Careful What You Ask For
Tags: Short Story, Sex, Erotica, Cuckold, Fiction

Photo by Sharon McCutcheon

The cool breeze followed me through the door as the thumping music greeted me. Steel clinking together added to the music and you could almost smell the testosterone in the air. Crossing to the front desk, I quickly swiped my badge to check in then searched the gym for my niece, Cassie. The place was packed with people working out. The whir of treadmills added to the din of weights being set back on the racks and the music creating a symphony of sweat and hormones. I spied Cassie on a weight bench pumping iron with our trainer, Kyle, standing over her. As she finished and sat up, she looked up and saw me standing by the desk and waved.

Returning her wave, I headed for the locker room to change. The room cleared out as I sat on the bench and dug in my bag. As I began changing, Cassie walked in to find me.

“Hey, you ready for this?” She asked excitedly. She was clearly pumped up from her work out so far. Cassie shot me a huge grin. “Wait until you see Kyle.”

I really wasn’t in the mood. The fight I had with my husband was still playing in my mind as I stripped off my shirt. “Not really,” I replied as I threw my shirt in my bag and dug out a shirt.

“Oh, come on. You know how Kyle always flirts with you Aunt Laura.”

Scoffing, I jammed my arms in my old t-shirt. “Yeah right. He’s like half my age. He’s not flirting with an old woman like me.”

“Forty-two isn’t old,” Cassie corrected me. “Besides, Kyle’s twenty-six. That’s old too. Besides you have awesome boobs and I’ve caught him checking them out on more than one occasion.”

I shot Cassie an exacerbated look as I replied. “To a nineteen-year old twenty-six is old and he is not checking out my boobs.” Then I felt bad for the tone in my voice, “I’m sorry. I had a fight with your Uncle C.J. I’m just in a bad mood.” I stuffed my bag in the locker.

“Well looking at Kyle will help with that and yes he does look at your boobs. I wish I had big D cups like yours. Plus, wait until you see what he’s wearing. You know how he usually where’s those baggie shorts?”

“Yeah. So?”

“Well he’s wearing some of those tight spandex shorts today and you can see everything. It leaves nothing to the imagination.” Cassie was either pumped up from her work out or she was just turned on by our trainer. Either way, she had gotten my attention.

“Like Tyler the other trainer is always wearing?” I asked.

“Exactly. You can see everything! I’m telling you you’ve got to see him.” Cassie was clearly excited about ogling the trainers. I’d noticed them mildly flirting before but just assumed it was part of the deal to keep me coming back and using their services.

“Tyler looks ridiculous in those. His penis hangs halfway down his leg and he’s just showing it off because it’s big.” Even as the words left my mouth, the thought of what he had on display was distracting me.

“Well yeah. You’d rather he had a little bulge in there instead. What fun is that?” Then, Cassie changed the subject. “What did you and Uncle C.J fight about?”

I hesitated a moment as I thought twice about telling her. My niece and I had developed a very close relationship and she was turning out to be a close friend as she grew up.

Finally, I relented and told her, “He wants to watch me with another man. Actually, he mentioned something about a threesome.”

“Oh wow,” Cassie exclaimed as she frowned. “Really? I didn’t see that coming.”

“Really.” I jammed a leg into my old sweats. I was still riled up as I thought about my husband’s idea.

“Here. No don’t put those on,” Cassie stopped me as she grabbed the other leg of my sweats. She pulled them out of my grasp. “Here. Put this on.”

She yanked open her locker and dug in her gym bag. Pulling out a pair of spandex shorts and bra, she handed them to me.

“Seriously?” I asked her ask I took them and eyed the skimpy outfit.

“You’ll feel better about yourself and you’ll get even more attention from the trainers. Then you’ll forget about your fight with your husband. Go on,” Cassie coaxed.

Groaning, I stripped off my t-shirt and bra. I knew Cassie well enough to know she wasn’t going to take no for an answer. Settling the spandex bra into place, I groaned again as it barely contained my large breasts. Stepping into the shorts, I pulled them up and looked behind me.

“I have no butt,” I told Cassie as I turned back and forth to try and see my ass.

“Stop it. You do too. Women would kill for your body.”

Scoffing, I slammed my locker shit then followed her out into the gym and we headed back to the weight bench she had left. Kyle was helping another client several machines down and I settled back on the bench prepared to do some bench presses and get warmed up. Cassie started spotting me as I began pumping the bar up and down. My anger was making my workout easier as thrust my arms up as I gritted my teeth. Cassie was right. The workout was making me feel better.

“Here, let me spot for her. Cassie go do some curls over there and don’t slack. I’ll be with you in a minute,” a man’s voice said above me.

“Sure Kyle,” Cassie replied as she stepped away.

Above me, Kyle swam into view as he took her place. His handsome smile and piercing blue eyes smiled down at me. Distracted, I almost dropped the weights as he caught the bar for me.

“Whoa. Look out,” he beamed down at me, but I didn’t notice his smile anymore.

My eyes were glued to the bulge in the front of his black spandex shorts. A huge bulge filled the front and the outline of cock stretched far down his leg. The front pouch was incredibly full and even soft, it was the biggest cock I’d ever seen.

“Sorry,” I muttered and tore my eyes away from his bulge to look up into his blue eyes. Cassie was right. His shorts left nothing to the imagination. Staring up into his face, his eyes were doing nothing to quell the flood that had started between my legs at the side of his bulge.

“Let’s do this safer,” Kyle smiled at me again as he began helping me raise and lower the bar as he squatted directly over my face. He left me no choice as I stared up at the huge bulge directly above me.

It was then that the idea hit me and my answer to the fight I’d had with C.J. started formulating in my mind.

Later that afternoon, after our workout and a little shopping with Cassie, I headed home and found C.J. sitting in his recliner watching football.

“Where have you been?” He asked as I walked through the living room carrying my bags. “Still mad about our argument earlier?”

“That was a fight not an argument. And no. I’m not.” I gave him a sly smile as I headed for the stairs.

“Good. Have you thought any more about it?”

“I have actually.”

He muted the television as I stopped by his chair and he put the footrest down suddenly more interested in me than ever. “And?”

“I think we should do it.” I smiled down at him as I watched the astonished look on his face that quickly turned to a wide grin.

“You mean you want to have a threesome with me and someone else or do you want me to watch you with another guy?” He didn’t even wait for me to answer before he continued. I’d never seen him so excited. “Either way, that’s awesome. I have just the guy in mind. Ken from work. He’s single. Fairly good looking. It’s perfect. Plus, I thinks he’s got an okay cock from what I seen in the men’s room not that I was looking.” He was sitting up on the edge of his chair by the time he finished babbling. C. J. was clearly excited about the possiblities.

“Well, I already found someone,” I confessed as I headed for the stairs again swinging my shopping bags happily.

“Who?” He stood up and started following me. “Who’s the guy?” I was getting the impression while it was something he had wanted, he clearly wanted to control the situation. I kept going up the stairs as he followed me to the bottom step.

“I have to get ready,” I told C.J. from the top of the stairs.

“You mean this is happening today?” Right on time, the doorbell rang. C.J. looked at the front door as it were alive then back up at me. “Now?”

“That should be them,” I told him with a smile.

“Them?” His mouth dropped open.

“Well yeah. You said you wanted to watch, and you mentioned a threesome. I found two handsome young studs to fuck me while you watch.” His jaw dropping to the floor gave me a sense of great satisfaction. “You better get the door Dear. Our guests are waiting.”

C.J. shot me a look then went to open the front door. Kyle and Tyler filled the doorway as C.J. looked them over in shock.

“You must be the husband Laura told us about,” Tyler said to C.J. as he brushed past him. Then, he looked up at me standing at the top of the stairs. “Oh hey, Gorgeous. You ready for this?”

“Come on up guys. I’ll be ready in a minute.” With a wink at my stunned husband, I left him standing slack jawed at the front door as Kyle and Tyler followed me up the stairs.

I headed straight for the bathroom and I saw the guys enter the bedroom behind me as I closed the door. C.J. was following them like a puppy dog with a bewildered expression like he couldn’t believe what was happening and I’m sure he didn’t.

Digging in my shopping bags, I pulled out the lingerie I’d just purchased and put it on. Adjusting the straps on the lace bra, I lifted my full breasts with both hands and settled them into place. Smiling at my reflection in the mirror, I noted the sea foam green lace highlighted my green eyes nicely and I blew myself a kiss. It was time to get the party started.

When I stepped back into the bedroom, all eyes in the room were on me as I looked at the guys waiting for me. C.J. stood awkwardly by the door unsure of what to do with himself but Kyle and Tyler were already by the bed ready for me.

“Wow,” Tyler exclaimed as he saw me in the lingerie, and I saw his face light up.

“I knew you had awesome tits. You were really showing them off earlier. They’re fucking amazing,” Kyle offered as I strode toward them.

The shear lace of my lingerie hid nothing. All my assets were on display and I saw the growing bulges in their jeans as I stopped in front of them.

Turning to C.J., I told him, “Have a seat Dear. We’re going to be all afternoon. Just like you said you wanted.”

Without another word, I dropped to my knees in front of the guys as they tore at the front of their jeans eager to get undressed. Their shirts were next as I settled back on my heels and waited for their cocks to be freed. They were both young, athletic and built like Greek Gods. Secretly, I was hoping that they hadn’t been using steroids to get those bulging muscles and cause them to have small balls. As their shorts were ripped down their muscular legs, I was more than pleasantly surprised to see that their balls were huge. I was also more than a bit nervous as I saw the size of their cocks. I knew they were bigger than my husbands, but as they both stroked their cocks to full size, I saw that they were enormous.

“Oh my God,” C.J. gasped from the chair in the corner where he’d taken a seat to watch the show. His eyes were huge as he stared at the two huge cocks before me.

“You’re both huge,” I exclaimed before opening my mouth wide and taking Kyle’s enormous cock in my mouth.

His salty pre-cum filled my mouth as I struggled to work his thick girth between my lips. I was stroking Tyler’s long ebony cock as I sucked Jeremy and noted my hand didn’t fit around Tyler’s thick girth. I had my work cut out for me as I sucked and stroked the two massive cocks in front of me. After a few minutes, I switched and started sucking Tyler. Pre-cum leaked from him like a dripping faucet as I worked his thick meat into my mouth. I was moaning as I enjoyed their taste and as I sucked him, I noted the lace between my legs was sticking to my cunt. I was drenched.

After several minutes, the guys pulled me to my feet, and I kissed Tyler. His full lips devoured mine as he pushed his tongue into my mouth. Breaking away, I turned and kissed Kyle. The entire time, the guys hands were exploring my body. Two sets of strong hands wandered over my breasts and down to my ass. When Tyler worked one around to my front and pushed between my legs, he discovered my secret.

“You’re soaked,” Tyler told me as I broke away from Kyle and looked at them both.

“Like never before,” I replied and saw the guys grin at each other. The fun was just beginning.

Looking over at C.J., he was watching everything with rapt attention as two younger guys fondled me. I could still taste their cocks on my lips as they began pulling off my lingerie. Naked, they lay me back on the bed and joined me on either side. As I ran my fingers through their closely cropped hair, two sets of lips sucked my breasts. Shock waves rolled through my body as my nipples sprang up hard and erect. When Kyle raked his teeth over the nipple he was sucking, I arched my back and moaned.

“Laura?” C.J. asked meekly from the corner. I ignored him. He was obviously getting more than he bargained for.

When Kyle shoved two thick fingers inside me, I could hear my wetness squelching as he fingered me. It felt incredible. As he crooked them up into my g-spot, I began to realize something. One, the guys had done this together before and two, they both knew what they were doing. With them both sucking my nipples and Kyle fingering me, I had my first orgasm. It shattered me as they worked on me and Kyle stroked my g-spot until I cried out as I came. As my orgasm died off, Tyler moved between my legs as Kyle pulled his soaked hand away. I was watching them both as Tyler raised my legs over his shoulders and he pushed his cock into my cunt. Out of the corner of my eye, I saw C.J. sit forward onto the edge of the chair to catch all the action.

When Tyler entered me, he stretched me open painfully. His thick girth pushed slowly into me and inch by inch I was impaled by him. Lodging his cock fully into me, he let me rest a moment as I gasped on the bed between the guys. Then, Tyler started fucking me. Pleasure coursed through my body. I was arching my back and moaning as I was being fucked until I saw Kyle’s enormous cock appear over my face. Opening my mouth, I sucked his mushroom-shaped tip between my lips as I moaned. With Kyle fucking my mouth as Tyler fucked me, I experienced pleasure that C.J. had never given me before and I realized he had been right all along. I did want to fuck other men. At that moment, I wanted to be totally fucked by the two young men I was with. As my orgasm slammed through me, I screamed around Kyle’s cock. I could feel my cum coating my ass as Tyler’s huge cock pulled it from me. Gasping and writhing, they fucked me senseless until Kyle pulled out of my mouth. The guys switched places.

Kyle’s cock was even thicker than Tyler’s and I didn’t think it would be possible, but he stretched me open even more. Tyler shoved his cum coated cock into my mouth and I savored my own sweet taste as they fucked me. Strong hands held my ankles as I was impaled by Kyle’s cock. Tyler was squeezing my breasts and thumbing my painfully hard nipples. I came twice more while I was fucked brutally. The entire time they were talking to each other.

“I love her huge tits,” Tyler exclaimed as he rubbed my nipples.

“Her pussy’s so tight. It’s like hubby over there has never used it,” Kyle replied.

Their comments went on and on.

“Suck that cock Laura,” Kyle told me followed by, “How’s your cum taste?”

The guys talk only turned me on even more as I came two more times before Kyle slowed his strokes and let me rest. I was sweaty, exhausted and completely satisfied but I knew the afternoon was far from over as their hands explored my body once again and I flinched as Kyle ran his thumb over my clit. It was tingling and hyper-sensitive after the orgasm that I’d had.

Then Tyler lay back on the bed next to us as Kyle pulled out of me. My legs were trembling from exhaustion as I sat up then straddled Tyler. His long ebony cock looked fantastic coated in my cum and saliva as I settled over top of him. Strong hands held me upright as I was set down on his cock and slid down it’s long length with a groan. He bottomed out in my cunt and for the first time ever I felt the delicious pain that could cause as I began rocking my hips. Kyle appeared in front of me as his cum covered cock was thrust back in my mouth. Out of the corner of my eye, I saw C.J. sitting in the corner with his cock out. He was stroking himself as he watched the live action porn in front of him. His mouth hung open in shock as he watched the younger bigger men fuck me.

On top of Tyler, I rocked my hips as he thrust up into me. Kyle’s cock filled my mouth as I slurped my own cum off him and he took my head in his hands. As I rode Tyler, Kyle started fucking my mouth. His hands held my head like a vice as he was shoved into the back of my throat until I gagged. I could feel the cum and spit hanging from my chin and leaking between my breasts as Tyler reached up and mashed them together. Another orgasm rocked me as the men used my body. It was shaping up to be the most incredible experience of my life.

I screamed around Kyle’s cock as I came. My body was trembling. Every muscle in me was shaking from the exertion. The guys were fucking me like a ragdoll as their huge cocks were pushed into me. I came again then again as I screamed around Kyle’s cock. Finally, I pulled my head back and gasped for breath.

“I can’t take much more. I’ve never been fucked like this,” I moaned as I stared at the huge cock throbbing in front of me.

I only knew one thing. I was soaked and more satisfied than I thought I could ever be. Kyle stepped away from me and I collapsed forward onto Tyler and was rewarded when he sucked my nipple into his mouth. I groaned as a fresh wave of pleasure rocked me. His strong hands were gripping my ass and his fingers dug into me as he rocked my hips as he sucked my nipple.

“Oh no, not again,” I groaned as another orgasm slammed through me.

Smaller than the others, I was nearing my limit. C.J. was long forgotten as Tyler fucked through another orgasm. A second later, the bed shifted behind us and I felt the heat from Kyles body as he knelt behind me. Tyler stopped thrusting and I felt Kyle’s huge cock probing my asshole.

“Oh God,” I groaned as he entered me then let me rest to get used to his girth inside me.

“Relax,” Kyle coached then slowly pushed his huge cock into my ass.

“I’m so full,” I moaned as I was filled with two huge cocks.

To my surprise, I took the entire length of Kyle’s cock into my ass then he began thrusting. Tyler began working his hips and as I rode him, two cocks were thrust into me at the same time. My orgasm hit me immediately. I had thought I was done and couldn’t come any more. As the guys fucked me like I was a bicycle built for two, the biggest orgasm of the afternoon slammed through me. I was screaming as I came.

“Don’t stop fucking me!” I cried. “Fuck it feels so fucking good!” I wasn’t sure of everything that I screamed as I came.

The guys were pushing and thrusting into me. Tyler’s lips were locked on my nipples. Two sets of hands held me tight to them as their enormous cocks filled me. Several more orgasms pounded through my body as I screamed at the top of my lungs. My husband sat in the corner long forgotten and watching his wife being fucked senseless.

All good things must come to an end as the saying goes and as I was coming for the last time, I felt the guys cocks throbbing and pulsating inside me. Kyle and Tyler both groaned at the same time as they jetted copious amounts of semen into me ass and cunt. It would leak from me for days afterward as the affect our afternoon left me aching and tingling. Kyle hands were on my shoulders as he gave my ass one last thrust and shot the last of his cum deep inside me. We collapsed on top of Tyler completely spent.

A few minutes later, Kyle slipped from my ass as I shuddered and rolled off Tyler. Cracking my eyes open as I smiled, I looked over at C.J. sitting in the corner with his spent cock in his hand. I was considering sucking him off to make it a trifecta, but he had already come. White semen oozed down his hand onto his balls as he sat staring at the three of us on the bed.

“You already came?” I asked my husband then smiled as I winced. I was already aching from the huge cocks that had been deep inside both my holes.

“I came when that one was fucking your face and you were gagging,” C.J. confessed as he pointed at Kyle.

“Too bad. I was going to let you do that,” I offered as I extricated myself from the guys.

Walking toward my husband, my legs were trembling. I rubbed my large breasts together and felt the ache in my nipples from them being nipped and sucked. Standing in front of C.J., I cupped my hand under his chin and raised his eyes up so I could look at him.

“I can’t believe you just fucked two guys in front of me,” he offered, and I detected a hint of sadness and jealousy. He knew that Kyle and Tyler had fucked me beyond my limits. Something he had never been able to do.

“Then you should have been more careful about what you asked for this morning when you said you wanted to bring another guy into the bedroom.” Then I got an idea. Turning back to the guys still laying on the bed as they checked out my ass, I asked, “Is there another trainer with a huge cock at the gym we can include next time. I’d love to have all three holes filled at once while C.J. watches.

“I’ve got just the guy,” Kyle replied as he grinned and nodded at Tyler.

I was already looking forward to next time.