Talk:Silesia/Archive 7

message: Back to reversion war. Page is protected again. Earlier talk archived. Kosebamse 11:55, 5 Dec 2003 (UTC)

message: I think this topic holds the record for "most archives of a talk page". Isn't there any area of argeement? Please, someone just list all the disputed points. Then we can go through them one by one. I can help, if people want me to. --Uncle Ed 18:28, 24 Nov 2003 (UTC)
replies: text: (That was fast! It only took 14 days for an answer to appear to my question... ;-) --Uncle Ed 16:22, 8 Dec 2003 (UTC)
thread_title:  State of the debate (list of issues) 

message: Nico, how do you dare to erase the definitions I pasted here, and insert olny those you like? How do toy dare -- CC, 21:34, 7 Dec 2003 (UTC)
thread_title:  Silesia: other encyclopedias 

message: Silesia (Polish Śląsk, German Schlesien, Czech Slezsko) is an historical region in east-central Europe, located along the upper and middle Oder/Odra River, bounded by the Sudeten mountains to the southwest, by the Beskid range to the south, and by the Kraków-Wielun plateau to the northeast, in what is now southwestern Poland and with parts in Germany and the northeastern Czech Republic. It was originally a Polish province that became a possession of the Bohemian crown in 1335 and passed with that crown to the Austrian Habsburgs in 1526. In 1742 most of Silesia was seized by Frederick the Great of Prussia in the War of the Austrian Succession. This part of Silesia composed the Prussian provinces Upper- and Lower Silesia until 1945, when most of Silesia was annexed by Poland.
The Polish portion of Silesia, which forms the bulk of the historic region, is now divided into the voivodships of Lower Silesian Voivodship, Opole Voivodship and Silesian Voivodship. The small portion in the Czech Republic is joined with Moravia to form the Moravian-Silesian Region of that country, while the Görlitz area now is a part of the German state of Saxony. 
Differences: Introduce more geographical information, Bohemian crown, remove expulsions and some details about the (non-Polish) remainder of Silesia after 1945. Language: "belonged to Poland in the middle ages" > "originally a Polish province", removed "Ties with Poland gradually decreased" etc.
/ Nico
This is fine with me.  john 19:10, 6 Dec 2003 (UTC)
thread_title:  Improved proposal 

message: Can we have the Silesia article reverted to any non-Nico version, not necessarily to my version. Nico is mainly editing the intro paragraphs of hundreds articles adding German names there, and nothing else. He is seldom developing the articles and adding valuable information. He has his version protected now and he is not interested in making compromise, so he can keep his version forever by blocking any compromise here. -- Caius2ga 04:33, 11 Dec 2003 (UTC)
replies: text: Well, Grzes, you could accelerate the process as well by making some input here. After the start of the discussion here you and Nico decided to continue edit wars elsewhere instead of contributing to discussion on this page. I also realised, that you did not reply to any of my polite addresses, that I directed to you on various pages. So one could doubt, that either of you is interested in a compromise. Nico can not block a compromise here; if this really should be what he wants, we would make an article without him. But if noone participates in a discussion, it complicates the issue for sure. Of course complaining, accusing and reverting is much easier than cooperating. (And for clarification: This means Caius2ga and Nico.) -- Baldhur 07:44, 11 Dec 2003 (UTC)
thread_title:  Can we revert to any non-Nico version 

message: Can we have the Silesia article reverted to any non-NEONAZI version, which is protected for the last 6 weeks. -- Caius2ga 22:59, 16 Dec 2003 (UTC)
replies: text: You had the possibility of discussing your views with other users above. (Ed asked you a special question there.) You are constantly not replying to other users' questions, and now you are calling other users Nazis again. In the entire process you did not show a little bit of cooperative behaviour. All the compromise proposals made by me and others remained unanswered by you. My patience with your annoying behaviour is clearly over now. So, if you want to withdraw from the project, I will not hinder you. Obviously you did not understand, how this project works. -- Baldhur 09:01, 17 Dec 2003 (UTC)
thread_title:  Can we revert to any non-Nazi version ??