Wikipedia talk:Requests for arbitration/Mr-Natural-Health/Evidence

message: A number of articles related to health have been categorized by Mr-Natural-Health as Alternative Medicine.  A number of users have edited out those Category:Alternative medicine notations.  After such a removal he puts them right back.  While alone that would just be a disagreement on content, the wide consensus that is displayed by these many users has been ignored.  Thus it rises to a behavior issue.  The consensus is that articles should be placed in categories that are reasonable for the given article, not any category that might be related.  For example, an article on Minerals that has mostly information about rocks, volcanos and minerology and a small section on dietary minerals is not an Alternative Medicine.  While AltMed folks might recommend walking, the article Walking should not be in category Alternative Medicine.  While Depression is health related, it is not an alternative medicine.   High and Low density lipoproteins are important in health, but are not part of category alternative medicine by the consensus of the group. 
The following persons have each at one, and in many cases more than one time, expressed that view to Mr-Natural-Health: (parenthetical expressons are the edit sumary for each edit as found in histories)
:Theresa knott (revert MNH innapropriate category)
:Erich gasboy (please keep your idionsyncratic categorisations to yourself)
:Kd4ttc (Books)
:Dwindrim (See also - Remove alternative link as irrelevant. I'm depressed and like to drive; can I link Cars?)
:Bodnotbod (-Category:Alternative medicine Good grief! "Clinical depression" is NOT an Alternative Medicine.)
:Erich gasboy (del cam link)
:Xgkkp (he changed the title - again.) (see above  - Xgkkp)
:Geni (See also - Remove alt med)
:PFHLai (revert to version from 23:12, 2004 May 25 to remove spamlink.
:John Foley (Delete reference link to alt. medicine until such time as the article covers it.)
:Marnanel
:Daveb (Physiotherapy / physical therapy is not an alternative therapy)
Stephen Holland, M.D. Kd4ttc 02:23, 9 Jun 2004 (UTC)
thread_title: Multiple users have disagreed with categorizations yet they continue

message: The following was posted on Vandalism in progress by MNP. It is not vandalism, but it may be relevant to his content and conduct disputes. Guanaco 03:31, 11 Jun 2004 (UTC)
replies: text: Thanks Guanaco. Martin 01:07, 13 Jun 2004 (UTC)

text: These unsigned accusations are made by User:Mr-Natural-Health who is currently in arbitration for various issues, one of which is his unwarranted accusations of vandalism.  I will add this action to the body of evidence that stands against him --bodnotbod 01:08, Jun 11, 2004 (UTC)
====Please ignore this accusation==== 
This is a content issue.  Fuelbottle unknowingly added his opinion to the consensus that the alt med categorizations were incorrectly applied.  The matter has been submitted and accepted for arbitration by the committee. Kd4ttc 01:56, 11 Jun 2004 (UTC)
thread_title:  Posted on [[Wikipedia:Vandalism in progress]] by [[User:Mr-Natural-Health|Mr-Natural-Health]] 

message: User:Fuelbottle systematically vandalized a large number of edits made by me while I was working on the Wikiproject on Alternative Medicine.  I have determined that it was in fact vandalism rather than an edit disagreement because he remove the project's infobox from Lifestyle diseases, an article that I personally wrote.  This article is 100% a philosophy of alternative medicine.  In addition, User:Fuelbottle removed the infobox from Massage which just happens to be a major branch of alternative medicine.  As the removal of our project's boxes was done systematically and indiscriminately, I am reporting catching User:Fuelbottle in the act of vandalizing a large number of my edits just a matter of 30 minutes or so ago.
User:Fuelbottle has repeated his vandalism.
:These unsigned accusations are made by User:Mr-Natural-Health who is currently in arbitration for various issues, one of which is his unwarranted accusations of vandalism.  I will add this action to the body of evidence that stands against him --bodnotbod 01:08, Jun 11, 2004 (UTC)
====Please ignore this accusation==== 
This is a content issue.  Fuelbottle unknowingly added his opinion to the consensus that the alt med categorizations were incorrectly applied.  The matter has been submitted and accepted for arbitration by the committee. Kd4ttc 01:56, 11 Jun 2004 (UTC)
thread_title:  User:Fuelbottle 

message: This is a content issue.  Fuelbottle unknowingly added his opinion to the consensus that the alt med categorizations were incorrectly applied.  The matter has been submitted and accepted for arbitration by the committee. Kd4ttc 01:56, 11 Jun 2004 (UTC)
thread_title: Please ignore this accusation