Talk:The Twelve Days of Christmas (song)

message: Several statements in the article assert that one lyrical variant or another is particularly common in North America, with a reference that starts “For example,” and then cites one book. This is not an acceptable Wikipedia citation. A claim that something is popular somewhere needs to cite a source backing up that popularity as fact, not a single example of its use. Unless someone can provide better sources for these assertions, I’d suggest removing them altogether. PacificBoy 00:54, 11 December 2020 (UTC)
replies: text: It is the most common wording in North America, but your question about the way the reference is formatted is valid. Walter Görlitz (talk) 01:14, 11 December 2020 (UTC)
thread_title:  One example doesn’t count as popularity 

message: As a lad I understood that the "four coalley birds" (or "colly" if you prefer) were coal tits.  However recent TV programs have suggested either the common blackbird or the raven.  Given the raven's association with Odin that might make some sense.  Does anyone have any evidence for the original intent (as against supposition)? Martin of Sheffield (talk) 22:31, 16 December 2020 (UTC)
replies: text: Slightly more like a raven, but with that neck I'm not sure the engraver had any particular species in mind! The trouble is, no-one (I suspect) knows how old the song was in 1800.  Martin of Sheffield (talk) 16:53, 17 December 2020 (UTC)
thread_title:  Which bird for number 4? 

message: This claim (or words to that effect) has been in the lede for years, attributed to Opie and Opie's Oxford Dictionary of Nursery Rhymes.  What Opie and Opie actually say  is more equivocal:  
* "A rhyme or chant, also known in France"
* Reference to similar chants in the Cambrésis and Languedoc
* "whatever the ultimate origin of the chant, it seems probable that the lines which survive today both in England and France are merely an irreligious travesty"
* [in a footnote] "If 'The partridge in the peartree' is to be taken literally it looks as if the chant comes from France, since the Red Leg partridge, which perches in trees more frequently than the common partridge, was not successfully introduced into England until about 1770".
The last point comes closest to a claim of French origin, but it is only conditional. 
Since the article was giving both more confidence and more prominence to the claim of French origin than the source it cited, I've removed this statement from the lede, and added the Opies' argument about the partridge to the "Origins" section. Grover cleveland (talk) 23:00, 18 December 2021 (UTC)
thread_title: "Is thought to be of French origin"

message: From the provided sources, it seems like 12 Lords is the more common order (ten sources), with Austin's 12 Drummers the sole aberration, is that correct? Shouldn't we show 12 Lords as the default? —Ashley Y 21:21, 8 December 2022 (UTC)
replies: text: I completely agree. I have never heard it sung with the Lords and Ladies outranked by the Pipers and Drummers. The anonymous ca.-1800 broadside to the right has them in the order in which they are normally sung. --Haruo (talk) 17:39, 30 January 2024 (UTC)
thread_title:  Twelve Lords A-Leaping