Talk:List of Byzantine scholars

message: Comment: I think the purpose of this article is unclear (which begs the question of whether it should exist). If it is nothing but an arbitrary list of names then it should be removed. If it is intended to be a list of the greatest contributors to Byzantine science then each name should be accompanied by a short description of who they were and why their contribution mattered. In other words, each article should attempt to concretely educate on a specific topic. A list of names by itself does not really fit the bill.
Frankly a lot of these names are people whom it is stretch to call "scientists". That is, although they may have been schooled in scientific concepts not all of these people actually did anything scientific (i.e. did not invent, did not educate, did not theorize; if all they did was read a couple of books then that does not make them scientists).
--Mcorazao (talk) 17:04, 8 April 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: Perhaps it would be better to rename the list to "List of Byzantine scholars", since "scientist" implies use of a scientific method, which few of them (if any) applied in their work. As pointed out, most of the persons listed created compilations of knowledge, and were, as such, excellent scholars, but did not actually discover anything new. Regards, Cplakidas (talk) 19:32, 19 April 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: That would be better. Rursus dixit. (mbork3!) 20:11, 2 May 2011 (UTC)
thread_title:  Purpose 

message: Although I tried hard to improve the article by removing some obviously irrelevant inclusions (eg Theodore Prodromos, Manuel Philes), the myriads of spelling errors and the dubious purpose of this article suggest that we should delete it. Is there someone able to start with the deletion review process ? (I am not familiar with it) --Dipa1965 (talk) 20:23, 21 February 2009 (UTC)
replies: text: I have also tried to improve it by sorting it chronologically, but when despair grips our throats, the most logical way out of it is not to delete it. It's usable, just not complete, but it will become better in time. Rursus dixit. (mbork3!) 20:11, 2 May 2011 (UTC)
thread_title:  Suggest to delete it 

message: The article should partake in filling some holes in the history of science: the time span from the antiquity (<400AD) to the islamic golden age (>700AD), and the translations from greek in the renaissance of the 12th century. 
The original source link went stale. Some inferior sources support the general image of the article, f.ex.:
* http://www.eie.gr/institutes/kne/ife/newsletter/nwsntr7.pdf
New sources are needed. I'll see what I can find. Rursus dixit. (mbork3!) 07:09, 3 May 2011 (UTC)
thread_title:  New sources 

message: Dumping the red and ambiguous links here:
==== Other ====
AMBIGUOUS:
* Hierocles - geographer
* Eustratios - meteorologist
* Theodore - taught Geometry at the University of Constantinople 
NO INFO ON:
* Chronas - mathematician
* Nikolaos Rabdas - scholar and mathematician
* Michael Balsamon - mathematician
* Manuel of Trebizond - scholar, mathematician and astronomer, student of Choniades
* Prodromos Neophytos - botanologist
* George Chrysokokkes - astronomer, geographer and mathematician 
* Manuel Bryennios - mathematician and astronomer
* Manuel Holobolos - astronomer
* George Kyprios - mathematician
* Neophytos Monachos - mathematician
* John Kamateros - mathematician
* Eleftherios Zevelinos - astronomer
* Nikephoros Patrikios - geometry University of Constantinople
* Constantine Sikelos - mathematician
* Theodigios - astronomer and mathematician University of Constantinople
* Theodore Geometres - mathematician
* Theophilos of Edessa - astronomer
* Soterichos -mathematician
* Dionysios Mikros - astronomer
* Rhetorios of Byzantium - astronomer
* Theodoghius - taught Astronomy at the University of Constantinople 
* Kometas - taught Greek Philology at the University of Constantinople
Rursus dixit. (mbork3!) 07:26, 3 May 2011 (UTC)
thread_title:  Dump of unsourced scholars 

message: AMBIGUOUS:
* Hierocles - geographer
* Eustratios - meteorologist
* Theodore - taught Geometry at the University of Constantinople 
NO INFO ON:
* Chronas - mathematician
* Nikolaos Rabdas - scholar and mathematician
* Michael Balsamon - mathematician
* Manuel of Trebizond - scholar, mathematician and astronomer, student of Choniades
* Prodromos Neophytos - botanologist
* George Chrysokokkes - astronomer, geographer and mathematician 
* Manuel Bryennios - mathematician and astronomer
* Manuel Holobolos - astronomer
* George Kyprios - mathematician
* Neophytos Monachos - mathematician
* John Kamateros - mathematician
* Eleftherios Zevelinos - astronomer
* Nikephoros Patrikios - geometry University of Constantinople
* Constantine Sikelos - mathematician
* Theodigios - astronomer and mathematician University of Constantinople
* Theodore Geometres - mathematician
* Theophilos of Edessa - astronomer
* Soterichos -mathematician
* Dionysios Mikros - astronomer
* Rhetorios of Byzantium - astronomer
* Theodoghius - taught Astronomy at the University of Constantinople 
* Kometas - taught Greek Philology at the University of Constantinople
</div>
Rursus dixit. (mbork3!) 07:26, 3 May 2011 (UTC)
thread_title:  Other