Talk:Ali/Born in Kaaba

message: == Insertion of Shi'a traditions as fact ==
Striver, nooo reputable historian of Islam accepts the stories that you are trying to insert. Those stories aren't in the earliest texts and they show every sign of being later fabrications. You are trying to insert them as if they were fact. 
We give enough links to Shi'a sites that if a reader wanted to explore further, he/she would certainly read those stories and hear those claims. 
It is not up to me to show that they are fables, it is up to you to show that they are not. Cites from Peshawar Nights are particularily problematic, since the text has been shown to be a Persian forgery. Zora 19:25, 30 October 2005 (UTC)
thread_title: Cut

message: Striver, nooo reputable historian of Islam accepts the stories that you are trying to insert. Those stories aren't in the earliest texts and they show every sign of being later fabrications. You are trying to insert them as if they were fact. 
We give enough links to Shi'a sites that if a reader wanted to explore further, he/she would certainly read those stories and hear those claims. 
It is not up to me to show that they are fables, it is up to you to show that they are not. Cites from Peshawar Nights are particularily problematic, since the text has been shown to be a Persian forgery. Zora 19:25, 30 October 2005 (UTC)
thread_title:  Insertion of Shi'a traditions as fact 

message: Then, as to prove the contrary, i quote witness-pioneer.org, a 100% sunni site:
:Birth of Ali
:Ali was born under unusual circumstances. On the thirteenth of the holy month of "Rajab", Fatima, the mother of Ali, visited the Kaaba for performing the pilgrimage. During the course of the pilgrimage while circumambulating the Kaaba, Fatima felt the pangs of childbirth. She retired to a secluded place in the precincts of the Holy Kaaba, and there Ali was born. Ali had thus the unique honor of being born in the House of God. This unparalleled honor has endowed Ali with a halo of sanctity, which has become the subject of many legends. A hundred years later, Zain-ul-Abidin a grandson of Ali (son of Husain) met as Arab woman at Najaf who told him that her grandmother had helped on the occasion of the birth of Ali. She narrated that according to the account of her grandmother, the child was beautiful, a smile played on his lips, it did not cry like other children, and its birth did not cause any pain to his mother.
:The Name
:Fatima wanted to name the child "Asad" after the name of her father. Abu Talib wanted to name him Zaid. When the mother and the child came home, the Holy Prophet, and Khadija came to see the newborn child. Since his birth, the child had not opened his eyes, and that worried Fatima and Abu Talib. As the Holy Prophet took the child in his lap he opened his eyes. The first person that Ali saw after his birth was the Holy Prophet. When the Holy Prophet was asked whether he approved of the child being named as Asad or Zaid, he said that as the child was born in the House of God, he should be named Ali, the word Ali being a derivative of Allah. Ali had thus the distinction of being named after Allah. No person before him had ever been so named. The name acquired further sanctity as it was proposed by the Holy Prophet.
So, having that said: i repeat my question:
:All Muslim traditions describe him being born inside the Kaaba, the most sacred site in Islam; however, non Muslim contemporary academic historians choose to not mention it. One historian, Simon Ockley, retold it as a "strange" narrration History of the Saracens page 331.
Are there any relevant and sourced arguments against having that line?  --Striver 05:41, 12 November 2005 (UTC)
replies: text: No more objections to this issue? The line is aproved by silence? --Striver 15:02, 12 November 2005 (UTC)
thread_title: 100% sunni 

message: == OK. Another approach. Forget whether Kaaba thing is true... ==
... would it be encyclopedic if it were?
To address that question, let's consult:
PRINCETON
http://www.princeton.edu/~batke/itl/denise/ali.htm
COLUMBIA
http://www.bartleby.com/65/al/Ali.html
BRITANNICA
http://concise.britannica.com/ebc/article-9354999
ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE ORIENT
http://i-cias.com/e.o/ali.htm
BrandonYusufToropov 22:20, 11 November 2005 (UTC)
replies: text: Yes it would be, this isn't like another encyclopaedia, most articles here have more depth that the websites above which is why wikipedia is great  87.194.54.232 00:48, 30 May 2007 (UTC)
thread_title: CUT

message: ... would it be encyclopedic if it were?
To address that question, let's consult:
PRINCETON
http://www.princeton.edu/~batke/itl/denise/ali.htm
COLUMBIA
http://www.bartleby.com/65/al/Ali.html
BRITANNICA
http://concise.britannica.com/ebc/article-9354999
ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE ORIENT
http://i-cias.com/e.o/ali.htm
BrandonYusufToropov 22:20, 11 November 2005 (UTC)
replies: text: Yes it would be, this isn't like another encyclopaedia, most articles here have more depth that the websites above which is why wikipedia is great  87.194.54.232 00:48, 30 May 2007 (UTC)
thread_title:  OK. Another approach. Forget whether Kaaba thing is true... 

message: ==a mistake==
This sentence is wrong.
"The Kaaba is said to have cracked open so that Fatima bint Asad, Ali's mother, could enter, then closed behind her." 
Ali's mother like others entered from the door not the wall.--Sa.vakilian 03:08, 3 September 2006 (UTC)
replies: text: I don't think it's wrong, that concept comes from Shi'a ahadith traditions and you can see some an an example -xx-Mohammad Mufti-xx 04:18, 3 September 2006 (UTC)
replies: text: The paragraph is showing the extreme mythical stories that have been created. See Birthplace of Ali ibn Abi Talib for references. Obviously the Kaaba didn't crack open, and he didn't come out of the womb speaking, but we put those in to comment on the phenomenon of myth-making that Shi`ah have participated in about Ali. Cuñado  - Talk 04:51, 3 September 2006 (UTC)
thread_title: From [[Talk:Ali/Archive4]]

message: This sentence is wrong.
"The Kaaba is said to have cracked open so that Fatima bint Asad, Ali's mother, could enter, then closed behind her." 
Ali's mother like others entered from the door not the wall.--Sa.vakilian 03:08, 3 September 2006 (UTC)
replies: text: I don't think it's wrong, that concept comes from Shi'a ahadith traditions and you can see some an an example -xx-Mohammad Mufti-xx 04:18, 3 September 2006 (UTC)
replies: text: The paragraph is showing the extreme mythical stories that have been created. See Birthplace of Ali ibn Abi Talib for references. Obviously the Kaaba didn't crack open, and he didn't come out of the womb speaking, but we put those in to comment on the phenomenon of myth-making that Shi`ah have participated in about Ali. Cuñado  - Talk 04:51, 3 September 2006 (UTC)
thread_title: a mistake