Talk:Guqin

message: Below are some former links and information that has since been removed from the article. They are reproduced here for reference as they are very useful and important to further qin study. Please do not remove any of them.
==Bibilography==
I'm moving most of the reading list here for archive:
*Zhou, Ningyun (1915, 2008). Qinshu Cunmu 【琴書存目】. 
*Li, Xiangting (1992). Tangdai Guqin Yanzou Meixue ji Yinyue Sixiang Yanjiu 【唐代古琴演奏美學及音樂思想研究】. Taipei.
*Li, Xiangting (2004). Guqin Shiyong Jiaocheng 【古琴实用教程】. Shanghai: Shanghai Music Press.  
*Wu, Na (2004). Guqin Chuji Jiaocheng 【古琴初级教程】. Beijing: Tongxin Press. /J‧105
*Huang, Datong (ed.) (2005). Chiba Guqin Kao 【尺八古琴考】. Shanghai: Shanghai Conservatory of Music Press. /J‧161
*Yao, Bingyan and Huang, Shuzhi (2005). Tangdai Chen Zhuo Lun Guqin Zhifa: Yao Bingyan Qinxue Zhu Shu zhi Yi 【唐代陳拙論古琴指法‧姚丙炎琴學著述之一】. Beijing: Shu zhi Zhai Wenhua Co. Ltd. .
:Part of the Qinxue Congkan 【琴學叢刊】 ("collection of printings on qin study"). 
*Yi, Cunguo (2005). Taiyin Xisheng 【太音希聲】. Guizhou: Zhejiang University Press. /J‧093
*Wu, Zhao (2005). Jueshi Qingyin 【绝世清音】; inc. 1 CD. Suzhou: Ancient Inn of Wu Press. /G‧259
*Miao, Jianhua (2006). Guqin Meixue Sixiang Yanjiu 【古琴美学思想研究】. Shanghai: Shanghai Conservatory of Music Press. 
:Part of the Series of Doctor Dissertations in Music 【音乐博士学位论文系列】.
*Xian, Zhi (2006). Qi-xian Midao: Jingdian Guqin Gushi 【七弦味味道‧经典古琴故事】. Beijing: China Three Gorges Press. 
*Xu, Junyue and Xiaoying (2006). Zhepai Guqin Yishu 【浙派古琴艺朮】. Shanghai: Shanghai Arts and Literature Press. 
*Liang, David Ming-Yueh (1972). The Chinese Ch'in Its History and Music. Chinese National Music Association / San Francisco Conservatory of Music
*Hsu, Wen-Ying (1978). The Ku'Chin. California: Wen Ying Studio, Pasadena
German books on qin:
*Manfred Dahmer: “Qin - die klassische chinesische Griffbrettzither". With Audio-CD. Uelzen: ML-Verlag 
Music books:
*Sachs, Curth (1940). The History of Musical Instruments. New York: Norton & Co.
*Lai, T. C. & Mok, Robert (1985). Jade Flute - the Story of Chinese Music. New York: Schocken Books. 
*Liang, David Ming-Yue (1985). Music of the Billion. New York: Heinrichshofen. 
*Herbet, Trevor (2001). Music in Words: A Guide to Researching and Writing about Music. London: The Associated Board of Royal Schools of Music. 
*Wang, Yunwu (1969). Wang Yunwu Da Cidian 【王雲五大辭典】. Hong Kong: Guanghua Book Department.
*No author (1976, 1982). (Putonghua : Yueyin) Zhonghua Xin Zidian 【（普通話‧粵音）中華新字典】. Hong Kong: Chinese Book Department, Hong Kong Section. 
*Addiss, Stephen (1987). Tall Mountains and Flowing Waters. Hawaii: University of Hawaii Press.  
*Yang, Xin; Barnhart, Richard M.; Nie, Chongzheng; Cahill, James; Lang, Shaojun and Wu, Hung (1997). Three Thousand Years of Chinese Painting. New Haven & London, Beijing: Yale University Press and Foreign Language Press.  
*Liang, Jianmin (ed.) et al. (2000). Gu Hanyu Dacidian 【古汉语大词典】. Shanghai: Shanghai Cishu Press.   
—Preceding unsigned comment added by CharlieHuang (talk • contribs) 11:19, 19 January 2008 (UTC)
thread_title: Resources

message: I'm moving most of the reading list here for archive:
*Zhou, Ningyun (1915, 2008). Qinshu Cunmu 【琴書存目】. 
*Li, Xiangting (1992). Tangdai Guqin Yanzou Meixue ji Yinyue Sixiang Yanjiu 【唐代古琴演奏美學及音樂思想研究】. Taipei.
*Li, Xiangting (2004). Guqin Shiyong Jiaocheng 【古琴实用教程】. Shanghai: Shanghai Music Press.  
*Wu, Na (2004). Guqin Chuji Jiaocheng 【古琴初级教程】. Beijing: Tongxin Press. /J‧105
*Huang, Datong (ed.) (2005). Chiba Guqin Kao 【尺八古琴考】. Shanghai: Shanghai Conservatory of Music Press. /J‧161
*Yao, Bingyan and Huang, Shuzhi (2005). Tangdai Chen Zhuo Lun Guqin Zhifa: Yao Bingyan Qinxue Zhu Shu zhi Yi 【唐代陳拙論古琴指法‧姚丙炎琴學著述之一】. Beijing: Shu zhi Zhai Wenhua Co. Ltd. .
:Part of the Qinxue Congkan 【琴學叢刊】 ("collection of printings on qin study"). 
*Yi, Cunguo (2005). Taiyin Xisheng 【太音希聲】. Guizhou: Zhejiang University Press. /J‧093
*Wu, Zhao (2005). Jueshi Qingyin 【绝世清音】; inc. 1 CD. Suzhou: Ancient Inn of Wu Press. /G‧259
*Miao, Jianhua (2006). Guqin Meixue Sixiang Yanjiu 【古琴美学思想研究】. Shanghai: Shanghai Conservatory of Music Press. 
:Part of the Series of Doctor Dissertations in Music 【音乐博士学位论文系列】.
*Xian, Zhi (2006). Qi-xian Midao: Jingdian Guqin Gushi 【七弦味味道‧经典古琴故事】. Beijing: China Three Gorges Press. 
*Xu, Junyue and Xiaoying (2006). Zhepai Guqin Yishu 【浙派古琴艺朮】. Shanghai: Shanghai Arts and Literature Press. 
*Liang, David Ming-Yueh (1972). The Chinese Ch'in Its History and Music. Chinese National Music Association / San Francisco Conservatory of Music
*Hsu, Wen-Ying (1978). The Ku'Chin. California: Wen Ying Studio, Pasadena
German books on qin:
*Manfred Dahmer: “Qin - die klassische chinesische Griffbrettzither". With Audio-CD. Uelzen: ML-Verlag 
Music books:
*Sachs, Curth (1940). The History of Musical Instruments. New York: Norton & Co.
*Lai, T. C. & Mok, Robert (1985). Jade Flute - the Story of Chinese Music. New York: Schocken Books. 
*Liang, David Ming-Yue (1985). Music of the Billion. New York: Heinrichshofen. 
*Herbet, Trevor (2001). Music in Words: A Guide to Researching and Writing about Music. London: The Associated Board of Royal Schools of Music. 
*Wang, Yunwu (1969). Wang Yunwu Da Cidian 【王雲五大辭典】. Hong Kong: Guanghua Book Department.
*No author (1976, 1982). (Putonghua : Yueyin) Zhonghua Xin Zidian 【（普通話‧粵音）中華新字典】. Hong Kong: Chinese Book Department, Hong Kong Section. 
*Addiss, Stephen (1987). Tall Mountains and Flowing Waters. Hawaii: University of Hawaii Press.  
*Yang, Xin; Barnhart, Richard M.; Nie, Chongzheng; Cahill, James; Lang, Shaojun and Wu, Hung (1997). Three Thousand Years of Chinese Painting. New Haven & London, Beijing: Yale University Press and Foreign Language Press.  
*Liang, Jianmin (ed.) et al. (2000). Gu Hanyu Dacidian 【古汉语大词典】. Shanghai: Shanghai Cishu Press.   
—Preceding unsigned comment added by CharlieHuang (talk • contribs) 11:19, 19 January 2008 (UTC)
thread_title: Bibilography

message: My someone has been busy...
I'll move some external links to here to chop it down. Most of them are useful, but in order to comply...
Qin society sites
*Jiuyi Qin Association 九嶷琴會 Vancouver based qin society 
*Zen Art Gallery: Yingzhou Qin Society 瀛洲琴社 Has an abridged list of the society's yajis 
*Northern Crane Qin Club 北鶴琴社 Another qin society in Canada
*Kamakura Qin Society 鎌倉琴社 Qin society located in Japan /
*Tokyo Qin Society 東京琴社 Qin society in the capital of Japan 
General Qin sites
*China Guqin Net 中國古琴網 A Chinese forum on the qin  
*2006 Beijing ‧ The Week of Qin Music Culture — with Memory of the Qin Master Wu Jinglüe's Centennial Birthday 纪念古琴大师吴景略诞辰100周年 Detailed site about the life of Wu Jinglüe /
*Live Online Guqin Concert Watch the Live Online Guqin Concert of 2003, plus some information about the players and programme / 
*Choi Fook Kee 蔡福記 Hong Kong based qin maker, Choi Fook Kee's site, with many examples of the qins he has made, with text to Qin Fu 
*"Dajia" with Li Xiangting 大家:李祥霆 A video of a television documentary broadcasted on China's CCTV with interview with Li Xiangting, discusses qin music and art 
*Digital Guqin Interactive Art Research-Creation Studio 數碼古琴互動藝術研究創作室 Shuen-git Chow heads the on-going "Digital Guqin Interactive art research-creation studio", first experimental results with team members of master guqin players and software developer. Qin players: Teo Kheng Chong, Wang Duo, software developer Etienne Durand
*The Classical Collection of the Art of the Guqin 古琴藝術數位典藏 A site with a variety of information, including scans of several qinpu 
*Hong Kong Wulin Qin Garden 香港武林琴苑 Hong Kong based site 
Sites dealing with qin notation and tablature
*Liuyun Lingling 流韵泠泠 A site with a large collection of scans of various tablature scores 
Other specialist Qin sites
*Madam Tsar Teh-yun A site established after Madam Tsar's death
*Guangling Yayun 广陵雅韵 A site with specialist news on qin happenings in China 
*Kinshi Shoga Su 琴詩書画巣 A site looking at Qin poetry /
*Qiulai 秋籟 Cheng Gongliang's site 
*Rong Naigong of the 27 Qin Room 二十七張琴室主人容乃公 A site with numerous articles and essays on the qin 
*Qin Compositions and Qin Poetry 琴賦與琴詩 Brief discussion of qin literature and poetry. With examples 
*Beyond the Strings 弦外说琴 Lengthy discussion on the qin 
Sites with a little information on Qin
*Kaneko Koto Sangen Gakki Ten かねこ琴三絃楽器店 A Japanese instrument maker's site showing a selection of curious photos of Japanese qin (called shichigenkin 七絃琴) construction process in Japan 
*Kumu Longyin 枯木龍吟——琴制與造琴 A short article describing qin making 
*Travel China Guide: Wuhan's Heptachord Terrace (Guqin Tai) Information about a site in Wuhan named after the guqin
===News articles/blog entries===
*China Today: A Classic Through Eternity December 2002
*China: Experts Urged to Preserve Guqin Zither 31st December 2002
*China: Ancient Guqin saved 3rd April 2003
*BBC News: Saving the world's 'endangered instruments' 5th August 2003
*BBC News: Changing China leaves guqin behind 7th August 2003
*Legends of China Festival: Guqin Culture and Guqin Masters of Hong Kong 16th October - 28th November 2003
*Guangdong News: Guqin auctioned for 8.91 m yuan 28th November 2003
*China: Bejing Guqin Lovers Gather Soon 2nd December 2003
*China Daily: Ancient instrument to be revived on stage 22nd October 2003
*Cultural Affairs Bureau of the Macao S.A.R. Government: Hchoes of Antiquity: an Exhibition on the Chinese Guqin 10th March 2004
*Cultural Affairs Bureau of the Macao S.A.R. Government: Guqin Recital in Macao Museum 27th April 2004
--Charlie Huang 【正矗昊】 10:30, 21 February 2007 (UTC)
thread_title: External Links

message: *China Today: A Classic Through Eternity December 2002
*China: Experts Urged to Preserve Guqin Zither 31st December 2002
*China: Ancient Guqin saved 3rd April 2003
*BBC News: Saving the world's 'endangered instruments' 5th August 2003
*BBC News: Changing China leaves guqin behind 7th August 2003
*Legends of China Festival: Guqin Culture and Guqin Masters of Hong Kong 16th October - 28th November 2003
*Guangdong News: Guqin auctioned for 8.91 m yuan 28th November 2003
*China: Bejing Guqin Lovers Gather Soon 2nd December 2003
*China Daily: Ancient instrument to be revived on stage 22nd October 2003
*Cultural Affairs Bureau of the Macao S.A.R. Government: Hchoes of Antiquity: an Exhibition on the Chinese Guqin 10th March 2004
*Cultural Affairs Bureau of the Macao S.A.R. Government: Guqin Recital in Macao Museum 27th April 2004
--Charlie Huang 【正矗昊】 10:30, 21 February 2007 (UTC)
thread_title: News articles/blog entries

message: *News Guangdong: Guqin: The First of China's Four Ancient Arts 24th May 2005
*Weekend Standard: The sound of old music 6–7th August 2005
*Shanghaiist: Tea and Ancient Strings: Shanghai's guqin shop 18th August 2005
*Peking University News: Promoting Guqin Lyrical Music around the World - An Interview with Guqinist Qiao Shan 14th October 2005
*China Culture Org: The Art of Guqin Music 8th December 2005
*China: Guqin-Piano Concert Celebrates Best of Both Worlds 19th December 2005
*Hong Kong Wenweipo: Jiuxiao Huanpei About the famous auctioned qin several years ago; 6th January 2006 
*Xinhua News: Nation designates Cultural Heritage Day 9th February 2006
*China Daily Shanghai Star: Delicate draughts of tradition 15th June 2006
*Oakland Tribune: Fans and players of the guqin to gather to display their pluck 17th July 2006
*Danwei: The guqin and earth’s greatest hits by Peter Micic 13th October 2006
*Information on music articles and news blog: The Guqin – A Chinese Musical Instrument That Helped Defeat An Army 4th January 2007
*Macau Art Net: Guqin Echoes to be heard at the Macau Museum 5th January 2007
*Sina: Traditional Chinese music to make ground-breaking tour in Europe, Africa 7th January 2007
--Charlie Huang 【遯卋山人】 11:26, 19 January 2008 (UTC)
thread_title: News articles/blog entries

message: This batch was deleted so I have transfered them onto here for reference:
Qin societies:   
*North American Guqin Association 北美琴社 Wang Fei's US based qin society, with a link to a store that sells good quality qins, CDs and books as well as other Chinese instruments, updates often and a library of qin music samples and other useful material   
*[4704 London Youlan Qin Society 倫敦幽蘭琴社/伦敦幽兰琴社] Cheng Yu's UK based qin society with information about each yaji and regular updates on upcoming events   
*New York Qin Society 紐約琴社 New York based qin society, with information of their previous yaji, now updated with new material /   
*Friends of Guqin : Amics del Guqin 古琴之友    
   
General Qin websites:   
*John Thompsons on the Guqin Silk String Zither A host of information on the qin and silk strings for qins in English, including extensive study of Shenqi Mipu and analysis of playing style, plus useful section on qin sources  
*Christopher Evan's Chinese Guqin Site Christopher Evans' site explaining Chinese music theory, notation and technique, with note position diagrams, is down pending a major re-write.   
*Julian Joseph's Guqin Site A site mainly about Julian's dapu of the Shiyixian Guan Qinpu [Qin Tablature of the House of Eleven-strings] plus several unabridged lists of commercial qin recordings   
*Yugu Zhai Qinpu Jim Binkley's translation of the qin construction manual with links to other sources. Includes a qin FAQ section and pictures of his 'blue qin' made by himself      
*UNESCO Proclamation of guqin as a Masterpiece of Oral and Intangible Heritage of Humanity   
*Chinese Guqin 中国古琴(Chinese)   
*The Qin on the Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, The Metropolitan Museum of Art  *The Qin on the Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, The Metropolitan Museum of Art 
*Silk on Wood A Feature Radio Documentary by Robert Iolini about the Silk String Qin and Madame Tsar Teh-yun. The website includes online video performances by the Deyin Qin Society of Hong Kong. An Australian Broadcasting Corporation production. 
   
Sites dealing with qin notation and tablature:   
*Qinqu Jicheng The near complete out-of-print PDF version of the Qinqu Jicheng download (vol. 10 missing)    
*Chinese Guqin and Notation Judy (Pei-You) Chang's very detailed and well illustrated site explaining fingering techniques, including sections on structure, forms and various information  *Chinese Guqin and Notation Judy (Pei-You) Chang's very detailed and well illustrated site explaining fingering techniques, including sections on structure, forms and various information 
*Jieshi Diao Youlan Manuscript View the original Tang Jieshi Diao Youlan manuscript kept at the National Museum in Japan here //// 
--Charlie Huang 【遯卋山人】 09:28, 28 August 2010 (UTC)
thread_title: Addendum 2010

message: Please add new points of discussion and questions about the article at the bottom of the page.
== Too long tag ==
OK, I added the too long tag because the article is one of the longer ones on all of Wikipedia, and should be split into sub-articles. It's 3 or 4 times the suggested length. I'm going to add it back in; if you think there's a good reason to remove it, please explain why here. Also, please assume good faith; I was not adding the tags wantonly without a desire to engage on talk page. -Patstuart(talk)(contribs) 06:51, 27 November 2006 (UTC)
replies: text: *Here is the link to the version before cutting up for propriety: http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Guqin&oldid=98892099 --Charlie Huang 【正矗昊】 19:30, 7 January 2007 (UTC)

text: The naysayers are not always correct, you know. There is always criticism for criticism's sake. What are they objecting to? Badagnani 19:07, 16 June 2007 (UTC)
replies: text: As wikipedia is based on published information, there shouldn't be sources such as personal communications in the articles anyway, as long as the sources of the information are shown, with footnotes for specific points if required, and the article does not quote word for word, I can't really see what's the problem. You don't have to provide a source for every single piece of information individually, a list of references together with footnotes at the end of the article will be OK. After all this is standard academic practice, just follow academic convention, you do not need any "courtesy of this and that" in the main body of the article. LDHan 00:46, 14 July 2007 (UTC)

text: Maybe part of the reason out of 1.4 billion people, only a couple of thousand at most know how to play this instrument is due to this possessiveness of information. This sort of behavior regarding esoteric subjects can be found in cultures all over the world. Badagnani 01:11, 14 July 2007 (UTC)
replies: text: If they do not want to share this information (properly credited of course) then they should not publish it. LDHan 01:18, 14 July 2007 (UTC)

text: Sounds good. What do you think of the idea of footnotes to replace the inline bracketed Chinese text in the lead? Or a dedicated glossary towards the bottom? Tony (talk) 14:46, 28 March 2008 (UTC)

text: Since there has been no opposition, I'll make it look like a standard article.  WhatamIdoing (talk) 19:39, 15 September 2008 (UTC)

text: Not exactly. The Guqin covers most positions indeed, but it also excludes some (the 1/7 is not in for instance, but the 1/8 is however. You can see this if you look closely to the three dots. The most left one is further away from the the second one. So that's not a 1/7 but a 1/8. The scale also appears on the Dan Bao, the Russian triangled bass and other non-western musical instruments. All with exclusions of certain 'unhandy' tones not fitting well in the musical tradition of that region, whatever the reasons therefore may be. The scale of harmonics is the fundamental scale. The Guqin is most closely related to it, others are a bit more distanced. Partch is working all the time with the scale of harmonics on his diamonds, just like many other microtonal reasearchers. 83.87.74.107 (talk) 18:16, 5 August 2009 (UTC)
thread_title: Discussion

message: OK, I added the too long tag because the article is one of the longer ones on all of Wikipedia, and should be split into sub-articles. It's 3 or 4 times the suggested length. I'm going to add it back in; if you think there's a good reason to remove it, please explain why here. Also, please assume good faith; I was not adding the tags wantonly without a desire to engage on talk page. -Patstuart(talk)(contribs) 06:51, 27 November 2006 (UTC)
replies: text: *Here is the link to the version before cutting up for propriety: http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Guqin&oldid=98892099 --Charlie Huang 【正矗昊】 19:30, 7 January 2007 (UTC)
thread_title:  Too long tag 

message: OK, I've created two articles in Classical Chinese and Cantonese. So far, someone has expanded the Classical Chinese one to a good degree. I'll mess around with that if i feel like it (since my Classical Chinese is rather novice level). I'll probably expand the Cantonese one since I am Cantonese myself. I'm relectant to do anything with the Mandarin one as it will require a major rewrite to get it to any standard near the English one (it mostly consists of lists of books and a general introduction). I won't bother with the other languages that I don't know; any new articles in new languages will be linked to each other and the Commons article so they all connect to each other. --Charlie Huang 【正矗昊】 16:08, 31 December 2006 (UTC)
thread_title:  Articles in other languages 

message: I've removed it form all guqin articles as I've decided to hang my wiki brush. I feel it is more or less complete. I will leave the article in the capable hands of Mr. Bagagnani and all those concerned. I will, of course, monitor the article and stop vandalism, etc. --Charlie Huang 【遯卋山人】 16:03, 25 March 2007 (UTC)
thread_title:  Guqin project template 

message: Right, I have personally been receiving a lot of stick recently from the qin community about referencing and copyrighting in the article and have frankly had enough of it. I will now do the dubious process of hacking the article and removing anything I deem to be vaguely 'not publicly known' or 'not my own' etc. Please do not revert and if you want to put certain information back in, you should discuss it here first. 
For sake of reference, the original version is here: http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Guqin&oldid=137294814
--Charlie Huang 【遯卋山人】 17:28, 16 June 2007 (UTC)
replies: text: The naysayers are not always correct, you know. There is always criticism for criticism's sake. What are they objecting to? Badagnani 19:07, 16 June 2007 (UTC)
replies: text: As wikipedia is based on published information, there shouldn't be sources such as personal communications in the articles anyway, as long as the sources of the information are shown, with footnotes for specific points if required, and the article does not quote word for word, I can't really see what's the problem. You don't have to provide a source for every single piece of information individually, a list of references together with footnotes at the end of the article will be OK. After all this is standard academic practice, just follow academic convention, you do not need any "courtesy of this and that" in the main body of the article. LDHan 00:46, 14 July 2007 (UTC)

text: Maybe part of the reason out of 1.4 billion people, only a couple of thousand at most know how to play this instrument is due to this possessiveness of information. This sort of behavior regarding esoteric subjects can be found in cultures all over the world. Badagnani 01:11, 14 July 2007 (UTC)
replies: text: If they do not want to share this information (properly credited of course) then they should not publish it. LDHan 01:18, 14 July 2007 (UTC)
thread_title:  Renovation of article 

message: If anyone can retrieve the list of qin in pop culture then please do and insert it into the main article. The guys that deleted the pop culture article didn't transfer the list back onto the main article wasting all that effort! --Charlie Huang 【遯卋山人】 10:26, 29 September 2007 (UTC)
thread_title:  Pop culture list 

message: added tone to the IPA. Of course, the diacritics don't match Pinyin. kwami (talk) 09:28, 19 December 2007 (UTC)
thread_title:  IPA 

message: On reading the article, I'm struck by the large amount of Chinese (and some Japanese and Korean) characters that pop up everywhere. I'm not talking about the spellings for guqin, or for other terms specificially related to the instruments, but about the Chinese names for all of the people, works, and other miscellaneous words. Effort should be given to trim any excess Chinese out of the article, as it clutters the article for the average English reader. Basically, any Asian characters that follow a blue link are unneeded, as anyone who wishes to know the spelling in the original language can find it its main article. Characters after red links and normal text generally are ok to stay until a stub can be created. On that note, perhaps someone with the know-how could create stubs for the "famous gin pieces" to establish their notability. I'm going to go ahead and start removing some of these unneeded characters.--SeizureDog (talk) 19:46, 18 January 2008 (UTC)
thread_title:  Lessen the amount of Chinese 

message: This has come up at MOS talk, and I'm using the lead of this article as an extreme example of such cluttering. The solution that I'm proposing is the sequestering of the transliterations in a Glossary at the bottom of the article. The concern, BTW, is not with the infobox or the references. Tony (talk) 08:49, 24 March 2008 (UTC)
thread_title:  Issue of non-Roman transliterations that clutter the text 

message: Well, it was expected since I resigned from making major contributions to it a few months back after the hoo-hars. Unfortunately, none of my colleagues are willing to take the helm or have experience in Wiki to do the nessary work to it so I'm afraid it will go into decline unless I receive a full mandate from my peers to assume editorship of it. --Charlie Huang 【遯卋山人】 13:50, 28 March 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: Sounds good. What do you think of the idea of footnotes to replace the inline bracketed Chinese text in the lead? Or a dedicated glossary towards the bottom? Tony (talk) 14:46, 28 March 2008 (UTC)
thread_title:  Demotion of article 

message: This article uses a non-standard layout for references.  The normal approach lists only those sources that were used to create the article under "References".  Things that were not used to create the article, but which might be interesting to the reader anyway, are listed under "Further reading" and/or "External links", which are properly not part of the "References" section, but separate things like "See also".  Is there a particular reason why this article uses such an unusual approach?  WhatamIdoing (talk) 04:36, 9 September 2008 (UTC)
replies: text: Since there has been no opposition, I'll make it look like a standard article.  WhatamIdoing (talk) 19:39, 15 September 2008 (UTC)
thread_title:  References 

message: OK, since I have improved my playing and have recorded numerous videos I have decided to replace the two or three videos with better ones. Take note. --Charlie Huang 【遯卋山人】 14:50, 20 December 2008 (UTC)
thread_title:  New videos 

message: Scale of harmonics should be merged to Guqin because "Scale of harmonics" is about a scale of the "Guqin", lacks references, and this scale is covered in "Guqin". Hyacinth (talk) 06:08, 4 August 2009 (UTC)
replies: text: Not exactly. The Guqin covers most positions indeed, but it also excludes some (the 1/7 is not in for instance, but the 1/8 is however. You can see this if you look closely to the three dots. The most left one is further away from the the second one. So that's not a 1/7 but a 1/8. The scale also appears on the Dan Bao, the Russian triangled bass and other non-western musical instruments. All with exclusions of certain 'unhandy' tones not fitting well in the musical tradition of that region, whatever the reasons therefore may be. The scale of harmonics is the fundamental scale. The Guqin is most closely related to it, others are a bit more distanced. Partch is working all the time with the scale of harmonics on his diamonds, just like many other microtonal reasearchers. 83.87.74.107 (talk) 18:16, 5 August 2009 (UTC)
thread_title: Merge: Scale of harmonics

message: I have recently been informed about the publication of this book by my colleague Julian Joseph. It is basically an edited (albeit, badly) copy of this Wiki article thrown into book form. From what I've heard, it is shabbily done. One wonders why one will get this book as all of the information is available here for free! Regardless, I am planning on writing my own book based on this article and the sister articles but totally re-written and edited to a professional standard with full citations as well as new information/sections and, crucially, peer reviewed by my qin colleagues. This will set things right. Personally, one of the reasons why I do not edit the article anymore is because of things like this happening. --Charlie Huang 【遯卋山人】 18:00, 23 December 2009 (UTC)
thread_title:  Book published on this article 

message: Hello fellow Wikipedians,
I have just added archive links to  on Guqin. Please take a moment to review my edit. If necessary, add  after the link to keep me from modifying it. Alternatively, you can add  to keep me off the page altogether. I made the following changes:
*Added archive https://web.archive.org/20060725171951/http://www.chinainfotravel.com:80/Guqin_Master_Xu_Kuanghua_1104.htm to http://www.chinainfotravel.com/Guqin_Master_Xu_Kuanghua_1104.htm
When you have finished reviewing my changes, please set the checked parameter below to true to let others know.
Cheers.—cyberbot IITalk to my owner:Online 13:26, 8 January 2016 (UTC)
thread_title:  External links modified 

message: Surely 派 is translated as "school", especially when referring to a specific musical tradition or style. "Clique" also has a negative connotation indicating exclusivity, which I'm not sure is intended here. The whole section is problematic, and might be original research. Given that there is already a section on Historical schools, and there is a separate article on Qin schools, it may be better to delete the whole thing unless someone else is prepared to rewrite and source the section. Hzh (talk) 12:27, 13 September 2019 (UTC)
thread_title:  Clique?