Talk:Dick Gaughan

message: Quite a comprehensive biography focussing not only on the field in which he is known. Nogwa
Hi. Nogwa, do you know the name of Dick's mother? I am looking for any extant samples of her voice, as I have heard so much about it. I credit her with raising this fine musician in the best way possible. MELINDA LEMMON (talk) 07:29, 2 August 2019 (UTC)
replies: text: His mother was called Frances MacDonald.  I have never heard that she was ever recorded singing, although she won a silver medal at one of the Gaelic Mods as a child in the 1930s - see the Biography section of the archive of DG's web site in the External Links section of the article. Molly Romanov (talk) 17:02, 2 August 2019 (UTC)
thread_title: Untitled

message: There are many aspects of these amendments which I strongly recommend are changed or deleted as they are either factually incorrect or personal interpretations.  A few specifics follow, but by no means an exclusive list:
You have written: "Gaughan began as a classic singer-songwriters".  Apart from the typo (and there are other typos in your amendments), this is factually not the case.  DG did not start out writing songs at all - he was a traditional folk-singer in the early days (you correctly state that he was "playing mainly traditional songs on an acoustic guitar").  The general understanding of the term "singer-songwriter", at least in the UK, is of a musician who writes and sings songs relating to his/her personal life.  DG does not perform introspective songs of this kind.
You also state "in recent years he has reverted to playing mainly an acoustic guitar".  This is hardly "recent"!  He played electric guitar with Five Hand Reel and Clan Alba.  I will check the actual dates involved.
"His solo albums of the 1980s returned to the 'singer-songwriter' style in which he had begun" - see my paragraph above.  DG was never what is commonly understood by the term "singer-songwriter", and the fact that he had started writing some (IMO excellent) songs does not make him so.  The majority of the songs which he performs and records are written by others.
"A Handful of Earth is generally agreed to be his greatest album".  The title is in fact "Handful of Earth".  I do not agree with your assessment that it is "generally agreed to be his greatest album";  it is certainly the most crucial album of his career, epitomising his decision to follow the route of political song, rather than being tempted by greater material gains through performing less challenging and more generally-popular material.
"Perhaps surprisingly for such a 'traditional musician' Gaughan is something of a technophile, being strongly in favour of the democratic potential of computers in general and the internet in particular." The first part is very subjective and should be removed.  Also, I have never heard any suggestion that his love of the Internet is specifically motivated by political principles, as is suggested by the use of the word "democratic".
I also intend to remove the link which you added back to his old web site at http://www.dickalba.demon.co.uk, and which I removed and replaced with his current site not long ago (from 81.178.168.159).  The old site is no longer updated and remains on the web only because it is much linked to from other sites; DG only maintains and updates the current site.
I will not be making any of these changes for at least 24 hours, to give you an opportunity to comment and support your amendments. --Molly Mockford 23:15, 21 February 2006 (UTC)
thread_title:  Amendments made from 86.3.29.137 on 19th February 

message: I have twice deleted the following sentence added by Martinevans123:
"1978 also saw the release of the first album in his own name, on the Topic record label."
The album referred to, "Gaughan", was not the first album in Dick's own name.  Prior to that he released three albums in his own name:  No More Forever (1972), Kist O'Gold (1976) and Coppers and Brass (1977) - as contrasted with albums under the names of "Boys of the Lough" and "Five Hand Reel".
The justification by Martinevans123 for restoring this sentence is "...still think both first eponymous album and Topic deserve a mention...".  "Eponymous" does not mean "in his own name" - it means "named after himself".  "Gaughan" is indeed an eponymous album;  but that is hardly interesting or unusual - and "first eponymous album"??  It would be more startling if there were to be more than one album called "Gaughan"!
As far as Topic Records are concerned, unless we are to include the labels of all Dick's other CDs - the recent ones of which are published by Greentrax - I see no relevance in including a link to Topic for just one recording.  One might as well mention that the cover photo was taken at Newhaven Harbour.  It's just trivia!
The body text by no means includes the release dates of all the albums;  this is the point in having a discography in its own section.  So it is not as though the album "Gaughan" has been for any reason ignored or neglected in the entry.
In summary, my view is that the sentence is badly worded and misleading;  it is also irrelevant and unnecessary.
Comments from others are invited.
--Molly Mockford (talk) 13:39, 6 September 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: Ouch. Well that's me told. You are quite right of course, although I don't see anything wrong with including all the labels. Nor even with Newhaven Harbour. I'll just shut up now. Martinevans123 (talk) 14:11, 6 September 2008 (UTC)
thread_title:  "Gaughan" album 

message: ... um, so why not have a new section for those "... recordings to which Dick Gaughan contributed only a few tracks", or indeed any track? Martinevans123 (talk) 18:25, 2 April 2009 (UTC)
replies: text: Nothing at all wrong with that, as far as I can see!  However, it really ought to be a separate section, and not conflated with the official discography.  Maybe it would be a good idea if it specified on which tracks in each album DG plays/sings?--Molly Mockford (talk) 18:12, 3 April 2009 (UTC)
thread_title:  Other albums 

message: Substituted at 13:22, 29 April 2016 (UTC)
thread_title: Assessment comment

message: I have enlarged the article to provide more information about Gaughan's music and to bring his career information up to date. I have updated the external links and expanded the discography. I have added numerous citations but will leave it to others to decide whether the BLP template may now be removed. RedKite (talk) 16:47, 22 March 2017 (UTC)
thread_title:  Substantial edit 

message: Does anyone know if there are any samples of Dick's singing mother on record anywhere? I would love to hear them. I don't know her name in order to search. MELINDA LEMMON (talk) 07:59, 2 August 2019 (UTC)
thread_title:  I remember Dick's talking about his dear mother. I know somewhat about her singing talent. But I am intrigued. Her musical influence on the boy was great, and I wish I could thank her. May I know her name in order to loom for any recorded samples of her voice? Again, I am intrigued with her 

message: I have removed this article from :Category:Scottish musicians by genre as that is a container category and as such should only contain other categories, not individual articles. Dunarc (talk) 22:53, 31 August 2020 (UTC)
thread_title:  Category:Scottish musicians by genre removal 

message: thank you Dick Gaughan for your music, for the words and for sharing your beliefs. Your honesty has touched my very soul. 🌍🕊️👩‍🦳 84.9.3.85 (talk) 15:08, 5 May 2023 (UTC)
thread_title:  Dick Gaughan