Talk:List of socialist songs

message: Eumn.... a list of socialist songs?! haha well er...
Katuscha by all means is not a socialist song. just a friendly love song about a girl who is waiting for her friend to return from the war.
And well... As a Trotskyist... I can't say I think the Hymn of the USSR and those 2 Chinese songs are Socialist...
But even then... if you think they are... they are not as importiant as the Internationale, The Red flag, the marxist ABC and all that kind of stuff.
Bobby Siecker — Preceding unsigned comment added by 86.84.223.146 (talk • contribs)  
:I'm skeptical about this list. I think that socialist movement/labour movement songs makes sense (see Jacob's list of labor songs below). Songs of "socialist" countries, this makes less sense. Songs by any socialist band (as previous version of page said) seems to me a really bad idea - too many notability issues. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Bobfrombrockley (talk • contribs) 
No Katyusha! was one of the most desperate encouragement and call etc. songs for the Katyushas in the winter defence nights of Leningrads!  The Siege of Leningrad 900 Days   — Preceding unsigned comment added by 5.158.3.21 (talk) 10:33, 31 March 2019 (UTC)
thread_title: Untitled

message: I'm not sure what people intend to include or exclude here. I wrote up the following entries but decided to move them to the talk page until we can reach some consensus.
* We Have Fed You All for a Thousand Years - An Unknown Proletarian, 1908.Joyce L. Kornbluh, Rebel Voices, pp. 28-29.
* Workingmen, Unite - by E.S. Nelson, 1908.Joyce L. Kornbluh, Rebel Voices, p. 13.
* The Banner of Labor - anonymous, 1908.Joyce L. Kornbluh, Rebel Voices, pp. 13-14.
* Paint 'Er Red - Ralph Chaplin or Elmer Rumbaugh, 1913.Joyce L. Kornbluh, Rebel Voices, p. 24.
* The Rebel's Toast - Joe Hill, 1914.Joyce L. Kornbluh, Rebel Voices, p. 57.
* Solidarity Forever - Ralph Chaplin, 1915.Joyce L. Kornbluh, Rebel Voices, pp. 26-27.
* Commonwealth of Toil - Ralph Chaplin.Joyce L. Kornbluh, Rebel Voices, p. 27.
And yes, I'm starting with Kornbluh because it's easiest to get though one source, noting the more famous of the class-struggle-oriented songs, and then the next source, and so on. Jacob Haller 19:26, 3 September 2007 (UTC)
replies: text: All good suggestions. I'd say put 'm in. What about "I Dreamed I Saw Joe Hill Last Night"? (Is that by Woody Guthrie?) BobFromBrockley 15:05, 5 September 2007 (UTC)
thread_title: Other Labor Songs

message: Putting the Internationale and early-20th century Union songs together with North Korean, Soviet and Czechoslovak Stalinist propaganda is nasty. There is a great difference between Socialism and Communist, although these terms are often mixed in the United States. Read how Lenin and other Bolsheviks were reacting to the Social Democracy. These page should be either divided or renamed to "Leftist songs" and categorized. --Zik2 (talk) 10:33, 13 March 2015 (UTC)
thread_title:  Socialist or Communist? 

message: I am not convinced that flags should be used in this list, per MOS:FLAG, as the country of origin has no official importance here.  (Separately, it strikes me as ironic for a socialist list!)  I defer to a more experienced editor's judgment. IgnatiusofLondon (talk) 12:37, 7 January 2024 (UTC)
replies: text: I'm on the fence. It's not critical information, but it is useful to know where the songs are from. SilverStar54 (talk) 21:17, 8 January 2024 (UTC)
replies: text: No issue with writing the country of origin, which I agree is useful information; I just have issue with the flags!  Sorry, my comment was unclear: an easier read would be "the state of origin" rather than the country. IgnatiusofLondon (talk) 23:11, 8 January 2024 (UTC)
replies: text: Gotcha. In that case, your suggestion sounds totally reasonable. Go ahead and be WP:BOLD! SilverStar54 (talk) 06:50, 9 January 2024 (UTC)
thread_title:  [[MOS:FLAG]]?