Talk:Reinmar von Hagenau

message: Agree same person, just need to decide on which title variant? (to kick off, I shall change merge tags discuss to point here, given the source) Widefox (talk) 13:46, 10 April 2012 (UTC)
thread_title:  Merger proposal 

message: Medivialists are still not sure where exactly Reinmar came from. The assumption that "von Hagenau" means a person "coming from Hagenau in Elsass/Alsace" is just one of the options available. As there are very few historical sources that could indicate his possible origin and there are at least three different old noble families with this name, scientific research on this topic is a challenge. --94.217.14.138 (talk) 11:01, 14 October 2015 (UTC)
replies: text: There is a family "von Hagenau" in Bayern/Bavaria and Austria: Die "Herren von Hagenau". https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herren_von_Hagenau --47.68.151.223 (talk) 13:24, 13 March 2016 (UTC)
replies: text:  As Reinmar had been living at the "Babenberger Hof" in Vienna and this noble Bavarian, as well as Austrian family had tight relations to the Babenberger dynasty, this option is likely to be the right one. On the other hand, the coat of arms as depicted in the Heidelberg scripture doesn't seem to fit in: Which coat of arms is the authentic design? --136.218.10.16 (talk) 13:22, 7 October 2020 (UTC)
replies: text:  There is a strange school of thought that searches to deny the obvious: Hagenau in Alsace was an important city in the Middle Ages and beyond (flourishing well into the 16th-century) and there is no reason to assume that Reinmar wouldn't have called himself with pride after his hometown, or be associated with it. Some people are desperate to make an aristocrat of him for the same reason some people are desperate to prove that "the real Shakespeare" was in fact a nobleman: because they despise people of humble origins. --Edelseider (talk) 14:00, 7 October 2020 (UTC)
replies: text:  There is a strange school of thought that searches to deny the status and fame of a family providing Imperial Standard Bearers in that epoche. Yes, Hagenau in Alsace had been an important German "Free Imperial City" in medieval times, but nevertheless the most important family of this time bearing the right name definitely is that of the king's councellors and Imperial Standard Bearers von Hagenau, please see  and , close relatives to the Counts and Dukes von Andechs, and more remote relatives to Hohenstaufen dynasty. Please do not spread your own theories and thoughts as facts, trying to urge others to believe what you made up or picked up somewhere. Thanks. 188.104.35.103 (talk) 11:01, 14 September 2021 (UTC)

text: Yes, right. But the article currently still spreads rather biased theories and not facts. 188.104.35.103 (talk) 10:16, 14 September 2021 (UTC)
thread_title:  Family and Origin of Reinmar 

message: As it stands, the article is copied more or less verbatim from a 103-year-old source, so it's badly in need of revision. At the very least, it shouldn't be too much work to add details of editions more modern than 1888!
I'm going to start by moving it to Reinmar von Hagenau - no other Minnesänger has had his von translated. --Pfold (talk) 14:17, 7 February 2016 (UTC)
thread_title:  Revision needed 

message: It says: "But this does not often happen, and most of Reinmar's poems show more elegance of form than beauty of sentiment. In a society, however, where form was valued more than contents, such poetry was bound to meet with favour." This might be a judgement based on prejudice, not on scientific evaluation. --188.99.28.183 (talk) 21:57, 15 January 2018 (UTC)
replies: text: Actually, I'm pretty sure it would be straightforward to find a reference supporting this view, though it could be expressed better. It's certainly not prejudice - Reinmar's songs are more abstract than those of contemporaries like Morungen and Walther. But, as I said here a while ago, really the article needs to be scrapped and rewritten from scratch. I've just been too busy with Walther von der Vogelweide to do anything about it, I'm afraid. --Pfold (talk) 23:08, 15 January 2018 (UTC)
thread_title:  Emotional Judgement? 

message: * Currently it says: "Hagenau has been identified as the Alsatian city, modern Haguenau, which was the location of an imperial court of the Hohenstaufen dynasty in the twelfth century and which lies some 20 miles from Strassburg." This rather should be: "Some scientists claim to have identified Hagenau in Alsace [...] while others do not agree." 
* Currently it says: "Gottfried's proximity to this Hagenau makes it unlikely that the place referred to is one of the many places called Hagenau in Bavaria and Austria." This assumption makes no sense at all, because Reinmar von Hagenau had been living and working at Babenberger dynasty's court in Austria some 600 miles from Strassburg anyway.
* Currently it says: "Whether Hagenau was Reinmar's home or whether it was simply the court at which he first made his mark as a singer cannot be known.". This is completely missleading, especially in case Reinmar was a descendent or relative of the Imperial Standard Bearers and Knight Bannertes "Bannerherren von Hagenau" , , , ,  and  which had been Bavarian and Austrian high nobility of this epoche. 188.104.35.103 (talk) 10:35, 14 September 2021 (UTC)
thread_title:  many theories, misleading conclusions and over-all lack of facts