Category talk:Coast of British Columbia

message: Created April 8, 2007, in accordance with geographic article on same region and consultation with Wikiproject BC Editors. Further category subdivision to follow. --Keefer4 | Talk 09:56, 8 April 2007 (UTC)
thread_title: Opening

message: Most of the fjord/sound/inlet articles contained here also are in the :Category:Fjords of British Columbia. Originally I had placed the entire :Category:Fjords of British Columbia into this 'Coast' cat, but reconsidered, because fjords should stand on their own as a geographical feature of he province, rather than being slotted in a sub-cat of :Category:Geographic regions of British Columbia, which this is. Therefore, the categories are not redundant, but as needed (and providing they're not freshwater fjords that are in the Kootenays, for example) fjords fall into each cat on their own merit..--Keefer4 | Talk 10:41, 8 April 2007 (UTC)
replies: text: And whatever the term, such a freshater cat would be a subcat both of :Category:Fjords of British Columbia and :Category:Lakes of British Columbia.Skookum1 00:38, 9 April 2007 (UTC)
replies: text: Also recommend :Category:Hydroelectric reservoirs in British Columbia as a subcat of :Category:Lake in British Columbia; Williston, Ootsa, Stave, Seton, Carpenter, Clowhom, Buntzen, Alouette, Arrow, Duncan....needless to say it's a huge list and a major cat; some kind of designation for those that were natural lakes before might be good, but tricky to label (Stave, Seton and Arrow all existed before inundation, for example).  I'd imagine that whatever :Category:Dams in British Columbia is or woudl be a subcat of :Category:Hydroelectric developments in Canada (??) or whatever; :Category:Dams in Canada exists, but I don't think we've pared away :Category:Dams in British Columbia, which as noted, again, shoudl be parallel to reservoirs as sharing a parent cat with the Dams cat.Skookum1 00:42, 9 April 2007 (UTC)
thread_title: Fjords cat vs coast cat

message: I just created the Central Coast of British Columbia category and sorted various items in the Coast cat properly.  Upcoming will be :Category:South Coast of British Columbia, where the :Category:Lower Mainland and :Category:Sunshine Coast and :Category:Sea to Sky Country will all be subcats, plus once-created :Category:Southern Vancouver Island and :Category:West Coast of Vancouver Island; the other VI subcat will be :Category:Northern Vancouver Island ("North Island" is what we usually say, but "North Vancouver Island" doesn't sound right, although the government tourism ministry's branding consultants are trying to push that lately....), but it's a subcat of :Category:Central Coast of British Columbia.  Division points for Central Coast are Campbell River-Discovery Islands (which can be in both Central Coast and the southward cat from there...have to name that, "Mid-Island" isn't quite right, means more Nanaimo-Ladysmith-Parksville than Courtenay-Campbell River but "Southern" will do for now; thinking that :Category:Gulf of Georgia would be useful, with the Southern VI cat, Sunshine Coast and other lower-coast mainland cats (Sea to Sky, Vancouver's, Lower Mainland, Gulf Islands) fitting in well; yeah I'm gonna do it, name is worth enshrining and spans the rest of teh South Coast.....Central/North dividing line is somewhere between Bella Bella and Kitasoo; Kitasoo I've put in both North and Central Coast cats....geographic paramters are Dean Channel and southwards are Central Coast, Gardner Canal/Hartley Bay is North Coast....changes/edits to suit coming to British Columbia Coast article - which, although I created it, really shouldbe Coast of British Columbia (and there needs to be a Pacific Northwest Coast article....Skookum1 (talk) 18:42, 16 April 2008 (UTC)
thread_title: Subcat discussion/parameters