The Legacy of Sir Elton John and the Art of Paying Tribute to a Living Legend
By: Richard Lebeau
Tags: Music, LGBTQ, Grammys, Pop Culture, Media

Lesson #2: Highlight the impact of the artist(s) on numerous generations of musicians with a tribute album, but don’t overemphasize hot young artists at the expense of seasoned contemporaries.

The most ambitious part of the recent Elton tributes are definitely the two tribute albums that were released on April 6th. Each album utilizes an impressive line-up of well-known musicians to cover 13 songs that Sir Elton John composed alongside his longtime lyricist Bernie Taupin (who has written the vast majority of Elton’s songs over his nearly half-century career). But aside from the concept, the two albums differ markedly.

Revamp, the pop oriented collection, boasts a great deal more star power and features better-known songs from Elton’s catalogue. The album gets off to a rocky start with a cover of “Bennie and the Jets” that makes great use of P!nk’s incredible vocals, but becomes a hot mess when Logic’s rap is introduced. Unfortunately, the lead off song isn’t the only disappointment. Q-Tip and Demi Lovato’s bizarre cover of “Don’t Go Breaking My Heart” is equally jarring, although it is arguably the classic hit of Elton’s that is most in need of updating. The most egregious sin on the album occurs in the form of Ed Sheeran’s cover of “Candle in the Wind.” His voice sounds nice, but the rearrangement is wildly inappropriate for the subject matter. (The song is about the tragic life and untimely death of Marilyn Monroe but he plays it like he’s at a bouncy jam session trying to flirt with a bunch of girls.) Then there’s Coldplay’s utterly listless cover of “We All Fall in Love Sometimes” and the utterly bizarre choice of Miley Cyrus to cover one of his most powerful songs, “Don’t Let the Sun Go Down on Me” (most famously recorded as a live duet with the late, great George Michael).

But thankfully the other 8 songs work quite well. Relative newcomer Alessia Cara adds grit to “I Guess That’s Why They Call it the Blues.” Mumford and Sons does an affecting rearrangement of “Someone Saved My Life Tonight.” Mary J. Blige wrings every last painful drop out of “Sorry Seems to be the Hardest Word.” Sam Smith soulfully evokes the deep sadness inherent in “Daniel.” The Killers do an excellent rendition of “Mona Lisas and Mad Hatters,” one of Elton’s best-loved album cuts. Queens of the Stone Age cap the album with a powerful take on “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road.” And then there’s the two best tracks on the album, Florence + the Machine’s cover of “Tiny Dancer” and Lady Gaga’s cover of “Your Song.” It is no easy feat making a cover of two of the most beloved songs in Elton’s catalogue work, but Florence and Gaga knock it out of the park, further establishing themselves as two of the greatest artists of their generation.

Restoration, the country oriented collection, uses somewhat lesser known stars and covers more obscure songs from Elton’s catalogue, but ultimately works better as a whole. In fact maybe it’s because the artists and the songs are less recognizable that it works better. But it’s not without it’s missteps. As good as Maren Morris sounds, we didn’t need a second cover of “Mona Lisas and Mad Hatters” (interestingly the only song duplicated on both albums). And we most definitely didn’t need a second appearance of Miley Cyrus, this time covering “The Bitch is Back.” But most of the rest of the album works exceedingly well. Little Big Town’s “Rocket Man,” Don Henley & Vince Gill’s “Sacrifice,” and Dierk Bentley’s “Sad Songs (Say So Much)” are stellar covers of some of his most well-loved songs. Miranda Lambert’s “My Father’s Gun,” Brothers Osborne’s “Take Me to the Pilot,” Kacey Musgrave’s “Roy Rogers,” and Rhonda Vincent & Dolly Parton’s “Please” give deserved second lives to lesser known album cuts. Although they aren’t the musical highlights of the album, Lee Ann Womack’s “Honky Cat” and Willie Nelson’s “Border Song” emphasize the songs’ impressive lyrical arrangements. And, Chris Stapleton’s “I Want Love” and Rosanne Cash & Emmylou Harris’s “This Train Don’t Stop Here Anymore” are superb covers of two of the most under-appreciated songs of the later stage of Elton’s career.

The albums include an impressive slate of famous musicians and classic songs from his catalogue, but they are not without notable omissions and missed opportunities. I, for one, would have loved to have heard covers of three of my favorite songs — the heavy and haunting “Believe,” the exceedingly romantic “Something About the Way You Look Tonight,” and the utterly masterful “The One.” And although it is moving to see how much the younger generation has been influenced by Elton, I would have loved to see more of his contemporaries make an appearance. Throughout his career he has had so many storied collaborations and personal relationships with music legends that it seems an utter shame so few true legends are featured on the album. Where’s Paul McCartney, Aretha Franklin, Stevie Wonder, Eric Clapton, and Dionne Warwick? Not to mention Madonna, who his love-hate relationship is a tabloid dream. And for better or worse (probably better), there’s no cuts from The Lion King soundtrack (Elton’s best selling album) to be found (although this is clearly explained by the fact that Elton created those songs with lyricist Tim Rice and not Taupin).

Lesson #3: Celebrate the legacy of the artist(s) with an all-star TV special, but don’t just make the tribute concert a promotion of the tribute albums.

On April 10th, CBS aired a two hour special called Elton John: I’m Still Stranding — A GRAMMY Salute. Even moreso than the tribute albums the special was somewhat shamelessly promoting the show was quite uneven. There were some strong performances, no doubt. Lady Gaga, Sam Smith, Maren Morris, Miranda Lambert, Little Big Town, and Alessia Cara did superb live renditions of their cuts from the tribute album. In a wonderful twist, John Legend took over “Don’t Let the Sun Go Down on Me” from Miley Cyrus and gave the brilliant song its just due; Kesha provided a typically raw and powerful take on “Goodbye, Yellow Brick Road” that matched Queen of the Stone Age’s take of it on the album; and Shawn Mendes and SZA did a cover of “Don’t Go Breaking My Heart” that blew the album version by Q-Tip and Demi Lovato out of the water. And then Sir Elton himself capped the show with a three song performance. He was in fine form, although I can think of several better songs than “Philadelphia Freedom,” “I’m Still Standing,” and “Bennie and the Jets” to highlight his incredible knack for performing live.

Interspersed with these rousing moments were a bunch of head-scratching and eye-rolling moments. Miley Cyrus’s tacky rendition of “The Bitch is Back” was a tone-deaf way to star the show. Coldplay and Ed Sheeran’s live renditions of their tribute album cuts worked no better this time around. Two attempts at turning Bernie Taupin’s lyrics into spoken word performance art were cringe-inducing. The tacky set design was cheap and uninspired (the worst being Maren Morris being forced to perform “Mona Lisa and Mad Hatters” alongside a replica of the table from Alice in Wonderland — get it?!?). And, most notably, other than a touching shout out to his AIDS activism the show said almost absolutely nothing about Sir Elton John and Bernie Taupin as people. I would have gladly excised a few of those performances for some words by people who actually know them or one of the countless classic clips that the Grammys surely has in its archive.

Elton John’s latest greatest hits collection (Copyright Virgin EMI)

Lesson #4: Release/rerelease classic music in a new, remastered package, but don’t ignore the die hard fans when crafting it.

Diamonds, the 51-track collection of Sir Elton’s greatest hits that was released last November in preparation for the farewell tour announcement, is great for the more casual fan looking to get a lot of his best known hits in one great-sounding collection. However, as the slew of negative reviews on the internet will tell you, it fell far short for his diehard fans. Many of them asked why a seventeenth (!) greatest hits collection was needed, when so many B-sides, live performances, soundtrack and compilation cuts, and other rarities remain so difficult to find. And they aren’t wrong.

But then again, collections that dive deeper into Sir Elton’s catalogue may still be forthcoming. After all, Sir Elton has made it quite clear that while he is done touring in 2021, he is not done with his love affair with music. And the world is better off for that.

Click here to read another article about a legendary music legacy: https://medium.com/rants-and-raves/counting-down-mariahs-48-best-songs-to-celebrate-her-anniversary-128535300326

Follow me on Twitter: https://twitter.com/RichardReflects