, 26 August 2006 (UTC)
thread_title: References

message: "Although Tretchikoff was now seen as one of South Africa's most prominent living artists, he has never gained the recognition that he deserved as a master of realism."
seems a bit NPOV, and also self contradictory (was he seen as the most prominent artist, or did he not gain deserved recognition).  If noone objects, I'll try to fix it up. -- dcole 00:38, 29 August 2006 (UTC)
replies: text: You beat me to it.  Please go ahead!  I'm sure there is something objective to be said along these lines.  The BBC obituary mentioned the same thing.  It says "But Tretchikoff had a number of critics in the art world, who dismissed his work as 'art for those who hate art.'"  If we could find who said that, that would be a good first step. -Dmh 16:25, 29 August 2006 (UTC)

text: Although Tretchikoff was seen as one of South Africa's most prominent living artists, he never gained the recognition that he deserved as a master of realism.  He was never taken seriously by art critics in South Africa, as, because of the reproductions done of his work, he was seen as too much of a commercial artist and it is only lately that his work has become more and more sought after and has escalated in price at auction houses such as Sotheby's South Africa.
So, he was prominent but unrecognised.  He was seen as too commercial, but his work has only recently become commercially popular.  There is room for more about Tretchikoff and a sensible appraisal of his importance and style - I'll ransack the newspaper obituaries later today.  --ajn (talk) 08:47, 30 August 2006 (UTC)
thread_title: NPOV

message: Hello,
my name is Yolanda pacheco and I have a print signed by v.Tretchikoff two times, the print was signed in 1953 by him at an art show. does anyone have any information regarding this beautiful and breath taking print? Dying Swan, I notice he has two dying swans, You can contact me at 408-448-1514 It is so beautiful and to be signed by him is wonderful, he seems like such a beautiful man.  —Preceding unsigned comment added by 67.164.40.186 (talk) 02:20, 20 July 2008 (UTC)
thread_title:  Dying Swan 

message: Someone added a section to the entry titled "Controversy regarding 'Lost Orchid' at Brett Kebble auction" which reads "Toward the end of July 2009, auctioneer Graham Britz told a newspaper tests revealed the so-called Lost Orchid painting signed as Tretchikoff was not the original painting as indicated in their brochure. Britz stated it might be another painting called the Last dance, surmising it was painted by Tretchikoff himself. The sale of the painting in question has been suspended."Nowhere does the editor list a source for these claims, nor does the claim of authenticity (or its lack) seem relevant to an entry on Tretchikoff, the artist. After all, if the WP entry on say, Picasso or Dali included every question about the authenticity of their work, there would be hundreds, if not thousands of such examples listed. Furthermore, to make a claim as to a work of art being a forgery is potentially defamatory, since it casts aspersions upon the credibility of the consignor and/or the auction house. If anyone (1) has a primary source to cite and (2) can demonstrate why it is relevant to the entry, feel free to revert. Otherwise, it has no place in an encyclopedia like WP. Bricology (talk) 02:45, 10 May 2011 (UTC)
thread_title:  Removal of unsourced, possibly defamatory claim 

message: Why is he being quoted as part of the legacy of Tretchikoff? He's has no background as an artist or as an art critic. He is a man who's integrity has been questioned by many, and putting that aside, his field of 'expertise' does not overlap with the arts, so having him quoted is incongruous. It would be likewise inappropriate to put every television personalities quoted opinion of Van Gogh on the Van Gogh page. I propose it be removed. Vynbos (talk) 14:34, 29 April 2013 (UTC)
thread_title:  Uri Geller